The Nation 1912-08-01: Vol 95 Iss 2457

Page 1

VOL. XCV—NO. 2457 The THURSDAY, AUGUST. 1912 Reg. U. 8 pat. Ofiee. PRICE TEN CENTS WORKS BY ANDREW LANG HISTORY OF ENGLISH Crown 8vo. 710 pages. $1.7 CONTENTS: Patt II. Part I. bethan and Jacobean Literature. 8vo. Modern Mythology. &vo. FROM ‘BEOWULF’ TO SWINBURNE By 5 net. Chaucer to Shakespeare. LITERATURE THE BOOK Mrs. Anprew Lanc. Edited by ANprew Lanc Just ready. With 12 Col 1 Plates and 18 other Illustrations by . ° 1] | & } ley ¢ . , } ; Early and Mediaeval Literature. J. Forp, Crown | Gilt Edges. $1.60 net Part III. Eliza- ey Vearly read Part IV. Eighteenth The Homeric Hymns. A New Prose Translation, and Century Literature. Part V. Nineteenth Century Essays Literary and Mythological Itustrated with 7 Literature. Photogravures and 7 Half-tone Subjects after the At tique Crown &vo $2.0« The Mystery of Mary Stuart. With 6 Photogravur: Plates (4 Portraits) and 15 other Illustrations. Crown The World of Homer. With 14 Illustr: s. Rvo &vo S2 50 Net, $: Prince Charles Edward Stuart, the Young Chevalier. Letters on Literature, Crown 8vo $1.00 With Photogravure Frontispiece. Crown 8vo. Net, $2.25 Old Friends: Essays in Epistolary Parody. Crown &v« Historical Mysteries. By Anprew Lanc. 8vo. With $1.00 Photogravure Frontispiece. Net, $2.50 Adventures Among Books. With Photogravure Portrait John Knox and the Reformation. With 2 Photogravure after Sir W. B. Ricumonp, R.A. Crown 8vo. Net, $1.60 Plates and 3 other Illustrations. S8&vo Net, $3.50 : ; P , : To ga oks an ook Se 2 Colored Plates and 17 The Maid of France: Being the Story of the Life and gag ten he: "Coon aut lored Pla a 2 = Death of Jeanne D’Arc. With 3 Portraits and 3 Maps . rt? ’ Net, $3.50 $3.00 New Collected Rhymes. Ballades and Rhymes. OF SAINTS AND HEROES Crown &v Net, $1.25 From “Ballades in Blue China” The Secret of the Totem. With Symbolical cover design and “Rhymes a la Mode.”” Icap. 8vo Net, $0.60 by H. J. Forp. 8vo. Net, $3.00 Ballads and Lyrics of Old France. Net, $0.75 Magic and Religion. 8vo. Net, $3.50 Sir Walter Scott and the Border Minstrelsy. 8vo The Making of Religion. Crown 8vo $2.00 Net, $1.60 Myth, Ritual, and Religion. 2 vols. Crown 8vo. $2.50 A Monk of Fife: A Romance of the Days of Jeanne The Book of Dreams and Ghosts. Crown 8vo $1.25 D'Arc. Done into English from the manuscript in arated 7" the Scots College of Ratisbon With Illustrations Cock Lane and Common Sense: A Series of Papers yon er 26 Crown &8vo. $1.25 ' . ' stm Tales of Troy and Greece. With 1 Full-page Illustra be ey With 7 lull-page pHustratsone by tions specially drawn for the book by H. J. Forp, and oP en — Te pt.50 a Map. Square crown &vo. Ornamental Cover. Angling Sketches. With Illustrations by W. S. Bur . Net, $1.50. By mail, $1.62 Murpocu. Crown 8vo $1.2 THE FAIRY BOOK SERIES, EDITED BY ANDREW LANG All Sorts of Storles Book........ Net of 60 Brown Fairy Bo Net 1.6 Rel Book of Heroes Vet 1.4 The Animal Story Book. owe Crimson Fairy Book : Vet 1.60 He Fairy Book 2 00 Red Book of Animal Stories Green Fairy Book 2.00 \ Fairy Book Vet 100 Dn DEED cocneaedscossececes ; Grey Fairy Book .. 2 OO Yellow Fats Somok 2 Book of Princes and Princesses...Net 1.60 Lilac Fairy Book . ; Vet 1.60 Blue Poetr Book 2 00 Book of Romance ..........+..+.. Net 1.60 Olive Fairy Book .... : Vet 1.00 I Story Book 200 Red Book of Romance ...... -Net 1.60 Orange Fairy Book R éeee : Vet 1.60 The Red True Stor I b 2 On Blue Fairy Book , , .ccssccsseessees 2.00 Cae ee GE lbtccccens 2.00 My Own I Book 20 Fourth Ave. and 30th St. Longmans, Green, & Co. NEW YORK Educational Educational Educational orrist School Morristown, N. J. Col- | HOROUGH AND EFFECTIVE PREPARA- “HE URSU 73 ’ uy p. M own lege Preparatory Boarding | tion for college by an experienced tutor _ - e ane a pone hy ’ A. HOME. School for Boys. Small classes. Supervised sports ; Highest references WALTER B. WATERMAN, 7 ad phe, « a oa my ef new evemnasium. Lower School for boys 10 to 14. Advisory Board—President Hibben, Prince- ton; Dean Hurlbut, Harvard; Rev. Anson Phelps Stokes, Jr., Secretary of Yale; Prof. Hallock, Co. lumbia; President Pr . Carnegie Foundation. ETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Bethlehem, Pa. ere for leading col- leges. Catalogue, H. N. FOERING, B.8., Principal. THE BRIARCLIFF SCHOOL FOR LITTLE GIRLS A boarding and day school for girls under fifteen. Address Mrs. FRANCES MARSHALL, Principal, Briarclif? Manor, N. Y. | A.M., 214 Boylston Street, Boston, Mase HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. ¢ Co., Proprietors. } , Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av., NewYork 610 Swetiand Bd.,Portland 814 Steger Bd..Chicago 2343 DouglasBd4., LosAngeles 920 Sav.Bk.Bd.,.Denver 2345 Wright Bik., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual Harlan P. French, Pro THE ALBANY EACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex perience in bringing together good teachers and schools. 81 Chapel St.. Albany, N. YY. Ask or bulletin 20 and see for yourself. Vincent B. Fisk. Mer situated on the outskirts of Middletown, New York also accepts young ladies and children during the summer months, and carefully provides for their protection and comfort. Students, who wish to cancel College or High School conditions, will find Summer Courses of Study provided. Terms on ap plication THE URSULINE ACADEMY Middletown. New York Pennesrtvania, Bryn Mawr. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Prepares for Bryn Mawr and other colleges. Cer tificate privileges. Number of pupils limited. Spe celal schedule arranged for each. Percentage of pupils who have entered Bryn Mawr College un usally large. Gymnastics. outdoor sports. 14th year opens Oct. 3, 1912

Page 2

The Nati ‘ le JNNation FOUNDED IN 1865 the . | Ey I t ¢ I \“ J I I I I if \ £ n » $4 ) HE NATIO "4 CONTENTS OF THIS EDITORIAL ARTICLES } 1 i the Po th Good I » Re \l I r B I Our 7 ! Ne rrea of tl H antl I of At I j ind ) ( Children of Al de« Rirot riotee! iptain Unafraid ir et émancipation des iznoles des origit 1 1s iectual and Pollt Curt Far Kast Religion of th Ancient ¢ hit Mountain Trail ter of Lady Ja (; DTA rate fall i cI line of 5s I rue Wee * * © Coples of The Nation may be 1 Par at Brentano's 17 Avenue de London fr. F. Stevens & Brown ~ re, Charing Crosse NUMBER rocure Opéra Tr af The Nation (Vol. 95. No. 2457 Educational Short - Story Writing A course of forty lessons in the history, form,structure, and writing of the Shert- Story, taught by J. Berg Keenwein, Editor L ppincott' ¢ Magazine Over one hundred Home Stu Courses under professorsin Harr 4 Brown, Cornell, and leading colleges. Dr Esonwein 250-page catalog free. Write to-day. The Home Correspondence Schoo! Dept284.Soringfield Mass Just Published A Two Years’ Course in English Composition By CHARLES LANE HANSON DO cents f the Years’ Course in Comyj of Han sition manuscript says Teachers should jump for it, for the wealth material is just what we need and what Ww have to supply at the cost of much drill work than f it miteria wk contains more composition Ss size for manual It pr abundance of the first wides an ind second year of any high school Every chapter wil be found and practical Beresford has arrived.” —London Morning Leader. A Candidate for Truth By J. D. BERESFORD “More than by any novel we have read for nonths we are captivated by ‘A Candidate for Truth.’”"—Chicago Evening Post. “Raises its author quite definitely to the front rank of living novelists.”—London Standard 486 pages. LITTLE, “Mr. Cloth. $1.35 net; by mail $1.46. BROWN & CO., BOSTON Books by WOODROW WILSON Congressional Government. A Study in American Politics. $1.25. Mere Literature, and Other Essays. $1.50. For HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., 4 Park St.,Boston sale everywhere LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT GINN & COMPANY, 20 BEACON STREET, Publishers BOSTON Memoirs of Henry Villard Journalist and Financier 1835-1900 [wo volumes, with Portraits and Maps, $5.00 net. Postage, 35 cents. An autobiographical record of the varied and romantic career of the war journalist who subsequently became a power in the financial world, and carried the Northern Pacific Railroad to completion. Full of in- cident and valuable for its reminiscences of Lincoln and other prominent men of the time, as well as for its descriptions of im- portant battles of the Civil War. “A book of extraordinary interest. It Is written with great ability, in a clear and flowing style; it details with perfect candor the Incidents of a great career; it is an ad- mirable report of great events, all of which the writer saw, and a large part of which (after 1870) he was; it exhibits the rise and growth of a rich and powerful personality and a character at once remarkable for its simplicity and its variety."—JoHN WHITE CHapwick, in the New York Times Satur- day Review. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY Boston ann New York, Magazine excerpts on all subjects sup- plied Let me know what you are inter- ested In. H. WILLIAMS, 105 East 22nd St., New York Situation Wanted \ Harvard graduate wishes to travel with one or two boys. Competent to tutor In all English subjects, elementary German and French @and Latin. Best of references given. Address N. A., care of The Nation THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND “A notable brief for democracy that everybody ought to read,"’ says Mr. Oswatp Garrison ViILLarD One Way Out: A Middle-Class New ; Englander Emigrates to America f By “WILLIAM CARLETON.” f The most notable book oj our day. Sixth Printing. 81.20 net; by mail, $1.32 Send for descriptive matter free. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston n order to relieve poverty you must firsi under- stand It. The problem is wisely stated in THE BURDEN OF POVERTY: WHAT TO DO CHARLES F,. DOLE A solution is presented by this sociologist, who s gifted with vision. Postpaid, 55 cente. B. W. HUEBSCH, Fifth ave., New ork wy oor 225 READ MONTGOMERY’S NEW BOOK CHRONICLES OF AVONLEA “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES,” ETC. Of which over 300,000 conies have been sold Net 81.25. ostvaid $1.40 THEAMERICAN GOVERNMENT By FREDERIC J HASKINS O.K.'d by the President, the Cabinet, etc Illustrated, 12mo. Cloth. $1 aet. Postpaid $1.15 J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia As a Brilliant Man Sees Us America of To-morrow By ABBE FELIX KLEIN At All Bookstores. $1.75 net. A. C.MeCLURG & Co., Publishers, Chicago 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, WRITE DODD, MEAD & COMPANY FOURTH AVE. & 30TH STREET, NEW YORK THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK For 1911 Now Ready

Page 3

‘ oi ms VEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 1, 1912 4 y The Week If President Taft could only bring Ohio into a condition in which it would be safe for him to take his eyes off of it for a moment now and then, surely his troubles elsewhere would be less formid able. The refusal of Judge Dillon to head the ticket there differs onlv in de gree of seriousness from a long list of difficulties that have bothered Mr. Taft in his own State from the moment of his first nomination. It was Chairman Brown who gave force to the disquieting rumors of a possible Roosevelt candi dacy by announcing his support of the former President, and Brown seems to be at the centre of the new crisis. He is evidently using his position to em- barrass the campaign of the regular nominee of his party, while not going so far as to incur the punishment of being thrown over the breastworks. In taking this attitude, he is showing himself to be a man after the Colonel’s own heart It may not be a straightforward course. It may be a line of conduct of which any but a hardened politician would be ashamed. Yet if it leads to success, is it not justified by the ethical code of the party that cares nothing for electoral votes, but everything for principle? With the State Committee for Taft, even by a narrow majority, and with the State Convention twice having pronounced for him, it looks as if a Taft supporter must be nominated for Governor. The Third Party adherents, however, can make the procedure difficult, and thus furthe: damage the Taft cause, preparatory to bolting and naming a ticket of theil own. No wonder the Democrats hopeful of breaking the long line of Re publican victories in the modern Motner of Presidents Sober-minded citizens must be asking themselves whether a candidate who has to run away to sea in order to procure the necessary leisure for composing a speech of acceptance has in him the stuff that Presidents are made of. Gov Wilson has been a Presidential candi date for less than a month, and already he finds himself hampered in the com The Nation position of public documents by littl things like a couple of hundred Con- gressmen and political leaders dropping in for lunch. Can the people be persuad ed to accept a mollycoddle of the Wilson type, when they may have, even with out asking, a man whose intellectual processes function with equal ease in the solitudes of the African jungle and in the surroundings of a boiler factory? To shake several thousand hands, to read half a dozen popular novels, to walk ten miles and play a dozen sets of tennis, to dictate a ten-thousand-word speech and an Outlook editorial, and to talk an hour or two into the long-distance telephone what is this but an ordinary day's work at Oyster Bay? In the face of all the manifest and 1 efforts to induce manifestly organize the House to recede from its determin ation to authorize no additional battle ships this year, what is the Peace So ciety doing? How many letters and telegrams are being sent to Congress men by those who believe that the waste on armaments is Inexcusable, and that it will never be checked unless a beginning is made? It is time for those who are not big-navy boomers, nor in terested in shipbuilding concerns, to be stir themselves. All the pressure should not be left for one side to exert In particular should a demand be made fo1 specifications. Just why must we au thorize one or two battleships in this year’s naval bill, or else despair of th republic? Who is there to demonstrate that our present naval strength is not adequate? If it is a question of keeping up with the English or German pr gramme everybody Can se tha tw battleships are merely a flea-bit ould be just as black treas¢ to au 1oOTiz only two as to vot | nor There should be at leasta d at on One argument freely ci! n ord break down Democrat re tance ( policy of navi ‘ been that Ge \W I l Vit the attitud ( t rt this seems to be put if est by the it ment said to have come from him t e is not meddling in any way content to leave it to his party in the House to do what it thinks right He ertainly could not be expected to give any aid to the Roosevelt-Hearst alliance, in this matter of battleships. The vote in the Senate last eek makes it pretty certain that Congress will again send to the President a bill reducing the wool duties, either t en or to veto. Apparently, it will be ery like the one which he refused to ipprove last vear tut this one he ld gn without any glaring inconsistency t will be remembered that he t | vear'’s veto main! y on the i { t Tariff Board had not mad: port on the wool-manufacturing That report, however, ha been made It clearly istified large ductions in existing rates, supporting many particulars the position taker President Taft himself, that the prese duties in Schedule K are indefen Even the regular Republicans in the Senate are convinced that some re tions ought to be made, for af feating the Hous bill by the narre t of majoriti« they made haste committee of the whole to adopt a bill suddenly reported from the Finar Committee by Senator Penrose. B er this wa et aside in the full Senat and the La Follette bill was adopted a combined ote of Democrats al surgent Republicans. The measure i* } goes to conference, and out of it a i should come, doubtless not as thoroug going a it ought to be, but ons ! res t it least a beginning in dé z represen a a De LINNINE na awa Wit! il juitous form ot ] ‘ LO] \ > I | ‘ ) tt 1 Den 4 ; this ] Ty t Sena ] . os ‘ | oa t . me nee \ ne i} an doubt T y i I iti nt ou ind shall ( ] nm « f f another J , ‘ ‘ ‘ if ( it jeast ye to oppose it—President Taf upposed to t for it, Gov W one ged and it Ol

