The Nation 1910-11-24: Vol 91 Iss 2369

Page 1

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 24, 1910. The Week. “President Taft’s policy of a scientific revision of the tariff, schedule by sched- ule,” says the London Economist, “de- ceives no one and appeals to no one. It is at best a plea for scientific protection, and the most that can be hoped for it is that a few of the most favored monop- olists may be reduced to something like the level of protection obtained by oth- er traders.” The Economist is right. And the first big task confronting the Democratic party in its new position of strength will be that of placing before the people a prospect of relief more sub- stantial than is offered by any such principle as that of making the tariff cover the difference, or alleged differ- ence, of cost of production between this country and foreign countries. It is a curious circumstance that in one re- spect—and that a very important one— this new formulation of the protection- ist principle goes beyond anything that used to be avowed by the protectionists themselves in their palmiest days. We refer to the entire and almost formal abandonment the infant-industries plea. After telling us for half a century that protection was to be used for the purpose of building up industries which would ultimately stand on their feet, we are now asked to tax ourselves per- manently in support of any industry, however costly, to just the extent that its extra cost may require. of The position of President Taft in re- gard to the Cunningham claims is made very plain by the letter from Mr. Norton, secretary to the President, in reply to the request made by Gifford and Amos_ Pinchot some days ago. Final action will not be taken on the claims with- out the previous consent of the Presi- dent, after submission to him of all the evidence. The President assents to the proposal of the Messrs. Pinchot to sub- mit to him a brief on the subject. It now rests with Mr. Taft to take such steps in regard to the examination of the whole case as will insure its deci- sion purely on its merits, and without any complication with personal entan- glements. jsince October 22, and have been Judging from the past performances ‘of Gov.-elect. Foss of Massachusetts, Senator Lodge is in for a pretty uncom- |fortable time if he persists in his de- sire for reélection to the United States Senate. There is an Ethan Allen sound in Mr. Foss's anti-Lodge pronuncia- mento: “In the name of the majority of the sovereign people of the Common- wealth of Massachusetts,” he announces, “IT demand that Henry Cabot Lodge sur- render his seat in the United States Sen- ‘ate by withdrawing from his contest for reélection.” Behind this challenge is the undeniable fact that the election of two weeks ago was as clear a popu- lar mandate for the retirement of Lodge as could be given under the in defeating Draper for Gov- circum- stances; ernor and electing Foss by an astonish- ing majority, the people plainly showed where they stood as to Lodge and the whole policy and system that he repre- Foss says that if Lodge he will stump the State sents. Now won't retire against him. Seeing that Foss's eiec- tion to Congress was the first manifes- tation of the Democratic landslide, it looks as though he might carry the State in his war on Lodge. New fol- interesting lull the investigation The election-time in York graft by has been lowed developments enough to satisfy the most exacting. The testimony of State Senator Travis is of special interest and importance not only because of the enormous size of the bribe which fered him to vote against the anti-race- track bills, but because of the corrobor- ation it presents to the story told to the committee by Assistant District At- torney Elder before its adjournment last month. The bribery allegations in that story were not statements of facts that came directly to Mr. Elder’s know- ledge, but were the result of informa- tion imparted to him in a conversation by ex-State Senator Gardner. Travis’s testimony brings the bribe ne- gotiation itself home to Gardner. A matter that henceforth be lost sight of by the public is the state- ment made by Mr. Bruce that subpena- servers have been looking for Harry Payne Whitney and James R. he testifies was of- Senator should not Keene un- able to find them; it is to be $d “=: = hoped that when these men are made to testi- fy, the heart of the story will be got at. In the testimony of Orlando A. Jones the so-called turf interests make a sorry showing; and altogether, the more the whole race-track business is looked into, the more one realizes what a degrading mess it was that Gov. Hughes set about clearing out. Minority representation in Illinois and its corollary, cumulative voting, are attacked by the Legislative Voters’ League of that State as no longer suit- ed to conditions, and as being deleter- ious in their effect upon the kind- of men chosen at primaries and elections the civil Il solidly and Following war, southern linois Democratic, northern Illinois as solidly Republican; and minority representation was adopt- ed as a means of giving representation in the Legislature to the Republicans in the southern part of the State and to Democrats in the northern part. The alteration of this political balance has weakened the reason for the plan, and the decision of the State Supreme Court that a primary is an election, necessi- tating the application of the cumula- tive provision to primaries, has empha- sized and increased its faults. As three candidates are to be elected from each legislative district, and as the voter may cast one vote for each, one and one-half votes for each of two, or three votes for one, the majority party in a district has adopted the practice of nominating only two candidates, and the minority party, similarly, only one, thus rendering the election perfunctory. The judiciary extension of the system to the primaries hampered the voters still further. The League is therefore start- ing a campaign for a constitutional amendment providing for the division of the State into 153 districts, each one electing one member to the lower house of the Legislature. was The fine discrimination characteristic of Gov.-elect Wilson's thinking, with which the whole country is rapidly be- coming familiar, appears again in his utterance before the Business Service Lecture League in Chicago. He remark- ed: “It has been truly sald that the

Page 2

A86 people of the country were so fast asleep that it took a brass band to wake them up. But we can’t solve the problems of the day by getting in behind the brass band. The solution will come in quiet | conferences.” Credit where credit is due | could not be more justly apportioned. The muckraking, but their tacit as- sumption that it is something more than tneir of their critics is their failure to recog- the necessity of disagreeableness in initial stages of public houseclean- nize suggestion Western judge platforms should be trans- Che of a that party formed from their present unsatisfac- charact is insincere bids for jokes which by much repetition lost their point, or literature ike “Paradise Lost,” everybody praises and nobody reads, is more com mendable than his proposed method of the mandamus to bringing about the change. for courts to have power by compel their enforcement, would lead at all in turn, would once to similar power over cam.- ' and this, at the most time-hon- paizn promies be ored and interesting feature of our pol- When candidates and parties are perforce gov a fatal blow itics the day comes in which erned by reason rather than by imagina- tion, will meagre audiences to the good old times of 1910, its crowds, with real envy. they look back from their and not too responsive Until then, we shall probably have to get along with but not altogether in- effective form of mandamus that issues the untechnical on the first Tuesday after the first Mon- day in alternate Novembers The census figures for the city of San Francisco and for the State of Indiana tell kind of that been coming from so many parts of the of and stationary or declining country pop the same story has country——that rapid urban growth ulation. The figures for San Francisco of from the fact that only a few years ago are, course, the more remarkable city was almost completely destroy- In the face the ed by earthquake and fire. of this experience, the population has grown 342,782 in 1900 to 416,912 in 1910, an increase of 21% per cent.; and when it is added that the outlying in the from citles of Oakland and Berkeley — jan mistake of the muckrakers Is not! | dently, the beginning of reform; and the error | The Nation. [ Vol. 91, No. 2369 environs of San Francisco, have shown an enormous increase—doubtless stimu- lated, relatively to San Francisco, by |the earthquake itself—the showing be- comes still more remarkeble. Oakland’s | advance has been from 66,960 to 150,174, increase of nearly 125 per cent.; Berkeley's from 13,214 to 40,434, an in- crease of more than 200 per cent. Evi- neither graft nor the fight against graft has been fatal to San Francisco's aspirations in the matter of numerical growth. The Chicago alumni of Delta Upsilon, at their last banquet, adopted resolu- tions declaring that no man who failed |to do his best by his college courses had done his whole duty by his college and This statement of principles was vitalized by the establishment of a fraternity fund sufficient to supply gold medals to the Delta Upsilon undergraduates at the University of Chicago and at Northwest- ern who attain the highest average rank And to add the final emphasis, at each presenta- tion of the medals a statement is to be read, setting forth the aim of the prize and the place which, in the view of the in scholarship for the year. | alumni, scholarship should have in col-| lege life. This statement is remarkable in assigning to the mastery of know- ledge just those virtues of accurate pro- cesses of reasoning, self-reliance, and high ideals of life and duty which we have all along understood were the pe- culiar merits of college athletics. For courses of study this is high praise in- deed. If this the fraternities are going to 17 history 9, and even Greek 1, may come assume position, English and ‘to be regarded as almost as important as the mysterious figures of football sig- nals or of track records. Andreas desiring to become an American citizen takes one’s breatn away. We are quite the liberty-loving alien whose ardor for our institutions impels accustomed to him to seek citizenship, and we are not unfamiliar with those foreigners who love the flag for what it promises in the line of office. But Herr Dippel gives the motive of his seeking naturalization in words like these: “I wish to become an American citizen because of what I see is the future of grand opera in the United States.” It is not for reasons of this nature that Patti, Dippel’'s avowed reason for | Paderewskl, and the ageless Sarah have honored us | with their presence, but the new motive _is nevertheless thoroughly agreeable. Too high praise cannot be given to ‘President Taft for his frank and straightforward statement as to the fu- ture of the Panama Republic. There have been alarming and apparently well- founded statements that the republic was nearing a collapse and likely to be allowed to fall to pieces. Some of the Washington correspondents have even detailed just what savings could be made by the United States were ail of Panama to be thrown into the Canal Zone. Now, the Panama Republic, as everybody knows, fraud, and its independence can exist only by the protection of the United States. But shameful as our treatment of Colombia was, we at least gave the residents of Panama to understand that was conceived in we were sincere in our desire to relieve the “tyranny” of Colombia. Others may have thought we had our tongues in our cheeks as we said so, but those inhabitants of the new republic not on the inside of the affair believed we meant what we said. The annexa- tion of the republic now would not mere- all Latin-Americans and in- flame them against us; but it would convince Europe that we are nothing but a set of base hypocrites. Mr. Taft’s statement that we are “the guarantor of the integrity of the Republic of Pana- ma, and therefore in a sense the guar- dian of the liberties of her people as secured by your Constitution,” and that them of ly alarm this “relation neither calls for nor per- to the point when it would have been easy to mits annexation,” is exactly remain silent. Not in many years has such disquiet- ing news come from Reports of violent dissatisfaction with the Diaz régime in all parts of the republic, and of actual outbreaks at various points, are meagre, partly because the Govern- ment is in control of the telegraph wires; but the evidence seems clear that political discontent, with mutterings of 'revolution, is more marked to-day than at any time since Porfirio Diaz made himself perpetual President. Coming 'so close upon the heels of the celebra- tion of the centenary of Mexican inde- pendence, these disturbances are a sar- donic comment upon much of the glort- Mexico.

Page 3

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation fication that was indulged in upon that occasion. The world will begin to think that a military oligarchy, thinly disguis- ed as a republic, may not be the best of governments, even for Mexico. There seems little reason to doubt that the central government will be able to throw sufficient troops into the disaf- fected territory to put down the quasi- revolutionists; but the whole affair is a pretty severe reflection upon the meth- ods of Diaz, and a sobering reminder of what may come after him. The pomp and circumstance of royal progresses are to be supplemented, in the case of the Duke of Connaught’s visit at the opening of the Parliament of South Africa, by a solid residuum. Sums aggregating $2,500,000 have been subscribed for the development of the Cape University, which is apparently a mere examining and degree-conferring corporation, into a teaching residential university. This is to be brought about by incorporating existing colleges as constituents of the new institution, and by creating chairs for those subjects for which a college would not provide. Funds from various sources have ena- bled the Cape University to complete what the Duke called its handsome pile of buildings, but the money for its ex- pansion has come from two men. Mr. Alfred Beit has agreed to divert the million-dollar bequest of Mr. Otto Beit for the foundation of a university at Johannesburg, to the creation of a uni- versity at Groote Schuur, and Sir Ju- lius Wernher is to make up the amount to the aggregate named. This strength- ening of an existing institution instead of building a new one, reveals a wise unselfishness on the part of the donors. The existence of a great university for the whole of South Africa cannot but make still more perfect the Union which the possession of a single Parliament at once typifies and enforces. The German Government's throwing open of its country to the admission of foreign cattle, save on the Russian side, marks a great victory for public opin- ion and the breakdown of one of the most, interesting protection experiments the world has seen. At the behest of the Agrarians, who control the Govern- ment, the importation of foreign cat- tle was virtually prohibited. If Germans wanted to eat meat’they must eat Ger- “man meat or none at all—that was the Finnish | way to protect the home industry of cat- | tle-raising. But the Agrarians at once |took advantage of the tariff to raise the price of cattle, with the result that, as the population grew, it went still higher. | Latterly there has been a regular meat famine, with many thousands of people going without meat as they would with- out tickets to the Imperial opera. The dispatches state that the headway made by the Social Democrats in consequence of this state of affairs is what compelled | the Chancellor to permit the entry of Dutch, French, and Belgian cattle. But the Socialists were not the only ones to protest. up in arms about it, and the municipali- ties of Berlin, Frankfort-on-the-Main, ,and other cities have complained loudly and bitterly ment. For a long time the Chancellor, like his predecessor, “stood pat.” But, as in this country, the outcry against standing pat was not to be stilled. Professor Westlake of Cambridge Uni- versity has just published a letter on the Russification of Finland, in which he sets forth forcibly the “hope of Eng-| lishmen that the Czar may yet turn his Nationalists back from the fatal path.” As professor of international at Cambridge, the words of Professor Westlake have peculiar He shows how ready the Finnish Diet has been to admit the supremacy of the | Russian Government in all that con- cerns foreign affairs, but that it, and a }united people behind it, are absolutely |unwilling to surrender the separate ex- law weight. 'istence as a Grand Duchy which Fin- | land has enjoyed for a century. There is a vast difference, as Professor West- ‘lake points out, between the unity of an | Empire and an enforced uniformity | throughout all its parts. Indeed, to in-! | sist upon the latter is a very direct way | | of destroying the sentiment of Imperial ‘unity. Austria has been wiser in this matter than Russia; has left much more free play to the different races and lan- | guages under her rule. The Russian rul- lers say that the “general interests” of the Empire must be safeguarded by compelling Finland to extinguish her- self. But it may well be argued that those interests will best be taken care of by meeting the aspirations of the Liberal newspapers and the. organs of the middle classes have been | to the Imperial Govern- | 487 people, instead of crushing them out. of claims upon Morocco is a piece of good Spain's favorable settlement her fortune for the Canalejas Government. Not only will it heighten the prestige of the Ministry, and in that way strengthen it for its contest with the Clericals, but it will actually throw a wind-fall into Canalejas’s lap. For to have obtained an indemnity of $15,000,- 000 from Morocco, besides some exten- sion of Spanish territory about Melilla, must be reckoned a great help to the Prime Minister in facing his domestic These For example, one feature of the Minis- problems are partly financial. terial programme is enlarging the num- |ber of public schools—a great desider- jatum in Spain—and better equipping The Mo- make |those already in existence. |roccan indemnity will obviously the financing of this project easier, and lavoid the grumbling which Increased itaxation causes, According to a Paris report, the Unit- jed States, France, | Britain | for the rehabilitation of Liberia. jrepresented that after prolonged nego- yermany, and Great at an agreement It is have arrived | tiations the four Powers named will uni- | ify and pay off the debt of Liberia by a | joint administration of the customs. Un- jexpected is the provision that | | | Liberia, without losing in any way her sove- reignty, shall hereafter be represented |abroad either by the United States diplo- /matic and consular officers or by spe- ‘cial attachés to embassies and legations. | France, it is reported, has insisted on jharsh terms, the of which will only intensify the anti-French feel- It stipulates acceptance ing in the little republic. that French troops guard their posts in Liberia until relieved by well-organized Liberians, and demands the ratification jof the delimitation convention of 190%, by which the French helped themselves to a large slice of Liberian ‘territory. On its face this agreement is, even with its drawbacks, a_ clever achievement of Secretary Knox. ‘The problem of Liberia has had its difficul- ties on account of the dangerous prece- dents it might easily establish. For the United States to assume the direction of Liberia, many felt, was to invite our jingo politicians to reach out for sim- ilar control of a lot of South or Central American republics. coolly

Page 4

488 ENGLAND'S POLITICAL TROUBLES. Such a political crisis as that which has been precipitated upon England is usually the work of extremists in both parties. The men on either side would seek an arrangement, in- stead of rushing to battle. So they would, apparently, at the present junc- ture. There are both Liberals and Con- servatives of weight and influence, con- stituting a sort of middle body of opin- ion, who deplore a rash appeal to the ratio ultima, and still maintain that a great Constitutional question can be set- tled by the give-and-take of responsible statesmen better than by a count of noses. Baron Courtney, a stout Liberal and a high authority on the English moderate Constitution, spoke up last week for further conferences on the reform of the House and protested against taking it out of the hands of Parliament and asking the man in the street to de- cide. With such a view, it is safe to say, both Mr. Asquith aad Mr. Balfour would their hearts sympathize. Speaking of the original plan for a con- ference, the Prime Minister has said that it was an experiment which, what- ever the issue, “it was the bounden duty of the statesmanship of this country to attempt.” And Mr. Balfour has borne witness to the earnest and honorable efforts made by the Liberal members of the conference to reach a compromise. But behind the leaders in both parties has been a force against concili- ation, and now, as the Prime Minister said in the House of Commons last Fri- of Lords, in there “we revert to a state of war.” still gave the Lords the chance of averting war by accepting entire and without alteration the Government's bill to limit the veto power of the upper but, naturally, they repudiated and immediate sur- there is every pros- country will soon be another general elec- to be more bDit- even more revo- of its aspects of last January. For is from Mr. Asquith’'s statement that the Liberals are now to xo nearly the whole figure of Lloyd George and Winston Churchill. In addl- tion to their fight for what they wish to make virtually a single-chamber gov- ernment, they are going to fling them- | selves upon the labor vote. This is day, He house; such a complete that the Into render, 80 pect that plunged It contested tion promises terly and lutionary in some than the one it evident The Nation. shown by the promise to extend old-age | | speeches already mate and the political pensions even to paupers, and to intro- cries caught up, we get a foretaste of duce a bill to pay salaries to members of the fury that is to come. Hard put to This last meas- it for a slogan, the Conservatives have taken up with that of “American gold.” ure has been, it is true, approved by many Conservatives, elnce the Gubérae| This is at least an act of reciprocity; we know how many American elections judgment makin it illegal te set ad = “British gold” sought to carry. But it aside labor-union funds to support la-| is really disheartening to see a man of bor members of Parliament; and doubt | Mr. Balfour’s canter and character as- less many “Tory Democrats” will be serting, as he did the other day, that ready to accept, or at all events will Not | what the Liberals pro is “a clin dare to oppose, the plan to remove the | ton financed by American gold.” Th pauper disqualification for old-age pen- | cefememas fo ts Cha Senta Ran ang i hon sions. Yet the whole maneuvre of the o ‘country by the Irish Nationalists. There Government has an unpleasant look. ‘is nothing new about this, and we be- Mr. Asquith acts like a man pushed on) Saati del ani alee rly s by irreconcilable extremists. Indeed, y so large sums /have been collected thi a both English parties are to be blamed | mmon ae tae Gane of =r se io for letting the political situation get out * ° rt of the money now procured came of hand, and hurrying the country into en d » |from the Irish in Canada, yet no Con- an election for which the sound reason | |servative will shriek about “Canadian is not apparent, and which may result | ea gold. We shall hear a great deal about simply in making a great upheaval, but |American millionaires seeking to buy leaving the balance of parties a! mines en 00: Se ok Homa an English election, and it may prove a |“good-enough” battle-c till after the The Government's position is, . Pes wd of ‘election; but it does not ra expecta- course, intelligible. It merely goes back - [ Vol. oh No. 2369 the House of Commons. |tions that the coming struggle will be /conducted on a —? level. to the condition of things before the conference. Mr. Asquith contends that | the Liberal party cannot carry on the Government without some kind of | CORPORATION MORALS. guarantee that its work shall not be It is possible that the officers of the blocked by the Lords, in which the Con-|New York Central Railroad Company servatives have always a brute major-| Will be able to’give a better look than ity. Only by undertaking to extort some they now wear to the peculiar facts re- such assurance, or to force through the lating to their figures of operating ex- needed legislation, could the Prime Min- | penses, as brought out by the report of ister obtain the votes of the Irish and | Mr. J. C. Wallace, one of the examiners members for the budget last of the Interstate Commerce Commis- spring. He is now merely carrying out sion. If they are able to do so, the soon- the pledges he then made. But there er they go about it the better. The has really been since a great change in things to be explained are not only the the situation. The country has come figures, which have much the look of over fully to the view that the House having been so manipulated as to give of Lords as it was has become impos- all possible countenance to the argu- sible. All parties are ready to modify | ment that increased expenses have made the hereditary principle, and to create necessary the proposed increase in a House of Lords that shall be more freight rates, but also certain correspon- representative and more accessible to dence between officers of the company public opinion. The Lords themselves which has the appearance we are in the have voted to make sweeping changes habit of associating with illicit desires, in the composition of their House; and | if not intentipns. When a financial off- it ie virtually certain that some fur- cer of a railway, after having submitted ther limitation or definition of their for legal advice a proposition to carry powers would be agreed to all round. | over an item of revenue to a subsequent But the hopes of a reasonable adjust-| quarter, with the apparent purpose of ment seem now to be dashed, and in-| making a poorer showing of revenue, stead of conciliation, we are to have,|and having it adversely reported on, after the long truce, a “state of war.” upon the ground that it is illogical, Reason as well as law is apt to be|though perhaps not illegal—when such silent in the midst of war, and in the|an officer writes “my only interest, of Labor

