The Nation 1911-07-13: Vol 93 Iss 2402
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL, XCIIL—NO. 2402 The Nation
A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. [Entered at the New York City Post Office aa second-class mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Pau! Elmer More. Editor. Three dollare per year in advance postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mexico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4.00. Address THE NATION, Bor 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street.
CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WEEK te EDITORIAL ARTICLES: America and International Law ...... 26 Poetry and Common Sense............ 26 EE MEE gicncccsesecvevsesve 27 SPECIAL ARTICLES: Patriotic Songs of India ............ 28 CORRESPONDENCE: Rabelais and More’s “Utopia”........ 30 MM EMOTO GE BEIT cc ccccccsecces 30 Professor Bergson’s Principle ...... 31 I TP ED sebeeScacdcscccecscese 3 Scientific Management ................ 31 Uncle Tom’s Cabin in the South... 31 LITERATURE: Amurath to Amurath ........... a The Miller of Old Church...... secu A ME PE cccccecasoccucsccess 3: tT PE <.vecnckeneuesveceee 34 The House in the Hedge ............ 34 Catalogue of Romances in the Depart- ment of Manuscripts in the British Museum ...... Lie ehiAeeeetheeesnse 34 William Lloyd Garrison .............. 35 The Intellectuals: An Experiment in BOE CO BBO wcccccccccevesccsecs 36 History of Taxation in Iowa........ 36 Scotch-Irish Pioneers in Ulster and . Socuae Gasbestiobenbanes en 37 Dn 5. ich eeedieekedceanade 37 SCIENCE: Burbank’s Improved Fruits .... . 39 DRAMA: Another Stage Experiment. . 41 i nibndudesuennss+s Pee 2 FINANCE: BE GIG cccccccvccsoces .§ & Books OF THE WEEK 44 * © © Copies of The Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. sq i, tare, vu THURSDAY, JULY 13, 1911 Pkg Educational tl Ol) TEN CENTS 2 Reg. U Pat. Office. PRICE Educational
ECOLE LIBRE DES SCIENCES POLITIQUES 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, 4 PARIS (quarante-et-uniéme année, 1911-1912) FonpatTevur: Emile BOUTMY. DIRECTEUR: M. Anatole LEROY-BEAULIEU, membre de I'Institut. CORPS ENSEIGNANT. MM LEVASSEUR, LYON-CAEN, RENAULT, A. LEROY-BEAULIEU, ESMEIN, CH. BENOIST, P. BEAUREGARD, DE FOVILLE, COLSON, RENE STOURM, VIDAL DE LA BLACHE, de l'Institut de France; J. OURGEOIS, LEVY-BRUHL, professeurs A la Faculté des Lettres; ROMIEU, France; EB. FLACH, professeur au Collége de conseiller Etat; TARDIEU, TEISSIER, maetftres des requetes bon. au Conseil d’'Etat; ARNAUNE, conseiller A la Cour des Comptes; R.-G. LEVY; G. PAULET, directeur au Ministére du Travail; ZOLLA, CH. DUPUIS, M. CAUDEL, PIERRE LEROY-BEAULIEU RENE HEN dD. Dd. CHR, DBE SCHEFER, ROUSIERS; député RY, P. BELLET, secrétaire perpétuel ae la Société d'Economie politique; YOT, chef de la comp- tabilité générale &@ la Banque de France; E. HALEVY, G. BLONDEL, A. SIEGFRIED,, docteurs @s Lettres, etc. TABLEAU Economie politique.—Economie sociale Finances publiques.—Affaires de banque étrangéres. Finances Monnaie, crédit et change Circulation interna tionale. Géographie commerciale et statistique. Commerce extérieur et Ilégislation dovantiére.- Légisiation commerciale comparée.—Colonisation comparée. Politique économique des principales puissances. Les grandes industries modernes Législation ouvriére. Technique industrielle. —Méthodes et statistique Questions agricoles au point de vue économique.— Valeurs mobiliéres. Etude critique des comptes et bilans.—Les assur- ances. procédés en SOMMAIRE DES COURS: Vie politique et organisation administrative en France et A l'Etranger Histoire diplomatique.—Géographie générale Droit Internationale conventionne! Droit des gens. L’Europe contemporaine et les intérétsa européens hers d'Europe Histoire de la politique intérieure des principaux Etats. Histoire parlementaire et I4gislative de la France. Histoire constitutionnelle européenne et américalae Histoire des idées politiques et de l'esprit public au XIXe slécle Ethnographie de l'Europe centrale et orientale Organisation militaire comparée.—Marine militaire L' Amérique contemporaine et les nouvelles sociétés anglo-saxonnes.—Questions politiques et éco- nomiques dans |’ Asie Orientale Questions algériennes.—Questions tunisiennes RENSEIGNEMENTS GENERAUX L’enseignement de l’Ecole des Sciences politiques est le couronnement naturel de toute (ducation libérale. Chacune de ses grandes divisions constitue en outre une préparation compléte aux carriéres @’Etat (diplomatie, administration, finances), & la vie publique et aux grandes entreprises financiéres tant en France qu’a |l’Etranger. Les éléves sont admis sans examens, n’ont A justifier d’aucun grade universitaire. Une conférence spéciale eat réasérvde avec |'agrément du directeur et du Conseil de l'Ecole; Us auz élévea étrangera dane le but de faciliter leurs (tudes La durée ordinaire des études est de trois ans, toutefols, on peut la réduire & deux années Ua diplime est délivré, en fin d'études, aux éléves qui ont subi avec succés les examens. ANNEE SCOLAIRE 1911-1912.—L’année scolaire commencera le 6 novembre 1911 et fnira le ler juin 1912 On e'inscrira au Secrétariat A partir du 26 octobre 1911. semble donnant entrée A tous les cours et conférences réguliers et complémentaires et A la Inscription d’en- bibllo théque (environ 25,000 volumes et 160 revues et jJournaux francais et 6trangers)....Parm annen 350 fr Une Brochure speciale donne dea renseignements détaillés et sur les carriéres aurquelles elle prépare. sur Vorgantaation de I’Hoole S’addreaser au Secrétaire Général de l’Ecole, 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, PARIS.
Brrn Mawr, Pennsylvania. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Prepares for Bryn Mawr and other colleges. Certificate privileges. Number of pupils limited and specia) schedule arranged for each. Percentage of pupils who have entered Bryn Mawr College un- usually large. Gymnastics and outdoor sporta. Thirteenth year opens October Sth, 1911.
'HE FISK TEACHERS' AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave, Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 611 Swetiand Bid,, Portland 89Jackson Bivd., Chicago 238 Douglas Bid., LosAngelee 405 Cooper Bid., Denver 42142Shattuck Ave.,Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual.
ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions Send for Bulletin No, 20. TIARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.¥ STURGIS TUTORING SCHOOL Preparatory and Tutoring Departments.
Summer Term, July 5 to September 21 Fall Term opens October 2. CONY STURGIS, Director, 4104 Stewart Avenue, Ithaca, N. Y.
ETHLEHEM SCHOOL, Bethlehem Catalogue. H. D L colleges, ling eading Principal Pa. Prepares for Foering, B.8., PREPARATORY DARIS—EXCELLENT PENSION de FAMILLE, highly recommended by Professors and Ministers. Every modern convenience. Trained nurse English spoken Ont parolas Esperanto $7 a week up. MME. GUERARD, 78 rue Michel Ange, Paria XVI.
Selections from Lincoln Edited with Introduction, a brief memoir, and notes by IDA M. TARBELL. Just Published 20 cents. A chronological selection of Lincoln's pub papers, speeches, and letters to friends Aside from thetr studies in pure and strong Eng selections offer a practical insight portion of our history and an in knowledge of the character Lin GINN & COMPANY, 29 Beacen St., Boston DANTE’S DIVINA COMMEDIA Ile and political connections value as the
Fulited with Introduction, Arguments, and Notes, By C. H. GRANDGENT Professor in Harvard Univeraity Vol. I--INFERNO .. Price, $1.25 Vol. Il—PURGATORIO (Just published) $1.26 D.C. HEATH & CO., Pablishers, BOSTOY NEW YORK CHICAGO
Page 2
The Nation [Vol. 93, No. 2402 THIRD EDITION NOW READY JohnBrown: ABiography Fifty Years After By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD SOME TRIBUTES TO THIS REMARKABLE HISTORICAL WORK. Philadeiphia PUBLIC LEDGER. “A tre mendous book ; more thrilling than any book of THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING COMPANY the purpose of establishing religion up- BEST facilities for supplying Publishers and Importers of Standard Works of Science, American Philosophy and the History of ao BOOKS * ella Religion, Ancient andModern Catalogue free. ‘LEMCKE Correspondence solicited. & BUECHNER Founded in 1887 by EB. C. Hegeler, for fiction, powerful in its appeal, and which, while on @ acientifie basis. Rotabliched se it is written soberly, as befits history, by the 8 8 over years. very nature of the narrative often rises to the The Open Court Publishing Co. ; highest dramatic level.”’ | 30-32 West 27th St., New York THOMAS WENTWORTH HiGGtNson. &23-833 Wabash Ave. CHICAGO, ILL. | “| can only say after reading from first to last ite more than 700 pages that I have never en countered anything this side of Gibbon's ‘Rome’ which has made me feel more the personal power of a single work.’’ JOUN TT. Statesmen MONTHLY. MORSE, Series, “Perhaps in thus fashioning bis volume, Mr. Villard obeyed an inatinct rather than acted upon a preconceived plan; that is often the case with a great work, where a writer's feelings are deeply enlisted. Be this as it may, the merit and charm are none the leas; be has eeized well a splendid oppor- tunity and has written one of the great biogra- phies of our literature."’ HORACE WHITE. “In my judgment a con tribution to American literature to take rank with the very best historical writing of our time or any time The only impartial history of the Kansas war.’’ American ATLANTIC dramatically Editor n | CLEAR STATEMENTS OF SOCIALISM BY JOHN SPARGO The Substance of Socialism ($1.08 postpaid) Sidelights on Contemporary Socialism THE NEW DICTIONARY OF STATISTICS By AUGUSTUS D. WEBB ($1.08 postpaid) B.Se. (Bece.), ¥.8.8. The Spiritual Significance of Modern 4to, $7.00 net Socialism (55 cents postpaid) y } k. A copious compendium of indis- B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, New Yor pensable information on the inter- national statistics of ECONOMICS, FINANCE, POLITICS, and SOCI- OLOGY. THE AEROPLANE PAST, PRESENT AND FUTURE By CLAUDE GRAHAME WHITE and HARRY ST. CLAIR McKELWAY in the Brooklyn EAGLE. “A biography replete with facts and marked courage and candor, learning and by HARPER With articles by Famous Avia- tors. 93 illustrations. Over 300 pages. Octavo. Cloth, $3.50 net E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY J. B. LIPPINCOTT co., Philadelphia. 81 WEST 23D STREBT. New YORE justice."’ Pertiand OREGONIAN, ‘The most raluable A book of rare charm and great usefulness. “The Great Novel of the Year.” and comprehensive biography issued this season, FLORIDA TRAILS THE BROAD HIGHWAY and the best and most candid estimate of John — , o By WINTHROP PACKARD, author of ‘‘Wild Pas- Brown. | tures.’’ ‘‘Wood Wanderings,"’ etc. Illustrated, By Jelfery Farnol. $1.35 net W. E. CONNELLEY in the Topeka| $3.00 net; postage 25 cents. Eleventh American Edition. Bleventh in England CAPITAL. ‘The unprejudiced student and “Mr. Packard,” said Nathan Haskell Dole re- seeker for truth will herald the book as a great cently in the New York Evening Post, *‘is cer- contribution to American history tainly the most entertaining writer on pature now tet before the public; he has keen eyes, lively sym- BOOKS—All out of print books supp » Bo Des Moines CAPITAL. ‘More powerful in| pathy. fue fanc lightful le,”’ ts appeal more dramatic than any book of Pluride Tratle yo aves teas shew te alt’ these matter on what eubject ; welts me, ona os fietion, is this wonderful biography of Jobn | qnalities to charm the reader. wanted; I can get you any book ever published ; Brown. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston when in England, call and inspect my stock of The North Carolina REVIEW. “In this 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, biography Mr. Villard has touched high-water John Bright St., Birmingham, England. mark. The book Is a delight to the reader for many reasons Fall of life and movement, e B J written In an attractive and scholarly atyle, ull Balza Bronté Brownin Carlyle, iy onHN KENNETH of sympathy and yet without any loss tn accurate a. oo Neen al oe —BARBAROUS MEXICO TurxeEr. The only book presentation. it sets a new standard for bio- G ay H h : H 7 i Plu h telling the unvarnished truth about the tyranny graphical efforts." ulzo awthorne, Hugo, Irving, Plutarch, o¢ piss ani the, belpless slavery of the peous . ’ | Poe, Prescott, Ruskin, Scott, Shakespeare,| Twenty engravings from corroborate Baltimore AMERICAN. “While the book | Thackeray, Tolstoi. | the ny Extra cloth, $1.50 postpaid. Charles has popular features in that it is entrancingly H. Kerr & Company, 118 West Kinzie St.. Chicago. interesting, its scholarship is of the highest Send for Catalogue. order and ite style reminds one a Iittle of Anthony Froude Mr. Villard has illus- trated in thie book the ‘finest ideals of literary | THOMAS Y, CROWELL & CO..New York conception and execution.’ FOREIGN 2x4 for ovteieowe. TAUGHNITZ Lendon TIMES. “It ts scarcely likely that any later writer will be able either to add any- thing of importance to Mr. Villard’s collection of material or to better his interpretation of the TO EDITORS OF DAILY OR WEEKLY NEWSPAPERS The SCNCENNGF BOK 68. BRITISH BOSTON. h AUTHORS BOOKS Mass” undersigned is prepared to make arrange- whole story It at once becomes the| ments for the supply of advance proofs of Sir} standard, and probably the final authority on its| Ray Lankester’s weekly column published in the) A. 8. Clark, Peekskill, N. Y., ie @ buyer theme."’ London Daily Telegraph, under the title, ‘‘Science| and seller of books, magazines, and pam- from an Easy Chair."" Apply without delay to Washington (PD. C.) STAR, “Mr. Villard’) W. H. MARSTON, 71 Fleet Street, London, Eng. | phlets. drows & compact, vivid, historic picture of the terrible focussing of this period upon our Civil War Straight and clear in ite literary way, this biography is a marvel of research and fair. mindedness."’ HENRY WATTERSON COURTER-JOURNAL, be found with Mr it is minute varnished in Loutevilie “No fault may justly Villard’s telling of the story and lucid, altogether fair and an ‘arlington (lowa) HAWKEYE, “It ts a book which will take a place in the library of every well established home in this part of the country."* Firat Second Third Edition, Edition, Edition, October tat; November Zitat; March Jat. Pully tratione illustrated with portrattea and other tlus With copious notes and bibliography 5.00 net Postage 26 centa. HOUGHTON BOSTON MIFFLIN COMPANY | NEw YORK FOR MANY WEEKS AFTER THE INDEX APPEARS Requests come to this office for additional copies. Therefore we call the attention of our readers to the fact that THE INDEX TO VOLUME XCII FROM JANUARY 1, 1911, TO JUNE 30, 1911 APPEARED IN NATION OF LAST WEEK ” THE >.
Page 3
The Nation NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 13, 1911. The Week President Taft was well within the truth in his reference to the fur seal treaty signed at Washington last Fri- day. That England, Russia, Japan, and the United States have at last compos- ed the acute differences that have exist- ed among them upon this subject for forty years is indeed cause for general satisfaction. It not only ends the dis- graceful killing of the seals, but, as the President indicates, forecasts the adop- tion of useful game laws for the open ocean. An especially significant state- ment is that the treaty would not have been signed upon its own merits, great as these are, but that the diplomats in charge of it felt compelled to bow to the growing sentiment for international ar- bitration. Be this as it may, the agree- ment itself is an indication of the rapid advance in this regard in recent years. The treaty seems admirably adapted for the conservation of a fast-disappearing resource. limita- tion of three miles from shore is abol- ished, and no fur seals are to be killed in the North Pacific Ocean, including the seas of Bering, Okhotsk, Kamtchat- ka, and Japan. the maintenance of a patrol of the seal The old common-law Provision is made for waters by representatives of all the na- tions concerned. The agreement is to hold for fifteen years, and as long there- after as no one of the Governments de- nounces it. The President's promise to urge Con- gress to establish a complete parcels post is another sign of the eagerness of If only the dwellers in the cities and their both parties to placate the farmer. suburbs were to be thought of, we could pull along as we do at present. The ser- vice of the larger city shops runs out through the whole suburban region, and there is always a swarm of local ex- presses radiating from populous cen- tres. In the country all this is differ- Whatever a farmer buys he must The phone may have brought him within or- ent. get home for himself. rural tele- dering distance of more than one town, but if he wants to get what he tele- phones for, he must hitch up a horse and wagon and go after it. Now, when he sees that the rural postman who brings him his daily paper drives up to his door with nothing in his wagon but a small mail bag, he would be a very unintelligent farmer if he did not rea- son that this same postman might just bring him his small parcels, When Mr. General pointed out that such rural par- as well too. Meyer as Postmaster- cels post service would make the rural free delivery pay for itself, he provided an argument which the farmers are re- peating in ever-growing chorus. The people of New York have been treated to an experience which it is safe to say has no parallel in the history of democratic or representative govern- ment. A city of vast population and enormous wealth, the chief city of a great democratic nation and the second city of the world, was to have its entire scheme of government rewritten, and nobody in authority had publicly stated what was the purpose of the meve, who was responsible for the character of the work as a whole, or how its details were | being managed. It was not pretended that there was any public demand which the new charter was designed to satisfy. The people of the city had hard- ly more part in the making of it than It cocted in secret by a committee at Al- the people of Timbuctoo. was con- bany, with the aid of a paid expert; and when these cooks had got the dish ready, it was to be passed upon by the Legislature as a matter of form, without the faintest possibility of real examina- tion. If anything even remotely resem- bling this proceeding, taken as a whole, is to be found in the history of govern- ment, we should be glad to be informed or it. Fortunately, Gov. Dix has at last let it be known that he will not approve the new charter, concocted and crowded There , newspaper speculation about } through in this way. is much is possi- ble motives, and we hear ingenious stor- ies about his having been drawn into an intrigue of Murphy's against Mayor Gaynor, and what not. But why delve so deep for reasons which lie on the sur- face? The proposal which the Governor has headed off was outrageous, and there is no need to go further. The Chicago Tribune's annual comp!t- lation of Fourth of July accident statis of deaths, with three exceptions, and the tics shows the smallest number fewest accidents, without any exception, since the figures began to be gathered in 1899. The largest number of fatalities occurred in 1908, when there were 72 The next year they were ten less, last year they fell to 44, and this year they rhe amounted to 1,358, which is more than were 39. accidents this year a thousand under any year siace 1901. About half of them, as usual, are cred- and ited to “fireworks,” with “flrearms “gunpowder” responsible for 200 each The heyday of the unsafe and insane Fourth was the period from 1903 to 1909, when the accidents were regularly 50 per cent. higher than in previous years, with the exception of 1900, which rivals the later period. Upon each of these seven Fourths the fatalities were more than fifty, and the accidents, with the exception of 1908, were above three The amounted to about $350,000, as against thousand. fire loss this year nearly $600,000 last year and $725,000 two years ago. With these exceptions, however, it is the largest ever recorded, the figures having averaged only about $100,000 prior to 1907. The accident roll will not be complete until August, when the figures of deaths from lockjaw be- come available, but a basis for calcula- tion is found in the fact that these re- ports have usually tripled the number reported in July. The thing that stands out in the entire calculation is that two Fourths—observed in but sane a part of the country—have reduced the num- ber of deaths by nearly 40 per cent. and of accidents by above one-half It is just a year ago that the town of Newark, Ohio, disgraced itself by lynch ing a young man for defending himself from assault while serving warrents upon notorious violators of the County The for that has done Three of community day the leaders in the lynching are now Option law. much to atone in the Ohio penitentiary, two for twenty- year terms and one for fifteen. Two or three others, who were hardly more than boys, have been sentenced to terms in the Reformatory institution at Mans- field, and several cases are still pending.
