The Nation 1912-03-07: Vol 94 Iss 2436
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
| e of ‘@ ; MAR =o Wiz eC AL™ OM, of we > M0,“ 'V. of mic %) Rae OES Se ac VOL. XCW. —NO. 2436 THURSDAY, MARCH 7, 1912 nee CS =6PRICE TEN CENTS By RUDOLF EUCKEN/ The Problem of Human Life Recent Importations Professor of Philosophy in the A new edition of Professor Fucken's famous work, called University of Jena. forth by the appreciation the original has received in this The Story of Korea country, and published at a price which puts it within the By JOSEPH H. LONGFORD the B23 illustrations and 3 maps Translated by Williston S. ‘ reach of a wider circle of readers than was the case in $3.00 net ‘ net. earlier edition Hough, of George Washington sone : 4 ene ther Gen 1900 University, and W. R. Boyce- Professor Eucken, then, has written a work which is an years before the Christian Era to se , ‘ in tant ac as s 0 ilos ore ’ the Japanese annexation, fully de Gibson, of the University of iportan addition to the treasures of philosophical literature, ecriptive of every aapect of the massive in content, masterly in its comprehensiveness, and country and the life led by ite Melbourne. thoroughly original.”"—Hibbert Journal (Prof, F. Granger). inhabitants 2.00 net Countries and Peoples Series ThePhilosophy of theEnlightenment Boch Vatome {itestreted Japan of the ja A Volume in the Epochs of Philosophy Series “A lucid, compact, enjoyable account of the course of philo By JOSEPH H. LONGFORD sophik a thought in the age that stretched from Locke throug! A ble, graphic description of ele . , nant to es na Vis the Japanese people thelr country Be rk ley, Hume, Leibnitz, and Rousseau to it nat iral climax and their life, which aime G@ret of in the ere and co-ordinating mind of Kant London to make the reader acquainte Post $1.50 net; postpaid $1.65 ‘ the Japanese’s personality Be lctam of the Be igians ADefence of Prejudice and OtherEssays by DEMETRIUS C. BOULGER Turkey of the ottomans By JOHN’GRIER HIBBEN President of Princeton University Editor of the Epochs of Phil- “He has yielded to the impulse to transla his v i I LUCY M. GARNETT osophy Series. t into the language of everyday life and apply it t tion of practical problems of the hour rhe essays are plea ingly written in simple, straightforward, effective Englis! Spain of the Spanish There is not a technical term in the ! Italy of the Itallans book.’ Yale Review France of the French “It is with delight—a calm and rational delight—that reflective reader makes his way through this little book The Dial. $1.00 net. Germany of the Germans Switserland of the Swiss TheCommonPeopleof Ancient Rome A Naturaliat on ‘As a vivid picture of daily life among the common peopl By 0. B. LOWS, iiusteated of Rome, with their language, their occupations, their senti- apg” ; : : ments, and their amusements, this volume can hardly be ex- ~ — ~— _ ‘condi eee elled. . . An amazingly real insight into men and poli- slands of the Caribbean Sea tics in the greatest city in the world nearly 2.000 vears ago.” which includes the description of Chicago Record-Herald $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.65 the life of a veritable Robins l f Americans By FRANK FROST ABBOTT Professor of Classics in Prince- ton University. Crusoe family of Peopl d Politics of A tR ine Great cop es an OLITICS O ncien ome the Great Thirat SPORT AND TRAVEL IN THE “Not only delightful reading, but brings the Romans within KALAHARAI!I DESERT reach of our human sympathies. . . . The twentieth century By LIEUT. ARNOLD W. HOD American comes into every-day relations with the Romans in sen ee pH U. Selous their streets and homes, and discovers that some disheartening tions. $3.50 net. aspects of BOC iety, which he has assumed *o be modern, are of On , ™ . 9° n oraepac ancient date.”—The Outlook $1.25 net Through Nigeria Ry J. D. FALCONER. With 32 lliustrations and a map. §3.50 The French Revolution a page illustra set . An act nt of an adventurous and A Political History oe Ses ee ee ae “Readers who are familiar with their Thiers and Carlyle te lh a4 Africa known as By A. AULARD their Tocqueville and Taine, have never heard the name of : ee Aulard; and yet Aulard has done more to promote the scien ae, Sanatene Professor of Letters at the Uni- jtific study of the French Revolution than all of the above By ARTHUR P. COLEMAN versity of Paris. / mentioned gentlemen taken together. . . . His work is that Ph.D... F.R.S Ww 3 mape of a ripe scholar, who has lived with his sources, printed and and 41 {llustrations. $3.50 net Translated from the French | manuscript, for a quarter of a century, and who sees his sub- Argentine Piains of the third edition, with a /ject as a whole. He advances no statement without the sup and Andine Gineters : rows . 2 e ateris a} : ave ind tea ‘ By WALTER ARDEN ae preface, notes, and historical J Port of valuable source material, and always indicates wha + Mag ae wonal Nawal te . “ i Miall this source is that the reader may control his work. What : gin ng College M ind 94 summaries, by Bernard Miall. mass of evidence often lies behind a single sentence, what an illustrations $3.75 net amount of labor has prece led a single ca itious generalizati My Climbing Adventures \only the initiated can know The Dial in Four Continents In four volumes. The sect, $8.00 net B AMURL F ae R. R Pl b . St db Famous Casties and A Palinces of Italy PLAYS BY ays Dy Augus rin erg hy FE. B. D'AUVERGNE, author AUGUST STRINDBERG Strindberg, the foremost figure in Scandinavian literature . — ; ~y- = ( ~yoe i o~ ¢ }to-day, and admittedly one of the greatest of living drama- olates. $3.75 — a Translated from the Swedish \ tists, is represented in this volume by three of his most char (ie hee Gene vary wall. and wm with an introduction by Edwin /@cteriste plays—“The Dream Play”; “The Link,” in one act duced a very interesting end valn ‘ ‘ y and “The Dance of Death,” Part I. and Il., a drama of: tr able work, which will be read Bjorkman. With portrait. $1.50 |. naous power, generally considered his masterpiece and treas red sali ; ow PP 1 legranp net; postpaid $1.65. ‘ Phila y Telegrap $1.50 net; postpaid $1.65 CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS BJ 153-157 FIFTH AVE, NEW YORK
Page 2
— Sa The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post Office as a nd-clase mati matter.) The Nation s 1 and owned by the New York } I ( Oswald Garrison Villard, Presid \ " J Pattison Treasurer; Paul Elmer M Ed r H ld deWolf Fuller, As sistant Ed Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in my part of the United States or Mexico; to Canada $3.50. and to foreign untriea comprised in the Postal Union $4.00 iddresea THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office 20 Veaey Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. i \\ 29 Ep RIA AR i What I elt Mea 226 It r ing the Judiciar 2ai Ir t ir i l iT i ! Ta 227 Rep f h Facts Co j 7 2°98 rt ( let i ooo Spt \ ART Georg Brand t " 0 ‘ for Bi 21 Cc PO | rar ( ! Yor} ~—* af 9 32 t B ird and i 232 rt Ad t ty i of é he Ca f High P Possibl Mot ! nti la 234 Li ‘ | William Pitt and t ( i Vat 4 Paradia« Farm 3 | Gods and Mr. Perrin 235 r? Fool in Chri r? Indian Lily 1 ou tor! St " of th rimberland 236 rt Vitalit f Plato ind Other } i 236 ] | f t I Lif of t | f | to Tolisto aod | fu It s I " R l s Sci } } \ i I i | 42 ly 4 Mi | Vi ‘4 An ' 245 FI ANC ttad : i Market 46 hn WW 246 * © © Coples f The Nation may be procured to Paris t Rrentano’s 17 Avenne de l'Opéra: in London of BR. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square Charing Cross ‘The Natio Ih [Vol. 94, No. 2436 Educational Travel I Me FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisx & Co., Proprietors. 25 Park Street, Boston 1845 U St., Washington 6 FifthAve.,.NewYork 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland S14 Steger Bd.,Chicago {3 DouglasBd., LosAngeles 120 Sav. Bk. Bd..Denver 345 Wright Bik. Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Marual. Harlan P. French, Prop Vincent B, Fisk, Mgr. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Knows w fwenty-one years of successful ex- ere n bringing together good teachers and good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask f bulletin 20 and see for yourself. WEST VIRGINIA, Lewisburg, Drawer 5 » Cal 4 N . ,Preparatory am ol- Lewisburg Seminary jece courses for girls. Also Music Art, FElocution Business Strong facults f experienced § specialists. Handseme, nedern buildings, steam heat, ete. Gymnasium, basket ball, tennis. Invigorating mountain climate. Catalogue upon request R. C. Sommerville, Pres Institute Athenaeum - Munich 26 HERZOG RUDOLFSTRASSE 26 for boys. Outdoor time. iss boarding school Individual training Bracing climate Entrance any Day sports. IIVATE BOARDING SCHOOL in the German university town Bonn would take girls from 12-18 years old; beginning Octeber, 1912. German, French, Piano and other branches. Good references. JOHANNA HINZEN, Zilpich, Rheinland. Briarcliff? Manor, New York MRS. DOW’S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS For cireular address Mrs. MARY EB. DOW, Prin. Ph.D. OF GOETTINGEN, AGE 31, v4 native of Belfast, author of ‘*Tudor-Stuart Views of English," with experience in University work, now teaching, is open for an engagement in in American University Apply to University, care of The Nation. ETE aS okt La Just Published A REVISED EDITION OF Montgomery's Leading Facts of English History that has American The history ind-by of been for years the schools. No other textbook has ever surpassed it In clarity of treatment, completeness and reliability It presents in brief compass the most im- portant points in the development of the English nation, and covers all the ground ordinarily covered by a high-school course. The revision embodies an extensive re- writing of the previous edition It includes at new maps and twenty-five new Illustrations, together with a new and superior letter- press throughout Teachers who desire to make a special study of Constitutional His- tory will be greatly alded by the revised Summary on that subject and by the im- portant Constitutional Documents contained at the back of the book Price $1.20. GINN AND COMPANY Boston NewYork Chicago London Atlanta Dallas Columbus San Francisco IN FABLELAND By EMMA SERL BOOK worth giving to a child a book that every child should read and re-read The wisdom and humor of thirty-four of A€sop’s im- ortal fables is set forth in modern dialogur Illustrated with charming line drawings printed in color. Prtee i SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO rntea EDINBURGH REVISITED By JAMES BONE Illustrated in collotype and line from drawings by HANSLIP FLETCHER Cloth $5.00 net. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Publishers, sro Our Tours are in effect pri- vate parties—practically inde- pendent travel. Personally escorted, avoiding crowds, annoyance and unnecessary * expense. Spring Tours ITALY, ALGERIA SPAIN, RIVIERA Summer Tours North Cape, Russia, British Isles, Balkan States, Germany, France, Special Swiss Tours. Steamship Reservations via all Lines Send for Book ef Tours | Raymond & Whitcomb Co. Chicago, Pitts- burgh, Detroit, San Francisco 06 Washington St Boston 225 Fifth Avenue, New York 1005C hestnutSt. Philadelphia | *. UNIVERSAL TALFAGAM DYNAMIC SYLLABICATION DICTIONARIES By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE Dictionary of Aviation. 257 p. cloth $1.40; post paid $1.45 (| Baker & Taylor Co., New York Dictionary of Hard Words, 645 p. cloth $1.20; postpaid $1.32§| Dodd, Mead & Co., New York In Preparation — Dictionary of Architecture; Dictionary of Filology; Dictionary of Names; Dictionary of Rime; Fonetic Dic- tionaries of Modern English and Modern French ; French-English Dictionary of Names. Send for circulars and sample works of Mr. pogee of these and other LANGUAGES COMPANY, 143 W. 47th St, N.Y. THE STUDY OF ANIMALS A LABORATORY GUIDE By Whitney, Lucas, Shinn, and Smallwood A course for secondary schools. The number of type-forms studied is large, and economic values are given prominence. Cloth. 200 pages 50 centa. D.C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere. 155 vols., pocket size. List prices, cloth, 35c. per vol.; limp leather, 75c. per vol. (Special prices to schools and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y.Croweil&Co.,New York BOOKS—All out-of-print books supplied, ne matter on what subject; write me, stating books wanted: I can get you any book ever published ; when in England, call and inspect my stock of 50.000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, Joho Bright St., Birmingham, England. FRE irs. 128 Tremont St - AUTHORS BOSTON, MASS. AMERICANS: An Impression By Alerander Francis A. 8. Clark, Peel.skill, N. Y., is a buyer and seller of books, magazines, and pam- phiets
Page 3
March 7, 1912] THE DRAMA A QUARTERLY REVIEW OF DRAMATIC LITERATURE EDITOR: CHARLES HUBBARD SERGEL ADVISORY AND CONTRIBUTING EDITORS : MATTHEWS, Columbia DICKINSON University of Wisconsin University of Chicago Harvard University BRANDER University THOMAS H ROBERT HERRICK GEORGE P. BAKER, RICHARD BURTON, University of Minnesota STARK YOUNG, of Texas BENEDICT PAPOT, Chautauqua Institution University THE DRAMA has become, in less than a year, indispensable to the follower of the worthy ac- tivities of the contemporaneous stage.’’-- Chicago Record- He: ald. The current number February, 1912, contains: HENRY BECQUE, by Benedict Papot. THE CROWS (complete), a Comedy in Four Acts, by Henry Becque, trans- lated by Benedict Papot SHAKESPERE’S ROMANTIC COME- DIES, by Brander Matthews STEELE MACKAYE, Dynamic Artist of the American Theatre; an Outline of his Life Work, by Percy Mac- Kaye AND OTHER ARTICLES. SIX Send Seventy-five Cents for Sample Copy or Three Dollars for a Year's Subscription. PUBLISHBD BY The Dramatic Publishing Co. 2 SOUTH DEARBORN ST. CHIC AG@ EUROPEAN YEARS | The Letters of an Idle Man $2.00 net. Postpaid $2.14 AT ALL BOOKSTORES The Nation The Boston Transcript says: il AliLt A Le TANTE By Anne Douglas Sedgwick The i { a ( executed, en! i D ( r ~ . ome . } : . ‘ in Oriiiance, l l i f i ye The Cleveland Plain Dealer says: In n er-dra Price 81.20 net; postage 14 cents. THE CENTURY CO. AN IMPORTANT BOOK Just Published! THE FULL RECOGNITION OF JAPAN Being a detailed account of the economic progress of the Japanese Empire to 1911. By ROBERT P PORTER Medium Svo, with seven colored maps, $4.00 Just the book for a traveller to the Far East to carry with him and study on the journey, if he wishes to take an intelligent survey of the interest- ing people whom he is to visit.” Times Literary Supplement (Eng.) For Sale by all Booksellers, or will be sent postpaid by the publiashera on receipt of price Oxford University Press American Branch 35 West 32d Street, New York For Sale YOUR SALE, AT PUINT LOWXOU 7, Psle au Haut, a cottage and a lot of about four aeres. Cottage has large sitting room, writ ing room, and two bedrooms on the first floor, and five bedrooms en the second floor. four bathrooms, and all modern conveniences. It commands, from the windows, views of the Camden Hills, Deer Isle, and the mountains of Mt. Desert. The cli mate is the best on the coast—excessive beat is never known, and, being twenty miles from the mainiand, the climate is exceptionally equable, the variation at times in twenty-four hours being even less than two degrees. The itsland is about 7 miles long by 2 miles wide, and the summit of the meuntain is about 600 feet above tide. A fresh water lake, of more than a mile in length, is stocked with land-locked salmon A road of thir GREEK - ENGLISH DICTIONARY A VOCABULARY OF THE ATTIC LANGUAGE By 8. C. WOODHOUSE, M, A. Late Scholar Christ Church, Oxford 85.00 Net W oodhouse’s English-Greek Diction- ary has already received the hearty endorsement of well-known classical scholars of both England and Amer ca, and has been introduced into a number of the chief institutions of learning in both countri: teen miles around the island affords charming views, and gives access to cliffs rivalling those of - ° Mt. Desert For terms, apply to Ernest W. Bow- E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY diteh, 60 Devonshire Street, Boston, Mass. 21 West 23rd St.. Mow York For Rent Inspiring and Informative. THOMAS D. MURPHY'S new book FN an gt HOUSE in Cambridge, Mass... next the Longfellow House, to rent for winter season 1912-13; 4 master’s living rooms, kitchen. laundry. and drying-room; 6 master’s bedrooms, 2 baths, 3% servants’. and 1 trunk-room Occupancy given after August 1, 1912 Apply to owner at 113 Brattle Street THREE WONDERLANDS OF THE AMERICAN WEST Beantifally illustrated, boxed, net $3.00; postpaid $3.30 L. C. PAGE & COMPANY, Pablishe-s, BOSTON “AtMcCLURG’S” It is of interest and in po lanes to Librarians to know that the hooks reviewed and advertised in this magazine In be pu chased from ws at advantage ous pl es by Public Libraries, Schools, Colleges and Universities In addition to have an eptionally large f the books of all pub these hooks sfrock o omplete a8 lishers a more sortment the can be found on the shelves of ay other book sfore in the entire juntry We solicit co respondence from hrarians unacquainted u fin ilities our fa LIBRARY DEPARTMENT A. C. McClurg & Co. CHICAGO ) “A actable brief for democracy that everybody eught to read,"’ saye Mr. OswaLp Ganaison Visage One Way Out: A Middle-Class New Englander Emigrates to America By “WILLIAM CARLETON,” The moat of our day Fifth Printing. 81.20 net; by mall, $1.32. Bend for deacriptive matter free. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers. Boston. F. M. HOLLY Authors’ and Publishers’ Representative FifthAyv,,.New York notahle hook Circulars sent upon request. 1
Page 4
bed o {| The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2436 Important Macmillan Spring Publications A NEW DANBY NOVEL “ JOSEPH IN JEOPARDY ” By FRANK DANBY (Mrs. Julia Frankau), Author of “The Heart of a Child,” “Sebastian,” etc. rilliar of a young man who, exposed to subtle and intellectual temptations, resists them successfully in iti nd striking situations ind bred manipulation of delicate themes, the wit, humor, and epigram, with a “thread of gold” r through the which distinguish this versatile author's previous successes are again manifest perhaps ip a hig legr in tl her latest novel Reviewing her worth The tcademy (London) deser'|be the author as “the greatest woman writer now living in England.” Cloth, 12mo, $1.35 net; postpaid, $1.45. THE WONDERFUL LITTLE BOOK. Special Easter Edition UTTER By Kathleen Norris ‘ i elg l ati mbhiar Ml Roose t and | e profoundly ij ressed with ‘Mother.’ I am particularly glad to have it.”—Theodore Decorated cloth, gilt top, 12mo, $1.25. ZANGWILL’S LATEST WORK THE WAR GOD. A Tragedy in Five Acts By ISRAEL ZANGWILL, Author of “The Melting Pot,” “The Children of the Ghetto,” et: rival nations which will be recognized readily, this powerful story—a com- t most powerful dramatic work of the season.” $1.25 net; by mail, $1.34 Decorated cloth, 12mo, A Fascinating Record of Travel, Adventure, and Antiquarian Discovery RUINS OF DESERT CATHAY Personal Narrative of Explorations in Central Asia and Westernmost China. By M. Aurel Stein graphic descripti of the archeological end geographical expedition undertaken by Dr. Aurel Stein for the G t of India } ne . ind j rich and almost unparalleled harvest of priceless memorials, manuscript and ot rt sure The Daily Chronicle CLondon) volu Prof ] trated, color plates, panorama, original maps. $12.50 net; erpressage exrtru. PANAMA By Albert Edwards ind cheaper edition of the best book on Panama for the general reader lilustrated. Decorated cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.62. OTHER NOTABLE NEW MACMILLAN BOOKS THE NEW DEMOCRACY. By Walter E. Weyl, Ph.D. \ brilliant interpretation of the Industrial, Social and Moral Revolution now going on in the United States.”— Philadelphia Public Ledge Cloth, 12mo, $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.12. DEMOCRATIC ENGLAND. By Percy Alden, M.P. \ brilliant study of the humanistic movement and the important social problems which to-day have partly led the gulf between British political parties and classes to the advantage of the entire community. Cloth, gilt top, 12mo, $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.62. ELEMEN’ rs OF es IALISM. By John Spargo and Dr. Geo. Louis Arner rhe omprehensive and sane presentation of the Socialist case yet made, Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net. (Subject to change.) ESSE NTIAL S OF SOCIALISM. By Ira B. Cross explanation of the arguments for and against Socialism. Just the book for i! co partial ind brief the busy readet Cloth, 12mo, $1.00; postpaid, $1.08. SOCIALISM AND THE ETHICS OF JESUS. By Henry C. Vedder \ notable comparison of the ethics of Christianity with modern Socialism Cloth, 12mo $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.62. THE MODERN WOMAN'S RIGHTS MOVEMENT. By K. Schirmacher lated from the German by Dr. Carl C. Eckhardt of Colorado ll and co lete d ription of the world-wide movement for women’s rights Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.60. THE SOCIAL ASPECTS OF EDU CATION. By Professor Irving King, of the State University of Iowa. ] » of th relations of th hool to the community as an instrument for social progress. Cloth, 12mo, $1.75 net. (Subject to change.) ALL THE CHILDREN QF ALL THE PEOPLE. By Witioss Hawley Smith, Author of “The Evolution of Dodd.” \ f r at f © atte of the lt ted Stat educate “all the children of all the people” and the present oblet Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.61. fran nad i } FARM BOYS AND GIRLS. By William A. MeKeover, Professor of Philosophy in Kansas State Agricultural f An interesting study of the rural hon haracter, development, environment. and related topics /iluatrated. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net. (Subject to change). THE NEW HISTORY. By James Harvey Robinson, Ph. D., Professor of History in Columbia University \ opular account of the great revolution vertaking h'storical study through the fundamental, social and intel- “ler { Cloth, \2mo, $1.50 net. (Subject to change.) tua inges by red THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “tien
Page 5
