The Nation 1912-03-28: Vol 94 Iss 2439

Page 1

VOL. XCIV.—NO. 2439 AMONG THE NOTEWORTHY SPRING BOOKS FHURSDAY, MARCH 28, 19T. Reg. US. PRICE 10 CENTS. Three Wonderlands of the American West Being the Notes of a Traveler concerning the Yellowstone Park, the Yosemite National Park, and the Grand Canyon of the Colorado River, with a chapter on other wonders of the great American West Written by Thomas D. Murphy “The author has caught the atmosphere of the ‘Wonderlands’ and has the rare gift of reader see with his eyes; te produce pen pictures second only being able to make the to the marvelous illustrations themselves,” writes Mr. Charles L. Bowman, President of the Union Library Association. With 16 reproductions in full color from paintings by Thomas Moran and 32 duogravure plates In a bor, net $3.00 (carriage 30c. extra). Chile and Her People of Today By Nevin O. Winter Author of “Argentina and Her People of Today,” et A new volume in the SERIES OF THE LATIN-AMERI- CAN REPUBLICS. “A comprehensive narrative covering every phase of life and history which one would wish to know about this country.”—Boston Herald. Profusely illustrated, in a bozr, $3.00. The Art of the Berlin Calleries By David C. Preyer Author of “The Art of the Metropolitan Museum,” etc A new volume in the ART GALLERIES OF EUROPE SERIES, devoted to the art treasures of the Kaiser Friedrich Museum and the Royal National Gallery. It is one of the most entertaining of this author’s productions and is literally a description of the works of the old masters, since it contains few biographical incidents With 48 full page duogravure plates, in a box, net $2.00 (carriage 20c. extra). Two New Novels The Dominant Chord By Edward Kimball “An absorbingly original story, with a forceful theory cleverly developed. It will impress itself upon the public as a book of lasting conse- Naomi of the Island By Lucy Thurston Abbott “One of those singularly appealing and exquisite stories. It strikes the human interest note in a most effective way quence.” Each with frontispiece in full color, net $1.25 (carriage 1l5c. extra). New Revised editions, brought up to date, of Forbes Lindsay’s authoritutive volume | Nevin O. Winter’s account of Panama and the Canal Today Mexico and Her People of Today Each, in the SERIES OF THE LATIN-AMERICAN REPUBLICS, fully illustrated, in a box, $3.00. Special editions of Grant Allen's five popular works on the principal cities of the Old World PARIS FLORENCE CITIES OF VENICE BELGIUM: ITS CITIES NORTHERN ITALY Previously published in two-volume sets. Now issued each one volume, with sizty-five full page plates, in a boz, net $1.75 (carriage 20c. extra). Ready Early in April Caroline Atwater Mason’s new volume in the popular Spell Series The Spell of France A companion volume to the successful THE SPELL OF ITALY, by the same writer, published three ago, and now selling in its sixth edition, and to Burton E. Stevenson's delightful THE SPELL OF HOLLAND, published last fall. Illustrated from rare old prints and photographs and with frontispiece in full color. In a box, net $2.50 (carriage 20c. extra). years 53 Beacon St Boston, Mass. Published by eo C. PACE & COMPANY

Page 2

The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. the New York City Poat second-class mati matter.) at Ofice as | for bulletin The Nation 1a published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Editor; Harold deWolf Fuller, As- President Elmer More, sistant Editor Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in @ny part of the United States or Mesico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4.00 Address THE NATION, Bow 794, Publication Office 20 Vesey Street. New York. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WEEK EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The English Crisis *“Syndicalism” Protecting the Immigrants The Extinct Angel Child Teaching the Farmers to Play Through the Outlooking Glass SPECIAL ARTICLES: Are the English Critical?—II News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE: Mr. Roosevelt and the Public Schools and the The Nervous Debility of Sashok and Sashka .. The High School Teacher of English.. Recall Recall Japanese seoves 312} 313 Art 313 313 | 313 LITERATURE: The Life Newman Odd Numbers The Great Gay Road The Way of an Fag George the Third and Charles Fox Modern Riding and Horse Education Cardinal 314 315 316 316 316 317 of John Henry Histo ation ind Post ondon WEEK * * * Coples of The Nation may be procured ino Paris Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brewn, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross : at in. ¥., _The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2439 Ed ucational HE FISK TEACHERS’ —————. Everett O. Fisk & Co., 25 Park Street, Boston 1845 U &t., eeyeoktont ashington 156 FifthAve.,NewYork 610 Swetland Bd. ,Portiand 814 Steger Bd., Chicago 343 DouglasBd.,LosAn les 920 Sav. Bk.Bd.,.Denver 345 Wright Blk., Berkeley. Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, Prop. Vincent B. Fisk THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Knows how Twenty-one years of successful = perience in bringing together good teachers and good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. 20 and see for yourself. HE UNITED HOSPITAL TRAIN- ING SCHOOL FOR NURSES, Port Chester, offers a three years’ general training to young women Applicants should be at least nine- teen years of age. Qualifications, one year high school or the equivalent. Remuneration, $10 month- ly Apply to SUPERINTENDENT OF UNITED HOSPITAL, Port Chester, N. Y. Institute Athenaeum - Munich 26 HERZOG RUDOLFSTRASSE 26 class boarding school for boys. Individual training. Outdoor Entrance any time. Day sports. First scholars Bracing climate. Briarcliff Manor, New York ‘MRS. DOW’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS For circular address MRS. MARY E. DOW, Prin. Published March 21, 1912. Illustrationsof Design Based on Notes of Line as used by the Craftsmen of India. LOCKWOOD DE FOREST 82.00 A carefully selected set of plates reproducing the exquisite work done by the craftsmen of India among whom the author has studied for thirty-five years. The method of working from notes of line, as used by the Indian craftsmen, is clearly developed. By beginning thus with the simplest problems the book *becomes valuable for the youngest pupil as well as for the skillful workman. Issued in portfolio form in the Biflex Binder; Illustrations of Design is of great convenience in the classroom as it allows the different plates to be re- moved for individual use. GINN AND COMPANY, 29 Beacon St. , Boston By BOOK S—All out-of-print books supplied. matter on what subject; write me, stating books wanted: I can get you any book ever published: when tn England, call and inspect my stock of 50.000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, John Bright St., Birmingham, England. THE JOURNAL OF POLITICAL ECONOMY Published by the University of Chicago In Co-operation With The Western Economic Society Important Articles in Recent Numbers. JANUARY, 1912 The Relation of the National Reserve Asso- ciation to the Treasury..A. Piatt Andrew The Specie Reserve in a Banking Sys- David Kinley Points in Opposition to the Aldrich E. D. Hulbert A Review of the Proposed National Re- serve Bank .-Andrew Jay Frame The Aldrich Pian: A Possible Monetary Gerrymander Alexander Wall American Railway Relief Funds: I. Hospital Departments Not Using the Release Con- . H. Allport Some FEBRUARY, 1912 | American Railway Relief Funds: II. Release ' | Contracts and Mutual Reltef. W. H. Allport A National Reserve Association and the Movement of Cotton in the South. J. Laurence Laughlin | Seminar Methods of Economic Instruction: A Symposium. MARCH, 1912 | The Socialist Party in the November Elec- Robert F. Hoxie Grain Legislation Affecting Western Canada D. A. MacGibbon | Setemattonat Arbitration and International Finance Alexander D. Noyes |The Butter M. Lippitt Larkin | Published Monthly, except in Au- gust and September. Subscription | price, $3.00 a year; single copies 35 | cents; foreign postage, 42 cents. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO, ILLINOIS Socialism is a force to be reckoned with. The INTERNATIONAL SOCIALIST RE- VIEW, monthly, $1.00 a year, is indispensable to the student who would understand rer ed Socialism. Three months, 25c. HARLES H KERR & CO., 118 W. Kinzie St., Chicago. THE Spring Announcement Number The Nation WILL BE PUBLISHED APRIL 11 number of copies will Besides its regular circulation, a large clubs and literary people. be mailed to libraries,

Page 3

March 28, 1912] The Nation MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY’S SPRING PUBLICATIONS THE AMERICAN MEDITERRANEAN. 3) Seepnes A. Boxsa ' llustrated., .. 1.6. A comprehensive study of the various islands of the West Indies The book deals with t history, foreign occupation, and their relation to the United States. (Heady May ist SURGERY AND SOCIETY: A Tribute to Listerism. 1) CW. Saccray, M.D. F.R.S.E,, 8vo A realization of the many vital public needs which until public opinion is acquainted with the facts of Lord Liste: Saleeby to undertake the fulfilment of this important work. THE SCHOOL IN THE HOME. ;;, TALKS WITH PARENTS AND TEACHERS ON INTENSIVE ¢ cational elements in this book are so blended as to mak: treme simplicity of the whole contention which hardly less surprise than the result re involved in Lister \poLtr A, Bert s attained. BIG BUSINESS AND GOVERNMENT. by) Cisnirs Nowwax Pa This book treats of the problems of Big Business and the Trusts from the “insider” and later of the opponent—a point of view of the problem whi sented before in book form in so complete and thorough and practical a 12m Wal LETTERS AND MEMORIES OF HARRIET HOSMER. Qdited by Mes. | 8vo. Illustrated A delightful volume about this famous American sculptor, in including many letter and Elizabeth Barrett Browning, William Wetmore Story and many other [-nglish and Amer can celebrities. MORE LETTERS TO MY SOW. by Wisirxen James, author eee } “The charm of the writer's rare personality, the pathos o ; ; r ignorance, the caressing quality of her voice, enlist our sympathy in knowing her as intimately as her communicatiy pet mits.”—The Atheneum. THE CANDLE AND THE FLAME. By GEORGE SYLVESTER VIERECI “The Candle and the Flame” will arouse again the interest of two continents, for is regarded as America’s first authentic voice in poetry since Whitman and Por insurgent who to the artistry of P of passion. oe and the social conscience of Whitman add NEW FICTION. THE SENTENCE OF SILENCE. By REGINALD WriGHt KAUFFMAN. 12m Like “The House of Bondage.” this book fearlessly and realistically portray are; but, unlike its predecessor, is instinct with a mellow philosophy ; humor, a delineation of character and i a literary techni maturity. This novel is vie that how q : | | one that promises help; it el THE PRINCIPAL GIRL. 1) ).c.s; “*The Principal Girl’ is charming gy hight-come engaging a hero and as sprightly a heroine evate ITH author of * \raminta,”” et ly throughout, and as have graced the page MY LADY PEGGY LEAVES TOWN. by) Fessces Avave Mariey The hero of this breezy extravaganza is an American des so daringly impetuous and yet so lovable and charming earlier story of “My Lady Comes to Town.” THE BLIND ROAD. By HuGcu Gorpon. This is an intense and ably handled story of shows the various effects produced upon a man and womat metropolitan life. THE MYSTERY OF NUMBER 47. By J. Storer, Clouston. [29T10.. 2 An ingenious story of mystery and a delightful travesty on the modern detective thriller MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY, Union Sq., New York

Page 4

The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2439 B. Lippincott Company’s Spring Books A TIMELY BOOK. The American Government By FREDERIC J. HASKIN. The book that shows Uncle Sam at work, endorsed by the President, the cabinet, the heads of departments, and prominent educators. With 24 full-page Original Illustrations. S8vo. Popular Edition, $1.00 net; postpaid, $1.15 To fill a book with a great mass of facts about the Federal Government, having them so accurate that the highest officials of the land can vouch for them, and at the same time weaving them into a story that compels the closest attention of the readers, is conceded to be a difficult undertaking. The author has demonstrated that this can be dons AN IMPORTANT EDUCATIONAL WORK. Current Educational Activities A Report Upon Current Educational Movements Throughout the World Being Vol. II. of the Annals of Educational Progress. By JOHN PALMER GARBER, Associate Supt. of Public Schools of Philadelphia. In Lippincott’s Educational Series, edited by MARTIN G. BRUMBAUGH. 12mo. Cloth. $1.25 net. A report upon current educational activities throughout the world, dealing with such problems as vocational and agri- cultural education development affecting the public schools and higher institutions of learning, social problems, foreign educational institutions, meetings, etc. A unique year book. Very serviceable. MISCELLANEOUS The Wit and Humor of Colonial Days By PROFESSOR CARL HOLLIDAY Cloth, gilt top, $1.50 net Postpaid, $1.65 If there is any branch of literature in which Ameri celled other modern nations, it is Humor Crown vo a has ex- In the present work the author traces the course of our wit and humor from the days of the first settlement up to the opening of the nineteenth century A Manual of Heraldry By GALE, PEDRICK F.R. Hist. §S Illustrated $1.75 net Crown S8vo This is a Popular Introduction to the Origin, Significances and Uses of Armorial Bearings: a Guide to the Forms and Regulations of the Art-Science of Blazonry; and a Prelude to the Influence of Heraldry upon Poetry, Art, Architecture, and Literature Amateur Gardencraft REXFORD. Profusely illustrated. 12mo. Cloth, ; net. Sent postpaid $1.65. \ careful description of the desirable varieties of trees, shrubs, vines, and species of flowers and of ornamental plants, summer houses, pergolas, and new garden features, as well as the requisites for a velvety lawn, is given particular attention, also the elimination of insect pests. >. .* . Garden Design in Theory and Practice By MADELINE AGAR Illustrated in color and line, with numerous diagrams throughout the text. Small S8vo Decorated cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net ook for garden architects is devoted entirely to the and layout of gardens, everything of a purely horti- nature being omitted TRAVEL. MyAdventuresAmong South Sea Cannibals By DOUGLAS RANNIE. Demy 8vo. $3.50 net. With 39 illustrations and a map. An Account of the Experiences and Adventures of a Govern- ment Official among the Natives of Oceanica. The Tailed Head-Hunters of Nigeria By Major A. J. N. TREMEARNE, A.B. (Cantab.), F.R.G.S., F.R.A.I. With 38 illustrations and a map. Demy $&vo. $3.50 net. An Account of an Official’s Seven Years’ Experiences in the Pagan Belt of Northern Nigeria, and a Description of the Manners, Habits, and Customs of Some of the Native Tribes. Through Timbuctu and Across the Great Sahara By CAPTAIN A. H. W. HAYWOOD, F.R.G.S. With 45 illus- trations and a map. Demy 8vo. $3.50 net. \n Account of an Adventurous Journey of Exploration from Sierra Leone to the Source of the Niger, following its Course to the Bend at Gao and Thence Across the Great Sahara to Algiers. Among the Eskimos of Labrador By 8. K. HUTTON, M.B., Ch.B. VICT. With 47 illustrations and a map. 8vo. Cloth, gilt top. $3.50. net A Record of Five Years’ Close Intercourse with the Eskimo Tribes of Labrador. \ New SERIES As INTERESTING AS FICTION. CONQUESTS OF SCIENCE The Railway Conquest of the World By FREDERICK A, TALBOT About 100 illustrations from photographs. Numerous maps and diagrams. 12mo. Cloth, $1.50 net A fascinating and instructive account of railway building all over the world since the earliest days of railroading The author describes for us the difficulties and obstacles which were overcome by the men of genius whose names are im- lized In rallway annals Moving Pictures How They Are Made and Worked By FREDERICK A, TALBOT About 70 illustrations from photographs, with many diagrams. l2mo ph Cloth, $1.50 net The object of thie volume |! © tell In a popular manner verything about Moving Pictuses——how trick pictures are produ ed pletures that mov ind talk color pictures ete The author alao recounta many of the thrilling adventures experienced by daring photographers In Pre paration Guardians of the Coast The Lighthouses and Other Lights of the World By FREDERICK A. TALBOT About 80 Illustrations from photographs, with diagrams. S8vo. Cloth, $1.50 net. NEW FICTION. From the Car Behind By ELEANOR M. INGRAM. Colored illustrations by JAMES MONTGOMERY FLAGG. Cloth, $1.25 net. Postpaid, $1.37. \ brilliant automobile story with plenty of go and vim. The speed never slackens from start to finish, and one turns the pages breathlessly. The Mystery of Mary By GRACE L, H. LUTZ, author of “Marcia Schuyler,” etc. Colored frontispiece by ANNA W. SPEAKMAN. Cloth, $1.00 net Postpaid, $1.10 One of the author's most entertaining novels. In addition to a sweet love story there is a mystery which results in a num- ber of unusual situations Hidden House By AMELIA RIVES, author of “The Quick or the Dead,” ete. Colored frontispiece by GAYLE Hoskins. Decorated lining papers. Cloth, $1.20 net. Postpaid, $1.32. \ remarkable study of dual personality, which, for sheer power and fascination of interest holds the reader breathless until the unusual ending One of Us By EZRA BRUDNO, author of “The Tether,” Cloth, $1.25 net. Postpaid, $1.37. This is a big psychological novel, yet charmingly simple in the telling. Adventure, intrigue, and the powerful play of hu-, man passions clothe the spiritual theme of this book in a fascinating garment of outward action Publishers J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY Philadelphia

Page 5

tT The Nation The Week NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MARCH 28, 1912. | made to the Whig Senators: “You have ! broken a Minister only to make a Vice- | President.” The public man to-day who has a grievance is President Taft. He At Portland on Saturday Mr. Roose- velt pushed his garbling and misrepre- sentation of President Taft several de- | grees further than in his Carnegie Hall speech. It is a performance intellec-| tually contemptible and morally quite shameless. never capable of anything so low. Mr. Taft had merely stated the truism that in this country the people have to gov- Bryan at his worst was ern themselves through representatives. It was no more than Roosevelt himself had asserted in his Columbus speech, in which he said that the initiative and referendum, advocated by him, should | not be used “to destroy representative is not airing it, but everybody feels it, and it is working mightily in his fa- vor. The outrageous nature of his treat- ment by Mr. Roosevelt is turning thou- sands of voters to the support of the President. The American people do like fair play, and they know that Mr. Taft is not getting it from the greatest shout- er for fair play. Proof of this is seen |in the caption which the Topeka Plain- dealer spread across the first page of its issue of January 26: “Why don’t some People Learn Sense? Roosevelt won't run against Taft. He's not that kind of Man.” But when Roosevelt showed, by his letter of February 24, that he was |exactly that kind of man, there was no- government.” But now he makes the President’s statement mean approval of “government by the bosses, by the men who represent the combination of poli- tics and big business.” And then he proceeds to declare that the President has in mind men like Senator Penrose and Senator Gallinger and Chairman Barnes as the really “representative part” of the people who ought to rule. Ic is not necessary to point out that the aid of all these men has in times past been gladly received by Theodore Roosevelt. Nor need we stop to remark that at this very moment he is hand in glove with even more disreputable politicians and with rich men, two of whom have been under indictment for illegally combining politics and big business. All that it is needful to re- mark is that the chivalrous Roosevelt, in his attack upon a sworn friend, has been guilty of a base nerversion of that friend’s language. This touches a depth of meanness and demagogy which no Fresidential candidate ever before reached. “It is an advantage to a public man to have a grievance.” This was said to Martin Van Buren by an English states- man, at the time when the news came that Van Buren, though appointed and actually serving as American Minister in London, had been rejected by the Sen- | ate. The saying certainly proved true | in Van Buren’s case. He fulfilled the prediction which Benton at the moment | thing left for the Plaindealer but to come out for Taft. There can be no mistaking the signifi- cance of the vote by which the income tax bill—nominally an excise tax meas- ure, to be sure—was passed in the House of Representatives. When a proposal conspicuously put forward as part of the Democratic programme, on the eve of a Presidential campaign, is passed in the House not merely by a majority of six to one, but by a two-to-one vote of the Republican members voting, there is no room to doubt the strength of the popu- lar feeling in favor of the policy it em- bodies. Eighty Republicans voted for the income tax, while only forty stood out against it; and when it is added that the avowed ground of opposition on the part of these was in considera- ble measure the doubtful constitutional. ity of the bill, even that small protest loses much of its force. It can hard- ly be doubted, therefore, that the in- come-tax amendment to the United States Constitution will before long be approved by the small number of States still needed to procure its ratification. Chairman Underwood asserts that an examination of the Tariff Board's report has furnished no grounds for changing the wool bill presented by his commit- tee at the last session of Congress. The assertion seems to us entirely justified by the facts. The Tariff Board's report gave the results of a long and painstak- ing inquiry, but it left the question just about as unsettled as it had been be fore. It still remains a matter of indi vidual judgment where the line should be drawn, even if the principle of differ- ence of cost of production is accepted as binding, since that difference, in the case of wool at least, is too vague and too varied to serve as a definite guide. If the bill should how be House and Senate, as it was last year, passed by it will become the President's duty to consider it on its merits, and in the light of the Tariff Board's report. The more boldly and explicitly he refuses to take into account any question of politi- cal tactics, any fear of seeming to have done a foolish thing when he vetoed the bill last year if he signs it this year, the better, we are sure, he will stand in the forum of public opinion. The Board has at least shown that a great deal of the present wool schedule goes far be yond any reasonable measure of what the protection should be. What the President refused to do when this infor- mation was not before him he may with . perfectly good grace do now. “We cannot emphasize too strongly,” says the minority report on the Panama toll question, “the elementary proposi- tion that tolls levied upon vessels en- gaged in commerce between our Eastern and Western seaboards increase the amount the transcontinental railroads may charge for the same service.” No, and we cannot emphasize too strongly the equally elementary proposition that the expenses of these vessels for coal, for seamen, or for repairs “increase the amount the transcontinental railroads may charge for the same service.” The trouble about the “proposition” is that it is altogether too elementary. No- body denies that any tolls that may be charged will form an addition to the transportation expenses; but unfortu- nately that seems to go a very small way towards freeing us from our solemn obligation to treat foreign and American yessels alike in the matter of tolls. It happens that the Democrats are preparing to live up to their platform pledges in the matter of Philippine in dependence. The proposed bill drawn

