The Nation 1912-05-23: Vol 94 Iss 2447
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘The 10 VOL. XCIV—NO, 2447 THURSDAY, MAY 23, 1912 Reg. U.S. PRICE TEN CENTS
HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY’S Important Publications
Ready shortly Henrik Ibsen By OTTO HELLER This sympathetic and enthusiastic study of Ibsen in the light of all his writings will meet the demand for a book about the man and his plays at once scholarly and readable, compact and complete. Professor Heller is a well-known authority in this field, and an able and vigorous writer. With frontispiece. $2.00 net. Postpaid $2.13. Waterways versus Railways By HAROLD G. MOULTON This volume contains the most exhaustive treatment of the comparative advantages of waterways and rail- ways under modern transportation conditions that has ever been undertaken. With maps and charts. $2.00 net. Postpaid $2.16. ' The Loss of the S.S. Titanic By LAWRENCE BEESLEY Among all the stories of the “Titanic” disaster told by the survivors, that of Mr. Beesley stands out unique for vividness, completeness, convincing and aut oritative reality. It will, for the first time perhaps, give the public an adequate notion of what actually occurred, while it is hoped it may lead to action of vital importance for the future. Illustrated.
PHILOSOPHY THE GREAT BOOK OF THE YEAR POETRY
ay hlietzsche The Promised Land Scum o’ the Earth By ROBERT H. SCHAUFFLER. “Mr. More's treatise is one of the By MARY ANTIN. “Filled with the finest instincts of clearest and sanest expositions of the o - humanity and brotherhood.”—Spring- Nietzschean idea that as yet has been One of the wonderful books not of this | field Republican. With frontispiece published.” — Philadelphia Ledger. | year or that, but of all the years.”—Jacob | $1.00 net. Postpaid $1.07 With portrait. $1.00 net. Postpaid | 4 Riis, Awthor of “The Making of an 1.05. < , $1.05 American, Little Gray Songs from Kant and Spencer ig ene. x By BORDEN P. BOWNE. “It reveals the mind and soul of the im . spas A critic:.1 presentation of the es- migrant, the ambition that surges in the By GRACE FALLOW NORTON sential teachings of Kant and Spencer | minds of many of them, and the rich con- “The beauty of the songs lies in from the standpoint of Prof. Bowne’s | tribution that they are making, and wil] | their exquisite simplicity.”—Minneap own philosophical system. $3.00 net. | yet make, to the greatness of America.”— | °/!* Journal. $1.00 net. Postpaid $1.06 Postpaid $3.21. Bo i ston Herald, The Adventure of Life “Should stand side by side with Booker The White Hills in Poetry By WILFRED T. GRENFELL. T. Washington’s ‘Up from Slavery,’ and Edited by EUGENE L. MUSGROVE. “He preaches the doctrine of the with Jacob Riis’ ‘The Making of an ‘Amert- A collection of poems so arranged as to constitute practically a poetic guide book to the White Mountain region. /llustrated. $1.75 net. Poat- paid $1.83 Christianity that manifests itself in works and love with an authority that few men can equal.”—N. Y. Sun. lars a : $1.10 net. Postpaid $1.19. Illustrated. $1.75 net. Postpaid $1.90 can.’ ’—Chicago Tribune.
STORIES OF UNUSUAL CHARM AND LITERARY DISTINCTION
High Bradford By MARY ROGERS BANGS “A picture of life in a Cape Cod village fifty years ago. . . A very sweet and charming story with the charm of the ‘old simplicities’ that even we of the modern days must treasure.’—N. Y. Times. Ilustrated $1.20 net. Postpaid $1.30. Tales of a Greek Island By JULIA D, DRAGOUMIS “These tales are peculiarly beautiful in their reflection of the tragedy and comedy that make up the life of the people of Poros. The old gossips at the village fountain live before our eyes, and the love tales of the island are full of human interest.”—The Outlook. Illustrated. $1.35 net. Postpaid $1.48. The Plain Path ty FRANCES N.S. ALLEN “A novel with a message for the human heart. . . . A wholly delightful story, the movement of which Is rapid enough to be exhilarating, the characters of which are lovable, and the poetry of which is certainly far above the ordinary.”—Minneapolis Journal. $1.30 net. Postpaid $1.43 Alexander’s Bridge By WILLA 8. CATHER “The story of a man with a divided soul.”—N. Y. Times. “At once dramatic, convincing and full of strange pathos. . In spirit and quality alike the book is unusually strong and fine.”"—Chicago Record-Herald. $1.00 net. Pos'paid $1.07.
Page 2
The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 Educational | Educational 7% URSULINE ACADEMY, A HOME- HE UNITED HOSPITAL TRAINING Schoel for Girls, delightfully and healthfully SCHOOL FOR NURSES, Port Chester, N. Y., ] UR V4 situated on the outskirts of Middletown, New York. | offers a three years’ general training to young JU LAV sik. lso accepts young ladies and children during the | women Applicants should be at least nineteen summer months, and carefully provides for their | years of age. Qualifications, one year high school » protection and comfort Students, who wish to/or the equivalent. Remuneration, $10 monthly. neel College or High School conditions, will find | Apply to SUPERINTENDENT OF UNITED HOS- FOUNDED IN 1865 mme rees of Study provided. Terms on ap-| PITAL, Port Chester, N. Y. Institute Athenaeum - Munich Middletown. New York a Se 26 HERZOG RUDOLFSTRASSE 26. The Misses Kirk's College Preparatory School First class boarding school for boys. Day Prepares for Bryn Mawr and other colleges. Cer- | scholars. Individual training. Outdoor sports ite vileges. Number of pupils limited. Spe-| Bracing climate. Entrance any time. dule arranged for each Percentage of have entered Bryn Mawr College un ss — . . om owe. Gomenctios. cebieer aperts. 2400 A YEAR OF STUDY IN FRANCE. Oct. 3, 1912 School for Americans of both sexes. Near Paris. Individual training In a French family. Only 7 , French spoken Credit given by Universities of Briarcliff? Manor, New York *hicago and Illinois. Exceptional advantages. Ad- MRS. DOW’ S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS jon PROF. WILLIAMSON, University of Chicago. circular address MRS. MARY E. DOW, Prin , TOR ~ pas » “T°HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everetr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 25 Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington Short - Story Writing 156 Fifth Ave.,NewYork 610 Swetland Bd., Portland . 814 Steger Bd., Chicago 343 DonglasRhd.,_LosAngeles ‘ A course of Gosty lnseenetn De history, 920 Sav.Bk.Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Bik., Berkeley orm, structure, and writing o ne Short- J 4 r, > ‘ y » al. Story, taught by 4. Berg Rosaweln, Editor Send to any address above for Agency Manual L‘ppincott's Magazine. Over one hundred Home St Harlan P. French, Prop Vincent B. Fisk, M Gourses under professors in Harvard. 1] |THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGEN Brown, Cornell, and leading colleges. knews how. Twenty-one years of successful ex- Ar ’ ’ . rye > > 250-page eatalog free. Write to-day. ONTEN OF THIS NUMBER. wr harmey a perience in bringing together good teachers and . The Home Correspondence Schoo! Dept284 Springfield, Mass good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself. Just Published | PHYSIOGRAPHY Citizenshiy v By Arey, Bryant, Clendenin and Morrey ~ ng Sty ony ro on CHRISTOPHER MARLOWE A text-book for secondary schools. It Fiction a emphasizes economic and human values, | kit e Glas 11 —FOUR PLAYS and meets the requirements of college en- ae trance. In the series of Masterpieces of the Cloth. 416 pp. Illus. and maps. $1.25. English Drama,edited under the su- pervision of Prof. Fenix E. Scue.- ff | 2-C-MEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago LIN‘ of the University of Pennsyl- vania 70 «¢ t ER eee LIBRARIES AND Contains amoburiaine (Doth parts), ——e boctur Faustus, the Jew of Malte. and 1 | BOOKS PURCHASED 12 Edward the Second, with an introduc- immer School 512 tion by Professor Phelps of Yale. The TO ANY AMOUNT ouncil 513 text follows the authoritative editions, OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, Books .. 613 with spelling and punctuation modern- PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT n the Courts 51 ized The Introduction deals with Marlowe and his work, with special THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND reference to the four plays included. LITERATUR! Adequate notes explain all difficult Memoirs and Letters of the Right passages, and a glossary gives the 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 Hon. Sir Robert Morier. G.C.B meaning of all obsolete and unusual FOR BOOK ABOUT IT, vere . “197 19 terms. DODD, MEAD & COMPA : from 1526 to 1876 , oie FOURTH AVE. & 30TH STREET, SEW YORK Counsel for the Defence 515 Denin .. B15 AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY A Knight in rhe Sentence of Silence ae New York Cincinnati Chicago Situation Wanted Blinds Down se¢ The Sources of Religious Insight ] a oe a | FJ IGHLY, EDUCATED LITERARY MAN, ee . . . . “ of force and personality, with experience The President's Cabinet Studies ! DEPARTMENT OF POLITICAL ECONOMY lin literary and sociological work, and with widest THE UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN | literary tastes, seeks a position as private secre- Amer in Institution 5 MADISON, April 9, 1912. |} tary or assistant to busy author, or business man, : with public interests, or as a writer on special Professor MUZZEY’S AMERI- | subjects. Apply, E. 8., care The Nation. CAN HISTORY is to a sociologist § | ” a . r the most interesting single volume § | SORES oeereneee, Sees — of American history that has yet | and porsoverenen, power of organization, male, appeared. I heartily applaud his j}aged 29, excellent references, superior education conception that the history of this | Apply, Secretary, care of The Nation. country continually needs to be § | reconceived in order to provide § | : background and interpretation for _ Boarding the interests and problems each , generation has to solve. By dar- § | Miss 38 JEAN GIDLEY, SEYMOUR LODGE. ing to throw the historical facts § | ¢ otnes, Devonshire, England. An ideal place for Americans to stop For reference, Mrs. into new perspectives, Dr. Muzzey KORTRIGHT, Bristol, Rhode Island. has succeeded in producing not only a strong and illuminating SAMPLE COPIES OF textbook, but also a book of in- § | tense interest and significance to , / ‘HE NA’ I ION the general reader. E. A. ROSS. GINN et a lishe I; ny RF pak aby a Will be sent to any address for three weeks WitrHout CHARGE. * * * Coples of The Natiog may be proc Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenne de Opéra; | A. S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. A new! ADDRESS London of B. F. Stevens & Brows. 4 Trafalgar) catalogue of second-hand Americana, now | and. will be sent to any address. |THE NATION, 20 Vesey St., N. ¥. Olty SSS ee GANA erg EOL OL ALL A ALC the Orlet: Formation, and Stru Square, Charing Cross ready,
Page 3
ie aaa, wee ’ ; d he NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 23, 1912 The Week There is no blinking the truth that the Ohio primary dealt President Taft yesterday the rudest blow he has yet re- ceived. To lose his own State after making such an unprecedented fight for it, is not only a bitter personal humili- ation, it is such a damaging of his po litical prestige as would ordinarily be fatal. The popular majority for Roos velt in Ohio appears to be more than 20,000. Taft will seemingly have no more than 10 out of the State’s 48 del There is no denying that this is President. The vote was light, but he had as good an gates. a great defeat for the opportunity as his opponents to get a majority of it. Though the campaign began late and confused, the issues were made clear enough before it was over. And even if it be contended that the test was rough and unfair, the President submitted to it, he expressed the opin- ion that it would be conclusive—his words were: “The vote in Ohio, my home State, will be the decisive one and will settle the question of the nomina- tion”’—and now, having put it to the touch and lost, there is nothing to do but to accept the facts without any at- tempt to twist them. Pity the poor candidate. Take the case of Gov. Wilson, for instance. It has long been stated sub rosa that the Catholic Church was wholly opposed to him because somewhere in his writings there was a tiny reflection, direct or in- direct, upon either the Pope or the Church. Now, there comes to us from the South a copy of a Tom Watson broadside, which, we are informed, was widely circulated in Georgia prior to the recent primary. Lo, in this Wood- row Wilson appears as being a mere tool of the Catholic Church—Woodrow Wilson, a former president of Presby- terian Princeton! That he appointed an alleged Jesuit as his private secretary, i; said to be a damning proof. But more than that, he has been deliberately and openly conspiring with the whole Cath- olic hierarchy. What could be plainer? Hence the appeal to all those who sym- pathize with A. P. A. methods to op- Similarly, Mr. Taft is portrayed as merely putty in the pose Woodrow Wilson. hands of the priests, all because, at the behest of Roosevelt, he carried out the successful negotiations for the purchase of the Philippine friars’ lands, while some other churches are still after him because he is a Unitarian. Party lines are broken in the two Lor- imer reports to the Senate. It is not as Republicans or Democrats that the majority and minority divide, but as those who take a narrow legalistic view of the case, and those who look at it in broad, common-sense way. The ma- jority report starts off by considering the matter as res adjudicata. The Sen ate has once affirmed Lorimer’s title to his seat to be valid. That decision must not be reopened unless evidence be forthcoming which is not only “new” but “substantial.” The majority denies that the long hearings have developed any such evidence. Upon this the mi- nority report comments illuminatingly. It is true that no witness has been pro- duced who saw Lorimer actually brib- ing. But the proof is overwhelming that at least ten members of the Illinois Leg- ‘islature were bribed to vote for Lori- mer. The details are not now traceable, but the total effect is undisputed. There was, as President Taft expressed it, a “mass and mess of corruption” connect- ed with the election of Lorimer suffi- cient to taint it. All that remains for the Senate is to say whether its sense of smell is less acute than that of the coun- try. The spirit of picayune economy that led the House to cut off the appropria- tion of $94,000 for the work of the State Department in extending our foreign trade, should be rebuked in the Senate by restoration of the items cancelled. It would be interesting to hear any reason that could be offered for the proposed abolition of the new Bureau of Trade Relations, as also of the four Divisions of Latin-American, Far Eastern, Near These enlargements of the Department, and Eastern, and European Affairs. the reorganization that they have brought about in it, constitute nothing There less than a modernization of it. Nation is no apparent reason for questioning the statement of responsibie officers of the Department that “such legislation would put the United States in the rear rank of all governments in the matter of legitimate and effective support to worthy American enterprises and to foreign commerce, and would doall this at the very epoch in our history when our foreign relations and our foreign trade have becon vastly more impor tant than ever befor d are plainly seen to | on " portal : vhicl i it the ) ] rbitratior till ! t to encount was fran} d President Butler's Lake Mohonk At ti! tit the i meeting of the Conf the signs were apparently pointing to a great step, if not indeed to a series of great steps, in the direction in w we seem so painfully crawling Then came the tension between Germany nd England, the outbreak of actual war b tween Italy and Turkey, and the lame and impotent conclusion to the consid eration of the general arbitration trea- ties by the Senate. Dr. Butler's linking of national with international political sanity was especially timely As he well said, all political progress “must depend upon trust in the better instincts of the people, and cannct rest upon their appetites and their passions, their envies and their animosities.”” Accus tom a people to acting in their own poli tics in accordance with their prejudices rather than their reason, and how else can they be expected to act with refer ence to other nations? If this view ap pears somewhat discouraging as appar ently increasing the difficulties already in the way of international good will, it is in reality heartening, since it means that every blow struck for decency and fair play in our relations abroad will react upon our politics at home, which are sadly in need of all the “uplift” that can be given them—and vice-versa The sudden shifting of the real polit cal capital of Pennsylvania from Phila delphia to Pittsburgh is focussing atten tion upon leaders and conditions in the Smoky City. Much more has been heard
Page 4
of Flinn as the new Republican than of his associate, Mayor Magee, but Magee’s power rests upon a much so‘id- er base than the popularity of a Presi- dential Roosevelt rise fall, Flinn but unless Pittsburgh turns Democratic, any candidate, may or with him, dragging aspirant for Republican leadership in must sooner or later “see” This fact is ment in the outcome of the recent pri- the State Magee the sinister ele- maries, for the Pittsburgh Mayor makes no such professions of reform as does his With any proposal, the question uppermost in his How will this affect Pittsburgh colleague. reference to mind is: and Magee? Observers are wondering | hew long the two men can work togeth- er. Interest in this is sharpened by a demand for the impeachment of three crusade On side, Guffey has been officials under Magee, and a planned against vice in Pittsburgh. the Democratic succeeded by leaders rather than bosses. If Pennsylvania voters really wish to rid themselves of boss rule, it looks as if would have to resort once more to of practices they their final argument: the election a Democratic Governor who what the Republican platform preaches. In ratifying the agreement drawn up by their representatives in conference with the mine owners, the anthracite service to In coal workers have done a themselves as well as the public. deciding to stand by their leaders and by such within their authority, have subscribed to, the mine workers have given an example of discipline which augurs well for their future as a labor organization. On a smaller scale we have here a repe- tition of what happened in the conven- tion of British miners called to decide upon the cessation of the strike after the passage of the minimum-wage bill. In that conventionthe sentiment against peace was probably in the majority, but that peace, the delegates had to face the fact of they most their leaders advocated and followed. If organized labor ultimate aims, it itself a mob may gain a tem- all. The hope to attain its must endeavor to make discl- plined army. A advantage, but that is of porary repudiation union leaders and duly formulated agreements which is so com- only of disputes, best m in industrial can the interests against boss lorganizations and ‘citizens of New York city in laying the acts as these leaders, acting | The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2447 ‘ eer, | Another important result of the Ti-| tanic disaster is the sending of the cruiser Birmingham to patrol the ice- fields south of the Grand Banks, to give warning by wireless of the position of icebergs, and to make a scientific study It is safe to say that no captain will fail ‘to of this unprecedented ice-drift. these messages. the commercial give prompt heed to For this practical action world is indebted primarily to the some public-spirited proposal before the Navy Department, which, much to its credit, has respond- representations. ed favorably to their When such international patrol of the danger zone shall have been accom- an ‘plished, we shall see something compar- able to the beating of swords into ploughshares, in the turning of instru- ments devised for the most terrible de- struction into means of preventing loss of life and property. Urban congestion is admittedly one of the most difficult problems arising out of Advocates of the striction of immigration lay great stress immigration. Te- on the point that not only was the im- migration into this country before 1880 different in racial character from what! it is now, but that the earlier immi- grants passed through our ports of en- try to distribute wide and empty spaces of the West. The newer immigrants swarm in the cities. Hence any scheme that would further a more even geographical dis- tribution of our alien population would themselves over the | verely criticised, partly because of the |lowed his troops. citizens of San Diego kidnapped a man from his room in a hotel, took him out- side of the city limits, tarred and feath- ered and branded him, and made a half- hearted attempt to set him on fire. Ap- parently there are certain human beings whose human rights are not deserving ot consideration in Southern California. Hence an act of unspeakable barbarity that makes entirely irrelevant the orig- inal issues at stake. A telegram of Gen. U. S. Grant of great historical importance was put up at auction this week. It is dated at City Point, Virginia, October 12, 1864, is ad- dressed to Gen. Sherman, and reads in part as follows: On reflection I think better of your proposition. It will be much better to go South than to be forced to come North. You will no doubt clean the country where you go of railroad tracks and supplies. I would wagon, horse, mule, and hoof of stock, negroes. As far as arms can be supplied . I would put them in the hands of the negro men. Give them organization you cap. They will be of some use. U. 8. also move every as well as the such as GRANT, Lt.-Gen. Now, the significance of this is that Gen. Sherman's commander deliberately or- dered that policy of laying waste the country which Gen. Sherman followed in his march. For this policy of ruin- ing the territory in which he operated, Gen. Sherman has ever since been se- operations of the “bummers” who fol- It is still the custom in many sections of the South to lay at his door any and all loss of property. What Sherman did on his march to the serve the double purpose of relieving | 509, Sheridan did in the Shenandoah, congestion in the East and testing at) the same time the perennial plaint that comes out of the West regarding the scarcity of labor on the farms. To make this experiment the American Immigra- tion and Distribution ganized in this city last month. Among ravaging that wonderful granary from which Lee’s armies drew so large a por- tion of their food each year until Sher- }idan made good his threat that a crow | flying over it would have to carry his League was Or-| rations on his back. In Grant’s tele- gram, cited above, we have the clearest the chairmen of its various commit-| | oot that, after three and one-half Delaware, New the Governors of Maryland, North Vermont, tees are Iowa, Massachusetts, Hampshire, kota, West Virginia, and Wyoming. In their recent primaries the people of Southern California rallied over- to the support of in whelming numbers the candidate whose platform is the de- fence of human rights against property rights. On Wednerday of last week the Dakota, South Da-| years of warfare, he, too, had come to the conclusion that the most humane method of conducting war was so com- pletely to impoverish and wreck the enemy's country as to make a long- drawn-out resistance impossible. “Baby-Saving Show” is not the most dignified title that can be imagined, but it is the name that has been given to something that is expected to be a mile- stone in the advancement of Philadel-
Page 5
