The Nation 1912-07-18: Vol 95 Iss 2455
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
gem *'s e ‘ hi , \ | om 19% al | Ny ne wie VOL. XCV—NO. 2455 THURSDAY, OHN BROWN: A BIOGRAPHY FIFTY YEARS AFTER By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD
Some Tributes to this Remarkable Historical Work Patiade — PUBLIC LEDGE R. “A tremend t or Des Moines CAPITAL. Ml thrillin han any book of fiction, powerful in its ppe and e 4 whi ch, “while it is written sober! ly, as befits histor) yy the ve J Brown » e ghest ’ , tte ‘ ‘ nature of the narrative ften to the higl mati The NORTH CAROLINA REVIEW. THOMAS WENTWORTH HIGGINSON. I car niy *& \ 1} t rs after reading from first to last its more than 700 pages that I t! eader for I have never encountered anythin this side 4 : ‘ ¢ which has made me feel more “ne personal work.’’ ‘ t f re Jonm *; MORSE, Editor Amerie an Statesmen Series, in Baltimore AMERICAN. ANTIC MONTHL \. erhap dram t ‘ ‘ Seah ming his volume Mr Vill a 1 ne ra th an acted upon a prec: nceived plan at is often the case w work, where a writer's feeling are deep) enlisted t may, the merit and char are none the less be ha _ . ) : , MES. well a splendid opportunity an a written one of the onsen, ri tf - gre it biographies of our literature.’’ a HORACE WHITE. “In my judgment a contribution to Amé¢ literature to take rank with the very best historical writing of ; s theme our time or apy time The only impartial history i eo ow ashington (Dp. CC.) STAR, Kansas war."’ viv nicture ea ST. CLAIR McKELWAY in the Brookly n E AGLE. por Civ W Straight and cl biography replete with facts and marked by courage al esear th : M th i learning and justice.’ HE RY WATTERSON in Toutlsville COURIER-JOUR- Al f may justly be fou bh M \ rd‘s tel Portiand OREGONIAN. “The most valuable and comprehens'v ' wit P biography issue/t this season and the best and wst candl f the stor It minute and ici together f estimate of John KBrown."’ WwW. E. CONNELLEY in the TOPEKA CAPITAL. ‘The ut Burlington (lowa) HAWKEYVE. prejudiced student ons seeker for truth will herald the book as take a t brary ¢ eve a great contribution to American history this part of ‘ ’ THIRD EDITION Fully illustrated with portraits and other illustrations. With copious notes and bibliography. $5.00 net Postage 26 centa Boston HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY __ New York " }
A notable brief for democracy that everyb DICTIONARIES TO FAMOUS AUTHORS “Mr. Beresford has arrived.” to read,’ says Mr."Oswatp Ganson Vin ~~ $3.00 net per volume —London Morning Leader. One Way Out: A Middle-Class New A DICKENS DICTIONARY A Candidate for Truth Englander Emigrates te America : > By “WILLIAM CARLETON.” mg a ecg dy Bo a By J. D. BERESFORD TI “i pat notable book of our da té i" ste ate 100 ; f A THACKERAY DICTIONARY “More than by any novel we have read for ? y By ISADORE G. MUDGE , months we are captivated by ‘A Candidat: Sixth ee #1.20 mets by mam, 05.58 A DICTIONARY of the WAVERLEY for Truth.’”—Chicago Evening Post . ae oe a aa ee NOVELS OF SIR WALTER SCOTT “Raises its author quite definitely to the mall, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston By M. F. A. HUSBAND front rank of living novelists.’’—London = order to relleve poverty you must first under A THOMAS HARDY DICTIONARY Standard t. The problem is wisely stated in with 2 Maps of Wessex 486 pages. Cloth. $1.35 net; by mail $1.46. ‘ KIPLING DICTIONARY LITTLE, BROWN & CO., BOSTON THE BURDEN OF POVERTY: By W. ARTHUR YOUNG : Ww H A T T Oo D Oo iby CHARLES F. DOLF E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY ony mis lad tee a oo 81 West 234 Street NEW YORK MONTGOMERY’S NEW BOOK » gived with vhaer Postpaid. ES vente e CHRONICLES OF AVONLEA © uvewscn 225 rie ave. Now vor By the author of Learn Latin to Speak “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES,” ETC. Books WOODROW WILSON
Of which over 300.000 conies have been sold is the common-sense in Latin; y ys } 25. s’oate 40 : Palastra some 30 pamphlets for class or rediacon PRREae Oe Congressional Government. A Study self-instruction by figures, cuts, texts on in American Politics. $1.25 subjects of daily life, supported by Roman aie vast SaceehanN” ine translations; THEAMERICAN GOVERNMENT Mere Literature, and Other Essays. reading, writing, speaking exercises; half Ry FREDERIC J HASKINS $1.50 published; $2.50 will bring all issued; com- Ott 6 ter the Prenthent, the Cablect. ot plete $5.00; no samples. ARCADIVS AVEL- , el, 12 Cloth. $1 net. I $1.15 | HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., 4 Park St.,.Boston LANVS, Williamstown, Mass J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia
j
Page 2
The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2455
The Nation Fol CONTENTS NDED IN 1865. OF THIS pwned by the | Garrison Treasurer ler NUMBER New Villard Pan As 45 Educational Educational
q ‘ P oe ° ’ The Western Theological Seminary N. S.. Pittsburgh, Pa. Founded by the General Assembly, 1825 A mplete theological rriculum, with yurses le to legree of B D ourses of the University of or to degrees of A. M. and Ph.D., are ope ly qualified students of the Se« minary. nal library facilities 34.000 volumes lormitory, equipped with modern rt. including dining-room, gymnasium and * now ready for ‘cupancy Next } Sept 17 1912 For information es. James A. Kelso, Ph.D., D.D {= URSULINE ACADEMY, modern elective ading the (Tra ate ng pe latest
School for Girls, situated on the outskirts of Middletown, accepts young ladies and children during the summer months, and carefully provides for their protection and comfort Students, who cancel College or High School conditions, Summer Courses of Study provided. Terms on ap plication THE URSULINE ACADEMY, Middletown. New York lso
PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr The Missts Kirk’s College Preparatory School Prepares for Bryn Mawr and other colleges. Cer tificate privileges. Number of pupils limited. Spe- celal schedule arranged for each Percentage of pupils who have entered Bryn Mawr College un isually large. Gymnastics. outdoor sports. 14tb year opens Oct. 3, 1912.
New Jensey, Morristown MORRISTOWN SCHOOL COLLEGE PREPARATORY BOARDING SCHOOL FOR BOYS Small classes Individual attention Partial self government large new gymnasium. ALL outdoor sports under expert sunervision. Es- eclally healthful location 30 miles from New York Lower School for Boys of 10 to 14
PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Prepares for leading col- FOERING, B.8., Principal. IE Tab EHEM > N | } A HOME-| delightfully and healthfully | New York. | wish to/ will find | ’ STUDY IN FRANCE, Near Paris. Only A YEAR OF School for Americans of both sexes. Individual training In a French family. French spoken Credit given by Universities of Chicago and Illinois. Exceptional advantages. Ad- dress PROF. WILLIAMSON, University of Chicago. TheBriarcliffSchoolforLittle Girls A boarding and day school for girls under fifteen. Address Mrs. FRANCES MAR- SHALL, _Principal, Briarc liff Manor, i. we
HOROUGH AND EFFECTIVE PREPARA- tion for college by an experienced § tutor. Highest references WALTER B. WATERMAN, A.M., 214 Boylston Street, Boston, Mass. Short - Story Writing A course of forty ry in the histo: form, (— and writing of the e 4. Berg Ksenwein, Editor outer one, one hundred Home Si ‘ourses under essorsin Harv Brown, Ress leading colleges, Dr. Esonwein 250-page catalog free. Write to-day. The Home Correspondence Schoo! Dept284 Springfield Mass
HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everetr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2a Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av..NewYork 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland 814 Steger Bd..Chicago 343 DouglasBd.,LosAngeles 920 Sav. Bk.Bd.,.Denver 345 Wright Bik., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual.
Vincent B. Fisk, Mer. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex- perience in bringing together good teachers and good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself. Harlan P. French, Prop
Just Published ENGLISH CLASSICS SERIES STANDARD Palgrave’s Golden Treasury of Songs and Lyrics William Trent, [Pro f En hw rakine, olum mo eouts : ‘eterfield od John , 2 extender 1 general, lyric as th Ge olden lassics at the 1 ‘ Palgrave’s Standard English C an excelient edition pub i surv in the indicates coat GINN AND 29 BEACON STREET,
COMPANY BOSTON
First Year Algebra WEBSTER WELLS, of the Massachu- setts Ins‘ itute of Technology, and WALTER W. HART, of the University of Wiscon Cloth. 340 pages. 0 centa. B sin D.C. Heath & Co.,Boston, NewYork, Chicago
LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSORIPT
CLARK CO., CLEVELAND
THE ARTHUR H.
pe. Ee ricana, address. Peekskill, ond-hand Ar ny CLARK of will A. & now italogus ready ind be sent to a A new) |20 Vesey St., ESTABLISHED SAN FRANCISCO BROKER for Eastern Mercantile or Manu- facturing concern or Capitalist First class con- nections in business and in other ways on the Pacific Coast. in Hawali, and the Orient. Wil! travel if inducement offers. Box 716. care of The Nation. wishes agency
DICTIONARY OF Hard Words By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE 645 pages. Cloth $1.20; postpaid $1.32 George Hempl, Professor of Filology in Stanford University, writes:—"'1l have no hesitation in saying that your Dictionary of Hard Words is the best book of its kind.’ DODD, MEAD & CO., 443 Fourth Ave.,NewYork
LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- ries Ancient and modern languaeces. Translation, revision of manuscripts, etc. MISS M. H. BUCK 96 Chestnut Street, THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK For 1911 Now Ready SAMPLE COPIES THE NATION be sent any address for several weeks WITHOUT CHARGE The Nation New York City <INGHAM, Boston, Mass.
will to
Page 3
7 YS SSO Saat da eke aaibiestontee d ore a The We Kk { | \ : ‘ i pa s t i ttle = iit i g ‘ nie . ‘ ‘ d , ‘y Rey i \ r \ I ] I i + , 2) ’ | e Drought to sob r ti ghts 4 ‘ \ I ’ | ; ; , , nsideratior at prefe " > , !T + t! pa I Ss penal R ; . | . 1 that if this Government iD —" nie oll exemy] nonaA i t might fier vea ' ed is ailtt ul y ) . } n shipowners before the Hague ‘ ‘ ; and assessed in enormous dal . s quite poss ble to arg i j . ca Ki 3 at after putting one treaty into i it would be per The Nation
Page 4
can be na State where, by so doing, Mr. | forced out of the party and to run on a ticket nominated That means punishing the not compromising with him. second there is no telling place iy happen on election day. Clos eart of Pennsylvania Republi- han either Roosevelt or Taft, is on Woodrow radical tariff-ré Wilson running duction dy vhict platform ive the protec- man, Taft or better chance against i he of the progress throughout the not aucur a Roosevelt tri nsylvania Republicans may that the Taft moment, decide after all, better with tte's latest attack upon Roose the most smashing he has yet Coming from any source it would aging, so formidable are the facts from the held ys, and coming pioneer who the true faith corned it, it The Wis is pec uli consin Senator Colonel his charge of ro with terrible effec a was more ready “steal” dele- was to the most destruc ettes arraignment which he shows that Mr. liberately sacrificed the Pro to his pe selfish rsonal ambition. Chi Baltimore, of attitude at urse at disadvantage troke of the Sen- that and as wickedly in, one in egard on is how long will thes« repeated as vithout replying? indoned his proud without The deeply an hit him return? ha will et in mevelt surely not reé lowing up betrayal The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2455 — —— the suppression of the lawless and vi- If at temper has given suggestion of insanity, cious black man. times Blease’s and his language has run strong with the vocabulary of the gutter, much must be forgiven the man who stood for the To bring charges of graft and official mis- the Galahad of South of trading in moral integrity of our institutions. conduct against Carolina, to accuse him pardons and exacting tribute from illegal rum shops, as several witnesses have done before an investigating commit- of the is to put a tee South Carolina Legislature, terrible strain on a man’s self-control. Certainly, the self-appoint- Carolina’s man- So ed champion of South hood is not the one to remain quiet. he proceeds to vindicate the superiority of a civilization of which he is the fair flower in such terms false, and it and Judge Jones down off the bench and wife to bring him his biggest he the feathers off his ped into the His staten Augusta owardly I defled the ad and to his and nd jun ents at little Supreme are puppy knows Court ran shaved ring be mistaken friend of It the must a very negro, indeed, who would want to see the colored people of the South raise themselves to the moral and intellectual level of a Blease. It the people now ensconced in the United would be just like the enemies of States Senate to pass the bill for pub- licity of expenditures in connection with nominating campaigns for the office of The bill lower house ten President and Vice-President. the weeks ago, and has since been held up the If the bill should become law, say, on it would not affect the Chi- or the Convention al- held, was passed by in Senate Judiciary Committee. August 4, Baltimore but it that cago ready would apply to the convention Thus one of Mr. La Follette’s fondest hopes would be realiz- cago on August 5. ed, and the exact measure of George W. Perkins’s the common people La Follette has love for would be ascertained here developed a pretty little moral is- sue of his own. He supplements the Col- Thou shalt with the commandment, “Thou shalt not take mo- not steal” onel's ney” from the Harvester Trust, or from Stee) Trust, or from William Flinn, Woodruff the from Timothy lwo words that regularly come for- is to assemble at Chi-' | ward in the newspaper columns with every renewal of the Olympic Games are “olympiad,” used in a wrong sense, and “decadence.” Time may teach the world the correct use of the term “olympiad,” but we cannot foresee an Olympic cele- bration that will not call forth solemn editorial discussion of the decadence of every nation that has not carried off so many firsts in the Stadium. England, of is the chief sufferer from that special form of selfanalysis. In Eng- land, they take decadence with their breakfast, lunch, and dinner. Has Brit- ain’s manhood lost its ca- pacity for virile sports? What has real- ly happened is that Britain’s monopoly course, taste and in certain sports has been broken. The other nations have taken up her games and We did it first in this country, and with our learn- learned how to win at them. more extensive resources, soon ed to beat the field. The Europeans are now taking up the games, with the result that our English in their own victory at Stockholm has been by no means so emphatic as our victories in the earlier Olympics. But that is not because Britain has been decaying, or because we are in danger of decay. After every golf tournament, such as took place at Apawamis last week, in which both amateurs and professionals compete, philosophers of the game find themselves asking what are the real reasons for the superiority of the pro- Rough and ready answers It will not do to say are better players fessionals. are unconvincing. that professionals simply because they are paid to be, Nor can it be maintained that they outplay amateurs because they are more season- ed, or keep more steadily in practice, or There Some engage oftener in competition. are amateurs and amateurs. of them are as veteran at golf, and are as often on the links as any professional, and surely take part in more tourna- ments. There are amateurs who drive as long a ball as professionals; others who play their iron shots as far and straight; others who are the equal of any professional on the putting greens. Why, then, do the best of them never quite rank up to the most skilful pro- fessionals? It is a question which has been earnestly Cebated in England; and the answer arrived at there would cdoubt- less hold for this country. It that, on the whole, the playing of the profes- is
Page 5
July 18, 1912]
The Nation
sional golfer is more even than his ama- teur brother. All clubs look alike to him. In the hardest stroke and the most delicate touch he is equally at home. Bad lies do not discomfit him. ©ut of the long grass or from the sand, he will play with the utmost confidence and sureness. Moreover, the top-notch professional is deadly straight in his It of the ball of Ray, who won the that went over the Muirfield links almost ex- flies. shots. is said that a map of the course open championship, would show it actly the crow Long hitting, as +y straight shooting, accurate approaching, deadly putting, nerves that no misfor- tune can unsettle—these are the high qualifications of the golfer, and the pro- fessional excels by uniting them better than the amateur
Monday was the date for the English workingman’s insurance act to into No £0 effect. law has been so bitterly at- tacked and even execrated, before going into operation, though even its fiercest antagonists have been forced to approve The House of Lords accepted it without seri the “principle” of the legislation. ous demur. But details of the bill have been assailed as grossly unfair and oner- ous, and there has been a vast deal of wild talk about meeting it with passive resistance. This was foolishly encour- aged by the Unionist leaders, who thought in that way to embarrass the Government and possibly to bring about a postponement of the operative date of the bill. “You will never be able to car ry out this act,” has been a frequent taunt, in the House of Commons as well as in the Tory press. But as the day drew near for the law to be enforced, the. Conservatives became alarmed at the spirit of lawlessness which they themselves had done so much to pro- voke, and began to call upon their fol- lowers not to attempt to withstand an act of Parliament. The case was well put by the veteran Unionist, Prof. A. V. Dicey of Oxford, who wrote to the Lon- don Times: Allow me to oin as briefly and em- phatically as I can in Mr. Lyttelton’s pro- test against any attempt to resist by any illegal means the operation of the National- al Insurance act I hold with him that the act is in mar of its provisions almost ntclerable, and ly pro unworkable. I also convinced that occasions may arise though they are ery rare—where re- sistance t he law of the land may be ome a duty No such occasion has as yet
