The Nation 1912-07-04: Vol 95 Iss 2453

Page 1

; os, > ° 7 JUL =-5 1912 e qty ~) Yury, or wc’ o%, *o% % VOL. XCV—NO. 2453 THURSDAY, JULY 4, 1912 kee. U8 PRICE TEN CENTS VITAL BOOKS TIMELY TOPICS THE SUPREME COURT AND THE THE TARIFF IN OUR TIMES CONSTITUTION By IDA M. TARBELL By CHARLES A. BEARD I} History of the Standard Oil Com- " ; , ar Author of “American Government and Politics pan ON A concise consideration of the charges made ir 7 the strenuous fighting during fifty gard to the usurpation by the Supreme Court of ‘ tariff making; a narrative of big interests powers not granted in the Constitution i I striai movements Cloth, 31.00 net; postpaid, 81.10. GOVERNMENT BY ALL THE PEOPLE Cloth, 81.50 net; postpaid, 81.63 THE NEW DEMOCRACY The Initiative, the Referendum, the Recall as By WALTER E. WEY L, Ph.D. THIRD EDITION Instruments of Democracy Pr und Economic Tendencies in the United States By DELOS F. WILCOX, Ph.D. e best and most comprehensive survey of the gen Author of “The American City,” etc. era al and political status and prospects that has , wai . j : , been published of late years he P bury > A timely exposition of the arguments in favor of ¥ nea athe sored oy che ch A ro ye be the initiative, the referendum, and the rec all as practi read widely and will exercise a large influence.”—The cal and effective instruments for establishing popular Evening Mail self-government, with a careful consideration of the A masterly, scathing, and absolutely fearless arraign- failure of the old system of checks and balances. ment of things that ought not to be in a republic, and of ‘ tendencies that no democracy ought to tolerate,”—Boston Cloth, 81.50 net; postpaid, $1.63. Herald Cloth, 82.00 net; pepe, 82.12. ASolution of the Trust Problem in the United States By C_R. VAN HISE His Life and Work President University of Wisconsin, Madison, Wis By HERBERT CROLY rae An indispensable work for all taking part in the iuthor of “The Promise of American Life. Presidential Campaign, as the most important problem The complete story of Mark Hanna’s life, and his confronting the people is the control of the trusts extraordinary career as an archetype of the business | Condenses all recent information relating to the trust man in politics situation. Cloth, $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.24 Illustrated. Cloth, gilt top, 82.50 net; postpaid, 82.70. THE WISCONSIN IDEA SOCIALISM AS IT IS By CHARLES McCARTHY By W. ENGLISH WALLING “A great feat, which deserves the careful study of ‘ : t a every true reformer.’—Chicago Record-Herald A Survey of the World Wide Revolutionary Movement Explains State regulations of railroads, public utili- Not mere theories, but the actual material of | ties, the referendum, the recall, primaries, etc., as identi- present-day politics.".—New York Globe. | fled with the famous “Wisconsin” development Cloth, $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.62. Cloth, 82.00 net; postpaid, 82.13. IMPORTANT SOCIOLOGICAL WORKS ‘THE SEXUAL LIFE OF THE CHILD By Dr. ALBERT MOLL. Translated by Dr. Epen Pavt. Introduction by Prof. Edward L. Thorndike, Columbia University, N. Y. C. Facts for earnest men and women, parents and teachers, concerning the growth and the moral and spiritual welfare of children, through the gradual development of the sexual life with its attendant dangers. Cloth, 81.75 net; postpaid, 81.489. ADDAMS A NEW CONSCIENCE AND AN ANCIENT EVIL By JANE ADDAMS FOURTH EDITION “Miss Addams’s volume is painful reading, but we heartily wish that it might be read and pondered by every man and woman who to-day, in smug complacency, treat wit ndifference and contempt the great struggle for social purity.”"—The Nation Cloth, $1.00 net; postpaid, 81.10 mictet THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “i!

Page 2

The Nation JOUR) a TAL. 1865 NDELU IN rOrtl New y ‘ ‘ i Ir } ! If As tn ‘ ' uv Canad 5 ‘ i ¢ h i f i t7ION ' ; CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER I \‘\ : l } ‘ Al ES ' Cor ntio 4 | by Rider | ( i ind Publ } i ‘ x ‘ - if ar aT hy htou i England 7 Spr ‘ AR ES RR nt French Novel 7 New r Bibliophil 9 ( ri I i I Tr Presid tial 7 4 I? Kad ile and Ro« 5 10 George Borrow 10 Tt | ith of Baron Takasal 10 Religt Propriety 11 LITERATUR! \ \ i (il il ll Wid 12 ! | t Stor 12 ) | ’ \d ni r 13 ro of I 13 I ! \ lear Robert I Le Viar : ! lier 13 I ition of Burma 14 i ! if ortation 14 ‘ War for a D 15 Fontalt 15 16 18 DRAMA ' ee 19 a 20 ART A ttl FI Art india and 20 FINA 1 j and ti i | Market 21 Bn ad ; Wie Ww 22 * * * Coples of The Nation may be procured tn / Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra;: io Leadon of BF. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Charing Cross Square The N ation [Vol. 95. No. 2453 Eadunstions Educational The Western Theological Semisary N. Seo Pittsberah. Pa Founded by the tier il Assembly, 1825 4 nplet modern theological curricul with tive rses uling to the degree f B.D ‘ira t courses of the Unlversity of Pittsburgh legrees of A. M. and Ph.D are ope | [™ jualifie!d students the Seminar Exceptional library facilities 4.000 ¥ imes \ ‘ 1 itor equipped wit! la et ww ern im \ neluding dining om. gymnasium and now re ly ’ Sept 17 1912 Por mtion Pres. James A. Kels Ph.D ‘DD_ {= URSULINE ACADEMY, A HOME- Sehoo! for Girls, delightfully and heaithfulls situated on the outskirts of Middletown, New York accepts young ladies an children during the summer months, and carefully provides for their protection and comfort Students, who wish t neel College or High School conditions, will find Summer Courses of Study provided Terms on ap ACADEMY, New York THE URSULINE Middletown plication PENNSYLVANIA, Bryn Mawr The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Prepares for Bryn Mawr and other colleges. Cer tite ate privileges Number of puplils limited. Spe- celal schedule arranged for each Percentage of pupils who have entered Bryn Mawr College un mally large. Gymnastics. outdoor sports. 14tb year opens Oct. 3. 1912 is New Jersey, Morristown MORRISTOWN SCHOOL COLLEGE PREPARATORY BOARDING SCHOOL FOR BOYS. Small classes Individual attention Partial self government Large new gymnasium ALL outdoor sports under expert st pe rvision Es pecially healthful location 30 mil from New York Lower School for Boys of 10 A i4 IN FRANCE, Near Paris family Only Universities of advantages. Ad- of Chicago. A YEAR OF STUDY School for Americans of both sexes Individual training In a French French spoken Credit given by Chicago and Illinois. Exceptional! dress PROF. WILLIAMSON, University [ leges PREPARATORY Prepares for leading col- FOERING, B.S8.. Principal. ETHLEHEM Bethlehem, Catalogue, Pa H. N. Fine and Industrial Arts in Elementary Schools By WALTER SARGENT Professor of Education tn Fine and [nodustil.l Arts, The University of Chicago, The School of Education Just Published 75 cents. book gives a f the place the various phases fine and in arts should occupy in elementary This which dustrial achools It discusses the of drawing, design, survey of educational significance and constructive ac tivities; the practical values of subjects and their relation to industrial education: and the general nature of the work suitable for successive periods of the school course. Suggestions for specific problems and a dis cussion of the standards of attainment which may reasonably be expected at each stege of the work are included The various subjects are adequately illus trated with drawings, and with photographic reproductions of the work of children COMPANY BOSTON GINN AND 29 BEACON fTREET, HOW WE THINK By JOHN DEWEY Professor of Philosophy, Columbla University A practical chology to the problems of education. Cloth. 230 pages. $1.00. D.C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago READ MONTGOMERY'S NEW BOOK CHRONICLES OF AVONLEA By the author of “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES,” ETC. Of which over 300,000 covies have been sold Net 81.25. socatvaid 81.40 SCHOOL, | | application of modern psy- | | cles | | | SCHOOL OF NURSING The Trustees of the Peter Bent Brigham Hospl- tal in Boston, Massachusetts, offer a three years’ urse of instruction in the science and art of nursing The hospital will be opened in the Fall f 1912 The school willl admit a class for pre liminary instruction in September. For admission to this course and for informa tion apply immediately to Miss Carrie M fall, Superintendent of Nurses, 697 Huntington Ave., Boston, Mass Short - Story Writing A course of forty lessons in the history, form,structure, and writing of the Skert- Story, taught by 4. Berg Esenwein, Editor L.ppincott's Magazine. Over one hundred Home —— } ang under rpraeors in Hare Brown, Cornell, and leading colleges. Dr Esenwein 250-page catalog free. Write to-day. The Home Correspondence School. Dept284 Springfield, Mass & . 4 “HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors 2a Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington NewYork 610 Swetiand Bd.,.Portland 814 Steger Bd..Chicago 343 DouglasBd., LosAngeles 920 Sav. Bk.Bd..Denver 345 Wright Bik., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. 156 Fifth Av Vincent B. Fisk, Mgr AGENCY ex- and Ask Harlan P. French, Prop THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ knows how Twenty-one years of successful perience in bringing together good teachers good schools 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. for bulletin 20 and see for yourself ERMAN PROFESSOR, FOR MANY YEARS J in the same position, contributor to journals and editor of text-books, desires a chang» Sub- jects besides German: French (ineluding Old French), Italian, Latin, Greek, Old English Ad dress M. N. O care of The Nation HOROUGH AND EFFECTIVE PREPARA- tion for college by an experienced tutor Highest references. WALTER B. WATERMAN, 214 Boylston Street, Boston. Learn Latin to Speak Palastra ‘s the common-sense in Latin; ee some 30 pamphlets for class or self-instruction by figures, cuts, texts on subjects of daily life, supported by Roman authors; vast vocabulary, no translations; reading, writing, speaking exercises; half published; $2.50 will bring all issued; com- plete $5.00; no samples. ARCADIVS AVEL- LANVS, Williamstown, Mass. LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND |} POURTH AVE. & 30TH STREET, DICTIONARY OF AVIATION By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE 287 pages. Cloth $1.40, postpaid $1.46 DOUBLEDAY, PAGE &CO., Garden City, L. I. “Seldom if ever NIETZSCHE beforehas Nietz- By PAULELMER MORE sche been so fair- With Portrait ly treated.” $1.00 net. Postpaid $1.05 —Chicago News LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- Ancient and modern languares. Translation, revision of manuscripts, etc. MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, WRITE DODD, MEAD & COMPANY NEW YORK

Page 3

oo The Nation NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 4, 1012 The Weck Woodrow Wilson’s nomination at Bal- timore on Tuesday was a vivid illustra- tion of one of the doctrines which he has long preached. This is the doctrine that the American people are capable of taking charge of their own affairs. Neither in politics nor in great business do they need little cliques of self-satis- fied men wise in their own conceit to tell trem what they must do. All the people know more than any one man or set of men. Their mature verdict is sounder. So it certainly was in the Democratic Convention. All the suppos- edly astute managers, all the veteran brokers in politics, were against Wil- son. He had no one but the amateurs to take charge of his fortunes. But they had zeal, devotion, and quenchless hope. And behind them was that slowly form- ing but finally resistless sentiment of the average delegate, aided and enlight- ened by the telegraphed appeals of aver- age citizens at home, which at last made the popular will felt and snatched vic- tory from what appeared to be destined defeat. In nominating Wilson the great body of the party rose up to assert itself against the professional compellers of conventions, who had kindly undertak- en to dispatch the business. The result is to make him his own man as few candidates have ever been. He has not had to strike hands behind the arras with a single boss. No pledges the man who that. There is nothing have been exacted from him. He has | contingent about the words of a man jthroughout whose proclamations an in- trails behind not been compelled to hamper and fet- ter himself in advance. It was not a series of trades and dickers which flock of very meek qualifications. the Colonel never goes into a fight on a brought him to the head of the poll at Baltimore, but simply the deepening of |contingency; his preference is for a sure the general conviction, until it became | thing. invincible, that he was the candidate best fitted to lead the party at this junc- ture. His nomination, thus achieved, | posed to contumely in Democratic Na- not only leaves him erect and unclog- | tional Conventions. In 1884 it was the ged, but discovers an array of defeated | Wigwam leaders, with their wonderful and discredited bosses almost without a|instinct for getting into opposition to parallel. They lay in heaps all along/the man who promised to save their the Wileon trail. This fact, known of | party, that Gen. Bragg referred to in his all men, is what makes Mr. Roosevelt's |famous phrase about Grover Cleveland: impudence so delicious in saying that|“We love him for the enemies he has | highly effective arraignment of Theo Wilson cannot meet the crisis because | made.” will be necessarily the bosses. All that is necessary to meet this ridiculgus and gangrened charge is to pronounce the name of one man his absurd charge about Wilson and the obviously all that he can think of in the first moments of his keen dis over Wilson's —people will only laugh at the man who chooses to forget his own submission to Platt and Quay, and Wilson's flinging of Smith over the all assertions to make against Woodrow Wilson, Theodore Roosevelt has chosen the most preposterous. can anything at affect any of his plans? “I never go into a fight on a contingent basis,” Colonel on Tuesday * Mr. Roosevelt dealt a body blow to contingency when he announced winter that he would be He hit contingency on the solar plexus when he declared at Chicago that there would be a third party, if the peo- ple wanted it, the third party, if no one else was chos- ' slugging contingency through the ropes with his “ifs” “on the one hands,” and his “provideds,” his and his raging dis- itinctions between the man who this and | itial loud defiance Tammany has before now many delegation went to Chicago tied up—like to like—to the fortunes of David B. Hill, ‘ts members were almost mobbed in the streets and were, throughout the Convention, made the object of abuse and execration. But it was reserved for this vear at Baltimore to bring the New York Democracy to the pitch of hostility and contempt. The Tammany display of incompetence has been masterly, and has so gone on from initial blunder to succeeding futility as to arouse the suspicion that the Iinten- tion from the start was to make New York an absolute nullity in the Conven- tion. Certainly, no set of men have ever been called upon to sit day after day in a National Convention exposed to such objurgation and insult as have beaten upon the defenceless heads of Murphy and his dazed and angry followers Still another Progressive Republican leader from a Progressive Republican State has announced that he has ho use for a third party. This time it is Sena tor Works, from Gov. Johnson's and Frank J. Henevy's California. What Sen- ator Works put into words on Monday has been in the minds of many Progres- sive Republicans ever since the Chicago bolt that is not yet a bolt, but soon will be, perhaps. Even from the Progressive standpoint is it worth risking the en- tire future of the Republican party for the sake of anticipating victory by four years? With no third party in the field two things are certain: the defeat of Mr. Taft and the complete capture of the Republican party by the Progressives in time for the next campaign With a third party in the field the outlook is not merely defeat, but such complete disruption as wil: leave the Democratic party in undisputed ascendency for years to come. And thus the thought forces itself upon the mind of the lead- ers: Mr. Roosevelt cannot afford to wait till 1916, but the Progressive element in the Republican party can afford to do so. Why should the permanent advantage of the Progressive movement be sacrificed to the immediate necessities of Oyster Bay? One point in La Follette’s sharp and Again in 1892, when the Tam- | dore Roosevelt has peculiar force. La