May 23, 1912] phia. All of next week there will be in the Quaker City a demonstration, by means of educational exhibits, lectures, and moving-pictures, of what can be done, and of what therefore ought to be done, to reduce infant mortality. Those who have made a study of the subject estimate that half of those who die can be saved. But this is only one side of the picture. The object of those who are promoting the Philadelphia exhibli- tion is not merely to keep more chil- dren alive; it is no less the intention to make life worth more to them by seeing that they have a fair start. There is one advantage about high prices: they swell the totals of statistics. Here, for instance, are the figures on our imports of luxuries for the nine months ending with March. If prices were lower, could we be sure of the sat- isfaction that goes with the breaking of records? For in many of the articles, and especially in the more important ones, the imports of this fiscal year will exceed in value those of any year pre- vious. The whole amount is estimated at $200,000,000. Art works show an in- crease of 50 per cent. over the highest value reached heretofore; they will ap- proximate $40,000,000 for the year. Much of this, presumably, is to be credited to the transfer of the Morgaa treasures. But diamonds and other precious stones, al- though they wil: not break the records | of 1907 and 1910, will probably exceed works of art in value. The largest item, however, is laces and embroideries, which are expected to go beyond dia-| monds by about $3,000,000. This is an increase of 50 per cent. during the dec- ade. Tobacco and manufactures thereof will add up to more than $30,000,000, and we shall have received nine million dollars’ wortn of toys. If the larger Eu- ropean countries sent us as much in pro- portion as some of the smallest, our luxuries would swamp us. Switzerland supplies about one-third of the leading | group of imports, the laces and embroid- eries, and Belgium and the Netherlands provide the bulk of our cut diamonds. English Catholics are undoubtedly de- riving a vast amount of quiet satisfac- tion out of the debates in the House of Commons over the Welsh Disestablish- ment bill. The cause of it all is Lloyd George's charge, flung forth more as a taunt than as an argument, that some The Nation of the men who are vehemently de’ nouncing the disestablishment of the Church in Wales as spoliation, are now the owners and occupiers of lands seiz- ed from the Church at the time of the Reformation. Goaded to fury by the per- sonal invective hurled at him by the Opposition, Lloyd George returned to the attack: What was the story of the pillage at the Reformation? They robbed the Catholic Church, they robbed the monasteries, they robbed the almshouses, they robbed the poor, and they robbed the dead, Then they come here, and when we try to recover some part ot the pillage for the poor they accuse us of theft, these people whose hands are drip- ping with the fat of sacrilege. Catholic historians have always ex- plained the Reformation as largely a movement on the part of the ruling classes to enrich themselves at the ex- pense of the Church, in England as in Germany. But there must be few Cath- olic historians who have put the case as forcefully as the great representative of English Nonconformity did last week. If we remember, furthermore, that Eng- lish Nonconformity regards itself as the true continuator of the Reforma- tion as against the Catholicizing tenden- cies in the Established Church, there is a full measure of irony in the spectacle of the Chapel to-day trying to redress the wrongs done to the Church of Rome four hundred years ago. If Thomas Carlyle had been alive to- day and preparing a new edition of “Sartor Resartus,’ he would have found excellent material for a foot-note in the story of the elderly gentleman in a sack-suit who was found dead in the streets of Hamburg and removed to the morgue: Often in my atrabiliar moods [says Car- lyle], when I read of pompous ceremonials, Frankfort Coronations, Royal Drawing- rooms, Levees, Couchees; and how the ush- ers and macers and pursuivants are all in waiting; how Duke This is presented by Archduke That, and Colonel A by General B, and innumerable Bishops, Admirals, and miscellaneous Functionaries, are advanc- ing gallantly io the Anointed Presence; and I strive, in my remote privacy, to form a clear picture of that solemnity—on a sud- den, as by some enchanter’s wand, the— shall I speak it?—the Clothes fly-off the whole dramatic corps; and Dukes, Grandees, Anointed Presence iIt- straddling Bishops, Generals, self, every mother’s son, stand there, not a shirt on them; and I know not whether to laugh or weep But what would Carlyle have said of Anointed Presence reduced to the anony- mity of the cold marble slab and that 5OT ultimate garment, the common winding sheet, which wipes out all the differences and distinctions that all preceding Clothes create? All Socialists are bad enough, but a clever Socialist is positively beyond the pale. What, for instance, could be worse than this utterance of the German So- cialist, Philip Scheidemann, in com- menting upon the recent threat of the Kaiser that he would incorporate Al- sace-Lorraine into Prussia if it did not behave itself and do what he wished: We regard it as a momentous confes- sion, when from a competent source in- corporation into Prussia is threatened as the most severe punishment that can be inflicted upon a people—a punishment like imprisonment and the forfeiture of civil rights. Now, instead of ignoring this remark the Chancellor.played directly into the hands of Herr Scheidemann by walking out of the Reichstag together with the other members of the Government. Lat- er, however, the Chancellor thought it wise to come back and defend the Kaiser, declaring that the Emperor was “naturally angry” at the recent conduct of Alsace-Lorraine, but that he had not meant to trespass upon the rights of the Bundesrath or the Reichstag, which alone have the power to revoke the Con- stitution of Alsace-Lorraine. It was only the other day that that Constitution was granted and hailed as proof that the captured provinces were now once more wholly German. But having autonomy, it likes to do things its own way; hence the Emperor's tactful smash your Constitution to fragments.” remark, “I'll A force of four thousand men, eager, anxious, and determined, has been re |ported by a Chinese newspaper to be marching upon Peking. The announce- ment has caused no alarm in the capl- tal, however, because their only weap- ons are Chinese pens, ink-slabs, and such things, and they are seeking not lives, but offices. Reformers may think that the new Government will make short work of many of the sinecures maintained by the old, says the Celestial Empire of Shanghai, but it will do no- thing of the kind, for the simple rea- son that it cannot. “For every needed man in China there are five at least to do the work.” Supernumeraries are a part of the Chinese method of doing business. ate a? ew LS
Page 6
508 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2447 OUR ENSLAVED CITIZENSHIP. In Ohio last Friday Theodore Roose- velt defined his principles and his plat- form in a single compact sentence: “I am tor solutely, so far it represents, but as when the representative government does not represent, then I want the peo- Like other definitions from the same itself to at Mr. ple to have a chance themselves.” »> many ree, this sentence lends last two Interpretations Roose- iy have meant that he favors rep- e government as a theory, but has broken down among be theory and must therefore Or he may have meant that pr ntative government should be re it functions well, but must ented or replaced by the di the people where it fails to econd interpretation, afest, is probably the elt would give to his own At, R ‘ {oo0eey vhichever meaning we lend il statement of creed, it will oticed that thing is taken for one existence of a free But both—the these United States. this wheels of What trying to do is to is caught in the us political machinery. essives” are lace this system with a more efficient tem of machinery which will neither eflect nor frustrate the will of this free agent, the American people. But there are progressives who appar- ently conceive their task as much more thoroughgoing than a mere overhauling of the machinery of government. They in vision not only a political, but a ial, revolution. Mr. Ray Stannard Bak- er, in the American Magazine, sums up differences between conservatives and progressives as follows of to-day—Taft, willing to tinker in small But the deeper. yw the conservatives ind others—are and : ! 1 few ul of the l let In ae sharers of government, redistribute benefits thus material progressives goes susinesa men and property owners » long dominated the country, an ase of people further down in nominally vot- to say though had cale nen who h reality nothing th government are ours. But we would fin- uur quotation with a sentence from a preceding paragraph which Mr. Baker has himself italicized Every political revolution ia caused by the effort of a clase demo new of people to oet into the acy s a representative government ab- We are here evidently speaking of a far lers have managed to reduce the prop- different thing from what Mr. Roose- velt means when he speaks of the Peo- ple. When Mr. Baker speaks of “an im- mense class of people further down in the scale,” who are to wrest a share of power from “the business men and prop- erty owners who have so long dominat- ed the country,” he is evidently refer- ring to what the Socialists describe as the proletariat, the great unpropertied classes, the hewers of wood and draw- ers of water. Mr. Roosevelt takes the People we all think of, millionaire and mill-hand, big business man and small business man, big farmer and small farmer. And he finds that all that is necessary is to free this People from the domination of the Bosses, and the will of the People will be done. But Mr. Baker feels that, after we are rid of the Bosses, there will remain the es- sential task of vindicating the rights of the factory worker and the farm hand against the business man, large and small, and the farmer, large and small. There is no way of getting around the fact—it is the “lower” classes against the “middle” class. Which view is the dominant one among “we progressives,” Mr. Roose- velt’s view or Mr. Baker's, there is no of But one thing ars not reconcilable. that by ascertaining. s clear—the Mr. Baker means two charges the govern- ment is monopolized those very classes—our American business men and property owners—whose cause Mr. Roosevelt has pleaded more than that of any other section of the community. What Mr. Roosevelt and Mr. Baker have in common is that certain alterations in the political machinery will remedy ex- isting wrongs; Mr. Roosevelt holds much the better ground For the wrongs Mr. Baker and in this matter the two. has in mind are so deep-seated and so bound with structure of our society that to imagine of up the entire economic them curable by a few political reforms is absurd. Just how have the proper- tied classes so deprived the proletariat of its proper share in the government? Surely, these millions and millions of farmers, manufacturers, shop-keepers, and professional men have not been ac- tually buying up the Legislatures and the judges, as Big Business is supposed to do. Then it must mean that by class prestige alone, by their higher position in the economic scale, the property own- ‘ertyless to the point where “they have in reality had nothing to say about the government.” If middle-class prestige has hitherto induced the workingman to use his ballot on election day against his own interests, why should it fail to do the same on primary day? Common to all the progressive schools is the assumption that there is a peo- ple that must be freed. Mr. Baker’s Peo- ple is enslaved by the propertied classes, and Mr. Roosevelt’s is enslaved by the Bosses. The fact remains that there is an enslaved citizenship among us and that representative furnishes the shackles that bind the serf. What is needed is a political revolution, Pro- gressivism stands for the popular elec- tion of Senators; it does not matter that under representative government we have virtually attained the popular elec- tion of Senators. Progressivism stands for direct primaries: it does not matter that in virtually half dozen years representative government has insured the triumph of the direct primary sys- Progressivism stands for the com- government a tem. mission form of government: in half a dozen years under the pall of represen- tative government the commission form of government has spread over the coun- try. No revolutions have been neces- sary to conquer these rights. People had only to make up their minds as to what they wanted, and representative govern- ment did not stand in the way of their getting it. It is not an enslaved citizenship that we have had, but in the largest measure an independent people. A nation is not saved by machinery, though the ma- chine may help. A resolute people will be free under representative govern- ment, and an indifferent people will be enslaved despite all primaries and ref- erendums. THE SUIT AGAINST THE “COFFEE TRUST.” Some novel and peculiarly interesting questions are involved in the suit, be- gun by the Federal Government on Sat- urday, against the agents of the much- discussed “coffee valorization” plan. Considered merely as an avowed at- ‘tempt to hold up the price of coffee, in America as elsewhere, through buying up huge quantities and keeping them from the market, it can scarcely be re- garded as anything but restraint of
Page 7
May 23, 1912] . The Nation 509 trade. That the price would have gone lower but for these forestalling opera- tions, is not denied by the authors of the plan; it is even asserted as their original purpose. That the holding back from market of more than 10,000,000 bags of coffee, while the world’s annual crop has ranged from 14,500,000 to 23,- 800,000 bags, has given the bankers’ committee almost absolute control of the market, is an accepted fact in the coffee trade. Furthermore, that the price of coffee has advanced at a rapid rate since 1906, when the operations of the bankers be- gan, is fully admitted. The Government's petition sets forth that this advance has amounted to 100 per cent., and it is matter of public record that a minimum selling price for the coffee thus acquir- ed was stipulated in the contract of the bankers. That the committee’s practice is to sell their holdings only in such quantities that the price will not be af- fected by the sales, and that they “re- quire an express contract from purchas- ers that they will not resell the coffee purchased, on the Coffee Exchange,” the Government positively alleges. All this, if applied to a domestic industry, would appear to constitute a pretty clear case of violation of the Anti-Trust law. The unusual aspect of the so-called “coffee valorization plan,” however, is that it does not apply to a domestic product, and that the plan was initiated under the auspices and at the behest of a foreign Government. Brazil, which raises about three-fourths of the world’s supply of coffee, produced in 1906 a crop larger by nearly 40 per cent. than in any previous year. The natural course of the market, in response to this pros- pect of an unprecedented increase in supplies, caused a commotion in Brazil- ian business circles much like the ex- citement which prevailed in our South- ern States when last year’s 16,000,000- bale cotton crop was being harvested There was talk in Brazil in 1906, as there was at New Orleans in 1911, of the impending ruin of planters and grow- ers. It resulted in legislation by the Brazilian state of Sao Paulo, subse- quently followed by legislation on the part of the Brazilian Federal Govern- ment, which led to the contract with the bankers. The Brazilian state borrowed $75,- 000,000 on its bonds from an interna- tional banking syndicate. With the proceeds of the loan, the Government’ ] bought great amounts of coffee from its | Own producers, and placed this coffee in the hands of a committee in which the Government, the international bankers, and vertain foreign coffee merchants were represented. It stipulated with great precision, in that contract, how the coffee market should be handled in the sale of these holdings, and as secur- ity for its foreign loan it pledged the public credit, the coffee itself, and the proceeds of a Brazilian export tax on coffee—which tax was to increase after exports had passed a given total. It will readily be seen, therefore, that some novel considerations enter into the present case. The contention of the syn- dicate, voiced by one of its members, Mr. Herman Sielcken of New York, in his testimony before the “Money Trust committee” last week, was that the whole operation was an affair of the Brazilian Government, with which our Government had no business to inter- fere. The Department of Justice, in its petition of Saturday, answers that acts and agreements in American trade, which are unlawful under our statutes, cannot be made lawful by the fact that they “were not unlawful in Brazil and were participated in by a foreign state.” It points out that the United States con- sumes 40 per cent. of all the coffee used in the world, and insists that no ap- proval or participation, on the part of a foreign state, can “serve as a protection to defendants as to any acts committed thereunder in the United States.” The petition therefore asks that the entire valorization scheme, in so far as it af- fects our own interstate or foreign com- merce, be declared illegal; that the syn- dicate be perpetually enjoined from holding its coffee accumulations off the market, or from selling with the con- dition that the purchaser shall not re- sell, and that a Federal receiver be ap- pointed to take charge of the coffee holdings, under authority of the courts. The situation created, or which may be created later on, is interesting and unusual. It is not clear, for instance, just how far even the granting of the Government petition would affect the “valorization plan,” since only a part of the syndicate’s coffee holdings are stor- ed in this country. Nor is it easy to foresee in just what spirit the Brazilian Government will meet this action of our own Federal authorities towards the plan which Brazil itself devised. These considerations, it should be observed, do not affect the intrinsic merits of the val- orization scheme itself. We have be- lieved from the first that the project embodied thoroughly unsound finance, from the standpoint alike of the Brazil- ian Government and of the coffee mar- ket. It is one of the most dangerous applications which our time has wit- nessed of the attempt to meddle with the normal processes of trade through lavish use of credit. THE COLOR LINE AT THE BAR. In their efforts to drop from its mem- bership the able and attractive Assis- tant Attorney-General of the United States, Mr. William H. Lewis, the offi- cials of the American Bar Association are more and more shaming themselves and the body for which they speak. Mr. Lewis, it will be remembered, is a man of color, a graduate of Amherst and Harvard, for years in the Federal Dis- trict Attorney's office in Boston, and now a trusted assistant of Mr. Wicker- sham. He was invited to join the Bar Association by a committee of its Bos- ton members, urged to recruit its ranks, Had he not become conspicuous by rea- son of his appointment to office in Washington, he would to-day be peace- fully a member of the Association. When opposition to his confirmation de- veloped, somebody noticed that he was a member, and then the trouble began. The President of the Bar Association, Mr. Stephen 8S. Gregory, suddenly dis- covered that the Association was a social body, with whose pleasures at its annual convention Mr. Lewis might interfere, if he should happen to attend. He then set up the remarkable plea that Mr. Lewis was elected under false pretences, that is, “misapprehension,” because there was not written all over his nom- ination papers the word “colored.” Of course, the Boston committee knew who Mr. Lewis was when they certified him to the executive committee for elec- tion as a desirable member. For six months he exercised his membership; then he was asked voluntarily to re- tire and give up something “obtained under a misapprehension.” Indeed, it speedily appeared that he had actually committed a crime, for he was “insist- ing on retaining the advantages of an election thus obtained’’—obtained by in- vitation of the Boston membership com- mittee and duly ratified by the execu- a ee eee ee es te
Page 8
510 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 tive committee. to fence of having a dark skin. This, of course, added the heinousness of the original of- The execu- committee then revoked his elec- What Mr. Wickersham, thought of this action ap- tive tion. the Attorney-General, pears from these his words: months later in executive com- third of Ww x ibership has ted nority with in the \ssociation, the election 1 the list This rtala rship of ce the Associa constitu to limit they mem- tion nev- the power had of the elected it in con Asso st) ny discussion of ot de- a mem t annual me th Association ne u er eting neantime privit s of ill rights as ber Truly an extraordinary action for a bedy which presumes in its membership to other the and dignity of the law; which represent more than any majesty assumes to enhance public respect for the profession and to resent with all its power lawlessness in every form! In the course of their astounding and indefensible actions the officials of the Bar Association declared that this case was exceptional, as Mr. Lewis was the only colored man on its rolls. “No per- whatever of another race has been that Mr. George Whitelock, the s0n elected to membership,” wrote Amazing the person, Secretary of Association, who recently been to Wickersham compelled that if write notify gen- such has Mr tleman that able continued to him vigorous (and, he might have added, unanswerable) letters, he should be obliged to refuse to acknowledge or re- Then it promptly appear- ed Butler Wilson of R. ris of Minneapolis, were members, and of Mr. Wilson of the local enter- welcomed ply to them. that two other colored men, Boston and William Mor- horror horrors was actually a member tainment committee whk h the while Association on its visit to Boston, Vir. Morris has been a member for some years. That made a quandary for two such enlightened men as Messrs. Gregory and Whitelock, who had repre- sented, with Alice-through-the-Looking Glass logic, that in the case of Mr. Lewis . of ineligibility of col- ored men to membership in the Asso- laration . ciation, but only a recision of the par- ticular election by the committee, which had occurred without knowledge on its part of the candidate’s race—regarded as a material consideration in electing!” But Whitelock have grasped the bull by the horns; to Messrs. Gregory and prove that there is really no caste or color feeling in the Association, they have merely notified Messrs. Wilson and Morris that their cases will be brought before and that this notice is given them to “avoid the executive committee, any imputation of laches” and that they “may have an opportunity, should [they] so desire, of retiring from the Associa- tion before any action is taken, and without any publicity.” To this Mr. Morris has replied in a letter which should stir every lawyer who reads it to fresh protests against this deliberate degrading of the Bar As- sociation, and would of itself, we are certain, insure the liveliest annual meet- ing which this body of lawyers has known, perhaps, in its history. Whitelock Have been deluged with protests from all over Messrs. Gregory and already the United States. no wise connected with the legal pro- fession have protested against this out- rage. As one lawyer of national stand- irg writes us: The issue having been made, there wil’ be presented to an association of five thou- sand American lawyers the question whe- ther they propose to go on record as ex- cluding from their numbers members of their own profession, of approved character, both individuals and as lawyers, on account of their color. 1 cannot doubt what the resuJt of that issue will be, nor the im- of flinching it, although may, and probably will, result in split- Association ixto two parts. as possibility from it ting the By all means, let the Association be split apart if need be in order that the country may know that at least a part of the legal profession will not stand for such lawlessness, injustice, and narrow prejudice as seem to actuate the pres- ent officers of the Association. THE ART OF GREAT FICTION, There have been frequent attempts within the past few years to bring back into serious fiction something of its mid- | Victorian spirit. The movement, if that word is not too formal, began with the first novel of De Morgan. A sense of Men of standing in| | single career, which Dickens and Thack- /eray knew so well how to create, was }given in “Joseph Vance.” Leisureliness ‘again came into fiction. Many were ap- palled at the size of De Morgan's vol- The reading of a novel had come to be thought of as the work of one sitting, ume and prophesied failure for it. preferably on a short journey. But De Morgan’s books did succeed amazingly. It was seen that he had turned his back on the ingenuity and other artificial cleverness which went into the making of the ordinary novel, and had his eye on real life. If amusement could be got by the way, well and good, but for his appeal the author relied most upon the cumulative effect of a career looked at Life had tu be represented. Following De Mor- in Great Britain and on from many angles. en bloc gan, writers the Continent, not so much in this coun- try, have been striving for similar large effects. Arnold Bennett is perhaps the most notable instance, but several oth- ers could be cited, notably A. E. W. Mason, Birmingham, Richard Pryce, and the author of “Jean-Christophe.” The feeling will not down, however, that the work of such men, with the | possible exception of De Morgan, lacks ‘some vital element of the older spirit. Is this want perhaps due to a change of method in manipulating individual 'scenes? Despite the care given by Dick- ens and George Eliot to the impression |of a work as a whole, in each of their stories a few separate scenes contrive to stand out indelibly. A rehearsal of them here is not necessary; every one will recall them fer himself. Both writers, in a word, did a great deal of editing o? material, and then committed to a small number of scenes, highly elabor- ated, the most significant moments. Not that their books could be reduced at once to scenarios. There is much neces- sary description and narration, but these usually prepare the way for animated scenes full of dialogue..That it is prep- aration is obvious after a little analysis. 'The ancestry and previous activity of icharacters are sketched at length, to give them a running start for the real scenes in which they are to figure. But the scenes themselves assume the main importance. So it is plain that the plan ‘of a story, thus managed, is dependent “upon certain fundamental laws of art. ‘Not actual life, but the impression of the executive committee made “no dec-|the fulness of life surrounding even a | actual life, is given. How to select and