Page 4
‘ of a The sheriff of the county resigned his office rather than face a hearing before Gov. Harmon, and has dropped into complete obscurity, fortunate to have escaped indictment for criminal com- plicity. The Mayor of Newark was driv- en from office and went to California. From there, it is reported that he wrote letter to the Governor asking to be ppt ed to some office, since he was out of work. Recently he returned to Newark and has announced his inten- tion to run for Mayor again this au- tumn, but has met with nothing but in- dignation and ridicule. Meanwhile, the Court of Ohio has decided that il- legally sold more or less secretly, about the are liable for the $1,000 saloon tax. This det little more careful about what goes on But the final test of thoroughness of Newark's reforma- will new city administration is to be chosen. Supreme some fifty places where liquor was the time when lynching occurred, ision will make property owners a in their buildings. the in November, when a tion come The primer is to betome more power- ful than ever if the Women’s Trade Union League of Chicago has its way. Heretofore, those who have prepared this handy little volume have limited themselves to such assertions as: “This is a bear’ and “The fox is a cunning animal.” Now it is proposed that, for foreigners at least, these statements shall give place to the more vital declar- ations “I am a member of a trade union,” and “J am working in a union shop and receive $10 a week.” The pic- d trees, and landscapes, will be of shops, all filled with wage-earners displaying union buttons. ture nstes of representing animals, stores, and factories, This plan of teaching the young idea, in what di- is so laudable that the not only how to shoot, but rection to aim, only wonder is why it has not been con- ceived sooner and why it is not carried farther. No textbook for aliens should be regarded as complete without such useful expressions as: “For whom shall 1 vole?” “I voted for you.” “What office do I get?” “I prefer one without an ex- amination.” To Joseph Conrad has been granted a pension of £100 out of the Br&ish civil If, award has been made on the ground of list. the usual custom is, the as the incident throws a curious need, light on the rewards of literary labor in The Nation [Vol. 93, No. 2402 Joseph Conrad’s case is not that ot William Butler Yeats, for instance, who is the recipient England. analogous to of a similar pension. Yeats is a poet and a pioneer in the upbuilding of an Irish literature and drama, and it is notor- ious that neither poetry nor pioneering pays. Conrad is a purveyor of the arti- cle that everybody cries for—fiction; his name occurs constantly in lists of Eng- land’s half-dozen leading writers. As a stylist he has been placed very near the top, and not in the sense that Meredith and Henry James are stylists. Conrad is the master of a language which has distinction without being particularly He is constantly spoken of That he should recondite. as a popular author. stand in need of a government subsidy be if it not for the striking difference between would almost incredible were the pursuit of literature in this coun- try and that in With us a man makes his mark and grows wealthy, England. or fails and stops writing ‘books. A long list of publications is prima facie evi- In England it is It is comparative- dence of prosperity. nothing of the kind. there to get a publisher for ly easy books that do not sell, or sell very little. Although the compilation of the fig- ures of the Canadian census is not yet complete, it is pretty certain that they will show a great gain in the French population. Out of a total of perhaps 8,000,000, the French are expected to number at least 2,000,000. Such growth from the 60,000 under the flag of France And in this reckon- ing no account is taken of the French- emigration to the United States. It estimated that in the whole of North America there must be in Canada in 1760! Canadian is fully 3,000,000 of French-Canadian de- scent, It is not surprising, then, to find Prof. Henri Lemay, in the Revue Ca- nadienne, predicting that a century hence there will be at least 40,000,000 French Canadians in all of North Amer- ica, and that Canada will be much more | If this be put’! exaggeration, there is at French than English. down as an least enough truth in it to show why Canadian politicians think it wise to be very considerate of the French vote. in Cuba need but un- Rumors of revolution not be taken seriously; happily the evidence is too strong to be| very ' disregarded that political conditions in the island auger badly for the future. A member of the Cuban Congress open- ly charges that President Gomez is per- sonally corrupt, and declares that he can prove that the chief of state, from being without means at the beginning of his term, has dishonestly amassed a large fortune while in office. This might be thought mere partisan slander, were it not so generally believed in Cuba to be at least partly true. Gomez had stated that he should not seek reélec- but latterly his friends began to This led to such violent protests—some of them tion; talk of running him again. made to Gomez's face—that he found it wise to reaffirm his purpose to quit the Presidency. If reports may be believed, he will also quit Cuba, after the bad fashion of the South American “kings leaving the Cuban Republic in exile,” to struggle on as best it may to re- cover from the bad effects of his tenure of power. An air of insincerity has pervaded the debates and manceuvres in the English Parliament concerning the Veto bill. In the Lords the Opposition have adopted certain amendments. But are they real- ly And if they were to be accepted by the Government, would the Conservatives then acquiesce in the main principle of the bill without more ado? Nobody seems to know. The Tory peers them- selves display great uneasiness and un- certainty respecting the policy of their leaders. The latter do not strike out boldly for rejection of the bill, but tem- porize and play for position. On the other hand, the Government are equally hesitant. They say they will not for a moment agree to the amendments vot- ed by the Lords, yet they display no en- thusiasm at all for either of the two intended to improve the measure? other courses which alone are possible— a new general election or the creation of 500 new peers. It is thus a kind of political unreality into which both par- ties have fallen. They are apparently being driven to extremes, though the weightiest men on either side do not wish to go there. The whole unhappy situation reminds us once more how great a misfortune it was that the con- ference committee of last year, compos- ed of the leaders of the two parties, fall- ed to come to an agreement.
Page 5
July 13, 1911] The Nation 25 The latest dispatches, however, seem to indicate that a way out of the mud- dle may be found. It is stated that the Government would make no objection to an amendment offered by Lord Newton, providing that no further step be taken in curtailing the power of the Lords without a referendum to the people. The force of this lies in the fear, to which Professor Dicey and others have given voice, that if the Lords consent to have their veto overridden after two years, the next thing will be a bill to cut down their time of grece to a year or even six months. If the Liberals now acquiesce in the amendment mak- ing this impossible, it will leave their Own measure intact, but will offer the Conservatives an excuse for retreating. The latter can say that they at least saved something, and that appears to be their main anxiety. To be sure, the Saturday Review sneers at this com- promise, as being, in effect, an agree- ment to concede to your opponents all that they ask, provided that they ask no more at present; but while this is for- mally correct, it may be said that Lord Newton’s amendment dées, after all, In the present embarrassment of the Tories mean a substantial compromise. any compromise may seem good enough until after an election in which they hope to win power and set about repeal- ing the whole bill, while reforming the House of Lords according to their own ideas. Scarcely had the outcry in Germany over the Catholic anti-Modernist oath begun to die away, church authorities made a display of when Protestant what appears to be a similar reaction- ery spirit. At the end of last month, a Prussian clergyman, Pastor Jatho, was declared by the ecclesiastical coun- cil of the province to have been guilty of heretical teaching, and was forbid- den to exercise any clerical functions whatever. heresy does not appear, but there has The precise nature of his been a great protest from many within the Evangelical Church at what they call a violation of the spiritual liberty of the clergy. Herr Jatho has been in the ministry for thirty years, and bore an excellent repute. The Cologne Zei- tung speaks of him asa man who spends his time from morning till night in do- ing good, and who had the affection of his parishioners ina remarkable degree. So great is the indignation at the sen-| tence against him that a “Jatho Fund” is being raised, partly to provide for his needs, and partly to carry the matter further and see if he cannot be restored to his church. It should seem strange if ate Protestants were to toler- of their that Archbishop once declared that there German a Modernisten-Eid own; yet remembers Whately really little difference in the spirit of one was intolerance whether found among Prot- estants or Catholics. Reports of monarchist activity in Por- tugal need to be heavily discounted. Royalist energy has hitherto manifested itself more conspicuously in the the field. precise sum of $410,000 that press bureau than in The magnifi- cent and has been contributed by Brazilian mon- of republic is probably as mythical as the archists toward the overthrow the army of invasion that is gathering in Spain for an attack on Oporto. There are, indeed, royalist refugees in North- ern Spain, but the Government at Mad- rid has been energetic in repressing armed preparations against Portugal. Such danger as exists for the Lisbon Government consists in mutiny among the soldiers or sailors. But while some small disorders of the kind are possible, it is hard to imagine that either the army or the navy will turn against the Government they were chiefly instru- mental in setting up. The outlook, there- fore, is not ominous for the Provisional Government. One reassuring fact is found in the recognition of the Portu- guese Republic by our own Government. This took place on June 19, the same day on which the newly elected Con- stituent Parliament assembled. Into the hands of this assembly the Provisional Government resigned its powers, and by it was requested to resume the functions of gow:-rnment until further orders. The situation in Albania, in spite of recent alarmist reports, is probably not so serious as it was a few weeks the hostilities. The Turkish Government is ago, when tribesmen were engaged in pretty sure to profit by the results of its Al. banians after the uprising of last year. disingenuous conduct toward the In the armistice concluded last Decem- ber, the mountaineers were promised a complete amnesty, the appointment of compensation for native magistrates, arms delivered and houses destroyed, and partial exemption from military duty. The Albanians lived up to the agreement by turning over their arms the Turkish part no attempt has been made to put to authorities, on whose the treaty into effect. Hence the pres- ent uprising and strained situation on the frontier of Montenegro, whose peo ple have been extending succor to their kinsmen across the _ border. Now, against the representations of the Pow ers, King Nicholas has decided to mo- bilize. But the move may be interpret- ed course as an attempt at influencing the of rebels and the Turkish rulers. negotiations between the Russian influence looms up behind Montenegro, but, on the other hand, Germany has it that with the Government at Constantinople. made plain her sympathy is India finds herself facing a new men ace, and from an unsuspected quarte: ren years ago there was only one point Chinese Empire really All the rest was sepa: ated China tribes which formed the “buffer” that the Eng- But at which the touched India. from by a hundred lish authorities encouraged now ribet, from being a mere Chinese pos- and all former session, has become a vice-royalty, posted the indignant words “The Chi Chinese troops have been along the southern side of “buffer” In the of the Calcutta Englishman: states. nese, in short, have grabbed country that was certainly not theirs, and which we have neglected to occupy and for the that we preferred that a stretch of uncivil- lie the problems that contact with China that Pe- king did not know of this self-denying administer simply reason ized states should between us and would certainly raise.” Pity policy on the part of its powerful neigh But its only answer now has been the the bor! to promote leader on border from Frontier Commissioner to Viceroy Sechuan, “where,” laments the Eng- “he will be from the Most been the attitude of the Chinese of Ran ot lishman, able to do more British point of of all nischief view disheartening has goon and Lower Burma, whom the Eng- lish citizens, had considered to be loyal British but who have surprised their superiors by showing that they regard “and full Celestial themselves as Chinese citizens of burning zeal for the Em pire.”
Page 6
26 Nation The | Vol. 93, No. 2402 AMERICA AND INTERNATIONAL LAW. The position taken by the United States in regard to several points in in ternational law has been much discuss ed of late last week, for example, when the House in England. On Monday of of Commons voted approval of the Dec- laration of London, the Foreign Secre- tary, Sir Edward Grey, dwelt at length upon the significance of the American attitude respecting that international agreement. Dealing as it does with the right of capture at sea in time of war, it makes a decided approach to the doc trine which the United States has upheld for more than sixty years—namely, that property should not be made 4a than land private prize at sea any more on The argument of Sir Edward Grey was that the deep interest which the United had an international prize-court, and wur States taken in the establishmert of support of the Declaration of London as showed that Lais & means to that end, country could not believe that its se.- borne commerce would be interfered with in ease of war. This as again- those bitter English critics of the Dec laration who took the opposite yiew. It is gratifying to have such a recognition of the humane and effective part played by the United States in modifying the ola and harsner rule, and in bringirg other nations to accept in good measure he doctrine which we so long main tained, virtually alone. The case is different, however, when we turn to another question having ro ao with international law, on which, too, the United States occupies an isolated osition. We mean the doctrine of “the most favored nation.” This has been under sharp discussion recently, not only in England, where the pendency ol the Canadian agreement gives it special point, but also In France and Germany rhe matter was brought up in the House of Lords, where Lord Selborne asked if the Government were prepared to admit the American interpretation of most-fa vored-nation clauses in treaties The official spokesman for the Ministry de clared that Great Britain had never as sented to the view of the United States on that point. Vigorous letters to the press by Harold Cox and Thomas Gib son Bowles have drawn attention to the singularity and difficulty of the Ameri can contention Not long. since. the >. Frankfurter Zeitung devoted an article to the same subject. In the course of it the attempt was made to show that Sec- retary Knox, at the time of the negotia- tions with Germany last year relating to duties under the Payne tariff, had the American posi- On February 5, 1910, Dr. Del briick, speaking for the Government in the Reichstag, declared that the State “ex- tacitly abandoned tion. Department at Washington had plicitly declared” that it was prepared to grant Germany the “most-favored-na ” tion treatment.” But this must have re- ferred only to the case in hand—that is, the question of tariff rates. The Frank- fort newspaper is surely not justified in inferring that the United States will, by parity of reasoning, concede at once i” German imports what it is making ready, by special agreement, to concede to Ca- nadian. We speak of the “historic” position of the United Siates on this point as if that were enough to justify it complete- ly. at the same time very perverse and em- barrassing. It may, indeed, be said that no hardship is imposed by us upon oth- er all perfectly what our diplomatic conten- our judicial decisions have But views may be very ancient and nations, since they understand tions and been. They know that our view of the business is strictly that of quid pro quo; special favor for special favor, with no outsider entitled to ask something un- less he has given something. But such considerations do not go to the root of that from It is easy to American of John Quincy Adams down, have consis- say State, the matter. Secretaries tently held to the American interpreta- | tion of most-favored-nation treaties, and The real question is whether we ought ever that our courts have sustained it. to have taken that position, and whe ther we ought not to begin to think of abandoning it, and adjusting ourselves to the opinion of all the world cxcept the United States. When no great moral or political prin- ciple is involved, the nation that finds itself differing, in a mere matter of in- understanding from all others, should ask ternational comity and of treaties, whether it is not probably wrong. This is especially the case when we are in the presence of a powerful movement to The Unit- ed States is helping on that movement unify international practice. in many ways, but in the matter refer- red to stands entirely aloof. The result lis a considerable amount of awkward- ness in international relations, together with apparent shifts to which we are driven in defiance of the seemingly plain language of treaties. Thus the terms of our treaty with England appear to be entirely explicit: No higher or other duties shall be im pesed on the importation into the United States of any articles the growth produce or manufacture of His Britannic Majesty’s territories in Eur.pe than are or shall be payable on the like articles being the growth produce or manufacture of any oth- er foreign country. But we instantly contend, by reasoning which other nations may justly call far too ingenious, that this promise has nothing to do with special agreements which we may find it commercially cor- venient to devise. We know that England does not so interpret her obligation un- der that same treaty. Nor does any other country so read its duty under ‘similar compacts. The United States calmly says, “Oh, you know, I never did take that view of it.” But this, we sub- mit, is scarcely a sufficient defence. No nation can compel us to change our posi- tion—though it would be interesting to know what the Hague Tribunal would |say of the American doctrine, if it were to be submitted to that body—but we ‘ought to ask ourselves whether it would not be more friendly and reasonable to |make ready to give up in due time our private and isolated view and conform to that held by all international jurists except our own. POETRY AND COMMON SENSE. A recent volume of translations from French verse written by Belgians is of Like the people among whom it came into being, more than ordinary interest. this poetry has a composite look, re- flecting literary tendencies and meth- ods of several countries and presenting little that can be called exclusively its on. Now it seems under the spell of France, now of Germany, and again of | Holland or Norway. Of alliance with English poetry, on the other hand, there |} is scarcely a vestige. If ever a type (of poetry may be thought of as Conti- nental, as opposed to English, the pres- ent collection is an excellent example of | such. It does in any case fix the attention |upon a certain few traits which one is | likely to find in the poetry of almost | any Continental country and which have | never taken root in the poetry of Eng-
Page 7
nse tit July 13, 1911] The Nation land and America. It would be interest- ing if one could explain their relative absence from English poetry by a dis- tinctive Anglo-Saxon characteristic—an imperative common sense. Verhaeren, one of the contributors to the collection, has been presumptuously called the greatest of French poets. The point of present interest is that his reputation has been made by a realism of a very un-English sort. Even in its drama and fiction England has lagged behind other countries in this respect, but especially in its poetry. It has never relished unblinking accuracy in setting forth the relations of the sexes. Frank utterances in “Don Juan” seem to English critics blotches of bad taste and bad art. To turn to America, Walt Whitman's similar experiments found favor chiefly on the Continent. The usual explanation is that such restraint is prompted by a finer morality. Prob- ably it would be truer to say that it comes from the poet’s common sense, a fellow-feeling with his readers. Con- tinental poets to a much greater extent than English have been tempted to fol- low out an idea or situation to the logi- cal end. For Verhaeren, as for many German and Dutch predecessors, poetry should have greater privilege than even painting or sculpture. With remarka- ble precision and detail he catches the rough unrestrained scenes of inn life which the pictures especially of Teniers and Jan Steen so often celebrated. Like them, he glories in the vitality and ca- pacity for enjoyment in his subjects; and with the added suggestiveness of language, he runs into outspoken erotic subtleties. Of Verhaeren it has been re- marred that he, along with many other Continentals, dares write what by him- self he would scarcely think. The Eng lish and American way is the reverse. Another difference is brought out by the following translation of Maeter- linck’s “Lassitude”: These kisses know no longer where to rest, For blind and cold the eyes were they caressed; Henceforth asleep in splendid reverie they Watch dreamily, as in the grass dogs may, The gray horizon-herded sheep-folk graze Upon the turf the moon’s dishevelled rays, Kissed by the sun, dark as their life is dark; Indifferent, without an envious spark For pleasure’s roses under them unclosing; And this long, green, ununderstood reposing. Not that English poetry has ever been opposed to personification. Again the difference is one of degree. Qualities QG and impersonal things have from early very nature of poetry needs a watchful times enjoyed an instant’s life and per- control of its elements and a nice bal sonality in English poets, but only sporadically and generally under foreign influence does one find their human ex- istence prolonged. Dante and Petrarch, with a child-like, unbarriered fancy, could send their sighs with elaborate in- structions to wait upon a mistress. And Heine lived in a world fully peopled by love’s paraphernalia. To Englishmen and Americans the carrying of the de- vice to the extreme appears sentiment- al; for them a lake in the moonlight may, for the nonce, wear a woman's smile; but the moment that it is ad- dressed as a woman, the conceit tum- bles into bathos. The Anglo-Saxon masses are too literal not to draw back from personification prolonged; so are their poets. Symbolism is the third device in re. spect to which English and Continental practice differs. André Fontainas is the most notable advocate of it in Belgium. Like Mallarmé and others of the school in France, he is constantly awake to double meanings. A fleck of color on the horizon, a cloud in the sky, a stray cow, each is big with a second self. If for the reader, under the spell of poetry, they took on the same meanings, there could be no quarrel. But in many cases the symbolism becomes flighty, incoher- ent, unintelligible, and reflects but that haphazard outer fringe of consciousness which sensitive persons possess but can- not communicate. The excess to which Fontainas carries the device results from his preoccupation with it, while the reader is forgot. Accepting symbol- ism as desirable, his instinct is to follow it out to the bitter end. It expresses his most transitory feelings; why should he tone it down to the pitch of ordinary mortals? English poetry has only in the rarest instances been so afflicted. Some of Shelley's works may be open to the charge, notably the “Epipsychidion,” a poem or two of Rossetti’s, and an equal amount of Poe—who in this sort of verse, significantly enough, first got recognition on the Continent; but it would be hard to multiply the examples. Common sense implies a somewhat lit- eral outlook which might seem to pair ill with poetry. The answer is not only the vast body of superb English poetry, but the fact that even theoretically they | ought to thrive together. The great range of suggestive power lying in the ance among them. Imagination is not at its best when it entirely releases its hold on tangible facts. One secret of Milton's strength, as of Tennyson's, is that in neither did poetic conceits often become heady; each transforms the uni- verse, but what results is still recogniz- able by the layman. SUCCESS AND LUCK, A Paris newspaper has been asking eminent Frenchmen to state what they think the influence of chance is upon success in life. Many of them have amiably responded, the topic.being ob viously one of those admirable midsum mer themes on which one man's opinion is as good as another's, and which can be discussed till cooler weather comes without arriving atasure basis of judg- ment. The replies, indeed, vary accord- ing to the taste and temperament of the several authorities invoked. Some of them rate luck very high; others put it wholly out of the reckoning. The com- poser Massenet gave a cynical turn to the discussion by avowing that, for his part, he believed absolutely that good fortune was the determining ele- ment in the success—of others. Only one of these intellectual French- men appeared to have a definite theory concerning the place to be assigned to chance in the case of marked individual achievement. This was Professor Richet of the Academy of Medicine, and he, doctor-like, was prepared to reduce the whole matter to a formula. Success, he declares, is due to the combination of intelligence, energy, and luck. The pro- portions in which they should be min.- gied are: 60 per cent. of intelligence, 10 of hard work, and 30 of chance. Yet Professor Richet evidently takes these figures to multiply with, instead of merely adding them, since he declares that if any one factor is missing the re- sult will be nil. That is to say, 40 per cent. of intelligence with, suppose, 5 of luck but no industry at all will not yield even a half-way success. All this is very like solemn fooling, as Profes- ser Richet himself is at least partly aware, since he quietly remarks that whether you have intelligence or not is itself largely a matter of chance. “There lig no worse stroke of bad luck than to ' be born a fool.”
