The Nation 1912-02-29: Vol 94 Iss 2435

Page 1

ene* At Ss MAR ~The ~ Nation © VOL. XCIV.—NO. 2435 THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 29, 1912 B€dad: PRICE TEN CENTS IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS Frederick Orin Bartlett’?s great new novel, THE GUARDIAN A rare novel of the great woods, breathing the keen air of the out-of-doors and portraying the rugged char- acters of the lumbermen with a skill which surpasses any previous attempt to show them as they really are. The central theme is simple yet stupendous, and in its broad human application, possesses a fundamental! quality that gives it the widest appeal. Published five days ago; second large edition already on press. By the author of “The Seventh Noon,” etc. 470 pages, frontispiece by N. C. Wyeth, $1.35 net; by mail, $1.47. Hewes Lancaster’s § ch:rming story of Louisiana, THE ONE AND THE OTHER Here the author of “Marie of Arcady” gives her growing public another delightful classic of ‘Cajan life, in which the reader meets many an old friend and catches glimpses of many a quaint custom handed down from gen- eration to generation, in a story thatis yet sturdily American, abounding in humor .nd human nature t is the story of twin brothers, the one a leader, the other a follower. $1.00 net; by mail, $1.08. Fred Lewis Pattee’s much-discussed novel of the modern church, THE BREA KING-POINT A novel of serious importance, with a theme that makes it worth the attention of every man or woman who has at heart the problems of the church and of its work in the world—the struggle of a minister to be the real spiritual leader of a great city church. By the author of “The House with the Black Ring.” $1.25 net; by mail, $1.37. Gaston Leroux’Ss delightfully absorbing mystery, THE MAN WITH THE BLACK FEATHER “Surely a French Edgar Allan Poe. The author has cleverly drawn Theophrastus Longuet, a retired manufac- turer of rubber stamps, and in making him the hero of a ‘mystery’ novel fashions 4 weird and interesting tale full of strange, whimsical humor.”—Portland Oregonian. Translated by Edgar Jepson. By the autnor of “The Phan- tom of the Opera,” “The Mystery of the Yellow Room,” etc. Illustrated by C. M. Relyea,$1.20 net; by mail, $1.32 READY SHORTLY . Credo Harris’s powerful novel of Kentucky life, TOBY This novel by a new author merits the attention of all lovers of good fiction for its vigorous and sincere por- trayal of life in the hills of Kentucky and its sound delineation of character. The regeneration of Toby and the revelation of his personality through the influence of a true and tender love form the theme of one of the most delightful stories that have seen the light of day for a long time. $1.25 net; by mail, $1.37. Marion Hill’s delectable story of the life of a wholly charming actress, GEORGET TE Have you ever wondered whether there is anywhere another actress as diverting as “The Chorus Lady’? Read “Georgette!” Have you ever wondered what goes on in an actress’s mind? Read “Georgette!” Have you ever wondered if an actress is always artificial? Read “Georgette!” Have you ever wondered why there is no real classic of the American stage? Tuere 1s. Read “Georgette!” By the author of “The Pettison Twins,” “Harmony Hall,” etc. $1.25 net; by mail, $1.37. READY SHORTLY Mrs. Mabel Loomis Todd’s delightful and authoritative TRIPOLI THE MYSTERIOUS This is the only book in the English language on Tripoli as it is. The author has had unusual opportunities for first hand knowledge, having twice accompanied her husband, Professor David Todd, of Amherst, on expeditions to Tripoli to observe total eclipses of the sun. The book is charmingly informative. By the author of “A Cycle of Sunsets,” etc. Profusely illustrated. $1.50 net; by mail, $1.62. Ezra Pound’s wonderful English verse translation of THE SONNETS AND BALLATE OF GUIDO CAVALCANTI Mr. Pound, who is widely regarded as the most original force in American poetry since Whitman, here de- votes his genius and his rich knowledge of things medieval to the rendering into English verse of the work of Guido Cavalcanti, the friend and in more than one way the inspirer of Dante. The result Is a Sook that may fairly lay claim to the distinction of being one of the most significant volumes of poetry ever done by an American. $2.00 net; by mail, $2.15. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY, 15 Beacon St., BOSTON

Page 2

The Nation Educational sO The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 Travel “HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. r , — . — Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 1MWEEKLY JOURNAL. 25 Park Street, Boston 1845 U St., Washington = \ York 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland 4 Steg I ( igo 18 DouglasBd., LosAngeles 2 I I I ver i5 Wright Blk. Berkeley Send t address above for Agency Manual. 18 I 4% Prog y ent B, Fisk, Mgr rith ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY I'wenty-« years of successful ex- ther good teachers and S St., Albany, N. ¥. Ask 8 for yourself 1 ’ ' —— — ——_- | 4 ] RITIN EN, AGE 37, 4 Pe t f ‘*Tudor-Stuart \ Englis with experien in University ! f n engagement in { ’ \ { 2 Nati ‘ ——— — PRIVATE BOARDING SCHOOL in G n university town Bonn would take 12-18 years old; beginning October, 1912 I ! and r branches. Good ch, Rheinland JOHANNA HINZEN, Zily irs are in effect pri- practically inde Personally ling crowds, ind unnecessary Our T« vate parties pendent trave | ve annoyance expense Spring Tours ITALY, ALGERIA SPAIN, RIVIERA Summer Tours i North Cape, Russia, British Isles, | Balkan States, Germany, France, Special Swiss Tours. Steamship Reservations via all Lines PU — Si | Send for Be urs ( ( THI NUMBER Briarcliff? Manor, New York | Raymond & Whitcomb Co. ’ , a? a ‘ | 38 Was gton St Bosto Chicago, Pitts MRS. DOW'S SCHOOL FOR GIRLS | | 2 rit ie Nowe Font | barat! Detroit ‘ ss M {ARY E. DOW, Pri: | eesChestustSt. Philadelphia | Sen Francisco SL A CTT “e - Just Published sieaieaiidinlta a : For Sale A REVISED EDITION OF sd ~~) ‘ ? > “O17 Montgomery's Leading Facts § /,04 847% 47 &uvTLoeKxol?, “ ” I 1 Haut cottage and a lot of about [ cres Cottage has irge sitting room, writ of English History Z ind two bedrooms on the first floor, and — - : e bedrooms on the second floor. four bathrooms, rhe Story ut s been for years the ' modern conveniences It commands, from . Ar 8 No other tl viows, views of the Camden Hillis, Deer is in clarity of Is ind the mountains of Mt. Desert. The cl ib ty. I the best on the coast excessive heat s it 8 ' s the most im nes known ind, being twenty miles from tl s : levelopment of the mainland he climate is exceptionally equable, t! I n and vers the ground wat ! times In twenty-four hours being ever ! s vered b gh-scho irse ' in two degrees The island is about 7 rt . r . } extensive re " . mc by 2 m s wide, and the summit of 1 t f ti prev edition It includes the mountain is about 600 feet above tide A fresh s and tw five new illustrations, vatet ike, f more than " in length is her w 1 new and superior letter stocked with land-locked salmon. A road of thir r th gh Teachers who desire to i nu s around the island affords charming ; clal study of Constitutional His views, and gives access to cliffs rivalling those \ t cr y aided by the revised Mt. Desert For terms pply to Ernest W. Bow i ( I s iry on that subject and by the im- litch, 60 Devonshire Street, Boston, Mass j nt Constitutional Documents contained eS = x of the book ’ Price 81.20. For Rent 7 ' GINN AND COMPANY aeerenennneienre = { Boston NewYork Chicago london J URNISHE | / Fin ¢ rage Atlanta Dallas Columbus San Francisco Mass.. next tt Longfellow Hons tr , rrr,” fer seison S12 bs a masters [eine rooms kitchen laundry amd gr master’s I | ri bewtrooms, 2 baths ser tx in 1 tronk-roon . Occupancy given aft August 1, 1912 Apply to HW owner at 113 Brattle Street I | : NINETEENTH CENTURY ENGLISH | By J. F. BLACKER SAMPLE COPIES Over 1,200 tluetrations, 534 pages, $3.50 net. A practical guide for collectors of old OF English pottery and ¢ ina. combined with a history in pietures of the work of the old English master potters THE N TION LITTLE, BROWN & C0., Publishers, Boston f \ PHYSIOGRAPHY “" “°° 80" 28eress fer :, ard Stes -_ By Avey, Bryant, Clendenin and Morrey several weeks ; _ A text-book for secondary schoo.s. It emphasizes economic and human values, I . and meets the requirements of college en- i jan WITHOUT CHARGE Cloth 516 pp. Illus, and mapa, $1.25 it " Wi °°) D.C. HRATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago The Nati i 0 denies tec teanieeen F. M. HOLLY e Nation ! Rrentano's 17 Avenue de l'Opéra ir . . . dee ene eeennne saan & ttbwn 4 testetene Authors’ and Publishers’ Representative « Charing Cross Circulars sent upon request. 156 FifthAv.,NewYork | 20 Vesey St., New York City

Page 3

Ed. by PORTER-CLARKE, Text of 1623, postpaid. Feb. 29, 1912] The Nation 11h THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE SYNTAX OF EARLY LATIN VOLUME I.—THE VERB Full Notes and Variants PRICE $4.00 Midsommer Night's Dreame."’ ‘‘Love's : * ‘ i rs Lost,” “Comedie of Errors,” “Merchant By Professor CHARLES E. BENNETT, of ( enice,”’ “‘Macbeth.’’ “‘Julius Csar,’ **Han let.” “King Lear,” “Twelfe Night,” “As You Extracts from the Reviews: ke. It."’ Henry the Fift.’’ *“‘Much Adoe About hing.** Romeo and Juliet,’’ “Tet st Winter's Tale."’ “‘Sbrew,”’ Iwo G f Veror Corlolanus ‘Merry Wivy s W Measure for Measure, A nie I ( ritus Andronict : rymon f n I les,’ Cymbeline,”’ rroylu hard i,’ “Richard It,’’ King John j ' ry IV Part I “Henry te Part I! t 4 Cloth, 75 cents; limp leather, $1.00 per volume . . Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.. New York i THE GLORY THAT WAS GREECE | | ~~: : A survey of Hellenic oulture and civilization so gut Vorg By J. C. STODART, M.A. *(Steht 200 illustrations. Cloth, gilt top. 7.50 net. tspract m Geblet J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Publishers, Phila. 0 nig A i weg , Six Months Subscription Free “ALLYN & BACON Boston New York Chicago THE NATION will extend SIX MONTHS the term of any sub Socialism (yienyirioxal socaust re | EUROPEAN YEARS scriber who sends a name not al- VIEW, monthly, $1.00 a year, ready on our list with remittance for Socialism. — Three months the new subscription for one year. euimmentiadioad is indispensable to the student Whe would understand contemporary : 25e¢ CHARLES H KERR & CO., 118 W. Kinzle St., Chicago The Letters of an Idle Man $2.00 net Posty aid $2.14 AT ALL BOOKSTORI L —" Y Send for catalogue N BROOKS All out ehastat becks supplied, no N A | | () N FOREIGN ote wior BOOK CO. TAUGH ITZ matter on what subject; write me, atating beoksa THE , - > —_— 28 Tremo itree shen g 20 Vesey Street New York City BOOKS BOSTON. MASS. AUTHORS 50.000 rare books, BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP Jobn Bright St Birmingham, Englenod School Advertising in The Nation THE NATION stands alone in its field. It has a larger circulation than any other politico literary journal published in this country, going to all the principal libraries and reading rooms, and into thousands of families The circulation i§ chiefly among the thinking and well-to-do classes—lawyers, phy sicians, bankers, and other professional men—and in the homes of cultivated people, where the education of children is a matter of careful consideration. The rate is reasonable, and discounts are made on continuous insertions, of which most of the school advertisers avail themselves. tion with the following discount 5 pet Advertising rates, 15 cents an agate line each inse 4 insertions, 10 per cent. on 8 insertions. SPECIAL RATE TEN CENTS A LINE NET FOR THIRTEEN TIMES (:ninimum space three lines) ( r wardec ou any responsible advertising agency, or directly to Orders may be forwarded through any res ble advertising agency y t TE NATION, 20 Vesey Street, N. Y. BRITISH wanted I can get you any book ever published n Englend. call and tinespect my stock ef

Page 4

lv The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2435 = = = ——— NEW BOOKS FROM THE DUTTON LIST Syndicalism and Labor By Sir ARTHUR CLAY, Bart. One volume, 7% in. x 5 in. $2.25 net A valuable book on the beginnings and rise to favor of the “General Strike” as Labor’s most deadly weapon, including some account of the French “Syndicats Ouvriers” which initiated it. The principal so-called “General Strikes” of the past few years in France, Sweden, Italy, and Spain are de- scribed and their results noted. A most timely and informing book, written in a temperate and judicial] spirit. The Pilgrims’ Way From Winchester to Canterbury By JULIA CARTWRIGHT (Mrs. Ady) New and Revised Edition. Illustrated by 8 colored plates, 8 half-tones and a large number of line drawings, all specially made for this volume by A. H. Hallam Murray. One volume, 8) in. x 64 in. $5.00 net A picturesque description of the ancient road still known as the Pilgrims’ Way, along which for nearly four hundred years the pilgrims to the renowned shrine of St, Thomas of Canterbury (Thomas a Becket) traveled from Winchester to Canterbury. The author knows her ground thoroughly, its history past and present, and takes her readers with her into the heart of the most beautiful and storied part of England. ° Mr. Hallam Murray's admirable drawings give an excellent idea of the old house, ancient ruins and the lovely scenery through which the old road zigzags from village to village. The Ideals of Indian Art By E. B. HAVELL, C.LE. Formerly Principal of the Indian Government School of Art and Keeper of the Calcutta Art Gallery. Au- thor of “Indian Sculpture and Painting,” etc. Illustrated with 33 plates from photographs. One volume, 10 in. x 7 in. $5.00 net This is a very original and very comprehensive introduction to the study of the main branch of Indian Art, namely Indian sculpture. The author maintains that the reason Europeans consider Hindu sculptures to be fantastic or preposterous is that the religious beliefs, legends and hopes symbolized in them are not taken into consideration by the Euro- pean critic. Here the author focusses the principal achievement of Hindu plastic art together with the leading re- ligious ideas of Hindu mythology which that art expressed, so that a clear perception of the relation between the two is possible to the reader. The plates are admirable examples of the photographic art. The French Ideal: Pascal, Fenelon and Other Essays By Madame DUCLAUX (“A. Mary F. Robinson’’) $2.50 net Madame Duclaux, wife of the celebrated Director of the Pasteur Institute in Paris, has already won distinc- tion in letters over two other signatures, A. Mary F. Robinson and Madame Darmestetter. Well known as a writer of beth prose and verse in her adopted language, French, and for her unusual power of expression in English, she is the ideal interpreter of the great French writers of the past generation for English speaking readers. The four essays are on Pascal, Féne'on, Buffon, and Lamartine. The Cult of Incompetence By EMILE FAGUET $1.50 net Translated by Miss Beatrice Barstow. P This work has attracted widespread attention in France, and exhibits many of the dominant tendencies of the democracy of the present day to discourage the highest talent in all principal walks of life, and to encourage medi- ocrity and incompetence, to the ultimate detriment of the nation and national character. Sixty Years: Life and Adventure in the Far East By JOHN DILL ROSS Three photogravure plates. 20 ether illustrations and a map. 2 vols. $7 net “A blography of adventure In love, trade, finance, fights and diplomacy . . . more human and at times more exciting than any novel we have seen these many years.” The Surgeon’s Log By J. JOHNSTON ABRAHAM Richly illustrated with photographs. $2.50 The day-by-day story of a ship's doctor on a well-found trading steamer. Rich in anecdote, reminiscence and description of many Eastern ports, the less familiar as well as the better known. Pocket Guide to the West Indies By ALGERNON E. ASPINWALL $1.50 net New edition with maps, illustrations, historic and statistical data and complete guide for each locality. E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY, 31 West 23d Street, New York

Page 5

The Nation NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 29, 1912.! been used in connection with the other | Western straw votes, that there is a whirlwind demand of the people that Debs be made President. The Week The winning of half the Oklahoma delegation to the Baltimore Convention the Chicago Ender Ocean, but ite espest- is a highly significant victory for Wood- tion to the desire of political conven- row Wilson, for it fully confirms the | tions to break all records for length of estimate that has been placed by his| coring popular leaders is both sound advocates upon his strength in the Mid- 144 poid. It owns to sympathy with dle West. In Oklahoma Champ Clark the man who rises and waves his flags was supposed to be strongly intrenched, | ..4 jets out his voice from spontaneous the neighborhood feeling, as well as oth- | |impulse. It even avows a belief in the er elements, being a powerful factor in | yelling that is sincere. But it criticises his favor. With this send-off in a com- | the “demonstration” that has become a paratively unpromising State, it may pore affair of keeping itself going as now be expected that cumulative indica. | ong as possible, and it refers to the Gens of Gov. Wilson's strength will be 'spectacle at Chicago and to the one at showing themselves, both in the West Denver four years ago when the names and in the South. Of course, much will ‘of Roosevelt and Bryan, respectively, depend on developments in the political | . ne presented. Those who read of situation generally, and in the Republi | nat followed may have received the can as well as in the Democratic party. | idea of a touching outburst of genuine The case is very different from what it | hoyalty which a solid hour of shouting would be if the Republican nomination and marching could hardly exhaust, but were a foregone conclusion. We are not always able to agree with For the) present, nobody can be quite certain what aspect the campaign will present; and at the last moment the choice may turn on the feeling that one Democrat rather than another is the “logical” can- didate to be put up at Baltimore in re- sponse to the choice made the previous week at Chicago. One straw vote in the West has been strangely overlooked by the Colonel's admirers, though it gives convincing proof of his immense popularity. We refer to the postal-card canvass conduct- ed by the Appeal to Reason, This is the well-known Socialist paper, with a large circulation. Calling upon its readers for an expression of their Presidential preferences, it has found, to date, that 41,384 of them want Roosevelt, while only 426 declare for Taft. This looks perfectly overwhelming till we note that Roosevelt really ran fourth, Debs lead- ing with 65,928 votes, McNamara get- ting 54,726, Gompers being third with 48,225. Closely after Roosevelt, the fourth favorite, came Haywood with 41,109 votes. This is fine company for the Colonel. But as he is only fourth in the affections of the Socialists, it fol- lows, by the irresistible logic which has | dic. |to those on the spot the creaking of the ‘machinery grew increasingly evident af- iter the first few minutes. And what good came of it at last? A few short |months after Mr. Bryan’s trained acous- ticians had triumphed over those of Mr. Roosevelt, and still more impressively over those of Mr. Taft, the last-named gentleman was inaugurated. Those were wholesome and sober words that Gov. Harmon spoke to the Kentucky Legislature when he said that the ultimate force behind the movement for the initiative, referendum, and re- call was supplied by the shortcomings of the men in public office. Agitators are quick to seize upon grievances and make a great noise about cheap cure- but there, such men would have little chance, alls; if the grievances were not /Quite properly, too, Mr. Harmon point- ed out some substantial administrative and fiscal reforms that had been accom- plished in Ohio in his term as Gover- nor; for upon actual achievements of this kind the government as we have known it in the It is to be regretted, case for representative past must rest. |however, that he put the case of the ex- penses of the national Government as he “It ought not to cost,” he said, “a billion dollars a year, or over $11 for each man, woman, and child in the country, to maintain the Federal Gov- ernment with its limited That there is need of economizing in the Federal Government is true enough; functions,” but such a statement as this makes a false impression. Outside the post of- fice, which is self-supporting, the annual expenditures of the Federal Govern- ment are not a billion dollars, but about $650,000,000; and of this about $400,000,- 000 are for army, navy, pensions, and What is spent in order to “maintain the Federal Government, with its limited as that phrase would usually be interest on the public debt. func- tions,” understood, is about a quarter of a bil- lion dollars, instead of a billion. Serious faults in the bill to regulate immigration, now pending in the Sen- ate, are discovered as the debate on the As drafted, the bill specified among aliens to be excluded eligible to come citizens of the United States by The ob- viously, to settle in this way the ques- measure proceeds. “persons who are not be- naturalization.” intent was, tion of Chinese and Japanese immigra- But difficulty once arose; for in order to become nat- tion. an unforeseen at uralized, applicants must be able to speak English, and hence this clause of the bill might be tortured into author- ity for keeping out all immigrants who speak only a foreign language. When this danger was pointed out, the advo- bill accepted an amendment providing that cates of the rather shamefacedly “no alien shall be denied admission to the United States solely because of in- ability to speak the English language.” Even this does not meet the case, since applications for naturalization must, by the law, be “signed by the applicant in his own handwriting.” Thus there might be in the clause in question a lurking attempt to set up by indirection the literary test for immigrants. Other similar complications might easily be caused by passing the bill as framed. Its chief defect, as we have before sald, is its lack of explicitness. It may be well to revise and codify our immigra- tion laws, but the work should be done with a thoroughness that left no room for suspicion of “jokers” in the bill.

