The Nation 1913-01-02: Vol 96 Iss 2479
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
now aUADENS-be ~ a fn 9 eal t Sp f eee ’ ‘The bon dh’), u 2, v. @ id : = —— A VOL. XCVI—NO. 2479 THURSDAY, JANUARY 2, 1913 mrt oa PRICE TEN CENTS The Nation Suet Published Educational PHILIP MASSINGER a DIDGEFIELD SCHOOL, Ridgefield, Connecticut. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUR PLAYS £4 deardingechest Set boys. Prepares for ied tie Edited by LUCIUS A. SHERMAN Rev. ROLAND J. MULFORD, Pb.D.. Headmaster. FOUNDED IN 1865. University of Nebraska. COLORADO [Entered at the New York City Post Office as (MASTERPIECES of the ENGLISH DRAMA TT second-class mail matter.) 70 cent ‘ THE WOLCO SCHOOL, DENVER q s Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges . " ” for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium Contains The Roman Actor, The The Nation is published and owned by the New Maid of Honour, A New Way to “T°HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. va) ¢ — ~ . ro York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, Pay Old Debts, and Believe as You sf on oo Ag a... President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul : - . ‘ . oie Gadee Ane thea 8a Menetia, , a List. With introduction on the life 156 Fifth Av.,.NewYork 610 Swetiand Bd., Portland Elmer More, Editor; Harold deWolf Fuller, As : 814 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd.,LosAngeles and work {M aye . @ os o & ge sistant Editor. and works of Massinger; notes €X- @ 920 sav. Bk Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Bik., Berkeley ae plaining all difficult phrases and Send to any address above for Agency Manual. obscure allusions; and glossary of Harlan P. French, Proj Vincent B. Wisk, Mar , = M ‘ rrepeh, ) cen | aig Taree dollare per year in advance, postpaid, i» @ a1) words not readily found in an | THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY any part of the United States or Mewico; to Canada : ies _ Tw ~ neranatul @ unabridged dictionary knows how Twenty-one years of successful ex aid perience in bringing together good teachers and $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4.00. Addresg THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. New York Cincinnati Chi good schools, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. ¥Y Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself FOOD IN HEALTH AND DISEASE By N.S. DAVIS, Jr., M.A., M.D. Northwestern University, Chicago Octave. Cloth 83.50 Postpaid. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. JUST PUBLISHED EDITORIAL ARTICLES: HISTORY OF MODERN ELE- pRB MENTARY EDUCATION ET vonseGaccdedbadsagioensdineeeoos OF a, rere ; . . », on ) Uncle Sam and His Competitors ...... 4 7 Specs Easier) — - The first part of this book reviews the + : - a ‘ ’ . 43 er inderlving ri iples econce ‘ The Massachusetts Senatorship ........ 5 of Chicago underlying principles neerning the nutri “hicag tive and other qualities of different kind The College Athlete 6 . nan , ted A ve pl gg an oe Rigg BR gn — ) e 2 noe G0 owen e 8vo, cloth, zriv+505 pages, illustrate of foods, discusses briefly their relation to $1.50 the digestive organs, and traces the changes a - en that fool must underg before it can SPECIAL ARTICLES: This carefully prepared ‘‘History of Mod be apprer riated to the moods Of the buman : ' - panhe Elementary Education’ deals primari); system “Th s is followed by detailed con The Modern Language Association . 7 with institutional developipent It empha sideration of the proper diet {ndicated for News for Bibliophiles ................ 8 sizes typical movements, institutions at r the various conditions of health and dis dividuals, thus showing e student ele ease, each condition being taken up reriatim mentary school problems from the Middle with conci« nlain directions, and diet lists CORRESPONDENCE: Ages to the present time otit th 1 ' Enough material for one hundred hours of 4 descriptive circular with list of con Railway Safety and Discipline ya's class work is provided in this book. If a Re ee ee ee ee eee 4 : > ran longer course is desired, the text may |} ‘cS . A Letter of Dr, Furness ...........-... 9 sueptemented with Rocsseau’s “Emile,” P. BLAKISTON’S SON & CO. A French Guide to French Novels .... 9% Pestalozzi's ‘‘Leonard and Gertrude,”’ and PUBLISHERS Spencer’s ‘‘Féducation."’ 1012 WALNUT ST., PHILADELPHIA ’ ‘ The publishers present this book with the LITERATURE: firm belief that it is the best one that has is i " yet been written for the student of edue ~ TEE TEU 6 nevtsestersecscenccse AO tion and the prospective teacher I Mitiodes k= oss e0e cb 6G) beste 66462 0000 BE in f m 7 - I «sc cech tenicedéxeetue Gn ‘ Read gs in A erican Con DEE i> oc cute ih 0c deecdeuee esis 11 GINN AND COMPANY stitutional History On Emerson and Other Essays ......... 12 70 Fifth Avenue, New York ee Ete TORE 6. cvsindcasdachsSéceoccse WA . Boston Chicago London Selected and edited by ALLEN JOHNSON, Larned The Last Legitimate King of France: Atianta Dalias Columbus San Frandisco Pr el ae = ry in Ya l'nl suis XV oe ee ere ee _— Pages Siglo 9p -.. vl pha aiz 1805 r = ‘The political campaign which recent loosed € m Campaign, D cececsseessasees ° was remarkable for the ignorance ontempt ED, ING, 0 sn catesind asesveasnasaees re widely exhibited of and for the prit ex of con Old English Ballads 0:02: sversnent Cou we “movie or tue 1 back : t y of the re United States are led to a new etu DO. 6.5 (bb ccdas oo 6.06 vase weeansien serials Oe By JOHN A. LONG fundamental principles of human erty which A collection of Robin Hood and other Old Eng “nieriie their government and to pew belief in wwusinente ° lish ballads, edited for the use of children and their wisdom and permanence, there is no hope ScIENCE: youth There is an appropriate introduction to for genuine Ra yh - ap nto on I 1" ares 1% : » each ballad he hook ntalt t { welcome with double warmth REA ‘G8 The Depths of the Ocean ... covcee 19| Gs Pann The book contains many charming AMERICAN CONSTITUTIONAL HISTORY, edited : by Professor Allen Johnson, of Yale University, . Cloth, 144 pages. Jiluatrated. 50 centa and we wish that Its contents might become fa DRAMA AND MUSIC D. C. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS, millar not only to students of law and politics, but : : += BOS’ ‘EW YORK ‘HICAG to the great body of American citizenship."’— Notes on German Drama 17 | BOSTON EW 2085 CHICAGO Educational Review HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY ART: LI BRARI ES A N D — NEW YORK ( on The Corcoran Exhibit .............. 19 ag BOOKS PURCHASED ES ae ae . TO ANY AMOUNT The Stock Ex hange and the Legisla- OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, Translation from Wrench and German. Bich- SEE Wab'n6l S60 ped bobadl cdeccesedbheceseeucve Oe PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT est references. Mise Julia Frankiia. care The Notice Books or THE WEEK ....... og [THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND | [YPEWRITING Jor, ier, ne icnbe Bee pool, 7 Berw .Bosto
Page 2
[Vol. 96 No. 2479 Nation THE LOEB CLASSICAL LIBRARY uniform series of classical Greek and Latin texts with parallel English translations of the highest attainable quality. Edited By M.A., and W. H. D. Rouse, Litt.D. Assisted By An Board of Eminent Scholars ew, comprehensive, T. E. Page, Advisory intellectual to our own addition to the higher and a credit } a notabdle ing hievement the English-spea The Nation FIFTEEN VOLUMES NOW READY GREEK SOPHOCLES. Vol. I. THEOCRITUS, BION, MOSCHUS (The Greek Bucolic Poets). 1 Vol. APOSTOLIC FATHERS. Vol. I. LATIN PROPERTIUS. | ST. AUGUSTINE. will be re A fine ar surces of pt opl 5, APPIAN. Vol. | APOLLONIUS RHODIUS. | EURIPIDES. Vols. |. and II PHILOSTRATUS. 2 Vols Vol. Vol. 2 Vols. shortly. Vol. | 2 Vols Five addit CICERO. TERENCE. nal volumes ady L de circular of the whole series mailed free on request. Each volume, cloth, $1.50 net; flexible leather, $2.00 net THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, 64-66 5th Ave., N.Y. scriptive Just Published THE FRANCO-PRUSSIAN WAR AND ITS HIDDEN CAUSES By EMILE OLLIVIER Translated with introduction and notes by George Burnham Ives. The real causes of the Franco-Prussian War as set forth by the head of Louis Napoleon's so-called Liberal ministry. With 8 portraits, g«arvii+520 pp. $2.50 net; by mail $2.65. Little, Brown & Co., Publishers, Boston THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YEAR ART By Auguste Rodin (Translated from the French of Paul Gsell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 illustrations In photogravure and half-tone Buckram, $7.50 net; three-quarter levant, $15.00 net; carriage ad- ditional A book which takes its place at once as the most important art book in years It covers practically the whole range of art, and abounds in memorable analyses of the works of the masters of painting and seulpture, ancient and modern, Send for descriptive circular. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston You can always find At DUTTON’S the latest books; the rare books; illustrated books of all kinds; cards, calendars and art novelties. 31 West 23d St. READ MONTGOMERY’S NEW BOOK CHRONICLES OF AVONLEA ty the ithor of ““ANNE OF GREEN GABLES,”’ ETC. been sok er 200,000 copl Postpaid 81.40 “At McCLURG’S” and importance that the ertised Die pur ntiage Public Libraries, creer Schools, Collenes | sstreiae f nou of wi or" ~ have Net 81.25. i ad ex erpts on know what Williams, 105 new cana, now your last book with solid shall be one of my og ae to make as many people read it is I can reach. It is full ripeness and mellowness—worth tons of ordinary social- ist prattle on that subject writes John Graham Brooks to Charles F. Dole, author of “The Burden of Poverty.” Postpaid 55 cents. B, W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth ave., New York. LIBRARY RESEARCH and Harvard Libra- Translation, read and it “IT have satisfaction Researches made in Boston ries Ancient and modern languages revision of manuscripts, ete MISS M. H 96 Chestnut Street, BUCKINGHAM, Boston, Mass. and Universities to these books we nally large all pul ion pl te as ) found on othey hook We pondence from li with niry unacquainted ties Put tha other try into thousands of families. n any LIBRARY DEPARTMENT School Advertising in The Nation Nation statids alone in its feld. politico-literary journal published in this coun- going to all the principal libraries and reading rooms, and It an a larger circula ion A. C. McClurg & Co. CHICAGO The circulation is chiefly among the thinking and well-to-do classes lawyers, physicians, bankers, and other professional men— and in the homes of cultivated people, where the education of children is a matter of careful consideration. rate is re ‘asonable, and discounts are made on continuous insertions, of w ! ) schoc rertis avail them- Plays and Players in Modern Italy ee of which most of the school advertisers avail them sCives., ! f ti Ita bh stage ff atte sa i life, manners \dvertising rates, 1: the following discounts: ! § insertion SPECIAL RATE--Ten Cents a (Mir The ——, with on agate line each insertion, on 4 insertions, 10 per cent. cents an S er cent. By ADDISON McLEOD ; with yal fiona £2.75 wet” line net for thirteen times three Serge! A&A » Chienge nim spe lines) fhartes be forwarded rnanirs any responsible aclvertising agency, or directly to Nation, 20 Vesey Street, Orders may THE N. Y. ABLIdtE m 1887 ECTOR ; i Cort!
Page 3
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 2 rT T » The Week President Taft’s acceptance of the of- fer of a professorship from Yale Uni versity is another answer to the ques tion: “What shall we do with our ex Presidents?” As in the case of Mr. Cleveland at Princeton, it is an alto- gether satisfactory one. Nothing could be more dignified than such a profes- sorship, and certainly no one who has been through the hurly-burly of a White House term could fail to find the quiet and the opportunity for contemplation and study afforded by a university as celightful and refreshing a contrast as he Mr. Taft will did Mr. Cleveland, a much larger audi- could wish. have, as ence than that which comes to hear him New public service will not be lacking, should al Haven, and opportunities for he desire them. This is far better than tiiat Mr. sion, whether provided by Congress or Mr. Carnegie or anybody else. At least it been felt till Put times are changing, and every on¢ Taft should retire on a pen- 80 would have lately. is coming to believe that somebody elses he sight owes him a pension by the time reaches seventy. Certainly, the o; Mr. Taft engaged in vigorous intel- lectual effort and earning adequate fuancial support thereby is in every way a better example for the country than would be his settling down at his ease somewhere on $25,000 a year. Complete returns of the Presidential election are now available. Instead of a falling off of about 400,000 in the total vote, there was a gain of about 150,000 as compared with the vote of 1908, the totals being (in round num- bers) 15,040,000 and 14,890,000, respec- tively. for the women added to the voting pop If allowance be made, however, ulation in California and Washington, and for the addition of Arizona and New Mexico to the list of States, must deduct a round half million o1 more from the vote of 1912, leaving fully 350,000 below the vote of four years ago; whereas if the total : grown in a measure corresponding to would the advance in population, there The ive been an increas a million instead of this decrease of This is a curious showing, and =0.000 opens up large possibilities for conjec- tural explanation. But any one who may essay such a task must go behind the immediate comparison, for the course of the Presidential vote is very peculiar. Thus, the total in 1892 was 12,000,000, in 1896 it rose to 14,000,000, in 1900 it was the same, in 1994 it fell to 13,500,000, and then in 1908 reached the high mark of 14,900,000. But after all is said and done, the fact stands out that, allowance made for the new wo- man voters, the vote in 1912 is only 3 or 4 per cent. greater than it was six- teen years ago, whereas the population about cent. How- be 1896 was quite abnormal in has increased per ever, it must remembered that the election of intensity of interest. minor ell Of the two prominent parties fared and the ill. a situation in which either of the great the Socialists very Prohibitionists Time when, in as parties—and especially the Republican was in a condition of demoralization, the Prohibitionists expected to profit perceptibly by the disaffection; but their vote this year was 50,000 below that of four years ago—203,000, as against 253,000—in spite of a gain of 17,000 in California and Washington. As for the Debs vote, which went up from 421,000 to 898,000, it owes no less than 76,000 of this increase of 477,000 to its gain in California and Washing- ton, where the Socialist vote of 1908 vas almost trebled in 1912. In Illinois, Ohio, and Pennsylvania the Debs vote was much more than doubled, and its increase in these States was 46,000, 56,- 000, and 47,000, respectively. In New York, the increase was only 65 per cent., and amounted to 25,000; while Massa chusetts and Rhode Island, where a striking increase might have been ex light increase, pected, show only a very and indeed a very small total—13,000 and 2,00C, respectively, being tl poll ade by Debs th ir in ft se two intensely industrial Sta rhe onviction o § é 4) men accused of participati« in the great dynamiting conspira: san event ation of something like whose importance, as affecting the f ture of organized labor, hardly requires setting forth. When the true nature of the connection between a number of labor-union men and the La Angeles outrage was first brought to light, there followed a curious oscillation of opin both among the great labor leaders and among the devotees of humanitarianism and social service In neither case dé we mean to include all of the class in question; in both cases we do mean to include a very considerable proportion What happened was first an outburst of indignation and resentment that charges of made against such atrocious conduct should be men high in the councils of labor; but when it became pretty evi dent that the charges were true, the ground was shifted to the position that though these things may have been done, yet they must not be regarded as ordinary crimes, but as the natural man ifestation of social discontent. We er solemnly adjured not to exact punish ment from the offenders, but rather to profit by the lesson they had taught, and set our house in order All this now has a very far-away sound The pro- cesses of justic ent on quietly, in their ancient ways; they dealt with this crude and barbarous conspiracy just as they would have dealt with an ordinary case of burglary or assault or ars they have come to their destined end, and the foundations of society remain unshaken by so much as the faint est tremor. The contemplation of this extraordi nury case cannot fail to present to t mind an impressive vindication of t jury system. Not because the tria sulted in a conviction rather than an acquittal; but because this conviction recorded as the unanimous judgment of twelve men taken out of the general mass of citizens by a process carefu designed to insure fairness and im tiality, carries weight of a sort no other method yet suggested cé | supply. It is impossible to suppose that these thirty-eight men would have beer ed guilty by the united judgm« those twelve plain Americar vidence of their guilt had been « The of any group of ] | 'rigivVve vé ne clusi lge, no judgment of no } udges, would be accept-
Page 4
