The Nation 1910-12-22: Vol 91 Iss 2373
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
RENCR ay l'2pa0 ARY, UNIV. Ge MACH. te=Nation
VOL. XCL—NO. 2373 THURSDAY, DECEMBER 2 22, 1910 a4 Sat PRICE TEN CENTS
Rodolphe Christen: the Story of an Artist’s Life By his WIFE. Profusely illustrated by Sketches in Color and Black and White, and several Portraits. 8vo. $7.00 net. Born in a remote valley in Switzerland, Monsieur Christen’s determination to become an artist vanquished all obstacles, and carried him triumphantly to success. He was well known as a brilliant and successful teacher of French methods and ideals in art, and spent many years painting pictures and por- traits. As a record of picturesque and romantic travelling, much of it on foot, through Spain, Italy, France, and Switzer- land, the book will appeal strongly to all lovers of the artistic and the unconventional. Clara Novello’s Reminiscences Compiled by aer daughter, CONTESSA VALERIA GIGLIUCCI. With Memoir by ARTHUR DUKE COLE- RIDGE. With 3 plates. 8vo, pp. vi+216. $3.00 net. These Reminiscences compiled from the great singer’s manuscript notes give vivid pictures of her early life, when Charles Lamb and all manner of distinguished literary and musical people were frequent guests at her father’s house. After her marriage with Count Gigliucci she lived in Italy, and there are various interesting side-lights on the stirring “_ han the Risorgimento and the unification of the kingdom of Italy. Recollections of a Scottish Novelist By MRS. L. B. WALFORD, autaor of “Mr. Smith,” “The Baby’s Grandmother,” etc. With 3 Portraits and 3 other Illustrations. 8vo. pp. xii+317. $3.00 net. “The lights and shadows of Scottish life and character sparkle on almost every page in picturesque description or piquant anecdote. The book is alive with genial humour and shrewd — and deserves to be widely read.”—Stand- ard, Seute Years in the Himalaya By MAJOR C. G. BRUCE, M.V.O., Fifth Gurkha Rifles. Fully illustrated. 8vo, $4.20 net. The Himalaya is a world in itself and Major Bruce has journeyed through it mountaineering, in pursuit of big game, or in the performance of his professional duties, for more than twenty years.
The Architects’ Libraryp—NEW VOLUME Edited by F. M. SIMPSON, F.R.I.B.A. Professor of Architec- ture in the University of London. Building Construction. In 2 Volumes.
By BERESFORD PITE, F.R.I.B.A., F. T. BAGGALLAY, F.R.LB.A., H. D. SEARLES-WOOD, F.R.I.B.A., and E. SPRAGUE, Assoc. M.Inst.C.E. Medium 8vo. Vol. 1. With nearly 250 drawings and diagrams. Pp. vili+452. $5.00 net. Brickwork. By Beresford Pite. Stonework. By F. T. Baggallay. CONTENTS (Carpentry. By H. D. Searles-Wood. Construction in Metals. By E. Sprague. Index. “Tne aim of the volumes on Building Construction in the Architects’ Library is, while treating the subject in a practical manner, to give to it also architectural expression. With this object in view most of the chapters have been entrusted to well-known architects. Existing books on Building Construc- tion are in most cases excellent in some respects, but too often fail to place before students the treatment which is necessary if buildings are to be not only sound, but also archi- tecturally satisfactory. Building Construction in itself is merely a skeleton; its effective covering is Architecture.”—Preface, ALREADY PUBLISHED. A History of Architectural Development Vol. I. ANCIENT, EARLY CHRISTIAN, AND BYZANTINE. With 180 Illustrations. 8vo. $4.00 net. Vol. Il. MEDIAZVAL. With 267 Illustrations. 8vo. $6.00 net. Vol. III. RENAISSANCE. [Preparing.] = . The same quality of sympathetic understanding of a still more difficult subject distinguishes Mr. Simpson's work on medi@val architecture. His aim, likewise, is ‘to trace the development of architecture through the planning, construc- tion, materials, and principles of design of the buildings de- scribed,’ with frequent reference to the influences which shaped that development. A valuable and illuminative volume.” —N. Y. Times.
by
Published Longmans, Green, & Co. New York 443 4th Ave.,
Some religious magazines are just that. ferent. | modern zest of progress? its enterprise?
——
tHe UNITARIAN ADVANCE A MONTHLY MAGAZINE OF PROGRESS IN RELIGION GEORGE H. BADGER, Editor YOU have always taken it for granted, no doubt, that a religious magazine must neces- | sarily be heavy, dull and uninteresting—though good! We aim to make the UNITARIAN ADVANCE dif- We believe that Religion can be made the most interesting thing in the world,—if you have the right sort of religion: eager; up-to-date; virile; not a thing of cant, but of reality; not an echo of old-time dogma, but a live-wire of tingling progress. CHIEFLY: are you not interested to have the world progress in reason, justice, truth and freedom: to have religion made human, rational, honest to the core, manfully invigorat- ing, not thinly and softly sentimental, but stalwartly enthusiastic, kindling, and dramatic in Well, that is what Tae UNITARIAN ADVANCE is concerned with. Why not have a part in | One Dollar a year; three months for 25c. THE UNITARIAN ADVANCE 104 East Twentieth Street New York
Bare tw. < to—-
Page 2
The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. (Batered ot the Now York Oity Post Office as second-class mail matter.) The Nation ts published and owned by the New | York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor. Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Canada 43.50, and to foreign countrice comprised im the Postal Union £4.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE W®PDEK EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Our Office-Holding System What the English Election Settled.... Mr. Carnegie’s Greatest Gift In College and After A Revolution in Greek New York's Need of an Art Gallery... 600 SPECIAL ARTICLES: News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE: A Source of “The Raven” The Quest of the Ultimate Railway Rates and Credit The Tariff Board's Report Was Samuel Daniel an Italian?...... 603 Wool and Sheep - LITERATURI The Campaign of Chancellorsville: strates and Tactical Study Just Folks The Vicar of the Marches - The Old Flute-Player . The Purchase Price rhe Bluse Arch edward and I and Mrs. Honeybun. Gireat American Universities Intimat Society Letters Mighteenth Century se Chandler Moulton 616 ** *Coplee of The Nation may be procured in Paris at Eirenteno’s, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in Loodon of BR. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross . The Nation [Vol. 91, No. 2373 Educational AE on TEACHERS’ Vv ° pA 4X & Cov.. Proprietors. if y fren i Pa. Ave., Washington rea ew York {i Bougiesht 2. Portiand $03 ich. Ave., C d., LosAngeles 406 Cooper Bid., Dente hn a Berkeley Send to any “address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ wi, compe Send for Bulletin No. HARLAN P. FRENCH, ai Chapel St. casione Just Published MATHER & HEWITT’S XENO- PHON—ANABASIS BOOKS I-IV. PRICE, $1.50. Edited by Maurice W. Mather, Pb.D., Formerly Instructor in Harvard Uni- versity, and J. W. Hewitt, Pb.D., As- sociate Professor of Latin and Greek, Wesleyan University. Prepared by editors experienced in sec- ondary work, with notes expressed in simple terms, and giving much translation of dimi- cult passages. Grammatical constructions are carefully explained, the vocabulary giver the special meanings, the introduction le clear and helpful, and the illustrations are numerous and worthy. AMERICAN ——. COMPANY New York Chicago Just Published LIVE ISSUES IN CLASSICAL STUDY By Karl Pomeroy Harrington, Pro- fessor of the Latin Language and tera- ture in Wesleyan University, Middletown, Conn. 75 cents. Four essays for students and teachers con- cerning the real value and place of the classics in school and college curricula. There is included an intelligent criticism of the present methods in teaching Greek and Latin, with suggestions for improvement. GINN & COMPANY, 29 Beacon St.. Boston Introduction to Economics By ALVIN S&S. JOHNSON, Professor in the University of Texas. ‘An Uluminating presentation, in brief and com- pact form, of the leading results of modern eco- University. Cloth. 416 pages. $1.50. D. C. HEATH & CO., Pablishers, nomic analysis.""—Prof. T. N. Carver, Harvard | seg schools and everywhere. r List prices, “ae ~ By se, ‘per vol BOSTON, NEW YORK, CHICAGO. | MAYER & MULLER, Booksellers 2 Pring Louls Ferdinandstrasse, Berlin (Germany). Direct eueply, at best terms, of GERMAN NEW | AND SECOND-HAND BOOKS, PAMPHLETS, and | PERIODICALS tn any department of Learning and Literature. Cheapest opportunity for Libraries, | | | | al Publishers New York Ask your bookseller for The Hygiene | of the Soul By GUSTAV POLLAK An Important Work on a nee Interesting Subject ““In these days of ‘mental | healing,’ it is good service to | offer in so attractive a form the | wisdom of a healthy mind.’’— The Nation. DODD, MEAD & COMPANY THE TEMPLE CLASSICS 233 VOLUMES General Borror: Israsi. Goutanwoz, M.A. Each volume contains a photograyure frontispiece, a decorative ti and «a ribbon bookmark; where advisa editorial appendices and marginia, also. PRICES: Im cloth, each volume 45 cts. Net In limp leather each volume 66 cts. Net E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORE. GROVER CLEVELAND'S last and favorite etched portrait, two-thirds life size. Autographed by the ex-President. Also a series of artistic and most au- thentic etchings of famous Americans, any of which can now be procured for a most suitable and refined gift for the Holidays, by addressing JACQUES REICH, | Studio 105 W. 40th St., New York. Handy Volume Classics j | | | | | | | Professors, and Students. Catalogues on applica- | tion Best references. Read L. M. Montgomery's New Book KILMENY OF THE ORCHARD By the author of “ANNE of GREEN GABLES” (23d Printing) anc “ANNE OF AVONLEA” = (12th Printing) ls., 85c. rot ang p leather, 7 Sa o “SEED FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y.Crowell&Co., New York The Channel Islands 0 of f California By CHARLES F. BI for the wealth -¥ its (i ty a tion and the ——- of i —S8an Peanehes Argonaut. Profusely illustrated. Or. 8vo, $2.00 net. A. C. MeCLURG & CO., CHICAGO DIGRESSIONS OF V By ELIHU VEDDER The autobiography of tae year. Profusely illustrated by the author. THE INTEREST OF AMERICA IN INTERNATIONAL CONDITIONS ADMIRAL A. T. MAHAN’S new book. $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.60. LITTLE, BROWN & COMPANY, Publishers, BOSTON CHOENHOF BOOKCO BRITISH ‘Nostox Mase AUTHORS E93 sine fr cits TAUGHNITZ STENOGRAPHER GEO B. COCK 3 1. coargis arak, Bata, une “a8 FRANKLIN BANK BUILDING. PHILADELPHIA WANTED—Numbers and vols. of The Vation later than vol. 70. A. S&S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS WHY WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! By GEORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth, $1 net each. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia, BOOK S—Al! out of print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me, stati books wanted: I can get you any book ever pu ~2 when in England, call and ip 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GRBAT BoOKSHOP, Joba Bright St., Birmingham, England
Page 3
The Nat NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 22, 1910. The Week For a subject that was pronounced “dead” a year ago, tariff revision is proving itself a particularly lively corpse. Both houses of Congress are giving up hours to its discussion. It is evident that the Western Republicans mean business; they are just as hot against dishonest tariff taxes now as they were during the campaign. An agi- tation of that kind, once started, gets rebellious ideas into the heads of the people, and will not dic down. Even Senator Aldrich now perceives that the popular wrath against his handiwork cannot be laid by smooth words, and is prepared to concede something to it. A great light has also dawned upon Sena- tor Lodge, and he—helped on, of course, by the angry Massachusetts sentiment which makes his reélection doubtful—is also found among the tariff-revision prophets. Little can be expected of the short session, naturally, yet there seems a chance that a bill may pass making the Tariff Board permanent and enlarg- ing its powers. Postmaster-General Hitchcock is just- | ly proud, in his annual report, of his reduction of the deficit of his depart- ment by $11,500,000. In his natural de- sire to wipe out the remaining deficit, he recommends the plan of making the magazines pay a higher rate for their advertising pages. Whatever the merits of this proposition, there is room for effecting great savings in other ways, by introducing business-like methods and getting the maximum work out of his employees. He has already proposed placing the low-grade postmasters un- der the civil-service rules. If he and Mr. Taft, without further ado, weed out a few hundred inefficient postmasters who hold office solely for political rea- sons, that alone will almost wipe out the deficit, provided that the postmas- ters are succeeded by energetic, enter- prising business men. All newspaper publishers know how untrustworthy the present postal service is. Those in New York are doing a lot of the work of the ' best way to improve its revenues would be to make it trustworthy and efficient. the House Committee on Invalid Pensions has fa- vorably reported a bill to add nearly fifty millions of dollars to the existing pension roll. The pension of a veteran Incredible as it seems, of sixty-two is by it increased from $12 to $15 a month. A veteran of seventy will receive from $50 to $75 a month ad- ditional, $20 to $36 a month. grade, between sixty-five and seventy, and one of seventy-five from An intermediate will come in for an increase of $20 a It is represented that in the first year the increase will “only be twenty-five millions,” but the fact re- mains that within two years the extra pay will be fifty millions. What becomes of the proposed government savings? The debt to the old soldiers, which every one acknowledges, has been met more generously than any similar one {in the history of the world. In addi- ‘tion, cowards, shirkers, and camp fol- lowers have profited by Treasury gifts until the privileged class of veterans |has become as dulled to what is just ‘and proper as have the protected man- ufacturers. —= The significance of the New York State election, especially in the light of 'a defeat to Mr. Roosevelt, is emphasiz- led by the official figures now publish- ed. We refer to the comparison be ‘tween the plurality attained by Mr. Dix and those given to his associates on the State ticket. It is plain from these fig- ‘ures that Dix ran almost exactly 50,000 ‘ahead of hig ticket; his plurality was (67,401, as against 18,403 for the Comp- month. | troller, 18,332 for the Treasurer, and 18,066 for the State Engineer. Compared |with the Lieutenant-Governor, his lead was not so great, while the comparison 'with the votes on Secretary of State and Attorney-General shows a greater lead; the reason in each case being obvious. Inasmuch as Mr. Stimson was an excel- ‘lent candidate, this preferential vote of | 50,000 in Mr. Dix’s favor is clearly to be interpreted as @ vote of protest; nor |does it begin to measure the extent of ithat vote. For every Republican that i0n ' probably three or four who either voted the straight Democratic ticket or did not vote at all. This conclusion, indi- cated by ordinary observation of the people during the campaign, is confirm- ed by the way in which the hoofs went with the hide—the Legislature with the Governorship—in spite of the advan- tages of Republican districting. Both Gov.elect Dix personally and the State of New York are to be con- gratulated on the decision of Mr. Charles EK. Treman to accept the very impor- tant post of Superintendent of Public Works. One of the chief difficulties encountered by Governors, and especial- ly by Governors of this State, in which the magnitude and complexity of the affairs to be administered are so great, is that of securing the services of men of a high order of ability in the prin- cipal offices connected with the Admin- istration. Acceptance of these duties, on the part of the men most peculiarly fitted to perform them, almost always involves a personal sacrifice, and there 'is no truer patriotism than that which is manifested by shouldering these bur- dens for the public good. In the case of Mr. Treman, the question of health entered into the case, and hence his fa- ‘vorable decision is all the more to be appreciated. There seems to be no doubt that Woodrow Wilson was approached by agents of Roger Sullivan when in Chi- }cago recently, and offered a bribe in the shape of the votes of the Illinois delega- tion to the next Democratic National Convention if he would only not oppose Mr. Smith’s election to the Senate. There are prominent politicians might mention, whose mode of proced- ure would have been to palliate, con- sider, and compromise in order to be It would by many have justifiable under the we “practical.” been considered new theory of applied political ethics. But Mr. Wilson's reply was prompt and vigorous. For those who know him or have watched his political career, it is ‘not difficult to imagine the fine scorn with which he waved these tempters ‘aside, with complete contempt for any post office, because the post office does ‘entered his protest by simply discrim- (effect his act might have on his own not do it in any satisfactory way. The inating in favor of Dix, there were career. This episode is, in fact, illum-
Page 4
594 The Nation [Vol. 91, No. 2373 ined by a significant remark made by | Wilson at the Southern Society's | Mr. dinner last week. Introduced, with poor taste, as a probable “future President,” Mr. Wilson promptly disclaimed any consideration of whither his new work would take him. He cared, he said, only for the task in hand, and not where he would arrive, except that he wanted to “on the necks of certain people.” is every reason to believe that he ‘The Americans who land There will have his wish. live in New Jersey, and those who live know a brave man when they From all accounts, the State Mr. Wilson in a way to Smith's brazen stand speedily elsew here, see him. is rising to make Mr. appear an act of political suicide. Pennsylvania's Legislative Reference is ready to perform its function Although cre- Bureau of first aid to legislators. ated by the Legislature of 1909, it was not until January of the present year that the Bureau began actual work. The first step was to establish a system of classification by which all the mate- rial to be gathered could be made avail- able for instant use. The basis of this classification is the living statute law State, that is, the unrepealed , exclusive of those which the of the slalule courts have held to be repealed by im- plication or that have been declared un- constitutional. The 2,200 bills of the session of 1909 were thcn filed accord- ing to this classification, the history of being indicated upon it. Cards were then obtained daily with the titles of bills introduced in the Legislatures of other States in the sessions of 1910, and the most important bills selected, sent for, and filed. Seventeen nbewspa- pers and a large aumber of periodicals were subscribed for, carefully clipped, and the clippings indexed and filed. Books and pamphlets, compilations of laws, and decisions of courts were also The object of the Bureau is each obtained. to present to members of the Legisla- ture information, digested and arrang- ed, upon as many subjects as possible of those they may be interested in. The corresponding experiment in Wisconsin has been highly successful. The seven selections for major-gener- als and brigadier-generals announced by the President represent almost a clean sweep for the bureaucrats of the War Department. one of the seven remaining civil war soldiers, is to be a major-general for three months before retirement—an honor no one will begrudge him. He is to be succeeded, not by one of the fifteen line brigadiers, but by the chief of the Coast Artillery, Brig..Gen. Arthur Mur- ray, whose place will in turn be taken by an officer on duty at the War Depart- ment, Col. E. M. Weaver. Of the four colonels to be promoted, the most grati- fying fact is that they are colonels, and not captains or majors. On the other hand, all four are men who have been on detached duty from their regiments for the greater part of the last four years. Col. Duncan, one of the two in- fantrymen selected, is on duty at the War Department, to which Col. Schuy- ler of the cavalry was under orders. Col. Evans, too, is an officer who has been a great deal on special duty these last few years. This batch of promo- tions is, therefore, certain to be receiv- ed by the army as official confirmation of the prevailing belief that the way to get ahead is to obtain duty near the powers that be in Washington. Why should there be objection to Brigham Young's portrait on the silver of the battleship Utah? Are we not wip- ing out all historical issues of the past and forgiving everybody for every- thing? With Robert E. Lee in Statuary Hall in his Confederate uniform, and Southern Governors declaring that Jef- regard to the past, and let us not im- pose standards of taste or ethics upon the rising generation. They have enough problems to face as it is. _ The moral influence alone of the Cen- |sus would justify its cost. Instead of ‘inducing satisfaction over past achieve- |ments, the impartial figures have only spurred ambition higher. This is true in a two-fold sense. In Chicago, this ambition takes the paradoxical form of looking forward to the day when an ob- stinate Census Bureau will allow the claim of 2,500,000 individuals within its ‘limits. This is a material reduction from the programme of the Three-Mil- lion Club, but, as an exchange of an im- practicable ideal for a possibility, speaks weli for the philosophic calm produced by the disappointing figures of 1910. But the great triumph of the Census is the emphasis it is leading many a city to place upon quality rather than quantity. | Boston is modestly insisting that it is ‘better to be just Boston than a so-called Greater Bostos, which would not rival ‘the largest centres anyhow. And to a |mnumber of other cities the population ‘figures have brought this same lofty aim and solace, Mr. Choate’s announcement that Sec- |retary Knox has worked out a plan by which the fifteen judges of the Court of ‘Arbitral Justice, recommended by the ‘engee Hague Conference may be chos- Gen. Charlies L. Hodges, | ferson Davis shall soon have a place 2 with satisfaction to the nations con- there as well, why cavil at Brigham cerned, is most gratifying. Owing to Young’s honoring on a battleship? Lee the inability to devise a method satis- was an admirable character and a won- factory to the smallest countries, this derful general; Brigham Young was an | court has languished. Few people real- amazing conqueror of the desert and a ize how much good will come from the remarkable captain of industry. The establishment of a permanent arbitra- one stood for slavery of the blacks; the| tion tribunal of this kind. Temporary other for the enslavement of women.| arbitration courts have done valuable But let us forget all that and put it service; but what is needed is a perma- purely on the ground of their own per-|uent court to build up traditions and sonalities. Let the dead political past rules and lay down new principles of in- bury its dead. Soon we shall have mon-/| ternational law and justice. The ques- uments to Benedict Arnold and Aaron | tion of enforcement of the decrees of an Burr—indeed, a memorial to Arnold in |international court was discussed last praise of his gallantry at Saratoga was Friday by a retired member of the Su- unveiled but the other day on the battle-| preme Court, Justice Henry B. Brown. field. In time, we shall commemorate | He regards the establishment of an in- as well Mr. Bryan’s devotion to the | ternational force to see to the accept- cause of sound money and James G./ ance of decisions as unpractical and as Blaine’s adoration of truth and common | leading to the wars the world is anxious honesty. The statue of Matthew Quay to stop. But many people will not be stands in the Harrisburg Capitol. What-|able to follow him in this. Why, for ever else we are, let us be efaritable in instance, assuming an arbitration be-
Page 5
Dec. 22, 1910] Natio The tween Germany and England, would it not be sufficient to have it known that France, the United States, Russia, Italy, and Austria would see to the acceptance of the court’s decree? No actual use of force would ever be necessary. The news from Cuba continues to be most unsatisfactory. So far as the Government is concerned, it long since forfeited whatever confidence of the bus- iness classes it ever had. Graft charges of a wholesale character are made every day, and Gomez himself, who is now re- ported to be in fear of his life, is the target of open accusation, and of much innuendo. No one believes that he will reside in Cuba, even if he survives his term. It has gone so far that a Havana newspaper is reported as lay- ing the attempted assassination of Gen. Pino Guerra, once one of Gomez’s close allies, at the President’s own door. As for the regular army itself, which, con- trary to common sense, the last Ameri- can Governor of Cuba, Mr. Magoon, forced on the island with the con- sent of Mr. Taft, it has become a source of weakness, instead of strength. This was foretold at the time, but the blun- der was insisted upon. Now Gomez is taking their ammunition away and scat- tering the troops over the island, to pre- vent their turning upon him. As the present Cuban situation is largely the result of Mr. Taft’s own policy, he can- not fail to be deeply concerned over the unhappy outlook. Pauperism in Great Britain has great- ly decreased in amount, although it has increased in cost. At present, the out- door pauperism is the lowest ever re- corded for England and Wales, and the lowest in London for seven years, while the indoor pauperism of the metropolis is the lowest for three years. Indoor pauperism has remained stationary dur- | ing the last ten years, says John Burns, president of the Local Government Board, because the workhouse is no longer the Bastille it used to be, and because children within the wards of the poorhouse no longer experience the treatment that was meted out to the Oliver Twists of fifty years ago. Above half of the indoor poor are now in spe- cial institutions, where their ailments are better looked after than in the old mixed general workhouse, which was a combination of the lunatic asylum and ithe jail, iis due to the higher standard of relief |for the aged, the sick, and children. It ‘is better economy to spend $250 in get- ting rid of sickness before the patient is fourteen years old than to spend $1,500 in palliating his symptoms after he is forty. Of the total pauperism, 30 per cent. is ascribed to sickness, and 45 per cent. to age and infirmity. As the fourth decade since the annexa- tion of Alsace and Lorraine by Germany draws to a close, the region formed by ithe two conquered provinces is about to enter on a new stage of its existence as part of the German Empire. The Bun- (desrat has adopted the draft of a con- stitution for Alsace-Lorraine, including the creation of a bicameral Legislatu ., o? which the lower house !s to be elected by universal suffrage. This may safely be regarded as marking a stage in the subsidence of anti-German feeling in the Reichsland, in which such a step is re- garded as unobjectionable by German ‘sentiment in the ruling classes. The event may serve, too, as a reminder cf |the virtually complete disappearance of the revanche idea in France, a thing which, forty years ago, hardly anybody /regarded as possible in so short a time. ‘Not that the sentiment of attachment ‘to France has ceased to exist in Alsace ‘and Lorraine, or that regret for the loss of her provinces no longer enters into the thoughts of the people of France; but the whole tone of the situation has changed. The fiery passions which for a few years after the great war seemed to burn with a quenchless flame, are now almost as completely a memory rs are the like feelings which were for a ‘time cherished in connection with “the ‘lost cause” in our own South. Monday’s action of the Imperial Sen- ate of China in adopting a resolution impeaching the Grand Councillors, ‘brings the difference between the Pro. gressives and the Regent party to an issue. Young China is impatient of further delay, and the imperial edict announcing that the demand for the ‘creation of a responsible Cabinet was refused, has only tempted the provincial delegates to take the bit in their teeth. If the contest were between the Pro- gressives and the Regent, prediction of the result would not be difficult. But “with a little bit of street-cor- ‘ner thrown in.” The increase of cost. 595 Chinese politics is not so simple. The Manchu nobles, who are adherents of the Empress Dowager, voted in October with the Progressives for the immediate convening of Parliament, and thus de clared themselves opposed to the con- servative policy of the Regent. But when, flushed with their successes, the Young China party passed a resolution calling upon the Grand Councillors to appear before the Assembly and explain their reasons for sanctioning the Hunan loan, a hint was conveyed through the president of the Ministry of Finance, who had been on the side of the Pro- gressives, that any further violent dis- play of hostility to the Government might mean the dissolution of the House. The Progressives of the Senate are evidently in the temper to test their power to the utmost, but no one can be surprised if, whether dissolution comes or not, palace politics defeats their pres- ent move for an authority which will be theirs in the end, but very possibly after a long period of waiting. If the late Professor Freeman still cares for what goes on in this world, an approving smile must have been seen on the features of his shade as he learned that the Asiatic Exclusion League of San Francisco had resolved last Monday to give up the use of the term “Anglo- Saxon.” Its motives are not exactly those of scholarship. It is not a question of substituting “Old English.” The point in this case is that the large num- bers of Germans and Irish and, we sup- pose, Slavs who, with the League, are determined to keep the pure native stock of this country from being con- taminated by Asiatic immigration, ob- ject to having our civilization described any longer as Anglo-Saxon. Hereafter it is to be known as “American”—though if anybody can tell what that word means, racially, he will be wiser than seven men that can render a reason. Professor Freeman held that Anglo-Sax- on was inexact and misleading, but we doubt if he would have liked ‘“Ameri- can” any better. Freeman was once toasted, somewhat ambiguously, as “the ‘historian who had shown such an intl- mate acquaintance with the rude man- ners of our forefathers,” but we think that, even in that matter, the Asiatic Exclusion League could have convinced him that time’s noblest offspring is the last.