Page 4

2 Follette popularity, but argues that his very pop- ularity shows that he is not a real Pro- gressive. In the nature of things, the Progressive movement in Illinois and Pennsylvania should not have won. What Roosevelt did in those States was to rally behind him those who felt that, but course Progressivism, Roosevelt, was The of the campaign justifies La Follette not a winner. Colonel's It began with at least the pretence of principles. There was the new Magna Charta pro claimed at Columbus. Then it narrow- ed itself down to the question of Presi- dential primaries. Then it narrowed it- self further to the question of getting Roosevelt delegates in any fashion. Then ! tapered down further still to the question of preventing any other Pro gressive than Roosevelt from getting the nomination for the Presidency. Gov Hadley’s statement that the Taft people were willing to accept any Progressl v candidate proves that the great fight for the people had resolved itself into a campaign of utter selfishness. To this extent, to be sure, the Colonel was jus- tifled financial no other Progressive could show of campaign backing to the amount $3,000,000 for a mere primary It hould not be overlooked that the Republican tariff plank quietly dropped the great discovery of 1908 that customs duties should be levied in accordance with the difference in “the cost of pro- duction,” at home and abroad. Whether the phrase was devised as merely one more protectionist juggle, or was hon- estly intended—as no doubt it was by President Taft—-time has shown that it was worthle in practice. So it has now been discarded. Attacked from the firat by economists, who maintained that it set up a standard impossible of pre cise ascertainment, it was little by lit tle perceived by practical men to be elu sive and fallacious Even the Tariff Board, composed of men who wrestled honestly and intelligently with the prob lem, was forced to tnform Congress that t had found a vide difference in effi- t y and coat" among American mills No fixed ost of production high or low ould be taken ifely as the basis for tariff legislation. As Rey entative Redfield pointed out in his admirable tariff speech in the Hous oste cannot t pred ated » few y ! r a short ‘ od Alread of tl | n wi r rt is ad the concedes the Colonel a vast | The Nation altered. The Tariff Board facts given are has come, lived its feverish and troubled life, and will turn over its work to a more efficient and continuous successor, which will, we trust, learn from its career that industrial problems cannot be grasped with ’" and that, in man- than the ob- a “hop, skip, and jump ifacturing, the unseen rather vious facts are ontrolling But the experiment has not been in vain if we have learned that it is as wrong to tax ourselves to support inefficient mills as to sustain incompetent doctors and law- ers. Attention having been called to the ost of productior we ha found that to be a complex and difficult subject, variable utur l haract E 1 thos ha g studied the scien i i ) f ts ir i i Wr To t Socialists possibility of a third party with Mr. Roos It at th head S 1a i! is apprenh n n They hav ilwa suffered when eve a Radical indida has b n the field Hiea i New York city vote in 1995,and Bryan's can didacy four irs ago mad: 1 sad dis- appointment nfident Socialist hope for a millior tes in the country With progressive ideals triumphant in the country and Colonel standing: ready to offer as sharp a brand of radi- calism as may be necessary, the Social ists are menaced monopoly as the party of protest. Their leaders recog- nize, howevel that the issue between revolutionary Socialism and progressiv- ism must be fought out some time, and the sooner the trial is made the better for the future of the part; If the acid test of Rooseveltism leaves them as strong as they are to-day, they will not be unduly downcast The Sulzer bill “for the improvement of the foreign servic: is being press- ed for passage by ommercial or- ganizations, as as by all those who wish to see efficien and not favor the rule of appointment and pro- motion in all branches of the Govern- ment The specific provisions of the bill are few and simple. The first one Is that appointments of secretaries in the diplomatic servi und of consular offi cers may be to grades instead of to places Under the absurd arrangement that we have followed from the founda- tion of the Government, if a consulate at one place ceases necessary, the President may clos¢ ut he may not use the onsul at anot pla where na great weeded, until Con- r s get i ! ) iting a con [Vol. 95, No. 2453 sulate there. A secretary of embassy cannot even be transferred temporarily from an underworked post to one that is being overworked—unless he chooses to take the risk of losing his pay. For the salary attaches, not to the man, but to the office. How long would any but a governmental organization have con- Then the bill directs the Secretary of State to re- tinued so foolish a practice? port to the President from time to time, along with his recommendations for pro- motion or transfer, the names of offi- cers or employees who have demonstrat- ed special efficiency, and also the names of persons who have shown fitness for appointment in examinations. The idea in this section is evidently that repeated hints in the right direction may avail indifferent tive, while furnishing the requisite ma- something with an Execu- chinery for one of the proper sort. And, finally, provision is made for these ex- aminations. The action of the Federation of Wo- men’s Clubs, now assembled in conven- tion at San Francisco, in voting to in- augurate a movement to substitute ar- tistic and humorous supplements in place of the present vulgar “comics” our Sunday of newspapers, will at first glance seem to many newspaper pub- lishers a good joke. They will insist that they are merely giving the people what they want, and will then prove it to you by showing you the enormous circulation gains a newspaper makes when it turns to the coarse and vulgar pages that pass for wit. It clearly comes down to a matter of dollars and cents. If the women's clubs can so arouse pub- lic feel it, there will be a prompt improve- opinion as to make the newspapers ment. That this education of the popu- lar taste will take a long, long while, is apparent when one recalls the masses of readers in all our large cities who find their chief mental relaxation in the silly adventures of some caricaturist’s reation. Telegraph companies seem to have got their eyes open to the advantage of hav- ing rates that will induce the public to The announcement that in certain zones the make greater use of their lines. charge will hereafter be 30 cents instead of 40 is the best possible evidence of of night letter” arrangement, which the of- the success the low-rate “day and

Page 5

July 4, 1912 ficials undertook with misgivings some months ago. The new rate, in its turn, while not nearly so great a boon as the opportunity “letters,” will doubtless promptly justify itself in the figures of gross and net earnings. Taken of these in connection with the reduction made a year or more ago in the charge for up- de- creases afford what solace there may be per berths in sleeping-cars, these in the lowering of the cost of some lux uries as a set-off against the rise in the price of a good many necessities. At least one member of the United States Supreme Court is not sold body and soul to the powers of reaction. Jus- tice Holmes’s eyes are not always turn- “As I Icok about me in this country to-day,” ed steadfastly towards the past. Justice Holmes told the students at Wil- find the than liams College, “I that young men are better we were at their The ancient grievances of youth against hold to-day. The tradition of timid old age laying a age.” its elders do not the ardent spirit of is completely outworn. Mid-Vic- believed that their sons were going to the devil, and palsied hand on youth torian parents may have may have tried to keep them back. The modern parent does something more than abstain from holding his children back. He gives them free rein. He pays them the compliment of confessing that they are better than he was at their express age. He pays them the implicit compli- ment of imitating them. It is a churlish young generation that would sneer at those whom only the accident of birth has made their elders. The Cuban uprising seems to be rap- idly nearing its end. The matter is one for self-congratulation in this country. In Cuba, as in Mexico, it has been shown that if the sinister play of foreign influ- ences be cut off, and if the constituted authorities feel secure against unwar- ranted intervention by our Government, our neighbors may be depended upon to fight out their own troubles. The chron- ic disorder that obtains in parts of Latin America is one thing. The crises that before it attains self-discipline, are some- thing quite different. This positively assert that Cuba and Mexico every nation must pass through does not are in a class apart from the rest of the Caribbean But sufficient reason for believing them dif-| republics. there is The Nation their being given a ferent, to justify fair chance. In the case of Mexico there are the very best reasons for believing that a new era will follow the severe test the country is now passing through. And in Cuba, too, the suppression of the present uprising without the interven- tion of the United States will act as a double discouragement to revolutionary ambitions in the future. Whether of the insurrection has actually come or is to be tle reason for doubting that the author- the collapse Orozco delayed for a few days, there is lit- ity of the Madero Government will soon be that firmly established in Mexico, and the country will set tranquilly about working out the serious problems that confront it. The magnitude of the task can hardly be overestimated. It be- hooves President Madero to restore, in the first place, the habit of public order Porfirio But the long ascendency of had whereas, under Diaz, order was obtained which Diaz imposed on the people by the sacrifice of popular freedom and of the classes, it is for Madero to set the Mexi the serious oppression laboring can people on the way towards solving the problem of combining internal peace with a fair measure of self-gov- ernment and far-reaching social re- is not only the evils of the to It Diaz régime forms. that have be undone. The unwarranted hopes aroused by the uprising against Diaz must be held in check. Neither free political institu- tions nor such an agrarian reconstruc- tion as Mexico stands in need of can be worked out in a month or a year. The future of the Mexican people is still be- set with uncertainties. But it is now fairly well assured that for some time te come the present Government will be allowed to proceed with its task, un- hampered by serious revolutionary dis- turbances. The Franchise bill which has just been introduced in the House of Com- mons carries with it far-reaching changes. Aside from the _ possibility that it may become the vehicle for a woman-suffrage amendment, such as Mr. has pledged himself to accept, dealt wi the The Asquith the direct questions th in bill are of the highest importance. of the most outstanding feature, but the re- abolition plural voting is, perhaps, moval of the property qualification and 3 the reform of the registration rules wil) have a far broader effect It is esti mated that the bill would wipe out half That constituency, a million plural votes. makes about 800 votes to a and, inasmuch as the plural vote is supposed to be divided in the ratio of one Liberal vote to three Conservative, the loss would be considerable to the latter party. By reducing the registration pe- riod from a year to six months, the Gov- ernment experts believe that no less than two million voters will be added to the electorate, and that is only one half of the adult males who are at pres- ent disfranchised. There are more than 12,000,000 male persons above twenty ne years of age in England, and less than 8,000,000 names are on t regis ter. So even the enactment of this pro posed measul! ive the fran chise something s inhood suf frage. The advan rthele would marked, and that i hy the Fran hise bill takes nh th Home Ruie and Welsh Disestal ment the fore front of the Governme! coalition pré gramme, The apartment-hous ia at la eached Calcutta, and old inhabitants ere shaking their heads over the pa ing of the day of spacious compounds and large-heaited hospital as There vas a time, says the Englishman, when eve rybody lived in a bungalow, kept troops of servants, rode horse and spent leisure hours in sports and pas times suited to the luxurious life of the planter in the tropics In those days the idea of more than one family in a house would have been put aside as pre posterous. But the entering wedge was the boarding-house, which sprang up as rents increased and smaller salaries ere paid. This mode of living became very popular, so that Calcuttans of a former generation were driven to com- plain that Members of Council and heads of firms resided in single rooms cheek by jowl with their extreme juniors, liere was the beginning of the end of the extravagant hospitality and gayety that made Calcutta famou Where peo- ple once gave balls and large dinner parties, they now collect a fe friends for tea and tennis, aft: arguing with their co-tenants as to the use of the sin gie-court tennis lawn, which has replac- ed the acres of garden that rrounded each house,”

Page 6

a REMODELLING CONVENTIONS. Every National Convention, like every opening new year, brings forth its crop of good resolutions. Unhappily, the analogy holds for a stage further, when we note the pitiful lack of practical re- sults from all the discussions and deci- sions on what ought to be done. Twen- ty years have now passed since Patrick Collins of Massachusetts and a group of tried to induce sympathetic colleagues the Democratic party to adopt a rule at its future the limiting the attendance National Conventions to delegates and alternates, their outside officers, the National Committee, the working mem- bers of the press, and a few distinguish- The thought these gentlemen the ed guests had was that deliberations of a were a serious duty, to be befitting their great party undertaken in a spirit importance and conducted with proper dignity, instead of being turned into a raree-show for the benefit of a horde of curlosity-seekers, “fans,” and “rooters,” hotels and dramshops and ticket-scalp- The and approved, but nothing was ef- ers movement was widely heartily fected at the time, and before 1896 came around the lessens of 1892 hzd been for- gotten. This year’s Conventions have merely emphasized the need of reform. As we have already pointed out, the one at Bal- | timore has shown that a Convention can be made both a workable and a delib- erative body; can be unbossed, and as Bryan has made clear, that a delegate who knows how can get a hearing on the floor, whether the managers desire him to or not. Again, the Convention at Bal- timore could have been made far more endurable for all concerned if business Why a Convention should meet at noon when hours had been insisted upon. it could just as well gather at 9 A. M., is Neither is an adjourn- P. M. the the delegates have sat for not explained ment at 4 rational, on ground that four hours; since, on reassembling at 8 PrP. M. their seats for twelve hours listening to they are compelled to remain in speeches no one wishes to hear, and to demonstrations” as senseless as they are useless. The managers at first acted as if they must prolong the Convention; it was sald that their contract with Bal them to hold sittings timore required for at least three days. But even when the deadlock was on, there was an ef.- fort to adjourn, as if for purposes of The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2453 | dickering, when a vast majority of the delegates, as the vote showed, were ready to remain in their seats. That the well “demonstrations” could be pretty controlled was also made evident. At least, a vigorous chairman could have prevented the carrying of banners, and notified the balconies that they would be cleared if any interfer- ence were attempted, while an agreement among the leaders of delegations would have prevented delegates from attempt- ing to stampede the Convention. Again, the nominating speeches could well have been cut from thirty minut*s to half that No such set speeches ever made By the time they are made every delegate time. a vote for a candidate, or ever will. knows how he is to vote. Moreover, these advocates of a candidate are much in the attitude of paid lawyers; hence their eulogies are discounted in advance. Everything that can be said in a man’s is said long in advance of the nomination. To repeat it is to waste time. Certainly, fifteen minutes is long enough to brief any man’s case. As for the demonstrations, ten or fifteen min- utes of racket was thought wonderful favor in the days of Horatio Seymour, and it was regarded as a great achievement to swell this to twenty minutes for Grant and then to twenty-five or more minutes | for the Plumed Knight of 1884. Now it is a question of rivalry. If one candi- date gets an hour and five minutes of cheering, the friends of the next must give at least an hour and fifteen. Turning from the matter of discipline and the procedure of the Convention, | it is clear that the effect of binding in- structions on State delegations is likely to be serious in the future if there con- tinue to be several candidates in the field. It was frequently asked in Baltimore what would happen if, with Presiden- tial primaries in virtually all the States, there should appear in the next Conven- tion not two candidates as well-matched as Clark and Wilson, but four. Or, to put it differently, how would the exist- ing deadlock have been broken if Har- mon and Underwood had entered the Convention with about 200 votes each, pledged to stand by them until a major- ity of each delegation voted that their particular man had no chance of win- Such instructions long prevented an agreement What if there had been more of them? This is a vital question for the future of the ning? at Baltimore. convention system, and for those who see in the Presidential preference pri- mary the best way of obtaining the real expression of a party's desire as to its national leader. Some way out of this dilemma will have to be found. Mean- while, if the National Convention is to remain, it should be reformed along the lines of Patrick Collins’s suggestions of twenty years ago. LEGISLATION BY The recent revival of the project to limit tenure in the classified civil ser- “RIDER.” vice in Washington to five years, shows how hard a vicious movement dies. Be- fore the merit system had thoroughly intrenched itself in the good opinion of the public, the assaults upon it in Con- gress used to take the form either of bold repeal bills, which never escaped from the committee-room where they were solemnly placed on file, or of mo- tiens to strike out the appropriations for the Civil Service Commission, and thus starve to death an institution which could not be got rid of by more direct methods. The motion to strike out was always supported by Represen- tatives of the Grosvenor stripe, and Sen- ators with the proclivities of Gorman, az long as support could be confined to making speeches full of flings at an “of- ‘fice-holding aristocracy,” and stories of /absurdities in examinations which ‘never had any foundation in fact; buta roll-call, putting every man on record, promptly drove the spoilsmen to cover and killed their scheme. A dozen years of security have caus- |ed a great many of the clerks in the "Washington departments to feel thut |they can afford to abandon their voting ‘citizenship in their respective States land settle down as permanent residents ‘of the District of Columbia. Here, then, ‘is a large army of disfranchised citi- zens, powerless to retaliate upon the ‘members of Congress who vote to put their positions back on the spoils list. Note the cleverness of the authors of the “rider” on the Sundry Civil Appro- priation bill, in confining the effects of their proposed blow to this particular group, but leaving untouched the civil servants employed in the Federal of- fices in their several districts and still able to revenge themselves at the polls! Though rejected by the Senate, the five-year tenure clause will remain a | menace down to the last stages of the

Page 7

July 4, 1912] The Nation bill’s career; and if it passes the con- | ference committee in the course of the trading to-and-fro between the two Houses, the responsibility for defeating it will be put up to the President. The only means open to him will be to veto the entire act. Such a dilemma faced President Cleveland just before the ex- piration of his second term. One of the last bills presented for his signature was the annual Indian budget, upon which a Western Senator had succeeded in grafting a very vicious mining job. In view of the short time given him for consideration, the President's simplest course would have been to let the bill become a law and leave his successor to wrestle with the sequel. But Mr. Cleve- land had mighty little “soft” stuff in his composition. He killed the act, and, at the special session which immediately followed President McKinley’s inaugura- tion, a bill had to be rushed through Congress simply continuing the appro- priations of the year before till a more satisfactory measure could be framed. But the next regular Indian appropria- tion bill was free from the taint which had stirred Mr. Cleveland’s righteous wrath. . Of course, the most obvious way of correcting this continually recurrent evil, with its incentive to log-rolling and its embarrassments for a right-feeling President, is to keep the annual supply bills clean of elements which do not belong in them. The moment any such bill is permitted to carry “riders,” good or bad, the doors are opened for abuses of all sorts. Unhappily, the difficulty of inducing Congress to pay reasonable at- tention to independent measures of con- structive legislation has led even the most scrupulous members to wink at the practice of attaching a progressive amendment here and there to some item in a budget. Such a device is always subject to a point of order in the first stage of a bill’s consideration; but often the floor leaders are persuaded, by ap- peals to their good nature or threats of filibustering tactics later, to ignore an opportunity to make the point, unless the amendment contains a feature mani- festly abominable. And so the bill comes up for final passage with a lot of alien matter clinging to it. By that time) nearly everybody is tired out, and ob- jections which might otherwise find | voice are waived for the sake of getting | through with the matter. In this era of overhauling and revi-| sion, it seems strange that nobody has urged one Constitutional amendment which would be enormously valuable to the whole people, and which has been tested with good results on a smaller scale. In New York and a dozen other States the Governor’s veto power ex- tends to items in an appropriation bill. The same power should be conferred upon the President, whose sphere of a tivity is many times as broad as that of any Governor, and who is confronted with problems correspondingly momen tcus. A reform of that sort would sure- ly appeal to the rank and file of the tax- payers, to whom it would probably mean a saving of millions every year. It would mean also an increased concen- tration of responsibility; so that we should no longer force upon our Chief Magistrate a share in our lawmaking, and hold him to that extent accountable for the joint product of Congress and himself, while denying him one tool, at least, with which to perform his part of the work acceptably. CORPORATIONS AND PUBLICITY The remedy which the Review of Re- views brings forward as a cure for pub- lic hostility towards the corporations lacks freshness to-day. We are now moving forward at a speed which makes it seem decades since it was first sug- gested that the general mistrust of cor- porate ideals and methods could be re- moved if the corporations and the pub- lic could be brought together for a heart- to-heart talk. This solution was based on the thoroughly sound theory that misunderstanding is at the bottom of every strained situation existing among men and groups of men. The muckraker had intensified popular suspicion of the corporations. The only thing for the corporations te do was to take the pub- lic into their confidence. The public. is not unreasonable. Let corporate capital take the citizen by the buttonhole and say: “Here is what we do and are try- ing to do, if you will give us a chance, and here is what we cannot do at pres- ent without being driven into bank- |ruptcy; be fair with us and be patient.” The great public-service institutions would better themselves by substituting for the old policy of the people be damned, the new policy of the people be informed. The theory was sound and there were enlightened corporations which hasten- 7 -) ed to adopt the practice of justification by words. But unfortunately the porations, as a rule, have adopted a very superficial interpretation of publicity They have used the advertising columns for pleasant little chats with their tomers. They have assured the publ that the corporations are really the p lic’s corporations, and they have tried to stow in how many ways the companies have been trying to minister to the eral welfare and comfort. We have had imiable, insinuating little confidences hich are really no confidences at all The public's memory is not always short. In New York, for instance, peo ple remember very well how every im- provement on the city railways has been fought by the managers on the ground that the financial condition of the com panies would not permit it. But no at tempt was made to throw open the cor poration books in order to prove the point. The motormen on the surface cars in winter had to risk their health and lives because vestibuled cars meant ruin for the company. The vestibuled cars came at last, but the published history of the Metropolitan Company showed that it was not the cost of the new cars that threw the city railway into bankruptcy. Side-doors in the sub way had to be fought for; fans had to be fought for; even decent lighting in the subway had to be fought for. We have these improvements now, and the Interborough is not threatened with in solvency. What could publicity have done for the Interborough when the public was demanding these improve ments? Real publicity would have shown that the company could afford to make the changes and that it refused to do so only in a spirit of greed One other point must not be over- looked. When we speak of public hos- tility to the corporations, it should be remembered that it is against the great nation-wide aggregates of capital that this hostility is chiefly directed. When we speak of the evil influence of the corporations on our civic and economik life we think of the Standard Oil, the Tobacco Trust, the Sugar Trust, and the railways. It is absurd to speak of real publicity in this connection. It is de lightful to imagine the Sugar Trust tak ing the public into its confidence and whispering into its ear all the interest- ing secrets that the public has recently found out by the roundabout way of the