Page 4

Cys ) es] & irdinal d ne of the third party Ke it or not, therefore, and nk it foolish, we must pre ' ! lade i Y, | I t d fro \ i i t An I t ) if the pudiated i W i | “bring nt to i ld i t pa s m child \\ t Bourbor ‘ i { NS l riders three ] Protect Tarif | | j Aldrich I vl Roe t The i ( vhat ite) Progre lve i o has moaned and even it the faithlessness of Pres ] n not cutting down tariff du lidat vho is going to “look tarill and ee if it is not re for the high cost of living, determined to reduce he >» now emits these wails the ilamity of giving the Demo il i hat to remove the burdens of taxation No wonder that Mr. Bryan lls the Colonel the prince of rea , On the tariff, which he ilways afraid to touch with the tip of or of fingers while he was Pres ident and had the power to do some thing to relleve the people, he writes in a spirit of bigoted ignorance that Payne could not surpass and Penrose or Smoot uld not hope to rival. Mr. Roosevelt's ringing of the old tariff alarm bells goes well ith his assertion that if the Dem- ocratic plan to make competition effec tive ind to punish Trust criminals, were carried out, “all business every where throughout the United States would stop lo this Perkins will say amen rhe recommendation which the Pub- lic Service Commission makes as a re- sult of ite investigation of the accident to the Twentieth Century Limited in March, is much farther reaching than the usual finding in such cases. It holds that the broken rail was a consequence of the derailment rather than tes cause, which is concluded to have been a low spot in the track, this being due in turn ‘The to the continual pounding of trains upon | Governor’s unpopularity with “labor” in it place inadequately drained. Accord- ingly, the Commission emphasizes the need of adequate drainage along railway racks. But it does not feel that this is caution enough, and proceeds to sug- rest a reduction of speed in long-dis- tance runs during the winter months, vhen “instead of the elastic roadbed of immer, the structure becomes almost is solid as rock.” In other words, we ave gone beyond the margin of safety in our eighteen-hour trains because we have not been able to build a proper roadbed for them, In making its recom- mendation to reduce speed during bad eather conditions, the Commission has been careful not to propose action which ould put one road at a disadvantage. rhe question, it says, has been discussed with officers of the Pennsylvania as well as the New York Central, and has been favorably received by them. The latter company, in commenting upon the re- port, while not committing itself to a lengthening of the time schedule, agrees that all tracks become slightly irregular in surface, particularly in severe wea- ther Woodrow Wilson, it has been discover- ed by a few editors of foreign birth, is the foe of the laboring man. “He has shown himself to possess no sympathy for the toiling classes.”” This is a seri- ous charge. It must be admitted that, beyond an employers’ liability and com- pensation act, legislation prohibiting the employment of children during school hours and at night and providing for a fifty-eight-hour week, the appointment of commissioners to study old-age pen- sions and insurance, provision for the protection of workers against draughts, fumes, and noxious gases, an increase in the number of factory inspectors and the raising of their standard of effi- cleney, the establishment of an eight- hour day for State, county, and munici- pal work, the providing of a _ semi- monthly pay-day for railway employees, the elimination of contract labor in penal institutions, the setting of a sani- tary standard for bakeshops, the regula- tion of employment agencies, and a few others of the sort, New Jersey, under the leadership of Gov. Wilson, has done almost as little for the toiling classes in the last two years as she had done in ‘the preceding seventeen. Doubtless, we have here tHe real explanation of the [ Vol. 95, No. 2457 his own State. Chairman McCombs’s first duty is to devise some way of pre- venting this tell-tale record from reach- ing the readers of the foreign-language newspapers in this country. Lieut. Becker's indictment for the mur- der of Rosenthal at once lets in a flood of light upon the crime, and is a terrible blow to the Mayor, the Police Commis- sioner, and the whole police administra- tion of New York city. The police with all their detective resources were unable or unwilling to run down the criminals cencerned in this astounding assassina- tion, and left it to the District Attor- ney to unearth the truth. Mr. Whitman deserves all thanks for his vigor and persistence. To have finally broken into the criminal circle, and to have forced confessions implicating Becker, is a great achievement, and will make the members of the “System” ask: “Who of us is safe?” We do not, of course, assume the guilt of the indicted officer; suspi- cion is one thing, proof another. The testimony against Becker looks very damning, yet it may be broken down at the trial. But the community is now ab- solutely convinced of one thing, and this is that unholy alliances for mutual gain do exist between certain members of the police force and desperate crim- inals, and that we shall have neither peace nor safety until these are broken up and made impossible for the future. Senator Curtis of Kansas maintains that, while he believes in Republican regularity, he is as progressive as any man; but the terms in which he assails William Allen White reveal an old-fash- ioned outlook upon things. It is decid- edly old-fashioned to ask one’s political rival if it is true that he is in the habit of being frequently horsewhipped and caned in public; that he has stolen mo- ney from the poor; that he has been de- tected in the act of putting arsenic in the village horse-trough, and has been connected, in public rumor, with the un- explained burning down of two churches and an orphan asylum. This smacks of ithe campaign style of thirty years ago. | The violence of the assault is all right. | Progressives are nothing if not violent ‘in fighting the battles of the Lord. But to-day people no longer assail the pri- vate character of their opponents. Op- probrium is measured out in terms of OO gas.

Page 5

9 The Nation =—=—_—_—_—_——_ pe social value. One's enemy is a brigand, Germany continue their protest against but a political brigand; a pickpocket, this agreement, which they aver is but a political pickpocket; a second-story | fraught with danger to the Empire. Th man, a horse-thief, an inmate of Bedlam, | Areuz-Zeitung, especialls in no a crook, a liar—but always in a politi- prospect of carrying out a iccessful cal sense. This is attested by the fact colonial policy in Moro What that that as soon as a man changes sides he policy ought to be is set forth elal automatically ceases to be a brigand, a ly in an article pointing to tl posse pickpocket, a second-story man, a horse- sions of Portugal in Africa, Ind thief, a crook, and a liar. China as fruitful fields for German onization schemes. Dr. Kar] Peters « ‘. . , , advocates i the Tag arranging Whenever a Government majority in ” ° ag arre on , . Great Britain to give Germany ; the House of Commons is brought to the!” in to } y a , , hand, regardless of the interests of P danger point, or is wiped out on a snap; wen _ iti " ge reedless say, the Liberal p vote, the Opposition never fails to shout | ' il. Needless to say, th — “s : . , 9 »f Germany refuses to see in the g1 Resign! Resign!” though the lack of |°! Ge?™many retu - ' : a > . ne etween France and Germa significance of such a vote is apparent. | ™°™* bet n Fran , ie 0.8 the Morocec: question a pret This is what happened on Friday when foroccan question a | the Liberal majority, in a very thin | /0™!al expansion on a vast s house, fell to three. It is true that when Lord Rosebery’s Ministry was beaten in Recent developments in Alsace-Lot the famous snap vote on the army cord-|raine emphasize the difficulty experien ite supply, the Premier accepted the ver- ed by the German Government in trying dict of the House and resigned; but that to weld into one patriotic whole the con was because the Ministry was then in| flicting elements of the Reichsland. Th« its last agony, and the end was not far | action of the Diet in limiting the allow- off in any case. On the other hand, |ances for the Imperial Governor, and it when Mr. Balfour was outvoted as the | opposing the personal wishes of the Em result of an Irish coup, a few months | peror, has offended many in Germany before he went out of office in 1905, all| Jn Metz the Liberals of Lorraine, who the subtleties of the Balfourian logic! see in the opposition of Clericals and were called into play to prove that the | French sympathizers a growing menacs defeat signified nothing, and for days|to their country as well as to the En British Parliamentary history was ran-| pire, have united in forming a Party of sacked for precedents on both sides. But | progressists, which attempted to show while Friday's slim majority was only |jts conciliatory spirit by holding its de- an accident, it is nevertheless becoming | }jberations in both German and French apparent that the Liberal coalition is|The party has made a special appeal to having its internal difficulties. The La-|jaboring men. In Alsace the path of bor members are indulging in more or/the supporters of the German Govern- less covert threats, and from the Radical| ment is even more thorny. The Strass wing of the Liberal party comes bitter | burg correspondent of the Frankfurter criticism of the Government's big-navy | Zeitung speaks of the unaltered hostility ; : policy. lof the old Alsatian burghers, rooted in , the traditions of the French bourgeoisie, Before the prorogation of the French | Who worship the memory of Kléber and Chamber Premier Poincaré spoke of the |/0uis Philippe and allow their sons bright future opening up to France in to expatriate themselves and serve in Morocco, as the result of the treaty with |the French army. And, most of all, a the Sultan. Gen. Lyautey, the French|®¢¥ pseudo-nobility has sprung up, Resident-General in Fez, whose powers | Which speaks French by preference and y>acquires Parisiz ways. Eve are almost unrestricted, is to carry out | Studiously acquires Parisian ways. Even a programme which has already worked ithose inhabitants of Alsace-Lorraine - —oiidinei » new orde successfully in Madagascar and Algeria, | “5° acquiesce in the new order of The Chamber of Deputies, in adopting | things, and call themselves Germans, the treaty with Morocco, by an over- whelming majority—in spite of the op- position of Jaurés, the Socialist leader —has thus fully sanctioned the German- French agreement of last November. Meanwhile, the Conservative papers in are concerned only in home affairs and still look upon the Altdeutschen as strangers and intruders. The Mediterranean phase of the Euro pean naval situation is beset with even more uncertainty and idle speculat than the British-German rivalry N h Sea It Ss as d that Ita atl Aus i ar ibe j I por i | at hipbuild progra ‘ e t I ple \ al Medit i il W) y ha pen in tl listant ture ‘ question. For the present it , tha ; Fr ‘ + il to b I \ ind | . P i | i i i a i ; ps | ‘ i ‘ I i S { n x lit inea t t led rral i iat kk d » (5 i I I y int ! } \ i Di tio I h treat I inand A an fleets as a unit a s. Ther no friendship t! » natior and n b there tle concealment fact that A ia 1 Italy are build £ p fa ithe, i i ta ol 1 inno 1t last k fro Constantinop! t il I ssic ill be made Albania, mari a? policy. The Albanian National Assembly hich met me eeks ago at Yunik, as the most representative body of that people which ever submitted griev- ances to the Turkish Government. It consisted of eighty-six popular leaders, Christians as vell as Mohammedans, and was presided over by Tabir Beka, i well-known Mohammedan landed pro prietor from the vilayet of Kossovo, The demands of the Assembly were for the stablishment of public schools, with in- struction in the Albanian language, for the safeguarding of the rights of all re ligions and religious institutions, for ad ministrative autonomy, economic re- forms, and the restriction of the priv- ileges of the Sultan's representative, Be- fore the fall of the Cabinet, the Turkish Minister of War, Shefket Pasha, while deprecating the action of the Albanian mutineers in the Turkish army, spoke highly of the patriotism of the Albanian people in general. He also declared that, in his opinion, there was a direct con- nection between the rising in Albania and the attempts to force Turkey into a peace with Italy.

Page 6

THE EVIDENCE. publication on Monday of a full of all the contests at the Chicago ug to set some men to rhe third party is built upon fraud by the National the interest of Taft, but that delegates were proot ept wild vociferation? Even velt followers there hioose really wish to There vho would the fact are are ipporting him, even one law schools one here and there a iany good people wlo Commandment “Thou but who believe that nt “Thou shalt not bear is equally binding. Such bound now to turn from the hrill about thievery to which theft cries show The of the record will there was any or not material at last made accessi ach contest is gone into in detail, argument and affidavits on the hear roll-calls, had have the We ink decisions have loud } bah outery now we Roosevelt himself will pay mm to this, there is no reason What he hi as published ha on and con taken hi been purely part probably ove! hired No one de allegations of Ormsby McHarg has, o1 Colonel inute and accurate has no head ort of thing Stephen went to India cCoae, °° on ial criminal dian offic whos of laying ything ympa offed ipply all on 10,000 not take ten min to enable any hon lared the of ake up his mind that Committees vere a set and robber Hie has loudly hundred times that they were, enough eviden ‘The [Vol. 95, No. 2457 Nation = Still, there will be a few slow coaches, who have not his lightning way of leap- ing to the desired conclusion, and who will be anxious to see what the proof is that President Taft is a pickpocket, as Roosevelt haz called him, before pro- The task of going of necessary nouncing him guilty. all tedious. evidence is, course, It statements, through the long and will be to sift conflicting and to weigh the arguments both from fact and party rules. Hence it will take a good deal of time for the publication of the official record to have its due effect. The lie has got a big start, and it will be a slow process for the truth to catch up with it But any one who wishes to make a beginning in trying to arrive at the rights of the business, cannot do better than compare some of the calm recitals of the published statement with the vehement assertions, relating to the Mr. in the Out- same matter, to which Roosevelt put his name in an article look the contests. We purporting to review will limit ourselves at present to a It was supposed to be the Roovevelt single case. case that had, in- strongest volving the delegation from the State of About no other “robbery” Now, let us Washington. he put side by side the account of what oc- has been more violent. (rather, as it was he facts), and as curred, as he gave it given to him: of course, knows no- thing whatever about the it in the publication made on appears Monday ~ con In King County a turned King nittec t in which S« of 250 men is situated. The velt dele the rhe principal on consisted the ma- ority of whom were that ting Roos« for Taft, and to State majority a‘ its executive committee, selected the Taft delegates to the rhe county ntion thi through vere elected from primary regu Convention the committee alled by a ma Stats the full nittee, by 6,400 was He had authority chairman of a Roosevelt man been by resolution to given general fill occurr committee \ of had raft cancies ng in the meeting mmittec held after the Council had di rected the redistrict of the off the It in possible City full ittes really ing city it to which it w resolv as the chairman not that git a bare ed faced more fraud dissenting rep could tc entativesr be the te aclected 331 until tion was held in Sep not fill new pre an elec tember, 1912. There- after, and in spite of this conclusion, the chairman assumed the right by his ap- pointment to add to the existing commit- tee 131 precinct com- mitteemen, and with voting in the committee it is claimed that a pri- was ordered However, the fact is that the Taft men against these mary protested any action by a com- mittee so constituted, the ground that the chairman had n authority to appoint the 131 new commit teemen. They refus- ed to take part in the primary, and so did the La Follette men on It is not to be expected that such a showing, or any of the others made from the records of the Chicago contests, will lead the Colonel to modify in the least the fury of his denunciation. But though he may scorn the idea of sitting down to pore over the musty documents, can he be sure that all his friends will exhibit a like disdain for the facts? He La Fo!- lette is on his trail in this matter, too. In La Follette’s Weekly, Mr. Gilbert E. may have noted that Senator Roe, the Senator's former law-partner, has begun an examination of the con- He lim- its himself to a scrutiny of the official tests for delegates at Chicago. record and a compilation of the facts; and, so far as he has gone, his conclu- sions are highly adverse to the Roose- velt contentions. He dismisses all but sixty-five Roosevelt contests as absolute vote against them in the frauds, the Committee being either unanimous or viva voce without a demand for a roll- call, so ashamed were even the Roose- velt members of the impudent pretences set up against the lawfulness of the Taft delegates. This is the kind of study of the facts which is sure to go on and to be seriously damaging to Mr. Roosevelt Long before to charge trickery and cheating, made the Convention he began just as sweeping assertions of fraud in New did like man carefully preparing in advance to bolt on the claim that he had been rob- York and Indiana as he in Texas and Arizona, and acted a bed of the nomination. But hereafter he will be confronted with the record. To the law and to the testimony, from now on. We shall probably hear less in the

Page 7

' NNTP Aug. 1, 1912} future about the Chicago pickpockets. have been mentioned as possible future Sea in undisputed Britis Even the Colonel's followers are getting allies of Japan These are Russia and reasoning, of ourse tired of this, or are beginning to doubt «, rmany, and no other Powers have miraculous capacities ieir al Vv r irc was their ability to prove their charges. Mr been mentioned because no ot s are nese and the Ge n George L. Record took the ground in available. Russia has been long th A nation that « New Jersey, last week, that it really hing "field than Germany It was n long “ings which Capt. Me didn t matter W hether the nomination expecting the lapanese : after the conclusion of the war in Man : had been stolen from Roosevelt or not, right belongs in partne : churia that the probability of an alli for the time had come to have a thir« tion that can do the su - ance between the two antagonists wa a ; . party anyhow, and they were going to Se : F a J 3 i Which the German I ee” a suggested. The idea had its principal have it, fraud or no fraud. ulways doing. in the basis in the dramatic instinct of man = : ervous Englishmen What could be more impressive than an B : , nares ca An alliance wit fuss JAPAN AND THE POWERS. alliance between two countries that had lliance with R : ‘ =" , , re easonable than ont h G The death of the Mikado will evoke Just emerged from a life-and-death strug 9 y ogy nee ra really among the prob: no change in Japan’s domestic policies Sle? So those political forecasters who ’ ‘ ; » hetween VPeration between Japan and or her foreign relations. Mutsuhito’s did not predict a second war between : E ; : —— — nS ee are temporary diplomatic pur] reign of forty-four years was an era of Russia and Japan thin ten years, - ! . = one thing ilitary extraordinary national development, but began to predict a Russo-Japanest , nowy, another tussia’s fleet pre tte Emperor's personal share in the not- 4illiance within ten years The argu n being, will long ! 2 ‘ 7 . . ‘ ‘ VU —' t bo i able historic process was probably not ment for an alliance wa hat both na ‘ : , , t! Baltic and ie Black Se a very important one. An absolute mon- tions needed. peace for a long time to } I : ‘ vy of the other Powe1 An arch in theory, the Mikado exerted less come, and that both nations were occu | : ; , > ramas = ‘ i had inh a@ sistance on iand ipar ‘direct influence upon public affairsthan pants of Chinese territory, and so ha V7 : ‘ ; cae ——~ wv - a er own army most constitutional rulers of Europe, really common interests in regard to the : ara ; al onceivable purp He did not so much rule through other Shaping of affairs at Peking ‘. ose peopl vl alk 2g men as he was used by them. The estab- The German alliance has not been dis “ 5 te Let lished native tradition looks upon the cussed at such great lengt! rhe ug , Manchuria only s en i Emperor as the source of a spiritual gestion has been brought forward recent me . bit too lachiavellia if authority which is translated into ac- ly, and it, too, appeals to the dramatic ’ ure d not I upp tion by professional statesmen and war- sense of newspaper writers and readers. . t en part i riors. He cannot be called a shadow-Em- If Japan's alliance with Great Britain is \ i ’ i «i geror, because this spiritual authority to be broken, why not join hands with : , anipic na hat I has been a very real force in the life of the Power that England hates and fears i ; no we overio ACU the nation. The sentiment that gathers most? But that is about the only argu R necessity, Ku a about the Mikado is the Occidental feel- ment that can be adduced in favor of a ;, But : : M - : apan ou ing for flag and country fused with an German Japane alliance. Real basis for I mem 0 lt element of religious worship. The im- such an arran t there is none. The must remain and til perial power is impersonal, and achange present agreement with Great Britain genera it lay Tt a d of rulers is no change at all. The per- rests upon the very sound basis of a . : lorming oO fran ho sonal influences that have guided Japa mutual guarantee of protection for the copik m t ra nese policy—the Cabinet, the Parlia-, Asiatic possessions of the two Powers , ‘| 41] ” ihe rij All I ment, and the survivors of the elder gen- If England's interests in India are in spite of ma d ! eration of statesmen—will continue to peril, Japan is bound to come to her aid. P , —— ‘Trance Khu an aliian shape affairs, now that Mutsuhito’s son An agreement between Russia and Ja- ; aprun years o.d, and shows ho reigns in his stead. pan would have a similar justification ing. International partnersnaip It will be, therefore, simply coinci- in fact, since Russia is an Asiatic Pow- ; ‘ ; the outcome ot me dence if, with the beginning of a new er, But Germany has no territorial in- . of long-continued pr reign, Japan should take up the recon- terests in the Far East, other than the ings may not @iways be appa struction of her foreign policy. Of that diminutive Kiau-chau concession. More ar d inal irgument aga t there has recently been a great deal of important still, Germany's usefulness to , bility of a Japanese-German talk. The treaty of alliance with Great Japan as an ally cannot easily be imag- . , anese-Russian alliance ist Britain expires in 1915, and, if it is to ined. In case of war between Japan and that th no real at i iat there is no real gr id f be discontinued, must be denounced a Russia, it is plain, of course, that Ger- ; ing that the Anglo-Japanese al year in advance. That the alliance will many could decide the outcome by at- " about to be airsolved. Of tl not be renewed is a possibility that has tacking Russia from the west. But the Powers with whom Japan can been brought forward repeatedly, and absurdity of such action, entailing as it . ? , ceivably come into conflict speculation has been busy finding a sub- would a general European war, is ap- till ti , wi nt sti e one who can best s stitute for Great Britain. Prince Kat- parent. As for the German fleet, under interests in Asia. sura’s trip abroad is supposed to have no conceivable circumstances can it be been undertaken for the purpose of pre- visualized as sailing forth to the help of liminary exploration. Only two Powers its Japanese allies, leaving the North ‘The Nation

