The Nation 1912-04-04: Vol 94 Iss 2440

Page 1

The VOL. XCIV.—NO. 2440 IMPORTANT NEW AND RECENT PUBLICATIONS OF THE HOUSE OF CASSELL Selected from the Standpoint of Editorial Exactness and Timeliness of Interest ¢ THURSDAY, APRIL 4, 1912°% Res. U8. PRICE 10 CENTS. SAL Rim. o” ‘*, if YE a bie % “a o% The New Garden of Canada Net, $2.50 By F. A. TALBOT. The eyes of the Twentieth Century are fixed upon Canada, “the Country of the Future.” On the back of a pack horse the author traveled through unde- veloped New British Columbia, and in this book brings the reader face to face not only with new wonders of Nature, but with enormous riches, agricultural, mineral- ogical, forestal, industrial—all lying dormant, and silently calling to the plucky and persevering. With 48 full-page plates and a map of the author’s route. Breedingandthe Mendelian Discovery Net, $2.00 By A. D. DARBISHIRE. During the past decade public interest has rapidly developed regarding Mendel’s theories, and the moment has arrived for a cheap and authoritative book embodying the results of the latest investigations. Mr. Darbishire, who is Special Lecturer on Heredity at the Imperial College, South Kensington, has met this need in his book, which is a concise and simple exposition of Mendelian principles, and of their commercal value. The four color illustrations in this book are unique. There are also 34 other illustrations. Astronomy For All Net, $3.00 By BRUNO H. BURGEL. Translated by STELLA BLOCH. This is a translation of a popular book on Astronomy which has bad an enormous success abroad. It is a very rare gift to be able to explain in a simple and attractive fashion the wonders of the celestial regions above us. In “As- tronomy for All” the author has succeeded admirably in imparting to his subject a new and living interest, which will open up to the casual reader a whole field of fresh sensations and reveal these marvels to him in a new and clearer light. The book contains 96 photographs and drawings. Cassell’s Cyclopedia of Photography Net, $3.75 By BERNARD E. JONES. For years a really complete dictionary of photography has been demanded. This work is the first attempt on a Yrand scale to meet the demand. The text is plainly worded and as non-technical as possi- ble, the needs of the amateur being always borne in mind, though the work makes its appeal to every photographer without exception. Whatever the photographer's dilemma, he will find invaluable help here, as the book contains the most exact information, contributed by the leading photo- graphers of the day, in a simple and easy style. With five color plates, nineteen full-page and hundreds of other illustrations. 576 pages, 4to. The Life of Tolstoy Net, $1.50 By PAUL BIRUKOFF. Translated by W. TCHERKESOFF. M. Paul Birukoff was one of Tolstoy's closest friends, and Tolstoy himself actually collaborated with him in the pres- ent work, and collected personally the letters and other documents from which extracts have been quoted. In order, moreover, that the book shall be complete, M. Biru- koff has added to his famous Russian work a short ac- counts of Tolstoy's latter days and a Prefatory Note, which should make the book a permanent unit in any Tolstoy col- lection. With photogravure frontispiece and 16 full-page illustrations. Can be purchased through all booksellers. CASSELL & COMPANY, Limited 43-45 East Nineteenth Street If by mail, add 10 per cent. for cost of delivery Marvels of Fish Life Net, $2.00 By DR. FRANCIS W. WARD, F.Z.3., F.R.P.S. The study of fish life from the photographic standpoint has never received the attention it deserves, and Dr. F. W. Ward, who is the leading authority on the subject, has produced a book which, to say the least, will attract and even astound the majority of readers Over 100 novel photographs of fish, taken in their natural surroundings, serve as a basis for a series of chapters dealing with many new facts about fish life Dr. Ward also describes special ponds, and details his methods of taking photographs of fish under water, so that one may see fish as they appear to each other. Wonders of Plant Life Net, $1.25 By 8S. LEONARD BASTIN. A fascinating book, which de- scribes in non-scientific terms the wonderful methods of growth of plants, the extraordinary means adopted for seed-dispersal and fertilization, and the manner in which insects are lured to further the alms of the plant. Para- sitic growths and the influence of the seasons form inter- esting chapters. The book is invaluable to teachers of Na- ture Study. Illustrated with 40 photographic plates by the Author, and eight Lumiere plates by H. Essenhigh Corke, F.R.P.S. S8vo, 148 pages The Desert Gateway Net, $1.75 By 8S. H. LEEDER. “Biskra and Thereabouts” ig the sub- title of this charming book. It deals in the flesh with the characters who people “The Garden of Allah,” and the book contains an answer to the thousand and one questions that daily and inevitably occur to every visitor to the Arab country, to whom the Arab has until now been an im- penetrable mystery. “It is the only accessible work of its kind on the region described in ‘The Garden of Allah.’ "— American Library Association Book List The Garden at Home Net, $2.00 By H. H. THOMAS. The association of practical informa- tion with the charming literary style that secured such a warm welcome for ‘The Ideal Garden” is to be found tin Mr. Thomas's new book The author suggests here in numerable ways of adding to the delight of the garden at home, and shows how it may be filled to overflowing with luxuriant blossoms, delicious fruit, and wholesome vege- tables. With 12 color plates and 96 half-tone illustrations from Lumiere plates by H. Essenhigh Corke, F.R.P.S. 8vo, 288 pages. Wild Flowers as they Grow Two vols.,each Net,$1.25 Photographed in Color direct from Nature, by H. Essen- high Corke, F.R.P.S. With descriptive Text by G. CLARK NUTTALL, B.Sc. With 50 plates. These volumes inaugurate a new era in -book-illustration: photographs direct from Nature—on one plate—with the colors of the plants and their habitat, are reproduced with startling fidelity. The text is of interest not only to the botanist, but to the non- scientific Nature-lover Both text and photographs are the work of foremost experts New York

Page 2

The Nation [Vol. 94 No. 2440 The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post Office ae sccond-clasa mail matter Th Nation is published and owned by the New wk Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, t; William J. Pattison ‘ Editor Harold deW lf Fuller, As “ ‘ y ad vance post i, in the United States or Mewvico; to Canada i 0 un untrica pupriaed in the Union $4.00 ress THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. ation Office, 20 Vesey treet CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER THe WEEK on ~- 325 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Crooked Deal. Do Words Mean Anything”? seco Oae The Labor Strikes : seeese Te Exhibit No Cotton 330 The Critic's Troubles 331 Through the Outlooking Glass s0ee Ge SPECIAL ARTICLES: German Books on America Swiss Notes ae News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE: Appeal and the Referendum eae ae DS BOO Bese Mccécccccesceccoscceses & 335 A Question of Translation eee A Parallel from Trollop: soos Cae \ White Course” soos ae Dr. Bolton and the Mexican Archives., 336 LITERATURE: Henry Fox, First Lord Holland Dorinda’s Birthday Chantemerle , The Man with the Black Feather The Greek Romances in Elizabethan Prose Fiction The Philanthropic Shaw Lowell , ; , The Tailed Head Hunters of Nigeria Alone in West Africa Work of Josephine NotTi + SCIENCE Researches on the Evolution Stellar Systems DRAMA Music Six Lectures on the Recorder and Other Flutes in Relation to Litera ture ART Sir Joshua D'Outre-Tombe FINANCE The Next Turn in Events Books orf THE WEEK * * * Coples of The Nation may be procured ta| Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in| London of B. F. Stevens & BrowR, 4 Trafalgar | Square, Charing Cross Treasurer; Paul | Educational Educatianal The University of Chicago Offers instruction during the Summer quarter on he same basis as during the other quarters of the academic year. The undergraduate col- leges, the graduate schools, and the profes- sional schools »rovide courses in Arts, Liter- ature, Science, Law, Medicine Educa- tion and Divinit Instruction ts given t; regular members of the University staff, which is augmented in the summer by appointment of pro- fessors and instructors from other institutions. Summer Quarter 1912 Ist Term June 17 to July 24 2d Term July 25 to Aug. 30 Detailed announcements are now ready for distri- bution, and will be sent upon application. The University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois 26 HERZOG RUDOLFSTRASSE 26 First class boarding school for boys. Day scholars. Individual training Outdoor sports. Bracing climate. Entrance any time. Briarcliff? Manor, New York For circular address MRS. MARY E. DOW, Prin. Published March 21, 1912. Illustrationsof Design Based on Notes of Line as used by the Craftamen of India. By LOCKWOOD DE FOREST 82.00 A carefully selected set of plates reproducing the exquisite work done by the craftsmen of India among whom the author has studied for thirty-five years. The method of working from notes of line, as used by the Indian craftsmen, is clearly developed. By beginning thus with the simplest problems the book becomes valuable for the youngest pupil as well as for the skillful workman. Issued in portfolio form in the Biflex Binder; Illustrations of Design is of great convenience in the cJassroom as it allows the different plates to be re- moved for individual use. GINN AND COMPANY, 29 Beacon St. , Boston IN FABLELAND By EMMA SERL BOOK worth giving to a child— a book that every child should read and re-read. The wisdom and humor of thirty-four of Avsop’s im- mortal fables is set forth in modern dialogue. Illustrated with charming line drawings, printed in color. Price, 45 centa. SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO | perience in bringin THE LIBRARY SCHOOL of the New York Public Library Entrance examinations June 11, 1912. i | year course for certificate. Two-year course for |diploma. Send to M. W. Plammer, Principal, 476 | Fifth Avenue, for descriptive circular. HE UNITED HOSPITAL TRAIN- ING SCHOOL FOR NURSES, Port Chester, | N. ¥., offers a three years’ general training to | young women. | Also Music, Art, Elocution, Business. ulty of experienced specialists. Applicants should be at least nine- teen years of he lifications, one r high ara or the equivalent. Remuneration, $10 mont Apply to SUPERINTENDENT OF UNI TED HOSP! AL, Port Chester, N. Y. WEST VIRGINIA, Lovie. Drawer S., on reparatory an ‘ol- Lewisburg Seminar y foot Goumene for girls. Strong fac- Handsome, modern buildings, steam heat, etc. ymnasium, basket ball, tennis. Invigorating mountain climate. Cata- logue upon request. R. C, Sommerville, Pres. 'HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Evmeett O. Fisx & Co., 25 Park Street, Boston 1845 U St., Washington | 156 FifthAve.,NewYork 610 Swetland Bd. , Portland | 814 Steger Ba 920 Sav. Bk.Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Blk., Berk Institute Athenaeum - Munich 323, MRS. DOW'S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS. Chicago 343 DouglasBd., -LoeAngeles Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, Prop. Vincent B. Fisk Mer. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex- al seechers = | good schools. 81 apel St., aa oS | for bulletin 20 and see for al LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND DICTIONARY OF AVIATION By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE 287 pages. Cloth $1.40, postpaid $1.45 DOUBLEDAY, PAGE&CO., Garden City, L. I. “It seems likely that Hauptmann’s THE FOOL IN CHRIST will ultimately take its place among the | masterpieees of contemporary literature,” |says Current Literature. | B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth ave., (Price $1.50 net.) New York EUROPEAN YEARS The Letters of an Idle Man $2.00 net. Postpaid $2.14 AT ALL BOOKSTORES Inspiring and Informative. THOMAS D. MURPHY’S new book THREE WONDERLANDS OF THE AMERICAN WEST Beautifully illustrated, boxed, net $3.00; postpaid $3.30 L. C. PAGE & COMPANY, BOSTON THE STUDY OF ANIMALS A LABORATORY GUIDE By Whitney, Lucas, Shinn, and Smallwood | | | A course for secondary schools. The/| | number of type-forms studied is large, and | | economic values are given prominence. Cloth. 200 pages. 50 cents. | | | | | D. C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago) FTE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK For 1911 New Ready FOREIGN . cre | BOOKS * BOSTON, MASS.” AUTHORS aaa ea For Rent URNISHED HOUSE in Cambridge, Mass., next the House, to rent for winter seasen 1912-13; 4 master’s living rooms. kitchen, la » and drylng-room: 6 master’s ——-. 4b. -. 83 servants’, and 1 trunk-room, Occupa fter A “ad 1, 1912. Apply to owner Pat att 3 "Brattle St acre ERR ERS PVE ~~ oy

Page 3

April 4, 1912] The Nation JohnBrown:ABiography Fifty Years After By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD SOME TRIBUTES TO THIS REMARKABLE HISTORICAL WORE. Patindelghta SURESC jmeeun. “A tre mendous book; more than any book of fiction, powerful “in i its oa . and which, while it is written soberly, as befits history, w the very nature of the narrative often rises to the h t dramatic level. THOMAS WENTWORTH HIGGINSON. “I can only say after reading from first to last its more than 700 pages that I have never en- countered anything this side of Gibbon'’s ‘Rome’ which has mate me feel more the personal power of a single work." JOHN T. MORSE, Statesman Series, in ATLANTIC MONTHLY. “Perhaps in thus dramatically fashioning his volume, Mr. Villard obeyed an instinct rather than acted upon a ved plan; that is often the case with a t work, where a writer's feelings are deeply enlisted. Be this as it may, the merit and charm are none the less; he has seized well a splendid rtunity and has written one of the great ographies of our literature.’ Editor American HORACE WHITE. “In my judgment a con- tribution to American literature to take rank with the very best historical writing of our time or any time. The only impartial history of the Kansas war."’ ST. CLAIR McKELWAY in the Brooklyn EA AGLE. “A biography replete with facts and marked by courage and candor, learning and justice." PORTLAND OREGONIAN. “The most valu- able and comprehensive biography issued this season, and the best and most candid estimate of John Brown."’ . E. CONNELLEY in the Topeka CAPITAL. ‘The unprejudiced student and seeker for truth wil herald the book as a great contribution to American history."’ | Des Moines CAPITAL. ‘More powerful in its appeal, more dramatic than any book of) — is this wonderful biography of John rown” The North Carolina REVIEW. “In this biograpby Mr. Villard has touched high-water mark. The book is a delight to the reader for many reasons. Full of life and movement, written in an attractive and scholarly style, tull of sympathy, and yet without any loss in accu- | rate presentation, it sets a new standard for biographical efforts.’’ Baltimore AMERICAN. ‘While the book has popular features in that it is entrancingly interesting, its scholarship is of the highest order and its style > one a little of Anthony Froude. . e Villard has {Hus- strated in this book the oan ideals of literary conception and execution.’’ Lendon TIMES. “it is scarcely likely that any later writer will be able either to add any- thing of importance to Mr. Villard’s collection of material or to better his interpretation of the whole story It at once becomes the standard, and ‘probably the final authority on its theme.’ Wpsttagten (D. C.) STAR. “Mr. Villard draws a compact, vivid, historic picture of the terrible focussing of this period upon our Civil War. Straight and clear in its literary way, this biograaphy is a marvel of research and fair- mindedness."’ EENRY WATTERSON in_ Louisville COURIER-JOURNAL. na fault may justly be found with Mr. Villard’s telling of the story. It is minute and lucid, altogether fair and unvarnished.”’ Sestingten (lowa) HAWKEYE. “It ts book which will take a place in the library ot li, well established home in this part the country."’ Third Edition, Fully lustrated with portraite and other tiue- trations. With coplous notes and bibliography. $5.00 net. Postage 26 gente. meeeETen MIFFLIN COMPAYN NEW YORE A Concordance to the Poems of William Wordsworth By LANE COOPER Assistant Professor of the English Language and Literature in Cornell University 4to, 1136 pages, gilt top, $12.50 net. A large and important work fur- thered by the American Concordance Society, which must be indispensable to Students of English Literature, as a guide not merely to Wordsworth’s language, but to the thoughts ex- pressed in his language. E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 West 23rd St., New York BEST facilities for supplying sas" BOOKS. Catalogue free. Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 years. 30-32 West 27th St., New York “AtMcCLURG’S” It is of interest and importance to Librarians to know that the books reviewed and advertised in this magazine can be pur- chased from us at advantage- ous prices by Public Libraries, Schools, Colleges and Universities In addition to these books we have an exceptionally large stock of the books of all pub- lishers — a more complete as- sortment than can be found on the shelves of any other book- store in the entire country. We solicit correspondence from li- brarians unacquainted with our facilities. LIBRARY DEPARTMENT A.C. McClurg & Co. CHICAGO i AGENTS FOR COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PRESS Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere. 155 vols., pocket size. List prices, cloth, 35c. per vol.; limp leather, 75c. per vol. to schools and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y.Crowell&Co.,New York (Special prices Learn Latin to Speak Palestra'* the common-sense in Latin some 30 pamphlets des class or solf-instruction by figures, cuts, texts on sabjects of daily life, supported by Roman authors; vast vocabulary, no translations reading, writing, speaking exercises halt EDINBURGH REVISITED By JAMES BONE Illustrated in collotype and line from drawings by HANSLIP FLETCHER 8vo. Cloth, $5.00 net. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Publishers, Phiia. published; $2.50 will bring them all plete $5.00; no samples. ARCADIVS AVE L LANVS, 47 W. 52d Street. New York City ‘‘A notable brief for democracy that every borty ought to read,’’ says Mr. Os waLp GARRISON VILLA One Way Out: A Middle-Class New Englander Emigrates to America By “WILLIAM CARLETON,” The most notable book of our day Fifth Printing. $1.20 net; by matl, $1.82. Send for descriptive matter [ree Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers. Boston. BOOK S—aAll out-of-print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me, stating books wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call and inspect my stock of 4 4 is a force to be reckone!? with The Socialism [yiensaTioNAL SOctALIST Ri VIEW, monthly, $1.00 a year, ts indispensable to the student who would understand contemporary 50.000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, Socialism. Three months, 25¢. CHARLES ii John Bright St., Birmingham, England. KERR & CO., 118 W. Kinzie St., Chicago THE Spring Announcement Number The Nation WILL BE PUBLISHED NEXT WEEK een Besides its regular circulation, number of copies will be mailed to libraries, clubs and literary people. a large

Page 4

The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2440 NEW MACMILLAN FICTION White Ashes The Touchstone of Fortune By S. R. Kennedy and A. C. Noble By Charles Major A strong novel abounding in clever strategy, Another charming story as dramatic and human as $1.25 net; postpaid $1.32. the pepular author’s great success, “When Knight- hood Was in Flower.” $1.25 net; postpaid $1.35. Joseph in Jeopardy The House of Pride By Frank Danby By Jack London “The most humorous and entertaining novel of the Gripping, vivid relations of life in the Hawaiian season.” $1.35 net; postpaid $1.45. Islands. $1.20 net; postpaid $1.30. humor, and romance. NEW BOOKS OF POETRY The Everlasting Mercy Daily Bread By John Masefield By Wilfrid Wilson Gibson Some of the most daring realistic verse which has Dramatic poems, poignantly presenting undercur- appeared since Burns's “Jolly Beggars.” rents of lives which, on the surface, are merely $1.50 net; postpaid $1.60. earning daily bread. $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.35. The Hill of Vision The War God. A Tragedy in Five Acts By James Stephens By Israel Zangwill Original verse, as striking and picturesque as the A compelling plea for humanity, described as “the author’s previous work “Insurrections.” most powerful dramatic work of the season.” $1.25 net; postpaid $1.35. $1.25 net; postpaid $1.34. OTHER IMPORTANT NEW MACMILLAN WORKS The Wisconsin Idea. By C. M. McCarthy Professor of Political Science in the University of Wisconsin. Of vital interest to all concerned in State regulation Of railroads, public utilities, the referendum, the re- call, primaries, etc., by an expert who has been closely identified with the “Wisconsin” development of these great questions of the day. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.62. The Record of a City: A Social Survey of Lowell. By Dr. George P. Kenngott A critical, exhaustive account of twenty years’ industrial changes and present conditions in an old Massa- chusetts town, $3.00 net; postpaid $3.16. Meteorology. By W. I. Milham Professor of Astronomy in Williams College; Author of “How to Identify the Stars,” etc. A volume explaining the entire mechanism controlling our ever-changing weather. $4.50 net; postpaid $4.73. Earth Features and Their Meaning. By William Herbert Hobbs Professor of Geology in the University of Michigan; Author of “Characteristics of Existing Glaciers,” etc. Gives the geological meaning of landscapes, with numerous appropriate illustrations. $3.00 net ; postpaid $3.24. Democratic England. By Percy Alden, M.P. A brilliant study of the humanistic movement and the important social problefMs which have partly bridged the gulf between Byitish political parties and classes to the advantage of the entire community. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.62. The New History. By James Harvey Robinson, Ph.D. Professor of History in Columbia University. \ popular account of the great revolution overtaking historical study through the social and intel- lectual changes in modern times $1.50 net; postpaid $1.62. The Social Aspects of Education. By Professor Irving King, of the State University of Iowa. A complete survey and discussion of the relations of the school to the community as an instrument for social progress. $1.60 net; postpaid $1.72. Food for the Invalid and the Convalescent. By Winifred Stuart Gibbs Dietitian for the New York Association for Improving the Condition of the Poor. A manual of value to help social workers and physicians in their efforts to treat disease and to conserve $0.75 net; poctpaid $0.80. wealth Farm Boys and Girls. By William A. McKeever Professor of Philosophy in Kansag State Agricultural College. An interesting study of the rural home, character, development, environment, and related topics. ; Illustrated. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.62. The Training and Breaking of Horses. By M. W. Harper Assistant Professor of Antmal Husbandry in the State Coliege of Agriculture, Cornell University. Author of “Manual of Farm Animals.” A work fully describing the most successful methods for developing and training young colts and the vari- Illustrated. $1.75 net; postpaid $1.92. ous classes of horses ruuesed =~ THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “2% = by

