The Nation 1910-11-17: Vol 91 Iss 2368
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation. — eee NBW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 17, 1910. o.| matter of the difference a cost of pro- | | emphatic and decisive endorsement. It The WwW wg The Democratic national platforms of 1900, 1904, and 1908 each contained a declaration in favor of the election of United States Senators by direct vote of the people. That public sentiment in ily growing in the past ten years is undeniable. House of Representatives will be fully in the control of the Democrats, and the Senate will be so constituted that a ma- jority can be easily commanded by them upon any proposition which could have the support of the progressive wing of the Republicans. Of course, a majority is not two-thirds, but the time will have | arrived when a proposal to submit to they can get. And secondly, he declares | succeed the late Mr. Dolliver. In the next Congress, the | ‘away from the revised Republican doc- ‘nue plan; ‘duction, which the Republicans are now using as the second line of intrench- | |ments for their tariff system, has got to 'be taken up before long by the Demo- crats. It is therefore worth noting that in this early utterance on the subject, by a man in a position of great influ- ence in the House and representing a support of this project has been stead- ‘mmenion which may be supposed to be more protectionist than any other in the South, two points are made that look trine. In the first place, Mr. Underwood indicates that industries must take 'their chances under the tariff-for-reve- it is only “most manufac- tures” for which the difference in labor cost would be covered by the tariff, and |the others must make the best of what is reasonable to infer that, had it not been for the persistent work of Mr. Churchill, there would have been a Dem- ‘ocratic victory in New Hampshire. The success of Bass means the fulfilment of Mr. Churchill's ambition “to clean up” the Republican party in New Hampshire without disrupting it. In a speech at Portsmouth three years ago he announc- ed, to the dismay of the machine lead- ers hoping for his final discouragement, that he was engaged in a crusade to which he was willing to give twenty years of his life. Gov. Carroll of Iowa, himself a stand- patter, just reélected by a greatly reduc- ed majority, has naturally turned to his own faction of the party for a Senator to In ap- the States a constitutional amendment | that protection of profits is not entitled | pointing Mr. Young, the editor of a Des providing for the direct election of Sen- | ators by the people will be in all ways” opportune. Indeed, if the amendment | were put forward by the Democrats, the | Republicans in the Senate could not op- | pose it without furnishing to the other. side a very acceptable bit of campaign material for the impending Presiden-| tial campaign. Campaign pledges, the | merit of the case, and calculations of party expediency, therefore, all conspire | to point to this move as part of the com- ing programme of the Democratic party. From the very centre of Southern manufacturing industry, from Birming- ham, Ala., the Pittsburgh of the South, comes aclear pronouncement for a “tar- iff for revenue only.” In addition to de- claring for this principle, Representa- tive Underwood adds that in his judg- ment such a tariff would cover “the dif- ference in the labor cost of most manu- | factured articles at home and abroad.” As for protecting profits, Mr. Underwood declares that he is opposed to it, “be- lieving that to protect profits means to protect monopoly.” His position as ranking Democratic member—after ‘to any consideration at all. Judge Baldwin of Connecticut is bear- ing himself as well after election as does Gov.-elect Dix. The citizens of New Haven desired to make a public |demonstration in honor of Judge Bald- win’s election, but he announces that his personal wishes are against any- ‘thing of the kind. His preference is ‘that his friends should wait till it is seen how he discharges his duties as Governor. He still clings to his purpose to “teach an ex-President some Jaw,” but the main thing he has on his mind is preparation for his official labors. All told, Judge Baldwin is exhibiting all of the dignity and good sense that were to have been expected of him. One thing to his credit is that he refused, though a man of means, to contribute a large sum to his own campaign. He gave a total of $4,000, which compares favor- ably with the $20,000 expenses sworn to. by Gov. Lilley of Connecticut, and the even larger amounts paid out by other candidates for the Governorship. One Republican victory has escaped Moines newspaper which has strongly and consistently opposed the Iowa in- 'surgents, the Governor has certainly not _— a conciliatory move. He might ‘have sought a neutral man, not active- ly identified with either element—if such a man there be in Iowa. Of course, the appointment is only tempo- rary. The Legislature will in the end elect, and presumably will not elect Mr. Young, unless he should experience a |change of heart. In any event, Senator Cummins will remain at the head of his party in Iowa, and will be in a position |to push his avowed candidacy for the | Presidency. Mixed feelings will be aroused by the defeat of Senator Beveridge in Indiana, |but, on the whole, his retirement will |cause little regret. He voted against his party on the tariff bill, but in Bev- eridge’s insurgency there was always a suspicion of acting and of expediency. His attitude on the other great public |questions which came up during his two terms in the Senate often lacked the ap- |pearance of settled conviction and en- tire sincerity; while his inordinate van- Champ Clark, the leader of the party— due notice in the turmoil of the disas- }ity and constant thrusting of himself to both in the Committee on Rules and the Committee on Ways and Means, gives. ters which the party suffered elsewhere. ‘The election of Robert P. Bass as Gov- ‘the front, along with the iterative drip let his oratory, had caused most people special importance to this statement of ernor of New Hampshire was a signifi-| in Washington to become very weary of position, made so promptly after the ‘cant triumph for Winston Churchill. him. That sense of fatigue seems also election which gives the Democrats the His campaign of reform, begun in the | to have reached Indiana. Even Roose- next House by a large majority. That summer of 1904, has thus received an velt, before rushing to the scene to ex-
Page 2
460 tend his fatal aid to Beveridge, had | spoken of him as “the lesser evil”; and the people of Indiana appear to have be- come much more sure of the evil than of the lesser. The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2368 = one-third larger than all New England.| enumerators colored men counted the It comprises the entire State of Iowa! whites, was there any real difficulty. and the northernmost forty-four coun-|A comparison of the work of the white ties of Missouri. There is probably no |enumerators who counted colored people ,other portion of the United States of | with the work of the colored census men equal extent which contains a larger shows that the latter took more pains proportion of good farming land. The last decade has been one of exceptional prosperity—yet in this entire region there now live 100,000 fewer people than resided there ten years ago. Outside the cities of more than 25,000 inhabitants the decrease in population since 1900 has been upwards of 140,000. This is a kind of story that the boldest prophet would not have ventured to predict as a possibility a quarter of a century ago, and it is well worth the careful atten- tion of political students to-day. Neither cost of living, nor tariff, nor Roosevelt, nor Republican extravagance was in the minds of the Tennessee vot- ers, the absorbing question there being | the issue raised by Gov. Patterson in his pardon of the slayer of Carmack, the insulting defiance of the Supreme Court of the State with which it was accom- panied, and the subsequent coercion which he attempted when some of the judges came up for renomination. The depth of feeling which this conduct aroused was manifested by an alliance of protesting Democrats with the Repub- licans, in support of Hooper, the Repub-| The narrow escape in New York from lican nominee for Governor. So for- a general strike ought to be the oc- midable did this alliance show itself to|casion for serious thoughts about the be that Patterson, who had been nom- | possibility of preventing such industrial inated by the regular Democrats for re- disasters. In France, the Prime Minis- election, voluntarily withdrew from the |ter has announced his purpose to follow contest, and his place on the regular up the recent railway strike with legis- ticket was taken by Robert L. Taylor. | lation designed to do away with such a But this move, after the Deraocratic in-| throttling of the nation’s commerce. M. dignation movement had got full head- | Briand’s words are: “It is not possible way, did not serve to bring the anti-Pat- that the country should go on exposed to terson Democrats back into the fold.| the same dangers, year after year. Such The rebuke had been earned, and they | problems must be thoroughly looked were determined to administer it, whe-|into. The government intends to study ther to the original culprit or his proxy. them carefully, and will not rest until The outcome at the polls showed plainly |it has found a solution which will pro- enough that Patterson would have been |tect the land from such perils at the snowed under if he had remained in the same time that it leaves essential liber- field. When Tennessee elects a Repub-|ties untouched.” Of course, the task in lican Governor in token of its resent- France is somewhat easicr since it is so ment for abuse of the pardoning power | largely a question of dealing with pub- and for disrespect to the courts, it is evi-| lic employees; but there appears to be dent that the spirit of independent citi-|a general tendency to bring all employ- zenship is confined to no section of the | ments “affected with a public interest” | within the scope of laws forbidding |either a strike or a lockout without due State lines do not coincide with nat- | notice or efforts to settle the niuatter by be arbitration. This was the principle of ural divisions, and the census might | made to tell interesting stories that now |the so-called Lemieux law of Canada, lle concealed, if figures were massed ac-|@macted in 1907. It appears to have other divisions. That the | Worked well. country. cording to population of Iowa has declined by. 7,000 in the past decade is remarkable| “All in all, the experiment of employ- enough; but a more striking result ap- | ing colored enumerators, while it involv- pears when a geographical ratuer than |ed much extra work for the Census Bu- a political area is considered. Bounded reau, has been entirely successful and by the Mississipp! on the east, the Mis-| reflects credit upon the colored people,” souri on the south, the Missouri and the | we read in the Southern Workman, It Big Sioux on the west, and the south-|explains that more than 2,000 colored ern line of Minnesota on the north, is |enumerators were put to work, and that an area of 78,000 square miles, or nearly in only one case, where for lack of white with the members of their race, partic- ularly in the matter of differentiating employments. Hence there are high hopes that the new census will throw more light on the industrial position of the colored people in the South than any heretofore. The Southern Work- man adds that a number of Southern cities have for some time past used col- ored men in increasing numbers in tak- ing school censuses. Finally, those who, like the Nation, have long been urging colored constabulary for the South to deal with negro crime and prevent race friction, are certain to be encouraged by the success in official positions of the census enumerators. The Harvard Alumni Bulletin laments that the autumn meeting for the award of academic distinctions has not achiev- ed its object of arousing a greater in- terest in scholarship. Most uaodergrad- uates, it seems, have remained away te scoff, and the recipients of the prizes have felt that the flush of achieve- ment was somewhat chilled by the long postponement of recognition. It is there- fore proposed to make the ceremony part of the commencement festivities. Whether this will do much to temper the admitted artificiality of the occa- sion may be a question. There will al- ways be a killing lack of spontaneity in things of this sort; a meeting of the Phi Beta Kappa, or of the Poets’ Guild, is a riot of enthusiasm in comparison. These at least are forms of organic self-expres- sion; the other, from certain student points of view at least, nothing but a fussy faculty notion of fostering infant industry. An undergraduate class is prouder of its real scholars than facul- | ties sometimes realize. It is usually the “mere mark-getter, with slight claim to distinction in humane society beyond a certain sheepish impulse to press for- ward along the indicated path, who fails of being borne aloft on the shoulders of his admiring fellows. No amount of factitious reward for such successful mediocrity will greatly alter undergrad- uate opinion on this point, for here at least it agrees perfectly with that of the world.
Page 3
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. All good Americans will be greatly re- lieved by the explanation from Profes- sor Miinsterberg’s friends of the real significance of the fifteen-to-one ratio against him in the number of minutes during which the Kaiser chatted, re- spectively, with him and with Professor Smith of the University of Virginia. That explanation is so simple and yet so notable as another triumph of the new psychology that the wonder is only over the delay in its production. The monarch’s chat with Professor Smith, while extended, was merely academic. His words to Professor Miinsterberg, while few, were intimate and at the same time international in their scope. It cannot escape notice that this expla- nation does not come from the Emperor, but we hope no doubt will be cast upon its validity by reason of this fact. One of the real literary wants of this nation is a Thanksgiving Proclamation “form.” Not to dwell upon the waste of labor necessitated by the devising of one Presidential and forty-five State proclamations, there is the present de fect, positively pernicious in its influ- ence upon American literary style, of the English that Governors in particu- lar delight to employ in their announce- ments of this annual festal day. Here, for instance, is the summons of the Governor of Indiana, disrespectfully cut by the leading newspapers of his own capital to we know not what percentage of its original length. But the fragment is enough. We have no quarrel—just now—with his conventional “never- ending procession of the seasons,” “the common parent of us all,” and “the corn and wine and oil of fertile fields and fruitful vineyards. We remember that Indiana is a literary State. But the spectacle of Indiana bowing “again her forehead to the ground” does give us a start from which we are hardly recovered by the assuring words, “and to the end that all may renew their al- legiance and give thanks to our coun- try’s God, in conformity with State and national usage.” We also fail to see the altruism of the concluding clause, in which the people of the State return thanks “for that he hath not so far) dealt thus with any people.” One reason why the English Liberals are looking forward to a general elec- tion with more confidence than the Con- | servatives is that in recent by-elections the Liberals have scored notable suc- cesses. They carried South Shields by an increased majority, and in the Walthamstow division of Essex, where ‘the new Solicitor-General, Sir John Simon, has just been reélected, his ma- ‘jority is greater than it was last Jan- ‘uary. Then it was 2,195; on November 1 it was 2,766. This figure was attained | in spite of the fact that the suffragettes }and the Labor voters were against the Liberal candidate. Yet it is noteworthy | that the Walthamstow poll was reduced. ‘The decrease in the Liberal vote, as ;compared with the general election in January, was 1,053, while the Conserva- tives fell off 1,624. But the result is taken as good proof that the budget is now very popular and that the Con- servatives are making no headway against free trade. It is partly in view |of this latter fact that the Spectator once more calls upon Joseph Chamber- lain to announce that, if the Conserva- ‘tives are successful, they will do no- thing to introduce the protective prin- ‘ciple into English fiscal legislation. The | appeal will doubtless be in vain, but so, ‘it is generally admitted, must be any hopes which the Conservatives entertain as they face a general election. | | The admission of “fashionable ladies, ‘actors, and descriptive writers” to the Crippen trial is defended by a writer in hen English newspaper, who saw no evi- dence in their faces of want of appre- ciation of the gravity of the case. He |clinches his point by relating how he sat next to a celebrated actress, who re- | marked, school.” Such models of justice as this ‘particular case seems to have been | |than for our criminal courts, however it may be with the British. To hold the mirror up to nature is at times difficult, |at times uninteresting, and our temper- ament demands excitement. The result is a mad race on the part of the drama to keep even with the more enimated moments of our not undramatic civiliza- tion. It is no wonder that it sometimes overleaps itself. But it was in another period of spacious times that our dra- ‘matic models were produced. Some- |thing must be wrong besides our tem- '_perament. There is either lack of the ‘creative imagination or sad misdirec- ‘tion of its powers. “This is our real dramatic | 461 The sudden shock of the contrast of American manners with those of the high-bred Spaniards who had gone be- fore in the Philippines, is regarded by a correspondent of the London Times as having “contributed largely to the first failure of the Americans to win the re- spect of the natives.” And in his en- deavor to deal with the misunderstand- ing “without hurting susceptibilities,” he suggests the possibility of such Americanization of the Filipinos that in a few generations they will become aware that “a spirit of hustle and down- right dealing, if at times a trifle un- couth, is better than an elaborate cour- tesy which has no sincerity of purpose behind it.” Meanwhile, however, it is “not of good omen that the interchange of social courtesies between the better elements of native society and members of the American community is still growing less and less frequent.” Well, all that our Imperialists can say is that our little brown brothers are too im- patient. The very fact of their caring for courtesy and having a desire for premature display of our sincerity of purpose, is evidence of their sad back- wardness. Even if we have introduced complications into the situation, that does not excuse the presumption of their official announcement that “the Philippine nation, being positively con- vinced that it possesses the actual ca- pacity for self-gevernment as a civilized nation, aspires ardently to be indepen- dent.” Until our impetueus colonizers are convinced of that, all this will pass as sheer impudence. The latest traveller to report war with Japan as imminent is the son of a ‘Standard Oil magnate. He has been in | would never do for our stage, any more Japan? Oh, dear, no. He has been hob- ‘nobbing with French and German army officers, and from them learns directly and certainly that Japan will ettack us before the Panama Canal is finished. Two hundred thousand troops are to be landed in San Francisco for the little jaunt to Washington—by airship and balloon doubtiess—and, of course, ruin and defeat will be the consequence. There is only one thing to do, avows this young militia captain, and that is to introduce at once a three years’ compul- sory army service as they have it in France and Germany. And he is going to begin to get compulsory service at once.