Page 8
28 The Nation In the other opinions printed we discover the same uncertainty and fluc- tnation that one would find in the views of any dozen men who might be in- terrogated anywhere. At one moment, opportunity seems the only thing; at the next, the dynamic force of the individual apparently accounts for everything. This whole region of inquiry is evidently bet- ter fitted for the moralist or the rhet- orician than the scientist. The ques- tion wraps up in itself too many inde- terminates and variables. It is like try- ing to make two of Emerson’s essays fit into each other. He writes of “Power,” and we seem to see the naked energy of the individual carving the world as he wills. He turns totreat of “Fate,” and man appears to be merely an atom of dust, the sport of cosmic forces. There is truth in either extreme, and either may be rhetorically emphasized to make the impression sought at the moment; but how to hold the two in accurate balance, how in any given instance to say just what is the part played by luck and what by skilled effort, is so far beyond the wit of philosophers that we may safely conclude it to be also beyond the power of newspaper interviews. If the test were made one of individ- ual consciousness, we think that some of the most successful men would be willing to admit—to themselves, at least that they have owed very much to good fortune. However comfortable a conceit they may have of their own pow- ers, or however they may plume them- selves on their intellect and energy, they cannot fail to see many points in their career, as they look back upon it, where everything seemed to turn upon a cast of the dice. If the particular opportu- nity which they seized had not presented itself, or the opening of which they took advantage had been denied, they may indeed flatter themselves that they would surely have found some other vent for their talents, but it would be impossible for them to say just what. In the very act of saying, as they must in honesty, that they had their chance and tcok it, they concede the influence in their lives of the unforeseeable and in- calculable. But those words are only polysyllables for luck M. Jules Lemaltre affects to believe that there is no such thing In life as chance. It is all a figment of the imag- ination. “What we call luck,” hasays, “is the belief in some equalizing power; an [Vol. 93, No. 2402 idea born of the innate instinct of jus- tice in man.” What he appears to mean is that the common mind ts averse to admitting that one man, no matter how shining a success he may have won, can be inherently so superior to his fellow. | So we say that one has luck and the’ cther had not. That is supposed to be | comforting to the latter. Certainly in | political life we often see that idea in-| trude. We heard a great deal of “Roose- velt luck”; we are beginning to hear much of “Wilson luck.” It is in this way tpat some would seek, as M. Lemaitre | says, to “equalize” their unrecognized | abilities with those of men conspicu-| ously successful. But this is really to) go over to the position of the pious ledy who said to her old pastor, apropos of a man who had suddenly leaped into large fame, based upon useful public activities: “And to think what humble instruments the Lord chooses to accom- plish so great a work!” To her replied “Far be it from me to put any limits to the power the sagacious clergyman: of the Lord, but Mr. —— is a very re- markable man!” PATRIOTIC SONGS OF INDIA. Baropia, India, May 20. When the white man first came to In- dia he found the people of this country | extremely deficient in one particular— they had no patriotism. Indeed, the babel of vernaculars lacked a simple, | single bungling phrases being required to voice the emotion. One result of con- tect with the Occident has been the de- velopment of this feeling in Indians. | The dialects now possess specially coin- 'ed terms, while the word “patriotism” | is on the lips of every English-educated person in the Peninsula. Fifty years ago bards sprang up who sang sonorously of patriotism, though after a while their songs fell into disuse. In the last few years, however, the people have turned to these singers again, for their souls have been touched by unrest. Of all the patriotic ballads which the | new spirit has revived, the most popular | is Bankim Chander Chatterjee’s “Bandé | Mataram” (“Hail Mother”). It first) saw the light of day in a book written | in Bengali, “Ananda Math” by name, which was published more than a gen- eration ago. At that time the Bengalis were not ready for it, and for years it lay unappreciated and unsung. But in | title of the song became a popular | phrase of salutation. It still holds its empire over the hearts of the Bengalis, and, to a limited extent, over those of other Indians. During 1906 and 1907, when the agitation against the dismem- |berment of Bengal was most bitter, , when the Hindu terrorist was just ap- | pearing, and when no one knew just how far nihilism had burrowed its way | into Indian society, this lay caused some | anxiety to the rulers. But, as is appar- ent from the following free translation, |there is nothing inflammatory in the | words, which are sung to plaintive, mi- | nor music: |I bow to thee, Mother, Thou who art rich in streams, fruit, and cool southern breezes, | Whose fields are green with harvests, Whose nights are a-glitter with the sheen of silvery moonlight, Who art decorated with blossoming trees, Whose smile is radiant, Whose voice is musical and whose words are like sparkling jewels, Who fulfillest desires. Thou who dost strike terror with thy babel of millions of voices, | And with the sharp swords of thy countless arms, Who dares to call thee helpless? | Thou who dost wield the strength of a mul- titude and repel hosts of enemies, | Thou who art the saviour of thy people, To thee I bow. Thou art wisdom, thou art religion, Thou art the heart, the very core of our | heart, | Thou art the life-breath of our bodies, Thou art the strength of our arms, | Thou art the piety of our heats. |In temple after temple we set up thine image. | Thou art the Goddess Durga, holding the ten weapons in thy hands; Thou art Lakshmi (the Goddess of For- tune), residing in lotus lakes; Thou art Sarasvati (the Goddess of Learn- ing) ; To thee I bow. I bow to thee, Lakshmi, the pure, the hand- some, the smiling, the sincere, the be- jewelled, the Mother, | Just as it comes natural to the Ger- man to call his country the Vaterland, so it is natural for the Hindu to regard his native peninsula as the Motherland. | Indeed, he virtually looks upon it as his mother. The subtle meaning of this is lost upon foreigners who do not com- prehend the feeling that an Indian cher- ishes for the woman who gave him birth. The mother is the most idolized person in the land. Therefore when the | Hindu typifies his country as such, he | iterally means that he gives his coun- try the highest affection of which he jis capable. Of all the patriotic songs which aim to express this sentiment, 1905, when Lord Curzon carried through probably the most beautiful is one com- the unpopular measure of partitioning posed by Rabindranath Tagore, who is Pengal, “Hail Mother” was at once tak- perhaps the greatest living Bengali poet en up as the national war-cry. The to-day. The English rendering necessar- tengalis went crazy over it, and the! ily takes away some of its charm, yet 5 me at alt lk
Page 9
July leaves enough to show the writer's po- | tent imagination: Thou who dost charm the heart of all the world, Thou land gleaming with the golden glory of the sun, Thou mother of our fathers and mothers, The soles of whose feet are washed by the waters of the blue sea, Whose green skirts are fluttered by the breeze, Whose forehead, the Himalayas, is kissed by the skies, Who wearest the diamond diadem of the snows; It was in thy firmament that the first day dawned, It was in thy hermitages hymns were sung. Words of wisdom, religion, poetry, history, first Were preached in thy forest temples. Thou art blessed, the eternal dispenser good. Thou dost distribute food from land to land The Ganges and the Jumna are the milk of mercy flowing from thy breasts. that the first of India is still a conglomeration of races refusing to realize their community of interests, and utterly lacking in co- hesion: but the poet has commenced to dream of unity. This note of union is especially to be detected in the patriotic songs. Mrs. Sarala Devi Ghosal Chou- dhrani, B.A., made an attempt, in 1901, te compose a song in which she linked together the different provinces and combined the watchwords of the various races and creeds—the Har, Har, Har and Hari Moraré of the Hindus; Dadar Hormuz of the Parsis; Allah-o-Akbar of the Mohammedans; Jai Jehovah of the Indian Christians; and Sat Sri Akal of the Sikhs. As yet such a union is only a figment of the poetic imagination: O my muse, recall the glory of past days and sing of Hindustan. O my muse, stir the soul of this audience, and sing of Hindustan. large Sing of that name which sounds our strength and wealth and fame. Bengal, Behar, United Provinces, Orissa, Madras, Maharashtra, Gujerat, Nepal, the Punjab, Rajputana, Hindu, Parsi, Jain, Christian, Sikh, Mus- sulman, All sing, in all the dialects of India, “Namo Hindustan!” (I bow to Hindustan) Har, Har, Har! Hindustan! Dadar Hormuz Hindustan! “Namo Hindustan! O my muse, kill the spirit of disunion, And sing the song of unity. O my muse, be the giver of great strength of body, mind, and soul, Hari Moraré Hindustan! Jai Jehovah Hin- dustan! Sat Sri Akal Hindustan! “Namo Hindustan!” O my muse, inspirer of all men, sing the new tune. O my muse, weld together a mighty nation, sing the new song. Lift up the flag of activity, Sound the trumpet of duty, And rouse all hearts. This was sung by the composer, on the The Nation first day of the Indian National Con- gress, in December, 1901. The chorus was chanted by 400 volunteers. After the second stanza was sung, every per- son in the huge pavilion joined in the refrain. Such a scene was never before witnessed at that gathering. Religion being the paramount force in India, and schisms and creeds being the agents that keep the various fac- tions warring among themselves, some patriotic poets are endeavoring to make a god of Hindustan for all Indians to worship—a faith to which all the peo- ple may subscribe. One of the most charming of these efforts is an invoca- tion put into the mouth of an ascetic in a pageant which the magnifi- cence of the rajas and emperors of the showed old days of Ind, and was performed at the recent exhibition at Allahabad. It ran: O God! The Nameless under many names! O Thou, the Formless under many forms! The Silent, who art heard in many voices! Through all the pores of Being take my prayer! Be land, This Motherland of saints and holy men, This land of hallowed hills streams, favorable to this ancient and sacred Of sombre forests and sun-flooded plains; This glory of the immemorial East, Whose dwelling is the splendor of the Sun; Our Motherland, our home, our India! May all her many peoples live together Honoring one another, quietly! Bring her the peace that kings cannot be- queath, The happiness that cometh not by wealth! Each in his own way, yet let each for all Work and let work, live and be good to life So let the self of each be India’s self, And India each man’s creed, and each man’s race be India, India, India In another song we find the poet dedi- cating himself to the service of the mother: To your cause I devote my body To your cause I devote my life For your sorrow my eyes shed tears This harp will sing your songs. Though these arms are weak and incapable, Yet they will do your work; Though this sword is dark with rust, It will cut ff thy bonds. O Mother, even though my blood avail you nothing, Yet I can shed it to wipe on your name, Or to allay the least of your sorrows O Mother, though there is no force in this music of mine, Who knows awake, By hearing these melodies! off the least stain but some child of thine may Some of the patriotic odes of the last generation were very plaintive. Here is one composed by Rabindranath Ta- gore that throbs with sorrow: Who is it that constantly approaches and retires, With eyes overflowing with Who is looking toward us with vain hopes? She is my Mother! She my Mother! tears? is
QO ~~ & In the dark house what sad-faced one has prepared the meals for us? Whose is the food that no longer | pleas ; ‘s Ae » ant to our palates? It is our Mother's! It is our poor Mother's! There is undertone the following short stanza an of shame in , written thir- ty years ago by Hem Chander Bannerjt: Bugle, sound this tun ‘In this world every race is free. All are alert with the pride of their honor Only India is asleep.” The songs written during few years show a marked difference. In the new lays there is a note of jubllance and hope. the last The following was com : I pos ed in 1903; the poetess fancies that India’s face, which once was fair like that of the Goddess Durga, the posses sor of ten hands, and the all-powerful ruler of the ten become black and terrifying like that of who is supposed to wear skulls, It Mother India! Who allayest the sorrows of all, regions, has Kali, a garland of She writes ow to thee, I bow to thee, Beneficent, good, a saviou Whose face has become darkened and ter rifying, like the countenance of Kali Through sadness ai the afflictions of India! The darkness of cycles now has vanished Oh, thou lotus-< omplexioned Mother, gu ihe The earth once more is beautiful with th: light of hope and a heart rejuvenated The ship of time is bringing to us a « irgo of new life, Smile, oh lotus-complexioned one Knowledge has come, prosperity and valor will follow We shall see thee once more the happy ruler of the ten regions Oh Mother, thou who art armed with lag- gers and vord Thou who wearest garland of skulls, The wounds of thy insultg shall healed. Bengali, of all Indian vermaculars, seems to be the most replete with patri otic songs, though the other dialects ere beginning to be enriched in the ame way. Kavi Narmadashanker La! shanker has left several stirring od: in Gujerati, the following, written about 1865, being a fair specimen of his art Let my countrymen awaken Let them ask for their rights and pr le If my countrymen hav any park of hu manity left in them rhey will surely demand the riglt that a theirs as human being Ev brutes do not fail to take revenge those who give tl i pain In thi world the ideas of proper per nalit nd f-respect ar ! iry Those who do not ask for their dus olate the laws of nature Let them not be afraid of powers that be Let them not sleep supinely with folded hands, thildren have to ask for what they war even from their mother, Why not then ask for rights which r in and cunning people try to ignore? Kings have waged wars for their right and men have lost their lives 1: struggle for rights It is a sign of manliness to stand up and demand our dues
Page 10
30 number of the songs, rpreted by the British been proscribed. All print- been seized and the cir- of them is made a of that have the indeed as lurid revolutionary songs in nguag They depict the English aining the life-blood of Hindustan and it to England to feed and fat- n their people, the Indians mselves are left a weakened, emascu- famine; A certain as s8e- ing inte tious, have copie have ation or singing Most under mnal offence those en placed ban are as any as ipping while lated race, a prey to constant nd they call upon the people to free elves. We may cite a few lines from a Punjabi song to show this sen timent The foreigners are looting Hindustan, Combine to save it from being looted let us go to the battlefield, Get our heads cut off (But) kill (the Englishman) Be not afraid of naked swords It is easy to understand that no Gov- ernment, in self-defence, could permit such sedition to fan the flames of its own destruction. Saunt NIHAL SINGH ( orrespondence RABELAIS AND MORE’S “UTOPIA.” To Tue Epiror or THE NATION: 31 In the review of “The French Rena ance in England” in your issue of lu 1. the reviewer speaks of the promi- nen Mr. Sidney Lee gives to “two recent liscover and writes of the second, “He rks out the j tion made by Professor Lefra that Rabelais adapted a part of Mor Utopia On page 74 of his book Mr. La terms “the evidence of familiarity th More book which Rabelais offers” “a w fact In the comparative study of French 1 king h literature ind says, “Rabe- la land of Utopia, with ‘the great city Amaurots,’ comes straight from More's rhe na are of More's inven t A foot-note on this asserts “Prof Al I ran in ‘Les Navigations de Panta f Ctud ur la géographie' rabelais- (Par 1905), while pursuing a dif t iit of inquiry, was the first to call attention = t Rabelais’s indebtedness to Mor Utopia.’ ” fut that Rabelais took these names from Utopia” has long been known, and is tated In both French and English booxs hat da much earlher than 1906. On page volume of Burgaud des Rathery’s edition of Rabelais’s firat work Par 1857), for inetance, this note is n Ww t Utopt firat occurs in the t xf L/Utople, ré blique tmaginaire, dont le vil | Amaurotes du mares apavpos, ob secur) eat la capitale, sert de titre au roman politique de Th. More, publié en latin; Lou- vain. 1616: Paria, 1516, 1517, et traduit en francais par Z. Lebiond, Paris, 1550. In-8 But this is by no means all that is un- satisfactory in Mr. Lee's statements con- cerning the “Utopia.” In view of the fact that in his life of More in the Dictionary be- The Nation No. 2402 of National Biograpay he stated that “Hyth- loday is a wholly fictitious per- sonage,” it is surprising that he now writes, “It was while More was engaged on diplo- matic business at Antwerp, where Frenca was the language of official circles, it was while he was talking in French with a Portuguese sailor who had voyaged to Amer- ica, that More’s alert imagination conceived ideal of society.” other than More’s statements in where, as Mr. cited, “a detect his new anything beginning of his book, well in the work just easily puzzled the fact ends and the fiction begins,” tae Lee reader says may be to where the authority should have been cited, for some one certainly has made a “new discov- ery.” But if, on the other hand, the only authority for it is the “Utopia” itself, there is nothing there to indicate that More con- versed with Hytaloday in French. What in- lications there are point rather to the of Latin, the lingua franca among scholars at that time: for introducing Hythloday at once corrects More's error in use Giles on taking him for an ordinary sailor, and ex- plains that he is a philosophical traveller “et latinw lingu@ non indoctus’’; and when Giles later says, “Mihi visum est non ut servias regibus, sed ut inservias,’’ Hythlo- day responds, with a peronomasia that would exist had they been talking French, “Hoc est una syllaba plus quam servias.” not But these are comparatively venial sins. Mr. Lee has a thesis to support, and in con- trasting the welcome that the “Utopia” re- ceived abroad, and especially in France, with what he is pleased to term “the cold neglect of the book at home,” he does so by nothing less than esuppressio veri, His statements are, in general, true; but they are far from being the whole truth; and the inferences from them given or suggested are | decidedly misleading. From his pages one could conclude only that it was merely the lack of English interest in its subject-mat- ter that prevented More’s writing the whole of his book in England and publishing it there, and that the only reason why it was not at once translated into English and giv- en “the unscholarly world” was that “England set small store by the stirring humanist revelation which her own to son offered her.” That “the greater part” of the “Utopia “was penned in aforeign country” isexplain- ed easily and naturally by the fact that at hou More had little opportunity to write (teate his letter to Giles), and in Antwerp, during the break in the negotiations with the Flemish ambassadors, little opportunity to do anything else. And, in the words of Morley, “ ‘Utopia’ was not printed in Eng- land during the reign of Henry VIII, and could not be, for its satire was too direct to when it mocked be misunderstood, even English policy with fronical praise for do- | ing what it failed to do.” More had narrow- ly escaped imprisonment or execution by Henry VII, and naturally did all he could the risk of incurring the dis- to lessen pleasure of his son. The first English trans- | lation did not appear until four years after | Henry VIII's death, and even then the trans- | “bolde | lator considered its publication a and rash enterpryse,” tried to shift the re- sponsibility for it to another, cated it to Cecil, who had been his school- fellow, “partly thatunderthe sauffe conduct of his protection it might the better be de- If this rests on| and dedi- | fended.” “France,” says Mr. Lee, in refer- ence to the French translation, “efficiently relieved More’s ‘Utopia’ of the risk of oblivion to which English blind- hess exposed _ 2a. as Robyn- son's translation followed Leblond's by but a year, and was entirely independent of it, the “risk of oblivion” does not seem to have been very great. And if the publi- cation of a French translation in 1550 shows warm appreciation, how is it that the pub- lication of an English one but a year later indicates “cold neglect”? That no commendation by an English scholar is among those printed with the first edition of the “Utopia” admits of an explanation much more probable than that Colet, Linacre, and Grocyn found nothing praiseworthy in a book that was a fruit of their teachings and the work of their inti- mate friend: viz., that they did not see it | before its publication, and hence had no opportunity of adding their commendaticrs. In the letter that accompanied it, Mcre apologizes to Giles for sending him the manuscript so much later than he had rea- son to expect it, and explains the cause of the long delay; he has been so busy since his return that he could devote to it “onelye that tyme whyche I steale from slepe and meate.”” Under such circumstances, it is not | likely that he would add still further to the delay by circulating what he had writ- ten among his English friends before send- ing it to Antwerp. But that Giles, on the other hand, should submit the manuscript to More’s Flemish friends before sending it to the printer, was virtually imposed by More himself: “I wyll as touchinge the edition or publishing of the booke,” he wrote, “followe the counsell and advise of my frendes, and specially yours.” Giles 'and four or five others, all residents of Antwerp, Louvain, or the vicinity, empha- sized their favorable advice by having printed with the book letters or verses en- comiastic of it and its author. But this does not go far towards proving “the cold neglect of the book at home.” Finally, Mr. Lee writes: Nor was English, the native language of the author, the first vernacular into which the work was translated. It was a French version which first popularized More’s speculations. . The anonymous French translator of 1549, and the Parisian booksel- ler, Charles Angelier, who in 1550 circu- lated More’s Latin in modern speech, may |be credited with giving the unscholarly world the first opportunity of studying at | first hand More’s social and political gospel. This is nothing less than astounding; for, as is shown in the life of More previously | cited, Mr. Lee knows that the French trans- | lation was preceded twenty-siz years by a | German and two years by an Italian! Ap- parently, the reviewer’s warning that from “the excesses in which this sort of study may involve one,” “he is not entirely free” is nearer the mark than his statement that in the book “there is a splendid union of | Scholarly precision and revolutionary de- duction.” WM. DALLAM ARMES. University of California, June 20. A LECTURE OF SUMNER’S. | To THe Epitor or THE NATION: Sir: Through your courtesy I should like | to appeal to your readers in behalf of the | Yale Press and myself for an elusive bit ‘of information. In a volume to be issued in
