The Nation 1911-04-13: Vol 92 Iss 2389

Page 1

2 Oe eae, = Nps = eT OMEN as eae GENER CRERAL LIBRARY; aig 4! ® APR 24 197; ‘he NS1on VOL. XCIL—NO. 2389 THURSDAY, APRIL 13, 1911 —~ gS PRICE TEN CENTS FROM DUTTON’S SPRING LIST UNSOUNDNESS OF MIND By T. S. CLOUSTON, M.D., LL.D., F.RS.E. Author of “Hygiene of the Mind.” Formerly Lecturer on Mental Diseases in the University of Edinburgh; Physic’an-Superintendent of Tae R il Kad burgh Mental Hospital; and President of The Royal (College of Physic'ans Edinburel Illustrated, $2.50 net This treatise is an attempt to bring before the intelligent layman, in language as free as possible from technicalities, the latest scientific discoveries and views in regard to those mental diseases, perversions, and defects which affect mankind and influence human conduct. There are few things in which the intelligent public are more interested than this, but about which they know less in a definite way. What UNSOUNDNESS OF MIND is, in the scientific sense, and what it not, and what are the indications for its recognition THE HOUSE OF HOHENZOLLERN By E. A. BRAYLEY HODGETTS “The Court of Russia in the Nineteenth Century,” et treatment and prevention are the objects of this treatise Author of Illustrated, $5.00 net Commencing with the life and character of Frederick | who was such a probl to Carivie, Mr. Hodgett i overed the whole period from that monarch to the present Emperor, a character sketch ¢ h lo he book H i i sumed that the reader is acquainted with the history of Prussia in its main features, and has confined himself to inter ing descriptions of the leading actors on the historical stage, accompanied here and there by extracts from their correspond ence, anecdotes, etc., the whole making a most entertaining and instructive work APPRECIATIONS AND CRITICISMS OF THE WORKS OF CHARLES DICKENS By G. K. CHESTERTON Illustrated, $2.00 net Mr. Chesterton keeps in view the relation of Dickens, not only to his own time and his own people, but to the ist and menacing movements which have emerged sin the Victorian compromis rhe any portraits of Dickens (some of ther rare) provide an added attraction for any Dickens-lover Each sentence is packed with keen observation, pungent criticis: trenchant thought for guage.”—Philadelphia Public Ledge) THE NEW ARNOLD BENNETT BOOK TWO IMPOSTORS and TINK ER DENRY THE AUDACIOUS By DOROTHEA CONYERS 5:25 net By ARNOLD BENNETT 4 charming story full of Irish wit and humor Author of “Clayhanger.” $1.35 net tae comedy as has ever been written.” THE BRASSBOUNDER “Written with very great facility and sparkles with By DAVID W. BONE $1.25 net cleverness from start to finish.”"—-New York Times “Thoroughly entertaining and novel.”—New York Herald \ strong ea story full of interesting ad ture BLAKE By G. K. CHESTERTON A SPIRIT OF MIRTH A profound and entertaining study of the genius of By PEGGY WEBLING $1.25 net William Blake, which not only interprets Blake, but gives us Chesterton in his happiest mood. Fully illustrated, lluatrated by the Autho The story of a pretty talented, optimistic girl sur rounded by a circl f real iracter A q Leather, $1.00 net; Cloth, 75 cents net. story well worth reading E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY, New York 31 West 23d Street,

Page 2

_ The Nation | Vol. 92, No. 2389. Educational The Nation Educational 4 WEEKLY FOUNDED IN 1865. New York City Post mail matter.) UNIVERSITE JOURNAL. {Entered at the Ofice aa second-class DE GENEVE COURS DE VACANCES DE FRANCAIS MODERNE 15 JUILLET—27 AOUT 1911 Pour recevoir le programme détaillé s’adresser au Secrétariat de l'Université. Summer Session The Nation \s published and owned by the New | York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; P ‘@ueen 5 University ee a | KINGSTON, CANADA : - JULY 3rd to AUGUST iith Three dollara per year in advance postpaid, in | Latin, French, German, Physics any part of the United States or Mexico; to Canada and to foreign countrica comprised in the | Mathematics, Chemistry, Botany Animal Biology, Public Speaking. 0, $3.5 Postel Union $4.00. | WANTED.—Queen’s University, Kings- ton, Ontario. An Assistant Professor |in Classics. Salary, $1200. An Assist- | ant Professor in Mathematics. Salary, '$1200. An Assistant Professor in Phil- | osophy, including Psychology. Salary | $1200. Duties to begin 30th of Septem- 'ber next. Applications accompanied by thirty copies of testimonials will be received up to May Ist next, by the | Addrvas THB NATION, Bow 794, New York | Cool lake Rrorae, clear fees ag, bononst P Quinte | uy blicatt: 20 ¥ r Excursions—Thousand Islands, Bay o inte, Publeation Oftce, 30 Vesey Stress. Rideau Lakes. No entrance cxaminatioa, | Registrar. For Calendar address—G. Y. CHOWN, Registrar. HWE FISK TEACHERS' AGENCIES. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER M NI H Braneee O. Pues f Co. Rivertotens. 186 Fifth Ave. ve New York & git pwottand Bad, Fe THe Week . 357 PENSION WALTENBERG, Hess Str. 30 {03 Couper Bld, Denver. 21az Shattuck Ave. roBerksley near Galleries, Best train connection. Send to any address above for Agency Manual. EDITORIAL ARTICLES: EXCELLENT FOOD ’ -— ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY A Symphony in K Fiat seeee - 360 l fag ting in (ambridge for admission Supplies schools of all grades with competent \ Municipal Donnybrook Fair 360 to College. Entire charge of boys throughout teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. Written and Unwritten C onstitutions. 361 | year. Summer in the country. Successful experience. Send for Bulletin No. 20. The Plight of the Poet _.. 862) Best references. Address M. C. 8., The Nation. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y. rhe Ravenous Social Programme” 363 _ rhe Invasion of North Africa . 364 : SPECIAL ARTICLES Just Published 6 DING wctat ARTIC B | A GUIDE TO READING IN Fowazearo's. Last. Nove iis TAINE’S LES ORIGINES DE LA SOCIAL ETHICS AND we tor ! op hiles 7 Libraries in New York Stat 69 FRANCE CONTEMPORAINE ALLIED SUBJECTS Edited by J. F. L. Raschen, Professor * CORRESPONDENC! of Modern Languages, Lafayette College. Forty-two Lists of Books rhree Arti in Boston 369 6O cents and Articles Selected and First Raising of the Stars and Stripes 370 Carefully chosen selections givinga Described for the Use of rt Exchange of Professors with Ger view of the conditions leading up to : " 7 : ny 370 the Revolution and the First Empire. General Readers by Twen- From Cause to Effect 71 There are copious notes, a complete ty-three Professors and In- Practicall 7 cabule and a biogre ics sketch 7 — ' ; of rahe _* ay Ore structors in Harvard Uni- LITE! re versity. Behind the Screens.—Highways and AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY eee Sen ee He of Japan.—Japan for a New York Cincinnati Chicago $1.25 ($1.38 postpaid); eee eae ae ae aper, $1.00 ($1.10 post: ° in ‘ empire and its Economic pay ‘ 7 pee (‘ondition The Political Develop paid). ent of Japan, 1867-1909 71 _ , The Broad Highway .. 378 duet Pubnenes, PUBLISHED BY rhe Prodigal Judge 373 . > Pestunate os A Latin Crammar HARVARD UNIVERSITY \ Captain of Raleigh's 374 By H. BE. Burton, Ph.D. Professor of PUBLICATION OFFICE: Angela's Ques a74 Latin, Dartmouth College. 90 cents. 2 University Hall, CAMBRIDGE, MASS. vhen Half-Gods Go 374 A text that fills a genuine need because, Alchemy of Thought 374 while clear and simple enough for the be- oldier Recollections 376 ginner, it is also sufficiently thorough and “The Soul of Man ? “The Richard Henry Dana, jr Speeches in scholarly for the college student The only = ? tirring Time and Letters to a Son. 376 text that adequately meets both needs. World’s Desires,” “The Prophets False Equat 77 SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY a 4 ss ny “ae New York Chicago of Israel,” and kindred subjects are listed in the splendid illus- : trated catalogue, “‘The Work of | ( | and Medical ” — THE NEW HUDSON ; Gh 9 Pgay SHAKESPEARE the Open Court Publishing Com- ! 380 99 . . offers interesting and valuable edi- | pany, a copy of which is yours Mt torial material, together with at- tractiveness in mechanical finish. The for the asking. ' ere of Itallan Opera 81 plays regently added to the series are: MIDSUMMER NIGHT'S DREAM } . . TWHLPTH SIGHT The Open Court Publishing Co. ,; os Rach volume, 50 centa | 623-633 Wabash Ave. CHICAGO, ILL GINN & COMPANY, 29 Beacon St., Boston | ! 1 Put « The Mechanics of Writing | By EDWIN C. WOOLLEY, Ph.D., i " WeEE! I83 Th C i Professor in the University of Wisconsin. e ors can | A a ont valuable ame the Satemenes ’ | principles of paragraphing and punctuation, wit ee o;4 f The Nation may be procured tn i" NAPOLEON'S DIARY | helpful suggestions on allied topics. I’ t Brentano's 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in One of the great diaries of litera- Oloth. 426 pages. $1.00 London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trataiga | | ‘Ure."—New Yous Times, posi sc: MBATH & 0O., Publishers, Square, Charing Cross | BOSTON, EW YORK, CHICAGO.

Page 3

April 13, 1911]

The Baker & Taylor Co.’s Books Cwo New Holines in the Guide Series Guide to English History By Henry W. Elson A narrative and anecdotal account of England's story by an eminent and popular histo:

12mo, 360 pages, fully illustrated, $1.25 net; postage, 12 cents. Guide to Great Cities—Western Europe By Esther Singleton Describes the famous cities of France and the Spanish peninsula. I2mo, 360 pages, fully illustrated, $1.25 net; postage, 12 cents.

Malory’s King Arthur and His Knights By Henry B. Lathrop Gives the true flavor of the famous old book: an ideal library edition I2mo, 370 pages, illustrated by RecinaLtp Bircu, $1.50 net; postage, 14 cents. Seeing Europe by Automobile By* Lee Meriwether Familiar and unfamiliar places seen from one’s own car. I2mo, 400 pages, fully illustrated, $2.00 net; postage, 16 cents. First volume in this new series. A Paradise in Portugal By Mark Sale A medley of diary and description, giving an intimate account of rural Portugal. I2mo, 168 pages, $1.00 net; postage, 8 cents.

FICTION Owen Johnson’s Lawrenceville Stories The Varmint I2mo, 373 pages, illustrated, $1.50. The Prodigious Hickey 12mo, 334 pages, illustrated, $1.50. The Humming Bird I12mo, 96 pages, illustrated, 50 cents. (To be published in April) The Tennessee Shad 12mo, 320 pages, illustrated, $1.20 net Continues the exploits of “‘Doc Macnooder,”’ “Dink Stover,” “Finnegan,” et al. Gilead Balm: Knight Errant By Bernard Capes A series of Quixotic detective stories united by a central romance. 12mo, 350 pages, illustrated, $1.25 net. The Canon in Residence By Victor L. Whitechurch A novel of life in an English cathedral town. Recalls Trollope in subject and manner. I2mo, 350 pages, $1.20 net; postage, 10 cents. Dan McLean’s Adventures By Frederick Walworth Brown Stirring exploits on the Mississippi among river pirates. An American “Treasure Island.’ 12mo, 300 pages, frontispiece, $1.25. The Blue Goose Chase By Herbert K. Job A camera hunt in the Southern swamps in which two boys play an active part. I2mo, 350 pages, illustrated, $1.25.

GENERAL The Dawn of Mediterranean Civilization By Angelo Mosso A monumental work of scholarship: and a beautiful book. Royal 8vo, 424 pages, 224 illustrations, $4.00 net; postage, 30 cents Sixtine Rome By J. A. F. Orbaan A contribution to the architectural and personal history of Papal Rome. 8vo, about 350 pages, profusely illustrated, $2.50 net; postage, 16 cents The New Nationalism By Theodore Roosevelt Mr. Roosevelt’s declaration of political principles and program of action. 12mo, 268 pages, $1.50 met; postage, 12 cents. Photographing in Old England By W. I. Lincoln Adams A description of charming and famous places, fully illustrated. Sq. 8vo, 112 pages, full gilt, boxed, $2.50 net. Rindesparten at Home By V. M. Hillyer Play lessons arranged for use by mothers, governesses, and kindergartners. < »

8vo, 200 pages, illustrated with drawings and diagrams, $1.25 net; postage, 14 cents Portrait Catalogue sent free on request

THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Publishers 33 East 17th Street New York

Page 4

MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY GOOD BOOKS NOW READY EVERYWHERE The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 & COMPANY MOFFAT, YARD ro I of all th Dispatcl “He picks up in many The Evening Post. vith Shakespe it is best associated in art and and poetry He studies life through genius. The book is, in short, one which will greatly increase the body of eighty-eight years of age, ard has had a unique history William Winter's admirers.” exempt from all taint of pedantry. It is a felicitous blend of pleasant and informing gossip, brilliant description, delicate and poetic perception and grave reverie. ‘ The intelligent reader who opens it will not lay it aside ited planet, not only in the solar system but in the whole until he has absorbed all that lies between the covers, stellar universe.” It is sure to be one of the great books and he will be grateful to the man that produced it.” GRAY DAYS AND | THE |WORLD OF GOLD By WILLIAM WINTER are’s England lllustrated LIFE A Manifestation of Creative Power, Di- rective Mind, and Ultimate Purpose By ALFRED RUSSEL WALLACE, literature th names, places and events imperishable M in English history, this volume must possess a worth 0. e F.R.S., D.L.C., etc. that cannot be overestimated.’”—Richmond Times- Illustrated. $3.50 net. By mail, $3.70. “The work is remarkable in many ways. It is the product of a remarkable personality; Dr. Wallace is spots the trail of romance Hartford Post. as a scientist. It is remarkable for its original thought “The whole book is charged with full and accurate | and thought-provoking theories. It is remarkable that a holarship, especially on subjects connected with the a man whose life has been given up to so great an ex- life, the creations and the times of Shakespeare, but is tent to the study of physical science should so firmly believe that spirit is the only real cause, and that this is the best of all worlds and that it is “the only inhab- of the twentieth century.”—Boston Transcript. The Interpretation of History By MAX NORDAU $2.00 net. By mail, $2.18 This closely reasoned book will make a strong appeal to all students of history and philosophy The History of Parliamentary Tax- ation in England By SHEPARD ASHMAN MORGAN 2.00 net. By mail, $2.20 An uncommonly clear and well-written account.”—New York Sun The Solution of the Child Labor Problem By SCOTT NEARING, Ph.D. University of Pennsytvania $1.00 net. By mall, $1.10 rhe sanest, clearest, atrommest volume.”—Reginald Wright Kauffman NOVELS Memorial Day (Our American Holidays) BARBARA @f THE} em sive scams: SNOWS One of the very best vol- By HARRY IRVING GREENE umes in a series of antholo- gies which is becoming widely Color frontispiece and Other Drawings by Harvey Dunn. 12mo. $1.35 net. By mail, $1.47 recognized and used, This is a fine outdoor novel, full to the brim of youth, | Queenie; the Auto- spirit, struggle, and unconquerable purpose. The story biography of an is swift in its action, whirling the reader from climax Italian Queen Bee to climax of a moral drama of real power. By T. CHALMERS POTTER Ill. 75 cents net. By mail, BASSET: A VILLAGE | cnn sory ot CHRONICLE popular schoo] of nature fic- tion.”"—New York Herald. By S. G. TALLENTYRE 12mo. $1.25 net. By mail, $1.97 “A tale which is sound as a ripe apple and real as Other Essays the quaint old daguerreotypes in the attic trunk, and which manifests natural, convincing admixtire of By JOHN JAY CHAPMAN pathos and humor, tragédy and commonplace happen- | $1.25 net. By mail, $1.35 ings, ‘pure human’ nature and the higher thoughts and emotions that sometimes transform it. Only, if you Pinay 3 - pl 4 happen to like good and modest literature—read ‘Bas-] turn to classical standards set,’ that’s all!"—-Chicago Record-Herald . of education. Learning, and eae NA, te NE BS le ws ie MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY, NEW YORK CITY

Page 5

sitainta April | 13, sh ~ a BROOKE BRUNETIERE COMPAYRE DOLE DURUY ELY FERNOW GROSVENOR JEWETT MACKENZIE MANSION MOSES NEWELL PALMER - PORTER ROGET SHELDON TRENT _ WARNER WINES The Nation HOROKOROFO KORO ROM Important Books for Colleges ROO RO Poetry of Robert Browning ........ aioe net $1.50 Manual of French Literature. . 7 Pioneers of Education. 6 vol... per vol. net Ethics of Progress History of France General History net Ancient History (Condensed) Middle Ages (Condensed) Modern Times (Condensed) . Socialism and Social Reform Economics of Forestry... net Contemporary History... The Pearl............. fe LE ROSSIGNOL Monopolies Past and Pecneat Orthodox Socialism net net State Socialism in New Dicheal net Evolution of Literature .... net Shorter French Texts. 26 vols., per vol. net Literature of the South........................... ne Irrigation .............. Nd ie net Self-Cultivation in English. Paper, net .10; boards, net Shakespeare, First Folio Text. 40 vols., per vol Browning, Camberwell Edition. 12 vols., per vol. Thesaurus of English Words and Phrases History of the Christian Church. 5 vols., per vol Colonial Prose and Poetry. 3 vols., per vol......... American Charities ................................06.. Punishment and Reformation ...... net Sample Volumes and Full Information sent on ‘Request Chamas YJ. Crowell & Cn. 428 WEST BROADWAY NEW YORK CITY 2.00 .90 1.50 2.00 2.00 1.00 75 1.00 1.50 1.50 1.00 .40 1.25 1.00 1.50 2.50 25 2.50 2.00 .30 75 75 1.50 2.00 75 2.00 1.75 V

Page 6

The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389

HODDER & STOUGHTON, Publishers aPRIL Spring Books © 1911 . By MARGUERITE AUDOUX A modern Classic. — Life. 12me. Net, $1.20 Marie Claire Possesses emphatic claim to originality and distinction.— The Evening Transcript, Boston. ° By ARNOLD BENNETT 12mo. Net, $0.75 The Human Machine A remarkable freshly written book. The author keeps us in his grip for the whole 123 pages he has decreed we shall read. —The British Weekly. By CONINGSBY DAWSON 12mo. Net, $1.20 The Road to Avalon A novel of happiness and joy based on the old French legend that King Arthur is living. It is original, strong and has a deliciously magical charm that strikes quite a new note in fiction. Leil By ANTONIO FOGAZZARO (Ready April 15th) 12mo. Net, $1.35 (A companion to THE SAINT) This, the last novel by the greatest of modern Italian novelists, is a sequel to THE SAINT. It is the story of a woman’s heart, while THE SAINT was a story of a man’s conscience. By SIR W. ROBERTSON NICOLL 12mo. Net, $1.25 The Round of the Clock The book of the story of a man’s life as shown by the twelve periods of five years each represented by the face of the clock. A storehouse of philosophy and pleasure An encyclopedia of accomplishment. A source of inspiration. The Lighter Side of My Official Life 8 S'® ROBERT ANDERSON [he inner story of Seotland Yard,—as fascinating as The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes. . ? By ARNOLD BENNETT 12mo. Net, $1.50 The Old Wives Tale \ new edition with the narrative preface of the book which the Review of Reviews declares is Arnold Bennett's best book

The Common Sense Collector ° **4™* "RANEPORT MOORE seve. Net, $3.00 \ hand of hints on the collecting and housing of antique furniture. : By ARNOLD BENNETT 12mo. Net, $0.50 How to Live on 24 Hours a Day The book that everyone is reading. At All Booksellers GEORGE H. DORAN COMPANY PUBLISHERS : NEW YORK

I Le Las “va var LAS aS: VE LA Uns ex Lt al Vares UN SS ae PSAs VN PAS La +N. BUN IS SANs LAN. vx + LE A BAS Ls Veil YN Zop| kos $25 O53 OS HOTS) py & aS OROROR DRG s¥, I 5% Sy PRO SY, SS SZ ORE >| ee Se > reat at mre at ma NAR NA ast NAR at FOROFOF NAG ree: a eat AGE VAG NAG NAS ~~ Ae i) VAs ~~ Er me 5 - SHOULD BE ON THE SHELVES OF EVERY LIBRARY

SAE AI -

. P e ” ° a % Biographical Dictionary gf Musicians & By W. J. BALTZELL Price, postpaid, $1.25 fag It is probably the most complete dictionary of American biographical data now in the oe ield.—tI.ouis C. Elson in the Boston Advertiser. ye 7 . » . of Resonance in Singing and Speaking By DR. THOMAS FILLEBROWN Price, postpaid, $1.25 [x His directions for deep breathing are, perhaps, the most lucid and valuable ever printed. They are important not only to students of singing, but to all who wish to enjoy

perfect health.—Henry T. Finck in The Nation of Feb. 23rd.

Your Orders are solicited for Musical Supplies of All Kinds We offer our services as advisers to libraries with music departments Our superb f lit ind tensis tock are urs to command SPECIAL RATES TO LIBRARIES. Publishers of THI MU SI IANS LIBRARY and THE MUSIC STUDENTS LIBRARY

‘OLIVER DITSON COMPANY Room 15, Oliver Ditson Building BOSTON, MASS. eens Lal ani Phd Be +3 lt el ws, ces it Al Alt At A ot SOT L eT LeeLee Lee ee r 6s Zhe) $7 > ta + ee £65 : BLAS +” >">. . ~~ > _ Cre +’ ~ * 7. ~ ~ net aa! wat ae “eat PISA? Wg eet eal ea AA Leelee ea £24 1 RAL Be Be “ 4 -

weer a,

Page 7

jan co inetd emetdeaammanmaied an ha Avril 13, tgit| We Sesesesese Nese eee see SEMEN MSE ‘The Nation NEW BOOKS OF GENERAL INTEREST You may find JUST THE BOOK you want for yourself, or a friend, by consulting this page FICTION What’s-His-Name By GEORGE BARR McCUTCHEON “What’s-His-Name” is the story of a man who is overshadowed by circumstances, overshadowed by his wife, overshadowed by New York—a man who tainks he is “no good,” and yet it is the story of a man who dis- tinctly and emphatically “makes good.” A great many, many readers are going to feel, as they turn the last page, that here is a truly wholesome and charming story, a story that does one good to read. Illustrated in color by Harrison Fisher. 12mo, $1.20 net. Postpaid, $1.32. The Catspaw By WILLIAM HAMILTON OSBORNE An intricate, ingenious, baffling, and surprising detective story by the au- thor of “The Red Mouse.” Illustrated, 2mo, $1.25 net. Postpaid, $1.37. The Unknown God Wonderful for the way in which it takes the reader to a strange land and sets nim squarely down in the midst of China. 12mo, $1.35 net. Postpaid, $1.48 5S VEE FD INL APS TN, Cynthia-of-the-Minute By LOUIS JOSEPH VANCE On a certain sultry morning, say as lately as last summer, there were residing in New York, among four and a half million other people, four individuals, who were strangers to each other, and within two days they were together on an outward-bound steamship And what a voyage that was! What a drama of adventure and sudden death, of secret treachery and unexpected heroism, of love-making and villainy, right to the de plorable words, “The End!” Illustrations by A. 1. Keller, 12mo, $1.25 net, Postpaid, $1.37. =i“ = By GOUVERNEUR MORRIS Adventure of the breathless, stir ring, sit-up-at-night-till-you-finish-it order. Illustrated. 12mo, $1.20 net. Postpaid, $1.32. Hearts and the Highway By CYRUS TOWNSEND BRADY A story of gay gallants and a dam sel fair, told with all the author's characteristic vigor and dash. Illustrated, 12mo, $1.25 net Postpaid, $1.87. Five Gallons of Gasoline By MORRIS B. WELLS A book to have at hand when tae chauffeur, or some one else, is lying on the road under one’s own machine engaged in tinkering; or when one’s machine is temporarily at the repair shop, at se many dollars per day This story will take the edge off such misfortunes ESSAYS Alarms and Discursions By GILBERT K. CHESTERTON “A volume of essays, bright, entertaining, epigram- matic, paradoxical, good sense disguised as nonsense; a book to make you laugh, a book to make you think, a court jester talking wisdom; in brief, G. K. Chester- ton."—The Outlook 12mo, $1.50 net. Postpaid, $1.63. The Patchwork Papers By E. TEMPLE THURSTON There could be no more characteristically fresh simple, and delightful book from the author of “The City of Beautiful Nonsense.” Not formal enough for essays, nor sufficiently constructed to be called short stories, they are just pictures of life. 12mo, $1.20 net. Postpaid, $1.82. The Patient Observer By SIMEON STRUNSKY “Every time I pick it up I find something a little bet ter than what I read before.” writes a well-known bookseller. 12mo, $1.20 net. Poatpaid, $1.22 Illustrated J2mo, $1.20 net. Postpaid, $1.32 TRAVEL How to Visit the Great Picture Galleries By ESTHER SINGLETON Within the 500 pages of this compact and convenient little volume is contained just the information which the average tourist needs and desire when ae visits one of the great picture galleries of the world Illustrated Hiandy Pocket Sire, Cloth, £2.00 net Poatpaid, $2.12 MISCELLANEOUS The Craftsmanship of Writing By DR. FREDERIC TABER COOPER An extremely practical, sensible, well-thought-out guide to young authors and would-be authors J2mo, $1.20 net Poatpaid, $1.4 The New Art of Flying By WALDEMAR KAEMPFFERT The science of aviation has opened a whole vast and hitherto unexplored fleld to civilization If you to understand it, and be abreast of tl times, read The New Art of Flying Iiluastrated ro, 37 net PPoatage caxtra, Yellow Men and Gold Publishers DODD, MEAD & COMPANY New York A ’ ee mame ERE EEE IER EEE EEE IEEE ERE EER EEE EEE IIIT NN EE EE EEE EE EEE EERE EE 28 eo ee nee

Page 8

— sO — The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 SOME WORTH WHILE SPRING BOOKS NEVIN O. WINTER’S cccount of Argentina and Her People of To-day Im the Series of the Latin American Republics Uniform with “Mexico and Her People of To-day,” etc. A distinctly readable account and adequate descrip- tion of a country and people not well known to the ma- jority of readers. Jllustrated, in a boz, $3.00. Old Country Inns of England by Henry P. Maskell and Edward W.Gregory “One cordially recommends ‘Old Country Inns of The book abounds in odd and quaint details The style is direct, unaffected and not Chicago Inter-Ocean, England.’ and anecdotes impeded by mere verbiage.” Cloth, Illustrated, in a bor, $3.00. JANE FELTON SAMPSON’S Abroad with the Fletchers A bright and chatty volume of travel through sun- ny Italy, picturesque Switzerland, quaint Holland and Germany, etc., etc. Well illustrated from photo- graphs taken by the author Cloth, 12mo, Bored; net $1.60. Published by L. C. PACE & CHARLES LIVINGSTON BULL’S Jascinating animal book Under the Roof of the Jungle “A detailed and remarkable account of the wild jungle region and its strange inhabitants. With sixty full-page plates, in color and black and white, from drawings done on the spot by the author.”—Boston Herald. Cloth 12mo. Decorative jacket, net $2.00. A Soldier of Valley Forge By Robert Neilson Stephens, author of “An Enemy of the King,” “Philip Winwood,” ete., and G. E. Theodore Roberts, author of *'A Captain of Raleigh's,” “‘A Cavalier of Virginia,” etc. A stirring romance of the Revolution, spirited and entertaining. With frontispiece in color by Frank T: Merrit. Decorative jacket, $1.50. G. E. THEODORE ROBERTS'S vew novel A Captain of Raleigh’s “A typical Roberts romance—dashing and brisk. A capital yarn.” Cloth, 12mo. IJllus- trated, decorative jacket, net $1.25. COMPANY 53 BEACON ST. BOSTON LONGMANS, GREEN, & COS NEW BOOKS A History of Wales from the Earliest Times to the Edwardian Conquest Ry JOHN EDWARD LLOYD, M.A., Professor of History in the University College of North Wales. Bangor. 2 vols Svo. pp. 380+ 468 $6.00 net In this work the story of Wales is told in detall down to the strug- le in which the country lost its independence Prehistoric Wales, mn Wales, the early institutions of the Welsh, the political divi- of the country, the Norman invasions and settlements, and the chievements of the more powerful princes are successively described Special sections are devoted to the history of the Welsh Church. The relations between England and Wales are traced at each stage, and the reaction of Welsh upon English history is illustrated The History of Trade Unionism hy SIDNEY and BEATRICE WEBB With Map and full Hibliography of the Subject New Edition, Tenth Thou- cs =—s sand kue $2.00 net This Edition hes a new tatreductory chapter dealing at considerable leneth with the tuation created by the Osborne Judgment, the prin cipal industrial confileta of recent years, and with the development of Trade Union constitution and function during the past two decades On the Theory of the Infinite in Modern Thought: Two tatroduactory Stuadtes iy 1 F. JOURDAIN. Doctor of the University of Paris, Vice-Principal St Hugh's Hall, Oxford Crown s&vo S075 net John Merridew I FREDERICK ARTHUR (Crown &vo $1.35 net: by nail, $1 John Merridew ta a typical thoughtless, sport-loving Pnglishman ard the len of the book te to show how hie character developed for the hetter under the polltical, religiou and social influences that are a ribet? tn the «tory A «stirring, seneational novel which grips the reader's attention."’ The Pall Mall Gaegette it te an excellent etory. full of the Itallan atmosphere, with ex citing moments and a genuine sentiment thet makes for the roman t ! t (riticleam apart we have enjoyed It extremely."’—The undaw Ti I Individualism Four Lectures on the Significance of Conscious- ness for Social Relations. By WARNER FITE, Professor of Philosophy in Indiana University, Author of “An Introductory Study of Ethics.” _ Crown 8vo. pp. xx+301. $1.80 net; by mail, $1.92. . Prof. Fite’s study {s of particular interest to students of philosophy, for he takes issue with Professor Royce, Prof. Dewey and other present-day philosophers on certain basic concepts, but the more general reader will also find the work helpful in getting his bearings as an individual and a member of society. Something of Nietzsche's robustness and self-respect, without his ruthlessness, and of the Utopian’s idealism, without his mysticism, are discernible in the philosophy of life here set forth.’’—Springfleld Republican. Dublin University Press Series A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity, from the Age of Descartes to the Close of the Nineteenth Century By E. T. WHITTAKER, Hon. Sc.D. (Dublin), F.R.S., Royal Astronomer of Ireland. 8vo. pp. xvi+476. $4.50 net. CONTENTS :—1. The Theory of the Aether in the Seventeenth Cen- tury; 2. Bleetric and Magnetic Science, prior to the Introduction of the Potentials: 3. Galvanism, from Galvani to Ohm; 4. The Lauminif- erous Medium, from Bradley to Fresnel; 5. The Aether as an Elas- tle Solid: 6. Faraday; 7. The Mathematical Electricians of the Middle of the Nineteenth Century ; 8. Maxwell; 9. Models of the Aether; 10. The Followers of Maxwell; 11. Conduction in Solutions and Gases, from Faraday to J. J. Thomson; 12. The Theory of Aether and Electrons in the Closing Years of the Nineteenth Century; Index. An Anthology of Modern English Prose (1741 to 1892) By ANNIE BARNETT and LUCY DALE (late Scholar of Somerville Collewe, Oxford). Crown 8vo. $1.25 net. New Ideas on Inorganic Chemistry Translated, with the author's sanction from the second German edition, by Edgar Percy Hedley, Ph.D. A.M.C.Se.1, By DR. A, WERNER, Professor of Chemistry in the Uni- versity of Zurich. 8vo. $2.50 net Published ~ Longmans, Green, & Co. 4th Ave. and 30th St. New York row Oe eee Se ee