Page 4
462 THE BEST FOOT FORWARD. In accounting for his defeat in New Jersey, the Republican candidate for Governor, Mr. Lewis, attributes the re- sult largely to “the wisdom of the Democratic party in selecting a candi- date of the calibre of Dr. Wilson.” Much the same could obviously be said of the nomination of Judge Baldwin in Con- necticut and of Judson Harmon in Ohio. The voters like to support clean and able men. Even a democracy is eager to open a career for distinguished tal- ent. This has been demonstrated again and again, but at no time more clearly | than in last week's elections. In many localities the electors displayed remark- able discrimination in honoring excep- tional men with an exceptional vote. Never was the moral sense of the com- munity more successfully appealed to. Now, this pre-election wisdom of the Democrats ought to be made post-elec- tion also. Other great struggles are before the party, in State and nation, and it cannot begin too soon to prepare for them by putting its best foot for- ward. This year’s sweeping Democratic The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2368 ed and gladly fly back to the arms of | the Republican party. The danger that | this may happen is undeniable. Demo- | crats in Congress have not, during re- cent years, made a display of great abil- ity or unity or consistency. Their situa- | tion in the next Congress will not be unlike that which they faced in 1875, af- ter the political upheaval in the election of 1874 had made the House Democratic for the first time in eighteen years. But | the Democrats of those days rose to the | ‘opportunity. They made Kerr Speaker and put S. J. Randall in charge of their plans for effecting economies. They felt | that they were on trial. It was for) them to prove to the nation that they had strong and safe men in whose hands the administration of public affairs could with confidence be placed. And the steadiness and sobriety shown by the Democratic House elected in 1874 helped the election of another one in '1876. Conditions to-day may be similar- ly availed of, or they may be stupidly wasted. Certain it is that if the Demo- jeratic majority in the next House does |/not put able and responsible men on success is nothing like a mandate to the “uty, stand for economy, and work out Opposition to take the reins of power two years from now. We have seen too many swift ups and downs in our poll- tics, too many landslides going now to this party, now to that, to justify any notion that the country has definite- ly made up its mind to put the Demo- cratic party in charge of the national government. This great blow to the Republicans was chiefly dealt by Repub- lican hands. A vast Republican vote, discontented with the managers and pol- icles of its own party, either went to the But this vote can be repelled as easily as it The temporarily disgruntled Democrats or was not cast at all. was won. Republicans, with the great body of in- dependent voters, can be readily driven away by Democratic ineptitude or folly. And the great teaching of this year’s campaign is that Democrats who look forward must seek to deserve success as and to that end the posts of honor and re- well as fight for It, should give sponsibility to men whom the country will perceive to be capable of govern. ment. Republicans are already prophesying —which is easy, but rather cold com- fort—that the Democrats will make such a mess of things in the next. House that the country will We disgust- | leonstructive plans for legislation, the party will be exposed in 1912 to as se- vere a rebuke as if the elections of 1910 had never brought a triumph. It is, however, upon the State of New York that specific attention will be con- verged to see what use the victorious | Democrats will make of their great op- portunity. Of the purpose of Governor- elect Dix to give a clean and business- like administration, there can be no doubt. He will surround himself with skilled and honorable advisers, and will, we are confident, make his chief appoint- | ments with an eye single to »fficiency. But it is the choice of a Senator to suc: | ceed Depew which will most quickly and definitely mark the attitude of the New York Democracy towards forward- looking and high-minded policies in the nation, and upon that choice thought | and effort should immediately be con- centrated. The degradation of the New York Senatorship by Platt and Depew has been one of the worst offences of the long Republican domination in this State. It will never do for Democrats who have cried out upon it not to exert their utmost power to complete the re- moval of that disgrace. It would be im- possible to go lower than Depew, but the Democrats are bound to go much high- er. If they were to make such a miser- ‘able failure now as they made after | 1892 when they elected Edward Murphy ‘Senator, despite the protest of President ‘Cleveland, they would go far to destroy /at once the respect of the people and ‘their own hopes for the future. It is | distinctly a time when a man should be | selected of the very highest type. Several excellent names are already under discussion, though some of the | men mentioned say that they cannot be ‘considered. We do not know that Mr. Shepard is or would be a candidate, but we do know that a man of his sort ought ‘to be chosen. Ability for ability, Mr. 'Shepard’s could fairly be matched with Senator Root’s, while his mature politi- cal convictions, his deep study of our ‘political history, his readiness in debate ‘and his value in counsel, together with his unblemished character, would make him a Senator whom New York would delight to honor. His personal wishes are unknown to us, but such a name as his should be kept te the front so that by discussion in the press and by indi- vidual urging the great duty of choosing a fit Senator should be held in the fore- front. What the party has won by go- ing to the polls with able and even emi- jaan neminees, it can retain only by ‘clinging to the same high standard in | appointments to office and in elections by the Legislature. THE PENSION ROLL. The Pension Commissioner’s annual report, which has just made its appear- ‘ance in full, is coincident with the pub- lication in the World's Work of a series of articles by William Bayard Hale on the “staining of the nation’s honor-roll fog pretence and fraud”—an exposure of some ef the crimes against honest | soldiers and against the government, in ‘connection with our pension system. But were this perennial uncovering of these abuses not going on, the report of the Commissioner would still deserve careful study, if only because of the de- mand for “dollar-a-day” pensions heard jae the last encampment of the Grand | Army, and the all-pervading public ig- norance as to the size of the pension ex- penditures. Mr, Davenport, the Com- |missioner, records that forty-five years after Appomattox there are still 602,180 soldiers and sailors drawing pensions, in addition to 318,461 widows and de- pendents and 442 nurses, who tegether
Page 5
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. receive annually no less than $158,332, 391.82—a sum exceeded but three times in our pension history, and but four mil- lions less than last year’s expenditures. Although there was a decrease of 25,111 in the number of pensioners the slight net reduction in the expenditures is plainly disappointing, from the tax- payer’s point of view. The average an- nual pension is now $171.90, against $138.18 in 1906; it increased only $2.08 above that of 1908-1909, but that in- crease added $1,915,852.64 to the total expenditure. These larger outlays were due to increased rates authorized by Congress, applications for larger pen- sions, and 3,015 special pensions granted by separate acts of Congress—the worst abuse of all. How the cost would jump if the 483,000 pensioners of the civil war were to receive a dollar a day, in place of $171.90 a year, any one can figure out for himself. But consideration for the Treasury never prevents the average Congressman from passing bill after bill to “correct the record” of de- serters, bounty-jumpers, end cowards, It is the easiest way for a Representative to make friends in his district. What cares he as to the character of the men | he places on the roll, so long as he may tell his constituents that he got Con- gress to agree to 250 or 300 or 600 pri- vate pension bills? Mr. Hale has print- ed some splendid samples of these, among them a bill of Congressman Brownlow of Tennessee, enrolling Brad- ford Whaley as a private in the Elev- enth Tennessee Cavalry, in which he never served, and then giving him a pension. As Mr. Hale says, Congress might as well have made Whaley a vet- eran of the Reyolution. Yet 3,015 bills of this kind, though few so flagrant, were passed last year and approved by President Taft—resulting in an increas- ed drain upon the taxpayers of no less than $894,495 and benefiting 6,063 per- sons. It is not, however, merely the growing size of the pension which is ominous. The number of widows of soldiers of the civil war increased by 9,045, despite the ravages of death among the 211,781 who drew pay last year for their hus- bands’ services forty-five years ago. It will amaze most people to hear that there are already no less than 27,889 pensioners of our brief war with Spain and the Philippine insurrection. There were not 27,000 soldiers in the regular army early in 1908, and, if we remember correctly, Gen. Shafter’s force at Santi- ago was not above 18,000 men. Yet within twelve years of that brief struggle there are-on the rolls 22,783 invalid soldiers, 1,183 widows, and 330 minor children, 3,072 mothers 512 fathers, 7 brothers and sisters, and 2 helpless children. the government paying for the fever camps and that one conflict which most civil war veterans would have regard- of soldiers and In such measure is ed as but little more than a ekirmish. Every war the country has been in is now represented on the pension roll, for there are still one “daughter of the Revolution” and 338 widows of the war of 1812 obtaining government aid; while 2,042 survivors and 6,359 widows are accredited to the war with Mexico, which ended sixty-two years ago. If the same longevity prevails as in the case of ' the last survivor of the second war with . England, we shall be paying Mexican war veterans up to 1941 and Spanish war veterans up to 1991. Already the Spanish war veterans and dependents have received 980,191,725.72, or within fourteen millions of the Mexican war. pensions and sixteen millions of the to- tal amount paid out for the war of 1812; and there were 47,295 claims for pen- sions pending in June, 9,135 for service against Spain or the Filipinos. Now, if the money side of al) this were the only question, it would be bad enough, particularly if we take into ac- count the pensioning of fully 100,000 Confederate veterans by the Southern States at a cost of probably $4,500,000 to $5,000,000. They have been well in- oculated, too, with the pension virus, for Georgia in 1909 pensioned 3,492 vet- erans at a cost of $561,077. But worse than the pecuniary aspect is the demor- alizing effect the in the North, at least, discriminates not worthy of system, which at all and bad, and unworthy applicants, but above 900,000 people the idea that patri- otism on the battlefield is cashable, and that it is the duty of the Treasury to hand out money, precisely as protection- ists think the government owes it to them to guarantee the profits of their business. In the South the pension sys- tem menaces, as a writer in the South Atlantic Quarterly points out, the prop- er educational and social progress of that section. In the North it is honey- combed with fraud, and offers such an between good gives to all 463 inviting opportunity for a President who desires to make a name for him- self as a brilliant administrator and an enemy of corruption, that it is hard to see how Mr. Taft can resist the tempta- tion to overhaul the whole business. And what we miss in the Pension Com- missioner’s report is an indication of a vigorous cleaning up of the pension- rolls. Only fifty-five frauds were pun- ished last year; but the country, as Mr. Hale shows, is full of them. NON-MANIFEST DESTINY. In the current number of the Popular Science Monthly there occurs the follow- ing quotation from the introductory statement preceding the list of courses in physics offered at one of our great universities in 1894: While it is never safe to affirm that the future of physical science has no marvels in store it seems probable that most of the grand underlying principles have been firmly established, and that fur- ther advances are to be sought chiefly in the rigorous application of these principles the phenomena which come under our notice. An eminent scientist has remarked that the future truths of physical science are to be looked for in the sixth place of decimals. “Then came,” says the writer, “the dis- covery of Réntgen rays, 1895; Becquerel ' rays, 1896; Zeeman effect. 1896; radium, 1898; atomic disintegration, the trans- formation of matter, the thermal effect of radio-activity, and intra-atomic ener- gy, 1903. I am unable to locate the sixth decimal] idea in recent catalogues.” The suddenness of the change in the aspect of physical research which has taken place within the past two dec- ades is a phenomenon of extraordinary interest; but the reflections suggested by the contrast above referred to are quite as pertinent in the domain of hu- man affairs as in that of scientific in- vestigation. We are all ready enough to admit in the abstract that it is the un- expected that happens, and that most but, specific application long-range prophecies are vain; strange to say, the of this maxim to the questions that con- stitute at once the most difficult and the most vital problems of humanity is al- universally neglected. When it comes to the great currents of human the doctrine of accepted with most history and opinion, “manifest destiny” is hardly a protest by the minority, the people who try more or less vigorously to work against the current or who at
Page 6
464 least wish that it were other than it {s. Up to a certain time a movement may seem to be utopian or academic or ec- centric; but let it grow steadily for some years and attain a position of real time soon comes when power, and the the word is passed all along the line that its ultimate and complete triumph is a certainty. Opposition may con- tinue, and perhaps the very people who admit the coming event may go on act- ing according to their principles; never- theless, the fact remains that the accept- of ance the manifest destiny idea, in each such case, is a factor of great potency in sapping the vitality of the opposition. Take such a matter as Socialism. There are to-day millions of people whose atti- tude toward Socialism is profoundly in- by they the feeling that, however may like it, sirable itself or ultimately imprac- ticable in its working they may be con- fluenced little however unde- vinced it is, yet it is sure to come. The day of individualism, they feel, is rapid- ly passing; in a hundred ways they see It is only lack of imagination, they say to them- the handwriting on the wall. selves, that prevents anybody from see- ing what is so clearly patent; a few more years and everybody will see it. But it takes more imagina- the existing tendencies than to in reality tion to realize possibilty of a change in realize what results those tendencies, if by bring about. unchecked new developments, will It was easy, for example, for anybody to see, only a few years ago, that China was on the eve of disso- lution and partition among the Euro- pean nations; it was not easy to see that this destiny, so manifest in every- thing that had happened for half a cen- tury, was suddenly to be abrogated by the marvellous assertion of the poten- tialities of the Orient made by Japan In And if it be said was related merely to her war with Russia. that this event the special characteristics of particular nations or races, while the question of Soclaliam is one that turns on forces imbedded the answer is simple enough. In the sea in universal human nature, of forces involved in the socialistic re- of human life are un- depths quite as far removed casting there sounded from our ken as were the factors which played a decisive part in the Russo-Jap- anese drama > What is true of these largest ques- ‘The Nation. tions is equally true in regard to politt- cal issues of lesser sweep. In our own country we huve seen a great growth of the importance and the power of the Federal government. That this growth made necessary by modern economic developments—the new rela- has been tions among all parts of the country created by modern methods of trans- portation and communication and the new problems arising out of the modern organization of industry and business— is very true. That the process will be and should be carried still farther in certain directions few reasonable per- sons will deny. But to drift from this conclusion, resting on reason and judg- ment, into an easy-going acceptance of | State impotence and central omnipotence as the verdict of manifest destiny, is a very different matter. When Mr. Cham- berlain started his protection agitation in England, manifest destiny, as shown in the spread of protection on the Con- tinent and in the alleged decay of Eng- land's industrial power, was his strong- est ally. Our own imperialist venture in the Philippines would never have been made were it not for the debilitat- ing effect of the manifest destiny idea at a time of sudden excitement and mili- tary vainglory. But the truth is we know but one thing about destiny—that | it is not manifest; and we have but one | duty concerning it—each in his degree to do what in him lies to shape destiny according to his conviction, not of what it will be, but of what it ought to be. INTELLECT AND SERVICE. In his remarkable “Statistical Study of American Men of Science,” Professor Cattell arrives at the conclusion that the number of our scientific men of im-| portance has in recent years been in-| creasing at only about half the rate of increase of the whole population, and that the production of scientific men of | the highest order has been faring far | worse. This latter conclusion he bases largely on the fact that in the complete list of men who, by the judgment of their peers, deserve to rank among the | thousand leading men of science there are only six under thirty years of age, and none of these in conspicuously high rank. “This,” he says, “is significant and disquieting. A man of genius is likely to do his work at an early age [Vol. 91, No. 236 ! gow at twenty-two, Thomson at Cam- bridge at twenty-six, Rutherford at Mc- Gill at twenty-seven. Men of science of this age and rank simply do not exist in America at the present time; nor is it likely that we are faring better in scholarship, in literature, and in art.” In the earlier days of the Republic, we used to explain any deficiency of our country in great intellectual fruits by pointing to the fact that we were en- gaged in “subduing a continent,” and that partly the material rewards and partly the inherent attraction of this la- bor took the flower of our youth away from intellectual pursuits. Later on, a factor different from this, though not unrelated to it, came into the forefront —the enormous and dazzling prizes ef- | fered to successful endeavor in the fields |of business enterprise, the overwhelm- ing prominence given to the pursuit of wealth at a time when fortunes unheard of in former days gave a position of |power and of popular eminence such as no other form of success seemed to of- ‘fer. Add to this the rapid growth of |luxury and the rise in the material stan- ‘dards of living, and you have a situa- tion in which a life devoted to intellec- tual effort, with small material reward jand with little stimulus from the inter- est and respect of the community at large, would not often present itself to a young man of talent, energy, and high spirit as the natural goal of his ambi- |tion. Indeed, it might be said that the social atmosphere of America has con- stituted, in the case of our young men, an environment comparable—though, of course, with an enormous difference of |degree—to that which has in all ages ‘surrounded young women as regards 'their intellectual ambitions. It is not nearly so much the presence of absolute hindrances as it is the absence of en- couragement and incentive, that ac- counts for that lack of intellectual ‘achievement on the part of women which, until our own time, was ascribed almost universally to inherent incapa- city. To this potent cause of deflection of young men of high intellectual endow- |ment from fields of intellectual endeavor ‘for which they are by nature and tem- _perament peculiarly fitted, there must, in our judgment, be added another ‘which seems destined to play a greater and to receive prompt recognition. Kel-| and greater part in producing this ef- vin was appointed full professor at Glas-| fect. We refer to that exaltation of
Page 7
Nov. 17, 1910] The N ation. =—— “service” as the only worthy aim of an intellectual life which has, within the past dozen years, been coming more and more into fashion. It should hardly be necessary for the Nation to protest that in entering an objection to this ten- dency it is not actuated by any deficien- cy in its admiration of the man who makes his scholarship an instrument of “service” or in its appreciation of the value of his work. We do not object to praise of the scholar in politics or of the scholar in social betterment or in economic reform; we object only to the preaching of a gospel which leaves all other scholars out in the cold. If, on the one hand, you offer all the shining outward rewards of effort to those who do not go into intellectual pursuits at all, and, on the other hand, you reserve all appreciation and praise for such in- tellectual achievements as bear directly on the improvement of political and social conditions, you cannot expect the life of the scholar and thinker and writ- er in other domains to present to aspir- ing youth that fascination which is the greatest factor in determining the direc- tion of his ambitions. In the speeches at the dinner given in New York in honor of the completion by Prof. E. R. A. Seligman of twenty- five years of admirable work as scholar, teacher, and citizen, it was natural that stress should be laid on the connection between scholarship and service to the community. A better example of the combination it would be difficult to find. But nearly every speaker gave voice, either expressly or by implication, to the doctrine that only by such service ean scholarship be truly justified; and one cannot help asking whether the president of Columbia University, for example, really thinks in his own heart that those who pursue studies and re- searches far removed from such service —Greek, for example, or the more ab- stract departments of pure mathematics —are mere drones, survivals of an out- worn tradition that continues emong us only on sufferance. We are perfectly aware that a tenuous justification might be made for these intellectual luxuries even from the “service” standpoint; but turn and twist as you will, the kind of talk that we refer to is simply incom- patible with the spirit of a whole-souled devotion to the things of the mind. And yet it is precisely that spirit—the spirit of Copernicus and Galileo and Newton and Darwin—that has not only illum. | ined the world but has furnished one of the chief refuges from the deadly grind of the commonplace and the material. Exalt service by all means, but preserve for pure intellectual achievement its own place of distinction and regard. Do the one, and applaud it, but leave not the other undone or unhonored. THE QUEST OF THE ULTIMATE. The number of serious books publish- ed recently with titles that calmly claim anticipation of the last word in relig- ion is not a little remarkable. Starting boldly enough with “The Coming Relig- ion” and “The Religion of the Future,” be- come imnatient of unnecessary diffi- dence, until, flinging to the winds the few remaining limitations of their pro- reached the W hether the writers of such books expect them to our modern seers have apparently phetic powers, they have climax in “The Finaj Faith.” be bought as genuine pronouncements of “foreknowledge absolute,” is as uncer- tain as whether they themselves so re- gard them. If they do, their sincerity is surely at the expense of their saga- city. But the publishing business will still go on, for there would be room for “The Final Faith, Revised.” yet Even then we should not hope te find in its pages a statement of ultimate truth. We should look for nothing more than an advance in that direction, or even for a pushing of the goal farther away than it at present appears. Either effect would be accounted an intellectual triumph, a step toward that finality of knowledge which we as little desire as expect. But if the piquancy of that search for a fixed goal is due in some measure to its endlessness, so that we are fain to satisfy our restless questioning with the dogma that success would mean satiety, the same does not hold in that realm of art where the interpretation of the fact is as important as the fact itself. The thrill of satisfaction at the discovery of the Pole, which was only man’s natural delight in the attainment, especially the long-attempted, difficult, and perilous attainment, of an ultimate object, not because of its usefulness, but cnly be- cause of the necessity of reaching what was evidently there to be reached, may have to be re-satisfied continually with other analogous triumphs. The other Pole, the partially conquered air, the stretches of space that still yield only a there 465 reluctant obedience to the breathless will provoke and defy in varying degrees monsters of steam and electricly, man’s quest of the ultimate. Science looks ever forward. But with whatever of aspiration for heights ungained, it is in a frequent and eager turning to the days that are no more that art finds its comfort and its joy. There are no more durable satisfactions of the human spir- it than the glory that was Greece and Florence and Weimar and Stratford. Here, in certain directions, man has apparently reached the ultimate goal, long before he had made more than a beginning upon those other paths that, crowded now with explorers, stretch ever farther and farther into the reced- ing distance. It is the habitual resort to these ac knowledged masterpieces that casts deubt upon our philosophic dogma of the identity of attainment with satiety. In the of which are merely provisional and intro so-called attainments science du@tory to others equally so, there is no real test of the matter. And, further more, there may be a difference in this respect between a master and those who can only admire, without imitating, his skill. But surely, even for a master is something indistinguishable from perfect contentment of satisfaction in beauty of line and color, of sound, The dif- ference between art and science here Is One does not take the “Iliad” as a starting-point for a greater epic, and of the artistry of words. absolute. o1 the Venus de Milo for a finer statue Accepting these as themselves ultimate, one either gives himself up to enjoyment of them, or strives, in the scientific man- to the event, he finds himself once more upon In the former, he longs only to see and ner, analyze them. In latter the endless road of investigation. hear again and again and again. He has found something which, although finite, is possessed of finality. Is this difference between the provil- sional character of science and the ulti- mate character of art inherent in the differing natures of the emotions and the reason? How has man been able to create objects of perennial satisfac- tion, but quite unable to discover the final truth about either them or himself? No wonder that the one power, however meagrely rewarded, however little de- serving to be called “useful,” has always, in the most highly cultivated as well as
