The Nation 1912-02-08: Vol 94 Iss 2432

Page 1

{ ’ T LIS KAY UNIY. Ur Mn FEB 9 1912 Me. | The fation VOL. XCIV.—NO. 2432 THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 1912) ffome: PRICE TEN CENTS *at. Office Syndicalism and Labor By Sir ARTHUR CLAY, Bart. One volume, 7 '4 in. x 5 in. $2.25 net A valuable book on the beginnings and rise to favor of the “General Strike” as Labor’s most deadly weapon, including some account of the French “Syndicats Ouvriers” which initiated it. The principal so-called “General Strikes’’ of the past few years in France, Sweden, Italy, and Spain are de- scribed and their results noted; while the effect of the new political power sought and obtained by the Unions Is forecasted. A most timely and informing book, written in a temperate and judicial spirit. The Pilgrims’ Way FROM WINCHESTER TO CANTERBURY By JULIA CARTWRIGHT ( Mrs. Ady) New and Revised Edition. Illustrated by 8 colored plates, 8 half-tones and a large number of line drawings, all specially made for this volume by A. H. Hallam Murray, One volume, 82 in. x 622 in. $5.00 net A picturesque description of the ancient road still known as The Pilgrims’ Way, along which for nearly four hundred years the pilgrims to the renowned slirine of St. Thomas of Canterbury (Thomas A Becket) traveled from Winchester to Canterbury. The author knows her ground thoroughly, its history past and present, and takes her readers with her into the heart of the most beautiful and storied part of England. Mr. Hallam Murray’s admirable drawings give an excellent idea of the old house, ancient ruing and the lovely scenery through which the old road zigzags from village to village. The Ideals of Indian Art By E. B. HAVELL,’ C.LE. Formerly Principal of the Indian Government School of Art and Keeper of the Calcutta Art Gallery. Author of “Indian Sculpture and Painting,” etc. Illustrated with 33 plates from photographs. One volume, 10 in. x 7 in, $5.00 net This is a very original and very comprehensive introduction to the study of the main branch of Indian Art, namely Indian sculpture. The author maintains that the reason Europeans consider Hindu sculptures to be fantastic or preposterous ig that the religious beliefs, legends and hopes symbolized in them are not taken into consideration by the Euro- pean critic. Here the author focusses the principal achievement of Hindu plastic art together with the leading re- ligious ideas of Hindu mythology which that art expressed, so that a clear perception of the relation between the two is possible to the reader. The plates are admirable examples of the photographic art. The French Ideal: Pascal, Fenelon and Other Essays By Madame DUCLAUX $2.50 net Madame Duclaux, wife of the celebrated Director of the Pasteur Institute in Paris, has already won distinc tion in letters over two other signatures, A. Mary F. Robinson and Madame Darmestetter. Well known as a writer of both prose and verse in her adopted language, French, and for her unusual power of expression in English, she Is the ideal interpreter of the great French writers of the past generation for English speaking readers. The four essays are on Pascal, Fenelon, Buffon, and Lamartine. The Cult of Incompetence By EMILE FAGUET Translated by Miss Beatrice Barstow. $1.50 net This work has attracted widespread attention in France, and exhibits many of the dominant tendencieg of the democracy of the present day to discourage the highest talent in all the principal walks of life, and to en- courage mediocrity and incompetence, to the ultimate detriment of the nation and national character. E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY, 31 West 23d Street, New York

Page 2

—e —_— The Nation WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 18665. [En ed t the New j k City Post Ofice ae The N n ed ! vned by the New York Evening Post ¢ Oswald Garrison Villard, P 1 W im J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Flr More I r Ha 1 deWolf Fuller, As sista I Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in eny pe f the United States or Mexico; to Canada $3.50 | foreton untries comprised in the Poa I e $4.00 ‘ . HE NATION, Bow 704, New York Put ion Office 20 Vesey Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. TI l2 E A i I oe iblican Prog ives 126 r I i of British Trad 127 I , H 5 127 i Healt 128 SPrt ! LES I ae t Italia H 12% It ] ( I r Q of Suffrage l I ! 1 Alti ] Portrait f Bentivoglio t Law Dela \ i rf Pe rt 133 LITE! I Lnferos ind Other Poems ( f Fr ‘ The Sailor Who iH riled and Other Poems rhe f 1) t The City of the Helen of Troy and Other | es of Courage and Other i !’ The Ballad of the Whit Hor The Dream of Al- f ! An Epie of the Navy Ameri- 1 the Beautiful and Other Poems rhe Upper Trail 133 } Giold rt Search Part I ue Lo 135 hauhl 136 ( t her 136 ‘ } and His Woman Friends 136 ( Currency Reprints 137 | 1 Realit 138 N l } ‘ ‘ | 141 I) 1 i 142 5 4 I ’ t | i? | ‘ i4 ih \\ 146 . f The Nation ofMy be procured to Paria at BR tano'’s 17 Avenue de l'Opéra in Stevens & Brown 4 Trafalgar The Nation | Vol. 94, No. 2432 Educational HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 25 Park Street, Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 FifthAve.,.NewYork 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland S14 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd., LosAngeles 920 Sav. Bk. Bd.,.Denver 345 Wright Bik. Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, Prop. Vincent B, Fisk, Mgr. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Knows how, Twenty-one years of successful ex- ‘ in bringing together good teachers and good schoo!s 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. YY. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself GARDENS AND THEIR MEANING By DORA WILLIAMS $1.00. book and a timely one for in children’s home Definite directions are given for the selection and laying out of the ground, the care of the soil, the choice of plants, and the way to make them grow. The most scien- tific methods of modern farming are adapted to children’s use Through- out the book is readable and extreme- ly attractive, and filled with suggest- ive illustrations MEIER’S PLANT STUDY Revised In Biflex Plant A new those interested or school gardens. Edition just published! Binder Study 75 cents 25 cents Sheets (1-36) GINN AND COMPANY 29 Beacon Street Boston > Songs We Like to Sing \ collection of universally loved songs—songs that will hold a perma- nent place in the hearts of the Amer- ican people. Selected through the ad- vice of leading Music Supervisors all over the country. Ideal for schools, and societies Price 35 cents. SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY assemblies, clubs, Bound in boarda. AN IMPORTANT BOOK Just Published! THE FULL RECOGNITION OF JAPAN - ng a detailed account of the economic yrogress of the Japanese Empire to 1911. By ROBERT P. PORTER Medium Svo, with seven colored maps, $4.00 “Just the book for a traveller to the Far East to carry with him and study on the journey, if he wishes to take an intelligent survey of the interest- ing p-ople whom he is to visit.”"— Times Literary Supplement (Eng.). For Sale by all Booksellers, or will be sent postpaid by the publishers on receipt of price. Oxford University Press American Branch 35 West 32d Street, New York BEST facilities for supplying American German English BOOK S Italian French Spanish Catalogue free Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 years. 30-32 West 27th St, New York AGENTS FOR COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PRESS. cals is a force to be reckoned with. The Socialism INTERNATIONAL SOCIALIST RE- VIEW, monthiy, $1.00 a year, is indispensable to the student Who would understand contemporary Socialism Three months, 25c. CHARLES H. KERR & CO., 118 W. Kinzie St., Chicago. FOREIGN BOOKS BOOKS—All matter on what subject; Send for catalogue T HNI T SCHOENHOF BOOK CO. pr scooalle 128 Tremont Street, AUTHORS BOSTON, MASS. out-of-print books supplied, no write me, stating books ROSTON NEW YOR . “AGO wanted: I can get you any book ever published; _ : FORs CHBCA when In England, call and inspect my stock ef 50,000 rare books. BAKER’S GREAT BOOKSHOP, 3 John Bright St., Birmingham, England. DANTE’S DIVINA COMMEDIA cnn, ene to ‘lites i On ri Send for price lists. Edited with Introduction, Arguments, and Notes utograph WALTER B. BENJAMIN, By C. H. GRANDGENT Letters 225 Fifth Av., New York. Profeasor in Harvard University. Pub.“*THE COLLECTOR,” $1 a yr. Vol. I—ENF BRNO ....cecccccess Price, $1.25 Vol. Il—-PURGATORIO (Just published) $1.25 D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers AMERICANS: An Impression BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO By Alexander Francis schoole and colleges everywhere 155 pocket size List prices, cloth, 35c. per leather, The. per vol (Special prices oF and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE, Thomas Y.Crowell &Co.,New Yor} THE GLORY THAT WAS GREECE A survey of Hellente culture and civitieation By J. C. STODART, M.A. 200 Ulustrations, Cloth, gilt top. 87.60 net. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Publishers, Phila. TWO COMPETENT rience! stenographers and typewriters sextet with bookkeeping: college train liege eraduate vreferred Apoly to Recording Dean Pa 1B "ANTED : able to r requieite letter only eee. Bryan Mawr, by n Mawr Col ryvo 4 ; 120 THE NATION will be sent to any address for several weeks WITHOUT CHARGE The Nation Vesey St., New York City

Page 3

Feb. 8, 1912] The Nation ili THE JOURNAL OF JOURNAL OF RACE DEVELOPMENT |) RELIGIOUS PSYCHOLOGY UDING ITS Founded in 1910 by Clark University and ted by a Anthropological and Sociological Aspects large board representing foreign countries and leading American Universities; gives the views of experts on the G. STANI HALL and ALEXANDER PF. CHAMRERLAID world problems of race advance ~ - i . Lendea I t er the l licated n t th ugh CONTENTS FOR JANUARY, 1912 “oc enigma Sia esa er eee RELATIONS OF JAPAN AND THE UNITED STATES Sy al tent en t I s of box i per ] By David Starr Jordan, LL.D., President of Stanford literature University ee : 215 ratu JAPAN REVISITED AFTER THIRTY YEARS By Thomas C. Mendenhall, Sc.D LL.D., f , fessor in the Imperial University, Tokyo . 224 . : S . 01? Mw. Bh Boney cece CONTENTS FOR JANUARY, 1912 By Jokichi Takamine, Se.D., President Nl ( I of New York ...... - : : 2 THE FAMILY OF NATIONS IDEA AND JAPAN > By George Grafton Wilson LL.D Professor Inter . national Law in Harvard University 246 i ~ ! GEOGRAPHICAL ENVIRONMENT AND JAPANESE CHAR Pa \ ACTER a By Elisworth Huntington. Ph.D., Assistant P f id Geography in Yale University - I oO} rla ) 1 ] j CATHOLIC PORTUGUESE MISSIONS OF ANGOLA . . By Rev. C. J. Rooney, €.S.Sp., recently Procurator General y and 8S of the Portuguese Missions of Angola 282 lexands Be oO} . in ¢ ( THE ANGLO-SAXON IN INDIA AND THE PHILIPPINES - r , ; By Theodore H,. Boggs, Ph.D., Dartmouth College 309 me SOrwN ary re A CHINA AND HER ROLE IN HUMAN HISTORY I t Bib By Alexander F. Chamberlain, Ph.D.,. Professor in Clark R - ae University ; » , I R we seats j NOTES AND REVIEWS 3453 PERIODICAL L Issued Quarterly. $2.00 a year Issued Quarterly. $3.00 a year LOUIS N. WILSON, Publisher, CLARK UNIVERSITY, WORCESTER, MASs. English Literature IN ACCOUNT WITH RELIGION By Edward M,. Chapman “Mr. Chapman’s work is certain- ly fascinating; his general treat- ment of a theme often controver- sial is remarkably free from bias or prejudice.”—The Academy (Lon- don). $2.00 net. Postpaid $2.17. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY BOSTON NEW YORK A Thrilling Tale is RAYTON: ABackwoods Mystery By THEODORE GOODRIDGE ROBERTS For sale everywhere. Net $1.25. L. C. PAGE & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON The Story of the Famous Donner Party THE EXPEDITION OF THE DONNER PARTY AND ITS TRAGIC FATE By ELIZA P. HOUGHTON With pictures from rare photographs. $2.00 net At All Bookstores. A. C. MeCLURG & Co., Publishers, Chicago NOW READY HE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK FOR 1911 A Record of Events and Progress in Every Department of Human Activity N fariy goo pages. I ui indexed, Sma 7 7 Semi-tlexible covers. D. APPLETON & COMPANY, Publishers 35 West 32d Street, NEW YORK F. M. HOLLY Authors’ and Publishers’ Representa‘ ive Circulars sent upon request. 156 FifthAv., New Y ork Reading Case for the Nation. To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound ip cloth. with The Nation stamped on the side in gold Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents. A notable brief for democracy that everyhedy DICTIONARY OF ught to read,’ says Mr. OswalLo Gannison VILLano HARD WORDS One Way Out: A Middle-Class New Englander Emigrates to America By ROBERT MOKRKIS PIERCE By “WILLIAM CARLETON,” 645 pages Cloth $1.26, postpaid $1.32 The moat notable hook of owr day ' ’ Fifth Printing. $1.20 net; by mall, 61.22. LANGUAGES COMPANY, 143 W. 47th St, N.Y. Sund-tar demaaien- enatiey Oe Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston.

Page 4

The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2432 Interesting New Macmillan Books ON POLITICAL, SOCIAL, AND EDUCATIONAL MATTERS , “The New Democracy” By Walter E. Weyl, Ph.D. You are entering on a Presidential campaign more tensely interesting than any since that of 1860. Into the exciting situation many forces enter:—the presence of the -“plutocracy” in politics, the growing solidarity of the labor vote, the woman suffrage movement, and a social consciousness waking and groping for “a new democracy.” If you are interested at all in the political and social situation, you will find that this book clarifies much which is confusing, expresses your feeling and outlines your program of democracy—political, social, and industrial—more definitely and forcibly than you have ever seen it done in print before. Ready this week. Cloth, 12mo, $2.00 net. The Modern Woman’s Readings on Parties and Rights Movement Elections in the United States By K. Schirmac er By Chester Lloyd Jones rransiated from the German by Dr. Cart C. of the University of Wisconsin. A discussion of Eckuanrpt, of Colorado. Cloth, $1.50; by mail, $1.62. the history of parties, of their defects and pro- posed remedies, Cloth, $1.60 net; by mail, $1.72. Democratic England Documents on the State-wide By Percy Alden, M.P. Initiative, Referendum and Recall A concise statement of the important social prob- By Professors Charles A. Beard lems which the voter in Kngland faces to-day. and Bird E. Schultz In press. Probably $1.50 net. A convenient compendium of current discussion of typical statutes and frequently advocated 5 schemes. Cloth, $2.00 net; by mail, $2.14. Socialism and the Ethics of Jesus ; By Henry C. Vedder Great Educators of Three Centuries An interesting consideration of the points of like- By Frank P. Graves, Ph.D. ness and difference between the ethics of Jesus Professor of the History of Education in the Ohio and the socialism of to-day. ° State University, Author of “A History of Edu- Cloth, $1.50 net; by mail, $1.62. cation.” Cloth, 12mo, $1.10 net. ; Outline of a Course of Study in the Social Aspects of Education Philosophy of Education By Professor Irving King By John A. MacVannel, Ph.D. of the State University of Iowa. A book of sources Professor of the Philosophy of Education, Teach- and original discussions of the social, as distinct ers College, Columbia University. from psychological, phases of education. In press. Cloth, 12mo, ninety cents net. The Record of a City: A Social Survey of Lowell By George F. Kenngott. (/llustrated. Decorated cloth, 12mo, probably $3.00 net. An explici* account of the industrial changes of twenty years and of present industrial conditions. NEW VOLUMES OF GENERAL LITERATURE AND POETRY Tennyson and his Friends Daily Bread Edited by Hallam Lord Tennyson By Wilfrid Wilson Gibson Contributed to by many of the poet’s friends. Dramatic poems, poignantly presenting undercur- Iltuagrated. Cloth, 8vo, $3.00 net. rents of lives which, on the surface, are merely earning daily bread. . loth, $1. t; , $1.35. By James Harvey Robinson, Ph.D. The Hill of Vision Professor of Modern History, Columbia Univer- By James Stephens sity. With other Essays in Historical Criticism. Author of “Insurrections.” Nearly Ready. Cloth, $1.25 net; by mail, $1.35. resistes “THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “#,54h,2v — |

Page 5

The NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 8, 1912. The Week The President’s recommendations re lating to Alaska are the outcome of a great deal of thought on his part and on that of the able and efficient Secre- tary of the Interior, who has made a special study of the conditions existing in that Territory. The establishment of a leasing system for the Alaska coal lands has long been plainly indicated as the proper solution of that problem. It is clearly recommended both by Gov- ernmental experience in Australia, New Zealand, and Nova Scotia, and by the analogy of the leasing arrangements under which coal mines in private own- ership are worked in this country; and it is difficult to see on what ground fail- ure of Congress to act promptly to this end could be excused. In regard to the creation of a Government-owned railway for opening up these resources, through the acquisition of a road already par- tially constructed, and through its com- pletion and continuation, there may nat urally be some hesitation; but, in the peculiar circumstances of the Alaskan the certainly has situation, proposal much to commend it. Finally, there is, and long has been, crying need for a better form of government than that under which Alaska has been struggli ing along and the President’s renewed rec- ommendation for the institution of a form of commission government should have the immediate and earnest atten- tion of Congress Two other recommendations of wide interest are made in the same message; that for the national inquiry high prices and that for the institution inauguration of an inter- into the question of of a comprehensive inquiry into labor conditions in this country. The former will, we have little doubt, be adopted without much The latter proposes a step of great importance, but discussion. one for which the time is evidently ripe. Properly conducted, the investigations of a commission which should look into the vaet and complex labor questions that have been growing more and more press- ing with the development of our indus- tries and the increasing concentration of industrial power ought to be of great value merely for the information it will elicit; and it is not too much to hope that in some vital respects they would result in beneficent practical recom- mendations. But everything depends on the character and ability of the investi- gating commission and on the spirit 1a That the “non-partisan, which its work is undertaken. be thorough, patient, and courageous” is the investigation should President's characterization of the qual- ity desired; and unless it is to come un to this description, it had better not be undertaken at all. Two reasons why Gov. Wilson cannot be elected President and ought not to be invite attention. One reason is, ac- cording to the rumor, that Grover Cleve- land did not like Mr. Wilson and said so which is believed to be in a letter extant. The other reason is, according to George Fred Williams of Massachu- setts, that Gov. Wilson admired Grover His- person, Cleveland, and treats him in his tory as “a somewhat godlike and finds nothing to criticise in his en- political career.” If Grover Cleve- Woodrow Wilson tire as Wilson admired Wilson would have been doubly damned in the land had much as admired him, eyes of George Fred Williams. And if Woodrow Wilson’s opinion of Grover Cleveland were as unfavorable as Mr Cleveland’s opinion of him Wilson ould have been doubly darhned, as far as the Sun is concerned. The two ends of the same stick are thus brought into masterly application. As to the possi- ble merit involved in Woodrow Wilson’ speaking in praise of a man ho had no praise for Wilson that is a ques tion of speculative morals into ich it is probable that neither George Fred Williams nor the in cares to enter Four weeks fre Tuesday the final vote is to be taken in the Senate on the rati- fication of the arbitration treaties with Great Britain and France. There seems to be no doubt that the fixing of this date by the Senate means the adoption of the treaties as amended—or, if you please, interpreted—by the Lodge reso- lution. No one can doubt that the adop- tion of the treaties will be a great step Nation a = ‘in the progress of the cause of arbitra- tion as a prevention of war. The steady advance the treaties have made towards acceptance by the Senate is due in very great part to the remarkable manifesta- tions of interest that have come from all parts of the country in the shape of pe If Democratic Senators who feel disposed titions and letters. there are any to withhold their assent, out of a desire to prevent the carrying out of a Repub lican President's plan, they will be mak- ing a great mistake; for it is quite plain that the force behind the treaties is not but the unmistak Presidential urging, able pressure of public opinion assertion of Secretary Stimson’s recent in his speech advocating a rebate Panama tolls on American shipping, that the British the same thing at Suez,is sharply chal- yovernment does virtually lenged by the Shipping World of Lon- don. Mr. Stimson stated that the “sub- paid to the Peninsular & Orien- sidies” tal the Suez Canal Company—the ncipal line using pr “amount to nearly six- sevenths of the tolls.” On this point he is flatly contradicted by the periodical referred t hich aff ( that e o not pay subsidi or t ull’; ind (2) that “not a shilling paid to Peninsular & Oriental Cor or ly other line of stea t f the National | ] juer, I il e or ( 0 nt of S ( r f cour British uy paid ours, fo ir! } ] 1 if I at { ] t vice, but it yf Llue received ! t (a it. nt f o! G I nt I s out in « te t a twenty-t kn t i out n tir of RB i lut no rela- tion to Canal tol It obvious that Secreta S n uld have more refull informed himss Secretary Meyer's petulant scolding of the Democratic caucus because of its vote against new battleships includes no argument of novelty or value He speaks, for instance, of the extent of our coast lines and the necessity of de- fending Hawali, Cuba, and the Philip- pines. But adequately to defend these