Page 11
July 13, 1911] “War the autumn, entitled and Sumner, occurs an essay-lecture on ‘War.’ Professor Sumner, some four wr five years ' Other Essays,” by the late Prof. William Graham The Nation periences. If our sensible experiences were not thus conditioned, how could matter be come isolable for us and prepared for our actions? 31 factory results; even a solution of copper sulphate (1 part to 2,000 of water) has been injurious to some forms of plant life when put directly into the circulation. The conclusions drawn from these ex- periments so far seem to prove that the variations in plant life are so great that anything in the nature of a ecifle ret edy cannot be discovered; and, as we do not uaderstand nervous action 1 th plant world, it is almost safe to say tl xp ments will be abandoned Heredity and environment must always be carefully con- sidered in any system which seeks to co bine organic and inorgani« il inces, of tu destroy the toxic principles of ase by the toxic principle of some other substance J ] lL) 4 Ogdensburg, N. Y., July 7, SCIENTIFIC MANAGEMENT. TO THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sin: As the correspondence jn your col- scientific management shows that are interested in the subject, you may care to print the following transcript tmns on people from the Rules on the Rice Plantation of P. C, Weston, South Carolina, published in 1857 in DeBow’s Review: A task is as much work as the meanest full hand can do in nine hours working in- dustriously. The driver is each morning to point out to each hand his task, and this task is never to be increased and no work is to be done over task except under urgent necessity, which overwork is to bo reported to the proprietor, who will pay for it. No negro is to be put to a task which he can- not finish with considerable ease. It is a bad plan to punish for not finishing task; it is subversive of discipline to leave tasks un- finished, and contrary to justice to punish for what cannot be done. In nothing does a good manager so much excel a bad n being able to discern what a hand is capa- ble of doing ané in never attempting as Lo make him do more. ago, spoke to me of having recent- Your reviewer says Professor Bergson's ly delivered this lecture; and my in- doctrine of the creative character of the distinct remembrance is that he said | evolutionary process can be ‘“‘more or less he had been “out to Buffalo.”” It is | dissociated from the durée réelle, and h desirable that we should know the date! predicts that thus it is likely to influence and place of delivery of this lecture, and we | the general view of our generation. How have not as yet been able to discover either. there can be any dissociation at all, with This is not the famous “Conquest of the/ out utterly destroying Bergson'’s point of United States by Spain,” but is of a more, view, it is difficult to see. The two appear general nature, dealing with the causes and| to be inseparable. It seems obvious that results of war. Any one of your readers; Professor Bergson so regards the In who can furnish us with the information| his ‘Creative Evolution” (p. 162) he speaks desired would confer a favor upon us by of “true continuity, real mobility, recipro addressing the undersigned, who is editing | cal penetration—in a word, that creative the collection. ALBERT G. KELLER. evolution which is life.” No. 55 Huntington St., New Haven, Conn., July 3 Is your reviewer right in attributing tl popularity of Professor Bergson to hi “ obscurities,” to the “ineffable nature of PROFESSOR BERGSON’S PRINCIPLE. | his philosophy? Is not his influence du . ee baal rather to his banishment of philosophi To THE Epiror OF THE NATION: . satettiininin: ak dues temas, an dinate Sir: Is it possible that the reviewer of ontiidn Gnien titel Thien ack Sie tome one “Matter and Memory” and “Creative Evo- ae detained: iy tee. diet tame he eben lution,” in the Nation of June 29, nas us authority to call a rose in our garden failed to understand Professor Borges S| rose, and not a fortuitous concatenation principle of duration? |of atoms, nor a mental perception, nor a Professor Bergson does not say we — |} part of the self-projected vision of an Ab think rea! time He says the opposite | | lute? Is not the spirit of these words (“Creative Evolution,” p. 46): (“Matter and Memory,” pp. 277-8) at the We do not think real time. But We/phottom of the growing influence of the live it because life transcends intellect great Frenchman’s doctrine?— Because motion is indivisible, thus per- That there are im @ sense multiple ob- mitting the flight of the Eleatic arrow, does | jects, that one man is distinct from an- it follow that we cannot get our sensible | other man, tree from tree, stone from experiences in drops? The life of each we oy PocBgg age gl nde 5 Reg ged us is a continuous duration, a becoming, | characteristic properties and obeys a d not a collection of static intervals. And/termined law of evolution. yet, when we use our life for action, when | 2 @ © tee we examine into it, we make cross-cuts | New York, July 2 in the becoming: we speak of our infan y,| our youth, or any of our characteristics | as if each were a real, divisible part * TONIC FOR TREES our personality. It is unnecessary to quote Professor |TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION James to show that our sensible experi- | Srr: I used to transform the appearance ences appear to us in drops. Is not the |of dog’s-bane and rose-leaves until they fact that they do so a central part of the | looked very much like coleus plants, with Bergsonian philosophy? Professor Bergson | be autiful, mottled foliage. It was done by says (“Creative Evolution,” p. 301): | adding bicarbonate of soda to the water in The primal function of perception is pre- |which the flowers were placed. But why cisely to grasp a series of elementary |the chemical acted in this way upon the changes under the form of a quality or of | veins, not upon the blossom, I could never a simple state, by a work of condensation And again (‘‘Creative Evolution,” pp. 272, 3): Preoccupied before everything else with the necessities of action, the intellect, like the senses, is limited to taking at inter- vals views that are instantaneous, and by that very fact immobile, of the becoming of matter. We pluck out of dura- tion those moments that interest us and that we have gathered along its course. These alone we retain. And we are right in so doing while action only is in tion. 92 “0 4), orienta- In “Matter and Memory” (p. Pro- fessor Bergson explains that the of our consciousness toward appears to be the psychical life. If these facts were not eo, how could we thuse action of tion fundamental law our 7 “centres be those ‘“‘centres of action,” of indetermination” which comprise one of | the pivotal points of Professor Bergson’s philosophy? No contradiction of Professor Bergson is apparent Professor James's assertion that there dis- creteness in the change of our sensible ex in is quantitative ques- | lascertain. Old gardeners, desiring to cre- | ate some abnormal growth, had a way of “feeding the | which through plant” some stimulant, taken puncture liquid the the is known circulation In this the “ was into a in vine way has arisen what as n jection treatment for trees,” nearly hypodermic treatment first attempts di- rected to efforts to the fruitfulness of plants, but apparently sub- in which is very analogous medical The entirely to were increase sidiary causes interfered | that definite | Then the idea was directed to various forms plant life, scientists concluded 50 many ways no knowledge was obtained Europe the Later though in that tem was of little practical use of diseased at least, sys our cwn agricultural stations experimented |with solutions of formaldehyde of varying istrength, from one-half part to one part to five hundred, but it was stated that the registance of trees to injury is extremely |variable, and great care must be used | Various fungicide solutions have been injected, but usually with quite unsatis- The full report from which this is taken, well as many other the prevailing attitude of Southern employers to the management of the hands on their plantations, is to be found in the first volume of the “Documentary History of American Industrial Society,” your columns. PHILIP as overseers’ reports giving recently re- viewed in P, CHASE Milton Mass 6 July UNCLE TOM’S CABIN IN THE SOUTH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION Sir: As a Northern woman in charge of a public library in the South, it has interest- ed me to observe the steady, spontaneous of the for “Uncle Tom's The younger generation is largely responsible for its circulation, though older people also ask for it. A countryman read the book recently, saying that he had been trying get it for years. Comments on book have been rare, but this man volunteered the information that there was nothing in the book untrue, adding, “I have always lived in the South; I know.” The present generation reads it with Iittle of the prejudice impossible for their elders to lay aside sixty years ago, and a truer understanding of the author's motives is though probably its appeal to young people lies in the fact that they re- it as a “good story.” LIBRARIAN, 1. demand public Cabin.” to the possible, gard Tyler Tez., July
Page 12
Literature THE TIGRIS AND EUPHRATES. to Amurath. By Gertrude Lowthian Bell. New York: E. P. Dut- ton & Co. With map and 234 illus trations. $5 net Seldom does there come to the weary reviewer a book of Eastern travel bear- ON Amurath ine the clear stamp of abiding value Such was Kinglake’s “Eotnen”’; such Burton's “Pilgrimaze” and Doughty's “Arabia Deserta.” Travel-books abound, but literature in travel is of the rarest. Into such a class this book must fall. It has the highest scientific value; but it has also charm; life has passed into it from its writer, and by that life it lives and the things of which it tells move before us. Yet there is more here than simple vitality. Miss Bell has the gift of language, and, from time to time, for all the vivid simplicity of her pic tures, she rises to a grave magnifi- cence of style. Thus for her in those lands through which she pass- ed “the reverberation of ancient fame sounds more richly in the ears than the voice of modern achievement. The banks of the Euphrates echo with ghostly alarums; the Mesopotamian des- erts are full of the rumor of phantom armies” (p. villi). And so her pages are haunted with the advance of the fated army of Julian and the retreat of the so differently fated Ten Thousand Greeks; with the expeditions of the Assyrians and the raids of now name- less Arab tribes; with the Sasanian fall and the Moslem golden age. The ghosts of dead empires dogged her steps while the air around her was electric with the birth journey fel| between February and July, ‘ morous. of a new era. For her): 1909, and it was at Tekrit on the Tigris, | the birthplace of Saladin, that she heard | of the counter-revolution: it was from the guns of Mosul proclaiming Reshad Sultan that heard of the capture of Constantinople; and her way through the mountains from the monasteries of Tur Abdin to the world again at Ce#- sarea was thick with vague ru- mors of the Cliliclan massacres. And another magic at work in these The Semite has al ways breoded on the mystery of the fol lowing and vanishing generations and of the unchanging and eternal earth. More, he has felt the appalling contrast tween the fragile life of man and the serene steadfastness of the buildings man can rear. In the desert such great stone or brick structures are as the eter nal hills of all the motifs of Arabic poetry is the deserted abiding-place. And when it is no mere cleared and trenehed camping-ground, but the castle and palace of a forgotten race, the nerve of imagination is touch- ed and the life of man in its transitor!- she sown there is yet pager Commonest, too, The Natio 'astes are paralleled by many a desert singer and recur again and again in the Koran of Mohammed himself. Thus in ‘the Koran (xxii, 44), there is the great passage concerning the city, whose peo- ple have perished while its roofs abide— “and how many a well lies abandoned and how many a lofty palace”’—which so troubled the Arabic geographers and eventually found its way into the Arab- ian Nights as rightly of the land of ro- mance. And the noble couplet of Le- bid, “We are worn away, but unworn are the stars that rise; and the moun- tains remain after us and the great works which we leave,” is of the very spirit of the desert. It was with due right then that Miss Bell prefixed this couplet to her volume, for her journey led her to many such silent monuments of vanished races. She left Aleppo on February 3, 1909, and plunged at once into the new Tur- key. Travelling alone with a caravan of trusted servants and evidently speak- ing the language easily, though not so secure in literary Arabic, she gives at every turn vivid little descriptions, scraps of conversations, estimates and snatches at truth on the situation and the races in it, their capabilities and disabilities. Turks, Syrians, Arabs, Kurds, Armenians, Yezidis, all are brought before us. Bishops and gov- ernors, Arab sheikhs, and Turkish ka- dis, soldiers, and muleteers, begs and peasants, all tala themselves frankly out; while Fattuh, the leader of her car- avan, an Aleppine of infinite resource and practical wisdom, is a constant background and chorus, an indefinite eliciter of humor, if himself not hu- Of many things is the talk; but chiefly of a mysterious new thing called hurriya, “freedom.” It is a word o* genuinely Arabic origin and forma- tien. Philologically, one might think that it could mean only one thing and that what it does mean; but it could not bave raised more doubts and caused more questions if it had been a borrow- }ed word of the foreignest. The Bedouins, it is true, are free, wild asses of the desert, with no yoke on their necks; but all evidently felt that this new thing could no such utter individualism. And if there is a binding unity and an it, obedience to whom or Obedience to an absolute ruler be obedience in what? 'whom they needs must obey; obedience to a religious or social code as old as| ‘tude, peace will follow (p. 247). j the hills and stark with tradition they could understand; but obedience to ua self-created and imposed law was too hard a saying. And so the government was still a higher power, to be thought of as though something elemental, quite apart from | the people. ‘sponsibility was, and is, still to come. Miss Bell found no real understanding | why the delegates had been sent to The sense of a common re- is the head and brains of the empire, and ble in any sense to their constituents. | The spies were gone, it is true; restric- tions had fallen away; passports could be got without delay or bribes. But jus- tice, if anything, had suffered from the shock. All men’s minds were uncertain, and Officials, through caution of the fu- ture, were slow to act. Naturally it would be for the local branch commit- tees to see to this—to educate the peo- ple in citizenship and to keep the of- ficials keyed up. Miss Bell was left du- bious of the extent and weight of their influence. It evidently varied greatly in different places, and the secret in- ner executive reporting to the central committee at Constantinople, much as the spies had reported to Abd al-Hamid, was of very uncertain value. What the people everywhere wanted was a strong hand in the executive, military if need be, and a government which they them- selves knew. And Miss Bell herself tes- tifies that wherever order had been kept during the Terror—for that exactly was what the reaction had brought—it had been due to a strong governor. Govern- ment, the popular voice would contin- ue, is of the Turks; they understand pclitics and brought the Constitution; for all such things the Arabs are use- less. And thus is raised the great question of decentralization, almost the only point at question between the Ahrar, the sc called Liberals, and the committee. That decentralization of some kind will come is certain. It is definitely written into the Constitution, and so multifar- ious a conglomerate as Turkey can only in the end issue in some confederated or federated system. But the very va- riety commands patience until some oth- er unifying force shall have been devel- oped than the deadly one of religion, and until the outlying provinces are in some degree brought level with Euro- pean Turkey. Thus Miss Bell writes in words that all who know the Moslein East will echo: and as Ottoman rule has shown itself upon these remote frontiers, it is better than the untrammelled mastery of Arab beg or Kurdish agha, and if the half- exterminated Christian sects, the persecuted Yezidis, the wretched fellahin of every creed, who sow in terror crops which they may nev- er reap, are to win protection and prosperity, Cruel bloody ; it is to the Turk that they must look. He, and he only, can control the warring races of his empire, and when he has learnt to use his power impartially and with recti- And, again, here is a tribute to what the Young Turks, in spite of everything, have accomplished: Thus it is through all the Asiatic prov- inces, and the further I went the more con- ivinced did I become that Buropean Turkey that if the difficult task of reform is to be carried out in Asia, it can only be done from western Turkey. I believe that this
Page 13
July 13, 1911] has been recognized in Constantinople, tor | the provincial governors appointed under the new régime have been almost invaria- bly well chosen (p. 73). Meanwhile, what of the hostile ele- ments, partly jealous races—Turks, Arabs, Kurds, etc.—and partly warring religions? The picture is an unhappy one. All round the desert, there abides the standing irritation between the fel- lahin and the Bedu—the farmer and the nomad. When the rains fail and the desert is dry, the tribes move—they can nought else—and seek their food in the sown lands. If the government is strong they may be beaten back; but the fierce necessities of life are hard to turn. Sim- ilarly, the Kurds in the northern moun- tains watch to drive their prey from the upland valleys and the fertile low- lands. Behind it all is the secular con flict of Turk and Arab, with contempt and conscious pride of race and con- quest on each side. And still further back and deeper lodged lie, between Mos lem and Christian, fear, distrust, and panic of massacre. Some of Miss Bell’s most telling pages go to make clear this final antithesis. On the Christian side are centuries of too well founded fear Among Orientals, ever swayed by sug- gestion, the madness of the crowd may sweep in a moment all restraint away— humanity, neighborhood, friendship, are nothing in the day of slaughter. And so, too, on the subject race there often falls a helpless panic, inconceivable to us to whom, when face to face with cer- tain death, there would come a lust uf dying with arms of any kind in our hands. On the Moslem side also, hard as it is for us to realize it, there is fear, the fear of our Southern States where the negroes outnumber the whites. Let there be wild talk among the negroes anywhere in these States, with purchasing and hoarding of arms, and scenes approximating to those at Adana might not be very far off. All would depend on those in authority. And so says Miss Bell, of Turkey: I believe that no great massacre has tak- en place in Turkey without the encourage- ment of the central] authority, or a passiv- ity which amounts to connivance the part of the local officials; a strong Vali backed by an enlightened government would keep peace in the most fanatical province of the empire (p. 353). on So the moral is that the Christian races must learn not to play politics and quar- rel among themselves, but to work hon estly and fairly for the country which is now theirs, and especially to bear their part in the burden of military service. That, more than anything else, will weld the empire together. But all this leaves untouched the side of her book which for Miss Bell was probably of most consequence. She is an archeologist, trained under £'r Wil- liam Ramsay, of wide interests, and) especially in the architecturally dim pe- The Nation riod from the Sasanian fall through the | Caliphate. So, with metre tape and rod, and, above all, with her camera, she went down the Euphrates from Car- chemish, now on one bank, now on the other, as ruins summoned her, to Hit. Then came a sweep through the desert with her great discovery, the lonely and abandoned palace of Ukheidir, as her farthest southing, seven hours southwest from Kerbela. Then Babil to Baghdad and up the Tigris to Mosul; thence zig-zag through the mountains of Assyria and Tur Abdin to Diyarbekr; then by Kharput, Malatiya, Aziziyeh and Ce#sarea to Konia. planned and photographed, and the first fruits of her labors are here in many architectural descriptions and in 234 photographs and ground-plans. Of the places and routes more dealt with are Rakkah, the mysterious of many names and sites; the Parthian sta- tion of Isidorus of Charax from Rakkah to Hit; and, above all, Ukheidir. This palace-fortress—-Lakhmid, Umayyad, Ab basid, who yet certainly tell?—is put before us in all its amplitude and wealth, architecturally and imaginative- ly. Architecturally Sasanian, its fit place is in the world of imagination with Irem of the Pillars and the City of Brass. In its ruined halls, where the song of Ibn ar-Rashid is now chant- ed, we listen rather for echoes of the lay of Lebid or the lament of Adi ibn Zaid. Under its arches the life of the Lakhmids and Ghassanids, between the desert and Persia and Byzantium, at last becomes real to us, and a world which for even the early Moslems had become a legend is created anew. And yet one other thing seems very clear. This “Little Green Place,” for so its name means, can have been no such arid waste as now. It furnishes anoth- er fragment of evidence for the drying of these lands, whether by pulsatory or Everywhere she largely can progressive change. Next in detail of treatment comes Samarra, whence Ibn Tulun got his mosque and minaret. Un- der its ruined vaults we can reconstruct the Baghdadian palaces of Harun ar- Rashid and move amid the scenes of the earliest Arabian Nights. With Mosul we enter Christian country, and early churches claimed Miss Bell's attention; and so she went through the Mountain of the Monks and on to Diyarbekr. All this is a suggestion only of the multiform interest of the book. Much must be passed over, and especially the | more intimate life. There is the story of Fattuh and his friend the thief, and of his experiences with the Evil Eye. The prayer for rain, too, at Mezreh, in which men of every faith joined under, their common need. Miss Bell does not notice that this is the one occasion when the Moslem canon law prescribes such united action. Even the domestic ani- mals must join in it, as we read in Joel and Jonah. Here, too, is probably the 3 3: first record of an Arabic ode to an au- tomobile—a veritable gasida of the old pre-Moslem unchanging type and sung with the same cries from the “It is the truth! It is the truth!” that greeted the great old the Fair of Ukaz. Details, of course, are subject to criticism. “Muhammad el-Abdullah” (p. 126) is a very strange name, and (p listeners, odes at 14) the Memluk heraldic bearings might have been recognized after Artin Pasha's labors on them. The pot-hooks are polo sticks and the cup shows th office of cup-bearer. The passage on p 6 about the mosque being mu‘allag on ‘amud is far from clear, and the Nagibs whom Miss Bell met at Baghdad and Mosul (pp. 195, 251) must have been the officials in charge of the registers of Sherifs in these two places But suc details cannot touch in the least t! great value of such a book ag this CURRENT FICTION The Miller Glasgow. & Co. Miss thought the vigorous South is reflected negro to the background, pears merely ture of the scape, and of Church New York Old By Ellen Doubleday, Page forward-looking life of the Ne She relegates the he indispensable fea In Glasgow’ where ap as an picturesque Virginia Jand the aristocrat” to a place of secondary of consigns “dilapidated the agricultural that has arisen out of the ignominious “pore portance. Most of her people are self-respecting class white trash” of anteLellum days. This has been a movement actually spectacu lar in its swiftness and its promise; and, by conveying a sense of the larger romance, Miss Glasgow amply compen- sates for a plot of somewhat convention al design. In the relations of the two households, the Gays and the Rever combs, the condescensions on tl one hand, the hostility on the other, we read the whole story of antagonism be tween the familie of tl plantation owner and the smal) farmer One is tempted to expatiate at length on thi typal perfections of the Revercomb group, covering in four generations the vho!e psychology and most of the hi tory of their entire class tended and the patiently grandparents, childishly greedy in their and devoted; quarrelsome dotage; the harsh meeting depredations womankind Archie, lazy ranger with dog and gun; and, mother, the silent Abner, upon hi with summary vengeance; lastly, the stalwart miller, embody ing all the virtues of his class its vigor, its independence, its intolerant idealism, its powers of r« crude its energy, endurance istance and No less admirable is the portrayal of the cultivated Gays, survivors of a ocial order whose standards no long- er prevail. No one has heretofore fet in the clear cold light of common
