The Nation 1911-03-30: Vol 92 Iss 2387
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENERAL LIBRARY; UNIV. OF MICH. WAR 81 1911 VOL. XCIL—NO. 2387 THURSDAY, MARCH 30, 1911 Res. U8. = PRICE 4 2 ae NTS PUTNAMS NEW BOOKS Little Cities of Italy Florence—San Gimignano— Monte Oliveto — Pisa--Lucca — Prato — Pistoia— Arezzo — Lecco Bergamo —Brescia—~ Verona—Vicenza~— Padua Mantua Argua By ANDRE MAUREL With a Preface by Guglielmo Ferrero Through the country of Tuscany and Venice, as the two main divisions of his work are entitled, M. Maurel has wandered from town to town, painting in vivid colors his impressions of their historical and artistic aspects, showing with keen insight how closeiy allied are these, what each owes to the other, and how indebted is the pres- ent to both. To the lover of Italy the book will afford fresh delight, and to those whose Italy consists only of Venice, Florence, Rome, and Naples these little sketches will open new and charming fields of interest. Fully Illustrated, $2.50 net. The Record of a Vigorous Life S 2 ee chools of Painting > . . "ar lo Am By MARY INNES. Edited, with a chapter on Schools of Ang erican Memories Painting in America, and certain further additional ma- By GEORGE W. SMALLEY, M.A. terial, by CHARLES Dr Kay Portrait. $2.50 net. 8ro, 106 Illustrations. Probable price. $2.50 net. These reminiscences range over a long period, and are This book offers a general view of the development of concerned with men of exceptional mark and position in painting in Europe from the first century Aa. Db. to the be- Europe and America whom the author has met, and with ginning of the nineteenth It supplies an historical back- events in politics and journalism of which he has personal ground to the art movements in various countries, so that knowledge. His long connection with the New York Tribune the influence of one school upon another may be rightly gave him an unique experience, and the opportunity of meet- judged. A brief biography is given of the prominent painters ing the more prominent men in the two continents; and what in each school, with a description of their most famous pic- he has to say of leading events of the last sixty years is tures and an appreciation of their work suggestive and more than usually interesting. The Lowell Lectures, 1910 . . *,* John Ruskin Republican Tradition in Europe Art Critic, Social Reformer, etc. Being a Series of Lec- By HERBERT A. L. FISHER. 8r0, $2.00 net. tures given in the University of Cambridge. By ARTHUR Mr. Fisher describes the course of Republican ideas in CHRISTOPHER BENSON. $1.56 net. Europe from the fall of the Roman Empire to the foundation “I have written these pages with the desire of provoking of the Republic of Portugal. The mediwval theory of gov- a discriminating interest in the man’s life and work, with ernment, the Italian republics, the rise of the Dutch State a desire to present a picture of one of the most suggestive the English Commonwealth, the French Revolution and its thinkers, the most beautiful writers, and the most vivid per- effects, the republican movements in Germany, Italy, Spain sonalities of the last generation.”—From the Preface, and Norway come under review. In the final chapter some explanation is offered of the decline of European Republican In the Time of the Pharaohs | “"~")." By ALEXANDRE MORET, Sub-Director of the Musée Behind the Screens in Japan Guimet, Professor of Egyptology in I’'Ecole des Hautes An Ww ’ : Etudes. Translated by Mme. Moret. wig tg eng hace eas y & 7. > d 3 ry) ne 8vo, with 16 illustrations. Probable price, $2.00 net. - The book is no surface picture of Japanese life, but a The first concern of the traveller in Egypt is to get some penetrating study of the country and its people based on a information about the ancient civilization—the political long residence in the land of the cherry blossom It plerces tenets, the diplomatic practices, the religious beliefs of the the thin coat of modernism with which tne little brown peo- people that of old inhabited the land; where these people ple of the East have industriously overlaid their ancient came from and when they came, what they brought with ‘ ° : ; agree on customs, and gives an unvarnished account of the sub-surface them and what they acquired; how they raised the time- aspects of Japanese life and character. Every page of the defying pyramids and the colossal temples, and what prompt- sila , om , th » embne book vibrates with life and scarcely one but has a spi of ed them to expend such Herculean efforts on these monu- ments; what literature they produced and what myths they - ™ | M handed down; what their ideas were of the present and of C m the hereafter. All this is set forth in Moret’s volume, and ri ina an much more that will prove invaluable to an appreciation of | According to the Classification of Cesare Lombroso. the country. Briefly summarized by his daughter, Gina Lombroso Ferrero. Crown &ro. Probable price, $1.40 net 2 Charles Il. and His Court Signora Guglielmo Ferrero’s résumé of her father’s work on criminal anthropology is specially dedicated to all those By A.C. A. BRETT, B.A. With 16 Illustrations. 8v0, $3.50 net. whose office it is to correct, reform, and punish tne criminal Portrays vividly and in some detail the life of Charles II. with a view to diminishing the injury caused to society by and his Court, dwelling on the personal and social side of his anti-social acts: also to superintendents, teachers, and their life rather than on the political questions involved. A those engaged in rescuing orphans and children of vicious detailed account is given of the flight after the battle of habits. as a guide in checking the development of evil germs Worcester. The final chapter discusses the mysteries of and eliminating incorrigible subjects whose example is a Charles's death and personality. source of corruption to others a4andewern ss, G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS x, neatora’st? strana humor
Page 2
The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2387 The Nation THE APRIL NUMBER OF THE HARVARD THEOLOGICAL REVIEW contains, besides other articles, the following: ITALIAN MODERNISM, SOCIAL AND RELIGIOUS FOUNDED IN 1865. By PROFESSOR WILLIAM F. BADB. A full and striking account of the history and present phases tf 1 at the New York City Post Office as movement by a trustworthy and unusually well-informed writer. il matter.] ) JESUS AS LORD By PROFESSOR BENJAMIN W. BACON. A noteworthy discussion of important questions connected with the origin of The tion is published and owned by the New the Church doctrine of the Person of Christ Secthens Saikano. Waacen Gee UNIVERSITY SETTLEMENTS IN GREAT BRITAIN A WEEKLY JOURNAL. of the Modernist - nid-« - Ir lent William J Elmer Mor Editor By PERCY ASHLEY. An elaborate and encouraging survey of the work of the British settlements by a sometime resident of the Passmore Edwards Settlement. Th lollara per year in advance poatpaid, in any port of the United States or Mexico; to Canada | Published by Harvard University, Cambridge, Massachusetts Loo and 0 foreagr countrica compriact t . } set tate oso. o" a FOR SALE AT THE NEWS-STANDS iddreas THE NATION, Box 794, New York I’ cation Office 20 Vesey Street Educational Educational | THE UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL, CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGEAMCIES. Everett 0. Fisk & Co., Rypestotese. THE WEEK ) wap Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washi Balt 307 CHAIR OF GERMAN be'Fitth ave. "New York 611 Swetland i Bla, Portland EDITORIAL ARTICt The Council tnvite applications yay chatr. iJackson Biv, ey ee ae Bericics MITORIAL ARTICLES: The salary is fixed at not less than £600 per an- ress . num. The duties of the chair will be entered upon Gens to cay oss above Ser Agenty Mesual. Peace Agreements .seeee 310/}0n October 1, 1911 Progress in Italy eens Te Applications together with the names of three! ° rhe Bible Tercentenary ...ss. 311 | Persons to whom reference may be made, and (if ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY The Exchange of Professors 312 | the candidate so desires) twelve copies of testi-| Supplies schools of all grades with competent Applied Literature 313 monials should be forwarded to the undersigned | teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining positions. sseee* S29 on or before Sth May, 1911. Original documents | gong for Bulletin No. 20. should not be forwarded HARLAN P. FRENCH. 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y. : SPECIAL ARTICLES: Women are eligible for any office in the Uni | 3 versity. | — Paris Book Notes 314 P. HEBBLETHWAITE, M. A., REGISTRAR. | UTORING i Cambridge for admission News for Bibliophiles Se, to College. Entire charge of boys throughout { | e- Summer in the country. Successful experience. 3 Best references. Address M. C. 8., The Nation. CORRESPONDENCE: THE UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL, | a hoe LECTURESHIP IN PHILOSOPHY | reau 15 | Shakespeare and Raleig 3 pee |THE NEW HUDSON i gh see ae . rite s Le Jol : » tne oe ae : The Council Invite applications for thi aC- | { ohn Taylor “of Caroline” . .seeeees 816) tureship. The salary Is fixed at £250 per annum | SHAKESPEARE Oriental Poetry 316) with a one-third share of fees. The duties of the | 7 Lectureship will be entered upon on October 1,| ff Offers interesting and valuable edi- LITERATURB: 1911 Applications, together with the names of | torial material, together with at- ‘ ‘ , three persons to whom reference may be made, and tractiveness in mechanical finish. The ; Modern Greek Folklore and Ancient (if the candidate so desires) twelve copies of tes plays recently added to the series are: Greek Religion -eesees $17) timonials should be forwarded to the undersigned MIDSUMMER NIGHT’S DREAM ; Deury the Audacious ee 318 | on or before April 22, 1911 Women are eligible TWELFTH NIGHT | Adventure oe. B18! for any office in the University | KING LEAR a The Andersons oetee ae P. HEBBLETHWAITE, M.A., Registrar. | Each volume, 50 cents. 4 Bassett: A Village Chronicle ........ 318 GINN & COMPANY, 29 Beacon St., Boston Lectures on the French Revolution 318 |@ One Way Out ile 220 Giray Days and Gold : .. 321 | Cecil Rhodes. His Private Life ...... 321| Just Published | PRINCIPLES OF ‘ _ .o TLATIN SIGHT READING INTERNATIONAL LAW ian By T. J. LAWRENCE, aoa on YEAR | pate Lecturer on International Law at the Roya ScIENCE SECOND Naval War College; sometime Professor in ’ Cloth, 12mo, 196 pages. Price, 30 cents, the University of Chicago. 3 Under the Open Sky—Birds of the The fourth edition of this authoritative work : Loch and Mountain 324 Combining the text editions of revised and rewritten, is now ready. ; twenty-five Lives of Nepos, and Epi- oh nce el og come . DRAM ‘ ae ‘Mw , in » C. > r CO.. Publishers, LAMA sodes from Caesar’s Civil War, suit BOSTON, NEW YORK. CHICAGO The Doctor's Dilemma, Getting Mar ed for sight reading in the second ried, and the Shewing-up of Blanco year , aor . By Joun KENNETH ' . 1 “ = ‘ c 1568-1642 3 : _BARBAROUS MEXICO | Turner. The only book gtish Dramatic Companies, 1558-1642 326 telling the unvarnished truth about the tyranny i AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY of Diaz and the helpless slavery of the peons. ; Twenty engravings from photographs corroborate Music: New York Cincinnati Chicago the story. Extra cloth, $1.50 postpaid. Charles H. Kerr & Company, 118 West Kinzie St., Chicago. Ariane and Blue Beard’ 327 "'* o Read the Futur soo | temporary form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, with “The Nation” stamped on the side in ' ¥ *® I gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and as 2 uate af Was Snaaen nae on Ge adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75c. 1 Avenue de l'Opéra in Londot rn ! Stevens & Brown 4 Trafalgar To receive the current numbers i READING CASE FOR THE NATION THE NATION 20 Vesey Street, N. Y. City n a convenient
Page 3
va oe eens ae ae ae March 30, 1911] The Nation THE TEMPLE CLASSICS | a S58 VOLUMES od va ne ee TT EA OODS anp THEIR frontispiece, a decorative title-page. and a ribbon bookmark; where advisable, editorial appendices and marginals, also. PRICES: In cloth, each volume 45 cts. Net | In limp leather, each volume 65 cts Net E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 81 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORK She A E The Origin, Manufac ture and Composition of Food Products, Detection stor dition of Common Adulterations. Food Standards. rs) P ts » Chief Chemiat, U. &. Department y oe By HARVEY W. WILEY, M.D. |e ee is the best for schools and colleges. 99 vols. List price, G0c. per vob.; price to schools, 40c There is no other man better qualified to write on the subject or who has SEND FOR LIST. had the extensive experience of Dr. Wiley Thomas Y.Crowell &Co.,Ne“ York 11 Colored Plates and 87 Other Illustrations. Second Edition. Octavo: 641 pages. Cloth, 4.00 net. THE BOOK OF THE YEAR What Eight Million Women Want Synopsis of Contents—/ntroduction.._Meats.—Poultry and Game Birds. By RHETA CHILDE DORR. —Fish Foods.—Milk and Milk Products.—Cereal Foods.—Infants' and Invalids’ Illustrated, $2.00 net; postage 20 cents . » > eel” , d Unique in every way. A complete survey of the Foods.—Vegetables, Fruits, Spices, Nuts, etc.—Sugar and Honey.—Detection ideals and accomplishments of the effective, think of Common Adulterations.—Food Standards.—indec. ing women of our time. Not a woman's suffrage book, but far broader. Essentially constructive No one who wants to know exactly what womer are doing can afford to miss this notable volume Orders may be sent to any bookseller; or upon receipt of price we SMALL, MAYNARD & COMPANY, Boston will forward to any address, postage or express charges prepaid. The book will be found on sale at The Baker & Taylor Co., 33 East 17th Street . ay ne ha (—_- Tt . Wm. R. Jenkins Co., 851 Sirth Avenue; G. E. Stechert & Co., 151 West d s rue ci ‘ . - » . ° . . . oA : Asmertal Beck-Plates will be seat pest free 20th Street, and G. P. Putnam's Sons, 2, 4 and 6 West 45th Street, on receipt of six-pence (or twelve cents) This New York. catalogue is illustrated with 85 reproductions of the various styles of the old plates, and it will ts Sail at" he Bork Hie steer “eX TP, BLAKISTON’S SON & CO., Publishers, 30/2 }¥a!rv',s¢ Massey, 136 Upper Tulse Hill, Londe on, — The only biography of the founder of modern Socialism, KARL MARX:| American Academy of Political and Sorial Science HIS LIFE AND WORK, by John iianiciiaiitien. ‘a Spargo, $2.50 net; $2.70 carriage paid. B. W. | IMPORTANT VOLUME ON THE INTEREST OF AMERICA IN || INTERNATIONAL CONDITIONS | co TERNATIONAL COMDTTIONS |! ARETE DUBLIC HEALTH $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.60. uma n MOVEMENT Read L. M. Montgomery's New Book. KILMENY OF THE ORCHARD | PART I.—THE GENERAL PROBLEM By the author of “ANNE of GREEN GABLES” (234 Printing) | PART 1I.—DISEASE CARRIERS “ANNE OF AVONLEA” (12th Printing) THe Controt or Causes. ! PART IIL—ELIMINATION OF DISEASE I=: PuysicaL Care OF INDIVIDUALS. FOREIGN ccoennor soox co. "surrey BOOKS "soem Ssc" AUTHORS Price, $1.00, paper $1.50, cloth | AMERICANS: An Impression Catalogue of Publications sent upon application. By Alexander Francis. ADDRESS WEST PHILADELPHIA POSTOFFICE, Philadelphia, Penn, or | BOOKS—All out of print books supplied, p matter on what subject; Tite me, stating hocks THE NATION icin ttocas: | The Corsican when in England all and inapect my ste of | 50.000 rare books BAKER’ 8 GREAT ROOKSHOP - NAPOLEON'S DIARY One of the great diaries of litera- | John Bright St., Birmingham, England will be sent to any address for | ture."—New York Times. (Four impressions) several weeks “HOW TO If you have a MS you desire to meee ne — ye, a ths WITHOUT CHARGE == PUBLISH. Wai Suniisus8e’tS FRENCH andITALIAN BOOKS ADDRESS YOUR BOOK” 25 prospway, Large Assortment of the Classics, . Dictionaries, Grammars, and Phrase | | e L ; EC "'LETE ox, / H E N A | O N penn a, oe sow Come , te tomate books. All the latest novels. Send for r+ be matled for examination to at ipplieant our catalogues. New York City | pitti, h? ARP BOTH. The Pine Street.” RITTER & FLEBBE, 120 Boylston St., Boston, Mass. Phil idelphia 20 Vesey Street
Page 4
The Nation [Vol. 92, No. 2387 (ae nnn ——— — — A REMARKABLE oe ae ae PUBLISHED FROM MEMORY’S SHRINE The Reminiscences of CARMEN SYLVA H. M. QUEEN ELISABETH OF ROUMANIA Translated from the German, by Her Majesty’s desire, by her former Secretary, Edith Hopkirk. — — . — In the preface to this remarkable book, Her Majesty expresses herself as follows :— “T am about to throw open the sanctuary I have so long jealously guarded from the world the private chapel within whose niches my memories are enshrined. Those to whom I pay constant tribute of love and gratitude were either the idols of my early youth or the friends of riper years. I shall try to show them as they appeared to me on earth, in every varying aspect, according to season and circumstance, and to the changes of my own mood and habits of thought during the different stages of my mental development. To my youthful enthusiasm many of them became types of perfection, in whom I could dis- cern no human weakness; to have known them was my pride and happiness. All that was best in myself I attribute to their influence.” With a Photogravure Frontispiece and Eight Full-page Illustrations. Demy 8vo. Cloth, gilt top, uncut, $2.50 net. Postpaid, $2.65. Publishers ps B. LIP P INCOTT COMP ANY Philadelphia —— ——_____— SN THIRD EDITION NOW READY JOHN BROWN: A BIOGRAPHY FIFTY YEARS AFTER By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD Some Tributes to this Remarkable Historical Work Philadeiphia PUBLIC LEDGER. “A tremendous bok: mac! Des Moines CAPITAL, “More powerful in its appeal, more thrilling than any beek of fetion, powerful in its apoeal, and dramatic than any book of fiction, is this wonderful biography of which, while it is written soberly, as befits history, by the very John Brown."’ mture of the € rime - ( * level *’ : 7 f r t parrative, often rises to the highest dramatic level The North Carolina REVIEW. “In this biography Mr. Vil- THOMAS WE NTWORTH HIGGINSON,. “I can only = say lard has touched high-water mark. The book is a delight to the ifter vending from first to last its more than 700 pages that I reader for many reasons. Full of life and movement, . hav n r encountered anything thia «ide of Gibbon's ‘Rome’ written Ip an attractive and scholarly style, full of sympathy and wh ch hen made me feel more the personal power of a single yet without any loss in accurate presentation, it sets a new wi rk standard for biographical efforts."’ JOUN T. MORSE, Editor — Statesmen Series, in paltimore AMERICAN. “While the book has popular features ATLANTIC MONTHLY Perhaps in thus dramatically in that it is entrancingly interesting, its scholarship is of the fashiontn m hie volume Mr. Villard obeyed an instinct rather highest order and {ts style reminds one a little of Anthony Froude. than acted upon a preconceived plan that je often the case with , . Mr. Villard has illustrated in this book the finest ideale great work, where a writer's feelings are deeply enlisted. Be of literary conception and execution.’ this ae it may, the merit and charm are none the less; he has cle] well «a splendid opportunity and has written one of the London TIMES “It ts scarcely likely that any later writer will great biographies of our literature." be able either” to add anything of importance to > Rg HORACE WHITE. “In my judgment a contribution to American collection of material or to better his interpretation of t whole literature to take rank with the very best historical writing of story. . . It at once hecomes the standard, and probably the our time or any time. The only impartial history of the Kansas final authority on ite theme.’ war.’ Washington (D. C.) STAR. ‘Mr. Vie, Goes o oa, ST. CLAIR MeKELWAY tn the Brooklyn EAGLE. “A vivid, historie picture of the terrible focussing of this per biography replete with facta and marked by courage ond candor, upon our Civil War. Straight and clear In its literary way. this learning and justice." biography is a marvel of research and fair-mindedness.’ Portiand ORBEGONTAN, ‘The most valuable and comprehensive HENRY WATTERSON in Loulaville COURTER-JOURNAL Hography leaned ie Senne | the best and most candid esti ‘No fault may justly be found with Mr. Villard’s telling of the — ay Senn ALA oe ee 5 qlee = story It is minote and tucid, altogether fair and unvarnished.’ W. FE. CONNELLEY tm the Tepeka CAPITAL, “The un Burlington (lowa) HAWKEYE. ‘It is a book which will prejudiced «tudent and seeker for truth will herald the book as a take a place in the brary of every well established home in this great contribution te American bhietory."’ pert of the country.’ First Edition, October 1st; Second Edition, November 21st; Third Edition, March Ist Fully (lustrated with portratte and other illustrations, With copious notes and didiography. $5.00 net. Postage 26 cents. Boston HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY New York t | ee een A a nt
Page 5
ae et ermine ee oa wn sien rae ae The Nation NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MARCH 30, 1911. ———— a The Week Whatever comes in Mexico, the Unit- ed States Government should be actuat- ed by its own settled policy of friendli- ness towards its sister republics and by the law of nations, and not by the size of our capital invested. If the invest- ment of a certain sum gives one na- tion the privilege of exercising unusual rights or powers, who is to say what that sum shall be? In what text-book is its size stated? Shall it be 50 millions, or 100, or 1,000? And does it vary ac- cording to the size of the country in which itis invested? A policy that would irretrievably disgrace this country would be one dictated by those who have en- trusted their moneys to Mexican hands. We have but to recall to our readers the price England paid for her war in South Africa, undertaken in behalf of the South African mine-owners, to re- mind them at what fearful cost a nation permits its foreign policy to be shaped by those who have a financiai interest. The very worst advisers in such a case are the men who have a money stake, for that blinds men more quickly than anything else to justice and humanity. The fact that the Mexican situation appears to be improving does not make this any the less fitting time to empha- size these truths. The danger in our mind is that the people as a whole, and not a few magnates, will become im- bued with the idea that large property holdings in Mexico give sanction to President Taft's action; that to the pro- tection of those outlying Americans must be shaped our whole policy toward Mexico—that we may even set a date when the rebellion must cease. To do this would be to substitute for the law of nations the law of the jungle. Europe itself has recently af- forded a useful example. When the monarchy of Portugal fell, anarchy reigned for a few days, and there were | grave doubts as to the stability of the new republic. No one in the great and powerful adjacent republic of France,|to be especially commended for holding | and the “contributory negiigence’ whose citizens are heavy investors in Portuguese government securities and | commercial enterprises, then dreamed of menacing that country by rushing a French army corps to the border. His- toric international policy was not to be affected in a moment because some French citizens might lose their all in Portugal. Foolish as have been the rumors con- necting the movement of troops to the Mexican border with the possibility of trouble with Japan, President Taft has done wisely in taking an early opportu- nity, upon his return to Washington, to set them at rest. It is stated that Baron Uchida, the Japanese Ambassador, in reply to the President's words of cor- diality and friendship, assured Mr. Taft that he had attached no importance to the reports; end it may be added that nobody else had done so whose opinion is worth taking into account. The trou- ble about the spread of such rumors, however, is that, unsubstantial and ab- surd as they may be, they are apt to leave a vague residuum in the public mind, which is of no consequence at the time but may go far, on some future oc- casion when trouble seems actually brewing, to aggravate the situation. It is well, therefore, to put a quietus on i} the matter at the earliest possible mo- ment, It was fitting that Mr. Roosevelt in his address a week ago at the Univer- sity of California on “the higher educa tion,” should have dwelt upon the high- er law in international relations. This law is, of course, that when you see any- thing you want, you are to take it. “I took the Canal Zone,” declared Mr. Roosevelt, “and let Congress debate.” This way of doing it, he explained, was much better than the “traditional, con- servative methods,” by which it is plain that he meant the legal methods. For ‘jaying down this doctrine, Mr, Roose- velt deserves at least praise for frank- ness. He sets an example of telling the truth. When he says, “I took it,” every- body knows that he is stating the exact fact, and that there is no need of look- ing further to fix the responsibility for the theft. And the ex-President is also up his own precedent before young men in pursuit of a liberal education. Their =—— = : ee] ' great temptation is to entertain so many scruples about laws and treaties and national honor that their resolution be- comes sicklied o’er, and they hesitate too long when there is a fine chance to steal foreign territory. As Mr. Roose- velt wrote to Sir Henry Johnston in 1908, “this people of ours simply does not understand how things are outside our own boundaries,” and “the worst of it is that the educated Northeasterners are not merely blind, but often malevo- lently blind, to what goes on.” At any rate, Mr. Roosevelt has now done his best to open the eyes of the malevolent- ly blind to what was going on when he “took” the Canal Zone. That the decision of the Court of Ap peals, declaring unconstitutional the Workmen's Compensation act passed by the last Legislature, is discouraging to those impressed with the urgent need of the object in view, cannot be denied. It is particularly discouraging because the act was framed with the greatest care by an unusually able commission fully impressed with the nece y of yiding as far a is | dle | a pie of legislation the dar r oO 1 nulment on constitutiona yund ind finall it must } I b pro nounced ) ~ lraging « for Lhe reason I l { ) I il lil Si d i the to be nm Vv i tion of a provision contained not only in the Constitution of this State but Iso in the Constitution of the United States In some respect however, the decision justifies a much m encouraging view. For the court, while declaring that the law, in making the employer in hazardous occupations iiable to the employee even for injur- ies for which the former was in no way to blame, runs counter to the Constitu- tional prohibition against taking prop erty without due process of law, shows in the strongest way a disposition to ap- prove any measure for the like purpose against which this objection does not clearly lie. It points out that it Its within the competency of the Legisla- ture to abrogate, as this act does in ef- fect, both the “fellow-servant” doctrine ’ rule, ‘in spite of the fact that these have here- i'tofore been settled parts of the juris-