arisen Employers and servants will jure a good cause if, instead of insisting on the amendment of the act they Be rash language which implies an intention to reak the law We have had fa much lately of botl iss ind a ‘ Sistal to the is aut e sla and this resistance has in s \ I te rar j ‘ iz f pow London has been having ons inifes tation of Imperialism which both me and striking. It is a Congress of all the Universities of the British Empire rhe desirability of summoning such a gat ering was uggested two vears go } the Principal of the University of Lon don, and it was fittingly at that institu tion that Lord Rosebery, as ( ince bade the delegates welcome lore 1an fifty universities were represented. The great expansion of higher ed ut i which this means was dwe Lord Rosebery. He said that such a congress had been held in 18 nd had been purely English, “it ould have been an interesting, private, and confi dential meeting of two representatives If it had been British, Scotland would have added four more If it had been Imperial, it would have taken in merely I Dublin and McGill But to-day fifty three men come from all parts of the Empire. Even in England proper, no less than five universities have been founded within the past twelve years; and with them Sydney and Calcutta, Saskatchewan and the Cape, are join ing hands Lord Rosebery put the weighty significance of the marvellous development in the following question “May we not believe that had Daniel Webster lived to deliver his famous eulogy on the British Empire—in a small space the most eloquent that has ever been delivered, and that by an American statesman—would he not have been able to add to his famous figure of the universal drumbeat of the Empire that it was now belted round with Uni versities?” The Italian Government not alte gether pleased with the optimism of the Italian press concerning the progress of the war. One of the best known of the war correspondents, Signor Cipolla, ha been outlining in his paper, the ta a plan for forcing the Dardanelles and attacking Constantinople by means of airships now being built in Milan and
47 elsewhere. A telegram by a correspon dent of the Berliner Tageblatt, comment ing on this fantastic plan, has been n fiscated by the Roman censor. on the ground that “it reproduces the opinions Arnaldo Cipolla as to the manner in which Italy can most rapidly finish the war with Turkey.” In its own wa however, the Government continues t furnish the papers with comments the war Thus there appears t Popolo “Romano an inspired article on Turk and Italian finances vhich pre . the atte ! a very ) i t W ] ke s said to be bankruptcy he omi on f aire d da ‘ £ I \ mul Phe Ita n bude ( June is said t é 1 sury ‘ AL | and tl aia t a il I 4 I ‘ T lig ort a ‘ I nsignificant lecrease pe In any case art e State i ippe to Italia al ta V< a s! \ that ‘ oul ound not oni & tO 1 ! tary org ization, but that ‘the nationa spirit and the general admin itive capacity a rising to the occasiot rl is a f good Governmental whistling courage The failure of the Chinese loan neg ations after so much fuss and worry not to be ascribed entirely to the a tion of the Chinese Government It is true that the authorities at Peking cognizance of the « compelled to take jection raised by the patriotic element in the provinces against the incurring o! any further foreign liens on ‘¢ ia right to manage her own affa It j ontinuance of the old anti-fe ig spirit which took form, half a dozen vears ago, against foreigi ailway terprise in the Empire I I eaders of provin pil ha eeded in blocking tl building of ivs Kuropean apital, the 4 ot bee eminentl essful in | ld g up i for China through na ‘ té | ‘ \ é rthe the cen al Government might ha kI ! ( ate local set t ‘ ‘ ‘ f the credit I el id not nae pretty plalr t! t la it | a " ere not in hea ‘ " t heir partners. Unde f the Government ppa a ft a i ne “£a re f
Page 6
ation s of h lant hes- thwarted and discredited. The nation ool and phil- festations of ind lw ¢ Ly pten b + is ti om iber ing out- isk, and made a patience, of rithmetic« to our and ignore eta T tir! sier Lord ing actly can nan Ss ee po undoubted l¢ will be — [ Vol. 95, No. 2455 has had time to look around, and it is visibly growing more composed in its mind. If one party is divided and dis- tracted, it sees that the other is united and marching forward under an inspir- ing leadership. Government by party vill not break down simply because one party has temporarily broken down. ind our ancient humor is also coming » the rescue. The country simply can- not take the Colonel so seriously as he takes himself. Ability to laugh at a who makes himself ridiculous is » sign of recovered coolness, and it is now to be seen on every hand. This villgo on. The country is not so mad as some of those who seem to have been striving to infect it with their own mania, and is daily giving new evidence that it proposes to keep its head and go about its business THE BRITISH PROTEST. News that the British Embassy had sent a note to our State Department, asking that the Panama bill be not pass- ed until a formal representation, now on from the British Government be given attention, greatly stirred pure minds of Senators in Washing- Here was an offensive meddling by eigners in a matter of strictly domes- legislation. If Congress desires to the Panama Canal free to Ameri- an ships, what concern of Eng- Cannot we do what we will our own? If we choose to enact a that no ship owned by a railway ill navigate the Canal, that is our own If the Canadian Pacific Railroad urt by such a provision, that is its isfortune, not our fault And if the ‘lish think that Congress will wait to ir from them before passing such sures as it pleases, they will speed- find that they are mightily mistaken. bill might not have gone through on but, by Jingo, if any foreign uests us not to hurry it up, pass it in a jiffy just to show that e cannot be bluffed. Thus speaks Bun- ombe County at Washington. We may be sure, however, that the retary of State and the President and serious-minded Congressmen will not be inclined thus lightly to toss the matter off A weighty affair of state is nvolved. Our national good faith in living up to the obligations of a treaty is called in question, It will never do to
Page 7
July 18, 1912] The Nation say that the Panama Canal is our own!if any were so insensitive on that sub- ber very few property and that we can do what we like with it. It is ours, indeed, but it is impressed with a lien, in the shape of a solemn national pledge, which we gave at the time of acquiring the right to an exclusive control of its operation. In the way of that, the Clayton-Bulwer treaty stood as an obstacle. Specifically to “remove any objection which may arise” out of that treaty to “the con- struction of such canal under the aus- pices of the Government of the United States,” the Hay-Pauncefote treaty was 1901, ratified and pro- It is now printed by negotiated in claimed in 1902. our Government in the volume of “trea- ties in force.” Another recognition of its binding nature was made in our treaty with the bogus Republic of Pana- ma, which Article XVIII provided that the Canal should be opened and all stipulations” of the treaty with Great of operated “in conformity with the Britain. Now, those “stipulations” were made for a purpose. England got some- thing for waiving her rights under the Clayton-Bulwer treaty. What did she get? She got a promise of neutraliza- \etion. She got also this specific pledge: { The canal shall be free and open to the ‘vessels of commerce and war of all na- tions observing these Rules, on terms of entire equality, so that there shall be no discrimination against any nation or its citizens or subjects in respect of the con- ditions or charges of traffic or otherwise. That pledge, in both its spirit and its letter, the pending Panama bill pro- It would do it allowing American vessels to pass poses coolly to break. by through the Canal free of tolls, while charging them upon This is the Congressional idea of “entire all other ships. equality” and “no discrimination’! The glaring bad faith of this has been re- peatedly pointed out, both in and out of Congress. But it has been replied, tri- umphantly: “There cannot be any force in your argument, otherwise England would have objected. Our treaty is with her, and if, as you say, the Panama Dill is in violation of it, why haven't we had a British protest? Are you more care- ful of English rights than the English Government is?” Of course, the law and morals of the case did not depend upon any action or non-action by England. There stood the plain words of the treaty. On the other hand, there stood the bill, absolutely irreconcilable with | them. That was enough for any man jealous for the honor of his nation. But ject as to need a pricking from the out- side, the announced British comes to furnish it. Those who thought protest it so clever to sneak a disguised ship- subsidy into the Panama bill, are now awake to the fact that they are surely bringing on an international compiica tion. They are forcing a reference of the dispute ‘to an impartial tribunal j which would be certain to decide as em- phatically against this country as the Paris Arbitration Court did against our exclusive claims in Bering Sea. “ The terms of the protest which Eng- is to make are as yet made No land known only in outline. Govern- ment could tamely sit by and the see rights of its subjects impaired by the ac- tion of another country, especially when those rights are guaranteed by special without making a vigorous ob- It to wait till the bill is actually treaty, jection. is said that England ought passed; that her protest is of no force against a measure not yet But clear that, if she were carefully prepar made law. it is ing & case to submit to The Hague, she would make her position stronger by showing that she had taken the earli- est occasion to remind the Washington to assert We Government of her intention her rights under the treaty. can only regard the step now taken as time ly and wholesome. The evasion propos ed by the bill has been passed over too that the duty we know nation’s honor the We see the danger of try- nonchalantly. Now and nation's are touched. ing to drive a subsidy coach-and-four through a precisely worded treaty. If such a thing could be done, American faith would get as Punic. No tions of good motives would avail, for we should have placed this country like that described by his “Diary”: bad a name as boasting and no protesta- in a situation John Quincy Adams in effort on our part to reason the out of a belief that ambitious will have no other effect than to con- vince them that we add to our ambition “Any world we are hypocrisy.” CAMPAIGN CONTRIBU- TIONS. OLD-STYLE The committee of the Senate inquir- ing into the campaign contributions of 1904 has so far dug up little but ignor- ance and forgetfulness. Chairman Tag- gart, for the Democrats, could remem-| 49 details, and last week Mr. | Cortelyou, chairman of the Republican National Committee, explained that he knew about the money matters of the campaign only in the most casual way. He with other was chiefly concerned things. When Mr. Taggart calmly stat- ed Committee books of the Democratk 1904 there was a joyous flutter among Repub- Aha, But you informed the Senate Committee that the of had been burned, there Mr. Cortel that lican newspapers. so vas something to cover up! all Treasurer Bliss had destroyed Republican books and vouchers also, So dishonors are easy. Now, the burning of books be well as a symptom of fright and a a sign of repentance, as tacit may confession that certain transactions will It that, as a consequence of the preaching of them not bear the light of day. is recorded of the Apostle, “many also which used curious arts brought their books together and burned them.” But did cretly. this “before all men,” not se- Whether they ‘ our practitioners of ‘curious arts” in politics were stricken with remorse when they burned their books, we cannot say, but it is a satis faction to know that publicity-laws have made it impossible for them to go back to the old methods, even if they desire It vestigation that the Senate is to. is, in a sense, an antiquarian in- making. Chairman Cortelyou made a frank enough appearance and told a story that sounds straight. But it was confessed- ly incomplete. He knew, or thought he knew, the “demnition total” of contri- butions, but was quite unaware of where many of the largest items came from. For example, he stated that he did not know until later that the big life-insurance companies had been as- sessed for $50,000 each. This was sus pected at the time, but the fact was not established until Mr. Hughes brought it out in the insurance investigation. Other corporations, as Mr. Cortelyou frankly stated, were asked to contribute to the He did not, but Roosevelt corruption fund. of ‘practical’ men like Harriman who were course, give it that name, the then putting up the cash, had no iilu- sions about what was done money. They spoke bluntly of the ef- fect of spending $50 in each election district, which Harriman said would be sufficient to “turn” 60,000 votes in New York city alone. And when Mr. Cortel- you testifies that “from $650,000 to $700, with the
Page 8
i purchased if tr of ry a@ = The Nation guaranteeing them the right to levy tar- all bleeding cor- States, it is doubtful » that all of this great iff taxes for their own benefit, was one with the of “speakers’ practice porations with the promise of looking after their interests in the Legislature Congress. The demand that this ended had both our and in plan be become so impera- tive that law-makers and our impaign managers had to give heed to ee no more of red these huge secret and laid out in ‘ ; rrupting effect, if not with a cor- iIrpost Presidential campaigns new order vil e both cheap ner. The Se mittee horrible the but is longel be. hat has by anybody's labelling it as Progressivtsm.’ -OLONGING Metchnikoff to dis« OV ife. Alas, histopheles, or as the elixir of only too soon that gly remedy after which the heart The evident pecomMes now celebrated eobacter is not man has lusted great scientist has sought for years a weapon against Roosevel . rime, and the hardening of the arter He more mi . has studied the way of the lac- ies quietly laced <a bacillus has gone to the dog tic most good 2 é : considered his intestines, and the he the ind the Senate inquiry one into wisdom has gained is that the of human system will stave off the ad only tten, and unhappy things of injection “sugar bacillus” into ve do not mean to imply that . the useful purpose It is vance of old age, provided—and there's down rumors of corruption; the rub: there always is a very impor the inder!ying or tant, very onerous “provided” to be dealt persistent an tne vik es of the old with die to savs rote or hnikoff, it would and y theories, be I b ld suddenly morrow, not dis cts we late in egan make reached gin with whatever results life to begin At beginning of middle for old age' forty to ations shaping one’s conduct so that one had come | may li be a hundred! No, this is elixir, of which a drop liostro's sends fire through shrunken veins new ind rears upright the collapsing frame It is restatement in specific imply a old belief that eternal vig of life that terme of the It was seen debauched elect really anything like alight to ons ilance is the price legislation Frying the worth preserving, everything manufacturers in return for elae | Vol. 95, No. 2455 Under these conditions the secret of long life has never been withheld from the knowledge of man. The author of Proverbs long ago had hit upon numer- ous ways of postponing the ravages of arterio-sclerosis The pursuit of wis- dom will do it. Fear of the Lord will do it. Submission to reproof will do it. The practice of mercy will do it. This is not putting the ase in biological terms; but the highest biology to-day recognizes the existence of the spiritual The Russian factor certain ement on which counted,” Metchnikoff, the Savant has says one writer « Professor be overlooked the st stimu- old tion moral which Impression organisn Sufferers from ill receive with the glycobacters and will Here excellent advics ive educatic and th zed mn find themselves doing « llently is the basis for a real understanding be- tween the wisdom of Pasteur and the King Solomon will Metchnikoff half- wisdom of Proverbs readily meet Professor way. A diet of sour milk plus the prac- tice of charity; glycobacters reinforced by keeping the mind on high ideals; ab- stention from excessive use of meat go ing hand in hand with abstention from evil thoughts—there is every opportu- nity here for the synthetic production really efficacious specific against But ot a old posed a patient spirit and long practice. age always there is presup- The pursuit of wisdom and the cultiva- tion of the lactic bacillus must really begin at the beginning of adult life have life is the difficulty Are men willing to long on these terms? That which confronts the Parisian biologist, as it did the wise king of the Jews. In will of small things, as in great, men rarely sacrifice the self-indulgence the moment for their own personal good. Not of life indefinitely prolonged will the ordinary with the certain guarantee man consent to listen unfailingly to the never to omit his milk. been so in the past, when, theoretically, admitted dictates of wisdom or daily bottle of fermented It has ‘verybody that long life is a is still more true to-day, blessing. It old the mind when age seldom presents itself to as an end to be worked for. The pleasure-lover’s maxim of a short life and a merry one has, in more philo- sophic times, become the underlying mo tive of modern existence. We lay stress
Page 9