Page 8

96 The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2457 TRIFLING WITH GOOD FAITH. A marked copy of Washington's Fare- well Address should be sent to certain Senators, to some writers on interna- tional law, and to a great many news- paper The passage especially to be underscored is the one enjoining us to observe good faith” towards all na- The pending bill to make the tivns Panama Canal free of tolls to American sels, with some of the speeches made oncerning the proposal, and the articles written about it, shows a tendency to play fast and loose with the plighted vord of the nation. This is the more prehensible in that, aside from the formal agreements of the Hay-Paunce- fote treaty, there was a separate and especial assertion that Great Britain might depend upon the absolute good faith of the United States. This comes out clearly in the full iccount of the negotiations which Secre- sent to the Senate of the Sixty- tary Hay first Congress detailed the steps taken in connection with the original treaty and its subsequent modifications. The correspondence showed the British Government to be desirous for a time of incorporating certain amendments, but, after a free interchange of views, Lord Lansdowne decided not to press them. main reason for waiving such Brit- finally The h contentions, and consenting to the form preferred by our Depart- ment of State, was succinctly given by Secretary as follows: Hay The President, however, could not consent to this amendment, because he apprehended that it be ther Powers parties to the contract and as in the would thus prac tically might construed as making the ng them contract rights canal 1 that it restore the treaty the substance of the provision the treaty is tortured in order to make it mean what it plainly was never in- If that will not work, we are told that the thing for us to do tended to mean. is to regard the treaty as so much waste of what some of our people want to do, why not paper. Standing in the way “denounce” it at once, and so get rid of it? This is the brute-force argument. It is pointed out by one publicist that Rus- Precedents can, of course, be cited. sia announced in 1870 that she would be no longer bound by the international agreement excluding her from the Black Sea, so why should we not be free open- ly to repudiate the Hay-Pauncefote treaty? The illustration is not fortu- nate. Everybody remembers how this act of Russia’s was involved in a great war; how Bismarck had agreed before- hand to give Russia a free hand in that matter, provided she would be neutral in the struggle with France, and enable Prussia to leave her Russian frontier un- guarded. A later instance would be Aus- tria’s annexation of Bosnia and Herze- in govina disregard of the Treaty of Berlin. Such things can be done. Trea- ties fall when nations go to war, and} treaties can be violated if a country is| strong enough and cynical enough to do it. But such a course would be pecu- liarly shameless in connection with the Hay-Pauncefote treaty, because, as Sen- ator Root pointed out, it is of the na- tract. England wished her to ture of an executed had something wh give up—namely, her right of joint con- ‘trol of the canal under the Clayton-Bul- | \wer treaty—and to induce her to surren- der it we offered a guarantee of neutral- ity and entire equality. Having got | to interfere. To this we know of only two objections. One is that it is immor- The second is that it is illegal. This last could hardly be doubted by any one who will take the trouble to read the treaty itself—which few of these rough- and-ready upsetters of it have apparent- ly done—for it distinctly provided for this change in the situation which is al- leged to be so vital. Article IV reads: It is agreed that no change of territorial sovereignty or of the international relations of the country or countries traversed by the before-mentioned canal shall affect the gen- eral principle of neutralization or the ob- ligation of the high contracting parties un- der the present treaty. It is gratifying to note that none of these discreditable efforts to get away from a binding treaty seems to find any general favor. Certain interested per- sons are making a great ado about the matter, and as usual covering private greed with the cloak of patriotism, but |the public, and even Congress, are not showing much concern. The probability seems to be that the Panama bill will | be passed, if at all this session, without 'the controverted clauses affecting canal tolls. There is certainly no hurry about those, in case of a canal that will not be |}opened for three years yet. We are un- der no necessity of rushing into legisla- tion which would be both a danger an@ is a national disgrace. THE NAVAJO RESERVATION. The progressive spirit of New Mexico is manifesting itself in a demand for the opening of the Navajo Indian reser- vation to white settlement. This was to | be expected, sooner or later. Its advent ‘80 early in the career of the infant State vhich the Senate had struck out as article(what we wanted, the proposal now is/| shows that the New Mexicans, in spite | He believed also was a strong national feeling of the former treaty that there inet giving to the other Powers anything the nature of a contract right in an af o pecullarly American as the no other right in or Powers had now any to give for acquiring remine or anything up with as consideration that they are to rely United States in it niract right goot 1 faith of the declaration to at Britain this it the and neutralization there set forth Gre in treaty and that adopts rules plea of with are adopted in the treaty eat Britain as a coneideration for getting d of the Clayton-Bulwer treaty It is faith of the nation, both tacitly and explicitly pledged, with and else- The at- away from our promises The this good Washington to trifle. which some in where are disposed tempt to get takes forms. language of many canal ;¢ (that we take back what we gave in order get it. Turpitude could hardly be more glaring. to One of the ingenious little shifts of the treaty-evaders is to assert that the situation has completely changed since the agreement was made. The treaty was ratified in 1901. But it was not till 1903 that Roosevelt “took” Panama. That act of robbery, it is alleged, is now of bad faith, has become American our warrant for an act since the “Zone” The canal is therefore a part of and whatever rules or soil. our “coast line,” regulations we may choose to make for the use of the canal are “purely matters of domestic legislation,” with which no foreign gountry has a shadow of a right ‘of numbering among them so many per- | sons of Spanish antecedents and habit, /are full of the Western idea that no time should be lost in reaching out for any- |thing they want. And what they par- \ticularly want just now is a big area of |public land to attract immigrants from | the East. | Jt is truly a splendid domain upon |which they have fixed their eyes—meas- ured by the surveyor’s instruments. On ithe map it would cover all the State of ‘Connecticut east of the Connecticut |River. It would completely blot out Delaware, or hide Rhode Island with a |eonsiderable fringe to spare. But not even the keen-eyed spies Moses sent into Canaan could find, in a forty days’

Page 9

ieee Se Aug. I, 1912] enough arable land to take care of hundred white families with the tradi- tions of their race. A few have already tried it, settling down as missionaries, teachers, or traders on the oases most available for home-building; and they would bear witness to the unsuitablk ness of the country to the general needs of a white farming population. Vast stretches of arid sand and clay, dotted only with sagebrush; few streams, and those wholly uncertain in volume and season of flowing; widely separated tracts of timber; forbidding bluffs ol bare rock; gray plateaus gashed with cafions whose walls have been carved immemorial erosion into grotesque, by half-finished architectural forms—these are the impressions the wayfarer gains of the Navajo desert. Picturesque, but not livable, is the universal verdict of those who are most familiar with it; and no one who knows the country is aston- ished selected for the Navajos in order to keep to learn that it was originally them forever out of contact with the whites, on the assumption that no white man could subsist in such a chameleon’s paradise. Yet this native people, in many re- spects the finest group of Indians in the United States, have not only subsisted but flourished there, numbering now be- tween twenty-five and thirty thousand The their neighbors souls. chief complaint of white is that they pay no taxes towards the support of schools and roads and courts, though swarming over all the northwest corner of New Mexico, the northeast corner of Arizona, and a considerable notch on the southern bor- der of Utah. But most of the little that has been done towards improving the land they have done themselves. With their crude tools and rough engineering, have the refractory they struggled bravely with few, rivers, and harnessed parts of them so as to irrigate small of They tiny wells and rain-cisterns for water- patches soil. have developed ing their sheep, their main dependence for support. If they had not been herds- men by instinct, they would have starv- ed to death long ago; and had they not enough of the nomad adaptability to be willing to move their homes, with their flocks, many miles from ture to winter shelter and back again, they would have had no sheep to herd. They of the summer , pas- have asked no aid Gov- search through this huge reservation, a The Nation ernment, and, beyond a few scattered schools, receive none. They are a proud people, independent of spirit, hardy, tem perate, industrious, ing apabl Crimes of violence among them ar rare As a trib tl kept t e Government ] into a compact of p y ears £0 Of cours ing to banish all ir Xu ‘stablished social i f estion of wl b nodernized ind brought into genera t the rest of the body po the white invader will e1 t Navajo country and possess idy entered and possessed the dor oO scores of other tribes. But it behooves Congress to go slowly wit ; legal re of this process. No ordinary allotment scheme will answer. The problem pre sented by the Navajos is complex be yond that offercd by any body of Indians who are agriculturists by inheritance or natural bent, or who inhabit a farming region, or who, having lived long on Gov- ernment bounty, have to be thrown out right upon their own resources as the last hope for their salvation. It is too large for solution by of the estab- of Before any law any lished agencies Indian administra- tion. on the subject is passed, it ought to be referred to a com mission of wise, high-minded, unselfish men, who are w to devote the ne« essary time an ight and undergo the months’ discomforts of several so journ in qn inhospitable desert, for the formulation of a plan which will meet equally the tests of philanthropy and practical common sense. THE CULT OF SUPER-GOLF. The historic and shifting contest be- tween the makers of armor and the mak ers of guns, to see which can get the better of the other, has its likeness in what has for some time been going on in the game of golf. Players and the architects of the links are continually pitting their wits against each other Every improvement in clubs o1 ills is but a signal for making the ourses harder. The average skill of golfers is all the time increasing; but greens com mittees display a fiendish ingenuity In seeing to it that the average score does not improve. You will see malignant officials on the watch for a poor shot of profe ssi good trate, too that luckily es id then darkly mut ’ ; su } a ti Ss ugl a >t . id gre i iz \ ) S i I 2 i . o l I | n £ } ‘ S p tT ;xt. 7 nh pe id wt t ind th Vill i area ter Raleigh's « uu are in tre lu cannot guarding the right puts you hole: while a will send you rough. So it must be stroke tain punishment tudy the wind man at a rifle ing towards a iese refinement knov elaxed attentio SUP POr self in a ¥ ' 7 mderful pread that snare aid, his piritual strength hat the statesman said about the f adversity ne 0 he remarked, “but adversity mustn't last long.” It possibly green » of yards to the goes hol ra ona!s and expert maintained, test the cunningly intellect ‘ oolne SS mistortunes for his party.

Page 10

OS J ff become permanently the sense of diabolically con- | shments Every golf club ts in adding hazard to hazard, i ating distances with transit ruits a growing corps of ling members. They like to play & protest that they do not wish | their time hewing their a t of the sand, or striving to be rate on the links as they have to lliard-table Anotl offence laid at the doors of engineers of transcendental golf nks that they will not let nature one Natural hazards have the best 1 for existence of any. A ravine to | h over, a fringe of swamp to carry, bit of wood to skirt, a river or pond to ! e across—such hazards no one ob to; they occur in the order of na re and excite little of the wrath, alice, and all uncharitableness which difficulties of man’s creat About the artificial ne so often provoke for the thought is that player's only in his way and must But ley happen to be omehow be got over or around. the devotees of supe! golf have small pa It They must t with what Nature has done, is ence for them to improve on her. veep everything clear to begin with, so that they may proceed to lay out their nks like a chessboard, plotting each hole with the utmost care and the nic- est balancing of difficulties, and penaliz- ng every stroke that does not drop the ball within a yard of the spot which they indicate We would not be understood as mak- nz a plea for duffers’ golf. The rigors of the game are rightly insisted upon. Chere is no real defence for those courses which “any gentleman” can ne- gotiate In comparatively low figures, no he But numbers of golfers, and we con- matter how plays there are gre ving ies that we sometimes sympathize with them, who take a certain delight, even a trifle shame-faced, in stealing if t tle asionally from the fearfully away oc and wonderfully concatenated traps and hazards that make up the orthodox links, and spending an afternoon of “low dissipation” on acourse of another kind. There it is refreshing to find that there is more than one way of making a given shot, that sinner while yet the lamp holds out to there is hope for the vilest burn on the putting green, and that | The Nation tead of being brac-'brook and terrace and bog have been left as Nature designed them. After a day of such unmanly self-indulgence, one go back with the intricacies of super-golf, determined can dutifully to wrestle to suffer and be strong. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES One of the provisions in the will of Alfred Henry Huth, who died in October, 1910, was that, before his library was sold, his ex- ecutors should give to the British Museum such 50 volumes as the Trustees of the British Museum shall in their uncontrolled discretion select from the Huth Library, provided that such Trustees shall not select perfect copy of any may be then already in the Museum Library except by of of such duplicate with the Huth was that a which Be- any duplicate or more volume which British exchange way Another stipulation of these books, designated as “Huth be the Museum is published. It is a the Oxford Uni- manner. There including a Mr. Huth, reproduc- of title pages, with the text There is by F. G Kenyon, the recently appointed head of the British Museum Library, and there is a longer Introduction Alfred W. Pollard, that most wise and generous Assistant Keep- er the Books, the friend and helper of every bibliographer, student, and book-collector. In the Introduction are in- cluded outline sketches of the lives of Henry Huth, the founder of the Huth Library, and of his son Alfred Henry Huth, the donor of the Huth Bequest, which, Mr. Kenyon says, Library.” catalogue be must separate the by were to quest,” printed That large versity catalogue now at best plates, late printed in the full-page of the of etc., short quarto, Press eighteen frontispiece portrait are facsimile printed Preface besides a number trons by of Printed is “beyond doubt the most important gift that has been mad e library of the) british Museum sin e bequest of the | Grenville Library in 1846.” Of the fifty items manuscripts, including a remarkable Latin Bible of Hours called “the generally tractive volume in the Huth Library,” and a Psalter, ascribed to the last quarter of the thirteenth century and of English exe- The selected, most cution sixteen ductions As might well be supposed, Nos. XIV to XLIX of the catalogue, the thirty-six print- ed books selected as desirable the world’s greatest treasure-hous. of books, separate mention Perhaps alto- gether the most notable are three first quar- “The Tragedie of King (1597), “The Third” (1597), and “A pleasaunt and excellent conceited of Syr John Falstaffe, and Wives of Windsor” (1602). three give the Museum a complete of firat editions of all the quartos up to 1623, save only “Titus Andronicus” (1594), the only known copy of which is in Mr. Folger’s library. Of collections of sonnets put forth deserve tos of Shakespeare Richard the Second” of King Richard the most Comedie merrie in England in the sixteenth century, three not before In the Museum, but now added, are William Smith's “Chloris. or the com- ‘ thirteen are| of French execution, a Flemish Book | at-| plates devoted to the} manvescripts contain upwards of fifty repro- | additions to) Tragedy | the | These | series | | Vol. 95, No. 2457 plaint of the passionate despised Shep- (1596); Bartholomew Griffin's “Fi- dessa chaste than kinde” (1596), and Giles Fletcher's “Licia, or Poemes of (1593). The Bodleian Library three, but the only other Mr. Pollard is a copy of ‘“Fidessa” well Court. “The castell of heard” more Love” possesses all located by at Brit- Among other English books are laboure” (Pynson, 1505), The floure of the Commaundements of god” (Wynken de Worde, 1510), and “The dictes or sayengis of the philosophres” (Cax- 1477), the first dated England. This last book was an and the two tnferior copies The fiftieth book tually a_ collection copy ton, book printed in exchange, for it Museum gave one of their the selection Is ac of seventy-four rately printed single-sheet ballads, of early date, bound together in one volume. This cost Mr. Huth £750 in the Daniel in 1864. An edition of the “Ars Memorandi” block- book and eight French incunabula are among the fourteen books in foreign lan- guages in the Huth Bequest. L. 8. L. of sepa- mostly volume sale Correspondence DEFINING OUR TERMS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: SIR Your correspondent from Provi- dence, “A. M, E.,” may be interested in an experience of my own in the campaign of 1896, when I spoke in one Or two places for McKinley, though myself an economic free- trader. I discovered how we in this coun- try are hampered by the etymological mean- ing of a term and the tendency to distrib- ute the term, in logical parlance, when discussing the problem. It was all due to American ignorance of the principles of economics and taxation. I told the people with whom I talked in private that I was a free-trader, having in mind the economic significance of the term, and was met with the that could not pay Federal expenses, if that policy applied. I saw at once what was the matter, and ever after that I abandoned the “free | trade” and deliberately resorted to the more | cumbersome phrases “taxation on imports | that we do not produce” and removal of | “taxation on what we do produce.” I never failed to convert a farmer or other person to my point of view when it was presented in that way, and he did not know he was accepting economic free trade. The situation is one which illustrates how social and political policies affect the meaning of terms. When the phrase “free trade” was adopted in England by the fol- lowers of Adam Smith, her system of taxa- tion for Government expenses was direct, and taxation on imports was not necessary and was applied in favor of monopolies. reply we were words Hence it was literally and etymologically “free trade” that the removal of them im- plied. But its economic meaning was not necessarily convertible with that, and no political difficulties arose in campaigning among the ignorant. It is quite otherwise in this country. Our Constitution requires the payment of Federal expenses by import taxes, and di- rect taxation is not permitted, except with a qualification, that is, in proportion to

