The Nation 1913-01-30: Vol 96 Iss 2483

Page 1

The N eon VOL. XCVI—NO. 2483 THU RSDAY, JANUARY 30, 1913 ret all PRICE TEN CEN NEW BOOKS READY ON SATURDAY rs HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY’S | =) Professor Hugo Munsterberg’s PSYCHOLOGY AND INDUSTRIAL EFFICIENCY This is Professor Miinsterberg’s latest and most important contribution to the practical applic a- tion of psychology in the problems of every day life. After an introduction on “Applied Psychology,’ the book is divided into three sections: OTHER BOOKS BY 1. THE BEST POSSIBLE MAN PROFESSOR MUNSTERBERG 2. THE BEST POSSIBLE WORK THE ETERNAL VALUES. $2.50 3. THE BEST POSSIBLE EFFECT net; postage 20 cents. SCIENCE AND IDEALISM. 85 Che book will be of unique helpfulness to all who are interested cents net; postage 6 cents ° . . 4 . THE ETERNAL LIFE. &5 cents in manufacturing and transportation or in the management of business wee; peatage © cents enterprises, while students and teachers of psychology and sociology AMERICAN TRAITS. From the : 2 tg ler rae Point of View of a German. $1.60 net; every where will find it one that cannot be overlo« yked. postage 14 cents. PSYCHOLOGY AND LIFE. $2.00. $1.50 net. Postage 13 cents. Cornelius Weygandt’s IRISH PLAYS AND PLAYWRIGHTS This volume fcllows the development of the much-talked-of movement which has given Ireland a real native drama. It treats of the plays of W. B. Yeats, Edward Martyn, George Moore, J. M. Synge, Lady Gregory, and other of the younger dramatists of note Fully illustrated, $2.00 net. Postage 12 cents. Anthony M. Ludovici’s THE LETTERS OF A POST-IMPRESSIONIST Being the Familiar Correspondence of VINCENT VAN GOGH The only first-hand account of the notable group of men known as Post-Impressionists, their ideals and their work, which has yet appeared. It is full of human interest and should receive a warm welcome. Illustrated. 2.00 net. Postage 12 cents. Elizabeth Kendall’s A WAYFARER IN CHINA Among contemporary travel books, Miss Kendall's account of a journey across southwestern China to the edge of Thibet, thence to Hankow down the Yangtse and north to the Siberian railway by the Russian railroad through Mongolia, will take a pobition of unique value and interest. Illustrated. $2.50 net Postage 17 cents. Francis E. Clark’s OLD HOMES OF NEW AMERICANS The large and growing public which has taken such intense interest in the phase of the im- migrant problem so brilliantly. stated and depicted in Mary Antin’s “The Promised Land,” will find Dr. Clark’s first-hand study of the old homes, in another part of Europe (Austria-Hungary, Dal- matia, etc.), of our foreign-born citizens, a most interesting and instructive volume Illustrated. $1.50 net. Postage 11 cents. Bradford Torrey’s FIELD DAYS IN CALIFORNIA The late Mr. Torrey’s experiences and adventures while bird-gazing in California, told with his customary charm. Fully and handsomely illustrated from photographs. §1.50 net. Postage 12 cents ENGLISH PEOPLE OVERSEAS By A. Wyatt Tilby This important, authoritative series will be read with much Interest in this country. scholarly but interesting fashion it studies the migrations of the English people to various part of the world—the threefold incentives to these migrations, trade, religion, and adventure; the effect that the Anglican race has had upon the native peoples among whom they have settled; and ~ history of the colonies. “He has written chiefly for the genera iblic, but his books will be of service to teachers and puy well The thor ¢ three t n incentives to migration: trade, religion, an! adventure Emphasis is place on the work of the 1 nary the er stroggles , e Christian pioneers are not forgotten; but more attention Is given to th great work for civilization in the darker places The aut " with the question of what the effects of Am ! ule in fl troy il lands have beer and ~ lusions prea t mw -~—History Teachers Magazine : ( Alre ady Published ) Vor. I THe AMERICAN COLONIES, 1584-1763 Vov. II] Britisn Norra America, 17¢ 867 Vor. Il Britisu INpra, 1600-1826 Vor. IV Britarn iN THE Tropics, 1527-1910 Ready February 26: AvusTRALAsIA. Each $1.50 net. Postage extra

Page 2

The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post Ofice as second-class mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor; Harold deWolf Fuller, Ags sistant Editor Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4.00 Addreag THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. INTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THe WERK eect ; , 93 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Secretary Knox's Note . ‘ ees 96 siinplicity at Washington ........... 96 Roosevelt and the Idaho Case saevs A Sisyphus Among the Sciences ....... 98 What Do We Read For? : ‘ 99 SPECIAL ARTICLES: Dant “New-Life 100 News for Bibliophiles : 102 CORRESPONDENCE: Disproportion in College Cultural jurses oeeecenenes pesees 103 training at a Gnat see ae Arent | -- 103 LITERATURE rhe Thr Brontés . . 104 lara some Scattered Chapters in the Life of a Hussy .... ; ovccose BOO Miria Lucas -+» 106 Mi Philura Wedding Gown 106 or rning Sally ; ; , . 106 Just Before the Dawn ‘ - 107 ” tory of the Modern World. 18165- 10 - : pecnee I The Wilderness of the North Pacific Coast Is ‘lands Trails Trappers and Tender et In Western Canada 108 7 . 109 tt bbeseeoues 111 ) 5 M 111 ART A | : 113 FINANCE rhe nvestigations,” and Afterward 115 Boo! Fr THE WEEK . ee obese 116 * * * Copies of The Nation may be procured fn Parise at Brentano's, 37 Avenue de l'Opéra In London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 HARVARD ANNOUNCES THE ORGANIZATION OF UNIVERSITY THE HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS ON JANUARY 15, 1913 Syndics of the Press ROBERT BACON, A.B., CHAIRMAN GEORGE FOOT MOORE, A.M., D.D., LL.D. ARTHUR EDWIN KENNELLY, 8.D., A.M. GEORGE LYMAN KITTREDGE, A.B., LL.D., Litt.D. CHARLES HERBERT THURBER, Pu.D. EDWIN FRANCIS GAY, Pu.D. WALTER BRADFORD CANNON, A.M., M.D. Director of the Press CHARLES CHESTER LANE, A.M. THE OFFICE OF THE PRESS IS AT NUMBER 2 UNIVERSITY HALL, CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS. Kuhnemann’sSchiller Translated from.the German by KATHARINE ROYCE, with an in- troduction by JOSIAH ROYCE. In two volumes. The set, $3.00 This life of Schiller reinterprets the permanent significance of the poet Schiller for the literature of the world. It shows clearly the relation of Schiller’s dramas to dramatic po- etry—ancient and modern. It explains the evolution of Schiller’s powers, ideas, and poetry. GINN AND COMPANY Boston New York Chicago London Atlanta Columbus Dallas San Francisco Old English Ballads ‘0's. By JOHN A. LONG A collection of Robin Hood and other Old Eng- lish ballads, edited for the use of children and | youth. There is an appropriate introduction to each ballad. illustrations. Cloth. 144 pages. Illustrated. 50 cents. D. C. HEATH & OO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON. NEW YORK. CHICAGO. The book contains many charming | LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. catalogue of second-hand Americana, now ready, and will be sent to any address. Trans'‘at on Translation from French and German, High- | est refe-ences. Miss Julla Franklin, care The Nation A new | Educational Miss GRACE LEE HESS FRENCH SCHOOL FOR YOUNG LADIES FOR SUPPLEMENTARY STUDY 23rd Year. 422 Rue Lauriston, Paris (Trocadero) formerly 145 Avenue Victor Hugo | JelnGarisLp SCHOOL, Ridgefield, Connecticut. A boarding-school aad boys. Prepares for college or scientific schoo Rev. ROLAND J. MULFORD, Pb.D., Headmaster. | The WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER, COL. | senarior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everetr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2a Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av.,.NewYork 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland 814 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd.,LosAngeles 920 Sav. Bk.Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Blk., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, Prop. Vincent B. Fisk, Mer. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex- | perience in bringing together good teachers and 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask | for bulletin : 20 and see for yourself. IN MANY Public Libraries The Office Clerks are instructed to cut out the advertising columns of THE NATION as a guide for the Purchas- ing Committees. “We buy every book you advertise,” writes one of the best known librarians in the U., S. To many libraries and to many individ- uals, books advertised in THE NATION are at once recommended as desirable. wee org E core

Page 3

. f $ : Jan. 30, 1913] The Nation ae a ee “At McCLURG’S” It is of interest and importance to Librarians to know that the books reviewed and advertised in this magazine can be pur- chased from us at advantage- ous prices by Public Libraries, Schools, Colleges and Universities In addition to these books we have an exceptionally large stock of the books of all pub- lishers—a more complete as- Sortment than can be found on the shelves of any other book- store in the entire country. We solicit correspondence from li- brarians unacquainted with our jacilities. LIBRARY DEPARTMENT A. C. McClurg & Co. CHICAGO THE LOEB CLASSICAL LIBRARY A new, comprehensive, with parallel English translations of the highest attainable quality Designed by Mr. James Loeb Edited by T. E. Page, M.A., and W. H. D. Rouse, Litt.D Assisted by an Advisory Board of Eminent Scholars “A fine achievement—a notable addition to the higher intellec- tual resources of the English-speaking peoples, and a credit to our own country.’—The Nation, TWENTY VOLUMES NOW READY GREEK SOPHOCLES. Vol. I. THEOCRITUS, BION, MOSCHUS (The Greek Bucolic Poets). 1 Vol APOSTOLIC FATHERS. Vol. | LUCIAN, Vol. I. LATIN PROPERTIUS. | Vol ST. AUGUSTINE. 2 Vols PERVIGILIUM VENERIS. |! Vol APPIAN. 2 Vols. APOLLONIUS RHODIUS. | Vol. EURIPIDES. 4 Vols PHILOSTRATUS. 2 Vols CICERO. Vol. I. TERENCE. 2 Vols CATULLUS. TIBULLUS. A descriptive prospectus of the whole series mailed free on request Each volume, cloth, $1.50 net; flexible leather, $2.00 net THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, 64-66 Sth Ave., N.Y. uniform series of classical Greek and Latin texts 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, WRITE DODD, MEAD & COMPANY FOURTH AVE. & 30TH STREET. NEW YORK Autograph Ltrs | "seria e"”"* THE FRANCO-PRUSSIAN WAR of Celebrities Bought and Sold Send for price lists WalterR. Benjamin,225 Just Published By EMILE OLLIVIER George Burnham Ives The real 8 portraits, rarvii 20 pp. $2.50 ne mail $2.65 AND ITS HIDDEN CAUSES causes of the Franco-Pru School Advertising in ] vscsccs 5 ee The Nation Translated with introduction and notes an Louis With t; by Little, Brown & Co., Publishers, Boston THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE selves. Tue NATION stands alone in its Geld. The circulation is chiefly among the thinking and well-to-do classes lawyers, physicians, bankers, and other professional men— and in the homes of cultivated people, where the education of children is a matter of careful consideration. The rate is reasonable, and discounts are made on continuous insertions, of which most of the school advertisers avail them- It has a larger circula ion (Translated “ ™m the Frenc f Paul ¢ painting and sculpture, ancient and modern for deacriptive circular memorable analyses of the works of the mast YEA ART By Auguste Rodin o,° ° . ° . Mrs Romilly Fe With o 100 1 than any other politico-literary journal published in this coun- ayn Be ol 200 sas try, going to all the principal libraries and reading rooms, and met irc aver tt on eee a into thousands of families. aM ig ay AB gr ty Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers. Boston You can always find At DUTTON’S the following discounts: 8 insertions. Orders Advertising rates, 15 cents an agate line each insertion, with 5 per cent. on 4 insertions, 10 per cent. on SPECIAL RATE—Ten Cents a line net for thirteen times (Minimum space three lines) agency, or directly to Tue Nation, 20 Vesey calendars and art novelties. the latest books; the rare books illustrated books of all kinds; car: 31 West 23d St. i “I have read your last book with satisfaction, and it shall be or pleasures to make as many people r a I can reach It Js full riper mellowness—worth tons of ordinar may be forwarded through any responsible advertising ist prattle on that subject,” wr . 5 Graham Brooks to Charies F. Dol The Burden of Poverty.” Pos atpat I Street, N. Y. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth ave., New centa York iti For Authors, $0. pert OOweords Typewriting ©" * rerpor 1ColambusAyv., boston

Page 4

The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 APPLETON’S NEW PUBLICATIONS “The ablest work since Grant’s Memoirs.” —The Nation. UNDER THE OLD FLAG By General James Harrison Wilson lhe famous commander's §recol- lections of three wars are told in imple truth regarding men and events. They shed new light on many phases of the Civil War, the Span- ish-American War, and the Boxer Rebellion, upon which historians dif- Ier so radically. OF FAMOUS AMERICANS The Dial “The best work of its kind in re- cent years.” Chicago Tribune “A valuable historical document.” Boston Globe “Picturesque and fascinating rec- ollections of an active and brilliant career.” General Ads lbert Ames “It is a remarkable writing. | know nothing like it.” Senator S. M. Cullom “T learned more about the actual movements of the army from this work than I have from any other book us General I. I. Winslow “It is intensely interesting.” General O, 1. La Grange “Tt is great You write as well as you fought.” General j) Vi V/. Gregg “I have found it wonderfully in- teresting.” UNDER THE OLD FLAG Two vols. Cloth, gilt top. Uneut edges. $6.00 net, per set. OPINIONS OF THE PRESS AND _ NOW READY The American Year Book—1912 A work of accurate information by authoritative writers on everything of importance with which America has been associated during the past year. A complete, impartial history of the happen- ings of the present—the only work of its kind. A reference work of especial value to every American citizen. Over 800 pages. Price, $3.50 net. Hail and Farewell: Salve By George Moore. “Salve” is the work of a genuine word artist and the beauties of his style and the originality of his mental processes will charm the reader on every page. Cloth, gilt top. $1.75 net. Postpaid, $1.89. Social Life in Old New Orleans Reminiscences of Eliza Ripley. Mrs. Ripley, a belle of New Orleans 70 years ago, records her recollections of the quaint French city. Illustrated. $2.50 net. Postpaid, $2.70. Sociology in its Psychological Aspects By Charles A. Ellwood, Ph.D., Professor of Sociology, University of Missouri. A work dealing with the origin of society and the theory of social order and progress. $3.00 net. Postpaid, $3.16. Principles of Educational Practice By Paul Klapper, Department of Education, College of the City of New York. A systematic analysis of the principles of education with practi- cal applications of educational theory. $1.50 net. Postpaid, $1.62. Newspaper Reporting and Correspondence By Grant M. Hyde, B.A., Instructor in Journalism, Umiversity of Wisconsin. A text-book of journalism presenting the fundamental prin- ciples of newspaper writing. $1.50 net. Postpaid, $1.62. The New Competition By Arthur J. Eddy. An important work by a prominent attorney upon the subject of competition and co-operation in business. $2.00 net. Postpaid, $2.14. Railroad Finance By Frederick A. Cleveland and F. W. Powell. The various methods of financing railroads are described in every detail. $2.50 net. Postpaid, $2.70. Democracy and the Church By Samuel G. Smith, D.D. Dr. Smith presents Jesus as the author of the ideals of Democ- racy and the Church as the historic institution in securing their realization. $1.50 net. Postpaid, $1.62. CIRCULARS OR FULL 35 West 3248. D, APPLETON & COMPANY, Publishers DESCRIPTION SENT UPON REQUEST. NEW YORK

Page 5

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 30, The Week It is reassuring to note the growth 1913 of sentiment in Congress, at any rate in the House, in favor of taking the short road out and repealing the clause of the Panama act which frees coastwise ves- sels from Canal tolls. The perception is sharpening on all sides that the thing is nothing more or less than a subsidy. It is not strange that the consistently anti- subsidy Democrats in Congress should feel indignant at the way in which they have been tricked in this matter. Their National Convention at Baltimore was similarly fooled, for somebody smuggled into the platform a plank favoring re- The thing was never discussed, either there or dur- mission of tolls at Panama. ing the campaign, and we presume that Mr. Bryan would be the first to repudi- ate the binding nature of a party pledge which nobody knew anything about and which was somehow foisted upon his platform committee. To save money in the wrong place is not a new practice in Congress, and it is not a surprise that the House followed its Committee on Indian Affairs in re- fusing the request of the Secretary of the Interior regarding the appropriation and medical for hospital, sanitation, work among the red men. The appro- priation has been $90,000, but investiga- tion has revealed a much worse set of conditions among the Indians than in the country as a whole. While the per- centage of deaths due to pulmonary tu- berculosis in the registration area of the United States, which includes twen- ty-one States, is 11, among the Indians it is 32. The death-rate from all causes among these peoples is above 30, or more than double that in the area noted. These facts led Secretary Fisher to rec- ommend in his annual report that the appropriation for hospital and related work among the Indians should be in- creased to $405,000. These figures, how- ever, frightened the thrifty members of the House Committee on Indian Affairs, and they declined to add a single cent to the amount at present allowed. It is possible for the Senate to correct this The Nation error by amending the Indian Appro- priation bill when it comes up for con- sideration. Lorimer does not sit in the Senate, but his influence is threatening to keep any one else from sitting there after March 4 as a representative of Illinois. For in order to elect a Senator the Leg- islature at Springfield must first choose a Speaker of the House and other offi- cers. Nor can the duly elected Gov- ernor of the State be inaugurated until this task has been performed, for the Legislature must first canvass the vote on State officers, and it cannot do this until it has organized. Hence two Gov- ernors are uneasily waiting at Spring field, and two Senatorships are in the balance, because a score of “Lorimer Democrats” steadfastly refuse to sully their good names by voting for an anti- By the patriotic aid of the twenty-five Progres- Lorimer candidate for Speaker. sives in the House, one of the Democrat- ic candidates climbed to within eight votes of the goal on the fifty-sixth and fifty-seventh ballots, but this so far is A deadlock of a somewhat similar sort was the high-water mark of the contest. threatened four years ago, when Gov. Deneen, fearing that the House would arbitrarily declare his election void on uninvestigated charges of fraud, and proceed to seat Adlai Stevenson in the Governor's chair, got the friendly Senate to refuse to enter the hall of the Hous to canvass the vote until an agreement had been made in reference to the meth- ods to be followed in attacking the legal- ity of his election. Missouri will have struck a mighty blow for pure government as soon as the Legislature at Jefferson City enacts Stark's bill that lobbyists employed about the State Representative providing Capital shall wear a distinctive uniform. After all, the first step any form of disease, private or social, is to isolate it and describe it. It is lurk- ing evil that eats at the vitals of the Put the lobbyists in uniform, in combating republic. and members of the Legislature will shun them like the pest. Pass another compelling grafters to wear uni- For the lobbyists it has been law forms. suggested that a brown suit, red cap, and green cravat would be appropriate The grafters might be compelled to wear white duck their sinful natures. as a satiric commentary on Adopt 4 veries of garbs for venal distinctive newspaper men, government contractors, log-roll- ers, pension hunters, and the various species and sub-species of reacticnaries, and the people of Missouri will hence- be saults upon their rights and their liber- It yet forth secure against insidious as thorough applica- of is the most of ties. tion the principle being “shown.” The special message on legislation to correct Stock Exchange abuses, sent by Gov. Sulzer to the New York Legisla- ture, is considerably less drastic in its proposals than there had seemed rea son to expect. It suggests, in fact, that the more carefully the Governor has ex amined the specific proposals for a change, the more he has found himself reasons against confronted with hasty and sweeping legislation. He denounces manipulation of prices, undertaken for the purpose of creating fictitious values and tempting the public to buy or sell on such a basis; but he recognizes that the visible methods used to achieve such ends may be hard to distinguish) from the methods used, for example, to sup stock when he port the price of a given ‘ has seized on t He sudden pani present of undoubted holders it. calls attention to in he certain evils occasioned connection with “short selling’; yet finds it necessary to add that these evils do not arise simply because men offer for sale what they do not at the moment possess, but because they misuse the per- f iu fectly normal machinery of sales for So even of what seemed all Ex- ture delivery. to be the central consideration of of the Stock the incorporation change. Nothing is easier than to say, “Char- ter the Exchange as a corporation, and then let the State insist on obedience to But such its rules.” observance or non-ob- servance of rules is a matter surrounded with questions of technical Under the present organ- of Stock construction. ‘ization and by-laws the Ex-