Page 5

PT Wa ear int org. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 4, 1912. The Week The vote on the Underwood bill reduc- ing the wool duties shows that the tar- iff-reform sentiment among the “insur- gent” Republicans has by no means died out. In one respect the vote of the twenty Republicans who joined the Democrats in passing the bill is more significant than the similar vote of the insurgents last year; for now the Re- publican “regulars” are ready and will- ing to make a substantial cut in the rates,and yet these men stand with the Democrats and their more radical pro- posal. It should not be forgotten that more is involved in the difference be- tween the two proposals than is shown by comparisons usually made as to the amount of the cut in the two cases. The reduction made by the Democratic bill is estimated to be about an average of 42 per cent., and it is said that the Re- publican proposal would make a reduc- tion of not much less than this per- centage; but the salient feature of the Underwood measure is the abolition of specific duties, the whole schedule be- ing put on an ad valorem basis. In the specific-duty system, there are always many chances for getting in “fine work” for the benefit of the protected inter- ests, the effect of which it is difficult for the public to estimate; and furthermore there is in it an inherent ‘tendency to bear more heavily on the cheap grades of goods, in which the masses are chief- ly interested. The Democrats have done well to stand to their guns; and if the Senate or the President should reject their plan, they can point to the fact that in two successive sessions of Con- gress it was approved by the House of Representatives by a more than two- thirds vote. A caucus by the House Democrats last week made opposition to an appropria- tion for more battleships this year or for new public buildings a party meas- ure. The vote was so overwhelming in favor of this policy that there can be | no doubt of its prevailing. It will be a| notable stand in behalf of public econ-| ing valid the election of William Lori-| omy, as the amount to be saved is esti-' mer as a Senator of the United States”;'in suppression of competition as are $50,000,000. Nor can it be seriously ar- gued that the public interests will take harm by this saving. Navy theoreticians, indeed, their grammes, calling for two new battle- have “scientific” pro- ships a year, but it cannot be shown that the navy will be crippled or the country imperilled by omitting the new ships from this year’s naval bill. The action of the caucus is, by so much, proof that the Democrats mean to live up to their pledges to keep down public We are bound to add, however, that they would appear in a much better light if they had not first passed the Sherwood Pension bill, en- 75,000,000. expenditure. tailing a yearly outlay of The Senate has done the expected Presidential-vear act in regard to pen- sions. It has not swallowed the Sher- wood dollar-a-day bill, of course, which the patriots of the House of Representa- tives so eagerly passed, but it put through a hasty make-shift, which is said to mean an addition of only a trifling $25,000,000 a year to the pension list, instead of $75,000,000. With this the “old-soldier vote,” it is to be pre- sumed, will rest satisfied for a while, supposing that the bill remains after conference and receives the approval— or rather the signature—of the Presi- dent; seize the first opportunity for making then the pension machine will another “strike” when the politicians The six- voted against the are in a sensitive condition. teen Senators who scheme are all Democrats. The names of two of them merit special mention as coming from States that do not belong to the “Solid South,” namely, Rayner of Maryland and Owen of Oklahoma. The country will not be profoundly impressed by the language of the major- ity of the Lorimer investigating commit- that should not be ousted. The resolution of tee in its conclusion Lorimer the majority declares “that nothing has developed in or by this investigation _ that justifies a reversal of the solemn and deliberate judgment of the United States Senate rendered during the last session of the Sixty-first Congress hold- mated to be between $40,000,000 and but if the verdict of acquittal has to be buttressed by an appeal to the moral weight of “the solemn and deliberate judgment” rendered by the Senate last year, it looks as though the case for it were decidedly shaky. Out of the eighty six Senators who then voted on his right to the seat he holds, forty declared him, and these forty against among were twenty-two members of his own party, including a large proportion of those having the highest standing in point of ability and character. We are not troubled by the view that the acquittal of the packers in the crim- inal prosecution under the Anti-Trust law is a blow to efficient administration of the law. Mr. Wickersham suggests, in his comment on the matter, that “the jury was loath to find officers of the Beef Trust individually guilty for what they were alleged to have done as a cor poration.” This feeling doubtless had its influence; but a far greater influence must have been exerted by the relu tance of jurors to inflict the penalty of imprisonment for offences which had not habitually been regarded as felony, and which were committed at a time when interpretation of the Anti-Trust law itself was disputed and uncertain. It is true, the evidence was convincing that the packers, through their actions as corporation managers, had violated the law as it is to-day understood and interpreted. But it is not by any means so convincing that they violated the law as they, their lawyers, and their bus!i- ness associates honestly believed it to have been applied and interpreted at that time. This might easily explain a decision for acquittal by a conscien tious jury. But to imagine that such an attitude, on the part either of a jury or of the people at large, insures immunity from punishment for future offences of the With the recent plain application of the Anti- kind, is altogether unreasonable. Trust law, by the highest court and in specific instances, we do not hesitate to say that repetition, by the Standard Oj! people, or the Tobacco Trust people, or the Beef Trust people, of such high- handed actions in restraint of trade and

Page 6

326 known to have Western city. In some parts of it, as | display their deeper convictions. been committed in the past, would be met by imposing the full penalty of the Anti-Trust law's criminal section, and rightly so. The corporation officers are themselves under no delu- sion on this point, and the public, which takes, we believe, a just and fair atti- tude towards the older practices, is in no mood to condone deliberate violation of the law, when there is no misunder- standing what the law forbids. One of the reasons for the conciliatory of bituminous fleld, according to the Coal attitude the coal operators in the ige,.is that by yielding to the demands of their men the mine-owners are in a position to raise prices to their princi- . Writing of the situation a few days ago, before the pal customers, the railways. agreement between operators and work- Coal Age finds that in ers was reached, the the railways would oppose advance the price of coal at a time of enforced but “if appear that economies; the operators can have it any advance they give has been forced by the miners, aid- ed in their fight by public opinion, then so the coal owners figure, a better face will be consumers will be more likely to stand put on the entire matter and for a raise in the price of coal.” This argues a bit of procedure on the part of the mine-owners which may be interest- ing as an exercise in Machiavellian tac- tics, but otherwise serves no useful pur- pose. It is to be presumed that railway men read the newspapers and are what conces- If the increase in prices asked for is out thus informed as to just sions the mine-owners have made. of proportion to the sacrifice made by the operators, the railways will presum- ably have something to say on the sub- ject. Why not give the coal-owners cred- it for simply recognizing the fact that their Interests would be better conserv- ed by granting the slight increase asked by the workers than by precipitating a bitter struggle at an unprop'itious mo- ment? Unwieldy ballots are proving trouble- some in Chicago, where they are too large for the voting machine. The man- ufacturers doubtless thought they were providing generously enough when they arranged nine rows of seventy spaces each, a total of 630 places for names of candidates. /young men at Harvard as elsewhere are But they underestimated | the extent of political amBition in the/sion, and more apt to disguise than to [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 The Nation The many as 635 candidates are trying to | “first and universal characteristic of the help the people rule, and the election| Harvard undergraduate,” he finds, “is a |dread of seeming to appear better than he is.” As a consequence, “he often ap- | pears worse than he is, lest you should | think him to be what he is not.” Prayer- |meetings repel him, and yet the daily morning service in Appleton Chapel is attended by one hundred of the fifteen hundred who could be expected to at- ‘tend it. In what ordinary community of fifteen hundred could you support a daily service with such an attendance? |And, in addition, this average of one |hundred “means at least three hundred men whose attendance is regular al- though not daily.” commissioners are facing the pretty problem of obeying the law that allows any citizen who can get a few signa- tures to a petition to have his name put on the ballot, and also the regulation that the voting must be done by means of machines. Fortunately, only a thou- sand of the machines have been pur- chased, and perhaps they can be placed in parts of the city where desire to) serve the community has not outrun the capacity of mere machinery to con- tain it. But the episode holds out a warning of the day in which men of an| adventurous spirit will enter voting- | t » > , Ln ooths with Baedeker’s “Guide to the That Jefferson County, Alabama, in 3 re . Ballot” in one hand and a lunch-box in| which ‘is situated the city of Birming- , ; the other, their faces set in a grim de | ham, has long been one of the most law- termination to discover at all hazards ‘Jess places on the globe, with more mur- the latitude and longitude of the names | sors a year than occur im all of Great in which they are especially interested. | Britain, including London, lends partic Te = oe ‘ular interest to a vigorous report just Secretary MacVeagh has actually had | submitted by a Federal grand jury. It the hardihood to speak up for that | finds that a “vast majority” of the many worthless class of Americans—the tour- | people who engage in the liquor traffic ists returning from Europe. He has| violate every State law relating thereto, urged Congress to pass a bill relieving | for the reasons that they “will not be these undesirable citizens from the in-| arrested if there is danger of conviction,” quisition and the penalties, in the cus-|and if arrested, material witnesses are tom-houses of their native land, which | got out of the way. That most offend- all good protectionists—except at the| erg escaped trial by reason of the con- moment of leaving a steamship them- | gested dockets of the courts is another selves—believe that they richly deserve. | circumstance reported by the grand jury. The easy-going Secretary would allow | As to peonage, this body found that it these recreant Americans to bring in| does not exist, but “what does exist is free of duty the clothes they may have | extortion and highway robbery.” There happened to buy abroad, as also to in-| ig not more peonage because those who clude in the $100 exemption whatever) would practice it “have devised a system trinkets they have picked up on their! of their own far more safe and lucra- tive,” a system of extortion backed by “the name and power of the State of Ala- bama.” Justices of the peace and con- stables are reported to be usually cor- rupt and beyond punishment, impeach- ment proceedings never resulting in a conviction, however flagrant the crime. As for the victims of the fee system, who are reduced to virtual slavery by it, the “Religious Life at Harvard.” The writ-| grand jury reports that a very large ma- er confesses to entering upon his task | jority are negroes, in every instance “with some trepidation,” which manifest-| “those too poor or ignorant, too humble ly excludes him from the ranks of the|or frightened, to protect themselves.” professional exposers. But his insight | “Were they not negroes, but members of is revealed by his generalization that/a more resentful race, anarchism would be prevalent.” In conclusion, the grand jury bewalls its inability to do anything. At least it has helped to make clear travels as souvenirs or gifts to friends. All this looks to us like a cunning at- the Administration to curry tempt by favor with the tourist vote. It is refreshing to come across such a presentation of facts as is contained in President Fitch's article in the Biblical World on quiet, well-informed unconventional In their religious expres-

Page 7

April 4, 1912] The Nation 327 why lawlessness prevails in Jefferson County. a day or two the military ar- in Within chives housed in the War Department Washington will be made accessible to stu- dents and investigators—a step which, for years, they have been cndeavoring to have the Government take. Pending the issu- ance of the new regulations, the authori- ties in charge have let it be known that those desiring to consult the archives may obtain permission at the office of the Sec- retary of War, Mr. Stimson.—Washington Dispatch, April 1. Those who read the letters printed in the Nation of February 22, know how keenly historians have felt the prepos- terous system of red-tape that has gov- erned the use of these important rec- ords, under the sway of Gen. Ainsworth. It is hardly possible to imagine the state of mind of an official who would thus de- liberately obstruct the patriotic as well as enlightening labors of scholars en- gaged in the investigation and preserva- tion of their country’s history. that this important step has been tak- en towards a rational policy, we may hope that it will be followed by others directed towards both increasing the ac- insuring the safety of Now cessibility and our national archives in general. President Madero’s cheerful account of the situation in his troubled republic needs, of course, to be heavily discount- | ed. His statement that calm prevails everywhere except in Chihuahua is un- important even if it is true. It is in the great northern State of Chihuahua that the fate of the present war must be set- tled, just as Madero’s own campaign against Diaz was virtually decided there. At the same time, it is well not to take too gloomy a view of the Mader- ist chances. Though the Federals were beaten in the fighting around Jiminez, it seems plain that the insurgent army suffered badly and is in need of recuper- ation; and here is where our recent proclamation of neutrality counts heav- ily against the revolutionists. In the person of Gen. Aubert, the Maderists seem also to have developed a leader of exceptional ability, who may yet turn the tide of insurgent victory. Torreon, where the decisive conflict is expected | to take place, is still safe for the Gov- | ernment. A Government diversion against Juarez is apparently under way. In the capital itself there is some dis-| content, but nothing like the universal|Churchill’s speech by the semi-official and animal mortality. | detection from Diaz which made the dic- | | Englishman's holding out a sword | tator’s position hopeless. Beyond question the Scott Polar ex- pedition will bring back from the Ant- arctic a more substantial scientific con- tribution than has resulted from any previous Polar expedition, north or south. During Admiral Peary's last suc- cessful considerable expedition, a amount of scientific investigation was carried out by Professor MacMillan, but Capt. Scott has under his command no less than sixteen men, of whom the greater part seem to have been engaged in work other than that connected with the dash for the Whether that venture has been brought to a successful Pole. conclusion we shall not know definitely for months to come, but the chances are in Capt. Scott’s favor. It will be noted 9 that from November 2, when he set out from his base on MacMurdo Bay, to Jan- uary 3, or roughly speaking, in sixty days, the expedition travelled six hun- dred miles under conditions of extraor- dinary difficulty. On January 3 he was 150 miles from the goal, with his men in good health and provisions for a month. Fifteen days at the rate hitherto at- tained should have brought him to the Pole. But, as a matter of fact, the wea- ther and travel conditions had improv- ed greatly as the party advanced south- ward, and so the goal may have been reached within a week after the depar- ture of the last supporting party. Mr. Winston Churchill quite plumed himself on his bluff English towards Germany, in his speech in the the naval estimates. lt was better to be per- fectly plain, he said. The Germans might as well understand, first as last, frankness House of Commons introducing that for every five Dreadnoughts they | built England would build eight. And if Germany cut down her ship-building programme, England would do the same, and then Germany could “keep her mo- ney in her own pocket for the enjoy- ment of her own people and for the de velopment of her own prosperity.” This may be simply big-boy straightforward- ness of speech, but it sounds uncommon- ly like a tone of offensive patronizing. That it would so be taken in Germany was the instant prediction of so plain- spoken a man as Admiral Lord Beres-| ford himself. The reception of Mr. German press showed, in fact, that the in hand in the other had caused much irritation one and a withered olive-branch across the North Sea. No notice of the matter was takeh by the German Gov- ernment except, perhaps, by pushing for ward the publication of the German naval plans, involving an increase in battleships. Anti-vivisection has received a serious setback in England through the report of a Royal Commission which gave heat ings for eighteen months and now pub lishes its findings after a delay of four years. witnesses were heard Eighteen in behalf of the anti-vivisection socte ties, but the Commission in its unani mous report found that the charge brought forward by these eighteen wit trivial. In nesses were parliamentary language, the Commission declares: “Af of the to the conclusion ter careful consideration above cases we have come that the witnesses have either misap- prehended or inaccurately described the of the the facts experiments.” the Upon ethical point Commission declares that “experiments upon animals, ade- quately safeguarded by law faithfully administered, are morally justifiable and should not be prohibited by legislation.’ To the public at large the Commission addresses a word of warning We desire to state that the harrowing de- illustrations of inflicted on animals, which are freely circu- scriptions and operations lated by post, advertisement, or otherwise are in many cases calculated to mislead the public, so far as they suggest that the ani mals in question were not under an anms thetic. ed to experiment in this country ar To represent that animals subject- wath- tonly tortured would, in our opinion, be ab solutely false But the significant, interesting, if not the of the section report is that which deals with most most feature vivi- the benefits conferred by animal experi- An- fever, mentation on the animal world. thrax, rinderpest, Texas cattle glanders, swine erysipelas—these and other devastating diseases are better un- derstood and better dealt with as a re- Thus, man, it is asserted, is more than the ar- sult of animal experimentation. rogant lord of earth, winning immunity for himself through pain inflicted on the brute creation. He pays back to the anl- mal world in its own coin more than he demands in the shape of animal pain

Page 8

328 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 THE CROOKED DEAL. Mr. Roosevelt hits out wildly, like a man dazed by the heavy blows he hag received. All semblance of restraint or dignity he long since cast to the winds, and his violence of language, his reck- lessness of assertion, his apparent in- to reason coherently, make of him aé_ spectacle distressing to his friends and mortifying to the country. All that he had done before, however, was left behind by the statement issued In it there ap- ability by him Sunday night. pears the almost insane hatred of Mr. Taft which he has displayed on former occasions, but it he this time masses together his misrepresentations with of the President and his perversions of the truth in a way to lay him open to crushing refutation by a plain recital of the facts. During Col. Roosevelt's Western trip last week, the question was raised whe- ther an expression in his Chicago speech meant that he was making ready to bolt the Republican Convention. When this was brought to his attention, he was in- dignant. He declared hotly: “Any man who reads into the speeches anything I have not said is deliberately and wil- fully misrepresenting.” Out of his own mouth he thus stands condemned; he has been going up and down the land for reading into a speech of Mr. Taft some- thing that Mr. Taft did not say. We refer, of course, to Mr. Roosevelt's delib- erate and wilful misrepresentation of the President's speech Toledo. In that address, Mr. Taft undertook to ex- plain in an elementary way the work- at ing of representative government, and remarked that the actual electors were only a part of the population, while “the controlling majority of the electorate” must bear a still smaller proportion to the whole body of citizens, so that, in fact, it is “apparent” that “ours is a government of all the people by a rep- resentative part of the people.” But this mere commonplace was instantly seized upon by Mr. Roosevelt, and by him distorted into the assertion that Mr. Taft did not believe in popular gov- ernment, and was for control by bosses. This is thoroughly dishonest. Mr. Roose- velt cannot be deceived about what he is doing. | and which the yellowest newspaper | ' Even in his excitement and|contractor to deliver the ballots on would feel to be too transparent as well | as too base to attempt to impose upon the public. Of such wanton twistings of the truth one can only say, as the Prince said to Falstaff: “These lies are gross tricts were incommoded, and the Taft voters were as much hindered as the Roosevelt voters. It is needless to add that the newspapers, never having de- nounced the primary as a “crime,” did not “instantly stop” doing so when they “realized that they might do damage to the representatives of the combination of crooked politics and crooked business as a mountain, open, palpable.” Equally dishonorable use has been made by Mr. Roosevelt of another phrase of the President’s. The latter wrote to| which they have been championing.” the President of the County Committee, All this railing of Mr. Roosevelt's like .n New York city that he was glad tu | 4 very drab is so without relation to the note that every enrolled Republican was | facts that there is naturally much spec- ulation regarding his ultimate motives. He must be fully aware that, as far as the Republican nomination this year is concerned, he is a beaten man. What the Seven Governors—whose number is to be “allowed” to vote in the primary. The reference was, and was known by Mr. Roosevelt to be, to the decision not to contest the legality of any of the Roosevelt petitions procuring his candi- dates a place on the official ballot. Some|the only thing left to make them of these petitions could have been suc-| thought of as wise men—invited him to cessfully attacked in the courts. It was | do was to “accept the nomination, com- shown that some of the signatures were| ing as the voluntary expression of the More than one notary public| wishes of a majority of the Republican forged. has been called to book for witnessing | voters, through the action of their dele- spurious signatures in Roosevelt's be-| gates in the next National Convention.” half. Had such a thing been proved of | Well, the majority is now seen to be a his opponent, we know what cries of| minority, and the delegates in the Con- “infamy” and “perjury” the Colonel vention are certainly not going to nom- would have raised. But passing all this| inate Roosevelt. Why, then, does he and ignoring the well-known facts, Mr.| keep up his useless fight, threatening his Roosevelt has pounced upon the Presi-|/own party with disaster as it does? Is dent’s word “allowed,” and hag ranted | he looking forward to rising on its ruins about the iniquity of conceding to Re | four years from now? Or is his master- publican voters as a favor what was|motive merely to feed fat his personal their unquestionable right! Whether this| resentments? He is certainly treating Taft most brutally. When Mr. Roose- velt was rejected as a juryman, he pro- 'tested: “Why, I would have given a square deal even to a railroad.” Some one soon said: “What a pity that Mr. Taft isn't a railroad!” is more silly than despicable, it would be hard to say. That it is either fair or honest, no sane man with all the facts before him would for a moment admit. Of Mr. Roosevelt's at:use of the news- papers, we are inclined to take a more charitable view. That is, we give ead the benefit of the doubt whether he DO WORDS MEAN ANYTHING? k rs wh Iki about. h ne we So ae oe a Whether thought is possible without was away last week, he may not have di known what the papers of this city said | language is an ancient dispute, of the about Tuesday’s primary, and on his re-| present status of which we have to con- turn may have been stuffed by some | £88 our ignorance. But that when we rash employee in the Outlook office. But | 40 think in words the process must be what he permits himself to say is wide extremely unsatisfactory unless the of the truth. It is not true that on/ words are used in something like a defi Wednesday the New York newspapers | nite ascertainable sense is a simple fact “denounced the so-called election as a| about which there has never been any crime.” They did correctly report that | dispute at all. Yet we seem, many of there had been confusion and delay on/| us, to have drifted into a state of mind account of the failure of the printing |in which this elementary requirement is cheerfully ignored. Examples of this habit are thick on all sides; but there rage his mind must work lucidly enough | time; but they also stated that the most to make him aware that he is stooping | serious trouble was in Brooklyn where to a mean misrepresentation which the|there were no Roosevelt candidates; lowest pettifogger would be ashamed of, | while in Manhattan but few election dis- lies before us a pamphlet which fur- nishes an unusually pretty specimen. The document is “A Special Message of