July 18, 1912 now on the intensity of life rather than on its duration. A higher productivity, a higher capacity for enjoyment, a more vivid realization of the self while con- sciousness endures—that is the essence of the modern outlook upon life. Pro- fessor Metchnikoff would please his gen- eration more by isolating the bacillus of energy rather than the bacillus of long life. Most of us would not know what to do with a hundred years’ time on our hands. Most of us feel no en- thusiasm at the prospect of a world of centenarians. A world in which people were slow to die would Lloyd the expenditures on old-age pensions and so destroy George’s budgets by heaping up cutting heavily into the inheritance tax In times like ours, when the duration of social philosophies and artistic the ories is measured by single years and months almost, to live a hundred years would be to follow up forty years of ex citement with sixty years of headache No, the world to-day is not interested in the prolongation of life. It would not be willing to pay the price if the thing be had. A small, old-fashioned minority there may be to were absolutely to whom a protracted healthy old age will appeal. From them, Professor Metch- nikoff’s glycobacters and lactic bacillus will receive respectful consideration But even with them, as we have said, the mere biological specific will not suf fice. tenaries in considerable numbers, some Before men will attain their cen- scientist will have to inoculate them with the bacillus of patient labor, of simple ideas, and of placid emotions. THE SCIENTIFIC ATMOSPHERE. At the unveiling of the statue to Lord Bacon in front of Gray’s Inn on June 27, Mr. Balfour was chosen to make the ad- dress. There could not have been a hap- pier selection, especially if Bacon’s im- portance in the history of thought was to be dwelt upon. And that is undoubt- edly the lawyer, the statesman, even Bacon his true carrying power. Bacon the writer of great English prose, is not of so much significance to-day as Bacon the philosopher. And of him in that capacity no one is better qualified to utter the just word than Mr. Balfour. Neither a vulgarizer nor a mere pane- gyrist, he is able to seize upon the es- sential thing in the Baconian philoso- phy, and to show what it meant in the ‘ < ition The N ’ seventeenth century and has incre asing ly meant down to our own day Mr. Balfour made rather short work of the theory that Bacon, by the inve tion of the observational and inductive method, put an instrument in the hands of mankind by which the world was abk to press on to one scientific discovery after another. “I do not believe, aid Mr. Balfour that any man i taught to reason by studyi t logis ind I am quit has evs been taught to study nz the nductive +} \ ’ eve Bacon himself may ha | about the matter, he did I vise a machine for scientific d Yet his philosophic writings did about a great chang i ] thinking; but it was m¢ i f attitude than of method I i had been to neglect or n t ternal world, and to engage in ! verbal disputes. Bacon exemplified taught the patient and child-] tude before nature—the humble and pro longed inquiry, the repeated experiment the docility and yet the eagerness of the learner—which is of the essence of what we have come to call the scientific mind This, declared Mr. Balfour, was the real glory and distinction of Lord Bacon “He created the atmosphere in which scientific discovery flourishes.” Thus his true rank is that of a seer. He was not a great investigator, but he put thousands of investigators on the right track. The full results were slow in coming. On this point Mr. Balfour said: Though dates cannot be fixed, | belli it will be found that it is relativel r cently, say within the last three or four generations, that industry has really been the child of scientific discovery Great scientific discoveries were made by Bacon's contemporaries, by his immediate suc« ors, in every generation which ha fol owed, but the application of ientific prix iples to the augmentation of powe! over nature is. I beli rela ly speal ing, of quite r growth You ay find exam] he and r but broad)} peaking, I would inybody’ to cast hi j ‘ r the. histor f discovery ir ] irts s tl of 1 1 n in the zg ra progr yf industrial and agr Itural 4d ove! and I belie he will come to tl conclusion for 1 upon m nd whieh I that the ffect which scier has had and is now having, and in rea g measure is predestined to have, upon the I f this wor'd, did not declare itself i takable letters until a century and a hal or two centuries had passed since tie ¢€ h of the great man whose nar is asst ated with the philosophy of induction
However it came to us, and wl ontributed most to the gift, the rid ww in possession of the scientif lo-day ‘ | at omy rs and : itors be devoting t a to ‘ ts of sea ) s D nt 1at ad W t dis i n k ‘ af - One d | ! ph | +, 7 i nitiat ( i I be Mie at hat sta r i 1 probl ind ‘ de i t compla S d jut men of se } f overweening in T asionally gon ipon t as pt n that nothing |! deeper t of chemic test that instrument of scientific precision l to say exactly what man and God But that is only to ‘ ! iin to be frustrated ] if t T own day to “prove immortatit tifically, is but an instance of what ill happen when science forgets to be truly scientific It zg ack eye it the same time that it upsets the equi librium of many eak brail Scien too, must stick to its last But within ts ne i t I nually at king ind ‘ t p that close to the ll-being ! ir an ar or truthf that it rdo 1 pefulness ha been qui h a. & ntif dea were I ) gh tl hearts of students a to day, nor did the great tasks still | cilentific investigation ever ! e pr fully appeal to devoted workers for the good of their kind. Onl onside for example, the zeal with which skilled in quirers in all countries are giving tl most laborious research to the au
Page 10
52 ~ The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2455 and cure of cancer. Never were there more indefatigable and, withal, more en- thusiastic investigators Give us time, they say, and we will grapple with and this terrible disease. It is not overcome only the desire to benefit humanity that unflagging in endeavor. by keeps them They are buoyed up also their pro- found conviction that the scientific mind The very vith the bound to win air filled they breathe is hope that has yet wonderful improvements science to make in the lot of man, and that true clentifiCc method ertain to go on, juer LITY IN PROFESSORS, nding superiority of the American professor, ac stinguished visi h and The »t without Is ri in- Ameri- best 18 ne dry intelle and tain tual vivacity lacks the rant and con spiritual col vith some tonic preciseness, sional twang; ingly in social dity that may inflattering American profes seconded, with a dif in his Prof ue of the vould ssors,”’ Har- agree that not what they ought further that they insists fal At re-—they have of Btate the grace example great genera Childs and Nortons and passing away, and the man mlucation has descended to un- ouldera-——to men of good train ome no doubt, yet with of the parts rth and stature elder ind the amplitude of personal power rhe p incapable roposition is obviously taken We all returns of is the of demonstration, and should with a liberal allowance of salt know that every graduate who mater an Mr. to his alma after absence twenty or thirty Warren of removal years the class of 1889-—is struck by of ancient landmarks and the vanishing of the old familiar faces, and is prone to declare that things have de- generated since his day. We all know how the elder alumni stroll through the Yard or campus and exclaim at the of luxury “The growth among generation: old college was a group of teachers; the new college is a group of buildings.” “Steam heat in the old dormitory, and bathroom for every suite! We used to split our own kindlings and wash under the pump. I remember how my roommate used to duck his head under the spout in De- cember, and call out, ‘Come on, boys, what makes character.’” We this is know, too, the inevitable turn the con- versation takes at the reunion banquet. “Well, there’s been a great change since dur time, and I’m afraid it’s not entire the “Not new a bad address but lv for better.” the president us, he is gave not the man his predecessor was.” “No; and with old Wells gone and Smith and Jones, and Stone and Huntington and it’s not the same all Stone to-day, and he says the outlook is find These young Walworth retiring, place at all.” “Not at I called on very gloomy; they can’t suitable men to fill the vacancies fellows are cast in another mould; they aren't of the calibre of Wells and Smith.” “Old Wells was a character, though, was- “But he did our paces, and you couldn't get around n't he?” put us through him.” “Old Wells was a war horse, but he business, and I don’t believe like meant there are many him in the new brood.” When all deductions are made for the of doubtedly a substantial basis for the dis- of old the pointed criticism of Mr. Warren. “Old of a Doctor glamour reminiscence, there is un- content the graduate and Wells,” though something Busby, was a thoroughgoing teacher, the terror and delight of the classroom. He touched a vital spot in every student who sat under him. He spoke as one clothed dicta were passed on by tradition. authority, and his obiter He furnished his disciples with a constant with measure of the difference between a cal- the younger | ‘fast passing away. ‘part of the administrators. ! faculty and in the community he held in his own right and not as a loan from the institution which employed him. So far as we knew, he had not a drop of German blood in his veins; yet he was a big and permanently impressive per- sonality. Now, “Old Wells” as a type of the undergraduate college teacher is Apparently, he is |passing away for the economic reason that there is no demand for him on the Other vir- tues than effective teaching and strength of personality seem now to be at a pre- mium; and we agree with Mr. Warren that it is time to be harking back to something that we have lost. Probably nearly every one will admit that the spot where our educational in- stitutions have suffered most deteriora- tion from loss of vital personalities is at the heart of them—in the colleges of liberal arts. Among the various rea- sons which may be brought forward to account for this decline, two stand out conspicuously: First, administrators during the past generation have direct- ed a large proportion of their energy and their funds towards advancing the graduate and professional schools. In- evitably, the attraction of pecuniary re- has into ward and scholarly distinction drawn the more ambitious men professional and graduate work, where teach- desideratum. rather than the Presidents protest that the exceptional successful research ing-effectiveness is undergraduate teacher is as precious to them as the exceptional researcher; but they open their purse-strings to the in- vestigator; and every one who hears university club gossip is familiar with the contemptuous “He's well enough for an undergraduate teacher.” The second reason for the decline is that the at- tendance at the universities has multi- plied faster than the endowments. As |a consequence, vast classes of 500 to 1,000 are vaguely lectured at by wholesale, or cut up into small sections and turned over to a battalion of teething assist- ants and instructors, who are not in- frequently far below the level of the low adolescent and a formed and pur- | average high-school teacher in person- poseful man in a world of men; and he taught them to prize with Montaigne “a strong and manly familiarity and con- verse, a friendship that flatters itself in the sharpness and vigor of its com- munications.’ His great prestige on the ality and in general intelligence. Be tween the graduate school above, with its emphasis upon investigation, and the “slave-labor” below, with its character- less semi-tutorial function, the high call- ing of the teacher is belittled, and the
Page 11
July 18, 1912] The Nation field tends to be left to somewhat weak- Drop “Old Wells” among them, and they would retreat like kneed Laodiceans. rabbits from the presence of a man. The protest against these conditions is certain to increase; for though the ad- ministrative watchword may be “the ad- vancement of science,” the rank and file of the alumni continue to demand “the formation of character.” THE BI-CENTENARY OF ROUSSEAU. GENEVA, June 30. One still remembers the elaborate cele- brations which took place at Geneva in 1909 in honor of Calvin; the celebra- tions to commemorate Rousseau, which have just come to an end, were, if pos- sible, even more notable. Some, indeed, thought that they were overdone. Fol- lowing certain reactionary writers in Paris who, under the leadership of Mau- rice Barrés, protested openly against the proposed festivities at the Panthéon and tried to interrupt the speakers at the memorial ceremony at the Sor- bonne, old patrician families in Geneva would like to have been spared the spec- tacle of their whole city thus idolizing a revolutionary son of the people. The popular impulse, however, proved irre- sistible. For nearly two years prepar ations had been making. Books anda pamphlets, magazine and newspaper ar ticles on Rousseau came thick and fast. On the eve of the 28th the Catholics is sued a statement to the effect that they also would join in honoring the man through whom the irreligious spirit of the eighteenth century was to some ex- tent checked. The Protestants organiz- ed a special meeting on Friday, the 28th, with Professor Fulliquet, the fiery theologian, as their spokesman. And it was agreed that on the following Sun- day Rousseau should be the subject of the sermon in every church. On the evening of Wednesday, the 26th, at a meeting of the Institut Na- tional Genevois, Rousseau exalted as a political writer, patriot, botanist, and musician. A poem made for the occasion was read, and several songs composed by Rousseau sung by artists. Thursday was called the day of the Société Jean-Jacques Rousseau, which does for Rousseau in Geneva a work similar to that of the Shakespeare Society in England. Its official mony took place in the Aula of the Uni- versity, and was attended by many scholars and writers, including several from abroad. The eulogy of Rousseau was pronounced by M. Rosier, the Min- ister of Public Instruction in Geneva. Addressing a largely academic audience, he emphasized the pedagogical reforms brought about by “Emile.” Then came the chief speaker, Prof. Georges Renard of the Collége de France, representing was were cere- all the French universities. His speech was a masterpiece of academic elo- quence, compounded of precise erudition and broad Professor Schulz-Gora of Strassburg fol- humanitarian aspirations. lowed, speaking for the German univer- He explained with more Grundlichkeit than eloquence the influence of Rousseau on thinkers as Kant, Goethe, and Schiller. A grat- ulatory letter was read by an emissary from the Tolstoy Society of Finally, Professor Seippel spoke briefly in the name of the Swiss universities. For the afternoon the Cercle des let- tres et des arts, together with the So- Rousseau, had arranged a repre- sentation of two of Rousseau's “Pygmalion” and “Le Devin du village,” to be given in the magnificent Parc de Ariana. The bright, harmonious cos- tumes, the zest of the players and sing- ers, the graceful dancing of the children made the spectacle perfect. None who was privileged to attend will forget this exquisite artistic treat, on that glorious day of June, near-by the lake of Rous- seau and Byron, the trees s0 green and so fresh. Friday, the 28th, was called a day of rest, but the people of Geneva were most active getting ready for the next, the of- ficial day, a holiday for business and The decorations were tasteful and very rich, especially so in the pic- of were erected on squares and in front of and private At seven o'clock on Saturday morning all the church bells were ringing and the cannon was fired on the old city fortifications. Unfortunately, the weather was not as beautiful as it had been. At nine o'clock a procession of children, students, and “Old went to the Grande rue, the narrow, old street where sities. somewhat such Moscow. ciété plays, under schools. turesque old town; busts Rousseau public houses. Grenadiers” Rous- seau's birthplace stands, and a wreath of flowers was hung over the door. While this was going on in the Haute Ville, the official reception of delegates from the French Swiss cantons, and from for- eign nations, took place at the foot of the philosopher's statue in the pretty Ile Rousseau, which was decorated in eigh- teenth-century style. This was a short, and dignified let me simple, ceremony tut turn to the really original 1e] banquets in the vat part of the festivities, nan , the open- air public of the ious quar ters city—original this function for the charming tustom one of his best pages of d'Alembert.” Tables an orchestra was, at least foreigners; Rousseau himself described it in the “Lettre a set in the public squares; hired to tunes; some people bring their own food, knev nd are 1s play patriotic and popular some buy it there. Citizens of all classes, with children, of course, are met together, drink to- gether. It is all very jolly. every one of these banquets has more or less its own particular character. Here, wives and together, dance Of course, CH 3 you in the quarter of Saint Gervais, have the working people, and especially those working people who are claiming new rights in modern society; at the table of honor, one sees Mr. Sigg, a well-known Swiss Socialist clsewhere at the Quarter of the Madeleine Chur: we have the lowe! lasses; but this time the humble people who enjoy with- out much thought that day of rest be stowed on them by destiny They are grateful for the little they get, and al though evidently indifferent to Rous seau, they have decorated with a pro fusion of flags and flowers their old, nar row, winding streets; a good many have the square; tables set the the simply taken out their family tables and found seats at on small church others have put them outside the door on the side walk; three poor fellows, with a harp, a guitar, and a violin, play in the middle of the street; the frugal meal has not yet come to an end when the good peo ple want to dance Only a fe steps further the official banquet takes place under the beautiful trees of the “Treille,” back of the antique walls of the capitol Here, as elsewhere, the democratic note predominates Mem bers of the most exclusive patrician fam ilies of Geneva face at one table the representatives of the radical Gov ernment; a clergyman is sitting next to a free-thinker and they make speeches in which incerely, they cal one another brothers There also sits the representative of the Federal Coun cil of Bern There is a long tablk little orphan boys, invited by th ganizers of the public meal ir membrance of Rousseau, the f nd of children In the quarter of Saint An toine, on a high terrace overlooking city, near the old “Collége of Ca the intellectuels of Gene i na ith ered, university professor riter urt ists The next number on t was the process hildren. The day } f them had received a ive! n resenting the or] O} R father, with the fathe point ¢ 4+) ty throug! l t ng ! 7 i | ‘ ’ t T) ! , i anti }) Hloud t on the Plalr Plair 1lais put pose being to inspire t an bition to 0 t nti ] Roussea But ist as the long pr g sion reached the podiun a terrifi instorm forced the children to « perss After about an hour of waiting in which an attempt was made to ha some of the eighteenth century dan: performed, everything The elaborate preparations (among oth ers a “cantate” and for that day) came to naught By eight o'clock, however, the sky wa clear again while authorities was given up written composed the and
Page 12