The NEW YORK, THCORSDAY, MARCH 7, 1912. The Week The report that Vice-President Sher- man has been chosen by the Taft lead- ers for running-mate to the President is emphatically, and apparently author- denied. Mr. Taft is amazingly ill-advised, the denial will be itatively, Unless adhered to and borne out by the facts. Such an attachment to Mr. Taft’s can- didacy would manifestly be a disastrous handicap in the electoral campaign, and there is good reason for believing that it would operate almost as disastrously in the nomination campaign. The dan- ger to Taft lies in the question of the final attitude of those persons who are not unfriendly to him, but who have ob- jected to certain features of his record, and who, though they may not be Pro- big P, and soberly progressive. are sincerely About the best gressives with a way to alienate such men is to tie him up with Sherman, and especially to fast- en upon him the responsibility for the selection. The choice of Sherman four years ago was not in pursuance of Mr. Taft’s desire or judgment, but was the to result of the efforts of men close Roosevelt. Mr. Taft's preference was for the late Senator Dolliver, perhaps the ablest of the Western Progressives. If he and his advisers are sagacious, they will look for a man of somewhat that type as his associate in the can- didacy. Mr. Taft’s attitude towards the Mexi- can revolt continues to be wholly ad- mirable. Once we put aside the unfor- tunate manner in which last year’s mo- bilization was initiated, the Administra- tion’s bearing in the face of a difficult situation has reflected credit on the en- tire American people, and served as the best possible rejoinder to the reflections frequently cast upon our motives with regard to the Latin Americans. When we speak of the situation as difficult, we have in mind not Mexico alone, The Administration has been under severe pressure to take aggressive action A man of differ- on the Mexican frontier. ent temperament from Mr. Taft's, and of a more complicated sense of right and wrong, might have found sufficient rea- son for intervention by this time. And especially in a Presidential year when parties pant after political capital as the hart after the water brooks, an Ad- election ministration facing a dubious might be tempted to inject the khaki element into the contest. But one finds it utterly impossible to think of Mr. Taft playing a game of this nature. of to President Taft’s re-statement his which he Mr. Francis E. Leupp for publication in the that He is schedule, based Board a per- of tariff views, gave Outlook, carries him over ground he has already made familiar. for revision, schedule by upon the findings of the Tariff The manent latter he would continue as body, acting as a fountain information for manufacturers and mer- chants as well as for Congress. In some Mr. Taft departs of of his expressions, widely from the accepted notions protectionists, declaring, for example, that protective duties are designed to help only those who are “economically helping, not to provide an am- for On the other hand, he now slips worth bulance the helpless or the lag- gards.” back to the plank of the 1908 platform which undertakes to guarantee a “reas- onable profit” to the American manufac- This had been quietly dropped and turer. by the President in his speeches messages, doubtless because he perceiv- ed that it made meaningless or decep- tive the talk of basing duties upon the difference in cost of production at home and abroad. If it is really a question of the Government insuring a “reasonable the laggards profit,” the helpless and are as much entitled to it as anybody else. Hansborough’'s To ex-Senator charges that Mr. Roosevelt ordered the grave pigeonholing of the proposed prosecu- tion of the Harvester Trust while he was President, there now come the familiar sweeping denials. It is all a “lie made out of whole cloth,” not worthy of notice But Mr. Hansborough is not thereby cast down. He returns to the attack in the New York World, declaring that his statements are based on knowledge, and then he asks these specific questions: Nation ‘Does the Colonel deny that he told me that he would prosecute the Harvester Trust on the Townsend report [made to Attorney-General Bonaparte]? Does he deny that he wrote a letter to Attor- ney-General Bonaparte directing him not to prosecute the Harvester Trust? Mr. Roosevelt may, of course, continue to ignore the charge. That is his priv ilege. Mr. Bonaparte, who is now out for Roosevelt, may also take the digni- fled attitude of refusing to answer these pecific questions. But the facts in the ase ought to be, and, we are inclined to nk, will be, brought out soon It is not denied that Attorney-General Wick- ham is now proceeding against the Trust, and there is in existen re over, the Stanley Committee, ch has the power to omipel the Depa it ol Justice to produce any letters in gard to the proposed Roosevelt prosec on 1907 if there be such on file. We sin- erely trust that the matter will be uickly probed to the bottom » that this “peculiarly iniquitou falsehood” ay be exposed. A long and somewhat hysterical at- tack upon Gov. Harmon has been pub- lished by the so-called “Progressive Democrats” of Ohio. In it they make many railing accusations against the Governor, not all of which those un familiar with the intricacies of Ohio politics will be able to weigh intelli- gently. But in one point the supposed odium poured upon Gov. Harmon will appear to disinterested outsiders really The house” to be praise. charge is that he has not “cleaned in Ohio, and that, despite his having been Governor for more than three years, there are still as many as 1,500 Republicans holding office under him—nearly as many as the Democrats whom he has appointed to official position This may seem an awful crime to Democrats whose “pro- gressiveness” means progre towards the swine-trough of spoils, but to those vho believe in the ideas of civil service eform, and the continuance of efficient public servant in office despite t party preference Harmon has had a feather stuck ap by his enemies It is not nec essary to impute sordid
Page 6
Baltimore otel. mana t whose action the Secretary National Committee immemorial hotel I ‘ risen in convention cities that could not have t bout t mere agreement favored spot oper price n and around it in as a violent in ction of gold To profit oper pon prices in general blame ‘ 01 ; Constitutional the Gove of rnotr \ hole Ve xed ques- tion « authority of a Legislature rhe ord occur in the message in hich G Osborn has summoned the lature in extraordinary session the purpose of enacting a Presiden tial preference primary law. What leads the utterance is an awkward pro on in the Michigan Constitution em powering the Legislature to give imme diate effect to acts which either mak: ippropriations or are necessary for the ervation of the public peace, heaith, or safety As it is not evident that a Presidential primary falls exactly un- either of these classes, the Governor eminds the legislators that half of the bills to which they gave immediate ef- fect in their last session were not ap- propriation bills in the ordinary mean- ng of the term, and that above a fourth of them carried no appropriation what “was just Be- a pro- evel And the Constitution as sacred last year as this year.” uch a law might contain ion for paying the expenses of dele- But he has little patience with line of 1 e kind asoning, which he regards t) of subterfuge that would be resorted to by those who desire to use the Constitution against the interest of the people. The great fact is that courts and lawyers of the better sort “now gard the Constitution as being broad and elastic enough to cover and warrant vhat is right, and especially when t no dispute ag to the right. Abraham Lincoln said: ‘The life of this natior greater than any Conatitu- tion And, of course, an oath to up- hold the Constitution is taken—in Mich- igan—in a purely Pickwitkian sense Nation ‘The The decision of the Supreme Court of Ilinois that an appropriation of $60,000 for the Medical School of the State Uni- because, not having had a conference committee report, versity is invalid been printed after it been made part of it “was not passed in the mode pre- scribed by the Constitution,” is not like- ly to have the sweeping effect upon oth- er and more important legislation of the last forty years that was at first feared. Every such law will have to be im- pugned separately, and will ed upon its own particular set of cir- session of to validate of the de- cumstances, while a special the Legislature can be called it if The teeth cision are in its implied warning against the necessary. future in Il- linois is one of the States that impose the length of the but, one of the rushed through in laws the same eleventh-hour confusion. no restriction upon legislative session, by strange inconsistencies of our political theories, the closing hours of her Leg- islatures have long been marked by a law-making. pandemonium of association of business men What can do to promote the general welfare, affairs, an well its own private is the as as by Illinois Bankers’ This deavoring to bring the private banks of Illinois under control of the State Bank- being shown Association. organization is en- ing Department, to cause regulation and restriction of so-called investment stocks, and to introduce habits of thrift and cautious investment among the peo- ple. But the association does not con- fine its energies to these purely finan- cial matters. Its wider activities in- clude the promotion of modern methods as applied to farming, and a campaign for the construction of better roads. It create a system of field demonstrations has also a bill before Congress to of the most approved agricultural prac- tice. This reaching out to economic re- form gn the part of bankers has been approved by the citizens of Illinois. It is evidence of the growing and wholesome tendency among techni- cal men and men of affairs to employ their special knowledge and exceptional heartily facilities for the public good. That graduates are neither scholars nor practical men may now be regarded as established by frequent rep- of both of the assertion. college etition parts be defend-| [ Vol. 94, No. 2436 ‘It is apparently one of those melan- choly truths to which we must yield in the end, and to this particular one we have become somewhat’ reconciled. But this only makes it harder to accept the further and more serious criticism that college men are not markedly superior to their unlettered companions in the ability to play One player-manager of renown is quoted as declaring that he could count on his ten fingers all the really good college baseball the country. It seems to be admitted that rowdyism has largely gone out of the game since the entrance of the man with a degree, but professional baseball. players in this merely moral improvement is no solace for the suggested failure of the graduate to excel in those feats that ap- peal to crowded and excited bleachers. We hope that some clever and, if neces- sary, not too scrupulous mathematician will without delay present a series of tables demonstrating that, despite ap- pearances, the college man, when it comes to a test of throwing or catching a ball or sliding to a base, is as far ahead of his unschooled rivals as we once fondly believed him to be intel- lectually. Attorney-General Wickersham has done a manly and a useful thing in pro- testing against the action of the execu- tive committee of the American Bar As- sociation which has voted to exclude from membership in the Association As- sistant Attorney-General William H. Lewis, on the ground that Mr. Lewis is a negro. Mr. Wickersham speaks of the committee’s “outrageous” action. It is difficult to say whether it is the out- rageous injustice or the outrageous stu- pidity of such conduct that stands out most conspicuously. The committee should have foreseen that precisely such a protest as the Attorney-General has made would be forthcoming. Nothing in the Constitution of the American Bar Association sanctions such race discrim- ination, and if lawyers were not tradi- tionally obtuse in the law when it comes home to them personally, the committee might have known that legal measures could be invoked against its arbitrary action, Secretary Knox's speech at Panama may not have appealed strongly to Cen- tral American statesmen, but their poets must have been stirred by it. Not only
Page 7
March 7, 1912] did the Secretary let himself go in praise of their beautiful scenery, but he showed that he had given so much at- tention to the poetry related to the re gion that he was able not only to quote it. He cited the line— which, we believe, has been heard before but did not make the mistake, with Keats, it but correct —‘Silent, upon a peak in Darien,” of saying that it was “stout Cortez” who first “stared at the Pacific.” The Secretary it Balboa. This is not bad for “Pittsburgh diplom- accurately made acy. Upon a clear issue between labor and capital concerning a question of wages, there has probably never been, in any country, so grave a situation as that which now presents itself in Great Bri- tain, since the mere continuance of the coal strike for a few weeks, even if un- accompanied by violence or disorder, would so paralyze all the productive ac- tivities of the country as to inflict last- ing injury of the most serious nature. As the London Economist put it, in a quiet and sober discussion of the situa- tion two weeks ago: “A prolonged coal strike would kill the present trade boom, and reduce the country from the heights of prosperity to the depths of depres- sion. In two or three weeks’ time the losses on both sides would pile up, and if months or years of bad trade followed the price of coal would suffer a permanent fall.” In other words, the possibilities presented by the coal strike in its direct economic aspect comprise —apart from its immediate hardships— a general depression of British industry for years, carrying with it as an inci- dental consequence most serious loss both of profits to the mine-owners and of wages to the mine workers. That the Government has been at its wits’ end in dealing with this impend- ing national calamity is plain enough. So far as the question of disorder is con- cerned, the indications are plain that the Government is determined to deal firmly with that aspect of the matter, should it come to the front. minimum-wage law As for a for coal-miners, it would not be the first step Parliament The Trade Boards act, which was passed in 1909, 1910, Board, with has taken in this direction. and went into effect January 1, created a Central Trade District Trade Committees working un- ‘The der it, the Trade Board having the pow- to fix Nation er minimum wages in certain specified industries, in which the “sweat- ing” The of operation of this act, as indicated in of- system prevailed. mode ficial explanations of its intended work- ing, is far removed from an arbi trary fixing of the minimum according It to a preconceived standard. was held to be essential to its successful working that there should be “a great flexibil ity of procedure, a treatment which would vary with the complexities of the particular trade, a wide discretion a corded to persons whose whole fortunes and trade affected, and the guidance at every interests were embarked in the stage of expert, impartial, and devoted officials.” From the beginning thus made in the case of a few minor—though not unimportant—trades in which the work ers were supposed to be peculiarly help would be a momentous to less, it step pass to the Governmental establishment of a minimum wage in the basic in dustry of the kingdom Riotous violence by a branch of the English suffragists seems the more in- excusable coming as it did so soon af ter the great meeting in Albert Hall, where Mr. Lloyd George set forth the attitude of the Government and the Par- liamentary outlook. He asserted that three-fourths of the Liberal party favor extending the suffrage to women. Two- thirds of the members of the Cabinet the Yet House for the suffrage be will vote in amendment. it could not made a Government measure at present, ex cept on pain of breaking up the Cab inet and wrecking the party. Lloyd George declared that no statesman and no party can now form a Ministry to carry woman suffrage. At the Economic Club dinner in New York last Thursday night, Mr. Shuster presented the tragic of Persia in case that lib- in- a few strong and simple words went to the heart of every lover of erty and justice, and every hater of cold-blooded of his the many international crimes that have iquity and oppression, within the sound voice. Among been committed in there latter days, the despoiling of Persia, the ruthless crush- ing out of her aspirations in the face of so much merit shown by her people un- der circumstances of almost hopeless difficulty, stands out preéminent in in- famy. It must us in struggle of the against unscrupul ing might, a part inspiring trymen., ! impressed ave Englishmen may passage in the London FE onomis How his 4 ‘ be a America that, Pers sours il ous so } was borne worl able leading ¢) A tit k an id al 8 nt ad it edit Tr rid of February was devoted to the subje \i Shuster’s spee erance a comt nviction a detail randor charges our, nat and | ge ) als and journalists, a minating haracter of ession on his au his ed and explained to reorganize the hose service he ha iw The disorders though laden with if allowed to gn essarily The tired of waiting Saine s the rep among | South only the constitute ituation, in testimony the Me dismissal was and heard Mr. Sh seriou a soldiers have other ublica t at Peking Mor unchecked } deep-s¢ appare d iy, I and presumed that if the financial st at Peking and by a large foreign no great difficulty tiny to an end. that Yuan tiny in order to dictatorship are lesert the have to reckon South, and the I tainly does not cipline among loan, in elsewhere there bringing Such Shi-Kai with explanation instigated fanta ’ republican prepare the S cau the resent argue a conditior Yuan's would enable him to make well-led repul the } The region, to te sination are the price transition fror be can completed. jlican that Chi regarded prese nt a +} ot mu I ould y } il relieved would be the mu the mu ne irmies aif oldiers oz , ul ud a for a ian ld againgt
Page 8
Q2 ~ 6 WHAT ROOSEVELTISM MEANS. his hat When Mr. Roosevelt threw into the ring the other day, he gave the ignal for a contest the like of which has not been seen before in this country. It is not like the struggle between the Bryan wing and the anti-Bryan wing of the Democratic party; it is not like any contest in which Mr. Roosevelt himself has hitherto figured. To attempt to sum up its character in a word or a phrase vould be quite impossible; for both on hi ide and on the opposing side there a highly complex array of forces vorking together without any true bond connection, It is none the less clear that at the heart of the Roosevelt move- ent of 1912 there is something abso- lutel distinctive, and something that American politics is wholly novel. It has long been a commonplace of po- litical comment among us that Roose has stolen Bryan's thunder; and it quite true that in a certain way he n tl if the man whose ra , hot many years ago, he de- nounces ith unmeasured vehemence. But there is one aspect of Roosevelt’s present candidacy, and that the most vital of all, to which Bryan's furnished no parallel. Bryan always had a para- mount issue, or a batch of paramount issues, on which the salvation of the people depended; but, in spite of the d enthusiasm he evoked, and the ex- traordinary hold he obtained over a large part of the nation, he never fora moment regarded himself, nor did his followers regard him, as a personal sav- lor of the American people. It was free silver that was to rescue them from the clutches of the Gold Power; it was de- struction of the Trusts that was to free them from the oppressions of monop- oly; it was the initiative and referen- dum that were to work the restoration of pure democracy; it was guarantee of bank deposits that was to make panics imp ible. Bryan appealed for the suf frages of the people on the ground that he is the champion of these measures, and on the ground that these measures ere desperately neces for the peo- uy ph elfare Never was there any clal expre or implied, that he car- ried in his own person a singular power, 1 unique virtue through which the country was to be saved and without which it was doomed to ruin. But the the Roosevelt campaign of _ very pith of The 1912, the thing that gives it life, the| Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2436 thing that will make it win if it is to win at all, is that upon Roosevelt per- | sonally our salvation depends; whether | shouted from the housetops or only in-| timated or implied, the master-thought | of the true Rooseveltian to-day is that) through placing Roosevelt once more in the Presidential chair can we | stem the tide that is making for revolu-| only tion. Just at this moment, indeed, Mr. | Roosevelt is placing in the forefront of his agitation the proposal that the de- cisions of the highest State courts on questions of constitutionality should be subject to reversal by popular But for the purpose of judging of the character of the Roosevelt move- ment, it is quite needless to go into the merits of that proposal. It has had no- thing to do with the rise of Roosevelt- made vote. ism; it may or may not have anything to do with its future development. If he is looked as the hero of the Progressive cause, upon it is not because of his specific position on this or on any other Upon not a single one of the great features of the Pro- radical issue. gressive programme, except that of con- servation of natural resources, has he played the part of a pioneer or even of a leader. His attitude the Trusts is wholly different from that of on the tariff he has been towards the radicals; not far from a standpatter; on the in-| itiative and referendum as definite prac- propositions, his even in the matter of tical position is ex- tremely canny; campaign contributions—surely a case | of the dollar against the man—he is on | record, in the very last months‘*of his | Administration, as opposing bitterly the | publication of contributions before the | election. What, then, is it that makes | him seem, in the eyes of thousands of enthusiastic admirers, the very embodi-| ment of progress, the pillar of a peo- ple’s hope, the centre of a world’s de- sire? The answer is not far to seek. It has been furnished by Mr. Roosevelt him- self, in scores of speeches and inter- views It buret forth in the first speeches he made in the West after his return Africa. “I will make the corporations come to time,” he declared In his Ossawatomle speech, he put the matter into more substantial shape, when he| spoke of the Executive as “the steward | from in his rear-platform harangues. of the public welfare,” and laid out a vague but sweeping programme of pa- ternalism to show what a vast area he meant should be covered by that steward- ship. His happy appropriation of the phrase of the “square deal” has fur- nished his followers with a convenient pocket edition of their gospel. It is not this or that measure that must be pass- ed; not this or that policy that is to be |promoted or stimulated. All the bless- ings that we seek are to be attained, all the burdens under which we groan are ‘to be lifted, by the magic of the square deal, with Roosevelt, its inventor and custodian, in charge of the process. There are doubtless thousands of Roose- veltians throughout the country who imagine that the movements for child- labor laws, and for employers’ liability, and for juvenile courts, and improved sanitation, which have been steadily spreading over the country for many years as a result of the earnest endeav- ors of many devoted men and women, owe their existence, somehow or other, and that progress will come to an end if he should disappear from the scene. But there is another thing far more serious. For the whole trend of the Roosevelt gospel is towards the belief that the deep-seated causes of unrest and discon- tent can be removed by the crude pro- cesses of a Rooseveltian square deal. To elect him would mean, to thousands to the virtue of Roosevelt, ‘of enthusiasts, the sending forth of a champion armed to the teeth, to destroy the dragons of injustice and inequality, and allay the clamors of the poor and discontented. To find the nearest analogue to this phenomenon we have to go to the French Republic in its Aark days. It is not a personal comparison we are making; we would not be understood to say that between Col. Roosevelt and Gen. Boulanger there is any resem- blance whatever, either as to character or ability. But between Boulangism and Rooseveltism there is a very close resemblance indeed. The sentiment that rallies to Roosevelt as the necessary savior of the Republic is essentially of the same type as that which made “le brav’ Général” for a time the idol of millions of Frenchmen, The test to which the American people are now about to be put is a test not of their judgment as to particular measures, nor even as to particular men; it is a
Page 9