Page 8
466 in the crudest society, been deemed to spark of the divine in it, have some while the highest tribute paid by sav- agery or mediwvalism to the wonders of the other was to credit it to a far less respectable, even if still super- natural, source. Our inquiries, however, are necessarily futile. They are of that part of the search for finality which, from all appearances, must go on for- ever, being itself the only surely final element in the process, It is better for the baffled mind to turn now and then from the endless puzzle of the why and the how, and to rest questionless before the finalities of finite workmanship. In his unavoidable quest of the ultimate, man must go for absolute satisfaction, not to the crucible or the study, but to the impassioned music of Beethoven, the tragic failure of Hamlet, the columned majesty of and the swinging hexameters in which the gods still live. the Parthenon, PASCAL. I. During the last ten years or so there has been a marked reawakening of in- terest in Pascal. This Pascal revival differs from the Rousseau revival that has taken place during the same period in being French rather than interna- tional, and also in being less easy to in- terpret. The return to Rousseau evi- dently bears a close relation to the great wave of radicalism that has been sweep- ing over the world. As the author of a recent work on the “Social Contract” re- marks, the proletarians hope to use the dogma of the sovereignty of the people to oust the bourgeois even as the bour- geols used it to oust the aristocrats at the time of the Revolution. But why this interest in Pascal, especially the side of Pascal that seems most remote from everything modern? The sym- pathy that appears in so many French writers is also manifest in the new Life of Pascal by Lord St. Cyres.* In spite of the unfortunate filppancy of the preface, Lord St. Cyres’s book has solid merit; it is abreast of French in- vestigations and points of view about *Pascal Vy Viscount St. Cyres. New York: Fr. . Detton & Co. $8 net.—Attention should aleo be eniled to The Nuna of Port-Royal by M. B. Lewndes, New York: Tlenry Frowde. The contem perary documents thet Misa Lowndes has collected and arranged with great «kil! give a apectally good iden of Mother Angélique Among recent French contributions to the eatudy of Pascal and Port Ttoyal mention sheuld be made of the edition ef Pascal tn the Orands Errivaine under the editor sbip fr MM Prunechvicg and Pierre Boutroux fr labore of Miechaut and Brunsechvicg on the text of the Penefese, and finally of the Pascal et son tempe of Vortunat Strowskl (3 which has already gche into a 1907-8), vole., fourth edition The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2368 Pascal, and though not contributing important points of view of its is admirable as an _ exposi- worthy both in literary form and intellectual quality of its great and stimulating subject. Justice is done to Pascal in his various aspects as saint and scientist and man of the world. Lord St. Cyres handles ideas, especially the ideas that bear on the “Provincial Letters” and the whole sub- ject of casuistry, with a keenness that is not common in English. His treatment of the more mystical element in Pascal seems to reflect in some measure the re- action against intellectualism which is attaining such large proportions, and of which pragmatism is perhaps the best known, though by no means the only, manifestation, The treatment of Pas- cal’s conversion especially is evidently colored by certain theories of James’s as to the réle of the subliminal in re- ligious experience. The great scientific intellectualists of the last century, who were striving to establish strict causal sequences between phenomena, looked with less favor on the “thunderclaps and visible upsets of grace,” and in general on the appeal to pure intuition that one finds in Pascal. “Converts are no friends of mine,” said Goethe, whose un- friendliness to Pascal in particular is own, Lion, well known. Sainte-Beuve never tires of | trying to prove that men remain after conversion about what they were before. This point of view explains the final coldness toward Jansenism that comes out so clearly in the postscript to the sixth volume of his “Port-Royal.” We may doubt whether the special kind of sympathy for the intuitive as compared with the rational that seems to be on the increase just now is a real advance over the sturdy intellectualism of a Sainte-Beuve or a Goethe. The in- tellect is at best only an intermediary power; che first things and the last are equally hidden from it. What knowl- edge it has of either it must owe to in- tuition. Yet the slighting of the intel- lect in the name of the higher intuitions that has appeared in the more ascetie forms of Christianity has always been unfortunate. We may suspect that the slighting of the intellect in the name of the lower intuitions, that has assumed so many forms from Rousseau to James and Bergson, is exposed to an even more certain retribution. Most of the early Port-Royalists were themselves sturdy iptellectualists and philosophically at the opposite pole from pragmatism. In Lord St. Cyres’s phrase, they defended “a highly mystical, intuitive religion by rows of serried formule marching past in battle array.” But In spite of all their logic and rationality, they put (their final emphasis on the mirac- ulous, on violent overturns of the nat- /ural order, and so prepared the way for the convulsionnaires and the Diaere Paris, that eighteenth-century Jansen- ‘ism into which Sainte-Beuve said that nothing in heaven or on earth could induce him to enter. There is already semething convulsive in Pascal’s con- ception of religion. If this were the whole story we should have to agree with those who regard Pascal on his purely religious side as obsolete. For example, the writer of the review of Lord St. Cyres’s book in the Spectator declares that the Pascal that really counts for the reader of to- Gay is the Pascal of the “Provincial Let- ters,” whereas what we have in most of the “Pensées’ are the last lingering shadows of mediewvalism that have not yet been banished by the bright sun- shine of the modern spirit. This point of view is all the more misleading in that it is at least half true. The “Provincial Letters” have the obvious advantage over the “Pensées” of being ‘not mere fragments, but the finished pro- duct of a consummate literary artist, of the creator, one is almost tempted to say, of French prose. For if the empty form lof the modern French phrase was per- fected by writers like Guez de Balzac, it was Pascal who gave this form vital con- tent. A Frenchman who set out to-day to write like Montaigne would be an in- tolerable mannerist; but Pascal’s French ‘has aged very little in either syntax or vocabulary; it remains the kind of ‘French that every Frenchman would ‘like to write, “if he only could.” Through the French influence on writers like Dryden, Pascal may be said to have contributed to the establishing of a standard of sound prose in English. If, however, the “Provincial Letters” show Pascal at his best as a literary artist, they are inferior to the “Pensées” ‘in human interest. Pascal’s attack on Jesuitical morality was intended for im- mediate effect, and so is at times too im- plicated in the local and ephemeral. Religion, again, in the “Provincial Let- ters” often appears as a mere occasion for the sparrings of theologians. Such distinctions as those between contrition and attrition, sufficient grace and effi- eacious grace, leave us cold. In the “Pensées,” on the other hand, we are made to feel that the doctrine of grace is at the very heart of Christianity; it is in fact, the doctrine that in its tri- umph best measured the force of the re- coil of Christianity from ancient nat- uralism and that in its decline has best ‘marked the steady encroachments of modern naturalism on the inner citadel \of faith. It is, in a sense, the distin- guishing doctrine of Christianity as an historical belief. IL Some slight anticipations of grace may, indeed, be found in the pagan phil- osophers, especially in Plato, when he says that virtue is “neither natural nor acquired,” but “comes to the virtuous by the gift of God” (“Meno”). But Plato
Page 9
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. and the other Greeks could not hold |calm but esthetic (“le dernier jour de the doctrine of grace in the true Chris- tian sense because they were “terribly at ease in Zion,”’ that is, they lacked hu- mility—the sense of absolute dependence oi a power that is above both nature and human nature. The doctrine of grace as elaborated by St. Augustine and revived by the Jansenists in almost more than its primitive austerity, was intended to sharpen a contrast not normally present to the pagan consciousness—the contrast between the utter sinfulness of man and the infinite righteousness of Deity. The gap between the human and the divine is absolute and only to be traversed by a twofold miracle—inwardly by the mir-. acle of grace, outwardly by the miracle of the redemption. For the Jansenist, as Lord St. Cyres puts it, “Nature soon be- came one vast, unholy chaos, one shak- ing quagmire of corruption, in the midst of which rose, stark and lonely, the storm-swept citadel of Grace.” Without the twofold miracle, and left to his own resources, man is helpless. The only thing noble in him, says Pascal, is rea- son, and yet, he adds, nothing is more “contemptible” than reason itself, being as it is the everlasting dupe and play- thing of the imagination. In the name of grace, Pascal thus seeks to discredit both the reason and the imagination, the two faculties by which the modern man must live. We are forced at iast, like | Voltaire, to “take the side of human na- ture against this sublime misanthrop- ist.” The difficulty with the doctrine of grace in its extreme forms is that it strikes one as an attempt to prop and buttress a tottering theology by estab-| lishing a spiritual reign of terror. This | is especially so in the use of the doc- trine by its last great exponent, Jona-| than Edwards. Without grace and Con-| version, according to Edwards, men are | suspended over the pit of hell by a slen- der thread that is likely to be singed asunder at any moment by the fire of God’s wrath, “however moral and strict, sober and religious, they may otherwise be.” We cannot blame the world for | having risen in revolt against so horri-| ble an obsession, for refusing to be) frightened into heaven. But the reac-| tion against the theological terror has | resulted in turn in an almost equally” violent and dangerous extreme. “Listen, my children,” said Mother | Angélique to her nuns a few hours be-| fore her death, “listen well to what I) say. Most people do not know what | death is, and never give the matter a. thought. As for me, I have feared it all, my life and never let it out of my mind. | But my worst forebodings were as no- thing compared with the terrors now | upon me.” In deliberate opposition to! such expressions of the theological ter- | ror Rousseau imagined the elaborate | complacency and self-satisfaction of the dying Julie, whose end was not only, ' sive. ‘Jules Lemaitre have noted the entire sa vie en fut aussi le plus charmant”). To the notion that nature is utterly cor- rupt and that men are “vipers spitting their venom at God,” he opposes the as- sertion that man is good and nature beautiful (or, as some one has summed up the doctrine in its Christian Science form: I am lovely, and the world is lovely, too). Instead of making the breach in the soul between sin and righteousness so wide that no amount of good works can avail to bridge it, Rousseau declares that there is no breach at all, that evil is introduced into the soul from without; in other words, he lays the blame for evil, not on the individual, but on society; he gets rid of the theological terror by undermining the individual’s sense of his own re- sponsibility. Not only the sentimental naturalism typified in Rousseau, but every other main current, both of the Catholic and the non-Catholic world, has been run- ning steadily away from the doctrine of grace. From the point of view of ma- ‘terial success no enterprise was ever so ‘surely foredoomed to failure as Jansen- ism. For the virtue of absolute humil- ity the Catholic Church has been tend- ing to set up the very different virtue of absolute submissiveness to outer author- ity. The non-Catholic world, again, has been moving more and more toward a 'naturalistic and humanitarian view of life that is neither humble nor submis- Good observers from Burke to absence of humility in Rousseau. The exultation of the scientific naturalist in man’s power is as fatal to humil- ity as Rousseau’s exultation in man’s goodness. As a sample of the hu- 'mility of a certain type of scientist, we may take the following from Clifford: The dim and shadowy outlines of the su- perhuman deity fade slowly away from be- fore us; and as the mist of his presence floats aside, we perceive with greater and greater clearness the shape of a yet grander ‘and nobler figure—of Him who made all gods, land shall unmake them. From the dim dawn of history and from the inmost depth of every soul the face of our father Man looks out upon us with the fire of eternal youth in his eyes and says, “Before Jehovah was, I am.” If Luther had anticipated that figure of “our father Man” with the fire of eternal youth in his eyes (the fire, he would have said, rather of eternal lust), would he have undertaken the great Schism? All the efforts of Luther and the Jansenists have availed very little to arrest the drift of the whole world away from the doctrine of grace to the doctrine of good works. In their em- phasis on good works as well as in their emphasis on submissiveness the Jesuits have merely exaggerated the modern Catholic tendency. Lord St. Cyres points out that Ignatius Loyola was the most “resolute of utilitarians.” Loyola 467 lays almost as much stress on the idea of service as any of our present-day hu- manitarians. According to the Jesuit one may be saved merely by being ser- viceable and submissive; according to the humanitarian, merely by being ser- viceable and sympathetic. Both Jesuit and humaniarian obscure the reality of sin, of the individual struggle between good and evil, the Jesuit by unduly en- couraging the individual in the hope that he may cast off the burden of his sin upon the priest and the priest's pow- er of absolution, the humanitarian by encouraging him unduly in the hope that he may cast off his burden on so- ciety. Both Jesuit and humanitarian emasculate the doctrine of good works not only as it might be, but as it ac- tually has been formulated. For, if Plato anticipates but faintly the doc- trine of grace, Aristotle sets forth very adequately the doctrine of good works. Aristotle, who would attach the indil- vidual by a thousand bonds to society, who even makes ethics only a branch of politics, does not, therefore, fall into the humanitarian error of making social ser- vice the goal of the individual. Society is chiefly impertant in the eyes of Aris- totle for the aid it may give the indi- vidual in realizing his higher self; it works upon him and gives him the pre- liminary training in right habits o in order that it may prepare him for the supreme task of working upon himself. Everything in Aristotle, indeed, con- verges upon the idea of habit—an idea at once scientific and humanistic, the means by which one gradually ascends from the goods of instinct to the goods of reason. The supernaturalist is prone to look with disdain on so uninspired a meth- od. Thus Jansen speaks contemptuous- ly of Aristotle and his little, choppy phrases that are unable to rise above the things of earth (“Minutiloguio suo sola terrena perscrutatus est”). In a similar spirit Holbein drew his picture of the prelates and doctors of the church, turning their backs on Christ, the Light of the World, and following Aristotle into the abyss. But Aristotle can be one of the most impressive of writers when the passion that so often lurks beneath his syllogistic dryness ac- tually flashes to the surface. Starting as a pure naturalist with the sense of vital growth and development, he rises gradually and without confusion of the planes of being to humanistic discipline, conceived as a mediation between ex- tremes, until from the very apex, as it were, of the humanistic virtues he glimpses a truth that transcends even the law of measure. “A man ought not,” he says, “to entertain human thoughts as some would advise, because he is bu- man, nor mortal thoughts because he is mortal; but as far as it is possible he should make himself immortal and do ‘everything with a view to living accord-
Page 10
468 ing to the best principle in him, which, though it be small in size, yet in power and value is far more excellent than all.” Aristotle is thus related on the one hand to the keenest and hardest-headed of our modern scientists, and on the other to Dante in his vision of the empy- rean. He has perhaps been surpassed as a naturalist and certainly surpassed as a supernaturalist, but like the other great Greeks he remains unsurpassed in his humanism; and it is the humanistic virtues that are needed to give meaning to either extreme. Perhaps the world would have been a better place if more people had made sure that they were human before setting out to be superhuman. Thus Pascal, who speaks so excellently of the humanistic art of mediating between opposite vir- tues and occupying the middle ground between them, was not himself a hu- manist. He conceived of religion only as a sort of “mortal leap” from naturalism to supernaturalism. “God of Abraham, God of Isaac, God of Jacob,” we read on the slip of parchment on which he recorded his conversion, “Not the God of the philosophers and the scientists.” On the face of it there is something incon- gruous in the fact that the man who made the Great Experiment and invent- ed the arithmetical machine, and estab- lished the first line of omnibuses at Paris, should be the same man that wore hair shirts and declared that sickness is the natural state of the Christian. Now- adays we are nearly all of us hardened and impenitent naturalists and from the Jansenist point of view altogether grace- less. If we have any religion at all, we are likely to get it, like Aristotle, through nature and not like Pascal in violent opposition to nature. In general the Aristotelian method of fixing our attention upon the orderly reaping of the reward of the good works we have wrought on ourselves and the world, and of the habits we have disciplined our- selves into according to the standards of right reason, is perhaps in itself more wholesome than the Jansenist emphasis on thunderclaps and visible upsets of grace—the tremendous spiritual roman- ticism of St. Augustine. III, Having granted so much, we should hasten to add that the doctrines of grace and conversion are, after all, only the theological expression of certain pro- found and, we may surmise, permanent aspects of human nature. Christlanity of the Augustinian type has at least the advantage of setting In sharpest relief the actual dualism between the higher and the lower self of man that even the Aristotelian naturalist is constantly tending to dissimulate and slur over. As a matter of fact, the example Aristotle set of an orderly ascent from thé nat- uralistic to the humanistic virtues and The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2368 from the humanistic virtues to religious | hopelessness and helplessness of a pure insight can scarcely be said to have been naturalism in dealing with ultimate largely influential. The main drift of problems. Mr. Chesterton says we have the ancient world after Aristotle was already reached the Heliogabalus stage toward stoicism and epicureanism, two |in this country. We are very far from opposite, but as Pascal insists, equally | having reached that stage as yet, though impossible views of life. This is indeed we may reach it in time if we think we Pascal's great central generalization that can discard all our traditional sanctions he has expressed most adequately per-|and discover a sufficient substitute for haps in the “Conversation with M. de some principle of authority, either with- Sacy” that is usually prefixed to the|in or without ourselves, in miscel- “Pensées.” Purely naturalistic explana-|laneous humanitarian enthusiasms. As tions of man will, according to Pascal, @ matter of fact, the American situation necessarily oscillate between stoic pride |does not differ very greatly from the and epicurean relaxation. In either case European one, except that we combine man will remain forlorn because de-|our increasing criminality and suicide prived of any firm centre in himself, and divorce and other familiar signs of of any principle that he may oppose to naturalistic disintegration with a more the vast swirl of phenomena, the endless UDflagging optimism. Europeans are flux and relativity of nature. ‘Teadier than we to admit certain Many of the “Pensées” are simply a tedium recasting of Montaigne, whom Pascal takes somewhat unfairly as a type of | the pure epicurean; for there is in) Montaigne, along with epicureanism, a genuinely humanistic element, and the skeptical mask that the human- ism assumes is itself a legitimate reac- tion from the “horrible mania of cer- tainty” that possessed the theological | ages. When pressed into the service of the violent logic of Pascal, Montaigne loses all his geniality, and something, too, of his shrewdness and good sense. Nevertheless, the “Pensées” that still have the most interest for us are those that establish the general contrast be- | ‘modern equivalents of the vite that afflicted ancient Rome. A writer named Fierens-Gevaert, who pub- lished a book a few years ago on “Con- ‘temporary Melancholy,” takes as self- evident that the underlying mood of cul- 'tivated Europeans is pessimistic, and proceeds to a regular inventory of the maladies of the modern soul: Infections of unutterable sadness, Infections of incalculable madness, Infections of incurable despair. The picture is probably exaggerated, and in any case would scarcely apply to England, though even in England there has been a marked falling off in what may be termed the Victorian exuber- tween the man of faith and the natural- | ance. ist, whether stoic or epicurean. For Our modern world, to be sure, has, the modern world, like the ancient, has|even when seen from Pascal’s special turned away from its traditional disci- angle, certain advantages over the an- plines and is moving more and more to- cient. According to Pascal, the great re- ward a pure naturalism; and it is not! source of fallen man is to divert him- difficult to detect in many apparently self; in this way he can lose in some ultra-modern points of view a mere | measure the sense of his own wretched- refurbishing of stoical and epicurean|ness (“la misére de l’homme sans tenets. We do not need, for example, to Dieu”). Now, when it comes to divert- go very deep into Sainte-Beuve to find | ing ourselves, we moderns are very su- the epicurean despair of human nature,| perior. The modern descendant of the | or, if we wish a still more recent and Roman noble who “made a feast and obvious epicurean, we have him in Ana- | crowned his head with flowers” has auto- tole France. We should, again, be struck | mobiles and can look forward to aero- by the resemblance between Taine’s at-| planes. He can count on an unending titude toward life and stoicism, even if succession of scientific toys that will di- we did not know that, like many other | vert him and beguile him from uncom- nineteenth-century stoics, he actually |fortable reflections on the essential sought a rule of life in the desolate and | problems of his own being. In the pathetic Marcus Aurelius. ‘words of Milton, “There be delights, there Various observers have been struck | be recreations and jolly pastimes that by the analogy between certain symp- | will fetch the day about from sun to toms that are appearing In our contem- sun, and rock the tedious year as in a porary society and those that appeared delightful dream.” We not only have in late Roman society, though few would | our delights, but are willing to pay for go Into such refinements as Signor Fer-|them. It is estimated that this country rero, who claims that Americans of to-|is now spending $600,000,000 a year on day correspond psychologically to Ro- automobiles, moving pictures, and phon- mans of the first century, Europeans ographs. to Romans of the second century of the) There may be some, however, who, An analogy of this kind its | without sharing Pascal's unduly ascetic attitude toward “diversion,” are, on the other hand, unable to acquiesce fully in either a stoical or epicurean natural- ism; who, in Pascal's words, feel the decadence. always incomplete and, of course, en- tirely unsafe as a basis of prophecy. So far as the analogy exists at all, it Is to be traced to a common cause—the
Page 11