Page 11

FO

Aug. 1, 1912]

population. In this situation we shoul either have to change our system of actual ; taxation or we could not pay Federal penses by the entire removal of import duties, which is what the publi inder- stands by “free trade,” its etyr og nterpretation. It is the wholly iniquitous our system of taxation that is responsi for this confusion. You can inflict al! sorts of commercial injustice under the name of “import” taxes, and the public would not find it out until long after Protec- tion” conforms in its meaning to “import” taxes, so far aS appearances go, and the public, knowing nothing about Uw inci dence of indirect taxation, will go «n and patiently endure all sorts of burdens until its bread begins to disappear What is needed is some short, crisp term whicn will indicate the situation and define for vs a system of taxation that can be seen at: clance. Whether this is possible is my contention. The economist might werk at that problem, But as long as We must have import taxes to pay Federal cxpense: the protectionist will have a clear oppo tunity to throw dust in the eyes of a peop! who will not inform itself on the pritciples of taxation JAMES H. HyYsI Tamworth, N. H., July 23 _ RAIDING THE TREASURY. To THE EpiToR OF THE NATION: Sir: One of the policies of the Empere Augustus took the form of making grants of money to impoverished Senators, to en able them to maintain their position by no’ falling below the Senatorial census of ons million sesterces (some forty-five or fift: thousand dollars’ worth of property) li once gave this sum to Hortalus, a grandson of the famous orator Hortensius, that thus Hortalus might marry, rear a family, and live in accordance with his rank. This nat urally tasted very sweet to Hortalus, aid iy, the next reign he wanted the dose r« peated. So he had his four sons present ai the door of the Senate House, and, while giving his opinion on another matter h injected his request as a “rider” to his speech on the matter in hand. The four boys were the great-grandsons of the great Hortensius, and the precedent had been set by dirus Augustus, What more natural then, than that the Senators should be fa vorably inclined towards passing this pie of special legislation. But Tiberius inte:- posed, in a speech sound to the core, and so replete with wisdom that I believe it wil! be welcomed by your readers in these days when our own national treasury is being increasingly depleted for the benefit of in dividuals, The speech is recorded by Taci tus in the thirty-eighth chapter of the se ond book of the “Annals,” and is commended to the notice of our next President: If all the poor people begin to come he: and seek money for their children, the dif ferent individuals will never be entire); satisfied, and the treasury will soon show a deficit (deficiet). Of course, when our fore fathers granted Senators the privilege of occasionally digressing from the particular topic up for discussion, and of expressing their views on matters conducive to the common good, it was never intended that we should here promote our private busi ness and add to the resources of our fami- lies. Such a course brines odium upon tl Senate and the Emperor, no matter whethe’ grant the iargets or relusé t Nx 1 we call this procedure a request is rather an imperious demand, made ul terly out of season, and sprung as a surpris ipon a Senate convened for other matter a Senator rises in hi lace, and by tl number and age of his children takes unfa edvantage of the Senate in this indelica' anner By so doing he acts in the sam¢ violent mode against and breaks hia Way, aS it were into the treasury, which will have to be replenished by wrong N if we exhaust it in our desire to gratify in dividuals The late lamented (dirvus) Au gustus gave you the money, H¢ not because you made a personal him, and certainly with no ex it should be given every ti: hoose to ask for it Otherw ‘ exertion will relax, and idleness will be promoted. People must be taught that only by self-reliance can they ward off the pov erty they fear or attain the success they hope for. Adopt any other principle than this, and the large majority of people (omnes) will become careless and will wait for other people to help ther being sloth ful themselves and a burden to us

That great Democrat, Grover Cleveland condensed this in his notable declaration (I quote from memory) It is the business of the people to support the Government. and not the business of the Government to sur ul port the people ADDISON HoGue Washington and Lee University Lexingtor Va July 15 CONGRESS OF THE HISTORY OF ART TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: SIR The ninth International Congress of the History of Art, which met at Munich in September, 1909, voted that Rome should be the meeting place of the next Coners which will accordingly be held in this city in the halls of the Royal Accademia de’ Lincei in the Palazzo Corsini The proceedings of this Congress will be of the greatest in terest and importance, not merely for their scientific and historical value as contribu tions to the history of art, but also because specia. attention will be given to the teach ing of this subject in universities and in schools of every description in which it can rightfully claim a place It will also be one of the chief objects of the Congress to consider the history of art in its in ternational relations. and more especial y the history of the artistic relations be tween Italy and other countries The papers and subjects for discussion will be grouped under the following four sections: (1) The History of Early Chris tian and Medi@val Art Down to the End of the Fourteenth Century (2) The Fif teenth Century (3) The History of Art from the Sixteenth Century to the Present Time (4) Historico-artistic Methodology; Care of Works of Art Historical Re searches in Technical Methods; General Or ganization of the Work of the Congresses The use of the Ita ian, French, German English, and Spanish languages is allow- ed, but it is noticeable that no subjects have as yet been announced in the Spanish or English language, although persons of both these nationalities have published the titles of papers they wil read For ex- ample, Dr. Thomas Ashby, director of the ' British School of Rome, will read a contri- bution in Italian, and Mrs. Strong, li- brarian of the same institution, in French. Among the names of many other well-known } persons on the programme are those of Mer. Wilpert, E. Wrangel, Henry Thode, Emie Bertaux, Carl Gebhardt, J. A. F.

Sire Hi k } \ , y t Ky i g li I Ad \ I T R , S 1 li’ Art iliana \\ I { ‘ g— €) sitior will t held < - ius } or rf ‘ st . 2 yf It i periodica “ n - r on or not or { al rt t ition Aarne is itaiogu ot priva tions 1talogzues 4) © t of paj pted for 1st n h t art ich ¢ insure, that is, durability nd J tographic reproductio exhibitors of the best shows und fir and last of these headings the Ital Ministry of Agriculture, Industry, and C« will award god medals, whils Congress itself will give diplomas to Winners in the other two expositions rh executive ommittec at Rome nounces at, a t reserves the right f adding t the programme until shortly be fore the date of meeting, those who expect to attend the Congress, and who wish read papers are invited to make known their intention to the general secretary Signor Roberto Papini, Via Fabio Mass 60, Ron Sienor Papini is also ready t receive the ibscriptions of those who wish to be “ ember of the Congress Tr subscription is twenty-fivefrancs; for ladies be onging to the family of a member, ter fra rT) embership, besides part tion in the eetings and social functions to t held it onnection with the Congre rincludes the right to reductions on rail ways in italy and other European cour tries, to fi ntrance to all Government and municipal museums and galleries for the entire month of October, entrance t private galeries and collections in Rome which are not usually open to the publ and to a opy of the proceedings of Congress H, | Rome, July

THE ROMAN PANTHEON To HE Ep! R « THE NATION Sin T nquiry in your issue of Ju) 18 regarding “The Pantheon in Rome perha t best answered in the words i is bb Book 53, chap. 27 76 re Tlawdecos wrvouague «efetreAece noomwayopevetar 64 er Taya mei ? TOAAw? Yews e.m0rvagq €h TOG GyaeAuaEe Te Té To \pews «a Tj TH Adpotirns, frahe ws te ¢ vouite tt «=odAoedég by te 3 obpar WHOTeOines nBovAnen wey obv 6 “Aypinwwas <a Avyoveror «vtavda itpvoa: rhw re Tod epyou éwiad aw aut ova “” befaudvor 2 avroi pnberepor (nee pew Te mpotepow Kaicapos dv be te apowd ToL Te Avyoveror “<a d¢avTo avéigudvtas éatnes He comp eted also the so-called Panthelor It has th name, perhaps because along with its dedicated statues—that of Mars and that of Venus—it received images of many gods; but as I think, because, being of rotunda form, it looks like the sky Agrippa wished, to be gure, to set up ther: the statue of Augustus as well, and ¢ ascribe the name of the structure to him (i. ¢., to name it after him); but, as he would accept neither honor, he placed in

Page 12

‘ former Cesar tibule nd of himself hi (pro height “x igonal upola ‘The Natio1 [Vol. 95, No. 2457 Literature THE GREAT STATE. m and the Great State: Essays in Construction. iy H. G. Wells, Frances Evelyn Warwick, L. G. Chioz- Lankester, C. J. Haynes, Cecil Chester- Roger Fry, G. Taylor, Conrad Noel, Herbert Trench, Hugh P. Vowles. New York: Harper & 2 za Money, E Bond, E. 8S. P. ton, Ray Cicely Hamilton, ce. Bros. $2 net. cone close ~ book that if what with Portia’s to do were good to do, this age ejaculation, were as to know had cottages his notion of easy as 7 is chape been churches, and poor Mr. fairly what but to to go Wells himself says the Great is still altogether unsubstantial. It mens Wells definite princes’ palaces. have a they and associates want, they do not appear know how Mr. conception of about to get it that their State is a project as dreamlike to-day ag elec- tric avia- in the year 1850 lighting, electric traction, or tion would have been A similar plaint is encountered through- out the book. Yet it is a stimulating publication, a positive enrichment, in fact, of the The reader, what- his previous con- politieal the moment air so- cialistic discussion. may of finds for at least breathing a freer and enter- taining the hope of a larger and more So long as hope continues to spring eternal in the hu- man breast, such pictures as Mr. Wells, the Countess of Warwick, Mr. Money, and the other contributors to this work have painted will be objects of delight- ful contemplation. Inevitably, however, the question arises, Is this too good ever Here and there throughout we encounter phrases which ever have been dition tude, economic or servi- himself captivating social life. to be true? these pages seem to savor of doubt, but on the whole one of abundant cheerful- “The permutations of life’s possi- to quote the final passage, “are telling tut this at least ve steadfastly believe: there is no in- uperable barrier between mankind and the tone 1s ness bilities,” beyond our the goal of our desire.” \ fairly presentation order is followed in this subject. H. G. Warwick and G. Taylor, had editorial charge of the publication) discusses ‘The Past and the Present of the Great State.” Next in’ order comes a treat- ment of “The Great State and the Coun- ide,” by the Countess of Warwick. 1.. G. Chiozza Money's outline of “Work in the Great State” properly occupies the third place. Then we find a discus- sion of the making of new knowledge, of health and healing, of law, of democ- racy, of women, and of the artist, by writers of such repute as Sir Ray Lan- Bond, FE. 8S. P. Haynes, logical of Lady the Wells rR. Stirling (who, with has try kester, C. J ‘ed Conservators. It Cecil Chesterton, Cicely Hamilton, and Roger Fry. This is succeeded by “The Present Development of the Great State” from the pen of G. R. Stirling Taylor. The Rev. Conrad Nobel pre- sents a “Picture of the Church in the Great State’; Herbert Trench traces “The Growth of the Great State,” and Hugh P. Vowles closes with a chapter on “The Tradition of the Great State.” We look in vain for what some would consider a most essential chapter—‘Fi- nancing the Change to the Great State.” The book, as might be expected of a work produced under such editorship, has a literary quality too often lacking The imag- ination is given a large place, but it is obvious that every effort has been made to keep it within the guidance of the reasoning faculty. The reader, never- theless, is not always able to tell where imagination ends and reason begins: a borderland between the two is not in- discernible, and one is sometimes im- pelled to cry out, “Tell me where is fan- cy bred, or in the heart or in the head?” Still, we have here a serious attempt at a synthesis of life, a theoretic recon- struction of human society along lines which for the most part run parallel with the best instincts of intelligent minds. H. G. Wells declares that this volume is essentially an in restate- ment, and to him has been committed the task of providing a nomenclature. Throughout this volume there is a “com- mon conception of a constructive pur- pose,” and what that common conception is Mr. Wells starts out to elucidate. In the effort he two expressions, which are employed by himself and his associates with a certain defined inten- tion. They are “The Normal Social Life” and “The Great State.” Each writ- er mvariably employs capitals in using these terms. The Normal Social Life is a type of human association and em- ployment, of extreme prevalence and antiquity, which appears to have been the lot of the enormous majority of hu- man beings as far back as history or tradition or the vestiges of material that supply our conceptions of the neolithic period can carry us. It has never been the lot of all humanity at any time; to- day it is perhaps less predominant than it has ever been, yet even to-day it is probably the lot of the greater moiety of mankind. Those persons who regard the Normal Social Life as the only prop- er and desirable life for the great mass of humanity are by Mr. Wells designat- is interesting, at this juncture, to learn that “the rural conservative, the liberal of the allot- ments and small-holding type, Mr. Roose- velt—in his Western-farmer philopro- genitive phase as distinguished from the phase of his more imperialist mo- ments—all present themselves as essen- tially Conservators, as seekers after and in discussions of this subject. exercise coins

Page 13

Aug. I, 1912] preservers of the Normal Social Life.” So, too, do Socialists of the William Mor- ris type; and so also do G. K. Chesterton and Hilaire Belloc. Opposed to the Conservators are two other classes. The first is composed of the Individualists, who appear to regard the extensive disintegrations of the Nor- that are going on to-day Tl ey voice mal Social Life with extreme hopefulness. the doctrine of the survival of the fit- test, believing that the future welfare of man may be trusted to the sponta- neous and planless activities of people of good-will, and that nothing but state interference « impede its attainment. Curiously, close to this ex- an effec tively treme optimistic school, in its moral quality and logical consequences, though contrasting widely in the sinister gloom of its spirit, is the socialism of Karl Marx. The Individualists and Marx con- verge in practice upon laissez faire. Planless Progressives is the name Mr. Wells has invented for them. On the other hand is the class which the writers of this volume of essays rep- resent, believes that the forces that have been assailing and disintegrat- ing the Normal Social Life are forces of wide and indefinite possibility that need to be controlled by a collective ef- fort implying a collective design, deflect- ed from merely injurious consequences and organized for a new human welfare upon new lines. To this class the name of Constructors is given. This greater social life is put forward as the only real alternative to the Normal Social Life from which man is continually escaping. It represents, in fact, the Great State. which Mr. Wells, in short, has set a compli- cated pattern for Lady Warwick, Mr. Money, and the rest to fill in. If in pre- senting their work for public inspection, they have left interstices, it is because they have refused to employ makeshift arguments and to invent a psychology more compatible with some of their the- ories of the Great State than the psy- chology which has dominated the race hitherto. They have taken human na- ture as they found it, and, believing it to be capable of a more rational develop- ment than it has ever had in the past, have pictured for it a millennial future, but they have not altogether forgotten the fact that they are dealing with the most intractable of all elements, human nature. Yet to some it will seem that this volume of essays is but a call to spirits to emerge from the vasty deep. Necessarily, the Great State implies a great advance in conscious rectitude on the part of the race. For thousands of years the prophets have been telling us that righteousness exalts a nation, and yet their message is still being vehem- ently preached, the only difference being that we now make a larger use of eco- nomic terms, of language which more dil- rectly connotes the purely material needs of mankind ze The Nation almost wholly in the light of is these that we must consider the appeal presented in this volume. Mr. Wells and those associated with him do not neglect the wsthetic side of life, but, af ter all, they strive to promote fly as a mere creature comfort t Ss not without a certain bo spect M Wells, r example, s , populat nin tl I I i oped lization emp! ! i s the hands of highly sl will mir toil to ft and declares t Q good pay, and all the in the evening camp that a and intelligent peopl themsel ve and there will t diff culty about this particula ' to differentiate it from any other sort of necessary labor.” It will be gathered f m this that agricultural laborers are no longer t spend their lives in grinding toil in iso lated regions, remote from the comfort and pleasures of town lif« They are to live in the cities and go out into th country to perform their few hours of daily toil. On the other hand, factory operatives are not going to be compelled Large cities, squalor, their yellow fog, and all thei other disgusting and debilitating fea tures, are to be obliterated. Lady War- wick says that the normal town of the Great State will probably have between to live in cities. with their fifty and sixty thousand inhabitants. How this would affect agriculture in such a country as Great Britain, it would perhaps be rash to assert. This much can be said, however: if all the cit ies of England, Scotland, and Wales of more than one hundred thousand popu lation were to be reduced to fifty thou sand, the displaced inhabitants undoubtedly be sufficient would in number to create at least three hundred new cit ies. That, of course, is an economic con sideration of no small importance The reader may not altogether share L. G. Chiozza Money’s hopefulness ré garding Work in the Great State, but will certainly admit the force of many of his denunciations of present econom ic conditions. Many persons will per haps share Mr. Money’s astonishment that in a nation of 44,000,000 souls about 20,000,000. of whom figure in the census as “engaged in occupations,” onl 9,000,000, or less than one-half of those working for gain, are engaged in eitl agriculture or industrial production; or, to put it somewhat differently, that onl) 45 per cent. of males over eighteen years iterial er of age are direct producers of m commodities. Many will also agree with him that there is a prodigious waste of producers’ work by reason of work which is involved in industrial pro cesses that are but the servants of un necessary competition The conception of the Great State is that the whole of the adult population will be organized to produce a minimum standard of life, expressed by th t put and distribution of the material p ts and services necessary to ! t I vork rie | < ? ‘ p i dual B iu I sory nd | i i ! ! iced ' ’ ‘ nad ] ‘ I da i i d aqaanyv « 1 bulk f l i t I i t he ne ' en ' 1? t and will be f , i i? 7 it t} if pa t ‘ I i a me t pa or ph j yher t ( ramat i é 1 sportsma idler T 5 ery dividual will have a _ pr nal and an amateur lif ind art i i product of the latter. | e have the Great State oadest outlines. It is a splendid refu tation of the chars hat faith has pe hed from off the face of the earth. Yet t could be wished that tl authors f this volume of essays were more ex plicit regarding the means of conver ug faith into works It is a little d concerting to find Sir Ray Lankeste1 writing as follows with reférence to the Making of New Knowledge “T confess that, after spending the best part of my energies during nearly fifty vears in endeavoring to increase the 1 ber vy fellow-citizens who have arrived at a ust estimate of the val 0 I knowledge and of tl for organization of it pursuit by the xpenditure of p funds, IT am di ppointed with the result.” And it omewhat discouraging to encounter this in Mr. Haynes's « ivy on Law and the Great State It is difficult to antic pate ar particular d velopments of tl la ROVE I ne f fatu of omen as dependent or independent of men, when the whole institution of mo nogamy, so-called, that now ¢ t mav fundamentally altered; and the diffi eulty r n more for dable in regard to child nd succe on of propert Sur matte I will leave to my col agues th a certain relief.” His col gue it hould be said, display no ilacrity in accepting the task. It looks very much as if the Great State would find woman a difficult prob el Cicely Hamilton, who writes on that aspect, says: “If I refrain from the in which the influence of women prophecy concerning particular d rection vho have attained to complete recogn tion of citizens and individuals will make itself felt in the atate of the fu ture, It is, honestly, because I find such