Page 6

20OO The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 Early action is expected in the Senate on the Stephenson case. The Committee on Privileges and Elections is unan- imous in saying that the expenditure of $107,793 (the amount which Senator Stephenson acknowledges he paid to carry the primaries) “was in violation of the fundamental principles underly- ing our system of government, which contemplated the selection of candi- dates by the electors, not the selection of the electors by the candidate.” Yet the majority of the committee does not see in that fact sufficient reason for un- seating the man who paid this sum of) money avowedly and designedly for that purpose. In other words, the majority lends its sanction to a violation of the “fundamental principles” of our system of government, and gives its assent to the selection of electors by the candi- date, on a cash basis. If the Senate ratifies the majority report it will by so much give license to the rich men of the country to buy up the seats in that body. If all the seats are to be put up at auction, there is no doubt that buy- ers can be found in all the States ag easily as in Wisconsin and Illinois, 4 brief homily on the question of vio- lence in labor disputes, chiefly interest- ing because it is written from the “in- side,” appears in last week’s Indepen- dent. The author is Harry Orchard, of Haywood-Moyer trial fame, and he writes from the inside of Idaho State’s Prison at Boisé. It is Mr. Orchard’s emphatic belief that “direct action” is both wicked and unprofitable. The sys- tem of intimidation by dynamite did work well, “with hardly an exception, up until the McNamara confession,” but it has now got a blow from which it will never recover. All right-thinking men will join Mr. Orchard in this hope. At any rate, Harry Orchard out of prison never did as clear thinking as he re veals in the following passage while the great wheels of industry T busy grinding out their dollars, they are also slowly but surely, grinding out the lives of men and women that keep them in motion.’ Some of the great in duetries are very hazardous at best The greedy captains that control them should be forced to make the conditions ag safe and sanitary as possible. The kind of force however, that we have been talking about will not do the work But if labor or eenizations will place big, broad-minded men at their head, letting them direct the policies of the union, and, énstead of sow- ing the seed of discontent and strife, es tablish schools of education along eco- | one of less importance, and eleven civil nomic lines, ete. |}cases. At the same time I opened my as- that the partisan of | *!2e in London, a court in Detroit, Mich., par, % j}only a few hours further along the rail- direct action” is dazzled by the imme- | road, began to get a jury in a murder case diateness of results obtained. A bridge|My four prisoners were on their way to or a factory is blown up and the “vic. | the penitentiary and seven of the eleven |civil cases had been disposed of before tory” is won. A fig for your painfully | hait the jury had been got together in De- slow orthodox union methods! What the | troit. Our criminal law is codified anarchist refuses to see is that violence, |!" the simplest possible form, and there is ;not an appeal once in fifty cases. like murder, will out; that his “victory” | turns to ashes, and that it takes years | The contrast may here be somewhat ex- |aggerated, but in essence it represents | the truth. And what do we get in re- |turn for the frightful waste and trouble ‘of our criminal procedure? Does any The American Express Company, We | one pretend that we get more exact jus- read, has paid $43,500,000 in dividends | tice than is attained in England or in since 1868. Forty-three million dollars Canada? Is it not true, on the contrary, in forty-four years is almost exactly @| that the tremendous cumbrousness of million dollars a year, and that might | our procedure only lowers the confi- not seem an outrageous annual profit for | gence of the community in the soundness a business concern of such vast dimen- | of its results? sions. Neither is there anything over-| whelming in the statement that this| Resolutions pointing to an energetic same company has received from its|campaign against the chestnut tree patrons during the same period the sum | blight marked the close of the congress of $598,000,000, which means an annual) of experts from twenty-nine States, gross revenue of $15,000,000 a year; | which, at the invitation of Gov. Tener, this again might seem no formidable has been meeting at Harrisburg. The sum for an enterprise of national scope. | gathering called upon the States, the One need not hold a brief for the ex-| Federal Government, and Canada to fol- press companies to question the ins Vint the lead of Pennsylvania in combat- tiveness of such long strings of figures. | ing the disease which menaces the entire Nevertheless, there is little doubt that| chestnut growth of the Atlantic Coast, the express companies have been charg- by making appropriations to “enable ing excessive rates and accumulating | authorities to cope with the disease, very large profits. The Interstate Com-/| where practicable.” One resolution asks merce Commission's investigation into | Congress to appropriate $60,000 for the express business has already been | the Government coéperation. Two op- more than justified. But for the pur- | posing points of view were manifest in pose of emphasizing the extortionate the first session of the congress. Delay practices of the express companies, the | was advocated by Prof. W. A. Murrill of statement that they charge fifty cents; New York. who asserted that public for carrying a parcel that could be car-| money could be saved by allowing active ried for fifteen is more convincing than field work to wait upon further scien- any number of millions spread before tific investigation; but for the policy of immediate extirpation of affected trees, to prevent further spread of the de- The trouble is of painful effort for labor to make up the loss of that “victory.” the eye. It would be interesting to know how | Structive blight, I. C. Williams, deputy ; leading members of the bar in our coun-| forestry commissioner of Pennsylvania, try feel when confronted with such a| Stood sponsor. The results already ob- statement as that made by Mr. Justice | tained by this method in that State led Riddell of Ontario, in an interview in| to the endorsement of its militant policy the New York Sun: | by the congress. 1 have been at the bar or on the bench | about thirty years, and never, even in mur-| The movement to erect a memorial to der cases have I seen more than half an Whittier in the national capital calls at- hour consumed in getting a jury. . . . Tl ontion to an odd diversity between our have never but once known even a murder | case to last as much as four days _| professions and practice. At bottom, we Some time ago I went to hold the London | ave a peaceable people, with a jealous (Ont.) Assizes. There were to be tried four!) orerence for the supremacy of the criminal cases, one of murder, one of man- slaughter, one of serious embezzlement, and! Civil power over all matters of the army rr

Page 7

Feb. 29, 1912] The Nation and navy. But when we look around for distinguished citizens to whom mon- uments may appropriately be erected, we are strangely beset by the notion that such persons must belong to one of two classes. They must be either dead therefore presumably The ex- ceptions are just numerous enough to the breaks the monotony of the long series politicians, and statesmen, or heroes of battle. emphasize rule. Longfellow now of statues to “public” men in Washing- ton, but there is no reason why his memorial should not be supplemented by those of several other men and wo- men who have raised our national rep- utation by what they have written rather than by what they done. Secretary Knox striking an appropri- ate attitude at Panama and bidding all Central and South America stop, look, and listen to the honeyed words in which their big neighbor at the North once more strives to express its feelings towards them, will be a sight for gods and men—and Mr. Dooley. “Here,” the Secretary may begin with a smile, “we ground—that is, of meet common course, if the Government which I have on the honor to represent does not decide to discriminate against you in the mat- ter of tolls. The one subject of possible disagreement between the United States and any of you having been happily re- moved by the—er—annexation of this fair land, my Government feels very strongly that it is a part of the patriot- ic duty of every citizen of a Central or ! | } South American republic, especially of | those in authority, to let bygones be by-| gones, to accept our protestations of goodwill at their face value, and, in a word, to think of us as we would fain be thought of.’ At this point the cheer- ing will doubtless no longer be restrain- ed, unless Col. Goethals should mean- while Nicara- gua’s book, and given orders prohibit. have taken a leaf from ing any demonstrations, favorable or otherwise, in connection with the Sec- retary's visit. The first bye-election in Canada since last year’s overwhelming Liberal defeat has resulted in a gain for the Liberals, which is quite in accordance with the law that seems to govern bye-elections. It is the regular thing that, after a gen- the country eral campaign in which has plumped with unrestrained enthusi- asm for one party or another, the vot- ers shall turn about, and right on the heels of election day begin to elect mem- bers of the minority. Apparently, there is about this procedure something of the shame-faced awakening to cold wisdom which follows an emotional outburst. Certainly some such reaction was to be looked for assertion in Canada, where a sponta- neous of unsuspected popular sentiment made fools out of the proph- ets in both parties. No one has yet been able to bring out all the reasons for that mad rush in which the Liberal party was so badly trampled. Partial explana tions are at hand in plenty, but at bot tom we seem to be facing one of those curious manifestations of the psychol egy of the crowd which make the busi- ness of political prophecy so hazardous The figure of George V has gradually emerged during the hopeful discus- sions regarding the betterment of An gio-German relations. A German news peper of standing assigns credit to the English monarch for taking the initia tive in Mr. Haldane’s visit to Berlin. There is nothing improbable in the hypothesis. It would be quite appro priate that King George should take up a line of activity in which Edward VII useful work have done The is conceded to for his country. late King was largely instrumental in forging the chain of Continental friendships and alliances which Germany chose to re- gerd as a menace to her own interests but which, there is good reason to be- VII the lieve, Edward regarded sincerely as working for peace of Europe. The sphere of foreign affairs is one in for all his which a British monarch, ecmplete subordination to Constitution- al forms, still exercises real power. Un- like the late King, who was his own travelling ambassador, and whose per sonality made him welcome in the capi- tals of Europe, George V chooses to work through his Ministers; but there is every reason to believe that the mon- arch’s views will carry weight with the Cabinet The bill providing for the annexation of Tripoli and Cyrenaica was passed in the of Friday with only thirty-eight dissenting Italian Chamber Deputies last votes in a poll of 469, and amidst scenes of frenzied popular enthusiasm. From the first it has been apparent that, with ‘> ~~ O1 the exception of the revolutionary So- cialist faction, the attack on T: had popular approval behind it, in the sense that the men who engineered the raid could count on certain indition of public sentiment The Italian peop has watched the annexation game beings played on all sides, bi France ahd spat Austria in the Balkar Bi in Morocco, by by Russia and Great tain in the Far East. The memory of Italy's own experiences in Abyssinia |! al National sentiment has bee it a climax by the celebration of t! ‘ 7 1 entennial of Italian «anit cian was taking undue risk in plannis an attack pon a defence] province undet only danger lay in military operations. A serious setback would bave been fatal to the ¢ ! 4 dete rushing at might have bee tal tothe throne. So far these dans been averted, till have out of the heavy taxa arising is the corollary f Imperi: and is beginning to be in Europe a f ful source of popular discontent Mr. Shuster’s statement to the I ~ is not so careful in its wording as } speeches in England and elsewhs his way home from Teheran At any rate, it is overstating the cuse Great Britain of having set out “to create a Russia after the lan strong It nor anese war.” Was not within Eng land's power for her be to create a Russia That strong pire’s recuperation from the disas ters of the Manchurian war wa i nat ural and inevitable proce proces remain true is that the present d ters of English foreign policy have at tached so much importance to Russia‘s friendship in Europe that they hav been willing to let the Czar have vir tually a free hand in middle Asia. That is a policy of which the wisdom as well as the morality may be easily weak question- ally friend is The Russia as an or a reed to lean upon. Frenct found that out again and again in th ccurse of recent complications with Ger many. And England, too, may discover Russia's friend of im the cold in time of crisis, that ship was not worth the sacrifice portant interests in Persia or blooded abandonment of that country to the tender mercies of the Czar

Page 8

ROR THE “HEAVY RESPONSIBILITY.” Mr. Roosevelt declares that he real- izes “to the full” the “heavy responsi- bility” which he assumes in announc- ing that he will be a candidate for the Presidency. But does he? Can he be en- tirely aware of the full weight of the which he is binding We doubt We grievous burden on his own back? it. should hate to think, for example, that he had deliberately considered and cool- ly the fact that about to shatter the ideal of Roosevelt which hi mistakenly, cherished all over the coun- disregarded he was is been admiringly, however For in that ideal one element has try been the conception of him as a man fit to stand on the holy hill because he sweareth to his own hurt and chang- eth not. ( But now he is seen to be false to his plighted faith, What he had voluntarily and solemnly assured the people that he would do under no circumstances, he now proposes to do without explanation or a glimmer of re- morse. Thousands of his truest friends have been vehemently asserting for three years past that Theodore Roose- velt was incapable of doing this thing. Whatever else he might be, But this trust in him In- he was a man of his word. he has now dashed to the ground. stead of Machiavellian prince acting on the max- the ideal Roosevelt, we see a im that a “signore prudente” does not feel bound to stand by his pledges when they can be turned against him, or when his motive for making them no longer exists To multitudes throughout the land this will seem a fall like Lucifer’s, that other son of the morning. It is not now a question of the validity of the tradi- tion against a third term. It is merely a question of Theodore Roosevelt's per- sonal honor. Others may doubt or chal- lenge the third-term custom; he cannot. He publicly pronounced it “wise,” de clared that he felt bound by it, and told the people who had just elected him President: “Under no circumstances will I be a candidate for or accept an- other nomination.” John Morley was a guest at the White House when Presi- dent that announce- ment on November 8, 1904. The story was printed at the time that Mr. Roose- velt said to Morley that his declaration ‘no string” to it. The Bnglishman Roosevelt made had was puzzled by this bif of American The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 ———= | slang. Now, however, Honest John will | party principles may be trampled upon, understand what it means. The “string” undying bitterness and rancor may be has been pulled and the word broken. It is a terrible thing for Roosevelt thus destroy the faith which credulous thousands have placed in his personal] to integrity. The heavy responsibility which Mr. Roosevelt has blithely shouldered in- cludes the confirming of the worst in- terpretation which has been put upon his conduct for the past three years. He himself now admits the truth of what he has been charged with. In the light of his own statements, few can be found longer to believe that his course has been aught but that of a secret plotter. To undermine his friend Taft has been his passion. To scheme for his own nom- ination has been his consistent but con- cealed plan. What are we to think now of its successive steps? First, he was not a candidate and would not be. He wrote last year that any movement to win the nomination for him would be a “genuine calamity.” He asserted that no friend of his could possibly coun- tenance kind. Then came the time of his standing on his dignity. He would not do a thing or say a word. After that came the period of contingencies. Roosevelt would not. lift his hand, but, of course, if the unit- ed voice of a mighty people summoned him as the.“one man in sight,” he could But presently even those anything of the not refuse. developed, Republican hopes may visi- bly turn to ashes—but what does this matter to the man who is so eaten up of selfishness and conceit that he thinks of all men and of all parties as only tools in his hand, to be used as long as | feared, Mr. professed hesitations and scruples were | abandoned: the Columbus address was an open bid tor the Presidency; ana now comes his acceptance of the firs. convenient and then thrown on the junk heap? ‘ The heaviest part of the responsibility which Mr. Roosevelt undertakes goes, however, beyond persons or parties. It touches the good of the country. At the moment when success was about to re- ward the painful striving of finance and industry to recover from the heavy blows they have suffered, when business 1aen were reporting the disturbance of Presidential year to be less than was Roosevelt invites us to plunge into a vast upheaval. He would call upon all the winds of social passion to blow and crack their cheeks. He would give us a series of explosions, and would precipitate a contest that would shake the land. If he has his way, in- stead of slow recuperation we shall have a period of fear and ferocity, of un- scrupulous appeal and incendiary tac- tics. But it is not to be believed that he is going to have his way. Even if he terrorizes or tricks the Republican Con- vention into nominating him, or if he sets himself up as the independent can- didate of all the discontented, he has the sober sense of the mass of his coun- trymen to reckon with, and upon that he cannot again impose. For it is no more the Roosevelt of old going forth in formal proposal that he be a candidate shining armor to overthrow his oppo- for the nomination—an acceptance tan- nents. He is known better now; troops tamount to a frank avowal that he of friends are walking backward from wants the Presidency consumedly and| him with averted gaze; his reckless will move heaven and earth to get It.| craving for power is at last disclosed. What a light all this throws upon the | What was said of Charles Fox, after he long and despicable intrigue in which | had made a betrayal of his friends and this frankest and most generous of men has for months been up to his neck! Another aspect of the heavy responsi- bility which Mr. Roosevelt light-heart- edly assumes is that of splitting asunder the party which has showered honors upon him and to which he has professed gratitude and devotion. To dash it to pieces now Ie but a trifle for his insati- ate ambition. He has delayed so long in coming out from his cover that a fierce contest within the party is to-day inevitable. In the struggle the organiza tion may be crumpled into a heap, the his party, may now be said of Theo- dore Roosevelt: “He felt that he had done something that required defence; the mouth still spoke great things, but the swell of soul was no more.” THE PRESIDENT ON POST-OFFICE QUESTIONS, Besides the seeond-class postage rate question, the President, in his message on post-office matters, comments on sev- eral other topics.of importance. Natur- ally enough, he gives a. conspicuous place to the fact that for the fiscal year

Page 9

Feb. 29, 1912] The Nation which ended on June 30 last the ac-| counts of the Post Office Department show a slight surplus—$219,000—com- pared with a deficit of more than $17,- 000,000 two years before. He is careful to state that this financial gain has been accomplished without curtailing the ser- vice, and indeed in the face of a consid- erable enlargement both of postal facili- ties and of salaries; moreover, there has been an increase of more than 8,000 in the number of employees. Of course, these things could not have been simul- taneously possible without a combina- tion of improved management and ex- panded revenue. As a matter of fact, the revenues increased by $8,000,000 in the last year, and by $13,000,000 in the last but one; but this is less than the usual biennial increase, and according- ly it seems fair to set down the bettered financial showing, in the main, to im- provements in administration. From the Postmaster-General’s recom- mendation that the Government shall ac- quire the telegraph system of the coun- try and operate it as part of its postal business, the President flatly dissents. The reasons he assigns for this conclu- sion will, we make no doubt, command general approval. Unless a perfectly clear case can be made out of great pub- lic advantage, it is evident that such a change is not entitled to serious consid- eration as a practical proposal. So far from thinking that such a case has been made out, the President is “not satisfied from any evidence that if these prop- erties were taken over by the Govern- ment they could be managed any more economically or any more efficiently, or that this would enable the Government to furnish service at any smaller rate than the public are now required to pay by private companies.” After this, it is not necessary for the President at this time to dwell on the seriousness of enlarging by hundreds of thousands the army of Government employees, though he makes it plain enough that this con- sideration weighs heavily with him. But he points out another consideration | which constitutes a special reason for not entering upon this undertaking, over and above the general presumption against it; namely, that the Department has now on its hands, and very far) from solution, a problem with which it is clearly called upon to deal before any new complication is added. In the | matter of a parcels post, we are far be- hind other countries, nor is this con- venience satisfactorily furnished by any private agency. In his recommendation as to rates for second-class matter, the President simply follows the report of the special Commission, consisting of Supreme Court Justice Hughes, President Lowell of Harvard, and Mr. H. A. Wheeler, president of the Chicago Association of Commerce. So far as regards the mat- ters of fact involved, there is no room for doubting the substantial accuracy of the results reached by the Commission, for the methods pursued are set forth with exemplary completeness and lucid- Its plan that the ity in its reports. general rate for magazines and news- papers mailed by publishers and news agents should be increased from one cent a pound to two cents is adopted by the President as his own recommenda- tion to Congress. This plan, the Com- mission explicitly states, is not based on any consideration of an existing deficit, but on the desire to bring the charges for this service nearly into correspondence with The basis of calculation is that, in estimat- more cost. ing cost, each part of the service must be charged with its proportionate share and not as a merely residual factor. On such a basis the cost directly assignable to the handling of pound-rate matter, exclusive of general post-office expenses, has recently been more than six cents a pound, and will in the future be in ex- cess of five cents a pound. Whether the public objects served by encouraging the dissemination of this matter war- rants a subvention so great as this is a question of public policy which Congress must settle; the Commis- sion and the President emphatically hold that a two-cent rate would meet) all reasonable requirements of the case; and it is hardly fitting that organs of public opinion, which have a direct pe- cuniary interest in the question, should press a contrary view. The facts relat- ing to cost are now before the country in an authoritative form. The whole matter affords an instruc- ‘tive illustration of the problems involv- ed in governmental ratefixing. The ascertainment of facts is necessarily only one part of the question; the ques- tion of policy still remains, and there is no way of getting rid of it. Indeed, the question of policy may be said to enter, and in a highly important way, even into. 208 that part of the task which relates ex- clusively to the ascertainment of facts; in this instance, for example, the result would have been materially different if an estimate had been made not of the of ond-class matter, but of what may be proportionate cost handling sec- called the residual cost—the amount added to the cost to which the Govern- ment would be put if this matter were not carried at all. But, waiving this, and accepting the estimate of cost as conclusive, there are still any number of questions of policy. Shall newspa- h miles, pay the same rate as magazines ? $Shall wit their average haul of 255 pers, with an average of 707 mile 8 there be a zone system? What attitude should be taken with regard to the com petition of private transportation agen- cies? All this apart from the three principal questions—how far shall the rate be fixed with a view to making the second-class service self-supporting, to what extent should consideration for established interests be taken into ac- count, and what weight should be giv- en to the public benefit derived from en- couragement of journalistic activities? The rate recommended by the Commis- sion is necessarily in the nature of a compromise; whether it is the best or not is, after all, a question for individ. ual judgment. And what is true of this simple question would be true of the myriads of questions that would arise in the administration of a Government railway system. Those who lightly ad vocate the assumption of such a task by the Government forget that in this country transportation questions play a part incomparably more vital than In any other country in the world. NEW IDEAS IN TRUST LEGISLA- TION. Several incidents of the past few |\days indicate a somewhat new turn in the controversy over control of combina- tions in restraint of trade. ence of the promoters of the so-called “Money Trust inquiry” has itself been pretty The ing defeat, in the House Democratic caucus of three weeks ago, of the pro posal for a special committee with in- structions which should take the re- sults of its inquiry for granted, and whose avowed purpose should be that cf spectacular agitation, was one indi- cation of the feeling of sober legisia- The expert- significant. overwhelm-

