The Nation 1912-12-19: Vol 95 Iss 2477
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
= umm - te VOL. XCV—NO. 2477 THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 1912 B® ba®: PP sE TEN CENTS @9@ NEW BOOKS OF TRAVEL, Etc. €?9% The Cottages and Village Life of Rural England B With 52 Colored Plates BY P. H. DITCHFIELD, M.A. and many line drawings A. R. QUINTON Mr. Ditchfield’s book is the expression of the feeling that the peculiar beauty of the old cottages and the viilage life of rural England is slowly, but surely, vanishing. The new aspects evoked by the Spirit of Modern Progress may have a charm of their own, but it is well that some one should preserve, as author and artist have done here, the old- time flavor. One may see the children at their games, the gossips on the bridge, the lace-makers throwing their bobbins; or may enter the low door of the village-shop, and hear quaint histories of the generations gone. Altogether they have given us a book of unusual beauty. The treatment of Mr. Quinton’s color-plates, giving the effect of dark frames on a tinted paper, is excellent. Demy quarto, net, $6.00 Karakoram and Western Himalaya |The Land That Is Desolate An account of the Expedition of the By Sir Frederick Treves Duke of the Abruzzi Probably the most valuable account of modern to the highest altitudes yet reached by man. Re- Palestine yet written. The great surgeon's power of keen diagnosis is not blinded by his deep rev- erence for sacred associations, and the result Is at once truthful and sympathetic. Illustrated from photographs by the author. $3.00 net; postpaid, $3.20 lated by Fillipo de Fillipi and superbly illustrated by Vittorio Sella. In two, vols., net $15.00. “After his splendid book describing Ruwenzori it seemed that nothing so fine in the history of exploration could be produced again, but this is even more fascinating.” —The Sun, New York. Dawn in Darkest Africa The Conquest of New Granada By the Rev. John H. Harris By Sir Clements R. Markham, K.C.B., F.R.S. 5h oauction her Rand Cosunee The first history of the lost civilization of the The force of the book will be felt wherever men Chibchas, by the well-known author of “The deal with a native population as a valuable asset Incas of Peru,” etc. With a map. of a country, instead of a burden. Lord Cromer’s Small demy 8vo, $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.10. Preface and Mr. Harris’s text should be read by , every one interested in missions or in colonies. The Surgeon s Log By J.J. Abraham The illustrations of native customs, etc., from The day-by-day story of a young ship's doctor photographs by Mrs. Harris, are exceptionally making his first voyage from gray Glasgow to vivid. $3.50 net; postpaid, $3.70 the Far East; one of the most fascinating books of leisurely sea travel ever written. ‘ Cloth, 8vo, $2.50 net; postpaid, $2.65. Rambles in the Pyrenees By F. Hamilton Jackson Aspects of Algeria By Roy Devereux Describes the romantic associations of the dis- A valuable account of the French attempt to tricts on the French slopes of the Pyrenees, colonize this picturesque Moslem land. Gascony, etc. 100 illustrations, chiefly by the Illustrated, $3.50 net; postpaid, $3.67. | author. Cloth, 8vo, $6.00 net; postpaid, $6.22 | E.P. DUTTON & COMPANY, Publishers, 31 West 23d St., NEW YORK
Page 2
The Nation 1 1 EEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 186 The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 Educational CONNECTICUT fi )IDGEFIELD SCHOOL, Ridgefield, Connecticut. \ A boarding-school for boys Prepares for illege or scientific school Rev. ROLAND J. MULFORD, Pb.D., Headmaster. COLORADO THE WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER Accredited with Eastern Colleges music advantages Gymnasium. I ii FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everetr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. Za Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av..NewYork 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland S14 Steger Bd..Chicago 343 DouglasBd., LosAngeles Bk Bd.,.Denver 345 Wright Blk., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Superior climate for girls Fine 920 Sav Harlan P. French, Prop Vincent B. Fisk, Mer. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY knows how Twenty-one years of successful ex verlence in bringing together good teachers and good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y¥ Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself PROFESSORSHIP professor of chemistry at und who has since had experience in chemical tn- dustries, desires to return to university work as professor of pure or applied chemistry Abundant vidence as to qualifications, professional standing im! exceptional teaching ability Graduate of leading universities at home and ibroad Address: ‘‘Spectemur,’’ care The Nation. A most appropriate and refined HOLIDAY GIFT The artistic and well-known Etchings of Famous Americans JACQUES REICH, 105 West 40th Street NEW YORK. You can always find At DUTTON’S the latest books; the rare books; illustrated books of all kinds; cards, calendars and art novelties. 31 West 23d St. A gentleman, for several years | 1 State university | ean be produced. | LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND JUST PUBLISHED OUTLINES OF EUROPEAN HISTORY: Part Il Robinson and Univer- By James Harvey Charles A. Beard, Columbia sity This new volume for high-school use is a cteristic and valuable addition to the tobinson and Beard Histories It is an ridgment f the author's two-volume elopment of Modern Europe,’’ and cov- the period from the opening of the eighteenth century to the latest events pre- vious to publication The text is marked by the same fine judgment of historical values distinguishes the other Robinson and Histories (In preparation.) Ow'lines of European History cloth, 555 pages, illustrated. $1.60. GINN AND COMPANY, Boston NewYork Chicago London Atlanta Dallas Columbus San Francisco, DEUTSCHE HEIMAT Edited by Josefa Schrakamp. 80.80 Treats the various divisions of Germany in geographical sequence, and gives short descriptions of nat- ural seenery, national and local cus- student life, important historical famous buildings, the tradi- tions and tales assoc!ated with them, and numerous Questions for use in conversation and a vocabulary are Included tome events poems AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Old English Riddles Eorren py A. JI. WYATT, M.A, University of Cambridge, England. Thia contains the text of the riddies of the Exeter MS., with | notes, and glossary | Belles Lettrea Serica. xxxvill4+103 pages, 69 cte. | D. Cc. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS, | BOSTON NEW YORK cnicaago. | TYPEWRITING Secu fier bocn, hetwick Pe Boston | | ninety-three introduction, | | LETTERS AND MEMORIALS OF WendellPhillips Garrison Editor of The Nation 1865-1906 In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. During the forty-one years in which he edited the Nation, with a _ thor- oughness, ability, and conscientious devotion unsurpassed in the records of American journalism, Mr. Garrison was an indefatigable correspondent, never employing an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who embraced practically all the leading American scholars and critics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a sufficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the relations between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exercised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes, and sympathies. The volume also con- tains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and several of his characteristic editorials, re- views, and essays, besides a fine photogravuré portrait. Price, $1.50 net, postpaid. _-— Houghton Milflin Company BOSTON NEW YORK
Page 3
Dec. 19, 1912} The Nation THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YEAR ART By Auguste Rodin (Translated from the French of Paul Gsell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 illustrations in photogravure and half-tone Buckram, $7.50 net; three-quarter levant, $15.00 net; carriage ad- ditional. A book which takes its place at once as | the most important art book in years. It covers practically the whole range of art, and abounds in memorable analyses of the works of the masters of painting and sculpture, ancient and modern. Send for deacriptive circular. Small, aennens & Co., Publishers, Boston ee “I have read your last book with solid| satisfaction and it shall be one of my! pleasures to make as many people read it as I can reach. It is full ripeness and mellowness—worth tons of ordinary social- | ist prattle on that subject,” writes John Graham Brooks to Charles F. Dole, author of “The Burden of Poverty.” Postpaid 55 cents. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth ave., New York. LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- ries Ancient —y modern languages. Translation, revision of manuscripts, etc MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. 96 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, WRITE DODD, MEAD & COMPANY FOURTH AVE, & 30TH STREET, NEW YORK Founders of Modern Psycho! nm eee ry The most important of recent books on the Near East. Mr. Woods carries the subject forward to a point hitherto unattained. —New York Times. THE DANGER ZONE OF EUROPE Changes and Problems intheNearEast By H. CHARLES WOODS, F.R.G:S. WITH 3 MAPS AND 52 ILLUSTRATIONS Svo. 1011. 32S Pages. 83.50 net LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston READ MONTGOMERY’S NEW BOOK CHRONICLES OF AVONLEA By the author of ‘“‘“ANNE OF GREEN GABLES,”’ Of which over 300,000 copies have Net $1.25. Postpaid $1.40 ETC. been sold Plays and Players in Modern Italy Being a study of the Italian stage fected by the political and social life and character of to-d as af- manners “At McCLURG’S” It is of interest and importance to Librarians to know that the books reviewed and advertised in this magazine can be pur- chased from us at advantage- ous prices by Public Libraries, Schools, Colleges and Universities In addition to these books we have an exceptionally large stock of the books of all pub- lishers—a complete as- Sortment than can be found on the shelves of any other store in the entire country. We solicit correspondence from li brarians unacquainted with our facilities. LIBRARY DEPARTMENT A. C. McClurg & Co. CHICAGO more book A New Book by Dr. G. STANLEY HALL D. APPLETON & COMPANY - NEW YORK By ADDISON McLEOD Svo, cloth, gilt top, with illuatrations $2.75 net Charles H. Sergel & Co., Chicago THE FLOWING ROAD j iventuring on the Great Rivers of South Translation eee t ASPAR W HITE Y - Magazine excerpts on all subjects sup- 24 inserts and maps Cloth £3.00 Translation from French and German, High- Plied. Let me know what you are inter- Postpaid $ ,. 20 est references. Miss Julia Franklin, care The Nation ested in. H. Williams, 105 E. 22d St.. N. Y. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. . > of Who Writes for The Nation? These names are taken from a list of more than two hundred contributors : Prof. Francis G. Allinson Prof. G. L. Goodale Prof. T. H, Morgan Prof. C. W. Alvord Prof. T. D. Goodell \. D. Noyes Prof. C. McL. Andrews Rear-Admiral C. F, Goodrich, U.S.N. Prof. G. R. Noyes Prof. Irving Babbitt Prof. W. W. Goodwin Rollo Ogden Frederic Bancroft Pr GC. i Grendeent Prof. H. F. Osbor C. William Beeb: FOE, a wenegen Countess Pardo-Bazar Bernhard Berenson Ferris Greenslet Mrs. Joseph Pennell Prof. Hiram Bingham Rev. W. E. Griffis Rev. John P. Peters H. W. Boynton Prof, A. D. F. Hamlin Gustav Pollal Gamaliel Bradford, jr Arthur 8. Hardy Prof. James B. Pratt Prof. James H. Breasted Prof. J. M. Hart Miss Ruth Putna William Garrott Brown Prof. C. H. Haskins Mrs. G. H. Putnan Prof. J. Douglas Bruce Prof. George Hemp] Prof. E. K. Rand Prof. Chas. J. Bullock Prof. F, Hirth Miss G. M. A. Richter Lawrence J. Burpee Prof. E. W. Hopkins Prof. F. N. Robinsor Prof. W. H. Carpenter Prof. J. K. Hosmer Prof. James H. Robinson Gen. W. H. Carter, U. S. A. Prof. A. V. W. Jackson Prof. J. Roye: F. W. Coburn Prof. Joseph Jacobs Prof. W. H, Schofield Prof. Archibald Cary Coolidge Prof, T. A. Jaggar Prof. H. R. Seager Prof. Lane Cooper Prof. Morris Jastrow, jr. Prof. Stuart P. Sherman Kenyon Cox Prof. W. H. Johnson Prof Paul Shorey John Cotton Dana Prof. A. G. Keller Prof. J. T. Shotwell Prof. W. M. Daniels Prof. Francis W. Kelsey Prof. J, FE. Spingarn Prof. W. M. Davis Prof. J. F. Kemp Lindsay Swift Stoddard Dewey Prof. C. J. Keyser Wm. R. Thayer Prof. A. V. Dicey Arne Kildal Prof. Calvin Thomas Prof. Frank H. Dixon Prof. George W. Kirchwey Pres. J. M. Thomas Prof. Ephraim Emerton Prof. G. W. Knox Prof. C. H. Toy Mrs. A. von Ende Prof. Chas. R, Lanman Paget Toynbes Prof. E. P. Evans L. 8. Livingston J. R. Towse Prof. Sidney B. Fay Prof. Gonzalez Lodge Prof. W. P. Trent Prof. W. 8. Ferguson . Prof. A. O. Lovejoy oO. G. Villard H. T. Finck Prof. D. B. Macdonald Luigi Villari Prof. Warner Fite Prof. Wm, MacDonald Dr. Joseph W. Warren Prof. George T. Flom Prof. A. C. McGiffert Prof. A. G. Webster Prof. H. J. Ford Prof. Allan Marquand Horace White Worthington ‘C. Ford Henry Rutgers Marshall Prof. Burt G. Wilder Prof. J. E. Frame Prof. Frank J. Mather, jr. Capt. C. deW. Willeox, U. ©. A Prof, Kuno Francke Albert Matthews Prof. F. W. Williams Fabian Franklin Prof. Elmer T. Merrill Dr. 8. L. Wolff Prof, P. H. Frye Prof. R. B, Merriman Prof. F. J. E. Woodbridg> Prof. John Fryer Prof. Lawrence H. Mills Gen, A. A. Woodhull H. Nelson Gay Prof. George F. Moore Prof. C. H. C. Wright Rev. Charles R. Gillett Prof. Louis T. More
Page 4
iv The Nation [Vol. 95. No. 2477 POETRY The MODERN READER’S CHAUCER The Complete Poetical Works of Geoffrey Chaucer rendered in modern English by Jonn S. P. Tat- rock and Percy MacKaye. Color plates by War- wick Goble. The handsomest book of the holiday season.”— The Bookman $5.00 net. $y JOHN MASEFIELD. THE STORY OF A ROUND-HOUSE AND OTHER POEMS $1.80 net. THE EVERLASTING MERCY AND THE WIDOW IN THE BYE STREET Incomparably the finest literature of the year.” d Edition $1.25 net. TRAVEL SOUTH AMERICA: Observations and Impressions By the Rt. Hon. JAMES BRYCE. mprehensive, clearest, sanest, and rh most co l iting volume on South America.” $2.5v net. PANAMA EDWARDS. of Panama from early times Illustrated. $1.50 net. ALBERT inating sent day by Che fase story to the pre SOCIAL BETTERMENT SOCIALISM FROM THE CHRIS- TIAN STANDPOINT By Father BERNARD VAUGHAN, 8. J. The broad facts of Socialism and their relation to Christianity. $1.50 net. CHRISTIANIZING THE SOCIAL ORDER By Dr. WALTER RAUSCHENBUSCH. The new social awakening of moral and religious forces $1.50 net. PUBLIC QUESTIONS THE GOVERNMENT OF AMERICAN CITIES By WILLIAM BENNET MUNRO, Ph_D., LL.B. Author of “The Government of European Cities,” etc. \ practical description of city government in the United States $2.25 net. THE ESSENTIALS OF INTERNA- by TIONAL PUBLIC LAW By AMOS 8. HERSHEY, Ph.D. A nm based on modern up-to-date au- thorities $2.00 net. ttable wor! youve xy THE MACMILLAN COMPANY — =e = eS) i ”n — e~ 0 | © | A ”D Oo = Ber oo co 2 ee > MN je) ys BELLES LETTRES CARMEN SYLVA: SKETCHES FROM THE ORIENT By PIERRE LOTI. Author of “Disenchanted,” etc. “A book of which every page is a picture. Written with the delicate art and grace of the greatest literary impressionist of our times.” $1.00 net. By WILLIAM BUTLER YEATS. THE CUTTING OF AN AGATES31.50 net. THE GREEN HELMET AND OTHER POEMS $1.25 net. New books which again reveal the distinguished Irish author as a poet and essayist of exceptional charm. | ART MORNINGS with MASTERS OF ART By H. H. POWERS, Ph.D. The development of Christian art from the time of Constantine to the death of Michael Angelo. Profusely illustrated. $2.00 net. A WANDERER IN FLORENCE By E. V. LUCAS. Richly illustrated and written in the same happy vein as the companion volumes, Paris, London, Holland. $1.75 net. HOME IMPROVEMENT | INCREASING HOME EFFICIENCY | By MARTHA BENSLEY BRUERE and | ROBERT W. BRUERE. The management of the home from the practical standpoint. $1.50 net. SUCCESSFUL HOUSES AND HOW TO BUILD THEM By CHARLES E. WHITE, Jr. An authoritative work on house-building for the house-owner. Over 400 illustrations. $2.00 net. LABOR PROBLEMS THE BUSINESS OF BEING A WOMAN By IDA M. TARBELL. Author of “The Tariff in Our Times,” etc. A powerful analysis of the effects of business life on woman's character. $1.25 net. ORGANIZED LABOR: Its Problems and How to Meet Them By A. J. PORTENAR. e “An intelligent summary of the labor problems of the day.” $1.00 net. On Sale at All Bookstor.s
Page 5
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 19, 1912 The Week Events have swiftly belied the predic- tion made in these columns the other day that the Progressive party would be defined as a party with the Chicago habit. future The national headquarters of the new party to New York, hereafter in the text-books of the have now been removed and social justice can be promoted without excessive expendi- tures on railway fare. Chicago will re- all capital of the new movement, but the po- main, in probability, the religious litical seat will be located in immediate proximity to the Perkins war chest and State the Munsey Department, and at no great distance from the headquar- ters of the First Army Corps under Gen- All movements prefer to post themselves on eral Flinn at Pittsburgh. militant the frontiers of the enemy's country. The proud distinction which New York State held for so many years in respect to Mr. against Bryan it will now uphold as the Colonel. Armageddon is thus definitely localized. The forces of evil may do their worst in the Supreme but will be accomplished Courts of Idaho and points east; their overthrow when New York’s forty-five Presidential electors awaken to the light. It is noted that Congress is getting far fewer petitions and memorials than usual. This is said by Washington ex- perts to indicate that the people are “sick of politics.” It may, however, merely prove that they are sick of peti- tions. Yet the persistence of that way of endeavoring to express public opin- ion and to influence legislation has been remarkable. In only the rarest in- stances could it be shown to have any direct effect, but it has been persevered in surprisingly. The Congressional Rec- ord has often been lumbered up with the mere enumeration of the petitions The “right to petition” has thus been firmly presented in House or Senate. upheld, even if it is futile in 99 cases out of 100. Doubtless, the flow of peti- will soon be resum- tions to Congress ed. sively show But that again would not conclu- that the people are tre- The mendously interested in politics. Just at present, there is plainly a sort of lull or truce. One of party is passing out power and another is coming in. The country is waiting. Moreover, the gen- erally prosperous state of industry and effect of and of business has had the usual diminishing active discontent busying people more about their private affairs than about saving the country. But no one need fear that the sway of politics will not in good time reassert itself. Highly complicated issues were in- volved in the coal-road suits, decided by the Supreme Court on Monday, and it is stand the at- somewhat difficult to unde! titude of the judges towards all the mat- ters argued before them. It has been hastily said, for example, that the deci sion makes waste paper of the “com- modities clause” of the Hepburn law tne clause, that is, forbidding railways to transport coal from mines owned by themselves. But in reality the Court merely says that many of the acts cen- pilgined of in the Government suit were committed before the passage of the Hepburn act. Its applicability to other like acts was dismissed without preju- That ‘s left free to bring other suits directly dice. is to say, the Government under the Hepburn law. Similar is the disposition of the matter of control of one coal road by a competitor, through stockholding devices. This, too, is left for the Department of Justice to deal with in the future as it sees fit. The Court held that on the general charge of an unlawful combination among the rail- ways, the Government had not made out its case; but it had no hesitation in pro- reuncing illegal the contracts made by the roads with independent producers, and also found the defendant companics guilty of unlawfully combining, through the Temple Iron Company, to shut out competing lines and in other to We think that the ways restrain trade. the more is studied more satis- be in decision it the factory will found. Plainly, the judges sought this which was case, begun in the lower courts five years ago and which the Supreme Court has held under advisement for more than a year, to render a decision fully in line with that in the Standard Oil suit. They take Natron pains now as then to show that the law dces not strike at all trade agreements, however “normal,” but only at thos which are abnormal by being monop: listic and oppressive in their effect upon the public. If one wishes to be strengthened in his conviction that the sooner the indi rect election of United States Senators is done away with, the better, he has but to look at the faltimore papers nowa days The Governor has ide a it terim appointment for e Vacancy caus ed by the death of Senator Rayner, bu the Legislature of 19i4 ll ha filling of that vacan: to M } besides electing a S« tor for tl full term of six vears fre piratio Senat Smith's ter Marc! } ’ Consequently, the pot has been boiling with much fury, thirteen months prio to the assembling of the Legislatur There is, indeed, a system enatorial primaries in Maryland, but, quite apart from any criticism to which it may be open as a mode of determining a par ty’s choice, it is impossible for mer: primaries to attain the result which di rect election by the people would pro cure, Voters at the general election will be compelled either to sacrifice their preference as to legislative candidat or their preference upon the Senator shiy 8, whenever these two come into cor And it sional politicians in flict. is plain that the profes Maryland are ha\ ing just the kind of advantage in pls ing their trade that such:+a complica- tion between unrelated things is calcu lated to give The immigration figures given in Se« retary Nagel’s report are decidedly teresting. The impression is widely cur rent that the country receives, through immigration, an accession of about a million a year to its population. In point of fact, the net immigration into the United States—excess of aliens com ing into the country over aliens going out of it—in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1909, was 544,000; in the year 19109 it was 818,000; in 1911 it was 512,000; and in the fiscal year which ended June 30, 1912, it was only 402,000. These figures is often at have not the character that tributed to them. Of course, the im-
Page 6