Page 6

94 change, a member is subject to disci- pline for conduct “detrimental to the in- terest or welfare of the Exchange.” This is a broad and sweeping provision, and All conduct injures the clients of the Ex- it was intended to be so. which change is detrimental to its interests, and has always been so interpreted. The governing committee possesses absolute power to decide when a member's con- duct is subject to that clause, and to in- flict at once the penalty prescribed—- from which there is no appeal. Let the Exchange be incorporated, and the of- fending member may appeal to the courts to construe the nature of his of- fence. It is doubtful if wrongdoing which lies on the border-line of the pro- hibitions can be reached at all with the facility now possible, and it is certain that inflictiun of the penalty will be be- lated. By taking much to heart the report of the Joseph Fels Fund Commission about the financing of the single tax move- ment in large part by one man, the Chi-| cago Evening Post, a Progressive organ, comes perilously near lése-majest6,. The report shows that, during three years, the Philadelphia millionaire has given | to the cause $115,000, while “all other contributions” have totalled only $60,- 000. Mr. Fels was not troubled by this, but he and the members of the Commis- sion were alarmed to find that “all other contributions,” instead of increasing, have been falling off. In the vernacular adopted by the report, “there has been a disposition to ‘let Fels do it.’” there is to be a change. Hereafter, the Commission will furnish money only in amounts equal to those raised in the lo- calities concerned. Thus it hopes to avoid “the pauperization by a rich man of the clearest, most fundamental, most intelligent democratic movement in the history of the world.” But what rela- tion can be imagined between this sit uation among the Single Taxers and Yet the remarks that “the that among the Progressives? Chicago newspaper Progressives can hardly be too demo cratic in their methods of raising funds, nor too careful about cultivating ‘an- gels’ in their movement.” We trust that Mr. Perkins and Mr. Munsey will pro test against this implied reflection. Two strikes have been, under way in New York city. The number of work Hence | The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 ' ers affected by the garment strike has | been estimated as well above 150,000, at one time. The number of men affected by the waiters’ strike is said to be about four thousand. The garment strike has witnessed several outbreaks of disorder, but none of them has been serious; and considering the vast army of workmen who have now been idle for a number of weeks, the strike may be called a peaceable one. The waiters’ strike has been conducted under the auspices of the I. W. W., with emphasis on the pic- turesque elements of stone-throwing and other forms of that delightfully fasci- nating new fad, sabotage. The garment strike is well along towards settlement on a basis of substantial gains to the employees. The waiters’ strike has col- lapsed within less than a week. So once more the lesson has been taught and learned that violence as a factor in collective bargaining is the cause of labor. I. W. W. come out of their latest adven- ture with little credit. The tactics by which they are supposed to differ from the old-fashioned trade-unionists have yet to be justified. They won at Law- rence and at Little Falls only through invoking that public sympathy which in theory they affect to despise. The Birmingham, Ala., News prints an amazing table of the homicides in Jefferson County during the last year. From December 29, 1911, to December 29, 1912, there was a murder every week day in the year! What other commu- nity in the whole civilized world makes so terrible a showing? No mining camp that we are aware of; no wild, debauch- ed frontier settlement can compete with this appalling record. Moreover, it is getting worse. In 1909, 1910, and 1911 there were all told 356 murders; in 1912 there were 306, and 1913 starts off with ten murders in nineteen days, besides eleven deaths from unknown causes. Thus Jefferson County, with 226,476 in- habitants, surpasses even the murder- record of New York City; this one coun- ty long since passed the record of an- nual murders for the entire United King- dom, including London. A column, says the News, could be consumed in analyz- ing the cause of this horrible record, but the main trouble is that nobody fears the law, which is without majesty in this American community. In 1912 only a single man was executed for murder, disastrous to | The leaders of the | and he, needless to say, was a negro. Only three white men were convicted of first-degree murder in 1912, and their cases are still pending on appeal. As for remedies, the News can only ask whether, somehow or other, something cannot be done to arouse public opinion. The punishment to be meted out by the Amateur Athletic Union to James Thorpe, so recently crowned with the title of the world’s greatest athlete, par- takes of the solemnity of excommunica- tion. Not only are Thorpe’s Olympic trophies to be returned to the Swedish authorities for redistribution, but the prizes he has won in this country are to be taken from him, and, worst of all, his records, which to the athlete mean his bid for immortality, are to be ex- punged from the official lists. It may seem that the penalty, though necessary under the rules, is disproportionate to | the offence, if the original nature of | Thorpe’s transgression be considered, wae his course in playing summer baseball for money. But Thorpe’s real offence consists in his keeping silent re- |garding his ineligibility under a rule |which is well established. Knowing |himself to be disqualified for competi- tion at Stockholm, he should have spar- led us the inevitable criticism which will | new be directed against us from quar- ‘ters where the misdeeds of American |athletes are a favorite subject of com- /ment. It required a great deal of effort on the part of fair-minded sportsmen on ‘both sides of the Atlantic to allay the |mutual recriminations which broke out here and in Great Britain after the Stockholm games. Now a good deal of the work will have to be done over. The British protectionists are in a sad plight. They have thrown the “food taxes” overboard, but their rejoicing ‘over that performance is more like the delight that “Hans in Luck” found in his successive Dargains than anything else that we can think of. The London Zco- nomist points out that the Daily Mail's placard, “Death of the Food Taxes,” is “just what the Daily News might have had on the occasion of any Liberal vic- tory during the last nine years,” and that the Mail, the Times, and the Tele- graph have been ardent advocates of the Chamberlain Imperial Preference pol- icy, of which taxes on foreign food sup- plies formed the cornerstone. It can be

Page 7

but a short time before the “tariff re- formers” will find that with that project abandoned their whole stock-in-trade is gone. And this is not only because it will be impossible to make up in the manufacturing centres for the loss of the support of the agricultural interests; it will also be because, apart from special interests, the one argument against free trade for England that has had any weight is the argument that it had been ruinous to agriculture, had cut down the sturdy yeomanry of the country. Well, if free trade had been doing this by simply refusing to protect British agriculture from foreign competition, what shall be said of a policy which, besides refusing that encouragement to agriculture, actually stimulates manu- factures by means of protective taxes? It looks as though the time were soon coming when the Unionist party will find as much relief in giving up all that is left of the protectionist programme as it has seemed to find in the abandon- ment of the food taxes. Violence as part of British suffragist tactics will be more than ever unwise after the events of the iast few days. Mrs. Pankhurst and her associates will maintain that they have been tricked by the Government; but that is a charge which can hardly commend itself to fair- minded men. If the entire proceedings in the House of Commons were simply a bit of elaborate stage setting by Mr. Asquith, who foresaw the Speaker's vital ruling on the Grey amendment to the Franchise bill, then Mr. Asquith must be a stage manager who is willing to pay a pretty steep price in order to obtain his effects. For even with the explicit reservation that the members of the Government were at liberty to take sides in the debate, there was always an element of danger in revealing the ex- istence within the Cabinet of,such sharp differences of opinion on any subject as prevails, let us say, between Sir Ed- ward Grey on one side and Lewis Har- court on the other. The latter’s attack on votes for women was so savage that it could not help being something of an attack on the general position of the Cabinet. As such it was weicomed by the Opposition. There is no reason for doubting that the Prime Minister was willing to have the troublesome is- sue fought out once for all, and that only the Speaker’s ruling threw the, question of woman suffrage, as well as the original problems involved in the Franchise bill, out of court. LONDON, January 23.—Board of Trad regulations issued to-day to become op- erative on March provide that British seagoing sl lips shall carry lifeboats and life-saving appliances for all on board This is of course due to the Titanic dis- aster. But why did the British Gov- ernment’s Board of Trade let matters drift un’.] a calamity occurred go ter- rible as to arouse the attention of the whole civilized world? We shall not attempt to explain. But if we were to adopt the methods current nowadays for the explanation of everything that is wrong in the world, we should say offhand that it is due to the heartless- ness of capital, the utter disregard of the needs of the poor by those who are in the high places of the world, the fail- ure to recognize that all men are broth- ers, the putting of the rich man’s dollar above the poor man’s life. However, seeing that a couple of hundred men lost their lives on the Titanic who had paid high prices for its luxurious ac- commodations, there must be a screw loose somewhere in that explanation; and seeing that probably not a soul of them made any inquiry about the life- boats, and that the same has been true of thousands and thousands of rich men who have been crossing the ocean all these years, we are forced to the con- clusion that when things in this world are not what they should be, the cause is not always to be found in stony-heart- ed wickedness. The manifold and far-reaching effects of the Balkan War will call for frequent comment from now on. One feature that may be already pointed out is that the present happy state of affairs re- flects great credit on the diplomacy of Sir Edward Grey. It was from the British Foreign Minister that the sug- gestion came of a conference of ambas- sadors that should be prepared to stand by and render assistance to the peace plenipotentiaries in case of distress. In the last resort it would be, of course, the will of the Powers that would determine the broad outlines upon which peace was made. But it is plain that if there had been no parallel series of negotia- tions among the representatives of the Powers in London, the break between the Balkan allies and Turkey over the mW) question of Adrianople would have brought abeut a much severer crisis than actually resulted. Valuable time would have been lost in bringing the European Governments together upon a common plan of action, and in the com- plicated interchange of views among so many capitals the chances of misun derstanding and headlong action would have been multiplied. As it was, the London peace conference was virtually a joint session of the official peace pleni- potentiaries and of the representatives of the Powers. In this specific matter British diplomacy has acquitted itself with conspicuous credit. The most romantic figure of contem porary history comes from the land of Aladdin, Sindbad, and Ali Baba. The career of Enver Bey is romantic, not af ter the modern habit we have of speak ing of the romance of science, of bridge- building, and of the glucose products. It is romance of the old-fashioned, heart- thrilling kind, in which youth slays monsters and is rewarded with the bands of beautiful princesses, and dons secret disguises and rides into the face of death on a white charger, and wins the cheering adoration of the multitude. In the summer of 1908,two young Turk- ish officers, stationed at Monastir, raised the flag of revolt against Abdul Hamid and took to the mountains. The two of- ficers were Niazi Bey and Enver Ber. The former has gone back into honora ble obscurity. The latter has remained the darling of fate. When the counter- revolution broke out in Constantinople, Enver Bey was with the army which marched upon the capital under the com mand of Shefket Pasha. When the Con stitution was reéstablished under a new Sultan, a niece of the royal house was given to Enver Bey for his bride. He went to Berlin as military attaché. When the war in Tripoli broke out it was Enver Bey who was sent to Africa to rouse the enthusiasm of the Turkish troops waging a hopeless fight against the Italians. Last week came the crown ing chapter in a career of romanti: glory. To lead a handful of mutineers against the palace of the Ministers, and, pistol in hand, to secure the resignation of a Cabinet and the possible reversal of a policy that may affect the welfare of two continents—for a parallel to this scene one must almost go back to Paris and the early days of one Buonaparte.

Page 8

Yo SECRETARY KNOX’'S NOTE. Secretary Knox’s reply to the protest of the British Government, in the mat- ter of the Panama tolls, assumes an air of mild wonder what the fuss is all about. We haven't done anything yet. The act of Congress, to be sure, autbor- izes the exemption of our coastwise ves- sels from Canal tolls, but they are not yet, in fact, exempted. One would al- most expect the Secretary, in pursuance of this line of argument, to point out that the Canal is not yet finished, and perhaps never may be; that our ships may all sink before reaching the en- trance; and that possibly they may not accept the remission of tolls even if it is offered. The whole drift of Secretary Knox's note is that of avoidance. He insists that the issue is not yet raised. If British shipping is ever, in reality, discriminated against by our Canal reg- ulations, then it will be time enough to inquire into the facts and submit the matter to arbitration. Congress has the power to violate the Hay-Pauncefote treaty, if it pleases, but kas not yet done so, according to Mr. Knox, by any overt and concrete act; so why not wait till it does? So far Philander C. of State. But not in this way reasoned Philander C. Knox, Attorney-General, when he urged the Supreme Court to dissolve the Northern Securities Com- pany, on the ground, not that it had Knox, Secretary actually suppressed railway competition or had raised rates, but that it had ac- quired for itself the power to do so. In the Government brief, whereon the name of Philander C. Knox stands first, the Court was asked to strike down, be- fore it was exercised, “the power to operate the roads in harmony and stifle | competition.” At that time it was the | counsel for the Northern Securities Com- pany who argued as Secretary Knox does now. They had not done anything | yet. Why not wait till they did? But} the Attorney-General and the Supreme | Court would not hearken to that. A dan- | gerous power had been asserted, and It must be denied and destroyed in limine. It was enough then for Mr. Knox that the “direct and necessary effect” of th assumption of power showed what its purpose was, and proved that it must ho grappled with before it had been actual- ly exercised. We do not deny that Secretary Knox's note in rejoinder to Sir Edward Grey 'was a point in the tolls above which [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 The Nation is adroitly written. It is the plea of a But it is, when all is It does not | skilled lawyer. said, a plea in avoidance. meet the main issue squarely. Nothing | but preliminaries and contingencies does it deal with. We do not say that | it is a sparring for time, but one can- | not help suspecting that Mr. Knox will | experience a certain relief in being able | to turn over the actual merits of the} controversy to his successor in office. | Whoever the next Secretary of State | may be, we hope he will not adopt one | position that Mr. Knox rather absurdly | takes in this note. He speaks of the | extraordinarily generous treatment of | the world’s shipping by the United States in the scale of tolls fixed for the use of the Panama Canal. We are to charge $1.25 a ton. But that rate will not suffice to pay interest and the cost of upkeep. Hence, says Mr. Knox, our Government will really be “in the posi- tion of subsidizing foreign vessels.” The | Secretary is astonished at our own mod- | eration. We might have charged, he seems to think, $3 or $5 a ton, and then what would foreign ships have done? The answer is that they would have giv- en the Canal a wide berth. Prof. Emory Johnson’s estimates and calculations pointed out from the first that there | the Canal would repel traffic. The rate fixed was believed to be all that the traffic would bear; and for Mr. Knox to plume himself on our not having made it much higher is a bit ridiculous. What one misses in the Secretary’s note is, not only a resolute meeting of the real question in debate, but the evi- dence of any deep moral and patriotic feeling in reference to the complaint that the nation has been guilty of sharp practice. He discusses the possibility of Congress and the President violating a solemn treaty as coolly as if it were a question of ignoring a municipal ordi- mance. Yet precisely this sense of humiliation and resentment at the thought that Congress has put the coun- try in an attitude of bad faith, has caus- ed all the agitation and evoked the pro- tests from the best men in the land. It was this feeling of hurt national hon- or that moved so ordinarily impassive a man as Senator Root to express him- self with so much passion in his speech in the Senate. Such intensity cf lan- guage would, of course, be out of place in a diplomatic note, but room ought to have been found for something of the sentiment inspiring Mr. Root’s words. And his absolutely unanswerable argu- ment for arbitration of the matters in controversy, in case the act of Congress giving rise to them is not repealed, comes very much nearer, we are con- vinced, to representing the real opinion of the people than do Mr. Knox's guard- ed and qualified offers. Said Senator Root: I realize, sir, that I may be wrong. I have often been wrong. I realize that the gentlemen who have taken a different view regarding the meaning of this treaty may be right. I do not think so. But their ability and fairness of mind would make it idle for me not to entertain the possibility that they are right and I am wrong. Yet, Mr. President, the question whether they are right and I am wrong depends upon the interpretation of the treaty. Gentlemen say the question of imposing tolls or not imposing tolls upon our coast- wise commerce is a matter of our concern. Ah! we have made a tréaty about it. If the interpretation of the treaty is as England claims, then it is not a matter of our con- cern; it is a matter of treaty rights and duties. Sir, we have another treaty, made between the United States and Great Britain on the 4th of April, 1908, in which the two nations have agreed as follows: “Differences which may arise of a legal nature or relating to the interpretation of treaties existing between the two contract- ing parties, and which it may not have been possible to settle by diplomacy, shall be referred to the Permanent Court of Arbi- tration, established at The Hague by the convention of the 29th of July, 1899, provid- ed, nevertheless, that they do not affect the vital interests, the independence, or the honor of the two contracting states, and do not concern the interests of third parties.” We are bound, by this treaty of arbitra- tion, not to stand with arrogant assertion upon our own Government’s opinion as to the interpretation of the treaty, not to re- quire that ‘what she deems injustice by violation of the treaty, or else go to war. We are bound to say, “We keep the faith of our treaty of arbitration, and we will submit the ques- tion as to what this treaty means to an im- partial tribunal of arbitration.” Secretary Knox does not shut the door on arbitration. But his references to it are hedging and temporizing. His note, in general, is of an evasive spirit. It merely stops a gap. It does not pierce to the centre. SIMPLICITY AT WASHINGTON. Woodrow Wilson's objection to the In- augural Ball seemed to be chiefly due to the expense, and the injury done to the public service by the use of the Pension Building. In announcing that he should not go to Washington in a special car,

Page 9

Jan. 30, 1913] and should stay at a hotel, like any oth- | er citizen, until he entered the White House, he was, it is true, but following precedent. Yet taking these things in connection with his refusal to accept Mr. Taft's offer of a Government ves- sel to carry him to Panama, we cannot but hope that this foretells a desire on Mr. Wilson's part to observe while Pres- ident true democratic simplicity. That would be in accord with his attitude hitherto. As president of Princeton, he was modest, unassuming, and accessi- ble; as Governor of New Jersey, his door has been open to all who had le- gitimate business with him, and nothing that savored of fuss and feathers, or display, military or civil, has been in evidence. To foreigners accustomed to elaborate European court ceremonial, the White House often appears to be the expres- sion of a perhaps austere republican- ism. Yet to those who recall the Presi- dent’s residence in the days of Mr. and Mrs. Grover Cleveland, there has been a marked change. At that time there was no large staff of army and navy of- ficers in uniform in attendance at recep- tions, with the chief duty of telling the women guests to stand when the Presi- dent entered or left the room. Ser- vants in livery were lacking, and guards were few; but if there was a touch pos- sibly of the bourgeois, the plicity of it all could but impress visi- tors profoundly, notably those from abroad. We have in mind a distinguish- ed German, familiar with all the courts of Europe, who, in company with a well- very sim- known citizen, found his way to Mr. Cleveland’s office without previous ap- pointment, after being challenged only by the doorkeeper and the secretary. True, the American him was well-known to the White House and Mr. Cleveland. But the absence of who went with uniforms and flunkeys, of ceremonial of every kind, was what astounded this foreign visitor. Nothing else America so impressed him with the fact that here was a great and true democ- racy. All the glitter of the Viennese court faded in comparison. Since then the work of the President has enormously increased, and his re- sponsibilities as well. There must be more attendants at the White and more secretaries. But to-day, in 1885, no amount of gold lace, of liv- eries, of military show, can magnify in all House as The Nation this office, or 1s needed to add to its dig-| nity. Nothing can be so impressive as lack of affectation in men who carry the heaviest governmental burdens of the world. Mr. Wilson will find oppor- check tendencies. tunities and there dan- Under Mr. velt began a serious abuse to here gerous Roose- the misuse of vessels of the navy. Without war- rant of law, three ships were maintain- ed for the use of the President, his fam- ily,and the Secretary of the Navy—the Mayflower, the Sylph, and the Dolphin. To those who recalled the abuse heaped upon Mr. Cleveland for going off on the Dolphin, or one of the lighthouse ten- ders, on a week-end fishing trip, the in- the policy If President is to have a yacht, Congress for it. difference to Rooseveltian Was nothing less than amazing. the should appropriate Then we should not have our Presidents setting an example of lawlessness, and the navy would not be deprived of the services of officers and men who are needed on the fighting ships of the service, for whose manning there is an annual demand for more men and more oificers. Mr. Taft has gone even further than Mr. Roosevelt, in that he has used for his trips to Panama both battleships and cruisers. The regulations require that officers shall not take aboard any women passengers; but the commande: in-chief, to whom al! look to set an ex- ample of obedience to law, has ignored it, and has not hesiiaied to withdraw ships from their regular duties. Mean- while, the Mayflower has been tied up at the dock in Washington, Ler officers paid for sea service, and her chief uss has been for teas and dinner dances, or sea wilh an in offi occasionally she goes to spection board of army and navy cers. To seem a all when some this may small matter the Government is spending billions; in reality, it is im- portant, for every example of this kind, by the man at the head, is the excuse for junketing or petty grafting by those be- low him in the service, Congress now appropriates handsomely for the Presi- dent’s travelling expenses; yet we trust that Mr. Wilson will draw on this fund most sparingly. Mr. Taft's travelling record is such that no one can rival him. Nothing, we are sure, has injured him more than his incessant moving about. Mr. Wilson will surely enhance the dig- of office if he sticks to the nity his 97 é White House and has people come to him, and makes so few speeches that each and every one will be a notable event certain to attract the widest pos- sible attention. To one matter in connection with the Presidency Congress might well devote its attention. A simple summer home in some cool region might well be pur- chased. Governor Wilson will plainly miss the summer headquarters the State of New Jersey provides at Sea Girt. But no grand mansion ist With all the idle peo- ple of wealth now crowding into Wash- here, too, nor v estate is needed. ington as winter residents—it is said that there are now three classes of mul ti-millionaires there: those from Pitts burgh, the South African, and all the others—there never Was a better oppor tunity for the President of the United States to set a noble example of digni- fied, simple living. ROOSEVELT AND THE IDAHO CASE joth before and since the election Mr. Roosevelt has had hard things to say of the Supreme Court of Idaho. Its action in holding some local editors for con- tempt, he fiercely denounced. But he had previously used language fully as severe in speaking of its decision of an election case last October. With the con- here tempt proceedings we have no con- cern, The judges may or may not have been wise in haling newspaper railers to court. But the other matter is still im- portant. From Mr. Roosevelt's savage expressions many people got the idea that the Idaho Supreme Court had been guilty of a high-handed judicial out rage. Few people seemed to know what the facts were. We had the curiosity to send for the complete record of the case, and a reading of it enables one to see what justification, or absence of it, there was for Mr. Roosevelt's scarifica- tion of the Court. Let us begin with his restrained and action 12, judicial characterization of the of the Idaho judges. 1912, he issued a statement at Chicago, On October in which he said it was “impossible to protest too strongly against what is lit- erally the infamy of this decision.” It was “utterly reactionary conduct by a reactionary court,” and was “absolutely without warrant of law.” Furthermore, it was “an attempt to beat the cause by “The trickery and chicanery.” decision