Page 8

Federal Courts. It is pleasing to think f publicity and tl Standard Oil, that i oncern, whose officials on the tand, during the last forty years, i had a p ania for blurting it ft I its One can us I ( | the Tobacco Trust would be to lay before the public I t yy which it orld And ay vith t les of dire ) al I ompany di rs and road quite plain d be perfectly hap kings to the [ ws Spe ik ' ty, it does not ai put corporation And i matter of fact, cour i broad sense, is what the pub of its local service corpor at | vill be crises, of course, he he publi ill insist on real pub i hen the battle for the three ent al \ raging in Cleveland. At that time it was a specific ques tion of earnings, expenditure, and profit, and the statistics were fought out in the newspapers But what the public wants year in and year out is not publicity, but decent service When a corporation shows itself willing to meet a reasonable public demand half way; when it stops making foolish pre testations of its inability to do things which a half-year later it does very eas- ly and profits by; when, in other words, it tries to serve as well as to make divi will talks there be no need for confi dential littl with the publi EXCAVATING A STATESMAN, There is a form of archwology which | ed with great vigor in the heat f i tieal campaigns and parliamen tary battl It consists In the digging | fa publ an past This exer fT fro the clence of archwol eral respects, In the firet 1 the k ilways carried ! ereas Troy 1 (ne ave all been t t In the t different ' t alwa set i t ne the past and the The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2453 ways searches into the past in order to the Like he liar. Schlie- Petrié, prove present a mann and Flinders loves to lay bare one level below the other in a great career. From this stratum he un- earths a letter written in a moment of Deeper down he roll-call. literary indiscreet confidence. discloses a damaging still giving voice to sentiments quite opposite Deeper he finds a youthful work to those displayed on the topmost stratum of the public man’s career. And the more violent the contrasts between the various culture levels, the greater is the satisfaction of the man with the spade. The mute evidences of catas- trophic change which make the histor- ian ponder over the vicissitudes of civ- lization are hailed with joy by the par- tisan investigator of political records of the past It is a business that can be sadly over- done. In theory there is no better way of confuting a man than by the words of his own mouth. In practice, it de- pends on how deep down into a man’s past one has gone to work his confu- sion. It also depends on the nature of the clash between a public man’s pres- ent and his past. Between the turn- coat and the statesman who has moved with the times there are many grada- tions. Before accusing a man of having should be at that the earlier state of mind was the right one. It bate for a man to acknowledge that he there evidence changed his mind, least prima facie has become an effective mode of de- has changed, and that he is glad of it. Bismarck made classic use of the argu- ment nearly thirty years ago: It does not in the least affect the intrinsic merit of the proposition from the point of of interests, if the view Imperial man should show that my present position) is inconsistent with views formerly express- ed such> shall even if there were, what does it prove? I inconsistency, as I show. can only reply that there are a great many people who during an entire lifetime have given birth to just one idea, with which they have never fallen into contradiction. I lo not belong to that class I learn from life. T learn as long as I live, I am learning t¢ la An effective rejoinder, and one that has been made a thousand times, though it may be pointed out that to use it with full effect one must be Bismarck. lust where is one to find the safe mid- die ground between the Bourbonism that refuse to change and learn, and the demagogiam that hifts and veers to breath of fortune? Success usual- gentle-| As a matter of fact, there is no ' But! ly intervenes to confuse the issue. One who would have been a demagogue in failure is an evolutionary statesman in But it enough rule to say that a public man shall be given broad scope in matters of opinion, but should be held sharply to success. in general is a fair account on matters of fact. It is record- ea of a celebrated American that when he became a candidate for a high Fed- eral office, he was much perturbed over the fact that he had years before writ- ten a book in which he spoke harshly of man a certain religious sect. A shrewd of politics before whom the case was laid, advised against sophistication “Just say you were very that.” But when it is in the matter. young when you wrote Usually that would be enough. a question of reconciling, not contradic- but the divergence between promise and accom- tory expressions of opinion, plishment, there is every reason why public men should be held to strict ac- countability. A statesman may evolve from conservatism to radicalism with- out having his motives impugned. But when a statesman declares that under no circumstances will he do a thing, and does it, the plea of a changed outlook will not hold as an excuse. The viola- tion of a pledge can never be explained ‘away. The most a statesman can do is to ask his opponents what they intend to do about it. In that there is a cer- tain picturesque strength, but to put the debate on moral grounds is absurd. Contemporary politics supplies interest- |ing examples of men who in the course of time have drifted far from their orig- inal moorings. Joseph Chamberlain be ‘gan as a radical and a republican and ‘has changed to an imperialist Tory. In |France, MM. Briand and Millerand have developed from anarchism and social- ism, respectively, into very safe Minis- terial timber. When Briand, as Presi- |dent of the Cabinet, set out to suppress the great railway strike with the aid of = army, M. Jaurés republished a |pamphlet written by Briand in favor of the general strike as the surest means of ushering in the social revolution. But even in such a case a man may shrug his shoulders and say, “I think differ- eatly Yet ing differently will absolve a man from “IT won't” into “I will” and “I now.” no amount of think- changing vill” into “I won't.”

Page 9

July 4, 1912 ROUSSEAU IN ENGLAND. One of the results of the celebration of the ousseau centenary in France— of the the or, Franco-British tente possibly, en- into French of the volume of the late Chur- has been translation ton Collins, “Voltaire, Montesquieu, and Rousseau in England.” It is the third part of the work to which the French critics are naturally paying the most attention just now. It was a picturesque episode in Rousseau's life—more pictur- esque than important, one would say. He had no particular sympathy with English ideas He could not speak a word of English. He passed his year (1766-67) in England, not because he was drawn there by the curiosity of an investigator or student, but simply be cause, to him, as to so many other Con tinental agitators or disturbers of the political peace, the island home of lib erty offered a refuge Rousseau, at the end of 1765, was in an awkward and even perilous position The dec reed the He thought but she re- Parliament at Paris had arrest of the author of “Emile.” to retire to Geneva, to harbor him. Berne was of the He then of fused same mind. repaired to Motiers, which was under the sovereignty of the King Prussia, but even there sentiment was strongly against him, and he retreated to the Lake of Bienne. he left meditations. formal not to his A of the Government required him to de gut there, too, was peaceful order part. He thought for a time of fleeing to Corsica, but at the critical moment Madame de Boufflers transmitted to him an invitation from David Hume to ac- company him to London, and Rousseau accepted it The passage of the Channel in Janu- ary by the two philosophers was more than traditionally trying. They were twelve terrible hours in crossing from Calais. It is amusing to note that the cool and impassive Hume was deathly seasick, and lay groaning in his berth all the way over, while the excitable and neurasthenic Rousseau stayed on deck, wet to the skin and half-frozen, but doubtless surrendering himself to the most thrilling emotions. What some of them were may be imagined from the fact that the moment the ship touched land, Rousseau burst into tears, threw his arms about Hume, and hailed him as the saviour who had led One fancies him to the soil of freedom ‘The that this did not help Hume to get over Nation his seasickness. Indeed, as is well known, Rousseau was a pretty formi dable guest for the Scotch philosopher The Frenchman's eccentricitic almost running at times into manias, his sus picions and his vacillations, made him as “gey ill to live with” as Carlyle, or even more The two fell near to bitter quarrelling more than once, though Rousseau quitted England with th warmest feelings of gratitude to Hum«e Luckily, the burden of Rousseau’s en tertainment in England was dely dis trivuted. The interesting foreigner was made a lion of in London H affecta tions, his Oriental dre s ol his adventurous and irregular fe, al conspired t ike him ; of ul versal curios Atter ho ered upon hit Gen. ( Se retary of State, called I G rick invited hi to a su] l te! gave a special theatrical perf n his honor. To this Rousseau was on the point of declining to go, at the last ment, on the plea that he could not leave his dog alone at home. It required som«e argument by Hume, who exp] ed that the King and Queen had taken a box, to convince the French radical that it would never do to put a slight upon royalty, to say nothing of his actor-host, for the sake of a dog. According to a contemporary letter by Lady Bunbury, which Mr. Collins printed, Rousseau thanked Garrick effusively, and sured him that he had alternately laughed and wept all through the pla though he could not understand a sifgle word But the pleasures of the city soon palled upon the man of whom Sainte-Beuve said that the note of love of nature first sounded clear in his writings Rous seau essayed various retreats in the country Finally a house was offered him at Wooton, the owner, in ord to meet Rousseau’s ideas of independe! charging him a nominal rent. There he had his dog, his Thérése vith her ir explicable ascendency over ! and | thoughts in solituds Bu f ni happy Exposed to impert nt intr sions, he felt himself more persecuted than ever At last he rote an ang! note to his landlord, and de d t return to France. He wrote to the Lord Chancellor to ask for a bodyguard ad quate to protect him, while tra ling to Dover, from his implacable enemle That official drily replied that his po tilion would suffice. Rousseau hast sailed from England, May 22, 176 His brief stay England ourse, insigznil nt ol pared permanent impression I ! ! litical philosophy mad n Engll hought As in his « n land ind e] here, it roused violent antagonisms same tin i won ardent hy That its influen Silently ] t n England to t day, t no questior th t I I I nch nd Eng tur much ( 1 it I twair athe ( REC] FI a Vi pie ‘ 60 ’ \ +?) i i ‘ ii ler | pl | t i } com On the lin i fi 1 adequate phrasil f ( efined ind cv! | + ey a ntillatior 0 Mi p he not da bv ad \ w i @ ’ ' han | f Sha p | Renal d lus And I t \ i in | speak ! 0) I tT} it é ods tha ' tan 4 if Olvn il ( ) nd their th ' t lof? ow He l nom pect ‘ ‘ tir h ' ’ ‘ p ro mo! t! fe i ) noe rt diapa I tuned hi te vyhen the irt la ] ‘ ‘ ne “4 ted t ve t France or fro that lat tit n h tone ! su th ¢ pi t! ! i | ko ( ] af vif nt © rn] | } | ‘ e stops | hero of i } G elir ainte pil « David ‘ he Pont-N t I il I f or ue be ' rning f , , B 7 } , ' ; iy

Page 10

assassination his own term Revolutionary after Robespierre. ognized Gamelin « women who but » ourselves guilty of and some one tosses into his cart On the hand, quickly with- charm of such an adieu The Nation with tenderness and love, she threw her- into the arms of Philip Such a book may prove Anatole France's greatest work: and he comes to it better fitted than for his “Joan of Art Of course, those of the old order who struggle to remain what they have always been are too imbecile in his pages, though generally amiable; and those of the new order are regularly too ous that bloodshed is crime and unconst too self-conscious of the right of their kind to remake the world by cutting off heads. But in the romance, as in the reality, the deeds which stand out to us in terrible relief are but a part of the daily details of life, eating and drink- ing, making merry and marrying. Much of been praising Anatole France most; but it can hardly please those who have Lord Acton, who knew, doubts our right of that it would be possible for an have a friend With “Pour de l'Aigle” francs each) “assuming honest historian to Ohnet’s books— and “La Serre illustrated, 3.50 we have a descent Olympus to the atmosphere of middle classes to which most of like the late Mr. Gladstone, say we proud to belong. We are still in stream of Revolutionary passion, directed against Bonaparte, who making the work of the Revolution in France, while doing away unpractical live through it. The ro- mances are built up around the con- spirators of the counter-Revolution— Saint-Régeant and Georges Cadoudal. Here there is no undertone of sus- pected philosophy to make us uneasy, no dull dust of daily life to draw our attention from the main show. The story is told in the emphatic style of the traditional historical romance, with all the melodrama and real tragedy ground into our quaking hearts. It has disputed whether Georges Ohnet belongs to literature; but it is beyond dispute that he has story-telling ability his generation. The basis of his also should not be depreciated, even though the advanced heads of some of the char- acters with every step they tread knock Georges two tuer Bonaparte” (Ollendorff, rude from those us, are the now was practical with the managed to been beyond those of historical stories out a star in heaven. It is to be re- gretted, at least for readers who are sons of Puritans, that the love-making of the Countess spy should be punished within our hearing in crude and cruel kind The instruments of Napoleon philosophize, in a middle-class way, of all they have seen: “Put into the bal- ance the deeds done by this side and by that—and see if it sinks in favor of one party They balance seemingly, equal ferocity and crime.” ‘Mon ‘that Let's Braconneau, wars. cher,’ said is the philosophy of civil go to bed!’” leaders that had | [ Vol. 95, No. 2453 As he mounts the scaffold, Georges Cadoudal gives the responses to the priest's prayers, but stops short before “at the hour of our death.” “What's the use? he said, tranquilly, “since it is now the hour of death.” He embraced the priest, made a gesture of adieu to his companions, lifted up his great round head and looked at the _ public crowding round him; and he cried with a loud voice: “Vivre le Roi!” The moment after, he was dead “La Jeune Fille bien élevée” and “Madeleine jeune femme” (Calmann- Lévy—38.50 frances each), by René Boy- lesve, bring us powerfully to our own time. Georges Ohnet to his series the term “Legend and His- tory”: here we have the every-day life of French men and women. Of the first of the two novels, which have the same characters, the author, rising near to the head of the line of living French novel writers, says: candidly applies who is In it I without afterthought, the story of the life of a young girl brought up as they were commonly in our prov- inces in the century (that is, twenty- five years ago). My heroine was born at a time when the spirit of inquiry, the taste for criticism, and the thirst for emancipation were in fashion: it was not I, her painter, that groaned beneath the weight of provincial customs; it was she, my model, whom I saw thus pained. And if, on the other side, I showed considera- tion for “prejudices” or persons of the old time, it was not I who counselled my con- temporaries to go backward to old things; it was my model, discerning in spite of herself all that was deeply true in her, who asserted in spite of herself a stronger attachment, more resisting than the en- ticements of the day, for the support and shelter which came to her from centuries ago. An invitation to reflect on life, at length and as deeply as may be, even with bitterness and difficulty—this is the proper moral action of the novel-writer— the extreme limit to which he can go with- out straining his kind of writing. ... While differing from direct moral and so- cial action, it is none the less important, for we have to remember that through ig- norance of real man and flattery for se- ductive ideas the gravest public errors are committed, and that for lack of psychology most private disorders are produced daily. composed, last All this explaining is kept out of the thread of the story and limited to a short address to the reader when the author takes up the story of his “well- bred voung girl,” now that she has be- come a “young wife.” Two notable books, indeed, with moralities impor- tant to all who reflect on society, that is, the living men and women around them. They are written in the lan- guage of refined French conversation, not dragging, except as life always grows long. The heroine is a daughter of a middle-class family of Touraine, which for centuries has lived on a plane of high, if narrow, tradition, | plainly, with high thinking and cultiva-