Page 14
The Nation | Vol. 93, No. 2402 above eight thousand separate articles, en upon the status of the South- drew Handel, an ascetic missionary n woman under the old régime, and from Vermont, all but declared his love a considerable number of which are re- ul no one but a modern artist could for the same goddess, when, as he was peated) of edifying stories, many of painted the slow martyrdom of about to raise her hand to his lips, “@ which are still in circulation. We use M Kesiah, to whom nature had strong shaft of moonlight struck the the term edifying, as well as entertain- both beauty and “the liver of a jong fingers which lay in his; and he ing, for this great mass of stories owes (“the difference between the liver saw their yellow gleam.” In short, ic, origin, almost exclusively, to the a lady and that of another person there are several thrills in store for the desire of medieval preachers to interest that one required no exercise and emotional reader. Scorned by her white and edify their congregations. The use other did"), and whose artistic pre- lover, Mahlee turns from the Ark of of illustrative stories in sermons, while ctions had been sternly repressed as the Covenant Mission to avenge the in- not unknown earlier, did not become oming in “a Virginia lady. sult to her race by becoming a conane general! until the foundation in the thir- d’Are of the Boxers. The not unim-|+onth century of the Franciscan and —_— Popham. By Mary C. E. We- | PTess!¥' tragedy of her end may be left phominican orders profoundly changed Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co to the — of the reader. the character of preaching. It is said O isly of the type of “Cranford,” Bh ee of the founder of the Ordo Pradicantium, tale betrays here and there the aidieahe ‘ ounce neat af te Avansabat oxemplis, quibus ad amorem ' familiar modern note of cleverness aaa een tn tem teaniis bathaieaeaial Christi seculive conterntum audientium nich wan utterly ferelan te Mra. Gas I . Recs ated tien ts aoe animi flecterentur ; and almost all who Yot Mre. Wemyas peaseases & nes pe eatinc oe at premier af were prominent in the use of exrempla cand ef genuine end infectious hamer, ing siieeaie or illustrative stories in their own ser- especially in her portrayal of childre SES. mons or by collecting them for the use sho seem te have stepped directly cut ae of others were Dominicans. A most im- of nature fhe conclusion supplied py | The House in the Hedge. By Ralph Hen- portant exception was Jacques de Vitry, little Pat Howard to an unfinished pro ry Barbour. New York: Moffat, Yard bishop of Acre, preacher of the crusade vert ansiamed ty bie governess te wertn| &@ Ca. of 1217, and historian of the Orient. He quoting: “People who live in glass| Early in the book, the winsome hero-| “4S the first to employ systematically houses—should undress in the dark.” ine of this little story climbs a tree. Up in his sermones vulgares (sermons ad- ‘The author shows a literary sense of in the tree is a platform where Mar- dressed to all sorts and conditions of phrase, too, in such comments as that jorie likes to read. From that exalted men) illustrative stories. Thesc stories, upon the “terrible facial stiffness which though rustic station she can look across or to give them their technical name, comes from the social smile.” And the the hedge that otherwise conceals the exempla, were collected separately for letter which the village doctor's wife house recently rented by a mysterious the use of other preachers, and similar pens to a hostess whose dinner, given stranger. The windows are open but collections were later made in alphabet- the previous evening, has disagreed with curtained, and through the curtains ical form, arranged by topics. With the the worthy physician, is inimitable comes the voice of a man entreating invention of printing, the older manu- Indeed, there is not a little to com-| Marjorie to climb the tree every day script collections were replaced by such mend in the painting of rustic manners and speak to him. He is reduced to ask- printed ccliections _ the “Speculum Ex- d motives. Christian Hope, the hero-|ing this favor by an automobile acvi- emplorum,” Herolt’s “Promptuarium,” the beautiful is a keen observer and ire, though not most Wo- man in the book s\inpathetic Jistener who will probably win the hearts of a good many readers. Lady ty] Victoria of is a of the husband, Popham diverting commu- wife, are unconquerable optim to the total plot is for the most part, as be, That it been marred by the illogical leading the person nity Howards, and children add The should ould have l who appreciably Tect rather slight. } almost absurd romantic breathless the nt of final pages is a pity Edith Lane Co Lantern By York Reo there Wherry John cer uprising of 1900, in China, of The Red daughter this not uninteresting Mahtlee, God Light a English ratl heroine of the Lantern is of obscure rasian an no man and an Chinese ler he depicted; woman Kast temperament the Peking We struggle between nd tf in is r own and scene In confronts her father and half-sister ah hite is genuinely dramatte Sam Wang, also Eurasian, and a leader n the wholly the not for thwarted by*death An uprising, is a grotesque figure convincing, whose parsion goddess is finally the followers hands of his own dent, which has turned Reed Harrington, the “Scala Celi” of Johannes Gobius, ete. Harvard football player, poloist, oars- eee exempla ne given in man, and what-not, inte a recumbent — a “ y, Se a =e o> figure, paralyzed below the shoulders. companied by a moralization. Of the lat- ter class the “Gesta Romanorum,” still a most interesting and precious work, ig the best specimen. One hundred and nine manuscripts are described and analyzed in Mr. Her- bert’s “Catalogue.” The large majority of these contain collections of Latin ez- So Marjorie continues to climb her tree and to engage in conversation with the until the invalid’s shame of his helplessness passes away. Thereafter Marjcrie and Harrington converse, not through lace curtain darkly, but face to face. Toward the end there is voice, as a a successful operation, of course, and empla, Some are in verse, such as Wil- Lappiness comes, postponed for a few|!!am of Waddington’s “Manuel des Le ” ~ x _ . paves, by a rather foolish bit of pistol- Péchés” (French), and its Engush translation by Robert of Brunne, both published by the Roxburghe Club. There _are also English metrical homilies, con- taining illustrative stories, some of which have been edited by Horstmann. In French is the collection known as “Vie des anciens Péres,” which has been ‘only partly published, and a collection cf pl The simple, straightforward nar- tative with its touch of school-girl slang and humor is really well done. ay. STORIES AND STORY- BOOKS. MEDIAVAL Catalogue of Romances in the Depart-\two hundred and twenty-nine ezempla ment of Manuscripts in the British | arranged alphabetically, and mostly tak- Wuseum. Vol. Ill. By J. A. Herbert, er from the “Alphabetum Narrationum.” More interesting is the translation in the Northumbrian dialect of the “Alpha- in the Department of Man- xii, 730. Print- assistant uscripts. Crown 8vo, pp ed by order of the Trustees. London, petum Narrationum” usually attributed 1910 te Etienne de Besancon, but shown oy One would not expect to find in a theauthor of the “Catalogue” to be more catalogue of mediwval manuscripts,| properly ascribed to Arnold of Lidge mostly Latin, a mine of entertaining (1308). The English translation has fiction, and yet the volume before us| recently been published by the Early contains literally thousands (there are' English Text Society, and is one of the
Page 15
a July 13, gli most interesting and valuable of the great collections. A considerable num- ber of other manuscripts have been printed, either fully or in part, such as the “Exempla of Jacques de Vitry” (by Professor Crane for the English Folk-Lore Society), the “Tractatus de Abundantia Exemplorum” (Ulm, 1480), and Etienne de Bourbon’s “Liber de Sep tem Donis” (by Lecoy de La Marche for the Société de l'Histoire de France). Cesar of Heisterbach’s “Dialogus Mirac ulorum” (by Strange, Cologne, 1851), Bromyard’s “Summa Predicantium,” and Herolt’s “Promptuarium Exemplor um” have been printed frequently. The Italian collection of moralized tales in MS. Add. 22557 has been printed Ulrich in the Romania, Vol. XII (1884), aud the “Gesta Romanorum,” of which fourteen manuscripts in Latin, two ‘xu English, and one in German are here an alyzed, is, of course, easily accessible in print. This is also the case with the important fables and stories of Odo of Cheriton, edited by Oesterley and Her vieux. hy vy There is left, however, an enormous mass of inedited material of the great- est interest and value to the student of medizval fiction. We may call atten- tion especially to the MS. Add. 11284, containing the “Speculum Laicorum,” usually ascribed to John of Hoveden, the chaplain of Queen Eleanor, mother of Edward I. The manuscript is often cited as the Thoms MS., as it once be- longed to that distinguished antiquary and bears his signature. The work con- sists of a collection of passages from the Scripture and the Fathers, arrang- ed alphabetically according to subjects in eighty-seven chapters, and illustrated by nearly six hundred short tales, apo- logues, and fables. The greater part of these stories are from the usual sources. The remainder, Mr. Herbert says, “be- long to the category of ‘temporum preteritorum ac modernorum event us,’ which our author had probably learnt at hearsay In the’ great majority of these the scene is laid in England, generally in some speci- fied locality, as Kent, Winchelsea, Ber- wick, Eynsham, etc. (especially the first-named, which occurs frequently). Two of the anecdotes relate to traits in Henry III's character; five others are narrated as having occurred during his reign; and others contain marks of time which assign them to the same pe- riod.” Our space will not allow us ‘o mention other collections, and the above must suffice to show the value and inter- est of medieval exempla. It remains to say a few words about the work of the author of this catalogue. In the first place, the range of this third volume is narrow and technical compared with that of the first two vol- umes, which contained, among others, ro mances belonging to the great cycles of antiquity, those concerning Arthur and The Nation Charlemagne, northern and _ eastern legends and tales, A2sopic fables, visions of heaven and hell, miracles of the Vir- gin, etc. A multitude of difficult ques- tions were discussed and solved by the responsible author, the late H. L. D. Ward (a name dear to hosts of scholars in this country and abroad), who had the able assistance of J. A. Herbert, the author of the present volume. In the case of this third volume, there were relatively few questions to settle, but an enormous amount of labor and erudition necessary for the manuscripts and the annotation of the This task Mr. Herbert has accomplished in a way the was the analyses of separate stories. to earn gratitude of all students of mediava!l fi tion. In addition, he valuable information about Odo of Cher has contributed iton, the “Gesta Romanorum,” the au thorship of the “Alphabetum Narra tionum,” etc. William Lloyd Garrison By Lindsay Swift. (American Crisis Biographies.) Philadelphia: George W. Jacobs & Co $1.25 net. Biographies of men like Garrison, un like those of statesmen, soldiers, or men of letters, must often be approached by the thoughtful student with somewhat of apprehension. However deep may have been the impression made by mor- al leaders or reformers upon their own times, one cannot be sure that the story of their careers will for succeeding generations. The moral prob- retain interest lems of one age are not those of anoth- er, nor is their full significance usually comprehended by those who wrestle wth them; and there is danger lest, their conditions are examined with more precision and at longer range, a critical evaluation may weaken, if indeed it does not go far to destroy, appreciation of what once passed for moral fervor. To one’s mind in situation whose chief ethical the form in which it presented itself at the moment, has been definitively and then to describe that situation with truthfulness, and detach- ment, is as hard a task as the historian is likely to essay. There is no. better American history of what has just been said than the of the abolition movement under Garrison. The story of the emancipation of a race from servi- tude, linked as it is with the story of the greatest of all wars, will never, we may be sure, lose its spectacular inter- est, however often it may be told. But for a generation which, though it has never seen a slave, nevertheless come to acquiesce in a policy of spread race discrimination and subjec tion, the moral enthusiasm with which the struggle for emancipation was wag- ed may mote, and even repellent. Here is a mov as orient a social problem, in solved, sympathy, illustration in course has wide well come to seem crude, re 35 yr ment which, as many students now af fect to see it, flouted history in affirm ing the natural equality of whites and blacks, ignored the economic advantages of slave Southern agricul- attacked indis- its pro leader under conditions, and who labor tural all iminately opposed gkramme of reform Here is a hose courteous rated and admitted matched by manners, conse zeal, intellectual power were fanatical intolerance and bitter speech; who seemed at tims to love violence as much as he alway: hated ease; who fell an easy victim to the latest “ism,” and quarrelled with the church as radically as with the state; who refused to vote or to join a party; and who, after denouncing in unmeasured terms the Constitution of the United States, publicly burned that instrument and advocated disunior Clearly, we do not do this sort of thing today, partly because we think rather bad manners, partly because it not sO easy as it once was to be a mal Why, then, should the tinue to be told, and each time with an tyr. story con attempt at still more accuracy and com pleteness? Why not leave a dead past to bury its dead? We are disposed to think that Mr Swift, in the volume which is the im plied answer to such a question, has met the difficult conditions of his prob lem with a very high degree of success Hlis book does not, indeed, add greatly of the of rison’s life, nor does it pretend Working, as he has been obliged to work, in has frank ly based his biography upon well-known Gar to to our knowledge facts do BU, small compass, he and easily available material, and has leaned hard, as all must, upon the mon umental “Story” by Garrison's sons. This is not to say that he has followed his authorities slavishly, or contented him self with rephrasing time-honored and conventional opinions. There is abun dant evidence that he has studied hi subject carefully and intelligently, and that his conclusion however much tiey may accord with those of previous field, have taken second-hand from any one. The merits of Mr. book lie, first, in the orderly and instructive set ting forth of the main events of Garri Considered as a vorkers in the sam: not been Swift's son's career. simply piece of biography, it is highly ble workmanship. There the general history to credita is enough of show the conne tion, and enough of personal] detail to show the man. If there has been in the background of his mind an ideal Garri is son, there is no evidence that it an ideal different from that which a straightforward and thoughtful narra tive would be certain to reveal Hie yond these excellencies, however, fairl to be looked for in the work of a dil gent student and practised writer, is the rarer quality of intelligent and syn pathetic appreciation. More successful
Page 16
ly, we think, than almost any histor- ian who has dealt with the abolition movement, Mr. Swift has outlined in true perspective the moral foundations of Garrison's course. Perhaps slavery would have disappeared in this country, in course of time, as a result of the operation of social, political, and eco- nomic causes beyond the control of any one man; but it in fact disappeared when it did chiefly because William Lioyd Garrison and his followers stir- red the conscience of the nation to the depths, and made the continuance of the institution seem a crime. Mr. Swift has not allowed the glamour of this moral revolution to distort his critical judg- ment. He sees clearly, and with cour- teous frankness e »oses, the weaknesses and mistakes of Garrison and his adher- nts, and gives full credit to the men who reaped where Garrison had sown. But he sees with equal clearness, and sympathetically describes, the moral conquest of public opinion which it was the distinctive work of the abolition agitation to achieve. In an age which, like the present, is fond of attributing pretty much all progress either to knowledge or to organization, it is re- freshing to come upon a book which, like this, tells once more the story of a social revolution whose greatest in- sitrument was persistent moral appeal. The Intellectuals: An Experiment in Irish Club Life. By Canon Sheehan, D.D. New York: Longmans, Green & Co $1.50 net. “Did you ever read ‘The Autocrat of the Breakfast-Table’?” asks Doctor Hol- den in one of the opening pazes of this book “Of course,” answers young Father Dillon, The Autocrat is well known to Canon Sheehan, who has frankly taken him for his model in this instance. His plan is more formal than that of Dr. Holmes. His interlocutors are not assembled in the casual fashion of the breakfast-table group. The intellectuals are “a society of select people, who meet together for amusement, instruction, and edification,” and call themselves with old-fashioned elfconsciousness the Sunetoi. The founder and moderator is young Father Diller The other members are the aforementioned physician and his wife, o banker and bankeress (the banker be- ing a confessed Philistine),a Dublin pro fessor, a young English poet and an old Irish one (but one “life” away from a title), an Irish girlgraduate and a Scotch bluestocking, and one of two oth- ers. Attempt is made to give the Prot- estanta a fair representation. The so clety meets at regular intervals at the houses of the members, who are all sup- posed to contribute to the entertain- ment. The enterprise is rather obso- lescent than novel, or would be in New England. But the imaginary conversa- [ Vol. 93, No. 2402 tions which form the real substance of | panies, inheritance and poll taxes, ex- the book have a good deal of freshness | emptions, tax limitations, the assess- and variety. Here Canon Sheehan has | ment of money and credits, and the tax- fairly struck the note of the Autocrat.| ferret system. Part iii treats with His good humor, his flexibility of mood, | equal care the subject of railway taxa- the range of his themes, all serve to re-' tion. These topics are handled with call, with no sense of feeble imitation, great wealth of detail and frequently those Beacon Street symposia of famous| by the comparative method. Iowa memory. Even the bits of verse are| has encountered all the difficulties, legal, not lacking which so pleasantly punc-| political, and economic, that have at- tuate the discourses of the Autocrat.| tended the best efforts of other States. Literary and moral questions have an/ Particularly instructive is Professor important place in these discussions; Brindley’s discussion of the taxation of but it is natural that the burning themes railways. In 1872, as a result of a coali- for Canon Sheehan have to do with the’! tion between the farmers and the rail- Ireiand—-the Catholic Ireland—of to-| ways, a law was enacted by which the day. The striking thing is that, with | roads have ever since been assessed by this frank preoccupation, he succeeds in the State, and the valuations so deter- presenting so many different points of! mined have been distributed among the view, and in leaving them as points of counties on a mileage basis, and then view. He offers no panacea for the ills | taxed at the local rates like the proper- of old Ireland, advances no arguments ty of individuals. The result has been (in his own person) for the confusion of | that terminal values have been distrib- Protestantism. A certain “love-interest” | uted among rural taxing districts, great- somewhat perfunctorily introduced | ly to the detriment of the cities; and might have been dispensed with: Canon| that on the terminal values thus dis- Sheehan is less fortunate in his touches | tributed the railways have paid local of romance than the Autocrat! taxes at the rate of $2.50 to $3 per $100, instead of city rates, which are fre- quently $8 or $9 per $100. Thus it comes History of Tazation in Iowa. By John about that to an important terminal E. Brindley. Iowa City: The State city is allotted an assessed valuation of Historical Society of Iowa. $31,297 for its railway property, while In these two volumes of the Iowa Eco-| the adjoining township receives a val- nomic History Series Professor Brindley | vation of $95,182. bas given the most careful and valuable; In considering remedies for the no- study yet made of the tax system of|torious evils of the present system of en American State. Part i deals with |taxation, Professor Brindley avoids the the general property tax, and is note-|hasty and superficial conclusions which worthy for the emphasis placed upon/a decade ago found such favor among methods of administration. From 1838 tax reformers. He shows that the pro- to 1857 the forces of centralization and posal to effect a complete separation decentralization contended for the mas-| of the sources of State and local reve- tery, victory resting sometimes with the| nues, entirely ignores the fundament- edvocates of township assessment and al evil of existing methods, viz., com- sometimes with those of county assess-| plete decentralization of assessment ma- ment; while the Code of 1851 vested chinery; and that State control of local substantial authority in a State Board assessments is the true remedy for the of Equalization. But from 1857 to 1873 conditions which the advocates of sep- the pendulum swung steadily toward {aration desire to change. He recog- administrative decentralization, with nizes also that in most of our States it the result that the city and township |is useless to propose the exemption of assessors were finally left in possession personal property from all taxation, and cr all effective power in the assessment | that the present tax on personalty is of property. Whatever the shortcom-|not likely to be abandoned until prac- ings of the general property tax may be |ticable substitutes are found. Such sub- and in Iowa they seem to have been stitutes, he thinks, may be found in a numerous and serious as elsewhere business or rental taxes, and in the it is evident that no system of direct imposition of a uniform tax, at the taxation could have been expected to rate of three or four mills on the dollar, work well under the chaotic conditions upon intangible property. In the taxa- attending the purely local system of ad- |tion of railways, he favors ad valorem ministration. Professor Brindley’s assessment by the State, with a proper work would be noteworthy, if for no apportionment of local and non-local other reason, for his firm grasp andjvalues. It is interesting to note that clear presentation of this vital fact,| last spring the Iowa Legislature adopt- which is one that has been ignored al-| eu the suggestion that a uniform tax ata most invariably by American students| moderate rate should be imposed upon of State and local taxation. | intangible wealth; and also authorized Part ii deals exhaustively with spe-|the appointment of a special tax com- cial problems in taxation, such as the | mission to investigate the entire sub- taxation of banks, insurance companies, | ject of taxation and prepare further evpress, telegraph, and telephone com-| measures of reform. In this work, the