Page 9

Pee oot April 4, 1912] The Nation Governor Chase S. Osborn to the Forty-| sixth Legislature of the State of Mich-| igan in Extraordinary Session,” and in it we find this delightful bit of political reasoning: Permit me to call your attention and the attention of the President of the United States to article nine of the amendment to the United States Constitution, as proposed by Congress September 25, 1791, and pro- claimed in force December 15, 1791. It is as follows: “The enumeration in the Con- stitution of certain rights shall not be construed to deny or disparage others re- tained by the people.” I understand from this that it is expressly provided that it is not the intention of the Constitution of the United States or within its scope to define all the rights of the people. This being true, in the light of article nine whatever is right is Constitutional. Now in the old-fashioned days when words had a meaning, the conclusion warranted by Gov. Osborn’s premises would not have been that “whatever is right is Constitutional,” but simply that whatever is not prohibited by the Con- stitution is Constitutional; but presum- ably nowadays the rules of the syl- logism must be regarded as subject to recall along with the rest of the anti- quated rubbish that old fogies pretend still to regard as worthy of respect. In the agitation that has been going on concerning the proposal to make ju- dicial decisions on Constitutional ques- tions subject to reversal by popular vote, there has been an amount of confusion of this same character which would be amazing were it not that this fashion of playing fast and loose with words has become so widespread. The great au- thor of the scheme may in one breath speak of it as a fundamental reform which our democracy must have or per- ish, and in the next declare that he is asking for nothing but what we have al- ready got and made use of a hundred years ago. That will be set down as) only natural, since a contempt for trifles is one of the prerogatives of the big | man who “does things.” But no sooner has this feat been accomplished than a gentleman of quite a different type, a skilful handler of words and a trained lawyer, as well as a picturesque wielder | of political power, outdoes the hero him- self in the same line. Mayor Gaynor of New York tells us that there is nothing objectionable in the Colonel's proposal except the personal claim of original. | ity, the real protagonist of the scheme having been none other than Mr. Gay-| nor himself. He, too, thinks that dect- | publicly, long ago. But then it turns | out that he means by recall of decisions | nothing but the passing of new statutes | by the Legislature, or the adopting of new Constitutional provisions, in the ways that we are all familiar with and to which no obstacle exists except a pos- sible indifference on the part of the peo- ple. This sort of thing makes one’s head swim—now you have it, now it’s gone. We are exhorted to arouse ourselves mightily and lay hold of a new weapon necessary to our freedom—and the mo- ment we protest that the gun looks dan- gerous we are assured that it is nothing but what we have had in our hands all the time. One of the curious aspects of this free and easy use of words is the way it lends itself to the perversion of the say- ings handed down to us from an older time. “There is a higher law than the Constitution,” said Seward, in the days of the irrepressible conflict between slavery and freedom, and when the na- tion was on the eve of its ordeal of blood and fire. “That is just what we say,” is the chorus of the Osborns and the Roosevelts. But it is not at all what they say. The radical abolitionists went further than Seward; they de- nounced the Constitution as “an agree- ment with hell and a covenant with death.” When a man says that, we know what he means. It is revolt. Right or wrong, it is manful and unmistak- able. To say that there is something higher than the Constitution, to say that the time has come when the Constitu- tion must be trampled on, in pursuance ‘of the imperious dictates of conscience and the paramount demand of outraged humanity, is to take a position which may be condemned, but which must be respected. To say that whatever is right is Constitutional is simply to palter with words—to utter that which one does not dignify by the name of a lie only be- cause it is inherently nonsensical. If whatever is right is Constitutional, why bother with a Constitution at all? Find out whether a thing is right or not, and |any reference to the written instrument is clearly superfluous. But the psychol- |ogy of the performance is simple enough. To denounce or defy the Constitution on the petty grounds which alone they could allege as their justification would be laughable; accordingly they take refuge in a mist of words without mean- sions should be recalled, and said so’ Ing. ~ 329 In a field far removed from politics there has been in our day a movement presenting a curious resemblance to this looseness of language and thought. It is unlikely that pragmatism has been in any degree the direct cause of our politi- cal nebulosities; but it is not impossible that the two have a common source in some mental peculiarity of our time. However this may be, at the door of the pragmatists must be laid the charge of having done, so far as in them lay, gross injury to one word that is among the most precious possessions of mankind. Their doctrine, so far as it can be under stood by the ordinary man, lays down as the test of truth that which may be a test of something—perhaps a test of something more important than truth but is not a test of truth at all. Advan- tage to mankind may be the only thing which we men should be willing to ac- cept as the final arbiter of belief or opin ion; but why call it “truth,” when it is not at all what men have been meaning by the word? However, we do not mean to suggest that the gentlemen who find out whether a thing is in the Con- stitution or not by icoking somewhere else, or who gay that a proposal is at once an innovation and a well-establish ed institution, have been seduced from the straight path of honest speech by the study of any philosophical theory; there is no need of this hypothesis THE LABOR STRIKES After a period far longer than had at one time been hoped, but far shorter than the intensity of the struggle led many to fear might be possible, the fea fully costly strike of the British coal miners at least seems clearly drawing to a close. That strike, however, though overshadowing all others both in the range of its immediate disastrous ef fects and in its momentous bearings on national politics and policy, is but one of a large number of labor movements in the same general direction, in various countries, and especially in the two great English-speaking nations. Our own coal troubles are still in the formative stage; strike movements are impending in the American railways; the New England mill strikes have furnished ex- traordinary developments, and disputes over wages are still to the fore in that section. The complexity of the factors that en- ter into the economic and social prob 5 ee Eom, ange

Page 10

330 The Nation lems of modern society has perhaps never been more signally illustrated than in these manifestations. In part, they are the ordinary endeavors of working people to improve their condi- tion. In part, they derive their origin, and still more their intensity and ag- the socialistic fer- And in addition to causes, there is no question that gressiveness, from ment of the time these the explanation of them is to be found in large measure in the rise of the prices in recent years. It is safe to say that the future historian of the social and economic history of our time will find in the slowness and the painfulness of the wages to prices one potent, though necessary process of adjustment of purely adventitious, cause of that inten- which has characterized the early years of the sification of the “class struggle” twentieth century. That the demands of labor for higher wages in coal-mining and on the rail- ways mean an increase of prices to the of acknowledged. consumer, some the labor leaders frankly quarters, this taken as demonstrating a vicious circle, have In some circumstance has been and as sufficient to prove that the de- mands are unwarranted, or impossible If, are told, wages are to be raised because prices have risen to concede. we and then prices are to be raised because wages have risen, where is the process ever to end? But the matter cannot be disposed of so easily as this; the ques- tion is far too complex to be covered by In a period of ris- adjustments any blanket decision. ing prices, the necessary are exceedingly irregular, and the things that have lagged behind must be put up to the line, even though this process | may, for a time, in some slight degree ac- centuate the difficulty. If general prices have risen 20 per cent., and the work- men in some particular field have re- celved only a 10 per cent. advance, they have good reason to demand an addi- tional 10 per cent.; and the granting of this demand, while very materially af-| fecting the condition of these workmen, | rational Socialism, whatever may be the and perhaps substantially increasing the price of the particular produét upon which they are engaged, will have only an extremely small effect upon the gen- eral The is whether, relatively to wages and prices price-level. real question in general, the particular wages in ques- tion are below a normal level; and this be decided otherwise question cannot ‘than by specific inquiry. Moreover, such [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 readjustments as go beyond what is eco- nomically justifiable will tend to defeat themselves through a falling off of de- mand for the product affected; it is not within the possibilities of the case to keep up that rising-prices-rising-wages- rising-prices endless chain which has been imagined by the critics we have referred to. A broader and deeper question than this of the relation between wages and has attained a certain promi- nence in the public mind during the strike movements of the past few weeks, on both sides of the water. A good deal has been heard of the notion that the workmen can get anything they want if they will only stand together. Before prices the chapter has been closed, there will | be much clearing-up of ideas—mostly sub-conscious, to be sure—on this mat- ter. way of all the working people standing together will have been once more dem- onstrated—have been once more demon- | strated in England; but that is not the whole, nor, we believe, the most funda-! mental part, of the case. We feel sure, the thinking people among the working- men understand that the difficulty in “getting anything they want” lies far deeper. Capitalistic enterprise, capital- istic management, the stupendous mech- anism and organization of production and exchange, the vitalizing and direct- ing forces to which all this owes its ef- ficiency and even its workableness— these are not the spontaneous gift of nature; nor can they be thrown aside and their fruits expected to remain. Even if the universal strike of working- men might be organized, and even if it were to result in extorting, somehow or other, an immediate concession of “any- thing they want,” how long would the victory last? The existing basis of industry and commerce—that which springs from the play of capitalistic mo- tive as we know it—would be destroyed, and nothing would have been provided to take its place. In the schemes of objections to which they are open, there exists no such fatal deficiency; and the hard-headed among the workingmen, whether leaders or in the rank and file, doubtless have an instinctive feeling that the age-long problem of the world is not capable of being solved by a mere wave of the hand. The prodigious difficulties in the) EXHIBIT NO. 2—COTTON. | There is something admirable, as well as something pathetic, in thé story of | Mr. Taft's dealings with the tariff prob- lem. Having pledged himself to the pol- |icy of relegating the question of revi- ‘sion, in its first stage, to the Tariff | Board which was created by Congress ‘upon his recommendation, he adheres to ‘that decision with a certain judicial | fidelity which, whether to be commend- |ed or not in a man confronted with the |} manifold perplexities of the statesman ‘and the politician, has in it a quality the respectability of which it is impos- |sible to deny. The wool report of the Board was disconcerting, the eotton re- | port is more so; but the President |}makes no attempt to escape from these embarrassments. J’y suis, j'y reste, has been his motto from the beginning; and, in the face of all the difficulties into which the tariff mess has plunged ‘him, it is his motto still. | Foremost among these difficulties is the impossibility, now twice demonstrat- |ed on a large scale, of determining that | “difference in cost of production” which was so cheerfully proclaimed, a couple of years ago, as the happy and com- plete solution of the tariff problem. Poli- |ticians might be ignorant or corrupt, manufacturers might be grasping and deceitful, but “science” would clear away the fog that has so long surrounded the subject, and mark out the straight and narrow path along which the honest lawmaker must proceed. Well, science has done her best, and what is it? The report on wool left a margin of doubt wide enough to accommodate everybody except the standpatters; the report on cotton does the same. A single quota- tion from the latter report may suffice to illustrate a difficulty that runs through the whole matter: Taking all the mills covered by the in- vestigation in each country, there were wider variations in the American costs se- cured than in the English costs, due part- ly to the fact that the English mills were all in the Manchester district, where wages and other conditions are well standardized, while the American costs were taken from mills covering a much wider area, with much greater differences in labor and other conditions. Another reason for the wider variation in American costs is that the English mills for which figures were se- jeured are all of a modern and efficient |type, while some of the American mills | included were old and of low efficiency. _ We have chosen this particular quota- | tion because its concluding remark sug-

Page 11

April 4, 1912] The Nation 331 gests a stumbling-block of another kind, a trouble that strikes even deeper than that attending the mere arithmetic of the difference-of-cost principle. The “wider variation in American costs” which was due to the inclusion of some American mills that were “old and of low efficiency” may, from the point of view of the Tariff Board's inquiry, be a mere matter of statistical fact, of which they properly take note without com- ment; but from the point of view of the people’s interest, it opens up a broad field of doubt and protest. How much are we all paying to support concerns, in all directions, that need the tariff crutch to keep them going? This very report tells us that in the cotton indus- try there are many instances in which the American labor cost per unit of product is less than the foreign, in spite of our high wages, owing to the superior efficiency of American labor and organ- ization; just as it also shows that the incomparably lower wages of Japanese workmen result in a labor cost only slightly lower than ours. Why, then, should not the people of this country get the full benefit of superior efficiency where it exists, instead of throwing a large part of it away in the shape of high-price bounties to bolster up enter- prises that are less productive? To enter into the details and complex- ities of the cotton schedule is a task which only those will undertake upon whom it is laid as a special duty or to whom the rates are a matter of busi-| ness interest. But from the report the broad fact stares out plainly enough that the schedule as a whole has been gross- ly excessive; and the public will no longer doubt that the scandalous char- acter ascribed to it, not only by Demo- crats but by “insurgent” Republican | leaders like the late Senator Dolliver, | is borne out by the facts. The President | asks Congress to act, and it will be the part of patriotic duty for the Democrats to forward the fulfilment of this rec- ommendation without any such balanc- ings of political debit and credit as too often come to the front in such situa- tions. It is stated in Washington dis-| ining of time. If the critic is inclined patches that the Democrats will hang back for fear that if anything were done to relieve the public, the President would get the credit; but such calcula- tion is too fine by half. The people will give any party that does its share to- wards actual accomplishment of reform the part of the Democrats to achieve what seems attainable will be set down not only as bad in itself, but as giving a character of insincerity and unreality to those Democratic proposals the fail- ure of which will have been due to oppo- sition in the Senate or at the White House. THE CRITIC'S TROUBLES. Mr. Howells, in a recent interview, has formulated his own conception of the right conduct for critics. It may be summed up in one word—kindliness. “You cannot schoolmaster an art,” says Mr. Howells, and his practice has al- ways been faithful to his theory. Young writers have never failed of encourage- ment at his hands. and his praise has always been full measure. Many a young writer has been ushered by Mr. Howells to a place in the firmament which the rising star has never quite succeed- ed in attaining. But what is the harm? If the young man in question has the right stuff in him, eulogy is just what he needs. If he offers only false promise, the law of natural selection will attend to him sooner or later. This is a cheer- ful and ingratiating theory of criticism, but a great many people will always take exception to it. They cannot free ‘themselves from the argument of ety- mology. Criticism, after all, does mean judgment and discrimination. Keep your critics or suppress them altogether, but if you keep them you have no right to turn them into professional eulogists. It is wrong in theory and it does not pay. Experience shows that in the end the “constructive” or incurably good-na- tured critic fails to satisfy those about whom he writes and those for whom he writes. If for no other reason than vari- ety, it is good to mix the bitter with the sweet. Once it is conceded that the critic may speak harshly, provided he does so in a good cause, it is unkind to taunt the critic with the mistakes he makes, or rather not his own mistakes, but those of his profession since tne begin- te take a severe view of the condition of literature in his own day, he is remind- ed that critics have always failed to find good in the men about them. If he ventures on the mildest form of “this will never do,” he is reminded of the the credit it deserves; «while failure on! glorious destiny of Wordsworth. The common formula is that genius has a)- ways been misunderstood—see Richard Wagner. Too commonly the formula is changed so as to read that being mis- understood is the first sign of genius. This view finds expression even in the conservative columns of the London Times. The argument is that to-day there may be great writers unrecogniz- ed among us: There is no great poet of the present day who commands the allegiance of young readers as it was commanded by Tenny- son, Browning, and Swinburne when they were at the height of their powers; but that proves nothing. Wordsworth, Shelley, and Keats did not command the allegiance of young readers when they were at the height of their powers; and there may be poets of the same excellence writing now It is true that we cannot name them; but that also proves nothing. Hardly any one would have named Keats or Shelley in their lifetime as two of the greatest English poets; and as for Blake, he was not com- monly esteemed a great poet until at least a century after his death Now was there ever so parlous a pro- fession to be engaged in as this business of literary criticism? Disregarding fear and favor, honestly and after much study and reflection, I am about to say that Smith’s verse is really third-rate, when an icy hand falls on the critic's shoulder and a solemn voice intones, “Think of what the world may say about Smith's verse a hundred years from now.” A Keats or a Shelley may be writing to-day—"“it is true that we cannot name them; but that also proves nothing.” Now this bland statement can only mean one of two things. Either it means that the present-day Shelley's verse has got into print, has been reviewed by the critic, and has failed to be recognized as the work of genius; or else it means that the new Shelley has entirely escaped the critic’s attention, has not even got into print, and is destined to serve the future as a monument to the cruelty of Chance. The latter possibility may be dismissed at once, for the very reason ' alleged by our writer in the Times: it means nothing. To go about and say that there are Shakespeares, Michelan- gelos, and Raphaels among us, but we cannot name them, is to fall into that auto-intoxication of the modern spirit which so frequently makes the younger generation look back with pity on the entire past. How can you help pitying the past? See how comparatively little they accomplished and compare it with

Page 12

« 332 the magnificent possibilities that may be going on among us! Blessed is the twentieth-century ferment, for out of it anything may come. To be sure, the. young generation easily enough passes from “may come” to “is coming.” The Shakespeares and Michelangelos are there, only we cannot place them. But this is very near to nonsense, So we return to the old accusation. The critic frequently has Keats or Shel- ley under his eye and fails to recognize him. The charge is true. The grava- men of it is, of course, largely mitigat- ed by various considerations. For in- stance, the very people who reproach the contemporaries of Keats for not recog- nizing him are the ones who will argue that Keats was essentially ahead of his times and could not be recognized in his own day. To blame the critic for not liking what it takes fifty years’ rip- ening to like is somewhat unkind. But for the moment we may let that pass. Let it be admitted that it is the critic’s business to have his taste so perfected that he shall discover and like what the ordinary man will discover and like half | a century later. The question then rises, How can you expect this highly refined palate to be tolerant of the gross meat | and drink that serve the daily pur- poses of one’s contemporaries? In other words, How can you expect the critic) to be both discerning and kindly? Does not the very business of hunting out a) Shelley and championing him before the world imply the necessity of beating down the vast mass of written stuff that is not like Shelley? It is precisely by clearing the garden of literature from weeds that the perfect flower may be grown, It is unjust to accuse the gar- dener of being cruel both to the weeds and to the flower. THROUGH THE OUTLOOKING GLASS Alice had been sprinkling water on his face and fanning him with her straw hat) for several minutes, and still the Red Knight lay quite motionless. He looked #0 wan and pale it made Alice's heart ache. | But Just when she had decided that a doc- tor must be sent for, the Red Knight opered his eyes and sighed “Where are wet” he said. “We are still in North Dakota,” said Alice “And our opponents?” “They have gone somewhere else.” “I knew it,” said the Red Knight. “They | have left the field to me. I knew it would | be Ifthe that. I always win. Did you see| me charge?” The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 ! to see you go over your horse’s head so many times.” “I did that to disconcert them,” said the Red Knight. “As long as I stayed in the saddle they would keep on fighting. But as soon as I fell off they would naturally be at a loss what to do next.” “But you frightened me horribly,” said Alice. “Every time you went over you land- ed on your head.” “Oh, that was all right,” said the Red Knight. “My head has always been the strongest part of me. Besides, I always think very well on my head. It stimulates ;}me. Some of the very best ideas I have had—like the recall of judges, for instance —came to me in that position. The thing to do is to follow up our victery.” “You must not bother about that now,” said Alice. “You must really rest. Talking isn’t very good for you.” “It never hurts me to talk,” said the Red Knight. “It is no strain whatever. I can do it without thinking.” A tired look came into Alice’s face. “You are not discouraged, are you?” ask- ed the Red Knight, a little wistfully. “You mustn't be, yeu know. If I gave up the fight who else would there be to carry it on?” “I'm sure I don’t know,” said Alice. “There is no one else,” said the Red | I didn’t tell you. These men you see are only my Field Marshals. I don’t suppose | you have ever met them before, have you?” | “I never have,” said Alice. “I am only | eight, you know, and Mamma says I must | be seventeen before I go out in mixed | company.” “Then I must introduce you,” said the | Red Knight. “The small man in armor on |the right is the Harvester. We call him that because with him money cuts no ice. | He just loves the people. He sits up half | the night loving them. And he is so mod- est that the people don’t even suspect it. |A good man, the Harvester, and as true as United States Steel.” “I don’t think I like him,” said Alice. “I didn’t until he came out for me,” said |} the Red Knight. “That showed how mis- taken I was. The tall, thin man in green next to him is the Forester,socalled bécause |he is frequently up a tree. He is a nice fellow, but not practical enough. I some- times wonder whether he belongs with the |rest of my Field Marshals. Next to him, in | sheepskin, is the Barrister. He got his title from his willingness to round up Southern | delegates for any candidate, bar none... He | is the most unprejudiced man I know. The | last man on the left, in a uniform of colored | frontispieces, is the Publisher. But some- |times we call him the Pink-Cheeked Boy, Knight. “I'll prove it to you.” He reached | because his circulation is so good. Have you into his back pocket and pulled out a col- | ever seen a more impressive lot of men?” lapsible foot-measure of the kind carpenters; Alice couldn’t honestly say that she had. use in their business. He handed it to} So the Red Knight gave the signal and the Alice and asked her to open it out. |convincible army started out. Soon they “This is a very droll rule,” said Alice. | came to two finger-posts pointing in the “I thought all these pocket-measures ran Up| same direction. One finger-post said: “To to six feet, but this one stops short at five| the House of Good Trust,” and the other feet eight and a half inches.” “Exactly,” said the Red Knight. “Now would you mind taking my measure, just as I lie here?” ‘ Alice wondered, but complied. “Why,” she said, “it is just your height.” “Of course it is,” said the Red Knight. |“That, you see, is the rule of the people. I always carry it about with me. It is a very good rule, because it works only one way.” “Having rallied my troops,” said the Red Knight, “I will now march to settle the Trust problem at the head of my convinci- ble army.” “You mean invincible, don’t you?” said Alice. “I mean convincible,” replied the Red Knight “Because we always mareh to battle convinced that we shall be robbed of the fruits of victory.” “Then why fight at all?’ said Alice. The Red Knight looked at her in aston- ishment. “If we don't fight, how can we ery fraud afterwards?” “But you don't absolutely have to cry fraud, do you?” said Alice, timidly. For the first time since their acquain- tance the Red Knight grew sarcastic. “If you can tell me any other way we can keep up our spirits, I'd be much obliged,” he sald. | finger-post said: “To the House of Bad Trust.” Alice thought that was very odd, but she 'resolved she’d wait until they came to a | crossing. But when they did the road on |the left had no guide-post at all, and the | two fingers continued to point down the | other road. | “Do Good Trust and Bad Trust both live |in the same house?” asked Alice. “I shouldn't be surprised,” said the Red | Knight, and they marched on till they came | to New Jersey; and there, sure enough—but | what Alice saw there will be told by the | Red Knight in the preceding chapter. | GERMAN BOOKS ON AMERICA. _ The reader familiar with the work of |Ernst Freiherr von Wolzogen is likely | to be disappointed on seeing the title of his volume of American impressions, '“Der Dichter in Dollarica” (Berlin: F. Fontane & Co.). But if on surveying |the contents of the book one feels that ‘the poet’s and the humorist’s license enters largely into its composition, this |is not meant as a reproach. From the | very first chapter the sympathetic read- Alice was just on the point of saying, er will sense the genuine Wolzogen spir- “You might whistle,” but she thought bet- ter of it, and turned the subject. “Your army doesn't seem to be a very large one,” she said, “Yes, it is,” said the Red Knight. “I have countless millions on my side, But they are of rather a retiring disposition, it and will gradually yield to the spell of his whimsical and graceful, and al- ways thoroughly individual, manner. | But it is not all whim. The chapters in ‘in which he discusses the “Yankee” race, ‘the “Yankee” as educator, and Ameri- “I did,” said Alice. “It mgde°me so sad! You'd nover suspect they were there if! can college life, show keen insight and | i RON a