migration of the ‘50's bore a vastly population; of the Northern higher ratio to the home but the net immigration the even "80's, when change from and Western to Southern and Eastern Kurope had already in a great measure effect, was probably much larger taken in proportion to the home population in that which we have been getting the past few years mendment of her Constitution start the The method At pri two-thirds of to ma he jurages Tennesse altering rs. chief stion is the ot instrument. sent, sary for both the Legislature to pass a pro d amendment at two successive ses submitted to the Tennessee Constitutional would enable 10 per to obtain by petition f any amendment. As of Unio, there vill probably for the purpose of new Constitution, but to f amendments which also It is shall be chos n the names of can d on ballots by peti rangements, of course, ndorsed b t successive Ten 0 best a new hardly in sight. s country are ngratulated the upon them by the to South Caro hn Brown's ll men take w he Ble nee ‘s pe r nd have made south speak out for or law The other hern Go rnor at Richmond were h very appearance to go with great be rd against lynching than ever doubts how is great contribution to law and ' let } ’ leading journals read the the Soutl particularly those They and rwn disgraced Stats make it plain that hereafter any one in the North South o1 who favors lyne hing, either directly or indirectly, degrades ong can truthfully assert hereafter that The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2477 ] Blease or his kind speaks for the sober | sentiment or the chivalry of the South. | article on “Rising | Public,” by Prof. John Bauer, in the Popular Science Monthly of the Readers the Prices and for December, will find several things that are well worth thinking about; all the more because they relate not to the causes, but to the effects, of the lowered purchasing power of the dollar. If your income, as measured in dollars, has ad- vanced along with prices to such an ex- tent that you can make the two ends meet just as you used to do, and also put by for a rainy day just as much as you used to put by, don’t flatter yourself that you are doing as well as of old. On the supposition, for example, that prices have risen 50 per cent. all round, and that in former times you regarded $1,000 a year as the amount to proper life requisite for the protection of your fam- be save, or $10,000 insurance as raised As different ily, these figures should now to $1,500 and $15,000, respectively. actual facts in the of the Bauer recites broadly what is generally for the classes population, Professor recognized; especially emphasizing the fact—forecast by economists @ priori, verified unpleasantly by thousands @ nosteriori—that, while wages have lag- ged somewhat behind prices, salaries have been vastly more inert than wages; Professor Bauer says they have “re- mained almost unchanged.” There is some comfort—which Professor Bauer cruelly abstains from giving—to the sal- aried man in the belief that, when sal- aries do get revised upward to conform to the high prices, they will stay up a long time after the prices go down, for their inertia works both ways; and a similar reflection should somewhat dull the edge of self-reproach on the subject of savings. But, as nobody knows when, if ever, prices will go down, it will not do, after all; to set too much store by these considerations. The American Academy of Arts and Letters may fairly be said to have weathered the storm of ridicule which faced it at the outset. The disclaimer of any intention to rob posterity of one of | its most precious privileges by arrogat- ing immortality to Academicians may be, accepted without any quibble. Nor does a challenge to some democratic spirits, signify anything more than the difficul- ty of hitting upon a suitable title. Nev- ertheless, if those belonging to the Acad- emy are content to leave the question of their own literary immortality to the future, they are bold in affirming their loyalty to the immortals of the pasi. In the present-day welter of vague Futur- ism and specific vulgarism, they dare to be orthodox. There must be many old-fashioned persons still who will wel- come the sounding of this note. To them it will require no argument to prove that “the and vitality in the ideals of arts and let- recognition of permanence ters’ is a highly proper aim; they will accept as axiomatic the statement that a body of persons interested in literature should stand for the discouraging of of language with the hoofs of buffaloes,” “the trampling our noble English of the confusing of advertisement with criticism, of the mistaking of hysteria for originality, of the admission that the only way to be American is to be provincial, and in general of the notion that taste is an outworn test of art. The architectural profession in this country and abroad will rejoice in the recognition which has come to William Rutherford Mead ia the bestowal upon him last Friday of the gold medal of the National Institute of Arts and Letters. Mr. Mead’s native modesty long kept him in the background, so far as the public well his McKim which knew brilliant Charles F. and Stanford White. It to some, that Mr. balance-wheel of the firm, who attended was concerned, partners, was known also, Mead was the to the business side and the practical details, and, remembering this, they overlooked too often the fact that in Mr. Mead there is a rare artist, a de- signer of first rank. The present award will help to let the public understand what the profession so well knows. Un- der Mr. Mead’s leadership the name of McKim, Mead & White is still one to conjure with. The the office are living up to the finest tra- ditions of the three founders, and are giving to the country many superb ar- chitectural monuments. new forces within “To tax and to please is as impossi- ble as to love and be wise.” The truth of this saying of Burke's is now being j | himself to the level of Cole Blease. Noj|the name “Academy,” which seems to be | brought home to the English protection-
Page 7
Dec. 19, 1912] The Na tio ists. The Conservatives hope to return | to power before long, and their pro- gramme calls for protective duties. These, to be consistent, must include duties on grain and meat, but on the question of such food-taxes the Con- servative doing a sad amount of wriggling. First, they said leaders are that they would never levy a tax in such a way as to increase the cost of liv- ing. Driven from this absurdity, they said that higher wages and increased prosperity would more than make up for a slight rise in the price of food. This not being meekly accepted, they said that, anyhow, they would not levy a food-tax until after taking a referendum on the question. But now they are try- ing to wriggle away from this promise. Mr. that any scheme of food-taxes would be Bonar Law explained on Monday arranged only as a part of an Imperial preference plan agreed upon with the Colonies. But with what face could the English negotiators say that they must submit the agreemert to the voters? Mr. Law’s ingenious plea is that for the Canservatives to adhere to their pledge ebout the referendum would hamper them in high and mighty Imperial nego- tiations: hence the pledge must be torn up. Yet they say that the English are a plain, blunt people, and do not like statesmen who indulge in subtle refine- ments of reasoning! M. Jaurés, leader of the Unified Social- ists in the French Chamber, has at last brought forward the scheme of army re- organization which he has been chal- lenged to produce whenever he has risen in Parliament to criticise the present army system. The Socialist leader does not share the anti-militarist views of M. Gustave Hervé. If anything, his propos- al is to bring the military ideal into closer touch with the life of the nation by establishing a sort of citizen army. Instead of calling recruits to the colors for a continuous period of two years, citizens between the all French male ages of twenty and twenty-five are to undergo a six months’ period of ser- vice supplemented by occasional periods of training. But the central point of the scheme is that which provides for a per- manent officers’ force of only one-third the the other two-thirds to be drawn, when That number required on a war basis, the need arises, from civil life. with the “aristocratic’ would do away Cr vas) spirit which at present animates the! not much more is to be expected, Prince commissionei ranks of the French army, in the opinion of the Socialists, whatever may be the opinion of foreign- ers regarding the extraordinarily demo- cratic relations that prevail between French officers and privates. Coming at the present time of crisis, the proposal certainly argues the courage of the So- cialist leader’s convictions. The death of the oldest living sove- reign the Regent Luitpold, removes one of the few re- maining figures historic in the found- ing of the German ‘Empire. in Europe, Prince It was he who, in the Palace at Versailles, hand- ed to King William of Prussia the letter inviting him to assume the Imperial This he did after duced his crazy nephew, King Ludwig II, to let Bavaria take the lead posal to which Ludwig was at first vio- crown. having in- a pro- lently opposed. But Luitpold’s great popularity throughout Germany was founded on other things than this. He was a man of the simplest tastes and devoted to his people. They always re- membered his kindly heart and many generous deeds. His love of hunting, which never forsook him—to it he yield- ed when in his ninetieth year—particu- larly appealed to the Bavarians. It was on these trips that he freely fraternized As- suming the regency at sixty-five, he was with his subjects of the mountains. then so fixed in his desire for a simple, unostentatious life, and so out of touch with things political, that it was not possible for him to become either a real statesman or a leader of the people. He was just a fine, rugged character, sym- bolic of the domestic virtues, and quite content to let the politicians and cleri- cals fight out the country’s future for themselves. This they have done with the result that the Catholic Church is more firmly intrenched than ever, and sees in the rising tide of Socialism the one force that menaces its domination. This cleri- cal control has not come about by any deliberate design of the Prince Regent. True, he looked on all Liberalism with suspicion, but even the Liberal newspa- pers, in reviewing his career at the cele- bration of his ninetieth birthday, admit- ted that his political shortcomings were due more to age and ignorance than to From his successor any other causes. Ludwig, whose extremely popular wife died but recently, is hardly the man to vigorously grapple with the problems confronting Bavaria. Grave issues there are which are not on the surface, But all the evils of a priest-ridden land He difficult, an amazingly the lack of un- derneath. Marriage is made with the result of high percentage of illegitimacy; education is equally startling, and con- ditions among teachers really deplora- ble. Not merely conservatism but re- action is in the saddle, and the curse of the heavy beer-drinking rests on the land. It is useless to turn from this pic- ture merely to say that Luitpold was a splendid patron of arts and sciences, that his charities were great, that un der him Munich grew to be the wonder- ful and beautiful city it is, and that the aged Prince was, as the Kaiser declar ed, “the of all the princely virtues.” incarnation and model Germany's war on tuberculosis is, in the opinion of our Department of Com- and Labor, entitled to the ad of the merce niiration entire civilized world as the first and most successful of its kind. of per 10,000 of population from this cause From an average 23 deaths in the quinguennium 1895 to 1899, the rate was reduced to 21 during the fol- lowing five-year period, and to 18.45 dur- The eX- ing the one ending with 1909. penditures on account of tuberculous wage-earners have gone up steadily. Commencing with an annual amount of $240,000 in 1897, the figure rose to $1,- 100,000 in 1902 and to nearly $4,000,000 in 1909. The economic results of insti tutional treatment are carefully follow ed by means of a special inquiry for a the period of five years subsequent to patient's discharge. By “economic rs sults” is meant restored wage-earning least Thess in the ¢ one capacity to the extent of at third of what it was originally. results are somewhat better ase of women than of men. The improve- ment in these results is measured by the advance from 68 per cent. of patient discharged with their earning capacity 1897, The (in its legal sense) restored in to 83 per cent. so discharged in 1909 whole story, in its general tenor and in its particulars, is a tale of the swift tri umph of applied science in a field that preceding generations had not thought of entering.
Page 8
DSO THE COSTS OF PROGRESS. emotionalism the Something more than enters into the profound effect of State Factory on public conscience the disclosures made before the Investi- gating Commission regarding the con- ditions that still obtain among women and children in industry. At least, it is a crude, blind emotionalism of the The heart will always respond of toiling bed- can- feel- to the story babes tenement of the child eir mothers in in the chill and dirt Symbols appeal to and the three-year-old nod ding in weary sleep over her work is such a symbol. But, after all, that child restricted to the three-year- sleeping is a symbol only. Our pity is not To-day we feel that it is not only old horrible thing that children of three hould be caught in the industrial ma- ne, but that it is wrong for children to work, or for chil- work rob them of their heritage childhood of four times three dren of any age to under condi- tions which of the happiness of and the up into healthy and effi- that it right to grow manhood. To-day we feel clent is wrong for women to be subjected to hours of labor which cripple them as in- dividuals and as mothers. Our feeling j not merely indignation against a ystem, but resentment against a em We do not say, “How s thing is,” but, “How criminal- foolish and wasteful this thing is.” ill emotionalism, but it is emo conditioned by knowledge provision becomes a law,” ar- ounsel for certain manufacturers, against a suggestion that all erlor stairways in factories should enclosed with non-combustible ma- most of the stairways in all have This years ago, feel the factories of Utica would rebuilt at great expense.” to be plea, famillar enough a few rings strange to-day Today we that the alternative to the expense of re- building staircases in factories is the possibility of another Triangle building will take catastrophe Presumably, it some time yet to impress on the selfish his legal representa of the manufacturer and the fact that the temper tives day will no longer tolerate the striking of a lives and balance between human The management here reinforces the ancient profits new doctrine of scientific doctrine of “Thou shalt not kill.” An The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 industry that can be carried on only by exposing its workers to the daily peril of injury and death is an economic as well as a moral monstrosity. The man- ufacturer who pleads expense against the safeguarding of life will soon be re- garded as a barbarous anachronism, It is not necessary to view this par- ticular factory owner as a Simon Legree wielding his lash over the backs of wo- men and children. He may not be alto- He may not be altogeth- er stupid. Consider him as being caught gether selfish. himself in the wheels of the industrial machine. Make for the helplessness of an individual in the face all allowance of a system. Yet our sympathy cannot go to the point of arguing that, because the duty which confronts the employer of labor is difficult, it is a duty which The pious wish that a better world may be brought about with- may be slighted. out causing anybody inconvenience leads us nowhere. The fact must simply be faced that if fire-trap factories are to be rendered safe for the workers, it will cost some one a good deal of money. If the exploitation of children is to cease, if humane Conditions of labor are to be made universal for women workers, it means a possible cutting down of prof- its for some time to come. Some one has to pay the costs of progress until such a time as the costs are redistribut- ed among the community at large. The factory-owner who protests that his in- | terests will suffer is entitled to no more consideration than the lawyer who will suffer when the enactment of a work- men's compensation law deprives him of the principal source of his income in form of accident and negligence The of declared for a workmen's insurance, and the Cases. judgment the day has the legal profession has to pay its part of the temporary costs of this forward step in social readjustment. It is this plea of unjust discrimina- tion that every sincere effort at reform, | outside of industry as well as within, | must encounter. Unjust discrimination cannot, of course, be defended as a sim-| ple matter of definition. But it cannot be admitted that discrimination in itself To admit that, The ad- have is by definition unjust. is to tle one’s hands forever. vocates of had to contend with a vicious circle of Thus one State would wel- childllabor regulation opposition. come restrictive laws were it not for the fact that it would be put at a disadvan- | tage with regard to another State, where such laws are not to be put into force. The advocates of tariff reform have met the same argument. This schedule can- not be touched because it will put a cer- tain interest at a disadvantage with re- gard to another protected interest. To judge from the constant plaint against inequity of treatment, one might imag- ine that we are living in a world of per- fectly adjusted privileges and rights, and that any attempt at change means the disturbance of a (perfect equili- brium. Whereas the truth is that the social order is constantly changing, that society is always growing, and that the growing-pains of society cannot be elim- inated. If child labor is to be done away with, if tariff oppression is to be reduced, a beginning must be made somewhere. The burden may fall a lit- tle more heavily on Smith than it does on Jones. Ultimately, the burden will | be readjusted in fairness both to Jones and Smith. The stirring of the social conscience with regard to the protection of the workers, and particularly of the woman and child workers, involves an indus- trial readjustment which calls up for comparison the industrial revolution of the nineteenth century from which the present movement is a reaction, The dislocations and rearrangements which followed tbe use of the factory system fell most heavily, for a time, on the workers. To those English anti-machin- ery rioters, the introduction of the ma- chine seemed virtually the confiscation of their chances of earning a livelihood. The same kind of error is committed by the factory-owner of to-day who cries out that the application of a higher stan- dard of conscience to industry means confiscation. It must be left to time to teach him that his best interests, like those of society, do not demand the waste of women’s and children’s lives. SAFETY IN RAILWAY TRAVEL. When Mr. J. O. Fagan writes on rail- way accidents as related to discipline and efficiency, what he says is pretty sure to make interesting reading. His letter to the New York Times in regard to the Westport wreck on the New Ha- ven Road, and to the Interstate Com- merce Commission's report upon it, is no exception to this rule. Taking up the Commission's statement that “the
Page 9
‘The N at Dec. 19, 1912] ion direct cause of this accident was a dis- regard by the engineman of the train, the Commission, says Mr. Fagan, inves- ‘Second No. 53,’ of signals and rules pro- | tigate the pressure on American rail- vided by the railroad company to pre- vent the occurrence of such accidents,” Mr. Fagan declares, in effect, that the di- way managements to keep the careless man in the service; and he declares that “it is absolutely useless to moralize rect cause was not this particular dis-| the situation at the top if we allow it to regard of rules, but the system under! be demoralized in this way at the bot- which such disregard is constantly tol-| tom.” erated and men habitually guilty of it, are retained in the service. In support of this, he cites, in particular, the bad | previous record of the engineman who was killed, along with many other vic- As we aave said, the point made by Mr. Fagan is both sound and important. with a dominant idea, or charged with a special mission, the point is overstat- ed. played by trade-union dictation in the it source of the evil, nor is it impossible tims of his carelessness, in the West- However serious may be the part port disaster; but, as he says, and as | every one who has read the Commis- sion’s report must now know if he did not know it before, the lack of real dis- | cipline exemplified in this particular | case is not exceptional, but general. The | matter, is by no means the only for the railway managers to procure great improvement in safety without waiting for the suppression of trade- peculiarity of Mr. Fagan’s remarks on/ union interference. The report of the this head is that he goes behind the! blame cast upon the railway managers Commission on the Westport disaster furnishes convincing evidence to this ef- for using pressure to procure speed! fect. It is not an undiscriminating in- while not using like pressure to in-| dictment of the management. In partic- sure safety. The Commission, he says,| ular, it gives the New Haven Company has investigated this matter, but it has failed to investigate the “far more im- portant” allegation “that for years pres- a clean bill of health on one matter which has been a conspicuous part of the newspaper arraignment. “The road- sure of the most palpable nature has| way and track conditions in the vicin- been brought to bear on managers to|ity of the accident are good,” says the compel them to retain in the service the! report, “and the construction of the careless and indifferent workmen.” cross-over was substantial. At We are not prepared to say that Mr.|the cross-over practically all the ties were new and screw spikes were used, and the track conditions at this point Fagan'’s views concerning this matter are in all respects sound. For instance, But its verdict in regard he asserts that, as a necessary corollary were good.” of the supervision exercised by the In-| to the larger questions relating to safety terstate Commerce Commission over! is very severe, and fixes upon the man- agement a kind of blame which cannot be shifted. The Bridgeport disaster of July 11, 1911, says the report, “was sim- freight rates, equipment, train stops, etc., the Commission “should now go to license work and both examine and those employees who are directly con-| ilar in all respects to the accident now cerned in the operating of the trains, in| under consideration’; yet the manage- the same way as those who operate ves-| ment of the road had ignored the rec- sels on the sea are licensed.” But there | ommendations of the Commission in re- gard to the increase of the length of the to the is no comparison between these two pro- blems, in point of complexity and diffi- Nevertheless, we are sure that cross-overs, installation—or at culty. least the serious investigation—of auto in again directing attention to the part played by trade-unions in obstructing wholesome discipline, Mr. Fagan is do-| The Interstate | matic devices for stopping trains, and to the introduction of a rule requiring fast trains to come to a full stop before taking the cross-over. And even in the enforcement of the existing rules, sure- might ing a public service. Commerce Commission will not have completed inquiry into the causes of|ly something more have been the lack of safety on American railways until this question has been cleared up. How the same thing operates in Eng- land is illustrated by the railway strike caused by the dismissal of an engine- | ways and the unions concerning this) done than has been done, without in- viting any serious clash with the powers of trade-unionism. As for the relation between the rail- | man for intoxication when off duty. Let! But, as is natural in a man possessed | O81 matter, we are inclined to think that much might be accomplished by a bold If the companies are submitting to injurious results their efforts to secure the lives of their policy of frankness and publicity. pressure, which in paralyzing passengers, we do not believe that they are helpless. The excuse for such sub- mission has some resemblance to the ex- that cuse so long was current among corporations generally for submitting to legislative blackmail. Bribery in our Legislatures could never have reached such dimensions, or been maintained through so many years, if corporations whose purposes were honest had refused to comply in secret with dishonest prac- tices in order to effect those purposes. A little heroic resistance, an open ap- peal to the public, might have involved some inconvenience and temporary loss, but it would have resulted in emancipa- for themselves and in immeasura- If the managements tion ble gain to the commonwealth. coercion of railway for the benefit of unfit employees is as bad do the railways are as Mr. Fagan represents it—and we not deny that it is not compelled to wait for an investiga tion by the Interstate Commerce Com- it. mission to disclose of A plain state- ment the case would quickly bring the influence of public sentiment to bear in faver of whatever disciplinary meas- ures are necessary to make life and limb safe for travellers. MR. REID AND JOURNALISM Despite the somewhat tragic circum stances of Whitelaw Reid's death, his iife was one rounded out with the hon ors which he sought and prized. The troops of friends which he won are has- tening to pay personal tributes to his memory. His public position as an Am- bacsador of long service has brought due acknowledgment of the loss caused by bis death. But there must be still many to whom the chief interest and eignificance of his career lie in his years of labor as a newspaper man. The he was one of great time during which a working was ournalist importance in the evolution of the American news- paper; and when its history comes to be written the part which Mr. Reid plaved in helping to change the tenden cles and the spirit of the daily press in this country will require special treat ment.