Page 5

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation. course, is the effect that it may have | upon matters now being considered,” it does not look as if his interest were one that would stand impartial scrutiny. If its bearing upon “matters now being considered” were entirely legitimate, there is no good reason why he should not use plain English in referring to them. When will corporation managers learn that honesty is the best policy, and that plain and frank statement of facts is the best evidence of honesty? If there was any justification for the New York Central in departing from its past methods of apportioning its expenses for replacement of ties and rails, why did not the officers of the company so state in submitting their figures, in- stead of leaving the change itself to be discovered by a Government expert? Possibly the condemned locomotives come into a different category, but it looks as though there was a remarka- ble concentration of that kind of thing into the particular month or quarter that is made the basis of the company’s claim of need for higher rates. What could be more destructive of the weight attaching to any representations made by railway heads in general than an ex- posure of want of fairness or honesty in simple matters of straight bookkeep- ing? The company may prove itself in- nocent of such a sin in this case, but appearances are against it, and the Gov- ernment examiner has certainly been impressed with a strong conviction that the accounts in the three items to which he refers were manipulated for the pur- pose of producing a false impression. If we cannot place reliance upon statements in which the elements are, comparatively speaking, so simple and definite, how much less are we to trust assertions relating to matters of ex- treme complexity, on which, even with the best will in the world, it is impossi- ble to arrive at an absolute conclusion! Take such a matter as that of the com- muter business, on which the Pennsyl- vania Railroad was heard the other day. It is difficult enough, on its face, to be- lieve that this or any other railway com- pany would deliberately carry hundreds of thousands of suburban passengers at a loss, year after year. In order that such an assertion should be received with any degree of credence by the public, there must be the strongest kind of presumption in favor of the trustworthi- ness of any statement coming from the management of the company. But how is such a presumption, in a matter in- volving most delicate and elastic consid- erations, to be maintained, when rail- way men render themselves suspect in matters of mere ordinary bookkeeping? Of course, so far as the commission is concerned, it will take into account, in the matter of commutation rates, the well-known factors bearing on them oth- er than that of immediate receipts. For instance, to the building up of suburban business as a whole, the commutation rates for daily passen- gers have been indispensable. But, such as it is, the argument of the companies is incalculably weak- in its general’ effect want of confidence, for which just such ened by a things as this latest affair of the New York Central are responsible. The same day that brought this matter forward gave us an initial judgment against one of the biggest industrial corporations of the country, charged with stealing water from New York city to the extent of $525,000. mean to put the question raised by the New York Central’s bookkeeping the same category with the Sugar Trust’s theft either of the city’s wa- ter or of the United States ment’s customs dues. It is well to pre- We do not into Govern- serve distinctions, and there are differ- ences of kind and of degree in dishon- esty. But nothing that our corporations, and our men in “big business” general- ly, could do would be half so much to their benefit in the long run—we mean in a strictly worldly sense, of the moral side there is no need to speak—as the adoption of a policy of absolute candor and honesty in dealing with every re- quirement of the law. knows when the time may come when the ex- isting organization of business and so- ciety will be subjected to tests strength compared to which anything we have as yet gone through is the mer- est child’s-play; and then the most crucial single element in the whole sit- uation will lie in the confidence, or want of confidence, of the people in the essential honesty of the conduct of the great business interests. To establish such confidence is the greatest task now resting upon our “captains of indus- try.” No one of 489 NAVY-YARD REFORM. Secretary Meyer has managed to make his recent trip of inspection of the East- ern and Southern navy yards highly profitable, in that he has found ways of saving fully $300,000. But even important is the Secretary's determina- more tion to recommend to Congress the dis- continuance of certain navy yards and really efficient That this is a bold undertaking is plain to every one who has followed the history of the var- making of others manufacturing plants. the ious navy yards. Most of them have been of the purely political variety, de- pending upon Congressional log-rolling for continuance, as they did for their establishment. They have been a fre- quent source of corruption, direct and indirect, and sectional feeling has been invoked and war-scares created, if nec- essary, to ward off inquiry or to fos ter large appropriations. So far no Secretary of the Navy or President has been able to make headway against this abuse. Hence it is refreshing to hear Mr. Meyer declare publicly that he will take the bull by the horns and call for the abolition of all the navy yards be- low Norfolk, save one to be supplemen- tary to the Guantanamo naval station is most enthuslastic— that for about which he apparently forgetting nobody in that Cuban port votes American Congressmen. Perhaps Mr. Meyer is encouraged to attempt his crusade against navy-yard the Senate of Senator Hale as Mr. Hale has performed by his refusal to be stam- by he none the less laid himself open to crit- waste by approaching retirement the Valuable service from of Maine. peded the big-navy mania, has icism by the skill with which he has nursed his pet navy yard at Portsmouth, New Hampshire. In this place, in one year, $790,000 was expended for labor- work ers—with votes—who valued at only $418,804. At New Orleans, produced in the same year, the output was worth $1,046 at a cost of $78,274; its floating drydock takes care of about one ship a year; yet the dock alone cost a million. At the Key West yard in 1907 an expen- diture of $94,318 resulted in a product valued at $7,126. Senator Hale’s navy yard has cost more than $10,000,000; its drydock meant an investment of $1,100,000. Yet the waterway to the yard is so bad that no battleship is docked there, and even a gunboat ap-

Page 6

~~ 490 proaches it with great caution. At least four other yards are defective because of their insufficient channels—Key West, Mare Island, Port Royal, and Charleston, S. C. At the last-named yard, which has cost above $4,000,000, the river is too narrow for any large ship to manceuvre. Hence, of late years it has been used as a station for torpedo-boats and de- stroyers. But the Port Royal yard re- mains the classic example of waste due to political influence. As far back as 1876 a naval board could see no reason whatever for recommending a navy yard there, but from 1898 to 1908 $1,- 084,346.26 expended it, drydock built, has never because the only battleship was on and a costly which been ever docked there went aground in try- used ing to get out. Port Royal is now aban- doned save it training for a marine barracks, al- though would have made an ideal naval station, where appren- tices and recruits could drill the year round. But instead of using it for this purpose, a few years ago Congress vot- ed the establishment of a training sta- tion on the Great Lakes, on which $10,- 000,000 must be spent, and this in a cll- mate where men cannot be drilled out of doors or venture upon the water in small boats for five months in the year. Even at Annapolis, recently rebuilt at an enormous cost, the water approaches are so poor that no battleships can lie off the Academy, where our naval offi- cers are trained, and, according to the Coast Survey, conditions there are get- ting worse. The Mare Island yard is another place where money has been literally thrown the prodigality and solely for political rea- sons. Although a high official recom- mended its abandonment in 1898, yet in the next ten years $728,886.12 was spent into water with for dredging the channel into which bat- tleships venture only with the greatest uncertainty, and where they frequently go aground, During this same ten years $5,124,712.49 spent yard itself. We notice that the Charles- was on the ton News and Courier ia still hopeful that Mr. Meyer will not recommend the abolition of the navy yard at its city; indeed, it says “the greatest navy yard of the Union should be situated here. Alas, for Charleston! There Is on rec- ord an official report by Rear-Admiral Sumner, submitted to the Fifty-sixth 7 P } utterly reckless | search of peace for his soul. The rest he | dreevitch Tolstoy, one of The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2369 Congress, in which he describes Charles- ton as a place sui generis: A fossil, an antique, non-progressive, and wofully and hopelessly in the rear, com- mercially and otherwise. Its health and sanitary conditions are shocking and dis- graceful. It has no proper sewerage sys- It has no adequate fresh-water sup- ply. It is the worst hurricane harbor on the It is not and cannot be made a fit harbor for heavy deep-draught vessels such as are common in this day. From an engineering point of view it would seem to be an absurdity to locate a naval station anywhere in Charleston harbor. tem. coast. Yet after this report was made, owing to politics, the Port Royal navy yard vas moved to Charleston! These facts are enough, we think, to show how great Secretary Meyer’s op- portunity is, and why we credit the re- | port that he will recommend the closing of the Charleston, New Orleans, Ports- mouth, and Port Royal yards, as also, we hope, that at Mare Island. President Taft deeply interested in cutting down the expenses of the government. Secretary Meyer, backed up by Congress and the public, could stop the waste of if naval expenditures were is millions, made as are those of a private, honest- ly managed corporation. Nowhere else is there a greater opportunity for mak- ing savings, except in the War Depart- ment, where the waste is going on at an even greater rate, but where there has been no real head since Mr. Root re- signed. TOLSTOY. There was something heroic, if pain- ful, in the thought of an old man like Count Tolstoy, leaving his home and family and setting out on a lonely pil- grimage, in revolt against a civiliza- tion he had so often denounced and in desired came to him in the form of death, early Sunday morning, in a hut at the railway flag station of Astapova. His wife and other members of the fam- ily had been summoned, and there were six physicians in attendance. His last articulate words were in singular har- mony with his life: ‘There are mil- lions of people in the world and many of them are suffering. Why then are you all around the bed of one sick man?” Count Lyeff Nikolaevitch Tolstoy was born at Yasnaya Polyana on August 28 (September 9), 1828. His father was a retired colonel who had taken part in the campaign of 1812-13, and was de- scended in a direct line from Peter An- Peter the Great's co-laborers in reform, His moth- er, Princess Marya Nikolaevna Volkon- sky, died before he was two years old, and he, his sister, and brothers, were looked after for several years by a dis- 'tant relative. Their educational advan- tages were meagre; German governors and Russian theological students suc |ceeded each other frequently as instruc tors, and none of them remained long. In 1843, Lyeff Nikolaevitch entered the course of Oriental languages in the Kazan University, remained one year, changed to the law course, to which he - adhered two years, and was preparing to go into the third course when his broth- ers passed their final examination. When they set out for the country, he left the university without completing his stud- ies. Yasnaya Polyana had fallen to his share in the division of the estate; thither went the eighteen-year-old boy, and there he dwelt almost uninterrupt- edly until 1851, only occasionally pay- ing a visit to Petersburg or Moscow. It is not known whether he wrote during this period, or what was the fate of his first efforts. The desire to be with his brother and to see the country lauded by Russian | poets led him in 1851 to the Caucasus, where he entered the service as non- commissioned officer in his brother’s battery. Here he began to write in ro- mantic form. It is a generally accepted | belief that “Childhood, Boyhood, Youth,” |of which the first section was completed and sent to the Contemporary in 1852, was intended to serve as the beginning of a great romance drawn from family memoirs and traditions. The second | part was also written in the Caucasus, as well as the series of sketches of Cau- casian military life entitled “The Incur- sion,” “Cutting Wood,” and the novel “The Cossacks,” which was printed much later. Tolstoy’s literary talent soon became fully defined, and his fame was es- tablished in the most cultivated circles of the Russian public. The young au- thor occupied an honorable place in the group of favorite authors of the sixties along with Turgeneff, Gontcharoff, Os- trovsky, Grigorovitch, and Pisemisky. New ideas were seething everywhere. Lyeff Nikolaevitch, who had lived close to the people from his early youth, un- derstood clearly his own sphere of ac- tivity. It must not be supposed, how- ever, that he introduced the peasant into literature. Grigorovitch was the first to write tales of peasant life in 1847; Turgeneff, Tolstoy, and others merely followed in his popular footsteps. After the emancipation of the serfs, Tolstoy was one of the few Russian pro- prietors who decided to settle perma- nently on their estates. He was for a time one of the arbiters between the proprietors and the peasants, occupied himself zealously with the schools for the people, and issued an original peda- gogical journal, Yasnaya Polyana, In this he began to utter his views, de rived from observation and experience;

Page 7

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation and to formulate his ideas on the neces- sity of educating the people, and on the sort of education which was adapt- ed to them. He also ventured to express serious doubts as to what is generally called culture (in the largest | sense), civilization, and progress. In view of the wide interest which his ut- terances on these subjects have attract- ed in recent years, it is important to bear in mind the early development of the ideas which have been falsely re- garded as novel. In reality, they belong to this epoch of Russia, and are not es- pecially of Tolstoy’s invention. In 1862, Count Tolstoy married Sophia Andreevna Bers, the deughter of a doc- tor, born in Moscow; devoted himself to family life, which had always been his ideal, and became more absorbed than ever in his rural idyl. His moral life previous to this time has been outlined by himself in his “Confession.” For many years nothing from his pen ap peared, until the end of the sixties, when “War and Peace” was begun in the Rus- sian Messenger. From the very first mo- ment it occupied a place of peculiar prominence such as nothing except Pushkin’s works had ever attained in the Russian literary world. One of the most remarkable points about it was the sudden revelation of the author’s ability to depict women. Up to this time no well-delineated female characters had ‘entered into his works; and here, on a sudden, a whole constellation of wo men, wonderfully delicate and true to life, flashed upon the reader’s vision. In 1875, “Anna Karenina” was begun, also in the Russian Messenger. After some years, during which he wrote “What to Do?” “Ivan Ilitch,” and a number of brief stories with moral aim —which occasionally err by containing two conflicting lessons—intended for the cheap, popular library, he added some belated pedagogical matter, and issued a twelfth volume of his collected works. Since then he has written a dramatical work, “The Realm of Dark- ness,” artstic but revolting, whose mor- al was wrongly construed by the peas- ants for whose edification it was com- posed; a comedy ridiculing spiritualism, called “The Fruits of Civilization”; a study from the early Christian era in- culcating brotherly and sisterly love in- stead of passion as the true foundation for marriage, entitled “Walk in the Light”—published in English under the title of “Out of Darkness into Sunlight” —the “Kreutzer Sonata,” which preaches celibacy and the extermination of the human race; “What is Art,” wherein he sums up the dicta of numerous previous writers, and his own observations, and arrives at the general conclusion that “art for art’s sake”—all art, in fact—is 4mmoral and indefensible; “Resurrec- tion,” and a number of articles on so- cial, religious, and political topics, many of which were sent direct to foreign | journals for publication. These propa- | Sandist articles do not represent any | essentially new idea, being, in the main, | merely repetitions of his arraignment of Church, State, and all the universally accepted institutions of modern civiliza- |tion, such as law courts, factories, and ‘so forth. It is safe to assert that Count Tol- stoy’s permanent place in literature at home, and more particularly abroad, will rest upon his two great novels, “War and Peace” and “Anna Karenina.” In them the peculiar power of Russians to visualize a situation and to express the passionate instincts of the human heart reach their consummation. Count Tolstoy passed but little time abroad. Yet there is an international, a uni- versal, rather than a strictly Russian quality about his best work, in spite of its absolute fidelity to the details of local life. The force of this point is best brought out by a comparison. Tur- geneff spent a great part of his adult life abroad. Though surrounded by for- eign atmosphere, that atmosphere never invaded his novels. He evidently re- mained to the day of his death a Rus- sian pure and simple. His characters are Slav to the very marrow. His style has the brilliance and play of light of a jewel. There are few artistic and in- tellectual treats as delicate as that of- fered by the perusal of one of those se- {verely condensed novels, which would | fill thrice the space of Tolstoy's if elabor- ‘ated on Tolstoy’s plan; which are cloth- led in language that has not a superflu- |ous syllable and that cuts like a knife. /'Down to the present day, he can be ‘thoroughly appreciated only by those persons who are well versed in the finer points of the Russian tongue and Rus- \sian nature, and who can read between ‘the lines in these productions, each of 'which evoked a cry and a protest from ithe Russians, whose tender points had been mercilessly laid bare. Tolstoy, on the other hand, had a mind of com- posite architecture: on one side Byzan- tine, on the other Renaissance. His per- sonages are cosmopolitan to such a de- gree that they can be readily understood by foreigners who possess no knowledge of the language, country, or people. Anna Karenina is as true a world-type as Becky Sharp. Tolstoy’s style in de- scriptive passages is often rugged and tautological. His effects are gained in spite of it. One never re-reads a phrase lof his for its artistic beauty, as one ‘does constantly in the case of Turgeneff. Of Tolstoy’s religio-dogmatic works it is difficult to speak justly with either ‘frankness or reserve. That his para- ‘doxes and contradictions are susceptible of a very simple explanation, the public must be content to accept as a fact, as it must also accept the statement that he was never crazy, despite the appar- ‘ently aimless arguments of “Life,” the ‘apparently inexplicable character of the 491 “Kreutzer Sonata” and its publication. His religious essays have comparative ly little literary or philosophical value, and their moral value is equal to that of innumerable similar attempts, in many ages and lands, to induce the com- plicated society of to-day to beat a re treat to the utterly different conditions of primitive Christianity. We may safe- ly assume that the permanent value of his “propaganda” (as the Russians call it) lies strictly in its softening influence upon occasional individual souls. And his political and artistic notions were like his religious theories, were indeed in no wise separable from the latter. As Prince Kropotkin said, in a lecture delivered in the course of a vis- it to America, Tolstoy was at heart an anarchist. He preached a return to the Gospel; as a matter of fact, he forgot that the Gospel, in its naked simplicity, was devised for a remnant and not for a civilization. His real inspiration was Rousseau’s doctrine of a return to na- ture, carried out in his mind to an ex- treme which Rousseau never contemplat- ed. So to him the only criterion of art was the taste of the uneducated peasant, ,and in some of his own later works, he unfortunately tried to cater to that taste in its most brutalized form. By pre cept and example, he set out to show that the world could be made over by purity and brotherhood. But even among his own countrymen, his teach- ings fell on deaf ears. The very classes to which he especially appealed showed the least signs of heeding him. He could have spared their overflowing af- fection for him if they had only shown ar intention of doing the things he said. It was followers his soul craved, yet followers he can scarcely be said to have had. For a time, indeed, there were groups of those who took up with the method of life which Tolstoy preach- ed—“Tolstovtsi,” they called themselves. Their coming into existence greatly heartened Tolstoy. He rubbed his hands and said: “My fire must be real if it sets others aflame!” But there we3 no permanent blaze. The temporary en- thusiasm died out, until, as Madame Witte wrote, “There are no longer any fraternal colonies in Russia, nor are there Tolstovtsi. Only one remained— Tolstoy himself.” Tolstoy has been called a prophet. So cool a head as Anatole France declares to-day that Tolstoy is entitled to rank as “one of the prophets of the new era.” This is because of his burning hatred of war, his unceasing struggle for the amelioration of society, and his passion- ate holding up of an ideal of humanity. When his particular message has been forgotten, he will be remembered as one of the great figures to whom otherworld- ly truth, as he saw it, was more real than all the rest of life. That inspira- tion is not a little thing. The world is not easily deceived about a great man.