Page 13

aa beret . RPE April 4, 1912] The Nation a just valuation of the character and the achievements of a society which strikes him as being, above all, endowed with “youth, charming, wild, naughty, strong, indecently healthy youth.” What Herr von Wolzogen says about the phys- ical advantages of the “Yankee” race curiously coincides with and corrobo- rates reflections which at various times and from various German sources have come to the knowledge of the reviewer, viz., that centuries of political and so- cial repression, military coercion, and individual restraint have left their im- print upon the average German pbhysi- ognomy and prevented the development of clearly and harmoniously cut fea- tures. It is interesting to learn from the chapter on private and public moral- ity that German newspaper correspon- dents in the United States are forced to cater to the prejudices of ignorant Ger- man readers by sensationally color- ed reports on things American. Herr von Wolzogen deserves credit for his condemnation of that system and for his attempts to correct some misstate- ments which have widely affected pub- lic opinion in his country. He regards political corruption as an inevitable re- sult of the expanse of the country and the four-year term. He rather admires the American’s patient acceptance of petty annoyances and nuisances which in Germany, as in other European coun- tries, would give rise to outbursts of bad temper, whether the scene be a pub- lic conveyance or a public thoroughfare. Of course, he disagrees with the system of avoiding the discussion of certain questions, however vital they may be, in our literature and the press. But he ad- mits that American morality and Amer- ican educators have provided the best possible material for future fatherhood, which is the highest compliment to be bestowed upon any nation. Considerable space is devoted in the book to the “cultural” aspects of Amer- ica, but the author’s familiarity with American literature seems rather lim- ited. Of contemporary writers he rec- ognizes only Jack London as possessed of a strong individuality with a distinct- ly American coloring. He justly cred- its German pioneers in music with hav- ing elevated American taste to such a degree that American audiences can appreciate a performance of “Parsifal” and a programme of Beethoven and Brahms, but when he mentions as one) of these pioneers Max “Friedrich,” he seems to have meant the veteran of the German Lied, Heinrich. Save for the) work of the New Theatre, he has a very low opinion of the American stage. The best comedy-acting he saw was by a. | abuses. But he is mistaken in assum- | ing that there is probably no daily in this country whiclk is not illustrated. There is a great deal worth reading in the last two chapters, especially the one entitled Was kénnen wir von Amerika lernen? He calls it the country of the absolute present, and a mirror in which all cultured nations may read their fu- ture, The thoroughgoing seriousness and dignity of Wilhelm Miiller’s book, “Das religidse Leben in Amerika” (Jena: Eug. Diederichs), revives the memory of the well-known, excellent work by Wilhelm von Polenz, “Das Land der Zukunft.” The German author, who for many years lived and taught in this country, had incomparably greater op- portunities to study its people than the other distinguished visitor, but the spir- it in which he went at this task made him arrive at similar conclusions. Von Polenz called America the land of the future. Miiller is inclined to call it the cradle of a religion of the future. Herr Miiller strikes the keynote of his book in the very beginning of the chap- ter on the Puritan pilgrims, where he quotes their Minister in Leyden and re- gards his words to his departing con- gregation not only as the consolations of a shepherd to his flock, but as the re- ligious and political. legacy of a sage with the statesman’s far-reaching vi- sion.» For him these words hold the seeds of a religious toleration which, notwithstanding painful lapses into an unbending dogmatism, were at a later period to yield the rich harvest of relig- ious freedom. He sees in the work of all the churches that gradually sprang up in the country the growing desire to give life an ethical content. Of interest to German readers is the relation which the author points out between Jona- than Edwards’s conception of history and that of Schiller’s famous line: Die Weltgeschichte ist das Weltgericht. But even more striking is his compari- son of Tolstoy’s method of realizing the ideal of a human brotherhood, and that of Edward Everett Hale, the former de- scending to the depths of the poor and lowly to be one of them, the latter lift- ing them to his height to make them his equals. The chapter on Transcen- dentalism is one of the most thoughtful in the book. Emerson as a spiritual power is compared to a rock in the high-tide of an all-uprooting material- 'ism. In the chapter on the Catholic) Church in America the author recog-| nizes in Hecker’s association with Brook | Farm, the influence which molded his character, and credits Hecker and his) anxiety sometimes felt in view of the stupendous growth of Catholicism in America, the author is inclined to share the opinion of Dr. Eliot, who said that the influence of American democracy upon that church is greater and deeper than the influence of the Catholic church upon the government and the society of this country. Some paragraphs on Walt Whitman are commendable for their sane inter- pretation of Whitman's philosophy of acceptance, but it is to be feared that the author overrates the number of ad- herents of the “Whitman Cult,” if such there be. When he surveys the work of the various “lay orders,” like the Salvation Army, his conviction seems to grow that the chief feature of these and other religious organizations in America is the desire to supplant or at least supplement creed by deed. The author of the book entitled “Was ich in Amerika fand,” Freiherr Hans von Barnekow, has been little concerned about the spiritual problems of Amerl- can life, but has pretty thoroughly stud- ied its material sides. The book, which is imported by G. E. Stechert & Co., Is written from the standpoint of the edu- cated immigrant, preferably the German army officer or “Junker.” The author seems to have known the life of the road as of the cheap lodging-house, and to have been in immediate contact with the vast army of the unemployed. He treats the many problems that confront the foreigner in this country with com- mendable judgment, but the order in which he presents his impressions fre- quently brings into. prominence things that were probably not so meant. Thus, in the very first chapter he launches forth into a discussion of the unrelia- bility of judicial practice and makes it the starting-point for a tirade about lynching, lending color to the foreign suspicion that this is a common prac- tice in America. In dealing with the Black Hand and other outrages he is In- clined to lay the blame exclusively at the doors of the police o* New York, without considering the unparalleled conditions with which this common- wealth has to cope, since its stream of immigrants is endless. His criticism of the average American newspaper is in most respects justified; so is his cen- sure of certain society fads. Where the writer makes excursiens into topics like the American woman, it is evident that he commits the common error of hasty generalizing. His amazing statement that American women among themselves discuss with appalling frank- ness subjects that even men shrink from “Yiddish” company at Miner’s, on the|teacher, Brownson, with the wider so- touching upon in conversation, curl- Bowery, which he calls “The Miners.” | cial activities of the church. He re-| ously contradicts the charge of prud- He is of the opinion that the safest way grets that the histories of literature ig-| ery raised against them even in their to lower the standard of a newspaper is nore men of such striking personality | own country. When he says that this to furnish illustrations, and sharply cen- and literary merit as Thomas Hecker | sort of unveiled utterance appears most sures sensational headlines and other and Father Tabb. Referring to the shamelessly in the newspapers of the

Page 14

[Vol. 94, No. 2440 334 The Nation emancipated woman, one is tempted to ask the names of those papers. A. von ENDE. SWISS NOTES. NEvucHATEL, March 7. Like the Germans, the Swiss are often blamed for their dislike of fresh air. Churches, university lecture-rooms, tramways, and restaurants are badly ventilated. To some extent, this ac- counts for the prevalence of tubercu- losis in this excellent climate. It is therefore satisfactory to remark that open-air schools for children have been founded near some of the larger towns. One of the best of these is situated near Zurich, on a high wooded hill, from which there is a beautiful view of the lake and mountains. Poor children in the canton can easily reach the place by tramway. The younger pupils are not obliged to follow any definite course of study. Those who are older have two hours of teaching in the morning, and they learn gardening and other out- of-doors employments. The physical re- sults of this system are excellent. In a Protestant country like Switzer- land it was reasonable to expect that Christian Sc'ence would find many ad- vocates. In the larger towns, especially, the doctrines of that sect have been well received. Professor Mayor of the University of Lausanne has lately writ- ten, if not a defence, at least a sympa- thetic appreciation, of Christian Science. It is entitled “Mrs. Eddy et la science chrétienne.” The frontispiece is a por- trait of the lady, whom Professor Mayor calls the prophetess of the new world, “la grande Américaine.” Another Swiss writer speaks of her as “the new Mes- siah of Boston.” Henri Cordey, another Lausanne professor, thinks, however, that Mrs. Eddy showed psychopathic symptoms. “We find in her case all the symptoms of an abnormal nervous con- stitution,” “a morbid suggestibility, akin to an obsession favorable to the development of monomania,”” Notwith- standing, Professor Cordey maintains that Mrs. Eddy’s influence was very be- neficent, in encouraging optimism and giving a new vitality to the Christian religion. Another Swiss professor, who is better known In America than in his native country, has written for a relig- ious journal, L'Eglise Nationale, a caus- tic eritieiam of Mrs. Eddy and her church. The author is Albert Schinz, now professor at Bryn Mawr, who is a native of Neuchatel. Dr. Bernhard Fehr of the University of Zurich has lately been lecturing on Oscar Wilde, as “Avsthete and Individ- ualist.” Without laying emphasis on Wilde's moral defects, he gave perhaps the best estimate of his place in litera- ture which has yet appeared. Naturally, it is difficult to separate the English au- thor’s character from his* work; but ‘some of Wilde’s work tempts one to for-| edition of John Gower’s “Confessio Aman- get his character. tis,” printed by William Caxton in 1483. Professor Masson of the University of| This is, perhaps, the best of the seven Fribourg has lately read a paper before | known perfect copies of one of the few the French Academy of Moral and Po-| original English books from Caxton’s press. litical Science, It concerns a rough! This copy, formerly Bryan Fairfax’s, was draft, or brouillon, of Rousseau’s! sold by him to Francis Child in 1756, and “Emile,” a manuscript now in the pos-| when sold at auction in the Earl of Jersey session of M. Favre at Geneva. The 28th | sale, in May, 1385, brought £810, and was ot June is the two hundredth anni-|>ought by Mrs. Norton Quincy Pope of versary of Rousseau’s birth. Of course| Brooklyn, In 1895, after Mrs, Pope's death, the book, with many others from her li- the occasion will be widely observed in| ; . |brary, was acquired by Mr. Hoe. One France. But Geneva is the place where) ; : . f jother Caxton, a fragment of his second Rousseau’s memory is most ondly | eaition of the “Golden Legende” (1483), is cherished. The people there still speak | j,cjuded in this sale, There are five books o1 him as “le grand citoyen.” Neuchatel, | from the press of Wynken de Worde: “A however, where for a time Rousseau Contemplacyon or medytacyon of the resided, has no special reverence for | shedynge of the blood of our lorde Jhesu the author of “Le Contrat social.” |Chkryste at seven tymes” (about 1500), ap- While a resident in this canton, Rousseau | Parently the only copy known; “The Chirche wrote several letters about the Neu-|°f the Evyll Men and Women, whereof chatelois which will never make his|“ucyfer is the heed and the members is jall the players dyssolute and synners re- »mo ear to the natives. But memory 4d . or proved” (1511), one of three known copies; neva is to celebrate elaborately Rous-| seau’s birthday. M. Fazy, a leading) Radical politician, has charge of the matter; and with him is associated Pro-| fessor Yung of the University. There) is to be a great public meeting, with ad-| dresses concerning Rousseau’s life and| work. A brochure about Rousseau is to be distributed to the young people in all) the schools. Then there is to be a pro-| cession of all the little Emiles and their sisters. Imitating their French neighbors in| the medical schools of Paris, students at | the University of Berne have been in rebellion. “L’unique objet de leur dé- testation” has been Professor Kolle, who has the chair of hygiene and bacteri-| ology. Kolle has earned a fine reputa- tion in science; but his assistants and) students complain of his severity and/| arbitrary methods. Besides being pro-| fessor at Berne, Kolle is scientific di-) rector of the Dresden Institute of | Bacteriology. It is from the Dresden) laboratory that “pyocianose” is obtained. | This seems to be a sort of panacea, cur-| ing everything from human influenza to) the petty diseases of cats and dogs. In a lecture delivered recently béfore | the Historical Society of Bale, Dr. Escher of the University there spoke of Riche- lieu as the Mecenas of French literature. Of course, Richelieu’s general services to literature are well known; but Dr. Escher has collected interesting and hitherto unnoticed facts concerning the Cardinal’s devotion to art and letters. Dr. Escher’s lecture is an important con- tribution to the history of a great literary period. A. A. ‘NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. Although the third part of the Robert | Hoe library, which will be sold by the Anderson Auction Company April 15 to 26, ie of less interest than the preceding | parts, yet the two catalogues, 3,412 lots, in- 'elude a number of important and valuable |books, Chiefest among them is the first |*The booke of good maners” (1507), having three preliminary leaves not in any of the other described copies; “The Golden Le- gend” (1527), the text of Caxton’s transla- tion; and a school grammar, “Promptuar- ium parvulorum clericorum” (1516). Among English books of the cighteenth century, the collection of first editions of Dryden's books is most remarkable. Among other rarities may be noted “A Poem upon the Death of His Late Highness, Oliver,” }and the same in “Three Poems” (both 1659) ; “To his Sacred Majesty, a Panegyrick on his Coronation” (1661); “The Conquest of Granada” (1672); “Absalom and Achito- phel,” both parts (1681-82); “Henry Pur- cell” (1696), and “Alexander's Feast,” bet- ter known as the “Ode on St. Cecilia’s Day” (1697). The first editions of Goldsmith include “The Deserted Village” (1770), on large and thick paper, a form virtually unknown to collectors and bibliographers, though there was a copy in the Rowfant Library, and another, uncut, in a private library in London. The owner of the latter has ac- companying it an uncut copy of the ordi- nary issue. With the two side by side all doubt as to their being two distinct forms is dispelled. Goldsmith’s “Poems and lays” (Dublin, 1777) is also on large and thick paper, and Anderson’s cataloguer surmises that it is “probably unique.” There are, however, at least two other copies in America (in the Morgan and Chew collec- tions), which, as the title-pages of the two differ, were described in this column some three years ago. The first edition of Pope’s “Dunciad” (1728), an uncut copy of which brought $1,800 in the second Hoe sale; and the first edition of Prior’s “Poems” (1707), a copy of which brought $350 in the preced- ing sale, are two rare books which Mr. Hoe owned in duplicate. While the Hoe library is not especially rich in first editions of modern authors, this third part includes a long series of Scott and Marryatt and desirable items by Thackeray, Swinburne, Ainsworth, and others. : After the two Columbus Letters, Plannck’s second edition (Rome, 1493), and the Ver- ardus-Columbus (Basle, 1494), the most val- uable early American items in this part LFEPA IR ORE eR Ot ee ee

Page 15

aitsaieMideetiies Ineasiatatoenn £ 2 * 7 April 4, 1912] The Nation 335 are two Mexican imprints. Richel’s “Com- pendio breve que tracta d’ la manera de como se han de hazer las processiones,” printed in Mexico by Juan Cromberger in 1544, is the Andrade-Brinley copy, and just about the earliest American-printed book which any collector may expect to be able to procure. Vasco de Puga’s “Provisiones Cedulas, Instruciones de su Majestad,” printed in Mexico in 1563, is notable as being the first volume of laws printed in America, and one of the earliest American- printed books not theological in charac- ter. This also is a duplicate, Mr. Hoe's other copy having brought $610 in the pre- ceding sale. But a later book, a compila- tion printed in Amsterdam in 1651 with the title “Beschryvinghe van Virginia, Nieu Nederlandt, Nieuw Engelandt,” etc., may, on account of a little copper-plate engrav- ing on page 21, be expected to bring a higher price even than the Columbus Let- ter of 1493. This little copper-plate bears the legend “t’Fort nieuw Amsterdam op de, Manhatans,” and is the earliest engraved view of the city of New York. The books in special or prevenance bind- ings include three specimens from the li- brary of Jean Grolier; Castiglione’s “Libro del Cortigiano” (1528), Cicero’s “Epistole familiares” (Aldus, 1522), and Albertus Krantz’s “Wandalia” (1519). There are also books bearing the arms of Colbert, Cardinal Fleury, Count Hoym, Louis XIV, Louis XV, Louis XVI, Louis XVIII, Marie Antoinette, Madame du Barry, Madame de Pompadour, the Duchesse de Montpensier, and other notables. At the end of the Catalogue is an index of the books with Armorial bindings. The French books include long series of the first editions of the works of Francois Coppée, Alphonse Daudet, Alfred de Mus- set, Georges Ohnet, and other modern writ- ers, as well as eighteenth century illus- trated books, a first collected edition of Moliére (1666), and other rarities. A remarkable collection of books and leaflets from the Lee-Priory Press, a series of late Eighteenth Century Jest Books, a Kelmscott Press Chaucer, bound by the Doves Bindery, and a number of Grolier Club publications, the “Life of Dante” being on vellum, are other features of this portion of the Hoe library. Correspondence APPEAL AND THE REFERENDUM. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In Col. Roosevelt’s novel proposal, in his Columbus speech, of a popular refer- endum on judicial decisions, overlooks one important detail in our pres- ent judicial procedure, which, moreover, has not been commented on in any discus- | sion of the matter which has come to my attention. His proposal relates entirely to decisions of the highest State courts of ap- peals, and is based upon the considerable number of decisions by these tribunals in which State statutes of a beneficent char- acter have been nullified because in con- flict with the Federal Constitution. It is true that he refers to the income tax de- cision, and that which declared the Fed- eral Employers’ Liability law unconstitu- ‘tional, as instances where the Supreme he entirely | Court of the United States has failed to reflect the public will. But his chief griev- ance is certainly with the State courts. In his Carnegie Hall address he says: “I am not proposing anything in connection with the Supreme Court of the United States or with the Federal Constitution.” He even admits that a case reversed by such a pop- ular vote might be carried to the Federal Supreme Court, where, presumably, the de- cision of the State court might be sus- tained and the referendum overruled. Now the Supreme Court of the United States takes a much broader view of con- stitutional questions than many of the State courts, as the Colonel himself shows in dis- cussing the Ives case. The constitutionality of a statute, similar to the New York Em- ployers’ Liability law, enacted by another State, was affirmed by the Federal Supreme Court. The reason why this statute could be passed upon by the highest court in the land, and the New York law could not be tested in the Federal courts, lies in the spe- cial provision of the judiciary act of Con- gress which governs the whole matter of appeals to the Federal courts from State courts. It is this detail of the Federal statute which has been overlooked in the current discussion. The law provides that appeals from State courts to the Federal courts shall only lie when the decision of the highest State court has been against the party in the case claiming a right under the Federal Constitution, statutes, or treat- ies. When the State court against the State statute in the case, declar- ing it invalid as conflicting with the Federal Constitution, statutes, or treaties, no appeal can be carried to the Federal court. The reason for this provision must be clear to any one. Congress presumed that if a State court declared a statute of its own State unconstitutional there would be no object gained in allowing the question to be carried before the Federal Supreme Court, since the latter could only be expected to affirm the decision. When, however, the decision went the other way the necessity of maintaining the supremacy of the Federal Constitution and law would be involved, and the Supreme Court of the United States must make the ultimate decision. In the case which Col. Roosevelt cites, where the Federal Supreme Court upheld the constitutionality of a State Employers’ Liability act, the decision of the State court was evidently in favor }of the act. In the Ives case the New York Court of Appeals took the opposite view and | forestalled the possibility of an appeal to | the Supreme Court of the United States and a decision on the question by that body. The remedy in the matter appears to the | writer to be a very simple one. An amend- ment to the Federal statute permitting ap- peals in all cases, where the question of the |validity of a State statute is denied on }grounds of its conflicting with the Federal Constitution, statutes, or treaties, would assure a final decision by the Supreme Court of the United States, and go far towards alleviating the difficulty of which the Col- onel complains. Since he admits that the Supreme Court must have the power of ul- \timate decision on appeal from, the popular referendum, which in effect is nothing but an intermediate instance between the high- est State court and the Federal judiciary, pronounces the State court to the United States court in why not make the appeal lie directly from| ‘piping triumphantly all cases? What possible purpose would it serve to introduce an intermediate instan in the form of a popular referendum on Sta court decisions, if an appeal therefrom cou in any case be taken to the Federal Supr: Court? WALTER JAMES SHEPAR! University f Missouri, March 26 A ROMAN STRIKE TO THE Epitor OF THE NATION Sir: As the public mind is now occupied with the subject of strikes, perha, a brief account of a notable strike that occurred in Rome in the year 309 A may not be without interest The pipers in ancient Rome were orig inally a small company whose duties w to furnish solemn music at the public sa fices and at funerals In virtue of their quasi-réligious character they dined at th public expense in the temple of Jupiter. Bu in process of time, and with the growth of luxury, it became the fashion to engage their services for private entertainments. With this increasing demand their numbers great- ly increased, and they began to be || voked upo2 as mere hired musicians; so in the year mentioned the censors deprived then of their daily dinner in the temple The touchy artists took this in high dudgeon and to a man picked up their marched out of Rome to Tibur (now Tivoli) pipes and The Romans were struck with consterna tion at this unlooked-for coup; not for tl loss of the music, but because no sacrifice could be tional tootings; and without sacrifices no offered without the proper devo campaign could be begun, no army march no consuls be inaugurated—in a word, all public, and much private, business would be at a standstill The Senate, recognizing the gravity of the situation, dispatched envoys to the Ti burtines, entreating them to send the pipers back. The Tiburtines wers what they could, and, assembling the strik ers in the curia, besought them to return The pipers said that there was nothing to arbitrate; if their temple dinners were re- stored they would go back; on no other condition would they budge. The Tiburtines a superstitious generation, did not dare to use force with men failings, had a sort of semi-sacred char acter. A council was called to discuss the matter In the discussion one citizen remarked that pipers were notorious wine avidum genus), and that in that weakness might lie the solution of the difficulty. The council caught the idea, and proceeded to act upon it. On the next holiday all th: wealthy citizens gave musicales, at which they supplied the musicians with wine so liberally that they lost consciousness of sublunary things; upon which th tines loaded them on wagons, drove then that night to Rome, and left them, still fast asleep, in the Forum Great was the joy of the Romans the next morning to find their pipers back. They besought them never to leave them again restored the temple dinners, and gave them and their successors for all time to come the privilege of celebrating their victory by marching in solemn procession § through Rome, every year, on the Ides of June, And this festive cel- willing to do who, whatever their bibbers (vini Tibur-