Page 10

QS the justice, against equity, the was against law, against and against whole course of decisions in all our American ourts.”’ much for Mr. Roosevelt's poetry; now for the prosaic facts. Under thé laws of Idaho there are three ways ip hich candidates may be nominated for office so as to be entitled to a piace on the official ballot. One is by the direct primary of a “political party,” in cas the last previous election of this the latter at cast at least 10 cent. the tota! per vote there is of the State. Under no possible claim for the Progressive party; it did not cast any votes at all at the last preceding election. The second method is by Convention of “any organ- ization of electors,” if such a Convention be held on the same day that the direct primary election occurs. That was July 30, last year, and on that day a sort of Progressive Convention was held at St. Anthony. But it was really a mass meeting, called explicitly to organize the Progressive party in [daho, and to send delegates to the Chicago Conven- tion of August 5. The Idaho court held that this St. Anthony “convention” was not one within the meaning of the stat- ute; but it is immaterial whether it was or not, for no attempt was made to file a ticket as coming from that body. The sole reliance of the Idaho Progressives was upon the third method of making nominations, and that is by petition. An effort on their part to get their nom- inees for Congress and for Presidential electors upon the officia] ballot as nam- 1 by petition, was what the Supreme Court frustrated by its decision. \ what was the law relating to non m by petition, and what were t facts? The law provides that cat: didates may be nominated by petition, provided the requisite number is ob tained of signatures—variously pre offices not joined in the eribed for different of quali fled electors who have nomination of any other person for the Lut here comes the crux of rhe same office the Idaho statute relating to Cane nominations by petition contemplated only “State officer It did so by gener al description and also by specific de tail—so many signatures for this office, so many for the other. For the nomina- of electors the Idaho laws made other pro- tion Congressmen and Presidential vision. They could not come under the section covering nomination by petition, - [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 The Natio A SISYPHUS AMONG THE SCIENCES. unless they were “State officers.” The Progressives, in their desperate legal There is something pathetic in the straits, gravely contended that Congress- ° . 8 oe : 8 delight with which Psychical Research- men and Presidential electors were, in ers have greeted the acceptance, by one fact, State officers; but the Court had of our leading universities, of an en- no difficulty in showing that law and & ’ ‘ : Ww > 0,000 > Ss " Constitution and precedent were dead dowment of $10,000 to promote the stud They do not hope for much from the work to be done with the dation, but they prize the respectability ies they have at heart. against that contention—Roosevelt, jus- tice, to the contrary notwithstanding. To of the unanimous Idaho Supreme Court: modest income of this foun- quote the language decision of the . , that is expected to come from the recog- Having treated “candidates for Congspess pe 8 throughout the direct primary election law and statutes of the State as separate and distinct offices, which they are, from “State offices,” and then having omitted candidates for Congress and Presidential electors from | section 385 of the statute, which authorizes for State offices by petition, it that the Legislature has not in- tended to authorize the nomination of can- didates for Presidential electors and mem- of Congress by petition. The is too well recognized and understood everywhere to even require repetition that the f is the exclu- nition thus accorded to their aspirations It may seem cruel to question the sound- But surely there is no magic power in a university for a place in the scientific world. ness of this expectation. Lo natior - seo my charter to effect what a generation of is € ae countenance and support by a number of men of great intellectual eminence bers boo has been unable to compass. The name AT of Henry Sidgwick alone, as the first expression of one thing president of the Society for Psychical Sior ( é I a s of another Research—not to mention notable asso- On the basis of that exposition of the ciates—was far more calculated to give law of Idaho, the Supreme Court ruled standing to its work than any mere of- that the Progressive nominations by pe- | ficial act of acceptance of a fund could tition for State offices should be placed on the official ballot, but that the nom-| inations for Congress and for Presiden- discussions tial The Supreme Court of Idaho did not | sidgwick are particularly be; and even more to the purpose was the high character of the reports and in the early years of the electors should not. of Mrs of A large number of persons Society, among which those worthy say whether it thought the law wise or mention. foolish. It merely pointed out in a long | who had previously refused to take and calm opinion what was the neces- questions of spiritualism or mind-read- Sary intendment of the statute. It is | ing or the like seriously felt that at not probable that Roosevelt had ever) j,.¢ a proper attempt was made to deal read the Idaho election laws. It is cer-| |} with them. that he had not read the full text decision of the Court which he tain of the Well, thirty years have gone by, and - where does the Society stand? Has it branded as “outrageous,” for it was not a p . commanded growing interest, or won in- until after his Chicago explo- printed ae creasing appreciation of its labors? sion. like sudden What happened in Idaho was very The its Progressive ue Quite the contrary. Outside the circle what happened in California. vl of those who are addicted to anything organization of . that smacks of the supernatural, the re- contemplated by never J ; z ports of the Society for Psychical Re- party, a thing the lawmakers, revealed defects in the ’ search attract almost no attention; peo- election statutes. In Idaho they operat- : . ple have given up looking for anything ed, under interpretation by the courts, ; : 4 Mr. R conclusive, either positive or negative, against the Progressives, an r. Roose — “s in its proceedings. And the reason is velt screamed about the frightful injus- plain enough. There is one mark of tice. . In California, as interpreted by scientific vitality which it requires no special study and no special skill to of cumulative Where there is a genuine the judges, they operated against the Republicans, and Roosevelt had never a As for the Idaho case, the recognize—the mark word to say. achievement plain tale of the law and the facts and kernel of truth, and many eager and earnest minds are at work in develop- ing it, we find an addition here, a cor- rection there, a new method or a new instrument introduced, sources of error jat first troublesome gradually removed, the reasoning of the courts is all that is necessary to show how ill informed Mr. Roosevelt was, as well as how reckless, cruel, and incendiary.

Page 11

Jan. 30, 1913] the goal of yesterday made the starting- point of to-morrow. The process may be slow, there may be painful setbacks; but is building up, that we are not everlast- there is the sense that something ingly compelled to begin at the begin- ning. And after thirty years of respec- table and patient work by many highly intelligent persons, Psychical Research is, in a scientific sense, precisely where it was at the beginning. There is, to be sure, an enormous mass of detached ob- servations, and of records of remember- ed or alleged experience; but no part of this mass stands out as a solid residuum, a starting-point for future work. The chief difficulties under which the Psychical Researchers labor are easily named. In the first place, they alone among the cultivators of science, or of would-be science, are continually con fronted with the necessity of guarding against fraud. Secondly, in this inher- ently difficult task they handicap them- selves by submitting to conditions which make the discovery of fraud still mors difficult. as imposed by the nature of the phe- These conditions they regard nomena they are studying, for the pre- cautions necessary to complete surveil- lance are supposed to hinder the phe- nomena from taking place; but if this be true, it is most unfortunate, since the hard-headed man of science will prefer the simpler hypothesis that what is pre- vented from taking place is not the al- the is due. to But leged phenomena but frauds which their appearance possibly all this might not be fatal were it not for a third circumstance. Even in the standard sciences, it is essential to the firm establishment of anything new to the science that the experience on which it is based be capable of exact repetition by any competent observer or experimenter; but the experiences of the Psychical Researchers, though hav- ing to make head against a tremendous presumption of fraud or malobserva- tion, never get themselves strengthened by this kind of repetition. It is easy, however, to account for the state of mind of those Psychical Re- searchers who have become convinced of the reality of the “supernormal” phe- nomena. When they witness a normal” phenomenon against the pro- super- duction of which by fraud or illusion a , great deal of precaution has been tak- en, they are impressed with the feeling that the probability of any actual fraud The Nation illusion is very small; and they fail or to balance this antecedent improbabil- ity the incomparably greater of As a against antecedent improbability the phe nome being genuine. matter fact, the non nod of first probability is by no means extremely smail, as witnessed by the undisputed fact that a very consid erable proportion of experiences held at the to be convincing by observ- time ers as good as any now at work, were afterwards demonstrated to be the re- sult of fraud or illusion. jut, so far from reckoning this probability as one in ten, or one in a hundred, or one ina thousand even, many Researchers are apt fn practice to think of it as abso- Ivor Tuckett, in Bedrock, neatly turns against them a lutely zero. Dr. writing phrase coined by the man who has done more than any one else in recent years Research to the Psychical he ticeable manifestation by them of keep alive movement, when says that any no- “the will to believe” must operate as a dis- astrous diminisher of the weight of their testimony. And when we add that we are constantly treated to exhibitions of credulity, ranging all the way from belief “the movement of a distant chair, visible in Sir Oliver Lodge’s firm in the moonlight, under circumstances such as to satisfy me that there was no di- rect mechanical connection,” to the stories cropping up periodically about knives or violins flying through the room, or the spirit of William James talking rubbish to a Researcher, it to gain is easy to see why the attempt respectable task of for Psychical Research a standing has been like the Sisyphus. WHAT DO WE READ FOR? “Our magazines,” wrote the librarian college fraternity recently, “are of a chosen to meet the demands of college of work in which they are engaged, or else recreation pur- men for information in the lines reading for This reading may be comprehended under a to form poses.” idea that the ends of sharp division between information and recreation is not the possessior of stu- dents alone, but is held and preached by some, at least, of those who are official- ly in charge of education. A State high- school the Middle West took pains a while ago to iwpress it upon a gathering of city school super- inspector in intendents, and also to point out some of its practical consequence: I n¢ kind of reading, he remarked, llus- trated by that which the lawyer does In his office when he goes over 1 ind the precedents, the dor if turns the pages of his medica rks the merchant when he studies look for prices, the housekee] ep she takes up an unfamiliar 1 7) such reading has one commor istic—it is purely intellectual These people neither laugh what they read; but slowly and ily word by word, sentence by sents ind paragraph by paragraph, the mast the thought Every possibl« eaning t be read into every word of the law the lawyer may lose his case; if the house keeper reads two instead of thre poon fuls, the cooking will be a fallurs ind the farmer may incur a posit f the statements of the artic! re , oughly understood The other kind of reading 1s of a very different nature. It is emphatically emo tional, and because of this immense dif turn to it as a relief and a ference “we ] ed rest when the mind is thoroughly ti: by the effort required by the first kind Now, as most literature, strictly so called, is strongly infused with emo- tion, the logical consequence of this analysis is extremely unfortunate, for any reading to which one turns as a re- lief when the mind is thoroughly tired will fail of its purpose if it makes any heavy intellectual demand, and accord- becomes We see ingly “literature’ synonymous with “light reading.” the same tendency carried to even greater great What lengths in the drama, where the motive is frankly “entertainment.” ock wi n room is there, then, for the | although intellectual, does not deal Or agi lh law or medicine or theology ture, and although emotional ard imag- inative, cannot be read as a relief ar rest when the mind is thoroughly ti Well, for such a book there is no ri except, to be sure, in the colleges do not count, and in the outworn cur ricula of our high schools, where, a ote 1, cording to the inspector already q' the matter is one deserving more atten- tion than it is receiving. We have thus a very modern evolution of De Quincey's literature of Power into a literature of Relaxation. As this officer sees it, there is a sim- ple yet fundamental principle by our pedagogical authorities should guided in this field. which be It is this: “What

Page 12

LOO are the best people of the community reading?” The most we can hope, he adds, is that our boys and girls will read “about the same” after they leave school. Are these people, then-——to put the question more specifically --reading the classics of our school lists, or are they reading the books and magazines of to-day? Here is the answer, and its corollary: “If, as is no doubt the case, it is the latter, we should certainly be giving a large place (I do not say the entire place) to the study and reading of current literature.” We hope that lovers of the classics will be duly ap- preciative of the courtesy of that paren- thesis—so long as it is suffered to re- main. But the pressing duty is clear: rhe young people should know something of the great magazines and of the kind of reading matter which may be expected in each A training which will lead the your people to select healthful standards and influential magazines is absolutely nece iry if we are to train for the best t'zenship One would think that, with current lit- erature forming the predominant part of parents’ reading, pupils might be trusted to absorb sufficient knowledge about it at home One might even hazard the notion that the standard of reading in a community, partieularly a comparatively new community, might not be the ultimate standard for the schools of that community. Why should not the school have the ambition to re- fine and broaden the literary taste of the growing generation, however unflat- tering the result to the sensibilities of the “best people” of the older genera: tion—if, indeed, they were not the first to welcome the advance? But this is te talk like one who does not know the differene between intellectual reading and reading to which one turns as a re- when the mind ig thor- lief and a res oughly tired The gravest aspect of this whole posi- tion is perceived only when it is realized that English is, for the mass of pupils, the one definite source of culture. Latia has been virtually banished, Greek they never had, and history is taught more and more as a kind of science, with em- phasis upon sources and facts, rather than upon the human element in it. And now we are told that in Bnglish, too, the classics are in the way of the mod- erns. It is apparently necessary to be gin at the bottom, and to ask what an education, what reading is for. Milton had the idea that_a great book was The Nation — —_ something more than an intellectual or an emotional product, or even a coni- bination of the two. To him, it was “the precious life-blood of a master spirit, embalmed and treasured up on purpose This would re- main true, were every teacher of Eng- lish as inadequate for his task as some of them must be confessed to be— would remain, that is, if it had been true in the first place; for, alas, the “Areopagitica” is but a classic. to a life beyond life.” DANTE’S “NEW LIFE.” Il gran teologo—the great theologian the early commentator who so describ- ed Dante was after all nearest the truth. From first to last Dante was a student and declarer of the word of God. If as artist in words he proclaimed himself apprentice of Virgil, as apostle of the Word he draws over and over again analogy between himself, follower of Beatrice, and St. Paul, follower of Christ. If Beatrice were merely the Florentine maid and later matron, of whom Boccaccio tells, so to liken service of her with service of Christ would seem an extravagance; Dante, I think, would have held it a blasphemy. But if we sub- stitute for Beatrice that which he tells us plainly her name signifies, blessed- ness, all incongruity ceases. That blessedness, fulfilled in the vi- sion of God, is the theme of the “Divine Comedy” no one doubts. It is the regu- lative ideal behind the argument of the “Essay on Monarchy” and of the “Ban- quet.” There are, Dante tells us in the former work, two ends set for mankind, to wit, earthly blessedness, attainable by man under the guidance of philoso- phy followed in the peace maintained by God’s temporal vicar, the Emperor; and heavenly blessedness, attainable by man hereafter, but here meditated in the light of things revealed according to the sanction of God's spiritual vicar, the Pope, and pursued with faith, hope, and charity. And the Wisdom, which is the theme of the “Banquet,” is like- wise twofold, that which is of the intel- ligence of man, philosophy, guiding to earthly blessedness, and that which is of the intelligence of God, theology, guiding to heavenly blessedness. In oth- er words, the way to earthly blessedness lies in the fulfilment of the moral vir- tues in the active life, the way to heav- enly blessedness lies in the fulfilment of the theological virtues-—faith, hope, and charity—in the contemplative life; and in proportion as heavenly blessed- ness transcends earthly, so the contem- plative life transcends the active. And again, the avowed purpose of the “Trea. tise on Vernacular Eloquence” Is to pat- tern a fit garment of words and music for high themes of “salvation, love, and virtue”—for the “poetry of God,” as Boc- ceaccio finely defines theology. For by love Dante here intends no vain and amatorious passion, but charity, the love of God which is the joy of blessed- ness, Now if through all Dante's other writ- ings so runs this one theme of man’s quest of blessedness, might we not rea- sonably listen for some accent of it in his “New Life,” the very title of which seems to imply a regeneration, a con- version—a “being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible. by the word of God’? And the expec- tation is heightened when we find Dante at once calling Beatrice his “beatitude” (beatitudo, beatitudine), or blessedness. Indeed, remembering his play on the names Giovanna and Primavera, we may well surmise that he either chose the |'name Beatrice outright, or at least pre- ferred it to its corruption Bice, for its etymological kinship to beatitude. Of course, many have suspected alle- gorical intent in the “New Life”—some- times with singular results, as when Dante Gabriel Rossetti, convinced that Beatrice stood for the Empire, anagram- matized the Amore of the “New Life” into Amo Re, “I love the king.” In gen- eral, I believe, these interpreters have accepted the issue that, if the “New Life” be an allegory, Beatrice cannot have been a real person, and so Dante’s love-story must be a mere fiction. Now that is a distinctly distasteful idea. We should lose perhaps our last truly granée passion, that dearest idol of the tribe of sensibility. Signor Carducci, probably head of the present school of interpretation of the “New Life,” chal- lenges doubt of Dante’s real love for a real girl called Beatrice with the same knightly heat as Warton put into his defence of the truth of Surrey’s love for Geraldine, or Grosart of Spenser’s love for Rosalind, or Swinburne of Shake- speare’s love for the Dark Lady. Who dare say that much learning cools the heart? Fortunately, the issue is a false one. Beatrice may have been real, and Dante’s youthful love in earnest (what- ever one means by that), and yet the experience as recorded in the “New Life’ be allegorized. There are indeed some apparent ob- jections. The “New Life” consists of thirty-one poems connected by prose, partly narrative, partly expository. The poems were not written for the work, but occasionally and at different times. Moreover, many of them, by themselves, convey no hint of allegorical intention. But the design of the work as a whole may appear in the separate parts as much and as little as the design of a mosaic in the separate pleces of col- ored stone or glass that compose it, These are so chosen and fitted as to bring out the design. Similarly, having

Page 13

Jan. 30, 1913] ‘The Nation later realized the providential design in his experience of love, Dante may have chosen from a not inconsiderable body of love-poems those which could fairly bring out that design. For Dante and scholastic thinking generally, the “moving cause” of anything is its final cause. If from profane love he had been led by purifying stages to holy love, some glimmer of holy love must have been present, though at the time not recognized, even in profane love. So precisely Beatrice tells him in paradise (v, 7-12). And if this redeeming some- what was present in the actual experi- ence, it should appear in his record of the experience; or if in his then blind- ness he had failed to indicate it, he had the right later to inread or insert it. The second objection is that Dante in the “Banquet” (I, i, 111 et seq.) calls his “New Life’ more “fervid and im- passioned” than the “Banquet.” But Dante’s actual contrast is drawn be- tween the two works in respect not to meaning but to method. Having said that in the “Banquet” the “viands,” or passionately expressed odes, are to be made digestible for the mind by “bread” of allegorical interpretation, he adds: “And if in the present work [the ‘Ban- quet’] the handling be more virile than in the ‘New Life,’ I do not intend thereby to throw a slight in any respect upon the latter, but rather to strengthen that by this.” Now how, it may in deference be asked, may the “New Life” in any way be “strengthen- ed” by the allegorical interpretations of the “Banquet” unless at least in principle these apply? To my indiffer- ent understanding the alleged objection to allegory in the “New Life” appears rather to be a fairly clear hint from Dante himself not only that there is al- legorical design in the ‘New Life,” but that it is in accord with that of the “Banquet” itself. Other objections might be met—such as that Dante was too young or too ig- norant at the time he composed the “New Life” to carry through a progres. sive philosophical allegory. In other words, the “first friend” of Guido Caval- canti, subtle metaphysician and author of an allegorical ode on Love unex- hausted by generations of commenta- tors, was too ignorant of the first prin- ciples of accepted Catholic doctrine to present them under the color of a real or feigned love-story. For that, and only that, is what I hold that he did. And, again, the same man who, as we are told, could not at thirty do thus much in spite of the incentives of literary fashion and personal emulation, yet could within fifteen years conceive and flawlessly execute the most learnedly comprehensive and subtly intricate al- legory ever written. Apart, however, from all antecedent gorical interpretation is whether or not it works. Assuming provisionally that we are justified in looking for a contin- uous allegory in the “New Life,” can we find it? I think we can. Entire con- vincingness, however, follows rather from cumulative detail than from any general consideration, and cumulative detail is impossible within the plan of the present article. I here merely out- line an interpretation for the consid- eration of Dante readers, reserving full- er and more technical exposition for a more appropriate place. On its face, the “New Life” tells ‘the story of a purification by successive stages of Dante's love of Beatrice. In the dramatic design there is obvious symmetry. The central event is Be- atrice’s death; and on either side of that there is a striking parallelism in the ac- tion. For nine years the young Dante worships the living Beatrice from afar, mute and unrecognized. Then she deigns to greet him; and in her salute, or “salutation,” he says, he sees his “blessedness,” and is filled with the spirit of “charity.”” With the best of in- tentions, however, he turns his outward attentions to another lady, gentle and very pleasing, as “a screen of the truth.” This unreal worship continues for “some months and years,” until the lady leaves Florence, when for the same reasons he gives his heart to another. And so verisimilar is his devotion towards this second “screen” that Beatrice, scandal- ized, denies her salutation. Dejected by the joss of her grace, Dante in a vision is counselled by Love to abjufe “shadows” (simulacra) of the “love which is nobleness,” and to confess his true love, Beatrice. And Love weeps for the present degradation of his servant. But in vain Dante for grace. Beatrice and her ladies only “mock” him. At last he is racked by a “battle of thoughts,” some humbly urging the beneficence of his love, others stubborn- ly objecting its humiliations and ap- parent hopelessness. But at last, at- taining the spirit of renunciation, no longer suing for her grace, he resolves to seek a blessedness that cannot fail him in contemplating and praising her; and gradually he finds it. Indeed, dis- ciplined at last to this novel kind of love, he finds it no longer bitter, but “sweet” to his heart; and is so happy in the “grace” of Beatrice’s ennobling beauty, that his heart cries for “more grace” (pia salute). Instead, apparently, the source of his blessedness is dried up. Beatrice dies. He has lost, it seems, the grace of her beauty forever. And so in his forlorn- ness, he accepts lovingly the consolation of another lady. Again, his intentions are good. The Consoling Lady is so gen- tle, so like the lost Beatrice in color and demeanor; “noblest " he as-| sues love, 101 probability, the final test of any alle- sures himself, must abide with her. But = Sa=—__ does not come; “battle of his earthly declaring it most as faithless to Beatrice. Again, this time of Beatrice, very likeness of the who had appeared—Dante is shamed his shadow-love, and in agony of penitence professes once more and for always only Beatrice. And in reward he receives in a vision again the sustaining grace of her visible presence in that higher life where he may yet see her face to fac« the expected rather he is torn by a new some justifying peace thoughts,” consolation, some “base by a vision Love before from this at the reader of summary of the story may think once of Rossetti’s “Blessed Damozel” wooing humanly her lover to her side, or of Goethe’s tender-hearted Gretchen humanly pleading with the Virgin for her erring lover. He may find in the “New Life” only that idealization womanly influence for good so familiar to us after the pseudo-platonism of the Renaissance and of the romanticists Now, I dare say of summed in Goethe's now hackneyed lines— Das Ewig-weibliche Zieht uns hinan But to Dante, I think, that romantic sen- timent would have appeared preposter- For philosophy and that of his school was simply inferior or unfinished man. His master, Guini celli, feigning himself rebuked by God himself for finding semblance of Him in “vain love” of woman and directing to her praise due to Him and the Vir- gin, makes the that the lady's “angel face” was merely a reminder of the divine beauty. In fact, the excel- lence of any of God's handiwork might have served—the beauty of the stars, for instance. Indeed, in the “Banquet” Dante, following also Aquinas, says as much (III, fi, 50 et seq. Cf. Aquinas, Comm. I Cor., xiii, 4). Now the high- est excellence under heaven is human reason, and it is precisely in defect of reason that woman is, according to Dante, inferior to man; he explicitly denies her even “virtue,” so far as that is the operation not of “a certain esti- mable emotion” but of reason. It would be obviously absurd, then, for man, su- perior in his highest faculty, to suffer himself to be led anywhere by woman, his inferior in just that faculty. I think it is safe to say that for Dante it was not Beatrice the woman who drew him “upward and on,”’—even if there was a woman called Bice whom he loved. ous. his woman excuse But suppose, granted her existence, that her name and “angel face’’ remind- ed him of blessedness, his ultimate good, then, that relationship once establish- ed, analogy might easily drawn between his profane desire of the wo- man and his holy desire of blessedness, and the course of the profane desire be be

