The Nation 1910-10-06: Vol 91 Iss 2362
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
NEW YORK, THURSDAY. OCTOBER 6, 1910. The Week. It is a long time since there has been an item of news about the Federal civil service so important as that which is now given out concerning the Post Office Department. Not only is Presi- dent Taft to put into the classified list, by executive order, between 7,000 and 8.000 assistant pestmasters, whose ap- pointment has thus far remaincd a mat- ter of patronage, but he will re-ommend legislation by Congress putting all sec- ond and third-class postmasters into the competitive class. This will leave to the patronage system only the compara- tively small number of first-c’ass post- masterships, and a portion of tne fourth- class postmasterships, and will thus mark a notable advance toward the final extinction of the spoils system in its chief remaining stronghold, the Post Office Department. But the most inter- esting thing about the announcement is the statement that both these reforms have been adoped by the President upon the special recommendation of Postmas- ter-General Hitchcock, who has heen led to make them as part of his earnest ef- fort to bring the Post Office Department up to a self-supporting basis. It is not so very long since civil service reform- ers were sneered at as dreamers and doctrinaires, who knew nothing about But here we have the appointed Postmaster- practical affairs. man who was General as the result of his successful management of Mr. Taft’s campaign—a man who is nothing if not a politician and a practical man—carrying the civil- service system beyond the farthest point it had yet reached, so as to enable him to make the two ends meet in carrying on the postal business. Mrs. Storer’s new attack upon the ve- tacity of Mr. Roosevelt was duly tele- graphed to the London Times. Its Amer- ican correspondent afterward cabled the surprising fact that, while many Ameri- can newspapers suppressed the matter, not one had come to the defence of Col. Roosevelt. Special wonder is caused by the Outlook's failure even to mention the controversy. Here is one of its own employees directly charged with un- truthfulness, and the documentary evi- dence to back it up is furnished, yet we get nothing but silence from the Out- look. at This must be the special re- quest of Mr. Roosevelt, as the editors, left to themselves, could hardly have let alone such a question of public morals. They might, at least, one would think, have printed some little consolatory ex- Bible—as, for example, tract from the that passage where Abimelech called hastily to his armor-bearer, aad said: “Draw thy sword and slay me, ‘hat men say not of me, A woman slew Lim.” Mr. John Hays Hammond was right enough in declaring that the difference within the Republican ranks on the tar- iff is “a difference of opinion, and not ct party principle.” The principle avowed regulars and insurgents in the mat- ter of protection is, indeed, much the same; but it does not occur to Mr. Ham by mond to inquire how it comes that a mere ‘‘difference of opinion, and not of party principle,” should result in such violent animosity, such heated indigna- tion, such revolutionary explosions, as the insurgent movement has manifested The answer to this question would, in- deed, not be pleasant to contemplate. The insurgents are so hot, because, in their the regulars, or stand opinion, they, patters, under cover of a principle-- the principle of safeguarding American wages—have persistently clung to per have no rela nicious practices which tion whatsoever to that principle; and because the protective system as actually maintained is based on false pretences and is a cover for outrageous spoliatioa of the masses of the people by great cap- italistic interests. Indeed, the insurgent Republican attitude carries, on its face, a far more serious indictment of the Republican party than does the Demce- cratic. A Democrat may believe that protection is robbery and yet admit that in the eye of a straight Republican It is no such thing; while the insurgent Re- publican declares that protection is ail right in itself, but that the masters of his own party’s policy have turned it into an instrument of oppression and fraud Wil impression All accounts agree that Woodrow son is making an excellent The Nation. It is no surprise to him should have success with his audiences as a campaigner. those acquainted with that he His powers as a speaker have been long Not all fident, however, that he could go before tested. his friends were con miscellaneous political gatherings and impress himself as he evidently has been doing in New Jersey. Personality counts for a vast deal in such matters, and Dr. Wilson’s frank bearing, his good humor, his readiness and his pungency would greatly help any orator in carry- ing the thing off. But in addition he has put high seriousness into his speeches, and yet has been able to clothe his po litical thinking in such direct and cléar language as to win and delight his hear- ers. All told, this university president urning his hand to active politics has hown how easy is the mastery of the mere forms of political campaigning, provided one has the ideas and the sin- fervor to make his ad- erity and the vocacy tell. The and Kansas are aghast at the performances of Roose velt in New York. They had taken him to their bosoms in the West, insurgents of Iowa rampant but now feel that they have only been varming a viper. The Des Moines Vews, Which is the personal organ of Senator Cummins, comments with the utmost bitterness upon the course of the New York Republican Convention, un of sweeping der the domination Col. Roosevelt. The of Taft and of the Payne-Aldrich tariff, and its entire omission of “progressive’ platform's endorsement doctrine, are described as “a staggering blow to the insurgent cause.” Says the Vews truculently: “Roosevelt, bringing with him Taft, Ballinger, Wickersham, Root, J. P. Hitcheock, and all the motley Morgan, Tawney, Lurton, crew oft plutocrats, the Hessians of privilege cannot enlist in the army of insur gency.” This is very sad, but it all rests upon a strange misunderstanding of Roosevelt. In the first place, he is the whether of not to “enlist” in any army, man insurgents or regulars It is his mission to command them both That is a part of his all-embracing com which is the thing that we should have supposed the prehensiveness, second Western insurgents would have grasped
Page 2
PF Aa Bb. ener eg ier aoe ee eRe rus = a + “tee te ea before now. Having put himself at their head on his Western tour, what more natural than that he should return to put himself also at the head of the Ad- ministration supporters in the East? This is only a proof of his many-sided- ness. As for the New York platform, so offensive to the West, Mr. Roosevelt could privately explain it to Senator Cummins as merely the temporary shift of a “practical” man bent on carrying his immediate point. The most bitter enemy of labor or- ganizations would hate to believe them directly responsible forthe awful crime of blowing up the building of the Los Angeles Times. That the terrible de- struction, with the loss of a score of lives, was due to an explosion of dyna- mite from the outside, appears to be conclusively established. Murderous as- sault by bombs was also planned at the same time, it is evident, against individ- uals in the city. But, although the Times itself had long been a non-union office, and had taken a strong position against the tyrannies of labor organizations, we are very reluctant to believe that the deed received anything like official sanc- tion from the labor leaders. The work may have been that of some miscreant who acted on his own notion. But granting this, we cannot emphasize too strongly the duty which this frightful assassination places upon the men re- sponsible for labor organizations. It is for them not only to disavow and de- pounce the crime, as they are doing, but to bend every energy to catch the crim- inal and make an example of him. But further than this, the appalling tragedy at Los Angeles should bite it into the minds of labor leaders that they can- not afford even to dally with talk about olence, or getting what they imagine to be their rights by force. A contribution to the explanation of the bigher cost of living has been made by the Census Bureau. Great increases io the growth of cities are reported from every section of the country. This does not mean merely that great numbers of people have flocked to the urban zone from the suburban zone, but a wide ex- pansion of the urban zone itself. The great advance in traction facilities has enabled communities to spread over the surrounding country, providing individ ual homes rathey thar? herding newcom- The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 ers in already congested centres. This fit system very often works on /jines too increase in the size of cities, territorial-|similar to the commercial insurance ly as well as numerically, has been the companies. The employee receives her means of wiping out thousands of acres benefit only if she is ill or injured of productive land that were used as | while still in the employ of the store. market gardens, and the men who work- If she leaves or is discharged, she sacri- ed them have either become toilers in the city or are taking life easy on the money paid for their farms. This has pushed the growing of market supplies farther into the country and into the hands of men new to the business. A decade ago thousands of farmers load- ed their wagons at night and drove to New York with produce raised on ground now occupied by mile after mile of homes. In New Jersey hundreds of farms have been given up to the real estate men, and lie unworked while waiting for the tide of settlement to reach them. It is plain from a study of the census returns that the demand for food products has been pushing the supply harder and harder. The article on salesgirls in the Octo- ber McClure’s is the first of a series by Mrs. Clark and Miss Wyatt on working women in New York. This series prom- ises to be subversive of some of the stock ideas of the ultimate consumer. He knows little of the elaborate pro- cesses involved in providing him with the thousand and one articles which make up daily life, beyond the bad man- ners or inattention of the clerk who waits on him. It is time that he should take a look at the question from the saleswoman’s side of the counter. Wages too small to admit of decent living, and fitful chances of promotion, added to nine hours of standing a day, may ex- cuse poor service. From the fifty his- tories collected among stores of differ- ent grades, the authors have given the details in the lives of six of these self- supporting women whose wages range from $4 to $12 a week. The pitiful struggle of those more poorly paid to make both ends meet during health and activity leaves the reader to won- der just what becomes of theio in case ‘of illness or when they are laid off dur- ing the slack season. Some unconscious ironies are reveal- ed in the six stories which the authors have selected as typical. Four of the women manage to get along on their salaries by virtue of the charitable homes in which they live. Also, the bene- | fices to the management the amount she has already paid in. Such questions as hours of employment too long for health and seasonal overwork at Christmas time can be wholly regulated only by law, and the Consumers’ League is con- tinually working for proper legislation. The difficulty of wages the girls may help to settle by organizing, while only a changed attitude on the part of the purchasing public can obviate certain others. For instance, it is useless for |the law to demand stools behind the ‘counters if the public will not buy from |a seated clerk. And those who object to ‘having the stores open till midnight during the week before Christmas will have a formidable opposition with 'which to contend just so long as an | enay-going public is willing to leave Christmas shopping until the last min- | ute, | | The horrible outcome of the Vander- ‘bilt Cup race makes it clear that our /roads do not lend themselves to so dan- _gerous and terrible a sport. For the benefits to be gained there is little to ‘be said. It is thrilling and dramatic _to see a car flash by at the rate of sev- ‘enty miles an hour, with its crew in deadly peril of their lives, but the thrill lasts only an instant and it is doubtful if it is adequate compensation. More in- teresting is the assemblage of cars and people and the excitement of staying up all night and racing back to town the next morning. But the price is too high. If there are those who feel they must still race, let them compete on tracks. A statement issued from the Standard Oil office intimates that the company is preparing for a war of prices in its for- eign field, in view of the recent immense increase, present or prospective, in oil production by foreign companies. To people who watched the singular out- burst of share speculation in London, last February, this announcement will at once call to mind the “oil boom” on which much of that speculation con- verged. One heard chiefly, in those pip- ing days on London's Stock Exchange, of the “rubber mania,” and rubber Se reat
Page 3
OP ge OO: Grp a. | Oct 6, 1910] The Nation. shares, new and old, undoubtedly kept the centre of the stage. But the oil shares held their own; while new is- sues of rubber company stock, in the first half of 1910, footed up $83,000,000, as against only $4,500,000 in the first half of 1909, new issues of oil-company shares rose in the similar period from $6,500,000 to $42,500,000. Just as the rubber boom was started by an extraor- dinary increase in shipments of that commodity to America for the motor- car trade, so the oil boom pivoted on a sudden order for 50,000 tons of fuel oil from the Scotch refiners for the British navy. The oil craze, like the rubber mania, ran its course, and prices for the shares got down by midsummer 25 to 40 per cent. below the February price. But meantime, thanks to the British pub- iic’s eagerness to place its capital at the service of the new producing enter- prises, they are equipped for competi- tion. This phase of the trade situation the Standard Oil Company recognizes with- | out mincing words. Its circular points out that “the level of prices for refined oil to-day in the United States is lower than at any time during recent years”; that “as a direct result of these prices, the consumption of refined oil in this country is increasing,” and that the purpose of the cutting of prices in the foreign field is “to increase the world’s consumption.” There are several inter esting aspects of the formal inaugura- tion of such a policy. It may attract at- tention on London’s Stock Exchange, where it could hardly be much more palatable to the “Oil Department” than the recent sudden shrinkage of orders from American tire-manufacturers was to the rubber-share specialists. But what is likely to attract the most atten- tion is the frank recognition, by the Standard Oil, of an old-fashioned prin- ciple of trade which we have lately been assured was obsolete. No secret appears to be made of the fact that low- er prices will stimulate demand from consumers, nor is any qualification ap- plied to the theory that the way to meet aggressive foreign competition is to meet it. Since the formation of our enormous Trusts in other lines of indus- try—a matter, principally, of the ten past years—we have heard much of the new idea that reduction of prices brings no fresh business, and that trade sup- ply and demand need have no influence on market quotations. The heresy of the Standard Oil, as regards this industrial philosophy, is the more noteworthy in that it not only repudiates the notion as applied to the foreign field, but plainly intimates that supply and demand are playing their usual réle at home. Under the heading, “A Severe Indict- ment,” the Educational Review reprints from the San Francisco Argonaut a statement concerning the qualities of our college-bred young men which it would be difficult to match in the anti- college utterances of recent years, nu- merous and sweeping as these have been. “In recruiting its service,” says the Argonaut, speaking of its own ex- | perience, “trial has again and again been made of the college-bred youth, but | never with any approach to success. We have never yet been able to find a col- lege-bred youth, without a long subse- quent practical drill, who could write clean English, or who could even write a hand which the printer could read.) Not one of those from Frank Pixley down, whose work in the Argonaut has been an element in its character and in- fluence, has been a man of college breed- ing. This remark applies to other pub- lications of the country representative of journalism in its higher rank. It is only a few months ago that there was assembled at a dinner table in the Cen- tury Club at New York a little group representing the very highest forces in American journalism—including the editor of Harper's Weekly, the then edi tor of the Century, and others of equal note—when, through a chance inquiry, it developed that only one present was a college-bred man.” And more to the same effect. But the trouble «ith this sort of general denunciation is that it obviously overshoots the mark. The ele- ment of truth in the Argonaut’s com- plaint would be much more forcibly brought home if presented with more balance. The fact is that neither in our colleges nor in our high schools do we insist upon habits of thorough and ex- act mastery of intellectual tasks as does the German Gymnasium or the English public school—with results that are evi- dent in many ways, though not justify- ing a view so gloomy as that of the irgonaut It is a rare compliment to our all too little recognized linguistic attainments that the French have just done us. ™ Damour, recent dispatches from Paris announce, formerly vice-consu!l at New Orleans, is on his way to these shores on “an official mission to encourage th: teaching of French in American schools, especially in those of Louisiana.’ The gallant Frenchman, we take it, has con versed in his own tongue with some of our countrymen. He has then made in- quiries, and been informed, to his great surprise, that their command of the lan guage was unusual for Ameriv@ns, the great mass of whom do not get to col- lege or even high school, where alone the language is taught. Encouraged by the progress his informants have shown after only three or four years of French in the high school and four more in col lege, he naturally has become énthusi astic when he has thought of what they might do if they began six or eight years earlier. We wish him all success in his mission of encouraging the teacb- ing of French in American schools, and merely beg to suggest the addition of the words “and colleges.” There is at least one country where “catchwords” in politics are under the ban. The Imperial Chancellor of Ger- many has been explaining his plan of campaign for the' election of a new Reichstag next year, and the semi-off- cial organ of the Government, the Norddeutscher Zeitung, in setting forth the programme of Bethmann-Hollweg, states that “we can give the assurance that in the highest responsible quarter catchwords are not being sought.” What is being sought is, apparently, a catch- all. For in the announced strategy of the Chancellor, as respects the next po- litical battle, we have one of those beautifully vague statements which defy analysis, and almost defy attack, but which are designed to attract the sup- port of all shades of opinion. Listen to this: “The Imperial Chance llor consid- ers it his principal task so to conduct the affairs of the Empire tht every- thing which is necessary for the pros- perity of its industrial and commercial life and for its military protection may be assured to it, and that its continued ? intellectual development may be safe ”" Does it not remind you of guarded. the finest Republican definition of the blessings of protection? Such sonorous phrases are not, indeed, catchwords, t they are intended to be catch-votes
Page 4
306 HE NEW YORK CAMPAIGN Stimson's nomination at Saratoga rnor was a shrewd and strong their list of eligibles, the New York State rrom an of could chosen a more promising can- For vho has displayed unusual ability, Mr. Stimson is not only a a capacity for hard work, but one public activity as Federal prose- tor makes him peculiarly available at juncture. It was his skil- of p sgn aving the web of evidence Morse which sent that unscrupu- ich man to jail, and his prosecu- Trust railways for rebating were equal- ions of the Sugar for stealing and ot equally impressed We do Stimson is a iccessful, and popular mind. not know M1 good cam- or would, in any case, boast of but Mr. to do the campaigning and the bis achi Roosevelt is I id vements, oasting for him Stimson the found in As an opponent to Mr Rochester have solution of the It was rats at n A oblem which confronted them. no Dix a happy il that their nominee should not i Tammany man and should not be Mr. Dix is bears an historic name of before Hearst. He has never done anything to His reputation is that inger * lustre. in business and and He too stanch a Democrat to support money and man honorable courageous in politics. in 1906, when by that adventurer secured the Dem- As State Chairman working nomination. ir, Mr. Dix rd and fruitfully to bring back the has been to its old standards and to tone its management. This was done with- the least thought of self-seeking, the at the yielding only ie long resisted demand Rochester that he should become candidate for Governor, when assured that his nomination could unite the party and meet the pe- He Is not an best cullar needs of the hour. orator of the impetuous kind, but is a character and convic- if elected, man of positive tions, and would certainly, gi the State a conscientiously busi ness-like As for Rochester ylicans in precision and in vigor. and clean administration. the platform adopted at it is superior to that of the Repu It is matt oth progressive and aggressive. In ‘rs concerning the State alone, it The Nation. swords most effectively with But the plank which | which of greatest strategic value in this crosses the Republicans. will most attract attention and is campaign, is the one openly challenging | ‘stands now. and directly attacking the New Nation- alism of Theodore Roosevelt. To have shirked this matter would have been not only recreant but foolish. Roose- velt is to be the head and front of the Republican campaign in this State. He made his party ticket; he is to put forth great exertions to elect it. It is a sure political instinct, then, which prompted the Democratic leaders to point their guns straight at him. To be sure, not a word is said about this doctrine in the Saratoga platform. Not even a faint hint of the purpose to promote such a doctrine is contained in it. Such suppression, however, can only be re- garded as an admission of the impolicy of attempting to force that issue at the present time upon the voters of this State, not as any ground for imagining that the danger which it portends has passed, or that it is not imminent. The doctrine so deliberately and so emphat- ically propounded in the Osawatomie speech is but the latest and most ex- treme expression of a spirit and ten- ‘dency which Mr. Roosevelt has always embodied. The limits of its manifesta- tion by him have been simply such as have been set by his opportunities, or his estimate of those opportunities. In preparing his Osawatomie speech, he felt that the time was propitious for [ Vol. 91, No. 2362 the tariff. By no sign or hint does it indicate that special interests, with an illegitimate and sinister hold on the par- ty, dictated any feature of the tariff 'as it stood before the revision or as it Notorious as it is that not even the crudest attempt was made to conform with the promise of the Re- publican platform, the Saratoga plat- form has the effrontery to talk about “still more accurately” determining in the future the difference in cost of pro- duction at home and abroad. What was done in the last Republican campaign in the way of tariff-reform promises was accurately characterized by Judge Parker in his speech. “The promise of a revision of the tariff,” he said, “by a special session of Congress, to be called immediately after the inauguration of the next President, was intended to hold the tariff-reduction Republicans in line, while the trick in the phraseology was to be made clear to the tariff beneficiar- ies.” And it was because the trick thus devised was carried out according to programme that we have seen the great insurgent movement which has split the Republican party in twain. It was only after the trick had been executed that the big men of the regular Republican organization realized that the honest tariff-reduction Republicans were suffi- cient in numbers and importance to be reckoned with after election as well as before. President Taft’s Winona speech, following on his laudation of Aldrich at Boston, was the signal for the breaking ‘out of a storm of which the strength that extreme deliverance; since then he has judged it expedient to reiegate to the rear the doctrine of suppression of State functions and unlimited exalta- tion of executive power centralized in and volume hav; been made continual- ily more manifest from that day to this. And yet the Saratoga Convention calm- ly goes on record as standing pat upon ‘the Payne-Aldrich tariff and inviting its the President at Washington. But with that doctrine Mr. Roosevelt is indissolu- bly bound up; and no result of the suc- cess of his campaign in New York would be more certain than that it would immeasurably increase his power ‘not only to advance his personal ambi- tions, but to promote the “New Nation- alism” and all that that term, in his hands, would imply. On the second of the two great is- sues, on the other hand, it is nut neces- sary to go behind the platform itself. | The Saratoga Convention puts itself | squarely behind the Payne-Aldrich tar-| iff act. It knows nothing of Mr. Roose- | velt's recently discovered mora! issue in | the tariff, or In the recent revision of endorsement by the voters of the State of New York. Truly, the Democrats have a straight and easy path marked ‘out for them. “BACON IS SHAKE-SPEARE.” The Baconian incubus is always with us—ever violent, but at some times more violent than at others. Only last year there was a mighty summoning of strength, with rumors that the author of the tome had submitted his ciphers to the department of mathematics in a large Eastern university and had been assured that the laws of chance could never explain them. The public breath- ed more freely when it learned that the