Page 6
596 The Nation [Vol. 91, No. 2373 ; = — — = OUR OFFICE-HOLDING SYSTEM. (tbe government may prove themselves to be, they cannot reach higher posts without The next great step in the advance- ‘procuring the active influence of a patron ment of the merit system in the Federal |or without commending themselves in some civil service was clearly indicated by brvdbghing pereens & when Ot he Meee President Eliot in his address at the) opening of the thirtieth annual meeting| 7 the promotion of this extremely neer in the introduction of the merit system in State and municipal office; but that system has not grown in strength as it should have grown with the needs of the time and with the prog- ress made in the Federal service. One of the National Service Reform League, in session at Baltimore. It is natural that the great extensions given to the system by successive Presidents, and the gradual but complete dying out of the futile opposition to it so long mani- fested in Congress, should have brought about a general feeling that there is nothing of much consequence left to do; but such is by no means the case. The number of offices outside the classified service is, indeed, not very great—only some “9,000 as against 294,000 in the classified service—but thoir exclusion is nevertheless a matter of unquestionable | significance. Being of a high class, and therefore much sought after, they fur- nish a very considerable supply of spoils for the politicians; a part, by the way, that is also played by the large important advance in our official sys- of the tests of the quality of the incom- tem, the Civil Service Reform League | will be able to point to the unequivocal | support of President Taft, shown in more ways than one. Dr. Eliot referred to the President’s recommendation in| his message that the first, second, and | third class postmasterships should be placed in the classified list; and Mr. R. H. Dana spoke of the programme of | civil-service legislation laid before Con- gress by the President as not only show- | ing Mr. Taft's clear comprehension of | the needs of the service, but also as in- | dicating that public opinion has “ad- vanced to a point where it will no long- tolerate existing conditions under which minor employees are selected for er ing Governor will be furnished by his handling of this subject. Whether it be viewed as one of the means of procuring economy and efficiency, or as an element in that upbuilding of State powers which is part of the general programme of the Democratic party, the strength- ening of the Civil Service Commission and the determined enforcement of the civil service laws are among the objects which, we trust, Mr. Dix will take seri- ously to heart. By so doing, he would greatly strengthen his hold on that in- |dependent sentiment to which he large- \ly owes his election, and at the same time get rid of a considerable part of the office-seeking pressure which threat- ‘ens to make life a burden to him. merit, while the superior officers in | charge of the work are to a large ex-| ‘tent chosen with regard to their politi-|-wHar THE ENGLISH ELECTION number of special exemptions within | | the classified service, stated by Presi- cal qualifications.” In commenting thus | dent Eliot to be 68,000. But it is more on the President's position, Mr. Dans | important still that, so long as they | doubtless had in mind the sweeping rec- are filled by favor, there cannot be with- | ommendation made in the message that in the classified service that spirit of | the Executive should be empowered to ambition, that incentive to superior ex- | include in the classified service “all local cellence, which is indispensable to the | officers” under the Departments of the maintenance of the work at a high | Treasury, Justice, the Post Office, the level; and, as a rule, it will also be true | Interior, and Commerce and Labor, the /necessity of confirmation by the Senate to be in all these cases done away with. Although Mr. Dana may be too sanguine in thinking that public sentiment at that the persons in the higher posts will not themselves possess the qualifi- cations that would be regarded as in- dispensable for such posts if they were treated as the natural goal of successful |this time calls for such a change, ex- effort in the lower positions. perience clearly shows that it wili re-| How great a stimulus would be given |auire only a vigorous and continued | to the whole body of the service if these | effort to educate public opinion to the 9,000 posts, or all but a few of them, | point of effectively demanding it. were thrown apen to proved merit—if; While the application of sound princi- they were filled, as a rule, by promo- | ples has thus been making continuous tion, and when not by promotion by | and splendid progress in the Federal competitive examination—can easily be service, it has to be recognized with re- imagined by any one who knows how | gret that in the States there has been the same kind of incentive operates in| little advance to record for a number railways, in manufacturing concerns,|of years. This is partly, and perhaps in financial institutions, indeed in any | entirely, to be explained by the circum- calling where a salaried man may look | stance that public attention has been di- upon his work as opening up possibil- | rected so much to the qventatened| ities of a successful career. That is|question of corporation abuses. But | SETTLED. As the close of the pollings in the English general elections leaves the strength of the respective parties in the House of Commons almost exactly what it was before the dissolution, there nat- urally are dissonant voices interpreting the result. If editors and public men were to be held to what they said before the election, or during !ts progress, it would be easy to decide what had been settled by the voting. Thus the London Spectator declared on November 12 that the Government did not need to procure so large a majority as they had before, in order “to place the Constitution at their disposal,” for “we may dismiss as idle the notion that the King could re- sist.” But this was merely meant to frighten people into voting Conserva- tive, not as a deliberate opinion on what should be thought of the election after it was over. So, too, Prof. A. V. Dicey wrote in advance that the “true issue laid before the electorate” was simply this: “Shall the Parliament bill [the abolition of the veto of the House of Lords] become the law of the land?” We presume that the Oxford professor what the classified service, great as has | whatever the explanation, the fact it- would not now admit that it must be. been the advance over the old spoils self is to be deplored. New York State— | After the first day’s voting, when it system, does not do. As President Eliot | which furnished the great leaders of the looked as if the Government might lose says: civil service reform movement in the | thirty seats, Lord Rosebery asserted However meritorious these servants of days of its militant youth—was a pio-| that, if they lost no more than five seats,
Page 7
Dec. 22, 1910] The N i they “could not go on with their pro-| posals.” Yet his Lordship, no doubt, will still be found fighting those proposals, although no seats were lost. “The veto of the Lords is dead,” affirms John Red- mond, Winston Churchill’s phrase is: “The veto of the House of Lords has been referended.” On the other hand, Mr. Balfour takes the view that the elec- tion has been indecisive, and that an- other one must follow next year. With doctors on the spot thus dis- agreeing, it would be rash for an out- sider to venture an opinion. What the course and order of business will be in the new Parliament; what the Govern- ment will attempt to do; what will be the attitude of the Lords; what posi- tion the King will take—about all these things it is impossible to make any safe prediction. But one result is assured. The election has taken one thing out of the realm of political controversy: it has made an end of the hereditary principle as the basis of the House of Lords. The actual change may be writ- ten into legislation and made a part of the British Constitution, slowly; it may be enacted in one of several ways; but the decree of the nation has now gone forth, and the House of Lords as we have known it is henceforth a thing of the past. It is the culmination of a movement long pursued. In 1884, when the Lords had thrown out a franchise bill design- ed to give the vote to agricultural la- borers, John Bright made a speech at Birmingham in which he directly at- tacked the hereditary principle as the basis of any legislative body. “Priv- ilege,” he maintained, “everywhere be- gets ignorance and selfishness and ar- rogance.” While Bright admitted that some of the members of the House of Lords were able and hard-working leg- islators, he had nothing but scorn for the mass of the Peers who never show- ec their face: Westminster except when they were summoned to reject some popular Bright was strongly then for either making over the House of Lords or limiting its veto. The proposal which he made was so nearly like the one which Campbell- Bannerman and Mr. Asquith later in- troduced that it is altogether probable that they drew their inepiration direct from that tribune of the English peo- ple. Bright’s exact language is worth quoting: measure. The proposition that I should make would be this—that they should have, unimpaired, |all the power they have now with regard to any bill that has passed the House of Com- mons for the first time during the session in which the Lords are called upon to deal with it. That is, in the case of this bill, they would be at liberty to amend it, and send it back to the Commons. If the Com- mons did not like the amendments, and would not accept them, the bill would go back to the Lords, and if the Lords chose, they might reject it. But in a second ses- sion, if practically the same bill was sent up to the Lords, they would then also have a right to debate and to amend; but when the bill came down to the House of Com- mons in this second session, and the Com- mons would not agree to the amendments of the Lords, then the Lords should be bound to accept the bill. It was virtually on this issue, as de- fined by John Bright in 1884, that a Lib- eral Government went to the people in 1910 and were sustained. Important events had, of course, come between. Chief among them must be reckoned the action of the Lords themselves, under severe political pressure, in voting sol- emnly that the hereditary right to sit in their House ought not to be alone suffi- cient for membership. knell of a passing régime. The details of the reform remain to be worked out. The plan of the Conservatives is to re- constitute the Lords but to leave their powers virtually as they are. In its naked form, the Liberal proposal is to have nothing to do with a reformed House of Lords, but to leave that body as it is and then practically paralyze it by taking away its veto on legislation. Yet if English statesmen have not lost their open-mindedness and their instinct for compromise, there ought to be found some way of adjusting the matter, by another conference or otherwise, so that what both parties profess to desire may be procured—namely, a dignified and ef- ficient Second Chamber, as ready to con- sider Liberal measures cn their merits as Conservative. MR. CARNEGIE’S GREATEST GIFT. Had the world not been, of late, some- what accustomed to vast gifts from Messrs. Rockefeller and Carnegie, it would to-day be fairly dazed by the lat- ter’s magnificent contribution of ten mil- lions of dollars to the cause of peace. Surely no great foundation was ever in- spired by a better motive, or dedicated to a higher cause. There is no issue of greater importance before the world to- day, from the financial, the economic, and the moral point of view, than this ation That was the) ia 597 lof doing away, not only with war itself, but with that preparation for war which is becoming quite as deadly t> social and ethical progress as actual slaughter. All this Mr. Carnegie has for years seen and clearly understood. In season and out of season, by the iIn- fluence of his pen and his prestige, as well as by hfs wealth, he has furthered every movement to open men’s eyes to the truth that war can no more be justi- fied among those who profess to follow the doctrines of Christ than it can be justified among brothers of the same | State or nation. So, with unfailing gen- erosity, Mr. Carnegie gave the $1,500,- 000 Peace Palace at The Hague, and built also the noble home of the Bureau of American Republics at Washington, and the lately destroyed international court in Central America, which he is now to rebuild. For the Heroes of Peace in America, he gave a fund of $5,000,000, and for those in France $1,000,000; yet these are but a few of the moves in his |high-minded and unselfish war upon ‘war. What war really is, Mr. Carnegie has described repeatedly, but never in terser or better form than in his deed of gift. We wish that every school house and library in America might have inscribed ‘upon its walls these sentiments: War is “the foulest blot upon our civiliza- | tion.” Although we no longer eat our fellow- men, nor torture prisoners, nor sack cities, | killing their inhabitants, we still kill each |}other in war like barbarians. Only wild beasts are excusable for doing that in this the twentieth century of the |Christian era, for the crime of war is in- herent, since it decides not in favor of the right, but always of the strong. And it would be only right to say, too, that, as Mr. Carnegie also states, a nation is criminal which refuses ar- bitration. To his truth that “honor is the most dishonored word in the lan- guage,” we might add that patriotism ranks next so long as it is held to be synonymous with a readiness to die for one’s country while blotting out the ex- istence of other men who are themselves innocent of blame or hate. The truth is that the making of war and the kill- ing of the warmaker’s pawns by the hundred thousand is but another form of the slavery of the masses to their rulers, from which the world has been so rapidly emerging. Is it not inevitable that in the years to come the monstros- ity of the Franco-Prussian war, which made of two nations the pitiful victims
Page 8
59S of a half-dozen politicians, will be a source of amazement? Will future gen- erations not find it utterly incomprehen- sible that the power of life and death over millions should have been delegat- ed to an Emperor or a Chancellor? How is this great gift of Mr. Carnegie to be utilized? How can its vast in- come best be spent to further the cause? The selves have no definite plan, and beyond newly appointed trustees them- indicating a few forms of activity, Mr. Carnegie himself rightly says: “Lines of be laid trustees wisely the themselves action cannot Yet, their future down.” as soon as and agents apply to their task, provided they do so with intention of a radical cam- the the honest paign against common enemy, a are cer- the thousand avenues of activity tain to Already mil- lion dollar f’. Ginn in Boston is at work in educa- open up foundation made by Edwin tion, carrying on a vigorous propaganda. the Carnegie Foundation can in- in volume; it can carry the facts ) war and peace into every house- ind into every school. It can un- 1 wise political propaganda of tional and an international char- How much education is needed home, the flaring headlines in about the annual “war scare” Mr. Taft has withdrawn the alarmist report of his press Washington, amply testify Secretary of War, who is one of the great appointments of his Administration; of the first things the Carnegie fll t one Foundation can do is to pour the day- light these perpetual war-scares, nd statements as that of Congressman Mc- upon apply calm reason to such absurd Lachlan that 200,000 foreigners could calmly land and intrench themselves on Patriots of this kind, in England or in America, can the Pacific Coast whether usually figure out just to the dollar or shilling what such a fearful invasion will cost their respective fatherlanda. And then the Foundation should certain- ly reveal the connection of ammunition, armor plate, ship and gunbuilding con cerns with navy leagues and boy scouts, and the war propaganda of every kind. Much will, of course, depend upon the trustees themselves, and there we con- to one in connec- with Mr Not a ngle radical opponent of war is on the fess disappointment tion Carnegie’s gift. list, but many who (as did Mr. Joseph H. Choate at the Root peace dinner of Feb- or as The Nation [Vol 91, No. 2373 ruary, 1908, and Mr. Roosevelt in Cam- bridge only last week) express an intel- lectual interest in peace, but are not against battleships, too. Great as are the services Mr. Root has rendered as a Peace Secretary of State, he has him- self reached the time of life when the forces of conservatism are at their height, and with him are a number of trustees of much greater age—for in- stance, two of seventy-four, one of sev- enty-six, two of seventy-eight, and one Much will be ac- complished in the matter of arbitration of eighty-two years. treaties, international courts, and con- ferences. But if the cause of peace is really to be advanced rapidly, it must be not by lip-service or by voicing the that run, “Of worse things than tiresome compromises course, there are war’; “there are times when people have to fight.” tion to war is what is needed—in the Uncompromising opposi- spirit of Tolstoy. However, no such re- gret can prevent the Nation from re- its deliberate belief that this gift of Mr. Carnegie’s cording is an event of great importance for the world. IN COLLEGE AND AFTER. President Lowell, in an article in the December number of the Harvard Grad- uates’ Magazine, undertakes to use, as the oft-dis- cussed question of the relation between a basis for judgment cn college-student rank and after success, certain statistics of the standing at- tained by Harvard A.B.’s in their sub- sequent studies in the Harvard schools of law and medicine. Two classifications are involved, the one according to the nature of the studies chiefly pursued by the student while at college, the other according to the rank attained by him upon as A.B. Under each of these classifications, the ques- his graduation tion is asked, what percentage of stu- dents of a given type took their pro- And this is President Lowell's summing up: fessional degree cum laude. The conclusions to be drawn from the whole matter are these: that it makes com- paratively little difference to what subject a man devotes himself in college, but it makes difference how good a scholar he is; and that the men who are destined to take the highest rank in the Law and Medi- eal are markedly better scholars both In the preparatory schools and in col- lege than their fellows. In intellectual pow- in other things is father to the man in immense S« hools the boy From the second of these conclusions '—that it does make a great difference whether a young man has or has not been a good student at college—there and this not because the statistics are them- selves conclusive, but also because the is no room for dissent; only conclusion might well have been regard- ed as established as a result of com- mon observation. It may be, as Presi- Gent Lowell says, that there is a “pop- ular prejudice” in favor of the opposite view—the view that a poor student at college is as likely as a good one to be a success in professional work; but, like the similar prejudice to the effect that precocious children are likely to be stupid or commonplace adults, and that the children of men of genius are not likely to be much more gifted than those of ordinary persons, it has never rested on any respectable basis of fact, but has on the contrary been in manifest con- tradiction to facts obvious to any intel- ligent and unprejudiced observer. To the “popular prejudice” on this last head, Galton’s “Hereditary Genius” may be regarded as having given the coup de grace nearly half a century ago; and the figures adduced by President Lowell should go far toward removing such misapprehension as may exist on the subject of the relation between a cred- itable record of scholarship at college and a like record in professional stud- ies. Thus the figures show that of men who simply got a plain degree at col- lege only 6.6 per cent. sucgeeded in getting a cum laude at the Law School, whereas this success was attained by 22.7 per cent. of those who, at college, had graduated cum laude, by 39.2 per cent. of those who had won a magna cum laude, and by 64.7 per cent. of the summa cum laude men. As the statis- tics cover twenty years, and more than a thousand men, this is a pretty con- clusive case of concomitant variations. Concerning the {::st of President Low- ell's conclusions, on the other hand, there is considerable reason for hesita- tion, both as to the conclusiveness of the statistics and as to the true signifi- cance of the conclusion itself. The four great divisions under which the men are classified according to the studies to which they were chiefly devoted are Language and Literature, Natural Scl- ence, History and Political Science, and Philosophy and Mathematics. Now, to begin with, President Lowell himself rules out the fourth of these divisions,
Page 9
Dec. 22, 1910] The Nation
because the whole number of students under it in the Law School was only nineteen, and in the Medical School only eight. There remain, then, at best, only the three other groups as a basis for judgment. But an extremely important objection must be entered against this conclusion; namely, that each of these large groups includes an enormous range, and that studies chosen within the group may be of the most diamet- rically opposite character as regards mental discipline. In Language and Literature, it may make all the differ- ence in the world whether one takes Greek or English; in Natural Science, whether the choice is physics or geol- ogy; in History and Political Science, whether it is political economy or mod- ern history. In a word, the classifica- tion is too loose to be made the basis of any confident conclusion as to the indifference of choice of subjects. It is quite possible that if a subdivision were made which would segregate the highly disciplinary subjects, these groups would show the same extremely high average of after-success that is shown in the fig- ures of the little mathematical group actually contained in the tables. Apart from the question of the con- clusiveness of the result, there is, as we have intimated, the further question of its significance. We do not refer to the distinction between selection and causa- tion—between what is to be ascribed to the kind of men who choose a given group of studies and what is to be ascribed to the effect upon them of that choice—which is somewhat touched upon by Dr. Lowell. Waiving this, we must still regard the subject from two dis- tinct standpoints. The studies pursued by a student in his college course may influence his success in his profes- sional studies in two quite distinct ways —first, by the amount of direct equip- ment he gets for his professional work through the acquired knowledge; sec- ondly, by the mental discipline which they impart and the mental habits which they engender. Upon the first point, the Harvard statistics may be re- garded as throwing some light, and per- haps justifying the negative conclusion; on the second, for the reason already mentioned, they throw no immediate light, and if they justify any inference it is the opposite of that which would be read on their face. It does appear, from the statements of detail made by Dr. Lowell, that the amount of know- ledge acquired at college in the direction of one’s profession makes little or no | difference in the end, at the profession- al school; whence if any inference can be drawn it is that what the student ‘gains at college turns on the general development conferred by the mental discipline. As we have pointed out, the figures throw no light whatever on the relation between success in professionai studies and severity of previous train- ing; but, indicating as they do that the mere choice of general departments of knowledge makes no difference, they should leave unimpaired the conviction, seemingly based on abundant experi- ence, and still entertained, we trust, by many, that a training in tific thinking and accurate study of lan- guage is not an idle exercise of useless intellectual muscles, but the most brac- ing and effective preparation for a ca- intellectual in any exact scien- reer of exertion field. A REVOLUTION IN GREER. Now and then a book is written which shows that, may be dwindling in the classroom, it is still very much alive in the minds of a few solitary scholars. Such James Adam’s “Religious Teachers of Greece,” published two years ago, posthu- mous work of one who was himself a much-regretted teacher. Such is the volume of “Lectures on Greek Poetry,” just published by J. W. Mackail, the pro- fessor of poetry in the University of Ox- The book is a fit companion to “Springs of Helicon” issued last year; if anything, we move here even ore securely on that ground where lit- erature and life come together than we did in the essays on Chaucer and Spen- ser and Milton. If we were criticising the book in detail we might indeed point to certain deficiencies, and espec- ially to a false note that has its origin Professor Mackail’s too great fond- of Morris however Greek was the ford. his in ness for the luscious style and Swinburne and in his constant use of these poets for comparison with the ancients. But there is life in these pages. The poets of Greece still speak here the tongue of living men; not only do their words carry the everlasting consolation which we are willing to accord to the memory of something beautiful and lost, but their criticism of life cuts into ac- tual problems of the day and all days. In some ways the most significant of 599 ‘the lectures is that which deals with the vexations of the Homeric Question —<deals with them somewhat in the man- ner of Dante’s Virgil with certain nox- ious souls: “Speak not of them, but look and pass.” The very gist of the matter is in this rather cavalier treatment of a theme that for a century and more has muddied the waters of classical scholarship and has been the occasion of a indescribable books and dissertatiuncule. The trouble be- gan back in the early days of Hellenic criticism, when the school of “Separat- tried to prove that the Iliad and library of ers” the Odyssey were composed by two dif- ferent poets. Suspicions of the author- ship of the poems crop out two or three times at the Renaissance and after; but the real debate, “die homerische Frage,” Die Frage, was started in 1795, when Friedrich August Wolf published his “Prolegomena,” and attempted to prove that there was properly speaking no Ho- but only a number of rhapsodes whose un- to- mer at all, nor any two Homers, written recitations got finally run gether somehow into the Iliad and the The effect was startling. It the of Goethe; it created manuals love to call the neuere Altertumswissen- schaft, the new science of antiquity; it was the source of innumerable theories and counter-theories. This man reduced the Iliad to a disjointed conglomera- tion of ballads; another plucked out for you the heart of the poem, the Ur-llias, about which successive had attached layers of easily distinguished the poem Odyssey. Olympian repose the disturbed what centuries weeretions; another rewrote in its original dialect and by the varia- tion of forms could tell you nicely when and where composed. They worried the poems into rags, and themselves into rage. Their treatises remain on the shelves of every well equipped classical library as one of the stupendous monuments of pedantry. universities But it For some time England, owing the various members were In general, the German were the centres of the storm. spread as much to her backwardness in erudi- tion as to her common sense, ignored the Question, but later it swept both Ox- ford and Cambridge. A genial man of letters, like Andrew Lang, might con- tinue to scoff at the theorizers, but the university men who had a scholastic maintain, soon grew old-fashioned reputation to ashamed of such ignor-