Page 14

proj I lificult, but im ! Phere i however, nothing ih declaration that “what is I the right to demand of her ly « indirectly, by bribe ct pressure—is that she, in return for its protection, shall consider | nd any obligation to produce its future tizen Perhaps it is too much to ask a con structor to be a criti Yet it could be " ied tha Wells and his friends, in framing up t Great State, had re called hat Lowell once said: “A wise skeptic is the first attribute of a good crit Hle must not believe that the insurance offices will raise their ates of premium on Charles River, be- cause the new volume of poems is print ng at Riverside or the University Pres CURRENT FICTION. The Children of Alsace (“Les Oberlé”) By René Bazin New York: John Lane Co The Penitent (‘Donatienne”). The same Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. Davidee Birot. The same. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. Ml. Bazin, whose recent visit to this country in connection with the unveil- ing of the Champlain monument is prob- simultaneous ably responsible for the appearance of three of his novels, of which only one is new, from as many different publishing houses, has been for a long time the principal exponent in French fiction of the provincial, patriot ic, and Roman Catholic tradition as op- posed to the literature of disenchant- ment and unbelief which centres’ in Paris In none of the three books we are considering is there a direct attempt te the polemist; the pleties of home, manifest. Now and then we come in touch specific In “Les Oberlé,”’ which created a sensation it was first published ten years ago, the prob The subject is play but in all of them writer's sympathy with the simple altar, and fatherland is with a issue when lem comes out clearest struggle of the people of the obstinate Alaace against absorption by the Ger manic conquero! “Davidée Birot,” the latest story of the three, is the history fa little achool-teacher in a remote cor ner of Brittany Here we touch, though slightly upon the conflict between church and atate over the control of public education, with a hint, naturally, at the bigotry of the present political régime In “The Penitent” the tragic story is founded upon the custom which takes sO many pearant women away from their homes to play the foster mother to children of wealthy Parisians But with a fine and sure art, M. Bazin never fails to keep his personages and their fortunes clear of the general prob lem Even in Oberlé.” which ts openly and fervidly a piece of patriotic ‘Les The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2457 pleading, the characters are very real, own simple fashion. Senti- ment there is in plenty in every one of his stories, but M. Bazin has not found it necessary to plunge too deeply into sen- timentality in his against the ’ spirit. “Davidée Birot,” as a of the antique womanly and char- ity, will bear comparison with the “Liza” of Turgenieff, of whose highly concen- highly restrained style M. Bazin reminds one. The simplicity of plot which is characteristic of all his stories shows best in “The Penitent,” a story of poignant realism in the finest traditions of classic fiction. M. Bazin’s books are certainly much better suited to the inherent taste of American read- ers than the great mass of the better- known literature of Paris. after their revolt ‘Parisian convincing embodiment virtues of sacrifice trated and — The Charioteers. By Mary Tappan Wright. New York: D. Appleton & Co. If a fable writer chose to make his animals change spots at every para- graph so that the leopard of the outset became successively a mongoose and a woodchuck, there would be neither limit nor criticism for the antics in which his creatures might be involved. On only some such theory of disorderly evolu- tion may one follow the characters in “The Charioteers.” Professor Manson of Great Dulwich College, Grecian and archeologist, husband of a dissolute wife and father of two growing boys, begins with a reasonable thoughtfulness for the reputation of the woman whom he would like to marry. After he falls ill in Greece and she has nursed him into health, passing as his wife, he still is the prudent, practical planner for ap- pearances and the conventions. On their return to America, when a divorce has made marriage possible, he is insistent on festivity and a wedding journey—in ' the dying husband who says, hospita- bly, “Come in; this is truly delightful; Nellie and I have been having the most charming talk.” “I don’t believe,” he adds after the intruder has departed, “there’s another woman in the world that could have played up to my game as she did. It has been most amusing— but tremendously exhausting.” Even granting the characters, a liter- ary chaos confuses the main issue. The irregular connection between hero and heroine is a failure, yet neither seems to regret it. The climax is not its rueful ending, which might have lent tragic im- port to the story. But we are called upon to follow Octavia’s subsequent heart adventures. These were, Item: one thwarted love for a youth eleven years her junior; one friendly accept- ance of an elderly suitor. The secon- dary characters are as incoherent as the principals. Billy, the soul of chivalry, does not await the answer to his pro- posai of marriage before engaging him- self to another woman. Calvert, who enters the scene like a satyr—a man |who, “with but two exceptions, always j|makes the good women uncomfortable” |—{s he who emerges the good genius of | unselfishness. even exaggerated ways showing himself | a stickler for conformity. Can this be) the same man who, having obtained his wish and found no flaw In the woman, should suddenly at fifty go utterly to pieces? Octavia, on her part, once flung herself into the situation, is too lofty-minded to conceal and regards her “rehabilitation” by mar- riage as almost insulting. Yet it is she who will not go to him, desperately ill|an eager adversary. having | anything Beyond illustrating the tendency of the large Bent fimily to “drift” in matters of the affections, no focal motive is discoverable in this nov- All else is a pathless jungle. The flora is minutely pictured; the fauna is often found in pungent conversa- tion; but the scene is a quagmire of no bottom and of none too sweet an odor. el. A Captain Unafraid: The Strange Ad- ventures of Dynamite Jimmy O’Brien. As set down by Horace Smith. New York: Harper & Bros. The faith and practice of filibustering are here set forth with candor and en- thusiasm. Capt. Jimmy O’Brien, who is supposed to tell the story, believes frankly in the inalienable right of any man to supply arms and munitions of war to any other man or group of men, at any time. It is quite clear, how- ever, that if that right had been legal as well as moral, Capt. Jimmy would have lost his opportunity in life. For he was fitted by nature to be a smuggler and buccaneer of the heroic type. He de- lights to pit his wits against those of He recounts with in the South, partly because she sus-/the gusto of the successful gamester the pects that another woman is taking care | long series of expeditions, carrying men of him, but also because she is “not sure|or supplies, or both, for the Cuban she has the right,” since doubts have |cause, which under his generalship suc- been cast upon the validity of the di- And it is she who, finding him vorce, ceeded in setting out under the very noses of the American detectives and faithless to her, can say, “But you, my | Spanish spies who were working togeth- poor Ned, can be a true husband to no/er to prevent his operations. If you had stood by Nellie’ | his feats in this kind seem to have been woman. Some of (the drunken wife), “I should not be|done in sheer bravado—feats such as here to suffer.” The horrid limit of in-|the landing of an expedition almost under consistency for a supposed gentleman |the walls of Morro Castle, by way of re- is reached when wife number to finds ‘tert courteous to bloodthirsty threats on wife number one gayly taking tea with the part of the discomfited Gen. Weyler.

Page 15

And our doughty captain is by no means averse to a “scrap.” The landing of his expeditions involves the burning of some powder, though the amount of blood shed in these pages is surprisingly small. One thing is plain—Dynamite Jimmy makes it plain: if it hadn't been for him, the course of history would have been altogether different. But for his supplies, the Cubans would have suc- cumbed to Spanish power, as they had so many There would have been no Cuban freedom, and there would have been no Spanish War to inflate the breast of the patriot—and the pensioner. times before. BOLIVAR AND THE SPANISH COLO- NIES. jolivar et Vémancipation des Colonies Espagnoles des origines a@ 1815, By Jules Mancini. Paris: Perrin et Cie. 7.50 francs. In its perspective and documentation, this should be the most important work vet published on the transition of Span- ish America from the colonial rule of three centuries to an untried indepen- dence. The diplomatic services of the author and his present post at the French Foreign Office have opened the various national archives to him after making him skilful in their use; and he has been industrious in the study of con- temporary printed matter and memoirs. As a European trained to the traditions of Government affairs, he has a wider field of vision than native American his- torians or students whose knowledge is limited to the documents in their hands. He has also an intimate acquaintance with the social as well as the political facts of the time and place—knowledge which unusual in English-speaking historians. With all this, the work is neither complete nor final, for reasons obvious when we have seen what it real- ly does for us. In a first book, the author traces the beginnings of revolution from the Span- ish Conquest in the sixteenth century and the organization of the colonial régime; the signs of a predisposition to independence on the part of inhabitants of the New World and the Comuneros of the eighteenth century; the liberal reforms attempted by King Charles IIIT; the disastrous expulsion of the Jesuit missionaries resulting in the destruction of their immense work and a moral abasement of the popular classes; and then, one after the other, the stimulus of example from the independence of the United States and from the French Revolution, with the underhand encour- agement of England, resulting in pre- mature attempts like that of 1794, for which Antonio Narifio was condemned to transportation to Africa as being a “partisan of an independent republic like that of Philadelphia”! This brings us to the youth of Bolivar among disci is 'certain The ples of Rousseau Nation (the literary embargo Was such that the text of the Rights of Man was received in New Grenada only in 1794, through the Viceroy); his jour neys to Spain and France; the influence of Humboldt and Napoleon, and particu larly of Freemasonry The second book is very justly devoted to Miranda the “Precursor” and to the lovyalism in the colonies which withstood the attempted Revolution of 1810 and the First Republic of Venezuela. In the third book, from 1812 Bolivar takes con trol of the irrepressible movement in New Grenada and Venezuela, with its Second Republic; and the volume ends with the restoration Ferdinand VII in Spain and the state of revolution in his American territories at the of 1814—from La Plata to Mexico In his preface, the author reads to us the meaning of this upheaval of the New World as he understands it: ot end 1 so By its effect on the political and life of peoples, the Emancipation of the Spanish colonies is an event of as consid erable importance as the discovery of th: continent where they were established. Th struggle engaged by the creoles against Spain on the morrow of the French Revolu tion, and pursued for more than a quarter of a century with equal rage on either side. was the prolongation on a new scene of the age-long conflict between two ideas whose alternate success and defeat domi nate History—Traditionalism and Liberty In truth, it was owing to the results of South American Independencs that the great movement of 178), ready to yield to the thrust of Restoration in 1815, was re vived in Europe and triumphed in 1830 |The peoples awaked to national life and consciousness The modern world evolved toward the Republican ideal Of this ideal, Bolivar is for America th: immortal symbol. If ever a man summed up in himself the tendencies of an epoch and personified an idea, it was very truly he whom his compatriots hailed with th: signal title of Liberator. The life of Boli- var serves to frame the Revolution in which he took the chief part In the framework, as we have it here, connections are wanting—prob- ably without fault of the author. In the preparation of the Revoiution among the people of the colonies, he insists rightly on the influence of former Jesuits after the violent of their order and the expulsion of its members by Spain; but he is too content—sympa thetic even—with the label, to inquire what it covered precisely. see clearly that these were sons of the country driven from home and the life career which they had chosen, mainly to the Roman states, lead lives of want without place or work, and, with the passing of their youth, slowly drift- ing back to their native New World, where their education up to the date of Europe made them an uneasy ferment. In North America also, where the Jesuits of Maryland had been able to keep together, they followed their lead suppression He does not to ‘ na ritt irienad Ceru and of Mirabeau in the ¢ evolution, another exam) by " religious vouth in the little This particular ious Spanis!) is had that time drifted principl of understood Com] influence amon colonies was individua scarcely reguilal spontante ous, astical, and without organizatior M. Mancini, in general, has no nected view of the revolutionary att tude of the organized and powerful ligious communities. Niles, a Conne cut Senator of the time (whose tensely prejudiced testimony is wort less except as a contemporary report of what was commonly said, attributes th« of the friars, perhaps to younge! Without this cle: it is doubtful introduction Rousseau's “Contrat S« cial” to and native brothers. al favor, such as it was, if the revolutions Spanish-American could have been accomplished. As number to the real leaders few in the revolutions according to Dr very all Gustave as is case in popular Le had then there is no doubt where they their and they ton Among their Europ sufficiently concerning expediency as their drunk inspiration selves with ‘an con fidants, were explic it sole rea son for admitting the religious element into their patriotic oaths. This is noted our author, along with the general of French philosophy and the by influence organization of Freemason lodges But here, too, he has no precise acquaintances with the organized influence of Free masonry. In fact, it is only now being studied dispassionately in the history of the French Revolution. It is curious that here in South America we see a shadowy intervention of Franklin. The introduction of Freemasonry into Mex ico by the American Poinsett will at once recur to those conversant with the history, as distinct from the controversy of the subject. Humboldt's be in rule, tific under States, rather results of Spanish he found institutions more highly developed it than in the English United of which he had apparently no great opinion at that time from his short Visit testimony would of the because favor rf) perhaps scien Among the Revolutionary leaders questions oftener§ than particularly No defence is given of certain acts of Miranda, which need explanation, while Bolivar’s case is ex po ed without comment. They may have of a piece with their time and country; but the suspicion arises that the real people had revolution thrust unon them. M. Mancini is not sive here, because he has evidently not worked out the complete facts nor his own facts completely. For the scientific student of history, there is a materia! moral arise among our own heroes, the use of cruelty if been conclu

Page 16

not be research world index of proper en to the treasures which is left to publish appeared Alberto tevolution onnection lation Etche ideo. tran an G f Montev f the evil as ; of the trans revolutionary were already an evolution al Currents in Paul Reinsch. Mifflin Co. $2 Politi By and Fast Houghton tual Fai Roston S 1et. There are those who may find it hard re Profe n the East. ad or Reinsch’s long essays The essays are old-fashion- couched philosophy, and eld reader who tries them higher aim than to his place with distinction at a din- tabl But the book admirable, both for its quality and for When eight chapters em- ed their thoroughness, are in in the language of few gleanings to the with no take nel is altogether the spirit in which it is written it is said that these ibjects that are, for their limits, and that they lack discursive quality which ill should have, there nothing more to which exception can be perhaps, too ree pleasant good essays is ken. Among the pitfalls that beset the Asia to-day the ved and misleading series of con West East in a discussion upon ary writer on is hackne ts offered between and Reinsch, which possesses a really born of irrepressi Unity,” flavor, dismisses fears llusion that there is onflict between Orient and Occident valid that Asiatics human and while tra find our an ground are, er all, a as we are, irked differences exist In customs, ' ind social policies, we can trident conflict with no That this conclusion does not acceptance among most com people only renders more nec which should be upon though Che verdict ound one ul@at So, too, is xed question of the Asi is put down as a unpalatable his treatment of the ve Oriental truthfulness Because lacks accuracy, he liar Truth, like be matter of conventional standards told atic is largely a “Vo. 2en- uty, racity,” we are in a luminous modity The Nation in England and America, in many cases scarcely involving any moral valuations at all.” continues] that most that pro- But we shall find [he ental honesty which should belief, Oriental 1 he evated fundar requires ictions to our corre spond d our gard peoples those of their beliefs own, but at ance be Confucian- in as high re as with ideals than our also less vari elief nd Buddhists rity of good Christian peop attitude that among than among le. More- or honest toward the ] charac- Buddhists and lan which Con- imagined; wise re- du- optim- ptim early seen, social et, and no facile gloss over our life's It will be a shock to some supporters of the propaganda learn that it is not Western culture as such, the of our religion, that set up barriers between East and West, but the profound discrepancy between Chris- tian profession and practice. Antagon- ism between races is not so much a mat- ter of standards as of friction. It prom- eventually to sink in China and Japan to relatively unimportant dimen- sions, while these nations develop their own destinies with the aid of Western machinery. For these peoples will re- tain their autonomy. In India, however, the author believes that “in measure as the consciousness of victor and conquered have reached clearness of ex- pression, this antagonism will be more pronounced.” The outlook is a gloomy one, and the conclusion rather unflatter- ing after a century of pretty honest ef- fort on the part of the British. Yet he is not a severe critic of British rule. The deduction is interesting as revealing an inherently impossible task in which they involved. Beyond his reprobation for the illiberal policy of the Govern- ment in scientific equipment for India, and the lack of training allowed natives in the responsible conduct of public af- fairs, he seems to think highly of the English administration. One point may be noted in which he fails to do them full justice. His statement that out of 1,307 places in the higher civil service only 97 were held by natives would have been materially modified if he had consulted more recent returns. In 1910 the Indian proportion of these better ap- pointments was above 26 per cent., and Christian to or tenets ises social are the discrepancy continuously lessens. It must inferred from the length of this critique on his earlier chapters that Professor Reinsch devotes the most of his volume to India, China and. Japan come in for attentive and im- partial consideration. A chapter on each of the three countries is given to a survey of the literature and leaders that influenced their intellectual life. not be have [Vol. 95, No. 2457 tion of permanent value-to those who are desirous of determining some of the causes of the present unrest in the Far East and who realize that the Oriental mind is being called to action quite as much by impulses of its own as by its fear of aggressive Occidentalism. It may afford the dispassionate inquirer a new sensation to learn that a Chinese general of the Ming dynasty propounded a philosophy like that of Hobbes which embodied the highest truths in action. This apostle of energism has recently received an intellectual throne and _ become the inspiration of modern China. “It is certainly,” observes the author, “a remarkable instance of common impulses moving the entire civilized world, when such theories of the actualization of thought are acclaimed in the Orient at the same time when the philosophical and ethical thinkers of the West are be- ing attracted by Pragmatism.” The Religion of the Ancient Celts. By J. A. MacCulloch. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $4 net. Two general features may be said to characterize Dr. MacCulloch’s treatise on Celtic religion, if we compare it with the rather numerous books on the sub- ject written in recent years. In the first place, it deals with the Celtic world as a whole, and is not restricted to a single period or region. It includes within the range of its inquiry the tes- timony of ancient classical historians and that derived frorn neo-Celtic litera- ture or modern popular tradition; and it brings out, perhaps better than any of its predecessors, the relations among these different classes of evidence. Sec: ondly, the author is not addicted to any particular theory of mythology or relig- ion. Bertrand’s “La Religion des Gau- lois,” one of the most influential recent works in the same field, was dominated, and its conclusions were to some extent vitiated, by a dubious classification of the races of Gaul; and Sir John Rhys’s learned and brilliant “Hibbert Lectures” made venturesome use, as the author would be one of the first to admit, of the method of extracting divine myths from heroic sagas. But no_ special formula or process is to the same ex- tent a controlling principle with Dr. MacCulloch. If anything, he verges to- wards the opposite extreme of eclecti- cism in the theories he sets forth; and his work lacks the coherence and con- tinuity, as well as the originality, of the others we have mentioned. By way of compensation, however, the reader will find that Dr. MacCulloch presents his material more objectively than most mythologists; that he frequently offers a choice of doctrines or opinions; and that, while he is not averse to occasion- al speculation (as in his discussion of the.bull-god, at page 140, or of the civ- tence, “is a social and commercial com-' This portion of the book is a contribu- ilization of the bronze age, at page 148),