March 7, 1912] test of their sobriety as a nation. Has! the country come to such a pass that it must turn for rescue to a savior of the Republic? Has this nation, of whose in- stitutions, of whose prosperity, of whose history, it was the custom of Ameri- cans, only a few years ago, to be so proud—has it suddenly been discovered to be in such dire straits that its salva- tion hangs on the heroic virtues of a single champion? France found she did not need her Boulanger; are we to con- fess that we are in worse case now than she was a generation ago? IMPROVING THE JUDICIARY. To a “looker-on in Vienna” the most interesting thing about the agitation for the recall of judges in our country must be neither the crudeness of the propos- al nor the fact that it has made some headway, but rather the fact that it has thus far shown so little sign of being regarded with approval by any consid- erable part of the American people. It has behind it a number of the forces that usually make for popularity. Among these not the least important, though perhaps the least spoken of, is the fact that now for a number of years the actual working of our judicial ma- chinery has been the subject of emphat- ic, and indeed vehement, criticism at the hands of the weightiest representa- tives of sober and conservative opinion. President Taft himself, whom it is the fashion of the moment, in certain quar- ters, to regard as the most benighted of reactionaries, declared two or three years ago that American criminal pro- cedure is so defective and so far behind that of other countries as to be a dis- grace to the nation; and in some re- spects his criticism of matters connect- ed with our civil procedure was only less harsh than this. He has several times since taken occasion to reiterate these strictures; and in doing so he was but giving the authority of his high office to judgments that have been pronounced by leading members of the bench and bar. Again, the picture which ardent agi- tators have drawn of outrageous condi- tions existing in certain special cases —such as that of California, for exam- ple—was naturally calculated to make a very effective appeal to the imagination. The best friends of the judiciary, so the thought may be supposed to have run, The Nation admit that there is urgent need of re- form; but they are only mincing mat- ters—look here, and here, and here, if you wish to see the actual truth. So there was the grievance, big and spec- tacular enough to make a popular issue. And as for the remedy, it had just that naive simplicity that is so calculated to win the favor of the populace, Let us get right down to the people, and we are sure to be all right. We know, to begin with, that the people are sound to the core. If courts and judges are not what they should be, it must be be ause we have not faithfully adhered o the democratic principle in the mat ter of the judiciary. Let us throw open the doors and windows ‘and let in the fresh air of the pepular will. That is the sovereign cure for all ills of the body politic; to doubt that it has virtue to effect the cure of this disease is to distrust democracy itself and be false to American ideals. We will make the judges created by the people subject to recall by the people. Then we shall have judges that are honest, efficient, expedi- tious, and methods of procedure that satisfy all the requirements of justice. Nevertheless, it may be asserted with- out the slightest hesitation that an over whelming majority of the American elec- torate has remained unmoved by the plea and is resolutely opposed to any such tampering with our idicial sys- say that the To say this is only t American people are still, as they have been throughout their history, a sober people. They believe in democracy, but they do not believe that there resides in democracy a magic power to dissolve all the difficulties, to disentangle all the intricacies, of life. No specious jug- gling of phrases can suffice to convince them that the simple process of occa- sionally recalling a judge whom the peo ple disapprove can be made a substitute for the patient, intelligent, and arduous vork that is necessary for establishing a stronger judiciary and a better judi And we think that there is.enough left of our cial procedure. cannot but “ancient humor,” of hard-headed Yan kee shrewdness, to see the inherent ab surdity of the recall of judges. The idea that we can procure for the bench a body of able, impartial, self-assertive, and independent judges by the childish expedient of once in a while thrusting out with ignominy one whom the people wish to get rid of is hardly calculated yeypry a ww | * to appeal to the average American's bus- iness intelligence It happens, too, that in intries where the status of the judiciary is p: ) ) cisely the opposite of that which the a Seeking es of the recall are bring about, no such complain are heard as those which form the basis of igitation. The English and the Ca idian courts, with their judges ointed and holding for life, are a d t cy nor of favorit i K ne { fTe« y nd dispatctl As for procedure, at Queen Victoria’s reign ju ial methods in England were en bered ! nicali nd ab i ties oa de il i r nha hing v kn here; and thers rid of within a few decades, not by the pplication of any cheap nostrum, but determined and intelligent effort on part of those who knew the bu they were dealing with. What we ] here we shall not get at any less p: Improvements in procedure will be at tained, if attained at all, by the twofold p ss 0 refully fra d laws d to that end and of judges choser ording to a higher popular star d nd under nditior ore cal ») attract the best type f n ‘ Not by the threat of dis } is might held ¢ rad ( ( the i tior t y and it ! t | t n ype t ! Kind I ! ught te ! ry place } ne t n » a pt | Lis Dem ( ha rea but there is nothing in its chart eals the la f hu n na i til those la have | 1 repealed we n never hope el it the quality he judi ring its sti 1g and authority FREE SUGAR AND AN INCOME TAXA The bills approved by the iucus O tHiouse Democrats for making sugar free and taxing incomes above $5,000, cam«é a genuine surprise. The secret of their preparing had been well kept They have been hailed as a great party stroke. Already the political advan tages to be gained by the Democrats are confidently reckoned up. But s a general rule in politics that sur prises and great strokes lead to disap
Page 10
228 pointment The surprise is as apt to prove disagreeable as of the other sort; ind the stroke may easily wound the party which thinks to inflict it upon the oth An proposal for a_ radical change of policy, particularly in the matter of taxation, has to be considered rot only as a matter of immediate im- pressions, but of ultimate judgment; not merely the tactics but the conse- quences must be taken into the reckon- ing. Viewed in this larger way, there to doubt the wisdom of bills seems reason these latest fiscal of the House Democrats So fai boldness goes in attacking as a protective duty which has come to have the air of a vested right, the plan both raw and refined, upon The pro- vehement fo put sugar, deserves praise. the Democratic Representatives the free list was adopted over posal protests of from Louisiana and Colorado, speaking for cane-growers and the producers of sugar beets But their local interest was disresarded, as every local inter- est should be when it conflicts with a broad and sound national policy. For this display of the true spirit that should animate tariff framers, Mr. Un- derwood and those who stood with him merit commendation. We cannot get a justifiable of tariff they are made to fit national conditions system taxes until and general demands, with parochial and even private back-yard appeals rul ed out But if tariff duties are to be levied for revenue only, we must be very careful about laying a rude hand upon a sched- ule which is confessedly a great reve The sugar taxes bring in That fact nue-produce! more than $50,000,000 a year is one which must bulk large with any ponsible for making up the na He not like the with ran re in the tional budget may cidental protection that goes tax, and may resent the insolent and threatening attitude of those who bene but still there stands the large He rightly think of sugar as now a univer of ita cost to millions: fi by contribution to the Treasury. it, may desire to re but if he is a he run off with the taking cry of sal necessary life and duce tatesman more than a politician will not a “free breakfast table” until he has dis in which the deficten- cove red some WAY cy In revenue may be made good It is only fair to Mr. Underwood to that he has consistently maintained Say The N attitude ation the correct in this matter. Both last year and this, in the drafting and presentation of tariff bills, he has kept steadily in mind the need of sup- with funds for carrying it on. it is in keeping with this position that he now admits plying the government Ana the necessity of making good the $50,- 000,000 of revenue which would be cut ofi by the Hence the proposal of an income tax. That natural alterna- tive, if the enactment of such a tax were abolishing duty on sugar. would seem a clearly legal, but suppose it turns out that you are only enacting a lawsuit? yield public revenue, as unhappily in 1895 when of the Wilson tariff was taken into the courts. Lawsuits no was discovered the income-tax measure And the present plan would inevitably About it there is an air or be so taken. of attempting something at least unforeseen. The excise tax on the business which the Su- preme Court has held legal in the case irregular, doing of corporations, is somehow to be ex- partnerships and to indi- viduals. But the whole thing is con- fessedly uncertain, and has the appear- ance of fumbling at a big problem. It is virtually certain that we shall some day have an income tax in this country. The Constitutional amendment making of tended to it unquestionably legal is in a fair way to be ratified. And if we are to have the tax at all we ought to haverit in a definite form, with the law drawn broad- ly and carefully, instead of by means of a device that looks very like a quibble, and in a halting measure which might be oppressive and unjust to some and which would surely leave many of the large incomes untaxed. advocates of a straight-out income tax will not like this which is neither flesh nor fowl nor good red ea “excise,” herring. such considerations It is that the Demo- in these Over and above there rises another not, country as are the crats in Congress neasures, impressing steady or entirely sincere. They seem to be feeling about for a fetching po- litical issue, rather than laying their real political programme before the peo- ple. It is searcely pretended now that the bills for making sugar free and for levying a disguised income tax can pass both houses and get the President's sig- rature. There is too much the impres- sion of something having been advanced | Even convinc-| [ Vol. 94, No. 2436 ' for political effect, not for serious legis- lation. This was not the case with the other tariff bills which the Democrats have favored and put through the House. They may not have expected them to become law, but at least they were ready to make them law, and if the Democrats were to be put in com- plete power next year, there can be no reasonable doubt that such reductions of duty as their party has committed itself to in the items of wool and steel and cotton and chemicals would, in fact, become law. With these latest propos- als the look of things is different. They do not have the appearance of mature consideration. They seem to be more like political experiments than deliber- ate legislation. And in our opinion they will not do the party any good, since they will make it appear not sure of its ground and disposed to be flighty. And if there is anything the Democrats need to do, in order to regain the con- fidence of the country, it is to show themselves calm and cautious and sure- footed. REPORT OF THE FACTORY COMMIS- SION. The dreadful loss of life in the Tri- angle Waist Company fire of a year ago brought home to the people of New York, as nothing else could have done, the lack of proper exercise of the police power of the State in safeguarding the lives of industrial workers. The most superficial examination revealed the 'fact that the loss of life could have been prevented, in fact that the fire itself would probably never have taken place, if the simplest precautions had been in force in this factory. If smoking had been prevented, the cigarette which started this fire would not have been lighted and thrown into the pile of waste. If the waste had been properly disposed of in fireproof receptacles, the fire could not have spread with such tremendous velocity. If an automatic sprinkler system had been installed, the fire would have been put out before it got any headway. If the workers had not been so crowded together and the aisles s0 clogged by their chairs and machines, the panic would not have started and the exits would not have clogged. If the exits had been properly marked, open, and brought to the attention of the workers by signs and fire-drills, the workers would have been
Page 11
March 7, 1912] able to escape from the fire in life been greater numbers and the loss of would have been much reduced, even if the other precautions had been omitted. These at time of the fire. facts were brought out the It was also recognized at that time that the conditions in this factory were typical of the conditions throughout the city and State in numer- Not only this, but ous other factories. the community awoke to a consideration of its neglect of other matters besides the fire hazard which are the prope: subject of police protection It was a recognition of these condi tions that led the Legislature of 1911 to appoint a commission to investigate the The been m this State. report ot ad factories in the Commission has just to the Legislature. It is a valuable piece of work. It takes its place in the sam« class with the report of the Employers’ Liability Commission to New York State Legislature and the report on railway securities to the President. It matter of congratulation that such is a work as this can be obtained by the State as a matter of patriotic duty in stead of for gain. The commissioners included two Senators, three Assembly- men, and four private citizens, all of whom served without pay. Their coun sel, who, of course, bore the great bur- den of the work, was Mr. A. I. Elkus, and he also served without compensa- tion; and many of the experts upon whom the Commission had to depend for help, such as Dr. George M. Price and Dr. H. F. Porter and others, gave their services virtually free. This preliminary report of the Com- mission covers only three months’ work and is remarkable for the great range of subjects which it treats, for the clear- ness and simplicity with which it pre- sents the problems, and for the definite- ness with which it makes recommenda- tions for new legislation. The subjects treated are fire hazard, factory inspec- tion, sanitation, occupational diseases, bakeries, manufacturing in tenements, employment of women and children, and foundries. At first sight, one might sup- pose it was a mistake to turn over to one commission an investigation cover- ing such a multiplicity of problems. What possible relationship has fire haz- ard to the employment of women and children, or to foundries? The answer is that legislation on each and every one of these different subjects depends for ‘The Nation its validity upon the exercise by the State of its police powers Acts have been passed from time to time in New York dealing with o1 another of the robienis considered y s Ce mission. For instance anu facturing has been the i t of legi lation, there has been t to regu late the hours ol gislation and manufacturing in i es h als been the subject ofl lat ‘ t ment In each case g tior has met with Constitut l jections, ch have led the Court Appeals t declare the a in par oid To « ree hese ( ] f ons s essential that act i ea ilid exer ft I In other words, the purpose t ist be to promote ea ty ind Ifa of the peo " in ne means pre 1e¢ t e clearly adapted to t 1. The ¢ on Db eves t i s ] la I n \ , Cons ent but ft ind ud nust | Zi It therefore ) definit recommendations on thes line but asks to have its time extended The report does, however, ike defi nite recommendations for sla tion in regard to many of the ibjects investigated. In connection the fire hazard, it recommends legislation to concentrate the responsibility for State inspection, to compel factories to put in fireproof receptacles, enclose and protect gas lights and prevent smoking, to en- ible the Fire Department to compel fire drills in factories, to require the instal- lation of automatic sprinklers in fac- tories where more than two hundred people are employed and the factories are above seven stories in height, to in crease the protection afforded by exits and fire escapes, and to regulate the vumber of workers that may be em- ployed in one of these factorie The specific legislation proposed in relation to this last point is perhaps the most nportant of the Commission's recom mendations. In this branch of its investigation, as well as in other branches, the Com- mission has but marked out the field and ploughed the ground Attention is called to the necessity of a building code and there is valuable comment on the subject of occupational diseases. eV of ten nt oroughly e empk t $s di isse tt : ns on 1K1INZ na@ations p 5 nf U it Ss ar ) ; . su ia ‘ é ‘ | if | I | i] y il | ; f ' 6} il 1 ry tior | HE COMPLET! I resente (1 it t tial a ( a pa} jal ni £ nd i I r y? "T I ei A Lif pict the ( : ‘ ‘ r , { olate i nee | e odig hich e gro al ard to say ype done the cause f harm, the satiri« rticle him as @& man ith pal the rear platform of an the ch bouncing tells how a optimist 0 outgolr lay
Page 12
230 through college on twenty hens a year. stuff ban consumption; it is intended for that Such is obviously written for ur- which at call independence in large body of straphanger regular intervals hears the of the is allured by soil and a truck-garden, but then shrinks from the prospect of carrying paper parcels into town The commuter may be sufficiently de- a citizen who digs in a garden This instinctive fined as and detests railway presidents. sentiment may vary from dislike to consuming hatred, but in some form it is always present. The atti- tude, one is bound to admit, is in one int respect unjustified; and para- nporta doxical as it may seem, the slower the trains on the commuter’s road, the less reasol there for resentment. For it s largely because he travels on a road which might carry him faster than it ac- tually does that the commuter is made valuable to himself, the State, and the natior Those two prolonged journeys every day give him the necessary leisure for contemplation that the man in the ty, clinging to a strap and wedged in between two men bigger than himself, l ntirely deprived of. ilts are obvious. As for the city in, the only way in which he in forget the misery of his situation plunge into a furious reading of ol ne paper after another, with the | object of obtaining, not infor ition, but oblivion The opportunity to read slowly, to pause, to reflect, and digest what one has read, is to be had only in a comfortable seat on a paratively slow train; and every dis- rangement of the schedule only con tributes to this educational process here are commuters—those who have just moved out to the country—who do indulge in fair dreams of wealth in connection with their poultry-yards, as we have described, but such flights of fancy are invariably reserved for the quiet hour on the train. Once at home, ther no nonsense in the business The daily trip is the commute?'s oppor tunity for a Aatharsis that makes men sensible r} regular adventure in the realm of fancy followed by a regular return to world of fact, makes the commuter On the train he dreams the an ideal citizen he works. In thus combines in himself an intelli- ponders the garden and He gent progressivism and an intelligent The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 conservatism. The man who has by patient labor brought forth the flower from the seed and the tree from the sapling, will not be carried off his feet by the quack economist and the dealer in political nostrums. He knows that peach trees cannot be made to grow by coming out loudly for the recall of the San José scale or the leaf-blight. He knows that vegetable gardens do not flourish when we solemnly reassert the superiority of human rights over the rights of the potato-bug. He knows that the earth will not yield its increase by the mere declaration of undying enmity Patient dig- ging and delving, ceaseless labor with against rust and brown-rot. the watering-can and the hose, patient and remorseless warfare with the ar- senic spray, the knife, and the shears— these are the methods by which garden- patches and orchards are kept in condi- tion and the increasing demands of the family are provided for. When some- body sends the commuter a catalogue it him on the train and thinks it over. He with miracles in it, he takes with has thus retained the antique vir- tues, this suburban citizen of ours, and added to them conquests of the modern spirit. In his hesitating, plodding way, he beats down the resistance of an un- grateful soil and surmounts the diffi- culties of ferry travel in winter. Rail- ay presidents are afraid of him. They may mock at him, revile him, tell him is unprofitable traffic and is not want- he ed; but they end by making excuses about terminal facilities and delays in- cident to regrading and electrification. He has his dreams of wealth, of the time when he may give up his desk in the city and put in ten hours a day on But it is doubtful whether at For in his land. heart he desires to grow rich. his situation he realizes the ideal of the Sabine farm, that alterna- tion of life close to nature and life close millionaires and poets all are able to present to Broadway which only with a prodigious income vithout any income at realize, GEORG BRANDES AT SEVENTY. Beraen, Norway, Februaty 14. The eminent Danish literary critic, Georg Brandes, celebrated his seventieth birthday on February 4, and was greet- ed as the great master and leader of the Intellectual world in articles and speeches all over the Scandinavian coun- tries. It makes a strange impression to see papers which forty years ago in- dulged in the vilest abuse, now joining in the praise of his life work, and to hear individuals who formerly compar- ed him to the devil now adore him as a demi-god. It reminds one of the im- pressions of Edmund Gosse expressed in his “Two Visits to Denmark, 1872- 1874.” Giving an account of his rela- tions with Brandes during his visit to Denmark in the latter year, the Eng- lish critic writes: It was difficult to account for the re- pulsion and even terror of Georg Brandes which I heard expressed around me when- ever his name came up in the course of general conversation. At the present day we have grown to be so lax and so in- dulgent to opinions that it is not easy for us to reconstruct, even in imagination, the indignant zealotry of ear-ier times. That universal suspicion, that scurrilous abuse, of She-ley, which prevailed about 1819, which culminated in the poet’s being knocked down an English bully in the post office of Pisa, and which were reflected in the loath- some insinuations of the Quarterly Review these are the nearest paralle! which I can think of to the way in which Brandes was shunned and maligned in Copenhagen in 1874, by But things have changed in the course of these forty years, and the mind and heart of the Scandinavian peoples have been widely liberalized. It is Brandes’s enduring merit to have brought about this change and to have “set thoughts free” in religion, morals, patriotism, and literature. On the occasion of the festival the well-known Gyldendalske Forlag (Gyl- dendal’s publishing firm) put out a new and splendidly illustrated edition (Jub- ilee Edition) of one of Brandes’s most famous works, the study of Shake- speare. At the same time was initiated at the Royal Library of Copenhagen a so-called Brandes Archive (Georg Brandes Arkivet), containing books by and on Brandes, letters, manuscripts, and so forth. On this occasion the chairman of the Danish Authors’ Soci- ety, Otto Benzon, paid a high tribute to the genius of Brandes, concluding as follows: So we transfer to the Royal Library the Georg Brandes Archive, oot as a valuable gift only, but as a monument of a man, a significant man, who, by knowledge and clearsightedness, threw new light on many things, a courageous man, who disinterest- edly fought for what he thought just and against what he thought unjust, a good Danish man, who did honor to his coun- try. Seventy years old, this knight- errant now stands in the arena, dauntless as ever. We wish that for a long time he may stand so. A Danish periodical, Tilskueren (The Spectator), to which Brandes for many years has been a frequent contributor, put out a special Brandes number, con- taining many valuable and interesting