‘) ~ ed by all classes with the same confi- bias or if required anything less than a unan- of an- the dence in its freedom from imus Still plainer is it that law im ous rdict, the moral effect the disastrously im- vils connected with here are often eXas- s from the require but in the things the things which ] hol relation of he law, the benefits criminal cases by jury, requirement of unanimity in them, vastly outweigh Pennsylvania politics these days is enough to make Senator Quay turn in Har- be in his grave Instead of a caucus at to killed the risburg, in which ambitions Speaker may conveniently be accordance with the will of boss, the fight this time is likely to go to the floor of the House, and nobody will ven- ture a prediction of the result. Dis- treseing as it is to all patriotic citizens, erstwhile reform partners, F'!inn the and Magee, differ as to who should be Speaker, and it is even said that Magee may throw his strength to a third can- didate, and is put,forward by the Vare brothers, who comes from Philadelphia those famous representatives of the con- of rival tractor-politician public man of the type Any various groups is if its one ready to stay out of the caucus ends will be served by such a course. The situation is further complicated by fact tl both at many Representatives rin Re- publican tickets, and so are in a poai- tion be the upon Washington party and to independent of any of the would-be dictators. To the triple divi- sion of the Republicans, the Democrata a united front, and will fight tor of result of these divisions should of oppose a legislative programme their own. ‘The net be unusually important, and he has already to make the attitude Gov. Tener announced his determination to use his veto unsparingly of the will wrest- Wilson's commendation Gov Pardons as an institution He ling with what is undeniably one of the if not quite the the Court of carry weigh*. has just been most try- with trying of which a most ing, al responsibilities Gc ernor is charged, the de | to The Nation cision of the question of life or death, of freedom or confinement, in scores of in- dividual cases pressed upon his atten- tion for the most diverse possible rea- He this most delicate function, the conclu- sons. feels that, in the exercise of sions arrived at by the Court of Par- dons are of the greatest public use, these being based, he says, on conscientious and capable inquiry by the members of There urged on the the court are considerations trat can be other side, but the prima fa case in favor of the cre- ation of some body charged with the duty of systematic inquiry into the mer- pardon is very its. of applications for strong bill to pay the National of the In aid of the of Federal Treasury, the Adjutant-General of New Guard of this State a pamphlet expjain- Guard the several States out York has officially issued to the ing the bill, giving in twenty-six pages all the reasons why it should become a law. This is characteristic of the thor- oughness with which sentiment for the It in the name of patriotism and ediciency. measure is worked up. is done Do you not want an effective militia? Then, if you do, keep quiet and iet us get our hands into Uncle Sam’: pocket- book to the tune, at first, of eight to eleven millions of dollars, and, of coursc, a much larger sum later. It is surely a trifling price to pay for a real army re- serve. Thus it appears that, by simply paying the sol- So runs the argument. diers for attending drills, to which they now come voluntarily without pay, we our militia efficient over- shall make night. Now, if all the troubles of the Nation- al Guard were due to a poor attend- ance at drills, something might be said for this reasoning. But every one fa- miliar with the militia knows that non- attendance at drills is not the chief evil correct; he knows, moreover, even if the men were paid, some of the conditions which make for non-attend- ance would still remain. Of the militia’s the election many weaknesses, perhaps greatest are the selection and of officers by the men in the ranks and political interference with the Guard. Is there the slightest belief anywhere that the paying of the troops by the Federal Government will remove politics from the militia? It is much more likely to that | two! No. 2479 [ Vol. 96, ' intensify the struggle for the places of importance. So long, moreover, as the election of officers continues, a chief source of inefficiency will remain in- tensified by the desire of an officer, who may be in pecuniary need or pecuniar- ily ambitious, to succeed his captain or his major. Again, it is asserted that pay “well-educated young We have no mean opinion of our presen: the cannot see how one dollar a week would would attract men” and a “better class of men.” citizen soldiers; on contrary, we be an inducement to any more young collegians or high-school graduates to join. A man goes into the militia either because of a patriotic desire to serve the State, or because he desires a club, reg- ular exercise, and the fun of wearing « uniform and going to camp. The indictment of President Mellen of the New Haven and Messrs. Chamber- lin and Smithers of the Grand Trunk, under the of the Anti-Trust ctliar and novel questions—in addition to the fact that the prosecution will be of persons on a criminal charge. It is undoubtedly true that if a “combination , conspiracy clause law, brings up some pe- er conspiracy in restraint of trade” was carried out by the managers of these cumpeting railways, the offence was committed after the law had been de- fined, interpreted, and applied by the highest court, and not, as in the North- ern Securities and tke Southern Pa- cific cases, for instance, when its inter- pretation was in doubt. On the other hand, the present case is not on all fours with any case previously adjudi- cated. The Grand Trunk was not bought up by the New Haven, and, on the basis of the final agreement, not even the jrand Trunk’s Vermont extension was to be sold to the New Haven—though that seems originally to have been con- templated. The formal basis of the agreement affected the joint inter- change of business by each of the two companies over the lines of the other, including the New Haven’s promise “to protect Grand Trunk, in every way in its power, in its present differential rates from New England points and such new territory as it is proposed to open up to it.” The Government will presumably con- tend, first, that the real purpose of the companies was indicated in the original
Page 5
Jan. 2, 1913] ‘The Nation agreement, whereby the was to sell its New England lines to the New ted abandonment secondly, that the admit- of the Grand Trunk’s Haven; work on the proposed competing exten- sions in New England was the real con- cition for the final understanding. But as regards the latter consideration, the case will differ materially from pre- vious anti-Trust cases, in that the New Faven's competitor merely ceased to extend its facilities for competition. If the Grand Trunk officers testify that their company’s financial condition had not warranted continuance of the ex- penditure on the new extensions, or that the money market was such that the requisite capital could not be rais- ed, then the argument that abandon- ment of the new extensions was a re- sult of will not be te conspiracy sO easy maintain. As it happens, there is ground for both the above contentions in the known situation of the day. In the absence of any documentary evi- dence that the extensions were aban- doned because of counter-offers from the Government's to the agreement as to rates and Haven, the case limited New would be in scope na- ture of the division of traffic, made after the Grand Trunk’s decision to stop its new con- struction. Much more than any of the recent leading anti-Trust cases, there- fore, this case of will have to be settled cr the basis the evidence. Popular disapproval of the New Haven’s meth- ods,and popular agitation over the con- duct of that road, must not prevent the general public from giving full and fair consideration to such evidence—espe- cially when, as on this occasion, the criminal clauses of the law have been distinctly invoked. Little by little, scholarship is picking up courage to defend itself against the of athletics. vances the claim that its representatives pretensions It now ad- cutlive those of its great rival activity. The. Harvard Graduates’ Magazine has compiled vital of the classes from 1860 to 1884, and it finds that among these the statistics 1910 the percentage of deaths 30.41 in 3,500 individuals was But the percentage for the elected mem- 27.51. bers of Phi Beta Kappa was only Moreover, since the 3,500 include tli 719 “first scholars,” the real advantag: of the latter in respect of longevity is not shown until we get the percentag: 3yrand Trunk for these classes exclusive of their Phi Reta Kappa members. This is 31.69, aud thus it appears that the expectation of life for a Phi Beta Kappa man, at Harvard at least, is markedly gvea than that of his unks yed classmate To complete the triump! the Vagazin« goes on to point It that it is i | in spite of the fact that very few Phi Beta Kappa men athlet during heir undergraduate day and that in after li tl Da on st ething mol than long | bears the name ( i Presider and \ Presi dent of the United States ol veral Covernors, Ambassadors ind Cabinet officers; of half a dozen college and uni- versity presidents . ; of financie: bankers, and heads of railroads and oth- er corporations. . .; of judges of th United States d other Supreme an Courts; of lawyers, physicians, and sur- geons of national reputation; of many professors and deans; of many authors and editors; of the leading American engineer of his time; and of theologians, preachers, and philanthropists.” No valid reason exists why Edward EF". Mylius should be refused admission to this country because of his convic- tion in England of having published a libel against the King. If the story of George V’s rumored secret marriage had been brought forward by Mylius with a view to blackmail, his conviction would undoubtedly have involved the element of moral turpitude, on the basis of which he might be deported from our gt ores. But it seems plain that the pub- lication of the story was in the nature of a political act. It the was done avowed- ly to discredit British monarchy, and was printed in a British anti-mon- This execrable archical paper published in Paris. the taste and, as the evidence adduced tend- attack on King was in ed to show, baseless. But, after all, the in political fight- The English ple are themselves jealous enough of the violation of good tast« ing is not a crime. peo- right of political asylum not to inter- rret the admission of Mylius into this country in any but the proper light The secret of long life has been re vealed by Admiral Dewey Join th navy, force your way into a mine-pro tected harbor, and attack the enemy's ships at their moorings, and keep away from public banquets. The 12-in gun has slain its thousands, but the {]l-cook ed lobster has rendered ts tens of thousands, thus ii peace, too, hath he $s and t s. it is gi ull of s i beha orag i t nis privile i to l lefence of | | hich a to o remarka! per S } i ling do 1 yn | cl I if the diz ] l pror imentos,in t ert pected ruth vh lated public dinner is bound hereby endangering d i the young and destroying the reputa for sobriety of many respectab! zens Bad food and poor talk a ’ combination fatal to the sound nan system. It has been written Avoid the groaning bx The devilled crab, the Melbas But, deadliest of all, avoid rhe after-dinner spe The territorial demands by the representatives of t states in the London peace “ould restrict Turkey in Eur triangle included between a Midia, on the Ble of Mar drawn from the Sea The possessions would be reduced hkodosto, on the Bosphorus Sultan's than 65,000 square miles to of less than 2,000 square mil however, than this severe is the fact that, under such a ment, Constantinople would be absolut ly at the mercy of the Bulgar lished at Rodosto. If Bulgar outside of the Dardanelles, tl be, in the case of a thing of a chance for the ed as they would be on the land side b: i the Tchatalja fortifications, and on tly | sea by the Bosphorus and the Darda nelles. To accept the allies’ demand would be to leave Constantinople t ist entirely on sufferance. It is not supposed that the allies will insist getting all they have asked for in first breath. They are simply following — } the traditional form of diplo It failure gling. is also premawire t a of negotiations ence between 65,000 square HH s miles is larg uare permit bargaining and concs ara my formul; amputa.i0' future war, som Turks, guard 1 pea he Balkan confer! ope to base lin: awk Seu, to mora, and European from lor a pitta en WW i h arra! lans esta ‘la kept 18 might ere mati O Bpeal rhe YY r g ‘ ssions
Page 6
The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2479 BRYAN ON SENIORITY. 7 perplexing. It must have been very hard, | Affairs Committee, had eighteen years nk that the rumors of Mr. Bry- for example, for his colleagues on the of service in Congress behind him. It already opening war on President bench of the Supreme Court of the Unit-| has often been said that it is ridiculous Wilson are, as Mark Twain said of the ed States to sign a letter, as they did to have a man of his kind in charge eport of his death, “much exaggerat- years ago, notifying a brother-judge of ©f such an important committee. But rhe Commoner editorial calling great age that his powers had obviously s'!ance down the list of his Democratic Democrats in Congress to failed and that he ought to resign. colleagues, and find a fitter chairman if rugele against reactionaries, ‘was It is, however, the particular situa- you can. Would it be Mr. Garner, of en before the editor's in-| tion in Congress that is at present de- Texas, or Mr. Difenderfer, of Pennsyl- vith Mr. Wilson. If after, it is| bated. The objection is not so much to! Vania? Who would dare to say? Even that he was expressing eld men as to wrong-headed men. It is| a party caucus, even Mr. Bryan himself, which the President-elect not merely new blood that is desired, with a perfectly free hand, could not rhe latter knows something | but new ideas. The point is made that make bricks without straw. government by committees in| the Democratic party is committed to That truth will be very evident in the s, a8 witness his early book on/| certain policies, borne in on the tide of next House. The large and unwieldy at subject, and possibly may feel as recent popular sentiment, and that some | Democratic majority will contain great ongly as Mr. Bryan that the men/of the older Democrats in Congress are | numbers of untried men. In the nature iced in leading positions in the new not sufficiently in sympathy with them. | of the case, they will not be pushed to ress should not be there simply be-| Only on that ground is the demand /|the front. Call it seniority or what you they have long years of public) made that the rule of seniority shall be | will, something will dictate placing in behind them. Why do not some no longer left supreme. There is unde-|the most influential positions members e ingenious commentators on Mr. niably force in this, so far as a few spe-| Who are familiar with the procedure, who n's declaration against the rule of cial cases are concerned. Look, for in-| have gone through the mill, who know ority see in it a purpose to relieve stance, at the existing Committee on| what to do and how to do it. Viewed Vilson of trouble? Mr. Bryan himself Finance in the Senate. This is the com-| in that light, seniority means common now a senior, and if all seniors are! mittee which will have most to do with sense. It is also to be remembered that nade to take a back seat, may we shaping bills for revising the tariff. The | a man of real force is not long overlook- lude that he, far from seeking ranking Democratic Senator is Bailey,|«c in Congress. Senator O’Gorman, Cabinet portfolio, will decide not to but he is shortly to retire. Next to him | though a “new man” in the Senate, was er superfluous on the stage? If it is' eomes Senator Simmons, of North Caro-| soon charged with important committee iestion of interpretations too clever} lina. Under the old plan, he would be | assignments. And there are other ways alf, this is as well worth consider- made chairman, when the Senate be- of making talent and power felt. It was as the others comes Democratic. But he is known as| long a just reproach to the Republi- rhe real question which Mr. Bryan a_ half-protectionist. He would fight cans, before they lost the House, that raised respecting the organization tooth and nail—in committee room, at/ they had organized it without brains at gress deserves serious considera- least—in favor of keeping every grain|the top. Cannon and Payne and Dal- It has both its general and its in-| of protection which North Carolina in- zell undertook to lead, but they were dual aspects. For many years the dustries think they enjoy. Plainly, he| not the men whom the House heard of seniority has prevailed in Con-! is not the ideal chairman for a commit-| gladly, or recognized as the real intel- ess. Men longest there get the best tee entrusted with carrying out Demo-/lect of the party. That is the task of imittee assignments This used to) cratic tariff pledges. Farther down the all successful party management—to get pointed out as the chief reason for list stands the name of Senator Wil- to the front the men who ought to be extraordinary influence of the Maine |iams. All impartial men must agree there. Merit is often connoted by seni- megressional delegation. That State that he would be a far better chairman ority, and when that is the case, the ept sending the same Senators and than Simmons; and if the rule of seni- rule of seniority is a good one; but if it epresentatives, term after term; and ority prevents it, so much the worse for implies keeping in high positions men ime did the rest Nor is this mere! the rule. of Bourbonish mind, who have ceased ine or rule of thumb. There is In the House, seniority has not been to think or to grow, there ought to be nd reason for the preference, in gen-| gy absolutely dominant as in the Senate. | a way of making the rule more honored ral, of the experienced man, All other’ Moreover, under the reformed proce-| in the breach than in the observance. gor on that principle, and/| dure, committee chairmen are not ap- not the public business? Of pointed by the Speaker, but elected by there must be limits to its appli-|the party caucus. Yet it is curious to UNCLE SAM AND HIS COMPETITORS, even when we are dealing with observe how, even in such a choice, “Loeb Quitting to Go with the Gug- utter abstractl) Lord Rosebery seniority prevails. Mr. Underwood holds | genheims’—that was an interesting bit here, referring to men In the most important chairmanship; he| of news to relieve the noiseless tenor of it seniority which often has been continuously in Congress for | the Christmas morning newspaper head- Against that, whatever eighteen years. The chairman of the| lines. The plain prose of the matter idopted bas always to be on’ Judiciary Committee, Mr. Clayton, has) is, doubtless, simply that Mr. Loeb. is u! The cases of difficulty are been a Congressman for sixteen years.| going to take hold of his new work for tut are admittedly! Mr. Suer, at the head of the Foreign! the same reason that led him to take
Page 7