Page 6

1 24 j , , \ i } ( I ‘ f | fer d d to I ( vot 1 | ’ ‘ | i \ “ » dt ind ’ t ‘ oO I oy Ru i More ia h | ntec Par Car ] ’ ; para \ d A! i f deftendlr t ited } ‘ hir \\ thi} t ‘ i r f o launcl aga " ‘ i gre ( i fleet Ee ! ti ’ ‘ s at | lel i s ad t powe ‘ il they might be in ipp t Judg Bregy fo ilatable trutl In uphold of Contractor MeNichol ‘ft t ‘ So 23.¢ upon the ‘ the city was legally bound the Jud f said 1 Co en al | nr ! . ¢ +} r ! and i 7 pe If t lk not r n ¢€ } la tl j f that glect r) ! ] for faithles nal, or reck le off ale lies n the ballot-box While | il legislators can be punished for la the joint act of a legislative bod innot be set aside by the court, even if t in be clearly shown that the act i ! of bad faith and bad public policy The ting of the decision lies in the condition that the city ig facing as a result of that neglect which the Judge rebukes So heavy are the obligations left by the machine as a legacy to the Blankenburg Administration that a per- manent loan of $10,000,000 is necessary for needed improvemenrts—this in face of the fact that the city’s funded debt Nation ‘Che —————_ nereased under Mayor Reyburn’s four vears from $66,! .000 to $ 109,800,000, ] a signed editorial in the Boston ! Robert A. Woods, the well-known tlement worker, admits that the rela- e absence of distress shows that on ( the employees at Lawrence n receivil sufficiently high s to enable them to provide for vants, and ev to lay something isid for emergencies. What more one possibly demand? But he » point out that this condition obta inde scale of weekly earnings h fairly shocking to the mind I ly every conservative American.” Instead of being able to adopt the stand of living which we know from the volul ssertions of protected manufac- tur one of the great blessings of high tariff rates, these Lawrence opera tives e forced to introduce into New England “the lowest scale of European vorking class existence.” Yet we have been told over and over again that pro- tective duties exist only to enable Amer can workingmen to live on the fat of the land There may be greater legal validity than at first appears in the argument of the Steel Corporation lawyers that its organization has been so long “acqui- esced in” by the Government as proper- ly to be immune from attack. Careless persons may be disposed to say that there can be no vested right in violation of violation is for the courts to pass upon. The Steel Corporation lawyers are, in effect, plead- a statute, and that the question of But that is just the point. ing a decision of the highest court in bar of action against them. To be sure, they do not name the Supreme Court, but they adduce one whose authority is When the Government acqui- greater than that of any court. that esced, they mean that the President who they say for seven years held a lit de justice in White unlawful and what was not, had given the House, deciding what was them a handsome certificate of charac- After that, it is sheer impudence to bring ter. if sult against them. not Majestitsbeleidigung No better purpose could be found for a public bequest of a million doliars than that contemplated in the will of'fall from his hands. ’ | Vol. 94. No. 2432 Mrs. Caroline W. Neustadter, which de- votes that sum to the building of homes for the working people of this city. That the exemption from inheritance taxes which the law provides in the case of bequests for charitable objects should manifest. Of different apply in this case seems course, that is an entirely thing from exempting the property in the invested from of fund shall be The particular which taxation. devotion money to this purpose is one of the things most worthy of encouragement as well as commendation. In the hands of the trustees of the fund, assuming that nothing will occur to divert it from this excellent object, will be placed a great opportunity and a great respon sibility. A careful compilation of facts relat- in disposing of York State will be delay Ne Ww ing to judicial murder cases in found in a letter appearing elsewhere in the Nation to-day. Our correspon- dent makes no comment, but the facts speak for themselves. They are taken from the records, and they show that out of 119 instances of appeal in trials for murder in the first degree, there were no less than 80 in which the time intervening between the conviction and the disposal of the case by the Court of Appeals was one year or more. If to this time we add that spent in bring- ing the case to trial in the first place, we see how remote the final disposition of the case must have been from the commission of the crime. All this is terribly wasteful and demoralizing. It does away with a large part of the ef- fect that the whole of prosecu- tion and punishment is designed to pro- process duce. A reform is urgently demanded. Events are forcing President Madero into a policy of repression which opens the way for the charge that his methods are to be in no way different from those o? Porfirio Diaz. But the obvious dis- tinction is that, whereas Diaz had forty years and more in which to develop his conceptions of the proper government for Mexico, Madero is just beginning his trial. The principal indictment against Diaz is not that he began to rule autv- cratically, but that he continued to do so, making no effort to educate the nu- tion against the time when he, Diaz, be- ing but mortal man, must let the reins Conceding that

Page 7

Feb. 8, 1912] Mexico can be ruled only by a strong man, Diaz made no effort to develop an heir-apparent to the throne. For some time to come Madero will have to reckon with the after-effects of the revolution which he himself began. Apparently the Latin-American appetite for guer- rilla warfare cannot be easily satisfied after its long fasting in Mexico. dic turbulence and riot are therefore to Spora- be expected. Only as time goes on can one say whether Madero’s methods are directed towards the best interests of the country or towards selfish ends. Tuesday morning’s dispatches stated that the Unionists are abandoning their announced plan to prevent, by riot and the Rule speech in Belfast this week by Winston This their senses, but it is welcome. their arms, making of a Home Churchill. is a late coming to Appar- ently, leaders have been unable to resist the sterm of ridicule and of protest which has beaten upon them. They did not like being called, with so much “the new Irish rebels.” The Crime,” reason, old was turned against them in the phrase, “Parnellism and form of “Unionism and Crime.” It must be admitted, however, that the militant Ulstermen are not without some excuse. They might allege that they were spur- For the latter have been for the past few weeks red on by English Unionists. making great play with the supposed iniquities of the forthcoming Home Rule bill. er, Mr. Bonar Law, has made a series The new Conservative lead- of rousing speeches, all on this theme; and all the orators of the party have been furbishing up the arguments and appeals and prejudices which they em- ployed with so much effect in 1886 and 1893. stir up so much popular feeling that the Lords will feel justified in throwing Their obvious aim has been to out the Home Rule Dill, the Ministry will be weakened, and a general elec- tion soon brought on which will restore the Conservatives to power. In an article reviewing the condition of real-estate business in the United Kingdom, as shown by the transactions of the year 1911, the London Economist refers to Ireland as having exhibited, far more distinctly than any other part of the things. country, an improved state of “In Ireland,” says the Econo mist, “the magic of property has work- The Nation ed wonders, and the mere fact that the tenants own their lands has produced an enormous increase in agricultural in- dustry and prosperity.” This statement with the observations and of some time past. is in accord narratives visitors to Ireland for The land-purchase leg islation enacted by Parliament after so many years of agitation has amply vin- dicated those who so persistently urg- ed that reform of the system of land tenure was the one most vital need of the country. Foremost among the names of those whose influence was ex erted in behalf of this wise and salu tary policy should be placed that of John Stuart Mill; how much misery and how much political difficulty and dan ger might have been obviated had his counsels been heeded seventy instead of twenty years ago, it is impossible to compute. A friend of the late Henry Labor chere writes that he usually had “that slightly forlorn and wistful cast which comes to the man who began by being funny and must at all costs go on whether he feels funny or not Thi refers, of course, to Mr. Labouchere's speeches in the House of Commons. It is interesting thus to learn that there are English parallels to an experience which has not been uncommon in this country. More than one _ promising Congressional career has been blighted by the reputation early acquired of be- ing a humorous speaker. If a man once makes sport for the House, it will there- after insist that he must always amuse it. or else it will refuse to listen. The classic example, of course, is Proctor Knott, with his famous Duluth speech, which he sought to live down after- wards, but was never able. “Private John” Allen of Mississippi is another instance, though he was able to convey a great deal of useful truth under the guise of laughter. But as a rule, the statesman who is ambitious and who hopes seriously to get the ear of the people, will do well to imitate, though for other reasons, Dr. Holmes’s resolve never to be as funny as he can The reconcillation between the two branches of the House of Braganza is an interesting proof that monarchs sometimes deign to learn from common- Let a Right or Left defeat, ers or Centre taste the bitterness of and, however = 1 ww e ) divided it may have been in the power, it is as a united Opposition at it faces the new Government, which on its part already begins to show sym toms of internal distress. Royal riva however, have never fallen so complete . ly into this beautiful custom. In F Bourbon and never grow! at one another so fi s when there of the Pretender is happiest tion monarchy, and in points to a republic But it requi nothing more than a little calm consid eration to see that it is better to i luke or a Prince, with a reve i nterest in the throne, than an outcast Mere politicians have always known th tinctively, and have profited by) r llingness to make “deals 1 to iit their turn How well the rt ese aspirants for the lost scept i\ asped the idea is shown } ul nouncement that the Pretende t finance the campaign, while t ll furnish the prestige Heartburni: ( r the ret f capital of India fror (‘a 1 ) Delhi had scarcely begun to abat e lore new woes were resoul ng ver Durbar Coronation medal Origin- ally, there were five thousand of t e rare prizes, all for milit fd tinction. Then it , innou! 1 that the number was to be i: an other five thousand for tl} ! k and file. But it wa noon | id t t il medals had gone to ladi« ( n various camps, to cler) ind o yf like prominence. In some piace medal was ladled out thout tl it st ceremony or order As a n quence, heads of departments have ap parently been passed by, and p ons vithout a shred of official position “pra tically had the medal thrown at t In any cage, the civilians ho have been varded by the bestowal of the pre ious bits of metal have been out of al proportion to those in the army who have been similarly blessed, and bad feeling has resulted. The Calcutta / lishman, accordingly, calls for an in tigation. But even if it were p b! to trace the medals, the attempt to take them away from those who have them and give them to thore who want them s a task fraught with peril to any Gov- ernment. It would be much safer ) issue medals to all who apply ! i when everyth ran Spain is a chance for a restor: Bonapartist and Orleanist

Page 8

4 - 126 FUTURE OF REPUBLICAN PROGRES- SIVES. Ex-Senator Allen of Nebraska gives Presidential it as his opinion that the election of this year will lead to the break-up of the Republican Progressive movement. The word “progressive” it- self will, he thinks, disappear ere long from the Republican vocabulary. He expe most of the Progressive Repub- lican leaders to be “reabsorbed” by the party, though he ventures no predic- tion as to what will become of their onstituents. The ex-Senator does not say so, but it is highly probable that he drawing a moral from the expert- ence of the Populist party, of which he was a member. It, too, for a time had its Representatives In the House and a handful of Senators, but in due time it rack be- Some of the Populists went one passed leaving not a away hind way and some another—joining the Republicans or the but Does or the the Democrats Socialists, as case might be as such ceased to exist. Republican the party a similar fate await the Progressives? It is too early toanswer that question confidently, but it is clearly the judg- ment of ob- servers that the Republican Progressive cli- in last competent and impartial movement has already passed its max. The decline evidently set A great deal of the moral force lost year. the cause was obviously when Taft w of Pre with ident as urging reciprocity Progressives, it. For the be- Canada, and the to a man, opposed country that trayal of the most vital principle which the first lay behind and the organization of the Republican They had almost believed this was a from the protests alleged vari- the Progressives President but the ous grievances against the management, chief one was the Payne-Aldrich tariff, and party which they asserted was in violation of solemn pledges to the people and was in pursuance of the old control of the party by a selfish clique that cared no thing for the real desires of the nation On that issue the fight was 1910, as a whole. made in 1909 and in both House and Senate, as well as In the press and The changes were rung on the stump. on the charge that the Republican party had been false to its promises, and that only the Progressivea could be trusted to give any relief from tariff taxes. But the reciprocity agreement with Canada [Vol. 94, No. 2432 was as a sword thrust into the vitals of the Progressive movement; and the at- titude of its leading representatives, un- der the test, was so disappointing as to cause multitudes to lose faith in their consistency or sincerity. And as the hope and life of the whole political dem- onstration depended upon the belief that the men engaged in it would stanchly stand by their convictions, the loss of confidence was instant and marked. Since that of the prominent Progressives has not time the course most been such as to persuade the country that they have either a very clear pol- icy or a wholly disinterested purpose. They have entered upon a period of po- litical uncertainty and even of intrigue. They to know neither their own minds nor what leader to fol- low. Their allegiance to Senator La Follette was but half-hearted from the been broken and have appeared first, and has since flickering, with disastrous results. A dis- patch from Seattle last week announced that the La Follette organization in the State of Washington had disbanded and that its members would at once form Roosevelt clubs in Seattle and seven other Washington cities. The announce- ment of Senator Cummins’s candidacy was itself a sign of the hopelessness of La Follette’s aspirations, and it is not denied that some of the latter’s inti- mate friends were opposed to his recent avowal never, never to withdraw in fa- vor of Roosevelt. Gifford Pinchot’s fail- ure to repeat his Chicago endorsement of La Follette’s candidacy at the Car- negie Hall meeting in this city, after he had prepared a statement for the lo- was also not cal press to that effect, without its significance. In other words, the attitude of that other great Pro- gressive at Oyster Bay had about set- tled the matter when La Follette him- self, by his ill-considered speech on Fri- day before the Periodical Publishers in Philadelphia, gave his candidacy the coup de grice. Nothing has hurt the Progressives so much their apparent readiness to drop La Follette or Cummins and to rush into the arms of Roosevelt, if only that silent gentleman would bid them come to his bosom. Meanwhile, their backing and filling, while perplex- as suddenly ed with doubt, is having a most disturb-| Many of the latter have serious misgivings} parties, has not been in favor: ing effect upon their followers. Progressive faith, especially in the mat- ter of the tariff. They remember how firm a standpatter he was during all his Presidency, and they also recall that the platform of the New York Conven- tion of 1910, which he controlled, sang so low on the subject of tariff abuses as to be well-nigh inaudible. If the Pro- gressives were now to go over to him bodily, it would show that they cared much more to win than to be right or even consistent. And, according to trustworthy reports from the West, all their dilly-dallying is provoking a great deal of dissatisfaction and exas- peration on the part of the Progressive rank and file. In view of the events and tendencies thus hastily outlined, it is not surpris- ing to learn from a foreigner who has for years been making a close study of American politics, that in his judgment the Progressive Republicans have seen their best days as a separate party. He does not, with ex-Senator Allen, count upon their being speedily “reabsorbed.” A few of the leaders, he thinks, will soon align themselves again with the regular Republicans. One or two may go over to the Democratic party. Others may remain for a time in an attitude of sul- len aloofness. But what of the Republi- can voters in the insurgent States? It is probable that they will before long seek new political affiliations. Some will go back to their old party; but the majority will be disposed to vote even this year for a Democrat, provided the candidate be one who strongly appeals to them. Large numbers of them would go for Wilson—a fact which, of course, emphasizes the good political strategy of his nomination. While we think that such a forecast will be found, on the whole, to have much truth in it, and while we consider it probable that the Progressive move- ment will not long remain distinct and vigorous, we would not be thought to disparage the work it has already done. It represented a powerful and useful protest. It was owing to this that the smooth-running machine.in the Senate, particularly, was broken to pieces, and conscientious speaking and voting put on a new footing. It is true, and it is doubtless well, that in this country government by “groups,” as in France or Germany, instead of by two leading that is about the Colonel being sound in the! one reason why the permanence of the

Page 9

Feb. 8, 1912] The Nation pected. Yet their influence will long re- main, amd we shail continue to owe them a debt for having so effectively vin- dicated freedom of action and having held up worthy ideals. THE PERVERSITY OF BRITISH TRADE. The trade figures for 1911 continue the tale of disappointment for those who, some years ago, were so indus- triously building up a case for protec- England, they saw tion in England. plainly, had entered on the down-hill path; she might hold her own for a while, but she had evidently reached the stationary stage, while German trade was forging ahead by leaps and bounds. If Britain was to continue to hold up her head at all, she must join the procession of the protectionist coun- tries whose rejection of the outworn fetich of free trade had paved the way to their national greatness. How pro- tection was going to do this for Eng- land, whose position was so essentially different, was never made any too plain, even if it were granted that the protec- tionist policy was the true explanation of Germany’s commercial rise; but it is difficult to get the wayfaring man to look an argument of this kind in the mouth. Free traders were put on the defensive. Unable to prophesy as glib- ly lowers, they had to content themselves that had not yet been fulfilled, and that the he unfairly chosen, and even if fair would as did Mr. Chamberlain and his fol- with pointing out his prophecies figures on which based them were by no be sufficient to prove his means point. For the rest they planted them- selves squarely on the ground of funda mental principle, and rallied their coun- trymen to their standard by an appeal to reason. That the appeal was success ful is strong testimony to the hold which the free-trade idea has acquired upon the public mind in England. Fortunately, however, the actual course of trade has been such as thor oughly to meet the protectionists on their own ground. The very year in which Chamberlain's agitation first came to the front showed an advance in the volume of exports, the prospec- tive decline of which formed the heart of the protectionist jeremiads; and that advance continued steadily and on a re markable scale until it was checked by Progressives, as such, was not to be ex- the depression following upon the panic of 1907. In 1903, the exports of British products amounted to $1,450,000,000, it- $40,000,000 over the preceding year; the next year self an increase of about broke all previous records, and so did and the the value of exports for 1907 was $2,- the next, and the next, next; 130,000,000, an increase of about 48 per cent. over 1903, although 1903 had itself high-water mark. The 1907, but been almost at years 1908 and 1909 fell below were record years with that exception; with 1910 came a figure breaking all records, and now comes 1911, beating 1910 by $120,000,000. The exports of British products for 1911 reached the enormous total of $2,270,000,000, thus showing an increase of 56 per cent. over the volume of exports of 1903, the year when Mr. Chamberlain's predictions of trade decadence first began to stir up the waters of British politics. It ought in fairness to be pointed out considerable of that this growth must in be prices—the measure ascribed to the rise lessened purchasing power of money; but for the purpose here in view it is not necessary to attempt to measure the degree in which this factor enters into the phenomenon. For the point of the British protectionist’s ar guments has lain fully as much in com- parisons with Germany as in any ass tions about British trade taken it self. Well, let us look at the German figures. The world has resound g with « i tic ( ( it the g th of Ge in ins j nd dé cal il p p ° Ol l ( ga I ol t t exp I oO | n, do (y I re ] i have ne t f t ( ik | d the Ger! ] 1D ) (it il ost ‘ I ( ao t 60.00 ( | p nt.; export fre t Un j aol advanced irom j { 2,150,000,000, r 1s it ° vould considerat ( l t or in termediate years affect the conclusion; there was quite as marked a dip down after the panic of 1907 for Germany as for England. It should be needless to say that to regard the figures of foreign trade as conclusive concerning the pros- the _ 1%"6 perity of either country would be ab- surd; but against those who a few years ago were passing sentence of death on the English free-trade system upon the confident expectation of what these very would prove, the showing is a In character figures complete answer. view of the truly wonderful of German activi- ties in the domains of industry, finance, and commerce, and considering the ex- traordinary development which England hed so much earlier attained, the fig- ures present a state of facts that is truly remarkable. Apart from the interest that attaches to these facts, especially in view of their bearing on the prospective devel opment of British politics, it is worth vhile to draw attention to them as a arning against the cor on tendency to draw larg conclusior fr i neagre statistical basis. It is aston! ing how prone to this weakness ar many men whose general ental pow ought to be a sufficient defence against it. Much, of course, is due to the wish being father to the thought; we pour upon a few figures that seem to point our way, and make the most of tl! But this is by no means adequa to account for the childishr that ) ften exhibited in t D r en of ré p t il ta t Mr. Char 1 more tha " d but there ‘ i} ! , P n 4 amy] I onl THE RIGHT TO “HAPPINI Some months ago, a great deal of ace was given in the newspapers to t apade of two young people who « tered upon the experiment of defying what many clever young writers are in habit of designating, in an easy-g»

