The Nation 1910-07-14: Vol 91 Iss 2350
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘The Ny tion VOL. XCL—NO. 2350. PRICE TEN CENTS. on THURSDAY, JULY 14, 190% TAKE THE NEWEST AND BEST BOOKS WITH YOU FOR VACATION READING L. M. Montgomery’s By the author of “Anne of Green Gables” and “Anne of Avonlea.” Norval Richardson’s Just Published. Virginia Church’s A novelization of the successful play | of the same name. Reginald W. Kauffman’s By the author of “Miss Baird, Detective.” Frances | | | | Theodore Roberts’s By the author of “Captain Love,” NEW “Kilmeny of the Orchard” “One likes the glowing spirit of youth that pervades this book, the fragrance of the wild cherry lanes, and the Canadian orchard.”—Monthiy Book Review Illustrated, “The Lead of Honor” A powerful novel of Southern life, and its hero many will recognize of whose the bloom of the $1.25 from cloth, young love, scents In the the $1.50 that wi.l attention Hon following one the steadfast arrest Prentiss, of Cloth, a portrait Seargent of the South, always of this fine “silver-tongued orator” theme “Commencement Days” “Combines all the fascinations of college is charmingly told.”—Pittsburg Bulletin, “My Heart and Stephanie” of the surrounding the death of the Rudolph of Austria is unusually well told. It has vivacity and vitality the casual light novel of th« Philadelphia Press. C oth, “A Cavalier of Virginia” It short lead of honor, forms the story which Cloth, $1.50 doings with a real love story “This story mystery Crown Prine beyond hour.” $1.25 “A story which peop‘e will want to read. begun there that Tran- $1.50 80 grips with of the its interest Boston Cloth, having once is no stopping placs end.” script. VOLUMES OF SUMMER TRAVEL Houseboating on a Colonial Waterway By Frank and Cortelle Hutchins An account | holiday spirit, reflecting minds alive —Brooklyn Daily Eagle. Susan in Sicily By Josephine Tozier Author of “It would be no easy book more brimming with merriment and shrewd observa living’ bubbles from every Attractively illustrated, tion. The ‘joy of ton Transcript. A of a summer lazed away to the “Among English Inns.” task to mention a recent James River allurements of natural scenery on a cruise up the “A leisurely narrative, pervaded by the true and eyes open to the charm of new scenes.” m photographs taken specially for the book, cloth, $2.50 In Unfamiliar England By Thomas D. Murphy “British Highways and Byways from a Motor Car I_lustrated fr Author of Written to travel in an entertaining style and few readers will be degree the I lustrated in coior and able turn its pages without in some enthusiasm of its author. experiencing Bos- $2.00 TIMELY NEW ART VOLUME page.” cloth, duogravure, cloth, boxed, $3.00 The Boston Museum of Fine Arts “This volume will be muscum, Published by L. warmly welcomed as a guide affording as it does a descriptive and critical account of its treasures.” C. PAGE & COMPAN By Julia deW. Addison to intelligent appreciation of the contents of the newly Boston Herald illustrated from opened Profusely photographs, boxed, $3.00 53 Beacon St. Boston. =
Page 2
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. Kntered at the New York Oity Poe accond-clasa mail matter.) Office @ The Nation tx and York Evening Post ¢ Williat J Ia Paliter published whet by the New Oswald Garrison Villard, Ir Paul I’resident ttinon Mor ssurer b.imer poatpaid, in or Merico to Canada sed im the ! are per in advance, th / md ft stal Union £4.00 THE NATION, ation Office year nifed Statca foreign countrivsn compri (ddreaws rk Publ Rox 2794, New Yo 0 Veacy Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. rue WEEK ARTICLES: for Able Men reer and Japan in Manchuria Fight on the Colleges Athletic Scholar o« EDITORIAL Looking Russia rhe An ARTICLES: A Study of the Librarians and Mackinac for SPECIAL Jesuits pepenaee rs News Bibliophile 8 CORRESPONDENCE: An American 1832 Library Aatrophel TTTiTT ee \ Free Academy of Graphic Arts... Attendance at French Universities Visitor to Coleridge Restrictions LITERATURI and Younger Choir.-—-The Frozen Grail Other Poems.—The Poems of James Ryder Randall.—Flower o' the Grass.—Monday Morning and Other Poems,—The Enchanted Island and Other Poems.—Odes on the Gen- erations of Men.—New Poems.—The Shadowy Garden and Other Plays. Happy Ending: The Collected Lyrics of Lou Imogen Guiney Mingled W ine Verses and Sonnets Fortune : The Silent Call The Rust of Rome The Professional ‘Tipta Minoa Charlies Sumner at and Greater A Vagabond Journey Aunt firitain Around the tire World DRAMA AND Muar fhe Mystery of Hamlet Prince Denmark AnT Dourlse and the Painters of Greek Vases FINANCE The Recent Decline 43 Rooks or THE Wrest 44 procured tn Opéra; ip 4 Jroafalgar eee; Nation may be 7 Stevens & ‘oples of The Rrentane s rk F Charing Cross Perta at Avenue de Lawion Brown, Square, i0 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., bg ood The Nation. [Vol. g1, No. 2350 Educational. New York, Tarrytown, Box 760. Hackley Lower School (Boys 9 to 13) Situated on an elevation of 500 feet above the Hudson River, twenty-five miles from New York City. Modern facilities for thorough school train- ing with every natural advantage for healthful home life. Prepares for Hackley Upper School. For catalog a illustrations, address AROLD F. AVERY, Director. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co.. Froocteters. 2 A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 203 Mich. Ave., Chicago 611 Swetian d Bid., Portland 406 Cooper Bid., Denver ugiasBid., Angeles 819 Hyde Bid., Spokane 2142ShattuckAve. Barnatey Send to » any address above for Agency Manual. Barn, Mawr, Pennsylvania. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other colleges for women. Smal! classes supplemented by careful indi- vidual instruction. Teachers all thoroughly familiar with Bryn Mawr ulrements. Tennis and basket- ball. Twelfth year opens Oct. 6, 1910. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY jes schools of all grades with competent teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining tions. Send for nee No. 20. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St.,Albany, N.Y BETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL. Bethlehem, Pa. Prepares for leading om THE TEMPLE CLASSICS 233 VOLUMES —— Borron: Ismam. -_~— M.A. qusteaten's decorati title-page, nd ribbon Doskunasts 5 where ‘advisable, editorial PRICES: In cloth, each volume 45 cts. Net In limp leather each volume 65 cts. Net E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 81 WEST 23D STREET. NEW YORK. A new book on Games PLA e GAMES FOR THE KINDERGARTEN, e SCHOOL ROOM AND COLLEGE By Emmett — —— i Fy or*f00's a. Wh A over many rely original. exmes, With over 50 illustrations. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.63 LITTLE, BROWN & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON —— a a “LITTLE BOOKS ON ART.” ARTS OF JAPAN—Dillon ILLUMINATED MSS.—Bradley Each with 40 illustrations. Pocket size, $1.00 net “A veritable library of information.” —Fine Arte Journal. A. ©. MeCLURG & CO., CHICAGO. leges. Catalogue. H. D. Foering, B.S., Principal SHOP PROBLEMS IN MATHEMATICS By Breckenridge, Mersereau and Moore List Price, $1.00. This work is designed to impart to the student information in regard to shops and shop materials in both wood and metal, and to correlate the work of the mathematical classroom with that of the departments of art and science. GINN AND COMPANY Dewey’s How We Think An exposition of the belief that the need- ed steadying and centralizing factor in edu- cation is found in adopting as the end of endeavor the scientific attitude of mind By JOHN DEWEY, Ph.D., LL.D., Columbia University. Cloth. 230 pages. Retail Price, $1.00 D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO OBER AMMBERGAU. accompanies select days’ board at house PASSION PLAY, American lady rsonall party of ten; best tickets; of Anton Lang: (reserved seat); Ist class rail re- turn from Munich; text-book; all tips; $30 in- clusive. Passion Play and driving tour to Royal Castles in Bavarian Highlands, best accommodation; alto gether 4 days, $50 Reference: Rev. W. T. Crocker, Rector of Epis- copal Church of Epiphany, New York City. Ad- dress MRS. VIRGINIE JOURDAN, Leopoldstr 9 Ill, Munich. Do you knowthe Beacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 50 cents net; by mail, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet Small, Maynard & Co. 31 Beacon St, Boston The only biography of the founder of modern Socialism, KARL MARX: HIS LIFE AND WORK, by John Spargo, $2.50 net; $2.70 carriage paid. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth avenue, NEW YORK WILLIAM J. TUCKER’S PERSONAL POWER “Vigorous and wholesome talks to college men.’"—Kaneas Olty Star. “A stimulating vyolume.""—San Francisco Chronicle. TAUCHNITZ FOREIGN pil J BOOKS ft INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS WHY WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! By GEORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth,$1 net, each. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. STENOGRAPHER GEO. B. COCK FRANKLIN BANK BUILDING, PHILADELPHIA Bend for catalogue. SCHOENHOF BOOK CO. 128 Tremont Btreet, BOSTON. MASS. AMERICANS: An Impression | By Alexander Francis. | WANTED—Some recent unbound vols. of The Nation. A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. FOR MANY WEEKS AFTER THE INDEX APPEARS Requests come to this office for additional copies. Therefore we call the attention of our readers to the fact that THE IN FROM JANUARY 1, NDEX TO VOLUME XC 1910, TO JUNE 30, 1910 APPEARED IN THE N ‘ATION OF LAST WEEK
Page 3