Jan. 2, 1913] hold of the New York Collectorship— that he feels the place will give him a chance for the exercise of great abili- ties as an organizer and administrator But there is poetry in the thing, too tragic or comic, as you will. For here is Mr. Roosevelt's pupil and right-hand man, his trusty and well-beloved per- sonal aide in the White House, pass- ing directly from the service of the peo- ple to the service of the arch-enemy of the people. There are malefactors and malefactors, but Guggenheim is a magic name that spells more kinds of malefac- tor of great wealth than any other that can be produced. In his recent cam- paign the Colonel used the word as a sort of handy abridgment of his whole vocabulary of condemnation. Lorimer was good for some purposes, Penrose for some, Archbold for some, but Gug- genheim was always in order. From stealing of lands to stealing of conven tions, there was nothing rotten in the country or in the Republican party but Guggenheim was its crowning embodi- ment. One does not know whether to laugh or to weep at the thought that the man who for seven years was in the closest possible association with the apostle of righteousness should hav selected for his future work, out of all the possibilities before him, the serving of the Guggenheim interests. jut, except for this singular conjun¢ ture of personalities, Mr. Loeb’s transfer of activities is far from exceptional. In deed, it is the very thing that one ex pects in the case of any servant of the national Government who has success fully filled a difficult post. High Treas ury officials have, in recent years, been pretty steadily gravitating towards the great places in the business world; and even in the case of men whose adminis- or skill in dealing with trative power, men, has been displayed in fields having no relation to finance or commerce, cpenings in high financial or business capacities have been found awaiting them when, either of their own motion cr because of a change in the Presi- dency, they were ready to relinquish their official posts. That there are in stances in which the attraction of great pecuniary emoluments has of itself drawn away from the public service men whose abilities it was unfortunat: that the country could not continue t command, is undeniable; but there is no in which, as a matter of pract way The Nation fact, this can be avoided. The Govern- ment should offer salaries that do not tceo grossly fall short of those that can be commanded by men of ability in pri- vate enterprises; but it cannot under- take to compete, upon a purely pecuni ary basis, with the great rewards which, in these days of gigantic inter ests, special ability can command in the world of business. It must rely in large part on the attraction which the iaea of public service presents, reinfore ed, as this has so strikingly been in a number of instances, by tl extraord rary advantage, in the way of general recognition and consequent advance rent either in public office or in private undertakings, offered by the possibili ties of effective work in the Govern Inent service, Of course, as regard the highest posts in that service—Cabinet offices, judgeships, and others—the ap peal to honorable ambition and to ] otic feeling must ever be thought of as the dominant factor. There is one aspect of this id stream of able public officers going back into private life wl des es sp i] consideration from a vy pra il standpoint. While a considerable pai of the movem: il there is wother rge part ( l be a d ed, to the ¢ it £ t | ( I ill t excep hat invo que ) li l ( n ( the i 1 Ad n ation were eld i | l ent tenul there 1 be tra tion in the Govern t t way down tl ine ni i . 2 does not at all hold out for men of ity and ambition. The beneficial sul of such a change would be many-sided Men in the lower ranks in a given de partment of work would feel that it was worth while to train for mastery of that field. Those who had reached the ton would feel far less disper d than at present to cast about for a private ope! ing. And, what would in iny cases be the most important of all, the accumu lated experience and special skill of these permanent officers would be ever at the call of the Governmer f di f It questior cal up for cor lera tior In retiring fro t ( p ol I port of N } I cal look back upon four ye of hard work ably done The d gu ture of | administration ¢« t off i been the lew without distinction o ial or political positior tures connected with ustoms duties from ire offensive in the high standing humiliation coming back to their na S poss le that Mr. Loe l that ould | dor nuisance within bound sence is essentially in of tual s hy pe n sine l Mr. Loeb des praise for his pers ( nforcement of th ] Hy} WA; 1CHUSETT SHIP Ihe oming election t r { ine re Miassachusetts I vl n. The Set it e Republican t! November els ‘ CO rno Ip iva ortification « en ote ol! i state Z0 Pre l ca f t} f ‘ tha ith il t 1} n ‘ _ ! thing i K i publ «hi las t 7 Dp i ( end ‘ to d f a Senator Phere mitroversy ove! a Senatorial cau decid the matte! usly denounced by espe illvy thos Irom etts. All told, the impa the State to ; t ae did Lodge's fight ir ago \ gn of t terest in the | ilt t ( the Senatorial t Mr. Charles Frat Ad W. Eaton, Rep lature f the t (dan ‘ Ada | Nias l I Seni Tl ] tion of part cont! politics put y! ort > rigorous entor
Page 8
Page 9
Jan. 2, 1913] upon achieving it. One notable coach at a famous Eastern university a dozen years ago was so fortunate as to have a brother who was teaching in a Middle attended Is it any wonder that for Western college, by sinewy farmer boys. a long period the teams of the univer- sity were built around stocky lads who of the West? is that of the came out A better known instance most famed pre- paratory school athlete of his day, who, as the time drew near for going to col- lege, kept more than one university in more than one State in hot water. In the end, he went to the university whose location would naturally have been thought sufficient to decide the point, and gave it four years of brilliant it looks back to achievement upon which with pride, and an occasional sigh, this day. It is as difficult to draw the line be- tween proper and improper inducements to a promising athlete to go to a cer- it the difference between speculation and gam- tain university, as is to define biing. Dean Briggs put his finger upon the sore spot in his opening address at the convention of the National Collegi- ate Athletic Association, when he urged the elimination of the professional spirit from college athletics. For the exist- ence of this spirit, many causes may be responsible, but the outstanding one is the attitude of alumni. A graduate goes back to his university once a year, per- haps, meanwhile keeping track of its progress by what he finds about it in the newspapers. Now, what he is likely to see in the newspapers is either the procuring of a handsome addition to the endowment or the winning or losing of athletic contests, and what he desires to when he makes his periodical see visit to the scholastic shades of his alma mater is a new building and an athletic victory. It is one thing for a Board of Trus- tees and Faculty to stand out against undergraduates; it is quite another to take a position against what seems the united voice of the President of the United States has been known to forget his favorite doctrine alumni. Even a of the square deal long enough to write the president of his university, request- ing the strengthening of a crew by the restoration to it of a student who had violated a rule relating to scholastic work, The way out has for some time been seen to lie in codperation. What The Nation can attempt only with diffi } one colle ge culty, a group of colleges can do with ease—if they really wish to do it. Suggestion tor here's the rub. Every purifyin college athletics raises the unspoken how will t If reins of at the query, his ailect my team? those in wh hands are the ose hletic direction could be sure iat alumni would supp them in rt the policy of seeking genuine amateur sport first, and victory second, they ten be inclined towards and nore measures that are now n needed. But the alumni should do much more They should not merely set the seal of their approval upon honorable but they shou ld be the first and most insistent i: ’ ' ne iit Mills demanding that tolerated. LANGUAGE TION. THE MODERN ASSOCIA The Modern thirtieth annual meeting of the Association, Friday, the | attended and Language d niversity vas held on Thursday, of wee k, at Pennsylvania, was largels al urday last ge nerally iccess Hall, furnished as pronounced a Houston where the papers we: read, a pleasant auditorium, with numerous lounging rooms for those Which the des well partially decid- had also ar the Frank Hotel Nor- enlivened by and the “Mihi Igitur’’; informal conferences at of past writers, as as of tinles ncoming scholars, are ed. The ranged two smokers, one lin Inn, the other the mandie. The latter Goethe 0 Local Committee at at was songs of and Heine old Propositum” and “Gaudeamus aud Prof. John A. cialty places him almost in the class of academic standbys est Lomax, whose spe- professional entertainers, sang some of his cowboy songs. Many of the papers, because of their very particular interest and bearing, may be passed over. Prof. A. H. Upham, of Bryn Mawr, showed the the t thirty century, a large, in years existence las during the seventeenth England, of of clearly defined reaction against the idea of woman which had been fostered by immorality England France. Mary Astell, to whom the say in Defence of the Female doubtfully attributed, was only one of many advocates of right to equal privilege in literature and learn- ing, rather than in affairs; the phases of the agitation ran parallel, in every case, to those of the woman move- ment in France. On Thursday evening the president of the Association, Prof. C. H. Grandgent, read an address on “The Dark Ages” which enjoyed a succes de scandale. For and “Es- Sex” courtly in is woman's and terests, at his hands the Dark Ages pr: ] be, not the period usually so-called, but the present day With Charl ene great capacity for interest and kn edge, and his contempt for any per not so constituted, Professor Grande: ontrasted modern tendencies i) the first age he said to belie A le’s statement ‘all men de kno So far hav e departed tua d ol tha 4 p ia politics in i up und ion of knowing something. A s i ammed full of mere knowledg: ‘ ld In the absence of a | of s sort,” retorted P1 r Grandgent, “let us assume or t literature, painting, and mu da e pointed out the lack dards, due to self-confident ignoranc ind to total disregard of the thoug!) past ages. The one aim in art, as in i. to “shock one’s grandmother \ oO dge, but pows is th i And as it is easic » « uf I than a sweet i rr, th 3 iz e stench the louder is the app: “How strong' For thos pall less methods of teaching = » longer upon a robust the memory, the speaker i ld but still serviceable n the sweat of thy face shalt ead,’ and charged them with | ucational cubists striving for il of “four square with nothing in de Words like these from on frofessor Grandgent’s position can fail to have a good effect, and we ma ppose that they will be reiterated their author at certain other meeting during the year Supplementary to Professor Grand gent's paper was one given the follo ing day by Prof. J. W. Cunliffe, of lumbia. He made a plea for the stu of contemporary writers, and uttered wholesome caveat against the spirit « antiquarianism. He would not neg! the work of preceding ages, but beli: that in Hardy and Shaw and Kiplins the student would find matter of grea interest Scholarly concentration upc men who are holding the public to-da would also furnish people with sour standards of criticism, and thus mis forestall absurd literary vogues Wi can imagine, too, that the machinery with which the investigation of, sa the Middle Ages is often lumbered wy would experience speedy correction it were applied to living writers Though not greeted in the Philad phia press by the startling headlins which confronted Professor Cunliff suggestions, Dr. Percy Long's pap: was almost as revolutionary He at tempted to demolish the tradition whi has set up a friendship of the intimacy Sidney and Courthope this friendship between Spense! regards the mainspring of Sidney's literary in large Mackail traces to it, in oved t i greatest as
Page 10
Elizabetha But in point of fact no eviden The Nation n NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. [ Vol. 96, No. 2479 ' ‘They later passed into the possession of Samuel Sewall and remained in the Sewall sts. When all the court Under the title of “The Fascination of family until some forty years ago, when . |Books” (Putnam), Joseph Shaylor has col- they were acquired by George Brinley, of A ee ae 1 a series of papers, on book-publish- Hartford. At the sale of his great library a ) hscgthntgega live: g and book-selling topi contributed by the almanacs for 1646, 1647, 1648, and 2 =e so him to the Nineteenth Century, Fortnightly 1650 were purchased by the late John Boyd ation existing between them. Review, Publishers’ Circular, and other Eng- | Thacher, of Albany, the Lenox Library be- , tradition received the 1 periodicals. Some of his subjects are ing the buyer of the issue for 1649. From Prot. ¢ Gauss, of Prince- irly Victorian Bookselling,” “The Christ- Mr. Thacher the four almanacs passed into hed his reasons for mov- is Book.” “The Evolution of the Bookseil- the library of the late E. Dwight Church, dat of Rousseau’s “Discours er.” “Booksellers’ Trade Dinner Sales,” | and now belong to Mr. Henry E. Hunting- l'écon e politique” from 1750, or | “The Use and Abuse of Book Titles,” and ton. Unique copies of the almanacs for 1656 vo later, to 1755. as not written until afte turn from Geneva, Oct i, and sin it appears to b al part of the volume of the edia in which it is contained, | p, »” “The Gen keiy reference to several of the othe Professor Gauss maintains tha au's intellectual intimacy witl must have lasted longer thar ipposed Other results o som ol them swe ping, wil worked out in due time. Schelling took “Some Re Applications of Demi-Science t Prof. E Ss. Me r, of Western Reserve, had ar peare severely to task paper on the employment o ; literature m Fontane, Ibsen, and Suder L.eitmotif by writers of bed to Wagner, was coined by Han: According Bookselling and the Public.” and 1657 are in the American Antiquarian In “The Christ: Book” he gives an Society’s collection, the richest of the kind account of the Annuals, which were so | anywhere. Up to 1700 Dr. Nichols locates I )- e riod, beginning about 1820 lr venir” were among the t | engravings by the best artists and “fugitive” erous and so successful for a long pe- | copies of sixty-eight different issues, of “Friendship’s | which the Society possesses forty-three; 479 Offering.” “The Keepsake,” “The Book of | issues are recorded from 1700 to 1800, of ‘and the “Literary Sou- | Which the Society possesses 367, and 513 is- most popular. Stee: sues from 1800 to 1850, of which the Society has 477. 1 poetry by forgotten writers make up the According to Isaiah Thomas, the almanac , ntents of these one-time favorites. for 1639 “began with the month of March,” f he paper on trade-dinner sales is, per- | #nd this was a peculiarity of all the New | |haps, the most interesting one in ne vol- England almanacs until 1687. In all ex- ume. The publishersused to issue catalogues isting copies for this period March is given ‘ which were distributed among “a _ select number of booksellers of London and West- | twelfth. Although the month of March was minster” (as the titles of some of them the legal beginning of the year in England ) *|read), and the 1 at half-past two o'clock precisely.” After , catalogue were sold to the highest bidder. Often important books were included, and nn. The word itself, though usually thousands of copies of more popular vol- 19,000 copies of one book were disposed of W olzogen Phe aaper of most . pal ‘t} ; n minutes, and at one of Mnrray's pt r interest was at wilt which > ths pos cue vas te —_ sa rhomas Tegz bought the stock of bis I ‘ ‘ ‘ o% , 3S r ” ‘ ‘ Conference oncluded—Professo FY; iy Librars 100,000, at one shilling ix on the secular songs, or “reels,” per copy the negro, most of them having rhe essays seem. some of them. to have ine directly from work on the plan-| been written many years since, his quota- rheir naivet genuine pathos, tions of prices obtained at auction for rare ffen their lyri beauty were to first editions being old records of ten or i j the audience a revelation. TI twenty years ago. —_ The , anacs print in Massachusetts the light-colored skin, s If-pity The Alm . Pp ited il ' a ae : h t . i from 1639 to 1850 are the subject of an im- not having enougn 0 Cau, an s , : portant and carefu! essay and bibliography > » get mone) ol by Dr. Charles L. Nichols, of Worcester, aue Mass., printed by the American Antiquarian playing seven up, Society. Gov. John Winthrop in his diary, white man takes under date of March, 1639, chronicled the beginnings of printing in the United States in the following words: wmiuent of the ne“kros sociological hile the pervading humor \ printing house was begun at Cambridge , ity to 1 somehow by one Daye, at the charge of Mr. Glover, | { ec me ( . on “7e ’ who died on sea hitherward. The first thing even on very litth which was printed was the freeman’s oath; \ hould have been glad for a word | the next was an almanac made for New . rate . ; England by Mr. William Peirce, Mariner; ( the Edit il Committee explain- | the next was the Psalmes newly turned into the spelling employed in the pro- metre eram ro Ul layman it is awful, Of that first almanac “made for New Eng- nd vs doubt If the scientist would land” no copy is now known, though it dare to call it elther phonetic or re formed By the side of “servis” we rote treatise’; “cud” has now become an auxiliary verb; why so many “e's in “therefore”? The following officers were elected for the present year: pres ident, Prof. A. R. Hohlfeld; vice-presi dents, Profs. H. Collitz, A. H. Thorn dike, and Kenneth McKenzie. In a few weeks the Council will decide upon a place for the next meeting, the chances favoring Cambridge. should seem from an entry in the manuscript catalogue given by Dr. Nichols (“Isaiah Thomas states that this issue and that of 1640 began with the month of March”) that a copy of the little book had been dinner was “on the table the dinner the books enumerated in the were sold, On one occasion above as the first month and February as the until 1752, nearly all other almanacs give January as the first month and March as the third. Dr. Nichols surmises that this may have been “an effort towards absolute truthfulness of expression,” or that it may have been one more proof of the desire of the people to “separate themselves, even in these ways, from those whom they left in England, for the sake of religious and per- sonal freedom.” In the earlier years of Franklin's “Poor Richard” January is put first but is called “XI Mon.,” February “XII Mon.,” and then comes March as “I Mon.” The astronomical calculationsin theseear- ly almanacs were for the most part prepared by graduates of Harvard. Of forty-four al- manacs issued before 1687, forty-one were prepared by twenty-six graduates, ten of whom were tutors in the institution. Dr. Nichols is of the opinion that the making of these calculations was a part of the preparation for the post-graduate degree of Master of Arts. The earliest known American almanac to contain the illustration of “the man of signs” was that of 1678. This was published by John Foster, the first printer in Bos- ton, and the cut was engraved by him. Many other interesting facts are to be learned in Dr. Nichols’s essay, while his list, filling nearly one hundred pages, will be found useful for reference. Correspondence RAILWAY SAFETY AND DISCIPLINE, To THe EpiITror or THE NATION: seen by Thomas about a hundred years ago, | and aleo that, although an almanac was issued from the Cambridge Press each year for the first twenty years, only seven is- Sir: With your permission, I should like |to call the attention of your readers to a | criticism of my opinions on management sues are known, and each one unique. These | and the safety problem on railroads which are for the years 1646, 1647, 1648, 1649, 1650, you have recently printed. It is an inter- 1656, and 1657. The first five of these are | esting criticism, absolutely sound in its the copies which belonged to the Rev. Sam- | | uel Hoygh, 6f Reading, Mass., by whom they | |} were interleaved, serving him for diaries. | ethics and its logic. As I look at it, how- ever, it is a challenge for information, as well as an all-around judgment or conclu-
Page 11