Page 10

Ss ing fashion, as the “conventions” of so- ciety, lies the idea of the individual's ciet Last Sunday the experiment came end here in New York in the shape tt. an of a double suicide. To elevate this piti ful little tragedy to the rank of a matter nt ould be to as ign hich 1t i8 in no nterest at as been attracted to th marticu ‘ ome attention to cer- node or ft ight and nance to the no to be mad L£oing fall that the world is that into a form should implies the most in human society |} than a passing convention ere use of the word in this wa exercise, upon thousands ned mind an insidious influ the thing can go is beet an ex falls ited when such perhaps, pression as “bourgeols convention” iite naturally from the pen of a gifted writer, as if the long result of fruit of of groping, the dear-bought ages il and suffering and were nothing but a petty arrangement among little people who have no vision beyond their cash-accounts Behind marriage, as behind similar views in re- this view of the sanctions of gard to other institutions of civilized so- The Nation [ Vol. 94, Many marriages are individuals think that by disregarding the bonds of mar- find vhich they feel they are by nature en- “right to happiness.” unhappy; many riage they can that happiness to titled. There is nothing strange or sur- prising in this; the surprising thing is that anybody except the party thus di- rectly concerned should feel that this view of the matter is “superior” or enlightened.” In point of fact, it is like the superior views of those who keep discovering that the earth is flat, or inventing contrivances for per- petual motion. The views that they propound are not “superior” or “ad- vanced” on the contrary, they are ude and retrograde. It needs no young prophet to tell us that marriage often n unhappiness; we all know at, but we know of no way to make everybody happy. The individual has no “right to happiness” other than such right as is consistent with the happi- ness and well-being of all mankind. What the malcontents would lightly cut away as a mere “convention” is the very sheet-anchor of society. In the vain endeavor to satisfy the unregulat- ed craving of each individual for all the happiness of which he thinks him- self capable, they would destroy that hich makes it possible for the great mass of mankind to have some tolera- ble degree of happiness and stability. Through the whole tribe of easy-go- ing and self-confident reconstructions of whether relating to the institution life, of marriage or to that of property, or what not, there runs one and the same fallacy. Marriage is a failure, private property is a failure, law is a failure— why? Because it has not brought about perfection; because, if you please, there stand to its account many glaring, even monstrous, wrongs and maladjustments. The suppressed premise in all this is that, somehow or other—Heaven only knows how—mankind was in possession of the means of procuring those bless- ings which it has not managed to ac- quire, and was balked of their attain- ment by the instrumentalities by which, in point of fact, it has attained so much of them as has actually been realized. Under the reign of laws, there is injus- tice; let us then abolish laws, and have that justice which anarchy alone can provide. Under the régime of private property, there are many who are poor | and suffering; let us then get rid of private property, and we shall all be sure to be prosperous and contented. In thousands of marriages there is not that concord of souls which is the ideal] to break away from each other whenever we feel union; let us then be free so inclined, and nothing can be more certain than that happiness and loyalty and contentment will be the lot of every man and woman. Strange that such childish absurdity should pass muster at all; stranger still that anybody should plume himself on superiority of it, does intellect in accepting and imagine it convince that those whom not are deaf to the voice of reason. ATHLETICS AND HEALTH. In his report for 1911, Dr. Charles F. Stokes, Surgeon-General of the navy, makes the rather sweeping statement that, in the opinion of the Bureau, athletics This “midshipmen “competitive and spectacular are undesirable in the service.” is particularly true for who are prone to overtrain for, or haz- Moreover, ard too much in, a contest.” while he has football in mind, he is thinking not so much of its hazards un- der present conditions of play as of its “disabling after-effects”; and he does not criticise it alone. Indeed, his con- cern is less with actual contests, whe- ther of football, boat-racing, or long- distance running, than with the train- ing that they necessitate. It is the “pro- longed rigorous course of physical ex- ercises necessary to excellence in physi- cal sports” that is believed to be dan- gerous. Under the conditions of service at sea, it is impossible to continue rigor- ous exercise, and hence one who has been accustomed to it tends to lose stam- ina, to fall a prey to degenerative changes, and in the end “fails to render as many years of efficient service under service conditions as does his less ath- letic, but symmetrically developed, class- | mate,” The figures which Dr. Stokes fur- nishes in support of his contention are suggestive than conclusive. A examination of the medical rec- former athletes of the rather recent ords of 625 ‘classes from 1891 to 1911 shows two ideaths “directly attributable to track 'and crew racing,” and one to an injury received in a football game. Of the 604 remaining in the service, over and above

Page 11

Feb. 8, 1912]

those dead or retired, 198 “have disabil- suffi-

ities or abnormal conditions of cient moment to be of official record, and to which their record as athletes bears a possible or probable causative inference is relation.” This enough, and it is to be noted ments regarding the physical of the 406 non-athletes are wanting That this, too, is not what it might ha by these two been is indicated fied declarations: An examination of physical on the Academy sl lition of the ows a marked g weight and strength age year, a slight loss of averag gt a decided loss of strength ring sequent years Ot training As this bears a decreas¢ n compuls 2 these years, as shown evident that the mind is expense of the body in the second, and first classes Manifestly, a midshipma: S height of his physical development at the close of his first vear in the Acad emy. It is equally evident that too lit tle training is bad, and that too mu is worse. Apparently, the right amount is not easy to hit. Doctors would not be doctors if they did not disagree, and consequently ons feels surprise at finding Stokes’s no conclusions provoke dissent as approval among medical men Dr. Sargent, for instance, in a sym posium upon the subject in the Medica the “vas Times, attributes of injuries resulting from the eral does very cause which the Surgeon-Gen- not make prominent, football; and not merely to training for the game, but to actual participation in it. Dr. Estes of Lehigh, on the con- trary, sees the harm to be in the “ul terior effects of over-exertion,” especial- ly by undeveloped boys who have not had sufficient training for the strenuous contests which they enter. This con- fusion in respect to the facts in the case is paralleled by the uncertainty of deduction drawn from whatever set of data one Here is Dr. Lam- bert of the of confersing that he has permitted some accepts. University Virginia, men to play who were suffering with derangement of the heart; explaining that he had known none of them to be injured, and that some of them had shown improvement; but unexpectedly adding: “This improvement I do not, namely, The Natton however, attribute to football.” Similar- ly reticent is Dr. Anderson of Yale ‘My conclusions showed that the ath- lete is not short-lived, but I do not State that he owed his longevity to ath tics He even allows the possibility ithletics m ha armed these ng d I s D Anderson also who points i source of diff iltvy in mak ng ‘ pa ons be ee ithletes and es, and hen determining , ol between thletics and \ atl d examined long-lived be a ‘ ( be I ked me \ thel i x I ! e 5 | a ft r Ya I all lane ( ty lr . , ( al bu io \( le ge! ia iol » al b ( tl the g ‘ I i VAY ti ird lis Ss I t iT] hard e der d t the p ti at mo col ges is m o mu to find ythe man S ] for athl the mal ) 1 made to stand the ain ( I nportal ga And n¢ I ommon mind thletics” is synon) t hat | Stokes calls “c« ) ind spectacular athletics,” in ‘ hich | Sharpe's admis I part laris plicabl the bu n < proof seen o be vpon tho o dissent from tl Surgeon-General's lict that such exercise is “undesir ‘ Dr. Gwathmey of this city set orth as the ideal that “every man in he institution should be trained mod- erately, instead of a few men who do not need the training being trained the limit of their physical powers Why not have both? There are signs of an awakening in the college world to the fact that athletics were made for man, and not man for athletics. This perception should be materially deep- ened by every such study of the ques- tion the Surgeon-General's report is as causing. L2Y BOOKS ON RECENT ITALIAN HIS- TORY. Firorence, January 24 Few periods of Italian history have been more closely studied by native his- torians than that of the Risorgiment while to none has less attention been devoted than to that whicl immediate succeeded the unification of the coun his past yea l é h the Jubil of the Italian king i ! 1 celebrated, we ha } be i of books on tl f d ne i at ie t or | int rk ¢ ond i lnape i l to t t! i ed | G. E. ¢ i vol ( rt I ‘ i ‘ Vic | Cay i ( ildi | tra i: 2 ( i ( t il f d , , ‘ Dp ! t ‘ p . Ga S ! ind attit t) | I , £ t t i ‘ 4 kno not a f it tl a, but hile t i { ent y y rie t t ¢ i 1 il] i l It te ind the ‘ in elgn inte it i As bald ndid I l ] I a ul not t t | Of exceptional interest the pondence between Victe } manure nd Garibald it ad known that the ¢ | i more in mpathy than Cav ‘ the Hero of tl Two W l Jf t there } Sec ind hye tween them a to tl ] hic] hould be followed; but the ten letters W h are no pul hed for tl first time show us the intr vor} va of the plot of the monarch and G baldi to subvert the old diploma ind bring about the collapse of the Bourbon kingdom and the union of Italy in the teeth of all the forces of reaction. Dr. Curatulo’s volume contains a mass of other valuable material, mostly unpub lished His comments are lucid and useful, but in his unbounded enthusiasm for Garibaldi he is not always fa to Cavour, and he is apt to draw deduc- tions from his material which it does not altogether bear out. T. Palamenghi-Crisp!, whose volume of documents on the part played by his uncle Francesco Crispi in Garibaldi’s expedition to Sicily, has already been noticed in these columns, has now pub- lished a book on Mazzini (“Giuseppe Mazzini: Epistolario inedito, 1826-1864”; Milan: Treves). The book contains

Page 12

180 much important material which prove valuable to future historians and enables us to study Mazzini’s character, aims, and activity in many fields. We realize the importance of his work in the period previous to 1859 when his countless conspiracies and projects and plotting served to keep alive, rather to create, the Italian political spirit which made Italian unity his tireless or possible and inevitable. After 1859 his task was done, and his subsequent ac- tivity did no good to the Italian cause and still less to his own reputation. These contradictions make it difficult for us to pass final judgment on Maz- zini; and the latter period of his life, and | limitations, are apt to obscure fron ir sight the immense services which he had previously rendered to his country As in the author’s former ork, the best use is not made of the material; the documents are set forth without logical sequence, and the edi- torial comment is at times insufficient and at others superfluous. A book of a different type is Senator Giovanni Cadolini’s “Memorie del Risor- gimento dal 1848 al 1862” (Milan: Cogli- ati). The author first joined the volun- tee! in his native town of Cremona when seventeen years old, on the out- break of the revolutionary war of 1848, and took part in various engagements. After the Italian defeats in the north, he joined Giacomo Medici’s force and hur- ried to Rome, where he served in the memorable defence of the city in 1849. His account of the siege is one of the most interesting parts of the volume, although it tells us little that is new. After the fall of Rome Cadolini went into exile in Piedmont and Sardinia, conspired against the Austrians in Lom- bardy, and helped to carry on the na- tional propaganda by smuggling pro | ! and newspapers into that ntr When the war of 1859 broke out he joined Garibaldi’s famous Caccia tori de 11) and distinguished him iny a stricken fleld Finally, he 1 Medici in the second expedi t iclly, in support of Garibaldi’s ‘ | The ind, fought at Mila on t Volturno, and elsewhere, until the n of Italian unity in 1S6l ! most recent perlod of Italian his t dealt ith In a large work pub ! d by t Accademia del Lincel, juant’ ann! di Storia italiana” ( in: Hoepli), by a number of au t Tl Lincel may be regarded as the oldest learned academy, havir g been founded in 160 and it has always maintained its reputation as an assem- bly of eminent scholars and men of aclence Consequently, when in 1909 Sig. Carcano, then Minister of the Treasury, on the occasion of the jubilee of Italian unity, conceived the idea of a work to be published under the aus- pices of the Government, setting forth the progress of the Kingdom in all its will | [ Vol. 94, No. 2432 The Nation aspects during the last fifty years, was the Lincei that seemed most suited to carry out the task. The programme of the work proposed was ambitious, but it achieved in part, if not altogether. In any case, the work is the most complete and important on the period in question which has yet e_peared. The first essay is a summary cf Italian political history from 1861 to 1910 ty Senator Raffaele De Cesare; the part dealing with the years subse- quent to 1870 is the most useful, as it is difficult to find any general and ac- curate account of that period, and any one who wished to study it has hith- erto had to wade through heavy tomes of Parliamentary reports, registers of laws, the Gazzetta uficiale, Government inquiries, and to supplement them with has been party pamphlets. Sig. De Cesare has not, of course, been able, in the narrow space assigned to him, to give more than a rapid sketch, but he is clear and concise; and although he does not hide his political sympathies, which are not favorable to the very democratic ten- cenctes of Signor Giolitti, he manages fair and impartial. Professor Lenini gives us an interesting and de- tailed account cf the demographic move- ment of the population, with much sta- tistical material. Carlo Ferraris de- ribes the development of the railway ystem.,. to be of the progress of the electrical industry, by Senator Colombo, the president of the Italian Edison Company, is of especial import- ance. The Milan central power station, hich was the first in Europe, began to perate in 1883, one year after Edison had set up the first plant of the kind in The account Tialian America. In 1898 there were 2,264 elec- tric power stations in Italy, producing 17,000 horsepower; of these 1,143 de- ed their energy from water-power. In the total number of stations had isen te 3,600, producing 820,000 horse which due to The projected plants will of 610,000 were produce another 250,000 horsepower, and available for icity i at about 3,000,- ) horsepower; but by means of reser- ; and other appliances a much high- er figure will probably be reached. This of Italy's nountains are singularly rich, has open- prospects of industrial de- elopment, all the more valuable ir a country lacking in coal, and it is grad- transforming many a mountain village Other writers describe other aspects of Italy's remarkable industrial development, while Prof. Ghino Valenti a long and detailed account of Italian agriculture, which is somewhat pessimistic as to the results of the action of the state, but expresses confidence in the work of the more intelligent land- lords and the peasants. Professor Valenti believes that emigration has contributed the total water-power electr estimated Ol which water-power, in ed up new ually gives it | in no small degree to the progress achieved, but that much remains to be done to give a scientific character to the agricultural industry, especially in the South. On the purely intellectual development of Italy we have Prof. Luigi Pigorini’s essay on prehistoric research, and that of Prof. Giuseppe Gat- ti on archeological discoveries and stud- ies, while Prof. Vincenzo Masi describes the educational system and institutions, both public and private. Jurisprudence, legislative progress, and the formation of the codes are the subject of Prof. Biagio Brugi’s paper. Paolo Carcano, who planned the whale work, gives an account of Italian finance. The situation, he writes, if not perfect, is certainly very good, for the income of the state has risen from 480,000,000 lire in 1861, when the population was 22,000,000, to 2,212,000,000 lire in 1910, while the popu- lation had only grown to 35,000,000, and there have been considerable surpluses in the budgets of the last few years. A proof of the sound financial condition of the country is to be found in the fact that the campaign in Tripoli is being paid for out of Treasury residues with- out as yet raising new loans or increas- ing the taxes. The third and concluding volume, to be published next year, will contain es- says on biology, by Professor Grassi; emigration, by Professor Coletti; bank- ing and foreign trade, by Bonaldo Stringher (the general manager of the Banca d’ Italia), etc. This publication, in spite of many merits, is far from faultless. The essays are unequal in value, and certain im- portant aspects of Italian development, such as literature, historical study, art, music, etc., have, for no apparent rea- son, been entirely omitted. 4 NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. In the interest of literary origins the real history of Mr. Rudyard Kipling’s ballad, “The Rhyme of the Three Captains” (1890) to be preserved. It is twenty-one years since the poem appeared, and the fires which evoked it have long since died. The poem may be found in the “Collected Verse of Rudyard Kipling,” Doubleday, Page & Co., New York, 1911, on pp. 222-226. Mr. Kipling has prefixed a note as follows (the italics are mine): This ballad appears to refer to one of the exploits of the notorious Paul Jones, an American pirate. It is founded on fact. This note is framed with great calcula- tion. The ballad appears to refer to an exploit of Paul Jones, when as a matter of truth it has to deal with a business experi- ence of Mr. Kipling himself and in so far is “founded on fact,” but the facts are quite different from what the casual reader would suspect. “The Rhyme of the Three Captains” was originally printed in the ithenaum of December 6, 1890, and its gen- esis is to be found fn a controversy of that year between Mr. Kipling and Messrs. Har- |per & Bros., in which the pages of the | Atheneum were the medium. In the issue ought

Page 13

Feb. 8, 1912] of October 4, 1890, under the caption, “Lit- erary Gossip,” is the following: A year or so ago Mr. Rudyard Kipling, when passing through New York, called on Messrs. Harper and offered them for re- printing “Soldiers Three” and other pieces of his, now famous. He was speedily shown the door, and told that a firm devoted to the publication of literature of a high class could not trouble itself about such writings as his. This autumn Messrs. Harper have picked out of the magazines some six stories of Mr. Kipling’s, without asking his permission or giving him an opportunity of revising them, and have printed them as a volume. They have sent Mr. Kipling a let- ter containing a bald announcement of the fact and the sum of £10, which has been promptly returned. The only side of litera- ture that Messrs. Harper appear to under- stand at all is the commercial. When an author is unknown to fame, they, it would seem, content themselves with insulting him; when he is celebrated, they insult and rob him. To this statement Messrs. Harper & Bros sent “A Reply” under date of October 14, 1890, which is printed in the Atheneum of November 1, 1890, in the course of which they say: The statements therein made are so at variance with the facts that we feel justi- fied in assuming that they could not have been derived from Mr. Kipling himself. The editor of the Atheneum subjJoined to this communication a statement that: Our information was derived from Mr. Kipling, who told us that the volume was published without his knowledge and much against his wishes. One week later, in the issue of November 8, 1890, Mr. Kipling published “A Counter Reply” of nearly a column and a half in length in which he submitted the proofs of his complaint. The closing paragraphs are those that interest us. He says (italics mine): Since Messrs. Harper & Bros. are so anxious to make clear to the English public that they possess a canon of commercial morality, it is hardly necessary to make clear both to public and pirate that the pur- chase of advance sheets of five stories does not confer the right of hastily hawking those five stories (and one other thrown in to make bulk) up and down the States in the shape of an unedited, unrevised, unfin- ished, disorderly abortion of botch-work. The real trouble, of course, is rot with this or that particular picaroon across the water. The high seas of literature are un- protected, and those who traffic on them must run their chance of being plundered If Messrs. Harper & Bros. had not taken my stories, some other long or short firm would have done so. Only, a pretentiously moral pirate is rather more irritating than the genuine Paul Jones. {thenrumne Besant dated para- On November 22, 1890, the published a joint letter of Walter William Black, and Thomas Hardy, November 17, 1890, in which is this graph: It is no part of our purpose to express an opinion upon this case. But it seems a clear duty tous, who have experienced honourabl« treatment from this firm, to enter a pro test against the sweeping condemnatios passed upon them in the paragraph in ques tion [i. e., the literary note published in the issue of October 4.] This paragraph does not take the form of a communication by a contributor singly responsible for his own opinion, but it carries the whole weight and authority of the greatest literary jour- nal in the country. A fortnight later, in the Athenawum of December 6, 1890, without note or comment, Mr. Kipling published “The Rhyme of the Three Captains.” In the light of the corre- ‘The spondence preceding, very illuminating allusions: Nation At the close of a winter Their anchors down, by London town, Great Capteina lay. And one was Admiral of the North from Solway Firth to Skye, And one was Lord of the Wessez coast and all the lands thereby, And one was Master of the Thames from Limehouse to Blackwall, And he was Chaplain of the Fleet—the stoutest of them all. Thelr good guns guarded the great grey sides that were thirty foot In the sheer, When there came a certain treding-brig with news of a privateer. Her rigging was rough with the crusted drift that drives In a Northern breeze, day, the Three Her sides were clogged with the lazy weed that spawns in the astern seca. Light she rode in the rude tide-rip, to left and right she rolled, And the skipper sat on the scuttle-butt and stared at an empty bold. “I ha’ pald Port dues for your Law,"* quoth he, t ast where is the Law ye bk If I sail unscathed from a heathen port to be robbed on a Christian coast?’’ 9 Who are the “Three Captains” And one was Admiral of the North from Solway Firth to Skye, Surely the allusion is to William Black, the novelist of the North Country And one was Lord of the Wessex coast and al! the lands thereby, No other than the author of “Wessex Tales,” who has made Wessex a Hardyshiie as truly as the English Lake Country has been called Wordsworthshire. And certain- ly the late Sir Walter Besant, the novelist of London life, and author of a history of London, is aptly called “Master of the Thames.”’ What was the name of the “certain trading brig’? and who was the “privateer”? The controversial correspon- dence outlined above surely contains the answer. The keenness of the allusion is significant throughout the rest of the poem: I had no fear but the seas were clear as far as a sail might far met with a lime-washed Yankee brig that rode off Finisterre There were canvas blinds to his bow-gun ports to screen the weight he ore, And the signals ran for a merchantman from Sandy Hook to the Nore He would not fly the the black, But now he floated the Gridiron and now he flaunted the Jack foremast rill I flag—the bloody or Rovers’ J not mend his boom, my deck patch fore He haa borrowed them both in the name of trade m the shore. My woulk bouse his and sold them . the Captains Three called courteously from deck to scuttle-butt: **Good sir, we ha’ dealt with that merchantman or ever your teeth were cut. words of a lawless race, And Your words be and the Law it standeth thus He comes of a race that bave never a Law, and he never has boarded us. We ha’ sold him canvas and rope and separ—we know that bis price ts fair, we know that he weeps for the lack of a Law as he rides off Finisterre."’ And The skipper called to the tall taffrail: ‘‘And what is that to me? Did ever you hear of a Yankee brig that rifled a Seventy-three? Do 1 loom #0 large from your quarter-deck that 1 lft like a ahip o’ the Line? He hae learned to run from a shotted gun and harry euch craft as mine.”’ the ballad has some 131 The next lines—the re.der is asked to mark the fact—bear a remarkable parallel to Mr. Kipling’s stinging prose in his let- ter in the Athen@um of November 8: The skipper bit on a little word, and the word it was not sweet, For he could see the Captains Three had signalled to the Fleet. By three and two, in white and blue, the whim- pering Gaga began :— ‘We have heard a tale of a — foreign sall, det he t@ a merchantman.”’ The skipper peered beneath his palm and swore by the Great Horn Spoon, ** *FPore Gad, the Chaplain of the Fleet would bless my ptearoon !”’ It is evident that Mr. Kipling really has in mind the “high seas of literature” and not the natural ocean. Note the unusual word “picaroon,” identical in both prose and verse, and the reference to Paul Jones in the letter, which gave Mr. Kipling room n after years, when the fires of indignation had died down, to say that “This ballad appeare to refer to one of the exploits of the notorious Paul Jones.” Verily “The Rhyme of the Three Captains’ is “founded on fact.” But far other- wise than the superficial reader would sur- mise. But apart from the the “facts” are internal evidence as to the real bearing of the ballad, there ts one other significant bit of evidence, In index to the Athen@um, Vol. II, 1890, we read: the Kipling (Mr. Rudyard) and Messrs. Har- per Brothers, 452, 547, 585, 627, 701, 776, 816. Page 776 containe nothing but “The Rhyme of the Three Captains.” Evidently the editor of the Athen@um knew the real application of the poem, for otherwise the connection would be singular. There remain two or three details to be noticed. I have compared the original text with the version in the volume of “Collected Verse,” and some of the changes in the re- vised version are not without interest. [n the original, the word “skipper” is printed throughout with a capital S, a touch of personal significance. Again, lines have been altered on page 223. The revised couplet reads: two My foremast would not mend his boom, deck- house patch his boate; my He haa whittled the two, thie Yank Yahoo, to peddle for shoe-peg oate. The line “Had I had guns,” etc., In the original reads: “If I had guns,” etc. In the original version Walter Besant is called “Chaplain of the Fleet, the stoutest of them all,” instead of “Captain... the bravest,” etc.; “crusted drift is in place of “clotted drift.” “The skipper bit on a Kittle word” instead of “a deep-sea word.” Finally, in the last line of the poem as printed in the volume, Mr. Kipling has disguised, if he has not softened, the allusion. The orig- inal reads: Shall dip their flag to a pirate’s rag—to show that his trade is fair. In the revised version the word “pirate’s” has been changed to “slaver’s,” which seems weak, and without relation to the sense of the whole ballad. JAMES WESTFALL THOMPSON.