Page 10
in the newspaper world was the least factitious. It was the al result of hard work and broad- ability. He was not one of our terwday Improvised journalists, with great fortune enabling them to buy ud exploit newspapers to the top of bent. Mr. Reid came up from the ranks. | As country editor, as indefati > ible writer on public men and politics, war correspondent, as a Washing editorial writer, he displayed li as qualities which naturally brought him promotion. |And when, after Gree- ley’s death, he came to be in control of Tribune, his work in enlarging the news side of that paper, while retaining procuring able and even brilliant and men to collaborate in its special depart- ments, showed that he knew what was demanded in the conductor of “a jour- nal of civilization.” It is, however, the part played by the ne under Mr. Reid in the liberaliz- ng movement which so powerfully in- fluenced the American press in the years to 1877, or thereabouts, that per- haps stands out clearest in his journal- istic career. This was the period when politically independent newspaper first began to set up a new standard, and to show that it could not only live, hut flourish. \There had been, of course, ew instances of newspapers that re- fused to bow down in the house of Rim Republican, un- The Springfield r the elder Bowles, had made a repu- n for itself as a paper free to speak But ts mind about men and parties. was the Liberal Republican agitation years mentioned that brought in of previous our newspa of the the large breatl the new freedom. For a long time per had hidebound politically be a rule, grievously had to been, as a Each one party organ, and politicians, no matter what they did, could count upon the support of the papers on their own as regularly as upon the coming in gids of But there was a great tide break-up in 1872, and later. the Party lead ers were aghast at the spectacle of in- fluential newspapers shaking off party etters and boldly saying the thing they honestly believed. The Chicago Tribune ook ude along with the Springfleld Repub- this independent and defiant atti ican. and they were joined by the Cin- ial and the Louisville The editor of the last- cinnat!l Commer Courter Journal named, Col. Watterson, has lately written [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 The Nation —S——— ‘for the ntury, in his characteristic | the drawbacks of the other plan were so way, half-cynical and slap-dash, of the clearly illustrated in Mr. Reid’s experi- meetings and doings of the independent cnce, even with the great rewards and editors at™the Convention of the Anti-\ distinguished honors which he attained, in 1872. Mr. Reid| that we may be pretty confident that of course, in| such cases as his will hereafter be high- Grant Republicans was there; primarily, Greeley’s interest, but the Tribune was found kicking over the party = - - == traces with the rest of them. After the unhappy campaign was over, the Tri- bune maintained for a time its detached and critical attitude, and did excellent the recent meeting of the Academic work in exposing the low moral tone| Committee of the Royal Society of Lit- ly exceptional. soon “RATHER HARD ON TOM.” Mr. J. M. Barrie was in the chair at which marked the second term of Grant.| erature. It was a gathering partly in Later, as everybody knows, it went back | commemoration of authors deceased and became a thick-and-thin party organ | within the year, partly to hail a rising once more. But it had aided in show- star. The Polignac prize for the best ing the way to a new liberty;\and the work of imaginative literature during American press never forgot the taste | the previous twelvemonth was conferred of freedom which it had in those years. | upon Mr. John Masefield, for his poem, Since that period the growth of indepen- | «The Everlasting Mercy.” Mr. Barrie dent journalism has been marked. All| had a few remarks to make upon the can grow the flowers now, for all have | standards of style, which it was the got the seed; but the seed was largely | quty of the Committee to attend to as supplied in that time of ferment when | far as possible. For it was style that Mr. Reid became editor of the Tribune. | mainly made the difference between one Since that day, American journalism | writer and another. It was not the sub- has become much more impersonal than | ject of the picture, but the way it was it then was. It is the newspaper, not| painted. Except for this, there would the personality of the man who happens; be no difference between a Venus by at the moment to be editor, that peo-| Titian and a Venus by Tom Smith. To ple speak of. .The reasons for this are say this, Mr. Barrie admitted, was plain, apart from the lack of command-| “rather hard on Tom.” ing figures, if one chooses to insist upon It is, indeed, hard every way on the The larger organization requisite| Toms who have no style. newspaper inevitably | they are conscious of this, and wish to that. Even when in the modern causes any individual connected with it/ find out how to acquire one, they are to wither, in comparison, while the in-| left very much in the dark. They can stitution as such becomes more and/ discover teachers to give them direc- more. In this, we suppose, lies the ex-| tions, but not to set them examples. planation of the fact often verified that | Professors of rhetoric are not often suc- the mixing of an editor in politics, with| cessful practitioners. And the great the inevitable result that he appears, at| practitioners either do not know how least, to conduct his paper as an annex ‘they got their style or will not tell. Mr. to his personal fortunes in public life, Barrie referred to a mysterious thing is a bad thing for the paper. That the in connection with all this. He had been Tribune suffered in this way when Mr. | lately in the company of a distinguished Reid began to turn his thoughts to po-| writer at a club where they were always litical advancement, is not denied. We/|talking about style. Here was a con- seem, in truth, to be setting up a jour-| fessed master of it, yet when he was nalistic tradition in this country against | pressed for information, could give them editorial office-holding. Abandon hope none at all. The only man in the room f political preferment, ye who enter | who had a style hadn’t the faintest no- here, is the new motto written over the| tion what it was or how he had come coor of the editor’s room. This was not) by it. This, too, it must be confessed, is the old American practice; it is not so| rather hard on Tom. strictly the rule in England to-day; in The fact seems to be that good writ- France the custom is quite the other ing is as incommunicable as any other way. But its advantages are obvious. It fine art. You can be taught what to is a part of the price that has to be|avoid. Your blunders can be pointed paid for editorial independence. Andj| out with a sure finger. On the other
Page 11
Dec. 19, 1912] hand, the best models can be set before you. The great writers with whom you are to spend your days and nights may And in- the be put on a vest-pocket list. cessant practice, self-criticism, se- verest discipline at the desk, can be urged. But when all is done, the ulti- mate secret of style is not and, appar- ently, cannot be imparted. This is the reason why the efforts of literary art- ists to explain their art—most of all, to explain their rise—are usually so futile. Stevenson tells us how he played “the sedulous ape” to this and the other mas- ter, but it is all little but words to the uninitiate. Teachers and writers of lit- erary confessions pluck off the petals of style, one by one, in their careful analy- yet ordinarily leave the bewildered “But sis, learner crying out at the end: where is the flower?” Literary advice to Tom is something well-advised would which the Yet an old English journalist from shrink. recently gave a piece of it which is per- haps worth noting for its novelty alone. He writers, addressing chiefly newspaper to keep was and those who have steadily at writing tasks, year in and year out. Their frequent sense is one of weariness and of being in danger of going stale. In such a mood, the ad- vice of this veteran editor was to read over some of their own writings of two or five years before. His point was this: in their blackest discouragement they could find an occasional gleam of hope from what they had done in the past. Either they would find something very bad in what they had written previous- ly worst at present that they could at least thank their stars that they were no long- er capable of that—or else some bit of good work which would cheer them with the belief that they had not always been idiotic and with the hope that they might again write in a way not to make something so much worse than their them ashamed. Such an experiment has its obvious perils. As a rule, a man should preserve his old writings as he love-letters—something There is, would his old to keep but not to read over. to be sure, the example of Swift with his “My God, what a genius I had when I wrote that!” but we believe that this dates from the time when Swift’s mind had begun to fail. Whether taught, the important thing for Tom and all the rest of us to fix in our minds style can or cannot be The Nation is that it exists. Help may be given in have to seek- ing it, but either way it is the pearl of It essary to waste words, or to endeavor to attaining it, or writers may work out their own salvation in great price in literature. is not nec invent new phrases, about this, for we all know that style is the distinctive thing in authorship—the thing that it Mr. | Barrie made a brief but feeling refer- the Andrew is known by and remembered for. ence to his friend, late Lang; and he said of him in all serious- had left behind from the literary point of view was his ness that all that he style. Truly, it is “of the man himself”; and if Tom has got it in him, he may comfort himself with the thought that he may yet bring it out. THE EYE AND EAR. tickled HUMOR OF Is the eye more easily than the ear? Do funny pictures have an ad- vantage over jokes conveyed by the printed word? In a sense it is the mind to which the appeal is made in both cases, and the eye, too, which first ap- prehends it. But as graphic humor must be looked at individually by every one who would appreciate it, whereas fun in be heard read aloud, the distinction is suf valid. once that pictures have a fundamental print can relished equally if it is ficiently It may be admitted at advantage in the case of certain sorts of The seeing a person in the act of losing his happenings. mirth occasioned by coat-tails flying and hat fully merely faithful picture of the thing. But balance, with askew, can be reproduced by a narrate the incident to one who has not it, his first concern is to know witnessed and you are apt to find that whe- ther any injury resulted. Grotesque de- tails put in narrative form are present- ed too slowly. Here a very elementary kind of humor is involved, the success of which depends upon the suddenness of its attack. In a picture the eye gath- ers up the details almost as rapidly as in actual life. And having given way to the crude fun of the thing, one lin- gers over the artist’s peculiar touches. This in its lowest form is the humor of the comic supplement. Starting with the small boy’s instinct to upset the next fellow’s equilibrium, it seldom gets beyond such superficial embarrassments as grandpa wakened by a firecracker or grandma in search of her teeth. Its D383 special fleld is “practical” jokes. In lit erature exact equivalents of the comk supplement are not numerou Po. Sawyer” and Huckleberry Finn na deeper—-yet they do exist, and it sig nificant that several such books hav: come out within the past few months The resemblance is so striking that on: is tempted to believe that writers, awar: of the success of “novelized” plays, hav: determined to make the comic liere ple. A man at a house party looking for suppl ment do similar duty. is a sam- his morning bath opens by mistake the door of a room occupied by an old maid She, in the act of putting on her toupée, is startled, knocks down the curtain pole, which upsets a Louis Seize clock, which falls upon her poodle, who jumps through a handsome Chinese screen The toupée drops out of the window, through an opening in the conserva tory, upon the head of the gardener. He brushes it off, and the next seen of it is months later when it is found entangled in the roots of a fancy tulip. Mistaken for a squirrel’s nest, it is lodged as a great curiosity in a museum Signifi- cantly enough, the one thing that saves this story from utter flatness is a pic- tured illustration of the toupée on the gardener’s head. It is bound to provoke at least a smile, but it does at the same time drive home the lesson that certain things which the artist may us ith some success, the writer would be wise tc leave alone. In the lower ranges of humor draw- ings can produce their effect quite cheap block- were enough ly. Many will recall how “Chip's headed little dogs in Punch in themselves to give him a vogue. 1ue artist’s individual style applied to an obvious situation—the special flirt he gives to a coat-tail or his particular way of perking a nose—enjoys a facti- It the artist can be tious value. is possible, however, more poignant as his These qualities are got that well as more sweeping in humor than the writer. by creating a suggestion of what cannot be indicated explicitly. Words become too precise for the occasion, while an indefinite tilt of the head may some- times speak volumes. Every one knows how in a great political campaign it is usually the cartoonist who can best fasten attention upon the big issues. For the “Biglow Papers” and the best of Mr. Dooley’s political satire there have been dozens of notable cartoons. Yet
Page 12
HS between high and low humor, in what may be called respectable every-day hu- mor, graphic form is greatly limited Besides sharing with painting the pow- r of dealing specially with only a par- ticular moment of life, or, if symbolic. with only one or two broad reaches of thought, it has usually to confine itself to the fun of situation; in short, to the The medium tends to of ical all The play on words which when express- ed pietured fare very turn humor into one situation. language is not visualized, when definite “programme drawing,” as it were. in becomes a spectacle, for the lacks the What may drawing, except of style, undoubtedly Humorous matter variety of verbal humor. done in literature with one branch c* humor is shown just now by the Lon- don set. Shaw, Chesterton, Belloc, Max Beerbohm, to go no farther, get their fun very largely out of what is techni- cally known as “wit,” or intellectual sharp practice. It is mainly formal log- ic applied to life. Touchstone knew the to Corin: “Why, if method Says he court, thou never if sawest good manners, then thy manners thou never wast at awest good manners; thou fever must be wicked; and wickedness is ain, Thou art in a And the the and sin is damnation. parlous state, good shepherd.” logic by which sheer All's scandal of clown in Well” essays to comfort has virtually elab- With of hu- the Countess, Shaw Man and Superman.” orated into Shaw, situation grows, not out man but out of the dictates of nature, logic worked with all its of logic, though hidden tricks ignoring the middle Chesterton's essays have the Belloc term inspiration, and and Beer- same bohm are different only in giving freer rollicking farce Here the rein to the incidental which their logic precipitates ariety among the four men is not 60 much a question of individual style the point which so often distinguishes humorous drawings—as it is a matter of emphasis placed on this or that ele- ment among the several of which wit is composed This back whether the humor of the word, with Its leads us to the question more varied possibilities, can ever de- generate to the level of the comic sup- plement and gain a large following. Yet until books of that kind are advertised as being among the best sellers, we with- hold our protest, hoping in the mean- The Natio Th [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 time that they will receive from the public every bit of what they deserve. THE JOINING HABIT. The S. P. U. O. is, needless to say, the Society for the Prevention of Useless Organizations. It has been founded by a handful of desperate citizens as a means of combating the ravages wrought by the fatty degeneration of the social ” instincts. Its motto is “Disorganize! Its emblem is a miniature portrait of John Hampden, the famous Englishman who first refused to pay dues. The char- ter members of the S. P. U. O. recognize the tremendous nature of the task that confronts them. It amounts to nothing | less than waging war against a nation-| al habit which is older than the Consti- tution and will endure long after the has been recalled. Hence O. entertains no illusions | Uproot- referendum S. P. U. as to the results it may obtain. ing the joining habit is a hopeless en- the terprise. The Society simply wishes to! save such individual feeling and thinking | as still hold out above the rising tide of In order to give vigor-| ous expression to its ideals and its pro-| the adopted a organization. gramme, Society has in fifty-three articles and The stitution provides for the usual officers Constitution a complete set of by-laws. Con- and standing committees, and, in addi- tion, a Committee on Press and Periodi- cals, a Committee on Pulpit and Peace Conferences, a Committee on Recent Tendencies Towards Decentralization, a Committee on Coéperative Efforts in Re- lation to the Cost of Living, and several others. The proceedings of the Society are to be conducted in accordance with Cushing's Manual. P. U. already intimated, eschews all In its prospectus the S. O., as we have the principle of organiza- “We could if we this would not if we could, hostility to tion in itself. not would,” says interesting docu- ment, “and we do away with the valuable psychological trait which impels half a dozen Ameri- form an association, adopt an emblem and elect officers, and proceed to carry | for ized. vast amount of good is done every day in the year in the way of encouraging progress and alleviating human suf- fering by bringing the disjointed efforts of thousands of individuals into har- monious coéperation. But a distinction must be drawn between coéperation for the purpose of doing things, and co- operation for the purpose of seeing, en- joying, and believing things. A society the suppression of tuberculosis needs no defence. But what shall be said of the mistaken social tendency which, revealing itself at first in com- paratively harmless form in the organi- _zation of Browning Clubs, ultimately leads to the formation of a Society for the Appreciation of Late Autumn Sun- sets, a League for Spiritual Relaxation, and an International Fraternity for the Development of the Individual? The S. P. U. O. is encouraged to be lieve that it is not engaged in an alto- gether hopeless fight, when it considers that at present there is a distinct reac- tion in public opinion against the fetich of organization. It was seemingly only a day or two ago that all of us wor- shipped bigness and complexity. To- |day we are wondering whether some of these elaborate machines of ours might not have a few thousand less wheels, belts, springs, and but- tons, and do just as much good. There gears, valves, are heretics now who question the ef- ficacy of organization as embodied in the Trusts. There are complaints heard to-day that the Church is over-organ- There are complaints that the schools and colleges are over-organized. There are complaints that our sports and vacations and holidays are over-or- ganized. This does not mean that the tendency is all one way. The standard- izing, organizing spirit is fighting back strenuously. There are still any num- ber of people who want to organize the Home, who want to organize Child Life, Motherhood, Sleeping in the Open Air, Poetry, and the utilization of the ten minutes that are usually lost between cans, whenever they come together, to | going to bed and falling asleep. The organizing habit is still very strong in the land, but it is an enormous gain that through their meetings with efficiency | it should be no longer accepted without and dispatch by a firm suppression of the minority party.” goes on to say that, for the purpose of giving effect to a policy, a reform, or| a revolution, organization is indispen- | question. To-day it is no longer held as The prospectus | self-evident that it is better to do a thing in two hours with the aid of a card catalogue than to do it in an hour and a half without one. sable. It would be idle to deny that a| The S. P. U. O., at bottom, is anxious
Page 13
Dec. 19, 1912] to prove that there is something very | desirable lost out of an emotion when it must be experienced in a quorum, and out of an idea when it must be approv- ed by a majority vote. It fears the loss of the principle of individual salvation which it believes has been productive of a great deal of good. It fears the loss of the faculty and the desire to think for one’s self, and with it the capacity and the desire to look into one’s self for those spiritual resources which surely cannot be quite exhausted. To read quietly in one’s corner and not as the member of a George Meredith Club, to walk at random across country on Sun- day and not as the member of a walk- ing club, to dream individually and not in conjunction with all the other mem- bers of the Karma Self-Absorption So- ciety—such old-fashioned habits the S. | P. U. O. thinks are well worth preserv- ing. All persons in sympathy with this view should lose no time in communi- cating with the Society’s Committee on | Restoration of Individual Initiative. THE WESTERN ECONOMIC SOCIETY. Cuicaco, Decémber 11. The Society chose Commercial and Industrial Education as the general top- ic for its fourth conference, held at Chicago on December 6 and 7. The two sections of the conference devoted their more special attention respectively to commercial instruction of collegiate or university grade, and to the problem of industrial training in public schools. One group of speakers on the side of the public schools came to report the results of their actual experience. Among these may be mentioned James J. Sheppard, principal of the New York High School of Commerce; James E. Downey, head master of the Boston High School of Commerce; William J. Bogan, principal of the Lane Technical High School, Chicago, and Lorenzo D. Harvey, who spoke of the system of in- dustrial education in Wisconsin. Miss H. Winifred Jevons brought word of the work of the Apprenticeship and Skilled Employment Association of London. But the interest of the audience centred par-| ticularly upon the prospect of widened opportunities of industrial training in the immediate future, and upon the question whether this training should | be separately organized and adminis- tered or developed in the existing pub- lic schools under the direction of the present school boards. The most con- spicuous advocate of separation was E. G. Cooley, who, under the auspices of the Commercial Club of Chicago, has embodied a proposal for separate in-| dustrial schools in a bill to be submit-| ‘The Nation ted to the Illinois Legislature. The op- ponents of such separation were repre- sented by Prof. Ernest R. Dewsnup, of the University of Illinois; Prof. F. M. Leavitt, of the University of Chicago, and various spokesmen from the pub- lic schools; and by Frank Duffy, sec- retary-treasurer of the United Brother- hood of Carpenters and Joiners of Amer- ica, in behalf of organized labor. The after-dinner speaking at the ban- quet of the Society bore mostly upon the industrial education of persons of common-school age. Miss Jane Addams emphasized the social need of training and guidance for the boys and girls who now seem to be sustained only by the saving spirit of their youth in feeling their way from the surroundings of school children to the life of men and women in the working world. Prof. Charles Hubbard Judd, of the Univer- sity of Chicago, in one of the most im- pressive addresses of the meeting, urg- ed the importance and appropriateness of contacts with vocational life even in the primary schools. The German Am- bassador, Count von Bernstorff, who was prevented by illness from being present, was to have spoken on the Ger- man system of commercial and indus- trial education. On the topic of collegiate instruction in economic and commercial subjects Prof. L. C. Marshall, of the University of Chicago, provoked active discussion by his plan for the sequential arrange- ment and standardization of elementary and intermediate college courses. But perhaps the most fruitful feature of the whole conference was the bringing to- gether of the deans of various univer- sity schools of commerce to compare their problems, their achievements, and their purposes. In this discussion the long-established undergraduate Wharton School of Finance and Commerce of the University of Pennsylvania was repre- sented by Prof. Roswell C. McCrea; the new Graduate School of Business Ad- ministration of Harvard University, by Prof. Edwin F. Gay; -the Tuck School of Administration and Finance of Dart- mouth College, by Prof. H. S. Person; the Schools of Commerce in Northwest- ern University, the University of Wis- consin, and the University of Illinois, by Profs. W. E. Hotchkiss, W. A. Scott, and David Kinley, respectively. Prof. L. C. Marshall spoke for the College of Commerce and Administration of the University of Chicago; Prof. E. D. Jones, for the commerce courses in the University of Michigan; Prof. H. R. Hatfield, for the College of Commerce of the University of California. Whatever the other results of this interchange of experience may have been, it is certain that the auditors were impressed by what has already been accomplished in working out a scientific view of busi- ness, in winning the adherence of busi- ness men, and in progressing thus to- 585 wards a freshened and vitalized inter- pretation of even the more academic phases of economics. James A. FIe.p. NEWS FCR BIBLIOPHILES. The new issue in the Connoisseur’s Li- brary (Putnam) is Alfred W. Pollard’s long looked-for volume, which is now pub- lished with the title “Fine Books,” and which the author says “should have had the explanatory sub-title: ‘A record of books valued for their printing, decoration, or illustration.’ If the book has, as Mr. Pollard states in his preface, been ten years “on the we may be sur» that the reason of the long delay is because he has spent so much of his time in giving infor- nation and assistance to other people who bringing out of their own. Those who have received assistance from hini at the British Museum know that, like stocks,” were books our own Wilberforce Eames, when he can help another his own individual work can wait. The history of printing and book illustra- tion and their development is a large fleld to be covered in a single volume. To give the necessary facts and leave out the un- necessary ones, and still make the book readable, was no easy task, but Mr. Pol- lard has achieved even more: he has given us the facts, which perhaps might have been found elsewhere, but he has put life into them by his own explanations and re- marks, and made the book one to be read with pleasure as well as for instruction. His chapters on block books and on the invention of printing contain the re- sult of the latest investigations of the Ger- man specialists, but the ordinary book-lover will read Mr. Pollard’s volume in prefer- ence to the publications of the Gutenberg Gesellschaft. The interest in the block books (books in which the entire printed matter, texts, and iliustrations, were en- graved upon wood blocks), he says, “sprang from an entirely reasonable, but probably incorrect, view of the part which they had played in the development of printing with movable types.” They are not as old as they were formerly declared to be, and there is no evidence to suppose that the earliest extant examples were issued be- fore 1450. Block books were volumes for which there was a large demand Edition after edition could be printed from the same blocks, whereas in the early days types were never kept standing, but were reset for each new edition. So that block books may be said to have been the fore- runners of stereotype plates. The few fragments of early and unidentified Hol- land printing, with a statement about Laurence Coster, told by one Cornelis, a bookbinder, “of great age but clear me- mory,” are the basis of the view that print- ing from movabletypes was actually invented in Holland; but they are not of much value when opposed to the long statement in the Cologne “Chronicle” of 1499, and shorter statements in books of earlier date, that Mainz, on the Rhine, was the birthplace of printing. In the account of the Donatus fragments of which the Costeriana is mainly com- posed, we find a word descriptive of some of them, “anopisthograpic,” meaning “not printed on the back.” Notwithstanding Mr.