Page 10
600 ance. French scholars followed suit, and so generally admirable a work as the Croisets’ “Littérature grecque” de- votes the best part of a volume to dis- jointing the Iliad and Odyssey and takes up the significance and value of poems which are the fountain-head of Euro- pean literature, as quite a secondary matter. Then came America. Only the other year a school history of Greek lit- erature gave most of what little space it had for Homer to an account of the Question, and to-day a translator of the Iliad has prefaced his hexameters with his own theory of authorship. But a change has come at last, and a scholar like Professor Mackail can now assume without apology or flerce argu- ment that the Iliad was in the main written by one real poet (written, for the old notion that writing was then un- known has been quite discredited), and that the Odyssey was probably from the same hand. It would be an exagger- ation to say that this simple acceptance of tradition has ended the horrid dis- pute, for many scholars, especially in Germany, still cling to their respective creeds of impersonal composition; but the trend is undoubtedly away from the whole complicated fabric of theory. The pilgrim of letters will soon be able to pass by the Question unafraid. In part this return to common sense is due to more precise knowledge; in part it is connected with a larger move- ment. The Homeric Question was in reality only an aspect of German roman- ticlam; it sprang up with the distinc- tion between nalve and artificial poetry, and with the whole sentimental glorifi- cation of Volksdichtung, which in turn was merely one outcome of the Roussel- lian ery, Back to the primitive, back to nature. If the Homeric poems were great, it must be just because they were authoriess, the unconscious creation of the people. For a century criticism in Eu- rope, with some notable exceptions, has been repeating in various disguises the dicta of Herder and the Schlegel broth- ore, and the revolt from the Homeric Question may lead to a sounder view of literature in general. It is a pleasant irony that the exaltation of primitive balladry should have resulted in so huge and so artificial a body of scholas- ticism. And there is another and more imme- diately practical side to this movement. It is an undoubted fact that the Homer- lie Question has been one of the con- [Vol. o1. No, 2373 The Nation spirited man are right, each merely tak- ing partial views of a somewhat compli- cated subject. It is perfectly true that hand, in itself and as part of the Teu-\no sensitive lover of art would care tonic system, it has tended to exclude either to support handsomely or attend from the professional study of the class- ‘frequently any big annual art exhibi- ics such men as had a clear vision Of tion, be it National or Royal Academy, the relation of literature to life, and, | gaion or Société. These omnibus shows, on the other hand, it has helped to | esthetically considered, are at best nec desiccate the teaching of those who have essary evils. One who loves painting or remained. It is almost an impossibility sculpture will naturally go for his de that a student who reads and digests |light to a place where he can see a few the mass of books on this and similar things of choice quality under good con- questions should be able with the fag ditions. More sensations of art may be end of his strength to put any vigor into had in an hour at a museum or at his teaching of Greek as a human docu- any good Fifth Avenue dealer’s than ment. It is in this sense that we judge may be gathered from the academies of Professor Mackail’s chapter interesting a score of years. Admitting this frank- in itself and significant of better things ly, there remains every reason why the to come, 'National Academy shouid continue to ‘exhibit and why it should have a proper NEW YORK’S NEED OF AN ART GAL- |°™!!ding. LERY. The large annual exhibitions, whep- In varying year by year the display ©¢Ver held, are not primarily esthetic or in its crowded galleries the Nationa) ®Ttistic functions; they are necessary Academy of Fine Arts merely rings the civic institutions having to do with the changes upon a distressful situation. | fostering of certain fine handicrafts The galleries of the Fine Arts building Which we over-ambitiously designate as were never big enough to house a rep- the fine arts. Let us recall that the resentative annual show. The Pennsyl- | terms of admission to the great exhibi- vania Academy exhibits regularly from ‘ions are not solely artistic, but techni- seven to eight hundred numbers under ©@! and professional. To be accepted favorable conditions. The National Means not that, on a universal scale, Academy can show, under the worst the contributor has made a fine work conditions of space, only about three |°f art, but that on the temporary scale hundred, and fails to hang at all a mat-|°f the day—the current art-school stan- ter of a hundred pictures accepted or |4ard—he has attained a considerable their merits. In the course of twenty Proficiency in painting or sculpture. The years high buildings have cut off the jouaee exhibition is, under the system sunlight from the Fine Arts building, so that prevails, about the only chance a tributing causes to the decline of Greek. Its effect was twoedged. On the one that a tolerable gallery light exists only YOU2€ man has of winning the formal for a few hours each day. This year, in ®PProbation of his elder colleagues. order to give sculpture its due of a sin- Now, since it is very desirable for the gle gallery, the walls are so crowded ®40rnment and dignifying of our life with pictures that a visit is a penance that all the fine handicrafts should be to any sensitively organized taste. What |Practised, the fixed exhibition renders can be done to liberalize the member-|®2 evident public service, and rightly ship and policy of the Academy has been |¢!aims public support. But that support done, but from the sheer unattractive. Should be asked and given in the light ness of its shows a venerable and useful of What can actually be done, and with- public body must either shut up shop Ut raising false esthetic hopes about or linger on in artistic insignificance. | What exhibitions never have done and Of this emergency two views are held. | mover can do. Your wsthete is likely to say, What of| To the trained artist, the large exhibt- it? Academies were never very good, tion is valuable because it affords him and will hardly be missed. Your average the only comprehensive opportunity he public-spirited man is likely to dwell | gets for measuring himself against his warmly upon the shame of not support- ‘strongest contemporaries. In an age too ing an ancient institution devoted to the | busy to seek the artist, the exhibition art of the land. As is so frequently the grants at least the possibility of public case, both the wsthete and the public-' notice and private patronage. It gives
Page 11
Dec. 22, 1910] to the middlemen, the official and unof- | ficial art critics, the privilege of cele brating new talent and marking the progress of established talent. If prop- erly managed, the more ambitious ex- hibitions serve a useful purpose as a market and keep alive public interest in the arts. No fine or profound knowledge of art can in the nature of the case be gathered from annual exhibitions. Their scope is too narrow. They may, however, create that diffused enthusiasm without which the economic basis of art is lack- ing. If ever the time comes when peo ple care enough for art to frequent the studios, big shows will become superflu- ous, but there is no indication that such a day is dawning. Meanwhile, we should face the facts as they are, without illu- sions and with clear-sighted public spirit. A calm estimate of values ought to shake hesitating patrons of the Nation- al Academy out of their misgivings. There is no question that, on a money basis merely, or considering more broad- ly the production and patronage of art, the great exhibitions of London, Paris, Munich, Venice, Philadelphia, do a val- uable service to their respective cities. If their wealthy men were met with a) proposal to withdraw support from such exhibitions, the suggestion would be scouted with wrath. Yet New York in-| comprehensibly withholds such aid from | an exhibiting body equally deserving. The public worth of an annual exhibi- tion clearly depends on its comprehen- sive and representative character. A small show pleases neither the esthete | nor the public-spirited man. As things stand to-day, our most important branch of painting—mural decoration—is_sel- dom shown in New York. The presence of the better decorative pieces of eacb year in the Academy would immediate-. ly add character and distinction to the display. The National Academy needs, and needs now, a building with abun-| It is amaz- | dant space and good light. ing and not a little shameful that in this age of profuse benefactions no donor should yet have seized upon so evident an opportunity for public use- fulness. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. Merle Johnson’s “Bibliography of the Works of Mark Twain,” just published by the Harpers, is an admirable piece of work. In it collectors for the first time have in first editions of many of Mark Twain's | books, Even when Mark Twain was writing for |the Virginia City Enterprise and for the | San Francisco Alta-Californian his material was freely copied by other newspapers. Af- ter his return from the “Quaker City” ex- |cursion and the publication of “Innocents Abroad,” the English and Canadian pirates reprinted everything of his they could lay their hands upon. Long before the present international copyright law was in force, by taking advantage of the fact that the English laws granted protection to foreign authors, providing that publication was first made in that country, he was able to pro- tect himself and his publishers there. In consequence the English editions of many of his books are actual firsts. Mr. Johnson in many cases, bas been able to ascertain the exact dates of entry and filing of copies at Washington and of publication in Lon don. “The Adventures of Tom Sawyer” was published in London on June 9, 1876 whereas copies of the American edition were not filed in Washington until January 2 1877. Both titles are dated 1876. A com- parison of the two editions shows that the American was actually the earlier text, which was edited more or less before it was printed in England. For example, in the fence-whitewashing episode (one of the best-known scenes in any of Mark Twain's books) all mention of Tom’s sore toe is cmitted in the English edition. In the case of “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” the London editicn, published December 10, 1884, is dated 1884 on the title-page, whereas | the American edition, published only three days later, is dated 1885. For a long time most of Mark Twain's books were published by the American Pub- lishing Company of Hartford, Conn., in the characteristic “subscription book” form of the seventies and eighties of the last cen- tury. And while the total number printed of many of the books ran far into the thous- | ands, the first printings seem to have been smal] in number, and to identify these first issues has been Mr. Johnson's task. The special features of the actual first issues of some of these books were described in this column on September 22 last. The Bibliography is divided into four sections: (1.) Books or pamphlets entirely by Mark Twain, and containing an impor- tant contribution by him; (2.) books con- taining speeches by him; (3.) books con- taining letters; (4.) books containing anec- dotes attributed to Mark Twain. The first section includes nearly all of the items of importance. Few of Mark Twain's speeches achieved contemporary printing outside of newspaper columns, though about a hundred of them have been collected in a volume since his death. Following the Bibliography are a series of interesting Notes and an Index which re- cords the appearance in periodical and book of every one of Mark Twain's pieces, which can now be identified, whether collected or uncollected. An examination of this Index shows that there is still considerable ma- terial not included in any of the uniform | editions, | The following titles ought to be added to | Mr. Johnson's Bibliography. Both were dis- |covered too late for insertion in the book: Tom Hood’s | Comic Annual | for | 1874, With Twenty-three Pages of Illustrations 601 lished at the Fun Office, | 80 Fleet Street, E. C. | 8vo. ; This pamphlet contains, on pp. 78, 79, “A Yankee Story” signed “G. R. Wadleigh,” but actually by Mark Twain. In No. xvii of “Chapters from my Autobiography,” pub- lished in the North American Review for May 3, 1907, Mark Twain tells over again the story of “Jim Wolf and the Cats,” and states that it was an actual adventure of his boyhood days. In 1867, when, as he says, he had “failed in all my other undertakings and stumbled into literature without intend- ing it,” he wrote out the story for the New York Sunday Mercury and received $26 for it In 1873, when he was lecturing in Lon- don, an impecunious American came to him for assistance, and, besides giving him mo- ney, Mark Twain introduced him to Tom Hood The young man, who turned out to be a swindler, wrote out this anecdote of Jim Wolf, signed his own name to it, and sold it to Hood for three guineas What American Authors Think | About In- ternational Copyright. | New York Ameri- an Copyright League 1888. 8vo A contribution by Mark Twain fills the left-hand column of page 10. A portion of Mark library will be sold at auction by the Ander- son Auction Company Besides books from his library a number of auto- graph manuscripts are included, among them considerable Twain's in January. the following: “Eve's Diary,” 34 pages; “Extracts from Adam's Diary,” 34 pages; “My Boyhood Dreams,” 18 pages; “The Death Disk,” 37 pages; “Italian Grammar,” 41 pages; “Meisterschaft, in 3 Acts,” 70 pages; “My Debut as a Literary Person,” 64 pages; “Concerning the Jews,” 37 pages; “A Horse’s Tale,” 147 pages; “How the Chimney Sweep got the Ear of the Emperor,” 26 pages. In our previous note on Mark Twain's books we referred to the statement prefixed to the “Extracts from Adam's Diary” (New York, 1904), that a friend of his had “‘print- ed a few copies in an form.” The autograph manuscript, which we have now seen, has this note at the top: “Pub- lished (don’t remember when), 8. L, C.” incomplete ’ Correspondence A SOURCE OF “THE RAVEN.” TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The most important source of Poe's “Raven,” Dickens's ‘“‘Barnaby Rudge,” has hitherto been dismissed by biographers and critics, including Ingram, Lauvriére, Woodberry, and H. E. Legler, with scant notice. Such an unconscious conspiracy of silence is not justifiable, however, in view of the noteworthy parallels between the two productions. As Mr. Woodberry declares, the proper starting point is Poe's review of “Barnaby Rudge,” published in Graham’s Magazine, February, 1842, in which he made ‘the following suggestion: The raven, intensely amusing as it is, might have been made, more than we now jsee it, a portion of the conception of the fantastic Barnaby. Its croakings might have been prophetically [the italics are Poe's) {heard in the course of the drama. Significant words these, when we remem- ber that Poe published “The Raven” in Jan- an accessible form exact particulars of the' By the Brothers Dalziel. | London: | Pub-'uary, 1845, and may have written it consid-
Page 12
602 ' erably earlier. He adopts, for example, his own suggestion in the very climax of the poem ‘‘Prophet!"’ sald I, ‘thing of evil !—prophet still, if bird Poe's essay, “The Philosophy of Compo- | (1846), purports to explain fully the composition of “The Raven”; critics now agree, it It seems to have written in In this fa- “Barnaby subject of or devilt’’ sition” and in reality, nothing of the sort. a deliberate hoax, and Swift. mention the ie M ger most in part pirit of Defoe ssay he does not his only words on rd being these naturally, a parrot, in the first in suggested itself, but was superseded vith by a raven, as equally capable of and infinitely more in keeping with ntended tone [the italics are again This. by reason of the fact that the raven the bird of ill-omen.” Such failure to acknowledge a debt to Dickens is not proof positive of the absence of the debt. Poe, un- fortunately, was sometimes disingenuous in especially when his vanity was Mr. Woodberry has emphasized with quite sufficient severity. I am aware, indeed, that there seems to be another objeetion to belief in any close like- ness between the two ravens: in the pass- age from the review of the novel, quoted above, Poe refers to the “intensely amusing” character of the raven in “Barnaby Rudge.” But any one who will take the trouble to examine those portions of the book in which Grip appears will perceive that Poe’s phrase is not applicable to all of them; there are several important scenes in which the bird moves in a sombre atmosphere. Moreover, the :aven is inevitably connect- ed—and Poe, as is proved by his review, wished him to be still more closely con- nected—with his master, Barnaby, who, on; account of his infirmity of mind, lives in a| half-supernatural world which Dickens has very powerfully described. Poe himself, in the review mentioned, quotes a passage in point. Now, if there is anything for which this American is famous, both in his stories and his poems, it is atmosphere. It is not to be expected, therefore, that so striking an atmosphere as that which surrounds the mad boy and his pet would pass out of the poet's memory in less than three years. It is questionable whether so salient a detail) as the refrain, “Nevermore,” was not sug- by the following, from a gloomy in the prison between Barnaby and hia mother: 18 statement, erned, con this point geated “You hope! Ay, but your hoping will not! undo these chains. / hope, but they don’t mind that. Grip hopes, but who cares for Grip?” The raven gave a short, dull, melancholy croak It sald “‘Nobody,” as plainly as a croak could speak “Who cares for Grip, excepting you and me?’ sald Barnaby, smoothing the bird's rumpled feathers with his hand. “He never speaks in this place; he never says a word in Jail; he sits and mopes all day in this dark corner, dozing sometimes, and some- times looking at the light that creeps in through the bara, and shines itn his bright eye as If a epark from those great fires had fallen Into the room and was burning yet. But who cares for Grip?” The raven croaked again—“Nobody.” never speaks in this place”—speaks but “Nobody”: and Poe’s raven no word but “Nevermore.” More- over, the “flery eyes” which “burned into; the bosom’s core” of the, lonelf watcher in “He no word speaks | Ultimate.” Na [Vol. 91, No. 2373 The the chamber are seemingly reminiscent of the peculiar brightness of Grip’s eyes. Is there not some significance, also, as re- gards the expectant atmosphere of the poem, in the admonition of Barnaby’s mother?— “You must not go out to-night. There are ghosts and dreams abroad” (p. 352). Truly, the ghost, as the villagers think it, of the murderer, Barnaby’s father, continually makes itself felt in the novel. Ghosts and dreams! Such is “The Raven”; such stuff as dreams are made of. And the ghost of the lost Lenore hovers constantly in the background. None of the foregoing parallels, I hasten to say, shows anything that may be called plagiarism—although Poe himself, that lit- tion erary detective, might have called it such | in Longfellow or other poets. Dickens made no charges against his American admirer; and even “Outis,” who bitterly attacked Poe for his charges of plagiarism against Long- fellow, did not mention “Barnaby Rudge.” Certainly “The Raven” possesses sufficient original features, such as the somewhat melodramatic perch of the bird upon a bust of Pallas, the skilful if artificial progress of the poem to a strangely effective climax, | and especially the reverie of a lover over) the death of a beautiful woman—a topic which Poe, in “The Philosophy of Compo- | sition,” declares to be “unquestionably the | most poetical in the world.” But, finally, is it purely accidental that the opening words lof “The Philosophy of Composition” should have been these?— Charles Dickens, in a note now lying be- fore me, alluding to an examination I once made of the mechanism of “Barnaby Rudge,” says, etc. In no better way could Poe have uncon- sciously acknowledged a debt which extends to much greater detail than has common- ly been supposed. Harry T. BAKER. Rockland, Me., December 14. THE QUEST OF THE ULTIMATE. To THe EprTtor or THE NATION: Srr: I have read with interest your ar- ticle of November 17 on “The Quest of the You certainly make out an at- tractive contrast between the seeming un- certainty of the realm of religion and the eternal realm of art and beauty; and you make certain writers upon religion seem very boastful and ridiculous in their ex- pression of a faith that mankind can ever enjoy such rest and satisfaction in relig- jon as the lovers of beauty have felt in the great works of art. May I raise the question whether it is necessary, or true, to make this contrast, and to part company between the lovers of beauty and the lov- ers of religion? Is it not possible that you fail to understand the point which the writers to whom you refer are seeking to make? It may appear that they are near- er to the main drift of your article than you imagine. I can best express what I mean, first, by quoting the remark of a very learned student of religion (one of your own valued contributors), who said in a conversa- tion, “There has been a vast deal of su- perstition tn the world, but so far there has been very little real religion.” It might be added—what every one must agree—that there has been a vast deal of ' discussion about religion, though real re- | gion has always been somewhat rare. | Must we not now say very much the same |with regard to art? We have loads of lerude art in every town; we have art | schools and endless books on art. But the |great masterpieces, giving joy and peace, jare very rare; and yet they are so rea) |that the artistic sense of the world is continually being renewed by the inspira- tion of these few great pictures, statues, temples, or poems. Would you call it very presumptuous, then, if a lover of the beautiful master- | pieces, writing to express his sincere feel- ing about them, ventured his faith, or hope, that the world will come to find more and more permanent satisfaction upon the lines of artistic excellence, al- ready laid by the great artists and poets; that the beautiful things are the simplest; that it is useless to strive and strain after |effect and sensation; that to possess a single object of beauty, yes, if only a flower, and to love and enjoy it, is better than to fill a palace with bric-&-brac; that to hold in memory a few stanzas of the masters of verse is happier than to learn the columns of an encyclopedia? I | can imagine a lover of art saying some- |thing like this, with the intent to call people’s attention from the distracting sight of the commonplace, everywhere set up in the market, to those very things which, you well say, rest and satisfy men’s souls as often as they are seen. Now I suggest, I hope without dogma- tism, that the lover of religion may try to say the very thing about the great, sim- ple, and everlasting values of religion, at its best, which you have said about art. Is it absurd or boastful to urge that the coming man is likely to be free, to an ever-increasing degree, of the haze of su- perstitions that have overclouded the sight of true religion; that he will learn to care more for the painting itself than for any particular style of framing about it; that he will set his heart on the beautiful teach- ings which rise like mountain peaks out of the Scriptures of the world, rather than on the monotonous levels in which these zreat teachings find their base; that even children and the unlearned may catch the meaning of certain splendid psalms and hymns which have always rested the souls | of good men and women; that it will be |held true to the end of time, as Paul |wrote, that “the fruits of the spirit” are \love, joy, peace, courage, patience, and | the rest; and that the image or ideal of | the good life (let them call it the “Christ- | life,” if they please), set up in the shrine jot the simplest man’s heart, is more pre- jelous than big books of dogmatic dis- | cussions about religion? | Now that I have risen to speak, may I be | allowed to add a few words which seem to |me to have importance, as bearing upon the | permanent policy of the Nation? I may be | justified in my interest in the paper, for I | became one of its readers, I think, in 1868. I have highly valued its utterances and have rejoiced often in its vigorous preach- | ing of righteousness. On the other hand, |I am one of a large number of its readers | who have wished that it might more often have added generosity and humanity to its _keen sense of justice and truth. It has | seemed to us to suffer from the prevailing peril of the people of a small sect. Their danger lies in severity, and in failure of
Page 13