inqueting in taking up ipation of vn gay Here id been re vere dancing sorder, treet no like Rous vo centur people went fellow was ré ike ourse Ives always know It was pre Rousseau had kind of Alem be rt A. S f lo ASSOCIATION LY 2 ARY JUNE 26-J1 July 10 1Go ll long remember which they ind Montreal The Cl were re Ottawa not less at Toron hicago and een invited to stop *a day on their way entertained both by the [ returned ry nd niversity those who to way of that city MeGill 1 were niversity for a the visiting librarians he freedom of the city, riding free on the ge of Saturday the Canadian Library As the Ex On enterta at and the ‘ city, en n on Wednes librarians ; of the The Nation self, but a benefit to the scholar becomes diffused him.” he continued, “for amplified and through ‘May a recognition ganizations also of that type which gave the of old? I mean the type represented by the Paniz- Garnetts, the Winsors, Pooles, Spoffords.’ a definite we not hope,” a re-cognition—in our or- personality to libraries zis, the and this Cutters, At conference pro gramme had been outlined, as express- ed the formal with which Mrs. Elmendorf opened the first general session of the Association. She set forth the ideas that had guided the programme committee, “The library is the one place where time and space are set at naught. It is the microcosm of the . The public for whom the library has little conception or comprehension of its power. How shall such publicity as will give this knowledge of it be not authority, hand. What shall the tests of fitness for such ser- vice be? The staff fit for such service must be rare material and quality. How conserve their strength, well-being, joy? Unskilled people cannot ren- fit What the things matter in training? How far can in address as follows: universe exists given? Service, must be at , Ol and der that training be effective’ This programme was rather closely ad- service. are hered to both in the general sessions and the meetings. Its unity was, however, broken to some extent by the programmes of the other organ- izations that meet with the American Library Association. No fewer than three other societies are directly affiliated, namely, the National Associa- of American Association and the besides, section many regularly Libraries, the of Law Libraries, Association: tion State Special Libraries the Bibliographical Society of America, affiliatea, meets regularly Then there rican Library Institute, which though not with this group of societies the Ame ort of superimposed on and of the American Library Asso- number of The Insti- “academy” eT body ce mposed Council and a spe- cted founded some } ation “academician to con- ars aLko thought suit- tant matte! italogue of the held ngs; f the et jointly im meet pro large to disc uss education of li T | Vol. 95, brarians. Among the other sessions of more or less specialized character the one devoted to the interests of the Agri- cultural libraries attracted the greatest attention. The programme was very full, dealing with the particular functions of the libraries connected with agricultural colleges and experimental stations. There was a symposium on recent reference books and new periodicals of special in- terest to agricultural libraries. Dr. A. C. Trude, director of the United States Office of Experiment Stations, presented a paper, entitled “Suggestions in Regard to a Policy of Administration of Agri- cultural College and Experiment Station Libraries,” in which he dealt not so much with the details of administration as with the results to be obtained. He paid particular attention to the function of the library in the general extension work of the agricultural college. The was also addressed by Martin Burrell, Canadian Minister of Agriculture, and by Prof. James W. Robertson of McGill University, chair- man of the Canadian Royal Commission on Industrial Training and Technical Education. Dr. Robertson took a par- ticularly active part in the work of the conference, besides being chairman of the local committee. On Dominion Day the Association lis- tened to a speech by Sir Wilfrid Laurier, who, on behalf of the Canadian mem- bers, presented to the president a gavel of Canadian maple and Canadian silver. The principal address of that session was by Professor Robertson, who spoke on the “Conservation of Character.” “Let us conserve life,” he said, “for the sake of character.” He condemned the mod- ern factory “that makes things of men and women.” He spoke of the immigra- tion of the American farmer into the Canadian Northwest. The American is always referred to as “chasing the dol- lar.” Why is this so? “He gg said Dr. Robertson, “for the sake of a home and to give some boy or girl a better start”; the call of the land lures for the the children. He also spoke of the importance of vocational, of occupational education. Not remarkable, though many the of Professor was the session does sake of less in ways Robert- de- Prof. antithesis address sion by McGill. He for the devel ized the importance speech, on the McNaughton, ioned son's same occ: livered John also of plea for spiritual made an impass the He of thinking, and gave the of thinking the modern development Germany, the land, had It was things of mind, nent empha as an example of power clear as said, of he said, land of country ol ome one lurringly ‘damned professors,” the ‘damned the had developed as it had in the world of just because Germany was profes ors” that in the things of thought. him- affairs. Her sons believed of the mind, in the Professor McNaughton world addressed
Page 13
July 18, 1912] self all through his speech directly to Professor Robertson, and the listeners bad the sensation of being witnesses at a duel between two principles, two schools. At the evening session of the same day President George E. Vincent of thi University of Minnesota delivered an ad- dress full of subtle irony and whimsical humor in which he pointed out how li- brarians could influence men’s character through their reading. ‘Books are dead symbols,” he said, “until they become vitalized in the hands of a living man.” Thus came to an end a conference of librarians at which the chief subject of discussion was not technique, but the results aimed at. It was not the first American Library Association confer ence where this tendency to substitute the essentials for the non-essentials was felt. but it was the first, I think, where a conscious effort in this direction had the pro- G. L. J for A guided those ré¢ sponsible gramme. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. New and important letters touching the early life of Edgar A Poe have come tc light t Librar f Congress. The are among tl Ellis-A:ia papers, a col lection of s¢ $42 rtfolios and volumes of office book letters of an old Rich mond, Va., fir Th iates run from 1799 to 1889 John Allan, Poe’s foster-father vas a memt of u r Poe was also employed tl S°7. but doubtless ré ceived his s¢ board and lodging fror Allar A letter from Poe’s aunt Eliza Poe, dated Baltimore, Fet ry 38, 23 about two years after |! had | n taken into the Allan famil s addressed to Mrs. Allan, asking about the we edgar A previ« letter had met th no response It should st i that date there had been nm tercou ‘ ‘ two families F.liza Poe after ! irried Henry Hert I I ght ind Poe's cousin Eliza H Pe mad 0 and ‘ eal g9 John Al » Poe's bre Wil I I be R24 At that d I ’ tl nior M Rif undvery li th > ] of th } ' ak } > INT P . 7 7 was to end in Poe's leaving his home s xisted other documenta rele vears later had now started Mrs. Alla Po which he had never ee = was suspicious of her husband, and \ H leclined to ! it Aus Most likely Poe ke; lea " ormed of some of Allan's secret fT an examitia But I Whe P 8 ther lied n Ri I pa ar Re 1, Allan took charge of the few fa . x ur trinkets and a packet of letters Several H. Wi ot these letters were alwa S ; . V Fume 28 ltl t fas let } P . oset Alla i ! ‘ ca Rigge Neg thane Mears warsege . Corresp lene letters, he probably knew th ontents : oOncdence I entire packet Mrs. ( Poe } n-law ind au } i RMS NEEDING D 4 ( Sssion ¢ sey il o t t ) estroved ® before her Gent . I 1e EpItoR oF THE Na a dark Poe family secret. and } ‘ ) > What doc ; _ impression that by her work all knowledge Radica ‘ this was now blotted out. Pert Allan a ee vished P to feel that } ! 1 th ly posstb! in a event ’ ‘ e ’ tra ! letter to Poe's bri er thy follow What hen i a free At least she [Rosalie Poe] is half your sis ind a : 1 God forbid He it w , t é tariff country? should visit upon the liv g th errors and il ‘ frailties of the dead.” Her the secret ho lent told for tl P trad t brother pretended to F. W. Thomas that } n M l , Kno wha j ‘ } ! n { r } 1 tor! . " : y i homas tl I id I ted } I New Yorthk . oo +} r thi charges of . i ause for Poe's alleged desertion P , Poe's brother also stated to F. W. Thoma : : is t that the cause for Edgar's leaving Alla em l Le juarr about the pittan f n } . a defin i vhat 1 : This is now substantiated Two t rs to Allan from Geor w. s } } ly rsit of Virs . : tre | , isking r pay for p I h ter id , ant—Poe t having, what otl ¢ as t ! had, a rvant to look } . 5 I trad ‘ P . om. Ther s also a Charlott: Va trade and ta yr bil { S I th le r to Poe isone fr i friend : 1 or partial ] h f de an 1G. ( sted Marcl : ho tl Poe \ j . ul lut ’ i i t & | ! i 1g It i r t if } y Pe is H R r rt th 7 | f } I ' | | 1 } +} ‘ ‘ h I t T i { T sa lames
Page 14
sur Moreau d St ‘The the Un party the inde Nor! onfir with brarian wo d in nd arrested Havre h for whither Sailed with the United this long and in t ing port \! up ind whe tion his five d iring I inn eg 17909 A eral h ordinary aucer Oo Sur ‘ 11 base poll il intrigue Nation and that he peror ernoon sev the stn} rinted in | iret he re pense tolerated ontagious!” ct poverty arts I he was a ne Fournier Moreau and loubtl which andy painful he Diary, ons lerk to re he honorable finance linen my celebrities Pes had that Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2455 brought him into con- mob by whom he was danger- He to small where he was discovered hid he was pursued and whence and children The description of escaped a but got free and at his wife two States is in of voyage given the The in most Ter- Santo and is one the the of volume and Moreau he civil war financially, so that too glad York mer- Philadelphia, and was only New erica a drifted to as a he he ier greater por- pub- bookse spent the years’ sojourn in the United Washington's second term Administra- and of Adams's returned ng France but to posts was re- straits through a he to made proud speech | do ask probity; I Fear For But ial that order this sell Then to your Majesty that had to in live not beg only disease lived in- nothing, my years he remarkabl« zed of Paris a But Balch month, had Philosophica! So- six his on every all sevVv- Dr at were recogni nearly nd of ther who mber of cieties né Mr eeting nor last gave who been American as in this galaxy, though n the extracts he was very furthermore tells us all any ary friends in ranks pf he.” strict had so mi as due to the which he had ¢ that “Tew ss largely motto n- his watch, so it est tou- And the words es ll bien with these petual that him where 66 000 sloved take were be em for his would told not advan and the whole family another lle« Revolution, lectoral wrote Silvestre us gives wonderful Inte tual ak of the the Paris E single night th: wonder that 1 and thou this his ore n three when struck in honor a medal. He was the author of a large number of sayings that were current. Here are two preserved by M. Silvestre: “Grati- tude is a flower of the tomb,” and “Calumny is a money that anybody can coin and few His death, it appears, was pre- cipitated by an act of kindness to a relative. It and not surprising to know that “he had a noble and beautiful face.” In the spring of 1794, Moreau made a Stage trip from Philadelphia to New York. lt is one of the most valuable portions of his well illustrates his passion for and out-of-the-way refuse.” is pleasant Diary and details, information and extracts precise data, which renders these notes so useful instructive to-day. I give sev- eral May 24, 1794 Princeton resembles all the other places already described that we have passed through since we started from Philadelphia, that is to say, it consists almost wholly of houses lining either side of the road, some eighty in number and chiefly made of brick The town has a Presbyterian church and a college. The last calls for a stop in order to speak of it, just as we made a stop to visit it. The building, which is of stone, is about 70 French feet in length and some 40 deep. It has three stories, if we count as a story the ground floor, which rises from 7 to 8 feet above the ground and thus makes possible cellars. There is a garret at the top, that the Americans say that the building is four stories high. In the mid- dle, the edifice advances so that there are ten windows on either side of this pro- jection and six more under the pediment. On the whole, this structure is quite strik- ing for America. In front is a large yard, shut off from the street by a brick wall, with pilasters at equal distances supporting wooden urns painted gray. This yard is rot well kept and is covered with the dung of the animals that go there to browse on the grass In the middle is an old iron cannon, a four-pounder, minus its carriage This cannon and the bad condition of the wall with several of the urns fallen to the ground, give an unkempt appearance to everything that you reach the building with a feeling of vexation that the students should have such a bad example before their eyes You enter this college, which alled Nassau Hall, by three doors, one cf which is in the middle of the portion of the edifice which advances and the two others on the sides and parallel to each other The steps leading up to these doors are in wood and without balustrades. The two upper floors are dormitories, with a cor- ridor running from end to end, which di- vides each floor into equal parts. There i2 rooms, each intended to accommo- three students On the ground floor chapel, a dining hall, and a library two thousand volumes, where you shown the justly celebrated planeta made by Dr. David Rittenhouse, who President of the Philosephical So- of Philadelphia, and who was born nnsylvania Facing the central door the back of the building a lareé roo! furnished with the usual the right on entering, you notice a picture some eight feet high—a full-length portrait of Washington, hold iis sword in right hand and in the of commanding, while his left hand resting on his hip, grasps his hat Behind him, on the left of the picture, and somewhat in the background, is General Mercer, lying on the ground, resting on his left shoulder. Back of the General are two aides-de In the distance, on the right side of the canvas, is represented the battle of Princeton. Though this picture not without merit, three criticisms of it may be made In the first plaee, General Washington holding his hat in his hand and appears very composed at the moment when he commanding in battle Sec- ondly, General Mercer, who died from the wound which he received at this battle of Princeton in January, 1777, does not appear to be suffering, and, thirdly, the aldes-de- camp are presented in such an uncertain attitude that they do not seem to be occu pled with the dying General 80 is are date are a f some re rium is now ety ir, Pe but at lass 0 is benches On his ct side a] amy is is
Page 15
July 18, 1912] At the back of the college yard, which, too, is dirty and the turf al- lowed to grow wild, so that everything hereabout has a neglected air Though there is room in the building for 120 stu- dents, only about eighty are present, com- from Virginia and the two I should like to praise the man- of this institution, but when one ing chiefly Carolinas agement has not been brought up in American fash- ion, this is difficult The system which puts no restraint on children is so closely allied with heedlessness on the part of teachers, and so strongly favors the indo- lent disposition of the Americans, that it can produce only a vicious order of things. Its effects are visible at Princeton Col- lege, where, I am told, the attention of the students is more occupied with gaming and licentious tendencies than with their studies Their board and lodging costs them $100 (550 francs) per year, and wash- ing one gourde a month Princeton is a very healthful place. This is proved by the registers of the College, which has lost but five or six students since its foundation. This, perhaps, is one of the reasons why young men from Santo Do- mingo flock here. There are several inns in the town, the principal one being that of the Sign of Washington, where Gen Rochambeau put up when he marched from Rhode Island to Virginia At this moment it is kept by David Hamilton. The houses are bordered along the street by very catalpas. fine September 21, 1794 The news has spread of the beheading of Robespierre. It has made a deep impres- sion in the United States, but in several different ways The Jacobins here were profoundly afflicted by it, as if they had lost their father, their leader, their best friend. But all those who are not Jacobins all true patriots and sincere friends of liberty see in this event a providential act only too long delayed. As regards the Amer- icans of all classes and all kinds, they show sincere regret for the disappearance of Robespierre, and are greatly moved by his death. Here is the reason for it; Robespierre made it impossible for French- men to remain in France As soon as a man or a gold could get out of the country, they came over here; and, as what are wanted here are men, money, and in- dustry, it is evident how the destruction of such a being will hurt this side! I have heard this said a hundred times with T ce piece those on a frankness which did not make it any more palatable to me For a long time the Jacobins declared that there was no truth in the report But I wagered two gourdes not a small sum for me—against one that it was true Oh! how I would all I possessed if my dear De Varenr have given had escaped from the monster whose execrable memory posterity wil never treat wo! than is d rved Who do t g to | the loss of a father, a ther 1 son, a daugl relat rf l i 0 atriot I I } g more 0 ess dear? Sent 1794 We had dining with Dr. Mit l celebrated New York ch ist. We wet to the horse races at Jamaica, Long Island i the evening, when I took hi back to New Yor! \ had a cold, strong wind, which drove us nearly down to Sandy Hook Ni ‘ I 19 1794 I went to Washingtor nter Congr and listen to his opening address How simple and natural it all was! But it was Washington, and it was the neeting of the representatives of a nation which had con- quered its liberty What vast, grand con ceptions in such a simple se How these republican forms address themselves to the and lift up the heart! What a destiny they predict for this part of the world! tting! soul February 28, 1796 I went and paid my respects to Mr Adams, who has become Vi President of the United States. January 21, 1798 I went and saw General Kosciuszko, who has just arrived in Philadelphia, where the Americans have received him with great there is also a ry .e . The Nation of joy. They carriage and drew where he had landed to the had lemonstrations horses from his from the point lodgings which been engags lv I ling against tl Fr h ing stronger every day In Ph it present, | am the only pers th French cockade rhe Ar ica R publicans fearing they ay t ows with the Federalists hav held a eeting and taken secret measures to prote é selves. I was present at this gath g and was given two keys for two different places of refuge for me and house should be threatened l ha taken passage on the Adraste. A little later I learned that Mr, Adams, President of th« United States, has drawn up a list of Frenchmen to be sent out of the country at the head of which list stand Vol: General Collot, and I I irious to know what Mr. Adams had rainst me So mine n ase my own was | asked Mr. Langdon, Senator fro New Hampshire, to enquires rhe answer