Page 16

The Nation . 336 [Vol. 94, No. 2440 ebration continued, certainly for three hun- 'y should still maintain, however, that | “white.” If there be any probability in dred years, and possibly for six hundred. “subjugate” carries at least as well “the|the above conjecture might it not be said oe H. full meaning inherent in the German | that a “white course” is really a modern - context.”—Tue Reviewer. ] |version of the “town of refuge,” and a on | “white professor” one who in the mem- ‘ory of the oldest undergraduate has never |been known to shed human blood? GUILMENSIAN. Williamstown, Mass., March 28. timore, 4 QUESTION OF TRANSLATION. A PARALLEL FROM TROLLOPE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Among the aspiring politicians and ambitious clergymen whom Trollope drew) so conscientiously in his leisurely Chroni- | DR. BOLTON AND THE MEXICAN cles, Mr. Supplehouse, in ‘“Framley Par- | ARCHIVES. sonage,” does not play a tremendous part, | but his conception of himself and his mis- |T? THE Epitor oF THE NaTIon: sion makes him a striking prototype of a| SiR: In a recent book, “California Under far cleverer, more conspicuous political | Spain and Mexico,” I state that Dr. Herbert character of to-day. Mr. Supplehouse was| E. Bolton of the University of California, ‘extolled by a portion of the metropolitan {m cataloguing the Mexican archives for daily press as the only man who could save| ‘he Carnegie Institution of Washington, To EpiITtor OF THE NATION: SIR THE ot my translation of Sudermann's “Indian Lily” (Nation, March 7). your reviewer starts out, quite obvious- ly, with an initial disapproval of my entire theory and method of translation Instead that however, he work with a degree of abso- the point reader an erroneous im- in In a notice ot stating disar proval, condemns my Ivteness which quite misses at issue, and gives the pression Two of the sentences which, his words, “are not the equivalent of the German,” read as follows in the original: 1. country,” and went about mightily | found it necessary to create his own system (1.) ersann sie einen Plan, den) “swinging his tomahawk”; and the author |°f reference. This statement, Dr. Bolton Se ee et aoe ere we. asks: “How can a man born to save a na-|!Xforms me, ts too broad, as the archives dachte. (P.92) . tion and to lead a people be content to|#re not without a system, and what he (2.) Auch sie selber sah die Welt seit fill the chair of an under-secretary?’’ 4/4 was in the main to separate the many langem nur durch blaue Schleier, horte die) again, “ ‘Let us throw in our shells,’ says| Volumes of vice-regal correspondence into TE Sehr aes Mr. Su~»lehouse, mindful as Juno of his | #PPropriate series. durch die erschlaffenden Glieder rinnen.| despised charms, And when Mr. Supple-| The results achieved by Dr. Bolton are (P. 99.) house declares himself an enemy, men‘ be published by the Carnegie Institution These two passages are thus rendered: (1.) she thought out a plan, the first of many by which she meant to rivet her beloved fer life. (P. 95.) (2.) She herself saw the world through a blue veil, heard the voices of life across an immeasurable distance, and felt hot, alien shivers run through her enervated limbs (P 102.) point of view from which these translations can be said not to be “the equivalent of the German” is one that re- The only goards translation as a task to be performed | in the light of a grammar and a lexicon. The values of literature, however, are con- notative, and its medium is one of symbols 1 hold the rhythm of a given paragraph to be no less a part of the full expressiveness of serious writing than the exact sense ol a single vocabl Your reviewer asserts tnat I show myself “unaware of the meaning of words.” But I am thoroughly aware of the fact, for instance, that “zu erobern” means “to conquer.” And thus I would ask students u& my elementary classes to render it I wrote deliberately “to rivet,” and I am still convinced that that verb, and that alone carries the full meaning inherent in the German context Similarly, I have trans- lated “aus weiter Ferne” by “immeasurable distance,” not because I am ignorant of the meaning of weit, but because the rich emo- ticnal value of the original phrase seems to me more adequately transferred by the word I chose In brief, then, | protest against your reviewer's saying, virtually: “This is a poor transiation’; instead of saying “This may be a very good trans- lation, but I disapprove in toto of the meth- od employed.” LUDWIG LEWISOHN, . Columbus, O., March 24 [My remark, “unaware of the meaning | of words,” was intended to apply, and | seems to me unmistakably to apply, to | English words; and I am of the opinion | that “rivet” as a translation of “ero- bern” and “across an immeasurable dis- tance” as a translation of “wie aus weit- er Ferne” are false. “Rivet” may have | in American slang some “connotative” value with which I am not acquainted; know how much it means. succumb to the terrible blows which are now in store for him.” ; But it is Mr. Supplehouse’s mental pro- cesses that interest and baffle us most. They should be of curious value for the psychol- ogist who would write an Introduction to the Theory of Political Motive: Was he not the man to save the nation; and, if so, why should he not pick up the fruit himself? What though the country at the present moment needed no more saving; might there not, neverthe- less, be a good time coming? Were there not rumors of other wars still preva- lent? The public mind was now awake, and) When a) understood what it was about. man gets into his head an idea that the public voice calls for him, it is astonish- ing how great becomes his trust wisdom of the public. Vor Populi ror Det. “Has it not been so always?” he says to himself, as he gets up and as he goes to bed. mm. G,’ Brunswick, Me., 26. March A “WHITE COURSE.” To THe EpiTror oF THE NATION: The college yell characteristic of American institutions of higher learning has, with some degree of plausibility, been explained as a custom adopted from the savages who, before us, inhabited this country. With perhaps an equal plausibility # common undergraduate conception may be correlated to an ideal similar in its origin. Westermarck, in his “Origin and Development of the Moral Ideas” (Vol. I, SIR: p. 380), quotes from Adair’s “History of the American Indians” to the following effect: In almost every Indian nation there are several peaceable towns, which are called “old beloved,” “ancient,” “holy,” or “white” towns; they seem to have been for- merly “towns of refuge,” for it is not in the memory of their oldest people that ever human blood was shed in them; al- though thes often force persons from thence, and put them to death elsewhere. It was a source of some perplexity to me during my university days why a given professor or his courses should be thought They know that that much-belabored Head of Affairs must in the) itself, but it may be permitted me here to | observe that his task, as he generously con- sented to regard it, involved the preparation and utilization of a special catalogue of some three thousand cards relating to Alta California. To this special work Dr. Bol- ton contributed largely of his time and scholarship, and its importance to “Cali- fornia Under Spain and Mexico” (be the execution of the latter what it may) was fundamental. IRVING B, RICHMAN. Muscatine, Ia., March 26. Literature A POLITICIAN OF THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY. Henry For, First Lord Holland: A Study of the Career of an Eighteenth Century Politician. By Thad W. Riker, M.A., B.Litt. Oxon. 2 vols. New York: Henry Frowde. $6.75 net. In an illuminating letter to Henry Pelham, August 25, 1743, Robert Walk pole wrote: “Fox you cannot do with- eut.” The remark remained the cus- tomary estimate of the man by succes- sive ministry-makers from that time till 1765, when Henry Fox finally laid aside public office. Whenever the diffi- culties in the way of forming Ministries seemed almost insurmountable, leaders like the Duke of’ Newcastle and the Earl of Bute turned in despair to Fox, the one man capable of forming combina- tions and sufficiently clever and un- scrupulous to create majorities in Par- liament. This chameleon-hued politician and typical eighteenth-century public man has waited long for his biographer. A sufficient explanation of the delay may be that his fatherhood of Charles James Fox transcends in importance his other services to his country; but it may be also that no biographer has had the hardihood to attempt the chron-

Page 17

Se bas ee oe NE TORRENT EY April 4, 1912] The Nation ecient {cling and explanation of his many po-| litical tergiversations. Considering the importance of the po-| litical life of the man, our sources of in- | formation are very meagre indeed. Only a few of his letters, published in vari- | ous works, have been preserved, so that our view of his activities is presented to us for the most part by such men as Horace Walpole, the Duke of Newcastle, and others who were at times Fox's bit- terest political enemies. Mr. Riker has used all available material with praise- worthy industry, and his statement of facts rests on a sound basis. Occasion- ally there. appears to have been given too great weight to the gossip of Budd Dodington and too little attention to such illuminating letters as those of Lord Lyttleton to his brother, the Gov- ernor. The information which the au- thor has found in the manuscripts of the Duke of Newcastle furnishes only an- other example of the importance and wealth of that mass of material which is left still unpublisned in the British Museum. There were two periods in Fox’s life when he played the title réle in British politics; and Mr. Riker, who has limit- ed himself to depicting the politician, has justly given these two periods the greatest prominence. The first and more important begins just before the outbreak of the Seven Years’ War and lasts until the formation of the Pitt-| Newcastle Ministry in 1757. The second period is much shorter, embracing the few months of the autumn and winter of 1762-63, when the treaty of peace was) ratified. Of the 772 pages of the biography, 440 are devoted to the story of the years 1754 to 1757. The reader feels that the author has made himself a master of) the events of this short period, and that his real contribution to the history | of the political life of Great Britain de- pends on the correctness of his inter- pretation of them. What precedes is but introductory matter and the pages which follow have been added to round out the biography, but do not reveal the | results of the same careful, even pains- taking, study. For this reason, it might have been better had Mr. Riker not at- tempted so ambitious a work as the po- litical life of Fox, but had limited him- self to what is undoubtedly the main subject of his two volumes, the history of British politics in the first years of the Seven Years’ War. The period which the author has fully depicted was worthy of monographic | study. It begins with the death of Henry Pelham, an event which marks | the beginning of the end of the old régime. The Whig party had been firm- | ly established in power for almost a! generation, and the Tory party was vir- | tually annihilated through its suspect-| ed leaning towards Jacobitism, so that) a rivalry between the two former an- tagonists was no longer possible. To the Whigs belonged exclusively the pleasure of directing the government and the enjoyment of fat sinecures. Early in his political career, Henry Fox, who was by family descent and tradi- tions a Tory, attached himself to the ruling class and swore his allegiance to Robert Walpole, the chief architect of the “Venetian party,” as Disraeli loved to call the small clique of politicians, principally noblemen, who disposed of the spoils of office and rough-hewed the destinies of their heelers and opponents. The long continuance in power of the Whigs without the possibility of rivalry was bringing, by 1754, its own nemesis, The party was broken into factions whose raison d'étre was the enjoyment of the “flesh-pot” of officeholding. The political chaos caused by the rivalry of these factions reached its climax in the years from 1754 to 1770. The few years of the ascendency of Henry Fox in the politics of Great Britain syn- chronizes with the opening of this pe- riod, and his career is identified with the breaking of the domination of the Whig machine. In the year 1754 there were five main factions, with several sub-divisions de- veloping rapidly into rival factions. Henry Fox was a member of that group which surrounded the Duke of Cumber- land, the favorite son of George II. With him were associated the Dukes of Devon- shire and Bedford, with their many de- pendents. The faction represented the former circle of Robert Walpole’s friends and still nursed an enmity to- wards those who had intrigued to over- throw that leader. Their most formid- able rivals and the ones in actual pos- session of the power which belonged to the Government were led by that fussy dispenser of patronage and capable poli- tician of the lowest order, the Duke of Newcastle, upon whose word hung the destinies of most of the placemen and sinecurists. Henry Fox knew the value of political power.and had been careful, in spite of the wishes of his associates, not to alienate completely this maker of fortunes, so that of the Cumberlandites, he was the least objectionable in the eyes of Newcastle and the one whom that nobleman always knew he could use. In a third camp, but not always cor- dially united, were two more factions, the Pittites and the heelers of Leices- ter House. The Pittites were neither nu- merous nor powerful, but in their lead- er, William Pitt, they had a great asset. For the most part they were homines novi, who had not yet succeeded in breaking into the inner circle of the “Venetian party.” Opportunity and ca- pacity were sopn to raise the “brother- hood” to the crest of the machine poll- tics. The Leicester House faction was composed of the bodyguard of Prince George, the future George III, and his’ mother, the Princess Dowager. They were for the most part Whigs who, dis- contented with the rule of the Pelhams and anticipating the change of mon- archs, preferred to trust their fate to the future reign. Among them the Ear! of Bute appeared as the dispenser of fa- vors, and he was ready at all times to unite with the willing Pittites for the overthrow of the Old Whig dynasty. Mr. Riker frequently confuses in his narrative—a confusion that is common in the best histories of the period—the Leicester House faction with the Tories The Tories could no longer be called a party, for they had ceased to exercise any real power in politics, and were like the other factions, a group of men acting together in the hope of picking up some of the political crumbs. Al- though all the factions courted them, they were most favorable to the Pittites and Leicester House, and, as a matter of fact, their recall, to a moderate political influence, was due to the action of the former. The pages devoted by Mr. Riker to this most important period of Fox's life contain a complete chronicle of the vari ous intrigues, conferences, and com promises of the five factions. From the literary point of view, the story is too crowded with names and incidents, and the attention of the reader becomes fatigued. In twenty-one lines on one page may be counted eleven names of men and four offices whose occupants one is expected to know. Yet such a surfeit of names only reproduces the picture of British politics in the eigh- teenth century, with its constant shift- ing of individuals, continual shuffling of places, and repetition of intrigues. After the death of Henry Pelham, the Duke of Newcastle found himself in an anomalous and difficult position. The dominance of the Whigs for a gen- eration had shifted the weight of influ ence from the House of Lords to the Commons, where had ruled successively the capable Robert Walpole and Henry Pelham. These men had built up the political machinery by the control of borough representation, places, sine cures, pensions, and bribery, until the Ministry always had a majority at its beck and call; but now the Duke had no trustworthy lieutenant in the lower house to whom might be confided the duty of buying majorities. He must, therefore, look outside for the leader. Pitt being by nature incapable of this charge, the Duke naturally turned his eyes towards Henry Fox, whose former loyal support of his brother seemed to presage a hope of continued support in spite of his adherence to the Duke of Cumberland. Fox was ready enough to accept the offer of the management of the House of Commons, provided hoe was made a partner in the distribution of the corruption fund. To this the Duke gave his consent at first; but, becoming

Page 18

338 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2440 a member of another faction with the ecrets and power of management, he denied his own words. Fox pointed out that, “if he were to have the absolute direction of the House of Commons, he must know who had been ‘gratified’ and vho had not; for how otherwise could he speak to the members without ap- pearing ridiculous?” Still the Duke was obdurate, and Fox withdrew his con- ent; and, although continuing as Secre- tary at War, he joined Pitt in opposi- tion. The opportunity to break the dictator- -lal power of the Duke of Newcastle was hortly offered. The policy of war which the Opposition advocated was similar to that upon which Robert Wal- pole had been broken. The colony of Vir- ginia was suffering opposition from the French in her attempt to extend her co- lonial settlements west of the Alle- ghanies. Col. Washington was actually attacked and forced to surrender. The Ministry was in favor of compromising with France; the Opposition naturally supported a war policy. The factions of Cumberland, Leicester House, and the Pittites united and forced a reluc- tant Ministry to send British troops un- der Gen. Braddock, a protégé of Cum- berland’s, to the Ohio Valley. Mr. Riker is probably correct in his belief that Fox had no real colonial policy, but that his interest was due to his opposition to Newcastle and his desire to further “his patron's martial policy.” Fox's action was not without political result. “If the mutual discontent in the spring and summer of 1754 had paved the way for a Fox-Pitt alliance, the perfect agree-| ment of the two in a strenuous military policy was quite sufficient to consum- mate it.” The overt act’ of war added to the fears of the well-scared Duke of New- castle. He must seek a real alliance. Should it be Fox or Pitt? Owing to the dislike of the King for the latter, the former was preferred, and there began again a series of conferences, of which Mr. Riker gives us a complete record. These ended in Fox retaining his office of Secretary at War and being brought into the Cabinet council with “no sep- arate power or confidence outside the Ministers.” Although the position was similar to what he had so recently re- fused and did not place in his hands the corruption fund, still it was the result of negotiations which were conducted in a manner in every way honorable to Fox Mr. Riker, believing that Fax in thus leaving Pitt prepared for himself a wheel. He knew also the vigor and in- dependence of the man with whom he had been onnected Between these two he chose the former, and in that act lay the greatest political blunder in his career fearful of the result of thus entrusting | ' The victory seemed to rest with the | must be ruined. The resolution was faction of Cumberland, whose weight in | suicidal, in view of the increasing pow- the Cabinet was greatly increased by er of Leicester House and the closer the accession of Fox, and their war pol-| Union of that faction with the Pittites; icy became that of the Ministry; but the | yet the Duke of Newcastle persisted in two principal factions could not agree | his policy until in desperation Fox de- on the manner of conducting operations. | termined to pull down the Ministry in Cumberland preferred a sea-war; New-| his own ruin. His resignation accom- castle, favoring the King’s European Plished this. With that event ended possessions, promoted the policy of sub-| the long unlimited rule of the Whig ma- sidizing German princes. The issue was | chine. With the death of Fox's political critical and caused more intrigue, in| career—for what was left for him after which Leicester House played the title he had betrayed his former friends and role. The Cumberlands were enticed to| ruined his new allies?—there was shat- throw their weight against Newcastle, tered that dominance in politics which for his comflete upset seemed possible. | had lasted since 1714. In this moment of danger the Duke of| In the kaleidoscopic intrigues, follow- Newcastle and Henry Fox followed| ing the downfall of the Ministry, when courses that were natural to their char-/| the alliance of the Pittites and Leicester acters. After vainly wooing Pitt and| House was triumphant, Fox’s one pur- Leicester House, the Duke determined | pose was to insure for himself the rich to undermine the Cumberlands by more | office of paymaster. Wealth was his one completely winning Fox to his support.| hope; perhaps it had always been. The This was edsy of accomplishment, for|same forces which raised’ Pitt to that Fox was not a man to allow political | leadership which made him one of Eng- alliances to interfere with his own pro-/| land’s greatest ministers, placed Fox in motion. He entered, therefore, into the| that coveted and secure sinecure. The ranks of the Newcastleites and became political buccaneer had his hands on the Secretary of State, bringing with him | money bags. to his new alliance many of his former; Mr. Riker has,given us in his Life of friends. This addition to the Minister-| Fox a faithful chronicle of these few ials was the more necessary since the| years. The remaining chapters of his failure of the conduct of the war was/| Volumes rehearse in time-worn fashion evident from the defeat of Gen. Brad-| the history of the last years of George dock on the banks of the Ohio. |II and the opening years of his grand- Fox’s decision marks the crisis of his| son, but add nothing to our knowledge career. He had raised himself to a place|of the era. The style of the work is of authority by the annihilation of the monotonous and rather amateurish; but, Cumberland faction. Through great|on the whole, historians will find it of military success alone could he justify | the greatest value as a vade mecum his defection and maintain his position. through the chaos of political intrigue Unfortunately for him, his gifts of or-| which followed the death of Henry Pel- ganization were not such as could make | ham. him a great war Minister. There was; The last chapter of the biography is need of a higher morale than he pos-|an attempt to depict the man Henry sessed. In a time of peace his political| Fox. The author finds him a typical doctrine would have been effective, but |eighteenth-century politician, holding, he could not lead a nation intoxicated | like so many of his contemporaries, a with the spirit of war. His philosophy |cynical view of life. He might have was about this time thus cynically ex-| gone further and said he was the typi- pressed: “Pitt is a much bet-/|cal political manager of all time. His ter speaker than I am, but tickling the| methods and ideals are the same as palm, not the ear, is the business now, | those of his prototypes in Greece and and he that can do the first is the best; Rome, as well as those of a modern orator, let him speak ever so ill.” It|chief of Tammany Hall. Fox is like was by “tickling the palm” that Fox | these and, although the reviewer is not carried the Newcastle Ministry success-| ready with Mr. Riker to call him “the fully through the Parliament of 1755-56. | greatest political manager his country It was not the events of the war that| has ever known,” still Fox certainly were to break down the new coalition. | must be placed within the first rank. The Whig political machine was rush- ae ing to ite destruction under the leader-| ship of the Duke of Newcastle and CURRENT FICTION. Henry Fox. The suspicious nature and | Dorinda’s Birthday: A Cornish Idyll. By autocratic character of the former could| Charles Lee. New York: E. P. Dut- hie later loss of prestige, writes: not endure such a powerful rival as| ton & Co. Fox; and, from the moment that the Dorinda is only a pretty, shallow, Fox knew the innate rottenness of the latter entered upon his new office, New-/|nut-brown Cornish maid. But she has machine of which he submitted to become -astie and his friend, Lord Hardwicke,|a seventeenth birthday, and it falls on were determined to break the new Sec-| Midsummer Day, and that, for the folk retary of State. Fox must either learn|of Nanheviock Valley, was “St. Hender to be a subordinate in the camp of the| Feast Day, with sports and games in Newcastleites or else his political career ithe glebe-meadow and a bell-ringing con- en ee er

Page 19

PORK phe emer, April 4, 1912) The:Nation 339 test in the church tower.” To the feast goes Dorinda with her neighbors of Sunny Corner, a group of three cottages with a human population of nine. The short day’s many adventures constitute the book. At three Dorinda’s father calls to her to come downstairs from her prinking and be ready for the start. And all is ended wien they return and the two grandfather clocks have made up “their totalish old minds for half- past nine.” But what riches may not be packed into the story of six and a half hours wlien there are visiting and bell-ringing and feasting and quarrel- ling and snake-walking and flouting and courting to be done? Chief of all the riches is the deliciously Cornish tone of actors and play. One must not complain if in the necessity for filling two hun- dred and seventy-odd pages, the story sags at moments into disquisitions of a humorously amiable sort. Thus there is leisure for a little essay on simples as we walk through the garden of old Ann Coad, the “harby-woman”; for sen- timents on Cornish merrymakers, reflec- tions on story-telling, minute confidings in the reader on a score of topics, some breathing a suggestion of padding, oth- ers pure nourishment, as when we read that “it is a noteworthy, and to house- holders a suspicious, fact that the world is full of retired butchers.” When at dewy eve we return to Sunny Corner we have learned many things of Cornish customs and made several likable, eccen- tric, and unforgettable acquaintances. Chantemerle. By D. K. Broster and C. W. Taylor. New York: Brentano’s. O, Romance, Romance, how many long stories of the French Revolution have been perpetrated in thy name! In this in- stance we are at least spared Paris dur- ing the Terror—a mercy for which past experience impels us to render devout thanks. The scene shifts just in the nick of time: Louis-Adrien-Marie-Hy- acinthe de Chantemerle, Vicomte de Saint-Ermay, is indeed incarcerated in La Force, but provincial cousin Gilbert- Octavien-Felix-Anne de Chantemerle, Comte de ChAateau-Foix, is opportunely on hand to extricate him and conduct him home to Chateau Chantemerle. Lu- cienne d’Aucourt, having once seen the | mob in the Tuileries, is promptly dis- patched by her royal mistress to safe- ty in England. So that the hazards of country travel for ill-disguised aristo- crats. and the Royalist uprising in the Vendée furnish the historical frame- work. Private motives are provided by a conflict of affection and jealousy be- tween the two cousins, Gilbert being the betrothed and Louis the beloved of Lu- cienne. Of the sterling qualities of the sternly conscientious Gilbert and the darling charms of the exquisitely gal- lant Louis, space forbids us to tell. The interest of the tale by no means compensates for its length. Instead of ‘being torn with apprehension and sym-! pathy, one finds one’s self picking holes in the historical atmosphere—wonder- ing, for instance, whether country tav- erns provided toothpicks with repasts as early as the eighteenth century, and what the modern “tip” might have been in the parlance of Marie Antoinette’s court. The Man with the Black Feather. By yaston Leroux. Boston: Small, Maynard & Co. This is a shilling shocker from the hands of the man who wrote that excel- lent tale, “The Mystery of *the Yellow Room.” There is comparatively little mystery here, but sensation enough to satisfy the least fastidious taste. Many of our readers, for instance, have read in history of the amiable Renaissance practice of cutting off a man’s ears. But how many modern readers have actually seen the thing done? It is done in M. Leroux’s book, and with a wealth of de- tail that is quite fatal to one’s appetite for supper. The main idea of the story is simple enough. The soul of Car- touche, a brigand who attained notori- ety under the Regency in France, and a man of a hundred murders, finds rein- carnation in the body of M. Theophras- tus Longuet, retired manufacturer of rubber stamps, resident in the suburbs of Paris. M. Longuet, impelled by this metaphysical motive power within him, casts aside his green umbrella at regu- lar intervals to reproduce under modern conditions the career of eighteenth-cen- tury Cartouche. Now and then the thor- oughly consistent way in which the scheme is worked out produces its ef- fect. But the author was evidently hard put to it to spin out a volume of atroci- ties, and so pads out his story with a rather silly and tedious chapter of mes- meric wonder-working, a journey in the catacombs of Paris, and a bit of detec- tive ratiocination quite in the vein of ‘The Mystery of the Yellow Room,” INFLUENCE OF GREEK ROMANCE. The Greek Romances in Elizabethan Prose Fiction. THE Press; Lemcke & Buechner. $2 net. For his purposes, Mr. Wolff takes into account only the three best-known | ot the Greek romances—“The A@thio- pica,” or “Theagenes and Clariclea,” by 'Heliodorus; “Clitophon and Leucippe,” by Achilles Tatius, and “Daphnis and Chloe,” attributed to Longus. These are the sole members of the extant group which “are found to have ex- ercised any influence upon Elizabethan prose fiction.” In a preliminary chap- ter, the Alexandrian spirit out of which the romances grew is admirably set forth. Its fondness for a series of By Samuel Lee Wolff. | New York: The Columbia University | small, loosely connected pictures—which spelled the death of the epic: for or nateness, smartness of phrase, and elab- orate experiments in unrooted senti- ment; its reliance upon lawless For tune to serve as a main actuating force, are all marks of decadence which, when carried to extreme, as they were in the Greek romances, kept the reader suspended in an atmosphere far re- moved from real life. Delight in pretti ness, surprises, and ingenious articula- tion of details replaced the older love of form and of consistently human mo tives. Yet in spite of their artificiality, these stories greatly outlived their own day. In the Renaissance, the three above mentioned went through numer- cus editions in several languages, and before the close of the sixteenth cen tury were accessible in English, the first two in translations, the third in a para- phrase. Their total influence upon the Renais e.nce must have been enormous, though it is far too complex to reduce to a definite statement. For some of their traits were shared by other ancient lit erary types, and by these, too, were passed on to later epochs. So the spirit of Alexandrian lyrics, which, like the romances, made much of elaborate deco- ration and sentimental introspection, got into the blood of the Renaissance lyric and combined with, if it did not partially produce, Petrarchism. In turn, Petrarchism subtly insinuated itself into nearly every form, whether poetry or prose, which was then practiced. And, vice versa, it is not at all im- probable that certain poetic details or attitudes in the Greek romances fre- quently inspired similar features in the European lyric. To distinguish one of these two ancient influences in every case from the other would require om- niscience. Mr. Wolff wisely limits his investigation fo the English prose fic tion of Elizabeth's reign, and in gen- eral ascribes indebtedness only when it can be well-nigh demonstrated. By means of excellent summaries, which |}he manipulates skilfully, he concludes that Sidney and Greene borrowed free- ly from the earlier romances; Lodge slightly; and that the central idea and method of Lyly’s “Euphues” almost cer- tainly came ultimately from them. With this positive side of his argument, most readers will agree. But his certainty that “Nash makes no use whatever of the Greek romances” is not convincing, even though it cannot be definitely con- troverted. Nash's fondness for gorgeous scenes, such as that of the notable Ital- jan garden described in “Jack Wilton,” and his love of quickly shifting in- cident, might have been fostered by Heliodorus as well as by previous picareeque literature. This is a small point, however, and only goes to show that Mr. Wolff, if anything, understates bis case.