Page 6

The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2439 302 by the House Insular Affairs Committee provides for a period of probationary independence of eight years from July 4, 1913, to July 4, 1921, and after that Until the bill itself actually appears it is, of course, hardly while its particular But is of enormous impor- full independence. worth to discuss merits. it tance that this question of the indepen- dence of the islands should be kept be- fore the public and constantly discussed. Throughout the country at large no en- thusiasm for retaining the archipelago can be found. Professional jingoes, big- navy advocates, and those who desire to the islands exploited by “big busi- will oppose. But the plain people know by this time that we have nothing See ness” to gain in a trade way by administer- the islands which we cannot ob- tain if the country governs itself; that ing the islands are a source of expense, and that Americans and Filipinos have little or nothing in common. The bill now under consideration by Affairs Committee of the House to improve the organization of the Foreign our consular and diplomatic service ought to be passed during the present Towards the state to session of Congress. the establish in a systematic way, there has of things which bill proposes now been for a series of years a steady approach in the actual practice of the State Department. The essential feature of the bill is seen in its first section: That the President may make all appoint- retaries in the diplomatic ser- consuls-general and consuls to ments of se vice and of grades instead of places, subject to the ad- vice and consent of the Senate in each case Then follow sections prescribing the sys- tem of reports on efficient service, and of examinations as to qualifications, which are to form the basis of the or- ganization of this graded service, as well as a definition of the grades themselves and the accompanying salaries. To make an appointment in the consular or diplo- matic service the stepping stone to a career, as well as to procure fairly qual- ified appointees in the first place, and to eliminate the spoils factor, is the ob- ject of the scheme; and so far have we got ahead that probably not a man will be found in Congress to attack the care- fully considered method of examination. Representative — Lindbergh's proposal to abolish the Senate and the Vice-Presi- | ' dent, and to cut the’ membership of the House to 315 has at least the merit of thoroughness. Nor is it altogether cer- tain that the country would miss the presiding officer of the Senate or the seventy-odd Representatives thus shorn of their powers. But that the rest of the House and all the orators of both par- ties, to say nothing of the newspapers and magazines, would consent to being deprived of their one perennial object of attack by the disappearance of the Sen- ate is so inconceivable that even this bold innovator dares not suggest it without a plausible substitute. He would have fifteen Representatives elected from the country at large as a “Committee- at-Large,” to be entrusted with control and veto power over the legislation of their three hundred humbler colleagues. The mighty fifteen would exercise their functions under the constant peril of the recall. The President, we presume, would do his best to keep up appear- ances by sending messages to the fifteen, and signing or vetoing whatever bills they were so gracious as to transmit to him, with as great a flourish as he could command. In this way, the great ideal of a really business administration of national affairs would be realized. The people, acting as a board of directors, would select and recall members of the Committee-at-Large as often as they could find time to attend to them, and life would be one long election day. Indiana Democrats threw Gov. Mar- shall’s hat into the ring last week by instructing the thirty delegates to the Baltimore Convention to present his name as that of their first and only choice for the Presidential nomination. There are cynical spirits who profess to see a string tied to this resolution, with one end in the hand of National Com- mitteeman and Delegate-at-Large Thom- as Taggart. The speech of the Gover- nor as temporary chairman of the Con- vention was strangely calm for these parlous times in which the very right of the people to rule is at stake. Until graver evils come than have thus far arisen, Gov. Marshall sees no reason for the initiative, referendum, and recall. In a mollycoddie spirit, he confesses that, although he often chafes under what he conceives to be the unwarrant- ed interference of the courts with his prerogatives, he refrains from denounc- ing them as instruments of oppression, and looks for relief to the remedies we already have. There was more than a mere formal- ity in the adjournment of the House on ; account of the death of Representative |Foster of Vermont. A member of Con- |gress for five terms, David J. Foster ‘had particularly impressed all his col- | leagues by the weight of his character, | as by his industry and the clear sanity |of his judgment. Serving on the Foreign | Affairs Committee, he made himself ‘known, especially in the last Congress, | as a firm champion of equity and moder- peor in international relations. The | arbitration treaties had no firmer friend ‘or more constant advocate. Of the best | American stock and with a long record |of varied public service, he was a Rep- | resentative whom Vermont did well to /honor and whose loss she and the coun- try have reason to deplore. Nemesis has at last overtaken the muck-raking magazine. Its own shames are now to be he’d up to public scorn, From “Masters of Wall Street” we are to proceed to “Masters of the Maga- zines,” the way, we take it, being a short one. The mere announcement of the ser- ies whets one’s appetite. “There is near- ly as much fiction about magazines as there is in them,” we read, and then the eye is greeted with such phrases as “re- cent changes in magazine ownership,” “centralized control of the magazines,” “the advertiser holds the power of life or death—the final word.” We are as- sured in the customary manner of the writer’s intellectual and moral fitness for his delicate task. Not only is he a | veteran in the magazine and advertising | field, a practical publisher, and “a fair | and open-minded student of the life that wwe on about him,” but he has “the |punch”; that is, he speaks “with all the | sympathetic understanding of an insid- er, yet he speaks boldly and forcefully— and fearlessly.” | $traw votes in the colleges uniform- ly show that the sympathies of the | American undergraduate are emphat- ically with the Republican party, Wes- leyan University’s underclassmen are three Republicans to one Democrat. A recent poll at New York University, in the very citadel of Democracy, showed an even stronger drift towards the Re- publican party. One explanation is to

Page 7

March 28, 1912] The Nation be found in the fact that the American undergraduate, unlike every other col- lege student on earth except the Oxford man, is conservative. This does not nec- essarily mean that the undergraduate mind regards the Republican and Demo- cratic parties as the embodiment, re- spectively, of conseivatism and radical- ism. The undergraduate is conservative in the sense that he believes in the status quo. Hence his inclination te- wards the Republican party which for sixteen years has been in control of the Government. There may be freshmen now in college who were born after Bry- an’s first defeat. And to the entire present college generation a Democratic President is hardly even a memory. We should not forget the great ser- vices to the cause of conservation ren- dered by the late Gen. John W. Noble, whose death occurred on Friday. It was during his incumbency of the of-| fice of Secretary of the Interior that the forest reservation policy was originated | under the act of March 3, 1891. The great Sierra Reserve was one of the first proclaimed, thanks to General Noble’s initiative. So vast was this res-| ervation that many timid persons criti-| cised the Secretary of the Interior for, gcing too far. Fortunately, this did not | deter him from stretching bis authority | a trifle in order to preserve the banks of that greatest of our scenic wonders, the Arizona Grand Cafion of the Colo- rado. Thanks to the Sierra Reserve, | California has had the use of the water resources needed for the irrigation of the San Joaquin Valley. For this alone that State owes to General Noble a last- ing debt of gratitude. Monsignor Brann’s advice to his hear- ers in New York to pray for the news- papers, arrests attention. What is worth praying for cannot be beyond hope. As a practical suggestion, however, there is greater force in Monsignor Brann’s ac- companying words: “And as for the bad ones—don't buy them; don’t read them.” It might be whispered that, as between praying for the editor and refusing to buy his paper, an ounce of the latter is worth a ton of the other, but there is no reason why the clergyman’s parishion- ers should not do both. If they prefer sensation to certainty, they will go where sensation is to be found. Such} readers, however, are estopped from | | complaining of the existence of the thing which they are keeping alive. The remedy for it lies in their own hands. The way to Trust regulation may not be clear; even the means of escape from political bosses may require considera- tion; but to dispose promptly and abso- lutely of gutter journalism is ridiculous- ly simple—that is, if people really want to dispose of it. If the Department of English of the University of Kansas has really begun a campaign against slang, it deserves the thanks of everybody who has ears to hear. That there is something to be said for slang cannot be denied. Those who devise it and those who use it are not always actuated by a desire to de- grade speech. At bottom there is the search for newly-minted coins which in a Shakespeare the world applauds. Some of the methods employed are common to slang-writer and literary artist, as the seizing upon metaphorical expres- sions and the drafting of a noun to do service as a verb. But the practice is so overdone in quantity and so under- done in quality that the principle has been buried under a mass of nondescript verbal concoctions. Such a fevered movement must die a natural death in the end, but meantime the not over-sen- sitive twentieth-century ear is being so violently abused as to make it question- able whether it will long have any pow- er of discrimination left. The virtue of the campaign said to have been under- taken by the University of Kansag lies in its endeavor te strengthen the sense of word values in persons who are not too old for reform. While British labor leaders are being sent to prison for inciting troops to mu- tiny, the anti-militarist movement in France, the place of its origin, seems to be distinctly on the wane. Thus is once more exemplified the réle of France, the pioneer of ideas, discarding the ideas about the time the rest of the world is beginning to put them into application. The present popularity of the army in France may be taken as part of the gen-_ eral awakening of the national spirit consequent upon the late crisis in Franco-German relations over Morocco. It is attested by the recent revival of the custom of parading the troops of the garrison of Paris through the streets of the city, whereas only a year or two 3083 ago, as one writer says, it was the cus tom to have the soldiers slink through the back streets of Paris for fear of arousing the ire of the anti-militarists Military ceremonies, for some time fall en into disuse, have also been revived Military reviews have become more fre quent. Characteristically enough, the militarist spirit is being fostered by a Minister of War who not so long ago was a Socialist, namely, M. Millerand. Violence by English suffragists contin- ues to elicit strong expressions for and against, but perhaps the most signifi- cant action taken is that by the Wo- men's Liberal Federation. At a recent meeting of the Executive Committee a resolution was carried, which was mov- ed by Lady Carlisle, and which utterly repudiated and condemned “the disas trous acts of violence,” and held that such “organized outrages endanger the cause of women’s suffrage.” This wo- men’s organization represents 860 Wo- men’s Liberal Associations. It conclud- ed its resolution by appealing to mem- bers of Parliament not to “swerve from their championship of a great cause’ merely because of “the wrongdoing of a small section of the army of women who demand the Parliamentary vote.” On the other hand, Annie Besant has pub lished a letter defending the militant and law-breaking tactics. Equal suffrage for women in China!’ It is limited, as yet, but evidently the people are going to rule, and not merely the male half about which our ex-Presi- dent is suddenly so deeply concerned in this country. What an argument ou: own suffragists will have hereafter everybody must see. What can a poor, badgered legislator say when, surround ed by a bevy of eager pleaders, he met by the question: “Do you want your State to be behind China!” Plainly, the Chinese Parliament, which is reported to have granted the suffrage to wome! simultaneously with the election to of the Chinese Mrs. Pankhurst joices in the euphonious name of Y}} Yug-Ying—intends to cure all the evils of democracy in advance by having the completest possible equality. When in history was there a revolution such as has come over the Celestial Empire, at least in so short a time and with such complete overturning of old forms of government?

Page 8

3804 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2439 THE ENGLISH CRISIS, Mr. Balfour's House of Commons as the spokesman reappearance in the for his party was more dramatic than fruitful. He put the temporary Con- servative leader, Mr. Bonar Law, aside but he could not overcome Mr. Asquith. On the second reading of the bill to set- tle the coal strike the Ministry had more than their normal majority. This did not mean that the Liberal party, or, indeed, the sober opinion of Eng- land, was satisfied with the Government measure. Brought forward only as a last resort and with many misgivings, supported in the House merely as an emergency bill of limited life, it is look- ed upon by all thoughtful men as a step which may have the gravest conse- quences. These were forcibly depicted by Mr. Balfour, but the sense of over- powering necessity was too strong for him, while his statement that, even if the Government were defeated, the Op- pesition would not seek to force a dis- solution, took the fight out of his follow- ers. Party advantage cannot well be got out of a crisis in which the Con- servatives have no alternative plan to offer. Politically, Mr. Balfour’s return will be accepted as marking the failure of Mr. Bonar Law's leadership. With it there have been increasing signs of dis- satisfaction. Mr. Law has abundant energy, but not too much discretion. He has made several glaring blunders. The Liberal press has been able to bring him into ridicule. And it was observa- ble some weeks ago that a movement was quietly on foot to bring Mr. Bal- four back. In place of the old initials, B. M. G., there was getting to be substli- tuted these other, B. M. R.—that Is, In- stead of the foolish cry by disgruntled Conservatives, “Balfour Must Go,” there came to be the refrain, “Balfour Must Return.” It is, of course, not certain that he will at once resume the lead- ership, but the ylelding of Bonar Law to him in the present crisis bears out the prediction made at the moment of Balfour's resignation: “In six months’ time he will have them all at his feet again.” Mr. Balfour well expressed the sentl- ments of those who feel that the pro- posed action of Parliament, in dealing) with the coal strike, is something s0 new in English law-making as to be al- most revolutionary. Yet it will not do) ‘to exaggerate the lengths to which the proposed bill would go. It may be said to be, in effect, an extension of the func- tions of Government conciliation in la-| bor troubles, as already possessed and discharged by the officials of the Board of Trade. The coal-strike bill proceeds on the assumption that the-mining in- dustry is so much a thing by itself, and that conditions in certain districts are | so exceptional, that special legislation is proper and necessary. What is planned is to set up boards for the several coal- mining regions, of which the duty shall | be to attend to the grievances of the miners and, roughly, to fix their wages. In each instance the whole question of peculiar circumstances and competition and profits will be gone into thoroughly, and the results determined in the cau-| tious English way of applying reason and justice to the facts. Up to this point, the bill could hardly | be called startling, though it is clear| that the Government would never have | thought of going even as far as this had it not been for the strike. But the novel | thing, the thing that may fairly be call-| ed revolutionary in English legislation, | is the legal recognition by the bill of | the principle of the minimum wage. | This, to be sure, is in general terms. The | miners have been pressing Mr. Asquith to do two things; first, to embody in the ' erly fasten upon the politics of it all. There has been a feeling, for which some justification exists, that the As- quith Ministry is losing its hold on the country. Some have even declared that the Government is tottering to a fall, ‘and have predicted that the Conserva- tives will be in power before the year is out. The bye-elections have been going ominously against the Liberals. But apart from the ups and downs of incl- dental pollings, stands the large fact of the actual Liberal strength in Parlia- /ment, together with the announced pol- icy and purposes of the coalition Minis- try. It still has behind it in the House _a majority of more than 100. This Par- liament has been in existence only about a year and a quarter. It has a normal prospect of life of over three years more. And the cohesion and tenacity of the Government must be greatly strength- ened by the situation in which it finds itself. After great exertion and succes- sive general elections, it was able to pass the Parliamentary Act, removing after a two years’ interval the veto pow- er of the House of Lords. But that measure was not an end in itself. It was only a means. The thing all the while aimed at was the enactment of legislation which the Liberal party had at heart, and to which it is pledged; and the Parliament Act was merely a bill the entire scale of wages, up and | preliminary to that, simply a tool to down, which they have demanded of the | remove obstructions from the path. The owners; secondly, at least to state in the whole logic of the position, then, is that law the exact minimum wage to be in-| the Liberals should stand by their guns, sisted upon, namely, $1.25 a day for men, | and press on the bills for Home Rule, and 50 cents for boys. The former the Prime Minister flatly refused to do, at the time of his conference with the min- ers. But he left the door open in the matter of specifying the minimum wage, and it was thought that he might yield on that point. But he has not done so. His position is, apparently, that the acceptance of the principle of the min- imum wage—that is, that the worker must get enough to keep soul and body together—does not require that the Gov- ernment shall say what such a mini- ‘mum wage is, but that this question shall be left in every given instance to be determined. by the local boards that are also to pass upon the other matters ‘in dispute. While waiting for the ultimate eco- nomic and social effects of the bill to show themselves, public attention and speculation in England will most eag- |for Welsh Disestablishment, for the abo- - ‘ition of plural voting, and for the re form of public education, which they /have promised the country, and to pre- | pare the way for which all the long and | bitter struggles of the past three years | were primarily undertaken. “SYNDICALISM.” | The Lawrence strike has brought into public notice in this country a new type | of labor union and a new philosophy of ‘the labor movement. The strike at Lawrence was conducted by the Indus- trial Workers of the World, familiarly known as the I. W. W., whose principles go by the name of Syndicalism. The term has been popularized recently by events in England, where Mr. Tom Mann, a veteran labor leader and the exponent of the new movement in the ae tal ere > ala! bbe ic Bie Reh sie 8e re ee

Page 9

4 4 % ® 4 é. z far “s March 28, 1912] The Nation 305 British trade unions, has been put in| prison for preaching sedition to the army in connection with the coal strike. Isolated theories and practices of Syn- dicalism have already become fairly fa- miliar to the general reader. Such are the “general strike” which constitutes the basic principle of Syndicalism, and “direct action” which has achieved noto- riety through the acts of the McNamara brothers. Even the French word sabotage has become acclimated in the newspa- pers. But a general account of the Syn- dicalist movement has been wanting till recently. The deficiency is now supplied by an admirable monograph, entitled “The Labor Movement in France,” from the hand of Mr. Louis Levine and pub- lished under the auspices of the Colum- bia University Department of Political Science. Syndicalism, in its latest phase has arisen out of peculiar conditions in the French labor movement. But the truth of Mr. Levine’s contention is quite ap- parent: Syndicalism is essentially a re- vival of conditions that prevailed at the beginning of the international labor movement fifty years ago. When the “Internationale” was founded in 1864, it was almost from the beginning torn be- tween two conflicting tendencies, which in broad terms we may characterize as the revolutionary spirit and the evolu- tionary, the anarchistic and the Social- istic, the gospel of violence as preached by Michael Bakunin, and the gospel of gradual transformation under the laws of industrial development as set forth by Karl Marx. In other words, the la- bor movement is only human. Like all great social and political movements, it has had its moderates and extremists, its legalists and its revolutionaries. La- bor and Socialism have witnessed the al- ternate ascendency of one faction or the other. In France, characteristically, this shifting of bases has always found its most vigorous expression. There, on the one hand, Socialists have consented to enter a bourgeois Cabinet and co- operate with the “exploiters” of the working classes. And there, on the oth- er hand, the syndicalist theory has been most completely worked out. Syndicalism or revolutionary trade- unionism is, in the first place, a sharp reaction against political or parliamen- tary Socialism. In theory it holds that the presence of Socialist or trade-union repudiates individual representatives of the working class, such as Millerand, Briand, and Viviani, as traitors to their class; but it regards the parliamentary system in itself as conducive to the sac- rifice of principles, the encouragement of petty intrigue, the fostering of cow- ardly conciliation, and thus to the weak- ening of the revolutionary spirit among the workingmen. Moreover, parliamen- tarianfsm leads to the domination of the working-classes by non-workingmen. It is the “intellectuals” who get themselves elected to Parliament; and such men, with all the good will in the world, can- not really enter into the feelings and the aspirations of the working-class. The “intellectuals” are necessarily inclined to take a philosophic view of the “war between the classes.” They are content to make gradual progress. They accept reforms. They cannot understand the real workingman’s passionate yearning for liberation, te be obtained in his own day and by any means. Syndicalism, therefore, rejects the idea of capturing the bourgeois state by legislative methods. It rejects pal- liatives and reforms because they do not go to the heart of the trouble, which is simply irreconcilable class warfare. Be- cause the state is always bound to be under the control of the propertied classes and the “intellectuals,” Syndical- ism declares war against the state. It finds in the workingmen’s organizations the only efficient agent for overturning society. It regards the general strike as the lever that will accomplish the strike may Mean- /overthrow. The general ‘come to-day or at any time. | while it is necessary to maintain the |class spirit unimpaired, to nourish it |on partial strikes, on constant agitation. Every victory over the employer is to be made the base for further conquests. |The irrepressible conflict is to be has- tened by a policy of constant irritation. Better than having Socialist Deputies in Parliament, is to force a bourgeois Parliament into concessions by force— by strikes, sabotage, protest meetings, and every other form of mass action. |The labor unions are the “standing army” of the revolution. They may not | represent a majority of the workingmen. |Even within the unions the majority ‘may not be in favor of direct action. | But that does not matter. In every his- representatives in Parliament is use-| toric movement, the conscious, resolute . less or worse than useless. It not only | minority has carried the indifferent ma- jority with it. Syndicalism has also its constructive philosophy. When the looked-for “gen- eral strike” has come and succeeded, when tiie present system of capitalist protection is overthrown, then the labor unions are to step in and assume con- trol of the business of production. The future state, as pictured by Syndicalism, will be a loose, federative structure of producers’ unions in which the work men will also be the owners, directors, and distributors. But, as a matter of fact, Syndicalism does not concern itself greatly with the nature of the future state. It has taken the old cry that the laboring-class has everything to gain and nothing but its chains to lose, and has given to this watchword a phil osophical cast. The most eminent theo- retician of the .Syndicalist movement, M. Georges Sorel, is a confessed Berg- sonian. We must trust ourselves to the stream of life. Creative evolution, work- ing in the domain of industry, will work out the salvation of society. Just now the most significant thing in Syndicalism is that it constitutes a men- ace, not to society, but to the Socialist party. It brushes away disdainfully the results of decades of Socialist effort and says virtually that the 110 Socialist members of the Reichstag, the seventy odd Socialist members in the French Chamber, the forty labor members in the House of Commons, the large Socialist party in the Austrian and Italian Parlia- All this is interesting to us of America, where po- ments, amount to nothing. litical Socialism is learning its first steps. Socialists have hardly done re- joicing over Milwaukee, Schenectady, and Mr. Berger, when up rises this spec- tre of “direct action” in their path. They are willing to accept the established doc- trine that the Socialist party and the unions represent the two arms of the. militant working class. But the Syndi- calists arise and proclaim themselves alone as the people. Salvation will not come through a Socialist majority of “intellectuals” in the House of Represen- tatives and the Senate, but through a minority of determined workingmen leading the masses into battle on the economic field. No wonder the Socialist Call loses its temper and declares that “worse than the ‘aristocracy of intel- lect’ is the ‘aristocracy of revolution.’ It becomes ‘an aristocracy of

Page 10

306 The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2439 : : | revolutionary intellect’ without a glim-| enforce existing legislation and procure/| new law immigrants are protected where mering of intelligence and none of the whatever new laws are needed; the/ natives of the country working along- revolutionary impulse, It becomes mere- ly a personal concern, with no shade of democracy it, lowers and with unquestioned leaders.” in with subservient fol- This exposition of Syndicalism, we leave to speak for itself. PROTECTING THE IMMIGRANTS. In the closing days of the session of 1910, the New York State Legislature passed four bills which marked a new era in the hu- manitarian and industrial legislation of the It established a policy and created a new kind of administrative machinery which now seem destined to lead both the Federal and State Governments in the de- velopment of a domestic policy in dealing with admitted aliens. These were the four immigration bills which created the Bureau of Industries and Immigration, and regu- private bankers, steamship ticket and notaries public. State. lated agents, These words are the introduction to the first annual report of the Bureau of Industries Immigration. It was fortunate at its inception in obtaining Miss Frances A. Kellor, and at its head whose work in connection with the su- pervision of employment agencies and in other fields of social endeavor had port before us is from her pen. | third is to investigate and study exist- ing conditions of life and labor; and the fourth is to publish the results of these studies. The Bureau has made only a begin- ning of its work. Yet no less than 2,956 investigations of subjects, and 749 direct investigations of complaints, have been made. Throughout the State were found colonies of aliens needing attention; some grouped around industrial cen- tres such as Rochester, Syracuse, Utica, etc.; others in remote mining or railway camps and along the great new aqueduct. In some of these colonies the conditions were found to be shocking in the extreme. To help immigrants who have been victims of this kind of ill- treatment or have been defrauded or maltreated by employment agents, con- tractors, private bankers, padrones, ticket agents, land and transportation companies, etc., has been the ceaseless aim of the Bureau. Where relief or financial aid was needed, the Bureau di- rected the applicants to existing char- itable agencies. Through a group of fifty newspapers representing all nation- won her a deserved reputation. The re-|alities and languages, it has reached | thousands of immigrants and laid before In brief, by passing this legislation | the State of New York decided to as-|ed, exploiters apprehended, besides set- sume a new attitude towards the immi-|ting forth the dangers that threaten, grant. the tender mercies of transportation companies and to those of the sharks who lie in wait for him at every corner. The State should be protected both on and after his arrival. It created a bureau to look decided to see to it that he) out for him wherever aliens are found | in congested quarters, camps, or colo- nies. The process of Americanization was to be furthered and supervised. But, above all, the Immigrant was to be pro- tected from exploitation because of his ignorance of the country and of its lan- guage. Obviously, this opened up a fleld in which sentiment might easily get the better of judgment. Miss Kellpr has en- deavored to carry out the new policy in four ways: first, by assuring to every admitted alien in the State who has a grievance a hearing in his own language and an impartial inquiry into his alleg- ed wrongs, with the State acting as me- diator for him where the wrong Is estab- lished, or as his attorney if arbitration is impossible. The second object is to them news of frauds detected and prov- He was no longer to be left to' and the labors of the Government and of individual societies in their behalf. Already the Bureau is in a position to make important recommendations, It would have the State establish free em- ployment bureaus for the distribution of unskilled workers now at congested cen- tres. It urges a “camp-school bureau or commission” to deal with the education- al needs in immigrant colonies and camps; and desires that the immigrant lodging-place law shall be extended to temporary labor camps. For the Feder- al Government there are eight recom- mendations, two of the most important of which are that the Government shall license and regulate labor bureaus which now supply labor to those engaged in interstate business, and that naturaliza- tion shall be restricted to Federal courts. The need of extending welfare and edu- work to small communities, camps, and colonies throughout the State, and of establishing an experti- mental school of citizenship, is also con- Curiously enough, under this cational sidered. } side of them are beyond the scope of the | Bureau; on the other hand, the foreign- ers in such outlying camps and commu- nities are usually overlooked in the mat- ter of schools, recreation, libraries, and | 80 on. The most striking thing about the |Bureau is its personnel and its spirit. | Twenty-five years ago it would have |}seemed a matter of course to put at its head some cheap politician wholly with- |out experience or fitness for the work. |It would have been deemed preposter- |}ous to choose a social worker, and a woman at that. The ordinary political bureaucrat will rub his eyes with amaze- ment when he learns that not only did Miss Kellor bring a fine personal en- thusiasm to her work, but that when it was found that there was not money enough appropriated properly to organ- ize the office, the head of the Bureau and her chief special investigator, Miss Car- ola Woerishoffer, contributed the funds necessary. A work which is carried on by such officials is bound to prosper. Un- fortunately for the State, death robbed it of Miss Woerishoffer’s service last summer with cruel untimeliness. Right- ly, the first page of the report before us is given to a tribute to her from which we extract the following: “The State has had no enrolled soldier who has re- sponded to every call more promptly, who has performed the duties set him more unflinchingly, or who has given his life more utterly on the field of bat- tle than she in the cause in which she believed.” THE EXTINCT ANGEL CHILD. Justice requires that a good word be said for the saintly infant of two gen- erations ago whom devoted parents brought up on pap and treacle to be a missionary among the cannibals. It has become too much the fashion to call him a prig and a snivelling humbug. To this sweeping charge at least a two- feld objection can be taken. In the first place, if the mid-Victorian child was a prig, it was because his parents were prigs; which is always a reasonable de- fence. In the second place, the mid- Victorian angel child never existed out- side of the books written for him by his elders. About 1830 Dr. Kendall pro- ‘duced, antong other books for children,

