The Nation 1913-01-09: Vol 96 Iss 2480

Page 1

[qu thet The Naira VOL. XCVI—NO. 2480

THI RSDAY, JANUARY 9, PRICE TEN CENTS . Reg. U. 8. 1913 Pat Office

For the Traveller Barker, E. H. Blashfield, E. H. and E. W. and Wales. Illustrated. net, 3.00 Boulger, D. Belgium of the Belgians, net, 1.50 teaux of France. 2 vols..net, 2.50 D’Auvergne, E. B. Famous Castles and of Italy Palaces Ca0th bas) oR, ae Field, H. M. From the Lakes of Killarney Freeston, C. L. Wayfarers in Italy . net, 2.00

Development of Religion and Thought in Ancient Egypt “This is the most notable contribution to the history of brilliancy which is usually as Evening Poat is characterized by the French.”—N. } and it cribed to the The Last Frontier Byron Art in Egypt living au- hooks ex- appreciation of one of the greatest particular country The knowledge and thorities on the art of a Clty f Parts

For the Traveller Loomis, LL. C. France of the French. ..net, $1.50 Index Gul t Travel snd rs vin ft , net Berry, Rebert Art Sf ' Germany of the Germans, net, 1.50 By James H. Breasted, Ph.D. Martin, B. E. Bicknell, Mrs. C. E. Professor of Egyptology and Semitic Languages, the I ate Charles . ati Paris and Its Treasures, net, 1.75 University of Chicago Stones f Paris in History aml Letters Italian Cities .... ...net, 2.00 religions recently made, and it is the most valuable ever ade 1 Bond, Francis, M.A to the history of the religion of Egypt. It embodies the most Matthews, Brander The Cathedrals of England exact scholarship of the type commonly regarded as German Theatres of Paris Meriwether, Lee Afloat and Ashore t th rrow, George Mediterrs Bor soore $1.50 net; by mail $1.65 Mediterrat Wild Wales net, 1.00 4 3 Monniler, mace Zincali, Gypsies «f Sy;atn, net, 1.00 pmo mie Mare | on ‘Wonders Murray (John) (ii Robertsen, A. I re the D1 Stevenson, R. L. I h Ditehfield. P. H. By Ethel Mayne lil Charm of the English Village : } ne net, 3.00 Miss Mayne has written a book for which she deserves the S Douglas, H. A hearty gratitude of all lovers of the poet. She is sincere, well I I oJ * #Be Venice and Its Treasures net, 1.50 balan ed, act wae a why or ghee pee lerr wd. by Dey agen tne Stoddard ©. A. Venice on Foot ........net, 1.59 hesitatingly call it the best of modern works on the subje \, Russia One of her merits is that she has the gift of presenting us with Spa Cities Du Chaillu, P. B. brilliant little character-sketches of the men and women who Sully, James, LL.D... Land of the Long Night 2.00 crossed the poet’s path, so that her book is not a life of Byron Professor of PI eoplis Engelmann, R. only, but a history of his times London Spectatoi ; ty Co - ge, Lat - - —_ - t ut rave Sketches Pompeii i _ net, 1.50 9 role.. illustrated. $6.00 net ver twenty full-pas Fea, Allan t by P. Noel I t Nooks and Corners of Olt READY THIS MONTH eee DT dédwdaeabecved Ge 6.00 = BS, SOUR , — lat 1 » Lit I thde-Rernays, H Rothenberg « he I to the Golden Horn. net, 2.00 _— * : "4 "ol . ~ ; + et Gibraltar .......... net, 2.00 A New Volume in the General History of Art Series ; Villlers-Wardell, Louis Greek Islands ..... net, 1.50 G <1 f+ Snanial Old Spain and New Spain, By . Maspero < ¢ ! net, 1.50 : Vineent, W. R. ; Director-General of Antiquities in Egypt. In the Shadow Finck, H. T. : es Spain and Moroceo.....n t, 1.25 A series in each of whose small volumes is concentrated the Waddington. MW. KR. High Roads of the Alps. .net, 3.00 : Fr The Passes of the I’yvrenees, emplify one of the most notable feats of literary compressio: Ita Letter , 1» net, 3.00 on the part of the writers, and of manufacturing compression n « Wit Hewlett, Maurice on the part of the publishers in the history of book aking Webb. Frank Earthwork Out of Tuscany 2 00 Vearly 1000 illustrations, $1.50 net; postpaid $1.65 rather protec i 7 eho So Road in Tuscany. 2 vols t, 6.09 Other Volumes in the Series. Foch $1.50 net Wendell. puowets Hooker. Katherine Art in Franee, by Lou's H Inspector of Fine Art« fn tl Wharton, Edith Hatton, FE. Art in Northern Italy, by Corrado Ricci, Director-General of F! " Country Walks About Florence Arts and Antiquities of Italy; Zimmern, Helen net, 1.50 Art in Great Britain and Ireland, by Sir Welter Arm«trong, he un rector-General eof the Nat tl] Gallers f Irelas ° © efe ° ° ° and Walk si Brooks, N. The White Man’s War for Civilization in Africa ert Mediterranean Trip net, 1.25 ‘ Boown, B. PF. By E. Alexander Powell, F.R.G.S. ag al In and Around Venice....net, 1.50 ' : , ¥ “One of the most vividly interesting and valuable books of Scotland ag ton J. w. , . the year. . It is a graphic discussion of the development Spalr 2° 1 ata io 1.50 of ~~ oa 9 = Faggeeges coins of world politics Seldom — Switzerland net any author been able so successfully to lay out in the pages o . Brownell, W. C. a book a great stretch of i1e earth’s surface for which the sao f French Traits -++-Met, 1.50 powers are contending, or have contended, with a clarity such rT rougl the French Prov meeenases, Sacsb Fc that the whole affa'r becomes as real as a chess-board, on een ! icerone, in Italy. . net, 1.50 which the pawns are moved as one watches the game Aside Penfield, Edward Collier, Price from this, Mr. Powell has sketched with remarkably quick 2 _ England and the English from strokes the main characteristics of the different parts into Holland Ske 4 , an American Point of View. — which Africa is divided by natural and artificial lines, their Spanish Sket sade net, 1.50 natural resources and the distinguishing qualities of their in Renwick, George Cook, T. A. habitants. There are a great number of excellently chosen Finland To-Da Old Provence. Illustrated. 2 7 photographs which are reproduced, not merely because they are Romantic Cor ‘ 0 VOIS. «sees eee, - net, 2.50 picturesque or beautiful, but in some cases because they ar Old Touraine. The Life and truly significant of movements now in progress.”—NSpringfleld Rehardaen. R. n. History of the Famous Cha Republican $3.00 net: by mail $3.2 ' : *

CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS 153 FIFTH AVE., NEW YORK |

a

Page 2

The Nation [Vol. 96 No. 2480 The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. the New York City Post second-class mail matter.) [Batered at Office as The Nation |e published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor; Harold deWolf Fuller, As- sistant Editor Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Merico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countrice comprised in the Postal Unton $4.00 Addresg THE NATION, Bor 704, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Sirecet CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. WEEK ARTICLES Short Way Emancipation Jubil New Governor ‘atrons for Certain RIAL Out Gentus Witty Fren SPECIAL ARTICLES: The American Historical Association The Philologists and Archmologists at Washington . ee The Society of Biblical Literaturs Central Division of the Modern Lan guage Association CORRESPONDENCE Cabinet Officers in Cong: Conditions in Cuba A Correction . “Napler’s Bones” An Elastic Currency Shakespeare and Aristot LITERATURE: Retrospection The Social Cancer (Noli gere)—The Reign of Greed busterismo) . Scientific Sprague Dawson, "11: Fortune-Hunter sie rhe Journal of a Sporting Nomad.— rhe Complete Wildfowler.—The Book of Winter Sports.—By Flood and Field Problems me Tan- (El Fili- of Men, Mind, and Morals.. Biological Aspect o ND Mt A Study in Cl ind Religion FINANCE Iwo Important A BASIS FOR COMPOSITION. Educational COLORADO | THE WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER) Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges | for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium. “J°HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Eveaetr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 24 Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av.,NewYork 610 Swetiand Bd., Portland 814 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd., LosAngeles 920 Sav. Bk Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Blk., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. | Harlan P. French, P: Vincent B. Fisk, Mer. THE ALBANY TY EACHERS’ AGENCY. knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex. | perience in bringing together good teachers and schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself. . : | PROF ESSORSHIP—A gentleman, for several years professor of chemistry at a State university - and who has since bad experience in chemical In- dustries, desires to return to university work as professor of pure or applied chemistry. Abundant evidence as to qualifications, professional standing | and exceptional teaching ability can be produced. Graduate of leading universities at home and | abroad Address: ‘‘Spectemur,’’ care The Nation. | Nearly Ready REPRESENTATIVE ESSAYS IN, MODERN THOUGHT Edited by Harrison Ress Steeves, A.M., Instructor in English, Columbia University, and Frank Humphrey Ristine, Pb.D., Acting Professor of English Literature, Hamil- ton College, sometime instructor in Columbia University This volume includes nineteen well-written, in- telligible, and authoritative essays by leading} authors upon subjects which grip the intelligent nterest of the average college freshman Each | essay is preceded by a brief Introduction dea'ing the author and his point of view In most cases where there are two sides to the problem that has been presented, two typical essays, show- ing both points of view. are offered One selec tion is to be assigned for reading each week, f>l- lowed by the writing of impromptu themes in the | classroom upon topics which suggest the salient} points of the work under consideration Every effort is made to encourage the student to think | for himself, to form his own op'nione upon proper evidence, and state his own position on the ques- | tions involved | AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY NEW YORK CINCINNATI CHICAGO with JUST PUBLISHED HISTORY OF MODERN ELE- MENTARY EDUCATION By Samuel Chester Parker, Dean of the College of Education, The University of Chicago 8vo, cloth, ceiv+505 pages, illustrated. $1.50 repared ‘‘History of Mod- ucation’’ deals primarily ent It empha- This carefully ern Blementary with institutional develor sizes typical movements, inStitutions and in. dividuals, thus showing the student ele- mentary school problems from the Middle Ages to the present time. Enough material for one hundred hours of class work is provided in this beok. If a longer course is desired, the text may be supplemented with Rovsseau's ‘‘Emile,"’ Pestalozzi's ‘‘Leonard and Gertrude.”’ and Spencer's ‘‘Paucation."’ The publishers present this book with the firm bellef that it is the best one that has yet been written for the student of educa- tion and the prospective teacher. GINN AND COMPANY 76 Fifth Avenue, New York Chicago London Boston | Atlanta Dallas Columbus San Frandisco | " THE FLOWING ROAD Adventoring on the Great Rivers of South America| * © © Goples of The Nation may be procured fn Paris at Brentano's, 37 l'Opéra; to Iondon of BL F 4 Trafalgar @quare, Charing Cross Avenue de Stevens & Brown, By CASPAR WHITNEY 24 inserte, and maps. vo Cloth. Postpaid, $8.20 LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. $3.00 net. ‘ J. B. LETTERS AND MEMORIALS Wendell Phillips Garrison Editor of The Nation, 1865-1906 In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. During the forty-one years in which he edited the Nation, with a thoroughness, ability, and conscientious devotion unsurpassed in the records of American journalism, Mr. Garrison was an indefatiga- ble correspondent, never em- ploying an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who em- braced practically all the leading American scholars and critics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been’ kindly loaned by the recipients, a sufficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the relations between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exercised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes, and sympathies. The volume also contains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and several of his characteristic editorials, re- views, and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. Price, $1.50 net postpaid. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO. BOSTON NEW YORK

Page 3

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 9%, 1913 The Week In deciding not to send to the Senate the nomination of Col. Goethals as Gov- ernor of the Canal Zone, President Taft is doubtless influenced largely by the wishes of that officer himself. It known that he has little ambition to be is Governor; and it is understood that he would not consent to be nominated for the position if his confirmation was to be opposed. But some of the Demo- cratic Senators, for reasons of their own—not unconnected, we fear, with a desire for office—-have announced that they will stand out against setting up a civil government at Panama for the present, and so the President drops the whole plan. It is a sordid piece of busi- ness as it stands, and where does it leave the great argument for driving the Canal Bill through in haste at the last session of Congress? When the strong objection to the shipping clauses of that act was made, and the danger of inter- national complications, such as have since resulted, was pointed out, there was a demand for more time for con- sideration. Why not let the bill go over to the next session? Ah, it was replied, that would be impossible, for it is im- perative to make provision at once for a civil governaient. We must lose no time in empowering President Taft to appoint Col. Goethals as Governor. Well, we have not got him in office, and we have got the international trouble. So much for hair-trigger legislation. Senator Bacon’s introduction of a joint resolution recognizing the Chinese Republic will, it is said, be vetoed by Mr. Taft if it passes both Houses. That may or may not take place; Mr. Taft's opposition to so many matters has van- ished before sufficient pressure that it need surprise no one if he should under- go a sea-change on this one, too. It is hard, indeed, to see why recognition should be longer withheld. As Ching Chun-Wang points out in the current Atlantic, the dynasty is dead. Prince Regent and Dowager Empress have for- saken it. As for the republic, it has existed ten months, nobody is contest- The Nation ing it; and as for disorder, there is not so very much more, if any, than there Indeed, so well thought of is the republic that the lead- was under the empire. ing European nations and the United States are fairly forcing their money upon it, which hardly looks as if anar- chy were expected to-morrow. The bur- den of the proof why the republic should not be recognized is plainly, as Mr. Ching points out, upon those who would deny it acceptance among the na- tions of the earth. Gov. Wilson has recently declared that the one great basic truth which under- lies political discussion to-day is “that singular fact that nothing is done in this country as it was done twenty Mr. Wilson over this statement of his and reassure years ago.” will need to glance himself of its validity, when he reads of the pretty little patronage schemes that are cherished in a number of Democrat- ic bosoms at Washington. Nothing may be done to-day as it was done twenty years ago, but the heart of man has not Old of thought, and evil instincts do not die so changed completely in that period. passions, old greed, old evil habits auickly. In spite of the lesson of near- ly twenty years of adversity, Democrat- ic leaders are still possessed with the spoilsman ideal. The plan of a general ripper bill which shall throw open the civil service to the Democrats sounds 80 utterly out of date, so much a part of the old order that has changed, that one finds it almost impossible to believe that such a plan could be seriously dis- And yet it spite of the plain warning of what will if it prove false to the opportunity which has cussed. is discussed. In happen to the Democratic party been finally granted it, there are Demo- crats who seem willing to take a chance. Mr. stances is perfectly clear. the circum- When Wilson's duty under the squealing round the public trough be- comes insistent, he will only have to recall that things are not done now as they were done twenty years ago. The business of Cabinet prophecy has at last been put upon a scientific basis by friends of the Democratic Governor of Montana, who confidently predict his the In- appointment as Secretary of Wilson That kind of equipment terior in the Cabinet, because his hair is red. necessarily carries with it a robust and highest aggressive honesty which is the jualification ons demand in a ser- can vant of the people. Militant progressiv- ism to-day requires that its champions if the color the shall be well-thatched, and be of Mr. Victor Murdock bore under his hat the sunset, so much better the oriflamme round which the original group of Republican insurgents in Con- Mr. not red, but makes up for that deficien- gress rallied. La Follette’s halr is cy by a defiant erectness that suggests the Spartans at Thermopyle. Mr. Sulzer faces the enemies of the commonweal with locks hanging menacingly over the brow. Here, then, is a capillary test work of future Give which should make the Presidents as easy as lying. 80 many points for the amount of hair and so many for the tint, and in crucial cases let the spectroscope decide. What Mr. Bryan’s chances would be under such conditions is obvious. The Colonel breaks his silence with shouts about another “infamy.” This shows that he is well and happy. Un- less somebody were “outraging” his feel- ings they would not be normal. People, however, who do not live at high pres- who wish and some- their sure as he does, how to adjust emotions to the facts, will ask what the truth is about the action of the Idaho Supreme Court which Mr. Roosevelt so furiously de- nounces. Hiis chief complaint is that, by a judicial interpretation of the State election lews, the people of Idaho were not permitted to have an official ballot But similar with his name on it. the Cali- fornia courts made a decision keeping Taft’s name off the ballot, and about that infamy the Colonel has had We he never a word to say. suppose was restrained, in that case, by his pro- found respect for the judiciary! Any- to see that he cannot he fish the other without impairing his reputa And wh how, ought make of one decision and fow! of tion for high impartiality at is really needed is a clear statement of the text and intricacies of the Idaho law, under which the judges felt con strained to decide as they did. This th Colonel has never made a pretence of