Page 13
March 7, 1912]
studies on the critic. Brandes also re- ceived a more official recognition of his work in the shape of the so-called “medal of merit in gold,” bestowed upon him by the Danish King on the recommendation of the Ecclesiastical Department. In Norway appeared a handsomely printed book of greetings from promi- nent Norwegian men and women, “Georg Brandes, 1842-1912, from Nor- way on the Septuagesimal Day.” The greetings vary in length from a single line to several pages, and are chiefly concerned with the immense influence Brandes exerted on individual develop- ment as well as on national life. The work opens with a_— characteristic note by the author, Knut Hamsun, in which he praises Brandes as the ever young and courageous champion; and is followed by contributions from such men Gunnar Heiberg, Christian Krohg, J. Lévland, Christian Sinding, and Gerhard Gran. A few of the utter ances may be worth quoting. The poet Gunnar Heiberg “As a man, I chose two teachers, Johan Sve1 drup and Georg The former maintained Norway for the Norwegians Georg taught me Europe fo! Norway. I never repented my choice.” The author Johan Bojer finishes a two page article with the following words: as says: young jrandes. Brandes “And now he is seventy years old. In the Germanic and Slavic world hi name started like a banner, then it be came a culture it has formed a generation.” The late Minister of For eign Affairs, J. Lévland, says in part “For the disposition, the fidelity, th« farsightedness, the courage, and the rich influence has shown in his many fights for liberty, he deserves the thanks and homage of all nations.” The Swedish periodicals and newspa pers paid an equally high tribute to his genius. From England he received an address expressing admiration of his work and good wishes for the coming years, signed by fifty representatives of the world of English literature and art. From the Danish colonies in London, Manchester, Newcastle, and Edinburgh were sent telegrams to their illustrious countryman. In strict accordance with his nature, Brandes fled from the country to avoid all the festivals and personal homage which he knew to be in store for him if he stayed at home. He went to Paris, where he spent his birthday in sim- plicity and tranquillity, refusing an in- vitation from the Scandinavian Soci- ety of that city to attend a banquet in his honor. A couple of days later he delivered a lecture in Paris for the benefit of a poor old newspaperwoman, whom he had come across on a street- corner near his hotel. now he ARNE KILDAL. The Nation NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES Henry de Quincey, writing to his brother
Thomas in 1808, says: “I send this by Mr. Harden, and should have co Vv se if it had not rained so I folded well in paper, that he might not s¢ he Iness of the cover through it and ther vy jude what was.” On this letter Th is in scribes this grim “me Th ‘kk was ‘The Simpliciad’ by Mr. Mant, a poor Ox ford Fool.” The author thus emphatically yndemned was Richard Mant born n i177¢ who atriculated at Oxford in 1793, became a ellow of Oriel in 1708 M.A 1800, and .D. in 1815 After holdi sé al t es he was appointed B K al 1s Bishop of Dow ] 82 of Dromor in 14 ind died No vember 1848. Probably if de Quincey had en ivored wit! i gl h reer of Ut , i " hara erized he wouid i ira 1dgiment in a lder | ras \ 1 if he had said that Mant wa } write! a foolish work—it is really only a of 5 pages—it would vf é is) a very ich » t pur} ga verdict B l LS0S a | lL.d rR xpression ) i | are I 0 oO I { j rh OkI ) i AuULHO lip i ittie | ! Brit Musée Catalog i in al rh { rH} SIMPLICIAD a a rico la Poen Containing i the scholars o new schoo gested | Horace’s Art P r ed a oO plation of work of the first masters Simplex indit Horace Undecked save with he If M lon: Printed for John Joseph Stock dale, No. 41 Pall Mall 1808 12mo The dedication, with its flimsy pretext of ilment by tl omission of owel 5 lo Messrs. W-ll --m W-rdsw-rth, R-b-rt S--tl and me * r-dz Precis references, with extracts r given » th tings of th three poet revolutionar The criti acknowledges that t wa his intention to ridicule the new and an lassical school,” but protests that he has sed no exaggeration and that ndeed, the school is incapable of caricature He discla all malignity, and SES led ation of a very unusual kind n hese words With the friends of humanity and virtue I venerate your humane feelings and your virtuous principles: with the generality of our countrymen, 1 acknowledge and ad nire uur talents but at same time, vith most men of discernment and culti- vated minds, I lament degradation of your genius, and deprecat: propagation of your perverted taste Such was the attitude of a man of class ical culture and of some poeti impulse ten years after the appearance of the “Ly rical Ballads.” To him the three are only Poets who fix their visionar sight On sparrow'’s @¢ggs in prospect of delight With fervent welcome greet the clowwor « fam Put it to bed and bless it ! ts na Hunt waterfalls that gallo lown tl t 4nd dance with dancing ghing daffodilis Or measure muddy ponds fre side t } And fnd them Poets three feet with t ther ark r brother 1 } ; And Mutter with half-brother butterfly lace V ty ’ \ . au j . er t iH f Pras o apos toll iisies learn to think, I) ghts from r f ) drink “ with fond lang ! t y Th i’ray their spa * 0 t spades \ ‘ atte ik hege “< *s \ ‘ ‘ en the . Wordsworth's small celandine is very irshly handled, and of ourse no mercy s shown to Coleridge's young ass But he criti praises a feeling’ poem in which Sout! invoked revenge for bleed- ing Afri wrong and warmly commends Wordsworth estal strain to good Lord Clifford's prais However, he cannot en- lure to hear of ( . Ww t t! pottage t ’ " . wl ve 1 Beggars | puder wl thrive A ge zg wi ! t know «se from five Such sut x 4 t true But then they're poor ar paltry ¢t And ti s awiftiy ¥ weds Ss ha t z a fe f I ! I ! s like these f ty le Dela se your t izhts and ma) guage vile He is deeply pained that the three revo- lutionaries ar not content with the metres of Milton, The ‘ Cowpel! Gray ind Dryden, but must rt I’ ] appt t I t Amt i I . t Wordsworth's Goo Blake Betty Foy and Al F and ir-¢ ] ollis Mi : | cial hilar r} | ! n ! I he list of ti Bisho vritings in tl Gj men’s Vagazine Ja " 1849), and is also mentione t biography t Archdeacon Edward Berens It is interesting to note thatin one of his latest publications, Bishop Mant quotes Wordsworth’s sonnet on the Decay of Piety.’ His objection to “th anti-classical school whom he had sat rized in his earlier days, was perhaps not inveterate. So far a the Bishop re membered at all t th generation, it as a nymn-writer “When all Bishop Mant’s translation original hymns, aad versions of the Psaln in common use are taken into account, it is found that h is somewhat strongly represented in mod ern hymnology says Dr. John Julian, In his “Dictionary of Hymnology.” From this bibliographical excursion may conc.ude that Richard Mant at thirty two and Thomas de Quincey at twenty-tw« were both somewhat rash in their judg ments. No great stress can be lald upon a private memorandum written on a private letter, but Mant’s anonymous more Mant’s attention of the growing tribe of Coleridge he names one by Wordsworth if diatribe was serious tract is worta tii collectors, for while by piece Southey and ons which he approves praise for 8. T. C The Simpliciad” had known thor of the Rayme As to this English language, Such are the onventional when confronted WILLIAM E,. A he has word of In the year 1808, when published, Coleridge au- no was years as the the ten of poem, been for Ancient Via of the Mant perils riner’! one great abseo- of by genius is est the silent in lutely the AXON
Page 14
a rim Y ° ‘ . 23: the Nat | SO 1e Nation | Vol. 94, No. 2436 , ; Notwithstanding the large and Binghamton 7, Mount Vernon 7, Schenec- id reas n t number of places tady 7. It must be remembered, however, e ta pport 1 their libraries, that the avérage cost per volume of is- ease ¢)} er of libraries ‘s is no final test of relative efficiency, » 7 s librari > s widely r e em- ling at a still more rapid rate, and braries differ so widely in th ' s ref ce are " t libraries chartered P!85'S On reteren work, ‘ . “orty-five aries f State ere at le] lit entirely for their Forty-fiv libraries of the State wer nefitec , : he ve , i - support on voluntary contributions Denefited during the year by gifts or be ' te as tred with 165 such Guests, each valued at $100 or more, the . ' ore important being: One hundred thou- : and dollars left to Rochester by will of ver gT 1 during the past M. W tundell for a library and fine arts new libra and 10 libraries tee . ‘ building $95,000 to New Rochelle from we izht nto relations ‘ Andre Carnegie for a library building; lucati« ] ul it by official : 0,000 to Washingtonville by will of Da of in the id A. Moffat; $29,000 to the Library As | in stat Sy wiation of Friendship by will of Mrs oO rises 1 rted, hy . . Ma Pitt $26,000 to Ossining from An +} publ ; i Cc Z or library build Legislature for ‘ J r $°5 OOO to Corning fro \n R i t yusand dollars 3 irew Carnegie; $18,000 to Nunda from Mrs for initial : Ww h are ' ipied new buildings during the ‘ tT 9 2 se ai New York Publi Library of the : and \ rican Geographical Society, New York :, — Hornell Public, Bolivar Free, Frank ie Fre Richfield Springs Public, She1 State, they . . Publ rheresa Free, Union Springs ry 1 West Hebron Fre Three of par? re provided by gift of Mr. Car- ak gis three by local subscriptions, two by ©X- gifts from interested patrons, one by city { ‘4 yut- iw at ond and one by accumulated funds of ' ce orporatjon. In addition to the branch } ; +} ° - 1. withil libraries in Greater New York, there are - rt ution of the in tl Sta 34 library buildings con- f Cee on ited by Mr. Carnegie, and 120 provided : A res- by other individual donors. There are 288 ] - 150,429 vol- 1ildings in the State erected and devot- ' r op - » 5 ation of v 1 entirely to library purposes, which, to- : : iT é » but 26 per tl with their sites, represent a valua- . ’ ation ind that of abo $47.300.000 it gures ‘ ling the i ind tl rage per capita aah Corr | penese Orrespon ence ' great as " it That but —_—-- . uised for li- ST. BERNARD AND NATURE. t j l ) llages and , .. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: ; , iri¢ ire ‘ i ) ind that S! As the object of the kindly admoni- : led , ort , rift ons of “J. H.” in your issue of February : tion und \ But. as iy I say that I suppose no person of ‘ =e ¢ ia . f public taxa- ntelligence would be likely to differ with - libra aking rapid him when he remarks: One should not take a single sentence f its alle - ‘ ' i in tl i illag and ake a singl ntence out of its allegorical ; , . ; h places voting context, and accept it literally because the sl librar , x years ago literal meaning happens to suit more mod- ' : ern sentiments, which had no place in Ber- ‘ ted ual appr i for rraries by . . nard’s ascetic mind provided always that ‘ r " aris iror ! hana illion dol- had they had no place in his n which is pre- : ! ! ( 7 hiel irs to thi hundred lwelve cities in the pu i is mind, ich e pre cisely the point at issue. “Moreover,” says f) iT " ’ i ropriate Sif or more tor S. = 2 our mentor, “it is easy to show that St. ' - ' ' hi ! ‘ : l v York, $1,- . : ' $40,500 Bernard had no eye for nature, or, indeed, ; , ; } 201 ¢ AD buffalo, $90 Syvracu $40,500: ‘ : for anything delightful to the senses.” And vith a tot 1 du tt i, $24,000 Alba $s 60 Yonkers, ~ . ' . ' hl his proof is that the old Latin life of St. : ) local | 3 vew toch 1,000 *oughkeep- ‘ 810.74 B i Mt Vv ‘eeP~ Bernard ascribes to him the statement that P } ‘ thar 640 inghar ind ernon, : in the woods and flelds he had no masters nt f t ’ t! ul h $10,200 Roche r and henectady : ‘ “' except the oaks and beeches! ; h it fy ary Among the works printed by Dr. Eales in | imber of ra t iting total ty appropriations in his translation as St, Bernard's is one con- port alded loca axat ‘ , of circulation, New York city pays cerning the site of the abbey of Clairvaux am it e of 18 above the preceding year , n for ach volu issued, Buffalo (“Life and Works of Saint Bernard,” II an total f taxati for | racu 14, Utica 13, Albany 4, Yon- 460-467). The reader shall judge from a brar hows a reasa, for tl ar 6, New Rochelle 8, Poughkeepsie 9, few extracts whether St. Bernard had “no
Page 15
March 7, 1912]
eye for nature, or, indeed, for anything de- lightful to the senses.” Here wears told of- the sturdy oak which salutes the heavens with its lofty the graceful lime-tree which spreads its arms, the ash-tree, whos wood is elastic and easily split, or the leafy beech. top, so Later he speaks of— verdant bank of a pool filled with pure running water, where they can watch of the little fish in water which swim to and fro in shoals the and the as crystal sports clear like marching armies; which seems like an anticipation of Ten nyson’s like a shoa Of darting fish, that on a summer morn Adown the crystal dykes at Camelot Come slipping o'er their shadows on the sand Not less beautiful is the author's descrip- tion of the fountain at Clairvaux: This fountain, then—which is said to be an indication of a good fountain—has its source opposite to the rising sun, so that at the time of the spring solstice it salutes the ruddy face of the scintillating Aurora Of the trees in the orchard adjoining the infirmary, in their relation to the sick monks, he observes Under their leafy screen the sun’s rays are softened, and their sufferings are sooth- ed as they breathe the air fragrant with the scent of hay. The pleasant green of the trees and of the turf rests their eyvs and the fruit whichhangs before them prom- ises them delight when ripened. Their ears are agreeably occupied by the sweet and harmonious concerts of birds of varied plumage. See how, in order to cure on sickness, the goodness of God multiplies remedies, causes the clear air to shine i! serenity. the earth to breathe forth fruit fulness, and the sick man himself to in hale through eyes, and ears, and nostrils the delights of colors, of songs, and of odors. It is true that he looks through nature up to nature’s God, as the following pas sage shows; but is he therefore to be cen sured for indifference to nature? The smiling countenance of the earth is painted with varying colors, the blooming verdure of spring satisfies the eyes, and its sweet odor salutes the nostrils. When eyes with the bright colors am reminded that this that of the purple rol of Solomon, who in all his glory could no equal the beauty of the lilies of the field although to him there was wanting neithe: richness of material, nor wisdom and tast I delight my of the flowers I beauty is far above in arrangement In this way, while I a charmed without by the sweet influence « the beauty of the country. I have not le delight within in reflecting on the m) teries which are hidden beneath it Such are the very sentiments wh Storrs (“Bernard of Clairvaux,” p. 157) at tributes to Bernard for assid His supreme lessons were always fror Scriptures, which he studied, in the in which he possessed them, with an uous zeal which we may well emulate; but he found great lessons and inspiring suge: tions in the lovely and lofty works of God and kept for these an open sense. Nor are they inconsistent with the prac- tice of his followers, as described by Nea (Commentary on Ps. 50:11): S. Bernard, forbidding, as he did, th: slightest ornamentation in his churches, for bidding towers, nevertheless taught his Cis tercians to choose the loveliest situation for their houses. I wonder whether it were the romantic situation of his father’s cas tle—Fontaines-l4éz-Dijon—that taught hin the instinctive love of natural beauty whic! found their places for Clairvaux itself. for Rievaulx in our own Yorkshire. for Ba talha in Portugal, and for hundreds of other situations The Nation
lf Bernard was indifferent to nat is singular that the most authoritative bo a ‘ I ve : i t z natur Bies Die | A x des Na turgeful Mittelalter ild me onl jus L r 106 in the s Se I but should ascribe to hi is a princly t learn fro arth and gra tre flowers, and fro z t that in both respects Bi« should be fi ed by Zéckler (“Geschichte der Bezi hungen vischetr The Oz 1 Naturw senschaft I, 318), who His ys 5 bears n not a few of its dev ( ments, a character of peculiar natura freshness, savoring Of the spicy ftragra of the ftorest. jernard stood by no means alone among monks in his love of natural beauty. Moré than three hundred years before his tim Alcuin (735-804) thus bursts forth poem (the condensed rendering from Mon alembert, Monks of th West,”’ I, 69) O my cell! sweet and well-beloved home adieu for ever! 1 shall see no more the woods which surround thee with their in terlacing branches and flowery verdure, nor thy fields full of wholesome and aromat herbs, nor thy streams of fish, nor thy or- chards, nor thy gardens where the lily min gles with the rose 1 shall hear no re these birds who, like ourselves, sing matings and celebrate the Creator in their fashior If one were to begin to quote Dante as il lustrating the love of natural beauty by a theologian of the Middle Ages, one would never end, and indeed it is sufficient to refer to the pages of Dean Church's 4d lightful essay; but one can at least quote two or three sentences from St. Fran (1182-1226) ever-new Canticle of the Sun Praised be thou, my Lord, with all thy creatures, especially lilord Brother Sun that dawns and lightens us; and he, beaut ful and radiant with great splendor, signi- fles thee, Most High Je praised, my Lord, for Sister Mo and the stars that thou hast ade } and precious and beautiful Be praised, my Lord, for Brother Fir through whom thou dost illu t} and comely is he and glad 1 and strong. Be praised, my Lord, for Sist« Our Me ther Earth, that doth « rish ani } ) and produces various fruit t ) flowers and the grass Al I S. Coot y I ers Fé \ THI ADJUTANT-GENERAL’S OFFIC! I HE Epiror F THE N ION Si rh extr t gz below taken f the pr to t ex volume of the “Record of t \ r of the Rebel lion,” may be of interest for other reasons besides showing what the resources of the Government are in the item of war mats rial of the manuscript sort Voluminous as is th ompleted publ ation, comprising 128 bool and a copious atias, it nevertheless fail to convey an adequate once on of the labor involved n its compilation and preparation The ajority of the papers printed exist in du plicate, if not in tripli originals sent and copies retained—al which it wa necessary to examine with great care in order to guard against omission and to ascertain the authenti« of documents selected for publication rhe published pa pers form but a smal] fraction of the myriads that were rejected as immaterial of no historical interest. or otherwise not within the scope of the work, but all of which required careful deration to de- termine their ineligibilit The papers ex amined were well-nigh beyond computa i ou " ‘ i ng ' a “ is ‘ ‘ Z he i t-cjevera om | Wa Depart 1 . ‘ } ataae ‘ a ix he alot ontair ! 1 as the oft " d the War Depart ent ha ] ol red pay | , prope f ed ! lit the ft to t fro hroughout the ‘ tr : donat or t I ‘ tance t} . , oaned wer of for ich as re Oo le atic re lication o itter only the ‘ thenticit of ginal lir had to be tra responde , 1 of) etene ‘ ed Obviou t} vA tude the ost “ 1.67 The importur historian cath I person writing a 4 allowed to interfere gree with th work there Was a Cabinet ¢ { anything like h atter of thers will ? plent ar a point it Ci War a pr th ir a i t ’ ’ | +) f credit, and ve fe t< } ‘ I 4% of a f } ii i ro ert q err it 7 ] la f WA r | ‘ ; } TH Al oO He Et I T} | ? y } : i { ind the ‘ nt } nl i } ’ hat a ’ ny . ’ é ur } ’ ‘ ‘ 9 1 tra t} nare the ‘ " = . fing fn of a of iil trad é . , ‘ inte ow } ot of ‘ a r te ré } } f food ¢ BR
a Ne ' n ' ail a he ud nd } ers and others loans or n donate d or
Page 16
The Nation | Vol. 94, No. 2436 It only remained to examine Philadel- phia newspapers, the result being that the following notice was found in Relf’s Phil- of October 19 and 20, 1820; imerican Daily Advertiser of adelphia Gazette Poulson’s October 20 and 21, and in the Aurora o! Oc- ber 20 and 21: ANTI-SLAVERY. Electors of President and Vice-President. rhe Citizens of the city and County of Philadelphia and of the adjacent counties, ho are opposed to the extension of slavery ! in favor of a public declaration of the ts of Pennsylvania, upon this mo- nto question, are invited to assemble Mayor's Court Room, on SATURDAY \FTERNOON the 2ist inst. at 4 o'clock, t purpose of agreeing upon an Elec- Ticket to 1} supported at the ap- line Election igzainst the Ticket ed upon at Lewiston. A not but shorter than the above, was ilso inserted in the Democratic Press of October 20 and 21, and during the next week there was newspapers about t} meeting. about anti slavery, and about } inti-Slavery Electoral Ticket. ALBERT MATTHEWS. I Ma » 1 Literature THE YOUNGER PITT. William Pitt and ti Great War. By J. Holland Rose, Litt.D. New York: The Macmillan Co $6 net. In the first volume of his admirable fe of the Younger Pitt Mr. Rose de- ribed, as was indicated in an earlier mber of the Nation (September 7, 1), the “national revival” which took place in England under Pitt's directing enius in the decade from 1781 to 1791. He made Pitt’s personality stand forth ominently from the history of the mes by his accounts of Pitt's wonder- rise to the Premiership, of his ener- etic attempts to repair the evils aris- ng out of the old order of things in England, of his tactful handling of the royal lunatic, and of his personal rela- tions with Wilberforce, Dundas, Dudley Ryder, and the otl intimate friend In 1791, at midsummer, the flight of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette to the eastern frontier, and their ignominious capture and return to Paris, sharpened antagonisms already aroused and gave greater momentum to the mighty forces already set in motion. Democrats and royalists were stirred to a fury, not only in France, but throughout Europe, a fury which foredoomed to failure all at- the old broke France and compromi:e between the War Revolutionary tempts at order and new soon ut between the old monarchies of Austria and Prus- sia. Pitt endeavored to localize the war, but his efforts were fruitless; thence- forth his chief task was to bring to an which he had War which and France, conflict the England honorable close a In between not sought. Great ensued Pitt and Napoleon were indeed the lead- ing actors; but even they were partially dwarfed by the mighty drama in which they played. In this second volume, therefore, we do not find the figure of Pitt drawn out so distinctly from the events of his age as in Mr. Rose’s pre- vious volume; there is something more of history and less of biography. Ex- ceptions to this statement are the ex- ceedingly interesting chapters on Pitt's resignation from the post of Prime Min- ister and his refusal to embarrass his incompetent successor, Addington; also the pages in which the author discusses Pitt’s private financial difficulties and his love for Eleanor Eden. He and Miss Eden were fond of each other; the mar- riage would have given Pitt's nature what it needed—wider sympathies, re- laxation, and a freer enjoyment of the amenities of life; but as both were poor and as he felt he could not support her adequately without resort to political jobbery, his scrupulous sense of honor made him renounce the idea of mar- riage. In his chapters on the Jacobinism in England, which ran parallel with that in France from the flight to Varennes to the rise of Napoleon, Mr. Rose has drawn richly from the interesting and little-used archives of the Home Office. The harvests ‘of 1792 had been spoiled weather; food prices were ris- discontent rife; bread riots out in Manchester, Liverpool, Sheffield, and elsewhere. Nowadays, high prices, heavy taxes, and conserva- tive landlordism lead people in a coun- ry like to vote the Social Democratic ticket. In those days, in England, it led them to devour Tom “Rights of Man,” join “corre- ponding societies,” and send fraternal by wet ing; was broke Germany Paine’s ddresses to the Jacobins across the hannel in France. A typical address this kind, read at the bar of the French Convention on November 7, 1792, eclared that five in England stepped forth to rescue their thousand signatories country from the opprobrium thrown upon it by the base conduct of Pitt’s Government. They looked on French- men as “citizens of the world, children of the common Father,” net as enemies to be assassinated “at the command of weak or ambitious kings, or of corrupt ministers.” They deplored the fact that George III, as Elector of Hanover, had joined his Hanoverian troops to those of traitors and robbers; “but the King of England will do weil to remember that England is not Hanover; should he for- get this, we will not forget it. We ar- dently wish a Triple Alliance, not of crowned heads, but of the people of America, France, and Great Britain, will give liberty to Europe and peace to the world.” After the example given by France, revolutions would become easy. “Reason is about to make rapid prog- ress; and it would not be extraordinary if in a much less space of time than can