Page 9

April 13, 1911] ‘The Nation not ait, Aer eke see ri eines Ome eaten HISTORIA NUMORUM. A Manual of Greek Numismatics. New and enlarged edition. By Barclay V. Head, assisted by G. F. Hill, George Macdonald, and W. Wroth. 8vo cloth, $12.75. Half Moro., $14.00. OXFORD STUDIES IN SOCIAL AND LEGAL HISTORY. Edited by Paul Vinogradoff, M.A., D.C.L., LL.D. Vol. Il. Types of Manorial Structure in the Northern Danelaw. By F. M. Stenton. Customary Rents. By N. Neil- son. 8vo, cloth, $4.15. THE STORY OF NEFREKEPTA, from a Dem- otic Papyrus. Put into verse by Gilbert Mur- ray. $1.50. JUSTICE AND HAPPINESS. By W. Benett. 8vo, cloth, $1.40. THE COPTIC VERSION OF THE NEW TES- TAMENT. In the Southern Dialect, otherwise called Sahidic and Thebaic. With Critical Ap- paratus, Literal English Translation, Register of Fragments and Estimate of the Version. Vols I, Gospels of St. Matthew and St. Mark: Vol. Il, St. Luke; Vol. III, St. John. Regis- ter of Fragments, etc. Facsimiles. 8vo, $26.50. ESSAYS ON ROMAN HISTORY. By H. F. Pel ham. Collected and Edited by F. Haverfield. 8vo, cloth, $3.40. HANNIBAL’S MARCH THROUGH THE ALPS. By S. Wilkinson. With 2 Illustrations and 4 Maps. $2.50. OEDIPUS, KING OF THEBES, by Sophocles. Translated into English rhyming verse, with Explanatory Notes by Gilbert Murray, LL.D.., D.Litt., F.B.A. Cloth, 75c. THE WORKS OF ARISTOTLE. Translated into English under the Editorship of J. A. Smith and D. D. Ross. 8vo. Departibus Animalium. Translated by William Ogle. RA. A.D. F.R.CP. $1.75. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS AMERICAN BRANCH 1611-1911 THE TERCENTENARY OF THE AUTHORIZED VERSION OF THE HOLY BIBLE Special Commemorative Editions 1. A photographic facsimile in a slightly re duced size (1134 x 8'4 inches), but containing all the characteristics of the original of the 1011 Bible in Black Letter, printed on rag-made paper. Edited, with a bibliographical introduction, | Alfred W. Pollard, M.A., Assistant Keeper Printed Books in the British Museum. The volume consists of 1550 pages and c tains the Translators’ Preface to the Reader, the Calendar, and all the material contained in orig inal copies of the King James Bible. This commemorative volume has been special- ly prepared for libraries and for those who wish to possess the King James Bible in its original form. In Cloth Binding, $15.00. Il. An exact reprint in roman type of the Authorized Version of 1611, edited, with a bib liographical introduction, by Alfred W. Pollard. Size 8 x 514 inches. Mr. Pollard’s bibliographical introduction is the same as in the larger volume but the smaller edition lacks the illustrative docu ments. Printed on Oxford India Paper, and Bound in Cloth, $4.50. lll. Records of the English Bible: being the documents (sixty-three in number) relating to the translation and publication of the Bible in Eng- lish, 1523-1611. Edited, with the Introduction already described, by Alfred W. Pollard. Crown 8vo. (7% x 5 inches.) Cloth, $2.50. This volume will be found a valuable work for Students of the Bible: it contains documents, never before printed, which throw great light on the subject. STUDIES IN THE SYNOPTIC PROBLEM. By Members of the University of Oxford. Edited by W. Sanday, D.D. 8vo, cloth, $4.15. JOHN THE PRESBYTER AND THE FOURTH GOSPEL. By Dom John Chapman, O.S.B. 8vo, cloth, $2.00. FOR SALE BY ALL BOOKSELLERS-—SEND FOR CATALOGUE OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS—-AMERICAN BRANCH 35 West 32d Street, New York es ee

Page 10

x ‘The Nation te 92, No. 9 FOODS anp THEIR ADULTERATIONS | The Origin, Manufacture and Composition of Food Products, Detection of Common Adulterations. Food Standards. By HARVEY W. WILEY, M.D. | o)airicciinrs, ‘Wweaniagton,D.0. is no other man better qualified to write on the subject or who has extensive experience of Dr. Wiley. 11 Colored Plates and 87 Other Illustrations. Octavo; 641 pages. Cloth, 4.00 net. Synopsis of Contents—/ntroduction.—Meats.—Poultry and Game Birds. Fish Foods.—Milk and Milk Products.—Cereal Foods.—Infants' and Invalids’ Foods.—Vegetables, Fruits, Spices, Nuts, etc-—Sugar and Honey.—Detection of Common Adulterations.—Food Standards.—Indez. There had the Second Edition. Orders may be sent to any bookseller; or upon receipt of price we will forward to any address, postage or express charges prepaid. The book will be found on sale at The Baker & Taylor Co., 33 East 17th Street; Wm. R. Jenkins Co., 851 Sizth Avenue; G. E. Stechert € Co., 151 West 25th Street, and G. P. Putnam's Sons, 2, 4 and 6 West 45th Street, New York 1012 Walnut St. PHILADELPHIA P. BLAKISTON’S SON & CO., Publishers, NOTABLE SPRING BOOKS HAUPTMANN, GERHART The Weavers This stirring delineation of the condition of the Silesian workers and their re- Ready this month volt against the forces that were crushing them is symbolic of the consciousness to which labor everywhere is awaking For some years the book has been out of print. though every library and book store In America and England has had requests for t $1.00 net; OPPENHEIM, JAMES by mail $1.06 Ready Jae, y . ae Pay Envelopes Tales of the mill, the mine and the city street, by the author of ‘“‘Wild Oats.” Vivid stories of the real life of the tollers, related with simplicity and directness that make of each a cameo of tragedy: a vignette of drama (Illustrated) $1.25 nct;by mail, $1.35. PARSONS, FRANK Read Legal Doctrine and Social Progress this month The author, late Professor at Boston University, believes that the main body of the law e primarily a reflection of the general progress of humanity toward abstract fustios Independent in ite basis and essence of economic interest and class bias. The work is one whose importance will be apparent to laymen as well as to lawyer ml Jude $1.50 net; by mail $1.60 SPARGO, JOUN Ready this month Side rd on Contemporary Socialism visions of the Leader and Guide: I Ant] Inte sliem in the clalist The Influence _ one are entitled: I Marx, Movement, A Historical Survey it of Mo rx on Contemporary Soctalivm It refutes the charge that Soctalist writers ‘liirees different arguments to their brethren than to outsiders for the first two sections were prepared for reading to Socialist audiences. $1.00 net; by mail $1.08 Bend for catalogue New York Published by B. W. Huebsch, 225 Fifth avenue, Interesting Paragraph from “The Sphere” Issue of June 25, 1910: “Meanwhile some American newspaper has been chiding Mr. Archer upon too great an enthusiasm for the American magazines, and has even suggested that America is not so well off as our own country in weekly newspapers. This complaint, however, comes from Chicago, where New York is said to be less loved even than London. As a matter of fact, the New York Nation is a more thorough and more scholarly paper than any that we have in England. Compared with some of the reviews upon well-known books in the New York Nation, those in The Spectator are positively illiterate.” 7. Letters and Memorials OF Wendell Phillips Garrison Editor of The Nation, 1865-1906 in one volume, crown 8vo0, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. During the forty-one years in which he edited the Nation, with a thoroughness, ability, and con- scientious devotion unsurpassed in the records of American jour- nalism, Mr. Garrison was an in- defatigable correspondent, never employing an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who embraced practically all the leading Ameri- can scholars and critics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a suf- ficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the rela- tions between Mr. Garrison an:! his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exercised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes, and sympathies. The volume also contains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and several of his characteristic editorials, re- views, and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. Price, $1.59 net, postpaid Houghton Mifflin Company BOSTON NEW YORK ee eee — owen,

Page 11

ee go peren NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 13, 1911. This is precisely in keeping with what sande The | Week The Democratic leaders in the House continue to indicate a most sensible pro- gramme. Following the assurance that there is to be no unnecessary mancuv- ring for political effect in regard to the Canadian reciprocity bill, there comes the statement that another bill is to be introduced at the same time, pro- viding for the lowering of the tariff on a number of articles in which farm- ers are interested as buyers and not as sellers. In the farming communities along the Canadian border there has been a very natural feeling that in the reciprocity arrangement they were asked to give up some.of their tariff advantages, while those to whom they were paying tribute through the protec- tive tariff were permitted to enjoy their special privileges unabated. A down- ward revision of the tariff on wire fenc- ing, agricultural implements, sewing machines, lumber, meats, and flour, which are among the items mentioned as likely to be included in the proposed bill, would be heartily approved by pub- lic sentiment generally, and would be to the farmers an extremely welcome rec- ognition of their right to consideration. Representative Foster of Vermont is one of the ablest and most responsible men in the House. As a member of the House Committee on Foreign Affairs, he speaks with additional authority. Yet he has no hesitation in declaring pub- licly that the latest attempt to manu- facture a Japanese war-scare by way of the City of Mexico is part of a deliber- ate jingo policy to force large naval ap- propriations. These are his words: I am absolutely convinced that there is a criminal conspiracy on foot for the pur- pose of bringing on a war between the United States and Japan. Thousands upon thousands of dollars are being spent to carry on this propaganda, and I am con- fident that the plans of these conspirators will unfold themselves before very long. I! am convinced that this constant agitation for a war between the two nations is no- thing but a subterfuge employed by those people who are determined that this gov- ernment shal! build not less than two battle- ships each year. To endanger the friendly relations of two great nations in order that certain selfish interests may be gratified is nothing short of criminal. many outside of political life have been saying for years past—that the rumors of war with Germany or Japan which have regularly appeared year in and ‘year out during the last decade are the deliberate work of those who would profit by an international conflagration. In taunting Speaker Clark upon the reduced prestige of his office, Uncle Joe is true to his own standards of delicacy and humor. “Aren't you sorry now that you voted last year for a Committee on Committees?” asks Mr. Cannon. The point would stick if last year’s uprising against the powers of the Speaker had been a partisan move directed by a Democratic minority against a Repub- lican presiding officer. For a man of that stand-pat temperament which never forgives and forgets, Mr. Cannon has very quickly forgotten the fact that he was deprived of his powers by a rev- olution within his own party. If Speak- er Clark stands to-day shorn of impor- tant prerogatives, it is chiefly because Mr. Cannon demonstrated that there may be Speakers who are unfit to be trusted with them. With a fine display of authority, Mr. Bryan has set apart the Democratic sheep in the United States Senate from the Democratic goats. Coming from Mr. | Bryan such an act of segregation must be very embarrassing—to the sheep. When war broke out within Republican ‘ranks in the Senate, progressives and reactionaries alike were fortunate in be- ing left to their own devices. The worst that could then be said of Aldrich and La Follette was that they were in the wrong; no one accused them of dancing to the crack of an outsider’s whip. That is the unhappy fate which threatens the Democratic progressives if Mr, Bryan abides much longer at Washington and continues to emit pontifical utterances. By what right Mr. Bryan issues orders and distributes praise and blame, we fail to see. Does he really find in the recent Democratic victory a vindication of himself? Has he stopped to think how much he contributed to that victory by his absence? The public reputation of Tom L. John- son, which came to be national, was iargely identified with his long contest to procure a three-cent fare on the street- railways of Cleveland. Our customary American facility in giving nick-names made him known as Three-Cent-Fare Johnson. In the obituary notices it is freely stated that he failed in this great fight of his life; but this is in- accurate. He was, indeed, beaten in his last contest for the Mayoralty, but a good part of what he strove for is now established in Cleveland. On some lines and for certain distances, there is a three-cent fare in that city. And even if the event shows that the three-cent fare cannot be made universal in Cleve- land, that will but slightly diminish the value of what Johnson achieved. For the question of the fare, more or less, was only a part of the object he fought for. His great aim was to bring about an entire change in the attitude of the people toward public-utilities corpora- tions, and in this he won a success which nothing can dim. Mayor John- son was, indeed, a leader in what we can now see to be a revolution effected. The old conception of an indifferent public on the one hand, and scheming and overbearing companies on the other, has passed away almost completely Little by little Mr, Johnson worked out a change of attitude in Cleveland toward the whole problem of municipal administration. He was, of course, a party man and a politician, and “play- ed the game” with the best of them, but in certain matters of high civic impor- tance he would not allow the govern- ment to be thought of as merely a dis- penser of jobs, or a system of outdoor relief for needy political dependents. If the city’s water-supply needed to be overhauled and regularized, he put a competent scientist at the work. So, too, in matters affecting the police and parks and public playgrounds and the lake-front and the much-needed union railway-station, Mayor Johnson took his stand on large principles more often than upon small politics. For all these reasons he deserves to be thought of as one of the earliest and most successful to enter upon the great work of renovat- ing the publie life of American cities MO ee ae

Page 12

Judge Sanborn's decision on Saturday against the Minnesota Railway Commis- sion was only what was expected after the report on the facts made last year by a special master, yet it has consid- erable importance. When we reflect that the opinion was handed down by the same Federal judge who held the North- ern Securities Company illegal and also decided against the Standard Oil Com- pany, we perceive that the courts will prevent confiscation even if they strike down monopoly And it is mainly on the ground that the orders of the Rail way Commission would prevent a fair return on railway property that the court declares them unconstitutional and void. By reducing passenger fares } per cent. to 2 cents a mile, and di- recting nearly as laree cuts in commod- ity rates, the Commission had not mere- ly interfered seriously with interstate commerce and brought about discrim ination between localities, but had dis abled the roads from earning a fair re turn on their property. The basis on which the capital is figured is virtually the cost of reproduction, rather than the market value of stocks and bonds, but the court decides that interest on the cost of reproduction of railway proper- ty at 4 per cent, “during one-half the time requisite to acquire and construct it,” is a “necessary expense of reproduc- tion and may be lawfully allowed as such.” It has often but erroneously been said that the Supreme Court of the United States has fixed 6 per cent. as the rate of interest which public-service corporations may be allowed to earn. What was really decided was that such a rate of interest in the case of the Consolidated Gas Company of this city was “not unreasonable.” Judge San- born now holds that “a net income of 7 per cent. upon the value of railroad property in Minnesota is not more than the fair return to which a railroad company is entitled under the Fourteenth Amendment.” This only shows that the courts will properly al low for differences in time and place The trade unions, we imagine, will utter no protest against the decision of the United States Circuit Court of Ap- peals In the Danbury hatters case. And yet the principle underlying the rever- sal of the lower court's judgment against the Hatters’ Union is precisely the same principle that is involved in >. ‘The Nation other decisions which have been criti- | cised as being animated by hostility to Labor. This is the very commonplace principle that judges cannot make the law, but can pass only on the question whether the law has been applied prop- erly in a certain case withcut violating the rules of judicial procedure. Upon the second point is based the quashing of. the lower court's findings in the hatters’ case. The Circuit Court of Appeals de- clares that the Connecticut judge was in serious error on several points, and primarily in directing the jury to bring in a verdict against the Hatters’ Union. The jury was thus prevented from pass- ing on the validity of the evidence sub- mitted and the case of the defendants was correspondingly prejudiced. A new trial is to be had, but the illegality of boycotting stands affirmed in the same pronouncement that orders a new trial. It would be a pity if the flaring head- | line should be allowed to prejudice | thoughtful readers against the valua-| ble and conscientious report just made public by the committee which has been investigating conditions in the under- world of Chicago. “Chicago’s annual toll to vice is $60,000,000"; thus the) truth is blazoned forth on the theory that all the sins and ills of humanity are now best translated into terms of doliars and cents. The annual homi-| cides in the United States cost us so many millions of dollars; the number | of miners entombed during the last) | | many millions of dollars; the number | of babies who die for lack of pure milk | represents the loss of so many more millions of dollars! The inhumanity of the argument is all the more inexcusa- ble because it is an absolutely ineffec- tive argument. Is the man in the street very likely to be roused by the thought of a hundred million highly metaphysi- cal dollars that he cannot even imagine, let alone hope to see? A month ago, in speaking of the loss of lives by fire, the scientific commentator might have told us how many millions of dollars are lost annually in the form of factory people who are burned up. But it was twelve months represents the loss of so not the capitalized value of 145 lives that recently stirred New York to hor- ror. The result of the Democratic primary election In Baltimore is not encouraging | Vol. 92, No. 2389 to those who are sanguine as to the /near approach of the adoption of sound ideas of municipal government by the mass of the voters in our great cities. Against the winning candidate, Mr. Preston, there were, indeed, no accuga- | tions of personal unfitness; but the con- test was nevertheless a clear-cut one be- tween domination of the city by a po- litical ring, with a coarse boss of the worst type at its head, and the reten- tion in the Mayoralty of a perfectly “straight” and “regular” Demecrat who had failed to satisfy the boss in the conduct of his office. An extraordinary effort was made by many of the most prominent and public-spirited citizens of Baltimore to achieve the renomination of Mayor Mahool, but the candidate of the ring beat him by 9,000 in a total vote of 50,000 at the primary. It is evi- dent that there is still plenty of work 'to do in the way of getting “the plain people” to place their interest in honest land efficient government above their at- ‘tachment to the party “organization.” New Hampshire has done its duty by the Crawford Notch. Gov. Bass has re- ceived a bill, duly passed, providing for the purchase by the State of the forests on the sides of the mountains through which, as the dispatches put it, the Notch “cuts its picturesque way to the heart of the White Mountains.” The larger value of this action lies in its ef- fect upon other Legislatures. It is a fine thing to save a piece of natural beauty for the enjoyment and the eleva- tion of the generations that are to be, but, incidentally, one instance of the kind is worth tons of arguments with reference to similar action elsewhere. Owners of masterpieces abroad, and even the countries where they live, may have to perform a sacrifice in order to save them for the nation. With our States, debt-ridden as they are, no such obstacle opposes the appropriation of whatever amounts may be needed for the preservation of nature’s wonders in their original majesty. The proposed creation of a chair in political science at Princeton Univer- sity for ex-Mayor McClellan should go far toward encouraging that friendly relationship between politics and schol- arship which is one of the newer phenomena of the times. He proba- bly knew more about Venice than any AT Sree raters TBH be boom ae ~

Page 13

ETE cae tn - rae April 13, 1911] The Nation 359 other man who ever made a mess of | liament at Ottawa, but that is a legisla-!therefore, under our most-favored-nation it in New York. Nor would it be tive library. Our own Library of Con- treaties, would have to be ex‘ended to raking up dead fires to recall that gress, says a Canadian complainant, fur- other countries equally. during the storm and stress of his four nishes a brilliant example of a legisla- —_——- years’ term as Mayor he often evinced tive and a public library in one, but it The signing of a satisfactory commer- a peculiar aloofness from earthly cir- is not a usual combination, and, as he cial treaty between England and Japan cumstance that was more suggestive of sweeps his melancholy eye over the is another blow to the British protec- academic shades than of the City Hall. earth, he is depressed as he sees that tionists. They had dogmatically assert- His example cannot be held to prove even the South American republics have ed again and again that without Eng- one thing or another about the college each their Biblioteca Nacional. But he lish tariff duties it would be imposs!- man’s qualification for an active career has practical suggestions to offer. For ble to make a bargain with any other in politics. Whether the result be suc- a long time the Library of Parliament nation in matters of commerce. The cess or failure, it is not the college man, has been overcrowded, and the authori- thing was clear as arithmetic. If you but the man, who has succeeded or fail- ties have halted between finding room have no tariff rates to lower, how can ed. At Tammany Hall, of course, the for the excess of books elsewhere, and you ask another country to lower hers? appointment of Mr. McClellan to the erecting a new building. Now comes Mr. Balfour urged the point in the very Princeton faculty would be received the suggestion of a national library, instance of Japan. Her Parliament had with wonderment. It is conceivable with removal to a centrally situated lately voted an increase in the Japanese that a professor should want to be building of all books that would natur- customs duties, some of which would Mayor of a large city; but why a man ally go with such an institution. bear heavily upon British trade. But an who has been Mayor should want to ——__——_---——— impotent Liberal Government, stupidly sink to a professorship staggers com- Qn the same day last week questions clinging to the worn-out formulas of prehension. were asked of the Government, both at free-trade, would be absolutely unable London and Paris, respecting Canadian to do anything in the premises because The misfortunes of the New Theatre reciprocity, their point being whether it would not be in a position to threaten give point to the suggestion, made in the reductions of duty made by the Unit. tariff reprisals. Mr. Asquith, however, the last number of Science, that there is ed States on Canadian imports could ‘calmly invited the Conservative leader room for a new profession, that of not be claimed by France and England to wait and see; and what he sees now acoustical engineering. Although the also under the “most-favored-nation” is the negotiation of a treaty highly fa- laws governing the perfect distribution treaties. The cautious answer was giv- Vorable to British commerce. Japan of sound in an auditorium have not en in both cases that due inquiries makes large reductions in whole classes been completely worked out, our writ- would be made. There cannot, however, of duties on English goods. er maintains that the theoretical results be any doubt on this subject in the mind obtained by physicists are far in ad- of the officials of either Foreign Office. The impression created by the Ca- vance of what architects have been put- They know what the uniform practice morrist trial at Viterbo is not only that ting into practice. The difficulty is that of the United States has been in the the spectators are getting an excellent the physicist is not concerned with the matter of reciprocity agreements. It show for their money, but that the pris- practical problems that confront the was stated as early as 1817 by Jot oners are getting a very fair trial for architect, while the architect is con-| Quincy Adams, to the effect that the their lives. It may be safely asserted cerned with many important problems mogst-favored-nation clause covers “only that European criminal jurisprudence, other than that of acoustics. Hence the | gratuitous favors” and does not touch as descended from the Roman law, is necessity for a specialist to mediate be- «concessions for equivalents, express or not the dreadful thing which we, as a tween the two. The suggestion is an 2t- implied.” In the case of Canadian reci- people happy in the possession of a tractive one. If science can work out ap- procity, of course, every concession Common Law, are frequently apt to as- proximately true acoustic formulas for made by us is for an equivalent conces- sume. The charge that European tri- halls of various types, the architect’s sion by Canada. For every quo there is bunals start with the assumption of the function would then be reduced to the |g quid. Hence there can be no doubt prisoner's guilt and not his innocence, is problem of putting this model space what the attitude of our State Depart- probably more epigrammatic than true. into the handsomest shell he can devise. ment will be if approached by the Brit- In any case, it is not to be denied that At present the auditorium is too often jsh or French Government. It will be at Viterbo the accused, each in his turn, scooped out within the solid mass, in- the same as that of Secretary Olney in‘are getting the fullest hearing that a stead of having the exterior frame the 1894 in reply to Germany, namely, that'man on trial could possibly ask for interior. in the question of given concessions “no! Add to that the apparent privilege of other country is entitled to them except proclaiming in open court and in quite For an American to rank Canada with upon rendering the same equivalent.” untechnical language that personal jus- Abyssinia or Siam, especially with reci- The case would obviously be different if tification which the average man aches procity pending, would be untactful. But Senator Cummins were to have his way to blurt out in defiance of lawyers’ ways, when those on the other side of the bor- and add to the list of free imports from and there is no reason for characteriz- der do it, one can only sympathize. Canada, outside of the bargain. As Mr. ing the proceedings at Viterbo as any- Their trouble is the lack of a national Root pointed out in the Senate, such thing but fair—whatever else they may library. There is the Library of Par- additions would be “gratuitous,” and be. EE a EY RE

Page 14

360 A SYMPHONY IN K FLAT. For some months it has been evident that the beneficiaries of the tariff du- ties on woollen goods—Schedule K — have been uneasy and apprehensive. It was bad enough to have President Taft declare the rates which they got in the Payne-Aldrich bill “indefensible.” But when they learned that the Tariff Board was looking into their protectionist rake-off, and that the Democrats were proposing in the extra session to put through a bill cutting down their du- ties radically, they began to exhibit a fearful looking-for of judgment. They had a convention in Washington to show what benefactors of the people they are and to make the threat that whatever member of Congress might touch a fleece of yon gray sheep should die like a dog. Later, they began a campaign, not of education, but of advertising. In sixteen magazine pages, the American Woollen Company has set forth, we will not say a defence, but a glorification of Schedule K, which it shows to be the! very article of a standing or falling re- public. The whole ig written in a taqne of almost religious exaltation, of which | [Vol. 92, No. 2389 The Nation ‘read me history, for I know that his-| heavily at the name of the President of tory is a pack of lies”? But this sym.- | the American Woollen Company, who phony in K flat does not pretend to be| pays for the orchestra. Then there is a strong on facts. Miserable sneateeets Vaal of triumphant outbursts. “Sched- tories about rates of duty and prices ‘ule K stands on its merits alone.” “The and quality have no place in this grand ‘case of K is now in your hands.” Sched- sweet song about wool at so much aj ule K can be destroyed only by “ignor- page. The idealist point of view is tak-|ance, malice, or party politics.” “All en throughout. Wool and woollen cloth- | the five millions of people directly ing, protected 100 to 200 per cont., | interested in the wool business believe become a sort of sacred symbol of | ia America for Americans.” “They be- American hope and grandeur. Unwor- | lieve also in the Golden Rule.” If it is thy motives or anything like a sugges-|not an anti-climax, we add that they tion of selfishness flees away. Note how |evidently believe, too, in unlimited hum- |the poetical advertiser, rising to the height of his great argument, disposes of the small-minded objection that all the information upon which Schedule K was framed “came from wool grow- ers and woollen manufacturers”: Where else should it have been secured? Does any business man expect practical, usable, technical information about his business from any save those acquainted with the business? Congressmen are mostly law-makers—not manufacturers. Their business is that for which they are elected—making laws. A tariff law must, necessarily, deal with complicated phases of many businesses— phases which are understood only by those |engaged in those businesses. one can hardly be expected to follow the dithyrambic reasoning, but before which the proper emotions are certainly won- der and awe. One of the earliest strains of this mu- sic about the wool duties reveals the hitherto unsuspected truth that they de- cided the issue of the civil war and saved the Union. We have often heard of the wool tariff of 1867, but our ad- vertising symphonist reminds us that Schedule K really came into being when the fate of the nation was at stake. It was first seen in a bill signed by Abra- ham Lincoln. That name is printed in black-faced type, and then our young- eyed cherubim goes choiring on: What were the Immediate results? Our soldiers were provided with the needed uniforms Victories were won War was ended All this Is history. Thus we see that any attempt to revise Schedule K iss not only un-Republican and un-American, but Is the height of national ingratitude and really next door to treason. We cannot follow our advertiser's further swallow-flights of song in “his- tory.” He tells us that, under free wool from 1894 to 1897, “nearly every wool- mill in America was closed.” Was it Sir Robert Walpole who said: “Don't! >. This is true of the tariff on wool. Schedule K is not easily understood by the average reader. But any—and every—part of Schedule K can easily be explained by wool growers, woollen manufacturers, or others directly concerned with the business. But while the American Woollen Com- | pany thus, with Milton, has a soul like a star that dwells apart, it also lays upon itself the lowliest duties—moral, not tariff, of course. Accordingly !t stoops even to meet the needs of the school-girl who wrote in her examina- tion paper, in reply to a question about the “chief uses” of cotton: “The chief use of cotton is to make woollen goods.” The advertisement takes up the “ridic- ulous” charge that “part-cotton” cloth is sold for woollen. In the first place, no law could protect any one against buying part-cotton cloth for all wool— “if they were wholly lacking in sense.” It is only the protective tariff, we infer, that makes it safe for even idiots to go into manufacturing; in ordinary buying and selling they have to look out. Be- sides, “have you ever paid an all-wool price for part-cotton clothing®”’ If you have, you are, of course, a fool, and so your opinion does not count. The advertisement closes in a grand climax fortissimo, The brasses crash bug and in throwing away their money. But, as they say, no law can prevent their doing it if they are wholly lack- ing in sense. A MUNICIPAL DONNYBROOK FAIR. If there are any citizens of New York who have been in doubt or ignorance as to the Hibernian character of their city government, they need only look about them now to see on all sides evi- dences of certain Celtic traits coming to the surface with the members of the Administration. The good, old Donny- epons motto, “If you see a head, hit it,” |is the order of the day on all sides. It ‘must make many a recent immigrant from Ireland feel his hand grasp his | patriarchal shillelah a little more tight- ily, as he beholds the grand mix-up in |and about the City Hall, and recall to many a veteran the glorious days | when to crack a landlord’s skull was the happiest diversion of a crowded hour in | Roscommon or Tipperary or County | Kilkenny. There is not a day passes ‘but somebody gets a black-eye or a rap on the head at the hands of a brother member of the Board of Estimate, with whom he chatted so pleasantly but a lit- tle while before in the presence of re- ‘porters, and the fun grows fast and fur- ious, with no signs of any weakening as the blood is spilled. To be a mem- ber of the city government these days \ is, indeed, to know the thrill and zest of life. It is the grand time these gentle- /men are having. There is Mayor Gaynor, for instance. |'There is a noble fighter for you. Let him but get the idea that a man has “vice in his head,” and there is no let- ‘up for him until that head is pounded to a jelly so the vice can get out. It’s all the sweeter task when one’s adversary has the fine old South of Ireland cog- |nomen Corrigan—nothing Orange about : ' : ' a ee rs ee. ee ealeglinge