Page 11

July 4, 1912] tion, in religiously, marrying and giving principles which are readers who feel that there must be a substantial life in France beyond that of the commoner yellow-covered novels will find interest and edification in the story of Mad- eleine’s girlhood and select convent schooling, in her marriage without her traditions or cultivation, and so beneath her, in her cheerful adaptation to it and salvation scath of the new world around the old habits of principle, which are, in spite of herself, her second nature, in the resignation with which she takes up the burden of life. Perhaps, the lack of principle to guide in brand-new society is accentuated; perhaps there is marriage English by rules into a class from her by a generation yet younger which is swinging round to the old traditions. Marcel Boulenger, who is a younger ris ing novelist, says that in his province marriages for money are sought by parents, and pleasure in life without responsibility by the children’ they marry to each other, far more avidly than in René Boylesve’s books. There, at least, the grandmother has some- thing heroic and the young wife has strength of soul. Perhaps a still later nnowledge of men now coming to ma- turity twentieth-century France would lead one to say that M. Boylesve in has drawn his male kind more harshly than France, ever renewing herself and her children, fairly deserves. “Petite Madame” (Plon—3.50 francs), by André Lichtenberger, continues the unreflecting, delightful story of Jacques and Jotte, just married, greatly pleased with themselves, a little uncertain how to behave to their various parents, who, on their side, hardly know whether tc laugh or cry. In reality, they are al. good as good, and we have their chartr- like that of our autlors petit Trott, whom the Academy long ago cro'vned king of child's stories Anc it ends in Life’s triumph, as the sunrise: ing chronicle as usnal there them Behind the curtains was a mewing noise. back There was a wriggling creature, and Jotte’s white Jacques drew eyes brightened She half arose “Give him to me!” 4 little clumsy, a little squeamish, re- spectful, very proud, Jacques lifted up the little squirming red being which was his son and laid it carefully beside its mamma these three beings silence The time is past when Jacques and Jotte had only to play ac- cording to the sprightly lack of care of their young fancy. The master of Among reigned. their life is this child. Who knows if this story, too, may not be continued in our next? It is cer- tainly delightful and edifying reading for all, even for those who have been persuaded that Frenchmen have no word for Home. André Lichtenberger, writing for French readers, does not Nation consider such a question, or he might —“Our Monsieur, Madame, weil word is Fam- Bébé very answer ily, Ss. D NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES In 1895, Falconer Madan of the Bodleian Library published “The Early Oxford Press,” being a bibliography of printing and publishing in Oxford down to 164 H has now just issued, through the Clarendon Press, a second volume on the literature of Oxford, being a study, bibliographical and descriptive, of all known books relating to Oxford printed there and elsewher luring the two hundred years, 1450 to 1650 It is a grand piece of work, upwards of seven hundred pages, octavo, of which more than one-fifth is an e aborate index It will in terest few people in the United States, but those whom it interests it will interest deeply. The first 147 pages of the volume describe the books about Oxford, but printed else- where up to 1640, the end of the period covered by the first volume, being thus a supplement to that volume There are al- so incorporated in their chronological places additions and corrections to Vol. I The so-called first Oxford book Exposicio sancti Ieronimi,” the co ophon of which bears the printed date 1468, has long been a bone of contention among bibliographers the claim being made, and generally ac cepted, that the actual date was 1478, a lower-case “x” having dropped out in pre paring the types for the press, a not un- common occurrence in early-printed books As an Oxford maa Mr. Madan has been slow fully to accept this explanation. Here he sets down six reasons or arguments the acceptance of 1478 as the true dat ind “The ments may be adds: cogency of each of these weakened, but they have con siderable cumulative force, and at present although the onus improbandi lies entirely with the assai‘ants of the earlier date, the balance of probability is markedly against 1468.” This is a more positive state t than he was willing to make sixtes years ago. The bulk of the volume, pp. 148-499, ds scribes Oxford books fro 1641 to 1650 and in it Mr. Madan goes over entirely new ground During the four years, 1642 to 1646, when Oxford was the Royalist head quarters, the presses were peculiarly pro lific. The great collection of Civil War pamphlets col-ected by George Thomason (who was particular to put the date of r+ ception by him on the title-page of each pamphlet), now in the British Museum, has alone made possible any adequate descrip tion of the output of the presses of Oxford and London during this period. Duplicate editions, reprints, and forgeries add to the interest and complexity of the study of the books of the period, making a compar! son of types, devices, ornaments, and even water-marks necessary. Books with coun terfeit imprints were exceedingly common “Out of 191 Oxford imprints in 1642 ao leas Mr only slizht than 58 are London counterfeits,” says Madan, and the proportion is ly less in 1643 and 1644. A very plausib:e Oxford imprints are given which, in 1642-1647, are always counterfeit The symbol “,” prefixed to these counter- list of nineteen feit tles indicating that tl ~K Was | 1 wher it professes vas iadvertently | ! t xpianation i r iat \ sy bol nd i « tha lesignated s i i I i i work, was a | M M t nted out thes s i Mr Pollar f ! B ety \ ther t h ‘ the Oxford Press } G English Provincia Print Stat and Bookbinders to I " shed he Cambridge University IF: I rh papers compri Sa ires on bibliography 4 ed i bridge in 1911 The dat f ! hosen by Mr. Duff as a pectus because in that year harter granted to the re-formed Co many f St tioners, which prohibited printing person not a member of the La ciety, and this virtually put an cnd te al provincial printing Th following " list of those towns outside of London and Westminster in which printing presses had been established prior to 1557, with t ip proximate) date of the first book printed in each town Oxford. 1478 (colophon of c actually dated 1468 but probably a s print). St. Albans. 148! Hereford. 1505 Exeter 1506. York. 1509. Cambridge. 1521 Tavistock 1525 Abingdon. 1528 Ipswich, 1547 Worcester 1549 Canterbury. 1549 In an Appendix is ven a liet of all lentified books printed y or for the sev eral provincial printers for the period cov- red The little book (it is rublist 1 at four shillings net) contains interesting. author tive, and up-to-date format hard ) find elsewhere L. 3s. L. ) , . orrespondence THE PRESIDENTIAL TERM To THE Epttor oF THE NATION Sut The following letters ay be found in the Congressional Library, and ar 0 far as I know, unpublished Th may be f interest at a ti whe th proposal t limit the Presidential tenure to « ter rf six years is to the fore \ letter of Jefferson's, written fro September 20, 1 gives particulars of certain eived fror America He writes that ti Virginia Convention proposed an a i ent of the Constitution for rendering the President incapable of serving more than eight years in any ter of sixteen New York has followed the ample of Virginia, expressing the substanc: of her bill of rights (i. e., Virginia's), and proposing amendments These last differ much from those of Virginia, but they con- ur as to the President, only proposing that he shall be incapable of being elected mors than twice, but I own I should like better than either of these, what Luther Martin tells us was repeatedly voted and adhered to by the Federal convention, and only altered about twelve days before their rising when

Page 12

7 ) ror ff to that he d in wit ears an ometime ral years it Paris, Philadel I think rst Would it not ive this ld find it i benelhit be risM. Itiem arrogance nited States oppos versa t primary, 1—t gh not the likew courts and pro ! stopping the [Vol. 95, No. 2453 The Nation ’ world-wide We are witnessing great hanges everywhere, aud no erratic, blat- unt would-be despots are bringing them about The notion, then, that our salvation, in the United States, depends on Rooseveltisn: and a third party composed of soreheads, inbalanced egotists, oisy and shallow humbugs, and dreamers who know nothing of politics is grotesque Third parties innot live by spite, fury, and hatred 1lon They are begotten of necessity There is no necessity for a third party of the Roosevelt kind We may ndeed, find it necessary to organize a party pledged to fr trade, to economy, to peace, and rbitration, to sound irrency reform, to ist and scientific taxation, but toosevelt ynd his chief backers would find no wel- on 1 such a party The failure of the Democra to li ip to its principles and opportunities may r ler a third party ecessary Just now rothing calls for it rhe time is not ripe; there are no converts r 1its ready to take up the cause ol ial freedor ind justice, of equai portunit in the philosophical sense olf these terms. The rea! radicals will wait, 1 In the meantime they will help to de- tre Ro elti which is fatal to san- y, healt ind decency in politics and ver nt Ss. R ( June 26. GEORGE BORROW ro THE Epitror OF THE NATION: : \ ol who boped for a time to G Borro rmanently among hero and who still keeps him ex- lingly high on his list of extraordinary j f es I have read with great interest iccount of him in the Nation for June 7 Never having gone threugh any ex- led ography of Borrow, save that icl furnished in a way by his best known books I hoped to ind in your etch, not something that would add to wonder at the man, which till great ih, but somethit that would restore admiration for hi For admiratior l cred both left me in large meas- ire when I encountered the almost un- idabl creed of rage and spite with hich the Romany Rys draws to its end. Without being especially orthodox in a religious way I had been rather shocked, n reading The Bibl in Spain at the oat complete absence of «¢ lence that Rorrow cared for the Bible as such, or bad any higher motive for h tremendous il in distributing it than h's desire to jite the Pope and tl priests, and toe inder n their power Accordingly, 1 arched Lavengro” and Romany Rye,” hook written later, though they tell of irlier events in his life) for something that eould be called mn the best sense, Christian feeling I was disappointed, finding, indeed, a irvellous and refresh ne tory of adventurs whether fact ofr fiction. but a growing rabidness of com- ment. directed against any institution or ny person that had offended his over- powering vanity, a passion which, com- bined with love of the mysterious and the ngular, ruled his lif Ae to the fact that Borrow did not ex- press himeelf in the ordinary way con erning inanimate nature and the emo- |what other writers were tions aroused by’ its contemplation, I think well be doubted whether he knew in the habit otf saying on this or any other ordinary topic of literature. Outside those flelds of learn- ing which he especially exploited, he was, (ne may suspect, strikingly ignorant of current writing. In the thirty-second chapter of “Lavengro,” speaking of him- celf as a young man who has gone to Lon- den seeking his fortune, after a number ef years in a lawyer's office, he says: “Yes, : up to the moment of which I am speaking, I had never read a newspaper of any description.” Whether we have lost much by his habit- it may concerning the emotions and inspired him the templation of external nature, we perhaps judge a study the lowing passage, which J take, putting reticence reflections ual in by con- may fol- cer from of tain parts in italics, from the seventieth chapter of “Lavengro”: Night came on, and a beautiful nigh: it was; up rose the moon, and innumera- tle stars decked the firmament of heaven. I sat on the shaft [of his tinker’s cart], my eyes turned upwarés, I had found it there it was twinkling millions of miles above me, mightiest star of the system to which we belong; of all stars, the one whic has the most interest for me—the star Jupiter. Why have I elways taken an in- terest in thee, O Jupiter? I know noth- ing about thee, save what every child knows, that thou art a big star, whose only light is derived from moons. And is not that knowledge enough to make me feel en interest in thee? Ay, truly, I never look on thee without wondering what is going on in thee; what is life in Jupiter? That there is life in Jupiter, who cap coubt? There is life in our own little star, therefore there must be life in Jupi- ter, which is not a little star sut how different must life be in Jupiter from what it is in our own little star! Life here ta life beneath the deav sun—life in Jupiter ia life beneath moons—four moons—no ein- gle moon is able to illumine that vast bulk. All know what life is in our own little star; it is anything but a routine of happiness here, where the dear sun rises to us every day; then how sad and moping trust life be in mighty Jupiter, on which ra sun ever shines, cnd which is never lighted save by pule moonbeamse! The thought that there is more sadness and melancholy in Jupiter than in this world of ours, where, alas! there is but too much, has always made me take a melancholy in- terest in that huge distant star. EDWIN H. HALL Cambridge, Mass., June 28. THE DEATH OF BARON TAKASAKI, TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: The of Baron Takasaki, the laureate, or, to speak more chief of the poetry office, makes me awhile and think over what he always expressed in regard to poetry, that is, the Japanese ute poetry. He used to begin his talk by quot- ing Kageki Kagawa’s well-known phrase: “Uta wa sugata, sugata wa shirabe,” which is quite difficult to translate literally, but with permissible change of words will mean this: “It is the true poetry when its grace- ful the life- movement Baron said: “We have rashii (ook like); that is the secret of our Japanese utas. The flower-poem should look like a flower- poem, the moon-poem like a moon-poem, the Sir: death poet the pause recent Japanese exactly, appearance becomes at once or rhythm.” The a word | summer-poem like a summer-poem, the win-

Page 13

July 4, 1912] ter-poem like a winter-poem, and so on.” Such language is too delightfully simple, and, of course, he meant something more. When he said: “Be natural,” I believe that he put a great value on the moment when one’s rhythm of soul responds and vibrates most truly to the life and motion of nature; the chief merit of a writer as a poet lies in how well and constantly he has been preparing to receive such a mo- ment; it is indeed at such a moment that he will seize the universal in the par- ticular through the virtue of his own per- sonality. Our Japanese uta poetry, at least in Baron Takasaki’s idea and conception, is neither art nor writing, but one’s own personality itself; before you talk on poetry you should begin by making your personality refined, ennobled, and strength- ened And the time when your personality rises to be high and strange is when it i righteously led by humanity and arm-in- arm will dance with that humanity on life’s highway; therefore, the question o the Japanese uta poetry is the question of humanity. “There is no real poetry in meré words or phrases,” he always exclaimed He always talked of Uta no michi, or the path of poetry, as if to say the path of humanity or benevolence; and he often made the former mean the latter, and al- ways commingled them. Rightequsness was, in his mind, the very first lesson of poetry, without the support of which th delicacy and beauty of life and nature could not be property fe t, because the uta poetry was nothing but the way of mankind, that is of humanity. Although not from any so-called Imperial- ism, but from his immovable faith, so sin ple and pure that all Japanese should lov: their own native land, he was first of all the poet of patriotism; when he said h was sure that he was a real Japanese, | think he meant in his heart of hearts that, whi'e not so sure of being a poet, he was also a real poet from the fact of his be ing areal Japanese. His talk with the Em- peror, on “Nothing Difficult to Write Utas,” is a famous story; it happened some thir- ty-three or four years ago in the steamer sailing back from Kobe to Tokyo, which carried his Majesty the Emperor on board who, to pass his lazy summer-time away had been indulging in the thought of utas and the writing of them, and when the Baron interrupted him with the famous words, Nothing difficult to write utas,’ he was irritated and again maddened by this most audacious declaration. But it was the great lesson the Baron offered to the Emperor which made him gladly turn spiritualist in poetry from being a mere poetical rhetorician from that memorable day. It was the very first triumph of th Baron's long life that he made the Em- peror his believer; and the Emperor's faith was never shaken in the long years when the Baron occupied the honorable dais of the chief of the poetry office Indeed, he made a student’s obeisance to him I am not a fit person to criticise the Baron's poetical work; I am at the present moment only wondering what effect his cor ception will have on the future, as I and others know well enough that he battled hard against the descending tendency of the present age, and was often pessimistic, and even recognized his failure. YONE NoOGUCHI Kamakura, Japan, June 1 tition The N« RELIGIOUS PROPRIETY THE EpITor OF THE NATION: SIR According press reports re Cardinal Gibbons at ratic Convention at Baltin from the diy greeted with No one was applause that ine t will deny on the labors about to be begun by th Democratic delegates was eminently appro priate and desirable, but that men should have applauded the clergyman who uttered the prayer is incomprehensible to a person brought up in any of the commonly accept- ed religious creeds. Clapping of the hands, with us, at least, is universally recognized as an expression of approval of some a of a public performer. But it is difficult to see the appropriateness of applauding a supplication for God's blessing; unless. in deed, the audience is to be thought of as approving the clergyman’s manner of exe- cuting a detached acti in which they take no religious part. Theoretically, at least, when a person prays in public, he is the mouthpiece for the assembled worshippers who are humble suppliants with him and raving divine assistance At the conclusion of Cardinal Gibbons’s pplication to the Almight umen” we have learly signified concurrence and as- nt, but what on earth can have been the attitude, mental, moral, or spiritual. of a gathering of human beings who wi | uy their hands on such an occasior I L. ( MORSI Chicago, June 2¢ . Literature AMERICANISMS. in American Glossary: Being an at tempt to illustrate certain American isms upon historical principles B Richard H. Thornton of the Philadel] phia Bar. London: Fran & Co, 2 vols., pp. vii, 990, vi In 1774 a writer in a Boston proposed “a plan for perfect lish language in Amer Magazine ing the Eng ica, through every future period of its existence,’ and sug gested the formation of a society .“‘con sisting of members in each university and seminary, who s\all be stiled ‘Fel lows of the American Society of Lan and that “the publish some observations upon the guage, rich, and refine it, guage, Society annually lan and from year to year correct, en until perfec tion stops their progress and ends their labours.’ Six years later John Adams submitted tc the consideration of Congress “the expediency and policy of erecting by their authority a society under the name of ‘The American Academy for Refining, Improving, Ascertaining the Eng lish Language.” In 1781 a first attempt Americanisms Witherspoon of the and to discuss was made by President College of New Jersey, to whom, indeed, we debted for that the entered by De Vere, tut more in word field Pickering, Webster, Farmer, Norton, and than are Later was Bartlett, others a generation 11 has gone by since the publication of Bartlett's and De Vere’s books: both of those are unsatisfactory in many ways, and a new work was greatly to be dé sired. This has now made its appea ance in London A decade or so ago S James Murray complained in these umns that it was not t t! credit of . American lexicographers that they f to their English brethren so much wor) that ought to have been done by tl selves This well-deserved rebuk: s emphasized by the present work, which comes from the hand of an English by birth, though Americans can take at least some satisfaction in the fact that Mr. Thornton is an Am: in citize: “It would be difficult, and indeed possibl writes Mr. Thornton, “to cor struct a definition of an Am« an which should be comprehensive and con cise”; and he has ely refrained f making the attempt But in tl pilation he has included (1) fo f speech now obsolete or provinci I England, which survive In the United States, (2) words and phrases of d tinctly America origin (3) né which indicate quadrupeds, birds, t1 articles of food, ete., that are distinct ly American, (4) names of persons ! classes of perso! ind of plac« { words which have ed anew! ! ing, and (6) words and phrases of w! he has found earlier examples in Amer can than in Englis rite Mr. 7 I ton adds r) ef ' ical ‘ , ‘ ling! 1 t so per cent 1 ur half a « 1 y t n mad to } tpourings of r ’ it 1 who wisl t I Ada } ‘ i raft ! i wrige ia ircl ‘ ! But " and hra ul ” ! t st left althoug! ler ] belor +} eriod th } ter a backwood in The plan of the work is thus mad cleat At the end is a useful “Index of authorities cited,” filling six pages. Mr Thornton's illustrative extracts are drawn chiefly from five source period ical publications, books describing pio neer life, a few historical works, books of the “Jack Downing” type, and the de bates in Congress Those drawn from the last source are particularly valuable, as probably no one but the compiler has had the courage to attack the debates But it is to be regretted that letters, diaries, and journals—which would yield so much of value-—-have scarcely been used at all. It is to be noted also that extracts before 1765 are extreme! few and those few largely taken from the Oxford Dictionary We think it would have been better had these been omitted altogether, for they do not ade