Dec. 22, 1910] sympathy toward those who differ in the least from themselves. They behave as if truth were a narrow line, and they alone | were following it. Have you no use for a| host of men whose faces may be honestly turned toward the light. but whose view of various subjects is somewhat different from yours? Of course, you answer, yes, | but you often give the contrary impression. | For example, I have to assume that the | Nation represents a philosophy of optimism, | or at least of meliorism, which is surely a form of optimism. Otherwise, what use| would there be in publishing a journal of | ethical and political reform, if its promot- ers did not believe that truth and righteous- ness are the victorious forces in the world? If the Nation does not stand, upon the whole, for faith in human progress, we have misread all the best things that it has ever published. Why, then, should you seém to show a sort of displeasure, such as would befit your treatment of “the wicked” (if | there were ever any persuasiveness in such | treatment) when you deal with the views of other optimists, and especially more hearty or confident optimists, outside of your own | editorial rooms? | | I should think that you would be pleased | to encourage all the actual friends of your fore asking for additional assistance. Is not | great cause, even though they may not ‘the promotion of efficient business methods | speak with the precise phraseology of your | editorial room. I should think that you bear the expense of mistakes ing manage- | ment. Surely, if the government is willing to put a premium on poor business meth- ods practised by many other favored in- dustries, it ought at least to allow the rail- ways to recoup themselves without going to the trouble of making, with a view to economy; a detailed analysis of their busi- ness and a reform from top to bottom. The people of the country have just given their opinion on the subject of sacrificing the public for the profit of greedy cor- porations. Industries, pleading their in- fancy—i. e., their inefficiency—as justifica- tion for their alleged inability to com- pete with foreign rivals, persuade Con- gress to allow them to dig deeper into the pockets of the consumer for their main- tenance. But the people have begun to show that they perceive the meaning of these unceasing supplications for public bounty. It is not altogether impossible that when all is done it may be found that an in- crease of rates would be permissible; but public interest and public sentiment de- mand that if the railways or any other business enterprise sin against business laws they should repent of their sins be- itself a matter of “vital interest to the/| public”? and would it not certainly “seem would like to try to understand them rath- contrary to the public’s own interest for er than to misunderstand them. deed, I should think it might occur to your own brilliant writers that there may be other tenable forms of faith in human progress, besides that cautious and some- what chilling type which you sometimes af- In- | fect. Or, do you imagine that the men of faith in religion and in the possibilities of civilization, who dwell outside your own | circle, have no eyes to see the great obvious facts of life and death, that they do not measure the inexorable law of cost that rules the world, and that their faith and hope are only a blind necessity of their temperament, and not the result of serious and thoughtful convictions? CHARLES F. DOLE. Jamaica Plain, Mass., December 5, 1910. RAILWAY RATES AND CREDIT. }make it well. jtably a laborious task and that time the government” to promote increases in rates and thereby obstruct the progress of economy and efficiency in business life? D. R. ANDERSON. Richmond, Va., December 17. THE TARIFF BOARD’S REPORT. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The Americans are unquestionably an impatient people. They want work done well, and yet done quickly. The keynote of Professor Emery’s recent speech at Chi- cago was a statement of the fact that we cannot remake our tariff quickly and He states that it is inevi- is essential. The many schedules of the Payne-Aldrich bill were encompassed in five months. This haste and the best methods we had at hand resulted in a bill |which deluded the people, which was un- To THe Epirror or THE NATION: Str: A sentence in the interesting let- ter of Mr. W. D. Hinds (the Nation, Decem- ber 15) struck me with great force. It; reads: “Bearing in mind that the im-| provement of railroad credit is a matter) of vital interest to the public, it would seem contrary to the public’s own interest | for the government to prevent increases in! rates and thereby obstruct the protection of railroad credit, merely because the rail- roads have not yet realized an ideal stand- ard of efficiency far behind that realized by well-managed industries in general.” Indeed, why should the government be more reluctant to bestow large favors upon the railways than it is to bestow them upon other great business corporations? Is it not a cardinal principle of our unwritten Constitution that large interests, regard- less of their mismanagement, should be | fostered by subsidies, protection, and priv- ilege? And the railways are not even ask- ing for subsidy or tariff, but are only re- questing the privilege of making the public }satisfactory to the country, and broke the Republican party. The tariff board was created to put things straight, by a system which after careful investigation should appear to be reliable and efficacious. The chairman of that board now states emphat- ically that such a system is possible, but to make it operative without arduous labor and sufficient time is impossible. There are many business men in this country who have been and are still in favor of a tariff commission, but it is an anomaly that many of these have been under the impression that an immediate |revision of certain schedules is quite prac- ticable. Professor Emery, however, has }made it very clear that this cannot be ex- pected. He has also proved conclusively that a |tariff commission cannot be of real value until! it is a permanent institution. He has with great frankness discussed the pitfalls and dangers, but he just as frankly states that the ultimate result can be only for the general good. 603 The value of the tariff board cannot then be determined until sufficient time is given to demonstrate it. The five months’ actual! work is proof positive that no just tariff rates can be made in that time This therefore upsets the statement that th: existing bill is as good as it should be. It also makes it clear that it is not yet time for revision, and establishes the fact that revision can and should be accomplished “one schedule at a time.” Another most important “finding” is th great value to commercial interests which a well-compiled glossary of the facts would have, aside from the making and recon mendations of rates of duty. This has long been needed in this country, and should prove of inestimable importance The final conclusion is one that stands out boldly. This country needs a _ tariff commission, needs it permanently, and needs the kind of a tariff commission which Professor Emery has 80 ably advocated. Never mind which political party accom- plishes it, let it be accomplished. HENRY T. WILLS, National Tariff Commission Association. New York, December 5. WAS SAMUEL DANIEL AN ITALIAN? To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: In an unpublished record of expen ditures (Public Records Office, Exchequer Accounts, Bd. 433, No. 8) made by Sir David Murray, Keeper of the Privy Purseto Prince Henry, son of James I of England, there oc- curs the following item: “June 14, 1609. To Daniell the Italian 1 li. 108.” Since the record contains numerous similar pay- ments to noor scholars, artists of all kinds and degrees, and in one case to “an Italian jugler,” this item might be passed over as insignificant, were there not evidence of considerable weight to connect it with the poet Daniel. In the same account book, under the date January 3, 1608 (09), there is a payment “To Mr. Daniell be comand [= This undoubtedly refers either to the poet or possibly to his brother, John Daniel, the musician, who was later master of the Queen's choir boys of Bristol; and it may be conjectured that the payment in June was to the same person. The fact that Daniel's brother and perhaps his father were musi- cians is in itself significant, since in the time of James I most of the masters of |that art—Ferrabosco, Bassano, Lupo, and others—were Italians. The name Daniel, jor, as it was usually spelled, Daniell, should |cause no difficulty, for it was borne by the Italian mentioned in the payment, and it | differs but slightly from the Italian forms | Daniele, Danielli, or Daniello. The poet’s close friendship with the Ital- ian John Florio should also be considered. Two of his sonnets written for Florio's |works are addressed “To my dear friend - « « »” and a third to “To my deare friend and brother. -" Daniel possibly owed his pension and his position in the Queen’s court to the influence of the Italian language-master; in the “Accounts of the Queen's Household, 1615-16," his name fol- lows immediately after that :f Florio. The latter, it will be recalled, was the son of a Florentine Protestant who came to England shortly before the reign of Edward VI; one is tempted to explain the friendship of the SIR
Page 14
604 The N ation [Vol. 91, No. 2373 two writers on grounds of family intimacy and kindred race. That Daniel travelled in Italy in his youth is shown by the headings of two sonnets In | the Delia sequence, “At the Author’s going into Italie” (sonnet lili), and “This Sonnet was made at the Author's beeing in Italie” (sennet lili), In Wright’s “Elizabeth and Her Times” (II, 315), we hear of a Samuel Daniel abroad and in the company of an Julio Marino. “A Descrip- translated out of Marino” Works, ed. Grosart, I, 263) can connected with the doctor, since n name was Giambattista, but Italian doctor, tion of Beauty (Daniel's hardly be the pe give Daniel's know! Italian language and his inter His first published " erve to illustrate f the rat lian lite ire d “Impres« was a translation ) tract on crests and seals by the Italian historian Paulus Jo friendship with the poet Guarini ed by following sonnet ad sir Edward Dimmock, Daniel's English translation of the on an 11 Pastor Fido” rejoyce learned and worthy Knight, it by the hand of thy kinde Country-man (Th painfull and Industrious Gentleman) rhy esteem'’d Guarini comes to light: Who I know tooke great delight As thou tn his, who now in England can Speake as good English as Italian, And here enjoyes the grace of his owne right. rhough I remember he hath oft imbas’d Unto us beth the vertues of the North, Saying our costes were with no measures grac’d, barbarous tongues could any vere bring forth I would be sawe bis owne, or knew our store, Whose epirits can yeeld as much, and if not more. deare in thy love N Lines 9-12 of the sonnet refer clearly to eonversations with Guarini, and apparently to a personal friendship. Furthermore, it seems highly improbable that the pronoun thy in the second line would have been used by a poet whe had every reason to consider English translator quite as much his ountryman as Dimmock’s. Here, it is true, the point is weakened by the irrence of our in lines 11 and 13, though the possessive in these cases indi- ates residence rather than citizenship. In general the value of the evidence that Dan- lel. though an Englishmen by allegiance and perhaps by birth, was an Italian by parent- age ist depend chiefly on its cumulative effect We have a payment to an Italian named Daniel from the same source and not long after a payment to the poet. We know latter was of a family of musicians when most professional musicians We know that he travelled in Italy, translated from Italian writers, spoke the language, was on intimate terms with an Italian poet, and that one of his best of the same stock. In the ab- ence of exact Information regarding his birth and parentage, these seem sufficient reasons for assuming that the stylistic puri- “well-languaged” Daniel is that of a English was not strictly ALLAN F. WestTcorr. the own oct that the In an age were Italians friends wa y of writer for whom the mother tongue Columbia University, December 16 WOOL AND SHEEP. To Tue Eprror or Tue NATION: Your Pittsburgh correspondent (the December 8) Is excited over How great the cry! How little the wool! Cannot the American farmer learn to raise sheep and not be a mere wool- >. SIR: Nation, wool ae grower? With sheep prices where they though irrelevant to the purpose of the have been for years, why mention wool at | book, Serve at any rate to enliven. | jall? Merinos, too; and I made many a Me- rino breeder angry because I then said the | fy] in Jessons. tariff was robbery. It enabled the few of us to get a greater price for sheep and wool, but for one of us there were hun- dreds whom we were plundering in the price of clothes. I then sold my Merinos and went to breeding sheep. And I bred them all through the nineties when the fool-killer was at home attending to his own business. I did not call upon the fool- killer, but gave my sheep good care, and excellent profits from them every year. If wool brought ten cents a pound, it clear gain, for good sheep, with proper care, will pay if they do not pro- duce a pound of wool. Sheep-breeders who call for high tariff remind me of those who bred cattle for their hides. Years ago I used to know many who sold their cattle-hides in the spring. That was their harvest, but they made was wanted a tariff on hides, as their cattle | paid nothing. Those farmers who to-day are raising sheep for wool are to be pitied in the same manner as we should pity the farmers who raise cattle for their hides, and hogs for their hair. J. A. BARTHOLOMEW. Naples, N. Y., December 14 Literature se CHANCELLORSVILLE. The Campaign of Chancellorsville: A Strategic and Tactical Study. By John Bigelow, jr. New Haven: Yale Uni- versity Press. $10 net. This work by an experienced soldier, who later became known as the teacher of military science in the Massachu- setts Institute of Technology, and as the author of works on campaigns in Europe and America, is a notable con- tribution to strategic literature. We think that no campaign of our civil war has been more accurately, elaborately, or ably described than is Chancellors- ville in these pages, and soldiers in | | We confess to some surprise at the Now I was once a breeder of sheep, and | auythor’s selection of Chancellorsville as the campaign of the civil war most fruit- He says that he chose it “because it presented a greater vari- ety of military problems and experi- ences than any other in which an army of the United States had taken part. In no other was there so rapid a succession of critical operations. Moreover, no oth- er one approaching it in importance has been so imperfectly apprehended and described.” This assertion will not pass unchallenged. The reasons given for selecting Chancellorsville apply much better, we believe, to Gettysburg. The Gettysburg story bristles with problems over which the authorities continue to dispute. To mention a few: Lee, in- stead of invading Pennsylvania, might better, perhaps, have used his interior lines and reinforced Bragg in east Ten- nessee; then, assuming command him- self, he could have thrown his mass, by forced marches, upon Cincinnati. Such operations in May and June might have caused Grant to let go his grip on Vicks- burg; indeed, a concentration like this of Southern power against the greatly depressed North might have made it possible to penetrate far into Ohio, and to the east from the west. Whether or not Lee erred here is a point not set- tled, the study of which is full of in- struction to the soldier. Did the Con- |federate right delay its attack unduly on July 2 and on July 3 was Pickett’s charge a reckless enterprise? Or had Lee good warrant for his rush at the Federal centre? On the side of the North, should Sickles be condemned for occupying, on July 2, the Emmitsburg road, or is the contrary view to be ac- cepted—held, we believe, by Sheridan and Gen. H. J. Hunt—that the position assigned the Third Corps at first was ‘untenable, and that it was only prudent every land will thank the author for a/| _perhaps the world in general has come technical study so satisfactory. No im- portant detail of the eventful story from Hooker’s assuming command at the end of January, 1863, to the retire- ment of the Army of the Potomac across the Rappahannock at the begin- ning of May, is omitted. The author does not restrict himself severeiy to the military record. Lincoln’s unpleasant quarter of an hour with “Mother,” after submitting himself to be kissed by the ladies at Hooker’s headquarters, led on to occupy the higher ground in advance? Again, as to the ending of the battle, should there have been a_ counter- stroke at once upon the repulsed Con- federates, as Lincoln thought and as to feel, or was Meade wise in not risk- ing further battle? We submit that in comparison with such problems as these the campaign of Chancellorsville offers little indeed. There is almost no difference of opinion as regards any important movement. Hooker taking command of a dispirited army restored promptly its morale and discipline. He struck at an opportune ‘moment when Longstreet had been de- by the Princess Salm-Salm—that, with | the joke through which Lincoln got out of the breakers, has a place in the nar- rative as well as the impact of the can- tached to southeastern Virginia with two divisions. He had two men to Lee’s one, and more. His cavalry served him not in the best manner; but keeping Lee non ball which stretched Hooker sense- in doubt as to his plans by good ma- less on the porch of the Chancellor house. Such occasional | neuvres, he succeeded in crossing the particulars, | Rappahannock and placing his army in
Page 15
Dec. 22, 1910] The Nation 605 excellent position on Lee's left flank. So | far his work was admirable. Now, how- ever, he forsook his fine initiative, and, | while his lieutenants stood amazed and protesting, retired to a position much | inferior where he awaited attack. Lee) was not slow to seize the offensive which Hooker had abandoned. Leaving a strong detachment to guard Fredericks- burg, Lee pressed close upon the retir- ing Federals. He weighed correctly Hooker’s incapacity, and with extraor- dinary audacity dispatched still another detachment, this time of half the force that remained to him, under Stonewall Jackson, to march across the front of the Federal army and turn the right. The movement was no secret; the march was plain to the Federals, but utterly misinterpreted. Hooker, with his vast preponderance, watched the advancing column, making only futile efforts to harass its progress, and awaking to his danger only at sunset, when the crush- ing blow fell upon the Eleventh Corps. His right was destroyed, but he still stood, more than two to one, compactly arrayed, close at hand to Lee’s army, now divided into three well-separated fragments. But Hooker’s efforts were more futile than ever. Two splendid corps, under Reynolds and Meade, prob- ably his best subordinates, were scarce- ly employed at all: the corps that fought were misdirected. Sedgwick, advancing from the east, stormed Marye’s Heights, and tried hard at Salem Church to fall on the Confederate rear. While his tac- tices may have been sometimes faulty, his promptness and resolution were in general admirable. But Hooker, out of his huddled thousands, sent him no help, though Lee from his handful strengthened the opposing line abun- dantly. A contusion quite disabled Hook- er for a time, and perhaps affected his powers until the close of the battle. But there was no transference of command. | The Army of the Potomac virtually had no head. To a large extent his corps had not been engaged. It was flung back in deep humiliation across the river which it had so proudly pass- ed, and occupied its old camps with a bitter sense of complete and quite un- necessary failure. Such are the main features of the story of Chancellorsville, a story, we believe, universally accept- ed. Scarcely one of the points mention- ed is in controversy; nor does Major Bigelow in his narrative present any point in a different way. So far from abounding in problems and situations in controversy, the case as to all the main incidents is remarkably clear. With Major Bigelow’s treatment of his theme, after once selecting it, we have almost no fault to find. The presenta- tion is always clear, the maps numerous and careful. To note a small thing, we think undue liberty is sometimes taken in spelling proper names. The author speaks of the difficulty here: he has to do with a large number of unimportant localities and humble individuals whose names in an unlettered country are often of most uncertain orthography. In the effort for correctness he sometimes goes too far. For instance, one of the most important points on the Chancellorsville terrain is “Tally’s,” a farm with a log cabin, where Stonewall Jackson first struck the Federal right. In the text this name always appears as “Taylor's”; so also in the maps, although here “Tally” is given in parenthesis after “Taylor's.” Heretofore the locality has always had the name “Tally’s.” It was so known on the battle-day and has been since. In 1904, the present writer vis- ited the spot, enjoying a talk with old “Tally,” a patriarchal figure who had interesting things to say about the bear- ing of Stonewall Jackson. The farmer walked at Jackson's stirrup as his guide, |while the last dispositions were made for the attack. We have insisted that in dealing with Chancellorsville the student has very plain sailing. Among the few things that are debatable perhaps no one is more interesting than why Hooker be- haved as he did. Our author cites here some graphic testimony. Two months later Doubleday, Hooker's close friend, said: “Hooker, what was the matter with you at Chancellorsville? Some say you were injured by a shell, some say you were drunk. How was it?” Hooker answered good-naturedly: “Doubleday, I was not hurt by a shell and I was not drunk. I lost confidence in Hooker, and that is all there is to it.” Major Bigelow appears to adopt this explanation: Hooker failed through irresolution, which, of course, springs from a lack of confidence. Probably the explanation is correct; but there will always be a sus- picion that Hooker’s well-known drink- ing habit affected him here. Couch and others, who were in close contact with him, declare that he took no liquor, but there may be something in the allega- tion, mentioned by Bigelow but not en- dorsed, that abstinence from his custo- mary draughts left him not at his best when his faculties should have been most alert. We feel like saying a word on the ideas prevalent as regards the vast lit- erature of the civil war. In the gener- al mind it is becoming classed under three heads. There are, first, the offi- cial records, which are coming to be held as the Bible, so to speak, infallible, or at any rate possessing a trustworthi- ness approaching perfection. Then we have an Apocrypha, containing the less formal documents of the great leaders’ autobiographies, memoirs, and such pa- pers as have been gathered in the “Bat- tles and Leaders of the Civil War,” doc- uments less valuable than the canon, to be followed with caution, and yet in- structive. Lastly, we have the multl- farious Profane Literature, the accounts of humble participants, and obscure ob- servers and commentators, which, though often interesting, are of worth far inferior, and not to be taken as sources of truth without careful scrut- iny. To men inclined to take this view, the exclamation of that good soldier, zen, George H. Gordon, in one of his books, ought to be disturbing: “God help the history that is based on official records!” He was outraged at the re- port of his corps commander. In the records themselves one may find a state. ment of Graham, a brigadier of the Third Corps, denouncing as utter false- hood the report of one of his colonels as to the achievements of his “Zouaves” on a certain field. These out of many. The fact is that many things conspire to make an official report constrained and formal. There is the natural desire of every man to put the best face on things for himself as he sets his case before the government and the world: subordi- nates must be let off leniently; you must live with them, and it impairs comfort to have them sullen. To make a statement unpleasant to a superior might be construed as insubordina- tion. The public welfare makes it im- perative to tell a flattering tale. The temptation is constant to tell not quite the whole truth and nothing but the truth. There are important sup- pressions of fact in the official records, none more so, perhaps, than as regards Chancellorsville. Hooker’s report was never published; our author says “he never made it.” Still more: other re- ports were held back till Hooker should speak, among them so capital a piece of testimony as ‘that of Carl Schurz; for what this admirably qualified witness saw and felt at Chancellorsville we must go, not to the official records, but to Carl Schurz’s “Reminiscences.” Indeed, it is the case that the roar of many a catastrophe becomes in the official rec ords as mild as the piping of a sucking dove. We should be sorry to be thought to minimize unduly the value of the offi- cial records. Unquestionably they form by far the most important body of evi- dence as to the period, but they require constantly to be checked and supple- mented by other evidence. The memoirs of the leaders, written in after years, though they must be read with discrim- ination, are most informing. The com- pendium known as the “Battles and Leaders of the Civil War” is declared by Henderson, the best English critic of the struggle, to be “one of the most im- portant military authorities ever pub- lished”; nor will the student enter fully into the crush and agony of the time who neglects such stories as that of Haskell, who, as an aide of Gibbon, was in the heart of things at Gettysburg, or the diary of the humble “war clerk” at Richmond, or that of Mrs. Chesnut, kept amid the wreck of a Southern home. It
Page 16