Page 5
' : ' ' a TR REE me» Oct. 6, 1910] The Nation. department was in reality that of educa- tion, and when ingenious jokers began to discover Bacon’s bona-fide signature in “The Light of Asia,” Gray's “Elegy,” a Tibetan grammar, and even on the cover of a bill of fare in a German res- taurant. Indeed, Bacon was everywhere, and there was an uncomfortable feeling that he might be found writ plainly even in one’s most private documents. Such anachronisms, it is true, could scarcely be offset by the fact that Bacon, accori- ing to his own statement, took all know- ledge for his province. It seemed then as though the death-blow to this fallacy had been administered—but only for a moment. Lovers of the under dog—and it is surprising how cheaply one can be- come the under dog—received romantic hurt from such trifling refutation as that just cited, and waited resolutely for another prophet. He has now ar- rived in the person of Sir Edwin Durn- ing-Lawrence, Bart, B.A., LL.B., etc., and from the title of his book, “Bacon is Shake-speare,” to the end the reader is left in doubt concerning neither his message nor his truculence. The old ground is covered, to the ef- fect that contemporary evidence exists of Bacon’s powers, both as poet and drama- tist, and of Shakespeare’s total ignor- ance of such matters. Like the rest of his cult, the author attempts the two- fold task of writing Bacon up and Shakespeare down. As the spokesman of his country, he proclaims: England is now declining any longer to dishonor and defame the greatest genius of all time by continuing to identify him with the mean, drunken, ignorant, and absolute- ly unlettered rustic of Stratford, who never in his life wrote so much as his own name, and in all probability was totally unable to read one single line of print. It would be unnecessary to reckon with such extravagance if it were not certain that this book will be read wide- ly. For the author professes to hobnob with leading Shakespearean scholars and shows what might be taken for im- pressive learning; it is clear, too, that he has a large Baconian library. We may glance at his crucial test. The well-known tribute to Shakespeare in the first folio, assigned to Ben Jonson, ccntains, if rightly manipulated, 287 let- ters. This is a magic number; be pa- tient yet a little. In “Love's Labour's Lost” the clown, we had supposed, was merely talking big when he said “honori- ficabilitudinitatibus,” especially as the word had been used a century or so be- fore. Not so; Bacon is breathing his heart-secret, for the letters may be ar- ranged into the bad Latin and bad hexa- meter Hi luldi F \Bacojnis na/ti tui/ti orbi, These plays F. Bacon's offspring are pre- served for the world More is coming. The initial letters of the words and the terminals, if put into numerals corresponding to their posi- tions in the alphabet, foot up to 136, which is the number of the page in the first folio upon which the whole word occurs! The similar numerical equiva- lent of all the letters in the word amounts to 287! Of course, the rea] test of this evidence is the still more star- tling thought that such a discovery should have been made exactly 287 years after the first folio appeared. The growth of Baconian literature will, we fear, never cease until legiti- mate scholars are willing to take the matter seriously. It does little good to show up the true meaning of any cipher, because any one who is committed to the cipher habit can easily find new com- binations when old ones are refuted. What is needed is a careful comparison of Bacon’s ideas and even of his style with Shakespeare’s, for Elizabethan! prose was in large measure poetic. For one thing, is it quite possible that one whose conception of friendship was strictly utilitarian and who insisted that the greatest men in the world never feil in love could have treated those quali- ties even in a fiction with what surely looks like instinctive idealism? Or the question might be fought out on the is- sve of humor alone. If there could be found in Bacon’s known works even one really good joke, not quoted—for he at- tempts to be funny at times, and surely has quite as much occasion for humor as Montaigne—his claim to the plays would be greatly helped. But, after all, to meet the Baconian problem seriously, Shakespearean crit- icism itself must assume a different form. Despite all that has been written on Shakespeare, ideas concerning him are still hit or miss, and largely be- cause scholarly attention has been fo- cussed on the formal, mechanical side. When one may read the statement in| authoritative books that Marlowe, for instance, might, if he had lived, have been a formidable rival of Shakespeare, it is clear that criticism has not pro- 307 gressed very far. Even at the outset, there was in Shakespeare’s poems and plays alike, a quality which Marlowe never possessed—an imagination whicna insinuates itself into the manifold bear- ings of individual moments. The richly varied Richard II placed beside Mar- lowe's monotonous Edward II furnishes a point of departure for Shakespearean criticism which might well be used. Such a study, if sanely pursued, would serve to identify Shakespeare to such a de- gree, we believe, that even a Baconian here and there might give heed. THE REIGN OF THE ELEMENTAL. When Mr. Bryce, in his revision of the “American Commonwealth,” comes to the chapter on “The Position of Wo- men,” he will find himself compelled to ponder the change that the years have wrought in the “fondness for sentiment; especially moral and domestic senti- ment, which is often observed as char- acterizing American taste in literature.” These words may have been true once, and may yet be true again, but can any constant reader of our contemporary Ht- erature uphold them as descriptive of its present phase? Is it sentiment that is displayed in the most conspicuous places on the book-stalls? Is it the gen- tle ripple of domestic felicity that is emblazoned in red ink on the covers of our most successful magazines? There may have been a time when we were threatened with the feminization of our culture, but that time, happily for any man who has red blood in his veins, is past. We are done with delicate touching of the outer layers of life. What we are all for now is the vital, the genuine, the wholesome, the un- afraid. We want—and get—stories and articles about big-hearted men, men who have a tang, men who are always stand- ing with one fist in the air in their hatred of sham, their devotion to jus- tice, their scorn of a lie. We have glar- iously emerged from the twilight zone ,of polite phrases and courteous dealing, and stand with a new bravery, trustful of no one, suspicious of everything that isn’t as open as we insist every sewer ought to be, and ready to meet, “man- fashion,” everybody and everything. It was time, indeed, that the change lcame. We were rapidly treading the way of all nations that had lost their | virility. We had lost the splendid dar- ing of our ozone-breathing forefathers.
Page 6
308 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 — We had lost the taste for the pathologi- | graphic. No person has anything to cal, if we had ever advanced far enough | conceal from any other person. Nobody to acquire it. It was the uncrowned |®Dy longer lowers his voice, because tu- poet-laureate of England that first rous-| |mult and shouting are provocative of \larger apparent results, and, besides, edges of a continent. He treated with force and sympathy many aspects of fisher life. The weather-beaten head of a sailor shouting through night and storm, “All’s well!” is representative of ed us to what we were missing in the | real world of masculine men and mas- culine deeds. From him we caught a liking for the untamed, the crude, the savage. He taught us where alone we might find the unspoiled, the undegener- | ate. This prepared us for a clearer call of the wild, a return to the time when | man was only a little lower than the | animals. To-day, it would be a brute indeed that could outdo us in robust- ness of temper, in freedom from squeam- | ishness, in absorption in the elemental. The primary virtues of truth and frank- ness are preached in every advertise- ment. siduously fostered by magazine-editors. The federation of the world for the con- servation of the primitive graces is | near. But while Kipling and Jack London must be credited with a large share in the movement of humanity towards freshness and pungency, could not have brought the revolution full. It required a more direct method, a still less restrained style, a yet fur- | ther remove from the softness and con- vention and hesitation that had follow- ed in the wake of good-breeding, falsely | so-called, to lift us to the plane where our hatreds should outweigh our loves, eur denunciations exceed our approvals, our enthusiasms overpeer our apprecia- tions, and our outspokenness blunt our discrimination. It was Thomas F. Law- son who, in the words of an admirer, was “cheerfully willing to let Jiterature ‘zo hang’ for braver things,” and mark- | ed out the path to the purely elemental. He was the firat of the present genera- tion to do anything “man-fashion.” Be- fore his lurid advent, people in their benightedness did what they had to do gentleman-fashion or woman- in mere fashion or ardly temporizings, all of them. But red-blooded human beings and all anil-| mals conduct their relations “man-fash- | ion,” and we are on the right track at last. We have mastered a new vocabulary, The brotherhood of man is as- | mere letters | child-fashion—absurd cow- | |low voices have “gone out.” We have | this side of his genius. But he is most | lifted the lid and smashed the glass | himself in those pictures which, without |that were keeping us from complete self. | conventional human interest, catch the | revelation to every passer-by. ‘ravening waves gnawing at the rocks, We would not underrate the positive | eommpan the seaweed into the crevices, “good in this stripping off of the clothes lor exploding in clamorous geysers. It of civilization, but we do protest that | was the awful energy of such a scene ‘civilization is more than a glove to be that attracted him. For him the spin- }removed and turned wrong-side out at pang was not merely a filmy and decora- will. There is a time for gloves and a/tive incident, but an acrid volley that time to go without gloves, but with |cut the exposed face. Waves were not for clothes it is vastly different. Outside of |him mere undulating forms, but active ‘the halls of art and the hospitals,|and potentially destructive masses of ‘clothes have too long been considered @| water, with formidable impetus and ‘decent and necessary part, not simply | weight; and although his sense of bulk of the body but of the whole man, to be |and texture was fine and accurate, he left off now. It is a return to the ele- | chose to emphasize in his latest work mental with a vengeance when person- | less the specific forms of rock and wave ality can throw off the delicate draper-|than the shock of their collision. It is jies that its own sensitiveness has woven | this dynamic sense that gives him a pe- ‘for it, and, with a bravery utterly be-|culiar eminence among the artists of his |yond the reach of the physical person, | time, and this demonic quality in the |count it a compliment to have it said of | work must condone some lack of the it that it is naked and that it is not! finest color sense and occasional crudity ‘of execution. His subjects did not com- ‘port with that small preciousness of WINSLOW HOMER. "workmanship which was so highly priz- The late Winslow Homer, one of the} ed by his contemporaries, and he will- | strongest marine painters of all time, | 78ly sacrificed epidermal charm to | ashamed. was already a popular figure fifty years |4¥"amic effect. ‘ago. As an illustrator of the civil war, Yet charm and dexterity he possessed he was counted with the best, and he ina high degree. Only it is little in sight ‘followed up that success with a series|in his later and standard work. For of admirable genre studies of negro life. | many years, he made water-color studies A self-trained man, he was emphatically | of all conceivable subjects. There is an ‘one of ourselves; his pictures needed | extraordinary series of fish leaping un- ‘no recondite eulogy or interpretation.|der the sting of the hook, there are Ste enw American themes with Ameri- | Sketches that contain the cerulean sea can eyes. That he was not contented and sky of Bermuda and Nassau, and en- with this easy and honorable path may (trap the very sunlight of those blessed ‘be judged by the fact that in his forties isles. Here, unlike his oil paintings, he abandoned illustration, settled on a| Which are a bit labored, all is spon- remote crag in Maine,and gave himself |taneity and gusto. These minor sketches to the study of the life of fishermen and | are miracles of execution. In them are the moods of the northern sea. balanced combinations of apparently in- After more than fifteen years of his compatible colors. Work, in the sense of seclusion, men began to suspect that a | repeated effort, is absent; the effect de- pends upon some incredible simplifica- tion, both of the vision and of the crea- tive act. Here such lightning execu- tants as Besnard and Brangwyn are great painter had arisen. The hand of |this veteran constantly gained power, ‘his invention instinctively attained clas- sie form. The last twenty years of his in which plain-epeaking and hard-hit-| life were distinguished by a series of ting, without cant and without adulter- | paintings in which was grasped, as never “strike vibrantly and aggressive- before in the history of art, the sheer jenergy of the ocean, its thunderous un- onslaught against the raw ation, ly the note of the new Americanism,” which is intensely human and intensely | forgetting challenged in their old field. In fact, for real analogues to this joyous side of Winslow Homer's activity one must go to the wonder-working painters of Japan.
Page 7
Oct. 6, 1910] The Nation. 309 It is strange and perhaps regrettable that he never fully established a good understanding between the sketcher and the deliberate picture-maker. His larger paintings had much to gain from the slightest studies. It is possible that he suffered the inevitable penalty of devout nature worship in a certain specializa- tion and narrowing of his gift. His theme was the eternal conflict of sea and land. May he not have feared to depict the tragedy in other than sombre colors? In any case, the suavity that sccompa- nies watercolor sketches is generally lack- ing in his larger marines, and his work presents a dual aspect. In an admir- able simplicity, energy, and fidelity to the apparent brusqueness of his | tient understanding.* Like most works of its kind, it suffers somewhat from uncertainty of aim, being neither quite encyclopedic in completeness of de- tail nor sufficiently arbitrary in selec- tion to deal effectively with ideas. But its arrangement by subjects and its in- clusion of so much that is commonly rejected from literary history offer this great compensation that we are enabled to see the interworking of the various intellectual currents: Darwin and Ten- nyson, Malthus and Matthew Arnold, Spencer and Newman, thus appear as fellow-laborers, moulding and express- ing that subtle, evasive thing we call the spirit of the age. Evasive in a way |that spirit is, as the inner forces of life must always be, yet there is one date and one book so preéminent that no one can go astray in seeking the centre of Victorian thought. At the close of the dynamic truth, we find the unifying | reign—Professor Walker recal's the in- principle of a stalwart and purposeful | cident that every one will remember— manhood and an enduring lifework. |@ London daily paper asked its read- jers to send in lists of the ten books, It was a resolute sense of ends that/ english or foreign, which in their gave Winslow Homer his immense su- | judgment were the greatest and most periority over most of his contempo- | influential of the century past. The |lists varied widely, save in one respect: raries in inting. The hesitant, day- | — ° jin every list stood Darwin’s publica- dreaming, essentially dilettante mood of ‘tion of 1859, “The Origin of Species.” many modern artists was alien to his| Qne is not inclined to take these spirit. Nobody tried harder than he, but | plebiscites very seriously, yet this was nobody would have been more scornful | really an extraordinary event. Prob- of conventionally romantic notions |®>!¥ not half the persons who named \“The Origin of Species” had ever seri- about the unattainable and the tragedy ously read it, yet they all felt in some of the artistic temperament. To the end, vague way that this book had struck which came in his retreat by his dearly | the keynote of the century. In Darwin's loved ocean, he was progressing. One | hypothesis, though they may not have life was too short for the complete un- ‘comprehended its full bearing, they {thought the mind of man had found at folding of so great a gift. |last that for which it had long been For twenty years past, honors have seeking—the perfect scientific formula: been showered upon Winslow Homer. it looked to them as if a new and ever- The other day a sympathetic British od — | Descartes had reduced the physical critic, estimating the American exhibi- | world to a mechanical system, and New- tion at Berlin, rightly found in Winslow |ton had formulated its mathematical Homer’s paintings the authentic and|laws. But Descartes had, theoretically valuable American note. Yet we doubt if |@t least, separated the sphere of the ‘human spirit from his system, and to ne ie eatecmed according to his merits, | ie living world, exclusive of and when his portfolios are searched| 25 within its control he had denied there may be surprises analogous to the |to animals all reason and emotion and sensation created by Ruskin when he treated them as mere machines; while explored the waste papers of the recluse Newton in his laws merely ignored the whole organic creation. This extra- scientific field Darwin finally reclaim- ed, and, by the elimination of teleolog- ical and other foreign elements and by Turner. VICTORIAN LITERATURE. |lasting basis for truth had been laid. | (The Philosophy of Change.) I. To write a history of English litera- ture from 1837 to 1901, in all its man- ifold ramifications from __ political economy to fiction, is a task to make any but the stoutest heart quail, and, whatever else may be said of Pro- fessor Walker’s volume, it bears evi- dence of industrious reading and pa- ithe authority of his vast patience, rais- jed evolution to the side of gravitation. of science. The new law left no place for a power existing outside of nature jand controlling the world as a lower order of existence, nor did it recognize a higher and a lower principle working within nature itself, but in the mere blind force of variation, in the very unruliness to design or government, found the source of order and develop- ment. Chance itself was thus rendered |ealculable, and science reigned supreme through “all this changing world of 'changeless law.” No wonder that men were a little dazed by the marvellous simplicity and finality of this formula, and were ready to exclaim, with a new meaning to the words: Let the great world spin for ever down the ringing grooves of change. II. All this may seem rather remote from Victorian literature, but in fact it is, as the anecdote related by Profes- sor Walker indicates, the very heart of the matter. Science has been, admit- tedly, the dominating intellectual force of the age, and the point of contact of science with literature is just this law of change. For it must not be forgot- ten that law, as it is understood in science, is a formulation of motion in the organic and of change in the inor- ganic realms as a power sufficient with- out any added principle of control to work out the ends of creation as we see them amplified in orderly recur- rence and progress. Modern science and romanticism sprang up together, and have grown side by side. In one re- spect they have embraced diverse, even hostile, temperaments—on this side the man who deals with facts and tends to a hard materialism or a dry intel- lectualism, on the other the man of sen- timent who dreams and loses himself in futile revery. Yet it is a notorious, if paradoxical, fact that the effect of science on art and literature has been to reinforce a romantic impressionism, and that the man of scientific training when he turns to the humanities is al- most always an impressionist. The ;reason is plain: he simply carries into ‘art the law of change with which he has dealt in his proper sphere, and ac- knowledges no principle of taste su- perior to the shifting pleasure of the individual. In this he is typical of the age, for if the particular causo-mechan- ical theory of evolution promulgated by Darwin has proved untenable, evolution itself has remained as almost the unil- versal creed of those who believe that ;some such hypothesis will ultimately be | As an equivalent of the mechanical law lof motion in the inanimate world he | found adequate to explain all the pro- gave precise expression to the absolute | cesses of life. law of change in the animate, thus unit: | And it is easy to trace the work- ing inorganic and organic (including |, of the same belief in other regions all that is man) in one universal scheme | of contemporary thought, most easy, no ‘doubt, in philosophy, which is nothing BY| more than the effort of the reason to interpret in its own terms the common **"The Literature of the Victorian Era."’ Hugh Walker, Cambridge University Press | York: G. P. Putnam's Sons.