Page 14

12 ~ iat illustrate American literary us- izes of the seventeenth and eighteenth nturies, and the space could better been devoted to more modern terms In the index of authorities cit- la a few mistakes No such publi- ca is the Boston Weekly Messenger as | ed in 1743. “F. Bailey” should l F. Baily J. Hall's “Letters from the West vere published in 1828, not 82 The author of “Short Patent Ser- mons, by Dow, Jr.,” was not E. T. Gerry, but Elbridge G. Paigs Why so many American authors in the second quar- ter of the last century wrote anonymous- ly or pseudonymously does not appear, und in regard to some of these Mr. Thornton is apparently in error or has neglected to give the proper names. Streaks of Squatter Life” was written by John S. Robb; “Some Adventures of Capt. Simon Suggs” and “The Widow Rugeby's Husband” by Johnson J. Hoop- ‘Chronicles of Pineville” and “Major Sketches of Travel” by William descriptive of “A Pleasant lones's T. Thompson; “Letters Virginia Springs” Peregrination through Prettiest Parts of Pennsylvania” Philip H Nicklin R. Carlton” was Baynard R. Hall; “Elnathan Elmwood” was Dr. Asa Greene: “Arthur Singleton” was Henry and the by the ( Knight And Seba Smith’s “Jack Downing Letters” have not been suffi- ciently differentiated from those written by Charles A. Davis rurning to the work itself, one finds though principle of selection is ecution to be admirable, Thornton's not always obvious Thus, he records j sla s but not anti-slavery; Jersey, but not York: Old Tenor, but not New ne And there are some notable i ons such, for instance, as Pil ‘ n Fathers and spotls system few ti occur to us igolia is a host-word, it being (as well as agelia) Mrackenridge error for ar@ali inti sf. as originally used, can hardly be described as “a name applied to the of Thomas Jefferson,” as Te i France when the Federal Consti tution is a vn up iuthor, meaning liter « publisher, should not have ! id tted as the word was so used England early in the eighteenth cen ' l'on bon up means not “to bristle i but to get up” a subject In his comment on Britisi Mi Thornton has been misled by Freeman, who was mistaken in supposing that Wesley could not have applied the name ‘Amer ican’ to the Eneliah folk of any of the Thirteen Colonies,” and that there was anything new in the use of the word British during the Revolution as ap plied to the royal army. Several years informed the re viewer that the Britieher was first applied to a British vessel. But it be added that the English were “Britishites” in this country in Brother Jonathan and Jonathan ago Sir James Murray word may called 1788 The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2453 = are really inseparable, and should have!terms and 15,000 extracts. Almost ex- head, but Mr. Thornton has missed an opportunity of showing that the former term had no- thing to do with Gov. Jonathan Trum- bull of Connecticut. We not know why to condition is labelled “originally Yale word,” since the earliest example ; from a Harvard source. Under ell or L, the elevated railway is not recogniz- ed. May not ganty be a misprint for genty, and goss for cos? (Printers were no more infallible then than now: in the Boston Gazette of July 25, 1768, Ed- Winter “Lecturizing which became “Electurizing Rods” on August 8, and “Electrical Rods” on August 15). No example of Jayhawker is given as a nickname for of Kansas. The statement that johnny-cake was “originally jour- ney-cake” we think, a mistake, as johnny-cake occurs earlier; but that it- self is doubtless a corruption of jonakin, found in 1676. The Boston Lib- erty Tree was not “the great elm on Boston Common,” but stood at the cor- ner of Washington and Essex Streets. Under Mecklenburg Declaration a warn- ing should have been uttered in regard The first extract been treated under one do ward advertised Rods,” a native is, a form tc its genuineness. under O. K. should have been dated 1850, not 1828. It is not true that “a bird which lives outside the dictionaries,” for it in several dic- tionaries under the spelling ph«be. Poppycock means “nonsense,” “rubbish,” rather than “bombast.” Scalage is la- belled “Not in the Century Dict.,” but it will be found’ in the two volumes issued in 1909. It should have been explained that Scophilites were so called from one Schofield), who had been commissioned by Gov: Tryon of North Carolina to suppress the Regula- In the first extract under to slick, phebe is is Scovil (Schovel or tors the word means not “to make smooth” or “to set in order,” but to beat or Iivnch, a sense of the word apparently the dictionaries, occasionally met with between 1825 and The significance of some et the extracts under terrapin is missed from Mr. Thornton's failure to point out that the word was applied in derision to nor recognized in though 1850 Jefferson's gunboats. Attention is called to these matters, mostly trifling, in order that corrections What that made in a second edition. dictionary may be is greatly needed is a shall illustrate American literary usages for three centuries, but such a work can be compiled only on the codperative plan, a plan but for which the English Dialect Dietionary and the Oxford Dic- tionary would have been impossible; and it is to be hoped that the present volumes will act as a spur to the mem- bers of the American Dialect Society. Meanwhile, Mr. Thornton has placed us under the deepest obligations for his “American Gloesary,” in which single- actly a century ago a Philadelphian said: “I wish to see the list of our Americanisms abridged as much as pos- sible.” If there are at the present time any who hold this narrow view, they would do well, for their own peace of mind, to avoid the present work, for it is filled with expressions many of which are vigorous, effective, picturesque, and racy of the soil. CURRENT FICTION. Wide Courses. By James Brendan Con- nolly. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. At his best, Mr. Connolly tells his stories with vigor and directness. Even when he falls below par, as in “Light ship 67” and “Captain Blaise’ of the present collection, he is still readable. “The Wrecker,” which stands first, is not entirely successful, though it contains one haunting phrase which comes honest- ly by its Celtic blood, “Who's to deny a woman whose son lies drowned?” ‘“‘Lay- ing the Hose-Pipe Ghost” is an amusing tale of Navy red-tape, told in a kind of subdued slang that adds much to the effect. “Jan Tingloff’’ is more serious, and the things that happen to him have an air of grim reality. The descrip- tion of the old side-wheeler foundering in a gale is extraordinarily vivid. But the best of this volume is to be found in the two stories dealing with Kieran, pump-man on an_. oil-tanker — Don Quixote Kieran, alias Cogan Capeador. Here Mr. Connolly does more than tell a tale; Kieran has a personality, human, attractive, and Wander- fever, or romance, or the spirit of ad- venture (the name does not matter) drives him from one end to the other of the seven seas. Athlete, Navy man, wind- jammer, bull-fighter—there are few things he has not been. He also com- poses chanties and sings them along the decks in spite of the opposition of the bruising bosun. The latter swore Kieran would never dare finish his Flying Wal- rus song; one day the deck-hands made a ring (while the Captain looked other way) and stood around to watch Kieran being killed. But it was the bosun who soused his damaged head in a bucket after the fight, and Kieran forebore to finish the Flying Walrus be- cause he thought that would be rubbing it in. picturesque. 50 the The Béhme, by Ethel Colburn Mayne. D. Appleton & Co. This “novel of to-day” is a lengthy, continuous exposition of conditions good and bad in a department store in Berlin. With German thoroughness the Department Store. By Margarete Translated from the German New York: | writer begins long before the beginning. tanded he has recorded about 3,000| We must follow the love affairs of the '

Page 15

July 4, 1912] The Nation parents of a girl who later becomes saleswoman in the store, their deaths and her adoption. We must be made acquainted with her adopted parents and their previous histories; with the neighborhood and its little home indus- tries and shops, before we are fitted to assist at the founding of the great store built up modern-wise on the declining opportunities of small dealers and ar- tisans. The “obviously ungifted” boy Joshua Manassa develops as he grows up the commercial genius on which the house is founded, and stands through- out the most striking figure in the book. A Jew, who for expediency changes his surname, a man who never lets feelings interfere with business, a lavish giver where his interests will not suffer, a moralist, and a man of absolute self-control, his god is “the holy spirit of labor, of progress.” “Like the spirit of God upon the face of the water, did his direct influence hover over the whole concern.” One of his sons begins life with idealizing notions of what may be done in a great commercial establish- ment, but time and a visit to America make havoc of his half-Socialistic ideas and their influence survives only in an art department, where three-colored pho- tographs and antiques are sold. The salesgirl in this department represents fidelity and enthusiasm, and, of course, wins a _ substantial matrimonial re- ward. For the rest, the characters are merely all engaged in intrigues, great and small, commercial and sentimental, for which, indeed, Joshua “does not stand,” but which pervade his shop and his circle. The rise of the vast empor- jum, its triumph over rivals, and its embracing in one or another capacity all the little workmen and _ work- women whom it had put out of busi- ness, is told in minutest detail. It is one long, sumptuous catalogue of fur- nishings, bargain sales, elaborate win- dows, intricate advertisings. These and the sorry heart-affairs of chiefs and un- derlings are the story. It is itself a huge show-window, which shows, 4s- suredly, but does not teach. The trans- lation in the main flows smoothly; a few palpable snags need not be particu- larized. We take it that it is not the translator who imports from the West Indies “a live, beauteous, almond-eyed Hindu.” stern ——=2 The Lone Adventure. By Halliwell Sut- cliffe. New York: George H. Doran Co. We may hope that this adventure will remain lone, for it is very wearisome. A large part of the book can be sum- med up in one of its phrases, “And still nothing happened.” The author has at- tempted to write in the style of Maurice Hewlett a romance of the Jacobite ris- ing of 1745. But there is something more in Mr. Hewlett’s style than odd words, inversion, and tortured meta- phors; there is imagination. Take that away, and the remains would resemble the style of Mr. Sutcliffe. He to work on the theory that “terror and pity may be caused by diction.” He determined to write in figures, and the result sometimes like this his soul was launched into the seems is is “Since Open sea of life, Rupert had known many a Geth- The extraordinary of plot and the deliberate eccentricity of could be forgiven if interest in character. times the hero, who justly under the scholar, passes through semane.” vacancy style there were any Five or six has suffered un reproach of being a a psychological experience which proves to him that he is & man; left yet the reader is uncon vinced. ¥ The Yoke of Silence. New York: G. P. A tidy little love story setting By Amy McLaren Putnam's Sons. in a Scottish There are glimpses of an old castle with an oubliette and seaward- looking terraces; there are a husband and wife parted by a woman unscrupu- lous in and as to money; there are doubts and fears and meet- ings and partings and peace-makings. There are a few Scottish folk of marked personality, a nice baby, and a perfect- ly appointed yacht. Need more be said? love worse TWO BOOKS ON GEN. LEE. Lee the American. By Gamaliel Brad- ford, jr. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. With illustrations. $2.50 net. Robert E. Lee, Man and Thomas Nelson Page. Charles Scribner’s Sons. trait and maps. $2.50 net. Each of these books is very good of its kind, but perhaps the greatest value or each lies in the testimony it bears to the charm of Lee’s character and to the growth of his reputation as one of the very noblest figures in American his- tory. Naturally, from this point of view, special value attaches to Mr. Bradford's beok on account of the writer's North- ern birth and affiliations. It was to be expected that Gen. Lee would be a spot Soldier. By New York: With por- less hero to Mr. Page; it is more im- pressive to learn that he is quite as spotless a hero to Mr. Bradford. It is the latter who writes, “I have loved him, and I may say that his influence upon my own life, though I came to him late, has been as deep and as inspiring as any I have ever known. If I convey but @ little of that influence to others who will feel it as I have, I shall be more than satisfied.” Mr. Bradford will doubtless have his modest wish granted, and perhaps he will obtain another desire that stands out from his book. He is a devotee of the art of “psychography,” the portrayal of souls, and Sainte-Beuve is his master. He actually adds to his book an inter- esting, though possibly a 13 superfluous, entitled “Lee and This means that appendix Psychog raphy.” his volume is not a straightforward, formal biography, but a group of chapters under such titles as Lee Before the War, Lee and his Army, Lee in Battle, and the like Each chapter is, in the main, made up of quotations bearing on the central topic and of comments upon thes citations and comments being excellent for their purpose Indeed, Mr. Krad tord seems thoroughly entitled to t praise of being a master in lit mosaic-work Whether a grouping mosaic chapters into a mosa volu furnishes a book that one puts d with entire satisfaction, whether method is not fitter for the essay than for the treatise, ambitious or unam! tious, whether psychography, as its ex ponents practice it, real are questions probably answer according to one's ten perament. Mr. Bradford's ic sufficient to say and wide sympathy Lee and the people he represented, and exceptional literary and psychological acumen Mr. Page's book the long-tried, straightforward type of biography, giv- ing a full, chronological, eulogistic, and apparently accurate account of his hero's career. It was begun as an en- larged edition of the writer's “Robert E. Lee, the Southerner,” but it soon grew into a new book, especially through largely increased emphasis upon mili- tary details. The result is a volume which ought to satisfy for a long time the demand for a fairly extensive biog- raphy of Gen. Lee, sympathetic, popular in the and on the most trustworthy military authorities on both sides. Mr. Page's practice as a trained narrator has stood him in good stead; he knows and loves the South, and he has made what seems us to be a very competent and conscientious study of the available sources of infor- mation. There little career prior to the Civil War, but the treatment of the four years of struggle sufficiently full to satisfy quirements, amounting as it does to five hundred pages. Excellent summarizing chapters precede and follow this stretch will ever vield us portraits, one will chapters, it here, show careful study of the sources, great with is best sense, based to is emphasis upon Lee's most re- is of military narrative; then we «have equally good chapters on Lee’s charac- ter and on the calm close of his life. Throughout, the writer's spirit is attun- ed to that of his subject, and there is partisan that can arouse opposition in a fair-minded read- In other words, while disagreement Mr. Page is permissible, heated controversy with him possible. We have made a long stride forward towards true national unity when such a statement is suggested by a book as loyally pro-Southern as this searcely a sentence er. with ought to be im-

Page 16

Nation ‘The ne and in its leve » li ju villages at I ch i essary and possible, work ra gray | but led bh When I ft Burma ] e add it, in j dg ] I had » surren hat s perhaps ! g hor Very p il mtribution, not ) ’ ' ! wild Ife kn d is to our man > a sagil ibjec viz., in By the spring of 1888 pacification had t tl f that t great- advanced so far that it was possible to iract und achis nent consider the reduction of the troops and I the 1 ilt of the their replacement by military police ul the aristocrat Early in 1886 these police numbered the consummate about 3,300, in 1888 between 5,000 and 6,000, in 1889 about 18,000, and in 1912 about 15,000. The rapid change of con ditions in 1887 is shown by the fact that rtOn ; B o it the beginning of the year the troops ; . York: held 142 and the police 50 posts, where- 4.00 net at the end of the year the figures were to tl 84 and 175, respectively On October I t 28 the same year the Village Regula tion Act is passed, which Dy ' ! ul t t ancient of Upper \ h ons l l i hit ( ! ] { t law | I t 1 bilit of ] tain i s ! I r to i , i to reside : 1iding and l i i rt nact ' ra sf accordance empire t t t i ist y law and with the It strengthened our hand or ind gave s a tighter grip on , . anything el uuld have In 1888 the process of disarming the natives was begun, and in the same year Burma definitely became a frontier province of the Indian Empire There were, however, a number of , ‘© outlying districts which demanded at ' ADOUL 14,0 tention, notably the Shan States, long ke ref, 1551, ©O torn by internecine strife. As the suc a t Bad been in essor of the Burmese State, England ab nSIS’ felt herself in duty bound to control all . "5! the territory that had been lawfully bl nd claimed by Burma. Accordingly, late in The ' is ultimat i886 the reduction of the Shan States i to | ' At fir Inder | was begun. the general policy being as 1 to be} follows ‘ i n bet n Le I plainin the principle which ; the we l ] ! British Govert t in it relat the I writt tl var : pit ' hief rm 5 " l | ha there | nk I . . » interfer i t! rnal VOY I f ) Stat Brit wy ' first great vledged, peace must be pre i is tl | 1, t t not be oppr ed r | ! i} } onditions and t the pa dif ‘ of a moderat tribute tt British ( 1 t undertool t ! the +] »w hiefal } j efre ation nm, to uphold U righ and ‘duall and t! Ly for co rhe i int tion of : oda fiehting tl har On tl trar t wa red » win thel ndahiy ind to in ! t} to tru Alr ly the duties 1] iene t nd mor hict trangled ! 5 trad in the King time had been swept i away It remained to establish peace and as yen tl trade rout which the prevall [Vol. 95, No. 2453 ing anarchy had closed. The leaders of the expedition were to take every precaution against giving avoidable offence or trouble to the people, to gain the goodwill of chiefs, priests, and villag- rs, to interfere as little as might be with their prejudices, their religious houses, and their private life (pp. 147-149) Meanwhile there constant guer- rilla fighting, and the difficulties of the English were enormously increased by the of the Dis- trict after district was reduced to peace and order. was configuration country. In some cases, as in that of Kentung, Siamese intrigue had to be counteracted; elsewhere China had to be considered, particularly in view of the large number of Chinese in Upper Burma. All this time the still more difficult tasks of civil organization pro the building of roads and official ceeded apace railways, the buildings, forest provision medical aid, and the like. The of the new administration may be gaug ed by the fact that, without the levying construction of surveys, of success of a single additional tax, the revenu of Upper Burma rose from £222,000 in 1886-87 to £1,120,000 in 1888-90. A chronological conspectus might with advantage have been appended to the book, and there are one or two disturb- ing errors and omissions. Some of these The context shows, are easy to correct for example, that Sir Charles left Ran- goon on February 27 instead of March 27 (p. 24), and it is obvious that the capital of India has not lately been mov- ed from Delhi to Calcutta (p. On the other hand, there passages in- volving a manifest error which cannot corrected. Thus, according to p. 265, Lieut. Hawker was mortally wounded at Muklon on February 21, but on p. 267 the place and date are given as Mukton and March 15, respectively. The disturbing feature of such oversight is that it arouses mistrust to the accuracy of other specific places and 76). are so be some as dates. History of Relation to Raper. $1.50 Railway Transportation: A Its Economics and of Its the State. By Charles New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons net. Lee the of systematic In 1885 appeared from pen President Hadley the first American treatise on railway transpor- In its marshalling of clear enunciation of principles, tation. concise facts, it its brilliant and incisive style, this book But has been made has not been surpassed because so much railway history during the last quarter-century, a dition was desirable. nouncement on the title-page of Profes- sor Raper’s book, that it is based with new Hence the an- author's permission upon President “Railroad Transportation,” the expectations of those fa- the earlier work. But the learns his disappoint- the Hadley'’s aroused miliar with reader soon to