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 14, 1910. The Week. Dispatches from Beverly report that the close friends of the President are entirely in the dark as to what “Roosevelt will do.” What this chiefly refers to is the question whether and how far the Colonel will “endorse” the Administration. No one dreams that he will openly attack it, but the fear is that he may conclude to damn it with faint praise. But this is surely to overlook the fact that such a course would be ful- ly as awkward for Roosevelt as for Taft. It must not be forgotten that the Col- onel has his reputation to sustain, not only as a politician but as a prophet. He confidently and repeatedly predicted that Mr. Taft would make one of the best Presidents the country had ever had. After the election of 1908, he issued a special bulletin to the nation congratu- lating it on the supreme wisdom it had shown in accepting the man he had rec- ommended. That work is too recent to be incontinently undone now. And there is another reason why we may expect that Mr. Roosevelt, after he has succeed- ed, with his accustomed deliberation and painstaking inquiry, in putting him- self in possession of the facts, will come out with the heartiest approval of the Administration. He cannot wish to give color to the malicious characterization of him as a man who throws over his friends when they cease to be usefu! to him or actually get in his way. The President’s order of a few days ago withdrawing 8,500,000 acres of wa- ter-power, phosphate, and petroleum lands is now followed by one affecting a still greater area. The new withdraw- al covers no less than 35,000,000 acres of coal lands in North and South Dakota Washington, Utah, Colorado, and Ari- zona; but in this area is included 14, 000,000 acres comprised in withdrawals previously made during the past four years. These latter withdrawals cannot now be disturbed except by express ac- tion on the part of the President or of Congress; whereas in former times a ence on the passage of the bill which importance. have made a happy choice in fixing upon the increase in the duty on manufactures of rubber as an object-lesson in the Senator Bristow appears to 30 to 35 per cent., (Mr. Bristow said 25 to 30), while crude rubber was left on the free list. The House had made no change, but Mr. Aldrich’s Senate com- mittee It doesn’t seem like a very great matter, put the duty up a notch. but 5 per cent. may mean a vast amount to the profits of a Rubber Trust, and tive for the creasing those profits. Our imports of manufactured rubber goods were insig- nificant, even under the old rate, and have fallen still lower under the new, so that revenue could not have been the object; and the claims of anything like legitimate protection must have been satisfied by the old rate, since importa- tion was almost non-existent. The size of the interest involved may be inferred from the fact that the crude rubber im- ported amounts to more than a hundred million dollars’ worth annually. What Mr. Bristow says about the di- |rectorate of the Rubber Trust makes in- A consolidation of |two of the three great rubber companies teresting reading. | became effective November 1, 1909, with the following board of directors: E. B. Aldrich, Nelson W. Aldrich, Her- man B. Baruch, Henry A. Bingham, Daniel Guggenheim, 8. R. Guggenheim, Paul Mor- ton, Allen A. Ryan, William Sproule. | And on December 6 the third of the com- |panies was absorbed, the board of direc- |tors remaining as above, and E. B. Ald- |rich, son of Senator Aldrich, being elect- led vice-president and executive head of the corporation. Evidently, the insurrec- |tion against the Payne-Aldrich tariff is ‘by no means over. No amount of statis- mere order by the Secretary of the In- | tical demonstration that the tariff has terior, which might attract no special attention, was sufficient to undo the act | been revised downward will avail against particular instances of deliberate outrage, of withdrawal. President Taft's insist-| established this condition of things is| thus again shown to have been of signal | ways of Aldrich tariff-making. The duty | on these manufactures was raised from this change from 30 to 35 per cent., | it is difficult to imagine any other mo-| change than that of in-| such as those contained in the changes of the cotton schedule and in the reten tion of the intolerable woollen schedule of the Dingley act. This rubber business is )not so serious as those, from the point of |view of the burden it places on the |people; but it jconnection between protection and mo brings up sharply the nopoly, and the connection between tariff extortion and high Republican politics Direct-primary advocates have always contended that the existence of the sys the effect machine tem would often have of frightening a discredited 80 that it would not dare attempt to foree on the party an unacceptable candidate It looks as though the force of this argu ment were about to be demonstrated in |New Hampshire. Winston Churchill has ‘been waging unceasing war on the Bos ton and Maine Gallinger machine in season and out for the past five years | Twice he has sought the nomination for |Governor, but, despite the fact that he /has both times had more delegates pledg ed to him than any other single candi ‘date, the machine leaders have effected ‘combinations that have defeated him. |But they could not prevent | talking, nor could they prevent a loyal him from and energetic group of men who be | Meved as he did from making their in | fluence felt throughout the State. Final ly, last year, after being thrice beaten by the machine, they succceded in get | ting