Page 10

QO d to misunderstand the le wood resoiution t t iu Phe igitator eously with tl move in the lon Trust” investigation, the Senate take in hand the d od question of supple rislation in restriction of in duastria Truata and monopolies Last eek Chairman Gary of the Steel Cor poraticn, who has been Insistent, ever since his Stanley Committee testimony of last June, for legislation empower ing Government to fix prices, forwarded to Washington a proposed measure to Nation ‘The that purpose Judge Gary proposed a | Vol. 94, No. 2435 that law have alleged must arise in for- commission of three to regulate inter- midable shape if the great combinations state trade conditions. A corporation engaged in such trade, with $10,000,000 capital or more, must have a Federal license, revocable if it undertook mo nopoly or restraint of trade. If it al ready controlled more than 50 per cent. s line it should not pusiness in | ve allowed to buy up any competing plant until the three commissioners had would not Finally, the decided that such purchase tend to restraint of trade. commissioners “may fix the maximum involved in such ices of any products an operation if, in the judgment of ission, the fixing of such prices shall be necessary to prevent a monop- oly or an undue restraint of trade or pith of this proposal is plainly in last-mentioned clause. That scheme ol overnmental price-fixing is some- thing of a retreat from Judge Gary's program! of last June, when he de- i Ltot Stanley Committee that he ild like to have some governmental zen where the Steel Corporation could go and say: “Here are our facts and figures, here is our property, here oul ost of production; now you tell us he to do and what pric e have the right to charge.” But the entering wedge of an extremely dan- gerons policy, pointing towards eventual State Socialism, is none the less in- and this fact is clearly recog- d in the bill introduced on Monday by Senator Cummins from the Senate Committee. Mr. Commerce Interstate proposes a commission of th power, not of licensing cor- orations, but of supervising them, He expressly leaves the present Anti-Trust law unchanged, but provides in addi- tion against the common ownership of transportation industrial plants and systems, against “community-of-inter- t'' directors, against watered stock, and, especially, against the “practice of selling below actual cost so as to destroy a competitor.” Corporations found to have been indulging in such a practice, or which sell to different customers at different prices, are to be excluded from the fleld of interstate commerce. Of Senator Cummins’s measure we | | are to be dissolved. There has been of iate something less of the confident as- sertion that “the competitive régime is lead,” but in shifting their position the advocates of dominating combina- tions rest on the assertion that return to what they describe as the “old-time cut- throat competition” would utterly dis- organize business. That some sort of protection against such a situation may be desirable, President Taft himself has admitted. For ourselves, we can see that the problem might be made more formidable from the mere fact that such enormous aggregations of capital are commanded by the present Trusts, and might be commanded by their compo- nent parts even after dissolution. EFFICIENCY IN PUBLIC SERVICE There is coming from the Chicago Bureau of Public Efficiency a series of reports upon the administration of the various offices of the city and county. These reports are of a detailed and practical character, and at the same time are so simply and clearly arranged and worded as to be easily followed by any intelligent person. With one of these before him, the ordinary citizen has no excuse for not knowing far more about the actual working of the depart- ment to which it relates, and of the di- rection in which improvements therein are needed, than any one except a stu- dent or an expert could have known previously. Here, for instance, is an at- tractively printed pamphlet of twenty- six pages, entitled “Administration of the Office of Sheriff of Cook County, II- linois.”” One's ideas of the natural and proper order of topics in such a report receive a surprise at the first glance at the table of contents, for the “Conclu- sions” are placed at the beginning, and the “Text of Report” at the end. Who, however, could resist a look eat conclu- sions so temptingly laid before him? This result was perhaps in the minds of the sagacious framers of the report, who were but too well aware of the nor- mal attitude of veters towards the ma- chinery of government for which it is their proud privilege to name the engi- shall now only remark that it under-| neers and pay the expenses. takes, without upsetting or emasculat-| A second surprise awaits the reader ing the present Anti-Trust law, to deal |in the opening sentence of the Report. with the problem which opponents of| “The present Sheriff,” it runs, “is de- a oe

Page 11

Feb. 29, 1912] = serving of great credit for introduci a system of reports and records design ed to indicate the character and vol ume of work performed by deputies and bailiffs.” Further on, one learns that “the attitude of Sheriff Zimmer indi cates a desire on his part to secure the efficiency in the ad offic e highest degree of ministration of his compatibl with existing political conditions. H: has shown much more zeal for publi service than any of his predecessors in years.” Evidently Public Effici that office for many the Chicago Bureau of ncy is anything but an organization for ritating the gentlemen whose offices it investigates. After such words of praise, qualified as they are “existing political conditions, an if imagine Sheriff Zimmer refusing to cor sider seriously any suggestion t Bu reau may offer for rendering his adminis tration worthy of more generous comp! ment? Nor does the Bureau allo ts tact to restrain it from criticism Phe Sheriff, it appears, owing to an incre: in the number of judges by six, is for ten additional bailiffs But the reau has made an analysis of the ser vice record installed by this efficiency loving officer, and finds from them that the work required of the bailiffs outside inconsiderable for It rect of the court-room is the number performing it. mends, therefore, the retaining of the bailiffs at the present number. And now the Bureau shows the of which it is made. The section dea ing th this matter of the bailiffs headed Recommended Decreases in Stafi. liere are the paragraphs in vhich the bold ecommendations are set forth rhe tual time reported ] I lusive of time inne ssal ir h ffi indicates that t or} hay n performed, and all ds l bee ! ided for, with four fewer deput decreased by that number rhe necessity for an assistant sheriff addition to a _ chief deputy sheriff is not apparent, particularly as the issistan sheriff generally unfamiliar with is one and that details of administration procedure is recommended, therefore this posi tion be abolished One important feature of the read ableness of this report is the brevity of its sections. Like a newspaper story in which we may not be especially in- terested, its successive paragraphs lure us on by the very rapidity with which they may be dispatched. The section by the reference to The Nation following the one we have ist been treating is entitled “Salary Reductions Recommended Ni ft $ thing Mmuiated ft i i t ana still more, the atte! f the ixpa ‘ t such 0 thes r} port does not was or tl id ~ D ence oO I na es the pil oO IS u y spl hat dep and ba ills ept the personal i il oO dg twenty-five in 1 overpaid And it pre ! >] t tha police ‘ i i im sala of $1.200 ea lave | tant duties to perf lep ‘ lls 0 ect t 2,0 It is difficult to ! I of Chicago or Cook ( TF d ing of the ght of frat I iil to be deep! nterested i h a report as his It method dispost completely of e objection tl ol cant! nd wv going on bet 6! nd off = ond ord Lite tions. Here are t dow! pla iN and white, specif reco! ‘ based upon careful ana i equally plain statement of t ol behind them. It is cl at ea ing to tolerate wit ner neg mp tience and protest th n slip shod management f mui ffa t} t ha g en 17 Old Worl Mir l ! I S regret that i tio ould ha I ( ved But t sordid first ft fight ad t f I alk ( effi en¢ i ] I the « tail vould i n a Du n ¢ i! | I el phen t ( ‘ , it bus P i I I tel ‘ il i ie f I at n effi I as but ‘ tly i Ké d to t! ( ~) es n tt a f t I | can hard be denied that, for once at least, public iiministration has been quick » respond to t new spirit that as manifesting tself n private af fair iND MORALS LAND LITERATURE IN ENG The conflict between the tritish censorship and the advanced element among British writers and playwrights has been increasingly animated and con- fusing. The word censorship is here used in its broad, non-technical mean- £ As ye I £ t il W : a I \ ' ) a [ mportat ‘ por ‘ th ‘ perhaps, tl ; i \ ou ‘ ond aot eat i i | ‘ ai » \\ \\ ‘ ‘ ! ane i | | ' i id | ( a \ | j ' ) ' i ne 1 « Cens i ty tr (yy 1) lode I i t! t bee! ? i | or de a ol j ( eta t I i l ipa ine \ f OT | ‘ kL principa poke I Wa St. La t Spe fat ) thie | Spectate ha een forer ti ingg the litra-realist ! temporary fiction as exemplified in Hf. G Wells’s “Ann Veronica,” against hich Mr. Strachey carried on a vigorous po lem He has also come to blow th the editors of the English Review, a publication of good literary standing and radical views, which is in the habit of describing itself as “the Great Aduit Re- view,” Mr. Strachey recently declared

Page 12

2O6 the Great Adult Review to be unfit for circulation among respectable people and ejected its advertisements from the columns of the Spectator. He immedi- ately became a literary storm centre. Therefore, when the editor of the Spec- tator appears as the head of a deputa- tion to speak on the subject of demoral- izing literature, the idea that first leaps to the mind is that here is at least a clear joining of issues between the new realism and the advocates of that older standard of reticence in the written word which is usually described as Mid- Victorian. But it is not with literature in a real sense that this particular deputation concerned itself. Mr. Strachey and his associates dealt entirely with that class of gutter print which the law desig- nates as obscene and which falls under the jurisdiction of the police in every civilized country. It seems to be agreed that the English laws against the pro- duction and distribution of filth of this kind are regrettably indulgent and in- complete, and the Home Secretary, in his reply, promised that the Govern. ment would take up and deal energet- ically with the problem. Now it would be an insult to the entire generation of English readers even to bring the names of men like Wells, Phillpotts, or Gran- ville Barker in connection with so dis- gusting a subject; and, of course, no such attempt was made. But it was unfortunate that this deputation against “demoralizing” literature should come at a time when conservative opinion is busy attacking the “demoralizing” lit- erature of the Wells, Barker, and Shaw type. It was also unfortunate that the leader of the deputation should be a man who has been in the forefront of the assault on the modern school of British fiction and drama. Thus if the unthinking public lumps together as “demoralizing” the work of the most skilful men in England and the products of the sewer, it is to a very appreciable extent the fault of much loose arguing on the subject by men who should know better. In the Hibbert | Journal, writing on the subject of “per-) nicious literature,” Canon Rawnsley is guilty of sad lack of discrifnination. | From the grossly indecent photograph | or broadside he passes on to the mov- ing-picture shows and so to the “nasty novelists”: Women in this field of licefise vie with’ ‘erature that properly falls under cen- ‘sorship. They do not circulate by the Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2435 ‘The men in writing seductively and realisti- | cally, but with no serious purpose, what! they are pleased to call the sex problem. | These novels, some of them, the publishers tell us, have gone through a million copies. They glorify lust; they preach free love; they mock at marriage as a relic of bar- barism, and appeal to pure animal pas- sion and appetite. Here is an unmistakable slant at the Wells novel amidst a rush of accusation that it would be outrageously unjust to bring into connection with Mr. Wells’s art or his motives. It is a case of mix- ing up two widely different things in such a reckless way as to give the radi- cals ground for fearing that the two things are really the same in the eyes of these men, and that the present move against obscene publications may be in- tended as an entering wedge for a cru- sade against the new realism in litera- ture. The present outlook is that it will be some time before the subject of realism in art and literature will be freed from the confusion injected into the problem by bringing forward the question of the defence of public morals by the police. The issue will then be brought back to its original form: whether the present state of English literature demands the exercise of some form of censorship, either by a regularly constituted author- ity, or as has been suggested, by an agreement among the circulating li- braries. The history of the English nov- el since its beginning weighs heavily against any formal censorship. It has in every age been the reflex of the pre- vailing tone of social life, rough and outspoken with Fielding and Smollet, | sentimental and outspoken with Rich- ardson, clean-lipped and sentimental with the Victorians. The danger of a censorship is that it intensifies the spirit of opposition and drives the recu- sant to extremes. The radical novels may have pernicious tendencies, but their evil, if evil there be, is different in kind from that of the pornographic lit- million, They address themselves to people of intelligence, and in the long run intelligent public opinion may be trusted to deal with the standards and motives of literary men. FRENCH BOOK NOTES. Paris, February 14. Emile Faguet’s “Vie de Rousseau” (Société Francaise d‘Imprimerie; 418 pages) came out a year before the bi- centenary of its subject’s birth (June 28, 1712). Jean-Jacques Rousseau, in life and in death, excites the same perennial flames of controversy. For the general reader, for the beginning student, this life is perhaps the best yet written, the most likely to set him afloat along a true course. Emile Fa- guet is the full man whom reading mak- eth, according to Bacon; but he is also the professor of the great Ecole Nor- male where the clash of alert, youthful minds will not allow of too much inex- actness. Besides his seat in the French Academy, he has some forty critical works to his credit, in literary history or literary politics. Not his least fit- ness for his present task comes from his studies in nineteenth-century ‘isms. His standpoint, clearly and deliberate- ly chosen, is that of French Liberalism, and is nearly akin to the traditional thought which alone has a right to the name of Americanism, as in Channing, who, in a way, was a by-product of Rousseau. With all this, Emile Faguet has an easy-going style, and says what he has to say quite fully. This means that his Rousseau is less precious as lit- erature than the Conférences of Jules Lemaitre, which set all these Rousseau controversies blazing. In twenty-five chapters, the book pro ceeds by little groups of years through Rousseau’s troubled life and still more troubled association with the lives of men and women around him; and a twenty-sixth sums up the life in itself. For, although the author is a critic of |political philosophy and influences in nistory, he has kept here to the life of the man Rousseau: Rousseau, as he said himself a thousand times, was born good, in this sense, that he was born tender-hearted, generous, charitable—in a word, an altruist. But he was also born without any moral sense, and his education, which was null, or rather very bad, gave him none. I understand by lack of moral sense the absence of all rule of conduct and of the need of having one. Never did Rousseau have such a need. He felt that he was good, which was true, and he concluded frem it that whatever he did could not but be excellent. This is pre- cisely the state of soul of most men, but with most men it is mixed, and with Jean- Jacques it was absolute. ... He has no moral sense, but little by little, as he frequents society that is somewhat better, he perceives it, seeks to deaden the thought by sophisms, at bottom suffers horribly from it—and this gives him a direction along two new ways: on the one side, to believe that, being born good, he has been depraved by society, which is half true, and to conclude from it that society is abominable, in which there is some truth also; on the other side, to believe himself obliged to repair his faults by the cult of Ly

Page 13

Feb. 29, 1912] virtue and the preaching of virtue. He said of Voltaire something which was very false when applied to Voltaire and was precisely very true, without his ever suspecting it, when applied to Rousseau: “His first impulses are good; but reflec- tion makes him perverse (méchent).” Voltaire and Rousseau made the eigh- teenth century their own and a great part of the nineteenth, until the reac- tion came and spent itself, when they resumed their sway for the twentieth: Je suis tombé par terre, C’est la faute A Voltaire; Le nez dans le ruisseau, C’est la faute a Rousseau. There are some new side-books to help us understand this wonderful eigh- teenth century. “Les Hommes de lettres au XVIIIe siécle” (A. Colin; 310 pages —3.50 francs), by Maurice Pellisson, is one of these. It is really a history of the emancipation of the literary man who, Carlyle said, is the priest of these latter days. From the documents of the time—many of them unpublished, from the Anisson Duperron collection— the author shows the relations of the men of letters with the law, Govern- ment, publishers, play-actors; in pri- vate life; among themselves (genus de- testabile, as poor Rousseau knew to his cost, but already fraternizing in their own cafés and, under Madame Necker’s guidance, beginning to erect statues to one another); with the world of the court and of the town; with public opin- ion; and (already) with journalists. There are twenty-six pages of docu- ments in an appendix—and ten entire pages of double-columned index of names of men of letters cited in the course of this valuable book for the history of literature. “Les Sciences de la Nature en France, au XVIIIe siécle” (A. Colin; 300 pages —3.50 francs), by D. Mornet, is, ac- cording to its author, “a chapter of the history of ideas.” It really centres in Buffon, who was to his century some thing like Darwin to the next. The book is systematic, erudite. In a first part, it shows the dépuration of science or “natural history” before Buffon, in the struggle against the marvellous and against theology; in a second part, the organization of science in systems, the Buffon quarrel, and the organizing of experiment; in a third part, the diffu- sion of science in the triumph of nat- ural history, its art of pleasing, and the consequences. ‘There are twenty pages of valuable bibliography and fourteen of text-references. Dr. Mornet, doctor of letters and university professor, has written before of nature-sentiment. In France, from Rousseau to Bernardin de Saint-Pierre, “Les Moeurs et la Vie privée d’autre- fois’ (Calmann-Lévy: 390 pages—3.50 francs), by Humbert de Gallier, is a first portion of alert, capable studies of private life and habits of living under | The Nation | the old régime; and, naturally, it looks closely into the eighteenth century. The present buok begins with “how they spent their money’’—gentiemen’s houses in town and country, and peasants’ houses, their size, furniture, rent, com- fort, and luxury; clothing, monsieur spending more than madame, and Queen Marie Antoinette in muslin and linen gowns (unavailing Rousseauism); and then hunting and gambling and mis- tresses and debts. “How they married” is explained among bourgeois (the mid- dle classes), the people, and the nobles. They married more then than now; and, because the family was every- thing and the individual little, mar- riage was at once more serious and more businesslike, with love, if it came at all, following rather than preceding; but marriage presents and ceremonies were ample. “How they were served”— the treatment of the servants and how these treated their masters, those who were of the fdmily and those who were only lackeys—leads the author to the conclusion that “the lot of domestics was better then than now.” “How they took care of themselves,” with all their healers and swift epidemics and still more sudden remedies, points to a con- trary conclusion, in spite of every man being his own doctor nowadays with an abundance of patented medicines. This book also has a laudabie index of names cited, eighteen double-column pages. “Trois Drames de Ilhistoire de Rus- sie” (A. Colin: 300 pages—3.50 francs), by the late Vicomte de Vogiié, gathers into one small volume three dramatic studies in Russian history, with its out- landish development of the eighteenth century. The tragedy of Peter the Great’s son, Mazeppa in legend and his- tory, and the lightning change of régime at the death of the great Cath- erine of the philosophers, are good sam- ples of the literature of a writer who introduced the Russian soul to Young France, whose pen was dipped in Cha- teaubriand’s inkstand, and whose own lofty soul was long supposed to have diffused the new spirit among his coun- trymen. It is not sure that his words are yet dead. How Germany rebounded from eligh- teenth-century philosophy and doctrin- aires is shown in “La Littérature patri- otique en Allemagne—1800-1815” (A. Colin: 310 pages—3.50 francs), by G. Gromaire. It begins with the literary patriotism which wa; the legacy of the eighteenth century, and follows the course of romanticism until the fatal date of Jena. Then, year by year, the author portrays the consequences of that shock—Austria and the campaign of 1808; the revival of Prussia from 1810 to 1812; Arndt, who merits a whole chapter; the romantics now at their full; a whole chapter again to Korner; and then, from 1813, the secon- dary poets and people’s songs. With 207 1815 the book stops, not because the patriotic movement of German minds ceased, for, on the contrary, it only then began sweeping the whole people within its train until the nation came into existence. But in 1815, “with the disappearance of Napoleon, the situa- tion of Europe changes.” The last verses of the book are from Ditfurth's elegy to the parting conqueror, for even after Jena Germans were found to rec- ognize that it was Napoleon who had brought the Fatherland to a conscious- ness of self. “It is the beginning of the Bonapartist legend which has spread throughout Europe—not excepting Ger. many.” It was Goethe's Epimenides Waking; and the French writer has the perspective needed to narrate it. Ss. D. ( orrespondence WEEMS. TO THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Str: There is so little accurate Infor- mation about Mason Locke Weems, the first to print the story of Washington and the cherry tree, that a summary of the facts which the writer and a few other persons interested in the matter have un- earthed in the past few years may be welcome in your columns. The date of Weems’s birth, as shown by family records in the absence of any entry in the parish register, is October 1, 1759 The place was the family estate of Marshes Seat on Herring Bay, Anne Arundel Coun- ty, Maryland. The next established date about him is his arrival in Nantes in 1782, as shown by a letter to Franklin asking for passports for England. In 1784 Frank- lin’s correspondence and John Adams's show that Weems tried to procure ordina- tion without taking the oath of allegiance to the British Crown. Finally an act of Parliament (24 George III, cap. 35) al- lowed him to do this, and he was ordained a deacon on September 5, 1784, by the Bishop of Chester, and on September 12, 1784, a priest by the Archbishop of Can- terbury. These incidents and Weems’s subsequent experiences as a rector in Maryland from 1784 to 1794 have been wel] set forth ino “Parson Weems” (Baltimore, 1911), by I. C. Wroth, to whom credit is due for dis- covering the dates of the ordination and for gathering considerable material from the manuscript diary of William Duke and the Allen manuscript, both in the Maryland Diocesan Library. These show that Weems early began Lis work of selling books, even before his marriage to Fanny Ewell on July 2, 1795, at Belle Air, near Dumfries, Virginia, which place became from that time his home. For the period from 1796 to 1802 Weems was chiefly employed by Matthew Carey, and continued to be more or less so for many years, as is shown by the letters pre- served by Carey's successors, Lea & Fe- biger. From 1802 to 1808 he also did much work for Caleb Wayne, who employed him to push the sale of Marshall’s “Life of Washington.” Much of this correspondence