Page 9
May 23, 1912] The Nation 511 seemingly not omit, and, above all, how to present vividly, are the problems with which Dickens, let us say, was concerned. He placed his emphasis upon the scene, giving sense of life by much use of conversation, and trusted largely to the principle of suggestion to bridge the gaps. The method of our moderns is very different. “Jean-Christophe” and Mr. Pryce’s “Christopher” for a moment as examples. may serve In each case the hero is followed from birth until well on is set forth, and he is looked at from in life; his outer and inner being innumerable angles. And yet there is scarcely scene of length in either book. in order to furnish settings one any Scraps of conversation are recounted for extended analysis of the hero's sev- eral stages of development. The analy- sis is often brilliant, and especially in the case of “Jean-Christophe” the most transitory, intangible feelings are with amazing insight and power of expression. life there is, too; only it is not edited and selected after the manner of the older writers. The result is a vague recollec- tion, on the part of the reader, of a story collectively or in parts. The way of Mr. Bennett differs some- what from that of his two contempo- raries. Scenes he has, sometimes of monumental length. Yet he, too, usual- ly gives the impression of being a chron- icler rather than a novelist. His dis- trust of the Victorian art shows itself not by his readiness to turn with un- due haste from an outward situation to an interpretation of inward broodings. He dwells lovingly on external details. Little men and women, in his most con- scientious wend their ways through a scrupulously accurate world. Yet, for all that, his scenes more often than not lack the Victorian objectivity, because his emendation of the old artis- tic doctrine of muiltum in parvo to crystallized Fulness of works, | mend itself. Perhaps it would if the stories which are put upon the stage were better than they are, But the artificiality of their scenes and their trivial purpose have caused the more thoughtful writers to suspect that all scenes so fashioned are not true to life. The suffered in consequence. Victorian model has It has appeared to them to be in structure and method of a piece with recent trash. So it has come about that writers who started out somewhat consciously to reinstate the Victorian spirit have neglected one of its most important elements; or rather have tried to replace it by something better. We suspect, however, that the broad out- lines of the many notable scenes which come to mind from the older day are still worthy of careful imitation. THROUGH THE OUTLOOKING GLASS the dear old lady in a could not help uttering At the sight of pannier gown, Alic¢« au little ery of delight. “Do let me introduce she the Red Knight, and she ran forward, pull- you,” said to ing his steed along by the rein. “The Red Knight, Mrs. Malaprop,” she said, and beamed upon both of them “Not the Mrs. Malaprop,” said the Red Knight, holding out one hand and clinging to the saddle with the other. “The same,” said the old facilitate you upon the results and Pennsylvania?” “I thank you,” said the Red Knight. “I have often heard you spoken of as one of our leading simplified spellers. If I am not your grandfather was Col. Lapsus “may I Illinois lady ; in mistaken, Lingu@ of Faux Pas.” “He was,” said the old lady. mother’s side I am related to the Bulls of Ireland and the Hiatuses of Prattling Com- If an old woman's good wishes count “And on my mon. for anything “Madam,” said the Red Knight, California, I freely recognize the extraor- dinary mental and moral qualities of our women voters.” “I have long wished to tell you,” the old woman, “how I admire the torious career of one whom I regard as the most Perkinacious of all our candidates.” “Pert, not Perk,” hinted Alice, gently. “Perk or Pert, what difference it make?” said the old lady. “We live not by “after said vie- does not enough he should have a if only by Hannalogy. Now I that right.” she said, turning Alice If two are third term, hope I got defiantly to But Alice’s feelings were hurt, and she said nothing. “And so,” concluded the old lady, “I hope that you will succeed in keeping up your blic inter spontaneous consumption of publi and that you won't let them take away your Southern renegades “Delega " said Alice befor | stop herself But the old lady only glared at ind went on addr ge the Red Knigl And ay all your enemié be like that |! : h duke who Was drowned in a barr M Ma \ lk r abl to control |! f But tl R Knight ‘ rne | to ) , : ] } ’ ] ’ y ; > } stion, my dear Ali l hall i} th rul ‘ lang the bosses who wri t i i NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES the invaluable ninth edit t ett's Familiar Quotations th Walter Raleigh ‘ Soul bod re + I na ‘ t Fear n t hest The itl be vy wart t Go, since I needs must d And give the world the It is also, with a dozen other sextains of similar form, found in several poetical anthologies with the same credit In other collections it is attributed to Joshua Syl vester, whose death occurred a few weeks before that of Sir Walter It should seem desirable at present to examine the grounds which the credit ought to be based the second folio edition of Sylvester's 1633, the fore- slight differ- en- or. In collected stanza works, printed in with twenty, together All following having la- appears, first of Soul's Errand.” going ences, as the titled “The the first are tionship with the stanza at the beginning and quatraina, close re In of a hundred fifty Thon “The Lie,” above, of the neighborhood years afterwards as Percy published a poem entitled the lines reproduced immediately Each beginning with followed ster quat and Sylve had however, a by six rains quatrain attached a a sort of refrain, effect that if the parties should presun tc “make reply, all lie!” There were also some negligible verbal half a version couplet then give them the stanzas not n added, finished look changes, and cozen Sylvester's were givine to than the the revision a more multum in multo has not yet proved to | the letter of the law, but by its spirituous original could show Percy’s well-known consultation. I have known candidates who propensity to alter verses coming within be true art or true psychology. It is have fought hard for their own ends, but his editorial purview being considered, to- again a case of refusing to edit properly.|none whose motives are so absolutely gether with the fact that no copy of his That the Victorian scene, so excellent Flinnathropic.” rendering of this poem exists of a date “Philanthropic,” suggested Alice, in a earlier than that for which he was plainly as it usually is, has been discredited by whisper. responsible, makes it very probable that serious workmen, seems strange, espe- “Please don’t interrogate so much,” said “The Lie,” as it now stands, was aptly cially at a time when the common run the old lady, but still without losing her entitled, and wag constructed by him on temper. “When I meet a public man who the foundation of “The Soul's Errand” in of novels are so closely related to the |i. ps ready to capitalize a own interests the folio of 1633 stage. Good sellers of this class are | to those of his country——” After considering all the arguments at- quickly dramatized and popular plays | “Sacri——” Alice started to say, but tainable in favor of Raleigh's authorship of id a ” ! |}caught herself in time. the revised verses, I cannot perceive that are “novelized.” One would think anid “Why, then,” went on the old lady, “he there is even one of any real weight. No the older pattern would strongly recom-! ought to have as many terms as he likes.. predecessor of Bishop Percy ever attributed
Page 10
512 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 them to Raleigh, so far as is known, and no trustworthy his era has pro- fessed to evidence tending to prove that Raleigh ever had anything to them Charles Sprague, a torlous minor American poet, did the best, that could be for the con- Sir Walter's favor, without the Atlantic Monthly for He frankly confessed at that he was strongly prejudiced Sylvester's claims, and desired to the Elizabethan courtier “had offspring his author sing have seen any do with meri- probably done t ntion in falsification November in 1867 the outset against feel that behind brain him as the of the impressive time.” Yet he “It is true I am not I think I prove it Sylvester.” It certain- claimed that Syl- was the of that particular ire of “The eeing that there is no authentic rec- eat one most any was admit yrrove it: but ot written by nnot be reasonably architect called verse generally its existence in that form for a hun- ind fifty but I original from which the later ver- It 80 many of and it was placed publicly years after the death of thar see no good reason to doubt was Sylvester’s work which productions was shaped has the noticeable rugged earnestness is in other the old puritan to his credit within fifteen years from his death by his poraries so far record. and never questioned con- as there is any If Sylvester's poem had been adapted from given out Percy, the spelling “ar- would not have been changed to “er- rand,” since the evident ith the former with the latter, while both forms of the word are found, for instance, in the Shakespeare Follo of 1623. And it is difficult to imagine Walter saying ( in lines common to the two versions), that royal court “glows and shines like rot- that the “doth no good,” “are that by rant” is more than rhyme v orthography Sir as is said some of the the ton wood,” Church that give if - brown-paint of nearly, and brazenly cites as his authority entitled “Sir Walter There evidence loved unless they the added potentates the Second Folio not of reply, Collier, amender of the reproduces Percy's version potentates couplets, the notorious and in one potentates give Payne Shakespeare an alleged manuscript Lye - that anybody else ever saw the manuscript, and | heard that the name “Wrawly” be found elsewhere in that seems that the six stanzas were taken for “The Lie,” and latter was the work either of Bish- Wrawly his is no have never was to It wrote certain which form fairly Bvivester from the prem of strongest vee in the constructioa of that the op Percy or of some acquaintance of his THERON WILBER HAIGHT. Correspondence .- UNCONSCIOUS HUMOR OR TINCTION? A NICE DI8- To THE Outside the legal profession the only man who will not smile when he reads the Illinois SupremeCourt decision, in the case against George Clark, charged with operat- is John Dembinski, > Eprrorn or THe NATION: Sin ing a confidence game, the victim of the game The decision in question reverses a ver- dict which provided a term in the peni- tentiary for Clark, and furnished, substan- tially, the only satisfaction Dembinski got | out of the matter. As it was among a large number of opinions handed down when the court adjourned, it escaped the attention of the press, or, if seen, presented so small an element of news value that the mere title of the case was published without comment. The original arraignment charged that Clark “did unlawfully and feloniously ob- tain from John Dembinski his money by means and by use of the confidence game.” He was tried, and after a petit jury had declared him guilty, a sentence of ten years’ imprisonment in the penitentiary was im- posed upon him. The case was appealed to the Supreme Court, Clark’s counsel set- ting up the usual charges of irregularity in the process by which he was brought to jus- tice, insisting that the indictment was faul- ty, that the trial was improperly held, and that finding was not justified. Par- ticular emphasis was placed upon the form of the indictment, and upon this phase of the proceedings the decision of the higher court rests. The opinion declares that the presentment was indefinite inasmuch as it failed to point out whose money Clark acquired from Dem- binski! As indicated, the indictment says that Clark obtained “from Dembinski his money,” and the court is of the idea that this statement may have misled some one, being subject to misconstruction. The pro- noun “his,” it maintains, might as correct- ly refer to the defendant as to Dembin- ski: “It would be as easy to say that the defendant obtained his own money from Dembinski, as that he obtained the money of Dembinski.” That the opinion rendered in the case might be made still clearer, the court adds: “A conclusion that the pronoun referred to Dembinski rather than the de- fendant could only be sustained on the ground that the grand jury intended to charge the defendant with a crime.” Since, in the opinion of the court, so violent an assumption would be contrary to all rules of criminal pleading, it is wholly out of the question to figure that the grand jury was endeavoring to accuse Clark of doing something criminal when it indicted him. And since it has no other means of deter- mining, from the indictment, whether the grand jury was trying to bring Clark to trial for getting Dembinski’s money in an unlawful manner, or was simply recording the unusual circumstance of a man “un- lawfully and feloniously” obtaining his own the money, the trial is irregular and the case) must be reversed. Occurrences of this character, of course, are to be regretted, but they are likely to continue so long as carelessness obtains in the drawing of court papers and the uncer- tainties of the English language are ignor- ed in their preparation—the preparation of court papers Perhaps we should add that Chief Jus- tice Carter filed a dissenting opinion in this case, holding that it “seems clear to me that the pronoun ‘his’ referred to Dem- binsk! and not to Clark.” J. H. RocKWELL. May 14 Springfleld, I1., A SPANISH SUMMER SCHOOL. |'To THE Ep1IToR OF THE NATION: €rr: For several years the various uni- | versities of France have had summer schools 'for foreigners and have advertised, by means of brilliant posters, their attractions | —picturesque, historical, and intellectual. |/Many Americans have spent summers at | these schools with much enjoyment and pro- fit. Few, however, know of the existence of 'a Spanish summer school which has been |eonducted very successfully the last four |years at Burgos. It is part of the large | work done by the eminent Spanish scholar, 'M. Ernest Mérimée of the University of | Toulouse. To his efforts are due exchanges |of professors among French, Spanish, and | Portuguese universities, as well as spring |courses at Madrid and summer courses at | Burgos for French students. The courses lat Madrid last from Easter to June and ‘are intended primarily for the candidates |for the agrégation. These are advanced |eourses in literature and philology: some of which are given by no less an authority ithan D. Ramén Menéndez Pidal himself. There are also classes affording practice in | the spoken language. These courses are of |interest to such of our scholars as are for- |tunate enough to have a year abroad. To those who have merely a summer to spend ‘in Spain, the courses at Burgos are more important, | The Instituto francés en Espafa, or the | Unién de estudiantes franceses y espafoles, |holds its classes in the building of the In- | stituto provincial of Burgos. The school | begins the first Monda in August, and lasts | six weeks. Although supported primarily |by the universities of Toulouse and Bor- | deaux, the courses are free to all French- |men. Persons not French or Spanish are |also allowed to attend, but pay a fee lof 60 pesetas. As yet, few such have lattended the school—not more than ltwo or three in a summer. The | courses, which are given by professors of |the Instituto of Burgos or from Madrid, are divided into two sections, elementary and advanced. A student must enroll in one of these, but he is allowed to attend the other as a listener. The classes come in the morning or late afternoon, and occupy about twelve hours a week. The books studied are those of the French official programme for that year. In the summer of 1911 the courses were somewhat as follows—Ele- mentary: grammar, composition, oral and written practice, translation from Le Sage and Galdés; Advanced: reading, comment, and translation based on Bruno’s “Fran- cinet,” La Fontaine’s “Fables,” the “Ro- mancero Caballeresco,” the “Marcos de Obreg6n,” with lectures on Spanish litera- ture. In addition to the Spanish courses there are French courses for the natives of Bur- gos. These also are open to the foreigner, but many of our students would find them rather elementary. In these, however, as in the Spanish courses, one gets practice in both languages. The Spanish courses are taken by about eighty French students of both sexes, and of varying ages and attain- ments. The majority come from southern France, and one hears a good deal of the resonant French of that district. There is always a number from northern France as well. Inasmuch as many of the students are studying English and eager to practice it, one would have no difficulty in arranging
Page 11
May 23, 1912] The Nation 513 an exchange of lessons, despite the Euro- pean prejudice against American English. Examinations are held at the end of the session and diplomas awarded; certificates of attendance are given to those obliged to leave before the close. The teachers and officers of the Instituto are eager to make one’s stay pleasant and profitable. Board in Spanish casas de huéspedee costs from three pesetas a day. A kindly and efficient physician looks out for the health of the school. The people of Burgos are interested in the undertaking and most hospitably open the doors of their comfortable clubhouse—the Salén de Recreo --with its reading rooms and library. Thursdays are devoted to excursions, visiting the beautiful cathedral and other local monuments, or in longer trips to neighboring points interesting for historical or artistic reasons. Burgos was chosen on account of its near- ness to France and because of the excellent Spanish spoken there. Situated 2,785 feet above the sea, the climate is better than that of many places in Spain. In the hot summer of 1911, Burgos was among the six or seven coolest places out of a list of some thirty given in the daily weather reports. It was usually 8 degrees to 10 degrees cooler than Madrid. The school has been recognized by both Governments, and its officers have received decorations. Further information may be found in the files of the Bulletin Hispanique or by writing to the Instituto at Burgos. A. F. WHITTEM. Cambridge, Mass., May 16. THE PRIVY COUNCIL. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In your discussion of the home- rule question (Nation, April 25), you appear to have fallen into the mistake of believ- ing that the power conferred on the Privy Council, or, to be more accurate, the Ju- dicial Committee of the Privy Council, to pass upon the validity of acts of the Irish Parliament marks the introduction of a new principle into the English Qonstitu- tion. You further declare that the Privy Council does not possess such power in respect to the legislation of the self-gdv- erning colonies. The mistake, I believe, is due to confusing the Privy Council as a political body with the Privy Council in its judicial capacity or the Judicial Committee of the Privy Council. The political Privy Council, or the King in Council, or the Cabinet, has the right of veto on all colonial legislation. The Judicial Committee of the Privy Coun- cil is also capable of passing on the validi- ty of all colonial legislation which is car- ried on appeal as of right or of grace to the King. The Parliaments of the self-gov- erning colonies are not suvereign bodies as is the case with the Imperial Parliament. As non-sovereign bodies their legislation is subject to the same judicial control as are the by-laws of any municipal corpo- ration. The Judicial Committee frequently has occasion to set aside the legislation of the Parliaments of Canada and Aus- tralia just as our Supreme Court does the legislation of the States or Congress. There is, of course, a higher regard for an act of the legislature in an English or Colonial court than in an American) ! ' leourt, but nevertheless neither an English nor colonial court would hesitate to declare a colonial act unconstitutional in case it were in flagrant violation of the terms of the Constitution. That English and colo- nial courts do not so frequently set aside colonial acts as do American courts is largely owing to the fact that the principle of the separation of powers between legis- lative, executive, and judiciary does not find the same acceptance in English and colonial law as in the United States; and still further to the fact that the principle of constitutional guarantees of individual rights of person and property is not to be found to any extent in colonial Constitu- tions. The new Irish Constitution, however, contains such guarantees, so that we may find the Judicial Committee assuming a new jurisdiction in respect to this class of cases. But acts abridging personal or re- ligious freedom would undoubtedly be ve- toed by the Lord Lieutenant, and not be left to the subsequent determination of the judiciary. In view of the recent agitation for the re- call of judicial decisions it may be of some interest to your readers to know that, a proposal was made in the convention which drew up the Australian Common- wealth Constitution that when a law of the Commonwealth Parliament was declared unconstitutional by the High Court of Aus- tralia, the Governor-General in Council might, upon the adoption of a resolution by absolute majorities in both houses or, as was also suggested, in one house, refer the law to the electors for their approval: In the event of any law passed by the Federal Parliament being declared by any decision of the High Court to be ultra vires of this Constitution, the Executive may upon the adoption by absolute majori- ties in both houses of the legislature, with- in six months after the decision of the High Court of resolution thereto directing, refer the law to the electors under Section 121, and if approved or therein provided the Constitution shall be deemed to have been enlarged and the law shall have been con- clusively deemed to have been intra vires of this Constitution from the passing there- of. It will be observed that this proposal car- ried with it a formal amendment of the Constitution and was designed to introduce greater flexibility into the Constitution rather than to curtail the powers of the ju- diciary. But the proposal was so severely criticised by Messrs. Symon, Isaacs, and Barton, that the mover, Mr. Holder, with- drew it. The fact that the American public are now being urged to accept a proposal very similar in character to that which the makers of the Australian Constitution sum- marily rejected may well cause the electo- rate to pause and consider carefully the important constitutional principles involved in its determination. C. D. ALLIN. University of Minnesota, May 6 POSTAGE ON BOOKS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I should like to supplement the let- ter of Professor Holt (Nation, May 2) on the “Exorbitant Price of Books” by a note calling attention to the custom of pub- lishers of adding to the list price of books the cost of carriage by mail. This custom is without justification, and has the par- ticularly irritating effect on the mind of the purchaser which such exactions always have. To a student residing in the coun- try the custom adds greatly to the total cost of his library It is unjustifiable, as a book can be pur- chased at any first-class book store at the list price, and the increasing of this price by the cost of carriage by the publisher cannot be to protect the legitimate book trade, as this would be done amply were the publisher to furnish the book carriag free at list price If a booksellers’ agreement compels the custom, it should be abrogated, as it is a short-sighted policy, the irritation it leaves is far beyond any value it can have for the trade OSCAR WOODWARD ZEIGLER Baltimore, Md., May 10 CLEVELAND ON THE COURTS TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION Sir: In reading recently Geo. F. Parker's Recollections of Grover Cleveland” I came upon the following words spoken by Mr Cleveland to the author a few months be- fore his death. They are emphasized by the times: The most serious difficulty confronting this country is that of maintaining the su premacy of the law, and this can only be done by inspiring respect for the judgments of our courts All the enemies of our s80- jelety and institutions, and of the dominance in them of the civil power, recognize, as if by instinct, that if they would break them down or undermine them, it can only be done by reducing our courts to impo- tence. If their decrees are not respected, or their judges who preside over them are rot men of the highest reputation for ability and fairness, then all the forces of discon- tent will unite in an assault upon them To me, nothing can be more deplorable than that open criticism of the decisions of courts which, all at once, has become fashionable on the part of executive officers whether Presidents, Governors, Mayors, or whatever the rank or position They are danger signals, and failure to see them may introduce practices which wiil threaten the independence of the courts Wma. C. COLLAR. Waban, Mass., May 18. Literature A GREAT ENGLISH DIPLOMAT. Memoirs and Letters of the Right Hon. Sir Robert Morier, G.C.B., from 1826 to 1876. By his Daughter, Mrs. Ross lyn Wemyss. 