Page 8
310 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362.
impulse and ambition of a period. The metaphysicians of to-day are not in har- mony among themselves, as they never have been. There is a respectable school of idealists who hold toatheory of abso- lute unity and stability in which all the diversity and motion of the world are in some transcendental way absorbed. But are not the regnant and effective teachers; they are, to speak, the beautiful relics of a past creed. Prag- matism is the slogan of the hour, and there is a kind of truth in the remark thrown out recently in an English re- view that William James was the most influential leader in the spiritual life of the present generation. Now Prag- matism is just the culmination of what may be called the central philosophizing of the past century. It has assumed many forms, and is sometimes denied by its votaries; but always it is a phil- osophy of the flux, and its general ten- dency is at once romantic and scien- tific, an adventurous revolt against the dogmatic intellectualism in which science has involved itself, and at the same time thoroughly evolutionary, even Darwinian, in theory. In the words of Professor Dewey*: When he [Darwin] said of species what Galileo had said of the earth, <@ pur se muove, he emancipated, once for all, genetic and experimental ideas as an organon of looking for expla- thes so asking questions and nations As a result we have the metaphysical conception “of a wide open universe, a universe without bounds in time or space, without final limits of origin or destiny”—in short, to use the elegant pragmatic diction borrowed from the police courts, “a universe with the lid off." No, continues our philosophical guide, Nature is not an unchangeable order, unwinding itself majestically from the reel of law under the control of deified forces. congertes of changes. are not governmental regulations which limit change, but are convenient formulations of selected portions of change followed through a longer or shorter period of time, and then registered in statistical to mathematical It ie an indefinite Laws forms that are amenable mantpulation I am not here attempting to contro- vert Pragmatiam, though it may be well to repeat what has been sald elsewhere, that it is just as much a one-sided ra- tlonalization of the data of experience as the contrary theory of idealism which Professor Dewey brushes aside contempt- uously as “intellectual atavism.” To the self-sufficiency of the pragmatist and idealist alike, there is one reply: “There are more things in heaven and earth than are dreamt of in your philosophy.” III. Of the other manifestations of the
*’"The Influence of Darwin on Philosophy, and Other Eesays in Contemporary Thought’’ By John Dewey. New York: Henry Holt & Co. law of change, I may speak even more briefly. In religion, it is exhibited in the extraordinary influence of Cardinal Newman upon Brunetiére and other French modernists who see, or think they see, in his “theory of developme it of doctrine” a means of reconciling Christian dogma with the scientific spir- it of the age. The Catholic theory of de- velopment as expounded by Newman meant the slow grasping by human in- telligence of great ideas which were nev- ertheless “communicated to the world once for all by inspired teachers”; it is a perception of change playing about a fixed basis of unchangeable truth, with a growing tendency to lay weight in this dualism upon the element of change. The so-called “new theology” of Protest- antism is more thoroughgoing, and, vir- | tually dispensing with the relation of) mankind to an immutable deity, discov- ers all of religion that is necessary in the varying sympathy of man with his fellow man unregulated by any divine command or revelation. Economics in its acceptance of the temper of the times has undergone a strange but perfectly logical reversal. Synchronously with the growth of the evolutionary theory arose the economic doctrine of laissez-faire, which held that a world of economic order would develop mechanically from the free play of in- dividuals upon one another without the intervention of any governmental and, so to speak, external regulation of com- petition. It was the acknowledged source of the Darwinian notion of the survival of the fittest amidst the accidental and competitive variation of individuals. Such a theory was pragmatic with a ven- geance, and brought its pragmatic pen- alty of social disease and rebellion. In its place has arisen the socialistic creed, which for the struggle of individuals sets up the warfare of classes. It is withal as convincedly evolutionary as was its predecessor—however much it may threaten revolution in practice— and as impatient of any Iaw of control outside of material forces, only these forces have assumed a social] instead of an individualistic form. Both self-devel- oping individualism and self-deveioping socialism are the children of the law of change, and the admixture of humanl- tarian sympathy in both is really only another aspect of the same principle. And the theory of education has nat- urally gone along with these economic and philosophic innovations. The elec- tive system in its present form is plain- ly a late-born offspring of the individ- ualistic doctrine of laissez-faire. The whole shift of emphasis from the classics and humanities to scientific or quasi- \scientific studies is a revulsion from the jold notion that the experience of life in | its essential phases is permanent and has once for all been expressed, to tho — of man as completely immers- ed in the indefinite congeries of changes which we call nature. We sometimes blame the teachers of Latin and Greek for certain disquieting weaknesses that have shown themselves in the recent re- 'sults of education; as a matter of fact their only fault has been the lack of sufficient insight and strength to stem ‘the tide of custom; by endeavoring to bring classica] instruction into conform- ity with the spirit of the age they have ‘largely forfeited its distinct virtue and have so far rendered it superfluous. If Greek affords no discipline corrective of ‘the influence of science and different from that of the languages in which |modern tendencies are expressed, the study of it is merely an enormous waste of time. IV. And inevitably as science, becoming |aware of the sway of change in nature, |tried to formulate this power in terms of a causo-mechanical law, so poetry at- | tempted to give it expression in human jemotion. If any one thing is learned /from such a survey of the poets of the past age and of to-day as we get in Pro- fessor Walker’s volume, it is the con- stant immanence of this philosophy of change, manifesting itself in both the form and the substance of our verse. Walt Whitman is taken by many to be the most significant poet of America, not on account of his mere democracy, but because his democracy was part and parcel of his proclamation of the philosophy of change and motion. The universe to his eye was a strange mot- ley procession of shifting forms, at which he gazed undismayed, calling upon no passing appearance to stay for jan instant and deliver its meaning. To William Morris also the world was a swift-moving succession of forms, glint- ing now with iridescent colors and »reathing entranced melodies, with al- ways the haunting fear in the observ- er’s mind that if for one moment they should pause in their headlong flight they would vanish irrevocably into the void: life is many-hued, intricate mo- tion; rest is death. And the evocation of Swinburne was essentially the same unintermittent flux of phenomena, though with him it took the special form of dissolving the earth into end- less impressions of blowing wind and | billowing water, with no solid ground | beneath the feet. In Browning the new | philosophy took the disguise of a buoy- lant revelling in the mere conflict and tumult of life without any formal re- straint upon its multiform activity. His joyous acceptance of the world and his exultant optimism that all things will of themse'ves work out right have pass- ed with many for spiritual insight, whereas in reality his appeal to the present is due to his blind courage in waiving the check that comes with in- sight into the spirit of permanence. There is, of course, another aspect of Victorian poetry which must not be ig-
Page 9
Oct. 6, 1910] The Nation. nored. As no age, even the most self- satisfied, is entirely itself, but carries with it the memory of all that has gone before, so these singers of the flux are troubled at times by echoes of a past experience. Now and again a line, a note, will slip in that recalls the old de- sire of changeless rest and of the con- summation of peace. It might even be more exact to say that the poets of the century as a whole do not so much give utterance to the unhesitating acceptance of the official philosophy as they ex- press its ever-growing predominance. And thus the most characteristic voices among the Victorians were just the two, Tennyson and Matthew Arnold, who felt most poignantly and sang most clearly, though in diverse ways, the transition from the old to the new. In Tennyson the two fields lay curiously side by side, and it is the sign of a certain lack of hardness in his mental fibre that he never seemed to perceive their mutual antagonism. At one mo- ment he is the conscious laureate of science and evolution and of a self- evolving change moving to some far- off divine event; at another he is the prophet of insight, singing the mystery of the timeless, changeless spirit. Mat- thew Arnold’s intelligence was too well- knit to suffer any such disruption of its powers. With him the error was deeper, yet more logical. Emotionally he was about equally susceptible to the prevailing currents of his dav and of the past, and their coming together pro-| duced a strange uneasiness of mind and | heart, leaving him at home neither in this world nor the other. He looked abroad and saw nothing but change, and it seemed to him as if the permanent things that his soul craved were them- selves in a state of transition. So it was he made his famous complaint, which is, in a way, the confession of his generation, at the Grande Char- treuse: Wandering between two worlds, one dead, The other powerless to be born, With nowhere yet to rest my head, Like these, on earth I wait forlorn. But if this confusion in Matthew Arnold, or parallelism in Tennyson, of the past and the present is characteris- tic of Victorian poetry, the triumph in the end is coming overwhelmingly to the new philosophy. If any one writer represents the thought of those who are most deeply immersed in the spirit of the passing day, it is George Meredith, and there is no poet or prose-writer in English who more speaks and exalts the belief in humanity as completely involv- ed in the process of natural growth. This, I suspect, rather than any per-| versity of wit, is the true reason that) the few who have not yet bent the knee to the time-spirit, are at once attract- | ed by his subtlety of superficial observa- tion and repelled by the absence of those deep underlying emotions which they have learned to expect in great literature. He has written out his read- ing of life in “The Woods of Wester- main,” and the heart of his reading is at the end of his glorification of Change as the wondrous renovator and _ re- vealer: Change, the strongest son of Life, Has the Spirit here to wife. Perhaps we do not often enough con- sider the profound innovation that such a sentiment indicates, nor look unflinch- ingly into the great gulf that is separ- ating our little space of time from all that has preceded. Innumerable poets of the past have reflected on change and mutability and on its part and meaning in human destiny, and their testimony, until this moment of ours, has been almost universally that which Spenser sang so well in the unfinished book of “The Faerie Queene”: What man that sees the ever-whirling wheela Of Change, the which all mortall things doth sway, But that thereby doth find, and plainly feele, How MUTABILITY in them doth play Her cruell sports, to many mens decay? V. No doubt there is much to admire in our modern poets, with the great name of Tennyson at their head, who have bowed down in the temple of the idol of Mutability. They have many traits lof beauty and strength; they tease us with subtle appeals to the heart and brain; they write from a wide and com- plicated experience, and their concern over “the hopeless tangle of the age” gives them often an air of profundity; yet withal they leave us doubting whe- ther there is in them the solid stuff to endure. Some deeper satisfaction or as- surance is wanting to their work, and they themselves seem in a way transi- tional and transitory, as their themes and their very rhythms spring from the spirit of change. For it is certain that the quintessence of poetical emo- tion, the very kernel of the bitter-sweet passion of life and the world, arises from the simultaneous perception in man’s destiny of the ever-fleeting and of that which is contrary to mutabilitie. The contrast has taken a thousand forms and concealed itself under many obscure disguises, but always, if you search deeply, you will discover its presence in the passages of verse, or even of prose, that stir in the reader’s heart the lasting response of art. If illustrations /are necessary, the most familiar are the best. Thus Andrew Marvell, in the poem inscribed “To His Coy Mistress,” starts suddenly from the contemplation of her several charms to that never-for- gotten outcry: But at my back I always hear Time's wingéd chariot hurrying near, And yonder all before us lie Deserts of vast eternity. 311 In those lines, more perhaps than any- where else in English, the coming to gether of change and changelessness, the conflict between the passionate de- sire of ephemeral beauty and the mo- tionless depths of man’s eternal nature, rises to a sublimity that is closer to fear than to pleasure. Oftener it speaks the language of regret or wistful play- fulness, as in Waller's inimitable descant on the old, old theme: Go, lovely Rose! Tell her that wastes her time and me— where the sting of the pathos is due to a kind of pretty condescension of the spirit to the transitory symbols of time. When I consider all the richness of emo- tional content that must go out of poetry with the loss in our conscious- ness of anything “stayed upon the pil lars of eternity,” I am filled with con- cern for the future of letters. Already the impoverishment of Victorian liter- ature in this respect is notable, and even where the contrast between the two spheres of our nature is implied it comes generally with a significant as- similation of the higher to the iower. The Victorian age, even more than others, was a time of transition. It has passed, and one thing at least is sure: we shall have no great literature again until we have looked once more within our own breasts and learned that there is something in human nature besides an indefinite congeries of changes. As it is now the very mould and genre of the higher emotion have been lost. It is al- most inconceivable, for example, that a true tragedy should be composed to-day; for the tragic character, whether it be Antigone breaking herself magnani- mously in the name of the unwritten eternal laws against the edicts of Creon, or G£dipus bruised and blinded by his ignorance of the divine purpose but caught up after years of submission into mystic fellowship with the gods, or Ham- let musing undecided while he listens to the fateful voices—everywhere the trag- ic mood depends on the unresolved con- flict in human motives between the unl- versal and the particular, the change less law and the temporal passion. It even seems that, with the disappearance of the greater form, there is passing away the ambition to write greatly. And naturally. For if the permanence of a work of art is due to its fit expression of the permanent in human desire and experience, what room is there for the long hope, or what impulse to sacrifice present popularity for enduring fame, when the very notion has become dis- ‘credited of any principle contrary to ceaseless change? VI. I have been concerned here primariiy with literature, but obviously the perils of literature are bound up with those that beset the practical world. There is need of firm hearts and clear brains to
Page 10
te ee Ie BAT ec el —- e & 312 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 bring us out of this slough of indiffer-| one of his last publications, will have, for ence, but unfortunately the strong men all who knew him, a striking solemnity: are too often paralyzed by a curious sU-| Let my last word, then, speaking in the |}mame of intellectual philosophy, be his pesatition of weedh, Tas yaa | word: “There is no conclusion. What has abroad that strength means joy 10 | .onciuded that we might conclude in regard change and that he who would question to it? There are no fortunes to be told change is reactionary and effeminate; and no advice to be given. Farewell! and so in the name of progress and vir-| Those of us who are still leaning on the jlity we drift supinely with the current. | recollection of his generous and gallant life If by reactionary is understood only the | = Ang Magra 0 jag beige | thr : man whe Ghudews at r* mie ps Pe | undiscovered countries, the lure of enchant- who cries out for some impossible restor-| .4 cities, the shout of the mariner, and the ation of the past, the charge is well cry of battle. I think in this message, as made. Such a man in the social realm | jp jj his life, we hear above the battle of corresponds to the metaphysician who the schools that cry of “On! On! On!” would deny the existence of change and| And while we shall remember his great the many for an exclusive and sterile | name and high example in many and af- idealism of the one. But reaction may | fectionate relations, just now, I think, we be, and in the true. sense is, something | shall bear him in our memory as one who : . ream-| ¥#* always pressing on, who never ven- rorsag A ‘= ae prathnnns 4 prose |tured to write conclusions and finalities, ° |who never presumed to lock those open with action, to oppose to the welter of | doors which no man may shut. There is circumstance the force of discrimination | «no conclusion” to such a life, or the nature and selection, to direct the aimless tide of truth. Not unto us—non nobise—shall be of change by reference to the co-existing | given the divine right to say, it is finished. law of the immutable fact, to carry the WARREN 8S. ARCHIBALD. experience of the past into the diverse | Pittsfield, Mass., September 28. impulses of the present and so to move | forward in an orderly progression. If) LE. any young man, feeling now within him- | THE MEANING OF STY self the power of accomplishment, hesi-| To THe Eprror oF THE NATION: tates to be called a reactionary, in this| Sim: In tracing the sources of my dis- better use of the term, because of the | content with usages and discussions of the charge of effeminacy, let him take cour- | ¥°T4 cs an long powory te yon e. The world i r w recent in your columns, > poses ny he ee een ae fronted, finally, not by a theory, but by a condition, namely, the condition of the word against the world’s belief will have need | “style” as actually meaning more than one of all a man’s endurance and all a man’s strength. The adventurous soul who to- day against the reigning scientific and pragmatic dogma would maintain no thing. If it might be said that the “style” of Ruskin or Tolstoy or Arnold is good and his “manner” bad; that both the “style” vague and equally one-sided idealism, | 404 the “manner” of Newman are almost be- but the true duality of the one and the yond criticism, and that the ee tae many, the absolute and the relative, the | S#imte-Beuve is perhaps even better than permanent and the mutable, will find|‘!* “style”; and if T might say is tiuaire- i that while in the tendencies of my own SES Ceres see eee See | thiskiog ond beliefs, there is perhaps more tion and contempt as effective as the | , sreement with Count Tolstoy than with inquisition in producing a silent con-! carainal Newman, yet Newman’s “manner’ formity. Submission to the philosophy | is so good that I sympathize while I dis- of change is the real effeminacy; it is | agree; whereas, if I disagree with Tolstoy, the virile part to react. P.E.M. /|1 am generally in a temper with him on /account of his “manner” toward any one who feels competent to disagree—all this would very well define the word “manner.” And this definition of “manner” would point lalso to the different definition of “man- | ners” under which one may accurately say that the controversial “manners” of Mil- To Tue Eprror or Tue NATION: ton and his contemporaries were bad— Sin: All the students of Prof. William | since brutal personalities are, of course, James, whether they knew him in the lec-| bad manners—whereas one would not go so ture-rooms at Harvard or in his books,| far in expressing regret for the patronage ond especially those to whom his gracious|@nd pedagogy of Ruskin and the super- personality was the Nght of all his teach- | ciliousness of Arnold as to say that it ing. will be grateful, I think, to have called| amounted to bad “manners.” to thelr attention an article in the July But a definition of “style,” as well as of number of the Hibbert Journal entitled “A| “manner,” is made by these illustrative Pluralistic Mystic.” This essay is charac- | contrasts, and this definition is open to the teristic of Professor James, for, as his cus-| objection that it chooses questionably be- tom was, he speaks of the concrete, the | tween the two meanings that especially human reality, the mysterious and unfinish-| aMfict us with confusion in the usage of ed world. And with habitual courtesy and| that word “style.” “Style” in this choice generous eloquence, he writes not for him-| meaning is that “rare gift of words, that self, but for another. But I wish to call; union of simplicity and freshness, which attention in particular to the Closing sen- | tends a charm to writing quite independent tences of this essay, which, as they are in’ of the ideas or images conveyed—there must Correspondence. WILLIAM JAMES. be no false emphasis, no straining for ef- fect beyond the needs of the time and place, no appearance of uneasiness, but quiet assurance and self-subordination. The law of style may be defined as the rule of Apol- lo: nothing too much; it is the art, first of all, of dealing frankly with the common- place and the trivial without being common or mean.” But it is easily recognized that the sense of the word “style” so analyzed is not the sense in which it is said that “the style is the man”—that is to say, a per- sonality passed through the channel of writ- ten language, which is to the reader in some degree what the physical presence of the writer may be to those who know him. These two definitions are so far apart that, under the first, writers like Dickens or Carlyle would be said to have little or no style, and under the second, to have so much that hardly a sentence can be read without recognition; under the one defini- tion it would be said that the great French writers have, on the whole, more style than the English, under the other, that the great English writers have, on the whole, more style than the French, a difference between French and English writers pointed out with some pains by Ferdinand Brunetiére. These two definitions, indeed, look back to, and are, perhaps, even founded upon, two literary ideals now rather vaguely de- fined as the classic ideal of self-control and the romantic ideal of self-expression, or the social desire for deference and re- straint, and the personal desire for assertion and expansion. And this distinction in the usage of “style” is closely paralleled by the twofold use of the word “distinc- tion” itself. For, to say that a man has “distinction” of style, or of personal bear- ing, would mean, in deference to etymology, that his personal bearing or literary style is marked, separate, and unmistakable; but in usage it means, also, if not rather, that his bearing or style has dignity and grace. It is evident that to have two ideas to one word is poverty and misfortune, not so much because it renders the discussion of style difficult as that—words being the means as well as the conveyers of thought—it rer- ders the antecedent thinking confused. Traces of this confusion are even in that fine analysis of the style of dignity and grace, which I have quoted. The “law” of even that sense of the word cannot be de- fined as the rule of Apollo: Nothing too much. The law must somewhere say, “There must be enough” with surely as much em- phasis, and Apollo himself must hate pov- erty as much as he does suverfluity and must love the noble generosities of lan- guage as well as its fine refusals. At any rate, there can hardly be question that the poverty of a critical vocabulary is a darkening of counsel. No language is too rich in synonyms, in different words for as- sociated things; and therefore another word is needed for one of the two meanings of style, and we do not know what the word should be. If we assign the word “style” exclusively to that rightness of form and freshness of phrase. and set apart by itself the meaning in which we say that anything characteristic is an element in style, and if we then assign to this latter meaning the word “character,” we fall into a new fam- ily of confusions; for the word “eharacter” is already burdened with more miscellaneous meanings than even the word “style.” Using the word “style,” however, from this
Page 11
Oct. 6, 1910] The Nation. 313
point on, in the sense of character in let- ters, it is evident then, that nvt all style is beautiful or interesting any more than all human character is beautiful or ‘nteresting. But whatever the man behind it may be, if it expresses him, it expresses him as nothing eise does. In all good writing that has style, that is, character, this style has been formed of constant, however unconscious, choices, innumerable sensitive gropings, instincts, suspicions, welcomes, hopes, and avoidances. It is something “closer than breathing, near- er than hands and feet.” It is the color and shape things take !n the crucible and mould ot the self. If we iry to restate some great man’s message whose works have been active | for generations, to lay bare the core of his wisdom and sift out “what it was he really had to say, stripped of the glamour of his | style,” we shall be apt to find it eitherfalse | or commonplace, or both. Whatever was) Is not this statement, so far as it applies to Cleveland, too sweeping? I am personal- ly cognizant of a case in which his prac- tice was the reverse of that ascribed to him. In this instance the candidate ear- nestly recommended by the local Congress-
|man (the latter, by the way, was an able. and influential man) was set aside be- cause of a protest made on moral grounds | by a fellow townsman, with whom Mr. Cleve- | |land had no personal acquaintance, and | | who had no other means of influencing him |than testimony deemed by him credible. | | Is it not probable that in other cases Mr. | | Cleveland spurned the evil unwritten law |of Congressional patronage? | The question may be added: What action in a case like the above would Mr. Taft's | letter lead one to expect from him? EDWARD Y. HINCKs. Andover, Mass., September 23.