Page 15

geet ee ee tS peers = ee April 13, 1911] him, praise be the Lord. Even a Pren-| dergast—is it Prendergast of Sligo or Cavan *—is a worthy foe to give the lie to while saying that ‘tis politics that bhoy’s afther. Then there is Mitchel, too; what more natural than that the blood of the Fenians should be stirring in his veins? Could there be any joy in life greater for him than standing be- fore a crowd and making a spectacle of his Honor the Mayor, or making him eat his words about the subway? There's McAneny, too. What county the other side of Hoboken his people came from we know not. That it was not far from Kerry we'll wager by the way he stands by his own when attacked, be it asphait or a Miller, and by the good sound piece of advice he gave to the Irish members of the Board of Aldermen the other day about the new Building Code the people will have—more power to his elbow! There’s a fighter, too, to please the saints. And those who cannot get their fill of fight by day, battle at night in the sessions of the subway committee. But what goes on there, and how many with broken heads they carry off each night, no man can say. And as for Charley Hyde, who could count the knives that’s out for him? It’s catching, this grand battling of the big men. Already a stray Ameri- can, who got into the Park Department by accident, Stover by name, is quarrel- ling with his landscape architect. In the Fire Department, there’s trouble all the time, with Croker on top and the Com- missioner with a German name, Waldo —Heaven be good to him—underneath. They do say that the Tenement House Department is quiet as yet, but it can’t be for long, for there’s a Murphy at its head. He will be at the Corporation Counsel next, the saints defend him! As for the police, they’re clubbing themselves and not the thieves to- day—but what can you expect, when there’s three such fine Irish gentlemen at their heads, as Cropsey of Monaghan, and Flynn of Donegal, and “Clem” Dris- coll of Dingle Bay? How could there be peace and quiet, unless they fought for it? Then there’s Tomkins, he of the Docks; he’s out after Prendergast and Mitchel, and even up in the Bronx there’s a grand row on between Miller and Thompson and one “Phil” Donahue of Tammany Hall, over the sewer pipes up there, with Messrs. Miller and Thompson singing: The Nation But when they grew impertinint we simultaneous | rose Till balf of them was Liffey mud an’ half was tattered clo'es. Now all this must be grand fun—in Ireland. We dare say that there it would be considered the best evidence that all was well in the body politic and that, besides proving the friendliest feel- ings among all concerned, there could be no better sign that the Government was alive and alert. But here it’s different. There are still so many of these dull Americans about who don’t know pure fun when they see it, that we fear there will be some serious public misun- derstandings ere long. They have a curious old-fashioned idea that a cir- cus is a circus and that its proper place, when not in winter quarters, is the Mad- ison Square Garden. They feel that the City Hall was never built for a bear- garden. They know, too, that while there has been many a feat of ground and lofty tumbling within that ancient edifice and many an educated and well- trained animal performer on view there, the real place for these antics is else- where. So we are very much afraid that, if the present public three-ring cir- cus continues, the spectacle will pail, and the ill-bred citizens who so far for- get themselves as to complain to the Mayor about the police and to tell him what they want in the way of a subway will begin to protest loudly about all the rowing that is going on. Impertinent ras cals that they are, they simply will not read Seneca or Epictetus or Lecky, and be quiet. WRITTEN AND UNWRITTEN CON- STITUTIONS, England appears to be on the eve of a constitutional change more important than any that has taken place since 1822, and in its nature more deep-seated than that brought about by the great reform bill of that year. The direct concrete consequences of the abolition of the Lords’ veto may, indeed, be far less pervasive and far less immediately manifest than those that attended the popularization of the House of Com- mons; but the departure is in its es sence more distinctly vital. If the im- pending change should go through as proposed, a very fair approach will have heen made to single-chamber govern- ment; and the approach will be of such a character as totally to remove any serious obstacle to the explicit adoption 361 of virtually complete single-chamber government. With the House of Lords constitutionally unable to interpose any- thing beyond a two years’ delay to the execution of the will of the House of Commons in existence atany given time, the reduction of even this prerogative to one consisting merely of the right to compel reconsideration will be a short and easy step whenever a strong ma- jority of the Commons may wish to take it, Reports from England indicate that while the Unionist party in Parliament is making a vigorous and resourceful light against the Government pro gramme, sentiment in the country at iarge is by no means active. If a change in the written Constitution of this coun- try were in contemplation, haviug a tithe of the importance or signiiicance of this that is impending in England, there would unquestionably be among us @ Vastly more active agitation in the press and among the people on both sides of the question. That the com- parative apathy existing in kngland 1s explainable by many circumstances Coh- nected with the history of the case is undeniable: the people have tired of aluuless manwuvre and sterile discus- sions, the result is looked upon 4s @ ioregone conclusion; and furthermore this present situation is but the climax ot a long series of somewhat similar vles that have arisen trom time to time ior half a century. But all this is in- sullicient to account flor the compara uive iack of interest; it must in very xreal measure be attributed to the dil- serence between the part played by a written constitution and an ulwritten coustitution ip the life of a nation. And \ue question thrusts itsell upon lle wind whether that diflerence—be it good ur bad—is not destined to be greatly ac- cenluated in case the present proposals, vr Lueir DOL improbable exlebsion above reierred to, should go into eilect. What the British Coustitution would ve with an ompipotent Mouse of Colm mons is @ question upon which the ex- perience of the past afllords bo secure guidance. That Kkuglands unwritten Coustitution bas given her much of the venetit to be obtained trom a written Constitution, while avoiding many evils and drawbacks that atlend the opera- tion of such an instrument, is unques- tionable. Probably most thinkers on the subject would agree that the balance

Page 16

362 has been decidedly in favor of the more indefinite and more flexible of the two systems. But flexible as the British Constitution has been in its usual oper- ation, there has always been a latent possibility of making it rigid upon any extraordinary occasion; and this latent possibility has been operative psycholog- ically, even when it may not have been brought patently into exercise. And for a long time back it has been in the powers of the House of Lords that this possibility has centred. The grievance of the Liberal party, that the House of Lords has been a check on legislation only when the Liberals were in office, cannot be disposed of in a word; there are real grounds for complaint. But on the other hand, it is in the very nature of a Constitution which shall not be a mere fiction that somewhere there shall exist a force which is intrinsically and permanently conservative. With us that force resides in our written Constitu- tion and our Supreme Court; in Eng- land, with the steady advance of the popularization of the House of Com- mons, it has resided chiefly in the House of Lords. With the further progress of that advance, with increasing democrat- ization of the nation itself, with the not very remote prospect of a paid member- ship of the House, it is difficult to see where that force could find lodgment. And so we may be approaching a time when the British Constitution, substan- tial in the past in spite of its vagueness, may become not only far more vague, but quite unsubstantial. It may be that a great democratic nation, constantly confronted with vast material and governmental issues, may prove perfectly capable of dealing suc cessfully with its problems without those restraints which we are accustom to designate as constitutional. Fur- thermore, it would be but a shallow view of the matter which did not take account of the mighty force of mere tradition, unembodied in any mechan- fam of checks and balances, as being at the heart of a constitutional system such as that of England; but these are days of rapid change, and half a cen- tury may see such a loosening of the hold of tradition as half a century ago would have seemed impossible. How much a written constitution iike ours, or an unwritten constitution intrench- ed as has been that of England in the past, may be capable of doing in the The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 way of preventing rash innovations | which, once introduced, may be sadly , repented, but may prove next to im-| possible to reverse, no one can say. In| our own country, with the tremendous | portunity. To be sure, he is looking at it with a poet's eyes, remarking that the theatre is but half-aware of the weighty forces which are stirring it to rebirth. He also includes the revival of pageant, | with its promise of vocation to the poet as tide of change in conditions and in| population with which we have con- stantly to reckon, it must, we think, be the inevitable conclusion of sober thought that, with all its drawbacks, our written Constitution—by no means unamendable, but difficult to amend—is an invaluable assurance of that com- bination of fundamental stability and reasonable progress upon which the great future of the republic must rest. ' = | THE PLIGHT OF THE POET. Mr. Perey MacKaye, in the North American Review, laments the hard | case of the poet. “The poet has no pro- | fessional vocation,” and consequently is often compelled “to make an avocation of his highest powers.” “Other workers in the fine arts—painters, sculptors, mu- sicians, architects—may make their art their recognized calling.” But the work- er in poetry must derive his means of living from other sources than his real occupation. Even Alfred Noyes, “whose poetry is said to be self-sustaining,” is | at work on a play. Why wonder at a) dearth of poets when society provides | no vocation for them? There are other | difficulties. “The cadences, the harmon: | ies, the seizure by the imagination upon consonants and vowels, sounds which | subtly evoke the human associations of centuries—these are addressed to the ears, not the eyes, of his audience.” And | “originally his audience was not a per- | son, but a people. Homer sang to all | Hellas—not from the printed page, but | from the mouths of minstrels. Thus the | very craftsmanship of the poet is based | upon two assumptions which are seldom granted him to-day: The sung, or chant- | ed, word: a plural audience.” From all) these causes, and others, the power of the poet with the people has waned, and | can be revived only by a partial re- | nascence of the older conditions. Spe- cifically, the drama is for him, as it was for his predecessors in the days of | Sophocles and again in those of Shake- | speare, the nearest approach to a@ con- | genial vocation. It must not be supposed that Mr. | MacKaye is ironical in this appraisal of | the drama as the poet's one great op-| such in the production of masque, bal- lad, and choral song. But it is obvious that even drama can supply employment for only those poets who can write drama, and they did not comprise a sin- gle great figure in either England or America during the nineteenth century, rich as that age was in the mass, the variety, and the quality of its verse. On the other hand, Mr. MacKaye reasons like a poet rather than a logician in his esti- mate of the necessity of the sung or chanted word and of the plural audi- ence. Homer may have moved thou- sands by his singing, but Homer in the printed page has stirred his myriads; while Tennyson and Browning won vir- tually every auditor they ever had with- out so much as having seen him. The poet need have no fear about his chant- ing. Let him put it into his verses, and they will roll the echoes long after his own lips are still. Must we admit that the power of the poet with the people has waned? “The inspiration of the ancient bards,” de- clares Mr. MacKaye, “has never passed from the earth. It is perennially in the poet’s heart. But it can never pass ef- fectively into the hearts of the people through their eyes—from the pages of printed volumes or magazines.” Are we, then, to betake ourselves, with our mag- azines under our arms, to those whose verses appear in them, in order that the inspiration which our eyes have failed to see may find effective passage into our hearts through our ears, as the poet lends to his rhyme the beauty of his voice? Macaulay, after demonstrat- ing the impossibility of a modern poet, rang up the curtain, in his usual theat- rical manner, upon one of the greatest of them. Mr. MacKaye gives one the impression that there are plenty of poets, but insists that they have no way of making their existence known. There is one man, however, from whom they cannot hide. Mr. Wallate Rice can put his finger upon “no less than seventy men and women” in this country “who are writing admirable poetry, which will bear comparison with the best poetry of the English at any time.” The circum- stance that it Is not read by anybody : ' : { 7 Sag Eee ee ~ 2 arterial:

Page 17

te ete ee TT ee seal April 13, 1911] is regarded by its discoverer as the very reason why it will survive. When we leave fantasy and paradox for solid ground, we can only wonder why any one should deny our lack of poets or our appreciation of poetry. The best evidence of both facts is the eager- ness with which we greet any prom- ise of a poet. The popularity of Kip- ling, so long as he kept out of absolute bathos, is an earnest of the dazzling re- wards that would be heaped upon a veritable singer. A more recent illus- tration is Francis Thompson, whose “Selected Poems” have been passing through several editions in England. As a British critic points out, Thompson's verse has characteristics of excessive waywardness of fancy and style which one might have expected to exclude him from his heritage of popularity for at least a generation, and yet it “has found its way to the hearts of lovers of poetry as Mr. Noyes’s never will.” A\l- though “critics assign to some of the best of his poems not less than classic rank,” they are popular with young men. The truth is that we are so eager for real poetry that we overpraise those who are more than mediocre. How many of our real singers have missed during their lifetime a substantial in- stalment of the fame that was to be con- firmed by the ages? This recognition is society's perennial call to the poet. An avocation, at first and for long, his work may be. It may be, as Mr. MacKaye says, that it is among those with independent incomes that most of the excellent names in Eng lish poetry are found. Nevertheless, if Burns had not won his immortality be- fore he won his chance for material suc- cess, he would probably never have won it. Without unduly minimizing this limitation, it is to be noted that the poet suffers therefrom in degree rather than in kind. What is a painter, a sculptor, a musician, an architect, a nov- elist, an actor, an orator, to do while he is still on the way to the place where he can afford to give himself up to the de- mands of the highest in his art? What of the historian, without money or repu- tation to collect the materials indis- pensable to the composition of his epic? ‘The poet can weave his tapestry on any loom, but canvas and marble are not to be had for the asking. The most pre- «ious element of all, time, is more eas- ily his than it is of the worker who must resort to wood or gallery, to li- The Nation brary or landscape. It may be hard and even cruel that things should be thus arranged, but they are, and it may be doubted whether society can much im- prove them. THE “RAVENOUS SOCIAL PRO GRAMME.” Im writing an introduction to a re cent volume on John Bright, Mr. Augus tine Birrell refers to that statesman’s life-long fight for economy in public ex- penditure, Especially valiant was that tribune of the people in opposing with voice and pen year after year the swol- len outlay for military purposes Mr. Birrell wonders what Bright would say if he were in the House of Commons now and speaking on army and navy estimates twice as great as those against which in his lifetime he pleaded and thundered. But then Mr. Birrell: goes on to remark that even if men like Bright could to-day keep down or even nearly abolish the expenditure on arm- aments, the result would be only a tem- porary relief to the taxpayer, since “the ravenous social programme’ would soon consume every penny that could possi- bly be got from taxation. This is not put forward as an argu ment against disarmament. It really cuts the other way. If there is, as there undoubtedly is in every country, this enormous pressure upon public finance to provide the means for social better- ment, the duty of statesmen to stra‘n every nerve in order to prevent the waste of money on guns and ships be- comes clearer than ever. A dollar saved from the arts of temporary destruction may mean more than a dollar gained for permanent upbuilding. On the oth- er hand, there is reason to believe that some of the advocates of big and ever bigger navies and armies are more or less consciously influenced by the hope of staving off in that way political move- ments which they dread. By taking for military objects all the money avail- able, they think to starve out the social causes which clamor for larger appro- priations. As a matter of fact, how- ever, those who pay taxes see the bur- den for both classes of expenditure steadily growing. Whether you look at Germany or England, France or the United States, you discover that the military budget and the peace budget enlarge side by side. If their united, strain is not to become intolerable, it should seem that one or the other must soon be lessened. In whatever way those competing fig- ures may be adjusted, however, there can be little question that Mr. Birrell is right in looking forward to a steadily rising scale of public expenditure as a result of the ravenous social pro- gramme. Every legislator, every execu tive, feels its appeal and its force. There isa constantly rising demand for expenditure on hospitals and schools and good roads and public health and better housing for the poor. When we add the appropriations for the endless forms of investigation and inspection, and for the new governmental machinery con tinually created in response to some real or fancied social need, we get a mounting total that would afiright an old-fashioned economist. And this is to say nothing of the more advanced and more expensive parts of the social pro- gramme which Mr. Birrell doubtless had in mind—old-age pensions, working- men’s insurance against sickness and lack of employment, the expropriation of land for the benefit of the small ten- ant, and so on. There is such a cry of “Give, give’ heard on every side of pub lic treasuries, great and small, that it is not strange that their traditional “watch-dogs” are frightened away. Now, there is one thing to be noted in connection with this ravenous social programme in our own country at least, and that is that it does not proceed upon any definite or consistent princi- ple. It is not the avowed Socialists who are pushing the social programme, with all its cost. They have their own ideas and aims and ways of working. For the time being, they may be tound ap- proving or at any rate demanding the various forms of governmental outlay which we vaguely call paternalistic or social, but by themselves alone they would not be strong enough to compass the object. The real moving force is that great and growing body of humane men and women who act in this matter not so much from a fixed conviction as from a philanthropic impulse. It is not a case of Socialism, or of any other defi- nite doctrine, but of rule of thumb. Without stating to themselves a precise economic or political reason or princi- ple, masses of people somehow find themselves at one in feeling that cer- tain bad conditions of life can no long

Page 18

8364 er be tolerated, that given facilities of civilization must and shall be provid- ed; and then follow agitation and or- ganization and protests and appeals to Governors and Presidents, to Legisla- tures and Congress, with the result that money is presently voted to clean up slums and build sanitary tenements and provide parks and playgrounds and reg- ulate industry and care in a thousand ways for what we call the unfortunate or dependent classes. That is what the social programme chiefly means in the United States at present, and it is cer- tain that it will long go on making fresh and large demands upon the pub- lic purse. We may not like it, but there it is, and it has unquestionably come not only to stay but to grow. It is not necessarily an enemy of economy in public expenditure, bet it does hold out a very clear prospect that for every dol- lar the public economist can save the social reformer will stand ready to spend two. One inference from all this is unmis- takable. If we are going in for the so- cial programme, we must be prepared to foot its bills. The tax is sure to run beyond our sympathies merely, and to hit our pockets. So that in the interest of frankness it ought to be understood that every man who advocates a new form of benevolent social activity on the part of government, is really advocating a new tax. It will not do to say ina large, Micawber way that the general resources are sufficient to meet the drain or that somehow the money will be found. The only way governments can find money is by looking for it and seizing it in the hands of citizens; and the latter may as well understand, first as last, that the social programme is a taxation programme. THER INVASION OF NORTH AFRICA. When Mr. Robert Hichens wrote the “Garden of Allah,” he initiated one of the moet impressive land reclamation achemes in history. It is only a half dozen years since Mr. Hichens entered the Desert, and already the face of the great waste is blooming with novels and romances by British and American writ ers. The present spring season har brought us two or three Saharan books, with the promise of a generous crop when the printers’ leaves begin to turn next autumn. From publishers’ advance notices we evolve the picture of an end- The Nation [Vol. oz, No. 2389 less line of high-powered automobiles, stretching along the hot sand roads from Oran and Algiers to Constantine, and on to where the cultivated land stops and the local color begins. The drivers of these high-priced automobiles are, needless to say, American novelists. They are in pursuit of the brooding desert silences and the hoary mysteries | of the East, for which there is a per- | ceptibly growing demand in the fiction market. India and Egypt have felt the demand; but for the moment the pio- neer energy of our best-sellers seems destined to move along the road from the Mediterranean, through the wall of the Atlas Mountains to the oasis of Biskra, a name that has oddly enough escaped the attention of the expert in nomenclature employed by our largest manufacturer of soda-crackers. Mr. Hichens has not merely given the | impulse to this new invasion; he has | decided its main characteristics in ad- vance. In all forthcoming novels of the Sahara, we take it, there will be (1) enervated Europeans or Americans in search of Peace; (2) sensuous Oriental | dancers; (3) Zouaves in red trousers, Chasseurs d'Afrique, with an occasion- al Foreign Legionary or a goumier; (4) fortune-tellers who read your fortune in the sand; (5) Arab curio-dealers with eyes of smouldering fire; (6) cam-| els; (7) a pretty love story; (8) oases; (9) Arab guides of princely bearing and cameo-like cast of features; (10) bour- nouses, hadjis, wadys, oueds, sidis, and babs, Individual temperament and apti- tude will, of course, embroider on the main pattern, but, in general, the at- mosphere will be what we have indi- cated. The two most radical innova- tions to be expected are (1) the intro- duction of automobiles, which Mr. Hich- ens does not even mention, and (2) the injection into the brooding desert si- lences of something of that red blood and cheerful optimism without which it is hard to succeed in contemporary fic- tion. The second hypothesis is not so vi- sionary as may appear at first sight. Of one Desert novel, it Is already asserted that its seenes are as clear-cut as the white houses of Algiers and its story | | story have sold by the scores of thou- sands, we have not the least doubt that |they can do it, and have done it. As | for the sociological implications of the |new Desert literature, we have no doubt ‘that it will be just as good a thing for | the Arabs and the Desert as for the |Feringhi novelist. Why should East and ‘West be content to remain eternally apart? The thing to do, like practical men, is to get together. The East can give the West enough brooding peace to repair the wear and tear of a hard year at Newport and bridge. The West can |supply the East with something of that “push” which the Orient must have, if it is ever to wake from its thousand- year-old dreams and develop progress, railways, standing armies, child-labor, /anti-tuberculosis campaigns, fire investi- gations, automobiles, press-agents, book- reviewers, and nature-lavers. Having seen that the novelists are now flocking to the Desert because Mr. Robert Hichens went there, it is next in order to ask why Mr. Hichens sought the Desert. The answer is that the world’s visible supply of local color is becoming so rapidly exhausted that writers of fiction, an industry into which local color so largely enters, have been compelled to search the world for new deposits of this precious element. The crisis is exactly the same as that which confronts the platinum, rubber, and potash industries. Up to a few years ago, for instance, Italy and the Riviera supplied pretty nearly the en- tire demand for exotic fiction. To-day the Riviera and Italy are beginning to be spoken of as worked out, both for the novelist and the tourist. The trend has been steadily toward the equator, Capri and Sicily have been stepping-stones to- ward the African coast and Egypt. There is plenty of steam-heat to be had now in the shadow of the Pyramids, to- gether with chefs and mechanical pianos equal to the best that London or Paris can offer. The oasis now furnishes its | visitors the combined advantages of the Peace of Allah, the heart of an exotic civilization, and the most advanced methods in water-therapy and Swedish massage. Our confusion of the novelist and the is full of the mystery of the East. How ‘tourist is intentional. Between the two a story of brooding mystery can be | framed in a clear-cut scene, we do not profess to know; but since previous there has grown up of late years an in- timate connection that cannot help be- ing regarded with concern by the Baede- books by the authors of this particular|ker interests. The localcolor writer . .

Page 19

Ante eee ee TT April 13, 1911] has been pushing hard the classic au-| thority on what is the proper fare for a drive for three persons in a two-horse carriage for two and a half hours out- side the fortifications between 8 and 10 P. M. But one disadvantage of the new method has been that when the tourist reaches the scene of action he finds real- ity drab and pale by comparison with his preliminary reading in the novelists. That is why even the vivid tones of the Riviera and Italy are losing their ap- peal. The tourist movement is toward the great primary colors of the Desert, of Egypt, and of India. But here, too, the traveller finds the fiction writer close at his side. WALTER PATER. Whatever else one may say of Pater, however one may like or dislike him, he stands in the complex, elusive nine teenth century as a clear sign of some- thing fixed and known.* But he per- forms this office not as a critic, as he is commonly reckoned; indeed, of the crit- ical mind, exactly speaking, he had lit- tle, being at once something more and something less than this. It is, of course, legitimate to take the expression of life as it comes to the critic in liter- ature, and from this to develop a phil- osophy and vision of the critic’s own; and this rather than any weighing of rel- ative values was the intention of Pater. Such an aim is entirely justifiable, but it is not justifiable to misunderstand or falsify the basis on which the critic’s own fabric is to be reared. If he is true critic his first concern must be the right interpretation of the documents before him, and whatever else he may have to offer must proceed from primary ve racity of intention or vision. Just here Pater faulted, or defaulted. He has much to say that is interesting, even persuasive, about the*great leaders and movements of the past, but too often his interpretation, when the spell of his manner is broken, will be found essen- tially perverted. This may seem a harsh judgment to pass on a writer who has been one of the main influences in later nineteenth- century literature, but it can be easily substantiated. In his three greatest works—“Plato and Platonism,’ “Marius the Epicurean,” and “The Renaissance” —Pater has dealt with three crises of history; and in each case he has grave- ly, though in varying degrees, falsified the reality. IL. “Plato and Platonism” is a book that every student of Greek and of life should *New LAbrary Edition of the Worka of Walter Pater. In Ten Volumes. With decorated backs. New York: The Macmillan Co. $2 net the volume. The Nation read; it is in itself a beautifully wrought work of art in which each de tail is fitted into its place as part of a total designed effect; but that effect, pre- sented as an interpretation of Plato, is of a kind, it can scarcely be said too emphatically, that differs toto calo from what Plato himself meant to convey in his dialogues, and is gained by a wilful distortion of the facts of history. In one of his chapters, Pater gives a pic ture, based largely on Karl Otfried Miiller, of the Doric life in Lacedemon a3 the actuality which Plato had in mind when he conceived his ideal city-state. It is a picture of cool colors and delic- iously subdued harmonies, an idy] beau tiful in itself and not without lessons for the youth of to-day in its insistence on the sheer loveliness and exquisite pleasures that may flow from austere discipline and self-suppression. It has its own wisdom, as in the development of Miiller’s text, that “in a _ Doric state, education was, on the whole, a matter of more importance than govern ment.” But it has one serious defect: it is not true. This city, as the picture finally arranges itself, is simply not the cold, hard Sparta that stood on the banks of the Eurotas, but some idyl lic Auburn wafted into some Arcadia of the imagination. At the end of the chapter, after giving a noble account of the training, or askésis, by which the Lacedemonian youth were drilled for life, Pater represents an Athenian visi tor as asking: “Why this strenuous task work day after day; why this loyalty t)» a system, so costly to you individual ly, though it may be thought to have survived its original purpose; this labor icus, endless education, which does not propose to give you anything very use ful or enjoyable in itself?” The ques tion is apt, and Pater puts the answer into the mouth of a Spartan youth: “To the end that I myself may be a perfect work of art, issuing thus into the eyes of all Greece.” The discipline of Lycur gus, that is to say, was to the end that the young men of Sparta might be “a spectacle, wsthetically, at least, very in- teresting’ (the words are Pater's) to the rest of Greece! Really, a more com- piete perversion of history has not of ten been conceived. The institutions of Sparta, as the Lacedwmonian in Plato's “Laws” admits without hesitation, were ordered to the end “that Sparta might conquer the other states in war.” Not the indulgence of vanity, however chastely controlled, but the law of self- preservation and the terrible survival of the fittest made the Laced#monians the most comely of the people of Hel- las; they were warriors and the mothers of warriors, not westhetes. And this same misrepresentation ex- tends through much of Pater’s analysis of Platonism. Pater saw, as all who study Plato are forced to see, that the heart of Plato's doctrine lay in his con- 3865 ception of ideas, in his use and enforce- ment of dialectic or the process of pass- ing from particulars to generals. [But Pater saw also something in this pro cess that militated against his particular notion of esthetics, and he was bound, if he accepted Platonism, as it was his desire to accept all the great move- ments of history, to interpret Platonic ideas in his own way. The result is a curious “apology for general ideas—ab- struse, or intangible, or dry and seedy and wooden, as we may sometimes think them”—as a means of heightening the momentary perception of particular, beautiful phenomena. Doubless to rep- resent Plato as an enemy of the decent and comely things of life, as an icono- clast of art and poetry and music in themselves, would be to forget some of the great passages in his “Republic” and other dialogues, in which the prac- tical effect of beautiful things upon con- duct is largely recognized and in which beauty in the abstract is placed by the side of the True and the Good in the gu- preme trinity of ideas. I would even admit that much of what Pater says in regard to Plato’s conception of beauty is sound and worthy of emphasis. He has done well in drawing out the ele- ment of discipline in the Platonic wsthetics—-the value of the capacity for correction, of patience, of crafty reserve, of intellectual astringency, which Plato demanded of the poet and the musician and of every true citizen of the ideal re public. Plato, as Pater rightly observes, was of all men faithful to the old Greek aying, beauty is hard to attain. But Pa- ter’s interpretation of Plato ends in a creed which Plato would have rejected with utter indignation. To recommend the pursuit of ideas for the sake of lend ing piquancy to the phenomenal, to us the intellectual apparatus in order to enhance the significance of the particu lar object, to undergo philosophical dis cipline for the sake of adding zest to sensuous pleasure; in a word, to make truth the servant of beauty, and good- ness the servant of pleasure, is to up hold a doctrine essentially and uncom- promisingly the contrary of everything that Plato believed and held sacred. To follow such a course, however purely and austerely beauty may be conceived, is, as Plato says, to ts Taw mada the subject of beautiful things and not their master. Plato taught that the perception of beauty in the particu- lar object was one of the means by which a man might rise to contempla- tion of the idea of beauty in the Intel- lectual world, and wherever he saw the danger of inverting this order, as Pater and many other self-styled Platonista have inverted it, he could speak of art with all the austerity of a Puritan. There is no sentence in the dialogues that cuts more deeply into the heart of his phflosophy than the foreboding ex- ‘clamation: “When any one prefers beau