Page 14
OHSR6 calls this a “barbarous term,” the word away and use it next edi- Pollard, who hall put are des Dye broadside ribing a single-sheet larat of Inde pe ndence, nm } ante! on DOOKS be ountries of Europe printed various that the tl lang word in in the purely arbitrary inabula from the all fit mystic Whether de youth waddllr lothes,’ raat used lmpressions to invest with a eading nuisances.” il okmaking or a l by the j words Any bh infant in the isty radle place as by the 0k relations of the early the difficulties which r work, and the ex they were surmounted, * its date or present price, a real incunabula.” books, ect of il- chap Pollard with woodcut bi ubj three Mr woodcuts pages old chapters of the England, and the work At the Pollard favors us with a new first book Mansion at en generally supposed that Mansion long and we after two on foreign sixteenth century, books Printing in n successors very eginning, Mr is to Caxton’'s and his with Colard Bruges though not Caxton joined him, in French were printed first, English translation of the Histories of Troye.” In to this book, Caxton says that for his friends: “My penne stedfaat id a going business there hed at two when th before C Recuyell of his books ixton the prologus ying it myn hand wery and not yen dimmed whit lokyne “Therefore I haue with ouermoche and at paper,” grete charge and book in ed & ler my this ned to ordeyne saide that this that the and Pleye two thinks was the first also of the books at Bruges second rhe it, after Game these 1 new type was cutand with it nted “Les Quatre thinks in French Then, he England (ax carrying with him the old fount for with it two more the first books Recueil des his ‘ais et prouesses had express of hi ! leaving ited koned it Caxton the oples plausibly suppose with engra a short fr n follow Collec the first The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 more of Mr. Pollard and less of his biblio- graphical authorities. On that account our fellow-bibliophiles who collect books not merely to read them, as well as others who collect old or beautiful china or silver not to be used for eating or drinking from,” will find it the the book most enjoyable chapter of Correspondence THE LOEB CLASSICS " SIR rut NATION: I should like to EDITOR OF THE If it is not too late the protest of Elizabeth Knight had been looking forward with great hope to the forthcoming editions, expecting them the same sort of service that Professor Norton’s translations for me in Italian. I Bradford, that the books useful to those of us who had read our Greek years ago and partly forgotten it, or whose knowledge of Greek was too scanty to enable us to read with- out assistance, but who with the assist- ance of a literal translation would be able to understand and enjoy the original. That the kind of service that Nor- translation does for the reader of That service can never be done by rendering of A&schylus or B. RUSSELL. join in Tompkins. I to do me of Dante have done supposed, with Mr were to be is precisely tons Dante a versified Sophocles. Halifax, N. S., December 7. To THE Ep!tToR OF THE NATION: Srr: If you can still find space for dis- cussion of the Classics, it may be worth while to say something about one of the latest translations and its use of verse. The offence against Euripides is repeated in the case of Sophocles. Most college grad- Loeb vuates who, like myself, follow the study of} literature. must take up Mr. F. Storr’s vol- ume with a sinking heart. If Dr. Way’s old Euripides was a disagreeable surprise, and the new Sophocles is something of a shock, what will happen when A®schylus is led to the slaughter? Mr. Storr “has sought to be faithful,” he tells us, it is a first principle with him that “a translation must be English; that is to say, it must be in- telligible and enjoyable without a .know- ledge of the original.” Mr. Loeb, too, aimed make the translations real pleces of literature, a thing to be read the Mr virtue sO and to “in themselves am unable to see one of Note two specimens for pure joy of it.” I that Storr’s book attains to any s claimed or desired for it pure joy” of one or hast come to a steed-famed land for rest, strange W with toll, land of im” glistening soll mn all lands the goodilest horror renders Again al and sibilant the Colonus ode! in fight, all yleld at a of glance "Epes imeter the \l- has Even little be work dvixare pdya often fare tter every page of Mr that fall to be faithful or to be Eng- and contrive to be a pure pain to the Read his rendering of hundred “(Edipus Colo- of the between Storr's lines lish example, lines ar for in famoug dialogue ‘ or the King and the herdsman in “(C£dipus Tyrannus” (lines 1119-1185)—I have chosen passages nearly at random. The translation, throughout, has little for “the college grad- uates who wish to renew and enlarge their knowledge,” it has nothing of the “pure joy” of form, and I fear it will not entice the Greekless reader “to gather an elementary knowledge” of the tongue. Now, every one will agree with Mr. Storr that verse translations are difficult. He fails in good company. Further, every one would wish, with Professor Wade of Tufts Col- lege (Nation, December 5), to have transla- tions possessing the quality of “plastic form.” But no one will find this virtue in Mr. Storr’s product. Where, indeed, can it be found in versions that are suitable for purposes of the Loeb Library? Mrs. Brown- ing’s “Prometheus” and Pollard’s “Greek Odes,” fine as they are, willobviously not do. Even Gilbert Murray’s superb Euripides is free. In fact, the value of the poetic form in such work is, as a rule, inversely proportional to its literal faithfulness. The problem of combining form anéd faithfulness in a translation is, of course, insoluble, as every one with a sense for language must feel. But, so far as it has been solved, the medium of transference has been prose not verse. For prose, too, has “plastic form,” if that expression means anything. Witness the Homer of Butcher, Lang, Leaf, and Myers, in spite of Professor Wade’s vain regrets; witness, too, the “Greek An- thology” of J. W. Mackail. And it is strange that Mr. Storr, Cambridge man as he is, finds no imspiration in the classic example of Jebb. Finally, an American scholar with a longing for “plastic form” should not have forgotten the charming rhythmical prose of Professor Palmer’s “Odyssey” and “Anti- gone.” G. G. SEDGEWICK. Mass., December 14. too Cambridge, [We print this letter without endors- ing the specific criticism of Mr. Storr’s work or in any way prejudging a book upon which our reviewer must pro- nounce. But we do agree with the gen- eral protest against the use of verse translations in this edition. The num- ber of letters we have received on this and kindred questions shows a gratify- ing interest in Mr. Loeb’s magnanimous project.—Eb, NaTIion.] FANCY AND IMAGINATION. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: As a complement to Mr. Edward Fulton's letter in the Nation of November 28, it is perhaps worth while to point out that, long before James Beattie’s “Disser- tations Moral and Critical,” at one distinguished English critic did not always the terms imagination and fancy as synonyms. This was Glorious John. In the “Epistle Dedicatory of the Rival Ladies” (1664) Dryden wrote That benefit which I [rhyme], is, that it bounds and circum- scribes the fancy. For imagination in a poet is a faculty so wild and lawless, that like an high-ranging spaniel, it must have clogs tied to it, lest it outrun the judgment. least use consider most in it The distinction between the words is made clearer by the following passage from the preface to “Annus Mirabilis” (1666): The first happiness of the poet's imagina-
Page 15
Dec. 19, 1912]
The Nation
| tion is properly invention, or finding of the | ferent courses in Greek Epigraphy (1 in- thought; the second is fancy, or the varia- tion, driving [v. 1., deriving], or moulding of that thought, as the judgment represents it proper to the subject; the third is elocu- tion, or the art of clothing and adorning | that thought, so found and varied, in apt, significant, and sounding words; the quick- ness of the imagination is seen in the inven- tion, the fertility in the fancy, and the ac-
curacy in the expression. B. S. M. Ithaca, N. Y. THE HISTORY OF ART IN OUR COL- LEGES. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In the Nation for November 21 there was a very favorable notice of a monograph on “The Study of the History of Art in the Colleges and Universities of the United States,” E. Baldwin Smith. It is said that this is a of all academic courses in the of art offered in America, that it is a brief history of the subject, that only Harvard and Princeton offer reasonably full university facilities Since the prefatory note Marquand grateful information the pamphlet purports “choose the place they can carry on their advanced study,” it is only fair to state that the information in the pamphlet by register history for research, etc. by Professor Smith will if the states be set straight, defective, and since help students be to is to where is so extremely defective as to render it useless, and that the study of art in our colleges is far more extensive than this pamphlet shows. It would be idle to tabu- late all the omissions and errors, but, lest my criticism seem unfounded, I call atten- tion to a few omissions for classical ar- chology alone, which I recall from mem- ory or experience. The list could easily be greatly extended. No mention at all is made of the archzo- logical seminaries, which are the most im- portant organ of training in graduate and research work. Seminaries on Cretan An- tiquities, Numismatics, Vases, Sculpture, Roman Topography, etc., are held at Bryn Mawr. Every year at the Johns Hopkins University there seminary in Greek Archeology and another in Roman Arche- ology (the subject varying from year). Also at Brown, Chicago, California, and elsewhere there are archeological semi- naries. For Bryn Mawr no mention is made of the European fellowships or of courses is a year to on Greek and Roman Life, on Pompeian Life and Art, or of the Journal Club, which in some years we have also at Johns Hop- kins. For Columbia none of the many arch@wological courses given by Professors Egbert, Wheeler, Perry, Young, and others is noted. The same is true for Cornell and Pennsylvania, where the arch@ologists An- drews and Bates and their courses in an- cient art are not even tabulated As for Johns Hopkins, there is a professor of Greek Archwology and Epigraphy and a professor of Roman Archwology and Epi- graphy, whereas at most universities there (or assistant profes- called a professor of Classical is only one professor sor) for both, Archmology—so at California, Chicago, Yale, and Harvard. has professor of Greek Archwology Art. At Hopkins, in addition to the six courses men- Columbia a and Johns tioned in this pamphlet, there are courses on the Mycenman Age, Greek Sculpture Greek and Roman Architecture, three dif- clude these because, in the case of Dart- mouth, Pennsylvania, and Syracuse, they are included), Greek Private Life, Topography of Athens, Topography of Greek Sites, Stra- bo, and three courses in Roman Topography, three Roman Epigraphy, Greek and Painting, Private Life. Sem have been given on Problems in Greek Vase-Painting, on Greek Pausanias, Coins Gems in Roman Roman naries Problems in Pausanias Inscriptions, on Roman Inscriptions, and Numismatics; and other subjects will be taken up in future years. For the Uni versity of Chicago the courses in Fourth Century Greek Sculpture, an introductory course in Classical Archwology, courses on Greek Topography, and on Olympia, D. Iphi, and Athens, on Greek Vases, on Red-Figured Ware, Greek Life il- lustrated by the monuments, on Greek Epi- graphy, Roman Private Life, Roman raphy, omitted No on Gems, on as Topog- etc., are mention is ;made of the fellowships and scholarships in that Mr. |
Classical Archwology at Chicago, Johns Hop- kins, and elsewhere, although this pamphlet states that Princeton offers two fellowships in Art and Archwology. Many omissions occur in the courses tabulated for Brown, California, Cornell, Columbia, Harvard, Iowa, Pennsylvania, Yale, and others, and many mistakes occur even in the courses listed. A circular was sent to some four hundred institutions, many of which failed to answer But the circular calJed for information for the year 1912-13 only, and it was not stated that the information would bs in a pamphlet for those further study, which would naturally mean graduate students, and which certainly must mean those who contemplate study after 1912-13. It is clear, then, that the pam- phlet will not be of much use to “those who further work in the History of Art,” enabling them to “choose the plac published who contemplate contemplate where they will carry on their advanced study.” It will not be of much use, be cause only for Princeton does it give the courses for the next few years. The pub lication of a single year’s schedule gives no adequate notion of the work at any uni versity, for most universities do not repeat or ought not to repeat the same courses in art every year, but have a cycle of courses extending three Mr Smith would have seen of over four this or years in the case had Register He could for othe r consult Johns Hopkins, for example, if he read carefully page 153 of which he had at his have procured the universities colleges ing years, art and Let drawn, our last disposal. information also and by their catalogues for several successive or by writing to the of ar< hwology the work professors themselves us hope pamphlet will be with and the scientific done over again in a Mr ith lé and accurate manner Sm curate, but he has not What a statement of the courses give has not only been ina: given us what is needed is is needed nin the pres ent and planned for the future, not only at Princeton, but at other universities, or a tabulation of courses given during the las five years, which are likely to be the cours: given during the next few years DavID M. RoORBIN Johns Hopkins University, November 30 [With reluctance the Nation gives
S87 space to the register of errata and ad denda, many of slight importance and all of the sort which by courtesy and good academic usage are generally ex- changed privately among colleagues That seminary courses are not register- ed specifically as such seems to us an imaginary grievance. ous graduate instruction is undertaken in America the seminary method is in use. Some universities, method, prefer not to use a pretentious name for small courses. Unquestion- ably, Mr. Smith’s pamphlet would have more useful if had included prospective courses. But the tabulation was made in: response to an emergency cal! from the International Congress of Art History. An apparently preferen tial treatment of Mr. Smith's own Uni versity, Princeton, is due the fact that Princeton, both in departmental and general circulars, presents whole art curriculum accessibly. In the cases of other universities who scatter Whenever seri while using th been he to her their art courses under other depart ments, some regrettable oversights oc- curred. Very few of these, however, seem to affect the general usefulness of the pamphlet. Intending graduate stu- dents know enough not to imagine that graduate courses are annually repeated. In short, the alleged defects are very rarely of a sort to mislead interested persons. Among the few really grave omissions one is obviously deeply to be regretted—that of the Arch#ological Seminary at Bryn Mawr, which is con- ducted by Professor Robinson.—Ep. Na- TION. ] Literature RECENT VERSE. The Land of Lost Music and Other Poems. By Robert Munger. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. $1.25 net. A Prairie Prayer and Other Poems. By Hilton R. Greer. Boston: French & Co. $1 net. Sherman, The Call of Brotherhood and Other Poems. By Corinne Roosevelt Robin- son. New York: Chas. Scribner's Sons. $1.25 net. Poems and Sonnets. By F. C. Goldsbor- ough. London: David Nutt Of the Valley and the Sea and Other Verses By Fanny Purdy Palmer. London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Trtibner & Co. Poems of Love and Death By John Drinkwater. London: David Nutt The Inverted Torch and Other Poems By Samuel John Alexander. San Fran- cisco: A. M. Robertson. $1.50 net Oxford Poems. By H. W. Garrod. New York: John Lane Co. $1 net.