Page 14

1O2R The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 so told as to imply the course of the | holy desire. Let us see. The literal story of the “New Life,” as outlined above, has two moments in which Dante’s desire of Beatrice is po- tentially fulfilled: first, just before her death, when, as he says, “her virtue wrought in me” so that “even as Love was hard to me at first, so now doth he dwell sweet in my heart”; secondly, in the final vision of her in paradise, when his “pilgrim spirit,” reaching whereto it desires, contemplates dimly “through her splendor” his lady in glory. Ac- cordingly, if Beatrice signifies blessed- ness, these two potential fulfilments are respectively of blessedness in this life and in the next. The one way to both fulflments is “holy love, or charity” towards men and God. By the grace of Beatrice—the salutation hoped for—“no enemy was left to me,” declares Dante, “but rather a flame of charity possessed me which made me pardon whomsoever had offended me; and to him who had then asked of me concerning any mat- answer would have been sim- ply: Love! with a countenance clothed in humility.” By the grace of Beatrice —the salvation hoped for—(since salute means both “salutation” and “salva- tion”) his whole care is to be with her “who gazeth in glory on the face of him, qui est per omnia sacula benedictus.” “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God. Thou shalt love thy neighbor as thyself. On these two Command- ments hang all the Law and the Proph- ets.” . Thus by desire of the earthly Beatrice, earthly blessedness, Dante receives hu- man charity which fulfils the moral law by overcoming not only sin, but the temptation of sin; and by desire of the heavenly Beatrice he receives divine charity which unites man with God and is the joy of the blest. It is, as we have seen, the dual message of the “Ban- quet,” the “Essay on Monarchy,” the “Divine Comedy.” But the way of true love never runs smooth. Human nature attains blessed- ness, earthly and heavenly, only by a of sighs.” Human desire is human understanding weak, shadows for realities. those shadows of “noble love,” those pleasing ladies, “sereens” of his blessed lady. Pursuing inordinately earthly “pleasures,” he lost for a time the hoped-for grace of bless- edness in this life. Then, that blessed- potentially attained, not at once realizing that it itself ig but the shad- ow of heavenly blessedness, he abides in the shadow of the active life, the fal- laciously Consoling Lady, until by dl- vine grace light is given to disperse the shadow and to lead heart and will and mind to desire and meditation of true blessedness As I have said, I do not expect this bare outline to carry conviction; but I) ter, my “way atrong; mistaking Dante ever Too well served ness venture to assert that body and weight | can be given it by side-hints and con-| tinuous accordance of detail. Certainly, | by such interpretation, if justified, the “New Life’ acquires new importance as conveying Dante’s essential message; and, I believe, also richer literary sanc- tion. Conceived as a love-story colored by “the mystic apotheosis of woman,” | it is open to the sarcasm of Karl Voss- | ler, a recent German critic: “There is) a foppish and modish cast to this youth- ful work which has made it especially dear to all westhetes.” But conceived as an allegory of religious conversion, its ecstatic intensity, its swoonings and} tears, genuflections and exaltations, cease to appear fantastic and improba- ble, for such is the confessed behavior of the religious convert of all ages; as a work of art it is so, and probably so only, true to life. J. B. FLeTcHer. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. The first editions of the writings of Charles Dickens hold a permanent place} in the hearts of book-collectors and on the shelves of their libraries. What is per- | haps the best Dickens collection ever brought together is the one now on exhibi- tion (to continue until March 8) in New| York, at the Grolier Club’s house in East Thirty-second Street. The books exhibited are, for the most part, loaned by members of the Club, though some items are from the collection of the late Harry E. Wide- ner. The catalogue, compiled by Ruth S. Grannis, the Club’s librarian, is a book of 228 pages, describing 342 items. While not primarily a Dickens bibliography and while not complete, owing to the omission of a few items (generally of minor charac- ter) not in the exhibition, it is, in fact, the best printed guide for the Dickens col- lector thus far issued. A few books are described which are not included in any of the earlier Dickens Bibliographies. Per- haps the most important of these new dis- coveries is an issue of the “Battle of Life” (1846), with a title differing from, and apparently earlier than, the three issues heretofore known. After the illustrative title-page, “A Battle of Life,” had been en- | graved, the publishers, or the author, de- cided that a further explanatory phrase, “A Love Story,” was necessary, and the | variations of the four issues are brought | about by changes in this sub-title. In this discovered variety, which seems to|} the first, the three words, “A Love Story,” are printed from type, below the/| illustration. In the second issue “A Love! Story” is in a simple scroll, engraved upon | the lower part of the plate below the Iillus- tration. In the third issue the scroll is al- tered, and the figure of a cherub support- ing it is added, as well as a publisher's imprint, in a single line. The fourth dif- fers from the third only in the absence of | the line of imprint, which has been re-| moved, Owing to the fact that a large remainder | of the sheets were discovered some years | ago in a printer’s warehouse, Dickens's | first play, “The Village Coquettes” (1836), | is no longer included among the great newly be rarities, although the separate issue of the “Songs, Choruses and Concerted Pieces” must be so considered. The copy of the latter which is exhibited is a presentation copy to J. P. Harley, who acted one of the parts when the play was first produced |at St. James Theatre in December, 1836. It is loaned by Mr. Morgan. Only slightly less rare (when perfect, with the frontis- plece by H. K. Browne) is Dickens’s second play, a farce, “The Strange Gentleman” (1837). The copy exhibited, loaned by Frederick R. Halsey, is perhaps the most valuable extant, as it contains Browne’s original drawing for the frontispiece. In 1871 Chapman & Hall issued a facsimile reprint, but without the frontispiece by Browne, which is so exact that no typo- graphical variations can be discovered. Miss Grannis indicates some slight varia- tions in the positions of corresponding words on two sides of a leaf, discovered by holding the paper up to the light, but we doubt if these would be constant in all copies. Any collector before buying a copy of “The Strange Gentleman” without the frontispiece would do well to insist upon a pedigree for it. Dickens wrote another play, “Is She His Wife?” which was acted at St. James Theatre in 1837, and, without much doubt, printed the same year, though no copy is now known. The Boston publisher, James R. Osgood, once owned a copy, which he described as “demy 8vo. 32 pages,” and from which he made a reprint in 1877. Os- good’s copy of the original was destroyed in the great Boston fire of 1879. There are in existence some three or four copies of an undated pamphlet edition, 22 pages only, of uncertain origin and date, but ascribed to 1873. The first of these seems to have been discovered in 1902. More definite in- formation about it ought to be forthcom- ing. Another dramatic piece, “Mr. Nightin- gale’s Diary,” is almost as rare as “Is She His Wife?” though printed fourteen years later. Osgood’s copy, from which he made a reprint in 1877, was also destroyed in the Boston fire, and for a long time the only copy known was the one in the Forster col- lection in the South Kensington Museum. The Grolier Club exhibit contains Wilkie Collins’s copy, afterwards Augustin Daly’s, now Mr. Halsey’s, and it is said that one other is known. Few Dickens collectors are familiar with 'the three Royal Literary Fund pamphlets | printed in 1858: (1) “The Case of the Re- formers in the Literary Fund. Stated by Charles W. Dilke, Charles Dickens, and John Forster”; (2) “Royal Literary Fund. A Summary of Facts. Together with a Report of the Proceedings of the last. An- nual Meeting, March 12, 1858”; (3) “Royal Literary Fund. The Answer to the Com- mittee’s Summary of ‘Facts.’ By C. W. Dilke, Charles Dickens, and John Forster.” | That Dickens was the actual author of the first and third is virtually certain, and the second, drawn up by a committee of the other faction of the Society, contains, in the report of the annual meeting, a speech by Dickens. First editions of all the regularly pub- lished books are shown in the exhibition, including the novels as issued in monthly parts. The “Pickwick” is a particularly interesting copy, the covers of Nos. 1 and 2 bearing the legend “With Four Illustra-

Page 15

b | i | Jan. 30, 1913] The Nation 108 ' tions by Seymour,” and that of No. 3 “With Illustrations by R. W. Buss.” Only a very few copies with these covers in correct state have survived. The covers generally read simply “With Illustrations.” As is well known, most of Dickens’s manu- scripts are in the South Kensington Mu- seum, to which they were bequeathed by John Forster. From the few important manuscripts not in the Forster collection the Grolier Club has been able to procure for its exhibition portions of “Pickwick” and “Nicholas Nickleby” and the entire manuscript of two of the Christmas books, “The Christmas Carol” and “The Battle of Life,” besides several shorter pieces, ar- ticles contributed to periodicals, a speech, the petty cash book kept by Dickens when a clerk in a lawyer’s office in 1828, various autograph letters, etc. A miniature on ivory, two portraits in oils, and several pencil sketches and wa- ter-color drawings are shown, as well as a few relics. A chair from the dining-room of Gad’s Hill, Dickens’s office slate, his paper knife, and the calendar which was upon his desk at the time of his death, give a personal touch to the exhibition which, though a little belated, is, we be- lieve, the best of the numerous loan col- lections brought together in England and America to mark the centenary of Dick- ens’s birth. Correspondence DISPROPORTION IN COLLEGE CULTU- RAL COURSES. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: SIR: Studying through college cata- logues, the open-minded teacher finds him- self with a growing amazement at the dis- proportion in time, effort, and nature of work existing among college cultural courses. The lack of proportion seems to be largely, but not wholly, due to the use of the semester system. Illustrations from the catalogues will lay bare the error, and constant mindfulness of the semester sys- tem will reveal what seems to be one of the chief causes. The policy of too many departmental! heads in colleges seems to be to treat all sub- jects alike. For example, an English lit- erature curriculum before me offers more than twenty three-hour-a-week semester courses. In it the history of English lit- erature receives the same amount of time —and presumably the same amount of at- tention—as eighteenth-century prose; the drama (1590-1640, exclusive of Shakespeare) as much as “Poetics”; “Beowulf” as much as Browning. Another curriculum offers a dozen three-hour-a-week year courses. The majority of these courses are just frag- ments of literature—all so-called periods of literature seem to be regarded as equal- ly fertile in cultural crops. A third of- fers twenty-five two-hour-a-week semester courses. In it “Beowulf,” Milton, four- teenth-century literature, drama, the novel, Shakespeare, history and principles of ver- sification, nineteenth-century poetry, nine- teenth-century prose, receive each two hours a week during a semester. That all fields yield like quantity and equal quality of crops is hard to believe. For instance, a class studying the novel (in still another college) meets three times a week for a semester. It reads seventeen novels—a requirement necessitating the reading of more than 500 pages a week. The studying in such a course will be neither prolonged nor intensive. But aside from undue length of assignments (which always mears hasty reading), and aside from what of value a student mayor may not have got when he has completed t's work, is not such a course a violation of the msthetic sense of enjoyment? The works of our standard novelists are to be read, if read appreciatively, in small bits; they are not to be gobbled down. The life in them is not in tabloid form; it is spread out—like life itself—and varied. Would it not seem that the nature of such a study lends itself not to a three-hour-a-week course through one semester, but better to a two-hour-a-week course through the year? A course in Victorian poetry gets th same amount of time, three hours a week during a semester. Students “study” the works of Tennyson, Arnold, Rossetti, Mor- ris, Browning, Swinburne, as “leading fig- ures of the nineteenth century,” in order to “trace the principal currents of nine- teenth-century thought.” Which course, this or the one in the novel, each receiving the Same amount of time, and, presumably, of attention, contains the greater cultural value? However, without asserting the pre- dominating value of one over the other, ask two questions: Which is the more suitable for study? and, Which lends it- self better to the semester system? The nature of such a course demands that the work be both intensive and ex- tensive. For working-material the student has fifteen or twenty short poems chosen from each writer’s poetry and extracts from his longer, more philosophical poems. So big is the demand and so inadequate are the selections that teachers, feeling guilty, refer the students to learned and highly specialized volumes dealing with the sub- ject. Through these the student may browse, forgetful, or almost forgetful, of the poet’s poems. When we are thus hastily shoving a stu- dent over the surface of a few selections, can we expect him to “grasp as a whole” the work of any poet—much less under- stand the poet’s “philosophical attitude towards life’ and his “reflection of the thought of his time’? If the course is to be thus comprehensive and thus philosoph- ical, the student must have plenty of the original material to work, must have time for study, must be taught to reflect, and must have time for reflection (And, by the way, he must not be deprived of the value and joy of discovery and of original work.) Should it not seem that ich a course with such an aim would | better treated in many semesters? If the novel is worth one semester—measuring iltural values in semesters—would not such a course be worth many semesters? So the disproportion goes. Courses seem to be constructed, not ordinarily in con- sideration of their sterility or fertility, but in consideration of their time-group- ing or clustering; if a number of writers lived at about the same time, they are to be studied together, almost without regard to the relative cultural values of their writings. Groups one is tempted to make | the deduction, must be of equal cultural value; and the individual writings making up each group must be of less value than the time-clusters Such reasoning is un- sound. Such apportioning of studies to time and to kind and amount of material suggests an unthinking desire of the in- structor to cover #80 much ground.’ HAROLD G. MERRIAM January 1S STRAINING AT 4 GNAT Sim: In the editorial on “The Efficiency Nostrum” in your issue of January 16, there appears to be a misunderstanding of what was attempted recently by the assist ant controller at Harvard There seems to be no ground for supposing that his in- quiry suggests a tendency towards install ing at Harvard or anywhere else a system requiring periodicall make report of every hour that he spent ipon his work, and have his pay doled out to him accordingls Data as to di si tion of time were sought “as a basis for pro-rating salaries,” not re-rating them It was contemplated using the figures “for the purpose of distributing salaries,” which does not mean assigning or allot- ting them to individuals tant’s, not the economist’s, sense of the term distribution which was evidently employ- ed. Many industrial concerns “prorate” or ’ the salaries and other gen- eral expenses each month, or each “period” of accounting, to the different departments of the business (“‘to the various claseified functions,” to quote the assistant control- ler), and that practice has no effect on the amount of the salaries, present or future, CHARLES W. MIXTER It is the accoun- distribute’ whatever. Philadeipbhia, January 24 AREN'T I? Te THE Epitor oF THE NATION SIR In the issue of January 23, J. M Hart asks Nation readers whether he is justified in rebelling at the use of “Aren't I” in Book II, chapter iii, of Wells's “Mar riage.” In my opinion, Mr. Hart is not justified In the sentences, “My dear! Aren't I a feminist? “Don’t I want women fine and sane and responsible?” the phrase is a mere piquancy of speech. Trafford, the speaker, ‘the latest word in British science and culture,” is perfectly conscious of his olecism. He is speaking intimat to his ife and employs the expression wit urti tie carelessness, just as Mark T “don’t” with a singular subject to pr re humorous effect There is a subtlety in the adaptation of words to emotions that ! much more easily felt than expressed. Mr. Hart ’ Is there anything to prevent our Am I not?” “Am I not” is ar ment to all lovers of graceful dignified discourse it dos ver We but in intimate conversation it is dey ng ly awkward If | were a womar ye husband said, “My dear! Am I not ist? Don't I,” ete., I should find in his question a certain argumentative iperior ity instead of affectionate sympathy There is no doubt that Aren't / is wrong, and Wells knew it was wrong and Trafford

Page 16

| Vol. 9 ———_—— 6, No. 2483 ne. and the readers of the it is, ‘the very sublime of faith, truth, published in the two collections of sition y it, and so do I. But we like | and devotion.’” One wonders a little) Emily’s verse made by Charlotte drew nl are sorry that Mr. Hart com- 1. in this leap-year hymn to Liberty, | their theme from the same imaginary iren't /, without reserva- Y e e Vis os, the point should have been overlooked land—for instance, “The Visionary’: tio indiscriminat jabbering or scrib- we think he misses some of that, in a still more specific way,“ Wuth-| Silent is the house: all are laid asleep: M. I. HASKELL. ering Heights” was the original; for | One alone looks out o'er the snow-wreaths deep, there, , the avowal of love had been : % we : ds - . . Watching every cloud, dreading every breeze left to the female characters. But the) phat whirls the wildering drift, and bends reader is likely to be more interested the groaning trees. . ‘ . in Emily’s epic venture than in this Literature y's el i i che i >» ~hes s the matt dubious praise of unrepressed passion, Cheerful is the hearth, soft the matted ay which, by the way, Jane Eyre would... Seer; R EMILY BRONTE utterly repudiate, or, rather, has nobly | — pee —— ee The Three Brontés. By May Sinclair. repudiated in word and deed. The little a burns straight, its rays Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $3 net. “The Complete Poems of Emily Bron- shoot strong and far; té,” edited by Mr. Clement Shorter in|I trim it well, to be the wanderer’s guiding Mi Sinclair has written her study i908, contained, besides the verse al- star. of the Brontés in a fierce glow of in- ready well known, the sixty-seven dignation against those who would trace poems privately printed in 1902 and a ae my engty sire! chide, my angry the beginning of Charlotte's power tO/new group of seventy-one poems then | set ange SUE to spy; threaten me with an ill-fated passion for M. Héger, the | @rgt made public from the notebooks shame: , . ; Belgian schoolmaster, or would attrib-| which had come to the editor from/|But neither sire nor dame, nor prying serf Emily's great work to her caitif€| Charlotte's husband. There is un- shall know, brother, Branwell, or in any other Way qoubtedly something extravagant in| What angel nightly tracks that waste of would deflect to some alien source the) yiss Sinclair's praise of Emily’s verse frozen snow. inspiration that sprang spontaneous IM | ag qa whole; a considerable part of this| what 1 love shall come like visitant of air the breasts of the divine sisters. She) product is of an immature, school-girl-| safe in secret power from lurking human has done a good work in laying those /jgh character, which tends rather to| snare; ghosts of criticism, and she has written | obscure the genius of the writer and| What loves me, no word of mine shall e’er an interesting book, although a reader|might better have been left unpub- | betray, here and there may feel that her lan-|}ighed. But Miss Sinclair has made | 720USh for faith unstained my life must guage is keyed a trifle too high, 18/ one discovery which, if not very valu- ate eats even hysterical in places, and may ask) able intrinsically, does in a way throw| Burn, then, littl; lamp; glimmer straight whether her peculiar tone of exultant| an interesting light on the working of and ¢lear— praise is not due to her conception| mmily’s mind. Scattered among the | Hush! a rustling wing stirs, methinks, the of the Brontés as rebels against the|new poems she has detected a whole air: limitations imposed on the feminine in-| group of inventions which she regards| He for whom I wait, thus ever comes to | me; a “— a. SS eae ae fragments of & Tianle cpts,” Strange Power! I trust thy might; trust appreciation of the Haworth novels.|on which the poet was brooding from thou my constancy. ro connect the homeliness of Jane Eyre | 1834, when she was about fifteen years (who, after all, was probably not so|old, until 1845, two years before the It is a fair conjecture that these stan- plain as she paints herself) with the publication of “Wuthering Heights.” zas, with their style halting between emancipation of woman has, at least,| The theme is traced by the recurrence the sublime and the naive, are the ex- its humorous aspect of certain fanciful names, such ag | Soeeeten neither of an actual passion More particularly, Miss Sinclair has|Gondal, Zamorna, Almedore, and from | idealized, as some would have us be- centred her admiration upon Emily,/the apparent importance of the first | lleve, nor of a pure mysticism, which who, rather than any dull male of|of these the poems are styled by Miss | Miss Sinclair would compare with the Brussels, was the awakener and sus-! Sinclair the “Gondal Chronicles.” | Divine Love of Juan de la Cruz. In talner of Charlotte’s genius: “‘Wuth-| Whether Emily ever had the plan of| the writer’s imagination these snowy ering Helghts’ was the fruit of a di- uniting these disjecta membra fnto a|™oors of Yorkshire were no doubt here vine freedom, a divine unconsciousness. | single epic, may be doubted; it is, how. | blended indistinguishably with “Gon- [t is not possible that Charlotte, of all| ever, perfectly clear that for eleven | 44l'’s mists and moorlands drear”; the people, should have read ‘Wuthering years her imagination was dwelling in| haughty sire and prying serf were at Heights’ without a shock of enlight-\a strange fictitious land, among the | once symbols of the restraint in the enment: that she should net have com-| Gondal folk, and was haunted by fairy | Haworth parsonage and actors in some pared it with her own bloodless work)| rumors of revolutions and embattled | #°ene of her epic dreams; and the vis- lin ‘The Professor']; that she should | armies, of exiled heroes, and forsaken | iting Power was a creature strangely not have felt the wrong done to her) ladies. It is all a wild medley of By- | combining the abstract spirit of re- genius by her self-repression.” Hence, ronism and Ossfanism and balladry, the| bellious mysticism and some exiled the glorious liberty of “Jane Eyre,” sort of thing, except for the occasional | Wanderer that sought his lady love on and hence a new phenomenon ifn letters. vigor of conception and language, which | Zamornah’s howling plain, or in some We are gravely assured that, until Jane one would expect to find inhabiting the | other equally fantastic land. confeased her love to Rochester in the mind of a romantic, lonely, halfedu-| It is a common thing to speak of orchard, “passion between man and cated girl, but astonishing in the mind | Emily as a Stoic or Pagan, and in sup- woman had meant animal passion’; | of a woman who had already written | port of such a view to quote the great and “it was this thing, cast down, de- “The Old Stoic,” and may even then lines: fled. dragged in the mud, and ignored have been plotting the story of &| Yes, as my swift days near their goal, heeause of its defilement, that Char- miraculous novel. A few of these! "Tis all that I implore; lotte Rronté took and lifted up. . . . newly printed Gondal ballads are them-| In life and death a chainless soul, She ehowed it for the divine, the beau-|selves of stirring beauty, and it is a| With courage to endure— tiful. the utterly pure, and radiant thing fair conjecture that some of the poems or the stanzas beginning, “No coward