Page 17
The Nation addresses of congratulation to a Nation- al Convention of England.” Addresses of this kind were delivered at meetings all over England and published in news- papers devoted to the democratic cause. To counteract their influence Pitt help- ed to start two new papers, the Sun and the Jrue Briton. They were of a popular type and expressed a rather cheap and sensational royalism; and their advent was much resented, as may be imagined, by Mr. Walter of the Times, after his support of the Govern- ment. Pitt had reasons to fear that deeds might follow words. British Ja- cobins were reported to have secretly ordered in Birmingham 20,000 daggers, twelve inches in the blade and five in the handle. Apparently, it was a sam- ple specimen of this weapon which Burke melodramatically cast upon the floor of the House of Commons during a speech shortly before the execution of Louis XVI. At the news of Dumouriez’s victory over royalism at Radicals in Sheffield evidenced their joy by roasting and devouring an ox, and marching in a great procession carrying the French tricolor and a burlesque ban- ner representing Pitt’s Minister, Dun- das, stabbing Liberty, and Burke tread- ing down “the swinish multitude” (a “phrase which Burke in his “Recollec- tions” had.applied to the French revo- lutionists). The growing boldness of the Radicals finally Pitt into a series of repressive measures. Writers have contrasted his earlier advocacy of liberal called “reign of terror” later; and have Jemappes, drew reforms with his coercive so- charged him with inconsistency But the charge loses force when one consid- ers how the times changed after 1791, with the rising tide of English Radical- ism. The whirl of events in France also seemed to show the need of taking timely measures against lawlessness and over-hasty reform. Years after wards, when the events of the Revolu- tionary ‘era could be seen in perspective, it was easy to ask: Why did not Pitt, in view of the unswerving loyalty of the great majority the good sense and weight of that mass of Britons, rely on to overbear the Jacobinical minority? It is to be regretted that he did not take that more intelligent and more courageous course. But to have expect- ed him to do so, in view of the actual events about him, is to expect of him more than human prescience. Mr. Rose traces in careful detail the events which, in spite of Pitt's efforts towards peace, drew England and France into war. It was not the execu- tion of Louis XVI, as so often stated, which was the prime cause of the war; it the advance of Du- mouriez towards the mouth of the Rhine and the danger from the subversive de- ciees with which the French enthusiasts threatened England's Dutch ally was victorious In the chapters on the conduct of the It two war, that on Toulon is noteworthy. the illustrates disadvan- labored in com- Whereas Napo- between It and the first clash national of the difficulties under which Pitt parison with Napoleon shows great leaders. many tages leon could communicate with his Gov- ernment at Paris in a few hours, it took Pitt at least eleven days to get dis patches from Toulon Napoleon had the loyal support and absolute disposi- tion of the entire French forces; the English commander at Toulon had man bickerings with his jealous Spanish al- lies who feared that the English were planning permanently to retain Toulon Gibraltar ite d, second o % a has often been and make This in such recent scholarly of Cottin. But Mr. Rose Pitt had no such plan merely hold Toulon clusion of peace, when French, though indemnitw in Pitt to idea repe even works as thos shows that He until if intended the be re to con would stored to the used as a handle for Corsica or the French West Indies exacting an owing fulfil ad promised to send Milan to It was disadvantage to at a culpable Thugut | Austrian not a man was also Austria’s failure her promises. = 000 soldiers from Toulon, but was sent. a vitiating flaw: in Pitt’s strategic com binations all through his conduct of the war that he too optimistically believed that the cabinets of Austria, Prussia, and Russia would live up to his own high standard of duty and magnanimous endeavor Counting the Austrian and other promised troops, Pitt had esti mated that there we 14.200 men de- fending Toulon. Mr. Re ilculates that there were actuall on 16,912 of whom not more than 12,000 were fit for active service. If Pitt had been in closer touch with the situation, as would have been possible with the modern telegraph, he might have dispatched troops then lying idle at Corg and elsewhere which might have saved Tou- ler When at last he real d the @t uation he instantly gave orders fer re inforcements to proceed from England one day before these orders were given Toulon had already surrendered Of all Pitt's problems perhaps the most complex and difficult were those connected with Ireland—the corrupt rule of a Protestant minority in the Irish Parliament at Dublin, the Rebel- lion of 1798, the constant danger of a French invasion, and the perennial dis orders in that unhappy country Pitt felt that the safety of the British Em- pire demanded the legislative union of England and Ireland under one central authority, just as Robespierre had seen the need of centralization of authority in France, and he obtained it brib- ery. He used bribery because corrupt means could he through that corrupt Irish legislature a measure entailing pecuniary loss on most of its by only by carry r.embers He hoped to Union by Catholic emancipation George III's threatened fit of lunacy the complete the But at mere prospect of allowing Catholics to sit in Parliament led Pitt to resign from office and delayed Catholic eman cipation for a generation While Pitt thought only of the safety of England the King’s thoughts continued to gyrate angrily and madly around the Test Act his Coronation Oath, and ties of Fox, In his handling of the Irish q n which at the present moment is in arousing sucl nterest and feeli as well as in dealing with the foreign war ind domestic legislation, Mr. Rose ha iin shown himself to be an hist of unusual ability He combines eat ndustr impartialit and insight h twentiet) ntur etiv i a distinctly pleasing H t ol- umes on Pitt " ‘ rarded not only the standard biography of reat statesman but as ene « the est a counts of English |! or et ! 781 and 1806 CURRENT FICTION Para } By Katharir I New York Duffield & ¢ M Tynan here forsal J ] ur t ind Iris) ene yet int I Weald } tl KeniIAlity hat 1 ks a her tale Witl ib et ird it il i false] ‘ ] usband-p Auld Ro Gray t I t | ty Id f il 1 } p } he } ; , ‘ . fortah) Pa , Ia buried } i ! background ed uts of hidder ip] ld l ! lady r} nt r 1, of Nancy Cri » | t ] “ n } it me of the difficult ta ired +? , a } } ‘ el fet’s troubles are Idom more than skir deep, one may trudge on through long lanes of predicament urfperturbed and ufficiently beguiled, quite confident of ppy turnings ’- ¢ rae The Gods and M Pe) i I ! Walpole. New York: The Centu ) You thint l es he pla t f i ll t a different i th ] ter You will be al i (rier mly enemies You thinh vou. Well, for a ent rhaj , for a moment y , iat friends with the Head, becau ther think that you are spying on u Y not be friends with us, because tl Head will think that ou are against him. You ust not be friends wit! the boys, because then we shall all hate
Page 18
236 they will despise you You will be quite I and more of it, is the gloomy ture drawn by the cleverest master rt a school faculty in Cornwall, Eng- nd, for the benefit of young Archie lraill, just through the university, and ntering upon his first year of teaching rraill himself, a normal, full-hearted outh, is brought into the story, as is Isabel Desart, a visitor, to set off by contrast the warped and cramped spirit of this little society Mr. Perrin is its ch embodiment 4 bachelor, at forty- five, and apparently with every good in- tention, he his soul ground down by the system to pedantry and pettiness ill, he will fight for the better side of see3 himself. He is in love with Isabel, and through her he will be saved. Little wonder, then, that pique is replaced by hetred when Traill, by sheer youth and ingenuousness, pushes him one side. Under the circumstances, Perrin’s neu rotic Introspections and final outburst seem hardly overdrawn. This schoo] is not Eton or Harrow, but, according to the author, it is typical of conditions in hundred schools throughout England. The Foot in Christ. By Gerhart Haupt- mann. Translated by Thomas Seltzer. New York: B. W. Huebsch. Indian Lily, and Other Stories. By Translated by same. The He I Lewisohn. rmann Sudermann. The translations are likely of their though neither permits us long to for to sat- readers, fy the demands get that the original is German. Mr. had the easier task, and per- formed it, on the whole, with sober fidelity His expressions do not always have the right connotation, nor always fit into their context. A more thorough re on of the version as a new unit in English would have made it more ho- mogeneou But, at any rate, it does not pretend to be more than it is. Mr Lewisohn'’s work, on the contrary, is a little marred by a pretentiousness which invol appears to be not altogether an untary reflection of the salient quality of Sudermann’s own style. The trans: lator not lacking in a sense of rhythm, nor in the capacity for hand- ling perlods; but he shows himself ometimes unaware of the meaning of vord ind what was in the original a novel, perhaps incongruous, but gt least ntelligible designation or epithet, be- omes In his translation frequently gro- teaque Thus: “A certain fogless free dom of thought seemed to me until to day the highest point of human develop- ment “She thought out a plan—the first of many by which she meant to rivet her beloved for life.” “With ab- stracted caresses she touched his weary fingers “She herself saw the world through a blue veil, ‘heard the voices of ‘The life across an immeasurable distance, and felt hot, alien shivers run through sentences as Nation ‘a single theme which results in a certain her enervated limbs.” Such these are not the equivalent of the Ger- man. Neither is it creditable to be un- able to distinguish between shall and will, Vane of the Timberlands. By Harold Bindloss. New York: Frederick A. Stokes Co. The British Columbian Pacific Coast, land of the log-driver, the miner, the prospector, supplies again the substance for Mr. Bindloss’s story. For back- ground there are men and women, love and and mutual service, but they are second in to the great romance of forest, river, and sea. No smooth-flowing idyl is this one of nature. Winds blow, floods destroy, shows smother, drifting logs betray; and whether on land or sea, men may rivalries, importance face hunger and cold. The author’s pleasure is to show the wildness and the beauty and the cruelty of such scenes and their effect on the men who brave them; from seeking their living along these ways of hardship grow into a fury of affection for them— ready equally to “achieve success or annihilation.” One such, Wallace is pictured this story, with his more cautious and considering friend, Carroll. Their journeys, some- times for their own behoof, and as often in almost quixotic behalf of sundry un- der-dogs, make impressive reading. That all this is more impressive than exciting is no fault of the experiences, but is rather because of a level of calm com- in the recital which never gives a chance to the breath in reading, and perhaps misses thereby a legitimate sensationalism. But the book worthily escapes the greater fault of hysteria over nature, or woman, and is in every way a sane, strong story, and refreshingly well worded who face Vane, in mon sense lose man, tone SENTIMENTAL PLATONISM. of Platonism, and Other Adam. Edited by Vitality Essays. By James his Wife, Adela Marion Adam. Cam- bridge University Press. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $2.50 net. In our notice (July 16, 1908) the lute Professor Adam's admirable treatise “The Religious Teachers of Greece,” we observed that, “if any part of the book has disappointed us a little, it is The oO. 0 these concluding chapters on Plato.” Something of that disappointment we} have felt, have felt even more keenly, | while reading these essays on Platonism and kindred subjects now edited and published by his wife. The book is made up of lectures on various occasions, and makes Mo pretence to strict unity of de-| sign. There does, however, run through | all the essays, more or less explicitly, | | Vol. 94, No. 2436 unity of impression; and, unfortuzately, the unsoundness of that thesis throws a vitiating atmosphere about much that otherwise nobly thought and ex- pressed. The fault first shows itself ciearly in a comparison of the ideas un- derlying Wordsworth’s “Ode on Intima- tions” with Plato’s doctrine of ana nnésis, or recollection. Only deep con- fusion of ideas can follow the failure, as Professor Adam here fails, to see a radical distinction between Words- worth’s notion of a spiritual inheritance of infancy which is gradually overlaid by experience and Plato’s doctrine of a vague reminiscence from a former life which must be brought to clearness and efficiency by labor and learning. How quickly such a confusion of ideas passes into dangerous error of precept may be seen in Professor Adam’s praise of “Plato’s view of education as the free and unconstrained development of the individual soul.” The definition applies well enough to Rousseau’s “Emile,” but we are at a loss to understand how such a picture of education can be drawn from the austere discipline of Plato's communistic “Republic.” At bottom Professor Adam's error springs from a fine but misguided en- thusiasm. In his laudable desire to link the religion of the past with that of the present in one glorious, unbroken tra- dition, in his Jonging to hold up the vitality of Platonism as a force still moulding the better thoughts of men, he has simply lost the sense of philosophi- cal distinctions. The logos is to him the binding thread, the idea at the heart of religion wherever found. Now, in the separate dicussions of this word and its synonyms as they are used by various ancient and modern writers, he no doubt suys many things that are right and in their way precious, but when by its means he would merge the philosophies of Plato, Heraclitus, the Stoics, and Wordsworth together in one _ indis- criminate welter of patheism, he is, we are bound to think, doing but an ill ser- vice to the cause he has so much at heart. Now I will ask you to believe [he writes] that this half-poetical, half-religious idea of a World-Soul, which, according to Plato, is as it were the incarnation of the Divine Reason, less perfect than God himself, but still wholly rational and far from anger or desire—I will ask you to believe that this World-Soul or World-Reason is in reality’ Plato’s conception of Nature. It fol- lows that Nature, as Dante somewhere says, is the child of God, that she is a spiritual material creature, good and not evil; for God, according to Plato, is the author only of good, and evil cometh not from him. In Plato’s way of thinking God and Nature are not two mutually opposing forces, but an omnipotent Father and a loyal son, working harmoniously together toward IS and not a that far-off divine event To which the whole Creation moves.
Page 19
/? ‘The BIOGRAPHIES March Nation Ig12]| That this sentimental view of nature may be educed from certain passages of OF TOLSTOY. The Life of Tolstoy. By Paul Birukoff. Plato’s Dialogues, especially the “Ti- ‘ra nelated 7 he > . ev meus,” we do not gainsay: but that it is ransiated from the Russian. New honestly representative of Plato’s whole York Cassell @& Ci Pp 6X $ ) view of life, we do most vigorously deny. "™ It is true of Stoicism; it comes into //e / f Count | \. Tolstoi.. By modern English literature chiefly Nathan Haskell | New York through Shaftesbury’s revival of Stoi Thomas Y. Cre & { Pp. 467. cism and the ensuing romantic school 32 net which reaches its culmination in Words- Tolst: By Ro R ’ Author of worth; but between Platonism and Jea Christophe rranslated by Stoicism there is a great gulf fixed. ‘“‘The Bernard Miall. N York: E. P. Dut Stoic conception of the Logos” Professor ton & Co. Pp. 321. § ) net, . am efi ~ > j hy) } } Adam defines “as the unity in which all Paul Birukoff, a d ple and it te opposites are harmonized. Now Plat friend of Tolstoy, has written two vo! in his dialectic, that is when driven , imes (Moscow, 190 nd 108 F the he mm Ss 7 "e reasor ioes. no . the commands of pure reason, does, npn of his master from 1828 to 1884, of doubt, attempt, though unsuccessfu ’ , . nut i : which only the first s been translated to find a rationa nexus between tle . . ws into English (Ne York 6 they many and the one. Even more clearly ‘ : . : ; re unfortuna ely rather a collection of his practical doctrine, his ethics, is a ., . ; ; Vaiuabdie materiais a i i discipline by which the soul, through : ‘ > ; s ; raphy Before eting } iin self-discipline and abnegation, is taught ,. : : : task. he has publis i short Ket of to raise itself to contemplation of the , : ° ntire l Lol ho divine unity and to:a state of justice , ‘ appea nan | hd s Hie pre which is the reflection of that unity in ; 3 : : sents ts s p I lea but lays the government of its own faculties. But : a ‘ ; : : ; most str on tl ( lopment of Tol sssentia'ly his philosophy, both dialecti essentia!] ph losophy, both diale« ie hens: mnare® thee 08 the eaves. te and practical, his Piatonism, so to speak, ; , P : . : ' says little, and that ttle y no mean 1s dualistic conception of the one an . . , : a‘ vell; Anna Ka ’ nd the many, being and becoming, ideas and ,, . on e Peace ne appare \ irds as mere phenomena, God and nature. To slur ' os , ; . y incider in thre Tolsto from over this dualism, as Professor Adam : ; =P itt i which some concl YT mav | lrawn does, in order to assimilate Platonism 3 : j r , s to | spiritual development. Himself with certain nineteenth-century notions : . “ag ; hout marked lite y t nt, he gives of religion and education and poetry, or ; . k us no conception ol 1¢ I ic gerius to represent Plato as attempting to ex ’ : ra f “a ? aes of his friend; but, writing affec plain away the existence of evil by a g > . - aa ; ; tion and reverence e conveys a first- kind of optimistic emotionalism, is to , P z : . hand, though som of tl it the whol vi ] a irt: and tl t t ‘ oO r the t ( l : ¢ a ho } Of Tolstoy’s religious and social the ories, M. Rolland gives no mere para phrase, but penetrates into the spirit of the man who found in the ymmand ment, “Love thy neighbor as thyself,” a taint of egoism, and dared to emend it into, “Love thy neighbor as Himself (as God). Even in treating Tolsto criticism of art, he can rise above tl superficial injustice and perversity of Tolstoy's single verdicts, and understand their essence when he writes
Page 20
238 What is the artistic significance of the religi ideal which he proposes? This ideal is agnificent The term “religious mislead one as to the breadth the conception Far from narrowing tl provi of art rolstoy enlarges it Art, he sa is everywhere “Art creeps i our whole life what we term art, na | theatres, concerts, books, exhibi- tion ic only an infinitesimal portion of art Our life is full of artistic manifes- tations of every kind, from the games of hildren the offices of religion. Art and peech are the two organs of human pro- gre One affords the cummunion of hearts, the other the communion of thoughts If either of the two is perverted, then so clety is sick The art of to-day is per- verted Restricting biographical details to the merest outline, M. Rolland, nevertheless, gives a clear conception of Tolstoy's per sonality and of his position in society, with his prejudices and peculiarities, as well as his ideal aspirations; with his youthful “pride of the great noble and the officer who condescendingly mingles with liberal and middle-class scribblers,” candor” candeur ) the “ineffable “simple-heartedness,” contrasting with (query, of the aged man, who on his death-bed wept, not for himself, but for the un- hap] saying, “in the midst of his ol There are millions of human be- ings on earth who are suffering: why do you think only of me?” And so M. Rol ind proceeds to his final verdict t loes not speak to the privileged world of thought hominibua bone He our conscience He says | thi we average people, and ‘ iff fear to read in ourselves He ! i aster full of pride one of t! haugl geniuses who are throned " ! ur I their art and their ! ‘ He 1 as he loved to styl h elf in hi letters, by that most beau tiful of tith the most pleasant of all r brother Students of Tolstoy will not be dis- turbed by some insignificant slips of de- tail in M. Rolland’s volume. Though we cannot refer to the original, the trans- has apparently done his work com- despite an lit to the words and idioms of lator petentl occasional too eral fidelity text the French lhe Works of Henrik Ibsen Edited with Introductions by William Archer. Vik ing Edition New York Charles Scribner's Sons 13 volumes. $2 the volume : Tne Viking Edition of Ibsen's works varie in comparatively little, save in the externals of bookmaking, from the Copyright Edition which the Scribners issued in 1908, “complete in eleven vol- umes,” but to which they have since thirteen, collection volumes twelve and Workshop,” a added, as “From Ibsen's of notes, scenarios, and drafts for cer The Nation [ Vol. 94. No. 2436 taln of Ibsen's later plays, translated by A. G. Chater, and the well-known “Life” of the dramatist by Edmund Gosse. The reprint has evidently been made with out very close supervision, since, though the circular announces that the set is to consist of thirteen volumes, the first words of the General Preface reappear exactly as Mr. Archer wrote them in 1908: “The eleven volumes of this edi- tion,” etc. The only significant changes in the text before us are to be found in the introductions to the various plays, where attention is happily paid to a large body of important material made acces- in 1909 through the printing of the ‘author’s “Efterladte Skrifter”’ (“Lit- erary Remains”) in three volumes. Nearly one-half of this material is re- produced in “From Ibsen’s Workshop”; but no part of what works earlier than “Pillars of Society” is com- in such short discus- prefaces of the sible concerns municated, except sions the revised present publication afford. doubt the Viking Edition as the circular states, “the standard edition in English of the great- as Without provides, est dramatist of the nineteenth cen- tury.” But it is not