Page 14

208 is preserved in the Dreer collection of man- uscripts in the Pennsylvania Historical So- \ soon as Washington died Weems brought out a small pamphlet on Washing te and added material as it came to him, until in the fifth edition, published in 1806 in Augusta, Georgia, he inserted the anec- lot of the cherry tree, the seeds, and t! rest of Washington’s youth. Only one of this edition has been known of late year and that, though in the pos sion of Pau! L death, seems now to have disappeared eicester Ford before his There is no direct evidence in favor of the authenticity of these anecdot« Weems leed knew any intimate friends of \ hington, but that he should have, as ! says, kept the stories secret for twenty j incredible \ better explanation } come to! from a grandson of Weems had it from his father. It is that the thing was suggested by a similar irrence to Weems's eldest son, who was born in 1799 He cut down a Pride of ( na and confessed, but, sad to say, ac- ling to my informer, he received not ! nes, but a sound thrashing. The seed is certainly from James Beattie’s yuunt of the youth of his son, James H Beattl Weems never regarded him eriously as an historian, but as a t r of moral and knew that dialogue lot wel unsurpassed in driving he i il I 1inder of Weems’s material about \\ } ‘ is derived from popular tra- the South (especially in the vi Mount Vernon, where he frequent- " ed the pulpit of Pohick Church, ‘ hown by letters and by Davis's | of Four Years and a Half,”) or fr \ known accounts, particularly the Annual Register and its plagiarists, Gor de and Ramsay The rest of his time he spent selling books throughout the Stats from New York to Georgia, and he died in Beaufort, 8. C Ma 1s He was first buried in Beau fort St. Helena Churchyard, but later ' i to wl Ewell burial ground at bh \ir, as was ascertained some years ! Vr. G. ¢ Round, the present own- er of the property, from interviews with ‘ me in the neighborhood His grave " he jutheast corner of the burial ground i) wt irked. though its occupant can ! called the creator of the current tion of Washington, and the author of t best-known hero tale in American history Wa en B. NORRIS 1 i ‘ Nava 4 ‘ Annapolis Feb COLLEGE ENGLISH I ie Eprror or Tuk NATION ! May I be permitted through your mone to add one more suggestion to the mans of which illewe teachers of freshman composition are now almost buried? Most of the dis- has clearly depended upon the defi- variegated counsel under ission nition of the purposes of such a compulsory course in writing No one can deny that daily themes do not create authors; but the Conservatives have replied to the Pro- gressive—not to say Radical—Professor Lounsbury that nobody is trying to turn Compylsory com- freshmen into authors The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2435 position is supposed to train students in the correct and accurate use of the English language. This sounds well, but the proof of the pudding is in the eating: and it is the almost universal testimony of college teachers that college seniors are in the vast majority of cases illiterate A #8e@- nior who had passed creditably in pre- scribed composition once met my criticism that a thesis of his was devoid of punctua- tion with the naive statement that he had not had time to put in the commas, and did not think it mattered much If pre- scribed work in composition can neither foster talent nor create competence, it cer- tainly has little ground upon which to plead immunity from criticism. But let us consider the problem which the teacher of college English has to face. His freshman students for the most part cannot spell Their notions of grammar are often either non-existent or hideously warped Their vocabularies are infinitesi- al, and, which is worse, their use of the few words that they dare employ without blushing is so loose as to defy definition. In preparation for college *note the irony of the phrase—they have written a few perfectly meaningless little essays on “Dr. Johnson and his Club” or “Was Hamlet Mad?” Thus the whole business of writing English has become, not a matter of ac- curate self-expression, but a frankly arti- ficial exercise of ingenuity, without method or purpose. All this the college teacher must fight against, and yet, out of respect for academic traditions, and also in con- sideration of the saving remnant to whom the English language has not become a snare and a delusion, he must make his work “advanced.” He cannot line up his class and institute a spelling-bee; he can- not take as a text-book a primer of gram- mar. In other words, he must try to recon- cile two irreconcilable elements. A Ger- man teacher who had his classes read “Faust” the day after they mastered Der- die-das would justly be condemned; yet it is with an equivalent amount of straw that the college teacher of prescribed composi- tion is expected, in the absurdly brief space of a year, to produce presentable bricks. It is not surprising that, as a general thing, he fails No reformation of college work in writing can hope to alter materially these con- ditions. The change must come first of all in the schools; for though a college stu- dent may be in dire need of a primer, he is beyond the stage when he is likely to profit by it. When the schools can supply more spelling than grammar, even if Dr. Johnson and “Hamlet” suffer thereby, which it has yet to be shown that they will, the college can shape its work to the require- ments of students who are fitted to pursue it HENRY ADAMS BELLOWS. University of Minnesota, February 21 4 BAVARIAN SCHOOL OF HOUSEKEEP- ING, To THe EpiTtor or THe NATION: Sin: As the train pulls into the little station of Miesbach, Bavaria, one of the interesting sights that strikes a stranger is the large red brick building standing on a high slope some distance away, and sur- rounded by trees and hedges which give it the appearance of a stately baronial estate lit is that of the famous School of House- keeping, which graduates yearly some fifty pupils or more. The inside of this sub- stantial-looking house shows its proximity to Munich, for the simple ornamentation, the tastful coloring, and the comfortable furniture bespeak its nearness to the great art centre of Germany. The school is fitted up in the most approved and modern fashion as to heat, light, electricity, etc. The large dining-room, with its soft tints of blue and white, its numerous small tables, covered with spotless linen and the prettiest of silver and glass, looks more like the dining-room of a well-kept hotel than of a school The kitchens are spacious, immaculate in their white tiling, and fitted up with every possible convenience The preserve-rooms fairly glisten with jars of strawberries, pears, plums, grape-jam, marmalade, as- paragus, beans, peas, tomatoes, sweet and sour pickles, etc., all grown and put up by the pupils of the school. There is a practical and a _ theoretical course, both of which are obligatory. The practical course includes: (1) cooking, bak- ing, and preserving; (2) washing and iron- ing; (3) housework, viz., bedmaking, sweep- ing, dusting, knowledge of the care of hard- wood floors, and of blanket cleaning and summer storing; (4) flower, vegetable, and fruit growing; (5) poultry and bee-keeping; (6) sewing, dressmaking, mending, and re- pairing. The theoretical course comprises an advanced course in botany, chemistry, physics, political economy, and household- bookkeeping. The science of nourishment is also taught, as is a proper knowledge of the different cuts of meat, their average cost and weight, etc.; also “first aid to the injured” and how to prescribe for the sim- pler ailments in the ordinary household, and lastly the elementary methods of caring for the health and character of children The outdoor life presents equally whole- some and desirable surroundings. Here all kinds of vegetables, flowers, and fruits are grown, tended in the most scientific fashion by the pupils of the school. Lettuce and cauliflower, for instance, are grown under the large glass bells found so useful in the sewage market gardens about Paris, and the poultry, ducks, and geese are looked after with the utmost care and knowledge, the large result of which is a commendable sup- ply of fresh eggs and marketable birds every week. The girls take turns each week in at- tending to the various household duties; a certain number taking charge of the kitchen, planning all the meals, buying and paying for all the food, and preparing and cooking it for the whole school. Another set of pupils do all the sweeping and dusting, all the silver and brass polishing, take note of the condition of the floors, and see that fresh flowers are put in their accustomed |places, Others, in turn, attend to the bees ‘and poultry, and still others do the garden- jing. The instruction in sewing, mending, | dressmaking, millinery, and embroidery is | rich in results, and teaches method and ithrift in buying clothes, and care in keep- | ing them neat. Every detail of the daily housekeeping is thought out to a nicety, and as few maids are kept in the school, the pupils are made responsible for the proper and efficient care of the entire household. The indoor life prepares pretty solidly for pia ene lot Higa pare Dac

Page 15

i ie a Os a Feb. 29, 1912] the subsequent mother. It is safe to say that when these girls have their own establishments to man- age, there will be neither culpable negli- gence nor ignorance MARY PARKINSON Munich, Germany, February 15 THE DEATH OF LYDGATE To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sin: John Metham’'s romance of “Amory 1»; and Cleopes,” soon to be published by the Early English Text Society closer limits for the death of the monk, John Lydgate. Writing, as he tells us in his “Envoy” in 27 Henry VI (1 Sept., 1448-31 Aug., 1449), Metham regrets that Chaucer and Lydgate are both dead. As the Pipe gives us Rolls give the record of the payment to Lydgate of his pension up to Easter, 1449 the date of his death should seem to be fixed between Easter and September 1, 1449, Metham lived at Norwich, and had been a scholar at Cambridge. As a resident of East Anglia, he is entitled to full credence on such a matter as the death of the monk His references to the monk’s work show that he was acquainied with the very latest production of Lydgate’s pen. So far as I know, Metham’s evidence has passed unnoticed in print. The recent ar- ticle on Lydgate, in the Encyclopedia Brit- annica, quotes Metham’s opinion of Lyd- gate’s writing, but follows the Dictionary of National Biography in retaining 1451 as the date of the death of the Monk of Bury. m. N. New Haven, Conn., February 23. MACCRACKEN. DIPLOMATIC SERVICE EXAMINATIONS TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The pamphlet of instruction issued by the Department of State, entitled “Infor- mation Regarding Appointments and Pro- motions in the Diplomatic Service of the United States,” provides that “the object of the oral examination shall also be to determine the candidate’s general alert- ness, general contemporary information, and natural fitness for the service, includ- ing mental, moral, and physical qualifica- tions, character, address, general education, and good command of English.” But the candidate is carefully asked if he is rich, or whether he depends upon his earnings for his living expenses. The Secretary of State recently, at a meeting held in New York, stated that it was impossible for the De- partment to recommend for appointment in the Diplomatic Service any but rich men It would therefore seem that “general fit- ness for the service” included, among other qualifications, a private fortune Does it also include political influence? Civil ser- vice examinations are supposed to be con- ducted on an impartial basis and to show no favor. Perhaps, however, the backing of a strong Senator or two may be included under “moral fitness.” Again, the pamphlet mentioned above pro- vides: “The names of candidates will re- main on the eligible list for two years, ex- cept in case of such candidates as shall within that period be appointed or shall withdraw their names.” But if a candidate fails to qualify in the oral examination— that of “general fitness’—he is informed by duties of housewife and the Department that “under the rule” he is not eligible to further designation or examination, and that he might as well drop out of the running. This in the face of the provisions of the regulations made What and who made it? How does by the President, November 26, 1909 is this rulk it take precedence over the instructions of the President and over the “Information” Department itself? F. W. K issued by the ° Literature ARCTIC VOYAGES. In Northern Mists: Arctic Exploration in Early Times. By Fridtjof Nansen, G.C.V.0., D.Se., D.C.L., Ph.D., Profes- sor of Oceanography in the University of Christiania. Translated by Arthur G. Chater. tispieces in color and over one hun In two volumes, with fron illustrations in black- The Frederick dred and fifty and-white. New York A. Stokes Co. $8 net From J. came the impulse which led Dr. Nansen Scott Keltie, we are told, to the production of the magnum opus Asked to contribute an account of Arctic now before us. voyages to Dr. Kel tie’s series of books on geographical ex- ploration, he accepted the commission and soon found himself involved in a sea of mingled myth, fiction, and his- tory almost as hard to navigate as the dark, curdled outer waters of ancient and mediewval legend. But he has fought his way through, and no less an author- ity than Sir Clements R. Markham, in the Geographical Journal for January, has given him credit for drawing the veil from the mystery of early Arctic history, as he had previously drawn it from the mystery of Arctic geography. Confessedly not a master of the classi- cal languages, he has called Amund Sommerfeldt to his aid in searching out and translating the numerous passages in ancient and mediw#val Greek and Roman authors bearing upon his sub- ject, as he has gone to Prof. Alexander Seippe! for help with his Arab sources, We mention this chiefly as a suggestion to college and university history de- partments which are guilty of encour- aging students to believe that they can fit themselves satisfactorily for “origi- nal research” in history with no broader linguistic equipment than a smattering of two or three modern languages, Dr. Nansen through with a noble enthusiasm. The whole story, he says, is a magnificent illustration of the power of the un- known over the mind of man. “No- where else have we won our way more slowly, nowhere else has every, new step cost so much trouble, so many priva- tions and sufferings, and certainly no- where else have the resulting discover- ies promised fewer material advantages has carried his work 209 and, nevertheless, new forces have al- ways been found to carry the attack farther, to stretch once more the limits of the world.” are given to the ancients. Here Pytheas The first three chapters of Massilia, of course, towers above all others, though distance has unfortunate ly blurred the definite outlines tower, as in the well-known illustration of Lucretius. Little as the ancient grasped the possible meaning of his discoveries, howevel ready son ol their historians were to accept his filtered down to justify Dr. Nansen in pronoun relations as true, enough has ing him “one of the most capable and undaunted explorers the world has seen.”” To break out of the Mediter ranean regions by sea as early as the time of Alexander the Great, and make his way to the Arctic Circle, coasting along northern Gaul and Germany, and by.inging to the then civilized world its earliest first-hand knowledge of Great Britain, the Scottish Isles, Shetland, and Norway, was to set a pace which, all things considered, has not sines been equalled Hut the world of h time could neither mentally appreciats nor physically appropriate his di ies. Dr. Nansen accepts fully the ide tification of the “Thule of Pythea with Norway, specifically combating t objections which Karl Mullenhoff raised against that view a few decades ago Later antiquity and the earlier Mid dle Ages made no real progress in nor ern research, being content merely to “chew the cud of knowledge that had been collected in remote antiquity,” and that mostly at second hand, from tli later Roman authors The first medi w#val contribution of serious import J recounted by the Roman historian Ca siodorus, but has reached us, unfortu nately, only through the Goth Jordan: in his “Origin and Deeds of the Goth The information concerning the North contained in this work Dr. Nansen be lieves to have come largely from the Norwegian King Rodulph and his men, the reality of whose visit to Theodori King of the Goths, there seems to be ne reason to question, The next authority of weight is the Byzantine Procopiu who had ample opportunity to gather first-hand information North from the northern warriors en listed under Belisarius in the armies of concerning the the Eastern Empire. But we have not space to follow Dr. Nansen’s chapters in detail. A point of prime interest to many readers will be his treatment of the much discussed discovery of Amer ica by the Norsemen He holds firmly to the belief that such a discovery was actually made; but after his relentless wiping from the slate of all the well- known lore of “Wineland the Good,” and other legends clinging around the name of Leif Ericson, one wishes that he had given a more definite statement of his positive reasons for accepting the dls-

Page 16

210 ? covery as a fact. The very name “Wine- land” is an accretion of far later date than the supposed discovery, and all the tales of wine and wheat found in such abundance by Leif and his men are traceable to familiar legends of classl- cal antiquity, making their first appear- ance in Norse literature only in the saga of Eric the Red, at the close of the thirteenth century. Readers of “The Discovery of America,” by John Fiske, will remember the high historical stand- ing which he assigned to this saga. “That document contains unmistakable knowledge of some things which medi- #val Europeans could by no human pos- sibility have learned, except through a visit to some part of the coast of North America further south than Labrador or Newfoundland. It tells an eminently probable story in a simple, straightfor- ward way, agreeing in its details with what we know of the North American coast between Point Judith and Cape Breton.” Mr. Fiske made no difficulty of identifying the “self-sown wheat” of the saga as Indian corn, and took this and the mention of the vines as evi- dence that Leif's visit should be located not farther north than Massachusetts Bay. But, of course, he never accepted the alleged discovery of “Norumbega,” Watertown, and his arguments against the theory of any actual settle ment by the Norsemen are keen and un- at answerable. Nansen's view, however, Eric's ‘contains scarcely a single feature that is not wholly or in part mythical or borrowed from elsewhere.” For the wine and the wheat of the saga we are to look not to the fields and forests of Northeastern America, but to ancient legend, gathered up in the pages of Isi- dore of Seviile, whose description of the Fortunate” gradually worked its way into the North and Inevitably connected itself with the mixture of myth and history which lay at the basis of such literature as the saga of Eric the Red. Professor Fiske could not see why the part of Eric’s saga which deals with Greenland should be accepted and the rest discarded: “What shall be said of a style of criticism which, in dealing with one and the same document, cuts it in two in the middle and calls the first half history and the last half leg- end?” (“The Discovery of America,” I, 2123). But Nansen remarks in a foot- note: “The beginning of this saga, deal- ing with the discovery of Greenland by Eric the Red, Ile taken straight out of the Landndmabék, and is thus much older.” But for the logs of historic value Dr. Nansen finds solace in increased admiration for “the extraordinary pow- ers of realistic description in Icelandic In reading Eric's saga one In saga “Insula literature. cannot help being struck by the way in which many of the events are so de scribed, often in a few words, that the whole thing is before pne’s eyes, and it ation [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 The N is difficult to believe that it has not actually occurred.” Professor Fiske took this very quality as a guarantee of the truth of the narrative, which to him read “not in the least like a fairy- tale, but often much like a ship’s log.” But Nansen adds to the words above quoted: “This is just the same quality that characterizes our Norwegian fairy- | tales: all that is supernatural is made so natural and realistic that it is brought straight before one. The Ice- landers created the realistic novel; and at a time when the prose style of Eu- rope was still in its infancy their prose narrative often reaches the summit of clear simplicity.” Dr. Nansen clinches | his extended discussion of the whole} matter with a formidable array of twen- ty-two numbered paragraphs, but it would be rash to predict that “the last word has been said.” In the field of historical argument the ciéture is hard | to apply. Dr. Nansen’s views on the subject were uttered in an address be- fore the Royal Geographical Society, in November, and any who have access to the Geographical Journal (December) will be interested in its account of the discussion which followed, in which the participants were Lord Curzon, Sir Clements Markham, and G. M. Ga- thorne-Hardy, Lord Curzon betraying the strongest signs of reluctance to give up any material part of the story of “Leif the Lucky.” Medieval cartography, Arab geogra- phers, compass-charts, the maps of Claudius Clavus, and fifteenth-century maps are among the various subjects which, along with accounts of actual or alleged voyages of discovery, go to make up a work which it is safe to pre- dict will see no rival in the lifetime of the present generation. CURRENT FICTION. | The Progress of Mrs. Cripps-Middle- | more. By Gerard Bendall. New York: John Lane Co. | A Mr. Hugo Street, reviewer, makes | his casual appearance in these pages, and | leaves behind him at least one memor-| able utterance. His journal, he com-| plains, is “literally inundated” with fic-| tion, and he has been compelled to in- vent a means of relief: “If a book is) slangy, middle-class, vulgar, we call it a little effort in the style of Dickens; | if full of cheap cynicism and matilin | sentiment, a contribution after the man- ner of Thackeray; if the writer appears | to have been to school, and to have a) slight acquaintance with vhe classics, we | say an essay in the well-known style of Thomas Love Peacock.” From this un- expected conjunction of Peacock with | Dickens and Thackeray, and from the) evidence of the present book, we should | say that Mr. Bendall has been accused | of being “Peacockian.” So he is, In a) | sense, and we take this to be a unique distinction in this day. He bears quite as close a relation to Peacock as Mr. De Morgan to Dickens, or Mrs. Watts to Thackeray. Why should not Mr. Hugo Streets be permitted to call at- tention to so interesting a fact? The group of persons who revolve about the bland figure of Mrs. Cripps-Middlemore are as carefully chosen types as the inti- mates of Crochet Castle or Gryll Grange; and there is no doubt as to the lineage 'of the suave, ironical style in which the story is told. The dialogue often amounts to discourse rather than con- versation, and the range of topics touch- ed upon is wide. But in one respect— and this gives the book its peculiar tone —Mr. Bendall seems to derive from an |older master than Peacock, namely, the Reverend Laurence Sterne. “The Phil- anderers” would have been a good title for this story, if it had been available. These persons, young and old, involve themselves in an extraordinary series of amatory situations, with which it is not professed that passion has anything to do, unless as the man about town understands the word. There is a great deal of insinuation and double meaning —a method more provocative than call- ing a spade a spade, and less in accord- ance with the traditions of the English- speaking race. The Heart of Us. By T. R. Sullivan. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. Love-making in Boston, with excur- sions into a rigidly respectable Boston Bohemia of Temple players to temper the decorum of the Back Bay, supplies this tale with its somewhat slender thread of romance. Upon that thread is strung a deal of circumstantial evi- dence to prove the story’s right to a Boston habitat. The evidence includes much talk, seasoned with learning in the shape of quotations from the Latin | Poets, and culture in the guise of allu- sions to more modern classics. There are hints also of a staid and sober phil- osophy such as might ripen in the pre- cincts of the Common and take the air upon Commonwealth Avenue. The hero is a young man of Beacon Street lineage, whose chief claim to the reader's interest is his possession of a soul strong enough to prefer banking to play-writing, in spite of having scor- ed an initial success as translator of a French piece and a subsequent failure with a play of his own devising. This superiority to the weakness of lesser men comes very near losing him the love of an excellent New England young woman with “views.” “And there you have the plot and the story. An elder- ly mentor and another excellent New England young woman of the innermost Brahmin circle assist the development with their several gifts of experience and feminine guile, and the little party