Page 6
308 The Nation [Vol 92, No. 2387 prudence of this State and country. “We|/serve to remind us that the medical entertain,” says the court, “an earnest | profession has had its martyrs. They desire to present no purely technical or |come to the front in time of war and hypercritical obstacles to any plan for epidemic, but they are also called upon the beneficent reformation of a branch |to pay their price in the ordinary daily of our jurisprudence in which, it must be conceded, reform is a consummation devoutly to be wished.” It may confi- dently be expected that the effect of this attitude of the Court of Appeals will be to cause the lower courts hereafter so to liberalize their position, so to dimin- ish the rigidity of traditional rules, that the laws in their actual operation will be in effect essentially modified and re- formed. Renewed evidence, if any were need- ed, of Grover Cleveland is held by his coun- the of the honor in which the memory trymen has been furnished in prompt completion of the fund of $100,- 000, contributed chiefly in small sums, for the erection of a Cleveland memor- ial tower at Princeton University. The contributions came from all parts of the country, and the amount was complet- | ed on Cleveland’s seventy-fourth birth- day. Few things are more encouraging as to the future of our country than the fact that this strong and simple nature, this career of steady and unshowy pa- triotism, this record of quiet and persis tent fidelity to principle without refer- ence to the changing moods and fash- ions of the time, should have made upon the nation so deep and lasting an im- pression. From the beginning of his | practice. It is difficult to conceive a |higher form of courage than is evinced ‘by the men who have inoculated them- selves with the germ of yellow fever and other dread diseases in order to |serve science and humanity. The two victims of meningitis must have known the danger they ran in going about their work among the infected immigrants. And that points to a moral. The charge of wanton cruelty to animals will not hold against scientific investigators who, when the need comes, will not hesitate 'to stake their own lives. The world has | come to hold that martyrdom is a good test of truth because it is an infallible jtest of sincerity. If medical investiga- tors contented themselves with cutting up little dogs and never took chances in person, there would be better ground for the charge. Readers of John Mitchell’s address on “Industrial Accidents, and Compensa- tion to Workmen for Losses Caused by Them” cannot fai] to be impressed by iis admirable tone as well as by its sub- stance. The facts of the case speak for themselves, if only they are adequately brought home to the minds and hearts |of the people; and Mr. Mitchell does not find it necessary to stir up passion by | accusations of inhuman wickedness or public career, when he buckled down to|preternatural greed against American the task of cleaning up the city govern-|employers and capitalists. Without en- ment of Buffalo, to the end of it, when | tering into any question of the degree of he upheld the cause of|moral culpability either on their part, President | | | as honest money in the face of overwhelm- ing hostility temptible vacillation in the opposite | of indifference on the subject—Mr. party, was always the same single-| Mitchell urges that a large proportion minded and devoted public servant. | uf the vast suffering and loss annually What made this record the more nota- | caused by industrial accidents in this ble was the fact that his attachment to|country is demonstrably preventable by his party was almost as strong as his|entirely practicable measures. This is It was al-|shown by such facts as that, while for or on that of the general public—which in his own and of con-| has certainly shown a lamentable degree attachment to his country. ways perfectly clear that he valued the|each 10,000 men employed in European preservation of the party as much as/|mines fourteen are killed annually, the | did the noblest “regular” of them all,|number of such fatalities in this coun- but that when a higher duty was manl- ‘try is thirty-four for each 10,000. Both fest he could not hesitate as to which /|io the enforcement of preventive meas- call was to be obeyed. |ures and in the reform of the laws re- |lating to workmen's compensation for Two young New York physicians were ‘injuries incurred in their work, we are killed Their Mitchell great as Mr. the week the within a by meningitis. | unquestionably, says, deaths in line of duty may diegracefully behind indus- >. trial nations of Europe, and this is a ccndition that cries out for remedy. We can think of. no more efficient agency for speeding the improvement than just such sane, and at the same time em- phatic, advocacy on the part of the real lator leaders as is exemplified by Mr. Mitchell in this address. The charge made against Booker Washington the other day was in every particular so wildly improbable that we are quite sure that there has been, among right-minded persons, not one in ten thousand who did not instantly re- ject it as false. Even if his past life had been merely one of ordinary re- spectability, the flimsy basis on which he was accused of having done a thing at once so queer and unusual, so wholly without rational motive of any kind, would put the matter beyond the need of discussion. This would be so even if we were to give Mr. Washington the benefit merely of that degree of consid- eration which is due to any person who has enjoyed an unblemished reputation throughout a long and active life. When, however, the case is that of a man who has done a great work, bringing him into continual contact with hundreds of persons in every station of life, and who has extorted, by sheer force of character and ability, the esteem and admiration of the white South in the face of every possible prejudice, the idea of permit- ting any shadow of doubt to cloud his name in consequence of a silly tale like that of the Ulrichs is one that can only arouse indignation. That their tale is the result of some stupid blunder on their part is highly probable; but from the details concerning Ulrich that have come out in the press since the assault occurred, it appears that the source of the story is even lower than might have ~ been inferred from the story itself. It is easy to sympathize with Mr. Roosevelt in his feeling about the ne- cessity of the recall as a remedy for conditions which have been shown to exist in the California judiciary; but it is easy also to sympathize with those who resort to lynching as a cure for similar evils. The question that a man has to ask himself, if he has a proper sense of the highest responsibilities of citizenship, is whether the attainment of the immediate end will compensate
Page 7
March 30, 1911] The Nation a for the violation of a principle of per- | The relations between the Italian TMahent and fundamental importance. Government and the Vatican at the be- ‘The real argument against the lynching ginning of the national jubilee will not of a corrupt boss, for example, is not | be improved by the inclusion of a strong only that it is lawless—there are times | Socialist element in the newly consti- of desperate need when it may be that tuted Giolitti Ministry. We need not even lawlessness is justifiable—but that accept seriously the rumor that Papal if a people is incapable of saving itself | disapproval of the celebration is to from misgovernment by the vote it will | take the form of closing the treasures of Lot long be saved from it by the killing ‘the Vatican to the public. The issues at of some victim of its wrath. And so in | stake are not to be fought out in so the matter of the recall of the judiciary. childish a fashion, especially if the new Ii is of the very essence of the judge's | Cabinet, as is probable, should be driven functions that he pass judgment without | to initiate an anti-clerical campaign. fear as well as without favor; and the | Thus far the astute Signor Giolitti has oply way to get good judges is to elect | refused to be drawn into war against the ©r appoint men who can be trusted. If a ‘Church. But it may be that he recog- people has failed to establish such stan-/nizes the favorable moment to be at | derds in the judiciary, the task must be hand. If, in the midst of general re- undertaken, however slow and laborious joicing over united Italy’s first half-cen- it may be, of toning up public sentiment |tury, the Vatican should hold itself 2nd public intelligence to the point at | apart, it would require no particularly ‘vhich these standards will be insisted | sxi}ful politician to stir popular discon- on. The short cut of the recall may|tent with the Curia to intenser activ- temporarily accomplish the result much | ity. To a certain extent, therefore, Sig- more rapidly—just as lynching might; |/nor Giolitti, in giving his Cabinet a but it would be a success achieved at the | strong Socialist tinge, has formulated a | mann-Hollweg referred particularly to | a statement in the Osservatore Romano | (the official Vatican organ) denying that the concessions made by Merry de! Val were the result of diplomatic repre sentations. That was not to give the whole truth, affirmed the Chancellor, and such publications would not help to restore good relations. But three cays later it was explained at Rome that the Osservatore was not correctly ‘understood, and that the Vatican was strongly desirous of coming to a good ‘understanding with Germany. To at- tain that end, however, it is clear that there will have to be a modification of the announced Vatican policy. For a parallel to the dramatic fall jand rise of Premier Stolypin we must | go back to the history of France under ithe Pompadours and Dubarrys as re- corded in the novels of Alexander Dumas the elder. Under Nicholas IJ as under Louis XV, ministers are made, unmade, and remade within twenty-four hours by a system which it would be a cost of such sacrifice of judicial inde pendence as might in the future bring evils incomparably more difficult to eradicate than those it was hastily adopted to remove. “Talking down” to the people has re- ceived another discouraging response in the preference at the Sunday afternoon concerts in Milwaukee for classical music, only 11 per cent. of the requests threat. Upon the fashion in which the /|farce to call government, composed as Vatican receives it may depend the be-|it is of equal portions of despotism, in ginning of a new era in the relations | trigue, and sheer incompetency. The between the Curia and the Government. That the relations between the Vati- can and Germany are somewhat disturb- ed was made evident by the Chancellor's recent speech on the subject before the Prussian Diet. Von Bethmann-Hollweg did, indeed, use a conciliatory tone and |parallel with the ancien régime is ‘completed by the floods of champagne lin which Stolypin’s fall was premature- ily celebrated. The few facts that stand jout of a muddled situation are these: |Constitutionalism in Russia is to-day lonly a hope, and a faint hope at that. |No legislative measure can become law being for a “rag-time” programme. The ‘expressed the hope that all the matters ‘without the consent of the Duma and fallacy in the argument of those who | 9+ igsue might soon be adjusted; but at | the Council of Empire, but if such con- undertake to please the public taste,/tpo game time he let it be known that | sent is refused, it does not really mat- whether in amusement, literature, or politics, lies in their supplying great quantities of the mediocre or worse, and then pointing to the consumption of it as evidence that it is what the consum- ers want. As well argue that people prefer adulterations of medicines and foods, because they buy them. Human Teadiness to accept what is offered is unfortunately prompt, but it is no more an indication of what is desired than the resort to a bank, because it happens to be around the corner, is an indication of a desire to be cheated. People are to blame for not taking more trouble to “insist on the brand,” as the advertise- ments put it, but this is no reason for confusing their indolence with unwhole- some longing, and then encouraging the | latter by pandering to it. the Government did not propose to sur- render its right to fix the conditions under which professors should serve in the universities. The demand by the Curia that all Catholic teachers in Ger- many should take the oath against mod- ernism, the Chancellor declared to be one which, if persisted in, might lead the Government to consider the advisa- bility of dissolving the Catholic facul- ties in the universities and suspending teachers in the gymnasia. He hoped that such a course would not be neces- sary,and a letter of Cardinal Merry del Val to Cardinal Kopp of Breslau put a better face on the matter. But what the Chancellor asserted to be absolutely es- sential was entire frankness and direct- ness by the Holy See in all its diplomatic negotiations with Germany. Von Beth- ‘ter. The Emperor can legislate by de- cree only while the Duma is not in ses- sion; but if the Duma happens to be in isession it can be prorogued from Mon- | day to Thursday and the required de- | cree published. Stolypin’s grip on the | Emperor consists in Nicholas II's recog- |nition of the fact that it must be either | Stolypin or a truly Liberal Ministry, which the Imperial Will regards with abhorrence, or a return to the old grand-ducal plunderers and incompe- teuts, which Imperial prudence shrinks from. So the man who crushed out the Revolution and tamed the Duma is to go on alternately bullying and cajoling the people's representatives, stifling the | universities, persecuting the Jews, and | ruling Constitutional Russia according to his own sweet will. ~~ oe
Page 8
310 PEACE AGREEMENTS. “International lawyers have done a great deal of mischief by taking upon themselves to interfere with the strat- egy and tactics of our naval campaigns.” This seems a strange deliverance to come from one bearing the name of El- lenborough. It is, however, a sentence from the speech made in the House of Lords not long since by Lord Ellenbor- ough—of the lineage of the great jur- ist. He was attacking the Declaration of London, with a violence befitting a retired naval officer. This highly impor- tant project, drafted by the represen- tatives of all the great Powers in a con- ference summoned by Great Britain her- self,and designed to strengthen the po- sition of neutrals in case of war and to extend the immunity from capture of private property at sea, seemed to the noble lord perfectly intolerable. To him it was “a one-sided treaty which favored Continental countries but was unsuited to an island Power such as we.” Any- how, the whole thing would be thrown into the waste-basket if there should be a war, since British naval officers could be depended upon, happily, to cut through “dubious wording” with the sword, Such an outbreak would not be worth referring to were it not typical of a great deal of talk that has been heard in England lately. Endless newspaper and review articles have been published and books written against the ratification of the Declaration of London. Their gen- eral argument comes down to this, that Great Britain is entitled to do whatever she pleases in naval wars, and should never assent to anything that would in- terfere with her treating neutral ships and private property at sea according to her taste and fancy at the moment. For- tunately, powerful voices on the other side have not been wanting. Professor Westlake of Cambridge, in his capacity as Lord Ellenborough’s hated interna- tional lawyer, has printed a series of articles in defence of the Declaration; while Mr. Asquith and Sir Edward Grey, for the Government, have stoutly advocated it, though agreeing to post- pone ratification until after the Imperial Conference in May. In the very session of the House of Lords alluded to, the Lord Chancellor made a weighty speech, setting forth the legal aspects of the matter with a kind of sledge-hammer authority, and dwelling especially upon The Nation [ Vol. oz, No. 2387 ‘the bad name that England would get | if she held aloof from a humane con- sensus of the other great naval] Powers. Said the Lord Chancellor in conclusion: I would ask your lordships to bear in mind that we are not the only nation in the world. We are not the only maritime or commercial nation in the world. If we wish, as some writers apparently desire that we should, to stand by our own law even to the last jot and tittle, if we are to refuse such concessions in return for the advantages which I have endeavored to place before your lordships, if we are to do that after we have ourselves been the people to invite the consideration of other nations nearly five years ago, it would be treated as a defiance of the opinion of the world This particular English debate is in- structive as an example of the play of opposing motives which enters into | every attempt by international agree- | ment to minimize the brutalities of war and to make peace more secure. Some public men will always take the atti- tude of Lord Ellenborough. They will sneer at the milk-and-water pacifists, fall back on what they call the un- changeable facts of human nature, and listen to nothing except the argument of pike and gun and the rule of tooth and claw. Particularly will they de- claim against treaties to keep the peace or to establish neutralization—treaties, they assert, which no nation will ob- serve if it finds its interest is to vio- late them. Even President Taft fell into that vein when he said that no de- pendence could be placed upon an inter- national treaty guaranteeing the neu- tralization of the Panama Canal. But along with this position of inter- national distrust and real disbelief in the power of moral forces and the good faith of nations, there is a slowly-gath- ering body of opinion in all civilized countries which is pressing with greater strength and success for peace agree- ments among the nations. We see how the idea spreads by the way in which President Taft’s stand for a comprehen- sive treaty of arbitration with England has so deeply impressed the imagina- | tion and kindled the hopes of Europe. Other lands than Great Britain are be- ginning to ask why they, too, should not be included within the circle of peace. The French Ambassador at) Washington has already made ap-| proaches to President Taft for the pur- | pose of seeing whether a like treaty with France may not be negotiated. We may be very sure that Germany, under her new Chancellor, would not be slow in responding to any advances along similar lines that might be made to her by our Government. It is more than fifty years ago that Lord John Russell wrote of one of his dispatches to Paris: “I hope you will not think there is too much of the Gospel in it for a Foreign Secretary.” Such a half-apologetic tone no man charged with the conduct of in- ternational relations would think of us- ‘ing to-day; and that fact alone is sig- nificant of the progress that has been made and of the swifter progress yet to come. PROGRESS IN ITALY. It is not altogether inappropriate that the dramatic trial of the Camorrists at | Viterbo should begin just when Italy is making ready to celebrate the semi-cen- tennial of her political unity. The fifty /years that have passed represent to the |Italian people something more than an /evolution from dismemberment to union, ‘The advance has also been from eco- ‘nomic destitution toward a high degree , of economic prosperity, and from social] | disorder to an increasingly emphatic reaffirmation of the reign of law. Dis- | union, poverty, and social anarchy were Italy’s inheritance from her unhappy past. The Mafia and, to a lesser degree, the Camorra were not, in their origin, mere criminal organizations. Both are directly traceable to the times of Spanish rule in Southern Italy, when the people, plundered and oppressed by their for- |eign masters, resorted to secret societies for the working out of some rude form ‘of justice. To-day they are an ugly sur- vival. The new Italy that has been re- laying the foundations of its economic prosperity, rebuilding its cities, and re- ‘asserting itself in the councils of the European nations, has now set out to eliminate the forces of domestic disor- ider. That the Camorra will be crushed at one blow is improbable. The signifi- cant thing is that the campaign, begun 'a half-dozen years ago, is being carried | out with determination. A succinct account of economic prog- ress in Italy during the last thirty years is presented in the last number of the Century Magazine by Ernesto Na- than, Mayor of Rome, and one of the /most prominent exponents of the mod- ern progressive movement in the Ital- ‘fan peninsula. Signor Nathan begins
Page 9
Seay ae | ial wae weer! eet Ts nah te lt Sa At thay 6 PAR At cal atth. te: ae ti — March 30, 1911] progress in Italy cannot be measured by American standards. As opposed to! America’s vast natural resources, We [the Italians] are a nation with a long and lean peninsula, the whole of which, even to the limits of eternal snows—plain and mountain, water and land—is totally appropriated and divided up; the birthright of which dates back some twenty centuries; which possesses no coal, indeed, no fuel be- yond its meagre forests, no source of energy beyond its streams and rivers, with all its natural resources long ago sucked dry. This is a condition of things that ap- plies with varying force to all of West- ern Europe; it applies with most force in Italy. Yet in Italy the population has grown since 1882 from twenty-eight to thirty-five millions. The budget defi- cit has been wiped out, in spite of the fact that the annual appropriations have risen from 1,270 million lire to over 2,000 million. Government securities to-day stand high. Signor Nathan tells how this has been brought about: Our people have worked hard, lived rather closely, and saved money; they have bought | back nearly all our stocks that were in for- eign hands (something like a billion dol- lars’ worth), besides putting aside other savings; capital has increased; post office savings banks, which, in 1882, had deposits of 59 million lire, now hold over 1,600 mil- lions; the 740 millions in the private sav- ings banks are now 2,460 millions; the deposits in banks of various kinds have swollen from 858 millions to 2,372. These seem small amounts to countries that cal- culate in billions of dollars, but they are satisfactory for poor people, and they are trustworthy, being culled from the state- ment made to Parliament last December by our Minister of the Treasury, Signor Tedesco. Italian engineering skill ranks with the highest in Europe. The consumption of coal in Italian industry has risen in thirty years from two and a half million tons to nine million tons, besides half a million horsepower of water. The coun- try has not escaped the usual evils at- tendant upon a rapid industrial devel- opment. There are urban overcrowding and want. Yet taking the population as a whole, the standard of living has per- ceptibly risen. The people, asserts Sig- nor Nathan, eat more than they used to, absolutely and qualitatively; they eat more bread, drink more wine, and con- sume more animal foods, and suffer less from malaria and pellagra. Mayor Na- than does not touch on one obvious source of Italian prosperity—her vast emigration and the resultant annual in- flow of wealth from abroad. _ The Nation with a necessary caution. Economic There are phases of modern Italian | progress that are not viewed with un- mixed approval, especially by the for- eigner to whom Italy is—Italy. The city-builder has laid his desecrating hand on the monuments of a glorious past, and hews down Renaissance pal- aces in the name of a new gospel that is called sanitation. But upon the great mass of the Italian nation, proud though it is of its past, the present enforces its problems; and the future, too, beckons Signor Nathan is a leader among the Vandals, or progressives, as we choose to call them. He thinks in terms of sewage and apartment-house blocks. He has declared with much vehemence that Italy is no longer content to keep her- ,self a graveyard and an archeological /museum for the nations. Utilitarianism has found curious literary expression through the mouth of the Futurists, a rather extravagant poetical band, whose leader recently told the Venetians that half of them are paupers, and dirty pau- pers at that, and called upon them to fill up their insalubrious canals and pitch their useless new Campanile into the sea, Like many other extravagances, this one of the Futurists is only the wild exaggeration of a sound and popu- lar idea. THE BIBLE TERCENTENARY. Elaborate plans are making both in this country and in England to com- memorate the three-hundredth year since the publication of the King James English Bible. Time would fail us if we were to attempt to enumerate the many reasons why this event deserves celebration, and we limit ourselves to one: the fact that the translation of the Bible made in 1611 is a great literary monument of the English language. Wholly apart from what the English Bible has been in the faith and hopes and prayers of nine generations, its weaving into the writing and speech and thought of millions of human be- ings has made it unique and venerable. This very fact, however, may raise a doubt in some minds. Are we con- founding effect with cause? Is there not a danger lest the immense impres- sion of long inherited associations, pre- cious and solemn, be transferred to the Bible as pure literature, and we incline to praise too highly as English style what we have first surrounded with 311 holy awe? Many a man, we fancy, has turned back to the Bible in later years with something of the anxiety with which he revisits what he felt in his youth to be grand and inspiring natur- al scenery. Will his mature judgment confirm young enthusiasms? Needless to say, any such apprehen- sion “is speedily dissipated in the case of the English of the King James's Bible. Its praise has been often in the mouth of competent and impartial judges. The great cloud of witnesses ‘o it includes not merely preachers and devout women not a few, but poets and orators and critics and statesmen. What forced the ice-cold judgment of Hallam into a glow, what the literature-devour- ing mind of Macaulay exalted as su- preme, lesser mortals need not be afraid to admire. Ruskin's crowning of the English Bible is well known; Hux- ley’s tribute less so, though even more convincing. It is a Catholic who said that the language of the Authorized Version “lives on the ear like music that can never be forgotten.” And so fastidious a critic as Professor Saints- bury has singled out a passage from the Old Testament as the best example known to him of “absolutely perfect English prose.” It is the following from the Song of Solomon: Set me as a seal upon thine heart, as a seal upon thine arm; for love is strong as death; jealousy is cruel as the grave: the coals thereof are coals of fire, which hath a most vehement flame. Many waters can- not quench love, neither can the floods drown it: if a man would give all the sub- stance of his house for love, it would utter- ly be contemned. Scholars and historians have often dwelt upon the fortunate conjunction of circumstances by which the English Bible came into being just when it did. It was a time when the language lent itself with ease to such strength and majesty as are fixed for all time in the King James version. Our present mind, however, is not to go over this beaten path again, but to refer once more to the great loss which the disappearance of the old familiarity with the very phraseology of the Bible has brought with it. The loss is, first of all, as of a key to a great deal of the best in Eng- lish literature. The Bible is not only a masterpiece itself, it is inwrought in many other masterpieces. Biblical allu- sions and terms of speech sprinkle the pages of Shakespeare, are as thick In Milton as his own leaves of Vallombrosa,