2 vols. New York: Longmans, Green, & Co. $8.75 net. Although the English resent foreign criticism to a degree that is often amus- ing, they sometimes criticise themselves not only very frankly, but quite accur- ately. Thus at the time of the Boer War they admitted that it was too much “muddling through” a difficulty. Slace the Crimean War, which they drifted into without calculation and emerged from without glory, their military operations have been mostly “muddled,” but in no de- partment has this characteristic been more marked than in their diplomacy. their habit to trust to |From the Restoration on, the British i : . * er |
Page 12
514 The Na ti on [Vol. 94, No. 2447 Foreign Office acted upon the theory that it need not trouble itself to know or care much about foreign peoples or governments: for, of course, none of them could hope to rise into the sphere which Providence had assigned to Eng- lishmen. As a result, the diplomats who repre- sented England abroad possessed usual- ly many excellent qualities except those which were indispensable to success in Among the earlier Foreign Palmerston was equipped. Lord John Rus- sell, his superior in many ways, was still unable to see international relations steadily, much less to think out before- the policy to be adopted in any 1859, with laudable en- thusiasm, he “Italy for the Ital- his motto; but, only two years he so far misread the Zeitgeist’s intimations as to be ready to support the South against the North in the American Civil War. The quality which British diplomats and Foreign Secre- diplomacy. Secretaries not even adequately hand emergency. In made ians” later taries have too often lacked has been a sympathetic knowledge of the policy and aspirations of the countries with which they had to deal. facts are impressed upon us, contrast, in reading Sir Rob- “Memoirs’: for he was, in Italy, the These through Morier's with Sir James Hudson British diplomatist of the last genera- knew his field through and through. Moreover, that field was Ger- many, and it would have been well for England if she had been willing to lis- ten to Morier in the days before the rise of Prussia. What not merely the aver- age Englishman, but official and univer- , thought of the Germans in ert tion who sity circle the late fifties and early sixties of the last century can be learned from the pages of Punch. The German was sup- posed to be a fat, ponderous, rubicund who smoked huge pipes a yard long and drank gallons of beer. If he were a Gelehrter, he added to this equip- te llow, ment a pair of goggles. No Englishman pretended himself over the internal affairs of the or more German States; and, in- to bother forty deed, that was a tangle which even the historian finds it hard to unravel. Lord John Russell said, with a touch of pride, pian af- that himself and one other understood the Schleswig-Holstein fair, and that the other man was dead; but we question whether Lord John did not overrate his own competence on this occasion. And yet by 1864 Morier had been expounding German politics to the Foreign Office for seven or eight years. Robert Morier was born in 1826, of Huguenot ancestry. His father had been consul-general for France and minister to Switzerland, and one of his uncles wrote “The Adventures of Hajji Baha,” a book which had considerable vogue. More important as a formative influ- ence was the fact that this uncle, and only ‘other members of the family besides| Liberals, he hoped, at the outset, that his father, held diplomatic or other po-|the resurgence of Prussia would result sitions: so that he was born into the|in the formation of a free and united environment of a cosmopolite. But he | Germany: but, from the moment when had the education of the traditional| pigmarck took the helm in 1862, Morier Englishman, and he never wavered in began to fear that freedom would be his loyalty to the best English ideals. | At Balliol College, he formed with Jow- ett, nine years his senior, a friendship which lasted through life. Leaving Oxford ir 1849, Morier filled a small post in the Privy Council Office, in the hope of receiving a diplomatic appointment. This came in 1853 when he went as unpaid attaché to Vienna. Six years later he was transferred to Ber- lin, and asmallsalary was assigned him. In 1866, he went to Frankfurt just as the Confederation ceased to exist; and for the next ten years he served at Darm- stadt, Stuttgart, and Munich, until at last, in 1876, at the age of fifty, he was promoted to be minister at Lisbon. The mere list of his posts shows what un- usual opportunities he had for studying yermany on all sides. In addition, he travelled much in Italy and the Orient, and served on several special missions. He also possessed certain personal quali- ties which caused his fellow diplomats, statesmen, and even sovereigns to con- fide in him. Morier’s daughter has much as possible. exaggeration to say that her volumes contain more new sidelights on the uni- fication of Germany than can be found in any other Englisk work. Morier had a passion for thoroughness which, cou- pled with a marked historic sense, led him to prepare for the Foreign Office papers which, though probably seldom read by his superiors, have a lasting im- portance for the historian. We cannot imagine, for instance, that Lord Palm- erston, whom he describes capitally as “half-hornet, half-butterfly,” spent labori- ous evenings over Morier’s monographs on the “History of Prussia” (1859), and on the “Constitutional Conflict in Elec- toral Hesse.” But the Foreign Office soon discovered that Morier was more than a routine man, and it resented, rather than welcomed, his activity. “Above all, not too much zeal,” was the instruction his chief, quoting Talleyrand, solemnly gave him. The enthusiastic and conscientious diplomat, however, continued to furnish the information which he deemed it es- sential for the Foreign Office to know: and if the occupants of Downing Street did not listen attentively, personages not less important knew his value. For he was the friend of the Prussian Crown edited his| “Memoirs” with a view to presenting as | political and historical material | This is well, for it is no} |sacrificed. In the German nature two |spirits—the Spirit of Liberty, and the | Spirit of Authority—have been at war |for centuries. Had the German empire- /builder been a Cavour, devoted to Lib- erty, he would have rallied those forces and found them sufficient; but Fate as- | signed the task to Bismarck, who or- |ganized Authority to a degre of per- | fection that no German before him, not even Frederick, had attained. Although Morier seems to have had no personal clash with Bismarck, he early incurred the Chancellor’s hostility. This was inevitable. Morier did not |disguise his Liberalism, and in his let- | ters he criticised the brutal methods by 'whicn the new Prussian policy was driv- en through. On his side, Bismarck nat- urally hated a man who was the friend of his enemies and the confidant of the Crown Prince and Princess. To rid Prus- sia of the English influence which Prin- cess Victoria only too evidently and very indiscreetly worked to establish, became almost a Bismarckian obsession. He feared that, in spite of his Titanic efforts for Authority, constitutional Liberty of the English sort might win the day in Berlin: then farewell to the hoped-for German Empire dominated by Prussia. He feared not only the effects of example and propaganda, but also, when the Dan- ish imbroglio loomed up, of physical 'force. Being a man of few words and decisive acts, he assumed that the threat- ening dispatches from London would be followed by British ships. When he found, however, as Morier remarks, that the British energy was purely “literary,” he uttered the scathing comment that h® “had wasted several years of his po- litical life by the belief that England was a great nation.” It is the direct and indirect testimony |that Morier gives concerning the rise of Prussia, and especially his criticisms and revelations of Bismarck that consti- tite for historians the weightiest part of these memoirs. Although he was undoubtedly a hostile critic, yet he was no carper. He tried, above all, to see things as they were, and to report them ito the Foreign Office. The wonder is ithat English official circles, having his |inside reports, should have been taken _by surprise at each of Prussia’s victo- /rious advances. Perhaps his frank crit- }icism of England’s “parochial” foreign /policy, may have caused his superiors ‘to undervalue his soundness. Neverthe- Prince and of Princess Victoria, and he! less, Lord John admitted that, if Mort- served with equal loyalty to spread a/er’s advice had been taken promptly, the knowledge of Prussia among the English,| Danish Question would have been set- and of England among the Prussians. | tled without a war. Sympathizing heartily with the German! We are not positively informed that
Page 13
May 23, 1912] The Nation 515 Bismarck’s campaign of calumnies and | spies, actually drove Morier from Ber- lin, but we infer that he found his stay at Darmstadt and Munich less torment- ed. Most important are his chapters on the Franco-Prussian War. He de- plored the amazing indecision of Lord Granville at the opening of hostilities. “To feel that England is for the future but as a bit of wet blotting-paper among the nations,” he wrote, “does upset one’s serenity and makes one almost wish to be a Maori or a Turco, both of whom have some kind of individuality and self-assertion left.” Morier sympathized with the Germans, because he disliked the truculence of the French Imperial- ists, but when France was beaten he re- garded it as a tactical mistake for Ger- many to annex Alsace and Lorraine, and he had a foreboding that their colossal success would convert the Germans into a domineering nation. To his infinite regret, he soon saw that German unity, instead of bringing to pass a millen- nium of peace, as he had dreamed, sys- tematized militarism on a scale unap- proached even by Napoleon I. At Munich he had a venerated friend in Dr. Déllinger, who had striven man- fully to check the tide of Catholic reac- tion before it promulgated the dogma of papal infallibility. There is a curious and very enlightening report of an in- terview in 1872 between Morier and Arnim, when the latter was returning from a mission to Rome, where he had sounded the Vatican as to coming to more enlightened terms with Prussia. Arnim told him: that in judging the court at Rome it was before all things necessary to get rid of two widespread misconceptions: the ons that it was an intelligent body, the other that it was invulnerable. It was the least intelligent of existing political powers, it was highly vulnerable the moment people ceased to believe in its invulnerability. That to obtain the clearest conception of what the Court of Rome really was one had to imagine three old Fakirs [Pius, Antonel- li, and the Cardinal Vicar], who, for up- wards of a quarter of a century ... had used the same phrases, spoken the sam« thoughts, mumbled the same anathemas, and who never held communion with any per- son but those who came to worship at their shrine. Arnim added that the tactics of the Ultramontanes were not elaborated at Rome, but by the Jesuits in concert with the Committee of Geneva, to whom the “three Fakirs” bowed their heads in assent. “The attitude of the Pope,” he said, “was that of a man who owes no man anything, but to whom the whole world is enormously in debt. Anything given to him, therefore, however valua- ble, was regarded but as a small in- stalment of that which was his due.” With the Papalists in this frame of mind, Arnim’s mission of conciliation failed, and Bismarck soon embarked on the Kulturkampf; although it appears that Bismarck had not scrupled a little | earlier to offer his alliance to the Pope against the Italians if the Pope, in re- turn, would guarantee the submission of the German Catholics. One further disclosure ought not to be passed over. Thiers, as French Presi- dent, had urged Pius to transfer the Holy See to France: first, in order to supersede Italy, which Thiers hated; next, to make France “the Defender of the Faith”; and, finally, to constitute France as a kind of Catholic Holy Land which it would be sacrilege for any one, especially for German Catholics, to touch. We have no space to cite the salient points in the remaining chap- ters: but we must call particular atten- tion to the account of the war scare of 1875, in which Bismarck’s Mephisto- phelian methods are again revealed. Morier had an honorable part in cir- cumventing them. The next year he was appointed Minister to Lisbon. So tardily was his unusual talent recog- nized. Although the “Memoirs” deal chiefly with political affairs, there are strewn through them many passing references to the personages of his time, and oc- ecasionally good stories. Here, for in- stance, is Metternich’s reply to a fright- ened Archduke who asked, when the revolutionists were roaring round the Chancery of State, what it meant. “The old fellow, with a grim and rather tri- umphant smile, observed, ‘Monseigneur, c’est ce que messieurs les Républicains appellent la voix de Dieu.’” Morier found Gortschakoff “one of the vainest of the bigger statesmen, Beust always excepted, with whom I have ever had to deal.” “It is not our vocation,” he wrote in 1864, “to compete with the Em- peror Napoleon in his professional pur- suits of surgeon accoucheur to the ideas of the nineteenth century.” In his more intimate letters—to his father, to Jow- ett, to Layard, and other friends—we get glimpses of other sides of his strong and sympathetic character. We hope that his daughter will carry the mem- oirs to the end of his life, for his great service as ambassador to St. Petersburg deserves to be fully recorded—including his repulse of Bismarck’s vindictive at- tempt to blast him even at that dis tance. CURRENT FICTION. Counsel for the Defense. By Leroy Scott. New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. We are used io novels in which the hero by unlimited patience, keen-witted- ness and courage surmounts all obstacles, while the heroine either remains passive or makes a few well-intentioned efforts which only add to the hero’s labors. It is refreshing therefore to come across a first-rate story in which the hero does the well-meant blundering, and the heroine, | pitying him and making allowance for him, accomplishes the great task. At the beginning of the book the overgrown vil- lage of Westville, Indiana, is about to celebrate the completion of the new waterworks, built and owned by the city. The celebration is almost a personal triumph for Dr. David West, an old man who has spent his fortune and the years since his wife’s death in studying the means of conquering typhoid fever. His only daughter Katherine, a graduate of Vassar and a member of the bar, who is engaged in work for a “municipal league,” in an Eastern city, comes home for the celebration. Meanwhile her father has been accused by the committee having the work in charge of receiving a bribe from the Acme Filter Company, and the story has been published with a savage attack on West by Arnold Bruce, the radical young editor of the Express. The evidence against Dr. West is apparently conclusive, and when no reputable lawyer will take his case Katherine horrifies Westville by assuming the defense her- self. Her father, nevertheless, is found guilty and imprisoned. Meanwhile Ar- nold Bruce has become convinced that the defense is right. He falls in love with Katherine. The story relates how his bungling gets him into serious trouble, from which he is extricated only by Katherine's brilliant success. The rather involved plot is carried forward rapidly and skilfully to an effective cli- max, and suggests a well constructed play. Considering the large demands of his plot, the author has been remark- ably successful in characterization. The style has a colloquial vigor which often makes the descriptions memorable A Knight in Denim. By Ramsey Ben- son. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. A half-witted farm-hand is not at first sight a very promising hero for a novel. Yet we venture a guess that Bill Har- baugh, the “knight” of this story, will be remembered when some of his more pretentious contemporaries are forgot- ten The book exists purely for the sake of Bill; there is not much story, and what there is is curiously vague as to place, time, and minor characters. Bill, a big, strong, simple-minded fellow, drifts into the farming country near Atro City, Nebraska, from no one knows where. Having proved himself a first- rate farm-hand, he hires himself out by the unusual method of pretending to buy his prospective employer's farm. After the fictitious bargain is struck, he works faithfully for the real owner, expecting in return only the satisfac- tion of his simple wants and the pleas- ure of keeping up the pretence. Defec- tive mentally as he is in some ways, in others he is quick enough; he has the intuitive keenness of sympathy and the occasional resourcefulness that some- ti } f > f HH
Page 14
516 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2447 times go with weakness in practical matters. In character he is a natural gentleman, and it is as a protector of the weak that he appears in the story. His devotion to the ill-used wife of his quasi-employer is like that of a splen- did dog. His good nature, his “festivity of temper,” is infectious. When he is called a “natural-born idiot” he only re- “Oh, come now. What if every- to called by their right name, slap out like that?” The unre- of the setting and some of the characters seems only to make figure more solid and real. plies, body was be ality other his sturdy By Reginald York: Mof- The Sentence of Silence Wright Kauffman. New fat, Yard & Co. Mr. Kauffman sets himself problem, and he approaches it with re- spect. His “Sentence” is the one im- posed on children by well-meaning par- who strive to bring them up in ignorance of everything pertaining to sex, on the assumption that ignorance is the equivalent of innocence. To prove the contrary, Mr. Kauffman conducts the object through a number of The evident honesty of the author's purpose does not altogether make amends for a crudity of incident verging at times on coarseness, he entirely convince us that a serious ents of his study unsavory experiences. nor does all the the result of his parents’ failure to en- lighten him in boyhood. Some trouble might have resulted, but seduction, adultery, and embezzlement, to mention only his major sins, make up a total for which somebody should be blamed besides his parents, who were good and simple country folk. It would be in- teresting to know how familiar Mr. Keuffman is with the “new psychology” and its tracing of childhood influences on later life. Blinds Down. By H. A. Vachell. New York: George H. Doran Co. The closed blinds belong to a house fronting on an unsavory Village street by the name of Hog Lane, and behind them, in wilful ignorance of the actuali- ties of life, sit the three poor daughters of an earl whose estate has gone by en- tail to a male cousin, The youngest of the three, a half-sister only of the two spinsters, is driven by family pride into a disastrous marriage, and her daughter is saved from a somewhat similar fate only by her intervention and her hardly-won experience of-life. So much for the plot. The theme of the book is really an impassioned ples against the narrow and conventional ideas of society In a village lying out- side of the world’s movement. The thesis is well presented, but the book leaves rather an acrid taste in the mouth and suggests a re-reading of “Cranford” or “Lady Ludlow.” It would be a pretty question to argue whether elder misdeeds of Daniel Barnes are! ' Mrs. Gaskell’s pictures of quaint charm | or Mr. Vachell’s arraignment of every- thing stationary as rotten conveyed the truest impression of life. ROYCE’S PHILOSOPHY OF RELI- GION. The Sources of Religious Insight. By Josiah Royce. The Bross Lectures for 1911. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $1.25 net. To those who, on the one hand, are unable any longer to accept the author- ity of Scriptures or of Church as the source of religious strength and insight, and who cannot even follow James and other recent writers in their confidence in the significance and trustworthiness of the mystic revelation, Royce’s latest work, on the sources of religious in- sight, will appeal as worthy of profound consideration. To many, in fact, it should bring new faith in the spiritual and new courage in the service of the ideal. For this book, though from the hand of a master of technical meta- physics, is no mere logical analysis of concepts, no coldly theoretical presenta- tion of epistemological considerations. It is evidently intended as a real gospel — almost as a religious appeal — and though clearly reasoned and never “emotional,” it is suffused with a fervor and a warmth commonly deemed im- possible for a technical philosopher. It is not the philosophy of religion that he gives us here; it is the religion of phi-| losophy. The student of Royce’s pre- vious works will find nothing new in this little volume—nothing new, indeed, | unless it be the synthesis of all his, It is as though the philosopher | works. were purposely calling our attention to the fact that the one unifying and con- trolling interest of all his intellectual life has been religion. Religion for Professor Royce is in- separable from the idea of salvation; and salvation, as he understands it, is itself constituted of two simpler ideas: The first is the idea that there is some end or aim of human life which is more important than all other aims, so that, by comparison with this aim, all else is sec- ondary and subsidiary, and perhaps rela- tively unimportant, or even vain and empty. The other is this: That man as he now is, or as he naturally is, is in great danger of so missing this highest aim as to render his whole life a senseless failure by virtue of thus coming short of his true goal. The religious insight is concerned both with the realization of the need of salvation and with the way in which it may be attained. The realization of the | need is, of course, fundamental, and it is this that is furnished by the first source of religious insight, namely, the experience of the individual. On this point the individual may be trusted— alas, only too well! To all who reflect upon their own experience it is plain enough that there is something wrong | with the natural man as he stands alone. But except for this recognition |of need, Professor Royce does not rate | the individual's experience as very trust- 'worthy; and if we would find not only | the need but the way of salvation, we must have recourse to other sources of ‘insight. Social experience is here of some assistance, to keep individual ex- perience sane and steady. But the two great sources are what Professor Royce |ealls reason and loyalty. In his treat- ment of reason as a source of religious insight, he falls back upon his own pre- viously published treatment of truth (and incidentally of pragmatism), and he repeats in popular form the arguments for the Absolute technically expounded in “The Religious Aspect of Philosophy” and “The Conception of God.” But this philosophical view Royce admits would be insufficient as a source of religious life if it were not brought into touch with our activities and interests by the “Religion of Loyalty.” Loyalty is the essence of all morality and the very con- dition of an individual, personal life. But loyalty to any cause logically thought out necessarily points to the one great cause, which is “loyalty to loyal- ty,” and thus it presupposes a reality that transcends any merely human ex- perience. And “however far you go in loyalty, you will never regard your loy- alty as a mere morality. It will also be jin essence a religion. It sup- plies in its unity the way to define, in harmonious fashion, the ideal of what your individual experience seeks in its }need, of what your social world, groan- ing and travailing in pain together, longs for as our common salvation, of what the reason conceives as the divine unity of the world’s meaning, of what the rational will requires you to serve as God's will. Through loyalty, then, /not only the absolute moral insight, but the absolute religious insight, as you grow in grace and persist in service, may be and will be gradually and truth- fully revealed to you.” Such loyalty can never fail. He who has set his will upon loyalty to the Eternal has found the way of salvation. “From out the lonely and darkened depths of his personal fini- tude, from out the chaos of his social promptings and of his worldly ambi- tions, amid all the storms of fortune, ‘midst of hell’s laughter and noises ap- palling,’ he has heard the voice of the Spirit. He has heard, and—however un- learned—he has understood. His own lamp is burning, and through his deed the eternal light shines in the darkness jof this world.” | But though the supreme kind of loy- alty makes failure impossible, it not only is consistent with but even pre- supposes the possibility—and the actu- ality—of sorrow. Yet sorrow, far from | being a refutation of the religious view,
Page 15
May 23, 1912] The Nation S17 is itself a further source of the religious | insight, for there are sufferings which, with all their pain, we yet would not) erase from our world, because they are a necessary constituent of much that is noblest and best in life. And from them we may gain at least a hint of the way in which all suffering is an essential part of the joy of the Lord. The Eternal is made perfect through suffering. That we cannot see just how this is need not surprise us, for our finitude limits us to a momentary glance, or an abstract guess, at the Real. But this very fact involves the necessity of an eternal and embracing experience in which we live and move and have our being. And the true Church—which is the final source of religious insight—consists of all those who in their great or humble way are strenuously and endlessly loyal to the supreme cause of Loyalty, and thus, though unwittingly, point to the Eter- nal. Many, of course, will not agree with Professor Royce’s conclusions; and sev- eral of his arguments are certainly open to serious criticism. But this is not the place for a technical analysis of his philosophy. And not even the most strenuous pragmatist and pluralist can fail to recognize the moral and religious value of this earnest and eloquent book. The Promised Land. By Mary Antin. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $1.75 net. The candid American will read this book with mingled pride and humilia- tion, and place it on the shelf where it belongs by virtue of its direct and vivid style and the importance of its message —with the “Autobiography” of Frank- lin, Jacob Riis’s “The Making of an American,” the “Reminiscences” of Carl Schurz, and Booker Washington's “Story of My Life.” It is a tale told with glowing enthusiasm of the trans- formation under the influence of new surroundings of a benighted Russian- Jewish girl into an enlightened and public-spirited American. “Although I have written a genuine personal me- moir,” says the author, “I believe its chief interest lies in the fact that it is illustrative of scores of unwritten lives.” What the descendants of the Pilgrim Fathers ought to do for the destitute, iI- literate multitudes crushed out of Eu- Tope and cast upon our shores, contin- ues to be a subject for troubled thought among legislators. Meanwhile, some of these men and women have already turned the tables, and found some- thing to do for the offspring of the Pil- grim Fathers. To the anxious and skep- tical among us they are proving our own opportunities and powers, pointing out the path of peace among racial an- tipathies, and strengthening our some- what languid faith in our own demo-. cratic institutions. Mary Antin’s book should cause the sociologist to reconsider what are the decisive elements in “environment.” For the first half of her thirty years her lot was cast in one of the most un- promising spots in the world for the production of American citizens. Born in the ancient town of Polotzk, one of jthe “concentration camps” of the Jews in Russia, she was cradled in a kind of medieval terror of the Gentiles, and was experienced from childhood in con- tempt and persecution. From one point of view, her most illuminating chapters are those in which she describes the duplex character developed by a de- spised people in the land of their op- pressors. In response to the grinding pressure of Christian Russia, the Jew of Polotzk assumed in the presence of his Gentile neighbors the self-preserving vices of external abjectness, hypocrisy, and double-dealing. On the other hand, reaction against the same pressure tried and hardened his special Jewish virtues. Bowed as he was beneath the imposi- tions of an alien law, he accepted the yoke of a rigorous domestic discipline, subjected himself with pride to the scourge of his own schoolmasters, and bore in the pettiest acts of his life the scrupulous exactions of the Mosaic code. Jealously excluded from participation in national affairs and the intellectual progress of his times, he was driven to seek his spiritual nourishment in the hoary culture of the rabbis and the im- memorial traditions of his race. All the forces of circumstance conspired to establish his objectionable habits, and to intensify his racial peculiarities. When Russia had left to Mary Antin and her family only their ancestral for- titude and the deep hunger of a starved heart and brain, she exposed them as unprofitable waifs in America. Now, what impresses one in the his- tory of this family after its arrival in the Promised Land is that in most ma- terial circumstances they were . quite as badly situated in Boston as in Po- lotzk. They had exchanged Russian wool for American cotton, and a low house in a provincial town for a third- story city tenement; but they were not better housed or clothed or fed or neigh- bored. Laws not entered on the books drove them as remorselessly as Rus- sian statutes into those squalid quarters of the city where Jews and Chinamen and negroes are segregated from the children of light. The father’s training for Hebrew scholarship gave him no ad- vantage over his competitors in selling kerosene and potatoes in an Arlington Street basement, or in dispensing pea- nuts and lemonade on Crescent Beach, or in serving as night-watchman after he had gravitated down towards the slums of Harrison Avenue. The world, as Teufelsdréckh says, was his oyster, and he had not wherewith to open it. |He had hoped, like many another imm!- ' grant, to make his fortune in this land of equal opportunity and exhaustless re- sources. He lacked the unum necessar- ium. His mission was accomplished when he had led his children to the one door that he found wide open and free to all—the door of the public school. Mary Antin went in at that door and began at once to blot out the distinc- tions between the Jew and the Gentile. Her account of this period is a notable tribute to the stimulating our primary school teachers and to their eye for latent talent. Later she went to the Latin School and to Barnard Col- lege. In a marvellously brief time she accomplished her exodus from Russia, Polotzk, the Ghetto, and the spiritual Middle Ages, and emerged in the twen- tieth century, an ardent American, dif- fering from the native-born mainly in the uncommon gratitude with which she has availed herself of common opportu- nities, and in the keenness of her hun- ger and thirst for light. “When taste diffused throygh all asks John Ruskin, “what will become of your classes?” If ten years of American education will obliterate thirty centur- ies of racial differences, what will be- come of your races? Mary Antin’s nar- rative terminates at the point where she feels that her Americanization was com- plete. There is every reason to expect that a woman so young and so happily endowed, so resolute and so kindled with faith, will give us occasion again in the years to come to take heart con- cerning the foster children of the Re- public. powers of is classes,” The French Ideal. Pascal, other Essays. By Madame (A. Mary F. Robinson). New E. P. Dutton & Co. $2.50 net. An acute psychologist, a well-read and sympathetic interpreter of the French ge- nius and ideal, and a graceful and deli- cate stylist, Madame Duclaux is one of the most delightful essayists of our day. She is, perhaps, less happy in the two long studies, “Pascal” and “Fénelon and his Flock,” which fill ful- ly two-thirds of the present volume, than in the briefer appreciations of her preceding volume, “The French Proces- sion” (1909), or in two short articles on “Buffon and his Garden” and “La- martine and Elvire,” which round out “The French Ideal.” Her rather minute verbal craft shows to better advantage on the smaller scale, and the effort af- ter concision throws her thought into clearer relief and conduces to the com- plete crystallization of her style. Par- ticularly in the “Fénelon” there is felt a certain redundancy due to the tempta- tion to quote too freely from a favorite writer, to a certain repetitiousness, and to indulgence in a vein of elegiac sentl- mentality which occasionally approaches the border line of bathos. ‘énelon, and Duclaux York:
Page 16
518 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2447 Yet, with all their defects, these two long studies, nourished, as they are, in the French phrase, with all that has been discovered and written in France recent years concerning Pascal and Fénelon, constitute a remarkable achievement. There is nothing else of equal importance about either of these great writers in English. Perhaps the for this neglect is that they exemplify profoundly the French ideal This Mme. Duclaux does not attempt define, nor does she make any systematic effort to close relationship among subjects under this ideal Fénelon may be, as she merely the complement or the reverse of a Pascal, but she also understands that in their religious views they were poles apart. All that they had in common was their intense spir- ituality, their ardent thirst for the in- finite. But this in itself is enough to set them side by side as representatives of principal preoccupation in reason so ideal to very establish a her four aspect. A remarks, a race whose [ has always been with the things of the| Even Buffon, although the anti- nomy of a Pascal, is one with him in philosophic force and purity of concep- His ideal, too, was a religious ideal, and “Buffon, the Naturalist,” is needed to complete this study of French spirit. tion. idealism, It is noteworthy that the revival of interest in these men is synchronous with a renewal of the idealistic element in French thought to-day; and it is not of Mme. Duclaux’s services indicates clearly the precise which these old influences more begun to make them- By a strange paradox, it is narrow and illuminated Pas to to-day. would thought, fifty that the author of the “Pro- agonies the least that she line along have once felt. perhaps the cal Who year selves that most present us is ever have ago vinciales,” with his spiritual and doctrine of predestination, could be- the of the twentieth entury? But wherever the individual has reawakened to a sense of its destiny, it is Pascal who supplies the language and the discipline for the expansion of the inner life It is only that Christianity is itself the inner life, that Pas- necessarily Christian. Maurice demonstrated how little of is the efful- come spokesman soul own in the sense the religion of cal is Barrés has Pascal called “grace” from any particular idea of divin- independent “salvation” be Christian conception of survival the Christian scheme of rewards and punishments, The drama of the soul is more self-contained to-day than it was for Pascal and his contem- poraries, but the sequence of its scenes what gence how of the and ity, and may and of its crises is the same sous I'ail des barbares as under the eyes of the unregenerate. But just as egoism has in a measure already had its day in modern thought, | so perhaps the influence of Pascal will wane again in favor of other poets, thinkers, saints, and mystics, whose teachings will, turn by turn, accord with the movements of ever-shifting modern sensibility. More recent is the revival of Fénelon, with his patience, his pas- sivity, his “sainte indifférence,” even his hatred of warfare, his response to human misery, and his conception of God as accessible, not merely to an élite, but to all, thus breaking down the walls and barriers between man and man with a gush of sympathy, and thus, per- haps, for the second time preparing the way for a great social revolution, The influence of Buffon is most deeply felt in the strictly intellectual domain where the value of classifications in natural science and the validity of general laws come up for debate. His scientific know- ledge, it might be remarked, is much more akin to the intuitive knowledge of Novalis and the German Romanti- cists than it is to the positive science of to-day. The cult which supports this, writes Mme. Duclaux apropos of Lamar- tjne, the poet of intuition, in one of her eloquent and suggestive passages, may even now be doomed, in the hour of its triumph. In France at least M. Berg- son, M. Le Roy, M. Péguy, and their follow- ers expect and prepare a reaction; and it is a sign of the times that so great a sa- vant as M. H. Poincaré lends an ear in- dulgent, perhaps amused, and sort of skeptical support to these underminers of the scientific position. These anti-intel- lectualists are seers and soothsayers who gaze beyond the regions of immediate fact. The tests of experience produce in them a mood of skepticism. Some of them, indeed, are inclined to suggest that experimental knowledge is a system of organized conven- tions, so neatly dovetailed into each other as to produce an effect of apparent cert- yet with no more real relation to the attraction, life, mystifica- se- a itude, hidden sources of genius, death, than the elaborate tions of a conjurer or the artificial quences in a game of cards. They whisper that scientific laws are the half-conscious invention of their contrivers or discover- that natural science, incapable of ap- ideal truth, can never be the ers; proaching moral g place in his education. The human mind (they say) deforms and alters everything it touches, giving (to what is in reality without form and void) a false aspect of a system and order; even as sea water, col- lected in a transparent vase, may appear a shining cube, or globe, or hexagon—bu the form is the form of the vessel, eter- nally distinct from the vast essence of the ocean, of which it contains but a drop. In fact, the mind manipulates Truth and makes it over in a mortal image, and there- fore the reality of Truth remains undiscov- erable to human reason. Happily man (they continue) is a medium for other forces than his intelligence—he is inspired by feeling, instinct, faith, ecstasy, and by those blind intuitions which emanate obscurely from a subliminal self. So, right or wrong, reason these idealists; and if, as it appears suffi- ciently probable, the generation born dur- ing the ‘eighties and the ‘nineties should adopt them for leaders, Lamartine, like Pascal, may yet have his revenge and his apotheosis, and appear to our children as a guide, philosopher, and friend. The President's Cabinet: Studies in the Origin, Formation and Structure of an American Institution. By Henry Barrett Learned. New Haven: Yale University Press. $2.50 net. Mr. Learned’s book is almost exclu- sively a study of the formal develop- ment of the Cabinet, as exhibited in the origin and functions of the several ex- ecutive departments. The suggestion of heads of departments, with some sort of joint action as advisers or excutive council, occurs early in the history of the Confederation, before a revised Con- stitution was thought of; and the whole experience of the Confederation was a commentary on the weakness and in- efficiency of a national government with- out an executive head. In the discus- sions which led up to the Federal Con- vention of 1787, as well as in the debates of the Convention itself, the idea of departmental organization was further developed; but the Convention went no further than a bare recognition of ex- uide of man nor take the leading | ecutive departments whose heads might be required to give opinions in writing on the duties of their respective offices, /and might enjoy some power of appoint- iment. The creation of additional de- /partments was left to the discretion of |Congress; while the question of meeting |the heads of departments as a body, or }consulting them on matters of general |policy, was left to the President without ‘constitutional direction of any sort. | In the examination of these formal |questions, Mr. Learned has ransacked |documentary and other sources with |}admirable thoroughness, and brought | together an imposing array of facts. So far as the legislative history of the several departments is concerned, the work of investigation will not need to 'be done over again. Incidentally, the inquiry sheds a favorable light on the | political acumen of Pelatiah Webster, }around whom the strife of historical |eriticism wages with some vigor; di- /rects attention to the almost forgotten | careers of Augustus B. Woodward of | Virginia and Charles B. Calvert of | Maryland; and recovers the interesting ‘story of the United States Agricultural Society. : | On the larger political or constitu- | tional aspects of his subject Mr. Learned |does not dwell, nor is he concerned with | Cabinet practices or personnel. He }does, of course, point out, as others jhave done before him, that the term |Cabinet, in so far as it suggests its | British namesake, is a misnomer; and 'that while a President may not with safety ignore the opinion of his Cabinet, he is not constitutionally bound to ask
Page 17
; : : ; j May 23, 1912] The Natio it or be governed by it. If the members of the Cabinet are, as Hamilton and others have described them, “constitu- tional advisers” of the executive, it is clearly not in any functionally binding sense. It is just at this point, how- ever, that the need of more light is greatest. What we most need to have pointed out is not the legislative steps by which Congress, always tardy in its recognition of administrative necessi- ties, has created the various depart- ments, useful for certain purposes as such information is; but rather such matters as the historical dependence of the President upon, or his independence of, his Cabinet or its individual mem- bers; the influence of the Cabinet in shaping executive policies, its relation to public or party opinion, its share in forming legislation, its responsibility for the frequent collisions between the executive and the other branches of the government; in short, its function as a group in the peculiarly organized Amer- ican federal system. From the stand- point of political science, the problem of the Cabinet is not so much one of the working of administrative machin- ery under a single executive head whose will must prevail, as of political leader- ship, in Congress and in the country, under a governmental system of execu- tive independence. We cannot pursue the question further, but we venture to add to our commendation of Mr. Learned’s laborious work the hope that he may before long follow his attractive subject into broader fields. Notes Among Putnam's forthcoming books are: “Paul the Minstrel, and Other Stories,” by Arthur Christopher Benson; “The American Occupation of the Philippines,” by James H. Blount; “The Promise of the Christ Age in Recent Literature,” by William Eugene Mosher, and “The Forty Martyrs of the Sinai Desert and the Story of Eulogios.” The last named, a Cambridge University Press issue, is a transcription of a Pales- tinian-Syriac and Arabic palimpsest, made by Agnes Smith Lewis. On the occasion of the Browning cen- tenary Henry James delivered an address before the Academic Committee of the Royal Society of Literature in London on “The Novel in ‘The Ring and the Book.’” It will be printed shortly. Houghton Mifflin Co. will have ready Saturday week: “The White Hills in Poetry,” edited by Eugene R. Musgrove, with an introduction by Samuel M. Croth- ers; “The Story of Christopher Columbus,” by Charles W. Moores; “The English Peo- ple Overseas,” by A. Wyatt Tilby; “Charles Dickens: His Life and Work,” by Edwin Percy Whipple, with an introduction by Arlo Bates; “A History of the United States for Grammar Schools,” by Reuben G Thwaites and C. N. Kendall; “The Classical Psychologists,” edited by Benjamin Rand, and “A Catalogue of the Collection of His- torical Material at Simmons College, Bos- ton.” J. D. Beresford’s new story, “A Candi- date for Truth,” is in the press of Little, Brown & Co. The Scribners have just imported “Social Insurance in Germany, 1883-1911: Its His- tory, Operation, Results, Together with a Comparison with the National Insurance Act of 1911,” by W. Harbutt Dawson, and “Rose Bertin: The Creator of Fashion at the Court of Mary Antoinette,” by Emile Landlade, adapted from the French by Dr. Angelo 8S. Rappoport. The cultivation of wheat in North Amer- ica is treated very suggestively by Dr. J F. Unstead in the Geographical Journal for April and May. From a careful study of the climatic conditions, the temperatures and rainfall, he believes there will be an enormous extension of the wheat area, es- pecially in Canada, and that the nine hun- dred million bushels obtained in 1909 will be increased to nearly two thousand mil lion in the future. Other subjects treated are the Sir Sandford Glacier by H. Palmer, the Antarctic expeditions of 1911-12 by Dr H. R. Mill, and the island-names in Mela- nesia by Dr. W. H. R. Rivers. Most of these islands have two names, one of Euro- pean origin given by an early discoverer, another used by the natives themselves, which is often the one by which it is known to officials, missionaries, and traders. A map accompanies the article. The New International Year Book for 1912 comes to us reduced in bulk almost by half through the use of thin paper, but counting its regular 800 and odd large pages. Much may be told of a year’s happenings in the space of a million words or thereabouts and this latest volume lives up to the high merits of its predecessors. There is an ex- cellent article on Aeronautics. The year's record in the pure sciences is given under separate heads; and as always there are the highly useful summaries of the political history of the year for every country and for every State in the Union (Dodd, Mead & Co.). “The Russian Year Book” (Macmillan) by Howard P. Kennard, is an exhaustive volume obviously intended for the merchant and investor. There are elaborate accounts of Russian commercial law, the rights of foreigners, fifty-five pages dealing with the natural resources of the country supple mented by thirty pages on mining and min- erals, forty pages on ports, shipping, and foreign trade, sixty-five pages on customs including a complete translation of the Russian customs tariff, and thirty pages on finance; altogether a wealth of economi: detail on Russia that is not accessible else- where within the compass of a single vol- ume. “Leaflets from Italy” (Putnam), by M Nataline Crumpton, is chiefly made up of a long essay on the Empress Galla Pla- cidia Two brief studies of St. Monica and of the City of Genoa are added for good measure. It is virtually a memorial volume to one who loved her Italy and sought to know it well. Agreeably written the essays hardly rise above a gentle and well-bred mediocrity The text of Francis Bickley’s “Where Dorset Meets Devon” (Dutton) is pretty 519 thin reading. The author has tried to ex- tend to the surrounding country the fac- titious interest that attaches to Lyme Regis from Louisa’s fall, but he has succeeded only indifferently well. The illustrations are pretty. Do not pick up Percival Pollard’s “Vaga- bond Journeys” (Neale Publ. Co.) to look for guidance in your own journeyings or to learn any important facts concerning European countries. It is frankly declared to consist of impressionistic sketches of ‘the human comedy at home and abroad.’ but chiefly abroad. Says the author: “J would ask the reader to explore—myself.” So he chatters in expansive fashion of the manufacture of antiques in modern Flor- ence, the secession painters in Munich. to- day, the glittering café life of Paris, the unpredictable pronunciation of the English language in England—in short, of anything that engages his wandering fancy. On all topics he pours forth reminiscence and “enlightened” comment with unfailing dif- fuseness. Indeed, we might almost con- clude there is a conscientious endeavor to make the exploration to which we are in- vited peculiarly wearisome. It is pleasant to see that Mrs. William Sharp has undertaken to edit a series of volumes containing a selection of the works which her husband published under his own name. The books are to be similar {ir make-up to the “Fiona Macleod,” which was issued by the same publishers (Duffield & Co.), and which was reviewed at length in the Nation of February 16, 1911 Of the new series one volume, containing ‘Poems has already appeared It will be time to write more fully of Sharp's acknowledged works when the present publication has progressed further. “War-Pictures From Clarendon” (Frowde) edited by R. J. Mackenzie, is, as the titl indicates, a selection of passages from Clarendon’s history of the Rebellion, so arranged as to give a fairly complete story of the military operations But some of Clarendon’s memorable character-sketches are included, and the book ought to find many readers among those who are fright ened away by the bulk of the complet work. \ selection of “Southey'’s Letters” has been made by M. H. Fitzgerald, and pul lished with sufficient notes The book though a handy-sized volume in the Oxford green and gold series, contains material enough to bring the reader into happy familiarity with one of the finest chara: ters of English literature As a motto for the letters the editor quotes the beautiful words of Thackeray: We have left his old political landmarks miles and miles behind; we protest against his dogmatism; uay, we begin to forget it and his politics; but I hope his life will not be forgotten, for it is sublime in it simplicity, its energy, its honor its af fection! In the combat between Time ar Thalaba I suspect the former destroyer has conquered Kehama’sa curee frightens very few readers now; but Southey’s pri vate letters are worth piles of epics, and are sure to last among us as long as kind hearts like to sympathize with goodness and purity, and love and upright life ' Just why the letters which Major Ander- son of Fort Sumter fame wrote when he was a captain in Gen. Scott's army in 1847 are printed as a separate volume (“An Ar- tillery Officer in the Mexican War,” Put- eg ei
Page 18
520 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 will perhaps become evident when his and are also published. At the present moment there is a certain timeliness in these letters ad- dressed to his wife by a very fond husband, while he was engaged in the campaign which forced the Mexicans to accept the conditions of peace dictated from Washing- nam) “Journals Correspondence” ton. Capt. Anderson was a remarkable ex- ample of the professional Christian soldier, trained to observe carefully and to present his clearly Ve little escaped his notice, he confidently trusted his wife to be interested everything that inter- ested iim. The Mexican war produced rath- er books its in the opinion of two generations later, called for, but is worth much ideas ry and in more than importance contribution of what There country of Mexico, this Capt. Anderson's has been no better Vera it was description fits Scarcely more than most printed on the subject is of the the Valley in How closely Mexico In 1912 a resemblance | descriptioa between Cruz and as 1847 18 not easy to say in the larger physical life of the was to be noticed a year The of the placed Mexico much nearer where she was in 1845 except features, and the lower intimate classes ago events past ten months have The tures Moore's De- Im- Johns Hop- in Johns their briefly the of federalism led to the of the the decline of this doctrine, and the growth of democ- which mean individualism and polit- To the military neces- War he at- Prof Phases John Bassett of Democracy, (The delivered of “Four nature le American velopment Federalism, perialism, Expansion” kins Hopkins titles Press), which were University, is indicated by Professor Moore traces which Constitution; growth adoption racy, ical sities growing out of the Civil the of he calls “im- perialism,” in he both the tendency to increase the power of the Fed- domestic affairs, the of the Monroe policy relating to the In the last lecture he reviews the various wars and treaties which of new terri- As might be and experience, him at particularism tributes growth what which includes eral Government in transformation and growth Doctrine, and the Interoceanic canal the acquisition United training in the from resulted tory by States expected his such discussion and analysis show his best two of the views expressed by the the first the contest From dissent that South we in place, be to slavery “in half- dis- became author must contention North been from the as settled tween the and originally intelligent could have by rested an-hour any three and minds were not partisanship,” but that conflict fanaticiem and Inte men whose assed irreconcilable of the the by it merely on ac- of the abolition- of the Dred Scott other This is taking of the of the abolish the “peculiar institution.” the that the merely char- an count int on hand dect one on pn the hand too rosy a view willingness South to kation we agree with view of the following rod difference the intent of the of a guarding WOT Philippines was habit which had national existence acquiring it anne the of a acter! the entire rhe territory integral the between of national with making an exer- purpose of the ac- an alien domain, or the and by part cise protectorate for American interests quisition of a colony peopled race, is fundamental. The fgct that, when | ' the question of the status of our insular | possessions came before the Supreme Court, | no two judges could be found who agreed) even as to fundamental principles, shows | that the condition is anomalous and at va- riance with the previous conduct and pol- icy of this country. “Auvergne and Its People’ (Macmillan), | by Frances M. Gostling, is the latest of many forlorn attempts to improve upon R. L. Stevenson’s “Travels with a Donkey.” | It might better have been called “A Writer in Auvergne. For, while Auvergne pro- | vides a background, the chief excuse for| the book’s existence is its naive self-revela- tion of the present-day upper-middle-class | Englishwoman, with means, the travel, and literary aspirations. We learn that the author is still young, that she has a nice automobile, and a husband who is a dear and a doctor, as well as amateur photographer and chauffeur; how he tells| that she always has her own way and else he said to her and she to him| through Auvergne. She} tells perhaps intentionally, how proud she is of being able to talk about “my next book,” and how she always means that each chapter shall be the best—and is her what as they motored us, not rather inclined to think it is—and how well | the peasantry knew their place when pat-| ronized by the “gentry”"—and so on and! so forth. Also she has read up the legend- ry of the Puy de Déme and the exploits of which make useful padding is silent. If not very Vercingetorix, when the doctor ple’ must have given great pleasure in the writing. Of the English versions of Kant’s writ- ings hitherto available, that of the “Kritik der Urteilskraft,” by Bernard, is certainly | Meredith has | |outworking of processes already operative the most execrable. J. C. therefore rendered a needed service in pre- paring a fresh translation of about two- | thirds of that treatise—the Introduction and First Part, dealing with wsthetics—under the title, “Kant’s Critique of A®sthetic Judgment” (The Clarendon Press). He has, neo-British provincialisms occasionally mar his English, per- formed this task with great success; the version is in some respects the best save for some which new example we have of the difficult art of Kant- | translation. therefore, that Mr. to omit from his rendering the whole of the “Critique of Teleological Judgment.” For students of the Kantian wsthetics alone, the serviceableness of the volume is increased a number of introductory essays of an and critical character, and by by expository some hundred pages of notes, devoted large- | ly to a comparison of Kant's opinions con- cerning the beautiful with those of English writers of the eighteenth century. lo the public which has enjoyed J. A. Spen- “The of is now offered a second series under the same title (Holt) Though a thinker to cause a onflagration on the Thames, “Bagshot” has a well-balanced head and a certain gift -t keeping his feet on the bottom in the turbid Among the essays and jottings in which unimpressively pre- comes here and there upon a moral or political aphorism well-pointed and serviceable for pricking the bubbles of folly as they pass. der's Comments Bagshot” not shallows of current discussion. fragmentary is rather his thought sented, one | Apostolic of Ava and Pegu. |the Burmese love of | |require further emphasis. |is a translation of the Burmese version of 'a Siamese work on | Neibban [Nirvina],” which is of interest as |taches to his description of the |gyies” (Buddhist monks of Burma), and he It is the more to be regretted, Meredith has seen fit! The house of E. P. Dutton & Co. is to be congratulated on having published a new edition of “The Life or Legend of Guadama, the Buddha of the Burmese,” two volumes, by the Right Rev. P. Bigandet, sometime Bisop of Ramatha in partibus, and Vicar This standard book first appeared at Rangoon in 1858, and | was greatly enlarged in the second edition, |also published at Rangoon, in 1866. From this the third (1879) and the present edition have been reprinted. The body of the work is a translation of the Burmese version of the Pali, “Mallalinkaravatthu,” the orig- inal text of which is still inedited, although rendering was completed in and the data of this treatise Byee A. Be |}have been supplemented by a translation of ,the “TathAgata-udina,” an eighteenth cen- tury Burmese life of the Buddha. The ac- count of the Buddha as here set forth is es- sentially the familiar story common to the Southern, or orthodox, school of Buddhism; its value has too long been recognized to Another work “The Seven Ways to a specimen of the later school of Hinay- fina Buddhist metaphysics. While portions of Bishop Bigandet’s volumes are now only of historical interest, such as his “Remarks lon the Sites and Names of the Principal | Places Mentioned in the Legend,” and his summaries of fiveofthe “Dzats” (“Jitakas,” lor stories of the former incarnations of valuable as a book, “Auvergne and Its Peo- | the historical Buddha), real value still at- “Phon- rightly emphasizes a point too often overlooked even to-day—that Buddhism, to be correctly studied, must be investigated, not as an independent religion, but as the in Brahmanism, which, indeed, in India was destined to reabsorb it. The work as it |stands has but one small blemish, which may easily be rectified in a subsequent re- issue. The majority of students of Bud- dhism approach their theme with no know- ledge of Burmese, but with at least a work- ing acquaintance with P&ali, many words lof which appear in corrupted forms in Bur- mese. A list of such equivalents (and a | good index) would make the book far more }convenient for reference and study. Even simple terms like dzedi (chetiya, “shrine’’), dzan (jhdina, “religious contemplation”), | tsekiawaday (chakkavattin, “universal mon- arch”), and pounha (“Brahman”) look somewhat strange at first, and many of the proper names become almost unintel- ligible to the ordinary PAli scholar in their Burmese guise. “Why the World Laughs” (Harper), by Charles Johnston, is not a psychological dissection of the sense of comedy. It is merely a compilation, an entertaining one, to be sure, of the witty sayings and hu- morous stories of mankind, “from China to Peru.” The intermittent effort to point out the distinctive quality of the racial sense of humor in each country does not add to | the value of the collection. We may add that two natives of Turkey now attending Colum- bia University read the chapters on Ottoman proverbs and tales, but found therein noth- ing characteristic of their comic literature. |The concluding chapter, indeed, “The ' Essence of American Humor,” ie a serious
Page 19
May 23, 1912] The Nation attempt to distinguish between wit and bu-! mor, and to prove that “the best American humor stands preéminent throughout the world and through all time,” because it is unconscious of racial differences. The distinction is familiar. The thesis is far from convincingly upheld. But the chapter does illustrate how difficult is the analysis which seeks to discover the individual and the distinctive in national humor. As a fund of pithy sayings and amusing stories the book should furnish a vade mecum for the after-dinner speaker and the profes- sional lecturer. Mr. Johnston plies a facile pen, tells his tale cleverly, and coins or captures many a neatly turned phrase. The Missouri Historical Society of St. Louis has just published No. 4 of Volume III of its Collections, which contains two contributions of general interest. The first is Auguste Chouteau’s “Journal of the Founding of St, Louis,” printed here in French and translation for the first time. The Journal is only a fragment of the ori- ginal, which was loaned by Col. Chou- teau to Jean N. Nicollet, and was par- | tially destroyed while in his possession. The account of events commences with the year 1762 and ends some time in 1764, when the first houses had been erected in the new village, the site of which Laclede, the founder, had chosen because he believed it would become a great commercial centre. The second contribution is a continuation of Judge Douglas's “Life of Manuel Lisa,” who was one of the first and most daring of the fur traders on the Missouri River. The narrative is interwoven with many liet- ters and documents, hitherto unprinted, and must be regarded as a most important con- tribution to the early history of the fur trade. Clifford Stevens Walton, an international lawyer, author, and for several years Con- sul-General for Paraguay in the United States, died last week at his home in Wash- ington, aged fifty-one. He studied law at the University of Madrid, and wrote two books on legal subjects: “The Civil Law in| Spain and Spanish America” and “Leyes | Commerciales Maritimas de la America Latina.” James Henry Haynie, for many years for- eign correspondent of American newspapers, died a week ago at his home near Boston, | in his seventy-first year. He was decorated with the crosses of the French Legion of Honor and the Greek Royal Order of the Saviour. Two books bear his name—‘Paris, Past and Present” and “The Captains and the Kings.” Capt. Lionel James Trotter, once a mem- | ber of the English army, whose death in his eighty-fifth year is reported, wrote biographies of several soldiers and states- men, among them John Nicholson, Warren Hastings, Dalhousie, and Lord Auckland. He was also the author of a “History of India,” in which country he served many years. Louis Henry Aymé, Consul-General for the United States at Lisbon, died last week in that city, at the age of fifty-seven. He early entered the consular service, and rep- resented his country in several lands. Among | his wide interests were arch@ology and | certain branches of science, upon which he has written monographs. He was also the author of “Notes on Mitla.” i |many; | Dora Williams, Science “Waterways Versus Railways,” by Har- old G. Moulton, and “The Laws of Sup- ply and Demand, with Special Reference to Their Influences on Overproduction and Unemployment,” by George Binney Dibblee, are announced by Houghton Mifflin Co A timely little manual on Tennis Court” is published Nast & Co. The author Walsh. To celebrate the sixtieth anniversary of its founding, the American Geographical Society of New York plans this summer to conduct a transcontinental excursion, under the direction of Prof. W. M. Davis of Har- vard. Though the list of participants is not yet completed, it now includes above forty geographers from different tries. Among the foreigners are: Partsch, Drygalski, Merzbacher, and Jaeger of Ger- Gallois, Margerie, and Vacher of France; Chisholm, Beckit, and Falconer of Great Britain; Niermeyer and Oestreich of Holland; Lecointe of Belgium; Beltran of Spain, Silva-Telles of Portugal, Briickner and Oberhummer of Austria, Cholnoky and Teleki of Hungary, Cvijic of Servia, Dou- biansky and Schokalsky of Russia, Anders- son of Sweden, Olufsen of Denmark, Brun- hes, Chaix, and Nussbaum of Switzerland, “Making a by McBride is George E. sixteen coun- ;and Calciati, Marinelli, and Vinceguerra of Italy. The excursion train will leave New York about August 22, andwili touch at Ni- agara, Detroit, Chicago, Madison, St. Paul— probably Duluth and the iron region—the Yellowstone Park, Spokane, Seattle, Ta- coma, Portland, and probably San Francis- co, and several other important cities. It will return in the early part of October. Proficient geographers who would like to join the party should address the director, care of the Society’s new quarters, Broad- and One Hundred and Fifty-sixth Street. A large reception, the date of which is to be announced later, will be giv- en in New York. way “Gardens and Their Meaning” (Ginn), by is the misleading title of a little book that would have been named more appropriately “A Plea for the School Garden.” A fervent plea it is indeed, but not an altogether wise one. The great interests of the twentieth century, in the cpinion of Miss Williams, are science— “The vertebre of civilized life to-day’— and codperation, or brotherhood, which, as the author treats it, is a hitherto neglect- ed phase of science. Her argument begins with an unlimited acceptance of the Rous- seauistic “education by actualities.” Ac- cording to Charles W. Eliot, “the most work- able laboratory is the school garden,” and since we need laboratories more than books, let us institute the school garden, not as an annex to the school, but as an integral part of it. In this garden, the pupils will develop spontaneously, like corn and pump- kins, and coéperation will tition. Instead of marks, we shall hear cf edibility and saleability; indeed, “one begins to wish that all the products of a school were of such a nature that they might be carried to market.” The joy of service will enable even a half-witted boy, the dunce of the class, to attain results in gardening that will place him with the “brightest” replace compe- | 521 pupils. Two words, science and codperation, recur insistently in this study of the true meaning of gardens; but, although what Miss Williams has to say of science is usually accurate and sensible, what she says of codperation is often ab- “The very ones,” “who surd she writes, are hot for science training in the schools are sometimes lukewarm in the matter of training for codéperation.” Miss Williams is indeed extremely “hot” for both first edition of Prof. “Text-Book of Experimental with wide approval second, which now comes from the Cam- bridge Press (Longmans, Green, in this country), ought to become much more pop- ular among teachers. It surpasses its pre- decessor in arrangement, and form. Charles §&. Pay- The The Myers's chology” met scope, There are now two volumes, instead of one. The first contains the the second the laboratory exercises treatise, The free use of stencils and patterns has long been the plague of psychological text- books. So closely such works fol- lowed a few stock designs in arrangement and content that a person familiar with two or three specimens might almost write off the complete table contents and some sample pages of twenty other volumes which he had never seen. In the past five years, however, there has been a sharp reaction And, as ever, the other extreme ap- proached. Prof. Robert M. Yerkes’s “Intro- duction to Psychology” (Holt) a number of other recent works that it is unlike all others. To begin with, its preface is put into the first chapter, “because it is intended to be read.” This trick is not whimsical, but indicative of a serious purpose; namely, that of teaching first of all the status and ideals of psychol- ogy. The second peculiarity is the total absence of physics and nervous physiology. The author believes these subjects must be studied independently, which is another way of saying that they have long since become too technical and too important to be passed out dilute, as in so many psychol- ogical textbooks. A third peculiarity is the elimination of nearly all experimental work requiring apparatus. What is a pretty full summary of established results. Description is first given of most conspicu- have of is resembles only in remains ous psychical types. Then follows a brief history of mental development—the least satisfactory section in the book—and af- ter that an excellent recapitulation of mental laws. The so-called psycho-phys!l- cal and motor problems receive separate consideration, and there is a suggestive closing chapter on the control of mental life, wherein is set forth the assistance the ought to render to education and Professor Yerkes offers an al great wealth of information and occasionally grazes the beginner's well-accentuated order, drawn, science eugenics. most throughout, interests far beyond But the clear, the sharp amply offset this virtuous defect too upon ken. and distinctions everywhere There appears to be nothing distinctly original in the “Notes on Qualitative Analy- sis’ (Van Nostrand), by Horace G. Byers and Henry G. Knight. Relatively to the size of the book, a disproportionate amount of space has been devoted to the detailed de- | velopment of the mass action law and ionic jtheory. These matters are more satisfac- \torily treated in a good course in general
Page 20