Page 8

492 It knows one the universal feeling about the passing of Leo Tolstoy is of such a nature and depth as to place the spiritual great- ness of the man beyond all narrow ques- tioning. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. Late in 1839, though dated 1840 on the title-page Lea & Blanchard published in Philadelphia the “Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque,” by Edgar Allan Poe. This, Prof or Harrison has called “the most original volume of short stories ever pub- lished.” The collection, in fact, made two volume and ineluded twenty-five tales, among them some of Poe's greatest work. seven hundred and fifty printed June, 1841, Poe to Dr. Snodgrass of Baltimore: It is said that only cop were In was writing Touching mv Tales you will scarcely be- lieve me when I tell you that I am ignorant of their fate, and have never spoken to the publishers concerning them since the day of their issue. I have cause to think, how- ever, that the edition was exhausted almost mmediately. On August 13, 1841, Poe was suggesting a new edition to Lea & Blanchard in a let- ter the original of which is in the Drexel Philadelphia: I wish to publish a new collection of my collection in Institute prose Tales with some such title as this: “The Prose Tales of Edgar A. Poe, Includ- ng “The Murders in the Rue Morgue,’ the ‘Descent into the Maelstrom,’ and all his later pl with a second edition of the ‘Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque.’” The latter pieces will be eight in number, making the entire collection thirty-three— which would occupy two thick novel vol- umea, I am anxious that your firm should con- tinue to be my publishers, and, if you would be willing to bring out the book, I should be glad to accept the terms which they allowed me before—that is—you re- ceive all profits and atlow me twenty copies for distribution to friends. His publishers replied as follows: r we very much regret to say that the state of affairs is such as to give little encouragement to new undertak'ngs As yet we have not got through the edition of the other work and up to this time it has not returned to us the expense of its pub- lication, This was begun in 1843 by another publisher, Willlam H. Graham. It as the cover stated, a “Uniform In answ. new edition was to be Serial Edition Fach number complete in iteelf.” But only No. 1 was ever issued. This contained two stories, “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” and “The Man that Was Used Up.” but a copy The publication price was 12% cents (lacking back cover) eold at the Frank Maler sale just a year age for $3,800 Meanwhile, Charles Dickens in his first visit to America in 1842 had met Poe, and on his return home undertook to find an Englieh publisher for an edition of the “Tales.” \ few months after his return that is, on November 27, 1842, Dickens wrote to Poe I should have forwarded you the ac- companying letter from Mr. Moxon before now, but that I have delayed doing so in the hope that some other channel for the publication of our book on this side of the water would present itself to me. I am, however, unable to report any success. I have mentioned it to publishers with whom I have influence, but they have, one and all, declined the venture. And the only consolation I not believe any collection of detached pieces when it sees him. And can give you is that I do | The Nation. by an unknown writer, even though he were an Englishman, would be at all likely to find a publisher in this metropolis just now. From the above letter we might have surmised that Poe had prepared a correct- ed copy of his “Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque,” with additions, perhaps, for Dickens to submit to the English pub- lishers. his, heretofore, has been sur- mise only, but now the book has come to light (at least the first volume has), and has been acquired by Stephen H. Wake- man of this city, adding another jewel to his wonderful Poe collection. This book is a copy of the first volume of the Philadelphia, 1840, “Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque” with title and preliminary matter removed. Inserted is a new manuscript title in Poe’s autograph: “Phantasy—Pieces | by | Edgar Allan Poe. | (Including all the author’s late tales with | a new edition of the ‘Grotesque and Ara- besque’).”” This is followed by a three-line quotation from Goethe, which had appear- ed on the title-page of the Philadelphia book: Seltsamen tochter Jovis, Seinem schosskinde Der Phantasle. Below this is “Three Volumes,” the “Three” marked out and “Two” written above. Pasted on the back of this title- page is a manuscript list headed ‘“Con- tents” and including thirty-six titles with two others marked out. On the margin is the inscription “To Printer—In printing the Tales preserve the order of the Table of Contents."”" The old heading at the top of the first page of text is marked out and a new one, ‘‘Phantasy-Pieces,” is written above. Poe, as well known, was always re- vising his writings and, with a very few exceptions, there are autograph manuscript alterations and corrections on every page of the volume. Some of these are merely changes in punctuation, but many others are of textual importance. In the head- lines of “The Fall of the House of Usher” the first three words are marked out at the top of every page. The title of “The Signora Zenobia” is changed to “How to Write a Blackwood Article,” and that of “The Scythe of Time” to “A Predicament.” Six lines in “The Signora Zenobia” are marked out ‘and twelve new lines in manuscript are on a slip, pasted in, with this note: “To Printer—Substitute this for what is mark- ed out in pencil.” Professor Harrison, in his edition of Poe’s Works, the latest and best edition, gives a variorum of all trace- able forms of the Tales, but he did not have access to the present volume. Most of them appeared first in some periodical, then in the “Tales of the Grotesque and Arabesque” in 1840, next in the volume “Tales” published by Wiley and Putnam in 1845, and finally in the Broadway Jour- nal, of which Poe was editor in the same year. A few only, however, made all four appearances. The manuscript variations in_ this Dickens copy have apparently never | been utilized by any editor and seem to) be in part unprinted, though some of the | changes were adopted in the 1845 volume or in the Broadway Journal, Numerous) is examples might be quoted but space per- | mits the citation of a few only. | The second tale in the volume, “Lioniz- was first printed ing,” in the Southern | lect. [Vol. or. No. 2369 Literary Messenger in 1835. When reprint- ed in 1840 the changes, though numerous, were not important. In 1845 it was vir- tually rewritten. In 1835 and 1840 the name of the narrator is given as “Thomas Smith.” This is altered to “John Smith” throughout, in the Dickens volume, and was changed to “‘Robert Jones” in 1845. At the end of the tale “William Wilson” the phrase “it appeared to me”’ is expanded in manuscript to ‘‘(so at first 1t appeared to me in my confusion).” In the Broadway Journal the additional words occur but “appeared” was altered to “seemed.” On the same page “Not a line” is expanded to “Not a thread in all the raiment—not a line,” ete. This also was used in the Broadway Journal but “the raiment” be- comes “his raiment.’’ Altogether this is perhaps the most interesting of the sev- eral Poe items which have been unearthed in recent years. Correspondence. THE PRIZES OF SCHOLARSHIP. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Your editorial on Scholarship and Athletics goes too far, it seems to me, in laying so much stress on the advantages of “the mere elimination of a multitude of minor topics from the curriculum.” While it is doubtless true that many minor topics are offered for the sake of appearances by men who have no particular interest in teaching them, it frequently happens that a teacher is at his best in the minor course which appeals to him most. Personally, I do not believe that the elimination of the possibility of teaching subjects which ap- peal strongly to the individual teacher would do anything toward “bringing back into our faculties men, who, by their intel- lect and personality, command admiration.” In the old days, when there were far fewer topics, and when every one was obliged to take the standard courses in Greek, Latin, and mathematics, the proportion of teach- ‘ers who commanded a following by reason of their intellect and personality was not any greater than it is to-day, if, indeed, it was as large. It seems to me that the difficulty is not so much with the number of courses—dis- tinguished foreigners to the contrary not- withstanding—as with the kind of questions we ask. It Has been my experience that the majority of examiners and quiz mas- ters ask questions which depend more on the student’s ability to memorize than on his ability to think. {The average teacher lays more stress on memory than on intel- Some teachers have a positive dislike of allowing a student to get credit for in- herited cleverness. To their minds the patient drudge who will work three hours on a lesson, is more to be admired tian the clever fellow who can write as good a paper after only an hour of work. The questions they ask are frequently aimed at eliminating the possibility of a man’s get- ting through on his cleverness. Many of us have too much of the old-fashioned schoolmaster’s idea that the principal thing for us to do is to make tho students work. Now the athletic coach, for whose mental equipment you say the student has so much respect, is not primarily interested in mak-

Page 9

Nov. 24, 1910] ing his men work. He is after results, and it is by results, not by the amount of work they do, that his men are judged. Many a student would willingly run ten extra miles if that would secure him the privilege of wearing the coveted initial. But under our present system the average student cannot make an athletic team, no matter how hard he tries, unless he has an unusually good physical equipment. On the other hand, he can make the first division in his class, even if he has not a specially clever brain, provided only he is willing to spend enough hours memorizing his lessons. It hardly needs to be added that a born athlete who will not train, and who shirks his work, generally fails of recognition. I would not have it thought that I am in fa- vor of rewarding any student who depends on sheer cleverness. I do think, however, that we ought to make it just as possible for the clever student, who is willing to work, to excel the mere drudge, as it is for the born athlete to surpass the ordinary man who is willing to spend more hours in training. I believe that the trouble lies in the type of questions usually asked. The bane of our present college teaching is the frequen- cy of questions beginning with “what” and “who,” and the infrequency of those begin- ning with “why” and “how.” Of course, such questions are harder to make out, harder to answer, and harder to mark than those de- signed to see whether the student can give back what he has heard the instructor say, or has read in the text-book. But my own experience has been that the results are correspondingly far more satisfactory. Furthermore, if the instructor would be- forehand give out a number of such ques- tions from which he proposed to select one to be used in the daily or weekly test, he would eliminate very largely that element of chance which so many students feel is indis- solubly connected with academic work. The average student, “trusting to luck” that he may get a question that he can answer, knows that the instructor will not be likely tu ask any question on which a student who has read the lesson over once, carefully, can- not do mode-ately well, and is naturally dis- inclined to undertake more than the mini- mum amount of mental effort. If he kncews beforehand, however, that there is to be ne luck about it, and that he is perfectly sure to get one of half a dozen previously as- signed problems, he is usually willing to take time to stop and think on those ques- tions; provided, of course, that they have been worded in such a manner as to require thought, and not simply memory, This works particularly well when, as one result of his work, his name appears among the elect, those chosen because they have brains and know how to use them. This leads to one more suggestion. I have come to believe sincerely in the efficacy of introducing the element of competition into scholarship, as has been so forceful- ly indicated by President Lowell, and is practised at West Point. I have tried the plan of posting after every written exercise a list of the class in the order of excel- lence, but without confusing the matter by announcing marks. The football coach does not give out percentages, but publishes a list of successful candidates, or assigns places on the first and second team. Some teachers say that it is childish to revert to anything resembling the old “spelling bee’ Th e Nation. methods. On the other hand, I have found that the posting of this list appeals to just that type of student who is normally only too well satisfied with the mark of “C,"’ the “gentleman's grade.” He dislikes to have it known that in answering questions re- quiring ideas, and ability to express them, he is behind his fellows. Correspondingly he enjoys being at or near the top of such a list. Furthermore, once let it be clearly understood that the list is based on the as- sumption that a man’s ideas are hisown and you eliminate the difficulty of “printed notes” and outside “seminars.” There still remains to be mentioned that old story, the tremendous influence of home atmosphere on a student’s scholastic activi- ties. So long as father and mother, and brothers and sisters, are more proud of see- ing their hero wear an “H,” a “Y,” or a “Pp,” than a ®. B. K. key, just so long will our students strive more in athletics than in scholarship. And yet I must believe that if we made the key stand more for rea! intel- lectual power and less for mere faithful drudgery, the day would come when the av- erage father would be more delighted to welcome to his office a son who could wear a key than one who could only wear an initial. HIRAM BINGHAM. Yale University, November 12. A FOOTNOTE TO “RICHARD FEVEREL.” To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Has it been observed that, in the 1862 volume of poems, “Modern Love,” etc., Meredith gives us a poetical footnote to “Richard Feverel”? The poem _ entitled “Phantasy,” though deservedly passed with- out comment by the critics of Meredith's art, is nevertheless not without interest to students of his thought. First printed (in Once a Week) two years after the publi- cation of “Richard Feverel,” it makes al- lusion to the “wise youth,” and presents in theme and doctrine a curious parallel to the first of Meredith’s novels. The poem relates the dream of a man who has de- serted his “village lily’’—whom he holds cheap, “and the dream arouad her idle’— for a trip abroad with “cynical Adrian.” The bells of Bruges, a ballet-dancer, and the want of his village lily unite to pro- duce a vision grotesque and fantastic enough for a Gothic romancer. The dreamer falls a victim to a delicious but unholy sisterhood, who are dragging him down to watery depths of perdition. He is saved only by an appeal to the village lily: Save me! save me! for now I know The powers that Nature gave me, And the value of honest love | know :— My village lly! save me! P Come ‘twixt me and the sisterhood, While the passion-born phantoms are fleeing! Oh, he that is true to flesh and blood, Is true to bis own being! And be that is false to flesh and blood, Is false to the star within him: And the mad and hungry sisterhood All under the tides shall win him! If it were not for the mention of Adrian, we might overlook the reminders of “Rich- ard Feverel.” But with that to start us, we are inclined to carry through the par- | the allel: the village lily suggests Lucy; “passionate Wili” suggests Mrs. Mount; and the trip with Adrian reminds us of Richard's enforced absence from his young bride. The cynical Adrian represents, per- 493 haps, an attitude towards love abhorrent equally to sentiment and physiology. As in the novel, outraged nature will have its revenge, if only in a dream, We nize the keynote of all Meredith's work in the magnifying of nature; and we have an anticipation of the praise of honest Aphrodite, sung more at iength the “Reading of Life.” The early gives such an impression of juvenility that one would like to regard it as a preliminary sketch on the theme of the novel; such an hypothesis, at any rate, would make the pcem no less significant a commentary on the novel. JoserpH WARREN Breacn recog- especially in poem University of Minnesota, November 15 THE LIFE OF ALEXANDER HAMILTON. lo THE EpItorR oF THE NaTION: Sir: In your last issue, in noticing my life of my grandfather, you criticise me for using the word /dches in reference to the weaknesses of Hamilton and his con- temporaries. My use of this term doeg not imply the severe censure you suggest. In looking over my dictionaries, which include the Century, Webster's, Worcester’s, and March's Thesaurus, I find it defined as “laxness,”’ “‘remissness,” “‘slackness,” and “non-observance,”’ and derived from lacher, which Spiers and Surennes, Gase and oth- ers, define as “to slacken,” “to let slip,” “to unbend.”” I really cannot see how it can be confused with anything else, al- though there is a French substantive meaning “a coward,” “a poltroon’’—which seems to be, to put it mildly, quite out of place in characterizing Hamilton. As the word I employed is so commonly made use of by intelligent people in the way I apply it, your objections seem to savor slightly of hypercriticism. ALLAN MCLANE HAMILTON. New York, November 16 {[Dr. Hamilton's note confirms our sus- picion that he did not intend to use a word so severe and insulting as ldche.— Ep. NaTION.] GLADSTONE ON THE CONSTITUTION. EDITOR OF THE NATION: At last a book has been published on the American government which does not call attention the fact that Glad- stone referred to the Federal Constitution as “the most wonderful work ever struck off at a given time by the brain and pur- pose of man.” Among the excellencies of Prof. Charles E. Beard’s “American Gov- ernment and Politics” is the omission of this statement. He would naturally have put it in the first paragraph of page 45. One is a little surprised to find Prof. A. B. Hart in this year’s edition of his “Actual Government” repeating the quotation and adding: “Mr. Gladstone was mistaken; the Federal Constitution was not a cre- ation.” This is said, with perfect serious- ness, as if anybody supposed that Mr. Gladstone thought the convention of 1787 had gone up into a mountain and received the Constitution written on tables of stone, with no basis whatever in buman experi- ence. How long its this fodsil, with its foolish gloss based on Mr. Gladstone's sup- | posed ignorance, going to cumber the books on civics? EDGAR DAWSON. New York, November 17. TO THE Sir: to

Page 10

494 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2369 PROBABILISM AND THE JESUITS. | ters's nose is very carefully, if somewhat | more than 70 per cent. if the names of _ unpleasantly, described thus: THE NATION: Nation of October 27, “J. R. letter about “Probabilism,” paragraph of which contains To THE EDITOR OF Sin: In the 8.” writes a almost every an error or a fallacy. (1.) He intimates that Newman’s Tract xe should have had weight in determining the validity of his orders; whereas, the or- ders of a priest do not depend upon his be- lief, but upon the manner of his ordination, (2.) He eriticises Rome for waiting until Duchesne’s history was translated into Italian bb condemning it. But the Congregation of the Index, as is well known, does not condemn instanter every heretical work; and it Duchesne’s book bad sufficient importance to be put into Ital- that it was placed on the list of for- bidden publications (3.) Whatever may be thought of Liguori’s opinions, it is quite certain that the Society of Jesus has never made itself responsible for them The may have approved them, but the Jesuits would be bound only by the Pope's ca cathedra utterances, Other- wise they might be supposed to approve of certain former Papal decrees against their order. Only declarations permitted or ap- proved by the general of “the company” can taken declarations of the Jesuits themselves. (4.) “J. R. SS.” remarks: “No doubt Tyr- rell would have lived and died a Jesuit if left This is simply to say that if the general of the Jesuits had not discover- ed Tyrrell’s heresy, he would not have pun- ished that heresy. was because ian Pope be as alone,” (.) R. 8S.” does, that “by a deft use of probabilism nearly everything is amounts to a perversion of the “deft” use of Bishop Butler's might lead to an ro say, as “J condoned,” do argument analogy equally unhappy result. (6.) The authority of Brownson, “the great- American Catheliec writers” (sic), ean hardly be sufficient to prove that the French Revolution is to be laid “at the door A. A. trime \ from eat of all of the Jesuits.” Neuchfte!l, Switzerland, November 5. THE NOSE IN POETRY. To THe Eprron or Tue NATION: Sin: Should it not be noted that the nose is described in English poetry, as well as in that of America, India, and Greece? In our older poetry, Chaucer alone has at | Of the Prioress six feminine was a noses! of the eleven that least onen, tretya” Idy!nesse had one while that “wel wrought"; proporsioun,” Reauty's of Fraunchise “good wae wrought at poynt devys Por it was genty!l and tretys. Deapalring of doing Justice to the nose of Gladnesse the poet says: I not what of bir nose descryve Bo faire hath no womman alyve The men's noses are also worth mention- ing. Sir “hadde a semely nose.” Myrthe's “by measure wrought ful right.”” while that of Daungere was “frounced,” and “full kirked stoode.” The miller of the “Reeve’s Tale” had a ‘“‘cam- use nose,”’ and in the “Prologue” the mil- Thopas nose was “nose | Hate's was “snorted up for tine;”’ | of | | setting forth , those were included who attended college Upon the cop right of bis nose he bade but did not graduate. The statement is all A werte, and thereon stood a tuft of heres, | the more astonishing in view of the per- Reed as the bristles of a sowes erys; centage of college graduates the Health His nosethirles blake were and wyde. League itself has honored by election to Chaucer even thought it worth while to|°Micial position in the organization. Its consider that the shape of the nose might | !ist of vice-presidents. counsellors, and ex- be hereditary and gives the daughter in ecutive committee ts composed of the the “Reeve’s Tale” a “camuse” nose just | "@mes of twenty-one men. Seventeen of like her father’s. | these names appear in “Who's Who.” Of A little later than Chaucer, the poet | these seventeen names, eleven are college Stephen Hawes describes a lady’s nose as | STaduates, one attended college two years, “straight and fayre.” |four graduated from medical colleges, and Nor is the nose entirely neglected by our |°™!y one never attended a college of any modern poets, The very ‘flower” of ali | *ind. It is to be regretted that so mis- noses in English poetry, a nose right under | /¢@ding a statement against college ef- everybody’s nose, is that of the petulant | ®¢lency should be distributed broadcast maiden in Tennyson's “Gareth and Ly- | into the homes of the land. ° NEY. nette,” of whom it is so poetically and tact- | T. LinpseY BLaY fully said Central University of Kentucky, November 12. and lightly was her slender nose (_eeaeaeaeawaoaeaeneeoo Tip tilted like the petal of a flower. ‘ . Literature. MARGRETTA MARTIN. Mount Holyoke College, November 19. THE AUTHOR OF “VATHEK.” The Life and Letters of William Beck- ford of Fonthill. By Lewis Melville. Str: Your reviewer of Wilpert’s latest New York: Duffield & Co. $3.50 net. book (“Die Papstgriiber”; see the Nation, Beckford’s letters now first given to October 6) expresses the wish that further | the public are not intrinsically very in- excavating may be made in the Roman Cata- teresting, and the editor has lessened combs. That is indeed devoutly to be | their value as a document by faulty hoped, but money is lacking. Why were transcriptions and by omissions and the Catacombs, be raised by. some great confusions so glaring that the perusal y some great | university in your country? Subscribers | °f his volume leaves one in a state of would easily be found in all parts of the irritation. And besides these minor er- Of course, the excavating should rors of editing, Mr. Melville, where he adds his own comment, has, we are obliged to think, utterly misrepresent- EXCAVATING THE CATACOMBS, to THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: world. be directed by the Papal archeologists; | there can be no question of creating an in- ternational committee for that purpose. But/ eq Beckford’s character and ignored the principles of scientific excavation are| what Beckford really stood for. To now so well known and so generally applied, | reaq Mr, Melville one would never sus- that no intellectual assistance need be of- fered to scholars like Wilpert and Marucchi, Sa Eanaaiie tatiana oo who are surrounded by some very promising pupils. The only help needed is money. | °F® of the most characteristic products The Christian and Jewish Catacombs of | of the romantic movement. Yet not only Rome have been, to a certain extent, the 40 his early letters fairly teem with the cradle of modern thought, and of modern influences of Rousseau and “Werther” morals; would it not be paying a debt if| and Ossian and Chateaubriand, but he the modern world, without exception of had the courage and the means to car- creed, belief, or unbelief, were to nelp to-| ry into practice what other men were wards exploring them completely? About only dreaming, and thus to become more two-thirds of the work remains to be done. ‘even in his life than in his famous ro- SALOMON RBINACH. | Hance of “Vathek” a symbol of the glowing fierce aspirations and the final spiritual bankruptcy of the new genera- tion. William Beckford was born at Font- hill-Gifford in Wiltshire, October 1, 1760. His father, Alderman and twice Lord Mayor of London, the celebrated radical and friend of Wilkes, fad in- herited an enormous estate in Jamaica. By his first wife, he had a stepdaughter, Elizabeth March, afterwards Mrs. Her- Paris, November 6. COLLEGE GRADUATES. To THe Epitor or THE NaTION: Str: I have just received a pamphlet advertising “The Health and _ Efficiency) League of America,” with headquarters in Battle Creek, Mich. On the first page its origin and aims, there appears in a prominent place the state- ment, “The small proportion of college graduates who succeed in any profession yey, who wrote some foolish, sentiment- is notorious.” It is surprising that &| 9} novels which her half-brother Wil- statement so wholly unwarranted could be| liam lauded as a boy and caricatured in countenanced by an organization boasting “ ” erman’ a distinguished array of officers. Accord. | bis pro it mateo ae tian a. ing to the statistics given by “Who's Who,” | - 1910, more than 60 per cent. of the profes- | longed to the Abercorn branch of the sional men listed are college graduates, Hamilton family. One of his brothers, and these figures would be increased to| William’s uncle Julines, had a son