Page 10
[ Vol. 92, No. 2387 The Nation 312 and color the phrase and thought of Tennyson. We remember to have seen a college examination paper on the lat- poet, wherein explanation was ask- Bible adding ter ed idioms of incidents and names and beauty and significance to his verse. It is unnecessary to say that most of the students miserably fail- ed to pass. What to boys and girls of fifty years ago would have been sec- ond nature, is to an appalling number of even well-educated young people to- day an alien world. Is there any way of making it as widely familiar again as it once was? This is a question often asked, not mere- but interested in the best secular education. ly by religious teachers, by those They know how maimed and half made- up a student of English literature must be unless the lingering charm of Scrip- tural terms of expression clings to his memory and he has an easy acquaint- ance with Bible narrative, yet how to the old knowledge from van- Modern prevent ishing away is the problem. attempts to solve it have not been high- ly successful. Formal schemes of Bible study in college or in special literary courses do not seem to meet the case. Students go out from such classes still dull the haunting words which a former genera- tion instantly identified with Bible dic- to sinewy phrases and the tion. And the great reason for it, we think, the almost insuperable difficulty, is that a late and literary study of the Bible can never make it the instinctive possession, the man of our counsel, that it was under the old system of assimi-_| lating its contents. Assiduous reading in the family from earliest days, the memorizing of Psalm and parable and prophecy and beatitude, the listening to the rolling echoes of Sinai in church ‘lost so much of this as our generation | ing of such scholars as Prof. William confessedly has is little short of an in-|M. Davis and Prof. Theodore W. Rich- tellectual calamity, and it is to be hoped |ards of Harvard, who devoted them- that the Tercentenary will aid in re-| selves to their tasks of the classroom covering something of what has slipped and forgot all about there being a court, from us in knowledge of a book that/or of a democrat of the type of Felix has for three centuries been “woven/| Adler is too readily forgotten when a into the life of all that is best and no- | successor gives a lavish dinner to a hun- blest in English history.” dred or more persons at which he him- |self, his wife, and children are toasted and extolled. And the true representa- THE EXCHANGE OF PROFESSORS. We are glad to note that in the sober |“ive of culture is also forgotten when press there is genuine disgust at the it comes to battles of the Schleppencour mortifying behavior of the two Ameri- | and the mad race to see who shall con- can professors who have been in Ber- | VeTse oftenest with the Crown Prince. lin this winter, and at their and their| Now to some it might seem as if the wives’ squabbles in the matter of going | S°lution of all this difficulty were mere- \to court. Every one must, indeed, have ly greater care in the selection of the felt astonishment that representatives | €xchange of professors; that President of American culture and learning could | Butler and the Harvard authorities |thus write themselves down as on a par | Should not only always select gentle- with vulgar nouveaur riches, wanting | men, but gentlemen who will put an manners and good taste. But, unfortu- end to the jealousies between the Roose- velt and Harvard professors, out of which have arisen many of the untow- ard incidents for which both univer- sities must blush. There is more to it than that. There ought to be a clari- fying of our conception of the duties of these professors in the light of the ex- perience gained. There ought to be a decision once for all as to whether these professors are ambassadors to the court, or to the Gelehrtenwelt, or gen- uine interpreters of the ideals, aims, and aspirations of one people to anoth- er. One of the most distinguished of German publicists welcomed with joy the news of the appointment of Felix Adler, because, he said, here is a great teacher who will not think that his mission has ended when he leaves the classroom or the eourt-levee, but will carry his message of good will to the people as well. But there are not /nately, the matter cannot be allowed to ‘rest there, for the whole scheme of ex- | changing professors has been endangered |by just this sort of thing. That is, it has been all but warped from its original |purposes by the influence of the Berlin |court and the readiness of many of the | representatives of this country to bow 'down before royalty as if there’ were ‘no such things as republican dignity, scholarly modesty of bearing, and indif- |ference to the glory of royal atten- ‘tions. The example of Franklin has too often been forgotten; we have heard | too much from returning professors of ithe graciousness of this or that prince or of the number of times the Kaiser invited them to lunch. Naturally, these things do not go un- noticed in Berlin. The social climber (Streber the Germans call him) is not iso unknown a specimen in that capital on Sundays, along with the lightnings | as to make it impossible to classify a and smoke of torment in the Apocalypse | foreign variety. A recent French book all this was a process to stamp upon ‘on Berlin contains an interview of the author with the Kaiser's Court Cham- berlain in which, in a way humiliating to all Americans, that official bewails the presence in Berlin in increasing numbers of rich and well-gowned Amer- ican women who go on their knees to the mind indelibly what no amount of | study can yield. Grant | sophisticated that there was a certain fear in the childish heart as the sacred page was | confronted; it was yet a way of sensl- tizing the photographic plate to make it receive and hold the impression. All| royalty and on all occasions betray their total lack of breeding and good manners. Now, the noise and glare of this type obscure those of this has largely gone, we fear, and with it the Intimate knowledge and the swift | response which a speaker like Webster people of or even Garfield could count upon In his audience when he played upon some chord that thrills in the Bible. To have culture and refinement who sojourn in Berlin to profit by its advantages. With the professors, too, the admirable bear- many Felix Adiers, and some great teachers like Professor Richards can only give their message in the chemi- cal laboratory; other real scholars often find themselves confined to their aca- demic audiences. None the less, there ought to be a re- adjustment of the point of view and a limiting of the choice to one of the two types, the publicist or the scholar. The Roosevelt professorship is not re- stricted to university teachers; it can be filled by public men or devotees of literature. Hence it is not true that the list of available candidates has been exhausted as some allege; there is as
Page 11
A, eS i actin row baie atl “ow March 30, 1911] The Nation great a range of choice as there are able men capable of lecturing abroad. But the real need is of men who can place before the German people the ideals and the ethical standards of the people, who can lay bare the nation's heart, and explain abroad those common denominators which at bottom make our democracy great. For the establishment of these professorships was primarily a peace measure; they were to be the un- official ambassadors who, free from the trammels of diplomacy, could smooth out misunderstandings and help to re- move that ignorance of one another which is the real source of most inter- national misunderstandings. As_ far back as 1907 able and outspoken Ber- lin newspapers were frank to say that the interchange had merely been a suc- cés Westime; that whether it was due to the court-stamp on the undertaking or not, the prospect was then that “no result worth mentioning, no real moral or scientific gain, will result.” The Ber- lin Tageblatt was even then fearful lest | the whole experiment only “turn out to} be a curiosity in the history of educa- | Has there been anything since | tion.” then to warrant a different view? Surely the time has come for those responsible to revise their plans, ail the more so because the German exchanges have been at times far from ideal. Is the fault, as the Tageblatt suggests, be- cause the emphasis is not upon the different methods of teaching here and abroad? Or does it lie deeper? Even if it should prove on examination to have been an impossible experiment based on impossible ideal, the truth | should be known. But one thing at least Harvard and Columbia can now do for the country. By eliminating the court feature and forbidding professors to seek royal favors for themselves and | their wives they can at least save us from national humiliation, even if they cannot assure us of the achievement of permanent good. =x APPLIED LITERATURE. A recent tale outdoes Jules Verne by presenting, partly in dialogue, partly in incident, the results of the astronom- ical observations and calculations re- specting the mysteries of Mars. The ! pure romance. They plan and achieve, love and suffer, as naturally as if they had nothing to do with such task-work as instructing the followers of their for- tunes in the results of a branch of scien- tific research. Indeed, the unscientific reader will not find it difficult or even especially distracting to turn the leaves more rapidly in some places than in others, and so defeat the author's an- nounced purpose of improving his mind, while discovering more speedily the ul timate fate of the beings in whom he is concerned. Such a book has an ob vious two-fold interest, and yet, with the characteristic defiance of art for mathematics, its appeal is less effective than that of unmixed fiction, Sooner or later the reader becomes impatient with its merely romantic parts, or more like- ly skips the informative interruptions The re- sult in either case cannot be satisfac- to the course of the narrative. tory to the painstaking writer, who finds himself unflatteringly looked upon jas an unskilful story-teller or a friv- olous savant. Yet he is in a large and not ignoble company, for, if it includes such mod- ern figures as George Eliot, with her “Felix Holt”; “Bleak House” and “Nicholas Nickleby”; Mrs. Dickens, with Browning, Tennyson, Zola, Ibsen, and Tolstoy; it comprises also Homer, with his catalogue of ships; Aristophanes, Virgil, Cervantes, Chaucer, and Bunyan. |Of lesser examples, such as “Uncle Tom's Cabin,” “Looking Backward,” “Robert Elsmere,” “Jude the Obscure,” “Ben Hur,” and “Justice,” the lists are equally full. Indeed, a casual survey seems to disclose as great a dispropor- tion between the amount of what we |may distinguish as pure and as applied literature, as there is between pure and applied mathematics, or science. This |probability grows toward certainty as one reflects upon the volume, not only of pseudo-scientific and historic tales,and of problem novels and plays, but of ‘those serving as vehicles for social and |while the novel is ordinarily fastened economic theories, or of mystery. And |/upon as the medium for such pedestrian | effects, poetry is not beyond impress- iment for the same purpose. Not to ispeak of the mass of personal, political, 313 “Progress of Flecknoe” to Gray's Poesy” and Tennyson's “Palace of Art,” there are the more extended ambula tions of Lucretius, of Horace’s “Ars Poetica,” Pope’s “Essay on Criticism,” and Wordsworth’'s “Recluse,” if one is not compelled to look a little askance at even “Paradise Lost.” It is Milton, however, that brings one face to face with the difficulty of draw ing the line between pure and applied literature. If ever there was a poem with a purpose, it was the one compos ed to assert eternal providence and jus tify the ways of God to men. Johnson's “Irene,” on the other hand, can hardly have had any except a literary end. Yet it is not the ostensibly literary, but the avowedly didactic, production that we admire, and for its majestic beauty. Spenser wrote his great work for the “generall end” of fashioning “a gentl man or noble person in vertuous and gentle discipline,” but it is not that which has sent every generation of poets since to the “Faerie Queene.” The diffi culty is not lightened when we turn to such practical, affairs-of-the-hour pro ductions as the “Philippics” of Demos thenes, the more familiar of Cicero's orations, or the inaugurals of Lincoln. If these are not pure literature, one is tempted to exclaim, so much the worse for pure literature. What a lot of well meant attempts in that direction they have survived! It all recalls the asser- tion that Burke should have written poetry, and Dryden and Pope prose. Is the distinction that is recognized in mathematics, then, between pure and applied, non-transferable to literature, or rather, not worth transferring? Does the paradox of pure literature which is inferior, even as literature, to that in which the literary element is only inci- > dental invalidate such classification’? Or are our instincts right in leading us to think more highly, as a rule, of those pages that are penned for nothing less direct than the winning of our appre ciation for their charm of plot, charac- jters, and style? Even of them, how ever, it would not be safe to assert the absence of all non-literary motive. We can hardly imagine an author solemnly setting himself down to the work of ‘turning out masterpieces—and succeed- book is, in form, a story, and in fact it|and didactic verse, often satirical, fre-| ing. And as a matter of fact, most of possesses all the necessary framework |quently little better than doggerel, of |them were not done in any such way. and accessories of one. In its pages | moderate live characters as real as those in alson’s “Campaign” and Dryden's “Mac length, ranging from Addi-|Sophocles was ambitious, primarily, to win the tragic prize from his brilliant
Page 12
314 rivals, A®schylus and Euripides. Shake- speare wrote, not for all time, but for a theatrical season, or, if luck favored him, for two seasons. Goldsmith was driven to immortality by publishers who had a mortgage on his genius, and such smaller stars as Herrick, Gay, and Lovelace composed their lines for the sake of giving pleasure to their friends. Milton, indeed, hoped to leave some- thing that the world would not willing- ly let die. Doubtless, many of the great, before and after him, bemoaned their inability to write with an eye single to the demands of literary art. They did not realize that pure literature, like fame or influence or character, is most- ly a by-product, and that what they craved, therefore, was as unnecessary as it was impossible. PARIS BOOK NOTES. LITERATURE AND CRITICISM Paris, March 18. “George Meredith” (A. Colin: 300 pages, 3.50 francs), by Constantin Photi- adés, is intended to satisfy the curiosity of French readers concerning the life, | imagination, art, and teaching of a man whom, “for more than fifty years, an international group of the initiated has been extolling as one of the greatest writers of modern England.” The book, with its French clarity (the author is a Parisian, if not a Frenchman), may serve an equal purpose to many uniniti- ated English and American readers. The author’s opening visit to Flint Cottage in 1908 is an illuminating personal rec- ord like Eckerman’s for Goethe. The life of Meredith is explained simply in its connection with his literature. His imagination is analyzed chiefly from his “Harry Richmond,” with copious transla- tions. His art, in its lyric qualities and style, with its analysis and concentrated effects and super-acute notes, is stud- ied in his poems as well as in his varied prose works. His teaching or logic and philosophy of life—his Notion of the Earth, his Notion of the Comic Spirit, which from Jupiter or Uranus might judge all our feelings and acts with re lation to our environment in our own planet—is compared with what critics of friendliest insight have said of him. “In all countries, most of all in France, there are people predisposed by charac- ter and culture to like Meredith.” “De l'Art, de I'élégance, de la charité” (Fontemoing: 270 pages, 3.50 francs), by André de Fouquiéres, is the work of an arbiter clegantiarum in the cosmo- politan salons of Paris. He has so long been before the footlights of fashion that what he has to say will interest many. Something ought to be learned >. The Nation from this renaissance of “dandysme” and from charity where “social service” is not yet the accepted formula, but each grande dame must have her partic- ular wuvre—maternal adoption of Jug- gling Jerry's children or the protection of young girls and the Red Cross. “Charles Ritter—1859-1905" (Paris: [ Vol. 92, No. 2387 _guards of language as Bentham, comes ‘out as clearly as may be in these let- ters, which, moreover, are anything but |scholastic. They will have their use as a manuductio in the erudition of phil- osophy. “I have read several of your /volumes and you have read some of my poor volumes, and we continue—what? Fischbacher; 310 pages, 3.50 francs) is; we begin debating all sorts of high a choice of letters to and from an able, pensive, cultivated Swiss professor, with “friends and masters” like Sainte- Beuve, Renan, Taine, Cherbuliez, Paul Bourget, the counter-theologian Strauss, George Eliot, Edouard Schuré, William James. The last confided to the Swiss friend of his youth that he was fully de- questions between ourselves, struggling against the double difficulty of under- standing and speaking.” “Histoire de la poésie francaise au xvie siécle’ (H. Champion: 290 pages 8vo), par Henry Guy, professor in the University of Toulouse, takes us into the literary heart of the Renaissance. cided to try the painter's trade; it was | This first volume deals with the school when James was eighteen. At fifty, he of rhétoriqueurs. It is the beginning of writes that his big book of philosophy a work of considerable magnitude, not is making money for him. In these engaged in the bibliography or philol- letters are many sincere utterances on |Ogy or esthetic criticism of French latter-day questions, such as are given| poetry, but investigating scientifically out among friends. how poetry arose in France, the influ- “Correspondance de Renouvier et Se-|ences which inspired the poets, and the crétan” (A. Colin: 168 pages, 8vo, 2 por- origins of their art. The book begins trait plates, 3.50 francs) will be chiefly | With the general characters of the pe- interesting to those who follow the|Tiod: the sources in other literatures, movement of philosophic thought. Even Such as the Bible, Greek, and Roman | now, perhaps, only one book and an | and medieval authors; the art centres, evanescent influence are all that re- | material situation of those who culti- mains from Secrétan; but Renouvier | Vated the art and those who served in has left the most continuous and con-| Place of Maecenas; the material of the sistent mass of criticism of the world’s | Poetry and its chief ornaments; its com- thought through the ages which was/Plications and plays of rhythm; and the published in the nineteenth century. | Poetic genres. The second part takes up His positive contribution is not sogreat,|!2 order the rhétoriqueurs from Oc at least not as it is found in his own/|tovien de Saint-Gelays, born in 1468, to works, although his thought shows the court poets and Jean Parmentier, through every page of Bergson and completing the first third of the cen- Pragmatism. From his first publica-|tury. Each chapter is followed by its tions in 1836, when he was fresh from | bibliography, and there is a complete the lessons of Auguste Comte on the | index of names—but, alas! no table of philosophy of mathematics at the Ecole contents. With all its scientific merit, Polytechnique, until the last days pre-|the book is very readable for the stu- ceding his death in September, 1903, |dent of French literature, Renouvier’s life was given over to the) “Souvenirs d’un enfant de Paris” (Fas- one absorbing study of philosophy. Un- | quelle: 430 pages, 3.50 francs), by Emile like Herbert Spencer, he attended first | Bergerat, is far from scientific litera- to the critical study of what others had ture; but it is the stuff from which thought, and then to the elaboration of|such studies of nineteenth-century his own system. Having a system of| French literature will have to be made his own was needed to give controver- | by the university professor of the fu- sial incitement to his criticism; and/|ture. The book tells entertainingly the this is the chief merit of his letters to| “years of Bohemia” of the author, a his friend of many years, Secrétan. | son-in-law of Théophile Gautier. From 1868 to 1891 these thinkers, both | Through his pages walk familiarly Vic- systematic, disagreeing gravely, held | tor Hugo and belated Romantics, begin- communion of thought. The persistent | ners like Sarcey and Daudet, amid very opposition of Secrétan, who never suc-| lively personal remembrances of the au- cumbed to the more powerful thought of|thor as a schoolboy at war with his Renouvier, helps to clarify many points | Latin; in the real war of 1870; and of the latter’s philosophy. Secrétan, in| then a long section of history and sto- his lumbering Swiss French, brings out ‘ries of the later years and company of his points clearly. Renouvier, with his|Théophile Gautier himself. The transi- life-long dislike of the Church, from the/|tion of Young France to what has turn- necessity of his thought strove after/|ed out to be a new era as well as a new more and more precision in what came/|régime is plain to be seen. Perhaps to be almost the historic scholastic vo-| Emile Bergerat is not even now quite cabulary and principle, bringing his|alive to the fact that he, too, in his criticism into the great body of classic | turn, is an ancestor; but this, like wine philosophy. His positive system, which | long-bottled, only adds to the sparkle he elaborated with as complicated safe-| of his anecdotes. 8. D. BL i eee ae The elf nha icin Fait tliat ea ttl ee ey
Page 13