Page 17

Aug. 1, 191 “I the element of conjecture is not unduly ! prominent in his pages. Whatever the merits and defects of the author’s method, the resulting trea- tise is an excellent survey of the whole field of Celtic religion. No important phase of the subject is overlooked, and there are very few phases on which the reader cannot obtain satisfactory guid- ance in respect to facts and opinions. To say that many topics are treated inade- ‘quately is only to recognize the imper- fect knowledge which scholars yet pos sess of the whole field of Celtic antiqui- ties. Institutions and practices like the taboo (Irish geis), fasting against an enemy, or working destruction by satirical verse, are often dismissed by Dr. MacCulloch in a few sentences, though each topic would afford material for a monograph. But the evidence on many such subjects still remains to be collected from the voluminous literature of the Celts, and an author could hardly canvass it all single-handed. The sources of information are only half-accessible, and progress in investigation is neces- sarily slow. “Apart from the general plan and method of the work, many other fea- tures deserve praise. Dr. MacCulloch shows, on the whole, a full knowledge of the vast and widely scattered litera- ture of his subject, and he can conse- quently be trusted to indicate very well the present state of opinion about the various questions he discusses. His pre- liminary observations, for example, on the racial mixture in the Celtic peoples and on the resulting complexity in their religion are sound and important. The breadth of his outlook is also to be com- mended. He makes constant comparison between the beliefs and customs of the Celts and those of other peoples, thus putting both in a clearer light. In in- sisting that cults and practices of a primitive or barbarous character are not always to be branded as non-Aryan, he corrects a frequent, though ill-grounded, assumption. When dealing, furthermore, with various matters of controversy, where his conclusions are not necessar- ily decisive, his discussions are usually cogent and profitable. Cases in point are his arguments on the existence of a general Celtic pantheon (pp. 124 ff.), on the supposed non-Celtic origin of the druids (pp. 296 ff.), and on the eschato- logical intepretation of the Celtic para- dise (pp. 362 ff.). In a treatise which is so largely con- cerned with recondite and disputed questions it would be easy, of course, to find points of disagreement with the au- thor. But a collection of detailed crit- icisms is hardly worth while here. Speaking in a general way, we should say that Dr. MacCulloch might well have made a clearer statement than he did of the successive stages, as he con- ceives them, in the development of Cel- tic religion. The topical arrangement of the book rather obscures the general The Nation lines of such a development, thor’s view nowhere clearly and the au- appears. In the separate chapters, too, more atten- tion might here and there have been paid to chronology in the arrangement of the materials. The reader is not al- ways sure, as things stand, how much evidence for a given institution is an- cient and how much is modern. Both the foregoing considerations concern rather the clearness of Dr. MacCulloch's presentation than the correctness of his teaching. His actual tionable statements of fact errors or ques so far as we have observed, are few, and they occur chiefly where linguistic information is involved. The gen’ral history of the Ceitic languages Dr. MacCulloch to have mastered, though his exposition of it (at pp. 15 ff.) is a little huddled and obscure. But relation to the whole philological side of his subject, we note the lack of referenc: recent authorities, mars of Thurneysen or the “Thesaurus of Stokes and Strachan; and in the handling of linguistic details the quite free from inaccuracy The older form of the Irish for “druid” drui and not drai, as given on p. 293. The discussion of Lochlarn, on p. 147, ig- nores the earliest form, Lothlann, and the etymological implications that it carries. And such spellings Kul and Matholwych, occurring re- peatedly for Kulhwch and Matholwch, or “Transactions of the Society of Cymmro- dor” for “Cymmrodorion,” even if they are misprints, seem to betray a lack of seems in s to the more the Pedersen, such as gram and Palwohibernicus is author not word is as hwuch acquaintance with Welsh. Finally, we should like to know why the St. Gall Incantation mentioned on p. 76 and p. 9- rc) reference to Irische (in the former place with a wrong Tezrte, I, p. 56,) is described as a spell for making butter. | The purpose of reciting the formula is clearly to remove a thorn, and the but. ter is used quite in the working of the charm. incidentally White Mountain Trails. By Packard. Boston: Small, Co. $3 net. Arrayed in what Lowell used to call Winthrop Maynard & an “edition de looks’—though the fifty somewhat murky illustrations are hard- ly in keeping—has appeared a book of White that a Mountain will win essays popular- travel not altogether undeserved The but ity. essays not are “nature those of Mr. Packard's He has wandered from mid- Chocorua to late-September Mt. Washington, that “highest of the Appalachian gods,” infinite gusto the trees and birds and butterflies and even the frogs and lichens; and he now reports his observations, in his cus- tomary sprightly vein, for the delecta- tion of the “nature-lover.” His eye is as are pa- pers, essays” sim- ilar to books. May earlier altar noting with 105 acute as Mr. Burroughs’s, and his style, though it has the taint of journalism, is engaging. writers on nature displayed their kn: quite as Seldom have « ledge so easily, almost Mr. Packard’: his subject defect nature lore is inclined to run away unconsciously close leads his Indeed, acquain with him to a tance characteristi knowledge of Wit him. To all appearances, it is impos ble for a writer in this age to best his attention on the landscape with acquiring an unliterary interest in the facts of nature “The cool, shad depths here,” writes our author, “will al ways be marked in my mind as the pla of great gray toads as if the cool depths were not more estimable than the toads therein! Elsewhere he re ked bravado, “All beetle which !s hardly so ill marks with wi look alike to me as he implies; but before long, as he encounters “a score of varieties. of dip tera and hymenoptera,” he utters the pious wish that he had at his service “a convocation of the Cambridge Entomo logical Society to name and describe them for me.” And throughout the book he forces into the gasping mouth of the reader such strange morsels as verat rum viride, grapta interrogationis, and eupatorium urticafolium, even when an agreeable English name is at hand In scientific manuals, where accuracy is everything, these things are proper; in literary essays, where reality supersedes actuality, they are distinctly out of place. Homo, the only animal, after all, in which we are perennially interested, appears but rarely in Mr. Packard's book. It is by no means clear that the old-fashioned artists were absurd in placing a human figure in their land scapes. Whatever may be the case in painting, Bradford Torrey, in his “Foot: ing It in Franconia,” gained much by including human beings in his White- Mountain essays; it is significant that Mr. Packard writes effective- lv when he writes about himself, which and most he does only too sparingly. So much of the book is devoted to lit- tle things—to butterflies and frail plants that the reader seldom brought to the mountains themselves. At intervals, the author reaches a moun- is to be sure, tain top, whence he may see lake and forest and other crests; but his mode of description is too often a matter of names, as if he were a Cook's guide pointing out the various celebrated peaks. Once, indeed, he resists the climbing instinct, preferring to allow Moat Mountain to remain “a soft haze of half-reality,” and somehow one feels closer to this mountain than if one had been conveyed the of it Mr. Packard is himself aware of the com- parative futility of mountain climbing; “it Is the unclimbed peaks,” he con- fesses after he has climbed most of them, “which are eternal.” Sensations of giddiness and “uplift” we may enjoy to top

Page 18

i ft Nati ‘ } we we ] i aright I White-M ta papers a hard i ful terar says, rthel ful hey Do ] rmation, and the informa ! il ) ag ibly impart- l i fears tl gidity of hand- f enabled to know me birds and flo ind in- Vhite ntains without ok contalr is ce Lady Jar G By Richard Davey. New York: E. P. Dut n & C $5 net I ite Major Martin A. S. Hume has | onsiderable group of disciples » bid fair to perpetuate the sort of il and biographical work which made the master so widely known. Mr I 3 prominent among them, and t present volume, really a sequel to Nine Days Queen,’ which appeared tl yea ago, displays all the merits 1 defects characteristic of the “Ro Biographies.’ It tells the ) of the fe of Charles Brandon, Duke of } ‘ arried the sister of Henry Vill and ame the grandfather ot i | G and then describes the DI i I f Lad Jar Gi S t Katherine and Mary, their , vithout Queen Elizabeth's ntrigues that surround ind their ruthles perse ‘ reign who dreaded Dp ble claimants to tl Tudor r) plenty of romance and i ' these three live ind when lull pla ir Mr. Davey is perfectly to leave the path that has been d ou for him, and ramble off f int, though doubtless enter i nts of royal marriages and ( ! tal pageant His book is in 1 fe amusement rather than for ! t is neither good history graphy but it will doubtless give a slight taste of Tudor ts and Tudor time to the increas | irge proportion of readers whose cl are too weak to digest stan | book teems with careless errors I print most of which occur in i er part for Mr. Davey knows I i VIII far lese well than his I bert It would be useless to enumer- " " divagations, but the follow nay be cited as examples: “Cal ta r “Carstairs” (p. 10); “Regi nald de la Pol for “Edmund de la Pol (p > Me Be Louls XI" for Louis XII” (p. 19); “epithallum’sS for epithalamium” (p 116) Neither Thoma nor “William” Cavendish wrote a life of Wolsey (p. 88); the blog- rapher'’s name was “Georg: We would respectfully suggest that an obvious ex ‘The planation of the “mysterious” favor hown by Wolsey to Brandon (pp. 56-7) is the Cardinal's desire to use him to Nation Ss counterbalance the influence of the How- rds in the Council. And, finally, we think that Mr. Davey would do well if he refrained from attempting to adver- tise his own accuracy by dilating on the errors of Froude. That that great his- torian made (and atoned for) numerous minor slips, every student of Tudor his- tory knows; in fact, it takes no very remarkable degree of acumen to dis- cover them. But what renders Mr. Davey’s arraignment of him peculiarly superfluous is the fact that the particu- lar mistake (in regard to the date of Lady Mary Grey’s marriage) which he goes out of his way to expatiate upon (p. 255) was perceived and corrected by Froude himself in a subsequent vol- ume (“History of England,” Vol. VIII, p. 204, n. 3; New York, 1868). Non tali aurilio does the true historian vindicate his learning Notes Sc. I Vaughan is liting, for the ‘ bridge University Press Putnam), a tion of rhe Polit ul Writings of RR Karl Giellerup’s romar The Pilgrim Ix ta is soon to appear in an English i ition (Dutton) Tr! ime house has Ii ress a new by Maarten Maarten i The story of Paradise Regained Williams & Norgate will publish in the Vol. I of a catalogue of works on ind international law the Nobel of Christiania Rider Haggard'’s “Maris innounced ) \ugust by Longmans, Green, recounts ry of a boyhood love affair in \tr 1 Lett from the late Justin McCarthy to Mr Campbell Praed will be issued in the by Chatto & Windus They are id » contain graphic pictures of inter- ting political situations, especially in the xis of the first and second Home Rule bill Theodore Dreiser has chosen a male haracter for the principal figure of his new novel, which will soon be published by Harpers Smith & Elder are bringing out a po- litical novel by G. A. Birmingham The Red Hand of Ulster which attempts to iy in advance what Ulster will do when the Home Rule bill is passed The Moon Endureth Tales and Fan- jew ia the title of a volume by the Eng- lish author, John Buchan, which Sturgis & Walton publish next month In “Prophetical, Educational, and Play- Ing Cards,” Mra John Kine Van Rensse- laer attempts to give a comprehensive his- tory of cards; the book is announced by George W. Jacoba Co The Century Company's announcements include Maurice Francis Egan's | [ Vol. 95, No. 2457 “Everybody's St. Francis,” with twenty i!- lustrations by the French artist, Boutet Monvel. We have received from the America Library Association, Chicago, the A. I A. Catalog, 1904-1911." It contains om" titles, compiled for a popular library, w notes and indexes, edited by Elva L. Bas- om Four volumes have. lately been added ¢ Everyman's Library (Dutton). A reissue ot Bolton King’s “Life of Mazzini,” whi first appeared in 1902, has allowed th: author to square his statements with the many letters of Mazzini which this interval of ten years has brought light. Writings by William Canton fil another volume—“The Invisible Playmats W. V., Her Book,” and “In Memory otf W. V.” They celebrate the life of a gir who died young, and picture a child's world with rare understanding From the field of medizwval romance, the editors have now selected the chronicles of Wace and Layamon, both being rendered into modern English prose. As is well known, Laya- mon, shortly after 1200, freely adapted the Norman Wace's de Brut,” in turn handed much of the that fountain-head of mediwval ri Monmouth thi “Roman whi down lore great mance—Geoffrey of In r form, laymen may for the knights convenient them ginnings of the Table another present search with profit rough be- the chivalrous who sat 4 fourth medizval volume con- “Piers examined it found. at tains WOrk Plowman.” So far we have Arthur Burrell’s as attempt to reprodu modern English is to be original metre in cessful as was expected suc What i the significance of the recent output of novels and life of Testament? Ss lramas concerned wi the other figures of E. Mosher a “pronounced re- and Ww. towards in the cultural future.” of the (Putnam) the Christ New mat i ligious the called Recent bells ves points trend development In his book Christ Literature’ he of this contention a account of the “Hilligenlei,” CLrist,” Sudermann’s “John,’ Rostanl’ The Samaritan Woman,” Widmann’s “Th: Saint and the Animals,” Andreyeff's “Judas and the Others,” Kennedy's “T) in the House,” Fogazzaro rhe Pontopiddan’'s “The Promized and Hauptmann’s “The Fool Here is a cloud of witnesses worthy immediate “The ol Promise Age in presents in support somewhat vorks “Anti- extended following Frenssen's Lager léf's Iscariot Servant Saint,” Land,” in Christ.” of a more critical examination than they have undergone at the hands of Mr Mo- shet. It should be obvious at a glance thet the testimony of this various compauy can- not be unanimous. Fogazzaro’s “Saint” points in one direction, and Sudermann John” in another. One reflects a religious imovement; the other has no religious imn- pertance whatever. Mr. Mosher hints a acubt here and there as to whether the vhenomenon under consideration is die t> socliulistic or to a religious impuls, but he seems to overlook the wsthetic consider- ations altogether. If we are not mistaken, works like “John” and “The Samaritan Woman” and “The Fool in Christ” are at- tributable rather to the decay than to the reflorescence of religious faith. They indi- cate not that the New Testament is gaining