BRR The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 chemistry, which should precede, Under the heading Qualitative Illustration (pp. 31-56) are given detailed explanations, in terms of the law of mass action and the theory of electrolytic dissociation, of the fairly large number of qualitative facts utilized in the classification of the metals into groups, as well as the separation of the component of These the stu- dent expe and understand before he hus be members each group cted to follow ig experimentally ac- quainted with the facts. It would be peda- ully | this information work it which goal ter to supply the laboratory In with part ii al work of analysis, to the princl- at 1 reterence 1uthors have been great in the fifty-six ding of they prec achemes analysis are open to do not provide in il notes the ne intended to ex- in that rddition cessary ntary information . iIts mentioned in obtain- other than thos only The work students are sults which il in heme, reé are le under ids conditions quantita- fe iture pletely ignored tive qualitative is com. this book; unknown do not in- this expected to prepare their first tions which of quantity; There statements of fa ts and mixtures from dire clude the seric question is a are a few mis- a number of minor us blunder typographical errors Thomas Muir's “Theory of Determinants,” Vol the If (Macmillan) presents the history of the of the period previous its develop- 1841 covered subject in order ment, embracing from to just the the long period terminants (by Leibniz in 1693) to 1841. The in the reader a good of the doctrine of determinants a suitable textbook for a begin- subject, but it may be profitably by side with such a book. 1860, as volume from the discovery of de- work presupposes knowledge and is not ner in the used side J. H. Walsh's “Practical Methods in.Arith- (Heath), J. H. Van Huyl’s “Complete Arithmetic” (American Book Co.), Kimball's Arith- (Putnam) are all of them intelligent attempts to the arith- metical instruction adapted to the needs and industry. A on a somewhat higher scien- Wentworth and metic” Business and G. 8 “Commercial metic” for meet demand uses of the modern world of like tifle level, is that of Messrs Smith in their “Vocational Algebra” (Ginn), attempt, in which simple explanations are given of elementary processes and formul@ that in various guises are employed in trade and industry Drama AUGUST STRINDBERG. By a happy chance, public attention in this country was directed to the per- and works of Sweden's most eminent writer at least a few months before his death, which was recorded in the Nation of last week. Not that he was unknown here before. But recent- ly the newspapers and periodicals had printed much about him; one of his plays, “The Father,” was performed the past season in New York, and plans sonality iself. were making to bring out others. Still ‘others have just been published in an excellent English translation.* One glance at the portrait of Strind- berg which forms the frontispiece of this volume is almost enough to reveal the secret of his life—his wild energy, both of intellect and imagination. From the start his career has shown the spir- it of unremitting, defiant curiosity. The son of a former barmaid, by whom his father, a tradesman of respectable orig- in, had previously had two illegitimate children, the boy August despised the conventional groove. At the University of Upsala he read with the tremendous earnestness of one destined to fashion his own fortune. In rapid succession, after quitting the university (he was too impatient of the curriculum to take a degree), he plunged into a study of medicine, tried to be an actor, gained some knowledge of the Chinese lan- guage, taught school, and experimented in several types of literature, among which were attempts to reform current views on Swedish history and on the conditions of marriage. Strindberg married three times, yet knew no peace, separating even from his last wife. He looked for the solu- tion of life’s riddle in a study of al- chemy, but found instead temporary in- sanity. When restored to health, he characteristically made use of his ter- rible experience to write a treatise on abnormal psychology. Latterly he had cut himself off from the world and de-| voted much time to sacred reading. He has been called variously a realist and a mystic, and in the latter capacity liken- ed to Maeterlinck, from whom, it is true, he got some suggestions. In Mae- terlinck, however, there has never been such fierce intellectual energy. A fairer comparison, to my thinking, is with that stalwart, tragic Elizabethan, John Donne. Donne applied his mind as bravely and almost as widely to cosmic forces as the Swede. Like him, he deemed practicable life utterly material, having curiously a similar cynicism to- wards women; and, beaten by his purely rational searchings, turned for help, but with little avail, to as wild an imagination as Strindberg’s; his final years were likewise spent in religious meditation. It is little wonder that Strindberg has made a profound impression upon Sweden. The breadth of his mental ad- venture has gone with little disguise into his writings. Not for a long time have the works of a notable author borne so unmistakably the mark of him- His development is too complex to be traced in a short paper, and his writings are too numerous and varied *''Plays: The Dream Play, The Link, The Dance of Death, Parts I and I1,"' by Anguaet Strindberg, translated with an Introduction, by Edwin Bjork- man New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $1.50 net. to receive individual mention. They in- |clude, besides his many dramas, poems, | stories, satires, and historical and scien- tific treatises—in all, enough volumes to fill a good-sized shelf. His judgment of life, however, remained pretty con- stant and can be illustrated fully enough by reference to a very few of his works as dramatist, which, after all, was his most significant réle. His judgment is always twofold—society is condemned by reason and by imagina- tion. So far as I can observe, his meta- physical speculations were compounded of these two elements only. z The two portions of his criticism are, naturally, not always fused. In- dealing, for instance, with his béte noire, mar- riage, the imaginative usually serves only as final confirmation standing somewhat apart; or at most enters pe- riodically in the form of a yearning sigh for the things that are not. No better example of this method can be found than the play which he himself admitted describes his own feelings on the occasion of the first di- vorce—“The Link,” written in 1897. Its structure is of the slightest, the action being confined to the courtroom. There there is presented the ugly spectacle of a couple with whom wrangling has be- come the first instinct. Braced by a previous agreement against the chance of their breaking out upon each other in public, they are led by the prodding lof the judge with whom rests the dis- posal of their child, from mild recrim- ‘inations to the most shameless revela- ‘tion of their past life together. As ;might be inferred, the woman provokes the whole series of disgraceful out- bursts; the man is, for the most part, istrictly logical, and answers back in ‘self-defence. The climax is deferred by ‘the reader’s uncertainty as to what |their genuine affection for the child | will at length induce them to do. Recol- | lection of it, the link, in turn stills and |aggravates their rancor. They decide to ‘begin all over again, only to have the | bitterness of their relation sweep the re- \solve aside as impossible. With the ut- /most ingenuity they play upon each oth- er’s weaknesses and upon the hideous- ness of past moments. As Strindberg ma- ‘nipulates it, the man’s course of action is |made to seem perfectly reasonable. Yet ‘it ig the reason of the mind, not at all ‘of the heart, and suggests not infre- | quently Bernard Shaw’s similar ratio- icination. One never gets the impression 'oy great generous impulses lurking be- |hind the word. Marriage, logically ex- ‘amined, is seen to be full of lies, |wretched compromises, and diabolical meanness. The final words of the play buttress this conclusion by the test of the imagination: Raronesa;: I shall never go back to my mother. Never! I shall go out on the high- roads and into the woods so that I may
Page 21
os eemey May 23, 1912] The Nation 523 = <_———
find a hidingplace where I can scream— scream myself tired against God, who has put this infernal love into the world as a torment for us human creatures—and when night comes, I shall seek shelter in the Pastor’s barn, so that I may sleep near my child. Baron: You hope to sleep to-night—you? Marriage is anathema from God and is a central injustice of our existence. For what else can it be called when placed beside that ideal of which it is impossible not to dream? The reality tortures by its suggestion of what might and ought to be. Strindberg searches marriage in similar fashion in other plays, among them “The Father” (1887) wherein he relates how a wife drives her husband insane by the false im- plication that he is not the parent of their child; and, much more elaborate- ly, in “The Dance of Death” (1901). Here the disillusions of a poor captain, mated to a high-strung woman, reach to a sweeping horror. The theme, it must be admitted, is powerfully worked out, though analysis on the part of the reader again reveals the author’s denial that magnanimous feelings can exist and direct in marriage. The method of his judgment here foreshadows the form it was soon to take. II. For though his outlook continued the same, he learned to apply it in subtle fashion, imagination and reason work- ing in close conjunction. On that ac- count many have jumped to the conclu- sion that he turned mystic. He was never strictly that, as we shall see. For- tunately, he has given the world in a single work a full reflection of this side of himself in typical operation, namely, in “The Dream Play” (1902). A care- ful study of this drama, of its form as well as of its thought, is necessary be- fore one shall try to estimate the worth and effect of his philosophy. Looked at superficially, “The Dream Play” appears to be nothing more for- midable than a phantasy, like “Peter Pan.” Indra’s Daughter, who may stand for a sister of Christ, for Astrea, or for any other embodiment of divine justice, descends to earth, and, after living here for some indefinite period during which she marries a poor law- yer and sees much suffering and confu- sion all about her, reveals the secret of life. “In the morning of the ages, be- fore the sun was shining, Brahma, the divine primal force, let himself be per- suaded by Maya, the world-mother, to propagate himself. This meeting of the divine primal matter with the earth- matter was the fall of heaven into sin. Thus the world, existence, mankind, are nothing but a phantom, an appearance, a dream-image.” Life’s complications are explained by the Daughter as mean- ing that, “in order to free themselves from the earth-matter, the offspring of Brahma seek privation and suffering. | | There you have suffering as a libera. | tor.” Yet craving for suffering is brought into conflict with craving for enjoyment, or love. “Do you now under- stand what love is, with its utmost joys merged into its utmost sufferings, with its mixture of what is most sweet and most bitter? Can you now grasp what woman is? Woman, through whom sin and death found their way into life?” And the end of it all? “Conflict between the pain of enjoyment and the pleasure of suffering—between the pangs of the penitent and the joys of the prodigal.” This is sufficiently paradoxical even for a phantasy. Other features of the play equally keep pace with a dream’s quick fancy. There is excellent variety, both of set- ting and character. With the castle of life in the background to give a certain stability, scenes in the foreground shift amazingly before your very eyes. The following direction is not an exaggerat- ed instance of the sudden transforma- tions that are required: Without lowering the curtain, the stage changes to a lawyer's office, and in this manner. The gate remains, but as a wicket in the railing running clear across the stage. The gate-keeper’s lodge turns into the private enclosure of the lawyer, and it is now entirely open to the front. The lin- den, leafless, becomes a hat tree. The bill- board is covered with legal notices, and court decisions. The door with the four- leaved clover hole forms part of a docu- ment chest. The scene ranges from the North to the Mediterranean. All classes of peo- ple are represented, and life in the large is aptly caught by vistas of whole com- munities, now in squalor, again bright with color and motion. To keep all this material from disintegrating—for the play has no particular plot, being simply a series of animated pictures— some half-a-dozen themes periodically recur. The continual expectation that a certain room of the castle will be un- locked which holds the secret of life; the frequent return of the officer to see if his beloved Victoria has come out from the opera; the refrain chanted by the Daughter, “Men are to be pitied,” are just definite enough to keep one from concluding hastily that the play is altogether a wild-goose chase. Some of the fancy, of a childish sort and em- ployed merely to add strangeness to a grown-up world, is handled as surely as the rest and bespeaks the. author's ver- satility. IIT. Reckoned as a phantasy, pure and simple, “The Dream Play” is highly di- verting, in spite of its melancholy ex- hibit of wretchedness. But it is much more. Strindberg had used this form more than once where it was evident that he had a serious purpose. It is unquestionably best suited to his strange blend of realistic and subver- sive mind. Nor are his well-known views greatly hidden. After the mar- riage of the Daughter to the Lawyer there is a scene which might do duty in “The Link.” The hopeless round of daily life where two beings rasp each other, the degradation of unrelieved poverty, the inability to escape with honor, and the slender chance that their child may effect a reconciliation, are described in the usual manner. The flings in “The Dream Play” at conventional ideas are also quite sin- cere. Many of them are found in a ser- ies of his satires on society. “Who is it,” asks the Daughter—‘I have forgotten that crucified Him?” “All the right- minded,” answers the Poet. And again: The Daughter. Why don't en do thing to improve their lot The Lawyer. Oh, they try, of cour but all the improvers end in prison or in the madhouse The Daughter. Who puts th: n prison? The Lawyer. All the right-minded, all the respectable The Daughter. Who sends ther to th madhouse? : The Lawyer. Their own despair whs they grasp the hopelessness of their ef forts. In the light of Strindberg’s own re- formative failures, ending in mental breakdown, it is not fanciful to regard the above comments as genuinely his. Scene after scene drives home life's in- justice and wrongheadedness. The au- dience is taken for the nonce to the shores of the Mediterranean. A deep- blue sea, orange trees with ripe fruit, and Italian villas fill the prospect with delight. “This is paradise!” the Daugh- ter exclaims. It is until she notices two coal-heavers on the shore. Though they are black to the waist with dust, they may not have a swim because even the waterfront is private property. A gen- tleman passes by who says he is taking a walk so that he can eat something. “So that he can eat something!” yells the first heaver. Children entering cry with horror at sight of the grimy work- ers—at them who are the foundation of society! In another scene music is heard on a hill, and it appears that the fatted calf is to be slain to honor the return of Lena’s sister, who went astray in the city; “but Lena, who stayed at home, has to carry slop pails and feed the pigs.” If these are only apparent wrongs, it is easy for Strindberg to prove the topsy-turviness fundamental. Take the four university faculties—theology, phil- osophy, medicine, jurisprudence—and what agreement can you wring from them on any subject whatsoever? The four appear on the stage wrangling about the contents of the secret room which has been opened. “Four heads,” says the Daughter, “four minds, 2nd one body. Who made that monster?” Some will recall Strindberg’s similar satire on legal procedure in “The Link.”
Page 22
The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 Truth, upon which society should build, will never be guessed by those in whose keeping it is usually placed. The poet is the only competent judge. But what ie poetry? “Not reality, but more than reality—not dreaming, but daylight dreams The Poet that we man children think playing—that we And the poets are only invent and make believe. The And fortunate friend the world would lie fallow for lack of ministration. No- be touching plough or spade, hammer or plane. Daughter. it is, my for otherwis« body would In a word, the poet’s and Strindberg’s truth—real truth—is destructive of so- clety in anything like its present form. Which does not make society any the better or more tolerable. Every human relation contains uncompensated cruel- no joy can be felt by one without pain given to another. Apart from their settings these are no more than sharp instances gathered by a mind on the look-out for logical flaws in life. Within the play, they are elevated by the imagination and seem for the moment to have general, symbol- ic values. I can scarcely illustrate by examples how his imagination produces its large effect. It is, above all, insinuating, all the more so because it ranges lightly. By his touch a stage- setting becomes gently permeated with the situation it enfolds. With more hu- mor than Ibsen he catches the bigger bearings of a theme without letting it become over-ominous or sultry. The dead-weight atmosphere of “Ghosts” and “Rosmersholm” is replaced in “The Dream Play,” which, considering its sub- ject, might easily have degenerated into a nightmare, by airiness and diversion. He creates ulterior meanings by attach- ing mundane situations, for the mo- ment, to the paradoxes lying at the heart of existence. The method is vague, but not ineffective. Yet, when operating on & small scale, his imagination is as precise as his chop-logic. The Lawyer, unhappily married to the Daughter, comes upon her in company with the Officer and discovers some tell-tale hair- ty; short pins Look at this one You see two prongs but it ils only one pin. It is two, yet only If I bend it open, it is a single plece there are two, but they one If I bend it back, for all that It means But if | break—like two. these this !— remain one two are one then they become The concelt, perfectly In character, sug geste not a little the speech of Othello: “Put out the light, and then put out the light,” At times his imagination ls as startling as a stab. When the meanness of man has been exposed, the Daughter asks suddenly, “You have seen a brain-—what roundabout and sneaking paths Continually he gives the impression of getting below the surface even when talking nonsense. A ship is seen wrecked, the whole crew being lost. ete “and lo, the life-buoy—which saved it- | important for one attempting to place self and let distressed men perish!” | Strindberg’s best work as literature. Such precision and shrewdness in man-/|Rostand in “Chantecler” made much aging details bestow a certain a priori /use, it is true, of symbolism. His uni- force upon his imagination in more am- | versal goddess, Light, reflects with very bitious attempts. The Daughter picks | various nuances the illuminating genius up a shell in Fingal’s Cave and, plac-|of poetic art, and the whole surface of ing it to her ear, interprets the silent | the barnyard throws off a rainbow of voices of the air by a haunting melan-| subtle meanings. But Rostand had first choly lyric. Upon analysis, what passes | constructed a definite framework, well at first glance for imaginative purpose | articulated, to give the more transitory is often merely his zest for the whim-| moods of the situation position and sical, which he paints so thoroughly and/ point. The underlying fable, or alle- with such seeming belief in it as to be| gory, is applied with great niceness and disarming. On nothing does his fancy | jeads step by step to a preconceived play more subtly than on the notion | vision and outlook. The result is a per- that men are but impotent shadow-|fectly intelligible microcosm, which one shapes. He illustrates it in a dozen dif- | may cherish or discard. In “The Dream ferent pictures, no one of which is quite Play” there is no such_ structure. cogent, but each of which has at least | Though more thrilling, the piece is hard- the effect of an insistent motif, especial- | ly more vital than the several dramatic ly when reinforced by the refrain, “Men | spectacles which have been presented are to be pitied,” All roads lead to the this year on the English and American conviction that life is a wretched image | stage. Gorgeous details of fancy, of some beyond. “Do you know,” asks | glimpses into a beyond, and all the oth- the Daughter, “what I see in this mir-| or gevices seek to convey the impres- ror? The world turned the right way! |sion that the unusual atmosphere is —Yes, indeed, for naturally we see it/symbolic of something which it is de- upside down.” “You have said it!” ex-| sirable to feel and surrender to, even claims the Lawyer, “. The copy—| though it is too fleeting and wayward to [I have always had the feeling that it/pbe entirely deciphered. was a spoiled copy" I do not, of course, presume to say IV. |that all of Strindberg’s dramatic output ‘is good for nought. Certain abuses he One cannot follow Strindberg’s grop- | ings for truth without feeling keenly |Powerfully lampooned. Yet the effect the man’s tragedy. High ideals he cer-| is Vitiated by the constant recollection tainly had, too high, alas! For, like | that the reforms are founded upon a Donne, he could never reconcile them|™istaken view of life. If Strindberg with life. He scanned human existence | Were now living and a young man there with a passionate desire to know what | Would be hope that he would outgrow it means and to help mankind; he found | his anomalous point of view. In youth That he was|it might easily be set down as the re- | sult of fearless curiosity exerted in ‘many directions without enough time unify. H. ve W. F. it to be only a brutal joke. doomed to failure there can be no ques- tion. His mind never attained to a| thoroughgoing system, or control. Skill | given to assimilate and in gathering and managing individual | moments of life led him to generalize | too hastily. What he might have! Fred Terry and Julia Neilson, who are achieved, especially as a dramatist, | still finding profit in “Sweet Nell of Old if he had got a more largely ration- | Drury,” have a new play which they will al outlook, one can only surmise. His | 'r¥ in the English provinces this autumn, and hope to produce in London next spring. close observation and quick, sympa- thetic fancy furnish a rare conjunction; | “Kismet” is to be produced soon in Ber- if properly directed, they are the stuff | '!. at the Kiinstler Theater. Herr Stern, that masterpieces are made of. But tak-| “** Reinhardt's stage manager, will be the ' P | director and Max Pallenberg will play Hajj. en as it is, even at its best, his work 18 | There is a probability of the piece being instinct with futility. His predilection, ‘played in Paris with Guitry as the beggar. considering his limitations, for the spec- | The Stage Society of London has given tacular phantasy as a vehicle of serious | with notable success, “The Bias of the thought, is in itself a sign of weakness. | World,” a translation of “Los Intereses It is the form which offers the readi- | Creados,” of the Spanish dramatist, Bene- est escape from defeat whenever one’s | ventes. purpose becomes embarrassed. If you| phe Crisis” is the name of a new play are not quite clear how to proceed, in-| py Paul Bourget and André Beaunier, which troduce an airy ballet, or fall into in-|has just been produced at the Porte St. tangible lyrics, or hide behind some oth-| Martin in Paris. The theme of it is the er divertissement. degrading effect of politics upon character, Many, however, have called “The | #24 certainly the picture which it draws of Dream Play” acceptable symbolism, even | * Supposed French statesman.is not a flat- while they reject its central teachings caring ome, Gitie Preuss, 8 Germs "| widow, who has been the innocent victim of in much the same way that persons who a scandal, has become the mistress of M. are not romanticists may chance to be) Rivardin, a man of lofty political ambi- The point {s/tions and brilliant prospects, She has a 'moved by “Chantecler.”