Page 17
July 13, 1911] The Na tion
commission cannot fail to derive the greatest assistance from Professor Brindley’s exhaustive, able, and emi nently judicious work. Scotch Irish Pioneers in Ulster and America. By Charles Knowles Bolton. Boston; Bacon & Brown. $2 net. Though the Scotch-Irish constituted the second most important element com- posing our population at the end of the colonial period, no treatise has ever been written presenting the extent of their settlement and summing up their influence in American history. Such treatment as has been attempted hith- erto is either partial and local or, if on a larger scale, is lacking in Jepth and thoroughness. Mr. Bolton here adds one more to the works of the former type, dealing only with the forerunners and carrying his account but little be yond the period of the great migration, 1718. His work is chiefly biographical and genealogical and is written in a fashion to attract but few readers. Nev- ertheless, it is based on considerable in- dependent research, and in all that it says of the origin of the movement is deserving of appreciation and respect. Mr. Bolton is interested in four phases of his subject: the conditions prevailing in Ulster County, Ireland, from which one or more members from nearly every family came to America; the occasional emigrants, generally min- isters, who came over before 1718; the migration to New England and the scat- tering of the newcomers in the frontier districts of Massachusetts, New Hamp- shire, and Maine; and lastly the migra tion to the Middle and Southern colo- nies, chiefly to Philadelphia and Charles- ton. The general estimate he has given, of the conditions prevailing in Ulster County is admirable and his account of the topographical features and the re ligious, social, and economic life con- stitutes a distinct departure from all previous modes of treatment. The de- tails of the migration and later settle- ments are fairly well handled, though sometimes not as clearly as they ought to be. Furthermore, Mr. Bolton is man- ifestly more interested in New England than he is in the South, despite the fact that for every one who landed in Boston a dozen set foot in Newcastle, Philadelphia, and Charleston, and de- spite the further fact that in the South the Scotch-Irish exercised greater influ ence in governmental and religious life than they did in New England. For the general reader, the most in- teresting and suggestive chapter is that on Scotch-Irish character. These peo ple were compacted of the sternness 2f the Covenanter and the wit and humer of the Irish. They were softened by the century's residence in the favoring en vironment of Donegal, Londonderry, Tyrone, and Antrim. They cared little
for culture and knowledge and were destined to play but little part in lite-- ature, art, science, business, philan- thropy, and music. They did nothing to beautify themselves, tieir homes, or their communities. They were pioneers and State builders; their law was util- ity and their philosophy pragmatism. They belonged to the frontier and, in all the colonies where they settled, they eventually found their way into the back country. If they remained in the cities, they became tradesmen, chiefly tailors. In the history of America, they stand for energy, resources, and endur- ance, They were earnest and ambitious. Deprived of political rights in their old home, they seized eagerly the opportu- nities that the new world offered. They became leaders in government, debaters in assembly, and, as a rule, vigorous up- helders of American independence against the rule of the mother country They were conspicuous in adventure, de fiant in revolution, and brave in war. Tenacious in their theological views, they became equally stubborn in their adherence to political dogmas, and whe- ther it was the wilderness or the cate chism or the government that opposed them, they fought with the same de termination against all. The names of Stark, Knox, McClellan, Asa Gray, Gree- ley, and Motley of the northern family stend beside those of Rutledge, Calhoun, Jackson, and McKinley of the southern group, as witnesses to the leading part which the Scotch-Irish have played in the history of American achievement. Notes Henry Holt & Co. have just contracted with Professors Trent and Erskine of Co- lumbia for a volume on “Great Writers of America,” in the Home University Library. In October the same house will publish “Language Lessons for Intermediate Grades,” as Book I in the series Progres- sive Studies in English, edited Miss Alma Blount and Prof. Cc. § Northup; Book II, “An Elementary English mar,” has already appeared Mrs. Frances Hodgson Burnett's novel “The Secret Garden,” will be issued from the of Stokes, August 25. The fol lowing month Stokes will bring out Robert Hichens’s “The Fruitful Vine,” and dora’s Box,” by John A. Mitchell, of “Amos Judd.” by Gram- press “Pan author Dout lk joss of In the list of arnoun of cay, Page & Co. are found: “The Wind River,” by A. M. Chisholm; “The Life and Letters of Moses Coit Tyler,” by his daughter, Jessica Tyler Austen, and the Basil W. Duke ements reminiscences of Gen to ce rate the en The tenary Titmarsh Club, of exhibition Thackeray's birth, holding an in Charterhou Ma iscripts, letters, drawings, and portraits of the writer have been lent by members of iy's family, Lady Ritchie and Denis Thackeray Pierpont Morgan, Walter Spencer and by Sir Frederick Macmillan, Mrs. G
ory <3 é M. Smith (widow of Thackeray's publisher), the Re- form Club, and others. of Cole- a supplement With the “Biographia Literaria” ridge 1847, which had been begun by Henry Nelson Cole- and was finished death by bis widow, Sara poet's daugh- there appeared, in after his the ridge Coleridge ter. Henry Ne nclude in this supplement the principal! of poet then with comments on his intellectual ment, and the part s in fact shaped in that way i Ison Coleridge had intended to letters the known, together leve lop- first of thé supplement Arthur Turn- bull has now carried out this design, from which Sara Coleridgedeparted in her sect of the supplement. The result able volumes in Bohn’'s Library (New York: ' ion is two agree- Macmillan), published under the title of “Biographia Epistolaris.” Mr. Turnbull prints theoriginal supplement intact, but et larges it by the insertion at the due chrono fogical points of further letters of Coleridg: and narration. As off by square no confusion of authorship occurs with editorial comment the new parts are marked brackets although the junctionof thestyles and opia- yns of three editors gives a curious uneven- the work Of the 747 letters of Coleridge which have hitherto appeared in print Mr, Turnbull 219, the others being omitted for copyright reasons Alto ecther the two volumes present a pretty fair view of Coleridge on his lower intellectual to ess includes level, with here and there a note of deep personal interest or high speculation, We cannot much commend the editor's own writing. In fact, one rather gasps at such a sentence as this from the Preface Cole ridge, in his letters, has written his own life, for his life, after all, was a life of thought, and his finest thoughts and his most ambitious aspirations are given expression to in his letters to his numerous friends.” Nor is Mr. Turnbull's judgment always more impeccable than his English. It is, for in- stance, a little disconcerting to find in the first volume (p. 235) Coleridge's fragmentary productiveness charged to his transce nden- then ond volume it attributed to an enlarged the cause tual genius, and in the se (p. 138) to find heart: “This physical defect of all inability own ambitious add, is deficient. was Coleridge's to execute his schemes.” The Index, we must Johnson” (Barnes) is a sketch of the late Mayor its candor ‘Tr Carl Lorenz's “Tom L land half- natters of Cleve ith netimes Its one virtue is truth, and untruth were sor of duction, and later pages did, he did love for his says the Intro- What- not becat of a fellowmen, but be- expediency with him,” declare that ever he is¢ great cause he was ambitious to stand above of the lay nature that liked a crooked way much justi- ‘ ommon politician The old Johnson straight course and loomed fication went a There too the up.” is only for expressions Otherwise, the book is disappointing. We get a view at close range of a powerful, impetuo trife-loving personality, with the Ameri can business man’s lack of appreciation of the finer things, but the view unsteady he writer fails to give due spa e of the turning-points in a career 4) apparently knows thoroughly he is also rritating at times in his phrasing or his observations. There are plenty of tool t literary
Page 18
38 The Nation | gentlemen become laborers, but few as good | laneous material. There are the texts of a| division of minds which in former days as Joseph Husband's “A Year in a Coal'number of wills, and summaries of, or | used to write histories of the world, he Mine” (Houghton Mifflin). Mr. Husband’ statements concerning, many other wills.| does not confine himself to any one genre had the great advantage of working for @| phere is a large amount of anecdote, gossip, | or nation, but presents a view of mankind legitimate purpose, that of learning the gnq comment; and a part of the book is de-| and its literature from pole to pole «nd business, without ulterior humanitarian or) yoted to wills figuring in literature and| from the dawn to the dusk of -ouscious- literary intentions. His story is compact! the drama. A statement of the plot of “The /|ness. First, he considers “‘primitive” liter- and vivid. It describes the workmen and/ Thunderbolt” illustrates the wide extent of|ature in Africa, Oceania, Asia, and Amer- their toil in a soft-coal mine in Illinois.| the author's inquiry. The testamentary ef-|ica, with special reference to rhythm, What is especially interesting to a lay read-| forts of Plato and of Mrs. Eddy enjoy | dance, drama, lyric, narration; uext, “bar- er is the sense Mr. Husband gives of that considerable space, while the wills of James | baric” literature in Africa, Oceania, Asia, remarkable system of artificial respiration gmithson, Collis P. Huntington, and Amos|America; then, “autocratic” literature; by which a coal mine is kept in being. One| R. Eno together command fewer than twen-| finally, the ultimate culmination of primitive gets the miner's feeling for the air as a@ ty lines. Among the “curious” wills is, ra- | shout and barbaric yawp under the oressure precious fluid, and a most tractable one. It ther appropriately, that of David J. Brewer,|of modern civilization in “democrati:” lit- is directed where the engineer will, dam- | “jate chief justice of the United States.” In/erature. It cannot be said that the whole med, secreted, diverted below according to| many instances the editor refers to judi- | process takes place visibly before tha vead- the needs of imperilled workmen. Absorbing cial decisions, but apparently in no in-jer’s eyes. The professor skims along over too, is the account of the fight against fire | stance does he give a citation of the author- | “autocratic” and “democratic” literature in the mine, of work effected in the poison-|jty, The wide range of idiosyncrasies in| like Camilla o’er the unbending corn; for ous reek by means of the oxygen helmet, of |testators is amply illustrated but there! he is bent uponthe formulation of the “pro- various ingenious attacks upon the smould-| may well be some doubt as to the useful-| visional laws” of literary evolution. Theze — enemy. In the end the fire won, and ness of the volume. | are three, and, he says, “are believed to be 1@ mine was aban e ) re ve ” j way a better fight than that which Mr. Huss | Several Fecent essays of Adolt Harnack, in] Ont oe uaa oy MaSheret wy, The band describes. This is a most informing his debate with Rudolph Schm on the origin Law of Progress may be stated thus: Under little book, written with the force born of of the church as & legal society and Ge similar conditions the average literary ad- knowledge and simplicity mature of ecclesiastical law, are mass Go| vance in a give i og given community is directly pro = cessible to the English reader in a volume} tional to th ‘dth 4 devth : Shepherd s ih , 5 D n “A Shepherd's Life” (Dutton) W. H.| of the Crown Theological Library, entitied | 9°7#onet to the width and depth of man's Hudson has tried to recall older conditions | “The Constitution and Law of the Church in | *tainment of consciousness of self and of on Salisbury Plain. He has lived with the the world. II. The Law of Initiative may : the First Two Centuries’; they are trans- oe P Wiltshire villagers, and has recorded the | jatea by F. L. Pogson and H. D. A Major | °® atated thes: Every step & Mevary gre- : r gress is initiated by individuals, whose suc- recollections of old men and women. ID | (putnam), Sohm’s theory, as advanced in his | é , general he harks back to the days before epoch-making “‘Kirchenrecht” in 1892 is | °C8 is measured by their own mental indi- agriculture and army manceuvres, when the that the New Testament Ecclesia was not an viduality and by the readiness of the com- wrenigyne Wiltshire sheep with the few requi- organization of any sort, either local or munity te receives as well as to perpetuate site dogs and shepherds held the downs, and general, but a spiritual fellowship; that a the new discovery in form or content. III. seeks to revive vatriare , F : saw os ivene stat> s to revive that patriarchal time with jega) constitution is opposed to the nature The Law of Respons! ngerens may be tated its few and chiefly physical values. An of the church, and that when the notion of thus: Other conditions being equal, literary ancient shepherd, Isaac Bawcombe, is the eccteniontion§ taw wes tatsebuce’ Chwlati- form and content vary directly with the ropresentative ) F astor: orientation of mental responsiveness in a ~ ~ , ativ wel vanishing pastoralism anity was transformed into Catholicism.|" tatic f a me sosaie ' : rn acta from Bawcombe upon | war-ack submits this thesis to searching estebenye ie l o a nesy cng erst impressionistic cursion , 2 es y m toes 1 - me ursions of his own, and criticism, maintaining that Sohm is correct | | ae beeen ape yin 6 Giteatien naturalizes i arge > j . ” irge among the birds, | in his affirmations, but wrong in his denials. dogs, and f 8 ) ‘ ' . | expresses them also thus: id foxes; but ever returns to his te discusses at length the first indications | ° hero Among the tall fellows of Isaac Suweenints cent Gin Be ie anes “Oe of organization in the primitive Christian | ae ane aeineten ‘an diets duane wane couse communities, with their various ordinances L—R+0 trespassing tn @ hay meadow and officers, paying special attention to the ; rise of the episcopate and a specific ecclesi- | For the meaning of the symbols we refer met ates Ge ee aby = astical priesthood. While Harnack is at | the reader to page 415. With a Newtonian morning the donkeys and aoe” with am pains to state his opponent's views accurate- | underpinning of this character, we do not had vanished, and the whole village won- | ly, one who would do full justice to Sohm | think that literary criticism need longer be dered how he had done it. The stone wall| should read the more sympathetic apprecia- complained of as without “even a sem = the pound was four feet and a half tion of Walter Lowrie in “The Church and|blance of science.” iigh, and the fron gate was locked, yet he | , a had lifted the donkeys up and put them Its Organization in Primitive Times,” pub- over, and had loaded them, and gone be-j{ lished a few years ago. Another recent fore any one was up. | translation from the German is the third Mr. Hudson, who when his theme war-| Volume of Pfleiderer’s “Primitive Chris- rants It can be tropical enough, here is | tianity,” by W. Montgomery (Putnam). The persistently demure and restrained. Any- | period treated is the same, but Pfleiderer’s body who is able to sift the wheat from| work is a general history, dealing with [ Vol. 93, No. 2402 The Colonial Society of Massachusetts continues its output of substantial pubiica- tions in the issue of the twelfth volume of its Transactions, covering the year 1908-1909. It announces the early appearance of two more volumes, one nearing completion and t} haff ‘ bag: » | Mt » destetens ti ell the other largely in type. The activities of ve chaff of Wordsworth’s “Excursion,” | literary and doctrinal questions as wel) QS) 11:. aistinguished society stand in striking will like “A Shepherd’s Life.” Those who| those of organization. find such a task beyond their powers or inclination might as well be warned off once for all. Mr. Hudson has achieved a new style as puzzling In ite way as the nanner of certain dons. Is it highly dis- tinguished? or is it merely dull? or is it compact of supersubtile Intelligence as- contrast to the apathy of some of our local Prof. A. S. Mackenzie’s “The Evolution |historical associations. Inevitably, in the of Literature” (Crowell) is, as the title| search for local data, such a society tends suggests, a somewhat ambitious work. “Is | to magnify local history and to serve up there no possible way,” asks the author,| much that is rather antiquarian than his- “whereby the art of the critic may be ren- | torical, but, in the main, the standard of its dered a little more objective? Can literary | papers is high. The present volume may criticiam not attain to the dignity of even | almost be characterized as a Harvard num- a semblance of science? It may if w2 en-| ber, since no less than six articles relate deavor to broaden and deepen our conception | directly or indirectly to the history of that of literature. It is such a purpose that | institution,’ and, in addition, an account is regulates the hope and the scope of the|given of the inauguration of President pages that follow.” The professor tukes the | Lowell. Andrew McFarland Davis’s contri- daring position that the evolution of liter- ‘bution on John Earvard, and his supple- lature is closely connected with the evolution; mental paper on “Hints of Contemporary Ancient, Curious, and Famous Wills” | of society, and he undertakes to display the Life in the Writings of Thomas Shepard,” (Little, Brown), by Virgil M, Harris, is a| mutually dependent developments proceed-|are delightful. In the latter instance dignified scrap-book of somewhat miscel-' ing together. Belonging to that grandiose Mr. Davis might have gained a hint or two suming the safe disguise of an expression from which sentiment has been carefully | eradicated? Here are niceties in which ! the gentle reader surely is as competent! as your reviewer. The book is of good Eng- lish make, and is pleasantly tllustrated with outline vignettes by Bernard C. Gotch
Page 19