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. need of discovering some firm island of Caxton, twelve printed by Pynson, and fifty faith in the midst of the “horrible flux or more printed by Wynken de Worde. The of all things.” Any wholesome revival] 5”#kespeare oe is, next to that of Pascal | the Duke of Devonshire, the finest in pri- pode to Saas cr aa tee seme! vt vate hands in England, though it is sur- be f 1 that some of the Fren token passed by both the Folger and the Church collections in New York. Early English est that has been shown in Pascal during poetry is represented by many of the choic- the past few years has been reaction-| est items from the Daniel and Corser ary in the wrong sense. For example, sales. At the Daniel sale Mr. Huth procured Vietor Giraud, applying to Pascal his for £750 a wonderful collection of broad- own phrase, says that he remains the side black-letter ballads, mostly unique. master of all “sorrowful seekers for the) A*t the sale im Philadelphia by Stan. V. truth.” This insistence on the mourn- "®™*e!# of the collection of Americana | brought together by the late William Fisher noe Ast ligious quest would | Lewis there was keen competition for the It reminds us too .arer Franklin imprints. A single number much of the old gentleman who remark- of the New England Courant, February, ed that he once set out to be a philoso | 1723, with imprint “Boston, Printed and pher, but cheerfulness would keep break-| sold by Benjamin Franklin,” brought $320. ing in. The Pascal whom it is possible The “Articles of Agreement made and con- and desirable to revive is not the Pascal | cluded upon between the Right Honourable who, according to fhe legend, saw an | the Lord Proprietor of Maryland and the 469 Correspondence. THE BUSY RICH. To THe EpiTror or THE NATION: Sir: Philanthropists and sociologists having occupted themselves extensively in studying the problem of the idle rich, might they not appropriately turn the trend of their fructifying thought towards the problem of the spasmodically industrious rich—especially when such industry is economically very mal @ propos? We read much about the economic waste of the man who luxuriates in purple and fine linen and chariots, and our souls are filled with economic horror at him who breaks good glass windows that the indigent glass-work- er may gain an honest penny; but how about the idle woman, who, inheriting wealth, wears ordinary tailor-made clothes, owns a car costing less than $2,000, lives abyss ever yawning at his side, but the Pascal who summed up his experience of religion in the words “Joy, certainty, peace.” Of course, many of the best of the “Pensées” are of a comparatively secular character, ranging in topic from government to literary criticism. Of the strictly religious “Pensées” the most ad- mirable are those that deal with the general contrast between faith and worldliness. After deducting everything that is morose and ascetic and media. val and narrowly theological, the residuum of pure religion perfectly ex- pressed is sufficient to make of the “Pen- sées” not merely a great French book, but one of the great books of the world. IrvinG BABBITT. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. The recent death of Alfred Henry Huth makes it probable, the English papers say, that the library brought together by his father, the late Henry Huth, will be put upon the market. This is one of the two or three important collections of rare books remaining in private hands in England. A catalogue in five large volumes was publish- ed in 1880. The son, in the preface to that catalogue, states that his father, born in 1815, began as a boy collecting books, though the bulk of the library was acquired after 1849. He says further: There were only two rules which father particularly observed: Firstly, that every book he bought should be in a lan- guage -he could read—a rule which was re- laxed only in a few instances of volumes of extraordinary interest; and secondly, that every book should be in as fine and perfect a condition as obtainable—illuminated manuscripts he never bought if imperfect. Mr. Huth’s collection of editions of the Bible is very extensive, beginning with the Sykes-Perkins copy of the Gutenberg Bible, printed on paper, and two copies of the Schoeffer Bible of 1462 (the first Bible printed with a date), one on vellum and one on paper. Several block-books, a long se- ries of Imcunabula (books printed before | property of Miss Nicholls, his nurse and at-| | Honourable the Proprietarys of Pensilvania” (1733) brought $515. The three Indian Treaties recently described in this column | brought $600, $625, and $510 All books print- | ed by Franklin are not worth such large sums, however, theological tracts by John! Rutty and William Law, printed by Frank-| lin & Hall in 1759 and 1760, selling for $5 | and $3.50. Books printed by William Brad- | ford, the prototypographer of Philadel- | phia and New York, do not seem to interest the collector as much as formerly, yet books | printed by him before 1700 are almost as) scarce as Caxtons. George Keith's “The Heresie and Hatred which was falsely | charged upon the Innocent justly returned upon the Guilty” (Philadelphia, Bradford, 1693) brought only $260, and Daniel Leed’s “News of a Trumpet Sounding in the Wil- derness” (New York. Bradford, 1697) only $262. The first of William Penn's folio tracts on Pennsylvania, “Some Account of the Province of Pennsylvania in America” (1681), brought $500; “The Frame of the Government of the Province of Pennsylva- nia in America” (1682), $210; and Penn’s “Letter to the Committee of the Free So- clety of Traders” (1683), $275. Gabriel Thomas’s “H'storical and Geographical Ac- count of the Province and Country of Pen- silvania and of West New Jersey in Amer- ica” (London, 1698) brought $675, and “A Brief History of the Mississippi Territory,” |by James Hall, a missionary, a thin pam- |phlet printed at Salisbury, N. C., in 1801, | brought $165. Of this latter only three | other copies can be traced. That the high prices paid last season for | engraved views of New York are likely to jcontinue is shown by the fact that $875 | was paid at the Pardee sale at Anderson’s |on October 28 for the “Southwest View” and |‘ Southeast View” engraved by P. Canot, |from drawings by Capt. Thomas Howdell. | These two fine plates were bound in with Pownall’s “Six Views in the Provinces of | New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania” | | (London, 1761). The volume cost the late | owner $105 in the Barlow sale in 1890. | A collection of 1,600 pages of George Mere- dith’s autograph manuscripts, representing most of his books after 1880, which are the |reduced to the in a house only reasonably gorgeous, but | devotes her spare time (which ts much) and energy (which is prodigious) to fo- menting strikes among female workers, who, previous to her advent, expressed themselves as delighted with the conditions of labor by which they live? In ancien. times Goody X. would have been ducked in a horse pond or proceeded against legally as a common barrator, but might not we, living midway between those barbarous days and that glorious dawn when all labor shall be unionized and all | industries taken over by an omniscient state—might we not hit upon a pie aller that should relieve the public of the an- noyance of interruption of traffic and dis- location of business, and, at the same time, gratify that only too evident penchant of Mesdames X, Y, and Z for posing in the spot light of publicity? Is it not a sad re- flection on our boasted civilization that a rich and idle woman, whose only sin is that she craves notoriety and publicity, is degrading necessity of chaining herself to a railing in the House of Commons or to masquerading in work- ing girls’ clothes and inciting hoodlums to attacks on the police—simply to draw at- tention to herself? We have devoted much thought to protecting the honest working girl from her numerous enemies—is it not about time to devote a little serious thought to saving her from her friends? These few “seed-thoughts” (that seems te be the appropriate jargon) are thrown out for the consideration of our bright and enthusiastic university students who pon- ,der on such great questions. A MERB MAN. Chicago, November 8. PROBABILISM. TO THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Sim: The problem before Butler was en- tirely different from that before the in- ventors of Probabilism (see ‘‘S. D.” in the Nation, October 13). Butler was trying to get an argument for the truth of revealed re- ligion that would appeal to the deists. For that purpose he assumed three things as 1500), a collection of Aldines, and & Very |tendant in the last years of his life, are | ‘Tue: (1) the existence of God, the Ruler of important assemblage of Spanish books (Spanish was Mr. Huth’s mother-tongue) are included; but the larger part of the great librarv is made up of books in Eng- lish. There are twelve books printed by to be sold on December 1 at Sotheby's. ——_————_—_===—_—_—__= the world, (2) the known course of nature jand the truth of experience as far as it goes, and (3) the necessary limitation of our knowledge. This last was fundamental in his reasoning. We cannot have perfect
Page 12
470 knowledge of anything because we do not have perfect knowledge of the whole. Prob- ability therefore is the “very guide of life.” As there are obscurities In nature so may there be in religion. Difficulties in nature Author is admitted to be God pre- pare us to believe that difficulties in re- ligion are not valid objections against it. But Butler goes on to show that the balance of probability is entirely in favor of re- ligion, and that this large probability is the conclusion from the study of nature it- self. And as in everyday life absolute cer- tainty is not attainable, and as religion is a matter of practical concern, the wise man will follow that course marked out by na- experience as by far the more that is, he will whose ture and probable and reasonable, accept revealed religion. Reade s of New- man's “Apologia pro Vita Sua’ will re- member how this argument made for him a preliminary basis for faith, supplemented as it came to be by Keble’s and his own reasoning. The problem before the casulists, however, was partly pastoral and partly sectarian— pastoral, to know how rightly to deal with penitents in confession and fairly appor- tion penance and grant absolution, and sec- tarian, how to get as many as possible to come to confession and thus keep them in the church, over against the rising Protest- antism The confessional must be made attractive and the Church must appear as an indulgent mother. The application of Probabilism was one of the means of this If the penitent had committed a deed which the confessor knew one writer held as a deed probably allowable, then the confessor the penitent guiltless. Of course people, the vast majority of whom could not read their mother tongue (though the princes and other high and mighty folk could read Latin readily were the chief beneficiaries of the system), would run around hunting for such a lax casuist, nor turn over books in Latin for his slippery concessions. This was, in fact, the less necessary, for it was the duty of the Father suggest the lax even contrary to his the in order to relieve the latter's conscience. Besides, such views have a way of spreading sufficiently quickly without special search for them Gury (Theol. Mor. I, n. 54) contemplates both educated and ignorant bringing them forward as their justification. It is well known indeed that others besides Jesuits were Probabilists, that some Jesuits strongly opposed that kind of ethics. That Pascal was too strict with himself does not excuse priests for being too easy with their confessing sinners, While Wesley was a hearty admirer of some Catholic saints, as well as of the Unitarian Firmin, publishing their books and circulating them far and wide, there were plenty of antecedents for his work as a revival in a much nearer atmosphere. Be- sides the things I mentioned before, Jona- than Edwards's great revival, 1733 ff., made a deep impression upon Wesley. In 1736 the “Faithful Narrative of the Surprising Work of God tn the Conversion of Many Hundred Soule in Northampton” was re- published In London. On the very eve of his great work Wesley read that book on a walk from London to Oxford (October, 1738), and comments upon it with the char- acteristic words, “Surely this is th® Lord's must consider who not confessor to if it one confessing opinion were own-—to and The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2368 (Works, Lond. ed. I, 160), J. ALFRED FAULKNER. Madison, N. J., November 7. AN APPEAL FOR GREEK ARCHAZOLOGY. To THE EDITOR or THE NATION: SIR: Some of your readers already know of the unfortunate troubles in the administration of antiquities in Greece, which have led to the discontinuance of the office of Ephor General. This act de- prived Mr. Kavvadias, who had rendered the cause of archmology efficient service for a quarter of a century, of his position, and interrupted the completion and pub- lication of much of his work. In view of these facts, the leading archmologists of Europe have undertaken to raise a fund which is to be placed at the disposal of Mr. Kavvadias, in order that he may be able to finish what he has undertaken. The committee chosen to further this end represents the arch@ological interests of | nearly every country in Europe, and in this country Prof. Martin L. D’Ooge, Dr. Edward Robinson, Prof. J. W. White, and myself were asked to be members of it. An appeal for funds has been sent out with the request that subscriptions be forwarded to the K. K. priv. Creditanstalt, Innsbruck, Austria, and it is hoped that \merican scholars and travellers who have of recent years had pleasure and profit when in Athens from the work of Mr. Kav- vadias, so plainly evident in the museums of the city, may feel like responding to it. As the appeal was sent directly from Europe, I do not know how widely it may have been distributed in this country. A few days ago a private letter from Prof. Dérpfeld, the first secretary of the German Institute at Athens, reached me, in this he speaks of the fact that Mr. Kavvadias, on the twenty-fifth anni- versary of his entry into office, was in- formed that the Greek government had taken his professorship in the university from him. This was, of course, a most and serious blow, and Prof. Dérpfeld urges his) own American friends to do what they can to mark their recognition of Mr. Kav- vadias’s efficient service to the cause of arch@ology and of museum management. If it should be more convenient to any intending subscribers to contribute by per- sonal check rather than by draft or post office order to the bank in Innsbruck, I shall be glad to receive and acknowledge such checks and to see that the subscrip- tions are forwarded to the committee in Europe. J. R. WHEELER. Columbia University, November 8. INTERNATIONAL AMENITIES. To THe Eprror or THE NATION: Sin: The recent hostile manifestations on the part of the Mexican populace against Americans in Mexico City show that our friends across the border are deficient in imagination. To @ Mexican it is incon- celvable that a human being should be burnt at a stake in a civilized community. It is also inconceivable to him that in any ‘community the general government should be powerless to punish the offenders. In poor, old “barbarous Mexico” a mob sim- doing, and it is marvellous in our eyes” | ‘lar to the Texas mob that recently burned |a Mexican alive, would be tried, led out, |and shot—probably every mother’s sor of |them—within ten hours after the crime. ‘That combination of races known as de- |scendants of the Conquistadores and the | Aztec (and other) Indians, may enjoy see- ing a man kill a bull of a pleasant Sua- | day afternoon, but it remains for nosotros los sajones to enjoy the final tortures of a human being slowly consumed by fire 'and to gloat over his screams and writh- ‘ings. Cuanhtemoe’s feet were boiled in oil; but that was some four centuries ago, ‘and it was not done by the Mexicans, but by a more civilized people—the Spaniards. | And does it become us Americans to hold up our hands in holy horror at ancient autos de fe, when we reflect on modern Texas? With the calmness of self-sufficient vir- tue we point the finger of scorn at our neighbors and cry: “Yaquis!” In re- joinder the Mexican hisses between his teeth, “Rock Springs!” Which has the better of the argument? E. L, C. Morse. Chicago, November 11. ELBA AND ST. HELENA, Tu THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In June last I wrote to you, asking whether there was any significance in tae fact that the hero of the “Return from Elba” landed on the anniversary of Water- loo. You stated then that you did not care to» prophesy wao was the Wellington or the Napoleon. Are you prepared to do so now? Max B. May. Cincinnati, O., November 11. SINGLE TAX. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Now that you have scotched so- cialism by exposing its backbone, will you not do the same for the single tax move- ment? Last year the city of Cleveland elected a board of five real estate appraisers, three |of whom were picked by Tom L. Johnson, | which means, of course, that they are dis- ciples of Henry George. Two of them are men of wealth, and all of high standing. | These appraisers increased the land as- |sessments for taxation purposes enormous- ily. A small area around the Public Square | was raised more than one hundred millions |of dollars on the land alone, | Since that time, the secretary of the board of appraisers, Mr. John A. Zangerle, himself a large land-owner, has been going about the city giving stereopticon talks on the subject of taxation. He throws e pic- ture of this small area of land on the screen, and tells his audience that this $100,000,000 of land value was not produced by the owners of the land and really he- longs to all of the people. Mr. Zangerle was smooth and cautious about it. He used no violent terms, as the Socialists do; but the point of his teach- ing is that rent is robbery. And, of course, the word rent is here used in its strict eco- nomic meaning. Is rent robbery? Or, rather, is private appropriation of rent unjust? H. M. H. Cleveland, O., November 11.
Page 13
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation A CORRECTION. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In an essay on Japanese color prints in your last number, the types made me call Fenollosa’s “Catalogue of the Mas- ters of Ukioye” heavy reading. It is the last word that could be applied to one of the most intoxicating bits of criticism in the English language. I wrote heady. FRANK JEWETT MATHER, JR. Princeton, N. J., November 10. THE CASTILIAN LANGUAGE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: It need hardly be said that the writ- er on “Pronouncing Spanish” (Nation, No- vember 3) is quite right in supporting the opinion expressed by Mr. Warshaw (Nation, October 20), that the language used in Spanish America is good Spanish. On the other hand, it is difficult to understand how he can assert that “the Castilian pronun- ciation is not used [in Spanish America], just as it is not used in Andalusia, whence 80 many emigrated to the New World,” and even that “Castilian is not a language, but a particular way of pronouncing a lan- guage,”’ statements these which are in di- rect contradiction to long and well-estab- lished doctrine. For Castilian—besides Gallego-Portuguese the only important and direct offshoot of Hispanic Latin— is the language in which the heroic spirit, the intensely loyal patriotism and the fer- vent faith of the Castilian nation have found their typical expression. If this no- ble tongue in the course of time also re- ceived the more comprehensive name of “Spanish,” it is because concurrently with the political ascendency of Castile over two other kingdoms of the Peninsula, Leon and Navarre-Aragon, it absorbed in a sense the idioms of these regions, and further- more because it became the vehicle of a literature both richer and more command- ing than that of the other Hispanic peo- ples. It is exactly this rdle of Castile and of its language in the development of Spain that gives the key to such a literary evolution as the one described by Mr. Ménéndez Pidal in his recent book on “L’Epopée castillane a travers la littéra- ture espagnole”’ (Paris, 1910). Beginning with the early part of the thirteenth cen- tury, the idiom of Castile followed the con- quering hosts into Andalusia and thence to the new possessions beyond the sea. It is owing to this well-known fact that the so-called peculiarities of Andalusian pro- nunciation are shared alike by parts of Castile and Spanish America, and that in the colonial domain the term lengua Cas- tellana is by many still considered pref- erable to lengua espafola. H. R. LANG. New Haven, Conn., November 7. PROFESSOR SANTAYANA’S PHILOSO- PHY. To THe EpiTorR oF THE NATION: Sir: In the review of my “Three Philo- sophical Poets” in the current number of the Nation, the critic says “there is in this {t%. ¢., in my] philosophy a disquieting touch of ‘make-believe’; we are to know the hard facts of life, and then we are to weave about them our ideas as in a play and im- agine these ideas to be true.” If he had said “and not imagine these ideas to be true,” he would have exactly rendered my meaning. It is a little hard, after devot- ing all my efforts to exposing the folly. and the want of “central veracity,” in palming 471 man since 1600, is excluded on the same ground that Napoleon and Frederick are. Having in mind Mr. White's qualify- |ing phrase—“in the warfare of human- off one’s imaginative theories for litera! | !ty with unreason”—we find his choice discoveries, as people have usually done in| Well justified; for this qualification their precipitancy and lack of critical con- | Tules out such statesmen as Alberon! science, to be now told by an evidently and Metternich, whose strength lay in well-meaning critic that it is I that ad- so combining and controlling the forces vocate “make-believe.” of unreason that they postponed the ;emancipation of humanity. Mr. White’s method is straightfor- ward. He gives a sufficient biography (I naturally regret that my review | vp his subject; describes the time and should seem to Professor Santayana to|tne environment; and then states the have misrepresented his book. At the | doctrines which the man put forth, or same time it is not easy to see how any his achievements in actual statecraft. other interpretation than that of the re- In this way, he emphasizes what is view can be given to the sentences there really important and omits the su- quoted trom the book itself, as, for in- | perfluous. Several of his essays—the stance: “The true theory [of the world] Grotius, Thomasius, Turgot, and Stein, like the false resides in the imagina- | ¢o, example—are the best in English on tion.” Statements of a similar nature | those men, if we judge them, as we might be quoted from Professor San-| should, by the limits which the author tayana’s other works. The point at is- cot himself and has consistently observ- sue really turns on the meaning of the led. The biography of Sarpi also is full much-abused word truth; and I can | o¢ pith, although the account of Sarpt's only repeat what I said in the review, | posthumous persecution might be con- that Professor Santayana’s philosophy ‘densed; and the whole may ,rofitably seems to me at bottom a pragmatism of ‘be supplemented by Horatio Brown's the imagination as the philosophy of | Taylorian Lecture. Mr. White's Ca- Professor James was a pragmatism of/your while containing the essential the will—Tne Reviewer. ] facts, seems less artistically fused than |his Bismarck, which is by far the jlongest of these studies, and paints what any one save a German idolater must regard as a very sympathetic portrait ‘ ,of the Iron Chancellor. Personal and WHITE'S SEVEN GREAT STATES- ‘official relations with the man, and a MEN. ‘familiar acquaintance of half a cen- Seven Great Statesmen in the Warfare |tury with Germany, have evidently con- of Humanity with Unreason. By An-|tributed to the success of the Bis- drew Dickson White. New York: The | marck. Century Co. $2.50 net. | If we inquire what each of these In a certain sense this book may be/|seven men did to entitle him to a place regarded as a sequel to President | in this group, we get some idea of the White’s well-known “History of the horrors from which mankind has G. SANTAYANA. Cambridge, Mass., November 8. Literature. |'Warfare of Science with Theology”; | emerged during the past three hundred ‘but he here pursues the more vivid and | years. Sarp!i stands for all time as the concrete method of teaching by biog- | champion of secular government against raphy. Principles never exert their/ecclesiastical domination. The argu- greatest influence until they are embod-|ments by which he resisted the preten- ied ina man. So Mr. White has chosen | sions of Pope Paul V will hold good not seven individuals through whom to il merely for Romanists, but for Greeks, lustrate the chief advance in European |or Anglicans, or any other religionists statesmanship during the past three in a similar situation. What gave edge centuries. The list is significant; it|to the Venetian resistance which Sarpi contains two Italians—Sarpi and Ca-/led was the fact that Venice was a de- vour; three Germans—Thomasius, | vout Catholic country in matters of re- Stein, and Bismarck; one Hollander— |ligion. The policy of state independence Grotius, and one Frenchman—Turgot.|from Clerical rule has gone on pene- It will be observed that there are no | trating every Catholic nation. At each Spaniards and no Britons, for the ob- struggle forward towards liberty the vious reason that since 1600 Spain| people, by a sure instinct, have sought has produced no statesmen of the first | first to destroy priestly control. There- rank, while the British statesmen have been busy in extending and perfecting principles already acknowledged rather than in promulgating new principles of general application. This is as true of Hampden as of Chatham and Burke, of Pitt as of Russell and Gladstone. well, the transcendent British states- by they follow Sarpi’s example, though they know it not: and Sarpi, we need hardly point out, had behind him all the great Catholics who agreed with Dante in condemning the blending of Crom. |secular and religious concerns at Rome. Grotius also proclaimed beneficent doctrines of universal application. Mr.