Page 11

Nov. 24, 1910} Peter, who married in 1773 Lousia Pitt, second daughter of Lord Rivers. For Mrs. Peter Beckford and her sister (ap- parently Marcia-Lucy), William had a profound and enigmatical] attachment. At the age of ten, the boy lost his father and fell largely under the in- fluence of his mother. Instead of un- dergoing the wholesome discipline of public school and university, he was, by the advice of his godfather, Lord Chat- ham, placed under the tutelage of the Rev. John Lettice, who seems, indeed, tu have been a scholarly and sensible man, but who at least was unable to drag his charge out of the fantastic dream-world into which he had fallen. When seventeen, William went with his “bear-leader” to Geneva, to continue his studies. From here, we have the first of his letters, some of them ad-. dressed to Mrs. Elizabeth Hervey, oth- ers apparently to the same person, al- though for some reason the superscrip- tion is omitted. The tone of these let- ters is of a frantic extravagance that might remind one of a sort of hybrid of Ossian and Rousseau, both a little mad. At the end of 1778, Beckford was back in England pouring out his youthful re- volt in letters from Fonthill: “I will seclude myself if possible from the world, in the midst of the Empire, and converse many hours every day with you, Mesron and Nouronihar”; and satisfying his ambition by writing his first book, “Biographical Memoirs of Ex- traordinary Painters,” which, for the benefit of the housekeeper who shewed strangers through the gaileries of Font- hill, attributed the pictures to such ar- tists as Og of Basan, Watersouchy of Amsterdam, Herr Sucrewasser of Vien- na, and the like. Mr. Melville seems to see a contradiction in this union of sentiment and burlesque in the same mind; they are, in fact, but different as- pects of the romantic desire to escape from reality, and have often gone to- gether, from the days of the double theme in Spanish drama to the magnifi- cent audacities of “Don Juan.” After a year and a half William made the grand tour with his tutor, and in May of 1782 went abroad for the third time, travelling now with all the lux- urious state that befitted the richest commoner of England. Some time in the interval between his second and third journeys, he had met at Bath Lady Margaret Gordon, with whom he fell in love, and whom he married May 5, 1788, coming back to England for this purpose. Two children were born to them; but after a union of three years his wife died, and the chil- dren, seeming, so far as the letters in- dicate, to have passed quite out of his mind, were placed under the charge of his mother; while he himself was hur- ried about Europe by his friends who, . according to his biographer, were “fear- ful of his losing his reason or taking The Nation. his life.” Mr. Melville asserts that “the marriage had been an ideal union,” and thinks that the memory of Beckford’'s loss, “acting upon an emotional na- ture, may have had more to do with his subsequent retirement than is gen erally supposed.” It may be so; yet such practical endurance of grief scarce- ly accords with the romantic tempera- ment as one reads the annals of those days; and indeed there is an aspect of this whole affair which is unpleasant- ly suggestive, but which cannot be en- tirely overlooked, as Mr. Melville over- looks it, without a gross misrepresenta- tion of what Beckford stood for to his contemporaries. Before he had met Lady Margaret and during his courtship he was writ- ing letters filled with disquieting con- fessions. Especially there is a series of letters to Mrs. Peter Beckford which are filled with allusions to a thorough- ly unwholesome mixture of passions which exhales the unclean atmosphere of the Schlegels and their sentimental circle. These letters are sometimes ob- scure, and the editor gives no help to their interpretation—rather, his story of Beckford’s life is incompatible with them as they stand. Of the still uglier rumors about Beckford, which, as read- ers of Byron know, formed the real leg- end of his life, it would be desirable perhaps to say nothing. Mr. Melville declares categorically that there is not a particle of evidence to support them, and dismisses them preposterous. Yet he himself admits that Beckford’s “Dreams, Waking Thoughts, and Inci- dents,” printed at this time, was with- drawn from circulation probably _ be- cause its romantic tendency might give some color to the noxious scandals. Some of the evidence he deliberately suppresses. Thus he quotes Rogers's vivid description of a visit to Fonthill, when Beckford read to the younger man the episodes intended for “Va- thek,” but never published. He does not add the comment of Rogers: “They are extremely fine, but very objectionable, on account of their subjects. Indeed, they show that the mind of the author was, to a certain degree, diseased.” One of the reasons for Beckford’s re- turn to England, in 1781, from the grand tour was that he might celebrate his coming of age in a manner befitting the fame of Fonthill. The festivities, which lasted for a week, followed the usual custom of the day, and might be dismissed with a word, were it not that they seem to have been one of the in- fluences that governed the rest of his life. “My spirits are not sufficiently rampant,” he writes to Lady Hamilton, “to describe the tumult of balls, con- certs, and illuminations in which we were engaged here a fortnight ago. On the desert down which ter- minates the woody region of Fonthill blazed a series of fires. On the as 4.95 left of the house rises a lofty steep mantled with tall oaks amongst which a temple of truly classical design dis- covers itself. This building (sacred to the Lares) presented a continued glow of saffron-colored flame, and the throng assembled before it looked dev- ilish by contrast.” These scenes at Fonthill, ending with the necessary touch of diabolism, sound almost like a chapter of “Vathek,” and, indeed, they certainly combined with Beckford’s early reading of the “Ara- bian Nights” and later acquaintance with the Oriental tales then popular in France to inspire that strange book. He himself gave this explanation, late in life, to Cyrus Redding, and declared that the great hall at Fonthill, with its many doors opening into dim corridors, suggested to him the idea of the Hall of Eblis. The old tradition of Beck- ford’s literary performance is well known—how he told Redding, in 1835, that he had written the story at one sitting of three days and two nights, during which time he never took off his clothes. Unfortunately, Beckford's correspondence with the Rev. Samuel Henley, which has since come to light, quite shatters that heroic legend. He was, as a matter of fact, at work on the manuscript at least for a number of months, and was tinkering at it at in- tervals for about five years. Mr. Mel- ville undertakes to reconcile Beckford’s statement with the facts by supposing he had in mind, when he was talking with Redding, not the book of “Vathek” as we have it, but merely one of the episodes designed for it, but never printed. That is possible, al- though, unless the episode was extraor- dinarily long, the feat becomes rather commonplace; and one two other lapses in Beckford’s metnory rouse the suspicion that he was not incapable in his old age of investing his youth with imaginary powers. Beckford wrote the story in French, and to his friend Hen- ley, a scholar of considerable Oriental attainments, was entrusted the task of furnishing notes and of making an English translation. Probably out of impatience over Beckford’s dilatoriness, Henley put out an edition of his ver- sion, in 1786, with a prefatory note stating that it was translated from the Arabic. Beckford was naturally in- censed at this treachery, and immedi- in 1787, published the original French with a reply to Henley’s mis- representation. We have thus the curi- ous fact that one of the classics of our literature was written in a foreign tongue; but the correspondence between Henley and Beckford shows that the latter passed judgment on the English and virtually stamped it as his own. “Vathek” is probably little read to- whole or ately, ‘day, and, indeed, a good deal of its ex- travagant fancy and grotesque humor rings rather flat, after the iapse of

Page 12

4¢ years. time, ment IG and is still one of the main docu- to one who wishes to study romantic movement. Its theme the unendlichkectsstreben and Titan: the insatiable thirst of experience and the self-torturing ego- which were beginning to run any the sources of the is ithum, tism, like wild-fire through the literature of Europe, and which reached their con- summation in “Faust.” Instead of the medieval setting of Goethe's poem, Beck- ford’'s hero is an Eastern prince at whose feet lie all the pleasures and powers of the world. Being dissatis- fied with the magnificence of his prede- cessors, he adds to his palace five wings in which, like a Des Esseintes of the Orient, he can indulge in the quin- tessential charms of the five senses. His thirst for knowledge is equal to his appetite for pleasure, “for he wished to know everything, even sciences that did not exist.” His power was greater than his knowledge; “when he was an- gry, one of his eyes became so terrible that no person could bear to behold it, and the wretch upon whom it was fixed instantly fell backward, and sometimes expired.” Only one thing the Caliph cannot command in his earthly paradise —content: the stars above his head, as he stands on his tower looking down contemptuously on mankind, are an ir- ritation to his desires and a humilia- tion to his pride. Then enters the tempter, in the form of a_ hideous Haour, who in return for a monstrous crime offers him the possession of the palace of subterranean fire where re- poses Soliman Ben Daoud, surrounded by the talismans that control the world. space the story is lost in gro- tesque adventures;. but at the end, as Vathek and the Princess Nouronihar approach their goal, the imagination of the author kindles and the sense of foreboding deepens and intensifies step by step, until in the great Hall of Eblis (for to this the promises of the Giaour bring them), at the sight of the vast For a unresting multitude who roam cease- lessly hither and thither itn furious agony or in rapt absorption, heedless of everything about them and forever avoiding one another, each with his right hand pressed upon his heart—the feeling rises to real terror and sub- limity. At last the trembling pair are led to the great Soliman, seated aloft, yet with his hand, like the others, pressed upon his heart, and listening intently to the sullen roar of a vast cataract, which was the only sound that intruded on the universal silence. He tella them of his doom, and con- cludes: “In consideration of the plety of my early youth, my woes shall come to an end when thie cataract shall for ever cease to flow: till then I am In torments, Ineffable tor- ments! an unrelenting fire preys on my heart.” Having uttered this exclamatiom Soliman But the book was popular in its jout of the author’s fancy; The raised his hands towards Heaven, in token of supplication, and the Caliph discerued through his bosom, whica was transparent as crystal, his heart enveloped in flames. The device of the burning heart Beck- ford borrowed from a French writer now forgotten, but he has more than made it his own. His genius was fitful and never under control; he was no philosopher or seer, but in this consum- mation of the undiscipiined revolt of romanticism he came closer to the facts of history, and showed a profounder insight into human nature, than Goethe displayed when he _ resolved Faust’s craving for unbridled experience in a rather futile act of sympathy. And as the Hall of Eblis is a mag- nified and Orientalized image of Font- hill, so the career of Vathek is a gro- tesquely conceived symbol of Beckford’s own life and of the romantic ideal. This is no place to go into an account of Beckford’s rebuilding of Fonthill at an extravagance and with a dzmonic energy which quite bewildered his con- temporaries, or to follow him through his loss of fortune and secluded days at Bath. Mr. Melville closes his introduc- tory chapter with the words of Beck- ford: “I have never known a moment’s ennui.” The saying may be true, but is suspicious. Beckford was indeed of a robust physique, and had the inherited strength of very prosaic and practical forebears. Ennui he may have kept at bay until the end by his unceasing ac- tivity. But withal it is not easy to read his letters and the story of his in- sane thirst and haste in building, or to picture his obstinate seclusion from the world in an artificial and barbarously ornate paradise, without remembering Nation. the last scene of his allegory of “Vathek.” This at least is certain: One who knows the literary history of that pe- riod may be thankful to Mr. Melville for printing these letters, but he will find it difficult to accept the hero whom Mr. Melville pretends to find !n them. CURRENT FICTION. By Edith Scrib- Tales of Men and Ghosts. Wharton. New York: Charles ner’s Sons. The enervating influence upon our popular story-writers of American mag- azine “policy” does not decrease with the seasons. One recalls the announce- ment, made something like a year ago, that Mrs. Wharton had been booked to write a series of ten or a dozen stories “about men.” Here they are in the pre- destined number, capably turned out ac- cording to contract. They are Ingenious and readable: so much the most doubt- ful forecaster must have been sure of. But their ingenuity is altogether too patent: they are too clearly trumped up even the doubtful forecaster must have hoped for [Vol. 91, No. 2369 better things from the writer of “The Valley of Decision” and “The House of Mirth.” Her use of the short-story form is not to be complained of, since it is true that she is naturally an interpret- er of the episode and the situation, rather than of action upon a large scale. Her latest essay in the novel, “The Fruit of the Tree,” resulted in a not very hap- py patching together of several distinct and obstinately detached episodes. But the book left one with an impression of earnest endeavor, if not of actually lofty achievement. Mrs. Wharton may have enjoyed the writing of these “Tales of Men and Ghosts,” but we ven- ture to suppose that her enjoyment was upon the comparatively trivial plane of technical facility. Not the least puzzling thing about this collection is its uncertainty of style. Two of the stories, “Afterward” and “The Letters,” are (rather ineffec- tively) in her earlier manner—that An- glo-Gallic manner, with its nuances, its compunctions, its hiatuses; which re- minds us of Bourget, when it does not go farther and fare worse by reminding us of Henry James. In “The Valley of Decision” this style seemed to have been so thoroughly assimilated by Mrs. Wharton, that one regarded her simply as one of the “psychological” school, as the cant was. Now one almost comes to doubt the spontaneity of that manner, with her. At all events, the rest of the stories here collected show hardly a trace of it. Their style is rather that alert and commonplace style of the magazine fiction of the day as turned out by an army of skilful practitioners. Mar. By Katherine Cecil ‘Thurston. New York: Harper & Bros. The author of “The Masquerader” has hit upon a kindred motive for her pres- ent story. It is a fresher motive than that of the Dromios: a girl who passes herself off as her own twin brother is a new engine of mystification. “Max” is ‘the name taken in vain by a young Russian princess, who, on the eve of marriage, runs away in the disguise of a boy. She is determined to win fame by pencil and brush, in that notorious haunt of genius and nursery of fame, Bohemian Paris. But, first of all, it is her ambition to “possess herself,” to re- main independent of authority—above all, the authority of love. Of course, there is a man in Paris who is destined to wreck this ambition: an Irishman of the world, nearly middle-aged, who has never really loved. A quick intimacy springs up between this gentleman and the so-called “Max.” If that young per- son’s speech and action are correctly re- ported, it is hard to see how any man of ordinary intelligence could have fail- ed to see through her disguise. But Rosalind so deceived her Orlando, and Portia her Bassanio: if we begin to jib at such situations, we shall have an end

Page 13

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation. of romance. He does not suspect, though a hint is given him as to Max’s real sex at the very outset. Nevertheless, we are to understand that he is unconsciously attracted to the supposed boy by the charm of sex. Together they loiter in- nocently through the haunts of Bohe- mianism. Max takes a studio on the heights of Montmartre, and prepares to produce her masterpiece. She is a ge- nius, but her disturbing relation with the man prevents the free play of her power. This fact does not trouble the reader, since it evidently does not trou- ble the writer. The studio and the pic- ture-making merely constitute a popular background for the action. Presently she paints a picture of herself as a wo- man, and the man falls in love with it. She declares that the subject of it is her sister, and that it is impossible for him to meet her. ness and contempt on his part, jealousy on hers, and a very pretty quarrel. There is no need of explaining what happens after this. The Right Stuff. By Ian Hay. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. The author modestly calls his story “a simple study of human nature,” and cautions the reader at the outset that it was originally written for English and Scottish readers, and that the larger) public to which it is unexpectedly intro- duced must be warned that its dialect and its handling of such matters as elec- tioneering and game-shooting have pre- supposed the British familiar know- ledge. Prepared then for the utmost in local quality and in slightness, the read- er’s resignation gives way to agreeable surprise when ciently clever little tale, small certainly, and local certainly. But its humor, sometimes clumping if you will, is at moments thoroughly delightful; and its entire course is without problem or tears. The Scottish versus the English habit of mind is the prevailing joke; of its quality may be given a specimen quotation from an Englishman in the story: It is no use arguing with a Scot about Burns. I remember once being nearly dirked at a Caledonian dinner because I ventured to remark that “before ye’’ was not in my opinion a good rhyme to “Loch Lomond.” Mrs. Fitz. By J. C. Snaith. New York: Moffat, Yard & Co. Whatever the author’s past achieve- ments, inthe present story, which is os- tensibly one of adventure, he seems to possess no sure instinct and to be dis- tracted from any one purpose. Like many a writer of detective stories, he ic carried away, when the progress of events should be his first concern, by the temptation to develop other matters, such as setting and character-study. In the confusion, these, too, are not well Thereupon ensue rough- | he finds a quite suffi- | | done, and the glimpses into the country life of Englishmen of the upper-middle- class are utterly wasted. Be that as it may, the author displays the right sort of ambition for the tale-teller in de- spising any but a royal situation for the nucleus. He has for his heroine the daughter of King Ferdinand of Illy- ria, who, to avoid the inevitable Russian grand duke has made a morganatic mar- riage with a dare-devil Englishman. The peculiar political situation in Illyria makes an enormity of this venture; as Ferdinand’s sole neir, the daughter is wanted by the royalists to perpetuate the monarchy—the oldest in Europe— aid the Republicans, bent upon killing her, are equally unwilling to let her out of their sight. Between the two, she is sufficiently beset. A rescue from the Illyrian embassy in London; the ne- cessity, when directly appealed to by the divinely rightful Ferdinand, of renounc- ing her husband and child; and finally, after the Republicans have assassinated the King, an escape on a saddle-bow are the steps to her ultimate happiness. STATUTORY LAW. Popular Law Making. By Fre:eric Jes- sup Stimson. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2.50 net. This book attempts to give a sum- mary of the statutory law in the Unit- ed States on property, and on personal, racial, and politica] rights; it also re- views the corporation, labor, pure food, and Trust legislation. The author, while regretting the ten- dency to pass statutes on every conceiv- able subject, even when, according to him, it would be covered much better by application of the principles of the common law, recognizes that at the pres- ent time, to the average man, “statutes have assumed the main bulk of the con- cept of law as we formulate it to our- selves.” His object, therefore, is to show both what has been accomplished by law-making in the past and what is now being adopted or even proposed, and in this manner to give some idea of the problems of the times which are confronting legislation to-day. Although the primary object, therefore, is to state the law as it is, the book is not merely a dry enumeration. Mr. Stimson under- takes to criticise as well, not hesitat- jing at times to express harsh censure, as when he justly condemns the freakish legislation which so often disgraces our statute books, and the slovenly way in which so many of our laws are drawn. Not all the views held by the author will, to be sure, meet with assent. His absolute condemnation of the tendency to confer power on commissions and of the regulation and recognition of politi- cal parties seems to run counter to the general trend of political opinion. Nor should the Sherman Act be repudiated | because it dispenses with a jury and = 49% throws upon the court “the burden of determining a complicated and volu- minous mass of fact.” The very circum- stance that the facts to be determined are complicated and voluminous would justify the exclusion of the jury, and our ancestors would not have been shocked at this so much as the author would have us believe. So it may well be doubted (and the decision of the Supreme Court in a_ celebrated case might be invoked to justify such doubt) whether the maxim that no one shall be compelled to incriminate himself is at the present time of such fundamen- tal importance that its abolition would result in the destruction of our entire social structure. Exception might, also, be taken to the view that the notion of law as a custom is purely Teutonic. Commentators like Savigny and the his- torical school in general have shown how great a part customary law played in the development of Roman law. In France, up to the time of the promulga- tion of the Civil Code, the law of a great part of the country was custom- ary in its nature. The thought which underlies the book and which is expressed on numerous oc- casions is the necessity of holding fast to the fundamental principles of the common law in regulating the labor and Trust problems, and its great superior- ity, as to all matters relating to per- sonal and political liberty, to the Contl- nental system. A careful reading of the chapter in which the author reviews the English statutes which preceded the Revolution, and which are part of the common law as it was adopted in this country, will justify the doubt whether this mass of crude and undigested leg- islation, enacted at a time when social and economic conditions were complete- ly different from those existing now, is as safe a guide for the regulation of our complex business relations as the au- thor thinks. The same may be said of the great superiority claimed for the common law in matters relating to personal liberty or safeguarding the individual against abuse of power of public officials. The author refers, for instance, to the rule that, under common law, labor con- tracts can never be specifically enforced, and contrasts this with the law of Con- tinental Europe as he understands it. In the first place, it may be said that, while contracts for personal 'abor are not specifically enforced, in many cases virtually the same object is attained by enjoining the defendant from working for anybody else. But a complete an- awer is that the doctrine of specific per- formance is entirely unknown, at least to French law; that in it the maxim that “nobody can be compelled to do any act” is fundamental, and that dam- eges are the only remedy where any contract is broken. He refers again and again, in support

Page 14

[Vol. 91, No. 2369 Nation. 498 The of his view, to the right given by the lized remnant of old Germany. Those | best in life and letters. The interpreter common law to sue public officials, and | who love this most specific of German was professor in a denominational col- claims that such liability is as good as | qualities will find Mr. Forman an excel- | lege which trains for the ministry, and to any other system. The lent travelling companion, always tact-| scriptural parallels are used with fine unknown unknown or Germany, and extended in the mer country under the present Re- publican régime. In this country and England such remedy, which is gener- principle is not in France been greatly has ally of doubtful practical value, is the} only one available to the party aggriev- | ed; the state itself cannot be sued, even on its contracts, and is not responsible | for the acts of its officials unless there | is an This principle has been extended so as' to apply to cities or other subordinate | political divisions when they act in a governmental capacity. Under this rule | express statute to the contrary. | either for-|regard the entrance of the Fraiilein. | strangers. ful and quietly humorous, more inclined to hint than to expatiate. Note in this A diligence is standing in the inn court of Heiligenstock as the disciple of Heine appears: As I was unstrapping my knapsack the lady in the mail-coach suddenly leaned for- ward to the window, and with that fleeting glance I had of her high-bred, delicate face I experienced the curious sense of vague familiarity we sometimes have on meeting Either I had seen her or met her before, or something within me leaped to meet her now. But in a moment she was | again hidden in the obscurity of the coach. rhe a person run over by an ambulance of and with horsehair plumes waving in the the Health Department, or injured in an elevator controlled by the Police partment, cannot sue the city, and it is a poor consolation to him to be told | that he is at liberty to bring an action against the ambulance driver or the | person operating the elevator. The con-| tal system. In France, for instance, the state is liable like any other employer, | groom in Lochinvar, dangling “bonnet and | and the only question {s whether the | action is to be brought before the ordi- nary or administrative courts. A strik- | ing application of this principle oc-| recently in Holland, where the of gambling houses, which were closed by executive order and without legal process, at once brought an action | for damages against the state, and won their suit. But while we may differ with the au-| thor on these and many other points, there can be no question of the value of | his work; he certainly has attained his | object to make suggestions which will | awaken the interest of his readers to | the importance of the subject. | curred owners In the Footprints of Heine. By Henry | James Forman. With illustrations by | Walter King Stone. Boston: Hough-| ton Mifflin Co. $2 net. The charm of this record of a holiday tramp through the Harz depends upon Ita youthful and ingenuous quality. Peo- ple were glad to take up with the au-| thor. Walters, innkeepers, and strolling | artisans told him ghost and fairy stor- les. On the top of the Brocken, in lieu of a Walpurgis night, he enjoyed a tol- erable substitute in the kneipe of a uni- versity corps. There also intervened a Fraulein with most amiable parents. Mr. Forman’'s hazards of the road are not ex- citing in themselves, and he refrains | plan was to walk. trary rule prevails under the Continen-|).4, gia the rest breeze they clambered up to the box. impulse to take passage in it and thus be- | come the travelling companion of the beau- | tiful lady. But conscience bred of New Fngland education reminded me that my Consideration for the The coach rolled away and I remained at the table, like the bride- plume,” and hoping that we might meet again. If the book labors a little under the burden of its title, it has substantial merits of its own. From the fustian and pretentiousness that infect its genre it is refreshingly free. Interpretations of Horace. By the late William Medley. Edited by John Green Skemp and George Watson Mac- alpine. New York: Henry Frowde. Lovers of Horace will enjoy this book and find it profitable. In it, each beau- tifully printed and followed by a com- mentary which deserves the name of) interpretation it bears, are nineteen of the best odes. There is none of the usual | excess baggage of learning that (per-| haps necessarily) cumbers text-books of Horace. The author of the interpreta- postillions had finished their repast | The | De-| coach was a public conveyance, and going | ' to Klausthal, my destination. I had a quick effect; but his Christianity never inter- feres with a just appreciation of the pagan poet’s most pagan ideas, and the poems here coijlected range from the Pyrrha ode to Delicta majorum immeri- tus lues. If the Horace of the interpreta- tions is a trifle more dignified and aus- tere than the Horace of popular imagin- ation as fixed by Eugene Field, it is be- cause Horace was really possessed of vusterity to the point of being himself something of 2 preacher, and his inter- preter’s appreciations are those of a scholarly mind, A quotation or two from the work will communicate its flavor. The first is from the Pyrrha ode, which is entitled “A Roman Lady Vere de Vere”: Verses 1-13: The tone is given to the picture and the |interpretation suggested, sharply and at once, by the first word, quis, repeated in | the cut of verse four. Each word stings: | “Who for whom?” There have | been many; there will be more; who is it now? Then she descends from her cham- ber to the gratum antrum—not “some pleas- ant cave,” as Milton has it, but the pleas- |ant grotto attached to a lordly house. It | is a cool and shady nook, with its statues |of Venus, its fountain, and its ferns. Gra- tum it is in itself, but yet more for its | Sweet associations, in the wooer’s mind, with blissful meetings. Here often of late has he been received. Again, from Parcus deorum, “Conversion”: J But see, here is a day serene; the sky | is clear, purum; no veil of cloud dims the blue vault of heaven. Then suddenly the crash from that pure sky, and the flame cleaves the air. To this trembling soul the thunder storm out of a clear sky is a veritable theophany: entitled | The voice of the Lord is upon the waters; The God of Glory thundereth, Even the Lord upon many waters. The voice of the Lord is powerful; The voice of the Lord is full of majesty. The voice of the Lord cleaveth the flames of fire. ‘It is Jehovah himself who speaks; the | thunder is His voice. tions takes for granted the desirable syn- | tactical, knowledge, and treats his literature in true humanistic fashion. Each inter- pretation, after an apt parallel passage or poem, begins with a paragraph in ap- preciation of the whole, and is then con- tinued in a running exposition consist- | ing sometimes of comment, sometimes of paraphrase, and sometimes of transla- tion, which is everywhere sane, sympa- thetic, and illuminating. A _ further quality gives it effect: it is personal in- terpretation. To use the interpreter’s linguistic, and other special | It is characteristic of the interpreter that in this poem he sees, not the record ‘of an experience of the poet himself, nor ‘a bit of atheistic banter, but a type of experience—th® conversion of an Epi- | curean. The character of these interpretations will be better appreciated after a read- ing of the editor's introduction. William | Medley taught for nearly forty years in /Rawdon College, an English institution little known this side of the water, and | died in November, 1908. The subjects in own words: “Much of these informal lec-| which he instructed are described as from adding rhetorical allurements to a plain tale. He does you scenery with a tures may be fitly described as the lee- | “Logic, Philosophy, Classics, and Intro- certain deftness, but where he is most turer's thinking aloud with his class.” duction to the Study of the New Testa- successful is In enjoying and conveying It is full of life and vigor, and makes the | ment.” He wrote much, but published the sense of that gracious Gemiithlich-| reader feel as if he were sitting under only one work, his Angus Lectures, un- keit which persists in the unpfussian- a teacher with broad knowledge of the | der the title “Christ the Truth” (1900).