Jan. 2, 1913] sion on the subject. The passage I refer to is as follows (Nation, December 19, 1912): If the coercion of railway managements for the benefit of unfit employees is as bad at Mr. Fagan represents it—and we do not deny that it is—the railways are not com- pelled to wait for an investigation by the Interstate Commerce Commission to dis- close it A plain statement of the case would quickly bring the influence of publi sentiment to bear in favor of whatever dis- ciplinary measures are necessary to make life and limb safe for travellers. Now, there is just one slip of the mind or of the pen in this passage As a mat- ter of fact, public sentiment is not and } never has been quick to move in supporting the superintendent and his authority on the railroads, even after “a plain statement of the case” has been widely published for the information of the American people Public sentiment will move, and must move in this matter before long, but it seems to be a slow process, and in my opinion a score of plain statements such as that which I now propose to make will be neces- sary before the railroad business in this country, especially the operating depart ] ment, can be conduct on a reasonably fair end safe |t Take, ior Pennsylvania Railroad in the years 1908 and 1909 \t that time the system was threat ened with a strike of large bodies of em- ployees which promised to lead to a general “tie-up.” The position and contention of the railroad in the matter can best be given in the words of W. W Atterbury, who at the time was general manager of the lines east of Pittsburgh His stetement to the pubiic was as follows There is no question of wages, hours of employment, or conditions of service at issue between the company and its men The men are demanding, however, that when grievances or demands of a general nature are to be presented to the management, they shall have the right to go straight to the general manager, ignoring the division Superintendent and the general superinten- dent. To agree to such a proceeding would be subversive of that discipline upon which the company relies to protect the safety of the lives and property of its patrons This statement and others of a similar nature were widely published at the time without the slightest response fro public sentiment But we need not go back to the year 1909 for illustrations and points In the month of June, 1912, a strike vote of employees on the same railroad, that is, on the P Vania, was threatened to enfor mands, the most important ofl the following That engineman X be paid for time lost On account of suspension of ninety days, i! posed upon him on the charge of low water in his engin« Now, of course, if management is to be held responsible for the efficiency of the ser vice, its authority must be recognized and supported But in the cases I have men tioned, and in others of a similar nature not a particle of assistance did the rail road receive either from the press or fron public sentiment Far from ‘quickly bringing its influence to bear in favor of necessary measures of disciplines public opinion at the time shuffled the issues, po litically tinctured, on to the board of medi ators, under the Erdman act. Just what th public got for its money, so to speak, in the case of the Pennsylvania Rallroad, can The Nation be understood from the following tel lialogue, which almost to the lett« sact reproduction or r irsal o ‘ lings Pennsyly i Railroad, is that yu why don't you offe hese é s kind of an live branch You know there is boul © be troubl f you Pe va a Railre | l id Iphia Pa lerstand that, Mr Mediator, but look |} this is simply a question of right iw rs inage ent, and to | you the truth, la sick and tired ar settleme in such Phat flat ou understand, and ther nothing t it Mediator That's il ver vel I vania Rail id. but yo t il | that liator ider t i it l nteres ‘ ! \“\ t I \ ha t \ | t with the right or wrong in this sy ' ec i j ! ) +} ’ for ) t lr ' 1 Bu o La ] r ’ fr ae | ’ ) I | ] I iff vy what l ni int Ir r eT ha } } ’ are not | ! I J ] I tl I th tu i I 1 j is . retty } for a 1 his » } f f the travelli And tly what arbi it I ns and ha 1 >t railroads f } et veal , r or I ’ | try i ilwavs } ! r sooner pul ler ! better it will at iat! ‘ * wr } t a J } ’ ! ! l f i f luring tl I , it « s ft he ] ‘ nov l tru DO ! | ihout t i j ' net : : t vrone ty \ | nti i () I \\ M D LETTER OF DI Fl \ l E I | s Th foll i f . ‘ » th fri h late Hora H rd | 1 quo t t , fait if T ] | 1 er i : : I I to her gt T 1 } lar +} late Francis Jar Child l an ackr ig of i tter ourag nt that had ist ) to ! fro Prof or hild Wholly apart from its interest a1 ord of friendship that existed bet t! kindred spirits, it gis one so! the patience and toil that may pr brief and modest comment of a great schol ur The letter is dated March 22, 1880, and therefore was written soon after the cation of “Lear.” Dr. Furness says publl as ever yet said t ippreciative word lent t at ti that lie hidden sometimes tion of a line. Not infrequently | : wl 7 eve ing in hu t! x } ] tatior I re r at gh ry | of |! I re vol } im tsi i search of a ing Mi lg arly a whole nig t I f q i in tl I ’ l four , ‘ ira al } f it San too ir ; Tih) vil And so ; \ 1iter all tl tt ‘ , is ¢ i Bal ‘ va requi 1 and ‘ Lé | s reading \ TT , Il] ! G. ¢ \ FRENCH Gl ) ) I E I } , ¢t} ' i ’ , f 1 +} i ica ! th ri fA Alt igh ] ‘ , i ’ o Ma it I I ) ? ; +} , f God thou t jlot } ~ | Sa breat i , Tl i t WV ’ 1 } knowr ' on of tl iret. Old HOOKS a Tri if B 1 M q . cont at ing gir! t re iT ro the English. s 1 H re's La Solitair ind, f el in “Un drame au Mar ind the translation of & Marvellous Voyags of N H od
Page 12
now how popular ig ar No matt Mar Let wo n ed ! \ nun ntime such 1erous novels s to ¢£ ‘ray at er how el Pre as old hours an it with tres ild tion of not as telling } whether ronit Literature EXPLORATIONS ON THE RIVERS OF AMERICA, SO UTH The Flowing Road: Adventuring on the Great Rivers of South America by Caspar Whitney With maps and photographs by the author. Philadel phia: The J. B. Lippincott Co. $3 net Under the quaint title of “The Flow ing Road,” i. ¢«., the stream that bears the traveller's boat, Mr. Caspar Whit- ney gives us a lively narrative of sev eral journeys, most of them by water, in one of the least known parts of the world, viz., that densely wooded and The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2479 ' thinly peopled region which lies be- tween the mighty Amazon on the south and the Llanos (grassy plains) which border the middle course of the Orinoco Eastern Venezuela. So thick are the that there means of traversing this region except by water, and transit is extremely slow and dif- ficult. The southern part of the region belongs to Brazil, the northern part to Venezuela; its few inhabitants, whether speaking Spanish in the former country Portuguese in the latter, are half- breeds and Indians. The latter, though far more numerous than the former, are in proportion to the vast area of the country, and nearly all live in prim- Most of their tribes feeble and so much white man that their presence does not greatly add to the difficulties which throws in the way of the adventurous traveller. Mr. Whitney is an explorer for the of He is something of a sportsman and something of a nat- But for Wan- dering is the desire to be in wild places and lead a wild, which is likely to be imperilled, life, in the presence of untouched nature. It would be hard to find a better country in which to gratify this passion than the cen- tral wilderness of South America, some of never been trav- , some of whose tribes hardly ever man. He describes regions with freshness and spirit, in forests is no or few itive savagery. are, however, afraid of the sO nature exploration. sake uralist. his main motive also an often whose woods have erst seen by civilized these giving enough detail to make the read- understand what are the conditions of travel, and what the daily incidents that it, but not wearying us with a repetition of trivial matters. Like oth- ers mark r travellers in the thickly wooded re- gions of the tropics, he is struck by the fact that wild creatures, and especially snakes, are compara- quadrupeds and tively seldom seen: of cours there is life in the deep for- est, plenty of it, but it is sly and noiseless, in keeping with the huge solitude it calls home You find here the many varieties of rodent family, the sly tapir, the clumsy- aring but surprisingly active ant-eater; coyote-like animal appe a wild dog-—a grayish with a dog tail—of which I shot one; sev- eral of the cats, though they (including the aguar, head of the family) keep closer to the jungle edges or near the breaks in the forest where birds and streams and pec- caries are more frequent, and the hunting } better How awesome is the deep equatorial for- est in ite immensity, and how disappoint- ing! It is not at all the picture of your untutored imagination—brilllant in flaming foliage and gay with the chatter of wild life. On the contrary, it I sombre, for- bidding. and silent. Here is no frog chorus or hum of insect or hoarse croaking bird: even the harassing voice of the parrot is silent—'tis a vast desert where you may not venture without compass, for neither landmagks nor the stars attend you: there is only the canopy of the trees above and the tangle of underbrush below and around. Where indeed is there a desert to equal this forest desert? But the trees are won- derfully impressive with their huge smooth trunks from four to six feet in diameter; limbless for forty to sixty feet. Some are supported by buttresses which stand out at their base or four feet like great flanges, and all share their burden of the marvellous parasitic life Which may express itself in flower-like decorations or in fes- tooning, entwining pendant vines, innumer- able and of every character and dimension. three A striking description of the parasitic growths of the forest may be found on page 50, and there are many interesting remarks on each of the wild creatures, from the great jaguar downward. Though our author is not a skilled zoélogist, and even less of a botanist, he has a first- rate traveller's eye, and is able t and describe the details, as we present the general effect of the scenery through whieh he passes. The account given in the above quotation of the sort of impression a vast tropical forest makes is perfectly correct. Such a for- est is almost terrible in its silence and in the sense which it gives of the abounding power and energy of nature; and it seems more terrible when, either on foot or in a small boat, the traveller o catch ll as to makes his way through one of these level tracts than when he is climbing up and down wooded mountainsides. There, as for instance in the maritime parts of Brazil or among the hills of Guiana or Colombia, there is variety, for the sun breaks in upon a cliff and streams sparkle over the rocks. In the vast Amazonian woodlands one de- pressed by the same sombre monotony for many hundreds of miles. There was only one part of his jour- ney in which Mr. Whitney penetrated what seems to have been a virtually un- is explored country. This was the upper part of the Orinoco, beyond the great reef of rocks and huge loose stones call- ed by him the Barrier, which extends across the river about latitude 3° north and 65° Here dwell small tribes of Indians entirely unmolested by the Venezuelans to the west of them and the Brazilians to the east of them, ab- solutely unaffected by civilization. These Indios bravos, as the whites call them, live in a half-nomadic way in small groups, and support existence by fishing with the bow and arrow and by killing birds either with arrows or with darts from the blow-pipe some seven feet long. Here our author had quite the most thrilling adventures of all his journeys, first in stalking these Indians and watching them from perches in the trees, and afterwards in saving himself from the attempt of his only compan- ion, a half-negro, half-Indian Venezuelan, to decamp with the canoe and the pro- visions, leaving him to perish alone in the wilderness. This part of the story is told with a graphic skill in the han- west.
Page 13
Jan. 2, 1913] a novelette of adventure might envy. Although these devious courses along the upper tributaries of the Rio Negro and the Orinoco are the most interest- ing parts of Mr. Whitney’s book, his record of a hunting trip in Western Venezuela and his account of a similar excursion up the Parana River in North- ern Argentina, may also be read with pleasure. He is a good observer of men as well as of beasts, and gives a life-like notion of the sorts of people, nearly all half-breeds of some kind or other, whom the traveller meets in the out-of-the-way parts of South America. Some useful hints on the equipments needed by the hunter or explorer in wild regions wind up a pleasant and agreeable book. It is not without interest that we find him saying, as not a few mighty hunters, including Lancelot Sanderson and Selous, have said, that he has ceased to find any pleasure in killing, and now shoots only for the sake of adding a new specimen to his collection. CURRENT FICTION. Atlantis: A Novel. By Gerhart Haupt mann Translated by Adele and Thomas Seltzer. New York: B. W Huebsch, Gerhart Hauptmann’s new novel, like almost all of his other productions, is concerned with a hero who can suffer but not do, act, construct. From “Son nenaufgang” (1889) to “Emanuel Quint” (1910), “Die Ratten” (1911), and “Gabriel Schillings Flucht” (1912), Hauptmann’s leading characters do not In his dramas this fault is even The lack of defensive or constructive will, the philosophy that goes with such a lack, well expressed in Hauptmann’s play “lead.” more serious. and pessimistic are “Das Friedensfest” (1890), one of whos characters says: “The will The will, the will, get out with your will! I know better! One may will and will a hundred times, and thing remains as it was!” In the present novel a German physi- cian, deserting his family to follow a young danseuse named Ingigerd to New York, narrowly escapes a_ shipwreck much like that of the Titanic. In Amer- ica he learns that his lady love is al- ready at heart of the demi-monde; he escapes to Connecticut to regain his bal- ance, is nursed through typhoid fever by Eva Burns, a young artist, and then returns to Germany. In the course of the story the hero wrongs both the danseuse and a Russian steerage passen ger. Throughout the story the reader gets the effect of tremendous forces in com bat, but upon careful examination sees that this impression comes from the masterly literary treatment of gigantic physical forces in action rather than from any spiritual struggle. Haupt is a straw! eve ry The Nation himself: the moved, is made no temptation, because conquer temptation is re- Ingigerd sinks to the depths. Nor can the humdrum ending of the novel, in which Eva Burns nurses Frederick through typhoid fever, and after the of Europe with him to be a mother to his children and with life of devotion to art, disguise this failure one whit. The neither great death his poor insane wife goes to him to live a underlying theme of “Atlantis” is The form nor unusual book's strength lies in its external its wonderful descriptions, its equally mar- vellous characterization, its vivid image of men and things brilliant ry, its record accurate observatio of in its striking figures, short, its style. It is in quite remarkable how even as skilful an urtist as Hauptmann could paint the pir ture of storm and shipwreck (both mol al and physical) and the hair-breadth rescue (also both moral and physical) ithout having gone through some such dreadful experience himself He sees everything, he hears everything even the sense of smell is alert and its experience recorded The condiment of satire on America and the Americans sprinkled upon this literary dish is rather flat. We have heard before of the worship of the dol lar, of the depreciation of art, of has’ oss ignoran unrest, etc., et a i) cifically American virtues Autobiographical elements appear in the hero's interest in art, and especially in sculpture—Hauptmann is said even now to do good modelling in his won derful house at Agnetendorf—and Dr. von Kammacher’s early biological stud ies perhaps hark back to Hauptmann’s Haeckel Thomas lena of Adel } xceptions well In the student days The translation by and Seltzer is with few « done Temple Thurs Appleton & Co. unusual The ton. New Antagonists hing in the least in the general situation from whi h this story is developed. A genius is born of ordinary an English The excellent two quite village. miller, “Sartor people in father is an ex-butler, a reads the an man, who Resartus and walks strait and narrow way The mother is an ex-governess, a sweet and under- standing woman. But “Dicky,” the child of unusual powers, finds plenty of antagonism in the antagon- ism of age, of environment, of sex. Very upon becoming a yield, but his world early his mind is set The sees no reason why the busi- painter. mother would the father ness of a successful miller should not be a better prospect than a dream of success in art. So the filial relation is start. All enough. man, be- the final a battle for Dicky from the this, is commonplace The tween we Say, strife between boy and ambition and caution, determination of the boy to burn his bridges and run away to London, so that he may somehow win the educa- tion in art his soul craves—these have been the motives of a hundred The sexual to be matter in the book is it At en Dicks by tl onscious new of begins awakening troubled of sex, and is ness present! alf-en lightened by a disillusioned an From that and his At become a with his old becomes His love thirty. time his instinct for art instinct of sex side. ! by seventeen, to painter—and fal n ‘ Dorotth Shie playmats then, also, in a sens S al tagonist. ambition points don. Her Ambition to holds him at the out tor wins day, and | pares set But. of course, ft and Mr. Thurs extraordinary quiet the sacrifice w i ood ready to make as bir here is a final meeting here ton, in a and simplicity, dé scribes eternal a last re the flitting not a book in that ons ene 1d to itself man This j but ot aren plane of imaginat Closing Net By Henrv ¢ New York crook continues to ‘ ! i of his ni The hero romance—as populi ost as itural enemy, the det e have a gentleman of th: \ an) blood, chiefly known t: i a “Wall ater Clam.” Street Frank,” o s1) LLit’e Being of the Ly orKing on a big scal Wher adily receives ner circles of the prot ( i { the Ame however, unexpectedly ir demonstration of to Zreat subse We he spectacle virtue, his rassment. citing of our d guist fellow-countryman opposed sing handed, to the powerful and organized class of Paris He has hi narro escapes, but they are escapes, and course, in the end, his virtue confirmed and his valor rewarded, he ma! the fair companion of many of |} id ventures, who, being verita int and professional taxi-driver, dese credit as a new compound in the f istry of romantic fiction. The st: better in manner than i: ibstar t is told with a some humor. al ' one deal « igo good
Page 14