Page 14
A472 White describes forcibly the awful con- dition of the world into which he was born, a world in which war was al- most the normal state of man, and sa- tanic cruelties were practised. Amid this welter of evil Grotius published in 1625 his work, “De Jure Belli ac Pacis,” “the most beneficent of all vol- umes ever written not claiming divine inspiration.” It asserted the rights of non-combatants; it appealed to arbitra- tion; it urged that the solidarity of civ- ilized nations imposed upon them the obligation to prevent any of their mem- bers from plunging into war to the in- jury of all; it preached tolerance. Gro- tius’s gospel has become so integral a part of the belief of enlightened men and women, that it is hard to realize that there was a time when it was novel and denied. Yet the great book was speedily put on the Index and kept there; and militarism was never so acientifically organized as it is to-day. The chief contributions of Thomasius to human progress were his opposition to persecution for witchcraft and to ju- dicial torture. Perhaps it is well that mankind forgets easily, because if they remembered the atrocities which their grandfathers committed they would be paralyzed by remorse; and yet, as a warning to what lengths unreason may go, the history of witchcraft ought to be kept fresh. Protestants and Catholics were alike guilty of persecution, but where the victims of the former were counted by tens, those of the latter suf- fered by thousands. Against this abom- ination and against procedure by tor- ture Thomasius wrought manfully, and with such success that before his death in 1728 he beheld the tide of reform rising. These three men—Sarpi, Grotius, and Thomasius—strove to abolish evils which did not belong to any particular time, race, or creed: for ecclesiastical truculence, war-lust, cruelty, and intol- erance are among the commonplaces of history. But Mr. White’s remaining four statesmen devoted themselves to the more specific task of destroying or transforming feudalism. Thus we find Turgot—of whom Mr. White writes with well-merited enthuslasm—busied with affairs of commerce and of agriculture, bent on removing unjust taxes, and on opening the door of opportunity to the downtrodden classes. Turgot sought to overthrow neither the King nor the no- bility, but to curtail their Ingatiate greed in order that those who made up the strength of the nation should share in the wealth produced by their labor and should enjoy political rights. Stein performed a somewhat similar service for Germany. To Cavour fell the still harder task of abolishing the old régime and of creating United Italy. He had to overcome not only class priv- [Vol. 91, No. 2368 suzerainty of Austria over three-fourths of the Peninsula. His work on one side resembled that of Sarpi, on another that of Turgot, on a third that of Bismarck. Bismarck, indeed, is the one states- man whose inclusion in this group may be questioned. Mr, White hardly makes clear what contribution the Iron Chan- cellor made to the warfare of human- ity with unmreason. He unified Ger- many, and in so doing he swept away many mediwevalisms, not because they were mediwval or unreasonable, but be- cause they interfered with the working of a centralized Imperial government in which the sovereign should be almost an autocrat. Bismarck’s guiding prin- ciple was not progress, but reaction. His prototype as a nation-builder is Riche lieu; as a law-maker it is either of the great Hapsburgs, Leopold or Joseph, with their enlightened despotism. Bis- marck had no solution save repression or extermination for those irresistible modern tendencies which we sum up in the single word democracy. His legis- lation against Socialism was a flimsy makeshift, which failed from the start. In economics, he fell back on protec- tion and subsidies. In his exaggeration of militarism he did homage to War— the embodiment of inhumanity and un- reason. Even in his Kulturkampf he seemed to be inspired by policy rather than by principle. If it turns out that mankind cannot stand liberty, then Bis- marck, as the foremost modern apostle of authority, will have a message for future statesmen; but if liberty be the goal towards which evolution journeys, those who trampled on liberty will be regarded as allies of unreason. Then Bismarck will not be grouped with Sarpi, Grotius, and Cavour, but with the welders of empire by blood and iron. The fame of having unified Ger- many can never be taken away from him. We wish that Mr. White had survey- ed in a final essay the course of states- manship, which we have so briefly glanced at, and had drawn parallels, in Plutarchian fashion, between one of his heroes and another. But in these stud- ies he has furnished material from which readers can make their own com- parisons. At many points he discusses questions which press upon us to-day. He lights up his very wide range of in- formation with personal anecdotes, and he keeps constantly before us the his- torical conditions amid which his he- roes lived. It is almost needless to say that he confirms his statements by con- stant reference to sources. No other foreigner, for instance, has read so ex- haustively as he in Sarpi Iiterature. And he is essentially fair-minded, al though he never hides his detestation of bigotry, superstition, and cruelty. This book ought to do much towards llege and absolutism, but the tenacious correcting popular misconceptions as to Papal institution and. the* practical what makes a statesman. Bspecially in america is that title bestowed with such indiscriminate profusion that it has come to mean little. An excellent series of biographies deals with some forty American statesmen. Judged by Mr. White’s Seven, only three or four of these forty were of the great breed. His book may also reassure those per- rons who, judging from modern in- stances, fear that statesmanship is merely another name for volubility. Not one of these seven was an haranguer: all of them were men of thought; Sarpi, Turgot, Stein, Cavour, and Bismarck were men of action, while Grotius and Thomasius proved that a thinker may deserve by his pen to rank among the world’s statesmen. One other fact is shown by Mr. White’s heroes: inflexibil- ity of purpose was a trait common to them all—even to Bismarck, who was unblushingly opportunist in his politi- cal dealings but steadfast in his authori- tarian ideal. We predict for Mr. White’s volume a wide reading among the read- ers whose opinion counts. CURRENT FICTION. Clayhanger. By Arnold Bennett. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. Helen with the High Hand: An Idyllic Diversion. By Arnold Bennett. New York: George H. Doran Co. “Clayhanger” is another chronicle of the “Five Towns,” as long and as min- ute as “The Old Wives’ Tale”; and read- ers who found that provincial epic eith- er dull or squalid should be fairly warn- ed. Mr. Edwin Clayhanger is not an exciting person: a sort of Mr. Polly sans humor and inspiration. He is the son of a self-made printer in Bursley. His education is small, and his travels, up to that middle age at which (for the moment) we leave him, have extended several times to London, and once to Brighton. He has some mental ability and more self-sufficiency. The story is told so scrupulously from his point of view that he seems almost to have told it himself. It is all serious business to him; why should it not be to us? And if it is also rather monotonous business, why should we not feel that, too? Un- less for that chance evening at the Dragon, with the Mutual Burial Club, and the vision of the ravishing Flor- ence Simcox—uniess for this cne inno cent lapse into a region of fleshly joys— Clayhanger’s youth is unrelieved by the sowing of wild oats. Its one dream is escape from the printing-shop, and the achievement of an architect’s career. But Clayhanger senior is a self-wrought nior’s fight for his own future is quick- ly over. When the old —this mercilessly detailed his lingering and doddering end most exacting realist of us might
Page 15
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation abridged—the time for dreams is past, and the son settles down to middle age, with a middle-aged sister whose share of romance has been far smaller than his own. For in young manhood he has loved and lost a girl of no ordinary type; and toward the end of this chron- icle, just as a crusty and finicking bach- elorhood seems to have claimed him, he finds her again. Why she has jilted him years before remains a mystery. That it is not to remain so, and that the unmitigated happiness ever after of the reunited pair is not to be taken for granted, is sufficiently guaranteed by the note appended to these seven hun- dred pages: The author will in 1911 publish a novel dealing with the history of Hilda Lessways up to the day of her marriage with Edwin. This will be followed by a novel dealing with the marriage. “Helen with the High Hand,” as the sub-title suggests, though it is also a “Five Towns” tale, represents a delib- erate relaxation of Mr. Bennett’s scru- pulous attention to the not always to- wardly fact (speaking romantically) of his provincial scene. Helen and her captive uncle are a charming pair who would be altogether out of their ele- ment in an “Old Wives’ Tale” or a “Clayhanger.” They give play to that Puckish spirit over which, when he pleases, Mr. Bennett has full control, but which remains a very rea! part of him. It has amused him to chronicle the feats of Helen, and the result is amusing. But we must continue to think that the real business of this versatile writer is the serious business of inter- preting his Five Towns in the light of that quiet and, if you will, sombre trony which distinguishes him from Mr. Hardy or Mr. Phillpotts. Molly Make-Believe. By Eleanor Hallo- well Abbott. New York: The Century Co. We had heard of matrimonial bureaus and of first-aid-to-bachelor-housekeeping, but never before of professional love-let- ters at so much the week. Once having hit upon this novel idea, a less capable mind than the author’s would have di- rected it to the unhappily married or to those past the marriageable age; but that a young man engaged to a Boston bud should be the chief subscriber fur- nishes not only the proper thorn for the rose of romance in this twentieth cen- tury, but much the right sort of flourish and bravado, too. One trembles a little for the author when one realizes that she is actually going to put through such a proposition. “The Diary of Adam” was a farcical idea, but many have wished that even Mark Twain had stopped at the mere title. And to write love-letters advertised at the cutset to be professional is not easy. Miss Abbott neatly solves the problem by not being professional at all, and by making her heroine—the head of “The Serial-Letter Co.”—a wee thing of impulse and sur- prise. For those who like them, the hero is built on Mr. Davis's rococo lines; and though the rendering of pvetic jus- tice at the close does not take long, the sentimentally-minded need have no fear of being cheated of a thrill. The Yardstick Man. By Arthur Good- rich. New York: D. Appleton & Co. The best thing to be said of this story is that the last seventy-five pages are markedly superior to those that pre- cede. This, as novels go, is by no means common. The amiable dilettantism of the author’s previous books has risen to real vigor and sincerity in the portray- al of the financial and moral crisis in which Jones, a “successful” business man, finds himself involved. That he emerges with credit from such a crisis is due to the generosity of a moderately young Lochinvar, Roger Mathewson, a former college acquaintance, who, as an emissary of the Pacific and Eastern Railway, comes in from the West to Manhattan, tactfully declines to run away with the “yardstick-man’s” wife— she preferring, in a passing mood of revolt, his unconquerable boyishness to “Jonesey’s” aridity—defeats the money baron, John P. Carnahan, and, incident- ally, Jones, at his own game of stock-jug- gling, and then loftily refuses to drive said Jones into bankruptcy. The tale is not unduly spun out, ard the style, if not one of distinction, is, at 4A7e ' patience than did the first; here first we come upon letters which are printed only from rough drafts. As these were often hasty scrawls with additions wan- dering up and down the pages and with many deletions, the nicest Judgment was required in forming a text from them. As for the substance of these letters from August, 1514, to June, 1517, they are of course largely concerned with matters of textual criticism and with compliments which fail to bring us very close to the heart of the writer or re- cipient. Here and there one marks a sentence or phrase for the nice turn of the language or for the glimpse it offers into some aspect of old life. Now and then we seem to get a hint of the new style and model that were to create the literature of the northern lands, as, for instance, in such a phrase as litterate voluptatis sensu tangi (p. 97), or in such 'a sentence as this: Proinde videbar mihi any rate, somewhat above mediocrity. | There are several faults in the story, the | most grievous of which is the attempted | characterization of a college professor, who is on a visit to raise funds for his beloved Credmore. His absurd manner- isms and almost as absurd language are not reflected from the mirror of nature. The author’s sense of humor, for the most part delicate, here plays him false. THE LETTERS OF ERASMUS. Opus Epistolarum Des. Erasmi Rotero- dami denuo recognitum et auctum per P. S. Allen, M.A., Collegii Mertonensis Socium. Tom. II, 1514-1517. New York: Henry Frowde. $5.75. We have already, in reviewing the first volume of this great undertaking (Nation, January 24, 1907), commented on the inspiring spectacle presented by the friendly rivalry of two Oxford men at work on the Letters of Erasmus, one printing them in the original, the other in an English version. The second vol- ume of Mr. Nichols’s translation carried the letters down to 1517 (see the Nation, January 12, 1905), and we now have the | Latin text brought to the same year. Of the scholarly zeal of Mr. Allen in his laborious task we shal! not speak again at length. But we may note that this second volume required more care and repperisse rationem ut delicatis animis hac arte obreperem et cum voluptate quoque mederer (p. 94), in which an attentive ear may catch sug- gestions of many things to come, down to Sainte-Beuve’s sad comfort in being le dernier des délicats. Oftener we may hear the forerunner of Voltaire, as in the words of one of Erasmus’s corre- tanquam spondents which might well have come from Erasmus himself: Sed quamvis cartera fragilis, studio tamen sum obfir- matissimus; quae una res me et reficit et valde consolatur (p. 158). That is not just the tone one hears in the letters of students to-day; indeed, it almost seems as if that power of reflec- tion and consolation in study was slip- ping away from our scholars, and books were becoming to them more and more a burden, The two most important documents in this volume—and in the whole collection —are the long autobiographical letter to a certain Lambert Grunnius written from London in August of 1516, and the letter to Martin Dorp, written from Ant- werp in May of 1515. Mr. Allen is in- clined to agree with Mr. Nichols in hold- ing Grunnius to be a pure figment, and we have already recorded our opinion that this is the simplest explanation of a thorny question. The letter to Dorp, which makes almost a little book in it- self, is Erasmus’s well-known defence of his “Moria Encomium” and of his de- sertion of theology for literature. It is one of the earliest documents in the long battle of the wits that was then opening, and one of the most interesting. Change “theology” to “philology” and we might seem to be hearing by anticipation the quarrel of Pope with his Tibbald. It would be an entertaining study, indeed, with this letter as starting point, to por- tray Erasmus as the first of the “wits”— at least the first in northern lands. This letter should not be left without refer- ence to the phrases in it which give an interpretation of Erasmus’s use of the sometimes
Page 16
4°74 word stultitia often missed by his critics It is that illusion of reason as wisdom and biographers. the heart, appearing folly, “overcomes all the of the w to the which orld.” History of the Great American For- tunes. By Gustavus Myers. Vol. III. Chicago: Charles H. Kerr & Co. $1.50. This of Mr. Myers’s work takes the achievements of certain contemporary millionaires; principally, so far as space is concerned, J. Pierpont Morgan. The book appeared at a mo ment when three magazines were begin- volume up ning, each on its own account, a “popu- lar sketch” of Mr. Morgan’s career in serial the grave announcement and flamboyant advertising of which might have led the familiar Man from Mars to suppose that the foremost citl- zen of the Republic was being chroni- cled., It has never, in fact, been wholly elear whether this unusual amount of deserip- tion, biography, and analysis, in the case of a career in high finance, was recog- nition of the fact, sometimes alleged, that the “multimillionaire” nowadays shares the honors of public pre-eminence with the statesman and the writer of short stories, or was merely an effort to hurt down wickednegs in high places. The same doubt existed regarding the prolonged embalming of John D. Rocke- feller in the columns of the same maga- zines. The historians of Mr. Morgan throw little light on this question. Some of them, like Mr. Steffens in Hvery- body's, affect the mysterious air of a Sherlock Holmes unravelling the secret crimes of finance, They and the anony- mous authorities with whom their long conversations on the subject are report- ed “laugh cynically,” “mutter,” and “whisper,” as they run upon one or an- other clue to the Money Power's infa- mies. Others, like Mr. Turner in Me- Clure’s, apply themselves to a study of inheritances, traits, and environment, as if admitting that the subject of their discussions is interesting solely’ in himaelf. Most of them, it must frankly be admitted, approach the matter with strong signa of preconceived opinion, not of a flattering character, whose correct- ness they mean to prove, whether or no. form, Of this type of discussion, Mr. Myers’s book is pre-eminent We hold no brief for the “multi-mil- llonalres.” We have, indeed, ourselves been assured by high authority In the railway and industrial world, and by authority as far as possible removed from the fleld of muckraking, that there are few if any of the prodigious Amerl- can fortunes, the history of whose ac- cumulation would not present at least one chapter of questionable business morality. Be this as it may; we Insist nevertheless that when an historjan sets out to tell the story of 4 man or a ca- ‘The Nation. reer, it is his business to tell it fairly. If one action in that career is open to grave criticism on ethical considera- tions, it does not follow that the next action is of necessity similar. But this is precisely what Mr. Myers takes for granted. The presumption with which he examines each successive achieve- ment is that there must have been some- thing wrong about it. Now, to study a great financial opera- tion, with a view to making sure wheth- er it was really a “square deal” or not, is assuredly the financial historian’s duty. But he must also know all the facts and circumstances before he is en- titled to pass judgment. Thus, the pur- chase by Drexel, Morgan & Co. of a United States government loan in 1877, and their prompt re-sale of it at an ad- vance of 1 to 4 per cent., is denounced by Mr. Myers as “one of the very worst cases ever known of the people being betrayed.” Perhaps so; perhaps not. In order to criticise the affair intelligent- ly. it is essential to know what was the real condition of the open investment market where Mr. Myers so confidently | declares the government “could have dis- posed of the bonds without intermedi- aries.” He gives not the least evidence | of having ever examined or considered | that question, or the further question, | what incidental profits great interna-| tional banking houses usually get for lending their credit to the placing of | loans even for great foreign govern-| ments. | After this, it is not surprising to and | the author denouncing the episode of 1895, when the bankers are pictured as “compelling” a bond issue and then “milking” the government on the terms. Again perhaps so, and perhaps not; the terms were certainly harsh. But we find no evidence that the author has ever reflected on the part played by in- flation of the currency through the Sil- ver-Purchase Act of 1890, and by the emptying of the Treasury through the) McKinley Revenue Law of the same! year. The conclusions arrived at may) conceivably be correct; the method of arriving at them is not deserving of serious consideration. Historically, it is all quite of a piece with Mr. Myers’s | offhand acceptance, in a sentence or two, of the wholly exploded theory of | the “crime of 1873.” We should hardly deem it worth while | to devote thus much attention to a dis-| cussion of the sort, but for the fact that such haphazard assertions and deduc- tions do harm, and do It, not to the men or institutions against which they are supposed to be directed, but to the cause of financial reform which they pro- fess to uphold. That the methods of what has come to be known as High | Finance in Wall Street have repeatedly been objectionable in principle, illegal ‘in practice, and utterly demoralizing in | influence, is nowadays scarcely a debat- | Vol. g1, No. 2368 able question. The efforts of sound thinkers and independent-spirited legis- lators have been directed towards pun- ishing such abuses where they can be punished, and preventing them at all times. The new insurance law and the new trust company law of Gov. Hughes’s State administration; the Supreme Court decisions under the Anti-Trust Law, at the instance of President Roose- velt’s Administration; the new powers with which the Public Service Commis- sions and the Interstate Commerce Com- |/mission have been clothed; the exten- sion, not yet completed, of the public re- strictions on capitalization of new en- terprises, on recapitalization of old, and on methods of speculation in the stock exchanges—all these are steps in the same direction. Further progress in that direction will be achieved, however, /not at all through indiscriminate clamor at everything done by great banking in- terests, but by careful, thorough, and entirely fair examination of every epi- sode involving the old-time financial | practices. Nothing in Mr. Myers’s book is more ‘striking an instance of the wrong way of writing financial history than his de- seription of Mr. Morgan’s part in the panic of 1907. Two legends have al- ready grown up regarding the incident of October 24, when the Stock Exchange had approached the point of general suspension of payments, and when J. P. Morgan & Co. appeared as lenders of $25,000,000, at high rates, to avert the catastrophe. One, the popular legend, regards Mr. Morgan as a sort of demi- |'god who had answered the prayers of | Wall Street and descended upon it in a |benevolent shower of gold. The other '—which we may term the La Follette theory, because that statesman gravely expounded it to Congress in 1908—as- sumes the existence of a group of mil- lionaires who create both prosperity and adversity for their own wicked ends, and who caused with that purpose the panic of 1907, by hiding away $25,000,- '000 in cold cash, which Mr. Morgan sud- denly produced and sold at exorbitant rates to Wall Street, whem he could see ‘no further advantage to be gained. Both conceptions of Mr. Morgan’s part in the panic are picturesque; Mr. Myers, it hardly need be said, accepts the sec- ond. One is as reluctant to destroy either picture as to destroy the time- honored narratives of Romulus and the wolf, or of Joshua and the sun. Such storles make for the winter fireside’s en- tertainment. But the simple fact, which any one who cared to inquire might have learned, is that on October 24, 1907, the New York banks themselves were in a panic; that they had begun to refuse to lend, in violation of the soundest princt- ples of dealing with a crisis; that the president of the Stock Exchange set forth the desperate situation to the banks, enlisting Mr. Morgan's large per-
Page 17