Page 15

Nov. 24, 1910 Among his unprin writings were in- | terpretations of the “Agamemnon,” the “Antigone,” the “Alcestis,” and the “Medea,” and these interpretations of Horace, now published posthumously. He was a man of deep personal quality as well as broad and sound scholarship. Rarely to a dead scholar and teacher is accorded the high and _ enthusiastic praise here given. The impression left by the introduction adds to and explains that left by the interpretations; one en- joys the disciples’ glowing exposition of the teacher’s character as much as the teacher’s glowing interpretation of Hor- ace, and understands each better for hav- ing read the other. The book ought to stimulate good literary teaching and editing of Horace. Naturally, we could not dispense with our learned editions | of the ancients; but many a teacher who reads this work of an almost un- known scholar will wish he had includ- ed all of Horace. Time and Free Will: An Essay on the Immediate Data of Consciousness. By Henri Bergson. Authorized transla- tion by F. L. Pogson. New York: The Macmillan Co. $2.75 net. Not the least of the services rendered to Anglo-American philosophy by Wil- liam James consisted in his employ- ment of his great influence to draw at- tention to that movement of French thought of which M. Bergson is the best-known representative—a movement having close affinities with James’s own doctrines, yet developed in an entirely distinctive way. A school so much talk- ed about at home was doubtless certain, sooner or later, to gain a hearing abroad; but its vogue among us has un- questionably been much accelerated by its finding as one of its earliest cham- pions so eminent a figure and so vigor- ous a fighter as Professor James. To the interest which he aroused must in large part be ascribed the zeal of publishers this year to bring out trans- lations of Bergson; it appears that ali three of this philosopher’s principal writings are very soon to be available. in English. The present volume is a rendering of the latest edition of Berg- son’s earliest work, his thése de doc- torat, published first in 1889 under the less expressive title of “Essai sur les données immédiates de la conscience.” The English title, it is true, indicates the subject-matter of only two of the. three chapters composing the volume. But those chapters are the important part of the book; the brief first chap- ter, on the notion of intensity as applied to mental states, though not unrelated to the principal theme, is rather loose- ly related, and scarcely essential to the argument. The rest of the volume, dealing with the problem of freedom in the light of the conception of “real dura- tion” as a unique characteristic of in- ‘up as barren and The Nation. ner states, constitutes an extremely | lucid presentation of the idée mére of . Bergson’s entire philosophy. | What is called Bergsonism is not en- tirely a doctrine without recognizable ancestry. The germ of some of it is, discernible in an important little book, , “De la contingence des lois de la na-, ture,” 1874, by Bergson’s teacher at the, Ecole Normale, Emile Boutroux, who has recently visitéd America. Some of it also may be found—combined with much else—in the philosophy of a not- able French thinker, too little read out- side of France, Renouvier, who exercis- ed likewise a considerable influence upon the formation of James’s meta- physical ideas. Bergson is very far from merely repeating doctrines of these older contemporaries of his; but he rep- resents the same general tendency of French thought, and part of his work has consisted in developing further cer- tain conceptions found in one or the other, or in disengaging these concep- tions from their former contexts to re- combine them with one or two other familiar motives of nineteenth-century speculation. Yet the outcome of this process has as high a degree of origin- ality as is often found in philosophical reasonings; and the principal argument of “Time and Free Will” may be re- garded as an essentially novel contri- bution to metaphysics. Time, as Kant had observed, is “the form of inner experience,” as space is of our perception of external objects; and this, Renouvier had contended—giving incomprehensible Kant’s supra-temporal ego behind both series of phenomena—properly means that succession and duration and be- coming are of the very essence of the reality that is inwardly and directly known to us. But precisely what, Berg- son asks, is the rature of our time-con- sciousness, and what is its relation to our spatial imagery? The subtle analy- sis which he brings to bear upon this question leads him to the conclusion that there is in mankind a strong dispo- sition to think time under forms bor- rowed from, and properly applicable only to, space, to assimilate the idea of duration to that of extension; and this, he finds, is the source of a host of errors in philosophy, including the error of de- terminism. All the perplexities of the ancient puzzle of the freedom of the will “come back, without our suspecting it, to the following question: ‘Can time be adequately represented by space'?”” Berg- son’s answer is a decided “No.” Time past may, indeed, be translated by sub- sequent reflection into categories alien to its original nature; but time in actual flow has a nature unique and irreduci- ble. Space we think of in terms of quan- tity, and as having all its points simul- taneous with one another and external to one another, their true relations inter s? being unmodified by change. We can ‘of 499 ideally pass through it in any direction, can repeat the same course, can come back to the same point. Now our ideas causal uniformity—derived largely from our experience of physical objects in space—though they refer to temporal sequences, are yet, soto say, woven upon a spatial warp. By “the same cause” we mean a set of conditions to which we can revert, which can be reconstituted without being significantly modified by the mere lapse of time. But time itself —the pure duration of inner experience —is, says Bergson, not a homogeneous and measurable quantity at all; it is, moreover, a one-directional flow whose successive moments imperceptibly in- ter-penetrate, which permits no repeti- tion and no returning, and in which every later phase, merely because it is later, must be different from and incom- mensurable with every earlier one, Thus our temporal inner life is a kind of-ex- istence to which the principle that “the same cause must always be followed by the same effect” is irrelevant, since the required “sameness” can there never be wholly realized. Future time, again, is not, to one actually involved in the tem- poral process, “contained in” present or past; and to say that the entire content of the future is completely preformed in the present or past, that With earth's first clay man knead, they did the last is simply to treat succession as if it were simultaneity, to abandon the point of view of real temporal experience, where the future always appears as in process of production through and part- ly by means of the present. The easy triumph of the old determinist argu- ments over the old freedomist argu- ments was due, Bergson holds, to the failure of the freedomist to utilize this distinction between the temporal and the spatial ways of thinking reality. Both parties, for example, “pictured the deliberation preceding choice under the form of an oscillation in space, while it really consists in a dynamic process in which the self and its motives, like real living beings, are in a constant state of becoming.” These reasonings can hardly be justly expounded, and they certainly cannot be adequately discussed, in brief compass. It may be remarked, however, that in his determination to make a complete severance between the temporal and the spatial categories, Bergson goes so far as to defeat his own purpose. To say ‘that duration is pure quality with no quantitative aspect, and that its mo- ments, though successive, are “without reciprocal externality,” is itself a way of reducing time to simultaneity. Berg- son's pages on this point at times sin- gularly resemble the arguments by which Professor Royce has ingeniously sought to show that experience as a whole—the “Absolute Experience”’— must be timeless.

Page 16

500 The translation is as a rule faithful and readable. There are added a sym- pathetic preface by the translator and an admirably comprehensive bibliography of articles about Bergson’s philosophy in several languages. The first presentation of this important contemporary to our public has been so well done that all readers of the book must lament the sudden death of the young Oxford scholar to whom we owe the service. Medieval Italy. By Prof. Pasquale Vil- lari. Translated by Costanza Hulton. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. $3.75 net. The coronation of Charlemagne, the last event treated in “The Barbarian Invasions of Italy,” forms the point of departure in Professor Villari’s new work, which follows the fortunes of the peninsula to the time of the death of Henry VII. The book is written for the general reader, and offers a _ straight- forward narrative, free from controversy and show of erudition, and based on thorough knowledge of the sources and results of modern whole territory tis Southern Italy on criticism of the investigation. The constantly held in view. and Sicily are accorded—for the first time in a general history—their full share in the record. The orderly con- trol of the many interrelated series of events is admirable. The book grows in interest and value toward the end. The concluding chapters clarify notably the events and the personalities of the late thirteenth century. Professor Villari deals almost exclu- sively with men and arms, The whole period, in his presentation, is dominat- ed by individual men, builders of states that disintegrate at the builder’s death, politicians whose policies lapse inte oblivion when the controlling mind is gone Institutions appear externally continvous, but devoid of vital growth; Papacy and Empire hold power or sink ignificance according as the men wear the tlara or the irun crown strong or weak. One could wish that attention had been paid to non-military matters. The intellectual and religious life of the Middle Ages, the condition of the people, the devel- opment of commerce, even matters of such political importance as the feudal system and the conflict of the investi- ture, are treated hurriedly and with far less clearness than the general reader In the single para- graph the Dominican and Franciacan (p. 267) they are differentiated only as being respectively bloodthirsty and tenderhearted. The implication (p. 266) that the “De fml- tatione Christi” was written in the time of St. Francis is unfortunate. Dante's into in who are more has a right to ask devoted to orders “De monarchia,” treated (p. 368) as of the time of the descent of Henry VII into Italy, was almost certainly not The Nation. [ Vol. 91, No. 2369 written before the last years of Dante’s | life. The comparison of Pope and Em- peror to sun and moon, attributed (p. 259) to Innocent III, goes back at least to Gregory VII. The translation has the prime virtue of accuracy. The only serious error is an arrangement of relative clauses which attributes to Sylvester II instead of to Otho III denial of the authenticity of the Donation of Constantine (p. 114). Sykelgaite should not be termed “high- souled” (p. 186) until she is quite clear- ed of her reputation for readiness with poison: high-spirited she certainly was. From the point of view of style the translation is very poor. The italian is followed closely in wording, order, and punctuation, and the resultant English is strange and unpleasant. The Italian phrases on pp. 5 and 158 have no tex: | tual value, and should have been trans lated. glicization of proper names is in gener- al well-handled. “Walter Offamill” (p. 247) might well have dropped an f and changed the a to the. The typesetter is presumably responsible for the dates “1909” (instead of 1009) on p. 130, and for “1,506” and “1,528” on p. 348, for “sunt” instead of sum on p. 198, and for “civitatis” instead of civitas on p. 341. The illustrations are well-chosen and well-made. as a diminutive kneeling donor, should have a more explicit title than the somewhat misleading “The Emperor Otho I.” The index is excellent. With Stevenson in Samoa. By J. H. Moors. Boston: Small, Maynard & Co. $1.50 net. Though Mr. Moors’s copiously illus- trated volume adds little of importance to our knowledge of Stevenson's charac- ter, it throws some light upon the avo- cations of his later years, and helps us to realize the Apian background. It is distinctly refreshing, too, because of the angle from which it was written. author of these memoirs did not go to Samoa to hang upon the lips of Tusitala. As shopkeeper, dealer in real estate, local politician, and chairman of the Board of Works he was—is still—in the island on his own account. His plain, unvarnished tale proceeds from an in- terest which was rather neighborly than literary—-we infer from some passing remarks that he is unacquainted with his neighbor's essay on Burns. Their relations, none the less, as the “Vailima Letters” and this book bear witness, were of the friendliest intimacy. They exchanged yarns and discussed local celebrities together, “generally in the evenings, as we sat in our pajamas on the balcony”; they conspired together against the German president of the municipal council; they collaborated on the materials for the “Footnote to His- The difficult matter of the an. | The interesting frontispiece, | from an ivory in which Otho I appears | The tory”; and Moors says, with a sugges- tion of pleasure in the reminiscence, that at one time Stevenson owed him above twelve thousand dollars. These are vital points of contact; Moors’s opinion of his friend should be of some weight. He finds it hard to believe in the can- onized Stevenson proclaimed in the pul- pits. The man he knew went to church only from deference to his mother, re- |garded the prayers at Vailima as some- thing of a nuisance, was more himself ‘in a paper-chase than in a Sunday- schoo] on the Lord’s day, looked upon |the wine when it was red in the Tivoli Hotel, and was “surprised more than once in Bohemia”—whatever that may mean. Moors therefore cites with man- ifest delight the following brief but pointed epistle: My dear Moors— I hope to get down to-day, but the weather | does not yet seem bordered up. We had a hell of a time yesterday; I wish the man who invented open eaves had been with us —I would have burned him to see to read by. Yours ever R. L. 8. All that this somewhat trivial testi- mony amounts to is that Stevenson, be- ‘ing neither a moral, intellectual, or so- ‘cial snob, was able to mix familiarly with all sorts of men on their own ground, and make them feel that he was no better than they. The defect of the critics who, like the late W. E. Hen- ley, insist on the “real Stevenson” is their unwillingness to recognize his many-sidedness—their failure to under- stand that a man of letters may give to the wide world some sincere and pre- cious part of himself which he cannot give to his nearest friends. The most touching passage in this book is the chapter entitled “A Plan that Failed.” Mr. Moors writes of the political troubles in Samoa from an in- side view, but of the ladies at Vailima, we trust, from the outside. He could not help feeling that they were a little queer: for example, “the whole family —I except Stevenson’s mother—wor- shipped at the shrine of ‘My Lady Nico- tine.” What was worse, he thought, ‘there was too much literary collabora- tion at Vailima. He felt a certain jeal- ousy of the influence exerted by the women over the master of the house! And with the talent of a conspirator he ‘bought a little island, and in 1893 se- ‘eretly proposed to carry Stevenson off | where he might work undisturbed and '“accomplish something worth attempt- ing”— The important question was how to keep |\the ladies away from our island retreat, but he said he would manage it somehow. | Meanwhile, I had myself vis'ted Nassau, and | had set a party of islanders to work... . | Stevenson, longing for the peace and quiet of such a spot, evinced a lively interest /in my account of these labors; and when we |left the tower [where Moors had unfolded | the plot) and rejoined our friends we drank

Page 17

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation. a quiet toast to our future happiness in Elysian fields. This little dream of a literary para- dise freed from the annoyances of Eve and her daughters was abruptly ter- minated by death. One may regard the affair as a bit of amusing gossip or as curious additional testimony pointing to that “other Stevenson” with the singu- lar power of exciting personal devotion frequently verging on sheer idolatry. Notes. “The Life of Tolstoy,” in two volumes, by Aylmer Maude, has just been published by Dodd, Mead & Co. It is a consecutive and detailed account covering the whole life. Forthcoming books from the Oxford Uni- versity Press include: “The Englishman in Greece,” as a companion piece to “The Englishman in Italy,” and “The Oxford Book of Ballads,” chosen and edited by Sir Arthur Quiller-Couch. D, Appleton & Co. announce for imme- diate publicaton “Farthest West: Life and Travel in the United States,” by C. R. Fnock; “On and Off Duty in Annam,” by Gabrielle M. Vassal, and later “Egypt: Ancient Sites and Modern Scenes,” by Pro- fessor Maspero. Doubleday, Page & Co. are already an- nouncing for the spring “The Children’s Library of Work and Play,” a series of ten volumes, each of which is to be written by an authority: “Carpentry and Woodwork,” by Edwin W. Foster; “Mechanics,” by Fred T. Hodgson; “Housekeeping,” by Elizabeth Hale Gilman; “Metalwork,” by C. C. Slef- fel; “Needlecraft.” by Effie Archer Archer; “Outdoor Sports,” by Claude H. Miller; “Interior Deceration,” by Charles IF. War- rer; “Outdoor Work,” by Mary Rogers Mil- ler; “Gardening,” by Ellen Eddy Shaw; and “Electricity,” by John F. Woodhull. James Lane Allen’s “The Doctor’s Christ- mas Eve” is expected from the press of Macmillan November 30. In “The Great Texts of the Bible,” a new series in preparation by the Scribners, Dr. James Hastings contributes to each of the selected topics pages of homiletical expo- sition and illustration. It is proposed to cover the whole Bible in five years. The first volume, “Isaiah,” will be published within a month. So far as the book has any one aim, it is to furnish material for ser- mons. Volume XXIV of the publications of the Selden Society, Volume V of their Year Book Series, “The Eyre of Kent 6 and 7 Edward II,” edited by Messrs. Maitland, Harcourt, and Bolland, will be issued in December. The December issue of Chambers’s Jour- nal will contain an article by Canon Daw- son on “The Morals or, Malory’s ‘Morte d’Arthur,’ with ‘Idyls of the King.’” As a companion volume to “american Duck Shooting” the Forest and Stream Publishing Co. is about to issue “American | Game Bird Shooting.” Among B. W. Huebsch’s announcements of the Round Table; | compared | are “Democracy and the Overman,” by Charles Zueblin; “The Philosophy of Plato and its Relation to Modern Life.” by Ed- ward Howard Griggs, and “Optimos,” by Horace Traubel. The Rev. Walter W. Skeat has issued a statement as to the present position of the Chaucer Society: It appears that some of the books, upon the completion of which the regular issue for the various years depended, are not even yet wholly ready; and the result is that more money has been received than has been expended, whilst at the same time, subscribers for the years 1907-10, have not yet received the parts due to them: and a few of the issues for earlier years are still incomplete. It has been decided therefore that the society will definitely come to a close, with the end of the present year. Such parts as are overdue will be issued at convenient opportunities. The society, which began work in 1868, was designed to publish what was most material for the study of Chau- cer’s text. In Dr. Skeat’s opinion this has now been accomplished. The last five or six numbers embodied the results of investi- gations by Americans. As a memorial to the late Dr. Furnivall Leonard Magnus and John Munro, the de- ceased’s literary executor, have suggested a volume consisting of a biography of the scholar written by Mr. Munro and apprecia- tions by others. The lis! promised to contribute are Dr. Henry Brad- ley, Prof. Alois Brandl, Professor Feuil- lerat, Dr. T. Gregory Foster, Miss Beatrice Harraden, Prof. W. P. Ker, William Poel A. W. Pollard, Prof. W. W. Skeat, Miss Spurgeon, Henry Arthur Jones, Mrs. Laur- ence Gomme, and Mrs. Stopes. Besides an edition at an ordinary price, there will be an édition de luxe. The subscriptions which are invited towards the expenses of pub- lication may be sent to Leonard Magnus, 9, Gray’s Inn Square, London of tho oO hav Yet another account of the career of Joan of Arc is offered to the public by Mary Rogers Bangs (Houghton Mifflin). Her nar- rative eschews controversy and gives a purely objective statement of the facts as ascertained by recent research, couched, it is true, in the language of enthusiasm, but not colored by any attempt at systematic explanation. To John Lane’s attractive edition of th works of Vernon Lee is added ‘Vanitas, Polite Stories, Including the Hitherto Un- published Story, A Frivolous Conversion.”’ In these four short stories of en meshed in the web of social circumstance the art of Vernon Lee appears with all its usual incisive delicacy, and with a somewhat exceptional grace of human com- souls passion. Her worldly malcontents are al- ways pathetic, and sometimes tragic. The last tale, “The Legend of Madame Kra- sinska,”’ is of Poe-like intensity. It is, for the most part, a sordid series lof servants that come and go in the pages of Elizabeth Robins Pennell’s “Our House and the People in It” (Houghton Mifflin). But, with the sordidness, there is so much of romance that a reader does not object to the author’s retaining each successive specimen long enough for her story to come out, especially as this second-hand method of learning it inflicts a minimum of the dis- |agreeableness that was plainly there. To ‘an American, moreover, there is positive oO1 charm in the very definite atmosphere that envelops the chambers from which one may look out on the Thames, down at St. Paul's, up to Westminster, and opposite to Surrey. Then, besides the succession of ser vants, from ‘Enrietter to the satisfactory and, one is glad to know, permanent Au- gustine, who receives the well-deserved honor of the book's dedication, there are the tenants, more respectable if less picturesque than the servants; the beggars, of that new and difficult sort that “make a profession neither of disease nor of deformity, but of having come down in the world’’; and the microcosm that bears the name of the Quarter. An occasional comment, such as any servant-seeker makes now and then, does not detract from the essentially narra- tive character of the book. After the merci- ful end of one of these servants, the writer concludes: No doubt, daily in the slums, many women die as destitute. But they never had their chance. Mrs. Haines had hers, and a fair one as these things go Her tragedy~-has shaken my confidence in the reformers to- day who would work the miracle, and with equal chances for all men, transform this sad world of ours into Utopia. He would be a churlish sportsman or na- ture-lover who did not enjoy E. P. Steb- bing’s “Jungle By-Ways in India” (Lane). Of the many other books on this subject, all save two or three are serious even unto dul- ness; but this is different. It is like the off-hand, rapid-fire talk of a friend who has just returned from a camping trip, and finds pleasure in sitting opposite the reader, telling his stories very much at his ease, and illustrating with rough sket and droll diagrams on the backs of enve- lopes. Besides the reproductions of photo- graphs, there are many simple sketches by the author, and they are of the most ab- stemious sort. There is never a line that could be spared. Crude and rough though good hes they are, they serve their purpose excel- lently, and even with the sambar stag, whose antlers as drawn represent a four- foot length, we do not quarrel, for that is the way big antlers often look to the hunter Mary persons sketches who sees them in the wilds. regard these impressionistic of the interesting features of the book. Mr. Stebbing is a keen and truth- ful and honest chronicler of his own adventures. He has hunted about all kinds of India big game south of the Himalayas, and he has vivid stories to tell the home life of elephants, tigers, barasingha, will as one most observer, an of leop- ards, bison, sambar, axis deer, bear, wild dogs, monkeys, and other species. His sense of humor is as rare—in books of big-game hunting—as it is welcome to the reader. He calls the barking deer “a funny little beggar’—as it is—and the cheerful confidence of the unconventionality is really refreshing. An Inductive (Frowde), J. granted that In “Second Chambers: Study in Political Science” A. R. Marriott takes for a bi-cameral legislature is essential to the continuance of democratic gov- ernment. He bases this assumption not on any abstract considerations but on the practical unanimity with which the system has been adopted by the civilized world. His object is primarily to explain the functions of the existing Second Cham- bers, and secondarily, to reach some con- clusions which may assist in solving the