606 is worth while to say thus much as to the weight properly due to the various classes of evidence relating to our civil var, because men here sometimes judge wrongly. We think that so great an his- torlan as Rhodes falls to some extent into error, and we observe signs in this book that Major Bigelow is not entirely Speaking in his preface of his sources, our author has much to say of value of the official records, and very little as to testimony of any other kind. We are bound, however, to declare that in the citations in the text is no neglect of testimony of any kind. The home-letters of the rank and file, newspaper waifs, the gossip of camps and cities, are utilized judicious- ly to throw light. Altogether, Major Bigelow’s book is masterly. We know of no more satisfac- tory scientific treatment of a military topic by any American writer. Shall we be thought trifling if we say that the book, while very handsome, is also very heavy? It weighs nearly five pounds and is nearly a foot square. Says Major Bigelow: “Whoever expects to follow a campaign reclining in an easy-chair, with a book in one hand and a cigar in the other, is doomed to disappointment.” We should say so. Some of our young soldiers are said to need exercise, and it will perhaps be a good thing If, while perfecting themselves in their art, free. the high there they can at the same time enjoy a stren- | but what of the dis-| uous gymnastic; comfort of the old-timers during the many hours necessary to a proper pe- rusal? CURRENT FICTION. Just Folks. By Clara &. New York: The Macmillan Co. The heroine of this modern story of Chicago is a “tiny sprite of a fair-hair- ed girl,” a probation officer of the Ju-! Called by the children “de p'leece lady,” she resolves to level all barriers that might separate her from them, and we first meet her half- wistfully renouncing a residence in Hull House. The privileges of that “splen- did inetitution” she meant to turn to her advantage and that of her boys and girls, but she elected to avoid the stig- ma of any appearance of “professional benevolence” by Hving In the most mod. est of rooms in the most modest of streets, and by turning her back on the luxury of even a settlement dwelling. The book naturally is a document of the most personal social service among “the other half,” carried on under en- lightened modern conditions. That any new theorfes are advanced is not to be said. But the book gives an account of the slums and the slum-dwellers, from the point of view of an equal, one might say, were it not rather as from that of an inferior, treating of her betters. The her Irish, her Rus >. venile Court. writer understand The Nation [ Vol. 91, No. 2373 sian, her Pole. She puts her characters through diverse paces of shiftlessness, misdemeanor, fidelity, heroism. Her heroine faces difficulties ranging from the recovery of pawned clothes to the tracing of traffickers in white slaves. She is full of tenderness and good sense, and only temporarily is tempted to defy the law in behalf of her stray lambs. The “awkward Samaritanism” of the rich is her reddest rag, and she does not always escape on her own part senti- mentality for the poor. But hers is a clear ray shed upon dark questions, and her story a modest lesson in unaffected brotherhood. The Vicar of the Marches. By Clinton Scollard. Boston: Sherman, French & Co. For those who like to hasten with an autobiographical hero through a series of hearty adventures, tinged with hate ' troduced several dialects, including an ‘alliance of German, Cockney, and Ital- ‘ian. Perhaps the realest thing in the ‘book is a burlesqued Ellis Island scene, in which the faithful M’riar, an amus- ing specimen of the familiar “slavey” |type, figures with distinction. The Purchase Price. By Emerson Hough. Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Com- pany. In “The Purchase Price” Mr. Hough has given a glimpse of the troubled _days of the Missouri Compromise. Poli- tics and history are freely discussed and treated with attention to detail. The dominating character is that of a beau- tiful Hungarian countess, an emissary of Kossuth, who puts her heart and for- _tune into the abolitionist cause. Her influence is so great that the authori- ties at Washington have her quietly kid- napped. Here the love story begins, and Laughlin. | and vengeance, and colored with love,|it proves to be an exciting one, though Tiso di Camposanpiero will make a/not before Josephine St. Auban has lost welcome companion; his struggles | her fortune, and, like many pioneers of against the fell power of Ezzilino da | reform, has been badly treated by those Romano, “well christened by some,” as she tried to help. Tiso himself says, “Ezzilino the Devil,”| Aside from the romance, the book are both valiant and plentiful. Indeed,/should be of interest to those who are Mr. Scollard has written a story thor-|not wholly familiar with that period of oughly impregnated with the spirit of|our history, in which conflicting Fed- the rough times of the old Italian city- |eral and State laws complicated the is- states, when Guelph and Ghibelline were sue between the advocates and oppo- at each other’s throats, and feud and nents of slavery. “As neither of the rapine were rife in the land. If the oc-| great parties of the day filled its ranks ‘easional clank of machinery makes a | from either section,” says Mr. Hough, ‘jarring note in the story, and if we find “so in both sections, there were many both hero and villain even more prodigi- | who espoused, as many denied, the right ‘ous in their respective qualities than is |of men to own slaves. We speak of slav- usual in tales of the type, “The Vicar|ery as the one great question of that ‘of the Marches” is, none the less, good day. It was not and never has been reading enough, and the spirit of old the greatest. The question of democracy romance is softened here and there by a |—that was even then, and it is now, the poetic note, the echo of its author's fa-| greatest question.” The book has re- miliar verse. ‘ceived a dress worthy of the theme. The Old Flute-Player. By Edward Mar- | The Blue Arch. By Alice Duer Miller. shall and Charles Dazey. New York:| New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. G. W. Dillingham Co. “Most women are loved for something A wealthy American woman suspects they give a man, for the relation, not her companion, a well-bred young Ger-| for themselves. But you will be loved man girl, of stealing a diamond ring. for what you are, for yourself, like some She hastens with the accusation to the| stupendous natural beauty. .. . Wo- girl’s father, an impecunious musician. men who are loved like that are not He, instantly taking his daughter's guilt easily forgotten.” Such is the distinc- for granted, assumes the responsibility |tion of Nina Sinnott, who, besides, is for the crime. The daughter arrives in| an engaging blend of ingenue and sa- the nick of time to prove her innocence | yante. She graduates from college with —the ring has been given her by her/an astronomical bent, and pursues her employer’s son, to whom she is engaged. ‘vocation in the face of family opposi- The implacable mother will consent to tion and dismay. As a crotchety as- the match only on condition that the! tronomer’s secretary in a mountain ob- ishabby musician shall not attempt to|servatory, and later as teacher in a col- daughter again. Everybody lege, she achieves gratifying successes; breathe hard! The musician, by docu-| but being, by her innocence and invol- mentary evidence, proves himself | untary seductiveness, quite unfitted to “Count Otto von Lichtenstahl.” Down cope with the insidious dangers of an falls mamma at his feet and entreats his | academic community, she is caught in danghter’s hand for her son. ithe toils of a faculty scandal. There- To make the presence of humor more;upon the crotchety astronomer turns than doubly sure, the author has in-;}human enough to extricate and marry see his
Page 17
Dec. 22, 1910] The Nation forcing his love upon her. He had mere- | ly permitted her to carry him his lunch- | eon, and to stay up nights recording his observations. The atmosphere of the whole book is rather thin and cold and dry. One is oppressed by a sense of restricting con- ventions, and the danger of lapsing from a great height. It is difficult to be- lieve that beings of real flesh and blood could keep alive, much less make love in it. Some of the subordinate char- acters, especially a likable flirtatious sister of Nina’s, are graceful and dis- tinct, but they have all to be sternly re- pressed in order to vindicate the at- tractiveness of a very special type of in- tellectual femininity. Edward and I and Mrs. Honeybun. By Kate Horn. New York: Brentano’s. The pastoral adventures of Lord Ed- ward Estcourt, second son of the Mar- quis of Adair and of his child-wife Ga- brielle: how they endured poverty for a season at King’s Chevral, a small property on the Suffolk Broads; how they were there subject to the heavy- handed ministrations of a single ser- vant, Mrs. Honeybun; how, for a period, they were delivered from her by one Seth Cattermole, agriculturalist; how, in a dark hour of misfortune and finan- | cial stress, Mrs. Honeybun returned upon them in her true character—a blessing well disguised; how in due time, by the discovery of a hidden legacy, they were restored to happiness and abundance. There is a delightful incongruity in pretending to introduce such exquisites as “Edward and I” to “the sordid miser- les of poverty” and in picturing them involved in the complexities of the sim- ple life. The sweet fragility of a Ga- brielle was clearly never intended for rough uses; nor was Edward designed for endurance. The story is told in a whimsically artificial wording, graceful, decorous, a little stilted, like the pose of the Chelsea shepherdess on Aunt Sabitha’s book-shelf, and leaves the reader with a charming impression of the idyllic, at once naive and anti- quated. TYPES OF UNIVERSITIES. Great American Universities. By Edwin E. Slosson. New York: The Macmil- lan Co. $2.50 net. Mr. Slosson has rendered a valuable service to that large proportion of the general public, with or without a tinc- ture of letters, which is mainly depen- dent upon intercollegiate athletes for its ideas of the characteristics of our leading educational institutions. He has spent a week—not an afternoon on the “bleachers”—at each of the four- teen universities ranked by their an- nual expenditure for instruction at the | likes to call “dynamic” qualities. her. He had never made the mistake of ‘head of the list prepared by the Car. | negie Foundation: Columbia, Harvard, Chicago, Michigan, Yale, Cornell, I)- linois, Wisconsin, Penr*ylvania, Califor- nia, Stanford, Princeton, Minnesota, and Johns Hopkins. The record of his brief sojourns makes without padding a vol- ume of over five hundred pages. It is no exaggeration to say that he presents a more distinct and many-sided view of every institution considered than many an old graduate could give of his own alma mater. The amount of solid infor- mation that he conveys along with his personal impressions is surprising. He has had an eye to the picturesque aspects of undergraduate life. He has meditated on the mysteries of univer- sity architecture. He has listened to the significant gossip of students and faculty. But he has also invaded the offices of registrars and presidents and presidents’ secretaries; has visited class- rooms and laboratories; has studied cat- alogues and university annals. He pre- sents his facts in the effective form of graphs and diagrams, and he relieves the burden of the tale by the help of a dry humor and copious illustrations. He has, furthermore, ideas enough about administration, education, and research to set up a college president. The book |is therefore no mere piece of superficial impressionism; it has what Mr. Slosson In or- der to appreciate its virtues it is neces- sary to understand that its author is lit- erary editor of The Independent, that | he is from Kansas, and that he is an ex-chemist. As a journalist he urges the univers!l-| ties to keep in touch with the modern world. He thinks the humanistic breth- ren are somewhat slow in availing themselves of mechanical appliances such as the stereopticon, the phonograph, and moving pictures to relieve the mo- notony of their lectures. He is struck by the inability of many of the univer- sities to maintain literary magazines and literary interests among the under- graduates. Perhaps his boldest sugges- tion relates to the doctor’s thesis in English literature. It touches, at any rate, upon the sterilizing influence of much of our “higher” English study. Mr. Slosson cannot understand why doc- tors’ theses in English should be limited to linguistics or literary history. Argu- ing from analogy with other profession- al degrees he says: It seems to me that it would be only fair to require of every candidate for Ph.D. in English literature the writing of a success- ful novel, a volume of good essays, a poem of distinct merit, an acceptable play, or some contribution to belles-lettres that will meet with the approval of the judicious if not of the public. That is, if liter- ature is a science, it should require orig- contributions to knowledge like the If it is an art, it should re If it inal other sciences. quire craftsmanship like the other arts. it partakes of the character of both, 607 should meet both requirements instead of dodging both by keeping between. As a western man, Mr. modernist, an ardent progressive, and a believer in “the people.” He feels heart- ily in sympathy with the dominant ideals of the State universities—their industry, their democracy, their indus- trial and professional education, their immediate service to the common- wealth. He experiences no academic languor in the presence of milk tests, cement tests, soil analysis, scientific cookery, and pottery. These things seem to him as legitimate curriculum material as rhyme tests, style analysis, and poetry. For he recognizes, in short, as few Eastern bred men are able to do, the “utilitarian idealism’’—please accentuate “idealism’’—of Martha, busy about many things. Mr. Slosson, as we have said, is, like Mr. Eliot, an ex-chemist, and his scien- tific proclivities reénforce his Western modernism and progressivism. He fail- ed to catch the enthusiasm when they talked to him at Yale about their tradi- tions. For traditions as such he ob- viously does not care a snap of the fing- ers. On the contrary, that a thing is an innovation appears to him decidedly in its favor. If it is not an improvement, it is at least an experimcnt; and the experimental temper indicates that a man is looking where the West looks, where science looks—into the future. Like Mill, he believes it is important “to give the freest scope possible to un- customary things, in order that it may in time appear which of these are fit to be considered customs.” Not disposed, as some renowned educators are, to fix his eyes upon the peerless perfections of a single institution, he deplores the imitativeness of the universities, wish- es them to specialize, and differentiate themselves as much as possible—each one to work upon an original plan of educational salvation. Mr. Slosson takes what we may call the university point of view as distin- guished from what he calls the point of view of the “old-fashioned college.” He has the open mind, the catholic taste, ari the optimism of the younger gen- eration which believes in everything. It is interesting to compare with this spir- it, the diagnosis of the present educa- tional situation recently made by an English journalist, Mr. Chesterton. The one thing from which we are all shrink- ing to-day, says Mr. Chesterton, is that “ancestral responsibility to which our fathers committed us when they took the wild step of becoming men. I mean the responsibility of affirming the truth of our human tradition and handing it on with a voice of authority, an unshak- en voice. That is the one eternal edu- cation: to be sure enough that some- thing is true that you dare to tell it to a child. From this high audacious duty the moderns are fleeing on every side; Slosson is a
Page 18
608 The Nation [Vol. 91, No. 2373 and the only excuse for them is (of course), that their modern philosophies are so half-baked and hypothetical that they cannot convince themselves enough to convince even a newborn babe.” Intimate Society Letters of the Bigh- teenth Century. Edited by the Duke of Argyll, K.T. With Portraits, Fac- and Other Illustrations. In Stanley Paul similes, two volume London: & Co There is nothing that to revive the past as a body of old let- when these are artless, emeditated epistles, free from ev- of literary self-consciousness, from no other inspiration affection, interest, the of affairs, or the mere love of gossip and the need of human inter- Then no subject, no turn of ex- pression, is taboo, and the reader has all the advantage of the eavesdropper without any of the sensations of shame and guilt. To be sure, it requires to some extent a special imaginative and historical faculty to extract from such letters all they have to yield. This is the principal difficulty for the general reader in the present work. It consists largely of letters written by men and women who, if not unknown to history, are quite unknown to literature. These not infrequently display small literary aptitude. Hence there is much iu the two bulky volumes that will ap- peal only to those who are accustomed to the study of contemporary documents and the dry task of separating the grain of wheat from the mass of unremunera- tive chaff. The opening series of letters addressed by John, second Duke of Argyll, to Queen Anne, and to Lord Godolphin, on the subject of the union of England and Scotland are occupied exclusively with political affairs and of- ficial business, and are scarcely related to the plan and scope of the work as indicated by its title. The same is true in a measure of the next series of ““Docu- ments relating to the Jacobite Wars in 1716 and 1745,” though they contain some interesting particulars of military movements in the Highlands during those exciting and romantic years. A chapter of “Domestic Documents,” In- cluding accounts which show “the cost of living” at Holyrood Abbey, a part of which was regularly occupied by the Dukes of Argyll, comes closer to answer- ing the reader's expectations. By far the greatest number of letters in the first volume are those written either by, or to, Elizabeth, Duchess of Hamilton and Argyll, who, of course, was one of the beautiful Gunning els- ters, and who married successively the Duke of Hamilton and the Duke of Argyll, having two sons by each mar- riage. As all of these, in turn, succeed- ed to their family estates, she was call-| a serves so well ters, especially unp! ery trace and springing that of than urgency course 1 ed “the wife of two Dukes and the moth-| er of four.” The lady's letters show the) intelligence and force of character for | which she is remembered almost as| much as for her beauty. But for a real-| ly human note, one must turn to the let- ters which open the second volume, and which were written to the Duchess by Dr. Moore, father of the “hero of Corunna,” concerning her younger son by her first marriage, Douglas, Duke of Hamilton. This rather shallow and in- dolent young man was engaged in mak- ing the customary European grand tour with the learned and serious doctor as his preceptor and companion, and it was part of the latter’s duty to make pe- riodic reports upon the progress and physical and moral health of the fledg- ling peer. The relations between the two are not without their side of uncon- scious humor, especially when the Duke, breaking bounds, allies himself with sev- eral young English officers, and accom- panies them to Magdebourg, giving his mentor the slip, and leaving him to write an uneasy but guarded account of the escapade to the truant’s mother. The poor doctor’s patience must, indeed, often have been sorely tried, and one feels that it was only a trace of obse- quiousness towards the rank of his noble patrons, coupled with a prudent desire | to conserve the good will of so in- fluential a family, that kept him from) throwing up his job or at least making | a much more candid report of his charge’s character and shortcomings than any which he sends the Duchess. | ‘life in the eighteenth century. Here, at least, there is a real side-light upon society in the eighteenth century, though it is scarcely a novel one. all events, it is pleasant to know that Dr. Moore received his reward for his | fidelity, even though this was not entire-| ly disinterested or unmixed with what) we should to-day call “snobbishness.” It was through the Duchess of Hamilton and Argyll that his son received that commission in the Fifty-second Regi- ment which opened the way to his brilliant military career. As it was that Wolfe also received his commis- sion, it should seem as if Engiand owed much to this beautiful Elizabeth Gun- ning, who was herself daughter of a soldier. European experiences of another sort were the lot of Lord John Campbell, who toured the Continent, in 1803, and who barely escaped arrest at the orders of Napoleon by crossing the Swiss fron-| tier, dressed as a woman. He had pre-| viously met the First Consul, of whom | he gives two interesting descriptions in | a letter to the Marquis of Lorne. It must have been the fresh and un- spoiled simplicity of the young Bri- ton that fascinated Mme. de Staél. Not the least interesting letters in ‘the collection are those which that lady wrote him from Coppet, where he At) |everything.” and a friend named Robinson had vis- ited her. With much ardor she ex- presses her desolation at their departure, and her desire to see them again. “There is that in your character and in the spirit of both of you,” she writes, “a kind of charm which makes me feel a perfect happiness, and I do not know what one would not do to rejoin those who have the magic taient of making one feel happy.” Doubtless what really speaks in these effusive epistles is the active boredom of the brilliant woman -cooped up in her provincial chateau, and kept by her tyrant from returnirg to that Paris where alone she felt it pos- sible to live. The bulk of the books is rather gra- tuitously increased by the appending of English translations to the French orig- inals of these letters and of those from Saussure, son of the great Swiss nat- uralist, who was another of Lord John’s Continental acquaintances. Also the work as a whole would have profited if it had been shortened by half. Some of the letters, though of slight intrinsic in- terest or importance, were naturally re- tained because of the fame of the writ- ers—William Pitt, George Washington, /Samuel Johnson, Rob Roy, and others. But there are groups where it would have been wiser to make a representa- tive selection. That the editor did not do this is due in part, perhaps, to a par- donable pride in the family archives of the Campbells, Dukes of Argyll, and a desire to reveal their wonderful rich- ness for the documentation of social Louise Chandler Moulton, Poet and Friend. By Lilian Whiting. Boston: Little, Brown, & Co. $1.50. This is the life of a very feminine and sympathetic woman of talent by an extremely sympathetic and some- what irritatingly feminine biographer. _Mrs. Moulton was a writer of stories ‘for children, literary correspondent, and |reviewer for several journals, and a through the influence of the same lady | minor poet of slender compass but with an interesting personal and lyrical note. |She had the temperament that craves and wins love, friendship, and admira- tion, and she repaid all her creditors with a bountiful hand. “In criticism,” she says, “I made up my mind, long ago, that one should be like Swedenborg’s an- gels, who sought to find the good in The fruit of this angelic spirit in criticism may be suggested by the fact that at her death her library included about six hundred autographed volumes, of which not more than a fifth, according to Prof. Arlo Bates, contained “well-known names.” Born in 1835, Mrs. Moulton was a critic and author by the time of the civil war, and she con- tinued to write and make friends with writers, both in America and in BEng- land, till 1908. Her list of literary ac-
Page 19