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. sonal influence to support him; that the banks yielded, issuing $25,000,000 in new credits through recourse to clear- ing-house loan certificates; that they fixed a high rate of interest, in line with the well-established rule that only thus could the loans be sure of going to the people who really needed them; and that Mr. Morgan’s house was employed to offer the bank loans on the Stock Ex- change. Quiet Days in Spain. By C. Bogue Luff- mann. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $2 net. The impression made by Mr. Luff- mann’s book is that the author has been sharing the everyday life of the Penin- sula, a life still destitute of almost every domestic comfort known to mod- ern civilization. He winters on a small estate in the bleak hills of the Sierra Nevada, and summers in the Vega of Malaga with an old woman who fur- nishes his table for six and eight pence a week. His book has little to say of cathedrals or galleries, art or history, nor is it the notebook of the would-be vagabond who, in search of the glam- our and romanticism of Gautier’s time, snapshots Spain from the third-class window and the casa de huespedes. The author says, “the aim has been to write provincially—to set the local fact on its ground.” In this he has succeeded. A multitude of humble details lend un- usual freshness to what is rather a pic- ture than a narrative, with all the con- tinuity and intimacy that distinguish living from sightseeing and reaiity from pose. That contradictions abound is proof of truthfulness, for Spain is the land of contradictions. The author is not so happy in his re- flections, for it is dangerous to gener- alize about a wkole made up of such parts as Castile, Catalonia, Biscaya, and Andalusia, and it would lead one far afield if one began to answer the chal- lenge of his general statements. The im- press left by the Moor upon Spain is fundamental, but it is absurd to say that “all his [the Spaniard’s} dreams are of the East and of the Moorish pe- riod in the West. His old romances are | based entirely on Arabic themes; his modern stage characters hail from Mo- rocco; his lover of fiction is under the spell of eyes which have captivated him in Tangier” (p. vii). To affirm that “all decrees are of a suppressive char- acter; press censorship; no public meet- ing; no free education; no unions or al- liances; no emigration without permit; no petitions for work nor demonstra- tions against rapacious authority” (p. ix), is to convey an altogether false idea of contemporary Spain. The state- ment that “the fingers are used alike by rich and poor in carrying food to the mouth. In the highest society food is handled a great deal, and it is a mark of attention to be fed from the fingers” (p. 96), might apply to Persia, but certainly not to Spain. The author’s habit of intruding upon the reader his personal views of life reminds one of Montaigne, though the manner is not so happy or naive. It is a little startling to be told that “nothing is important which man may do. It may be neces- sary for the moment; at the next a new necessity will arise. Consider what any reform has ever done. Never has there been one which did not increase human misery.” For all this, the book may be heartily commended for its portrayal of provin- cial life, for its homely illustrations of local character, and for the many inter- esting facts which find no place in hand- books or among the superficial notes of the ordinary traveller. Practical Real Estate Methods. New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. $2 net. This volume comprises the addresses tdelivered during the last five years to the real estate classes of the West Side Yourng Men’s Christian Association of New York. Some thirty different ex- perts have here expressed tlemselves upon various real estate problems. Francis E. Ward, former president of the Real Estate Board of Brokers, and Joseph P. Day, the present president, are among the contributors. The public questions pertaining to realty, such as tax assessment and tenement-house reg- ulations, are admirably canvassed by Lawson Purdy and Lawrence Veiller, | respectively. An examination of the volume reveals how various are the qualifications need- ed to equip the successful dealer in real estate. The realty history of the city in general and of particular neighbor- hoods; the law of leasing, managing, appraising, condemning, insuring? sell- ing, and building; the tact for admin- listration; the diplomacy of commerce; no less than character, personality, and imagination are all required. Not only the practitioner, as well as the owner and investor, ean obtain ser- viceable suggestions from this sym- posium; but the economist also will profit by its perusal. The subject of land in theoretical economics is too im- periously dominated by certain broad ‘and rigid generalizations, such as the | assumed limitation of the land supply, ithe automatic increase of its rent, its |comparative freedom from commercial |risk, and its supposed coign of vantage as regards the other factors of produc- tion. All of these hypotheses are rude- ly jostled by the testimony of men who |make real estate dealing their profes- sion. When the retail shops begin to re- locate, and wholesale houses invade the forsaken territory, there is often “an | actual drop in the value of property so | replaced by wholesale {establish- | | England offers her successful ATS ments] (p. 203). The agent, it is now universally admitted, seeks the tenant; not the tenant the agent, as formerly. The trade is evidently as plastic as mest other commercial enterprises; and land and its improvements are seen to be quite akin to the other instrumental- ities of production. The closet econom- ist’s ideas about land remind one of what Emerson says of the young citt- zen’s illusion about society: It lies before 8, in rigid repose, with ertain name men, and institutions, root- ed like oak trees to the centre, round waich all arrange themselves as best they But the old statesman knows that so- is fluid; there are no such roots and but any particle may suddenly be- him they can ety entres come the centre of the movement, and com- pel the system to gyrate round it Notes. Dent & the introductions to the Everyman of Dickens which written by Chesterton. Sons are to bring out separately Edition G. were K. As number three of the “Girton College Studies,’ the Cambridge University Press is publishing Miss M. G. Clarke's “Sidelights History during the Migration from Beowulf and on Teutonic Period: being Studies other Old English Poems.” “The Mayor of Casterbridge”’ in Harper's new thin-paper edition brings us to one of the three or four great books of Hardy's Wessex series—probably most readers would think quite the greatest after “‘The Return of the Native.” Thomas Hughes's ‘History of the Society of Jesus in North America” (Burrows Brothers), noticed in the Nation of October 27, is to be completed in six volumes, of which the third volume forms the second instalment of Documents. The publication xf the second volume of Text is not yet announced. The seventh series of Paul E. More’s “Shelburne Essays,” just issued by Put- nams, contains twelve studies of nineteenth- movements, viz.: Thomas Hood, Ten- Louisa Shore, Francis Thomp- authors and Wordsworth, William Morris, Thomas Bailey Aldrich, The Socialism of G. Lowes Dickinson, Pragmatism of William James, Crit- (dealing mainly with Matthew Ar- nold, Pater, and Cscar Wilde), and Victo- rian Literature (The Philosophy of Change). A number of these papers ap- peared originally, in considerably abridged entury Shelley, nyson, son, The cism form, in the Nation, H. G. Wells's novel, “The New Machia velli,” the publication of which Duffield & Co. have postponed until January, sketches the rise of the hero to political fame, and his renunciation of the great prizes which leaders. Henry Frowde, publisher of Prof. Ed- ward Suess’s “The Face of the Earth,” writes to inform us that the fifth and con- cluding volume of the work will contain the index. Emily James Putnam is publishing, with Sturgis & Walton, “The Lady,” or studies of ladies of various nations, contemporary
Page 18
476 and otherwise. The same announces “The Children’s City,” a sketch by Esther Singleton of resources of New York city, as a pleasure-ground for young people. house New publications from the press of Scrib- the month of November include: under the Republic,” by Jean Bracq, professor of romance Vassar College; “What Is Van Dyke, and “Tales of by Edith Wharton. issue simultaneously America, Germany, France, Denmark, Holland, and later Spain, Italy, and Russia, an en- larged edition of Mr. Angell’s book, “Eu- Optical Illusion,” under the sub- “The Great Illusion.”” The author at- tempts the thesis that, owing to the growing complexity of the modern redit system, it is a physical impossibility nation benefit economically by t of another. “A Short History " by Eugene Hecker, is the Putnams. the Cambridge “The Works of Francis and John Fletcher,” vol. ix, edit- Rk. Waller, and containing “The WW Several Weapons,” Maid of Inn,” “Cupid's Re- The Noble Kinsmen"; Revolution 1905-1909,"" by Browne; “The First Part of lV edited by J. H. Lobban; God in Ear Religions,” yvons \ W of Ens ners for “France Charlemagne in John C Ghosts,’ languages Art,”” by Men and Th in Ey Swed Putnams will rland, Norway, in rope's , title, to establish for to the of one conque Wo n's Rights, also in the hands of American repre- University ime firm, of the nounces: as at the and Two ot ly by Geometry for Sanderson; ‘‘Commer- and Scotland, Keith, with a archdeacon of Ely; “The Binding Force International Law by A. Pearce Higgins, and “The Presentation of Reality,’’ by Helen Wode- land Theodora pre W. Cunningham, of house Henry Hlenry A Romanticiem” reprinting Prof. “English Holt & Co Beers's are two books on in the eighteenth and nine- teenth centuries, William Transcript Howe Downes, art editor of the toston is preparing the author- ized biography of the late Winslow Homer, be glad to of Homer's letters. and would hear from persons prom me ng any two new volumes were added in Oc- by KE. P. Dutton & Co. to Everyman's Library Wwe few of titles: Sir Walter Scott's “Lives of the Novelists,” by Saints- in volumes, and Con- Fifty tober select a the with an introduction Professor three The Decline of Roman Empire’ “The of Granada,” with an introduction by Bede's “Eccles al His- Nation,” by Vida "On the Other Critical by Ernest Lord Strangford “Taliesin”; bury; the completion with index, of Gibbon’s Fall que Ernest of the and the Rhys; jastie with an intro- D. Scudder; Study of Celtic Essays,” Rhys and and re Hazlitt’s “The Spir- tory English duction notes Matthew Lit with an Arnold's rature, and introduction by Nash's a supplement prints from Lectures on English Poeta” and it of the Age.” introduced by A. R. Waller; “Theology in English Poets, Cowper, Wordsworth, Burns,” by Stopford A. Brooke; Minor Elizabethan Drama, Vol. I, “Pre- Shakespearean Tragedy,” selected, with an introduction, by Prof. Ashley ‘Thorndike; Minor Elizabethan Drama, Vol. Il, “Pre- +) ne The Nation. [ Vol. 91, No. 2368 Shakespearean Comedy”; “Aucassin and Nicolette,” and fifteen other Mediwval Ro- mances and Legends, selected and newly translated by Eugene Mason; Huxley’s “Lectures and Lay Sermons,”’ with an in- troduction by Sir Oliver Lodge; “The His- tory of the Adventures of Joseph Andrews,” with an introduction by Professor Saints- bury; Sir William Smith's “Smaller Classi- cal Dictionary,” revised and edited by E. H. Blakeney; Spinoza’s “Ethics” and “De Intellectus Emendatione,” translated by Andrew J. Boyle, with an introduction by | Professor Santayana, and John Stuart Mill’s “Utilitarianism, Liberty, Representative Government,” with an introduction by Prof. A. D. Lindsay. The Nobel prize in literature has been awarded this year to Paul Johann Ludwig Heyse, who for half a century has been in the forefront of German literature, as poet, dramatist, and novelist. The Geographical Journal for November contains an account of a journey down the east bank of the Euphrates, by Gertrude L. Bell. It is a little known region, but it is full of ancient ruins, the location and of which were the main ob- The first Transandine investigation ject of the journey. connecting Buenos Aires and Val- railway described, with maps, sections, illustrations, by W. S. Barclay. One tant result of it, he asserts, will be establishment of a regular line of ers from Chili to Australasia. Now it necessary go to Francisco incouver. Other articles relate to New Russian Turkestan, and the Hima- paraiso is and mpol tea first or Vv Zealand, layas. San to The University of Cambridge has taken over the copyright and control of the En- cyclopedia Britannica and will issue from the Cambridge University Press, at the be- ginning of the year, the eleventh edition, a completely new work. India paper will be employed, by which the weight and bulk will be reduced to one-third of its pres- ent size. The new work will be issued, in twenty-eight volumes, as a complete whole, instead of volume by volume as previously. That worse than being unemployed is be- ing unemployable, and that the first state leads directly into the second, are the basic facts in a vigorous article by Edith Sellers in the November Cornhill. For the improv- ing of both conditions, she urges technical training for the young, compulsory evening classes, sanatoria, insurance against inva- lidity, people's kitchens, penal colonies, col- onies for inebriates, and, especially, reform- ed casual-wards, which, stepping-stones to the workhouse, will fulfil their purpose of helping men who are out of work to find work, and of helping them to keep themselves fit until work is found. For these last objects she suggests a labor bureau in every casual-ward, good food and beds, the opportunity of resting instead of working while there, and, not of least im- portance, their reservation exclusively for genuine work-seekers. The place for a work-shirker is a penal colony or a prison. A casual-ward ought to be kept as a refuge for decent men overtaken by misfortune, The future of China ts declared by Gil- bert Reid, who Is the director-in-chief of the International Institute of that country, |to be neither partition nor revolution, nor yet federation with Japan. In an article in the World’s Work for November, entitled instead of being) t |“China—A Permanent Empire,” this writer outlines the government of the China of \the future as that of an empire similar to |Germany, although he does not make this comparison in so many words, The time 'for dismemberment, he says, was China’s moment of folly in the Boxer uprising of /1900, with a declaration of war against the whole world, and a most outrageous mas- sacre of innocent men, women, and children. But there were four reasons why partition | did not then take place. The first was the efforts of Sir Robert Hart in behalf of China, despite his own heavy losses in the outbreak. The second was the prompt ac- tion of Secretary of State John Hay in urg- |ing upon the Powers the advisability of maintaining the autonomy of China. The | third was the position taken during the out- break by strong viceroys in arranging that no foreign troops should infringe on the jurisdiction of the central and southern provinces, so long as they should stand aloof from the Boxer campaign; and the fourth, which seems sufficient in itself, was the con- viction of the generals and ministers of the Powers that occupation of more than Peking and the metropolitan province was beyond their reach. The conditions that make revo- lution improbable are the newly-trained army, the counter-plans of the so-called reform party, and, mainly, the lack of a leader. Neither of the two men who might Lave accomplished it, Li Hung Chang, and, more recently, Yuan Shih Kai, chose to at- tempt it. As for federation, China is un- able to appreciate such friendship as Japan displays in Korea and Manchuria. The fu- ture is to be a government of Emperor and Parliament, with decentralization of the power now, at least nominally, focussed at Peking. Division of functions between the Executive and the Legislature will thus be paralleled by another division between Pe- king and the twenty-one provinces. We trust the Ball Publishing Company of Boston will be encouraged to continue its admirable series of reprints. Not long ago it gave us an interesting volume of essays by Francis Thompson which had never be- fore been collected. This was followed by | the audacity of a third series of Matthew Arnold’s “Essays in Criticism,” and now we have a selection from the journalistic work of John Davidson, under the title of “The Man Forbid and Other Essays.” Ed- ward J. O’Brien, who edits all these volumes, is happier, and briefer, in his Introduction here than he was with Arnold, and shows clearly the place of Davidson as one of the originators and leaders of that school of crackling, paradoxical, sententious style |which is carrying everything before it among the reigning London wits, and which reaches its consummation in G. K. Chester- iten. Some of the genre pictures, indirect | critiques, and dialogues in the present col- lection sound a bit thin to ears accustomed to the enormous impertinence of Messrs. Shaw and Chesterton and Galsworthy, but, }as a whole, we relish this revival of one | whose tragic death is still so fresh in mem- ory. Every teacher of English in a college of any size knows the almost insuperable difi- ‘eulty of providing the reading material for a course in the general history of Eng- |Iish literature. No library contains dupli- ‘cates enough to meet the needs of a class of four or five hundred, and extremely few stu- dents can afford to buy everything that Is
Page 19
Nov. 1 7, 1910 requisite. Into this economic opportunity there has flowed within recent years a stream of wholly inadequate little poetical anthologies and slender volumes of prose selections compiled in haste by light-hearted instructors for light-hearted publishers. The situation obviously called for a well- edited volume or two of manageable size, with opaque paper, clear type, and the ca- pacity of an old-fashioned folio. Professor Manly at the University of Chicago ap- proached the mark with two volumes, one for prose and one for poetry, of some 500 double-column pages each—a really sub- stantial provision for a year’s reading. Professors Cunliffe, Pyre, and Young at the University of Wisconsin now go a step far- ther and present a sjngle volume of some 1,000 pages of similar style, containing both prose and poetry—‘“Century Readings in English Literature” (The Century Co.). The book is a credit to the publishers, and, so far as we have examined it, to the editors as well. We should like a little of Pepys’s “Diary” to match the generous extracts from Boswell, a few letters of Chesterfield, or a part of his essay on decorum, or an essay of Hazlitt in lieu of some of the twen- ty pages of George Meredith’s knotty verse; and so, we think, would most college stu- dents. On the whole, however, the “Cen- tury Readings” covers the ground from Chaucer to Meredith in a notably satisfac- tory manner, and, as a make-weight, the editors have thrown in a translation of “Beowulf” and “Gawain and the Green Knight.” In “The Silent Isle” (Putnam), A. C. Benson has written his impressions—or confessions-—of life in perhaps a more ram- bling, intimate way than in any of his seven other volumes. He chooses, as he says, not to record his views in a single picture, but rather to sketch a hundred details, seeing life “from a simple plane enough, and with no desire to cenform it to a theory, or to find anything very definite in it, or to omit anything because it did not fit in with prejudices or predilections. The only unity of mood which it reflects is the unity of purpose which comes from a decision”— this decision being to live upon “simpler and more rational lines,” in consequence of “a deliberate belief that conventions were not necessary in contentment.” So Mr. Benson lets fly a shaft here and there at the shallowness of literary discussion, at the cock-sureness of the modern young man, at modern biographers, and what not. In one passage upon the writing of books Mr. Benson seems to answer those criti- cisms of his former works which have charged him with lack of fixed purpose. The author has finished the book with which he has lived for months, and dispatched it to the press: And then comes what is the saddest ex- perience of all; it will pass into the hands of friends and readers; echoes of it will come back to me, in talk and print; but it will no longer be the book I knew and loved, only a part of my past. And this is the hardest thing of all for a writer, that when others read one’s book they take it for a flash of the present mood, while the writer of it will see In it a pale reflection of a time long past, and will feel perhaps even further away from his book than those who criticise it, however severely. If my book is criticised as I write it, or directly after I have written it, it is as though I myself were maltreated; but when it appears so belatedly, I am often the harshest critic of all, because my whole potnt of view may perhaps have shifted, and I may be no long- Nation. The er the man who wrote the book, but a man of larger experience, who can judge per- haps more securely than any one else how far behind life the book lags. There is no season in the world in which the mind travels faster from its standpoint’ than when it has finished a book, because during all the writing of it one has kept, as it were, tensely and constrainedly at a certain point; and so when freedom comes, the thought leans hurriedly forward, like a weight lifted by an elastic cord that has been stretched almost to breaking It is easy to speak ungraciously of cer- tain traits of Mr. Benson's writing—the monotony of his the disquieting contrast between his rather self-centred epicurean life, as he portrays it, and his everlasting preaching of the creed of love, unselfishness, and consideration for others —but on the whole his is one of the quiet voices making for reflection against the prevalent worship of strenuousness and in- discriminate activity. It is encouraging to know that his successive volumes find so large a circle of readers. We could wish that he might feel inclined to vary his appeal by throwing his next volume into the form of discursive fiction. By far the best sections in “The Silent Isle” are, in our judgment, the sketches of the people that flit across the pathway of the recluse and this gift of characterization might be employed more copiously and to better ad- vantage. Whatever may be thought of his poetry, theme, Prof. William Cleaver Wilkinson has at all, events erected a very respectable monument to industry in the writing of his epics. There are three of them—a “Saul,” a “Paul,” and a “Moses’’—in four personable octavos, with which is associated, in com- | pletion of his poetic labors, a fifth volume | frankly, unreadable. ,a kind of Miltonic intention, with a kind of of miscellaneous verse (Funk & Wagnalls). What is at first so striking about the ar- ray, which is nothing less than imposing in its library habiliments, is the fact that such a bulk of verse should ever have got itself written at all in “this ghastly thin- faced time of ours,” when a first effort is usually sufficient to exhaust a poet's vital- ity and conviction. Nor is it less amazing to consider the motives which must have nerved a writer against the discouragements of such a particular task as this. For that an epic in one volume, much less in two, should find audience of any kind, to say nothing of one fit, though few, even the most sanguine could hardly believe now- adays. Not that it would be fair to deny Professor Wilkinson's performance certain merits. But as a whole his epics are, In a way they combine Browningesque execution. They have all the enginery of epic—elevated action, set similes, supernatural machinery, blank verse—everything which an epic should have, except the inspiration at once popular and literary, the universal moral appeal, intense and immediate, which does, or did once, vitalize such a production. And there is the point: in a time which has as a whole no moral insight to speak of, epic, like tragedy, is—it will not do to say im- possible, for there is Professor Wilkinson to confute such a statement—but devoid of in- fluence. Under these circumstances that a poet should be able to bring three works of the kind to pass, is evidence of remark- able force of character. And the pity of it that the waste of such powers—for wasted in a measure they are—is evidence also to ~~ ATG the unhappy conditions under which our more ambitious literary work is done, in moral and intellectual solitude, and with a desperate persistence on the poet's part in his own sense of relative values right or wrong. The Blacks have added their list of sumptuously illustrated books about an attractive volume entitled “Pompeii” (painted by Alberto Pisa, described by W. M. Mackenzie). The narrative is written with knowledge, and with a literary quality not too common in works of this charac- ter. The twenty illustrations in color as well as those in black and white are well- selected and excellently rendered. The book is imported by the Macmillan Co. In “The Buried City of Kenfig’ (Apple- ton), Thomas Gray sets forth with great thoroughness all that can be gleaned from old annals and documents regarding that interesting town in South Wales. Its known history, he tells us, begins with the Nor- rran Conquest, but the city is older, the earliest mention of it being in 893 A. D. It was destroyed by a sand-storm—the fate many cities in this sandy region— time between A. D. 1246 and 1317. and the only existing remains at the present day are a portion of the wall of the castle, sit- uated at the top of the hill, which forms a picturesque detail in the lonely landscape. The task undertaken by the author of telling the history of a city destroyed six hundred years ago, and only occasionally mentioned by old chroniclers, is one that required great patience and conscientious- ness. The book shows both these qualities, and it is, therefore, the more pity that much of its value is detracted by the in- appropriateness of its style. In a few chapters, indeed, in which the old build- ings of Kenfig are described or extracts from old documents of its history are given, scientific language is used, such as becomes a scientific subject, and these pages will be appreciated by the interested student. But the author seems to have desired to capture the layman as well as the student, and doubtless, if he had had the gift of making the past live in the present, he might have exercised a universal appeal. But, unfortunately, Mr. Gray’s imagination is not of that stamp, and all he can do, in his fear of boring his imaginary casual reader, is to fill his pages with sentimental meditations clothed in flowery language. His style is, indeed, described by Walter de Gray Birch, the writer of the preface, as “bred of pure naturalness and keen obser- vation,” but whether these are its charac- teristic qualities, the reader may judge for himself from the opening paragraph of the book: Overhead birds are singing with heart- felt joy of life this glorious summer morn- ing. All around me are hillocks of golden sand, tipped with pleasing contrast of colour by the green of the sea-sedge, with which they are clad in part. The soft summer wind whispers its sad note through the waving rushes as it comes from over the great waste of triumphant sand _ which seems as it were out of place so far from sound of murmuring sea. To write a book of 230 closely printed pages about a little group of islands which contain only some nineteen square miles of land, and a population of less than twenty thousand souls, presupposes an in- teresting community, or an author most interested in his subject. In W. B. Hay- ward's “Bermuda” (Dodd, Mead), we have to places of 80 some