Page 18

SOR burning question of the reform of the House of Lords. It may be doubted whether the appeal to history is asconclusive an answer to those who desire the abolition of the House of Lords as the author claims. In the great majority of instances quoted, the second chamber finds its reason of existence in the federal character of the country un- der consideration; in many others, to the country’s strongly monarchical and undem- France is, perhaps, the only modern democracy where a more or less successful attempt has been made to or- ganize a chamber which may be said to rep- resent the and industrial in- terests in the country. But none of the pro- made for the reform of the House Lords, which are discussed at length In this work, would result in the creation of a chamber of this character; they might cause ocratic nature. social great posals or the exclusion of some of the notoriously un- | fit, but would not, certainly as long as the hereditary principle is not entirely aban- doned, procure the creation of a really rep- resentative body, capable of checking ef- fectually the power of a democratic House of Commons. In fact, at the end of the book, the author virtually gives up his case, and admits that it is seriously open to question “whether restriction of the powers or alter- ation of the structure, or both in combina- will compose the constitutional differ- He admits that there is a considera- ble party which favors the referendum in place of such reorganization. The fact tnat such a new and untried experiment can find such support, would seem to indicate that sentiment rather than reason dictates the statement In another part of the work that the question of the abolition of the House of Lords is outside of the domain of practical politics. tion,” ences, Former students at Yale as well as those not dis- the appearance of a “new and further enlarged edition” of Prof. Henry A, Beers’s “The Ways of Yale in the Consulship of (Holt). Written without ulte- rior distorted little, apparent- ly, even by glamour which usually at- taches to the book commemo- rates instructively a time that is no more— a time, that Is, when the college world was now a law unto itself. curriculum bullt upon the ages, its elements of Latin and Greek and mathematics and philosophy and science, and feared no encroachment from the flut- changes and demands of the outer Then Socrates and Plato, reincar- waged on error, and another Horace into the night, while New England snows fell, feeling that peace that understanding it life they lived, with the perspective created by acquaintance with of will be pleased at the present generation Plancus” and the retrospect, motive rather than The with more was tering world pate war quaffed ale passes all was a simple former times actually shaping their judg- | Athletics ran their | ments of present needs course, even Intercollegiate athletics, usurping firat The thing that strikes one most in the book Is that, propensities, whether to idling, his joys and sorrows connected with the Intellectual of the with- out importance whatever a boy's grinding or were closely atmosphere college. The author of “The Spaniard at Home” (McClurg), Mary F. Nixon-Roulet, aims to the point of view of the or- and to describe Spain, for in English, from the stand- depart from dinary the first tourist time | with friendship’s happier moments. |of Stevenson. All in all, | The Nation. [ Vol. 91, No. 2369 | point of the native. A praiseworthy under- jtaking if the writer be qualified for the | task. Unfortunately she proves her incompe- | tency on nearly every page. The first thing to strike the reader’s eye is the ignorance | displayed of the Spanish language. To give a list of her errors would be useless. Most |of them are repeated several times, so that |they are scarcely to be ascribed to bad proof-reading, although misprints abound. When the author makes such a mistake as to write parita for perrita or semule for sémola, it is apparent that she has learned by ear a few words and phrases and written them down without troubling to look them up in a dictionary. One chapter is entitled Fetes and Festas! Bebe is not a Spanish word, as the author seems to think. All told, the reviewer has noted 274 similar errors in the use of Spanish, an average of nearly one mistake to a page. It is needless to say that an author so ignorant of the Spanish tongue is utterly unqualified to discourse upon Spanish literature. That chapter might better have been omitted. In the chapter on education, pages 249-251 are taken al- most bodily out of Fitzmaurice-Kelly’s “History of Spanish Literature” with neith- er quotation marks nor credit. If it were worth while, the “deadly parallel” might here be employed with telling effect. The Spanish point of view appears in an apology for the bull-fight, the argument being the usual one that other sports, too, are cruel. The best chapters are those devoted to de- scriptions of life and customs, but these pages also are replete with misinformation. “The Book of Friendship” (Macmillan) is an anthology of verse and prose in twelve parts, covering such diversities of the friendly relation as Childhood Friendships, 'Inarticulate Friendships, Friends in Need, Brothers in Arms, Odd Companions, and Boon Companions. Nor are its sterner pos- sibilities blinked, since the section entitled When Friends Are Parted includes Austin Dobson’s “Dr. Johnson and Mrs. Thrale” and Brownin~’s “The Lost Leader,” as well as “David's Lament for Jonathan” and Shakespeare’s “When to the sessions of sweet silent thought.” But the bulk of the little volume is made up, as is fitting, of selections concerned in one way or another These selections range from the abstractions of Emerson and Carlyle to the facetiousness of Horace, the animation of Dumas, the seri- ousness of Thomas Hughes, and the delicacy And while no anthology is to be swallowed whole, or even read very consecutively, this one presents the charac- teristic agreeableness of this literary form in the piquant incongruity of successive selections. Frederick Denison Maurice's “Friendship of Books” loses nothing by fol- lowing Cowper’s “Epitaph on a Hare.” The drawings, by W. T. Benda, are in good taste | and add to the value of the pages they adorn, but the introduction, by 8. M. Croth- ers, is rather labored, Its place might well be taken by something of the same writer ‘less formally, if at all, introductory. From the office of the Publishers’ Weekly, the American agents, we have received “Whitaker's Reference Catalogue of Current Literature” for 1910. This, as is well known, consists of the catalogues of the English publishers (there are 195 houses represented in this issue) bound together in two large volumes. The Index, by authors and titles, | now occupies a third volume, itself of more }than a thousand closely printed, double- column pages. In his “Strikes: When to Strike, How to | Strike” (Putnams), Oscar T. Crosby makes an attempt to discuss in a simple manner | such fundamental questions as the morality of the strike, the purpose of the union, and | the nature of the boycott and picket. Al- | though the volume doubtless will fulfil the _ author's purpose to “help a few busy men, | Wage-earners, and wage-payers, to clearer ' vision and wider charity,” it is far from be- | ing comprehensive, and gives the impression at times of being hurried. | Walter Sichel’s “Sterne: A Study” (Lip- | pincott) rests its claim to existence upon two grounds: a presentation of fresh ma- ‘terial about Sterne and a fresh charac- terization of Sterne. It does not justify | itself upon either grgund. The professedly |new material is either not new or not im- |portant. It is unimportant that Mrs. Sterne was a cousin of Mrs. Montagu, the “Queen of the Bluestockings.”” It has long been known that Mrs. Sterne was “gey ill to live wi’.” It is unimportant whether Sterne went abroad with a pupil just before or just after his marriage (p. |54n), and whether “D’Estella” was in York or near York (p. 34n). It is unimportant that Sterne changed his opinion of Dean Fountayne (pp. 110-112); that his “dear Kitty” de Fourmentelle may have been a kinswoman of Richard Berenger (p. 132), /and may have written to him a letter puff- ‘ing “Tristram Shandy” (p. 135), and may have sung at Ranelagh some doggerel com- posed for he: by Sterne (p. 147). Upon Mr. Sichel’s carly rather than late dating Sterne’s acquaintance with Warburton 155), Mrs. Vesey (p. 166n), and Selwyn (p. 251n), rests no such radical difference in one’s estimate of Sterne as does rest upon Professor Cross’s early dating of | Sterne’s flirtation with Lady Percy. Nor coes it matter greatly that “Janatone,” the innkeeper’s daughter of Mcntreuil, probably married, and went to England, and met Eliza Draper (p. 245). These chroni- clings of small beer possess interest enough to justify their being communicated, say, to | Notes and Queries—not enough to justify a |book. They are meagre gleanings of a | field which Professor Cross has harvested. | Though Mr. Sichel’s footnotes everywhere j}acknowledge his obligation to Cross’s “Life,” he seems not to have seen Cross’s edition of Sterne’s Works (1904; reprinted | 1906). Th's edition contains the letters ‘which Mr. Sichel cites from the old edi- tions, and all but an inconsiderable one cr two which he cites from supposedly un- published MSS. Moreover, it arranges the letters chronologically; so that Mr. Sichel is mistaken in supposing (p. vill) that they “have been left dishevelled.” Finally, it contains the “Journal to Eliza,” which Mr. Sichel believes himgelf to be publish- ing for the first time (pp. viii, 17). A closer study of Cross’s “Life” would have pre- vented other blunders. We should be glad | to learn, too, how Mr. Sichel knows that . ‘Slawkenbergius’ is an actual person” (p. | 208). We had supposed him to be a crea- ture of Sterne’s brain. By way of charac- terization and criticism this book likewise offers, for the most part, matter that is either trifling or not new, or, if new, unduly «expanded. Altogether we can see no jus- tification for this biography of Sterne. oO; (p.

Page 19

The Nation. Gordon Home's “Motor Routes of France” (Macmillan) exactly meets the needs creat- ed by the new method of road travel. For the route covered—from Havre, by Rouen, through Touraine to Biarritz, a short ex- cursion over the Spanish frontier to Pam- plona and San Sebastian, the northern slopes of the Pyrenees, Provence, the Riviera, and back to Dieppe by the valleys of the Rhone and Loire—it is a complete guidebook for the motorist. The practical notes, hints on touring, road warnings, and directions for drivers are supplemented by a log of the author’s car, and each day’s run has a map on which are to be found precisely those details required by a novice on the road. The type is large, yet the volume can eas- ily be slipped into an overcoat pocket. The book is evidently the result of large ex- perience, and the descriptive and historical text is equally well done. that the author will be encouraged to do for other parts of Europe open to motor travel what he has done in this book for France, and in previously published ones for England. The colored illustrations add to its attraction. “Ribbon Roads” (Putnam), by A. T. and B. R. Wood, is another story. It has no value for the motorist, being simply a plea- | sant account of a motor journey whose practical side receives no attention. It be- longs, in short, to that amazingly large class of books on travel for which there is no discernible raison d’étre. How many travellers in any land—Spain, for instance— leave an indelible record of their impres- sions? or how many impressions are worth euch a record? The few of permanent value, | even though they be, like Gautier’s, out of date, can be counted on the fingers. The rest are writings on sand. Mr. Home’s book possesses distinctive value, and is designed to meet a real need. “Ribbon Roads’ may be classed with the letters from abroad which, before the days of motors and Lusi- tanias, filled the magazine page of the week- ly newspaper. A few months ago the Gesellschaft der Bibliophilen sent out to its members, as one of its regular publications, the third and concluding volume of “Schillers Per- séniichkeit.”” The work was originally planned and undertaken for the society by Prof. Albert Leitzmann of the University of Jena, who set out to collect Schiller’s recorded conversations and all the authen- tic accounts of significant facts in his life, as well as the utterances concerning his personality based on immediate associa- tion and impressions. Becoming too much absorbed in other scholarly pursuits, Leitz- mann resigned the task in favor of Max Hecker of Weimar, who brought out the first volume in 1904. When the second vol- ume was well under way Hecker was in turn forced by his duties as collaborator on the Weimar edition of Goethe to turn over the completion of the collection to a third editor. Julius Petersen of Munich has seen it through to the end. The student of Schiller will find in these three volumes, conveniently arranged and carefully edited, the widely scattered original sources, some hitherto unpublished, which, together with the poet’s works and letters, comprise the raw material of a Schiller biography. Pure- ly literary notices of contemporaries, that throw no light on Schiller the man, are ex- cluded from the compilation, so that, ex- -™ for one newspaper extract, there is no overlapping with Braun's three-volume “Schiller im Urieile seiner Zeitgenossen.” The their earliest publication and important va- riant readings, and refer to some of the more important literature on various doc- uments, without attempting to abstract all the accepted results of critical research in this fleld. notes contain a list of sources with | They further correct some of the! errors in the documents themselves and furnish some commentary on points that need it. A full index adds to the con- venience of the work for reference. The! print and paper are of a character well | calculated to delight the eye of the true | bibliophile. Although the whole work will ;not take the place of an interpretative bio- graphy, it does enable the reader to obtain ‘a vivid picture of Schiller in his every-day It is to be hoped | life and at his work, seeing him through the eyes of his contemporaries and hearing him through their ears. It warm reception in America accorded to it in Europe, but, unfortunate- ly, like the other publications of so- ciety, it will not be obtainable through the ordinary channels of the book cept occasionally at second hand deserves the same as has been the trade, ex- One of the books of real value evoked by the Risorgimento semi-centennials, which Italy has been celebrating, is “Milano e la Lombardia nel 1859,” by Col, Carlo Pagani (Milan: Cogliati). While the author's | forte is military criticism, he shows a thor- |ough acquaintance with the political situa- tion during the momentous year when Ca- | vour forced Austria to declare war and Napoleon III to champion the Italian cause. Col. Pagani refers to much material not easily accessible on this side of the water. His opinion, evidently formed with de- liberation, carries weight. We note that he maintains the traditional Italian con- tentions, first, that the Piedmontese troops reached Magenta in time to give the Aus- their quietus, and, next, that they Benedek from the heights of San Martino, after the French already victorious at Solferino. trians drove were The Rev. Francis Dent died last Sunday. He was born in Ireland in 1840; came to this ,;country when nine years of age, and grad- uated from the College of the Franciscan Monks. With Fathers Leo and Eugene, he founded the first Italian mission in this city. After a year, as father superior in the Franciscan home at Winsted, Conn., he had charge of a church in Hartford. He went to Rome in 1878, and lived there until 1906, and was present at the burial of Pope |Leo XIII. and the coronation of Pius X. Father Dent was the author of several books on religious subjects, one of which, |The Temporal Domain of the Popes in the {Divine Plan,” won him leather seals from | Popes Leo and Pius. He was engaged at |the time of his death in writing the last chapter of “The Blessed Virgin.” Wilhelm Raabe, the novelist and writer, died last week in Brunswick, Germany. ;} Known under the pen name of Jacob Cor- vinus, he started to write in 1856, and, odd- lv enough, his first work, “Die Chronik der Sperlingsgasse,” proved to be most in de- mand, having reached in 1905 the forty- first edition. “Der Hungerpastor” has pass- ei through twenty-five editions. Many of his stories are in two volumes, some even in three. One of his best books, “Horaker,” | stroyers 503 'shows successful humor. Other character- \istie stories are “Abu Telfan” and “Der ,;Schidderump.” On his seventieth birth- day, in 1901, the University of Gottingen honored him with the doctor's degree = science. Methods of Attracting Birds. By Gil- bert H. Trafton. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $1.25 net. This is a practical discussion of the of befriending birds in winter as in summer, and, from the point of view of the birds, is especially Mr. Trafton remarks subject well as timely just now. that the reasons for attracting birds around our homes are twofold: first, the protection of the birds, and second, the resulting benefits that accrue to man, both on account of the great economic value of these birds to the farmer in his struggle with injurious insects, and also on account of the pleasure derived in helping and watching the birds Mr. Trafton gives special attention to the economic factor. He says that the progressive farmer does not begrudge the expense entailed in securing a spraying outfit and the annual outlay involved in its use. With an expense so small that it hardly needs to be taken into account, the have very efficient insect-de- in the flocks of birds be attracted around the farm which do not require the time and super- vision of the farmer to render them effec- tive, but which of their accord are constantly at work from sunrise until sun- freeing the its insect ene- mies. farmer may which may destroyers own set, farm from It needed no expert ornithologist or entomologist to make this discovery; anybody who is at all intelligent about birds knows that they are indefatigable in the destruction of harmful insects; and yet the actual number of persons who have a really clear appreciation of this important fact is amazingly small, and includes an infinitessimal percent- age of farmers—the very ones who are most concerned. Mr. Trafton’s little book is, therefore, in its purely econom- ic aspects, a valuable contribution to agricultural literature, and its useful- ness is heightened by the simplicity of its style, the clarity of its descriptions, and the practicability of the devices suggested. Nesting-houses of various kinds, so designed as to attract the espe- cially useful birds, like the swallows, |blue-birds, chickadees, martins, and |wrens, and costing but a trifle, are de- scribed and pictured by means of line- 'euts and half-tones, and there are also chapters on Attracting the Winter Birds, ‘on Drinking- and Bathing-Fountains, on Planting Trees, Shrubs, and Vines, Bird | Protection in the Schools, and Bird Pho- ‘tography. Mr. Trafton acknowledges ‘his indebtedness for many suggestions