Page 4

4 The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2480 giving. It is so much easier to hurl epithets, from a safe distance, and to affirm that this case “proves” that udges ought to be kicked off the bench whenever “the people” don't like the ay in which they declare what the ay 5 Mr. Gompers, as an individual citizen, ht hold hat opinion he pleased " lal inion dynamiters and on, and might orate on the é is heart's content. The only any sensible man pays attention hat he says is that he is at the head the American Federation of Labor; and for him, in that capacity, to emit such utterances as he did before a Sen ate committee on Monday is a serious business. In what he said there was not one hearty word in condemnation of rime; on the contrary, the whole drift of his remarks was that it was no won- der laboring men had been driven to dynamiting and murder the only left “tyranny” as them of resistance to the of means their employers. Such thinly-veiled apologies for assassination would be monstrous, even if the facts were as stated by Mr. Gompers. But the truth has been clearly established | that the main purpose of the explosions was to strike terror into the hearts of non-union men and those who hired them, and to compel both men and mas- ters to submit in all things to the labor Tyranny for organization tyranny, where could there be one more intolera- ble than this? Yet murder in its name is explained as devotion to the sacred cause of labor! Fresh evidence of the aggressive way work appears from to the which Boston is going to in rehabilitate its port fact that its “port directors” have decid- ed bulld drydock of to a 1,180 feet long sill. rhis will be the largest drydock in the vith a width 100 feet at the country, and the enterprise is supported by all the leading transatlantic lines, vhich have agreed to pay something for it each year, so that they may have a dock on this aide of the Atiantic avail- able in case of accident As is well known, there is not a single drydock now on our shores which can take in the Olympic or the new Imperator of the Hamburg-American Line, or any of the other giants of the ocean. The largest is the one now drydock of the navy building in Seattle, which is to be 827 feet long, while the second largest, in this city, is only 694 feet in length, so that the navy, too, will welcome the new Boston enterprise. But the port directors of that city are not going to feet huge stop there. A smaller dock, 900 long, is also contemplated, and piers near both docks, in order to ac- commodate ships while awaiting their turn or in port for commercial reasons. The vill shortly directors believe that there be plying port as Many as twenty-one steamers, between Europe and North will be compelled to use this dock or none at all. They feel that if ever steamers can be ; for repairs, there will be hope of get- ting them to run there regularly. The promise of the Hamburg-American Line American ports, which induced to come to Boston to dock to send ships to Boston beginning next May has greatly encouraged the city’s boomers. They are leaving no stone un- turned to have other lines follow this example. Chicago’s Bureau of Public Efficiency has begun to win victories. About a year ago, it recommended a material reduc- tion in the number of officials and em- | ployees in various departments. The rec- ommendation came too late, however, to affect these appointments for the fol- lowing year. But when they came up in 1912, as they did recently, the con- clusions of the Bureau had sufficient | weight to result in the lopping off of more than fifty places. Only in the sher- iff’s office were the recommendations dis- regarded, and there apparently for rea- sons which might be honestly presented. Now, the Bureau has won a partial vic- tory the matter of distribution of appropriations to the several wards. It made a scientific estimate of the per- in centage of this money that should go) to the thirty- five the estimate of the City Control- ler was increased by the Bureau, on the ground that these wards had never received sufficient funds under the old system of each Alderman grabbing all In the oth- er sixteen, the Bureau cut the Control- The finance committee each. In nineteen of that he could for his ward. ler’s estimates. of the City Council at first rejected the Bureau's recommendations in toto, but at a full meeting of the committee later accepted. This ought to pave the way for a complete triumph for the Bu- reau’s programme in this field next year. At last the “Jim Crow” laws are to be tested in the United States Supreme Court. A white woman, having bought a berth in a Pullman sleeper from Vicks- burg to New York, protested against ne- groes being permitted to travel in the same car, and later sued the Alabama & Vicksburg Railway Company for dam- ages. She obtained judgments against the railway in the Circuit Court of War- ren County, Miss., in the sum of $25,000. The case was appealed to the State Su- preme Court, which held that the com- pany “Jim Crow” law, to provide separate accom- modations for the races within the State of Mississippi, and affirmed the judg- ment of the lower court. The record is now being prepared for transmission on a writ of error to the United States Su- preme Court. The “separate coach acts” were not enacted without opposition ‘from the whites in the South. It was not difficult to foresee that they would be productive of much litigation, and it was feared that they would increase /race antagonism. Thus, when the mea- was presumed, under the sure was under consideration in Ken- _tucky, Gen. Cassius Marcellus Clay op- posed it in an address to both houses of |the Legislature. A negro oratcr from | Lexington, who had lost a leg while serving the Confederacy, moved his au- | dience to tears, but the bill was passed ‘as a strict party measure. Most of the levils predicted followed this wave of legislation throughout the South, the least bejng that the coaches set apart | for negroes were and are older, shab- bier, and dirtier than those reserved for whites at the same tariff. | Registration figures of our universi- ‘ties are interesting, among other rea- _sons, for showing the proportion of stu- | dents in what used to be the “main tent,” |namely, the undergraduate department of the College of Arts and Sciences. As tabulated in Science, these statistics put Columbia at the head, wherever grand totals are concerned. That institution has a registration of 9,000, followed by California with 6,500, Chicago with 6,400, Harvard with 5,700, and Michi- gan with 5,600. It also has the largest a compromise was adopted, the princi-| gain over last year, the figures being ple, but “not all of the practice, being /1,100 for Columbia, 700 for California,

Page 5

Jan. 9, 1913] The Nation 500 for Minnesota, and so on. But when! we leave out the Summer School, the)! order is radically changed. Then it is Indiana that has the largest gain, with 1,000 students, followed by Chicago with 700, California with 700, and Columbia with 500. The same omission affects the totals of registration by reducing Co- lumbia to 6,000, although this still leaves her at the head of the list, and gives Michigan second place with 4,900, Harvard third with 4,800, California fourth with 4,700, and Cornell fifth with 4,600. The college undergraduates are far below these impressive numbers. Harvard leads in this respect with 2,300 men and 500 women, counting Radcliffe, and is followed in order by Indiana, with 1,400 men and 900 women; Cali- fornia, with 900 men and 1,400 women; Michigan, with 1,550 men and 700 wo- men, and Chicago, with 900 men and 700 women. Columbia is ninth, with 800 men and 600 women, but is closely press- ed by Princeton, with its 1,400 men. These figures reveal the overshadowing numerical prominence of professional or summer schools, or both, at the present- day American university. One business that is seriously threat- ened by the march of civilization is that of the musical comedy librettist. His field is rapidly shrinking as the back- ward nations of Asia and southeastern Europe succumb to the spirit of pro- gress. Gilbert and Sullivan would have found it very difficult to write the “Mikado” after Port Arthur and Muk- den. Constitutional China is spoiled for the purposes of comic opera. Now the Balkan peninsula, so fertile in musical- comedy kingdoms and principalitics, has become impossible. The authors of “The Chocolate Soldier” were just in time. There is no trouble, of course, in inventing mythical Balkan countries with names ending in “ia,” but Balkan countries must be inhabited by Balkan peasants, and you cannot saddle a pony ballet, a couple of waltz tunes, and a comedian with a papier-maché nose painted green, on the men who fought at Lule Burgas and Monastir. Most of the small islands of the world, Zanzibar, Sulu, and the East Indian archipelago have already been exploited. Perhaps there is still a “show” or two in Mo- rocco. But after that the librettist will have to go either to the North Pole or any one of its members, and suspension back to Montmartre. Assuming that the dissensions which | have fallen upon the Unionist party in Great Britain have been exaggerated in the newspapers, the presence of a very acute crisis cannot be explained away. The most puzzling feature of the situa- tion is the suddenness with which the bye-elections. Rumors of dissension in the Ministerial caught in a minority many quarters as an omen Home Rule, Disestablishment, franchise legislation, three abreast, with- out coming to grief? heterogeneous united Conserva- counting the days to a general election That was the picture frequently drawn in the press. To-day the Conservative leader is in the unhappy position of ad- vocating a cause that has been emphat- ically repudiated by the great mass of his party, and the Liberals seem com- long enough to put their legislative pro- gramme into law over t House of Lords. It is one of our patriotic the nation from which dependence is essentially and un hange- How, then, are we for the very enterprising action an engine-driver for running past sig- Perhaps the explanation is sim- that such a procedure is in line with another absurdity with which we credit our British cousins, that, namely, enlightened land, an engineer who runs past signals is not an individual to be lightly treated. For one thing, his act, if by good luck it does not result in an passengers at their destination on time or a little better than on time. regarded as a fine achievement by his superiors, who insist that the travelling public also is pleased by it. is his union to be taken into account. It ‘stand for” unfair treatment of treatment. The consequence of this set of conditions is our record-breaking ac- cident statistics. The Interstate Com- merce Commission is compelled to de- vote a large amount of time to investi- gating the causes of the numerous in- juries and deaths on certain of our rail- ways. Its recommendations will be awaited with interest, and are likely to receive greater support from the publi than either the roads or the unions seem to realize. Warin the Balkans can hardly have been waged in a more savage spirit than marked the recent struggle in Paris over the election of a “prince of poets” and a “prince of story-tellers.” The con- test, naturally, was wholly among the “jeunes.” That any writer who had “ar- rived” might carry off the honor, was not to be thought of. One impassioned orator was heard to exclaim: “It cannot be that you will inflict upon us the dis grace of an Academician prince.” Hap- pily, that shame was spared French let ters. No one had the hardihood to pro- pose Rostand. The princely honor was finally conferred upon Paul Fort He was the candidate of the left bank of the Seine, though the right bank did not fail to put forward a favorite. In fact, it Was a war, not merely of literary champions, but of the two banks of the river. The Seine was the line of cleav- age between ideas. The beaten right- bankers at once began to denounce M. Fort as an obscure decadent, who could by no possibility get himself accepted by the great public. To this the fiery dwellers on the left bank naturally re joined that those on the other side of the Seine were wholly insensitive to true literary merit, and cared for noth ing except commercialized art and suc cess at any price. Before the prince of story-tellers could be elected—the rival candidates were Messrs. Ryner and Duvernois—there Was many a passage at arms, physical as well as intelle tual. The peace of the city was serious- ly endangered. To crown all, the hon- esty of the electoral methods of the left bank was impeached by the right. One can imagine how the Boulevard Saint Miche! boiled at this. There is a ballad of Coppée’s—who, of course, is now hope lessly antiquated to the young on both banks—of which the refrain used to b popular

Page 6

( * a -_ THE SHORT WAY OUT. President Taft's declaration that he is ready and willing to arbitrate the Pan- i dispute with Great Britain has with instant response, both there and here It must be peculiarly grati- fying to Englishmen, because the whole drift of Sir Edward Grey's note of pro- test was a request for arbitration. The British Government did not propose to stand stiffly on what it believed to be its rights, but was prepared to leave all the matters in question to the decision of ompetent and impartial arbitrators. Mr. Taft evidently hopes that this may not be necessary. He speaks of the possibil- ity of the controversy being settled by diplomatic negotiations. But they are inevitably slow, and it is hardly to be expected that an adjustment in that way can be reached in the remainder of Pres ident Taft's term. In view of this fact he sald squarely that, so far as he is concerned, he should not hesitate to agree to arbitration, whether we won or lost This is a manly clinging to the principle which he has stoutly advocat- ed, and fully deserves the applause be- stowed upon it. That the promise may not be brought to the test of perform- ance does not lessen its value. If Presi- dent Taft is not called upon to carry out his pledge, President Wilson will have the same difficulty to confront, and will be helped in meeting it by the large ut terance of his predecessor There is one place, however, where Mr. Taft's words in behalf of standing up to our national agreements, even if to our own hurt, find no echo. That place Is Congress. Enough Senators have been interviewed and have given their opinions to make it plain—what was, ndeed, made plain in the debates at the time the Canal Bill was passed—that two-thirds of the Senate could not be got for a treaty providing for arbitrat- ing the question of canal tolls. The opponents rest the thing on brute pow er They do not deny that the matter involves the interpretation of a treaty, and that this nation has solemnly bound itself to submit such questions to arbi- tration. As one Senator bluntly puts it, the same vote that tore up the Hay Pauncefote treaty can tear up the arbi- tration treaty. Of course, a show of eason is attempted. It is said that the exemption of our coastwise vessels from tolls at Panama is purely a “do- which this country estic question,” The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2480 could never submit to arbitration. It is added, with great innocence, that we should be certain to lose our case if it went before an arbitration tribunal, which is naturally a powerful argument against letting it go there. These not very exalted outgivings by Senators are yet accompanied by state- ments which indicate a way of escape. Some of the most extreme opponents of arbitrating the tolls dispute say that, rather than be forced to take up such a proposal, they should prefer to repeal the one clause in the Canal Bill that has made all the trouble. There seems, in fact, to be a growing opinion in both Houses that the original exemption of our coastwise trade was a mistake. This is admitted not merely because it has precipitated a needless and unpleasant international controversy and has given us a bad name abroad. In addition, it is felt that the favor shown to coasting ships was really favor shown to a mo- In that trade, there can be, under our laws, no competition by for- nopoly. eigners. It is shut up as a preserve for certain classes of our own citizens. And now, as many Congressmen seem to be discovering for the first time with mor- tification, it is proposed to grant a sub- sidy where we have already conferred a monopoly. For there cannot be a par- ticle of doubt that the exempting ‘of coastwise vessels from tolls is exactly the same thing, in effect, as handing to them that amount of money from the Treasury of the United States. The at- tempt was at first made to extend this form of subsidy to our ships engaged in| the foreign trade, if they used the Pan- But that was found to be too “raw.” It was both too plainly a violation of the treaty and too obviously a voting of public money to private ship- owners. So that part of the bill was dropped; but the subvention to coast- ama Canal. wise vessels was retained. For Congress to repeal this now, be- fore it has gone or can go into effect, would be the shortest way out of the muddle. Why should it not be done? The time seems favorable to strike for such a measure. Several influential Congressmen are convinced that the leg- islation was a blunder from the start. It was merely a pampering of an al- ready pampered monopoly. It was a form of ship-subsidy certain to whet the appgtite for more. Moreover, for a petty cause, it has embroiled us with the nation that is most friendly to us in all the world, and that is our best cus- tomer. What better course than frankly to admit the error in the framing of the law, and to save a deal of time and trou- ble by taking it out? That there are ‘any really thoroughgoing champions of the exemption clause, outside of those pecuniarily interested, no evidence is adduced to show. There was, to be sure, an early blustering cry about an Amer- ican Canal being for Americans, but that has mostly died out. It was prompt- ly abandoned, as respects ships in the foreign trade, and it would be a small step to abandon it also in regard to coastwise vessels. We hope to see a movement speedily begun in Congress to repeal the clause of the Canal Bill which now so obviously lies in the na- tion’s path as a rock of offence and stone of stumbling. THE EMANCIPATION JUBILEE. The celebrations last week of the fif- tieth anniversary of the final Emanci- pation Proclamation have recalled to many survivors of the events of 1863 the thrill with which the nation receiv- ed that immortal document. The ear- lier September proclamation had estab- lished the fact that slavery was in its death-throes; no one could fail to see that the end could not be deferred much longer. But, nevertheless, the race about to be freed, and those once despis- ed reformers and agitators to whom the chief credit for this act of national jus- tice must be ascribed, waited as with bated breath for the consummation of their hopes. Few who were not a part of the abolition movement can, we sup- pose, appreciate to-day all that it meant. But it is gratifying to know that there has been a widespread celebration of the semi-centennial; for a nation which could be dead to so momentous an event as the at ve of a race, would be sus- ' pected of not knowing the grand things of its owh history. Yet it is not upon the events of 1863 that we would dwell to-day. Many have seen the hand of fate in all the defeats prior to the Emancipation Proclama- tion, believing that the canker at the nation’s heart would not have been cut out had the North had an easy march to Richmond. Perhaps all that terrible blood-letting in 1861 and 1862 was neces- sary as a means of convincing Lincoln ee ere

Page 7

Jan. 9, 1913] and his Cabinet that the slaves must be set free as a blow at the Confederacy and in order that they might be used as troops of the North. But neither that nor the bloodshed that followed caused the nation to think very seriously about the future of the beneficiaries of the Emancipation Proclamation. Carl Schurz wrote in the latter years of his life that the problem confronting the Johnson Government in 1865-66 was one of which no complete solution was possible. And the fact is that, aside from the spasmodic efforts of the Washington authorities as evidenced by the Freedman’s Aid move- ment and of the several carpet-bag State governments, the freed men and women were chiefly left to shift for themselves. They were unlearned, often half naked, and all without property. Yet they have stumbled “up from slav- ery” in the most wonderful way, as each census shows—without national guid- ance, with almost insignificant Federal aid, and none from the States. They have fought their way onward against odds great enough to discourage any race. Their material welfare and progress, their contributions to the wealth of the nation, Mr. Washington and other leaders have dwelt upon times without number; these things would by themselves justify emancipation, did nothing else. Their contributions to the intellectual and spiritual life of the na- tion are less referred to. It was a Southern professor who declared a few years ago that Booker Washington and Dr. Du Bois had produced the two great- est books written in the South since the Civil War. Any college might be proud to have Prof. Kelly Miller on its facul- ty. The lyrics of the elevator boy, Paul Laurence Dunbar, are as much read as ever. Musicians everywhere admit their debt to the men and women of dark skin. The Philharmonic Orchestra last week played, in commemoration of the Proclamation, the New World Symphony of Dvorak, which owes much of its in- spiration to the songs of the colored people; and a stirring, brilliant rhap- sodic dance of the British negro com- poser, Coleridge-Taylor, whose prema- ture death kas been regarded in Eng- land as a national loss. In Will Marion Cook and J. Rosamund Johnson, of New York, two colored composers have been found whose promise is very great. In the field of painting, an American ne gro, W. O. Tanner, has won eminent honors, here and abroad. Only the other day a young boy, Richard Brown, aston- ished artists here and elsewhere by the skill of his untaught brush. Who can estimate what fifty years hence will be the contribution of this often peetic and ever musical people to the intellectual wealth of the nation? Long before the next half-century shall have passed the country will, we trust, have awakened to the resources it has in this still lowly race. As they have made the best soldiers in our reg- ular army, so the South may yet real- ize that, by kindness, by the abolition of lynching, peonage, aud the horrible chain-gangs, by reasonable wages, and by the inspiration of civic and political rewards, its negroes may be made into thoroughly efficient labor. Common sense alone will urge a different course from that of to-day in the fields and fac- tories where negro labor is abundant. In the North negroes will be valued as a bulwark against union-labor tyranny and labor anarchy, and as an asset of the Protestant Church. As they are en- couraged and helped forward and aided in freeing themselves from the condi- tions of life which make for inefficiency and immorality, our colored Americans will repay, even in a purely material way, those who aid them upward. Just as their gratitude for the Emancipation Proclamation is measured to-day not by the meetings they hold, but by their ma terial and intellectual advance, so the nation can best express its gratitude to Lincoln and his generation by taking hold of this so-called negro problem as a whole and hastening its solution in accordance with the dictates of democ- racy and of justice. THE NEW GOVERNOR. Gov. Sulzer, of New York, takes of- fice with a somewhat amusing byplay of being just “plain Bill,” but we do not think that this, or anything else in his past career, will prevent the people of the State from giving him fair play. He protests that he is the same man he always has been, and this may readily be believed. He has still at command those minor political arts which the judicious smile at ratler than condemn; his little affectations, his conscious poses, at Albany are only what he has long accustomed us to at Washington; and they are among those rather comic The Nation “devices of popularity Which, Burke said, “diffuse occasional gayety over the severe brow of moral freedom But by none of these things, nor even by his political antecedents, will the 1 Governor of New York be finally judged His mannerisms and his boastings all easily be passed by, provided that he shows real capacity and vigorous honesty, both personal and political administering the affairs of the Stat: No one will begrudge him, and ever) one will wish him, success His beginnings are plainly significant of good intentions, though neither in his inaugural address nor in his mes sage to the Legislature did he get mu beyond the region of large but vageu promises. But it would be prematur: to form a complete judgment from tl because Mr. Sulzer himself admits t need of being more specific in futur: messages, and implies that he shall b. It is well to preach economy, and to hold out the hope that by retrenchment the need of a direct tax may be avoided but somebody is bound to show what ar: the definite savings that can be effected What particular offices may be abolish ed, and what public appropriations can be cut down. So of many other recom mendations made by Gov. Sulzer. They are nearly all in general terms But ttey will have to be made precise, if they are not to add to the number of New Year's resolutions, made only to bi forgotten. And the incidental evils of a plan that sounds promising will also have to be fully considered by some on Thus Mr. Sulzer favors a scheme of wages boards, to fix the minimum rates in given industries, and to allow no one to work for less. On this subject Pro fessor Seager read a paper—generally favorable to the project—before the American Economic Association, in which ke admitted that a necessary part of this plan seems to be that the State would have to assume the support of those whom it forbids to work at less than the minimum wage. Has Gov. Su! zer ever thought of this? All that he has so far given us to go upon is evidence of his general attitude towards legislation and towards admin istrative work. As regards the former it is evident that he intends to favor policies that he thinks are “popular” and that in general are along the line of what has come to be called progressive legislation. In all this we do not ques