was Nothing in particular but he is 00 French.” Now, all the tir Mr \dams was Vice-President, he often came to my house, to my office, and to my o We even presented one another with our books But I never saw him after he becar Pres ident Mr. Robert Liston, Minister Plent- potentiary of England, has ry kindly provided me with a passnort for me, my family, my goods, papers, maps, drawings et August 22, 1798 On the celebrate ball to asked occasion of a proposed Washington's birthday I Mr. John Vaughan, a merchant, my near neighbor, and a fellow member of the Philo sophical Society, to get me one of the tick- ets which were on sale and which gave ad- mittance to the ball But he answered that as I was a storekeeper I could not claim such an honor Whereupon, I an- swered Are you not aware of the fact that I was never mor your equa than from the noment that I a notl uv I did not get a ticket, and | did the ball One day I was talking in my hop with Mr. Swanwick, merchant and m« er of the House of Representatives, when the publisher, Matthew l ligence, but an American of the Carey, a an of int States, drew me aside and said with a trou bled alr: “Are you aware that you ire speaking with Mr. Swanwick? Yes,” I answered. “And you do not address h as Excellency, knowing that e belongs to tl Lower House?” I replied When Mr. Swanwick, who know that I was a ‘ er of the Constituent A whicl was at least ten times mor rtant than your Congress, excel i lo the ime, but not before \ Philadelphia shoemaker d I ler himself d graced if vorked for lren TI aptain of i I Us lumt of New York told 1 hat at never ate with hi beca ft t get! tl would ta and t hen ft \ n of j n ler of tl United Stat ‘ gon ’ 1 | r iil ’ 1 ga 1 ica rh t i I York ind ft 1 +) ta ‘ or igacity ro ar Ame in j r t gn of ] riorit t sior fa irr I the lally sho id ‘ bor ] lelir j \ vO ur * 7, riag erf t! rtair ¢ 7) ‘ 4 +} vo i ha no carriag th i r will t be considered her equa Cr ’ y pr vate irriages a ratl ! But th ar not ver ) forta 4 Au ’ of ther ire open in front ke th stage In Philadelphia there are f two-whee ] carriages and 409 four-wheeled, besides carts and wagons for transporting Irpo There is an organization to bring about he abolition of slavery But tl makes very slow progress, as pub! nion is more opposed than favorable t the were ar sttend A word ing the oncerning opening of the session f ¢ ner « took the / When tt t ber requir President is if th states o1 I self When ses t is es t ‘€ > ate sitting l f the House of R rt Senators ym hall of the Re neress rhe pears, the Repre s geant-at-art to tl erior w irily noon wl eated alone in rses His thr ur in whit live irs I front ‘ able with fourteen ~ pol enters, everybody) the Speaker ent ind goes presiding rhen hav lress star standing in chairs ¢ offi ing iding The mn W floor of the H luring the ngton har of the ds a and returns to ame Washingtor furbished wearing a arrying a the others emony. H ing nor in 1 in the s worthy wiz put i addrs presiding his I on e was golr publ 1z of the I 1 very inte 4 1 to find Di it Morea } f nd ds } lial 1 ’ l | rhe f t l iw 1 of inton I ¢ not +} i ‘ } Hi b Ml ' MI ' j ' ¢ ; | A ; tr ia per } } for listrib I tint So ] pub ished { zg pa igé | ar the applauds The galleri« g by on he whol rH he two chambers hav th } the a le
Page 16
1as been quoted by Talley and that it ns be tween it Philadelphia Loliée and t biographies of the also ads ting article in La Revue ladelphia tor 7 tet and ba l on the of cour that I have in no Diary nt of the fact that Stanton had seen 1 I think Mr. Stantons tity my f lot not jus glad to tl profit ath ontained n ie let i wwledgement of it in to the edition of the Diary publication at j which titution has just had mad for me, and at my own initi will send me his ad be pleased to mail him a eady for dis NTHEON IN ROME if NATION one kindly tell n if Pantheon in Rome did rather the not it not dedicat Julia Literature in rRINE OF SOUL. THE \ History and a De By William Ik I} New York The Ma ) net ‘ 1 in the ib l if K n it con { it | it fi n 7 n ] t list rps ' e to of mething ent from that principle gen ferred The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2455 necessarily or always conceived as an immaterial and indi- vidual being or soul.” This, the doctrine of the the real subject of the book. “I hold,” says Dr. McDougall in his Preface, “that men of science ought to make intelligible to the general public the and of scientific dis- cussions upon questions to directed.” erally, but not soul, is issue the wider which their researches Recent attempts in this direction have not been eminently successful in deal- ing thus with psychological and philo- sophical problems, and it is a gratifica- tion, therefore, to find that in this case the pressure of this sense of obligation has led to the writing of so worthy a course are book. This, however, will not surprise those who have followed Dr. McDou- gall’s career; for he has already won not only as a neurologist, but lately as a psychologist; and laurels, also mort no English writer is better equipped by temperament or training for the task undertaken. Nevertheless, it is not at all certain that he has succeeded in this effort to present an argument that shall be fully “intelligible to the general pub- lic.” His opening historical chapters are not easy reading; and the same must be said of his excellent studies of the physiological, psychological, and philosophical objections, which have led, as he acknowledges, to the very wide- spread rejection of the animistic hypo- thesis by the modern world. The plain man will thus probably find the first half of the book too difficult to follow, and will be tempted to »vass over light- ly the critical matter there treated, while accepting gratefully the closing favorable to animism with likely to find himself in arguments which he is sympathy. Adopting the method of the trained scientist, our author in the first six chapters makes a careful study of the the doctrine this historical four chapters care the which and development of rise under consideration: urvey being followed by in which he opposition to with great the view states Ee in in the end he is presenting arguments, and developing to suppo! + the uiverse their strength, with a fairness that is truly admirable when one considers the final drift of his thought. He then pro d " n the eaknesses of erst rgument the diffi- nected with t ibandonment v ition of the soul; and find- t ( eaknesst ind difficulties fl ntly formidable to lead him to re n the mass of his fellow-scien 1 rejecting the animistic doctrine, i elf warranted in choosing t ! to the traditional view, which ippeals to his inner nature, notwith- tanding its acknowledged perplexities ind obscurities, Apart to below, details to be re from some there is no just ground ‘tor any substantial disagreement with the author until we reach his final step; but here we must demur. Although he has not hesitated te face the unanswered difficulties connected with the concep- tion of the soul, yet one feels that he tends to overemphasize the cogency of those connected with the opposition. His argument appears at most to warrant a suspension of judgment, rather than the positive advocacy of the animistic hypo- thesis with which the book closes: for it cannot be granted, even on pragmatic grounds, that he is justified, as he thinks he is, in “willing to believe” in a concept which he acknowledges to be obscure and involved with objections, unless he can present sound reasons for his belief that the rejection of the con- ception of a soul must necessarily in- volve the unfortunate moral results he fears. But this he fails to do. Nor is he justified in asserting that his final interpretation of the meaning of this concept of the soul is fitted to meet the needs of the people, the utter demoralization of whose lives he fore- sees if belief in this is weak- ened. The soul, he tells us in his clos- ing chapter, “is a being that possesses, or is, the sum of definite capacities for psychical activity, and psycho-physical interaction, of which the most funda- mental are (1) the capacity of produc- ing, in response to certain physical stim- uli, . the whole range of sensa- tion qualities, in their whole range of intensities; (2) the capacity of respond- ing to certain sensation-complexes with the production of meanings; ... (3) the capacity of responding to these sensations and meanings with feeling and conation or effort, under the spur of which further meanings may be brought to consciousness in accordance with the laws of similars and of reason- ing; (4) the capacity of reacting upon the brain modify their course in a way that we cannot clearly define, but which we may provisionally concept these processes to conceive as a process of guidance by which streams of nervous energy may be concentrated in a way that antagon- izes the tendency of all physical energy to dissipation and degradation.” “The “has always held that all ‘memory,’ all popular view,” he continues, mental retention and reproduction, all mental and moral growth, is rooted in the soul; that, in short, the soul is the bearer of all that is essential to the de- veloped personality of each man,” But this view, he agrees, “cannot be recon- ciled with the fact that the makeup of human personality includes many hab- its that are unquestionably rooted tn the structure of the nervous system, It conflicts also with the large mass of evidence which indicates the depen- dence of all the sensory content of con- eclousness . . on the integrity of the brain.” He therefore accepts an hypothesis of dual conditions of mem-
Page 17
July 18, 1912] ory, and under this view holds (p. 372 that, although “all habits belong to the body, the soul does undergo a real de- velopment, an enrichment of its capaci- ties’; and if it survives death, “car- ries with it some large part of that which it has gained by intellectual and moral effort”: and that, although it is “impossible to suppose the surviving soul would enjoy the exercise of thought of the kind with which alone we are familiar, yet it is not inconceivable that it might find conditions that would stim- ulate it to imageless thought, might find under other conditions (pos- sibly in other bodily organism) a sphere for the appli- or association with some cation and actualization of the capaci- ties developed in it during its life in the body.” It is not easy to believe that faith in the existence of souls of the nature thus described by our author would carry with it the comfort and moral stim- ulus which he feels it so important to retain. While in a measure it may meet (p. 371) “the mere personal dis- like of the prospect of extinction,” it can scarcely give satisfaction to the “promptings of personal affection.” It surely points to no way by which “the injustices of this life may be made good” in another world; nor does it obviously strengthen “the hope that those highest products of evolution, the personalities built up by long sustained moral and effort, shall not wholly pass away at the death of the body.” Clearly the nature of the indi- vidual his concep tion from that of the personalities men te interest the plain nian, desires and hopes, as our author acknowledges, the survival of intellectual personalities which diverse living whose is too suggests of will only be satisfied by a soul that has not only something “of that distinguishes one personal ity from and “marks of the experiences it has undergone in its em- bodied life’; but that continuity of personal memory” whit h another,” also “enjoys a type familiar to us all in every-day of life. The critical tone of these remarks must not give the reader the impression that the writer of this review is ul sympathetic with these desires and hope of the plain man. The best of | , plain men during a large part of « waking hours, and as such must share the feelings and aspirations of our f lows. But we must not lose sight of fact that are here deali1 not with desires and hopes, nor even ¥ rit but with an attempt to gain clarity o thor t The doctrine of the existence of a which endures aft death i certainly carried with it man re benefits to struggling humanity, and not to be lightly discarded because of the doubts raised by modern science But surely even one who believes most fully that the concept of immortality embodies a < The truth, which N will 1tion a great that thes doubts, agree our author's own state ments must emphasize, indicate that the truth which is so bound up with thes benefits is ill-expressed in the animisti concept It is true indeed that doubt does not necessarily indicate the total invalidity of the concept it leads us to distrust; it may, and usually does, mean no more than that the doubted concept gives us a distorted image of the truth But where doubts are so well founded as our author himself shows them to be in this case, their significance cannot be overlooked; and if we believe that the doubted concept embodies a vital trut we must agree that there is call for its re-expression. That such a re-expression of the truth which is ill expressed by the animistic hypothesis will be forth coming at no very distant day is the firm conviction of the present writer; and he is inclined to feel that a thinker of the ability of our author, instead of cling ing to the old concept by an effort of will, should have felt himself bound to look for such re-expression Passing from this general view, we note certain details of Dr. McDougall's argument which are not thoroughly con vincing. He properly gives weight to the difficulties connected with the hypo thesis of “parallelism” as devised and developed by the Assoriationists, who ac the uncritically cepted conception of mind as an aggregate of psychic atoms But this atomistic view is now-a-days de } fended by few psychologists, being gen erally displaced by the conception of mind as a psychic system; and our au thor’s objections to the parallelism of the atomists do not appear to apply to the hypothesis of mental and physical correspondences within correlated ph cal and mental systems, in some of the forms in which it has been presented Dr. McDougall quite properly empha sizes the difficulties attending the ae ceptance of the mechanist explanatioz of biological phenomena, especially those relating to the existence of var on; but we surely are not thereby f ed to assume, as he t! planation ot the pi ( i nm « e found in tl f I f iT tT { dor not | be | red it { rgument i much ol t it, atte ter! ( ! i ‘ tep ! the st all « ( perience re ted t ~ +) special situations or changes n physical system rather ; @ & welcome acknowledgement tl knowledge of consciousnes given our interpretation of introspection surpasses in breadth our kn Ig the nature of its physical is S an acknowledgment by on: f our f most neurologists is significant a indication that we are awakening the Spt ll under whicl ave placed by the psycho-p t nd ready again to conti: e study psychology from whi ades they have diverted nt We shall return to tl ish owe vith glad acknowledgment t of the work done by the exponents o misnamed “New Psychology so far it gor and ready to avail ou hat is valuable to our purpos n rather meagre data tl ha t n to gather. These critical obse itio t lead the reader to und t ite value of the book D MeDougall given us. Differing from the author ve do, in relation to certain t n points in his exposition, and den as we must, the legitimacy f s f conclusions, we nevertheles ecor fully the value of his acl met s just because of this val that book is worthy of careful analysis thorough study: and we nn this review without ref: ng f vith admiration to the fair ! di and intellectual rectitude of its aut! nor without repetition of t con that he has given us a! t enlig ing contribution to the \ diffi t ct he has undertaken t 1 CURRENT FICTION T) Dewpond By (Cl ur New York John Lar ( This is a bewilder Like the ork of or rs of modern fi i ‘ en that " ‘ | the ‘ ;
Page 18
60 For much satire is lavished on the ' Mi ‘ rs unfortunate Saintsbury'’s crude no- creative mind gets the how the tions as to its material and on great publi extraordinarily stupid about on There is throughout a condemnation for all who the narrator’s views on morals, and the reads in a guilty literature, s of life One detected in a “usual” atti- The characters being anything marvellous subtlety. No toward tude are drawn with they, but and women bris unexpected them types men tling with per selve but as brightly visible as wisps. The plot deals ious discontent of a wife all hose “passions and pref were intellectual.” He “had been had never had youth”; he by could not see sonality, ng always the unexpected, will o the the half-un- with het and do with conse husband erences young, but he red fac tion, but he had be her her observa- Hilda Flora, and When mother of little fulfilled far as was concerned, The youth ful to which he still rele- gated her after to the vas not quite big enough acqul ts reason ome the destiny seemed sO husband unimportance coming conclu sion that she part of a political hostess” a half-acknowledged griev to play the became to het whom she happened “unawak tell where ance Uniluckily, an author had along at the unconsciously inspired moment when her beginning to this is ndition Incidentally, in the ‘unawakened woman” Why awaken Hilda’s case was was ened upon he rson, character of The tiresome the usua’ pe worm, turns grows her sleep dificult motherhood” “had giv least the knowledge” that she Though she hardly wasted: kept because it was “mar which hing was being duties and responsibili the triangular with more re ind vith less of politics not end hip which led f the time and cane ere hardly tin e because they most dis friend oc\al did quarre! hel iat the for i@ marriage t To cept of uch a story a query will persist, narra of pro the than From ind is not the in the “awakenting’ 1 anti-climax to her t? The scenes by less subtly presented of the to political dinners there unfolding drama tudi i8 An OTERY oO parti of brilllancy dimmed only by of the be The floun the tendency un-obvious to come obvious plain reader The N ation [ Vol. 95, No. 2455 ders when told that Hilda was “Flemish rather than Florentine, with the clear, square drawing that you get in a white tulip.” Blinks when she asks, “Yes, but isn’t it part of the blessing of knowing what you want that you're not meant to To Mr. Saintsbury this “would but, of have?” have seemed sheer nonsense,” course, we others know better. The White Waterfall. By James Fran. cis Dwyer. New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. Polynesia is inexhaustible ground for adventure. Each new island may have hitherto unvisited by the story- writer. Maoris, Kanakas, and Fijians may plausibly assemble, lending a hand, friendly or otherwise, to English and Californian explorers. This is what happens in “The White Waterfall.” A San Franciscan scientist, with profound interest in ancient Polynesian skulls, is lured to a voyage of investigation by a wretch whom it were flattery to call a devil. The professor’s two daughters accompany