impersonally true in his message has long | been impersonally absorbed in the common inheritance, and whatever was impersonally false is dead. But if we turn to his writ- ten words, we shall find his message neither false nor commonplace, but still fresh and true, for he himself was that message and we had left him cut. “Stripping off the glamour of his style” was taking away most | of his characteristics. The question, “What | in point of fact, did the man mean by it | all?” is answered. ‘“‘Whatever he may have thought he meant, in point of fact he meant | himself, and so far as he truly expressed | himself his message was true.” The world | does not alter so much from age to age its | large features of “hunger and labor, seed- time and harvest, love and death.” The va- riation, which saves from repetitious mo- notony the succeeding reports upon it, is the variation in the witnesses. It is true that written books live on for various reasons, and the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, which is by nature one of the cullest and most impersonal things existing, will outlive many glittering competitors for the History of England; but the common antiseptic to the disease of time is style, be- cause it is that which most directly conveys “GOOD AND READY.” | To THE EDITOR or THE NATION: Srr: In his letter regarding “good and” jand “make good” (Nation, September 8), |which has just come to my notice, Prof. | |J. M. Hart asks whether “any one has dis- |cussed the phrase “good and ready” as a mere intensive=‘“‘very, thoroughly.” mention only one or two works familiar to the student of English, this and allied forms of expression are adequately treated in Storm’s “Englische Philologie” I (Leip- zig, 1896), pp. 690-692, and and Kittredge’s “Words and Their Ways in } | | tionary, |structure, such as “fine and strong,” “nice lana cool,” which we are wont to use in this | country, are not infrequently met with in | England. Some of these are quoted from | English novelists by Storm, who very | properly classes them as instances of the | substitution of parataxis for hypotaxis, far as one may judge from the Oxford Dic- other expressions of identical ‘ameg as we also have in phrases like “try | In registering this construc- | and do,” etc. a person. Because it is through persons, | sion s. v. end B, I, 4, (p. 316 €), the Ox- through the separate man, rather than) : through organised systems or series ot | £0rd Dictionary cites a passage from | Shakespeare, “Romeo and Juliet,” ii, 2, 8: events, that divinity is manifested, if at all, in human affairs. The separate man is its channel of communication, its elec-| a |green”). For evidence of the usage under tric connection. Through him it ash eth ‘ani easnge <ed ge Oyeened ways comes, the unstaled wonder, the im- | ¢ euages y mortal novelty. Not in the thunder or the stars, or in the long fugue of history, but in the lonely soul that reaches upward in the dark is divinity most here and now, or whatsoever it is named which is always a problem and never an answer, and which is | fcrever so mercifully wiser than those who seek it that it will not let ‘hem find it. ARTHUR COLTON. New York, September 26.
CLEVELAND'S APPOINTMENTS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In your issue of September 22 you say, in discussing President Taft's promise to give patronage to insurgent Congress- men: The offices in question are those not cov- ered by the rules, not in the classified ser- vice. These have been filled by all recent Presidents—by Cleveland as by Roosevelt— on the recommendation of Congressmen. |““Her vestal livery is but sicke and green,” | | interpreting it as a case in point (—“pale | necessary to cite such an expression as the | Italian bell’ e detto, or the Anglo-Saxon | come and geseoh (St. John, I, 46), translat- jing the veni et vide, errou kai ide of the | Latin and Greek. H. R. LANG. Boston, September 20.
NIETZSCHE'S MADNESS. THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Is there enough critical interest in ir | Nietzsche in this country to warrant a cor- | rection of a misstatement in regard to him by that undeniably clever writer, Ver- non Lee? In her “Gospels of Anarchy,” she has a chapter on Nietzsche, and toward the close of it she says: Haunted, hag ridden, by the sense of his own sore and struggling ego, Nietzsehe, true to the autobiographical instincts which he discovered in all philosophic systematiz- ing, made life synonymous with that ego’s realization and assertion. “Give,” he wrote To) in Greenough | English Speech” (New York, 1901, p. 315). | | While it is true that “good and” does not | j}occur in the works of English authors, as | in one of his latest and finest works, ‘Give me, ye gods, give me madness! madners ;}to make me believe at last in myself." | Now these words occur in what might |be called an historical or psychological | paragraph on “the meaning of madness itn the history of morality.” In it Nietzsche |eites Plato end his high estimate of mad- ness (see the “Phadrus,” 244), one species of it, the prophetic, being called the special gift of heaven, and the source of ‘the chiefest blessings among men. The general problem with which Nietzsche was concerned was how, under primitive con- ditions of thought, one with ideas at vari- ance with the mores of his community was to be assured that he was right, though all that passed as morality (i. «¢., conformity with mores) was against him. | In just such a situation as this the signifi- |cance of madness appears. For this, which consisted in a losing of one’s proper | senses, was, according to early ideas, not |a degrading, but an elevated phenomenon, |a kind‘of sign of divine possession and ap- |proval. Hence it was something that an innovator in lonely, despairing moments might covet. And Nietasche, with that wonderful power of sympathetic portrayal of the past which he possessed, pictures isuch an one putting forth the ejaculation or prayer which Vernon Lee quotes. But she, apparently hitting simply on the words, and disregarding their connection, makes the ejaculation Nietzsche’s own! A | lesser inaccuracy is in attributing the pas- |}sage to Nietzsche’s “latest” works, when it actually belongs to his middle period— the period in which he was skeptical, posi- tivistic, and, according to ordinary ways of speaking, coolest. It occurs in “Morgen- | réthe” (“The Dawn of Day’), section four- jewes Mr. James Huneker, in quoting the passage in his “Egoists’” (p. 268), is less |confused as to its date, but still speaks jof it as “hig [4 ¢., Nietzsche’s) prayer.” | The serious study of Nietzsche is appar- ‘ently yet to begin in England and this |ecountry. Impressionist writers like Vernon Lee and Mr. Huneker one had better be- ware of. WILLIAM M. SALTER. Silver Lake, N. H., September 5. Literature. —_——_ NEW YORK LOYALISTS. |Minutes of the Commissioners for De- tecting and Defeating Conspiracies in the State of New York. Albany Oown- ty Sessions, 1778-1781. Edited by Vic- tor Hugo Paltsits, State Historian. Vol. I: 1778-1779, Vol. II: 1780-1781. Vol. I1I: Analytical Index. Published by the State of New York, Albany. An adequate history of the Loyalists during the American Revolution has yet to be written. The studies of Messrs. Flick, Fisher, and Gilbert have advanc- ed the subject in certain directions, and Mr. Van Tyne has pointed out in his ex- cellent work the direction that further investigation should take. But for an account of the Loyalist movement in de- tail, we have not progressed much be- yond Dr. Ellis’s essay in the “Narra- tive and Critical History,” published
Page 12
314 twenty years ago. Yet even that schol- arly paper says very little of the south- on an in- The based material papers and is survey of the of Loyalist in the Public Library valuable and forming in a way a first fighting line of evidence, are but of the available material; and other records, once extant, but that continued search will probably bring to light. To handle all the sources and to cover every part of the field will be a hard and prolonged but a worthy one, for it will de- peculiar qualities of mind and body: the spirit of mental detachment, coupled with hard physical labor. Gen- eralizations as to the social status of the Loyalists not be safe until hun- dreds of personal careers are examined much genealogical work done, af- ter the fashion of Sabine’s well known col'ection of Loyalist biographies. Ques- of culpability, injustice, and ill- treatment can be answered only when the in all the states relating to Loyalists and their property are analyz- ed and their operation noted; when the activities of State and county torial boards, of whatever’ kind wherever found, existing for the pur- pose of detecting and punishing disaf- fection, are critically studied, and an estimate formed of their character and efficiency; when the later careers of refugee Loyalists in England, Canada, and the West Indies are to a certain ex- tent followed up; and when the work of the Claims Committee in London has been more thoroughly investigated. Even then there will be left the dif- ficult ethical, psychological, and econom- ic aspects of the case, all of which must remain more or less speculative even among the most impartial observ- The is far from simple, it been shamefully neglected nearly all our students of Revolu- history Except for Ellis, is the only one who has ern Loyalists complete transcripts New York though they are a part there are now iost task mand will and tions laws ers subject and has by tionary Dr. Mr. Van honestly grappled with it Tyne The two volumes which Mr. Paltsits, the new State historian of New York, has edited as the first fruits of his of- fice, are a valuable contribution to the Loyalist question. They contain the journal of the Albany County commis- sioners, 1778-1781, appointed for detect- ing and defeating conspiracies in the State of New York, one of the few re- maining records of its kind, since none of the other minutes of the seven New York county boards are known to exist, and even these minutes are incomplete, covering only about three-fifths of the five years of the board's life. The val- uable collateral papers, frequently re- ferred to in these minutes and consist- ing of the accumulated files of corre- inquisi- | and | [Vol. 91, No. 2362 The Nation. tions and designs of the foreign and do-| mestic foes,’ and under its instructions, it concerned itself with a wide range of activities—counterfeiting, murders, rob- bery and plunder, passes, prisoners, de- serters, etc., but its main business was watching Loyalists. In the widest sense the term “Loyalist” included not only those who had property claims to pre- sent to the Claims Committee after 1783, but also those who suffered no loss, ex- cept, perhaps, of liberty and bodily com- fort. The board looked after every dis- affected person—those who drank the King’s health and “damned every one who opposed the King’s laws,” harbored or concealed emissaries from the enemy, furnished the enemy with provisions, sought to enlist men in the enemy’s ser- vice, met in suspicious gatherings, as at Livingston’s Manor or “back of Cook- sakie, under a pretence of religious wor- ship,” or in general did anything that placed them in the class of suspects. Even the “Shaking Quakers” came un- der suspicion, “as having a tendency to alienate the minds of the people from | itheir allegiance to the State by incul- cating an opinion of the unlawfulness of taking up arms in defence of the American cause.” The duties of the board were very undesirable, and when, in 1782, it was proposed to abolisn it, those who were members at that time declared that they did not “wish to in- sinuate a desire of continuing in the ‘exercise of the office, it being a very dis- jagreeable task and subject to asper- jsions.” Yet the record of their attend- jance shows that in forty months, they |}met above 650 times. | From the rather meagre entries of the | journal it is difficult to torm a satis- uous member of this group, bears wit- ness to the sufferings endured. Whether or not the law was necessary, we may not decide; the board certainly deemed it so and interpreted it with the utmost strictness, holding many of these Loyal- ists as prisoners of war subject to ex- change. But the number of “banished” Loyalists was comparatively small, and we hear little of the law after 1778. The main business of the board was not with these “neutral and equivocal 'characters,” but with persons actively disaffected and consequently dangerous to the State and to the American cause. Hundreds of such persons are mention- ed by name and occupation in these rec- ords. The most incorrigible of them the board confined in jail, where they were kept at the expense of the State for varying terms; but many more were simply placed under bond, either fur- nished by themselves or by some good surety, preferably a freeholder. Such persons pledged themselves to be on their good behavior, to remain within certain defined limits, sometimes on a farm, sometimes in a town, or some- ‘times within a larger area, to serve if called upon in the militia, and to ap- /pear before the board once a month or whenever required. The amount of bail ranged from £100 to £5,000, the sum de- /pending, not on social rank, as a “gen- tleman” is bailed for £100 and a “tay- lor” for £2,000, but on the nature of the charge. During 1780 and 1781, nearly all who came before the board were al- lowed to go on recognizance or on bail. There is ample evidence to show that the board could temper justice with le- niency. It inquired carefully into the /merits of every case and dismissed, with | factory estimate of the attitude and ef-|@ reprimand to the accuser, many a per- ‘ficiency of the board. Everything goes |80n unjustly charged. In some cases to show, however, that the commission-| Where the evidence seemed doubtful, it ‘ers sought to act honorably both in law |called for additional witnesses, giving and equity. They were governed chief- | the suspect a full opportunity of clear- ly by two laws, that of February 5, 1778, |!ng himself if he could. When request- which contained the instructions, and |¢4, it took measures to protect individ- that of June 30, 1778, which concerned | ¥@ls and families in danger of maltreat- “neutral and equivocal characters.” A | ment from their neighbors, and allowed later law of July 1, 1780, required them |™any wives of husbands gone off to the to provide for the removal of the fam-/|®nemy to remain in their habitations un- ‘ilies of persons who had joined the en-| ™o0lested, on assurance from well-affect- lemy. Under the second law, the jus- 'ed persons that to do so would not prove tice of which has frequently been called dangerous or detrimental to the Ameri- in question, they “banished,” that .s,/©@% cause. During the years 1780 and sent within the enemy’s lines, certain) 1781, many in jail were released on ‘persons of prominence in the State, | petitions, for one reason or another, and who, though willing to take oath not to | #!lowed to go at large under bond, and aid the enemy in any way, would not |im cases of sickness or of family need ‘take the oath of allegiance required, and temporary release was frequently grant- ‘were compelled to leave at shortest no-|@¢- The impression gained from read- \tice, with those of their families inca- ing these minutes is that the board en- |pable of bearing arms and, if they forced the law as the times demanded, wished themselves to bear the cost of Dut mitigated its penalties whenever transportation, with all their clothing Justice or humanity required. and household furniture. No one will! Mr. Paltsits, as editor, has done his deny that this law imposed excessive| work in a manner that is almost fault- less: the text is reproduced with great spondence and the like, are unhappily |hardships upon those against whom it missing also. The board was gppdinted | was directed, and the well-known “Life” to guard “against the wicked machina-|of Peter Van Schaack, the most conspic- care and accuracy, as is evident from the very short list of errata given in
Page 13
Oct 6, 1910] The Nation. the third volume, the introduction and accessory matter are all of value to the student, and the third volume contains an admirably constructed analytical in- dex. The only addition of importance that might be suggested is a series of tabulations furnishing statistical data regarding the persons brought before the board—their names, residences, vo- cation, ground for suspicion, penalties, amount of bail, and the like. Such in- formation,conveniently arranged, would save the investigator much time and labor. CURRENT FICTION. The Glory and the Abyss. By Vincent Brown. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. In “The Screen” this writer gave us not long ago a study of churchliness versus simple humanity which differed from current studies of the sort in be- ing written from within the ecclesiasti- cal enclosures. It was impossible to doubt that the deponent had intimate knowledge of the habit of life and thought prevalent within the Church of England fold. In “The Glory and the Abyss,” also, the ecclesiastical, or at least parochial, atmosphere is felt. A rural vicar, his daughter, and his cur- ate son-in-law, form a species of un- sympathetic chorus to the tragic action. The daughter is really mistress of the parish, a sort of Mrs. Proudie in a nut- shell—on the whole an oppressively in- human figure. Set off against her and her interpretation of life is the vicar’s brother, a writer whose theoretical pes- simism and even cynicism merely masks the nature of an idealist. He only of the socially superior group discerns the marvel of Peter Bonoor’s nature. “The Soul of Peter Bonoor” might have been a fitter title for the story. He is the slow-moving, slow-thinking, illit- erate son of a degenerating peasant stock. The father is a good-for-nothing drunkard. The mother has given birth to fourteen children, buried eight of them, and lives in a condition of feeble sentimentalism which is almost apathy; has her flabby being, as it were, on the border of two worlds. Four of the sur- viving children have gone to the bad or are on their way to it, when the story opens. Peter is the strong rock upon whom, as if in spite of itself, some sort of family life continues to be founded. One of the brothers is hopelessly de- praved, but Peter saves the other for a decent manhood. A _ neighboring squire seduces the two pretty sisters in turn. Peter has nothing but love and pity for them, and by his influence they are saved from utter wreck. The event for Peter himself is prophesied by the literary ironist, Gilbert Biddulph, to the utter incomprehension of his churchly auditors: “He is not a great man; great soul.” but he is a “What is the difference?” Haviland asked. “I'll give you the world’s answer. It has always martyred its great souls; and it has always grovelled at the feet of its great Mr. men. By all the spiritual laws known to me, Peter Bonoor ought to be sacrificed for his people. He is offering himself for them, and the great, still eyes of the gods are watching for the moment.” The total effect of the story is not mor- bid, or even sombre: Peter's soul is too great for that. The Scales of Justice. By George L. Knapp. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippin- cott Co. The usual conflict between the ama- teur detective and the professional takes the form in this case of a tirade against the use of the “third degree” in extort- ing confessions of guilt from innocent victims. The amateur is a supernatur- ally wise and strong young reporter— star reporter of a yellow newspaper; the professionals are the chief of police and the head of the detective depart- ment in New York. A great and merci- less financier is murdered, and the pro- fessionals, forced to find some one guil- ty, batter a poor wretch of the streets into signing a confession. It is a lurid and monstrous presentation of a meth- od of detective work bad enough in it- self. The interest of the book is sus- tained by a rather amusing company of inquisitive boarders at the house where the reporter lives. The end is a well- managed surprise. As for the style, at least it moves. The Peacock of Jewels. By Fergus Hume. New York: G. W. Dilling- ham Co. A mysterious treasure whose secret is to be revealed by reading the hiero- glyphs of a jewelled peacock, a Hindu prince in search of the secret, an old English abbey inhabited by a miser and his ward, a young London lawyer who is in love with the ward, and incidental ly has some of the traits of Sherlock Holmes (as all lawyers and reporters have, in these days), and a lonely man living in the London slums—the ingred- ients are obviously orthodox, but Mr. Hume has made of them a detective story decidedly better than the average, and quite as original. The wicked wo- man of the story is a character well and effectively drawn. Kane. By Anne New York: The Franklin Winslow Douglas Sedgwick. Century Co. This book might be called the ro- mance of a masculine Maggie Wylie—a man who has “nae charrm.” It is can- didly and simply a study of sentiment and exhibits a trio of complex, ultra- modern, and more or less morbid tem- peraments in their relations with a na- ture of transparent honesty and good-' 315 ness. Althea Jakes, a young American of moderate wealth and spineless emo- tions, settles in an English country- house for the summer, and gathers to her there Gerald Digby, a fascinating but superficial young detrimental, and Helen Buchanan, a girl who, despite her singular charm, has loved Gerald hope- lessly since their childhood, Gerald, blind to this attachment, proposes mar riage to Althea on a basis of sound esteem and mutual helpfulness, which she accepts, only to find herself a prey to an exacting love which beats in vain at the indifference of her betrothed, while the helpfulness proves to be ex- tended mainly by her to him. In the meantime, Franklin Kane, an Ameri- ean of scientific tastes, who has adored Althea as long and as vainly as Helen has Gerald, discovers unexpected balm in Gilead, namely, Helen. His friendship for her ripens to a love deeper than his long constancy to Althea, and although her affection for him is more theoretical than actual, she consents to marry him. Thereafter the three hungerers for im- possibilities rend his poor soul among them, and though he is left at the end victor over himself and over circum- stance, it is with a mortal hurt upon him, Although such stress is laid upon Franklin's unattractive appearance, it is difficult to visualize his insignifi- cance, and consequently to understand why he should seem so undesirable even to those who most clearly recognize his worth. The four are an exasperating collection, for even Franklin's nobility borders enough on that of Don Quixote to be trying at times, and the only per- sonage of the story who does not irri- tate the reader is the excellent Aunt Grizel, who towers nobly above the nerve-storms that rage about her, stout- ly panoplied in the saving common- sense, which seems, alas! so pathetical- ly uncommon. Royal Lovers: The Adventures of Two Empresses. By Helene Vacaresco. New York: John Lane Co, This book, printed in England, is sure of a considerable market in the land of the free. Nowhere are em- presses more popular than on this side of the water: nowhere is the glamour of royalty more palpitatingly felt. What chiefly impresses us, no doubt, what, however fancifully, we most delight in, is not the white light that beats upon a throne, but the august shadows that surround it. This volume, bound in pur- ple, gives forth the aroma of court life as the romantic reader would have it— as it is recorded in the letters and memoirs which are from time to time brought forth by the literary grubber, not to say the literary scavenger. Granted, the premises that the royal persons here presented are worthy of special attention because of the divinity