Page 20

366 ty to virtue, what is this but the real | and utter dishonor of the soul?” II, From the study of “Plato and Platon- ism” we turn naturally to the greatest of Pater’s works, “Marius the Epicu- rean,” and here again we are confront- ed by a false interpretation of one of the critical moments of history. The theme of “Marius,” I need scarcely say, is the life of a young Italian who, in the of Marcus Aurelius, is searching for yme guiding motive amid the dissolu- tion of all traditions. He sees the world about him, the world at least that has outgrown the ancestral belief in the gods, and has not sunk into frivolity or sad skepticism, divided between the two sects of the Epicureans and the Stoics; and the larger part of the story is really a disquisition on the effect of these oppos- ed philosophies upon the human soul. In the choice of Epicureanism instead of the harsher Stoic creed as a prepar- ation for Christian faith, Pater, I think, shows a true knowledge of the human heart. Pascal, it will be remembered, found himself fifteen centuries later face to face with the revived tenets of Mpleurus and Zeno, which are indeed the expression of the two main tenden- cies, not of one time but of all times, of those who attempt to stop in a relig- ous philosophy just short of religion; and Pascal, too, saw that the step from ipicureanism to Christianity was eas- ier than from Stoicism. So far Pater n his account of the relation of the Pagan philosophies and Christianity s psychologically right, but his por- trayal of Christianity itself one is com- pelled to condemn in the same terms as his portrayal of Platonism. Read the story of Marius at the home of the Christian Cecilia and at the service of the mass, and you will feel that here is no picture of a militant faith in train- ing for the conquest of the world, of a sect looking for struggle and moral regeneration, but the report of a pleas- ant scene where the eye is charmed and the ear soothed by the same subdued and Janguid loveliness that seemed to Pater to rule In Sparta and the ideal city of Plato. No doubt it would be wrong, as Pater asserts, to set over “against that divine urbanity and moderation the old error of Montanus” (Montanism, it may be observed by the way, was at that date quite young, but In the roman- tie convention everything is “old”)—to et up as the complete Christian ideal the “fanatical revolt" of Montanus, our, falsely anti-mundane, ever with | an alr of ascetic affectation, and a bigot- ed distaste In particular for all the pe- culiar graces of womanhood.” It is well to avoid extremes in either direction. Yet if choice had to be made between the dainty voluptuousness of religion as it appeared to Marius, and the moral rigor ef Tertullian, the great Montanist | The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 preacher who was contemporary with Marius, it would not be hard to say on which side lay the real Christianity of the second century. Against Pater’s “elegance of sanctity,” as he calls it, a Christian might exclaim with Tertullian that “truth is not on the surface but in the inmost heart.” Pater, borrowing the phrase from Tertullian, describes the death of Marius as that of a soul naturally Christian. Beside that pic- ture of a soul daintily dreaming itself into eternity set the apostrophe of Ter- tullian himself to the anima naturaliter Christiana: But I summon thee—not such as when moulded in schools, trained in libraries, fed in attic academies and porches, thou blurtest forth wisdom—I address thee sim- ple, and rude, and uncultured,and untaught, such as he possesses thee, who possesses thee and nothing else; the bare soul, just as it is from the road, the street, the weaver’s shop. The simple fact is that in Marius we have no real conversion from Epicurean- ism to religion, no Christianity at all as it would have been recognized by St. Paul or St. Augustine, but that pecu- liarly languid wstheticism which Pater sucked from the romantic school of his century and disguised in the phraseol-| ogy of an ancient faith. To write thus was to betray Christianity with a kiss. IIT. In the third of Pater’s major works, “The Renaissance,” there is again a reading of Paterism into the past, but without the offensiveness that is felt in his treatment of Platonism and Chris- tianity. Not a little of the romanticism from which Pater drew his philoso- phy may be traced to the Italy of Botti- celli and Leonardo da Vinci; but the tone, the energy, the ¢thos, are changed. The nature of the change cannot be bet- ter displayed than in the famous de- scription of the La Gioconda in the es- say on “Leonardo da Vinci,” which is too familiar for quotation. Now I shall not criticise this famous passage for its treatment of plain facts. Those who care to see how far Pater has de- parted from the inconveniences of history may consult the mono- graph of Salomon Reinach in No. 2 of the Bulletin des Musées de France for 1909. And, after all, Pater was not dealing with facts, but with emotions; as a “lover of strange souls,” to use his own phrase, he was analyzing the impres- sion made upon him by this picture, and trying to reach through it a definition of the chief elements of Leenardo’s gen- ius. Yet viewed even in that light, the description rings false—not so false as his interpretations of Platonism and Christianity, but still subtly perversive of the truth. It may be true in a way ‘that the genius of Leonardo, as Goethe said, had “thought itself weary”—wmiide sich gedacht; but the deadly and delib- erate languor that trails through the lines of Pater—not, I admit, without its own ambiguous and troubling beauty— has no correspondence in the virile art of Leonardo. And whatever may have been the sins of Leonardo in the flesh, and whatever may have been his intel- lectual doubts or indifferences, he would not have understood that strange and frequent identification among the mod- ern romantics of the soul and disease. Into the face of Mona Lisa, says Pater, “the soul with all its maladies has pass- ed!” as if health were incompatible with the possession of a soul. The simple truth is that Pater was in no proper sense of the word a critic at all. History was only an extension of his own ego, and he saw himself whith- ersoever he turned his eyes. To form any just estimate of Pater’s work, we must forget the critical form in which so much of his writing is couched, and regard the substance of his own philoso- phy apart from any apparent relation to the period or person to which it is transferred. And here we are aided by the singular consistency of his nature. In his works all is of a piece, and all is the perfectly lucid outgrowth of an un- varying design and of a single attitude toward the world. IV. If we search for the sources of this design, apart from the original charac- ter of the artist himself, we shall find them without difficulty. Among English writers he himself would probably have ascribed the chief influence upon him to Ruskin, but as a matter of fact I sus- pect that the more dominating personal influence came from another and more insinuating mind. I do not certainly know that Pater ever met Rossetti in the flesh, but he recognized that great and sad genius as one of his teachers. But however Pater may seem to have lighted his torch at Rossetti’s flame, we must not overlook the strong imperson- al influence that emanated from the memories and the very stones of Oxford. We ali know Matthew Arnold’s apos- trophe to the “home of lost causes, and forsaken beliefs, and unpopular names, and impossible loyalties”; to the dream- city that “lies, spreading her gardens to the moonlight, and whispering from her towers the last enchantments of the Middle Ages.” The call of Oxford is, as her lover says, to beauty and to higher ideals; but there is an aspect of her ap- peal which is not without its fascinat- ing danger. From the beginning she has been the home of secluded causes as well as lost causes; she has stood al- ways as a protest against the coarse and ephemeral changes of civilization, but she has maintained this centre of calm too much by a withdrawal from life rather than by strong control. Hers at her origin was the ideal of monas- ticism and of faith fleeing the world; her loyalty to the king was strongest

Page 21

April 13, 1911] when loyalty meant a separation from | the great powers of political expansion; her religious revival in the nineteenth century was not only the desire of re- suscitating an impossible past, but sought also to sever the forms of wor- ship entirely from the influence of the state and of the people. Certainly much good has come out of this pride of se clusion, and waves of spiritual force have continually emanated from this reservoir of memory; but it is true also that these influences have often ended in sterility or have tended to widen rather than close up the unfortunate gap between the utilitarian and the sen- timental phases of English life. In a word, they have been too often a rein- forcement to the romantic ideal of the imagination as a worship of beauty iso- lated from, and in the end despised by, the real interests of life, and too seldom a reinforcement of the classical ideal of the imagination as an active power in life itself. The very contrast of the en- chanted towers of Oxford with the hid- eous chimneys of one of England’s great manufacturing towns seems to give to the university an atmosphere of exsthet- ic unreality. Ideas do not circulate here as they do in a university like that of Paris, situated at the heart of the na- tional life, and in too many of the books that come from Oxford one feels the breath of a fine traditional culture that has somehow every excellent quality— except vitality. And so it was not strange to see the Oxford Movement depart further and further from practical and intellectual realities and lose itself in an empty and _ stubborn ritualism. Thought is the greatest marrer of good Icvks, said Oscar Wilde, and that is why there are so many good-looking young curates in England. The estheticism of William Morris and Burne-Jones was a conscious revolt from the vapidity of the later stages of the Oxford Movement to a pure and Pagan sensuousness. Ros- setti gave body and passion to the re- volt, and Pater, following in their steps, lent a scholastic authority to their ar- tistic achievements. Paterism might without great injustice be defined as the quintessential spirit of Oxford, emptied of the wholesome intrusions of the world—its pride of isolation reduced to sterile self-absorption, its enchantment of beauty alembicated into a faint Epi cureanism, its discipline of learning changed into voluptuous economy of sensations, its golden calm stagnated into languid elegance. v. In more than one passage Pater gives direct expression to his philosophy, no- where else s0 explicitly as in the conclusions to his volume on the Renais- sance. The motto of that chapter is the famous saying of Heracleitus, “All things are in a state of flux and nothing abides”; and the chapter itself is but a brief exhortation to make the The Nation most of our human life amidst this end-| less and ceaseless mutation of which we are ourselves an ever-changing element. That is the sum of Pater's philosophy as it is everywhere implicitly expressed in critical essay and fiction: the admoni- tion to train our body and mind to the highest point of acuteness so as to catch, as it were, each fleeting glimpse of beau- ty on the wing, and by the intensity of our perception and participation to com- pensate for the brevity of the world's gifts; in a word, the admonition to make of life itself an art. Now, we ought, | think, to be grateful first of all to any- one who recalls to us and utters in man- itold ways this lesson of the immediate perception of lovely things, of grace within answering to grace without. Per- haps no other philosophy to-day has so completely passed out of our range of vision as this doctrine of the art of liv ing which has been one of the guiding principles of the great ages of the past. We are too hurried for this, a little too unbalanced between egotism and senti- mental humanitarianism, a little too un- certain, despite much optimistic brag, of any real and immediate values in life. And there is much also to com- mend in the method Pater proposes for attaining this ideal. If he teaches that the art of life is to train our emo tions, like a well-trimmed lamp, “to burn always with a hard, gemlike flame,” he also endlessly reiterates the lesson that this joy of eager observa tion and swift response can be made habitual in us only by a severe self-dis- cipline and moderation. Only when the senses have been purified and sharp ened by a certain chastity of use, only when the mind has been exercised by a certain rigidity of application, do we become fit instruments to record the delicate impacts of evanescent beauty. In his essay on Raphael, one of the soundest of his critical estimates, Pater refers to the “saying that the true ar- tist is known best by what he omits”; and this, he adds, is “because the whole question of good taste is involved pre- cisely in such jealous omission.” No one, indeed, has seen more clearly than Pater that virtue is not acquired by a rebound from excess, but is the exquis- ite flower of the habit of moderation. Yet withal, the account with Pater cannot stop here, nor, if we consider the fruit of his teaching in such men 4s Oscar Wilde, can we admit that his teaching was altogether without offence. His error was not that he inculcated the art of life at all seasons, but that his sense of values was finally wrong; his philosophy from beginning to end might be called by a rhetorician a kind of hysteron-proteron. And this is vis- ible in his treatment of the three great movements of history. Thus in his in- terpretation of Plato, we have seen how he falsified Plato’s theory and use of facts by raising beauty, or esthetic 367 pleasure, above truth as the goal to be kept in sight. Now this may seem a slight sin, when, in extolling the one, nothing is intentionally taken away from the honor of the other. Pater would even say that as truth and beau ty are the same, it makes no difference which of them you set before your gaze, and in this he would have the author- ity of many eminent predecessors. Are we not all fond of quoting the lofty words of Keats?— “Beauty is truth, truth beauty’’—that is all Ye know on earth, and all ye need to know. Perhaps, in some high philosophical realm that is the case; but it happens that in practice in this mundane sphere, truth and beauty are by no means al- ways identical; and it makes a world of difference where you come out, ac- cording to whether you hold this or the other as your first desire when the divergence occurs. I have been struck by a passage on this theme in one of the recently published Japanese letters of Lafcadio Hearn—certainly no foe to romantic beauty. “They all [the ro- manticists] sowed a crop of dragon's teeth,” he says. “Preaching without qualification, the gospel of beauty— that beaufy is truth—provoked the hor- rible modern answer of Zolaism: ‘Then truth must be beauty!’” Pater’s misin- terpretation of Plato was equally a mis interpretation of life. In like manner, when Pater in his treatment of Christianity placed msthet- ic satisfaction before religious duty, he really missed the goal of happiness he was aiming at. The old Scotch preacher Blair pronounced the sure answer to such an error many years before Pater- ism existed: “To aim at a constant suc- cession of high and vivid sensations of pleasure, is an idea of happiness alto gether chimerical. . . . Instead of those fallacious hopes of perpetual fes- tivity, with which the world would al- lure us, religion confers upon us a cheerful tranquillity.” Nor was Pater’s fault in regard to the Renaissance es- sentially different in its consequences; it may even be that here, where his temperament would seem to be most at home, his subtle inversion of the facts, in making beauty and pleasure the sole purpose of life instead of the reward or efflorescence of right living, is the most instructive of all. Read Pater’s exquisitely refined pages on Leonardo da Vinci, with their constant implication that beauty is a kind of malady of the soul, and then recall the strong, lusty soul of the Renaissance as it speaks, for instance, in the ringing lines of Chapman: Give me a spirit that on this life's rough sea Loves t’ have his sails fill'd with a lusty wind. .. There is no danger to a man that knows What life and death is—

Page 22

368 recall the whole magnificent passage, and you will see why Pater’s philosophy leads on inevitably to weariness, and satiety, and impotence. This exaltation of beauty above truth, and esthetic grace above duty, and refined perception above action, this insinuating hedonism which would so bravely embrace the joy of the moment, forgets to stay itself on any fixed and unselfish principle, and forgetting this, it somehow misses the enduring joy of the world and empties life of its true values. It is for such reasons as this that we cannot finally accept Pater’s philosophy of the art of life, notwithstanding all that may be said in its favor; that even his lesson of moderation and self-restraint, much that lesson is needed to-day and al- ways, seems at last to proceed from e deep-seated taint of decaying pow- ers rather than from conscious strength. So intimately are good and evil mingled together in human ideals. P. E. M. FOGAZZARO’S LAST NOVEL. FLorence, Italy, March 29. “Leila,” the novel which Fogazzaro published shortly before his death,* is . continuation in a certain sense of “Il Santo,” for, although none of the char- acters of the earlier work, save in one small incident, reappear in the later one, it is permeated with the same ideas and tendencies, and the hero of “Leila,” Massimo Alberti, is the devotee of Pietro Maironi (“Il Santo”) and a continuator of his tradition. I fear that the au- thor’s last novel will not add to his reputation; it has neither the techni- caland psychological merits of some of his earlier novels, notably “Daniele Cor- tis’ and “Piccolo Mondo Antico,” nor the inspired religious fervor of “Il San- to”: the style lacks vivacity, the plot is not convincing, the motives and person- ality of most of the characters are mere- ly perplexing and unsympathetic, and the general treatment is weak. Leila Da Camin, the daughter of disreputable par- ents, but herself a fine character—at least. so we are told—was engaged to Andrea Trento, although she esteemed rather than loved him, and at his pre mature death was glad to get away from her own parents, She goes to live with his father Marcello, who desires to have her constantly by him as a reminder of his dead son. The son's most intimate friend, Massimo Alberti, a young Milan- ese doctor and a “modernist” of deep, if convictions, comes to omewhat vague, pay a visit to Trento, who conceives that a marriage between him and Leila would be in every way desirable. Mas simo falls in love with her without re it, but Leila, thinking that he Is alizing merely an adventurer, after her fortune, treatae him with absolute rudeness, so that he leaves the house crestfallen. lemeke & Buechner, New York The Nation [Vol. 92, No. 2389 ‘Marcello Trento dies suddenly, leaving | Leila his property; but as she is still a) minor, her father comes to take tempor- | ary possession of it. A priestly intrigue | is on foot to prevent her from ever mar- | rying and to induce her to enter a con- | vent, so as to get control of the Trento) inheritance through her father—a time- honored motif in Catholic countries. A | common friend, however, Donna Fedele | Brayla, intervenes and brings Leila and Massimo together. Religion plays a very | large part in the book, and we are told at great length what are the convictions of each of the characters. Leila and Mas- | simo, who had almost lost all faith in) the church, owing to the unworthiness of some of its members, regain it through mutual love; and after Leila has renounced the Trento inheritance in | favor of her father, the couple retire) to a mountain village, where Massimo will devote himself to assisting the poor | as medico condotto. Yet with all its faults, and they are| many, the book has charm; the descrip- | tions of the scenery in the Alpine foot- hills near Vicenza and in the Valsolda | above the Lake of Lugano are delight- fully fresh. La Montanina, the house where most of the action takes place, is a living and lovable personality, and many of the minor characters show the hand of a master, Above all there is the charm of Fogazzaro’s own spirit. Even through bad workmanship and poor character-drawing, we always feel the deep sincerity and refinement of the au-| thor; he is always an artist and a gen- tleman, although his treatment may be | often inartistic. As in “Il Santo” so in | “Leila,” we see Fogazzaro against hope-| less odds ever fighting the good fight of | reconciling traditional Catholicism with | modern thought and modern science; in the former work the struggle is for the | reformation of the church from with-| in, in the latter for the regeneration of two souls. “I said to myself,” writes Leila to Massimo, “all or nothing. As) long as I could I accepted all. Then when I saw things more closely and found allied together the persons who incarnate the All—the arciprete, the chaplain, the arciprete’s sister, my father, a certain Molesin, a friend of my father’s, I could not resist and said to myself: better Nothing. But Nothing | fails to satisfy me, and I ask you for a faith, glad that you are freed of your old beliefs, of your ideas of a Catholic renovation. I ask of you a God whom I can worship in the woods of Dasio, in the gorge of the cascade, on the waves of the lake, in a wedding chamber; who does not impose official intermediaries, who asks me only for love and forbids me only hate; who does not torture my intelligence with incomprehensible dog- mas nor annoy me with tedious observ-| ances; who does not undertake to at- tract me with heavens or terrorize me} L. V. with hells.” NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. The very remarkable collection of rare books which was brought together by the late E. Dwight Church, and which has been often referred to in this column, has been sold privately by the executors of Mr. Church’s estate, through George D. Smith, the New York bookseller, to H. E. Hunt- | ington of New York city and Los Angeles, Cal. For its size, the Church library is without doubt the most valuable collection of rare books ever brought together. The elaborate catalogue under way for several years, and just nearing completion at Mr. Church's death, is in seven imperial octavo volumes, printed on Van Gelder paper made especially for the work in Holland, and with hundreds of reproductions of title pages. It cost upwards of thirty thousand | dollars. The price paid for the collection has not been made public by either the pur- chaser or the seller. When the collection was first offered for sale it was held at a million and a quarter dollars, and this sum | was given in the newspapers as the pur- chase price now. It may be stated, on good authority, that the sum paid by Mr. Hunt- ington was approximately eight hundred thousand dollars, and, although this sum 1s a considerable advance upon the cost of the library to Mr. Church (exclusive of inter- est charges), it must be regarded as a low price. Mr. Huntington already owns a large and important library (he was the largest buyer at the Henry W. Poor sales, taking about one-third of the entire collec- tion), and, if he retains the Church books and manuscripts, it will place his library very near the head among private libraries of the world. Mr. Church was, during a quarter century, the buyer of many of the rarest books, within his lines of collect- ing, that came upon the market. By the dispersal at auction of the Barlow and Ives libraries and the breaking up privately of the Kalbfleisch and Lefferts collections (and from other sources) he was able to bring together a collection of rare Ameri- cana such as would have been supposed im- possible, ranking, for rarity and condition, though not in number of volumes, with the John Carter Brown and Lenox libraries. By the purchase of the Rowfant library, he put his Shakespeareana at the head of American collections, though in this depart- ment it is probably now surpassed by Mr. Folger’s collection. Mr. Hoe, at the time of his death, had printed, in an edition of one hundred cop- ies only, a catalogue of his printed books, forming fifteen volumes. A catalogue of his wonderful collection of illuminated manu- scripts was in preparation. Since his death this has been completed and printed. The volume describes upwards of two hundred and fifty manuscripts, ecclesiastical and classical, illustrating the art of the calli- grapher, illuminator, and miniaturist from about 1200 till nearly the present day. A selection of seventy of these manuscripts }will be sold at the twelfth session of the first Hoe sale, Monday evening, May 1. We have already noted the famous Pembroke | Hours, perhaps the most valuable of the Iil- luminated manuscripts. In this first sale is also included the almost equally important manuscript known as the Charles VI Mis- This is a fine manuscript of the four- made for Charles VI of zal jteenth century,

Page 23

April 13, 1911] The Nation France and given by him to King Henry V of England on the occasion of his mar- riage to Catherine de Valois, daughter of King Charles VI. It seems to have re- mained in the hands of Henry VI, Henry VII, and Henry VIII, but in the reign of the last-named it passed into the ownership of Jean Legrand and was sold by a certain Gilles in Antwerp for Legrand’s account to the monastery of Tongerloo, where it remained for nearly three hundred years. In 1869 it was acquired by a Paris book- seller, by whom it was sold to M. Didot, and came up at auction with his library in 1879. Q. Pope collection. It is very copiously illustrated, containing no less than 107 large miniatures, each (with a few excep- tions) having on the same page four small miniatures, thus making the total of 529. Another historic Book of Hours in the Hoe collection was made about 1477 for Anne de Beaujeu, daughter of Louis XI of France. This also is from the Didot col- lection. Thirteen other fine manuscript Books of Hours mostly of the fifteenth cen- tury are included in the first sale. Among notable secular manuscripts of continental origin are a fine Josephus in Latin, as- cribed to the thirteenth century; another Josephus, in French, of the fifteenth cen- tury; Horace’s “Opera”; Martial's “Epi- grammata’’; a late fifteenth century man- iscript of the French poetical version of Ovid's “Epistole Heroidum”’; and Pe- trarch’s “‘Sonette, Canzoni e Trionfi,” in a contemporary Florentine binding. Of sev- eral specimens of English execution Lyd- gate’s “Lyf of Our Lady” and an early manuscript of Richard de Bury’s ‘Philo- biblon” are of special interest. Several! il- luminated Persian manuscripts and a fine specimen of the work of Nicholas Jarry, a noted French calligraphist of the seven- teenth century, are also included. The Jarry manuscript is in an elaborate inlaid Trautz Bauzonnet binding, being No. 7 of twenty- six mosaic bindings executed by him. The French books, in point of actual numbers, form the largest section of the Hoe library, upwards of a thousand titles being scattered through the two volumes of the Catalogue of this first sale. These are first and other early editions of the French classical authors as well as many beautifully printed modern books issued in very limited editions, some containing water-color drawings. Almost all are in handsome bindings by French artists or by the Club Bindery. A copy of “La Tribu indienne,” a romance by Lucien Bona- parte, printed in 1799 but suppressed, is the only uncut copy of the three copies now known to exist. LIBRARIES IN NEW YORK STATE The State Education Department received reports last year from 1,345 libraries in this State, of which 710 are free circulating libraries, and 635 are limited in use to par- ticular institutions or associations. The stock of books reported in all the libraries was 10,094,246 volumes, and the total cir- culation for the year was 20,573,449 vol- umes. In the free circulating libraries there is a stock of 4,341,449 volumes, and the circulation in 1910 was 19,254,727 vol- umes. Compared with the figures reported @ year ago, there has been a gain of 39 Mr. Hoe acquired it with the Norton. in the number of libraries reporting, 137,021 in the number of volumes in stock, and 657,- 163 in the circulation. For the free librar- fes, the gain has been 21 in the number of libraries, 113,437 in the stock of books, and 506,880 in the circulation. These gains are not so great as have Leen reported in recent years, but they show that library expansion is still proceeding at a more rapid rate than the increase in population, and that such decreases as have recently been reported in a few of the cities of the State, and have been made the besis for discouraged comment, are purely local and exceptional. In estimating the significance of the gain reported, it must be borne in mind that this is the seven- teenth successive year in which gains have been shown, and that in this period free libraries in the State have increased in number from 238 to 710, in stock of books from 849,060 to 4,341,000, and in circulation from 2,293,000 to 19,254,000—a gain of 300 rei cent. in number of libraries, 500 per cent. in stock of books, and 850 per cent. in irculation. Even during the last five years there has been a gain of 100 in the number of libraries reporting, of 1,000,000 in the number of volumes, and 7,000,000 in circula- the of the in circulation from libraries enactment 1892 the grown six tion. Since present library free law times the more State. has repidly than the Of the 710 free libraries reporting this year, 462 are in direct relation with the Education Department, and are privileged to draw an annual grant of $100 each from the State for the of approved books, provided they apply the same amount of their own money for this purpose, The amount thus apportioned by the State last year was $32,915, divided among 370 li- braries which applied and qualified for the grant. The total amount of local taxation for the support of libraries was $1,471,022, population of purchase an increase above the previous year of $34,- 090. In addition to school libraries, of which are free to the general public, 281 libraries are now receiving local tax Of the 49 cities of the all Watervliet, and new of Lackawanna free libraries, and of these, 40 make an annual appropriation for library purposes. Of the 118 villages with a population of above 2,000 52 of Two some State, the public support except Cortland, city have or each, 92 have free libraries, which are local hundred half, of the libraries connected with the Th llages or hamlets of less Of the 451 incorpor- State, 231 supported by taxation and nineteen, or nearly one free State pertment are in v than 2,000 population provided ated villages of the are with free libraries and 220 are without such facilities. Outside of incorporated pla there is a population in the State of 1,500 0; for this population there is a total of free libraries Assuming that each of these libraries is available to as many as 1,000 people—a very liberal estimate, there is left a rural population of 1,400,000 en- tirely without library privileges Adding to this the population of incorporate places not having libraries, it will be seen that at least a million and three-quarters peo ple are without public library advantages The following libraries have completed and occupied new buildings during the year: Heermance Memoria! of Coxsackie, Normal School Library of Geneseo, Mt. Morris Free, Seward Park branch, New York city; Olean Public, Pleasant Valley 369 Free, Portville Free, of Sag Harbor, Margaret Reaney Memoria! of St Johnsville, Lake Free, David A. Howe Library of Wellsville of these Carnegie gift, and, among the 62 gifts recorded the past year, but two were from Mr. Carnegie. Numerous and conspicuous as the Carnegie gifts have Jermain Memoria! Saranac and Only one was a been, it is worthy of note that in this State, of York, of the 146 different places receiving gifts of buildings cutside Greater New the last seventeen years, only 31 were from Mr. Carnegie, while 115 were from other icnors, ’ *yr ] Correspondence THREE ARTISTS IN BOSTON. To THe Epiror oF THE NATION: Sin: There is at present in Boston an exhibition of paintings wort) more than local notice. When three artists, taking a gallery together, hang it with white and panel it with evergreen, and show but four- tcen of their works, their taste and reserve suggest stronger qualities The quotation from Kipling that heads their catalogue— There are nine and sixty ways Of constructing tribal lays, And every single one of them Is right-— is both a promise of independence and a challenge to criticism. On examination, the e: hibition by Messrs. Hopkinson, Prender- gast, and Pepper shows strength and in- cividuality in all three men. Mr. Charles Hopkinson’s five’ pictures cover a wide range in treatment. That his technique is sober and even old-fashioned shows especially in his two portraits. These are splendidly direct studies of personality, without a trick or a flourish, indeed, with- out an accessory in the composition, to dis- tract attention from the characters of the sitters. His Marine is but rocks and surf and sky; its lighting is of the late after- ncon; the work is as sober as the portraits, but shows in its haze of color and its truth the flash of the less crests, the suggestion of wider powers. the Arranging Flowers color; the but the the scattered and curtain, take all the always in harmony. of distance, and in rest- These are set free in remaining two pietures, is a study in simple at nasturtiums before her the pure composition is erough, woman in white the table, the dell, among them but Island is scarcely a se green chair Japanese notes The upper or the gamut, Wonderful ine—it has too much Jandscape; is ¢ for it foreground ond mar- arcely a landscape, much of sea, the the of a pine; below this stretch the tops of trees still the has too Into sweeps bough in varied green; further down li this light. pale tessing waters of a and beyond up the islet, shadows of the lighted crags, and tl vaters them, are dark rich, the strong of the picture; the isle is crowned trees whose autumnal foliage gle oftened by the the inlet sland cove, sunset bla lying in the roch KS rises The prrple; are below and notes wth ws evening but is dis- To the left is hurbor, and beyond the limit further shore. in the tance from the lies a broad water, at wi the » unusual in its effect the shows, faint in The line as well as color the middle childhood’s strange the ;oRe haze, composition dia- ad- centre upon island in tance, a place for

Page 24

3870 ventures This quiet and yet strongly inaginative piece forms the fit centre to the four paintings which flank it Mr. Maurice Prendergast is more indi- vidual in technique than either of his friends, and more certain to rouse opposi- on, if not resentment Yet his mosaics ot color patches melt at a slight distance inte the required effects of light and air, of people and of natural objects One must not inquire too closely the sex or the age or the employment of his small figures; but with him a crowd is a crowd, a building is clid. and sea and sky are real. The recent advance his revealed by the presence of an earlier subdued and of tapestry quality beside the «lowing color paintings Mr. hee command of atmosphere and distance. His most pleasing work is Brimstone Cor- in which the handling of the old Park the snow-clad Common, the turrying people, and the smoky sky, is mannered than in the other pictures. fhough Mr. Prendergast is a little hevond us, his virtues are very real The special quality which marks Mr. Pep- per’s four figure pieces, beyond the interest in color which is characteristic of all three and which does much to unify the ex- in work is piece, his recent ol ner Street church, less often men hibit, is a peculiar absorption in the per- acnality of the sitter. In these life studies the pleasurable sweep of line shows a dif- ferent method of attack from Mr. Hopkin- son's directness; nevertheless, Mr. Pepper also centres Interest in the face. This is shown especially in his group of three, of which each serves to emphasize the others The lady with the veil, who seems to add charm of mind to charm of person, contrasts with the Widow who reveals the devasta- tions, the still present power, of grief. Be- tween them, the little Jap, even as she pe es across the narrow field of her pic- ture, appeals with child-like eyes and half quivering lip for your patience while she hastens on your errand It is quite worth noting that Mr. Pepper, with no attempt to tell a story—for these three pictures are but figure and bare background, nothing eds in thus drawing attention to t} mental trait of his subject mr three artists. of whom Mr. Hop kinson shows the broadest range, Mr. Pren lergast the most uncompromising methods, Mr Pepper th most persuasive appeal, } by different ways, reached different nite of view All the more interesting is then. to s their works together, and to find that each of the fourteen paintings lea ita distinct Impression This is not because of their eamall number; I write at two day Interval after viewing the col- lection, and without a note taken at the t e, which gives plenty of chance to forget the Inelignificant If, then, each ts worth remembering, perhaps indeed “every single of them la right.’ ALL FRENCH ‘ ord Manes March 10 FIRST RAISING OF THE STARS AND STRIPES To THe Eprrorn or Tus NATION: Sik I note with considerable interest the letter tn your tasue of March 9, entitled the “First Ralsing of the Stars and Stripes.” and signed “American.” This is a the writer has taken a which he has 7. which of sublect in good deal interest and Prendergast | The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 studied for a long time. There are very few facts regarding the early history of the flag that can be proved. One statement made by “American” is incorrect—that the flag was carried for the first time in the battle of Brandywine. It is generally ac- cepted that the skirmish at Cooch’s Bridge in Delaware on September 3, 1777, was the first engagement in which the American flag was used after it had been publicly proclaimed as the national flag. To mark this site a monument was there unveiled with appropriate ceremonies, September 3. 1901. But unquestionably the Stars and Stripes | were in use in the army long before Con- |gress officially adopted them. A portrait of Gen. Washington after the Trenton, December, 1776, by Capt. Charles Willson Peale, the commander of a company | in this battle, which is supposed to have been painted immediately after the battle and which was, until recently, on exhibition in the Senate Wing of the National Cap tol, shows a flag with a blue field and white stars arranged in a circle. Another por- trait of Washington Before the Battle of by John Trumbull an aide-de- camp to Washington, shows the American flag with thirteen stars. This would prove that the Stars and Stripes were really used by Gen. Washington before they were officially adopted. Now, we know that Washington was en- camped at Middlebrook Heights near Bound Brook the month of June, 1777, and that Congress officially adopted the Na- tional flag on June 14, 1777, the exact word- ing taken from a fac-simile of the Journal of the Continental Congress, reading: Resolved: That the flag of the United States be 13 stripes alternate red and white, that the Union be 13 stars white in a blue field representing a new constella- tion Princeton, This being an order affecting the Military Department, it according to all military regulations, be at once transmitted to army headquarters, which we all know at that time at Camp Middlebrook. Allowing time for the courier to reach headquarters, “American” seems correct in that the Stars and Stripes were raised not more than two days after June 14, the route from Philadelphia being open as history records. The flag was already in of the army head- quarters as has been shown. There a very interesting book about the flag, entitled “The Evolution of the would, were his statement 1777, possession is American Flag,” compiled by George Can- by, a grandson of Betsy Ross, and pub- lished In Philadelphia in 1909. RUSSELL E. WATSON. New Brunswick, N. J., March 13. To THe Eprror or THe NATION: Sin: The date of the first raising of the Stars and Stripes, a matter referred to by ‘American” in of March 9, is hard to settle with certainty. The first dis- continental flag was raised over in Cambridge January 1, 1776; but, of course, this was not the Stars and Stripes, for the colonies had not as yet decided that separa- tion from England was necessary and un- avoidable. This standard introduced the stripes of the present flag, but retained the crosses of St. George and St. Andrew on a blue ground in the corner, the whole your issue tinctive Washington's headquarters on Battle of | implying the surviving acknowledgment of the royal power, with the appearance of a new nation. When independence had elim- inated the royal element, the crosses were replaced (1777) by stars as at present. This national flag—thirteen stripes, red and white, and thirteen stars on a blue field— was adopted by the Continental Congress on June 14, 1777; but, for some reason, the adoption seems not to have been officially promulgated until September 3, 1777. (See Harper’s Encyclopedia of United States History, Vol. III, p. 383.) It seems hardly probable, therefore, that this national flag was officially raised over the army head- quarters before that date. This supposi- tion, inherently probable, is confirmed by the statement of the late John Fiske in his “History of the United States,” p. 227. Describing the march of St. Leger down the Mohawk Valley and his siege of Fort | Stanwix, he says: That same day (August 6, 1777), the gar- rison at Fort Stanwix made a sortie and sacked a part of St. Leger’s camp, captur- ing five British flags. They hoisted these flags upside down over their fort and raised above them a rude flag made of scraps of a blue jacket and a white shirt, with some bits of red flannel. Congress had in June adopted the national banner of stars and stripes, and this was the first time it was ever hoisted. W. H. WHITING, JR. Hampden-Sidney, Va., March 14, THE EXCHANGE OF PROFESSORS WITH GERMANY. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Will you permit me to express my concurrence with your view of the purposes and methods appropriate to the exchange of professors with Ger- many, and to say that it accurately represents the plan as originally proposed? A strictly academic interchange of instruc- tion, an acceptance of the visitor on both sides as a member of the teaching staff with no exceptional place or mission, a be- lief that each university had something to teach which the other might wish to learn— this, and nothing more, was the scheme wel- comed by Harvard University in 1905, and the consistent maintenance of this view is essential, if we are either to get competent scholars to go to Germany or to command the confidence of scholars there. On one point, however, I venture to take a more rigid view of the case than your edi- torial suggests. You remark that “the es- tablishment of the exchange was primarily a peace measure; they were to be the un- official ambassadors, who, free from the trammels of diplomacy, could smooth out misunderstandings.” That seems to me a dangerous extension of the visiting pro- fessor’s functions, and precisely the peril which the exchange has encountered. To fancy one’s self an “unofficial ambassador” is almost inevitably to become involved in afiairs of the court and the chancelleries, with which one’s mission has nothing to do. A German professor does not come here as lan “ambassador.” He comes to lecture on | Greek or music, and if international peace | is promoted, it will be simply by his know- | ing us better and believing in us more. The |same limitation of function should be ob- | served in Germany. You justly commend | the services of Professor Richards and Pro- ‘fessor Davis. They were, however, not