Page 17

Jan. 30, 1913] The Nation soul is mine,” or the wooing words of | the Night-Wind: And when thy heart is resting Beneath the church-aisle stone, I shall have time for mourning, And thou for being alone. But from Paganism or Stoicism, in any precise use of the terms, she was really removed by a whole world. Power of endurance she had, sympathy with na- ture she had, but the spirit beneath it all that of romantic rebellion rather than Stoic apathia, and her true father was Byron rather than Mar- cus Aurelius or Epictetus. When by chance the true Pagan note does come out strongly, the result is a common- place, as in the close of one of the new poems (No. xl): was True to myself, and true to all, May I be healthful still, And turn away from passion's call, And curb my own wild will. The lines are commonplace, because they do not belong to the writer. They do not express her temper in life. They belied by her passionate will when she came to die, and by the pitiful rebellion of her spirit against the frailty of the flesh, causing agony to herself and wringing from her sister were Charlotte the cry of distress: ‘“Mo- ments so dark as these I have never known.” Mrs. Gaskell tells how Char- lotte shivered at recalling the pang she felt when, “after having searched in the little hollows and sheltered crev- ices of the moors for a lingering spray of heather—just one spray, however withered—to take in to Emily, she saw that the flower was not recognized by the dim and indifferent eyes.” And the closing scene is equally fitting and symbolical. Emily's fierce bulldog, Keeper, “walked alongside of the mourners, and into the church, and stayed quietly there all the time that the burial service was being read. When he came home, he lay down at Emily’s chamber door and howled pitifully for many days.” Fitting incidents these, for when we think of her in life, it is with the image in our mind of the’ slight, unyielding figure, a mere girl, abroad on the lonely moors, with face set against the wind, and by her side the savage guard and companion. The other sisters loved their home in the moorland, but to Emily it was very existence, and in her brief absences she pined for it as the prisoner yearns for liberty. “Every morning when she woke,” wrote Charlotte of the un- fortunate time in Brussels, “the vision of home and the moors rushed on her, and darkened and saddened the day that lay before her.” But, again, let us not mistake the nature of Emily’s passion for her be- loved moors. It certainly was not Stoic, nor was it in any sense Pagan: Virgil or Horace would have deemed it a mad-' ness. Neither had it that touch of mysticism which springs from the con- trast of the earth's stability with man’s ephemeral generations; there was little or nothing in it of the neo-Paganism of Thomas Hardy's description of the bon- ' fires on Egdon Heath—‘the great invio- late place,” unaltered amid the succes- sive destinies of mankind, with “an ancient permanence which the sea can- not claim,” and with of peace for “the mind adrift change and harassed by the irrepressible New.” emily Bronté was too inexperienced in a message on life to bring to the moors any such wor- ship as that: she brought to them rather her own spirit of romantic revolt, and in their lonely winds and empty spaces found what seemed to her a sympathet- mood. With the help of the Gondal poems, it is not difficult in a way the kind of thoughts and emo tions which brooded in her solitary walks. The feeling that preyed upon her soul was more an inarticulate, almost sullen, clamor against the in humanity of an unknown destiny than ic to conjecture upon she any definite rebellion against the par- ticular circumstances of her life, and no inconsiderable part of it, one sus- pects, sprang from a kind of emptiness of heart, from the stirring within her of deep emotions which had no specific object of attachment Out of that vague rebellion and those unfed emo tions, and out of the memories mantic reading, ating a world of her own, peopling of ro- went cre- it her genius with heroes and heroines of strange names and malignant fates and la mentable utterance. It seems all very girlish, yet in the girl's brain thers dwelt intermittently a power of imagi nation and insight and a faculty of pen- etrating expression, which made of her immature musings the prophecy and at times the reality of true and courage ous literature: No coward soul is No trembler in the world ] sphere I see Heaven's glori« in And faith shines equal, a ng me fr fear. From the Gondal and more personal poems to “Wuthering Heights” the step is not great, either in time or in mood; and in the novel find the same spirit prevailing of vague romantic re- volt, the same depth of inexperienced emotion, the same faculty, more concrete now, but still half-inhu- man. The style and sentiment of the book are occasionally and even feeble, yet, withal, the story, from the opening scene, grips the attention, and in we creative crude as a whole is undeniably successful the mind of the reader the mind of the above “Jane Eyre” ignore the to in it is to conveying what author To place creation was as a greater ele- 105 ments of art, but in its own way it is undoubtedly one of the miracles of literature—-more miraculous, indeed, suddenness, The pression it gives is such as might come the than admirable Its very so to speak, is astonishing im to who was lost moors the one thick on of absolut« in obscurity night, moving apparently in an solitude, when out of the darkness came a flash of light and passed again into the dark before the ness, revealing for a moment of dazed eyes of the wanderer a group actors, human and more than human noiselessly engaged in some deed of terror. There is no connection of th: plot and characters of the story with a surrounding world; all about it is opacity. The origin of the hero is unknown; he has but a single name Heathcliff, and is brought into the lit tle group of actors from the unexplored outside and for unexplained reasons For a while, when he has been baffled by the marriage of Catherine and Edgar, he disappears again into the outlying shadows. And at the end he fades into death by a kind of unaccountablk suspension of the faculties—‘I have t remind myself to breathe,” he exclaims, “almost to remind my heart to beat!” His passion has burnt itself out, and ob- livion falls upon the scene like a black curtain And within that circle of im penetrable darkness, he move as a creature whose emotions are derived from another world than ours ‘How did you contrive to preserve the com mon sympathies of human nature when you resided here?’ writes Heatheliff'’s young bride to the old servant. “TIT can not recognize any sentiment which those around share with me Is Mr. Heathcliff a man?” And at tl nd the servant herself, who tells th story, asks “Is he a ghoul or a van piper . « Where did he come from the dark little thing, harbored by a good man to his bane There has been some discussion in regard to the master passion of the story: to one critic it is the working of heredit to Miss Sinelnir i gs a spir itualizing love which takes possession of a soul and casts out every other feel be properly ing. But how, it may asked, can such feeling b a being who, from beginning to end, is a attributed to represented as scarcely human? The fact is the author herself was too littl attached to the world of men to give articulate expression to any such tle between man and woman tut out of her self-devouring heart and her rebel- lious soul she drew the understanding of one passion, scarcely human indeed, though it sometimes visits menkind, the most terrible and blinding passion the world knows, the passion of sheer, enduring cruelty. That is the emotion as yet vague and unnamed, that comes

Page 18

LO6 The Natio , No. 2483 around that we find so many charming But to t reader when, with the fictitious Clara's action here, as always, is r of the story, he is first introduced essentially romantic. She is a cham- maidens of a certain age in the Yankec haunted chambers of “Wuth- pion of the weak, a friend to the down-| villages. But it is never too late to t That is the spring of cast, a humorist without feeble senti-| hope: in fiction at least, they ar« al- olical treatment of mentality. Life never for a moment ways hoping, and there is always at ind h fe and his own piti- loses its zest for her, by reason of its least a chance for them. Men become E ) Heathcliff own succulence, and there is always a widowers. The boy lover whose bud- ( afte | death, is dream in the distance to sweeten pres- ding passion has been nipped by paren- irvivor’s heart into a ent good. From the book as a whole tal interference, or blighted by ambition \isition: “She has disturbed | one gets an impression of uncertainty to see the world, returns to his old n night and day, through eighteen of a brilliant young journalist trying home and his old love. eal he eries, “incessantly—remorse-| his hand at various moods and modes. And there is always the parson. Miss lessly | yesternight—and yesternight Several of the chapters might better Philura, sticking womanfully to her vas tranquil. I dreamed I was sleep- have been omitted, as of small account! post, is rewarded by this chief of matri- ing the last sleep by that sleeper, with in any way. But about the person of monial prizes. Her “transfiguration” heart stopped and my cheek frozen Clara herself there is no uncertainty— | has been recorded in an earlier story against hers She showed her- @ real creature and a lovable. The theme of this narrative is consid- self, as she often was in life. a devil erably slighter, a mere feminine drama to And since then, sometimes more, | Miriam Lucas. By Canon Sheehan. New of dress. The short of it is that Miss and sometimes less, I've been the sport of that intolerable torture.” Cruelty and not love, cruelty of the living and of the dead, is the master passion of the book If one were looking for a parallel to the sufferings of those who are the it would be found in the diabolism that surrounds Webster's Duchess of Malfi: I'll tell thee a I t id ye miracle; t, to my cause yf sorrow CURRENT FICTION Clara: Some Scattered Chapters in the Life of a Hussy. By A. Neil Lyons. New York: John Lane Co. Facing the title-page of this book is a list of works “by the same author,” classified under the headings Romantic and Unromantic. After reading “Clara,” which falls under the romantic cate- gory, we find ourselves wondering what this Mr. Lyons is like when he is being unromantic. There are passages and hapters here of as unvarnished realism as ever came from the pen of a news- paper-bred cockney. Some of them are shocking—notably The Mile End ition That fragment is among the interlude which have nothing to do r But she herself lives in a orld of spades which are to be called nk) name, and is a hussy accord- r i j n rules. She is a thief, aft ‘ i disreputable and content- d in the slums. She has “done her bit’ In prison, and the father of her on is, during the episodes here record- d, performing a similar office for soci ety rhe parents are married—to third and fourth parties. But that has noth- ing to do in one way or another with their devotion to each other or to their be The story of Clara’s marriage as she tells t is reallatic and squalid nough in point of detail. She marries 1 cur of streets in order to avenge inspeakable treatment of his dead The sole of the consists in a horse-whipping ad- incident honey- moon ministered by the bride, followed by the permanent disappearance of the groom, : Like all of Canon Sheehan's stories, sport of this inhuman passion, York: Philura ardently desires a white wed- ding-dress which she has no means of buying. At a meeting of an “Ontologi- cal Club” she has heard a lecture about the Encircling Good, from which faith might win whatever it sufficiently desir- ed. She applies for a white gown, and obtains it, through channels somewhat less than mystical. The little story is not too far-fetched: the village dialect uncommonly good. Longmans, Green & Co. this one has a quaint and individual fla- but unlike several of them, it has very little else to commend it. The plot is melodramatic, the situations are forc- ed, the persons are unreal: the hero a flabby figure, the villain a monster, the heroine a bore. It is always a risk for this writer to undertake an elaborate and sustained narrative. His sketches of Irish character are engaging, and once at least, in “The Intellectuals,” he produced a longer work of distinct mer- it. That book owed its charm to the fact that it did not attempt sustained narrative. It was little more than a ser- ies of dialogifes strung upon a slender thread of incident—a species of “Auto- crat of the Breakfast Table” with Irish setting and personnel. The present story involves a large number of char- acters, a continual shifting of scene, and a confusion of themes. The shadow of the author of Waverley hangs over the opening pages. A lonely neighborhood, a great house furnished with a curse and a prophecy, and inhabited by a beautiful girl about whose birth hangs a mystery; a guardian who covets her person and her inheritance; a gallant young gentleman of established social position who stumbles upon her to some purpose; his worldly mother—here are familiar materials. A new point of at- tack or fresh method of treatment might excuse their rehandling. The only novelty in Canon Sheehan's use of them is his presenting them, in all their antiquity, alongside certain industrial and social materials whose modernity makes them appear more hopelessly ob- solete than ever. vor; Concerning Sally. By William John Hop- kins. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. In “The Clammer” and later stories, this writer has produced work of rather studied quaintness. The present novel shows less of mannerism. Its quality is, however, distinctly feminine, and we imagine few men will care for it. Sally herself is one of those distressingly wise, capable children whom juvenile fiction is wont to hold up as models for both young and old. At twelve Sally is the real head of her family. She knows more than her father or her mother about the conduct of life. Her mother is a lady, but rather a fool. Her father is a university professor, but very much of a rascal. It is for Sally to in- struct the one and spy upon the other, and, with the aid of her creator (we mean Mr. Hopkins), to show herself the intellectual and moral superior of—her betters. The type is familiar. In boys’ stories it has long held the stage. Sad- ly, with a sense of misspent youth, must the shade of Rollo look upon these he- roes, free not only to defy, but to ad- monish their more or less contemptible elders. The heroine of the “story for girls” has acquired this license more recently; but she has acquired it. Lec- turing her parents is the breath of her nostrils. a fiss Philura’s Wedding Gown. By Flor- ence Morse Kingsley. New York:| ‘The present story is not professedly Dodd, Mead & Co. a story for the young. Sally grows up What would our fiction be without) physically, and is admitted to be an the spinster of New England? Her ex-| adult during a considerable portion of istence as a type is quaintly due to a|the narrative. The point is that, mor- surplus of the sex in that snug corner ally and mentally, she cannot grow up, o”? America. It is, we are told, because | since she has sprung full-grown from there are not enough husbands to go|the head of Mr. Hopkins. Fox Sander-

Page 19

Jan. 30, 1913] —_—_ —__=_— The Nation son, for whom she is clearly destined from the beginning, is a fit running- mate—a preternaturally wise and vir- tuous undergraduate, who will never be anything less than wise or more than an undergraduate. We do not feel that Mr. Hopkins is writing from the shoul- der about people whom he feels to be real. The rascally professor is impossi- ble, not because he is both a professor and a secret gambler, but because we are expected to believe that in his char- acter of gambler he is naturally cruel to his wife. It is the kind of story which, all the more on account of its clevernesses of detail, provokes cgain the query, Why should anybody in this day go to the trouble of making a novel out of whole cloth? THE FRANKLIN OF JAPAN. Just Before the Dawn: The Life and Work of Ninomiya Sontoku. By Rob- ert Cornell Armstrong, M.A. New York: The Macmillan Co. $1.50. Japan’s debt to her own past is very imperfectly understood by Americans. Her military achievements are obvious- ly too considerable to be fortuitous, and we readily attribute them to inherited traditions of training and obedience, but we have much to learn of those moral and mental qualities which the nation owes to a similar inheritance The illusion that the Japanese are some- how different from ourselves in essen- tial traits of humanity ought to be dis- pelled by Mr. Armstrong’s study of the Franklin of Japan. His transla- tions from the abundant native litera ture on the subject show the common farmer at work in his old-fashioned way. It is a revelation of the influ- ence there of the type of homespun phi- losophy which our country folk like to call hard-headed, and brings these peo- ple singularly close to our own. Barring the rather flabby imagery of his title, Mr. Armstrong’s book is an ex- cellent piece of work. The world owes too much to missionaries abroad to crit- icise their literary taste severely, but they seem to moult the feathers of early Victorian taste in metaphor with strange reluctance, and they are regret- tably apt to leave to librarians the pain- ful task of cross-reference and explana- tion made necessary by meretricious titles. The “Dawn” in this case means the time preceding the Meiji era of en- lightenment in Japan, not the earlier periods of Jimmu or Shotoku, which were equally years of dawn in the same sense. The predicament of Japan af- ter two centuries of Tokugawa tyranny is one of extreme interest to the stu- dent of society, for in no other case has a hermit-nation programme been at- tempted upon the same scale and under such favorable conditions. The empire at the time of Queen Elizabeth’s death was probably richer, more populous, and more cultured than England. Its people were saved from anarchy in that year by the effective in the hands of one master, but internal peace and protection from foreign inter- produced at the complete stagnation. When Ninomiya, a peasant with of his work two hundred years later, eco- concentration of power ference were price of own, be ideas his gan nomic decay and social corruption had reduced a flourishing to im- potence. The contrast to fortunes of Great Britain in the same period of- fers an impressive object-lesson to stu- dents of history. This situation is briefly outlined the earlier chapters of the book. It has an interest all its own; but the lapse of an eager people, deprived of any scope for their energies, into luxury and vice which debauched even the serfs on the soil and paralyzed the resources of the country, is only one feature of its con- tents. A second is found in the fact that in one of the most consistently aristocratic communities ever organiz- ed the impelling spirit of reform came from the lower classes. The subject of this volume, who died about the time that Commodore Perry's treaty was rati- fied, was one among several reformers from the common people who labored for the relief of poverty in their gener- ation. His chief claim to the admira- tion of his compatriots comes from his power of organization and from his re- fusal to dispense alms to the unemploy- ed. His doctrine was the simple doc trine of work and thrift, and in his steady insistence upon this idea, as well as in the homely aphorisms by which he enforced his teachings, he continually recalls Poor Richard. The Japanese like the Yankee, knew no short- to prosperity; it must reached constant effort and to methods which experience, recommend- doles and only hin- drances to the able-bodied. For this rea- he entertained the ironical contempt for Buddhism Franklin had for Christianity. institution he objected to the church because it har- bored drones and encouraged speculation. But the as distinguished from r was not ignored. “He believed,” we are told, “that while it was a good thing to re- form the individual, it was a better thing to unite men in the interest of the country and society in general. Hence came the organization of Hotoku, with its twofold object: first, to devel: op morality; second, to promote indus- try and economy. The plan of the so- ciety was to lay aside a fund from which loans could be made to members and others who were struggling with debt or unfavorable circumstances, and which could also be to improve poor or neglected homes or villages, to and enterprises, country the in sage, cut be by submission ed; charities were Same that s0n AS an useless value of morality ligion other used industries start new and for public works ot (liter ally, “reward for gra societies num above six dred in Japan to-day) i i Le i ie! and 1} i I al purpos i] id \ i ioved tual l 4 third feature of this volume should command the attention of dents of Japanese society, is the philos phy whi inderlies Ninomiya’s systen Though he approached his problem from the economic rather than the religious side, he was as far from Rousseau as he was from the priests | nd lv ¢ natural law I leclared], and are led astray by mers mal passion and lust, human life, with all that is peculiar to it, will be dest ed Though there no paths on the ocear the ships have definite channels they t follow or be dashed to pieces on the roc) So, though it is natural for man to d lelicate food nd extravagant cloth ust control mere passion and live within his eans This is the way humanity To sow our grain nat but if w Wish to make the grain profit able we pull the weeds around it It is not natural to pull up the weed Ss following natural desire we must lal but when natural desire clashes wit! it must be restrained It was, therefore, with no fear of in consistency that, despite his disbelief in prevailing superstitions, he appealed to the supernatural succor of a temple god when it was necessary to deal with vic« and evil habits. The appeal, even to a vain belief, served his purpose and he employed it as a restraining influence. With his almost fierce emphasis upon the necessity of work for every one went the shrewdness and humor which inevitably attend the efforts of every effective philosopher. His sayings were not strikingly original, but they were propounded in original ways and ap plied to circumstances that were new His method of teaching people to help themselves and refuse Government aid in an age when all looked to the state for guidance, constitutes his chief claim to originality. The enduring influence of his propaganda demonstrates, mor over, that there is a true democrati element in Japanese society, and that his people are susceptible to precisely the same weaknesses, promptings, and vulgar truths as ourselves 4 History fhe Vodern World, i815 foo By Oscar Browning Two umes New York: Cassell & C To one interested in recent ten porary European history Mr. Brown ing’s work is a fascinating tl ilant The reader feels that it is not the lor less compliation of a Dryasdust, but the personal expression of a ad inct ind viduality who has opinions of his own 1 contains much quiet humor and some