nan MO hn, nel ty Lat A hr Ml ian ba ae ipl te eats 0 woah te March 30, 1911] The Nation 315 NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. The first selection from the great library of the late Robert Hoe wil! be sold by the Anderson Auction Company in nineteen ses- sions, beginning April 24, and continuing to May 5. The catalogue of this first part is issued in two volumes containing 3,538 lots. The vellum copy of the Gutenberg Bible is included in this part. This, the first book printed with movable types, was very fit- tingly the glory of the library of Mr. Hoe, the man who did more than any one else of his generation to advance the art of printing. This copy, printed upon vellum, has an authentic history going back to 1825, when it was bought at auction by J. and A. Arch, booksellers, for Henry Perkins, a brewer, and one of the greatest book collectors of his day, for £504. Perkins died in April, 1855, his library going to Algernon Perkins, who died in 1870. In 1873 the library was sold at auction, bringing £26,000 for 865 lots, the vellum Gutenberg Bible bringing £3,400. It was bought by F. S. Ellis for the Earl of Ashburnham, and when again sold with his books in June, 1897, Quaritch paid £2,000 for it. It probably cost Mr. Hoe about $22,000. Of the seven known copies on vellum of this all-important book this is not only the only copy which has ever been sold at auc- tion in England but is the only one which any collector can ever hope to stand even the remotest chance of procuring, all the other known copies (excepting Mr. Mor- gan’s) being in public libraries from which they can never pass. Of the seven known copies on vellum two are owned in New York, one in England (the Grenville copy in the British Museum), one in France (in the Bibliothéque Nation- ale), and three in Germany (one in the Royal Library at Berlin, and two in Leip- zig). It would be a notable thing for some wealthy American to seize the opportunity to buy this copy and, at his death, to pre- sent it to the Library of Congress. Only one copy of the book has heretofore appeared in American auction rooms. At the Brinley sale, in April, 1881, Hamilton Cole paid $8,000 for a paper copy, having seventeen leaves in facsimile. He sold it privately to Brayton Ives, and at the sale of his books, in March, 1891, it brought $14,- 800, being bought by Mr. James Ellsworth, who still owns it. The first Hoe sale includes also his re- nowned copy of the first edition of “Le Morte D’Arthur,” “reduced in to Englysshe by syr Thomas Malory knyght,” and “deuyded in to xxi bookes chapytred and enprynted, and fynysshed in thabbey West- mestre the last day of July,” 1485, by Wil- liam Caxton. This, the most valuable of all Caxtons, on account of its fine condition and rarity, has a long and interesting his- tory. In October, 1698, it was sold, in the library of Dr. Francis Bernard, physician to James II, bringing two shillings and six- pence. It was bought by Sir Robert Har- ley, first Earl of Oxford, who had it bound in red morocco and tooled in the style since known as Harleian. Upon his death, in 1724, his library. descended to his son, Edward Harley, the second earl, who died in 1741. The next year the library, including about 50,000 books, 41,000 prints, and 350,000 pam- phiets (the greatest private collection ever brought together) was purchased entire by Thomas Osborne, the bookseller, for £13,- 000. Osborne issued a series of catalogues (5 vols. 8vo., describing more than 50,000 lots), and th's copy of the “Morte D’Ar- thur” appears as No. 372 of Vol. III. The catalogue notes: “This was a favorite Book with King Henry VIII. See what a Char- acter Ascham gives of it, in his School- master.” The book seems to have been purchased from Osborne by Brian Fa'rfax, the yvoung- er, who died in January, 1749. The Malory was valued by the appraiser at £2 12s. 6d A catalogue of the library preparatory to a sale by auction was printed in April, 1756, but the whole was sold to Mr. Child of Osterley Park, Middlesex. It seems to have passed in 1804 into the possession of George Villiers, fifth Earl of Jersey, by his mar riage with Child’s granddaughter It re- mained at Osterley Park, until the books were removed for sale at Sotheby's in 1885 The Caxton “Malory” was there bought by Quaritch for £1,950, for Mrs. Norton Quincy Pope, of Brooklyn, the most notable woman book-collector America has produced. In 1895, shortly after Mrs. Pope's death, her husband sold the library entire to Mr. Hoe. One illuminated manuscript included in this sale is worthy of being mentioned with the two printed books already described This is the famous “Pembroke Book of Hours,” made for William Herbert, first Earl of Pembroke, who was beheaded in 1469. It was later in the possession of his grandson, William Herbert, in whose time, probably, some leaves, written in English, were added. Its further history is un- known until it turned up about 1880 in Italy in the possession of the Borghese family of Rome. From them it passed through an Italian antiquary into the possession of F. S. Ellis, the London bookseller, who sold it to Brayton Ives of this city. At the sale of his library, in March, 1891, it brought $5,900, and was bought for Mr. Hoe. Correspondence A NATIONAL LEGISLATIVE REFERENCE BUREAU. 10 THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Two bills introduced at the third session of the Sixty-first Congress, and no- ticed little, if at all, by the public press, are of much significance in the fight for more scientific and studied legislation. One at least will no doubt be again introduced. Senator Owen of Oklahoma has proposed “to create a United States Legislative Ref- erence Bureau” (S. 10,041), and Represen- tative Nelson of Wisconsin would establish a “Legislative Division of the Congressional Library” (H. R. 31,536). The legislative reference library as al- jready established in nineteen States and several municipalities aims to give to the members of the Legislature or Municipal Assembly the opportunity of making a com- parative study of the questions which come before them as lawmakers. The published experience of other commonwealths as em- bodied in their statutes, the actual results of the application of these statutes as given by those who must apply them, the literature of sociology describing the conditions of society which give rise to the necessity for new forms of legislation, the best thought of the scholarly theorists in political sci-' ence, and the experience of those who are daily meeting and solving the complicated problems of modern administration—all this the legislative referenc: library aims make available to its patrons Senator Owen's bill would have the chief of this bureau appointed by the President and would make its business to locate, catalogue, and index all material in various government departments in the shape of bills, laws, debates, departmental research, findings of commissions, consular reports, treatises in legal brief and schol- arly periodical, and so forth, touching upon problems of current legislation; to gather catalogue, and index such further material pertaining to legislative experience at home and abroad as shall seem expedient. Results shall be made serviceable, and : every possible way the enactment of mors scfentific legislation shall be aided This bill is brief and carries no appropriation as drawn at present. The House bill of eight sections provides that the Librarian of Congress shall appoint the division chief and in specific language sets forth with what high educatjonal qual- ifications this chief must be endowed. His staff of secretaries, technical assistants, in- vestigators, and draftsmen shall be of his own selection. While broad in scope this bill is far more specific and detailed than that of the Senate and carries with it an appropriation of one hundred and fifty thou- sand dollars annually. Legislative reference work so-called may be said to have had its beginnings in the New York State Library in 1891, when was issued “Legislation No. 1,” a bulletin pre- senting a “comparative summary and index of State Legislation in 1890." The develop- ment in this field of library work since that date is significant. The Governor of Wis- consin, in his message to the Legislature in January, 1911, in asking for an increase in the appropriation for this department in his State to twenty-two thousand dollars a year, takes occasion to express his appre- ciation of its efficient service in the cause of careful lawmaking. JOHN BOYNTON KAISER. Austin, Tex., March 9. SHAKESPEARE AND RALEIGH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I am unable to find in any edition of the “Merchant of Venice” or elsewhere notice of the striking resemblance between Shakespeare's song, “Tell me where is fancy bred,” and a poem which appeared in Da- vison’s “Poetical Rhapsody” (1602), signed with the initials W. R, (See A. H. Bullen's edition of the “Poetical Rhapsody,” Vol. II, p. 112.) It is hard to believe that the matter has escaped the attention of the lynx-eyed generations of editors; but !f any discussion of the relation between these two pieces exists it has not yet found its way into the main current of Shakespear- ean commentary. The corresponding parts of the two songs are as follows: Tell me where Is fancy bred, Or in the heart or tn the head? How begot how nourished? Reply, reply. It is engendered in the eyes, With gazing fed; and fancy dies In the cradle where it lies. A POESY TO PROVE THAT AFFECTION 18 NOT LOVE. Conecelt, begotten by the eyes, Ia quickly born, and quickly dies;
Page 14
The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2,87 316 For while it seeks our hearts to have Meanwhile there reason makes his grave; - x— For many things the eyes approve, Which yet the heart doth seldom love. in spring time sown, lie in the ground ere they be grown; Por as the seeds, whose rooting fails, As child that in the Such is conceit, cradle quails, (ir else within the mother's womb Hath his beginning and his tomb Affection follows Fortune's wheels, And soon is shaken from her heels; For following beauty or estate, Ifer liking still is turned to hate: Fer all affections have their change, And fancy only loves to range. The letters W. R. in the “Poetical Rhap- sody” are supposed to stand for Walter Raleigh; and this song has frequently, though he would go a through a snowstorm to cast a deciding vote to make his friend President, he must be considered as an opponent of the Adminis- tration—becavse honest opposition was es- sential to keep the servants of the people in the right way. Taylor was three times a member of the | Senate, 1792-1794 by election, October-De- cember, 1803, by appointment, and 1822-1824 by election again; and he might easily have |had a seat there at other times had he so | desired. He would have spurned appoint- ;ment to any office under the Republican | Presidents, all of whom, however, were on jterms of intimacy with him during their | Administrations. He was one of the first lof the race of mugwumps, a prince of in- though not always, been printed among his | dependents, and also a writer of many books, works. The possibility of a literary rela- tion, however slight. between Sir Walter and his great contemporary is of considera- ble interest; and it would certainly be worth while to bring to bear upon this poem now little known, as will be seen from the | following list: “The Spirit of Seventy-six” (1809), “An Inquiry into the Principles and Policy of the Government of the United | States,” a reply to John Adams’s work on any evidence which might help to establish | the Constitution (1814); ‘“‘Arator,” a series its date or to confirm its authorship. JAMPs HOLLY HANFORD. Simmons College, March 4 JOHN TAYLOR “OF CAROLINE.” To THe EpiTror or THE NATION: SIR I have recently come into posses- sion of a letter of John Taylor of Caroline which will interest students of American history, especially of secession. John Tay- lor's name appears in few of the ency- clopedias of to-day, though he was one of the most influential publicists of his time. He was born in Orange County, Virginia, in 1750, avd died in Caroline in 1824. He was an ardent revolutionist in 1776, a fol- lower of Patrick Henry, and opposed to the compromising, perhaps loyalist, attitude of his uncle, Edmund Pendleton. Most ardent his attachment to Virginia and to the rights ideas in the early national career, he came soon to be counted with the little group of Jeffersonians to which in States of agricultural essays (1818), “Construction Construed,” an attack on the judicial opin- ions of Chief Justice Marshall (1820); “Tyranny Unmasked” (1822), and “New Views of the Constitution of the United States” (1823). He was a member of the Senate at the time of his death in 1824—a man of such prestige and influence that Presidential as- pirants of 1824 made pilgrimages to his re- tired Virginia home seeking his approval. Few men who wrote so much, wereso long in the public eye, and who deserved so well of the country, have been so ignored in works of reference or general information. Hence the following letter, bearing upon an im- portant crisis in our history, and counter- acting, as it does to some extent the view of so many students of the Jeffersonian epoch, is offered to the readers of the Nation, WILLIAM E,. Dopp. University of Chicago, March 2. Virginia, Port Royal, Dec. 30, 1820. Dear Sir: Your letter has reached me, but the gentlemen it introduces have not rhomas New belonged, who desired a peace- | appeared. Their ———— = — le tee ; a Bead very agreeable to me, and an exchange 0 abl reak-unp of the Un on. But Taylor | opinions, when neither a spirit of opposi- was not a disun-onist (Gaillard Hunt: “Dis- | tion nor the allurements of victory would union Sentiment in Congress in 1794," a| prevail, might have been someWhat useful. pamphlet published in 1905); rather an | x —— J eet eee 5 = coe bg Ms ; a the “New School. s phrase idealist who hoped to see all government | to the notion of constituting a geographical reduced to the irreducible minimum. He | party by the cement of a temporary im- given no existence to corpora- tions business, he would have had no money but gold and silver, and he the of stocks and bonds prima facie evidence of degeneration. He warred against the growth of economic and financial interests of the East, and la- mented, especially from the economic point of the of slavery in the South. In 1798 he espoused the doctrine of the Virginia and Kentucky resolutions and be- came Madison's ablest lieutenant in the en- suing conflict between the States rights and the Federalist school of politics in the Virginia Assembly. He thus had much to do with formulating the doctrine which the South was to adopt in Justification of seces- would have doing interstate thought ownership view, existence | | sion, After Jefferson became President he opposed some of the main items of the Re- publican programme, and when Monroe was made Madison's successor, largely because of Taylor's activity as a peacemaker be- pression concerning slavery, the _ policy will have no permanent effect, except in accelerating the dissolution of the Union; because solid geographical interests will inevitably obliterate a contemplative opin- jon naturally transitory. If it refers to the notion of contriving laws for making one portion of the Union tributary to an- other, that policy is equally unsustainable for any considerable period; because, though the Southern States might long sub- mit to their commercial disadvantages, so beneficial to the Northern, they will not long bear an aggravation of them by geo- graphical legislation. Whenever a, disso- lution of the Union happens, both these projects will fail, and the Southern con- federation will either embrace most or all of the waters of the Mississippi, or the confederations will be Eastern and West- ern. I cannot see what interest can induce the Northern States to wish for either. These strange geographical concussions seem to have put a more useful subject, that of weights and measures, out of the mind of Congress. More useful, because a cement of the Union by an uniformity in thie respect, however small, is preferable to disuniting projects, however great. I tween Madison and Monroe, he wrote that, lately was present at a delivery of grain, . hundred miles where three sealed half-bushels and two stamped fifty-six weights were produced. No two of the former agreed, and the dif- ference between the largest and the small- est extended to a quart. One fifty-six weighed by the same pair of stilliards above fifty-nine, and the other above fifty- eight pounds. Upon information entitled to much credit, it is probable that the frauds committed by false weights and measures are innumerable, and that they play in a scope of 10 per centum at least. Indeed, the half-bushel is gradually grow- ing towards a whole one. Vice, distrust, and even some degree of enmity between States are thus generated, together with commercial inconveniences to a great ex- tent. If Congress should only establish a common half-bushel, and a true avoirdu- pois pound for the present, it would be highly beneficial. The English Winches- ter bushel would be the best, as being about the medium of these frauds, and because our commerce with that nation and its de- pendencies, in articles of dry measure, may again be greater than with any other. You see, my mind yet clings to the Union, as a man in a consumption does to life. Fare- well. Yours with great regard, JOHN TAYLOR. (Torn] Washington, D. C. ORIENTAL POETRY. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: That little poem of Yone Noguchi given by your correspondent, S. Tsushima of Kamakura, in your issue of February 16, has no doubt set many readers thinking about the difference between Eastern poetry and our own. A little acquaintance with the poetry of the T’angs shows easily the source of the leading ideas in the verses quoted. The voice of the bell, the shadow, the breeze, the moon, the mountains and rivers, the flower petals, the flash of the stirred leaf, the whispering of the wind in the grass—these may almost be cailed the stock in trade of the T’ang poets. And so we may assume that in that branch of Chinese literature Yone Noguchi must be deeply read. The combining of these various elements to express some special moment or phase of individual experience is also the method of the T’ang poets, and that is ex- actly the method of the verses in question, which might indeed be the product of the Buddhist or Taoist tendency in a T'ang poet. In that poetry, then, what is it that, being different from our own, is yet so attractive? Is it not the contemplation of nature as a play of vast forces in a sphere of their own, independent of and superior to any particu- lar humen interest? Our poetry may be said to centre in man, of whose situation and activity nature is merely the background or the instrument. Eastern poetry centres in nature with its imperious motions, its inscrutable laws, its tranquillity and beau- ty, over against which man appears from time to time, not to change but to contem- plate and admire. This is, of course, the most superficial, as it is the most salient, idea of Eastern poetry, but I have found it a solvent of many difficulties, and a stimulus to further curios- ity regarding a mode of thought which though apparently so different, is yet, in a way, the natural complement of our own. In fact, might not one hazard a guess that Fastern thought in general may prove to be rather complementary than supplemen- tary to ours, the other side, as it were, of known experience, rather than additional knowledge; and that a certain roundedness
Page 15
March 30, 1911] 317 The Nation of culture may perhaps in time result from increasing interest in and knowledge of the Fast. Yone Noguchi is one of the pioneers of this new knowledge, and I have no doubt tbat many lovers of poetry will, like myself, feel the attraction of his lines, even if at first we may have to grope around some- what and feel our way in the unfamiliar but truly poetical Eastern setting. JAMES BLACK. Denver, Col., March 4. Literature —_-~. FOLKLORE OF GREECE. Modern Greek Folklore and Ancient Greek Religion. By John Cuthbert Lawson. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $4 net. Mr. Lawson has devoted the leisure of ten years to working up into a solid and interesting book the collections of Greek folklore which he made in Greece dur- ing his two years’ tenure of the Craven studentship from 1898 to 1900. After studying the fear of the evil eye, as a first and typical illustration of the sur- vival of ancient superstitions, he pro- ceeds to an exhaustive survey of the eu- tire mythology from Zeus and Poseidon t» Pan and the Nymphs. This attempt at systematic completeness results in some perfunctory chapters. There is not much real evidence for the survival of the greater gods. The only testimony for Zeus is a Cretan invocation, Zéve 6c, which Mr. Lawson himself has not heard, but takes from Santzos. The functions of Zeus, including the duties of clerk of the weather, are transferred to God or distributed among the saints. The modern Greek woid derporedde sug- gests the reflection, that “though in the ancient literature, we may nowhere find the word réews used of the thun- derbolt, there is no reason why the mod- ern word should not be the expres- sion of a conception inherited from an- [Lucian to those of Life. And to uphoid ers whom their Achwan neighbors held |his unhesitating identification of Charos in awe for this gift and termed Pheres. with Charon, Mr. Lawson is driven to This, if not true, is at least admirable | “suspect that in ancient times the liter-/ romantic philology of the new anthro- jary presentation of Charon was far more pological type. circumscribed than the popular.” For The second half of the volume deals | the survival of the coin placed in the with more general religious concep- {wont of the dead, Mr. Lawson has only tions and superstitious practices. Mr hearsay evidence. He could not elicit! Lawson finds survivals of divination any positive statement that it was the|from the flight of birds, chance words, ferryman’s fee. The Fates, too, embody sneezing, the lines in the shoulder ‘a universal commonplace, and the many ‘blades of sheep, and, in one case, from interesting stories collected and plaust: |a pig's spleen. A study of vampires in- ble analogies noted prove little. Initroduces the whole question of short, we may be very grateful to Mr.|venants and bloodguiltiness. The words Lawson for the immense stores of en-| alastor, miastor, and prostropaios, all tertainment and instruction presented in| refer primarily, he thinks, to the venge this volume, and yet retain some re-|ful revenant wandering in bodily form. serves as to his main thesis, i. e., that) The “Mycenwan” inhumation and the Greek folklore is a real survival of clas- | “Ach@wan” cremation, both had ?or their sical mythology. Skepticism is always | object the normal dissolution of the in place with regard to travellers’ ac- | body, which put an end to such wander- counts of popular beliefs. The imagi-|ings on earth, and at the same time nation of the people is constantly fed | made possible the reconstitution of the by imperfectly apprehended suggestions corpse's elements in a corporeal and that filter down to it from above, and | happy life beyond the grave. The bless- about which the accretions of popular | edness of that life consisted in a re- fancy cluster. This is especially true of| union with the gods, which is described a people that possesses the great liter- | explicitly and not figuratively as a mar- ary tradition of the Greeks and takes/riage. The literary parallelisms be | such pride in it. The population of| tween marriage and death, from the nearly every canton of Greece has been | “Antigone” re- to the latest epigram, are repeatedly shifted, exterminated, and re-|to be taken litefally in this sense. The placed. The one abiding fact is the “Pelasgian” mysteries of Eleusis rep- pride of the Greeks in the language and | resented the consummation of this the writings of the ancients. In the/urion of the human and the divine, democratic fellowship of Greek life, | and so provoked the indignation and therg have always been fluent talkers/the calumnies of the Christian Fath with some tincture of letters whose con-|ers. The love philosophy of Plato's versation would supply hints to the “Symposium” has its source in the imagination of the illiterate. Both in|same order of ideas. To test and crit language and fable, then, the hypothe- icise these interesting suggestions sis of revival is always to be weighed would far exceed our scope. It is 4ll against that of survival. If you meet systematically developed with intense the phrase (ewevsev) and pvripos in the conviction, an enormous mass of illus- mouth of an uneducated Greek to-day, trations, and the citation of many au- you do not assume either that it is thorities. It will have to be reckoned a genuine survival or that he has read with. But it will first have to be veri- tiquity.” Of like character is the evi- | paper paragraph written by some gym- dence for Poseidon and “Lady ’Phrodite.”|nasium graduate. ‘This is an extreme Demeter and Persephone yield more. St.| but actual instance which illustrates the Demetrius is the patron of agriculture. possibilities. Some similar process seems But at Eleusis, the peasantry are said|to us the most probable explanation of tu have worshipped a statue of Demeter |many of the stories related by Mr. Law- as St. Demetra so late as 1801. The leg- | son on the authority of Schmidt, Sant- end of Demetra’s wanderings, as relat-|zos, or Lenormant. ed by an Albanian priest to Lenormant| Especially interesting are the rich in 1860, we cannot regard as confirma |chapters about the Nymphs, Nereids, tron. It is obviously contaminated 5) |and minor figures of mythology and literary reminiscence. Nor is it probabl. | folklore. Are we really to believe that that the occasional acceptance in Greece the female demons, the Gelloudes, are of the Mohammedan taboo of the pig goes | derived from Sappho’s Gello? From a back to ihe Demeter cult. Curious is the |table of twenty-three spellings of the surv:val in Arcadia of the divinity Des- name and on other good and valuable poina, to which Mr. Lawson is, he be-|ccnsiderations, Mr. Lawson decides that lieves, the first to call attention. \those mischievous monsters of popular Charos supplies material for one of | fancy, the Callicantzari, are the Cen- Mr. Lawson's best chapters. But the|taurs. The equine half of the Centaur ideas, the imagery, the conceits, and the was merely a symbol of his power of jests are those which human fancy as- | assuming any animal shape. The Cen sociates with death from the pages of|taurs were a tribe of reputed sorcer the “C2dipus at Colonus.’ He has heard fied. Like other systematic reasoners, |it from somebody who read it in a news- Mr. Lawson is sometimes tempted to force the facts to fit the system. He translates Aeschylus, “Coephori” 287-8: wavrev 8 ariysov nédiAov Cvianey xpévy canws TapixevOivTa waydOdpty popy “To die at last with none to hon- or, none to love him, damned even in the doom that wastes all, to know no corruption.” (Italics ours.) A@schylus is thus made to con firm the view that the object of crema tion and inhumation alike is the disso lution of the natural body, and that the failure of such dissolution is the most awful of curses. But the translation is flatly impossible. The muse of conjectur al, romantic anthropological philology is a fascinating creature, but she cannot be exempted from the primary duty of con- struing her Greek correctly.