Page 20

340 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 The most significaht portion of the book has to do with the origins of the “Arcadia.” The writer demonstrates what any one familiar with Sidney's rare union of sensitive response to con- temporary tendencies and of ability to assert his own personality, might read- ily have suspected. More than any one else, he caught the spirit of the Greek romance, and almost domesticated it | in England. Incident after incident he takes over bodily from Heliodorus and Achilles Tatius; others he fash- ioned completely in their manner, and in every case worked his details as nicely as they into a big frame- work. The framework, especially, il- lustrates how unslavishly he borrowed. Whereas the Greeks made much use of Fortune, their equivalent for the will of the gods, Sidney almost emanci- pated himself from it, while appreciat- ing its artistic purpose To give a similar impression of a huge pre- siding motive, he turned to the Renais- sance conception, virta, which in his day, was held to be Fortune's antithesis. At one place, Cecropia explains: “to that passe had my husband's vertue (by my good helpe) within short time brought it with a plot we laide.” If worked out, virti® would, of course, have turned the “Arcadia” into a novel of character. But Sidney kept the em- phasis strongly upon incident, which from time to time we see is controlled by the other element, the virta, the valiancy of individuals. One's destiny is thus made largely dependent upon one’s inner nature, which in turn is projected This method did not re- move the opportunity, so beloved of the Greek romancers, for orymora of situation and phrasing. The surprises and contrasts with which the older Fortune confronted human beings could still be furnished by opposing the pre- liminary conditions surrounding a per- son to those foreshadowed by his abid- ing aspirations. A new light has been thrown upon Sidney's skill by Mr. Wolff's study of the old “Arcadia,” or first version, three manuscript coples of which Bertram Dobell discovered in 1907. To the old “Arcadia,” which is in five books, Sid- ney made many additions, some of them so complex as to amount to a large re- casting of material. He increased and expanded the princes’ adventures, “and he added in toto the episodes of Ar- galus and Parthenia, Amphialus and Helen, Phalautus and Artesia, Pamphi- lus and Dido, the Paphlagonica or Calatica, and Cecropla or the Captiv- ity.” Besides, he compounded one char-| acter.of two earlier ones. From the. Eclogues accompanying the old “Ar-) cadia,” he took the episodes and the pre- vious history of the princes, and Insert- | was not until he recast it that Sidney / light of Mr. Wolff's study. Most of the quite mastered the Greek’s methods. It| important literary types developed grad- is significant that in the révision not a| ually and took on accretions trom the thread was dropped. ages immediately preceding the Eliza- The influence of the ancient romances| bethan—the drama, the lyric, the po- upon Greene was far greater than upon | etical romance, though quickened by a Sidney, in the sense that he lacked the/ return to the classics, were yet instinct latter’s capacity to assimilate. This in-| with medieval and more modern ele- fluence, as Mr. Wolff observes: ments. But Elizabethan prose fiction— begins with mere transcripts from | °F at least its foremost representative— Achilles Tatius in “Arbosto” (1584), “Mor- | transplants the Alexandrian spirit modi- ando” (1587;? 1584), and “Carde of Fancie”| fied but little by the intervening cen- (1587; ? 1584)—a stage of immaturity and/| turies. superficiality, which, in the main, bor- ne rows non-structural ornament. “Philomela,” | which seems to fall in immediately after | The Philanthropic Work of Josephine this group, shows Greene taking less from Shaw Lowell. Containing a biographi- Achilles Tatius (only the trial at the end),! cal] sketch of her life, together with a and more from Heliodorus, chiefly by way) selection of her ‘public papers and pri- i ween ped — ere vate letters. Collected and arranged reaches its height in “Pandosto” (1588) for publication by William Rhineland- "| er Stewart, President of the New York which takes a little from Achilles Tatius, “ - but now gets structure as well as matter | State Board of Charities. New York: from the solid Heliodorus, together with) The Macmillan Co. $2 net. incident and ornament from the decorative Of good New England ancestry, with Longus. The influence degenerates at once | traditions of stern integrity and lofty in Pener~cqgadl (1589), which, though/ morality behind her, Josephine Shaw structurally based upon Heliodorus, is a) vas brought up from infancy in a Staten ane 6S em. Almost ce@8-/ 1 and suburb of New York. She was ing in the realistic pamphlets of Greene’s| ‘ last year, the influence flickers up | reared in an atmosphere of culture and : in “Groatsworth” (1592) in refinement. But she was also trained in the form of a suggestion from Achilles|@ school of patriots, stimulated to the Tatius. . }utmost by the struggles to set free the Mr. Wolff suggests that Greene’s fond-| siaves and to maintain the integrity of ness for feminine characters, which|the country. At the age of twenty she shows to advantage in his dramas, too, married Col. Charles Russell Lowell. He was largely inspired by Heliodorus.| Was killed October 18, 1864, just as he Finally, it should be noted of Greene | had been commissioned brigadier-gen- that, in good ancient fashion, he in-/ eral. stalled Fortune as the mistress of his| Stunned at first by the shock of her plots. Lodge's prose fiction, on the con-|husband’s death, it was some little time trary, is found to be “medieval, euphuis- before Mrs. Lowell began to interest tic, and Italianate, rather than Hellenis-| herself in charitable and public works. tic,” the influence of the Greek romances | Then she joined the Freedmen’s Associ- upon him amounting to a little more | ation, especially interesting herself in than occasional allusions to them. \the establishment of schools for the If Elizabethan prose fiction had led | colored people in the South. In 1872 the to the founding of the modern English | State Charity Aid Association of the novel, the importance of Mr. Wolff's Richmond County Committee was book could scarcely be overestimated. | formed, of which Mrs. Lowell shortly Unfortunately, the “Arcadia” is the only became a member. Near her home, at Elizabethan prose romance which seems Castleton, S. I., was the Richmond Coun- to have had any effect upon eighteenth | ty Poor House, with which she made and nineteenth century writers: in a herself familiar by frequent visits. As a few instances, Richardson and Scott kept | result of her observations there, it was it vaguely in mind. For the rest, the|decided, on her motion, to conduct an type became virtually a closed book short- inquiry into poor-law conditions in gen- ly after the end of the sixteenth century. eral, the place chosen for special inves- Mr. Wolff's investigation clears up, nev- tigation being the county of Westches- ertheless, one significant matter. To ter. The burden of this investigation students of this period, the atmosphere fell upon Mrs. Lowell. Her report was of even so well-executed a romance as | presented at the fourth annual meeting Sidney's has appeared to be strangely|of the State Charities Aid Association, remote from the spirit of the times.| in 1876, and, as a result of this report, For hand in hand with the Elizabethan’s Gov. Tilden, who had been present at riot of imagination, there was usually the meeting, appointed her to a vacant a certain balancing sense of fact. The seat on the State Board of Charities. extreme sensuousness of the “Faérie With her assumption of this official posi- Queene” is saved from nonsense by its tion begins her larger work, to which rational purpose, and the bombast of Mr. Stewart has devoted more than four- ed them in the body of the new work, | “Tamburlaine” does not quite conceal fifths of this volume. etc., etc. The original version was | the play’s central idea. The reason | One is amazed at the record of work drawn largely from Hellodorus, but it) for this difference becomes clear in the accomplished. First, the long struggle >. Fe ta ae ae ee

Page 21

~ om eh PERT April 4, 1912] The Nation 341 tc reform the conditions of public insti- tutions throughout the State, and partic- uiarly those dealing with women, result- ing in the establishment of State re- formatories for women at Hudson, Al- bion, and Bedford, and of the State Cus- todial Asylum for Feeble-Minded Wo- men, This, in Mr. Stewart's judgment, was her most useful achievement; her successful “labors to rescue the erring and feeble-minded of her sex.” As an outcome of her investigations of the sys- tem of administering temporary or out- of-doors relief in several counties of the, State she was led to feel the necessity ot the organization of charitable as-, sistance: hence the Charity Organiza- tion Society, out of which again grew the Penny Provident Fund and the lodg- ing house and woodyard, which latter ultimately led to the municipal lodging houses. But Mrs. Lowell’s activities were not confined to what is commonly called charitable work. In 1889, after thirteen years’ service on the State Board, she refused reappointment for reasons which she thus explains in a letter to a protest- ing friend: Five hundred thousand wage-earners in this city—75,000 of those working under ‘dreadful conditions or for starvation wages. That is more vital, than the 25,000 de- pendents, counting the children. . .. It is better to save them before they go under than to spend your life fishing them out when they’re half-drowned and taking care of them afterwards. From this time on, while she contin- ued her interest in all charitable and beneficent work, her essential concern was with industrial, social, and politi- cal affairs, and her papers on those sub- jects contained in this volume are really her best. One practical result of Mrs. Lowell’s interest in industrial problems was the Consumers’ League. She believed in the codperation of women in govern-| mental affairs. Practically this belief tound expression in the organization of the Woman's Municipal League. She be- lieved that the participation of women in the government of the city would have an educational influence upon wo- men themselves. But she also believed that women would contribute a positive element, of great importance in govern- mental matters, because possessing a more sensitive moral instinct than men as a class possess. But she did not believe in any woman undertaking public or charitable work until every home duty had been discharged, and, while organizing and systematizing charity, she was at heart opposed to in-| stitutionalism, maintaining that even a poor home was preferable to a good in- stitution. The book does not seem to admit us | | down with the impression of having learned about Mrs. Lowell rather than of having met Mrs. Lowell herself. A friend said of her family life: “I had never before been with people who talked over the affairs of city and State exactly as they would those of their own family.” Is this the reason of that im- pression of impersonality which one re- ceives from this volume? The Tailed Head-Hunters of Nigeria. By Major A. J. N. Tremearne. Philadel- phia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $3.50 net. Alone in West Africa. By Mary Gaunt. New York: Chas. Scribner’s Sons. $3.75 net. These two books have this in common that they are both written by Austral- ians, who have learned to know, at least in part, the same African tribes, and that both writers are plucky, re- sourceful travellers. Mrs. Gaunt’s is, however, the more interesting book, not only because the author is a woman who, skirting the Gold Coast, penetrat- ing into Ashanti, and going up the Volta River, braved hardships and dangers to which few of her sex are equal, but be- cause she writes directly and to the point, whereas Major Tremearne is often prolix. Partly, perhaps, because of his greater learning, he conveys relatively less information about his own doings. He is not, first and foremost, a travel- ler, like Mrs. Gaunt, for he was much concerned, while an administrative offi- cer in northern Nigeria, about writing two theses for the University of Cam- bridge, on anthropology and the study of the Hausa language. So he frequent- ly lugs in too much scholarly lore, on extraneous subjects, as in his chapters on customs and superstitions, and court- ship and marriage. Still, he conveys much valuable anthropological informa- tion. The tone of his book is less sensa- tional than might be inferred from the the title. The tailed head-hunters are wo men, who, after their marriage, adorn themselves with a mushroom-like ap- pendage made of a palm fibre. The men, though cannibalism is not yet entirely extinct among them, are usually quite amenable to the police measures of the British and yield to their “peaceful pen- etration,” which, confessedly, usually ends in fighting. Punitive expeditions (sometimes undertaken because of a failure to pay the annual tribute of a few paltry pennies per head) are, how- ever, a much more serious matter, and the administration of justice where crime is concerned is swift and rigor- ous. Major Tremearne, who served as a police officer, as well as in a judicial |}and political capacity, had absolute pow- er over life and death. On one occa- into the inner circle of Mrs. Lowell's! sion he was, reluctantly, compelled to life. It shows why she was called the| execute the death sentence he himself “City’s Saint”; but one lays the book had pronounced. Mrs. Gaunt, on the whole, judges the natives more favorably, though she, too, believes whipping to be the only correc tive for the negro’s incurable stubborn ness. She has a dismal story to tell of the condition of Liberia. Monrovia she describes ag “an outrageously ill-kept town.” Throughout the book she con trasts German and British administra- tive methods to the disadvantage of the latter, and she pays, in particular, a glowing tribute to the German physi cians in charge of the sleeping-sickness camps. She is, however, by no means blind to the brutality that sometimes goes with the success of the Germans in colonizing West Africa. Mrs. Gaunt's knowledge of natural history is not con- siderable, as her allusions to the native flora show. The forest trees north of the capital of Ashanti dwarf, in her opinion, “all other trees in the world They are, of course, far inferior in size to the giant trees of the Sierra Nevada Notes _—_—_ Gustav Pollak, who is preparing a biog raphy of Michael Heilprin and his son: will be glad to receive any letters by tl late Prof. Angelo Heilprin. They may be sent to Mr, Pollak at No. 21 West Eighty fifth Street, New York, and will bh. ly returned to the senders pro ' >. “Among the Carpathians,” by Lion Phill more, is an account ef gipsy-like travel through hitherto undescribed country Holt will publish it the middle of this month Prefaced by Bonar Law and introduced by Sir Edward Carson, a book, entitled “Against Home Rule” is about to be issued by Warne & Co. of London In the issue of March 21 we announced the “Railway Economics,” promised by the University of Chicago Press, as a “colle: tors’ catalogue It should be a “collective catalogue.” The American Library Association has just issued in its March Bulletin a detailed list of the important gifts and bequests to American libraries during 1911 The total cash donations amount to $3,364,822.49 which is nearly a million and a half dol lars more than was given in 1910. Of this amount Andrew Carnegie gave $2,326,370 more than double the amount donated by him to libraries in the previous year. One hundred and thirty-six towns and cities in the United States and twenty-eight in Can ada were recipients of his generosity. The majority of these towns are in the Middls West and the South, and in the province of Ontario, although nearly every State in the Union is represented in the list. Other gifts than money include 65,575 volumes, six sites for library buildings, and seven buildings presented for library purposes One of the notable gifts of the year was a very remarkable collection of books, manu- scripts, photographs, and other amounting to 33,407 items and relating to the native races of North America, Hawaii, and the Philippines, which was made to the Newberry Library of Chicago by Fdward E. Ayer of that city. matter

Page 22

34.2 ,Lthe Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 It is always a pleasure to acknowledge | Michigan Historical Studies published un- | Upon the teachings of Christianity a cyni- the receipt of new volumes of the beauti- fully printed Scriptorum Classicorum Bib- liotheca Oxoniensis. The latest additions to the series are a fascicle of Plato, contain- ing the “Euthydemus,” “Protagoras,” “Gor- gias,”’ and “Meno,” and “Isidori Etymo- logi#,” in two volumes. “Peeps at Many Lands: Oceania” (Mac- millan), by Frank Fox, is scarcely origi- nal or striking, though net without value. From varied sources, as also from per- sonal experience, the author draws a pic- der the direction of the department of his- /cal philosophy supervenes, which derives all tory. It presents a chronological analysis human activities from self-interest; though of the President's Cabinet from Washing-| reason must still restrain, it is recognized ton to Taft, dealing especially with the per- that without self-love to urge we should sonnel, characteristics, and methods of each | “never get anywhere”; self plucks up heart, President’s official advisers. The develop- and flushes with pleasure when Pope writes, ment of the Cabinet as an arm of the na-/jn 1733, “self-love forsook the path it first tional executive is traced, together with pursu’d, and found the private in the pub- the varying powers and duties of the Cabi-|jjc good.” After the cynical rationalists, net members. Of particular value is the /come Rousseau and Goethe and the optimis- full discussion of the reasons and influ-/|tic French Revolution; self emerges from ences which have determined Presidents iD | contempt and bondage, rosy and smiling; their selections. Nowhere else have 80/jn fmerson’s “Representative Men’—the ture of British colonial life which ought | Many facts been gathered to throw a light essay on Goethe—appears (1847) the first to be flattering to national self-esteem. An on the always interesting process of Cabi- | recorded example of self-culture; in 1837, Australian himself, he is most enthusiastic net-making. There is an introductory | for the first time in this sense, self-perfec- about New Zealand, “the empire’s pattern chapter on the Origin of the Cabinet, and tion enters in a significant sentence of Har- dominion.” Mr. “ox is neither a geographer nor a scientist, and his account of the Maoris and the official life of New Zealand is such as any well-informed journalist can furnish at short notice. Some repetitions concerning the fauna of the regions he has visited betoken haste in the preparation of his matter Inordinately heavy paper has swelled the rather meagre contents of the volume to the regulation thickness. As is so often the case with the tri-color process, the Illustrations somehow fail to impress one with a sense of reality. The plain half- tones commonly used are far more char- acteristic and convincing. East and west from Sebdon to Medenine and south into the desert at Ghardaia and fougurt went Mrs. Emma Burbank Ayer in her “Motor Flight through Algeria and Tunisia” (McClurg), and her book is a very kindly,«gossipy, and intelligent record of it all If there is much of the small beer of travel, it is all informing, and the de- tails go to make definite pictures, assisted greatly by above a hundred and twenty ex- cellent little photographs. Of course, the life is the outside life seen by the tourist, except when Mrs. Ayer’s curio and orna- ment hunting led into more intimate byways. There is a good index, and the book with its readableness will be useful in the coun- try itself Many things of more than mere local in- terest are to be found in Volume VIII of the Bostonian Society Publications. The diffi- culties which had to be overcome before the Church of England could have a permanent home in the Puritan town are described by the late Rev. H. W. Foote. The opposition to the theatre lasted much longer, for in an account of the first 6ne established, W. T. W. Ball, the writer, quotes from a vigor- ous public protest made by Gov. Hancock before the Legislature in 1792 against theat- rical exhibitions. They had just been intro- duced under the name of “Moral Lec- tures.” One of the early announcements says that there “will be performed the much admired comedy written by Shake- apeare called ‘The School for Scandal.’ ” Dr F. H. Brown gives some noteworthy facts in regard to the practice of medicine in New England in the seventeenth century. Among the receipts is one for the treatment of a “Cancer Humor,” in which three frogs are a principal ingredient, or “Wee may att sartin times apply a Tode cutt In two to the wound 2 or 3 times a week.” A useful volume for historical reference is Mary L. Hinedale’s “History of the President's Cabinet” in the Wniversity of there are three general chapters “in con- | riet Martineau’s—“In the days when mutual clusion on the Principles of Cabinet-Mak- and self-perfection will be the prevalent mer The Cabinet and Congress, and The ja.q which the civilization of the time will Cabinet ay ey ag The — express.” A curious corresponding shift mates on t pny ry! —— ally | takes place in the sense of the word self- enti ei gore . robes respect. The first meaning given is, “a democratic y, Walch it attained car | private, personal, or selfish end”—an obso- in our history, and that “just because it | , ms lete sense illustrated by this from Bishop has undergone a democratizing” it has been ome, . tome . Hall, 1613: “Subject to all passions, in- able «to fulfil with satisfaction to the coun- - | firmities, self-respects. The second mean- try the conception of the framers of the Constitution that it should prevent the Pm, GO AFUR apesete, Me Uai-deve, 0 self-conceit,” illustrated by this from President fr ting hastil inadvis- 9 ‘ihe yeni tat Pre wine ~ a a Hawke, 1657: “Most men are transported forming any blind or unsuspected func- la bs apy Aly a pnp The ay tions,” concludes Miss Hinsdale. “Neither ogg ry y . wi i py one has it been the seat of any great transfor- me were 16 im te excursion” © ords- worth, where at last it means “a proper mation in the nature of the Government. It at h ' ? is not a mainspring or a pivot; but it has | * ate or the d gnity of one’s person or one’s position.” shown jtself to be an essential attachment. It is so adjusted that the American execu- The Oxford editors present as usual a table tive is plural in deliberation while it _is' showing how far they have surpassed their single in responsibility.” The volume 1i8/ predecessors in the number of words and provided with a full bibliography, instruc- | quotations. One point appears constantly tive foot notes and references, and a good | in these comparisons which is perhaps worth working index. In addition to its value as|remarking. Other dictionaries they surpass a work of reference, the book is noteworthy not merely in the number, but also in the because it is the first serious contribution proportion of quotations to the number of to the study of the growth and develop- | words illustrated. Johnson alone keeps pace ment of this important branch of the Amer-/| with them in the proportion; he even some- ican Federal Government. times, as in the present section, surpasses them. Thus they illustrate 2,463 words with 9,004 quotations; he illustrates 98 words with 386 quotations. In analyzing the senses Oxford English Dictionary, SEE-SENA- and displaying the history of any given TORY, edited by Dr. Henry Bradley) word, Dr. Bradley of course commands vast- (Frowde). The unusual prominence of the ly greater resources. Turning, for instance, native element is chiefly due to the presence |to the article on self in Johnson's folio of a half-dozen monosyllables which have edition of 1755, we find that he disposes of developed a wide variety of senses, or have| Dr. Bradley's sixteen-page theme in two been fertile in compounds. The compounds | pages. And yet, for all that, a “moral” man of self, for example, dating from about like Mr. Pecksniff would doubtless find 1550, occupy sixteen pages; yet we are something to say in favor of the Great informed that “only a small selection has Bear’s handling of this topic. A moralist |been given from the innumerable obvious / at the same time that he was a lexicograph- combinations found in the collected quota-|er, Johnson had probably given more tions.” Self, as Mr. Pecksniff would have | thought to the real significance of self than said, is a “moral” theme—let us improve|any or all the Oxford compilers. In con- our minds by mutual inquiry and discus-| sequence of that ever-present personality sion—let us contemplate self! With a litthe| which emerges in the celebrated definitions pains the compounds of this word could be | of oats and pensioner, his article has a so arranged as to mark like milestones the | continuous “human interest,” and can be moral pilgrimage of man. A large share of read through by a layman with pleasure and the earlier forms are employed by men to/ edification. In these two pages on self he whom self appears as a power to be hum- | exhibits about one hundred quotations bled, thwarted, destroyed: in 1657 Baker com- drawn from about thirty-five authors, nearly |mends “service to God, performed with ajall of excellent standing. Hig illustrations, |perfect seelf-abnegation”; in 1647 Harvey furthermore, are not inconsequential snip- |praises “self-condemning shamefastnesse” ;| pets from the middle or ends of sentences, | in 1683 Tryon tells us that the way to health but complete pointed thoughts, mainly con- cannot be followed “without self-denial”; in ducive to virtue, and often obviously related |1647 More describes the valley of Ain in cpl os the editor's convictions—one feels here as “Song of the Soul” as “self-nothingnessc.” | one feels in the presence of Bishop Wilson's Words of Old English origin occupy about half the space in the single section of the! .