Page 20

LOS ‘The Nation [Vol. 96,'No. 2483 sarcasm; many réussi phrases, and some! drops the Near Eastern Question com-' the author's photographs. New York: moralizings worth pondering. The style, pletely, merely remarking, “I'he whole Henry Holt & Co. $3 net. with its staccato sentences, is always! Story of the Treaty of Berlin enforces lvcid, and often enlivened by judicious *“@ Melancholy reflection that the world, quota ions from the actual words of the after all, is governed with very little great statesmen of the nineteenth cen wisdom.” He does not tell us how that tury treaty has been violated by nearly every As the Alpine climber, who toils up| PoWer that signed it, how it is respon- the long ascent and reaches at last the ‘ible for the situation which led to the summit, turns to look back upon his|"ecent outbreak, nor how, thirty years arduous course and survey the panorama after it was signed by Abdu] Hamid, the of peaks which he has passed, so Mr. Turkish Revolution put an end to his trowning—himself an Alpine enthusi-|®%0™minable despotism. Mr. Sheldon’s volume opens with the record of a trip to Vancouver Island, in the autumn of 1904, in search of a bull wapiti for the scientists of the United States Biological Survey, who were in- terested in determining the relation of the Vancouver wapiti to the Cervus Roosevelti of the Olympics. The search was not successful, but the record makes attractive reading and carries much in- cidental information on various topics ast—who for thirty years has been toil- Similarly, also, as the mountain-climb- ef natural history. In the spring of ing with students at the University of | °r cannot see the villages in the valleys 1905 Mr. Sheldon spent several weeks Cambridge and with historical investi- ed forgets for the moment all the in- hunting for the big bear of Hinchin- gations, and who for nearly seventy sistent sociological problems of the brook and Montague Islands, Alaska. years has been closely watching history | World beneath him, so Mr. Browning On the basis of five specimens, sent to in the making, now turns at last to sur-| seems not to see the life of the people. the Biological Survey at Washington, a vey the events of a century. His point It should seem to be an ill-proportioned | new species has been officially recog- of view is that of an Englishman and an History of Modern Europe which con-| nized, with the appropriate title of advanced Liberal. It is this English tains such a full account of so many I rsus Sheldoni, of Montague Island. An point of view, supported with good ac- wars as those mentioned above, and yet appendix gives a full description of this counts of the growth of the British Em-| Says virtually nothing of the advance’ bear, from the pen of Dr. C. Hart Mer- pire, the extension of the suffrage, and | of the industrial revolution in the coun-/| riam, who is inclined to regard the coast the course of progressive legislation in | tries of Europe, of the organization of region of Alaska as the original home England, which lends these volumes a socialistic political parties, of old-age! from which the big bears of America thread of unity and helps bind together pensions and sick insurance, of the! have radiated. During the autumn ot what is necessarily a broad and some-| Hague Peace Conferences, and of Mod-' 1906, Mr. Sheldon visited Graham Is]- what disjointed subject ernism. This, however, is part of the and, of the Queen Charlotte group, to rhe peaks of modern European his-| secret of the delightful impression of | solve the mooted problem of the exist- tory which Mr. Browning chiefly de- freshness and individuality which his | ence of caribou there. Though he did not lights to study from his summit of ripe | volumes make. succeed in setting eyes on a single cari- experience and reflection, are the great As a text-book for classroom use Mr.| bou, unmistakable tracks were discov- moves in the field of diplomatic and Browning's work is altogether inferior ered in sufficient numbers to remove all military history These are subjects to such an excellent recent book a3 that | doubt, and two years later two half- which, when treated briefly, are usually of C. Pp. Hazen; for there are no maps, breed Indians shot three specimens, the neither interesting nor clear; from Mr.' no bibliographical apparatus, and no Skins and skulls of which were procured Browning's pen they are both; they are proper sense of proportion; but the let-| for the Provincial Museum, in Victoria. ter-press is excellent, careful reading is Its natural habitat, however, is in the His narrative is always easy and inter-| made easy by good catchwords in the dryer interior regions, and in the opin- esting to follow, and his judgments are! margin, and for the teacher, the general ion of the author the small group that fair and statesmanlike In addition to! reader, and so-called “collateral read-| has existed in the Charlotte Islands is the inevitable chapters on the great ine” in colleges, it is informing anc Im process of rapid extinction. In the vars Which resulted in German and Ital-| stimulating. This is particularly true of Closing clapter Mr. Sheldon drops the ian national unity and in the carving {he excellent chapters on the Balkan | ™ore scientific attitude for a sketch of up of Turkey, there are excellent ac- «youhles. Here Mr. Browning severely 2 two months’ outing with his wife, on ounts of such less obvious subjects a8 scores Disraeli and Salisbury for their’ Admiralty Island. The ambition of the the Indian mutiny, the Afghan War, | ;enorance of real facts of geography and | trip was to place a bear to the credit of Khartum and the Sudan, the Zulu and ¢rpnology, and for the political blind-| rs. Sheldon’s rifle, but the fates did the Bo Wars, the Chinese-Japanese, ness which led them to tear up the not will the success which is supposed Treaty of San Stefano in 1878 and sub- to come so regularly to an inexperienced i! as upon the American Civil War .ri+ate for it the many absurd ang im. Woman in such matters. As we are told and the Spanish-American War But practical terms of the Treaty of Berlin | that she fell into a deep pool and suc- Solisbury afterwards admitted that b.| ceeded in keeping her mouth and her e¢, or at least docs not adequately de-| wag rong, and his admission has been | T!fle above the surface until Mr. Sheldon ecribe, the fundamental, causes and the made more glaringly evident by the|could get hold of her, the conclusion events of the last six months; but it| Suggests itself that she was not quite was a poor reparation for a disastrous | Unsophisticated enough to get a bear error for tim to say, as he did, some! *:mply by way of “a woman's luck.” only the briefest account of the slavery | years later, that he had “put his money| Mr. Washburn’s book smacks all the the subjects in which he is at his best. Boxer, and Russo-Japanese conflicts, as from | immit Mr. Browning does not permanent results of all these wars. For instance, to get a start for his discus sion of the Civil War in America he has question; and after the assassination of 4» the wrong horse.” way through of the style and vocabulary Lincoln absolutely nothing appears to of the college student which he was in have happened In t!e United States un the later nineties, when his trips into t{l the blowing up of the Maine in 1898.| »),. wygerness of the North Pacific| the western Canadian wilds began. Hie describes the Franco-Prussian War Coast Islands. By Charles Sheldon, There is no pretence to the scientific in detail, but gives no account whatever 7 quality which one finds in Mr. Sheldon’s author of “The Wilderness of the Up- per Yukon.” Illustrated. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. 2 net. of the constitutions of the new French pages, and in his enthusiasm for Charles M. Hays and the conception of the Grand Trunk Pacific, his rhetoric at devoting fourteen chapters, out of a to- Trails, Trappers, and Tender-feet in| times runs perilously near the realm of tal of sixty-seven, to the wars in the Western Canada. By Stanley Wash-| the exploiter. His enthusiasms are ap- Balkan Peninsula prior to 1878, he burn With 80 illustrations from parently unbounded in many directions, Republie and the new German Empire which resulted from that war. After

Page 21

Jan. 30, 1913] The Nation the ascent of high mountain peaks, and the other the penetration of any fast- ness whatever which compels the use of his own shoulders as a substitute for tke pack-horse. “I pronounce it the su- preme limit of wretchedness and mis- ery, this making a pack-horse of one’s — ee At first the forty, fifty, or sixty pounds seems light enough, but after the first half-hour it is like lead, and by noon it is a millstone, while when night comes it is a great black nightmare, hanging to one like the Old Man of the Sea to Sindbad the Sailor.” After what has been said above, we must do Mr. Washburn the justice to record his warning statement that mis- representations have led distant and confiding purchasers to pay high prices for land virtually worthless, and that those who wish to obtain a stake in the fertile and highly promising land that certainly does exist in the regions de- scribed should see their purchase with their own eyes before letting their money go. + Notes The President and Fellows of Harvard College voted, on January 27, to establish the Harvard University Press, for the pub- lication of works of a high scholarly char- acter. For some years the University pub- lication office has issued a few special works. The present intention is to organize and extend this activity. Among the books in preparation are volumes by the late Prof. James Barr Ames and by Profs. George Foote Moore, Eugene Wambaugh, Arthur E. Kennelly, George L. Kittredge, Charles H. Haskins, George A. Reisner, and W. B. Munro. The board of syndics who will decide on the books to be published are Robert Bacon, chairman; Professors Moore, Kennelly, Kittredge, Gay, Cannon; and Mr. Charles H. Thurber, of Ginn & Co. The director of the Press is Charles Chester Lane. The establishment of the Harvard University Press recalls the fact that the first printing press in América was a gift to Harvard College in 1639, which was set up in the house of Presfdent Dunster. On it were printed the “Bay Psalm Book” and John Eliot’s Indian Bible. By arrangement between the University of Cambridge and the University of Chicago the following periodicals will be issued in America, in the future, under joint im- print: the Modern Language Review; Brit- ish Journal of Psychology; Journal of Agricultural Science; Biometrika; Parasi- tology; Journal of Genetics; Journal of Hy- giene. Several new books in the Cambridge list are also to be taken over at once and published in this country under joint aus- pices, including: “The Life and Letters of Lord Hardwicke,” by Philip Chesney Yorke; “The Duab of Turkestan,” by W. Rickmer Rickmers: “The History of Romanesque and Byzantine Architecture,” by Thomas Gra- ham Jackson, and “The Genus Iris,” by Wil- liam Rickatson Dykes. the Co. Mr. Oscar 8S. Through Century but two sharp limits are detected—one, | Straus will bring out in April “The Ameri- can Spirit.” Cassell & Co. issue this week two books by anonymous authors—“Cleek: The Man of the Forty Faces,” a detective story, and “Princess Mary's Locked Book.” M. Gueschoff, Prime Minister of Bulgaria, has written the introduction Lieut Wagner's “With the Victorious Bulgarians,” Houghton Mifflin C almost for which o. has ready. to Master the McClure for How by Edwin G. Lawrence's Spoken Word,” February, deals with oratory from the time announced of Gorgias to the present day, and is in tended to serve as a text-book The following are some of the Oxford books in preparation by Frowde: “Aris- tarchus of Samos,’ by Sir Thomas Heath: “Opus Epistolarum Des. Erasmi Roterodami, Tom. III, 1517-1519,” edited by P. S. Allen; “Antigonos Gonatas,” by W. W. Tarn; “The Life of Porphyry, Bishop of Gaza,” trans lated by G. F. Hill, and “Selected Essays of Plutarch,” translated by T. G. Tucker Longmans, Green & Co. are bringing out Drake’s “The Wondrous Passion” and Sir Rider Haggard’s Zulu romance, “Child of Storm.” E. P. Dutton & Co. have a long list of spring announcements. It includes in fic- tion: “American Nobility,” by Pierre de Coulevain, in a new translation by Alys Hallard; “The Fear of Living,” by Henri Bordeaux, translated from the seventy- fourth French edition by Ruth Helen Davis; “The Quest of Glory” and “God's Play- things,” by Marjorie Bowen; “A Slice of Life,” by Robert Halifax; “Seven Scots Stories,” by Jane Findlater; “Crossriggs” and “Penny Monypenny,” by Jane and Mary Findlater.—Miscellaneous: “Essays in Biog- raphy,” by Whibley; “The War Drama of the Eagles,” by Edward Fraser; “The Philosophy of Ruskin,” by André Che- vrillon, translated by Andrew Boyle; “The Influence of Baudelaire in France and Eng- land,” by G. Turquet-Milner; “The Nature of Woman,” by J. Lionel Tayler; “The Everyman Encyclopedia,” edited by Andrew Boyle in twelve volumes, of which Vols. I and II are now ready; “The China Year Book for 1913,” by H. T. Montague Bell; “Prayers, Ancient and Modern,” by William Charles Angus Knight; “Yang Chu’s Garden of Pleasure,” translated from the Chinese by Prof. Anton Forke, with an introduction by H. Cranmer-Byng; “Dante and the Mys- tics,” by Edmund G. Gardner; “The Sea and the Jungle,” by H. M. Tomlinson; “Shakespeare's London,” by T. Fairman Ordish, new edition, and the following num- bers of the Channels of English Literature series: “The English Novel,” by Prof. George Saintsbury; “English Lyric Poetry,” by Ernest Rhys; “English Dramatic Poetry,” by Prof. Felix Schelling; “English Elegiac, Didactic, and Religious Poetry,” by the Rev. Dr. H. C. Beeching; “English Satirists and Humorous Literature,” by Oliphant Smea- ton; “The English Essay and Fssayists,” by Prof. Hugh Walker; “English History and Schools of History,” Prof. Richard Lodge, and “English Criticism,” by J. W H. Atkins. A few of the in this spring list have already appeared by volumes A comprehensive “History of India,” from the earliest times to the present day, on LOY Modern the the “Cambridge preparation by The equally among the model of tory,” is in Press will be divided Ancient India University york volumcs t! India main periods India, and British A book by Swinburne on Di sisting of an article Quarterly Review of additions which appeared in t July by by 1902, and cert the poet, Chatto & Wind } } Will manuscript published immediately Prof. C. M. Andrews will shortly issue t third and concluding to the Archives.” volume of his “Gul Manuscript Materials in Lond Professors Fraser and Squair have “Shorter French Course,” wh Heath pared a about to be issued by February 1 is the date set by P for the publication of the following t His Cambridge “The Hero of Herat,” by Maude Diver “Ashes and Sparks,” by Percy Whit Lit tle Cities of Italy,” Vol. II, by André Maurel, translated by Helen Gerard; “The Romance of the Rothschilds,” by Ignaz Balla, and “The History of Modern Phil osophy,” by Prof. A. W. Benn Forthcoming books in Doubleday, Page & Co.'s list include: “Virginia,” by Ellen Glasgow: “The Devil's Admiral,’ by Fred erick Ferdinand Moore, and Preci Waters,” by A. M. Chisholm. Sturgis & Walton promise for March “Lanagan: Amateur Detective Auction Pinochle,” by A. P. George, and Little Mamselle,” a juvenile story by Mrs. Au gusta H. Seaman Descriptive notes of a journey through Dalmatia, Montenegro, Bosnia, and Herz govina by Assistant Prof. Kenneth MeKen zie of Yale, the opening article of the Ds cember number, just issued, of the Nation- al Geographic Magazine, give a vivid idea of the great variety in land and people of a small part of the Austrian empire. This article is followed by pictures of scenes in the Tyrol prith explanatory text by D W. and A. 8. Iddings An intricate racial problem for American ethnologists, the o igin of the blond Eskimo discovered by Stefansson, is discussed by Major-Gen. A. W. Greely, with numerous extracts from the reports of various Arctic explorers The account of the ascent of Mount Sinal to see the sun rise and set, by the Rev. S Prentice, jr., is illustrated by the reproduc- thirty-four unusually photographs tion of and striking interesting Harpers have reissued Woodrow W! son's life of “George Washington,” first publish: in 1896, now printed with the proud legend op the title-page under the author's nam: “President of the United States.” The “Poems of Robert Bridges,” which we noticed in the Nation last week, are now issued by the Oxford University Press in an edition printed on India paper The address of Mr. Justice Swayze, of Supreme Court of New Jersey, at th« cation of the Washington statu: ark, November 2, 1912, has been but deserves general circulat printed, and-attention. characteristics of the tive American have been noted greatest constru and a pl osophic view of his official capacity forth. So clear and felicitous the sty and so true the estimate, that extra at New l privately Within a small compass th:

Page 22

The Nation _ [Vol. 96, No. 2483 from this essay might well form reading serious, neither in the past nor, @ la experienced in popularizing Catullus, has lessons in any course of history, and the rigueur, in the present.” This of the fiery been very successful. Sometimes a para- i 1s a whole find a place in the best stoics that took Port Arthur, a nation rear-| phrase conveys the true meaning to those ol /f comments upon the first Presi- ed in the austere discipline of an ancient’ versed in the classical ways of satire and chivalry, the land of Ito, Okuma, and Nogi! pleasure, while on the surface the words It . little difficult for the Oriental O@e finds what one seeks, whether in Tokio/ are sufficiently decent. Elsewhere a phrase mind to grasp the truths of the Christian °° !" Paris. When one has recovered from) or a passage is frankly omitted, and the religion aS understood in the West. and ‘%e intoxication of Loti, one may read with | omission indicated by points. A few of the any of our official interpreters are mak special profit the “Bushido” of Nitobé. naughtiest poems he has turned over to ~ a dark glass more opaque. A Japanes: Gen. Juba] Anderson Early’s “Autobio- the general editor, Dr. W. H. D. Rouse, Buddhist, who ig looking into Christianity, graphical Sketch and Narrative of the War who has exercised on them an extremely recently said to the writer of this note,’ Retween the States,” has now been pub- nimble wit to good purpose. In all cases What for the ministers do they always) |ished, nearly twenty years after his death, the Latin text is complete and intact. In tell what Browning think? It would not and is furnished with notes by R. H. Early general, Mr. Cornish’s English is an excel- lo to say that the ministers are the only | (Lippincott). Gen. Early’s narrative deals lent medium for those who turn to it for ones that know. Nor that the poet is more | with the Civil War campaigns and battles | "¢!P im reading the Latin. We cannot say impressive than he who set forth the mys- | jn Virginia, Maryland, and Pennsylvania. that it has independent qualities of a high t of the logos—because less generally |{t is impersonal in a marked degree. Prob- character. For example, such a phrase ul rstood It was an awkward question. ably it would have been less so if Gen. John | #* “how many kissings of you” (No. vii) may I it this moment there came to hand A B. Gordon's “Reminiscences” had been given convey quite accurately the meaning of tin Foster The Message of Robert to the public before Gen. Early’s death,| @¥0t mihi basiationes tue,” but it can I v0 (Doran) Mr. Foster answers for Gordon held Early responsible for the | * arcely be regarded as elegant; nor does the question in a mentary on ten or @| failure to press the retreating Union forces the attempt to be poetical seem entirely t gnificant poen Browning is yn July 1 at Gettysburg. as well as for| h@ppy in such a line as “remains to be I Prophet whose message is compar- negiect to turn Grant’s flank in the Wil-/| Slept the sleep of one unbroken night.” that of the Hebrew prophets, but qoern and for inactivity in not driving ‘Tjbullus and the “Pervigilium Veneris” ght up to date in form and feeling. home the Confederate victory over Sheri-| are jncluded in the same volume with As t i vere first published in the | qan’s army at Cedar Creek before the Catullus, the former being the work of een & ‘ard Bearer, and, in one In- | Union forces had time to overcome the ef-/| prof. J. P. Postgate, the latter of Prof. J. my jeard with favor by the Aberdeen fects of their first panic. Considerable| w. Mackail. The English version of Tibul- Diocesan Society, we suppose they may portions of the book suggest in style a lus and the poems that pass under his name is thoroughly serviceable, though occasion- ally the more delicate sentiment of the original is missed. Perhaps the most ro- mantic verse in Latin is that in the Paraclausithyron, I, ii, 25: be confidently recommended to the Oriental | restatement of official reports. Apparently es a Key to the modern sermon begun soon after the close of the war and Carmen Sylva and Sketches from the| WTitten with caution as to Southern feel- Orient.” by Pierre Loti. in a translation by | '988. the criticism is confined to Northern Fred Rothwell, is a discreet, rather than | Policies and acts. The pages justifying the a thoroughly representative, selection from Southern treatment of Union prisoners of the works of our recent visitor (Macmil- | ¥®™ could have been spared, as the claims lan). These half-dozen sketches of the ac-|™&de do not accord with the reports of which becomes merely feeble and trailing complished Rumanian Queen and her court, Confederate officers sent to inspect the An-/|!n its English form: “Lo, I in my wander- dersonville prison. The accounts of bat-/| ings in distress through all the city in the tles make little attempts to understand | dark.” ; or set forth the Northern side of a move- ment. For instance, Meade’s successful charge at Fredericksburg, which cut the Confederate line, the charge of an unsup- ported division, the reader might suppose En ego cum tenebris tota vagor anxius urbe, Constantinople in 1890, African serpent- charmer a Japanese temple in the forest, and Japanese women in 1890, Illustrate ade- quately Loti’s descriptive talent. But,as they were care‘ully prepared to avoid offence, In dealing with the “Pervigilium” Profes- sor Mackail has allowed himself consid- erable license in amending the text and in they fail to convey the full tang of his arranging it in symmetrical stanzas. His sensual melancholy. “The more highly col- . bh version, too, is liberal, and attempts to ored pieces read like superfluous leaves | ‘Tom Gea. Early's account had been mate | convey the romantic tinge of the original. from hig novels, and the “Carmen Sylva,” |>Y the First and Sixth Army Corps, Frank-| 4s an example of his cunning work, the lin’s whole command. though not without effective strokes, is | first stanza may be quoted: done in his least characteristic vein of Although Early fought in most of the | To-morrow shall be love for the loveless, pink-and-white sentimentality, As long ago| great battles of the East, his principal | and for the lover to-morrow shall be love. as 186%, Flaubert, Gautier, and the Gon-| service was his campaign in 1864, when he| Spring is young, spring now is singing, ’ spring is the world reborn. In spring the courts foregathered apropos of one of carried the war from the upper Shenan- | joves make accord, in spring the birds Sainte-Beuve's articl and agreed that the doah Valley to Maryland and came near | mate, and the woodland loosens her tresses great critic did not comprehend their exoti- | capturing the city of Washington. Through- under nuptia! showers. . word in which they distincuished| out, he displayed great energy, skill, and To-morrow shall be love for the loveless, |and for the lover to-morrow shall be love. two ining ‘ hi the first was the self-reliance. Stonewall Jackson could not ia os one ned n space. le goat de have done better, and, perhaps, never dia | The refrain may give some offence at first VAmérta 1 d femmes jaunes,| as much That with his small force of | Plush for its very free handling of precious vertes { yout for dark and some 10,000 men, he should have played for words, but we are not sure that the flavor caw! ns in a ting of pal trees. so long a time with Sheridan and his army of the original has ever been better con- » desert eands that Lot{ of 40,000 men and have come so near rout- veyed. aa f and , Yin ie wture It is ing the Union forces opposed to him, is Of A. 8S. Way’s Euripides, the third and Id saserted that , eunded the & tribute to Early’s audacity or evidence | fourth volumes of which now appear, some- ) of the Orfent. but what is meant ts that | of Sheridan's timidity. Early’s own expla- | thing has already been said in our notice } 1s tasted and retasted in all the ports nation is as follows: “The events of the/of the first output of the Loeb Library. world t intoxication of the bi ast month had satisfied me that the com-/| The letters which have come to us on the 1a broken all taboos. and has revel- | ™ander opposed to me was without enter- | subject, and some of which we have printed, led in the sweet bitterness of spiritual ex- | Prise and possessed an excessive caution indicate that the weight of opinion is stlor rhe Orient of Loti’s books is | Which amounted to timidity.” The book 1s | etrongly against the use of metrical trans- .einary territory annexed to the Orien- | !e#s for the general reader than for stu-/ lations. It seems to us even more impor- 1] paradise of the Romanticists in Paris; | dents of Civil War history. In appear-| tant that in future issues of Greek authors n creation. a sentimental sall- | ance it is a credit to the publishers a thicker paper should be used, with cor- lream of geishas and cherry blossoms Che great difficulty In dealing with Catul- respondingly fewer pages to the volume. it almost seems,” says this sounder of jus in such a publication as the Loeb Clas- rhe interest in the publication is manifest- national souls 1s though Japan would sical Library (Macmillan) is to conceal the ly great, and the consequences may be far- lose its raison d’étre, were it not for the! poet's nastiness without leaving too many | Teaching. mousme Resides, in Japan, noth-| hiatuses in the translation. In achieving| “Our Country Life” (McClurg), by Fran- ing Is of much consequence; nothing is very | this feat Mr. F. W. Cornish, who is already lees Kinsley Hutchinson, is a rapturous