Page 25

April 13, 1911] “smoothing out misunderstandings,” but lec- turing on chemistry and geography; and the opportunities which they had of meeting distinguished personages were as incidental te their work as an evening at the opera. Academic interchanges may be no slight contribution to the peace of nations, but this must occur, not by conscious intention, but by strengthening the bonds of scholarship and by teaching the unity of truth. Harvard University has committed itself to the pro- motion of this strictly academic aim; and the Prussian Ministry of Instruction — where, under the arrangement with Harvard University, the choice of visiting professor is annually made from a submitted list—has again expressed its agreement with this view by selecting as its guest for 1911-12 Theo- bald Smith, professor of comparative path- ology. FRANCIS G. PEABODY. Cambridge, Mass., April 6 TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: While fully sympathizing with the sentiments expressed in your article on “The Exchange of Professors” (Nation, March 30), I should like to draw your at- tention to two or three points. First, one of “the two American professors who have been in Berlin this winter” is a German, born and bred; secondly, the Harvard ex- change professor is selected not by the “Harvard authorities”’—though doubtless in consultation with them—but by a high offi- cial, presumably the Minister of Public In- struction, in Berlin; third, the notion of a college “forbidding” its professors to con- duct their social lives as may seem to them good appears, in Cambridge at least, a little comic. The right to be a cuss@d fool Is safe from all devices human; It's common, as a general rule, To every man that’s born of woman L. W. HOPKINSON. Cambridge, Mass., April 2. FROM CAUSE TO EFFECT. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Your editorial in a recent number, entitled “The Human Factor in Medicine,” is more a criticism on Bernard Shaw than a disposal of the assertion that the present tendency in medicine is to kill us with“serum cultures” and hypodermic in- jections. Within the past few days I have heard two men of average intelligence re- gret that the Flexner serum had been used in the case of the doctor who recently died. Thirty years ago there were no “Rockefeller Institutes.” Brown Sequard was criticised as a dangerous enthusiast because of his “reckless” use of subtle vegetable poisons. Yet his remedies were administered through the stomach, where their virulence was im- mediately modified by chemical action. Now it is well known that these same poisons, when administered subcutaneously, in in- finitesimal quantities, have sometimes pro- ‘duced alarming symptoms and even death; while in other instances many times the quantity has produced no dangerous effect. It must be admitted that the difference was in the patient and not in the drug. Dr. Snow may be too severe and Bernard Shaw too sarcastic, but this is a question that is agitating the public mind perhaps | more than is generally suspected. Various | serums differ in their mode of preparation, The Nation | but all depend for their so-called curative properties upon the poison that is in them. No doctor in New York would risk injecting 1-100 grain of atropine into his own system, for while he might do it in perfect safety he knows that no two systems are alike, and he knows that no chemical combination is absolutely a success. The ordinary medi- cal practitioner's knowledge of chemistry does not seem to be large, but he knows that prussic acid does not kill every dog, even in big doses. If doctors were all well balanced and cautious men, the danger would be less, but their professional attitude is largely influenced by their temperament; and I think it will readily be conceded that the medical fraternity has not gained any- thing by its appearance in court, as “expert evidence. If pain and increased tempera ture are but symptoms, why should the doc- tor seek to destroy them before they have developed into any recognized type of dis- ease? J. E, DuBois. Ogdensburg, N. Y¥., April 2 “PRACTICALLY.” To THE EpirorR OF THE NATION: Sir: Iam glad to see in my last Nation (February 9%) the letter of Professor Mc- \Knight on “Commercial English,” and that of Professor Hall on “ ‘Pessimistic’ and ‘Optimistic.’” I have long desired to see such a treatment of practical and practi- cally as Fitzedward Hall would have given them, if he had happened to notice the impropriety with which those words are used, perhaps by all writers! I am led to such notice of it as I can give, in the absence of books and notes, by an unusually strained use of the poor word in a leading article in the same issue of the Nation, p. 135, col. 2, line 38: “What practically happens .. is,” ete The usual misuse of the word is for nearly or almost. 1 think the dictionaries recognize it as a use, with no hint of its impropriety. The Standard Dictionary rec- ognizes enthuse, with no hint, if 1 remem- ber aright, of its vulgarity (possibly ‘col loquial”’). This perhaps raises the ques- tion: What is the function of a dictionary as to words that creep into the language from infected sources? Ought it to wel- come allnew-comers alike, or draw a line be- tween those invited by need and intruders? Proposition is not needed for anything but something proposed, and practically is not needed for not quite. Is a dictionary not out of its function as much in recognizing vulgar words as valid as in the other ex- treme of not recognizing bad usage at all? Or what usage is it that makes words? The usage of business makes business words of course; but can the usage of every writ- ;er under the sun make practically a good word for almost, or proposition for man or circumstance or enterprise or thing? JOUN E. Powers Palermo, Sicily, March 1 {The Nation agrees with Mr. Powers in regard to the common misuse of practically for virtually. As a matter of fact, the word in this particular in- stance was used correctly as meaning in practice. Ep. Tue Nation.) ve ~ hed, Literature BOOKS ON JAPAN. Behind the Screens: An Englishwoman’'s Impressions of Japan. By Evelyn Adam. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $1.50 net Highways and Homes of Japan. By Lady Lawson. With a frontispiece and 59 illustrations from photographs taken by the author. New York: Fred- erick A. Stokes Co. $3.75 net. Japan for a Week. By A. M. Thompson With numerous illustrations from photographs. New York: John Lane Co. $1.50. Vilitary Japan. The Japanese Army and Navy in 1910. By J. C. Balet. Translated from the French by C. A. Parry, B.A Yokohama: Kelly @ Walsh The Japanese Empire and its Econom Conditions. By Joseph d'Autremer, Lecturer at the School of Oriental Languages, Paris. Translated from the French. With a map and 20 illus- trations. New York: Chas. Scrib ner’s Sons. $3 net, The Political Development of Japan, 1867-1909. By George Etsvujiro Uye- hara, B.A. (Wash.), D.Se. (Lond.). New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $3 net The first three of these half-dozen books on Japan recall the kind of criticism and appreciation we used to get a score of years ago, when the globe-trotter But there is a difference: the traveller needs to be discovered the country. more carefully equipped now than then Yet even with his increased accuracy it is doubtful if if he hopes for readers. he conveys a truer idea of the real Ja- pan than he did before she had acquired a navy. There remains ever the intan gible something that separates’ the Oriental and the Occidental. It effec- tually obscures even the simplest state- ment; it misleads the best intentioned critic whose sympathy and long experi- ence with the people of another world are incontinently betrayed by alien stan- dards. A type of this sort is the author of “Behind the Screens.” She has a shrewd wit and some knowledge of the language. She is cheerful and generally charitable in her observations upon a people who are passing through the awk- ward age of a nation in transition. She gives us a clever and decidedly read able book. It is doubtful, however, if much is gained on either side by print- ing the “wholesome truths” she hag to tell, or by pressing the analogy of the individual and the nation; there are re- semblances between the two, but they count for little as a basis of political estimate or reform—and the political relationships of Japan bulk rather large in her pages. A grewcome tale is told of a poor old couple procuring from the . aaa

Page 26

372 War Office the release of an only son from military service during the late war. After being summoned one morn- ing to the Office to get his papers the boy's body was delivered at nightfall at his father’s door with the laconic message, “He will remain at home now.” Stories of this sort are floating about every club and hotel piazza in the East. They are sometimes founded on fact, but they are almost always untrue. Does it serve any decent or honorable pur- pose to repeat them in print? Lady Lawson's “Highways and Homes of Japan” is a duller recital, but more instructive and better worth a place on a library shelf. She has filled her note books with items small and great gath- ered upon two visits to the Empire and digested with considerable care. There is little criticism and abundant sympa- thy shown in her minute examination of the social structure, but we are never for a moment relieved from the stan- dards of good old England. “What a contrast,” she exclaims, after seeing “one fat and flabby wrestler pushed out of the ring by another even fatter and more flabby”—‘“what a contrast to Bu- ropean professionals, who are trained down until nothing is left but bone and muscle!” One recalls the contrast ob- served by another Englishwoman at the theatre between the domestic life of Cleopatra's court and “that of our own gracious sovereign.” A. M. Thompson is an editor and dra- matic critic who is not ashamed to say that he went to “Japan for a Week” to get local color for setting a new play in London, and thought an account of his trip worth putting into his paper. The letters thus engendered were obvi ously written for an uncritical group of readers. He is willing to say what he thinks, and to say it frankly. He did not like the geishas, or the inus, or the cooking, or the smells; he “came to seek the capital of fairyland and discov- of ered an Oriental Manchester.” course, if Mr. Thompson did not like a thing it was not good. “Military Japan” is something more than the soldier's handbook which the title implies; it is the initial portion of a larger work by a French officer long resident in the country, the remainder of which will be devoted to the econom ic resources and social life of the Em pire. The information compressed in this little volume is more complete than any to be found elsewhere in a Euro pean language, and on this account it will be invaluable for reference to the atudent of Japanese policy. Among many penetrating observations of the author two are worth noting: despite an appearance of perfect solidarity in the governmental machine, the two feudal clans of Choshu and Satsuma which led the revolt against the Toku- gawa in 1867 still maintain a selfish and exclusive control over the army and sno [ Vol. 92, No. 23895 navy. In the antipathy shown by these | clans toward each other and toward the rest of the provinces, the author sees a menace of future strife which | may in time repeat the medizval strug- gle between Taira and Minamoto; “for | it must not be supposed,” he adds, “that this absolute preponderance of the two. clans is accepted joyfully and without jealousy by the rest of Japan. Attacks, though as yet timid ones, have been de- livered in Parliament, in the press, and in public meetings at this relic of feu- dalism, bambatsu seifu.” M. Balet’s sec- ond observation relates to the Japanese common soldier. He praises him for his implicit obedience and devotion to the politico-mystical faith in the im- perial divinity, qualites that have been “cleverly kept up and skilfully worked” by the authorities to accomplish great things in a short time; but the Japanese individual he describes as lacking in frankness and decision. “The man is formal, arrogant, addicted to excesses, rancorous, and vindictive. On the oth- ‘er hand, he loves reason and has a pro- found sense of justice.” This estimate by a considerate interpreter of Japan as she is to-day is suggestive, in view of his conviction that “the Japanese army, young, enthusiastic, and never having known defeat, is certainly preparing it-| self for new victories.” M. d’Autremer’s “Japanese Empire and its Economic Conditions” is a sober volume which has served a useful pur- pose as a work of reference for French students of Japan. It hardly seems worth putting into English when ac- count is taken of the numerous books of this sort already in our language. The volume amply furnished with statistics on the products, trade, and in- dustrial development of the country. It is only possible here to pass these by with a nervous twinge of gratitude that we do not have to stop and verify the figures, but confidence in their proba- ble accuracy is not increased by occa- sional slips which the author has made in historical statements, such as giving 1852 for the date of Perry's expedition, referring to the of Japanese ports to foreigners down to 1617,” and to Kyoto as the first permanent capital of the Empire. The book has the same inadequate map that appears in the vol- ume on Japan in the Story of the Na- : is ‘closing tions series. Dr. Uyehara’s “Political Development of Japan,” submitted as a doctor’s thesis to the University of London, is the most careful and comprehensive study that has yet appeared on the introduction of representative institutions into Japan. Though it is now twenty years since Nitobe began the series of historical | and economic studies on Japan issued | by successive Japanese students trained | in foreign universities, this essay may | still be counted as among the first fruits of that intellectual harvest from which | ‘and solidarity of the nation.” much is yet to be expected in these profitable fields of research. The au- thor of this volume is not quite so hap- py in his preliminary discussion of “the nation and its political mind” as in pre- senting the political situation as it is at present. He need not be blamed for being less of a philosopher than an his- torian, but a reviewer has a right to inquire why he declares that “a retro- spect of many centuries furnishes no trace of civil wars or of struggles which might have threatened the unity The of Japanese history feudal period |strikes the Western observer as having been singularly contentious as compar- ed with other states of the same de- gree of culture. The genesis of the constitutional movement in Japan is generally dated from the promulgation of the “Charter | Oath” of April 6, 1868, at the beginning of the present Emperor’s reign. Dr. Uyehara makes it plain that this oath was inspired by the determination of a few leading statesmen of the period to undertake a national reorganization for preserving the independence of the coun- try and freeing it from foreign aggres- sion—not, as has been alleged, to check- mate the Western daimyos in their at- tempt to obtain supreme power. A com- parison of this crisis with the barons’ uprising against King John of England is inappropriate, therefore, because in Japan the impulse toward change came from above, not from the people. And this has been the process from the in- ception of Japan’s political reconstruc- tion, where liberty is bestowed and the political struggle, such as it is, remains a clash of feudal clans. The peace of the country has been preserved by a supreme and _ divinely established throne, always able to silence agitators by sheer weight of prestige, but not in any real sense responsible to the peo- ple. This feature of the Japanese gov- ernmental system is scarcely understood abroad. It is a mask of representative institutions, not responsible government as accepted in the West. Here is where Japan still halts on her way from pure autocracy to a genuine parliamentary régime: According to the traditional political ideas of the Japanese, the chief duty of the ministers of state was to keep the coun- try for the Emperor and to promote the happiness and prosperity of his subjects. To fail in this duty and to allow the Em- peror to be cognizant of the dissatisfaction and suffering of his beloved subjects was considered disloyal on the part of the min- isters and deserving of hara kiri. It was, and still is, imagined by the masses that the wish of the Emperor to make his sub- jects happy and contented is akin to that of a kind father toward his children. The matter is one of great interest to ‘students of government because Japan \is the first country outside Christendom ‘to assume the machinery of European

Page 27

April 13, 1911] administrations. The machinery once set up, it remains to be seen whether an Oriental people can work it. At present it should seem that Japan was far from comprehending the true idea of constitutionalism. The “oligarchic statesmen” in power adopt the methods of Walpole and of Tammany to procure their ends; the voters take bribes. This, the author declares, is not because they have not enjoyed the franchise long enough to understand its use. Corrup-| tion, instead of decreasing, has stead- ily increased under the constitutional régime, and has not been checked by the passage of a Corrupt Practices Act in 1901. With this also is found the unwholesome symptom of abstention, the increase’in the proportion of voters who stay away from the polis having risen from 11.72 per cent. in 1898 to 28.56 per cent. in 1908. A tendency is noted toward the development of professional politicians, rings, and bosses, and with these has come the inevitable increase in the expense of standing for election, so that it now costs a successful candi- date about 3,000 yen—a heavy burden when the wealth of the country is con- sidered. “Yet the seat for which they pay so dearly yields them very little power; some members of the House never take part in a debate during the whole of their parliamentary life, but simply sit and vote as directed by the whips of their party. The worst part of the bargain, however, is the uncertain length of their parliamentary existence. It is limited to four years, but at any’ time the House may be dissolved at the fiat of the bureaucratic statesmen in power.” But the fault need not be supposed to lie in a lack of intelligence on the part of the voter or in a low state of public morality; in both of these respects Ja- pan is probably as well off as America. It remains for her to finish her task and remove the remaining traces of feudalism and autocracy by making the government really responsible to the will of the people. CURRENT FICTION. The Broad Highway. By Jeffery Farnol. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. The American publishers of this tale have trumpeted it as a masterpiece by a new author; and the English press notices furnished from the same source show that the book has been favorably, if not judicially, received in London. One critic declares that it is “more fas- cinating and even more human than ‘Lorna Doone,’ ” a second rates the story- teller with Dumas, a third thinks him like Dickens, and a fourth (that well. known critical authority, the Sports- man) traces his derivation to “Fielding or Sir Conan Doyle,” Addison, and Steele. All of which would indicate that the exuberant pressman is not an exclu- The Nation ' sively American genius. The Sportsman further declares this novel to be “a work of art by an unconscious artist.” Nothing more patently untrue could be said of this book. Its “ante scriptum” quite frankly confesses a self-conscious origin. And Mr. Farnol’s real model seems to have escaped the ken of the above-cited commentators. There is a romantic story, and a sufficiently wild one, but where the book most distinctly has merit it owes most to George Bor- row. The simpler adventures of the road, the colloquies with tinkers, coachmen, and the like, the Scriptural tang of narrative and dialogue, all owe their favor and inspiration to Laven- gro. As for the more conventionally ro- mantic part of the book, the quality of the incident oddly antedates the setting. That is, the action takes place in nine- teenth-century England, but the atmos phere is that of the 'sblood period, the day of smallsword and periwig. Peter Vibart, the hero, is a man of good blood and education, suddenly thrown upon his own resources by the eccentric will of an uncle. A clause of the will gives him the nominal chance of winning a for- tune by marrying a certain town beauty and toast. The chance is also open to a wild cousin, Peter’s double in appear ance, and antithesis in character. Peter takes to the road, becomes a blacksmith and, of course, in due time, brings the wild cousin to confusion and carries off the lady and the fortune. The plot is developed ingeniously enough, and the incidents are not more improbable than ordinary in the popular romance. But the charm of the book lies in its Bor rovian touches. The Prodigal Judge. By Vaughan Ker ter. Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Co. Such a string of adventures as that which forms this story ought, if rightl handled, to hold the reader's interest securely. Back in the days of Andrew Jackson, we read, a small boy of un certain origin, Hannibal Wayne Haz ard, is left by the death of his pro tector, a mum old general, living on a huge estate in North Carolina, to the care of the mountaineer, Bob Yancey. Enters at once Capt. Murrell, the vil- lain, sues in vain for the hand of Betty Malroy, an heiress from Memphis, and then tries to possess himself of Han nibal,.who is evidently the key to some mystery. There follow: An attempt at kidnapping; a country law trial; flight by Hannibal and Yancey, with Murrell in pursuit; a drunken encounter at an inn where Yancey is all but killed; Han nibal’s escape from Murrell to the com- pany of the two middle-aged, bibulous pals, the judge and Solomon; the judge's imprisonment and jail-breaking; the mi- gration of the three to Memphis; the ar- lrival of Murrell, and the kidnapping of 37 Hannibal and Betty; the rescue by lovers; the solving of the mystery by the judge regenerate; the seizing of the fortune. Here is stuff for a “Treasure Island,” for a capital detective story, for a “Can dide,” for an “Ivanhoe,” to go no far- ther. Our quarrel with “The Prodigal Judge” is that its author has given us something like all of these combined; he has not seen that to animate such a mass of incident, it is choose and stick to some one fictional type. The story has no informing em. phasis, and is hence without literary meaning. It is kept from being a close: necessary to ly-reasoned mystery story by several loose ends in the plot—why, for in stance, after the boy has testified to Murrell’s murderous assault upon Yan- cey, is nothing done about it? So, too, the author has not the audacity for pure adventure, being too much ¢oncerned with prosy preparation. He has no tal- ent for sketching historical background of the sort which gives reasonableness to highly wrought action. And as for his satire or character-drawing, except (which are in it ing a few good touches in a rise work of such length), above the judge, who is picturesque, solely be of a Falstaff, being an adult bald head and with a notable full -lengta profile evitable dces not his chief creation cause superficial resemblance to “sport,” with a Fortunata. By Marjorie Patterson, New York: Harper & Bros. After readingthis book and upon think ing it over in cold blood—a temiperatt not hindered by the reading —or re flects, “What a delightful novel the au- thor might write! What a hopelessly, sordidly worldly one she ha itten!” Bitter, cynical, vicious, one may not eall t, even though its scenes are al? thes or they are given as by a note-taker and not a sympathizer Untidy it sel dom is. Amusing at points it may be found; conspicuously clever in its tool ork it is beyond a doubt. A touch, an epithet, a gesture, and a portrait is made manifest. A word, a line, and the Italian scene or the English hearth stands forth in high relief. The en ment of mere cleverness finds here its satisfaction. Enjoyment of any other sort turns away baffled. The story treats of an Italian, American-tinctured family and its struggle for life. Life in the case of Fortunata is interpreted to mean an advantageous marriage. With her half-sister Antonia it is a combination of religion and of an open liaison with her husband’s brother. The American in- valid mother of Fortunata asks only to take her medicines in peace. The Eng- lishman seeks a healthy wife and a gen- tleman’s career; the Italian men their drink, their pleasures, and their quar- rels. The horrible old princess aunt, who dominates them all, finds her life

Page 28

374 in bullying the family circle, in prac- tising trickery, with less finesse than we should have expected, and in equip- ping her favorite Fortunata with every weapon that unscrupulous worldliness can devise. Fortunata, apt pupil, is helped by having only a rudimentary heart. Her early tribulations seldom reach a deeper depth than ennui and pecuniary embarrassment. She fights valiantly to reach social heights, dis- carding many a lover, each one for the At hand Lord sake of one on a higher step. some, rich, English Trevers she pauses, long enough to mar inarticulate, ry him, and still plots on, her aim now dizzy diplomatic heights for her hus band. The publishers call Fortunata an Italian Becky Sharp. She does in deed belong among the professional self seekers of fiction, and the book among the portrait of all sorts and conditions of degradation. But it is cal culated to make one do a tardy justice sigh for galleries to Dobbin, and _ positively Amelia By G. E. Theo L. C. Page A Captain of Raleigh's. dore Roberts. Boston & Co Mr dent tiful girl taking passage, under the name Roberts's story lacks neither inc} nor action, and certainly a beau and guise of her twin brother, on board a sailing for Newfound land in the stormy days that immediate vessel bound ly succeeded Sir Walter Raleigh's execu tion, makes a situation dear and famil iar to true lovers of romance. There is fighting, too, kidnapping, hair-breadth duels in which the ugly and in gentleman-adventurer escapes, significant proves himself a marvellous swordsman and a generous victor; a hero, half pirate, hali gallant soldier, and sailor; and there is atso, of course, the sort of love story which is part and parcel of romance rhe Devon fishermen have been less used than most colonial material, and the book is smoothly enough written, but Mr. Roberts kills his effects by describ ing them, and the only real people are gentleman-adventurer and an_ old ship-master. In a word, the spirit of romance that can kindle into life hack neyed situations and well-worn types is the lacking and nothing Is given us in its place ingela’s Quest. By Lilian Bell New York Duffield & Co, The trembling fugitive from convent thralldom hastily pulled down her im perfectly adjusted wig, and the unsus Pinkerton detective, who was outlook for her wealth of red- gold tresses, from the car.” Then the friendly young reporter sit- ting next, who had given her the tip, | summed up the literary value of the sit- vation “IT feel.” said he, “that Laura lean Libby ought to hear of this.” Be- pecting on the “passed ion [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 The Nat | yond this two-edged comment there is nothing in this piece of melodrama to suggest the seasoned observer and quiet recorder of “The Love Affairs of an Old Maid.” The nature of Angela's quest and the degree of its success may be inferred from the final scene. It takes place on the “shining deck” of a private yacht off the coast of Central America, while in a small boat below, half-drowned and both ankles broken, lies the villain who has “cheated the hangman for thirty years”: The band, spent and broken wreck of her hus- white-haired, unkempt, and clad in filthy rags, tottered across the deck. . {He had been “railroaded to a madhoyse” thirteen years before to a day.] With a low ery Mrs. Cravanath held out her hands... and gathering him into her arms... spoke . . [She had been totally paralyzed for ten years.] At this, Angela, who had rot been told of her father’s identity, ran forward and flung herself on her knees by the side of her reunited parents, her long ropes of auburn hair sweeping the deck, as rapturously into their glorified aloud . she gazed faces When Half-Gods Go. By Helen Reimen- snyder Martin. New York: The Cen- tury Co. The highly improbable in fiction calls loudly for the highly plausible. This has hardly been attained by Mrs. Mar- tin in her study of the artistic tempera- ment. The story in its main lines is not incredible. The blameless divisibil- ity of artists’ affections, the pained com- of clear-eyed wives, the high intent of beautiful, meddlesome souls, deceitful wiles of chivalry are fair game for the fiction-hunter. It is the performance, not the plan, that in spite of a natural manner, has brought the story close to caricature. The bride of a music professor confides to a woman friend in a series of letters the story of her days. She and her husband begin by being ideally happy. They work to- gether in a conservatory of music and live with his colorless mother and high- ly-tinted brother, a man of Rochester- like manners which conceal the usual brain and heart. To this family group enters Dorothea, of musical genius and pliance the soulful philosophies, who embraces the | double task of teaching at the conserva- tory and of uplifting Edith and Robert to her own high plane of thinking. And here is the place where plausibility be- gins to flutter its wings—pauses long enough to see Dorothea, still in the mis- sionary attitude, help herself to an un- due share of Robert; hears Edith call Dorothea “magnetic, gifted, womanly, lovable, and good’; hears her declare that she should have a poor opinion of Robert if he didn’t fairly worship her— but does not take actual flight till chased away by the sheer tiresomeness of Dorothea. It is not feasible to fancy any one, least of all an airy charmer [like Robert, with a soul scornfully above the obvious, sitting spellbound by her | platitudes. Brother Eliot presently takes a hand, arranging in his clear- |sighted way to save his brother and sis- ter-in-law by diverting to himself Doro- |thea’s affections; the which having obtained in embarrassing degree, since he did not in the least want them, he hands back to Dorothea in the pres- ence of the others. Dorothea makes an exit from the room “in one swift move- ment,” calling herself correctly but in- adequately “a selfish fool.” Robert re- tires to a sanatorium and to an oppor- tune death. Edith endures a few months of disquietude, after which oc- curs the arrival of the god in the person of Eliot. It now appears that she was the only woman to whom he had ever given a thought. The reader, in spite \of Eliot’s early manner, has suspected him from the first; ever since the mo- ment when he had said to Edith at the |piano, “Your playing so absolutely ex- |presses the feminine that it’s almost | weirdly alluring to the male, my dear!” RELIGIOUS PRAGMATISM. The Alchemy of Thought. By L. P. Jacks. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $3 net. Professor Jacks is best known in this country as the editor of the Hibbert Journal and the possessor of a spright- ly pen. He is also dean cf Manchester College, Oxford, and, in the world of philosophy, one of the leaders in the at- tack upon the “conceptualistic logic.” Though not himself technically a prag- matist, he shares the pragmatic spirit. The book is a collection of fifteen es- says, written at different times and on diierent subjects, and hence is some- what lacking in unity and even in con- tsistency. This, however, is less unfor- tunate than the fact that to a consider- able (and sometimes to a wearisome) jextent the essays overlap and repeat in several forms what had already been made sufficiently clear. If the book had heen written as a whole and from a sin- gle point of view it would probably have been only a third as long—and fully twice as readable. What unity the various essays have ‘they get from their common attack upon conceptualism. This attack starts |with a consideration of the philosophi- ‘cal attitude, which, we are repeatedly reminded, is not the only one. The uni- |verse may be regarded as a problem to be solved; but it is absurd, in fact it is ‘impossible, for us to regard it only ‘thus. Yet the insistence of philosophy |upon this view has made most of us |forget the other possible and actual ways of regarding the universe, and has resulted in much harmful skepticism and other unnecessary evils. One of the greatest of these evils is to be found in the usurpations of language. We con-