Page 14
316 [Vol. 91, No. 2362 The Nation. that hedges them, and all goes swim- mingly. and utterances, as a whole, are of hard- present. They consist of repartees which Otherwise, their experiences | pass in court between opposing barristers | compliance. ‘or rebukes administered by judges to servance of which the Prince promised But, notwithstanding his promise, he proposed the health of the ly more than ordinary interest. But the | offending counsel. To the American mind | Lord Chief Justice. Coleridge, in his re- royalty is thére, and the adventures of |there is in much of this rather more of |ply, referred to the psalmist’s injunc- royalty are safe terms of middleclass life. from reduction to rudeness than of wit. It is seldom that|tion, “Put not your trust in princes.” The rebel- |one encounters anything so good as the 'In the course of his speech he mention- lion of the Empress Georgina against|remark of a judge to a barrister who /|ed the reply of Pope to a certain Prince the laws of her caste exhausts itself in epistolary protest: “I listen without benefit,” she cries, “to the dictates of our rank; I shall never be reasoned out of my contempt. . What are stage tricks to our tricks, s'il vous plait? Sarah Bernhardt and Eleanora Duse assume a part for two or three hours, whereas we have to be unreal and de- ceptive from morning to evening.” Georgina is daughter of a line in which madness has more than once appeared: her cousin, King Frederic, solitary and music-mad, is drawn from an easily recognizable model. Georgina and her royal husband adore each other, yet live together coldly, parted all their lives by a flimsy but insurmountable barrier. The second imperial pair, far more IIl- matched, arrive at a sort of harmony through common suffering. The story takes the form of letters, written by some seventeen persons connected with one or both of the royal groups involved. As dramatic compositions, the letters have a good deal of merit. ANECDOTES OF THE ENGLISH BAR. | Reminiscences of a K. C. By Thomas Edward Crispe of the Middle Temple. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. $3.50 net. W. J. Locke in one of his early novels describes a cockney. He says quite truly that the real cockney never gets London out of him. No matter where he goes, he carries with him the look of the familiar streets: the City, with its narrow, wind- ing lanes, for which, of course, the han- som was invented; the Strand, with its shops and ‘buses; the dip of St. James's | Street and Waterloo Place; the homely gloom of the heavy atmosphere, to him always pleasant. This scene is the only real home he will ever know. The au- thor of these reminiscences is through and through a cockney. He does not tell us that he was born in London, but ac five years old he saw the procession on the Coronation Day of Victoria, and was taken to the fair in Hyde Park, giv- en in honor of that occasion. He saw there the celebrated “Hottentot Venus,” upon whom he had a ride. He tells us: “I plied my toy whip on the flanks of my beautiful jade, who, screaming with laughter, raced me round the circle.” From that day, which was in 1838, to the present, he seems to have been hav- ing experiences as amusing as the above. The anecdotes of the bar he gives us are usually such as a traveller in Eng- land will hear in the parlor of an inn when a few barristers and solicitors are /had said that the advocate on the othor \side was the greatest bore that ever jaddressed an English court: “Mr. S., you forget yourself.” There is, perhaps, rather more of rudeness than of wit in the reply, related by the author, of Sar- gent Parry to an insignificant person who had said in court that Sir George Jessel dropped his h’s: “Sir, I would ‘rather drop my h’s with Jessel in hell |than aspirate with you in heaven.” The writer of this notice, who has often been in Jessel’s company and knew him ‘fairly well, never observed that he had this infirmity. But a defect resulting \from early education is more likely to (appear in the course of a long address {than in ordinary conversation. It would |not be unusual, for instance, in England, |to hear a clergyman, a university man jand a scholar, who had made a slip of | this kind in the course of a sermon, |chaffed afterwards regarding it by some of his parishioners. Mr. Crispe in his comment upon cele- brated English judges and barristers is for the most part kindly, although now and then critical. He admires Lord Russell, but thinks he was not a good criminal lawyer. ward Clarke would have easily secured Mrs. Maybrick’s acquittal. {t should seem that Russell, like many other able men, was not a good diplomatist. Mr. Crispe attended the trial of Col. Valen- tine Baker, and thought that he was not well defended by Sir Henry Hawkins. Of Hawkins, whom he does not admire, he He says that Sir Ed-| of Wales who had said to him, “Mr. Pope, you do not like kings?” “Sir,” said the poet, “I prefer the lion before the claws are grown.” The late King, who was a clever man, no doubt appre- ciated the wit and skill of this pretty flattery. There are stories of the eccentricities and peculiarities of recent English judges. Certain judges did not allow barristers addressing them to appear with watch chains or flowers in the buttonhole. In the sixties and seven- ties these ornaments were much more brilliant than they have been since. Many men wore, not one rose, or a few | violets, but small bouquets. The writ- ‘er remembers that in those days, on the porter’s table at the front doors of the clubs, there were a number of small glasses, containing water, in which men entering the club would leave their “but- tonholes” to be kept fresh. In view of the size of these bouquets, it is not so surprising to read of Mr. Justice Den- man’s remark to a barrister, who was trying to address him: “You compel me to speak, sir; I do not allow buttonholes in my court.” The disinclination of some judges to | listen to a barrister who wears a mous- ‘tache (which, of course, does not look well with a wig) is a little harder for /us to understand in this land of “go as | you please.” Mr. Choate relates that he was once looking out from a For- eign Office window with Lord Salisbury, when Mr. Choate pointed to some men has some new stories to tell, none, how- | lying about on the grass in St. James’s ever, quite so good as one lately report- | Park, and said, “That would not be toler- ed from London. Hawkins (Lord ated in America; we should keep them Brampton), coming out of the Athe-| moving.” “What harm do they do?” neum Club, told the driver of a han-|said Lord Salisbury. “That is what I som to take him to the Courts of Jus-|say about you Americans. You have tice. The cabman, who no doubt knew /no sense of personal liberty.” We fancy Hawkins perfectly well, said: “Courts that these differences are very much of Justice, sir? Don’t know ‘’em.”| matters of habit, of what you are “Don’t know the Law Courts?” said | used to. Hawkins. “Oh! the Law Courts!” said | After the bar, Mr. Crispe has most the cabman. “I know them; but you/to gay about the stage. Between the said Courts of Justice. That's a different members of these two professions there thing haltogether.” |seems to be a sympathy and an affinity. There is much about Lord Justice | The author was in his youth an ama- Coleridge, who was a very brilliant af- teur actor, and has all his life been ter-dinner talker, and had a great fund keenly interested in theatrical matters. of anecdotes. Mr. Crispe, as usual tell-| His pages are full of reminiscences of ing us what he has himself seen and the English actors of our own genera- heard, gives us some examples of Cole- tion and the previous one and of per- ridge’s wit. On one occasion, when the | sons cotnected with the stage. We no- late King, then Prince of Wales, at-/tice an allusion to a little remembered tended a dinner at the Middle Temple, | person, which happens to be of interest Coleridge sat next the Prince. Cole-|to the present writer. The person is ridge reminded the Prince of the rigid Mr. Bellew, the father of Kyrle Bellew, rule that no toasts were allowed ex- whom, however, Mr. Crispe seems only cept the usual royal ones, to the od- | to remember as a clergyman of the
Page 15
The Nation. Oct. 6, 1910] 317 Church of England. He speaks of his |inheritance and the rustic patois, has incomparable reading of the services. long been accepted as the medium of in- The present writer, however, remem-|tercourse in business and society, the bers seeing him in one of the most ex- newspapers and the schools. traordinary theatrical performances it| M. Fougéres is especially effective in was ever his good or ill fortune to wit- the chapter on Picturesque Greece. His ness. The play of “Hamlet” was given thesis of the harmony of land and wa- in dumb-show. Bellew, a remarkably lter reads like a pean. But he is not handsome man, stood at a desk in front merely exclamatory. As in a sparkling of the stage in ordinary evening dress | prism, all the color of the atmosphere is and read the entire play, while the divided and reflected. He gives his rea- actors, male and female, grimaced and |sons for regarding Greek landscape as gesticulated behind him. /unique—even in the Mediterranean. The —————————— | following paragraph may serve as an example: The original feature of these Greek landscapes is a harmonious and firm plas- ticity. Each object is frankly either plain or mountain. The lines are never vague, never lost or hidden. There is noth- ing mediocre, limp, common, ordinary. On the other hand, there is nothing out of pro- portion, nothing exceeding the compass of the eye, nothing but what can be perce!ved clearly and distinctly and compared, to use a technical term, with the human scale. Greece in Evolution: Studies prepared | under the auspices of the French League for the defence of the rights of Hellenism. By Th. Homolle, Henry Houssaye, Th. Reinach, Ed. Théry, G. | Deschamps, Ch. Diehl, G. Fougéres, J. Psichari, A. Berl, M. Paillarés. Edited by G. F. Abbott. Translated from the French. With a preface by Sir Charles | W. Dilke, M.P. New York: Wessels & Bissell. $1.50 net. These ten lectures, as might be expect- ed from the distinguished writers, con- tain mueh that is stimulating and time- ly, in view of the events in Greek lands which have taken place since they were delivered. The (anonymous) transla- andria, Philo, “the Jewish Plato,” who Bentwich. Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society of America. tion is uneven, and, at times, unidiomat- lived in the first century of our era, ic, but it occasionally reflects the charm \stands easily first. But he has been, at of the original which appeared under |any rate until lately, a prophet without the title of “La Gréce.” pervaded by a Gallic enthusiasm, wel- (call him “the Jew,” with implied rejec- come enough to ardent Philhellenes, but ‘tion of his Hellenism, while for the Jews | here and there calculated, especially in he is “the Alexandrian,” a heretic whose this crude translation, to awaken a cer- teachings were alien from the orthodox tain hostility in the minds of the in-| Palestinian tradition. He wrote in Greek, | different or uninitiated. The open-mind- and in the early Christian centuries he | ed reader, however, will find in these was much read by the Christian fathers, lectures a well-developed brief for the | but was not translated into Hebrew. His claims of ancient and modern Greece rejection by contemporary Jews reminds upon the civilized world. These claims, |one of the similar treatment of Spinoza, however old, are renewed with a French |and, furthermore, is typical, since the precision in regard to the literature and | art, the unique charm of the country and | philosophy and must always regard with the people, the services of the Greek 'suspicion any doctrines which might church and its martyrs in the cause of change the character of their religion, Greek independence, tne burning ques- that is to say, the basis of their nation- tion of Hellenism in Turkish Asia and ality. Philo was thoroughly Hebraic in in Macedonia. There are included an in-| soul. He was a missionary philosopher, structive chapter on modern Greek eco- | and, as Bentwich points out, he was far nomics, a sketch of Heroic Greece in the years 1821-1827, a chapter on the seic Law; rather, he desired to convince significance of Modern Greece in Eastern mankind that the Torah contained the Europe, and an approving résumé of |whole of ethics and metaphysics. All the Philo-Judeus of Alezandria. By Norman | The book is|honor among his own people. Gentiles Jews have never welcomed a secular | ‘from wishing to tamper with the Mo-| what the Greeks themselves have done, as excavators and restorers, towards the renascence of ancient Greece. It is to be regretted that M. Psichari in his otherwise admirable chapter on the poet Solomos, the author of the Greek national anthem, should have in- truded one of his polemics on the mod- ern Greek language. Non-resident Hel- lenists might well be silent after the temperate reply of Professor Hatzidakis, of Athens, to Krumbacher, in which he shows tha* this language, although a partial compromise between the literary most characteristic Platonic theories had there been anticipated. It was his aim to expound the allegorics that he found in the Bible, and in so doing te |became the greatest of all the allegor- ists. battle, he came under his spell and henceforth regarded Platonic ethics and /metaphysics as a possession of Judaism | whose beauties he was born to reveal. His failure was pathetic, and the tardy recognition by the Jews of his real great- ness and singleness of aim is actually j|due to what he himself would have de- Although he never fought Plato’s | ‘plored, the slow secularizing of Jewish thought. Philo did not escape the in- fluence, either, of Pythagoras, which made number symbolism a favorite su- perstition with the Greeks, and here again he found a link between the teach- ings of the Bible and Hellenic thought. Needless to say, he found in symbolic numbers, especially seven, .en, and fifty, further evidence of the sanctity of Jew- ish institutions. Too Hebraic for the Hellenists, too Hellenistic for the Jews, Philo would seem to have labored in va:n to convince, on the one hand, the man of secular cul- ture of the truth and beauty of mono- theism, and, on the other, to enlist Hel- lenic philosophy on the side of Judaism. But of late there has been a reaction of interest, if not conviction, in his |favor. The Berlin Academy is preparing a critical edition of his voluminous writ- ings, which will supersede the unreliable Tauchnitz text of eight volumes, and the bibliography. in Mr. Bentwich’s book |shows the increased attention paid, in this century and the last, to the great- |est of all the religious philosophers of the Jews. Among the Hellenized Jews of Alex- | Robert Herrick: A Biographical and Critical Study. By F. W. Moorman. New York: John Lane Co. $5 net. On the score of diligence only praise can be given to Dr. Moorman’s work, and if in his ransacking of documents he has discovered nothing of real im- portance, this is probably due to no fault of his, but to the treacheries of time. Some new light he throws on Herrick’s relation to his uncle and on the career of |the undergraduate at Cambridge, and |does what he can to lend reality to the | poet’s friendships and surroundings, but jthe real puzzles of Herrick’s life are left unsolved—must in all likelihood remain forever unsolved. There is no- thing in a way strange in Herrick’s career as we find him, first an appren- |tice in London, then a student at the university, then studying law at Trin- ity Hall, taking orders, going as chap- lain to the Duke of Buckingham in his | fatal expedition to the Isle of Rhé, ac- cepting the vicarage of Dean Prior in | Devonshire, living in retirement under the Commonwealth, and returning to Dean Prior in 1662. That was by no means for that age a life of surprising | changes, but somehow the man through |it all escapes our definition—his relig- jion and his license, his paganism and his Christianity, his passion and his playfulness, somehow baffle us in their contrasts. Much the best chapter in Dr. Moor- man’s book, in our thinking, is that in which he gives an historical study of Elizabethan and Caroline lyric poetry. His distinction between the school of Donne and the tribe of Jonson is well made, and is essential to a right com-
Page 16