Page 14

The Nation the custodians of the race, forever lack, in our society, that edu- ation that comes from friction against one’s are Correspondence ; ist _—— ellow-men, and that constitutes the best rHE QUESTION OF SUFFRAGI raining of mankind for citizenship Neither of the great classes of young To THE Epitor oF THE NATION women who earn, or mature women who Sin: Nothing is more clear to the ob-'| serve at home, provides its pro rata of the server of current politics than the ap- voices that are raised for the suffrage. proaching sur that will crown a long) After these two classes are subtracted from period of persistent agitation for the ex-| the female population, there remains a third tensior the franchise to women. Rising class, proportionally small, of independent, in the East, on theoretical grounds, the de- mature women—the women who are poten- mand was first conceded in the Western tially the best citizens. These, to secure Stat where the binding force of tradi- suffrage for themselves, advocate it for all tion was lower than elsewhere in the Union. | their sex, regardless of the burden it will The logical propriety of the concession has jmpose or the service it will render. These made the cause hopeful, reduced positive’ make most of the noise, and are enabled to opposition, and left the movement with only | do so by the labors of some one else. Some that obstruction to meet that comes from accident of inheritance, or success of pres- the wee of habit and the immobility of) ent supporter, has removed from them the institutions But, once started, as a fact need to carry a share of the chores of with six States ready to try it, it is likely feminine existence. Few can name more to complete the conquest of the United) than a handful of women who, having them- States before the first women voters have selves earned an independence, are devoting forgotten their original sensations on cast- jt to the cause. For this handful, it must ing their first ballots be conceded that no offi s too high and It has more than once been pointed out no right too generous that the opponents of woman suffrage are The value placed upon suifrage by its ad- tongue-tied. The arguments in favor of it yocates compels the student of institutions are irly voiced and loudly stated. They | to question the complete capacity of even evoke no articulate contradiction, yet their) the Jeaders of the feminist agitation. After speakers often show an irritation because | ajjowing for all the factors of strife and ex- neither conviction nor rebuttal is produced aggeration essential to a propaganda there by their efforts. It is worth while for the! remains behind the movement the assump- advocates to consider whether in thisstion that the evils of to-day would not exist f there may not be room for reflec-}i¢ women voted. Too often their arguments tlor seem to imply that women are so much more It 1dmitted at once that the pres- jntelligent, honest, and virtuous than the ent drift f politi favors the extensiony men whom they have trained that the faults or t franct to every sentient being |o¢ masculine government will be swept away who d it. It unfair to deprive any| at once. Nothing but a belief in the reality ' idult of a share in his own Gov-| of such reform could justify the virulent ‘ t It is unwise to make martyrs! speech and lawless conduct of the most mili- iderable element of the popula- tant of the reformers. Yet were all women t T) il nvited by an extension of | the civic equals of the small class of inde- t! ! ire smaller than those en-| pendent women, there are grave doubts talled by the closure of this social safety whether they would outrank the men in any virtues save those which sex has fastened I things which provoke the silence; ypon them They are not trained to the that fF s to give consent in this case honesty that is the backbone of masculine from a fear that the suffragists have | pbyusiness. Contractual relations and com- mista the inclination of their sex, and promise do not enter into their daily rou- ha over-estimated the significance of tine, In public and in private they are their reform. more interested in carrying the point than In sor future day society may be en-| jn doing abstract justice. That the mass of tirely reorganized, but as it stands now the| women are now, or are likely in the near wo who support themselves by “gainful fyture to be, the civic equals of their hus- occupation,” as the census calls it, are hands and brothers, it is impossible to be- ! tly young. Pleasure and spending-money | jijeve. Civi virtue does not come from a are often their objects Even when they clean heart alone. It comes from a first- are self-dependent they rarely ripe to po-| hand knowledge of the workings of social sitions of independent responsibility, but forces. Mankind cannot be preached into an accept a boss and a wage as servants, clerks, advance: it can be led there only by toler- f " hands, or teachers, and look for- ant fellowship that can operate as readily ward to eraduation into matrimony No in the barber-shop, the cigar-shop, and the ‘ r advat 1a theory of political sal- galoon as in the church or on the platform. vation based upon the votes of men of sim The sober reflections occasioned by the flar age. The women who are mature are progress of the suffragette do not inspire ' t! ried. and pledged to a trade in to formal argument. It is too late to argue gor year are de- the atter now But no suffrage worker | >a ' he and the famill Their should convince herself—or himself—that h t good. as the race ea it onsists lack of opposition proves the complete ac- i ting for her own children the ceptance of the contention. The capacity of lat t bl hare of life and its ful-| women is not in question; in an intellectual ness rm) work and their responsibility way they can do anything that men can do. cannot be delegated, and no public activity! The inclination of most of them will, in our that hifts thelr primary interest can be civilization, keep them from being a politi- , rtal by them They rarely associate cal motive force. Even were they otherwise on a titive basis with wther persons} inclined, they do not differ enough from the of thelr own standing an! maturity They’ men to change the aspect of government _ but they [Vol. 94, No. 2432 greatly. But whatever their capacity, incli- nation, or influence, we are in for woman suffrage, and we shall have to see it through. We shall get from it a few notable women of whose services we are now de- prived. But we shall inflate the electorate with a body-of voters even less socially in- clined than our men; and with the women, as with the men, our political salvation will depend on the fact that though most will be indifferent, uninformed, and unwise, they will fall into two equal camps and neutralize themselves. Leadership and growth will continue to depend on the ef- forts of a handful of self-sacrificing men and women, and the race will blunder along only as rapidly as these can prod it, nag it, and direct it. FREDERIC L. PAXSON. Madison, Wis., January 16. RESEARCH AND ALTRUISM. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The vigorous and well-expressed ideas of your correspondent from Baltimore in “An Undergraduate View” (Nation, Janu- 18) deserve careful reading and atten- tion, and will doubtless command them. His moral strictures on the selfishness of the acquisition of knowledge for itself alone (as it may appear to the less learned) may per- haps be briefly dismissed as being for the most part what Kiplingesque undergraduates are wont to call “fat piffle.” As a consider- able part of every day in the life of an or- dinarily intelligent human being is almost perforce spent in the acquisition, deliberate- ly or unconsciously, of some sort of knowl- edge, human society is not likely to suffer if a small part of its members deliberately choose to disregard what appears to them trivial in favor of that which appears to them to exercise the higher functions of their rational faculties. I seem to detect, indeed, a certain weakening of the principle of altruism in his complaint about “re- search” as the means by which “success and prominence” are attained. Ought a real altruist to measure his own success by his “prominence”? The vast majority of teach- ers’ positions in this country do not re- quire proved ability in research as a quali- fication in their would-be incumbents. We are not such fools as all that. The field of real success in the profession of teaching is not by any means closed to the ambitious young altruist sketched by your corre- spondent, even if he does not feel the zest for research. And even the salaries of school positions of the better sort are quite as large as those attainable in colleges and universities. There is a margin in them for occasional opera fickets for the first gallery. Nor does {it appear in general an utterly reprehensible thing that he who chooses a teacher’s career must definitely forego the hope of high money rewards. In the face of the present-day tendency to measure all “success and prominence” by returns in hard cash, it is something to have a career offered that recognizes a different ideal. In the course of my observation as (I must confess it) a now tolerably aged col- lege instructor in classics, I have often been tempted to lament the moderate intel- lectual ability and the lack of strong per- sonality in many of the young people who intended to follow the profession of teach- ing. But when I have deliberately sat down ary

Page 15

Feb. 8, 1912]

to compare them with others, I have been compelled to admit that they did not fall by any means below the average intelli- gence and character of the students whom I had seen attain “success and prominence” in other walks of life. Now a few words about that painful sub ject of “research.” I cannot help the sus- picion that the young altruist depicted by your correspondent has an envious and de- signing eye upon one of the _ university chairs held by worthy old gentlemen lik« me, who show no hopeful signs of relin- quishing them, even under the dulcet at- tractions of Mr. Carnegie’s benefaction for the speedier creation of vacancies. Let me regretfully assure your altruist that neither altruism nor personality is a satisfactory substitute for knowledge, though they may exist amicably alongside of knowledge, and even conjoined with it. That last clause is meant to contain for him the element of hope. I have always believed it possible I still believe it possible—for a an to be a ripe, and fine, and even a great scholar and teacher, who has never printed a word But I can hardly conceive that a man the ability and the zeal for learning make any great progress in that field with with could out spying a dozen directions in which his mind would be irresistibly tempted to essay the penetration of the yet unknown The “research test,”’ so far as there is such a test for positions of “prominence such as the undergraduate’s altruistic soul longs for, a rough-and- And and is after all in its purpose only ready the zeal for the zeal for tea prominencs without is likely A somewhat members of college faculties in this country had tended to my judgment that the ity of the large majority of these gentlemen test of learning and for “success the ludicrous hing, zeal for learning, failure. acquaintan to be a extended with rather than weaken ability and personal- onfirm were such as would have ensured their at tainment of equivalent “success and prom nence” in whatever other employments they might have chosen. Your correspondent sternly, and no doubt sadly, thinks far other wise. It is surely hard for us to see our selves as the sapient undergraduate sees us E. T. M University of Chicago, January 30 SOLARIO’S PORTRAIT OF BENTIVOGLIO To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The interest which attaches to th beautiful portrait of Bentivoglio by Solario lately acquired by the Boston Museum of Fine Arts from England, is further in creased by a recent discovery made in Ita] In the collection of paintings belonging t Signore Andrea Monga in Verona is a pi ture, which, to judge from photograpus, is identical with that in Boston except for a few details, such as the window in the background, which is not so high in the Verona picture as in the Boston one and therefore better proportioned. This and other small differences favor the supposi- tion that the picture in Verona is su- perior to that in Boston The Andrea Monga Gallery, which comprises six hun dred paintings, was formed about a hun dred years ago, and has been inaccessible for forty years. After the recent death of the last owner the collection passed into the possession of the city of Verona, but Nation

it will probably remain inaccessible for some time, since there is at present no room for its exhibition, and since most of the pictures are in a bad condition and have to be cleaned I was fortunat: nough to obtain permission from the city iuthorities to examine this collection, and am therefore in the position to give a pro visional opinion as to the importance and the artist value of the portrait of Bentivoglio in Verona. The surface is over- painted, and covered with thick, dull var- nish, which completely covers the original olor, so that the picture has the ap pearance of a copy, perhaps of lat lat But this opinion is not _hared by Verones: art critics As regards the question of au thenticits we have to reckon with the pos sit t tha re than rr rit i } B t a i been ordered f1 es iint And th gl i I i R ar let their assistants mak« the replicas ‘ tt i é é ; ) ’ ' p ' STATISTICS OF TH W's LAYS I E EI ) I NA S S I i ‘ Febr r i pea i ] Uu i Ma I 1s 1d to h ; } ‘ \\ ; i \ : , ida i i ads > \ ) i ) i ra ] ] ) g a a r 7 rst degre 1 this Stat wT ! ‘ I senta so ‘ t ! H g I 3 \ l 1 1 I ] \ Part I ~ i ‘ nt oO : ‘ | bs] l ( \ iis I 1 i exe itlo 5 th ii ; | ] ) i il en y nt Fra o i ir ] garded i ! figures approx l il | 1 o | a No. of-cas t ) J 12 yr l1 ) ‘ f r ‘ $ 24 mo z 25 or (B 1 7 ) s ‘H yr M ; 4 B 9 a 4 - ( (Sart .. ! (Patr 47 $ Tota 119 It wil t ] it o of 119 appeals only } r ] ed of within 4 ear 0 i i . Dar quir ! re i ) irs This letter ly pres they a withou atte pt ¢t suge 1 New York ¢ I ary . DEFINITIO®N i) To THE EDITOR Ts N SIR Readers of | . i definition of the Lliing r finding just what ti wing definition, by Mr ! 8s th ost satis Th tr t I Ss ; es yf a | ft is ’ ehe " ’ w xg biograpl Me irs Vol, Il s ( 5 Uta J i . sy” | *4> Literature RECENT VI =F | 1 1) ) , ‘) liar H VW Printed for tl Auth f f f f | i } PI i elp { ) $1 yA , ; fhe Sailor Who Has Poems. By Benjamin R. ¢ York: John Lane C $1.2 The Inn of Dre By |] Douglas New York Joh $1.95 net The City of the § i By Dougla \ York . ’ net Helen of Trov and Other Po Teasdale. New Yo G Sons. $1.25 net Sonas of Courage a Or Bertha |! Gordon faker & Taylor Co $1 net Poems By Harriet Mel Boston: Little, Brown & ¢ The Ballad oft f! bert K. Che n. > Lane Co S1.2 t T) Dream of A { Vavy. By Wallace Be London: David Nutt 2 ! 1" athe Beautiful and Ot} By Katherine Lee Bate Thomas Y. Crowell Co. $1.2 T} Upp Trail B | G Chicago: The Alderbrink P With re spect to the irtit f the poets have at all ti pretty uniformly divided T en deniers or affirme: looked upon i pecious illusion or else a mendous and significant real one hand, like Mr. Woods in jackgrounds,” they are set the face behind the t either as a be that shall rip appearance Iike a 3 Le ‘j \ | B ( D i y ty ing 3 mask, the revelation rétaty Abid

Page 16

184 ‘The Nation [ Vol. 94, No. 2432 and disclose the apocalyptic vision be- Let priestly pardoners still shrive the world, I shall not know if it be night or noon— hind the veil “The play, the play's the thing!” Lord Ham- rhe peopled and illimitable night Hath mightier ghosts than Denmark’s, and the light That limns the upturned face Paints half a world of faces in its glow; Arden hath untold jovers hid from sight ro Rosalind, and many a willing sprite Unknown, unsummoned, waits on Prospero. What else is watching in the dark behind? Who knows when legions, angel, ghost, or djinn, Shall break from out the backgrounds vast that bind Our cramped of Romeo horizon, and o’errun’§ the scene, Or God himself crash on us mummers blind, And play be done, and life, life, life begin! lo such as these what passes before the as in Miss Rob- less facti- mere bodily eye seems, “At Tintagel,” hardly tious and legendary than “the memory of some old tale twice told”: erts 8 Here where the grass is wreathed with fairy rings, There where the crumbling crenellations rise, I see dim shapes of half-forgotten kings And queens with starry eyes. The shouts of strong, exultant men I hear, rhe ring of harness on the causeway-stone, The clash of arms comes faintly to the ear, And bugle-horns are blown. What profits it, the ancient tale oft told Of love or tournament or bloody fight? If Guinevere’s deep hair were royal gold, Or Yseult’s hands were white? Dead, dead are they, and gone with all their train, Dead, dead are they, or haply never were; Perchance the phantoms of the misty brain Of some old chronicler. And yet the moan of tae remembering sea, The ancient winds, Iike pardoners to shrive, Repeat their names’ Ah! no; not they but we Have never been alive On the other hand, there are the na- tures thirsty for experience—those who are drunken with the vitality, anima- tion, and movement of existence—who sing like Mr. Low In his “Vigil at Arms” It was but lately that a child I came Firat upon life Loving spring flowers, gentle, without blame, Knowing not atrife The world was old ere battles bloomed for me; Boyhood was dreams, and swooning min atrel : I wandered all alone and wandered free Where dreams are rife But all at once the silver-crested surge Ceased to be cloud, And thundered over me; I felt the scourge And sting, and bowed Under the brine, until half-dead, I lay Forespent upon the sand *and from that day, Triumphant-tongued, the fury of the fray Calls me aloud. White and aloof; Mine be the battle-flame, the fear unfurled— The storming hoof; Let me be mingled with a maze of blows; Hard-pressed to live, heart mad, beset with foes, Or, lance in rest,ride down the lists’ enclose To peril’s proof. Differences of shading there may be; but the ground color, the general tone of poetry, is determined by one or the oth- er of these two moods, the reflective or the active. Is life a mere appearance, a show, a painted cloth before the truth, then were it hardly werth the pains. It were better far, in the words of Lady Alfred Douglas, to fall asleep— In some great embroidered bed, With soft pillows for my head. I am weary, let me sleep. Petals of sweet roses shed All around a perfumed heap White as pearls, and ruby red; Curtains closely drawn to keep Wings of darkness o’er me spread. I am weary, let me sleep In some great embroidered bed. Let me dream that I am dead, Nevermore to wake and weep In the future that I dread. For the ways of life are steep. I am weary, let me sleep. At all events, it were as well to turn the attention elsewhere, to seek a less ambiguous, if minor, reality in things of one’s own creating, in the cultivation of an art or in the construction of a sin- gle perfect sonnet, whose difficulties and satisfactions Lord Alfred Douglas cele brates in a sonnet of his own: e To see the moment holds a madrigal, To find some cloistered place, some her- mitage For free devices, some deliberate cage Wherein to keep wild thoughts like birds in thrall; To eat sweet honey and to taste black gall, To fight with form, to wrestle and to rage, Till at the last upon the couquered page The shadows of created Beauty fall. This is the sonnet, this is all delight Of every flower that blows in every Spring, And all desire of every desert place; This is the joy that fills a cloudy night When, bursting from her misty following, A perfect moon wins to an empty space. On the contrary, if reality is to be judged by the intensity of sensation, if even the start and thrill of pain are evi- dence of life, then there is nothing so much to be dreaded as the cessation of that consciousness in which alone man exists. It is the horror of such oblitera- tion, the loss of that one chance to know, which Miss Teasdale voices in her lines on “Fear”: [ am afraid, oh I am so afraid! rhe cold black fear is clutching night As long ago when they would take the light And leave the little child who would have prayed, Frozen and sleepless at the thought of death. My heart that beats too fast will rest too 8000 ; me to- Yet shall I struggle in the dark for breath? Will no one fight the Terror for my sake, The heavy darkness that no dawn will break? How can they leave me in that dark alone, Who loved the joy of light and warmth so much, And thrilled so with the sense of sound and touch— How can they shut me underneath a stone? In the face of such a catastrophe there is one way of saving the dignity, or at least the pride, of human nature— to meet it with the self-assertiveness, if not the truculency, of “Prospice,” the 'desperate elation of a sanguine spirit rioting for the last time in the exercise of its powers and draining intoxication from the very lees of life. So Miss Gor- don, mindful or not of Browning, in her “Song at the Brink of Death”: Before I leap and lose myself below, Give me one moment’s look beyond the brink. Volumes of fog, vast piles of rolling mists, Make war upon each other like the waves. I hear strong humming as of mighty winds, And shock and crash, as if a myriad Of toppling worlds were crushed and ground to dust. And from their dissolution, whirling, rise Sharp fumes and strange; and all the ting- ling air Seems full of unseen thorns that prick and burn. My soul is in my hand—I shall not fear. Now shall I test the temper of that sword That I have spent my life to weld and whet. Through ills I dream not of, through agony And ruin I shall cleave my flery way. The heart within me burns like glowing | wine, And as the husk of earth slips from my soul, |The thrill of dawning godhood stirs within. I swing my sword, and with a cry I leap. But better yet to think the horror clear away in something of the calm old Platonic fashion, of whose resignation the following sonnet by Miss Kimball is no unworthy modern expression: Save that there may be one love-garnering breast Will hold us unforgotten when we die, From all the paths that most familiar He We shall be missed but few brief days at best, Noteless as noiseless pass we to our rest; Slip from the ear and tongue as from the eye. Earth knows no break, no change to signify Absence or loss; and Time and Nature, lest In our behalf remonstrant they appear, Make stealthy haste to blur and cover o’er The stone's laborious lettering before The yividing mound that settles year by year Is level.ed, and the place—our last place here— | That knew us once knows us indeed no more. | ' §uch are the two moods of poetry to- day, as they have ever been; and they affect the poet’s vision of the past as of ithe present. To the ardent tempera- ‘ment ¢f a Mr. Chesterton the pageant of ‘history is but another stimulus, another