Page 29

April 13, 1911] Nation stantly forget that language is not the | only form of expression and that there are many things which by its nature it cannot express. Hence “we have con- fused the unsayable-by-us with the inex- plicable-in-itself, and drawn the Agnos- tic’s conclusion that things about which we can say nothing, can say nothing about themselves”: It is only after prolonged and often painful self-examination that any of us can realize the extent to which our minds are in bondage to words, to phrases, to formule. We are children of an age which spends the best energies of its life in an atmosphere of deferred fulfilment, con- tinually postponing the act of living to the work of mentally preparing to live. To this confidence in the power of language are also due many of the fail- ures of philosophy. For, in the opin- ion of our author, the static can never express the dynamic; and the deeper problems of a dynamic and changing world and of a developing and willing mind can never be solved or even expressed by means of words and concepts, which are essentially static. Hence the real aim of philosophy is not to photograph and reproduce the uni- verse—why should it care to do that even if it could?—but rather to enlarge and enrich it. by freeing us from the usurpations of language; and beyond that by enforc- ing the attitude of meditation: Reflective thought ends in the discovery that we do not explain any object until, like the poet, we “‘fade away” with it into the silent forest, far from the strife of tongues. Thus philosophy ends in the wonder with which it began—a state of mind which prefers to attend rather than to speak. This attack upon abstractions cul- minates in the somewhat grotesque es- say entitled “Devil's Island”—a symbol- ic interpretation of the abstract method in philosophy. The essay is not always as clever as it means to be, but its description of the “Omniscients” (or conceptualistic monists who know “the ALL as such”) will probably be long re- membered by every reader of the book. In a conversation with one of these Omniscients, the author, who has spent some years on Devil's Island, happens to refer to a small flower, a snapdragon, whereupon the Omniscient exclaims: What fool is talking of There are no snapdragons “Snapdragon? snapdragons? here.”’ “But what’s that you're looking at?” I cried, pointing to the flower in the cran- nied wall. “God-and-man,” he groaned; “God-and- man! Will the awful thing never depart?” He turned his eyes upon me and the utter vacancy of their look made me shud- der. Then in a flash the secret of his trouble was revealed to me. “He's at the universa] standpoint,"’ I thought, “and sees nothing. It’s the blindness of omniscience The Oneness of the One has got hold of him.” This it can do in part | “The Alchemy of Thought,” from which the book takes its name, is the title of one of the essays, and it ex- presses what, next to the insufficiency of conceptualism, is the main thesis of the book. This thesis is stated as follows: To interpret experience is to change it. To suppose that any physical or psychical object remains passive under our effort to understand it, and is the same when understood that it was before is as though one were to say that the bacon which a man eats for his breakfast is still bacon when it digested and used up in the nourishment of his brain. An interpretation is a kind of alchemy which, when applied to any object, transforms its character as a thing to be understood. A fact to be under- stood bears the same relation to the fact understood, both as to its sameness the man to the has been not and difference, boy. as bears Numerous illustrations of this pecu- liar form of transformation are given both in this essay and in the one en- titled “Self-defeating Theories.” Thus, “assuming Mill's explanation of the love of virtue to be true, my only chance of retaining that love is to remain in total ignorance of the explanation.” Likewise, if prediction in human affairs is possible, the prediction must not be made, for knowledge of it might very well defeat its fulfilment. But this pe culiar result of thinking is especially important in connection with the larger theories of metaphysics. For every at- tempt to express the nature of the uni verse makes the unTverse different, and hence no expression of it can ever be taken as final. This is no less true of pragmatism than of all its predecessors No philosophy, not even the most flu- ent and “dynamic,” can ever quite keep pace with the universe, which sarily is always at least one step ahead of the philosopher. Each new philosophy adds something to the universe, and is at the same time the product and expression of the uni- verse which it expresses. In this sense the universe is the great philosopher, and the various philosophies are the self-revelations of the one reality. Nor should the contradictions between oppos- ing systems be considered inconsistent with this view, for all these diverse philosophies are needed, if the richness of reality is to get expressed. In short, Professor Jacks is so thorough-going a pluralist that he has room even for mon ism as one of the many real aspects of his many-faced universe. No philoso- phy—not even pragmatism or pluralism —expresses all the truth. In the narrower field of human nature, no less than in the broader metaphysi- cal sphere, the principle of the Alchemy of Thought finds important applications. There can be no “Science of Man’’—no really scientific psychology, anthropol ogy, or ethics—both because man is es- neces- ~S —_— e3Ge sentially a living and willing being, while the terms of science must be static and fixed: and also the knowledge of such a scientific truth con- cerning him if known by him would enable him to thwart it, and thus make the so-called “truth” longer true. This fact, in our author's opinion, makes the modern attempts to “manipu- late man”—the “moral education” of children, the management of “lower races,” the attempted interference with Nature called “Eugenics”—as irration al as it is wicked: Man Man; of developed, compelled to serve a because very once no That ploy ed by is an inetrument to be that he is a thing to be exploited, turned to account em made use reformed purpose, by beings who call themselves “we'’; that “we'’ can raise him as though he were a bullock; that ‘‘we"’ can improve that can breed him on Mendelian or other though he Cochin that dictate his though hedge to be trimmed or to be confined—this illusion him as though he were a cart-horse; “we” principles as were a a li he a torrent ‘hina fowl; can mibits as were a we repeat, is our deep-seated Doubtless Prof. Jacks is right in say ing that the manipulation of man has often been carried much too far. Yet something might still be said for the rational guidance of the race by the race. Reason is not altogether inferior to instinct and impulse, and we are to some extent our brothers’ keepers. Nor is it altogether certain that even the conceptualistic logic is as black as it is sometimes painted. It in fact, be questioned whe.uer Professor Jacks or Bergson or James, for that matter sufficiently distinguishes between a prop er and an improper use of the concept. may, When properly employed, even by an “intellectualist,” it need not oust reality nor pretend to “copy” it. One should abstract, but It simply reality, its Why it a as well reality’ has never been made sufficiently clear. To be sure, it is not the reality it points to, but It should hardly be condemned for not be ing what it never set out to be. Taken in a rational sense, it is a tool only, but an absolutely indispensable tool essential is it, in fact, that all its crit ics perforce have to make constant use of it. Professor Jacks is among the num regard it as merely an useful shorthand expression. stands for and points to only apology being its function. cannot to as to a “static” point “dynamic” So ber. Hence one feels like asking him: If no statement in words can be strictly true of a “dynamic” universe, is this statement true? And it may strike the reader as somewhat anomalous that one should write a book of 350 pages on philosophy to prove that true philosophy is silent. In like manner, one feels a little uncertain how to take the author's philosophical position that no philosoph ical position is so true as to exclude ita contradictory. Is this true of the an- thor’s position, as well as of the others?

Page 30

376 and here one becomes a trifle bewildered. At any rate, it begins to look as though Professor Jacks might have added one more notable example to his list of “Self-defeating Theories.” The truth seems to be that the “conceptual- is a dangerous thing, consid- ering how very dead it is, and that one should reckon with it before writing a book on philosophy. If so istic logic” A Soldier's Recollections. Leaves from the diary of a Young Confederate. By Randolph H. McKim. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $2 net. The venerable rector of the Church of the Epiphany in Washington, D. C., gives in this book an account of his ser- vice half a century ago in the Army of Northern Virginia. A serious-minded boy, in a beautiful home in Baltimore, his father a Union man, McKim went to the University of Virginia, already look- ing forward to the life of a clergyman. This, however, he postponed for nearer duties at the outbreak of the civil war. He took in the from Bull Run to Appomattox, at first in the ranks, then as a staff-officer in the Stonewall division, and ended as chaplain of Mum- He was not less in the stress of battle while an aide-de-camp than while in the ranks, and as chap- lain was always on or near the firing line. The interest of the story culmi- nates at Gettysburg, where he went as a participant with the force which, pen- etrating behind Culp’s Hill, so nearly reached the Baltimore pike and the rear of Meade’s army. He was a youth of high religious character, convinced of the justice of his cause, and sternly reso- lute. The record, though composed in age, largely taken from the young man’s diary and letters. What it may lack in grace and picturesqueness is am- ply made up by its straightforward hon- part action tord's cavalry. is esty and force and by its spirit of warm humanity The book contains also an address given by Dr. McKim to Confederate vet- erans in 1904. Although we admire its general tone, especially its hearty accept- ance of the result of the war, and its earnest loyalty to the now reconstitut- ed Union, there are several points, main tained here and also in the body of the book, to which we demur, We shall not ith his argument for the right that indeed, be a threshing over of old straw All now admit that the point in the Constitution Dr. McKim's statement, while plausible and good-tempered, is yet ex parte, not judicial; and we hope the English readers, whom, no doubt, he to will remember that another side. Dr. McKim has rie ddile v of secession; would, was in doubt desires reach, there is no love for slavery, and argues that its extension into the territories would, by dissipating its spread, but to its extinction. it, have contributed not to We re- >. The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 call that Madison, in the time of the Louisiana purchase, foreseeing a vast emigration into the unfriendly trans- Mississippi country, feared detriment, if not destruction to the Anglo-Saxon mass- es from “the dilution of the population.” The facts have not justified Madison’s fear, nor do wt think Dr. McKim’s the- ory reasonable as to the probable effect of slavery extension. Again, our author, while asserting what no one will deny, that economic reasons and not conscien- tious scruples brought about the disap- pearance of slavery in the North, de- clares that economic reasons had little or nothing to do with the tenacity with which the South came to hold to it. The invention of the cotton-gin had small influence on the growth of cotton. The system of bondage was an in- heritance impatiently suffered, rather than approved; and our author scouts the idea that the purpose of the South was to form a state, whose corner-stone should be slavery. He asserts that in 1832, Virginia was on the brink of abol- ishing slavery, and changed her mood solely because the Northern anti-slav- ery men, led by Garrison, showed such violence that in resentment Virginia be- came reactionary. Now, if these conten- tions are well-based, it is, indeed, an ur- gent matter that our history of that pe- riod should be rewritten. We have cer- tainly been taught that economic causes worked powerfully in behalf of Southern slavery. In the far South, it was cot- ton raising; in Virginia, the tobacco crop and the breeding of slaves for far Southern markets were lucrative sources of revenue. Masses of the population were affected by these considerations, until slavery from being merely endur- ed was cordially embraced. To be sure, a line of high-minded men can be trac- ed, from Washington to R. E. Lee, whose repugnance led them to the length of manumission, but they in Southern so- ciety were not representative. So we have been taught, and such conceptions our author warmly disputes. Is he blindly partisan, or have our historians played us false? Other contentions of Dr. McKim must be fully admitted. Slave-trading was long and shamefully rife in New Eng- iand ports: during our first half-century, New England was repeatedly aflame with the spirit of secession, on grounds at bottom narrow-minded and discredit- The sons in 1861, were, we think, wiser and more scrupulous than the fathers. We have reached better days. It is a thing to rejoice over that this able and stalwart Confederate now strongly asserts his patriotism, and is heartily loyal to an indissoluble Union. His insistence that the cause of the South was not lost, but that a vindica- tion was achieved of the right and dig- nity of each constituent State within the Union, which was indispensable to the national well-being, is forcibly put, able. ‘and all Americans wiil eagerly hope that our future course will prove this to be just. Richard Henry Dana, jr.: Speeches in Stirring Times and Letters to a Son. Edited, with introductory sketch and notes, by Richard H. Dana, 3d. Bos- ton: Houghton Mifflin Co. $3 net. The speeches and papers here collect- ed comprise, among others, Dana’s speech in advocacy of an appointed ju- diciary, before the Massachusetts Con- stitutional Convention of 1853; his ar- gument before the Massachusetts Legis lature, in 1867, in favor of the repeal of the usury laws; addresses before the Free Soil meeting in+Boston, in 1848, and the Free Soil convention at Buffalo in the same year; “The Great Gravita- tion Meeting,” a parody on the Fugitive Slave Act of 1850; arguments in the fugitive slave cases of Shadrach and Burns; the “Grasp of War” speech on the reconstruction policy, delivered in Faneuil Hall in June, 1865; his great legal arguments in the Prize Cases and before the Halifax Fishery Commis- sion; and the elaborate note on the Monroe Doctrine, originally contributed to Wheaton’s “International Law.” To this last paper the editor has added a continuation, bringing the account down to the present time. While these pieces, in no instance, are rare, they have not as a whole been readily avail- able, and their republication in the present form is a welcome addition to the literature of American politics and constitutional law. The course of Dana’s public career has been so fully and well traced by Charles Francis Adams, in his two-vol- ume biography, as to need no repeti- tion; but Mr. Dana’s_ introductory sketch adds a number of personal items, particularly significant as illustrations of Dana’s intellectual habits, his inter- esting friendships, and his exacting ethical standards. We frankly think that the series of “Letters from a Father to a Son” jar somewhat with the remaining contents of the volume; but they are at least interesting in themselves, and are quite justifiably made public. The introductory notes to the several pieces are informing, and there is also a select bibliography of the most important of Dana’s numerous writings. “No doubt,” says the editor at the close of his introductory sketch, “Mr Dana’s life was, on the whole, a disap- pointment to him.” One of the greatest of American jurists and publicists, he failed, to a singular degree, to reap the rewards of ability, industry, and high purpose. His partner and friend, Francis Edward Parker, well wrote of him as “buffeted ... for more than twenty years, disappointed in ‘every high ambition of his life, fall-

Page 31

April 13, 1911] en on evil times and evil chances.” It | was his fate to champion, as a pioneer, unpopular causes which later, under other leaders, were to become respecta- ble, and to oppose his party on grounds which, rejected at the time, have since come to appear sound and statesman- like. After years of hard work at the bar, with an especially lucrative prac- tice within his grasp, he sacrificed it to serve his State in the Legislature. His nomination as Minister to England, a post which he frankly coveted and rich- ly deserved, was rejected by the Sen- ate. Yet it was his service to add ma- terially to the body of American juris- prudence, and to represent the United States with distinction in great causes; and if, with all his great powers, he found no place exactly worthy of them, it was because the times, rather than he, were out of joint. Happily for his memory, he kept himself from melan- choly, though not, we think, as his son puts it, from sadness; he cherished no grievances, and continued with good humor and courage to the end. A False Equation: The Problem of the Great Trust. By Melville M. Bigelow. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. $1.50 net. The Great Trust is the fundamental duty imposed by the sovereign people | upon the State of establishing and’ main- taining Equality (the capitals are Dean Bigelow’s) before the law, in the gener- al sense of providing, so far as possible, that all citizens shall have equal oppor- tunity in the pursuits and enjoyment of life. The state, it is contended, has been remiss in keeping the trust; privilege or monopoly has become unduly estab- lished, and there has been a disintegra- tion of the bonds of authority. In the first half of his book, which discusses the weakness of the state, Dean Bige- low gives us a jeremiad; in the last half he suggests a remedy, not, however, in terms that are wholly convincing. On the whole, this book is not cheer- ful reading. It is true that the evils complained of exist. And it is true that if we were quite another people than we are their elimination would be a meas- urably easy task. But there’s the rub. The American temperament, though Dean Bigelow does not employ that catch-phrase, is a big problem, To many minds nothing short of the means which he suggests as a remedy will seem adequate. If, he declares, there is to be “government of the people, by the people, for the people,” the state must be greater than all the forces that oppose it. “It will not be enough to pass statutes and decide disputes; there must be power behind these to enforce the will of the state. There must be men competent both to direct and to execute that will.” That we have not such men implies defective education. Apparently, what is needed is an organ- The Nation ized education that shall take cogniz- ance of the fact that the “gray layer of J our brains is actually plastic and capa- ble of being fashioned,” and that shall so fashion it as to recover for us the breed of noble bloods in affairs of state. That is an end we must all desire, but we are not sure from anything Dean Bigelow tells us that it is in a fair way of being brought about. We are, we sus pect, an obstinate people where our gray matter is concerned. Notes In the spring announcements of the Scrib- ners are found: a new edition of “England and the English from an American Point of View,” reissued with Price Collier's new book, “The West in the East from an American Point of View”; Mrs. Belloc Lowndes’'s “Jane Oglander,” a novel of Eng- lish country life: “The Revolutionary War é 4 from the French of Jules Claretie, by Mary Safford Messrs. Longman are bringing out “Some Problems in Philosophy: Being an Uncom pleted Introduction to Philosophy by the late William James, and “Napoleon I: a Biography,” which is a translation into two volumes, by Annie Elizabeth Adama, of Prof. August Fournier's work, published in Vienna, 1905-7. In the series of Philosophies, Ancient and Modern, Constable is issuing “Pragmatism’ and “William James.” The same house has in a series of illustrated and Modern, spheres of modern literature, politics. In the literary series nounced: Sainte-Beuve, Samuel Butler, Laf preparation Ancient the Biographies, selected to illustrate and an- science, are cadio Hearn, Tolstoy, and Lecky. “Lollardy and the Reformation in Eng- land,” from the death of Henry VIII through the reign of Edward VI, by James Gairdner, is a title in Macmillan’s spring list, which also includes Owen Wister’s new novel, “Members of the Family,” a tale of and the Military Policy of the United |) Western life States,” by Gen. Francis Vinton Greene;| In “Religions and Philosophies of the “The Agonists: A Trilogy of God and Man,” East,” issued this week by John Lane Com by Maurice Hewlett; R. L. Stevenson's “Lay pany, J. M. Kennedy aims to give a con Morals and Other Papers”; “Isabella of | cise history in a single volume. Milan,” by Christopher Hare; “The Spring books of Sherman, French & Co High Roads of the Alps,” by Charles L. Freeston; “Finland To-day,” by George Ren- wick; “Florence, Past and Present,” by the Rev. J. Wood Brown; “Java and Sumatra, and the Other Islands of the Dutch East Indies,” by A. Cabaton, translated by Ber- nard Miall; “The Price,” by Francis Lynde; “Mr. Wycherly’s Wards,” by L. Allen Hark- er, and “Esther Damon,” by Cora Older. To their series of Latin-American Repub- lics, L. C. Page & Co. are adding “Argen- tina and Her People of Today,” by Nevin O. Winter. Frederick A. Stokes Co. announces: “Mark Twain,” by Archibald Henderson: “East- ern Asia: A History,” by Ian C, Hannah; “London Clubs,” by Ralph Nevill, and “Al- pine Flowers and Rock Gardens,” by Wal- ter P. Wright. “The Kipling Index” has been compiled by Eugene F. Saxton and is issued gratuitous- ly by Doubleday, Page & Co.; it may be pro- cured by any one who sends to the publish- ers five cents in stamps to cover postage. The series of animal biographies, pub- lished by George W. Jacobs Co., is to be augmented this year by Clarence Hawkes’s “King of the Thundering Herd”—the story of the American bison. This house announces “Quaker Ben.” Dr. Henry C McCook. Monroe Royce is publishing through Thom- as Whittaker “The Passing of the Amer- ican,” which tries to show that the American is being outstripped by the alien also by native A second posthumous volume of O. Henry's stories, entitled “Sixes and is promised by Doubleday, Page & Co. in the autumn. Toward the end of April Sevens,” D. Appleton & Co. will put forth “The Training of Chil- dren in Religion,” by the Rev. George Hodges; “The Social Direction of Human Evolution,” by Prof. William FE. Kellicott; “Educational Problems,” by G. Stanley Hall, and “Which is My Husband?” a translation American Philosophy include: “The Pragmatism,” wherein A. v, C. F. Huizinga attempts to show that Ritschlian theology is the temper which pragmatism voices; “The Volitional Element in Knowledge and Belief,” by Prof. Delo C. Grover; “The Future Citizen,” by F. W. Myers bring out The Val- Classical On April 15 Henry Holt & Co Miss R. Macaulay's Welsh novel, ley Captives”; H. Stuart Jones's Rome,” an historical guide, and Frederick Bliss Luquien’s ‘‘Three Lays of Marie de France, Retold in English Verse.” The fourth and revised = edition of Brehm’s “Tierleben,” in thirteen volumes is announced by Lemcke & Buechner. The same firm, as agent for the Columbia Unit in hand: “Power,” Prof. C. E. Lucke; “Business of Congress,’ W. McCall: “Problem of World Or ganization as Affected by the Nature of the Modern State,” D. J. Hill; of Voltaire’s Novels,” by W. R Greek Romances in Elizabethan Fiction,” by versity Press, has by 8 “Symbolism by Price rae S. L. Wolff; “The Rise of the Novel of Man ners,” by Charlotte E. Morgan; “John Det nis, the Critic,” by H. G. Paul; rhe Po litical Prophecy in England,” by Rupert Taylor, and “The Poems of King James I of England,” by Allen F. Westcott Desmond Fitz Gerald's announcement f new fiction include: “Thurley Ruxton y Philip Verrill Mighels, and “The Infinite Capacity,’ by Cosmo Hamilton The spring list of Forbes & Co. of Ch cago includes: “Americans All,” by John Merritte Driver; “Buttered Toasts,” by Fred Emerson Brooks The University of Chicago Press has in preparatior “The Elementary Course in English.” by James Fleming Hosic; “The Theology of Schlelermacher,” by George and “The Hebrew Prophets, or Patri a text-book for Cross ote and Leaders of Israel,” of Chamberlin pupils high-school age, by Georg'a L

Page 32

378 train: “Down Our Mrs. J. E. Buckrose: “William the Silent,” a biography by Ruth Putnam; “More Than Kin,"by Patricia Wentworth; “Log of the North Shore Club,” by Kirkland B. Alexander, and “Aspects of Religious Be- lief and Practice in Babylonia and Assyria,” The Putnams have in Street,” by by Morris Jastrow On behalf of the Cambridge University Press, the same house announces: “Roman Stoicisn by |} Vernon Arnold; “About Edwin Drood,” by H. J.; “The Theory of roleration under the Later Stuarts,” by A. A. Seaton: “A Descriptive Catalogue of the Manuscripts in the Library of Corpus Christi College, Cambridge,” by Montague Rhodes James; “An Easy Selection from Cicero's Correspondence,” edited by J. D. Duff; “The Hexaplar Psalter—Being the Book of Psalms edited by William “Gilbert Abbot of by J. Armitage Robinson, elation of St. John the Di- vine,” edited by G. H. 8. Walpole, Bishop of Edinburgh; “The First Book of Samuel” and “The Second Book of Samuel,” both ed- ited A. F D.D.; “Judges,” edited by John Black, and “Ruth,” edited by Streane. & ¢ have in Six English Versions,” Aldis Wright; Westminster,” D.D.; “The Re Crispin, by Kirkpatrick, Sutherland A.W in their list: Claimers,” by John Fleming Wilson; “The Moving Finger,” by E. Phil- lips Oppenheim; “To Love and to Cherish,” by Eliza Calvert Hall; “The Path of Glory,” by Paul Leland Haworth; “The Spirit of the Little, Brown ‘o. “The Land Island,” by Joseph Horner Coates; “Bud- die: The Story of a Boy,” by Anna Chapin Ray; “The Captain of the 8S. I. G's,” by Etta Anthony Baker; “Ancient, Curious, and Famous Wills,” by Virgil M. Harris; “Prac- tical Salesmanship,” Nathaniel C. Fowl- er, jr., and “Brain Power for Business Men,” by by Annie Payson Call “Classical Rome,” by H. Stuart Jones, a new volume in Grant Allen's Historical Guides series, will be issued at once by Henry Holt & Co “The Peace Problem,” by Frederick Lynch, ia in the list of the Revell Co rhe University Presses of Oxford and Cambridge announce two new editions of the Revised Version, in which for the first time the text Is divided into verses as in the 1611 Bible Hitherto, the Revised Version been obtainable divided into para- of the olumn references, will be pub- has only graphs. One new editions, contain- ing central lished on May 17, the thirtieth anniversary of the appearance of the Revised New reatament, when 1,000,000 copies were sold in the course of the day; and the other edi- tion, text only, will be ready a few weeks later rhe University Presses have also ready for publication a cheap edition of “The In terlinear Hible,’ which combines the Authorized and the Revised Versions Where the versions vary the passages are printed in emaller type, so arranged that reader following continuously the upper the the Revised Version, or the line haa text of the of account of the friendship and rupture with Wagner is particularly clear and just. an interpretation of Nietzsche's philosophy following the lower line Authorized Version: and yet sees at a glance the differ [Vol. 92, No. 2389 The Nation | Ideal Italian Tour,” by Henry James For- | “A Year man; and ina C Joseph Husband The for a strong now consists and Henry all possible standard merit. Messrs. by Marco Luzzatto,’ seh ben James, measures of English” Luzac mann Gollancz’s “Hebrew Glosses and Notes which discusses Menas- Israel's attempt to reconcile con- Academic Cor of thirty-thre and to by have in ha flicting texts of Scripture. Holders of No letters from t which oal Mine,’ Royal Society of Literature has ar- ranged, according to the London Atheneum, which in- cluding Joseph Conrad, Maurice Hewlett, “is to take maintain a good recognizing even unpopular work if it is of genuine literary nmittee, @ persons, nd Prof. he is preparing a biography of the historian. The centenary edition of Dickens (import- is increased by six new volumes, including “Hard Times,” “The Old Curiosity Shop” (2 vols.), “Barnaby Rudge” > vols.), and “Christmas Books.” ed by Seribne this publication and for the price rs) (one dollar th e volume). will be completed in thirty-six volumes. We more tion of Thomas Ironies” and the Hardy: ‘The Well-Belo have to record the appearance of two volumes in Harpers’ Thin-Paper edi- Little “Life's ved.” As both collection of stories and the novel are comparatively short, these two volumes have the advantage at once of slenderness and comfortably substantial paper. “Hood's Texas Brigade (Neale Publish- ing Co.), by J. B. Polley, is frankly based upon personal narratives and reminiscences, and shows few traces of the use of the official records of the civil war, Confederate or Federal. thor Fortunately, however, the au- himself a member of the organization, tells his story in a straightforward fashion, with little bias, and with no more reference tu the general operations of the Confederate armies than is necessary to make clear the of movements the brigade. A contemporary portraits are reproduced, and there is a muster roll of the brigade; but Her- late Henry Charles Lea will confer a favor by sending the originals or copies to Arthur H. 2004 Walnut Street, Lea, Philadelphia, who We have already called attention to the make-up of its unusual excellence It , by | ‘have been the work of partisans, and we number of an index, well-nigh indispensable in a book of this character, is lacking. No life of Nietzsche can ever take the place of that from the pen of his sister, Frau Férster-Nietzsche; although that work, it must be admitted, is inordi- | nately long, and a little too sugared- o'er with sisterly affection. For those who desire something shorter than this, et more detailed than the _ sketches hitherto printed in English, we can recommend heartily “The Life of Friedrich Nietzache,” Daniel Halévy by the translated from by J. M. Hone, Macmillan Co. It the and published is sympathetic, but does not blink the disagreeable aspects Nietzsche's character and career. The As rhe following books will appear April 15 the book needs to be supplemented by the from the pre of Houghton Mifflin Com- treatise of Mr. Mencken or Mr. Kennedy, pany People of Popham,” by Mary C. | aithough: neither of these expositions is, in BK. Wen France in the American ine judgment of the present reviewer, en- by Breck Perkins; “The Revol James ition.’ iirely adequate Hitherto the books written French of | in English about Nietzsche—and their num- ber is increasing with surprising rapidity— have yet to read an exposition of his the- ories of the Superman and of conduct “be- yond good and evil” which, without falling into diatribes of abuse, shall give them their true place in the history of philosophy. The Introduction of T. M. Kettle, M. P., to the present biography is well enough, but does not pretend to go deeply into philo- sophical questions. The translation, by J. M. Hone, is good. The ninth volume of “The New Schaff- Herzog Encyclopedia of Religious Know- ledge” (Funk & Wagnalls Co.) includes ti- tles from Petri to Reuchlin. The work is much fuller than its German precursor in biographical articles, and contains a large amount of new and valuable material on minor topics in ecclesiastical history. The treatment of religious denominations and sects is especially full, with many facts and statistics difficult to find elsewhere in such concise and convenient form, e. g., in the ex- haustive article on the numerous branches of Presbyterians. Other denominational ar- ticles in the present volume are “Protest- ant Episcopalians,” including a sympathet- ic sketch of the Cowley Fathers by Bishop Hall of Vermont; “Plymouth Brethren,” “Reformed Episcopalians,” and “Dutch Re- fcrmed Church.” One of the longest articles is on “The History of Preaching,” by the Rev. Dr. Edwin C. Dargan of Georgia, au- thor of an elaborate treatise on the same subject published a few years ago. The joint article on “Puritans and Puritanism,” by the Rev. John Browne of England and the Rev. Morton Dexter of Boston, is well written. Other noteworthy subjects are “Pietism,” “Pope, Papacy, Papal System,” including a chronological list of the Popes; “Protestantism,” and “Rationalism and Su- pernaturalism,” the latter by Prof. Charles A. Beckwith, departmental editor in syste- matic theology. In general this encyclopr- dia attempts to furnish accurate and recent information, embodying the results of the latest research, but does not undertake to supply monographs which present new the- ories or add to the sum of existing knowl- edge, It has lately been so much the fashion to scrutinize eighteenth-century literature for signs of revolt against neo-classicism, writes Dr. Herbert E. Cory (“Spenser, Thomson, and Romanticism,” Publications the Modern Language Association of America, XIX, 1), that some critic of the future may gain novel distinction by prov- ing that a school of Pope once actually ex- isted. A revival of interest in Spenser has, in particular, been held an important factor in the development of nascent romanticism. But, Dr. Cory points out, the Augustans imi- tated Spenser as they did any accepted classic; self-consciously and somewhat me- chanically, no doubt, but in a spirit neither of indifference nor of mockery. His sweet- ness, simplicity, and copiousness of fancy they recognized, but they had no difficulty in reconciling these with their classical models; and, indeed, one great aspect of his genius, now neglected, they were peculiarly fitted to appreciate—his didacticism. It was long before these neo-classic imita- tions showed any persistent spark of roman- of ticiam, anything which suggests the ro- mantic reincarnation of the _ spirit of Spenser to be found at times in Keats.