Page 16
HSS By Howard V. Suth- Desmond Fitz- Idas and Marpessa New York: 60 cents net erland Gerald and the Widow Masefield $1.25 gq Mercy f by he Macmillan ¢ ee John T ‘o Wilson Gibson. New $1.25 net. Wilfred The Macmillan Co Varriott Wat- $1.50 Rosamund w York: John Lane Co of the one-piece vol- ume of them which contain more than a single satis ard of reason of some one poem significant that so many sues of verse are There are only a few factory poem, many these are markable by no comparison this they the they in their poetic superior as to bear the littl For reason to others surface critic; so much occasional of them, are happy not character as in some mood st many or suggestion Indeed, like Mr. Muneger’s “Mood,” frankly ac- indebtedness to just knowledges their is sort of inspiration shall in,” I mimer come hath been of yore, flowery is it speak, its ‘chanted wonder shall be wed withheld before, it shall outpour its answers long light ven; flooding and lie stricken Darkness shall dusk the cricket sings, and th on dull vain vision in the es early waiting days ind hover wings, of the its old gaunt shadow iil, the known barren glean stays flings, Bane such verses are a veri ce; it is as impossible their way to them as to re sion which gave them birth Mr “Poe,” a t would the writer repeat the occ Greer 8 of be a mere pas a palpable artifice dnight, misty-moondéd, oft n unwiet ely tunéd elodiat p, ter uurnful m 4 the hath tresse kist mtrings are n Death ithly eweet!—the music, h lips of doom, of i haunted doom note veaper, young phantoms whisper echoes the ne cadence fle d, eilrd ned to sigh forever, llencéd and breathless dead perhaps it is in the like success apart from abso Iter spent self be 1 Death But sonnet that anything lute genius or sustained training is rar- est. And yet it is poasible to pick out occasional sonnets of a very fair order of merit, due apparently to some mo- mentary and impermanent exaltation of The following, entitled “After Life,” Miss Robinson, an instance: feeling Long by is After long life if I should be bereft Of this Earth's passion and its endless pain, And then, if I could live my life As one Death forgotten and Youth left, I wonder again by long with all the deft unshackled brain Would I mortal would I Desires of my own free, To enter Life’s arena? gain No more ‘twixt hope and anguish cleft \ mbodied A swift Of Life's tence of soul and the dise view sense, mystery the solution of great pageant, and poor pre- Heaven's high-handed Inconsistency? still kneel unto God, to the of So visioned, Or Yield obeisance would I soulless sod? Nor the one to Death and the other to the Emperor Julian, by Mr. Goldsborough and Miss Palmer, un- are these two, worthy of consideration: Not God himself can kill, life are There is no death. He <¢ but one And this is fate And with what dubious baleful draughts to fill The goblet Of time veers otherwhither, Illumes the path of races yet unrun By souls abandoning pale forms grown still! Hence, for death, I know I pray an change Hunger and to be and be undone, the rill and what sun of our being, ere when I pray For what no fate can give—for what the years Know not—nor which the swayed eternal spheres Meet upon any paths of night or day. Abidest rhen hast beyond the scope of God? Death, thou ne'er thou seek me by ways trod In student's garb, a lithe accomplished lad Unfriended—yet self-centred and calm- browed He dwelt, amid the disputations loud Of an imperial Pledged to no cause, for that his fears for- bade \ scholar More, of proud court gone schism-mad, to vowed— of learning birthright, of all than first ideals his Devout, heroic, like Galahad The boldest legions follow where he leads Down that long River servile to his oar: He lifts his faith above the clash of creeds; And the grim game of chaste stakes his fate on War Dead: while upon his life an era hung; Perishing his too rash; so with gods young Mr. Drinkwater, too, while invariably writing with and practice, seems at intervals, it must be confessed, very much superior himself. His | manner is never sombre; he has a way | of touching a grave subject with reas-| suring lightness. But at times his se- riousness, without becoming neatness to heavy, | }second volume. ol. 95, [V No. 2477 - = —_————— = ———_— — deepens—-with great advantage to his style, as in the verses which he calls “An Epilogue for a Masque”: A little while they lived again, and lo! Back to the quiet night the shadows go, And the great folds of silence once again Are over fools and kings and fighting-men. A little while they went with stumbling feet, With spears of hate, and love all flowery sweet, . With wondering hearts and bright adven- turous wills, And now their dust is on a thousand hills. We dream of them, as men unborn shall dream Of us little the Before we too go out beyond the day, And are as much a memory as they. who strive a with stream, Death, coming, shall not seem a thing Of any fear, nor terrible his wing. We too shall be a tale on earth, and time Our pilgrimage shall shape into a rhyme. Even Mr. Alexander, who moves through a wide range of mood to a variety of measures, is hardly master of them all. He has his distinctively bet- ter moments, which seem to coincide with an unusual gravity of feeling: And 80 Oh, Face Divinely Human, grave and tender, Deep-lined whereon I trace Sad thoughts, that mar the splendour We might not dare to face; else ineffable Lord, Lord, I see the beauty of Thy Being, And of Thy Words that shine Star-like across dim ages; but the seeing May never make me Thine. The solemn, sacred service of Thy Preach- ing Lies patent to mine eyes. Yet what my might Teaching Pagan heart denies. soul gather of Thy My Still must I hear in western woodlands ring- ing The Syrinx pipes of Pan; Striking old chords of recollection, bringing My vales Arcadian. must some Pagan Almond Flower of beauty To which my heart shall cling Bloom from the barren Aaron's rod of duty In perfect blossoming. On the whole it cannot fail to strike the reader of current verse that there is something a little fortuitous, a little factitious in much of the poetry that gets itself published nowadays. No wonder that so few writers produce a Even Mr. Viereck has threatened to leave the muse for the ticker. Apparently poetry is ceasing to be a vocation. And yet even as a diver- sion it is hardly to be flouted if it con- Still |tinue to produce such admirable vers d’occasion as Mr. Garrod's—for instance, his lines to J. L. S.: To you at least these barren rhymes Will speak of all they do not say, And bring from unforgotten times The things that cannot pass away :—
Page 17
Dec. 19. 1912] The N ation The Devon places and their breath, The open moor’s untrammelled room, The gold gorse shot with silver heath, The peat-stream and the quiet coombe, The bridge that carried once the cars— Or so we deemed—of Celtic kings Pursuing unremembered wars And dreaming of immortal things; It may be as they went their way They paused to see the sunset stir With purple of the dying day The green and gray of Bellever; Or, if those old unfeeling kings Passed all that glory coldly by And in their proud imaginings Went to do battle and to die:— Their brows at least the moorland wind Washed; and their blood divinely beat; And all that never touched the mind Gave lightness to their faring feet. I, dreaming in the dreaming hill, I, singing to the singing stream, Woo vainly all they felt, and still Miss—or I cannot hold—the gleam. There is some encouragement, for a continued belief in the genuine- ness of the poet's calling in the per- sistency of a few poets. Among others there is Mr. Sutherland, who continues his “Idylls of Greece’ without apparent fatigue or discouragement. It is the tale of “Idas and Marpessa” that he handles this time. And while quotation is difficult in the nature of the case, the following description may serve to give some idea of his treatment: And now the heights were silent. Cloud on cloud, With fleecy shoulders leaning each to each, Took for the night their stations, while the winds Remain’d without and roam’d, disconsolate, The starry highways. One splendid one The gods lay down to wait Aurora’s call To see the dayburst, note with ecstasy The modest flower’s unfolding, and delight In that first note with which the happy bird Heralds the day and all its promises. Austerely silent, at the feet of Zeus They fell asleep, or gazed through half- closed eyes Upon the face that tower’d over them. And once again, like huge brooding birds, The watchers of the tragedies of men Lay couch’d amid the cloud-mass stillily; Prepared to dream of flights against the sun, Enormous circlings to the pleasant earth Or swift descents through endless gulfs of space. by and For some reason or other the tale or story in verse appears to be coming into vogue again. Though it is impossible to | extract from them, two volumes of this kind, one by Mr. Masefield and one by Mr. Gibson, are unusual enough to re quire notice. too, | | subsequently, ito the extent of $100,000, While the latter is anec- | | vulgarized. Still the inspiration is suf- ficiently remarkable. Among recent collections the poems of the late Mrs. H. B. Marriott Watson is the most considerable. The greater number of the pieces have been publish- ed already; but a new series, “The Lamp and the Lute,” which was to have ap- peared separately in the spring, is also included. It is from this addition that the following lines, entitled “Thalassa” and inscribed with the name of Walter Raleigh, are quoted: | By lonely outland coasts and strange isles set Where vast green waters surge winds blow, They say that sea-whelmed souls go sailing yet, |On swift white wings the drowned folk come and great and go. So would I fare—O Thou who didst decree |The sea-mew’'s soul in this of mine, | Bidding my very sense and spirit to be | Deep tinctured with the sea-breeze and the brine. poor earth it not fall that when the last fails, |The doors be opened and the long lease run, |My ghost may go perchance on silver salis To wander ‘twixt the sea-foam and the sun? | Shall light CURRENT FICTION. The Financier. By Theodore Dreiser. New York: Harper & Bros. Turgenieff dismissed a pair who. pros- | pered on the fruits of iniquity with this observation: “Everything in the world, both good and bad, is bestowed upon a man, not in accordance with his merits, but as the result of some unknown but logical laws which I will not even take upon myself to indicate, although it sometimes seems to me that I dimly dis- cern them.” These laws Mr. Dreiser is prepared to declare unto us. Scanning the phenomena of success afforded by our national life, he selects typical career to illustrate their workings—a perfect specimen of the American finan- cier whom he represents as having liv- ed in the Philadelphia of two genera- tions ago. Briefly to summarize the achievements of thirty-odd years, this genius of finance made a fortune in local specu- lation; saw it wiped out in the collapse of the market caused by the Chicago fire, and his share in the time-honored traffic in city funds thereby brought to light; paid the penalty of this exposure by a year in prison; and, a few months having recouped himself carried his new-made fortune West. From the time when young Cowperwood took his first a dotal and sketchy, they are both of them | object-lesson from an aquarium trag- singularly reminiscent of Crabbe in sub- | edy, watching an unwilling squid ap-| ject and manner—though to be sure it | propriated bit by bit by a relentless lob-| is Crabbe modernized and even a little | ster, to the day when in the fulness of | HSO his powers he migrates from his native habitat to a freer fleld of development, the study leaves little to be desired from a biological standpoint. To our thinking, Mr. and away the ablest at work in the American fleld. True, much that is fine slips through his net. But that in itself is no cause for dissatisfac- tion. Other novelists who have had any- thing like his power of analysis have been uniformly predisposed to confine themselves to what is choicest and most attenuated in our national life. We re- joice that Mr. Dreiser is not too dainty in his selection, especially since his grasp upon what he has apprehended is so stout. The collection of types in this case is remarkable, both for its repre- sentative completeness and for the con- sistent individuality of each character. Still more remarkable is the singleness of intention with which they are ana- lyzed, and as it were, comparatively es- timated. Who is fittest to survive amid the forces of man's own creating? The answer is, for this milieu as for the jungle, he who is most vigorous, most acute, and most intelligently selfish— in a word, Cowperwood. He is the stan- dard. Other characters are measured thereby and their fates justified. Small pity is wasted on those who fall by their deficiencies, as Stener, the flabby-minded city who paid the natural price of being other men’s tool, and the of whom Cowperwood quietly rids himself. Whatever sympathy Mr. Dreiser permits himself is expended on those who fail by the superabundance of their endow- ment—a superfluous capacity for other motives than self-interest. The reader's cordial partiality is enlisted for Butler, the old Irish contractor and politician, whose daughter becomes Cowperwood's young mistress. He is vulnerable in his large, fatherly heart, and the re- taliation which his strength renders so disastrous to Cowperwood is still more fatal to himself. Aileen herself, though leave her in the ascendency of her legally wife, shows doubly the ity of her taste and the uncontrollable Dreiser far humanologist is treasurer, temperamentally unresponsive wife we youth established as Cowper- wood's marked for later discard by ineradicable crud force of her affections. It is in his erposé of character and re- lationships and his constructive feeling human drama that Mr distinguished. His literary tions are many and glaring. He only speaks right interminably, diffuse- ly, redundantly, with no stylistic guide beyond a warm feeling for phrase. His attempts identify story with a definite period in the past are strangely intermittent. Fven more exasperating are his ram- L.. ug incursions into the fleld of ethical speculation. The ease with which he walks through the things he does not see is certainly extraordinary. But he is for Dreiser is imperfec on an apt to his
Page 18
29O ut for exercise—nothing so rn as pioneering. Those who accom- willingly soonest back in 1 to point they started from. best the essays in unconventional morality he in Sister ( rhe mei hols him most will eive that they are coming the discernment, of our already accomplished “Jennie Gerhardt,” and has arrie, not yielded one to him Obviously, until his own convictions he an do little to inform our understand and wrong. Financier,” have usion that hearted defence seems worth a have clarified, ing of right fest of a Bad Job. By Norman Dun- New York: Fleming H. Revell We are wont to pride ourselves on the fact that sentiment does not play its ‘The Nation boy has bequeathed Old Tom his gospel, “to make the best of a bad job”; and he buckles to the job of living again for the boy’s sake. Thcreafter no misfor- tune shakes him. He is presently cast away on the ice and becomes snow-blind. A “short allowance” of sight is restor- ed to him, but it is chiefly by his culti- vation of other faculties that he contin- ues to captain his fishing vessel, caps his career with an amazing performance of pluck and skill, and fulfils his ambi- tion to leave a tale to prove the truth of his gospel, “a tale t’ be told in the forecastles o' the Labrador craft 0’ windy nights in harbour.” ther, and as epitaph his favorite motto: “My friend is Laughter from Get-Along- Somehow, an’ my best bedfellow is call- old bold part in our literature. Even half! ed Grit.” American with sensibility. and drooped their fainted their way through at least; bachelors still reveries; and the wide, was a place of warm and Now- self-consciousness has taken Anglo-English reticence Newcome and manner of relegated literature. worn a century ago, English and all sighed, fiction was awash Ladies still and of books, to lashes the life ‘ onfe ssed ids omewhat world self-conscious emotion. adays our another turn Colonel in the Inanner gkrows uponh us Little Nell day: it the died best now of longer is a the to shabby gentilities Broken hearts are no on and scenes of overt pathos are sleeves un the left to those great repositories of the and We withal hionable relics, stage grown a Fear of 3m in danger of producing a ; and dryness of manner which feel every f melodrama have wardly senti- is inmost really our The express re are moments when is at heart a sentimentalist the better for it, since they are only There (thanks is even a season of the the of we to moments when to author _ vt > our eal agree insensibility, Littl they say) ibandon pret nee of ind to play our joyous part in a Christen dom of sentimentalists Vr. Duncan is one of the writers who ight to be approached in this mood, if itis of sensibility The rom Tulk of the present story, the Skipper Tumm, who tells it, and his random audience of Labrador fishermen to it, all dwell of ardent and trem which the traveller eyes and ears of a child it is te Old rulk life time of hardship on the Labrador seas, all is a gospel and traders who listen ithin that zone feeling must with the » mean anything to him iloug enter rom has known an ordinary great sorrow comes in the loss young grandson. The boy is a and a consumptive. His death led up to by Inches, and is left unextracted of parting. The ripple ia looked for, of pathos final » drop the acene from Burgoyne. By York: The Mrs. New The Rich Norris. Co. Macmillan Like monette to inculate artfully designed sentiment in the women to whom it is addressed. The preacher has the secret of making common-sense palatable—if anything, palatable, like the medicinal compound of which it is vaunted “children cry for it.” It is very pleasant to read how Santa Paloma, Cal., improved under the win- sume example and wise precepts of this Santa Pa- wholesome too nice young widowed heroine has perfectly the air of the California town, its “best set” its follies and its friendli- meet loma sO modern is so like, in ness, the young married folk in other small towns, and each step of the betterment is accomplished before our eyes with such a cheerful wealth of lifelike circumstance. It pleasant also to behold a deserving hero prompt- ly delivered out of many difficulties by a brisk feminine hand. It is only after have seen Santa Paloma well on the way the millennium, and our hard-working, happy pair safe on the road to matrimony, that we begin to re- member that the course of true reform seldom runs so smoothly, and that it was all so pleasant precisely because it we is we to wes too good to be true. BYZANTIUM. Eastern Roman Em- From the Fall of Irene to the Accession of Basil I (a. p, 802-867). By J. B. Bury, Regius Professor of Modern History and Fellow of King’s College, in the University of Cam- bridge. New York: The Macmillan Co. $4 Twenty-three years ago Mr. J. B. Bury, a recent graduate of Trinity Col- lege, Dublin, attracted favorable notice of the historical scholars of the world 4 History of the pire, So Old Tom | Tulk passes, leaving as legacy the trick | of steering by the echoes in foggy wea- | Kathleen | “Mother,” this is a pretty ser-| 95, N [Vol. by a remarkable work in two volumes on the Later Roman Empire. The epoch included in this youthful attempt ex- tended from the division of the realm of Theodosius the Great between his two weakling sons, Arcadius and Honorius, to the crowning of Charlemagne in the reign of Queen Irene (800 a. v.). It was treated in a leisurely narrative without much distinction of style or weight of reflection, but with abundance of know- ledge and unusual breadth of vision. Clearly the young historian had gone to school to Freeman. | The promise of this striking begin- ning has been richly fulfilled in the past two decades. Professor Bury has now to his credit the standard brief history of Grecce in the English lan- guage and the only authoritative life |of Saint Patrick. His edition of Gib- bon rightly takes precedence of all others, and the new “Cambridge Medi- eval History” is being executed accord- ing to his plan. He has edited texts of the Nemean and Isthmian Odes of Pin- dar, published Harvard lectures on “The Ancient Greek Historians,” and contrib- uted many articles to the scientific jour- nals. His latest volume is in a way a con- tinuation of his youthful venture. It deals, however, not with two centuries but with two generations only—the fateful sixty-five years of the so-called Amorian dynasty. The increase of the author's experience, power of judgment, and critical faculty, moreover, makes it really an independent work. It is, in our opinion, the most finished book which Professor Bury has yet written, and is perhaps the most important work on Byzantine history which has thus far appeared in the English lan- guage. The author’s theme and attitude are defined by himself near the beginning of his last chapter: The Amorian age [he says] regarded as an inglorious interval between the rule of the Isaurians, who renovated the strength of the Empire, and the bril- | Hant expansion under Basil I and his suc- cessors. The losses of Crete and Sicily have been taken as a proof of decline; the character and the régime of Theophilus lhave been viewed with antipathy or con- tempt; and the worthlessness of Michael I1l has prejudiced posterity against the generation which tolerated such a sovran. 'This unfavorable opinion is not confined ‘to the learned slaves of the Papacy, who fare unable to regard with impartial eyes |the age of Theophilus the enemy of icous, jand of Photius the enemy of the Pope. | The deepest cause of the prevalent view |has been the deliberate and malignant de- }traction with which the sovrans and servile |chroniclers of the Basilian period pursued | the memory and blackened the repute of the |Amorian administration; for modern his- |}torlans have not emancipated themselves |completely from the bias of those preju- diced sources. is apt to be
Page 19
Dec. 19, 1912] In the foregoing pages we have seen that, while even detraction not ventured the Amorian of exceptional rigor in taxing their subjects, the Empire was wealthy and prosperous. We have seen that it maintained itself, with alternations defeat and victory, but without losing ground, against the Caliphate, that preserved the Bulgarian frontier, that the reduction the Slavs in was completed. Oversea dominions were lost, but against this we have to set the fact that the Amorian monarchs, by taking in hand the reconstruction of the naval establishment, which the Isaurians had neglected, prepared the way for the successes of Basil I in Italy. We have still to see what services they rendered to art, education, and learning. In _ these spheres we shall find a new pulse of move- ment, endeavor, revival, distinguishing the ninth century from the two hundred years which preceded it. We may, indeed, that our period established the most fully aeveloped and most pardonable self-com- placent phase of Byzantinism. has to accuse rulers of peace was and Greece on of The book opens with a detailed ac- count of domestic policy and events. The narrative is styleless in the best sense. Truth is never sacrificed to an epigram nor precision to rhetorical ef- fect. Artless the story certainly is not. Professor Bury has steeped himself in the Greek, Arabic, and Syrian sources. He views them critically, of course, and confronts them not only with one an- where that is possible, but also with the archeological and epigraphic- other al records, which under his skilful man- | agement are a formidable adversary of falsehood. At the same time, however, by a careful use of stories, anecdotes, and culled from histories, chronicles, pamphlets, and hagiogra- phies, he contrives to surround his act- ors and incidents with the atmosphere of medieval Constantinople, an atmo- sphere of intrigue, piety, superstition, luxury, elegance, prurience, tolerance and intolerance, reverence for the sanc- tity of human life and atrocious cruelty —the strange blend of opposites which carries ninth-century Byzantium so far away from our modern experience. Before proceeding to deal with foreign policy and events, Professor Bury in- terpolates two chapters, one, entitled Ignatius and Photius, in which the great ecclesiastical controversy of the age is formulated and interpreted with such force and clarity that it appears no longer trivial but almost worthy of its intense contemporary interest, and an- other on Byzantine finance and govern- ment which is at least a partial illu- mination of a very dark place. After the foreign reiations have been considered in five chapters, the narrative ends with an effective characterization of art, edu- cation, and learning in the Amorian period. The five chapters on foreign affairs cannot fail to command the attention of historians at large. For what student) legends, say | The Nation ‘of history can afford to ignore a work in which the foundings of Venice, Bagh- dad, Kiev, Itil, and Pliska are described with the aid of new or terials? In part Professor Bury deals, not with an ob- scure epoch of Byzantine history, but with the history of the world from the Byzantine point of view. The political map of Europe from the Ural Moun- tains to the Baltic Sea ceases to be a bare patch and becomes animated with Patzinaks, Khazars, Magyars, Bulgar- ians, Russians, Servians, and other Slav- ic, Finnish, and Turkish peoples whose institutions are sketched and whose movements are interpreted with refer- ence to Byzantine projects and impulses Here Professor Bury’s knowledge of the Semitic and Slavic languages has abled him to use stores of information |\hitherto beyond the reach of the ordi- nary English and American student of history The reader who demands that history shall give him the thrills which he gets from the novel may not relish even the first part of this “History of the East- ern Roman Empire’; but to the man who cares for the niceties of historical research and composition the book will give a rare pleasure. The specialist may find errors of omission and com- mission. Where the field broad they are unavoidable. But he is bound to envy the author his amazing control of the modern literature of the subject. What the general reader will miss most —intimate and truthful tion of the chief men of affairs, and com prehensive description of the social and economic foundations of the state—Pro fessor Bury denies that it possible for any one to give him. He may right, but surmise that a Theodore Mommsen an Eduard Meyer would have made the attempt. inaccessible his ma- this of volume en- is so characteriza is be we or The Autobiography of an Individualist. By James O. Fagan. Boston: Hough- ton Mifflin Co. $1.25 net. A reader unfamiliar with Mr. Fagan's earlier books might well be puzzled to understand how a man passing an ob- scure and uneventful existence in a rail- switch tower at West Cambridge, Mass., should expect the American pub- lic to have any interest in his life. But many will recall the impression creat- ed by “Confessions of a Railroad Signal- man” and “Labor and the Railroads,” and will not have forgotten the clear vision and the courage with which the weaknesses in the railway labor situa- tion were exposed. Whether or not one is in agreement with Mr. Fagan’'s views, and a considerable number of close stu- dents of the problem are not, one must recognize his sincere and earnest pur- pose. That same spirit dominates his way autobiography; his gospel of individual- oY1 ism as applied to railways his sole it iS thought; explains his book. His life in Scotland, Amer ica, and in South Africa was not event and justifies in South ful enough to be of any general inte est, and has its signiffeance only in the fact that in the author's belief of that period profoundly affected thinking and influenced the develop ment of his philosophy. That philosophy applied to the railway industry is sim ply a plea for the restoration of the free- incidents his dom of the individual—freedom from the red tape of officialdom, and from the tyranny of the labor union—and for a closer and more personal relation between the directing force of the rail- way and its employees. Of particular interest is the portray- New England railways in the eighties, which describes a situation in akin that which the author wishes to see restored. He as- serts, for example, that “with the same al of some respects to consecration to duty to-day as then, the modern accident problem would lose its significance.” One is involuntarily attracted to this While working as night operator at East Deer- field at eight dollars a week, he receiv- ed the offer occasionally of an increase quiet man, unique in these days. in salary. “I told the authorities,” he says, “not to bother about it, and they did not.” He accepted a shift at the West Cambridge interlocking tower be cause it reduced his hours of duty from twelve to eight, brought him near the libraries, lectures, and churches of Bos- ton, and gave him ro the study of social and industrial pro- ’ After referring to “progressive people” who recognize no condition as forever more time to devote ] . ems, sound in which one is not on jump towards something better, he tie sums up his attitude towards life with the following delightful comment: “Such people have little appreciation for conditions and individuals in this world that wisely slow up or stand still for inspirational purposes.” of who have times marvelled at the attractiveness of style displayed by one whose pursuits have Those us many not led him along Literary paths can now have our curiosity satisfied At East Deerfield he carried an English dictionary in his pocket, which he con- sulted on his walks. He read the book through three or four times, and rein- vestigated many of the words in larger dictionaries. At West Cambridge in the signal tower he devoted his spare time to the construction of sentences, and when he launched into narrative he rewrote his first story at least one hundred times. A thorough drilling in Latin and Greek in his youth came to his aid. He says, “As a simple practl- cal equipment for life’s journey, what may be called my classical foundation seems to me now to be worth all the