Page 16
318 CURRENT FICTION. Denry the Audacious. By Arnold Ben- nett. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. Like “Helen with the High Hand,” this a diversion on Mr. Bennett's part. No doubt “The Old Wives’ Tale” and “Clayhanger”’ represent his serious work; but, much to our advantage, he is of the temperament which disdains to always wise. The Denry of this di- vertisement is another Clayhanger in origin and environment, but he exists altogether different plane of Mr. Bennett's fancy. His mother is a sempstress and washerwoman, living among the “potbanks” of Bursley; and “Denry” is her time-saving rendering of Edward Henry. The boy shows no spe- cial promise. In the course of every- day life he is commonplace enough. But at decisive moments he has an instinct for action, gloriously rash and glorious- Copybook morality does not deter him: he is a Five Towns Na- poleon, following his star. In short, as “Clayhanger” is a soberly ironical study of the humdrum, “Denry the Auda- cious” is a blithely ironical study of the inspired. In his own sphere, Denry breathes the true afflatus. His career is a series of tours de force. Bursley is proud of his feats, vaunts him as a “card,” and finally awards him the su- preme honor in her gift. The tale of his exploits is told with much good hu- mor—it is hardly more than a clever bit of fooling. A reader unfamiliar with Mr. Bennett would not be likely to cred- it the writer of this story with powers beyond those of a pleasant entertainer. is be upon an ly successful. But there are unexceptionable prece- dents for genius entertaining itself with the play of mere talent. Mr. Ben- nett’s versatility of mood is more re- markable than his virtuosity of method. Adventure. By Jack London. New York: The Macmillan Co, This is upon a different plane from Mr. London's recent novels. It is free from didacticism, has no remonstrance or propaganda up its sleeve, but dis- ports itself frankly in the realm of the agreeably preposterous. The time is the present, the place is the Solomon Isl- ands, and the persons—the only neces- sary persons—are an Englishman and an American girl. The man is in soli- tary charge of a plantation manned by cannibals, who are an unusually bad lot, even for cannibals. The island is fever-stricken when the scene opens, and the white man, who is himself sick almost to the point of collapse, main- tains his life and his authority solely by virtue of that miraculous function which, according to the muse of imper- laliam, enables the Briton to bear his burden. Shipwreck brings the girl upon the scene in the nick of time. She takes charge of the sick man and his affairs, and he recovers to find her >. The Nat [ Vol. 92, No. 2387 ion established in his household, and vir- tually refusing to budge. She laughs at the qualms and scruples that agitate his conventional soul, and proposes a business partnership. As an alterna- tive she threatens to buy an island and acquire cannibals of her own. Her body- guard of big Tahitians she regards as all that can be desired in the way of chaperonage or other protection. Of course, there is only one thing that can happen at the end of the road, and the interest for the hardened observer must lie in the incidents by the way. These include a revolt on the part of the resi- dent cannibals, and the pursuit of some of them far into the enemy’s country. Gory details are not lacking, horrors of the sort upon which Mr. London’s readers are wont to sup. One learns, for example, the exact method of smoke- curing a human head for the Solomon- ian trophy-room. But the flavor of the tale as a whole is that of a milder type of romance than Mr. London is in the habit of offering his public. The Andersons. By S. Macnaughton. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. Flora Anderson, an able young Scotchwoman resolved on matrimony, and her animadversions upon a halting lover furnish the sustaining interest in this extended narrative. The plot—both rudimentary and trite—is comprised in the disastrous excursion of a middle class Scotch family into London soci- ety and their prompt rescue by awld ac- quaintances. Though candidly deplor- ing her ill luck, Flora takes no shame from her situation, which she invests with the dignity of a sociological in- stance. “When the supply does not equal the demand, there is always a fic- titious value set upon even the most worthless goods. One million more wo- men than men in the British Isles——” And, indeed, the pressure exerted by this calamitous circumstance is plainly apparent upon all the marriageable wo- men in the book. The initial difficulties |attending the cooking of the hare, where hares are leanest and wariest and excel- lent cooks abound, have seldom been more frankly and feelingly expounded. But it is from the writer’s keen flair for native idiosyncrasy and her skill in de- picting Scotch genre scenes, rather than (from her insistent harping on. this theme, that the reader’s enjoyment is derived. Basset: A Village Chronicle. By 8S. G. Tallentyre. New York: Moffat, Yard & Co. This is a little masterpiece of histort-| cal perspective and imagination, You must rid yourself of the prevalent pre- disposition, in favor of a clearly defined plot, in order to enjoy properly a mod- ern representation of early Victorian village life, which is like nothing in the world but Trollope seen through a re- |versed opera glass, unless it be Mrs. Gaskell en plein air. Every member of the group constituting a typical Eng- lish rural community of seventy years ago is drawn as if from life; the artist’s jestimation of character values is that of her own day and generation, but the characters themselves belong indisputa- bly to the period which she undertakes to re-create, and she has enveloped them ia an atmosphere that is not merely dec- orative but vital. Some changes in per- sonal relationship work themselves out slowly to a satisfactory issue in the course of the chronicle; the situations are significant and often humorous, but never approach a dramatic pitch, ex- cept on the occasion when an eloping bride disappoints a waiting congrega- tion. There is a hint of altering con- |ditions in the intrusion of a young Lon- don physician upon an old country prac- |titioner’s preserves, and a glimpse of the then fashionable affectations exem- plified in the persons of a clever frump and her son, a foppish littérateur. Upon |closer examination, it will be realized that this village group comes near to epitomizing the national life of its dec- jade. Balzac himself might have sketch- 'ed such a figure as the village parson, |whose clumsily assumed cloth conceals |a veteran of the Peninsular campaign jand an unsuspected hero of knightly |adventure. | | LORD ACTON ON THE FRENCH REV- | OLUTION. | Lectures on the French Revolution. By | John Emerich Edward Dalberg-Acton, First Baron Acton, D.C.L., LL.D., etc., late Regius Professor of Modern His- tory in the University of Cambridge (England). Edited by John Nevile Figgis, C.R., Litt.D., and Reginald Vere Laurence, M.A. New York: The Macmillan Co. $3.25 net. Since Lord Acton’s lamented death nine years ago several volumes of his writings have appeared which have won for him a fame wider by far than he enjoyed in his lifetime; for though the very small circle that knew him per- sonally had the warmest admiration for his powers, his very name was unknown |to the great bulk of Englishmen as well ‘as Americans. First came his “Letters to Miss Mary Gladstone,” then a volume of lectures, put together from the notes |of his pupils, together with two volumes of collected “Essays”; and now we have ‘this volume of university discourses on the French Revolution which were the | fruit of his latest years. They form the most considerable single and con- |tinuous piece of work he ever did, and | probably would never have been com- |posed but for the necessity that lay upon him of preparing lectures for a class. His passion for striving upwards ‘toward the ideal he had set up of fin-
Page 17
March 30, 1911] The Nation ished literary form, coupled with the passion for accumulating facts and hunt- ing everywhere for new sources, prompt- ed him to keep back for further elab- oration whatever he wrote. These lec- tures would doubtless have been much enlarged as well as polished for publica- tion had he lived longer. But his fastid- iousness might have refused to let them appear at all, and we may well be thank- ful for what we here and now receive as the last fruit off a wonderful tree. Like everything else that Lord Ac- ton produced, these Lectures have that charm which is felt both in conversa- tion and in reading when one finds -one’s self in contact with a full mind, a mind that gives forth out of a store so abundant that one knows it could give much more than it has given, and that the opinions it delivers, be they right or wrong, are based on a wide range of knowledge. There is also here, as usually in Lord Acton’s writings, a curious un-English quality which im- parts to them a certain piquancy. There is a perfect command of materials and a power of referring to out of the way sources which is characteristic of the German scholar, and along with these aptitudes, there is also a fondness for anecdotes, especially those which turn on some pointed saying of historian or essayist which reminds one of the French. Indeed, not infrequently his “own way of summing up a view in an epigrammatic phrase reveals the influ- ence of French models. The phrases are often excellently turned, but they have sometimes that fault of lum- inous obscurity which is the weak point -of an epigrammatic style. One finds in this volume aphorisms which sound striking, and which obviously do con- ‘tain the results of careful thought, yet the meaning and bearing of which are far from clear. That this defect cannot be altogether due to the form of lectures in which the book appears, is | shown by its appearance in some of Lord Acton’s articles collected in the volume published in 1907. No modern theme is so well worn as the French Revolution of 1789-99. But these Lectures make it as interest- ing as a romance, at least to those who will bend their minds to master the full sense of what is given, for the strenuous thinking of the writer requires a corre- sponding exercise of thought in the read- er. Few historical treatises of more solid value have been published in our language for a long time past. Near- ly all the English books describing the Revolution have been either narratives of events, or studies of the more con- spicuous figures. Thomas Carlyle’s His- tory, the best known of them all, was written some eighty years ago, when the materials available were far infe rior to those we possess to-day. It is a splendid piece of literature, but it passes lightly over the constitutional part of the story and tells us little either of the ebbs and flows of surface opinions or of the underground forces which were at work. A good deal of it has been rendered obsolete by the discovery and examination of sources unknown when Carlyle wrote. In that most instructive review of the literature of the subject, which we find in the appendix to these Lectures, Lord Acton says of Carlyle’s book: The vivid gleam, the mixture of the sub- lime with the grotesque, make opponents forget the impatient verdicts and the pov- erty of settled fact in the volumes that de- livered our fathers from thraldom to Burke. They remain disap- pointing storm clouds that give out more thunder than lightning (p. 358). one of those Passing in review the books of Droz, Lamartine, Louis Blanc, Michelet, Villiaumé, Genoude, Gabourd, Barante, Tocqueville, Duvergier de Hauranne, La- boulaye, and some memoir writers, such as Mallet du Pan and Malouet, Lord Ac- ton awards the highest praise to Sybel, Taine, Sorel, Dareste and Aulard, not as necessarily the greatest writers, but as the most useful for the several sides of the subject which they treat. There is nothing better in the volume than this fine analysis of the historians of the Revolution, rich with weighty judg- ments and glittering with vivacious anecdote. No living man outside France |could have composed a survey so full |of knowledge, and of that kind of know- | ledge which is derived not wholly from |books, but from intercourse with the ‘best minds of France and Germany. | The distinctive note of these Lectures, (as compared with other English books j}and most French books on the subject is their careful study and exposition of the constitutional side of the movement and of the ideas which animated its | leading spirits. To trace those ideas is }no easy task, for in the four years be- tween the meeting of the States Gen- |eral,in May, 1789, and the voting of the |Constitution of June, 1793—an instru- ment which never, in fact, took effect— there was an incessant conflict of theo- |ries and doctrines, so that almost every ‘form of constitutional monarchy, of mod- |erate republicanism, and of democ- jracy, both representative and direct, ‘had its exponents and advocates. |Among the theorists, the clearest as {well as most resourceful and inven- | tive thinker would seem to have ibeen the Abbé Sieyés; and, so far as any person can be called a revolution- ary hero in Lord Acton’s view, Sieyés, “the most perfect representative of the | Revolution,” is that hero. At any rate, 'this book is the first one In our tongue in which the gifts and the influence of | this remarkable person, whose eminence |Talleyrand (in his posthumous Me- | motrs) acknowledges, malignant as his comments are, have received due recog- nition: 310 As a priest without a vocation he employ- ed himself with secular studies and master- ed and meditated the French and English onomists he and was thor- writers of the age, and philosophers. politicians, e Learning from many became the disciple of none oughly independent, looking beyond the hor- izon of his own century He understood politics as the science of the State as it ought to be, and he repudiated the product of history which is things as they are. He turned resolutely from the past and re- fused to be bound by the precepts of men who believed in slavery and sorcery, ‘no torture and persecution: Siey@és was es- sentially a revolutionist because he held that political oppression can never be right and that resistance to oppression can never be wrong. He was a royalist, not as believing in the proprietary right of dynas- ties, but because monarchy, justly limited and controlled, is one of many forces that secure the liberty which is given by society and not by nature. He was a Liberal, for he thought Liberty the end of government, and defined it as that which makes men most completely masters of their faculties in the largest sphere of independent action He was also a democrat, for he would re- vise the Constitution once in a generation and he described the law of those who are those who govern have no share in making. But he was less a democrat than a Liberal; and he contrived scientific provision against the errors of the sovereign nation. He sacrific- ed equality by refusing the who paid no taxes, and elaborate system of indirect election. He became odious to Robespierre, who, af- ter the fall of Danton, turned against him and required Barére to see what he could be as the settled will governed, which vote to those he preferred an and filtered charged with. The Abbé’s nerves never quite recovered from the impressions of that time. When he fell ill, forty years later, and became feverish, he sent down to tell the porter that he was not at home if Robespierre should call. What I have just said will give you a more favorable view of Sleyés than you may find in books. The Abbé was not a high-minded man, and he has no friends in his own country. Some dislike him because he was a priest, some because he was an unfrock- ed priest. He is odious to royalists as a revolutionist, and to republicans as a rene- gade. I speak of him as a political thinker, not as a writer, an orator, or an adminis- trator. Certain papers have recently come to light tending to show that he was as wicked as the rest of them. They would not affect my judgment on his merit as a thinker (pp. 159-163). We have made these long quotations from the estimate of Sieyés, not only Lecause the view presented will be novel to most readers, but also because they are a good instance of some of Lord Acton’s qualities, thoroughness, vigor- ous independence of judgment, the habit of looking at a man all round, the gift of enlivening disquisition by anecdote. There are, in these Lectures, many brief- er, but equally striking characteriza- tions of famous figures, such as Necker, Mirabeau, Danton, Dumou- riez, Charlotte Corday, Marat, Robes-
Page 18
320 The Nation [ Vol. 92, No. 2387 pierre, The judgments passed are, most | of them, Lord Acton is what used to be called in England (in the old- “a hanging judge.” Revolutions severe, er days) are said to bring unscrupulous men to the top, or to make the able men who come to the top unscru- pulous; but few revolutionary epochs show so high a percentage of wick- edness as this does. Even the Gi- rondins, whom we used to be taught to esteem and pity, fare almost as ill at Lord Acton’s hands as at those of Car- Ivle. The eloquence of Vergniaud wins for it is only the courageous Lanjuinais whom we are per- mitted to respect Among them all, Robesplerre and his immediate group retain a sort of hateful primacy in blood shedding, though Danton, with his mas- sacre of September, is really no better, while Tallien, Collot, and the other Ther- midorians are just as brutal and ruthless the dictator they overthrew. Rightly, as it seems to us, Lord Acton finds for the by all the factions, no great palliation in the intoxication of the people with the ideas of freedom and equality, or in the panic created by the foreign invasions. More vulgar causes—revenge, the feroc- ity of those whose savage impulses were set free from the usual restraints of law, the excitement of destruction, and the selfish ambition of faction leaders seeking power for themselves, suf- ficiently explain the action of the chief movers and the ruffians who followed them. That which the sense of danger from without did, was to make the larger mass of the Parisian populace ac- quiesce, or regard with stolid apathy horrors which, had that peril been ab- they might have been roused to him little indulgence; whom a8 crimes committed sent, check. The sternness of our author's attitude strikes us most when we come to his ar- raignment of the King and Queen. Louis XVI was not a wicked man. He gener- ally wished to do right, and on the few occasions when he showed firmness, it was in defence of a principle. Several times, indeed, he played a double part, | and conspired against those who had wrested power from him, in a way that might called treasonable, but this course could easily, to a man who saw how things were rushing downwards to the abyss, seem justifiable In the inter- esta of France, as well as in his own. His excuse ia better than that of the English Charies the First, when the latter stood in a somewhat similar posi- tion. Lord Acton, however, passes sen- tence in these words: be absolve him its impossible, for we better than his persecutors, how he To know intrigued to recover uncontrolled authority by devastation upon the over whom he reigned. The crowning tragedy is not that which Paris witnessed when Santerre raised his sword, commanding the drums to beat, which had been silenced by the first words of the dying bringing havoc and people imaginative power. speech; it is that Louis XVI met his fate with inward complacency, unconscious of guilt, blind to the opportunities he had wasted and the misery he had caused, and died a penitent Christian, but an unre- pentant King (p. 255). If history weighs the demerits of men by the results of their errors and their weaknesses, those of the unhappy king | will be heavy indeed: At every step downward, the King and Queen were the authors of their own disaster. The French republic was not a _ spontaneous’ evolution of | social elements. The issue between constitutional monarchy and the _ re- was decided by the crimes of men errors more inevitably fatal than crime. There is another world for the ex- piation of guilt, but the wages of folly are here below. public and by payable Though the book is not so much a narrative history as a series of running | comments upon events, and especially on those movements of opinion which were the most important among the events, it would be unfair to forget to note the author's qualifications as the | This is the only one | teller of a story. of his books in which he appears in that capacity. The art of narrative is one in which he had little practice, yet every | now and then he reaches high excellence. The general march of political change, the succession of events by which the revolutionary movement advanced and prevailed, is, indeed, not very clear- ly given. So much is assumed as known, or is told by allusion, that in most chapters the reader wishes for some sort of chronicle with dates to help him. But particular episodes are often told with a freshness and graphic force which make one feel the author's The description of Maillard’s march to Versailles and its consequences is admirable. In Thomas Carlyle’s book, there is no finer passage than the account of the Flight to Var- ennes. Lord Acton’s description is less passionate, less highly colored, perhaps | less thrilling. But it is not only far more | accurate, an easily gained advantage be- cause much new material has been dis- covered since Carlyle wrote, but equal in dramatic interest, because we are made to feel at almost every hour of the long and fateful day what was passing, and how the persons were acting upon whose codéperation the fortunes of the enterprise depended. Not infrequently we find in Acton’s writings not only the raconteur’s love of anecdote, but also a tendency to search for the causes of great events in small ones, sometimes because the small one happened at a critical moment, sometimes because, though not decisive in itself, it reveal- ed the quality of character in which suc- cess or failure lay. Many of the anec- dotes are new, some of great interest, such as those given on p. 223 about Dumouriez, and those on pp. 245-7 about the massacres of September 1792. Some |few will be found surprising, such as the following about Pitt’s relations with Danton (p. 254): | Information was brought to Pitt, from a |source that could be trusted, that Danton would save the King for £40,000. When he | made up his mind to give the money, Dan- ton replied that it was too late. Pitt ex- plained to the French diplomatist Maret, | afterwards prime minister, his motive for hesitation. The execut'on of the King of France would raise such a storm in Eng- land that the Whigs would be submerged. Hardly anybody comes well out of the story of these years. The sovereigns of Europe and their ministers are less ‘eruel but hardly less selfish and cal- lous than the revolutionists of 1792-6. Mirabeau took money, Danton took mon- ey, Robespierre’s reputation for not tak- ing it helped him to be more horrible than any one else, except indeed Marat. Has public conscience improved since | those days, as we all like to believe? Lord Acton answers gloomily. Speak- ing of Danton and Robespierre and the massacre of September, he says: | We are in the company of men fit for Tyburn. I need spend no words in im- pressing on you the fact that these re- publicans began with atrocities as great as those of which the absolute monarchy was justly accused, and for which it just- ly perished. What we have to fix in our thoughts is this: that the great crimes of the Revolution, and crimes as great in the history of other countries, are still defend- ed and justified in almost every group of politicians and historians; so that, in prin- ciple, the present is not altogether better than the past (p. 248). He might have added that the massa- eres of Corcyra in the fifth century, B. C., were not worse than St. Barthol- omew’s Day at Paris in the sixteenth, A. D. Thucydides was horrified by the former, and we all know how Papal Rome received the latter. But Lord Acton’s condemnation of the Revolution- ists does not affect his view of the Revo- {lution itself. To him it marks an im- mense onward step in the march of mankind, a thing to which we are al] to- day indebted for some of the political | benefits we enjoy. + One Way Out: A Middle-Class New Eng- lander Emigrates to America. By William Carleton. Boston: Small, Maynard & Co. $1.20 net. This is a most interesting book, well- written and straightforward. More than that, it is a really notable brief for democracy that everybody ought to read who is fearful of the effect upon our in- stitutions of our new citizens from over- seas. The story is a simple one. The narrator—it is asserted that the book is a narrative of actual experience—was a clerk in a large corporation trying, on a meagre salary, to make both ends meet, and limiting his family to one child in order to make possible that
Page 19