Page 11

March 28, 1912] The Nation 307 “The Prize for Youthful Obedience,” of | which the story moves in this vein: A kind and good father had a little lively son, named Francis; but, although that child was six years old, he had not yet learned to read. His mamma said to him one day: “If Francis will learn to read well, he shall have a pretty little chaise.” The little boy was vastly pleased with this. He presently spelled five or six words, and then kissed his mamma. “Mamma,” said Francis, “I am delight- ed with the thoughts of this chaise, but I should like to have a horse to draw it.” “Francis shall have a little dog, which will do instead of a horse,” replied his mamma; “but he must take care to give him some victuals, and not do him any harm.” The natural desire that arises in the modern soul to assassinate little Francis and his mamma is only stayed by the re- flection that among little Francis’s con- temporaries were Tom Sawyer and Huck Finn. Obviously the fault lies not with little Francis but with his creator. The child has always been the victim of standards imposed upon him by his elders, in literature as in every other phase of life. the child soul has been very much what it is to-day. century Massachusetts when the Rev. Michael Wigglesworth wrote his charm- And always, we imagine, It was so in seventeenth- ing little lyrics about infants in hell fine, and when two-year-old babes lisped: I, in the Burying Place, may see Graves Shorter than I; From Death’s Arrest no age is free, Young children too may die. It is so to-day when little Socialist chil- dren in Socialist Sunday-schools con- strue in their Socialist primers exer- cises of the following general tenor: See the Capitalist. Is he a fat Capitalist? Yes, he is a fat Capitalist. See the Workingman. Is he a thin Workingman? Yes, he is a thin Workingman. Why is the Capitalist so fat? Because the Workingman is so thin. But even in Massachusetts of the seven- teenth century it is on record that the | histories of Tom Thumb and Jack the | Giant Killer were circulated in printed | form. Whatever the Puritan father may | have thought about it, the conjecture is, a safe one that the Puritan mother put | her children to bed not with extracts from the Rev. Michael Wigglesworth, but | from the vast body of Mother Goose literature which no age and no country has ever been without. It is undoubt- edly true that the Socialist child of to- day does not pursue his inner spiritual life under the shadow of the Material-' istic Interpretation of History and of the Class Struggle. and folk dances and flag drills with the red flag, of which the symbolic meaning They have games may not always be present to their young minds. To-day it is true in one sense that the gap between child nature and the na- ture of child literature is narrower than it was with the Puritans and the Vic- torians, and than it threatens to be un- der the Socialist régime. We take pride in recognizing the existence of the “real” boy and the “real” girl. Animal spirits, far from being banned, are ex- plicitly encouraged; not only on the theory that boys will be boys, but on the impressive philosophical assumption that the individual life mirrors the his- tory of the race and that the boy has a scientific excuse for being something of a savage. Hence the present-day literature deals with boy scouts and boy hunters, with pirates and treasure trove, with football and college frater- nities. And then all at once you observe a peculiar lapse into didacticism; for the modern boy has his educational books about wireless and aeroplanes, about Dreadnoughts and submarines. Where- in, now, are we better than the Victor- ians who wrote about pony chaises in connection with obeying mamma and be- ing kind to the dog? The Victorians encouraged moral prigs. We are turn- ing our children into scientific and tech- nical prigs. Recall how pedagogists in- sist on reminding us of the joy the child takes in making helieve that a dog is a prancing charger, or in raising large families of calico-dressed clothes- pins taken from the wash-line. In them- selves the wireless and the Dreadnought |have no greater appeal for the child than good dog Ponto harnessed to a wagon, Only we choose one way of pre- paring the child for citizenship and the Victorians had another. We are inter- ested in the evolutionary effects of play, and the Victorians were interested in moral effects. It is to be doubted, how- ever, whether the Victorian mind was capable of conceiving a monstrosity like “directed child play,” which, we under- stand, is one of the rising new sociologi-| cal sciences. Other times, other—no, not other cus- toms—but other ways of formulating the same old habits of mind. Whether) the object of education is to make a good man as the Victorians called it, or a socially efficient citizen as one sup- posedly ought to call it to-day, it is real- ly the same object. Only once upon a time people went directly at their goal. Little Francis’s education was in closer touch with actuality than many of our own methods. There did exist cannibals whom a little boy might reform, convert by kindness. But an education in pirate- treasure and wood-lore is no preparation for a clerkship in a shoe-shop or a bank. For all that he was a prig and a nuis- ance, little Francis was in touch with those great principles of morality and conduct which underlie every condition of life and every state of society. The modern librarian ejects the Horatio Alger books from his shelves, presum ably on the theory that stories for boys, no matter how interesting they are, must necessarily be smug and priggish if they speak of bootblacks who became wealthy honesty, merchants through industry, and fidelity. That librarian’s shelves are crowded with best-sellers, for adults, which are nothing but the Alger gospel warmed up and served with modern trimmings. TEACHING THE FARMERS TO PLAY. The common conception of country) life as all work and no play is one of those generalities that are established rather than weakened by investigation. The life of the average farmer, says Prof. John M. Gillette of the University of North Dakota, in the “Country Life” number of the Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, “is a round of eating, working, sleeping, saving, economizing, living meagrely. recognizing only the bare necessaries, skimping along with inconveniences.” Let such a man accumulate wealth, and move into the city to enjoy it, and he becomes one of the most helpless of men. “He still practices tue stern economies, lives in houses without modern conveni- ences, keeps the old rag carpets, attends no theatres, goes to no lectures unless they are free, and acts as a man in a strange world or as one with a starved soul.” The rural telephone, rural mall delivery, and increased use of machin- ery have greatly altered conditions for the better, but the farmer who runs down to the station in his automobile to meet his dinner guests from the near-

Page 12

The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2439 B08 est city is as yet much oftener seen in | cartoons than in life. The result is that much of the relaxa- tion which he manages to get is arti- ficial; it is apt to be either solitary or amid surroundings that are not of his making. In either case, it is not what it should be, and is quite different from that enjoyed by the urban laborer. The solitary forms of his play, such as hunt- ing and fishing, tend to diminish; while the other sort, for which he resorts to the village or town within easiest reach, is made up of moving-picture shows, sa- billiard and lodge-rooms. The mere geographical fact that these loons, halls, attractions are on alien ground exerts a subtle psychological influence upon him. He at feels himself, if not in a new heaven, least on a new earth, and he has a consequent the checks and balances of his native heath. sense of release from This disparity in location between his labor and his play has another unfortu- nate effect in making him dissatisfied with the place of his work, and drawing him towards the spot which he associ- ates with his brighter hours. This cir- cumstance alone is sufficient demonstra- tion of the vital connection between work and play, and of the need for the development of the latter in the rural communities themselves. Their dearth of social intercourse in all but the most rudimentary ways is doubtless connect- ed with their lack of intellectual stim- ulus, It may seem that this view gives scant credit to the cultural value of the in- formal gatherings in the store, the post office, the railway station, or the one building that houses all three. One of our traditions has been the hard-headed tiller of the soil, listening at the Satur- day evening assembly to the reading of a newspaper, and then engaging in home- ly but pithy discussion of the questions that are puzzling the wise men at Wash- ington. The facts seem to be quite dif- ferent communities, according to Dr. H. Wilson, Presbyterian Superintendent of Church and Country Life, is saturat- ed at such times, not with political wis- dom, but with economic commonplaces. The church does little more for the s0- clal instinct. Being far too numerous for the population the churches “become the vehicle of express- ing grudges, resentments, narrow and The social mind of our rural Warren they serve, mean social feelings.” he old-fashioned | rural home has disappeared, and consol- idation and centralization of country schools has only begun. The way to better things is a double one. In the first place, conscious effort is now made to supply the wanting so- cial activity. With what might seem to a stranger a merry jest, the metropoli- tan centre of the hemisphere is the head- | quarters of an organization that pro- | poses to train our rural inhabitants in the art of recreation and amusement. | Parents shall be instructed in telling | stories, clubs shall be organized for the | boys and girls, there shall be lecture | and entertainment courses, reading cir- public libraries, choral unions, | more intelligent church and school so-| cials, itinerant social and literary meet- ings, systematic teaching of plays and games, modern forms of camping, en-| couragement of tramping and houseboat parties, and a great many more delight- cles, ful doings. One’s head reels at the elab-| orateness of the programme. Carried out in its entirety, it would inevitably de- feat its purpose by driving the exhaust- ed merry-makers from the country to the cities, for the sake of rest and quiet. But probably it will not be carried so| far. Programmes seldom are. The in- ertia of the rural subjects of the experl- ment will furnish a sufficient counter- | poise to the enthusiasm of the experi-| Tried tactfully, as no doubt) it will be tried, it must awaken many a| community to the realization that there| is a better means of escape from the | grind of toil than “recreations” which | leave the body little better off, and the mind decidedly worse off. menters. The larger hope, however, would ap-| pear to lie in less self-conscious, less ex: | ternal, less specific methods. Typical | and perhaps most important of these at | the moment is the Chautauqua. Here | pveople sit together without petty dis-| tinction of creed or party, listening to vigorous utterance and challenge of opinion, and finding their way into new intellectual realms. The extent of the movement in rural regions may be known from the statement that in Ne- braska, with its sixty towns of a popula- tion of more than a thousand each, there are fifty-five Chautauquas; in Iowa, there are nearly two hundred; and in Kansas and Missouri, fifty each. The brevity of the time during which the sessions are held, the average being only ten days, renders them a means of sug- gestion and inspiration rather than a so- cial institution. But in this circum- stance is their value. Instead of supply- ing the farmer and his household with ready-made schemes of recreation, they quicken his mind, open for him ho- rizons beyond his farm, and, best of all, make it harder for him to enjoy the thin and vapid amusements of the neighboring village. With such a hint, he can be trusted to develop a social life of his own, without peril to the natural character which no one wishes him to lose. THROUGH THE OUTLOOKING GLASS The Red Knight had been rowing for a long time and Alice noticed that they were still in the same place. That was on ac- count of the peculiar way in which the Red Knight handled the oars. He pulled at the right oar as hard as he could and he pushed with the left oar as hard as he could, and the boat went round and round in a circle. “We aren’t getting any nearer the shore, are we?” he asked anxiously. “Not a bit,” said Alice. “That’s fine,” said the Red Knight. “Now | you can see that I am neither a wild-eyed radical nor a moss-grown reactionary.” But Alice’s conscience began to trouble her. “You know,” she said, “I promised Mam- ma that I would go out in a boat under no | circumstances.” “That's all right, then,” said the Red Knight. “It’s just what you are doing.” “But I am not,” said Alice. “You are very stupid,” said the Red Knight. “Suppose you said, ‘I will go out in the rain under no umbrella.’ Wouldn’t that mean that you intended to go out with- out an umbrella?” “It might mean that,” said Alice. “And suppose you said, ‘I will go to bed under no blanket,’ it would mean that you preferred to sleep without a _ blanket, wouldn’t it?” “I suppose so,” said Alice. “Now, were there any circumstances why you should have gone out with me in this boat?” asked the Red Knight. “No,” said Alice. “Well, then, isn’t it as plain as anything that you are going out in this boat under no circumstances?” But Alice only began to whimper. “I promised Mamma,” she said, “that I should be home at five o'clock.” “Selfish!” said the Red Knight. “IT am not selfish,” cried Alice. “I prom- ised Mamma I’d come and I want to keep my promise.” “That's what I call selfish,” said the Red Knight; “giving somebody your prom- ise and wanting to keep it, too. I'd never be guilty of such conduct. It’s like giving somebody your piece of plum pudding and wanting to keep it at the same time.” “But a promise isn’t plum pudding,” said Alice. “Of course it isn’t,” said the Red Knight. “Plum pudding is much harder to uswal- low.”

Page 13

x a — a a C: March 28, 1912] The Nation 309 “Oh, you know well enough what I mean,” said Alice, quite out of patience. “It isn't the promise I want to keep; it’s what I promised about.” “Oh, in that case, we quite agree,” said the Red Knight. “If you give people 4 promise and keep something else, it’s all right.” And he began to row harder than ever. “When I went to school,” said the Red Knight, “I was particularly good at Riddles, Reverence, and Rithmetic.” “J’ye studied arithmetic in school and played riddles after school,” said Alice, “but I don’t know what you mean by Reverence.” “I’m surprised,” said the Red Knight. “Reverence means doing honor to great men. For instance, when I look at myself and am reminded of Abraham Lincoln, George Washington, Napoleon, Mark Twain, Ad- miral Peary, and Joan of Arc, that means reverence. But perhaps you'd rather have me ask you riddles?” “T think I should,” said Alice. “Very well. What’s the difference be- tween a Southern postmaster in 1908 and a Southern postmaster in 1912?” “I’m sure I don’t know,” said Alice; “What is it?” “IT give it up,” said the Red Knight. “What a queer way of asking riddles!” said Alice. “Not at all,” said the Red Knight, “What's the difference between taking a canal from Colombia and taking candy from a child?” “T never did understand politics,” said Alice. “What is it?” “I give it up,” said the Red Knight. “Oh, pshaw,” said Alice. “Please, do be sensible.” “I am sensible,” said the Red Knight. “Why ig George W. Perkins like the voice of the people?” “Well, why?” “I give it up,” said the Red Knight. “Oh, that’s too absurd for anything,” said Alice. “If you like to tease people, please find some one else to tease.” She walked away to one side, quite angry, and! began to play with the daisies in her new spring hat. The Red Knight sat down on the river’s edge and broke out crying. He wept so bitterly that Alice felt sorry for him. She came back to where he sat and said, “I’m awfully sorry. I didn’t mean to hurt your feelings.” But the Red Knight only went on weeping. “Please, do stop crying,” said Alice. “Take out your handkerchief and wipe your eyes; come now.” “T can’t,” said the Red Knight. “I had my handkerchief in my hat, and my hat is in the ring,” and he sobbed as if his heart would break. So Alice took out her own handkerchief and wiped his streaming eyes, but still he would not stop. So, to quiet him, she said, “But you said you were good at arithmetic.” “Oh, I am,” said the Red Knight, and his face grew quite radiant. “Have you ever figured out how many Governors have come | out for me?” “No,” said Alice. “Well,” said the Red Knight, “there’s the Governor of New Hampshire, and the Gov- and the Governor of New Hampshire, that . makes-———” | | “But you counted the Governor of New | Hampshire,” said Alice. “Only once,” said the Red Knight. “Peo- | ple say that the Governor of New Hamp- | shire is of two minds about me—that means | twice, doesn’t it?” “Does it?” said Alice. “Of course, it does,” said the Red Knight. “Then there is Kansas, which makes five, | and Nebraska, which makes eleven, and California, which makes twenty-four, and New Mexico, which makes thirty-seven out of a total of forty-eight Governors.” “I don’t see how you figure that out at all,” said Alice. “I do it by long addition,” said the Red Knight. —_—— ARE THE ENGLISH CRITICAL?—II, V. Thus far in my comparison of Eng- lish criticism with that of other coun- tries, especially France, I have been try- ing to show that it has suffered from the superabundance of certain virtues— imaginative fervor, moral earnestness, geniality, and humor. We still have to consider how far it has been affected by certain positive deficiencies in the Eng- lish. In the first place, they would seem, as compared with the French, to lack taste (using the word in a somewhat literal sense). In this sense, taste, as Voltaire says, is a “prompt discern- ment like that of the tongue or palate, and which like it anticipates reflection.” The taste of the critic should be the lit- erary equivalent of that of the connois- seurs in Sancho's story who were able to detect the flavor of iron and leather in the wine; their verdict being after- wards confirmed by the discovery of an old key with a leathern thong at the bottom of the hogshead. Sainte-Beuve, like Voltaire, was fond of insisting on this analogy between taste in the liter- ary and taste in the physical sense, and he adds that he had noted that doctrin- aires were nearly always indiscriminate eaters. M. Guizot, for example, would have eaten cardboard and never known the difference. Now, I believe that we may detect a certain coarseness in both the physical and the literary tastes of some of the great English critics. Dry- den confesses that he prefers Juvenal to Horace, and there is something about this preference that coincides with what we know about Dryden's taste in food— a taste that was hearty rather than deli- cate. Dr. Johnson piqued himself on culinary refinement and boasted that he could write a better cook-book than had ever been seen in England, but from | what Boswell and others tell us we should infer rather that he was a huge /and indifferent feeder. After all, the critic is simply a man | who knows a good book when he sees it, | ernor of West Virginia, that makes two; | whether the book was written yesterday |or a thousand years ago, and who, if 'the book is good, can also tell what is had to warn him to dcsist. Now we may | its class and degree of- goodness. Now, 'a gift of this kind must always in ‘some measure be intuitive. According ,to Professor Saintsbury, it is “beyond |}controversy” that “Boileau has left us not a single impartial and appreciative criticism of a single author, ancient or modern.” If this means that Boileau did not warm up to real excellence, it is palpably false, as the “Second Satire” to Moliére and the “Seventh Epistle” to Racine would suffice to prove. Boileau was not only capable of the “enthusias- tic appreciation” which, according to Professor Saintsbury, is the “highest function of criticism”; he was also capa- ble of that judgment which is in reality its highest function. He probably made fewer mistakes in his actual verdicts than did any other critic of whom we have record; and this not because he had a code of rules, but because he backed up the rules with an almost in- fallible literary intuition. Johnson had the same rules, but comparatively little of the intuition; and s0 he praises Blackmore's “Creation,” and calls “Lycidas” disgusting, and declares Field- ing a barren rascal and disparages Gray. We can at least understand Cow- per’s point of view when he writes to Unwin: “I am convinced, by the way, that he [Johnson] has no ear for poeti- cal numbers. Oh! I could thresh his old jacket till I made his pension jingle in his pocket!” The love of fine and artistic speech would almost seem with the French an inborn aptitude. I am not, to be sure, setting up any theory of racial fatality. The French may lose their taste; in- deed, there are signs of late that they are losing it; it is likewise possible that certain critical virtues that have in the past been somewhat rare among Englishmen may in the future become common. Still, the members of the French Academy, who, as we are told, spent three months examining critically one of Malherbe’s poems without get- ting beyond the first stanzas, seem to be the legitimate descendants of the an- cient Gauls, one of whose chief ambi- tions was, according to Cm@sar, to ex- press themselves discriminatingly (argute loqui). Possibly it is the keen and intuitive response of the Frenchman to the con- crete work of art that has kept him in spite of his logic and love of abstract reasoning from flying off like the Ger- man into the intense inane of esthetic theory. We are told that during his lust illness Boiledu set out to read one of Crébillon’s plays, but finally threw the book across the room exclaiming that the play was so bad that it was shortening his life. It is also related of Sainte-Beuve that during his last !1l- ness he got so excited in the course of jan argument with Gaston Boilssier as to the merits of Ovid that his physician }