Page 20
‘) ~~ 59 other features of school education put together. Unfortunately, he is not infallible. Af- ter enjoying the pleasures of good Eng- lish until the work is nearly ended, the reader suffers a painful shock when he comes upon thist “Out of a caldron of industrial and political interests and factions on the railroad, he must pluck by hook or by crook, in some way, the flower of satisfactory service.” my Myths and Legends of Japan. By F. Hadland Davis. With thirty-two full- page illustrations by Evelyn Paul. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell Co. $3.50 net. Like other recent writers on Japan, the author confesses his prime indebtedness to Lafcadio Hearn, “who first revealed to me the Land of the Gods.” It is not therefore surprising to find that there is more of impression- ism than of scholarly finish in his han- dling of Japanese matters. Yet he starts out in his preface with a long list of authorities from Prof. Basil Hall and Dr. W. G. Aston to Arthur Lloyd. Hearn’s to copy his weaknesses rather than his virtues, and to distort in a blundering way the country they profess to elucidate. Certainly no critic would have object- ed more strenuously to statements made book than the late Dr. Aston, Mr. Davis is so fond of quoting. “Shinto taught her [Japan] to mighty dead; the very of Shintoism [is] associat- ed with ancestor worship,” declares Mr. Davis in his Introduction, at pages xii and xvi, without any discussion or apol- Bu this is not very courteous to Asto, “Shinto, the Way of the wheve the exact contrary is stat- 36: some Chamberlain the late Rev. pupils seem in this whom has revere the nature ory bt Gods ed at page is of a list of “Greater Shrines” the comprised An analy century yields the tenth or the 1 iits prepared in gods deities following res are nature one is ich probably represented a na less the priestly vo or are more or eased Mikados more one 18 ofa of statesman of the Dii Shinto are ipposed ancestor ne ia the ancestor an em deceased None lent ia 6A 177.) an preas one [Or again at page Majorca of the more deified men In like the present, a wrong impression of the nature of Shinto will to vitiate the and this is actually A consultation of the authori reveals the a work naturally go far whole treatment; what happens in the preface author's lack of anything but a super ficial with tteir works. The list is supplemented by an impos- ing bibliography at the close, extending to five pages. But why are Murdoch and Knox omitted, while the names of tles quoted acquaintance _ regent, The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 trivial writers of mcre recent date find Murdoch's “History of Japan,” published two years ago, is a pro- found and thorough study, to which writers like Professor Chamberlain are very willing to acknowledge their in- debtedness. Dr. G. W. Knox, who died but a few months ago, gives in “The De- velopment of Religion in Japan” a mas- terly treatment of the very subjects that Dr. Davis blunders over. In the Bibliography are found the names of Batchelor and B. H. Chamber- lain, with Ainu treatises attached to them. Mr. Davis wouid have found in these treatises a discussion’ of the strange fact that Yoshitsune, to whose feats he devotes half-a-dozen pages, is to this day revered as a hero among the aborigines of Northern Japan. It is, indeed, the most interesting fact in Ainu mythology; yet Mr. Davis is si- lent about it, while devoting considera- ble space to Japanese gardens, which are not associated with Japanese myth or legend. Many of the stories which he gives, as, for instance, “The Burn- ing of the Three Dwarf Trees,” are real tales dealing with personages of interest to students of constitutional history. Moreover, this tale is not well told. The leading character, Tokiyori, was a capable Kamakura shikken, or belonging to the noble Hojo family. The province he visited was not “Kodzuki,” but Kodzuke, and he was not a “royal wanderer.” The samurai Sano’s second name was certainly not “Genzalmon.” Yet in many respects this handsome volume, with its attractive illustrations Japanesque rather than Japanese— deserves commendation; and its de- fects may not be present to the ordinary reader, who may be led by it into a fairy world. But it invites awkward comparison with a masterpiece like “The Tales of Old Japan,” which covers much the same ground, but was written by an author who «new his, material perfectly, and whose English is impecca- ble. a place? Notes Mr. T. M. Healy’s “Stolen Waters: a Page from the Conquest of Ulster,” which Longmans have in preparation, is based on unpublished manuscripts, state papers, etc., dealing with the title to two great fisheries in northern Ireland. Markham's “The is announced Conquest E. P Sir Clements of New Dutton Grenada” by issuing the following “The Concept of Sin,’ by F. R. Tennant; “The Epistle of Paul the Apostle to the Romans,” introduction and notes by R. St. Putnams are books The Cambridge edited with) John | letter to Greeley and the Gettysburg Ad- - edited with introduction and notes by Mon- tague Rhodes James, and “Light on the Gospel from an Ancient Poet,” by Edwin A. Abbott. The Hawthorne Memorial Association has been incorporated for the purpose, in the words of its charter, “of the erection or establishment and maintenance of a memo- vial to Nathaniel Hawthorne in the city of Salem, Mass.” In Salem, on Union Street, is the house in which Hawthorne was born. Opn Derby Street is the old Custom House, in which he acted as surveyor. On Mall Street, off the Common, is the house in which he wrote “The Scarlet Letter,” etc. | The city has quite enough associations with him to warrant a general interest in the memorial which is proposed. The Associa- tion has selected as its artists Bela L. Pratt, sculptor, and R. Clipston Sturgis, architect. The expense of the memorial is not to exceed $50,000. Those interested may get full information from Harlan P. Kelsey, secretary, Salem, Mass., and contributions should be made out to the Hawthorne Me- morial Association, addressed to Mr. Kel- sey. We read in the Cambridge Review: After quite a little flutter of verse-loving fly-sheets, the changes in the Classical Tri- pos were carried in the Senate on Satur- day by 55 to 44; and in 1915 and thereafter candidates will not necessarily lose any- thing if they do not offer Greek or Latin verse. The economic evolution of Lorraine is the subject of most general interest treated in the Annales de Géographie for November. The industrial conditions at the time of the Franco-Prussian war are compared with those of the present day, showing a re- markable progress in these forty-two years, “through persevering work and methodic organization.” On the other hand, in an article on Spanish emigration it is shown that “almost the whole of Spain is being drained of its peasantry, a grave economic condition [malaise] due largely to bad land ownership, heavy taxes, and the irregular climate.” The other contents are geologic studies of the North Atlantic and English Channel sea-bottom, and the structure of the Titteri, one of the ranges of the Atlas Mountains. The frontier region of Turkey and Servia sketched by Major O. Kreutzbruck v. Lilienfels in the military department of Petermann’s Mitteilungen for November. The four principal routes which invading armies would take are described in detail, and there is an admirable map, in which is shown the location of the various fortifica- Among the other subjects treated is the temperature of the earth in its re- lation to the development of vegetation. is tions. In our recent notice of Miss Helen Nico- lay’s “Personal Traits of Abraham Lin- coln,” reference was made to her opinion that not more than a hundred of the sto- ries attributed to Lincoln were probably genuine. Mr. Anthony Gross, in “Lin- coln’s Own Stories” (Harper), has brought together about three times that number. While the collection includes anecdotes about Lincoln, as well as stories by him, and while such inclusions as the Union Parry; “The Second Epistle General of | dress are foreign to either category, the Peter and the General Epistle of Jude,”| reader who likes to begin anywhere and
Page 21
Dec. 19, 1912] The Nation stop at any time will probably find the volume both entertaining and instructive. “Joseph Pennell’s Pictures of the Panama Canal” (Lippincott) consist of a series of lithographs made by Mr. Pennell in the early months of this year, together with paragraphs of explanatory text. The spirit of the work is aptly conveyed sen- tence or two from the paragraph accom- yanying the picture of The Guard Gate, Gatun: The scale, the immensity of the whole may be judged by the size of the engines and figures. 1 have never seen such a mag- nificent arrangement of line, light, and mass, and yet those were the last things the engineers thought ef. But great work great art, and always was and will be. This is the Wonder of Work. by a is Mr. Pennell’s bock is indeed an extraordi- nary record of this Wonder of Work, much of which will ealed when is completed and filled with be com the canal water. Grace G. Montgomery has adopted a novel and very practical method, that of ques- tion and answer, in her “Auction Bridge in Ten Lessons” (Scribner). The salient fea- tures in her directions for playing the game do not differ materially from those given in other handbooks on the _ subject, and the chief value of the present volume is in its compression and convenient size, and in its clear arrangement. It should be of considerable both to be- ginners and to players of moderate skill who wish to improve their game. assistance, Jeannette Marks has herself felt the spell of Wales, and endeavors in “Gallant Little Wales” (Houghton) to communicate her emotions to others. This little volume is conscientiously written, and in parts structive, yet somehow it seems to just the impression which the author evi- dently wished to convey. There are many irritating repetitions and some anecdotes of personal experiences which, however thrill- ing to the subject of them, fail to intrigue the general reader, and there is a chapter devoted to Dr. tour of North Wales which is rather perfunctory and quite unprofitable. On the other hand, the au- thor is able to reflect a little of the spirit which animates the Eisteddfod, and in the chapter on Hill Top Churches she skirts a field which might repay fuller exploration. Perhaps it is the inevitable comparison with the absorbing Borrow, perhaps the recollec- tion of treasured emotions of one’s own, evoked by adventures in this romantic cor- ner of Britain: whatever it be, the present volume somehow fails to set the pulse of enthusiasm beating. Dr. J. Franklin Jameson has edited, with an eppreciative biographical introduction, the late Gertrude S. Kimball's “Providence in Colonial Times” (Houghton Mifflin). The volume is only a section of an intended larger work, but the part now published, with the exception of a fragmentary final chapter on old Providence houses, was left in a completed state at the author’s pre- mature death in 1910. Few students knew mor¢ intimately than did Miss Kimball the early history of Providence and Rhode Isl- and; while at the same time her previous publications, notably the “Correspondence of the Colonial Governors of Rhode Island” (1902-1903) and the “Correspondence of Wil- liam Pitt” with colonial officials (1906), kept before her a clear view of the wider his- in- miss Johnson's ’ torical relations of the period. As a con- sequence the present work. while exhibiting am easy familiarity with local and personal details, rarely loses sight of the general historical background, and entitles the book to a high place in the scanty list of first- rate local histories. The checkered career of Roger Williams has nowhere been traced with a better mixture of sympathy and impartiality than in Miss Kimball's first three chapters; and the chapter on the early shipping trade of Providence, fore- shadowed in part by the author's earlier paper on the East India trade of the town from 1787 to 1807, published in 1896, is a solid contribution. The forty-seven full- page illustrations are intelligently chosen and notably well executed. The Lost Cause and causes that are hang- ing in the balance are brought into juxta- position in the little of Roger A. Pryor’s “Essays and (Neale) The book with the author’s speech on the independence of the South, deliv- ered in the House of Representatives after volume Addresses” opens the election of Lincoln; it closes with his argument in the case of the People of New York vs. the North River Sugar Re- fining Company, described as the first ef- fort in any court in the land to break up a Trust. This was in 1890, but previous to the passage of the Sherman act, and the effort was Between the two dates Pryor was a member of the first Confed- erate Congress, and, ultimately, a Justice of the Court of New York. His style old-fashioned leisureliness, and the mentioned are the only ones of much interest. The book needs a few notes, particularly on the first speech, and more dates. successful. Supreme has the two addresses “New Trails in Mexico: An account of one year’s exploration in Northwestern Senora, Mex., and southwestern Arizona, 1909-1910" (Scribner), by Carl Lumholtz, is not on the as interesting the author’s previous work, entitled “Unknown whole as Mexico,” which was published in 1902. The latter contained the record of five years’ exploration and embraced territory more than five times the size of that which he now deals with. The method of treatment is much the same in both books. Perhaps the most valuable contributions in the pres- ent volume are the maps which cover an area hitherto little known, that of the ex- treme northwestern corner of Mexico. The romantic early history of this country to- gether with that now included in the present State of Arizona is only slightly touched upon. “Original documents,” the author writes in his Preface, “relating to the his- tory of this region, are not always of easy access, and I have not had an opportunity of consulting them.” The tions of the Hispanic Society in New York seem to have been overlooked in this con- nection. This is one of many where a library, and especially this derful of Mr. Huntington's, is rot without honor in its city. Mr. Lumholtz’s work is evidently a transcrip- tion directly from the notebook with little rearrangement of material, a fact which will often make it difficult for the specialist to separate from the mass of rather prolix description the material he is seeking, al- though a good index is furnished It is to be tregretted that the interesting flora valuable collec- instances won- collection own 593 not considered by them- selves wth greater detail and accuracy, per- and fauna were haps in appendices as has been done with th» geology of the country To the general reader the book should prove entertaining ia its description of travel in an ill-watered country which is virtually unknown Mrs al John King van Rensselaer has written of 392 “Prophetical, Edu- and (Jacobs), with a few chapters on chess and fortun: The Mrs. lies attempt 00k pages on ational Playing Cards telling book relation interest in van Rensselaer's to and the ancient in her establish a between cards roth Ménestrier mysteries of Hermes-Trismegistus Ever since in 1704, looking through the ac- King Charles V1, discovered that the Royal Treasurer had Gringonneur Parisis counts of in 1392 paid “58 sols et the been Jacquenin trois jeux ouleurs de plusieurs devises of subject. pour de cartes A or diverses problem most himself be- invented in the Abbé Gern and of about of the origin cards has a Ménestrier had in intricate been 1771, prove original hom (and not in 216 of Mrs. v appeared ai curious de Gebelin, which De Gebelin, general lieved that they He inecken, 1781, tried respectively, as the Then, 1779 find on page book), a certain Court to France and Rive, in to any Spain all cards. in 1785," as we an Rensselaer'’s work by devoted chapter cards. of in forgotten, a those histories the tried but who wrote one eighteenth century to prove that the allegorical figures which represented the Book of Wis dom of the ancient He was not taken very seriously. The most valuable con- cribution in 1784. Jo- hann Gottlob Brietkopf, one of the founders of the famous music-printing house of Leip- much in but vogrue since nothing cards were Egyptians. appeared, however, “Versuch, den Ursprung der die den zig, his Spielkarten, in Leinen Holzschneide- declared In- Einfiihrung des und Anfang der papiers, kunst in Europa zu erforschen,” of Eastern had time that cards were probably origin, and been imported into at the of the Crusades Sicily, and Central Italy D'’Ambly, but (1842) all cards dian, Via The Chatto, Europe the further earace ns, investigations of most especial- the supported Cicognara Leber have and ly those of of Viterbo Cards Lacroix Archives Breitkopf divining their in playing well as which by as cards, were adopted for pur- palmists the of upon s00n cut act ord- the India, and handed higher classes, poses and as the brought them the were first like the war-game magicians as printing and wood within press reach all ing to best knowledge sub- ject were, used in Northern forgotten four for the gradually adopted by the mass of the peo- now chess, a ple. books easily like and children’s ple ture-books, cooking are Only a few old packs are left to us dificult full of It seems to van Rens- investigated subject in accepts the anything of ill- information. Babylon- Cards, destroyed Their pit- very and us that Mrs the She without study is a one falls. selaer has haphazard of De and buries a most way. Gebelin it under a heterogeneous theory more, mass assorted and She adds quantity of Assyrian ijan-Hebrew-Greek-and-Egyptian occultism We read through the book with great We find, however, that to re- fute single statement by Mrs have care. every made
Page 22
= 94 a work of at that book care- take can Rensselaer would Wwe interest van least 600 only hope her pages the controversial which may call forth will induce a more ful inve understat readable and fascinating stigator to us a lable give volume on this sut The Missouri Louls has ist Dr. F. A. Wislizenus’s “A Rocky Mour the Year inhabitants St of the The of driven by the authori- Society of translation to Historical published a Journey 1839.” itains in was one ot those no were account of partici- 1836 pul shores, on revolutionary d himself settlement movements. In St. Clair County, of ause of their “Die in in a German ke himself, who, be« lucation, were styled La rhe by writes German doctor was life, “irresistible at length Mountains young the quiet by an teiner not satisfied being seiz- ed pulse for is h im- made This ex- wandering,” and the Rocky little which The simple, the journey described cessively carce, 1840 told which to he in a volume, now published in of his ad- straightfor- the reader a observations. was St. Louis in story in a creates is ventures ward way in feeling of confidence in his rhe credit t book is well printed, and is a great the Soclety The Ma print of Henry B and millan Company has issued a re- the autobiography of Bishop Whipple of Minnesota, “Lights of a Long which published in 1899 It the of the Indian, a man of unique Shadows Episcopate,” first is the of wa of story one greatest and noblest Ameri- can friends and fase than fort inating personality, whose more of Minnesota in the The in- Bishop form a most creditable chapter Amer effort his full years as history of ican religious narrative f experiences is of at The Nat Monsignor the act ities called excellent attention of in on of April 25 Ward's of the the has volume history Roman Catholics early nineteenth ce just of his “I (Long! ntury published a third of Catholle covering the of ng elf neland n rhe and tuthor final ve ans) At the Catholic Church use divided Ipation”™ to 1830 beginning in |! against it Deo ad emancipation ‘onal antagonisms and es L! political had been done But tthe progress h mw irds done mostly In England in 1823 1} : forward in Ireland to He of England itholl Assoctation began ent I in source fro er since re of Catholl formed political lation in ror dis England en s of pr powerful a in agents The factor a8 years the English Govern disso had and safety demanded it however O'Connell of of originality the 1 man both When he of and bold lection English eived the standing for « con as The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 member of Parliament from County Clare, | in spite of the fact that he could not take the oath required to confirm his seat in was elected, as Monsignor Ward describes, with unbounded enthusi- asm, by the priests and by the people. By this act O’Connell forced the crisis which finally led the Government to concede Cath- olic Emancipation. Besides describing this political struggle, the author gives a good account of the restoration of the Eng- lish Jesuits, of the payment of the claims for the destruction during the French Revo- lution of the Catholic property at Douay, and of the other activities of leading Eng- lish during the third decade of the century. Parliament, he Catholics nineteenth as much foreign philosophical lit- remains un- So long erature of real importance translated, the appearance of English ver- works of minor consequence cannot be recorded with entirely unalloyed satis- faction. The collection of essays by Eu.ile Boutroux, which F. Rothwell has done into English, under the title “Historical Studies in Philosophy” (Macmillan), was not a book of which the translation can be said to have been imperative. The French orig | inal appeared fifteen years ago Exactly half the volume consists of two reprinted encyclopedia articles—those on Aristotic and Kant, from “La Grande Encyclopédie.” Of this circumstance the English publish- unlike the French, have neglected to make mention. These articles give brief biographies of the philosophers with whom they deal, and fairly clear and _ skilful précis of the philosophers’ writings. But, except for a few interesting paragraphs on Aristotle’s relation to modern thought, they | contain no critical or constructive matter of consequence; and the article on Kant in- cludes rather more than a reasonable num- The freshest and of the book are Socrates and of Jacob Beehme. The translator inexplicably omitted from the part of the original having a special interest for | sions oO ers, of historical errors portions of ber most valuable those treating has English version the an historical discourse on upon French | English readers the of philosophy. The has the sole merit of being tolerably idiomatic; with the | French tongue and with the terminolos7 of | very intimate ac- blunders are nu- conversion of the snail’; the philosophique influence Scottish translation philosophy it betrays no Elementary the quaintance merous—such as (chenille) into “a of name caterpillar Vencyclopédice of a philosophical