Page 33

Biased

April 13, 1911} The Nation

Much, indeed, that is good in Thomson's “Castle of Indolence” is neo-classical—its gentle satire and its moral allegory. What Thomson adds, that is neither neo-classic nor Spenserian, is a spirit of “delighted doubt.” It is not often that one encounters criticism of this sort, at once so acute and so broadly founded on the facts. Dr. Arthur Drews presents in “The Christ Myth” (Chicago: The Open Court Publish- ing Co.) a study of Christian origins from the point of view of an idealistic monist. Relying mainly on W. B. Smith’s “Der vor- christliche Jesus,” he contends that there existed in secret pre-Christian Jewish cir- cles a cult in which Jewish messianic spec- ulations were blended with the widespread heathen myth of a suffering, dying, and rising god, and that the god of this cult was Jesus, a sun-god probably, like Joshua and Jason. Indeed, a papyrus, evidently of the fourth century of our era, explicitly says: “I adjure thee by Jesus, the god of the Hebrews.” When Saul of Tarsus, who was at first offended at this blasphemous fusion of Jewish hope and heathen myth began to catch the significance of the cen- tral idea of the Jesus-cult, the idea, namely, of a self-sacrificing god who becomes man, and as an expiatory representative of the people unites man with god; and when in the power of this idea his own longing for redemption was satisfied; then Christianity came into being. The Christ of Faul in so far as he is man is simply the human race considered as a person. The incarnation, death, and resurrection of Jesus represent not an actual but an eternal story in time Hence to search after evidence in Paul, that is, Van Manen’s Paul, of an historical Jesus is to betray a complete misunder- standing of the real founder of Christianity To be sure, there are a few passages which seem to point to an actual Jesus, but such passages are either wrongly interpreted or are obvious interpolations. In fact, not even the Synoptic Gospels or their two main sources, Mark and Q, com- pel the assumption of an historical Jesus As for Mark, Wrede has shown how un- reliable it is as a source for the life of Jesus; and Schweitzer has rightly insisted that the figure of Jesus depicted by German liberal critics is pure fiction. Mark’s nar- rative gets to be intelligible only when it is recognized that it reflects the constant traits of the god-redeemer myth. As for Q, even Kihler admits that we possess no single authentic word of Jesus. In fine, “the life of Jesus, as portrayed by the Synoptics. merely brings to an expression in historical garb the metaphysical ideas, religious hopes, the outer and inner experiences of the community which had Jesus for its cult- god” (p. 264). Such, briefly, is the line of argument of the book, which is creating a stir in German theological circles. There are some who have become convinced that Jesus never lived, just as there are some who believe that Queen Elizabeth was a man. But such great faith is not yet for all. The English translation is made from the third German edition, and fairly reproduces the original. The publishers would render an even greater service if they would under- take an English translation of the less pop- ular but more important work of the Tulane professor already alluded to, “The pre- Christian Jesus.” Much of value is to be found in a recent volume entitled “State Socialism in New Zealand” (New York: Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.). The book is the work of two col laborators, Prof. J. E. Le Rossignol of the University of Denver and Mr. W. D. Stewart, a barrister-at-law in Dunedin, New Zea- land, the result of whose collaboration is very happy. In the opening chapter the fact is brought out that the notable differences in regard togovernmenta! functions between the New Zealander on the one hand and th Anglo-Saxon of the United States or Can ada on the other must be due to enviran- ment, rather than to differences in character. The beginnings of state enter- prise were closely connected with gov- ernmental ownership of land and building of railways The chapter on Roads and Railways corrects a common misconception held in America as to the nature of railway travel in New Zealand It tells us that on most of the branch lines the service s infrequent, seldom exceeding one train a day each way,” and that the speed of the trains is much less than in the United States; express trains are said to travel from seventeen to twenty-five miles an hour Passenger fares about equal, and freight charges considerably exceed, the correspond- ing rates in the United States Neverthe less, railway service is being rapidly im proved, and transportation charges are steadily being reduced, in conformity with the theory that all revenues in excess of necessary expenses shou'd be returned to the general public. The government of New Zealand furthermore operates life, fire, and accident insurance offices as a_ distinct state department, Here, too, there is no in- tention of making profits, and the state of- fices are taxed and otherwise treated like an ordinary company. The volume takes up such other topics as the land and in- come tax, old-age pensions, the arbitration act, wages, and cost of living In her latest work, “The New New Guinea” (Philadelphia: J. B Lippincott Co.), Miss Beatrice Grimshaw has two ends in view One is to show how the Terri- tory of Papua, for this is now its official title, is being transformed since it came under the centrol of the Australian gov- ernment a few years ago. To describe its wonderful undeveloped natural wealth In such a way as to attract the white planter is the other. The necessary information she gained in a year and a half spent in this country, during which she “travelled into every part attainable without an ex- ploring <pedition,” at times with the Lieutenant-Governor on his official tours Her account of these trips and of the tactful and peaceable way in which friend- ly relations are being established with hostile natives is interesting and encourag- ing. It seems not unlikely that before jong cannibalism with them will be a cus- tom of the past In some places they are beginning to show an intelligent In- terest in agriculture, and to aid in this there are four government plant nurseries where seeds and cuttings of all plants suitable for cultivation can be obtained Many are efficient laborers on the plan- tations of white settlers, who have come since the advent of the Australian gov- ernment What a promising field Papua is to the European with means, the auth- oress clearly shows. The soil and cli- mate are peculiarly adapted to the rais- ing of sugar, cotton, coffee, copra, and rubber, while in some districts four crops of maize in a year can be grown The vast forests contain woods of great value and variety, and the country | exceeding ly rich in valuable minerals.” Among her many interesting experiences the most unusual was what she terms her living début” at the Thursday Island pearling grounds She says: It is a strange sensation, this walk ing alone in the depths of th sea and one that I think no one could describe adequately To get away from the laws of gravity as you have known them ail your life is in itself a somewhat disor ganizing experience. And the laws of grav ity do not act at the bottom of the seas is they do on land. . Fish swim past you green and gray in the green wat You realize with something of a shock that they are not afraid of you On the leck of the sloop, the mere shadow of your hand would send them flying as they glide past the ship's counter, but here in the depths of the sea they fin their w way up to the very windows of your hel met, and look in at you with thelr cold glassy eyes, unafraid Regarding the book as a whole mo if not all, of its readers will agree that it ow convincingly that “the pluch ermination, and strength” of the Aust lians have changed a usel tract of sa ge country into a “habitable, peaceful, and flourishing colony.’"’ There are forty- nine reproductions of photographs, a map, but no index. rhe death is reported, in his seventieth year, of John Charles Freeman, since 1879 professor of English literature in the Uni- versity of Wisconsin. He was United States consul at Copenhagen in 1900, and the fol- lowing year United States chargé d'affaires He edited Xenophon's “Memorabilia” and the “Dialogues” of Lucian, and wrote a “History of American Literature.” Charles Frederic Moberly Bell, who died suddenly last week, had been managing dl- rector of the London Timea since 1908. He was born in 1847, was the Timea correspon- dent in Egypt from 1865 to 1890, and wrote “Khedives and Pashas,” “Egyptian Finance,” and “From Pharaoh to Fellah.” three thoughtful books The Rev, Dr. Alexander Mair, whose death is announced from Edinburgh, was the au- thor of “Studies on the Christian Ev dences,.” — Science Biology, General and Medical. By Jo seph McFarland, M.D. With 160 ib lustrations, including five plates. Phil- adelphia: W. B. Saunders Co. $1.75 net. The pioneer “Elementary Blology” of Huxley and Martin was mainly a guide to the examination of selected animais and plants The recent “Biology” of Needham combines that feature with a simple and progressive presentation of the main facts and principles relating to organisms The present work con tains only incidental suggestions as to personal observation by the student; in his own words It has been the purpose of the autuor to acquaint his readers with the peculiar ona

Page 34

e ¢ ISO ture and interesting reactions of “living substance’; to help him [them?] to trace it to its probable (though unknown), begin- nings and follow it through its multifarious differentiations its highest complexi- ty . All of the subjects treated are of interest and importance to students of med- icine to and physicians. Following are the chapter titles: The cosmical relations of living matter. The origin of life The criteria of life. The manifestations of life. The cell, Cell division rhe higher organisms. Repro- duction. Ontogenesis. Conformity to type. Structural relationship. Blood Parasitism. Infection and im- Mutilation and regeneration. Senescence, decadence, and death. Divergence relationship munity Grafting All these topics are important, and interesting either per se or because of their significance. The author treats them modestly, judicially, and with varying degrees of fulness and ac- curacy. Especially commendable is the chapter on Infection and Immunity, a ubject embraced within one of the au- other two works, “Pathogenic Bacteria,” of which the Saunders Com- But author and publisher should have real- ized that such a variety of difficult .top- ics could not possibly be presented ade- small volume or accur- individual. The author valuable suggestions and criticisms from a friend and colleague. But treatise the manuscript or proof, as a whole or in part, should have been submitted to at least ten specialists in their respec- Among them the author thors pany has issued the sixth edition. quately in one ately by one acknowledges with so comprehensive a tive branches. would have been warned against the declaration (p. 218) that “every em- bryo has at every stage pecu- liarities which distinguish it from every other genus and species’; he would have been told that “homoiogues” on p. 109 should be analogues; that the pro- cess called “plant respiration” on p, 89 and that the 103 as to the relative somat- really photosynthesis; Dp. numbers of chromosomes in the ic and the germinal cells is the reverse of the fact 18 statement on There are numerous errors as to both and technical words. The in- lacks at of entries. There should be a full glossary of the common dex least a score comparatively unfamiliar terms with which some pages almost bristle The plates are excellent, and many of the figures In the text are well-chosen and clear; others are on too small a scale or insufficiently explained. The following case exemplifies the lack of due provision for the needs of students On p. 124 Is a good figure of the “nettling cells” of Hydra. and lay readers There is no reference to fig. 41 where the entire animal is represented for the sake of orientation; neither Is there reference to p. 126 for an account ef the process of “exploding” the cell. The Nation | Vol. 92, No. 2389 nerve-cell; the figure lacks clearness, has no relation to the adjacent text, and is not referred to fig. 57, the more com- prehensive scheme of nervous action, which itself is nowhere adequately eluc- idated. At the close of each chapter are nam- ,ed from two to sixteen publications on related topics; among the seven for the chapter on Infection and Immunity two by the author are presumably compila- tions, like the present work; yet the original researches of V. A. Moore and Theobald Smith are nowhere mention- ed. With a volume intended for gener- al readers as well as for medical stu- dents, the sixteen advertising pages might have been devoted to more ap- propriate titles. These pages, by the way, are of better paper than the book itself, which, as a whole, hardly sup- ports the claim of the publishers to “set a standard for mechanical perfection and scientific superiority.” In Frederick A. Stokes Co.'s list of sci- ence books we note “The House-Fly—Dis- ease Carrier,” by Leland O. Howard. Lemcke & Buechner, acting as agents for the Columbia University Press, will bring out Prof. H. E. Crampton’s “Doctrine of Evolution.” “Psychic Phenomena, Science and Im- mortality,” by Henry Frank, and To-morrow,” William W. Kinsley, are soon to be issued by Sherman, French & Co. Forbes & Co.'s list includes: “Confidences—Talks with a Young Girl Con- cerning Herself,” both by Dr. E. B. Lowry. | In Longman’s list of announcements we | “New Ideas on Inorganic Chemistry,” A. Werner, “The Chemistry of Synthetic note: Prof. Hedley; by P Drugs,” by Percy May, and Lord Avebury’s | book and Reli- gion: “On Marriage, Totemism, A Reply to Critics.” The division of the population of the dif- ferent countries of the world according to sex is shown in Petermann’s Mitteilungen | It seems that) for January and February. there are trustworthy census returns for 61 per cent. of the total population of the earth, and that women are in a minority in this thousand million by 4,600,000. Taking 000 more women than men, while Asia has 8,000,000 and America 2,400,000 less. In ten New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, New York, New Jersey, Mary- land, Virginia, North Carolina, South Caro- Georgia, as in the District of Columbia, women are in the majority, The United States States, lina also Department of Agri- culture recently issued a bulletin (Farmers’ Bulletin No. 433) describing the cultivation of cabbages from the points of view, respectively, of the gardener, the market gardener, and the truck farmer. James Evelyn Pilcher, U. 8. A.,, in Savannah on Satur- has home Capt. retired, who died day, at the age of fifty-four, had occupied the chair of military surgery in the Ohio University, Starling Medical Col- | Medical “Man's | a treatise on immortality by | “Truths— | Talks with a Boy Concerning Himself,” and | translated by Dr, E. | | in | masterful figure of William, if somewhat | over-gilded with human virtues which do the continents as a whole, Europe has 5,600,- | met rightfully belong to Bim, ts vigereusty Opposite p. 126 is represented a motor lege, and in Creighton Medical College; he | was at one time professor of sociology and | political economy in Dickinson College, and |professor of military jurisprudence at | Dickinson Law School. He was the author of “First Aid in Illness and Injury,” “Life and Labors of Elijah Holmes Pilcher,” “Co- lumbus Book of the Military Surgeons,” “The Arms and Seals of the State of Penn- |sylvania,” and “The Surgeon Generals of |the Army.” | Drama | | Sardou’s “La Perle noire,” edited with |notes and vocabulary by Dr. Kenneth Mc- | Kenzie, and Jeanne Charbonniéras’s “Un | Bal manqué” are soon to appear from | William R. Jenkins’s press. | Badger announces for immediate publi- |eation abridged translations of “The Cred- jitor,” by Strindberg, and “A Man of the | World,” by Marie von Ebner-Eschenbach. | Walter S. Hinchman has written “Wil- |liam of Normandy” (London: Kegan Paul, Trench, Triibner & Co.), in the form of a chronicle play, and an interesting story he has made of it. For stage purposes, even if presented in the Elizabethan fashion— ithe only possible way—it would probably prove unsuitable, because of the prepon- | derance of dialogue over action, and the lack of progressive dramatic suspense. To cut the dialogue would result in de- priving the piece of its chief signifi- cance and value. It is written in smooth 'and forcible blank verse, of distinctly poetic quality, though without pretence of inspiration or any indulgence in rhapsody. There is scarcely a line in it that is not pertinent to the personage or the occasion. Imagination, which it does not lack, is not allowed to interfere with the known facts. | The spirit and conditions of the time (1071- 1087) are reflected with scholarship and | sufficient accuracy. There are, necessar- ily, but unfortunately, long gaps in the historical story—years are supposed to elapse between the acts, the tale opening 'with the event that led to the sack of |Ely and jumping to the fatal close at Rouen. The merit of the work lies, not in the perfection of the chronicle, but in the portrayal of the characters concerned it. This is consistent and vital. The and, in the main, truthfully depicted, and his relations, paternal and political, with | his fiery and irresponsible heir, Robert, are vividly and effectively sketched. Robert himself is an admirable study of aspiring, reckless, passionate, but essentially gal- lant and generous youth. Matilda is a noble and tender woman, while the character of |} the crafty warrior-priest, Otho, is drawn with a skill that carries with it the convic- tion of veracity. Many of the minor char- acters of the drama—Anselm, Lanfranc, Shrewsbury, Warwick, and other barons— are drawn with notable realism and con- sistency. In short, this is an excellent piece of work, which will bring to any intelligent reader both pleasure and profit. But before the footlights—should it ever get there—it would probably be doomed to

Page 35

4 A mete a4 April 13, 1911] The Nation failure, by the lack of competent players to act or speak it, if for no other reason. Grace George opens William A. Brady's theatre in Forty-eighth Street, “The Play- house,” this Saturday, with two perform- ances of “Sauce for the Goose,” the new comedy, written for her by Geraldine Bon- ner and Hutcheson Boyd. She will then resume her tour. In the autumn she will head the stock company which is to pre- sent a series of plays, old and new, in this latest addition to New York’s places of dramatic entertainment, In “Sauce for the Goose”’ Miss George will play the part ofa young wife whose abilities have been under- estimated by her literary husband, who neglects her for another woman. In the conflict of wit and intrigue which follows she proves herself much more than his match, and, in the end, he is only too glad to be permitted to return to his allegiance. The dramatic scheme is an old one, which has done good service in the past, and may be put to still better use in the future. Mr. Brady’s plans for the house next season seem to be of an ambitious character. He proposes to follow the policy originally out- lined by the New Theatre, and to organize a first-class company for the presentation of all that is best in the old and contem- poraneous drama. Among the modern au- thors to be interpreted he mentions Ibsen, Shaw, Sudermann, Rostand, Broadhurst, Edward Sheldon, Thompson Buchanan, Mar- garet Mayo, and others, while he promises revivals of Shakespearean and other classi- cal plays. It is a fair programme; but pos- sibly he, too, may discover that these things are more easily said than done. Good plays are plentiful, good performances exceeding- ly rare, His stock company would inspire greater confidence if he did not purpose to have a star at the head of it. The London critics are not all of one mind as to the quality of ‘‘Lady Patricia,” the comedy by Rudolf Besier, which has just been produced in the Haymarket Theatre. The plot of it, evidently, is a flimsy artifi- cial thing. A scientific husband of ripe age has a lovely romantic wife, who grows somewhat weary of his virtues and so enters upon a platonic flirtation with an agree- able youth. Presently the husband, feeling himself neglected, seeks consolation (also purely platonic) in the society of a young girl, daughter of a Dean. The youth and the girl actually are in love with each other, but are flattered by the attentions of their mature admirers. Through the mal- adroitness of an old servant, comic compli- cations arise, and are disentangled in due course, and all ends well. One critic says: “Playgoers of robust appetites will say it is all hors d’wuvre, or more sauce than fish. That cannot be gainsaid. Mr. Besier in avoiding the heavy has not perhaps guarded against the opposite pitfall of the flimsy.” Another and more enthusiastic observer writes: ‘ ‘Lady Patricia’ will live. Here ts the ‘literary drama’ to a certainty. It is not merely literary drama, it is literary farce. Much better, it is a delightful play and an hilarious entertainment.” When Pinero’s comedy, “Preserving Mr Panmure,” has run its course at the Lon- don Comedy Theatre, it will be succeeded by a version of Ferenc Moln4r’s “The Life- guardsman,”’ which has been written by Capt. Basil Hood, who has anglicized the piece very thoroughly. Indeed, according to report he has retained little of it except the skeleton. There are only half a dozen characters of any importance, and one of these does not figure upon the programme. Robert Loraine, Alexander Carlisle, and Mrs, Charles Calvert are among the princi- pal performers. Henry Ainley is to play the part of Gaybor Arany in “The Concert’’—the char- acter enacted here by Leo Ditrichstein— when the piece is produced in London. Robert Arthur is to establish a stock company in the London Coronet Theatre, for the presentation of old and new plays, but will engage special stars, a policy which is utterly subversive of the true stock-com- pany idea. He will begin, on the 24th in- stant, with a series of Shakespearean re- vivals, in which Alice Crawford will be seeu as Rosalind, Beatrice, Viola, and Katha- rine. After this, he proposes to present some new dramatizations of Dickens, in- cluding versions of “Dombey and Son,” “Bleak House,” “David Copperfield,” and “Great Expectations.” Alvah 8S. Lipman, an actor, who died last week in his fifty-seventh year, had been connected with the stage since early youth He made his first success in “Fditha’s Burglar”; he played the title réle in “Jim Bludso” and was a member of the compa- nies of Eleanor Robson, Mary Mannering, and May Irwin. He wrote several plays in collaboration with Florence Gerald, one of which, “The Sunset Limited,” was recently produced at the Broadway Theatre. Musie Some Forerunners of Italian Opera. By W. J. Henderson. New York: Henry Holt & Co., $1.25 net. Many Americans will undoubtedly vis- it Rome this year and there hear some of the historic operatic performances covering the time “from the madrigal compositions and comic intermezzi of the cinquecento to the intensely dra matic lyric creations of the contempor- ary period,” as the official prospectus has it. These exposition visitors, if se riously minded, will do well, in packing their trunks, to include, besides their Baedeker, a copy of Mr. Henderson's new volume, which is a short study of the lyric drama in Italy prior to the birth of opera as shaped by the Flor entine reformers toward the end of the sixteenth century. It begins with the assertion that “the modern entertain ment called opera is a child of the Ro- man Catholic Church,” and the first two chapters are devoted to tracing the lit- urgical ancestry in the processions and ceremonies, the costumes, and the delin eation of episodes of religious history, such as the strange féte of the ass at which priests and congregation hee hawed as realistically as they could. This festival dates from the eleventh century, and open-air performances of religious dramas, with music and danc- ing, took place in the twelfth, if not sooner. 3Ssl The bulk of the volume—seven chap- ters cf 111 pages—is devoted to a study of the character and performance of the first Italian secular drama, the “Orfeo” of Poliziano; this study, the author de clares, is the result of some years of labor. He believes that what he has to offer on this topic will be found to pos- sess historical value; and such it doubt- less has. While some of the conclusions reached are conjectural, much ingenuity is displayed in disentangling the actual facts from misleading and conflicting evidence, and the bibliographic foot- notes show that the writer has studied his subject exhaustively. Mantua was the birthplace of the secular drama with music; of Mantua’s intellectual atmos- phere, its activity and importance as a literary and musical centre, the author gives a vivid picture, after stat- ing the reasons why there was no drama in the Middle Ages till the church began to revive it in liturgies and sacred representations. It is not without significance that the legend of Orpheus, chosen by Poliziano, subse- quently also inspired the originators of real Italian opera, Peri and Caccini, and the epoch-making Monteverdi and Gluck to write operas of historic im- portance; Gluck’s is the oldest of ail operas that have remained in the mod- ern repertory. While Poliziano’s “Orfeo” was musi- cally as different in character from the opera as from the liturgical drama, Mr. Henderson tries to show that none the less it contained some of the germs of the modern opera. It had its solo, its chorus, and its ballet. The story it- self made “an ideal opera book,” and the points at which the music must have been heard are clearly indicated by the text. Unfortunately, all record of the music itself appears to be lost. By the use of what might be called circum- stantial evidence, the author proceeds to guess what sort of music it was, with an ingenuity which finally makes him pause, lest reconstructive ardor should carry him too far. But the search for the probable style of .the music in this play, casts instructive sidelights on many points in the musical practice of the period. The scenic and lighting pro- blem are also discussed, and the final chapters are devoted to disquisitions on the frottola and madrigal dramas, the influence of the Netherlands on musical Italy, the growth of the comic element resulting in opera buffa, and the birth of real Italian opera, which came about through a revolt against florid singing quite as much as through a reaction against polyphonic complexity Madame Adelina Patt! (Baroness Cedar- strém) has generously offered to give a con- cert, on June 1, at the Royal Albert Hall, for the benefit of her old friend, Wilheim Ganz, who since last December has been un- fortunately kept by an accident from all

Page 36

¢ > J ‘ 382 work Patti was born sixty-eight years axo Massenet’s “Don Quixote” has proved a great success in Paris. When he was asked the other day which was his favorite opera, he replied that he thought it was “Thérése,”’ which will soon be produced in Paris. It wa written before “Don Quixote.” His latest work, “‘Rome Vaincue,” is to have its first hearing at Monte Carlo Massenet is n his sixty-ninth year. When asked whether he now intended to rest, he answered: Never! I am already at work on the opera to follow ‘Rome Vaincue.’ ”’ In a Berlin lecture on Strauss’s new opera Der Rosenkavalier” Dr. Max Burk- hardt declared that neither the composer nor the librettist had succeeded so far as the humorous element was concerned. He said Strauss had fallen short of real spon- taneous humor, in spite of brilliant color- ng and orchestration and in spite of some excellent musical Jokes. Burkhardt further stated that even the waltzes, so brilliant during the first few numbers, soon grew dull, and proved that Strauss, after all, ould not write a real waltz; that Strauss acked the flow of melody which had made t la omi operas immortal Phéodor Radoux, whose death is reported i he age of seventy-five, was director of ! onservatory at Liége and the author of two opeius-comiques, “Le Béarnais” and la Coupe enchanté and an oratorio, Art By John A. Gade. Houghton Mifflin Co. $5 net. tourist has made a thor- ough study of architecture and is well acquainted with the structural media the architect employs, he can never ful- appreciate the artistic value of the great cathedrals of Europe. One who is not thus instructed will be fortunate if, in visiting the cathedral cities, he can gain the companionship of some intelligent architect who will point out to him the special problems presented to the designers for solution, and the procedure by which they aimed to solve these problems. In the book before us Mr. Gade, who is an architect, travels with the reader through Spain, and in the study of ‘ts most important cathe- drals attempts to supply the place of such a companion for those who are not fortunate enough to obtain one in the The task thus set for himself he Cathedrals of Spain Boston: Unless the ly flesh has accomplished with no little success: and although the book ts distinctly an architectural guide-book, the non-profes sional traveller will find it not only useful but readable; for it contains something more than is given in a Baedeker, and is enlivened by occasion- imaginative descriptions foreign to the habit of the ordinary guide-book writer. For the general reader who has not visited Spain the book is naturally much The text, in- deed, is embellished with many fine pho- al less satisfactory. tographic plates, but it is obviously im- The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 possible to show in such illustrations any large proportion of the details to which reference must be made. The Spanish cathedrals are notable for their size, are intensely interesting | historically, and are instructive to the philosophically inclined architect as in- dicative of the result of the ready as- similation of architectural styles _bor- rowed from other lands. The social de- mands of the rival wealthy communi- ties compelled the construction of these vast piles; but the builders were not in- tent upon the development of any in- herited architectural style, being satis- fied to adapt to their own needs archi- tectural forms used by their rivals in other lands whom they wished to im- press with their own greatness. Their cathedrals thus appear as an expres- sion of the social genius of the people rather than of their artistic convic- tions; and the unconscious recognition of this fact leads the casual visitor in Spain to turn his attention less to its cathedrals than to the land, and its peo-| ple, and to such non-ecclesiastical arch- itectural remains as tell of the real in- terests of the powerful races that con- tended for mastery through so many centuries. The ordinary tourist natur- ally hesitates to devote to the cathedral in Granada, for instance, any large part of the time allotted to a visit to this enchanting spot, which can seldom be long enough to satisfy one’s interest in the Alhambra and Generalife, with their wealth of gardens, their panorama of | the distant Sierra Nevada, and their vistas of the golden plains. From such joys we must be enticed if we are to study the cathedrals of Spain, and Mr. Gade has done well to write this mono- graph which will lead the traveller to note much of interest that he might oth- erwise overlook. Louis Hourticque, inspector of fine arts of the city of Paris, has placed his book, | “The History of Art in France,” with the | Scribners. “Portrait Book of the Kings and Queens | of Great Britain,” by Charles FE. Pascoe, and “Chats on Old Pewter,”’ by J. L. J. Masse, | are announced by Frederick A. Stokes Co. “Lady Charlotte Schreiber's Suneatet| illustrated with above a hundred reproduc- tions of ceramics and antiques, are pub- | lished this week by John Lane Co. | Dr. George Herbert West is publishing) through Bell & Sons “Gothic Architecture | in England and France.” We learn that the pictures of chAteaux| in France, painted by Cotelle by order of Louls XIV for Versailles, will be removed | from the dining roam at the Palace to the | | Trianon A plecture representing the death of the | Virgin by Holbein the elder has recently | been added to the museum at Budapest. “Schools of Painting’ (Putnam) by Mary Innes is edited by Charles DeKay for American use, and the last chapter, on |} executed by the sculptor Euphranor. | scriptions, | Aparchai American painting, is by his hand. This book claims the distinction of being written in untechnical style for beginners. Such merit may be conceded, and also the excel- lence of the illustration. But the title is a misnomer. There is no clear d'scrimination and characterization of schools. The book is merely the usual history compiled along biographical lines and displaying the cus- tomary defects of lack of accuracy and pro- portion. The dates of Foppa and Antonello da Messina should be corrected in the light of recent research. The value of the treat- ment of the Florentine school may be meas- ured by the fact that Antonio Pollaiolo is omitted. In short, about all that can be said for the book is that it does in some fashion cover in one volume the whole range of post-classical painting. There is very wide interest in anything connected with the building and furnishing of country houses, if one may judge by the vast number of publications concerned with such matters. Prof. C. F. Osborne has taken advantage of this to offer in “The Family House" (the Penn Publishing Company) a great deal of practical advice to the man who his home-making' seriously. Questions of site, exposure, disposition, and construction are clearly treated, and should be of real assistance to the house- renter or house-builder of moderate means —but, unless he is a man of more than moderate leisure, it may prove better econ- omy to ask an expert’s opinion than to master the somewhat technical chapters on heating and ventilating. Mr. Oeconomou, ephor of antiquities in Corinthia, Argolis, and Arcadia, has pre- sented a report to the Greek Archeological Society on the excavations which were near the Theseion in Athens in the Among takes made hope of finding the ancient Agora. | the objects discovered the most important |is a torso of a beautiful statue of Apollo, which Mr. Oeconomou identifies with the statue referred to by Pausanias as being There found several important in- one containing a law on the of Eleusis; another relating to the mines of Laurion; and a third mention- ing for the first time the name of an Athenian archon called Athenodorus. It should appear from the inscriptions that under the Theseion there was situated the were also |famous Metroon of Athens, the position of which has long been a disputed point. At a meeting of the Austrian School of Archwology at Athens, Mr. Premerstein, the director, gave an interesting account of the researches on the plain of Elis, in extensive area near the mouth of the river Peneus, known as the “Curved Elis.” Remains of columns were unearthed, which perhaps came from the Temple of Athena described by Pausanias. The most im- portant of the buildings discovered was the Octagonon. Near this edifice. which in Christian times was transformed into a church, were found a number of inscribed tombstones. In one of the tombs there was discovered a beautiful gold ornament (now placed in the Museum at Athens); in others vases of local manufacture, which will prove of special interest to archwolo- gists. Louls Oscar Roty, the French medallist, died a fortnight since, aged sixty-four.