Page 17

Feb. 8, 1912] possible source of sensuous and emotion- al excitement. When he describes the political condition in Alfred’s day, he does so with a provocativeness, an im- pressionism, which makes it swim before the exalted senses in a luminous mist of an actuality: like wisps of cloud on irresistible, perhaps a anny fascination, which Miss Bates’s For the end of the world was long ago, When the ends of the world waxed free, What myriad life through sands When Czesar’s sun fell out of the sky, : Futil rtitudes and miseries And whoso hearkened right : é Switt printiess§ fee caressing va Could only hear the plunging , - Of the nations in the night — Grotesque nd lethargies that When the ends of the earth ca march : , i = Huddled or la ] } ng i . “ Cl I ( th hip ta To torch and cresset glear G re t t of t fl And the roads of the world that lead t Rome Where are tl ! tial | Were filled with faces that moved like foa Hawk-head Horus a t I Like faces in a dream. .. . Rar Vulture, Ape, d it r W rll we ea f | | And men brake out of the northern lands Pe li: Enormous lands alone, Where a spell is laid upon life and lust Thy stript, dishonored Pharaol I And the rain is changed to a silver dust In golden chambers ystically wr And the sea to a great green stone. .. At usky heart of cliff or pyramid Impass i ties, i r though And the cry of the palms and the purple Wh are tl iravan burde! moons, Booty of ivory lar, fragrant gun Or the cry of the frost and foam, Swept ever around an inmost place, Nor are Mr. Blanden’s lines to a mum And the din of distant race on race my in the British Museum conceived in Cried and replied round Rome. a very different spirit, though it is the Nor is Mr. Nichols less affected by the fatally ironic contrast between the, same patriotic theme. As he sings the ©hangeless shell and th tive essence dream of Alfred, launching a puny fleet Which is their immediat piration: —forerunner of England’s sea-power 1ughter and ea en against the Danes, and hymns the im- H fr ‘ ne perial mission of Great Britain, his Wrapt in ' o AD voice is thick with the fulfilment of ; prophecy: he is not a dreamer, but a seer: O windy-r ied, t pest rcleted sea B ght 1 da we have atched th ' ' hine 1 flash +} A mutinous Ophir of magnificent wrath . And shall we not, in emulous anger, wreck The black fleets of the poisonous tyrannies } Of thjs lust-opulent world, and break and crash lacid , , Upon the « sts of Wrong, and ruin her ; bor And sap her headlands? Was it not r tl Th orb \ placed hin ir hands t God O wind 1, t pest ] ‘ Hull-haunted rew-swirled, traffl ‘ rs. i’ The tireless caravans of puissance fa! Across thy deserts le with tl | —_ ’ sc aang teye on D eee ie CURRENT FICTION Of science, and precious oils, and hea hn G 1 } Party herbs, Lalage’s Lo By Gi A. Bir And Art's celestial attars—journeying on ngham. NY York G H Unto their Mecca, human brotherhood De n Ce And we, their sheiks, the Apostles of Ad vance There is a ] isant t at the Must guard them when they dare thy peril- literature of the Er peaking race ous wastes, is common property ar all i n Hull-haunted, screw-swirled, traffic-cloven perg Of books which have become sea! Class ie or “standard this is true Not so do the distant shapes of his- enough. But as for current literature tory appear to the contemplative imag- it is oddly untrue of the very depart {nation looking down the dwindling per- ment in which one might look to find verses “To the the images of transiency and change. such minds the thought of Egypt and its vanished civilizations has always had un- in slightly is reflected Nile’: The Nation spective of the past. Rather they seem horizon, For 1835 it a matter of course. One has only to look over the English reviews to note how few of the American novels of the hour—the pieces of home-made fiction which are being most widely read here are noticed at all We may consol ourselves with the fact that there are novelists in England who have beer writing successfully for years, and of vhom we have never heard This situa tion is due to a cautiousness which |! been drilled into the publ er by long experience. What is sauce to the Ame! ican goose is not always sauce to the British gander, or the reverse. So sen tive is the novel to variation perature on the two le of the i I that it frequently shifts its title on the And the ter all, is a barometer, and not an art vay over, er of taste, knows that he canno t upon the popularity on on ore f whatever may have found a cordial hearing on the other The most that he can do is to wa commodity, and seize the fit hour whe! it come Hence: th occasional | ! non of a wl ‘ books | some author of whom e have never heard, thrust in a mass le e@ ouc stonished gaze, ith mu trumpeting and acclaim on the part of the delight- ed sponsor. Something of the ort happe! i not long ago in connectior ith « ne found Arnold Bennett; and t! hich exploited mar } I ett books no co oO i I oop, thie I i be fairly cal I { 4. Bir ngha PI ! f i ttle a i nty of Cor i f t yme half-d a i I f t I ( pal lle ‘ ‘ i? ( I nt oO , kit : ‘ t! f |] be 1 il J o be | | d t nd y 1) ] i nd ¢ n ] ligy ' t of John Bull « | The ky thing to take ! I q erious!] nd try to pi I is | ea is in the graver i ns of lif It is then that he complains of misrep resentation. Mr. Birmingham commits no such er ror. He returns as light-heartedly, and

Page 18

136 rances as whole-heartedly, to to all appea . the traditions of Lever and Lover, as if mystical and reverend Celt had ! been revived. The authors of “Ex- ! n of an Irish R.M.” may have £ ourage for this ingenuou | ‘ but ‘ uspect that he did I he git And in t he Mr Curat f Ballyme pre I ‘ hout paral ( t iMmadale he he whol l the Am t parsol | t¢ ‘ 1s 1 and he i aea i { Ss I I pl If t of Ba no has ' ‘ be a 1] oO i il id mnfined, and { d i th ‘ ade I Sir 7 er ) ‘ ture 4 ed tantasia I ( i i Party whe | tl part ¢ i infterio tneit Lalage’s Love n of the three noug but it 1u I ng of the othe t nomer La | | ive come nearer I é laid in Ireland, i 1 England almost a i young girl of in © fancies herself a \ n-up enfant terri tir various high id lu tamed by marriage | ch would be call é I in this country lists ng type accord ane to have a stomac! ‘ pect that Mr. Birming il at may become a | yrist ! By Richard Bart New ffat, Yard & Co \ | high might be dismissed as if it were not also a little gusting Its faults have nothing in pal ular to do with ite theme, which the application of the woman suf frage theory to a particular case. Giv- a woman of twenty-three with a nor- eT al husband and baby, and an abnormal desire to possess them utterly and self hiy, and you have material enough for domestic excursions and alarums, wars and rumors of war, without calling in the ald of the suffragette motive. But heroine of the present story, and all rest of the alleged persons therein, absurd dolls who are put through the the are The Nation could be on land or sea or in the ro- dull for the most part, and then a level of indecency which gives them a certain chance with a certain audience. It is hard to understand why reputable pub- lishers should permit so-called novels of this paltry type. various antics, but reaching now themselves to is- Richard Bos- Mifflin Co cl) stop) By Pryce. Houghton vork of an author well-establish- England but to American like the novel of similar title by Romain Rolland, in throwing plot to winds and prearranging a series of the development for as new eaders is r ments hero’s patently in ich events are created the necessity arises. It is the progress f the soul for which this English au- or is concerned (“Cl ristopher,” as he ‘ ily states, “was destined to have ni impressions” at this point or oth- and as this soulis highly romantic d in large measure fashions its own nal world, why should one compel anything so objective fy om oO ¢ erTgt ia a plot? So be Mr. Pryce admits the read- outdoing M. Rolland by a day, to ( stopher’s life just before birth. A posthumous child, possessed of a charm- mother and a notable nurse, of two and two wealthy grand- ‘thers, clearly he not to undergo purification by poverty, such as was ng idoring aunts is that thought a necessity for the little Chris- topher of the Rhine town. His very oung life is passed in the English col- ony at Boulogne in the seventies, with the war in the immediate background. Though quiet, the place is full of vari- ety and wonder for the sensitive little boy All children are poets and phil- ophers, and Christopher is a rare hild; beauty is in his soul. We see him tilting in its behalf with a child’s only half-revealed motives—battles of devotion, often to lost causes. Expec- tancy and trust make life wondrous fair, philosophy unifies the universe. This first half of the book has great charm, and the realness of the child jus- tifles the author’s method. After hesitations Christopher’s mo- her, Mrs. Herrick, remarries to a man of upright character, who had become entangled with a Mrs. St. Jemison of dubious repute; and Christopher goes to boarding school, to Oxford, then travels for two years, and settles in rooms in London, bent on a writer's career. The reader is hurried towards the final test—Christopher’s love for the daughter of Mrs. St. Jemison, his angel in white, his Laura: Benedetto sia il giorno, {1 mese, e l’anno! He is still the romantic, the poet, but the author has lost grip on him. Ut terances of his childhood, which seem- natural even when precocious, are love-making which never ed replaced by [ Vol. 94, No. 2432 mantic’s heaven. When the great dis- illusion comes, and ‘the shallow charac- ter of the mother reveals itself in the daughter, pathos is absent, because it is clear that the tragedy is an unem- bodied theme. Other characters in the story Mr. Pryce has kept well sustain- ed. The philosophizing of Trimmer, the nurse, rare fun; Mrs. Herrick, senior, the dowager of Herrickswood, has the keen iron nature known so well the mid-Victorians; Christopher’s mother utterly real, oddly through the sheer faultlessness of her breeding. is to is ONE ASPECT OF GOETHE. Goethe and his Woman Friends. By Mary Caroline Crawford. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. $3 net. “Ihr naht euch wieder, schwankende all are here, from the of boyhood to the somewhat nebulous Ulrike v. Levetzow of declining Not only are the poet's love-affairs analyzed, but also his relations to his mother and Klettenberg, to Gestalten!” Yes, obscure Gretchen Goethe's hie * are his years. sister, Fraulein v. the two Weimar duchesses, and even to Barbara Schulthess of Zurich. For the first time the reader who knows only his English or has not access to a well- stocked Goethe-library, will be able to study Goethe from this side. Yet, after all, the question will obtrude itself: Is such study worth the while? Is it even sound psychology to detach this single fibre of a highly complex organism and scrutinize it under the microscope? Our praiseworthy, she shadows to author’s purpose is wishes to clear away and misrepresentations have gathered round Goethe's Her sympathy is keen, her industry is un- flagging. Besides, she is entitled to the distinction of being the first woman to champion the poet against the field. Yet, to our way of thinking, such a method of defence can never be truly effective. To understand Goethe one must study him in his entirety. He was a myriad- minded, myriad-mooded mortal, vitally interested in everything that makes up humanity. As a great poet his sym- pathies were quickly stirred, his pas- sion was strong. His will, however, was still stronger. Hand in hand with his loves and friendships go his studies in literature and the drama, in history, art, architecture, music, botany, anat- omy, mineralogy, finance. All are in- extricably intertwined. To disengage Goethe the lover is impossible. In proof there is “Dichtung und Wahrheit.” Professedly, the work is nothing but the autobiography of its author's boy- hood and youth. Yet those who have studied it from cover to cover will ad- mit that in their reading they have been forced to try to know a little at least of everything. True, love flits through certain which fame.

Page 19

12] Feb. 8, 19 the pages, but only in kaleidoscopic mutability. Besides, we are not persuaded that our author has learned the real Goethe secret, without which one bound err. At page 3 read, in comment upon Goethe's witty little sketch of him self: “And it may as well be added at once that he always valued his paternal heritage [the serious conduct of life] less highly than the gift of writing : the ‘philosophy of a cheerful life’ whi to is we was his mother’s dower.” No, emphat ically no! The poet characterized him self on another occasion as one who had taken life hard. The German is more graphic: “Einer, der sich das Leben hat sauer werden lassen.’ Wit the exception possibly of the first wild weeks in Weimar, there was never a time in his long life when he did not in weariness—break off from so-call pleasure and plunge into something difficult and of abiding profit. resolutely In truth, his extraordinary relation t Karl August, what is it but a contin uous story of “des Lebens ernstes Fiihren”? On this point the memora ble poem “Ilmenau” is conclusive. Further, we doubt whether our au- thor is sufficiently conversant with th Goethe without a profound know- regime from which Yet it one cannot hope to estimate general sanity. On the one hand was unscrupulous libertinism, on the what call mental gush. Between this Scylla and Charybdis the poet steered a prett; middle course. At times unwise, ancien sprang. ledge of Goethe's should senti other we steady even sinful, his errors were of th healthy sort to which most creeds ex tend a measure of tolerance. Our ad vice is: Neither condemn the poet ni seek to justify him, but take him as | was and make the best of him. Still further, our author seems t find it difficult to keep in mind tl! shifting in Goethe’s social status. F example, at p. 92, she writes: ‘“Inas much as he was the son of an impor tant Frankfort citizen his position almost that of a nobleman, as compar with hers [Frederika’s].” This will never do. When in all the history Germany was there such an Absta between a mere studiosus juris, s0n of a humdrum retired lawyer, and the daughter of a respectable countr; parson? As a set-off, we know that Lili's family looked upon Goethe askance as not of their “set,” and that Weimar so ciety in the early days was anything but affable to the bourgeois. Of the seventeen chapters, these fou! have pleased us best: Goethe's Sister Cornelia, The Friena with the Beaut! ful Soul, Lili, Frau Aja. Of cours: such an estimate is purely subjective; each reader will judge for himself. At any rate, we must protest against the heading of the Sesenheim chapter: yoethe and his Beatrice. The picture ir The Nation “Dichtung und Wahrheit” is truly idyl- lic, but trait suggests Dante and The glorified Italian man Jed her worshipping lover through not a in if Beatrice. Wwo- the mysteries of Paradise; whereas Frederika, the gentle, ingenuous coun- ry maiden, led nobody, least of all Goethe; she merely listened and fol lowed. The chapter on Frau v. Stein is tiresome, though that is scarcely the fault of the author, rather of th ject. The author hits the nail on head, when she sserts 189, tha Frau v. Stein “was not really a woman ot great intelligence One mus have the courage of one’s convictior We of the twentieth century can d tect in Charlotte's diathe S a ting ( the morbid: he nqu ioned ae acy W a bit hect St t Goethe should hav ren ( | the ict so ] L W ‘ [ n | nkfo1 1 it ost from tl tart. In this « r the ne rave I 1 t G ! letter of June 1, 1789, t etter provoked the rupture, i riven at 207-9. In the original the preserved tl] ighout ! then, for skipping fr t and back to ‘thou n tf transl n And, p. 209, the phrase hen he vw able to get perspect ‘ . $s poor English. Among 1! ble ‘ e not p 184, A it, f konnt tw blurs th f | Casterta, p. 2¢ read Caserta, the name of a well-know lialian town. In four places, pp. 2¢ 273, 275, 278, the proper name Reiff: stein is printed Rieffenst At the translation rur Ev love ha t collec ind I ould l that reje bra ns were aga ccllected t n scatte ! thoughts Tr} utterance will ass dl be crypt t eve! read wit na I n witl tl Ge anguag f ( nizes the yord Y ect a l t tean Then, Goethe wrote, ¢ customal lirectness: To every love t e belongs Sammlung [a shrewd pla’ on t double meaning “collection” and omposure and I-would rather gather scatte 1 coins than scattered t hts In the note to ] 316, the te January 12, 1801, must be a sl for 1807. Uncorrected, the note impli: that Goethe's son August achieved the feat of tossing off seventeen glasses champagne at a sitting, when barety Add six years and ths One will by eleven years old feat becomes a sad possibility un familiar with German affairs somewhat mystified by the account, 254, of the dinner in honor of Frau Aja Why should the host be referred to as “Prince,” “Abbé,” and “Primate,” and who was he? One needs to be in formed that the host was the Prince Archbishop of Mainz, the oldest see in Germany. Whether. he Primate, as the Archbishop of Canterbury is Pri was 1 3 ~ é mate of England, may be questioned In 1806, Regensburg was to the fore We regret that the book contains so many illustrations by Kaulbach, f that artist's treatment is irremed coarse It merits a reversed John ian epitaph: @ fom f f a f fs hHS2 Witl ] l i ‘ And MeFa nd | \ 1\ be I eS ‘ W t ‘ ? i { ) ‘ nt ( t i i } } h ‘ | } t i ' ° ‘ ‘ i tT t ‘ ( Ir e | " il es] interesting in t ‘ nd i { al i ui p | curren f a i nd the ! i ta Fron this | I ot ] need for d t the dividual app he conse ‘ | ind pi ll { d cre eer I f det i t p i | > All ¢ to a { t j t I} I ul ed I I i pe ! d-hunge ba l | thu di t of paj | to pa 1 the ‘ to eva ; 4) ‘ ' } } of pap j t] eferring pa) nt appealed strong ose who needed f ef from de t is an ea transition from the pa ent of public indebtedness with | of credit, to issues by private organiza- tions for the relief of the unfortunate in land and commerce. This is the story that is told in Mr Davis's volumes, and no aspect of the question escapes consideration Mer chant, farmer, citizen, and offer their opinions in confusing n plicity, and some of the writers prominence in provincial affairs, ble of speaking with authority. Ti bor of identifying the writers alone Mmagis we trate nulti of capa- re 1e la con