Page 8

25 The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2480 tion his sincerity, nor do we doubt that | the former to chase the latter with “the | to paper, it will be better for the years he will beable to accomplish something. cheap numerosity of a stage army,” and in which he has carried it in his heart. We are content to wait for the proof of strike at him with a tin sword, the two) But here again the youthful enthusiast the pudding in the eating. But in addi- thereafter to get together and “do busi- will demur. Is success incompatible tion to planning, there is always the dif-| ness” amicably. But this could impose with any except the highest motives? ficulty of execution. It is one thing to! upon nobody. If Gov. Sulzer is honestly Do all poets write purely for the joy of ! ae vis hanges in the law, and another to fight Tammany there must be real dierent : eet ef . y ‘ the writing, and without ever a thought to get the right men to carry out the’ weapons and real blood, and at the end 5 : ‘ of self-glory? Are there no mixed mo- law. The danger of a breakdown on the a real corpse. j , tives in the turning out of novels, even administrative side is one that ever be- sets a Governor, and it is evident that PATRONS FOR GENIUS. Mr. Sulzer is peculiarly exposed to it. The Independent recently printed a novels with a purpose? Why should no admixture of selfishness be allowed the ‘ambitious youth without a patron? | There was Horace himself, the man who made Mecenas famous. Did he write Proof of this is seen in hisremanning !etter from an aspiring youth who was of the State Civ | Service Commission. im search of a patron. None has yet On the general subject, he expressed in | 4PpPpeared, at least openly, and now the) | with ve f erity? e his message admirable sentiments. He 8ame magazine publishes a letter from |!th no eye for posterity Or ae 8 , ; acs ; , , , sng | Make assi ce 0 was for maintaining and extending the 42 older and wiser man who also was | » use of the generous assistance of law establishing the merit system: and | Once in quest of a Maecenas. Ten years | ‘© Father of Patrons all the more glad- he wished the Commission to coéper-|a&0, he writes, he had an idea for a|'¥ because it enabled him, as he sang, | with charming candor and superb self- |confidence, to build an enduring monu- the performance? That was a theory | Suggesting the plot or the treatment he|™ent to his name? Practically, it does had in mind. This, by the way, might | 2°t matter. One seeking a patron would have been sufficient to put him on his| naturally take care to put the best mo- ate freely with county and municipal | 8Teat romance. He knew it to be origi- authorities. That was promise; what is| nal. No story had been written even on paper; who are the men selected to give it concrete embodiment? Men ut- terly unknown to the reform. They have | guard. The extreme of the unfamiliar| tive foremost, if it were not the glori- no record except as regular party poli-|could hardly be much better than the /0US distinction of youth to be conscious ticlans, and no evidence is given, with| extreme of the familiar. But he was|°f no motives but the best. And pa- their appointment, that they have ever| wrapped up in his glorious dream. He| ‘trons have a way of scattering their fa- had any interest in civil-service re-|piously believed that God had granted|Vors that seems to take no account of form, or any comprehension of it. They him the theme he had prayed for. He | motive, and to be guided by no rule but may turn out to be better than any one| Was confident of his ability to handle | chance. now believes them to be; but it is plain it. All that he lacked was time, and | It would ordinarily be as idle as cruel that the Democratic spoilsmen do not|for that he begged, he says, in words | to ask the attention of a Macenas-seek- think so. ‘The latter are now chuckling not unlike those of the letter that has|er to the point of view of Macenas. over the new Commission as one that| brought his own struggle back to him.| Now and then a patron arives who is “will not need to be watched.” Now, our! What was the result? “I didn’t get the | apparently gifted with power to gaze point is that Gov. Sulzer might have help, and I am heartily glad that I did| upon the seeds of time, and say which named men whose appointment would not.” What an anti-climax this will eles them will grow, and which will not. everywhere have been recognized as to those who cannot look down upon it} Horace, for instance, turned out to be meaning the rigid upholding of the civil-| from the calm vantage-point of ten| very good fruit. But how was the Earl service laws. The Governor might have years later! How it will seem to them | of Chesterfield to know that the awk- followed up high professions by high se-| but one more illustration of that fear-| ward figure whom he had encouraged lections. And there was the more rea-| ful, yet seemingly inevitable, chilling of and who was now threatening ruin to his son for doing so in that the Civil Ser-| the noble flame that burns so brightly | fine carpets, as well as to his reputation vice Commission had been brought under | as one starts out to conquer the world! as an associate of the well-bred, was to suspicion and under fire during the past| That at twenty-five fhis correspondent ‘develop into the petted bear, if not the two years. A really intelligent and de-| should not have succeeded in finding a/ lion, of London society? Being a Mecenas termined civil-service reformer would, in| Mecenas is natural enough—only too | is very much like being a gold-hunter: it Gov. Sulzer’s place, have seen the neces-| natural, they will think; but at thirty- | is so easy to spend a fortune in hunt- sity of striking hard at the beginning, | five to be heartily glad that he didn't— | ing one. Thus the fallibility of the and of getting Commissioners whose |is not this treason to the spirit of| judgment of the patron combines with names would speak of knowledge of Youth? ‘the fallibility of the judgment of the what was needed, and of resolution to Superficially, it might seem so, but | patron-seeker in reference to himself to see that it was done. ithe correspondent himself has a further | make the path of the aspirant difficult Gov. Sulzer plainly desires it to be un-| word about it. The romance, he still | and lonely. His loneliness, too, is derstood that he is his own master, and | thinks, was a worthy theme. It was him- | usually increased by the conviction that independent of Tammany. But the facts self that was wanting. “I was not|/ no one was ever in his position before. vill speak louder even than his loud ready to write it,” he says. “I was striv- | The talent, as he believes, which has words about this. The story is current ing for self-glorification. I wanted time| been committed to him, he keeps in a that a kind of theatric encounter is to and ease in which to make people lion- | napkin, not from choice, but from ne- take place between Sulger and Murphy, ize me.” eNow, if the story ever comes | cessity.

Page 9

Jan. 9, 1913] The Nation SS Hig case is made worse by the appar- | ently unlimited supply of Mecenases for certain kinds of activities. The man who is curious about the habits of a hith- erto misunderstood earthworm; his fel- low who takes an equal interest in the proceedings of the in the winter of 1784; their associate who is fired with enthu- siasm for the bibliography of literary criticism in Polynesia prior to the ex- town meeting of Penobscot and plorations of Captain Cook—for these men there is a patron in almost any street. For them Institutions and Foun- dations are created, college chairs are fellowships and travelling scattered. But the man or woman with endowed, an unsung poem or an untold tale, a painting or a statue that exists only in the tude. loins of these draw no sympathy from Occasionally, one can get revenge on one’s own unappre imagination, must dream in soli- The unlit lamp and the ungirt the more fortunate. ciative generation by leaving behind a treasure that posterity will place among the masterpieces, but this is at best a somewhat unsatisfactory method, ticularly since one can never be quite par- sure what posterity will do. And even this does not meet the problem of the word that waits forever for the moment of leisure in which alone it may be made worthy to be uttered. “A CERTAIN WITTY FRENCHMAN.” “A certain witty Frenchman, on one occasion, said,” etc. Not that he always said the same thing at this one supreme moment. But we don’t expect consis- tency from any one so clever as he. It is enough that we feel gratitude for all the poor jokes which, recounted in his name, have somehow been spared the fate of falling flat. He is in a class with “a London specialist,” flitting nameless through the press, at whose prescription bachelors cheerfully try to raise hair and young women to grow thin. With most people the reputations of both men are firmly established, and it is only a question of deciding wheth- er the Frenchman was wittier than the London specialist scientific. The tenses of the verb applied to them are important. For the one thing known about our two benefactors is that the is Londoner still lives, while the French- The is invariably quoted as saying, the lat- man belongs to the past. former ter as having said. There's the rub for the modernists, who are just now hav- ing things much their way—to see their witticisms passed by for those of a dead What they can get from the situation comes from sometimes recognizing their own Frenchman! consolation words in those said to have issued from lips long sealed. But this is not enough. The modern- ists have lately broadened the question. They ask, Is the humor of bygone days really as good as that of Broadway in year of grace? Are the “snappy” as those of a certain (not nameless) pair Far be it from us to give an answer on compulsion, for this present jokes in “The Rivals” as of living comedians? it is perfectly evident what one is ex- pected to reply. But in a narrower form we have been attracted to the discussion by a volume come to our notice from the middle of the eighteenth century, entitled ““The Oxford Sausage, or Select Poetical Pieces, Written by the Most Celebrated Wits of the Oxford.” It is perhaps possible to make some comparison of the college humor of a century and a half ago with that of to-day. As might be expected, aca- demic fun still clings to some of the University of old lines. Corresponding to certain well- known Harvard tributes to John the Orangeman is the following ode to one Tyrrell, a famous Oxford cook: How I congratulate fair Isis, That such the taste for mutton pies is! Hail glorious Ben! whose genius high First plann’d a genuine mutton pie! Born to combine with matchless taste The charms of pepper and of paste! Was but the motion of my pen Quick as thy rolling-pin, O Ben! O, could my thoughts thy pastry ape, And slide, like yielding dough, to shape; My genius, like thy oven glow, My numbers, like thy gravy flow; Or, in the twinkling of an eye, I cook an ode, as you a pie, etc. And one is reminded also of Milton's) mock seriousness in memory of Hobson, the Cambridge postman. Quite as profane as the Yale student's caricature of Wordsworth’s reverence for the commonplace, in the form of “Meditations of a Banana-Peel on Being is the Ox- ford man’s fling at Gray's “Elegy”: Run Over by a Dump Cart,” The curfew tolls the Hour of closing Gates, With jarring Sound the Porter turns the Key Then in his dreary Mansion slumb’ring waits, And slowly, sternly quits it—tho’ for me. “Integer vite” proves, at the hands of 29 another Oxonian, to be “the man who not a farthing owes.” Most of the se do with the reading to which a boy in those days would nat- Pope, Swift, Young, lections have to attracted Thomson, though all of the life which came under his eye was perfectly good urally be the liveryman, the wigmaker, the And not infrequently he praised his ale or to- bacco, while ostensibly imitating a dig- grist tavern-keeper, and the bar-maid. nified poet. The one point of difference between college humor then and now, at least to judge by this volume, is that to-day it is much nearer to the humor of the “The Oxford Sausage” contains an occasional to London or to European politics, but in the main reflects university life. Every one knows the changes which have been world at large. reference made since then, and especially how has grown to the We recall the modest admonition of a dean of one American institution that the stories in the college paper would greatly profit if close the college world without its walls. they employed as heroes students who at least spent their nights in the col- lege Yet, may desire, it appears inevitable, under the present circumstances, that students should take on color from the world at large, and particularly that they should adjust their jokes to those of the stage and the popular periodicals. Save for the few lingering forms of literary bur- lesque, already described, college humor be said to-day to differ from the variety only in the fresh- town. whatever professors may professional ness, the delightful inconsequence, which youth can normally muster. Yet the modernists must wait for an answer to their question whether college fun at present is not superior to what it wasa century or two ago. One point, at least, we are willing to concede—namely, that the “witty Frenchman” was not all that he has been cracked up to be. THE AMERICAN HISTORICAL SOCIATION. AS- Provipence, R. I, December 31, 1912. The meeting of the American Histort- cal Association at Boston, December 27- 31, promised from the start exception- al interest in the fact that the president of the Association was Theodore Rooso- velt. Beyond the reminder, however, still as necessary as it is commonplace, that literary attractiveness is not in- compatible with scholarly worth, and

Page 10

3O that a book velt’s address offered noth the historian; ontribution to mistaking the the repre accorded mainly it ay never pl d society sidency ol will cholars rather reserve than for political The of papers and confer- nted progratinie hich unusual ar exhibited an preset if distinguished names, antage tle activities of Archives Boston with manifold rhe Public organized at the ago, ol to ad the Association { ommission, fourteen years and meeting s on the archiv two-thirds of port begun to inter re States to credit, has elf year, for example, the con its one with other archival ern it This of archivists paid particular at ta. ference tention to a proposed manual of archival administration, and to the effort, unfor- tunately not yet in a very forward state, for the national archives Dr Ames, service, of by for a building Herman V. retires from at Washington after ten years of the Commission, and is Victor H. Paltsits The Historical Manuscripts Commission, hich the chairman- ship of Worthington C. Ford, promises, edition of the William Vans the the chairmanship ucceeded continues under among other things, an private correspondence of to John France in ad- Adams. programme of of the section present condi- their respec- Murray, Minister ministration of of the papers, several dealt the tion of historical study tive flelds, or pointed out new paths still awaiting the investigator. Oriental and direco-Roman history, the Middle Ages, modern American history 1815 to 1860, were all surveyed in result- Instead usual formal meetings with in commerce, from with a doctoral Prof as this comprehensive way, ing wealth of suggestions for and special studies frankly of the of Dodd, of Prof of dissertations Edwin F fiction a Gay characterized had passed of American the Uni Ulrich B. Michigan, thor good deal W hat in history com fleld LD and instruction the Willlam CLicago, University lor In his Prof versity of Phillips, of the the of side, though differing views regarding the economic profitable ness of that Professor Dodd's paper, bristling with suggestions be neverthe illustration the encouraged minimize the merce tory, emphasized need of a more ee onomik their ough study slavery on its sharply in Inatitution work yet to done, Was striking me dulou aly of less a ten dency, rather in quarters, to point academik« almost to the lition movement and the moral oppost- of the North to and to the history of certain vanishing abo slavery, the tion write anti-slavery ' ‘The Nation able if it is to movement primarily in terms of eco- nomic development. Prof. T. C. Smith, of Williams, while sweepingly repudiat- that of Von very properly questioned the con- temporary prominence of the plantation system as a factor in national politics; and Prof. Allen Johnson, of Yale, wise- ly deprecated the sectional treatment of American history in any period. Con- regarded as a of learn- importance in a like the United States, found no champion in the discussion. A largely attended section on military his- tory, marked in- crease of interest in this neglected field; and a forthcoming report on the study of military history in colleges and uni- with keen ex- ing such a treatment as Holst, stitutional history, once and ing, and obviously of serious dignified branch country however, evidenced a versities will be awaited pectations. An otherwise informing paper on “Re- ligious Forces in the American Revolu- by Prof. C. H. Van Tyne, of the University of Michigan, developed a curious inaccuracy in the use of terms; the author devoting the larger part of his attention to the politica! influence of the New England clergy, and reach- ing the subject of religion only at the latter portion of his paper, where the of Samuel Adams and others Catholicism, and of various dissenting sects to episcopacy, was in- terestingly touched upon. Prof. George L. Burr, of Cornell, on the other hand, offered a brilliant and all-too-brief dis- cussion of the religious and theologital conception of the state in the Middle Ages, and the position of Lutheranism in relation to it. Of another sort was the concise and straightforward paper by Henry P. Biggar, of London, on “The New Columbus,” traversing the recent hostile criticisms of Vignaud, and up- holding the older view that the discov- ery of America was accidental, and that the Indies were the region of which Co- lumbus was really in search. Charles Francis Adams, with his usual incisive- ness and n.ore than his usual eloquence, pointed to the victory of the Constitu- ticn over the Guerriére as the birth of the United States as a world power. Tle Historical Bibliogra- phy developed and lively dis- cussion over the reviewing of histori- cal books. Prof. Carl Becker, of the University of Kansas, who opened the had no difficulty in demon- strating the shortcomings of much which to-day, especially in daily news- papers, passes for book reviewing, but his solution of the problem hardly matched the keenness of his criticism. What Professor Becker desired, appar- ently, was distinct kinds of re- views: the of the utmost brevity, restricted entirely to biblio- graphical specification; the other a more or less elaborate essay which should be, not merely an appraisal of tion,” opposition to Roman on a section novel juestion, two one almost | Vol. 96, No. 2480 the book, but a critical contribution to the subject. He failed to take any satisfactory account of the fact that, while reviews of the first class would undoubtedly meet the needs of bibli- ographers and specialists, and those of the second must be as rare as great lit- itself, the needs of an intelli- gent public, joined to practical condi- tions of space and proportion in every periodical, create a legitimate demand for reviews which, in modest compass, shall nevertheless be both critical and informing. That there is abundant need for reform in this direction every edi- knows, but it was not with this phase of the matter that Professor Beck- er and most of those, nearly all of them reviewers, who discussed his entertain- ing paper appeared to be chiefly con- cerned. The New England History Teachers’ Association, which held its semi-annual meeting in connection with the Ameri- can Historical Association, offered a contribution of special significance to teachers. A committee, the chairman of which was Prof. John O. Sumner, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technol- ogy, undertook the task of showing the kind of equipment which the study and teaching of history and economics in secondary schools requires, by fitting up at Simmons College a series of model classrooms. Separate rooms for ancient, European, American, and economic his- tory, a library, map, and study room, and a history room for rural schools, were furnished with carefully selected maps, charts, pictures, casts, and other illustrative material, besides a liberal provision of books. An informal report by Professor Sumner (the full report will appear later), embodying the re- turns from a questionnaire, showed on the whole encouraging gain in equip- ment in the secondary schools of New England, notwithstanding that in the majority of schools no adequate provi- sion for teaching history is yet made. The reports submitted at the busi- ness meeting indicated that, while the membership exceeds 2,800, the financial resources of the Association do not at present justify the assumption of any new undertakings. Encouragement is to be found, however, in the fact that the History Teachers’ Magazine, taken over by the Association a year ago, promises shortly to be self-supporting; and the series of prize essays, separate- ly issued, bids fair to pay for itself. The Justin Winsor prize was awarded to Dr. A. C. Cole for an essay on “The Whig Party in the South.” A committee on the preparation of teachers of history in schools, headed by Prof. Dana C. Munro, of the University of Wisconsin, will shortly report in print. The meet- ing of 1913 is to be held at Columbia and Charleston, 8S. C., with Prof. Wil- liam A. Dunning, of Columbia Univer- sity, as president; and the meeting- erature tor