March 30, 1911] The Nation 321 standard of comfort demanded by con- | into exuberance. But these essays, evi- impatience or ill temper are not alto vention in the suburb in which he liv- ed, when he suddenly lost his position. Having no savings, and having no ac- quirements save those of a _ routine clerk, he found himself at thirty-eight unable to go West or to procure re- employment. In most books of this kind the “way out” is to go back to the land, to wring a livelihood from some abandoned New England farm. Instead, this hero went to a new tenement and began life again, in the topmost fiat, with the aid of his admirable wife, and as a day-laborer. How they lived on $9 a week and how “Carleton” won his way upward is absorbing reading. Some housekeepers may question the finan- cial statements given; the very finical might even point out a place or two where the narrative is vulnerable, but it is a stirring human document never- theless, for the reason that it shows how the stream of immigration quickens our whole national life, and because it con- centrates in one human _ experience much of the romance and the opportu- nity of America—the freedom to rise that brings the foreign masses to our shores. This particular American who, as he says, “emigrated to New Eng- land,” illumines in his book a large part of the natural phenomena of our demo- cratic life, besides showing in an admir- able way the fine things that adhere to honest manual] labor and the cramping | effects of middle-class convention. It is a bit of stimulating Americanism that ought to find a place in our school li- braries next to Jacob Riis’s “The Mak- ing of an American,” for its emphasis is always on the things that are really worth while. Gray Days and Gold. By William Win- ter. Revised edition. New York: Mof- fat, Yard & Co. More than twenty years have elapsed since William Winter first published his delightful notes of travel in the British Isles. The public appreciation of them is best proved by the fact that they have passed through fifteen editions. Now they reappear, after careful revision, and with much additional matter in the new and handsome form chosen for his collected works, with all the advantages conferred by noble type, fine paper, am- ple margins, and copious illustrations | of singular refinement and beauty. In the earlier volumes, articles on Scottish scenes and places were included. These have been reserved for a later book. The present papers, twenty-four in number are devoted, with one exception, to Eng- lish subjects and two-thirds of them are virtually fresh. It would be diffi- cult to exaggerate their charm. Every- body familiar with any of Mr. Winter's critical or other writings, knows that he is a master of rich and melodious English. In the past, his facility of ut- terance has betrayed him occasionally |dently a labor of love to him, are mod- els of musica] prose and are free from jredundance. To all educated travellers along the route which they follow—from |Southampton to the Scottish border— they will prove an invaluable and faa cinating guide to the spots most notable for their historic interest, literary as- sociation, or natural loveliness. The whole book is charged with full and accurate scholarship, especially on subjects connected with the life, the creations and the times of Shakespeare, but is exempt from all taint of pedan- try. It is a felicitous blend of pleasant and informing gossip, brilliant descrip- tion, delicate and poetic perception, and grave reverie. One of its greatest charms lies in its reflection of the .u- thor’s personality, his poetic suscepti- bility, his appreciation of the exquisite or the sublime, his alert humor, and his vein of philosophic pathos. It would be easy to quote many passages illustrative of his keen critical faculty --from his tributes to Byron, Tennyson, | Wordsworth, Matthew Arnold, and oth. ers—or of his rare gift of eloquent and |realistic description in picturing the beauties of Stratford-upon-Avon, or the jsolemn magnificence of old cathedrais, but the value of this book is not to ne tested by samples. The intelligent read- er who opens it will not lay it aside un- til he has absorbed all that lies between the covers, and he will be grateful to) ‘the man that produced it. | | Cecil Rhodes: His Private Life. By his | Private Secretary, Philip Jourdan. New York: John Lane Co. $2.50 net. The appearance of a third book about |Cecil Rhodes within eight months wit- nesses to the interest which is felt, or which English publishers believe to be felt, in England in the character and career of a man whom the swelling wave of what is called “Imperialistic sentiment” has raised to surprising prominence in Great Britain as well as in South Africa. We have so recently, in reviewing the two books about Rhodes written by Sir Thomas Fuller (Nation of August 25, 1910), and by Sir Lewis |Mitchell (Nation of March 16, 1911), ‘commented upon that character and ca- reer, that all we need do in noticing this third book is to call attention to the further light,.such as it is, which is here thrown upon Rhodes’s personal- ity. Mr. Jourdan writes with the par. \donable enthusiasm of a private secre- tary to whom the hero has not ceased to be a hero, intimate though his know- ledge is. His book is filled with a jseries of incidents or anecdotes calcu- |lated to show Rhodes in a favorable light as a kindly, generous, warm-heart- ed man, loyally steadfast to his friends, jand seldom personally bitter towards ‘his opponents. His occasional fits of gether hidden of sight; other blemishes denied, The biographer admits the quarrels with Gen, Kekewich during the siege of Kimberley and de out nor are plores the passion for bridge-playing which Rhodes contracted in his later years and which, as it induced him to sit up late at night, involved the dis continuance of the earl¥ morning rides that had theretofore kept him fresh and vigorous through many toils and vicissi tudes. But Mr. Jourdan the calumnies which were circulated about refutes Rhodes in his later years—that he was in the habit of betting, that he gam bled in stocks, that his habits were in temperate, that his private life was lax. All these charges, and especially the two latter, are declared to be base less calumnies: and this seems to be proved by plenty of concurrent testi- mony from those who had the best means of knowing. We are according ly ready to believe that Mr. denial of them is sincere and ought to be accepted. He renders a service the memory of Rhodes by telling in de- tail the story of the lady, described in the book as of Russian birth, who per secuted him by her attentions, circulat ed false stories about him, and was ulti mately convicted of having forged his name to promissory notes. The account here given completely clears Rhodes, whose life was shortened by these ox currences, for he went from England to South Africa in order to give evi dence at the trial, and, being already in weak health, suffered severely from the journey. His medical advisers had warned him of the risk, but he felt that he must at all hazards give in court evidence needed to vindicate his charac- ter. The book, as we have said, is slight and anecdotal rather than historica) It is not always correct, in its facts, nor even in the account ot Rhodes'’s own opinions about other men, and it fails to grasp some of Rhodes’s most interest ing traits. But it gives an interesting and self-consistent picture of a man of remarkable practical gifts, cared little for the smaller things of life, be ing indifferent to comfort or luxury and unmindful of dress, who had pronounced literary tastes, except Roman history, and no definite relig ious opinions, though he was ready to subscribe for religious purposes. All his energy was reserved for the large schemes he was constantly revolving, and into these he threw himself with untiring persistence. He expected all whom he employed to display the same vigor and persistence. If they succeed- ed, he rewarded them liberally. [If they failed, he cast them aside with- out ruth. He was often brusque and impatient, but not spiteful or vindic- tive. He loved power and glory with a passion which made him occasionally Jourdan’'s to who no for
Page 20
yey 3 ~~ transgress the bounds which conscience ought to have but his not selfish and desire did not into lower of vanity in whom, with all was much to like as well as to admire. set; his lapse the Altogether a man faults, there and honor aims were for fame forms his Notes King Over the Water, or the Mar- of Mr. Melancholy,” of dealing with the old Pretender, which H McCarthy with & Blackett riage is the title a novel Justin is publishing Hurst out L. Hutchinson bringing Old Ne Me “Parodies are sare and \ by Stanley Adam T novel, Copas 7 Sir Quiller-Couch’s new A “Brother the will come this month Collier's house West of same “The Point Scribner press fron its list Price in im the View has ast from an American contracted with volume Co. have Holt ederi & Taber Ame Henry Fr on representative for rican story-tellers. Ir Cooper a “Purgatorio,” edited by Prof. C. after the manner of his edi- Dante's H tion of the “Inferno,” is announced for im- issue by D Heath & ¢ The is also in preparation Grandgent mediate Cc ‘o. “Paradiso” The Macmillan Company promises short- ‘The Ladies’ Battle,” an argument woman suffrage, by Molly Elliot and “World Literature,” by Dr. Moulton ly against Seawell, Richard G id tell Cassell & has placed a new novel with Co John Spargo is publishing with B. W Huebsch “Sidelights on Contemporary So- cialism.” novels will be issued in April the Century Mary Dil- Livingston's Companion,” and Mrs Two new May by lon's “Miss “An Ardent Codman and Co., American,” by Russell been ap- the United the Univer- ‘ Co. have Gre & for the publications Longmans n in of agents sale of the of Manche In hia series of California stories, Rich- out immediately Miss G. A. Den- Daughter,” by pointe ad State nity ster bringing by is Meadow,” Sagasto's Badger Dawn “Don Blades ard “The nen Paul J. B. Lippincott “From Memory's Shrine,” of Car- men Sylva, Queen of Roumania: ‘The Cap!- tale of China,” by William Edgar Geil; “A Short History of the United States Navy,” by Capt. George R. Clark; “The Boy Scouts of Rirch-Bark Island,” by Rupert Sargent Hlolland In the list of Henry Holt & Co, are: “The and Co. announces: reminiscences Valley Captives,” by R Macaulay; “Household Administration: Ite Place in the Higher Education of Woman,” docu- ments edited by Alice Ravenhill and Cath- erine J. Schiff; “Three Lays of Marie de France,” a paraphrase by Prof. F. B. Lu- qiens, and Wildenbruch’s ‘“Kindertrinen, edited by Dr. A. E. Vestling [Vol. 92, No. 2387 ‘The Nation Division” (Henry Frowde, Oxford Univer- sity Press) does not threaten to reverse the world’s opinion of the Monk of Bury, but, in the light of Prof. Henry Cracken's scholarly introduction, this assumes not a little interest. Writing in 1422, apparently at the mand of Duke Humphrey of Gloucester, then Lord Protector, Lydgate endeavors to illustrate the dangers of civil strife by re- count ng the life of Julius Caesar. It was a time of general apprehension; Henry V had died, and his heir was only nine months old; but Lydgate is too true to himself to be fired by the opportunity. He sets resolutely to work, collecting his ma- prose tract com- just terials, with scant eye to proportion, from the best authorities, and turns out what is, at any rate, the most extensive treatment of Julius Cesar in Middle English, and one of the very earliest political pamphlets in English history. Even Lydgate’s sources, which Professor MacCracken works out with care, are rather soberly matter of fact. In dealing with Julius Cw@sar, the on the whole, close and Suetonius. The present text on the Fitzwilliam MS., supple- by the Calthorpe MS.; the read- of the Pepys and the Harvard MSS. collated throughout The three reproductions from contemporary illustrations highly at- mediwval writers kept to Lucan is based mented ings ire page manuscript are tractive. Prof. John Livingston Lowes (“Chaucer| and the ‘Miroir de Mariage,’ "’ Modern Phil-| ology, VIII, 2, 3) continues with great acute- | the Old French materials which Chaucer, the “grand translateur,” so thoroughly assimilated and which in- fluenced him more extensively and more persistently than has generally been sup- This time it is the “Miroir de Mar- loge.” a twelve-thousand-line poem of Eus- tache Deschamps, which supplies Chaucer with a good deal of material for the dis- cussion of marriage in the “Merchant’s Tale,” with more than one suggestion for the Wife of Bath, and with sundry bits that appear in the A-Prologue to the “Legend of Good Women,” the “Miller’s Prologue,” and the “Franklin's Tale.” Bound up in this discussion are important considerations ness to identify posed. of chronology and of the development of | Chaucer's narrative art, which Professor Lowes intends to treat later more at large. + The march of civilization and the hu- manizing of manners are eloquently attest- ed in the changed relations between au- thors and publishers. What the eighteenth | century writers thought of their booksell- | and how the booksellers treated their writers, has become tradition. Even the | gentle Elia grew venomous on the subject. When the great houses of Constable and | Ballantyne went down in the financial) panic of 1826, Lamb wrote to Wordsworth: “When Constable fell from heaven, and we all hoped Baldwin was next, I turned a slight stave to the words in ‘Macbeth’! (D'Avenant’s), to be sung by a chorus of | authors: ‘What should we do when Booksellers break? We should rejoyce."’ | ers, And there is, of course, the famous letter | to Bernard Barton: “Throw yourself on | the world without any rational plan of sup- | port beyond what the chance employ of | | booksellers would afford you! ! ! Throw The publication of Lydgate’s “Serpent of ' yourself, rather, my dear sir, from the steepest examples of Celtic art dating from Noble Mac- | full- | | Tarpeian rock, slap-dash headlong upon iron spikes. They are Turks and Tartars. | Come not within their grasp.” Yet in this same volume that chronicles the wrath of Lamb, and cites the famous anonymous epigram, “‘Now Barabbas was a publisher” —Frank A. Mumby’s “The Romance of Bookselling” (Little, Brown & Co.)—we find the story of numerous hearty fr:endshins between authors and publishers. Of Con- stable, over whose fall Lamb rejoiced, Scott wrote to Lockhart: While I live I shall regret the downfall of Constadle, for never did there exist so | intelligert and so liberal an establishment. | They went too far when money was plenty, that is certain; yet, if every author in Brit- ain had taxed himself half a year’s income, he should have kept up the house which first bruke in upon the monopoly of the London trade, and made letters what they Dow are. Perhaps the classic type of the benevolent and wise publisher is George Smith of Smith, Elder & Company, the friend of Charlotte Bronté, Thackeray, George Henry Lewes, Harriet Martineau, Mrs. Gaskell, Anthony Trollope, Symonds, Matthew Ar- nold, the Brownings, and George Eliot. Mr. Mumby touches on the ever-fresh sub- ject of authors’ earnings. While it is gen- erally true that authorship before the nine- teenth century did not “pay,’’ every age has had its exceptions. Martial grumbled at the scant profits from his verses as com- pared with Horace’s Sabine farm and Ver- gil’s 10,000,000 sesterces. The Elizabethans were the victims of pirate publishers. Mil- ton signed away the copyright of “Para- dise Lost” for £5, with a further £5 at | the end of the first, second, and third edi- tions. Altogether, Mr. Mumby calculates Milton received what would be in present- | day money about £63. But already Dryden receives £1,200 for his “Vergil” and £250 for the first edition of his fables. Estimates | of Pope’s profits from the “Iliad’’ range be- tween £4,000 and £5,320. Johnson received for his “Dictionary” £1,575, for Rasselas £125, for his Shakespeare edition £1,300, for the “Lives of the Poets” 200 guineas— this because Johnson did not ask for more; the publishers stood ready to give 1,500 guineas. Among large author’s payments in later days were Crabbe’s £3,000 from John Murray for “Tales of the Hall’; Mrs. Strickland’s £2,000 from Bentley for ‘‘Lives of the Queens”; Lord Lytton’s £20,000 from Routledge for a ten years’ right to issue cheap editions of his published works; Thomas Moore’s £3,000 from Longmans for “Lalla Rookh"”; Macaulay’s £20,000 from Longmans for profits on the third and fourth volumes of his “History”; George Eliot’s £10,000 from Smith, Elder & Co. for “Romola.” For “Treasure Island” in book form Stevenson received, “how much do you suppose? Well, a hundred pounds, all alive O! A hundred jingling, tingling, golden, minted quid! Is not this wonder- ful?” In the account which the London Athe- na@um gives of the exhibition, now open at |the British Museum, of Bibles and docu- ments illustrating the history of the Eng- lish Bible, we note: The exhibition is in two parts, the first comprising the chief Biblical manuscripts of the Museum, including the Codex Alex- andrinus, some early Hebrew and Latin codices, the Bosworth Psalter, and the famous Lindisfarne Gospels, one of the fin-
Page 21
March 30, 1911] The first case on the about 700 a. p.... left contains a number of fifteenth-century Bibles printed in the vernacular, includ- ing German, Low German, Italian, Dutch, and Bohemian . . illustrated Bibles, ex- amples of which are the Low German Bi- ble of 1480, the Italian one of 1493, the Ma- lermi Bible, and the French Bible of 1510. A copy of Lyndewood’s Provinciale is open at the decision of the Synod of Oxford in 1433 forbidding the circulation of the Bible in the vulgar tongue, with a note to the words “noviter compositus” pointing out that ancient versions were not forbid- den, a point afterwards made by Sir Thom- as More. In the second case are several treasures: The only known fragment of Tyndale’s first New Testament, the printing of which was interrupted at Cologne in August, 1525; the only complete copy known of the second New Testzment, printed at Worms in the same year; two copies of Tyndale’s version of the Pentateuch, printed in 1530, and his translation of Jonah, printed before June, 1531. In the same case are shown Joye’s unauthorized edition of Tyndale’s New Testament of August, 1534; Tyndale’s edition of November, 1534; Joye’s second edition of January, 1535; and Tyndale’s of 1535, Anne Boleyn’s copy of the November, 1534, edition shown is on vellum. Of six reputed editions of the New Testament printed in 1526 no copy is known to exist, unless, indeed, the fragment in the Dur- ham Cathedral Library prove to be one The editions used by Tyndale—Erasmus's Latin-Greek New Testament and Luther's German version—are also shown. The next case contains the first com- plete English Bible printed, that of Cov- erdale in 1535; Matthew's Bible of 1537, printed at the expense of Richard Grafton and Edward Whitchurch; Taverner’s Bi- ble of 1539, and two out of the three edi- tions of the Vulgate with the English trans- lation of Coverdale. The next case contains: Five out of the seven editions of Cran- mer’s Bible of 1540, together with the Royal Proclamation of May 6th, 1541, enforcing its use. The history of the popular Geneva version, of which first editions of the New Testament (1557) and the Bible (1560) are shown, is fully illustrated, and copies of the Bishops’ Bible, the Rhemish New Tes- tament, and the Douai Old Testament fill the next case. A folio edition of the Geneva version shows that it was used in church- es for some years from 1578, and the last edition in folio, issued in 1644, fixes the date when it began to be superseded by the Au- thorized Version. The cases devoted to the Authorized Ver- sion show: The two versions of 1611 (the “He” Bible and the “She” Bible), the 1613 and 1617 editions, and the first quarto and octavo editions in 1611, while a last case contains some curiosities, such as the “Wicked” Bi- ble of 1631, which omitted the ‘“‘not’”’ in the seventh commandment, and the “un- righteous” Bible of 1653, which printed 1 Cor. vi. 9 as “know ye not that the unrighteous shall inherit the kingdom of heaven.” Some further revisions are shown, including the Cambridge ones of 1629 and 1638; Baskett’s “Vinegar” Bible, which was called “a basket-ful of errors’; and an Amsterdam Bible of 1643, containing the text of the Authorized Version with the notes of the Geneva issue. The cases devoted to documents affecting the history of the English Bible include: The first mention of Tyndale’s transla- tion, in a letter of Lee to Henry VIII in December, 1525, from Bordeaux on his way to Spain, Lee had probably learnt of the printing of the Testament at Calais, where Roye. Tyndale’s assistant, had friends and relations, Other items shown are the Bishop of Norwich’s subscription to the fund for buying up Testaments to burn them, Mon- mouth’s petition giving the history of his relations with Tyndale, Grafton’s corre- spondence with Thomas Crumwell, _li- censes for printing the Great. Bible, the Welsh Bible, and the Geneva Bibie. The director of the New York State Li- brary for the Blind, which is operated as a division of the State Library Albany, reports a collection of 3,000 in raised letters, and a registry of 800 active blind borrowers. During the last years 50,000 volumes have been borrowed by blind persons, an average of 17 issues for each volume in stock and of 60 loans to each borrower. The difficulty of enlarging the collection is pointed out in the fact that it costs $316 to print a single copy of such a work as Parkman's “Oregon Trail” and $230 for a copy of “Rebecca of Sunnybrook Farm,” each of these works appearing two mammoth A corresponding advantage in this high cost is noted in that only works of real worth and interest are thus available. Books which have had the largest circulation the last two years are “Tom Sawyer,” borrowed 104 times; Lee's “Uncle William,” times; Hale’s “Daily Bread,” 91 times; Gaskell’s “Cranford,” 90 times; Andrew's “Perfect Tribute,” 80 times; Wiggin’s “New Chronicles of Re- becca,” 64 times; Wister’s “The Virginian,” 61 times; Harker’s “Miss Esperance and Mr. Wycherly,” 54 times; Aldrich’s “Selected Stories,” 53 times; Taft’s “Present-Day Problems,” 36 times. By act of Congress in 1904 provision was made for the free car- riage by mail of all books for the blind when sent from or to libraries, so all blind persons of the State have the free and equal use of this library, wherever they may reside. at volumes twelve in volumes 97 “A Little Fifer’s War Diary” (Syracuse, N. Y.: The Author), by C. W. Bardeen, is not an important contribution to our civil war literature. Mr. Bardeen was but thirteen at the firing on Sumter, and though he went through two strenuous years with the First Massachusetts, his diary is very meagre, as might be expected of such a child. Nor do the author's recollections help the matter much; for in great crises, as at Chancellorsville and Gettysburg, they are quite crowded aside by quotations from other participants, from privates up to corps commanders, whereby we lose the personal touch. The history is bad. For instance, it is well ascertained that Stone- wall Jackson was wounded fatally by the fire of his own men, and not by Federal volleys, as Mr. Bardeen contends, and few students of the engagement will conclude that the honors of Gettysburg belong to Sickles, and not to Meade, as is here as- serted. The illustrations are purtraits, and the crude contemporary sketches of the pictorial newspapers, vivid enough surely, but for many years scattered broadcast, and easily accessible in more complete and better shape. In the correspondence re- lating to a pension, introduced to show the unreasonableness and inefficiency of the officials, the commissioner of pensions ap- pears to much better advantage than Mr. Bardeen, Proper vigilance and system in the discharge of a most responsible and arduous duty ought not to be stigmatized as ridiculous red tape and stupidity. “Yesterday and To-day in Canada” (Lon- don: G. Allen & Sons), by the Duke of Argyll, is one of the three opening volumes in a series of books on the British Em- pire. The Duke of Argyll, the Governor-General of the Dominion, retains an interest in all matters Canadian, and is eminently qualified to deal with his subject one time 323 in a thoroughly informed manner. He re- fers in an impartial way to the race prob- lem of Canada, which continues to persist as a fundamental problem in the face of passing decades. The author devotes a chapter of general information to each province of Canada except diminutive Prince Edward Island. Attention is di- rected then to such timely and pertinent questions as the naval and military defence, the development of transportation facilities, the meeting of ministers London the chapter the an account is given of the naval de in the Canadian Parliament during the early part of 1910 interesting and colonial in In on defence issue bates Doubtless the most to Americans as well that entitled National The author describes present condition of the Railway, the Grand Trunk lines in the chapter, as Canadians, is Highways of Canada. the and Canadian Paci fi Pacific Railway, country. He goes into detail, In the Grand Trunk Pacifte, and presents statistics showing the immense ad- of gradients, this line, now in process of construction, is to have the Northern, Pacific, and other lines across the continent In later chapters, is directed Canada's relations with the United States He that the notion that England has wantonly sacrificed Canadian interests on several occasions is not based on fact. He discusses the Elgin- Marcy reciprocity treaty of 1854-66, the Alaska boundary controversy, the New- foundland fisheries question, and many other matters having to do with the lations between Canada and her great Southern neighbor. This leads the author naturally to his pet subject—Imperial fed- eration. growth and other respect to vantage low and easy which over Great Union attention to endeavors to show prevalent re- “Corpus Nummorum Italicorum” is the title of a catalogue of mediwval and mod- ern coins, struck in Italy or by Italians abroad, which is in preparation by the firm of Savoie in Milan; the first volume of the ten which are planned is now ready. The work is based chiefly upon the col- lection of the King, who, from childhood, has been devoted to the subject. “Aus meinem Leben,” Erster Teil, by A. Bebel (Stuttgart: J. H. W. Dietz), is an unusually interesting contribution to mod- ern history by the alert leader of Social Democracy in Germany. Bebel’s account of his humble youth and of the development of his political and theories all the more valuable because written an exceptionally and objective Among the most interesting features of this work are the author's personal accounts of such history-makers as Bismarck, Lassalle, E. Richter, Liebknecht. The book Is a fine literary exponent of modern Social racy which incites to thought even where it is in way. economic calm Democ- provokes opposition. The new German edition of Falk and Torp’s Etymological Dano-Norwegian Dic- tionary (Norwegisch-dinisches etymolo- gisches Wérterbuch, mit Unterstiitzung der Verfasser fortgefiihrte deutsche Bearbei- tung von Hermann Davidsen; Heidelberg: C. Winter, 1907-1911) is now complete. Its advantages over the older edition (published in Christiania, 1903-1906), which it fal- lows after so interval, are (1) That al! explanatory matter is in German, brief an
Page 22
324 which will make it accessible to many students of etymological problems to whom the original Dano-Norwegian text presented no inconsiderable difficulty; (2) that it has undergone thorough revision, involving numerous corrections and the addition of no little supplementary mat- ter. Especially welcome in this connection are the “Literaturangaben und Nachtrige”’ (pp. 1425-1582), with references to the di- verging opinions of other etymologists; (3) that indices of Old Norse and Ger- man words are included, the first edition having indexed only Norwegian dia- lect-words. The work with its treatment of numerous High and Low German loan- words and cognates is an invaluable supple- ment to Kluge’s Etymological German Dic- tionary, which in its last edition (1910) has emphasized more especially the histort- cal development within the modern High | German literary language. The philological world owes a debt of gratitude to the pub- lisher of the new Falk and Torp for the rapidly progressing realization of his plan of an extensive series of grammatical and lexicographical works, and not least for an admirable new periodical devoted to etymological-archewological research (Worter and Sachen, 1909 —) From time to time there appear books undertaking to trace all religious ideas to some point in the remote past. Some of these works (like those of Winckler and Jensen carrying back all myths to Babylonia) have the semblance if not the reality of scientific method; others have not even the semblance of such a method. In the latter class must be placed Dr. Albert Churchward’'s “Signs and Symbols of Primordial Man, being an/| explanation of the evolution of religious doctrines from the eschatology of the an- client Egyptians” (Dutton). The author's main interest appears to be in the history of masonry, signs of which he finds in Cen- tral America, Assyria, and elsewhere, all going back to Egypt—a genealogy by no means necessary in order to establish the worth of this venerable institution. From | Exypt he derives the word “totem,” suppos- ed by most scholars to be of North Ameri can origin; “American,” however, for Dr. Churchward, would be ultimately “Egyp- tian.” The oldest speech of man he holds to be that of the African pygmies, and it, he says, is identical with old-Egyptian; he gives a list of words to prove this identity. From Egypt, according to his scheme, came the code of Hammurabi; Moses was a priest of the Solar Eschatology of the Egyptians and knew that this was brought on from the Stellar; and the Jewish religion is founded on the Mysteries of the double hor izon of Ra Harmachis—the Hebrew Penta teuch is based on an Egyptian collection of four books (probably the present arrange ment in five books came about in the pro cess of translation § into Hebrew); the Brahmanic, Buddhist, and Persian religions are of Egyptian origin; the Great Pyramid, having been built In the period of the Stel lar Myths, must be more than 15,000 years old. With such material as this the author fille over four hundred pages. One section of his book that might be of value is his account of the pygmies, in which he gives measurements of individual men and wo- men; but from these prosaic details he passes quickly to an tmaginative descrip t'on of their “spirit-houses” and their cult < an Supreme Being