Page 20
A78 both, and the combination produces a re- sult attractive alike to the reader, who has Bermoothes,” and Iwelt there always. 4t two historical and history of the islands, for eral reader, at least, has the merit complete novelty, and is told a style at once simple and direct. From successive wrecks which had given the rs Islands such a bad name, from the days of struggle and starvation of its inhabitants, through slavery times, until, feeling neglected by England, it was, not unwillingly, robbed of its English gun- powder to help eur Washington fight Eng- lish troops, and then of its struggles as a whale-fishing, shipbuilding, not too loyal colony, until the outbreak of our civil war, and then of tne glorious days of blockade- Mr. Hayward picks out of his documents the salient details of history, and so builds up a no dull moments. In the chapter on literary associations, he has brought together in entertaining fashion pretty much everything that has been said about Bermuda, from Shakespeare to Mark Twain; and even one familiar with the island will probably be surprised to learn how many men of letters have written of it fave to our never seen the “vexed to one who has is divided de the ga of almost In the Som into The parts, riptive early running, mass of Bermuda's story that has Anthony Trollope, who, in contrast author, says: And they all praise its amenities—all | “It seems to me) there can be no place in the world as to)| there can be less to be said than is about this island.” The last four with Bermuda of the pres- ent, and are in the nature of a guide book. Taken together, the two parts of the book are a history and a description of a interesting and compara- The book is well printed, although photographic illustrations jack somewhat in artistic merit and fail to give the atmosphere of the “Enchanted Ielands,”” as the pencil of an artist adequately could do, which there chapters deal place singularly tively unknown, its only Zettachrift fir Kolonialaprachen is a new periodical, edited by Professor Meinhof of the Hamburg Colonial the first number of which appeared this month at Institute, Berlin An album-like book, “Photographing in Old England, with Some Snapshots of Scot- land and Wales,” by W. I. Lincoln Adams, editor of the Photographic Times, is the lit- erary and photographic record of a summer tour. It addresses chiefly the public of ama- teur photographers, and ;ives practical ad- as to outfit, developing facilities, and Excellent is the counsel that prints should ruthlessly trimmed until they come into some sort of compositional The publishers are the Baker & Tay- lor Company, The Bari, what of the moat vice choice of view. be unity 0 undertaken Laterza Fight of the publication of virtually be a complete corpua literature from its origina to present day. The codperation of the distinguished scholara of Italy has already six hun- dred volumes are promised, each edited with of critical apparatus, but a maximum of textual accuracy, by the scholar most competent to deal with it. The volumes which have already appeared—two containing Bandello’s novels, ong of Gozzi's “Memorte,” and a fourth Containing a rep- publishers, e nave will Italian been obtained, and some a minimum | there. The Nation. resentative collection of “Lirici Marinisti” edited by B. Croce—give a most favorable impression of the series, both as to its scholarly character and its outward garb. The same publishers have also collected a half-dozen of Signor Croce’s earlier es- says on seventeenth-century literature un- der the title of “Saggi sulla Letteratura italiana del Seicento.” The death is reported in his sixty- seventh year of James C. Brogan, a scholar of distinction, and a writer, translator, and compiler for several encyclopedias. He was born in Ireland and educated at Maynooth College, but came in early man- hood to this country. Before the breaking of his health he had reviewed a number of books for the Nation. James Frothingham Hunnewell died re- cently in Boston, after having been in ill- health for six months. He was born in Charlestown in 1830, and during his long life wrote extensively on history. Among his works are: “Bibliography of Hawaiian Isl- ands and Civilization of Hawaiian Islands,” “The Lands cf Scott,” “Bibliography of Charlestown and Bunker Hill,” ‘“‘Voyage of the Missionary Packet,” “The Imperial Island,” “The H‘storical Monuments of France.” Dr. man, who was decorat’d by King Oscar II for his eminence as a pvt, died last week in Philadelphia. He was vorn in Sweden in 1858 and received his early education He spent the greater part of his | life in Illinois, and there held important offices in the church. King Oscar honored him in 1897 with the jubilee token in sil- ver, and in 1901 with the blue ribbon, which is the highest award for literary merit. Five years later Dr. Holmes was knighted with the insignia of the Cross of the Order of Vassa. His best-known work is a volume called “Dickter af Lud- vig.”” Ludwig Holme:, a Swedish clergy- | L Vol. 91, No. 2368 leading to escape from enemies or in al- lowing an easier approach to a victim. ,The former kind of coloration is knowr to-day as protective coloration, the lat ter as aggressive resemblance. A fur |ther development of the same theme has led to the recognition of mimicry ‘and warning coloration. Mimicry means ‘resemblance to another kind of animal or plant, either through a similarity in ;coloration or more especially through a resemblance in form. Warning colora- {tion means that the animal, being nox- jious to possible foes, advertises its of- 'fensiveness by exhibiting itself conspic- uously. | These matters have received elaborate |treatment in two recent publications. Professor Poulton of Oxford, an ardent disciple of Darwinism, has brought to- gether in book form some six lectures and addresses published in connection ‘with the recent centenary celebrations of Darwin’s birth. G. H. Thayer, the ‘son of the artist, A. H. Thayer, applies and develops the views of his father in regard to the réle of concealing colora- |tion in animals. _ With the exception of certain highly questionable hypotheses relating to mimicry in the butterflies of North | America, there is little that is new in |Professor Poulton’s book. The author /goes over the old ground with obvious ‘relish, and has little to say, except what is derogatory, about the splendid ad- /vances that have been made since Dar- 'win’s time in the study of variation ‘and heredity. The occasion may excuse, | perhaps, the sentimental tone of the ad- ‘dresses, but hardly the lack of critical |judgment. If the scientist sometimes advertises his emancipation from that ~ very human weakness, credulity, he has Science. THE AFTERMATH OF DARWINISM. Charles Darwin and the Origin of Spe- By E. B. Poulton. New York: $3. Concealing Coloration in the Animal Kingdom; Being a Summary of Ab- cies. Longmans, Green, & Co. bott H. Thayer’s Discovery. By Ger- | ald H. Thayer. New York: The Mac- millan Co. $7 net. No chapter of Darwinism has held naturalists more entranced than that concerning the rédle of color of animals. Before Darwin it was recognized that the color of an animal might serve to. protect it from enemies, adapting the | animal to its environment, and thus ful-| filling a “purpose.” Color was designed, | in brief, for protection from foes, and these foes likewise were designed to pur- | sue each kind of animal and destroy it, the relation being so cunningly devised that the balance of nature was main- tained. After Darwin the origin of color was explained by its usefulness either in /only to read what has been written on |this topic of animal coloration to hum- ble his pride. Starting with a reason- ably good case, the advocate of the réle |of protective color in nature is led by ‘insensible steps to the wildest flights j of undisciplined imagination. This is well illustrated also in Mr. Thayer’s beautiful book. With great skill and insight he points out some of the remarkable ways in which animal coloration might serve as a protection. His admirable illustrations of the ef- fects of counter shading draw atten- tion to a matter of interest to every stu- dent of nature. His photographs make good his claim that the lighter under- color so prevalent in animals serves to make them invisible to us, and there- fore presumably to some of their ene- mies, but whether the protection is needed or of ‘ital importance to the animal as a protection against its ene- mies is a point taken for granted rather than demonstrated. His account, moreover, of the rdle of protective markings of animals, while full of in- terest, yet impresses the naturalist as ltoo often a feat of the imagination
Page 21
Nov. 17, 1910] rather than a contribution to zodélogy. For example, many of the cases that the naturalist has described as warning col- oration because they have seemed to him to be obviously conspicuous are cited by Mr. Thayer as in reulity pro- tective if looked at from the right point of view. The case of the skunk made invisible by his white stripes that /pttractive. break up his contour against the sky line—the sky line, that is, of the grub on which he feeds—will appear fantastic, to say the least; and when roseate spoonbills and red flamingoes are pro- jected against glowing sunsets and sun- rises, one wonders whether this is art or science. The artist forgets that the devices which on a large scale seem to him to protect the animal, occur also in microscopic animals, where they can scarcely be supposed to represent all the shifting scenes of the forest; and while this difficulty does not, of course, disprove the conclusion that the larger markings may be useful, yet something more than an enthusiast’s account of the possible protection offered will be necessary to establish the view that such effects have any significance in the battle for existence. The death is reported from his home in Stamford, Conn., of Uriah Cummins, in his seventy-eighth year. He was the inventor of thirty successful mechanical devices. Besides writing upon scientific subjects he was the author of tales, historical and fanciful. dealing largely with the Indians of western New York. The death is reported of Désiré-Jean- Baptiste Gernez, the French physician and | chemist. He was born at Valenciennes in 1834, and studied at the Ecole Normale Su- périeure, in which he was appointed pro- fessor in 1881. He wrote numerous 3cien- tific treatises, and in the sixties collabor- ated with Pasteur in the study of vines and the diseases of silk worms. Dr. Henry Wurtz, chemist and scientist, died at his home in Brooklyn last week in his eighty-third year. Dr. Wurtz, who was born in 1828, was a graduate of Prince- ton University and also of the Massachu- setts Institute of Technology. He was chemical examiner in the United States, Patent Office at the beginning of) the civil war, as well as professor of) chemistry in the National Medical College | at Washington. Subsequently he was editor) of the New York Gas Light Journal, and was one of the judges at the Philadelphia Exposition. He wrote numerous scientific treatises and discovered and named the) minerals Huntilite and Animikite; the mineral Wurtzilite was named after him. Ly Drama. “THE THUNDERBOLT.” “The Thunderbolt” of Sir A. W. Pi- nero, first played in England more than @ year ago with a comparatively small measure of public success, was present- ed in the New Theatre here on Satur- The Nation. day night, and proved to be a work of rarely high quality. A popular piece it is not likely to be, for the humor of it is drab and cynical; the story, although both interesting and dramatic, is devoid of romance or sensation, and the per- scnages, drawn with admirable verac- ity, are, with two exceptions, wholly un- But as a genuine play, re- flecting the manners and morals of a class and a period, and deriving its sig- nificance from the revelation of charac- ter under the stress of circumstance, it is, perhaps, the highest achievement of its author. Some of his most successful productions—“The Gay Lord Quex,” “The Second Mrs. Tanqueray,” and “The Notorious Mrs. Ebbsmith,” for instance —models of stage craft in their way, are more or less suggestive of insincerity, of a calculated theatricalism, but “The Thunderbolt” is free from all suspicion of this sort. Neither in topic nor in treatment does it provide any cheap or glittering bait for the multitude. On the contrary, it is one long, bitter, sa- tirical attack upon hypocrisies and meannesses common to all mankind, but jattributed especially, in this instance, te the smug British middle class pro vincial. The immediate theme is the jheartless and abominable conduct to which professedly respectable and re- |ligious persons will resort in order to maintain a false position or procure pecuniary gain. To illustrate it—the story need not be given in detail—Pinero introduces a ‘family group consisting of a reputed rich contractor, James Mortimore, his brother Stephen, and a sister, Rose, married to a Col. Ponting—all eminent- ly respectable folk, who, for many years, ‘have ostracized another brother, Ed- |} ward, who has “gone into beer.” When Edward dies, however, leaving a vast fortune behind him, without any appar- ent will, they all assemble in his house, like birds of prey, eager to seize upon heir inheritance as next of kin. They all know that Edward had an illegiti-. mate daughter, whom he worshipped, and whom they had expected to be his , heiress, but they tacitly agree to ignore |her moral rights and leave her to shift Only a_ fourth brother, Thaddeus, a poor musician, who has outraged their finer feelings by marry- ing Phyllis, the daughter of a small tradesman, for love, upholds the actual, if illegal, rights of the orphan. It turns j}out—and the scheme is handled with ‘for herself. _ extraordinary naturalness and dexterity '—that Edward really did make a will jleaving his whole estate to his daugh- iter Helen, and that Phyllis, finding it j}accidentally, and tempted beyond her strength, destroyed it. At the moment when “the family” are about to grasp their fortune—the expectation of which already has led them into various ab- ‘surd extravagances—Thaddeus, too hon- est to profit by the fraud and resolved to 479 save his wife at all hazards—declares the existence and purport of the will, and accuses himself of its theft and de- struction. The scene of the confession, perfectly natural in its occurrence, is one of the most ingenious and, because it is natural, one of the most truly dra- matic that any modern dramatist has devised. And it is wrought with a re- alism that is a triumph of minute ob- servation. In general effect it is sordid, mean, repulsive, but it is undeniably and horribly true. On cross-examina- tion Thaddeus contradicts himself so hopelessly—-and here, too, Sir Arthur's cleverness is brilliant—that his wife's guilt is made manifest. Thus all the claimants, pillars of British respectabil- ity, are put at the mercy of the illegiti- mate child whom they have conspired to defraud. She, a proud, intelligent, hon- est, self-reliant creature—pitying, Phyl- lis, who has made full confession, and satisfied with her father’s recognition— declines to assert her rights, and, in- cidentally condoning a felony, agrees to an equal division of the estate, count- ing herself as one of the family. But the value of the piece consists not in the incidents of the story, but in the vigor and truth of its satire and the veracity of its characterization. All the personages have their distinct personal- ities and are absolutely alive. And they are embodied with artistic fidelity at the New Theatre. Louis Calvert, Albert Bruning, A. E. Anson, Ferdinand Gott- schalk, and E. M. Holland are the most distinguished figures in an eminently satisfactory cast. The performance was a striking illustration of the advantages of the stock system. Oscar Wilde’s whimsical comedy, “The Importance of Being Earnest,” was revived in the Lyceum Theatre, on Monday evening, with considerable but not brilliant success. In London it has just had a very long run, but there it probably was better played. The piece shows its age very clearly. Some of the particular social follies which it ridicules have made way for others, and much of the humor—never wholly original— long ago became conventional. But the far- cieal situations and the epigrammatic cynicism of the dialogue, are still potent sources of amusement. Every scene bristles with smart phrases, but the wit tn them ts seldom of that rich quality which will bear reflection or repetition. Much of it is tricky, shallow, or obvious, and nearly all of it Is suggestive of labor under the lamp. Flashes of anything resembling inspira- tion are rare. Nor is the satire In itself effective, for there is no energy or purpose behind it to make it real. All is conceived in the same light mood of indifference or even of utter cynicism. As drama, of course, the piece is of no account. It is insignifi- cant and preposterous. But it will always be more or less amusing to persons seeing and hearing it for the first time. The pres- ent representation is only moderately good, none of the players being oratorically capa- ble of giving full effect to the artificial dia- logue.
Page 22
480 Me Ss { Dent have announced a new se- illed “The Shakespeare Circle,” in Shakespeare's plays will be carefully pared for reading classes. They are to t so as to bring each within the com- pass of more than two hours and a half The Merchant of Venice” and “As You Like It,” both edited by Dr. Alfred P. Graves, will be the first to appear. Madam Lillemohr Halversen, a Norwe- gian actress who has won considerable rep- in Christiania by her interpreta- tions of the heroines of Ibsen, will soon her first appearance on the London stage in “The Whip,’ at Drury Lane. An opportunity, of course, is an opportunity, but this seems to be somewhat of a descent. The Coburn Players are to produce, at their second matinée, for the first time on any stage, “‘Aicestis,”” a poetic drama in English verse, by Blanche Shoemaker Wag- staff. The mythological story is closely fol- lowed. rs ri whicl pr be cu not utation make Charles Frohman has decided to make a Christmas revival of Pinero’s ‘“‘Trelawney of the Wells,” in which Ethel Barrymore will have the part of Rose. This piece was a great success when it was originally pro- duced here with Mary Mannering and Hilda Spong in the cast. The unabated popularity of “Henry VIII," at His Majesty's Theatre, in London, forces Sir Herbert Tree to abandon his original intention of producing Alfred Noyes’s fantastic play, “The Forest of Wild Thyme,” at the end of the year. He de- nies, however, that this piece has been shelved. He hopes to make it his Christ- mas attraction next year. The dramatists whose works have been produced at the Comédie Francaise duriug the last twenty-five years entertained Jules at luncheon in celebration of his “silver wedding’ as administrator of that theatre. Sixty-two authors were present, and M. Claretie’s health was pro- by Paul Hervieu, the academician, Paul Ferrier, president of the So- clety of Dramatic Autbors, In his reply, M. Claretie pointed out that the House of Moliére was more hospitable and less for- midable than was sometimes believed. Both the public and the critics expected more of it than they expected elsewhere. M. Loubet once asked him why people were so severe in judging the Comédie Francaise. “Ah! Monsieur le Président,” he replied, ‘‘c’est nous sommes le Gouvernement.” A government which had 171 curtain-raisers and 600 or 700 plays which it might pro- duce, and only 365 days in the year to pro- duce them in, required three er four the- atres, if it was to satisfy all those who of- fered it new pleces for production. Then were the actors—and actresses. As put it sueecinetly, “there are sometimes very beautiful—that shine Claretie posed and que there M eyes like Laurence Housman has just given a pub- Ile reading In London of his play, “Pains and Penaities,” which recently encountered the veto of the The piece proved to be a dramatization from official sources of the later career of Queen Caroline, who is depicted as an innocent victim. Comment- ing play, the London Timea ex- plains that the usual Inference that there is something “not nice” In plays held up does not apply,to “Pains in which’unpleasant sub- Claretie daggers.” censor upon the by the censor and Penalties,” The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2368 jects, so far as they exist, are treated with delicacy and good taste. The real justification of the censor’s decision Hes, according to the Times, in the fact that the lives of George IV and of his pathetic Queen are not far enough in the past for an audience to distinguish an author’s sub- jective treatment from the objective reality. Musie. BERLIN AND NEW YORK. It is now generally assumed that Ber- /lin is the musical centre of the universe. It certainly is the goal of thousands of students from all parts of the world. America contributes so many of these that not a few of the more prominent |teachers have found it expedient to fol- | low them and reopen their studios there, sometimes with the same pupils they |had at home. Of miscellaneous concerts and recitals Berlin has a greater num- ‘ber than any other city—sometimes more than fifty in a single week. The |Royal Opera gives performances ten months a year, as against the five oper- ‘atic months of New York. Does it not |follow that Berlin is the world’s musi- ‘eal metropolis? But this is to judge imerely by quantity. If New York hears fewer musicians than Berlin, it is be- cause here little attention is paid to any {but the best, who never fail to visit us. \In this way, too, we escape the deaden- ‘ing glut of music with which Berlin is afflicted. Berlin has no better orchestra than the reorganized Philharmonic, or the visKing Bostonians, or the New York Symphony Orchestra. Nor has it a |greater quintet of conductors than Gus- tav Mahler and Max Fiedler in the con- cert hall, Arturo Toscanini, Alfred Hertz, and Cleofente Campanini (for ten performances) in the opera house. | Operatically, we are as far ahead of Ber- ‘lin as Berlin is ahead of us in choral music. Doubtless the Berlin Opera de- votes more time to rehearsing than our Metropolitan does; but, after all, three rehearsals, with the world’s greatest singers in the cast, lead to better re sults than thirty rehearsals with medi- ocre artists. We send young singers to Germany to get an education and ex- perience, and the successful ones we promptly claim again as our own. This has been the situation for years, and now a new humiliation confronts ‘Europe. We are getting, as usual, not only the best foreign singers, in addi- tion to our own, but the leading com- posers are beginning to honor us by giv- ing our Metropolitan Opera House the privilege of first staging their new works, and, in addition, they cross the ocean to superintend their production personally, thereby emphasizing the compliment they pay us. Probably the premiare of “Madama Butterfly” would not have been a failure in New York, as ‘it was in Milan; consequently Puccini is taking no chances with his “Girl of ‘the Golden West,” but puts it into the |/hands of his countrymen, Caruso and 'Toscanini; while Humperdinck, for sim ‘ilar reasons, gives us the first opportu- jnity to hear his “Children of Kings.” | Next year it ig likely that several other composers for whose new or forth |coming operas the Metropolitan has ao quired the sole producing rights for this country—Debussy, Charpentier, Le- ‘roux, Salvayre, and Ravel—will cross the ocean to see them launched. The |time may come when these visiting com- |posers may feel tempted to make New 'York their headquarters, just as, for a number of decades, the leading Italian and German composers made Paris their field of activity. The French school of grand opera was built largely by four Italians—Lulli, Rossini, Cherubini, Spantini—and two Germans—Gluck and Meyerbeer—while a third German, Offenbach, was chiefly responsible for the world-wide vogue of French opera bouffe. The great opera composers whom France herself produced learned much from these resident foreigners. Why should not history repeat itself? Giulio Gatti-Casazza, now sole manager of the Metropolitan Opera House (Andreas Dippel having been transferred to Chicago), showed courage in beginning the season with so serious a work as “Armide” on what is supposed to be more a social than a musi- eal occasion. Gluck’s opera, though first produced in 1777, had never been sung in America, and the infrequency of its per- formance, even in Paris and Berlin, must have made it clear to the manager that it probably would not make a strong appeal to modern taste. However, he had at his command a bigger cast than Gluck could have dreamed of—a cast including Caruso, Fremstad, Homer, Amato, Gluck, Gilly, Reiss, De Segurola—and funds sufficient to provide scenic marvels calculated to hyp- notize the spectators into a fairy-tale mood in which they would more readily overlook the foolishness of the libretto. Quinault’s libretto, which Lully had already set to music a century before Gluck, has for its heroine a Saracen princess, who, with the aid of sorcery, first attempts to kill and then to win the love of the Crusader Re- naud, who is the hero of Tasso’s “Jerusa- lem Liberated.” He succumbs for a while, but is rescued by two other knights, who, with magic sceptre and shield, overcome Armide’s magic arts. Much of Gluck’s mu- sic is as antiquated as this style of plot, and it cannot be said that there is as much melodic invention in this, his last opera but two, as there is in his “Orfeo,” written fifteen years sooner. In its splendidly real- istic choruses, however, and in some of its recitatives, it foreshadows modern devel- opments surprisingly. For us it is difficult to realize what an audacious operatic nov- elty “Armide” must have been in the last quarter of the eighteenth century. To Gluck’s contemporaries it seemed as revo- lutionary and as much music of the future as Wagner's “Lohengrin” did to the Ger- mans in 1850.