Page 11

Jan. 9, 1913] —— The Nation places for 1914 and 1915 have also been decided upon, the former at Chicago, and the latter, in the summer, at San Francisco in connection with the Pana- ma-Pacifie Exposition. WILLIAM MACDONALD. THE PHILOLOGISTS AND ARCH~2- OLOGISTS AT WASHINGTON. GRANVILLE, O., January 4. The annual sessions of the American | Philological Association and the Arche- ological Institute of America were held in the rooms of the new building of the National Museum, in Washington, De- cember 26-31. The weather was plea-| | Profs. Frank F. Abbott and Carl D. Buck sant with the exception of one rainy day, the usual forms of social recogni- | tion were extended to members of the several organizations, and the authori- ties of the Library of Congress placed on exhibition for the occasion a selec- tion from its facsimiles of ancient and mediw#val manuscripts. Three long ses- sions each day, however, left compara- tively little time for outside attractions. | As usual, the main feature of the first evening meeting was the address of the retiring president of the Philological Association. Prof. Thomas D. Goodell, president for the past year, took for his subject “An Athenian Critic of Life,” | and gave to his hearers a very scholar- ly and effective appreciation of Sopho- cles. Prof. William Gardner Hale, whose active interest in effecting a readjust- ment of linguistic terminology is well known, presented a scheme for the clas- sification of sentences and clauses. The current classification as declarative, in- terrogative, imperative,’ and exclama- tory, he assailed as not resting upon any one consistent basis of division, and for various other defects. In its place he would put a three-fold division, based on the fact that each sentence or clause either tells something, asks something, or assumes something. The terms de- clarative and interrogative would there- fore be retained from the present classi- fication, and the term assumptive added. Zach one of the three, without losing its basic character, may become exclam- atory under pressure of strong feeling. The whole matter of proposed changes in grammatical terminology will come formally before the Philological Associ- ation next year in a report from a joint committee of this Association, the Mod- ern Language Association, and the Na- tional Educational Association. The main purpose of the movement is to pro- cure a uniformity of grammatical term- inology for the various languages taught in our schools and colleges, but it is not unlikely that the fundamental de- sivability of such uniformity will be strongly assailed when the report cocs up for action. The attendance of members of the Philological Association was less than) | whe average, New England sharing with the Middle West and the South in re- | sponsibility for the shortage. The ques-' ; tion of a meeting place for next year | was left with the executive committee, |with the suggestion that a joint meet- ing with the Modern Language Associa- tion would be desirable, if suitable ar- rangements could be made. This does. not indicate the intention to break away permanently from connection with the; Archeological Institute, but it was held that there might be gain in the occa- sional cultivation of other affinities, and | perhaps in occasional meetings alone. Prof. Harold North Fowler was elected president for the coming year, with vice-presidents. Prof. Frank Gardner Moore, of Columbia University, was con- tinued as secretary. Washington is naturally favorable to a successful meeting of the Archeologi- cal Institute, and the session just closed is regarded as the most satisfactory in the history of the organization. The re- port of the president, Prof. Francis W. Kelsey, of the University of Michigan, gives a most inspiring sketch of the growth of the Institute since 1902, the date of certain changes in methods of administration in the interest of a more effective forward movement. Since that date the regular income has more than doubled, and the membership has risen from a little above one thousand to near- ly three thousand. President Kelsey's five years of service have been marked by unbounded energy and enthusiasm, and in laying down the office he ex- presses the belief that the Institute “has only begun to realize the possibilities of its twofold mission, the advancement of knowledge in a most important field of human achievement and the wide dissemination of the highest ideals of art and learning.” Among the recom- mendations of his report to the Council were the formation of a Committee on Egyptian Archeology, coérdinate with the existing Committee on Mediaeval and Renaissance Studies, the investigation of the possibility of procuring funds for the establishment of an American School in Peking, and the formation of a Committee on Museums, consisting of experts who will hold themselves in readiness to render assistance to affill- ated societies in this part of their work. | The Council took favorable action on all these suggestions. On the last day of the year the ab- sorption of the School of Classical Stud- ies in Rome with the American Acad- emy became complete, and thus the school passed finally out of its subordi- nate relation to the Institute. It is con- fidently expected that the movement to procure endowment for the School in Jerusalem will make such progress dur- ing the current year as to relieve the budget of the Institute of further ex- pense except for the fellowship which 31 it provides. A similar hope is enter- tained for the school in Santa Fé. The interesting fact was brought out that the representatives of the Institute in Santa Fé have been repeatedly appealed to for assisiance in bringing the archi- tecture of the city into harmony with its historical traditions and in recasting the naming of the streets to the same end. Possibly the most important item of all in the work of the past year is the finding of a long bilingual inscription in the Lydian and Aramaic languages. As the accumulation of Lydian inscriptions now in hand is large, the importance of this key will readily be realized, espe cially when we consider the tradition of the Lydian origin of the Etruscans During the past year the demand came to the Institute for several series of “Extension Courses” of lectures on archeological subjects, and the success of these courses was so great that ten similar courses have already been ar ranged for the coming year, lascing from one to three weeks cach. his movement, beginning in Colorado Springs and confined to the West, so far, is of course in addition to the rev ular system of lectures provided by the Institute under the direction of the gen eral secretary, Dr. Mitchell Carroll, ot Washington, and is likely to be of great service in strengthening the local af filiated societies and interesting a wider circle in the work. The presidency of the Institute was filled by the unanimous choice of Dr Harry L. Wilson, of the Johns Hopkins University, who, as vice-president, has had charge during the past year of the work of excavation and exploration. W. H. Jonnson THE SOCIETY OF BIBLICAL LITER ATURE WASHINGTON, December 30, 1912 The meeting of the Society this year (December 27 and 28) in conjunction with the Archeological Institute of America and the American Philological Association had the effect of bringing a larger number of its members to the sessions than usual. The social inter- course with numbers of colleagues in other flelds at afternoon teas and eve- ning receptions was also a pleasant fea- ture, the nature of which, as an offset to the specializing tendency of modern scholarship, is not to be underestimat- ed. On the other hand, there are some who feel that the distinctive and in time character of the scientific sessions is unfavorably affected by the somewhat restless spirit that accompanies large and promiscuous gatherings. Perhaps as a compromise, a combination of kin- dred stientific bodies should be planned at certain intervals, but not as an an- nual occurrence. The feecure of the opening session is

Page 12

The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2480 32 always the president's address, which this year, given by Prof. L. B. Paton, of Hartford Theological Seminary, proved to be particularly valuable and sugges- Professor Paton chose as his sub- ject “Israel's Conquest of Canaan.” Be- ginning with an analysis of the two ac- counts of the conquest, one in the Book of Joshua and the other in the Book of Judges, which cannot be reconciled with each other by any sound scholarly meth- od, he passed on to a consideration of the evidence from outside, chiefly Egyp- tian, sources for the of He- brew tribes in Palestine, which parallels the apparent contradictions in the Bibli- cal sources. Some of this evidence points to the conquest of tribes forming part of the later Hebrew federation dur- the Eighteenth Egyptian Dynasty, other phases of the evidence lead Nineteenth Dynasty. The solu- on proposed by Professor Paton, with a due consideration of the entire ma- terial, was to assume two conquests, an tive presence ing \ hile is to the earlier and incomplete one by the tribes grouped around the name of Leah as of the wives of the traditional Ja- and a later supplementary one in one cob, which the Rachel tribes form the chief factors The former, recounted in Joshua, he would place in the Ejigh- teenth Egyptian Dynasty, the latter, de- Judges, in the Nineteenth l'ynasty. This bare outline cannot do justice to the scholarly polish and charm of Professor Paton'’s presentation of one of the most difficult, though also one of the most fascinating, problems of an- clent Hebrew history. Prof. Paul Haupt’s contribution this session was on the visions of the Prophet Zachariah, which he interpret- ed as referring to internal dissensions in the Persian Empire during the reign of Darius I (522-486 n. c.), which it was the Jews lead to the overthrow of the Empire and the tri- umph of the Jerusalem priesthood over that of the rival sect, with its religious centre in Samaria. seribed in at hoped by would An incisive investigation of the al- leged medical language of the Gospel of Luke and Acts was contributed by Prof. Henry J. Cadbury, of Haverford College. Ever since the days of Hobart, an American New Testament scholar who died in 1830, the thesis has been maintained that the medical terms in Luke and Acts confirm the tradition that the books were written by a physician Professor Cadbury took up a detailed study of the language of these books, with the result that the so-called medical terms are neither such as are peculiar to distinctly medical writings nor such as a layman could not be ex- pected to know. Applying the same test to other writers, such as, ¢. @., Lucian, who we know was not a physti- clan, he found by statistical word stud- ies that Lucian’s Dialogues and Essays might have been written by a physician. two The conclusion reached, therefore, was | that the long-accepted thesis was un- sound. The rejection of it does not! prove that Luke was not a physician or that he is not the author of these works, but merely that the language is of no avail in settling the two questions. Prof. Morris Jastrow, of the Univer- sity of Pennsylvania, presented the out- lines of a study of the thirteenth and fourteenth chapters of Leviticus, which form a little group by themselves, detail- ing (a) the symptoms of various skin diseases, as well as spots in garments, stuffs, or houses, and (b) the purifica- tion ritual in connection with those phenomena. He showed that the start- ing-point was a little Torah, or a series of priestly decisions regarding the man- ner of treating one supposed to be af- flicted with leprosy, and what he was to do in case he was healed. This “stock” of the two chapters antedates a temple or- ganization, as is shown, first, by the fact that the purification ritual takes place outside of the camp, where the suspect is obliged to dwell, and, secondly, by the circumstance that in this earliest form of the ritual the cleansing from disease (placed on a level with sin) is accomplished by the primitive method of transferring the disease to a bird, just as the scapegoat carries the sins of man with him into the wilderness. The elaboration of this little Torah into the detailed analysis of various skin diseases, and the attachment of an elab. orate temple ritual for purposes of puri- fication, were the work of many hands and many generations—the result of successive attempts to distinguish on the one hand and to amplify on the other. At the second session, Prof. B. W. Ba- con, of Yale University, gave a conclu- sive demonstration that what has hith- erto been held a prologue to the Gospel | of John in the earliest codex of the Latin | version of the New Testament was in reality a subscript to the Apocalypse, ascribed to John. The formula formins the epilogue was written between the Apocalypse and the Gospel, and by a/| careless scribe was attached to John in- stead of being regarded as the conclu- sion of the Apocalypse. The practical | agreement of this epilogue with one} found in an Ethiopic version of the Apocalypse made the demonstration complete. Prof. M. G. Kyle, of Xenia | Theological Seminary, laid before the Society the evidence from excavations conducted by Flinders Petrie at Heli- opolis in the spring of 1912, at which | Professor Kyle assisted, to show that this most ancient capital of the Egyp- tian kingdom contained traces of Hyksos occupation of the same charac- ter as the Hyksos settlement at Hres— the modern Tell-el-Yehudijeh—only a few miles from Heliopolis. This evi- dence comes from the character and | measurements of the wall traced at! ithat in its Heliopolis and from the stjle of the pottery. Several papers falling properly into the category of Biblical studies were read at the Oriental section of the Archeological Institute, which met with the Biblical Society on Saturday morn- ing. Mention should be made of an un- commogly convincing argument to show original form, Tatian’s “Diatesseron,” which is the earliest Har- mony of the Gospels, did not contain the genealogy of Jesus as given by Mat- thew and Luke. The two genealogies, therefore, represent later additions to the Gospels and refer to distinct sources, though both are based on Jewish ma- terial. Prof. George A. Barton, of Bryn Mawr College, was elected president of the Society of Biblical Literature for the en- suing year, M. J., JR. CENTRAL DIVISION OF THE MOD- ERN LANGUAGE ASSOCIATION. UrBana, Ill., December 30, 1912. About one hundred teachers, repre- senting sixteen Central, Western, and Southern States, attended the eigh- teenth annual meeting of the Central Division of the Modern Language Asso- ciation, held at Indianapolis, December 26-28. The Central Division was this year the guest of the State University of Indiana, of Purdue and De Pauw Universities, and of Wabash, Earlham, and Butler Colleges. Such a combina- tion made possible the entertainment of the Association on a generous scale without imposing an unreasonable bur- den upon the modern language faculties of the separate institutions. The local committee representing the various in- stitutions of higher learning in the State was assisted in its work by the modern-language faculties of the Indi- ana high schools; and the departmental meetings of Friday afternoon were, therefore, appropriately held in the rooms of the Shortridge High School. These departmental sessions, which have become an important feature of the annual meetings, are peculiar to the Central Division, the Eastern meeting never having set apart any time for the discussion of the pedagogical problems connected with modern languages. At the departmental gatherings this year, the members discussed such matters as “Philology versus Literature” and “The Use of Phonetics in the Teaching of German,” together with other topics of interest to Philologers who chase A panting syllable through time and space. The English section has undertaken to deal methodically with certain prob- lems connected with the teaching of that subject; it has appointed commit- tees to carry on an extended investiga- tion, the results of which have from

Page 13

; 4 Jan. 9, 1913) time to time been published. The com- mittee appointed two years ago to in- vestigate the labor and cost of composi- tion teaching presented its final report this year. The report showed, among other things, that English is the least expensive subject taught in the high school, the average annual cost of sup- plying a pupil with instruction in Eng- lish being only seven dollars, as com- pared with an average annual outlay of sixteen dollars the pupil for chemistry, and of twelve dollars for combined vo- cational subjects. This committee was continued for the purpose of investigat- ing the conditions of composition teach- ing in colleges. The chairman of the section present- ed a report of an investigation of the preparation of college teachers of Eng- lish. Fifty-four per cent. of those doc- tors of philosophy who answered the in- quiry sent to them believed a change in the training of graduate students for the teaching of undergraduates desira- ble. Of the college presidents who re- plied, 52 per cent. expressed a similar discontent with the present system. Both groups agreed, in a general way, that the graduate schools have over- stressed scientific research. They be- lieve that there should be more empha- sis upon composition, and proportionate- ly less upon linguistic training. As a result of these criticisms, a committee was appointed to investigate and formu- late on the constructive side some defi- nite suggestions for the improvement of graduate training of future teachers of freshman English. The Central Division meeting was in one respect unique in the history of the Association. The programme was actually finished by Saturday noon, and the final session was, consequently, omitted. Such alacrity was made possi- ble by the small amount of discussion that followed the various papers. This was due in part to the crowded condi- tion of the programme, and in part to the high degree of specialization of which the papers were the expression. One questions whether the future pro- gramme should not be arranged on a somewhat different plan. The alterna- tive would be to limit still further the number of papers presented to those certain to be provocative of discussion, leaving others to enlarge the list of those to be read only by title. Such a modification of the programme would be quite within the discretion of the secretary, and would almost certainly increase the interest of the meeting. The next meeting of the Central Di- vision will be held at Cincinnati. The officers elected for the ensuing year are Prof. T. A. Jenkins, of the University of Chicago (chairman), and Prof. C. B. Wilson, of the State University of lowa (secretary, reélected for four years). As members of the executive committee were elected Profs. F. G. Hubbard, of on executive tact points ment fe« tively |; not care The Nation the Kuersteiner, of the University ana, and G. O. University. A F. Indi Northwestern University of Wisconsin; of of Epwarp C Curme, BALDWIN Correspondence CABINET OFFICERS IN CONGRESS? To THE EDITOR THE NATION SIR Pres of In excellent comment on ident Taft's ficers should that this the time your suggestion that Cabinet you point d down.” to appear in Congress “has en ura of not be improper ih) of father out plan long be here, fron Judge Story for m« the many Perhaps it may remind readers of the Nation advocated to he real- after years during which my the last sec which ms of shortly to the your the measure at reasonable distance late within the began coming ization the on In sixties, writing Nation both dis« point war, he the elsewhere and olumns he every subject, in ussed and proposed nded as thorough as they we reform from of view, defe it with arguments re rational, and answered innumerable object brevity, and he bec political ors With fairness point As time that the change of advocated would be the cities and States tional Government, years with energetic to the attempt to leader in a reform convinced he beneficial the devoted his effort the must went on, ame machinery even more in than in na- and he last and passionate Massachusetts believed afford a tting The presented to the make which he and would cure for evils now surely come of the experiment in democracy great of Mas- many bes our collection his papers recently sachusetts Historical Society is a remark- able illustration of long, patient labor for a patriotic object with little hope or prospect of reward. “The Lesson of Pop- ular Government” collects the results of this labor in definite, tangible, readable form It may well be that my father exaggerat ed the advantages of the end he aimed at All reformers do. In his calmer moments he would have been the first to recognize this. No universal panacea can be found for the vast ills that necessarily beset an organization so huge, so complex, and 80 nervously sensitive as the self-government of one hundred millions. But my father had limitless confidence in the honesty and good sense of the mass of the people and he was convinced that the only thing needed to bring these qualities into effective action the perfecting of the gov- ernmental In other words, thought the cry that the best ling to take wrong, that the best careful machinery was he wil- all were kept out of which men are no part in politics was men premium and that least facili- point politics by a system set a dishonesty the change he tate and incompetence, urged would at He improvement would often out, what you justly observe, that all civil- ized Governments except our own bring direct that Govern- ef- and ke the would legis!ature into con- belleved of to do and further some in constitution our enable this than father us more nation he plan other me that of his almost any said to the credit My did 80 often who got ford’s long series of letters publishe d a rival company Brooks does not Administration