Page 17

Feb. 29, 1912] The Nati OTL of Bohemians assembled around the! leading comedian of the Temple com- pany provide the lovers with a curtain- raiser and a finale to their own drama. There are touches here and there of something which might almost be life, might almost be charm—but just misses the mark. The Believing Years. By Edmund Lester Pearson. New York: The Macmillan Co. These are stories retold, in an alter- ed form, from a series published in the Outlook. They are very real reproduc- tions of the mind and activities of the ordinary small boy. He is not the boy of Kenneth Graham, nor of Robert Louis Stevenson, nor of Mrs. Ewing, but the unvarnished man-child living in a somewhat unvarnished surrounding, having feelings and experiences which pertain less to the castle-building, hero- worshipping child than to our own fa- miliar little Toms, Dicks, and Harrys. The appeal is perhaps less to the lover of universal childhood than to the re- memberer of his own. Any man who has hated arithmetic, has loved fishing, egg-hunting, playing Indian, or has saved his pennies to go to the circus will follow reminiscently the vacation days of Sam and his fellows. Here are photographs of boyhood as it used to be when one was a boy in a New England coast town—a boyhood not unconcerned with knightly adventure, but having also largely to do with strange messes cook- ed out of doors, with wriggling moist treasures, and experimental buryings and up-diggings. The stories are pleas- antly told, simply, with a twinkle of the eye and with a climactic prick at the end of each one. than a selfish young dream-cub, a paper- doll Hamlet. What if Oldroyd had mur- dered Richard's father? Richard need not on that account have taken to him- self the réle of emotional jumping-jack, at poor Alice Oldroyd’s expense: his sentimental reactions become tiresome to the point of nausea before we are done with them, and we wish heartily that Oldroyd’s daughter would send him about his business. But her part is that of the modern Griselda, and she plays it not without dignity, the only real figure in a world of not very skil- fully manipulated puppets. LIFE OF FREDERIC HARRISON. Autobiographic Memoirs. By Frederic Harrison. New York: The Macmil- lan Co. 2 vols. $7.50 net. Mr. Harrison sets for a motto on his title-page, Vivre au grand jour, and who- ever reads his two volumes will recoy- nize its fitness: for from early man- hood until his eighty-first year, in which he completed this autobiography, Mr. Harrison has always been living in broad daylight. He has been among the first to detect and to welcome the currents of fresh thought and to enlist ian the vanguard of new causes. To epitomize the substance of these rcminiscences would require a closely- packed essay: but we can at least in- dicate their quality. They are as frank as Mill’s—an obvious virtue; and if they do not leave so deep an impression upon us as Mill’s, it is because we never feel that the tragic conflicts of life ground as poignantly into Mr. Harrison’s soul as we know they did into Mill's. Mr. Harrison, like Ulysses, seems to have habitually taken the thunder and the |sunshine with a frolic welcome; and at ‘eighty, The Toll Bar. By J. E. Buckrose. New | York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. Whether of earlier or later origin, | this is a disappointing story from the | author of “Down Our Street.” The | rich and quiet humor, the tenderness, | the simplicity of that delightful book | are altogether lacking here. Instead | we have a melodramatic plot, rudimen-| tary characterization, and a general straining for effect. The chief persons) are pale caricatures, relics of a cruder | age of fiction. Daniel Oldroyd, the| landlord of the Toll Bar Inn, is an in- human monster who cannot be made credible by the assertion that “he stood | on the bedrock of things where men’s) instincts generate and mature while | their souls remain in embryo.” He is a) mere bogey. And his wife, with her pallor, her impassivity, and her inter- social issues. he declares himself an opti- mist. He has seen the world improve | greatly during his life-time: but he ad- mits that its present lack of faith in religion is the cause of many evils, and that the growing disbelief in the family is “the most dangerous symptom of our age.” Mr. Harrison’s method as an autobi- ographer is somewhat mixed: for he in- tersperses chapters of straightforward nerrative with others devoted to special topics or general information. Thus he interrupts his account of his education, in order to discuss the reforms intro- duced into Oxford sixty years ago and to contrast old Oxford with that of 1910. So, too, he digresses into a survey of the Crimean War, or of India during the Mutiny, or of a dozen political and If this method, on the one hand, prevents a perfect fusion of description of French celebrities ‘the | political upheaval. | stance, minable patchwork, into which she autobiographic material, it permits, on stitches the substance of a lifelong trag- the other, the introduction of much val- edy, is at best no better than a stage uable material, such as his gallery of presence. The young hero, Richard,|pen-portraits of Mill, Bright, and the supposed to be laboring under an equal- politicians of 1860-70, or his paper on ly tragic curse, is nothing more or less | London life during that decade, or his 211 All this would convince any doubter that the memoirs are thoroughly documented: and in addition, Mr. Harrison furnishes appendices containing sections of correspondence, extracts from his diar and even from his pamphlets and other sources. hia As is often the case with honest au- tobiographies, with Mr. the story of his childhood and forma- tive years is the most interesting of all. so Harrison's, Besides an unusually inquisitive mind, he had the interest that a healthy boy should have ip unbookish things. But he preferred normal exercise to ath- letics. Though he began early to specu- late on the ultimate facts of life, he seems never to have suffered any spir- itual pangs, much less such a wrench as his elder contemporaries, Clough and Arnold, experienced, in breaking away from the religious traditions in which they were bred. Mr. Harrison became a rationalist, and, when he reached ma- turity, a Positivist. It is as the chief British disciple of .Comte, indeed, that he has been latterly most easily classified, and these volumes will need to be re- ferred to by whoever wishes to follow the fortunes of Comtism during the last half-century. But although Mr. Harrison himself naturally regards this as the most im- portant concern of his career, there were many others which will appeal quite as strongly to most of his readers. Without ever sitting in Parliament, he was behind the scenes in more than one political campaign. Politicians of both parties trusted him, and he had inti- mates among churchmen and dissenters, Roman Catholics and agnostics. By accident of early schooling in France, he came into close sympathies with the French, and in middle life he more than once served the London Times as special correspondent on the occasion of French political crises. Espe- cially interesting are his pages about the birth of the republic and the mon- archist plot of 1877. Mr. Harrison had a way of turning up on the Continent just at the right moment to report a He kept copious diaries and wrote voluminous letters, from some of which he has drawn vivid passages. One might fill a page with bright anecdotes and epigrams. Gam- betta’s definition of Blowitz, for in- is worthy of Bismarck's wit: “Il a tous les vices—il est Juif, Bo- héme, Catholique, et décoré.” To which Blowitz might have replied that the Paris correspondent of the Times, if he would succeed, must be all things to all men. These “Memoirs” confirm the impres- sion that Mr. Harrison's talent is that of the publicist—or pamphleteer, as he would have been called in the Georgian era. He mentions some eighty essays, besides his lectures and addresses, and

Page 18

‘> 1 +) ~ ~ let » and discussions in the newspa pel H olume with the exception ri hort biog ip! ies of Cromwe ll, \ im e Sile Ruskin, and Chat- ha i ostly collections of articles first appeared in the magazines He h displayed remarkable versatil ity, but that alone ould not account ( pre ( he has made. While las treated many themes, he has put h of h essa He has written, orked, to promote great " le of fair-play, his sturdy hor I ef in liberty, and his ( through all his writing: lle i refreshing frankness in giv ! dow! ht opinions. Even on t il a h s not deficient tributes to Ruskin—al ke many another Englishman, ial prefers to show the world nt ial side only jut it is his | gent speech that has carried He crit ed English man- ne I i ind men with perfect in depends and more than cleverness d that the English like, if it be done I t elves and not by a for eligi fi ed h opinions, it first hand nd always day! HH Memoir like ina I nu i I det ) a sil I Sir Ja Don Printed f tl Un ! y by a 4 i trad nal Eng it ide to ippears to be founded , hat it is primaril t the state i po ble ime ) pt (of ti ure h i I, bu ii! or the rained } re t that tl al ly in f ! tland we looks juite a different stand i tl it lation. It 7 i int ] n Kr or a vaste! ol ead at I ) ad ot i onception y of tl tate which is a com i] alae n America When the tat otland disestablished Roman naturally possessed itself of the den ecclesiastical foundations, but n the course of the juggling back and forth from which that unfortunate realm uffered for more than a century, the en- dowments of the universities were in large measure diverted from their orig inal purpose The state assumed au thority over the universities, and re sponsibility for their maintenance. But Scotland became politically united with to the Parliament at thoroughly English in tra England, and Westminster, ditions and sentiments: the Scotch unt-! Defensor Fidei, led J. Ernest Whitney,|the name, Sansloy, or Nation The versities must henceforth look for sup- plies. The lamentable. The Englishman held a different theory from the of the state to wards education, and declined to recog: in taking over the rights and emoluments of northern realm had inherited responsibilities other than result was Scot about the duty that nize the he those he acknowledged in his own coun- try The Seotch universities were left to poverty and hard work. From this untoward condition they are only just now emerging, and that with but grudg- ing assistance from Parliament, upon which they directly and willingly ac knowledge themselves to be dependent, The University of St. Andrews, the olde of the Scoteh foundations, has ust celebrated with great scholastic im- pressiveness its five hundredth birth- day At the same time its well-beloved principal, Sir James Donaldson, com: pleted the twenty-fifth year of his ex- tremely able administration. As his own contribution to the quincentenary celebrations he has republished in a handsome volume the series of public lemic addresses with which he has yppened th Ieee years of scholae ork. In each he reviews briefly the history of the past year, and in many e sf forth with considerable fulness ind in charming manner, some item in he earlier annals of the University, or his own views about scholastic ideals of e present and future. The result is a olume of much more interest than a formal history could have possessed, be cause of the greater intimacy to which the reader is admitted. The American reader will find it unique in affording him an inside view of the wide differ- nee of ideal, standpoint, method, and character between Scotland and Eng Principal Donaldson's theories of duca n are most sane and virile, and 1 point for America as well as ‘ otland. Incidentally also the tem- ental kinship between American and Scotchman, contrasted with the lack of it between American and Eng- lishman, can here be further observed; ind much of the recent history of the nternal development of St. Andrews is strangely like that of a New England generation ago. But no Amer- college a ican faculty of equal size could measure the re- achievement to of up in scholarly markable faculty St. Andrews. Political and Ecclesiastical Allegory of the First Book of the Faerie Queene. By Frederick Morgan Padelford. Bos- ton: Ginn & Co, 75 cents. That there was a certain amount of political allegory in Spenser's great poem, even in the first book, has, of course, always been recognized. A sug- gestion of Spenser's eighteenth-century editor, Upton, that the Red Cross Knight might be identical with Henry VIII as 2435 [Vol. 94, No. in the Transactions of the American Philological Association for 1888, to d: velop the theory that there was a gen- eral correspondence of the kind just in- dicated. Padelford takes this theory again but carries it much further, inasmuch as he tries to discov- er in the political and ecclesiastical his- of England during the Reforma- tion the key to every character or inci- dent of any importance in the first book of Spenser’s poem—so that this book be- comes under his interpretation a detail ed allegorical history. To drive a theory Professor up tory as hard as this arouses in the reader a spirit of incredulity, which, we believe, is not likely to be allayed on a closer examination of the evidence. For, ac- cording to this supposition, in plan- ning the first book (which alone is con siderably more than half the length of “Paradise Lost’), Spenser set himself the task inative tute inventing a series of imag should consti- and religious allegory, itself of an intricate character, of incidents which a continuous moral and at the same time an allegorical r« flection throughout of the historical de- velopment of the English Reformation That he intended the first is, of course, beyond dispute, and it is merely a ques tion of the second. Now, on the fac of it, such a procedure is highly im probable. There is nothing similar els« where in the history of allegory, and the enterprise is one from which even the most heroic spirit might have shrunk. As a matter of fact, Professor Padelford, himself, breaks down at the Cave of Despair and the reader shares his sense of exhaustion. This is bound to be the fate, we are convinced, of any commentator who endeavors to hold down the poet to so complex and rig ous a schemé Spenser has told us that Belphebe intended to represent Queen Elizabeth in certain aspects, yet no one would maintain that much—perhaps most that is related of this heroine has any allegorical significance; but, if this is true of a character of the later books, why should we expect such rigorous consistency in the first book, even though the allegory here is, obviously, more systematic? In matters so vague defend proposed Wolsey, with hard to combat as to identifications Sansfoy it is as those with Sansjoy such as by Sansloy author: with Gardiner, Pole, Sir Satyrane with Cranmer, the lion with Thomas Cromwell. In the case of Sansjoy, as Professor Padelford acknowledges, the identification has lit- tle force; and there are serious flaws in that of Sir Satyrane, for Cranmer was not of illegitimate birth, and Sir Satyrane should have lost his life in | the defence of Una, if the two were iden- tical. Furthermore, whatever Gardiner’s ‘faults may have been, we do not see |any appropriateness in applying to him “Lawlessness.”

Page 19

Feb. 29, 1912] The identification of Wolsey with Sans- foy of necessity rests on considerations ot the vaguest kind, for the character appears in only one passage of eight seems to us, moreover, that if Professor Padelford’s theory rect, he is called on to supply the his stanzas. It is cor- torical key to such minor characters as Fradubio and Fralissa, a task which he Finally, do appeal we not the does attempt. believe that muse of history, apparently, rather than not Spenser's to to the muse of epic poetry in the Prologuc to this first book, affords any support to our author's thesis. In the intro ductory letter to Sir Walter Raleigh, Spenser designates the great epic poets, Homer, Virgil, Ariosto, and Tasso as “poets historicall.” This reveals suffi ciently his point of view. Tennyson and His Friends. Edited by Hallam, Lord Tennyson. New York: The Macmillan Co. $3 net. It is a matter of taste whether the reader will enjoy this collection of rem iniscences as a whole. The present 1 viewer, who in general is none. tot squeamish in accepting the personal re ords of great men, must admit that his final impression of this work of filial piety was not altogether pleasant. Pos sibly he was prejudiced against the whole book by the opening chapter, which contains the Re collections of My Early Life, by Emily, Lady Tennyson ‘You ask me,” the writer begins, “to tell you something of my life befor: marriage at Horncastle in Lincolnshir« It would be hard indeed not to do any thing you ask of mé if within 1 power. To say the truth, this pa ticular thing you want is somewhat Lady Tennyson's instinctive repugnance in nicer insistence. Her and painful.” is taste than he son's Recollections are rather feeble should never have been printed. Certain other chapter: contributed by willing or unwilling friends of the poet are garrulous ol! empty, and, especially in these days when his own name is somewhat und eclipse for the sentimentality of much of his verse, will not add to his fame Two of the sections are made up ol Tennyson own poems on his Cam bridge and later friends. It is somewhat significant of the tone of the book that included: “A Character” is not With a half-glance upon the sky At night he said, “The wanderings Of this most intricate Universe Teach the nothingness of things Yet could not all creution pierce Beyond the bottom of his eye. me With lips depress’d as he were meek, Himself unto himself he sold: Upon himself himself did feed: Quiet, dispassionate, and cold, And other than his form of creed, With chisell’d features clear and sleek. That caustic portrait, we believe of the The Nation future Master of Trinity (one of the finest things Tennyson ever wrote, by the way would have been a relief in these pages. We miss something of Thompson's own pungent and unchar itable observations Bu f the taste of the book as whole may be quest oned, there are tions of it that stand out by the solidity of the information or by the enterta ment they provide Perhaps the most purely nteresting chapter is that n ch Willingham Rawnsley rites of rennyson and Lincolnshire There are t of admirable description in these pages, with many quotations showing hov pe sistently (the act Vas alread well known, of course the sights and nd or the Lincol ‘ old and irsh recu 1 the pe ~ rks No! have w ever read a better account of the families about Somers! sited Dy the Tennysons, or of t peasants and sel nts whose sturd ndependence made so deep an imp n on the poet mind The story of old Wa » cavalryman who da oach ma t Halton Rectory (the he of e Rawnsls ), may! ! ew, thoug ve do not at the 1 t call iving read it before At an ra t a ~ nz enougi ind ha t en k 0} repeated t haps I ad t t 5 t I I a d th q ke ! t t l h t { i G } } ] t " \ Ployt ok nf ’ , ‘) , The best of the characte! Ket { our tast is the long chapter o Jar Spedding contributed = b W Al Wi t—-Spedding, “the Pop on 1 young men, the wiss man I kno i Tennyson said; the al ho pent a lifetime whitewashing Bacon, and v hose majestic head furnished FitzGerald with some of best rail lerv: as in his letter to Laurence “You have, of course, read the account ol Spedding’s forehead landing in Amer ica, ete And if Spedding’s altitu dinous brow was the cause of wit in the letters of others, some of his own let ters, as given here by Professor Wright, if not exactly witty, are solid and good, and in their way, as becomes a great Baconian, entertaining. We wish that Professor Wright had been able to give us more of the correspondence between Spedding and Thompson. Other chapters of particular interest are those that deal with Frederick and Charles Tennyson and with the poet's friendship for W. G. Ward. In the let- ters of Frederick something may be ob- served of the vs ] i : irough the famil and that f is f xpression in the p Alfred ‘ m the hapter on W., ¢ Wa \ nel is We on t | i ive marked while eading \ are inclined to ash I | el! ot he \ ‘ h i i ] 1 s la ( ‘ ’ ad ‘ be ! ot rrei or ! ndant Né vest Bacqueville d I Frey Royal ¢ I ’ { di Ma \ \ Or ind T ! ted 3S f Age i I \ r rar ‘ nd th iD I t Helen | and: Arthur H. ¢ ( : The t oO volul ‘ its ut hundred page vork of one ho, d become known a iking student ir 1 f irch. Mi It] ble for Er I i but i KI ! | ! ‘ ition a gy Ire thie (sl i iat ( nd thie t , il I ‘ ’ ind Fe India ! \ lo these I i ! ippen ib L] N i P ot I il ors I I i lé ! rY | ‘ etter tt, ‘ ad $ and o I character and p nt « e Sioux Pota i i \ Che } r . i nat ‘ } I i fi t i l tatior I Kr | OUR { to | he second-hand | t is well know! i t ‘ ali i t ‘ l ! better and more re t oe Indians than the ne Father Hennepit Bare nd Jonathan Carve Pert nearly forty yea! a sul trader, and explorer among the if know did. them as few met! In his Mer came to and his generation treats at length of Indian life as it man ifested itself in various way ind add thereto an excellent history of the wars of the Iroquois with the nations of the work | the “History of the Savage Peoples Allies of New France by Charles Le Roy, Sieur de Bacqueville de la Potherie. It the of the author's “Histoire de Lake region. The other French who are Claude is recond volume Amérique