The Nation [Vol. 92, No. 2387 | The Rev. Dr. William Walker, whose|stem,” and that “we are still waiting ‘death is announced from England, at the!|for the master mind who shall fathom |age of ninety-four, wrote a notable life of| the forces which work so silently.” He the Rev. John Skinner, the author of “Tul- has also expressed clearly and well that lochgorum.” remarkable botanical hypothesis—ap- Prof. Henry Mitchell Whitney, one of four parently as plausible as poetic—that our brothers who had attained distinction as dearly-loved arbutus is a cousin (if scholars and educators, died suddenly on P not a nearer relative) of the very sim- Saturday at New Haven, Conn. He was born mee 3 h 'sixty-eight years ago in Northampton, Mass., r Japanese plant; that they had a common ancestor in the northern parts | and served in the civil war, being sergeant- major of the Fijfty-second Massachusetts|Of Asia and America, and that they Volunteers in 1862-3. In 1864 he graduated| were separated, during the glacial pe- from Yale, and four years later from the/riod, by the great ice-cap which forced Andover Theological Seminary. He wrote|one branch of the ancestral plant down in collaboration: “Columbian History of through Eastern Asia and the other Education in Wisconsin,” “History of the through Eastern North America, Fifty-second Massachusetts Regiment,” and whence, having become somewhat va- |“Twentieth Century New Testament.” aiae je the parent steck by didier- ben Rev. nee mpgs Bag ns gi ent surroundings, the plants are now ee eee n language @n@) moving slowly northward again, appar- literature at Amherst College, and the au- re “a ently with no fear of the “yellow peril |thor of numerous Latin works, died at his |home in Amherst, Mass., on Saturday, at the in the heart of the American flower. ‘age of eighty. He retired in 1908 on a Car- It is a little surprising that so good negie pension, after a service of fifty years.|}an observer as Mr. Schmucker should From 1880 to 1894 he served as dean of Am-/say, in discussing the blackbird’s pecu- jherst. More than twenty years ago he lost| jiarity of walking, that “most of our | the sight of both eyes, but continued his | common birds that fly well, walk indif- | work as professor. Dr. Crowell was ®\ferently, and are apt to hop along the | Sraduate of Amherst in 1853, and in 1859 was | ground lifting both feet at once,” inas- licensed as a Congregational preacher. He} nuch on Sin. etek. te red-winged began teaching at Williston Seminary, East- | blackbird the anime the starting | hampton, Mass., in 1853, and soon after join- | ‘ed the Amherst faculty. He was editor of|(mow virtually Americanized), the a large number of Latin text-books, and|meadow-lark, the oven-bird, the water- became known as one of the leading men in|thrush, and the Louisiana water- his branch in the country. thrush (not to mention the herons), all ae = = == | of them good fliers, are also good walk- . ‘ers; while perhaps our best-known bird, | Science ‘the robin, a strong and skilful flier, | neither walks nor hops, but runs. We must take issue, also, with the author with Nature. By Samuel Christian | “2€" he characterises the woodchuck as Schmucker. With illustrations by | °‘UP!4"; he is far from that, as is prov- Katherine Elizabeth Schmucker, Phil- jell Pragfin -ipdh ne po hg cee ge genes ~ D Spee oe eed PA all sides and at short range by his ; /mortal enemy, man; and it may fairly |Birds of the Loch and Mountain. BY | be doubted also whether squirrels ac- Seton P. Gordon. New York: Cassell | tuatty make very effective use of their | & Co. ‘bushy tails in guiding their leaps from The style of Mr. Schmucker’s book is | tree to tree. usually direct and not without a certain | On the other hand, there are accurate literary grace, while his descriptions | observation and correct deduction in the generally are lucid and sometimes real-/account of that wonderful little crea- ly graphic. The slight flaws in his lit-\ture, the humming-bird; and many oth- erary technique are, indeed, easily for-|er subjects (taken up with a charming igiven in the evidence that he is not | disregard for the relation of one to an- only a sincere lover of nature, but/ other, excepting a purely seasonal one), an accurate and thoughtful observer.|such as the development of the “June- He seems to appreciate, too, the differ- | bug,” the growth and nature of the ence between the merely curious and (strawberry, and the “run of the shad,” \the significant. For example, the de-| receive intelligent and readable discus- scription of the mole is a capital bit of | sion. natural history writing in a popular) ‘he illustrations should not get off vein, Again, in his second chapter, The gcot-free. The frontispiece is an incor- Great Spring Rush, Mr. Schmucker dis-| rectly colored picture of a meadow lark cusses in a manner which is bound to/), quite impossible surroundings, and hold the attention that most interest- the full-page drawings are almost equal- ing natural process, the flow of the ly at fault, especially those of the black- sap; the limitations of our knowledge |pird, the Baltimore oriole, the wood pe- prompt him to say that “not any, nor all “wee (which is wholly unrecognizable), of these [theories] put together, seem and the kingfisher. Unfavorable impres- enough to account for this work of sions are greatly lessened, however, by bearing the life-giving stream up the'the graceful marginal illustrations—
|
Under the Open Sky: Being a Year)
Page 23
March 30, igi1} The Nation ' " jack-in-the-pulpit, the skunk-cabbage, ap-| in principle as the little, but very comfort- ple blossoms, white clover, etc. Mr. Gordon's “Birds of the Loch and Mountain” is a well-written book about the birds of a part of Scotland. It in-| cludes the golden eagle, red grouse, cap- | light they are almost impossible to decipher ; ercailzie, ptarmigan, woodcock, goosan- | | able device of the Vatican Palace for the study of the pictures by Michael Angelo on the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel. The rubricated constellation names seem to us a mistake, because in yellowish artificial been much a tissue interleaf would have der, golden plover, curlew, sandpiper, | better, with no names whatever on the redshank, oyster catcher, common tern, | charts proper. common and black-headed gulls, water | Edward W. Branigan, professor of clini- ousel, bullfinch, meadow pipit, willow |cal dentistry, and acting dean of Tufts Col- warbler, and peregrine falcon. The text | lege Dental School, died a week ago at the shows that the author is a careful and | Charlesgate Hospital in Boston, aged fifty- sympathetic observer: it contains much | three. Last year he was president of the first-rate ornithclogy which will inter- est the student of bird-life, even though he has no personal knowledge of the! birds described. ptarmigan is especially interesting be- cause of the opportunity it gives for comparing that bird’s habits and appear- ance with those of its American ana- logues, of which there appear to be four distinct species. parently is as prompt and as prudent as The account of the! National Association of Dental Faculties; he was the author of many works on dental subjects. Dr. Edward F. Ashley, the bacteriological |expert on the quarantine staff of Dr. Alvah of New hospital H. Doty, health officer of the port York, died last week in the on | Swinburne Island, of malignant spinal men- the American about changing its clothes | | practised several years in the City Hospital (from ground colors in the summer months to nearly pure white when its mountain haunts are snow-clad); some of these costumes Mr. Gordon shows poy skilful photographs. Evidently, how- ever, he has not succeeded in catching |: | : | ingitis, |course of his work against that disease. Dr The Scotch bird ap- | which he had contracted in the Ashley was thirty-five ot age He was a graduate of Yale, and of the College: of Physicians and Surgeons of this city, and years He thought that there was a greater future in bacteriology than in any other branch of his profession, and did not take up gen- |eral practice. the bird in its white plumage, as J. Al. | den Loring contrived to do in Alaska in | 1901, when he procured a picture of a white ptarmigan on bare ground, which reveals in a striking manner the fact that even in such surroundings the bird’s plumage gives it considerable pro- tection by reflecting the ground tints, | and thus partly concealing nearly half of its body. Many of Mr. Gordon's cther photographs (there are ninety-odd) are noteworthy additions to nature photogra- phy, the picture of the bullfinch brood- ing being remarkably lifelike. A Congress of Technology, which will give in the papers to be presented a record of the place and practical achievements of sci- ence in modern life, will be held in the buildings of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology in Boston on April 10 and 11. The sessions will be open to the public. To his fascinating “Astronomy With an Opera Glass,” his delightful “Pleasures of the Telescope,” his by no means dry “Other Worlds,” his untechnical “Moon,” and his captivating “Curiosities of the Sky,” Gar- rett P. Serviss has now added “Round the Year With the Stars’ he sets forth the chief beauties of the heavens as seen with the naked eye. His advice is practical, and the charts are well adapted to the beginner's needs, having plain instructions how to use them to ad- vantage. The patient reader soon finds that less effort is needed in acquiring familiarity with the aspects of the sky than in attain- ing the fundamentals of geology, botany, or other natural sciences. Mr. Serviss mends highly the use of a mirror and study of the asterisms by reflection. Certainly it is an important convenience in studying circumzenith constellations, and is the same com- | Drama The Doctor's Dilemma, Getting Mar- ricd, and The Shewing-up of Blanco Posnet. By Bernard Shaw. New York: Brentano's. $1.50 net. Disraeli’s phrase, “A sophistical rhet- orician intoxicated with the exuberance 'of his own verbosity’’—no more than an insolent gibe when flung at Mr. Glad- stone—acquires the force of a _ scien- tific definition when applied to Bernard | Shaw, the author of this bulky, preten- | tious, and exasperating book. Mr. | Shaw, of course, is much more than a | thought, (Harper), in which | mere rhetorician. He narily clever and highly accomplished man, plentifully endowed with wit and a rare mastery of grotesque humor, and a literary facility which enables him to exhibit his varied acquirements in glit- tering and attractive form, but his in- tellectual powers are made virtually in- operative by his congenital incapacity for or deliberate rejection of logical and the monstrous egotism which leads him to seek notoriety by the means of paradox and audacious misrepresentation. It is a melancholy thing to see such gifts, which might have constituted the full equipment of a great and inspiring satirist, employ ed for ignoble or futile purpose. There is almost always a residuum of fact at the bottom of his most frothy and dis- ingenuous deliverances, and it is this that might make them mischievous if they were more widely circulated. To the Intelligent reader, who goes to them jing an economist. is an extraordi-| for mere entertainment, they will long be a source of rich and comparatively harmless enjoyment. All his characteristic literary vices and shortcomings are illustrated copi ously in this present volume, made up of three plays—which are negligible so far as any actual dramatic value in them is concerned—and sundry prefaces of inordinate length which are suppos ed, presumably, to be entire justifica tions of the conditions, theories, and personages exploited in the dramas. “The Doctor's Dilemma”™—the nature of the dilemma need not be specified here is one long tirade against the medi- cal profession. The supposed indict- ment is fortified by reckless misstate- ment, gross exaggeration, unscrupulous special pleading, suppression of the truth, malicious suggestion, and dog- matic assertion. Occasional instances of maltreatment are quoted as general examples. A quasi-scientific gloss is im parted to fluent nonsense by the use of technical phraseology. In his preface he coolly writes: “I deal with the ject as an economist, a politician, and a citizen, exercising my common cemmon sense being the one quality of which his fallacious illustrations conspicuously devoid. He plain why an economist or a politician should be an infallible judge of medi eal ethics, practice, and ability. Never were methods more unscientific than those which he employs. Unfortunately the adroitness of his whimsical humor often distracts attention from his malpractice. He does not always talk pernicious rubbish. His of sunshine and soap, for instance, as san itary agents, is perfectly sound. But his wise edicts are mere platitudes. Some of his conclusions are indisputa ble, but when he points out the way to reform he shatters his pretence of be He ruins his case by his unjust perversity, dishonesty, and egotism. But his humorous caricatures of different types of physicians and surgeons are delicious, as is his possi bly unintended exposure of the humbug sub sense,” are does not ex own advocacy lof the so-called “artistic temperament” in the person of the fascinating rascal Dubedat. Mr. Shaw knows something about shams. There is much clever tion, too, together with some that is im possible and inhuman, in his “Getting Married,” which proceeds from comedy characteriza to farce and from farce to sheer bur lesque. It is amusing and often bril liant in its insincere way, but nothing need be said about the story, which is absurd and = dramatically With its voluminous preface it ies Mr. Shaw's notions the of matrimony iquity of British laws concerning it. The that daily exacting attention and of worthless embod about the various estate and in subject is one is more and more public fers many opportunities for effective at
Page 24
326 The Nation
[ Vol. 92, No. 2387
- ———— ~ tack. But here again Mr. Shaw ruins the futility of genius when it is not al-| We have already noted the great his case by his violence, his exaggera- tions, his cheap cynicism, and his sub- stantial ignorance. He would reform the institution, apparently, by abolish- ing it altogether, although he admits that folk must endure it for the present. The average married man he describes—in what society he formed his ideas is a mystery—as a monster of selfish and brutal sexual depravity, and compares him with a balloon that has lost the lifting power of gas. Evident- ly he himself has escaped, as yet, that calamity. He admits that his specula- tions on the aspect of domestic life are unsupported by evidence, suspect, seemingly, that may be affected by this co- incidence In pouring contempt upon the motives of marriage he flouts nature well as law. Divorce, he maintains, should be had for the asking, and for any cause rather than that of infidelity. wise necessarily but not their value does as The religious side of marriage naturally excites his fiercest scorn, which be- trays him into confusing the principles of Christianity with dogmas of the early and mediwval churches. In conclusion by way of putting the cap on the pin- nacle of his wisdom—he remarks that the remedy for all the social evils which he has been depicting is perfectly sim- ple, being nothing more nor less than the provision of the means of indepen- dent livelihood for women. This is a ample of his grasp of economic prob lems. Of course, he does not offer any olution of this one, He devotes seventy-five pages to an account of his adventures with the Lord Chamberlain's office in connection with the refusal of a license for the public presentation of his play, “The Shewing- up of Blanco Posnet.”’ Somewhat too much space in the press has been devot- ed already to that incident. On reading this plece a cynic might be tempted to that Mr. Shaw—who has often himself keenly to all the advantages advertisement—deliber- ately inserted certain passages to make suspect shown alive ot the refusal of a license absolutely cer- taln. However this may be, the Brit- ish stage has lost nothing by the sup- pression of this crude specimen of al- ternately coarse and sentimental fron- tler melodrama. The plece belongs to no higher dramatic category. Its inci- dents, ita characters, and its atmosphere are all equally theatrical and untrue. The dialogue, of course, is enlivened oc- casionally by flashes of the author's pe- cullar smartness, which, however, are generally inappropriate to the scene. But no consideration of this kind influ- Mr. Shaw, who rarely permits reason, probability, or fact to interfere with the exercise of his sardonic humor, ences his irresponsible wit, or his faculty for | is that he has is The result bulky volume which distortion. produced a worthless except as a demonstration of | lied with sanity. English Dramatic Companies, 1558-1642. By John Tucker Murray, 2 vols. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $7.50. Fleay’s “History of the Stage, 1559- 1642” may be said to have marked an epoch in the study of the Elizabethan drama, but,-apart from the disadvan- tages that would naturally attach to any work in a field in which so few had labored, the book was often seri- ously marred by the author’s tendency rash speculation. Moreover, Fleay purposely ignored the provincial com- panies. There was accordingly great need of a new history, and with this Mr. Murray has supplied us in an emi- nently satisfactory manner. As éx- plained in the Preface, the work was originally begun a Harvard thesis on the provincial companies, and it is still most notable for the flood of light throws on their history and activity; but the writer was gradually led to embrace the London stage also, and as the final result we have the first volume devoted to the London and the second to the provincial companies. How great the number of the latter was appears for the first time in this work; the interest of Elizabethan Eng- land in the drama seems to have ex- tended to every part of the kingdom. Mr. Murray very wisely does not fol- low Fleay’s plan of discussing stage his- ording to periods. He takes up the individual companies in succession and relates separately the whole his- tory of each, before beginning with an- other. Furthermore, at the end of the history of each company a list of all re- corded court performances and provin- cial visits of the particular company is given. In the first volume, where he traverses the ground covered by Fleay’s he has the advantage of re- viewing the work of his predecessor, and we may add also of a soberer judg- ment, so that he is able to supply cor- almost every page. The notes of this volume are full of such corrections, while certain of Fleay’s more important errors are handled in appendices. Especially notable among the appendices of this nature are those which deal with the history of the Earl of Pembroke’s company, the question of the great actor Alleyn's later connection with the stage (which, contrary to Fleay's supposition, he seems not to) have abandoned until 1604), and the re- lation of the plague to the closing of) the theatres, 1558-1642. The evidence shows clearly that in the period most | in dispute, namely, from about 1608 on, | the theatres were closed when the week- | ly deaths from the plague exceeded for- ty. <A table of deaths for the Apron 1563-1642 (with no breaks between 1605- 1642) is included. to as which it tory ack treatise, rections on
value of this work for the history of the provincial companies. The final ap- pendix, which makes up more than half of the second volume, is a collection of notices drawn from local histories, the publications of the Historical Manu- scripts Commission, and the records themselves, especially the account books, mayors’ court books, and letter- books of the various corporations, the records of Norwich proving particularly fruitful. A great number of compa- nies are unearthed whose existence had not been previously suspected. In this connection it is singular to find the citi- zens of Kendal as late as 1586 still clamoring for the old Corpus Christi (miracie) plays. As far as we have observed, the work is remarkably free from inaccuracies. The new patent, however, granted Prince Henry's players (see I, 208) was not dated (Aprii 30), 1607, but 1606. Mr. Murray is here, no doubt, following the transcript of the Patent Roll printed in the “Shakespeare Society's Papers” (1849), but the original license with correct dating is given in the company licenses, quite recently edited for the Malone Society by E. K. Chambers and W. W. Greg. A few of the fourteen li- censes printed by these scholars are new and contain details of interest for the history of individual companies. Furthermore, Mr, Murray does not seem to have been aware of the important documents relating to the Fortune and Red Bull Theatres printed by Dr. C. W. Wallace in the University of Nebraska Studies (1909). Perhaps, like the li- censes, they were published too late for use in his book. As appears from them, the Red Bull Theatre was already in existence by 1605. Among _ other things, they contain interesting mate- rial regarding a law-suit between the actor Alleyn and a brother of the the- atre-manager Henslowe, and give the only information we possess as to the compensation of the Elizabethan “gath- erer” (that is, the man who took in the money at the door), which, according to Dr. Wallace, was one-eighteenth of the total receipts. In another matter, of very slight importance to be sure, Mr. Murray accepts the current view that Shakespeare and other actors fol- lowed King James in the royal pro- cession on March 15, 1604. Ernest Law, however, in his “Shakespeare as a Groom of the Chamber” (published about the same time as the present work) has shown convincingly that the King’s gift of red cloth on this occa- sion did not necessarily imply any such thing. In conclusion, we recommend heartily this excellent treatise, which, we are sure, will take its place at once as the most trustworthy authority in its fleld.
Hauptmann’s drama, “The Weavers,” is
Page 25
March 30, 1911] The Nation to be republished this season by B. W. Huebsch. Granville Barker has arranged with Mitchell Kennerley for American publica- tion of all his work; the first volume will be “Three Plays,” containing ‘Waste,” “The Marrying of Ann Leete,” and “The Voysey Inheritance.” Matheson Lang and his wife, Hutin Brit- ton, have made arrangements for a pro- longed tour in South Africa. Irene Vanbrugh has been engaged as leading lady of Frank Curzon and Gerald du Maurier for their managerial alliance at Wyndham’s Theatre, London. She will play the leading female character in Had- don Chambers’s new “Passers-by.” now ready for production. This is said to be something entirely different from any of the author's preceding plays. It in four acts, of light texture, and tells a story of modern London life. Mr. Du Maurier has a young man’s character. Miss Van- brugh’s part, on the other hand, is said to be of a different type from any that she has yet played. piece, is At the London Lyceum Theatre on the afternoon of Apri] 4, the eve of the poet's birthday, Elsie Fogerty’s company will give a commemoration matinée performance of Swinburne’s “Atalanta in Calydon” in aid of the funds of the Poetry Society. Miss Fogerty’s original performance in the part of Althea and Muriel Elliot’s music have been highly praised by English critics. The Oxford University Press (Frowde) is engaged in issuing “The Complete Works of William Shakespeare,” three of the pro- posed nine volumes having already appear- ed. The general introduction, written by Swinburne, was evidently chosen for its commercial value rather than for any profit to the reader. With the panegyric of one poet by another poet no one need quarrel; it may, besides, be highly sugges- tive. But in this instance, mixed in with pure lyric outpourings, there are state- ments which pass on old errors of fact and judgment, and an individual bias of the eritic which will perhaps deceive no schol- ar, but is likely to deceive many for whom the edition is planned. For this, we are in- formed in a few pages by Mr. Watts-Dun- ton, is designed to be an open-air Shake- speare. To make the idea seem less fanci- ful, we are let into a secret: It is a singular fact in regard to the king of dramatists that, although his rep- resentations of life were written to be act- ed, the most delightful way of enjoying them is not to see them on the stage— where, too often, the obtrusive personality of the actor blurs or is mingled with Shakespeare’s own vision of the character— nor even to study them in the closet, but to read them in the open air, along the banks of a river—the Avon, say, or the Ouse, or the Upper Thames—or under the waver- ing shadows of English trees, with the mu- sic of the summer birds and the distant bleat of the sheep lending an accompani- ment to the music of the poet’s verse. If an open-air edition is perfect, each page will “pass into the reader’s soul with no more suggestion of printer’s ink than the hymn of skylark overhead.” So the italics, which usually mark the stage-directions, have here been replaced by Roman letters: “the sunlight filtering through the leaves upon the page is apt to dazzle and vex the eyes by accentuating the lack of harmony between perpendicular and oblique lines.” ; performance. For the same reason not a note can be found, either with the text—that of the Oxford edition—or after it. Introductions excepted, among which should be mention- ed preliminary notices of the individual plays by Professor Dowden, there is nothing to distract the song of soul or bird—save the publisher's advertisement of 168 books and 2 bookcases. Despite their perfection, the volumes look as thvugh pleasant to use. Vol. I contains “The Tem- pest,” “The Two Gentlemen of “The Merry Wives of Windsor,” “Measure for Measure”; Vol. II, “The Com- “Much Ado About Noth- Labour's Lost,” “A Midsum- and “The Merchant of “As You Like It”; “The “All's Well that Night,” and “The they would be Verona,’ and edy of Errors,” ing,” mer Night's Dream,” Vol. III, of the Well,” “Twelfth Winter's Tale.” “Love's Venice”; Taming Shrew,” Ends The with velopment of histrionic the lectures de - which New audience four upon first series of illustrations, the the English Brander Matthews is delivering in th« Theatre, It is evident that the public interest in the theatre is deep and widespread. Mr. Mat- thews, of course, can only touch upon the outskirts of his subject in the brief space allotted him. Speaking the miracle and mystery plays and the morali- ties which grew out of he briefly demonstrated their ecclesiastical and traced the of which ‘not know much—by which they gradually became secularized. His explanation was as it could be made in the cir- icumstances, and fortified by several apt illustrations, but was necessarily }mentary in character. received with eager attention by the audi- ;ence, in which the student element was con- spicuous. The acted examples were “Noah's Flood,” one of the Chester series of mys- {teries, with a few interpolations from an- other source, and “Nice Wanton,”’ a moral- jity of about the middle of the sixteenth of drama attracted an enormous to on ancient them, origins process we do clear as was ele- Nevertheless, it was century. The first was acted in a two- storied wheeled ark, which was dragged upon the scene, the market place of old Windsor, by the performers. The stage and its appurtenances were sufficiently accurate, and in many respects the conditions of the time were reproduced faithfully, but it was | possible to question some features of the For the hair, and beard of the actor who played Dominus were gilded. The effect ingenious and striking, but it is doubtful an expedient would be within the resources of the poorer strollers. The whole equip- ment of the actors, indeed, seemed too new and prosperous. Anothef point to be raised lies in the disparity between the players themselves, the artistic dignity and the elocutionary power and skill displayed by the Dominus and the Noah, and the frankly bucolic extravagances indulged in by Noah’s wife and other comic characters. The fact is that we do not and cannot know just how these pieces were presented. For “Nice Wanton” the actors built their stage upon trestles. The piece is of small account, but the performance was excellent and carried more of illusion than might have been ex- This was because the individual players more in earnest. On the whole, the New Theatre is to be congratu- lated of its instance face, was whether such pected, were the success upon experiment. fadea (J ~) Music “ARIANE AND BLUE BEARD.” Either the attitude of the public has changed, or that astute Maurice Grau was wrong in holding that it does not pay to produce new operas in New York or in the other cities of this country. Andreas Dippel has found in Chicago and Philadelphia a strong desire for operatic novelties, and within the last few weeks he has also given New Yor ers a chance to hear two new scores Victor Herbert's “Natoma” and Wolf- Ferrari's “Le Secret de Suzanne”’—both o° which were favorably received. Next Yuesday he will produce still another work never heard here, Jean Nougues’s “Quo Sienkiewicz's fa- mous novel; and this, it is promised, is to be tacle witnessed opera house. Mr. Gatti-Casazza, his part, has staged Puccini's “Girl the Golden West” and Humperdinck’s “Konigskinder,” each of which will have had nearly, if not quite, a dozen repre- sentations by the end of the season—a once before, when Vadis,” based on the most elaborate operatic spec ever in a New York on of record exceeded only Emma Calvé first came over to act and sing “Carmen,” times in one “stagione.” To the works of Puccini and Humper- dinck the manager of the Metropolitan has now added Paul Dukas’s “Ariane et ' Barbe-Bleue.” This, however, though new to America, is like the leneras just referred to, an absolute nov elty, having been produced fn Paris, at the Opéra-Comique on May 10, 1907. The ‘prima donna, on that occasion, was Mme. Leblanc, the wife of Maeterlinck, of whose play this opera is a setting; she did not, according to common port, make the of her opportuni ties; but the scenic attire was beautiful and the play and music appealed to the ‘thousands of admirers of Maeterlinck’s mystic conceptions, wherefore the opera It was also which she sang fourteen not, two re most was pronounced a success produced in Brussels and in Vienna. The story of Blue Beard has been repeated ly set to music by Grétry (in his “Raoul’), Offenbach, who burlesqued the story, and several In Maeter- linck’s play, Blue Beard is not the mon- ster of the original French legend, who murdered five wives in succession for the reason that, in his absence, they had used the golden key to open the for- bidden chamber of horrors, while the seventh wife was saved at the critical moment by her brothers, who slay Blue Beard. In the latest Parisian version, Blue Beard gives each of his five cessive wives seven keys, golden, the others silver, with permission to use ‘only the silver keys. They all disobey, ;sooner or later, and disappear mysteri- ‘ously. Rumors of murder are current j}among the peasants, whose voices, when ithe curtain parts, are heard warning others Buc- one