Page 14

The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2439 310 be sure that neither Boileau nor Sainte- Beuve would have been greatly stirred by learning that some German professor had just written a series of volumes to prove, let us say, that beauty is a pro- cess of “infeeling.” VI. Mention has just been made of the I'rench love of logic. Though this has not led them into an excess of esthetic theorizing, it has given to their criticism method and coherency. In England we find distinguished individual critics, in France an almost symmetrical suc- cession of critical schools. There is a scrt of logical rhythm that runs through French criticism, just as there is a logi- cal rhythm that runs through the archi- and streets of Paris compared with the architecture and streets of London The French of course have often suffered from the excess of this their prime virtue of logical thorough- ness. John Adams's saying that man is a reasoning but not a reasonable animal, would seem to apply with special force to Frenchmen. The English are fond of comparing with this logicality of the French the superior merit of their own habit of muddling along. But the su- periority of the English to the French is a moral one. The English lack of clear apd logical thinking is a grave defect even from the purely practical point of view. However that may be, ideas, especially since about the middle of.the century, have been uncom- monly scarce in English as compared with French literature. In their stanchness and mental inflexibility the English have something that recalls the ancient Romans, whereas the in- tellectually versatile French have more in common with the Greeks, even though we should have to add with one of their own moralists that they are only Greeks in profile. Critics have at times been so numer- ous in France that they have had to fall to criticising one another like the sword of Hudibras which ate into itself, for lack Of somebody to hew and hack tecture eighteenth Taking the word in a broad sense and allowing for many individual exceptions, we may affirm, indeed, that the French have often suffered from an excess, the Finglish from a deficiency of criticism. For criticism with its tendency to dissolve everything and to call all things into question has very grave dangers, dangers of which the Athenian jury had a dumb inkling when it condemned one of the greatest representatives of the critical spirit, Socrates. The intellect is fatal to earnestness, says Emerson; Goethe has said still more wisely that everything that emancipates the intellect without giving us a corresponding self-mastery is pernicious. Many Frenchmen seem to are fools.” the French character does not measure ! up to the French mind. On the other hand, one not infrequently encounters in England men who are giants of char- acter, but who remain intellectually in- fantile. Goethe was not really inconsist- ent when he expressed great admiration for the Englishman and then said al- most in the same breath that the “Eng- lishman is properly speaking without intelligence” (a saying by the way that merely repeats the substance of Dryden's line: “Like true-born Britons who ne’er think at all’). The natural opposition between char- acter and intellect is pleasantly ex- pressed by Bagehot’s boast that in “real, . sound stupidity the English are unri- valled.” This saving stupidity, accord- ing to Emerson, masks and protects their perception as the curtain of the eagle’s eye. Burke, who could be on occasion one of the keenest of critics in his own field of political thought, shows a similar satisfaction in the intellectual imperviousness of the Englishman when he compares the radicals of his day to a few grasshoppers—‘the little, shriv- elled, meagre, hopping, though loud and troublesome, insects of the hour, who make the field ring with their importu- nate chink, whilst thousands of great cattle repose beneath the shadow of the English oak, chew the cud, and are silent.” This is to renew the error of Aristophanes, who refused to distin- guish between Socrates and the sophists and thought it possible to check the in- evitable advance of intellectual self-con- sciousness by falling back on a stolid Toryism. The natural working out of such a point of view is seen in the re- cent pathetic exhibition of Lord Hugh Cecil and his aristocratic friends with their resort to lung power, when it is so perfectly plain that only brain power will serve. Things have already reach- ed a pass where the only hope for the conservative is to oppose a first-rate criticism of society to the second and third-rate criticisms we are now getting from the Socialists and other radicals. Unfortunately, the present crisis is find- ing the Englishman intellectually un- prepared. His mental constitution has not been gradually hardened and in- ured to our modern contagions. The danger is that when he does catch ideas | they may prove, like measles for the South Sea Islander, a fatal disease. It! is not unusual for an Oxford student, | on breaking away from traditionalism, | to become an anarchist. VII. | Another positive limitation of the | Onglish that appears in their criticism | and is almost too familiar to insist) upon, is their insularity. “For anything I see,” said Dr. Johnson, “foreigners Something of this faith ern France. Evremond complained that Frenchmen were incapable of getting outside them- ‘selves, and even went to the point of calling a man a foreigner in his own country. Nowadays this is a trait that we should associate rather with the English. I remember, indeed, once ask- ing an English acquaintance at Paris whether he did not feel very foreign among so many people whose language he could neither speak nor understand. “No,” he replied, “but these people seem very foreign to me.” Both the insularity and intellectual imperviousness of the English are more or less bound up with the splendid con- vention of the English gentleman. The English gentleman is distrustful of thought, but prides himself, and rightly, on being great as a man of action. Scott, the best example of the gentleman in ‘English literature, happens to be also one of the greatest of English humor- ists. He can scarcely be said to display any interest in ideas except as they may be used to illustrate either indi- vidual or national humors, as we see, for example, in his treatment of the Covenanters. In striking contrast to the richness and variety of his Scottish and other humors is the monotony and colorlessness of his ladies and gentle- men, and that, as I conceive, is because his ladies and gentlemen are all gov- erned by the same convention. Scott shows too much Tory complacency; he is too unconscious of the undermining by the French Revolution of the whole social order upon which the convention rests. In his preface to the “Human Comedy” Balzac records his indebted- ness to Scott; but Balzac differs from Scott in no respect more than that his whole work is dominated by a logical ‘idea—the attempt, namely, to show the moral disintegration that has resulted in French society from the Revolution. His novels are really a caricature of the modern French, a sinister and lurid pic- ture of the fatal triumph of egoism in a society that has broken away from tra- ditional religious restraint. Balzac’s conception is, if not fundamentally false, at least very one-sided, though I note that M. Paul Bourget, himself a reactionary, to be sure, declares in a recent essay that Balzac has shown him- self a wonderful diagnostician of the ills that have actually fallen upon mod- The point I wish to make, however, is very similar to my previous point in comparing Addison and La Bruyére. Balzac is more intellectual and critical, Scott more genial and hu- morous. VIII. In my enumeration of the virtues and defects of the Englishman and their re- lation to literary criticism, I have failed ay yet to speak of what is perhaps the have more intellect than their character still survives in the average English-|master-instinct of the whole English- entities them to. As M. Faguet puts it, man. In the seventeenth century Saint-|speaking race—the instinct for practi-

Page 15

Tis ac March 28, 1912] The Nation cality. What logic and ideas the Eng- lish have had, they have put mainly in the service of utilitarianism and scien- tific positivism. One is sometimes in- clined to think that Bacon catching his last illness while stuffing a chicken with snow im an attempt to discover the principle of cold-storage is more typical of the English race than Shakespeare in the act of composing Hamlet. Stu- dents of comparative literature know that the foreign influence of Shake- speare, even his influence in Germany, is easily exaggerated. But wherever in the world we see smoking factory chim- neys looming on the horizon we have a tribute to the potency of the Baconian influence. The gap between this utili- tarian side of the English-speaking race and its imaginative side is too wide, jvst as the gap is too wide between Ox- ford and an English manufacturing town. The great representatives of the utilitarian and positivistic tradition— Bacon himself, Newton, Hobbes, Locke, Hume, Adam Smith, Bentham, Stuart Mill. Herbert Spencer, Darwin—have had ideas a-plenty and at times plenty of logic, but in matters artistic and literary have been little better than Philistines. It would be easy to run down the list from Newton, who could see in the finest statues only stone dolls, to Herbert Spencer, who went to Homer “to study superstitions,” but was so bored that he could not get beyond the sixth book; and finally to Darwin, who confessed at the end of his life he could see nothing in Shakespeare. The ultra-utilitarians are not only as completely lost for art and literature as the Puritans, but their point of view is far more catching. We see the waves of utilitarianism rising higher and higher every year in France and Ger- many, and even threatening to engulf the Gothic turrets of Oxford. It is doubtful whether in a world so com- pletely devoted to utility there will be any room for art and literature as these terms have been understood tradition- ally. Here again the right attitude is that of the Aristotelian. Practicality, the Aristotelian would admit, is one of the main virtues of the peoples of English descent, along with imaginative fervor, moral earnestness, geniality, and humor; but practicality ,ursued mechanically and one-sidedly may become a vice. And this utilitarian excess would seem to have been reached not only in England and America, but more or less in the whole Occidental world. IX. It would carry.me quite beyond the limits of the present subject to discuss the means by which we may hope to recover sound literary standards and guard against the present drift towards a scientific and industrial materialism. One of the most obvious needs is that we should revive in ourselves the sense o. literary tradition. To this end it is urgent, if I may venture to repeat what I have said elsewhere, that students and teachers of English and other modern literatures should coéperate cordially with the representatives of the ancient humanities instead of tending to ally themselves as now with the utilitarians. But though we need to revive our sense of tradition we cannot afford to be mere traditionalists, lest we suffer from that lack of ideas which isthe chief lack T have noted in English, and I may add in American, criticism. Our holding of tradition must be in the highest degree critical; that is, it must involve a con- stant process of hard and clear think- ing, a constant adjustment, in other words, of the experience of the past to the changing needs of the present. Who are to be our models for this right critical interpretation of the pust? They are curiously hard to find in the nineteenth century, in spite of the fact that it is commoniy supposed to be the most historical of centuries. There pre vailed during this period two main atti- tudes towards the past which may be de- fined, respectively, as the scientific and the romantic. The man with the sclen- tific attitude is chiefly concerned with investigating and establishing the facts of the past. The romanticist, for his part, revels in the mere picturesqueness of the facts or else takes refuge in the past from the present, uses it, as Taine would say, to create for himself an alibi. But the past should be regarded primarily neither as a laboratory for re- search nor as a bower of dreams, but as a school of experience. Where, then, is the man who has been fully initiated into tradition, and at the same time knows how to bring it to bear upou the present? Even Sainte-Beuve does) not fully satisfy us here. He was one of the victims of that naturalistic fa- talism that has lain like a blight upon the human spirit for the past fifty years or more. “Man,” he says, “has the illu- sion of liberty.” What is the use of knowing the past if one is not free to profit by the knowledge? We think by contrast of Goethe (whom Sainte-Beuve himself calls the king of critics), and of Goethe’s saying that the chief benefit one may derive from a total study of his work is a certain sentiment of inner freedom. Goethe, indeed, comes nearer than any other modern to what we are seek-| ing; not the romantic or scientific Goethe, it should be added, but the hu- manistic Goethe, who is revealed in the conversations with Eckermann and oth- ers, and in the critical utterances of his later years. For Goethe, after having found in “Faust” the happiest formule for the two main forces that were to dominate the nineteenth century—scien- tific positivism (Im Anfang war die Tat) and Rousseaulstic romanticism (Gefihl ist alles)—lived long enough 311 to repudiate the romanticism, and, while holding fast to the science, to insist that it should keep in its proper place. As an actual practitioner of the art of crit- icism, he seems to me inferior to the best of the Frenchmen; but as an in- itiator into the critical habit of mind he is incomparable. He has assim- ilated not merely tradition, but all tra- ditions, and that without ceasing to be a modern of moderns. As Sainte-Beuve puts it, he keeps watch for every new sail on the horizon, but from the height of a Sunium. He would use the larger background and perspective to round out and support his individual insight and so make of the present what it should be—not the servile imitation, nor again the blank denial of the past, but its creative continuation. “To the errors and aberrations of the hour,” he says, “we must oppose the masses of universal history.” He would have us cease theorizing about the absolute and learn to recognize it in its actual mani- festations. This particular form of the humanistic art ‘of seeing the One in the Many would seem especially appropriate to an age like ours that differs above all from other ages, Greek and Roman antiquity, for example, in having at its command a vaster body of verified hu- man experience. Goethe can, therefore, be of more help than any English or French critic in solving one of our most pressing problems: that of finding stan- dards to oppose to the scientific and utilitarian excess, on the one hand, and, on the other, to the excess of romantic impressionism. In his general History Professor Saintsbury says that Goethe's high standing as a critic is a “‘supersti- tion, now somewhat stale”; which sug- gests that we might begin our reaction against romantic impressionism by re- acting against Professor Saintsbury. His own reputation as a critic may turn out to be the real superstition. That this reputation should be as great as it is, is perhaps in itself a proof that the Eng- lish are not critical. IRVING BABBITT. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. A new edition, condensed and somewhat revised, of Arundell Esdaile’s “Bibliography of George Meredith” is printed at the end of Vol. XXVII of the Memorial Edition of his works, recently published. Though called a “bibliography” on the title-page, it is more correctly described as a “chrono- logical list” in the head lines. Only much abbreviated titles are given, and no colla- tions whatever. A good bibliography of Meredith is a desideratum. As there is a strong interest at present in the first edij- tions of Meredith among collectors, the fol- lowing bibliographical notes may be of in- terest. In the “Poems” (London, 1851), Meredith’s first published volume, there should be found a slip of errata, showing four er- rors. Below the heading “Errata” is a

Page 16

312 short rule with a diamond-shaped expansion the At some time this slip was reprinted, the later form having a straight rule, a trifle shorter than the original. The space between the rule and the first line of text less in the reprint than in the genuine slip. Harry E. Widener owns an important copy of the book, the errata slip of which contains an additional correc- tion Meredith's autograph. This seems to fix the priority of the with the diamond-shaped expansion in the rule, rhere editions of Mere- dith’s “Poems and Ly! printed in bes bought first edition in centre is somewhat in variety two distinct of of heretofore, are verse, Earth,” volume Joy have third of which 1 sold indiscriminately tual first edition was printed by R & Taylor, and has their imprint vi. The second edition, page for page, imprint of R. & R. Clark, Edin- copies of this volume contain slip, but ap- the first of the errors noted, “Re- “Revolt,” in the last line of p. x, has been corrected. The presence of this to indicate the earlier issue. e copies contain a cancelled leaf for 63, 64, pasted on the stub of the origi- leaf, which has been Some also, contain at the end a Catalogue dated “April, variations in the n 1583, as “ons errata in most copies, itly, tl” for seems error? removed. emillan’s publications, There are also slight » binding. The second edition, printed by R. & R. though an entire resetting, contains errors indicated in the errata p of the first edition. The most impor- tant textual difference between the two are the improved titles of three of the sonnets. are corrected to read as follows: P. Spirit of Shakespeare: Con- tinued 176, “Camelus Saltat: Con- tinued”: p. 150, “My Theme: Continued.” In the first edition printed by Clay, the title of each of these three sonnets is merely “Con- (iark most of the sl These 162, “The p tinued.” Almost all coples of “A Reading of Life” (1901) contain two cancelled leaves, pp. 65-68, printed as a separate sheet and past- ed on the stub of one of the original leaves which have been removed. We have never seen a copy containing the originals. At least three “separates,” or early pulls, from the types of poems contributed by Meredith to magazines have been preserved are Mother to erso blank Thes« one Babe.” \ leaflet Apparently printed from of the Jliluatvuted Maga October, It the William Meredith, which was when the In the magazine, (1.) pag the English types rine for 1886 is without illustration by printed the appeared in the magazine also, there was a page-number “25” besides or Barrie page poem printing on the reverse of the leaf rhe Appeasement of pages fi}, 2, 3 centre, and from Demeter.’ and 4, the the without headlines Apparently printed the types as set for Macmillan’s Magazine for September, 1887 In the it is paged 374 to 377, and occuples three leaves, there being other printing on pages 373 and There are head-lines (2.) “Outside the Crowd.” A leaflet, one page, verso blank Printed, from the types of the National Review for (2.) Four page numbered numbers in magazine also 378 September, published The Nation ing on the reverse, also the page-numbers “25” and “26.” These cannot, strictly speaking, be called proof-sheets, but are pulls from the types after corrections had been made. The private, unauthorized, first edition of “Jump to Glory Jane,” of which fifty copies were printed in 1889 as a little pamphlet ot sixteen pages, the last blank, was not mentioned in the first edition of Esdaile’s “Bibliography,” but is included in the “Chronological List.” Another private reprint, “Twenty Poems by George Meredith,” being a collection of contributed by him to Household Words between 1850 and 1856, issued in an edition of twenty-five copies only, in 1909, is not noted by Esdaile. These poems, when appeared in Household Words, were unsigned, but their authenticity is proved by the office record of the magazine. Two other poems pub:ished in the same magazine in 1850 were, with some alterations, re- printed by Meredith himself in his first vol- ume, published the next year, 1851. “George Meredith and the Monthly Ob- server” is the title of an essay by Maurice Buxton Forman, of which twenty-one copies were printed privately in London last year, and which will interest Meredith collectors. The Monthly Observer was a manuscript magazine, of which Meredith was one of the editors and contributors, and which con- tains his earliest literary works known to be extant. Only five numbers are known, Nos. 11, 13, 14, 15, and 16, for January, March, April, May, and June, 1849. These were sold at Sotheby's about a year ago. L. 8. LIVINGSTON. pieces they -| true? Correspondence MR. ROOSEVELT AND THE RECALL. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The comments on Mr. Roosevelt's address before the Ohio Constitutional Con- vention have varied as much perhaps as the popular idea of how Constitutions should be construed will vary. While there is much |that is fundamentally moral and well said jin apparently, | 1896, where the poem was first/tion to fit them. In the magazine there was print-!parts of a Constitution might become anti-'have on remaining judges, but the power in the address, there are parts which I think, and even more strongly feel, are unsound. We should scrutinize rigidly those doctrines which appear the welfare of the masses when they come from oné who de- the masses for his to touch pends preéminently on following Mr. understand it, is essentially this: that the people have, by their Constitution, expressed, or attempt- ed to express, their will as the funda- mental which they desire to govern their servants, the judges, are selected interpret the fundamental law so that it will be in accord with the will of the As conditions change the will of the change, and the inter- preters who are to apply the Constitution as the touchstone are to do so in a manner to fit actual conditions of life at the time the construction is called for. Tiere should be, the main, no quarrel with this view, provided it were admitted that conditions might so change as to make it impossible to interpret even the most pliable Constitu- In other words, certain Roosevelt's position, as I to law them; that to people people may | quated. Mr. Roosevelt would not advocate a construction directly opposed to every ‘conceivable meaning of the words of the Constitution or a resort to fiction simply ‘to make a highly favored law constitutional. In such cases there would be reason for amendment. ® But Mr. Roosevelt takes the further po- | sition that the final decision as to the con- struction of the Constitution should rest with the people. This view presupposes a higher order of intelligence and greater popular grasp of fundamentals than even the people of Edward Bellamy’s Utopia pos- sessed. It is a flattering homage to the masses by a man who depends on those masses for the support of his ideas. To hold that their judgment could be other than sound would be self-condemnatory on his part. This plan, if adopted, would nullify one of the primary purposes of Constitutions. | State Constitutions are meant to provide |a sufficient bulwark against the momentary impulses of the people, and to postpone ac- jtion, by making it difficult, in order to “ascertain whether the ills suffered are réal- ly permanent and due to the supposed |causes. Carried to its logical conclusion, it |might be argued that where the. people, through their agents, the legislators, pass a | favored law, they at once express their de- jcision as to the meaning they want at- |tached to their Constitution, and that it | would be the duty of the judge to con- strue the Constitution so as to conform to |that law. This assumes that the constru- ing judge knows the prevailing opinion in |regard to that law. And is the converse If a judge is of the opinion that the law will not promote the ends of:jus- . tice, or, rather, if he is of the opinion that the people think it would not promote justice, would it be correct for him to in- terpret the Constitution in all cases so as to | invalidate the law? . Mr. Roosevelt quotes Lincoln: “With Lin- coln, I hold that this country, with its institutions, belongs to the people who in- habit it. Whenever they shall grow weary of the existing government, they can ex- ercise their constitutional right to amend.” How different is this statement of Lin- coln’s from advocating that the final tri- bunal for the construction of the Consti- tution should be the people themselves. Lin- ;coln was too sound a thinker and endowed with too high an order of practical judg- ment to advocate such a doctrine. He be- | lieved that the power of government resided jn the people. He also knew that the peo- Iple, by their own free will, and by means lof this very power, placed limitations on the ease with which they could use their power and thus prescribed a constitutional method of amending. There is merit in the statement that a \judge who has outgrown his usefulness should no longer remain in office. There is merit in the statement that there should be some method of retiring judges who have become so steeped in the, technical dead let- |ter of the law that by their decisions they |thwart all reasonable reform. But in such a matter the method is everything. The plan of recall as applied to the judiciary presents grave doubts. It is not so much the effect which the actual recall of a judge or which the power of recall will

Page 17

March 28, 1912] The Nation 313 of threat which such an institution fur- nishes. Unserupulous attorneys with a po- litical backing may make use of it covert- ly and indirectly to influence decisions, es- pecially when the question before the court has a political or quasi-political tinge. And it must be remembered that the re- call is a measure which is likely to be abused more and more as its ease of use- fulness is better understood. More than most measures, its good effects will teach the way to misuse. JaMeEs H. WOLFE. Salt Lake City, Utah, March 15. PUBLIC SCHOOLS AND THE RECALL. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The public elementary schools of this country are often blamed for the faults and ignorance of the ordinary citi- zen, and it is comforting, therefore, to come across a good piece of work that may fair- ly be credited to the American schoolmaster. It is an easy thing to teach and not dif- ficult for the pupil to understand that in theory, at least, the laws in the United States are made by the Legislature, but are interpreted and applied by the judici- ary. Given this simple elementary fact, well hammered into the youngster’s head, to- gether with the subsidiary fact that a judge who respects his oath of office must decide strictly according to laws laid down for) him by another branch of the Government over which he has no control, the con-| clusion is inevitable that the remedy for | miscarriage of justice, in the absence of moral obliquity of the court, is to be sought in reforming the law, and not in assailing the judge. Indeed, it should seem as if the American people were beginning to see that a judge who should distort and nullify a law that seemed to him unjust, would usurp functions foreign to his office, and, worse than that, set a precedent that would upset all established commercial, moral, and industrial relations of society. There are, of course, many other aspects | of the case against the recall of judges, but they all depend on the fundamental fact that, with us, the laws are not made by the courts that interpret and apply them. That this simple and single fact has been well drilled into the heads of the-present | generation is to the credit of the American schoolmaster, E. L, C. MORSE. Chicago, March 20. | THE NERVOUS DEBILITY OF JAPANESE ART. condition of the Japanese life at present? So it is. My mind recalls this moment a certain clever English critic, who said it was life that imitated art; but here it is the art following after the life of modern Japan, vain, shallow, imitative, and thoughtless, which makes us pessimistic. The best possible course art can follow in the time of its nervous debility might be that of imitation; I know, of course, there is a moment even for imitation, when it almost becomes creation. The question is how you imitate. And what does the Ja- panese art imitate? What it imitates is the Western art as the life here coples the civilization beyond the seas. When it tells something, I thank God, it is from its sad failure; indeed, the present Japanese art is a lost art, since it explains noth- ing, alas, unlike the old art of idealistic | exaltation, but the general condition of life. It is cast down from its high pedestal. I do not know exactly what simplicity means, when the word is used in connec- tion with our old art; however, it is true we see a peculiar unity in it, which was | cherished under the influence of India and China, and always helped to a classification | and analysis of the means through which the artists worked. And the poverty of sub- jects was a strength for them; they valued | workmanship, or the right use of material, rather than the material itself; instead of style and design, the intellect and atmos- phere. They thought the means to be the only path to Heaven. But it was before the Western art had invaded Japan; that art told them of the end of art, and laugh- |}ed at the indecision of msthetic judgment and uncertainty of realism of Japanese art. It said: “It is true that you have some scent, but it is already faded; you have refinement, but it is not quite true to nature and too far away.” Indeed, it is almost sad to see the artists troubled by the Western influence which they accepted, in spite of themselves; I can see in the present exhibition or any other exhibition that many of them have long ago lost their faith by spiritual calamity, and it is sel- dom to see them able to readjust their own minds under such a mingled tempest of Oriental and Occidental. Is it not, after all, merely a waste of energy? And how true it is with all the other phenomena of the present life, their Oriental retreat and Occidental rush. Again here are so many pictures which are the works of workmen bored, after the Western fashion, sometimes offensive, | often overstrenuous, their personal vanity | being too clear, as well as the loss of the |} humanity and love that always went with To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: When I say that I received almost | no impression from the annual Government Exhibition of Japanese Art, opened last November in Uyeno Park, nor, let me add, } fzom any other exhibition I have seen in the last five or six years, I have a sort of same feeling with the tired month of May when the season, in fact, having no strength | left from the last glory of bloom (what | a glorious old Japanese art!), still vainly | attempts to look ambitious. Although it) may sound unsympathetic, I must declare | that the present Japanese art, speaking of | it as a whole, with no reference to separate | works or individual artists, suffers savaer nervous debility. Now, is it not the exact | the better old art. You do not know what bad effect Millet, Corot, and others had up- on the artists who thought their genre pictures quite adoptable; but they did not know, as it seems to me, that the real realism was not a matter of mere external aspect. It was the literature, I mean the novels, first, that cast away offhand the old ideals earned through sacrifice and pain, and even laughed wildly with De Maupassant and other “Madmen” as if they thought nakedness was the happiest thing they had found out; well, that is not en- tirely bad as a protest or temporary change. When I say that the present Japanese art, too, is moved by such a tendency, I do not mean that it makes a kotow before the shrine of realism, but that it bas sadly strayed from subjectivity, the only one ci- tadel where the old Japanese art rose and fell; I wonder if it is not paying a too tremendous price only to gain a little ob- jectivity of the West. This morning I was informed by the press that the four Government Exhibition jurors of the old Japanese school had suddenly resigned, saying that their opinions and desire to preserve tle time-honored art intact had been always insulted, Jeered, and laughed at by the other jurors of the West ern imitation, who always outnumbered them. The resigning jurors published their proclamation. to the effect that the real Japanese art was dying. I murmured to myself: “This is the autumn of life and the country when the leaves and art are | falling.” Our Japanese life, indeed, suffers from nervous debility as a result of the whole sale Western invasion, under which we have become spiritual gypsies, Josing our own | homes. YONE Noat | Kamakura, Japan, February 0 | — SASHOK AND SASHKA. |TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: I have supposed these many years | that in Russian the name Sashok was a pet | abbreviation for Alexander, and that Sashka was the corresponding girl’s name. Cer | tainly the little Russian boy who lived in |the house with me, in Geneva, was invari ;ably called Sashok by his elder brother j}and by his tutor. And Rembrandt's famous |painting, in the Dresden gallery, of him | self, and his wife sitting on his knee and | drinking a glass of champagne, is commonly | known among Germans as Die Sashka. But }now it seems that in Andreiev's new novel | Soon to appear under the title “Sashka | Zigulev,” the titular hero is the son of an |old general. Will not some one of your Slavic scholars enlighten me? M. New York, March 21 THE HIGH SCHOOL TEACHER OF ENGLISH. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In the Nation of February 29th, Professor Bellows cleverly explains that “Hamlet” and Dr. Johnson wiil not suffer if high school students cease to write about them. This is only too true, but it is just as true that the student, as well as the high school he represents, wil] suffer when he takes his college entrance examination if he cannot write “a perfectly meaning- less little essay on ‘Dr. Johnson and his Club’ or ‘Was Hamlet Mad?’” The high | school teacher, however, has at least one | legitimate motive for assigning theme top j}ies which colleges force upon us and then ridicule. In sheer self-defence, the teacher of English, haunted by visions of ungraded themes and test papers, must combine the study of the classics and the writing of themes in a vain attempt to kill two spar rows with one wax bullet We devote the first two years to a mas- tery of the principles of rhetoric with a slight mixture of philology; in the third and fourth years, we survey the history of American and English literature. In ad- dition each year we study intensively in class six classics and read four others at