July 13, 1911] from Shepard's letter to Hugh Peter of December 27, 1645, conspicuously print.d not many years ago. Scarcely less valuable are Herace Everett Ware’s papers on “Win- throp’s Course Across the Atlantic” and “A Forgotten Prime Meridian,” the second which, as distinctly mathematical rather than historical, may be in honor of the late Simon Newcomb, whose picture forms the frontispiece to the volume. On the other hand, Simeon E. Baldwin's paper on Spring- field seems to be but a rethreshing of old straw, while the articles of John Taggart Blodgett on “The Mayflower Compact” and Merton Dexter on “Plymouth and James- town” are on a lower plane of originality and scholarship. One item is certain to puz- zie the historian. On page 190 we learn that James B. Ayer “read some notes, covering the period from 1764 to 1785, concerning Harvard College, taken during a recent visit to London from the of the New England Company.” “New England Company” at that time? It is a matter of regret that the notes thus read were not printed in full, that their source might be identified of records What existence was in Students of ballot and election laws will welcome the monograph of Arthur C. Lad- ington on “American Ballot Laws, 1889- 1910,” published as a bulletin of the State Department of Education (No. 488). The monograph contains an historical survey of ballot-law legislation for the past twen- ty years, together with a comparative tabular digest of ballot laws of the forty- six States and the Territories of Arizona ana New Mexico in force last November. It is divided into several parts, as follows: (1.) Achronological survey (1888-1910) of ev- ery law enacted and every constitutional emendment proposed by the Legislature. (2.) A classification and summary presenting in tubular arrangement the principal chang- es in the form of ballot in the several States since 1888. (3.) A summary for each State, under various heads. of the principal features ef their ballot laws as they stood on November 8, 1910. The sgubdivisions covér constitutional provisions, type of tallot, the arrangement of names on the ballot, methods of voting “split” and “straight” tickets, methods of placing names on the ballots, and details of the provisions for voting and counting the bellots. A “Latin Grammar,” by H. E. Burton of Dartmouth College (Silver, Burdett & Co.), is an intelligent attempt to set forth the essential of the Latin language for the use of intelligent students. The details necessary ‘for graduate study are omitted but everything of value for school lege teaching is included. In the book differs greatly from current gram mars. The customary tion of Words has been broken up, and the fcrmation of nouns is treated at ning of the the formation of verbs at the beginning of the chapter on verbs. While be said for this innovation, it tends to distract the attention of the younger student the vital matter of paradigm study. In the arrangement of the syntax Professor Bur- tor contents himself with plain statements of fact. If he has theories as to the de- velopment of from earlier types, he shows little indication of them in While he adopts Profes facts or col- arrangemen’ chapter on Forma- the begin chapter on noun inflection much may from constructions his presentation sor Hale's volitive subjunctive, he retains the potential subjunctive in spite of Pro- fcssor Eimer. On the other hand, he net make of syntax a lexical treatment of particles as did Lane, nor does he arrange his topics according to the elements in a The cases does developed sentence as did Gildersleeve case syntax follows the order of the the verb syntax the order of the moods In general the author is chary of coining new terms or including new categories. But the useless ablative of the road finds place, and the ablative of extent of time has the dignity of a separate heading. The treatment of the syntax is fresh, straight- forward, and clear; no subtleties of expres sion or vagaries of interpretation disturb the comprehension. Least successful the author in handling the dative case, where he shows himself a modified localist, while in regard to the other cases he leans to the grammatical theory. The treatment of cenditional sentences is particularly good, while in the matter of temporal sentences he shows weakness, especially in cum with the indicative, and antequam and prius quam, In the introductory chapter on Sounds, we find the latest results as to vowel length, though the author is con- servative as to word-division and accentua tion. Very few errors are to be found, In the paradigm of the verb we meet with the incorrect form amatus case, although cor- rect examples are given in the syntax § 948 anc a glance at Priscian would have him from the blunder. nowhere defined, between but chapter without saved The parts of speech doubtful substantive are and so the noun and the devoted definition translations Cistinction is avoided; in syntax, we have a Substantive of the of the netion whole to Ciauses, any word substantive. The examples are good, but lack the disti of the translations of Gildersleeve o: But, speaking generally, the grammar is an extremely capableand satisfactory work and Lane cCeserves cordial recognition, while the ty- pography is excellent and adds greatly to the good impression which the book pro- duces Edward Dicey, the English author and journalist, is dead at the age of seventy- nine. He took honors at Cambridge in botn the mathematical and classical tripos; was called to the bar in 1875, and during his career as a barrister spent much of hig leisure in literary work. For a short time he was editor of the London Paily Tele- graph, and from 1870 to 1889 of tne OD server, in which ne strongly urged the an- nexation of Egypt by the English Mr Dicey was the author of “Rome in 1860," Cavour, a Memorr,” “Six Months in tn Federal States,” “The Schleswig-Holstein War,” “Battlefields of 1866 “A Month in Russia During the Marriage of the Czare- witch,” “The Morning Land,” “England and Egypt,” “Victor Emmanuel,” “Bulgaria, the Peasant State,” “Tne Story of the Khedivate,” and “The Egypt of the Future.” The death is reported from London of Samuel Henry Jeyes, a journalist, and au thor of translations from Juvenal and of volumes on the Marquis of Salisbury, Mr Chamberlain, and Lord Rosebery Ulric de Fonvielle, who died recently at the age of seventy-eight, was a man of varied activities He began as a painter but soon turned to Jjournalisr He took part in our own civil war, and fought in Italy on the side of Garibaldi He accom panied Victor Noir to the interview with Prince Pierre Bonaparte when Noir was shot. He was in the Franco-Prussian war and though condemned to death by the Com mune, obtained refuge at the house of Sardou. Later he returned to journalism and painting. He was the author of “S« venirs d'une chemise roug published in 1861. Prof. Otto Gilbert, director of the versity library of Halle, who is dead at tl age of seventy-one, had written a number of books on classical subjects, among them Rom Karthago terlehre ‘Die he (01 Phe« Griechis und meteorologischen Altertums and rien des griechischen Science BURBANK’'S IMPROVED FRUITS. A picture of John Burroughs sampling the “Patagonia” strawberry in its orig inator’s garden at Santa Rosa, Cal., is in Luther Burbank’'s latest bulletin. In this berry Mr. Burroughs discovered “a wonderful pineapple flavor” and _ pro nounced it the most delicious strawber ry he had ever tasted. It is said to be an exceptionally good keeper, and can be freely eaten by those with whom the common acid strawberries disagree. It is the result of a full quarter of a cen tury’s patient experiments on the part of the most ingenious and successful of all hybridizers. For twenty years Mr Burbank had, as frankly tried in vain to improve on the finest the market. Knowing that all our best strawberries have descend ed wholly or in part of the Chilian varieties, he got one of his col lectors in Chill, five years ago, to send him seeds of wild strawberries from the Cordillera and the regions Among the plants which fron these seeds he found value he admits, berries in from one from Coast grew that when some prom ised to be of great crossed with the best American strains. With his tience, he experimented the very numerous seedlings under test was found this unique berry, which wa at once recognized as the grand prize and European pa “among usual Edisonian until In this little genealogical tale we have an excellent illustration of that “judg ment as to what will likely be good and what bad” which, in the words of Pro- fessor Bailey, is “the very core of plant breeding,” and in which jurbank ex- cels.” His bulletins give many similar instances; and in view of the fact that his rivals and others belittle his la bors, it is proper that he should plead his own cause. His bulletins call atten tion to some of the results of his meth ods as compared with those of other plant-breeders. Here, for instance, is a fact for his detractors: “Nearly 95 per cent, of the new plums introduced since 1890, now catalogued as standards, orig inated on my own farms, although neat
Page 20
4-O ly four times as many new varieties have been introduced by other dealers. Most of the introductions of others are not now generally even listed.” The Burbank plum, which was introduced less than twenty years ago, is now per- haps more widely known than any oth- er plum, the world over; but, he says, “hundreds of better plums have since been produced on my _ experiment farms.” The Burbank potato is now the universal standard in the Pacific Coast States, and is gradually taking the lead in the Middle West. The new Burbank cherry is sold at high prices in Eastern markets. Altogether, there are already above a hundred valuable new plants, fruits, and flowers, “every one of which has proved better than those known before in some new qual- ity, in some soils and climates. All do not thrive everywhere. Please name one good fruit or nut that does.” The last two sentences are directed at of Burbank’s critics trium- phantly point to cases of failure of his in thi that locality. Judgment has to be used; “certain vari- eties which are a success in one locality may be, and often are, a complete fail- miles distant, or near by on a different eleva- Burbank Crimson Winter been offered by unprinci- in the cold Northern States, those who new products or ure a few different soil tion.” The Rhubarb has pled dealer a or at though they must know that it cannot prove successful there. For this new tvpe Mr. Burbank makes the claim that it is the most valuable vegetable intro- the last quarter of a cen- tury been made with itin California and Florida that it has been named “The Mortgage Lifter.” The chief forester of the Government of South Africa reports that at Cape Town, duced during So many fortunes have where all other rhubarbs had been a failure for two centuries, the Burbank Crimson Winter variety turned out a Yet Mr. Burbank now has a still further improved variety, the complete success, Giant, which excels the original Crim- son Winter Rhubarb “at least 400 per cent.” “It is amazing what opposition one has in experimenting, and the ignorance there is to contend with,” writes an Eng- lish appreciator of this American's re- markable horticultural achievements. Yet Luther Burbank declares that the greatest inconvenience or injustice he has met is not misunderstanding, preju- dice, envy, jealousy, or ingratitude, but the fact that purchasers are so often deceived by unscrupulous dealers who, his carnations, name, folst upon the pub- bananas, watermelons, and a Misusing lic blue thousand other things, including United § thorny cactus for the Burbank On this point Mr. Burbank writes with feeling. Four- teen years ago the first scieqtific experi for the of cactus green hardy rose eedless State Government Thorniless. improvement ments The Nation [ Vol. 93, No. 2402 plants were instituted on his farms. Eight years later, when the long and costly labor was crowned with success, the United States Department of Agri- culture spent $10,000 in searching the world for a cactus of great agricultur- al and horticultural value like those al- ready produced on his farm, but the re- sult was a failure; the “spineless cac- tus” sent out by the Department of Ag- riculture is not spineless, not safe to handle or feed to stock, and the fruit is small and poor. Nine years ago Prof. L. H. Bailey of Cornell wrote of Mr. Burbank: “He secures his livelihood from the new va- rieties he sells to seedsmen and nursery- men, but his experiments are so exten- sive and he tries so many things for the mere zest of it, that he does not make money”; and he suggested that some philanthropist could “render a good service to mankind if he would en- dow this experimental garden and allow its proprietor to devote his whole ener- gy to research.” A few years later the Carnegie Institute undertook that ser- vice, but the alliance did not last long. Mr. Burbank now writes that “after hav- ing been under ‘capture’ for the avowed purpose of ‘the benefit of science’ for five years by the Carnegie Institution of Washington, five years of care, lean- hampering restrictions, and un- profitable conditions, and having dictat- ed to and corrected for their botanists several thousand pages, it is a most gracious relief to return to a life free from the red tape of institutional re- strictions, to a life of active freedom.” At present, he adds, he has reorganized his whole business and promises to give to the world more good fruits and flow- from time time. This he will doubtless do. ness, ers to Acting as agents of the Cambridge Uni- versity Press, the Putnams announc “Aerial Locomotion,” by E. H. Harper and Allan Ferguson, with introduction by G. H. Bryan, and “Ticks—A Monograph of the Ixodoidea,” part ii, by George H. F. Nut- tall. Longmans, Green & Co. have in the press for early publication “Monographs on Top- ics of Modern Mathematics,” edited by J. W. A. Young; “Big-Game Shooting in Upper Burma,” by Major G. P. Evans, Indian Army, and “The Monkey Folk of South Af- F. W. William Magie’s “Principles of and “A Laboratory Outline of Or- ganic Chemistry,” by Prof. Lauder William Jones, are in the hands of the Century Co. rica,” by Fitzsimons. Prof. Physics,”’ Rehder and Charles Sprague Sar- are issuing Alfred of the Arnold Arboretum through the Riverside Press, Cambridge, “The Bradley Bibliography,” five volumes, in an edition limited to five hundred copies. It is advertised as “a guide to the litera- ture including books and articles in learned s80- cleties, and in sclentifie and popular jour- nals, published in all languages to the end of the nineteenth century.” gent of woody plants, the proceedings of Gardeners, professional as well as ama- tcur, who did not procure Allen French’s “The Book of Vegetables” when it first appeared, four years ago, will do well to co so now under the new title of “How to Grow Vegetables” (Macmillan). No other bcok quite takes its place as a practical gvide. At a glance one can refresh one’s memory by reading the instructions therein given for the planting or cul- ture of any vegetable, from asparagus to zit-kwa, just before starting for the gar- den. The yield of a garden can be doubled by following the directions here given re- garding seed and soil, fertilizers, pests, and diseases. The author is skeptical as to his ability to teach the American farmer to add variety to his very limited list of poorly- grown garden truck; he appeals more to vegetable gardeners who do their work for the fun as well as the profit of it. The best vegetables in our country are, in his opinion, grown in the thousands of small home gardens that surround our cities. But the owners of these gardens also are still somewhat limited by national habit and local knowledge; they need to know some- thing about such European delicacies as the globe artichoke, celeriac, cardoon, sea- kale, chard, endive, and Mr. French sup- plies the necessary information. He errs in saying that of the two varieties of en- cive the curled is more tender than the broad-ieaved, for surely the tenderest, crispest of all salads is the escarolle, which has been making its way into our markets within the last five or six years. He is also hardly fair to the seedsmen in quoting scme “wise man” who said, with reference the novelties offered every year, that the value of a variety is inversely as the space given to it in the dealer’s catalogue. That was true years ago; but at the present the best seedsmen have trial grounds which they carefully test new varieties them to their cus- to time in before recommending tomers. The second of the handy little volumes of the “History of Chemistry” (Putnam), .by Sir Edward Thorpe, has another value than that implied by its name. Since it covers the period from 1850 to 1910, during which dis- covery has been most rapid and the modern theories of chemistry have been built up, it affords a rare opportunity for one who | has not studied chemistry for some years to catch up with the progress of the science. Here, for instance, is the story of the radio- active elements told very clearly and defi- nitely in eight small pages, with a portrait of Marie Sklodowska Curie thrown in. Last December, when Professor Van ’t Hoff re- ceived the Nobel prize, and again when, three months later, he died, the newspaper reader was doubtless mildly stirred up by curiosity as to who he was and what he had done to make him famous. Here, in twelve pages, is an explanation of Van ‘t Hoff’s hypothesis of stereo-isomerism and its im- portance as a guide to research. In the chapter on physical chemistry we see the face of Svante Arrhenius of Stockholm, now lecturing at Yale. A rather comprehensive treatment of stresses in stationary structures by graph- ical methods has been undertaken by Wil- liam L. Cathcart and J. I. Chaffee in a text called “Elements of Graphical Statics” (Van Nostrand). The authors state that, as
Page 21
civil engineers, they have prepared the present work for students of mechanical and marine engineering. With the exception of chapters on friction and shafting, there is not much to differentiate it from other texts. However that may be, the book is satisfactory in its scope. With respect to the action of wind pressure on roofs, at- tention should be called to the work of Pro- fessor Nipher, which seems to have been overlooked. “Three-Phase Transmission” (Van Nos- trand), by W. discusses the practi- cal problems of installing and maintaining this method of electrical transmission. No attempt is made to give the theory of these currents; it is rather the notes taken from the experience of the writer, was the chief expert-assistant of the Dublin Cor- poration Electricity Supply. Brew, who The death is reported from London of G. Johnstone Stoney, the Irish scientist, who was born in 1826. He was assistant astronomy to the late Earl of Rosse in 1848 professor of natural philosophy in Queen's University, Ireland, and secretary of institution from 1857 until its dissolution in 1882. He was foreign member of the New York Academy of Sciences and of the Amer- ican Philosophical Society. He wrote “Me- moirs on the Physical Constitution of the Sun and the Stars,” on the atmospheres of planets and satellites, on the internal mo- tions of gases, on and scopic in this telescopic micro- vision, etc. Drama and Musie ANOTHER STAGE EXPERIMENT. For its first experiment, the Chicago Theatre Society, which was recently or- ganized under the presidency of Ham- lin Garland, annovnces a season of “joy- ous” drama. The phrase is a happy one, possibly even more so than the user of it was aware. For to Mr. Garland the principal function of the “joyous” drama would be to wean the American people away from the puerilities of the musical “show.” But the comedy of character and manners can do some- thing more than to supply a substitute for “The Prince and the Pippin.” It can be made the instrument for educat- ing public taste and the public’s judg ment to the highest forms of the drama. Reformers of the theatre too often make the mistake of leaping from the musi- cal-comedy level to the Ibsen level, and thus supply an opening for scornful girding at the “highbrows.” What re- formers too often fail to perceive is that there can be truth and art in the lightest of comedies; and that truth in art is what the American theatre needs most. As a people we dislike, on the stage, what is truthful and what is dis- agreeable. When you give us Ibsen, you give us both. What the Chicago experi- ment seems to be on the point of doing is to omit the disagreeable treatment for the present. It is a counsel of wis- dom. répertoire of “joyous” drama than it is to talk about one. In the list of plays already announced for production we find several that do not quite bubble with the joy of life. It is hard to think of Becque’s “Les Corbeaux” as jocund, or Brieux’s “Robe rouge,” or Synge, or “Faith Healer.” the other hand, there is partial reassurancs in Augustus Thomas, Pinero (if he be taken in his lighter moods), Shaw (if he be taken in his more re ible moods), Yeats, and Barker. The mana- gers of the Chicago enterprise would do well draw on rather than on Pinero as qualified above, even Moody's On spon to Augustus Thomas on Pinero rather than on Shaw, on Shaw rather than on Barker, according te a scale which it should not be im possible to determine. This is said with full consciousness of the fact that our sequence of names is probably in in- verse order to the men’s standing as serious dramatists and critics of life. But it is precisely because we are afraid of the richer fare that we give Augustus Thomas the preference over Pinero and Shaw. In Thomas you will find enough the common faults of our to attract the crowd, and enough of truth ol stage and art to whet the appetite for solider many at have failed through fundamental quality in education fare. So attempts educating the public neglect the patience. f ol Our greatest need for the present is not to be educated in the subtleties of the human soul and human conduct, but and the melodramatics that travesty the broadest facts of human conduct. Of use is it that our more ambitious playwrights go in for photographic realism, if,in the midst of it all, we are suddenly to be projected into the at- mosphere of Robert W. Chambers and George Barr McCutcheon? Of what use is the most painstaking reproduction of an East Side street scene, if you peo- ple that scene with men and women whose psychology is of a kind associated with Mr. James Montgomery Flagg? It should be a punishable crime for dra- matic critics to write, as many of them so often do, that “in spite of ex- cessive recourse to the long arm of co- incidence, the play the of this, that, and the other thing to a de- gree sufficient to justify the manager in taking your money. It is the oiled arm of coincidence that typifies the vice of our drama. From seeing peo ple happen to be in places where they have no right to be, and turn out to be what they have no right to be, one gets easily accustomed to seeing them perform unnatural heroics, take unnat- ural postures, and exhibit unnatural virtues and vices. what sO has merit” over- Many plays succeed because they are “dainty,” and “clean.” No one would grudge them qualities they “sweet,” their success if to these to be rescued from the posturings, 41 added a touch of truth and life. But too often in the play is as false its mechanism as the would-be realis- play. “charming” tic Our serious plays suffer from of Most our plays from an of but chance for the an light what excess melodrama of sufier excess we think is “life” is not then, drama, If it belief that left the and character behind, that is no insistence Here is the can only free u ous the when we enter a e have probabilities of it will the work lies closest t ' ’ ' he iy ihere here on the int drama, nor even on the drama the the ectual hat settles same questions of the newspapers setth ol villains iV that The ock-exchange eve ry industry and honest day. captains and attorneys who have lat- the debasement ing district illustrate ad- of standards invaded stare that have erly irably melodra Trusts ud private secretaries and stenograph and for vhich we described as Multi-millionaires and iLics. are undeniably real things, he audience consequently takes it be a realis- ol granted that the play must But if the the intelligence good tic play. captain indus- try displays of a rab the the +1 Lif heroine re and bit, if young business man of Ivanhoe the veals virtues an who frustrate captain reveals chiefly a fascinating of of industry mile and a touch hysterics—it is from that species of the “drama of life” that the “joyous” drama can deliver us. Give us comedy of the lightest if you vill, but a comedy of human beings and not of lay-figures. M Charlotte Porter of the Folio Shakespeare (Crows is added the two part of feury he Fourth,” in two volum 0 onvenience, accuracy, and siveness of this edition we né iZ i peak In th Introducti« ti ond part Miss Porter tak to the recent attempt of Ilfred W. I rd to show that the manuscript of tl a vas “obtained from the chamberlait men with their full authority,” and that the Quarto dition of 1600 is, therefore, the authentk text. Without going into the detalis of the discussion, we can at least agree with Miss Porter that the best method of presenting the play in its antique form is to reprodu the Folio text exactly, while giving the va rious Quarto readings in footnotes “Brought Home,” a four-act drama f erican life, dealing with the subject of oO} ) in the Middle West, and writ 1 by Henry M. Blossom, jr is | } pt | _o 1 } Harr i 4 produced in the early autumao Franklin Fyles, for many ar ! ] itic editor and crit of the New Y Sun, died last week in his sixty-fourth year He wrote one book on tl i rbeatre and Its People,” several short stories, and a number of pla . known being “The Girl I Left Behind Me,” in collaboration with David Bela ) Two other pleces also had profital
Page 22
42 The Nation [Vol. 93, No. 2402
land '61.”