Dec. 22, 1910] The Nation quaintances begins with the Boston and | Cambridge group of Holmes, Whittier, Longfellow, Alcott, and Lowell, and ex- tends to John Davidson, A. C. Benson, and William Watson. There was material here for some- thing more than a memoir of a coterie or a parish, but the possibilities have not been realized. The biographer sets out in this lofty and alarming strain: Genius, love, and friendship make up a triple dower which holds within itself the possibilities of high destiny. Their chang- ing combinations comprise all intensities of human joy and human sorrow: the richness of sympathetic companionship; the en- chantments of romance; the glow and pas- sion of artistic achievement. . After such an overture one relinquishes hope of any distinct presentation of Mrs. Moulton’s character or appraisal of her poetical accomplishment. Between her and the reader there has been in- troduced the veiling enthusiasm of an admirer without a particle of humor, critical discrimination, or feeling for lit- terary perspective. The result is the more distressing for the reason that humor and a sense for perspective are not prominent qualities either in the specimens of Mrs. Moulton’s letters and journals here displayed or in the abun- dant extracts from the letters of her appreciative friends. As solemnly as if appealing to the highest tribunal, Lilian Whiting quotes Mrs. Spofford’s verdict on Mrs. Moulton’s last volume of poems: “‘At the Wind’s Will,’” says Mrs. Spofford, “fitly crowns the literary achievement of the century. . Her work exhibited in previous volumes has given her a rank among the foremost poets of the world.” The labor expend- ed by the biographer in accumulating testimonials of this nature is only equal- led by her industry in setting forth the “brilliant” dinners, receptions, evenings- at-home, etc., at which Mrs. Moulton was present, together with a list of the other “brilliant” guests, checked off with comment suitable to the “Society” column of a daily newspaper. The point of view is parochial. Notes Smith, Elder & Co. are preparing for publication early next year a supplement to the Dictionary of National Biography which will include names of persons who have died in the interval between the death of Queen Victoria, January 22, 1901, and the close of 1910. Suggestions are invited by the editor, Sidney Lee, which may be sent in the care of the publishers. The opening article in the Annales de Gé- ographie directs attention to the work of the hydrologic service of the United States Geological Survey. It is stated that through its long-continued and widely ex- tended observations it has contributed more than any other similar service to the so- lution of the great problems of erosion and ‘that his chance of success was 1-52. continental denudation which Hie at the base of physical geography. A detailed ac- count, illustrated by reproductions of pho- tographs, is given of the sixth geographical excursion of the French university students made last June, during which the western Alps were studied. The “List of Books Printed in the Fif- teenth Century in the John Carter Brown Library and the General Library of Brown University,” which originally appeared as an appendix to A. W. Pollard’s “Catalogue of the Rush C. Hawkins Collection,” has been issued in separate form, with two plates not in the previous publication. These show the front and back covers of a bind- ing which is signed “illigatus in Gyslingen 1470 per me Richenbach.” There is a short account of the work of Johannes Richen- bach of Gieslingen, who was probably the most widely known bookbinder of the fif- teenth century, in the Zentralblatt fiir Bibliothekawesen for last September, by Seymour de Ricci of Paris. M. de Ricci describes seven surviving bindings signed by Richenbach in European collections, and notes the sale at auction of three more, the present location of which he has not traced. The John Carter Brown example makes the eleventh recorded. In his “Hidden Signatures of Francesco Colonna and Francis Bacon” (Boston: W. A. Butterfield) W. 8S. Booth devotes about half of his book to the subject of his title, and the rest to other forms of Baconian “evidence.” For the attacks made on his previous acrostics in Shakespeare's Folio he can find no better refutation than ridi- cule. In his present argument he relies mainly on a single acrostic signature, simi- lar in principle to his former ones, but complicated by the presence of certain nu- merical properties relating to the date of the play, etc. In working out these nu- merical properties the author has used figures at will to suit his own aims; and that he should gain such results by such methods is not surprising. We have found numerical combinations almost as astonish- ing in the first book which came to hand. And the explanation of our method Is also the explanation of Mr. Buoth’s. Had we for- mulated what we were looking for before- hand, our chances of finding it would have been very small; but we were not looking for a set formula, but simply for any striking combination. Mr. Booth was not looking for a signature Baconicsicnarf, but for any one of his many combinations which would work out, and his chance of finding such a signature is not his chance of finding Baconicsicnarf (as he erroneously assumes) but his chance of finding any one of a great number of combinations. All Mr. Booth’s mathematical reasoning is wrong because he ignores a very fundamental principle; that the chances of having anything occur are given by a fraction, having all possible chances as its denominator and ail possible favorable chances as its numerator. For in- stance, a man’s chance of drawing any one particular card in a pack of 52 would be 1-52; but his chances of drawing a heart would be 13-52. Now suppose that a man before drawing should be satisfied with any heart, but that after drawing he decided that the heart actually drawn was the only | one he wanted. His real chance of success would be 13-62 or %; but he would say This 609 represents Mr. Booth’s position exactly, and shows why he can prove things impossible by mathematics when other men have proved them possible in practice. He says that there is one chance in eighteen of finding a capital B beginning the first line in the Folio. But a capital F, I, M, 0, 8, N, or T would have offered him just as favorable a chance, for each of these letters occurs at one end of some of his acrostics, and each could have been justified later by some different juggling of his hints and numerals. Moreover, the position held by the M of Mast. would be just as significant as that held by the B of Boteswaine, had it worked out. Wé have then eight possible letters and two possible positions for each; and the chance of getting started is not 1-18, but nearly 16-18, or almost certainty. As for the rest of the book, Mr. Booth's literary scholarship seems of a piece with his mathematics. The fact that Bacon could write a sonnet in an age when son- netteering was a fad is no proof that he could write Hamlet’s soliloquy; nor does the fact that he showed some admiration for poetry prove that he could write “The Tempest,” for on that basis all cultivated men would be Shakespeares, Neither are we greatly impressed when the author sets his own unsupported literary judgment above that of Spedding. When Spedding said that a few lines of Bacon's best verse were al- most equal to Dryden's, he did not mean that it was quite equal to Shakespeare's. These books on the Baconian theory are like the desert, tedious to travel through and useless to mankind. In “The Historic Episcopate” (Philadel- phia: The Westminster Press), Dr. Robert Ellis Thompson, favorably known by his history of American Presbyterianism and by his interest in church unity, has given an admirable introduction to the main question at issue between Pre sbyterianism and the Episcopacy. Firmly believing that the way can be cleared for the reunion of Christendom only by a reéxamination of the historical grounds for the theory of the “divine right of the historic episco- pate” and “of an Apostolical Succession of manually consecrated bishops the necessary channel of grace in the Christian church,” he devotes himself to the study of the matter historically in the hope of contributing to a consensus of opinion. He concludes that the theory mentioned has no warrant in the Scriptures, as Jerome testifies, or in the earlier Christian lit- erature; for the writers of the second cen- tury, Ignatius and “Ireneus” (so the name ie consistently spelled) excepted, are “The Presbyterian Fathers,” as the title of the second chapter significantly suggests. Dr. Thompson has difficulty in accepting the Ignatian Epistles as authentic, and is con- vinced that the monarchic bishop therein presupposed is not the diocesan bishop of modern times, but the pastor of an urban church whose members constitute a single congregation. He does not allude to the suggestion of Harnack in his treatment of Third John (1897), that Diotrephes is the first monarchical bishop whose name we know. Of Irenmus, the writer is also suspicious, at least of his reference to the establishment of a monarchic epis- copacy in Rome. He thinks, however, that the estimable Bishop of Lyens was too wise to commit himself to the theory as
Page 20
610 that John set up a monarchic bishop in| themselves thoroughly w Not in the New Testament, not ig the copious bibliographical references the field. The plea for a more effective min- Ephesus [Vol. 91, No. 2373 The Nation ith the subject, In the second century really, but in Cyp- jin the margin, for authority and further rian is to be found the conception of the/|{nformation on the topics briefly handled church ‘a which alone, and the Holy Spirit confers grace upon men,"’ and the other conception “of the succession of those bishops to the authori- ty and functions of the Apostles.” conceptions, leading to papacy, were ‘“‘elab- rated from age to age by the later fath- ers,”’ In spite of Jerome, by the “Roman- ist Canonists since 1570, and the Anglican Dr. Thompson closes with “Are these to remain the permanent obstacle to a reunion of our Protestant alone, — polemics since 15 the question: Christendom?” r Moss, who is his own publisher Didsbury, England, rhe Fifth Book of Pilgrim- 1 He It is an agreeable genealogy, archwology, and gen- mostly referring to Wales and where Fletch t ld Parsonage, rine Naworth Castle, transcribe Lanercost Pri- Roman Wall are typical volume con- than halftone ; greatest find Its the actual made his A sceptic the book the point time to some accounts, the Carlisle, Stokesay, tie to large octavo two hundred Caractacus Romans In fact, esting as giving almost extinct Whoever tea amiable and al ant iy , rec p ior ed of idios quaries roadside yocracy three or according boiling na teacup put of sugar, o the sugar pour ewed tea, enough to cover sugar Fill up with sweet from the fresh milk nd be thankful lumps of punting for popular taste ck's “The Andes th eived a scant welcom and ich rec 1907, now the read ym geographical critics in has fourth p bile meet to edition, to that likes iutiful Andes; the giving Andes: the Perhaps into it fa terrible death- reason the “The be the Hf Andes!" been so popular in England tis on of its attitude toward the United In speaking of the Monroe Doc- which Mr. Enock inclined to he remarks: ‘Unfortunately ind administrative Amer! ire not the One one Is methods such as to of is anes elr taking up position thing with on the sooner closer Ir association nm the r capaci- de- (imported by the will the :iministration be est edition than olored the omitted, but the charming front- of the in a cheaper form plates and map it distinguished author ra tained Otherwise there is no edition of “The In- United States,” by of Wellesley Col- issued by merit of this familiarize vised of the Coman shed particular hing t in 1905. Is wis 0 a visible corporation, within | jn the text. through whose bishops brought so closely up to date as to in- These | These references have been clude historical or economic publications issued from the press barely a month ago. Emerson Houga’s “Singing Mouse Stories” (Bobbs-Merrill) are not stories, but sketchy allegories, somewhat lacking in concreteness and, accordingly, in effectiveness. Parable is so neglected in our time that any indi- cation of interest in it on the part of a writer might be welcomed, but to call this collection much more than such an indica- tion would be to exaggerate the facts. A se- lection will best show the tone of the book: “Do you know the story of the Wedding of the Times?” said the Singing Mouse. “You know, all life is a wedding. The flowers love, and the grasses, and the trees; an the circle of the wedding ring is the circle of life and the sign of eternity. Death and life, not life and then death, is the order ind the law.” Less commonplace in idea and finer in expression is a short paragraph in the sec- tion entitled The Bell and the Shadows: “Thoughts,” said the Singing Mouse soft- ly. “Thoughts and remembrances. These are the things that live for ever. It is only the shadows that are real!” In “Daniel Boone and the Wilderness Road” (Macmillan), H. Addington Bruce continues his work in the interesting field he entered with his “Romance of Western ” As a biography of Boone— und the present book is more than that— t would not be just to compare it with valuable life by Dr. Thwaites. But as of the work of Boone and his it is a book of real value. Mr. historical is a kind fortunately, more common than formerly, and which, while written in an entertaining and popular vein, is far from hack work. The author has sought to make the book the purpose of a life of Boone and an of the first phase of the nation’s territorial expansion of the This idea has been well carried out, Boone’s contribu- tion to the upbuilding of the country is set forth all its stirring and romantic de- tails, but the author has not allowed the biographical matter to hide his deeper purpose of portraying the process of ex- pansion in its politica], economic, and military aspects Indeed, his success in these two purposes is so well is difficult to say whether the to be classed as a history or Expansion the an account companions of Bruce's writing which, is serve double account Alleghenies vest in balancing done that it book a blography ought Vanderbilt Univer- Tenn., for the year 1910 were delivered by Bishop William Fraser McDowell of the Methodist Episcopal Church, and are published under the title In the Christ” (Revell). Con- cerned with the training of young men for the ministry, they set forth the religious the prospective minister should learn from a devotional study of the Gospels. Much of their matter is neither new nor original, but the spirit is earnest, practical, and devout. The valuable suggestion is that each clergyman, as well as the religious leaders of a city or country a well-defined pro- Cole Nashville, The Lectures at sity, School of Christian lessons most listrict, should have _ gramme of work, based on careful study of istry is forcefully spoken. The same lec- tures at Vanderbilt University for the pre- vious year were by the Rev. Charles Mc- Tyeire Bishop, on “Jesus the Worker: Studies in the Ethical Leadership of the Son of Man” (Revell). Their publication has been delayed until now. Dr. Bishop |surveys the activities of Jesus during his ministry as examples and incentives for Christian service to-day. “Shelley’s Prose in the Bodleian Manu- scripts, edited with corrections, additions, notes, and unpublished fragments” |(Frowde), by A. H. Koszul, is intended to serve as a sequel to C. D,. Locock’s ex- amination of the verse in the same collec- tion. It presents conveniently the “Essay on Christianity,” “A Defence of Poetry,” and fragments on marriage, God, and metaphysics and morals. The substance of these fragments, often rough notes, adds little or nothing that is new to the body of Shelley’s thought before published; but may be useful in fixing more precisely than we knew before the dates at which cer- tain of his mental attitudes first took hold of him. Alfred Séderstrém of Warroad, Minn., has been occupied for some years past in collecting material for a history of the Swedish press in America. This material, written largely by himself, with contribu- tions by others, he has now published under the title “Blixtar pA tidningshorisonten.” We find reminiscences, anecdotes, charac- ter sketches, etc. On pp. 16-53 there is a complete list of Swedish-American news- papers and other periodical publications, in all not less than 1,158, of which 58 weekly and 232 monthly journals are still current. Two or three years ago Dr. Ernst Schultze of Hamburg, the well-known pro- motor of the cause of public libraries pub- lished the first volume of an Archiv fiir das Volksbildungswesen aller Kulturvélker, which was intended to be a repository for information about all phases of popular education. Unfortunately, only this one volume appeared, but it is really « ona:plete in itself, as its several articles make up a handbook on the progress of public libra- ries, museums, lecture courses, etc., up to the date of its issue, in the year 1907. The two numbers which have so far appeared of the quarterly Volksbildungsarchiv, publish- ed for the Zentralstelle fiir Volkswohlfahrt as “contributions to the scientific intensi- fying of the movements for popular educa- tion,” and edited by Dr. Robert von Erd- berg, contain several important contribu- tions. Rudolph Eucken offers some thoughts on the ideal of popular culture, while Wal- ter Hoffmann in Dresden publishes a large amount of statistical material on the read- ing of the working classes. The next, or tenth, publication of the Gutenberg-Gesellschaft will be a new work by Seymour di Ricci, the author of the “Census of Caxtons,” being a “Catalogue raisonné des premiéres impressions de |Mayence,” together with minute descrip- tions, the history of each copy to date, and the price paid for it. This announce- ment is made in the ninth annual report, from which we also learn that the society is to bring out a study by Gottfried Zedler of Albrecht Pfister, the printer of Bamberg, who came into possession of Gutenberg’s
Page 21
Dec. 22, 1910} The iW ation earliest type. As usual, the report is ac- companied by the address at the annual meeting—‘‘Die liturgischen Druckmiler in ihrer Blitezeit,” by Dr. Karl Schottenloher. The twenty-eighth annual meeting of the Modern Language Association of America will be held at the College of the City of New York, Wednesday, Thursday, and Fri- day, December 28, 29, 30. The general meeting of the Archzological Institute of America for 1910 will be held at Brown University, Providence, December 27-30. There will be five sessions for the reading of papers, including joint sessions with the American Philological Associa- tion and the American Anthropological As- sociation. The titles of the to be presented are as follows: papers “Roman Privernum,” by Henry H. strong, Princeton University; “The fication of Orestes,” by William H. University of Pennsylvania; “New Facts Regarding Justus van Ghent,” by Morton H. Bernath; “Report on the Excavation of Sardis,” by Howard Crosby Butler, Prince- ton University; “Classical Studies and the Awakening in Art,” by Mitchell Carroll; “An Archaic Greek Grave Stele in the Mu- seum of Fine Arts, Boston,” by Lacey D Caskey, Boston; “The Bird Motive in Ancient Pajaritan Pottery,” by Kenneth M. Chapman, Santa Fé; “A Bronze Cista in the Loeb Collection,” by George H. Chase, Harvard University; “The Erechtheum,” by George W. Elderkin, Princeton University; “The Case of Kyniska,” by Alfred Emerson, Chicago; “Report on the Excavation of Cyrene,” by Arthur Fairbanks, Museum of Fine Arts, Boston; “The Work of the School of American Archmology in 1916,” by Alice C. Fletcher, Washington; “Two Lekythoi in the Worcester Art Museum,” by Elizabeth M. Gardiner, Worcester; “Measur of Arm- Puri- Bates, ments 1910 in the Spiral Stairway of the Leaning Tower of Pisa,” by William H. Goodyear, Brooklyn Institute of Arts and Sciences; “Philistine and Hebrew in Palestine,” by Elihu Grant, Smith College; ‘“Ameri- can Excavations in Crete in 1910,” by Edith H. Hall, Mt. Holyoke College; “The Tewa Game of Kahtohphe,” t John P. Harrington, Santa Fé; “The Sequence in the Development of Art in Copan and Quirigua,” by Edgar L. Hewett; “Parthe- non Studies,” by B. H. Hill, Athens; “The Harvard Excavations of 1910 in Samaria,” by D. G. Lyon, Harvard University; “Clas- sic Myths in Art,” Edmund von Mach, Cam- bridge; “Della Robbias in America,” by Allan Marquand, Princeton University; “Italian Paintings in America,” by Frank J. Mather, jr., Princeton University; “Some Ostraka from Samaria.” by George F Moore, Harvard University; “The Historical Value of the Books of Chilan Balam,” by Sylvanus G. Morley, Santa Fé; “The Exca- vation of Balcony House, Mesa Verde Na tional Park,” by Jesse L. Nusbaum, Santa Fé; “Survivals of Primitive Religion in Lewis Paton, Hartford Seminary; Incantation by James A. Montgom- ery, University of Pennsylvania: “The Chair of Maximianus in Ravenna,’ Thomas J. Preston, jr.; “Coptic Architectural Frag- ments recently acquired by the Metropoli- Bayles “Some Syria,” by Theological Bowls from Nippur,” tan Museum,” by Caroline L. Ransom, New York: “Two Copies of the Head of Athena Parthenes from Corinth,” by David H. Rob- inson. Johns Hopkins University; “Notes on the Recent Egyptian Acquisitions from Gizen now in the Boston Museum of Fine Arts.” by L. Erle Rowe, Bostor; “A Marble Roman Bowl from Bagdad.” by Oliver 5S Tonks, Princeton University: “Methods of Classifying Roman Concrete Structures,” by Esther Bo'se Van Deman, research asso ciate of the Carnegte Institution, Rome, and “The Werk of Domitian on the Palatine Hill in Rome.” by Esther Boise Van Denian According to the report of the treasurer of the institute, which has been listributed in anticipation of the meeting ome from all sources in the last fiscal year exclusive of the gift of James Loeb for th endowment of the Charles Eliot Nerto ! memorial lectureship (noticed in the Nation October 21, 1809), amounted to $36,684.47; the number of members is now 3,000, dis- tributed in thirty-two affiliated societies The rapid growth of the institute in recent years is indicated by the fact that as late as 1992 it had approximately 1,000 members, and an income of less than $7,500 a year. The death is announced, in forty- third year, of Paul Eve Stevenson, the au- thor of the following books: “A Deep Water Voyage,” “By Way of Cape Horn,” and ‘“‘The Race for the Emperor’s Cup.” his Science Weeds of the Farm and Gar- By Harold C. Long, in collabora- tion with John Percival. New York: Frederick A. Stokes. $2 net. This book deals with British weeds, but since weeds are cosmopolites, much of the treatise may be applied to these plants found anywhere under the same general climatic conditions. The authors —one a member of the Board of Agricul- ture and Fisheries, and the other a pro- fessor of agricultural botany in Univer- sity College, Reading, England—have given us a very readable and instruc- tive work. Common den. There are sundry mischiefs attributa- ble to weeds: they hinder proper and thorough cultivation; they harbor in- jurious insects and fungi; they dimin- ish the ease with which a crop can be harvested; their seeds may reduce the value of harvested grain; they may block an entire system of underdrain- ing; and, worst of all, they take up room and absorb much moisture, air, light, and heat. The sum of injury is vari- ously estimated by good observers as from 30 to 47 per cent. In other words the farmer is obliged to calculate whe- ther it is worth while for him to fight to save this large Such a question is one of great importance to every cultivator, whether he is farmer, gardener, or merely an amateur. percentage. But how came certain seed-plants to be the enemies of man? They are not all of them descendants of the punitive thorns and thistles. Why should a few plants more than with cultivated crops the right to every foot of the soil? If we glance at what has taken in recent partial answer can be suggested, namely, that these plants, by some unhappy accident obtained a start over the others and have kept the su- premacy. A single illustration will make The island of Tasmania possesses a climate which is favorable for rapid and healthy growth of almost any vegetation of the temper- zones. Some of the early colonists, wishing to surround their homes with garden plants holding pleasant associa- tions with their English birthplace, se the common others contest place times a called weeds, have this suggestion probable. ate lected, among other things | sweet-briar, 611 the eglantine. Within a few years this innocent plant had invad- ed much arable ground, rendering it ab solutely useless, and resisting all at- tempts to exterminate it. In short, it has now become one of the worst possi- ble weeds, exceeding in its pertinacity the most troublesome thistles. It had been freed from all of its British enemies of fungi and insects, and it pro- ceeded to run riot. As time passed, it found some Australasian foes, but they vere not those of the old surroundings. Another illustration is found in the so- called “water-hyacinth,” which, coming from the district of the Amazon, spread so rapidly in the still waters of Florida as to call for governmental intervention to eradicate it. But there is this mark- ed difference between the plants which domain of and the even uddenly encroach upon the plants in a new country that the of luxuriance from other former soon which they decline, whereas most weeds hold their own against all comers. Neverthe- less it is probable that some temporary freedom from enemies gave most of our weeds a start at the outset. common weeds, reach a point Our flowering plants have in general two modes of reproduction, one by seeds and the other by buds or offshoots of some kind. The very process of “weed- ing” by hoeing pulling break the plant into fragments, each of which is virtually a “cutting” or “slip,” ready for independent growth. And hence it happens that the cultivator may be a distributor of the very plant he is try- ing to eradicate. But the immense num ber of seeds produced must not be forgotten as an important factor in their distribution. And, moreover, it must be remembered that the seeds of a certain number of our are ma- ture at about the time of harvesting, and are by it disseminated. Still further, it must not that almost every plant under cultivation is a help- less thing, dependent upon man for en- richment of for a certain degree of protection from harmful influ- On the other hand as a can look for and avail themselves of the enrichment of the soil, so that, in fact, the strife tween weeds and crops is very unequal. In all of its aspects it is a strife which is extremely interesting to every onlook- er except the farmer or the gardener. The present treatise shows plainly how or may by plants weeds be forgotten the soil and ences. weeds, rule, out themselves be- the cultivator can give his crops much- needed aid. With the issu of this month the Political Science Quarterly completes its twenty-fifth year. The one hundredth num- ber, like the first, appears under the man- iging editorship of Prof. Munroe Smith of Columbia University Prof. F. J. Good- yw, who contributed an article to the first number, furnishes the opening article in this issue In “The Legislative Power of Congress Under the Judicial Article of
Page 22