Page 14

34 \ CORRECTION I I I THE NATION In your review of “The Works of I " Delo (December 5, 1912) you redit the phrase better bread than could l ide of wheat to Sancho Panza Al- t! zh he does use the phrase in the six- ty-s nth chapter of Part II of “Don Qui xote” (published in 1615, not, as your re- jewer says, in 1600), yet the knight's niece gets the start of hi in the seventh chapter of Part I (1605) JOSEPH DE PEROTT. \ Ml I 27, 1912 NAPIER’'S BONES.” ro TH Epil rR « THE NATION Su Your editorial on “A Mathematical Centenary December 26, 1912) may make pertinent the following information: At iuction sale, last November, in London of the library of the late Dowager Lady Napier and Ettrick, “some interesting relics of the inventor of logarithms appeared Among them were the original wooden and metal numbering rods, called ‘Napler’s bones,” used by John Napier in his ‘Rab- dologiw#, seu Numerationis per Virgulas li- bri duo,’ in 1615, and forming the first attempt at a calculating machine. For these £121 was paid by Mr. Quaritch.” (Anti- quary, December, 1912, n. s., VIII, 441-2.) ROCKINGHAM B J ‘ AN ELASTIC CURRENCY To THe EpiITor or THe NATION: Sin: In your financial article of Decem- ber 12 you state the case for attributing the recent slump in stocks mainly to money market conditions i e., to the dearth of money at the critical moment of moving the crops If the point is well taken, what is this but another example of the mischief due to an inelastic cur- re y rhe Government persists in fail- ing to apply to the currency problem such a measure of financial capacity and effi clency as we see successfully applied in most European countries, and in every im- portant group of British Colonies We all know that the losses to the coun try tn the panic of 1907, due to the cur- rency chao vere simply incalculable, but how about the annual losses due to the J iu The rich men's panic” of 1907 left four bad years in ite wake—vears of hard work for everybody and thin profits for the most, and of heavy exports to pay foreign lebte and interest on foreign loans, while busines remained bad long after the re turn of trade activity in Europe, and in spite of rising merchandise prices At every slump in American stocks Fu rope buys, to unload later at higher prices The profite thus harvested by European in vestora must amount to many millions an nually—all paid for by exporting the pro- ducta of American soll, mines, and labor At the same time, the richer and glearer headed financiers at home gather in sound stock at ut prices These conditions leat favor tl bie men at the cost of t) u ral publ they tend to bulld up Mi Trust,” and yet Congress, instead f « the urgent dewand for a proper seas 1 ? ery The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2480 other commercial country, spends public money and wastes the valuable time of busy men in a futile “Money Trust inves- tigation.” F. R. WELLES. Paris, December 27, 1912 [It is going altogether too far to as- sume that, because money stringency oc- curs in the autumn crop-moving period under the present currency system, therefore the currency system is exclu-| sively responsible for it. The truth is that some such autumn stringency would presumably recur, even with | a scientific system of central reserve | and rediscount in operation. Our) reasons for thinking so are, in the first place, that autumn Is a season of mon- ey stringency in European countries as well as in our own, despite the central banks of those communities, and, in the next place, that the particular “harvest demand” is for paper money in iall denominations (a need which banknotes do not fill) and for “lawful money” to build up interior banks’ reserves at a time when their home loans are expand- ing. A scientific currency system would doubtless mitigate the stringency of an active autumn season; but would hard- ly remove it altogether. The panic of 1907 was not caused by a defective cur- rency system, and, granting the same financial practices and abuses as preced- ed it, the panic would not have been averted by an ideal currency system. What such a model banking system might have done is to have checked the reckless and mischievous practices of our most powerful financiers before it was too late, and to have prevented the bad effects of a currency-hoarding mania as the Bank of France is doing to- day.—Eb. NarTIon.] SHAKESPEARE AND ARISTOTLE. To THE EpiTorR oF THE NATION: In Shakespeare’s “Troilus and ’ in a speech by Hector, occur the (ii, 2, 165-7): Not much Unlike young men, whom Aristotle thought Undt to bear moral philosophy. For some time (cid. Holmes’s “The Au- thorship of Shakespeare” et al.), Baconians have pointed to these lines as evidential of Bacon’s authorship of the plays. They call attentfon to the fact that, in Bacon's “Ad- SIR Cressida,’ following lines vancement of Learning” (first printed in| 1605), Aristotle, as in “Troilus and Cres- sida” (first printed 1609), was misquoted, and in a similar manner. Bacon says, “Is not to be regarded men are no the opinion of Aristotle... wherein he saith that young fit auditors of moral philosophy?” (Aristo- tle that young men are unfit to study political philosophy. “Nichomachean Ethics,” | But the misquotation goes back to a date sume eighty years earlier than 1605. Eras- hie “Colloquia Familiaria,” in his address to the reader entitled “De Utili- Colloquierum” (Basil, 1526), says had sald 5.) in rics tate velut irrfpe ne in animos adolescentium quos recte scripsit Aristoteles inidoneos auditores Ethice Philosophie.” And again « few lines farther on he says: “Aristo- telis Ethice non est apta pueris.” In regard, then, to the lines in “Troilus and Erasmus, not Bacon, was responsible the misrepresentation of what Aristotle wrote. (“Troilus and Cres- though not published till 1609, was certainly acted much earlier, vid. Malone, Furnivall, Halliwell, et al.) DANIEL FORD. Cressida,” for s'da.” University of Minnesota, January 2. Literature MEMOIRS OF H. H. BANCROFT. Retrospection. By Hubert Howe Ban- croft. New York: The Bancroft Co. $2 net. Mr. Bancroft, now eighty years old, gives in this book his own story of his extraordinary and useful career. “I hardly know,” he says, “what first led me into collecting books. Perhaps it was because I was a crank.” Whether he was “a crank” or not, he served his age well, and his account, written in most informal style, descending some- times to slang, is absorbing. Born in Ohio of New England parents, he established himself in early manhood m the book-trade, at San Francisco. He prospered greatly, finding time from bus- iness to read, write, and collect. This work grew on his hands, and he pur- sued it for fifty years and more with diligence ever increasing. He amassed a library at last which is one of the wonders of our Western coast. It re- lates to the western half of our conti- nent from Central America to Alaska, and in respect to history is as nearly exhaustive as human energy can make it. Mr. Bancroft has worked unremit- tingly himself and employed copyists, translators, and investigators by the score, often scholars of a high rank. He has bought manuscripts, pamphlets, printed books, often whole libraries, in America and Europe. His agents have taken dictations in the huts of the Eski- mos and Aztecs, ransacked the old Spanish missions, set down the stories of pioneers, English, Spanish, Russian; explored government archives whenever there was a hint of material, and stop- ped at no outlay which would procure even a scrap likely to be of value. The mass of information has been intelll- gently connected and indexed, and care- fully prepared histories summarize and supplement where needful. The time was propitious for such a labor, the mo- ment when the Anglo-Saxon advance was displacing in the West what had gone before. The entire collection is now the property of the University of California. Mr. Bancroft interests us most when describing his library and its forma- tion, but he does much more. His

Page 15

Jan. 9, 1913] The Nation Retrospection goes through the whole of his long and wide experience of Ameri- car life, and indeed takes into view our history from the beginning. To a large extent his chapters are not retrospec- tive, but discussions of matters of pres- ent moment, and he does not withhold himself from prediction. In these excur- 8:ons, breezily and roughly set forth, our author lays himself open to crit- icism. His knowledge is comprehensive but not accurate. Witches were never burned in Massachusetts; no John Owen founded the community at New Har- mony on the Wabash; the pioneers of Kentucky were not allured by any land- scapes of blue grass, for, if we may trust good Indiana historians, blue grass was carried into Kentucky as an exotic by soldiers returning home from the cam- paign of Tippecanoe in 1811. But pass- ing over small errors, we find more seri- ous faults. Mr. Bancroft lays down an excellent principle. Whoever, he says, discusses contemporary or proximate events should confine himself to state- ments of fact, with authorities; he can- not do more without danger of dogmat- ism and prejudice. Having thus declar- ed himselr, our author straightway plunges into a handling of men and events independent and audacious to the last degree, in which, to any calm judgment, dogmatism and prejudice run riot. As to the races which have come to America, he holds the negroes to be slothful, unstable, and licentious, at the present moment in our society hope- less economically, politically, and social- ly. Their deportation from Africa was a passage from the depths of cannibal- ism and degradation far worse than any Egyptian darkness to what was rela- tively a Canaan of ease and security. They prospered and multiplied under slavery, and now that slavery is gone, they remain only as a dismal encum- brance, not to be assimilated or employ- ed for the purposes of a high civiliza- tion. In contrast with this gloomy view of the Africans are Mr. Bancroft’s con- victions as to the Asiatics, of whom he considers in particular the Chinese. These he holds to be industrious, most capable, cleanly, and peaceable. Their coming in large numbers to our West- ern coast was of vast benefit. They worked contentedly and effectively for small wages, affording to the new com- munities a most useful form of cheap labor. He minimizes their vices, and holds that a main argument for their exclusion, the fact, namely, that they do not desire American citizenship, but uni- versally return with their small savings to China, is strongly in their favor. As to individuals, Mr. Bancroft’s char- acterizations are equally incisive and uncompromising. Seward was probably the best and brightest man who ever sat in the chair of the Secretary of State. McKinley was a magnanimous spirit policies and intentions were whose | sound. For Taft there is mention of | “his ponderous flesh and sickly smile,” |his “narrowness of mind,” “his childish wilfulness and petulance.” Roosevelt, on the other hand, is one “of the great- est men that ever lived,” and Hiram Johnson followed Roosevelt “as Christ followed John the Baptist.” There is, in fact, little to relieve the gloom of the outlook but the presence in our firma- ment of such stars as these. Rockefel- ler and Leland Stanford are “car- buncles,” morbid excrescences on the body of society, and Carnegie, of whose libraries our author speaks contempt- uously, is perhaps no better. We think that Mr. Bancroft’s great desert in the field of history is as a col- lector, compiler, systematizer, and in di- recting and inspiring the labors of oth- ers. A calm, judicial poise, the primary requisite for him who shall write his- tory greatly, is not evident in this book. The New West, Mr. Bancroft’s special field, has risen in Miltonic fash- ion, “like an exhalation,” over night. Exhalations almost of necessity connote miasma, and we unquestionably have been breathing very bad air. Asphyxia- tion, however, we may hope, is not im- minent. In the physical world we are coping with malaria and the “cobras of the air” that distribute yellow-fever, typhus, and infantile paralysis. As to moral malaria, is there less reason to hope? To weigh these things right- ly requires of the historian of our period infinite coolness and discrim- ination. We think Mr. Bancroft over-nervous sometimes in his fears. Some of his heroes we think Dbétes noires, and vice versa. We distrust his judgment in dealing with past events and in interpreting the signs of the present. Where cannot follow we find him always stimulating. He has his human limitation. In his proper field he has done his country and his age a great service, rendered with force, abil- we ity, and purpose of the highest. We re- joice in the vigor unabated, if some- times impatient and eccentric, of a champion so eminent and venerable. CURRENT FICTION. The Social Cancer (Noli Tangere). By José Rizal. Translated by Charles Derbyshire. New York: The World Book Co. me The Reign of Greed (El Filibusterismo). The same. Here are two books that every Amer- ican should read; not simply because a | portunity Malay novelist is a great curiosity, but! because these romances contain a seri- ous exposition of the conditions which prevailed in the Philippines just before the American occupation. Those who readily believe in racial superiort- ties and inferiorities may find in these novels some stimulus to reflection. For 35 here is a Filipino, with no European blood in his veins, who writes with the compelling charm of a Galdés, who has a considerable store of European and a perfect understanding pean ideals; who strikes chords of emo- ulture of Euro- tion that no American could find ex- otic; who believes passionately in all that Western civilization stands for, and whose appeal for the fraternity of races has not a trace of cowardice o1 We feel even that if José Rizal seems post foreign to us at all, it is because cer tain literary motives that in the West have become sodden from over-cultiva tion return in his works with the fresh sincerity of youth. Few of our contemporary novelists could describe with such true exultance the beauty of Oriental moonlight, a tropical spring, all that distinctive local environment that so moves men like Pierre Loti or Laf.- cadio Hearn. This exquisite delicacy, so characteristic of Rizal's ment, is all the more remarkable when we try to estimate the amount of furl- ous passion tnat must have been behind his novels. For, after all, they are ro of most sombre and their tragic appeal is intensified by the’ apparent effort for reserve, and kindliness of judgment A Spanish imperialist of course, Maintain that Rizal's novels are a gross slander on Spanish and that his execution in justified by his revolutionary associations by the inflammatory spirit of his works. We are probably still too close to the involved to reach valuable clusions on such questions But should observe that the major theses of tempera mances outline, for sobriety, would, rule, 1896 Was and events con we Rizal are distinctly pro-Spanish in every essential. He attempts to prove first that everything good in Filipino civilization is due to Spain; and then that permanent advancement must come not from political convulsions, not from endless and abortive revolutions, but from an assimilation of Spanish civil ization which automatically will place the Filipinos on a footing of equal op with their rulers great case against the Spanish is their So his refusal to disseminate their civiliza- tion, their use of the Islands preémi- nently for commercial and social ex- ploitation, their exclusion of them from a respectable place in the Spanish Em- pire, and their inhibition of any na tional spirit, even of any Spanish na- tional spirit, among the natives. He is fighting less for Filipino independence than for a Spanish school system on democratic lines. We believe that this is the only fair interpretation of Rizal's position in his novels; though it must be confessed that the emotions aroused by them are not those best suited to guiding pacific re- forms. If we are to bells his biog raphers, his own life experiences have entered too directly into the principal

Page 16

; of his books not to have left in pisod them some of the wild passions which his own sufferings, ending in martyr- must have created. And perhaps lection that shapes the plot around a constructive plan for social betterment in his countrymen, is ob- scured by the violent emotional reac- tions caused by the narrative of oppres sion, sorrow, and death. We can see now a remote public might find here a . dose of melodrama But if these based on facts, and some of them are documented by Rizal him elf, how are we to calculate the effect they must have had on a suffering peo- ple knowing them to be true? This portrayal of Filipino life gives permanent interest to these books, The characters are taken from every branch of society, including the Spaniard of noble ideals and the native of barbar ous instincts We are not sure that psychologically these people are very deeply or acutely drawn; but their ex- teriors at least are real and vivacious. If we do not carry away from among them any lasting friendships, we. do gain a picture of life in the Philippines that is varied and complete. rhe translation is accurate almost to literalness Yet it more appreciatively worked in the spots where the spirit becomes most distinc- Here, in fact, the transla- might have been tively local tor missed a fine opportunity for edi- torship. His notes are too frequent on the commonplaces of European erudi tion: at times too personal in their views; most often entirely neglectful of those characteristic features of Orien- tal life which necessarily recur in the narrative, and which only people of long residence in the Philippines can be pre- sumed to understand. The few Filipino words that appear are interpreted in a useful glossary Scientific Sprague. By Francis Lynde. New York: Chas. Scribner's Sons. This volume continues the history of the Inter-mountain railway which play- ed title role in the “Taming of Red Butte Western Re-christened the Ne vada Short Line, that indispensable and now thoroughly regenerate branch of the Pacific Southwestern might have enjoyed deserved prosperity had not its ancient enemy, the avid Transcontinen tal, marked it for ite prey. Many and fiendish were the devices by which the “pirates of high finance” sought to ren der the Short Line amenable to assim jlation through the depreciation of its stock. Wrecks were mysteriously Iincit ed by fake messages on the train dis patcher’s wire, important papers en route to a directors’ meeting were in- tercepted, a tunnel was to be demolish ed by nitroglycerine, a dam by dyna- mite, whiskey was surreptitiously fed to men and vitriol to engines, and, these expedients failing, the big system The Nation made a last audacious attempt to swal- low the little road whole, alive and vio- lently kicking, and to retain it by pro- In every case it was Scier- cess of law. tific Sprague, the Government soil-test er, and amateur detective, who foiled the agents of the enemy and identified the long arm of criminal enterprise with its directing brain-centre in New York In spite of his friendly services to the Nevada Short Line, and his admirable endowments of size, muscle, and modes- ty, it is doubtful whether Sprague as a personality will strongly impress hiiu- self upon the popular mind. Few read- ers are likely to share the gaping mys tification with which the other people in the story follow his unerring steps towards prevention and detection, or to be as profoundly impressed as is the author by those seizures of sphinx-like immobility in which Sprague did bis best thinking. The “appeal” of the tale lies neither in the mysteries of crime nor the ingenuities of the sleuth, but in an abundance of situations boldly de signed to raise the reader’s hair with apprehension. Dawson, ‘11: Fortune-Hunter. By John T. McCutcheon Pictured by the Au- thor. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. Dawson is a farm-grown boy just out of college and in search of a city job. Most of the story is told in the form of letters to his mother—genuine boy-let- ters, full of the conglomerate humor which is the special art of the under- graduate. The city does not welcome lim with open arms, and he has a strug- gle to get a foothold—and to hide the extent of his troubles from the little family group at home. When he does find work he is tempted to trickiness by more than one employer, but the high moral ground he takes pays in the long run—in a somewhat shorter run, it may| te, than is common in real life. A thread of romance is connected with the plot, and the pictures characteristic of Mr. McCutcheon almost tell the story by themselves. SPORT AND ADVENTURE, The Journal of a Sporting Nomad. By J. T. Studley. With thirty-nine illus-| trations. New York: John Lane Co. $3.50 net. The Complete Wildfowler. By Stanley Duncan and Guy Thorne. Fully illus- trated with practical drawings and diagrams and with many illustrations in half-tone. New York: The Outing Co 3.75 net. The Book of Winter Sports: An Attempt to Catch the Spirit of the Keen Joys of the Winter Season. Edited by J. C. Dier. New York: The Macmillan Co. $1.50 net. By Flood and Field: Adventures Ashore and Afloat in North Australia. By Al- | Vol. 96, No. 2480 ' fred Searcy, author of “In Australian Tropics.” New York: The Macmillan Co. $2 net. If we may put one of these sporting authorities against another, Mr. Stud- ley’s “Journal of a Sporting Nomad” must be relegated to a_ distinctly inferior position at once. He has ig- norantly spoken of “a gaggle of geese on passage,” whereas a “gaggle” of geese never exists except on the water; transforming itself into a “skein” im- mediately on rising for passage, in the parlance of every sportsman whose tongue is truly attuned to the shib- boleths of up-to-date wildfowling. And Mr. Studley is still further discredited by the admitted discovery that his birds were not geese at all, gaggle or skein, but merely sand-hill cranes. A day or two of watching, however, brought him another discovery which would be of importance to the naturalist if authen- ticated. “It was perfectly evident to me that on arriving at this particular place some old bird of the lot, who knew his way about, was showing the birds of the year some of his landmarks that would enable them to find their way for the future.” This and various other passages indicate that the author can draw a heavier percentage of conclusion from given premises than the trained naturalist would sanction, but in his various wanderings he has picked up much that is interesting, nevertheless. His sporting career began in Newfound- land with six close-range shots at a caribou, which walked calmly off un- scathed when the fusillade was over. Seven chapters are given to Africa, where he went in 1894 as private secre- tary to Sir Claude Macdonald, and came into contact with about all the varie- ties of big game for which that land is ‘famed. In 1896 he accepted an invita- tion to accompany Sir Martin Conway to Spitzbergen, where whale, seal, and reindeer were the chief objects of in- terest; the voyage was varied by a visit to the ill-fated Andrée and his balloon, at Danes Ghat, where he spent two months. Several pages are given to a detailed account of the balloonist’s out- fit and operations. Visits to the Florida Tarpon region, different parts of Can- ada, and Alaska are also described. “The Complete Wildfowler” will make its best appeal only to those who have 'some acquaintance with the ways of the fowler and the fowl on the other side of the Atlantic. We shall not rec- ommend too highly to “the general pub- lic” a book which declares with a tinge of acidity, on its initial page, that it is not intended for such. The authors seem unnecessarily sensitive on the sub- ject of mistaken criticism of the sport |to which they are devoted, as involv- |} ing cruelty, butchery, etc. One does not need to be a technical expert on the | subject to know that a continuance of | conditions existing in a not remote past ae, 7 LT