Page 20

138 stituted a difficulty, which the editor has solved very successfully. But the chronological arrangement develops the extent and the strength of the discus- on, and the liberal extracts from the journals of the time add much to the opular understanding of the merits of The notes of the editor are bibliographical as well as ex- the matters at issue. planatory, and the student cannot go tray while threading his way through discussion. The experience was com- plete, extending from the first inception to the final redemption in specie, and conducted upon a scale equalled in no other part of the British colonies in the eighteenth century. The volumes ire as necessary to the historian as to the economist, and the illustrations of- onvenient aid to the bibliogra- and Reality: An Introduction to Theory of Knowledge. By John Elof Boodin New York: The Macmillan It is symptomatic of the weariness with ch philosophy is beginning to regard r-time inclusion within the cir- of mere experience that several re- nt ventures have adopted the name of ilism, to which, however, the “prag- matic realism” of the present writer has perhaps the best claim. Pragmatic real- endeavor to justify both the ght of the subject to measure reality } meanings and the right of reality tence (though not necessarily of its own. The situation vriter, who is professor Kansas and a graduate larval pparently made up of l empl m of James and the bse ( ealism of Royce As against that reality is 1 ir ’ nad ition Oo prag } | pil l on nt of hi ‘ ; ‘ hole ' ' npl ‘ P ! ? 7 T ’ { it i n in ft " to effect | 0 1 defin ! nd f real } the ec] ‘ on What Pra nd Is Not it should en f nything, indeed to recommend it. Here of the doctrine; ther hand, it ems that ill that has been claimed t, ‘ | — fulne is rejected as a riterion: and the general effect to transform a position which we pposed to be omew hat proudly in different to external authority into a rather servile deference tg fact Real. m suffers somewhat less at the writ [Vol. 94, No. 2432 The Nation | er’s hands, but, in order to forestall Professor Royce, he boldiy affirms that the real things are not indifferent to our ideas, though they may be lacking in any meaning of their own. How, then, can they respond to our meanings, so as to serve as material for truth? The writer replies by suggesting a “pre- existent fitness for truth” (p. 121), though rejecting a preéstablished har- mony (p. 253). Altogether, it must be said that the relation of the two terms of the problem is left very much in the air. The writer is evidently more in- terested in setting forth his views than in justifying them, or refuting the op- posing views, by closely reasoned ar- gument. Had he come to close quar- ters with his conceptions, he might have discovered, perhaps, that in a region of rather high criticism he was still oper- ating with an uncritical psychology, in which the facts are assumed to be once for all given independently of the ac- tion of ideas. The book is nevertheless a serious at- tempt in a direction which calls for some courage; and not altogether a fruitless attempt. Loosely put together, it is still full of suggestive material, especially in the chapters dealing with realism. The style is personal and frank, and pleasing if not always skil- ful. The undergraduate, for whom it is to be an “introduction,” will only open his mouth and wonder—at least after the middle of the book—but the maturer student of philosophy will read it with relish. “Pragmatic realism” has not yet been shown to be a contradiction in terms; let us hope that Professor Boodin may still get them adjusted. Notes xford University P1 s about to on copvricht. by G. 8. Robert- the light of the new Act Mr. William Hirsech’s “Religion und Civi- Standpunkte des Psychiaters,” rewritt " I h and will be t at once by the Truth Seeker \ Yor t of books of M: York we note Leona Dalr le “The 1 Deluge.” by Garrett P. Serviss; { 1 Flower Garden,” by Hanna iH I r House,” by Al i ind Andorra, the Hidden Re l I Ga 1 Lear | Return of Pierre a novel by Donal Ha te Haine i in preparation by H t Holt & Co Dr ] ‘ Devon has placed with John Lane Co. his new book, “The Criminal and the Community.” tome Oxford books in preparation by Frowde are “Townsend's Poems and Masks.” edited by EF. K. Chambers; “A by Manual of the Kashmiri Language,’ ‘ A. Grierson; “Responsible Government in the Dominions,” by A. B. Keith; “Tacitus’ Histories,” translated by W. H. Fyfe, and “Eomeri Opera V (Hymnos Cyclum Frag- menta Margiten Batrachomyomachiam Vi- tas Continens),” edited by T. W. Allen. The Century Co, is bringing out this nenth: “The Fighting Doctor,” by Helen R. Martin, and Isabel Gordon Curtis’s “The Weman from Wolvertoa,” a story of Wash- ington life. Henry Sienkiewicz has a new book in the press of Little, Brown & Co., “In Desert and Wilderness.” It deals with Africa at the time of the insurrection of the Mahdi, and is translated by Max A. Drezmal. Scribners announce a series of essays, “Why Should We Change Our Form of Gov- ernment?” by President Butler of Colum- bia. Other publicationsto be issued this month by the same house include: August Strind- Lerg’s dramas, “The Dream Play,” “The Link,” and “The Dance of Death,” parts i and ii, translated by Edwin Bjorkman; “Fathers of Men,” a story of English board- ing-school life, by E. W. Hornung; “The Chink in the Armour,” by Mrs. Belloc Lowndes; “Consul Assigned,” by Mary Ray- mond Shipman Andrews; “It and Other Stories,” by Gouverneur Morris: ‘Wide Courses,” by James B. Connolly; “The Inn of Tranquility,” a volume of essays, by John Galsworthy, and “Riding and Driving for Women,” by Belle Beach Among the books which will be brought out shortly by Longmans, Green & Co. are: ‘The Life of John Henry Cardinal New- man,” based on his private journals and correspondence, by Wilfrid Ward, in two volumes; “George the Third and Charles Fox,” the concluding part of “The Ameri- can Revolution,” by Sir George Otto Trevel- yan; “Spiritual Progress: A Word of Good Cheer,” by Rev. Arthur W. Robinson, with an introduction by the Bishop of London; Love's Ascent: Considerations of Some De- grees of Spiritual Attainment” by Rev. Jesse Brett, and “The Passion of Christ: A Study in the Narratives, the Circumstances, id Some of the Doctrines Pertaining to Trial and Death of our Divine Re- mer,”’ by Rev. James S. Stone. Books to be published by Houghton Mif- flin Co. on February 17 include: “The Heart of Us,”’ by T. Russell Sullivan; ‘The ist Cruise of the Saginaw,” by George H. Read; “The Luck of Rathcoole,” by inie Gould Lincoln; “The Egyptian Con- ’ eption of Immortality,” by George A, Reisner; “Harvard Essays on Classical Sub- ts,” edited by Herbert W. Smyth, and “Little Gray Songs from St. Joseph’s,” by Grace Fallow Norton. ro the Dictionary of National Biography, 1 new supplement will shortly be added by Smith & Elder, under the editorship of Sir Sidney Lee It will include mention of persons who died between the death of Queen Victoria (January 22, 1901) and the end of 1911. “The Power of Tolerance,” by George Harvey (Harper), is a_ collection of peeches that have been made in the last half-dozen years, and a narrative that originally appeared in Harpels Weekly. They are all readable, and some of them are much more than that Two of the more pretentious addresses are the first, which gives its name te the collection, and ithe one entitled “Journalism and the Uni-

Page 21

Feb. 8, 1912]

versity,” which was the 1908 Bromley ture at Yale. Not the least interesting fea- ture of the volume is the variety of oc- casions covered by the speeches. A reader wonders what freak of publishing policy is responsible for the use of the title of the initial address as a running title The top of each might have particular speech throughout the volume. right-hand page at least tained the title of the represented upon it, with an obvious gain in accuracy and convenience of reference con- Much is contained in little space in Mrs H. P. Clark’s book on Auction’ Bride: (Dodd, Mead). The chief points of tl game are concisely and clearly expressed, a real advantage to beginners who hesi tate to wade through the many pages of text and illustrative hands of the usual work on bridge. The tyro will here find in few words all he needs to know about the game Ralph Nevill’s “Floreat Etona” (Max millan) is confessedly an anecdotal story of Eton College, but it is based on sound knowledge of the historical background, and carries its anecdotes as far back as the records go. Those who have in their blood the Eton traditions will no doubt read the book with avidity; to the outsider, a clear picture of life at the most famous of the English public with its changes and its strange preservation of the past. Mr. Nevill writes from the frankly Tory point of deploring the rising tide of innovation, yet in the matter of curriculum of studies, which is in reality intimately associated with ideal, he himself something of an opportunist. We commend the book as good reading. The illustrations, largely private sources, are a distinct the text it gives schools, view, his conservative shows from addition t “Trekking the Great Thirst” (Scrib- ner), by Arnold W. Hodson has in- terest and value for several reasons, It is the story told in a quite art less way by a police officer of the Bechuanaland Protectorate, of his arduous duties in the hot and thirsty wastes of the Great Kalahari Desert, now the least known part of South Central Africa. Thess duties consisted of visits to the villages scattered over the wilderness for the col lection of the hut disputes, and the settlement of maintenance of tax, the law and order. Then he also had to explore un known regions and to report upon their suitability for cultivation or pasturage, to make roads and to designate the location sand-hills.”’ life of water pits in the “sea of This necessitated an almost continuous in the trackless infrequently in desert, where he great danger of from thirst In one large district the na tives and their cattle tirely upon melons for food and drink. On one of his first trips he was obliged to go with ox-wagons 110 miles across sand with no water supply on the way. service on the frontier during the Herrero war of 1904-5 he was commended both by the Germans and the British Foreign Of- fice. The country abounds in game, and he gives a list of thirty varieties which he shot, sport being his chief recreation. His narrative is substautially a transcript of his reports to the resident commissioner, and so has much monotonous detail. But it shows a true interest in the natives and was not perishing depend almost en For special lec- The Nation tactful dealing with them valuable exceedingly and information in re His interest in his lure of the contains some gard to their customs work Kalahari so was so great and the once strong that more than return to civilization he confesses to on his @ feeling of homesickness for “the wild des

ert country which had for so long a time been my home.” The hapter descriptiv fal ting trip of Lord § higt oner of South Afr 1 i ler the guidan of I tenant Hods« wa vr n t Mr. Vaughan-Kirt sport in ind author, who also contr } 1 t of 1 thrilling xper witl 1 one The eighty-five trat 1 of ¢ ‘ and +? rT f ? maps of routes across th lesert There-is much to 1 iba and Her Pec e of To-day (L. ¢ Pa X ( tr) author Fort Lindsa } ul Cubans, their virtu and hor it ind seeks to create a better und ling the part of Ar , wl rt have a moral respo ity tow i r public, but are ex ts | and their industries H tl history with special referer to its devel opment, and analyzes conditior both so ial and economic, a finds them to-day No people were more handicapped in their levelopment, he thinks, and “what the Cu- ban s to need than anything els to develop virilit ind hard common scns It i 1lways to be re é bored that he was freed fromiis swaddling hes bu esterda He r before had chance to grow ) h | i t think and act for 1 elf In Mr. Lindsa on ecendition of Cuba ora t t! Ifare « ts populati« t a f re own per ce a th land ! working Littl ri tl vyealth created t oreign capital finds i vay into tl | ets of the negro or th ijiro (the whit peasant juatter), who i neverthele op pressed by taxation, while the profession- 11 politician waxes fat and lives in cor ntment As a cor quence, there é i Mr. Lindsay 1 perma prot torate < } part of tl { lfed t is t I t « tual ethod of solv Cuba 1iffi t rhe ire chapt toba i gar ! I ™ I tura ind mi al ft ree ad ‘ r eettle 1 ’ | il! ratic Maurice Evan Har has edited and the Clarendon Pre has is l The Rowley Poems of Thomas Chatterton.” A para graph fro th Introduction will gi the exact procedure in forming the This edition is a reprint of Tyrwhitt’s third (1778) edition, which it follows pag: for page (except the glossary; se« p. 291). The reference numbers in text and glossary, which are often wrong in 1778, been corrected; line-numbers have wrong, and added to which are without them in 1778, and the text hag been collated throughout with that of 1777 and corrected from it in many places where the 1778 print er was at fault These corrections have been made silently: all other corrections and additions are indicated by footnotes en- closed in square brackets. note on have been one corrected when or two poems In the Glossary Mr. Hare has added the definition of a number of words which Tyr- whitt, not knowing Chatterton’s use of the dictionaries of Kersey and Bailey, could not

nd sensible in his introductory remarks on Chatter ton’s act of forgery, finding it possit to treat the boy poet with tenderness hout lispla « any silly rancor towards Wal po In hi ritical re irks |! ta ways *0 happy. He quotes, for t ‘ stanza from “A@lla” See! the whrte ua es Whyte ys Why ° ya t « Whe ‘ he eve “ vith the comment A bette ( in this « what called the tt f ] It is unfortunate t vho } \ “A } l to ¢ ) +} har of Chatterton (wl at h lut q ) sl ld so oft fa t ‘ 1 of xtrava iT We t I bibliog ipl Mr Ha f i ‘ tion (perha intentior ) f it « I i ( tt M t Yard & tt \ t Monta is t t t) or M M 1 luct gned), } ur to earth Sophie Da Q f Chanti La ) 1‘ better known the Baronne le | ye in her la i andal« part tl ate hist of the Orlea Her name, Ww be ve ha t } red in Engli biographical liter ‘ tl author was of the opinion that ‘ f life of the “extraordinar v in wh for near! twenty year ruled ‘ t! ind ind cor len of tl inwor lant of the great Cond ht t t ionger vithheld. And tl I ippar t! has no diffi t j | j ind for aught we know, may find read for, a letailed account of the ] an | lish adventure of tl ow tt wil became the istres f the D ! 5 bon and was tried on tl har ft 4 i é ory to hist sterle leatl it M. Bers » has rt t his tem a general treatise ! but he has at | 1] l her Hy t t eal t 1 t! t | crous (“Laughter.” Tl Ma illar Co.) H att t ' ’ of t er} at ‘ - af rt But fr ] har ter of rt fl n t M. Bers ) thing und bh littl t h mor f literar i t f i Tt i i gf t ra vid ! t ] j I 1 of t t a for i Z ed t 4 al ! ] ! ly f Ir 1 in t of t! 1—t r of t xa ar ! odated onl I torturing fut retat ; rr? ! is thus an admirable ) n of 1 le spect of tl cor 4 at t ame time it is one long seri of g ral zations that will not bear a mx nt’s parison with the facts M. Bergson's v firet assertion, for example, is that uv comic does not exist outside the ale of what is strictly human.” Has he, then, never seen a dachshund? Or does he think that when we laugh at a pun, we are always laughing at the author of it, and not at th: explain. Mr. Hare is moderate an

Page 22

i “ t His last conte { ‘ na laughter is iiways ( ii I tion a 1 has ta h « isperit if not of cr that patl i ipable of ntering to th " f th ‘ ly fleetingly and A ipse | i ition Can it be that M. Bers ha witnessed tl admir ! | lor laugt f row ups at tl l table blunders of children—one of the great sourc of natural laughter-sup- ! ra l his ransiators, C I ind | Re ll. th author has aga I fortunat their English is often " M. Bers n's French Occa r. the ss a French idiom rer rait d rien de trés bienveil- pl hould not t rendered t! } ry benevo ] hter 1 So far, then t ] tol othing ver enevo i ! f ! ike of stylis ot losing of tl book ) i lated Wh a tt find in 1ught i 1 petit juantite ade i rta lo l‘amertu t it hat on find i ! after ‘ ' Hlow Jol » tw years i titled W t I Real ] } ppli it th ! » t I the to e attempt to neile ] +) ‘ ‘ rit ; . +f . on ect ript t on human ex tr o volution is tl ‘ facts of expe ’ 1 and mad ur Al alir ealed thi yu i ! xa I ich doctrin ot i 1 benevo t of God il t har t with the bod Christiar God, a ’ } ew } } he t ta iH tlhe 1 t He \ but inifestiy His works f ! t 1 petter to I gz t tat H elf than t rior. The ! in tl 1 I trad il . respecting t itty it of God are recog 1, but t ended taat there ars hi! re than compensate in f tl God of things as rl il result of such n'eas ' itisfaction of neither ! ! if l t : l that fail to nee either t a to the religious implica ! r tl taeologian as to ! odit if of religious doc ff t with the pragmatist’s | tr vhich work ta that ] o doctrines have yet ! ff t 1 t afford a basis " { itis on | Port ) { reity Pr ) ad l t f rt un and | : i the Iit fol l Hamt ind theauthor Is equal \ 1 t if r r transportation 1 A 1 is to 1 r *) t ist be ] | that of t) I und the Rhine 7 [ T i W ] ‘Lhe Nation feld's standard work on “Die nordwest- europdischen Welthdfen,” but he has car- ried on independent investigations, and pro- luced a valuable handbook, not too techni- al for the general reader, on the port fa- ilities and the maritime commerce of Hamburg, with some sidelights on German waterways and railways generally. te highly lauds the dock system of Hamburg, as contrasted with that of London, Liver- pool, and Antwerp. Mr. Clapp evidently identifies himself with the enthusiastic ad- vocates of a great trans-oceanic Germany, is he quotes approvingly from Professor Schmoller’s speech in 1899, as follows: “We ist desire that, at any price, a German land with a German population of twenty to thirty millions shall arise in South Brazil in the course of the next century. It is indifferent whether it becomes an in- lependent state, or whether it comes in e connection with our Empire.” The ovement of German emigration does not to bear out this prognostication. Sir James MacPherson Lemoine died at 1ome in Quebec on Monday, aged eighty- In 1897 he was knighted for his lit- iry work, which includes books, in both nglish and French, mostly on the history Among them are “L’Ornitho- logie du Canada,” “Les Pécheries du Cana- i.”” “Maple Leaves” (6 vols.), “The Scot in f Canada Ne France,” “The Chronicles of the St Lawrence,” and “Monographies et esquisses.” The death is reported, in his seventy-sec- 1 year, of Otto Liebmann, who up to last summer, when he resigned, was pro- fessor of philosophy at the University of na He was the “Kant und die Epigonen,” Vier Monate vor Paris,” author of several im- portant works: the latter a diary kept luring the Franco-Prussian War; Analyse der Wirklichkeit,” and “Gedanken Prof. Salomon Lefmann, who died recent- ly at tl age of eighty. was professor of Sanskrit at the University of Heidelberg \t least two of his works deserve mention: Vistara, tibersetzt und = erklart” id “Geschichte des alten Indiens.” Maurice Maeterlinck Is fortunate among contemporary men of letters in his ap- ‘parent immunity from adverse criticism. Either the Belgian writer has been uni- ally accepted, or else those who find choose to be silent. 4 rare exception is the Abbé Ernest Dimnet, n him no appeal who, in a trenchant paper in the Nineteenth Century entitled “Is M. Maeterlinck Crit- illy Estimated?” Belgian philosopher without gloves We say the philosopher, because with Maeterlinck the poet and dramatist the Abbé has no quar- handles the rel He does protest against the concep- tion of Maeterlinck as a sage and a guide to life 1s the Belgian’s most successful experi- ment In the fleld of speculative thought, our Taking “Le Trésor des humbles” writer is chiefly impressed ‘“‘by the pleasure M. Maeterlinck takes in stringing words together, and by his indifference to the de- elop nt of the lea from which he originally started.” In “La Sagesse et la destinée” we do find one idea which has en helpful to many discouraged souls, uit it is not an original discovery. The notion that Destiny is only a word and that free-will can modify the so-called | Vol. ug No. 2432 course of fate was long ago expressed in the French proverb, “Aide-toi, le Ciel t‘aidera.” The real cause of his popular- ity lies in “the snobbishness of the crowd —I mean the reading, not the working crowd.” The success of his philosophical books is “of exactly the same order as the success of any second-rate novel or drama.” His influence does not count with people who count. By contrast with this vehement bit if depreciation we may mention a short paper by Randolph S. Bourne in the Atlantic Monthly entitled “The Mystic Turned Rad- Mr. Bourne finds that by long wan- dering in the field of semi-conscious sensa- tions, Maeterlinck has attained a clarity of vision which, trained upon the social problems of the day, has made him the leading exponent of the rights of the inner man as against the scientific determinism of the times. ical.” In the same number of the Atlantic Har- riet Finlay-Johnson describes under the Dramatized” a scheme of pedagogics which suggests that a better title would have been “Education Anar- chised.” In the model school under consid- eration—Miss Johnson frankly places it in Utopia—work begins at no slavishly fixed hour. “Just as soon as We can race there, will be the correct time for us.” When the teacher appears and says, “Now, l]’m ready,” the children bring forth specimens of flowers, weeds, leaves, grasses, and shells, and each child tells “exactly in its own way” what it has found and observed for itself The elder children produce wooden ships of their own manufacture ind a geography lesson begins. Objects in the classroom serve as mimic mountains apes, and islands, and the children are frankly delighted “when they discover that the North end of the room is really the coldest end, because that makes it easy to all it the North Pole.” By what system of internal heating and ventilation the teacher succeeds in producing extraordinary climatic differences within a small class- room is not stated. In the same way arithmetic is dramatized by setting the hildren to dance with each other, after assigning a number to each child and stipulating that the arithmetical sum of every couple must be 10. It is a striking anomaly of revolutionary educational thought of the day that with the progress of democracy and the vast increase in the number of children who must be trained, name “Education the methods being evolved should be in- creasingly complicated, deliberate, and costly Jules Lemaitre has remarked of the elaborate Rousseauan system of educa- tion that it is “simply and purely a dream of an education ultra-aristocratic.” Samuel McChord Crothers has a delightful paper in the Century on what he calls “The Obviousness of Dickens,” from which one feels tempted to quote again and again. Dr. Crothers admits that the humor, the pathos, and the people in Dickens are obvious, but he begs to distinguish between the percep- tion of the obvious, which is no great mer- it, and the creation of the obvious, which is genius. The writer confesses that like certain Mid-Victorian Lord Chancellors, he has wept over Little Nell. “Doubtless we ought not to have done so. Our excuse is that, at the time, we could not help it. We may make the further plea, common to all ee ee