a State-wide direct primary law on | the statute books. It is to be tried for the ‘first time on September 6. Mr. Churchill \is not a candidate this year, but one of | his associates is, who has been a pro gressive or “insurgent” from the begin jning of the fight against the machine ‘domination. He stands out now as the “Churchill candidate,” seeking the en 'dorsement of his party under the new primary law. And lo! what is happen ing? The machine leaders are one af ter the other throwing up their hands and declaring for him, until now it looks as though he would have little if any seri ‘ous opposition in his own party. Ali of which must be rather pleasing to Mr. Churchill, who more than any one. else has made such an outcome possible. Emil Seidel, the Socialist Mayor of Milwaukee, is like Mr. Gaynor of New
Page 4
24 a Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2350 York in one respect: scarcelya day passes advance we have made in our standards | neys by the slovenly look of village that he does not do some sensible thing in a simple way that no one had thought He a little more than two months, yet the of before has been in office only Republicans and Democrats who proph- esied dire things as a result of his election are joining in his praise. does not act as they thought a Socialist Mayor would act. high regard for his oath of office, and a wholesome respect for the laws and or- dinances of the city, that his Democratic | predecessor, David Rose, never even pretended to have. As a German and a Socialist, he was expected to interpret Yet under his con- trol the total number of saloons has been the laws “liberally.” cut down considerably by the refusal of licenses to a long list of places which have been notoriously ailowed to break in the past the excise regulations with impunity. Last week a hundred of these “protected” places closed their doors in despair. Mayor Seidel is enforcing the liquor laws in the restricted districts—a feat which was supposed to be impos- sible. that He has just now made it clear the Johnson-Jeffries fight-pictures will not be tolerated in Milwaukee. In many ways, he has bettered conditions Yet his methods are far “a he declares. “I prefer to ask And I think that will re- in his city. from militant. don't like to issue orders,” for coéperation. the desired generally accomplish sults.” If this be Socialism, make the most of it! In offering to President Hadley of Yale the chairmanship of the commis- He | fe seems to have a) of appointment. { Promotion of common transportation and commerce, and pres- ervation of good relations between all the countries concerned by adherence to the principle of arbitration, are, of course, the burden of Secretary Knox's “instructions to our delegates to the Pan- American Conference. In making partic- ular mention of Nicaragua, he is formal- ly justified by the circumstance that there has been a discontinuance of dip- lomatic relations between the United States and that country, but, of course, Mr. Knox’s real object is to present the grounds on which our recent policy to- ward Nicaragua has been based, and to invite the sympathy of the other Pan- American delegates for our present at- titude in the premises. He sets up a con- trast between the situation in Nicaragua ‘and that existing in “the progressive American republics, with stable govern- ments and high ideals for such govern- |ments,” and expresses entire confidence ‘that these republics have not miscon- strued our position. Explicitly the sub- ject can hardly come up at the confer- fence, since it is not included in the programme, and would require a two- |thirds vote to be introduced. Moreover, the invitation extended to Mr. Henry |White, chairman of our delegation, to make the response on behalf of Pan- America to the opening address by the |Argentine Minister of Foreign Affairs, lis hardly consistent with the possibility of any widespread desire to challenge the position of the United States. interests in sion created by the new interstate com- | merce act to investigate the stock and | bond issues of railways, President Taft has made a choice of the highest excel- It is to be hoped that Dr. Hadley will find it possible to accept the offer. Such an inquiry as is proposed for the commission depends for its usefulness on a combination of unquestioned impar- tiality with high special ability such as it Is dificult to obtain. In Dr. Hadley, these requirements are fully met. He has made a lifelong study of railway questions, and is an acknowledged au- thority upon them; and his broad knowl- edge of economics in general would be of the utmost value in giving direction An Irish Mayor calling upon the fas- tidious Puritans of Boston to clean up their city physically, and pointing out \that their growing habit of throwing lit- |ter and refuse into the streets is giving |the New England metropolis a bad name for its dirty appearance, is a spectacle ‘not without its humorous aspects. The thing he strikes at is, however, serious ‘enough; and it is not the withers of Boston alone that are wrung. Pv»lic un- tidiness is a national