Page 20

HOA to such well-known ornithologists as Frank M. Chapman, Dr. A. K. Fisher, Ernest Harold Baynes, and Edward H Forbush, while his book was prepared “with the support of the National Associa- tion of Audubon Societies after consulta- tion its officers, issued.” with with whose express approval it is now The Cambridge University Press is to bring out “Principia Mathematica.” Dr, A. N. Whitehead and Bertrand Russell, a work whose aim is “to show the depend- ence of mathematics upon logic by deducing by from purely logical premises the elemen- tary propositions of its various branches.” The first volume, which ts soon to appear is entitled “Mathematical Logic and Pro- legomena to Cardinal Arithmetic”; the sec- ond volume, “The Principles of Arithme- tie’; the third, “The Measurement and the Principles of Geometry.” A new and revised edition of “Diophan- Alexandria,” by Sir T. L. Heath, is This will be previous edition tus of promised by the same press as the is most welcome, now out of print. “Tae Farm Book,” written and illustrated by EF. Boyd Smith, which will be issued by Houghton Mifflin Co. November 26, under- takes to Interest Bob and Betty and other juvenil in ploughing, reaping, milking and all the rest of farming. The leading article in the National Geo- graphic Magazine for November is a de- seription of scenes of every-day life in Korea and China, by William W. Chapin. Of its fifty Ulustrations, thirty-nine are in color, reproductions of photographs colored by a Japanese artist. The value of lignite as a new source of power, if burned in a gas producer, is demonstrated by Guy E. Mitchell. “Th Science of Living, or the Art of Ke ng Well” (McClurg) Is the rather ap- pealing title under which Dr. William 8. Sadler succeeds in giving an extraordinary about four hun- He skips gayly from one topic amount of information in dred pages. to another, often with a dubious generaliza- tion or a happy disregard of fundamentals. however, It said matters the essentials are given that the reader is not dan- On the whole, may be that in most n ch a way gerously misled Many writers of repute are drawn upon but not always with perfect understanding, and the numerous il- lustrationa darken the text quite as often as they tiluminate it Selections of food and diet are treated at some length and with details and tables not easy for the general reader to understand. Dr. Sadler, a and a believer in a low appears to gives too ‘two-mealer” of nd a food supply frank protein level requirement I j ’ recomime which few calorica He asserta that most of us have a “protein habit” and have developed a kind of “protein tissue intoxication.” A certain heredity of thie habit is held to explain racial differences in diet, an ex- planation whose Ingenuity is more apparent than ite validity The author gives ten sample breakfasts and dinners, each esti- mated to contain a thousand calorics, and also other tables of food values which the beginners will not readily interpret. The “menus” are vegetarian in character, but are not strictly orthodox. The epicure will The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2369 will hardly feel himself seriously tempted to give them a trial. The death is reported of Felipe Valle, director of the Mexican National Observa- tory at Tacubaya. Drama. PROTECTING NATIVE DRAMATISTS. It is not likely that much more will be heard of the latest agitation in favor of some plan—apparently a trade con- spiracy—for the protection and encour- agement of the native American dra- matist. In the first place, it does not seem to have any backing except that of ar inconsiderable performer, who has profited largely by the use of foreign material, and, in the second place, it proposes the application of a boycott against all foreign plays which, without | the aid of inconceivable legislation, could not be proclaimed, and could not, in any circumstances, be enforced. This protection idea, of course, is rooted in utter fallacy—for art does not need cod- dling for its development, but fair and open competition—but it is so common that it may be worth while to cast an eye over the existing theatrical situa- tion and see how the case stands. The first point to keep in mind is that the interests of the public at large, not of a restricted class, are para- mount; the second is that it is useless to fight against the law of supply and demand. Broadly speaking, the best plays of their class—there are excep- tions, of course, to every rule—will yield the largest commercial return. If plays of foreign origin make the most money in the United states—a proposi- tion which is by no means universally, | even if it be approximately, true—the logical presumption is that in the pub- lic judgment at least they are of’ su- perior quality. As a plain matter of fact, they very often are. It is little short of idiotic to suggest that they) ought to be excluded, in order that in-| ferior compositions might enjoy a mo- nopoly. The truth is that within the last half-a-dozen years substantial for- tunes have been made in this country by young dramatists with crude sensa- tional pieces exhibiting the worst char- acteristics, while devoid of the artistic workmanship, of their foreign proto- types. Many of these have been desti- tute of any redeeming feature, some of them have been vile enouzh Lo be stopped by the police. On the other hand, it is most pleasant to know, many native dra- matists, within the same period, have won fortune with genuine American. plays, both serious and comic, which were not only innocent, but of substan-. tial dramatic and artistic merit. It is clear, therefore, that the Amer- | ican drama has not been suppressed, but | find them entertaining and curichs, but he! !s growing. That it has been hamper-| | Cub.” -enport | Appearances,” ‘ed cannot be disputed. So has the Eng- lish drama, and much in the same way. But one reason—not the only one, however—why English and Continental plays occupy so many of our theatres, is that the theatre is an older institution on the other side of the Atlantic than i‘ is here, and the dramatic output there is larger. There is also in Europe a larger body of play-writers of establish- ed reputation. A comparison of the English and American fields would show that the former is much the richer in older men of proved dramatic ability. But there is abundant promise in the swelling ranks of the younger men in this country. It is too soon yet to pro- nounce final judgment upon the abili- ties of such sensationalists as Eugene Walters, Edward Sheldon, Rupert Hughes, Jules Eckert Goodman, Porter Emerson Brown, J. Hartley Manners, and W. J. Hurlbut. They are all suf- fering still from the exuberance of youth and have not learned how to dis- tinguish between strength and violence. But they all show signs of dramatic in- stinct, as well as a keen sense of theat- rical situation, and when, with experi- ence, they have acquired moderation, they may all go far. C. M. S. McLellan may yet add to the reputation which he earned with his “Leah Kleschna.” John Corbin, in his “Husband,” furnishes a pledge of much higher achievement in the near future. This is an immature work, but evinces grasp of form and power of expression, and is marked by clear and courageous purpose. Thomp- son Buchanan reveals humor, original- ity, and theatrical capacity in “The Rachel Crothers has demonstrat- ed ability of no common order in “The Three of Us” and “A Man’s World.” She is observant, imaginative, humorous, and creative. Edward Knoblauch has written “The Shulamite.” Butler Dav- came near to writing a comedy in “Keeping Up and there is_ true comedy in the “Her Husband's Wife” of A. E. Thomas. Charles Rann Kennedy, a new American, has written two of the most remarkable plays in the last decade in “The Servant in the House” and “The Winter Feast.” And then there is Percy MacKaye, the au- thor of “Sappho and Phaon,” a piece of high artistic and dramatic merit, and “Joan of Arc,” an eloquent and imagina- tive romance. Unfortunately, his genius is wayward and has strayed of late in perverse and unprofitable ways, but nev- ertheless it is a force to be reckoned with. On the whole, the native play- wright does not appear to be greatly in need of protection. He has to face a powerful opposition, but that is whole- some, and ought to be inspiring. But he, in common with his English rival, does need a fair measure of op- portunity. It is not opposition that is hurting him, but the lack of it. The first-rate

Page 21

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation. whole stage in England and America is groaning and smothering, because the greedy, ignorant, and demoralizing com- mercial system, which has no other prin- ciple than the seizure of the immediate dollar, and no regard for either art or morals, has secured the control of the majority of the theatres of both coun- tries, and so made itself the arbiter of what shall be played and who shall play it. The public virtually no longer has a voice as to the character of the | dramatic entertainment which it pre-| fers. “Runs” are a matter of preordi-| nation. If a play fails in one city, it is| not withdrawn, but is started on its | predestined circuit. In this respect one syndicate is just as evil as another. The | “long run” is equally fatal to the de-| velopment of actors and the creation of | dramatists. The sooner the opposing | syndicates cut each others’ throats, the better for actors, writers; and audi- ences. What the American playwright | should pray for, is not protection, but a | free fight. And there are signs that it) is coming. Walter Prichard Eaton, for several years an industrious writer on dramatic subjects in the daily and periodical press, has re- vised a number of his essays and collected them in a volume entit'ed “At the New. Theatre and Others” (Small, Maynard & Co.). On the whole—although many persons of wider experience than the author will disagree wholly with some of its judgments —it is a clever and entertaining book, full of sharp observation and lively humor and | a wholesome spirit of independence. Mr.| Eaton at least knows the contemporaneous | theatre well, has ideas of his own and ex- | presses them with indisputable ability, if. with a somewhat injudicious dogmatism. | Some of his dicta, for instance, on the old and modern schools of acting, the meaning of versatility, etc., would have been greatly | modified, doubtless, if he had had any actual | acquaintance with the more finished players, | on either side of the Atlantic, of forty or fifty years ago. He has some trenchant and true observations on the evil wrought by the syndicate system, and on the benefits of the open theatre, but is, it may be feared, somewhat too sanguine concerning the im-_| mediate outcome of existing managerial | rivalries. One syndicate is very much like another. But, of course, opposition is a good thing in itself. His estimates of the| genius of some modern stars need not be disputed, but they will not be approved by | veteran playgoers. About the work of the New Theatre he writes with point and dis- cernment, and his papers on Clyde Fitch and Augustus Thomas are both excellent. Sir John Hare writes to a London journal as follows: “I shall be extremely grateful if you will contradict a statement, which I believe has emanated from America, to the effect that I am to visit that country professionally in the spring.” Gustav Amberg announces that he has completed arrangements with the manage- ment of the Irving Place Theatre by which Herr von Possart will appear at that play- bouse for a special engagement of two weeks, beginning on Monday, December 26. Herr von Possart, who is in the front rank |but not very sincere of living actors, brings his own complete company, and will make a brief tour of the principal American cities. His reper- tory will include “The Merchant of Venice,” Shylock being one of his most famous im- personations; “Nathan the Wise,” “Friend Fritz,” and ‘“Fallissement,”” by Bjérnsen. With all these plays his name has long been associated in the minds of Germanic play- goers. He comes to America only by special permission of the Prince Regent of Bavaria, without whose consent it is not possible for him to appear outside his native country. His company is recruited exclusively from players in the regular organizations of the Court Theatres in Munich and Berlin. Bernard Shaw’s new play, “The Dark Lady of the Sonnets,” is to be presented for the first time, in London, by the National Shakespeare Memorial Committee, at two matinées, organized for the benefit of the scheme. The author himself speaks of his piece as merely an interlude, which in per- formance will last only half en hour. The characters are limited to four—Queen Eliz- abeth, Mary Fitton (the Dark Lady), Shake- speare, and a Beefeater. The theory that the Dark Lady was Mistress Fitton has been | adopted, and Mr. Shaw has availed himself, | of the opportunity to attack the notien that | Shakespeare was an illiterate. Shakespeare, according to Mr Shaw, was the son of a mersnarnt, Who considered himself a gentle- man, and married a woman of good family, who considered herself a lady, at a time when the modern conception of a middle class did not exist. The success of the latest play of H. H. Davies, “A Single Man,” which has just been produced in London, seems to depend largely upon the power of a single scene. It opens, apparently, in a vein of clever light comedy. A middle-aged bachelor falls in love with a pretty little girl, not yet out of her teens, and, being shy, begs his typist to under- take his wooing for him. She fulfils her task with an earnestness which shows how much her beart is set upon her employer. Suc- ceeding in her suit; she cannot bear the contemplation of his happiness, and soon the old bachelor begins to think that he, too, may have made a mistake. One evening, as the typist is about to leave him, and he is preparing to dine alone, he asks the former to share his solitary meal, and, with the first sip of champagne—an un- known liquor—her tongue is loosed and she betrays the love that is in her. This scene is said to be managed with charming deli- cacy and imagination, and to raise the whole play to a higher level. And it is admirably played by Cyril Maude and Hilda Trevelyan. The death isannounced from Rome of Hen- rjetta Hobson, once a very popular English actress, and for many years the wife of the well-known Henri Labouchere, the editor and owner of London Truth. In 1860 it happened that she and one other—Henry Irving—were picked together out of a crowd of applicants by the manager of the The- atre Royal, Manchester. Bristol was an- other of the towns where (those being the days of stock companies) she learned her business and won admirers. She was among the many well-known players who at one time or another appeared on the stage of the old Prince of Wales’s Theatre under the Bancrofts; but her chief successes were 5Od5 won at the Queen’s Theatre, in Long-acre. She was one of the brilliant company brought together by Alfred Wigan to play in that theatre at its opening in 1867—a company which included also Henry Irving, Ellen Terry, Charles Wyndham, Lionel! Brough, and J. L. Toole. Later she herself assumed the management of the house. One of her productions was Mr. Labouchere’s version of Sardou’s “Patrie,” called “Fa- therland,” in which she played with great success the part of Dolores (Countess Ry- soor). After her retirement her days were spent chiefly at Pope's Villa, Twickenham, and later at Mr. Labouchere’s villa near Florence. Musie. Correct Principles of Classical Singing. By Max Heinrich. Boston: Lothrop, Lee & Shepard Co. $1.50 net. My Voice and I. By Clara Kathleen Rogers. Chicago: A. C. McClurg & | Co. $1.50 net. Most people think it must be great fun to be an opera or concert singer, but Sir Charles Santley wrote at the age of seventy-four that no gold or ap- 'plause could repay the toil and the dis- appointments of a singer’s life. Judg- ing by his descriptions and those of ‘other great artists one gets the impres- sion that singers, every time they ap- pear in public, have to endure hours of mental agony comparable to that of a man awaiting the hour when he is to be hanged; and few, if any, are exempt. Max Heinrich, admired for thirty years as one of the best of oratorio and lieder singers, declares that he has known nearly all of the celebrated singers and players of our time and none of them was exempt from this battle with the nerves. Young singers are assailed by it fully twenty-four hours before the actual moment of the ordeal: A beating heart, flushed cheeks, spas- modic respiration sometimes liter- ally to the point of nausea; the restless, perturbed sleep of that last night before the concert; the fear of the critic; the fast-approaching hour; at last the mo- ment of actual appearance—heart in mouth ah! who among you has not been con- demned to live through this agony? Stage-fright is only one of the many difficulties that confront singers. Mr. Heinrich divides these difficulties into two kiuds, the mechanical and the in- ‘tellectual. Under the first head come \voice production and placing, and breath {eontrol; under the second, phrasing, dic- tion, tone color, and personality. To each of these he givesa chapter, writing |about it in a rambling way. While |correct voice production and placing are of the utmost importance, he thinks most students give too much time to it, to the neglect of the Intellectual prob- lems—those which make an artist of a singer. The author relates, with par- donable pride, how he once sang for the

Page 22

. HOG redoubtable Hans von Biilow. Begin- ning with a Schubert song, he added another, and followed it up with one by Biilow came closer to the no comment till Mr. playing his own to the middle of Schumann. piano, but Heinrich accompaniments) made was got (who Brahm “Wie bist du, meine Kénigin?” when the great pianist suddenly hit him forcibly on the back and exclaimed: “You are a liar! You said you were a singer! You are not a singer; you are an artist!” What Bilow meant by this becomes clear to any student or teacher or ma- ture singer who will read this book. Max Heinrich is a singer of the Wiillner he showed to Americans long be- fore Dr. Wiillner crossed the ocean that there are things in music more important than a beautiful voice—more important not only from an esthetic point of view, but as a means of sway- ing an audience and making every one eager to come again. After discoursing on diction, on the art of coloring tones, and the meaning of personality, the au- thor proceeds to discuss oratorio sing- ing, with especial reference to the tradi- tions relating to recitative. He speaks scornfully of opera singers who flounder when attempting oratorio, which, like Ffrangcon Davies, he evidently regards as a higher form of art than opera. Whe- ther it be so or not, need not now be discussed. Recognizing the importance of details, Mr. Heinrich devotes the last hundred pages of his valuable little book to excerpts in musical type, from ora- ongs, with hints as to color- ing, diction, and breathing. An important feature in these direc- tions Is the use of special signs to indi- cate only where the singer is to breathe, but where he is not to do so, untimely breathing being the most fre- quent cause of incorrect phrasing, which both mars the melodic curve and makes the words unintelligible type; vocal torlos and phrasing, not Rogers's book is also concerned with higher problems of singing which have come more to the fore since Dr. Wiillner visited us. It is dedicated “to those follow art not as a means of distinguishing them. Clara Kathleen those who selves, but of fulfilling their highest possibilities.” By inheritance and ex- perlence she is well qualified to write on the art of singing. Her father, John Barnett, is referred to by Grove as “the father of English opera,” and her musi- cally gifted mother was a daughter of the famous violoncellist, Robert Lind- ley. She studied under such eminent teachers as San Glovann! and Hans von Biilow, sang in opera and concerts with the Parepa Rosa and other companies, and finally became a teacher. Her stage name was Clara Doria, and she was born In 1844. Seven years ago she wrote | a book entitled “The Philosophy of Singing,” which was favorably comment- ed on. e Na [Vol. 91, No. 236 The tion. Her new volume is not so egotistic as | its title, “My Voice and I,” might seem | ‘to indicate. There is nothing personal in the book, her own voice and art not | being referred to at all, although she does introduce here and there valuable illustrations drawn from her long ex- perience as a teacher. In choosing that title she was guided by the desire to in- dicate that, unlike most writers on the art of singing, she wished to discourse on the relation of voice to the singer rather than on its relation to its physi-| cal organ. Laryngology is useful to throat specialists, and teachers should know about it, as an aid in locating | faults of tone production; but students are not only not helped by such know- ledge, but actually hindered. What they need is a model; they must have oppor- tunity to hear good singers and thus get into their minds correct ideas of the! tones they wish to emit, whereupon the throat muscles will instinctively pro- duce them. This is supposed to have been the “old Italian method.” In his “Psychology of Singing” David C. Taylor developed the same idea; and it is surprising that Mrs. Rogers does not refer to his book. However, her treat- ment of the same theme has many in- teresting features, and there is much additional information and discussion of value to all singers and teachers. Her remarks on the superiority of dramatic singing to merely beautiful singing are particularly commendable. Mrs. C. Milligan Fox has been busy among the peasants of Ireland noting down folk songs, not a few of which, she is convinced, have never been put into type. in press a book entitled “The Bunting Papers and Memories of Irish Harpers,” and will lecture on this topic American cities this season. Another American has been honored. Paderewski, who last July presented Po- land with a magnificent monument to the Polish kings at Cracow, was to have given a recital at the Chopin centennial in Lem- berg, but owing to an attack of rheumat- ism had to give up the project. Asked to name the pianist whom he would prefer take his he suggested Ernst Schelling, who was at once accepted by the committee. He gave a Chopin recital, which justified his selection. Concerning Lillian Nordica’s brilliant success as Isolde at the Paris Grand Opéra, the London Telegraph says: The student element in Paris took spe- celal interest in the venture, and there were scores of pupils of the Conservatoire | and of all the famous teachers to be seen among the audience. They were not the) least impressed by the extraordinarily pure | and perfect rendering of the title réle.| The singer’s voice was as superb as ever.) Her method, her style, and her masterful | art were a revelation to the young aspir- | ants to the operatic stage, whose num- ber Is legion In Paris. By way of celebrating the seventy-fifth birthday of the greatest composer (with ‘the exception of Bizet) that France has ‘ever produced, a Saint-Saéns concert was She has in he to place, ‘given in Paris a few weeks ago, in which '¥saye and Hollmann took part. The pro- gramme included a new work by the aged master, entitled ‘“‘The Muse and the Poet.” He calls it a symphonic poem, but it is really a concerto for violin and violoncello, with orchestral accompaniment. The themes are said to have a melancholy character. Other works by Saint-Saéns played on this occasion were the sym- phonic poems “Phaeton” and “Om- phale’s Spinning Wheel,” the “Andro- mache” overture, the “Heroic March,” the violoncello concerto, and the “Rondo Cap- riccioso.” Art. MR. VEDDER'S REMINISCENCES. The Digressions of V. Written for his own Fun and that of his Friends. By Elihu Vedder. Many illustrations by the author. Boston: Houghton Mif- flin Co. -$6 net. At the beginning of this book the ban- ner of whim is flaunted in a most curi- ous combination of prefaces and perora- tions interlarded with digressions. Mr. Vedder is open-hearted; the wholly decorous or systematic reader is elim- inated at the outset. Throughout the recollections the method is circular. No association is resisted; far-awny events are linked together in surprising fash- ion, yet the whole gives a fairly unified impression of shrewd and delicately self- conscious old age groping tenderly back ‘for the vestiges of youth and more vig- orous manhood. To increase the com- posite character of the story, poems in the artist’s lettering, with pictorial set- tings, are interpolated as half-titles to the main sections. Of course this auto- biography, depending not on journals but on memory, is emphatically “Truth and Poesy,” but the many ingredients combine in a portrait essentially consis- tent and credible. The most charming part of an auto- biography is likely to be the childhood chapters, and Mr. Vedder’s is no excep- tion. His own childhood was passed be- tween old New York, the still Dutch town of Schenectady, whence the family sprung, with casual schooling at Mo- riches, Long Island. We glimpse the manners of a simpler time, and catch some racy tang of characters rich in idiosyncrasy. The inventive streak in |/Elihu Vedder is ascribed to an ill-bal- anced English uncle, who left the lad as inheritance a kind of alchemist’s laboratory and the quest of perpetual motion. What made young Vedder a hero among the boys was his Cuban trips. There his father sought an un- certain fortune, while the motherless boy varied an erratic schooling with deep draughts of tropic indolence. Of this life Mr. Vedder tells with gusto. An extract may illustrate the easy literary fashion of the book: Guanahai was an easy going place, both in manners and customs, My bed was of