Page 37

April 13, 1911] The Nation Finance PAST, PRESENT, AND FUTURE. Wall Street is alternately the slave of precedent, in the sense of believing that things which happened once under given conditions must happen in just the same way when similar conditions return, and a rebel against precedent, in the sense of believing that new financial contriv- ances and new economic forces have made useless the teachings of the past. Just now, its mood inclines to deep re- spect for precedent. Perhaps the reason is that the contrary attitude of scorn at all who described the boom of 1909 as a duplicate of the ill-fated boom in the second year after 1893, has been render- ed untenable by subsequent events. The premature demonstration of 1895, with its rise in commodities, its excited Stock Exchange speculation, and its rec- ord-breaking iron production, collapsed over-night as it were; a year or more of profound depression followed. To the exactly similar “boom year” 1909, com- ing at a similar interval after a great panic, the sequel was the same This being so, it certainly is not strange that Wall Street should again be making its bow respectfully to prece- dent, and asking what our past financial history foreshadows at this present juncture. The nearest precedent is fa- miliar. We are now in the fourth year after the panic of 1907; a corresponding interval after the panic of 1893 brought the country to the early months of 1897. The “after-panic boom year,” 1895, had by that time been almost forgotten; we were living under the shadow of the prolonged reaction and liquidation of 1896. In that respect, the resemblance to the present position of affairs is man- ifest. It is so in other ways. At the open- ing of 1897, the country’s industry was marking time; the pulse of the Stock Exchange had almost ceased to beat; in April, sales had averaged only 125,000 shares a day. Commodity prices were falling; even steel rails declined in Feb- ruary from $28 to $25. Dividends of several railway companies were reduc- ed. In April (such are the accidental parallels of history) stocks declined abruptly on an anxiously-awaited Su- preme Court decision against the cor- porations—the “Trans-Missouri Railway case,” under the Anti-Trust law of 1890. But on the other hand, money went at 2 per cent. for two-months’ Wall Street loans; the New York surplus bank reserve was larger even than it is to-day; loans of all the country’s na- tional banks were down $65,000,000 from the year before, and, in response to the lower prices, excess of merchandise ex- ports, which had been only $70,500,000 for the nine months ending wiih March, 1896, was $323,000,000 for the same pe- riod up to the end of March, 1897 a 383 figure quite unprecedented in that era. | period's financial crisis came on the The result we know. market began to rise; in June a genu- ine “boom” was under way; in August our famous bumper wheat crop in the face of European famine, and the rapid recovery in general trade, changed the whole face of the We fairly on the way to the great financial and industrial Thus 1897 is a highly agreeable prec- edent for the fourth year after a great financial panic. But it is not the only precedent. We have also the period fol- lowing the September panic of 1873, and situation. were revival. the month whose distance from the acute disturbance of that year corre- sponded to the present occasion was March, 1877. pening then. The story differs curiously from that just narrated. There was in 1877, there is to-day, a halt in the movement of industry and finance, but it was a halt inspired by well-grounded appre hension. In that very month, rate wars broke out among the railways; earnings were poor, dividends low, and severe re- trenchment necessary. The economies took the shape of cuts in wages; what followed was the savage railway riots of July in the Pittsburgh district. Stock market prices swept violently down- ward, and in almost all respects it was au unhappy financial year. It was saved from a continuous story of reaction by the harvesting of wheat and corn crops larger than any previously gathered in this country. and the largest cotton crop since the civil war. There was no for- eign shortage, as in 1897; but abundaat home production served at least to check the business depression of the day, and in the autumn, trade activity increased and Stock Exchange prices rose. But il was a very slow recovery, and at the end of 1877, a year and a half was still ahead of the United States before it was able to taste the fruits of genuine trade revival. Why should a situation, closely resembled both in chrondlogy and in general aspects those of 1897 and of 1911, have produced results 30 different from what occurred in 1897 and from what every one hopes will oc cur this year? There are various the- ories. One is that the shock of the 1873 panic had been more severe than that of any which came afterward—a sup position partly confirmed by the fact that no such vigorous effort of recovery occurred in 1875 as occurred two years after the panics of 1893 and 1907. An- other theory is that the depreciated cur- rency of the seventies obstructed genu ine revival in fact, did not come, until after resumption of specie payments in January, 1879. A third, and rather plausible, explanation is that Europe itself had been financially dam- in 1873 as it in 1893; other words, that worst of the Let us see what was hap as which 80 which, was not the aged in In May the stock | Eastern and Western hemispheres sim ultaneously, leaving neither shape to help the other out. Yet another, often heard, is that the world’s gold output was decreasing, against its immensely rapid after 1893. But this last explanation will not hold. There were no such huge additions to that annual output in th seventies as occurred two decades later; but as against the $90,700,000 of 1874 a progressive had of in that generation, to th: of 1877. in any is increase yearly increase curred, even $114,000,000 BOOKS OF THE WEEK Afftalo, F adelphia \iton and G Regilding tae Crescent. Phil- Lippincott Holland rhe King’s Vol. Il Dutton $2.50 net Railey, L. H The Country Life Macmillan. $1.25 net fain, F. W The Ashes of a God Belloc, H On Something net, Bell, R. H. The the Impersonal Eldredge $1.25 Bible A Reprint of Introduction by A Bickerton, A, W. The Customs Movement Putnam Dutton $1.25 of Hinds, Beauty and Noble & Religion Estate. the Edition of 1611 W. Pollard Frowds Birth of Worlds and Systems. Harper's Library of Living Thought Rook of Love Introduction by Madison Cawein Macmillan $1.25 net Cannizzaro, 8. (1858) Sketch of a Course of Chemical Philosophy Univ. of Chicago Press 42 cents Curpenter, F.G. How the World is Housed American Book Co. 60 cents Catherwood, M. H. Rocky Fork New ed tion. Boston Lothrop, Lee & Shepard $1.25 Coggins, J. C A New Philosophy of Life Broadway Pub. Co Inage, G The Imperial Organization of Trade Dutton $3.50 net Eggleston, G, C. What Happened at Quast! Boston Lothrop, Lee & Shepard $1.50 Fldred, W. L. Camp St. Dunstan. Boston Lothrop, Lee & Shepard. $1.50 Ellis, H The World of Drean Boston Houghton Mifflin $2 net Ely, H. R The Practical Flower Garden Macmillan $2 net Garnett, EF Hogarth Dutton 75 cents net Gautier, J Wagner at Hore Lane $3.5 net Hardy's The Well-Beloved. Harper $1.25 ne ft. Head, B. V Historia Numorun A Mar ual of Greek Numismatics New and en larged edition Frowds $12.75 net Hewlett, M Brazenhead the Great Seri ner. $1.50 Historical Records and Studies Vol. VI Part 1 The United States Catholic H torical Society Horder, W. G An Ethical Diary. Dutton 75 centa net Hueffer, F. M Memories and Impressions Harper $1.60 net Huntington E Palestine and Ita Trans- formation joston Houghton Mifflin. $2 net Irish Texts Society Vol. XT (1908). Poems of David O’Bruadair. London: Nutt Kansas State Board of Agriculture Seven- teenth Biennial Report, for the Years 1999 and 1910. Topeka Kenilworth, W WW Thoughts on Things Psychic. Fer $1 Kennett, R. H Composition of the Book of Ieniah (Schweich Lectures 1999) Frowde Kent. CC. F Bibl i! Geography and H tory Soy bner $10 net Ker, W. I Warton Lecture on English Poetry Frowde McCarthy, J. H. The Kine Over the Water Harper. $1 McKinney, A_H Practical Pedagogy in the Sehool Revell. 50 cents net Sunday

Page 38

The Nation

Murray, R. H Revolutionary Ireland and Rolfe’s Satchel Guide to Europe. Its Settlement Macmillan. $3.25 net tion Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.5 “Pan Lost on the Trail Boston Lo- net thre Lee & Shepard $1.50 Sadi’s Bustan. Translated from the Persian Paterson, W. R The Old Dance Master. with introduction, by A. H. Edwards Dutton. 60 cents net. Samuel, A. Piranesi. Scribner. $5 net. Lond Chapman & Hall Per is, J. B. France in the American Rev- tion Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $2 net 1911 edi- Scheffel'’s Ekkehard—Audifax und Hadu- Phillips, D. G Tne Grain of Dust. Apple moth. Edited, with notes, by C. H. Hand- tor $1.30 net schin and W. F. Luebke. American Book Pe rd A. W Records of the English Co. 60 cents. Kh e Edited with an introduction. Schreiber. Lady Charlotte Schreiber’s Jour- Frowde nals. 2 vols. Lane. $12.50 net. Porterfield, A. W Karl Lebrecht Immer- Schreiner, O. Woman and Labor. Stokes. mann A Study in German Romanticism $1.25 net. Le ke & Buechner Skeat, W. W. The Place-Names of Berk- Rhoad N Maisie’s Merry Christmas shire Frowde. Boston: Lothrop. Lee & Shepard. $1 Slaught and Lennes. Solid Geometry. Bos- R W. and F. The Humbler Poets (second ton Allyn & Bacon. 75 cents serte Collection of Newspaper and Stratemeyer, FE Dave Porter and His Periodical Verse, 1885 to 1910. New edition. Rivals. Boston: Lothrop, Lee & Shepard. McClurg. $1.50 net $1.25

RECENTLY ISSUED BY HENRY HOLT & COMPANY *Net postage 8% additional NEW Helen R. Albee’s The Gleam A Spiritual Autobiography. 12mo. David Starr Jordan (Editor)—Leading American Men of Science $1.75.* Ostwald’s Natural Philosophy = $1.00.* Novicow’s War and Its Alleged Benefits $1.00." Alice Ravenhill and Catharine J. Schiff (Editors)— Household Administration in the Higher Education of Women $1.<0.* Pfungst’s Clever Hans (The Horse of Mr. Von Osten) duction by C. Stumpf and an illustration and 15 figures. Translated by Carl L. Rahn with a prefatory note by J. R. Angell and a table of references. $1.50.* Charles D. Hazen’s Europe Since 1815 Library Edition _$3.75.* The Turner Essays in American History Dedicated to Prof. Fred’k Jackson Turner and written by his former pupils. $1.50.*

Recent American Nature Series Books Fully illustrated R. W. Doane’s Insects and Disease

$1.50.* Helen R. Albee’s Hardy Plants for Cottage Gardens B. E. Fernow’s Care of Trees in Lawn, Street and Park D. S. Jordan’s Fish Stories V. L. Kellogg’s Insect Stories $1.60.* $2.00.* $1.75.* $1.50.*

For Travellers H. Stuart Jones’s Classical Rome (Grant Allen’s Historical Guides Series). With maps Clara C. Perkins’s The Builders of Spain— French Cathedrals and Chateaux $1.35.* Roth bool Max Vernon’s In and Out of Florence im new one volume editions Illustrated, $2.50.* Lucy Humphrey (Editor) — The Poetic Old World— The Poetic New World of poems for travellers, in full gilt, pocket volumes, with illus- Collection ‘ uniform with The Open Road Each: Cloth, $1.50*; leather,

: w w w : b 4 trated r-lining 99 60.° : Vusic, Drama, Etce.., W. J. Henderson’s Forerunners of Italian Opera ¢; 2<.* : Clayton Hamilton’s The Theory of the Theatre and Other Principles of Dramatic Criticism. $1.50.* F.E Schelling’s English Literature During the Lifetime of Shake- speare $2.50."

For Young Folks Half a Hundred Hero Tales Edited by FRANCIS STORR Except thirteen by Hawthorne and one by Bull- finch, these are new renditions of the class cal stories of Ulysses, Aineas, etc. Illus- ate . a 1 819 The Silver Thread and Other Folk Plays for Young People Ry Miss C. D. Mackay. Eight simple folk plays for the school room or ttlement, by the author of “The House of the Heart and Other Plays for Young Folks.” Fach. $1.10." A NEW UP.TO-DATE EDITION with 1,090 new Entries of Champlin’s Young Folks’ Cyclopaedia of Persons and Places rofusely illustrated 1,104 pp. $3.00 prepaid

Each with 64 illustrations. $3.00." | 34 West 33d St. YORK Bergson’s Creative Evolution Translated by Arthur Mitchell. 8vo. $2.50.* $1.35." A contribution to experimental animal and human psychology. With an intro-

Sutherland, H. V. The Woman Who Could: A Play with a Purpose. Desmond Fitz- Gerald Taine’s Les Origines de la France Contem- poraine. Edited by J. F. L. Raschen. American Beok Co. 60 cents. Taylor, H. O. The Mediwval Mind: A His- story of the Development of Thought and Emotion in the Middle Ages. 2 vols. Macmillan, $5. Weaver, L. Small Country Houses of To- day. Scribner. $5 net. Wilcox, D. F. Municipal Franchises. Vol. I! Engineering News Pub. Co. $5.50 net, Willey, A. Convergence in Evolution. Dut- ton. $2.50 net. Winans, Walter. The Art of Revolver Shoot- ing. New edition, rev'sed. Putnams. $5 net, Young, M. Somebody's Little Girl. Hinds; Noble & Eldredge. 50 cents.

(Just Published) QUICKSANDS A NOVEL By Fannie Heaslip Lea 12mo. Illustrated. $1.20 net. Brilliant dialogue, a subtle sense of the comic and the tragic, a graphic touch in the portrayal of an attractive group of people and their environ- ment, and, in general, a fine artistry, characterize this novel, which presents a_ recurring problem—a wife out of love with her husband and deep in love with another. How she contrives to save something of honor and happiness from ship- wreck is the theme of this en- grossing story. STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 E. 27th St., New York

The reminiscences of “the ambas- sador of international journal- iam," and “the foremost dip- lomatist of modern times. George W. Smalley European Correspondent of the “‘New York Tribune,”’ and sometime Ainerican Cor- respondent of the London ‘‘Times.’’ Anglo-American Memories Mr. Smalley’s long and active life has brought him into contact with celebrated men and women of leading position in Europe and America, and he has a first-hand knowledge, from the inside, of the chief political and social events of the past sixty years. “More even than Blowitz, was he the ambassador of international journal- ism. To them the exalted official world, usually inaccessible to most of their profession, was always open.” 8ro. IJilustrated. $2.50 net. G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS, S*Yonpon

BOOK-PLATES (Ex Libris). An Illustrated Catalogue of Old and Rare Armorial Book-Piates will be sent post free m reeeipt of six-pence (or twelve cents), This catalogue ts ilustrated with 85 reproductions of the various styles of the old plates, and it will be found useful to those interested In Genealogy as well as to the Book-Plate collector Cc. A Massey, 136 Upper Tulse Hill, London, England

Page 39

April 13, 1911] JohnBrown: ABiography Fifty Years After By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD SOME TRIBUTES TO THIS REMARKABLE HISTORICAL WORK PhiladetIphia PUBLIC LEDGER. “A tre mendous book; more thrilling then any book of fiction, powerful in its appeal. and which, while it is written soberly, as befits history, by the very nature of the narrative often rises to the highest dramatic tevel."’ THOMAS WENTWORTH HIGGINSON. “I can only say after reading from first to last its more than 700 pages that I bave never en countered anything this side of Gibbon’s ‘Rome’ which bas made me feel more the personal power of a single work.’ JOHN TT. MORSE, Editor American Statesmen Series, in ATLANTIC MONTHLY. “Perhaps in thus dramatically fashioning his volume, Mr. Villard obeyed an instinct rather than acted upom a preconceived plan; that is often the case with a great work, where a writer's feelings are deeply enlisted Be this as it may, the merit and charm are none the less; he bas seized well a splendid oppor- tunity and as written one of the great biogra- phies of our literature.”’ HORACE WHITE. ‘In my Judgment a con- tribution to American literature to take rank with the véry best historical writing of our time or any time. The only impartial history of the Kansas war."’ ST. CLAIR McKELWAY in the Brooklyn EAGLE. “A biography replete with facts and marked by Courage and candor, learning and justice."’ Portiand OREGONIAN. ‘‘The most valuable and comprehensive biography issued this season, and the best and most candid estimate of John Brown.”’ w. E,. CONNELLEY in the Topeka CAPITAL. ‘The unprejudiced student and seeker for truth will berald the book as a great contribution to American history.’’ Des Moines CAPITAL. ‘More powerful in its appeal, more @ramatic than any book of fiction, is this wonderful biography of Jobn Brown.”’ The North Carolina REVIEW. ‘In this biography Mr. Villard has touched high-water mark. The book is a delight to the reader for many reasons. Full of life and movement, . . written in an attractive and scholarly style, full of ‘sympathy and yet without any loss fn accurate presentation, it sets a new standard for bilo- graphical efforts.’’ Baltimore AMERICAN. ‘While the book hes popular features in that it is entrancingly interesting, its scholarship is of the highest order and its style reminds one a little of Anthony Froude. . .. Mr. Villard bas itus- trated in this book the finest ideals of literary conception and execution.’ Lendon TIMES. ‘‘It is scarcely likely that any later writer will be able either to add any- thing of importance to Mr. Villard’s collection | of material or to better bis interpretation of the whole story. . It at once becomes the standard, and probably the fifal authority on its theme.”’ Washington (D. C.) STAR. “Mr. Villard | draws a compact, vivid, historic picture of the terrible focussing of this period upon our Civil War. Straight and clear in ite literary way, this biography is a marvel of research and fair- mindednéss.’ eS WATTERSON in Loutsville | TER-JOURNAL. “No fault may justly be found with Mr. Villard’s felling of the story. It is minute and lucid, altogether fair and un- varnished."’ Burlington (lowa) HAWKEYE. ‘‘It is a book which will take a place in the library of every well established home in this part of the country.’ First Edition, October tnt; Second Edition, November 2tiat; Third Edition, March tiat. Pully illustrated with portraite and other illuea- trations. With copious notes and bibliography. $5.00 net. Postage 26 cents. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY BOSTON NEW YORK The Nation ‘*There can be no doubt that the Robert Hoe ‘ale will t of aggrecate totals, the greatest event in the of ite kind in the annals of Look Auctions.”’ From the LONDON TIMBS, Oct. 21, 110 THE FIRST SALE of the ta Robert Hoe Library Will Begin on MONDAY, APRIL 24th, 1911, and will continue through the following two weeks, excepting Saturdays and Sundays. Two Sessions will be held each day, beginning at 2.30 and 8.15 P. M., in the main gallery of the NEW BUILDING of THE INCUNABULA, : ANDERSON AUCTION COMPANY, at Madison Avenue and Fortieth Street, New York. This first and most important sale will constitute about one ILLUMINATED MANUSCRIPTS, HISTORICAL BINDINGS, EARLY ENGLISH LITERATURE, fourth of the entire Library, which numbers about 16,000 items and is made up from all classes of books in the collection, including RARE AMERICANA, FRENCH ILLUSTRATED BOOKS, EIGHTEENTH URY ENGLISH AUTHORS, AUTOGRAPHS, MANUSCRIPTS, ETC. (Ap THE CATALOGUE (illustrated) will be issued in four parts of about 600 pages each, with indices. Orders for the complete set will or $1.50 for each part. PARTI, IN TWO Y. Other parts will = be received at $5 per SECTIONS, IS Now R Y FOR DEL be issued prior to each sale. THE BXHIBITION at Madison avenue and 40th street will be open to intending buyers on and after APRIL 10TH. Expert infor mation will be given and commissions executed at the sale upon re quest. e The Anderson Auction Company, Madison Avenue at Fortieth Street and (ontil May 1) Twelve East Forty-sixth Street, NEW YORK. —s | fax Sse2sesS —_ J A WHITE PAPER GARDEN By SARA ANDREW SHAFER, Author of “Beyond Ohance of Chiinge,"’ etc Dictionaries, Gramfnars, “Its author is a garden lover of the books truest, who has read and felt and done 4 some good, wholesome thinking.’ —Chicago Inter-Ocean. our catalogues. FRENCH andITALIAN BOOKS barge Assortment of the Classics, and Phrase All the latest novels. Send for RITTER & FLEBBE, 120 Boylston St., Boston, Mass. Beautifully illustrated. Large 8vo, $2.50 net C. MECLURG & CO., CHICAGO THE INTEREST OF AMERICA IN \BARBAROUS MEXICO } Tu =. & ae telling the unvarnished truth about the tyranny |of Diaz and the helpless «slavery of the peons | Reenty engravings from photographs corroborate the story. Extra cloth, $1.50 postpaid Charles H. Kerr & Company, 118 West Kinzie St.. Chicago $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.60. INTERNATIONAL CONDITIONS ADMIRAL A. T. MAHAN’S new book. LITTLE, BROWN & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON BOOKS—aAll out of print books supplied. on “HOW TO If you have a MS. you desire matter on what subject; write me, stating books to issue send postal for th’ wanted; I can get you any book ever gree PUBLISH interesting work BROAD- WAY PUBLISHING CO. when in England, call and inspect my ste of - 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT ROKSHOP YOUR BOOK B25 BROADWAY, Y. Bend for catalogur John Bright St., Birmingham, England FORE of Celebrities Bought afd Sold TAUCHWITZ SCHOENHOF BOOKCO. gRITISH Autograph Send for price lists WALTER R. BENJAMIN BOOKS on T Street, Letters I Ag Fi Av., New vy ‘ROSTON, MASS. AUTHORS ‘ab. “Tue CoLtector,’”’ 1 yr A. 8. Clark, Peekskill, N. Y., is a buyer and seller of books, magazines, and pam Ky Alexander Francis AMERICANS: An Impression ohlets

Page 40

X1i The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2389 BOOKS BY HUGO DEVRIES The most important contribution to science by the greatest living botanist’’—New York Bun The Mutation Theory Experiments and Observations on the Origin of Species in the Vege- table Kingdom. (2 vols.) Numerous illustrations, colored plates. Translated by Prof. A. B. Farmer and A. D. Darbishire. Cloth, per volume, $4.00 net. Intracellular Pangenesis Including a paper on Fertilization and Hybridization. Trans- lated from the German by C. Stuart Gager. Cloth, $3.00 net. Species and Varieties, Their Origin by Mutation Edited by D. T. MacDougal. $5.00 net. (21s. net.) Plant-Breeding Comments on the Experiments of Nilsson and Burbank. Illus- trated. Cloth, gilt, $1.50 net; $1.70 postpaid. Special offer:—$12.00 buys the set, including a year’s subscription to The Monist, quarterly magazine. Open Court Publishing Company 623-633 Wabash Avenue, Chicago Ge UNITARIAN ADVANCE A MONTHLY MAGAZINE OF PROG- RESS IN RELIGION GrorGE H. Bapcer, Editor YOU have always taken it for granted, no doubt, that a re- ligious magazine must neces- sarily be heavy, dull and uninter- esting—though good! Some religious magazines are just that. We aim to make THE UNITARIAN ADVANCE different. We believe that Religion can be made the most interesting RECENT PUBLICATIONS THE COUNTRY CHURCH AND THE RURAL PROBLEM. By Kenyon L. Butterfield. A practical treatise on the oppor- tunities of the country minister. 165 pages, 12mo cloth; postpaid $1.08. THE HIGHER EDUCATION AS A TRAINING FOR BUSINESS. By Harry Pratt Judson. A sane and sober discussion of a much-abused topic. 56 pages, 12mo cloth; postpaid 55c. THE DEVELOPMENT OF PERSONALITY AS THE CHIEF AIM IN EDUCATION. By Thiselton Mark. Prof. Mark is a leading English authority in pedagogy, and his book is based on experience. 244 pages, 12mo cloth; postpaid $1.07. SIR PERCEVAL OF GALLES: A STUDY IN THE SOURCES OF THE LEGEND. By Reginald H. Griffith. 140 pages, 8vo cloth; postpaid $1.35. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS, CHICAGO, ILL. AGENTS—The Baker & Taylor Co., New York City. Cambridge University Press, London and Edinburgh. Th. Stauffer, Leipzig. thing in the world,—if you have the right sort of religion: eager; up-to-date; virile; not a thing of cant, but a reality; not an echo of old-time dogma, but a live-wire of tingling progress. CHIEFLY: are you not inter- ested to have the world progress in reason, justice, truth and free- dom: to have religion made hu- man, rational, honest to the core, | manfully invigorating, not thinly and softly sentimental, but stal- wartly enthusiastic, kindling, and dramatic in modern zest of | progress? The Spring Edurational Nimber of The Nation will be published May IIth Well, that is what THE UNI- “TARIAN ADVANCE is concerned with. Why not have a part in its | | enterprise? ! One Dollar a year; three months for 25e. THE UNITARIAN ADVANCE 104 East Twentieth Street New York

Page 41

April 13, ro1t| THE TUDOR FACSIMILE TEXTS “These co'lotypes are beautifully made and reproduce the originals as exactly as human ingenuity can effect.""—-Nation (New York). For all practicable purposes these texts are as and may be accepted with confi students who have no access to, the ifhenwum good as dence by originals."’ imerican Subecribere will please note that sizty- siz playe in folio and crown Ato have already been issued, Le., 23 VOLUMES MORE THAN THOSE FIRST ANNOUNCED. Full Hist on ap- plication. A NEW AND IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT THE “DOUBTFUL” PLAYS or THE Third Shakespeare Folio (excepting ‘Pericles’). first 4to’s, viz.:—‘The Lon- don Prodigal’—‘Lord Cromwell’—‘Sir John Old- castle’ (with the two title-pages, one ascribed to Shakespeare)——‘The Puritan,’ ‘A Yorkshire Tragedy’—‘Locrine.’ Facsimiled from the ete NOW READY, in 1 vol. Feap xvi and 362 in facsimile. 4to, pp. Price £2 12s. Gd. net, (This Collotype Facsimile is necessarily limited to 250 copies.) JOHN 8S, FARMER, Amersham, Bucks. Eng 260004. ‘ POPC SCCLe **In buying b: oks for our library we are _ pretty much governed by THE NATION; by its adver- } tising as well as its re- | views.”” —, Librarian, —— Publio Library. Seed like the frequently received by The Letters above are ~errrerrrerereereerererererereeeeeeee Nation, in whose columns IT PAYS TO ADVERTISE BOOKS As a weekly review of Lit- Art Peeve? erature, Science, and Politics, it reaches the the the thinker and the professional scholar, student, man, as well as the homes of people of intelligence; all book readers and book buyers. PRP PPPEPCLCLPPSLLPCLLCFPPFCC LLL ESLOPSSGISCLOOSOOOe : ‘ 4 . 4 . . 4 : ‘ 4 4 ‘ : ‘ . ‘ ‘ . : ‘ ‘ 4 . . ‘ ‘ ‘ q : ‘ ‘ a ‘ ‘ ‘ 4 ‘ ‘ ‘ 4 4 7 ‘ : : ‘ 4 4 ‘ 4 (SOO0000500656665565565660088888088 The Nation Xii b pede FOUR IMPORTANT SPRING BOOKS FOR SALE WHEREVER BOOKS ARE SOLD ording to the most trust the ltnited and, ace best ¢ dition of the In its worthy reports fourth large one books in selling States William Carleton’s ONE WAY OUT A Middle-Class New-Englander Emigrates to America “A really notable brief for democracy that everybody ought to read.” —Nation. “An engrossing, because a vitally human, story.”—J. B. Kerfoot, in Life. has most gripping appeal New York Times Vew York Observer. “A great adventure that “One of the strong books of the season “A very genuine inspiration.”—Outlook. “There are some fine suggestions, much food for thought, and a dra- matic story in the evolution of the theme.’—Literary Digest “A book worth forty novels.’"—William Marion Reedy in the St. Louis Mirror. $1.20 net; by mail, $1.32 ’ surprising and exciting tale of and Arnold Bennett’s mysterious jealousy, by many peopl con sidered the best story he has written THE GHOST By the author of “The Old Wives’ Tale,” “Buried Alive,” ete. Third large printing. $1.20 net; by mail, $1.32 b J eve and alluring tal of love, in Stephen Chalmers’ (1.0 0, 0" A PRINCE OF ROMANCE By the author of “When Love Calls Men to Arms,” ete Just published. $1.20 net; by mail, $1.52 “A new book by Stephen Chalmers is as welcome as the flowers in spring.’”—The Bellman. “The story of the young American's thrilling adventures and of the sacrifice he makes for love of a beautiful Scotch girl will hold the reader's rapt attention.”—Boston Globe wensely entertaining story of mystery Henry Second’s ()°°)" 0" CAPTIVATING MARY CARSTAIRS Just published. $1.30 net; by mail, $1.42 the quickly-moy Laurence Varney of fun in the “There's never a moment, from beginning to end of ing, well-told narrative when poor—in the end happy! isn't keeping the reader's attention agog. And there's a lot story, too.”--Chicago Record-Herald. SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY Publishers BOSTON VOLUME IX APRIL, 1911 NUMBER THE PRINCETON THEOLOGICAL REVIEW CONTENTS : THE CHURCH, HER COLLEGES AND THE CARNEGIE FOUNDATION: | W. 8S. PLromer Bryan, Pastor of the Church of the Covenant, Chicago. | ON THE BIBLICAL NOTION OF “RENEWAL: By Bensanwin BO Wa t fessor in Princeton Theological Semin THE ORIGIN OF THE FISH-SYMBOL: 1 ‘ KR. Money, Precey I mn University JALABERT’S “EPIGRAPHIE” AND GALLIO: Ey WeecaMm PB Auwe ‘ Professor in Princeton Theological Seminary REVIEWS OF RECENT LITERATURE A Quarterly Journal of Theology edited by the Faculty f Vrinceton The gical Seminary hor Bate © fa whe THE PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS, PRINCETON, N. J. Three dollars a year eighty cents a copy

Page 42

The Nation [Vol. 92, No. 2389 Announcing Lippincott’s New Spring Books A REMARKABLE BOOK OF ROYAL REMINISCENCES FROM MEMORY’S SHRINE The Reminiscences of CARMEN SYLVA H. M. QUEEN ELISABETH OF ROUMANIA In a series of chapters that are neither memoirs nor yet character sketches of the usual kind, Carmen Sylva ad- mits her readers to a shrine hitherto visited by herself alone. It is a sanctuary whose lares domestici are people, both of humble and of high estate, who left abiding impressions upon her mind when she was young, or who were the friends of later years The book is written with touching sincerity and simplicity all through. Vhotogravure Frontispiece and Eight Full-Page Illustrations. Decorated Cloth, Gilt Top. Uncut, $2.50 Net. An Unknown People in an Unknown Land _ Cliff Castles and Cave Dwellings of Europe By W. BARBROOKE GRUBB By 8S. BARING-GOULD, M.A. With #% Illastrations and a Map. Octavo. 330 Pages. With 10 Fall-Page Illustrations. Octavo. 319 pages. Cloth, 83.50 Net. Cloth. 83.50 Net. Seventeen Years Among the Sea Dyaks of Borneo By EDWIN H. GOMES, M.A. timate Association with the Natives of the Bornean Jungles. With 40 illustrations and a map. Octavo. 343 pages. Cloth, $3.50 net. Among Indian Rajahs and Ryots Oriental Cairo By SIR ANDREW H. L. FRASER, K.C.S.L., The City of the “Arabian Nights” Ex-Lieutenant-Governor of the Province of Bengal By DOUGLAS SLADEN With 34 Tilustrations and a Map. Svo. 168 Pages. With 63 Intimate Pictures, and the Newest Map of Cloth, 84.00 Net. Cairo. Large Svo. 417 Pages. Cloth, $5.00 net. A Short History of the United States Navy By Captain GEORGE R. CLARK, U.S.N., and others I hist has been written to present a record of exactly what happened without personal, sectional, or nat- ional prejudice, and to regard naval events from the professional rather than the picturesque point of view With 16 Foll-Page Ulustrations and Many Pictures in the Text. Cloth, #3.00 net. Ready in May. New Spring Novels READY SHORTLY—THE HIT OF THE LONDON SPRING SEASON PHRYNETTE By MARTHE TROLY-CURTIN on publication this refreshing novel took London by storm, and three large printings have already to meet the demand. It tells in a delightful way the impressions and experiences of a French miss of oes to London to live. The author's style is brisk and snappy, there is irresistible humor in places, and a interest throughout, Colored Frontispiece by Frank Desch. 12mo. Decorated Cloth, $1.25 net. FOURTH LARGE PRINTING SECOND PRINTING “ME—SMITH” THE GOLD BAG By CAROLYN WELLS CAROLINE LOCKHART An 18-kt detective novel by the author of “The Clue.” Colored Frontispiece. Cloth, Picture Inlay, $1.20 net. The trongeat. most onsistent tory of the west which hee 0pm ared in year ond ta many important potate excels OUT OF RUSSIA Virginian yorthiest predecessor in the same field.” Peet i Chicago Daily News By CRITTENDEN MARRIOTT \ stirring novel by the author of “The Isle of Dead Ships.” Five Illustrations. Cloth, $1.20 Net. Four Illustrations. Cloth, 81.25 Net. EIGHTH LARGE EDITION—JUST ISSUED ROUTLEDGE RIDES ALONE By WILL LEVINGTON COMFORT \ year-old novel etill gaining in sales and winning enthusiasm with the force and certainty of a classic Decorated Cloth, $1.50. { SHE BUILDETH HER HOUSE By Will L. Comfort COMING IN MAY { IN HER OWN RIGHT By John Reed Scott J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Pablishers, PHILADELPHIA

Page 43