Page 20

214 septentrionale.” La Potherie’s first em- ployment in America was in the squad- ron under D'Iberville that was sent in 1697 to drive the English out of Hud- son’s Bay. The following year he was appointed to the newly created post of comptroller-general of the marine and fortifications in Canada, where he lived till family affairs compelled him to go to Guadaloupe. The second vol- ume of his history only is here trans- lated, as its basis is the lost memorials of Perrot. Th tions have been faithfully, although brilllantly, executed. Miss Blair's long experience as a translator for the “Jesuit Relations” and works of similar character has fitted her well for this kind of editorial work. For Per- rot's Memoir she has generally retained else summarized Father Tailhan’s her own longer notes being re- served for the other documents. The last two documents are of much less importance and of later date. The letter of Major Marsten, addressed to the Rev. Dr. Morse, was written in 1820; and the “Account of the Manners and Customs of the Sauk and Foxes,’ by Thomas Forsyth, bears the date 1827. Both are very interesting, and the lat- ter is printed for the first time, but one wonders why such a long leap across the “sands of time” was made. Cer- tainly there are similar accounts of the Indians of the Lake region, both printed and unprinted, which might have been found to bridge the gap of one hundred years, during which time most impor- tant changes occurred among the In- dians, both in customs and their geo- graphical situation. The frontispiece of the first volume is a map showing the location of the lead- ing Indian tribes from the earliest time until they were driven across the Mis- ! i or notes, sissippi. the position of shifting tribes with large hunting areas over which they roamed offers great difficulties, which Miss Blair has succeeded in overcoming; but! the notice of the reviewer is caught by some errors. She locates the Peoria In- dians at Kaskaskia from 1700-1833, and on the Illinois River from 1768-1832. The fact is that they were at the latter place when Joliet and Marquette came up the river in 1673, and never remov- | ed from there until the nineteenth cen- tury. It is evident, both from note 19 on page 46 and the map, that Miss Blair has committed the usual error of iden- tifying the eastern and western divi- sions of the Shawnee, for she writes of that tribe crossing and recrossing the Alleghanies, when the truth is that the western division moved only from the Cumberland River to the Ohio about 1700, and never farther eastward. The attempt to associate one division with the movements of both has unfortunate- by Darewell Stone and David Capell Simp- ly led to several curious mistakes 1n/.on: “Christ's Message of the Kingdom: dates on the map. These do not serious-| A Course of Daily Study for Private Stu- The making of a map to show | [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 The Nation ly impair the value of the work, how- | ever, and the two volumes will be re- garded by historians as a worthy and fitting monument to the memory of a faithful. scholar; and the publishers have given the work a beautiful setting through their choice of paper, printing, and illustration. Notes Included in Macmillan’s list of spring publications, part of which was printed in Nation last week, are: “The Hill of poems by James Stephens; “Daily Bread,” by Wilfrid Wilson Gibson; “Swinburne,” by George Edward Wood- “Tennyson and His Friends,” edited Hallam Lord Tennyson; “The Complete Poetical Works of Geoffrey Chaucer,” put into modern English by John S. P. Tatlock and Percy MacKaye; “Thoughts on Educa- tion: Chosen from the Writings of Matthew Arnold,” edited by Leonard Huxley; “Ex- | pository Writing,” by Maurice G, Fulton; “A Course in Public Speaking,” by I. L. Winter; “Laws of Wages,” by Henry L. Moore; “Essentials of Socialism,” by Ira B. Cross; “The Governments of Europe,” by Frederick Austin Ogg; “Initiative, Refer- endum, and Recall Documents,” by Charles A. Beard; “Readings on Parties and Elec- tions in the United States,” by Chester Lloyd Jones: “The New Realism,” by Profs. i B. Holt, W. T. Marvin, W. P. Montague, R. B. Perry, W. B. Pitkin, and E. G, Spauld- ing, and “Outline of a History of Psycholo- | Max Dessoir. the Vision,” poems berry ; by gy,” by The following books will be published by | Houghton Miffln Company on March 2: “The Plain Path,” a novel by Frances | Symmes Allen; “Copyright: Its History and Law,” by R. R, Bowker; “The Adventure of | Life,” by Wilfred T. Grenfell; “Socialism | and Character,” by Vida D. Scudder; “The | Rolling Earth: Outdoor Scenes and Thoughts from the Writings of Walt Whit- |man,” compiled by Waldo R. Browne; “The Boy and His Gang,” by J. Adams Puffer, | and “Improvement of Rural Schools,” by | Ellwood P. Cubberley. Among the new books announced by Scribners are: “The Sources of Religious Insight,” by Josiah Royce; “Suggestion and | Psychotherapy,” by Dr. George W. Jacoby; '“The Abolition Crusade and Its Conse- | quences,” by Hillary A. Herbert, with a |preface by James Ford Rhodes; “Courts, | Criminals, and the Camorra,” by Arthur | Train; “Wisconsin: an Experiment of De- | mocracy,” by Frederic C, Howe, and a vol- j}ume of verse called “Wild Oats: Moods, Songs, and Doggerels,” by John Galsworthy. | T. & T. Clark publications, wuich will |be imported this season by Scribners, in- clude: “Greece and Babylon: A Compara- tive Sketch of Mesopotamian, Anatolian. and Hellenic Religions,” by Lewis R. | Farnell ; “The Religion of the Ancient | Celts,” by Canon MacCullogh; “A History lof Creeds and Confessions of Faith in Christendom and Beyond,” by W. A, Curtis; “Communion with God: The Preparation | Before Christ and the Realization in Him,” dents and for Bible Circles,” by A. G. Hogg; “At the Temple Church,” by the Rev. H. G. Woods, and “A Disciple’s Re- ligion,” by the Rev. W. H. Hutton. Little, Brown & Co.’s miscellaneous spring publications include: “A Handbook of Home Economics,” by Etta Proctor Flagg; “The Boys’ Parkman,” compiled by Louise S. Has- brouck; “The British West Indies,” by Algernon E. Aspinwall in the All-Red Brit- ish Empire series; “Pin Money Sugges- tions,” by Lilian W. Babcock, and “Anomalies of the English Law,” hy S Beach Chester. Prof. William T. Brewster’s “English Composition and Style,” and Prof. Carl Holliday’s “English Fiction,” which latter is a study of the story-telling instinct among the English people and a survey of the English novel from the fifth to the twentieth century, are in preparation by the Century Company. M thuen announce a new bio- by Messrs. graphical study of William the Silent, Jack Collings Squire. Gilbert K. Chesterton has written an in- troduction for the Rev. A. H. Baverstock’s “The English Agricultural Labourer,” which Mr. Fifield will shortly issue. The fifth and final volume of Petrus Jo- hannes Blok’s “History of the People of the Netherlands,” translated by Oscar A. Bierstadt, is promised by Putnams for early March. In the list of Fleming H. Revell Company we note: ‘American-Japanese Relations,” by Prof. Kiyoshi K. Kawakami; “The Battle of Principles: A Story of the Hero- |ism and Eloquence of the Anti-Slavery Con- flict,” by Newell Dwight Hillis, and “The Stolen Bridegroom and Other East Indian Idylls,” by Anstice Abbott. Moffat, Yard & Co. have in hand: “The Blind Road,” a new novel by Hugh Gordon; “On the Trail to Sunset,” the story of a motor trip across the country, by Mr. and Mrs. Thomas W. Willy, and “The Sentence of Silence,” by Reginald Wright Kauffman. “The Festival Book—May-day Pastimes and the Maypole” is the title of a book by Mrs. Jennette E. C. Lincoln which is now in the press of the A. S. Barnes Company. Prof. Morris W. Croll has prepared notes and an introduction for “English Lyrics from Dryden to Burns,” announced by Holt as a number of the English Readings for Schools series, edited by Prof. W. L, Cross The same house will bring out short- ly “Language Lessons for Intermediate Grades,” by Dr. Alma Blount. The three memoirs which make the text of “Cambridge Under Queen Anne” (Lon- don: Bell & Sons) were already accessible in type. The memoir of Ambrose Bonwicke, indeed, was published in 1870 by Prof. J. E. B. Mayor himself, with this statement: This volume is extracted from “Cam- bridge Under Queen Anne,” which will also comprise visits to London, to Oxford, and particularly Cambridge, by Francis Burman in 1702, and by Zacharias Conrad von Uf- fenbach in 1710. The complete work is printed mainly for such of my private friends as are interested in the history of the Universities, and in the advancement of learning and science, Professor Mayor never printed the com- plete work, but at the time of his death he had prepared a vast mass of notes illustra-

Page 21

Feb. 29, 1912} tive chiefly of the allusions to Cambridge in these three tracts, and these, with the tracts themselves, are noW issued by the care of the Cambridge Antiquarian Society. To his task of annotation the editor brought the same patient and inexhaustible learning which distinguishes his “Juvenal.” The re- sult is something like an encyclopedic ac- count of a host of obscure men and books, without neglect of some of the larger names. As an example of these biographical sketches we may specify the pages on the too little known and read Benjamin Whichcote. Nor are customs and places ignored in the ed- itor’s all-embracing interest. As for the three tracts themselves, those of Burman and Uffenbach are mainly valuable for the allusions and details which have instigated the editor’s research. Bonwicke’s memoir, written by his father, gives the pathetic story of a scholar of St. John’s, who died early from consumption, to which excessive study and painful religion were contribu- tory causes. Were it not for something hectic in the young man’s faith (not to use the harsher word, priggish), we might think ourselves, while reading his letters and devotional exercises, back in the mid-seven- teenth century instead of the deistic days of Anne. His difficulty in taking the oaths and his conscientious manner of evading their consequences are of considerable in- terest for the psychological student of his- tory. “The Public Library of the City of Bos- ton” is the history by its librarian, Horace G. Wadlin, of the first large library estab- lished as a municipal institution. Its found- ers, therefore, are justly entitled to be call- ed the fathers of the public library move- ment. Singularly enough the interest in it was awakened by a French actor, Alexandre Vattemare, who had left the stage in order to promote a system of international ex- change of books and the establishment of free public libraries and museums in all countries. With this end in view he came to Boston in 1841 and explained his plan at a public meeting, with the result that a committee was appointed to consider the practicability of the scheme. Though some of the leading citizens pleaded for the li- brary as completing the system of popular education, yet it was regarded, says George Ticknor, the Spanish historian, “by many whose judgment and influence could neither be wisely nor safely overlooked, as an experiment, promising little real or last- ing good to the city.” This opposition was gradually overcome, and the library was put on a firm basis in 1852 by the unexpected gift of $50,000 from Joshua Bates, a member of ‘he house of Baring Bros. His reason for it is given in a letter to a friend: My own experience as a poor boy convinc- ed me of the great advantage of such a li- brary. Having no money to spend and no place to go to, not being able to pay for a fire in my own room, I could not pay for books, and the best way I could pass my evenings was to sit in Hastings, Etheridge & Bliss’s bookstore, and read what they kindly permitted me to; and I am confident that had there been good, warm, and well- lighted rooms to which we could have re- sorted, with proper books, nearly all the youth of my acquaintance would have spent their evenings there, to the improvement of their minds and morals. > The larger part of the book is naturally of purely local interest. After tracing the development of the library and enumerating its notable gifts and collections, the author The Nation | gives brief biographical sketches of the leading trustees and librarians, the closing chapter being devoted to an account of its present condition and method of operation. Including the branches it contains nearly a million volumes, the home use being more than 1,500,000 annually. One of the earliest gifts, it is interesting to note, was about fifty volumes from the city of Paris. The educational value of the library is shown by the fact that “four hundred and seventy- seven different volumes were recently con- sulted in one day by students from a single college.” The work, which is the product of the library press, contains a map show- ing the location of the branches and read- ing-rooms, pictures of its three homes, and fourteen portraits. Though the argument is labored, repe- titious, and too long spun out, William Royd’s book may be recommended as a work of solid usefuness for one seeking to form a clear conception of “The Educa- tional Theory of Jean Jacques Rousseau” (Longmans). Dr. Boyd makes use of the political writings, and the “Nouvelle Hélo- ise,” quite as much as of the “Emile’’; for, as he shows, Rousseau’s pedagogy is everywhere involved in his politics In- deed, it is a question whether, in the pres- ent volume, the politics is not the major topic. In one mood an extreme -individu- alist, in another an equally extreme so- cialist, Rousseau aims in his theory of education, now to develop the self-suffi- cient man, now again the good citizen. The truth is, however, according to Dr. Boyd, that in both cases he is thinking of the small, well-harmonized social group, such as the city-state of his native in his pedagogical theory, the family. His hostility to society is directed, therefore, against the modern nation for which neither his social nor his educational] the- ory is able to provide. Yet, with all his defects as a man and as a writer, he has performed an imnortant service to mod- ern education—a service more warmly ap- preciated in the preface than in the text— in being the first of a series of writers to call attention to the point of view of the child. With the passing of Froebel and Herbart, the direct influence of Rous- Seau came to an end. At present, however, we are witnessing a recrudescence of Rousellianism in our American “child- study,” which Dr. Boyd thinks to be of doubtful value, with the exception of the writings of Prof. John Dewey, to whom he accords high praise. Geneva, or, Edwin J. Dingle, the author of “Across China on Foot, Life in the Interior and the Reform Movement” (Holt), is a young English journalist, who seems to have firs: determined upon a waik across China as a vacation ramble, with little preparation for the trip and with even less apprecia- tion of its risks. It might be wished, since he has ventured into print, that he had taken the precaution to study his subject, if not the language of the country, before starting. As it was, he wasted a considera- ble amount of vital energy in the perform- ance of a task made more difficult than it had need to be, and produced a result hard ly commensurate in value with his pains But time and experience are effective teach- ers. The traveller becomes less common- place in his observations as he becomes accustomed to the people and the land, and at the end of an arduous year he is able te contribute information about them that is worth recording. In another book, which he promises to write on the aboriginal tribes of southwestern China, he bids fair tu produce a work of serious interest, but he is likely to live long enough to regret the rather inconsequential character of this drst effort. Mr. Dingle’s pedestrian ur comprised the river trip of 1,500 miles by steamer and boat to Chung-king, aad thence 1,600 miles on foot and horse to British Burma It might be unfair te in- sist upon the misnomer involved in his titl but it deserves mention. Half the distanc« across China by road was enough almost to kill him in two illnesses brought on by hardships; had be undertaken to perform the other half in the same way he would presumably have perished incontinently rhroughout his long tramp he proves him elf to be a cheerful traveller, fairly ob servant of the things which he can hough not always inspiring confidence tn told him by his boy.” His record has been compiled from the things repeated as i diary written on the way in 1909 ith much revision and often corrected by foot notes added a year later, which occasioa ally contradict the statements in the text Mr. Dingle’s interest in the countrymen of China reveals a sympathetic nature sike most visitors who take the trouble to get their point of view, he sees , reat p« ibilt ties in even the lowest grades of the people and is not repelled by their uniform indif ference to filth and squalor. Indications of new currents surging in the life of these re mote districts were visible frequently If not everywhere; but to the question Doe China really want the foreigner?” he ts inclined to return an unqualified “no.” Yet if change means progress, China s pl gressing rapidly, for every considerab centre he reached displayed the two sig: which chiefly mark her departure from h old ways—public schools and modern mill tary establishments. The former are hardly more than an advertisement of what is yet to come, a costly plant already wel! begun but no educated class so far produced that is capable of moulding the opinion of the community. The Model Army already developed in Yun-nan impresses him, how- ever, as being a thoroughly trained and equipped force. “The military academy.” he declares, “would be a credit to any town in India; the discipline and military bear- ing of the troops on parade would be no disgrace to any native or foreign regiment in Asia; the thoroughness with which tbe Yun-nan Model Army is equipped with mod- ern gear not only shows that the provin- cial authorities mean business, but that the army shall be in a position to put that business through.” And what is going on in the capital, he saw in a lesser degree tn other towns throughout the province. H's opinion that the new army would remain loyal to the Government has already been demolished by the events of the last few months, but the spirit developed in these troops here and elsewhere in China ought if his observations are trustworthy, to car- ry her through the crisis, when a real leader is found. Whatever the outcome of the rebellion, the forces of a militant China already generated promise no fur- ther submission to predatory foreign Pow ers in the future Egerton R. Williams, jir., has followed his “Hill-Towns of Italy” with a volume on

Page 22

216 ‘lain-Towns of Italy” (Houghton Mif- flin) His “plain” is old Venetia, and his limits are Udine on the east and Brescia on the west. He describes many of the place once famous but now usually neg- lected by the tourist, although they well deserve attention Whoever would recover ome of the Old World Italian atmosphere should pass a day at Bassano or Vicenza, or at any one of the dozen other towns to which Mr. Williams devotes a chapter, Ve- rona and Padua he treats at much greater lengtl Hi ethod is to give not merely " ghtsee! npression, but such historical 1 artist nformation as a cultivated tra r desir know He writes agree- ibly, and i ellent illustrations. His olu ought to serve as a delightful com- pl t to Baedeker for every one who ex- I the beautiful Venetian Plain. I \ \ntiquarian Society of \\ r, Ma has introduced a broader ) blications by printing " ilatiorn British Royal Proclama tior relating to America, 1603-1783," pr Clarence 8S. Brigham At best a ition requires some interpretation 1 its time and sphere of action should be 1, unless those facts are stated in th: ! nt rhe proclamation of 1622, for imple ssued at the behest of the coun cil for Plymouth, to prevent irregular trad ing outside of the council’s patent in w England, had no effect, because there not sufficient force to make it effec- tive Fach document has a history, and it id t Wished that the notes of the edit idicilous as they are, had been ex led rhe prominence of the tobacco in t f Virginia is shown by the eigh- t rocla itions issued before 1640, or in one-half the total issued in that ! Frade regulation is the most im- ta imal ubject treated and the rd do not how any undu interfer ‘ ‘ ith American affairs, for the meas- ur re framed according to the com- il pirit « the day Pir y, the ap hension of riminals, and th continu office of Colonial administrations attention rhe proclamations for lave from 1776 to 1783 are little mor iriosities There are one hundred i proclamations printed in the vol 1 convenient compilation for refer- smnination of eleven new volumes in Home ( ersity Library (Holt) con vhat was said in these pages regard the firet instalment of these little ok It a useful and interesting se ri which now sells at the moderate rate of 50 centa the volume, in large, clear print, | attractive binding The monographs ire written by men of unquestioned author in their fleld, but evidently with a mini of general editorial supervision. This cans that there is a considerable variety h regard to method of treatment Not | of the volumes are primers in the sense of aiming at the simple presentment of iccepted fact for the ordinary reader. Fre- quently the author chooses to develop his cwn views on a controverted question, and sometimes he does so ina manner that pre- supposes considerable preliminary know!l- edge. One advantage is that we have here n vigor and attractiveness of style that are not to be found in the ordinary hand- book. G. H. Mair writes om“Modern Eng-' Nation ‘The lieh Literature” with ease and authority His treatment of the subject is not inclu- sive, and, since he allows himself to pass judgment on writers of recent date con- corning whom criticism is as yet in a con- dition of flux, there is room for taking ex- ception to opinions But there no doubt that text stimulates further study in the subject, and so serves its pur- of personal treat- sketch, “The Pap- in which the author his is his to Another example ment Dr. Barry's acy and Modern Times,” pose is develops the thesis that the Vatican has played an important role in, history as the hampion of the individual and the state against Cmsarism Professor Myres of Oxford, in “The Dawn of History,” studies historical evolution as shaped by physio- graphical and primitive sociological con- ditions; he takes account of the latest coveries in Egypt, Mesopotamia, and the Igean. Closer to the type of the ordinary text-book are the “Astronomy” of Arthur k. Hinks of Cambridge Observatory, Eng- land; “The Civilization of China,” by Prof Herbert A. Giles of Cambridge University, n intimate and comprehensive little trea- tise; and “The History of Our Time, 1885- 1911,” by G. P. Gooch, which necessarily fails to be comprehensive. W. M. Geldart’s “Ele- ments of English Law” is an excellent So is W. F. which sets out to be a survey of summary Barrett’s “Psychical Research,” the results so far achieved by the Society fur Psychical Research. Two volumes, which suffer from an overloose treatment of a D, Evolution of Industry,’ ed also by an obscure style, and Prof.J. Ar- “Introduction to Science.’ Professor Thomson is one of thegeneral edi- Macgregor’s “The which is handicapp- vague subject, are thur Thomson's ters of the series, and, with Professor Geddes, has written the fascinating volume on Evolution Here we have a discursive treatment on the nature and implications ef science which is agreeable philosophiz- ing, but does not get anywhere in particu- lar The only American contributor is Prof. Frederic L, Paxson of the University of Wisconsin, who writes on our Civil War. preface Paxson t to be “reasonably clear to-day, that the outh would of herself have discarded slav- in " That presup- position does not interfere with his giving In his Professor asserts ery another generation is a straightforward rerrative of events. “The Edward Modern Railroad” (McClurg), by Hungerford, depicts in twentieth century magazine style the human side of the railway industry. It no concern with the railway problem Its purpose is to give the reader an intimate knowledge of the everyday problems of the en- gaged in building and operating our trans- portation lines, by describing in order the duties of the different railway officers, and of the various grades of employees. It is filled with significant statis- tics, dramatic and it is generously illustrated While its may have great a tendency to surround with an atmosphere of romance what is mere commonplace, its five hundred pages contain of interesting in- formation “The Civil War Literature of Ohlo: has men anecdotes, and situations, writing too a store A Bib- liography,” by Daniel J. Ryan, published by Burrows Brothers Co. of Cleveland, is a distinct contribution to the literature of Western history and bibliography. vivid | | There | Vol. yy No. 2435 ' are in all eight hundred and ninety-nine titles listed, consisting mostly of public documents, regimental histories, and ephem- eral literature, such as speeches and ser- mons. The annotations are excellent and of such a length as to make it unnecessary, in many cases, for the student to go to the original. The editor has followed the usual bibliographical method of arrange- ment in alphabetical order, although the grouping into topics would be far more convenient for the student, and all the benefits of the alphabetical order might be put in the index. Three-fourths of the titles are taken from the editor’s own library, but the list does not indicate where copies of the others may be found, information that is essential in the and little- known books and pamphlets. case of scarce A second edition has just appeared of that work by Prof and Structure fascinating and valuable Otto Jespersen, the “Growth of the English tioned by the Nation in February, 1906, be- it the the Institut Although the substance greatly altered, the extensive than the in the Preface The as a slight through Language” (Teubner), men- received Volney prize of de been fore France. revision has not has been more author's modest might lead has explanation to gained one expect work whole changes of ex- fresh through pression here and there, lustrations, and through occasional conden- il- sation. Several errors of the printer hav« disappeared, and, so far as we have ob- served, no new ones of importance have crept in. The bock is now a little more compact, and the new type and paper make easier reading. In connection With the chap- ter on Shakespeare and the Language of Poetry, we may remark, as Professor Jes- persen duly notes, that the whole subject of the diction of Shakespeare, as compared with that of Bacon, “has been investigated N. Boégholm (‘Bacon og Shakespeare,’ Copenhagen, 1906), who has succeeded in pointing out an astonishing number of dis- crepancies between the two authors.” We recommend all of the chapters in their new dress to teachers who desire to attract im- mature students of language by means that are at once inspiring and safe. by Dr. Andrew Martin Fairbairn, for twenty- three years principal of Mansfield College, Oxford, died recently in London, at the age of seventy-three. He was Lyman Beecher lecturer at Yale in 1891-92, and was the au- thor of several works on religious and phi- losophical subjects, among them “Studies in the Philosophy of Religion and History,” “Studies in the Life of Christ,” “Catholi- cism, Roman and Anglican,” and “The Phil- osophy of the Christian Religion.” Mrs. Margaret Byers, doctor of laws, and principal, since 1859, of Victoria College, Belfast, died in that city last week. From the first she was deeply interested in ali movements looking to the improvement of the condition of Irish women, and in due course became the founder and director of Victoria College, which has been prominent ‘in all pioneer and educational work. It was | begun as a secondary school before col- |legiate education for women was thought of. |In 1878 she worked for the inclusion of |girls in the benefits of the Irish Intermed- liate act. The college was a natural evo- |lution of all that had gone before, when, in 1881, the Royal University of Ireland of- fered its examinations and degrees to wo-