Page 17

a ee ee ee oe hae mantreraa a al cm Jan. 9, 1913] would soon have left no game or wild- fowl in existence. Cruel and useless slaughter was rife everywhere, and men who classed themselves as sports- men, with no challenge to their claims, were not ashamed to boast. of feats of killing which could not be repeated to- day without great scandal. If this re- action, which alone has made the pres- ervation of material for hunting, an- gling, and fowling possible, has natur- ally involved a certain amount of un- intelligent and unduly severe criticism of these sports, no level-headed sports- man should be disturbed by that. On guns and their care, ammunition, wild- fowl dogs and their training, and the various other branches of their subject, the authors write from extended person- al experience, and their book may be ac- cepted with confidence as a safe guide. “The Book of Winter Sports” is a compilation from at least a score or two of writers, including such well-known literary names as those of Charles Dickens, R. D. Blackmore, John Adding- ton Symonds, A. Conan Doyle, Robert Burns, James Hogg, and “Christopher North.” The most interesting pages are those which deal with some of the newer types of ice craft, such as those driven by the aeroplane type of propel- ler, or those which pull upon the ice itself by a chain around the tire of an automobile, or by a spiked wheel; or, again, the “scooters” of the Great South Bay, little flat-bottomed boats with run- ners attached underneath, which, with a good wind, can take the water from the ice or the ice from the water with equal facility and can be pulled over the ice by hand or rowed through the water when wind is wanting. Devised first, we are told, for life-saving pur poses in dealing with the difficulty of the Great South Bay shore-ice driven by the tides, the “scooter” has naturally been taken up as a means of sport, chiefly along the shore ot the bay wher it had its birth. Ice sports of all types and in all lands are considered, and the book is well illustrated with half tones, drawings, and colored plates. “By Flood and Field” is an extremely interesting account of the author's ad- ventures in the northern territory of Australia, some twenty-five years ago, grewsome in parts but of value to any one concerned with the problems of con- tact between civilized and uncivilized peoples. Blown out to sea in a dinghy from Selaru Island, picked up when al- most exhausted by a boat-load of Malays caught in the same storm, compelled to live for some time among the blacks, reduced at last in wearing apparel to the simple breech-cloth of the natives Mr. Searcy had opportunity to know at first hand of the native life to which a good part of his book is given. Af ter a time he was taken by the blacks to Port Essington, and from there was finally able to reach Port Darwin, where ry — . The Nation he found men of his own race, and was taken into service in the Customs House. Here his chief duty was the circumvention of opium-smugglers. Lat- er he joined the police force and was occupied in the region of the McArthur and Roper Rivers, to the west of the Gulf of Carpentaria. As the narrative is confessedly written for the most part from meniory, after the intervention of about a quarter of a century, one can not help feeling that certain of the sen- sational adventures recorded may un- consciously have taken on additional color in the meantime; but on the whole the book is doubtless a_ trust wortl y picture of conditions then exist ing. Problems of Men, Mind, and Morals. By Ernest Belfort Bax. Boston: Small, Maynard & Co. $1.50 net. The miscellaneous essays contained in this volume are on the whole good re ading be« ause of the frank directness with which the author states his views; Lut they cannot be said to be marked by either profundity or originality. The view of Ethical Evolution set forth in the first chapter is not “the entirely new view” which the author leads us to expect, but simply the view at present current among the majority of moral- ists of the sociological school; and the essay on Speculative Thought is no thing more than a good summary of the history of philosophy for a small encyclopedia. The essay on Modern Feminism, though slight, contains some refreshing common sense. It is indeed a question how far an already over-privileged sex is entitled to the fur ther privilege of the vote. A certain unity of motive may, how- ever, be derived from the circumstance that ten of the fifteen essays are con cerned, more or less directly, with the defence of Socialism—against its ene mies, but chiefly against the more timid of its friends. Socialism is accused of being unpatriotic, atheistic, and in fa vor of free love. Apparently, Mr. Bax resents this way of putting it—at least as regards the last term; but all his efforts are directed to proving that the formulation is correct. Socialism stands for internationalism as against patriot- ism, because patriotism isaform of capl- talism. Nevertheless, Socialism is not a purely economic doctrine, but a theory of society based upon modern science. Hience, while permitting liberty of opin- ion, it is necessarily opposed in sym- pathy to all theology or transcendental metaphysics. In sexual relations, how- ever, while not positively recommend- ing looseness, Socialism stands for un restricted freedom; that is, for freedom qualified only by certain considerations connected with offspring Apart from these considerations, sexual relations are nobody's business, provided there is mutual consent. Marriage is to be simply a private contract. New con tracts may be formed as often as you please, and they may be frankly and exclusively contracts for animal grati fication—or perhaps there may be no contract; they are to be secure from interference and even from criticism It is rather hard to see why this should not be called “free love.” And upon looking deeper we find a certain strain of tendency running through the volume which is at on amusing, repelling, and illuminating The book is a vindication of Socialism from the standpoint of individual free dom. Those who think of Socialism as a system of organized interference into private affairs are slapped in the face with the assertion that Socialism proposes to regulate only those actions which concern society, leaving private conduct free. But all this assumes naively that human actions can be di vided and distributed into two boxes as if there were any private action wholly without effect upon the lives of others or any communal action without some effect upon every individual! And those who reflect upon the extensiveness of the economic interests which Social ism proposes to control will wonder vhat is to be left for the individual when society has taken its own, From reading Mr. Bax they will be led to in fer that the chief item in freedom is sex. And when they note in particular his justification of sexual intercourse ‘from the standpoint of mere animal enjoyment, his rather undisguised in difference to any higher aspects (in “Sex and Sentiment”), and (in “Modern Feminism”) his open assertion of the erganic inferiority of women, they will doubtless conclude that socialistic fre dom presents a very pretty pictur Notes The Putnams will publish earl year: “An Interpretation of Rudolf |! \ en's Philosophy,” by W. Tudor Jor rm Positive Evolution of Religion rr eric Harrison; “The Personalit leon” (Lowell Lectures, 1912), ! 1 Hol land Rose The Problem of tl Jean Finot The Evolution ! J. M. Robertson rhe Englist t n tl Kighteenth Century it tud ditions, by |! S. Rosco | Adam Lindsay Gordor Douglas Sade Mishnal the Basel Prir inte of le ’ tr } i f } Goldir and ‘ f Anh 1s Who | La { t Patsy } t i. a R. Cr t ’ have I ] rh te f en lia

Page 18

the ast of which has just come fre tl I ss, are preparing an exhaustive index of tl work “Zor Poll nan 88,” by Harry A. Frank which t Century Company will issue shortly, recounts the author’s experiences us pla thes policeman and census-taker luring f onths In Panama Among the books shortly to appear from the pr of Longmans, Green & Co. are the follo “ The Wondrous Passion,” by the Rev. F. W. Drake; “The Sympathy of God,” 1} the Rev. Forbes Robinson; “Help from the Sanctuary,” by the Rev. Jesse Brett Child of Storm,” by Sir Rider Hag gard nd Essentials in Early European History.” by Samuel Burnett Howe Mi Elizabeth Kendall has placed with Houghton Mifflin her new book on “China.” An Oxford euition of Browning's “The Ring lt Book” comes to us from Henry Frowd I this volume Prof. Edward Dowder tten an introduction. and there facsimiles from the Yellow Ro \ ich both the special student of t bethan age and the general read W welcome is “The Correspond- ence of I Sidney and Hubert Languet,” whiecl Me nount Press, of Boston, has ublished in a handsome volume with mar- xi red type The text is a reprint I translation from the Latin r ! Steuart A. Pears, Fellow of Christ hurch, Oxford Sidney first I cundian at Frankfort in 1572 vl Sid just out of Oxford, was a en and Languet was fifty four rrespondens was continued with f gularity until the elder man died, etght ears later It is a lasting ! to bot but is of special in- t ! hat it reveals of Sidney's ex- traord apacity for knowledge devel- oped t mn early age, and may be read and 1 with steady inspiration We alac end anew the two letters, at the le of the volume, written in Eng- i! ! to his younger brother, Robert vhen the latter was travelling abroad More than any documents which we recall, they serve to correct the natu- ral impression that Elizabethan life lack- ed del netincts. The book is provided with ar nforming Introduction, by Wil- lian Aspenwall Bradley, which describes the political situation of Europe of those days. Th who have followed the growth of The Humaniet’s Library will heartily welcome thie fifth number of the series as being well p to the standard of editing and beautiful press-work which wae in the original plar The drawing of historical parallels is proverblally as diMecult as it is fascinating, and we annot think that Robert W. Mec- Laughliir n hie “Washington and Lincoln” (Putnam) as been more successful than most wit who have essayed such allur- ine tae) The trouble lles, of course, not in int resemblances or differences, but In making comparisons that are really significant We are unable to agree with Mr. McLaueblin that elther a philosophical or a biographical study of “the central problen of constitutional government,” namel power In its derivation, expression, and abuse,” forms in the present instance ' The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2480 the indispensable common ground; for the reason that, instead of being a distinctive problem of 1789 recurring in 1861, it is rather the primary problem of government I at all times and everywhere. On such a basis, one might profitably work out his- torical parallels between almost any two political leaders At the same time, Mr. McLaughlin's analysis of the conditions un- der which Washington and Lincoln worked, the methods they their public friendships, and their qualities of mind and heart, is interesting and instructive; it may well contribute something to the apprecia- of the characteristics of their admin- istrations employed, tion In 1905, Sir Ian Hamilton published his Staff Officer's Scrap Book,” a personal rec- ord of the Russo-Japanese war. The book had a well-deserved success, and merited translation into German It is now re- published in slightly abridged form, and in one volume only, by Longmans, Green & Co For the proper understanding both of the course of Jewish religious thinking in the two centuries just preceding our era, and of some aspects of the teaching of Jesus, especially the self-designation Son of Man, the composite pseudepigraph commonly known as Ethiopic, or I Enoch, is admit- tedly of immense importance Competent editions of this document have been pub- lished in German by Beer (1900), and in French by Martin (1906); but, without question, the best edition is the present volume, “The Book of Enoch” (Frowde), rom the hand of one of the few experts in the fleld of Jewish apocalyptical litera- ture, R. H. Charles. Since 1893, when he published his first edition, with an English translation, based on Dillmann’s Ethiopic text. Dr. Charles has issued his own Ethi- ople text, edited from twenty-three manu- scripts, together with the fragmentary Greek and Latin versions (1906), and has discovered that the original language of like that of Daniel, is both Hebrew Aramaic, and that of Enoch is poetical in structure and other findings of long-continued investigation, to- gether with the use of six additional Ethi- the editor to say Enoch, and much These induce opic manuscripts, of the present volume that it is “not so much a second edition as a new book,” and that “alike in the translation and in the | commentary it forms a vast advance on its predecessor.” The best of the eight chapters in the re- cent volume by Prof. Alexandre Moret on the “Kings and Gods of Egypt” (Putnam) is the last, on The Reading of Hiero- glyphics. It gives an account of the deci- pherment of the picture-writing of the Egyptians, and contains considerable de- tall, both of the history and process. It is both full and lucid. This is a subject in which a Frenchman may justly take pride, since the major part of the credit for find- ing the key belongs to Jean Francois Cham- pollion, a fellow countryman The other seven chapters deal with as many sub- jects: the temple of Queen Hatshopsitu at Der-el-Bahri, the ancient Thebes; the religious revolution of Amenhotep IV, who attempted the introduction of a solar mono- theism into Egypt to the exclusion of all other gofls, and particularly of Amon; the of Osiris, the earliest passion- Passion play; the mysteries of Isis, and their adop- tion into the circle of Roman _ religious practice; the immortality of the soul, and moral retribution through the ages; some legendary travels of the Egyptians in Asia; and the Egyptian origin of many incidents and statements in the poems of Homer. These chapters give sectional pictures of Egyptian art, culture, religion, thought, and history. Essentially, there is not much new material in the volume, and some of its statements have become antiquated, on account of the more fundamental results reached by Professor Breasted in his re- cent lectures on “Religion and Thought in Ancient Egypt.” Nevertheless, Professor Moret’s works deserve a place in the popu- lar literature of Egyptology; this in spite of the absurd appearance of the native names, transliterated according to the French systera. At a time when a career was open to tal- ents there were many cases of men who rose from obscurity to dazzling prominence; no case, perhaps, is more extraordinary than that of the son of a poor cooper who rose to the envied position of Marshal of France and Prince of Moskowa. The steps Ney’s career, his daring success in the ir capture of Mannheim, his share in the wonderful concentration which resulted in the capitulation of 60,000 Austrians in the campaign about Ulm, his immortal defence f the rear column in the retreat from Russia, his desertion to Napoleon after his foolish boast that he would fetch his for- mer master to Paris “in an iron cage,” his delays and wild mistakes at Quatre Bras before Waterloo, and his noble bear- ing as he stood up against a wall to be shot as his penalty for treason, are all well told by A. Hilliard Atteridge, in “The Bravest of the Brave” (Brentano's) The author makes, however, no pretention to any original contribution; he draws mostly from the well-known works of Bonnal, Houssaye, and Weil, and from the usual memoirs. He has found it necessary to bur- den his biography with a good deal of general military history of a rather ama- |teurish sort. He is more successful in portraying the personality of his hero than |in describing the hundred military events |in which Ney took a prominent part. An admirable, succinct statement of the main facts of the advance in democracy, agriculture, industry, and social legislation which Europe has made since the French Revolution is given by F. A. Ogg in “Social Progress in Contemporary Europe” (Mac- millan). He succeeds in giving a good introduction to such subjects as the English Industrial Revolution and its progress and results in the other countries of Europe, old-age pensions and sick insurance, the | immense increase of population in the nine- |teenth century, and the progress of social- lism. His treatment is topical rather than lby countries, and is supp6rted by well- grouped facts and figures. It is just the |kind of book which is suitable for Chau- tauqua reading groups, by whom it has been already adopted, and might also be success- fully used in college courses as a parallel study of economic development along with the ordinary text-books which confine them- selves chiefly to political development. Each chapter is furnished with a good bib- HNography intended for beginners rather than for research students.

Page 19

Jan. 9, 1913]

The Nation

In “Short Story Writing” (Macmillan) Prof. Walter B. Pitkin presents a rare spectacle. A professional lecturer on phil- osophy and an occasional student of Dewey's psychology, he offers a manual for increas ng the already alarming production of short prose fiction. With the well-known odesty of the man with a hobby, he vigor isly insists that his is the first exposition the real technique of the subject. In the first section ‘The Art of Short Stor Vriting he does indeed explain and app! a theory of “integration” which is true igh as psychology and fits in well with the current doctrine of the “short-story operly hyphenated, but has little re ? some academicians | But this technique is clearly be yond the intelligence of the persons the or has in mind in the second par discusses the business side of subject He presents calmly the commer al status of short fiction, as seen by a ractical journalist. He very sensibly ad onishes his aspiring readers to eschew religiously Poe, Maupassant, and othe short-story classics; to give their days and nights to the study of the Saturday Ereniny Post and the Argosy, and to write stories as rapidly as possible and publish all that are accepted in any quarter. An unimpres sion‘stic critic might observe’ that writer’s psychology has done the world a real service in making him miss the ps chology of the would-be producer of penny- a-word fiction. However that may be, his style shows the coloring of his magazine diet, notably in the topsy-turvy incongrui ties in the manner of O. Henry that ar sprinkled through even the gravest parts of his handbook. The American Short Story” (The Editor Company), by Dr. Elias Lieberman, has its value for the author. He is learning to write. Such high praise cannot be meted out to his attempts at investigation and criticism. The enticing sub-title of th: volume is, “A Study of the Influence of Locality on Its Development.” But ths pages following thereupon do not indicat: in what sense there has been a development of the literary genre in America. They do not furnish, aside from a few excerpts from previous writers on the subject, even an inkling of what the influence of localit has been on the form. Besides, the nin chapters dealing with the fiction represent ing different localities from old New Ene land to new Alaska discover no traces whatsoever of study, of rumination, or cogi tation In short, the book is distinguished by a plentiful lack of ideas As stated in the publisher’s preface, the present edition of “Illustrious Dames of the Court of the Valois Kings” (The Lamb Publishing Company) is a reprint, in less expensive form, of Katharine Prescott Wormeley’s translation of Brantéme’s “Vi: des dames illustres,” or, as the author him self called it, “Le Livre des dames.” This ontains, also, in the shape of a “seventh liscourse,” under the title of “Various II- lustrious Ladies,” the chapter on “Th: Widows” in Brant6Ome’s companion work entitled “Les Dames galantes.” To each of the longer, as well as to several of the shorter, sketches, Miss Wormeley has added Sainte-Beuve’s comments on the per- sons described, from the “Causeries du Lundi,” thus rounding. out and rectifying BrantOme’s picturesque but partial charac- terizations. For the volume ehe has writ- ten a biographical introduction based upon the introductory essays of preceding ed tors, quoting at length the remarks of on of Brantéme’s earliest commentators, Cas aud, who was almost a contemporary According to hi Pierre de Bourdeill Abbé de Branté: was descended from a K ng of France named Mare r and Tiloa I 1. daughter f King of England t g h nt and ho fami ) I Pe i Brant lik is fath o ! whe th cn / t s tl i re t vy of his a it ] i i “ Pop Jul i s t ind i tie H worked } +} honors and l t tair ind felt } " f destiny It was « towards tl ! 4 life that by way ofl onsolati« ) pose l the works through which ! famous and which are of ich alue in helping us to 1 mstru tacle of courtly manners and oral nder the Valois kings He did not iblish them himself, though he freely showed his manu scripts to his friends and atron and even his heirs were evidently as fearful as he of causing scandal In violation of his testamentary njunctions, they let the manuscripts lie for fifty years later in their five volumes covered wth velvet, blach tan, green, blue, and a large volume, which is that of ‘The Ladies,’ covered with green velvet,” until, after they had found their way into the cabinets of collectors they finally were printed in Holland Miss Wormeley’s translation, although o casionally awkward and guilty of minor inelegancies, is, on the whole, satisfactory, and succeeds in retaining something of the spirit of the original. She adds several appendices, one of which contains a literal translation of Marie Stuart's lament on her sorrows after the death of her husband, Francois II, “En mon triste ‘et doux chant,” and the book is embellished with photogravures of several famous paintings and portraits illustrative of the text teaders of Mrs. Hugh Fraser's “A Dip- lomatist’s Wife in Many Lands” will not need to be assured that there is excellent entertainment in the supplementary volume, “Reminiscences of a Diplomatist’s Wife” (Dodd, Mead) We have the familiar med ley of genealogy, anecdote, personal recol lection, and hearsay presented with Mrs Fraser's usual good-natured toryism. No- body can lead or o readily ip or down a family tree witness Uw ketch of the Moltkes Reminiscence of Vienna, of her brother Marion Crawford villa at Sor rento, and an extended sketch of diplomati residence in Chili are tl ief topics. With- in equal compass it ild hard to find i keener and mor Z ing a ount of Latin-Ameri S« G t storie are not absent, among tl igularly grew- some tale of a were-wolf picked up on the Roman Ca izna. It iggested by ana tual experi e with a lycanthrope in Chili He howled most wolflike in the street, even if he did not actually change his form be fore the author's expectant eyes An in teresting observation is that th inner r le of European diplomats is still obedient tl traditior of Metternich, Beacor f ’ and in er r n * #) , at ane