Page 23

i : 4 3 be ntti lea Pra cs om

<5 sh at eM ta iin Ratiintnn + a NO aaa sa at,

April 4, 1912] “Sacra Privata.” Here are no less than seveh pious passages from the sermons of South, an author whom he recommended to Boswell as an antidote to loose thinking Here are four from Watts, of whom Johnson remarked on one occasion, “I shall do what I can for Dr. Watts.” This, for example, might have been transcribed from Johnson's private diary: “The religion of Jesus, with all its self-denials, virtues, and devotions, is very practicable.” Dr. Bradley cites un- der self-preservation this from Milton: “If the punishment Thou canst avoid, self-pres- ervation bids.” In that truncated form the precept seems dubiously related to virtue By quoting three words more, Johnson, al- ways concerned for conduct, brings down with one stone both the lexicographical and the moral birds: Repent the sin; but if the punishment Thou canst avoid, self-preservation bids By this trait Johnson seems to be distin- guished from most modern philologers; he never looked for words without at the same time looking for ideas. It is a pretty ques- tion what relation the labor of compiling a dictionary in this fashion bore to the so- lidity of his prose style and the sententious gravity of his daily speech. The presses continue to pour out books on Holland, which, as the great majority of them are written by tourists, are naturally much alike. Invariably are mentioned: the black-and-white cows; the horrible sound of ‘g's’ and “sch’s,” together with the American's and German’s way of pronounc- ing “‘Scheveningen”; the number of petti- coats worn by the women of Volendam; the spic-and-spanness of Broek, reputed to be the cleanest town in the world; the nobil- ity of Leyden in preferring a university to exemption from taxes; the cheeses of Alk- maar and Edam; the smoking capacity of Dutch infants, and the oldest bits of “Dort.” All this, we must confess, re- mains charming, even when described by unskilled writers. Blair Jaekel’s book, “Windmills and Wooden Shoes,” just pub- . lished by McBride, Nast & Co., goes over the usual ground, and is written in what often passes as a “snappy” style; its hu- mor, however, is much too elaborat« Winthrop Packard’s “Literary Pilgrim- ages of a Naturalist” (Small, Maynard) is -bounded, geographically, by Marshfield, the Isles of Shoals, and Provincetown, and chronologically, by William Bradford and Thomas Bailey Aldrich—a rather extensive range, one would think, for an octavo vol- ume of two hundred pages printed in large type with liberal margins. Even so, we hear nothing of Whitman’s beloved “Pauma- nok” and his Camden country, nor of the haunts of Cooper, nor of Lanier’s South- ern marshes, since to a true New England- er, literary or other pilgrimages are hard- ly conceivable outside of New England. On the other hand, one is puzzled to know what bearing the last two chapters (Vermont Ma- ple Sugar, Nature’s Memorial Day) have on American literature. A good deal of the book is either fragmentary or diffuse, jour- nalistic in a bad sense. Too often the sen- tences do not stand on one leg even, but. as some one has said of Debussy’s tech- nique, with both feet in the air. This journalistic looseness, though it is more noticeable here than in Mr. Packard’s ear- lier nature essays, is, however, offset by the spirit of the writer, a highly agree- The Nation able compound of sentiment, ingenuity, and masculinity that makes itself felt on almost every page. It is too much to: say that Mr. Packard writes well: but it is not too much to say that he is as delightful a companion as one could want in making pilgrimages to “straunge strondes”; and if he tells you that it is essential to plunge with him into Walden Pond before sun- rise, you will plunge, and issue as refresh- ed as you were on first reading “Walden.” The following, the close of the chapter on Whittier’s birthplace, is in Mr. Pack- ard’s least journalistic vein: They lighted a fire for me in Whittier’s fireplace—and as the rose glow on the walls of the old living-room brought back the hearth-cheer of bygone years, as the witch- es, daintily making tea without under the lilac bush, brought the romance and legend of the olden time to the threshold, so the erackling draft of the fire up the deep throat of the chimney seemed to draw in to the place the free, hearty, farming wood-loving life of the man of the earlier centuries out of which the poet drew what was best in him, to be given out in unfor- gettable verse to us all. If such a place was ever lonely it was that gentle and de- sirable loneliness which great souls love. — “The Life of Dr. D. K. Pearsons,” the Chi- cxgo benefactor of small colleges, has been written by Edward F, Williams (The Pilgrim Press). Dr. Pearsons was born in Vermont, procured a meagre-medical edu- cation at an institution in Woodstock, Vt., long since extinct, practiced medicine in Chicopee, Mass., at the age of forty came to Chicago with $5,000, and in thirty years in real estate business attained a fortune of at least $5,000,000. Retiring at seventy, he set about to distribute his capital. He made a few gifts to Chicago hospitals, missionary societies, and theological semi- naries, but by far the largest number of his benefactions have been to small col- leres. The most active period of his ben- evolence was contemporary with the rise and expansion of the State universities, and hic encouragement and example have had much to do with the continued influence of tre smaller institutions. As it is now seen that there is a field for the small college Dr. Pearsons’s influence in American edu- eetion has been of real value He ‘did more than any one else to bring the conditional gift into vogue, as it was his usual custom tu offer a gift, usually $50,000 three times the sum could be obtained from provided others, This manner of benevolence has been much criticised, but undoubtedly it has enabled many institutions to bcth their resources and their friends-and nereast to develop a permanent constituency and ecnfidence in their own strength That it has been adopted frequently by Mr. Carne- gie, and that the General Education Board follows the plan cons'stently in all its benefactions to colleges, is high approval of Dr. Pearsons’s judgment his life is a human document of much in- terest, William Albert Finch in Cornell University, died in Brooklyn on Sunday, after an illness of several months. He was born in 1855, graduated from Cor- nell in 1880, and after practicing law for some years, was admitted to the Cor- nell facu'ty in 1891. He edited several works in his subject, among them “Finch’s Selected Cases on the Law of Property in Land.” The story of professor of law We notice with regret the death of E. W -

343 B. Nicholson, who had been Bod.eys libra rian for thirty years. With untiring zeal he had exerted all the powers of his strong character to make the library more widely useful, and before he died had intr a system of shelf-classification and a su! ject catalogue, and had created an add tional reading-room. His personal assist ance to American scholars, as to ot has often been acknowledged in p: The death is reported from Ber Christian Gottfried Albert Traeger ber of the Reichstag from Oldenburg, and known as the “Father of the Hou he was born in 1830. As a writer | sr membered chiefly for his “Gedichte a vol ume of poems which has passed through twenty editions He wrote several plays and some of his novels had a consideral From 1865 to 1883 he issued a vear book, called “Deutsch: Lied.” He a‘so tion into German of Burns's poems vogue. Kunst in Bild und Ollaborated in a trat The death is reported from Linde Westphalia, in his sixty-fifth year, of t) miner poet Heinrich Kampchen. He worked in the mines from the age of sixteen, and his poems deal for the most part with that life, showing, it is said, considerable fee} ing and penetration. Geheimrat Dr. Gustav Wendt, who is dead at Karlsruhe, aged sixty-five, was director ot the gymnasium of that town from 1867 to 1907, and was a distinguished teacher’ of the classics ‘Gymnasium und 6ffentliche Meinung,” “Didaktik und Method deutschen Unterrichts und der philosoph ischen Propideutik,” and translations of Sophocles’s tragedies are among his work Karl May, whose death in his seventieth year is reported from Dresden, Germa was a well-known writer of Indian tal and romances for boys He many stories from the Arabian lurk Persian, and Chinese Science Researches on the Evolution of the Stet lar Systems Vol. Il The Theory of Cosmical Evolution. By T. J. J. See. Lynn, Mass.: T. P & Sons, Dr. See, who has been for many years professor of mathematics in the United States navy and in charge of the Maré Island time ago brought out a volume of re Observatory, California some searches on stellar systems, in which he first directed attention to important and previously unrecognized features of binary stars. This gave him an estab lished name among his fellow-investigat ors. Quite recently he has published a second volume, finely printed and lavish. ly illustrated. It is a prodigious piece of work, but in large part and highly technical, and in that re spect is quite unfit for extended notice here. Broadly speaking, Dr. See's work is devoted to the amplest exemplifica mathematical ition of what he has called the capture |theory of the cosmogony, and every- thing connected therewith: a theory to

Page 24

344 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 replace every vestige of the Laplacian nebular hypothesis by one which postu- lates the gradual formation of stars, suns, planets, and satellites by capture of the materials composing them from a resisting medium that in the early history of the universe filled all space. Dr. See states his claims with the broad inclusiveness of a blanket policy, though with scarce a trace of that gentleness and humility which in every age have been thought to characterize the truly great. Apparently, his ambition is to force everybody to admit that everybody else, Anaxagoras of Clazomenz and Laplace to Lord Kelvin and Sir George Darwin of Cambridge, has been hopelessly deluded about this cosmogony business, and that the persplendid light of the cosmos has shone first, of all men, on the present author. It is amusing to note the differing reception of this work: astronomers not too seriously offended by the author’s braggadocio find it “food for thought”; others a monumental work of great im- portance; still others lay it aside to await the final judgment of Darwin, Poincaré, and other masters in the same field; while a literary gentleman never having heard the name of See before and examining his book for the first time must be excused for his harsh judg- ment that it seemed to transcend the border line between genius and—not genius. Dr. Moulton of the University of Chicago, whose “Celestial Mechanics,” published eight years previously, See seems to have Tlattered by imitating, not to say transferring bodily without ac- knowledgment, some important pas- sages, goes so far as to dub the capture Dr. See the “cap- See's specula- not end with the cosmogony proper, but are amplified include pretty much all the moot points in pres- ent-day astronomy, such as the secular acceleration of the moon's mean mo- tion; the rotation of Venus which he “proves” must be, not slow as the trend make it, but from theory presented by tured theory.” Dr. tions do to of current research would than the earth's; a comprehen- of the sun's constitution; a discussion of planets ulterior to Nep- tune of which Dr. See says there are many; and his origin of comets, which after all turn out to be “nothing but sur- viving wisps of nebulosity from the out- er shell of the ancient nebula which formed our system.” It is a dangerous theory that pretends to explain everything, and Dr. “*Seo’s hypothesis of cosmic evolution comes perilously near that limit. Should his| theories be finally accepted and adopted, they will truly form that salient epoch | in the history of the cosmogony which | he audaciously assigns them. Sir George Darwin, who received Dr. See's work at the conclusion of his article on the| tides in the eleventh edition of the En-| cyclopedia Britannica, states in a note | sawifter sive theory lthat he “does not feel convinced by the arguments adduced.” F. W. Headley’s book, “The Flight of Birds,” shortly to be published by Witherby & Co. of London, contains some interest- ing advice to the aviator. An institute for research in chemistry, physics, and mineralogy has been founded by the Academy of Sciences in St. Peters- burg. It is called the Lomonossov Insti- tute after Michael Lomonossov, sian naturalist of nearly two centuries ago. Sir J. J. Thomson has been appointed to the Order of Merit, due to his distinguished work at the Cavendish Laboratory at Cam- bridge, Eng. Drama Edward Everett Hale, jr., has brought out a sixth edition, enlarged and revised, of his “Dramatists of To-day” (Holt). Ros- tand, Hauptmann, Sudermann, Pinero, Shaw, Phillips, and Maeterlinck are the subjects of his discussion, which he describes mod- estly as informal and which might also be called impressionistic. The essays make very pleasant reading. They are written in fluent, unaffected, but never slovenly style; reflect broad and sympathetic intelligence as well as wide information, and, if they are not particularly original or incisive, are at least free from narrow dogmatism. To the amateur student of the theatre they will bring both pleasure and profit, al- though they sometimes presume a greater familiarity with the original text than the ordinary reader is likely to possess. The best papers, perhaps, are those on Rostand and Maeterlinck. In both the relation be- tween the dramatic works and the peculiar genius and philosophy of the authors is plausibly and ingeniously set forth. But Mr. Hale, like many other modern critics, is sometimes inclined to seek for mysteries where none exists. In “Cyrano de Berge- rac,” for instance, the most poignant moral, surely, is that which lies most clearly on the surface, the cruelty and the folly of judging by appearances. A hero, well en- dowed with all the manly virtues, is ecorn- ed by the exquisite woman whom he loves ideally, because he has not, like his empty rival, a pretty face. There could scarcely be a better theme for satirical and tragic romance Elsewhere Professor Hale discourses, soundly enough, on the futility of probing for the inner meanings of the symbolism in Hauptmann’s “The Sunken Bell,” but he might have expressed the con- clusions to which his arguments tend with greater boldness. The simple truth is that, on the stage, a symbolism which ts so vague as to excite doubts as to its real signifi- cance is absolutely worthless, for the rea- son that it leaves the road open to the im- agination, which is then at liberty to in- terpret it at will, possibly in a manner entirely subversive of the proposed alle- gory. Drama can be judged only by its face value. In an appreciative and generally judicious discussion of Sudermann Mr. Hale advances several conjectures in ex- planation of that author's failure to main- tain or Increase the reputation he enjoyed too deeply ! ten or fifteen years ago, but overlooks the possibility that his earlier achievements may have been somewhat over-estimated and that he is only a sufferer from the re- action which is apt to follow after extrava- gant enthusiasm. Many modern dramatic critics have little or no sense of propor- | tion. In his analysis of the work of Ber- |nard Shaw Mr. Hale, while duly recognizing the brilliant faculties of that dazzling hu- the Rus- | morist, fails to emphasize the reckless in- }accuracies, gross if not wilful misrepre- | sentations, and palpable insincerities which |are as conspicuous ingredients of it as are | its keenness of observation, its spectacular |but ill-digested erudition, and its barbed |satire. As for his observations on recent miscarriages of the poetic drama—in con- nection with a highly laudatory review of the literary work of Stephen Phillips—it may be pointed out that the principal rea- sons why poets do not succeed upon the stage to-day are two. One is that they do not know how to combine human and dra- matic interest with literary charm, and the other, that there are no longer any actors capable of giving an adequate interpreta- tion of poetry or romance. The Poetry Society of London recently gave a performance of the “Hippolytus” lef Euripides, using the rhymed English |translation of Prof. Gilbert Murray. The representation took place on the steps of the Marble Hall of the University of Lon- don; very few accessories were used, and the whole was of the simplest possible character. All efforts were concentrated on dignity, simplicity, and as close an adher- ence as possible to the Greek spirit. Sir Herbert Tree now announces his long- promised production of “Othello,” at His Majesty’s Theatre, in London, for the 10th of April. He lays stress upon the fact that, for historical reasons, he has«selected the year 1480 as the period of the action. The presumption is, therefore, that the splen- dors of the scenery are to be supported by certificates of their archmological accuracy. It is not likely that the minds of the or- dinarily intelligent playgoer will be great- ly excited by this information. He will not care much about the particular year in which the Turks were drowned and the Moor’s confidence so shamefully abused. He will be more concerned about the inter- pretation of one of the greatest tragic mas- ‘ terpieces in the world. Accuracy of scenic detail has its value, of course, up to a cer- tain point. Scenery must at least be de- cently appropriate to the incidents of which it is the background, but in the case of Shakespeare, a too minute insistence upon it has its dangers. It may, for instance, emphasize the anachronisms and inaccur- acies in which the poet himself indulged so freely. It was Charles Kean, a second-rate actor, but astute manager, who, under the pretence of scholarship and Shakespearean devotion, first tried the experiment of of- fering glittering spectacle as a substitute, or a screen, for inferior acting. He set a most mischievous example. But he exhib- ited a proper reverence for the text, and never dared to tamper with it, as Sir Her- bert has habitually done. H. B. Irving is expected in London at the end of May. He closed his New Zea'and season at Christchurch with a performance of “The Bells,” which caused great enthusi- asm. From there he went to Sydney for

Page 25

I ea ee ee ee a a Bi ri April 4, 1912] The Nation a farewell engagement. He will make his reappearance in London in the summer or the early autumn. His success at the An- tipodes has been very great. There is none in sight, apparently, to dispute his leader- ship ef the English-speaking stage, and his rapid progress makes it likely that he may equal—or even excel—the renown of bis father. Edward O'Connor Terry, who died in London on Tuesday at the age of sixty- eight, though never a great actor, was a performer of much versatile skill. After twenty years of apprenticeship in minor Shakespearean and other parts, he opened, in 1887, Terry’s Theatre, winning favor in both “The Churchwarden” and “The Woman Hater,” but it was in Pinero’s “Sweet Lav- ender” that he made his fame and fortune. Marie Desclauzas, who was long a con- spicuous figure in the theatrical life of Paris, is dead at Nougent-sur-Marne. She was born at Paris in 1840. Her first ap- pearance was made at Reims, but she soon returned to Paris, and divided her long career among the various theatres of the! capital, except for the time she spent in Russia, where she was very popular. One of her earlier successes was in “Héloise et Abélard,” and another in “La Prise de Pékin.” She won favor in America in the operettas of Offenbach and Lecocq. In Brussels she created Mile. Lange in “La Fille de Madame Angot.” Afterward in Paris she was successful in “Le Petit Duc,” “Sapho,” “L’Abbé Constantin,” “Musotte,” and in “Mam’zelle Piou-piou,” at the Porte St. Martin. In later life she was at the Gymnase., Music Siz Lectures on the Recorder and Other Flutes in Relation to Literature. By Christopher Welch. New York: Henry Frowde. $3 net. Not long ago, the bagpipe, in spite of its .greatly decreased vogue, was hon- ored by being made the subject of a monograph. Now we have a volume of 457 pages on the flute, an instrument which, though still used a good deal in orchestras, does not play a role in our general musical life one-tenth as impor- tant as it did half-a-century ago, and which does not now seem particularly to interest either professionals or ama- teurs. Mr. Welch confesses, in the preface, that he has made no attempt to render his pages attractive “by imparting to them the graces of style, or pleasant by excluding from them what is dry, dull, and heavy.” They abound, he warns us, “in notes, digressions, cross-references, and descriptions often tedious and some- times irrelevant.” But, lo! when the’ reader, after abandoning all hope, en-| ters these premises and has scanned a) dozen or two pages, he finds himself | more and more interested, and ends by | perusing everything, including the foot- | notes, which, as in a German profes-| sor’s textbook, often take up more than | half of a page. Mr. Welch's book, to say it at once, is infinitely more than a mere monograph on the flute; it is the work of an astoundingly erudite schol- ar (an Oxford M.A.), who incidentally throws perhaps more light on various aspects of musical life in Old England than any other writer has done. There are doubtless hundreds of flute players who, seeing merely the back of this volume, marked “Six Lectures on the Recorder,” would never suspect that it was a book brimful of interest for them. Not only has the recorder been out of use since the end of the eigh- teenth century, but the dictionaries do not make very clear just what kind of instrument it was. The most satis- factory definition is that given in the new Encyclopedia Britannica, which describes it as “a mediwval flute blown by means of a whistle mouthpiece and held vertically in front of the perform- er like a clarinet. The recorder only survives in the now almost obsolete flageolet and in the so-called penny- whistle.” In works of reference in gen- eral, and in the notes of editors of old English authors, so much confusion pre- vails as regards this matter that Mr. Welch was moved to write a whole chap- ter of 127 pages entitled Literary Errors | on the Subject. That so many errors were made, and that even such men as Sir John Hawkins, Dr. Burney, William Chappell, and Carl Engel could perpe- trate them, was due largely to the con- fused nomenclature. The word recorder seems to be of English origin; Mr. Welch's researches lead him to believe that it was in use in the fourteenth cen- tury, but did not come into existence until after the Norman conquest. In/! Chaucer's time it was called a flute, and in the eighteenth century even such au- thorities as Hawkins and Burney did not know that “the flute’ with which they were so familiar had once been known as the recorder. It was early in the sixteenth century that the recorder was at the zenith of its popularity. It had been a fashion- able instrument ever since the days of Chaucer. One of the daily tasks of Henry VIII was practicing on it, and he was the possessor of a collection of in- struments of the flute family such as the world has never seen. They were 154 in number, and 76 were recorders. Many were of ivory, some had silver or even gold tips. In the seventeenth cen- tury there were whole bands of record- er players, up to thirty or more. The instruments were built in various sizes from the lowest bass to the highest treble. But the time came when the recorder fell from favor, and this was due not so much to the fact that the Puritans made war on it (as they did. on the organ, that “squeaking abomina- tion”), but to the competition of the German flute, which was better suited for combinations in mixed bands, and 345 which made it possible by the action of the lips to vary the tone. While conceding these advantages of the flute, Mr. Welch greatly regrets the disappearance of the recorder. It had a “rich, soft, cooing” tone, which made it most agreeable to the ear. Samuel Pepys declared it to be the most pleas ing of all sounds in the world, and that Pepys was a good judge of music has been attested by Dr. Hueffer Many were moved to tears by it (see the very interesting footnotes on pp. 136-7) Mr Welch indulges in fascinating specula tions as to the use of the recorder in old English plays to produce the il- lusion of an angelic choir. He describes the means used by Wagner in his “Lohengrin” prelude to represent the “chaste rejoicing’ of an “angelic host” by the tremulous notes of the violin blended with those of the flute and oboe, and inclines to the opinion that a band of recorders would have been even more serviceable for the effect de- sired. It does not seem at all unlikely that Richard Strauss or some other mas- ter in search of novel colors may take Mr. Welch's hint and revive the record- er. Unlike other obsolete instruments, it is easy to play. Handel, whose ear for instrumental coloring was as keen as Wagner's or Berlioz’s, made much use of the record- er, and the author shows by numerous examples how Handel deemed it more appropriate for certain passages than the flute. Shakespeare honored the re- corder and the flute as he did no other instrument. To a_ chapter’ entitled Flutes and Pipes in Shakespeare, Mr. Welch devotes 70 pages, and this is pre- ceded by one on Hamlet and the Re- corder, which hereafter no manager who stages that play can afford to ignore The author’s thesis is that Shake speare’s design has never yet been real- ized on the stage, and his reasoning is as convincing as it is elaborate. To Mil- ton’s allusions to instruments of th« flute family another long chapter is de- voted, and this is followed by two more, in one of which the marvels related of the old Greek flute players are recalled, while the last is concerned with the tomb pipers and the connection of music with mourning. This section is illus- trated with numerous examples of wail ing tunes among the Irish. Apart from these, there are above a hundred illus trations, many of them full-page fac- similes, which help to make this one of the most fascinating and suggestive books ever published on the art of music, its history, sociology, and psy- chology. The score of Richard Strauss’s new opera “Ariadne auf Naxos,” is not to be printed in Berlin, but in Paris, becaus: the copy right there extends for fifty years after the death of the composer, which is twenty years longer than in Germany.