him, naturally. The leading scoundrel and a villanous’ English ship's captain are offset by the owner's gallant nephew and an intrepid mate, while brown and black up the crew. Thus through storm and stress they come to the Isle of Tears and have amazing adventures among amazing surroundings which are not all invented properties, but are warranted by the au- thor to have analogies in real South Sea Island history. And of the Dance of the Centipede and the Vermilion Pit and the Stone Sacrificial Altar with the mov- able slab, the reader will not let go till the White Waterfall has been found, the Maori's song fulfilled, and through fear- some scenes a happy ending procured for the deserving few. The story leaps along seductively and, if not in the clas- language of Defoe, is told in an agile with no detaining superfluities, been make sic fashion The Blue Wall. By Richard Washburn Child Mifflin Co. Many Hands” and The Man in be dis- appointed in Mr. Child's lates! In the stories the great was the sympathetic presentation of attrac- tive in “The Blue Wall” character is sacrificed to story, and the not the Jull- anna Colfax, a charming girl, supposed- ly the daughter of a fine old New Eng- land judge, discovers after his death that she is really a sort of changeling, the daughter of a drunkard murderer. The plot turns on the effect which this supposed fact has on her life. Clearly, here is a chance for an interesting study in character. But the author chooses to neglect this opportunity, and to make an artificial mystery out of his hero- ine. To heighten curiosity, he devises a series of disquieting events; he throws Boston: Houghton readers of “Jim the Shadow” will book. earlier merit characters; story is worth sacrifice out numerous dark suggestions and mis- leading clues. Apparently, we are to have a detective story. The doctor, who is the principal narrator, gathers his facts from four subordinate narratives, and the central situation is not disclos- ed till past the middle of the book. To preserve the mystery, the heroine is kept in the background until almost the end, when, of course, she supplies the solution. Meanwhile, like Chaucer's Custance in the “Man of Law’s Tale,” she displays a taciturnity explicable only on the ground that without it there would be no story. To balance this unnatural reserve, her husband shows an equally abnormal loquacity; at a time when he is half-distracted with anxiety about his wife’s condition, he relates with much dramatic skill the strange course of his courtship and mar- riage, at a length of more than a hun- dred pages. Finally, the theory that Julianna is the drunkard’s daughter is found to rest solely on the testimony of an untrustworthy old servant, who dis- appears after declaring that, for rea- sons of her own, she has fabricated the whole thing. It is a sort of “The Lady or the Tiger?” dilemma; was Julianna daughter to the judge or to the murder- er, and was the change in her due to her heredity or to her mistaken belief about it? Mr. Child's very sensible an- swer to these question is, “Who cares?” MILITARY FINANCE. Modern Wars and War Tares: A Manual of Military Finance. By W. R. Law- son. Edinburgh: William Blackwood & Sons. Though this book has some very grave defects, it is nevertheless an important contribution to one of the greatest dis- cussions of the day. Mr. Lawson says that Norman Angell’s “The Great IIlu- sion” is too refined and obscure an ar- gument to have much weight with the democratic assemblies who will be the chief war-makers of the future. No one will say that of his own argument. The democratic assemblies will not find it too refined, and if it is obscure, they will not discover the fact. He seems to fancy himself at Donnybrook Fair in- tent on cracking a head wherever he sees one. Sir Robert Walpole, Adam Smith, Cobden, Gladstone, and Lloyd George all feel the weight of his cudgel. His excursions into economics some- times land him in very peculiar situa- tions, and his philosophy of history might with some truth exclaim, “I am fearfully and wonderfully made.” Yet he has written a timely, read- able, and on the whole instructive book. He does not err in saying that there does not exist in the English language a textbook of military finance, and he de- serves more than slight thanks for at- tempting to supply a great need. In view of the pioneer character of his ef- some
Page 19
July 18, 1912] fort, and of the stress of political emo- tion amid which it has been accom- plished, it is not surprising that this need has not in every particular been successfully met. It is quite obvious that our author is addressing with quickened pulse an audience keyed to a high pitch. Much that he says is fantastic, irrelevant, or even absurd. Nevertheless, there is an _ irreducible minimum of sound sense and prophetic warning that entitles this book to wide and careful reading. Andrew Carnegie and Edwin Ginn will probably dissent from the declara- tion that armaments are not to be put down by pacific crusades. They rest, we are told, on too broad a founda- tion for that. They should be studied as one of the fundamental problems of modern civilization. Critics who would judge them fairly and intelligently must put themselves in the place of the re- sponsible rulers, who, one and all, re gard them as a necessary evil. A mod- erate amount of historical knowledge, declares Mr. Lawson, will suggest vari- ous rational motives for even a peace- loving state to hold it a duty to be well armed “in unsettled times like these.” The legitimate rivalry of nations, for example, was never so keen as at pres- ent. Another motive is found in the fact that all states, and European states in particular, are more exposed than ever before to the formation of new combinations which may threaten their security and their international rights. Thirdly, it must be remembered that there still a large leaven of brute force in the world, which breaks out ever and anon, in comparatively cultured communities. Nor should ignore the fact that the principle of na- tionality is still rampant in many coun- tries, one can see from the Italian raid on Tripoli. And, lastly, racial ques tions of supreme gravity are being brought to the front, China, for exam- ple, being alive with them. Gentlemen may cry “Peace, peace!” but evidently there is no peace. is even we as Mr. Lawson's conten- tion appears to be that the world is con- fronted with a condition rather than a theory, and, that being the case, it is high time to put armaments on a sound economic foundation. The parts of his book which undoubt- edly are to his mind the most valuable will strike many of his readers as the most negligible. Economics is not his strong point. He should have known better than to declare, in his chapter on Food and Finance, that, “with all respect for Adam Smith and his Socialistic per- verters of the present day, labor is not the sole source of wealth. The means of keeping labor in good condition and fit for work—in other words, an ade-| quate stock of food—is as much wealth as labor itself.” Statements so ill-con- sidered as this are calculated to weaken his influence when he talks on subjects The Nation he is with economics. His comparisons of the financial strength of the chief Powers are a more respectable accom- plishment in this particular domain, yet they fall very far short of being satis- factory. They strike one as being about of a piece with most of the statistical compilations got together in Great Bri- tain in times of political agitation. Mr. Lawson is over-fond of rhetoric. “There are,” he of statesmen in England, as in most other countries. One can clearly things under his nose, and form sensible but superficial opinions them. He will not, however, look half an inch beyond his nose, either right or left, before or behind. This Mr. Cobden's favorite method of argument.” Here we have Mr. Lawson at his mild He is a bit more vigorous when he Says, “two classes see very very about was est. exclaims, “When there was no Chatham or Pitt or Canning or Palmerston or Beaconsfield available, we have had to get on as best we could with Foreign familiar with concordats Ministers who were more catch-words than with protocols, and more at home with par liamentary platitudes than diplo- matic precedents. On the they have been wonderfully lucky in keeping out of serlous scrapes.” He is perhaps most picturesque when he declares that “everybody [the Ministry and Parlia- ment] concerned in burking the report of the Royal Commission of Food and Raw Materia’ Supply in War runs a risk of summary hanging, should or with whole, 1903 on the British navy ever lose command of the sea”; or in his reference to “the craven and corrupt administration of Sir Robert Walpole.” Interspersed, however, with much that will make economists stare and phil- osophers rub their eyes, there is a great amount of shrewd and pithy comment on the course of nations, particularly the British nation—enough, fact, to give Mr. Lawson's latest publication a solid détre. With all its short- comings, the book has the great merit of presenting one of the most momen- tous problems of this or of any age ina manner to excite the thought of both large and small minds. in raison By Joseph H. Charles Scrib- Japan of the Japanese. Longford. New York: ner’s Sons. $1.50 net. This is a contribution to the Countries and Peoples series by the professor of Japanese at King's College, London. His long residence in the Island Empire and admirable training in the British con- sular service have prepared him to give the publica thoroughly trustworthy book; and in all essential qualities this com- |pendium is to be highly recommended. The historical chapters dealing with the growth of feudalism and the samurai |class are especially valuable. For the, with which he is more conversant than | ethnology, a subject still in the realm of to mention. 61 hypothesis, it is doubtful whether the writer is justified in ignoring the sup- put cent “History of Japan, position forward in Murdoch's re- that the ruling the by Imperial to element, represented family and the Fujiwaras, ought be other than the referred to a continent of Asia, probably to the South source Seas, via Kyushu. This origin might explain the fondness of the Satsuma youth for the sea, for “it was at one time said that the navy was the exclu- sive preserve of the representatives of the Satsuma clan” (p. 234). Particular ly interesting is the account of the de- velopment of the spy system in the na- tion, so that to-day “what may be euphemistically termed the secret ser- vice of Japan is by a long way the most highly organized in the world No in strument is too humble for it” (p. 74). The story of the plucky fights of the embryo navy of Japan at Miako and Hakodate, when Admiral Enomoto so distinguished himself, is excellent read ing, although the map ought to have shown Miako harbor. The chapters on the Press and Criminal and Civil Law are also valuable. The iter does even justice to the national characteristics. While he allows that merchants find much to complain of in tl ommercial habits of the Japanese trader, not being himself a merchant, he “learned in Ja- pan to trust all with whom he had busi ness dealings, both Japanese and Euro- peaps, and on his final return to Eng- land, he regulated his life on the same principle, with the result that he nd more occasion to regret it ten years’ life in England than he did in thirty years in Japan.” There are, however, gra ! ns in the book. No light vhatever is thrown on the subject of missions, Cath- olic or Protestant, nor the contributions made by Christianity to education In f.ct, the whole subject of education is equally neglected Not one of the top- ics, Education, Schools, Universities, ap- pears in the Index. This defect ought surely to be remedied at once, seeing that the writer is now professor in a university. An odd effect is produced upon an American in reading page 150, where the subject is the rapid spread of the English language in Japan. All the credit for the’ popularity of English is attributed to the influence of Great Bri- tain, “which held, in the thoughts of all Japanese, a position which was immeas- urably above that of all other nations of the West.” This palpable unfairness crops up again in the account given of railway construction, at pages 252-3. While the first two railways were built by English engineers, the third was not the Kioto-Otsu extension of the Kobe-Osaka line, but a railway built up in Hokkaido by Gen. U. S. Crawford be- tween Otarunai and Sapporo, after the American fashion; this the writer fails early
Page 20
pa other publi While hig al r V ington tril expe ted, therefore the ‘ before in 1 hrow His aur 1iTs ince mew hat long i t t he he good » of the clumsy Pre and ace, inept Irish (Jap Irish Universit. of ries the 911, the of lectures \ and entirely le« ture ‘ they en york but engers conveya be lieves on nces th at at onal our in railways new nations that de School of now pub light ire valua temper weecusa man who 118 high practical the gislation, courts n ent, whe not and to Indus urles suf and greater ry a . The Nation part of the expense should be paid by insurance the employers or by mutual to be holds that there is no reason why the should if and formed by them, he companies contribute, it by of its police power, stop the busi- State not neces- sary also why should not, rtue he complies the mutual require, If ision of our Constitution stands the difficulty must be nendment. employer until ecautions which pl urance companies may rov ay remov- » author advocates that cases ied with- the to on their merits, re- its disagree with he technicalities or stem some reforms pro- would mat- greater cedure i vil cases t of the ing allow- the nion on the in- general asces, lent on and answer in It practice f fact is latter to di nt in cases ad under the agreemé pl at In unanimous efendant be the jurors defendant esent system a accident verdict al- the negli- believing, arrived an tance, a may given, of are of iat the at the perhaps contrary to the opinion of the at the contributory negligence advocated the agreement would be the result As to his suggestion that the presid- ing judge doubtless power of the judge adopted by various States make a trial by jury a farce. But, in of the fact that court has power aside if it it improper, a strong expression was while same time was guilty the dis- majority, tl plaintiff of staetem Under by author a should receive greater power, the absurd restrictions of the view the verdict, the other hand, the on that the jury know to set a deem of opinion by the judge, not only on a particular piece of evidence or on the of the but on the as a whole, might vir- credibility witness, merits of the case tually amount to a coercion of the jury. If the the author expresses as to the calibre and intellect of founded; if it true in practice, where let without the help of the judge,” take “twelve random from a crowd” who are the to do,” the h trial by jury, at in civil cases, and let the judge decide the facts as is done in ad- miralty and equity cases. Here the au- lacks the courage of his convic- tions. He is more radical in his pro- posed reform of criminal procedure, for low opinion which our jurie is well is that “what we do we a jury decide is to men at “entirely work obvious expérience§ in asked aboli without they remedy which are is to least thor [ Vol. 95, No. 2455 ~= — as - - 'he advocates the abolition of the time- honored rule that no one is bound to in- criminate himself, and is in favor of the adoption, with some modifications, of the continental system. His argu- ments in support of this proposal seem cogent and convincing. Notes issued im the Francis Among the novels to be this summer autu by & Co or Miss Sonni Douglas rhe Dix translation, Blas¢ Horn,” Gate Mar- lbanez's = Beulah Marie Wells by and riage,”” by H. G Little, Brown & Co. have Court in press T} novel by Anthon Abou Hassan “Buddie at Gr Je tay St. Simon,” a “The Gift of Elliott, and Anna Chapin of Partridgé Francis P Buttes,” by The Wind Be Munger bring out rry the Dawr Double fore day, Page & deals w and whicl H vill next month, th ono! husband W ii er announce a Latini plvribvs xt—“Epitome Thesavri edidit be planned the twelve con work. volumes, is to et auxiliantibu Vollmer.” The four handy those of the which will issued for whom ise of students Thesavr Lingv@ Latir ssible vs volumes This latter work the adily acce the ire not re is, of courss basis of one shortly to ippear Methodist Book Concern of Cincin- promises for Lectures on the Spiritual Mean- by A. H. Tuttle; “The Preacher Modern Mind,” Geer Jackson ; in the Early Church,” John Alfred Faulkner; “The Apostles Creed; An Examination of its History, and an Ex- position of its Contents,” by Henry Wheel- er; “The Christian View of the Old Testa- ment,” Frederick Carl and Historical Setting of the Thomas C. Hall. The nati next month: “Egypt to Canaan, or of Exodus.” th ings and ny 7@ “Crises yy by Eiselen, Early Gospel,” by The Florence Summer University has is- sued its programme for the season of 1912 which begins on August 1 and closes Sep- tember 15 Lectures will given in the mornings, while the afternoons will usually given over to visiting the galleries, mu- seums, churches, et On Saturdays per- sonally conducted excursions, some of them be be lasting two days, will be made to the regions the city The lectures will de- in Italian in the large hall of the fililogico,” 4, Via Tornabuoni be Italian history, Italian art outside be livered ‘Circolo There will Florentine courses in literature, and Ticknor life sentimental! “Neighbourhood” (Dutton), by Edwardes, a chronicle of village the English Midlands The reminiscences of the elders, the tion of the birds, the making of dew ponds— of the pathos equally restrained give is in enumera- such are some features. A personal humor and a sort of quality to a book of very familiar type, and excellent of ita kind in at There is much of Old World romance the plain tale of Philipse Manor Hall
Page 21