Page 23

Feb. 8, 1912} soft-hearted sinners, that if we hadn't wept other people would, so that no grea was done after all.” Obvious? Yes The man with the flamboyant whom you saw on the 8:40 train may als be the author of a volume of exquisit ics but you never saw th lyrics did see the necktie. In the scale the necktie may be the least importa of this good man’s life, but it is t thing about him which attracts att . We see things and infer orrespond It is not the whol it is all of him that is for we are very Dickensy So Madame 3ovary and Mast Solness are acutely) nalyzed;: in the yellow curl-papers In the World’s W k ther pre atic ‘ < 1 I relat +} At ~ } ‘ Cwedich wu ; 1 ‘ ' S T 7 , Basil ; Qe -_ 1 : the Contemporary R } s ]T é } 7, ‘ sa ) tir y I I S f s of ter Te 1p 1a . ’ g iter ' 1 oY fied | lid and not } I I 1 for arguing i 7 1 R is S vit} er r ¢ f th Science THE ANCIENT FEUD Pee air n Conte Philoso} B Emile Boutroux Translated by Jonathan Nield. Ne York: The Macmillan Co. $2 net It annot be said that Ir. Nield’s translation is in all respects fortunate The English style is unattractive and occasionally lacking in lucidity. This however, is not altogether Mr. Nield’s fault. In Professor Boutroux’s style one looks in vain for that lucidity and pr cision which usually characterize mod ern French writing, and most of the un- fortunate qualities of the translation a but reflections from the original. The book is a scholarly exposition and able criticism of the leading attempts made during the last century to end th: conflict between science and religion, to- gether with Professor Boutroux’s own view as to the solution of the problem In the early part of the last century, our author points out, there was a lull in the conflict; a temporary armistice was patched up on the basis of a division of the human functions, after the manne! suggested by Schleiermacher. But in the fourth decade of the century the struggle broke out again and has been raging ever since. The account of this ‘The Nation StLTULEB Ie vl fil most of the yvoiun lis into two parts, which expound re pectively r} Na ralistic Tendency} ] rhe Sp tualis Tendency Uy the first heading Boutrouy eals (¢ e, dS r, Ha ke ind hat n the French « I ‘ KIS ‘ na 5 { £ ‘ The expe S t ’ « t t r ( , Ty ‘ ‘ ( tl i 1s . ‘ ‘ | \ pe , oles ‘ ‘ t ‘ ‘ ‘ 1] rhe i ¢ , ‘ | t ‘ ‘ nkno ble and t pre Herbert Spence i i 1 ed to it a ies t t these 1d nt ( know ledg iré rt ipable of progre nd development? If the H nit (Grand-} ( of Al guste Comte an incomplete and ur stable conception, seeing that ma I essence. a being ho gor beyond If there is still greate easol I ve ul things proceed, and then tell them that they can neither understand nor depend upon this Being in the smallest degrees The weakness of Comte’s position re appears in an exaggerated form in the materialistic “Monism” of Haeckel. On the one hand, indeed, Haeckel’s solution of the controversy between science and religion is beautifully simple—religion namely, is altogether illusory and must eventually disappear before science. But on the other hand, like Comte, Haeckel recognizes that there are certain peren- nial human demands, especially those represented by the words Truth, Beau- ty, Goodness, which are satisfied in part eligis nd I t does no tists l fT seeks to a d by . vie ‘ ‘ I 1 srr ai | : " rT} : ' ‘ ; al } t ma ré de ‘ ! i ! ib] ’ t ’ by tre opinion hy ‘ or i tak if of t ! ' i ‘ ] } io! really going to be ¢ " d y the facts of human consciousne peal must be made to clousners as it is, in its full and complex richness of yn crete actuality, not to a collection of manufactured “ideas “laws etc., In vented by an artificial associationism And if we view consciousness as it rea! ly is, and appeal to it, we shall find in it a fulness of life which is religion and which is not explicable by an) scientific categories It may, indeed

Page 24

142 that religious phenomena are only sub- jective phenomena; but from this it does not follow that they are therefore in no way different from other phenom- ena or that the claims of religion are illusory. For the modern view of relig- ion makes God immanent rather than transcendent and his relation to us an inner rather than an outer one. And the reason why psychology can find in religion phenomena nothing peculiar may be because it is impossible for psychology to take note of anything that does not fit into her categories. An in- telligent electric light could never see a shadow; but shadows would exist none the le 558. An interesting treatment of Ritsch- lianism begins part ii, the “Spiritual Tendency.” Boutroux is not blind to advantages of Ritschl’s attempted divorce between religion and theology. If such a complete separation could in- deed be brought about, there would seem to be little chance of conflict between science and religion. But, as a fact, its original form re- the Ritschlianism in tains enough objective conrent to make it very open to the attacks of science; and its ideal of religion without any metaphysic, if actually attained, would make faith nothing but subjectivism without content. And even in this un- obtrusive and non-militant form, faith i not b secure against the at- i ence for since the days of n the form of psychol is | n the invasion of the inner nd I on is to remain s here yme more adequate de be found for her than that by Ritschliani defen iy be obtained i nta of the analysis of ) ich en as Poincaré, ] ix \ i fair pre- ‘ t p n of t men t little qual atic i lern d nde nee is herself a ted both in her } pt lier ol t Dp i than reali nd t | rt nd « ons of experience rather than ex the truth about an indepen rea y Yet our iuthor warns u t ft j it optimism even here I le dogmatic in her own claims t of ence ig no more ready t n for rly to admit the claims of re- ligior Rather she will insist that if a thing 1 unknowable for her it is @ fortiori unknowable for religion and every other discipline. And a solution of the on the basis of the lim its of sclence will satisfy neither science problem nor religion [wo more spiritualistic attempts considered—the “Phil- (as Boutroux calls a and the at solution are now osophy of Action” modification of pragmatism) appeal of Willlam James to religious ex- The Nation [Vol. 94, No. 2432 perience. These are taken up in turn and treated with a good deal of appre-| ciation. In our author’s opinion, how- ever, neither of them is satisfactory to either science or religion. Thus we are brought, in a somewhat bewildered state, to the “Conclusion.” And the Conclusion does little to abate our bewilderment. In it Boutroux at- tempts to make clear his own solution of the problem, but unfortunately the skill he displayed in expounding other men’s views seems to desert him when he starts to explain his own. Throngh- out this whole concluding chapter his thought wavers and winds, paragraphs follow each other with little logical con- nection, and one gets the impression that one is reading the jottings from a notebook rather than a careful presenta- tion of a single line of thought. The gist of the conclusion is that the con- flict is not so much between science and religion as between the scientific spirit and the religious spirit; that these two have to do with such different aspects of life and mind as to be almost incom- mensurable; and that therefore neither can nor should really destroy the other. This conclusion is based in part upon the modern view of the nature and limits of view which, it will be re- membered, our author in a chapter had affirmed was of little use in the solution of the conflict. This is an science—a inconsistency which he, apparently, fails | to or at any rate nowhere at- tempts to explain. In contradistinction to the impersonal point of view which cience maintains toward experience, re- takes the personal and subjec- tive attitude. This is equally real and justifiable, and in the great religions it notice, ligion is broadened by looking at things not from the point of view of a single indi- vidual but from that of society as a le. Further expositions of the mean- of religion waver be- with morality no and nature tween identification of it ind the insistence in addition upon faith in some sort of supernatural and metaphysical sanction. It is therefore hard to see how our author would meet the dilemma: in so far as religion is nassailable by science, it is only mor- ality; in so far as it is more than mor- ality, it is still open to the attacks of clence. Of course, it may be able to resist those attacks; but, be that as it may, Professor Boutroux’s proposed treaty of peace would appear to be no- thing than for a re- newal of hostilities. In short, it does not the age-long conflict will be ended by the appearance of this book. Boutroux’s solution of it Is open to the same dou- ble criticism that he makes upon the solutions of most of his predecessors— it will be acceptable neither to science nor to religion. But for all that, the work is a valuable presentation of an question, earnest, judicial, more an occasion important previous | eem likely that} ‘scholarly, and helpful. And though its value lies chiefly in its criticisms, it will rank as a real contribution to what the author calls the “spiritualistic ten- dency.” Charles Gilbert Wheeler, the chemist and mining geologist, died last week in Chicago, aged seventy-five. He was born in London, Canada, graduated from Har- vard in 1858, studied in foreign universi- ties, and in 1868 was appointed professor of chemistry in the University of Chicago; at the time of his death he was the last survivor of the original faculty of the old university. He invented the Babcock chem- ical fire-extinguisher in 1869, and was geologist and interpreter—he spoke seven modern languages—on the Commission to jexamine the route of the Nicaraguan Ca- |nal in 1899. Several books in his particular | subjects bear his name. Dr. David Christison, whose death is an- nounced from Edinburgh, was among the |first to become interested in scientific |archwology in Scotland. Besides numerous | papers on the subject, he wrote “Early For- | tifications in Scotland” and “The Prehistoric | Forts of Scotland.” Drama and Music EXOTIC PLAYS. The current theatrical season has brought the American playwright face to face with a formidable Asiatic peril. If this were not a bad time for protec- tive tariffs in general, our dramatists might well appeal to Congress for a heavy import duty on Oriental drama, with which the stage is in danger of be- ing swamped. The beginning of 1912 in New York found no less than four plays of lifein the distant and odorous East. “Sumurfin” and “Kismet” are straight out of the Arabian Nights. “The Garden of Allah” is North Africa. “Ben Hur’—this last, it is true, of na- tive manufacture—is Syria and Pales- tine in Roman times. Add to this “The Arab,” produced earlier in the season, the play of native life in Hawaii now running, “Madama Butterfly” at the Metropolitan Opera House, and the Rus- sian dancers pretty nearly everywhere, and it is apparent that the playboys of the Eastern world are having things very much their own way with us at present. A play of Chinese life is an- fnounced for immediate production. A Japanese play, “Typhoon,” has been given at the German theatre in this city. What other evocations of the East are ‘before us, one can hardly say. The out |look is that very few corners of the Mo- | nammodan, Buddhist, and Polynesian | world will be left untouched before the | fashion changes. | Some of the causes that have set this wave of Orientalism sweeping over Eu- rope and this country are not difficult to trace. The underlying motive is the

Page 25

Feb. 8, 1912] passion for novelty which makes itself felt in the theatre more powerfully than in any other form of art. Europe seems to have grown pretty tired of the romantic drama, the social drama, and the out-and-out sex drama in its fam‘liar Occidental form. In this con- nection it is significant that “Sumurdn,” the latest word in spectacular exoticism, should come from the man who was a pioneer in Germany of the intimate so- cial drama, or Kammerspiele. In re- action against the painful realism of a few years ago we have the phantasy of the East. In reaction against the toy- theatre we have the elaborate specta- cle. Probably, too, the decline of good acting enters into the problem. Scen- ery and costume-display strive to atone for the essential element in the pleasure of the theatre—impersonation. Above and beyond all this, one wonders how much is to be explained by the course of history in the East during the last few years. The average theatre-goer is not peculiarly interested in the pro- gress of international politics. But the men who cater to the theatre-going pub-. lic may very well have been attracted by the stir, the turmoil, and the clash of events in Japan, China, India, Persia, Egypt, Morocco, and Tripoli. In our own case there is still another cause to be taken into account, and that is the widening scope of foreign travel among the well-to-do. People who once went to the Riviera now cross over to Algeria and Tangier, and Biskra is becoming as familiar as Nice and San Remo. Egypt has grown almost com- monplace. People nowadays winter in India, Hawaii, and Manila. Frequent round-the-world excursions set out from Atlantic and Pacific ports. Here, then, is a considerable constituency to which the theatre offers an opportunity to re- vive the recollections and the atmos- phere of the East. And there is, of course, the added advantage that the theatre allows ‘the traveller to see, or at least pretends to let him the intimacies of that Oriental life of which he has caught only a hasty glance at the externals between two dips into Baedeker. The stage will always be more interesting than life, we presume, and the costumes in “Kismet” and “Su- murin” are probably more Oriental to the ordinary eye than the crowds at Algiers or in Bombay. There is a certain irony in the fact that a wave of Eastern invasion should have broken upon us just when patriot- ic theatrical criticism was celebrating the emancipation of the Amevican the- atre from the foreign yoke and the com- ing of the American dramatist into his own. Theorizing is always a little be- hind the facts in the theatre, as in every other field. The plays that have made their impress upon the present theatri- cal season, with a few exceptions, are see, The Nation the specimens of Eastern drama have enumerated, plus such foreign products,-or plays dealing with foreign subjects, as “Bunty,” the Irish Players, and “Disraeli’—the last one, by the way, dealing with precisely the spot in- dicated by Mr. Kipling as the dividing point Western and Eastern morals. In this temporary the drama of native there cause for fear or regret. In the of the drama, as a branch of art, petition is not yet obsolete. There is no between ol is no field com.- retrogression life, reason why we should prefer a third rate American play by an American writer to a good play from abroad. We cannot help feeling that the young American playwright has gone in too much for the type of the times and the question of the hour. Captains of indus- try and political bosses have beset us in wearying succession. and the cost of living are serious problems, but a more serious and interesting problem is life. To the extent that our play- wrights are dealing honestly with life they will need no protection against for Trusts eign competitors. “The War God,” by Israel Zangwill, is promised by Macmillan for this month. In it Bismarck, but lightly veiled, personifies War, and Tolstoy Peace William Watson’s “Heralds of the Dawn,” which John Lane Co. promises for March is in four acts and is written mainly in blank vers The five or six small volumes of the Tudor Shakespeare (Macmillan) which have reached us give an adequate idea of what this edition when will be. From the mere announcement of the work it was complete all along clear that the general editors, Professors W. A. Neilson and A. H. Thorn- dike, were concerned to choose competent assistants. Fach play has a separate edi- tor, save for “Romeo and Juliet,” which the general editors themselves have done, presumably to indicate the method of treat- ment desired. As much of the best Ameri- ean scholarship is to be employed on the Tudor Shakespeare, one can confidently predict that glaring errors will be lacking, and that all the latest investigations on various phases of the subject will be re- ferred to To speak safely seems to be the main impulse of the editors, and the edition might properly have been called the Safe and Sane Shakespeare, even though that title implies some lack of inspiration True, the size of the volume—slightly lare- er than that of the little Temple Shake- speare—leaves small room for flourishes even if they were desirable. An introduction of about ten pages goes over the usual mat- Date of Style, etc the general editors, the named topic is finished off in fifteen to us that even a compact Composition, Sources the examplar ters of Text, of the Plot, put out by In last- lines It occurs intro- the play very vol- have done more with and Juliet.” Each brief notes and a appearance the outside, are most agree- thus far received, besides might “Romeo very duction style of is followed brief umes, by glossary In inside We have and able we 143 the “Romeo and Juliet,” “Henry VI,” part 1, edited by Louise Pound; “Henry IV part i, edited by Frank Wadleigh Chandler; “As You Like It edited by Martha Hale Shackford; “Henry V," edited by Lewis F. Mott: “The Merchant of Venice edit- ed by Parry Morgan Ayres, and “Macbeth,” edited by Arthur C,. L. Brown rhe price is thirty-five cents net the vol “Lydia Gilmor« the latest sta vor f Henry Arthur Jones, now to b« en in the Lyceum Theatre and described on tl pr gram as a ind orig 1 pla longs to the cla pot-t It however, superior t the majority f its kind in workmanship and invention rhe object of it is two-fold—first, t furnish as many theatrical thrill old and new, as possible within a given space for the de- lectation of the crowd, and, secondly, to supply Margaret Anglin, or of our most loqu ‘ tional a with an abun- lan of harrow itions. Unfortunate- l in his efforts to pile up the agony, Mr Jones has partly defeated his own purpose, His first act is a masterly bit of melodrama, The artificial nature of it apparent only upon reflection. «In act it is swift, plaus- ble, and highly effective rhe ene is the drawing-room of a country ! N Dr. Gilmore. There has been a dinner party, and one of the guests, Ja tracey, @& neighbor, is going to London after taking his wife home Every ons heerful for the doctor has just given h t the betrothal of his sister to an ardent young lover Only the doctor 8 ] traught be- au Mr Stracey, his secret has ven in a gnation at her ! after her h ind’s departure i i lis- covered thi and in aying l ht dig- cour tl beauti of fr ! } ently Gil goes out, to si i as he says, bidding his wife, Lydia, not to t up jut the latter has work t lo for her little boy, a young scapegra ie sible for the unexpected entrar fr ard Benham, K.C., an old k r of } ther Benham avows a pa yn, which Lyd as wife and mother, decla ! H hen retires, and alin ] G returns, trembli and horror f to confess his intrigue with Mrs a and his murder, after a strugz!l } ! band, who had been await ! t 4 a most striking scer cleverly agined and vividly told, and ends tl f ict with an uncommonly ¢ tive « x. TI i act, in which Lydia, for her l l's ike olunteers to perjure her f in order to prove an alibi for her husband, if ry, s also strong and interestir but after that hat is eant to be tl t of I Ay proves its weakne I lia pelled to tell the truth to Benha who can lisprove the alit and the latter, a famous lawyer, suddenly urged with tl prose cution of Gilmore, who has bee ir d, carefully instructs Lydia how t erjure herself to the best advantag« and ledges himself to ald her in his cross-examination In the ensuing court scene this plot—which makes criminals of both hero and heroine is successfully carried out, until an anony- mous letter to the judge—a trick unworthy of Mr. Jones—causes Lydia to break d 1 and betray herself in a fit of ungovernable hysteria. To crown all Gilmore commits suicide in order that Lydia and Benham may be united in the end. Rarely has Mr.