Page 19

Aug. I, 1912] bew veneration as to the source of religious that it has become attractive source of literary material, like the of the Volsungs and the Nibe- lungenlied, with the additional advantag« that it has not been exhausted by a Willian doctrines but the story at Morris or a Richard Wagner. Extend the inquiry a little and ask after the religious significance of Flaubert’s “Temptation of Saint Antony” or Anatole France's “Thais.’ What does the pleasure of the nusi hall at the dance in “Salome” foretoken’” In the sensuous imagination that curiously up the of Jesus” luxuriates in the sins of Magdalen but a dubious augury of a spiritual renais onjures “sweetheart and we find sance Francis Gribble, author of “George Sand nd Her Lovers,” “Rousseau and the Women He Loved,” “The Romantic Life of Shelley and other romances in history and biog graphy, now comes forward with a char acteristic tome entitled, “The Comedy of Catherine the Great” (Putnam). Mr. Grit ble has now been so long before the publi that it is unnecessary to dwell upon the lit departs in We find presenta- erary virtues of a work which no way from his familiar method here the same brisk, journalistic: the of alacrity invention tion, the or Smartness the when same interpretation ofr a speech in dialogue documents are lacking same cynical clubman’s wisdom, and same tendency to lubricity that all lov- of Gribble have learned to look for, It be that book rather one sensibilities with the lives men and ,women of letters Shelley ay said, however, this is obnoxious to ’s less than his various meddlings f the Unlike Catherine by the hnemoirs romantic Rousseau and of for example be hurt writer of scandalous of that thor- Russia cannot much rehandling of a She is a representative the In her personal habits and f oral world in which author is oughly at home

itions and in the smaller intrigues « the palace she offers no problem beyond the range of his sympathies and under standing. To the reader who finds history too heavy and biography too prolix, Mr Gribble presents a tertium quid, which gox swiftly through the council-chamber and lingeringly down the back stairs Vous vez le latin, sans doute a Ss faites comme si je ne Sava This seductive legend from “Le Bour geois Gentilhomme” is inscribed upon the title-page of a book which will commend itself to every lay linguist and amateur Lilologer—Prof. Ernest Weekley The Ro ance of Words” (Dutton) Here is a fair ly rich collection—properly indexed—of tl iriosities and surprises of English sp so arranged as to illuminate such per ntl fascinating topics as folk-et) g phonetic accidents, popular , I ily lame semantics t Professo Weekle think that the vecial feature of his work is that “it deals essentially wit origin of words, and ikes no attemy to enforce a moral.” We should say rath« that it is distinguished by containing a aximum of information with a minimum of talk, and, further, that its author. an etymological contributor to the “Oxford English Dictionary,” has been able to draw more largely upon that great treasure house than most of his predecessors Hi book is, however, as he justly points out by no means a mere compilation; he has « < ‘The N 1€ ik light to bear upon a score o and his entirely the ition brought new r so of words illustrative quotations his browsing are almost own As here a to the reading specime the curious gentle reader opene d we submit following observation the chapter or the I ceeded which m the interesting nited States refined society in banning " ust now ‘ T i when possessor 1 and th refinement is not u nown in Eng land We the best host is hasten to assure t Professor in Society 1 usually he offe that States the refined way—when limb England We Possibly is base our hi I passage just ited The Barbados a Fate had placed ote to the ladies of ored equally sensitive to a fine turkey should posite if I her ner have tl lea iT to a piece ot ing ed your larn indignantly at me impudence sar I wonder wl manners if ples hosom, you E. Roe’s little book, “O (Huebsc! Gilbert Oligarchy Follette cial La nakes a rather pa s comn is no question of he the to set wears air have out too meagre array oO studied to indict a contention is power to 1ecla therefor ill ! N Mr. Roe and ding to eco! al ertainly tl politic eior ( ira eo fort of “usurpation,” and with it, of course, falls the larger part of Mr. Roe’s book LOG Burdett's Hospitals and Charitle DB arks the twenty-third year of f this compendium of philanthrop ! British Isles More than 700 of pages are taken up with a directory stitutions impressive by its very ‘ More readable is tt serie of tt hapters preceding these lists, and d with The Volume of Charity r tior nsurance Act ind tl \ Hospitals Hospital Fi ‘ ileulat that th ! f institutior n Great Britai and ree is at $t of th Swed ] i ner xt t ! iry rift ' x ! j I ld I . Canad \ i } 7? ha { ed & t ‘ { ‘ } " v) ' | ull k T ire t i ' Eee " t f tl I — T} lit +) ths ‘ \ t d i I kk tt ! t phila ropy whicl proudest boast The year il standard omp! ’ | t Prof. I » ‘ | i ¢ ‘ ( 1 wi ' } ! i 1 ! ; ’ Hi ‘ ' , ] 1H arhit r wd . i i J ba ¢ t gat lee r iw I ik of th ‘tf Bu i fr questio tha f er of the dispute wl nation annot be d led Fe v principl ]

Page 20

1OS > i : Al : f 1 o ) 7 i? fAict " I i ’ H MI I I iH " 1 | } 1 in least to ell i Ment i mal pro li and rea r e ) of H } had his ; i 7) il } \ ro n f t pera ilthoug!l +} nd Baron vo tT } ’ r fa sack nobl ! } } | f a banker M Ther vas I re t relationship i I polit il r afer 1 1 yubl 0 f ' of ‘ ind idy wa tra for a boring ty. She ! fida ll the end of his ! ' } va loubtl a closely in publ Tair Sl ven, on one " he " rformed a delicate " i for Bismarck But one irch this book I: iin for a single licat of tl qualit of mind from ! h two uch statesmen might be eX- lf ler noral and intellectual sup t r that could have attracted a bril ] rele of men of letters to her entour h prints with perfect composure let ind peeches full of flattering al ! t her personal charms, and Intro ! t) reader with the utmost intimacy to ery phase of her private life with the rin All is retailed with an amazing int of taste or discretion, and without en the poor palliation of literary art or ite analysia of emotion for judging at least, by the English translation. the atyle is a8 banal and the method as tain and in effective as the matter isa insipid and insig nificant George Coffey's “New Grange and Other Incised Tumull in Ireland” (Dublin: substantially a reprint of articles contributed by Mr. Cof- fey the Proceedings of the Royal Irish Academy and the Journal of the Royal Society of Antiquaries of Ire- But and new Hodges, Figgiea & Co.) ta several years ago to land the text is considerably modi- fied illustrations. have been added The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2457 to those which accompanied the original tion and the establishment of the Chinese irticles. The material, moreover, is of such Republic. inusual interest that historians and ar- The death is reported from Denver of hwologists will be glad to have it conve- Bishop Henry White Warren of the Metho- tly accessible in a separate publication. gist Episcopal Church, at the age of eighty- rhe book, as now issued, is a complete and ono Bishop Warren published several bstantial work of more than a hundred pooks among them “Sights and Insights,” ges It contains careful descriptions, «p~pe Lesser Hymnal,” “The Bible in the th admirable plans and photographs of worjq’s Education,” “Among the Forces,” rial ounds at New Grange (Brugh and two popular treatises on astronomy. Boinne) and several other ancient Irish s; a discussion of the testimonia con- = g thes eteries in early Irish lite- rature ind, in particular, a comparison of ae rish rock-decorations with those found science r parts of Europ: Several conclu- f eneral interest are drawn con- j the meaning of decorative types In the early autumn the Yale University i e history of their tran ssion. The Press will publish: “Stellar Motions,” by irity of th Irish rock-carvings to William Wallace Campbell, director of the ny rved in Crete or at Mycen@ is Lick Observatory; “The Probleme of Gene- " utter of common knowledge. But the in- tics,” by William Bateson, director of the rpretation of their meaning is quite un- John Innes Horticultural Institution, Sur- rta and ‘opinions differ even on the ! kLngland, and “The Doctrine of Irri- funda tal question whether the figures tability,” by Prof. Max Verworn of the Uni- ire purely geometrical or are the conven- versity of Bonn. tionalized outgrowths of representative Simon B. Elliott, for many years a prac- lrawing Mr. Coffey would associate most tical student of reasonable forestry, has of t with solar worship, though he does given in his “Important Timber Trees of not s his theory. The most characteris- the United States” (Houghton Mifflin) a ul lesigns on the New Grange stones are yseful handbook which is well adapted to spirals, which Mr. Coffey, in keeping with those whom he calls on his title-page “lay- the usual opinion, holds to be the forerun- men in forestry.” The book is hardly suit- ners of the concentric circles and semi- ed to class-work, because it is not sufficient- circles found on many monuments. But @ jy formal in itsconstructionor treatment, but different theory of the relation of the two jt ig thoroughly readable and appears to de groups of figures has been recently set trustworthy in its advice. It is to be re- forth by the eminent French archeologist, gretted that the author has not availed M. Déchelette, and his article (in L’An- himself a little more freely of the stores thropologie for Jan.-Feb., 1912) is in of information in Professor Sargent’s works veral respects an important con- and in Hough’s handbook. The photographie tinuation of Mr Coffey's investiga- representations are well selected and are of tions In dealing with the route of a high order. transmission of the spiral design, where No partiality for Bergson need be im- Mr. Coffey takes issue completely with the plied in the judgment that Hugh S. R, El- traditional view, he seems to be in the liot’s “Modern Science and the Illusions of right. He holds that the form in question Professor Bergson” (Longmans) is a ame to Ireland from Scandinavia rather stupid performance, the character of than from France or England, and that the which is not relieved by the preface examples found at Gavr-Inis, in Brittany, in which Sir E. Ray Lankester follow rather than precede in date those tells us gravely that, of course, every- on Irish soil. The distribution of the monu- body knows that metaphysics is non- ments strongly favors this theory, and it is sense. Mr. Elliot is the editor of “The Let- ely t VE " ” - kely to provall ters of John Stuart Mill,” and his reflec- tions upon the theory of science seem to have ceased at the point marked by Mill’s “Egyptian Afsthetics” (Open Court) is an appreciation of what the traveller in Egypt may see if he have eyes, and feel if Logic. His point of view is a perfect il- he have apprehension In it one does jystration of scientific dogmatism. His not look for a Baedeker-like accuracy as to favorite mode of refuting Bergson is to details, nor for the precise information| roar out: “I fail to see it: produce your which belongs to a history. It is rather! facts’—as if it were a question of fact rather than of the interpretation of fact. But only three of the seven chapters have any close relevance to Bergson. The other four are essays on the province and pro- gress of philosophy, the learning for which was acquired from Lewes’s “History of | Philosophy” and Lange’s “History of Ma- ‘terialism.” The real “illusion” is that the book should be conceived to be the proper an interpretation, a recording of impres- sions, a stimulus to the sightseer to use his powers of vision, and a reproach to the negligent that he failed to perceive all that The descriptive powers of the Francis, remark- was there author, Rene are quite able In “The China Year Book” (Dutton), two Anglo-Chinese journalists, H. T. Montague Bell and H. G. W. Woodhead, have brought | reply of science to Bergson. together a mass of figures dealing withnat-| For a book of its size, W. H. Jordan's ural resources, trade, and finance. There |“ Principles of Human Nutrition” (Macmil- le a detailed account of the system of pub- len) is exceedingly good. The author, the Ite justice that is taken up entirely with | director of the New York Agricultural Ex- procedure, and is of doubtful utility. Un-| periment Station at Geneva, makes no pre- furtunately, the very complete account of | tence of authority or originality, but has proposed Imperial reforms which the au- | drawn liberally and wisely from many good thors have been at pains to draw up, has /| sources, and, quite unlike some writers on been readered obsolete by the late revolu-| these topics, has used his material with ex-

Page 21

The Natic Aug. 1, ellent judgment. Wherever we have looked the disputed questions, for example, the problem of the purin bodies and of vege- tarianism, we have found the discussions il- luminating, as well as iull of judicious dis- rimination concerning what we know and hat we guess at. The book is elementars n character, and is written for students who have not specialized in organic or bio- logical chemistry For such and for the eneral reader it may be highly recommend- ed as a thoroughly good outline of practi- il dietetics In the very rational chapter on milk, the point is well made that, while he public sale of ilk is much safeguarded s between the milkman and the purchaser, the individual as the actual, in fact. the ul nate ‘“onsumer in the hotel or restaurant w boarding-house has little or no protec- n We recently called attention in these col- umns to the appearance of an English translation of selected essays on insect life by the French philosopher-naturalist, J. H Fabre There is now at hand another vol- ume of twenty-one essays by this remark- able observer, translated by Bernard Miall, under the title “Social Life in the Insect World” (Century). The selections treat the life-histories and habits of the cicada. the curious praying mantis, the golden scarabeus, crickets, the Sisyphus beetle, the bee-hunting Philanthus, the emperor and the banded moths, and various species of weevils Especially detailed and valuable are the extended experiments on the al- luring powers of females of certain moths A single specimen of the giant peacock moth, kept under wire-gauze cover for eight nights, attracted a total of one hundred and fifty males, a stupendous namber when the comparative rarity of the species in Fabre’s neighborhood is considered The odor emitted by the nubile female must be of extreme subtlety. Though it is imper- ceptible to our own olfactory sense-organs, a series of observations showed that when the wind had been blowing for a week from the north, the males hastening to the pris- oner al] entered the garden from that di- rection. In other words, “a powerful cur- rent of air, sweeping away all particles that might not prevent rection inform the sense of smell, does the moths arriving a di- to that taken the ef- fluvial stream, as we understand such mat- ters. Like those here chosen observa- tions, presented in a most vivacious man- ner. The translation, on the whole, is excellent, though one is struck by the use of cigale instead of the good English word “cicada,” and the frequent use of the word “butterfly,” in referring to the moths described, might better have been avoided. The legend of three has been con- fused, and “lob-worm” of plate seven and of the text, page 112, is not a but, as the original has it, terre,” the common earthworm. are excellent, and the make-up of the book are attractive. It should be welcomed by all lovers of na- ture, for in Fabre’s writings we have com-| bined keenness of observation and inter- pretation, a genial philosophy, and a pol- ished and fascinating style. j from opposite by all of Fabre’s abound in original writings, plate lob-worm, “le ver de! The plates binding and whole D. C. Heath & Co. publish a “Text Book” and a “Laboratory Manual of Physics” for E Linebarger | preparatory schools, by C of the ak View High Scho Chicago Both of these books in t i The text k is unusu ment and a Irate in stat li sion ol bstract echa 1 li placed, fr its st i t beginning, by the ri t of atte This is lent th int s - & tudent start and t ad grad thorny t ry of mechani t tory mal! l has its iz puncl t : filed i ises ] t and vers ! s on « f th er or i t tion t trv t« I o re range nys . tual t u vould | putt i B in tl ) tr ! enga 1 ir ; } ‘ pils who ] | the schools ai t gi fact rat t r dis lir Musie and Drama A 1 sed lition of T Mu I S Cyclopedia.” by Rupert Hughe W t sued in tl autumn by Doubled Pa & Co Oscar Ha rerstein has n r l | a work by Wolf-Ferrari: yet it to Mr Hammerstein that that half-Ger: half Italian composer owes his present nence It was Hammerstein who ed that it pays to mount new oper His success caused a diligent search for new operas all over Europe by both tl Metro politan and Mr. Dippel It so ha 1 that Wolf-Ferrari had several to offer. T! were produced in New York and Chicags with success—rather more succe ndeed than they deserved; and now that composer has entered the race with Mascagr Pu cini, and Leoncavallo. Unfortunately, Wolf-Ferrari seems to have made up his mind to rival Mascagni and Leoncavallo in productivity, a method of work that cannot but harm him in the long run. From Venice comes the news that he is at work on three new operas at once! One is a setting of Moliére’s “Le Malad imaginaire”’ the second, “Miss Figaro,” which is to have only one act; the third, a TL comic opera entitled “Honi soit qui mal y pense.” London ival has decisive, ceasing Rumor is persistent, says the Times, that “the last Handel fest now been held, and for the most if not the best, reason that it is to pay.” It urges, however, one more try. Mahler’s eighth symphony, whi ch re- quires a thousand players and singers for is not only being and in performance, all Germany probably be heard next season with the sang it in Berlin, and with monic Orchestra of that city. over Austria, t Paris and chor the same produced mut will London us that Philhar- Mah'er’s ninth symphony had its first per- in Vienna July anywhere festival formance musical of Bruno during Walter |“ the ind the Philhar n Orches " ' 1 it . 1 it with I r ] “A I i 2 i " \ rian wa ; a > | fr , of 1 a 1 wi ilwa ed 0 ! l impre j ir. Me head ke Mal ‘ H +} - ‘ a ' I | ‘ if I - , \ : ' ’ il | } ) Br { Bet f ) I to Her 1 l M Br ( Ret i I I ] | rd I | ' ho ] ) (5 ‘ " f Ww ! led ‘ Th } | ) Leopold Schmid t vith Hermann Li Friedrich G ind the famil Hecht ich ylur h i I I f ! ul given, and ill ! ! ice than Bral etter > w ‘ as diffu i j hi Lee avallo’s latest i \ ines¢ rf) i r Havi failed to dupl ite th ] f ! l Pagliacci,” he has writt« 1 co yperetta ntitled La reg tta delle ro wa well received at re t produ tion in Florence rh » ot rned with the revolution in Portugal ind w King love affair and tl i is aid to sound a good deal a f I 0 ser of “The Merry Widow had written it Another English omposer has been deemed worthy of attention in Germars Berlin has undertaken to produc in Sep tember, “Konig Harlequin by George H Chitsam. Montreal will have a season of opera asting twelve weeks. The same company will give three weeks to Toronto, one to Quebec, and one to Ottawa By an ar- rangement with the Boston Opera Company the management will be able to present some of the operas, notably “Aida” and “Thais,” with exceptionally fine scenery The repertory includes twelve French and eight Itallan operas, as fo lows French— “Louise,” “Thais,” “Hérodiade,” “La Vi- “Romeo “Cendrillon,” “Faust,” Jongleur Juliette vandiére,” Carmen,” et