beyond reproach either in contents or in style. Mr. Arch- er omitted, we think, ~without sufficient reason, Ibsen's first play, “Catilina,” hich contains in germ many of the au- thor’s characteristic ideas. Ibsen in- sisted on the importance of reading his chronological or- first in the in “Catilina” plays throughout der, and placed definitive edition he himself prepared. Mr. Archer is right in saying that it ‘would seem a deliberate disregard of the poet's wishes” to perpetuate the original rather than the revised version fruit of his invention. But, surely, more culpable dis- regard of the poet's wishes to omit the play altogether. That “Catilina,” not to mention four other complete plays by the author printed in Norwegian, should “standard edition” of first it seems a of this be passed by in a the poet's “collected works,” and a whole volume be devoted to scraps “From Ibsen's Workshop,” is a rare ex- hibition of inconsistency. Not that we deprecate the publication of this con- which unquestionably throws valuable light on the dramat- ist’s technique. On the contrary, we wish that the “Literary Remains” might have been translated entire, for they contain other matter of as great inter- est as anything in the parts selected. Particularly is this true of the so-called “Epic Brand,” the recovery of which, after its mysterious loss for some thir- ty-five years, is one of the most curious incidents of modern book-history. One cannot help wondering if the fact that Ibsen's early work is chiefly in verse did not occasion its neglect. Mr. Archer had a hard experience in translating “Peer Gynt.” cluding volume, | the fact that he had not the poetic ca- pacity to reproduce that great work ade- quately, because of its lavish variety of metre, he requested the author's permis- sion to put it into prose. But Ibsen ab- solutely refused to allow that to be done with his sanction, and only reluctantly agreed to the compromise line-for- line “crib which was finally evolved. Mr. Archer, at first apologetic for the result, has since grown proud of it; but probably no one else regards his version as satisfactory. We regret that Professor Herford had not a larger share in the English edition of Ibsen's collected works. His translations of “Brand” and “Love’s Comedy” are excel- lent. He shows us in his preface to “Brand” what he might have done with the epic fragment had he undertaken to render it all in English. Had he been general editor, we should pretty certain- ly have had a volume of Ibsen’s shorter poems in our own tongue. As it is, English readers are bound to emphasize Ibsen the problem-play writer unduly at the expense of Ibsen the poet. The Copyright Edition, being conveni- ent and inexpensive, is likely to remain in most general use, but the Viking Edition, to be sold in sets “by subscrip- tion only,’ should be preferred by all to whom two dollars a volume (four dol- lars in half-levant) is not a prohibitive price. The paper is of superior quality; the printing and binaing are handsome. On the other hand, though some of the illustrations are exceptionally good, the majority, especially photographs of ac- tors and on the stage, might have been omitted without loss. scenes By Joseph Conrad. $1.25 net. A Personal Record. New York: Harper & Co. It is hard to advance who is likely to the familiar vein. One might have thought that Jo- seph Conrad, with his varied experience and powers of descrip- tion and narrative, would have made an easy business of the present infor- mal autobiographical record. But it is evidently hard for him to hit the right tone—a matter of calculation rather than instinct. In the “Familiar Pref- ace” he is self-conscious and ill at ease. Towards the end of it his discomfort expresses itself in the frank utterance of a doubt as to the probable result of his “trying to be conversational.”—‘I have never been very well acquafnted with conversation,” he confesses. “. . . My young days, the days when one’s habits and character are formed, have been rather familiar with long silences. Such voices as broke into them were anything but conversational.” In the attempt to buttonhole his reader, he assumes a jaunty air which is rather distressing. But this vanishes for the guess in succeed with his uncommon Recognizing | most part with the beginning of the
Page 21
March 7, 1912] reminiscences proper. These remi- niscences are of casual and fragmentary sort, at first glance, but when one has finished reading them one must feel that the writer’s hope has been real- ized: “that from these pages there may emerge at last the vision of a person- ality; the mind behind the books so fundamentally dissimilar as, for in- stance, ‘Almayer’s Folly’ and ‘The Se- eret Agent,’ and yet a coherent, justi- fiable personality both in its origin and in its action.” The writer who has chosen to be known as Joseph Conrad, and to make English his medium, is of Polish birth. A grand-uncle had been a Chevalier de la Légion d’Honneur under Napoleon, had gone with him upon the Russian campaign, and had literally eaten dog on the way back. His father ac- tive in the ill-fated uprising of ‘63, and exiled thereafter. The boy himself had a longing for the sea from his earliest years—an unaccountable instinct. “Why should I, the son of a land which such men as these have turned up with their ploughshares and bedewed with their blood, undertake the pursuit of fantastic meals of salt junk and hardtack upon the wide seas?” The question remains unanswered; but greedy for the sea this son of a land-bound nation was, and he was finally, against the protests of all his relatives, had his way. Fortunately, the uncle who was his guardian, though he disapproved of his nephew’s project, did not forbid it. The boy had determined to not only a seaman but a British seaman; and the reader may piece together from differ ent portions of the fragmentary narra tive the stages of Conrad's ascent from seaman to full Not until he was some thirty-five years old and near the top of the ladder the British mercantile marine, did the idea of his first story begin to take shape in his brain. The result, “Almayer’s Fol ly,” was the intermittent labor of years, and made an author of him. For this doubt, because it marked the transition from seaman to book- man, the genesis of “Almayer’” is trac- ed fully in these pages, from that first meeting with the real Almayer far up be common master. in reason, no , a Bornean river to the completion of the story many years later. To ac- count for himself as a man and as a writer, are the two purposes of the rec- ord. “In the purposely mingled reson ance of this double strain,” concludes the Preface, “a friend here and there will perhaps detect a subtle accord.” And, indeed, the book has a curious completeness. This effect, one perceives, is gained by the method of the fiction- writer—a careful choice of telling de tail—rather than in the cumulative manner of the autobiographer. Its dis- cursiveness and fragmentariness, for which the writer apologizes, are appar- ent, not real. So much the better: the The Nation book would have been a little master piece in a rare kind if there had been no attempt “to be conversational.” Notes Henry Holt & Co. have in hand Ralph Straus’s “The Prison without a Wall the story of a sensitive scholar clo stered in the University of Cambridg Karin Michaelis’s “Elsie Lindtner,” a s quel to “The Dangerous Age vill be issued ty John Lane Compa this spring The Century Company promises for this month a book by Rupert Hughes, giving the picture of a mother’s longing for her scattered brood; “The Burgundian,” a tale of the court of the mad King, Charles VI of France, by Marion Polk Angelotti, and “The Yosemite,” by John Muir Fiction in Duffield & Co.'s spring t ludes The Adjus t by Marguet Bryant The Gate Hort by B ! Marie Dix: “Paradise lar ! IX } Tynan; “The High Adventure by John Oxenham; “Country Neighbors: A Long Isl nd Pastoral,” by Susan Taber Mens rekel,” by Augusta Groner rl H Robershaye,” by Emma Brooks The Wool len Dress,” a trans! 0 H Bor deaux’s “La Robe de lain The Garder of Indra,” by Michael White, and “Puttine Marshville or he Ma ! in William Ganson R Gi r Ser I h wil Thread of Life an avthorized trar it of the Infanta Eulalia’s book; rhe Co plete Nonsense Bool by Edward ur I va } Scribners are bringing out this ynth Included Doubleday, Page & C« pring announcements are The Real Mr Hol yer by Francis Channon Pleasures and Palaces,” by Juliet Wilbor Tompkins William the Silent,” by J. C. Squire On Look Back,” reminiscen of fifty vears of public life in London, by George William Erskine Russell: “The Life of David CC Broderick,” by Jeremiah Lynch: “The Life of Woodrow Wilson,” by William Bayard Hale, and “Plantation Ballads,” by John A Lomax In “Bahaism, the Religion of Brother hood,” announced t Messrs. Longmans Francis H. Skrine seeks to tra the eve lution of organized creeds from agi through spirit and ancestor worship, totem ism, native worship lualism, pantheism, and monotheism, culminating in the ideal- ism of Baha ‘Ullah and his successor, Ab- dul Baha To book-lovers we ay properly recom- mend a work named for them The Book- Lovers’ Anthology ompliled by R. M Leonard and published by Henry Frowds A suff the vo.ul en e number of explain various questions Katherine -tevenso Stevensot! is to sa whose curiosity concert but pret ! not y , ty bee to Colvin rative o urces portance whi ture of furnish descripti grant.’ rees b at andladie together within cribing ahe de an act sketches men of Nothing ligious ny} f know of the Stevenson never an ve i and his at h there n California I> Osbourne’'s R lians of the it Assumes a desperate n satisfie Mr trip a Closse roas Silverado, or various biographer I this per text adds very ‘ tt The ill Sixty-nine istrat are illu nat powers of ‘ " There are views ts { ount fa Monters part th of rocky coast at
Page 22
2AO
Nation ‘The | ‘ of the nformation collected in the forty- I Immigration Com- } been well fulfilled; but the bo not, in any sense, a careful and gration problem | ted State There is no bibliog- 1 reference to other ibject th the exception I r Steiner Perspective and sym- icking i there are no cli- tony and fix the or , nt ( t At times the failed to pu t t I lr ire nd riousness of the \ 1 pa thors tl elvé ex to have quet tion probler this country. Phases he ‘ ‘ no yered by the Com- rt al almost untouched iterial was together re tl freq repetitions, al- rbati: it English is often 1 at times execrable. Occasionally of terms leads to actual \ limited degree of simplified | hich seems to follow \ " ‘ pilation of data tatistical, the ook is of great \ it xa t rvation that itious will not Id conditions and » America” stands 1d yet would be pur é l ervers who have t! ntir ile population of absolutely ler tl United States law, oO 1 to America, through the combined ent and the ls in America. But one who uses due idgmert will find in this book a large ly arranged informa- rhe abundant statistical tables in the » has contributed oO tudies of labor legislation to the lication of the United States Labor, has now na compact entitled “The Law of the Employ- (Macmillan) mportant enactments of Labor endeavored to hor irize the more licial opinions which bear upon the Mr. Cat ‘ ent of labor in this country The lt e of the worl well revealed in the t cal table of content j indeed com " rehensive, embracing not merely such fun i vy tt ontre ! ental is the legal nature of the labor t ! the na tract and the law governing the payment t t ol t f 7 but also the regulation of condi attitude of the ‘ n i gor tions of employment, the . ver five and irts towards labor organizations and labor for ; ¥ : liapute dor liability, and legislation for the compensa- Over all this fleld painstaking trines concerning employers’ injured workmen author has worked with (Funk @ attention to detail, Obviously, the compress hh We lenks and W. ine of o much into mall compass neces- ‘ what ite authors 4sitat terse and concentrated treatment; t copious citations of authority offer op- fa rather than 1 suggest. The purpose portunity of further study to those who rv wish to verify or to elaborate the brief statements of the text. The list of cases thus convenient and Wubi ‘ ’ o put into the gist yp othe | Vol. 94, No. 2436 ited comprises some thirteen hundred titles Yet, despite the style in which the book is written, it is not condensed and documented unreadable. As a reference book, to which one may readily turn for information on the present status and trend of labor laws, it promises to be of real service ial investigations in a local field Labor Laws and Their Enforcement Reference to Massachusetts (Longmans)—is issued as Volume II of the Rela- tions of Women established under the di Studies in Economic ection of the Women’s Educational and In- dustrial Union of Boston Several authors 1 re ontributed the results of ind ndent r irch rhe opening cha risa ! intial monograph by Charles E. Per ns on The Early History of Factory Leg- islation in Massachusetts, to 1874 The brief description of Unregulated Condition in Wo ’s Work. by Miss Mabe! Parton and Miss Caroline Manning, owes much of interest to the fact that the authors wer the factories, worl hops, and restaurants in which they found ictual employees in regard of sanitary requirements M Gra F. Ward, Miss Edith Reeves M M l Mos liscuss in s eed- ipters th lefect n the provisions ind for it of tl Massachusetts child labor law th idministration of Mas < s ] r 1 lation n general, th iracter of the legislation most recentl ied to the statute books of the Common- I 1 illy, the Regulation of Pri- t yjlovment Agencies in the United States How r unlike in plan and un yal it x tion these several essays ma ! ectively they render not a little as- owards the achievement of their oO on purpose to give a clearer un ler- indine of the development and present po- tion of labor legislation in Massachusett: is a preliminary to further improvement of ministration.” Banques d’Emission et Trésors publics 8vo), by Ra- hette, 652 pages, s perhaps the most note- is sure to be among the most year’s books on finance. Pro-
fessor Lévy’s lectur at the Ecole des Sci- es Politiques have long been well know for their ready and apparently inexhausti- le fund of clear information about all financial questions debated in the modern vorld: and the thirty and more books pub- lished by him during the last quarter of a entury (one in 1898 on “Finance in the United States”) have a ‘customed the finan- to look for his judg- based on the al world everywhere ments. They are always facts in the case. This new book gathers into one volume much that is found scattered through the half-hundred publications (some of them of the highest interest) of the National Monetary Com- mission at Washington. tate! portabie The part of financial science which treats of banks of issue comprises, to a certain extent, the whole question of banks: for no bank is entirely independent or re- mains forever isolated from the creative organ of currency bills. In this fleld there j one particularly interesting point for study—the relations between issue institu- tions and public treasuries and the influ- ence, direct and indirect, of such relations on the credit of nations. This study is bound up with that of national finances for issue banks receive their commission from the sovereign power.
Page 23
March 7, 1912] In a masterly introduction of 24 pages Professor Lévy indicates the evolution oi the issue bank in the various nations—anc without being a poet, he ventures tv look forward to its term in the financial fed- eration of the world. He has no illusions for the present, and this gives .the chi value to his book. He sees clearly that the monetary system of the modern stat net a matter of pure finance: One of the reasons which will long delay the “unification of systems” is the desir ef governments to keep at all times ‘h: upper hand of issue banks. With th thought, more or less avowed, that in t 5 be ot crisis the banknote will war money, the state will not agree that paper shall be created only ty economic rules and to serve solely commercial uses. How is this idea made manifest nowadays in the organi- zation of issue institutions? In what meas ure and under what limits does publ action rule their business behavior? These relations of public treasuries with treated in order. Nearly the book is devoted to banks are issve three-quarters of the study of banknotes—in countries which like France, Belgium, Holland, Austria Hungary, Spain, Portugal, Switzerland Rumania, Norway more Servia, and others issue Turkey, Greece, Denmark, Japan, dent, have granted an one perticular bank; in countries like Eng- land, Germany, Italy, Mexico, and others (including the privileged banks of Canada) in which the privilege of note issue is given to a limited. number of establishments: sand the single country of the United States in which the right to issue notes is gran: depe n- monopoly t ed to an unlimited number of national banks, which are bound to observe pre scriptions of uniform legislation. To th latter country 43 pages are given, to which 30 more pages have to be added further on to explain fully the American situation This is in the second-part of the book; it deals with state currency bills—in coun- tries which have a state bank, like Russia Bulgaria, Sweden, Uruguay; and in coun tries like the United States, Canada (for the Dominion Treasury), Argentina, Chili Brazil, and others. Our work will have its full reward if by an impartial exposition of the facts, we succeed in convincing the reader of the dangers of state intervention and in d termining what relations ought to exist be tween issue institutions and public treas uries. The services which the former ren der to the latter are so much the greater as their existence is more independent and their management more sharply separated from that of the finances of the state. The less the public authorities occupy them selves with banking, the safer is the guard kept over the credit and the riches of thr nation. Dr. George N. Olcott, professor of Latin at Columbia University, died of pneumonia in Rome on Saturday. In the last fifteen years Dr. Olcott had employed much of his time in archwological studies in Italy He was an editorial contributor on numis matics to the American Journal of Arche- ology, and the author of several works or Latin inscriptions. He was born in Brook Ivn in 1869, and in 1893 graduated from Co became a fellow of the Studies at 1897 he School of lumbia In American Classical tome aditl The obvious charge to bring against } Wharton’s long poem, “Pomegranate Seed,” that has taken Der Hecate and put i: Scribner’s, is she ter and Persephone and The Nation modern introspective pessimisn nto their ancient naive Greek heads But we ‘confess to an occasional fit of weariness at the sol emn differentiations between the classic and the modern soul The similarities we daré say have always been ore than the differ ences At any rate. M Wharton has taker the ancient story and given it a new turt Persephone, recalled to earth, insists on go ing back to Pluto and his shades; she has learned to look sadly upon life as only th preparation for deatl There are beautif lines Persephone I fear the light I fear the sound of life hat thunders in mins ! customed ears Demeter Here is no sound but the ft-falling rain lersephone Dost thou not hear the noise of birth and being rhe tr of sap in boughs pregnate And all the deafening rur of the g . Demeter Love hear I, at his endless task of life Persephone rhe awful immortality of fe! The white path winding deathlessly to deat} Why didst thou call the rain from out her Aves To draw a dying earth back to the day Why fatten flocks for our dark feast, who « teside the gate, and know where the path ends Execrable offices are theirs and thine! Mine only nursiings are the waxen-pale Dead babes, so small] that they are hard to te From the little images their mothers lat Beside them, that they may not sleep alone “The Inside of a Business Man by Joseph Fels in the World's Work, is an ex cellent example of the growing literatures of self-exposure The earlier type of phi lanthropist was always a little inclined to ningle self-praise with his benefactions His charities were a form of expressing gratitude towards a Providence that had deigned to codéperate with his own excep tional abilities But there is a type of modern philanthropist who frankly ds scribes his charities as the restitution of stolen goods. Mr. Fels begins by callinghim } self a robber, and explaining his methods Arthur Christopher Benson writes about Charles Dickens in the North imeri can Review with a little more than usual ot that certain condescension in Dickens ritics which the centenary has brought out n rather startling relief The accepted process in forming an estimate of Charl Dickens is to begin | wondering why so many people for so many years should have liked a writer with so many faults as Dickens, and to end with ti discovery that Dickens was reall 1 very great man don't you know The fault in him are vulgarity, exaggeration, and mawkish sen timentalisn He is great in his fundamen tal human sympathi his vast hilarity, his fine optimism, ete. Tl implication is that we the critics love hir because of the best in him, which is an easy way of compli menting ourselves that might have ap pealed to Dickens’ humor Some times the doubt occurs whether we do not love Dickens for tho faults which our critical faculties feel impelled t fre upon—his vulgarity, his exaggeration. and his mawkish sentimentalism For the rest Mr jenson points out with considerabl: truth how Dickens’s genius and his meth ods were essentially of the theatre His books are all drama “with long ds scriptive stage directions, the scenes de- scribed, instead of being painted His characters are typical figures they make their exits and entra es, tl 6 x ‘ : very o else I the BC é ; ‘ about, they play i » One another ha Und tl heading Mania r Hyperbolism,” in the irrent number of Bookman, Max Nordau ha s tr shar] ind a sing Uw ibout the literary i ft ¥ £8 eration Critica vie wit t worshipping at tt uitar of tl } lative They ¢ jlate they ta I stutter Frequently the mere word prove nadequate, and exclamation point lashe nd dots the punctuation used | excess ve excitemert é nto play The new ritic writes of a pi ire It irrigated t ill the torrents of thought of this age and the feelings thrills ai Of a book of ve é This narrow volume i “ oOlce And here Mr Nor lau has an excellent parenthesis By the way t! book is no narrower than an other it is precisely the same width as every volume of the usual octave form, but the employment of tamiliar terms in an entirely wrong sense is also one of the characteristics of this fashionable tyl narrow” is used here for “thin.’’) The third paper » C] me ‘ ' Coo] r serie Tr \r I } graduate he Century ! wit t pirit of the ollege amy I it Psst the pr arti fi odu ve in one reader 1 it | t fa e of disapporr tand Irri M Cooper text wa er ! lw there, and icceeds only in reiterating reg i iter i tr trut that i tor tl t hi orld \ l 1 iré I protu 1 give the impre o f xistir i their ow! rké It } ea j ! that i low for i } tradictior ‘ vith t raph rhe j \\ I ! ) i \a\ ad I I | I ; ‘ ’ ' | for his able ‘ } ~ la di i i l ) j bate pr 0 née i } ' - t} tent world i led til 1 1 wh ] fro x) j ’ , P iT W ] } lex ! | ‘ I j th lars if t té i | 4 ‘ +} ; r rf la ‘ } " . er al 0 ! i i nz tl n befe It is certalr i ] it that the further ! it the | tl ond i ] the a t } oft ‘ r i hort ha r of h Jeffs Mar haw i in botl li ! who had w ked out rt Jo } Jeff ‘ Miss Shaw on the diff the stage and |} t of eri ) ght well tah t iywrieht f heart There ar nin toblograyt al ind an autobiographical drama tr ‘ the list of Aus t Strindberg pited |t Edwi Bjérkmar { the Fo ; his would : L pr ‘ mne’sa self wt } we lo not " with t) r f r
Page 24