ESSAYS ( } son and Othe? F MAETERLINCK., laeterlinck. Tra an transiator net is slen ym those ali and | eterlinck aT ith his 2) nootnnes rk has g! en so to idioms, and epres nor terlinck t* mn W E ‘ssays rmerson (1894) ysbroeck (1891 By Mau- nslated by Mon ‘The most devotional, in tone, but with just; less edifying than amusing. For a par- that toucn of reserve which gives an ef-| allel one would have to go back to the fect of discretion to homage. They re-| bland confessions of some imaginary veal familiar traits in the lissome and! person of quality in Defoe or Smollett. willowy style, and in the serene gusto, His father he mentions with an ac- the placid self-regalement, which suggest cent of apology as “a charming man,” , the transfigured epicure. Maeterlinck’s but strangely insensible to the family ) expertness in the technique of introduc-| passions for racing and other robust Nation [ Vol. 96, No. Moses. New York: Dodd, Mead ler volume are, tions is not remarkable, The essay on| sports. He admits that there may have French, introductions to| Hmerson flutters round Emerson, or been excuse for this limitation, as his WW riters, two 0 tuysbroeck, are himself riginal in the of his phras ave faults. The f rather uses him as a perch or resting-| grandfather had practiced “racing, elec- » place between flights into the empyrean.| tioneering, hunting, and cock-fighting”’ rhe range, the virility, the self-trust, the to the serious damage of the family often reveals homely shrewdness of Emerson, have, fortunes. It was this grandfather who » pardonably enough, escaped Maeter- is gleefully handed down to posterity linck: what he sees is a pious brother, in these pages, sitting on a Dublin pave- » Fra Rodolfo as it were, holding his ment embracing a lamp-post, and refus- speak, dusted taper in the fraternal procession of the) ing to budge on the ground that, as the there are other | ly not respon inuscript and * mystics. The essay on Novalis lacks an houses were all going round and round, ed usage for elective unity; it makes several trips he might as well wait for his lodgings rather than one voyage. The critique to arrive, and then “just pop in.” Luck- of Ruysbroeck is the least dithyrambic ily, his second wife was of a managing Mr. Moses and the most serviceable of the three; |turn, and contrived to save something rnorance irom must defend him 0 hese ,andthea at t howevel isped oa ept the 7 p et that French il (| ) ous (p ns “reflection } I ans (p. 194), that S ip 214) no part (p ins nhabita indeed, the words appears } uthor’s knowl the meaning ecification 18 haracte! subjoin an i ! The lating Ruys e que nous jt now Te! o! l us n eT ol ‘ en 1) et nous Che ‘ ‘ obovionu i | id) as | inh 0) 7 of (the Cod We remain al vhat the mn nage “Tuast eves, 80 do we lose them raplidl) modify the ith Ene are pleasingly disint a | but never ggardly of loitering, thought and we dwell neither raise reputation lish readers erested, leis thrifty but admiring, al is effectively ordered, is packed with for later Lords Rossmore to enjoy life quotations, and really clarifies an unfa- ith. The present incumbent was born niliar subiect sixty years ago into a jolly world. “I he assignment of space to Emerson, hzve lived an amusing life, but a happy Novalis, and Ruysbroeck is represented one, notwithstanding,” he says. Is this by the ratios 1, 3, and 5; it may or may a pure Hibernian touch, or in rebuttal not be just to associate these propor-|cf the Puritan theory which connects he facts that Emerson’s was strict virtue and happiness? This writ- a mind of many windows with varicus er is capable of either turn of humor. outlooks .upward and outward, that in|“! am fortunate in possessing a charm- Novalis this many-sidedness was only a ing wife, and the best children in the promise, while in Ruysbroeck we seem) world. I have many friends, and I hope to see a man lying on the floor of a cell| few enemies; and if I haven't done and watching a strip of exquisite sky | much good in the world. at any rate I through the single orifice in the quaint-|do not think I have done much harm ly panelled ceiling. We may note also,|either.”. One thing he is sure of—that without insisting on the fact, that in|/he has had a good time from first to the Ruysbroeck essay passages that are) last. It is true there is an elegiac note mere curiosities and passages aglow jin his memories of boyhood. After tell- with a real if cabined and confined spir-| jing how his brother and he were wont ituality are quoted without any mani-|to hunt by moonlight—“and as this hap- fest sense of the enormous difference in| pened after dinner, reckless riding was their values. For the rest, the mysti- more likely than not”—he sums up with, ism is sunny, airy, and inviting, a lit-/“We were up to all kinds of devilment le provoking now and then because jn which boys delight, and looking back- apparently a little wilful in its suave in-| ward I can only say that I think there tence on the supernatural clairvoy-| jig nothing in life to compare with its ance of the most commonplace people in| springtime.” But the ensuing narra- the most ordinary situations—a theory tive does not make clear just where the urely not bound up, either as support) devilment is supposed to have ceased: or consequence, with the soundness of the inconsequent airs of springtime ex- mystic principk hale from the last of these pages as from the first. tions with t The family estate of Rossmore is con- sidered, its master believes, to be “one of the beauty spots of Ireland,” and he Limself ventures to think it “one of the The things Lord Rossmore can tell) prettiest places in the world.” Planting are so many and varied, the leeway he! and replanting is a mania which he con- permits himself in point of taste (not fesses to sharing with Louis XIV, and to say morals) is so generous, that we his pride in his home is as pleasant and find ourselves wondering a little what! jagenuous as his pride in his horseman the things are he can not tell. His anec-) ship, or his ability to stay above table: dotes have an eighteenth-century flavor; “The claret was a bit full-bodied for his jokes are of a sort which our an-|them, but I finished what was left, and cestors, even In America (witness Poor | thoroughly enjoyed it.” A human being Richard's Almanac) did not hesitate to capable of thoroughly enjoying every- put in print, but which are now rele-\ thing life has brought him for sixty gated to the smeking-room. The experi-| years (including, but merely including, ences he rechbrds with greatest gusto are| his drink), has a strong appeal for the Thinas I Can Tell. By Lord Rossmore. New York: George H. Doran Co. $3.50
Page 15
Jan. 2, 1913 natural man in all of us. Among other things, he enjoyed shooing a woodcock from his own gun to that of his friend, the late King Edward's: I quite thought my action had been un- observed, but a friend came up to me when the beat was over, and said, “Derry, old nan, that about the woodcock was smartest do! thing I’ve ever seen.” “Good heavens!” I exclaimed. “You don't say you saw i On no account let the King know at I saw it all right,” rejoined friend ind in my opinion many a man has been made a Duke for less.” He enjoyed his companions, whom h¢ recalls fondly from their drunkards graves by fond nicknames, such as “Cootie” and “Old Joe” and “Sugar” and “Chicken”—titles which Dickens would attached to bibulous other end of the social scale. If gratification than that provided its impudent good cheer were to b desired of this narrative, it is surely af forded by the spectacle of inherent and perfectly unconscious vulgarity here of- fered noble lord for the je: contemplation of democracy. have at the other persons by by a ring The King of France: New Last Legitimate Louis XVII. By Phoebe Allen. York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $5 net. Did “Louis XVII” from Temple Prison? Were Josephine, Bar- ras, and Robespierre privy to his eva- Did Louis XVII subsequent!y as sume the name of Naundorff, and are the Naundorff claimants therefore d: serving of our credence and sympathy? These questions the author answers in the affirmative with the fine feminin conviction of a devotee of a lost cause. And hers is not the only voice crying in a wilderness of unbelief. Books sup porting the Naundorff claim have b¢ come increasingly numerous lately. A monthly periodical in Paris is devoted to its defence. In March, 1911, the French Senate, at the ardent insistence of M. Boissy d’Anglas, appointed a com- mittee to hear the petition of Naun- dorff’s descendants for legal recognition as citizens of France. That a sickly child died in the Tem ple on June 8, 1795, as asserted by the existing death certificate, there is vir- tually no doubt. ‘that this child was a substitute for Louis XVI's son is possi ble, but, as it seems to us after reading the evidence, not probable. The theories of the substitution of a wooden figure, of a dumb child, or of a scrofulous weak- ling scarcely rise to a matter of convic tion in the mind of the reviewer. The contemporary evidence is so meagre that it is impossible to come to a well- founded historical judgment as to whe- ther Louis XVII perished in the Temple in 1795 or not. Granting for the moment, however, that the Dauphin may have escaped, did he survive in the nerson of Naundorff? } the escape sion?
‘The Nation It is known that the belief well escape gave the basis for the appearance, after Napoleon's fall, cf some forty per vyho claimed to be the real L ms \ yuis XVII Thirty-ni < then at any rate, must have been impudent im] tors. There was, for instance, Eleazar Williams, whom Louis Philippe’s son found in an Indian family in Ns Yor}
State, and whom he tried in va to sign a document abdicat French tl suade
alleged rights to the tisans of the survivance are now gene! ally agreed that the only claimant not an impostor was Naundorf! rhe au thor therefore traces in detail Naun dorfft’s chequered career from his first emergence in Berlin until he came to Paris in person in 1833 to prove his case before the French courts; and she describes his vicissitudes in England and Holland after his expulsion from France until his death at Delft in 1845 To establish her case she quotes largely from Naundorff’s own allegations and ol ] royalists might h the fall of the monarchy. Un from sworn depositions by servants and who ave known him before fortunately, she does not sufficiently real ize the historical untrustworthiness of statements made from memory thirty or forty years after the event, even when made by the most honest and well intentioned persons. Nor could she have accepted so unquestioningly Naundorfl read the recent hirch in the His- CVI, 535-599 ), had Ts ft (1910; she assertions if critical study by he Zeitschri made with German in the Pru effectually of all toris thoroughness from material sian archives. disp ses Naundorft's complaints of “persecution” in Germany. By noting the different dates at which Naundorff composed his different state- grow ments, he is able to show that they full as Naundorff had suc oppor- tunities for learning more details about the French Revolution—details which Naundorff then proceeded to exploit as his own personal recollections. His con clusion is that Naundorff also is an im postor, and one of the most impudent, because he kept up the imposture throughout his life and probably tried to bolster it up and acquire sympathy by instigating apparent attempts at his own assassination short, this biography of a would- not In be prince is interesting and with- out pathos. But its composition must be regarded as an act of devotion rather than as an historical investigation The Ulm Campaign, 1805. By Col, F. N. Maude, C.B., late of the Royal Engi- neers. Special Campaign Series, No. 12. With maps. New York: The Mac- millan Co. $1.60 net. Col. Maude has contributed, besides the present book, two very interesting studies to the Special Campaign Series: “The Leipzig Campaign, 1813,” and “The
Jena Campaig ‘ Hi ‘ having con | 1 on u . his ‘ i ‘ d method of i i fol wed i i i ns ai | ) | ; | ror’s st ‘ obi . ration ¢ SU] I ‘ p " ! y a und y th j n ) i Orn QO! ir Lol l ( strated tha Napol ‘ id ing ga ] ‘ ( novelt eapon is irning to i | latest #tudy depicts the Er ro $s irst essay in the conduct of a reat i organized into divisions and corps In ese three studies the fundamental purpose is to establish the fact it Na poleon’s strategy was not born ft grow but was rather “the outcome of his experience, developed logically and step by step” (p. vi) “The Ulm Campaign” fully maintai: the standard set by Col. Maud other works, and is undoubtedly tl best summary of the sort thus far published in English. A brief account of t! Au trian and French armik up 180 more admirable than that contained in his first two chapters cannot be found in any language. The author announces that he had originally intended merely to translate the introduction to the French Official History, by Colin and Alombert but pon finding that his o opinion regarding tl abilit ( Ge! Mack and the conduct of the Archduke I linand differed so widely from that o com pilers, | bandoned the idea 1 de cided to “unravel far as p the ndamental Luse vhi the root of the le se! of « it he Austrians endured at tl French, from the ver ot tl French Revolution” (| I French Official History is a los vork in four huge volume 3,084 pages and accompanied by a sma er volume containing docu nexes, and maps, compiled by Capt. J Colin, of the Historical Section General Staff, and P. C. Alo Controller of the Administratior French army The former } a written “L’Education militai d i poléon, which has been ds ved crowned by the French Academ end the latter, “Le Corps d'armée aux o! dres du Maréchal Mortier: Combat d Dirrenstein,” a work of the itmost dealing with the opera Army thoroughness. of the from during the Vienna French tions Grand march the Traun to after Mack's capitulation at Ulm. The Official History—the title of which “La Campagne de 1805 en Allemagne’ terminates on November 11, three weeks before the battle of Austerlitz. Although by all odds the most comprehensive and authentic history of this campaign yet published, it is both unfinished and far 8
Page 16
Col the main Like every other historian before him, The Nation ast word on the subject; and exposing of the French line of ontain any inexcusable errors. In-| munications, and the escape of Wer- orders and reports are inac- meck’s corps and the Austrian Reserve omplete copies of the orig- Artillery from Ulm on the 13th, where uments of the utmost im-| it rightly belongs. e either been omitted in- More careful proofreading would have what is much more like- ¢liminated a number of errors in dates escaped Colin and Alom- and spelling. A book so full of “meat” om this, dozens of impor-| Will certainly warrant a subsequent edi- and reports in the Austrian tion in which these defects can readily ivs and in the archives of | be corrected. Meanwhile it will supply General Staff ought, most @ long-felt want on the part of the gen- » have been at their dispos- eral reader and the military student attempt been made to pro-| Who do not demand absolute historical The reviewer, for instance, | @ccurac)y many months of research i,and St. Petersburg, was sccura and complet Railro Finance By Frederick A. every document given Cleveland and Fred Wilbur Powell. ddition to a great number) New York: D. Appleton & Co. $2.50 heir history Since Col. het is depended so largely upon That effective public regulation of Alombert, it is obvious that railways is only to ve attained through must partake of their | an intimate knowledge of the account- ing features of railway operation has r declares that he has “nev-| long been realized by close students of ») share the views of those the problem. It is therefore to the pub- efeated general | lic’s interest that these highly technical 254-255). omies of one kind and another, but in what fashion the reasonable margin be- income and outgo is to be pre- does not appear. In fact, it is armies on the east (pp 0 Maude fails to put the blame for tween isolation of Dupont’s division, the served com- ear ag the hero. the thelr { Val. 96, No. 2479 in the discussion of just such contro- verted questions as these that the book will probably prove disappointing to many readers. Whether the principles ot “scientific management” are applica- ble to the railway industry is a much debated question. The arguments on both sides are presented in this book, but no attempt is made to test their validity or to reach any conclusion, notwithstanding the fact that the senior author is peculiarly fitted by experi- ence to express an opinion of value. the discussion of over-capital- ization contains an exhaustive treat- ment of the various considerations that have been offered from time to time as aids in the solution of the vexed prob- lem, but beyond learning that valua- tion for taxation should be based on in- come and valuation for rate-making on investment, the reader gets no answer to his question. What elements spe- cifically should be included in the val- uation and what method should adopted for its determination are ques- tions left for the inquirer to decide. Nevertheless, the book has fulfilled with great success the purpose laid down in [=] Again, be either an imbecile or a/matters should be explained and their ait viil)—a very praiseworthy bearing on the problem of regulation the preface, “to describe the methods ind takes up the cudgels clearly established. This book is the of financing railroads in the United half of Mack (pp. 22-36).| first important attempt to treat in a States.” H tly disagrees with the bias | systematic fashion the financial and ac- olin and Alombert in favor | counting development of railways dur- ™ \ luke Ferdinand, the nominal | ing the last three or four decades. N otes f the Austrian army at The work has been admirably done. iinst Mack (p. 182), but, on Its method is to follow chronologically ee ‘ ; } hand, he places far too much the stages in a railway corporation's Frederick Warne & Co., otal York will d i Mack's “Mémoires justi-| experience—through promotion under- say ppcsad oo Pan the “4 : ‘ survey by various hands of the safeguards fi om which he quotes frequent-| writing, capitalization, construction, for the preservation of the rights of th ind at considerable length. This doc- equipment, organization, and the Vari-| people, with a preface by the Marquess of tituted the defeated gener- ous problems of operation and manage- Lansdowne. : pal defence at his court-mar-| ment, and then to lead one on the down-) «Nogi: A Man against the Background of t ngenious and plausible though it hill road through insolvency and re-|a War” is announced by Henry Holt. The iot unfrequently it is wholly at vari- ceivership to reorganization. Conclud- author, Stanley Washburn, was one of the ul he orders actually issued ing chapters relate to consolidation and , newspaper correspondents who were with ‘ de's strictures on Napoleon's overcapitalization. The newly establish-| this Japanese general through most of the rT in regarding Augsburg “as/ed accounting system of the Interstate campaigns with Russia. tl the whole situation” (p. 254) Commerce Commission receives extend- The Century Co. will publish early in , vell founded, in view of the ed treatment, and its significant fea- tte new year “The Shadow,” a tale of de- Emperor received respect-| tures are indicated. On this technical tective adventure, by Arthur Stringer, and ; er of Austrian troops in| side the authors find the greatest defect a book of short stories by Anne Douglas fi First Corps and the expect-| to be the failure to adopt what is term- png 4 arriv: of the Russian army in that | ed the “double balance sheet,” by means Three new novels will be brought out this i October 13 (p. 222), and of which the confusion between capital moa ty Sale, Srews s pe A tiv ; Heatherby,” by Payne Erskine; “The Little necessity in consequence and current resources and liabilities is Gray Shoe,” by Percy Brebner, and “The f tablishing the eastern group of the removed. This makes possible the set- Happy Warrior,” by A. 8S. M. Hutchinson Bre tn i. ¢, Bernadotte, the Ba- ting up of the separate fund reserved A phototype reproduction of Montaigne’s in ind Davout—so firmly on the for the permanent use of the corpora- «p..aig” with more than a thousand plates Ina banish all possible apprehen- tion directly against the obligations cre-| anq an introduction by Pro’. Fortunat on on the seore of Kienmayer and ating it. Thereby the fact that capital | strowski, ig among the announcements of Ku off ntil he had finished with is a trust fund becomes clearly recog-| the Librairie Hachette & Cie. The manu- Mack Subsequent events demonstrat-| nized on the books. script employed is that of 1588, belonging ed that this wise precaution thwarted The authors recognize the tendency | ‘© Bordeaux, which has corrections in the the very object which Mack sought to for expenses of railway operation to author's own hand ffect, namely, to crush the French be- increase, and state flatly that reduc- The automobile is responsible for a num- tween the anvil represented by the tions in wages are impracticable. They | be? of things, evil and the contrary, and irmy ¢ the Iller and the ham-| would apparently look for a solution of | *™0P them ts the development of a new mering of the Russian and Austrian this financial difficulty in greater econ-| "87h of HMterature, not to be classified ther as travel or as romance, but a sort combination of the two, with a motor- The Williamsons started vogue for this type of reading, and disciples increase and multiply.