dotes oncerns Princess Metternich, who

‘ riticised the Empress Eugénie for smoking \ |} ncehw ‘ | And wha about he | pres f <A _—s = OR x igatr ’ s ‘ 1 ours wa I | ress ha i xt to do a j s ! th izs LB t! } t . rt x ik ‘ tr { { \ | and Pana ‘ ! f } P { j ea y ; +? 4 ' I . | ! \ full ! r ry Tt Med T Ya ol " g Uj I north ‘ et i ne ariou i i 2 the mainland as far north as M ippendices contain valual i } will prove iseful to ountries There is an ama information contained | t seems in most cases to |! ) vhole-souled love and apprecitati ation which is characteristi rf M ans and is particularly strong " er or less fortunate classe , pues tioned, and the statement tha Mexicat have much affinity with th pan to our mind, incorrect In opposition to the talk armament and arbitration a i ) it! panacea for all international diff { Capt, A. T. Mahan offer some storical and theoretical counter argun » A somewhat rambling volume, entitled “Arma ments and Arbitration” (Harper The ten chapters have already appeared a igaziue articles in the North America R et the Century Magazine during aim to demonstrate the Iinevita ten beneficial use of force In tl) tl t of international question He tl t arbitration cannot alway be i ra or beneficial substitute for arr t ' the settlement of questions in policies of two countries confi which there is no established His method of argument " in the discussion of internat neat which have been 1 ! used either actually in war o1 clul settlements which t now generally agreed wer t j settlements n which he thi uld have been either wil or would have resulted in less ati actory ) ha ’ to a refutation of some of tl ions of tl suthor of The G inother to t ilitary favor of fortifying apr Par a | ther t & t ! tha Mr. I t t I | 3 no A Chapter f Na D a] t of his tw i t i ind ru wor | fo ’ } r r j 4 ! tiflal r ti U1 1 and rf P

Page 20

AO Science \ BIOLOGICAL ASPECT OF CANCER Cancer 18 a phenome non of growth, normal growth to be sure, but growth nevertheless, and therefore a biological prob uite as much as medical. The ire of cancer, yet to be found, will be mpi and purely medical. The pathological effect of cancer on the or- inism is also a medical matter, and te beyond the realm of a biolog I} ondary aspects ort can l, biologically, are not a part of th cancer problem as a phenomenon of growtl rhe explanation of this growt ind th iture of the causes produ are distinet biological problems, and if they can be solved and the cause o malignant growths discovered, new av: nues for experimentation in cure or prevention will be opened. tissues of the body, or, bet tissues, Certain ter, the cellular begin to grow, until an abnormal mass ct cells results; this mass is malignant the ra- units of these oO non-malignant, according to ture of the growth and of the tissues in volved. After an injury of slight char acter, such as an abrasion, the srr rounding cells grow and replace the lost o> injured parts. This is termed regen eration, and the underlying biological principles are the same as in abnorinal diifer- limited growth cancer. The essential that regeneration under or ence is is a whereas malig are unlimited the organism. growth control, cancers get of regeneration nant tumors or control The develop beyond the growths which regulation of into cancerous processes as is frequentiy may processes even In cancer following surgical opers tion In science, when exact knowledge of causes is inaccessible or absent, hypo theses are formulated. The value of such hypotheses depends upon the area covered in the fleld of observed phe- romena, and if accepted as working hypotheses, they are valuable in stimu- lating If, on the other hand, they are conceived in a earch for ultimate causes. dogmatic spirit, and if investigation is ILmited to the search for phenomena vhich fit the hypothesis, then they are not only valueless, but pernicious The cause of cancer is not known; but many different working hypotheses, me Valuable, some pernicious, have been formulated. The valuable ones have imulated research and have been most seful in focussing searchlights from every angle on the cancer problems, Of the pernicious type none is more harm- ful than the pessimistic view that the of cancer will be known only the secret of life is revealed. A cause when divergent branch from a streara may be traced back to the boulder which divides the stream, without the need of chemical | | Vol. 96, No. 2480 The Nation analysis of the water, or search for the source of the stream. So with cancer the cause of the divergent process of erowth, like the boulder, imay 2 and will be discovered without the need of solving the riddle of life. It criticise purpose here to discuss in detail the various hypo- cause of cancer. The Cohn- heim theory of dormant embryonic tis- sue; the parasite theory; Ribbert’s the- of theories of mal- rutrition and disordered vital functions, is not my o! theses of the ory tissue tension; and a score of others, all have value as or facts. The all current broad be useful, as is the case with theories based hypotheses and are more working obs« rve d that ess supporte d by general criticism is |! ypotheses are either too to on malnutrition or deranged metabol- ism, or else they do not cover a suffi- ciently large field of observed facts. A biologically satisfactory working hypothesis of the cause of cancer must explain not only the different types of malignant and non-malignant tumors, but must also account for the phenom- ena of regeneration. We find it diffi- cult to believe that there is a “self-per- principle in living matter which upon the production of the normal type; we think it more prob- able that stimulant to growth is produced through the abnormal condi- tion of the injured part. We formerly thought that the presence of food in the intestine stimulated the pancreas to secrete, but we now know that the acid food irritates the lining cells of the in- testine, causing them to secrete a sub- tle chemical body called secretin, be- longing to a group known as hormunes. This hormone, or enzyme, is carried by fecting” insists some the blood to the pancreas where it stim- ulates the pancreas to activity. Knowledge of these chemically elusive termed enzymes, is still frag- mentary and vague, but enough known to intimate that they will play a most important rdle in the biology of the future. Many vegetable galls caused presence of insects or thread worms are due to the abnormal developmen‘ o! the plant cells. Something derived from the sting of the maternal insect, or as an exudation from the developing larva stimulated the cells of the division. In some have been deter- mined specifically, nu- cleo proteids or products of the chemi- cal disintegration of protoplasm. Here is a biologica! fact that may hove some bearing on the problem of the cause of cancer, viz, a chemical substance form- ed from disintegrating prctoplasm stim- cells bodies, ig by the ha. unwonted worm to the er plant stimular‘’s ‘oases enzymes or, “as ulating adjacent normal celis to abnor-| mal division. Regeneration following injury may be interpretcd as due to stimulants in a similar way, the injured cellg and tissues unde-going chemical disintegration into amino acids and ' their derivatives and purin bases and their derivatives, some of these or all ac‘ing as stimulan:s to the adjacent normal cells and causing them to pro- liferate and to develop under control and regulation into the norm. This, in brief, is the underlying prin- ciple in a recent hypothesis of the cause of cancer advanced last May by Dr. Bullock, Dr. Rohdenburg, and myself. We believe that it is the most widely applicable of all the existing theories of cancer. It offers a common biological interpretation for the manifold varie- ties of tumor growth and brings into farmony the facts observed by advo- cates of the different hypotheses of tu- mor origin. Chronic irritation produc- ed by injury, by X-rays, by parasites of many kinds, by betel-nut chewing, by hot rice eating, by smoking, by mam- mary or uterine irritations, etc., all lead- ing to injury and death of cells, and this to the disintegration or autolysis of their protoplasm, produces the chem- ical substances or enzymes responsible for the stimulated division energy of ad- iacent cells. Normal regeneration fol- lowing the initial injury becomes chron- ic regeneration or a tumorous growth with continued irritation; and, once started, a tumor grows with increasing momentum by virtue of the chemical substances derived from its own degen- crating cells. Oertel asserts that he traced the development of a liver can- cer from degenerating liver cells. ‘4 mouse tumor transplanted iuto normal mice, grows, in a varying percentage of cases, into fatal cancers in the other- vise normal mice. With every trans- plantation, degenerating cells are tranc- planted with the living cells, and the tiansplant thus carries with it its own stimulants for cell division. The mouse furnishes food and oxygen for the grow- ing tumor, and absorbs more and more of the poisonous products of degenera- tion until, overcome by cachexia or gen- eral poisoning, it succumbs. Amino acids and purin are produced by successive oxidations of the nucleo-proteids making up proto- plasm. Hence, in active, malignant tu- mors, some parts of which are degener- ating, oxidation processes are more ac- tive than in normal tissue cells, waich accounts for the greater avicity for oxygen on the part of cancer cells as ontrasted with normal vells a discov- ery made by hriich and Wassermann Gary N. CALKINS derivatives iast year. The Sarah Berliner Research Fellowship for Women, of $1,000, is offered now every year. The successful candidate is the most promising among those who present them- leelves in the fleld of physics, chemistry, and biology, some ~=.preference being | felt by the committee for these subjects |in the order named. The chairman of the |committee ig Mrs. Christine Ladd Frank- " 'lin, No. 527 Cathedral Parkway, New York,

Page 21

et a ee

Jan 9, 1913]

from whom further information may be obtained The Naples Table Association for Pro moting Laboratory Research by Women offers this vear, for the sixth time, a prize of $1,000 for the best thesis written by a woman on a scientific subject. The thesis must embody w observations and new con clusions based on independent laboratory research in biological, chemical, or physi cal scier This prize has been named the Elle Richards Research Prize, in hon or of Mrs. Richards. The Association also maintains a research table for qualified wo men stud ts at the Zodlogical Station at Naples rh hairman of the committee is Dr. Lilia Welsh, Goucher College Bal- timore The ri is offered every two years Dr, William Henry Watson, ex-regent of he University of the State of New York, is dead at his home in Utica. He was a native of Providence, where he was born in 1829 He graduated from Brown University in 1852, and was one of the founders of the New York State Homeopathic Asylum for the Insane, at Middletown. In 1880 he was surgeon-general of New York Among his publications are many contributions to medical journals Dr. Lewis Swift, astronomer, died on Sun- day in Marathon, N. Y., aged He had discovered 1,300 nebule and eighteen ninety-two years ago he was stricken Dr. when took his he set cider-mill. at the each year from comets. Several blind, and forced to give up his work. Swift he name in 1862, which Rochester, Duff's business et into the came prominence discovered He to observatory the comet went where up an Though time, he discovered on in hardware a com 1877 to 1882. For three successive years the of for contributing most awarded him to was the author of “Simple Imperial Vienna its medal omy He sons in Astronomy.” Academy astron- Les- Drama and Musie . One the Season of most successful pieces of the “Jelfs” of Judged the London is the Vachell. (Doran), it is present Horace printed copy the procured in Annes!ey by not easy to ac- count for favorable critical it has tidious judges comment generally fas- whole, it of conventional, if from Sone Considered as a belongs to a very common order semi sensational drama with a fairly who interesting, and they story personages although have long been a in the theatrs of their living ategorical that the suddenly cepted tualities but types as at are reflections proto For } ities of mn i ! sed with f nkness a : ; , It t t 2 Houg Bo \ M H ‘ } ) ind I rid w } ha | ! } . I I , i ’ ¢ Of rt } 7 «} , irs her ] il 4 ne nd t! i ti ot iv ¥ the end, however ! an who had hel | o recover her |! d ! said to be very “ but it is not likels i robable and disae deemed by mere lit Sir John Hary lelivy l speech on the British d: i Benevolent Fund dinner Hy nearly fifty years he had be the London stage, for twen London manager, and, in his time during that lons in the stage in England b a condition as regards tl promise of the younger who acted on it and the | those who wrote for it passed when the Fren sta as a model, and h or itself could not boast of six better acting and mors could be shown than at tl! His Majesty's, Royalty W New, and the Savoy at the ment Compare the with the early sixties wi nelodrama and its indiff: of indifferent French by the genius of that and natural school, To Re pare it with the early pre-\ and the sufferings of Macrea ed in his diary that ! “ performance wear body, sunk and lang to be a party to rance, and wantor grade the poor art I live in happier ti been living now, he not ashar 1, of th he belonged English new Al leath of George Rie whose Henry \ rheatre is ll frest older playgzoers It thy personation t had not uch art or ! + appeared her o a ( Willia it Black 1s characters, but work listinetior ind l pressior Rut “

in wil the “ai _ ‘ ba ‘ i ree i } , . ’ | } . il ti \ ) iid t it tor in actor of f years a op ion it no of vears had n so healthy ability and 1 and women i gitts of t had wa held up 1 that Paris itr where t ble Ss Ja g's ndhar the pr nt no 0 of things th turgid , ; il lati is ily rel ed r ot t ‘ rtson (or torian period ho! rd t fr each i fated In elled gno W M i i ; q h rf +) glish actor | Booth’s or of ghtily ff ex ilthough it hind it He | Melnotte ind other ) had 0 D it iT h bad act Born at Le ster, i sas first or “ h th rh Royal a* Bath i | “ l a _ nw j ss it l xt AX and ¢ } ' ‘ 0 1 tt i ' d wit , I n I ! tt ha » be f ! il work Mr. R ‘ t R joc gd tl pose ho w 1a i i ! first New York recital will ! it .Molian Hall inuary 1 rhe f il i ‘ will | i s York P hal () l tra eti | I hich they wil ir ibscribers onl 0 Januar iin wl é ( great digtineti i ill t h re tal next Saturda ng Sct Wanderer i } 1? inge! l ‘ I Brah Strauss, and otl Hans Richter le jor ot t y more 1 irr ocahl he was invited last immer t Schul ius to onduct the giganti oncert s to be giver London on May r’s hundredth birthday, he wrots lear friend Schulz-Curtius The ul Greeks burned their shi in order t return impossible ifter the ‘M singer’ performan it Rayreuth,e¢ 1 burn all my bAtor \\ ’ r old Han rhe sical cr ) ! / Zeitung ha gz t ] rictures i rt berg, the ling ‘ Frankfort t) M {; inded I 7 ' ert f t | itical i j ‘ aDe . t} , ‘ th M haf Richard Wag wro think of th jolin only in s dis gzulal 1 Be s hi l iat lon , : fl and a ) wer x |