Page 26
328 The Nation [Vol. 92, No. 2387 Ariane, the sixth bride, just arriving in| and fantastic to be effective as a play, a carriage, not to enter the dangerous|but for a musica] setting it is admira- castle. What the audience beholds is| bly adapted, and it may be said at once a scene in the interior of the castle, a|/that Paul Dukas has made good use of large hall, semi-circular in form, with|his opportunities. Reports had come three small doors with silver locks on|from Paris that he had outdone De- each side. Ariane, with her nurse, en-|bussy; but that is not so. There are, ters the hall; she has in her hand the! it is true, a number of places where the seven keys; the one of gold alone inter- harmonic—or rather dissonantal—pro- ests her; the others she throws away.|gressions that are now the fashion in The nurse picks them up, and unlocks! Paris are used, but there is quite as the first door—whereupon a cascade of| much of Wagner in this score, and the amethysts falls upon the floor—rings,!| best things in it are Dukas’s own. He bracelets, diadems, and other ornaments. | had previously shown in his orchestral The same results follow the unlocking | scherzo, “The Sorcerer's Apprentice” of the other doors, except that the jew- | (which has become a favorite in our els are different—sapphires next, follow-| concert halls) that he is a composer ed by pearls, emeralds, rubies, diamonds. | with a personality; and this impression Though dazzled by all this splendor, | is strengthened by his opera. Ariane continues to search for the gold- What distinguishes it most favorably en lock; at last she finds it, inserts her | from “Pelléas et Melisande” is that it key, and, when the door opens, a stifled | contains real melodies and dynamic con- distant chant comes up from the depths |trasts. Some of the leading themes are the chant of the five imprisoned wives. | so individual that they impress them- At this moment Blue Beard enters and | selves on the memory at once and be- tries to drag Ariane away. The cries 0f|¢ome more effective with each succes- the nurse attract the peasants; she|sive hearing. One wishes that more of draws the bolts and they come tumbling | this melody were assigned to the sing- in. Blue Beard draws his sword, but/erg; but in confiding it chiefly to the Ariane sends the peasants away with the | orchestra Dukas was simply following words: “What do you want? He has not |the example of other composers of the harmed me.” |period. It is a fashion which must The scene of the second act is one of|have its day; some future Bizet will the dark underground halls dear to|end it. Ariane’s diamond air is the Maeterlinck. Ariane and the nurse de-| nearest approach to the set numbers of scend, lamps in hand. They come across | opera as it used to be; for the rest, the the discarded wives, huddled together.| vocal parts are a sort of intervallic Ariane embraces them, and urges them | declamation or recitative, less monoton- to follow her out of the dungeon to the jous than Debussy’s, yet seldom expand- sunlight and flowers above. A pale/jing to sustained melody. The advan- green light serves as guide; it comes|tage of this method of writing for the through a glass skylight which the five | voice is that it enables the singer to wives think keeps out the sea water; |enunciate distinctly; it enforces the but Ariane takes a stone, and smashes | principle, first followed by Peri and the glass, whereupon they emerge joy- | restated by Gluck and Wagner, that ously into the garden bordering on the/“the play's the thing.” Its disadvan- sea. In the last act we see the rescued /tages are partly overcome by the or- wives in the semi-circular hail, where|chestra, which in “Ariane” nearly al- ress as she is a singer, else it would have been foolish for her to essay the part of Ariane. At the dress rehearsal, on which these comments are based, she fascinated the invited audience, win- ning much applause for her skill in as- similating a style of music to which she had heretofore been unaccustomed. She shared the honors with Mr. Toscanini, who demonstrated on this occasion that he can interpret a Parisian opera of the hour as sympathetically as the Wagner, Verdi, and Puccini operas that have made him famous. After nearly forty years of secret exist- ence, the autobiography of Richard Wagner is to be published this year by Dodd, Mead & Co. In one striking incident he relates how he was summoned from school to the bedside of his dying father, for whom he was asked to play. He did so, and the fa- ther whispered, “I wonder whether he will ever develop a talent for music.” Art Répertoire de Reliefs Grecs et Ro- mains. Tome Premier, “Les Ensem- bles.” By Salomon Reinach: Paris: Ernest Leroux, In bringing out this volume of repro- ductions of Greek and Roman reliefs M. Reinach has again earned the grati- tude of students of ancient art. Every archeologist is familiar through con- stant use with Reinach’s “Répertoire de la statuaire grecque et romaine” (3 vol- umes), and his “Répertoire des vases grecs et étrusques” (2 volumes). A work of a similar nature on Greek and Roman reliefs has been looked forward to since the promise of its publication eleven years ago. Its appearance there- fore is welcome news, though this is only the first of the two volumes ex- pected, and there seems to be no imme- the jewels are still sparkling on the| ways has something to say. There are | diate prospect for the publication of the floor Encouraged and instructed by|gseveral superb and genuinely dramatic Ariane, they adorn themselves so as to| (not merely operatic) climaxes; six of | second. The present book is entitled “Les En- show off each one’s peculiar beauty to|them in quick succession after the doors | sembles,” that is, it contains reliefs with best advantage. The nurse creates alarm /are opened that had hidden the jewels | groups of figures which either formed by announcing that Blue Beard is re-|—each orchestral outburst being differ- part of the decorations of ancient build- turning. But the peasants, armed, are|ently colored, like the jewels them-| ings, such as metopes, friezes, and pedi- watching for him; there is a fight; they selves; but the grandest of them occur| ments, or ornamented smaller objects, bring him in, bound, and place him on| where they are most needed—at the the sofa. Ariane bids them go back to) close of the different acts. The exultant the village and dress their wounds. | strains heard when the liberated women When she turns her head she sees the | gambol in the flower garden are among | such as metal vases. It is not the au- 'thor’s intention to reproduce all known reliefs of this nature; but a selection of the more important works is given, ar- five wives on their knees gazing on Blue the most exhilarating things in modern | ranged in chronological order according Beard with adoring miens. She cuts opera. Of musical “atmosphere” there the ropes that tle him; she bids him jg an abundance throughout the opera, good-by, and asks the wives to follow the most striking instance being the her: but they refuse to leave him. His gubdued moaning chorus of the impris- own eyes are fixed on her retreating oned women in the first act after) lerto could only be studied in bulky, ex- form Ariane has used her golden key. It has been surmised that Maeterlinck, “Ariane” is almost as much of a} noting how much more effective his “prima donna” opera as “Lucia,” though | Pelléas et Melisande” ig with Debussy’s in a different way. On Geraldine Far- | ‘to the places in which they were found. Thus, the sculptures from Delphi, from Ephesos, Assos, Phigalia, Trysa, etc., as |well as the reliefs from the various arches and columns of Rome, which hith- pensive editions, often difficult to ob- tain, are here faithfully reproduced side by side. As M. Reinach proudly says music than without it, deliberately rar rests the chief burden of the opera/in his preface, the works published in wrote his “Ariane et Barbe Bleue” as a so far as the stage is concerned. She!|this volume could before only be found libretto. It certainly seems too slight is, fortunately, as accomplished an act- | scattered in seventy-three publications, GS RE A OO IIOD OLE LIE. GE NIE Pa PR ree oars ye
Page 27
DE oy cate woddrwien Leen March 30, 1911] The Nation 329 costing about $600. Of course, the re- productions in M. Reinach’s book do not pretend in any way to have artistic merit. They are mere records in black and white of the compositions of the groups, without any indication of detail- ed work, but for reference they will be invaluable. The text which accompanies them is reduced to a minimum; there is no attempt at general descriptions or artistic appreciations, but the essential parts of the history are stated in a clear and concise manner, and references to the chief publications are duly given. Altogether, the author deserves the highest praise for bringing before us this valuable material, particularly as it | was a work which, while it required in- finite patience and exactitude, was un- relieved by the stimulus of original re- search or the building up of theories, so dear to the hearts of most archeologists. “A, B, C of Old English China” was an- nounced by George W. Jacobs & Co., and not, as we stated, by John Lane Co. Hutchinson & Co. include in their spring list “John Opie and his Circle,” by Ada Earland, author of ‘“‘Ruskin and his Circle.” An appendix will contain a list of Opie’s pictures. The German archeologist and assistant director of the Royal Museum at Berlin, Prof. Otto Puchstein, died recently at the age of fifty-four. He made a careful study of the sculptures at Pergamon, and pub- lished several works. He wrote: “Reisen in Kleinasien und Nordsyrien,” with Hu- mann; “Pseudohethitische Kunst,” “Be- schreibung der Skulpturen aus Pergamon,” | and “Die griechische Biihne.” Henry A. Ferguson, the landscape artist, died last week at his home in New York city. He was born in Glens Falls, N. Y., about sixty years ago, and was educated at Trinity College. When he left college he travelled extensively, and set up his easel in Egypt, Italy, Mexico, and South America. In recent years Mr. Ferguson had devoted a great deal of his time to the restoration of paintings, a work in which he achieved great success. He was an associate mem- ber of the National Academy of Design. Finance —_—. TRYING TO READ THE FUTURE. On Friday of last week, total transac- tions on the New York Stock Exchange fell to the smallest aggregate of any full business day since July, 1908, when the after-panic inertia seemed to reached its climax. On Monday of this present week transactions touched a y * : 7 ae ] | that the outside investing public, tak- en as a whole, is neither buying nor selling stocks; that foreign markets are not dealing actively in our shares; that the large banking houses are taking no /ageressive attitude, and that therefore even the professional speculators on the floor of the Exchange are unable to dis- cover any continuing tendency. Even as regards prices, it is possible to say that, at this week's opening, the half- dozen most active stocks hardly varied jhalf a point apiece from their prices of |March 1. At such times the question | follows, What does this complete finan- cial hesitation mean? | At the moment, it is probably true that the business community is divided between two main opinions—one, that American industry, having finished the work of drastic readjustment, is await- ing the signal for another forward move- ment; the other, that it is pausing on the brink of renewed and even more general reaction. The basis for the first opinion is the country’s unvarying ex- perience with the severe industrial set- jbacks of the past ten years. The basis for the second is the experience of oth- er generations. Seasons of trade de- |pression such as 1904 and 1908 were |largely completed in the compass of a year, and the halt after twelve months’ liquidation we now know to have sig- nified, not the inertia of exhaustion, but |the massing of tangible resources in ad- |vance of another “boom.” But seasons ‘of depression such as followed 1876 or |1890, for example, were the affair of | years; they embodied not only radical ‘and permanent revision of staple prices, of wages, and of cost of living, but thor- ough change in methods of doing busi- | ness. Now it is true, the teaching of all history is that the kind of prosperity |that is marked by violent speculation and by intense industrial activity, goes by long upward and downward swings which cover a stretch of years. When the sensational chapter of 1869 and 1870 had been closed, no other chapter like it was opened in this country until 1899 and 1901. Furthermore, it may be ad- mitted without the slightest hesitation that the general trend, from that point of view, has been downward ever since 1901. Such a receding movement is never continuous and unbroken; each relapse is followed, just as it was before, have | by another upward surge. But the boom lof 1906 was a very much smaller thing than that of five years before, and it is still smaller figure; the day’s whole bus-| not at all improbable that the next for- iness being 150,000 shares, as compared with one day, almost exactly a month ago, when nearly a _ million shares changed hands, and with a daily aver- | ward movement, even if more substan- tial than the illusory boom of 1909, will | . be still less spectacular than 190€. But that is not the same thing as saying age of upwards of half a million only | that the country is in the sweep of a a few weeks ago. Under such circum-!movement of prolonged depression. On stances, “dulness’’ has itself become the|the contrary, it is possible to argue that principal topic of conversation in the! progress on conservative and Wall Street offices. It is plain enough stable lines, even if the speculators and pro moters find their energies shackled by | circumstances, is in the long run an in finitely more wholesome condition than the crazy delirium of a decade ago. As for the notion of an impending plunge into a gulf of black depression there is one simple fact to which peo ple may as well pin their faith. This is the same United States as that of a de ade ago—stronger because of its in crease in population, its development of ‘resources, its expansion of facilities, its recent study of economics in production, and, not !east of all, because of its grad ual escape from a false and mischiev ous system of industrial exploitation of which the fundamental ideas were the wasting of natural resources and the perfectly unscrupulous dissipation of capital. Most other nations, after passing through such an experience and learn ing its necessary consequences, would have found that the horse was gone some time before the owner had got to the stable door, and some of them would have proceeded to burn the stable down But the American people were more for tunate. Having reached a_ thorough comprehension of what had been going on, they have busied themselves with fit ting bolts and bars. It is quite in keep ing with the programme that this pro cedure should have started an outcry that we were putting a quietus on all future booms and were strangling that prosperity which, but for this sudden stupidity of people, law-makers, and courts, might have gone on forever on the scale of 1901. The probability ts, however, that the nation itself has |reached the conclusion that it has had quite enough of that brand of prosper ity to last for a generation. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Aix. Thieves. Duffield. $1.30 net Albee, H. R. The Gleam. Holt. $1.35 net Albert, A. E Alice Rayden, or Weighed tn the Balance Broadway Pub. Co. $1.25 Auerbach, B The Villa on the Rhine Translated by J. Davis Holt. $1.50 net Avebury, Lord. The Origin of Civilisation and the Primitive Condition of Man. (Re issue with a new Preface.) Longmans Bancroft, H Inheritance Taxes for Inves tors. Boston: Boston News Bureau Co. $1 Behm, J. P The Subjunctive in Latin Syracuse CC. W. Bardeen Borup, G. A Tenderfoot with Peary. Stokes $2.10 net Brennan, | Mountain State Gleanings Boston Badger $1.25 net Brown, F. W Dan McLean's Adventures Baker & Taylor, $1.25 Browning's Men and Women, 1855 Edited by G. FE. Hadow Frowd: Bury, J. B The Imperial Administrative System in the Ninth Century Frowds Catalogue of High School and College Text books Boston Ginn Chappelle, L. L. The Diverging Paths 4 Story of Pioneer Days of M ourl Broadway Pub. Co $1.50 Chaucer D The Simple Life Limited Lane $1.50 Cone, H. G. Soldiers of the Light Boston Badger $l net Connor, H. G., and Cheshire 1B. jr The Constitution of North Carolina Raleigh Edwards & Broughton Printing Co Crawford, F. M Wandering Ghoat Ma millan $! » net
Page 28
3830 The Nation | Vol. 92, No. 2387
Cushman, H. E. A Beginner's History of Hutchinson, H. G. A Saga of the “Sun- Rich, J. W. The Battle of Shiloh. lowa Philosophy. Vol. Il, Modern Philosdphy. beam.” Longmans: City; State Historical Society of Iowa. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.60 net. Innes, M. Schools*of Painting. Edited by Saunders, R. N. The Teacher and the Times. De Vries, Hugo. The Mutation Theory. V6l C. De Kay. Putnam. Syracuse: C. W. Bardeen. Il. Chicago: Open Court Pub. Co. $4 net. Ironside, J. Forged in Strong Fires. Bos- Shantz, H. L. Natural Vegetation. Wash- on, W. H., and Keck Cc Grammar ton: Little, Brown. $1.25 net. ington: Dept. of Agriculture. School Reader Book |. Chicago Scott, Jones, M. C. Achsah, the Sister of Jairus, Skeat, W. W. A Concise Etymological Dic- Foresman Broadway Pub. Co. $1. tionary of the English Language. New Dilemma of the Modern Kinsley, W. W. Man's To-morrow. Bos- and corrected impression. Frowde. Sherman, French ton Sherman, French. $1.20 net. Sophocles’ Antigone. Translated into Eng- Knight, W. A. Outside a City Wall, Bos- lish verse by J. E, Harry. Cincinnati: rs from the Wayside: A ton Pilgrim Press. 50 cents net. Robert Clarke Company. $1 net. joston: Sherman, French. Lamb's Elia Edited for school use by G. Stauber, B. T. Romance of the Universe. W. Benedict. Chicago: Scott, Foresman. Broadway Pub. Co. $1. ngland What It Is and 5 cents. Stewart, A. S. St. Luke’s Garden. Boston: Boston Chamber of Le Queux, W. The Red Room. Boston: Sherman, French. $1 net. Little, Brown. $1.50. Studies in the Synoptic Problem. By Mem- ble Bush Appleton. Litchfield, G. Les Enfants: A Book of bers of the University of Oxford. Edited Verse in French-Canadian Dialect. Bos- by W. Sanday. Frowde. Lord Bellinger An Auto- ton: Badger. $1. Sylva, Carmen. From Memory’s Shrine. Ly DuMield. $1.20 net Lynch, F. The Peace Problem. Revell. 75 Philadelphia: Lippincott. $2.50 net. H The Mother of Parliaments cents net Teall, G. The Contessa’s Sister. Boston: Little, Brown $3.50 net Macaulay's Essay on Clive. Edited, with Houghton Mifflin. $1.20 net &® What Will You Do with notes, by V. A. Smith. Frowde. The Priest: A Tale of Modernism in New is Christ? Boston Pilgrim Press. Marriott, C. Out of Russia. Philadelphia: England. Boston: Sherman, French. ) cents net Lippincott, $1.25 net, $1.25 net. Griffis W > China's Story Boston: Matthay, T. Some Commentaries on the Tucker, W. J. The Function of the Church Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net Teaching of Pianoforte Technique. Long- in Modern Society. Boston: Houghton Groner, A The Man with the Black Cord mans, Mifflin. 50 cents net. Tran by G. I. Colbron. Duffield. $1.20 O’Brien, R. B. John Bright: A Monograph. Underwood, E. W. A Book of Dear Dead net Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $3 net. Women. Boston: Little, Brown. $1.25 net. Hang, Y. Y. The Commercial Code of Japan. Palmer, A. W The Mountain Trail and Its University of Manchester. Department of University of Pa. Law School Series, No Message Boston: Pilgrim Press. 50 Education, 1890-1911. Longmans. I Boston: Boston Book Co cents net Wagner, C. R. Spanish Grammar. Revised Hart. A. B The Obvious Orient. Apple- Parrish, R. Love Under Fire. Chicago: edition. Ann Arbor, Mich.: The Author. ton. $1.50 net McClurg. $1.35 net. Wharton, S. The Wife Decides. Dilling- Henderson, A. Interpreters of Life and the Philippine Islands. Annual Report of the ham. Modern Spirit. Mitchell Kennerley. $1.50 Bureau of Health—1909-10. Manila. Wild, I. net Pryor, Mrs. R. A. The Colonel's Story. Mac- Withers, P, The Garland of Childhood: A Hilscher, 8S. 8 The Eternal Evangel millan. $1.20 net. Little Book for All Lovers of Children. Broadway Pub. Co. $1.50 Resegger’s Der Lex von Gutenhag. Edited, Holt. $1.50 net. Hopkins, U.N. A Winter Romance in Poppy with notes, by B. Q. Morgan, Boston: Wright, W. B. The Heart of the Master. Land Boston Badger. $1.25 net Heath. 40 cents. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net.
' - 4 [ Henry Holt & Co. wits (Just Published) | . THE Mave Rea QUICKSANDS| | NEW NATIONALISM ’ » Bergson’s Pyeng By THEODORE ROOSEVELT Creative Evolution Authorized translation by ARTHUR By Fannie Heaslip Lea 12mo. 268 pages. iy qustage SR emt y MITCHELL, revised by the author. 407 12mo. Illustrated. $1.20 net. Mr. Roosevelt’s declaration pp. S8vo. $2.50 net me of his political faith and of , The late WILLIAM _JAMES, reviewing Oe Brilliant dialogue, a subtle the principles on which it is Pree eet og et na te te | | sense of the comic and the founded. the way of erudition are remarkable, and in the way of expression they are simply phenomenal 1 tragic, a graphic touch in the A book that marks a turn- Open Bergson, and new horizons open on every page you read. It tells of reality itself. Nothing portrayal of an attractive group in oint in American olitical ; in Bergson is shopworn or at second-hand. of people and their environ- hitosy. P W. J. Henderson’s ment, and, in general, a fine Some Forerunners of artistry, characterize this novel, The Baker & Taylor Co., New York which «presents a_ recurring | | — Italian Opera problem—a wife out of love By the musical critic of the ‘‘Sun,”’ author with her husband and deep in of “Richard W er, Hila Life ad DD And “Modern "Musieal" Drift,” ate. A (notable. book love with another. How she ‘JOHN VIRIAMU JONES, on the Mediaeval lyric dramas before Perl an ‘ > Caccin!, Several chapters are devoted to a contrives to save something of and Other Oxford Memories vivid account of Polizeano’s “‘Orfeo."’ and Ite performance. 243 pp. 16mo. $1.25 net. honor and happiness from ship- By EDWARD BAGNALL POULTON, D.Sc., wreck is the theme of this en- Professor of Zodlogy in the University of Household Administration grossing story Oxford. With 5 illustrations. 8vo. $3.00 in the Higher Education pos oacbanil, atin aad hai ?of Women STURGIS & WALTON CO. details ‘of the oubavgueet ane, of the . . 21-223 EB. 27th St.. New York first Principal of the University College a. -— of 7) <s a Erne mae end Carumnine of South Wales and first vice-chancellor 2 a _ of the University of Wales. Some memories 4 NEW UP-TO-DATE EDITION WITH of the Oxford Union in the '70s are given, 1,000 NEW ENTRIES OF The Channel Islands of California with reminiscences of Lord Curzon, H. H. A ith, Lord Mil 3 d oth ‘ Champlin’s Young Folks’ By CHARLES F. HOLDER, F.L.S. B48 7 oe wordgaes. 5 Cyclopaedia of Persons tion “and the plenitude of its pictures" | | LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York —S8an Francisco Argonaut. and Places Profusely Illustrated. Cr. 8Svo, $2.00 net. Profusely (Mustrated. 1,104 pp. $3.00 prepaid A. CC. MeCLURG & CO., CHICAGO NEW ONE.VOLUMB EDITIONS WITH ALL Six Months Subscription Free. FEE ILLUSTRATIONS OF “A REMARKABLE BOOK.” : THE NATION will extend SIX Miss Clara Crawford Perkins’ | china under the Empress Dowager Builders of Spain | With 80 iHlustrations and # map. Large 8vo. | MONTHS the term of any sub- and J. BB. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia scriber who sends a name not al- French Cathedrals A. 8. Clark, Peekskill, N. Y., is a buyer ready on our list with remittance for and Chateaux Each $3.00 net. and seller of books, magazines, and pam- Aer | phlets. the new subscription for one year.
*Poatage on pet books, 8% additional,
Page 29
ih ae