612 the Constitution,” Professor Goodnow ar- gues that Congress has wide powers of) legislation which are still unused, and that, in particular, it might establish uniform law to be applied by the Federal courts in controversies between citizens of differ- ent States, and between citizens and aliens. Cc. F. Robinson writes on “The Mortgage Recording Tax"; J. B. Ross on “Agrarian Changes in the Middle West,” showing that the drainage of rich prairie lands is pro- ducing a reverse current of migration from the West eastward; Prof. C. F. Emerick calls attention to “A Neglected Factor in Race Suicide’; Prof. W. M. Sloane con- cludes series of studies on “Radical France,’’ and Prof. Edwin Maxey describes “‘The Reconstruction of Korea” by Japan A leading review of Croly's “The Promise of American Life” is by Prof. Royal Meeker. University of Berlin was founded in 1809, and in commemoration of this fact Prof. H. Wagner of Géttingen calls atten- tion in Petermann’s Mitteilungen to its not- able contributions to our geographical | knowledge by its professors during the first century of its existence. Those whose work is particularly described are Carl Ritter, characterized in the Encyclopedia Britan- | nica as “the greatest geographer of mod- ern times”; H. Kiepert, Baron Ferdinand von Richthofen, and the present incumbent of the chair, Albrecht Penck. The death is reported from Turin of| Prof. Angelo Mosso, the physiologist, at the | age of sixty-four. He received, 1899, from the Accademia dei Lincei the Grand Prix for his work on the circulation of the blood in the brain. He invented several medical instruments, founded the scientific institute on Monte Rosa, writing his results in con- nection with it in “L’Uomo sulle Alpi,” and as an archmologist excavated in South Italy and Crete. Democracy in contributed The Drama Percy MacKaye's satirical comedy “Anti- Matrimony” has been published (Frederick A. Stokes Co.) In attractive book form. A reading of it does not greatly modify the impression made by its recent performance on the stage. It is brightly written, con- talns many effective humorous and satirical | strokes, and is sound in its ridicule of va- rious social vagaries. But it is too crazy in ite construction and too grotesquely vio- | lent in its incidents to have much theatrical | or other value “God's Heroes” is the title of a five-act drama by Laura Clifford Barney which has been published (J. B. Lippincott Co.) with an elaboration of ornament altogether out of to the value of the subject matter page illuminated with symbolical Oriental designs which claims to be historical,| a modern Persian’ religious! movement—apparently a sem!-Christianized Mohammedanism—which is sald to be! spreading and has already had its martyrs In that reapect it is Interesting, and it is plainly the product of a fervid enthusiasm, | but it has no serious literary or dramatic value. and its influence is not likely to be widespread. proportion Every is presumably The deals atory, with Henri Bataille’s “The Foolish Virgin”! é i ! } created somewhat of a sensation in Paris, | like, untheatrical, and charming. The piece he Na tion [Vol. 91, No. 2373 when it was produced there last winter, is in no way remarkable for literary bril- but is not likely to prove successful here. | jiancy or novelty in characterization. There The English version of it, given in the Knickerbocker Theatre, is of indifferent quality and the performance is distinctly poor. It is an essentially French piece, full of all sorts of emotional extravagances, which suffers much from the heavy-handed methods of the English speaking stage. In spite of its pretensions to serious social and philosophic purpose, it is only domes- tic melodrama, the exaggeration and in- consistency in both characters and inci- dents relegating it to this category. Its main thesis, apparently—for it deals sensa- tionally with more motives than one—is| infidelity man is that in cases of marital not always the seducer. Mr. Bataille might easily have provided a more plausible illus- tration of this indisputable proposition, if he had not been more anxious about the- atrical effect than any sort of truth. He has imagined a school girl reared under the best domestic influences, daughter of a wealthy duke, who becomes the enslaver of a middle-aged barrister; and who, guid- | ed by passion alone, persists—in spite of warnings from father, mother, and her lov- | er himself—in carrying him off from his | devoted wife, and casting her own and everybody else’s reputation to the winds. He has succeeded in making his heroine a wanton, but not in shifting one feather’s | weight of responsibility from the shoul- | The deserted wife is reso- | ders of the man. lute in the defence of her husband, stands by him in evil, as in good report, watches over him perpetually, excuses him as the victim of an irresistible power, interposes to save him from the hand of the avenger, and so demonstrates the nobility of her love that her rival becomes suddenly re- morseful, and commits suicide, in order that the truant husband may be at liberty to re- | turn to his allegiance. There is much emo- tion, with some effective situations, in the story, but precious little truth of nature or life. Mrs. Patrick Campbell, who enacts the superhuman wife, exhibits some strik- ing outbursts of passion, but emphasizes the unnaturalness of the character by her mannerisms of speech and gesture. No dis- cretion was shown in the choice of her supporting cast. It is pleasant to note the return of com- edy—very light but genuine comedy—to the étage of Wallack’s Theatre. In “Pomander Walk,” which was produced there on Tues- day evening, Louis N. Parker, in an interval of his labors as pageant master, provided an uncommonly fresh and pleasant entertain- | | ment in a form which in many respects may be said to be new even to veteran playgoers. His scene is a little red brick crescent of six practicable houses, which he has peo- pled with a group of personages who live their everyday life, as it were, in neighborly converse and exhibit their personal pecu- liarities in the course of their ordinary pur- suits, without the least apparent conscious- ness of serving any dramatic purpose what- ever. A small riparian suburban community is brought into the limelight for a day or two and then the curtain is dropped upon them and all is over. Two or three love stories are brought to a happy conclusion, just to give the necessary spice of romantic interest, but there Is no trace of a plot, no | harrowing emotion, no sensation, and no mystery. And the effect is singularly life- is no more straining after effect in the dia- | logue than in the incidents. But the under- | lying idea of it is as original as it is in- | genious, and it opens up a new field for | dramatic experiment. It is not necessary here to enter upon descriptive details. A | brief synopsis would be unintelligible. The 'time of the action is supposed to be in 1805, |which offers rich opportunities to the cos- |tumer. Among the principal personages are a choleric, jovial old admiral, one of Nel- son’s men, superbly played by that finished | comedian, George Giddens; a retired butler, aping fashionable airs, excellently acted by Lennox Pawle; a shy musician, very well done by Reginald Dance, and half a dozen | women of various types, all cleverly embod- ied. The general representation is notably |competent. “Pomander Walk,” in short, is delightful entertainment, and it was evident- ly enjoyed heartily by a very large audience. John Masefield’s tragedy, “Pompey the | Great,” which has just been acted by the Stage Society in London, appears to be an uneven work, in which passages of great beauty and nobility of ideal are mingled with anachronistic modernisms of all kinds, las if to show, in spite of Moliére, that the ancients and the moderns are very much alike. Cc. M. S. McLellan’s play, “Judith Za- raine,” will be produced here in Christmas | week, with the well-known English actress, Lena Ashwell, and Wilton Lackaye in the leading characters. The story deals witb a labor crisis in a Pennsylvania town. A mill employing thousands of operatives has |been forced out of business by a stronger rival, and the men are thrown on the |street, filled with an intense bitterness against the powerful corporation. They |are led by Judith Zaraine, who is one of | the workers, and who centres her condem- |nation upon the head of David Murray, the |guiding spirit in the Trust. The situation | reaches the acute stage when troops are lealled out to protect the company’s prop- erty. David Murray, who likes to do his | thinking for himself, and to examine into | conditions, visits Minetown, where he poses as a reporter for a New York paper, sent ‘to cover the labor troubles. He inter- views Judith, they become interested in each other, and their intercourse results in much mutual enlightenment. The end of the piece may be guessed. The announcement has been made al- |ready in this journal that Marie Tempest is to be seen soon in the New Theatre as Becky Sharp in a version of “Vanity Fair’ which is new to this country. It appears that she is also to enter upon a career of actor-manager, both in this country and in England. Here she will open proceedings next autumn in Maxine Elliott’s Theatre, j\where she will produce, among other things, a piece dealing with vaudeville life by Paul Kester, entitled “The Bill Top- pers,” and a comedy by George Pastor, entitled “Clothes and the Woman.” Lewis Waller has agreed to give a scene from “Julius Cwsar” in a London music hall. Soon he is to appear in a new play called “Bardeleys the Magnificent.” Charles Frohman will soon produce in | London a new light comedy by W. Somerset ' Maugham. It is entitled “Loaves and
Page 23
Dec. 22, 1910] The Nation 613 —————— — SESS ii) [ ; Fishes,” and the principal part will be The plan of the present book is sim- to Franz. Exception may also be taken played by Irene Vanbrugh. Ellen Terry has begun in the Christmas number of the Windsor Magazine a series of articles on “Shakespeare’s Heroines.” — Music Massenet and His Operas. By Henry T. Finck. New York: John Lane Co $1.50 net. It is strangely true, as Mr. Finck ob- serves, that there was no English work on Massenet until the publication of the present volume. It is equally true that there was no widespread interest in the creations of the French Puccini till the indefatigable Oscar Hammerstein, seek- ing material with which to infuse indi- viduality into his seasons at the Man- hattan Opera House, hit upon the happy idea of giving Massenet’s operas in a characteristically Parisian manner. Mr. Finck is justified in his assertion that the few scattered performances of “Werther,” “Manon,” and one or two other of Massenet’s operas at the Met- ropolitan Opera House never focussed public attention upon the peculiar man- ner of this interesting French master. The presentation of “Manon,” in the days when Jean de Reszke made an en- chanting melodic personage of the Chevalier des Grieux, was one in which the work, as a whole, was prostituted to | the office of glorifying two or three sing- ers. There was something like real pathos in the one appearance of the un- fortunate Sybil Sanderson in the title réle, but her flitting across the operatic stage cast but a momentary shadow | upon the glamour that went with the name of Jean de Reszke. Later, we heard the opera with other prime! donne, but none of them even faintly suggested the real Manon. Mr. Finck is most amiable in his comments on the present-day represen- | tatives of Manon and des Grieux at the Metropolitan. With all his kindness, | he must feel in his heart that it is not | an ideal French conception of the work | that is offered to the public. He doubt- | ‘ple and direct, and the work will un- doubtedly serve excellently its purpose. Mr. Finck, by reason of his warm sym- pathy with the French school of opera and his high admiration for some of its leading interpreters, was precisely fit- ted to produce a book of this type. Without doubt, he could have subjected Massenet’s art to a more searching and Giscriminating criticism, had he so cbosen to do; but it is obvious that this would have been outside the scope of his present volume, which is plainly designed as a help to further public understanding of the nature and beau- ties of these charming operas. It is pleasant to find that he has not hesitat- ed to pay a proper tribute to such im- personators of Massenet’s people as Mary Garden, Dalmores, and Renaud. Nor has he forgotten how much the works owe in America to the insight and affection of Cleofonte Campanini, a conductor wonderfully free from racial cr national prejudice and narrowness of view. Perhaps in the final estimate of things musical, whenever that shall be made, it will appear that Mr. Finck ‘has not laid too much stress on the greatness of Maurice Renaud. In the lyric world, he is, indeed, a splendid to the statement that Strauss “knows Schubert, Schumann, Franz, and Brahms fonly to avoid them.” Franz peeps at us from more than one page, and who, on jhearing Strauss’s “Morgen” (op. 27 No. 4), would ever suspect that anybody but Brahms could have written it? Grieg was in Strauss’s memory when he penned ‘‘The Saffron” and ‘The Three Holy Kings.” _Two of the most popular songs—the ‘“Ser- enade” and “Cwcilie’—are not included ,in Mr. Huneker’s list. One wonders, also, why he excluded the songs in the comic jvein, like “Herr Lenz” and “Fiir finfsebn Pfennige’’; but as it stands, the collection he made undoubtedly affords a good birds- eye view of the lyrics of Germany's most J prominent composer. David Bispham will give another all- English recital at Carnegie Hall, on the afternoon of Tuesday, January % The programme will include a group of mod- ern songs, several excerpts from operas | of Verdi and Wagner, and a recitation of Tennyson's “Enoch Arden” music of Rich- ard Strauss. ' | In Italy the most popular of Puccini's ;operas is “La Bohéme,” which was sung jlast year some five hundred times. j In other European countries and in Ameri- | ca, the favorite among his operas is ‘“Ma- }dama Butterfly,” which was given last year ~ seventy-three theatres in Germany alone In France, according to Comedia, 833 per- formances of foreign operas were given be- artistic figure. His interpretation of the | monk Athanael ought to live in operatic |tween January, 1899, and January, 1910, at history as one of the most pathetic and | the Opéra Comique, and Puccini stood frst, poignantly tragic creations. Its perfect | his “Bohéme,” “Tosca,” and “Butterfly” hav- counterpart was his assumption of the ing received in that period 390 representa- role of the Friar Cook in “Le Jongleur tions, or nearly one-half the total number. |de Notre Dame,” an exquisitely poetic) the popularity of Puccini and Wagner, and also of some of the older French com- posers — Bizet, Gounod, Massenet, Saint- Saéns—has moved the younger opera writ- piece of human comedy, of which the ‘gentle humor and fathomless sweetness of temper will assuredly remain peren- nially clear in the minds of thoughtful |°™s to form a “defensive and offensive | league” for the purpose of obtaining more Levens Of epee, | attention for their work. To this the au- | thorities replied that their justification A few years ago Richard Strauss @D~|jieg jn the fact that the old familiar operas nounced that he would write no more Or-|,,, while the French novelties do not. chestral tone poems, but would confine him- | Lydia Lipkowska, who is to do Thais in self to the operatic field. He has done 80,’ Boston, says that Massenet has rearranged yet he finds time meanwhile to dash off an | some of the music so that it will better suit occasional song. Melody is scarce in these |her voice, products, wherefore it takes a vocalist of | the Willner type to make them palatable. a Strange to say there has been hitherto) no collection of the Strauss Meder. This| Art lese felt this when he was impelled to| want is now supplied by “Forty Songs write comments showing that he placed |by Richard Strauss,” just published by the productions of Oscar Hammerstein the Oliver Ditson Company. In accord- above those of the Metropolitan Opera|2"ce with the plan of the Musicians) House. There can be no question that Librery, to which this volume belongs, |James Huneker, being the foremost Amer- the juster appreciation of the value and omg renee: Sreediggameggptioeen the character of Massenet’s operas dates to select the songs and write an intro- from the night when Mary Garden Te | Guction; but why did he devote eight col- vealed to New York her ravishing Thais. | ymns to that composer's career and his Mr. Finck recognizes the artistic im- orchestral works and less than two col- portance of this incident and very prop- /tmns to his songs? As a measure of their | ——_ THE WINTER ACADEMY. The feature of the Academy exhibition at the Fine Arts Building is the me ‘morial display of five Winslow Homers in the Middle Gallery. Lacking the spe cific preciousness of fine painting, these pictures are so nobly imagined, so sim- |plified to the bones of the graphic theme, that they give far cleverer pictures the ‘look of not much mattering. Surely the erly accords to Hammerstein’s produc-| value this may be just, but in a special tions of Massenet’s works the first posi- tion in his volume. He deals with the Metropolitan performances afterward, end reserves for the final part of his hook consideration of those operas which are not yet known to the Amerti- can public. collection of these songs, and the first one, too, one would have welcomed more copious comments from one s0 well-in- formed and so enthusiastic—one who finds Kosta he i that Strauss is, in these lieder, “the empnasis yond his common visual ex- patient, curious master of miniatures, the PeTience. Unless the landscape painter ivory worker of exotic shapes”—a char- @Dlarge and intensify my seeing, to what that seems more applicable purpose does he paint? ‘business of landscape and marine paint- ing is to enhance the vision of the ordi- nary man, to give him some aspect or acterization
Page 24
614 Such a standard would give to a deal of our landscape merely the value of a rest cure for the artistic tempera- ment. Yet here and there something is being done. A group, who, for conven- ience, may be called the naturalists, has at least recovered a fresh and vigorous idiom in paint. Redfield, the most ac- complished member, is not represented this year, but we have Ernest Lawson's tingling Harlem River, George Bellows’s Blackwell's Bridge, with a surging blue tideway; Gardner Symons’s River Gorge, and Cullen Yates’s The Rising Fog. One could wish this last hung by the Wins- low Homers. It has the assured pictorial quality that the naturalists generally lack. Most of them paint and see with a sort of impatience that too often ends in swagger and casual emphasis. They are alive and help one to see keenly, but there is strangely little modulation in their product. In America to-day, there is no cleverer contriver of the minimum indication that spells light, distance, tex- ture, than Mr. Bellows. Yet his East River scene tends to fall apart and abounds in uncertain indications. Gard- ner Symons has ably caught the look of a mountain in afterglow beyond a shad- owed river valley; has caught every- thing but the main thing, the sense of vast space and of a unifying atmos- phere. Mr. Lawson permits us to look through a crystalline lens that intensi- fles the view. Such painting as his is in itself almost pictorial, but not quite. Cul- len Yates gets his picture out of sim- ple constituents. An eroded cut in the rock swings down to a lapping sea, the horizon of which is lost in mist. Dip- ping strata, largely drawn, and giving a sense of continulty with unseen rock systems, interlock at the turns of the lit- tle gorge. It is extraordinary that so blond a mass seen under masked sun- light can be so vigorous, and that so hemmed-in a view can give its sense of immensity. It is in this kind of rhythm that much good painting is deficient. Childe Hassam naturally falls into this group. In poor light his Summer Idyl, with its tiny figure set in a big oblong of highly schematized saplings, seemed mo- notonous. While the fine executants just mentioned have notably improved and invigorated the practice of landscape art among us, many will feel that the most enjoyable landscapes are still painted by men whose vision is perhaps more dis- tinguished than their handling. Here may be mentioned Groll’s desert scene, with its fairly illusionary clouds poised in the middle distance; W. A. Coffin's A March Evening, with an im- mensity of cold sky encompassing a sombre upland; Leonard Ochtman’s Morning in Early Summer, a delicate blending of silvery and tawny values. Ben Foster, in his picture of a weedy pool at Longpré, reveals a novel and in- teresting manner, but there is perhaps The Na tion [Vol. 91, No. 2373 good | the insistently realized water and the ghostly peplars beyond. William Rit- schel’s Night Shadows, the Grand Cafi- on, is one of the most ambitious and se- rious canvases shown. Its nearness to the Winslow Homers betrays the lack of characteristic and defining accent, or again it may be like many other land- scapes the victim of a gloom cast by neighboring sky-scrapers. Charlotte Co- mans’s Hills of Blizabethtown has a quiet and charming intimacy. William | S. Robinson’s Golden Days, which wins the Carnegie prize, is sumptuous in au- tumnal russets and ochres, but without distinction of arrangement. As if in deference to the mighty shade of Winslow Homer, marine painting is somewhat in abeyance this year. Such strong men as Woodbury and Paul Dougherty are absent, so is Carlsen. Rehn and Bogert, from whom one ex- pects better things, appear in rather sugary dilution. and, St. Ives, firmly set between a pale stretch of tidal sand and a lowering sky, and F. J. Waugh’s colorful Harbor Cove in Sunlight, seem about the only contributions of note in this class. In recent Academies street scenes, hol- iday crowds, have been prominent and good. This year the hanging committee has sternly set its face against these ephemeralities. Only Joseph Pennell, an accomplished master in this genre, occupies the line. Mr. Olinsky’s illumi- nated Piazza of St. Mark’s, Venice, has been sent to the “morgue,” together with Ernest Lawson’s Umbrellas, Coney Island. One can see that these are strong pictures, even by electric light, but only surmise that they are fine ones. So long as the Academy has no wall space for large decorative designs, so long its representation of current figure painting will be merely fractional. We have this year the plein-airistes Dufner and Lillian Genth in agreeable but en- tirely familiar vein. George Bellows displays a new side of his versatile gift in a polo scene. It has not merely the rattle and rush of the subject, but is also well put together. Three very typi- cal kinds of figure painting are repre- sented by the president's contribution, a purely decorative, one might say cal- ligraphic, arrangement of two female forms; by Kenyon Cox’s A Book of Pic- tures, an academic performance in the best sense, and Charles W. Hawthorne's Refining Oil, which comes near the mod- ern ideal of painting for paint’s sake. Ot Mr. Alexander’s always debonair and graceful accomplishment no new word can be said. It has its roots, probably, in the rhythmical decorators of the past, the Venetians for choice, and it has taken eclectically the muted harmonies of the Whistler tradition. The result is a thing pictorially sure and invariably pleasing, but without a hundred art students have already murmured “old hat” before Kenyon Cox’s academic group. If so, let them reflect that a few thousand up-to-date art students will pass away before any of them will do anything nearly as good. Mr. Cox has succeeded, where he often fails, in striking an equilibrium of bright colors, the linear drawing of the group of mother and child is ex- quisite, and the expression is where the ‘mob always refuses to look for it, not |in the eyes and lips, but in the whole figure. The abstract merits of fine analytical design and learned arrange- ment are not much valued to-day. No more will the taste that loves hasty Henry B. Snell’s Isl- | syncopations and specious approxima- ‘tions be much valued in some wiser to- jmanres. Mr. Cox’s picture is not worse, |but better, because it recalls the blithe /mastery of early Renaissance painting in Italy. Though Mr. Hawthorne has an excellent eye for character and some regard for arrangement in line and |mass, his preoccupation is mainly with ‘paint. And this is, so far as it goes, /high commendation. But it means, too, 'that he exalts the grammar of his art a ‘little at the expense of its rhetoric. It ‘is the flashing of green glass and pot- }tery in a dusky interior that this time has challenged his able brush. These indications of an evanescent reality he grasps and records with fine gusto. As mere painting it is very nearly of the best. If it fails to make an impressive pictorial effect, that may be partly be- cause the arrangement is obvious and rather uninteresting, and even more be- cause the scale is miscalculated. We have in the dimensions of life what is really a cabinet piece. The same care- less attitude with regard to scale is shown in Mora’s spirited study of young yachtsmen, which unkind fate has rele- gated to electric light. And while on the sore topic of the “Morgue,” be it” said that by a proper installation of re- flectors the horrors of what one regrets to call The Academy Room could be mitigated. The Independents last win- ter had the same problem, and solved it with relative success. A good deal of the portraiture of every year necessarily is what may be called official. Workmanlike up to a certain point, deserving of exhibition, it arouses neither enthusiasm nor dissent. This year there is little stirring among the portraitists, and the exhibition, if reduced to a single class, might best stand on such contributions as Tarbell’s President Timothy Dwight, superior of- ficial portraiture; Louis Betts’s forth- right head of Gardner Symons; Mary | Foote’s very picturesque study of Mrs. ‘John Carpenter in keen blue hat and pink coat; Wilton Lockwood's tense and ‘reserved presentment of Dr. J. W. El- Hot, Albert Rosenthal’s Peggy MacRae, |wholly winsome in port, and a lovely some lack of pictorial harmony between ‘great vigor or variety. It may be that ‘shimmer of dull lilac and rose; Lydia >. +
Page 25