318 prehension of the poets that followed. With Dr. Moorman’s chapters on the work of Herrick himself we are not so entirely satisfied. They are certainly too long, and they seem to us to contain some doubtful judgments. In part, his views are unquestionably sound. In contrast to Lowell's estimate of Herrick as “the most Catullian of poets since Catullus” he makes a strong compari- son of Herrick and Horace, discovering many points of similarity, but emphasiz- ing a little too much in our opinion the Horatian gravity in our English singer. It his final ranking of Herrick that find ourselves in strong dis- agreement. To Swinburne the lyric poetry of the century “culminates in the crowning star of Herrick,” and to Dr. Moorman Herrick was, in like terms, “the supreme master of the lyre in his own generation, and the glorious consummator of Renaissance song.” Dr. Moorman continues: All the most melodious notes in that loud chorus which made of the England of the “a nest of singing-birds’’ are heard in the “Hesperides.” Herrick can to the strains of Marlowe melodists of Elizabethan he can rival the gallantries of his immediate contemporaries, Carew and Suckling. The of his genius gives him also the to sit down, in that Elysium which his poetic fancy wrought, with An- acreon on his right hand and Catullus and Horace on his left. He is at once romantic and classic, learned and popular. Nothiag is too low for his genius and nothing too high. That, we protest, is altogether to lose sight of critical discrimination. In one sense Herrick was the true artist of his age in so far as he was able to main- tain a surprising level of workmanship; he was, too, capable of a great range of styles and themes; there is, in fact, something of the mocking-bird in his power of imitation; but to intimate that he ever reached the supreme height of passion or expression, that in religious verse he wrote anything at all compara- ble to Vaughan’s “They are all gone,’ or that in amorous verse he ever ap- proached the passion of Donne, or that in classic beauty he knew the secret of Jonson's “To Celia”—\a quite to forget his true place. In little things he was in great things he was only second. He was winsome enough and great enough to merit this careful biog- raphy, and, whatever room there may be for difference with Dr. Moorman on some points, all lovers of English verse will be obliged to him for his labors. in we is Renaissance attune his lyre earliest at the and the song, and same time, courtly varying ply right supreme; Women and the Trades. By Elizabeth Beardsley Butler. New York: Charities Publication Committee. $1.50 net. Work-Accidents and the Law. By Crys- tal Eastman. The same. $1.50 net. These volumes are the first of a ‘se- ries of six which are to embody in per- The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 manent form the results of that unique was assured, rarely find it necessary to experiment in social research conducted by the Sage Foundation, the “Pittsburgh Survey.” Local and limited as is their scope, their significance is national. For what is true of women and the trades and work-accidents and the law in Pitts- burgh is true in other cities. The evils described are general, and the remedies suggested merit attention wherever wo- men toil or the wheels of modern in- dustry revolve. Miss Butler’s volume is a painstaking review of the conditions under which the 22,000 girls and women found to be employed in manufacturing and mercan- tile pursuits in Pittsburgh during the winter of 1907-8 earned their livelihood. Following an introductory chapter on Workers and Work-Rooms, are nineteen detailed chapters describing particular industries, from canning factories to mercantile establishments. The book con- cludes with two chapters on The Social Life of Working Women and four chap- ters summarizing the information pre- viously given as to Wages, Hours, Health, and Economic Foothold. Logical as this arrangement is, it has the dis- advantage of involving not a little repe- tition. Nor is the author’s effort to dis- guise this by varying her phraseology always to be commended. Thus she tells the reader on page 25 that women are employed to “screw nuts on bolts” and a little later (p. 31), that their work is to “put. . . bolts on nuts.” On the whole, however, the descriptions of men’s work are accurate, vivid, and interesting. Appendices describing the the investigation and supplementary infor- and a full easily the of useful a bibliography, make the book methods giving mation, index most complete and scholarly study of! American women in industry that has yet been undertaken. Like every other investigator, Miss Butler finds low pay the most serious evil which confronts the woman wage- earner. Above three-fifths of the girls and * women she studied earned less than $7 a week, and less than one-fifth of them earned more than $8. Like other in- vestigators, also, Miss Butler finds the reason for this low pay in causes that can only gradually be overcome. Women have not the physical strength to do cer- tain tasks. They cannot repair their mia- chines and they dislike to clean them. Trade unions oppose their admission to occupations which have belonged in the past exclusively to men. As a rule, they expect to be gainfully employed only during the few years that precede mar- riage, and consequently they lack ambi- tion to master difficult tasks or to rise above the general level. These circum- stances, combined with others peculiar to smoke-begrimed Pittsburgh, limit the occupations that are open to women and make competition for these occupations so severe that employers, as Miss Butler wo-| advertise for women hands, a simple sign ‘in the window usually bringing an ade- quate supply. In Miss Butler's opinion, the earnings of a majority of the working women of Pittsburgh are insufficient to maintain them in full economic efficiency. This does not mean necessarily that they are losing their health and vigor. Most of them are partly supported by their fam- ilies. It does mean, however, that they fail to get a living wage. Socially their work is partly paid for by employers and partly by their fathers, brothers, or whoever else helps to support them. It is this fact that makes the lot of the working girl who has to support her- self, and even more of the widow who has others dependent upon her, so often a tragedy. Beside this, the other unfavor- able aspects of women’s work—excessivea nervous strain, unduly long hours, and unsanitary surroundings—dwindle into insignificance. Miss Butler has no novel remedies to suggest for the situation she describes. Effective legal regulation of hours and working conditions, trade training that ‘will fit girls for positions requiring greater skill and intelligence, and legal regulation even of wages, appear to com- mand her support, but the great merit of her book is that it presents the prob- lem of women in industry so fully and convincingly that even the blindest op- timist is forced to face it. Of somewhat different character is Miss Eastman’s volume. Her task was to trace out the causes and results of the 526 fatal and the 509 serious, but non-fatal, work accidents which occurred in Allegheny County during the periods chosen for study, and to compare Penn- sylvania’s method of dealing with these accidents with the methods of other countries. With sympathetic insight, she tells the stories of these 1,000-odd per- sons who were killed or injured at their work. She concludes that 30 per cent. of the accidents were due to the neg- | ligence of employers or their legally con- stituted representatives, 28 per cent. to the negligence of the injured themselves ‘or their fellow employees, 16 per cent. ito contributory negligence, and 26 per }cent. to the hazard of the industry. Ac- ‘cording to this estimate less than one- ‘third of these accidents could be made ‘the basis of a legal claim for damages /against the employer. The actual pro- | Portion of cases, in which the employer |made any substantial payment was even |smaller. Thus the author found that in 53 per cent. of the industrial accident fatalities considered, the widow and chil- dren had to bear the loss of the entire income, and in less than 30 per cent. did they receive more than $500. The defects in our system of employ- | ore’ liability have been so often pointed /out that there was little scope for orig- inality in this part of Miss Eastman’s
Page 17
Oct. 6, 1910] The Nation. study, but she has shown the faulty op- eration of the Pennsylvania law with in- telligence and skill. No one who follows her careful analysis of cases will dis- sent from her conclusion that “the law is not only in many of its principles unjust, but also in its method of opera- tion harmful to the interests of all con- cerned.” As to what is to be substi- tuted for it, she offers no very positive suggestions. In her concluding chapter on legislation, however, she shows what has been substituted in other coun- tries and lays down three principles which must guide any reform. Any new policy, she thinks, must put a substan- tial part of the burden on the employer to stimulate his zeal to prevent acci- dents; must shift the loss from the in- dividual family of the victim of the ac- cident to the industry he serves; and must reduce litigation to the lowest terms. Like its predecessor in the series, Miss Eastman’s book is supplied with a num- ber of useful appendices and a full in- dex. Taken as a whole, it is an admir- able discussion of a complex topic, and must aid powerfully the wide-spread movement to substitute for our outworn employers’ liability law a more rational method cf distributing accident losses. Notes. Messrs. Longman have announced “The Collected Works of William Morris,” in twenty-four volumes, under the editorship of Miss May Morris; the edition, which will contain introductions, biographical notes, facsimiles, and frontispieces, will be limited to one thousand copies. The first four volumes will appear in November, their contents being “The Defence of Guinevere,” “The Life and Death of Jason,” and two volumes of “The Earthly Paradise.” Two other volumes to be issued by this firm are “The House of Lords during the Civil War,” by Prof. C. H. Firth, and “Lec- tures on the Greek Poets,” by Prof. J. W. Mackail. Edmund G. Gardner’s new book entitled “Dante and the Mystics” traces the influ- ence of St. Augustine, St. Francis, and other Christian mystics upon Dante, discusses the relation of the “Divine Comedy” to other vision literature, and attempts to define Dante’s position in the Franciscan move- ment. “Voices from Erin” is the title of a new volume of poems by Denis A. Mc- Carthy, which is now in the press of Little, Brown and Company. “The Second Chance,” by Nellie McClung, is in preparation by Doubleday, Page & Co. The publication was begun last month the Mercure de France of the letters Mérimée to Sutton Sharpe; these are interest especially for their references by of of to contemporary figures in literature and poli- | tics. 'siter Johnson's umes of a revised and enlarged edition of “The United Irishman,” by Richard Robert Madden. When completed, the work will contain twelve volumes. Christopher Hare's “Charles De Bourbon, Constable of France” is to be brought out this week by John Lane Company; also “A Queen at Bay,” by Edmund B. d’Au- vergne, and G. F. Hill's “One Hundred Masterpieces of Sculpture,” from the sixth century, B. c. to the time of Michelan- gelo, with plates and descriptions Wessels & Bissel will publish “The Sea Hawk,” a story by Bailey Millard; ‘The Song Lore of Ireland,”” a volume by Red- fern Mason, and a revised edition of Ros- “History of the War of Secession.” John T. Trowbridge’s “‘Darius Green and His Flying-Machine,”’ written more than for- ty years ago, will be re-issued by Houghton Mifflin Co. in a popular edition, with il- lustrations by Wallace Goldsmith. The same house is preparing the second volume of “The American People: A Study in Na- tional Psychology,” by A. Maurice Low, which it plans to publish early next year. A series of tales properly graded for the various ages of childhood is planned by H. M. Caldwell Company. It includes: “Stories from Grimm,” “The Doctor's Lass,” “Cherrythorpe Fair,’ ‘“‘The Rambles |of Three Children,” “Stories from Ander- sen,”’ “A Book of Stories from the Norse,” “The Waits of Bremen,” “Tales of an Old Yew Tree,” “Things Will Take a Turn,” “King Arthur and His Knights,” “A Saxon Maid,” and “The Knights of Charlemagne.” Carro Frances Warren's Garden Series for children, which is in the hands of C. M. Clark Co. of Boston, will shortly be in- creased by the volume, “Little Danny Dan- delion.”’ B. W. announced autumn list: Huebsch adds to his previously “Temples of Peace | Built of Untempered Mortar,” a criticism of the protective tariff, by John Bigelow, and Frank Parson’s ‘“‘Legal Doctrine and Social Progress.” To the books which Frederick A. Stokes has promised for November should be added: “Home Rule,” by John Redmond, M.P.; “Masterpieces in Color: Murillo’; in the Coast Series: ‘“‘The Norfolk and Suffolk Coast,”’ by W. A. Dutt; “The Corn- wall Coast,” by Arthur L. Salmon, and “The South Devon and Dorset Coast,” by Sidney Heath; “Anti-Matrimony,” a drama by Percy MacKaye. Henry Frowde’s autumn announcement of the Oxford University Press contains: English: “Essays by Members of the English Association” (H. Bradley, R Bridges, W. P. Ker, G. Neilson, G. Saints- bury, E. Sichel, C. E. Vaughan), collected by A. C. Bradley; “Six Essays on John- son by Walter Raleigh; “The French Renaissance in England,” by Sidney Lee; “Tudor and Stuart Library: Traherne’s Poems of Felicity,” now first published from the MS., edited by H. I. Bell; “The Oxford Book of Ballads,"’ chosen and edit- ” , ed by Sir Arthur Quiller-Couch; “Plays from the Italian (Supposes, Buggbears, Misogonus), edited by R. W. Bond; “Cole- ridge’s Poems,” with much unpublished |matter, edited by E. H. Coleridge; “‘Spen- The Tandy Publishing Company of New | York is to issue this month the first vol-' Poems), edited by E. De Sélincourt; ‘The’ ser’s Poetical Works’’: volume i (The Minor 319 Englishman in Greece,’ with introduction by Sir J. Rennell Rodd. Modern languages: ‘An Introduction to Old High German,” by Lionel Armitage; “Living Speech in Central and South Africa’’: an essay in- troductory to the Bantu language, by A. Cc. Madan; “The Life of the Black Prince,” by the Herald of Sir John Chandos, edited and E. C. from the MS. by M. K. Pepe Lodge; “Oxford Book of Italian Verse,” XIII-XIX Century, chosen by St. John Lucas Theology: “Old Latin Biblical Texts, VI: Codex Veronensis },” edited by E. S. Buchanan; “John the Presbyter and the Fourth Gospel,”” by Dom John Chap- man, O.8.B.; “Gesenius's Hebrew Gram- mar,” new edition, translated from the twenty-eighth German edition (by E. Kautzsch), by A. E. Cowley; “Studies in the Book of Isaiah,’ by M. G. Glazebrook, with two maps. History: “Tudor and Stuart Proclamations, 1485-1714," calen- dared by R. Steele under the direction of the Earl of Crawford, K.T., two volumes; Sir C. P. Lucas’s “Historical Geography of the British Colonies”: volume v, Canada, part ili (Geographical), by J. D. Rogers, with maps; “Documents Illustrating the Continental Reformation,” edited by B. J. Kidd; “The English Factories in India,” by W. Foster: volume v, 1634-1636; ‘“‘Henry Fox, First Lord Holland,” by T. W. Riker, two volumes, illustrated; “Trichotomy in Roman Law,” by Henry Goudy. Classics: Oxford classical texts—‘Tacitus, His- tories,”” edited by C. D. Fisher; “Cicero, Orationes’’—Post Reditum, De Domo Sua, De Haruspicum Responso, Pro Sestio, In Vatinium, De Provinciis Consularibus, Pro Balbo, edited by W. Peterson; Pro Plancio, Pro Fonteio, Pro Sulla, Pro Archia, Pro Scauro, Pro Tullio, edited by A. C. Clark (The publication of these speeches will complete the edition of the Orationes.) “Historia Numorum,” by B. V. Head, sec- ond edition; “The Works of Aristotle,” translated into English under the editor- ship of J. A. Smith and W. D. Ross— “Historia Animalium,” by D’Arcy' W. Thompson; “De Partibus Animalium,” by W. Ogle; Oxford Library of Translations— “Cesar’s Gallic War,” by F. P. Long; among many school books are: “English Political Institutions,” by J, A. R. Mar- riott; “From Metternich Bismarck”: a text-book of European history, 1815-1878, by L. Cecil Jane; “Kinglake’s Eothen,” with introduction by D. G. Hogarth and notes by V. H. Collins In the Oxford Poets Series: “Dryden,” edited by J. Sar- geaunt; “‘Moore,”’ edited by A. D. Godley; “A Book of Light Verse,”’ edited by R. M. Leonard in the Oxford Standard Au- thors: ‘“‘Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe,” with Cruikshank’s illustrations; ‘“‘Dante’s Divine translated by Cary, with Flax- In the Oxford Edition many illustrations): ‘‘The Heart of Midlothian,” “Redgauntlet,” “The For- of Nigel,” “The Antiquary,” and Monastery.”” In the Oxford Library and Poetry: “Clough’s Poems,” including “‘Ambarvalia’’ and the first edi- tion of “The Bothie,” edited by H. 8. Mil- ford; “Shelley's Poems of 1820"; “Jeffrey's Literary Criticism,’’ edited by D. Nichol Smith; “Charles Reade’s A Good Fight” (the first version of The Cloister and the Hearth). In the World's Classics: ‘‘Shake- epeare’s Plays and Poems,” with a general to Comedy.” man's illustrations. of Scott (with Abbott,” “The “Kenilworth,” tunes “The of Prose
Page 18
B20 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 introduction by A. C. Swinburne, intro- ductory studies of the several plays by E. Dowden, and a note by T. Watts-Dun- ton upon the special typographical features of this edition. Volumes i to iii. In ad- dition: ‘“‘Letters by Edward John lawny,"’ mostly unpublished, edited by H. Buxton Forman, C.B.; “Pages from a Jour- nal,” by Mark Rutherford, second edition, enlarged; also a companion volume en- titled, “More Pages from a Journal’; “The Serpent of Division,” by John Lyd- gate, the Monk of Bury, edited, with tn- troduction, notes, and glossary, by H. N. MacCracken, with facsimiles; “Wood Carv- ings English Churches,” volume Staiis, by Francis Bond (Church Art in England Series); “American Railway Prob- lems in the Light of European Expe- rience,”’ by C. 8. Vrooman. Yale Univer- sity Publications: “The Records of the Federal Convention of 1787," edited by M. Farland; “The Campaign of Chancellors- ville; a Strategic and Tactical Study, by John Bigelow, jr., Major U. 8. Army, retired, with 47 maps and plans, and “The High Court of Parliament and Its Supre- macy’: an historical essay on the Boun- daries between Legislation and Adjudica- tion in England, by C. H. MelIlwain. in The ubiquitous Baedeker has revised edi- tions, in English, of “Paris” (the seven- teenth), “Berlin” (thefourth),and “Belgium and Holland” (the fifteenth), which we re- ceive from Charles Scribner's Sons. They bring with them, as always, reminiscences | and hopes of travel. Dr. Henry Bradley has added to the “Ox- ford English Dictionary” the double section | Sauce-Alone-Scouring (Clarendon Press). As compared with the previous instalment of 8, this section makes somewhat dull reading; for words with long, diversified histories are notably few, and there is only a sprinkling of novel and curious outland- ers from the Orient and the New World. | Among the quaintest oddities are the ob- | solete oaths--the “fossils of piety”—ex- humed from the older dramatic literature; "sblood, ‘abobs, ‘sbodikina, and ‘sbud well illustrate the way in which blasphemy writhes behind the fig leaves of euphemism till a fastidious and sancti- fied lady may use in all innocence the blood- curdling ejaculations of bandits and barge- men. Of modern English made in America perhaps the most significant specimens are scallywag, achoolmarm, and schooner—“a tall glass of beer”—a word first recorded in Webster's Supplement, 1879, but now said to be available in various cities of the Brit- ish Isles. The precise origin and develop- ment of scallywag are obscure: Bartlett localized it in 1848 as a “favorite epithet in western New York for a mean man”; during the Reconstruction it became a term of political reproach; in 1868 it was de- clared to have been originally a drover's word for ill-conditioned cattle; in 1891 it appears as trade-union slang for a man who will not work. Dr. Bradley strangely neglects remark that scallywag, like scamp (which formerly meant a “highway robber"), has lost much of its early savor, and is now largely employed as a term of endearment for particularly vivacious and heart-ravishing infants. One is surprised, also, to find no mention of scade—Ameri- canism—meaning “stacks,” “heaps,” or “bushels” of anything. to Tre- | *abody, ‘sbores, | Of the longer articles, that on science is from many points of view the most inter- esting. Probably no other word has within | the last hundred years so startlingly con- | tracted the limits of its meaning. In the | Middle Ages science meant, among other things, “knowledge as a personal attri- bute”; so that Chaucer could write of “the soule whiche that hath in _ itself science of goode werkes,” and Lydgate could say that the cherubim are full of science and divine sapience, and a plain, | plous man could declare that he had sci- ence of God. With the meaning, further- more, of a “particular branch of knowl- edge,” science was not then the antonym but the synonym of art; the “seven sci- ences” and “the seven liberal arts” were | interchangeable terms. Even as late as | the early nineteenth century acience was | applied at Oxford “to the portions of an- | clent and modern philosophy, logic, and cognate subjects, included in the course for a@ degree in the school of Litere Humani- ores.” In 1884 Freeman writes: “I re- member him years ago as a logic and sci- ence coach. I don’t mean for cutting up cats, but what science meant then, ethics, Butler, and such like.” In 1840 Whewell | felt the need of coining the word scientist, and from about that period metaphysics and theology began to be excluded from the meaning of science and its scope to be | limited to those branches of study dealing | with the phenomena of the material uni- verse, which in the seventeenth and eigh- | teenth centuries had been commonly known as philosophy. One old sense of the word | marked obsolete by Dr. Bradley—‘‘a craft, trade, or occupation’—appears in_ this country at least to be enjoying a revival. “Whan a virgyn begynneth fyrst to lerne to sewe in the samplar,” says an author of the sixteenth century, “‘that scyence to her |as than semeth very harde.” If Dr. Brad- | ley thinks this sense obsolete, let him look lover the courses in sewing, sweeping, and | bread-making offered as “household sci- ence” in American universities. “The Forerunners of Dante: a selection |from Italian poetry before 1300” (Frowde), is the last product of Prof. A. J. Butler’s ‘long study and great love of the Floren- |tine master. The manuscript of the notes |was finished only a fortnight before his |death. The book contains about seventy | Canzoni, mostly of the Sicilian school, in- | cluding several not to be found in the Ttal- ‘fan anthologies. The sonnets had been | reserved for a companion volume. The work was undertaken with the purpose of throw- |ing Nght on the lyric tradition which en- tered into the work of Dante. Of the Ital- jan poems referred to in the “De Vulgari | Eloquentia,” all those now extant, except | Dante’s own, are here—even “Una fermana | iscoppa!l da Casciol!.” The preface and the 'notes bear witness to the growth of Pro- ‘fessor Butler’s delight in the lyrics for their own sake. He found many a stanza form of peculiar beauty, many a perfect phrasing of graceful thought, and, here and there, the very thrill of passion. The lamento of Giacomino Pugliese, in particu- lar, for its deep, manifold grief, directly voiced in worthy artistry, seemed to him comparable with the greatest poems of bereavement. The book is edited with scholarly care, The best texts of the several poems were utilized, and bettered, in a number of cases, through the conser- vative ingenuity of the editor. The notes, which are grouped together at the back of the book, leaving the poems free, con- tain enough explanation to make the read- ing of the canzoni possible for any reader of Dante, and afford many instances of new and valuable interpretation. G. Barbéra of Florence has just pub- lished an attractive anthology of the say- ings of Galileo, “Pensieri, motti e sentenze di Galileo Galilei,” a small volume in 24vo., in the collection Diamante, originally edited by Giosué Carducci. It has been com- piled by Antonio Favaro, who for the past thirty years has been occupied in preparing the monumental National Edition of Gali- leo’s works. The anthology is not, then, a chance, catch-penny piece of editing, but a maturely studied compendium. As Favaro observes, the dominating note is Galileo's passion for direct communion with nature and his consequent intolerance of the prin- ciple of authority. “A Congressional History of Railways in the United States,” by Lewis H. Haney (Uni- versity of Wisconsin Bulletin, Vol. 6, No. 1), is the second volume by this author under the same title. Volume 1 carried the his- tory down to 1850. This study continues the subject, and covers the period from 1850 to 1887. It is a time of general interest in railway construction, when the land-grant policy is begun, developed to its extreme, and finally, because of its glaring abuses, is brought to an end. During these decades, the Pacific railways are built, and the foundations are laid of our present regu- lation policy. All these questions are taken up by the author chronologically and topi- cally; much attention is given to the va- rious bills introduced, and particularly to the debates, for any side-lights which they may contain. There is very little of in- dividual opinion or attempt at interpreta- tion of the historical movement; rather is it a faithful record, carefully supported by elaborate references. Occasionally, how- ever, the author ventures a personal con- clusion on some mooted point. It is his judgment, for example, that had the rail- way come a little earlier, direct subsi- dies would have been given and govern- mental lines constructed, but this later be- came impossible, largely for political rath- er than for economic reasons. He fails to find any clear justification for the exten- sive subsidies to the Pacific railways, and considers it as certain that within two decades private enterprise would have suf- ficed to build the roads. Political considera- tions probably justified aid for one trans- continental line, but the United States would have best solved the problem by constructing a national railway over the central route, leaving the exploitation of other lines, without aid, other than right of way, to private initiative. The two vol- umes of this history provide a valuable and convenient work of reference to students of railway development in the United States. “A Transformed Colony” (Lippincott), by T. J. Alldridge, is a description of the present conditions in Sierra Leone, as com- pared with those a few years ago. Then it was the prey of the slave-hunter and des- olated by tntertribal wars; now it is a land of security and freedom. The author has an especial fitness for his task, as he came to the country in 1871, and, as travelling