Page 23
Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. 481 The literary works of *‘. .gner, thirty-five in number, which are not included in the “Gesamtausgabe,” have been edited by Dr. Julius Kapp, ani will be published shortly by Schuster & Loeffler. Mme. Sembrich will present at her sec- ond recital in Carnegie Hall on Tuesday afternoon, December 6, a unique pro- gramme, on which she has been engaged for several years. It will be made up entirely of the folk-songs of various peo- ples, beginning with the days of early Greece, and presenting specimens of such songs in every nation. Mme. Sembrich will sing these numbers in their original tongue. With many of them she is fa- miliar, as she speaks fluently Polish, Rus- sian, German, Italian, French, and Eng- lish, while she has studied the others with natives of the countries from which the songs were selected. The executive committee of the Symphony Concerts for Young People announces the scheme of the concerts for the thirteenth season. The first, fourth, and fifth pro- grammes will illustrate the symphonic de- velopment of music by the German, French, and Slavic nations, and will show how the national character, history, and environ- ment have influenced the music. The sixth concert will be a spring festival of sym- phonic dances, in which the music of the symphonies which breathe the spirit of spring and flowers and the influences of na- ture will be interpreted by professional dancers in costume. On December 17, “The Children at Bethlehem,” a Christmas mystery play by Gabriel Pierné, will be presented with scenery, costumes, chorus of children, singers, and orchestra. The third concert will be devoted to the old negro melodies sung by Miss Kitty Cheat- ham, who has made a thorough study of these wonderful songs, now fast disappear- ing. The Oratorio Society will revive Eduard Grell’s “Solemn Mass” at its opening con- cert, Tuesday evening, December 6, at Car- negie Hall. This famous setting of the church office, though written by a modern composer in 1863, is in the contrapuntal style of three hundred years earlier. Paderewski was the chief speaker at the Chopin centenary celebration at Lemberg, a few weeks ago, which was attended by) ‘long before that art was xenerally ‘known in this country, and his work members of the Polish nobility and by eminent men from other countries, among them Alma Tadema and Jules Claretie. The pith of Paderewski’s remarks is given in these words: We Polish musicians are the children of one father, Chopin. But he is a tree the branches of which reach to the sky, where- as we are mere twigs. He was the great- est of Polish patriots, for in the tones created by him we hear the wild cry for freedom, for liberation from the chains of thraidom. Therefore, all honor to him, because he not only introduced his coun- try’s music with his strains into the world of art, but also demonstrated to all man- kind by his works that Bismarck’s as- eertion that there is no culture in Poland is untrue. As turely as there is a heaven there is a Polish culture, and in the name of this culture and of Chopin I shout, “Long live Poland!” It is reported that the directorship of the Vienna Hofoper will be held by Wein- gartner until] March, 1911, when he will be sueceeded by Hans Gregor, now director of the Berlin Komische Opera. Art. JOHN LA FARGE. Even to those who have known the feeble condition of Mr. La Farge for the past half year the notice of his death on Monday, at the Butler Hos- pital, in Providence, R. I., will bring the shock that accompanies «ll great losses. York city in 1835. His father was an officer in the French navy, who drifted to America in 1806, and married a Miss Birsse de St. Victor, cousin of the cele- brated French critic. Her father, a miniature painter of some talent, gave | his grandson his first lessons in draw- ing. When a young man he found himself in Paris with a desire to try his hand at painting, and he procured a letter of introduction to Couture, who soon re- cognized his American pupil's originali- ty, and advised him to go away and study by himself. “Your place,” he said, “is not among these students. They have no ideas. They imitate me. They are all trying to be little Coutures.” Up to this time Mr. La Farge had not defi- nitely made up his mind what profession to follow, although his education had been legal more than anything else. He returned home and entered a lawyer's office, and it was many years before he ceased to struggle against his destiny. At length he found a friend and master in William Hunt, whom he followed to Newport, R. I. Hunt had been a pupil of Jean Francois Millet, and was the first interpreter of the French school in this country. In 1860 La Farge mar- ried Miss Margaret Perry, 2 grand- daughter of Commodore Perry of the battle of made their home in Newport. From 1859 to 1870 Mr. La Farge was engaged in illustrating “Enoch Arden” and Browning’s “Men and Women” for the Riverside Magazine.. He had be- come a great admirer of Japanese art showed the Japanese influence. Among the illustrations, which were drawn on wood, was The Wolf-Charmer. Years afterward, when he was in Japau, a copy of this drawing was shown to him in the studio of a well-known Japanese artist, who greeted him as the “Wolf, Man,” and said: “You must have paint- ed this with a Japanese brush.” While he was at work on these illus- trations his sense of color was develop- ing, and his mind was bending toward decorative work. He was a friend of Mr. La Farge was born in New. Lake Erie fame, and they | the Three Marys at the Tomb. and |Christ and the Magdalene, which were | destroyed when St. Thomas's \as burn- ed. These and The Ascension, in the Church of the Ascension, in Fifth Ave nue, were his principal religious mural decorations. It is probable, however, that he will owe his lasting fame to his stained. giass windows. In that particular ‘branch of art he was a pioneer, for he invented a new kind of glass, and he had to give his personal attention to the making of the material from the be- ginning. When he was visiting Eng- jland in 1872, he was attracted by some stained-glass of Burne-Jones. On his re- turn home he was invited to design a ‘window. He had remarked that the English artist’s work had ceased im- proving; that the modelling of form was merely the copying of a delicate ‘and often a weak drawing. The design- jer had become separated from his work- }men, so that, however beautiful his de- signs might be, the results were not | satisfactory. He made up his mind that he would follow the design through its entire course of manufacture. The situ- ation he described as follows: There were no good painters on glass, even of a fairly low degree, and the choice of glass was extremely limited. We re- | ceived here only the poorer and less artis- tic samples of material, the better being |culled by the good European workers, and | moreover, as all importations were com- /mercial, they were made, as they always |are, to appeal to the largest and widest me- | diocrity of taste. In the course of an illness he amused ‘himself by combining various tones of iglass by “plating,” that is, placing sheets of different colors one over the other. A soap dish, made of glass in imitation of white china, stood on the window sill. It was an imperfect piece, that is, it was not strictly opaque as white china, is, but was opalesceut. He noticed the beauty of quality it gained by being imperfect, and also that when it stood alongside what is known as “pot-metal,” the ordinary st-ined glass, this opalescent quality caused it to take on the suggestion of a complementary color in harmony with that of the piece of pot-metal, so that when associated with a piece of violet glass it showed a golden yellow, a pink flush when laid on a piece of green glass. It occurred to Mr. La Farge that to obtain the diver- | sity of form and the shadows in colored \glass, then done by painting, it would only be necessary to have this opal- ‘escent glass made first without color 'and then with variations of color. In | 1878 Mr. La Farge made what is prob- H. H. Richardson, the architect, who/ably his mort important work of this obtained the order for building Trinity | class, the so-called Battle Window in the Church, Boston, in 1876, and engaged Memorial Hall at Cambridge, Mass. He La Farge to do the decorations. This used in it almost every variety of glass, work was just completed when Mr. La) and even precious stones, such as ame Farge was asked to decorate St. Thom-|thysts. Most of his windows were built as’s, in New York, which he did with up with leads after the usual fash-
Page 24
The Nation. [ Vol. 91, No. 2368 482 Towards the end of his life sos fasion he ceentsa in concrete and pic- turesque wisdom, He was one of the great talkers, and it is to be hoped that some record of his oral wisdom has been ion. tried fusing the patterns together with- out leads, or joining the glass by thin flaments of metal fused to the glass and plated on—a variation of cloisonné. Of kept. these experiments the most remarkable In his art the scholarly and retro- was the Peacock Window now in the/spective cast of his mind was possibly Worcester Art Museum. ‘a limited good. It may have been more But Mr. La Farge was not only a| Valuable to us, as a link with the past, painter and a maker of windows. He /|#" induction to the study of the great was a man of literary instincts as well, |Styles, than it was to him. With his as was shown by his letters fro:n Japan. | Tange of memories it was inevitable that His most esteemed book is “Considera-|the appeal of other men's art should be tions on Painting,” a suggestive but |®8 strong as that of nature itself. He difficult work. He published also two | retained, then, despite great gifts as a volumes of essays on the old masters, | Colorist and master of monumental de- and one on the Barbizon school, entitled Sign, a sort of eclectic quality which “The Higher Life in Art.” His mind,|may make against the permanency of almost to the end, was alert to respond,|his fame. It is possible that he was and readers of the Nation will remem-|sTeater as a man and a pervading in- ber the letters he contributed on a _ fluence than as a painter. And yet when eubjects not many months ago. He | one recalls the thousands of beautiful was also an occasional reviewer in these |@nd scholarly designs, all marked by a icertain largeness, that he has left be- | hind, one is reduced to simple gratitude. In a day of small things, a great and well-rounded personality has expressed pages. For a generation, indeed, he has been the most salient artistic personality in America. In culture no artist since the Renaissance has surpassed him. |!t#elf both im paint and in words; and Through his acquaintance and by the |"°™ehow by this simple fact the com- |monplaceness that affects so much of |our art and literature seems offset. In he exercised a powerful influence |# VeTy true sense, the astute worldling, upon other artists and upon cultured | John La Farge, stood like Athanasius America generally, His books carried |®8@inst the world. where his finely modulated voice could; For his extraordinarily successful in- not reach, and had he painted nothing, | ventions in stained glass he is sure to had he never made his beautiful inven. be remembered, He brought back the tions In stained glass, he would still be glow and sparkle of medieval glass, and remembered beside Charles Eliot Nor- | added resources of depth and opalescence ton as an wsthete and, In a manner, a| undreamed of by the early artisans. To dignify this new and lovely material, he charm of his wisdom—he was one of the most delightful talkers of his time moralist. As a prophet his quality was peculiar. contributed many of his best designs. Our pathfinders of the spirit have al-| Purists say that these were too pic- most invariably been of a single type— | torial, preferring the more conventional the Puritan. Emerson, Lowell, Norton | Patterns of the Gothic tradition. We in all of these there has been a mark-|think the fairer way is to take them ed strain of other-worldliness. None of |auite frankly as gorgeous translucent this in John La Farge. He accepted the Pictures. How remarkable they are world blandly and with shrewd sagacity, |™#Y be realized simply by comparing somewhat in the spirit of those Jesuit |®"Y of the numerous faithful imitations fathers from whom he received his first With a fine La Farge window. In con- instruction. He represented to us the nection with this work and with the mellowness of the Catholic clvilizations |™ural painting which he practised as- of Europe, and his subsequent study of siduously, he revived the old system of Eastern philosophies merely confirmed the studio as a populous workshop. So him in a kind of gentle pragmatism. commanding was his personality that he Mankind was his subject, and he found made very able men his mouthpieces. it unfailingly engrossing. The sages of | Their work is completely merged with Japan and the mild aborigines of the his, and sometimes they cannot even Pacific passed under his observation. | identify their own contributions to great From both he learned much, and of both Compositions. Wherever Mr. La Farge he made some of his most briliiant pic-| 48, his leadership was acknowledged. torial records. Few men of our time /|At every point his distinguished career ‘confirmed the truth that it is the man have combined so universal a curiosity | ; with so complete a tolerance, and such of imagination who is the real man o action. opportunities for contact with the sim- plest and with the most sophisticated of As one takes leave of this great spirit, men. To this first-hand knowledge he visions of his works are haunting. added extraordinary reading In poetry Strange fairy-tale people pass by, grave and philosophy. Thus he was, in the Ba-| 'saints and benign philosophers, flowers conian sense, a “full man”; his slight. shimmer in an opalescent mist as they est talk readily veered to the® greatest never do on earth, palms wave beyond issues, and while he abjured philoso- | blue water, serrated ridges cut into the upper blue, below brown savages sol- | emnly perform strange rites and dances. One would gladly rest a while and muse ‘in the quiet Church of the Ascension |which his imagination has made one of the most appealing personal monuments. But the glory of paint and glass fades from the mind as one recalls a quiet, rather quizzical voice, an elusive meas- uring glance, and lips that dispensed that experience which is beauty and that fantasy which is highest wisdom. We have already noticed Johanna Ka- nolt’s useful little “Guide through the Old Pinakothek of Munich,” and now merely record its appearance in an English trans- lation by Clara Hellwig, with twenty-four illustrations. (Munich: Heinrich Jaffe.) “Landscape and Figure Composition,” by Sadakichi Hartmann (Baker & Taylor) is a collection of plain and practical papers written originally for the Photographic Times. These counsels are primarily for photographers, and for this reason crowd- ed figure compositions are not considered. The method is that of proceeding from the underlying relation of lines and masses to the pictorial effect. Many diagrams and reproductions of modern pictures are given, and the author’s criticism of such eurrent work is interesting, and usually judicious. The celebrated animal painter, Francois Vuagnat, died recently at Geneva, the city where he was born. The death is reported from Copenhagen of Julius J. Exner, professor of arts at the Academy of Fine Arts. He was born in 1825. Finance. AN “AFTER-ELECTION MARKET.” On the Stock Exchange, the day be- fore the voting of November 8, Steel common shares sold 12% points above their price at October’s opening. Read- ing had risen 8% points, Union Pacific 10%, St. Paul 454, Amalgamated Copper 6%. October’s routine news had been either of negative character or distinct- ly unfavorable; therefore Wall Street's assertion that the action of prices was a “preélection boom” was reasonable. On Monday before election, the strong drift of expectation was that the outside public would show great enthusiasm at a Democratic victory, especially at a victory in New York. Some parts of this expectation did not come to pass, but the Democratic landslide did. When the House of Rep- resentatives, held for sixteen years by good-sized Republican pluralities, was turned over to the Democrats by a ma- jority of more than fifty; when all the great “pivotal States” swung over to the Opposition—Ohio and New Jersey polling the largest Democratic majority in their history—and when even such famous Republican strongholds as Iowa and Pennsylvania were barely saved from a similar fate, there could be no doubt
Page 25
j ' 5 | Nov. 17, 1910] The Nation. of a Democratic landslide, and of a land- | diet and riot as you choose.” Another | 483 |If it did mean dismay and fright, then slide of such proportions as has occur- reason for the election argument's pop- | there would at least be presented the /ularity is that things sometimes happen interesting spectacle of Wall Street, af- red only four times in the past half-cen- tury. Wall Street’s predictions were fulfilled. But the stock market did not respond as Wall Street had imagined. After the news of Tuesday’s voting, Wednesday’s market opened here very close to Mon- day’s level, then crumbled rapidly away. Such losses were made, on that day and the next, as 5% points in Steel, 5% in Union Pacific, 55% in Reading, and 6% in St. Paul. Some stocks lost all of their October rise. There were various explanations. The election had been “overdiscounted.” The prophets had forgotten that the election- week booms of 1908 and 1904 occurred on the basis of 2 per cent. money and plethoric bank reserves, neither of which exists to-day. There had been too much company in the October rise, and too many “tips” to sell on Wednes- day. Finally, Wall Street had so con- verged its mind on the “Roosevelt is- sue” as to forget the uncertainties in- volved in a general landslide. Such was the week’s philosophy. The last of these “arguments” is the only one which calls for serious finan- cial consideration. It is true that great victories sometimes go to a party’s head; they did so with the English Liberals, after their sweeping victory of January, 1906; they did so with our own Democratic party after November, 1892. But it must also be observed that Wall Street, after receiving the election news, appeared to forget its own pet re- assurance of the past few months, to the effect that a Democratic House, pit-|that Wall Street, having industriously | ted against a Republican Senate and pinned its faith to a sort of financial | President, could do nothing definite, and hence would make for peace. In so far as that consideration ever had any force, it still remains. But apart from all such purely po- as a result of an election. been elections when the success of one candidate might have decreed disunion for the United States, or unlimited greenbacks, or resumption of specie pay- | ments, or free coinage of silver, or pros- | perity of which he was the advance) agent, or a war of classes, or a boom in stocks. The third reason makes an even stronger appeal to the speculative tem- per; because, while no one can surely know beforehand whether these re sults are predestined by a given elec- toral vote or not, it will at any rate be possible forever afterward to declare that such subsequent events as did oc cur were caused by the election. This reasoning is familiar; it may even be used so courageously—on Wall Street, in Congress, and on the stump—as to declare, fifteen years afterward, that the sequel of 1894 was witnessed in 1893. Chronology, indeed, which plays small part in political reasoning, may be made to play as little in finance. Every one knows that the only reason why the financial reaction of 1910 was not caus- ed by the Supreme Court's decision in the Oil and Tobacco cases was that the decision had not been handed down. But no evasion like that is possible for elec- tions. Elections occur when the law pre- There have ter helping along that result by voting | Democratic Tuesday, and while cheer- ing heartily on Wednesday over the ac- tual news, resorting simultaneously to the Stock Exchange to express its dis- approval. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Adams, J. J. Jimmy. St. Louis: The Au- thor. American Jewish Historical Society Publl- cations. No. 19. Ashdown, Mrs. C. H. British Costume Dur- ing XIX Centuries. (Civil and Ecclesias- tical.) Stokes. Benson, A. C. The Silent Isle. Putnam. $1.60 net. Boyles, K. and V. D. The Spirit Trail. Chi- cago: McClurg. $1.50. Braden, J. A. The Auto Boys’ Quest. Akron, O.: Saalfield Pub. Co. $1, i Bradley, A. C. Collection of Essays and Studies by Members of the English As- sociation. Frowde. Bradley, C. Good Sport with Famous Packs, 1885-1910. Dutton. $5 net. Brown, D. W. The Commercial Power of Congress. Putnam. $2 net. Burns, E. E. The Story of Great Inventions. Harper. $1.25. Burrage, C. New Facts Concerning John Robinson, Pastor of the Pilgrim Fathers. Frowde. Cambridge History of English Literature. Vols. V and VI. Putnam. $2.50 each. Camp, W. The Book of Football. Co. %2 net. Child R. W. Jim Hands. Macmillan. $1.50. Cohen, H, Talmudic Sayings. Bloch Pub. Co... 50 cents. Coman, K. The Industrial History of the United States. New edition, revised. Mac- Century scribes, and if the community’s mood is opportune, it can be shown that they. ‘caused whatever happened afterward, if ‘not what happened before. | This being so, it may seem strange | | | | Christmas stocking which was to come | with the vote of November 8, should | have switched sbout on November 9, and proceeded to break the market. But |the trouble lay, very largely, in the high millan. $1.60 net. Coolidge, D. Hidden Water. Chicago: Mc- Clurg. $1.35 net. Davenport, E. Domesticated Animals and Plants. Boston: Ginn. Davis, E. W. The Imaginary in Geometry. Reprinted from the University Studies, Lincoln, Neb. Deutsch, G. The History of the Jews. Bloch Pub. Co. 60 cents. Dodd, W. F. The Revision and Amendment of State Constitutions. Baltimore: Johns Hopkins Press. Dumas. Pages Choisies. Edited by B. L. Templeton. Frowde. Edwards, D. M. The Toll of the Arctic Seas. Holt. $2.50 net. “Fiona Macleod” (William Sharp). Poems litical considerations, it is possible to ‘pitch to which our speculating million- attach more importance than is war-/|aires have carried the process of antict- ranted to the break on the Stock Ex- |pating events through Stock Exchange change after election. If prices declin- | operations, two or three weeks ahead. It ed when election results were known, is difficult to imagine how this process they had at all events risen with equal can be carried very much further with- violence beforehand, in expectation of out reversing all the usual methods of those results; and in processes of this | inference from a rise or fall in stocks. | sort, the Wall Street of to-day has its A financial market where prices should eccentricities. There are three reasons why a politi- | unpleasant news, and break when the cal election is a favorite “argument” for |D¢ws was favorable, would properly be- the Stock Exchange. One, and not the long to such a world as Bernard Shaw least important, is that it happens on a oT W. S. Gilbert pictures; yet we have stated date. The Wall Street tempera-|!atterly come pretty close to such a mar- ment is not such as to be satisfied with ket, when Stock Exchange prices rose assurances that its health will be better | violently in October on news of a really in a month or two, or that it must be "Nfavorable nature from the London | careful for several weeks in order to Money market and the American steel | escape relapse. The doctor who gets | trade. Wall Street's fee is the practitioner wee! Perhaps, therefore, it will never be says, “You are pretty sick; I find nu-| merous symptoms of chronic disorder; or not last week’s “after-election break” but on Wednesday, at 10 A. M., you will | meant that the financial community was be restored to perfect health, and can dissatisfied with the electoral results. habitually advance on announcement of susceptible of convincing proof, whether and Dramas. Duffield. $1.50 net. Foord, A. S. Springs, Streams, and Spas of London. Stokes. Fraser E. Bellerophon. Stokes. | Fraser, G. Crow-Step: a Romance of Gow- anus Canal. Witter & Kintner. $1.50. Frost, W. D., and McCampbell, BE. F. A Text-Book of General Bacteriology. Mac- millan. $1.60 net. Gaskell, Mrs. Bell. Goldsmith’s She Stoops to Conquer; Good-Natured Man (illustrated). nam. $2.50 net each. | Gordon, 8. P. Birds of the Loch and Moun- tain. Cassell. Gratacap, L. P. The Mayor of New York. Dillingham. $1.50. | Graves, C. L. Life and Letters of Alex- ander Macmillan. Macmillan. $3.50 net. |\Grayson, D. Adventures Friendship. Doubleday, Page. $1.20. |Grimshaw, B. The New New Guinea. Phil- adelphia: Lippincott. $3.50 net. Hardy's The Mayor of Casterbridge. Sylvia's Lovers. London: The Put- Har- per. $1.25. |Hare, A. The Wollopors. Pictures by H. L. Miller. Akron, O.: Saalfield Pub. Co. 50 cents. Harland, M. Where Ghosts Walk: the Haunts of Familiar Characters in History and LAterature. Putnam. $2.50 net. |Harshbarger, J. A. Gentleman Don: the | Life Story of a Dog. Topeka, Kan; Crane & Co. $1 net.