Dec, 22, 1910] The Nation 615 Field Emmet's Portrait of a Lady, most/with style. He has highly developed! aristocratically conceived, and, last but not least, MacCameron’s profound and merit. In contrast with this method, a sympathetic interpretation of a young man of poetic type, and Blumenschein’s charmingly natural and humorous de- lineation of Mme, G. MacCameron’s paint has beautiful quality. With little poly- chromy he achieves the sense and depth of color much as Venetian portraitists did of old. Blumenschein has not mere- ly an extraordinary eye for the accents that mean character, but also a sym- pathetic humor that evokes idiosyn- crasy, without suggesting caricature. Last winter his striking portrait of a comedian did not win me. I thought it overemphatic. I must have been wrong, for this year I delight in an al- most identical treatment of Mme. G. How piquant the awxward way in which she slants comfortably across the ob- long, how diverting the harmony, De- bussy type, of a magenta footstool, with a wrap just flushed with palest salmon pink, how engaging the sense of good humor, self-possession, and genial seif- criticism! Mme. G. is documentary of a civilization. It is as good as read- ing a novel in Henry James’s latest man- ner, to reflect that no well-to-do Ameri- can woman would ever permit Mr. Blu- menschein to tell this amount of inter- esting truth about her. Wilton Loekwood’s Peonies is an ex- quisite bit of painting. Perhaps nothing in the exhibition except Alden Weir's little girl, in Playmates, approaches it for distinguished conception and flaw- less execution. About a hundred and fifty pieces of sculpture are set in the South Gallery, and the apparent compensation for crowding is that for the first time in many years the display is fairly repre- sentative. French’s memorial to Alice Freeman Palmer and Karl Bitter’s por- trait of Presideat Angeli of the Uni- versity of Michigan, both high reliefs, occupy the end walls. French’s composi- tion is symbolic: a matronly woman guides from behind a slight girl who carries the lamp of learning. The gen- era] motive is that of an Attic stele. The arrangement of the figures 1s rhythmical, and the sense of protection and guidance is feelingly given. The relief is a good example of the studied grace of French's best work, and is a worthy memorial of the one-time president of Wellesley. Karl Bitter’s presentment of President Angell is genial and evidently an excellent por- trait. It hardly fills a space which in parts is overburdened with small ac- cessories, but in its destined architec- tural setting the proportions may come right. James Earl Fraser’s capital mar- ble of a baby’s head, and a finely posed nude called Grief, are from the point of view of craftsmanship among the more attractive displays. Three por- trait heads by Grafly show a severe simplicity of modelling which is instinet ithe sense of artistic economy, a rare young English sculptor, Theodore Spic- er-Simpson, works out his bronze head of the late Moncure D. Conway in all detail, without losing the specific sense ‘ot intellectual melancholy. The work recalls not unworthily the famous Hel- lenic idealization of Homer. A group of portraits by Edith Woodman Bur- roughs and a marble portrait head by Evelyn Longman show kindred qualities of elaborate and sensitive modelling. F. J. M., Jn. “Notes on the Post-Impressionist Paint- ers (Grafton Gallery, 1910-11),"” by C. J. Holmes, will be issued immediately by Lee Warner. The sculptor Charles Verlet, professor at the Ecole des Beaux-Arts, has been elected successor to Emmanuel Frémiet at the Académie des Beaux-Arts, after a spirited contest going to nine ballots. A reproduction has been made by Dr. Gerolamo Calvi, under the auspices of the R. at Milan, of Leonardo da Vinci's treatise on the nature of water, which is in the library of the late Earl of Leicester at Holkham. In the Church of S. Martino a Strada, near Florence, has been found a large fresco of the Annunciation which is ascribed to Spinello Aretino. A family legacy has added to the Louvre collection a series of more than sixty works of the eider Isabey (Jean Baptiste). It greatly supplements the known work of this portrait painter of the Revolution, Constituante, Directory, Empire, Bourbon Restoration, and Louis Philippe’s monar- chy. Isabey died in Paris in 1855, at the age of eighty-eight, and he painted to within a few years of that time. The new acquisitions begin with the artist’s own portrait, painted at eighteen (1786); he already wears the hat which has since been identified with Bonaparte. From 1789 we have a crayon portrait of David, in whose studio young Isabey was work- ing. There is a vignette of 1791, repre- senting the luckless little Dauphin at his promenade near the Chateau of Meudon. There is @ probable portrait of the Revo- lutionist, Collot d’Herbois; Madame de Staél, at thirty, with attractive looks be- lying the tradition of her ugliness; 4 sepia of Napoleon at Notre Dame; Jose- phine, Hortense, Madame Mére, the baby King of Rome, fifteen days old, and Marie Louise a year later; Talleyrand and Met- ternich in 1812; Josephine as retired Em- press; Prince Eugéne, Louis XVIII, Paul 1 of Russia, Duc de Bordeaux (future Comte de Chambord or “Henry V"’) a8 a boy in 1830; Dufaure, who lived to be Thiers’s minister under the Third Repub- lic, as he was in 1841, when he was @ member of Thiers’s cabinet, under Louis Philippe, and many unofficial celebrities in between. An album, “La Peinture Chinolse au Musée Guimet” (Paris: Paul Geuthne, in the series of Annales du Musée Guimet), by Tcoan yi-tchou and J. Hackin, repro- duces some notable works from a late exbibition of Chinese paintings. It is pre- Istituto Lombardo di Scienze e Lettere! faced by an excellent short history of Chinese painting; and its alphabetical in- cex of painters is praiseworthy for being accompanied by the Chinese characters. Reproductions in the Japanese art review, Kokha, made known some time ago the rich collections of such paintings in Japan, and showed the inspiration caught from them by Japanese artists. The late Em- press Dowager presented to M. Guimet two particularly noteworthy landscapes. One, by Tchao Po-kin of the eleventh cen- tury, has a delightful impressionist effect: the sun is setting behind a mountain whose base pluuges in water from which mists are rising, while the summit is still in the golden ligat. There is a finely execuled court scene by the Emperor Siuan-ho (twelfth century); paintings ia camaieu of Tchao-Mongfou (thirteenth century); landscapes of T’ang-hi (four- teenth century); a mMmaguificent warrior ieaning on his sword, and various Buddhbic or Taoist personages (seventeenth cen- tury); sample sketches from life, from which Chinese artists prepare the por- traits of ancestors, showing great truth of expression. There are also rubbings irom more @ucient engravings on stone, reproducing among Other subjects a por- trait of Confucius, by Wou-Tao-tseu (eighth century), and similar reproduc- tious of the works studied by Professor Chavaunes of the Collége de France, in his book on Chinese sculpture, in stone, of the Han dynasties (tenth century). Be- sides its human and historic interest, ali this Opens new vistas in the technical bis- tory of art aud art processes. Anotber step forward has been taken ia bringing forth from the shadows of docu- mentary hints aud expert's conjectures, a “Maitre de Moulins,” as successor of Fouquet, painter of earliest Bourbons. A drawing in the Louvre coliection, hither- to catalogued as Flemish of the fifteenth celtury, Was swuug round to this unkuown artist at the exhibition of French primi- lives in igv4. Last May, at the Lanna sale, in Prague, the Louvre drawing (No. 199), on a “xxxili,”” and toru from the same album as certain other designs which were dis persed at the Klinkosch sale in lssy, liave been attributed by Sir W. M. Cou way to Gérard David, and as such the Lanna leaf was sold. Now, by comparison with other Louvre drawings and paintings, it is going to swell the mysterious mas- ler’s Claims to existence and lame. acquired a4 leat puumbered These A sixteen years’ discussion of the au- thenticity and priority of two similar pic tures of Leonardo da Vinci—Our Lady of the Rocks in the National Gallery, London, aud La Vierge des Rochers in the Louvre, Paris—seems to be fivaliy seitied by Salo- mon Reinach in a communication, made to the Académie des Inscriptions et Belles Lettres, of documents the notarial archives at Milan. The French picture was painted by Leonardo at Florence before 1483. In April of that year he received an order from Milan for a Virgin with two prophets, and he took the two Milanese brothers De Pretis to aid him in accessory details. With bis usual dilatoriness, he delivered the painting only in 1492; but, ia- stead of prophets, he had painted a Virgin and Child with the Angel and St. John, in other words, a replica with a few varia- from
Page 26
616 ) The Nation [Vol*91; No. 2373 tions of his Florentine picture. It is the | the private capitalists with whom it | as it does to-day. In the United States picture which is in the National It was painted with the help of de Pretis, probably, says M. Reinach, because Leonardo was overladen with other work. If this version is accepted, Messrs. Claude Phillips and MacColl come out best among the critics who have taken part in the controversy. Sir Edward Poyn- ter was all at sea in his identification of the different periods of Leonardo's art. Some- thing yet severe should be said of Richter and Mintz, who led the attack on the British picture, disparaging Leonardo time. It will be remembered that a previouscommunication of M. Reinach showed from similar documentary sources the futility of such art criticism about Leonardo's Lisa as “the ineffable, mysterious, plaintive, and haunting smile that had fascinated and perplexed the world century after century in the portrait of La Milanese Gallery Ambrogio more at the same Mona Gloconda |" a I'inance CHAPTERS IN HIGH FINANCE. To.a rather unusual degree, the Wall Street community has displayed interest in the rearrangement of membership in the firm, announced by J. P. Morgan & Co., whereby George W. Perkins, a part- ner since 1901 and a leading figure in the spectacular finance of the ensuing decade, retires, and two new partners of highly conservative antecedents are admitted—W. H. Porter, now president | of the Chemical Bank, and T. W. La- mont, vice-president of the First Nation- | al. The public’s particular ground, for interest was undoubtedly the great place which this banking house has filled in American financial history | during the decade past. In the finan- clal world, personalities play at times as large a role as events; indeed, when | one reviews the notable chapters in re- cent Wall Street history, it is not easy to say which is the more important key to the story of the period—the influ-| ence of personalities on events, or the influence of events on personalities. No doubt the conspicuous individual achievements in the financial history of years like 1901 and 1906 and 1908 and 1909 would have been impossible) but for the particular underlying con-| ditions in each of the four years. But, | on the other hand, it is extremely doubt- | ful if events would have shaped them- selves exactly as they did, on any of the four occasions, but for the personal qualities, ideas, methods, and influence of the conspicuous financial leaders. The history of the world’s great bank- ing houses, in this and in former gen- | erations, is a fascinating study. But it is apt to be difficult to discover from it just how large a part, in any given in-! stance, the individuality of partners | played. From the beginning of great) financial operations, the power and pres- dige of such a house depended also on covld surround itself. Sometimes, mem- bership of that surrounding group has been the focus of public interest, rather than membership of the banking house which acted for it. But, on the other hand, there are numerous instances where the leadership of the banking | house itself has been of so vigorous and personal a character as to obscure com- pletely the individuality of outside cap-| italists numbered in its following. The familiar episode of Mayer An-| selm Rothschild’s getting his start in high finance through safeguarding the, Elector of Hesse-Cassel’s fortune after Jena, and returning it with interest nine years later, in the Waterloo year, was an individual achievement. But the great place which his five sons ac- quired in European national finance re- | sulted much more obviously from their power of massing the financial resources | of their race. Nobody but the Roth- schilds could have defeated, as punish- ment for the expulsion of the Jews, Rus- sia’s extensive plans of 1892 for borrow- ing in Paris; yet that action was hard- ly a matter of individual initiative. was action by the group. But the bold and aggressive stand taken by Nathan Mayer Rothschild in defence of British 'publie credit, during the darkest days of the Napoleonic period, was a person- al achievement; even his associates be- 'gan to criticise him as a man who took rash chances. As a rule, the high traditions of great houses have been sustained through a series of generations; yet even in this there have been exceptions. Walter Bagehot pays the highest tribute to the older members of the great Lon- idon banking house of Overend, Gurney & Co.; but he adds that, later on, “the rule in it passed to a generation whose | folly surpassed the usual limit of imag- inable incapacity.” This led to 1866. ‘The inside history of the house of Bar-| ing Brothers has not been convincingly written. That house, too, was a fam- ily institution, and the family was and still is a very remarkable one; Lord Cromer, the financial administrator of Egypt, is one of its members in the lat- er generation. But something went very seriously astray with the business judgment of the house in 1889 and 1890. The episode was the more extraordinary in that the natural following of the house In Lombard Street was drawing cautiously away from Argentine invest- ments, at the very hour when Baring Brothers were underwriting and bring- ‘ing out loan after loan for the Buenos Ayres government. Among financial houses of the really highest grade, commercial death has been extremely rare. But changes in relative position of such houses are con- stantly going forward. The house of Morgan cut no such large figure in New York finance, two or three decades ago, It | SovernaRt's operations in the money |miarket of 1878 and 1879, August Bel- | mont & Co. casily held the centre of |the stage. Probably Wall Street would |say that the successive steps which real- |ly gained fer the Messrs. Morgan their more recent commanding position were the government bond syndicate opera- tion of 1595, the railway reorganizations of 1897 end the railway combinations ‘afterward, and the industrial recapital- izations of 1901. These were in very large measure individual achievements, made ‘possible by the remarkable per- sonality of the head of the house. One of the interesting problems of the day \is, whether the country itself may not have passed into a new economic era, which will give no further opportunity for achievements of that peculiarly spectacular character. If so, the great finance houses will have different prob- ‘lems of policy to solve. However this may be, the century or so in which high finance on the modern scale has prevailed, in Europe and America, has established at least these principles: First, continued mainte- ‘mance of a great position of the sort, by any banking house, depends on con- tinuance of absolute public confidence in its character, capacity, and financial judgment. Beyond this, it is essential that the career of such a house should |/be marked by ccntinuing achievement in large affairs—along the lines, how- ever, of real conservatism. That such attributes will be largely created by the personality of those who direct the great financial houses, is the teaching of all the century’s history; and that explains why financial markets watch with the largest interest all changes which come, in the vicissitudes of time, to the mem- bership of such houses. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. American and English Genealogies in the Li- brary of Congress. Preliminary catalogue. Ww Bingham, C., and Thompson, C. H. The Airship in Animal Land. Dutton. Bjornson, B. Sigurd Slembe. Translated by W. M. Payne. Chicago: C. H. Sergel & Co. $1.50 net. Financial. Letter Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; 0 also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits available in all parts of Credit sss: International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. No. 59 Wall Street, New York
Page 27
Dec. 22, 1910} The Nation De Menil, A. N. Forest and Town: Poems. Cedar Rapids, Ia.: Torch $1.25 net. Dolly Darling and her Pretty Clothes: Model and Painting Book for Children. Dutton. Dryden. Poems of John Dryden. Edited by | John Sargeaunt. Frowde. Duttan’s Holiday Annual. 23d Year. Verses and stories illustrated. Easy Opera Melodies for the Piano; Opera Transcriptions for the Piano; Encore Songs (high voice). Ditson. 60 cents each. Fea, A. Old English Houses. Scribner. $3 Fishberg, M. The Jews: A Study of Race and Environment. Scribner. $1.50. Guyot, Y. Economic Prejudices. Trans. by F. Rothwell. Scribner. $1. Haney, J. L. Monsieur D'Or: a Dramatic Fantasy. Philadelphia: Egerton Press. $1.20 net. Haultain, A. The Mystery of Golf. edition, revised. Macmillan. $1.76 net. Hinckle, W. A. The Evolution of Religion. 24 edition. Boston: Sherman, French. 80 cents. Holland. The Spanish Journal of Elizabeth, Lady Holland (1802-5, 1808-9). the Earl of Ilchester. Longmans. Hollingsworth, C. M. From Freedom to Despotism. Washington, D. C.: author. $1.50 net. Honey, J. A. South African Folk-Tales. | Baker & Taylor. $1 net. Ilbert, C. The Government of India. Sup- plementary chapter. Frowde. Internoscia, J. New Code of International Law. International Code Co. “The ties: work of fiction | of the twentieth century.”— Edmund Gosse. JEAN CHRISTOPHE Dawn—Morning—Youth—Revolt By Romain Rolland. Trans- lated from the French, 600 pp. $1.50 net. The romance of a great musician. Just ready. Henry Holt & Co., 84%; 84,34 *> NEW x:ORK A notable Art book, “ The Golden Age of Engraving,” by FREDERICK KEPPEL. $vo, 550 pages, 263 illus- trations, cloth, $8.50 net. In this book Mr. Keppel brings to- | gether his life-long experience, and Surveys the whole field of engraving | | from Diirer to Pennell. | PORTRAIT CATALOGUE.—Our new Por- trait Catalogue, containing 83 portraits of | authors, will be sent free on request. The Baker & Taylor Co., 33 East 17th St., New York Second | Mann, N. Edited by. The | | Jewett, S. Poems, edited by L. R. Jewett. Crowell. $1.26 net. John Carter Brown Library, List of Books Printed in the Fifteenth Century. Provi- dence, R. I.: Brown University. |Keith, T. Commercial Relations of England and Scotland, 1603-1707. (Girton College Studies No.1.) Putnam Knight, W. The Glamour of Oxford: De- scriptive passages in verse and prose by various writers. Frowde. Knowles, M. H., and Favard, B. des C. Per- fect French Possibie. Boston: Heath. Lagerléf, S. The Story of Gésta Berling. | New edition, illustrated. Little, Brown. $2 net. McComb, S. Christianity and the Modern Mind. Dodd, Mead. $1.50 net. Macgregor, W. M. Some of God’s Ministries. Scribner. $1.76 net. |Mackay, C. D. The Silver Thread and Other | Folk Plays for Young People. Arr. for use in grammar grades. Holt. $1.10 net. Import and Outlook of Socialism. Boston: James H. West Co. $1.50 net. Marden, O. S. The Miracle of Right Thought. Crowell. $1 net. Michell, L. Life of the Rt. Hon. Cecil J. Rhodes. 2 vols. Kennerley. $7.50 net. |Miles, D. H. The Influence of Moliére on Restoration Comedy. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Moore, T. Poetical Works. Edited by A. D. Godley. Frowde. Morris, M. The Reign of William and Mary (dog and cat story, illustrated). Dutton. | Newman, F. H. Adventurers (poems). Chula Vista, Cal.: Denrich Press. $1. 617 | Pearse, Mrs. G., and Hird, F. The Romance of a Great Singer: a Memoir of Mario. London: Smith, Elder. Pendry, H. W. Elementary Telegraphy. Macmillan. $1 net. Pepys. Red-Letter Days of Samuel Pepys. Edited by EB. F. Allen. Sturgis & Walton. $1.25 net. Report of the Librarian of Congress for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1910. Rickmers, W. R. Ski-ing, for Beginners and Mountaineers. Scribner. $1.50 net. Ridgeway, W. Minos the Destroyer. Frowde. | Ridgeway, W. The Origin of Tragedy, With Special Reference to the Greek Tragedians. Putnam. Roeder, A. Sea Pictures (poems). Illus- trated. New Church Board of Publication. | Stopes, Mrs. C. C. William Hunnis and the Revels of the Chapel Royal. (Materialien zur Kunde des Alteren Englischen Dramas). London: David Nutt. Sunderland, J. T. Oh, to Be Rich and Young. Boston: American Unitarian Assen. $1. Weedon, L. L. Fairy-Tales in Wonderland. Illustrated by G. 8. Hardy. Dutton. | Weedon, L. L., Fletcher, E., and others. | The Model Menagerie (juvenile). Dutton. | Welch, J. 8. Literature in the School. Sil- | ver, Burdett. $1.26. White, H. The New Theology. Broadway Pub. Co. Wisconsin Historical Collections. Vol. XIX. Madison: State Historical Society of Wis- consin. Woods, 8. D. Light and Shadows of Life on the Pacific Coast. Funk & Wagnalls. $1.20 net. By Elise W. Rose and Vida Hunt Francis Cathedrals and Cloisters of the Isle-de-France (INCLUDING BOURGES, TROYES, AUXERRE, REIMS AND ROUEN) In Two Volumes Cathedrals and Cloisters of Midland France BURGUNDY, SAVOY, DAUEEING, AUVERGNE, ACQUITAI NE In Two Volumes Cathedrals and Cloisters of the South of Franee PROVENCE, LANGUEDOC, GASCONY In Two Volumes Bach Set of Two Volumes Contains over 200 Illustrations (some in Photogravure from Original ee. Per set (of Vols.), $5.00 ne These saree are the fruit of many suc- cessive summers spent in wanderl in ‘rare unspoiled France’’ where the tourist and his suit-case are practically unknown. With pen and camera the authors picture the Cathedrals of France, presenting the views of the consecrated structures as they appear to-day and telling their life story, with its drama and its glory in the days of old, before secularism sought to lay its paralyzing band upon them. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, S*voxpon COWBOY SONGS With the Music to the Best of Them Collected by JOHN A. LOMAX, Shel- don Fellow of Harvard. Introduction by Bs RRETT WEHDELL. Songs breezy, devil-may-care, comic, and pathetic, gathered from the life of the cowpunchers. The music to the best of them enhances the value of the book. (12mo, cloth, $1.50 net.) RED-LETTER DAYS OF SAMUEL PEPYS Selections from the Diary. Edited by E. F. ALLEN. Introduction by F. B. WHEATLEY. Typical passages from one of the world’s most entertaining books that give in little the enlivening chronicle of the many-sided Mr. Pepys, who turns himself inside out with such as- tonishing frankness in his immortal Diary. (12mo, cloth, illustr. $1.25 net.) STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 E. 27th St., N. Y¥. ©. 7 vu sT !#sweo Income Taxation By KOSSUTH. KENT KENNAN eevee A review of the methods and results of taxing incomes in the Colonies and States of the American Union and in a large number of foreign countries. Containsa full account of the Civil War Income Tax, | the Income Tax Law of 1804, the Corpora- | tion Tax Law and the proposed Sixteenth j Amendment. ; Full Buckram, Uncut Edges, Gilt Top, 8-vo., Price, net $3.50 $3.76 Burdick & Allen, Publishers. Milv aukee, Wis. —— ——— Express or Post, prepaid (boxed) “Philosophy as a Science” | By DR. PAUL CARUS Pp. 220. Price, paper, 25c.; cloth, 50c. A brief statement of the principles of | Philosophy, together with a list of books | pathy. ‘and articles on this subject; an excellent guide to those wao want to begin a sys- tematic course of reading in the PHILOSOPHICAL CLASSICS THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING COMPANY Founded im 1887 for the increase and diffusion of scientific knowledge. Send for Complete Catalogue 378-388 Wabash Ave. CHICAGO, ILL. | A book of rare charm and great ustfuinces. FLORIDA TRAILS | By WINTHROP PACKARD, author of ‘‘Wild Pas- tures," ‘‘Wood Wanderings,’’ etc. Illustrated, $3.00 net; postage 25 cents “Mr. Packard,” said Nathan Haskell Dole re cently in the New York Evening Post, ‘is cer- tainly the most entertaining writer on nature now | before the public; he has keen eyes, lively sym- fluent fancy, delightful style.”’ and is | Florida Traila be has given free play to all these j qualities to charm the reader. | Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston |The only biography of the founder of modern Socialism, KARL MARX: HIS LIFE AND WORK, by John Spargo, $2.50 net; $2.70 carriage paid. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Filth avenae, NEW YORK
Page 28
The Nation [Vol. 91, No. 2373 Standard Text-Bonks Morphology of Gymnosperms. ByJoun M.CouLTerandCHArR.Les J. CHAMBERLAIN, 470 pages, 462 illustrations, 8vo, cloth. Post- ACADEMY, D. MACLAREN ROBERTSON : paid $4.22. | An original history in English from the Academy’s foundation, Methods in Plant Histology. compendious yet adequate, treating of its General nitery: ; of that | By CHARLES J. CHAMBERLAIN. of its Dictionary, an institution of itself; of its Members ip (with | 72 pages, 8vo, cloth. Postpaid iis composition in three different lists) , whose literary achievement § ; ; ; is placed under the eye of the reader in brief biographies ina more §j | $2.39. compact form than ce Agha else batvees, two covers, oven, in § A Laboratory Guide in Bac- rench ows Clearly, also, the relationshi between the five i . , “ great national Academies and the Institute oF France, of which teriology rn ae See the history is sketched in outline. ADH. xiv. +144 pages, 12mo, The authority of its sources, its thoroughness and complotences | cloth. Postpaid $1.61. within its scope, its fund of information an anecdote, shou . s make this book what it aims to be, a permanent work of reference Animal Micrology. ypboyerers as an authority in English on (in Hallam’s phrase) “the most F. Guyer. 250 pages, 8vo, cloth, illustrious institution in the annals of polite literature,” besides §| Postpaid $1.88. forming for the general reader an —_ story and for the 9 Write for Circulars. student an introduction to the French literary and political history The UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS of nearly three centuries. CHICAGO, ILLINOIS 8vo. Cloth-bound. Seven full-page half-tone illustrations. § | Asents—THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO,, 405 pages. Price, $3.00 net. Postage, 15 cents. | oe a ee ee ee ee (i. W. DILLINGHAM COMPANY : Publishers : New York Now Ready A HISTORY #, FRENCH SECOND EDITION NOW READY JOHN BROWN: A BIOGRAPHY FIFTY YEARS AFTER By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD Some Tributes to This Remarkable | Historical Work Philadelphia PUBLIC LEDGER. “A tremendous book; more, Des Moines yt “More in appeal, more thrilling than any book of fiction, powerful in its appeal, and | dramatic than any book of fiction, this we. J biography ot which, while it is written soberly, as befits history, by = 4 John Brown.’ nature of the narrative, often rises to the highest dramatic lev THOMAS WENTWORTH HIGGINSON. “I can only “y ee ie Ge noe oe ise dell py. after reading from firet to last its more than 700 pages that reader for many reasons. Full of life have pever encountered anything this side of Gibbon’s ‘Rome written in an attractive and scholarly style, full of aan sympathy and which bas made me feel more the personal power of & ‘ingle yet without any loss im accurate presentation, it sets a new work." — A aout , standard for biographical efforts.”’ sony ,, ORSE, tor merican Statesmen Series, in ATLANTIC MONTHLY ‘Perhaps in thus dramatically Baltimere AMERICAN, “While the book has popular features fashioning bis volume, Mr. Villard obeyed an instinct rather in that it is entranci interesting, its scholarship is of the o acted upon a preconceived plan; that is often the case with highest oer — Fey oo illustrated. in =e ot Pay By =a work, where a writer's feelings are deeply enlisted. Be . it may, the merit and charm are none the less; he has of iiterary conception and execution.’ velzed well a splendid opportunity and has written one of the) yondgon TIMES. ‘It is scarcely likely that any later writer will eat blographies of our literature be able either to add anything of Laosstanes to Mr. Villard’s HOR AG = Wire. “In my Judgment a contribution to American collection of material or to better his interpretation of we whole ture to take rank with the very best historical writing of story It at once becomes the standard, and probably r time or any time. The only impartial history of the Kansas the final authority on its theme.’ Washington (D. ©.) STAR. ‘Mr. Villard draws a compact, ST. CLAIR MeKELWAY tin the Brooklyn BAGLE. “A vivid, historie picture of the terrible focussi of this period blogrephy replete with facts and marked by courage and candor, upon our Civil War. Straight and clear in its iterary way, this learning, and justice." blography ts a marvel of research and fair-mindedness.’ Portiand OREGONIAN. ‘The most valuable and comprehensive HENRY WATTERSON in Leuleville COURIER-JOURNAL blography leeved this season, and the best and most candid esti- “No fault may justly be found with Mr. Villard’s telling of the mate of John Brown.” story. It is minute and lucid, atteguiner fair and uovarnished.” W. BE. CONNELLEY tn the Topeka CAPITAL. “The on Burlington (lowa) HAWKEYE. “It ts « book which wiil prejudiced student and seeker for truth will herald the book as « take a place in the library of every well established home in this ntribution to American history part of the country.’ FIRST EDITION EXHAUSTED IN 7 WEEKS Fully Ulustrated with portraits and other illustrations, With copious notes and bibliography. $5.00 net. Postage 26 cents. Boston HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMP ANY New York _j