disci- translation (used a® the Encyclopedism” ; “right.” The last error sentence: as basei, not He defends the sentimentality of to room by “philosophical droit line) of by of irony of right reward the not ind invariably this the most amusing instance is the “Kant re undesigned gards penal on utility, but on against did order leath alty per ‘abol- for aside propose to “find proposed to Re irla Kant ish learning ir bell he the pretension to knowledge (of the super- To say that Kant’s “Critique” is de Veaprit humain Is is of the pillars 164 the sense of the “possible.” and ia) French merely set sensible) monumenta that it wn des not to say “one of human thought.” On p is reversed by sub- for printed, the an entire passage stitution of “impossible” The furnished with edition lacks admirably index, which volume Is an “Letters of Ulysses S. Grant” (Putnam), edited by Jesse Grant Cramer, is a small | collection of letters written by the General to his father and sister between the years 1857 and 1878. Their historical value. is very slight. One learns how the secession movement was received in Illinois around Galena; there is a hint of the “pulling and hauling” for appointments in the army at the opening of the war; and something about the carping criticism indulged in by Northern newspapers with respect to mili- tary operations. But the letters are main- ly concerned with personal and fainily af- fairs. Even about the General himself they tell us little that is new. The early let- ters have something about his experience as a farmer; the later something about his travels. And certainly no one would these letters for the letters’ sake. Gen. Grant was not of those who, like Horace Walpole, write interesting letters even when they have nothing to say. “I have nothing particular to write about,” he says rather helplessly. “We are all very well. Julia contemplates visiting St. Charles next Saturday.” Yet, give him something tangible, and he writes well enough, with that direct simplicity, that homely phraseology, that precision and read |} economy of words, which, in the Memoirs, won the praise of so fastidious a critic as Matthew Arnold. Here, certainly, the style is the man; and the chief, and almost the only, interest which the letters have, is in revealing that elemental simplicity of mind and heart which made Gen. Grant a great man. He had, in the highest degree, the common man’s common sense, his ca- pacity for hitting the mark by instinct without resorting to logical processes of thought. “Whatever may have been my political opinions before, I have but one sentiment now. That is, we have a govern- ment, and laws, and a flag, and they must all be sustained.”” Now, if you boil down all the volumes of argument employed to sustain the Northern position, this is pre- cisely what they come to. This was ex- actly the position of Lincoln. But what with Lincoln was a reasoned conclusion with Grant was an instinctive sentiment. Whitelaw Reid, Ambhassador from the United States to the Court of St. James's, died at Dorchester House, London, on Sun- He was born in Xenia, O., in 1837, and in 1856 graduated from Miami Uni- versity (Oxford, O.). In 1858-9 he edited the Xenia News. After experience as legislative correspondent, as war corre- spondent, and as librarian the House of Representatives, he became attached, in 1868, to the editorial staff of the New York Tribune, of which paper he was editor-in- chief and chief proprietor from 1872 to 1905. In the latter year he was appointed Mr. Roosevelt Ambassador to England. Previously he had been Minister’ to France, under President Harrison. Several including his own, conferred hon- Princeton, Yale, and Manchester from Oxford day. of by colleges, orary degrees upon him. Cambridge, St. Andrew’s, him the LL.D. and received the D.C.L. Mr. Reid was the author of numerous publications, among them: “After the War, a Southern Tour,” “Ohio in the War,” “Schools of Journalism,” “Some Consequences of the Last Treaty of Paris,” “Our New Interests,” “Problems gave he
Page 23
Dec. 19, 1912] The Nation O95 | of Expansion,” and “How America Faced its Educational Problem.” The death, at the age of seventy-nine, is reported from Cannes, France, of the Rev. Thomas Augustus Jaggar, D.D., a bishop in the Episcopal Church, who in 1908 was ap- pointed bishop in charge of American churches in Europe. He was the author of the “Bohlen Lectures” for 1900, and various essays. The Rev. John Donnan Countermine, D.D., a Presbyterian minister, whose death, at the age of sixty-two, was reported last week from Philadelphia, was the author of several books, including “The Religious Beliefs of Shakespeare,” “Joseph Addison the Man and Author,” and “Daybreak Ev- erywhere. author who died last week Henry B. Pratt, aged eighty, a graduate of the Princeton Theological Seminary. At the time of his death he was engaged on a the Spanish Bible for the American Bible So- ciety. Among hig other works is “The Bur- ied Nations of the Infant Dead.” Another clergyman is revision of his work on William many Dr Hand Browne, writer, and for librarian of the Johns Hopkins University, died on Friday in Bal- years timore. He was born in that city in 1828, and graduated in medicine from the Uni- versity of Maryland in 1850. Since 1891 he had been professor of English literature in Johns Hopkins. He was the author of “Maryland, the History of a Palatinate,” “George Calvert and Cecilius Calvert, Ba- rons Baltimore,” and collaborated with Col. R. M. Johnston on the “Life of Alexan- der H. Stephens.” As compiler he is re- membered for his “Clarendon Dictionary of the English Language” and “Selections from the Early Scottish Poets.” He also translated Von Falke’s “Greece and Rome” a.” other works —— Science Alpine Studies. By W. A. R. Coolidge, M.A. With sixteen illustrations. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $2.50 net. In this book Mr. Coolidge (who is, we believe, of American birth) gives us a number of short essays and sketches, most of them describing excursions in the Alps, some few dealing with ques- tions of Alpine topography and nomen- clature. The latter will have a special interest for those know the au- thor’s name as being that of the man who is credited with a larger knowledge than probably any other American or Englishman possesses of the history of Alpine exploration and Alpine geogra- phy. His many papers upon these sub- jects, and the library of books and maps throwing light upon them which he has formed, have given him a well-earned distinction not only in Switzerland, who where he has (as we are informed) re- sided for many years, but among Euro- pean students generally. which The volume, is illustrated by good photo- graphs of rock and snow scenery, con- tains twelve chapters describing expedi- tions in the High Alps, four chapters on the history and nomenclature of the mountain region round Monte Rosa, and four “subalpine” chapters on scenes in the lower parts of Switzerland. Of these three sections, the second has the most novelty, and, accordingly, it is to it that what we have to say of the vol- ume will be chiefly directed. Mr. Coolidge truly observes that the names of high mountains were generally used vaguely and loosely, not by early travellers, but also by the people who dwelt near them before the days in only which scientific explorers appeared and regular surveys began to be undertak en. This was especially the case with lofty snow summits like those of the Pennine Alps, because the dwellers in the valleys had little to do with them and because their forms appear quit different as seen in different valleys, especially when the valleys lie on op- posite sides of the great watershed di viding the Swiss Valais from Italy. Ons may, indeed, go so far as to say that the local nomenclature of mountains is min ute and accurate only in countries where the inhabitants are, by their daily life, in actual touch with the ridges and peaks, as happens in countries like Scot- land, where the herdsman drives his sheep or cattle over the hill pastures Mr. Coolidge further remarks—and this is also a general truth—that the names of passes are apt to be fixed sooner than the names of peaks, and that there is often a confusion between the name of the pass and that of the peak. A cen tury ago people still talked of Mount St Bernard or Mount St. Gothard, and the ordinary reader used to suppose that these names denoted peaks, whereas they only expressed the fact that the traveller had to climb a great height to cross the pass. Starting from these general proposi tions, he examines with great care and a copious citation of authorities from many writers, from the middle of the sixteenth century (a few even earlier), the origin of the names of the great summits which we now call Monte Rosa and Matterhorn, and of the pass, lying between the Matterhorn on the west and the Breithorn on the east, which we call the Col de St. Théodule. It take too long to set forth the of the investigation by which Mr. Cool- idge shows that the name Rosa has no- would details thing to do either with any Celtic wora for mountain nor with the rosy light which irradiates the snows at morn and evening, but comes from the word ruez or r0oise or rvesa, which is the local name for a glacier. The ulti- mate etymology he does not attempt to trace, with showing that this is a word native the region. Thus just as Kinchinjanga means the “icy mass,” so “Rosa” is the “ice.”’ Original- content to ly applied to the whole mass of sum- which above bas at last connecting ridges the Monte Moro Arolla, it mits and stretches from Macugnaga to been confined to one small group of peaks at the head of Val Sesia, the highest of which is now usually called by the name of Dufour Spitze. The Théodule pass is shown been known and used from very early times, certainly as far back as the seventh cen but the older writers speak Glacier” (Gletscher), name afterwards ap plied to the Matterhorn), or Mons Cer- to have tury A. D., of it “the Mons Sylvius as or vin, or Mons Matter, and the name St Théodule does not appear before 1688, though, as there already existed on the top an old wooden statue of the Saint (who is the patron of Valais), the pass vas doubtless called after him before that dat Among the descriptions of mountain excursions which occupy the rest of the volume, climbers will probably read with most interest those relating to the Maritime and Cottian Alps, for these regions are even to-day, when Alpine climbing has been fashionable for near- l sixty years, much less visited than are the Swiss or Tyrolese Alps, where the heights are greater, the glaciers longer, and the accommodation far bet- ter Dauphiné, which has a lofty and striking group of peaks, is even to-day poorly supplied with mountain inns, when compared with the other parts of the great chain. Tt Theory of .kvolutior ! R | l Frank, 8. J vith a \r { ts and Termit G | } h War inn, S. J ha t ra i ] +) Ge an by ‘ har! | 1) ' ! br ght out short! K I & Co H Their Origin and ! t t \ rt i Cambrid i il which t Putr s are bringing Bird-Lore for November-D« ber ns the annual r ort of \ ‘ ? \udul a0 rl include I r ' the ght fleld agent nd tw societies The j ileo a de o photograpl of a killd rock ballast of a railway ist thr ind one-half feet from t rail o south-bound track Fro ippeared tha he bird w l D til } roacl K i i fe list ind would i fl i] i r ir ne » the } ! tral had passed A Stitch in Time” (Putnam), prepared by a graduate nurse and a grateful patient,”’ not otherwise named 3 a little book of seventy-five pages likely to be use ful to intelligent readers in time of trou ble It deals, not with surgical stitching but with simple procedures in domestt emergencies apparently too trivial to re quire professional care, or when such help is not readily to be had. There are also many good “receipts” for feeding the sick
Page 24
596 The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 and sick gestion some for the notably a rational sug- the cold bath. As to the directions are generally well the but there of apparently, the rhe of rather lib- take mean- idental advice well, ine good and the on overdoing treatment to seems to suited purpose, be some slip in the matter poisoning by trychnine (page 53), where had mustard as an et! should will need lose of ind that mere ed to nilk; 1uthors opium in mind dose etic is more eral than we Many ing of ded care to give or the calomel explained, readers to have sealing can- in heating stop further digestion only cooling or Musie Drama and abethan Playhouse W. J delphia: J. B net and Othe By Phila Lippincott Co $3 Lawrence, 50 the very active discussion conc rn inge the Elizabet! construction and usages of the Which has been the the a prominent part, and students of will an stage in progress during last or sO, the ten years tuthor of present work has taken the drama welcome this ingather- ing of his most important contributions to this thorny subject. The first article the yet published of our information in regard to the stage of the the deal with is best summary conditions time: remaining articles special questions, as titles “The Situa- Room,” “Title the Pre-Restoration the Eliza- chronologi from their the appears tion of Lords’ and Locality Boards on Stage Music in The list of Elizabethan playhouses at the be- Professor and Song bethan Theatre ete | il d of the article the announcement first was printed of in the requires ‘eulllerat discoveries Loseley accordingly ion in regard to Blackfriars, which, un VSs., and corres it ariiest management, we the third theatres. Fortunate was off the had a preliminary com the . #0 that now to have been in date of Eliza ethan the eulllerat volume press, ‘ published in essol Jai Chronicl main the end of unleation embracing points hia di overt at Mi has been able of article Lawrence vor discussion these mat In we note es eclally the final proof of the occasional em setting (in cer the Blac explana vinent oft multiple rn lrama of Lyly’s) on suggested of the " which came to be applied ta also a to the origin puzzling rivate as to some other Eliza According to this view, the to give dra atic performances in the old monastic fo that theatre nan t he itres rarrant, who was first building of Blackfriars (in 1577), evaded Act of for the regulation of acting within the city by Council” the Common living himself on the premises and avoiding the collection of money at the theatre itself. By pursuing this course, he could call these performances “pri- vate” and so escape the penalties of the above-mentioned act. Hunnis, the next manager, was able to throw off the mask, but the old designation of a “private house” stuck to the place, and was later on applied to still other theatres whose stage conditions and terms of admission were similar. In connection with these Blackfriars matters, one is surprised to find Mr. Lawrence, earlier in the volume, accepting without question Professor Wallace's theory that this theatre in the period of its greatest importance—under the management of Evans—was subsi- dized by the Queen. As regards the author’s general views concerning the Elizabethan stage, may that he is altogether uninfiu- enced by recent writers who are inclined to claim for Elizabethan staging a larg- er element of pictorial illusion than was once thought possible, and who in other respects minimize to a certain extent the archaic features of the stage of the far as the public theatres are concerned, we have no doubt that Mr. Lawrence is right. The stage in such theatres was essentially a platform stage and so afforded little opportunity for pictorial effects. To be sure, there was a rear stage, but, as Prof. G. F. Reynolds has justly argued, every con- sideration of convenience would require that where there were two stages (to say nothing of the third one aloft), the acting should be mainly on the front stage, which fact excludes pictorial {!- lusion as an element of any importance. It seems to us, however, different with the so-called private theatres, from which, and not from the public theatres, the theatre is undoubtedly de- these cases the stage did out into the middle of the audience, and the conditions from the first invited more elaborate furnishings and to a certain degree scenic illusion. Neither Lawrence nor Reynolds appears to consider the possible influence of court performances on the staging of the pri- vate theatres, at least. The documents relating to the Office of Revels, published Feuillerat, show court plays was as anything known to ou?e Shakespeare “revivals,” and hence It is natural that this same French scholar, in his more recent treatise, “Le Bureau des Menus-Plaisirs et la mise en cour d’Elizabeth” (1910), should whether Shakespeare, after having seen one of his plays, e. g., “Love's Labor's Lost,” acted in this man- ner, would not be likely to seek an im- provement of his own stage in the same direction, as far as the resources of his one say period. So modern scended In not project ago by staging in some years that the elaborete as modern la ask sefne A company permitted Among the conclusions relating to the Elizabethan stage which the author ar- ! | rives at in this volume, we note the fol- lowing: That the titie of the play of the day was commonly announced on a board set up in sight of the audience, but that boards indicating the locality of the scene were only sparingly used. Indeed, the Elizabethans did not shrink from wholly unlocated scenes. Further- more, there were normally intervals be. tween acts, though brief; inter-act song, dance, and even music seem confined, however, to the private theatres—only in regard to music were there occasion- al exceptions. Mr. Lawrence lays stress, moreover, on the multiple or simulta- neous setting, which was common on the court stage of Elizabeth’s day, as it had been in the Middle Ages. Feuillerat had already recognized this principle, but by neglecting it, R. Warwick Bond, the editor of Lyly, has seriously mis- represented the staging of that writer's plays. We have only touched on the more articles in the work before us, important are a number of others, like but there that on the mounting of masques in the reign of Charles I, the early history of French players in England, which de- serve attention. The volume is beauti- fully printed, and its value is enhanced by a series of admirable illustrations. Israel Zangwill’s play, “The Next Re- ‘‘eion.” which was treated with a good deal of deference by the English critics when it was produced in London some months ago, now appears in book form (Macmillan), but is not likely to prove more impressive in print than it did upon the stage. it con- tains much witty and satirical writing, sev- eral effective situations of a dramatic and pathetic kind, some vigorous assaults upon dogmatic theology, but is strangely deficieat n the two qualities, clearness of conviction and evident sincerity of purpose, without which a work of this kind can have no sub- stantial value, That it should offer nothing new in the way of argument on one side or the other is not particularly surprising, for the themes chosen for discussion have been debated along almost every imaginable line, but the fact that it might have been written by an agnostic, a Hebrew, or a professing serious dramatic Christian constitutes a and artistic defect. Mr. Zangwill’s hero is a liberal-mind- ed clergyman of the Protestant Episco- pal Church—the story, though ingenious, calls for no detailed analysis—who has lost all faith in his professional creed, and even in the possibility of a future existence. Be- ing honest, he refuses to cherish his flock upon fond delusions, resigns his and starts out as the prophet of a new religion, based on the facts of science and aiming at the establishment of a heaven upon earth through the agency of brotherly love and universal altruistic endeavor, By the aid of an agnostical millionaire, he is enabled to found a magnificent cathedral, with a sumptuous ritual of his own invention, which attracts crowds. He is encouraged to believe that his most comprehensive ideals are about to be realized, when his only son, whom he had trained to be his successor, post,
Page 25
Dec. 19. 1912] ‘The Nation — is murdered by a crazy fanatic, faith in his own convictions is proof even against this blow, but his wife, a religious devotee, who has followed his fortunes with self-sacrificing fidelity, rebels when he de- nies to his dead son the hope of resurrec- tion, and, although he remains steadfast, the play ends upon a note of triumphant evangelical inspiration. In her case, at least—and from first to last she is the the- atricalantidote to her husband’s chill philos- ophy—the next religion is a hollow fallacy. Possibly Mr. Zangwill meant to imply that woman’s faith is less intellectual and more emotional than man’s. or that superstition is proof against the light of reason, or that the craving after immortality is deeply rooted in human nature. Or, again, he may have wished to demonstrate the superiority of pure reason to all emotional weakness. A fable capable of so many interpretations is of small account in the theatre. More- over, the play, with all its cleverness and occasional eloquence, often shallow, tricky, and theatrical, and in places i!!- informed. modern utterly fan- tastic. Mr. Zangwill evidently knows little of the elasticity of the later theology. Even the arguments of his skeptics are sadly old- fashioned. Ne sutor supra crepidam is a proverb of which a scholar should be heed- ful, and the heat of argument the skilful will hesitate wouad the religious susceptibilities of his opponent. is Some of the dogmas ascribed to Episcopalianism are even in disputant to Some of Mr. Zangwill’s utterances may or may not be pertinent, but they are in ex- ecrable taste. Such raw crudity defeats its own object. One of the most flagrant sins recently committed in the way of dramatic adapta- tion is Porter Emerson Browne's transfor- mation of the “Chains” of Elizabeth Ba- ker, produced in the Criterion Theatre. The original piece attracted much attention in London, as a study of the hopeless condi- tion of millions of the lower middle classes. The hero, clerk to a big corporation, feels that he is doomed to lifelong servitude, without any hope of independence, and longs to emigrate to some newer country where his energies may have wider scope. But his wife, whom he cannot afford to take with him, and all her relatives oppose his desire bitterly. Finally he decides to get away secretly, but he learns that his wife will soon be a mother, and he, therefore, abandons all idea of escape and resigns himself to a life-time of dreary routine. These domestic and social responsibilities are the chains, according to Miss Baker, which bind men to slavery. Mr. comedy, purporting to be founded upon Miss Baker's, is a clumsy travesty of it, with an inverted moral. The conversion of the characters into Americans, with a corre- sponding change of scene, inevitably plays havoc with the quality and design of a piece dealing exclusively with British con- ditions, but the climax of Mr. Browne's artistic offence is that, for the sake of a happy ending, he has made nonsense of the whole, by making the impending birth the beginning of a new era of happiness, in- stead of—ag the author intended—a crown- ing calamity. Moreover, he has vulgarized a serious work by much trite and foolish humor. The philosophy of Miss Baker's Browne's play is not, perhaps, impregnable, but that His stoical | is no reason why it should be exposed to such utter misrepresentation. Next season Mabel Taliaferro and her sis- ter, Edith Taliaferro, will be joint stars under the management of Joseph Brooks. They will be early in in New York in a drama now being written for them. seen September According to a statistician, there have been since 1875 no fewer than 171 women composers in the larger forms. The num- ber of women who compose songs and piano pieces is not given. The number of pianos imported last year into the United Kingdom was 18,508, valued at $2,733,712. A preponderant proportion of these were imported from Germany, the German piano being very popular and en- tering into successful competition witd those made in England. Comparatively few ,of this number were products of the United these It pianos is to produce States. said that 18,508 in England would quired the labor of 3,000 workmen in twen have re- ty factories, working on full time with wages at $5.73 per week, a total of $1,- 459,950 for labor At the conclusion of the London Philhar monic Society’s last concert, in the course of which Mr. Harold Bauer played the solo part of Beethoven's concerto in G major and subsequently Brahms’s “Walzer” (op 39), the artist was presented, at a gathering of the members of the Society, with the Beethoven gold medal Mr. J. C. Ames made the presentation on behalf of the committee, and Mr. Bauer, in returning thanks, told how deeply he was moved by having attained the ambition of his boy- hood. The only other living pianists upon whom the distinction has been conferred are Paderewski and Sauer. Parry has of a It is rumored that Sir Hubert been contemplating the foundation chamber-music club, at which members will be assured of finding the ingredients of a trio or a quartet. The orchestral parts in Richard Strauss’s operas are reckoned the most difficult ever written. To make them conveniently ac cessible to students who want to improve their technique, the Berlin publisher, Adolph Fiirstner, has printed the parts in separate volumes at three marks each, 80 that every violinist, ‘cellist, flute, or clari- net player, trumpeter, and so on, may have what concerns him. Even the kettledrum, glockenspiel, and xylophone players have a volume all to themselves. Teresa Carrefio continues to arouse en- thusiasm by her playing in various Euro- pean countries, and she nearly always puts on her programme a piece by her pupil, Fdward MacDowell. Madrid seems to be kind to musicians, foreign as well as domestic. The pianist, Edouard Risler, for example, is giving no fewer than eight recitals there this season, the famous Rosen Quartet will give six concerts next February, at which all of Beethoven's quartets will be played. The Madrid Orchestra and it is said that Sebastian in summer the gambling rooms are always emptied during the concert hours. The conductor of this orchestra has decided to take it for a visit to Paris while popular institution, it is a when plays at San NATIONAL ACADEMY OF DESIGN, The opening of the Winter Exhibition of the National Academy in the same week in which the tong-heralded Scan- exhibited sug- If nothing more, it dinavian pictures were gests comparison. brings up in passing the old question concerning the verity of the art of our countrymen as a national product. A radical readjustment of the artistic point of view is necessary in order to take pleasure in both the Scandinavian Exhibition, dominated as it is by new and restricting conventions, and the National Academy, where that phase of art which makes for serenity and charm and adheres to the beauty of line and surface is still much in evidence. The Academy is not rife with restless experi- mentation just now, buf*a positive an- swer to the question as to the American quality of American art comes clear and unmistakable in many different notes. An obvious indication of this nation- al spirit is manifest in the growing at- tention the ol Western scenery; but, indications of the same spirit wanting. The very atmosphere of the landscapes in general—thin, bright, and bestowed on interpretation in truth, larger are not clear—and their strongly decorative character expressed through this rare- fied atmospheric medium, are of this country as of no other. And in the fig- ures—particularly the portraits, of course—the national types are marked. In this latest Academy Exhibition, as in almost all miscellaneous collections, even the wayfarer may distinguish, without need of catalogue confirmation, the work of well-known artists. John W. Alexander’s contribution is thus read- ily discovered. It is called A Meadow Flower, and is the portrait of a young girl, painted with a subtly woven color harmony of great delicacy and beauty. Another easily recognizable picture is William Chase’s gorgeous still life, im- peccable in its glitter of fish scales, its splendidly placed lobster, and dark, rich gleam of copper. It is not so easy to attribute to him, off-hand, the ponder- ous elegance and faultless technique of the portrait with which he has won the Proctor prize, but once the fact is known, it seems inevitable that he should have painted the picture. Colin Campbell Cooper does not disguise his style by shifting from aspiring cathe- drals and skyscrapers, enveloped in smoke and steam, to the low, broad arches and strong horizontal lines of the Ponte Vecchio, with the soft roman- tic richness of an Italian sky. It is a joy to see again Wilton Lockwood's Peonies, delicately pink and white and perfect. E. Irving Couse’s Indians are easy to recognize when once their acquaintance