Mowbray Morris, who died recently at the is best remembered as a position which he held of sixty-three, critic, age a dramatic “The Governor of Kentucky” and “Cumber- | nest time in America a new symphony by | paint on the damp plaster is certain; in | Anton Dvor4k—a posthumous work. A | fact, so obvious an expedient is never likely close friendship is said to have existed for|to have been wholly ignored, but that the several years between Dvoraék and the Bo- | Pompeian and Roman wall paintings are hemian conductor, in whose career he took in any exact sense frescoes has yet to be a special interest, and when several manu- | proved. Dr. Uaurie imagines a gradual for several years on the London Times He published a volume called “Essays in scripts were discovered the executors of the | process extending over several days, the Theatrical Criticism.” Dvorak estate turned them over to Stransky | wall meanwhile being kept sufficiently moist for editing. These compositions, now being | through the thickness of the various layers = ~ published in Germany, include two sym-/|of superimposed wet plaster. Experiment Hawthorne's best story has again been! phonies, two overtures (“Dramatic” and/|has proved this method practicable, and it set to music, this time by Charles F. Carl- | «ppagic’), an orchestral rhapsody, as well| seems worth the attention of decorators, son, dean of the University of Denver Col- | 4, quartet in A major for strings, and a/ but the methods of the Pompeian painters lege of Music, under the title of “Hester, | quintet hardly bear this explanation. It appears or The Scarlet Letter.” It is soon to be _|that the general tone of the wall was published A second opera by the same "| painted in fresco, but this surface seems to composer is entitled “Phelias.”” Andreas have been polished subsequently with wax. Dippel has seen it and has promised to (rt Upon this ground the figure painting is “keep it in mind for the near future for . |}usually executed, often with heavy impasts production Mr. Carlson's third opera is ae | Such a condition of things is hardly com- to be on a subject by Longfellow. Of this ‘The Royal Copenhagen Porcelain: Its |patible with fresco even in Dr. Laurie‘s the first act was finished last month. History and Development from the Eigh- | very broad use of the term. No painter, August Spanuth estimates that ambitious | teenth Century to the Present Day,” by A. | we feel, will doubt that the actual fig- musicians spent over a quarter of a mil- | Hayden, is to be issued by Fisher Unwin. |}ure subjects in the Pompeian villas were lion dollars last season for the privilege The Danish court painter, Prof. L. Tuxen, |done on a dry wall with a viscous medium, of giving concerts in Berlin He regrets who was commissioned to paint pictures of |in some form of tempera or encaustic. The that it is not possible to print the total |¢he Diamond Jubilee and the coronation of | literary evidence on the subject, especially earnings side by side with the total losses, i992 has once again been engaged. | that of Vitruvius, is ambiguous, because we to seare off the ever-swelling throngs of The Prix du Salen has this year bese lean never be sure whether artists’ methods aspirants to fame. < lor decorators’ are being described. The whole last season Lamoureux, and being the three leading orchestral associations in their The took in $618,500, the Opéra-Comique $535,000. These figures absolutely being verified by the poor-law authorities, whose inspec- all amusement accounts, appro- 10 per cent. of the gross receipts paid only $102,000 Colonne, Parisians for the Con- ervatoire concerts, those city Grand Opéra are trustworthy, tors audit priating Lillian Nordica begins a Canadian con- cert tour on September 26 Waldon Fawcett remarks that many of the best of the Indian songs have been com- women. Why cannot the same and music? the interesting subject posed by the said about white. women lf Mr would ig not mistaken, ques- of discus- Fawcett tien make an anthropological and psychological ion For the first time in years Italy's leading the Scala of Milan, closed with surplus instead of the usual large deficit “Sleg- opera house rhe principal operas performed were fried “Simone Boccanegra,”’ “I! Matrimo nio Segreto Romeo and Juliet,” and ‘The Rose Cavalier.” It is surprising that the ltallans, who never cared for the melodious Mozart, are always among the first to pro the latest opera of the anti-melo ou Johann Strauss Wa ly Safonoff ended his season by lucting a concert in Turin, and then for his summer home in the Caucasus s Constantinople, Odessa, and the Black ’ Hie caleulates that he has been heard luring the past season by audiences ag mregating 000 hearers His next season already booked up to March It opens n October at Copenhagen, and includes enty-four concerts In Scandinavia, St Petersburg Kief, Waraaw, London, and Rome He will also play the plano part eight chamber-music concerts of Beetho- en's ‘cello and plano sonatas, for which he prepare himself during his ten weeks’ the will vacation in Caucasian mountains When Josef Stransky takes up the leader- hip of the New York Philharmonic Orches tr he will
next autumn, for the
i produce
‘story awarded to Lucien Jonas for two pictures at the Salon des Artistes Francais: the por- |matter in short remains conjectural, and trait of Henri Harpignies and Les Méde- | the secrets of the ancients are still invio- ma la Consultation late in spite of much more or less ingenious | speculation, According to the London Atheneum Rem- | brandt’s house at Amsterdam in the Joden- Breéstraat, which was sold, with all its art treasures, in 1656, when the artist was de- clared bankrupt, is to be restored. The In discussing medieval painting Dr. Lau- rie traverses anew the ground so ably cov- ered by Eastlake, with whom he differs chiefly in regard to the legendary vehicle of the Van Eycks. The amber varnish, of
official inventory of that year fortunately which Kestlake made so much. Dr. Laurie eurvives, giving exact information as to regards as mythical It is re the first the disposition of the rooms. The exterior ; : place, a poor vehicle, next difficult to ob- | tain, and finally amber is and was readily Interesting discoveries have been made in | confused with other hard resins. For the Rome, under the Church of St. Crisogono, in | preservation of colors Dr. Laurie has found tne Trastevere district, where excavations certain balsams, especially Venice turpen- have for some time been carried on under | tine, remarkably efficacious. He has no the direction of Professor Marucchi, the | doubt, for example, that the extraordinary Christian archwologist. The church is said | greens of the early Flemish masters can to have been founded by Pope Sylvester, in nave been preserved only by some such the fourth century, but was rebuilt first in|medium. To Eastlake’s view that the Van 731, and later in the seventeenth century. | Eycks used mainly oil, subsequently adding The excavations brought to light some time |a little varnish, sharp exception is taken. ago basilica, with remains of | Such a procedure would never yield a homo- the subterranean ‘‘confession” of the church, geneous and durable pigment. Berger's the under which the/|view that the Van Eycks used an emulsion martyrs were buried. It has now been dis- | of egg with fatted oil or balsam is borne covered that the church, like so many early | out by Dr. Laurie’s experiments. By using places of worship, was included | Canada balsam emulsified with egg he has ancient Roman house, which was|repeated the characteristic colors of the adapted for ecclesiastical uses, and decor- | Van Eycks, and the colors have stood dras- ated with paintings, including portraits of | tic tests for permanency. The recipe for a Popes, belonging probably to the | picture to last five hundred years may be or ninth century A. D. There was|of interest. It is to prime a panel—all also found, next to the apse, a large hall, |canvases make for mutability—with glue dating apparently from the twelfth century, | end gypsum, after Cennino Cennini’s meth- the walls of which were painted with floral | od, then paint with colors ground in a mix- portraits, and heraldic de-/ture of two parts of linseed oil to one of Two large sarcophagi were alsu UN- | copal varnish, overlaying the paint as little earthed, one plain, the other richly carved | ag possible and always proceeding from with a representation of the light to dark. It is obvious, as Dr. Laurie herd in the style of the fifth century. admits, that modern artists would hardly In “The Materials of the Painter's Craft" | use so heavy a vehicle or bind themselves (Lippincott) Dr. A. P. Laurie carries the | to so orderly a technique. Only the Pre- of pigments and vehicles from the} Raphaelites have taken such pains. Still earliest times to the beginning of the eigh-| this book should prove suggestive to paint- teenth century. What he has to say about | ers, to the few at least who respect their mural painting in classical times is re-|craft. A kind of instinct has kept some peated in the main from his recent book on | scanty remnant of fine craftsmanship alive that subject and will be provocative of dis- | among us, but many of the most imagina- That the Romans knew how to' tive paintings of recent times have vir- of the house remains much as it was of old. a primitive containing altar, Christian in an various eighth decorations, signs Good Shep- cussion
Page 23
July 13, 1911] tually perished within the life of their creators. This book is well! illustrated. The plates, of which several are colored, include microscopic enlargements of “crackle.””’ We hope Dr. Laurie will continue his research- es to the present day. Finance AUTUMN CROPS. The financial outlook is always cloud- ed at this period. The nation is tossed between hope and fear with reference to the crops, and usually the money market has a somewhat dubious cast. Last year both the érops and the money market were the occasion of no small amount of apprehension, particularly the latter. Yet as a whole our harvests were abundant, and money proved to be in sufficient supply. Seldom if ever has a bad situation been rectified so quickly as in the summer of 1910. Dis- aster was averted, but general industry was left with impaired stamina. Hope was virtually abandoned that the au- tumn and winter of 1910 would wit- ness a return to bustling activity: we should have to look to the autumn of 1911 for a rehabilitation of industry. Yet the outlook is by no means clear to-day. Certain contingencies that wor- ried us last July have failed to present themselves this year, but others that were then quite generally overlooked have come into view. The puzzling question with most persons is now to find the determining factor in the situa- tion confronting us. That, however, is not an easy task. The only thing real- ly certain at this time is that the mo- ney situation is better than in July, 1910. Still, the easy rates that have pre- vailed for so many months have failed to stimulate industry. There is a com- fortable belief that the material inter- ests of the nation will not be adversely affected in the autumn and winter by a) money stringency, but there is no gen- eral confidence that a sufficiency of money at that time will greatly increase the activities of mill and shop. This summer rumor appears to have outdone itself in connection with the crops. Predictions of record harvests have been offset by predictions of extra- ordinary damage. At the moment it would be futile to generalize from what purports to be the crop news, other than to say that it is quite possible that we shall need something more than even record harvests to impart vigor to the financial and industrial situation. Or- dinarily, a large agricultural yield co- incident with easy money would mean extensive trading in general commodi- ties and securities. But it is now com- monly believed that other aids will be necessary this year. The present ease of money has a sig- nificance which is too frequently over- The Nation looked. Money is easy because it can not be employed as freely as it was so long as commodities and labor re main at their preseut quotations. The whole people are down closer to the necessaries of life than they have been for many a year, closer possibly than at any time since 1896. Bank have been high enough in recent months to admit of a much larger production of commodities than has taken place, but the task has been to find a market for enlarged production. It is no long- er stoutly contended, as was the case a few months ago, that only greater con- fidence is required. It is not a question of confidence at all, but of purchasing power. The absence of that quality is what has made the present situation. Merchants and manufacturers have pretty generally recognized that fact, and, what is equally important, the banks also have recognized it. Produc- ers and middlemen cannot at this time give free rein to their misguided judg- ment; should they be so disposed, they would quickly find themselves curbed by their banks, which for months past have deliberately refused to lend their influ- ence to further enlargement of over-pro- duction. It may be said of producers generally that they have not lacked courage in the past twelvemonth. They have, in many instances, knowingly pro duced more than they could sell, their raw material and labor costing them more than the price they could expect to get when the finished product was offered for consumption. Their hope has been that eventually prices would work up to their level, but this hope has met with disappointment. It has been difficult to effect a rise in retail prices. “Bargains” have sold freely enough in the depart- ment stores, but the great public have refused to pay for such things as shoes and textiles prices commensurate with those for raw hides and cotton and wool. The chasm between consumer and producer has been widening rather than narrowing, and it is not at all clear that big harvests this year, assuming that there are big harvests, will change this tendency. Big harvests, of course, are always a blessing, but the blessing may conceivably be of a negative character —preventing a worse embarrassment than the present. Here it is proper to mention one of the most important contingencies now confronting us. The past year has seen a great liquidation of securities, and a very considerable liquidation of certain commodities. But there has been no pronounced liquidation of labor. Labor if anything, a little higher rather than a little lower. There has, needless to say, been a curtailment in the use of labor. This curtailment rendered necessary by the exigencies of the sit- uation: manufacturers, for could not pay labor its unit price and buy so many units as formerly. This reserves is, was example, 43 connotes several very important facts. If this policy is continued much longer the working classes will be at the end of the resources which they have ac cumulated in the past to tide them over such periods as the present, in which event poor harvests this autumn would be truly calamitous. To have everybody at work at wages which insure the necessaries and many of the comforts of life, is the for the present situation. But everybody not been at work and many that have been have not been employed at anything like full time. It begins to look as if it might be impossi ble to achieve full employment by a reduction in the price of labor. The contingency is not altogether pleasant. The wonder to many is that labor has so long been successful in preventing a re remedy has of late months, exce pt duction; this, however, is explained by the fact that, owing the industrial prosperity of the past decade, the aver- his pre of also to age workman was able to increase accumulations for a rainy day, the being that the treasuries the organizations were strengthened. Still, the mass of kind are never any too far from want, and the last year must have imposed a heavy strain on them. It may perhaps be rash to postulate liquidation of labor as a sine qua non, but it is certainly a fact that there present a strong tendency so to do. And there is also growing up a feeling that liquidation must in also. A year ago there was a great deal of talk about inflation in Western farm values; to-day the talk is chiefly of city All along the line of pro duction and distribution charges been rising, until the final who in every case pays the bill, is fair ly staggering under his load. Such a presentation of the facts of sumption labor man is at ensue real estate real estate. have consuiner, the situation might have been deemed academic two years ago. To-day, ever, we are delving into the fundamen tals to find a way out of our protracted industrial depression; and of discoveries is that we have created an industrial plant large, and, particularly, too expensive in how- one our too more opera Financial. Letters Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits ) Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. Neo. 59 Wall Street, New York Certificates
Page 24
“4b tion, for the purchasing power of the nation. The process of readjusting the cost of real estate, of labor, and of raw to the pocketbooks of final consumers has yet to be undertaken. While at the moment there is no good reason for predicting a change for the in the financial situation, it is hard to discover ground for any real mprovement short of such liquidation materials worse as has been instanced above. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Aeschylus Agamemnon Greek text with English verse translation. Frowde Astronomical Observatory of Harvard Col- lege. Annals. Vol. LXVIII. Part ii. Cam- bridge. Baum, L. F. The Daring Twins: a Story for Young Folk. Chicago: Reilly & Brit- ton $1 net Bell, C. W. The Good Old Days. McClurg. 50 cents net. Black and Whit (Anonymous). phia: Literary Pureau Blackwood, A. The Human Chord. Macmil- lan $1.50 Bunyan's Pilgrim's Progress. J. H. Gardiner Holt Burn Poems Published in 1786. Frowde Carden, R. W. The Life of Giorgio Vasari. Holt Chicago: Philadel- Edited by NOTEWORTHY BOOKS Recently Issued by Henry Holt & Co.sw yonx Books marked * are net postage 8% additional. : GRANT ALLEN HISTORICAL GUIDES With Maps and Ills, Each..... .*$1.35 Classical Rome Christian Rome Florence ‘ Also FOR TRAVELLERS Vernon's In and Oat of Illus- Max Florence. trations sceoses © eeseccesese Locry Humrurer (Fd.) The Po- etic Old World—The Poetic New World. Selected poems by numerous authors !a two ornamen With numerous t pocket volumes Bach . *1,.50 Leather pen - *2.50 , MISSELLANEOUS “a. W. Garpen’s Life of Glorgio VWemmees EG ccocceccccccceses *4.00 Semrie’s Influence of Geo- araphic Environment. With Maps . oveccccs “OES Leamine’s A Philadelphia Law- yer in the London Courts. | 5 SPT ETT TTT TTTITrTeTreriee *2.00 Rencson’s Creative Evolation.. *2.50 (Ctroular on application.) THE COMIC SPIRIT IN GEORGE MEREDITH An Interpretation. By JOSEPH WARREN BEACH $1.25 net; by mall, $1.35 Crown AVO The author ders the comic spirit in Meredith's novel their chief distinction On this 1 the significance of Meredith's work as a whole ia discussed, and indi vidual nov naracters are interpreted Ie and LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York The Nation | Vol. 93, No. 2402 Cicero. Somnium Scipionis. Frowde, Coleman, C. B. Church History in the Mod- ern Sunday School. St. Louis: Christian Board of Publication. Cory, H. E. The Critics of Edmund Spen- ser. Berkeley: University Press. Crawford, J. R. Lovely Peggy: A Play in Three Acts. New Haven: Yale Univ. Press. $1.25. Dean, J. T. Visions and Revelations. Scrib- ner. Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe. Edited by W. L. Cross. Holt. Drinkwater, J. Poems of Men and Hours. London: David Nutt. Eliot’s Silas Marner. Edited by E. E. Gar- rigues. Holt. Firth, F. J. The Holy Gospel, Protestant and Roman Catholic Versions Compared. Revell. $1. Forbes, N. Polish Literature: a Lecture. Frowde. Fortescue, J. W. British Statesmen of the Great War, 1793-1814. (Ford lectures for 1911.) Frowde. Fulda’s Der Talisman. Edited, with notes. by O. Manthey-Zorn. Boston: Ginn. 145 cents. Furniss, R.M. Shadow Fairies and Others. Hermann Lechner. | Gore, C. The Question of Divorce. Scrib- ner. 50 cents net. Historical Publications Relating to Canada. Vol. XV, Publications of the Year 1910. Toronto: University Press. Howard, C. What Happened at Olenberg. Chicago: Reilly & Britton. $1 net. Irving, W. Astoria. (Astor Prose Series.) Crowell. | Jones, H. S. Classical Rome. (Grant Al- len’s Historical Guides.) Holt. Kennedy, R. The Principles of Aeroplane Construction Van Nostrand. $1.50 net. Lamberton, C. D. Themes from St, John's Gospel in Early Roman Catacomb Paint- ing: a Thesis. Princeton University Press. McLaughlin, A. C., and Van Tyne, C. H. A History of the United States for Schools. Appleton. Macphail, S. R. Colossians. With intro- duction and notes. Scribner. Merrill, W. A. Studies in the Text of Lu- cretius. Berkeley: University Press. Murray, M. Francis Bacon, a Drama. Spo- kane, Wash.: Albert F. Grazer Co. Roberts, M. Thorpe’s Way. Century Co. $1.20 net. Rodin, A. L’Art. Paris: Bernard Grasset. Sargent, C. S. Trees and Shrubs. Vol. II. Part III. Boston: Houghton Miffin. $5 net. Schwenke, P. Die Turkenbulle Pabst Calix- tus III: Bin deutscher Druck von 1456 in der ersten Gutenbergtype. Berlin: Martin Breslauer. Scott’s Guy Mannering; Kenilworth. Ed- ited, with notes, etc., by A. D. Innes. Frowde. Shakespeare’s As You Like It; Julius Ca#- sar; Macbeth; Merchant of Venice. (Eng- lish Readings for Schools.) Holt. Stevenson’s Treasure Island. Edited by 8S. P. Sherman. Holt. Toch, M. Materials for Permanent Paint ing. D. Van Nostrand. $2 net. Waller, E. English for Italians. R. Jenkins Co. $1. William Not too heavy—not too light Vacation Reading Max Pemberton’s New Novel WHITE MOTLEY The art of flying and the art of love; the dreadful hazards of an Al- pine flight, and the dangers of a peril- ous love-affair;—these are the thril- ling themes of this dare-devil tale of adventure in the air and on land. Cloth, 12mo. Frontispiece. $1.30 net. QUICKSANDS A NOVEL By Fannie Heaslip Lea A novel of fine artistry, presenting a recurring problem—a wife out of love with her husband and deep in love with another. How she contrives to save something of honor and hap- piness from shipwreck is the theme of this engrossing story. 12mm. Illustrated. $1.20 net. STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 EB. 27th St., New York MANUSCRIPTS WANTED FOR PUBLICATION Also juvenile scripts. I deal with the best publishers. Bring me in Hours 2-4 P. M HELEN NORWOOD HALSEY Literary Worker, Manuscript Expert 110 W. S4th St.. New York City Tel. 708 and 704, Murray Hill. Suite 800. Send for Mise Halsey’s ‘‘Writer’s Ald Leaf let."" 25 evote in stampa. your scripts. Consultations free. THE HUMBLER POETS Second Series A Collection of Newspaper and Periodical Verse, 1885 to 1910. Compiled by WALLACE and FRANCES RICE Price $1.50 net MeOLURG & CO., A CHICAGO Read L. M. Montgomery's New Book. KILMENY OF THE ORCHARD By the author of “ANNE of GREEN a — pl (23d Printing) a “ANNE OF AVONLEA” = (12th Printing) ~——- ~~ WILLIAM THE SILENT 1533-1584 Prince of Orange, Count of Nassau, in the Revolt of the Netherlands. By Ruth Putnam, author of ‘Charles the Bold,” “A Mediaeval Princess (Jacqueline of Holland),”’ etc. No. 45—Heroes of the Nations. Or. 8vo. Illustrated. Cloth, $1.50 Net. Half Leather, $1.75 net. Miss Putnam’s biography presents William the Silent in his human as- pects, with human inconsistencies and shortcomings, as well as the qualities that give him a just claim to rank as a hero. Send for New Illustrated Cataloguv. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS NEW YORK: LONDON: 2, 4 and 6 West 45th St. 24 Bedford St., 27 and 29 West 23rd St. Strand. SEEING EUROPE BY AUTOMOBILE By LEE MERIWETHER 12mo, 425 pages, $2 illustrations, end papers, map, index. $2.00 net; post- age, 16 centea. An entertaining and serviceable book for the motorist in Europe, full of information about handling a car in Europe. Describes a trip of 5,080 miles in hundred days. By the cuthor of “A Tramp Trip Abroad.” The Baker &Tayler Co., 33 E. 17th St, N.Y. The Corsican NAPOLEON'S DIARY “One of the great diaries of litera- ture.”"—New York Timea. (Four Impressions) AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis.
Page 25
ee,
J pena | ‘ea { ” ee lege-ay, » : a . —~ “- e « “ ° Ld . ‘ . see * — — « . “e i ds ; o > = Fa a OG SS STS ees : “ i * \
e / _ ey eo nN 7 ’ 7» e a we " a ipa esa sl