Page 23

Jan. 30, 1913] The Nation account of the joys of life as lived at a country house by “the Enthusiast,” “the Constant Improver,” and their relatives and friends. “The big house” (it replaced a “tiny cottage”) is situated on an island in “our dear” Wisconsin lake, which other- wise nameless lake is nine by three miles in extent. So far as one can judge from the numerous reproductions of photographs, the house, together with the surroundings, is unusually attractive and conveniently ar- ranged; to say more would be hazardous, since the author tells us little. Most of the book consists of incoherent chatter about the petty pleasures and large exhilarations that make the author’s life in “God's glo- rious out-of-doors” inexpressibly wonder- ful, so wonderful, indeed, that she tells us at intervals that her “emotions had risen almost to the breaking point.” of the book Come to the woods and wa- ters, and feel the peace of nature steal over you; but curiously enough the influenc: of nature on the author is for the most part highly intoxicating. Thus, sleeping out of doors brings, not repose, but “revelation,” in a pseudo-mystical sense. As for the styl one sentence will suffice: “I did so one yellow bed, for I am afraid I must con- is, want fess that is my favorite color, and this seemed a reasonaLle request.” The Rev. Eben Burt Parsons, D.D., for more than twenty years secretary of the faculty and registrar of Williams College, died last week at Williamstown in his sev- enty-eighth year. Dr. Parsons was the compiler of “The Obituary Record of Wil- liams College.” Science Among the science books in Dutton’s spring list are “The Sheep and its Cousins,” by R. Lydekker, and “Medical Benefit in Germany and Denmark,” by 1. G. Gibbon. The January number of the Geographical Journal opens with a charmingly simple account by Capt. Roald Amundsen of his conquest of the South Pole in i911. Of one region passed through during the ninety- nine days’ journey he says, “I have never seen a landscape more beautiful, more wild, and more imposing.” The greatest height reached was 10,750 feet, though mountain peaks 15,000 feet high were seen. The low- est temperature observed was —74.2° Fahr. and the mean temperature for the year —14.8° Fahr. During the twelve months the expedition was on the ice there only “two moderate storms.” “A Geograph- ical Interpretation of Missouri” is the title of an article by Fred. V. Emerson of the University of Missouri, in which he de- with diagrams and pictures, th: contrasting physiographical divisions of the State. An account of th exploration and survey of the i4ist mx ridian, the International Boundary between Alaska and Canada, is given by Mr. D. H Nellas, the leader of the survey party, and the natural features and life of Southern Nigeria are described by Mr. A. E. Kitson for five years principal of the mineral sur were scribes, three strongly vey of that colony. Miss Belle Beach, author of “Riding and Driving for Women” (Scribner), is well qualified to speak on this subject The ' The burden ,h: daughter of a lady who has been an in- structor in riding for many New York ladies, she has of course ridden from her childhood, and has herself taught riding fer several years. She says modestly “) ot which takes me but a moment to tel. has taken me years to learn.” Her bool. is the result of her own experience The reader may not always agree with her but he will find what she has to say worthy of serious consideration. The volume deals with such topics as Hands, Form in Rid ing, Riding Astride, Hunting, Show-Ring Four-in-Hand, Tandem Driving, Bits, Har ness, etc. There are a great many pictures which are, as a rule, excellent. We are not of Miss Beach’s way of thinking about riding astride, which, as we should expect she rather disapproves of, nor in what she has to say about docking, which sh fa vors, alleging a number of pra i! yr siderations But we are very sure that ople do not dock horses for any other reasons than those of looks. On the ques tion of its inhumanity the author remarks that a long-tailed horse in harness cannot keep off flies with his tail We lo not quite see that. Then she ays that a dock 1 horse can be turned out in summer with a sheet on. Very true, but what a nuisance that must be for the horse! Has the author ever ridden or driven a horse in Virginia mountains in October when the first frosts have come? The big horse-fly common in that country, when chilled by the frost, will light on the coat of a horse, and, feeling the warmth, will stick there and bite until the unhappy animal is frantic. In England, it is said that pasture can be got cheaper for docked horses than for long-tailed horses, because they are prevented by flies from eating as much as long-tailed horses Miss Beach’s argument that all horses should be docked because they be driven as tandem leaders, and tandem lead ers behave badly when they get the reins under their tails, does not seem convinc- ing. Not very many horses are tandem leaders. If a tandem leader get his tail over the the groom get down and go to which he has to do pretty often in any case. Hunt- may driven as does reins, can his assistance ers are not docked any longer. And yet the horse to be ridden in the hunt is driven to the meet in the lead of a tandem. Prof. Charles A. Ellwood’s text-book of social psychology, “Sociology in Its Psy- chological Aspects” (Appleton), is one of the books which suggest that, if economics is the dismal science, sociology must be the dull science. The dismal science makes each of us a cog in a machine; sociology makes us just one of a species And not only is sociology jealous of the individual; so intent is she upon the biological con- tinuity of man with the lower species, so unmindful of the significance of our self- consciousness, that she deprives even the race of its human distinction. One is not surprised, therefore, that “‘societ becomes a colorless generality; and sociology an elaboration of empty methodology Mr. Ell vood fills 123 out of 395 pag with this leadly stuff, while telling us that the time is not yet ripe for a science of sociology which, being interpreted, el to mean, If you had a brother would he like chee , The special purpose of the book, which in a way is not badly fulfilled, to ex functional theory of fereral is hibit the consciousness 1il * in its application to social relations Ac- cording to this theory, developed chiefly by Professor Dewey upon the basis of James's chapters on Instinct, Emotion, and Will consciousness is a biclogical function, the sole purpos of which is to readjust the organism to a change of environment by restoring order among the onflicting in tinct the instincts supplying all the pulses to action By substituting persons for instincts We get a social organi! and a social psychology One cor quer of the theory seems to be that ho hat we call ilture is a waste product at least we do a vast amount of thinking, talk ing, writing, and the like that we uy t chance discover one idea useful for race conservatior Mr. Ellwood comfort is with the reflection that th i atures method” of producing “a superabunda that actual funct alr ! iin of being ‘ Put, though Mr. Ellwood al at his consequ f tl the y i [ t l itations l fails her meaning thi superabdbunda " i and in general his prese ati i icking in firmness f conviction and lear of outline erhaps in a sure grasp of the functional theory Otherwise it is dificult to understand “the large part [sic] which tincts play in our social life” (203); or how the element of instinct seems to dom- inate more in woman's life than in man's” (236); or why we have in man “no definite, hard and fast instincts, such as character- ize the lower animals” (207); or the pres- ence of intellect, feeling, and some other things, by the side of instinct. According to James, and according to the logic of the theory, all conduct, of men or animals, men or women, has its basis in perfectly definite instincts; human instincts differ from those of the lower animals only in being vastly more numerous; and emotion and reasoning are simply cases of the on- flict of instincts Drama and Music I rr. D mm & Co. have ft me I wards th ew Theatre, t I Gordon Craig We have 1 i 1 the following additionsto the Tudor Shakespeare (Macmillar which is prepared under the general supervi rf Professor Neilson and Thornd Two Gentl n of Verona,” ed l Prof Martin W. Sampsor rwelft! t i ited by Pr Walter Morris Hart Mea sure for Mea edited by Prof . Morris All Well That I l ] ] ited by Prof. Join L. Lowe The 7 : of the Shr edited Prof. Fred Tupper r Timon of A 1 Prof Robert Hu I ] ‘Venus and Adoni The Ra ere ’ ; Carlet Br \ ! i } is their rf he t is harg i ! p | DB 1 ’ tl iff t ‘ n 1 wi tl | ness. Pr hing 1 tant per Tt

Page 24

112 The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2483

rona with the later representatives of | family to the son and heir, who sooner or | which is to be built. The proposal of the their types in Shakespeare More might! later must fill his place and carry on the| Town Council is that the sum of 2,000,000 properly have been said of Helena, of Kath- | old traditions. This is his one aim in life,| marks be set apart as a first instalment, erina. of Isabella, and of Timon. The edit- | and it is this policy which, when pushed to| to be followed by further sums of three this edition too often convey the im-/| an extreme, stirs his eldest daughter to re-| millions, or a total of nearly a million pi ion of wishing to “play safe” rather bellion and an indignant refusal to accept and a quarter dollars. The Society which than of desiring to relieve the elementary | the condjtions imposed upon her, her sis- | is to carry out the undertaking pledges it- lent of his perplexities ter, and her long-suffering mother. self to build a theatre to seat 2,000, to pro- duce only approved plays, and in the course of every year to give at least ten afternoon performances for school chil- dren at a price not to exceed fifteen cents per ticket. The production of “The New Secretary,” “Pearls” is the name of a little one-act in the Lyceum Theatre, afforded a striking | “thriller” which the young English dra- illustration of the mischief that may be | matist, Stanley Houghton, has written for to a forelen play by a clumsy adapt-| Arthur Bourchier and Violet Vanbrugh, er and unintelligent stage management. The | Who are playing it in vaudeville. A fash- a iginal French comedy, by Francis de. lonable couple just returned to their lux- inp Croisset, has been running in Paris for | urious apartment—the wife from the opera) It has been definitely settled that Pade- twelvemonth, and has been the object of | and the husband from a club—talk of their rewski is to return to America next sea- I h eritieal commendation. Dramatical-| desperate financial straits. Presently the 8° for an extensive tour throughout the ly considered. the story—which tells how | wife discovers a wonderful pearl necklace Country, which will be under the direction hly gifted young secretary rescues’ “hich in some way unknown to her has of Charles A. Ellis. He has not been in his foolish millionaire employer from the | been entangled in her draperies. She is| America since the winter of 1908-09, when he hes of a pair of plausible rascals and | sorely tempted to keep it, but her husband spent a few weeks in the East. His prin- the heart and hand of a lovely and| says that the trinket must be returned | cipal object in coming to America at that i] heiress by confronting her with | promptly to the owner, whom he knows. time was to have his Symphony performed ereater than her own—is not in it- | The loss had been reported at his club, he by the Boston Symphony Orchestra. He elf very valuable. It provides two excel- Says, and some woman was under susp!- has not made an extended concert tour in lent theatrical situations, but is conven-/| cion of having stolen it. He is about to America since the season of 1907-08. Since tional in design, and not too credible. The| start out with the pearls in his pocket that time he has had a very successful tour which it has won at home ts clearly | when there is a knock at the front door, in South America, and an equally success- ! to the freshness and vitality of the | and, looking out, he recognizes the police ful tour in South Africa, while giving many principal personages and the brightness of | After a few moments of hesitation he re- concerts in Great Britain and on the Con- t! dialogue, qualities which are still per- solves to face the music. The door is tinent. Paderewski will arrive in America ble here the English artificer, Cosmo | opened and a policeman enters to say that in September, and will open his tour with Gordon Lennox, has not departed too far; he has found a kitchen window open. a series of concerts in Eastern and West- from his original. Unfortunately, it is only ern Canada. He will be here until April, J. T. Grein has published some details of his plans for the revival of the Inde- pendent Theatre in London: and will play in the neighborhood of one hundred concerts. Mr. Ellis has also made t rare intervals that the flat commonplace \nglicized small talk is relieved by a al Gaitte wh eo erties, The Get arrangements whereby he will have the hich | —- ativets seers . Europe is full of remarkable plays, and direction of a season’s tour of Fritz Kreis- whi a os en ely conversa- P ¢ ’ eve ¢ ‘ — "| there are also a few plays of the old jer the greatest of violinists. He will tional and explanatory, suffers especially | répertoire that deserve revival in 1913, er rae : from this maladroit interpretation. When | because they will be more appreciated and arrive in America towards the end of the tlon really begins to excite interest, | better understood than in the distant days October, and stay until spring. Both Mr. the see f the dial ‘ght be | OL the dramatic daybreak of the nineties.| Kreisler and Mr. Paderewski will give con- he poor quality o 1@ dialogue might be) Such plays are: De Banville’s “Kiss,” > : 4 certs 2 ac Ss é — onsequence if it were not for the| Edward Brandes’s “Visit,” van Nouhuys’s certs along the Pacific : lope and in the rd overemphasis given to it by incom-| “Goldfish” (translated by A. Teixeira de South, as well as in the Northern and East- ; - > é § at. ” ert who acted the hero | 4. nouse of Moliére, in which he may | ®¢¢4 for help at this time is great. Con le spirit and fine tact; Ferdi- | ,.4, part. Nevertheless, he continues to tributions to the fund for his family may ork done by other play nand Gott il whose windler was @/ 1+ in “Les Flambeaux,” at the Porte St. be sent to Mrs. Alexina Carter-Barrell, No. briltiat bit of ntri comedy Mrs Martin. The case will come up soon in 100 Boylston Street, Boston, Mass. Whit ho wa A delis actus as a fond | tne courts, and doubtless will attract much “Die toten Augen,” or “The Dead Eyes,” venee oad fey cae Pp re ie public attention M. le Bargy declares jig the title of a new opera by the famous that he would return to the Francaise if| German composer Eugen d’Albert, which robbed of half we eMiciency bY -ertain abuses in the management were! will be produced at the beginning of next = Pps associate rhe net result | poctified He complains that the chief| season. The text is by Hans Heinz Ewers, ‘ ’ r = “ megees , . 7 that “a om : performers are continually absent on for-| and the theme one of poetical sadness. The com 0 node } nanne * wae conve ha i. oan” one of third-rate elgn engagements It appears, however,| new work will be staged in one long act. . : ; that he has been one of the most conspicu-| The central figure is that of a blind young — ous truants, Maurice de Féraudy, one of | Greek woman, who lives on the scene and in the time of Christ's entry into Jerusalem. Heir,” ha tarted In the London Strand| that the institution is suffering from &|/ The New Testament incident forms the rheatre this week. It was completed two/| !ut of sociétaires, and that it will alway8| packground of the whole work. The Sa- tre ago, and the title originally selected | be In trouble until it gets rid of half of | yjour himself will not be portrayed in per- for it was “The Eldest Son,” but in this| them son, His presence being expressed by the holee the author was forestalled by John The municipality of Berlin is consider-| music and the phantasy of the work. Touch- Galeworthy. Pride of race, or of family,| ing a project for building a large theatre| ed by the healing hand of Christ, the blind is the subject handled in both pleces, but| for the working classes on land recently| woman regains her sight, and her eyes, the treatment is widely different Miss | occupied by slums in the very heart 7 filled with the light of love and passion, Unger’s protagonist is a bluff, hearty, but! the city. All the slum buildings have been | fall first upon a magnificent Roman, whom i narrow-minded country squire, prepared to! cleared away, and the theatre is to form| she believes to be her husband. Her hus- sacrifice all the remaining members of his! an architectural centre of the new district! band, however, is really a most repulsive Glad Unger’s new play, “The Son and| the oldest associates of the Francaise, says

Page 25

Jan. 30, 1913] The Nation 1138 figure, and it is in giving expression to the | conflict of emotions in the woman's heart when she discovers her mistake that the music of the new opera finds its vent. The finale takes place at sunset of the same day. The woman, troubled and disturbed in spir- it, stands gazing into the glory of the west- ern sky until she again becomes blind, and with her loss regains her peace of heart. Cosima Wagner is indefatigable in her efforts to perpetuate the “Parsifal” mo- nopoly at Bayreuth. A dispatch from Berlin dated January 22 stated that Crown Prince William heads the list of signers of a petition which has been presented to the Reichstag asking for the enactment of a special law to extend the copyright of “Parsifal,” which expires this year. The Crown Princess is second on the list, and the Imperial Princes follow. The appeal is made on the ground that Wagner wished to have his last work reserved for Bayreuth alone. The strangest thing about the affair is that Frau Wagner and her adherents, who are so very anxious to carry out his wishes in this matter, so thoroughly disre- gard his other intentions regarding Bay- reuth. He strongly deprecated the idea of commercializing Bayreuth—of making mon- ey with “Parsifal’’; yet that is what his widow After the last festival but one she admitted a profit, yet for the next festival she raised the price of seats from does. $5 to $6 each. It is not likely that the Reichstag will yield her point, for if it did, the result would be that all opera hotses in Europe except those in German cities would be able to produce “Parsifal.” the England, Augustus van Biene, who died stage last Thursday at Brighton, was a man of decided talent, both as actor and musician. He was born in Holland in 1850, and began life as a street player on the ‘cello. In this capacity he attracted the attention of Sir Michael Costa, who encour- aged him to develop his natural ability, and found him orchestral employment. In time successful soloist, organized concerts, and at one period was manager of the Gaiety Theatre, in London. In 1892 he made a hit in “The Broken Melody,” a sentimental piece of his own composition, in which, as an old musician, he was able to display his skill as composer and instru- mentalist. For twenty years he travel- led all over the world with this piece, presenting it in regular theatres and—in a condensed form—in music halls. Recently, it appears, he had sought relief from the monotony of his work in a new piece, on the old lines, called “The Musician,”’ and it in this that he died, with his beloved upon he became a was ‘cello in his hands. He was well known in this country. Gustave Carl Luders, composer of light music, died a week ago at his home in New York City. He was born in Bremen, Ger- many, in 1865. He studied piano, violin, and under Henry Petri, later concertmaster at Dresden, and to this country in 1888. Mr. Luders’s best- known operettas are: “The Burgomaster,” “King Dodo,” “Prince of Pilsen,’ ““Wood- land,” “The Shogun,” “Mile. Napoleon,” “The Grand Mogul,” and “The Old Town.” His latest work was “Somewhere Else,” produced at the Broadway Theatre only last week, on which occasion he was pres- ent in the audience, and, apparently, in good health. composition came Art ALMA-TADEMA. Lonvon, January 18. The Winter Exhibition at Burlington House, instead of being the Academy's winter-garment of repentance, as it was once described, threatens to become the cemetery of dead Academic reputations When an Academician happens to die in the course of the year, he is eagerly seized upon to replace the old masters of whom the Academy is tiring to share the winter show with them. We have had Leighton and Millais and Watts, the most prominent, and certain- ly nothing was added to—rather some- thing was taken away from—their fame. Only a year ago it was Abbey who suf- fered. And now it is Alma-Tadema, and, of all, he comes least well out of the ordeal. This is not because not been made to represent ade- quately. The collection, which fills four galleries, could scarcely be more rep- resentative. The earliest work goes back to his very infancy, and a chalk drawing of foliage, said to have been made when he was but four years old, is so careful and precise that it is diffi- cult to believe it belongs to quite so childish a period. There is a portrait of himself done when he was sixteen, and one of his mother painted a year later. There are pictures belonging to his student days under Gustav Wap- pers at Antwerp; and pictures that show the influence of Baron Leys, his second and only other master; and pictures, following one another in a long cession, that he exhibited at the Royal Academy, from his coming and settling in England in 1870, down to last year, the year of his death—pictures that won for him popularity and fortune and hon- ors to a degree in which he had few rivals, probably none who survive him, except perhaps Sir Hubert Von Her- komer. The trouble is really that he is too adequately represented. So many of his works hung together reveal most lamentably his weakness and his lim- itations, while his better qualities are or has effort him every suc- not of the kind to out-balance them. For his pictures were machine-made; there can be no question of it. It is careful, serious, painstaking machinery this seriousness was his strong point as a painter—but it was machinery all the same. You have only to look at that little drawing of leaves and blos- soms to see that, from the beginning, he spared himself no pains, that he did his work honestly, that he was no char- latan, no lover of short-cuts. The por- trait of himself as a youth, seated, his sketching traps on his lap, a curtain and a pillar in the background, shows careful study and observation, though not so much of nature as of the old Dutch portraits that must have been ’ familiar to him. Already an improve ment is seen in the small head of his mother, in which, indeed, there is more of an attempt to render the quality of flesh than in many of his more mature portraits. The Corner of a Courtyard in Amsterdam and the Old Staircas: at Antwerp, just a little later in date, are full of the same care now applied to architectural subjects, though in neither is there a suggestion of light or atmosphere, in anything than a dull prosaic statement of archi neither more tectural facts. The motives are those of masters who were his countrymen, but the treatment is without a sugges tion of the fine qualities, the fine in sight, that transformed the most ordi nary material in their hands into a splendor of color and tone, a poem of and shadow. If the pains Alma-Tadema never spared | imself anything he undertook to terize his first performances, so also do sunshine n do chara the commonplace vision, the mechanical technique, the exchange of nature for statistics, that make this long series of his pictures so terribly monotonous and uninteresting to-day. That he strayed further and still further from was not altogether due to lhiis training under Baron Leys, though the no doubt drew the student’s attention more and more to historical subjects, so that from the early sixtics he al ready preoccupied with Rome and Ko mans, rather than with Holland and Dutchmen or Belgium and Belgians The Pyrrhic Dance, A Roman Amateur, Tarquinius Superbus, A Roman Picture Gallery, were the characteristic sub jects of these years. But Tadema left to himself would most likely have seen, as h's great countrymen saw before him, the beauty that beautiful paint beautifully applied can give to the simplest, homeliest, things in a paint- nature master was never er’s daily life. Terborch, Jan Steen, Ver Meer, Metsu, and a host of others had had their imaginations stirred, their brushes inspired, their love of na ture and the real awakened, without going further than their own rooms or their own back yards. And they had had modern successors who could prove and yet re themselves great painters, tain their love for life as they knew it. Brakeleer, the Belgian, little known if at all out of Belgium, had already d veloped his way of expressing the beau ty and splendor of color and tor Matthy Maris, Tadema’s fellow-count man and contemporary, was beginning fn his early work to reveal himself as the legitimate descendant of the great Dutchmen. There are in the collection land scapes and portraits of Tadema’s matur ity which explain his attitude before na under record, he was no obligation reconstruct, or which did not know and never could kno" ture when to that he