Page 23

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation. rawhide, as smooth and hollow as a Japan- ese lacquered bowl. You simply slid down to the middle of it—the sheet became a rope under you, and was discarded. A sheet, a pillow, and a mosquito-net formed the outfit. My dress was equally simple: A pair of trousers. a shirt worn outside, a pair of low canvas shoes, a sombrero. Add to these a pair of spurs, a handker- chief around the waist, another about the neck, another tied on the head, and the sombrero on top, and I was dressed for the day. I must not omit the long prac- tical knife, thrust into the handkerchief at the waist. And the day consisted of a visit to a coffee or sugar plantation, and the evening of sitting with chair tipped against the wall of my friend, the apoth- ecary’s shop. That is—when I did not go to a few houses beyond to sit and gaze into the eyes of Dolores. These very eyes here turn ianguidly upon the reader from an unskilful boy- ish sketch which yet tells of the pre- mature splendors of this Cuban sweet- heart. Almost from infancy Mr. Vedder has kept his sketches, and these records | dotted through the pages are an extra- ordinarily interesting feature of the book. One may regret that he has not) presented more of those admirable chalk studies of recent years which are known | only to the few privileged to examine) his portfolios, but in making up the pic- torial record irrespective of quality he has shown a sound autobiographical in- stinct. This reluctance to put his best foot forward is very characteristic of | the book. Our author wishes to be lik- | ed merely as “V,” the friend, the wit, and boon companion; he requires no offi- cial admiration and almost evades it. Of what is perhaps his most important work, the decorations in the Congres-| sional Library. he tells no more than that he tried to make the paintings ac- cord with the architecture. When he praises his own work it is likely to be some little study that has never left his studio. Only in the matter of the fa- mous designs for the Rubdéiy4t does he give expected explanations, and then briefly. Similarly, in portraiture of his friends at Rome, he passes the celebri- ties, Charlotte Cushman, the Storys, and others, with a mere word, while he ex- patiates upon the good fellows of the Caffé Greco. There was Simmit, the zodlogist, who after simpler informa- tion had been absorbed would reveal the secret that the elephant gave birth to its young in carefully corded packages. There was Rauch, who, as he grew poor- er and his dog older, found that meat did not agree with him. It continued to agree with the dog. For these vig- nettes of forgotten people—of Thomas Hotchkiss, who should have disputed the laurels of Inness; of Bonaiuti at Florence, who consumed a life in teach- ing and copying, while planning a sin- gle masterpiece eventually to be colored “in the manner of Titian”—for these amiable ignoti one can dispense with the great of the earth. We hope that Mr. Vedder may yet communicate his reminiscences of his celebrated acquaint- ance; his reticence in the present shows sound autobiographical tact. Too free an introduction of persons of impor- tance would have sadly changed the character of the most informal! of tales. Rather oddly, Mr. Vedder has omitted from the illustrations what one regards as his important works. There is no material for the estimation of the illus- trator of Omar and the mural decorator. Instead, we have intimate sketches, some in colors, closely associated with the text, we have always “V,” and never the decorator of the Bowdoin Art Gal- lery, of the Congressional Library, and the C. P. Huntington house. It is not an art that is presented for criticism, but a versatile, whimsical, highly self- conscious personality that is to be tak- en or left. Here is a boy that invented a religion, a man who contrived phonet- ic alphabets, an autobiographer who ex- presses himself readily in both verse and prose of unliterary effectiveness, who passes blithely from pathos to buf- foonery—a flexible, insinuating, multi- form personality—here is “V,” and ac- cording to your temperament you will take his book to your heart or put it on | the family index. It is a book of all soris; no methodi- ‘eal review is possible, and in sampling it we can do no better than transcribe jone of those extraordinarily vivid pas- sages which crop out startlingly from the average texture of pathos and mirth. It is a Cuban scene. In going to the fishing grounds ed along the coast in the dark, warm ic night, kept from going land breeze, which came off laden with the strong smell of earth the odor of the flowers, the air tremulous with we drift- trop- ashore by the to us and the trilling of thousands of tree-toads, sounding like innumerable silver sheep- bells The starry sky was mirrored in | the sea below, so we seemed between two |skies, except when below the wave a phos- |phorescent track, like a shooting star, marked where some big fish was chasing a smaller one; for while all seemed peace, and in the mind of a lone thoughts ‘akin to worship arose, in Nature all about him it was pitiless war: and death kept |pace with life. This was impressed on me one day by a vision of sudden death which ‘I have never forgotten I was following the padron casting his net. We were wading clear water, waist-deep, when I saw some- thing on the bottom and called him back to look at it. It seemed a vigorous mass lof vitality, of a rich velvet brown, and |had large eyes. The padron at once tore it up from off the rocks, and it as quickly embraced his arm with its tenacles. This did not seem to concern him, for he man- aged to get at the under side of the anil- ‘mal, and fumbling at its very vitals, |brought it to his mouth and gave it a |quick, sharp bite. At once over this rich |brown live thing, spreading to the end lof its arms, passed an ashy pallor, the jarms fell limply off, and he threw the dead ithing into the basket at his back. boy who was in the SOT Surely, the painter has digressed in an- other art with surprising success, Laf- cadio Hearn himself need not have been ashamed to avow these paragraphs. On one occasion young Vedder almost persuaded Emerson that the arcist must live abroad among the archives of his trade. After a fitful struggle in New York in war-time, “V” went back to Rome to practise his own preaching for many years. At Paris he had already passed through the classical atelier of Picot, at Florence had studied with the literalist Bonaiuti. There he fell under the influence of the Pre-Raphaclites. In short, every reactionary or obsolescent schoo] had a hand in his training, and it is remarkable that he weathered his education. He writes in rueful self- analysis: me a home- I mean, they or school, and to me a great of the the My pictures always have to made air which I don’t like lack the air of a period this—I say it seriously—seems great defect, I eommenced with love of color and a strong sense solidity of form; but drawing killed color, and atmosphere weakened the form, reduced me to what I am I loved a and landscape, but was urged to paint the fig ure thus my landscape was spoiled by the time devoted to the figure; and the figure suffered by my constant flirting with landscape What I felt strongly, I could strongly express in the sketch, but the fin- shed picture killed the feeling—and then n addition, all became sicklied o’er by the pale cast of thought. I was accused of aving imagination To such self-criticism nothing may profitably be added except that this min ute training and eclectically cultivated sensibility, made Mr. Vedder ideal illustrator of the quatrains of Omar. A somewhat moody and highly sensuous quality that overweights much of the work, here gains interpretative value. The influence of Blake is freely admit ted, but this homage to the poet paint- er is temperamental and never sinks to obvious imitation. It would not be sur- prising if the public verdict were right in accounting this peculiar blend of Per- and modern mysticism Mr. Ved der’s most permanent achievement Among Mr. Vedder's many artistic in ventions this autobiography is not the least noteworthy. an sian In “The Story of Spanish Painting” (Cen- tury Company) Cnarles H. Caffin shows his familiar qualities of ready sympathy and literary deftness, and, profiting by the com- pactness of the theme, produces a more unitary effect than he did the similar handbook on the painting of Holland. El Greco finds in our an unwavering advocate, Ribera a discreet apologist. The closing sentiment of the chapter on Greco is characteristic enough to be quoted. He (Greco) will help us to an under- standing of other great artists of ex- pression such as Micielangelo, Giotto, the nameless artists of the Byzantine period, and the known and unknown masters of Buddhistic art. We can imagine this appealing with bene- in author

Page 24

DOS dictional force to a lecture audience, but closely analyzed it means that a peculiarly of painting ntral styles. Prob- the absurdity through Greco, and Mr. Caffin that he nis flock to these Madonna at feel- No but cloistered manner to the cx remote and is the portal ably no reader will commit of approaching Giotto yet should hesitate There 80 persuasive is to expos: hazards is an ancient Seville which displays a “union of the ing of Cimabue and Fra Angelico.” harm is meant by such analogies violence is done to clearness of apprecia- Take onisin tion again the definition of impres- of an Impressionist, we in literature, or drama, sculpture, colors his im- to the moods of his When we an one, who or painting, or pres according femperament, speak rr ons would comfort- Ruysdael, such a definition include Claude Lorrain, Winslow Homer. It would ex- frigid artists if such there We regret especially Mr. Caffin’s careless use of language in all generalizations, because tie substance of his concrete criticisms is sound, agreeably ex- This book, as its predecessors, will be popular. More’s the pity then that an occasional rhetorical sally of an extraneous sort may make the that the business of gen- eralization is a mere occasion for bandying fine The book is attractively made and well illustrated, Clearly ably Monet, and only clude completely be. pressed, and likely to do good. reader suspect words successful exhibition of Chinese and works of art at Munich in 1909, large Mohammedan exhibition re- held there, indicate a very lively interest in the development of these de- partments of Oriental culture, Additional evidence of it is furnished by Dr. Oskar Miinsterberg’s “‘Chinesische Kunstgeschich- te,’ the first volume of which, treating of painting and sculpture in the pre-Buddhistic period, has just been published by Max Schreiber in Esslingen on the Neckar. The second and concluding volume on Chinese architecture and artistic handicraft will appear in 1911 The author has devoted himself with diligence and ability to the study of the growth and character of civil- zation, and especially the evolution of the fine Asia, and has em- bodied his researches in several works, in- cluding a history of Japanese art in three volumes (1904-1907). Chinese art, it Is stat- ed influenced by that of Greece ind Rome as early eighth century before the Christian era, and reached its highest of about twenty centuries later (A. D The rplecea produced during this period ex- erted a marked influence on European art, cepecially perceptible, our author suggests, in paintings of Leonardo da Vinci Rembrandt Watteau The Chinese were ardent lovers devoted taste to making gallery of the to have con of which were The cata volumes still exists, but be seen only tn few These constantly occur for the disap that it is The Japanese and the cently irts in eastern began to be as the perfection 960-1280) point MmAas- the and emperor na sa rule, works of re zeal illectiona of Hiuitaung 192 art, and and good The sald all Tartare at them limperor is tained 6 dd tre logue n paintings, invading yed by twenty can a the pictures Japarese ¢ ples devastations account of the ring originals, 30 pearance themselves | The Nation. of the immense empire, or to form any proper conception of the quantity produced or of their inestimable value Dr. Miin- sterberg has opened an entirely new and extremely interesting field of research, and already gathered considerable mate- pertaining to the subject. The book is richly illustrated, containing fifteen col- ored plates and 321 engravings in the text. The price of the first volume, unbound (pp. xvi, 352, 8vo.), is twenty marks, or five dollars nas rial Justin Chrysostome Sanson, the French sculptor, died in Paris a fortnight since, at the age of seventy-seven. He was the au- thor of many busts and medallions of celeb- rities, and had exhibited at the Salon for the past fifty years. [ Vol. 91, No. 2369 mal conclusion as to plans and alterna- tives; to the public, at any rate, the views of most of its members are un- known. These facts are not recited for the purpose of discountenancing the discus- ;sion. On the contrary, it is high time that the Monetary Commission, which 'has been in existence since May of 1908, should take measures toward some defi- ‘nite proposition or propositions. This ‘is an indispensable first step, because, jas Mr. Jacob H. Schiff has correctly jsaid, public discussion is bound to be largely suspended until the Commission makes its own report. That report might submit one plan or more than = one; it might present the Commission's Phe Finance. COMMISSION AND THE CUR- RENCY. In his speech the other day before the Academy of Political Science, Senator Aldrich said of the Monetary Commis- sion’s work: THE Y We to-day, I think I may safe- ly say, our work upon another and even more important phase of the difficult task which has been assigned us. We intend to cemmence immediately the work of exam- ination with a view of completing our work and of making our report of a plan, of some plan, for the approval of Congress at the earliest practicable moment. What we now propose to do is to seek counsel and to invoke the calm judgment of economists, of students, of men of af- fairs, of bankers, and business men, with reference to the work which we have in commence hand. On the basis of this statement by the ,chairman of the Monetary Commission, | Washington advices have been predict- ling efforts to bring about the imme- diate enactment of a currency and bank- ‘ing bill at the coming final session of |the Sixty-first Congress. It is difficult ito share that particular expectation. | This session of Congress will expire by ‘law on the fourth of March, and it |would be an unprecedented feat to con- jstruct, propose, consider, and enact, in lthat short interval, so complicated a ischeme of legislation as the reform of ithe banking system. It will be said, | perhaps, that the Specie Resumption act | was passed in the last weeks of an ex- piring Congress, whose Republican ma- jority had just been defeated at the polls. But the subject of specie resump- tion had been before the people for a decade; intelligent opinion, in and out of Congress, had pretty solidly crystal- | lized on the practical basis of reform, land the drafting of the law was sim- |plicity itself, compared with the present problem. To-day, even the party at ipresent dominant in Congress is not | agreed regarding the plan of currency reform. It is doubtful if the Monetary unanimous judgment or it might em- 'body majority and minority conclusions. But until some conclusion is officially reached, it will be difficult for the com- munity at large to look upon the dis- cussion as practical. Opinion at Washington seems to be that such a report would favor, exclu- sively or alternatively, the Central Bank expedient. This impression has presum- ably arisen from the fact that the Cen- |tral Bank has been avowedly favored by Mr. Aldrich, chairman of the Senate Finance Committee, and by Mr. Vree- land, chairman of the Banking and Cur- rency Committee of the House. After adjournment of this Congress, however, neither Senator Aldrich nor Mr. Vree- land will occupy his present chairman- ship; indeed, it is a rather curious fact that, out of the eighteen members of the Monetary Commission, no less than ‘eleven have either died, or announced their retirement from public life, or been defeated for reélection. Exactly what will be the bearing of this fact on the Congressional prestige attaching to the Commission’s recommendations, it is somewhat difficult to say; but the fact itself cannot be wholly dismissed from calculations of legislative proba- bilities. The strongest argument for a reform in our banking system, based upon a centralized reserve and centralized pow- ‘er of issue, was stated, in a recent ‘address by Paul M. Warburg, who thus set forth what he deemed the sine qua non of effective reform: Cash reserves must centralized into lone strong organization where they will be available when needed, and where they will leommand such confidence that they will | pot be withdrawn except for actual circu- | lation or gold exports. | In order to secure the free return of cash “into the central reservoir there must be | Some means of exchange between the cen- tral reservoir and banks, so that banks | may rely on their ability to build up with the central reservoir a credit balance | against which they may draw cash if neces- |rary, This medium of exchange must be |}commercial paper. Fluidity of credit must be our final aim. 1A sound financial system must mobilize be now impossible to find them in any part’ Commission itself has reached any for- | its commercial paper and make it a quick >. ,

Page 25

Nov. 24, 1910] The Nation. asset instead of a lock-up. Mobilized com- mercial paper must finally become the most important basis of our financial structure instead of bonds and loans on Stock Ex- change collateral. This statement of the case touches a most serious evil of the existing sys- tem—the evil which many practical ob- servers consider largely responsible for the others. It is the practice of accumu- lating in the larger city banks the coun- try’s temporarily idle credit fund, of paying interest for the use of it, and of lending it out, in prodigious sums, to houses which use it for Stock Exchange speculation. In this practice, and not in any defect of note-issue powers, the stu- dent familiar with the history of Wall; Street will almost invariably find the ex- | planation of our 25 and 50 per cent. call money rates. It is this practice, also, which explains why the regular autumn harvest movement so frequently in- volves collapse of financial values. How | much it may have had to do with the peculiar banking phenomena of the pan- ic of 1907, is at least a question worth considering. As matters stand to-day, the currency and banking discussion will largely con- verge on the question whether the very desirable reforms prescribed by Mr. Warburg can be effected only through a Central Bank, or can be reached by a different reorganization of our banking | machinery. The further problems of. the part which a Central Bank, consid- | ered by itself, would play on our finan- | cial stage, and of the attitude of the | other sections of the country towards | such an institution, will also come up| for due consideration. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Abbott, L. The Spirit of Democracy. Bos- ton: Houghton, Mifflin. $1.25 net. Acton, Lord. Lectures on the French Rev- olution. Macmillan. $3.25 net, Ansell, F. J., and Fraprie, F. R. The Art 4 the Munich Galleries. Boston: Page. net. Archer, G. L. Ethical Obligations of the | Lawyer. Boston: Little, Brown. $3 net. | Bailey, H. T. When Little Souls Awake. Boston: Pilgrim Press. 25 cents net. Baldwin, James. Stories of Don Quixote | written anew for young people. American Book Co. 50 cents. Barbour, R. H. The Golden Heart. Illus- trated in color. Philadelphia: Lippin- cott. $2. Beach, E. L. An Annapolis First Class- man. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Bedier’s Romance of Tristram and Iseult. Translated by F. Simmonds. Illustrated by M. Lalau. Philadelphia: Lippincott. $3.75 net. Belloc, H. On Anything. Dutton. $1.25 net, ; Blake, E. C. The Great Moments in a. Woman's Life. Chicago: Forbes. 75' cents, Bolton, C. K. Scotch-Irish Pioneers in_ Ulster and America. Boston: Bacon & Brown. | Bonaparte. The Corsican: A Diary of) Napoleon's Life in His Own Words. Bos- ton: Houghton Mifflin. $1.75 net. Bowne, B. P. The Essence of Religion Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.50 net. } Brailsford, E. J. The Spiritual Sense in/ — Legend. Eaton & Mains. $1.25 | | peas, M. M. My Grandmother's Garden, and An Orchard Ancestral. Boston: Badger. Brierley, J. Life and the Ideal. Boston: Pilgrim Press. $1.25 net. Brooks, R. C. Corruption in American Politics and Life. Dodd, Mead. $1.25 net. Brown, C. R. The Cap and Gown. Boston: Pilgrim Press. $1. net. Browning’s The Pied Piper of Hamelin. Illustrated in color by Hope Dunlap. Chicago: Rand, McNally. $1.25. Bussell, F. W. The Roman Empire. 2 vols. Longmans. Catholic Encyclopedia. Vol IX, Lapr- Mass. Robert Appleton. Clarke, H. A. Hawthorne's Country. Baker & Taylor. Cervantes’ Don Quixote. Trans. into Eng- lish by R. Smith. Dutton. $3.50 net Chamberlain, H. 8. The Foundations of the Nineteenth Century: A Translation from the German by John Lees. 2 vols. Lane. $10 net. Cook, A. S. The Authorized Version of the Bible and Its Influence. Putnam. $1 net. Coolidge, D. Hidden Water. Chicago: Mc- Clurg. $1.35 net. Curtis, A. T. Grandpa's Little Girls’ House Boat Party. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Cynewulf. Poems. Translated into Eng- lish. Prose by C. W. Kennedy. Dutton. $2 net. Dillon, E. Porcelain and How to Collect It. Dutton® $2 net. Dryden Selected Dramas, edited with introduction and notes by G. R. Noyes. Chicago: Scott, Foresman. 2.25 Dunham, W. R. Science of Human Life. Boston: Badger. Earl, J. P. Captain of the School Team. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Ehrmann, M. Poems. Dodge Publishing Company. $1.50. | Ellwood, C. A. Sociology and Modern So- cial Problems. American Book Company. Emerson, Journals: 1833-1835, 1836-1838. 2 vols. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, $1.75 net, each. | Erckmann- Chatrian. The History of a Conscript of 1813. London: Bell | Ernst, O. Bliihender Lorbeer. Leipzig: L. Staackmann. Essary, J. T. Tennessee Mountaineers in Type; a Collection of Stories. Cochrane Pub. Co. $1.08. Field, E. Poems. Scribner's. $2 net. 'Field, W. T. What Is Success? Boston: Pilgrim Press. 25 cents net. - Firth, C. H. The House of Lords During the Civil War. Longmans. Forbush, W. B. Church Work with Boys. Boston: Pilgrim Press. 50 cents net. Fox, F. M. Seven Little Wise Men. Boston: Page. Fulda’s Der Dummkopf. Introduction and notes by W. K. Stewart. Holt. Garnett, Louise A. The Rhyming Ring, with pictures by Hope Dunlap. Chicago: Rand, McNally. $1.25. Gesenius’ Hebrew Grammar. Second Eng- lish edition revised by A. E. Cowley. Ox- ford University Press. $5.25. Goold, W. D. The Dream-Road and Other Verses. Boston: Sherman. French. $1 net. Gould, E. L. Felicia’s Visits. Phila. : Penn. Pub. Co. $1. Gould, E. L. The Admiral’s Little House- keeper. Philadelphia: Penn Pub. Co. $1. Griffith, H. S. Letty and the Twins. Phil- adelphia: Penn Pub, Co | Grissom, I. W. The Superintendent. Alice Harriman Co. $1.35 net Guiterman, A. A Book of Hospitalities and a Record of Guests. San Francisco: E!- der. $1.50. Gutzkow’s Uriel Acosta. Intro. and notes by S. W. Cutting and A. C. von Noé. Holt. Hale, E. E., and Brewer, D. J. Mohonk Ad- dresses. Boston: Ginn. 90 cents. | Hanson, J. M. Frontier Ballads. Chicago McClurg. $1. |Hanson, J, M. With Sully into the Sioux Land. Chicago: McClurg. $1.50. | Hagood, J. Memoirs of the War of Seces- sion. Columbia, 8. C.: The State Co. Hare, T. T. A Senior Quarter-back. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Hartley, Cc. G. Things Seen in Spain. Dut- ton. 75 cents net. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology. Vol. xxi, 1910. Cambridge, Mass. 509 Hay, M. The Winter Queen: Being the Unhappy History of Elizabeth Stuart, Queen of Bohemia Boston: Houghton Mifflin $4 net Heinrich, M. Correct Principles of Clas- sical Singing. Boston Lothrop, Lee & Shepard. $1.50 net Higgins, A. C A Little Princess of the Pines. Philadelphia Penn Pub. Co $1.25. Holbrook, F. Hiawatha Alphabet. Chica- go: Rand McNally Howard, W. G. Laokoon Lessing, Herder Goethe. Selections Holt Howe, M Sicily in Shadow and in Sun Boston: Little, Brown Huey, M. M. Marjorie Moxie, Her Expe riences. Chicago: Rand, McNally Hurlbut, J. L. The Superintendent's Helper, 1911. Eaton & Mains. 25 cents net. Husband, M. F. A. A Dictionary of the Characters in the Waverley Novels of Sir Walter Scott. Dutton. $3 net Ingelow, J. Mopsa the Fairy Philadel- phia: Lippincott $1.50 International Studio Autumn Number Peasant Art in Sweden, Lapland, and Ice- land. Lane. $3 net. Isham, F. 8. The Social Buccaneer. Indian- apolis: Bobbs-Merrill. James G. W. Heroes of California Bos- ton: Little, Brown. §2 net Jefferson, C. E. An Original Year; Congre- gationalism. Boston: Pilgrim Press. 50 cents; 35 cents, net Johnson, A. T. Chickens and How to Raise Them. Philadelphia: Penn Pub Co. Johnston, A. F. Mary Ware in Texas. Bos- ton: Page. $1.50. Johnston, R. F. Lion and Dragon in North- ern China. Dutton. $5 net. Kennedy, C. W. The Poems of Cynewulf. Krout, M. H. Platters and Pipkins. Chi- cago: McClurg. Lambert, M. B. Handbook of German Idioms. Holt. Lang. A. The World of Homer. Longmans. Lee, A. L. A Freshman Co-Ed. Philadel- phia: Penn Pub. Co. Le Rossignol, J. E., and Stewart, W. D. State Socialism in New Zealand. Crow- ell. $1.50 net. Lewis, H. P. Lippincott’s Primer, Phila- delphia: Lippincott. Lloyd, H. D. Lords of Industry. Putnam. $1.50 net. Lobstein, P. An Introduction to Protestant Dogmatics. Translated from the French by A. M. Smith. University of Chicago Press. $1.62. London, J. Theft: A Play in Four Acts Macmillan. $1.25 net. Lucas, E. V. The Slowcoach. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Lyman, A. J. Underneath Are the Ever- lasting Arms. Boston: Pilgrim. 60 cents. McIntyre, J. T. Ashton-Kirk, Investigator. Philadelphia: Penn Pub. Co McIntyre, J. T. The Young Continentals at Bunker Hill. Philadelphia: Penn Pub. Co. Mackall, J. W. Lectures on Greek Poetry. Longmans. Madison, L. F. Peggy Owen Patriot. Philadelphia: Penn Pub. Co. $1.25 Malet, L. The Golden Galleon Doran $1.20 net. Financial. on all foreign points; 0 also make collections, available in all parts of of Deposit. Buy and sell bills of i and issue Commercial Credit the world. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. Letters exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money and Travellers’ Credits International Cheques. Certificates No. 59 Wali Street, New York ~~ eee Smeny Lara PF scr erent