Page 22

K an Tosca,” Rigoletto,’ Bo ble 8 ices of W. ire editor and nown, but from the Shakespearean stu yaison d'étre of the espeare, Himself and a Study (Ber lescribed on the edition, entirely re idition Anything ling a“ | sten to find in biograph it facts of the few enough, but r the leficiency by il ful hypo heses an interminabk vaardonable pel lentify the val vitl Bartholomew i More Chast the only begetter th William Ham nt, although neither of any weight. If Shakespeare speaks taken as proof this way, when dramatist; or if occurs in As , inclined t a of his Shakespeare rarite Rome at gentle rT mos the ait and atter Har and least nan.” ’ The work has no merits of literary appre- defects just commented for instance, are con- poor and weak.” “The Tempest” have borne clation to offset the on The demned as Sonnets is “quite long enough to some curtailment.” Mr. Hazlitt gives a measure of his critical capacity when he says that the constituent parts of [Tennyson's] Maud’ are rearrangement or redistribution at pleasure.” We find here the usual exaggeration the the early eighteenth Shake- what is susceptible of repeated with old entury ol against being indifferent to But if this Pope's lines? reproach speare'’s work is true the point of Shakespeare, whom you and ev'ry playhouse bill Style ti e divine, the matchless, what you will One might cite, likewise, the encomiums of Fielding, never surpassed in their warmth, say nothing of others. But even in the Npectator Shakespeare is frequently refer- d to and always as a standard classic. For our own part, when Addison says: “It shows i greater genius in Shakespeare to have drawn his Caliban than his Hotspur or Julius Ceesar; the one was to be supplied out of his own imagination, whereas the otl might have been formed upon tradi- tion, history, and observation,” he evinces, mn our judgment, both sympathy and dis- ernment in a far higher degree than Mr. Hazlitt shows in the following gem of crit- icis This character [Caliban] is not an attract one, and in some of the language which is put into his mouth, the revolting oarseness jars with the ideal simplicity and purity of Miranda. One can scarcely avoid regretting that a passage or two was I oO 7 Art \T THE TATE GALLERY. London, July 19. Change is the order of the day in England, and it has reached even the national galleries and museums. There Was a time when enterprise was about the last thing to be expected from them, and, as you left them on your last visit, so you found them on your next But directors and curators are beginning to learn that their position has not been awarded to them as an agreeable retirement for their old age, and they are as a consequence making ¢ surprisi show of activity This is especially the case at the Tate Gallery, here, f some months past, there has ‘ 1 succession of loan exhibitions, Charles Aitken, the new director, no doubt, feeling the necessity of keeping up the reputation he earned at the Whitechapel Gallery as a purveyor of popular entertainment-——a reputation to which he probably owes his present promotion from the East of London to the West First, at the Tate, came the Alfred Stevens Show—the English Al- fred Stevens; then the Pre-Raphaelites, the Birmingham Gallery in the mo- ment of building having lent its cele- brated and fairly complete collection; | next followed Alphonse Legros, who is known, except to the few, so much less in his work than in that of his pupils; and now Legros is succeeded by Whistler, explain. This list that not chance but repentance had inspired own just why it is not eary to might almost suggest the choice. It is, at least, a curious ce- incidence that so many of the artists represented are those who were officially slighted and overlooked in their day. The case of Alfred Stevens was, some years after his death, worked up into a public scandal. The fate of the Pre-Raphaelites the world by this time knows to the most minute detail, into such an excellent advertisement the world’s first abuse of them quickly turned. Legros, obscure and virtually forgotten in his suburb, lived to pupil after pupil recognized at the Royal Academy and in other official places, though he continued until the end an “outsider.” The prejudice Whistler had to face all his life is now an old story. Whistler, who was not given to turn ing the other cheek to the oppressor, re- sented this prejudice, and, in his resent ment, expressed his desire that no pic- ture of his should ever find a place in an English gallery. It is one of the lit- tle, or big, ironies of life that, hardly had death silenced his protests, before he received the distinction he so little coveted, or rather so strongly objected to; and his Old Battersea Bridge found a permanent place in a national collec- tion, while within a very few years an exhibition of his work has been made the special attraction at the National Gallery of British Art. Nor does the show offer any obvious reason for this indifference to his wishes. The Memorial Exhibition, held seven years ago, much more complete, much more impor- tant. It should seem almost as if there tould have been no reason for getting together the present collection at the present moment, unless to prove how much, or how little, of his work re- mains in Great Britain since Americans, once they discovered it, began to buy it up. But if this were the reason, the re- sult has entirely Whistler’s earliest period is represented by At the Piano, but then La Mére Gérard, which Swinburne owned, is still Miss Alexander, whose beauty fades, familiar as it grown by reproduction, is the one large full-length portrait; but the Carlyle is still the property of Glasgow; the two memorable full-lengths of Lady Meux have not yet left the country, and I have not heard that the Mrs. Hutt and the beautiful, almost unknown, Mrs. Ley- land have passed into American collec- tions, though so much mystery attends some of these transactions that one can never be too sure; all are pictures, and there are others of perhaps lesser note, that would at the same time have own was see was not been successful. in England never has ee ee

Page 23

a Aug. I, 1912] The Nation strengthened the exhibition at the Tate, It is hard to understand why som: pic- and given a better idea of the number tures, the best known, should be entered of Whistlers that have not been drawn With elaborate notes, and s, the from out the hands of their British own- least Known, with no notes at al! ept ers, across the Atlantic, by the irresisti- that exact notes for all ild LN ble force of the American collector’s mil Meant more _ research vhi means lions. However, it see a collection of Whistlers, complete or incomplete—always again the most splendid of his master- pieces; and some of his masterpieces are to be seen among the thirty-eight paint ings, pastels, and water-colors that now fill Room V at the Tate, where, unfortu- nately, no space is left any of his etchings or lithographs. It is well that the attention of Americans should be called to the exhibition, for, as it is to remain open until October, many are coming abroad will have the of it and of studying and enjoying pictures which are not likely to be exhibited Amer- if, ever, Here only Miss but Girl, perfect as the Valpa- on the Ocean, one in which Whistler world the true loveli- for who this year opportunity visiting in again Piano and White indeed, At the The Little is famous; ica soon, not Alexander, are it Twilight long series ag raiso of the vealed to a blind re ness of evening and twilight, of night and moonlight; others as memorable of the same series: Mr. Alexander’s Noc ind the beautiful the turne and Mr. Studd's Old Battersea Bridge from nent collection of the Tate early Battersea that belongs to Edmund has a place. And there are characteris- tic examples of the marvellous little seas and the studies of children he painted there are several of perma- Gallery; the and Sil- Davis, also sridge—Brown ver, in his later years; those charming pastels of delicately draped figures: there are a few water colors; and there is one very interesting study of three women in flowing drap- that I have never seen before, but the balcony where they are grouped, with ery the view beyond of the opposite shores of Battersea, suggests that it belongs to the period of the painting called The Balcony, one of the series known as his Japanese pictures. I make no attempt to describe in de tail these different works. The most important have been described many times; in fact, few old masters have been so honored—or dishonored—by de- scription, as Whistler But the occa- sion is too interesting to be passed al- together in silence, partly because of the belated official attempt reparation which Whistler, foreseeing, protested against; partly because of the opportu- nity to study him moods and plasee, in many mediums and manners. Certainly, it interesting enough to make one regret the careless ness of the small catalogue that is given free to the visitor. If a fee for it would have entailed more care, I doubt if many people would have grudged tle expense. at in so many 80 is is always a pleasure to a pleasure to see a distinct mistake more trouble. It is to say that an American crit 867 wrote of The Little White G bit ed in the Universal Exposit t Paris: A powerful female with red r and a vacant stare in her soulless t was of The White Girl, a \ liffer ent picture, hung in the American s« tion of the Exposition, that this is written. The mistake already has beer widely repeated by the art crit of the British press. It is thus by offi 1 care lessness that history is per ted. It is misleading to say of The Artist's Studio lent by the Dublin Gallery, that “anot} er version of this picture vas lent to the Memorial Ex tior rgan ized by the International Society in 1905." The other “versior referred to was the painting ther Douglas Freshfield’s possession, now in the Chi cago Art Institute, and it perfectly well known that doubt | as n t even by Whistler—upon the D sion. If mistakes can be ma official so soon after an artist leat! hat faith can we put in the moder? and his exact knowledge of mast: lead centuries ago? J Pa the Met olitan M Wi i of ist W > t Hi wr boo d treatis =e Finance THE DECLINE OF SPE \TILO Speculators in Wall Street | I ip preciated both the qualit ! manner of the retort made last turning financier upon a paper porter who bothered him wit juestions down the Bay. “Young mar the re porter said the financier said I don't know and I don’t think Though the speculators had long previously attained to that utter blankness of mind. they could not have believed a great financier to be in the same intellectual plight, On the contrary, they had been looking for ward to his return as an event of some consequence to the stock mar On the day following, the tap: fered no thing new, there was no increase in transactions, and peopl ere the same uncertainty as before whether to buy stocks on the fine crop prospects or to sell them on the “political situation For three months there has been first one pretext and then another upon which ; to defer speculation, until the cumula t f s of Stock Exchange n g& a I ner { Se; 0 D rs t ubsen f 3] ‘ «A Ss ‘ abs { £ “il ip ms so 8 ig think t i in Wi St I s then surpt 1 of a half i fit secu ty 5 = id of Ju irpas i all | s half-year records, and led li of the «x rrer ponte nk $327,000,000, As specu idly th pi stat neg ind as speculators deal pally in stocks, it is furt irp! nd that o as Mf Sac ) ’ , a { spondin rf p ling vear, $18 epl 1 ased out] ly B i " of Stocl ang t i n ‘ n Wall S t he fi ) ti | St I I 1 t i l i bealt Yo Ss > , ) é al as il pp at Stock E ! i 7 heer ' t} i| n il I ted al é 1904 n tl irket ] ‘ ring fro t f t of long a dec] 1 ul en the state if thine il if efacto! to spe +) ' niv n degt T that ‘ Wall Street prodt and d ributing sé ties | ontinualls ! reased t LY wtual ! t mont] f year al I ord, Stock Exchange sp I i pressed in terms of a t' is tended to decline. One explanatior t Stock Exchange speculation co ul in eccentric cycles, and t yt to be accounted for But it may be asked whether n the decline of the ratio of Stock Exchange activity to the actual production and distribution of securities, there is not a reflection of a change in method The methods of distribution have changed, to some extent, almost everywhere else in the last ten years. Conspicuous among the new flotations this vear have been the shares of new industrial companies representing the incorporation of old firms and trade-marks and legends, near ly always with a large addition for good

Page 24

112 Formerly flotations of that sort went directly to the Stock Exchange, and manipulators were engaged to dis- will tribute the shares to the public, with the | of professional speculators. Steel Corporation's shares, for instance, were distributed to the public via the Stock Exchange, and that achievement helped greatly to swell 1901 Stock Exchange transactions. Nowadays it Is differently done in very A syndicate :s formed to underwrite the new securi- which are then offered to the public Afterward, a New York listing may or may not be applied for. Houses of issue place new securities either directly with in- with dealers who reach the in and no assistance is required from speculators. In brief, it has been found possible on a pretty large scale to and merchandise securities with- out the assistance of speculation, where- formerly it was thought that it was feasible to distribute securities, ex- a speculation in them. assistance The United States the volume of many cases, ties subscription. ' On Stock Exchange vestors or estor, create as not cept by fomenting needs to read a work such as this real picture of the Middle Ages nd of feudalism... Such conditions... like fiction The wonderful thir- nth century was wonderful in France as in other parts of Europe. The author does not neglect any side of the social life which he is portraying. We get in this book a picture of the everyday life of the priest, student, canon, bishop, monk, noble noble dame, the peasants and burghers.” Boston Traneacript. Luchaire’s SOCIAL FRANCE the Time of Philip Augustus. Trans- lated by Dr. E. B. KREHBIEL. viii +441 pp. 8vo. $3.00 net; by mail $3.16. Henry Holt & Co. to get a living In 34 i3d St W DICTIONARIES TO FAMOUS AUTHORS $3.00 net per volume A DICKENS DICTIONARY By ALEXANDER J. PHILIP A THACKERAY DICTIONARY By ISADORE G. MUDGE A DICTIONARY of the WAVERLEY NOVELS OF SIR WALTER SCOTT By M. F. A. HUSBAND A THOMASHARDY DICTIONARY with 2 Maps of Wessex hy F. BAXELHY A KIPLING DICTIONARY hy W. ARTHUR YOUNG E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 11 Weet 284 Street NEW YORK WILHELM TELL, Act 1. By ScHiccer Dons Gomatate Captapeand) Tat 6 Alwaye Viable; Fonetic (alfagamic) German ord for. word Engtish } Ordinary (romanised) German rs pL ene yp he IDEOFONIC Texts for Acqui Ry 4A, a lye + PIERCE Editorial Critte: GEORGE HEMPL, of Stanford U 2 pages Cloth We, postpaid (0; paper ihe, Ble LANOUAGES COMPANY, 143 W. 47th St., New York A. S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y¥. A new catalogue of second-hand Americana, now ready, and will be sent to any address. | The a The N ation | Vol. 95+ (No. + 2457 noOKS OF THE WEEK. Some of the Contributions of to the New Japan. (Re- Asakawa, K. Feudal Japan print from the Journal of Race Develop- | Vol. 3.) Endowment for International Year Book for 1911. Washington. Euterpe. Recipes from East and West. Dutton. $1 net. Dall, W. H. New Species of Landshells from the Panama Canal Zone. Smith- sonian Institution. Washington. Day, Holman. The Red Lane. $1.35 net. Demosthenes’ Public Orations, translated by A. W. Pickard-Cambridge. 2 vols. Frowde. Edwardes, E. T., and Haité, G. C. Side- Lights of Nature in Quill and Crayon. Second edition. Dutton. $1 net. Foster, William. The English Factories in India, 1637-1641. Frowde. Halifax, R. The Borderland; Dutton, $1.35 net, each. Hall, G. 8S. Founders of Modern Psychology. Appleton, $2.50 net Haverfield, F. The Study of Ancient His- tory in Oxford: A Lecture. Frowde. Hegel’s Doctrine of Formal Logic. Intro- duction and notes by H. S. Macran. Frowde. Hill, G. F. Some Palestinian Cults in the Greco-Roman Age. Frowde. Horace, The Odes of. Books I-IV. ed into English Verse by W. Frowde. Jack, A. F. of Life Assurance. ment, Carnegie Peace Craies, Harper. Low Society. Translat- S. Marris. An Introduction to the History Dutton. $2.50 net. ' | Lillie, Arthur. Rama and Homer. Dutton. $1.75 net. Loeb, Jacques. tion of Life: Biological Essays. sity of Chicago Press. $1.50 net. Morris, Charles. History of Pennsylvania. Philadelphia: Lippincott. Mosher, E. M. Health and Happiness: A Message to Girls. Funk & Wagnallis. $1 net, Oxford English Dictionary. Vol. IX, Sleep- Sniggle. Frowde. $1.25. Oxford University Handbook. Revised to June, 1912. Frowde. Page, L. W. Roads, Paths, and Bridges. 75 cents net. Sturgis & Walton. Palgrave, F. T. The Golden Treasury. Edited for the use of schools by W. F. Trent and J. Erskine. Boston: Ginn. Pali Text Society publications. The Maha- vamsa, or the Great Chronicle of Ceylon, translated into English by W. Geiger. Frowde. Phillips, H. A. The Plot of the Short Story. Larchmont, N. Y.: Stanhope- $1 net. Dodge Pub. Co. Robinson, Victor. An Essay on Hasheesh. Medical Review of Reviews. 50 cents. Roccatagliata, R. Come si pagano le Im- poste e le Tasse in Italia? Seconda edi- zione. Milan: Hoepli. Stewart, M. M. Greyhound Fanny. Donnelley & Sons. Voltaire, Contes de. Edited by H. W. Pres- ton. (Modern French Series.) Frowde. Welles, F. C. Principles of Social Devel- opment. Second edition. Bucks, Eng- land: The Author. The Mechanistic Concep- Univer- Chicago: MADAME STEINHEILS MEMOIRS A Mysterious and Absorbing Human Document. These memoirs are interesting not merely as a brilliant and beautifal woman’s apologia and autobiography. They are also en- thralling as a picture of the ele- gant, daring, cynical, and culti- vated Parisian society in which she moved, and they introduce famil- iarly many people of distinction in the social, artistic, and literary life of the French capital. Her rela- tions with Pres. Faure throw strange sidelights upon contempo- rary French history. Price $3.00 net; postpaid $3.20. Octavo, Fully Illustrated. Gilt Top, Boxed. STURGIS & WALTON CO. 21-83 East 27th Street, New York THE STATE ELEMENTS OF HISTORICAL AND PRAC- TICAL POLITICS By WOODROW WILSON Gives Dr. Wilson's views on the Nature and Forms of Government, the Nature and Development of Law, and the Functions and Objects of Government Cloth. xxxv +650 pages. $2.00. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago D.C, ESTABLISHED SAN FRANCISCO BROKER wishes agency for Eestern Mercantile or Manu- facturing coneern or Capitalist Firet class con- nections in business and in other ways on the Pacific Coast, in Hawall, and the Orient. Will travel if inducement offers. Box 716, care of Nation, LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- ries. »Ancient and modern languaces. Translation, revision of manuscripts, ete. ‘ MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, | | Vol. 5 Completing the Work History of the People of the Netherlan By Petrus Johannes Blok Professor of Dutch History in the University of Leyden Vol 5, 18th and 19th Centuries. 8vo. with Mapes, $2.50 net. By mail $2.70. Set & vole., $12.50. Vole. sold separately. The history covers the period from, the earliest known times to the present, and many hitherto neglected portions of the early his- tory of Netherlands are authorita- tively presented. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS EW YORK LONDON SOME THINGS WE HAVE REMEMBERED (Samuel Thornton, Admiral, 1797-1859; Percy Melville Thornton, 1841-1911) By PERCY MELVILLE THORNTON, LL.M., Ex-M.P., Clapham, 1892- 1910. Author of “Foreign Secretaries of the Nineteenth Century,” “Harrow School and its Surroundings,” “The Stuart Dynasty,” “Continental Rul- ers of the Nineteenth Century,” etc., etc. With 7 Portraits and 4 Other Illustrations. 8vo. Pp. xii+337. $2.50 net. + & most absorbing plece of writ- ing on the homes of England filled with great traditions, on the gossip of the court, on the goings and comings at Westminster. There are enough detached te of great men and great incidents to make the reputation of any volume —Boston Daily Advertiser. Longmans, Green, & Co.

Page 25