Page 18

314 me We also require at least one theme week, generally based upon the classics ead. You can readily see that the student eting the college entrance require- ents with a vengeance. The teacher of English is apparently the factotum of the school. Literary societies, school publications,andthe coach- ing of debating teams come as dessert after the de in the form of five classes each day. in English are er small and never select. Students are required to take it, and the teacher is re- quired to get them through it. The high school teacher may not be so independent college professor, and of necessity onsiderations other than the student's abil- ity enter into his being “passed.” We pol- with the same tools, if not same fervor, We polish the dia- after four years we send him a finished pebble. college trains the teacher of Eng- prescribes what he is to teach, and is horrified at the result. A similar attitude is maintained by the high school] towards the grade teacher, who defiantly places the This would be amus- The student general resistance Classes prece nev is the ish the pebble the and with mond to the The lish college blame upon heredity. ing were it not so tragic. blames everything or nothing; the student) likewise pays the fiddler. The high school teacher as well as the college professor the farcical side of the teaching of and just as earnestly seeks relief J. W. IRWIN, Central High School, Muskogee, Okla., March 18 se68 English Literature CARDINAL NEWMAN, of John Henry Cardinal New- Based on His Private Journals and Correspondence. By Wilfrid Ward. 2 vols. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $9 net. A biography of the great which gives only a single chapter to the events of his life down to and including his conversion, and devotes the remain- der of two bulky volumes to his experi- ences in the Roman Church, might seem to resemble “Hamlet” with the prince left out. For this outrageous dispropor- tion Mr. Ward is not altogether respon- sible. The story of the early years and conversion has already been related by Newman himeelf in the “Apologia,” and this has been supplemented by the two volumes of his letters edited by his sis- ter-iIn-law, Miss Mozley. It was Newman's own desire that nothing should be add- ed to those records by his present offi- clal blographer, Mr. Ward’s work, there- | fore, should properly be read, not as a complete and independent memoir, but as a continuation of Miss Mozley's rec- We are bound to say, however, even with this reservation, the volumes err somewhat in pro- portion. Newman was seldom at his best as a letter-writer, and a good deal of the correspondence now printed is, in our judgment, neither necessary to an understanding of Newman's» character | The Life man convert ord that present nor entertaining in itself. Much also of | was something in Newman's conversion The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2439 his life after 1845 was passed amid pet-! of personal defection, a betrayal of the ty, thwarting circumstances; and the’ will, and, despite the fact that his great- tale of these eccelesiastical intrigues | est work is just the “Apologia” for his will seem to the taste of most readers; change, he was debarred by his surren- somewhat too finely-spun. For the rest,| der from taking the supreme place as Mr. Ward's difficult task has been admir-| an English author or as a religious ably and courageously carrfed through. | leader which belonged to him by birth When he himself takes the pen in hand | right. his narrative and characterization are| And this is the lesson we read in Mr. clear, succinct, and interesting. His| Ward’s narrative of the years from the balance of judgment, however it may ap-/ conversion to the end. It was as if the pear to those more concerned in the/convert, by altering his direction, had questions at issue, seems to the present/ suddenly brought himself face to face reviewer a notable achievement. His’! with a stone wall. To every plan he tact is particularly in evidence when he| broached for new activity came the be- deals with such delicate matters as the | numbing reply, Non possumus, if it was negotiations at Rome over the Cardinal-| not Non possis. He was, as it were, ate; evidently he feels something slip-| hemmed in, barked at by opposition on pery and unfair in the acts of Manning| every side, beaten down by exasperat- and Talbot, but at the critical point he|ing distrust and envy. Mr. Ward tells merely quotes documents without com-| with valiant honesty all the plans of mitting himself on the question of ve-| the convert that were balked in one way racity. On the other hand, though his|or another. The difficulties that beset work as a whole is distinctly a vindica-| him as editor, as rector of the Irish tion of Newman, he by no means at- | Catholic University, and as promoter of tempts to dissimulate the weaker sides/| a propaganda in Oxford to influence the of the Cardinal’s own character. Per- | intellectual life of England, are typical haps we can best express our opinion of | of his career. In the end, when his ac- the writer’s honesty by saying that we tive years were past and he could no know of no book composed by a Cath-| jonger disturb those in authority, he olic which is more likely to deter sym-| received due recognition in the Cardin- pathizers with the church from entering | alate, and his closing days were, we the bondage of Rome. like to believe, crowned with a great At the close of the chapter which in-| peace. It is true also that more than cludes the conversion Mr. Ward quotes | once in his bitter years, with a tone of the beautiful words of Principal Shairp on the effect of what seemed to Angli- cans an act of apostasy: How vividly comes back the remembrance of the aching blank, the awful pause, which fell on Oxford when that voice had ceased, | knew that we should hear it no more. It was as when, to one kneeling by night, in the silence of some vast cathedral, the great bell tolling solemnly overhead has suddenly gone still. To many, no doubt, the pause was not of long continuance, Soon they began to look this way and that for new teachers, and to rush vehemently to the opposite extremes of thought. But there were those who could not so lightly forget. All the more these withdrew into them- selves. On Sunday forenoons and evenings, in the retirement of their rooms, the print- ed words of those marvellous sermons would thrill them till they wept “abundant and most sweet tears.”” Since then many voices of powerful teachers they may have heard, but none that ever penetrated the soul like his. and we With no desire to intrude into the de- conviction it would be dishonorable to question, he repudiated the suggestion of regret over his move. In his saddest moment he could write—ez animo, as he said—“that Protestantism is the drear- iest of possible religions.” He could distinguish clearly between the church and its rulers: To-day is the 20th anniversary of my setting up the Oratory in England, and every year I have more to thank God for, and more cause to rejoice that He helped me over so great a crisis—Since A.B. obliges me to say it, this I cannot omit to say:—I have found in the Catholic Church abundance of courtesy, but very little sym- pathy, among persons in high place, except a few—but there is a depth and a power in the Catholic religion, a fulness of satis- faction in its creed, its theology, its rites, its sacraments, its discipline, a freedom yet a support also, before which the neglect or the misapprehension about oneself on the part of individual living persons, how- ever exalted, is as so much dust, when weighed in the balance. This is the true bate between Anglican and Roman, with | secret of the Church’s strength, the prin- interest centred rather upon the purely | °!Ple of its indefectibility, and the bond of human aspect of the act, one may well | its indissoluble unity. It is the earnest feel, even to-day, something of that and the beginning of the repose of heaven. deep chagrin which Principal Shairp| Yet it is true nevertheless that he re- and Matthew Arnold and other contem-| sented keenly and sometimes denounced poraries expressed. Not for Oxford con- | sharply not only the thwarting of his troversialists alone, but for all who | personal ambitions, but also the limita- draw thelr spiritual sustenance from | tions imposed upon his intellectual and English literature, that event was, if not | spiritual mission. He who felt himself the silencing, at least the muffling, of a| born to be a leader of his people found magic voice; say what one will, there| himself suddenly thrust into ignoble ob-

Page 19

March 28, 1912] The Nation 315 security. To his beloved Ambrose St. John he wrote, in 1857: “To the rising generation, to the sons of those who knew me, or read what I wrote fifteen or twenty years ago, I am a mere page of history. It was at Oxford, and by my Parochial sermons, that I had influence—all that is past.” And three years later, in the intimacy of his diary, he could exclaim: “O my God, I seem to have wasted these years that I have been a Catholic. What I wrote as a Protestant has had far greater pow- er, force, meaning, success than my Catholic works, and this troubles me a great deal.” It is not strange that his inner vision was at times perturbed, his faith almost touched. “As years go on,” he records in his diary, “I have less sen- sible devotion and inward life.” He even notes a change in his physical ex- pression: “Till the affair of No. 90 and my going to Littlemore, I had my mouth half open, and commonly a smile on my face—and from that time onwards my mouth has been closed and contracted, and the muscles are so set now, that I cannot but look grave and forbidding.” Inevitably as this feeling of failure and | loneliness deepened, he contrasted the | poverty of the present with the actual power and richer promise of his Oxford career. There is a pathetic letter writ- ten in 1863 to Keble, who had begun the Oxford movement with him, or even be- fore him, but had drawn back at the edge of the precipice—a letter whose closing words are, as it were, the reve- lation of a great and hidden tragedy: I have said all this, knowing it will in- terest you. Never have I doubted for one moment your affection for me, never have I been hurt at your silence. I interpreted it easily—it was not the silence of others. It was not the silence of men, nor the for- getfulness of men, who can recollect about me and talk about me enough, when there is something to be said to my disparage- ment. You are always with me a thought of reverence and love, and there is nothing I love better than you, and Isaac, and Cope- jand, and many others I could name, ex- cept Him Whom I ought to love best of all and supremely. May He Himself, Who is the over-abundant compensation for all losses, give me His own Presence, and then I shall want nothing and desiderate nothing, but none but He can make up for the loss of those old familiar faces which haunt me continually. It would be easy to exaggerate, possi- bly the tone of Mr. Ward's narrative tempts one to exaggerate, the sadder -aspect of Newman’s life in the Catholic Church. It must not be forgotten that his “Apologia,” which contains some of the most beautiful religious writing of the age, his “Idea of a University,” and other works which will not be forgotten, were written after his conversion. But we repeat that the more deeply one con- siders his career, the more thoroughly is one convinced that the act of 1845 was ing to an authority which promised to allay the anguish of his intellect he rejected the great mission of the imag- ination that he might have fulfilled. For at bottom it was as a poet of the mystic imagination, and not as a logician or theologian, that he affected the men of his generation, and might have affected them more profoundly and permanently had he remained true to himself. The mere physical change from the glories and haunting traditions of the colleges of Oxford to the blank and utter new- ness of the Oratory at Edgbaston took away one of the props of his imagina- tion. The feeling that he no longer be- longed to the faith of the great body of his countrymen, but was regarded by them, whether rightly or wrongly, as one of a sect, deprived him of that sup- port of sympathy which was necessary to the full unfolding of his genius. Newman, as we have seen, speaks of the contraction of his features under the stress of his new life. The word, to one who examines his later portraits, does not seem quite precise; the marks of struggle are visible enough, but signs of contraction, in the sense of harden- ing or strengthening, we do not see. The mouth is strong, but the lines are a lit- | tle relaxed; the eyes are veiled and look | wistfully beyond what is immediately before them to some visionary hope; the brow is high and wrinkled transversely from the perplexity of an inner conflict. Something has gone out of this face, the contact with individual facts has been broken, and in its place has come the sweetness of self-surrender, the sub- missive pride of one who has given up much that he may find all—if haply he has found. This, in the end, must be our reserva- tion in the praise due to Newman's beau- tiful life, that he stopped short of that purest faith which demands no revela- tion and is dependent on no logic, but is content within itself. It is written: “Blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed.” He was not strong enough to hold fast to the actual facts of life and to discern his vision of peace quite apart from their illusory sphere, but found it necessary to surren- der the discordance of experience for a divine law within them. There is a sen- tence in a letter of Cardinal Wiseman | which comes naturally to memory when one thinks of the agony through which the later prelate was to pass. Speaking of his own struggle as a young man in Rome, Wiseman wrote: I was fighting with subtle thoughts and venomous suggestions of a fiendlike infi- | delity which I durst not confide to any | one, for there was no one that could have | sympathized with me. This lasted for | years; but it made me study and think, to ‘conquer the plague—for I can hardly call | | it danger—both for myself and for others. | |, . . But during the actual struggle the! , | | simple submission of faith is the only rem- | ed at the time like temptations against any other virtue—put away. There is the quick of the matter: thoughts against faith must be treated at the time like temptations against any other virtue—put away. The sentiment, it must be admitted, recalls a little the original metaphor of Hobbes: “For it is with the mysteries of our religion as with wholesome pills for the sick, which, swallowed whole, have the virtue to cure, but, chewed, are for the most part cast up again without effect.” The same idea occ ars over and over again in New- man’s writings, is, in fact, the very basis of his logical system. In an era which assailed him with unanswerable doubts he could not lift his faith to those serene certainties which need no con- firmation of the reason and from which his imagination might draw the sub- stance of healing visions for his pee- ple. He was not strong enough to a cept skepticism and rise above it; in identifying dogma and faith he, the man of perhaps the finest religious nature of the century, failed his country at her hour of greatest need. CURRENT FICTION. Odd Numbers. By Sewell Ford. New York: Edward J. Clode. “Most of us are so shy of lettin’ go of any sentiments that can't be had on a rubber stamp that it takes a mighty small twist to put a person in the queer class.” This remark, as its author, Shorty McCabe, might say, makes one think of John Stuart Mill's line of talk, though it’s not exactly in his lingo. “Shorty,” the narrator of these tales, as a philosopher recalls not only Mill, but Mr. Dooley; as a story-teller he owes something to O. Henry. He is an ex- pugilist of wide observation and experi- ence who conducts a Physical Culture Studio on Forty-second Street. He is especially interested in “odd numbers,” that is to say, persons in the queer class, and he describes a motley and en- tertaining group of them. The formula on which most of the stories are con- structed is simple. Begin with a bit of conversation or moralizing, not neces- sarily relevant, but calculated to rouse curiosity; then introduce your “odd number,” who, though odd, usually rep- resents some tolerably familiar type; old-fashioned grandmother or aunt from the country, imaginative and impecuni- ous promoter, mental-healing crank, or girl from the backwoods who has a lit- tle money and means to “take in” New York. Describe the queer one briskly, |and then let him do something which is not only queer, but altogether aside from his normal line of queerness; or else let him succeed contrary to all prob- ability in his simple and child-like plan. On this theme a good many variations something of a gran rifiuto; in succumb-| e4y. Thoughts against faith must be treat-| are possible; but the stories owe their ee a ed

Page 20

“816 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2439 interest not so much to formula or|in time prevails over the extraordinary variations as to diction. a large slang vocabulary with consider- | able aptness and freshness. The New York: Brentano’s, The audacious vagabond has had many abler apologists than the present writer. Indeed, a desire to emulate the successful performances of Mr. Farnol et al. would seem to have aspirant’s sole qualification. Certainly his tale is without any saving grace of imagination or of diction. For plot, one clever idea suffices. Thanks to the nightly candle and the unlocked win- dow, which for twenty years have in- vited the return of Sir Crispin Vickery’s long-lost son, two hungry tramps obtain access to a comfortable London estab- One of them is mistaken for prodigal, and welcomed ac- cordingly. By this point, unfortunately, the author has quite exhausted his in- genuity. There is not the slightest fla- vor of adventure about any of the ensu- incidents. No more successful is characterization. A highly disagree- this Hilary Tolfrey mere impudent windbag. His Perkins, a nondescript whose gutter slang is not even amusing. Less grotesque but even wooden are the martinet Sir Crispin, his downtrodden maiden sister, their pretty young niece, her youthful lover, and the faithful family servant— the stocklest of stock characters, one and all. lishment. the overdue ing the able impostor is Kite, a henchman, is adult waif, Way of an Eagle. By E. M. Dell. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. The heroine is placed in the embar- rassing position of owing her life to a who inspires her with much the same sentiments that young rabbit might entertain towards a hovering bird of prey. It is the immense difficulty of habituating her to his presence that chiefly retards the courtship. Other peo- ple found him charming, in spite of his monkey-like agility and leanness, his wrinkled face, his claw-like hands, his sunken but flercely gleaming eyes, “like the eyes of an eagle.” But the fastidious fair one viewed this phys- jeal make-up with uncontrollable repug- nance. The hero's handicap was also heavily increased by gruesome memor- jes of their Anglo-Indian adventures in common—the horrors of a siege in a hillcountry fort, the grim promise that constituted him her protector (to shoot her rather than to let her fall into the hands of the hostile natives), the stray The suitor a yellow, Great Gay Road. By Tom Gallon. | ‘one mutual friend to fall grievously ill | |} that they may be associated in bedside | Mr. Ford uses | reluctance of the maiden, although it is first necessary to them both to journey | = for a series of brilliant por- traits, and they do not lose in effect by ‘his comparing North’s Cabinet with that |home to England and back again, for | of Chatham. | Nick to lose an arm and Muriel her | been this! tribesman he killed before her eyes, not) to mention the summarily administered | opiate which obviated her initial oppo-| navy, But! Downing Street, issuing contradictory sition to being rescued at all. “Omnia vincit Amor” is the motto, and the extraordinary patience of the lover | alternative lover, and for more than) vigils. CHARLES JAMES FOX. George the Third and Charles For: The Concluding Part of the American Rev- olution. By Sir George Otto Trevel- yan. Vol. I. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $2 net. Thirty-one years have passed since the appearance of the Charles James Fox,” the merits of which received immediate recognition. George resumes the biography, but now connects it with his history of the Amer- | ican Revolution. By 1778 the policy of coercing the revolted colonies had fail- ed, and the Royal Peace Commission had | ended its labors by the issue of a proc- lamation which announced the King’s attitude. After three years of costly war, waged without distraction from a foreign enemy, the King held only New York, and outside of that city not anoth- er mile of territory in the northern and | central colonies. He now proposed to harass the States into submission, deter- mined never to recognize their indepen- dence. and burnt, and Indian incursions against the frontier settlements encouraged. The | capture of Charleston seemed to assure the Southern States. upon Virginia and Connecticut, the de- sultory operations in the North, the de- feat of Gates at Camden, and even the | treachery of Arnold, were the fruits of this policy, cruel to both colonists and loyalists. tional war. ments gave aid or sympathy. Interest thus centres upon the course | of events in Europe, and the English | commanders in America were deliberate- ly sacrificed to the political exigencies at home. generals were not of a high order in| strategy, and had failed to display quali-| ties necessary to success. Sir George in- dicates one leading cause of their short- comings—they were subject to the stifling atmosphere of political intrigue and official dishonesty. Liberal appro- priations were made, but they were squandered with little result and under ill-considered instructions. Barrington, Germaine, and Sandwich, plotting against the best officers in army and directing the campaigns from orders or nore at all, and bent upon en- riching their followers, offer Sir George “Early History of! Sir) A few leading points would be) occupied, the seaport towns plundered | complete reduction of the more| The descent of Arnold | The war became an interna-| France openly sided with) America, and other European govern-| Mr. Adams has shown that the! To expel these men from office, and to reform the system of court subsidy and ‘favoritism under which they could con- tinue in power became the leading ques- tions in Great Britain, and so the Sen- | ate came to be more important than the |camp. For the period of the American | Revolution the most distinguished repu- tations made were those of civilians, not | soldiers, and among the civilians, after |the death of Chatham, Burke and Fox |stood preéminent. The one, says Sir | George, was the precise complement of | the other. Burke thundered against the ill-tempered proclamation of the Peace Commission, the employment of Indians, the corrupt and extravagant expendi- tures, and the restrictions on Ireland and the Catholics. Fox sought to drive Germaine and Sandwich from office. He |denounced the sacrifice of Burgoyne’s larmy and the state of unpreparedness for war with France; he supported Kep- pel when under trial for his life; he at- tacked Sandwich for his incompetence, for the demoralization of the navy; arid he sought to obtain a wider hearing for public measures. This “opposition” policy suffered tem- porary defeat because the King could purchase support by direct bribery or by a drastic use of patronage. Further, the British public could not know what was being done by Parliament or by |Ministers. The majority of the mem- ‘bers of Parliament were too closely ‘bound to the King to be representatives of the people, and the debates in the | House on questions of moment remain- |ed unknown to the country, no reporters or spectators being permitted in the gal- lery during such debates. The news from the seat of war was doctored for the public consumption: Washington’s army was killed several times over, and died several times over of hunger and disease, in the columns of the | Morning Post and the Morning Chronicle. |The history of Burgoyne’s operations took a fantastic shape in the inspired news- | papers. The affair of King’s Mountain was call- ‘ed a “ridiculous rumor”; Washington lappeared as deserting the American | Cause, and yet again as plotting in an |extraordinary. manner against London ‘and the shipyards. The public knew only what the subsidized press found its interest to print, and could read only such speeches as were written out by the speakers, the “very burlesque of par- liamentary reporting.” Fox procured a greater degree of publicity, which told in favor of the “opposition.” Fox is represented ag one who has outlived the follies of his youth, yet as retaining to the full the qualities which charm, and as seeking only the nation- al welfare with a generous self-sacrifice j