‘ 24° » ~ ~ For that matter, Strindberg can hard- ly be called modern. He has swung through- f the tire compass from naive idylli- the t pitiless naturalism. He is LI und old-fashioned. Nor can ! artist evolutions and reactions b¢ 1 | rresponding processes in the his own soul. He seems i have een very easily influenced by the He ha opied Ibsen ind M rl but whatever he did ind t pe! A writer vho ha yund iny thing it an 1 iys in which t » me j has found Vational Geograph : j ‘ Rear-Ad | 1 a uu ing ~ I Hi i i i , . vel , | o } help ti ry to a ‘ R I to the noble work onari he qu 5 Ir ( id that I ha ! ihabitants of tha ill Europe combined r.t t! Greek br s found t} remair i Greel i oast Both articles 1, as ne uj t re irc! in (ret Lr ~~ Prof f Harvard dis ses the , r pl i ‘ : la ti t l rher l scrence CANCER / Report the Imperial P h Fund. By Dr. E. F i lbirector of the Laboratory. I r & Franci 6d é I dread which a subtle } ince! mpresses on the people, some of the general ontained in this report are nf d reassuring. Others tend vith a wet blanket, the op ; nz from the too-serious ne 0 ocalled cancer cures in the | The popular conception , incer is a novel disease brought t the intensity and strain of | inder the conditions of modern ition, is again refuted by’ refer- et » the fact that all animals down to tl marine fishes are also subject to al It tated, however, although na guarded way, that workers in some fleld labor are more susceptible to certain types of cancer than are other people; also that certain types of can- cer are on the increase, especially those of face, lip, mouth, bladder, urethra, and breast—facts which ‘offset some what the caution on page xill: “For the [ Vol. 94, No. 2436 The Nation first time it is fully demonstrated that it is erroneous to make statements of a disquieting nature about the increase of cancer in general.” The foundation for such a caution is to be found in the new tabulation of statistical data in the decennial Report of the Regis- trar-General for the years 1901-1909, in the preparation of which the Census Bureau had the coédperation of the Im- perial Cancer Research Fund. It may be remarked here, parenthetically, that a similar and a closer coéperation than Director of the now exists between our Census, or heads of State and municipal statistical bureaus, and such organ- itions as the American Medical Asso- iation or the American Association for Cancer Research, might result in more thorough and enlightening infor- ition concerning the incidence of can- more in this country. conclusions by Dr. inheritance of Some Bashford cancer important relating to the are based largely on a special in the Dr. J. A. Mur- ray, in which data are brought together covering many years of breeding exper- From these data it ap- paper report by iments on mice, pears that cancers are more likely to develop in the mammary glands of mice with cancerous ancestry than in mice whose ancestors were free from the disease. Such cancers are more frequent for all age-periods in the for- mer than in the latter group, the max- ima occurring at the same age-period in both, viz., sixteen to eighteen months, being 21.6 per cent. and 32.1 per cent., respectively, for mice of non-cancerous and cancerous immediate ancestry. To guard against undue apprehension from nelusions drawn from these results, Dr. Bashford points out that it is only ireful inbreeding of mice that this ondition of greater liability to cancer the mamma can be developed, while en with such procedure no great pre- disposition can be engendered. ! neentration as can be attained nental animal an only occur in ! in sul t by hazard, as a coinci- ‘ onsiderable rarity, and it is prob- hat the influence of heredity in the ral opulation is anifested as an predisposition of low general in- t ige XVi) lo students of cancer the more im- portant conclusions of Dr. Bashford are those that concern the problem of the genesis of malignant tumors. He demon- strates that the beginnings of cancer and the growth of are distinct phenomena, since the conditions neces- the normal tissue cells to divide are different from those which tend to maintain the division evergy after the habit of division is ac- quired. Previous reports from the Lon- don laboratory have been devoted large- ly to the results obtained by the propa- of strains in mice. In is laid on the! cancer sary to induce eancer emphasis gation this Report, conditions under which cancers develop, and a much larger field of biological inquiry is involved than heretofore. It is clearly stated that tumors, however they may be of the same type, are not equivalent, but each is individual and distinct from all others. This is proved by the fact that it ‘s impossible to make ® primary tumor grow in another ani- mal having a similar primary tumor, although it will grow if transplanted tu another part of the same animal from which it was derived. In other words, the tumor and the animal in which it have a certain symbiotic re- lation which is characteristic and dif- ferent from all other analogous rela- tions. Cancer represents, therefore, not only an abnormal growth, but also an abnormal condition in the host. The factors which go to make up this ab- normal condition are those which have tu do with the genesis of cancer. Bash- ford and his collaborators, in searching for the origin of such conditions, lay considerable stress upon the effects of chronic irritation as the cause of cer- tain types of tumors. Attention is called to the fact that cancer of specific regions of the body is prevalent in connection vith certain clearly defined habits, such a» chewing the betel-nut in India, eat- ing hot rice in China, and the habit of develops cvrrying small charcoal stoves on the abdomen in Kashmir, ete. In these cases it is assumed that a prolonged proliferation of normal cells under the the influence of chronic irritation may result in the cancers characteristic of the people subject to these habits. The authors, agreeing with the ma- jority of pathologists and students of the subject, are convinced that cancer is not to any common causal parasite. They give some evidence to show, nev- ertheless, that chronic inflammatory changes due to the presence of para- sites may be responsible for the later- developing tumors. In M. Haaland’s paper on the “Spontaneous Tumors in Mice” printed in the Report, it is stated that nematode, or round, worms were usually found in the interstitial tissues , due of old mamma, and that these were capable of causing a considerable in- flammatory reaction. From these and other similar facts, he reaches the fol- lowing significant conclusion: The importance of local factors for other forms of cancer has long been recog- nized Whether they be animate or inanimate, bilharzia, nematodes, growth of or mechani- al and actinic influences, the ultimate result of their action may be the the creation of new cell-strains continuous power of growth. The part played by the chronic is obviously a mediate one, either it produces the altered conditions which the first departure of the cell the normal may take place, or that it gives spontaneously occurring sports of cells op- portunity of multiplying and by degrees adapting themselves to a new mode of life, other cancer cells, chemical, same: with ° irritant in that under from
Page 25
March 7, 1912] similar to what is observed in propagated tumors. This hypothesis rests on the as- sumption that the malignant transformation of the tissues may take place by stages, for which there now seems to be ample evidence both from the facts obtained from observations of spontaneous cancers and from those obtained from propagated tu- mors (pp. 87-88). From the prominence given by Bash- ford and his colleagues to chronic ir- ritation as a possible explanation of the genesis of cancer, it is evident that new lines of experimental investigation will be developed. The hypothesis that can- cer is an abnormal deviation from nor- mal reparative processes, brought about through their continued activity, is bio- logically acceptable, but the difficulty comes when we attempt to account for the unlimited division energy of can- cer cells. As Bashford points out, there is a distinct difference between the gene- sis of cancer and the growth of cancer, and the responsible for the initiation of cancer may be quite differ- ent from those responsible for its con tinued growth. It is on this point that the advocates of the parasite hypothesis had an advantage, for the continued presence of the hypothetical parasite would be sufficient to for the continued stimulus to division. Another conception, however, possible: if a parasite is capable of stimulating the cell to divide, it must be for the reason that the normal physiological balance of the cell is upset. It is conceivable that such an upset on the part of cells stimulated to an unwonted activity by chronic irritation might be brought about by deranged vital activities, or by the accumulation of waste matters pro- duced by incomplete nutrition and de- Here is a field of investiga- not been sufficiently processes account is generation. tion which worked. has Drama written a volume of with New England Duffield & Co MacKaye has dealing Percy one-act life; it plays is announced by (Oxford University Press) first volume of an edition of Shakespeare in the Oxford Standard Au thors series. Two volumes will published later, and each of the three will The chief fea- those which are Henry Frowde issues the other be procurable separately. f are tures of the embodied in volumes are—a general introdu by Professor by W. J. Shakespeare's edition edition of nine smaller by the house Th introduction by Swinburn: of the sevé Dowden, and a text prepared This first comedies. an issued t same studies ral play Craig volume contal! The essential weakness in Sir A, W. Pine “Preserving Mr. Panmure,” which has produced Ly- ceum Theatre, is lack of any appealing to general human interest. All the personages are either insignificant or des- picabl No doubt it reflects with sufficient ro’s comedy, just been in the its motive accuracy the manners and morals of cer- tain typical characters plentiful enough mass vaguely England, but in described as “middle class” in the story vital point and so entirely dependent upoa theatrical mechan for effects, that it has smal! laim to consideration as serious outline of the plot must be pretty gen 4 shallow the heterogeneous social is so devoid of its main drama i he erally known by this time pom- ous county magnate, a rake reformed by orce of circumstances, is married to a re ligious devotee, who makes him deliver sermonettes” at the family prayer meet ings. Incidentally it may be remarked that the treatment of this topic is not always in the best taste rhe pretty governess Josepha—adored by all the men in a large hcuse party—shows hi how to gain credit for theological learning by ribbir his iddresses from an edition of the early fa ers, and in his gratitude he gives her a kiss Her indignation exacts fr hi an abject apology, and gre to keep si lence for the sake of his wite Uninten illy sl betrays t offen no ime of th I ( eq n sus . x j Pa I wl ha onerated, and the household is distracted t I » this ! , } ] of ] g ) ; ter it é , il f al so oO I \ 2 t! i ity and indefinitenes r Y ul yutatic ‘ Piner« } ha } f he ‘ cp rt al i is ib] +) neatness of the é I ij pi riat and itir 1 tl true and facil chara h o which was destroyed tl rfo Se slight and w si fabri f ought to have been ndled delicately by the players, but os ( th added ex aggeration to exagee tion, so that light omedy was converted to farce, and farce ito buffoonery | icl new ira t } ass th inent Frenchactress, Madame Simone furnishes fresh evidence of her intelli- gence skill, and versatility Her latest impersonation here is tha if Melissinda, the heroine of “The Lady of Drear al Eng ish adaptation and expansik of Ros tand's La Princesse Lointaing it 5 a performa full of gra beaut ind pas sion, but somewhat lacking in the g amor of roman and imagination For several reasons it would be unjust to measure it by the standards of precise riti I the firs place she i irl ! ra d 1 the foreign tongue; in tl ond, tl ( Mr Parker ad! t nd pret as it n is not the Rost and i ne rd t! : t \ support 1 her [ l experier va { intic dr i t) \ } } ade ly} jue npl l to appropriat hasis rhythr i L’Estraneg wa £ figur t tl Knight Bertra he c pre ng er tha : displa | th power and perceptior n his acting, but neither in speech nor ture had he the finish of the old Bens Most of the mi nor players tried t ike up in vigor for their deficiency in inning. As for Madame ' 243 Simone she scarcely realized—except in the atter of physical beauty—the ystical poetic charm of the idealist! visionary princess She was, in the earlier scenes at all events, distinctly modern, although her Melissinda had nothing in n with the heroines of “The Thief” or The Re turn to Jerusalen In the final act, how er, in her gradual surrend to the high spiritual love by the litter of the dying Prince Rudel, she entered mor: ompletely nto the spirit of the idyl and aved with an ecstatic tenderness and self-devotion which were exceedingly frective Ss) won personal success, but tl ation as a whole, suggested the dif ties with which any present attempt t romantic drama must be attend Edward Terry and Fred T t big } Lv ] hee } i ] re said now he " i pa to I! ul we ‘ \ as } . I a A I . i ‘ i er M I I H il] t 1 | I l » dt i ‘ | ( K VI vho wrot I Fabia ‘wa it ‘ Hig ) rT) 4 it? i lra ! i t 1 } th , 1 I irth and I | ] ’ i ntil ill lud I i 1B ] 0 Mever of the Lo 7 t has procured the | LA ‘ 1 co ] t I ‘ ed at rhe ! ittra Vv ia ‘ i ha t li} ! it Vor? i ! oO ! i } wi 4 hot f } | ur | I } | ‘) r brother, ¢ I : 1 i } t r er f r ir ‘ € ’ ‘ I for half a i fa rite of tl Born | ‘ Ma r it ta pa evts wt : 4 Griff ‘
Page 26
N yuth Wales In Mell t sl lay two seasons | i I ler i t of G. H. Rowe l s t ‘ 1 Edw : ms ins i \ rican i hed to tl r He rst i — i Ll pag in ‘ I ,ork l i i rr I t of Vl 4 ’ 1 i ery \V Id ) gaged her t tl Grand O ra H ter upon her h Harrigan and Hart Co ] Hart wa 1 genius 1 Harrigan played one type \ Mr Yea i ! xtin i I y 1 ia le abundant x He i or was pr } i Cordelia Aspirat‘ons I ind tl I r Hundred Th i i ima " t in id at last M Yea ur i ired thereafter un iz en ind j ill rts of rt Lig I ! ) { re Ca ! ind a G& He f Gre itl I th vell-known ha r and yj ! nterta died ro England, on March 1 iged four H ippeared in tl l ling t of tl Gilbert and Sullivan i I legr he left the stage I earlier o pation i in Liner which h won s on | of } Atlant \ ' imi nd rare ywer ind |} tation of r rmers, whether vocalists. in I iter ifter-dinner speak i trics, were notable. Mr ft 1 t! tuthor of various musi- } ) ’ whicl av he r t ! ind Saucer Mr. Guffin's ! t rl Gireat lovkir and Ha to the Weddi: He also published tutoblography Musie Post-Vict an Mus By Charles L. Graves New York: The Macmillan (‘o $2 net his volume consists of forty-four pa pers which originally appeared in the London Spectator, and they were decid edly worth reprinting Mr. Graves is a remarkably sane and liberal critic, apparently quite free from all objection able bla Hle has had wide and varied experience, and he is master of a sim ple, lucid atyle. The first section of his book, which isa devoted to Richard Straus “Domestic Symphony,” “Elek- tra and “Salome,” indicates at once that the title “Post-Victorian” does not ply that the book tis concerned with England only While London ts the background of most of the articles, the author takes his readers on literary excursions to Germany, Austria, and Russia; nay, there is even a paper on American Musical Critigism, in which The Nation he notes that, while in the domain of music America has hitherto been as- milative rather than creative, she has begun to stamp the impress of her in- dividuality on the alien composers and artists, and on journalists of foreign descent, including one who has gone to length of Chopin at the expense of Beethoven, depreciating Brahms, and of claiming for MacDowell Schubert and Schu- mann as a song-writer. Times change and opinions them. Of this truth Mr. gives some interesting illustrations. For several generations Handel wor- hipped in England so exclusively that excommunication, if not the gallows, would have been the lot of a critic dar- ing to write, Arthur Johnstone has done in our day, that “no greater praise can be bestowed on Handel than to say that in his very best moments he is al- the extolling of a place alongside change with Graves was as most worthy of Bach.” Mendelssohn alone was allowed for a generation to share the honors with Bach. His wor- shippers “regarded it as an act of duty any newcom- who ventured to disparage the music of er—notably to imperil the supremacy of their idol.” Mendelssohn himself did not share this a rehearsal of the Lon- example, became Schumann narrowness; at don Philharmonic, the orchestral ous and laughed at the triplet figure in the last movement of Schubert's C major told them that if they re- proper re- when mutin- for players symphony, he treat would to Schubert with he overture fused spect withdraw his own new Mr. he interesting of pages are in which describes the gradual conquest of Eng- land by the German Lied. Sir George Grove took every opportunity to call at- tention to the beauties of the songs of Schubert and Schumann, but it was not until Stockhausen visited England that British audiences began to appreciate these lyrics. Subsequently, Henschel, Bispham, Plunket Greene, and others en- tered the field, and at present London has its daily song recital. What is hard to understand is why the leading Eng- lish singers for the most part ignored Sims Reeves confined himself exclusively to oratorio, Italian opera, and English ballads. Santley had two Schubert songs on his Of all of them Among the most Graves's those this movement. almost list, and Lloyd had one, the author might have asserted what he says of Santley “While keeping abreast of sound popular taste, he did little pioneer work in enlarging the horizon of the average concert-goer.” Patti, who for so many years was the idol of the English, confined her excur- sions into the realm of the Lied to Schu- bert’s serenade and a few other simple melodies. Most amazing was the atti- tude of Antoinette Sterling. For the last two decades of her career she devot ed herself almost entirely to English [Vol. 94, No. 2436 ballads, by Sullivan, Cowen, Molloy, and others. Her attitude towards the accom- paniments of songs explains why she had no use for the German Lieder, in which the piano often plays as important a part as the voice. She would never al- low more than a bar or two of accom- paniment between the verses. After the voice had ceased, a couple of bars, sounded very quickly, were the utmost she would permit. Musicians sighed at the liberties she took with their works, but as these helped to turn them into popular successes, they had at least the larger royalties to console them. Eng- lish audiences of to-day have becpme not only tolerant of the haunting melo- dies on the piano; they even applaud songs by Strauss and Wolf and Debus- sy, in which the voice is entirely subor- dinated to the piano part. Some kinds of music are at a disad- vantage in London (as they are in New York) because of the lack of suitable homes for them. In a chapter on Lon- don’s concert halls Mr. Graves notes the fact that, whereas there seems to be no difficulty in procuring capital for the erection of new theatres or new hotels, no one comes to the rescue of the con- cert-givers. “Whenever in Central Lon- don old buildings are demolished, it is generally to make room for some new temple dedicated to the pleasures of the table.” He is optimistic enough to hope that when the present craze for restau- rant life has abated, one of the superflu- ous monster hotels may be converted from the service of appetite to that of His concluding remarks are, how- er, cheering. He half agrees with a distinguished foreigner who main- tains that musical England is deterior- ating, the interest in the art being diminished by the multiplying of com- peting distractions. art. less There are indications that the Wagner centenary will be celebrated all over the world next year, with a fervor exceeding even that of the Liszt festivities this sea- son. Oil is being poured on the flames by Breitkopf & Hartel and others who own the copyrights of Wagner's productions. As these expire next year, the publishers are anticipating the demand for cheaper edi- tions, both of the operas and the literary works, by issuing them at fabulously low rates—the operas at two or three marks each, and the twelve volumes of operatic texts and prose works for only twelve marks! An association has been formed in Paris for the purpose of collecting funds for a monument to the late Alexandre Guilmant. Humperdinck’s “Kénigskinder” is grad- ually passing into various European lan- guages. A few weeks ago it was produced in a Dutch version at Amsterdam, with brilliant success. Humperdinck, according to the latest news from Berlin, is slowly recovering the pewer of speech, which he completely lost during his recent illness. His mind, however, is not yet clear, as he still believes himself to be in London
Page 27