Yonkers, N. Y., as told by Edward Haga- man Ha’! in a smal! volume published by and Histor Preserva- tion Society of New York, which is now the the American Scenik legal custodian of the place On June 12 royal charter was granted in th William and possessions of Frederick Philipse (tl sur 1693, a name of Mary, erecting th name may be spelled almost as “into a Lordship or Manor yf borough new wife the titles of Lord and Lady, 1 spectively, and conferred upon the family residence the designation of t Manor Hous At this time his lands reached fr the Croton River to lower Yonkers, and Park to Spuyten Du 1 Creek, a total d tance of twenty-two al t smooth! ind n gayly, for I and second Lords of PI! M 1 for ore than twent i t i N les 4 personag than Co Georeg Wash ngton bore testi to tl " of Mary Philipse, sister of the last-na 1 Lord, al though the depth of his attachment to her is uncertain But evil days am it last for the third Lord of the Manor threw in his lot wit h K la un nf it followed \ I g of both forces becaus ff its situation in the neutral ground, tl " " was broken up, and the Manor Hous vas turn ed into a ty hall, from hich servi it has been rescued to occupy an honored po Sition as one of our histor monuments Dr. Hall is a autious, but by no in Manor's interesting past. The value of his book is enhan dull, chronicler of the a dozen ha‘f-tones, the first being a re production of “A View of Phillipp’s Manor in 1784 - If the present Speaker of. tl House of tepresentatives and late candidate for the nomination of his party for the Presidency has ever made a mistake, it is not recorded in the pages of W. L. Webb's Clark” (Neale) There this “really great orator,” whom no one can hear without be ing “entertained and “Champ sometimes instruct ed,” marches from glory to glory He has not only read the Declaration of Independ ence, the Constitution, and Farewe:] Address, but he has also assimi- lated them. to memory. Washington's Once he even committed them “Now he no longer recalls their made it his phraseology, because he has own, and thinks and speaks it. Occasion ally, just by way of variety, he speaks the language of Patrick Henry, but even that he does unconsciously.” It is decidedly agreeable to learn that theoretically “our Congress is composed of the ablest men in the nation, and practically the House is not far below the though this over the Senate The standard,” al- doubt apparently theoretical leaves one in painful book 1s a serious one, but it would unkind to The Class of 1907 of Bryn Mawr has put address¢ leliv volume the i nwich House, into a small ered at the meeting at Gres October 30, 1911 n emor} of Carola Woerishoffer bodies and together with 1 ylutions of various litorials Ida M. Tarbell contributes an which is really a sketch of Miss hoffer'’s life The book is its concreteness In its pages one newspap ntroduction Woertls charm and alue of the becomes acquainted with the personality L and achievement of a very ur jal spirit It is frankly panegyr but f it was ds ved oO ul g ‘ red « ading or ins i ai s | . ‘ k of the r ] S r g lé 0 WW 7 +) — ’ ¥ It e, War ‘ a Etat I (P I & A ) } ’ Li a st } , | \7 , , 1 1 ; ] a | vo ra I ‘ ind nh mail I a j I 1A 1. Howard B. Maste i H Britis Con l n M i t sketch for read h l o t ng ot Engl l his I ired, apparently with en t the needs of the t ( of the Workers’ Eduvational R { like ost handbooks of th t ur rati ha been carefully t ] late Truman O. Douglass's “Pilgr f low (Pilgrim Press) is a history of ‘ greg tionalism himself is subject, for he ~ 1868. only in a thir Congregational State of lowa; ot the that with has is date “patriarchs,” he Western St in a began his ty years a f missionary and he m« as he has been it position los the interests of Congregat k ' long been secretary of Missionary Society. The b i glorification of the work lacking in scientific spir information are, besid nory. a few well-known of the Home Missionary told in a rather interest fir part particular! ellent picture of the |! tier preachers The au tor ant saying The or G a | as written n,”” but ha methods,” ge F social that he Record with the “a s “avoided which is +} ’ an is not a trains of a City Kenngott, is ar and industrial iM ay ) th arlie ir tl 1 Sin necte at il Hor f while pur thor 1 I 1 tl i 4 ‘ Va an 7 owell Mass and of hav grown out of ways f th and hotograpl . , ; ' % ‘ ‘ i ‘ ta o the F1 h ¢ I ‘ | fro vding and ) VAK inl i ‘ te t) ; iutifull | n ge the G ‘ Oo t} New Testament” (Quarit I id Hobhouse +} ipplen nts his question irk iggested | | codex and of arks in Volume |! ) that » ( le I nt } r ! | r “a J t 1é ; ti iT I , r y f ider 4 lift ou P of t ocla Col i } re B tance of ght Beer Foundat ersity during April
Page 22
64 nteresting, since it gives a clear- ositic than can perhaps be found } of what may be termed a social theor f progress According to Professor Hobl view, progress does not consist ally or even chiefly in the iImprove- the racial stock, but in procuring n the manifold developments of This harmony is chiefly the reflec- t f the growth of the social mind. The iding chapters apply this conception of progress to the development of the state. I th reader who is not interested in losophic question as to the nature of progres will find the beok interesting. I upt on The Value and Limitations é s an acute and well-informed of a programme which is ordli- narily too vaguely conceived, and the chap- te Social Philosophy and Modern Prob- an exceedingly happy summary of nglish social legislation. hensive survey of England's do- tl Caribbean is given by Al- P } \spinall, secretary of the West tte The British West In Litt Brown). Mr. Aspinall touches historical side and discusses govern .dministration, labor, tariffs, laws, and He describes the general aspect ls, their flora, fauna, and nat- ristics, but his chief interest lik the industrial conditions and the rt now being made to de- irkable and varied agri- ources It is obvious from his it the islands are no longer in fact, are In process of regen- ‘ Mr Aspinall writes hopefully rf re, believing that the open- Panama Canal will add mate- r wealth and importance In re ef possibility of federation of West ndies, he says is 1 blinking at the fact that al till mar neular prejudices and al i to be overcome before the ration of the West Indies can be brought t ) if it be practicable. There must gin with, a far better understand- K « the residents in the various col- Greater uniformity would add to tl trength, prosperity, and influence West Indies There is at present a ntable lack of it and this 1 be righted gradually without any po- al upheaval, and the meeting of an olonial conference at Barbadoes pe- consider how uniformity could in directions, immense value ally, to be brought l prove about various of ] book te illustrated, and has a map socialistic attempts by “Gracchus” Babeuf of 1796. The privations, arrests, his deep-laid plot to over- plutocracy of the trial and death in English by Episode of the the earliest ommubnleth by or of lize ideals revolu in of made ari the apring story Babeuf early and of undemocratic nia rect ind of his tragk told Laat etingly I Relfort Bax ("The French Revol Small, Maynard & Co.) the Peasant Revolt the time of Luther, Mr. Bax as an interpreter for English established throwing light by original of his Here he relies mainly on the works of Advielle, Buo- ition volumes on mn teer at any rather of fa holar write well new readers ta already thar La researches own narroti, and Fleury, and on some of the newspapers of the period; the eleven vol- umes of pamphlets and papers in the 455 [Vol. 95, No. 2 British Museum relating to the Ba beuf conspiracy, which might have afford- ed him, an Englishman, an excellent oppor- tunity to add something really original to the history of this attempt at a socialistic revolution, he wholly ignores or neglects Students of Socialism and the French Revo- however, h's transla- of full extracts from Babeuf’s pro- grammes of reform, and from his corre- spondence with his friends. Mr. Bax’s sym- of on the sid this martyr of communism, but his con- think just: “Of the cour- lution will welcome, tion pathy, is strongly ol cluding course, judgment we absolute sincerity, earnestness, and age of the protagonist of the Equals there can be no sort of doubt. Of his grasp of the situation and of his intellectual ca- pacity as the leader ot a party of wide reaching revolutionary aims; as much can- not be said.” At the instance of friends, Mrs. Russell Barrington has published her diaries and flying trip “Through Greece On the whole regret her compliance. Her party in a lunar month sketches of and Dalmatia” a (Macmillan) one must did Greec« Under have if the a @ would The by sion and Dalmatia conditions, genius could And, indeed, Symonds and value present work ridiculed only these anything worth saying liberal excerpts from were eliminated, most the that Jackson disappear from author's foible is once by minor analogy. The Parthenon for example, reminds her, or she reminds it the is not quite clear—that she was the friend of Watts and Leighton. In short, a background of the best British society advancing to the picture hardly surprising that this fails to tone foreground a case insists It background that ever on plane is with a and mediswval There no English Baedeker on the Russian Empire. Ruth Kedzie Wood has at- tempted to supply the want in “The Tour- ist’s Russia” (Dodd, Mead). If the reader will consent overlook an occasional rhapsody on Nature and her works, as well certain other naive garding Russian character and social hab- its, he will find this a useful little manual St. Petersburg is treated scantily, but Mos- the Volga are very satisfactorily is by turns Greek is to as generalizations re- cow and done. “A Resident’s Wife in Nigeria” (Dutton), by Constance Larymore, has attained, as it amply deserved, a second edition. It is a model of good taste, good temper, and sound sense. Mrs India, and did some Larymore spent four years in camping in Kashmir before going to Nigeria, she is thus equipped, as few travellers to give practical advice to those about to set out and are, for distant lands. Nowhere else can be found more valuable hints for the com- fort of man and beast in the tropics. “The Story of Korea” (Scribner), by Joseph H. Longford, formerly a British Coneul at Nagasaki, presents the main in- cidents in the history of that distracted country tn a readable form that will com- mend the volume as a desirable addition te the reference shelf of every public library. Professor Longford’s knowledge of Japan- ese adds to the reader's confidence in his understanding of the subject and use of ma- terials, though it does not appear from the bibliography of works consulted that he has Ruskin of illustrating a major impres- | Japanese sources for anything but recent governniental acts. The chief authoritivs for his outline of Korcan his- the well-known works of Dallet, Ross, and Hulbert, which he has condensel into a fairly clear narrative without imposing too many uncouth names upon the Western reader. He is severe upon the American naval expedition which tried in 1871 to terminate the l“orean policy of isolation by forcing its purblind court to answer for the destruction of an Amer- ican ship and the murder of all her crew. The cttempi should have been made, if at all, in codéperation with other Western Pow- ers, and some convenient harbor occupied urtil the Koreans understood the meaning their demands; but such concerted ac- tion was impossible in the year of the Paris Commune and the Alabama Claims Commis- sion. In the diricult matter of Japan’s réle in Korea and the resulting annexation the author maintains an attitude of entire fair- ness. He that Koreans suffered from repeated acts of spoliation by Japan- ese officials as well as adventurers, but as the stronger redeemed their initial errors of a similar kind in the early mili- tary occupatio2 of Formosa, he believes that a similar success will be achieved present- ly in Korea, “followed by the heart-whole conciliation of the people.” The Rev. Dr. Thomas Hume, who died at Chapel Hill, N. C., on Monday, aged seven- ty-six, had long been identified with South- ern institutions of learning, among them Roanoke Female College and the University of North Carolina. He was also the author of English writers employed tory ar. Courant, of concedes race several treatises on Science A Cyclopedia of American Medical Biog- raphy: Comprising the Lives of Emi- nent Deceased Physicians and Sur- geons from 1610 to 1910. By Howard A. Kelly, M.D. Illustrated with por- traits. 2 vols. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co. $10 net. Several years ago, while writing the |life of a medical worthy, Dr. Kelly |found himself hampered by the inade- |quacy of the existing books of biogra- phy of the medical men of this coun- itry. This defect he undertook to cor- rect, and with the aid of a large body ‘of collaborators, apparently more than itwo hundred in number, has meas- ‘urably succeeded. The outcome fills two rather large but handsome volumes, and ;contains incidentally some forty por- ‘traits. The term “eminent physicians and surgeons” is-taken liberally enough ‘to open the door for Agassiz, Asa Gray, |William James, and some others whose ‘connection with medicine wag not very \close. There are very interesting but | Somewhat uneven prefatory sketches of \the development of certain but by no means all medical specialties in this country. The biographies are valuabie, although isometimes unduly extended. Even a ‘casual reader will not fail to be im-
Page 23
July 18, 1912] The Nation pressed by the sturdy independence and | resourcefulness of the American practi- tioners, particularly of those of earlier times when training in theory and prac- tice was much less developed and gen- eral than now. There certainly were giants in those days, and a standard was set up which the present generation, with all its opportunities, will find it hard to maintain. It is almost ungracious to speak ill of a book that brings so much welcome ma- terial, but the hope that a new edition will soon be called for leads us to make the following comments. One cannot read far without perceiving that there is much in these biogra- phies and that the pruning knife might be used to advantage. It is, of course, most difficult to fix upon a rule which shall determine admission to a work of this kind, and if Dr. Kelly had some good standard in mind, as his preface seems to indicate, his contributors have had no clear understanding of it, either as to quantity or quality In the matter of omissions we have checked off the book against unevenness logues of a certain college and from some other sources that happened to be at hand. Of names at least as eminent as many of those recorded by Dr. Kelly, failed to find: John Bacon, J. P. Bancroft, Henry J. Bigelow, Amos Bin- ney, H. I. Bowditch, S. E. Chaillé, Sam- uel Clossy, Dickson (of the Jefferson Medical College), R. M. Hodges, Charles Harrington, the younger Holyoke, J. B. S. Jackson, Edward Jarvis, J. S. Lom- bard, George Parkman, A. M. Shew, N. B. Shurtleff, D. H. Storer, G. G. Tarbell, Robert Thaxter, Samuel Webber, J. W. Webster, Rufus Wyman, not to mention a score of others. Some of these were very distinguished persons, and the ab- sence of their names is remarkable, par- ticularly because many of them are inci- dentally mentioned in other biographies or in the historical introduction as im- portant in the development of medicine in the United States. Of the others it may be said that they are at least as much entitled to a record as the young man on page 101, whose sole claim on posterity seems to be that he was of much promise and died at thirty, as was the custom of his family. As to errors and misprints, it may be noted that Agassiz lectured on anatomy in Charles- ton (as recorded on p. 7), not Charles- town (p. xxi); that the noted teacher of the blind was Samuel G. and finally, that O. W. Holmes was born at Cambridge (not Boston), and the name of his father was Abiel (not Abial). we Howe: Science books in the list of Longmans Green, & Co. include: “Researches in Color Vision, and the Trichromatic Theory,” by Sir William De W. Abney Preventable Cancer A Statistical Research.” by Rollo Russell, and “Soil Conditions and Plant Growth,” by E. J. Russell a short, list of names gathered from the cata: | The account by Geo. Shiras, 3d, of his trip to Alaska last summer, mainly “to Stalk, study, and photograph” the giant moose, will be a revelation to most readers of the National Geographic Magazine for May. Few will have realized that any part of the Arctic territory could have been so rich in big game, sheep, and birds as the Kenai Peninsula. The 59 reproductions of photographs give a vivid impression not only of the animal and bird life, but also of the beautiful scenery The salmon America’s most valuable fish, is described with numerous illustrations, by H. M. Smith He dwelis particularly upon the five distinct species on the Pacific Coast, directing at tention to the remarkable fact that “every individual of every species dies shortly af ter spawning.” The illustrated description of the California seed-farms by A. J. Wells will be another revelation Not ma t will have known that “seed-growing has be ‘ an established branch of California horti culture and seeds now go in car lots even to France and to Holland.” There is a field of lettuce two miles long, and there are tracts of sweet peas from 100 to | 600 acres in extent. A large picture of th Matterhorn is given as a supplement to the richly illustrated number Morocco and its future is the subject of an instructive article by A. G. Ogilvie in the Geographical Journal for June. He con fidently maintains that the agricultural pos sibilities of the country are very great and that “the forests offer immense possibilities of development Further, nearly all irts of Morocco which are unsuited for agriculture or forestry can be utilived for stock rearing; fisheries, too, will afford a good return for well-directed encourage ment, and there is the possibility of the ex istence of mineral wealth.” Among the greatest needs of the place are peaceful and efficient and strategi« government and by Carruthers gives an account of sure communica tions roads railways D explorations in northwestern Mongolia; Sir C. R. Mark ham reviews the results of Antarctic work during the past twenty years, and R. N Hall describes some very remarkab!° Bush man paintings in caves in soutl Rho desia Drama and Musie Forthcoming books in the list of Ginn & Co. include “The Dramatic Method of Teaching,” by Harriet Finlay-Johnson Quaint Old Stories to Read and Act,” by Marion Florence Lansing George Calderon publishes translation humor or pathos, and their effective play of satire, but they are invertebrate and epi- sodical in form, deal with common types and are often conventional when the are not extravagant in action Mr. Calderor who, with all his enthusiasm, seems to haves an uneasy consciousness of the inherent weaknesses of the plays, hints that their true significance is to be sought, not so much in the fate of the puppets presented as in the effect upon them of the external conditions of life to which they ar sut t and before which they are hel; es They are to be regarded less as individuals tha is samples of the mass In this tl is nothing new Interrelationship of cir imstance and character Is t root of lrama, and all personages may be take i symbolical of class rhe listingtis! traits of ost of the characters in the tw p ‘ are selfish individualism and s and pessimistic fatalism nd the i not attractive In the play called “The Seagull Tehek hoff himself shows the result of external fluence, although he is no mere copyist. It 8 a queer mixture of modern realisr bolism, romanticism, and conventional melo lrama Th? unhappy, undisciplined dea istic Trepoff is sketched with some compre hension Trigorin, the novelist, is a ca tal study of the capable ethodical, adre creator of “best sellers with his finger ever upon the popular puls« Arcadina is an ad mirably realistic embodiment of the selfish ness, the shallowness ind the vanity of one type of actress There are undeniable truth and pathos in tl fate of the romantk misguided, and ultimately half-crazed Nina The representation of certain phases of Russian society carrie 1 conviction of phe tographic verity, but the actors In it a trivial and sordid, and the dramat and human interest rare As for the symbol ism beneath it all, it too vague to be important In “The Cherry Orchard” thers is the same facile and doubtles in the main, truthful, portrayal of middle-class Russian society The student Trophimoff who is presun ably the spokes in of Tcehek hoff’s own philosophy, complains that the ‘great majority of his countrymen are ‘‘g1 tupid, and profoundly unhappy.” He says that the one thing needful is work, coupled with a disposition to help tl few who ar seeking for the truth. The majority of th lucated classes, he adds isk for nothing and 4d nothing They only talk about ind inderstand little r nothing abou irt It is sufficient, 1 hay t that the characters accord with the d tion In the theatre they would be ne r entertaining nor profitable, even if they w wholly redible But the old servitor with introduction and notes, of “The Sea- Firs, who has outlived his own generati: gull” and “The Cherry Orchard” (Mitchell ®"4 bas nothing in common with the new Kennerley) as representative of the earlier * Teally striking creation. Unfortunately and latest work of the Ruse dramatist ©" all character does not make a drama Tchekhoff, in whom he discerns great and The plays have a certain val " original genius. It is possible, of course onistic Russian sketches by a nat are that the original works possess literary and but are in no sense mastery other merits which are but 4d reflected in the English versio: but ertalr lowing the exampl f in their present shape they d t suggest rs—notably Italians any great dramati nstinct or fertilit ree, or a dozen failures do not 4 yu invention Clever the ! il £g Frederick 8. Convers a 8 » be various wa esp ally t listinct t work on another opera, t librett ness of characteriz Y t it Ines ich has been pre led Per M in ine letall the q + te ) P K The tenta R