Page 26

114 The of a bit of open country, or a few hay- a river bank, or a woodland, or a line of red roofs above a distant hedge, and they are all marked by the same commonplace way of looking at things, the same lack of invention, the same absence of air and light and life, the same uninteresting brush-work. And the portraits are as unimaginative, as uninspired, as uninspiring, the pose as a rule as banal as that of the pho tographer, the costume given in its un- redeemed ugliness, and not made beau- tiful by the expression of the character in its ugliness, the figure never in its envelope of atmosphere, the whole dry, landscapes are small in size, notes stacks by inanimate, flat. Two or three excep- tions might be pointed to: The Misses Alma-Tadema as Children, two little girls in white frocks and aprons, a portrait group in which there is more than the usual sense of character and life; the large three-quarter length of Miss Anna Alma-Tadema, too. well- known to be described again, hard and tight and frigid, but with a hint of har- mony in the arrangement of the grays; and the, I fancy, still better known My Doctor—his brother-in-law, Dr. Wash- ington Epps—sitting by the bedside of the patient of whom nothing is seen save the hand on the white bed clothes, the doctor’s fingers on the wrist as he looks down at his watch, the head stud- ied with more, if possible, than Ta- dema’s accustomed care and elaboration. Even with these exceptions, however, the portraits confirm the general im- pression one brings away of conscien- tious but dull mechanical workman- ship If Tadema could rarely suggest life, or vith originality and charm the figu before him, it is not to be expect- ed tl could succeed better with the fi he had never seen and had not the genius to imagine. He impress ed the public by his classical subjects, for they seemed, to the unlearned, brim- ful of learning He was extolled as a scholar among painters, an artist who made the old world real for us. What he did actually was to search the class!i- cal dictionaries and archmological text- books, and put down his idea of what the classic world, seen through them, must have been. Fortunately for him, the old Roman could not come back to Bay what he thought of Tadema’s baths and forums and temples and amphitheatres, while I am pretty sure, to-day, when Tadema's name has lost a little of ite old glamour, I am not alone in thinking that if the classic world and classic life were as he has recon- structed them, then we have reason to be thankful for having lived too late to see them for ourselves. Among his ear- liest works is The Parthenon at Athens, dated 1869, in which he labored to paint the frieze as he supposed it must have looked When the original ' color was fresh and vivid on the mar- [Vol. 96, No. 2483 The Nation ble, but if there is in his version a shadow of the truth once claimed for it, one can only marvel how the Greeks ever got their fame as an artistic na- tion; upon the scaffolding just below | the frieze, figures are grouped, and/| the catalogue explains that they are Phidias, Pericles, Aspasia, Alcibiades, | and Socrates. Call them what you will, | they have less life than the marbles) above. And so it is with all the fig-| ures, as you examine one painting af- | ter another. Lay figures again form the inanimate procession in his Finding of Moses. And, again, lay figures compose the audience—whom Tadema, in an ecstasy of statistics, declared to number five thousand—and fill the Imperial box in his Caracalla and Geta. Nor is there! more life and reality in the smaller pic- tures: those arrangements of white marble, blue sea and sky, blossoms and costumes which were hailed as Tadema’s masterpieces, and which he could not paint fast enough to satisfy his insatia- ble public. I think in these, really, the commonplaceness of his outlook is the| more apparent because he did not dis- guise it under some Biblical or classi- cal incident or legend. A youth with a ring in his hand, or jewels in a casket, or spring in the blossoms, give the clue to the sentimental anecdote the British public loves, explaining the figures and justifying the marble. And the blue sky above, and the blue sea beyond, and the blue mountains in the distance are reduced to no less obvious conventions. And the white marble, the famous white marble, looks as marble never looked in the open air where a real sun shines and real fall. These little paintings, praised for their light strong of Coliseums or Tadema’s white shadows truth, smell as the the big the big Egyptian landscape. house in St. John’s Wood was, if any- thing, more notorious than his canvases. The golden stairs, the studio with its treasures, the pseudo-classical rooms, the decorations by the masters of a short day, were for long in everybody’s mouth, coloring and magnifying and enriching his reputation. But all put together could not, in the end, serve that reputation so well as one piece of real marble—and not marble evolved from his inner consciousness—studied in real sunlight and not in the atmos- phere and light of the most splendidly appointed studio in the world. I think Tadema himself realized that his greatness was a little dimmed in the eyes of the world before he died. He could sometimes be so bitter that it was clear he heard with apprehension the younger generation of critics and artists | knocking at the door. But the least enthusiastic in his regard cannot but be astonished at the way his reputation ias vanished since his death. As many | of the criticisms of the exhibitions in| and their studio as ' the leading London papers as I have seen have all been patronizing, if not worse, so much so that already one voice has been heard in protest, calling upon the. critics to remember his con- summate draughtsmanship and impec- cable technique. The adjectives are |}more than a trifle exaggerated, though it would be folly to deny Tadema’s care and conscientiousness as draughtsman and technician. He allowed himself no slovenliness, no indolence. He did not, like those who now excuse themselves as Post-Impressionists, make a virtue of incompetence or save himself trouble and call it expressing his individuality. His drawing was academically correct, if personally inexpressive. He would have scorned the immortal game of be- wildering the bourgeois by eccentricity, or of scoring success by sheer acci- dents. He paid such close attention to the quality of his pigments that his paintings, far from emulating old mas- terpieces before their time, have pre- served almost too much of their orig- inal freshness. But care and conscien- tiousness cannot create genius, even though genius in art has been before now defined as genius for hard work. N. N. Mr. Joseph Pennell’s lithographs of the Panama Canal, which are now on exhibi- tion at the Sala Leonardo da Vinci in Florence, have been purchased by the Ital- ian Government for the Uffizi Gallery. The Government has also purchased Mr. Pen- nell’s lithographs of the Grand Cafion and the Yosemite. We have received the first number of a new quarterly, Art in America, which is edited by Mr. W. R. Valentiner of the Metropolitan Museum and published by F. Fr. Sherman. It will be devoted chiefly to objects of art of Medieval and Renais- sance periods owned in America. This first number presents, the editor, such distinguished contributors as Dr. Bode, Mr. besides Berenson, and Professor Marquand. Dr. Bode describes two very early Rembrandts, Tobias and Balaam, one dated 1626. Mr. Berenson associates a small Nativity in the Johnson collection with the style of Pietro Cavallini. Professor Marquand treats of a portrait bust of Francis owned by Mr. George Blumenthal. Mr. Valentiner ascribes the much-discussed Sleeping Cook of the Widener collection to Esaias Boursse, and detects the hand of this little-known Dutch painter in some other half a dozen pictures owned in America. Joseph Breck provides a catalogue raisonné of works by Tiepolo in the Metropolitan Museum. Profes- |sor Mather ascribes to Matteo da Sienna a splendid pair of cassone panels in Mrs. C. P. Huntington's possession, and a similar piece in the collection of the Earl of Crawford, London. Perhaps the most im- portant work of art reproduced in the num- ber is an exquisite Madonna by Carlo Cri- velli which has recently been acquired by Mr. Philip Lehman. The picture is briefly discussed by Professor Mather and dated about 1482. This incomplete survey will suggest the scope of the new magazine. Its make-up is somewhat scrappy as yet, but

Page 27

Jan. 30, 1913) if it continues to procure first publication of so many fine works as grace this num- ber, it will be indispensable for all art li- braries and serious students. The form is an in-quarto agreeably printed in a sin- gle column of clear type. The annual sub- scription is four dollars. Among recent acquisitions to the Metro- politan Correggio’s canvas of Four Saints | is easily the most important. Painted in his twenty-first year it cannot represent the glory of his mature style, yet it is in every | way a gracious composition. Since no ex- | ample of equal importance and quality is ever likely to come into the market, the Museum should be congratulated on an ex- cellent purchase. Two wooden statues, an Annunciation, though crudely répainted, represent a rare and impressive type, dat- ing presumably from the late thirteenth century; the surmise may be hazarded that these are Bavarian sculptures or from some provincial. school in north Italy under Bavarian influence. Numerous minor acqui- sitions in stuffs, pottery, etc., testify to the activity of the Department of Decora- tive Art. It is a shock to find in the new acquisitions room such thoroughly banal paintings those by Alexander Harri- son and Albert Herter. To be sure these are gifts, but a large part of the business of @ great’ museum is to look such gift horses as these quite fearlessly in the mouth. Louis De Coppet Bergh, architect, died on Tuesday in Washington. He was born in New York in 1856, and after an educa- tion in the public schools, he studied in Europe at the Military Gymnasium, Os- trowo, Prussia; at Lausanne, and at Stutt- gart. Returning to New York, he became expert architectural and sanitary adviser to Mayor Strong’s City Commission He Was the author of “Safe Building,” in two volumes, and “Safe Building Construction.” as Finance THE “INVESTIGATIONS,” TERWARD. A N I ) AF- Since the markets quieted down from the particularly agitating financial in- fluences of the summer, there has been somewhat more consideration of the question, just how far the matters which Wall Street financiers have put to the front causes of dis- turbance are bound to exert that in- fluence. This is undeniably an era of “inquiries” and “investigations.” Com- missions to look into something are distinctly the order of the day, and the results of their examinations, as reported in the daily papers, chal- lenge the reader’s attention more in- stantly than anything in the headlines, unless it may be a district attorney's hunt for the identification of the “man higher up’”—which, after all, is very much the same sort of thing. But now that the “Money Trust Sub-committee,” on whose inquiries public attention bas so long been riveted, has closed its in- vestigation and begun to prepare its formal report to the House Banking as | pages. |a year or more ago, when three or four The Nation Committee and to Congress, discussion as to the tangible results of such inqui- ries in legislation becomes more to the point. The testimony before a commission, such as the public has become accus- | tomed to, makes several definite appeals to the public interest. It is usually wei staged. The witnesses are apt—on occa- sion, at any rate—to be the men to the story of whose lives the ten and fif- teen-cent magazines have been devoting There was a time, for instance, publications of that nature were simul- taneously depicting Mr. Morgan's ca- reer, in serial form, to their respective readers. This testified to the valuation placed on the general topic as “copy” by the editors. Every reflective person knows how much of its vogue and pres- tige Mr. Thomas W. Lawson’s “Fren- zied Finance” owed to the notion, prev- alent among village statesmen and oc- cupants of city third-floor that its author had been one of the triumvi- Rockefeller Money backs, rate (Morgan - Lawson) which managed the monopolized American finance, turned State’s guilty copartners to the public. and had his Trust but evidence against and was confessing What more natural, therefore, than that this public should now, in its sim- ple way, conceive that the criminals were at length actually in the dock with a prosecuting attorney baiting them? The Pujo Committee’s counsel himself fell victim to this notion during the early stages of the inquiry; though it is fair to say that the later cross-exam- inations have pretty much abandoned the Old Bailey method. But the ques- tion naturally worries the quiet and im- partial watcher: What will be the result when all these investigations are com- pleted? There is undeniably a timid appre- hension, in many quarters of business and finance, that the public and the leg- islators are hungry for blood; or, to change the metaphor, that they will in- sist on the present machinery of trade and banking being torn down and re- built in accordance with new and sud- den happy-thoughts. Nobody, to be sure, has imagined a Terror with high finance to the lamp-post and the guillotine; the revolution which uneasy minds conceive is more like that in under the general uproar for a order of things, the legislators of a certain mo- mentous period were so bent on change for the sake of change that even the names of the months and week-days had which, new to be reformed and the year 1789 be came Year I, because there was noth- ing worth remembering before it. In fact, it must be admitted that the mood of to-day, which induces women of good society to fight in the streets to prove their capacity for the ballot, labor leagues to demand that 115 the employees run their industries and hire their pres ent employers, grave conventions to dis- cuss the plan of Government regulation as to whom one shall or shall not mar- ry, and what sort of children he may have, and even the staid and respecta- ble hotel waiters to indulge in frantic riot, appears on its face to embody a general demand for a world turned up- side down. But the American people have never shown disposition to translate angry demands and denunciation into offhand statute law. After the uproar and excess- es of the stump, the cheap magazines, and the penny newspapers, the practical work in matters of the sort is placed where it belongs—in the hands of legis- lators who must look behind and ahead, must bear the responsibility for after-effects of what is done to-day, and who are quite well aware that the public which to-day is demanding action will be the first to denounce and punish its representatives at Washington, Al bany, if their precipitate action brings about bad results. It is this sober sec- ond thought—such as invariably, in our history, has followed the frantic demands for parting company with in the past—which may be in the public measures the present controversies. who or most stitutions of upon follow relied which We are ond period, when public men must de cide, not what to say, but what The moderating sideration is already visibl zer’s cautious and self-restraired sage regarding Stock Exchange reform by legislation—the of the re- ponsible executive to the irresponsible now on the verge of this sec- to do influence of this con- in Gov. Sul- mes- answer newspaper clamor for haphazard inno vation in Stock Exchange affairs. It will of comes for- visible when, later on, the report the Money Trust Committee mally before Congress; if not in the re- port itself, at any rate, in the Congres be sional discussion of it This does not mean that nothing will be done to correct or restrain possible abuses in either of the two directions. There will quite conceivably be legisla- tion of the sort. There was such legis- lation after the searching and sensa- tional life insurance inquiry of 1905. It introduced some much-needed reforms— not through destroying existing institu- tions, but through squarely prohibiting future misuse of policyholders’ funds by Wall Street promoting syndicates. What- ever legislation sequel to the present inquiries, is likely enough to take a leaf from the book of the pro- posed corporation for Jersey—which, in response controversy based on the gravest sort of known abuses under the older laws, pro- occurs, a8 a new laws New to excite d pose to destroy nothing and to tear down nothing, but to put a stern and positive veto on future recourse to de

Page 28

116 The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2483 monstrably evil and dangerous practices which have grown up and flourished un- and improper cor- poration laws of the past fourteen years. der the bad finance BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Adams, John Quincy. Writings. Edited by W. C. Ford. Vol. I, 1779-1796. Macmillan $3.50 net \ Rifleman.” The Struggle for Bread: Goldie, V. The Declension of Henry d’Al- A Reply to “The Great Illusion.” Lane. biac. Stokes. $1.25 net. $1.50 net Grierson, Elizabeth. What the Other Chil- Baedeker'’s Northern Germany, 1913. Scrib- dren Do. Macmillan. $1.25 net. ner $2.40 Grow, Oscar. The Antagonism of Races. Banning, Kendall. Songs of the Love Un- Waterloo, Iowa: The Author. en ding Chicago: Brothers of the Book. Halifax, Robert. A Slice of Life. Dutton. Beer, G. L. The Old Colonial System, 1660- $1.35 net. 1754. Part I, Vols. I and II. Macmillan. Harris, A. M. Letters to a Young Lawyer. $4 net St. Paul: West Pub. Co Bertram, Paul. The Fifth Trumpet. Lane. | Harrison, Frederic. The Positive Evolu- $1.25 net tion of Religion. Putnam. Black, Mra. Elmer A Terminal Market Hauptmann, Gerhart. Dramatic Works. System: New York's Most Urgent Need. Edited by L. Lewisohn Vol. I, Social Privately printed Dramas. Huebsch. $1.50 net. Blundell, Peter. The Finger of Mr. Blee.' Henderson, E. F. Symbol and Satire in Lane. $1.25 net the French Revolution. Putnam. Bowen, Marjorie The Quest of Glory. Hull, Eleanor. The Poem-Book of the Gael: Dutton. $1.35 net Translations from Irish Gaelic Poetry Bridges, Robert. Poems (Oxford India into English Prose and Verse London: paper edition.) Frowde Chatto & Windus. Browning's Ring and the Book. Frowde Ibsen, Sigurd Human Quintessence. Buchanan, Alfred The Modern Héloise Huebsch $1.50 net. Dillingham. $1.25 net. Jackson, W. 8. Cross Views. Lane. $1.25 Clark, A. H Notes on American Species net. of Peripatus, with a list of Known | Judith, Madame. My Autobiography. Put- Forms Washington: Smithsonian Insti- nam. $3.50 net tution Kropotkin, P. Fields, Factories, and Work- Coleridge, 8. T. Poems. Frowde. shops. New edition, revised. Putnam. Conrad, Joseph. 'Twixt Land and Sea. Macaulay, R. The Lee Shore. Doran. $1.25 Doran $1.25 net. net. Cooley, W. F. The Principles of Science: McDonald, Ronald. Lanchester of Braze- 1 College Text-book. Holt. nose. Lane. $1.30 net. A Notable New Novel Laurence Housman’s King John of Jingalo While this is a clever satire on England to-day, King John's lova- ble personality dominates the book. We learn how he becamean authority on history, consented to his son's romantic match, had a bomb thrown at his carriage and was ar- and thrown into jail. $7.35 au $1.45. Henry Holt & Co. NEW YORK. I Ve . ; } re : ed / 7 34 W. 33RD ST., Columbia University Studies in History, Economics, and Public Law Vol.LI. THE SALEOF LIQUOR IN THE SOUTH. lhe History of the Development of a Normal Social Restraint in Southern Com- monwealths. By LEONARD STOTT BLAKEY, Ph.) fometime Schiff Fellow in Co lumbia University Associate Profes sor of Eeonomics and Sociology tia Dickinson College. 4to. Paper covers, $1.00. Cloth, $1.50. Longmans, Green, & Co. - ! Findlater, M. and J. Monypenny; ton. $1.35 net, each. Fouché, Memoirs Relating to. from the French by E. J. Méras. & Walton. $1.50 net. France, Anatole. Jocasta and the Famished Cat. Translation by Agnes Farley. Lane. $1.75 net. Pyvie, John. The Story of the Borgias. | | Putnam. $4.50 net. Godet, Philippe. Neuchatel: Attinger Fréres. Translated | Moreau-Vauthier, Charles. Sturgis Frederic Godet (1812-1900). Crossriggs; Penny | Martial, Wit and Wisdom from. Epigrams Seven Scots Stories. Dut- | ¢hosen and done into English, with notes, | by A. 8. West. London: Priory Press. The Technique of Painting. Putnam. Pageant of English Prose. M. Leonard. Frowde. | Parmelee, Maurice. The Science of Human Behavior. Macmillan. $2 net. Pryce, Richard. Time and the Woman: A Novel. Fenno & Co. $1.25 net. Reinach, Salomon. Cultes, Mythes et Re- | ligions. Tome Quatriéme. Paris: Ernest Leroux. Roberts, Morley. The Private Life of Henry Maitland. Doran. $1.25 net. Robertson, J. M. The Evolution of States: Edited by R. ' An Introduction to English Politics. Putnam. $2.50 net. Schiller, Friedrich. Kabale und Liebe. Edited, with notes, by W. A. Hervey. Holt. Spearing, H. G. The Childhood of Art, or the Ascent of Man. Putnam. Spenser, Edmund. PoeticalWorks. Edited by J. C. Smith and E. de Sélincourt. Frowde. Squire’s Recipes: Being a Reprint of an Odd Little Volume as Done by Ken- dall Banning. Chicago: Brothers of the Book. $1. Stevenson, George. Topham’s Folly. Lane. $1.30 net. Stubbs, A. W. Other Poems. Sypherd, W. The Indian Princess, and Boston: Badger. $1.25 net. O. Handbook of English for Engineers. Chicago: Scott, Foresman. Thwing, C. F. and C. F. B. The Family. Revised, enlarged edition. Boston: Lothrop, Lee & Shepard. $1.60 net. Tomkins, F. W. _ Sunshine on Life's Way. Selections collected by Mrs. W. C. Knowles. ‘Dutton. $1.25 net. Vachell, H. A. Bunch Grass: A Chronicle Doran. $1.20 of Life on a Cattle Ranch. net. Just Published. SOCIAL WELFARE IN NEW ZEALAND By HUGH H. LUSK This book sums up the re- sults of twenty years of progres- sive social legislation in New Zealand, and seeks to interpret its signiticance to the United States and other countries. Itisa work of the kind long desired by sociologists and political econo- mists—a work based on Govern- ment statistics and data not ac- cessible till 1912. The author was for ten years a member of the New Zealand Parliament. 12mo, $1.50 net. The English Scene in the Eighteenth Century By E. S. anand With 24 Illustrations. $2. By mail, $2.90. A graphic account of the essen- tial characteristics of life in Eng- land during this period, embracing the nobility, the middle class, the industrial revolution, and the new provincial citizen, the man of let- ters, the naval officer, the clergy, and the peasantry. New York G.P. Putnam’s Sons London 8ro. 5 net. Plays and Players in Modern Italy STURGIS & WALTON CO. B1-88 Past 27th Street, New York. Being a study of the Italian stage as af- fected by the political and social life, manners and character of to-dav. By ADDISON McLEOD 8vo, cloth, gilt top, with ilustrations,$2.75 net Charles H. Sergel & Co., Chicago a SHAKESPEARE’S WORKS ‘THE FLOWING ROAD First Folio Edition. lotte Porter. 40 vols. vol.; leather, $1.00 per vol. “By all odds the best edition now accessible.”"—(The Living Age. THOMAS Y. CROWELL CO., New York Edited by Char- | | Adventuring on the Great Rivers of South America Cloth, 75c. per | By CASPAR WHITNEY | 24 inserts | maps. vo. Cloth. $3.00 net, Postpaid, $3.20. |\J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. | (tempora cloth, BINDER FOR THE NATION, To receive the current numbers in a convenient 7m) form, Substantially made, bound in with THE NATION stamped on the side fn Magazine excerpts on all subjects sup- | gold.’ Holds about one volume. Papers easily and plied. Let me know what you are Inter- | Bestly s usted, Sent, ety on receipt of 75 nts. Address The Nation, 20 Vesey Street, New ested in. H. Williams, 106 EB. 22d St., N. Y.: York City. Pyne

Page 29