Page 17
Jan. 2, 1913] Louise Closser Hale is one of the band, and in “Motor Journeys” (McClurg) has col- lected a series of light articles dealing with European travels en auto that have already appeared in various periodicals In the words of Lincoln, when asked to criticise a poetic effusion, “if you like this’ sort of thing, why, this is just the sort of thing you like.” A word of praise must be said for the excellent pen-and-ink sketches by Walter Hale which illustrate the book. “The Romance of a Favourite” (Apple ton), from the French of Frédéric Lolié« purports to be a biography of the Countess ct Castiglione, the most beautiful woman of the Second Empire. It was popularly supposed that Cavour hoped, through her fuscinations, to win Napoleon III to the Italian cause; but of this the book tains nothing authentic. Indeed, it value to the historian, except as throws side-lights on the gilded dissipa- tions of the Court of the Tuileries. Th matchless Countess had many admirers, in at feet secrets confided to con- has it no cluding the Orleanist princes, her her; if, seen she had M. us, of some and why does he thousands die d oft sixty many Loliée tell us so little, or has The Castiglion: ago, at the even to her inti mates, and her present biographer does really lift the veil. Still, the of her career is sufficiently apparent. The bcok is translated by W. M. Fullerton, who though Harvard graduate and Paris correspondent of the London Times, as he her letters? ten mystery assures possesses, who years age was a not tragedy th a long th seems occasionally to forget his native idiom In “Walking Essays” (Longmans) Ar thur Hugh Sidgwick rides his hobby wit! a mock solemnity that is quietly amusing He rises to the height of his great argument by a series of paradoxes: such ag that Wordsworth was not a good walker, bh cause he did not become intimate enough with nature The most entertaining essay is on “Walking in Literature.” Therein he soars no middle flight in pursuing thing unattempted yet in prose or rhyme. Walk ing assumes its appropriate dignity in the scheme of the universe, and other subject sink to their proper insignificanc: Th high seriousness of the undertaking may be judged from Appendix A to the essay which contains calculations “On the Rates of Walking of Various Persons in the Ego- st, Chapters 25 sqq.” The scientific spir of the investigation appears in the r cluding sentences: \ frivolous observer author was not very but, apart from the this would invalidate n irgument. We therefore and affirm that wrong might suggest careful in hi hideous blasph st of the prev shut our eyes ¢ De Craye’s watch the ing; ore went “An Original Canto of Spencer, D Part of his Fairy Queen, but ed. Now made Publick, Esq.,” the In sign’d as never Print by Nes tor Ironside author and publi er, Arthur H reproduction Nason, has given us a pho tographik (without annota tion) of Samuel Croxall’s politfeal allegor in published which is Spenserian stanzas, én known as one of the earliest ar of the eighteenth vival of interest in the poet the century r The imitatior whole, rathe ilfestations if Spenser’s style is, on a happy one The publisher has repro The Nation the text (thirty pages) with a view to ‘Graduate School instructors who desire to drill their students in the mysteries of ex ternal and internal criticism.” In our judg it make use edition would be a waste of time to of the poem, but the since the text in original form is not readily accessible. To from Mr which panies his reproduction, he does not aware of a second imitation of Spenser by Croxall published shortly after this one and ment, this welcome, new is its judg: accom- Nason's circular, seem entitled “Another original canto of Spen | cer.” The besetting sin of Wordsworth in his hours of weakness Was a prosaic solemnity and the same defect attaches to “Words worth, Poet of Nature and Poet of Man” (Ginn), the work of his latest critic, E Hershey Sneath. Even the dullest portions of “The Excursion” are not more unre- lieved by any touches of vivacity The es- say has a kinship with this particular poem in other ways also, for, despite Mat- thew Arnold’s warning, it is the philosophi cal side of Wordsworth’s poetry that espe cially attracts Mr, Sneath, and so the con sideration of the poet as a literary artist is virtually excluded from the plan of the book. The author first discusses tl sup posed influences of heredity and of physical and social environment in the early life of Wordsworth, and then proceeds to trace the evolution of his poetic and philosoph creed through the stages of growth and maturity If any value an | lair 1 for the book, it will be on the scor of the chronological ethod here ndicated But there was no need of burdening the pa with so large a number of detailed analyses of the poems Apart from the repetition in volved, no one who requires such analyse is likely to read an essay on Wordsworth with profit, and, on the other hand, it be trays a want of skill in the ritic to be so dependent on this method of interpreta tior Wor rf ] hows r. @ riticisr is not d I hed t l t of thought or by charm of styl New iders are not likely to be we for Wordsworth’'s poetry by language like the followi ( plied to the Ode Intimatior I I tality’) rhe I il p logy and philosop! f ind t vith their episte ole ] i ol i i tior ! ter vv i imagine the mn feelir t ] one e told } that } t ‘ Gr Ger l peal th t n i ort} oO but the t ( gm ts te ha \ ] phil osophi s) H | sopn A i ’ i festl ol 5 t t 0 portal! 1% i ( yrical r rat ; +} yor f Furtl Y ‘ i ’ , rdsworth t Poet M H olnt ew wi too ex ivel ral For t i ior or pora the Frer R itic t Ma t la t e the whi iter the pol al aspect f ti I 1} , K ] Ss no r | I ture t} extract of beef is like the | Z Ox regards the p s phil I of nature Mr. Sneath is rig points out Lord Morley’s misappr of Words th’ eaning tanking a hal niavful lly the lines: One fr May ofr Than TE) pHAa se om a mor of of ¢ can teach you and sages moral evil all the But surely misapprehension the quibbling to the On to ness poet mere pantheism of the “Tintern Is there really any essent! the of which the seems us conception underlies tween that re} verna othe Abi al diff this most to pression of pantheism in ancient tl viz., the eloquent lines in of Lucan’s “Pharsalia’? Estque del sedes, nisi terra et Ft cwlum et virtus ultra? Iuppiter est, quodcumaque moverisa The (Lippincott), Literary by La Sallie has two purposes. incomplet: of “T Born ord somewhat of residence Night,” “The Flam a score of other also to note incidentally of prosatk Poe places wl h were {| key productions ear and is that The glories Much the conje dull a hows meant full tvle mi of the ijor purpose moist ture of this son, the the manner her poet a gloomy, though brilliar istory of American Iitera rilby intended t The Eng rhe British In North America io American ¢ Mifflin) ton career } though sh The min tragedy « Superos per vite Hearthstones Corbel ty th Poet Southern ie Timrod, at sentimen ar pour sophon Ol >
Page 18
The Nation as becomes a correspondent who took the fine arts, as well as politics, for his prov- ines He has papers on Whistler, Gilbert, Irving, and Bernhardt, and, best of all, on the wonderful French tragedienne, now for- gotten except for her passionate letters, Aimée Desclé« He also writes up Mr. J. P Morgan and Mr. Carnegik For unalloyed fulsomeness his tribute to W. W. Astor re- alls Bishop Newman's ten-thousand dollar panegyric of Leland Stanford, jr. Until we read Mr. Smalley we did not suspect what in irreparable loss the United States suf- red when Mr. Astor deserted his native land in order to become a British subject On tl whole, we wonder whether enlight- encd public opinion was, or ever could be, influetr 1 by a writer of Mr. Smalley’s haracteristics, even though he had the i intage of speaking through such mega- phor is th London Times and the New York Tribune As a text for his volume he quot Ll senten from Machiavelli: so far § iny of his stories go the Italian pro- vert 8 non & vero, & ben trovato—would make a better motto The Witnesses to the Historicity of ] " (Open Court) is an English version of second part of Arthur Drews’s Dic Christusmythe.’ The translator, Joseph McCabe, abbreviates the preface f tl German edition omits alto- gether Smith’s reply to Weinel. and makes 0 r but ¢t plot of the original remain the sar Since for lircws the basel principle of all deep rel life ideal onism, and t nal does not haves in inde- lent ind unique significances in the ‘ l-p1 s, the question of the historical oO Jesus is for h in the main * an historical but a philosophical ques- fact, he urges frat y that the j tl I orical real of Jesus obstacle to r IS progress.”’ Vith this feeling, it is not ising that Dy 3 I basal principl ‘ all deep , , _ He 1 t t discus- r ness¢ to ft h vical ex- of Jesus with ination of y non-Ch an do ty neglect- t nsideration that t possible l is meagre, owing to the paucity extant sources, and by assuming that t oures must have referred to the in J had He really existed, Drews i ibl to reduce the actual evidence to ro He is aided at times by a method of procedure of which the treatment of the famcus passage in the “Annals” of Tacitus | notable instance. Here he pro- poses alternative hypotheses, including that of interpolation, to explain awey the force of the evidence, all the while refusing to entertain riously the only theory that has hitherto se« ed obvious With reference to the wit of Paul, he observe that we hould never have found the historical Jesus | the Pauline eplaties had we not previously d. termined to find Him thers and h contends that f Paul did know of an historical Jesus, t rematlr the nost it lubl of problems ] mad no wu of th knowledge r) ruth is that the ad erning reader, l or namely who shares the philo ophical pt ippositions of Drew recog- tantly that the person referred to Paul i@ not a real, that ie to say, an historical, man, but tl idea of a God
[ Vol. 96, No. 2479 Redeemer who becomes man. Passages to point to ar oppo- for which should seem conclusion are obviously glosses; - < is not an in- site example, Cor. xi, 23, terpolation in the text, there are no in- terpolations at all in the New Testa- ment.” Thus it appears that there is “no other source of the belief in an historical Jesus but the gospels.”" Since, however, the method of interpretation commonly employed by liberal treologians has gone must be The bankruptcy, a w method wit, the “mythic-symbolic.” into used, to anplication of this metLod to the gospels leads not unexp edly to the conclusion that Jesus is not an historical, but a Jesus is thus reduced chief obstacle to re- ligious progress removed. Like the “Ecce Deus” of W. B. Smith, to whom, with J. M. Robertson, acknowledgment of indebtedness mythical personage. to an idea, and the is made, the present volume is controver- sial rather than constructive, its special concern being the demolition of the his- torical or, as Drews prefers to word it, theological method of German liberal scholarship. After an interval of fifteen years since the second part of Prof. Ernesto Monaci’s “Crestomazia Italiana dei primi secoli” was noticed in these columns, the third and final part of this important work has at last appeared (CittAa di Castello: S. Lapi) The first two parts (1889 and 1897) have already rendered immense service, both as a textbook for students of the early Italian language, and as a collection of texts, many of which were otherwise difficult to find; but the need of the promised glossary and grammatical summary was keenly felt Many scholars, including at one time Pro- fessor Monaci himself, began to fear that they should never see the work completed; fortunately, however, the concluding part now before us, is no mere perfunctory end- ing, but more than fulfils the promise made at the beginning Additional texts, repre- senting types not previously included, to- rether with notes, corrections, and the ex- haustive grammar and glossary, bring the whole book to more than seven hundred large octavo pages The texts are both numerous and varied enough to make the grammar and glossary which are based on them comprehensive, and the competence of Professor Monaci for the task is The completed “Crestomazia” becomes the most important for the study of early Italian; and if it does unques- tioned. now work available not entirely supersede previous works of the kind, it makes them seem elementary in comparison, In his works on the life and writings of Cortes and Las Casas, Francis Augustus MacNutt had shown us what to expect of his specially numbered edition, just published of “De Novo, the Eight Peter Martyr D’Anghera” (Putnam), lated from the Latin with Notes and Intro- ductions. Peter Martyr was one of the most notable of the their residence in Orbe Decades of trans- took ut nth part Italians who many Spain in the sixt century. He. played a very important at the courts of Ferdinand and Charles _# He was a priest, finally an Abbot, a cour- tier, a diplomatist and ambassador, a sol- dier, a man of letters, and a scholar. Al- the conquest, Martyr had abundant opportunity though not an eye-witness to Spanish
Page 19
Jan. 2, 1913] to interview many of the Conquistadores on He obtained first- of the new country and His writings therefore first in importance on the early history of Spanish America, espe- their return hand of its are to Spain. information inhabitants. the among very cially Yucatan He was the first to give to the world detailed accounts of the dis- covery of a new continent. His writings are usually most accurate, as, for example, his description in the Fifth Decade of the form of the books used by the natives of the new country. Considering the difficul- ties of the original Latin, which is sadly mixed with Italian and Spanish forms, the editor has been most successful in his translation. It is a free rendering and is most readable. Frequent notes at the bot- tom of the pages and a careful index in- crease its usefulness. A few omissions hav: been noted in the bibliography of Martyr's writings. The ‘rst French edition of the first three Decades published in Paris in 1532 and the late editions in Spanish in 1892 and French in 1897 should be men- tioned. It is to be hoped that the editor and translator will continue to bring out further editions of the writings on Spanish America of the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries. Gomara, Oviedo, Remesal, Co golludo, and Villagutierre are only a few of those whose yvorks might with profit bé presented to th-» general reader. Science The Depths of the Ocean. By Sir John Murray and Dr. Johan Hjort. With contributions from Prof. A. Appellof, Prof. H. H. Gran, and Dr. B. Hellend- Hasen. New York: The Macmillan Co. $7.50 net. The mysteries of the ocean, its physi- cal and biological conditions, have long attracted the attention of scientists, but it is only in the last forty years, begin- ning with the famous Challenger expe- dition of 1872-76, that extensive and sys- tematic attempts have been made to ex- plore this unknown world. Now many organizations are engaged in the devel- opment of the modern science of ocean- ography. Foremost among these organizations has been the International Commission for the Scientific Investigation of the North Sea, which was inaugurated in 1899, largely through the activity of Sir John Murray, who had been connected with the Challenger expedition. In 1909, convinced that systematic observa- tions on the Atlantic might throw much light on some of the problems then studied in the more northern he proposed that if the Norwegian Govern- ment would lend the exploring ship Michael Sars and her scientific for a four months’ summer cruise in th« seas, staff North Atlantic, he would pay all th other expenses. The proposal was fa vorably received, and by the first of April, 1910, the ship was fully equipped and started to sea in charge of Dr. Jo han Hjort, Director of Norwegian Fish The Nation largely the scientific researches of this expedition, is nevertheless a thor- ough of these and general readers as of oceanography. on along we kk ome d account modern work will be by we ll lines, as by students Sir John Murray gives a succinct his torical review of oceanographical inves tigations, from the middle of the fif teenth century, when Cardinal Nicolaus Cusanus attempted deep-sea soundings with his spherical bathometer, down to the present. The prominent part which our Government and semi-private or- ganizations in this country have played in this work may justly be a matter of pride to us. Dr. Hjort points out that the of depends to a great extent upon the development of mechanical meaning the scientific instruments employed, but progress oceanography aids, not only also the whole arrangement of the ship itself. Ina he therefore its non-technical the equipment, comparing modern aids and manner discusses ship and methods with those of the Challenger expedition. He then takes up in some detail the work and the cruises of the Michael Sars in the ten years that she the oceanographi cal research and fishery problems in the has been engaged in Norwegian seas. General chapters on the depths and deposits of the ocean and on physical oceanography are followed by a more detailed discussion of pelagic plant life —the primary source of fish food—and by chapters on fishes from the sea bot- tom, invertebrate bottom-fauna of the Norwegian Sea and North Atlantic, and on pelagic animal life. Dr. Hjort’s final chapter on general biology is a valuable consideration of the adaptation of mar- ine organisms to their environment and an attempt to analyze the distribution of in relation to their external conditions. Nearly six hundred charts and figures, the latter mainly of collecting apparatus and of characteristic animal and plant organisms will greatly aid the general reader to an understanding of the text. The tables for converting metres into fathoms and for converting degrees of Fahrenheit degrees of Centigrade will likewise prove helpful. Not only does the book present in a pre- liminary manner many new and valua- ble data, but it is to be commended as a of species various discussed, into trustworthy contemporary epitome work in an important field of scientific research, The Geological Sut has ompleted i rer T ’ ) ’ re, f ta \ in tl ! lar } ty eight States of tl I M it in Callforr 14 I hi lr ‘ 4] } ‘ ly Vi { « Mount Elbert ’ feet ich, or onl ; Whi Mi t Ranier A 14 eries. ‘The book before us, though based feet, or 8 low i M I Wh and » feet lower tI wo riva In Wye g, ( N Mexico, a Nevada a i x iz y } ! ght 1 if ! Drama and Musie NOTES ON GERMAN DRAMA, Gerhart Hauptmann has been desery edly called the poet-voice of contempo rary Germany. For no other writer r« flects with like directness and intensity the conflicting currents in the emotion al and intellectual life of his generation Every one of that long line of his works, labelled with questions and situations confront briefly problem plays, deals ing people whose ethical standards have been unsettled by a new philosophy and whose attempts at living a new life end in hopeless tragedy. He lays bare the network of contradictory motives n which their will is entangted, with an understanding born of personal experi ence, He himself is the poetic incar nation of a transition type All his plans lend themselves to speculation concerning the slender thread of actual ity that underlies the author imagir ings, and his new drama of the artist temperament, Gabriel S lings Flucht” (Berlin: S. Fischer Verlag), is no exception The plot itself is old, the deserted wife and the discarded mis tress furnishing no new situatio! The audience is supposed vo be moved by the fact that Schilling should be lost to the world as man and as artist, because he is being ruined by these women But somehow the phrase “am Weibe zu Grunde gegangen” has been heard to often of recent years, and succecds only in suggesting the pitiful weakness ol these popular heroes of modern German In fact, the Achilles type almost drama and fiction heel of this ludicrously revealed in the scene Maurer, Schil masculine is whe re the sturdy and stalwart ling’s sculptor friend, who has just in vited his musician sweetheart Lucie to go with him to Greece, suddenly trans fers his interest to a new arrival—a change which the sensible girl takes as a matter of course. Sonorous phrases about the Hellenic spirit and Helleni manhood are current coin to-day But surely, Hellenic poets did not set up hu man weather-vanes as heroes of seriou drama. Would that Schilling trag! words, “Wir sind keine Grie lieber Junge! were heeded Hermann Bahr, th aut Concert,” has itten anot tfu comedy, “Das Tanzchen : F Verlag) It dea with the Meulti brought upon an elder! J ] member of the Get m tie barrassing alliance it it 1 ad venturess who las ! dr 1 to his family as piano teacher ey