Page 24
Ltion The N: } | y la era I he \ he ¥ | rks \ grulit i id Art ’ \ ROPOMORPHI STHETICS } 5 i Other Studies I ogical A é By Ver- and ( Ans r-Thomson. ine Co . t | t ‘ ho know Vernon Lee” only a it larg 4 ghly techni- ' i ime may is repellent as ivy ! As a matter of fact, it is ! I en Vit 1 rabbedness ex- ( gz t demands of its difficult mat- ' nevertheless a valuable book, , nging to sharp focus the main is- . ' and solutions of Kdern psycholog- psthe l book grow ( of an’ essay, . 8: tv an v published by the ; t I ! irs a It was the n psychology was over-driv- ul of ) hypotheses. l ing im ad seemed to ) t 1 ‘ i motor re ‘ : ! | ntra iu more accu t bst the emo Rernhard Berens« ad just a l ' ti lue of t I nunicate 4 itior And in his i l pa s he insisted that ulue purely mental, t ve! ac ! I reactior n | lrea n carried a r it i ( iypothesis Lil 1 an ) rsthet ‘ , t fiv by the n ! I | ition 7 ta Reau | ! a, had of Fin | | i! n Vy any ecting a é t nduing ) t n our , , n » in 1897 : ' ) ' ric ypot ia of : f thi I ttingly in ex- } mpan Thes vere, however, ! the exception of lame psychol unversed in the newer literature, : Thetr say arose quite independently ! real origin was the discovery of an traordinary ntrospective gift in C to able She w
[Vol. 95, No. 2455 and describe whole slight motor accompaniments of her en of These, observ ee ovment art. unconsciously
amplifying the hint of Karl Groos, she located chiefiy in the organs of vision and spiration, and interpreted ; mimetic of the ontemplated object ‘Vernon Lee” <« ontributed the psy¢ holog al ymmentary her collaborator's to observations, and, as true devotee ol a regarded th: of the le Lange-James theory, motor phenomena esthetic es as sen Such participation in the imag ned lif of an object of course ranged he authors as unconscious d iples of Lipps’s anthropomorphic wsthe procee ded howeve r, to renoun tl I various articles, insisting that all m« tor accompaniments of an impres ion of beauty either negligible or actual de our are ‘uctive, the wsthetic imputation of own iife to an enjoyed object being purely mental Through defence, interpretation, and illustration of the original essay, “Beau book h the betrays ty and Ugliness,” present as grown, and it in occasional 1 dundancies its episodic origins. Still, by way of excerpt and discussion it contains full the of Groos and Lipps, a very exposition of esthetics and presents a rea- sonable programme for the scientific in- vestigation of ive phe The identif ing Anstruther-Thomson’s motor type of the most e&vVvas of these nomena initial error tify- P OI esthesis with that human race is handsomely avowed. Likewise, the in felicity of declaring that such motions vyhen present are necessarily mimeti Such reservations bring the authors ery close to the purely mental ELinfuh- ng of Lipps. And, in fact, what sepat ites them is merely the conviction on “Vernon Lee’ part that these moto accompaniments of impressions of bea tudy liere, ty are inherently worthy of ve feel, nobody will gainsay her. Pro fessor Lipps’s denial of all ilue to the yuter symptoms of inner @st! esis is ol! the face of it highly arbitra Esthetic empathy is “Vernon |! eo valent for Einf ng. Botl ~ irly perceives are open to t serious objection of suggesting an a i] ran é ot ou life Oo an r opiect essor Lipps knows that s nhatrans fe ; unthinkable and purely illuso but he constant! rites, in fairly mys to if there were a real eman on I the observer ft obi Tt hort, any term which suggests that nh urselves into any external thing objectionable. The proper statement s that we think it into ourselves i imilate it in terms of our experience irt‘culate it imaginatively with appro- An quite priate memory impressions exact really simple to find, but esthetic assimilation perhaps fairly su term for a process the &s not easy phrase £ gests the facts, and has no misleading connotation. This book closes with a long « hapter
Page 25
July 18, 1912] of what may be called field notes—“Ver. | non Lee’s” memoranda before famous pictures and statues, chiefly at Florence. She has the habit of mentally repeating strains of music, and a considerable and rather inconclusive part of the notes is devotea to the compatibility of these musical memories with impressions of graphic and plastic art. The notes are valuable because they show the great variety and complete relativity of gwsthetic experience in a highly trained person. It appears that, short of that absorption in the contemplated object which Schopenhauer regarded as the ideal, there are many grades of esthesis. It does not seem hopeless to believe that an analysis of such notes, aided by care- fully framed questionnaires, might give us a real classification of esthetic states as more or less typical and complete. “Vernon Lee” is actively engaged alcng these lines. That she may carry inte these severer studies the grace and lucidity of her literary criticism and dialogues is the hope of her admirers. Meanwhile, may say that the an thropomorphic esthetics have at least brought us down to the real problem, and probably contain, if in a manner as yet not quite clear, the truth of the mat- ter. It is surely a gain to set esthetics firmly in the psychologic field—to real- ize that is not an attribute of things, but an expression of a complex individual experience concentrated upon we beauty a selective and receptive act. Florentine contemporary of the Madon precisely the reflect womanhood of of M (imported nas Thag painters the the city, is central ‘Madonne Fior- The book readiness with the Ferrigai'’s by Stechert) the me entine” the is a fair example of which modern cultivate] Italians turn their themes gut at best, the certain hands to belle-lettristi nor Ferrigni’s plea is merely spe- cious Unquestionably, correlation asserts exists in artists, for in- Floren- their ap- stance but in general tine typical proach is kept lccal book handsomely n Fra Filippo are remarkable for There portraiture ideal are merely ads photographic Madonnas is Divine seldom The where quality any to mother and the an racial To 18 in reaim qualities suspended us ingenious. It rather small folio reproduc tions, seems in a with many good which are apparently its raison d’étre. Iinance LIQUIDATION IN THE KET. STOCK MAR- The stock market was interesting last week mainly on account of the liquida- tion There sensational break in prices, and at times which took place was no there were periods of real strength. But the movement as a whole was different from that ef the fortnight be- cause of heavy selling. This movement before, coincident with the efforts of cer- banks to build their item, which owing to the continued out- flow of cash could be strengthened only was tain up reserve through a drastic curtailment of loans. In spite of the various explanations to account for the selling, it may be said that the liquidation was natural under the circumstances and could not well be avoided. The market, fairly well; what nical position strengthened however, stood the test is known as the tech- was unquestionably it. Nothing occurred to make real holders of stocks sell out, and since the public was not speculating to any great extent, to the decline of the borne chiefly by professional But the firmness in money rates, as reflected by the higher price charged for call loans and time accommodation, showed that the inquiry was broadening and that the banks were no longer inclined to tie up large sums in term loans or in fixed forms of investment, as they did a by the losses incident week were operators, year ago, when business was less ac- tive and merchants were borrowing meagre amounts. The situation, there- fore, has changed to the extent that dis- counts are hardening here just as they are hardening abroad, where the mar- kets are still fearful that the New York banks may make heavy demands upon Europe's gold supply. The chief problem everywhere, how ever, is how to provide for the immens« which must securities volume of new soon be marketed. Within the last fe days there has been further selling of British consols at London by the banks forced order to of these tal which were to dispose in the ins ments due on the underwritings of bonds securities pay which the syndicates have not been able to sell. trouble This problem has given serious to the banks looks now as if there would be a deal of forced liquidation before the a count is adjusted and the undigested s« London und = it great curities are lodged permanently with vestors. The serious liquidation at Paris has arisen partly from the same ca For not a few months the great Frenc! investment banks have been heavily committed to various bond operations which have not worked out satisfa torily. Ordinarily it has been Ss for se institutions to make a market for of the cared to bring out. But « the virtually any bonds onditions changed in France, as they have in most other countries where the new secu! issues have been excessive. In German) the situation has been slightly different as the market there has had an ad al upset through the abuses which have resulted from the reckless speculation of last year. This trouble became so acute as to make it necessary for the Reichsbank to adopt drastic meas jut in Germany, as in the other great markets, are large loans which must be provided for in the near future. Und these conditions, with all the foreie markets under strain from largely, Same Causes, it is natural that Europ financiers should over the disclosures of the p return of July 6 Europe's interest in the question ha mainly to do with the possibility getting gold from abroad It is re ognized that with our international! trade balance as favorable as it is, with Germany _ still our debt through temporary loans obtained in this heavily in ' market, and with large outstanding ba ances to the credit of our banks at other European centres, it New York to should would be easy for attract gold from abroad money rates advance sharply here It is ht, ditions h true that and that no such movement is in sig money market con re do not suggest a violent rise in rates in the near future But London financiers hav been mir for some time of the extraordinar cumstances which govern the situatior his yea It is recognized, also, on other side, that the real test will cor vhen he ra ivs begir to Or A ! i ind when the eat mas qadustrial eurities appea on ti ma t Mie} } an] 1 Vy , nai th van i l ally « d for when ‘ ‘ yperation . to f il ] } et tha ‘ period Weste al I Faster ‘ ’ ' ’ } ts a } r? i arke ’ t { f 3 0 t up pectatio part irs the tota tion of a " ould pr fie ie I ) ist ea s i i I i t shipme fa « ‘ j ’ East eS ntres BOOKS OF TH KEK } A lL, | Re | r Mr I , \\ | H 4 '? g ' (; I { ] I i | H ‘ ! MI , } H [ } ; $1 net ah ‘ ‘ iT \ H i 1S ] Pay | ~ , 7 T ‘ p
Page 26
The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2455 Italiane, a cura di | Lowery, Woodbury. A Descriptive List of | Sargent, Walter. Fine and Industrial Arts secondo. Bari Maps of the S»anish Possessions in the in Elementary Schools. Boston: Ginn. 75 s 1502-1820. Washington: Library cents $1 of Congress. Selden, G. C. Psychology of the Stock Mar- Lyford, J.©. History of the Town of Can- ket. Ticker Pub. Co. ons of the King: terbury, New Hampshire, 1727-1912. 2 vols. Shakespeare's Henry IV, Part II; Richard Dowell Press Concord, N. H.: The Rumford Press. Ill (Tudor Edition). Macmillan. 35 vilabus of Englis Mackay, Helen. The Cobweb Cloak. Duffield® cents net, each. ~ Sanborn & Co $1.25 net Smith, E. F., and others. The Structure and alism. 1791-1797. Mathews, A. H. Life and Times of Rodrigo Development of Crown Gall: A Plant jorgia, Pope Alexander VI. Brentano. $4 Cancer. Washington: Government Ptg. f Beauty. (Agnes net Office. t Moore, J. A. The Sentimental Song Book. Step, Edward. By Sea-Shore, Wood, and in Women and Platt & Peck. 50 cents net Moorland. T. Whittaker. 75 net Munro, J. I A Research into the Origin Symons, Beryl. The Roses of Crein. D. Philology, ed- of the Third Personal Pronoun. Frowde. Appleton. $1.30 net. assica] In- Nichols, E. L., and Merritt, E. Studies in| Tilney, Robert. My Life in the Army uu escence Carnegi« Institution of Philadelphia: Ferris & Leach. $1. “ Washington University of Pennsylvania. Publications of in. Vincent The Good Girl. Dut- the Babylonian Section, Vol. II, No. 1, $1.35 net Business Documents of Murashu Sons of ) orges. L’Art d’inventer les Person- Nippur; No. 2, Temple Archives from Nip- Dramas ze Paris: Figuiére et Cie pur. By Albert T. Clay. alifornia Port: H. Miss Billy’s Decision. Bos-, Vineberg, Solomon. Provincial and Local f ‘ & Co. $1.25 net. Taxation in Canada. Longmans. ; it 1, M. A. Poetic Justice in the Drama. | Watson, H. B. M. The Tomboy and Others Notre Dame, Ind University Press Lane $1 net. Raeder, A L’Arbitrage International Chez Willoughby, L. A. Dante Gabriel Rossetti Hellenes Tome 1, Publications de and German Literature: A Lecture. l'Institut Nobel Norvégien. Putnam. Frowde Rodway, James Guiana British, Dutch, \u-Yue Tsu. The Spirit of Chinese Philan- ind French Scribner thropy. Longmans. W. ” . READY THIS EEK Columbia University Studies in ° ’ History, Economics, and Salisbury, Barrows, and Tower's Sion tne ELEMENTS OF GEOGRAPHY Vol. XLIX, No. 1. British Radical. ROLLIN D. SALISBURY, Professor; HARLAN HARLAND BARROWS, As- ae See By oer Sea rATTER SHE ' TOWR hates >rofessor » Sometime Fellow in His- Professor. and WALTER SHELDON TOWER, Assistant Professor, tory, Columbia University. I'niversity of Chicago ix+616 pp. 12mo. $1.50 net Svo. Paper covers. $2.00. : . nae ye Vel. XLIX, No. 2. A Comparative essor Salisbury's text-books in physiograph) are recognized as the las Study of the Law of Corpora- this fleld for schools and colleges. This new course in geography treats tions, with Particular Reference hvysiographic processes and features, but develops at greater length the to the Protection of Creditors ons of earth. air, and water to life and especially to human affairs. The au- and Shareholders. ny A. OU believe that the chief object in geography teaching should be preparation Kuhn, Ph.D., LLB. 7 renship. They have accordingly emphasized certain points that are now, . . : “ -. ree $1.5 are soon likely to be, of national importance, as for example the need for = w Satay Roe on Negro at . The | trations are a wits ork in New Yo ‘ity. onserving the natural resources of the country The illustrations are a vital tox Tieenemnte prearuss. iy Geena part of the book. | Edmund Haynes, Ph.D., Some- i Fell f the B HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY 2°cut8&5 |} ciat Research, New York School of Philanthropy; Professor of So- cial Science in Fisk University. 8vo. Paper covers. $1.25. Cloth, $1.75. Vol. L, No. 1. The Spirit of Chinese TheGENETIC PHILOSOPHY In the Amazon Jungle Philanthropy. A Study in Mutual ; Aid. By Yu-Yue Tsu, Ph.D. OF EDUCATION ADVENTURES IN A REMOTE PART OP | Svo. Paper covers. $1.00 THE UPPER AMAZON RIVER, IN- 5 ‘ G. EB. PARTRIDGE, Ph.D. CLUDING A SOJOURN AMONG Vol. LII, No. 1. Provincial and oe ; : THE CANNIBAL INDIANS. Local Taxation in Canada, By The Nervous Life.” ane Solomon Vineberg, Ph.D., Some- ine of Individual Study By ALGOT LANGE time Garth Fellow in Economics, WITH AN INTRODUCTION BY With an Introduction by FREDERICK Columbia University. STANLEY HALL, PH.D. LLD S. DELLENBAUGH. Octavo. With 86 Svo. Paper covers. $1.50. Cloth, $2.00. illustrations from Original Photo- graphs by the Author. $2.50 net. Longmans, Green, & Co. A description more wonderful than the work of Paul du Challlu, and holds the reader as intensely as the stirring narra $1.50 net; postpaid $1 63) importance of this book—the comprehensive and orderly tive of Stanley's adventures in Africa.” éaumé of the educational phil sen Franctaco Chronicle On the Art f the The osophy of Pres. G. Stanley Hall j “A remarkable 0 atre more narrative of strange he at onee recognized The experiences and perilous adventure would By EDWARD GORDON CRAIG ' ea ’ be hard to find among the works of r " summariz the dominant Bg «4-2 .. 8 e See, boards, with illustrations, $2.00; by mail, $2.14 ind progressive educational move The most important book about the theatre ent, and the ideas it assembles Notable among works of exploration published in years. onatitute the most important con- and discovery.’ The Outlook Charles H. Serge! & Co., Chicago ribution of all time to education omparable for study and refer G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS r a normal achool text or NEW YORK LONDON | raries As a Brilliant Man Seca Us | America of To-morrow STURGIS & WALTON CO, | 1° WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300) By ABBE FELIX KLEIN 91-82 East 27th Street, New York FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, WRITE At All Bookstores. $1.75 net. DODD, MEAD & COMPANY _s |: A. C. MeCLURG & Co., Publishers, Chicago FOURTH AVE. & SOTH STRERT, NEW YORK |