Page 23
May 23, 1912] salon and admiring friends, is moderately respected, and tolerably happy, but is not so young as she was, and longs for marriage. This Laurent Bernard, a Socialistic Deputy, offers her, but Rivardin refuses, on the ground—he is Prime Minister now—that such an alliance would be fatal to his Ad- ministration. But he coes not wish to lose Giséle, and sees in Bernard a dangerous rival. So he offers him a Cabinet position on the sole condition that he shall see no more of Giséle, or, at least, that he shall promise not to marry her. When Bernard refuses the bargain, Rivardin tells him the old scandal about Giséle, declaring her to have been a false wife before she was a kept woman. A bloodless duel follows, and then comes a scene in which the two men are confronted with Giséle. Rivardin now proposes marriage, but she gives her hand to the more high-minded Bernard. The pla) contains some strong scenes, and much brilliant dialogue, but it is criticised as untrue, and Rivardin is called a travesty. Madame Réjane acted admirably as Giséle. Musie Seventeen volumes of Wagner’s letters have been printed, and there are more to come. A uniform edition of those so far published is announced by Breitkopf & Hartel. The first two volumes contain those addressed to his first wife, the third those written to other members of his family. To Uhlig, Fischer, and Heine, those in Vol. IV are addressed. Mathilde and Otto Wesendonck were the recipients of the let- ters printed in Vols. V and VI.Those to the publishers, Brietkopf & Hartel, and Schotts Séhne, add two more volumes, and one is taken up with the correspondence with Liszt (including Liszt’s replies). Volumes X to XIII bear the names of Theodor Apel, August Réckel, F. Prager, and Eliza Wille as the persons addressed, whilein Vols.XIV to XVI are miscellaneous missives to many persons who were concerned with the Bay- reuth festivals in an artistic or business capacity, Vol. XVII contains a sort of after- math, letters addressed to friends and con- temporaries from the earliest years to the last period of his career. Verdi and Wagner were born the same year (1813), and while the Germans are preparing to celebrate Wagner with an éclat surpassing even the Liszt festivities of the season just ended, the Italians will show appreciation of their greatest musi- cal genius in many ways. One of these will be the publication of his correspon- dence. A few weeks ago, at the Villa Sant’ Agata, which Verdi occupied to the end of his life, Boito and a number of other emi- nent Italians opened the box contajning the literary remains and were, as the Mi- lan Perseveranza reports, astonished at the rich find. Five folios were filled with Verdi’s correspondence with publishers, ex- tending from 1830 to 1890. The letters to his librettist, Ghislanzoni, will make a large volume. There were found many operatic sketches, both musical and poetic; some of the unused melodies were adjudged equa to the best that Verdi has given to the world, and of special interest is his own sketch, partly in prose, partly in verse, of the “King Lear” he had intended to co The Nation pose. There are also fragments of a “His- tory of the Popes,” which Verdi started to write. The complete correspondence of Verdi has been placed by his heir, Mme. Marla Carara, into the hands of an editor, Signor Scherillo It will be published shortly. Humperdinck left Berlin some weeks ago to recuperate at Meran. During the sum- ’ mer he will be an inmate of the Villa Fal conieri, near Rome, which the German Em- home for invalid art peror procured as a ists. One of the scenic surprises of the Ber lin production of Mozart's “Magic Flut was the use of motion pictures on a larger scale than had been seen before It was in representing a waterfall, and the “trans- parent” reached the unprecedented height of ten yards. The films had been exposed in Switzerland and the Tyrol In the re vival of “The Magic Flute” at the Metro- politan next season, the Berlin setting will be used as a model. The plan of attempting to soften the hearts of culprits in prison by means of music is being tried in England. An or- chestra has been engaged for a special pri- son tournée. The beginning was made at Maidstone, where the programme included Gounod’s “Queen of Sheba” march, Men delssohn’s “Hebrides”. overture, “Two Ele- giac Melodies” by Grieg, and the same composer’s “Peer Gynt” suite, Schubert’s Unfinished Symphony, and Meyerbeer’s “Coronation March.” The deepest im- pression was obviously made by the Schu- bert and the Grieg music, which seemed “like a message from heaven.” Art In “Rambles in the Pyrenees,”’ which Mur- ray of London is publishing, Hamilton Jack- son has much to say about the architecture of the country visited A handsome volume containing “A De- scriptive Bibliography of the Most Import- ant Books in the English Language Relat- ing to the Art and History of Engraving and the Collecting of Prints,” is promised shortly by Ellis of London The volume, which is the work of Howard C. Levis, is limited to 350 numbered copies (325 only for sale), and the price to _ subscribers, which will be raised after publication, Is £2 12s. 6d. net. A summer session of the School of Amer- ican Archeology will be held in Santa Fé and at the ruins in El Rito de los Frijoles near by, August 1-30, inclusive Lectures will be given and research work conducted by the school’s regular staff A few miles from Vicovaro, on the pre sumed site of Horacé Sabine far a Ro- man villa of the second century A. D. has been found, with interesting batl but nothing has as yet come to light which can be held contemporary with the poet At Sorrento some fine fragment of statuary have been unearthed vhich belong. prob- ably, to the pediment of a temple, and at Pestum a fine statue of Claudius and va rious buildings of the Roman period have been discovered Important excavaticns are carried on at Terranova Pausania, - H2L5 a the ancient Olbia, in the northwest corner oi Sardinia, where porcons of the city wall with a postern gate and tower have been found. These must have been nstructed to fortify the town foon after ‘ sland Lad passed into the hand ft R a at the end of the third c« In a lecture at the Continental H Cairo, Prof. Flinders Petrie ga a liminary account of his recent in Egypt Excavations were cal d lifferent sites, so that the 1 ilts f varied character. An extensive « was found about thirty-five miles south of Calro, which dates from the earliest h age down to the Pyramid period \ the most interesting objects brought to light are pleces of clothing and coffins made of wood, basket-work, reeds, or withl« all in a remarkable state of preservation; al bed-frames, sometimes retaining the ru work webbing or decorative plaiting of palm fibr« and carved bulls’ leg with beautifully tapered poles less perishable material were about alabaster vases and dish ind a great quantity of pottery. In one tomb we sund pottery jare, with dra fore part and the hind part of ra " another were impressions of four sealings ot King Narmer-Mena, not hitherto know At Heliopolis some surprising 4d verica have been made, traces of ar her obel having come to light, beside the well-known obelisk on that sits At Me phis, work | progressing rapidly, and an a sphinx, weighing about eighty ton ias t unearthed The annual exhibition of a quities will be held at Universit lege London, in June and July In general characterization of “The Book of Decorative Furniture, its Form, Color, ind History” (Putnam), by Edwin Foley, a copiously illustrated work, now completed with the appearance of the second volume, there is not much to add to the review of Volume I which appeared in the Nation of June 8, 1911 The book is decidedly in- teresting to the student of the historical development of furniture Mr. Foley con- tinues to indulge in divagations, ‘nterspers- ed with regrets over the lack of space to deal properly with certain details of his subject. Such desultoriness is accented by the manner in which the descriptive text of two pages before each color-plate is set, being continuous with the general reading matter. Thus, from page 4, for example, you pass on to page 7. Nor are the plates necessarily concerned with the matter of the adjacent text: Georgian furniture is sandwiched into medimwval, and in the midst of an array of British art you get not un- pleasant surprises in the shape of a plate each of Asiatic furniture and the “naive charm” of Austro-Hungarian peasant ar The consideration of the influence cf sur- roundings as well as of material ts wise adhered to, and is underscored in references uch as the one (p. 362) to Georgian furni- ture as “a distinctly English interpretat } of home life.” In the se 1 chapter, on our Colonial Furniture, appreciation isshowr the statement regarding th fanback” chalr used by Thomas Jefferson spar t torical associationa, { i ‘ i venient, comfortal and t t one marvels at the scarcity of t utter in England Statements concerning Cl * et oe ne undises eons
Page 24
526 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2447 influence before Chambers (p. 10), or the ante-Empire occurrence of classical motifs | in the Louls XVI period (p. 270), or the! indebtedness of Adam to Pergolesi, “more marked” than that to Piranesi (p, 97), will help to revise some general conceptions. The efulness of the book is increased by tables designers and periods, plates of typical details of decoration and color reproductions of woods, a classified bibliography indicat- ing periods dealt with in each one of the books mentioned, a glossary of terms which might have been extended, and an index! which is apparently the result of an honest effort to furnish a key to all details. “Art, Artists, and Landscape Painting” (Longmans), by William J. Laidlay, is an odd confessional book and by no means un- interesting. Mr. Laidlay treats the paint- profession from many aspects. He is ready to advise on colors and sketching kits relation of the artist to so- ers and on the Much of this advice is sensible, a rtain portion naturally represents idio- ncrasy It certainly is good counsel not ketch too long year at the ex- of picture-making. There thing to be for adding premier after the picture has carefully painted. Mr. Laidlay being hopeless individ- might give up trying to their condition through organiza- All the he concludes his book a petition to the King of England to away the favoritism of the Royal Academy. The book contains considerable utter of an anecdotal sort and ts fully il- lustrated. every is some- said, too, ip and bravura fle t } holds ualists, een that artists, as well improve tlor same, with re form Daniel Cady Eaton, professor emeritus f the history and criticism of art at Yale University, died at New Haven on Satur- lay He was graduated from Yale in | } l’inanece NEW POINTS OF VIEW. Of the especially interesting movements which have occurred in the recent markets, it may be said that each has a particular significance of its own Both the price of wheat and the price of stocks have declined simultaneously with considerable rapidity, just as their advanced simultaneously six or elght weeks ago. Ordinarily, one might the stock market to advance when the grain market declines, and versa; for a decline in wheat should mean better prospects for the crops and therefore brighter outlook for railway and industrial enterprises, while a vio- lent rise in wheat, foreshadowing short crops, would usually be interpreted as a bad sign for general business. But the simultaneous decline in in wheat may perhaps be two price expect past week's stocks and most fairly characterized by saying that one reaction resulted from prema- ture expectations of good in the general investment fleld, while the other result- ed from premature expectations of evil in the season's agriculture. the + The wheat market's case is particular- ly interesting. Between April 1, when dispatches began to come in of damage to the winter wheat crop, and the sec- ord week of May, when the Govern- ment’s unfavorable crop report was pub- lished, the price of wheat at Chicago |rose from $1.01 to $1.18% per bushel; between May 10 and Monday of this! week, it declined from $1.18% to $1.11%. In other words, it has lost nearly half) of the season's earlier advance, and this was clearly attributable to the fact that the grain trade’s ideas of two or three weeks ago, regarding the actual damage to the crop, now appear to have been very greatly exaggerated. The grain crop outlook is by no means | all that one might wish it to be; but this is one of the incidents which brings sharply to mind what an exceptional country this is, in geographical area as variety of climate and capacity for production. In Europe, it is customary to hear that have run short in France and England, but are offset by excellent yields in Germany and the Balkans, or that Eastern Europe has not produced enough, but that Russia has filled the bag. But the stretch of the United States from East to West and from North to South is not much less than Europe’s, and it would require a very remarkable series of misfortunes to spoil all the harvests of the country. Even when the corn crops of 1894 and 1901 ran disastrously short, we had handsome wheat yields; the deficient wheat crop of 1904 was offset by a bumper yield of cotton, and we all know what happened with the South’s agri- cultural staple when the Northern grain yield was cut down last year. But the country, like Europe as a whole, is also large enough to admit of disaster to a single crop in one part of it, while the same crop in another sec- tion will come through the season in better shape than usual, and it is just this possibility that the wheat trade has discovered this present week. The grain trade speculators had concluded that, since the Central Western States had lost half of the wheat which was planted fn the autumn, therefore the in crops same thing must have happened to the)! fertile region beyond the Mississippi. It is now beginning to hear that the trans- Missouri district, up to date, has fared as much better than usual as the sec- tion to the east of it had fared worse. We shall have plenty of agricultural vicissitudes between now and harvest time, but we have already had the not unfamiliar lesson read to us that it is not the habit of Nature to kill the coun- try’s harv®sts before the middle of May. That is only the habit of the Chicago Board of Trade. How far the rapid decline on the Stock Exchange, from the high prices of a few weeks ago, was caused by the agricultural uncertainty, and how far} | by the very much greater confusion of Presidential politics, is an open ques- }tion. That sober financial sentiment /had been adversely affected by Mr. | Roosevelt’s radical campaign and by his /unexpected victories in the Eastern pri- |maries, could not be doubted. It was /not easy to say how dominant an infiu- ence this was—first, because the actual | bearing of any political situation on in- vestment values is always hard to man- age, but also for the reason that no one has been able to foresee the result of the fight for the nomination. The tendency has lately been to await the Ohio primaries of last Tuesday, with the idea that they should give some defi- nite indication as to the actual trend of things. The earlier votes had caused very mixed emotions. In fact, the com- munity had been so sated and surfeited with the absurd working-out of the Pres- idential primary experiment—it is much as if the old-time uproar over the “Octo- ber States” had in those days been re- peated six or eight times in advance of the national election—that each new “primary crisis” in another State, each new exchange of epithets on the hust- ings, each new reference to “what I did” or to the rat in a corner, each new mix- up about the ballots, each new suspicion that voters of one party are helping along the vote at the other party’s pri- maries, and each new subsequent batch of claims and explanations, had begun to pall on the taste. But all experienced observers recognized that Ohio was a different matter, and when the decisive victory of Roosevelt over Taft, in the primaries of the President’s own State, became known on Wednesday morning, it was felt that the Roosevelt movement must be faced by the financial commu- nity in a somewhat different spirit. It is likely, therefore to be a study in Stock Exchange psychology, how the market takes the later developments in this remarkable episode. Wall Street is able to change its mind on such mat- ters with entire shamelessness. Its vpinion on events is notoriously influ enced by smooth and oracular hints from high financial quarters, and when Presidential campaigns are personally underwritten by Wall Street celebrities, it is to be expected that such hints and intimations will not be lacking, any more than they would be if the under- taking were the conversion of a com- pany’s share capital into bonds or the listing of its stock in Paris. Besides, it is usually the preference of high finance to back the winner as soon as it knows who the winner is to be. Just now, it is extremely puzzled over the question; hence, perhaps, its discreet and dignified reticence as to the bearing of politics on the markets. All th's will make it interesting to observe what happens to “Wall Street senti- ment,” in the light of any of the various political possibilities which the next few
Page 25
May 23, 1912] weeks, and next week in particular, may bring to light. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Armitage, E. S. The Early Norman Castles of the British Isles. Dutton. $5 net. Baum, Julius. Romanesque Architecture in France. Edited, with introduction. Dut- ton $7.50 net. Bazin, René. The Children of Alsace. Lane. $1.30 net. Blakey, R. J. The United States Beet- Sugar Industry and the Tariff. Colum- bia University. Blythe, 8. G. Cutting it Out: How to Get on the Water Wagon; The Fun of Getting Thin. Chicago: Forbes. 35 cents, each. Borchard, E. M. Guide to the Law and Le- gal Literature of Germany. Washington: Library of Congress. ‘ambridge Manuals of Science and Litera- ture: Migration of Birds, by T. A. Cow- ard; Prehistoric Man, by W. L. H. Duck- worth; Natural History of Clay, by A. B. Searle; The Modern Locomotive, by C. E Allen; Earthworms and Their Allies, by F. E. Beddard. Putnam. 40 cents net Carlyle’s Heroes, Hero-Worship, and the Heroic in History. Edited by G. Wherry. Putnam. 45 cents net. Henry Holt and Company 34 West 33d Street Have Just Published The First Volumes of an Important New Series The World’s Leaders Edited by W. P. TRENT. It is designed not so much to recount history as to por- tray those who, in their respective depart- ments, have made history. Per volume, with portraits, large 12mo, $1.75 net. POETS Homer, Virgil, Dante, Shake- speare, Milton, Goethe. By H. W. BOYNTON, in one volume. PAINTERS. Leonardo da Vinci, Raphael, Titian, Rubens, Velasquez, Rembrandt. By G. B. Rose, in one volume. Other volumes in preparation. Filson Young’s Christopher Columbus And the New World of His Discovery By the author of “The Wagner Stories,” “Master Singers,” etc. With maps and illustrations. 8vo. $2.50 net. During the past fifteen years a flood of light has been thrown on Columbus and his enterprise, and makes very opportune this handy one-volume biography. Henry Vig- naud, the distinguished historian of Colum- | bus, says it “shows Columbus for the first time as a living man.” By the Balzac of Spain |The Blood of the Arena BY VINCENTE BLASCO IBANEZ A story of the bull ring by Spain's Loe writer. $1. net. A. C.MeCLURG & Co., Publishers, Chicago THEAMERICAN GOVERNMENT By FREDERIC J. HASKINS O.K.’d by the President, the Cabinet, etc Illustrated. 12mo. Cloth. $1 net. Postpaid $1.15 J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia SCHOE wit F BOOK G TAUGHNITZ AUTHO BOOKS “teenie The Nation Types of English Piety. Scrib- The Great Taxicab Robbery. Mermeix’s Chronique 527 Ricci, Corrade. Baroque Architecture and Sculpture in Maly, Dutton Roberts, Richard. The Renascence of Faith Revell. $1.50 net. Rosner, Karl, Georg Bangs Liebe (Ger man novels.) Brentano t Sando, R. B Practical Poultry-Ke g Out bg Pub cs ; Sims, N. L A H University Slee ’ J.u esa ! l gziu Sim f } rut na 1) Tho s \ n P ; H I i no Br i t ‘ Ung G . Fi ( i I th I \ dd | i ‘ Wi I \ | } I } | j try Outir l ) t Wil brucl ) | j ] with notes, t R. I ! iH its Wilson, C, D Working O \ College Chicago: McClurs $i Wright, M. 17 The Char I) pleton $1.30 net Yiddish Tales Translated by Helena Frank Philadelphia Jewish Put ciety of America MADAME STEINHEIL’S MEMOIRS { Mysterious autobiography. vated Parisian society in which she iarly many people of distinction in stic, and literary life French capital. porary French history. STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 East 27th Street, New York Vol. 5 Completing the Work History of the People of the Netherlands By Petrus Johannes Blok University of Leyden 18th and 19th Centuries. Selected Addresses By JAMES BURRILL ANGELL, LL.D., President Emeritus of the University of Michigan; Ex-Min ister to China, etc. Crown 8vo $1.60 net; by mail $1.70 CONTENTS ce igural Ad sity of Michigan, Jup 28, 187 Higher Exlucatior A | f M Accessible to All: III. Commemorat ' tion, University of Michigan, 1887: IV. State Universitte University f Missour Tao \ rhe Old College and the New Ur University of Chicago. 1899: VI A Me Disco e: Simmons Fries VI Influence fa Lawyer Outeld f Prof shor Vill rh Inadequate RK ! Diplomatists br Historians IX. The Fur pean Concert and the Monroe Doetri: xX Present Problems in the Relatior ‘eM t to Government Xi rt l Studies in Wistory, Economics and Public Law Edited by ine Faculty of a a. plum bia The United States Beet- Sugar Industry and the Tariff ‘".c‘y" By ROY G. BLAKEY, Ph.D. § Pape r Covers $2.00 Longmans, Green, & Co., New York “It seems likely that Hauptmann’s THE FOOL IN CHRIST will ultimately take its imong the masterpieces of contemporst terature,” says Current Literature. (Price $1t net.) B. W. HUEBSCH, 22) Fifth avs New York neglected portions of the ¢ , of Netherlands are THE MOST FASCINATING ” daca SINCE JULES VERN THE DOMINANT CHORD By EDWARD KIMBAL! Net, 81.25 tively presented G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK For 1911 Now Ready
Page 26
The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2447 JUST ISSUED AHlistory of French Literature By Prof. C. H. C. Wright Harvard University A convenient and comprehensive history of French literature from the Middle Ages to the present day, written in English. A very com- DIGTIONARIES TO FAMOUS AUTHORS 83.00 net per volume A DICKENS DICTIONARY By ALEXANDER J. PHILIP A THACKERAY DICTIONARY By ISADORE G. MUDGE A DICTIONARY of the WAVERLEY NOVELS OF SIR WALTER SCOTT By M. F. A. HUSBAND A THOMAS HARDY DICTIONARY with 2 Maps of Wessex By F. SAXELBY A KIPLING DICTIONARY By W. ARTHUR YOUNG E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 West 23d Street NEW YORK plete bibliography and index con- clude the work, ‘Scholarly, ing.’’—Prof. C University A very consclentious and reliable work.’’ — Prof. Adolphe Cohn, Columbia University. Easily frst among the histories of French literature in English.’’—Pro/. O. B. Super, Dickinaon College. Cloth 064 Pages and interest- Harvard judicious, Grandgent, clear, Hi. Postpaid, $3.00 Oxford Untveratty Press American Branch est S2d Stre New York ‘A notable brief for democracy that everybody ought to read,’’ says Mr. Osw4ip GaRRison VILLARD One Way Out: A Middle-Class New Englander Emigrates to America By “WILLIAM CARLETON,” The most notable book of our day. DICTIONARY OF Hard Words By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE Send for deacriptive matter free. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston 645 pages Cloth 1.20; 8 i 2 . ‘ 7 ou Je me - oom p — rhe . A new volume in the “All Red o eaperes *rofeas f tology in the mie " . -y e shagen, writes Your Dictionary of British Empire Series, just ready. Hard Words seome to be an exce nt work have ead the Preface with great pleasure and yoked up a cio may wens wore Hove Wverywhere e-4'™ | Phe British West Indies. forthcom fie ti ary of proper names and the com plete pronoaucing dictionary which you are preparing By ALGERNOMN EB. ASPINALL hev are sare t mark an epoch in the study of your mother-tongue ’ 435 pages. With illustrations and colored map. $3.00 net | DODD, MEAD & CO., 443 Fourth Ave., New York LITTLE, BROWN & co., Publishers, AUTHOR'S AGENT THE DRAMA WILFRED A. RADWANER book and short story manu Dotlare for a Year’s Subscription ted for publication School Advertising in The Nation NaTION stands alone in its field. It has a larger circula :on than any other politico-literary journal published in this coun- try, going to all the principal libraries and reading rooms, and into thousands of families. [he circulation is chiefly among the thinking and well-to-do classes jf) rig physicians, bankers, and other professional men— and in the homes of cultivated people, where the education of | children is a matter of careful consideration. discounts are made He on continuous [he rate is reasonable, and | insertions, of which most of the school advertisers avail them- selves, HE Advertising rates, 15 cents an agate line each insertion, with the following discounts: 5 per cent. on 4 insertions, 10 per cent. on 8 insertions, SPECIAL RATE Ten Cents a line net for thirteen times (minimum space three lines) Orders may be forwarded through any responsible advertising agency, or directly to Tue Nation, 20 Vesey Street, N. Y. | — —— Sixth Printing. $1.20 net; by mail, $1.32 | BOSTON | A Quarterly Review of Dramatic Literature | Send Seventy-five Centa for Sample Copy or satis “Washington (D.C.) STAR. | ‘HOUGHTON BOSTON 'JohnBrown: ABiography | Fifty Years After By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD | | | SOME TRIBUTES TO THIS REMARKABLE HISTORICAL WORK. | Philadelphia PUBLIC LEDGER. “A tre mendous book, more thrilling than any book of fiction, powerful in its appeal, and which, while it is written soberly, as befits history, by the very nature of the narrative often rises to the highest dramatic level."’ THOMAS WENTWORTH HIGGINSON, “I can only say after reading from first to last its more than 700 pages that I have never en- eountered unything this side of Gibbon’s ‘Rome’ which has made me feel more the personal power of a single work."’ JOHN T. Statesman MORSE, Editor American Series, in ATLANTIC | MONTHLY. ‘Perhaps in thus dramatically fashioning his volume, Mr. Villard obeyed an instinct rather than acted upon a preco ved plan; that is often the case with a great work, where a writer’s feelings are deeply enlisted. Be this as it may, the merit and charm are none the less; he has seized well a splendid opportunity and has written one of the great | biographies of our literature.’’ we WHITE. ‘In my judgment a con- tribution to American literature to take rank with the very best historical writing of our time or any time. The only impartial history of the Kansas war.” ST. CLAIR McKELWAY in the Brooklyn | BAGLE, “A biography replete with facts and marked by courage and candor, learning } and justice.’ PORTLAND OREGONIAN. “The most valu- able ana comprehensive biography issued this season, and the best and most candid estimate of John Brown.” Na yout nctipts Rditing, revising “Gnd mar: |THE DRAMATIC PUBLISHING CO. | x ryping done by manuscript experts. Suite _ ’ 1% E. CONNELLEY in the Topeka oO, 110 West 34th St., New York 542 South Dearborn Street, CHICAGO CAPITAL. “The unprejudiced student and seeker for truth will berald the book as a great BOOKS—A wut-of-print books supplied, no cals is a force to be reckoned with. The} contribution to American history.”’ tter on what subject ; write “me, stating Seeks Socialism INTERNATIONAL SOCIALIST RE- | . — , i ean get you any ok ever published VIEW, monthly, $1.00 a year, is indispensable to “a ‘ 1 Engl a. call enh tae spect my stock of | the student who would understand contemporary va age og i a as — pe 0 wre books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, | Soctalism Three months, 25¢. CHARLES H. fiction, is this wonderful biography of Jobn j Bright St Birmingham, England KERR & CO., 118 W. Kinzie St., Chicago. Brown. ” — } The NORTH CAROLINA REVIEW. “In this biography Mr. Villard has touched high- water mark, The book is a delight to the reader for many reasons. Full of life and movement, . . written in an attractive and scholarly style, full of sympathy, and yet without any loss in accu- rate presentation, it sets a new standard for biographical efforts.’’ Baltimore AMERICAN. ‘While the book has popular features in that it is entrancingly interesfing, its scholarship is of the highest order and its style reminds one a little of Anthony Froude. . . Mr. Villard has filus- trated in this book the finest ideals of literary conception and execution.’ | tendon TIMES. “It is scarcely likely that any later writer will be able even to add any- thing of importance to Mr. Villard’s collection of material or to better - eg of the whole story. once es the standard, and ‘probably the: final authority on its theme.’ “Mr. Villard draws a compact, vivid, historic picture of the terrible focussing of this period upon our Civil War. Straight and clear in its literary way, this bs eyo is a marvel of research and fair mindedness. RY WATTERSON in _ CLoutsaville COURIER JOURNAL. “No fault may justly be found with Mr. Villard’s telling of It tis minute and lucid, altogether unvarnished.’’ the story. Yair and Barlington (lowa) HAWKEYE. “It ts a book which will take a place in the library of every well established home in this part of the country.” Third Edition. Fully Ulustrated with portraite and other ilus- trationa. With copious notcsa and bibliography. $5.00 net. Poetage 26 centa. MIFFLIN COMPANY NEW YORK