Page 23

Feb. 29, 1912] The Nation 217 men. Mrs. Byers was interested in many forms of philanthropic work. But amid her many labors she found time for a good deal of literary work. Dr. Joseph Ettlinger, who a short time before his recent death, in his forty-third year, was appointed feuilleton editor of the Frankfurter Zeitung, wrote a number of distinguished biographies; for example, “Hofman von Hofmanswaldau” and “Mad- ame Récamier.” ——— —= Science Aerial Navigation. By Albert F. Zahm. New York: D. Appleton & Co. $3 net. This book has unusual merit. It is popular in tone, but contains many im- portant scientific facts related directly and indirectly to aviation, and cannot fail to be regarded as an excellent addi- tion to aeronautic literature. The au- thor is professor of mechanics in the Catholic University of America in Wash- ington, and has conducted some excel- lent investigations on aerodynamics, especially concerning air resistance to moving planes, and the coefficient of skin friction. In the historical introduction, Profes- sor Zahm has a most interesting chap- ter on the Fancy and Folk-lore of fiy- ing. Ovid’s account of Icarus, son of Dedalus, is quoted, and there are many other references to such legends, in- cluding the tales of the great fiy- ing bird, the roc. Among those who imagined the possibilities of the so-call- ed Dedalean flight was none less than Leonardo da Vinci, a gifted engineer as well as an artist, who devised a fly- ing gear for man which clearly showed genius. The devices invented are re- produced from Da Vinci's sketches. To Jean-Baptiste Dante, who lived in the fifteenth century, is credited the first successful soaring flight. The experi- ments took place at Perugia. The re- markable flight of the Marquis de Bacqueville in Paris over the Seine in 1742 is described. From the evidence available, it is probable that both Dante and De Bacqueville used some sort of aeroplane glider. The early history of the many forms of balloons and their fanciful inventors, which follows, is very entertaining. Part I is entitled “The Growth of , Aerostation,” and in the first chapter is found a history of the development of the passive balloon. Progress in the science got its first real impetus from the discovery in 1766 by Henry Caven- dish that hydrogen was many times lighter than air. Dr. Black, an Edin- burgh chemist, suggested the of hydrogen for balloons, an idea shortly after put into practical use by Tiberius Cavallo in the form of small soap bub- bles filled with that gas. It was left to the Montgolfier brothers and to the physicist, Professor Charles, to devise use t ’ the man-carrying hydrogen balloon. The balloons of the Montgolfiers were high- | ly decorated and designed in curious shapes. It is said that the suggestion of the invention came from the Siege of Gibraltar, the possibility of escaping like rising smoke having occurred to Joseph Montgolfier. The brothers were rich paper manufacturers, but Stephen is said to have been an architect also. The passenger balloon designed by Pro- fessor Charles about 1783 was a truly scientific invention. It was twenty-sev- en and a half feet in diameter and made of varnished silk. After several suc- cessful ascensions it was destroyed. The adventurous flight of Glaisher and Cox- well in 1861 is described in detail, with a discussion relating to the height reached by these aeronauts. At an alti- tude of 30,000 feet or more both became almost unconscious, but they managed somehow to descend. The early history of power balloons begins essentially with Blanchard’s, in 1784,. which was provided with a boat- like car having aerial oars. A number of the pioneer forms of these balloons are pictured, but it is evident that the real advance was the man-carrying di- rigible, La France, of Capt. Renard and Capt. Krebs, in 1884. This aerial ves- sel actually returned to the starting point against a wind, the propelling power being a 220-pound electric motor which developed nine horsepower. Then came the famous dirigibles of Santos Dumont, which are described in detail. Seventy-five pages are devoted to the various gasolene-driven dirigibles. These are divided into two classes: the non- rigid, represented by the Clement-Bay- ard, and the rigid type, such as the Zep- pelin. Part II relates to the growth of avi- ation. Here again the reader is led back to the early history of the science. Leonardo da Vinci's fertile mind con- ceived three distinct devices for carry- ing a man in the air. Owing to the lack of motive power the early inventors, of course, could not navigate dynamic fly- ers, however ingeniously contrived. Da Vinci's first design, referred to in the in- troduction, is shown by a drawing cop- ied from the original. It provides the operator with two wings manipulated by his arms and legs. The second de- sign is a helicopter. The drawing shows in diameter to It is quite never framed a screw twenty-six feet be operated by the aviator. that the machine used. The third sail, on which a man could settle slow- ly down to the earth. Thus da Vinci was the father of the parachute. The first use of the parachute is said to have been made in the year 1783, when Lenor- mand from the Montpelier Observatory by means of two specially made umbrellas, one being held in each hand. In this connection the author de scribes an interesting parachute found obvious was device was a descended in nature in the form of a two-winged seed which grows on a tree in India. When the seed falls it descends to the ground in wide, graceful De scriptions follow of the of the Englishmen, Sir George Cayley and Henson. The latter in 1847-48 construct ed a model which the first flying machine successful flight. Other are cited, including the kite of Hargrave, the which is based the construction box kite bearing their name, so univer sally used as the most efficient form. The work of Langley is illustrated with ex cellent photographs, as is also that of the unfortunate Lilienthal. Four beautiful photographs show the Wright brothers’ first their first power-driven are curves, inventions was supposed to be to early perform a models aeroplane of the on design of and second gliders and aeroplane, and some interesting stories of their expert- ments on the dunes near Kitty Hawk, North Carolina. Not the least interest ing are the descriptions of the remark able glider flights of the late Professor Montgomery, who was killed in Cali fornia recently. In a hundred subse- quent pages the progress of aviation is sketched during the past four much of which is familiar to all. Part III is a discussion of the gener there veare, al properties of the free air. On page 349 a table gives the percentage distri- bution of gases in the atmosphere up to an altitude of 150 kilometers, which is taken from Moore's “Descriptive Meteor ology.” The accuracy of this table is questionable, since it represents an un proved theory only The other tables are good, and there is much of interest in the hundred pages which deal with “aeronautic meteorology,” for the au thor presents the subject well The aeronautic letters written from Passy, France, in 1783, by Benjamin Franklin, relating to the experiments of the Mont golfier brothers and Professor Charles, are of The pages of the book are devoted to mill tary dirigible to planes which can rise from water particular interest last balloons, and aero Science books in Ma Ilar list if ! “Insect Pests.” by W ( O'Kane mr Beginner in Poultry,” | C. S. Valenti “Farm Boys and Girls.” by Willia \ McKeever Milk and Its Products.” by Henry H. Wing The Training and Breat ing of Horses,” by M. W. Harper Forag Crops for the South,” by 3 M Ira “Farm Management.” by G. F. War “Farm Poultry,’ by George f Wa Poultry Husbandry,” by J. E. Rice Plat Breeding,” by H. J. Webber The Health Baby and How to Keep Him So,” t Roe H. Dennet Food for the Invalid and the Convalescent by Winifred § Gibt Stuttering and Lisping,” by FE. W. Seri ture Who's Who In Science College Z« ology,” by R. W. Hegner Principl f Human Nutrition,” by Ww H Jord Meteorology,” by W I. Mitha arth Features and Their Meaning.” by Willia

Page 24

The Nation

[Vol. 94, No. 2435

Herbert Hobbs; “Analytical Mechanics,” by Alexander Ziwet and Peter Field; “Storage Batteries,” by Harry W. Morse; “Elements of Statistical Method,” by Willford I. King; “Anthropology,” by Dr. H. Schurtz, trans- lated and adapted by Prof. Franz Boas. “The Teaching of Primary Arithmetic,” by Henry Suzzallo, will be brought out by Houghton Mifflin Co. on March 2. Edward Bok has arranged for the pub- lication by the Fleming H. Revell Co. of a series of treatises on sex hygiene. The first three are now announced: “How Shall I Tell My Child,” by Mrs. Woodallen Chap- man; “When a Boy Becomes a Man,” by H. Bissecker, and “Instead of Wild Oats,” by Winfleld Scott Hall. The Smithsonian Astrophysical Observa- tory, which, on account of its work on the sun, enjoys the unique distinction of three- fold location—in Washington, and on the summits of Mount Wilson and Mount Whit- ney, California—has accomplished much excellent work in the past year. Following up the work of the late lamented Langley, whose first expedition to the summit of Mt. Whitney was undertaken nearly a third of a century ago, Dr. C. G. Abbot, the director, has now made solar-constant de- terminations simultaneously at sea level (Washington), at above a mile altitude (Mount Wilson), and again at Mount Wil- son, and at nearly three miles altitude (Mount Whitney). Although both the quan- | tity and the quality of the solar radiation found at these stations differ very much, neither the “solar constant” nor the dis- tribution of the solar energy in the spec- trum outside the atmosphere, as fixed by the wholly independent measurements at these three stations, differs more _ than would be expected in view of the unavoid- able small errors of observation. It seems just to conclude that we do, in fact, elim- inate the effects of atmospheric losses and actually determine the true quantity and quality of the sun's radiation outside the atmosphere, as we might do if we could observe in free space, with no atmos- phere at all to hinder. Also, Dr. Ab- bot reaches the further important con- clusion, though as yet tentatively, that the sun actually varies from day to day in its output of radiation § with- in limits of from 6 to 10 per cent. in quan- tity, and in irregular periods of from 5 to 10 days; and that the solar radia- tion comes from sources ranging in tem- perature, perhaps, between the limits 6,000 degrees and 7,000 degrees absolute centi- grade, but mostly from sources between 6,000 degrees and 7,000 degrees. Charles Robert Sanger, professor of chem- istry and director of the chemical labora- tory at Harvard University, died in Cam- bridge on Sunday, after a brief iliness, at fifty-six years. Profeseor Sanger graduated from Harvard tn 1881, and after graduate work there and in Germany filled the chair of chemistry at the United States Naval Academy for six years and at Washington University in St. Louls for seven years. He was called to Harvard in 1899. Philip Rounseville Alger, professor of mathematics at the United States Naval Academy, died on Friday of last week, at the age of fifty-two. He was an expert in ordnance and the chemistsy of explosives, and was the author of “Exterior Ballistics,” |“Plastie Strength of Guns,” and “Hydro- hold the reader, do so by qualities which ‘in the main, his plays, In so far as they are very different from those implied in Lamb’s phrase. This is t ven of the Miss Grace Anna Lewis, one of America’s ae sie par yest. his i foremost scientific women and widely known) connected, “The Witch of Edmonton,” as a naturalist, died in Media, Pa, on Sun-| 444 ne preduced in conjunction with day. She was born in 1821. In 1869 she Ford. One cannot say positively, of co ’ printed a pamphlet showing the relation of | how much of this play we owe to the su- birds to the animal kingdom. This pamphlet | erior tragic genius of Ford, but after all was the germ of charts that she prepared | it remains on the level of domestic tragedy, later, among which were “Chart of the | and despite its genuine pathos and power Classification of Birds,” “Chart of the Anil- | i¢ is wanting in the imaginative quality mal Kingdom,” and “Chart of Geology, with) which might have lifted it into the higher a Special Reference to Paleontology.” She | regions of poetry. also prepared “Water-Color Paintings of | ; Wild Flowers” and “Studies in Forestry.”| Miss Hunt's book is generally well-writ- |ten, but we cannot regard as very happy = ig yt bog gh soe | deep devotion to each other. Their chosen rue w c o e | ' 7 , | affinities, with whom they exchange vows be. It must also remain uncertain whether | 4¢ eternal fidelity and renunciation—for Dekker travelled on the Continent in his | the bonds are to be entirely Platonic—are early life, although his fondness for Dutch | a boy and girl who, of course, fall in love lends some color to the supposition that he and leave their elderly adorers, after hu- Gamaaee te tg ots rape reee | miliating exposure, to finish their lives to- 0 ylographic " | gether as they best may. Lady Patricia, almost wholly to Dekker’s works, especially the mature spouse, who revels in the the dramas. Like nearly all students of | notion of reciprocal devastating passions the poet in recent times, Miss Hunt writes | which are to be altogether Platonic, is an under the apett of Charles Lamb's saying | .ntirely Gilbertian figure, and, of course, that Dekker “had poetry enough for any-| cugnt to be enacted with perfect sincerity, thing, omy sy Pcemagy: Ee } vay as if she were really the languorous, ele- exaggeration. or nstance, “The Shoe- ° ant, and passionate sentimentalist of her maker’s Holiday,” which is probably the peed inti It is only thus that the best of his plays not written in collabora- piece can be made effective as genuine sa- tion, possesses an undeniable sweetness and | tirical comedy Mrs. Fiske, one of the arene charm, moti A he bene least plastic of stage performers, has not that it notre 7 M . ~ tes aa - the temperament, the style, or the acting wa oo oe Sotho tee en dat ard abilities necessary for the proper interpre- n J . tation of such a character. She makes of believe, however, that he was nearer the en anedh mooning Patricia a pert near Fe sryh pmo ities gan. | incisive, self-conscious personage, resem- mk . “| Dling a burlesquer never unmindful of her tunatus” as “this beautiful play.” In read- | ron hab sonny impersonation lacks imag- ing Naor ata gomeynodl Seton te! ination, refinement, and fascination, three we ee a e@ much | it ost vital elements. The piece was classiciam had its uses after all—and not ae @rentea end rt yeaty but the merely in prose. We do not mean to deny acting throughout was of achat ete quale to Dekker, of course, a true lyrical charm | ity, and the representation dragged for the marge ae pope oa want of a little interpretative intelligence. i ° | ; occasionally beautiful images and even fine | The stage version of H. G. Wells's | passages of a somewhat greater extent, but, | “Kipps,” prepared by the author himself and Rudolf Besier, will be presented soon

Page 25

Feb. 29, 1912} The Nation ! in London. It is in three acts, the first being laid in the shop where Kipps served his laborer’s apprenticeship; and the sec- ond in the house of which the little hero became the proud possessor. The third and last act is divided into two scenes, the first introducing a big garden party, and the second the kitchen of Kipps’s abode, where he and Anne eventually come to- gether. Louis Calvert will be the produc- er, and the scenery will be painted by Mr. Joseph Harker. Early in March there will be produced in the Aldwych Theatre, London, a four- act play, entitled “Proud Maisie,” by E. G. Hemmerde, K.C., part-author of “The But- terfly on the Wheel” and “The Crucible.” “Proud Maisie” deals with a Scotch sub- ject, and abounds in moving incidents and thrilling adventures, set in a framework ot pure romance. The two principal char- acters will be played by Miss Alexandra Carlisle and Henry Ainley. A new three-act comedy, called “‘Miner- va’s Husband,” is to be presented by the Playfellows’ Society, in London. The author is J. B. Sterndale Bennett, a grandson of the famous composer, and report speaks well of his work. Alfred Sutro’s new play, “The Fire Screen,” which has just been produced at the Garrick Theatre, in London, does not appear to be a work of striking originality or great dramatic value. But, it is said to have the merit of being exceedingly amusing. There seems to have been no particular reason why the London Stage Society should have produced the “Travellers,” of Nor- man McKeown, except possibly the fact that no one else would. Half of the independent societies appear to be possessed by the de- lusion that any piece which no practical manager will have anything to do with must naturally be a masterpiece. “Travellers” is a tale of the unlawful passion inspired in the breast of a mining Hercules for the wife of a puny little professor, who prates about eugenics and the neces- sity of improving the human race. Hercules proposes to make a practical application of these theories, but when he broaches the subject to the professor, finds himself look- ing down the barrel of a revolver, and lis- tening to a stern injunction—which he obeys promptly—to be off about his proper business and keep hereafter at a respectful distance. The New Players of London have been giving the “Medea” of Euripides in Gilbert Murray's translation. Adeline Bourne was the Medea. Mr. Walkley, writing of her performance, says: Unless the Medea is great enough to fill us with awe, and not merely horror, the play will not earn the honorable title of tragedy. And Miss Adeline Bourne, while she shocked and thrilled and now and then all but disgusted us with the intensity of this haggard, dishevelled, neurotic woman's distorted passions, hardly made Medea great. Her vengeance did not fill the heav- ens; it made the earth creepy. And there are at least two passages where Medea’s sorrows, as distinct from her wrongs, well to the surface in “warm tears”; these pass by all but unnoticed, W. B. Yeats has made a new version, in prose, of “Cfdipus Rex” for production at the Abbey Theatre, Dublin. Gordon Craig's scenery is used for the purpose. “The Five Frankfurters,” a successful | jhave come, one Berlin play of which the American rights have been obtained by the Shuberts, deals with the beginnings of the house of Roth- schild. The date is 1822, and the first act takes place in the living-room, situated over the historic bank in Frankfurt where the fortunes of the Rothschild family were started. Here, in company with their moth- er, are assembled the brothers, who from another from London, a third from Vienna, and so forth, to discuss the question of a big loan to be made to an Austrian Duke. A love story is blended with the financial motiveof the tale five Paris, Music MASSENET’S “CENDRILLON,” Previous to the opening of the Man- hattan Opera House, four only of Mas- senet’s operas had been heard in New York—“Manon,” “Werther,” “Le Cid,” and “La Navarraise.” Oscar Hammer- stein added five more—‘“Thais,” “Le Jongleur de Notre Dame,” “Hérodiade,” “Sapho,” and “Grisélidis.” The tenth of Massenet’s twenty-two operas, “Cen- drillon,” had its first hearing in this city on Tuesday evening of last week, when it was sung at the Metropolitan Opera House by Mr. Dippel’s opera com- pany, which had previously won genu- ine successes with it in Chicago and Philadelphia. The cast included Mary Garden, Maggie Teyte, Marie Cavan, Mabel Riegelmann, Hector Dufranne, and M. Huberdeau, who, under the pains- taking and enthusiastic direction of Campanini, gave an admirable render- ing of this characteristic product of Massenet’s genius. Particular interest attached to the Cinderella of Maggie Teyte, who, not long ago, jumped into sudden fame in Europe and on this oc- casion made her first appearance on the operatic stage here. She has evident talent for acting; her voice is youthful and charming, and no one could have sung the music better. Mary Garden has once more put Massenet under obli- gations by impersonating one of his parts—that of Prince Charming—with rare art, while her singing was better than usual. When “Cendrillon” was produced in Paris it was suggested that Massenet had been prompted to set this fairy tale to music by the sensational success of Humperdinck’s “Hansel and Gretel.” As a matter of fact, “Cendrillon” had been planned and partly written before that Cerman fairy opera had been launched; but it was put aside and was not produced at the Opéra Comique till six years later (1899). It was excep- tionally well received by both public and press. Louis Schneider, Marsenet’s official biographer, declared that the composer “dusted the tale of Perrault and the libretto of Henri Cain with a fine powder of sounds,” which applies to the opera as a whole, but does not do _ «, 219 justice to the more emotional moments of the score. Henri Cain's poetic merit, and in perfect accord with It. Parisian has the gift of composing sim- ple, pleasing melodies, the impression has gone abroad that he is not a deep expert musician. As a matter of fact, he was for a number of years professor of harmony and composition at the Paris Conservatoire, where most of the young: er men prominent in the musical life of that city came under his influ- None of these is a thor- ough master of his craft than but better than all of them he knows how to conceal art, and combine depth with libretto is of unusual Massenet’s music is Because this now ence, more he, clarity, while avoiding needless disson- ances. “Cendrillon is as exquisitely scored as “The Juggler of Notre Dame.” In all French opera there is perhaps no- thing more delicious than the passage “You are my Prince Charming,” where the oboe and voice chant together lov- ingly. There is a surprising amount of variety, too. Cinderella's song, in which she resigns herself to her dull life, Is plaintive, while nothing could be more pompous or grotesque than the entry of her relatives. Exceptionally good, also, are the dances at the ball. The first one is rhythmically as Spanish as the “Carmen” ballet, while the third has a piquant pizzicato Altogether, “Cendrillon” was decidedly worth pro- ducing. Possibly, next season, Mr. Dip- pel may choose to produce Massenet’s latest opera, “Roma,” or his “Von Quixote,” which is now having a run in Paris and which give Maurice Renaud a splendid opportunity to reveal his art in a new aspect. ostinato. would their ope- Dodd, Mead & Co. have added to librettos of famous ras two of Wagner's: “Die Meistersinger” and “Tristan and Isolde,” like their predecessors, in red and of convenient size for the pocket. W. J. Henderson, as before, has provided readable and helpful introduc- telling the stories and commenting collection of bound, tions, ‘briefly on the peculiarities of the operas Inasmuch as Humperdinck’s second fairy opera, “Kénigskinder,” had its first per- formance anywhere in New York City, it Is proper that the first books on it should also be local time ago Anna Alice Chapin wrote a book telling the story of this opera in a simple style, for the bene- fit of children But unlike “Han- sel and Gretel,” this work appeals to adults even more strongly than to the young folks, devoted into latest products Some since, there was room for another book, the task of initiating opera-goers subtle art of Humperdinck’s This book written by well-equipped men, Lewis M, Isaacs and Kurt J. Rahison (Dodd, Mead & Co). iz contains a portrait of the composer with to the score. has been two a sketch of his career, pictures of some of the scenes, a lucid synopsis of the plot, and, best of all, nearly sixty pages in which the musical web of the beautiful ore is put under the microscope and ana-