Page 19
Oct. 6, 1910] The Nation. 321 commissioner, did pioneer work in open- ing up the then unknown Hinterland, mak- ing treaties with the paramount chiefs, and pacifying the various tribes. In the latter years of his service he was the district commissioner of the Sherbro. In 1908 he made an extensive journey in the protec- torate, going over much of the ground he had traversed before, and his book is a rec-_ erd of his experiences and impressions, to- gether with much information about native | customs, especially their secret societies. Beginning with a detailed account of Free- town, the capital, he describes a trip by the government railway over 200 miles into the interior, one which he had taken be- fore by hammock. The most interesting incident in this was his visit to a govern- ment school at Bo for the sons of native | chiefs, the object being to train them “in such a manner as to make them good and useful rulers of the country in the future.” With this end in view, they are taught “the ordinary branches of an English education, together with special and practical training | in farming, carpentry, bridge-building, road-making, and land-surveying”’; and no dressing up as Europeans is permitted, ac- cording to the school regulations. All the, methods of instruction planned did not meet with universal approbation. In the govern- | ment notice of the establishment of the school it said: By means of lantern lectures pictures of the principal incidents in the lives of such women as Florence Nightingale, Eliza- beth Fry. the late Queen Victoria, and many others, will be shown and explained to the pupils, with a view to increasing their respect for women. Im-iediately a petition was sent in to the Governor, saying that Mohammedans ob- jected to all this, because they had nota- ble women of their own known to every Moslem. The opposition, of which this is only one form, was speedily overcome by the creation of a Mohammedan advisory board. At the time of the author’s visit, the school had eighty pupils. Great emphasis is laid on the undeveloped native wealth of the country. Immense quantities of fruit, rice, cotton, and tobacco could be grown. while vast forests of oil-palms—a_ tree which may be said to be the “Ruler of West Africa’’—are standing year in and year out untouched by anv human hand. The rubber»vine is also common through- out the Hinterland, but is neglected or destroyed by the native. The general pros- rerity of the protectorate, however, is in- dicated by the fact that the revenue, which in 1887 was $300,000, in 1907 was $1,800,000. The illustrations, sixty-six in number, are all interesting, but particularly those show- | ing the members of the secret societies and their strange costumes, There is an ex- cellent map, furnished by the War Office also an index. The ninth book of Livy contains an ac- count of the battle with the Samnites at the Caudine Forks, and the subsequent sharp practice of the Romans in evading their obligations through technicalities. The famous speculation on the power of Alexander as compared with that of the Romans is also found in this book. These would be ample justification for the edi- tion which has just been published by T. Nicklin (Clarendon Press). A short in- troduction is noteworthy only for a chap- ter of Hints on Translation in which stress is laid on the metaphorical character of | | L‘vy’s language; the point is illustrated by | quotations from English authors, only a. | single sentence In length, which when com- |pared with the corresponding passages in jthe text show admirably the essential differences between English and Latin |style. No indication is given of the source of the text. The notes are intended for freshmen students. | Col. A, O. Green, who has done much to facilitate the study of Arabic by the English officials in Egypt, has prepared a second |edition of his “Modern Arabic Stories, Bal- lads, Proverbs and Idioms” (Frowde). first edition employed the Arabic script; | this one gives in part i the transliterated the English translation, with explanations of local terms and customs. (taken from Spitta and others, except a Voyage of Sindibad) form a valuable con- | tribution to the history of Egyptian Moslem manners. Part ili of the “Clavis Linguarum Semiti- carum” (edited by H. L. Strack) is “‘A Man- ual of the Aramaic Language of the Baby- lonian Talmud,” by Max L. Margolis, pro- | fessor of Biblical philology in the Dropsie College, Philadelphia (New York: G. E. Stechert & Co.). The work consists of a grammar, with chrestomathy and glossaries. Grammatical forms, examples, and texts are taken from the best manuscripts and print- ed editions of the Talmud, and older and later forms and usages are distinguished. Here, then, we have for the first time a satisfactory grammar of this important dia- lect, and the Manual will doubtless be in the hands of all students of the Talmud. Prof. Joseph Wright’s “Grammar of the Gothic Language” (Clarendon Press), which author and publishers have seen fit to issue instead of a third edition of their “Primer,” differs from the shorter work chiefly in being printed in larger type and being amplified in the direction of compar- ative grammar. The facts of Gothic gram- mar are presented in the same lucid order and for the most part in the same language as in the “Primer”; but in this book the Gothic forms are traced back to their Indo- European originals, parallel forms in Greek or Latin, in Primitive Germanic, Old High German, and Anglo-Saxon, and additional tables are given to exhibit the development of sounds and words. The inclusion of the Greek of some chapters of the Gospels, which are in part reprinted In the version of Ulfilas, will make the study of the Gothic more instructive. Professor Wright has here and there revised as well as supple- mented his former treatment of the subject: he offers texts in sufficient abundance to enable a student to acquire a working knowledge of vocabulary and idiom; so that the book in itself is an adequate, as it is an admirable, introduction to the study of Germanic philology. Students of Scandinavian languages have for years known that Verner Dablerup, as- sociate professor in the University of Co- penhagen, editor of Icelandic sagas, and writer on Danish literary and linguistic topics, has been working on a great dic- tionary of the Danish language. As long ago as Christmas, 1890, it was maintained | at a meeting of the Modern Language As- sociation of America, thatthe chief desider- atum of those interested in Scandinavian ‘studies was an adequate thesaurus of the ifor the People,” The | text, with grammatical notes, and in part 11 | The selections | | therefore, | Chauvet. Danish language, while others held that an etymological dictionary was the main thing wanted. The etymological dictionary has been supplied by Professors Falk and Torp of the University of Christiania (started in 1901 and completed in 1906), a German translation whereof is now in the course of publication. The absence of a satisfactory and accessible Danish dictionary has been partly remedied by the “Danish Dictionary which has been in the course of publication for the last seven years by the Gyldendal Publishing House (Copenhagen and Chicago), and which now, with its twenty-seventh part has come down to about the middle of the letter S. This dictionary, while being distinctly bet- ter than nothing, is not of a kind to satisfy the present standard of scholarly thorough- ness, correctness, and conciseness. It is, a matter of distinct grat- to all those interested in Danish, and we may well say Germanic ‘philology, that the same publishing house (Gyldendal) has recently sent out a fascicle of Dahlerup’s above- mentioned work, entitled, “Ordbog over det danske Sprog’’ (Dictionary of the Danish Language), the publication whereof is to be started in the near future. The present fas- cicle of forty quarto pages carries us from A to Aarefistel, and shows that the work will be particularly valuable by its wealth of reliable and pertinent quotations. The dictionary will be especially devoted to the last two centuries of the development of the Danish language. One might perhaps express a wish that the author should give more detailed information in regard to the older history of the words. Mrs. Rebecca Harding Davis, died just a week ago, was the mother of Rich- ard Harding Davis, and the widow of L ification who Clarke Davis, at one time editor of the Philadelphia ‘Public Ledger, Mrs. Davis was born in Washington, Pa., in 1831. She began her literary career by contribut- ing in 1861 to the Atlantic Monthly an ar- ticle entitled “Life in the Iron Millis,” in which she depicted the grinding life of the people about her. The following year the Atlantic published her first long “Margaret Howth.” In 1869 she a position on the editorial staff of the New York Tribune, which she held for several novel, acc epted years. Besides many short stories, Mrs. Davis was the author of “Waiting for the Verdict,” “Dallas Galbraith,” “John An- drus,” “A Law Unto Herself,” “Earthen Pitchers,” ‘“‘Kitty’s Choice,"’ ‘Kent Hamp- den,” “Natasqua,” “Silhouettes of Ameri- can Life,” “Frances Waldeaux,” “Dr. War- rick’s Daughters,” and “Bits of Gossip.” Dr. William Maclagan, the late Archbishop of York, who died two weeks ago, had pub- lished several volumes of sermons and had written hymns, the as well the words, music as Emile Raymond Blavet, who died at Nice at the age of seventy-two, was a journalist of high standing, a dramatist, and the au- thor of several novels. He had contributed to the Figaro the section, “La Vie de Paris,” and started the Petit Bleu. He was a nfember of the Legion of Honor. The death is announced from Caen of the aged French phiiosopher J. A. Emmanuel He was professor of philosophy at Caen from 1870 until 1899, when he re- tired, and besides publishing many essays
Page 20
‘> 3822 he works of Plato. The author of the history of Switzerland volumes, Prof. Karl Déindliker, Kiissnacht, at the age ef collaborated on a translation of the in twelve died recently at sixty-one Science. Tactical Principles and Problems. By Matthew Elting Hanna, “Third States Cavalry. Menasha, George Banta Publishing Co. Formerly, West Point was the sole reservoir of learning for the land forces, and it has always been devoted to forming character quite as much as to supplying higher non-mathemati- cal instruction. It gave no post-gradu- ate course. Officers appointed: from civil life absorbed the military rudiments by association with graduates; those com- missioned from the ranks supplemented their familiarity with barrack and pa- rade, and their usually slender book- learning, by what might be gleaned through observation of others who were better taught. But now conditions have changed, so that at appropriate Capt. United Wis.: posts there have been established grad- | uate artillery, cavalry, engineering, sig- nal, and army medical schools for officers of those respective arms. At Fort Leavenworth, out of a verita- ble military kindergarten established in former years for insufficiently informed officers, have evolved an army school of the line and an army staff college. There Capt. Hanna has been teaching the art of war, and a part of his in- struction is in the practical form of laying before the student-officers succes- sive military situations and requiring them to solve problems based thereon. Certain eonditions assumed, what would be sound tactical operations? When the field itself is not available for inspec- tion, or there are no competent maps to be studied, such questions and their answers would be the haziest generali- ties. It is impossible to describe ver- bally the details of any terrain so that the memory may serviceably retain them. Often even veritable actions can- not be followed in detail without some graphical aid. Certainly, an account for the public should embrace the out- lines of military geography quite as well as the movements of troops and their fire action. Independently of their help in appre- clating what has already occurred, topo- graphical detaile are so essential in active fleld work that the command which neglects them handicaps itself exactly so much. The era of combined courage and momentum culminating in brutal frontal attacks upon selected po- sitions, as illustrated at Bunker The Na Hill | and Fredericksburg, passed from even | tion. [ Vol. 91, No. 2362
————— The accuracy of to-day’s arms emphasizes the importance of ap- proach under cover and of selecting, | where selection is possible, defensible | positions. This is especially true in such preliminary study of the field as patrol and outpost duty involve. The object there is to see without being seen, and the character of the field must be considered also when wider and more important work is at hand. The use of cover is not new in Amer-| ican theory, but its scientific employ- | ment is more beautifully demonstrated in these Leavenworth lectures than ever before in American text-books. they do not end there. tile contact should be conducted with independent commands, up to small brigades of infantry and cavalry with- out artillery. To make such demonstra- ‘tion possible, the volume is happily equipped with two large detached mili- tary maps on which every natural fea- ture and the more important artificial ones are noted, and which are profuse- ly sprinkled with numerals and letters for easy consultation and reference. One map covers about nine by sixteen miles around Fort Leavenworth on a scale of two inches to the mile, and the oth- er about four by six miles of the same territory at four inches to the mile. |The contour intervals are twenty and ten feet, respectively. There are also three small maps. The text is a well- written group of problems in the field use of infantry and cavalry, gradually increasing in complexity, each with a reasonable solution followed by practi- cal comments. It is serious but not dry or abstruse. The student is en- couraged to make a personal solution lafter a careful study of the problem, and then to compare it with that pre- sented in the book. But Capt Hanna modestly announces that his own solu- tions are to be regarded neither as faultless nor as by any means the only | good ones; and that any uncomplicat- | ed solution which violates no sound tactical principle and accomplishes its object is good. Clearly, the purpose is | not to unravel arbitrary tangles, but to master the practical philosophy of the minor operations of war. When the available territory is examined with the care advised and the sagacious commentaries are absorbed, the student will have a fair comprehension of the applied tactics of two arms. Every offi- cer of the organized militia, and equal- ly his fellow in the permanent estab- lishment, for whom this book was espe- cially prepared, should be the careful student of these lectures. They should be interesting also to the general read- er, especially in helping to dispel the popular delusion that soldiers are a flat product, the immediate result of a call long-range | And | They go on to) illustrate the principles by which hos- | In construction the text is admirable. The narrative is clear, the orders are well written, the solutions and com- ments logical and acceptable, and throughout there is a refreshing ab- sence of adjectives. Occasionally, it is true, shall and will, and should and would, replace one another; but these /are slips which do not distort the mean- ing. There are, however, two mislead- ing corruptions in the lettering of the staff map; one a matter of taste, the other an historical error. The first is “Sheridan’s Drive,” which also repeat- edly appears in the letter-press. The possessive has no proper place there; otherwise there should be Grant’s Ave- nue, Wagner’s Point, and so forth. The “Sheridan Drive” is euphonious and con- ‘sonant with descriptive nomenclature. | Besides, that is its name. The other, |“Kearney” Avenue, is a gross blunder, for it cannot hark back to Commodore |Lawrence Kearney of the navy, distin- 'guished as he was. The able and effi- ‘elent Gen. Stephen W. Kearny had official association with Fort Leaven- worth, and his dashing nephew. Philip Kearny, has conspicuous claim to sol- |dierly remembrance. “Kearny” would | commemorate either or both, “Kearney” ' neither. In the next edition the value of this | work would be increased by an analyti- cal index; not a mere catalogue of names or a distended table of contents, but a careful alphabetical reckoning of ‘principles under key words. It is well worth such labor, but an incompetent index might be worse than none. The | very recent detail of Capt. Hanna to the |General Staff is a deserved compliment ‘to him and a comforting sign that the | Staff is well selected. “Bird Flight as the Basis of Human | Flight,” by Otto Lilienthal, has been trans- | lated from the second edition, and is to be | issued by Messrs. Longman. Tables of the four great satellites of | Jupiter have been composed by Prof. R. A. | Sampson of the University of Durham. { Very attractive in cover design and gen- |eral makeup is ‘Louis’ Every Woman’s | Cook Book” (H. M. Caldwell Co.), with its | clear type and ornamental margins. One | hundred and twenty pages are devoted tu | recipes, and an equal number of blank | Spaces are provided for memoranda. The | directions are clear and simple, and the choice comprehensive. In “Peaks and Giaciers, a record of pio- neer exploration in the Punjab Himalaya,” ‘by Fanny Bullock Workman and William | Hunter Workman (Scribner), the main point of interest to the unscientific reader is Mrs. Workman’s record-breaking climb, when, | with two companions, she ascended a peak | 28,300 feet high, the greatest altitude ever |reached by a woman. The party also camp- |ed higher than tents had ever been pitched before, with one possible exception, and the most sluggish minds with ¢he South |for volunteers. True soldiers are de-| ¢neir experience with change of temperature African demonstration of its futility. ‘veloped, not generated by command. was probably unparalleled. In the after-
Page 21