Page 20
rhe Junker, whose name, Biest-Zeser, the nas been just lex Biest,’’ provid- a moral censorship nearly be blac toreaten like lf art, very omes extortion and kmail, hu ind Junk But » former he after all, more Zeser, Junker to capa- convincing t hin on Biest M.D.R. The commending him shrewd and the danger- characters are superb- ypes of certain of ' The dialect familiar conversation adds an ins lally thus settles classes Berlin al flavor. work Seerauber”’ Fulda’s latest is a four- “Der The Andalusia in and the plot hinges hero-worship of a man married Pedro, lthy man of staid and commonplace An elderly neighbor of dubious ipholds the heroine in her both engage in a an itinerary booth on the notorious n verse, I. G. Cotta). scene isa wn of the sev- enter entury, npon the romantic young to a \\ rs | habits reputation ind flirtation in women with his notiol! di mountebank sperate who as marketplace parades a pirate pposed to have perished at sea. beggar who has arrived at the same time, the populace learns that Pedro is the dreaded pirate. To win who has eloped with the the villain, Mm to enjoy spoils of makes a confession, but is arrest while the elopers are married by the himself. The picturesque set- amusing situations furnish of light and charming enter- But through a back reformed this actor-pretender, ad settled who h town of his career Crovernor ting and the an evening tainment Wilheln It Welgand’s “Kénige” (Leip- is a five-act drama of tical The is fourteenth century and dreaming of beauty poetry, menacing the of the famous s¢1-Verlag) merit acene a monarch, ning to music and of the rough danger the approach His great-uncle, a | magician, conjures a vision royal conscience a dream-play within of which a peas- rretender the from ro and is about to be proclaimed the awak announcement of the He suddenly realizes tedl to rouse the on forme n the cours wrests crown when dreamer the arrival gh The Nation his neglected responsibilities, summons his warriors, and vows to lead them to The play is a dignified and thoughtful piece of work, but did not at the performances in the spring prove a valuable acquisition of the theatrical victory. repertory. No Dauthendey, works by Max weaver of been year. how- than three that less one-time poetical arabesques, have published The ever, 15 f lusive and played within the circumstance, by tl e extraordinary explained success of his play, “Spielereien einer Kaiserin, hich so effectively handled the person- Russia. “Der Albert Lan- in three acts Catherine of (Munich is a romantic drama which, through the part that fate plays harks back the “Schicksalsdramen” the old school, though it presents some original fea- tures. The scene is a remote corner of Sweden, the atmosphere of which would make the improbable incidents plausible. A young man has been driven to suicide his love for an unscrupu- lous woman: his friend, with whom this woman is in love, avenges his death. These two, and the old lighthouse-keep- er who tells them the grewsome tale of the sea-dragon wurauli, are the sole ac- the drama, the bloody end of the audience to protest. has unusual dramatic some rare poetical ality of Drache Grauli” geen) to in the action, of most by in which But the strength tors roused work and touches. Franz Diilberg’s “Cardenio” (Berlin: Egon Fleischel & Co.) is a five-act drama in verse, in which the university milieu of Bolcgna at the beginning of the sev- enteenth century forms the interesting background for a passionate tragedy of student love. The author tells in the preface that the plot, which is original- that of a Spanish story, had been previously exploited in drama by An- dreas Gryphius, Achim von Arnim, and Immermann, but there is an intensity of feeling in the work which proves that the subject had taken an unusually strong hold of the author. He has made his hero something of a modernized Don Quixote, an incarnation of chival- rous righteousness and romantic love. The cosmopolitan student crowd lends itself to an abundance of characters, some of which are very skilfully drawn. A curipus little one-act piece by Rob- ert Scheu is entitled “Der letzte Abend” (Albert Langen). It presents the end of a friendship between two artists, the younger having outgrown the power which the elder wielded over him, and exulting in the breaking of this bond. That friendship meant for him the dawn of a new life, and it had brought the message of the great, wild, pagan life. When he upbraids the mas- ter with having raised in his works the cross, which denies his former aspira- tions, there is a remote suggestion of Wdgner-Nietzsche case. The de- ly him the [ Vol. 96, No. 2479 velopment of the conflict is rapid and clear, and the three characters, the master, his wife Cornelia, and Angelus, the seceding disciple, are well drawn. A. VON ENDE. “Years of Discretion,” by Frederick Hat- ton and Fanny Locke Hatton has just been produced in the Belasco Theatre is a piece of very uneven quality. In parts asion- which comedy, but oc thin it is excellent light it not too degenerates into and Founded it of a ally decorous the fect valuabk its legitimate ef- and the pleasant farce upon a idea, misses lack little This is a pity in a ein aitrical discretion of for for many of The of the good taste sce written nes ind ine a are pertinent satirical humor hero- forty- dulness rich and comely widow eight, suddenly »f a humdrum but useful and honorable ex- Puritanical New hankers after pleasures of the gay revolts against somewhat She stence in a England atmosphere the excitements and world, and resolves to taste them once mor: before the zest for them is dead in her for- A life-long friend, a New York enter the so- 50- ever. ciety woman, enables her to cial lists and provides a selected band of eligible bachelors her. With the expert aid of beauty doctors, hair-dresser, and costumers she is transformed into a vision of youthful loveliness, and is quickly besieged an anarchistical free lover, an ardent Irishman, and a cosmopolitan clubman, who has long been the envy and despair of the gentle sex. Her flighty con- duct into the heart of her strait-laced son, a youth of twenty-four, who is made the butt of his mother and her lovers. It is in the scenes in which this young man is introduced that violence done to nature, proper feeling, and refine- ment. She the clubman, after an admirably scene in which confesses to her ferhale federate that she shall not be to endure much longer the torture—of tight Boots, tight lacing, etc.— inseparable from the imposition she is prac- ticing. When the clubman, a great travel- ler, proposes a journey round the world for a honeymoon, she realizes that she is unequal to the enterprise, and in another excellent scene, which gives the play most of its value and brings it to a fresh and im- pressive close, makes full confession to her husband, before whom shepresently appears in all the comfortable charm of ripe ma- turity. Thereupon he admits that he, too, has been simulating more youthful energy than he really possesses, and declares his perfect readiness to pursue with her the peaceful joys of middle age. Apart from its more trivial or melodramatic moments, which are inconsistent with the general scheme of the composition, the piece is true comedy, and applies the lash smartly to many current fashionable follies. If the authors had been less eager after cheap laughter and applause, they might have achieved something much more worth while. As it is, the representation owes most of its success to the capital acting of Lyn Hard- ing, Bruce McRae, and Herbert Kelcey among the men, and, especially, of EMe Shannon, who enacted the heroine delight- fully. The scenic setting was perfect. No manager knows better than Mr. Belasco distract attention from inherent to meet by strikes dismay is captures humorous con- able physical she how to
Page 21
Jan. 2, 1913] dramatic defects by the arts of the pro- ducer. From the purely dramatic point of view Rutherford Mayne’s comedy ‘The Drone performed in Daly's Theatre on Monday afternoon, is not of uch importance, for it is somewhat crudely constructed along con- ventional! lines, and is almost devoid of ac tion or effectiy neident But it neverthe- less has its significance as another brick in the rapidly rising structure of the Irish National Theat In characterization and atmosphe! it is thoroughly representative of life on a small country far If the framework is ricket the personages, with the si ex on of an interpolated Scot are absolutely ifelike, and all the minor details of their domestic manners and halt its xtraordinarily veracious As a bit of genuine Irishry, the whole performan was more convincing, perhaps, than anything dene here by the Abbey Theatre players of Lady Gregory, though the representations of the latter were, as a rule, far superior in imaginative quality The acting of the company, imported by W. A. Brady. was notable for its level excellence and intelli- gent cooperation Charles Hawtrey will begin operations at the Apollo Theatre on the evening of Thursday, January 9. He will then pre- sent Birmingham's London George comedy, “Gen eral John Regan,” which the part of genial Irish doctor chief mission in life is to settle the affairs of his neighbors. His company, although still in- will include Cathleen Nesbitt, Vane Tempest, H. Winman, and G. W. Fay. Mr. Hawtrey is in negotiation with Leonard Boyne. in he plays a whose complete, also Henry Arthur Jones is writing a series of on the subject of the British Na- tional Theatre, about which he has definite ideas. essays The latest biography of Wagener, Cc just is- sued in Leipzig by F. E Leuckart, is by the Norwegian composer, Gerhart Schjel- derup. who a few years ago wrote a book on Grieg It is averred by the publishers that this is the first biography which describes certain episodes life without bias in Wagner's One of the principal events of the opera season in Paris be the production of Massenet’s “Panurge” at the Théatre de la Gaieté. Novelties are the order of the is to day at the Opéra Comique, in Paris. No fewer than eighteen first performances are scheduled for this season, most of them the first anywhere. Among the composers on the list are Rabaud, Tiarko, Pugno, Boulanger, Erlanger, Doret, Morel, Ropartz, Trépard, Laurens, Nogués, Lattés, Ratés, and Bru- neau whose “Les Bacchantes” seems to have scored little more than a succés @estime. Dancing plays a prominent réle in most of these operas After an absence from the concert stage of a number of years, Eugen d’Albert has once more reappeared before the public, and though during that time he devoted his attention exclusively to composition, his technical facility seems in no way to have forsaken him. The revelation of his skill at the piano given in the Liszt and Brahms concerts, which he played recently in Vien- na, was such that it comes in the nature The Nation of a sensation for the younger generatior of concert goers The tennial of tl G schaft Musikfr i in Vienna is rought or to th for t? : S } ri s | ! ) i t or had tl ) ! i inder tl r hare guist is Br ind R il £ [ nu I Hans R t i ted tl I tl i I known to A . is tha Wi Ger ‘ tious il itho i nt the } — ] r ~ Kr r H ( , thar , +} r Vort vear } will be i 4 } Pader ki 1 it not hat ¢ two iv be } ird tog her tal Last r t R i s land, they pla ita t } } for Art THE CORCORAN EXHIBI' Once in two years the Corcoran Art Gallery in Washington removes its per manent collection of paintings to make place for an exhibition of contemporary American art. A particular effort made has been this year by the hanging ommittee to space each picture, and, with few rare exceptions, to hang only one line of pictures. Among the pictures which stand out in,the exhibition there is one which no will fail tion, aside from its quality, give it prom- inence. It full-length of a fencing master, by Gari Melchers. The visitor to se Size and posi is a portrait gloveless hand shows labor, and the high lights on the nose and forehead diminish somewhat the effect of breadth jsut these are details insufficient to de stroy the total effect of surprising big- ness and poise. The same painter shows also a church interior, in which there are fine spontaneity and an altogether delightful realization of light, though success in attaining color is not so marked. In the same gallery with Melchers’s Church Interior is E. C. Tarbell’s Chil- dren Going to Ride, a rather inadequate picture for Tarbell and not as well com- posed as another picture, Portrait of a Young Lady, which might have been a preliminary study for it It the lat- ter a young girl is sitting on the steps ff a porch, arranging flowers, her face seen in profile and cut out a little too sharply against the sunlit lawn behind. It is not Tarbell at his greatest, but it is fresh and agreeable in color and is in every respect American It has refinement and native characté Among the portraits of tl present exhibition those by Cecilia Beaux take One of the a high position se is a po! trait of Sereno E. Pay good, livir work, able i hara I t} 1 portrait of a ia anding \ ning i and dress Aga st has hieved « i ~ y subt ; a i ss and cloak ar rilli xT ; id l he n 7 Vad ! \ i t overburde 1 with iint ! suc en able In tl same ’ vith I 1uX 8 portrait o Sereno E. 1 t her noteworthy portrait ur Both are by W. M. Chas laughter, the other of “Mr ( r} ire highly accomplished ri n such as makes an especially fine or dee] ippeal. Passages of vivacious pal! are in each, yet it cannot be said that the artist has shown his usual taste His exhibit also includ: ( of his celebrated still-life picture ‘ fish The Corcoran Art Gallery is fo nate in having purchased one of tl three examples of Frank Benson's w« in the present exhibition, a portrait ol his daughter seen in a light that rae ates upward, a serious piece of w which marks distinctly another hase of the American school. The spectator may quarrel a little with a light that throws the features into such strong relief that he as conscious of ey and nose and mouth is parately as of th SE whole head n all ia sal the And yet, © he picture is representative 7) painter, though not indicating the i extent of his vitality the insisted note he Since American little view, to follow it upon in t leads natur work as the landscape of Ben F« which could not be anything but native work. His Litchfield Hills is as trus it can be, and it gives out a sense of “the good brown earth’ in a pens mood. In his Late Autumn Moonri the masses of brown fern and dark tre are well composed, and the mystery and ; melancholy of the moment are felt wit! | out being sentimentalized Th another picture which the Gallery ha bought for its permanent collection One must be in an adaptable mood to see a true interpretation of natu! i in the work of Ben Foster and Ern: Lawson at the same time in the ul room. The two temperaments are wi ’ ly different, and yet there is a ‘ spirit in each Mr. Lawson's land ‘ is fine in light and color, th: f as sure in handling as the earth No painter in America to-day 4: more fully the distinguished tior which he has won for himself than Al den Wel: It would be impossible for
Page 22
20 painter to be less gifted with super Clever paint- the ial tricks of handling has apparently never made t invasion upon his own meth- all of cleverness, a certain ods One feels in his work an in stinctive dislike suggestion the bombastic the He is to the to notice antipathy towards mere of a false attitude one of strongest antidotes in cer- And painting tendency one is obliged tain superficial energetic workers. he has of that is developed a style absolutely personal His autumn landscape in the present exhibition the has simplicity and depth of the catalogue In his style tone reproduction in do it carried not beginning to justice other canvas he has his to the point of mannerism, though here again is the sense of reticent refinement so characteristic of this painter's work. tefore facing a picture by Arthur B. the mnind of idea that painting is necessarily a of He human figure and the land and sea, even but it is object seen that is to be considered, Davies, we have to divest the uses the Inatter representation. the glow of moonlight: not the rather the interpretation of an abstract as the limi- This paint- idea, as nearly akin to music tations of paint will allow er, Who employs suggestively primitive, terms, is one of our most Yet it is hard to find ndred spirit this side of Botticelli, E. W. Redfield pictures, both ilmost archalke modern painters al two night dark-blue both too heavy handed for so sub- Much better night pictures and seen through his own Mr French schools have had an effect modern their good and bad art has not escaped. presents done in tones and tle a problem than his Redfleld’s winter landscape im- eves is rhe measurable painting, influence Most of our ablest painters have native quality. Mary C will probably take her place in the of on and from American assatt is a striking exception. She hi ist tory art as a French impression- classification she has Camille Mau- pretence of her development 4 pupil of Degas, she has ed of life nd painting has very little in com under which already been ranked by makes no the clalr Miss Cassatt whatever of disguising sources pas most her in France, her mon with other American work The ingly piace with a Cat, not be more atrik than it Children a child's portrait by Miss itting on point could brought out has been by her pieture, Playing beside 1 Emmet In Cassatt’s ple its moth held color a nude child is cat The attacked with a legit that mother-and-baby and playing with a irl at em is frankly lap young her side painter interest never fails ve’ these subjects en presented by Miss Cassatt, from sentimental In comparison with canvas, Miss Emmet's picture of a golden-haired The Nation (Vol. standing with a her shoul- girl bonnet hanging down over ders seems tame and undistinguished— a pretty picture-book child. might be But it would be difficult to pass by without remark three pictures in Gallery F. Be- tween George Bellows’s Polo Crowd and Beach at Coney hangs John