Page 22

Of the fulfilment of this prophecy ry ago ere are no signs at present Last Sun- la efre Zimbalist played the Mendels- erto with the Philharmonic Or- hestra while the New York Symphony Orchests joist the same afternoon was Mi } lmna Both these artists enjoy " 1 nd } play concertos ll the orchestras in the land ror tals with plano ac- . ly two of half loz or iperior violinists who itre for ex Albert Spalding was ! t tl n rt season in Europe Another ul iolinist Maud Po ! ! i Spalding was ! Zimbali Then I ! finall by wa rf al 101 rea hav lived Ku Ysa ind Fri Kreislet Having l ough x si ontract by Bost Sy Orchestra, Mr. Kreis played only oncertos, the one excep ! 2 il he gave to aid the Music School Settl I He returns next ison for a recital tour. Ysaye is an old- I i but his tone and his technique are a young as ever, and his popularity is unbounded He, too, has been heard, as a matter urs: at Sunday concerts, of which there are now usually five, six, or ven \ few years ago it was an unusual thing have more than one Art Jade: A Study in Chinese Archwology and Religion. By Berthold Laufer Chicago Field Museum of Natural History. Publication 154; Anthropo- logical Series, Vol. X. Of all the precious minerals, none pos- sesses more historic interest than do nephrite and jadeite, commonly combin- ed under the single denomination jade. times they have at- tracted the eye of man, and their quali- ties of color and composition have ren- dered them favorite materials for orna- From prehistoric mental use And, over and above this merely artistic value, these substances were regarded in early times, and are still regarded in certain Eastern lands, a and also as exercising as possessing a mysterious potency, talismanic virtue, a singularly effective therapeutic action. Indeed, both the physical and the spir- itual welfare of human beings were sup posed to be furthered by the ownership of an object made of nephrite or jade- ite, more especially when it had been worked into a form symbolizing certain natural forces Much has already been written on this subject, and we need hardly call atten tion to the monumental work describ- ing the unrivalled Heber Bishop collec- tion, “Investigations and Studies in Jade,” privately printed in 1906, a work registering the results of a careful study of these fascinating minerals, as well The Nation [ Vol. y6, No. 2480 - from a mineralogical standpoint as from an historical one. The present book by Dr. Laufer not only completes and am- plifies the part devoted to Chinese jade carvings, but offers much new and valu- able information in regard to them. Dr. Laufer was well fitted to prepare a staidy on this intricate subject. He was born in Cologne, in 1874, and re- ceived his degree of doctor of philosophy in Berlin. He took part in the Jesup Expedition to Siberia, in 1898-99, and the East Asiatic Expedition to China, 1901-1904. From 1904 to 1908 he was assistant curator oi the ethnological de- partment of the American Museum of Natural History; from 1905 to 1908, lec- turer on anthropology at Columbia Uni- versity, and from 1905 to 1908 assistant curator in charge of the Asiatic depart- Field Museum in Chicago. the Field Museum was a ment of the His trip for most successful one. The present work | presents the fruits of years of travel and study. While Dr. Laufer freely acknowledges that the great Bishop Collection of Jade, in the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, is the most extensive collec- tion in existence of such objects, yet he thinks that the jades gathered by him in Si-yan-fu, Shensi Province, for the Field Museum, while conducting the Mrs. T. B. Blackstone Expedition to China and Tibet, from 1908 to 1910, in- clude a number of interesting types of jade amulets of the dead not represent- ed in the Bishop collectiaqn. The special significance of the vari- ous jade ornaments is illustrated in the case of the girdle-pendants, which were not merely ornamental, but were thought to emit musical sounds as they struck together when the wearer was in mo- tion. In the Li Ki it is said that gen- tlemen in olden times always wore these suspended jade ornaments, and that, while those on the right side emitted the notes Chih and Kio, the fourth and third notes of the Chinese scale, the jade objects on the left side gave forth the first and fifth notes, Kung and Yii. | The melodious intermingling of these notes was believed to banish all de pressed thoughts from the soul and to instil virtue into the wearer's heart. The color of these jades was strictly deter- mined by the rank of the wearer—white jade being reserved exclusively for the Emperor's wear; jade of a green hue, like the green of a wooded mountain, be- longing to princes of the first and sec- ond rank; water-blue jade to prefects. To the heir-apparent a special jade was also assigned, while plain officials had to comfort themselves with inferior greenish minerals, probably a variety of prehnite, or bowenite, a serpentine. Moreover, these girdle ornaments, ac- cording to a first-century writer, sym- bolized by their shape the occupation of the wearer—farmers wearing ornaments repreaenting plough-handles or shares, ' and workmen those figuring axes or adzes. An almost endless variety of forms for these girdle ornaments were invented by the Chinese in ‘the course of centuries—fish-forms, dragon-forms, various animal-forms, etc., each having many symbolical meanings. Certain of them were love-tokens given by hus- bands to their wives, and these were sometimes interred with the wife’s body as protecting amulets. As Dr. Laufer writes: “The relations of a husband and wife did not cease at the moment of death; they continued to be united even beyond the grave, and expected to resume their marital relations in a fu- ture life.” In regard to the jade objects buried with the dead, denominated by Dr. Busb- ell “tomb-jades,” the author calls at- tention to what he believes to be a mis- understanding of the Chinese designa- tion han yii, interpreted to mean “jade ‘placed in the mouth (of a corpse).” He lasserts that this name always means ‘either jade of the Han period or jade of }a kind particularly used in this period, land he does not believe that there is a 'single, large comprehensive class of |“tomb-jades,” but several widely dis- ‘tinguished groups of jade objects found in Chinese tombs. | Much valuable information is given ‘touching the hammer-shaped tablets of | jade. Originally, in China, as in many |other parts of the world, this shape was brought into connection with solar wor- ship. The Chou emperors (1122-249 B. Cc.) are said to have worshipped the sun by holding in their hands hammer- shaped jade symbols of sovereignty. The hammer form was so conventionalized in process of time that it is now often difficult to determine whether a given |ceremonial tablet belongs to this cate- | gory or to some other. | Regarding the source of much of the 'old Chinese jade, Dr. Laufer, in accord with others who have treated the mat- ter, admits that it probably came from jancient Chinese quarries, all traces of which have now been lost. He states ithat Chinese antiquarians fully agree with the view that the jades of the Chou ‘and Han dynasties came from mines in |'Shensi Province, and points to Lan- 't’len and Feng-siang-fu as the chief an- leient mines, although we know that at | present neither jade nor jadeite is found | within the confines of China proper. | The so-called Nephritfrage is treated |briefly in the introduction. The discov- |ery of masses of jade in situ in various parts of Europe clearly indicates the source of much of the prehistoric jade |found in European countries, and chem- ‘ical analysis has confirmed this, not- ably the 4,700-pound mass of nephrite /jade found at Jordansmuhl, Silesia, by | Dr. Kunz in 1899, now in a Heber R. Bishop collection exhibited at the Amer- ‘fean Museum of Natural History. Dr. | Laufer, however, inclines to the belief

Page 23

Jan. 9, 1913] The Nation that the first worked jades were proba- bly acquired from an Asiatic source, and furnished the inducement to seek for a home supply of the material. Although it was not Dr. Laufer’s aim to treat of the mineralogical character- istics of nephrite or jadeite, but to con- fine himself to the cultural and religious ideas and concepts associated with them, and largely governing their use for or- namental purposes, it is somewhat to be regretted that he did not have analyses made of some of the specimens, so as more definitely to determine their source and affinities. However, collec- tors are justified in hesitating to trust their jades to the tender mercies of the analyst. The numerous, well-chosen, and excel- lently executed illustrations, 68 plates (six of them in color) and 204 text-fig- ures, display all the principal forms otf Chinese carved jade from historic times, and serve as invaluable aids to the stu- dent, making this work an eminently useful guide-book for those seeking in- formation upon this important and diffi- cult subject. Two art books will be brought out short- ly by the Putnams—“The Technique of Painting,” by C. Moreau-Vauthier, and “The Childhood of Art,” by H. G. Spear- ing The energy and consistency of Romain Rolland’s “Life of Michelangelo” (Dutton) have brought it promptly the honors of translation The work, saving bad tran- scription o! Italian names is tolerably done by Frederic Lees. That Michelangelo's life was one long tragic maladjustment between great genits and a_ hesitating will, is M. Rolland’s thesis It is ably supported from the sonnets and the well- known facts of the master’s life. The style is emphatic, nervous, at times torrential— in striking and refreshing contrast to the usually placid tone of French monographs on art. Many will feel that M. Rolland forces the note of tragedy. At least, he deserves the credit for a reading that is coherent, suggestive, and masterly. Louis B. Akin, an artist who received the commission, two years ago, to do mural paintings of Indian life for the American Museum of Natural History, died a week ago in Flagstaff, Ariz. He had just completed the work, which includes a sixty-foot panel Born in 1870, he first received public recog- nition in 1907, after an exhibition in Chicago of a year’s work among the Hopi Indians. Finance TWO IMPORTANT DECISIONS. In its weekly budget of decisions, handed down by the United States Su- preme Court on Monday, there were two of great importance. The ruling of the Court on the proposed plan for dispos- ing of Southern Pacific Railway stock in the Union Pacific's treasury, and its de- cision that the Anti-Trust law, in its criminal provisions, necessarily applies | to an attempt to corner commodities, open up far-reaching possibilities. It is more clear in the case of the corner de- cision, than in that of the Union Pacific merger, what the broader consequences of Monday's decree will be In the Union Pacific matter, counsel had proposed that the company, in di- vesting itself of its Southern Pacific holdings as previously ordered by the Court, should be permitted to allot or sell that Southern Pacific stock pro rata to Union Pacific shareholders. In defending this method of compliance with the Court's decree, argument nat- urally rested on the Supreme Court's own approval of the pro-rata distribu- tion, as applied in the dissolution of the Northern Securities and Standard Oil holding companies. In the first of these dissolutions, the scheme of dis tributing the assets pro rata to the hold- ing company’s shareholders was con- tested, carried up to the Supreme Court, and upheld by that Court in 1905; in the second of them, the Court itself, in its original decision, recognized that method of disintegration as proper. In rejecting the application of a sim- ilar plan to the Harriman merger, the Court draws distinction between a hold- ing company which is required to part with all its holdings of stock in two or more competing corporations, and a rail- way company which has merely bought control of one competitor through pur- chase of its stock. From the language of Monday’s opinion it appears that if, for example, a separate holding com- pany had been organized to hold the stock of both Union and Southern Pa- cific, and if that holding company were ordered dissolved, the assets might be distributed pro rata; but that the same expedient is inadmissible where the chief party to the suit is a powerful corporation which continues in the field. There is obviousl¥ a line of distinc- tion here; though it may be that the Court has surrounded with a good many difficulties its future adjudication of similar cases. It is true, last Monday's opinion positively restates the Court's position that “each case under the Sher- man Act must stand on its own facts,” and there is also to be remembered the Court's declaration, in the Standard Oil opinion, that “one of the fundamental purposes of the statute is to protect, not to destroy, rights of property.” But it is at least conceivable that rights of property may be impaired, though not destroyed, through departure from the pro-rata rule. That would inevitably be so in a case where forced public sale of such holdings, with the parties most in- terested eliminated from the bidding, was the only alternative recourse. The Union Pacific has no such prospect be- fore it, since not only its own sharehold- ers, but holders of the 54 per cent. of 43 Southern Pacific stock which Union Pa- cific does not own, are interested in ob taining a fair value on the sale. But how the same rule would operate, in a case where all the stock of one railway were held by another, it is not altogeth- er easy to foresee. The Supreme Court's decision regard ing corners in commodities, under the Anti-Trust law, is entirely plain, and the scope of its future application is not at all difficult to foresee. The defen dants in this case had combined in 1910, after a disastrous s) ortage in the Amer- ican cotton crop, to obtain control of the cotton actually available on the market, in quantity sufficient to make them masters of the price. The purpose and method of this conspiracy were per fectly well known on the cotton ex- changes. It had the result, first, of ad vancing the price of cotton from 13% cents a pound in November, 1909, to th: 20 cents utterly preposterous figure of a pound in August, 1919—a price never reached, outside of paper inflation days, since 1836; and, next, through the vir tual blockading of supplies except at th: prohibitive corner prices, of emphasiz- ing the world-wide depression in the cot- ton-spinning trade. The operations of Messrs. Patten, Brown, Haynes, and Scales did not primarily cause the troubles of the trade, but they unques- tionably aggravated the situation To put the matter in another way, a vi cious and brutal attempt was made to extort speculative blood-money from the misfortunes and necessities of the cot- ton consumer in a trying season The Court does not pass upon the accuracy of the facts alleged; it merely gives its judgment as to the applicabil- ity of the Sherman Act, assuming the facts to have been correctly stated. The lower court had ruled that the corner manipulators were not engaged in inter- state trade; that corners stimulate in- stead of restraining competition, and that any effect of a corner of inter state trade could be only indirect. But Monday's decision takes ground very positively that cotton as a commodity was cornered, and that cotton is a sub- ject of interstate trade; replies that even if corners stimulate competition, they do so through methods as obnox ious as the suppression of competition; and concludes by reaffirming the prin ciple that people “engaging in a con spiracy which necessarily and directly produces the result which the statute is designed to prevent,” are properly “chargeable with intending that result.” It is difficult to see how any future attempt to corner a commodity market can escape the scope of this decision. As the Government's Solicitor-General points out, such undertakings will here- after be subject to restraint, in their In ception, through Federal injunction The speculator who should try again the ea

Page 24

44 experiment 1910 ket, or of 1909 in the we add, would of in the of 1906 in the have be an reckless adventurer. may ke bold to and BOOKS OF THE WEEK Chr Praises erman, stmas ton: Sli The I reh-King I nner Life leosoph al B Ve s. Gg The Making of a Philadelphia Altemus Bradley, R. M rhe English Housewife } Seventeenth and Eighte Loagmans $3.50 net Association Year States New York Clemen, Carl Primitive Christianity Its Non-Jewish Sources Trans. by Nisbet. Scribner Clifford, John The Scribner ordanza Petrarca New Co nth Brewers Book of United R Gospel of delle Compila Haven Rime di Con Yale University. net Griffin, G tory \ ed During Report Amer Washington Harvard Unive Cambridge. Heywood Ros G Writings Bibliography 1910 on of Reprint Historical Books from Asen., reity Catalogus Here Sherman, and Ther French $1 Loulse 20 net. ton Gohdes and Buschek’s sprach- und Lesebuch H. Gonpes, Head of Department of bon Languages in the Horace Mann High School, New York City, and H. A. BuscneK, Head of German Department the Brooklyn Polytechnic Preparatory hool x +370pp 12mo $1.15 This book embodies the direct method in a form ted f American beginners and includes only which has been repeatedly tested with j f high achool age Ihe ntrotiuctory ma tert of each lesson conalets of a number f een imtrating lirectly nt coneretely some stien point This te followed by a reading im? by eimp'e and var 1 exercieos, beaed the trodnetor sentences and the reading I w he * are vided at regular intervals English sentences for transliat lee ‘ Ivanced leseons rhe book udes aleo ‘ on eystematic grammar in English for ref ence Mio a series of apecia asystemat voeabu * for encl f tl firet sixteen lessons, besides the usual Germen-English and English fierman vocabularies cotton Mar- wheat market—or, copper mar- unusually and French. ind Pub Newspaper in Centur the and G. Gladness. Francesco ta da Kenneth McKen- $10 American His- Publish- Annual 1910 1912-13 a Leaf. m are appended to 84 W RS Bt I lenry | lolt&C Oo olew York ‘The How Louis Verses Jastrow, N ation The Boston: Morris, jr. ligion Babyloniens sen Alfred Kauffman, R Saints London Kunze, J. The New Testament. by G. W. Gilmore. nts net ay b, Charles Press edition.) $1.50 net Lawton, Lancelot East 2 nard Leets, Youth Replies, and Other Sherman, French. Bildermappe zur Re- und Assyriens. Gies- Tépelmann and R. W. The Latter Day Williams & Norgate. Aposties’ Creed and the Tr. from the German Funk & Wagnalls. 75 (Riverside Mif- Old China Boston Houghton The Boston Empires of the Far vols Small, May- s and Latin Amer- Diplomacy New Orleans: Juan. United Stat ica Dollar The Author Library of Congress—Check List of Ameri- can Eighteenth Century Newspapers. Com- piled by J. Van Ness Ingram. Washington: Government Printing Office. 50 cents. Library of Congress. Report for fiscal year ending June 30, 1912. Washington: Gov- ernment Printing Office Living Church Annual Churchman’'s Almanac. Young Churchman Co. Lohr, Otto. The First Germans in North America and the German Element of New Netherland. Stechert & Co Whittaker’s Milwaukee: and 1913. Mason, J. A. The Ethnology of the Salinan Indians. University of California. Myrick Herbert Coéperative Finance. Orange Judd Co. $2.50 net Nobel Institute Catalogue de la Biblio- théque I, Littérature Pacifiste. Put- nam Paredes, J. E. The Morgan-Honduras Loan. Part III, The American Claims. New Orleans, La.: The Author. PYGMIES AND PAPUANS: The stone age of to-day in Dutch New Guinea. R. WOLLASTON. The adventures and scientific re- sults of an expedition to the Snow Mountains of Dutch New Guinea made under the auspices of the Royal Geo- graphical Society. Octavo. Profusely illustrated in color and black and white, and with maps. $4.00 net. By A. F. Studies in the Psychology of Intemperance By G, E,. PARTRIDGE, Ph,D. Author of This book relation to conditions. in science, interested dividual $1.00 net, "The Nervous Life,’’ etc. its subject in psychological and social Practical and grounded it is of special value to all in intemperance as an in- or social problem. 12mo. postpaid $1.10. considers TRAVEL PICTURES The Record of a European Tour By BHAWANI SINGH, Raj Rana Bahadur of Jhalawar With Photogravure Portrait and 96 Illustrations from Photographs by the Author. S8vo. $2.00 net; postage 1S cents This work represents the first attempt which has as yet been made by an Indian Ruling Chief to de- scribe the impressions derived from a prolonged tour in the United Kingdom and Continental coun- tries Longmans, Green, & Co, STURGIS & WALTONCO. 81-822 East 27th Street, New York. book with solid be one of my: people read it last shall “T have read your satisfaction and it pleasures to make as many as I can reach It is full mellowness—worth tons of ordinary social- ist prattlie on that subject,” writes John Graham Brooks to Charles F. Dole, author of The Burden of Poverty.” Postpaid 55 cents B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth ave., Founders of Modern Nene meee | | A New Book by Dr. G. STANLEY HALL D. APPLETON & COMPANY ~- NEW YORK Magazifie excerpts on all subjects sup- | plied. Let me know what you are inter-| ested In. H. Williams, 105 FE. 224 St., N. Y. ripeness and | New York, | bad ol. 96 No. thes a Parker, S. C. Textbook in the History of Modern Elementary Education. Boston: Ginn. $1.50. Riverdale Hymn Book. Edited by I. S. Dodd and L. B. Longacre. Revell. Robinson, J. H., and Beard, C. A. Outlines of European History. Vol. Il. Boston: Ginn. $1.60. Rosett, J. The Middle Class: A Play. Bal- timore, Md.: Phenix Publishers. Scheltema, J. F. Monumental Java. Mac- millan. Smithsonian Institution. Annual Report of the Board of Regents, for year ending June 30, 1911. Washington. Starkweather, A. M. Leaves from the City Beautiful. Boston: Sherman, French. $1.25 net. Strindberg’s Lucky Pehr: A Drama. Trans. by V. S. Howard. Cincinnati: Stewart & Kidd. $1.50 net. The Puritans’ Farewell to England. Re- printed in facsimile for the Members and Friends of the New England Society, New York. Thorburn, Reply to Christ: A Die Chris- s. Jesus the Professor Drews’ tusmythe. Scribner. Vila, A. F. The Former Countess (of Na- varre): A Romance of the French Revo- lution. Boston: Sherman, French. $1.40 net. Villari, Luigi. Gli e l’Emigrazione telli Treves. Wallin, J. E. W. Ex Mental Defectives. & York. $1.25. Watts, M. S. George Frederic Watts: The Annals of an Artist’s Life. 3 vols. Doran. $10 net per set. Work, M. C. Auction of To-day. Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Uniti d’America Milan: Fra- Stati italiana. perimental Studies of Baltimore: Warwick Boston: Thy Rod and Thy Staff By ARTHUR CHRISTOPHER BENSON Author of “‘The College Window,”’ $1.50 net; by mail, $1.65. more Mr. Benson has put forth one of his appealing and elo- quent studies in human motive; and once more he has succeeded, with un- failing certainty of touch, in getting out of his study a remarkable and im- pressive effect.” In the last of his books, which dealt with personal ex- “Ones periences, “The Silent Isle,” the au- thor promised the reader that he would some day tell how it was that the pleasant design that he had set for himself failed. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS NEW YORK LONDON a COPIES THE N ATI ON will be sent to any address for several weeks WITHOUT CHARGE ADDRESS THE NATION 20 Vesey Street New York City

Page 25