Page 26

The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2440 346 The correspondence of Weber, whose 1it-| erary works are almost as interesting as his music, is to be printed by Breitkopf & Hirtel. The coming across the Atlantic of the London Symphony Orchestra to give a se- ries of concerts in this country and Canada, under Arthur Nikisch, gives occasion to call to ome great advantage which (and American) orchestral play- have over their German colleagues, that their higher pay enables them better instruments—a matter of| as it affects the euphony)| of the orchestra's tone. attention English ers namely to great importance, buy Art SIR JOSHUA D'OUTRE-TOMBE. Sir Joshua Reynolds is not precisely a leading influence in modern art crit- icism, yet his catholicity and supreme good sense have caused something of a revival of interest in “The Discourses.” There must, then, be a considerable pub- lic that will welcome the appearance of an unpublished paper of Reynolds's on “The Adaptation of Talents,” in a recent number of the Mercure de France. M. L. Dimier, who translates a manuscript preserved in the Fitzwilliam Museum, Cambridge, naturally presents his “find” in his own tongue. And it is one of the oddities of modern international schol- arship that an English-speaking critic must perforce offer his extracts from this interesting work of Sir Joshua in a retranslation from the French. Sir Joshua discusses with his custom- ary clarity the conditions under which artistic genius can flourish, and arrives the conclusion that an enlightened and aristocratic Mecenasship is the nec. essary basis. It should be observed at once that this view is borne out by the of art history, though sharply countered by much recent criticism. It is a subaxiom of Socialism that art shrinks and cheapens under capitalistic patronage. Tolstoy would have abolished all art which did not appeal to God-fear- ing fraternalistic peasants. And many who are neither Socialists nor Tolstoy- ans firmly believe that the social basis of modern art is far too narrow. On all these matters the testimony of Sir Joshua, old-fashioned as it may seem, is not without interest. He departs from axioms uncongenial to the modern temper: at whole The wants of man increase in society. His necessities remain the same, and moral which are equally part of his nature, | are added. A division of labor, which es- | tablishes itself in society, provides for the | of his physical and rational life Education and society have set great ait. | ferences between the man of science and | the man who works with his hands, though | nature perhaps has not; on its own side, | nature has made distmetions which educa-| This inequality of apti- | needs diverse requirements tion cannot efface. | denial, tude perfects the social system by turnish- | ing for the various tasks which convenience | and refinement impose a corresponding variety of capacities. | Here is the doctrine in its naked Tory-. ism. Yet it is not only true, but one of) those truths that outwear all evasion, | and sophistication. Even to the most perfervid equajitarian, life now | and then brings home with stunning and demonstrative force the truth that! inequality of human capacity is not a semblance or a temporary and curable disease but an eternal fact—a fact, as| complacent Sir Joshua would hasten to add, upon which a perfect social system | must rest. Sir Joshua, in establishing a distinc- tion between artists and business men of all degrees, again drives home a truth, tremendously exaggerated during the Romantic period, and now, under humanitarian sentimentalism, corre-| spondingly obscured. The merchant's service is valued by every one. From the state he needs only protection from oppression. The artist’s service is un- derstood and valued by the few, and to those he must look for support. The rewards of commerce and of art are pro- portioned to this fact. “The proper re-| ward of industry is wealth and secur-| ity; the proper reward of genius is) fame and independence.” Yet the inter- ests of the two careers are one. Any failure to provide for the exercise of the | multiform capacities of men means in unemployment and all manner of inner and outer misery an embarrassment to the whole social body. Since the artist provides for remoter desires and ministers to needs feebly felt by the majority or not at all, he cannot hope for support from the peo- ple. If he obtain it, it will only be at the cost of debasing his art. To the question how the dignity necessary to the artist may be procured, Sir Joshua replies squarely: By a Mecenasship exercised from above | and in a liberal spirit. Only the great and the cultivated are in a position to give dig- nity and importance to art. They must) begin. Their example will teach the mid- | die classes of society to take a just es- timate of that which the elegant and en- lightened classes prize so highly. “Rankest snobbery!” we hear some one protest. Not at all; merely a frank statement of historical fact in phrases, somewhat old-fashioned. Sir Joshua's simple remedy may at least have a diag: | nostic value. Much of the trouble with | modern art has been precisely the fact that great patrons were unenlightened and correspondingly narrow or capri- cious in their taste. Modern society re- verses the process imagined by Sir Joshua. Instead of a cultivated aristoc- racy extending the benefit of its taste to the middle classes, through most of the nineteenth century and still, we | Meecenasship |tarian speculations on the topic. have had the spectacle of a small body of enthusiastic but quite uninfluential amateurs of the middie class keeping alive the generous traditions of taste and patronage in the face of the ignor- ance of capitalistic Mecenases and their quasi-esthetic parasites. If this be the disease, the specific is neither more nor less than the educating and refining of our wealthy classes—a difficult but not an impossible emprise. Already the imagined by Sir Joshua ‘exists in germ. What is still wanted is that courage and independence of taste in high quarters which are not infre- quent amid humbler art patrons. There is a kind of conspiracy to prevent such /education. The natural vanity of wealth and power and the interests of purveyors ‘combine to narrow the sympathy, and, of course, to limit the knowledge. The ‘fingers of two hands would be enough 'to count the very wealthy Americans who in any branch of art patronage real- ly deserve the proud title of Amateurs. It may be asked, Where do the people come in? They come in at precisely the most important point. It has usual- ly been and it normally is the function ‘of the people to produce the artist of 'genius. Tory Sir Joshua wishes to give ‘him opportunity when he appears, to offer him dignity and independence, in- stead of the hap of eating out his heart in some uncongenial mechanic job. In this sense Sir Joshua would not quarrel with the modern formula that art needs “a broader social basis.” The way to get this broader basis may well be as he suggests: the presence of a special- ized and highly trained class of art patrons. On the whole, even in the hu- manitarian balance, his Toryism com- pares very favorably with most equali- His view has at least the merit of taking into account the facts of artistic produc- tion and of society, as they have been and still are. “An Architect’s Sketch Book,” by Robert S. Peabody, which is in Houghton Mifflin’s list, has to do with England, France, and Italy. Estella is publishing, through Canziani | Dana Estes & Co., “Costumes, Traditions, |and Songs of Savoy,” with 50 full-page il- | lustrations in color. “Famous London Houses,” by A, St. John Adcock, and “English Secular Embroidery,” by M. Jourdain, are announced by Dutton. Heinrich Jantsch, of Delitzsch, near Leip- zig, Germany, announces a second Oriental expedition, for the purpose of photograph- ing manuscripts and papyri. He will visit Egypt, Sinai, Jerusalem, the isles of Pat- mos, Lesbos, Chalki, and Constantinople. Arrangements may be made with him for special commissions by directing to De- litzsch until May 20. The dance in various periods of the past will bé iliustrated at an exhibition to be held this spring at the Bagatelle, Paris, by the Société Nationale des Beaux Arts. For some time Mr. Sotiriadis, the ephor

Page 27

ees. ee te Re ee OO ene April 4, 1912] The Nation 347 of antiquities, has been carrying on exten- sive excavations in the neighborhood of Mount Parnassus, near the site of the ancient city of Elatea. His efforts have now been rewarded by the discovery, upon a ris- ing piece of ground, of an entire prehistoric village. The character of the objects un- earthed shows that this site was inhabited from very early times. In the lowest stra- tum were found finely polished implements of stone together with various articles of bronze, indicating that the period repre- sented was a transition stage from the Age of Stone to that of Bronze. The bronze arti- cles bear a strong resemblance to those of the Early Minoan period in Crete. In the next stratum the deposits belonged ex- clusively to the Bronze Age. In this period the place had been occupied by stone build- ings, and among the remains of these were found numerous fragments of vases, which had been decorated with a coating of black color on which were painted geometrical designs in white. The uppermost stratum contained objects synchronous with the late Minoan period of Crete. The work of Mrs, Elizabeth Stanhope Forbes, who died recently at Newlyn, Corn- wall, has been somewhat overshadowed by that of her husband, the Academician. She was born in Ottawa, Canada, in 1859, and for many years exhibited paintings at the London Academy and the Paris Salon. A collection of half-tone cuts after good, bad, and indifferent pictures; a commeatary making overtly for righteousness and be- sprinkled with literary citations, such is Henry E. Jackson’s “Great Pictures as Moral Teachers” (Philadelphia: The John C. Winston Co.). The book is unquestion- ably edifying, but not to an art lover. Finance THE NEXT TURN IN EVENTS. When the Stock Exchange ended last week and began the present week with another burst of rising prices—in the face not only of the beginning of the anthracite coal strike on Monday, but also of a fall in New York bank reserves on Saturday below the legal minimum— the financial position became interest- | ing. The “million-share day” of Mon- day of last week, with the manifestly enormous realizing sales of that and the three- succeeding days, seemed on its face to mark the end of the Stock Ex- change rise. The subsequent discovery that the banks were “overloaned” added to that probability. It showed how rap- idly an active stock market uses up available stores of capital; for when the recent advance began, in February, the bank position was the strongest ever re- ported at that date, except for 1908, in fifteen years, whereas last Saturday’s | deficit in reserves was the first which has occurred at the end of March since 1883. This led to a somewhat general feel- ing that the more rash and excitable speculative faction was now responsible for the latest movement of the market. | and it has certainly done so on this occa-| what we are presently to see in the gen It was admitted that, towards last lic’ had taken a hand in speculation. Sometimes the outside element, at such times, takes the bit in its teeth, snatches the market violently away at the mo- ment the large manipulators think the bull movement ended, and forces prices materially higher. It certainly did so af- ter the Taft election in November, 1908, when even Harriman, who had started the preélection rise, warned his friends that “the situation is dangerous” and that “a halt should be called.” On the other hand, there were voices raised on Wall Street this past week (as there were, indeed, in November, 1908), to re- ply that a further rise was warranted. A strike of hard-coal miners was no doubt beginning, but it would not con- tinue long, and meantime the threatened soft-coal strike had been averted. There was admittedly a deficit in our bank reserves; but the same banks had at least $150,000,000 loans outstanding on Continental Europe’s markets, and could convert them into cash resources when- ever necessary. Two well-known and important finan- ciers, towards the close of the present week, expressed as follows their person- al views of the situation. One said that the recent stock market movement had been well-founded, and that the funda- mentals in the financial and industrial position were sound, but that the rise of stocks, in its later stages, had been en- tirely overdone, and would have to be fcllowed by a severe decline. The other took the ground that the March advance in prices was only preliminary, that a steadily improving condition of finan- cial and industrial affairs was at hand, and that whether incidental reaction oc- curred now or not, the rise would be re- sumed and would continue well into the coming months. r As between these two opinions, ob- servant readers will no doubt be able to make their own judicious choice. But most people, in Wall Street at any rate, would probably agree that the truth as regards the underlying situation stands somewhere between the two. This con- sensus of opinion—in which, it is now quite manifest, the majority of outside business men agree—is interesting be- cause of its contrast with the opinions current not very long ago. It is less than five months since we were assured, from high financial quarters, that the black- est industrial storm in sixteen years was just ahead of us. Stocks could not rise in the face of the Trust prosecu- tions, business could not revive in the face of a Presidential election, and neither could look forward to anything but deepening depression until some change of heart swept over the whole community. The course of events financial often seems to play pranks with the prophets, | ’ —a —————_— sion. The change of heart was not week's close, the so-called “outside pub | forthcoming; but announcement of the Steel suit, which was to be the signal for chaos in the financial and business world, was promptly followed by a 15- point rise in stocks and a sudden revis al in the steel trade. Next, into the a! ready sufficiently confused political sit- uation was injected Mr. Roosevelt's rad- ical campaign, into the unsettled finan- cial situation the gathering clouds in Germany, and into the troubled business situation the English coal] strike, the declaration of war by the American min- ers, and the threats of the locomotive engineers; whereupon a four-weeks’ rise in prices on the Stock Exchange en sues, with such predictions on top of it as those already quoted. Such a seque! justifies repetition of the question, what then is actually before us” Some things, to begin with, are al- ready evident which the Stock Exchange instinctively foresaw when they. were visible neither to the gloomy financial prophets of November and December, nor to the general public. One is, that an attempt to tie up a nation’s industry by a general strike will inevitably break down, through the reaction of its effects upon its authors. Sweden learned this in 1909; England has learned it as plain ly, this past month, and American work- men will probably not care to invite a similar lesson of their own. Another discovery of the financial markets is : that the American people are not in any such wild and extravagant political ’ frame of mind as despondent observers had pictured. Between the political extremists o crusted bigotry and of shallow empir- icism there has always been, as Ma- caulay pointed out, “a great mass which has not steadfastly adhered to either, which has sometimes remained inertly neutral, and which has sometimes oscil lated to and fro,” and whenever that part of the electorate has leaned in eith- er direction, its weight has been irre- sistible. We frequently have to re-learn the truth that, in our own country pri- marily, it is this body of cautious citi- zenship which makes majorities, which in doing so does not hesitate to admin- ister stern rebuke to a one-time political favorite when he presumes on the pub- lic’s favor, and which is quite as ready to repudiate the extravagant agitator as to turn its back on the moss-grown con- servative. Usually the lesson is taught us in November of an election year; sometimes considerably earlier, and in either case we understand why the Stock Exchange habitually looks forward with calmness to a Presidential vote } How far the markets of the present month represent merely reaction from such previous declines as may have been caused by the action of financiers whose views of these matters were mistaken, and how far they were the foretaste of ’

Page 28

348 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2440 movement of prosperity, are open questions. Ordinarily, a really notewor- thy rise on the Stock Exchange will be followed, after a longer or shorter in- terval, by signs of similar industrial im- provement. But that in turn will be regulated, so far as regards its continu- ance, by other influences not yet measur- able, and meantime the stock market, when it has performed its task of imme- diate prophecy, must wait until it can foresee these new influences. We are close to the season of prelim- uncertainties. We have drawn very heavily on our available bank resources, even in advance of a nor- mal demand from general business. We have yet to determine just what is the trouble with Europe's continental mar- kets, and what they will do if require- ments in America were to bring back our European loans. We have not yet settled clearly the problem of profits in relation to working costs, and the labor disputes now pending do not make the any simpler. eral inary crop question BOOKS OF THE WEEK, Austin, Alfred Love Poems. Lane. 60 cents net Bigandet, P. The Life or Legends of Gau- dama, the Buddha of the Burmese. 2 vols. Dutton. $7 net Begbie, Harold ble Edited by clety The Children’s Story Bi- H. Thompson. Grolier So- Grant Allen’s Historical Guides Fach separately, nts sold nO net itself and $1 form with enlarge & A. M. Cruickshank complete in te pocket size re-appearing In a new tw im revisions by J. W ind others Smaller Tuscan Towns New volume, illustrated Umbrian Towns New edition, revised and Illustrate Venice. Classical Rome. Florence New etition Christian Rome New edition, revised and |} Henry Holt & Co. wi rners Feventh Edition revised and Illustrated lustrated THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION Vol. IV. Saratoga and Hrandy- wine, Valley Forge, Eagliand and France at War. GPORGE OTTO Vew Edition Pp. xil+492 by mat, $2.18 SIR oOnM S¥o i the Rian? Tlon TREVELYAN Bart witt » Mar Crown Ite! cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net cheaper edition of ‘‘The Amert- Part It, and ts uniform and 3, already tseued at oume This le a n Revolutl with V 2° lumen 1, 2 “i net. each ¥ Longmans, Green, & Co., Publishers THE DRAMA A Quarterly Review of Dramatic Literature | Send soa five Conta for Sagpple Copy or Three Doers for a Year's Subscription ,, THE DRAMATIC PUBLISHING CO. 542 South Dearborn Street, CHICAGO | | rles i revision of manuecripts, 225 Fifth Avenue, Letters. $3 net. Phila. : Borrow, George. Darlow. Doran. Cady, Jay. The Stake. Co. $1.25 net. Camp, Walter. Auction Bridge Don'ts. Platt & Peck Co. 50 cents net. Channon, E. M. The Real Doubleday, Page. Chesterton, G. K. net. Cubberley, E. P. The Improvement of Ru- ral Schools. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. 35 cents. Cullum, Ridgwell. Phila.: Jacobs & Dorrington, Albert Doubleday, Page Doughty, K. F. The Suffolk, 1480-1905. Dowden, Edward Study of His Mind and Art. net. Edwardes, Tickner. Neighborhood: Year’s Life in an English Village. ton. $2 net. Fowler, J. S., Our Wea- Jacobs & Mrs. Holyer. Manalive. Lane. $1.30 The One-Way Trail. Co. $1.25 net. The Radium Terrors. $1.20. Betts of Wortham in Lane. $5 net. Shakespeare: A Critical Dutton. $1.50 A and Marriott, W. ther. Dutton. 35 cents net. Frankland, F. W. Problems. Fifth edition, don: Nutt. Jarrett, A. E. The Advance of Photography. Dutton. $4 net. Harper, M. W. The Training and Breaking of Horses. Macmillan. $1.75 net. Harris, Corra. The Recording Angel. bleday, Page. $1.25. Home University Library. Nos. 30 to 38 incl. Holt. 50 cents each. Hosford, H. E. Woodrow Wilson, and New Jersey Made Over. Putnam. $1. Houston, T. W. Mey Wing: A Romance of Cathay. Topeka, Kan.: Crane & Co. $1. Hwui Li. The Life of Hiuen-Tsiang. New edition. Introduced by 8S. Beal. Dutton. $3.50 net. Hyamson, A. M. upon the Spanish Main. the “Voyages” of Richard Hakluyt. ton. $1.50 net. revised. Lon- Elizabethan Adventures Adapted from Dut- ! Edited by T. H. Dut- | | Oldham, Thoughts on Ultimate Dou- Johnson, Owen. Stover at Yale. Stokes. $1.35 net. Jourdain, M. The History of English Sec- ular Embroidery. Dutton. $3.50 net. Just, Adolf. Return to Nature. Translated by H. A. Nesbitt. Dutton. $2.50 net. Keen, W. W. The Cheerfulness of Death. Philadelphia: Griffith & Rowland. 15 cents net. Kellogg, V. L. Beyond War, Holt. $1 net. Kennard, H. P. The Russian Year Book for 1912. Macmillan. $5 net. Knibbs, H. H. Lost Farm Camp. Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. La Farge, John. One Hundred Master- pieces of Painting. Doubleday, Page. McCarthy, Charles. The Wisconsin Idea. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Macaulay, R. Views and Vagabondage. Holt. $1.35 net. Mackay, C. D. Patriotic Plays and Pageants for Young People. Miles, Eustace. Prevention and Cure. Dut- ton. $1.50 net. Okey, Thomas. The Story of Avignon. Dut- ton. $1.75 net. J. B. The Renaissance. 35 cents net. Palmer, H. R. List of English Editions and Translations of Greek and Latin Classics. Printed Before 1641. London: Biblio- graphical Society. Pratt, E. A. A History of Inland Trans- port and Communication in England. Dut- ton. $2 net. Sadler, C. G. The Pendulum: A Novel. Bos- ton: Sherman, French. $1.25 net. Savage, W. G. Milk and the Public Health. Macmillan. $3.25 net. Seton, E. T. The Forester’s Manual. bleday, Page. $1 net. Straus,. Ralph. The Prison Without a Wall. Holt. Tompkins, J. W. Pleasures and Palaces. Doubleday, Page. $1.20. Tuckett, I. L. The Evidence for the Super- natural. Dutton. $3 net. Van Eden, Frederick. Happy Humanity. Doubleday, Page. $1.25 net. Boston: Dutton. Dou- THE DRUNKARD By GUY THORNE Author of “‘When it Was Dark.’”’ A powerful novel written by a man of the world for men and wo- men of the world. To the general reader it is a strong story of deep human appeal. To those to whom drunkenness is a painful personal and social problem, it is the sympa- thetic revelation of the physical and mental state of the drunkard, which makes help for him possible. Probably the most startling and impressive story in any language concerned with the psychology of intemperance. In “When it Was Dark” the author proved his power of holding spell-bound a vast com- pany of readers. (Cloth, 12mo, $1.35 net; postpaid, $1.47.) STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 East 27th Street, New York LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- Ancient and modern languages, Translation, | ete, MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM. 06 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. I am ready to buy autograph letters or documents of celebrities of any time or any nation, in or small euce nd me a list of what you have, WALTER R. BENJAMIN, New York. r What Is Judaism? A Survey of Jewish Life, Thought, and Achievement By ABRAMS. ISAACS, Ph D. Professor of Semitics, New York University Cr. 8vo. 218 pages. $1.25 net; by mall, $1.35 The volume throws light on the history, literature, services, and present status of the Jew. A clear, intelligent, frank, and fair account of their ideals and accomplishments. NEW YORK LONDON NINETEENTH CENTURY ENGLISH CERAMIC ART By J. F. BLAGKER Over 1,200 illustrations, 534 pages. $3.50 net. . A practical guide for collectors of old English pottery and china, combined with a history in pictures of the work of the old English master potters. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston LOUISE BE. DEW LITERARY Y REPRESENTATIVE. want ‘or booklet “FROM THE ED Die s vik POINT.” 156 Fifth Ave., N. ¥. A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. catalogue of second hand Americana, now ready, and will be sent to any address. A new

Page 29

~