Page 26

144

I itio iad gulit ina YT } ich i But it only fair to add that ! l \ I re irkable I athe ar theatr l ich of his characteriza- His t ore at fault I nst rhe é , a8 a ] n the case | ) i I lia with re ind infit variety of é t | H personal su < } was indis] ible ing | luctl f 0 r 7 t I Liebler & Co, ! al ! To the Bill Sykes if lit the Nancy yf Constance Ol r of Marie Doro can ! M | yf Susanna Shel I 0 \\ lha th Grit I r M h I Month of Er I Hr | Charles Harbut I | } LYo It i ! ‘ T il [ he ) ‘ ' . | igair | to | furi tl t Ww reve! for tl ; t t {) i ict rowd Ng a rad ) ratify ; ] ) } f t +) f ] ris [ t t t forgotten tl hid ‘ ! te! of J. W. Wallack I d m 4 f rt’s Bill i T have ‘ acter f Dick i t and vita ! Ca ! ttle of Florer | I Cale Owe and J M AW of G I Ro | | \ ird, tl Jing! yf i ‘ } t! ‘ is po ) at of t ndividuality | l I s | ! their reator ; t t ist i t tho ids of I atl long ago passed ! (or h ? ’ la new thre act i of A rican lif titled Ransom- ed by Theodore Burt Sayre and Cleve- land Rogers. He will produce it early next sea Frank Curzon and Marte Tempest will goon tal harge of the Prince of Wales's ] atre, in London, They will begin opera t s with a new play by Anthony Whar t i hor of Ire Wycherly.” The new ri iid to be of a much more heerful It s called “At the Barn,” and ! rid » contain an excellent part for M I pest. Evidently the lady is of the he would have allowed some ’ roduce tl pier ; { r! Kenyon who has established a ler ‘ reputation in the English pl nee haa taken a lease of the Littl tre 1 London, and will produce thers e Blindness of Virtue,” an adaptation ! Coamo Ha illton of his own novel of hat narn This s a thesia play, of an unced”’ character, dealing with the ed ition of girle and the responsibilities of mothers , * . Cyril Maude is going to revive Capt Marshall's “‘The Second in Command” at tl Playhouse in Lond

‘The \rthur Chudleigh has produced a new Nation ay by R. C. Carton at the London Comedy atre It is called The Bear Leaders.” The two principal characters, to be played by M‘ss Compton and Edmund Gwenn, ars supposed to be ppo prominent figures in the world of fashion, who, with the view of eking out a tenuous income, undertake the instruction of youthful members of the aristocracy. In other words, they charge themselves with the task of licking society ibs into shape. Among those confided to their care is a youthful couple, boy and girl, and it is with the development and ultimate fate of the pair that Mr. Carton’s story is concerned, Florence St. John, Whose death is an- nounced from London, was a capable and statuesque performer, whose artistic ca- pacity was not in full proportion to the great popularity which she enjoyed for many years upon the English stage. Her maiden name was Florence Grieg, and she was born in Devonshire fifty-seven years ago She was married early in life and afterward to the well-known actor M. Ma- rius (Duplany). She attracted the attention of H. B. Farnie and Alexander Henderson, who engaged her for London, where she acted and sang with success in “Les Cloch- es de Corneville,” “Madame Favart,” and Olivette.” Her prosperity endured for irs. Some of |! hief successes vere mad in “The Great Mogul,” “Faust Up to Date.” “Carmen Up to Date,” “Little Christopher Columbus,” “The Grand Duch- é et In later years she acted in com- ed \ omposition of especial interest will I n the programme of the fourth sub- ription oneert of the Kneisel Quartet 1t the Hotel Astor on the evening of Feb- ruary 13—the Quintet in B minor for two violins, viola, ‘cello, and clarinet, op. 115. It is one of the four chamber works by Brahms in which the clarinet is employed. Leon Le Roy, clarinetist, will assist the Quartet. At the second subscription concert of the MacDowell chorus in Carnegie Hall on February 12, the entire Philharmonic Or- chestra will take part, and the soloists will be Maggie Teyte and George Harris, jr The programme will comprise short con- trasting numbers intended to represent the modern French school. A special feature will be the first American performance of excerpts from Debussy’s “Le Martyr de St. Sebastien If the present rumors about a season of French opera at the Century Theatre prove to be true, there will be much rejoicing among its lovers, who are many, and who, since the closing of the Manhattan Opera House, have been longing to hear favorite works of the French school more frequent- ly With such artists as Mary Garden, Maggie Teyte, Maurice Renaud, Charles Dalmores, Hector Dufranne, Gustave Hu berdean, and others of lesser note, the enture would doubtless be a success The Bishop of London did not allow Handel to produce his oratorios as operas, but the Moody-Manners Opera Company has just obtained permission from the Lord Chamberlain to produce a dramatic version of Mendelssohn's “Elijah,” which, accord- ingly, ie to be brought out with splendid to , 7 | Vol. 94, No. 243 scenery and costumes. The reverend Dr. Haweis used to maintain that all oratorios would be much more popular if given as operas The London Symphony Orchestra, which is to arrive in New York on April 8 for a series of concerts, under Arthur Nikisch, will in twenty-two days give twenty-two concerts, and travel 5,000 miles, as far West as Denver and North as Toronto and Montreal. The members will travel in a special train-de-luxe, on which not only will they sleep, but also do the necessary re- hearsing Art Dr. Hofstede de Groot of The Hague will publish Macmillan the fourth volume of his “Catalogue Raisonné of the Works of the Most Eminent Dutch Painters of the Seventeenth Century,” trans- lated and edited by Edward G. Hawke. It includes the paintings of Jacob von Ruis: dael, Meindert Hobbema, Adriaan van der Velde, and Paulus Potter. shortly through Among the books imported by Lemcke & Buechner are “Les Temples immergés de la Nubie; Debod bis Bab Kalabzche,” a monograph in German, by G. Roeder, and ‘Miniaturen aus Handschriften der Konig}, Hof und Staatsbibliothek Miinchen,” issued by Dr. George Leidinger. The latter pub- lication will begin with “Miniaturen des Evangeliariums berihmten sogenannten Kaiser Ottos III.” Many critics have attributed to Leonardo da Vinci a little Madonna in the collection of Mme. Bénois at St. Petersburg. Others have been repelled by the somewhat primi- tive aspect of this charming work. Sidney Colvin, in the Burlington Magazine for January, reproduces from a sheet of draw- ings by Leonardo in the British Museum no less than three composition studies for the Bénois picture. It is apparently one of the “two Virgin Maries” the beginning of which is noted on an Uffizi drawing dated 1478 The identification of this early Madonna reopens the whole problem of Leonardo's origins. Obviously the discovery tends to confirm the views of the Jate Eugéne Miintz, who ascribed to Leonardo a considerable number of finer pieces of Verrocchian type “Sculpture in Spain” (Lane), by Albert F. Calvert, is an extended essay by the ac- complished editor of the “Spanish Series,” and contains 162 illustrations. The early period is treated topically—a chapter on architectural sculpture, another on tombs, on altarbacks, ete. This involves discon- certing leaps and retrogressions waich may confuse the beginner. With the fifteenth entury begins a more satisfactory arrange- en§ by schools and artists. The survey nds with the seventeenth century The book is rather a record than a criticism Indeed, Mr. Calvert's comment is pretty well confined to running praise of Spanish polychromy and apologies for Spanish naturalism. It is not strange that he should somewbat exaggerate the msthetic value of this art. His constant reminder that we must assume the standpoint of Spanish sensationalism will remind a_ thoughtful reader that the eulogy is after all relative and adjusted to Iberian latitudes. Though

Page 27

Feb. 8, 11:2] less comprehensive and thorough than Paul Lafond’s “La Sculpture espagnole,” this book may better serve the need of the aver- age reader. page 74, Annunciation printed where the corresponding plate shows On is Assumption is intended. It may be well t note here that the Hispanic Museum in this city contains fine examples of Spanish sculpture of the best periods. The Egypt Exploration Fund is continu- ing its excavations at Abydos. Work been carried on in the great cemeteries, and has tombs of all periods have been opened Among the most noteworthy is a magnifi- cent example of a Roman tomb, which con- sisted of a vaulted chamber, about twenty feet in length, built of mud bricks and orig- inally almost hidden in the sand. On its floor were found twelve heavy coffins of limestone, each with its cover carefully sealed. Inside each lay the mummy wrap- ped in linen bandages, the blue and gold of its painted coverings as brilliant first laid in the tomb. The fact that another when as similar tomb was built over it at a slight- ly later date had saved it from the plun- derer. At another place in the cemetery was found the skeleton of a woman buried deep in the sand. She had evidently been buried decked in all her jewelry; on her wrists were bracelets of cowries and beads of cornelian; on her finger was a ring of five fine scarabs, one of which bears the cartouche of Sheshonk, a Shishak, the Egyptian King of the XXII Dynasty who sacked Jerusalem in the time of Rehoboam:; under her head was found a mass of orna- ments, scarabs, shells, pebbles, copper and iron rings, and various beads; and on the nose was a little silver nose-ring. Not far from this spot was disc»overed a more an- cient burial, probably of the XII Dynasty It consisted of the skeleton of a woman, with two alabaster vases placed near her head. Round her neck long necklace of beads, and at her left hand three scarabs, one a fine amethyst. These excavations have been carried on under the direction of T. E was a Peet; on the arrival of the director, M Naville, the scope of the work will be en- larged, and the clearing of the Osireion, the great underground temple of Mesneptah, Will be begun. John Garstang’s excavations at Meros and Kabushia. in the Sudan, are making great progress Three hundred natives, with a staff of trained Egyptians are em- ployed, and a light railway and aerial ca- bleway constructed for the re- moval excavated material. In the Royal ( large number of buildings have been revealed. The Palace near the Temple of Ammon, which has now been cleared, contains more than forty chambers and On the foundations im- portant found. have been of the ‘ity a a large court reliefs have been Gifford whose ported Charles death abroad for formerly in ago he exhibited a collection of his paint- ings. a painter, Munich, had years. He eleven Dyer lived dwelt years is re] from about twenty Chicago, where The death is reported from Brussels of Henri Hymans, aged seventy-five. At various times he was connected officially with the Bibliothéque Royale and the Beaux-Arts of and with the department of art Academy. Numerous contribu- periodicals, a book on Ru Brussels at Antwerp tions to several lives in the “Biographie Nationale,” art bens, The Nation started by the Belgian Academy, “Villes l'art célébres,” the last on Ghent and Tour- nai, are among his works I} ‘ A Nance THE BUSINESS WORLD AS DICK- ENS DREW IT. The centenary of Charles Dickens yes- terday was of interest to people in the walks of finance for one particular rea- son—that Dickens included the domain of business and banking in his narra- tives, with results which were some- what curious. As a rule novelists who have taken practical finance as the back- ground of their stories made a pretty Opinion differs as to why be the is treading unfamiliar ground poor fist of it. th narrator is should whether because and therefore verging on the grotesque in character and incident, or because the practical affairs of trade do not adapt themselves to story. There is something in the last-nam- ed theory: it has been said that the Stock Exchange lends itself more read- ily to constructing fiction than does fic- tion to depicting the Stock Exchange Certainly there is a dull and sordid at- mosphere about most imaginative nar- ratives of finance. Bulstrode of “Mid dlemarch” was a banker, but he might have been anything else, so far as the tory is concerned, and the business orld of Mr. Howells’s Silas Lapham was narrowly circumscribed Possibly the late Frank Norris came closest of any one in our day to giving romantic life to the every-day detail of the mar- ket But Norrts had a method of his own; he was writing the Novel with a Purpose; he steeped himself in the ac- tualities of the Board of Trade before he set his scene; the machinery was really more important than the charac- ters, and that perhaps is why the Leit- ers and Pattens of the day can read “The Pit’ with a convincing sense of being intimately at home in its descrip- tive chapters. This not Dickens's method approached the world of an uninformed outsider. What He practical was finance as he would have made of his bankers, his promoters, and his merchants, if his humor could have played as natural ly about them as it did around his young men in search of a career, his first-floor boarders, his country gentle men, his lawyers, his strolling actors, hig impecunious debtors, his police ser geants, and his still more numerous gen tlemen of no visible occupation, can only be conjectured. But the insur mountable obstacle appeared to be that Dickens, like many other people in or out of the literary profession, instinc- tively looked on City trade and banking, whose intricacies he did not understand, of ichievement a realm mysterious as where the inhabitants were 1r other human beings. That was never sketched a convincing like a business man, as such Scrooge and Ralph Nickle nig aived' in argument; for to D (perhaps because of his early x nee in an habitually insolvent fa a money-lender was not only ! ily a usurer, but, when pictured story, was something like per usury. In his later and more care! wrought-out novels, Dickens att something better than these sketches, but with almost equal! ferent success. In “Dombey & Son tried to draw a great City met and in “Little Dorrit” a great | er. But Mr. Dombey and Mr. Me are depicted by the mature exactly as Dickens in Old | reporter days would undoubted depicted them. The extren figure which he presents as the Dombey & Son was thus portra doubt partly because all City me seemed of Dicke ing witl partly a him t biili iv pation ‘ man feelings and emot serve d ers, the make rs, moro The ' liat HOVE US fice to g amusing ens can picture, f of cove ilistic serve a within t iim coat.” aged to aused but neit discover as tha moting, ition ¢ bla erdle the nT feeling like ns the (he \ 1 his Iso imagine ndowed for the be Cal t to Vas if retail tl qui lay-figure nt @ trad th ions rh ship-chandlers, the ins ind th is side leaves o home clerk, not of resist Mr. with i 1 a undertake! was visible relief tag ui ith Dombey ! Dom be Inmis laugh a Mr when he makes riend, Mr. as ever he up with discover the her was , in the t the that iffice nor gI the eh nd ekboard Millions the Dombey “that he he resources oO one No reader of just failure an 4 a) ler eat Govern! l yuld Game ( the of y dle pl the } sic ‘ 1¢ Dickens explains, heated ret li rit’ A ist ¢€ 71 up his « Harriman Daniel Stock banking ith ve rs caree tne the at rud of hods r is yuld r th vl gallows mentary high f what I ve he iy yn of the Merdls he ] 8 le* , and oat or Drew or Exchange, house and Cates his shuffling ret takabl but tl Toots *hicke! 0K evel I Ik it W lombey ever pl ode omotet nent ¢ held } Ol of manher, eating hil ] matching it or Geor ze or in even iis Jay Ge Hudson intere propo JUG

Page 28

146 just a little whimsical to people who know what successful promoters have to be. Such reminiscences suggest the query whether English fiction has ever por- trayed with real insight the character and life of a practical financier, from the simple business side of it. It is doubtful if the thing has ever been sat isfactorily done but once. How Thack- eray gained that view of the instincts and feelings of a City financier which made possible, in his “Vanity Fair,” the picture of old Sedley, it would be interesting to know. Perhaps he himself had as a boy been tipped by a prosperous merchant of the sort, had met him in the club or the street after , the tragedy of bankruptcy, and had been curiosity to trace the intervening incidents. But, after all, it is the downfall of the business man, the change in his place among his col- leagues and acquaintances, the pathos of the disintegration of the flourishing financier into the helpless seeker after petty agencies and commissions, which caught the imagination of the novelist. What Sedley or his old acquaintance Osborne did at their City offices, when the ordinary business of the day was started, Thackeray does not tell us. Per- haps he was not himself very sure about it; perhaps his instinct pointed out that it would not have interested the reader. Bis. RECENT SPANISH TEXTS Valdes: Sulpicio 5 = (Just out.) y { a. . moved by La Hermana San 50 cents. by J G. GILL, Trinity College, Ayala: Consuelo 60 cents. ‘dite’ by AURELIO M. ESPINOSA, Stan- University Caballero: La Familia de Alvaredai Vo: abulary edition.) 75 cents ' ! by PERCY B. BURNET, Kansas City > High School Spanteh Ballads 75 cents. MORLEY, University si y el Encogide ents J. GEDDES, JR., Boston Uni-/ versity | itexd 8 a 60 « ’ od 7 oc a La Coja ¥ Henry Holt & Co, W. 39d Bt, Studies in Mistory, Economics and Public Law _The Nation | Vol. 94, No. 2432 BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Angell, J. R. Chapters from Modern Psy- chology. Longmans, Green, $1.35 net. Arey, A. L., Bryant, F. L., Clendenin, W. W., Morrey, W. T. Physiography. (For High Schools.) Heath. $1.25. Atkinson, William. The Orientation cf Buildings, or Planning for Sunlight. Wiley & Sons. $2 net. Begbie, Harold.. Other Sheep. Doran. Book-Lovers’ Anthology. Edited by R. M. Leonard. Frowde. 75 cents. Boutroux, Emile. William James. Trans- lated from the second edition. Longmans. Bowie, H. P. On the Laws of Japanese Painting. San Fr.ncisco: Paul Elder. $3.50 net. Bradsher, E. L. Mathew Carey, Editor, Au- thor, and Publisher. (Col. Univ. Studies.) Lemcke & Buechner. $1.25 net. Carver, T. N. The Religion Worth Having. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1 net. Chase, Prentice. Labor, Law, and Justice. Stamford, Conn.: Bulletin Pub. Co. 50 cents. Edited, with W. R. Jenkins Chateaubriand, F. A. Atala. notes, by Timothy Cloran. Co. 85 cents. Cornish, Vaughan. Waves of the Sea, and Other Water Waves. Chicago: Open Court Pub. Co. Dresser, H. W. Human Efficiency. Put- nam. Gaunt, Mary. Alone in West Africa. Scrib- ner. Irvine, David. The Badness of Wagner's Bad Luck. London: Watts & Co. Murphy, T. D. Three Wonderlands of the) American West. Boston: Page & Co. $3 net. Newsholme, Arthur. The Declining Birth- rate. Moffat, Yard. 50 cents net. Nietzsche’s Works. Vol. II, Early Greek Philosophy and Other Essays; Vol. VII, Human, All-Too-Human (Part 2); Vol. VIII, The Case of Wagner; We Philolo- gists: Vol. IX, The Dawn of Day; Vol. XVI, The Twilight of the Idols. The Anti- Homo; Macmillan. $1.25, $1.75, $1.25, 76 "ak Christ. Vol. XVII Ecce $2 net. Nowowiejski, Felix. Quo Vadis? (Musical drama.) J. Fischer & Bro. Original Narratives of Early American His- tory: Pennsylvania, West New Jersey, Delaware, 1630-1707. Scribner. $3 net. Oxenham, John. The High Adventure. Duf- field. $1.20 net. Pattee, F. L. The Breaking Point: A Novel. Boston: Small, Maynard. $1.25 net. Piffault, Eugénie. Ma Tante et Mon Curé: Comédie en trois actes. William R, Jen- kins Co. 75 cents. Reed, James. Hidden Riches. Philadel- phia: Lippincott. $1 net. Roberts, T. G. Rayton. Boston: Page & Co. $1.25 net. Saleeby, C. W. Surgery and Society; The Methods of Race-Regeneraticn. Moffat, Yard. $2.50; 50 cents, net. Scheffauer, Herman. The Masque of the Elements. Dutton. Sienkiewicz, Henryk. Through the Desert. Benziger Brothers. $1°35 net. Taber, Susan. Country Neighbors. Duf- field. $1.20 net. Tennyson and His Friends. Edited by Hal- lam, Lord Tennyson. Macmillan. $3 net. Tynan, Katharine. Paradise Farm. -Duf- fleld. $1.20 net. Wadlin, H. G. The Public Library of the City of Boston: A History. Boston: The Library. Weber, F. P. Aspects of Death in Art. Open Court Pub. Co. Weyl, W. E. The New Democracy. Mac- millan. White, Michael. The Garden of Indra, Duf- fleld. $1.25 net. Winter. N. O. Chile and Her People of To- day. Boston: Page & Co. $3. Wright, H. S. The New England Cook Book. Duffield. $1.50 net. Year Book and Proceedings of the Fifty- first Annual Convention of the U. S. Brew- ers’ Association. THE LIFE STORY OF J, PIERPONT MORGAN By CARL _HOVEY Crown 8v0. Illust rated. $2.50 net, postpaid $2.66. This accurate biography, contain- ing “inside” information never be- fore in print, brings the record of Mr. Morgan’s life into the year 1911, and chronicles his early be- ginnings and immense achieve- ments in the world of business. It presents the commanding person- ality of a great man of affairs and patron of the arts, and is engross- ing to the general reader and in- forming to the financier. STURGIS & WALTON CO. B1-88 East 27th St., New York Rdtted by the Faculty of Political Set of Columbia University. THE RICARDIAN SOCIALISTS By ESTHER LOWENTHAL, Ph.D., Assistant in Smith Col- lege Paper Covera. $1.00 Economica, SvO LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., NEW YORK A. 8. Clark, Péekskill, N. Y., is a buyer and seller of books, magazines, and pam- | phiets NINETEENTH CENTURY ENGLISH CERAMIC ART By J. F. BLACKER Over 1,200 tlustrations, 534 pages, $3.50 net. A practical guide for collectors of old English pottery and ¢.ina, combined yy a history in pictures of the work of the old English master potters. LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston The Greatest Street in the World Broadway, Old and New, from Bowling Green to Albany By STEPHEN JENKINS 160 illustrations and siz maps; 500 pages; $3.50 net. By mail, $3.75. Mr. Jenkins has presented the historic associations of Broadway from pre-Revo- lutionary times to the present, its theatres and the actors that made them famous, its literary incidents and personalities, the busy hum of city life that rises heavenward between its towering buildings, and all the abundant energy that flows through it ceaselessly. » . NEW YORK LONDON Just Pablished. CHINA: Social and Economic Conditions Articles by well known authors and au- thorities on Chinese Affaire including Dr. Arthur H. Smith, Putnam Weale, Frederick McCormick, and several Chinese writers— Discussions of the political situation in Man- churia, and the possibility of establishing a Republic. Price, $1.00, naper: $1.50, cloth, AMERICAN ACADEMY OF POLITICAL AND SCIENCE 0. Philadelphia, Pa. West Philadelphia P.

Page 29

i ‘ uw » ‘ < a FS . é . * F j F } Ps | hee J . = 2 : . ie si i ‘ « 7 WN Seseo TE - . *