Ort. 6, 1910] noon the mercury in the solar thermometer went up to 193° Fahr. “At sunset the temperature fell to freezing, and an hour later to 10 degrees Fahrenheit, reaching a minimum of —4 degrees before morning. It thus underwent a variation of 197 degrees in somewhat more than twelve hours.” From the fact that during this climb five nights were passed without sleep, the inference is drawn that the loss of strength from sleep- lessness, and not the difficulty of breathing, is the greatest obstacle to very high ascents. The student of mountain and glacier forma- tion will find much interesting and valuable information, especially in regard to mo- raines, and the curious nieve penitente, the collection of pyramidal pinnacles of ice or hardened snow arranged in rows on the mountain slopes or glaciers. It was firs noticed and described by Andean explorers, and for a long time supposed to be peculiar to the Andes. The Workmans discovered eight different varieties during this expedi- tion, besides one made two years later, in 1908, which are described in detail, with photographic illustrations. They have added much to the exact geographical knowledge of this little-known part of the great range, with the intention of making a full and ac- curate survey map possible. The fall-page photographic illustrations which appear be- tween nearly every two pages, are remarka- ble pictures, especially of pyramidal peaks and glacial ice formations. One shows at the apex of a snow-covered summit a won- derful profile strongly resembling the Em- press-Queen Victoria. Drama and Musie. The fabric of Maeterlinck’s “The Blue Bird” consists of such delicate and fanciful stuff that the transfer of it from the library to the stage, without the loss of any of its fragrance or bloom, must be an almost im- possible task. To the long array of decora- tive and mechanical problems is added the need of sympathetic and enlightened acting. It is not surprising, therefore, that the pres- ent representation in the New Theatre fails to do more than suggest some of the author’s ideals, The merely mechanical difficulties have been surmounted with much ingenuity, and several of the stage pic:ures are exceed- ingly beautiful, but they are not especially notable for high imaginative quality, and this last remark may be applied to most of the acting. It is not necessary to enter into any details of a story which must be well known to most of our readers. Briefly, it relates the dream adventures of two poor children who, under the guidance of a fairy, seek for the Blue Bird, which is the symbol oi happiness. They are accompanied by the Cat—who, representing the powers of Dark- ness, is their secret foe—by the Dog, man’s one friend among the animals, and by the embodied spirits of different elements and things, who give them no practical assist- ance in their quest. They invade the mys- teries of Night, interview the dead in the Land of Memory, explore the Kingdom of the Past and Future, and learn finally that happiness is illusionary and fleeting, that it can be seized, lost, and recaptured, and that it may often be secured by imparting the means of it to others. Or the surface a fantastic fairy tale for children, the piece is written in the simplest style, and yet is The Nation. crammed with ingenious allegory, philo- sophic reflection, and poetic fancy. It re- quires acting of the most delicate and sincere kind, and the best ability in the service of the New Theatre might have been worthily employed upon it. For the lack o’ it, several scenes were deprived of near- ly all their poetic and artistic significance and became conventional. The inadequacy of the actor entrusted with the part of Time for instance, was almost fatal to the imagi- native scene in the Kingdom of the Future Eleanor Moretti played Night in the right vein, but an actress of more tragic power /} would have made the act doubly impressive. The Fairy Berylune was the ordinary fairy of pantomime. The children were un- fcrtunately stagy and unreal. No parts, however, could be more difficult to All. The Dog and the Cat were both excellent, the impersonation of the latter by Cecil Yapp being one of the features of the perform- ance. The most successful scene of all was that of the Land of Memory, where Tylyl and Mytyl visit their dead grandpar- ents. Here the acting of Robert McWade and Eleanor Carey was admirably and natural, while the scenic arrangements Regarded as a whole, the en- tertainment is one of high merit and rare beauty, but it scarcely fulfils the highest expectations founded on the known resourc- es and capacities of the New Theatre simple were perfect. In a monograph entitled “Der bestrafte Brudermord, sein Verhdltnis zu Shakes- peare’s Hamlet” (Leipzig: Leopold Voss), | Marshall Blakemore Evans reopens an old, | perplexing question and furnishes a highly probable solution. His cenclusion that the German play goes back originally to the “Ur-Hamlet” and that this latter may r.a- sonably be assigned to Thomas Kyd, wili, of course, surprise nobody, as this has been the impression among scholars, in America at least, for several years. It is satisfac- tory, neverthcless, to have the impression confirmed by such a careful and minute study as Mr. Evans has here made. “Der bestrafte Brudermord,” in its present form, dates from the year 1710, but the writer makes it clear that it, all likelihood, preserves with considerable fidelity the ver- sion which an English company brought to Germany and acted in 1626, and then by the perilous but necessary device of paral- lels he sets out to identify it as the best extant relic of the “Ur-Hamlet,” showing (1) that it is closer in its phraseology to the first quarto of Shakespeare's “Hamlet” than to the second, that the variations in the second quarto look, on the face of them, like later revisions; (2) that the German drama draws upon Belleforest for certain incidents which are not contained in the quartos; (3) that it makes use, to a much greater extent than the quartos, of Seneca, a thing to be expected in the adaptation of a pre-Shakesperean English tragedy; (4) that, not only in the matter of indebt- edness to Seneca, but, in other details of style and construction, it bears a striking resemblance to the work of Thomas Kyd. Up to this point the argument is well han- died, even if enthusiasm for his thesis leads the writer occasionally to submit evidence which proves nothing; incidentally, it makes the conclusion necessary that Shakespeare's first quarto, whether pirated or not, records a cruder form of the play than the second in short, that Shakespeare must have made revisions in the play in the in ’ many year af- ter its first appearance. The rest of th argument, which tries to work out in deta! the genealogy of the Hamlet the nature of the case, less convincing. At the end of the book is a reprint of Belle forest’s novel, text of 1576, with variant readings and an introduction story, is, by There are freshness and humor in “Th Concert,”” which was produced in the Theatre on Tuesday an English version by Leo Ditrichstein of a Herman The finds lasco evening It is comedy by the German dramatist, Bahr, which has had success in Europe hero of it is a famous pianist, who it difficult to resist the his adoring female pupils. One of them, a mar- ried woman, accompanies him to his bua- fascination of galow in the mountains, whither they ar: promptly followed by the deserted wife and husband. These two profess to take a philosophical view of the situation and propose a peaceful and permanent ex change of partners, instead of a publ scandal Put in this ridiculously unro mantic situation, the elopers speedily re- alize the folly of their conduct, and a gen eral reconciliation effected before ir remediable mischief has done Mr Ditrichstein’s adaptation is clever, and the piece, which is beautifully mounted and very is been well played, is likely to prove a hit It contains much effective satire upon th airs and affectations of the artistic tem has an abundance of comical and some bright characteriza- the concluding act would be effective if half an hour were it. Mr. Ditrichtstein gave performance the pianist perament, ncident, but more out of admirable tions, much cut an of ————» Paris is somewhat behindhand as regards the production of Massenet’s operas. The last three of them, “Thérése,”’ “Bacchus,” and “Don Quixote,” have not yet been heard there, the honors of the first performances having gone to Monte Carlo and Brussels. During the present season, however, “Thérése will be produced at the Opéra-Comique. It first heard at Monte Carlo on February 7 1907, with a cast including known and admired in America as Armand, and Dufranne as André Thore!l was two artists Clément During Thomas Beecham's recent season in London, the biggest popular su were Offenbach’s “Tales Hoff - mann” and Johann (not Richard) Strauss's “Fledermaus.” These two operas accord ingly were chosen for the first this company's provincial tour. The latest European sensation, Mahler's eighth “symphony,” has just appeared in a version for piano with text included. Ax cording to the Berlin Signale, Mahler has not been idle since completing this work, but has already completed his ninth sym- phony, and got ahead, numerically, of Beethoven, Schubert, and Bruckner, by be ginning his tenth. opera cesses of week of Mahler is the subject of an enthusiasti tribute in the current number of Die Musik (Berlin), in which Dr. George Géhler places him in line with Beethoven, Schubert, Wag- ner, Bruckner, Hugo Wolf, Liszt, and Brahms as one who, scorning sensational advertising methods, is not known in his true greatness to his contemporaries, but will be admired more and more as time goes on. The fact that he calls for a large or chestra, larger even that R. Strauss, and that his works are very long, has caused
Page 22
324 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 look on him as being of the same school This notion Dr. Gohler controverts emphatically A like Strauss, spends years in setting to music manifesta- tions of diseased feelings, can have little in ommon with an artist like Mahler, who writes music in which we hear “a thousand any to man who, voices of nature—of the forest, the ocean, | the starlit nights, the mountain solitudes, of pring, and of ripe summer."’ Mahler uses no programme notes to explain his scores, every one who knows those voices of nature hears them in his music.” yet Art. Die Papstgrddver und die Cédciliengruft in Ger Katakombe des hl. Kallistus. Von Joseph Wilpert. I. Erganzungs- heft zu De Rossi's Roma Sotterranea. Louis: B. Herder. $6.75 net. For the study of the life and beliefs of the first four Christian centuries no field is comparable to the Roman cata- combs. In this field one man, G. B, de ltossi, one of the three or four greatest ircheologists of the nineteenth century, cstablished the criteria of judgment and brought order out of the chaos. His “Roma Sotterranea,” supplemented by numerous periodical studies in his Bul- lettino di Archeologia Cristiana, is the ornerstone of the new science, and per- haps no scholar has ever shown so clear- the mechanism of his methods, so others can apply them to what- ever new material may come to light. Of his immediate pupils two showed especial activity and talent, Henry Ste- venson and O. Marucchi. The brilliant Stevenson's early death and the widen- ng of Marucchi’s studies seemed to l ave the fleld open, and it has been ynown among scholars for many years that a young German archeologist, Mgr. Wilpert, was intending to take up the ork. Wilpert controversy with St. lv ihat into notice through a certain Protestant echolars on the principles of Barly Christian archeology, but particularly ‘hbrough a number of monographs (1889- dealing very thoroughly with certain subjects of the catacomb fres- From these he passed, a few years aco (1903), to a more general work on the “Paintings In the Roman Cata- monumental publication, in plates were remarkably fine Now, as a logical growth mes this of wider scope, in hich topography, history, architecture, culpture, inscriptions, graffiti, paintings all the many-sided themes of Chris- tian antiquity—are treated This volume is the first of a series which Wilpert plans to publish on the as De Rossi's “Roma Sot- terranea,” and as supplementary to It. is so fortunate as to be able to se lect for its matter the two most impor- in the entire came omba,”” a ch the and faithful. volume ‘me scale He monuments tant single | field: the famous Papal Crypt and the | combs, which are among the few bits of neighboring chapel of St. Cecilia, in the territory that in 1870 were left by the Catacomb of Callixtus. When, at the Italian Government in the possession close of the second century, the Apostol- °f the Pope. During the last thir- ie cemetery at the Vatican became too|tY years, partly through lack of small to receive any more burials, it fds in the Papal treasury, very little was decided to prepare a sepulchral | 588 been attempted in the way of ex- crypt in the one official catacomb of the |©@Vating or clearing out catacomb gal- cburch. This was done while it was ad- /eries. The public little realizes how rainistered by the deacon Callixtus, who |™uch still remains undiscovered. It is afterwards became Pope, and who he world in itself, with story on story of gave his name to the catacomb. The S¥Perposed galleries: many that were first Pope to be buried there was An-|¢¥€m known to explorers of the sixteenth teros (+235), closely followed by | Century are now unknown. Fontianus, Fabianus, etc. Nine popes) and several prominent bishops received! Winslow Homer, the artist, died at his Lurial in this crypt during the third cen- | home in Scarboro, Me., last Thursday, aged tury. The body of Pontianus was even Seventy-four years. He was born in Cam- brought back from the Sardinian mines, | »Tidge. At the age of nineteen he was employed in a lithographer’s office, making titles for sheet music and a series of por- traits for the Massachusetts Senate. In 1858 he went to New York and attended a where he had been deported by the Ro- man administration. Parts of the se-| rulchral inscriptions of seven out of the nine popes have come to light, and are given here in facsimile. It is interest- ing that all but one are spelled with Greek instead of Latin letters; and it is | also significant that the title “martyr,” | which we read on several, was not orig- inal, but added later in the century. | Qf course, this Papal crypt has long! been known and was carefully described by De Rossi as one of the most remark- eble records of the early Church, but | Wilpert, especially through discoveries | made in 1909, is able to add considera- | tiy to our knowledge. Contemporary | with the tombs of the popes is the sar- cophagus, for instance, of an historical personage of some importance, Aure-| lius Prosenes, who, though a Christian, was a chamberlain of the emperors | from Commodus to Caracalla. There is a full description of the restorations of Popes Damasus and | Sixtus, by which a more monumental aspect was given to the Papal crypt after the close of the era of persecu- tions. There is also an interesting dis- cussion of two puzzling little monu-| ments above ground—the two three-| apsed chapels which have been thought | | to be rare examples of small places of | worship before the age of Diocletian. | In the opinion of Wilpert, fortified by | excavations, this is not so. The chapels are early, but not earlier than the fourth century, and he believes that one of them marks the martyrdom and burial of Pope Sixtus IJ, and the other the tomb of Pope Zephyrinus. Throughout this part of his work the author in- dulges in controversy to a considerable extent, perhaps more than seems neces- | sary in a work which should aim to) confine itself to accepted facts. His method has the advantage, however, of acquainting us with the different the- cries that have been advanced on sub- jects that are of wide interest to all students of the first Christian centur- les. Perhaps this publication may stimu- late further excavation in the Cata- | night class in the National Academy of De- sign. Two years later he accepted an ap- 'pointment as war artist from Harper Bros., his Prisoners from the Front dating from this g@riod. He received the following prizes :*World’s Fair, in Chicago, first prize; Pittsburgh, 1896, gold medal; Philadelphia Academy of Fine Arts, 1896, gold medal; Paris Exposition, 1900, gold medal; Pan- American Exposition, Buffalo, 1901, Temple gold medal; Philadelphia Academy, 1902, gold medal; St. Louis Exposition, 1904, gold medal, member of the National Academy. In 1866 he assisted in organizing the American Water Color Society. Some of the pictures | devoted to the life of the fisherfolk are, the Life Line, Eight Bells, Danger, All’s Well, Undertow, Watching the Tempest, and Perils of the Sea. Two of Mr. Homer’s pictures are in the Metropolitan Museum of Art; they are The Old Gun in the Havana Har- bor, and The Northeaster. Finance. A CURIOUS MONEY MARKET. Two incidents in the past week’s mo- ney market were of a character which, at this time in certain other years, |; would have impressed the financial mind The /most interesting fact about them, on the present occasion, was that they seemed |to have no effect whatever, cither on ithe money situation of the weck or on | financial sentiment. One was the rise ‘in the Bank of England's official dis- count rate, last Thursday, from 3 per cent. to 4, accompanied by an advance from 4 to 5 in the rate of the Imperial Bank of Germany, and from 4% to 5% in that of the Bank of Belgium. The other was a decrease for the week of ' $12,500,000 in surplus reserves of the New York Associated Banks, bringing the surplus down to $4,900,000. A 4 per cent. London bank rate is not exorbitantly high, but it is higher than is usually reached as early as this in autumn, and is in fact as high a rate |with something like misgiving.
Page 23
Page 24
3524 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2362 look on him as being of the same Gohler controverts like Strauss, any to school This notion Dr emphatically A spends years in setting to music manifesta- tions of diseased feelings, can have little in with an artist like Mahler, who in which we hear “a thousand voices of nature—of the forest, the ocean, the starlit nights, the mountain solitudes, of ripe summer.’’ Mahler uses notes to explain his scores, yet “every one who knows those voices of hears them in his music.” man who, ommon writes musi spring, and of no programme nature A rt. Die Papstgrdder und die Cédciliengruft Aatakombe des hl. Kallistus. Joseph Wilpert. I. Ergiainzungs- zu De Rossi's Roma Sotterranea. St. Louis: B. Herder. $6.75 net. For the study of the life and beliefs of the first four Christian centuries no in der Von heft field is comparable to the Roman cata- combs. In this field one man, G. B, de ltossi, one of the three or four greatest ircheologists of the nineteenth century, tablished the criteria of judgment and order out of the chaos. His Roma Sotterranea,” supplemented by numerous periodical studies in his Bul- leitino di Archeologia Cristiana, is the ‘rnerstone of the new science, and per- haps no scholar has ever shown so clear- lv the mechanism of his methods, so ihat others can apply them to what- brought field: the famous Papal Crypt and the neighboring chapel of St. Cecilia, in the Catacomb of Callixtus. close of the second century, the Apostol- ic cemetery at the Vatican became too |tY years, When, at the) combs, which are among the few bits of territory that in 1870 were left by the Italian Government in the possession of the Pope. During the last thir- partly through lack of small to receive any more burials, it fnds in the Papal treasury, very little was decided to ‘BRepate’ a sepuichral | been attempted in the way of ex — crypt in cbugeh. To inieter: afterwar cave his first Por teros = ( Fomtian: and seve Lurial in tury. Th brought v here h man ad rulehral nine por given he ing that Greek in also sign whieh w inal, bu Of cour been kn: by De R eble rec Wilpert, made in lly to with th: ever new material may come to light. copRagu Of his immediate pupils two showed persona especial activity and talent, Henry Ste- liug Pre venson and O. Marucchi. The brilliant wag @ Stevenson's early death and the widen- from Cx ng of Marucchi’s studies seemed to There ave the field open, and it has been regtorat ynown among scholars for many years Sixtus, that a young German archeologist, Mgr. aspect was intending to take up the | after # Wilpert, ork, Wilpert came into notice through a controversy with certain Protestant cholars on the principles of Barly Christian archwology, but particularly ‘hbrough a number of monographs (1889 97), dealing very thoroughly with certain subjects of the catacomb freg From these he passed, a few yeara! ago (1903), to a more general work on the “Paintings In the Roman Cate a monumental publication, in were remarkably om be, ch the plates sili ited ry g as a logical gro of wider scope, history, architect Now, volume and faithful. this hich topography, culpture, all the many-sided tian antiquity—are treated. This volume is the first of a series hich Wilpert plans to publish on the ‘me seale as De Rossi's “Roma Sot as supplementary to It. as to be able to se two most impor- the entire rranea,” and Me is so fortunate lect for its matter the monuments in tant single i inscriptions, graffiti, paintings | sary fh themes of Chris-| method has the advantage, however, acquainting us with the different the- confine cries that have been advanced on sub- jects that are of wide interest to all students of the first Christian centur- les. Perhaps this publication may stimu- late further excavation in the Cata- PAC MISS @ decrease for the week OL ve ie $12, 500,000 in surplus reserves of the New York Associated Banks, bringing the surplus down to $4,900,000. A 4 per cent. London bank rate is not exorbitantly high, but it is higher than is usually reached as early as this in autumn, and is in fact as high a rate