Page 26

(v i inrepresented limited and deep shadows \lbr fmecsses of early Nation ‘The blues have been faithfully conveyed to iper, the greens and yellows are of ‘ dne d delicacy. Merely plates the student could n much, and he who in addition pos l a few good typical piec might lily perfect his ceram education It this English-French catalogue, h is properly ancillary to the re oductions, and sensibly omits mark authors have laid most stress upon classic reign of the Emperor Kang Many pieces a edited to th irlier Ming dynasties, but idgine plate not a quarter of sucl bution ! enabl In particul | ‘ ascribed to Cheng-hwa ar nagnificent examples of Kang hais! Thi hole matter of ng attributions may be less impor nt than it seen We fancy, indeed t if Ming pieces were as plentiful as ) of Kang-he, a sensitive collector uld in most cases prefer the later ur Because of their rarity one pos- y exage ites the quality of the piec Considerable attention is n this catalogue to the Yung- period wl h tnessed the devel- nt of 1 and egg-shell iins The Kien-lung products, ilready mark the decline of the t, al cantily but sufficiently repre- ted These dryly perfect master- of tl la ig nth century are ] e sat tory in the cabinet, pu Iv ad itive nothing e finer than t large ngle-colot of Kien-lu | porcelait his work contains us plat ( ut crystal, glass, d ud These are often extraordi | be iful object but they are nt at the cost of slurring more int matters Whites, celadons, we 6 lune, crackles, ete., are quite The It excuse is difficulty reproduction ould be more co- it if the process did not cope success- rock the plates crystal. allotted to finest ith ruld nara the problem of that had an wish tones been devoted the ites, and to epitome of the and stoneware types are, their in work a of not numerous ould guide W have made this Chinese ceramics We that moved to complete their ot to class hope these be supplementary ighest ithors may rk with a volume cope indicated above Meanwhile, vy have done a great service to collec and students. The edition of this umptuous catalogue, which is doubly eful because most of the pieces are inaccessible in private collections, is to one thousand copies. large, thin follo, in blue boards, on cht Diirer” (Macmillan, $2.50 net) Is of the beat arranged art books that has under our eye The text German of Dr. Friedrich Nichter om the [ Vol. 94, No. 2435 comprises a terse biograpay enriched from with explanations op- The is an Durer's own the fifty writings three plates reproduc- posite int! mway It j enthusiasm and in niy occasionally ex nearest h approat scribing of statement is in d t} pe 1A ord of Sheraton out ofl th su furniture masquerades day un Colonial” and which a Molinier aptly desc mplicity of prison credible that eppelwhite, and turned iarked W“ iorms furniture Chippendale should hav been for and repul which frequently ler the name rds with what “the horrible riods mahogany hou elumsy t« of M Styl and s fron 1 old cords it news vertisements tories, and wills iliven the chapters on ‘ror trames, al questionable generalization ma noted now and then Concerning Span Gothic furniture, for exampl that “litt study has yet beer issertion during the the au arch to the arts i Spain il \ges”’ makes one wonder if properly valued the res¢ under- Williams's of Older lying Leonard three books on ‘Arts Crafts Spain.” General- and nevertheless this furniture to recently cribbed that extending congrat book rior several published ompiled rance is rT is so supe inuals of hastily and badly information its eA cause for ulat to the publishing house which s had ely ions the to produce it so hand Many from courage a of the illustrations have collections Art. the furniture Museum of drawn the Metropolitan The So des Artistes Indépendants who hold March 15 Paul leté their next annual exhibition at the Quai d'Orsay, have reélected Signac president French Under-S« for Fine Bérard, reflects the spirit of the announcing to The Arts new cretary Léon times in his intention open to the public; he entirely with “paying that the transferred short- for it the Louvre freely to It embourg Museum may be to the the nore aesires do away days.’ is his hope,, also, Lux ly quarters prepared in Seminary of St. Sulpice The English graver, death en- Charles William is reported of the Sherborn The Farningham Kent, is reported from N. Ward, the death of Joseph well-known translated | Egyptologist, and author of publications on art A collection of Greek coins made by

Page 27

him is now in J. Pierpont Morgan’s exhibit at the Metropolitan Museum Jules-Joseph Lefebvre, the well French painter and member of the Insti tute lied Saturday in Paris. He was born rournon, i tl Department of ul Seir Mar 1834. was a pupil of Léon Cogniet ind won the Grand Prix itl his painting rhe Death Pria t six years after his id Salon. Among his } i gs al La Cigale, in the Museu Ss - La Vérit tl M I irg 1 Dian Sur j ! Buenos Ayres. He was decorat with the Legion of Honor in 1870, becor an officer of the order in 1878. The Acader Fine Arts elected him to members! i 1891 \ S s to s fron Berlin of t : } Prof Albert Hertel, painter o ] ] ¢ ind still lif iged ixty z H r of the Berlin Acad in ” OF “DULNESS.” One all others in topic, novel, has large- not at ly superseded financial dis during the past two or three cussion weeks. In most other fields of hu man interest, it is taken for granted that conditions are normal and usual when nothing in particular is happen ¥ hyayt 7} ; ing, bu hat the fact of sensational ac ] tivity at once calls for explanation. On the Stock Exchange the eontrary is true. Nobody ever thinks, when th stock market is stirred into violent com motion, of asking why should be No prices moving financial critic ever heads an article Activity, and proceeds to dis cuss his topic as in itself the perplex ing subject of the day. But columns o inquiry, and conjecture ha argument, been published under the heading Dul hess. In a measure, this attitude is mere re flection of the impatience of speculators at the absence of any such sharp fluc- favor quick profits to But it more ra- when it is the fact that not only are price fluctuations tuations as will g00d guessers. has a tional excuse based on narrow, but that actual purchases cially by the are abnormally small. espe outside investing public, The total of 127,- 000 shares sold on Tuesday of last week the New York Stock Exchange the smallest of any day since the close of last July. It was not far above the smallest day’s trading of 1911—the 80,- July 14—or the 70,800 shares of July 3, 1908, which is the low- full day’s record in fifteen That small day of last week followed a week whose total transactions the smallest of any corresponding week since 1903. Thus Dulness is at what unusually on was 500 shares of est years. were all conspicuous events some just now known ‘The natural Nation and it is enough that explana ions should be asked 4 common an ve Ss that professional traders on tl floor « rh. ng 0 a £ i } ip the b I if ia > i Debit nto ha it I na ( but i t I t ry { i I f I i xX \ dence, and the coming in ! | il ould wake up 5 prob hy the ou r or sell inher seel to be t ers to the questiol e f and most familiar is the politica ta Whether Taft will ites hether he can be elected if het s reélection would good thing or a bad thing Roosevelt's intrusion is a n cause of his excessively d ( ul speech or a matter i 1 il because he denounces t St | prosecution; whether, if VW I Democratic nomination, radical or too unstable, an¢ et he does not get it, somebody still radical may not ru all the i iderations which may easily ake real investor pause I quite p that t ourse of ind nd p perit vill be dul p nominated o1 lected Bu I high financial quart D irgelv formulated ill = ( nee percolate Oo t } ! orld), there nd obstinat claratior ary To that extent, t ) i no mplaining ! 0 Duin i ther " le it \ ewhat similal ! i n the cond exp i the Trust prosecutior tion on rail iv rate advance and the tariff leg ition are the cause of t out af sub apathy A good case might be made out for the argument that all these things were exaggerated a influence on prosperity, or that, at any rate, they have been discounted. But, on the oth- er hand, important financiers are yn record as proclaiming impetuously that three paralyze all had a gramme of the influence vere bound to these activity, and their predic- hand in shaping the tions public It might be remarked of the two. ex- planations already noticed that the ab- sence of any continuous decline in prices be construed as reassuring It that can would seem to mean the public in tends to keep what securities it has al- ready The third explanation, less fre quently heard, is somewhat more far reaching, since it involves the query whe ther prices of stocks and merchandise are really low or not Some commodi ties—cotton and steel, for instance seem to be heap, « nt p ‘ ol wtto ed gl hh 4 dities a Fel ; i i «Al | 1) } i he H Miffl \W i ! i I iH ‘ Barir M | | ‘) | Vl : Reerbo Mi 7 e1 Be i KK Beth ] M the \ ( Eh q Ber ol ’ ' Be juet, B. The Pr and alu (G Mac iA s T { i bridge Mar i" } oO | ration Edited | LR. B N. W Hel Ameri Dost Divina ¢ Englis? ree } - Frowde Da M.0O. The Stor Delattre Floris ber from the Origins to tury Frowd Delattre, Floris Re Félix Alcan -) ~ 1 ' i King ( $1 af {, : ' !

Page 28

x The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2435 Ditman, N. E. Home Hygiene and Preven- tion of Disease. Duffield. $1.50 net. Eucken, R. The Problem of Human Life. Translated by W. 8. Hough and W. R. B. Gibson. Scribner. $2 net. Farnol, Jeffery. My Lady Caprice. Mead. $1 net Forbush, W. B. D. Appleton. $1.50 net. Foulke, W. D. Dorothy Day; politan Press. $1.25 net, Freeman, M. E. W The odd, Mead. $1.20 net Granger, Grace. The Cosmopolitan Press $1. Groves, W. H. The Rational Memory. ond edition. Cosmopolitan Press. net. Haines, Dodd, The Coming Generation. Maya. Cosmo- each. Butterfly House. Light of the Gods. Sec- $1.35 D. Fi. The Return of Pierre: Tale of 1870 Holt. $1.25 net. Halsey, R. V. lcrgotten Books of the Amer- lean Nursery. Boston: Goodspeed & Co. $4 net Hammer, V. P. The United States Govern- ment Neale Publishing Co. $1.25 net. Harvard College Observatory Annals. Vol. LXI, Part Ill, A Statistical Investigation of Cometary Orbits, by W. H. Pickering; Vol. LVI, No. VI, Stars Having Pecullar Spectra, by W. P. Fleming. Haskin, F. J. The American Government. Philadelphia: Lippincott. $1 net, Haydon, A. L. The Trooper Police of Aus- tralia. Chicago: McClurg Hodges, Arthur. The Essential Dodd, Mead $1.30 net Honan, J. H. Handbook to Medical Europe. Philadelphia: Blakiston $1.50 net. Hornung, E. W Fathers of Men. ner. $1.30 net Jacks, L. P. Among the 91.35 net. Jepson, Edgar. Pollyooly: a Romance. dianapolis: Bobbs-Merrill. $1.25 net. Johnson, T. M Ship Wiring and Fitting. Van Nostrand. 75 cents net Jones, Katharine The Man Who Reaps. Desmond FitzGerald. $1.20 net. Jordan, M. H. Vagrant Verses; The Studio Baby. $1, $1, $1.25 net, A Thing Scrib- Idolmakers. Holt. In- Sidney; Cosmopolitan Press. eacn. ‘*A book that is one of a thou- sand, both for its truth to human nature and literary excellence,’ is what the Boston Transcript called L. P. Jack's stories, “Mad Shepherds.” This au- thor is thought to have written a new and similar book in his Among the Idolmakers $1.35 net. By mall, $1.46. Henry Holt & Co. wits. Studies in Wistory, Economics and Public Law Bdited by the Paoulty of Political Sotence of Columbia University. THE RICARDIAN SOCIALISTS By ESTHER LOWENTHAL, Ph.D., Assistant in Economics, Smith College. | Keet, A. E. Hands Across the Equator. Savage, B. A. Old English Libraries. Chi- New York: The Author. cago: McClurg. Fennerly, 8. J. The Story of Sam Tag. Scudder, V. D. Shorter English Poems. Cosmopolitan Press. $1, Edited from the College Entrance Re- Kimball, G. 8. Providence in Colonial quirements in English. Chicago: Scott, Times. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $6.50 Foresman. net. Scudder, V. DL. Socialism and Character. King, C. A. Constructive Carpentry. Amer- Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.50 net, ican Book Co. 70 cents. Serl, E. In Fableland. Boston: Silver, Lancaster, Hewes. The One and the Other. Burdett. 60 cents. Boston: Small, Maynard, Serl, E. W. The Laughter of Jesus. Neale Lémonon, E. L’Europe et la Politique Publishing Co. $1 net. britannique (1882-1911). Paris: Félix Severance, F. H. Studies of the Niagara Alcan. Frontier. Buffalo (N. Y.) Historical So- Leveridge, B. G Appreciation of Art. ciety. $4 net. Granville, O.: The Author. Shakespeare, Tudor edition. Henry VIII, Linebarger, C. E. Text-book on Physics. edited by C. G. Dunlap. Macmillan. 35 Boston: Heath. cents net. Litsey, E. C. The Man from Jericho. Slosson, A. T. A Local Colorist. Scribner. Neale Publishing Co. $1.50. 75 cents net. Mackaye, Percy. Yankee Fantasies: Five Spender, J. A. The Comments of Bagshot One-Act Plays. Duffield. $1.25 net. (Second Series). Holt. $1.25 net. Macmillan, Donald. A Short History of the Scottish People. Doran. $3 net. Maeterlinck, M. Death. Dodd, Mead. $1 net. Miles, A. H. The New Anecdote Book. Thomas Whittaker. $1.50. Nassau, R. H. Where Animals Talk: West African Folk Lore Tales. Boston: Badger. $1.60 net. Nemuan, B. Paul, Roddles. London: Mur- ray. Packard, Winthrop. Literary Pilgrimages of a Naturalist. Boston: Small, Maynard. 2 net. Perry R. B. Present Philosophical Ten- dencies. Longmans. $2.60 net. Petrie, G. L. Israel’s Prophets. Neale Publishing Co. $1.25 net. Prentys, E. P. German for Daily Use. W. R. Jenkins Co. 50 cents net. Rexford, E. E. Amateur Garden-Craft. Philadelphia: Lippincott. $1.50 net. Robbins, M. H. Truant from Heaven. Bos- ton. Badger. $1 net. Rubber Industry: Report of the Proceed- ings of the International Rubber Con- gress, London, 1911. London: Interna- tional Rubber and Allied Trades Exhi- bition. Spivey, T. S. The Seven Sons of Baily- hack. Cosmopolitan Press. $1. Starr, C. A. The Underworld and the Up- per. Eaton & Mains. $1 net. Stone, J. S. The Passion of Christ. Long- mans. Stranathan, May. The Huff Case. Boston: Badger. 75 cents net. |Strindberg, August. Plays. Translated, with introduction, by Edwin Bjérkman. Scribner. $1.50 net. Thomas, A. C. A History of the United States. New edition. 2 vols. Jewish Fress Publishing Co. Thorne, Guy. The Drunkard. Sturgis & Walton. $1.35 net. Tolstoi, Leo N. The Living Corpse: A Dra- ma. Trans. by Mrs. E. M. Evarts. Phil- adelphia: Brown Bros. $1 net. Trepoff, Ivan. He That Is Without Sin Cosmopolitan Press. $1.50. Wallis-Tayler, A. J. Refrigeration, Cold Storage and Ice-making. Third edition, revised. Van Nostrand. $4.50 net. Webster, W. F. English for Secondary Schools. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. % cents. Whetham, W. C. D., and C. D. Heredity and Society. Longmans. THE LIFE STORY OF J, PIERPONT MORGAN By CARL HOVEY Crown 8vo. Illustrated. $2.50 net, postpaid $2.66. This accurate biography, contain- ing “inside” information never be- fore in print, brings the record of Mr. Morgan’s life into the year 1911, and chronicles his early be- ginnings and immense achieve- ments in the world of business. It presents the commanding person- ality of a great man of affairs and patron of the arts, and is engross- ing to the general reader and in- forming to the financier. Seo. Paper Covers, $1.00. IBRAHIM PASHA: Grand Vizier ‘of Suleiman the Magnificent STURGIS & WALTON CO. 81-832 Bast 27th Street, New York By HESTER DONALDSON JEN- KINS, Ph.D., Former Professor of History in the American College for Girls, Constantinople 8vo. Paper Covers, $1.00 LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., NEW YORK A New Presentation of @ Beloved Author ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON IN CALIFORNIA BY KATHERINE D. OSBOURNE. Outdoor Philosophy The Meditations of a Naturalist By Stanton Davis Kirkham Crown 8vo. $1.50 net. (By mail $1.65) A protest against life as it is lived by the majority to-day, a slavish pursuit of worthless ideals that impoverish the soul. The author dwells on the contrast, which Nature evokes, between her own sublime harmony and the discord and strife and ugli- ness of life in the teeming cen- tres of population. NEW YORK DICTIONARY OF AVIATION By ROBERT MORRIS PIERCE 287 pages. Cloth $1.40, postpaid $1.45 DOUBLEDAY, PAGE&CO., Garden City, L. I. Illustrated, $2.00 net. At All Bookstores. A. ©. MeCLURG & Co., Publishers, Chieago A. S. Clark, Peekskill, N. Y., is a osm and seller of books, magazines, and pam- phiets it ‘AMERICANS: An Impression pression| By Alexander Francis Inspiring and Informative.

Page 29