Page 21

¢ “# ae March 28, 1912] . nN ~~ The Nation and whole-souled patriotism. Once a! brethren, to the effect that there is real- | is a study based upon S17 member of North's Administration, he ly something worth while dn a weli-bal- | archives of France. had not committed himself on American | questions, and after 1778 he was the un-! disputed leader of the Opposition in the) Commons. Not only eloquent, he had a policy. In the face of war with France and Spain he would leave America alone, until these European enemies had been defeated, believing that the Americans would act lukewarmly when the contest was transferred to Europe, where their interests were small. Defence at home and victory against the hereditary ene mies of Britain formed the cardinal fea- tures of his policy. In seeking its attain- ment, he suffered temporary defeat, but he brought into prominence the dangers of court influence as exemplified by the King and his ministers. On the style of this volume little need be said, for the high qualities of Sir George as a compiler and narrator are well known. His digressions, such as those on social life in the country, on Brooks's Club, and on landscape garden- ing, are interesting and do not interrupt the relation of the political history. He depends too unquestioningly upon Isaac Arnold's life of Benedict Arnold, and it was a letter from Howe, not Gage, that Washington refused to receive. Certain- ly, no fault can be found with his judg- ments on American affairs. Though he is no cool partisan, and deals gently with the shortcomings of George III and the good-natured North, his distribution of praise and blame commends itself by its good foundation in balanced and thorough investigation. Modern Riding and Horse Education. By Major Noel Birch, Royal Horse Artillery of Great Britain. New York: William R. Jenkins Co. $2. It is always refreshing to find an Eng- lishman who gives consideration enough to horsemanship to lead him away, for however brief a time, from the claims of the hunter and the cross-country course. But the world moves in the matter of horse education even if it does forget and return periodically to rediscover the essentials and glibly to argue the points mooted by succeeding generations of horse lovers. Major Birch has faithful- ly endeavored to qualify himself as a writer on the subject of the horse by reading the long procession of books from Xenophon down to the idealistic | volume on the “Psychology and Train- ing of the Horse” by Cesaresco. The resulting volume is interesting in | many ways, but in none more than the | frank manner in which he states his | views of the methods of numerous re-| puted masters of the subject. The con-| clusions reached on many points accord with the experience of students general- ly. It is readily observed that Major Birch has honestly tried to let in some light to his fox-hunting, cross-country | anced animal, trained for general pur- poses under the saddle. To present this view has long been regarded as a hope- less task, even in the British cavalry and field artillery. As far back as 1839 American officers were sent to the justly celebrated French Cavalry School at Saumur to acquire a knowledge of equitation and mounted drill regulations. The influ- ence of their work upon the regular cav- alry still lingered, but the source of this influence was forgotten, until Saumur was rediscovered by one of our accom- plished military attachés. The result of the reawakening has been to extend a knowledge of equitation throughout the American service and to create on all sides a desire to reéstablish our rap idly disappearing breeds of worthy sad- dle horses. The advantage of such a volume as Major Birch’s arises from his discussion of balance, grip, the use of the reins, the jumping seat, and various details of riding and training the horse from the point of view of one who has been an unprejudiced seeker after truth. In America the methods of Fillis have ap- pealed strongly to students of equitation . and his discourses have been accepted as authoritative, but there is always room for such a volame as “Modern Riding and Horse Education” the ab- sence of dogmatic theories will appeal to those who ride for pleasure and who prefer a trained, well-balanced horse, perticularly one made so by instruction of its owner. The Horse Shows are giv- ing evidence constantly that the public is acquiring a better appreciation of horsemanship in distinction from mere ability to ride difficult animals. If the present revival of the popularity of the horse continues for a reasonable time, the nation will be the beneficiary in more ways than one. The automobile will answer for getting about in town, but for country life nothing can take the place of the horse. where Notes John Muir’s guidebook to “The Yosemite,” together with “Captain Martha Mary,” by Avery Abbott, and C. H. Claudy’s “The Bat- tle of Base-Ball,” will be brought out by the Century Co. next month. Beethoven's love-affair with the Countess Guicciardi has been made the subject of a Swedish novel, “Quasi, Una Fantasia”; the book will be issued in English form by Sturgis & Walton Co. A handbook on Bahaism is in »reparation by Longmans; the author is Francis H. Skrine. The Yale University Press announces for | publication in the spring or early summer) Stewart L. Mim’s “The Commercial Policy of Colbert toward the French West Indies.” It ,; tory of researches in the Macmillans will have ready tn April a new edition of Joseph Conrad's first book, “Almayer'’s Folly.” and Marcus Alonzo Hanna; His Life and Works by Herbert Croly. The “Fame Seekers,” by Alice Woods, shortly to be published by Doran, ts a story of Parisian life. An authoritative account of the history and activity of the Jewish national move ment from the earliest times to th: day will soon be issued by the Zioniat C: tral Office, Berlin, through W Sons of London. The pamphlet, written Israel Cohen, Zionist Movement: Its Aims and ments.” present Speaight & which 1 Achi« rhe ve by is entith “The Revival of Printing: a Bibliograpt ical Catalogue of the Works Issued by t) Chief Modern English edited by Robert work which Ma lla will publish in for the Med clety of London. The volume will b: in three different styles, prepared for the student ing. March 30 Mifflin Co, lowing Presses.” Steele, is a April $ and peciaily of modern is: the date set by Houghton for the publication of the fol “Polly of Hospital Staff,” by Emma C. Dowd: “A Child's Jour with Dickens,” by Kate Douglas Wik- “Tales of a Greek Island,” by Julia 1D Dragoumis; “The Home-Mads by Archibald the Riverside Press edition, “Lines tle, and Other Poems,” by Henry Brownell, with De Wolfe”"Howe. books: the ney gin; Kindergar ten,” Nora Smith, and, for Bat Howard M \ ot an introduction by Four new volumes are announced by Dana Estes & Co. in their Beautiful Ireland “Ulster,” “Leinster,” “Munster.” ar “Connaught.” The same house has in the pre with the of Baroda,”’ by Clair Weeden, His Work,” ries \ Year Rev La Shaw Gaekwar the Edward St and “John very and by Walt¢ Sparrow. the issuc books which Putname “The by Among will shortly Comedy Cathe- Francis H Wind,” Patricia revised of “The Evil,” with new material covering the 1902-1911, edited by Prof. R. A. Seligman: “My Friendship with Prince Hohenlohe,” being the Memoirs of the Baroness von Hedemann; “Leaflets from Italy,” by M Nataline Crumpton, and “The Heroic Age,” » book dealing with the early heroic poetry and traditions of the Teutonic by are of rine “The worth; Gribbl Went lal are the Great,” Devil's a by edition Soc ve pe oples, H. M. Chadwick The list of E. P. Dutton & Co, includes,in biography and history: “The Life of Hiuen- Tsiang,” by Hwui Li and Yen-Tsung;: “The Life or Legend of Gaudama, the Buddha of the Burmese,” by the Rev. P. Bigandet: “The Sisters of Lady Jane Grey.” by Rich ard Davey; “The Life and Work of Romesh Chunder Dutt, C.LE.," by J. N. Gupta; “Thomas De Witt Talmage; an autobiog raphy; “The Making of Western: Europe,” by Prof. C. R. L. Fletcher; “Modern Eng- land,” by Louls Cazamion, and “A His- the Renaissance,” Temple Cyclo- pedic Primers, by B. F. Oldham.—General literature: “Poetry and Prose: Essays on English Poetry,” by A. A. Jack; “A Book of Scoundrels,” “Studies ih Frankness,”

Page 22

318 “The Pageantry of Life,” all three by Charles Whibley; “Posthumous Essays,” by Churton Collins, edited by C, L. Collins; “First and Last,” by Hilaire Belloc; “The Views of Vanoc,” essays by Arnold White; “Neighborhood,” by Ticknor Edwards; “Modern Tariff History; Germany, United States, Fraace,” by P. Ashley; “Animal Life in Africa,” by J. Stevenson Hamilton; “In- land Transport,” by E. A. Pratt; “Two Visits to Denmark,” by Edmund Gosse; “The Creed of Half Japan: Sketches of His- torical Buddhism,” by Arthur Lloyd; “The Irish Harpers, with a Memoir of Edward Bunting,” by Charlotte Milligan Fox; “A Magician in Many Lands,” by Charles Ber- tram; “Rowlandson’s Oxford,” by A. Ham- ilten Gibbs; “The Evidence of the Super- natural,” by Ivor D. Tuckett; “North Sea Fishers and Fighters,” by Walter Wood; “English Philosophers and Schools of Phil- osophy,” by Prof. James Seth, and “Prac- tical Library Administration,” by W. S. 8 Rae In “Socialism and the Ethics of Jesus” (Macmillan), Prof, Henry C. Vedder of Crozer Theological Seminary sketches the history of Socialistic principles, defines the fundamental principles of present-day Socialism, and compares these principles) He promises to with the ethics of Jesus make this investigation “not as the cham- pion of any social theory, or the briefed de- fender of any social system, but in as im- partial and candid a spirit as possible, as a student of history, of the Scriptures, of Candor and impartiality stay by the author in the economics. of social institutions.” first few chapters, in which he discusses the social enthusiasms of the Anabaptists and early French and German Socialism, but in the subsequent portions of the book these desirable qualities are signally lack- ing A man who can refer to the late Ee. L. Godkin as one who “spends one-half his talent and energy in telling the work- ers that they have no right to aspire to the pursuit of happiness, that it is their duty to accept their hard lot without murmuring or questioning; and the other half in ad- ministering sedatives to the consciences of the well-to-do, so that they shall rest con- tent with what they have and make no effort to better conditions,” is not impar- tial, and it ts difficult to see how an in- telligent person who can make such a state- ment is candid. This is only one instance of the author's vicious practice of calling names. He criticises Socialism himself, but he allows no one else to do so without fall- ing under his rebuke for writing “non- sense.” To occupy both sides of a ques- tion has always been the genius of theologians, and Professor Vedder enjoys this ability In one chapter he is a fully persuaded Socialist, denouncing capital with the vigor of a atreet orator, and, like the veriest demagogue, accusing Wall Street of producing panics, while in the next he exposes the fallacies of the Socialists’ with equal violence. The book is energetic and eprightly, but if the author is able to main- tain hie present attitude, it is dificult to see how his readers will not desire to go further in either one direction or the other. The passage of the Parliament Act last year was universally felt to mean a pro- The Nation | Vol. 94, No. 2439 ’ William R. Anson brings out a revised re- issue of the fourth edition of his “Law and Custom .of the Constitution” Press), the alterations in Vol. I, dealing with Parliament, being almost wholly con- fined to explaining the new legislation referred to. Sir William is, as is well known, a prominent Conservative, and a certain tinge of party bias shows itself in what he writes of the clipping of the veto powers of the House of Lords; yet he states the matter accurately, makes it clear precisely what has been taken away and what has been left, and keeps up a measur- ably good hope for the future. The same subject is treated from the Liberal stand- casting their general schemes. Thus Sir point in the new edition of “May’s Consti- | ito obtain ready money in the Rumanian tutional History of England” (Longmans), edited and continued by Francis Holland. May's work closed with 1860, and his pres- ent editor has added a third volume: to bring the history down to date. The method is not strictly chronological, but chapters are given to separate subjects. These are dealt with compendiously, but impartially version of the affair is read first by every foreign office in the civilized world. On his story, the editorials on the “situation” are based, from London to Buenos Ayres. (Clarendon What strikes the reader most in Mr. Wash- burn’s account is the resourcefulness often needed by a person in his capacity. The cable is to such a one what the air tube is to the diver, and how he shall beat the other fellow to it keeps him con- tinually planning for the future. When Mr. Washburn arrived at Constantinople, for instance, on his way to Russia, he wise- ly concluded to charter a tug-boat. With it he could freely enter turbulent Russian ports, gather news, and race for an un- censored cable. One of the most readable chapters describes his ingenious measures town of Sulina. The consternation of the natives over the spectacle of a private in- dividual wishing to send a thousand words by cable, and the formidable impression | which he contrived to make, though with- and accurately, so far as we have been able} to apply tests. The whole is a useful continuation and reprint of a work which already had a secure reputation. Coming events cast their books before, and “The Framework of Home Rule,” by Erskine Childers (Longmans, Green & Co.), confessedly has its reason for being in the approaching renewal of the great debate in Parliament over the question of Irish Gov- ernment. The author starts out by pointing to the fact that Ireland is, historically, an English colony, and then he shows what England has done for her other colonies Canada, Australia, South Africa—in the way of large grants of home rule. All candid persons admit, in fact, thdt the founding of the Australian Commonwealth and the establishment of the South African Con- federation, both events having taken place since the Irish Home Rule bill of 1886, have profoundly modified the point of view. If Ireland were 3,000 miles away from Eng- land, she would have had home rule long) ago. Mr. Childers takes it for granted that she igs soon to have it, and his volume is a full and careful discussion of the details— legislative, financial, and administrative. It is a work based on wide knowledge and ing to population, taxation, land purchase, and the like, so that it will be a very handy book to have by one as the Parliamentary | discussion comes on after Easter. out securities, upon a banker there, are amusingly told. It is easy to understand Mr. Washburn’s statement that the correspondent that represents a con- servative paper has a truly mean time when he is on an assignment with a number of fellows who are cabling for the other type, for it is not at all uncommon for them to take rumors, even fakes, agree on the details, and send them broadcast. We may suggest, however, that when placed in such a position, a correspondent might fill his time, to the great benefit of the far-away public, with discrediting such ru- mors. While the day of the square-rigger and deep-water ships seems to have passed, it is a pertinent fact that the fore-and-aft rig is not only not on the decline, but, as a matter of fact, is multiplying both for commercial and for pleasure purposes. For that reason the history of this rig, which has been traced by E. Keble Chat- terton in “Fore and Aft” (Lippincott); makes a peculiar appeal to yachtsmen and to all who love the sea. Mr. Chatterton fol- lows the fore-and-aft rig from its origin in the days of the Egyptian, down through | the ages, taking up the history of the rig in northern Europe, in Holland, in Eng- |land, and America, and of its introduc- embodies the latest official statistics relat- | ton to yacht use. The book is filled with illustrations of the rig as seen at various periods, in drawings, reproductions of paintings from the Dutch school, and in photographs of the various models to be /found in museums in Europe, while at the The shifts to which a war correspondent is put form the subject of Stanley Wash- burn’s book, “The Cable Game: The Ad- ventures of an American Pressboat in Turk- ish Waters During the Russian Revolution” (Sherman, French). The author, a writer for the Chicago Daily News, was at Pe-| king, when without yet knowing the mean-| ing of it, he received the message: “Russia | direct. When do you start?” It was the end line drawings and sail plans of yachts, fishing vessels, and working boats are given. In most essentials the fore-and-aft rig is the same to-day as it was hundreds of years ago, some of the same details of rigging now used being in evidence then; although in the cut of the sail and in the lightness and convenience of the rigging we have made marked improvement. The service which Mr. Chatterton performed arsignment for the Russian insurrection.| for the history of the sailing ship, two | The romance of the game, Mr. Washburn | assures us, becomes utterly when one realizes that one’s paper $10,000, for an account of a world event. A single story of this kind is printed in ten thousand papers in fifty different lan- years ago, in his “Sailing Ships and Their engrossing | Story,” he has now done for the fore-and- _aft-rigged vessel in particular. He has | |}made an interesting and useful volume. will pay fabulous sums, $2,000, $5,000, even | A new edition of Horace White's valu- | able textbook, “Money and Banking’—long found change in the English Constitution, | guages within twenty-four hours after the| recognized as a high authority on current and already we have the systepatizers re-| correspondent files it in a cable office. His! financial problems in the United States and

Page 23

Lie a (A ORY RS March 28, 1912] The Nation S1)) on American financial history—has been put out by Ginn & Co., so as to extend the discussion to the plans of banking and currency reform which have been placed before the American people since the third edition of the book was published in 1908. The full text of the Aldrich plan, endorsed a few months ago by the Monetary Com- mission and now in the hands of Congress, is included in the present book. There are also added a chapter on the guarantee of bank deposits, and another on the rela- tions of the Stock Exchange and the money markets—a subject on which Mr. White speaks with particular authority as the chairman of the special committee appoint- ed by Governor Hughes in 1909 to investi- gate the question of speculation in stocks and commodities on the various exchanges The additions bring this useful book com- pletely up to date for purposes of refer- ence on the pressing financial and bank- ing problems of the day. We have received the “Yiddish Diction- ary,” dealing with the Hebrew and Chal- daic elements in the present-day Yiddish vernacular. We take the appearance of this volume as an interesting sign of the efforts that are being made to raise the Yiddish, hitherto regarded as a formless jargon, to the level of an ordered language. The authors and publishers of the diction- ary are Dr. C. D. Spivak and Solomon Bloomgarden, of whom the latter has won distinction as a poet, under the pseu- denym “Jehoash.” He has translated “Hia- witha” into the Yiddisn. Maximilian Harden, the well-known edi- tor of the Berlin Zukunft, does not show to great advantage in the English dress Julius Gabe has given him in “Word Por- traits” (Brentano’s). Some of the sketches are characteristic enough of their author, | and in their day probably served to enter- tain or startle Berlin for a brief hour, but in the years that have elapsed since Old William, Richter, Waldersee, Stoecker, the Empress Frederick, and Bismarck him- self evoked so much sound and fury, the world has learned to speak of these sub- jects dispassionately. Least of all is pos- terity to accept Herr Harden’s rhetoric as the judgment of history. There have been political pamphleteers who have out- lived their day and generation, but few of them were Germans, and none of them wrote as Harden does. Stored as his mind is with varied and surprising knowledge, he has neither strict logic nor telling satire nor deep feeling at his command. Wit is not his in the sense in which Heine and Borne have accustomed us to it. He is essentially a rhapsodist and, for all his revolutionary flings at tradition, a sentimentalist—a talk- er, not a causeur. Least of all is he a great thinker. His vehemence is studied, his pathos false, his heaping of metaphors in- tolerable—even in the original German, where much is forgiven to a show of learn- ing. Unfortunately, Harden’s influence on newspaper diction has been considerable. He has introduced and made popular the staccato phraseology that marks so much of progressive journalism—not only on the other side of the ocean. The political es- says in this collection, with the exception of that on Gallifet, are all grouped around the overshadowing figure of Bismarck, the one deity Harden worships. Literature is represented by clouds of words on Ibsen and Zola; art, far more interestingly by | essays on Bicklin, Lenbach, and Menzel; | acting, by overwrought papers on Char- lotte Wolter, Mitterwurzer, and Matkow- sky. At the suggestion, we believe, of President Butler of Columbia the Weidmannsache Buchhandlung of Berlin has undertaken the publication of an important series of books, of which Dr. Butler and Dr. Wilhelm Pasz- kowski are the general editors. This is no- thing less than a translation into German of the principal books on American institu- tions, history, and culture. Three volumes of the series have already been issued, and come to us from G. E. Stechert & Co. of this city; they include “George Washing- ton,” von Henry Cabot Lodge, in two vol- umes, and “Die Amerikanische Literatur,” von C. Alphonso Smith. The names of the translators are not given on the title pages. The latest successor of Mademoiselle de Gournay is Miss Edith Sichel, who re- counts her likings and her reflections in “Michel de Montaigne” (Dutton). The book consists largely of sentences and para- graphs translated from the “Essays” and so grouped as to illustrate various charac- teristics of Montaigne the man and Mon- taigne the philosopher. The passages are for the most part well chosen and well rendered. It is to be hoped, though, for Miss Sichel’s peace of mind, that she will | never discover the real point of the anec- dote she has quoted on pages 43 and 44. The discussion in which the translated passages | are set reveals a knowledge of Montaigne at once genuine and eager. The appraisal ef his qualities is just; but the attempt is too often made to reconcile his inconsistencies. Miss Sichel’s style is modelled, consciously or unconsciously, on that of Montaigne, but her epigrams do not ring true, and her fre- quent carelessness in the use of words con- victs her of instability in constructive thought. Witness this paragraph: No shibboleths for Montaigne. Dilettan- tisme oblige was his motto. And dilettant- ism must not be an insipid business. “No wind maketh for him who hath no destined |port,” he once wrote, and he _ steered straight for knowledge—rich, haphazard knowledge of human life. Miss Sichel has but little to say that is worth the attention of those who are al- ready familiar with Montaigne. Such oth- ers as read her study are likely to gain| from it a good measure of immediate en- joyment and the resolution to know Mon-| taigne for themselves. The book is well in- dexed and well printed, and the illustra- | tions are excellently chosen. Prof. H.S. Jevons has performed a useful service to students as well as an act of filial piety in editing a fourth edition of Prof. W. Stanley Jevons’s “Theory of Politi- cal Economy” (Macmillan). The work has) become an economic cjassic, and Jevons’s exposition of some fundamental points of economic theory is still unsurpassed. In the new edition the text is unchanged from that of the second and third editions, except for the correction of some obvious slips, and the addition of a few notes designed to make the meaning of obscure passages clearer or to correct slight errors. Three new appendices are added to the two contained in the sec- ond and third editions. The most interest- ing of these is a fragment on Capital and Interest which Jevons had intended to use in his “Principles of Economics.” The venerable, but stil! active historian Prof. Pasquale Villar!, has just § issued “Scritti Vari" (Bologna: Zanichelill), a vol ume containing fourteen essays, most of which have appeared before. Their sub jects are fairly balanced between history and literature, and range from a long dis cussion of history as a science, to short studies of Margaret Fuller, De Amicis, and Tenca, and a paper on Gaetano Negri, writ- ten as an introduction for the Duchess Litta’s translation of that author's well known work on Julian the Apostate. The most recent essay is on Dante's “De Mon archia.” Charles Ezra Sprague, president of the Union Dime Savings Bank of New York, died at his home last week, in his seven tieth year. Besides inventing many de- vices for savings banks and other book- keeping, he wrote the following treatises “Hand-Book of Volapiik,” “The Accoun- tancy of Investment,” “Interest Bond Ta- bles,” and “The Philosophy of Accounts.” The death is reported from Warsaw of Prof. Max Mandelstamm, the expert on in- ternational law Science Science books in Dutton’s spring list in clude: “British Trees and Shrubs,” by the Rev. C. A. Johns; “British Fungi,” with a chapter on Lichens, by George Massee; “British Ferns and Their Varieties,” by C. T. Druery; “Return to Nature,” by A. Just; “Every Boy’s Book of the Zoo,” W. S. Ber- |ridge and W. Percival Westell; “The Boy |Fancier,” by Frank T. Barton; “Pepper's Boy's Playbook of Science,” by John Maa- tin; “The Advance of Photography Its History and Modern Applications,” by A. E. Garrett; “The Great Star Map,” by H H. Turner; “Liquid Fuel and Its Appara- tus,” by William Booth; “Talks about Our- selves,” by Viscountess Falmouta: “Science lof the Sea,” by G. Herbert Fowler;; “Sport }in Vancouver and Newfoundland,” by Sir | John Rogers; and “The Noble Science of Fox Hunting,” by F. P. D. Radcliffe Chemistry is one of the most impersonal of the sciences, and {t is only recently that efforts have been made to give it some of |the human interest attaching, say, to as- jtronomy or zodlogy, by biographical |sketches of the founders of the science. | Apparently, E. Roberts’s “Famous Chem- ists” (Macmillan) is such an attempt, but if so, it is not altogether successful, for | the biographical details are packed into a few paragraphs at the beginning of each chapter, and the rest are devoted to an expla- nation of the discoveries of the chemist under consideration. There are no por- | traits, and the reader gets no conception of a personality, such as, for example, is |furnished by Ostwald’s “Grosse Manner.” But this little volume is well worth the space it occupies, for its explanations are clear, and it will be handy for the student who wants to know what contribution to science this or that chemist made. Twenty- eight chemists are included, beginning with Stah! and Boyle and ending with Perkin and Meyer. The American Ephemeris and Nautical Almanac for 1914, just issued from the Gov ernment Printing Office by the Department