Page 17

July 4, 1912] ment that this book is Hadley with Had-| ley left out. In the first place, the emphasis has been changed. Whereas President Had- ley gives only five out of thirteen chap- ters to foreign ccuntries and lays stress upon our own history, intermingling with his historical treatment his brilliant elucidation of fundamental principles, Professor Raper gives but five out of seventeen chapters to the United States, and these are the least valuable chapters in the book. In the matter of style the contrast is so marked as to be almost distressing Unhappy choice and actual of words repeatedly mar the text, and the constant repetition of such adverbs “wonderfully,” “tremendously,” “vitally,” misuse as detracts from the effectiveness of the discussion. Such inventions as “trans portational” and “damageability” are hard to forgive. We are confronted with such terms as “densely populated peo- ple,” “important significance,” “increas- ingly slight,” and “inefficiently cheap.” We are told that the “length of their haul is very short,” that the railways have caused places of raw materials, of manufacture, and of consumption “to be brought into unity”; that no important area of the United States is without the choice of a number of market centres “around which the minor markets all rotate,” and that Berlin was not the centre “from which the Prussian lines originated or focalized.” Poor sentence structure often obscures the author’s meaning, and a habit of throwing the verb to the end of the sentence disturbs the reader’s equanimity. The chapters on the United States, so far as they relate to the period previous to 1885, are distinctly inferior to those of Hadley, and the treatment of the la- ter period lacks distinction. The author seems erroneously to identify the dis- tance principle of rate-making with the cost of service principle. He states that the long and short haul clause of the Interstate Commerce Act forbade a greater charge for a shorter than for a longer distance on traffic moved in the same direction at the same time. It is, of course, untrue that the shipments must be contemporary. It is difficult to understand how our transcontinental traffic has been “profoundly influenced by the steamers that operate through the Suez Canal.” : The value of the book consists in its summary of recent European transporta- tion history. One may differ with the author’s conclusions as to the results of policies in the various States, and may properly take exception unsubstan- tiated opinions introduced by the phrase think,” but the historical treat- seems general to be carefully to “we in Many statistical comparisons of ment done. European and American conditions fail to give the lack of comparability of data, and hence leave due recognition to The Nation the reader with inaccurate impressions. It is impossible, for example, with the different accounting to pare accurately relative costs of opera tion, rates of dividends, or capitalization systems, com- per mile. Confusion is also caused by the use of the term average rate when the author clearly means averag: ceipts. On the question of State ownership Professor Raper is a conservative His conclusions are that government owne! ship, with a few notable exce ptions, has the ticularly « been a burden on taxpayers, that it has ‘especially the United States do not desire at ent the h necessary for not been “par ficient’ or cheap,” that the people of pres ghly centralized to “possess” administration nationaliz ation, that Government oper needed the United facilities or to correct ation not in States to supply the abuses of pri vate operation, and that its “only possi ble defence would be Socialism.” He: suggests in the place of State operation the extension of the parcels post in the United States, but his brief discussion of this subject is superficial and fails to take account of many factors in the problem. Desert. By Francis Herbert & Dan- Iralys War for a McCullagh. London: iel. The note struck by Mr. McCullagh in his very title is maintained to the last page. It isa bitter indictment of Italy's motives and methods in her invasion of Tripoli. The Italian people, the press, the navy, the army, are handled with no pretence at In his introduc- tion Mr. McCullagh tells of being visit- ed in his English home by a party of courtesy. Italian gentlemen, headed by the “fu- turist’’ leader, Signor Marinetti, who challenged the author to a duel. We can very well believe that the hot Ital- ian blood must have boiled repeatedly under the pitiless scourging administer- ed by Mr. McCullagh, whose reputation as a veteran war correspondent was sure to give weight to his charges. He ridi- cules the Nationalist movement in Italy, which, in the mind of its most fervent advocates, has taken on the aspect of a crusade for the restoration of the Ro man Empire. He takes delight in draw- ing comparisons between Scipio Afri- canus and the half-disciplined Sicilian troops who have again and again turned in cowardly flight before an enemy vast- ly inferior to them in numbers and equipment. The spirit of the following sentences permeates the book: rT? real ’ Y I Ita ; j f; , ] ; ‘ ; } ul é AY ding bh it | ent stor D ] j ~ 15 planned. Mr. McCullagh begins by con ‘eying the impression of extreme preju- dice He carries it to the point where many a reader will be tempted to put down the volume with distrust. But if the reader persists until he comes to the heart of the book, the massacre of the suburban Arabs perpetrated by the panic-stricken Italians during the three days following the battle of Sharashett on October 23, of last vear, his attitude towards the ithor ill change Here the accusation of prejudice will not hold Mr. MecCullagh’s own statements are reinforced by a mass of irrefutab] testimony As one reads the irt-rend ing story of those dreadful thre davs when the Italian army ised to b in irmy and became a horde of maddened soldiery, virtually runnin amuck; of men and women and children who were shot down in squads without semblance o a trial, one can easily understand why Mr. McCullagh and several of his colleagues should hav anded in their papers to the Italian commander as a protest. Four thousand Arabs perished during these three days, according to our writer. Three thousand is the tes timony of French correspondents friend ly to the Italian cause. One feels that Mr. McCullagh has made out a case. But he could have made it stronger by not stopping to pick fault with anything and everything Italian Frank Hamel. $3 75 net la Fontaine. By New York: Brentano's The first lines of Mr book are more sympathetic than all the rest; in them he tells the of the little girl who tried to say the Lord's Prayer in French, and haunted by the fable of the fox, the of cheese, began “Notre sur un arbre perché.” Turning then to the slim events of Fontaine's tranquil life, Mr. Hamel forth in a straightforward and unpretending fash- ion which reading, but which does not quite satisfy. With no sharp vision of La Fontaine's personal ity, and with little distinction of style, he manages to indicate some clearness the exterior surroundings But There is hardly any crit- illuminating comment. It Jean de Hamel's story being crow, and the piece Pére La them sets makes easy yet with and ma- scarcely man 8s terial he goes further. ical study or is simply a relation of facts, with a cer tain number of anecdotes for embellish ment. Mr. Hamel apparently takes these last directly from d’Olivet, “le pauvre abbe,”’ whom M. Lafenestre calls one of the least clairvoyant of La Fontaine's biographers It was d’Olivet who said the poet was an idiot because |} never n life did anvyt f ap propriately As f the letters I n, Mr Hamel finds t lisa I FA : d ! e of tl il be T t the

Page 18

16 sense of the term There is no jutpouring of emotion on paper ad d to one woman and containing a and lasting pas contain nothing ndly feell How a Fontaine ng and could it passion in real self inter vho had light and Mr un poet ’ a sympathet he calls La Fontaine bumpkin” as he country rm “old reprobate” lat Roth these expressions, in an at iated iy have some applica but sense, Mi they dreamer in Fontaine of both miss La the woods full of at a young ears old who still au-Thierry with his the table pretty nes, Or merry man dinner loses his the Hamel's girl sitting next to like the which the ifter a check, slips When it comes to discussing lack of The “Contes” reprieve. It told, em. They are mentioned only because to words are through a sieve momentary isé works, this sympathy be- comes plainer are con- is not to demned without nec- ssary, we are for us read necessary Hamel wish- preserve the in- the not quoted the passage from “Les Oies Philippe,” for its natural effect more of a deliciously human. The the “Fables” are little more a catalogue, interspersed with quo- and translations. Elizur Wright, are commonplace, though an for one by the from the fable of his first cat, his of biography it is But if Mr morals from them i to our fluence of “Contes,” he should have du Frére to make one wish to know matter so two chapters on than paraphrases, at, mostly by and 1 may be made Lucas Collins who ee uns mouse in his innocence affinities of soul his ears are shaped trong Hamel d almost entire- interpretat’on human nature well more im ediate references to the court of Louls 1V and the soclety of the century. His m the subject are perfect- Taine, in his complete and brilliant development of this theme, llustrates from the fables the king, the princes, the court, the nobility, the curé, the the magis- professor, student, the peasant Mr. Hamel something else: “A wonderful procession of anl- mals stalks through the fables, almost ry kind of zodlogical specimen being regards of as fables is the few remarka ¢ ’ conventional doctor, the the bourgeols, trate, the seC8R ve represented. The Nation [Vol. 95, No. 2453 There are rats enough to require the services of many Pied Pip- ers of Hamelin, lions enough stock the equatorial forests, wolves enough to make the Steppes of Russia seem crowd- ed, bats and birds, gnats and frogs ga- lore To fair, let add that he to say that the poet “modern- old animal stories “to the ex- them the manners All the social or- ders represented classified.” But for the central fact of La Fontaine’s poetry, is not this statement rather bare to be us goes ized tent on the of reflecting in and foibles of his day. were and summary? book is thick which to a great There is photogravure frontispiece, and there are and The extremely 380 pages excellent printed on its an paper, swells size. a number of prints. Notes National Education Association will in Chicago July 6 to 12 “Retrospections completed in the Doubleday, John Bigelow’s Life” the publication of Volumes IV years 1867 to 1871, and Volume The of an At late tive will be autumn by by Page & Co IV covers the Vv, 187f to 1879 and V. Volume The same in hand: “Browning and His Helen A, Clarke; ‘Reminiscences of the South Seas,” by John being the diary which the artist and Fiji; “A&sop’s Arthur Rackham. house has Century,” by Farge, while in La kept Fables,” Samoa illustrated by The Century Company will publish in Au- gust “C. Q., or In the by Arthur Train, and later in the year “A Ro- Hill,” by Alice Hegan Wireless House,” mance of Billy-Goat Rice. Sir Archibald Geikie, Royal Society of London, has monograph on “The Love of Nature Among the Romans” in the the Re- public and the first century of the Empire The work will be issued by Murray. Allen H. Eaton is bringing out, McClurg, “The Oregon System: The Story of president of the written a last decade of through Direct Legislation in Oregon.” A forthcoming book in the list of Stanley Paul & Co. is “The White Slave Market,” by Mrs. Archibald Mackirdy Mr. Willis, who formerly a member of the Aus- and was tralian Parliament “The Cahusac Sturgis & Walton; the author is H Prichard Jane Addams’s “The Spirit of Youth and the City Streets,” first in the autumn of 1909, has just been added to the Standard Library. announced by Hesketh Mystery” is published Macmillan The Newdigate prize at Oxford has been awarded this year to William Chase Greene | of Balliol College, Rhodes scholar from Massachusetts, for a poem on “King Richard First Before Jerusalem.” Mr. Greene class odist and salutatorian at Har- 1911 the was vard in a grandson chester, for many years publisher of the He is a son of Prof. Herbert | E. Greene of Johne Hopkins University, and of William L. Greene of Dor- | | appendix containing extracts from Ameri- Congregationalist. The Newdigate prize of twenty-one guineas for English verse was founded by Sir Roger Newdigate in 1806, is open for competition each year by undergraduates of Oxford University. Among those who have won the prize are Matthew Arnold, Robert Stephen Hawker, Oscar Wilde. and John Addington Symonds. and the “The Symbolism of Voltaire’s Novels” (Columbia University, Lemcke & Buechner), W. R. Price, is a detailed investigation, to “Zadig,” of contemporary social by reference of an to make the veiled allusions The to characters, political allegory the Voltaire with special Voltaire’s satire conditions, and attempt, by ingenious tive work clear and identify to lete« specific. author seeks names, hints, fit the to show Dr. thing which for another thing for other things.” A field is thrown open to a mind ingenious at solving rebuses or charades, and this sort of mind Dr. Price The book shows industry and learning based on a thorough of Voltaire. The cenclusions, how- ever, cannot rely for acceptance on abso- lute proof, but only on probability, and the reader is sometimes left wondering whe- ther the writer is not carried away by the explorer’s enthusiasm. One of the most in- teresting passages relates to the origin of the name “Voltaire.” The volume is cleare ly a dissertation, not pretending to liter- ary form, and, unfortunately, the author's erudition has not petent proof-reading at the press. times; in talking and to short, what was about. Price uses symbolism as “any- or thus stands wide possesses. study been seconded by com- Under the title “World Organization Affected by the Nature of the Modern State,” Dr. David Jayne Hill has pub’ish- ed eight lectures given at Uni- versity, in March, 1911, on the Carpentier Foundation (Columbia University The purpose of the lectures, which are both historical and critical, is to “the growth of juristic consciousness among all civilized nations,"’ and “the peculiar adap- tability of the modern state for entering into a world organization in a juristic sense.” What form such organization shall take, Dr. Hill does not pretend to indi- cate in detail; but he reaches the conclu- sion that the usual and accepted princip!es of jurisprudence are sufficient for the ad- judication of all international disputes; that substantial progress has been made, through the various Hague agreements, in the direction of universal justice among rations, and that the development of a “society of states’’ presents no insupera- ble difficulties. Disarmament appears to him to be a natural result of such ganized international relations, rather than an ideal to be striven for as such The book is not easy reading, but it is, never- theless, one of the most thoughtful of re- cent contributions to the difficult subject of international conciliation. as Columbia Press). show or- “Replanning Small Cities,” by John Nolen, fellow of the American Society of Land- scape Architects (Huebrch), is made up of a general survey of the subject, studies of six American cities from this point of view— namely, Roanoke, Va.; San Diego, Cal.; Montclair and Glen Ridge, N. J.; Reading, Pa., and Madison, Wis.—a section on how existing cities may be replanned, an