March 7, 1912] } a great musica! Unfortunately the gay the usual wherefore during the Munich, r of next No past city has had such Vienna capital of k of attempt to as Austria outside Is tras international tourists, no is usually made round them in other the however, Vienna that summer up (as vm sum for week offer a musical Bayreuth, and towns) a n¢ fourth will doubtless attract festival During June feast of foreigners. at the Imperial halls there masterworks far at Vienna was t will thousands In a series of performances Opera in the be presented a number of the ities and concert will in Surpassing variety the festivals in other place where Mozart, Gluck Bruckner, and Mahler wrote their masterworks:; offerings he Schubert, Brahms Beethoven. where the Bohemians, Smetana and Dvorak, help- ed to provide variety; where Hugo Wolf added his songs to the treasures of Schu bert and Brahms; where Lanner and Strauss created new styles of dances and operettas where folk-music flourished as in few other places. All these phases of Vienna's mu- sical life will be vividly illustrated during the festival week, and at the same time the Court Theatre will present the best works of Austria’s playwrights Art Etchings. With 44 illustrations By Frederick Wedmore. (The Connois- seur’s Library.) New York: G. P. Put- nam’s Sons. $7.50. “The world that cares for art at all,” says the author in the preface, “has be- come strangely and creditably occupied with original prints.” One sign of this interest in prints is to be found in the comparative frequency of additions to the literature of the subject, making interleaving already necessary in Bour- card's bibliography (“Gravures et Gra- veurs,” Paris, 1910). Mr. Wedmore’s book in a measure serves both the connoisseur and the less advanced student. While not a system- atic history of etching, it has conti- nuity of purpose, and the division into chapters on individual artists or on groups of related etchers helps to em- phasize the ever-present importance of the personality behind the print. In etching this factor is particularly po- tent, for it, more than any other graph- ic reproductive process, has served as a painter art. It has been preéminently the vehicle for the conveyance of ar- tistic impressions set down directly, without the aid of an intermediate agent, a professional engraver. This re- production of an artist’s work in fac- simile constitutes each proper impres- sion from an etched plate to all intents an original work by the artist. In the present book—the product of experi- ence and taste—the limitless possibili- ties offered by copper-plate, etching needle, and acid to the free expression of ideals and moods are emphasized by an inclusiveness, a catholicity in appre- The Nation ciation which is not, perhaps, always to be expected from the land of the au thor’s birth. It is refreshing to find Rembrandt, Steinlen, Van Dyck, Jacque Hollar, ers equally mart, Veyrassat, Bracquemond Bauer, Goya, Helleu, and oth di Vith before us The the the verse in individuality, set discriminating com ment ment state of general principles by fair-minded Simon ha is sane and In oT BF. but author s employed sentence, dainty telling—never obliter the nues which is 101), and expression by lin tching” (p. terse ly ating of the very essence of « only characterize the of defines his opinion a rhe not which he writes, but to the p Yo) reminder learly art reticence color de first first, fifth,” fact when the the the the also necessary (see And state his that necessarily it be peradventure, sirable is not but the best, “whether the second, or, so much a truism a basi repe t Is > a not that will bear ition. There are limitations to may be ignoring of Germany, and for the strange A. Platt somewhat to be noted, pre temperament. Various the sumably due reasons sought for entire Charles and Miss the omission of unbalanced America from of individual such the characterization in traits, may be as “well considered.” bly not relevant catalogues in the chapter on is well to remember that a catalogue Cassatt chapter Certain seven pages on also Zorn's por- comments, of male acceptance all his generally As to the possi- as easy not accepted remarks anent Whistler, quite it is a catalogue and not a selective list, and also that an able critic may be an indifferent cataloguer and a cataloguer incidentally a discriminating connois- seur. The bibliography negligible, and in the index the author has appar- ently attempted to summarize his com- is ments on each individual artist, a futile effort with an amateurish result. The collector will place the book on his shelves next to Hamerton, Hind, Koehler, Beraldi, and the The beginner, who has entered into the de- lights that the print offers, through one of the two or three really introductory books (not that written on prints, will do well to read the present more detailed work. He will well others. histories ) have been find imagination and recollection aided by the illustrations, which are happily reproduced by a process that breaks the line very much less percep- tibly than the screen of the half-tone. And that is of prime importance. In- deed, in etching the line, quite apart from its collective use to render masses of shade or tone or texture, often is employed in suggestive indication, with synthetic elimination, and stands out with noteworthy clearness as the sym- bol that it is. “Edin Artists’ the Black's done Lester G. Hornby has of A. & C burgh” volume a i Y Hi 4 Ww it a ‘ wor le t i | ‘ and T [ a Tt ii t i! at \r \ t ~ a ra al a I « . t Aw } } iT ’ MI eval Tow H I v \\ - x H B Wi < ‘ ) fi Jol Lal i] I f the t! we ker Hi Shinr 1 also pay An Et Zorr lo rl \\ H ial Exhibition.” Th litt book i ngl a t tl Mer & 3 tains ‘ u ind tl d We have r« 1 fre Philip I r, publisher for the Med So don, “A Catalogue of an Exhit or Masters in Aid of the National Art tions Fund, Grafton Galleri 1911 exhibition ha ilready bee re “ our London correspondent in the n October 26, 1911, and we need only a this light and beautifully printed is under the very competent editors! Roger E. Fry and Maurice W. Brock and contains eighty collotypes of old ma of every school According to the governing loan exhibitions, the attr are those of the owners rh per of error unusually small, and } of Claude Phillips's pre notice exhibition the warning signal is where needed The scholarly chara this work, and its fine reproductior commend it to seriou stude of tory of art Professor G ing his avati« i M tal of Ethie i resulted in re earthed he i pr ( ipat f Me ” 1} i r . ) , Da ] +) ries of aquedu and final! flo ade betwee nur lie and other art al I va ornamented with rows of c:« 1 til orated elie ii itio and I } " a number of statues rh iraporta this disec« I ] act that t 14 pre inda R an it | A has hither t ] rT} bronz ! ] f ! d overs ind “ 245 } qui arte ye
Page 28
46 qe 'inance BAD NEWS AND THE FINANCIAL MARKETS. During several weeks, it has been a tter of remark that prices on the Stock Exchange were not responding, n what would have seemed the logical iy, to distinctly unfavorable news. A discouraging announce- Ss, a ; of reports that business, the count over, had disappointed the hopes th which the year began, and deepening of the political confusion, t home and abroad, were received on stock market merely with apathy difference The casual observer d not have guessed, from a glance ent of prices for the day, ng at all had happened. Follow that period of inertia came singular turn in events. A he stock market which ! ;o down began to rise, and lays of greatly increased activity ft the leading speculative k t prices 3 to 5 points above last s ficures rhis occurred in the fa 0 h interesting items in the is e passing of its dividend by largest steel-producing com- inies, the further fall in prices on the of the andidacy radical plat- of extremely bad January teel market, the announcement on a Roosevelt rin, a series railway reports, the strike of a million English coal miners, the victory of New Iengland’s textile laborers over their employe the hint at a possible com- ng coal strike here, the preparation for the Money inquisition the and the pub- Trust “by House of Representatives, of a Corporation lication very hostile report on the Steel by an expert appointed by the Congressional commit- tee to its books. There seemingly Exchange to the news, not altogether new; the 15- investigate are various explanations of so anomalous a response of the Stock The phe- nomenon point advance in prices, immediately af- ter the Steel prosecution was announc- ed at the end of last October, is a lead- ng precedent It is not wholly clear, even mn whether that “November rise” reflected chiefly indifference to the uit, of buying on bad news” in an versold speculative market, or know ledge of the surprising volume of rail orders which were presently to be placed In the steel trade, Probably ost people would say now that Wall treet had talked so long of the coming suit that the thing had been “dis inted” in prices weeks before, that the state of the money and credit mar- ket was too sound to admit of any fur- ) ther undermining, and that therefore \ stocks went up in anticipation of some- thing really encouraging—which came, as such events usually tome after a season of uninterrupted gloom. ‘The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2436 It is yet to be determined whether the past week's rise in prices is a mere flash in the pan, due to the restless activit? of professional speculators, or is a sign that a turn for the better in the gener- al situation is at hand. Not the least singular aspect of the Stock Exchange's attitude is its indif- ference to the English coal strike, which began a week ago, and whose larger possibilities are admittedly of the most formidable sort. Preparations for a par- tial embargo on English manufacturing and transportation industries, for lack of fuel; rumors of possible similar dem- onstrations in the coal flelds of Ger- many, France, and the United States, and indications that the British Govern- ment had lost control of the situation, vere factors which might easily have haken financial confidence on every side. On the London Stock Exchange, is true, consols declined % point, and shares of English railways fell off 1 to 5 points: yet even at London there was no sign of demoralization, prices recovered sharply this week, and the hief comment in financial quarters was that the Stock Exchange was unreason- ably disregarding the panicky warnings and predictions which had been finding voice in the London press. It may done market sometimes measures such a situ- ation more wisely than the paragraph- The possibilities involved in a general embargo on the British coal fields are undoubtedly large enough to excite the imagination. Almost any- thing in the way of industrial disaster may be reasoned out from the conceiv- able sequel to an indefinitely prolonged industrial deadlock of the sort. But when the London editorial writers tell us, as they did last Saturday, that no such catastrophe has threatened Eng- land since the Spanish Armada set sail in 1588 from Corufia for the Channel, and the Stock Exchange hears the ver- dict without emotion, one is tempted to suspect that Capel Court may have kept its head while Fleet Street and the Con- servative Clubs have not. It might be superfluous to suggest that such a view of the case forgets the Dutch fleet in the Thames in 1667, the Mutiny of the Nore in 1797, Napoleon at Boulogne in in have so: yet the stock ers. 1804, and the Chartist meetings Trafalgar Square in 1848, not to men- tion Great Britain's complete interna- tional isolation in the stormy days of 1779 and 1895. But the more obvious conclusion is. that the coal trade crisis itself is not looked upon with a very philosophic eye. Threats of a general tie-up of all in- dustry have not been uncommon in the history of France was confronted with a possibility through its railway employees in 1910; ourselves had a taste of it in 1894; both occasions the problem recent nations such we and on | which inspired such extreme dismay was quickly solved, with the help of Gov- ernment, simply because its conceivable possibilities were so grave. It may, in- deed, be said of the English strike that the prospect of a similar early settle- ment is very much better because of the formidable condition of things which would follow its indefinite prolongation. That, beyond doubt, is what the Stock Exchange has had in mind. When the every-day comforts, necessi- ties, and activities of society at large are menaced with interruption by an obstinate labor demonstration in a sin- gle industry, society as a whole ranges itself on the side of restoration of nor- mal conditions. The laborer himself, and the quiet middle-class citizen whose action is frequently decisive in emergen- cies of the sort, took their stand with Cleveland in 1895 and with Briand in 1910. They knew very well that their own personal rights had been invaded, and their attitude rendered a settlement imperative. What remains to be deter- m'ned is whether the English difficulty can solved, under present circum- stances, without undue political commo- tion and popular disorder. be BOOKS OF THE WEEK, Adams, C. F. The Trent Affair. Fron Massachusetts Historical Society Pro- ceedings. Boston. Arvine, W. B. Hang Up Philosophy, and Other Poems. Boston: Poet Lore Co. Bailey, H. C. The Lonely Queen. Doran $1.20 net. Balch, G. B. Poems. Boston: Sherman, French. $1.25 net. Love in a Mask. Trans- Balzac, Honoré de. Ivimy. Chicago: Rand, lated by A. M. McNally. $1 net. Parton, F, T. The Boy Fancier: A Manual of Matters Appertaining to Domestic Pets. Dutton. $2 net. Bedickian, S. V. The Red Sultan’s Solilo- quy. Boston: Sherman, French. Benoit, Francois. L’Architecture Antiquité. Paris: Librairie Renouard. Betz, Frederick. Deutscher Humor aus vier Jahrhunderten. Selected and edited, with notes. Boston: Heath. 30 cents. Bowen, M. God and the King. Dutton, $1.65 net. Bowker, R. R. Copyright, its History and its Law. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $5 net. P Cabot, W. B. In Northern Labrador. Bos- ton: Badger. $2.50 net. |Carry, M, D. Betty Moore’s Journal. Chi- cago: Rand McNally. Castellane, Marquis de. Men and Things of My Time. Translated by A. T. de Mat tos. Chicago: McClurg. $1.75 net. Cazamian, Louis. Modern England. Dut- ton. $1.50 net. Cross, I. B. The Essentials of Socialism. Macmillan. $1 net. De Navarro, Antonio. Causeries on Eng- lish Pewter. Scribner. Being Letters Written Select- Sturgis Dickens as Editor: by Him to William Henry Wills ed and edited by R. C. Lehmann, & Walton, $3.25 net. Dunn, S. O. The American Transportation Question. D. Appleton. $1.50 net Elements of Phonetics, English, French, and German. Translated and adapted by W. Rippermann, from Professor Viétor’'s Kleine Phonetik. Dutton 75 cents net. Farnell, L. R. Greece and Babylon: A Comparative Sketch of Mesopotamia, An- atolian, and Hellenic Religions. Scribner. | Fowler, N. C., Jr. How to Save Money. | Chicago: McClurg. $1 net.
Page 29
March 7, 1912] Glover, E. H. More Guessing Contests by “Dame Curtsey.” Chicago: McClurg. 50 cents net. Goddard, Joseph. The Rise and Develop- ment of Opera. Scribner. Grenfell, W. T. The Adventure of Life: Being the William Belden Noble Lectures for 1911. Boston: Houghton Mifflin $1.10 net Griffin, Z. F. India and Daily Life in Ben gal. Third edition. American Baptist Pub’n Society. $1 net. Haggard, H. Rider. Red Eve. Doubleday Page. $1.20. Hard, W. The Women of To-morrow. Baker & Taylor. $1.50 net Hardy, E. J. The Unvarying East: Mod- ern Scenes and Ancient Scriptures. Scrib- ner Hirsch, William. Religion and Civilization Truth Seeker Co, $2.50 net. Honey, S. R. The Referendum Among the English. Macmillan. $1 net, Hough, Emerson. Jobn Rawn. Indianapo lis. Bobbs-Merrill. $1.25 net. Hough, L. H. The Theology of a Preacher Eaton & Mains. $1 net. Kinne, Helen. Equipment for Teaching Domestic Science Boston: Whitcomb & Barrows 80 cents net. Ladd, A. C Hieronymus Rides. Macmil- lan $1.35 net. Leavitt, M. B Fifty Years in Theatrical Management Broadway Pub. Co. $5 Lincoln, N, S. The Trevor Case D. Ap- pleton. $1.30 net Longford, J. H. Japan of the Japanese Scribner Lynch, Jeremiah The Life of David G Broderick: A Senator of the Fifties. Bak- er & Taylor. $1.50 net. Charles B. Davenport’s HEREDITY IN RELATION TO EUGENICS By the Director, Department of Experimental Evo lution, Carnegie Institution of Washington. With diagrams 208 pp. S8vo. $2.00 net.* One of the foremost authorities ... tells just what scientific investigation has established and how far it is possible to control what the an cients accepted as inevitable. . The scientific student of heredity will find In it the latest de- velopments and achievements in his particular prov ince. . . Nevertheless, it Is meant more for the intelligent general reader, who will be able to read it with entire comprehension. . Many interest ng instances that illustrate how good or bad ten dencies, physical, mental, or moral, radiate from the focal point of a single individual or family The Times Revieu Henry Holt & Co. w. ss. Studies in History, Economics and Public Law Edited by the Faculty of Politicai Science of Columbia University. IBRAHIM PASHA: Grand Vizier of Suleiman the Magnificent By HESTER DONALDSON JEN- KINS, Ph.D., Former Professor of History in the American College for Girls, Constantinople. 8ro Paper Covers, $1.00 THE LABOR MOVEMENT IN FRANCE A Study in Revolutionary Syndicalism By LOUIS LEVINE, Ph.D. With an introduction by Professor Franklin H. Giddings 8ro. Paper Covers, $1.50; cloth, $2.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., NEW YORK The Nation Lynch, L. L. (E. M. van Deventer). A Blind Shakespeare’s Tempest; A Midsu r Lead. Chicago: Laird @& Lee. $1 Night's Dream Ben Greet edition, for Mackereth, J. A. In the Wake of the Phoenix Young Readers and Amateur Players Longmans Garden City Doubleday, Pag t Marshall, W. V. A Curb to Predatory net, each Wealth Second edition, revised, Fenno Shakespeare, Tudor edition 1M & Co Night's Dream, edited by J. W Masse G British Fungi and Lichens Macmillan cents né Dutton $3 net Shakespear World Master in, J. H. B H f the Br Vil, Vill, IX Yr ish Constitution Macmilila SO ents Stein, M. A Ruins n mal Narrative of xplora Matthews, Brander Vistas of New York tral Asia and Ws Harper $1.25 net Macmillan $12.50 m Nichols, C. W Songs n Many Moods. Stephens, James The Hill of \ M Belchertown, Mass Press of L. H. Black- lan $1.25 net. mer Suteliff Hi rhe Lone Adve Pazaurek, G. E Guter und Schlechter Ge $1.35 net hmack im Kunstgewer Stuttgar Thomas, Helen Study of t I Deutsche Verlags-Anstalt American Book Co 00 cen Platonis Opera Tomus IIT, Fas Il. Verney, M. M Buch Biogra Scriptorum Classicoru Bibliotheca Ox School Book Frow ds oniensis Frowds Washburn, Stanley The Cal ‘ Putnam, N. W In Search of Arcady. Dou- ventures of an Amer un Py bleday, Page. $1.20 net. tor Sherman, Frenc! $ , Ravenel, 8S. W Ravenel’'s Road Primer for Whitman, Walt The Rolling Eart .) School Children ‘ igo McClure door Scenes and Thoughts Rideing, W. H Many Celebrities and a W. R. Browr Boston Houg Few Others Doubleday, Page $2.50 net flin $1.25 net Roe, E. T. Standard Key to Successful Dik Who's Who in Science. (International) , tionary Work Chicago Laird & Lee Edited by H. H,. Stephenson Ma illan 10 cents $2 net Saintsbury, George. \ History of English Willcox, L. Cc The Road to J Ha Criticism: Being the English Chapters of 0 cents net a History of Criticism and Literary Worden. J .. Greer : p Taste in Europe. Dodd, Mead. $2.75 net say H. A rh Monitor Schiller’s Don Carlos: Ein dramatisches rimac. Harper 0 nt Gedicht Edited, with notes, by F. W Wrench, G. T. The Mastery of L Mit Cc. Lieder Frowde. $1.25 net ll Kennerley. $4 net Scott's The Betrothed, and 17 Highland Zangwill, Israel The War God: A Widow Frow de in Five Acts Macmillar $ 2N ~~ CHARLES DICKENS | | THEMODERN PARISIENNE AS EDITOR By OCTAVE UZANNE VEARLY 400 HITHERTO UNPUB With an Introduction by the Baroness von Hutien LISHED LETTERS OF DICKENS vo. $2.25 net. (By mail, $2.50 Edited by R. C. LEHMANN of “Punch” Of the women of all nations t! m1 t : : ¢ . e ~ he ne snni | This most important of the Dick Parisienne is the most sphinx-li ens Centenary publications con- the most enigmatic, the most bril tains some 400 letters of the great liant and the most attractive T novelist, only a handful of which author passes briefly under review have ever .before been published, women of every rank, environment and all of them written at the and occupation, sketching with th . 4 , ne * hie life most interesting period of his life Nehtest and surest touch their vit They voice Dickens's intimate opin- ; . , . tues and failings ions on his literary contempora- ries and things in general. One group of them tells of his second American tour. (Cloth. Crown 8vo. Photogravure Illustrations. Boxed. $3.25 net, NEW YORK LONDON postpaid $3.45.) STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 East 27th Street, New York BI ~ I facilities for supplyina NINETEENTH CENTURY ENGLISH | Ams"ican meg English Italian CERAMIC ART French Spanish By J. F. BLACKER Over 1,200 tlustrations, 534 pages, $3.50 net A practical guide for collectors of old English pottery and c ina. combined with a history in pictures of the work of the old English master potters. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston Socialism is a force to be reckoned with. The INTERNATIONAL SOCIALIST RE- VIEW, monthly, $1.00 a year, is indispensable to the student Whe would understand contemporary Socialism. Three months, 25c. CHARLES 4G. KERR & CO., 118 W. Kinzle St., Chicago. of Celebrities Bonght and Sold. Autograph Send for price lists WALTER R. BENJAMIN, Letters 225 Fifth Av. New York. Pub."*THE COLLECTOR,” $1 «a yr. Catalogue free Correspondence a LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 years 30-32 West 27th St, New York AGENTS FOR COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PRESS LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra ries Ancient and modern languages Trapslation revision of manuscripts, ete MISS M. Hf. BUCKINGHAM 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass
Page 30
The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2436 Sone Notable Cexthonks NEW Outlines of Economics DEVELOPED IN A SERIES OF PROBLEMS By Members of the Department of Political Economy in the University of Chicago. Vew and Enlarged Edition rhe problem of improving the current methods of teach- ng elementary economics is now attracting widespread in- This planned to answer the demand for courses The which have funda- ntally determined the character and content of the book (1) A belief that the elementary course in economics book is proved ideals most t exceptional opportunities for training in thinking and ng; (2) A desire to connect the theoretical principles wi the actual facts and with current problems I s world I result 1 careful analytical syllabus of the subjects the introductory course, accompanied by ju or and problems It is expected that the Out es will be ised in connection with some textbook. W he ' lopted, tl book has improved conditions in a ! is timulated interest, vitalized the independent thought 160 pages, interleaved, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.13. EDITIONS OF TWO IMPORTANT TEXTS A Laboratory Guide in Bacteriology By PAUL G. HEINEMANN Second Edition, Enlarged and Revised. The field in bacteriology is rapidly enlarging, and the knowledge gained is being put to vitally practical use, not only in medicine, but in several of the commercial industries. With the exception of the Laboratory Guide, there is no practical handbook for students preparing for work in the branches of the science in the fermentation in agriculture, in medicine, in the municipal control of milk and of water-works, etc. The new edition of the Laboratory Guide is designed to cover the outlines for work in elementary courses in the various branches of bacteriology It is intended to serve as a guide not only to the instructor, but especially to those engaged in applying the fundamental principles In technique and method it has been care- and itself represents first edition various industries, practically of the science fully revised and brought down to date, since the the progress made in the scienc appeared in 1905, 216 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.50, postpaid $1.59. TWO STANDARD SERIES FIRST-YEAR MATHEMATICS SCHOOLS, 378 pages paid $1.15. FOR SECONDARY 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, post- SECOND-VYEAR MATHEMATICS FOR SECONDARY SCHOOLS, 296 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.50, post- paid $1.63. TEACHER’S MANUAL FOR FIRST-YEAR MATHE- MATICS, 176 pages, 12mo, cloth; net 80 cents, post- paid 89 cents By GEORGE W, MYERS, Vathematica and Astronomy, College of Education, University of Chicago, and the Vathematices in the University High School Professor of the Teaching of Inatructora in t eatriking departure from the old way of teaching int im the algebra, and geometry ] To confine the student to the handling fusing of arithmetic, ear and to the study of forms for another possibility of natural development In- 1} now led to express geometrical facts by algebra trat algebraic ones by geometry. and thus to » the casential facta that underlile both ENGLISH POEMS Selected and Edited with Illustrative and Egplanatory Notes and Bibliographies By WALTER C. BRONSON “Professor of English Literature, Brown University OLD ENGLISH AND MIDDLE ENGLISH PERIODS. 436 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.15. THE ELIZABETHAN AGE AND THE PURITAN PERIOD, 550 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, post- paid $1.15. THE RESTORATION AND THE EIGHTEENTH CEN- TURY. 541 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.15. THE NINETEENTH CENTURY, 635 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.15. This series of four volumes is intended primarily to af- ford college classes in English literature a convenient, inex- and scholarly collection of the most important Eng- lish poetry. The selection and arrangement are such as to show clearly the development and decline of the successive schools as well as the individual work of each significant poet. The selections, so far as possible, are complete poems. though concisely expressed, occupy nearly a hun- The books are in use in 100 pensive, The notes ired pages in each volume. leading American colleges. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO, Th. Stauffer, ILLINOIS AGENTS The Baker & Taylor Company, New York; The Cambridge University Press, London and Edinburgh; Leipsig, The Marusen-Kabushiki-Kaisha, Tokyo, Osaka, and Kyoto.
Page 31
» Ma ¥ ‘ : : 7 1 2 ‘ : ' i U « . ! ‘ . m ° . rs - = * — ” - - se “ 7 * S, 7 > . . m* \ ¥ , . er, . 7 7 * * . ¥ 4 a F 7. ' ‘ ‘ - : g . — ° - ee re age A . - ry auf ~ . ’ ‘ * - C ~ ‘ “ a. . . — q ” J * . m . é ° a ‘ a . ~ ie . , if e ’ by . * r : ¢ . ’ mn — * be * ; . a z ‘ * . id ’ : : ; ' ” : ‘ ‘ ‘ : 1 > ‘7 — * . r : ‘ , ; ' . ‘ . it r * i ~~ ‘ ead ‘ i i. 4? ara . : — ‘ P| : ‘ 4 4 . « ‘ a e % 1 Ps * - id é ‘ Me 4 . Ly * i : ‘ * * oe ** : . * ° a ad ‘ i ‘ bo ‘ * ¢ ba 2 . ‘ ‘ ' ‘ . * . : . * = i cas _ saa een ae -