Page 24

B20 [Vol. 94, No. 2 439 of the Navy, under the direction of Prof. W. 8. Eichelberger, is like its predecessor in material and arrangement. American geodesists and astronomers are particular- ly favored with a copious catalogue of stars whose positions are computed with all need- ful precision In this respect our national ephemeris is now far in advance of all simi- lar European publications. Mars comes to his next opposition January 5 of that year, total eclipse of the sun for two 21 Russia Persia nd a transit of Mercury on Novem- rhe occults tober 14, but no planet or other Many observers will value the nt data for physical observa- August from to moon passes over or moon, and planets which Pro- fessor Eichelberger now incor- Eephe regularly meris each year Prot Thon prot: or of as Harrison Montgomery, jr., the University of last ek, at the the author of one Dese: Ani- zodlogy in died was ania, who we thirty-nine of ysis Racial nt in Iph physical geography of the United and Stockman of the de- in Cornell best-known geog States, an au- earthquakes, died cerebral hemorrhage a week He pedition to Greenland, and spent sev- Alaska at the head of the for the United States Geological 1882-83 he was Assistant United Commissioner, Tarr one raphers in the and m glaciers tron ago, aged forty-eight once led a Cor- eral immers in tion sur In ish connected He b phe on geographi al and geological it t and of being also at the Smithsonian author of several that tir with was the well-known ofa series Drama Edward Dowden's “Shakespeare, a Study His Mind and Art,” will be brought out by Dutton in a completely revised edition. Cleverne the and originality mark most of Percy. Mackaye, and both exhibited in his latest play, (Frederick A. Stokes Co.); is not particularly impressive, or as principle in professed purpose its main contention no thoughtful person ever it—but unfortunately is ever Iikely to come, within the re- That the mul- insane, dis- | is a hideous admitted How deal that has long Secu- the most earnest and check it, here and police methods, n proved possible in a very limited of work qualitie are lo-morrow”™ the piece be favor whether it considered as drama ir of a great which is ite rheoretically, of course enough ot lreamed disputing now, nor ecial al the it | instances, th of ae | generally politics tion eriminal generate classes to with it is a problem 1 the attention of To legislative iologiatea +) re hy has and bee degre: Mr. Mackaye, inspired apparently by the horticultural triumphs of Luther Rurbank, has adopted the loose theory, no longer fresh, that the human race may be perfected physically, intellectually, and/| the enforcement of principles | morally, by of selection analogous to those practiced by The Nation the expert gardener, forester. dog-fancier, So he presents an illus- tration. Feter Dale, philosopher and plant- grower in northern California, has reared Mana, with such tact and wisdom that she is a paragon of health, or cattle-breeder. his daughter, beauty, discretion, and innocence, a creature | He | comparable with Eve before the fall. designs her for Mark Freeman, his trained assistant, and, in his eye, the perfect male. A serpent enters this Eden, in the shape of Julian, a brilliant young politician, full of fascination and all sorts of poisonous blood taint. In spite of Peter’s opposition he woos and has almost won Mana, by his sophistries and passion, when the sturdy Mark interferes and flings him over a cliff. it needless to say, she discovers is Mark alone whom she has loved all the The love story Mr. Mackaye tells prettily and effectively, but it de- notes nothing, and the action is sorely im- peded by the didactic passages in which he deduces laws for human regeneration from horticultural experiments. These are among the commonplaces of modern agriculture. But how are such processes to be applied in wholesale or effectual fashion to humanity? Who to confine, select, or exterminate? Mr. Mackaye appears to imagine that these Then, is that it time. is responsibilities might be entrusted safely to the doctors. The proposition scarcely needs discussion. There is a fairly good stage story, with some excellent literary dia- logue, in “To-morrow,” but the anthropo- logical speculations are negligible. More- over, the subject belongs to the lecture- room and not to the stage, since it is en- tirely and necessarily incapable of signifi- illustration cant dramatic Josephine Preston Peabody may be con- gratulated on having found for her “Piper” so sympathetic and skilful a German in- terpreter as Margaret Miinsterberg. “Der Pfeifer” (Munich: Siiddeutsche Monats- hefte) preserves all the charm of the origi- nal, indeed lends itself particu- larly well to German adaptation. The play, in this version, will no doubt be appre- ciated in the fatherland, as it has bees in this country. Barring a single halting line, “Ich sagt’ euch alles—das ist des) Teufels Pakt” (which can be matched by Mrs. Marks’s “In it, is Love. It is clear well-water”), the translation reads smooth- ly throughout. As an example of Miss Miinsterberg’s mastery of versification, we refer to her rendering of the exquisite song beginning with “Out of your cage.” By a change of metre in the sixth line she pro- duces a happy rhythmical effect lacking in| the original, where “Scribe and Stay-at-| is left unrhymed. which home” We give both versions of the song: | Out of your cage, Come out of your cage And take your soul on a pilgrimage! Pease In your shoes, an’ if you must !— But out and away, before you're dust: Beribe and Stay-at-home, Saint and Sage, Out of your cage, This is the spirit of the true translator, |who (as Fulda does in his version of “Cyrano”) succeeds only if he keeps con- stantly in mind the different poetic sus- ceptibilities and melodic standards of the two languages he is concerned with. It was the slavish endeavor to pour the pre- cise syllabic content of Goethe's “Faust” into English metre that prevented Bayard Taylor’s version from being more than an extraordinary tour de force. If Miss Miinsterberg’s effort attains, as it deserves, a second edition, she will have an oppor- tunity to eliminate a few slight blem- ishes, such as “eine schébige hélzerne Tir’ (p. 37), and “das Sprudelwasser” (p. 69), for “bubbling water.” The quaint line, “Man muss sie fangen, wenn sie halt noch jung sind!” introduces an Austriacism rarely met with in German literature. For the meaningless stage direction, “entschul- digt leidenschaftlich” (p. 94), the equally awkward English “excuses passionately” is responsible, “When It Comes Home” has been select- ed as the title of the first of the three comedies which Augustus Thomas has con- tracted to deliver to Charles Frohman. It is in four acts, and the scenes are in old and new New York. Gail Kane, Ffolliot Paget, Louise Muldener, John Findlay, Earle Browne, and William Courtleigh are among the performers. The piece will be seen first in Chicago on the 8th of April. Arrangements have been perfected for the construction of a Children’s Theatre on the roof of the Century Theatre. It is expected to be open in October, and the plays will be of a kind specially adapted to juvenile appreciation, such as “Alice in Wonderland,” etc. The need of a Chil- dren's Theatre has long been felt in this city, especially at Christmas time, when there has been nothing to fill the place of the old pantomimes. But it is to be hoped that the Lieblers will not make the mis- take of supposing that children are only capable of enjoying sheer nonsense, the sort of knock-about fooling that they get in the circus. Children have a wonder- fully’ keen appreciation of the romantic, beautiful, heroic, and sentimental, and the new institution ought to give great scope to their imagination. As a successor to “The Dust of Egypt,” when that piece has ended its career at Wyndham’s, in London, Frank Curzon and Gerald du Maurier have chosen a new |four-act play, provisionally entitled, “The Kangaroo,” by Horace Annesley Vachell. This tells a story of our own times, the laction taking place partly in London and partly up the Thames. Although light in places, it maintains a serious interest. The character designed for Gerald du Maurier is that of a young man, a rough |diamond, who inherits a fortune. Charles Hawtrey has accepted a play by | George A. Birmingham. Although not a Out of your cage !— Heraus aus der Haft, Hleraus aue der Haft, Und achick’ deine Seele auf Wanderscoaft! , | } | } Und musest du, so piigre mit Erbseen tm Schuh! Nur herave, eh du Staub bist, und fort ohne Rah: Schreiber, Gelebrter und Heiliger dazu, Alles was hockt su Haus, Komm aus dem Kifig beraus. Komm aus dem Kifig beraus! | dramatization of any of his novels, it deals with characters which figure in the “Search Party.” Edward Knoblauch and Arnold Bennett seem to have made a hit with their comedy, “Milestones,” which has just been produced at the London Royalty Theatre, It is agree- able to know that the play has already been obtained for this country.

Page 25

elt ecceas en March 28, 1912} The Nation Music , Studies in Musical Education, History, and 2 sthetics. Sixth Series. $1.60. By those interested in serious discus- sions of important musical topics no publication is more gladly welcomed than the annual volume containing the Papers and Proceedings of the Music Teachers’ National Association. The sixth is now in print, containing the most important papers read at the Asso-, |} genius-composer of “Carmen.” It can be ciation’s thirty-third meeting, which was held at Ann Arbor, Mich., last Decem- ber (copies may be obtained of Waldo S. Pratt, Hartford, Conn.). Glancing at the table of contents, one may perhaps be surprised to find an article entitled, “Was Richard Wagner a Jew?” Its author, however, is none less than the scholarly Oscar G. Sonneck, of the Library of Congress; and the inclusion of an article or two in a lighter vein in each of these volumes has become a habit—a wise one, since, particularly in this case, the more widely prevalent in- terest in biography than in discussions of the artistic or scientific aspects of music may attract the general reader. No fewer than five of the papers in Volume VI are concerned with orches- tras, and are therefore particularly time- ly, since the multiplication of orches- tras in the cities of the United States is the most remarkable musical fact of the day. The Orchestration of Bach is con- sidered by Frederick Wolle, the or- ganizer of the unique Bach festivals at Bethlehem, Pa. The “Orchestra before Berlioz” is described by Louis Adolphe Coerne, of the University of Wisconsin, the author of a valuable history of in- strumental coloring. The “Orchestra since Berlioz’ is discussed by Frederick A. Stock, the admirable conductor of the Theodore Thomas Orchestra in Chi- cago, who also speaks as a thorough ex- pert. “Conductors and Non-Conductors” is the title of a diverting paper by Charles K. Skilton of the University of Kansas; and Samuel Pierson Lockwood of the University of Michigan writes amusingly about “Amateur Orchestras” and the trials and tribulations of their conductors. Dr. Wolle refutes the charge that Bach’s instrumentation is monotonous; he tells of an amusing tiff he once had with Theodore Thomas on the vexed question of Bach’s trumpet parts, and urges musicians to pay more attention to the works of the Leipzig Cantor. In Mr. Stock’s paper the most valuable pages are those in which he traces the successive steps by which Wagner im- proved his orchestral coloring, from “Rienzi” to “Parsifal.” Referring to) those who say that “Tchaikovsky's this great Russian’s “handling of the orchestra is that of a genius, and his music is of that kind in which every note sounds and sings.’ We wish to call particular attention to what Mr. Stock has to say about two other masters whose genius was of a much more tran- scendent kind than most professional musicians realize: It would be a sin of musica! omission to speak of orchestral music without men- tioning another Frenchman who “made a school,” and still is making it, Bizet, the stated with all confidence that seekers for knowledge in orchestral matters can derive a hundred-fold greater practical good from the study of the score of “Carmen” than from a dozen instruction-books on in- strumentation. Some of the Johann Strauss, the Waltz-King, also fur- nish most excellent material for studying their practical value from this point of view has never been fully ap- scores of purposes ; preciated, Mr. Skilton gives interesting informa- tion regarding the formation of school orchestras, which is one of the hopeful signs of the times. Few of them are more than ten years old, but already they have created a new interest in student life, being more artistic than the man- 'dolin or glee club, more educational than the dramatic club. In this line the |colleges for men or for women alone are, it seems, at a disadvantage as com- pared with co-educational institutions, where the strings are chiefly played by women students and the wood-wind and brass instruments by male students or instructors. Mr. Skilton is an optimist; he sees in the growing interest in music indications that “the tidal wave of ma- terialism which has overwhelmed our land during the last decades is begin- ning to recede.” Liszt is another timely subject dis- cussed in this volume. The centenary of his birth naturally suggested the query: What has been done in piano- forte music since his death, a quarter of a century ago? Albert Lockwood and Allen Spencer discuss this topic, the first-named holding that nothing fur- ther can be said after Liszt until the very nature of the keyboard has been changed; while Mr. Spencer calls atten- tion to the significant fact that it is the “quite recent acknowledgment of his genius that has given piano-playing its newest development.” In naming the great pianists who have made the real Liszt known to the public, he forgets the greatest and most persuasive of them all, Paderewski. Edwin Hughes of De- troit, in discussing recent composition for the piano, gives a page to Debussy as “the first really creative innovator in piano-playing since Liszt’; yet it can-| not at all be said, he adds, that he has music sounds much better than it is,” revolutionized piano-playing after the he replies that it is “difficult to deter-| manner of Chopin or Liszt. mine whether to apply this in a prais- ing or fault-finding sense,” adding that | He also tries to show wherein Godowsky and Rosenthal, in their transcriptions of 321 waltzes, have gone beyond Liszt in the matter of “clever keyboard intricacies. We cannot dwell on tbe suggestive points made in several papers printed under the heads of “Report of Harmony Conference,” “Report of Voice Confer- ence,” and “Report of Public School Con- ference.” A word must be said, how- ever, about two important papers con tributed by Mr. Sonneck; the one al- ready referred to, and another, most curious one, entitled “MacDowell versus MacDowell,” in which he relates in a most entertaining way the difficulties he has encountered in trying to procure for the Library of Congress a complete file of the first editions of the foremost American composer's works. No less readable is his paper, “Was Wagner a Jew?” It was Nietzsche who first set in vogue the notion that he was a Jew, by asserting that “his father was a stage-player named Geyer,” and that “a Geyer is almost an Adler.” Mr. Son- neck’s argument to prove that Geyer was only the step-father is intricate and ingenious; but he does not succeed in obliterating the impression that Wagner himself lived and died in doubt as to his parentage. One thing, however, is certain: Wagner was not a Jew, regard- less of whether or not he was the son of Ludwig Geyer. The researches of Glas- enapp and Bournet have proved a purely Protestant lineage for Geyer, as far back as it can be traced (1649) “Historical, Descriptive, and Analytical Account of the Entire Works of Johannes Brahms” is the title of a volume of 599 pages, by Edwin Evans, just issued by the covers the vocal works Vol. Il levoted to Scribners. It lieder, part songs, and choral work of this exhaustive work will be the piano and organ works; Vol. II! to the chamber and orchestral works Saint-Saéns has changed his mind ia gard to Offenbach, as he confesses in L’Echo de Paris Once he _ prophesied “Posterity will not know him.” But he was mistaken. “Offenbach is again in fashion.” “Les Contes d’Hoffmann,” and Le Belle Héléne” are going around the world again Composers of our day look down ¢ gayety as inartistic,and as the public cannot do without it, there is a revival of operetta. What makes Offenbach interesting is “a superabundance, a fertility of melodic tin- vention of which there are few examples.” His “Tales of Hoffmann” is very rich io melody, sparkling in spontaneity, full of dash; in short, {it is “music comparable to Grétry’s.” He even, now and then, “made curious harmonic discoveries.” Saint-Saénsa concludes his article with the words It is time for me to stop; a little more and I shall be saying things I don't want to say.” Arrigo Bolto celebrated his seventieth birthday a few weeks ago (February %), and still that long-expected second opera of his, “Nero,” is not forthcoming. } D’Albert’s new opera, “Die Verachenkte | Frau,” which had its premiére in Vienna, |has already been accepted for performance lin ten other German cities. His “Ticfland,”

Page 26

[ Vol. 94, No. 2439 aoe ; 322 The Nation which was a failure in New York, had its did this, with them, lead to any desire 400th Berlin performance a few weeks ago. or effort to throw off the healthy shackles of tradition. It is a curious and suggestive contrast A 't to turn from the exhibition at the Tate — Gallery to some of the contemporary PRE-RAPHAELITES AND POST-IM- PRESSIONISTS IN LONDON, in London. On every side ample evidence ig furnished of the effect the “Post-Im- pressionists”’—the absurd name given to them which I use for convenience— have had since they were seen last win- ter at the Grafton Gallery. There was no reason why their work should then Lonpon, March 12. This winter's show of Pre-Raphaelite pictures at the Tate Gallery, lent by the Birmingham Corporation, could not have come at a more opportune moment. We have been seeing a good deal lately of| have come as such a surprise. Exam- what the young men in England are do-| ples had often been hung in the Interna- | ing in imitation of the new movements |tional Society’s exhibitions. But Lon- on the Continent, and it is interesting to compare their work with that of those other young Englishmen who were considered so daring and revolutionary now a little more than half a century ago. Of these Pre-Raphaelite pictures it | would be more than useless to write in| detail. Everybody knows the collection, and probably no other group of modern | painters have had as much said and/| written about them, or have been the subject of more exaggerated praise and | gradual result has recently been seen in more exaggerated blame. It is only to-| the galleries and in a series of decora- day that they are beginning to be seen |tions in a public building. There has been in the proper perspective, and it is a/at least one “one-man” exhibition, that curious sign of the times to find the| of Roger Fry, whose chief business is writer of the Introduction to the Tate| writing and who has not until now been Gallery exhibition, while admiring them, | over-industrious as an artist. I remem- still admitting in their work “a trace of | ber in the past his allegiance seemed to camera photographing reality,” “an ele-| hesitate between the eighteenth-century ment of the uncouth and provincial,” “a| landscape painters and the early Eng- stamp of Victorian sentiment and man-| lish water-colorists, but then he exhibit- ners’: the very last things the Pre-|ed comparatively little. This winter, Raphaelites in their zenith would have | however, under the spell of Post-Impres- been credited with. But the result of all this talk is that nothing remains to be added to it. The value of the exhibi-| tion at the Tate Gallery is not in any- thing new it can show to London. The principal pictures in the exhibition have been already seen here more than once. It is the representative character of the exhibition which gives it value. These artists may not have been the masters they once were thought, nor their pic- tures the masterpieces. They may have mistaken absorption in their subject for the observation of Nature which was the very foundation of their creed, so that their often degenerated painted anecdotes, sometimes al- most groteaque, sometimes almost com- le, and their revelation of “delicate re- lationships between man and woman in domestic life, history, religion, and ro- mance,” so far from being the “real ad- dition to the treasure of art” which the Introduction approves, has little to do with art at all. But whatever the weak- ness in their work, however mistaken their aims and objects, there can never be any question of their seriousness, | their determination to study and work out the artistic problems they had set themselves in their own fashion. Nor don is as slow to open its eyes to the new as it is quick to go off its head once it has opened them. When Post-Impres- | sionism finally dawned upon the town, it made a sensation that neither Romanti- cism nor even Impressionism enrolled in its day. The result was a torrent of talked at meetings held for the purpose; also a rush to France and Germany of those who wanted to learn the trick and make a sensation themselves. landscapes and portraits and still-lifes in which Cézanne, Van Gogh, and the less reflected. There is at least one ex- hibiting society, the Friday Club, men and women with reputations still to make—have apparently no other aim the group whose work a year ago was the talk of the studios. And there is pressionists do not make some sort of an appearance. Only yesterday, visiting the Women’s International at the Graf- ton Gallery, I found a number of land-| scapes and still-lifes upon which the movement—new in London as it grews!| old in Paris—hags set its stamp. We have been told only too freqpently | that the great virtue of what is called Post-Impressionism is its defiance of all convention and its encouragement of all | individuality of expression, Eloquent de-| scriptions have been given of the unwear- ied researth, the heart-breaking strug: | gles which the masters of the new school | willingly undertook and endured in| their determination to break loose from | tradition and to evolve their own per-| pictures into exhibitions recently held and still open) nonsense published in the press and/| The more | sionism, he filled a whole gallery with | other accepted masters were more or| in | which almost all the members—mostly | than to proclaim themselves disciples of | hardly any exhibition in which Post-Im- | sonal method of expression. The Ex- pressionists, for this reason, is the name ‘enthusiasts have bestowed upon them. To the artist’s personal expression jeverything else should be sacrificed, even if to attain it he must put himself in the attitude of a child, of a savage, when he confronts himself with Nature. Now, whether this is possible, whether the artist any more than the writer can free himself from centuries of tradition; again, whether the masters of the pres- ent Post-Impressionists prized the ex- pression of their own individuality any more highly than any other artists since the world began, I do not care here to |discuss. To begin with, there is not space for such a discussion; nor is there really any necessity. But the reminder of the principles and aims attributed te the masters is useful in helping to ex- plain how far the disciples are from un- derstanding or approaching them. As yet, in the mass of work produced so rapidly that one can but suspect a pleasant facility in the recipe, I have seen, with a few not too notable excep- tions, nothing that suggested to me an | effort to express any personality save | that of the master who happened to be chosen for the assiduous study, if imi- |tation is not a better word, of the mo- ment. The mannerisms, the limitations leven, that is, the characteristics least de- sirable, in the work of Cézanne or Gauguin or Van Gogh, the exaggerations 'of Matisse, the dots of Seurat and Sig- |nac, the eccentricities of the most stren- ‘uous of the Indépendants in Paris— | those are what I find; not any endeavor of the artist to see with his own eyes and put down what he sees in his own |way. The Post-Impressionists in Lon- don have escaped from one convention only te bind themselves more irrevoca- bly by another. The Pre-Raphaelites, it may be said, did much the same thing. But, then, they believed it was only by respect of the right tradition that they could develop whatever talent or genius they might possess, and the seri- ousness with which they studied, with which they trained themselves by hard work, is seen in everything they did. The essence of Post-Impressionism— so we are told—is to distrust or to scorn all tradition, and the diligence with which this distrust or scorn is be- ing expressed by faithful adherence to a new tradition makes one wonder if the attraction may not be, not the principles of the school, but the short cut it seems to offer to art. The work of one of the London groups has been solemnly ex- plained in what is usually considered an official quarter, as the effort to dis- cover a method of painting that can be practiced successfully without a long training in the schools—to make paint- ing more easy is now, we are assured, an aim all over Europe. There, I think, you have the reason of the popularity of Post-Impressionism with those who