Page 19

July 4, 1912] can and foreign legislation relating to the matter, and a bibliography modestly de- scribed as a “Short List.” The illustra- tions are especially interestine. They in- clude the bay front of San Diego as it is, and as proposed, general plans for Read- ing and Madison, and L’Enfant’s plan of Washington. Mr. Nolen points out that the notion that comprehensive plans are only for large cities is a misconception, the re- verse being nearer the truth: “There is scarcely anything in the smaller places that may not be changed.” To the movement to make such changes his book should give definite impetus. Prof. Alexander Viets Griswold Allen, who has been made the subject of a me- moir (Longmans), by the Rev. Charles Lewis Slattery, rector of Grace Church, New York, was born in 1841 in Otis, Mass., where his father was rector of the Episco- pal church. The home was filled with the best traditions of New England evangel- icalism—its seriousness, its consecration, its culture; filled, also, with what so often ac- companied these, a hard struggle for an ex- istence. After strenuous financial efforts, Alexander Allen was graduated at Kenyon College, Gambier, O., and entered the Di- vinity School, in the same place. In his time the insurgent wave of modernism was just beginning. He kept, however, his fundamental beliefs, his passion for truth, his sweetness of temper, and his closeness to his parents. After two years spent in Andover Theological Seminary, he founded a little Episcopal mission ehurch among the mill-hands of the neighboring Lawrence. The enterprise was success- ful, but his characteristic work was yet to come. In 1867 the Episco- pal Theological School was established in Cambridge, Mass., and the Lawrence rector was called, at the age of twenty-eight, to be its first professor of ecclesiastical] his- tory. Those who were in his class-room almost always awoke with surprise to a realization of the vitality of the past. Dog- ma was to him concentrated life, needing but expansion to become living and ab- sorbingly interesting. And so his greatest book was appropriately “The Continuity of Christian Thought.” Other books followed —a “Life of Jonathan Edwards,” ‘Re- ligious Progress,” “Christian Institutions,” “Freedom in the Church.” After the death in 1893 of Phillips Brooks, his brother, Dr. Arthur Brooks, undertook a Life of the Bishop; and when Arthur Brooks died two years later, Professor Allen was asked to complete the work. The last of the three volumes appeared in 1900. It) was an appreciation of Phillips Brooks rather than a critical estimate. This, with twenty-eight articles contributed to books, papers, and magazines, complet- ed Professor Allen's literary output. He delivered the Bohlen lectures in Philadel- phia, Lowell lectures in Boston, Dudleian and Noble lectures at Harvard, besides lec- turing in the regular courses at Harvard and in Union Theological Sem'nary, York. He received the degree of D.D. from Kenyon College, and from Harvard and Yale Universities. He died in Cambridge in 1908. Dr. Slattery had the difficult task of telling a story where, in popular estima- tion, there was none to tell. For a life| with so little incident presents to the bi- | ographer few peaks to which to attract | New The Nation passing attention. Yet for those who are concerned with the movements of thought, a career which, like that of this seminary professor, was in close touch with every vital current of his time, has no need of events in order to procure profound in- terest. And Dr. Slattery has wisely made Professor Allen's letters largely tell the story. “Outlines of School Administration” (Macmi-lan), by Arthur C. Perry, is an at- tempt to put in form for textbook use the present methods of school administration in the various nations which have made really significant progress in public edu- cation. The matter is placed under five headings, school organization, school direc- tion, school supervision, echool manage- ment, and class management, the methods in vogue in the various countries being grouped about these several topics. As a textbook on comparative methods, one might wish that the books were tured with the personal! bias of the author on various problems involved. “The Criminal and _ the (Lane), by James Devon, has a sonal flavor which it contrast to the literature of impersonal criminal science. Dr. Devon is the of all institutionalism and of all study of men by the method of statistics and aver- ages. For him the criminal is first of all a person, and such thoroughly known is a better basis for a study of the subject than any He himself speaks from the authority of many years of personal experience as medical officer in Scotch prisons and poorhouses, which he utilizes for a highly instructive, less tinc- Community” rare refreshing per- makes a enemy “one case amount of tables.” and evidently clear-sighted. account of the motives and conditions of crime, more particularly of the conditions leading to petty crime and first offences. The striking feature of the book is his proposal to lib- erate prisoners when responsible citizens offer to become their guardians. Arguing from a purely utilitarian standpoint, Dr Devon contends that imprisonment is a flat failure. It is not very effective as a de- terrent, and no useful purpose is served by the prisoner's degradation. The prison may sometimes benefit his health, but it en- feebles his mind and at the end of his sen- tence sends him out into the world without an occupation, often without friends, and wholly unfitted for communal life. Its only use is to hold him until provision has been made for his supervision and livelihood; and if no such provision is made, it is absurd to release him at all. However re- formed and improved, the prison suffers from the of institutionalism; and the same is true of the system of liberation on probation in charge of an officer. The nor- mal life of a man is in the society of those who are personally interested in him, pre- ferably in a family. What Dr. Devon con- tends for, then, is the policy of boarding out which has been found to be successful in the case of pauper children and the in- sane. He thinks that there are few crim- inals without friends who would be willing to assume their charge At any rate, he holds, the problem of crime is insoluble until those in the outside com- munity are ready responsibility. vice responsible to assume a personal To show what is the difference between the Scottish and the English peoples may =~ é 1 fairly be said to be the object of Dr. Don ald Macmillan’s “Short History of the Scot tish People” (Doran) It tempt at a pendant Green's History,"’ and, like its prototype, is to the greater glory ef its subject Not n years ago it would have been to the glory of the Kirk and the Covenant; as it is, the ecclesiastical thread is followed And there was right in truth ‘p. 301) which the of Scotland than any other, it But the Kirk and historically of work- ie an a to Short any closely it. It “It people ie said with perfect there is one institution ought to love the Church of Scotland.” the fallen evil is now more is on the “quietly have and so it whom have a picture, ing out their own salvation while kings and lords were destroying each other" (p. 194). And the judgment of the people is used to rescue the most shady characters rhat Moray was called “the Good Regent,” ab- solves him of the charges of meanness and Covenant days, people we treachery. In the same perfervid popular ism, Burns is reckoned the greatest Scot tish genius Yet the book is an interest ing and solid piece of writing, enlivened by a queer jumble of style. On one page the cat jumps, and on another we expiscate the truth. References, too, are sorely need ed, even marked quotations being simply “by a recent writer.” The five maps me! tioned on p. xx are not in the review copy. Lieut.-Col Andrew © P Haggard's “France of Joan of Arc” (Lane) belongs to the well-known class of “popular” histories Two-thirds of the by a commonplace recital of the events of fifty years preceding the arrival of Jeanne on the but there is nothing in the way of information which be had from a school textbook of worth. volume are occupied scene; could not moderate Originality of treatment and a good style, had they present, as an but 80 served the been might have excuse ; far as appears, author proceeds as if he were treading fresh ground, and as if the reader were supposed to be ignorant of the fact that the subject had ever been touched by Ana- tole France, Andrew Lang, or Gabriel Han- otaux. The style is sometimes melodra- matic, sometimes facetious. We are told in one place that “Charles VII had been only able to regale” La Hire “with the very scraggiest kind of a dinner.” The only thing approaching an idea to found in 350 extraordinarily thick pages is the state ment that, had no divine mission: France would really have been better off under English therefore, since the Maid, in spite of this, delivered her country from the English, the supposition is that the Divinity could have had nothing to do with the matter. be in the author's opinion, Jeanne rule; Miss Betham-Edwards knows her France wel, as her various writings testify has now gathered into a volume entitled “In the Heart of the Vosges” (McClure) number of sketches of which appeared in periodicals—ranging from the towns of Alsace to unfrequented corners of the Pyrenean valleys, back and forth to Picardy, French Flanders, and the Alpes Maritimes. The sketches are discursive and uneven, and the chronology of her wander- ings is sometimes uncertain, but the whole readable and lifeike. We _ get glimpses of Lourdes, Narbonne, Marseilles, Nice, Monte Carlo, and other interesting She a some have is very

Page 20

a great cor! and prototype bined Arthur Young : the of agricultural But re hers re tra she nd wh her ere is disappoin urate she Bartho'omew rate beyond reminded vellers in and social Miss the Ex sur- attempts ting speaks hapter In Gustave Oth of Nation ‘The of the and are, in a a belated justification of that expulsion. For clearly how very Moslem still were, even after ternal of Christianity, and more than a century's iso‘ation the Moslem world and exposure to a Christian environ- Instead of Arabic they had to speak Spanish dialect, but they wrote it in the so-called Aljamia, read own Arabic These ranged popular tales, valuable for folk-lore, and usually in Aljamia, to standard theological tre of hoard, 34 at near Zaragoza, the the Junta para Madrid, de- of Professors bee published {rabes y Aljamiados de la la Madrid, pp. xxxii. ers sixty-seven manuscripts and in Moriscos sense, they show very their owners ex- acceptancs from nent 30m Arabic continued to characters, ind their books ost irom written such atises one Almonacid, of at now prope rty ién de estudios a escription by pupils Asin has ist n Junta fragments loos¢ photographic 1043 admirably fror \ northern expulsion lore the folk Brooks, who for several years f Publi home eighty ad iward erintendent died ay Oo Schools in near that ynd devoted at his in his ser year Brool s h retelling Dr him- clas- rn Roberts, 1 whose dé work Epigraphy S aste rnest bridge ith we ofa Greek had 4. Gardner Cat 1uthor in two iction to voPume he the ollaboration Science University Press has under- of f Ww ation series, en Allied W“ Sub- 1] be by McBride ndoors announced and ad ind Garden Pig by “Gardening Rockwell; f Hous: I ind our lohn in V (Dutton) is book 1 Newfoundland” Rogers “Sport in a and mentioned liffuse account of hunting untries be learned from It by ortaman t nnot ithority ' [Vol. 95, No. 2453 streams, and recommends that the local Government let the waters to private par- . in order that the waters may be better preserved—for the rich sportsmen. As a matter of fact, Newfoundland has the proud distinction (and long may it remain), of keeping all its waterways open to every fisherman who is willing to pay the small tax of $10. The photographs reproduced in the book are fair, the sketches execrable. There is no index ties Health” (Macmil- Savage, an English con- “Milk and the Public by Dr. William G health officer and bacteriologist venient book. A of it special for the general reader, out the larg- portion the dangers milk and the methods by which the, supply may be lan) is a is rather too part er discusses of improved and safeguarded, and in such that the profit intelligent layman may of considered, fashion course, English con but that the discussion, the work Dr. Savage read with not the litions are does and done on holds that impair the value of is familiar with of the Atlantic there milk Pasteurization and pending improvement uthor this side hat is no convincing evidence value effi valuable nutritive to be and impairs its he useful boiling believes an edure, in the milk business; harmful than and the cient pro t is, however, benefi- al litions lated necessarily harmful likely to harm children when given fcr ! of time. They and their of controversial more con- regu proper amounts are healthy adults invalids and young unless rigidly supervised of Preservatives its employment carefully in rot to but are any considerable are generally unnec- dirty milk. ngth essary, use methods the Savage encourages and handling matter of tuberculosis collecting In Dr. tuber- is convinced that bovine ulosis is a source of human tuberculosis It is seldom that a scientific subject treated in popular form with such thorough- ness as has gone into the making of A. E Garrett’s book “The Advance of Pho- tography; Its History and Modern Applica- *" (Dutton). The author has adopted, with only a few alterations, the historical given in Vogel’s “Chemistry of Light and Photography”; the of the book is new. Every one knows, of course, that photography is used in many ways, but it is only when a detailed account is fore that an appreciation of its indis- pensable assistance to all branches of and life in general The very difficult task has been attempted of briefly, not all the processes appliances of photography, but also its chemical and phy- is on tions’ account rest be- one art, business, science, is quite possible explaining only and sical laws and related phenomena. Although action of light matter compli- cated and obscure, the author succeeds re- markably well in leading up to it from the The book be highly for accuracy and the on is actions both impler can commended, inter- t issued The Absorp- H. C experimental The Institution has ther monograph (No Carnegie an- 160) on tion Spectra of Solutions,” by Jones nd W. W The of the work is elaborat: the Strong part many photographic lates being given of absorption spectra of rare salts, and the effects of temperature The first chapter is devoted to the the the on them th absorption of Al- and the of by eory emission nergy atom and electron

Page 21

July 4, 1912] The Nation though the writers state that our present theory is very simple, most physicists are inclined to the opinion that the mechanism of radiant energy is about the most baf- fling problem in modern science. {t is dis- appointing that monographs which furnish such an immense amount of data, should contribute to this problem of radiant energy so little definite help The growing independence of psychology and the self-sufficiency of its body of facts appear in Prof. Knight Dunlap’s “System of Psychology” (Scribner). This interest- ing volume is not an elementary textbook. It is the first draft of a general psycholog- ical hypothesis Both the draft and the hypothesis are unusual. It ought to be a seven-day wonder that a psychologist of Professor Dunlap’s repute pronounces a thorough literary training the most impor- tant prerequisite of psychological study. This science, he says, “least of all can be com- municated or comprehended in a_ special jargon,’ but requires all the assistance that can be given by command of the resources of the language of the masters in letters. At the very outset, Professor Dunlap con- fesses that “the data of psychology cannot at present be definitely described except in terms of theories which are more or less ‘philosophical.’ "’ He also says that the very first propositions about elementary facts cannot be rid of ambiguity save by acute philosophizing. ‘The volume faithfully re- flects this belief. It is the only work of its kind which reveals an appreciative ac- quaintance with the contempo- rary philosophical analysis. It builds upon not a few important distinctions which psy- chologists have not been drawing, and which will, doubtless, the student for a while. For the venerable theory of mental images is rejected, and the seem- ingly paradoxical anti-idealistic doctrine is maintained that are not the brain, but just where they are experienced as being. The of relations for the author, not below that of entities; and 80 opposed to and which respectively exaggerate minimize the metaphysical of relations. Professor Dunlap deals only with the facts and of normal adult psychology. His philosophical point of view makes the result hard reading, but profitable results of harass instance, sensations in status is, he is equally idealism materialism, and importance problems “A Text-Book of Botany for Colleges and Universities,” Vol. II, “Ecology” (American Book by Professors Coulter, Barnes, and Cowles of the University of Chicago, has been prepared by experts. Though Professor Barnes died in 1910, it clear that he had a large part in the preparation of this volume, for the physiological aspects are as fully present- ed as the structural, and therefore the whole symmetrical, As the term indicate, all the relations considered of an organism its The book breaks new ground Company), is work is “Ecology” would to are here surroundings. in two essential ways: first, it attempts more or less successfully to simplify the termino'ogy; and, secondly, it substitutes mechanical causation for tele- adaptation. The last chapter to a philosophical discussion of It has written, embodies likely to throughout ology and is devoted adaptation and meet been carefu!ly views which are with wide acceptance | Vant Drama THE STAGE AND “MORALITIES.” The revival of “Everyman” ten or a dozen years ago was not without con- siderable influence, it appears, upon the dramatists of the day. All were aston- ished at the impressive effect made by this manipulation of abstract qualities. That Life and Death personified could reach to the poignancy of great tragic moments had been almost forgotten. Along with out-and-out allegory the morality had been consigned to the whims of the long ago. But when the Elizabethan Stage Society in 1901 gave a presentation of “Everyman” it was seen at once what a broad range of dramatic possibilities the play pos sessed, and several writers were moved to try their hand at work of much the These matters are inter discussed by J. W “The Morality Motive English a startlingly up-to-date subject dissertation same sort estingly Barley, in temporary who n Con Drama” has taken for his doctor’s Mr. Barley mentions a formidable list of plays in fluence of “Everyman” was pretty cer- tainly present. It was acknowledged Yeats, the author of “The Hour wherein a Wise Man, a Fool, an and other types figure as char the whose composition the in- by Glass,” Angel, acters, against and which inveighs preaching of materialistic philosophy Then there is Arthur Symons’s “The Fool of the World,” having Death and a Pilgrim to prompt a probing of the eternal mysteries. But perhaps Nu gent Monck, in “Life’s Measure,’ came nearer than others to catching the mor- ality tone and manner. Young Man eager for fame devotes himself to Labor, who has explained to him the need of incessant toil. Motherhood implores him not to forget his soul in his work The Fool and the Poet—laughter and beauty of life—urge him “to mingle the service of self with that of his fellow- man.” He is obdurate. Age comes and with it a sense of the emptiness of life. in the garb of a pilgrim, touches his heart it too late, for woman spurns Death over- takes him, and is inexorable; yet he has light, and thus something saved from the ruin. “The the Third Floor Back” and “The Ser in the House,” which Mr. Barley likewise in this general move- ment, are too well known to need refer- ence here. They, illus- trate the desire of recent authors to re- store to the stage old preaching function, and, specifically, by ubstractions or unmistakable types Still further practice of this would most probably benefit writers not littl ern conditions means ability t on, Love, is when him. is Passing. of seen the places the others, with something of its genre To adjust the morality to mod life Oo see whole, and what it signifies in the simple terms of and self-sacrifice, vanity lov e and hate and x! iu humility it means reducing existence to its ments might Ww not ho repeat shall say itself; Shakespearean drama grew all-embracing moralities, so simila the perimenting might cret all ages? questionably suffered in almost Zz the instinct for the abstract and allegorical. Probably to a great mar persons to-day “Everyman,” like Pil grim’s Progress, is a “Sunday 01 story,” even to those whom tl iy for the moment moved It n st fessed that at least the imitatior f this drama did not give to abstra the objectivity throug} v] these can become powerful The thors could not assume that perfe derstanding on t part of the aud vhich used to ist in day ‘ the “Nice Wanton trutted so brave and naturally to doom s p! l gory, just now apt to appear ld play. Broad] speaking t ha n hurt by the hold of literalness e one side, and on the other by that complex allegory, beloved of Maeter linck, which all too easily merg nto an almost unintelligible symbolism. Vir tue and Vice, set in a confusing 1in- bow of poetic images, are not, an re than when in the employ of the too n scious teacher, truly effective Properly managed, practice in dra matic allegory should facilitat he sketching of types of human existen: and distinguishing of genuine types from iwechanical divisions. This is a itter to which the American playwright espe cially has given little thought. Types he has fancied that he was dealing in He has drawn the Yankee, the Southern colonel, the cowboy; latterly the captain of industry, the political boss tra elling salesman, the slum child and the pampered darling. But these a! af ter all, markings on the surfa ‘ Let most of these characters | placed within the true old framework of th morality, and what becomes of them Many of them would vanish in mid-air having none of the underlying qualities of how urally and at the same tims to Modern n ot present that il that, out furnish a situations } ot vitally generations } of which real types are composed capitalist and politician should ways be painted black, and th: child is not always the special of injustice. It was, of course, 1 tLat the rapid development of An life should centre attention upon externals jut ju now this country is growing to be s ngly homogeneous Even tl tional geographical distinctions passing. The Down-Easter, t! rner, and the Westerne: et t and seem to understand ons What this means for the tag I ( ] i nave torr ' ry the lat ‘ T) et i 4