Page 26
598 is mad give us pictorial reminders of the bet- ter aspects of a weakened and fast-van- ishing race. But the Indians of Mr. Couse’s pictures are so archwologically correct, so well-placed for the best ef- fect on the canvas, that one may be par- doned a backward thought of Sir Fred- erick Leighton’s immaculate and im- pressive forms and compositions. This is not to deny warmth and life to Mr. Couse’s figures. Gardner Symons’s iden- tity with his picture is more difficult to guess. The Bridge and Winter Sunshine be or it might be Red- but sunshine wonderful, icy stream and violet shad- ows remarkable, and the carrying qual- unexcelled in the Exhibition. It is a sort of tour de force in technique, and It is a happy thought thus te might Symons's field's the is the snow ity interesting as such. Across the room John Carlson's Gray Woods gives a quieter, more restful aspect of the snow crossed by the brown trunks and bare branches of the forest trees. It speaks rather of nature than of the vision of the artist, though the latter is unaggressively there. Two other landscapes, not far away, by William Wendt and Daniel Garber, are notice- able for the poetry of the painter's in- terpretation of nature, with their dark green pattern of trees in the foreground, the golden middle distance, and the wa- ter that, in its reflections, makes the sky justly part of the picture. the line Mr. Garber’s land- scape is a quiet little interior by Louis Berneker, reminiscent of Dewing, if you like, but with much charm and faithful rendering in tone and composition. Chere are a number of pictures that an integral On above are interesting as types of girlhood as well Joseph artist's methods. and as or the Alvira unusual Trotta’s Tessie and something have something sensitive in the of Venetian in the warmly harmonious col countenance, cast or, and something quite the artist’s own in the simple, certain, and adequate modelling Helen Pauline American type of girl, painted with in- arrange- effec- ver- rurner’s is a sturdy simplification and pleasing and composition. The the dress telligent ment that make a tive decorative tical lines of the trim- ming, and the bird-cage wires, the sub- of color to pose, dued figures giving a note the background, leading up to the more intense color of the birds in the cage, all nerve a setting of distinction for Pauline’s vivid gypsy-like beauty. Charles W. Hawthorne's The Rose re- calle the great days of English portrat- ture, In the color composition and in the character of the face, not to mention the artist's methods with his paint, which put him always with the masters of his craft. In the Girl in Green, M. Jean McLane has successfully achieved a _ difficult shadow effect and an English feeling of to make out-of-doors. Hubbell’s English The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 pre- Raphaelite children ought to awaken keener interest than they do, for there is good work in them, and the same thing is true, in a different way, of Barse’s pink girl called Youth, and of John Johansen’s Village Rider. They do not justify their size. Frieseke’s picture called Youth gives evidence of much skill in painting, in a high key, the whites of drapery and flesh, but the rococo effect of twisted lines and many unrelated things mars, with a feeling of unrest, the pleasure it should give. Blumenschein, in the picture that takes the Isador prize for figure com- position, has given an original, decided- ly American yet classically dignified rendering of the subject, Three Ages of Man, which he calls, however, Wise Man, Warrior, and Youth. Annie Traquair Lang’s Gray Kimono is extremely well painted as to textures, flesh, and tone. The interest of the pic- ture is heightened by the American type of woman—nervous and anxious— that wears the Japanese garb. In Marines, Paul Dougherty has out- rivalled himself in his granite shore and quiet water that speaks the calm before the storm. Henry Snell and Frederick Waugh have delicate color effects of water in contrast with the chalk cliffs of Eng- land, and the flat wave-worn rocks of the Maine coast. John Benson expresses the resistless power of the waves and William Ritschel their softer aspects on the Monterey coast. In the many landscapes there is great cleverness; much technical knowledge is displayed and usually a definitely decorative design apparent. Some- times this is attained by taking nature as the artist finds it, sometimes by se- lection and arrangement, and by one or another of these means many moods and phases of feeling are vividly in- tensified for the ordinary observer. In of the disadvantage of crowded and the many impressions that succeed one another too rapidly for real esthetic pleasure, the excellence and va- riety of the landscape part of the Exhi- bition are very noticeable. Leonard Ochtman and Charles Rosen have deli- cate tones with feeling for nature's quiet moods of Spring and Winter. Ernest Lawson's Palisades is full of the poetry of evening. Charles Eaton Warren's | Among the Dunes gives a gray day’s dreariness with interest. Granville-| Smith's The Old Stone Bridge shows! color organization and unity. A little | timidity in handling does not keep the picture from having much merit. De Witt Parshall’s Abyss of Shadows gives the ghostly rock formations of the mighty Canyon of the Colorado with the shadows of night around them. He expresses by a suggestive glimpse more is spite walls, successfully than most, something of the | awe which that restless, illusive depth inspires in the mind of man. L. E. 8. To the attractive “Little Books on Art,” published by McClurg, are added “Ben- venuto Cellini,” by Robert H. Hobart Cust, and “Rodin,” by Muriel Ciolkowska. Both are illustrated. Mr. Cust’s task reduces itself to the obvious and not quite grate- ful one of condensing the incomparable autobiography. This version may be use- ful to those who are unable to bear the moral shock of reading the original. Oth- erwise its utility is not apparent. The book on Rodin is written in a spirit of un- qualified adoration, is clear and fairly com- plete—an excellent short cut to the volu- minous writing that gathers about the mas- ter of Meudon. It was perhaps hardly to be expected that an enthusiast should admit or even perceive the serious falling off in Rodin’s work in recent years. It still re- mains for criticism fairly to estimate this great and baffling personality in whom su- preme sanity and soundest workmanship often lapse into ‘the merely capricious or positively morbid. Posterity may well date this decadence from the Balzac. Unques- tionably a work of genius, it represents genius that has strangeiy lost its bearings. This is an informing and well constructed little book. Reynolds, Gainsborough, Romney, Turner, Constable, Landseer, and Watts are the themes of F. J. Rowbotham’'s “Story Lives of Our Great Artists” (Stokes). Here is a fluent and sufficiently agreeable compila- tion of an anecdotal sort. Why Landseer is in and Hogarth, surely the greatest of Bri- tish artists, out, does not appear. It is a book for such as must take their art plen- tifully sugar-coated with obvious human interest. “The Colonial Homes of Philadelphia and its Neighborhood” (Lippincott), by Harold Donaldson Eberlein and Horace Mather Lippincott, will naturally appeal most strongly to Philadelphians, but the gen- eral reader, too, will find it a book of great charm. The sketches are arranged geo- graphically without any special effort to earry a connecting thread of narrative, or, to apply the remark of a Quaker, “They begin with Front Street and end with Lau- rel Hill, as all good Philadelphians should.” In Colonial dayg, the built-up portion of the city extended no further west than Seventh Street, and it is in this small sec- tion one must look for the city houses dat- iag from that period. In view of the many years this region has been deserted by fashion and given over to offices, it is re- markable how many charming Colonial homes have remained. But they are grad- ually being cut into, and in a few years they will have disappeared. The old Cad- wallader house, at Fourth and Locust Streets, has been purchased by an insurance company, in the few brief months since the authors have completed their work. Their book will soon therefore be most valuable as a record. The revival of Colonial archi- tecture will give it special interest to many, as the views, particularly the interiors, represent the purest and best types. Equally truthful are the descriptions of the social life in old Philadelphia in Revo- lutionary times. Dining in those days was
Page 27
Dec. 19. 1912] a formidable function in Philadelphia. Three o'clock in the afternoon was the usu- al hour selected, and the list of viands might well account for the considerable prevalence of the gout among present-day descendants. Here is an entry from the diary of John Adams, made while he was stopping in that city: “Sept. &th—Dined at Mr. Powel’s a most sinful feast again! Everything which could delight the eye or allure the taste.” Philadelphia wasa solid, peace-loving, feast-loving Quaker so- ciety. If the city life lacked something of the spirituality and” idealism of the Colo- nial New England cities, the country life, which grew up on the banks of the rivers and creeks near by, had a charm peculiarly its own. Even the Hudson could scarcely excel the charm of the Schuylkill, lined from Bartram’s Garden to Laurel Hill with delightful country seats. Nor were these merely stately homes. Almost without ex- ception they housed men famous in the life | of the nation. Such names as John Bar- tram, Judge Peters, Benedict Arnold, and Tohn Penn (the poet) have a truly national importance. Nearly all of these Colonial seats have been purchased by the city and preserved with utmost fidelity to the past. The writers’ style is admirably adapted to their theme, but it is perhaps to be gretted that they of their narrative by the genealogical in- formation scattered through the text, which adds nothing to the value of the book for the general public. There were many pic- re- turesque characters in those days, and amusing anecdotes could have been intro- duced in its stead. Mary Elizabeth Tillinghast, artist in Stained glass and designer of many well- known windows, died on Sunday. Miss Til- linghast was born in New York and studied art in Paris under Carolus Duran and Hen- ner. Since 1882 she had been an artist in Stained glass, and at one time was asso- ciated with John La Farge. She received a gold medal at the Chicago Exposition in 1893. Among her most important works area stained-glass portrait of Mrs. James Brown Potter as Charlotte Corday; the Gould win- dow, presented by Mrs. Russell Sage to the Home for Friendless Children in honor of the work of Miss Helen Gould; the Hut- ton window in Grace Church; the Revoca- tion of the Edict of Nantes, in the New York Historical Society's building; an as- tronomical and window, Urania, in the new Allegheny and mural decorations in the café of the Hotel Savoy. classical Observatory, Finance THE “MONEY TRUST.” The declining prices and the atmo- sphere of despondency, which for a fortnight past have prevailed on both home and foreign stock exchanges, are primarily to be ascribed to the prevalent | world-wide money stringency. It might! perhaps be doubted whether Wall Street | impaired the continuity | The Nation a tariff readjustment. But the point to observe is, that even such incidents as ;these are judged very largely in the light of the stock market’s actual con- dition, and a market's condition is bound to be in the main unfavorable when money is hard to borrow. Just now, all the European banks are guarding their reserves with a view to the large external demand for gold—a consequence both of the recent war dis- turbance and of the prosperous trade throughout the world. Our own market, straitened by the demands of the pros- perous interior at this month's climax of trade activity, cannot resort to Eu- rope for relief. This hampers the inter- ests, large and small, which buy stocks |}on the market, but it does not restrain the sellers. That very largely explains the violence of the recent declines, on news which, in a normal money market, would have been taken with equanimity. On such occasions, something always |happens to give special ground for a market’s apprehensions and misgivings, and in the present instance, quite apart from Balkan disputes and Supreme Court decisions, it is undeniable that the financial atmosphere, so far as regards Wall Street itself, has been further ob- scured by the proceedings in the “Mon- ey Trust” investigation. It must frankly be admitted that at least a part of such apprehension may actually have existed over that in- cuiry was due to the fact that some un pleasant truths were publicly brought out this week. Wall Street itself has cer- tainly not been unobservant of the ten- dency in the matter of progressive con- solidation of banking resources in this city. That movement, in a sense, stood by itself. But Wall Street has chafed under the programme of stock- market manipulation on a prodigious scale, conducted with utter disregard cf all ulterior consequences except the manipulators’ personal winnings. It has seen even the Bank of England pub- licly oppose the indirect placing of Eng- lish capital at the service of such under- takings. It has indulged in a good deal of angry muttering, when some of the most offensively notorious of these ma- nipulations were known to have been conducted by an individual placed in an office of high t.ust and responsibility in as also ithe banking and credit field. These considerations were so weil known that most of the Washington tes timony was to Wall Street nothing more than a thrice-told tale. Sooner or later, every serious-minded man knew that | there must be a reform which would at least abate the worst of these financial abuses. But the particular uneasiness with which this week's public evidence was received arose from the circum- and Europe would accept that explana-| stances under which it was this time tion as complete. the Balkan dispute, the Supreme Court's | They would point to) told. It was elicited when the public mind Southern Pacific decision, the coming| bad been so inflamec, by a long series of -) Y 9 sweeping and irresponsible declama tions in the yellow newspapers and the cheap magazines, that the people at large had seemingly become unable to distinguish between real evils which can be and ought to be abated, and imaginary dangers which do not exist, and for which there is therefore no cure. ‘the outg'vings of the La Follettes, the l.indberghs, and the Henrys, on their conceptions of the “Money Trust,” have been so wildly extravagant that the sim- plest and plainest incidents of finance, wholly isolated in character from the abuses above referred to, have been in- stantly ascribed to gigantic conspiracy. A policy of very doubtful wisdom for imposing compulsory charges on collec- tion of out-of-town checks; the practice of disciplining ill-managed banks through clearing-house supervision; the exercise of powers by the Stock Exchange in refusing quotations to securities; the use of Government ds necessary posits to relieve a highly dangerous money crisis on the stock market as well as in the general fleld of credit—all of these things, which were perfectly or- dinary incidents of banking, im puted to unprincipled and wicked Unhappily, the nature of the com- earlier cross-examinations sich as to add its own constant uation that effect. All rences were made to bear the mark of the Beast, precisely as, in last spring's Congressional debates, the fall in ton and the rise in wheat were the work were mo tives. mittee’s was insin these to occu! cot- of the malign Money Trust, and precis ly as, in the Populist party’s day of the early nineties, the Money Power was de- clared to be supporting the gold stan dard of currency merely to enslave the world. The general of tion, therefore, is a mixed bundle many true and many entirely investiga of result this in ferences, fallacious, which hardly fit either com mittee or Congress or the public to ap- proach the general question properly to day. Yet, of all problems in the world, the problem of dealing with the bank- ing, credit, and Stock Exchange machin ery of the nation is the most delicate, and calls for the largest experience and practical wisdom, if we are not to walk the path of futility and blunder. This being so, it is fortunate that the litical situation, in the last weeks of an expiring Congress, is such that no one expects a serious effort to take the mat ter up now for legislation. po BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Alexander, F. G. Wayfarers in the Libyan Desert. Putnam. American Scenic and Historic Preservatior Society. Seventeenth Annual Report tv the Legislature, State of New York. (N 154 Nassau Street, New York.) Barrett, Michael. Up in Ardmuirland. Ben- ziger Bros. $1.25 net. Birdsall, Ralph. Sermons in Summer Cooperstown, N. Y Arthur H. Crist Co. $1.
Page 28
600 The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2477 Catholic Encyclopedia. Vol. XV, Tourn- Zwirner, Errata R. Appleton Charles, R. H Fragments of a Zadokite Work. Trans. from the Cambridge He- brew text. Frowde. Clarke, H. A. Browning and His Century. Doubleday, Page. $1.50 net. Clay, A. T. Personal Names from Cunel- form Inscriptions of the Cassite Period. New Haven: Yale University Press. $2 net Cramp, W. 8. The Two Gods. Boston: Badger. $1.25 net. Dewson, G. E The Right of the Child to Be Well Born net Diggs, A. L Bedrock lal Center Pub. Co. Funk & Wagnalls. 75 cents Detroit, Mich.: So- Duncan, W. B Immortality and Modern Thought Poston: Sherman, French. $1 net Earle, Ferdinand. The Lyric Year: One Hundred Poems, edited. Mitchell Kenner- ley $2 net. Edgar, Lady \ Colonial Governor in Maryland: Horatio Sharpe and His Times, 17 177 Longmans. $3.50 net Elwell, J. B. Auction Bridge. New edition enlarged Scribner. $1.25 net Francis, M. E. The Book of Grasses. Dou- bleday, Page $4 net. Goodwin, G. D Horizon Songs Boston: Sherman, French $1.25 net Graves, J. A. Out of Doors, California and Oregon Los Angeles: Grafton Pub. Co. Hard P. Mes Loisirs. Paris: Librairie \ P ind Hark Lu Syndicalism. Dodge Publish- ( 1) cents net fr — —COOLEY’S = Principles of Science Ry WILLIAM FORBES COOLEY, In- structor in Philosophy in Columbia University. v+245 pp. 12mo. $1.25. Th duction to textbook for college courses in intro- lu philosophy has grown out of the ond half-year’s work in the course at) Columbia, the first semester of which is de- voted to logi It should appeal especially to scientific students It carries on the student's study of logic and, assuming only such knowledge in general as he may properly be expected to have, it directs his inquiry along the lines of the principles of science to the fundamental problems of philosophy. The opening discussion of the basic intellectual methods of science is fresh and illuminating The value of the book as a class text is greatly increased by the provision of a num- ber of exercises at the end of each chapter, of science devised to stimulate originality in the student by application of the prin- ciples just discussed 84 W.83 Bt. Henry Holt&Co. , New York Harris, Frank. Mitchell Kennerley. $2 net. Hill, J. McK. Practical Cooking and Serv- | | Peeke, G. H. The Spiritual Body in Re- ing. Doubleday, Page. $1.50 net. Holt, cett, the Blind Postmaster-General England: For Children. sociation for the Blind. Hulbert, J. R. Menasha, Wis.: George Banta Pub. Co. Irwin, Florence. The Development of Auc- tion Bridge under the New Count. Put- nam. $1 net. Journals of the Continental Congress, 1774- | 1789. Vol XIX, 1781. Washington: ernment Printing Office. Key, Ellen. The Woman Movement. nam. La Farge, John. Reminiscences of the South Seas. Doubleday, Page. Lamborn, E. T. Edith’s Silver Comb, and Other Stories for Children. Philadelphia: Biddle Press. 75 cents net. Lindsey, F. B. The Spirit Prospero, and 25 cents net. Put- | Winifred. A Short Life of Henry Faw- | of | New York As- Chaucer’s Official Life.| Railton, G. S. The Authoritative Life of The Women of Shakespeare. Owen, W. B. The Humanities in the Educa- tion of the Future. Boston: Shermaa, French. $1.25 net. lation to the Divine Law of Life. Bos- ton: Badger. $1.50 net. Phillips, F. F. Idylls Beside the Strand. Boston: Sherman, French. $1 net. Gen. William Booth. Doran. $1 net. Richardson, H. H. Maurice Guest: Roman. Zwei bande. Berlin: S. Fischer Verlag. | Robbins, Tod. The Spirit of the Town. Gov- | | Russell, | | Other Poems. Boston: Sherman, French. $1 net. McLaren, W. D. Our Growing Creed. Scribner. Mead, L. A. Swords and Ploughshares. ; Foreword by Baroness von Suttner. Put- nam. Moritzen, Julius. The America. Putnam. Narratives of Captivity Among the Indians of North America: A List of Books and Manuscripts in the FE. E. Ayer Collection of the Newberry Library, Chicago. Nevinson, H. W. Dodge Publishing Co Peace Movement of 20 cents net. THE CAT Edited By AGNES REPPLIER collection with a charming essay, Miss Repplier has here brought together her favorite passages in literature devoted to the eat. A dainty and attractive gift- book. 16mo. THE MAN WHO Prefixing this Illustrated. $1.00 net. CAME BACK By JOHN FLEMING WILSON Author of “The Land Claimers,” etc. The story of a young man spoiled by wealth and dissipation who “strikes bottom” in a Shanghai slum. How the prodigal “comes back,” bring- ing the fatted calf with him, is what this tale tells. 12mo. Illustrated. Tic STURGIS & WALTONCO. Shakespeare, Bacon, 81-33 East 27th Street, New York. and the Great Unknown By ANDREW LANG. With 8 full- Books page Plates. 8vo. $8.00 net. WOODROW WILSON (Postage 16 cents.) wineneatend Government. A Study ‘ ' The Bacontan and Ant in American Politics. $1.25. \“ ' , tlor Milence’’ bout hom wg, Mere Literature, and Other Essays. Mel i“ Shakespeare Mr (hurton $1.50. . - pneu “2 —— ua vat Pa For sale everywhere. I I Labour Lost''-—Contem HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., 4 Park St.,Boston Ihe tlor f will as Author ! n f Phiiiy Ilenslowe The 1 ] fs keapenre Iile Monument é ! A, . rr . be = eH A ' , of Celebrities Bought and Sold. a a Tceaataeindiete ati Send for price lists pote yy ew «5 wlograp WalterR. Renjamin,225 SthAv.,N.Y. pendix 1., Chettle’s Supposed Allusion to Letters ESTABLISHED 1887, W Shakepere Index Pub. “THE COLLECTOR.” $1 4 yr. A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. A new Longmans, Green, & Co. | catalogue of second-hand Americana, now ready, and will be sent to any address. The Growth of Freedom. ' 20 Vesey Street J. S. Ogilvie Pub. Co. $1. B. L. The Gold. (Poems.) Bos- ton: Sherman, French. $1 net. Sidney, P., and Languet, H. Correspon- dence, edited by W. A. Bradley. Boston: The Merrymount Press. Simpson, E. B. The Robert Louis Stevenson Originals. Scribner. Sleight, M. B. At the Manor. Fenno & Co. $1.25. Sombart, Werner, Krieg und Kapitalismus; Luxus und Kapitalismus. Miinchen: Duncker & Humblot. Strong, Rowland. Sensations of Paris. McBride, Nast. $2.50 net. Trine, R. W. The Winning of the Best. Dodge Publishing Co. 75. cents net. Wetmore, M. N. Index Verborum Catullia- nus. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press. $2 net. Whicher, G. M. and G. F. On the Tibur Road. Revised edition. Princeton Uni- $1. Geschichte der Indischen Zweiter Band, Erst Halfte. Amelangs Verlag. versity Press. Winternitz, M. Litteratur. Leipzig: C. F. DE ORBE NOVO THE EIGHT DECADES OF PETER MARTYR D’ANGHIERA Translated from the Latin with Notes and Introduction by Francis stus MaecNatt, Author of “Bartholomew de las Cases,’’ ‘‘Fernando Cortes and the Conquest of Mexico,’’ etc. Letterpress Edition. Limited to 350 num- bered sets. 2 wols. Swvo. Illustrated. $12.50 net; carriage 50 cents. A typical Italian of the most bril- liant period of the Renaissance, Pcter Martyr was a learned, classical scholar, an acute observer and philo- sophical commentator, and an accom- plished courtier. Mr. MacNutt has ably rendered the original text into fluent and readable English: Briefly, graphically, and impressively he in- treduces to us the man behind the author. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS NEW YORK LONDON SAMPLE COPIES THE NATION will be sent to any address for several weeks WITHOUT CHARGE ADDRESS THE NATION New York City