Alex- The facile elegance is not seen to Many justapositions cited for the sake of comparison. more his ander’s The Gossip of Mr. Alexander's advantage in proximity to George Bellows’s crude vitality. In the Polo Crowd everything is ex- The work is that of a young yet ob- ex- art such close xciting aggerated. painter not yet fully equipped, nor near his ultimate goal. Yet every vious defect seems justified by the tremely exhilarating effect achieved. In the same gallery hang the two hibits of Frederick Frieseke, one a char- acteristic garden scene with two ladies, a Japanese umbrella, and the patterns of sunlight and flowers. His more in- teresting picture shows a woman stand- ing by an open window hanging a bird- cage, the window box and the effect of within giving the ar- It is a joyous and ex- a conservatory tist a typical subject. charming canvas, the woman at the win- dow in a most amusing dress. A landscape by Willard Metcalf, The Red Bridge, is full of observation, not exactly big in treatment, but delicate, and with more atmosphere than this ar- tist generally attains. Compare it, for example, with his other landscape, which, like so many pictures in the pres- ent exhibition, has been seen before in New York. Two autumn-toned trees make a note of warm color at the foot of a hill. The hillside surface is well felt, but the picture lacks air and the shadows of the trees seem colored. Near The Red Bridge is a typical work by T. W. Dewing. Long ago this artist learned to paint delicate, fragile, beautifully colored genre pic- And if he has repeated himself a rather limited minute, tures until his art seems specialty this fact should not close the to the genuine quality in those than dry me- mind pictures which thodical repetitions ing, done on a wood panel, is one of that kind, painted apparently with charms and incantations beautiful, elu- but never frank are more sive, and suggestive, vieorous To progress so far without mention of the prize-winning pictures at least pre- giving them undue prominence. Childe Hassam won the first prize and the Corcoran gold medal with his New York Window. In addition to this beau tiful picture the has here The Bowl of Goldfish, in which color s unusually fresh and luminous. It is a fine gpecimen of his most felicitous was awarded or vents same artist worl The second prize to Daniel Garber for his Wilderness, a characteristically decorative picture. The artist has used nature rather free- ly to carry out a design somewhat trite- Gardiner Symons has won the third prize with a spacious landscape showing a river with ice breaking, that leads away to hilly coun- try, a good example of his work. The fourth prize went to Carl Nordell for a nude seated figure. The artist is not afraid to attack a difficult problem, though his success with this canvas is only half complete. The figure does not detach well from the background, partly because the local color in the hair is not enough affected by the light that flows over the rest of the figure. ly “idealized.” Tapestries, long neglected, are to-day sought so enthusiastically for museums and private collections that welcome will be given to the encyclopaedic “Tapestries, Their Origin, History, and Renaissance” (Lane), by George Leland Hunter. The author, a Harvard graduate, a trained weaver, and experienced writer for an upholstery jour- nal, has studied tapestries in American and foreign collections. Among his previous description of Burgundian contributions is a Museum’s original the Metropolitan Seven Sacraments published in the Burling- ton Magazine in 1907. His scholarship is such as to enable him to present an appar- ently strong case against M. Guiffrey’s ex- planation of the tapissiers sarrazinois who made trouble for Parisian workers on the haute lisse in 1302, the American writer urging that these “Saracen weavers” were not weavers of othertextiles than tapestries, but practitioners of the low warp weaving that characteristic Renaissance tapestry weaving. Lack ot lite- rary finish and lucid arrangement makes Mr. Hunter’s book hard reading, despite its pro- fusion of alluring information and tempt- ing illustrations. The non-technical reader is confused at the start by frequent refer- ence to technical processes, an explanation of which begins on page 232. Considerable repetition occurs. Thus the nature of the transition from Gothic to Renaissance is touched upon in set phrases in each of sev- eral chapters. One seems, in brief, to read a series of magazine articles which, under more liberal use of scissors and blue pencil, might have become a consistent book. This sense is heightened by so obvious a slip as that of referring to M. Jules Guiffrey as if early became of The present paint- | he were still administrator of the Gobelins; whereas he resigned that office several | years ago. Important tapestries have lately Boston Museum of is no mention, are described. acquired at the Arts of which there older possessions been Fine though These and other minor defects, due presum- ably to preparing sections of the book at different periods, should be corrected in a later edition. The merits, prehending what ancient and modern tapestries transcend all The writ- tapestry and of a work com- knowing meantime, is worth about limitations of style and make-up hopeful for the future of weaving. He describes the founding continued success of the first tapestry works in America at Willlamsbridge and the sub- sequent starting of the Herter looms; also er is
Page 23
Jan. 2, 1913} Of the most celebrated tapestry manu- “I believe in New York city. of present-day European facturers the statement it at the the art in its pristine vigor if they will de- liberately forsake nteenth and eigh- teenth-century precedents, andreturn to six- teenth-century method.” With English during and the nineteenth-century revival of arts Mr He foremost producer of these tap- fairly book): is made: is possible Gobelins to revive seve texture and tapestries produced since and crafts Hunter is sympathetic. says of the (and literary illustrates “William citation of the the form estries the Morris (1834-96), who founded the tapestry works at Merton, near London, in 1881, was a genius. He had more influence on the in- dustrial arts, I believe, than any other man in the world’s history. He actually made the blind see and the lame walk. He changed the whole point of view of thou- sands who buy art objects, and the methods of many who produce them.” The Merton processes, as still continued, are commend- ed to American craftsmen for imitation in preference to those of Paris and Aubus- son. “If we ever get down in earnest to the weaving of modern tapestries in ar- ras texture, we shall, like William Morris go back to the high warp loom and once more compose line drawings in wool and gold and silver, with little silk or none at all.” In general, he fully appreciates Gothic tapestries and has no very high opinion of the Renaissan productions. More “atmospheric” than Mr. Hunter’s work is “The Tapestry Book” (Stokes), by Helen Churchill Cande: Its sprightly manner is seen in the dedication “to two certain Byzantir Madonnas and their own é rh ithor develops many literary elationships which give the reader a sens¢ ff the place of tapestries among the arts and their ir rtance as historical docu ment The tal of tapestry,” she writes “is like a vine hanging on a frame of his tory Following for the most part facts set forth in French by Michel, Jubinal Guiffres and other writers, sh tells a straightaway story, with passing references to social and economic conditions, as well as to tl personal influence of monarchs and of such great artists as Memling, the Van Eycks, Raphael, Rubens, and Watteau Venice and Genoa receive full credit as centres for distributing Renaissan tap- estries. There is an amusing description of the patronage of Francis I, “an over- dressed, ever-ambitious figure, at the be- ginning of things modern in French art.” The rise are traced fluently. generation Mrs skeptical, writing the possible decadence of Gobelins Of their Candee “Men and re- is apparently who have worked in the deadening influence of the Gobelins declare that the factory cannot last much longer. jut it is improbable that France —republican France that holds with bour- geois tenacity to aristocrat evidences will abandon this, her expensive tax, her inheritance of the line of Kings The Merton, Baumgarten, Herter, and other modern products are commended highly. Robert Lee MacCameron, an artist known specially for his portraits, died in New York Sunday morning at the age of forty elx He was born in Chicago, and after va rious experiences studied phinting in Paria under Géréme Of late ur is main and New tained studio ! The Nation York. Among those who have sat to him ar President Taft and President McKinl D. Jeror Elwell, an A rica painte lied in Naples on Friday ged sixty-five When he Was twenty-fiv rs old } to Antwerp to continue his study of irt nd during t period produced t of } best-knov work \ vy ¢ \ ve l unes ¢ Dombereg \ r hibiti hi pictures 1 this ntr l ‘ tt ind sir ' 3 ved ih « } li broad Jea B | ird ) r ibly } } ) f ‘ | rs Is ¢ iin P He \ t 1S48 ] } j n s Meiss« I H hit Sator of 1867 } I > r f Meiss s li I hi i ry life was. { al at tion At the Salon of 1868 h xhibited th Halt of ntr vhich Edmond About d s j lint R ! Deuwr I 1 \ It Re t Drill. Ca ~ M ly hed ll r tl T j 1 io } eX 1) I Prus W ) ( | w ] I i ox ni The ¢ é I 872 id g I nd ! z of f tr Par } lal ‘ ‘ il ’ i I Honor Amor } wu 1 t oiti S t , _ inance E STOCK EXCHANGE AND THE LEGISLATURI It can ! lly | lou d I teé of legis: ol n regard Ste c change ill b brought up in the Legislature of N York Stat ee ing session; with what result, it would t premature to predict \ngry crit- icism of Stock Exchange methods and practices had become very general, even before the re port of Gov. Hughes's com mittee of 1909 on speculation and the stock exchanges. The bitterness of this criticism is to be explained through Various causes. It began ith numerous incidents on the Stock Exchange, dur ing the decade past, which caused some extremely indignant comment on Wall Street itself, and even in the Exchange's own membership I is intensified h 1 tures of fact and f ion, asoned high for the general publi pala Mr. Lav son's “F izied Finat It naturall ter ove | If Ww I 1 p) n ft j out the “Mone rrust I vas stir red up to a pitch « ( d ¢ nt tl earings of ] » f +) ss 1 of last spring, was directed largely to both real whose examination witnesses, and fancied abuses of the New York Stock Exchange, and which more lat lv, at Washington, drew forth some rather extraordinary testimony from the chairman of the Stock Exchang own law committee taken articles in along with All this, nunciatory many po the press, has virtually insured t nsideration of possible Stock Ex hange regulation and reform through e new State Legislature which con nes at Albany this mont! rhe unfor tunate part of the whole pending crit icism of financial practices and institu tions—not excepting that which has been excited by the Money Trus it vestigation is that it has been so im and n pregnated with ignorance sapp! hension that, by attacking imag ury vils, it has frequently missed the real Is altogether. What those real evils are, eve telligent man who has observed the trend of thing in the decade pas perfectly well aware. Chief among t the gross manipulation of certa tocks by men with a ma in ( f nceial resource ind mit u ( mon sense or moral scruples ( purpose has been, on t ( i their activity to create a false i ; rance of heavy, bona-fide buying, and i false Ik fj ‘ i iders ma ve deluded | + I i or I ) ( t year reached | , f aiss wetul il tolerabl ao | T ‘ : nki ‘ ind tt ired avils mu ae ! i t! vill real 1 { gh S reported 1 109 that j ( ! int cal pr! t evil by ey rt I er 1 authority « r the 1 bers to p ! then But the k J ha does not fulfil that dut t will 1 I festly have put a] timat eapon int the hands of the advo of dra public regulation The pity of it is that the pending d cussions of the problem, instead of d recting its attention to the things that can be and ould be reformed hould beat the air with all sorts of haphazard suggestior based on ae superf ! glance at the whole Stock E in problem In one of last eek ! i of the nec iry basis for dealin t Stock Exchange refort vl ] ribed as the three } ere set fortl that the Ex ncorporated, that . ia t act ‘ indt only lace n yor} 4 ontract in be enfe d iy ea re how t ould appeal to tl! inds ‘
Page 24
> ~ “> ~ The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2479 cious and nothing could more utterly | have ignored the path to correction of the real abuses. The Exchange is unincorporated, and virtually all other exchanges are and have always been; for although the Bourse is a quasi-governmental institution, and although it is styled the “company of agents de change,” the power to discipline members is lodged with the governors as in the case of other stock exchanges. The re- port of Gov. Hughes's committee, even while intimating the possible future ne- for requiring incorporation, pointed out that the resultant submis- to the courts of cases of wrong- doing in the membership of our own Stock Exchange “would involve delays and technical obstacles which would im- pair discipline securing any greater measure of substantial justice.” 80 Paris elected cessity sion without One is tempted to inquire how much been given to this the reform. consideration has fact cates of overnight the practice cocksure advo- To say that important by Stock Exchange “is permitted to not only puts the cart the but whatever usury” effectively before horse, makes account either of reason the exemption of demand loans from the ( tical pli ments collateral mergency, no for restriction or of its prac- That the exemption ap- negotiable instru- Exchange market as that nobody, er cent effect to all Oo sorts of s well as to Stock that, in a money it favors the borrower uch as it does the lender: is com- n or out of the Stock Exchange, A MONTESSORI MOTHER By DOROTHY, CANFIELD FISHER Surel tie t in piring mos ional »rd- aucat R —_ | I] $1.25 net Henry Holt&Co “i, fe 84 W.33 8t «9 New York Columbia University Studies in Wistory, Economics, and Public Law Vol. LII., No. 2. THE DISTRIBUTION OF IN- COMES IN THEUNITED STATES By FRANK HATCH STRI Pa at . ' A 7 te sity Fello Columbia Author of The Standard ing.” Rvo Paper cot M onomics De Univer University, of Liv $1.50 GHTOFF, Ww ere Longmans, Green, & Co. pelled to borrow on such a basis; that the borrower adopts this recourse be- cause he can pay off his loan at will to-morrow, instead of paying interest during a month or more, and that the | system of call loans flourishes on the | Stock Exchange primarily because of the system of daily settlement of ac- counts—these are treated as wholly im- material considerations. As for the enforcement of “gambling | contracts,” it will hardly be disputed that plenty of Stock Exchange opera- tions fall morally under such a category. But exactly the same thing may be said of any speculative market and of every other industry. Whether the buying of real estate for a rise on borrowed money, or the contracting to deliver at a fu- date grain or building material the contractor does not to-day possess, but which he believes he will be able to get at a lower price than to- day's, does or does not differ in mo- rality from similar undertakings with investment securities, is surely a ques- tion worthy of sane consideration. The problem, in other words, is not whether certain admitted practices and tendencies on the Stock Exchange do not need correction, but whether the way to correct them is to conduct a cam- paign of so blind and sweeping a char- acter as to miss all the genuine points issue. Perhaps, in the subsequent course of the discussion, some intelli- gent suggestion will emerge as to how the known and recognized evils, which were part of the rank and unwholesome ture which at PYGMIES AND PAPUANS: The stone age of to-day in Dutch New Guinea. By A. F. R. WOLLASTON. The adventures and scientific re- sults of an expedition to the Snow Mountains of Dutch New Guinea made under the auspices of the Royal Geo- graphical Society. Octaro. Profusely illustrated in color and black and white, and with mapa. $4.00 net. Studies in the Psychology of Intemperance G, E. PARTRIDGE, Ph.D. her of “The Nervous Life,"’ ete, B A Thie relation conditions in Li le ne ’ 5 considers its subject in psychological and social Practical and grounded it is of special value to all interested in intemperance as an in- dividual or social problem. 12mo. $1.00 nbt, postpaid $1.10 STURGIS & WALTONCO, 81-38 East 27th Street, New York. book to 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, WRITE DODD, MEAD & COMPANY FOURTH AVE, & 50TH STREET, NEW YORK | growth of financial exploitation in the | Past dozen years, can be dealt with by | themselves. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Almanach de Gotha. 1913. Lemcke & Buechner. Bridges, Robert. Poetical Works, excluding the Eight Dramas. Frowde. Daugherty, L. S. and M. C. Principles of Economic Zoélogy. Part I. Philadel- phia: W. B. Saunders Co. $1.25 net. Eugenic Record Office, publications. Me- moir No. 1, The Hill Folk, by F. H. Dan- jelson and C. B. Davenport; No. 2, The Nam Family, by A. H. Estabrook end C. B. Davenport; Bulletin No. 1, Heras#ity of Feeble-mindedness, by H. H. Goddard; No. 4, Inheritance in Epilepsy, by C. D. Davenport and D. F. Weeks; No. 5, He- redity of Insanity, by A. J. Rosanoff and F. I. Orr; No. 6, The Trait Book, by C. B. Davenport; No. 7, The Family-His- tory Book, by C. B. Davenport; Heredity in Mental Diseases, by H. A. Cotton, Cold Spring Harbor, N. Y. Gosse, Edmund. Portraits and Sketches. Scribner. Kipling Reader for Upper Grades. pleton. McConnell, F. J. Eaton & Mains. Massinger, Philip. (Masterpieces of the English Drama.) Edited by L. A. Sher- man. American Book Co. Oman, C. W. C. Wellington’s Army, 1809- 1814. Longmans. $2.10 net. Russell, A. G. B. The Engravings of Wil- liam Blake. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $7.50 net. Sharman, Lyon. The Horse that Educated the Children. Winnipeg: The Author. Smart, G. T. The Temper of the American People. Boston: Pilgrim Press. $1.25 net. Streightoff, F. H. The Distribution of In- comes in the U. 8S. (Col. Univ. Studies.) Longmans. Walton, Perry. ton, Mass.: Printing Co. Wren, P. C. Dew and Mildew. $1.35 net. | D. Ap- The Increase of Faith. $1 net. Bos- and The Story of Textiles. Walton Advertising Longmans. Immigration and Labor The Enonomic Aspects of European Immigration to the United States By ISAAC A. HOURWICH, Ph.D. With numeroug diagrams and maps. 2.50 net; by mail, $2.75. An exhaustive treatise tracing the causes of immigration to the United States and its effect upon the condition of American labor. The author concludes that the most drastic restriction of immigration would not facilitate the solution of any of the labor problems engag- ing the attention of the public, whereas the proposed literary test would prove futile even as a meas- ure of restriction. New York G.P. Putnam’s Sons London 8vo. THE FLOWING ROAD Adventuring on the Great Rivers of South America By CASPAR WHITNEY inserts and maps. S8vo. Cloth. $3.00 net. Postpald, $3.20 - B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. NUEY MARL | 24 | Founders of Modern |] A New Book by Dr. G. STANLE ' D. APPLETON & COMPANY NEW YORK
Page 25
‘