Page 27

March 28, 1912] The Nation 323 profess it. those heart-breaking struggles, on the part of the leaders were simply that the followers might escape the drudgery of the school and the tedium of hard work in the studio. Art, once an art education was put within the reach of almost everybody, attracted hundreds of men and women, who ought to be serving behind counters or sitting on the high stool of office, by the easy and pleasant way of making a living they were fool- ish enough to believe it promised. But experience quickly showing how little ease there is in the life of an artist, Post-Impressionism is now welcomed as a nice and light substitute for the old-fashioned notion of long and arduous training. N. N. Finance THE VERDICT. On Monday of the present week, the stock market reached the highest fig- ures of the year Since February, the more active shares had scored advances ranging from 5 to 11 per cent. On the London Stock Exchange, also, English railway shares advanced, while the Eng- lish coal strike, with its increasingly hurtful influence on transportation, was obstinately continuing. Since Monday, along with the news of the English Government’s failure to settle the coal strike in that country and with the near approach of April 1, when our own anthracite miners are to quit their work, prices on the Stock Ex- change have ceased to rise and have oc- casionally declined rather sharply. Whe- ther this was a consequence of increas- ing doubt over the industrial outcome, or was merely a natural reaction after a prolonged advance, is no doubt de- batable. But the problem of the re- cent continuous rise in London and New York prices, under conditions which might easily have led to a rapid fall in prices, remains the foremost considera- tion. The real significance of the attitude of the stock exchanges towards the highly sensational industrial incidents of the day is the evidence that the re- sponsible part of the community is keep- ing its head, and is not going into pre- mature hysterics over a disquieting so- cial situation. sion of the English coal strike, and of the probably impending dispute in the same trade here, indicates that the prob- lem is social quite as much as industrial or financial, and it has been entirely possible to picture the outcome in such colors as to suggest a temporary break- down of civilized institutions. Not only the events themselves, but other circumstances surrounding and preceding them, might easily be cited to deepen such an impression. A world- All that hard research, all’ For the trend of discus- | wide overhauling of established tradi-' who have had trouble in shaping their tions of government; insurgent repub- lics in such unimagined places as China and Portugal; arson and assassination, in behalf of a labor union, defended in public as a kind of patriotism; public leaders in the United States clamoring for a changed Constitution and a fet- tered judiciary; ladies rioting and fight- ing the police in the streets of English cities; and all this restless excitement, in the words of an English social critic, “running around England, Europe, America, Asia, and the world, like the Dancing Mania of the Middle Ages’’— here is certainly an interesting back- ground on which to project a strike so contrived as to bring to a stop the whole movement of a nation’s trade and industry. The scope of the present labor demon- stration may readily enough, in fact, have suggested recollections of the great Stockholm strike in 1909, when the unions placed a ban on transportation, street lighting, and the gas and water supply, or the attempt of the French labor-syndicates in 1910 to stop all rail- ways and the entire postal service. It certainly recalls unpleasantly the mani-| festo of the Continental syndicalists not so long ago, to the effect that the gener- al strike, through making unworka- ble by capital the enterprises affected, |will eventually dislodge the capitalist owners of the industrial plant, leaving its management in the hands, not even of the state, but of the labor unions, the laborers thereafter to be the masters and the managers the employees. Wild as this dream may have seemed to be, it is not so much wilder than the manifold other dreams that are trou- bling the repose of the body politic, and nothing is easier, if the imagination is allowed free play, than to conceive of the existing situation as prelude to a formidable effort in exactly that direc- tion, with consequences as difficult to foresee as the social and political sequel was in 1789. The Stock Exchange is above all things imaginative, and no- body could have blamed it, or regarded its action as unreasonable, had it fallen into outright demoralization at the pre- liminary moves in that direction. For if this had actually been the signal for the crusade to expropriate capital from its control of industrial affairs, then it must also have been the beginning of a movement to reduce stocks and bonds to the status of so much waste paper. This view of the situation, which has more or less dimly suggested itself, at times, even to the sober-minded part of the community, is itself the sufficient explanation for the importance which observant people have attached to the recent attitude of the Stock Exchange. It is becausg the stock market expresses the mature and sober judgment of the majority of experienced men on the pub- lic events of the day, that other people | own opinions are so often influenced, in doing so, by the course of prices. At the present moment, it would be hard to say whether general opinion on the outcome of the labor controversies has not been quite as much influenced by the rise the Stock Exchange as the Stock change itself has been by the absence of excited and hysterical prediction in th: matter, But one fact is Stock Exchange, both here and at don, has flatly refused to indulge in of these prevalent mental extravagances regarding the breakdown of society, and has taken the ground that the thing is impossible in itself, that conspiracies to establish any such new order of civiliza tion will of before they threaten tions, and that, if labor unions and la pur- on ex indisputable-—the Lon any themselves, long institu collapse existing bor leaders have entertained pose of the sort, it is quite as well that the matter should be brought to a prac- tical test, so that even the laborer will learn what the universal strike would mean for him. This self-possessed at titude has had precisely the good effect on the thinking community which is ex erted when a chorus of confused and ex cited voices, in bewildering controversy, is interrupted by a word of calmly em phatic and authoritative common-sense. any BOOKS OF THE WEEK, Abbott, L. T. Naomi of the Island. Boston Page. $1.25 net. Alexander, Miriam. Beyond the Law Put nam. $1.35 net. | Angellotti, M. P. The Burgundian: A Tale of Old France. Century Co. $1.30 net Barr, Robert Lady Eleanor: Lawbreaker Chicago: Rand, McNally. Brinsmade, H. H. Utopia Achieved: * No el of the Future. Broadway Pub. Co. $1.50 Brown, Vincent. The Irresistibl: Husband Brentano. $1.35 net Brudno, Ezra. One Of Us Lippincott. $1.25 net Byers, H. G., and Knight, H. G Notes on Qualitative Analysis Van Nostrand. $1.50 net Cambridge Vol. VIII, $2.50 net. Carpenter, Rhys. The Tragedy: A Poem. Sturgis & Walton $1 Castle, W. R.. jr. The Green Va Mead. $1.30 net. ‘atholic Encyclopedia Vol Simon. Robert Appleton Cory, D. M Moods Bostor The Poet Lore Oo Currier, A. H. The of Crime Boston Danish Fairy Tales Translated by J. G Cramer. Boston: Badger. $1 net Denman, F. H. From Babel to Brotherhood The Thwing Co. $1.60 net Dowd, E. C Polly of the Hospital Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1 net Elshemus, L. M My Brother Victor Th Dreamers Press. $1.25 net Philadelphia English Literat of Dryden Pu History of The Age of FEtart XIII, Revel Present Day Probl Badger $1 net Evans, Edwin Johannes Brahms: Vol. I, Handbook to the Vocal Works Scribner Fletcher, Margaret. The Fugitives. Long mans. $1.35 net Frankfurter Zeitung, Geschichté Frank furter Zeitung (American Agency, New York) Frith, Julius Alternating Current Desigt Van Nostrand $2 net Galeworthy, John. Moods, Songs, and Dog- gerels. Scribner. $1 net Gibbs, Philip. Oliver's Kind Women. Bos- ton: Dana Estes. $1.25 net

Page 28

324 The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2439 x ————— Gibbs, R. E. of Verse $1.50. Gillespie, Foy. tan Press. $1.50. Goldoni, Carlo rrans. by M. Pierson in Dramatic Society Hamel, Frank. tano. Hawkins, V. D. ondary Schools Longman Hebbel’s Agnes Bernauer. Ein Trauerspiel San Francisco: Madison Edited with notes, by M. B. Evans. Bos- ton: Heath 50 cents Hemmeon, J. C The History of the Brit- ish Post Office. Harvard Economic Stud- ies, Vol. VII Cambridge, Mass Herrick, G. F. Christian and Mohammedan Revell $1.25 net Hobbs, W. H Earth F¢ Meaning An Introduction to Geology Macmillar $9 net Holmes, Bayard. Friends of the Insane, and Other Essays Cincinnati: Lancet-Clinic Pub. Co Hughes, Rupert The Old Nest $i net Hynd-Lindsay \ Sweet June. (Poems.) Broadway Pub. Co 75 cents Irwin, Beatrice. The Pagan Trinity Lane e] net in, M.S Race Suicide Pr £1.50 Century. Cosmopolitan SS RE ‘DY THIS WEEE. The Squirrel-Cage By Dorothy Canfield J \ WILLIAMS $1.35 net } flon t vel of Ame rican life tt sympathies ind experiences hut > a i narily an absorb 1 real f family life io ator. Grant Allen’ $ Historical Guides in itself and sold separately, ers pocket salz $1.50 net g in a new form with enlargements md re t Their object t« to supplement ither ft nt compete with standard travellers’ med. tne It was Mr. Allen's purpose ft give hie reader the reenite of his own thirty-five years f foreign travel, and to explain to them in com- et for ' things not elsewhere htainable And | ‘ k abundantly full ill ite claims expound the } tory md meaning of ich work nt reader in such a position that u himeelf f the wathetic beauty nd success f the subject before hin Roaton Smaller Tuscan Towns By J. W. and A. M. Cruickshank ‘ Tuscany Massa Pisa, I I Lawes Pistoia, Prat Faatern re 1 Ares ‘ Tuacany —Em- M “t 7 Climignane, Stena, thern sarany—4 4. Quirte l'Oricta, J nu Vonter ean Monte Amiata Weatern \ Masen Marittima, Grosett Umbrian Towns res t! mt. and Illustrated rw ss. eS nt I KSHANK Venice. By Grant Allen Pdition Iiluetrated Classical Rome. By H. Stuart Jones “ well equipped for. the | f t ua tl nut Vatih Florence A ' luetrated by J. W 1A M crREICK HANK Christian Rome lit ! 1 tlhuetrated A.M CRUICKSHANK lenry Holt & Co., hes ven THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK For 1911 Now’ Ready St Songs of Content: A Volume Elder & Co. The Defenders. Cosmopoli- The Mistress of the Inn. Wiscon- Jean de la Fontaine. Bren- Applied Physics for Sec- atures and Their Isham, F. S. A Man and His Money. In- dianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill. $1.25 net. Jacoby, G. W. Suggestions and Psycho- therapy. Scribner. $1.50 net Japan Year-Book. 1912. Seventh Annual. Tokyo, Japan. Kellow, H. A. lish. Boston: Layton, W. T. An Introduction to the Study of Prices. Macmillan. 90 cents net. Leonard, W. E. Glory of the Morning: A Play in One Act. Madison: Wisconsin Dramatic Society. McConnell, R. M. Criminal Responsibility and Social Constraint. Scribner. $1.75 net. Macnaughton, S. Peter and Jane. Dodd, Mead. $1.25 net. Marivaux’ Le Jeu de l’Amour et du Hasard, Edited, with notes, by A. Fortier. Bos- ton: Heath. 35 cents. Morris, Gouverneur. It, and Other Stories. Scribner. $1.25 net. Newell, Cicero. Indian Stories Silver, Burdett. 650 cents. Orchestral Music. Catalogue Scores. Pre- pared under direction of O. G. T. Son- neck. Washington: Gov. Printing Office. $1. Partington, J. R. Higher Mathematics for Chemical Students. Van Nostrand. $2 net. Philbert, Leo. Mentor. 75 cents Potter, R. H. The Common Faith of Com- mon Men. Teachers College, Columbia University $1.08 net Practical Training in Eng- Heath Boston: | Robbins, Tod. Mysterious Martin. Co. $1, Broadway Pub. Co. | Ogilvie Pub. Robertson, G. S. The Law of Copyright. Frowde. Roz, Firmin. Le Roman Anglais Contempo- rain. Paris: Hachette. Scharff, R. F. Distribution and Origin of Life in America. Macmillan. $3 net. Schiller, F. C. S. Formal Logic. Macmil- lan. $3.25 net. Scott, Leroy. Counsel for the Defence. Doubleday, Page. $1.20. Social Evil: Report Prepared (in 1902) un- der the Direction of the Committee of Fifteen. Edited by E. R. A. Seligman. Second edition. Putnam. Spargo, J., and Arner, G. L. Elements of Socialism: A Text Book. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Stockton, F. R. The Lost Dryad. River- side, Conn.: Mrs. F. C. Bursch. $1. Sutherland, H. V. The Legend of Love. Des- mond FitzGerald. Suzzallo, Henry. The Teaching of Primary Arithmetic. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. 50 cents. The White Gods. London: T. Werner Lau- rie. Thomas-Stanford, Charles. About Algeria. Lane. $1.50 net. Tollemache, Stratford. Reminiscences of the Yukon. Longmans. $3.50 net. Watson, John. Children of the Resurrec- tion. Dodd, Mead. $1 net. THE DRUNKARD By GUY THORNE Author of “‘When it Waa Dark.’”’ A powerful novel written by a man of the world for men and wo- men of the world. To the general reader it is a strong story of deep human appeal. To those to whom drunkenness is a painful personal and social problem, it is the sympa- thetic revelation of the physical and mental state of the drunkard, which makes help for him possible. Probably the most startling and impressive story in any language concerned with the psychology of intemperance. In “When it Was Dark” the author proved his power of holding spell-bound a vast com- pany of readers. (Cloth, 12mo, $1.35 net; postpaid, $1.47.) JUST ISSUED. Vol. VIII. The Age of Dryden TheCambridgeHistory of English Literature Edited by A. W. Ward, Litt.D., and A. R. Waller, M.A. To be in 14 Volumes, Royal Svo, of about 600 pages each. Price, per volume, $2.50 net. This great work, when completed, will be the one indispensable history of English literature for the scholar’s library, and the best work of the kind for the reference library of the stu- dent. It will represent the last re- sults of scholarship and research. Send for Circular. NEW YORK LONDON STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 East 27th Street, New York CERAMIC ART By J. F. BLACKER Over 1,200 illustrations, 534 pages, $3.50 net. A practical guide for collectors of eld English pottery and china, combined with a history in pictures of the work of the old English master potters, LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston | NINETEENTH CENTURY ENGLISH | SAINT FRANCIS OF ASSISI: A BIOGRAPHY By JOHANNES JORGENSEN. Translated from the Danish, with the author's sanction by T. O'CONOR SLOANE, Ph.D. With 5 Illustrations. Svo. $3.00 net ; $3.16 by mail. Contents: Francis the Church Builder— Francis the Evangelist—God's Singer—Fran- cis the Hermit—Appendix: Authorities for the Biography of St. Francis of Assisi.— Index. Studies in Bistory, Economics and Public Law Edited by the Faculty of Political Sctence of Columbia University. The Labor Movement in France A Study in Revolutionary Syndicalism By LOUIS LEVINE, Ph.D. With an In- troduction by Professor Franklin H. Gid- dings. 8vo. Paper Covers, $1.50. Cloth, $2.00 i " PHYSIOGRAPHY By Arey, Bryant, Clendenin and Morrey A text-book for secondary schools. It emphasizes economic and human values, j}and meets the requirements o! college en- | trance. Cloth. 416 pp. Itlua, and maps. $1.25. D.C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago Longmans, Green, & Co., Publishers EUROPEAN YEARS The Letters of an Idle Man $2.00 net. Postpaid $2.14 AT ALL BOOKSTORES

Page 29

March 28, 1912]

The Nation

GEORGE THE THIRD AND CHARLES FOX: The Concluding Part of “The American Revolution.” By the Right Hon. SIR GEORGE OTTO TREVELYAN, Bart., O.M. Author of “The Life and Letters of Lord Macaulay,” and “The Early History of Charles James Fox.” In Two Volumes. Vol. I. With Map. Crown 8vo. $2.00 net; by mail, $2.18. “Its two volumes—of which the first is here, and the second is already more than half written—will carry Fox up to the moment which, so far as personal success was concerned, proved to be the culminating point of his whole career. Tney will likewise include, and com- plete, the history of the American Revolution—my tran- quil and pleasant occupation during the later years of a life much of which was passed in stormier waters.”— From the Preface. THE PERIPLUS OF THE ERYTHRAEAN SEA: Travel and Trade in the Indian Ocean by a Merchant of the First Century. Translated from the Greek and annotated by WILFRED H. SCHOFF, A.M., Secretary of the Commercial Mu- seum, Philadelphia. Illustrated. 8vo. Pp. vi+328. $2.00 net; by mail, $2.17. “Valuable and very useful, and deserves particular notice. . . . The value of the Periplus lies not in its literary merits, but in the importance of this very early account of the trade of the Indian Ocean, and of the settlements around its shores, concerning which until this time we possess almost nothing of an intelli- gent and comprehensive nature.”—Philadelphia Public

PRESENT PHILOSOPHICAL TENDENCIES By RALPH BARTON PERRY, Assistant Professor of Philosophy in Harvard University. S8vo. $2.60 net, by mail, $2.76. A critical survey of Naturalism, Idealism, Pragmat ism, and Realism, together with a synopsis of the phil osophy of William James Che Architerts’ Library A HISTORY OF ARCHITECTURAL DEVELOPMENT. In Three Volumes Vol. Ill. THE RENAISSANCE IN ITALY, FRANCE, AND ENGLAND. By F. M. SIMPSON, Architect, Professor of Architecture in the University of London; Fellow of the Royal Institute of British Architects. With 268 Illustra tions. Medium 8vo. Pp. xvi+359. $6.00 net. The new volume treats of the Architecture of the Renaissance in Italy, France, and England, and con cludes with a chapter dealing with the “revivals” of the last century, and the confusion in ideals which then pre- vailed. The different periods are treated distinctly, and the main characteristics of each period explained ALREADY PUBLISHED: Vol. I. Ancient, Early Christian, and Byzan- tine Architecture. With 180 Illustrations. $4.00 net. Vol. Il. Mediaeval Architecture. With 257 Illustrations. $6.00 net.

Ledger.

*,* A Prospectus will be Sent upon Request.

Published by.

Longmans, Green, & Co. 443-9 Fourth Ave. New York

Learn Latin to Speak is the common-sense in Latin; Palestra’s 30 pamphlets for class or self-instruction by figures, cuts, texts on subjects of daily life, supported by Roman authors; vast vocabulary, no translations; reading, writing, speaking exercises; half published; $2.50 will bring them all; com- plete $5.00; no samples. ARCADIVS AVEL- LANVS, 47 W. 52d Street. New York City.

“A notable brief for democracy that everybody ought to read,’’ says Mr. Os waLp GARRISON VILLARD One Way Out: A Middle-Class New Englander Emigrates to America By “WILLIAM CARLETON,” The most notable book of our day. Fifth Printing. $1.20 net; by mail, $1.32. Send for descriptive matter free. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston.

“It seems likely that Hauptmann’s THE FOOL IN CHRIST will ultimately take its place among the masterpieces of contemporary literature,” says Current Literature. (Price $1.50 net.) B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth ave., New York

A Charming Picture of French Home-Life A GARDEN OF PARIS By ELIZABETH WALLACE With dainty line drawings. Price. $1.25 net. At all Bookstores. A. C. MeCLURG & Co., Publishers, Chicago

Bend for <7 TAUCHNITZ FOREIGN SCHOENHOF BOOK Batis BOOKS ‘xt ere A AUTH A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y¥. A new catalogue of second hand Americana, now ready, and will be sent to any address.

IMPORTANT BOOKS ON TROPICAL FEVERS By Sir Rubert Boyce, F.R.S. YELLOW FEVER AND ITS PRE- oo ES ee fT HEALTH PROGRESS AND AD- MINISTRATION IN THE WEST INDIES .ncccccccsccscccccce NOt $8.50 MOSQUITO OR MAN........Net $3.50 By Major Roland Ross, F.R.S., C.B. THE PREVENTION OF MALA- BEER. soccsccvccsvercssccseeecWte Qaee Descriptive Circular on Application. E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 West 23rd St., New York

THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE Ed, by PORTER-CLARKE, Text of 1623, Full Notes and Variants Ready “‘Midsommer Night's Dreame,"’ ‘‘Love's Labour's Lost.’’ ‘Comedie of Errors,’’ ‘‘Merchant of Venice,"" “‘Machbeth,"’ ‘“‘Julius Cesar,’ Ham let." “‘King Lear,.’’ ‘“‘Twelfe Night.’’ “‘As You Like It,’’ ‘‘Henry the Fift,"’ ‘“‘Much Adoe About Nothing,’’ “Romeo and Jullet,’’ **Tempest,’’ “Othello,”" ‘“‘Winter’s Tale,’’ ‘‘Shrew,"’ ‘Two Gen tlemen of Verona,’’ ‘‘Coriolanus,’’ ‘‘Merry Wives,"’ “All's Well,’’ ‘‘Measure for Measure,’’ ‘‘Aatonle and Cleopatra.’’ ‘“‘Titus Andronicus."’ “‘Tymon of Athens,’ ‘Pe ricles " —"'Oymbeline,’’ ‘*Troylus,’’ “Richard = ITIl,"’ ‘Richard 11," “King Johao,”’ “Henry IV’’-—-Part I Henry IV’ Part I! Cloth, 75 cents; limp leather, $1.00 per volume postpaid Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.. New York

Dynemic Syllabication and the universal ‘selfa,gzem World Romic notation used in Dictionary of Hard Words (postpaid $1.32), Die- tionary of Aviation (postpaid $1.45), and Ideofonic Texts for Acquiring Lan- guages (postpaid, cloth 60c, paper 3ic) By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE LANGUAGES COMPANY, 143 W. 47th St.,N.Y.

Travels in the Confederation, 1783-'84 From the German of Schoepf by Alfred J. Morrison ‘“‘An invaluable record of the early infancy of our national life."'—Chicago Record Heraid “A work of peculiar interest."’"——London Con- temporary Review 2 wolsa., with portrait, 86 net. | WILLIAM J. CAMPBELL, 1623 Chestnut St., Phila.

| AMATEUR BOOK COLLECTING,.—tTen les- sons of value, $5.00. Personal advice as to given | editions, etc., included. C. A. Herrick, Delaware, O. IN FABLELAND By EMMA SERL BOOK worth giving to a child a book that every hild should read and re-read. The wisdom and humor of thirty-four of A€sop's im- mortal fables is set forth in modern dialogue. Illustrated with charming line drawings, printed in color Price, 45 conta SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO

LOUISE BE. DEW, LITERARY REP ye

~e-9 ripte wanted Circular ” request Send 25 centa for booklet “EPROM ” HE EDI. TOR S VIEW POINT.” 156 Fifth Ave., N. ¥ For Rent fr 'RNISHED HOUSE in Cambridce, Mass., next the Longfellow House, to rent for winter seasen 1912-13: 4 master’s living rooms kitchen, laundry, and drying-room 6 master's bedrooms, 2 baths, 3 servants and 1 trunk-root Occupancy given after August 1, 1912 A owner at 113 Brattle Street

Page 30

as he e N a at i on [Vol. 94, No. 2439 Economic Dilees NINTH YEAR In order to arouse an interest in the study of topics relating to commerce and industry, and to stimulate those who have a college training to consider the problems of a business career, a com- mittee composed of Professor J. Laurence Laughlin, University of Chicago, chairman; Professor J. B. Clark, Columbia University; Professor Henry C. Adams, University cf Michigan; Horace White, Esq., New York City, and Professor Edwin F. Gay, Harvard University, has been enabled, through the generosity of Messrs. Hart, Schaffner & Marx, of Chicago, to offer in 1913 four prizes for the best studies in the economic field. In addition to the subjects printed below, a list of available subjects proposed in past years can be had on application. Attention is expressly called to the rule that a competitor is not confined to topics proposed in the announcements of this committee, but any other subject chosen must first be approved by it. Is a money trust possible? How far is competition actually crippled to-day in American industries? A study of various forms of combination. Recent developments of the German Kartel. A study of the industrial effects of the dissolution of the tobacco trust. Methods of forcing employers to accept the demands of labor unions. How far is the theory of trust regulation applicable to labor unions? A study of the code of ethics peculiar to labor unions. on SW DON Class B includes only those who, at the time the papers are sent in, are undergraduates of any Americah college. Class A includes any other Americans without restriction; the possession of a de- gree is not required of any contestant in this class, nor is any age limit set. A First Prize of One Thousand Dollars, and A Second Prize of Five Hundred Dollars are offered to contestants in Class A. A First Prize of Three Hundred Dollars, and A Second Prize of Two Hundred Dollars are offered to contestants in Class B. The committee reserves to itself the right to award the two prizes of $1,000 and $500 of Class A to undergraduates in Class B, if the merits of the papers de- mand it. The winner of a prize shall not receive the amount designated until he has prepared his manuscript for the printer to the satisfaction of the committee. lhe ownership of the copyright of successful studies will vest in the donors, and it is expected that, without precluding the use of these papers as theses for higher degrees, they willcause them to be issued in some permanent form Competitors are advised that the studies should be thorough, expressed in good = any and although not to length, they should not be needlessly expanded. They should be inscribed with an assumed name, the limited as class in which they are presented, and accompaniéd by a sealed envelope giving the real name and address of the competitor. If the competitor is in CLASS B, the sealed envelope should contain the name of the institution in which he is studying. The papers should be sent on or before June 1, 1913, to J. Laurence Laughlin, Esq. The University of Chicago Chicago, Illinois

Page 31