Page 22

2O writers have got to re-classify their ma- terial by getting deeper into it and by placing the emphasis upon the qualities which have long held essential. They could not do better than to keep the plan of the moralities well in mind. For, after all, the chief concern for the writer ig to be able to recognize and label the good and the bad, whether in youth or in age, in a sombrero or in a silk hat. Adopting broad outlines, as was done in “Everyman,” is likely to lead to drama of wider and truer appeal than is the sort of artificial specializa- been tried so mueh of been tion which has late Musie In commenting on the recent death of Ricordi, the ontrol of the him tren opera houses and many music despot of Verdi power Giullo Italian works and whose Puccini zg 1endous over ull ave the Italian in other a German jour- calls attention the fact that Ri- controlled the rights to the per- Italy of Wagner's operas that he provided for some in countries, to ord ilso formances While in admitting s of these operas the took often ery good performance Italian Same writer re Ricordl everal cities arks Wagner of those care not to have the owned him Franchetti that given too to detriment including The is his son other by of of operas Boito the de was and suc- ASOT ceased publisher rito America two ago Girl of the Golden West.” in years The who to help stage of last month a French made an excursion from The object of the excur- sion tablet the which Bizet died on June 2, 1875 were made by Pierre Lafitte, Xavier Leroux, in which the speakers dwelt on Bizet not the second day of of letters On number prominent musicians and men Paris to Bougival house in Addresses was to put a on and others fact a genius whose until after l'Arlesienne” of genuine of the a favorite resort Turgenieff, Bizet alth the that was greatness was known his leath to armen” and were immortal of Hougival was Halévy referred types h town of as Fren melody music racy soll rhe of and Dumas When he eart broken by Sardouw went there his was impaired the conviction that con eriti and was a complete fallure, a on hin indifference by the adverse of the public, box offi . orced the adily din receipts the ate intshing buffo tenor, Julius Lieban, has stage after singing in that He Angelo Neumann's hie best and “Sieg he almost The retired fron Berlin the ity twenty-nine years first attracted attention as a member of Wagner and Mime "in which Albert travelling Company role was in Kheingold” tried equalled in his best Re day, ise melodious and emotional Humperdinck's (the moet inspired the possible Manru”), has German cities The critics carpings and Koénigekioder™ opera since “Carmen,” with of lasting favor in it ready written Paderewak\i's all the properly thelr exception won was sung with where were usual The Nation [ Vol. 95, No. 2453 doubts, but the public took the opera to heart at once At a recent London conference of men interested in the commercial side of mu- sic, one of the points discussed related to the differences between publishers and mu- sellers in regard to prices, a topic upon appeared much to be said on both sides One of the recommendations was that the present discount system should be abolished, and the one-price sys- tem adopted, and that the price should be clearly marked on sheet of music sold. It was argued that as the booksellers adopted a similar system a few years ago with to novels, the music trade could the experiment. The all Reger, has is entitled a “Concerto in the old style for a small orchestra.” The Bote & Book, Berlin, and the first perform- will be Hamburg on October 28. sk which there every reference safely follow fertile of Max completed most composers, ance at Jean-Jacques Rousseau was famed in his day as a composer. His opera, “Le Devin du Village.” was first sung in 1752. A few weeks ago it was revived in Paris, by way of celebrating Rousseau’s bicentenary. Rousseau was also the author of the first musical dictionary in the French language. In it no distinction is made between “suite” “sonata.” In the musical war between the Italians and the French, he sided at first with the Italians, declaring that the French language was not suited for musi- settings. Oddly enough, it was a Ger- man, Gluck, the of his style and expressive use of words, convinc- ¢d Rousseau of his him take back what he The late known, the Belgians of his native country as he H> began his career at the age of twenty-five bringing a collection of Flemish folksongs, entitled “Ons Vaderland.” The best of his operas, “The Tavern Princess,” was produced in New York by Hammer- stein, and carried his fame all over Europe; but his other works have been mostly ignored abroad In 1900 he began a “Till Eulenspiegel,” but never got beyond the first act and cal who, by elegance error and made had said. Blockx Was think, outside deserved to Jan not be. by out Art A History of Fine Art in India and Cey- lon. By Vincent A. Smith. Oxford: The Clarendon Press (Frowde). Large quarto, 386 illustrations. As a condensed discussion of the chief monuments with complete bibliogra- phies, this book immediately approves itself as useful. And in general the dis- tribution of space is judicious. Sculp- ture is most fully treated, occupying about half of the five hundred pages. The introductory chapter is devoted to a general sketch of the architecture. The later semi-European buildings of the Mogul Emperors and the fascinating de- velopment that Persian miniature paint- ing received at length. Here excellent plates in gold his opus 123, which | publishers are! so well)! $19.25 net. | in their courts are noted | and colors illustrate the sumptuous re- finement of this heterodox art. As a conspectus of the field the book may be compared with such a work as Dalton’s “Byzantine Art and Archeology,” gain- ing, however, @ more personal quality through the author’s long contact with the material and through his frankly communicated prejudices. There is in the book an odd mixture ‘of detachment and special pleading. For our author the extra pair of arms of a Siva is always an offence. Why this is worse than a centaur, a satyr, a sphinx, or a beast-headed Egyptian god does not appear. In fact, in the best bronzes of dancing Siva the superfluous arms seem valuable factors in animation. For such specific dissent our author atones by a valiant attempt to justify the term “fine art” as applied to India. It is sig- nificant that the endeavor puts him con- stantly on the defensive, and it seems to us that the case is far from proved. India seems the classic instance of a civilization deeply versed in the indus- trial arts, but failing to make the next higher step. Against Mr. Havell and 'recent native critics who celebrate the glories of the ancient Asoka style, it ;might be reasonably argued that India | first enters the field of the fine arts with |the great Mogul emperors of the seven- |teenth century. The apologists for the archaic work virtually rest their case upon religious considerations. The ad- vocate of Indian art must meet the fol- |lowing difficulties: (1) The lack of any principle of proportion in the old tem- |ples, (2) the tasteless profusion of |sculpture upon these temples, which is |destructive both of its effect as sculp- ‘ture and of any repose the building |might inherently have had, (3) the fact | that the finest monuments of Buddhism |are not found in India, where the cult originated, but in China, Turkestan, and | Japan, (4) the correlated fact that In- ‘dian art always improves by exporta- tion, as may be seen in Ceylon, Cam- bodia, Tibet, (5) the ready penetra- bility of India by foreign strains, suc- cessively Hellenistic, Sassenian, old Per- sian, Chinese, Italian, and neo-Persian. ‘Such facts seem to show quite obvi- ously that India never attained the de- gree of unity and national self-conscious- ness that makes possible a progressive and consistent racial expression through the fine arts. In a narrower sense than was the case even in Egypt, art remain- ‘ed the abject handmaid of religion. excepting the Mogul art, which was that of ultra-refined invaders, and per- haps neither more nor less significant than the courtly art of France in the eighteenth century, there are not a doz- en plates in this volume, containing nearly four hundred, which give your reviewer the sense of a thing nobly conceived and finely executed. And it should be recalled that these plates rep- resent flattering excerpts from confused’

Page 23

July 4, 1912) ensembles. The merit which appears in the cut would be obscure in the monu- ment itself. Immensely richer would be similar excerpts from any famous medi- #val building in Europe. Notre Dame at Paris, for example, would offer per- haps a hundred times more evidence for greatness in sculpture than our author has been able to present for all India. Yet precisely because India remained in the incipient stages of art, this his- tory is most instructive. No great plas- tic or graphic art could grow out of any nation that consistently believed life to be evil and the world of appearances to be illusion. Tempered with such buster practices as ancestor worship or with the delicate epicureanism of the Zen sect, the skeptical monism of In- dia became fecund of art in China and Japan. Some degree of conscious love of life underlies all the finer expressions of art, and some degree of racial and national consciousness must be attain- ed before a race or a nation can attain a central and representative art. Art as mere symbolism, art as a transitory adornment to be repudiated as moral perfection and sagehood were reached —these were the leading ideas of the best minds of India, and there are ob- viously anti-esthetic ideas. No wonder then that, save as her conquerors have brought in the pride of life, India has remained in the sub-esthetic stage. The essential abstractness of the old Brahmanism, with which Buddhism ever temporized, forbade it appropriate visible symbols. Thus the painting and sculpture of old India seem a kind of base and ineffectual vulgarization of ideas incommunicable under the condi- tions of objectivity required by the fine arts. The real sages of whatever per- suasion must have disapproved such fu- tile symbolism. There is abundant lit- erature of many sorts in India, but no ancient pundit ever thought it worth his while to write on the fine arts. Con- trast with this condition the early esthetic literature of Greece, China, and Japan. In fact, to a Hindu adept of old-time the modern native vindications of the art of India would seem supreme- ly inconsequent, and the art itself would probably look no more important than the Alaskan totem poles do to esthetic frequenters of ethnological museums. In our quarrel with his title we have perhaps done .less than justice to Mr. Smith’s solid, learned, and informing book. It is an indispensable revertory of facts for all who would follow the subject into the realm of ideas. ro- The death is reported of Oscar L. Lenz, the sculptor, in his thirty-ninth year. He had studied in Paris under Saulierre, and in this country was a student of Saint- Gaudens. He executed part of the designs of the Court of Honor at Chicago, the Co- lon'al group at Charleston, S. C., and some of the figures in the Pennsylvania Railroad “Station in New York. fy he Nation Finance JULY INVESTORS AND THE BOND MARKET With the turn of the half-year, there has naturally been a revival of interest in the bond market and in the prospects for quick employment of the funds paid out as July 1 interest and dividend dis bursements. The question is not only occupying attention here, but in the Eu- ropean markets as well, for they have all been movre or less disturbed for weeks past by both the efforts to finance the half-yearly payments and by the embar- rassment of various bond syndicates which have found themselves loaded with bonds for which they could not find a market. At London there has been real disturb- ance attending the fall in price of British consols; and the belated efforts of the Government to appropriate a portion of the sinking fund in order to stop the decline in the national se curity have excited comment throughout the financial world. In Paris also an effort has been made to strength- en the market for French rentes and to fortify the position of the banks, which for months past have been tied up with various securities that they could not sell advantageously. In Germany the situa- tion has been further complicated by the stringency of the money market, which is emphasized by the unusual ments offered by the Berlin banks procure heavy advances from London, New York, and Paris. At Amsterdam also a glut in the bond market has made it impossible for the bankers to bring out the new issues which are ordinarily offered at this time of the year steady the wide induce- to In comparison, therefore, with condi- tions prevailing abroad, the American market has been much more comfort- ably situated, despite the fact that new security issues here for the year 1912 to date have surpassed the records of all Figures for the half-year but for the five 31 it has been and industrial $1,265,000,000, other years. are not yet available, months ending May shown that railway sues aggregated against $991,000,000 in months last year and 1910, the increase above 1911 per cent., and above the year preceding 35 That the rate of new se curity issues here promises to establish for 1912 a certain high record was em- phasized on Wednesday of last week, when the Governing Committee of the Stock Exchange, holding its last regu- lar meeting before the summer vacation, admitted to listing the largest aggregate in par value of new securities that has | been introduced to trading on the Ex- | change since the billion dollars, par |value, of United States Steel stocks is- as five in 28 the same $917,000,000 being per cent. 21 were put on the list in 1901 The ag gregate was more than $430,000,000, and while part of it represented substitution of new securities for old, still a very large proportion reflected the issuar of entirely new corporation sti s and bonds. Thus, while it car shown that demand on capital is continuing ‘ large scale, and that securities are being turned out in tremend: imeé t ain that on the surface, at least, the has been neither the ! st ‘ i London nor the mone ma dis ance which has so lon he f of the market in Berli: One develoy ment which has had considera fl nee here is the increased inquiry fr the savings banks, which last vear and the year before did very little bond ing around July 1, These institutions for several weeks past have been quietly picking up high-grade bonds, and, lb cause of the larger excess of deposits above withdrawals, are now in a posi tion, barring unforeseen complications to continue such investment purchases for some time to come Because of the country’s Presidential! election next November and of the ex treme violence shown at the nominating Conventions, unusual interest is mani fested in the probable attitude of the investing public after the disbursements during June of nearly $260,000,000 in interest and dividends The city of Philadelphia last week found it possible to obtain par for a small block of 4 per Other municipalities have of high-grade But in cases where cent. bonds marketed small issues bonds on that basis. attempted it the any large offerings have been been difficult of individual such terms. An international of usual shrewdness in judging investment to obtain support has investors on banker un conditions gave it as his opinion that none of the great railway corporations would find it possible to sell even the best bonds this vear at terms which of fered the investor much less than 41% per cent With all the important banks and trust companies, the chief inquiry still is for short-term notes or for bonds with only one or two years to run. The dé mand for short-term notes is still so broad as to suggest that there will be further important issues made by cor porations having in the near future to borrow large amounts For the year to date the volume of notes put out by railway companies has been $60,000,000 less than last year, although an increase in industrial note sales, induced by the abundance of money at low rates of in- terest, has in considerable measure off set the decrease. The bulk of the gain in the total of corporation emissions this year has been in stocks bearing a liberal rate of interest; the high yields shown by these has compelled the rail-

Page 24

hold from tl market new i vl it rate of re : } “AT ‘ fina of tl year to da vill ’ i ud xpansion in at n ! ear It out of ti ond mar 108 ch « ributed t« d trial ri ry whicl panic ¢ 104 1K Of HE WEEK \ M | P i rim t j/ V7’ Ol Hall’s Elements of Physics 1} t™ Snow’s Fundamentals of French Grammar Head of the Dk , English H 5 ! uspects | « 6 top: ; le r The v } " by I n i a t Tt t tet “ ‘ Pre ' ! treat w“ 34 W.83 Bt I “sae I Jolt&C Yo 4 New York Columbia University Studies History. Economics, and Public Law British Radical. By Walter Phelps Hiall, Sometime Fellow in His- t Columbia University x Paper « P No, 2. A Comparative the Law of Corpora- Particular Reference otection of Creditors holders By A K. D., LL.B j eve : i, } rhe Spirit of C binese Philanthropy, A Study in Mutual Ald Ry \¥ Yue Tau, Ph.D j Ss) tm Provinelal and in Canada, By Ph.D, Some- in Keonomik a in Vol, ALIX, No. 1 ism, 1701-1797, | eed , Vol. XLIX Study of tions, with the I d Share rh Prgine... | were Garth Fellow ‘Longmans, Green, & Co., New York Modern Dramatists Ry ASHLEY DUKES ' ( th G t $1.50 i 1} HARLES H. SERGEL & COMPANY ! CHICAGO The Nation eb 95, No. 2453 Dowd, E. C. Playtime Games for Boys and Gir-s. Phila.: Jacobs & Co. 75 cents net. Drews, Arthur. The Witnesses to the His- toricity of Jesus. Trans, by J. McCabe. Chicago: Open Court Pub. Co. $2.25 net. Hosmer, Harriet: Letters and Memories Edited by Cornelia Carr. Moffat, Yard $3 Lowrie, Donald, My Life in Prison, Mitchell Kennerley $1. 25 net Martin, C. M Italy (When Mother Lets Us ravel series) Moffat, Yard >1 net Moyer, A. C. A Romance of the Road. Chi- ago: Laird & Lee. $1 Miller . My Syste for Ladies M Gustavu History of the Supreme ( irt of the I Ss Chicago: Kerr & Co . rt Prophet Broadway Pub. Co Pet | W The Preservation of Mine Washington Government Ptg Ome Sachs, Julius. The American Secondary School and Some of Its Prob ems. Mac- millan. $1.10 net. Scharlieb, Mary. Womanhood and Race- Regeneration. Moffat, Yard. 50 cents net, Scott, Morgan. Oakdale Boys in Camp. Hurst & Co. 60 cents. Sombart’s Die Zukunft der Juden. Leipzig: Duncker & Sumbolt. Weill, Félix. French Newspaper Reader. With notes and exercises. American Book Co. 50 cents. Weir, James. The Energy System of Matter. Longmans. Wilcox, D, F. Government by All the Peo- ple. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Woerishoffer, Carola. Her Life and Work. Bryn Mawr College, class of 1907 ‘Wood, R,. K. The Tourist’s Russia. Mead. Zenner, says. pany. Dodd, Mind Cure and Other Es- Stewart & Kidd Com- Philip. Cincinnati: $1.25 net. Just Published THE LIFE OF NIETZSCHE By Mrs. FOERSTER-NIETZSCHE VOLUME I.—THE YOUNG NIETZSCHE V ime Il Preparing This life is written by Nietzsche's sister, Whose life-long devotion to her brother, as intellectual com- panion and as nurse, is well known. Now for the first time published, simultaneously in English and Ger- man, it will supersede all other biographies of the philosopher, by its completeness and its fresh ma- terial. It draws upon all available sources, including hitherto un- known documents possessed by the biographer, and upon her own won- derful memory. In it the author vividly presents her brother's per- sonality and environments in a nar- rative of oe interest. ach $4.00 net ($4.20 po STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 East 27th Street, New York ‘ Rr fini stpaid) DICTIONARIES TO FAMOUS AUTHORS $3.00 net per volume A DICKENS DICTIONARY By ALEXANDER J. PHILIP A THACKERAY DICTIONARY By ISADORE G. MUDGE A DICTIONARY of the WAVERLEY NOVELS OF SIR WALTER SCOTT By M. F. A. HUSBAND A THOMAS HARDY DICTIONARY with 2 Mapes of Wessex By F. SAXELBY A KIPLING DICTIONARY Ry W. ARTHUR YOUNG E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 West 234 Street NEW YORK ‘It see likely Leladee FOOL IN CHRIST the ms that Hauptmann’s will itely take ts pla ‘ imong paterp of mporary§ literature, ‘ Curvent I (Price $1.50 net.) Bb. W. HUEB Fifth ave New York conte iferature ACH THEAMERICAN GOVERNMENT Hy FREDERIC J HASKINS 1 1} he | i lent th 7 . ‘ mn ‘ ; #1 t B1.15 J. LIPPINCOTT Co., Pr bhitode Iphia MY FRIENDSHIP WITH PRINCE HOHENLOHE By Baroness v n Hedemann Svro. With many hitherto unpublished letters and original illustrations $2.00 net By mail, $2.20. The Baroness, who, after a gloomy and neglected childhood, made a loveless marriage, found herself some years later the vic- tim of a divorce scandal and a social outcast. At this critical time the man of her destiny, the great Prince of Hohenlohe-Schil- lingsfurst, entered her life. Their attachment was as lasting as it was spontaneous. The book con- tains many intimate sketches of, and allusions to, people of prom- inence. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS NEW YORK LONDON “Mr. Beresford has arrived.” —London Morning Leader. A Candidate for Truth By J. D. BERESFORD than by any novel we have read for months we are captivated by ‘A Candidace for Truth.’ ""—Chicago Evening Post. “Raises its author quite definitely to the front rank of living novelists.’"—London Standard. 486 pages. Cloth. $1.35 net; by mail $1.46. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., BOSTON CA A SS Ee OE “More “A notable brief for democracy that everybody ought to read,’’ says Mr. OswaLp GARRISON VILLARD One Way Out: A Middie-Class New Englander Emigrates to America By “WILLIAM CARLETON.” The most notable book of our day. Sixth Printing. #1.20 net; by mail, #1.32 Send for descriptive matter free. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston A Charming Picture of French Home-life A GARDEN OF PARIS Ry ELIZABETH WALLACE With dainty line drawings. Price. $1.25 net. At all Bookstores. A. C. MeCLURG &Co.,, Publishers, Chicago THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK For 1911 Now Ready catalogus A new now A. S. CLARK, Peekskill, of second-hand and will be sent to » we Americana ready any address

Page 25