fault. It is more noticeable in cities, by its massing there, than elsewhere, but even the roadsides in the “sweet, pure country” are often | terribly unkempt and have the air of be- streets and by the appalling amount of waste matter everywhere flung about. We have so long been used to having all out-doors in which to throw things that we are in danger of forgetting how much like the neighborhood of a Zulu kraal we often make our outlying regions “appear. Gov. Harmon, in his energetic pro- ceeding in the Newark lynching case, is making use of the law which holds lo- cal authorities responsible for such out- breaks as recently took place in that city. The Ohio statutes provide the Gov- ernor with all the power he needs. Al- ready he has suspended the Mayor of Newark under authority of a law which has been on the statute books for a dec- ade but has never before been enforced. He is proceeding against the sheriff of Licking County under another statute | (the Eubanks act) which was passed |only a year ago and applies specifically to failure to protect prisoners from \lynchers. This law is explicit and man- |datory in ite provisions. Under it the Governor must suspend a sheriff from _whose custody a prisoner is taken and \lynched. The author of the law, a ne- gro member of the Legislature from ‘Cleveland, drew it to fit such cases of negro lynching as took place a year or ‘so ago at Springfield. But it is now to be first enforced in connection with the lynching of a white man. It is conceiv- able that the Eubanks law, like that pro- ‘viding for the suspension of mayors, |might have been evaded or ignored. But Gov. Harmon is meeting the situation | squarely, and will give a wholesome demonstration in Ohio of the responsi- ‘bility of local authorities for the en- forcement of law and the preservation ‘of order. There is another law, seldom invoked, which is to be vitalized for this joccasion. This is the mob-violence llaw, by which Licking County becomes ‘Mable in the sum of $5,000 for the ‘death of the lynched man. The rigid _enforcement of these laws ought to have a salutary effect, and Gov. Harmon will deserve the thanks of law-abiding peo- ple everywhere for showing how the law can really be made a terror to evil-doers. The National Education Association, to the Investigation. That the President's | ing made a convenient dumping-ground. | for the first time in its forty-eight years choice should have fallen on such a man| Mr. H. G. Wells, when in this country, of existence, has elected a woman as its is another instance of the immeasurable ane much struck in his railway jour |president. The event is the more notable
Page 5
July 14, 1910] The Nation. = from the nature of the claim on which the choice of Mrs. Ella Flagg Young by the delegates was based—the extraordi- nary distinction of having been chosen as superintendent of public schools in the second greatest of American cities, and the efficiency she has shown in the conduct of that office. If more points were needed to emphasize the character of the event, two might be mentioned, to show how far we are from the days—not long back by the ordinary count of time —when the idea of a woman accomplish- still One is that Mrs. Young obtained a university training in middle life, getting the de- gree of Ph.D. at the University of Chi- cago at the age of fifty-five; the other is that, while she has been placed ut ing great practica: results was strange in most people’s minds. the head of the educational system vf Chicago in recognition of exceptional qualifications, the foremost figure in tha work of social improvement in the same city is also a woman. And Jane Addams, even more distinctly than Mrs. Young. opened for herself the path to extraor- dinary usefulness. The death of Dr. Rolfe, even though not unexpected, con- William James sidering his advanced age, will come as a shock to students of English litera- ture both here and abroad. For the po- which Dr. much the same as that held by the late Dr. Furnivall. sition Rolfe occupied was Both were scholars of untiring activity and enthusiasm, al- though the positive achievement of nei- ther was of the sort which is termed bril- liant. Both, too, did a vast amount to make the pursuit of letters seem wor- thy and attractive to younger men, and left a heritage of loving devotion to scholarly interests which will not soon be forgotten. It is doubtless as an edi- tor of Shakespeare that Dr. Rolfe is best known, his little brick-colored volumes being as familiar to students throughout the country to-day as, or rather more familiar than, the family Bible. As a scholar, he ranged widely over English literature, editing many of the poets be- sides Shakespeare. He contributed fre- quently to newspapers and magazines, and the Nation particularly was glad to profit from his minute knowledge otf books. His letter “Lest We Forget,’ published in the Nation only two weeks ago, is typical of his habitual method of exacting search for the truth. The World of New York has printed a clear and circumstantial statement, by Representative Martin of Colorado. of the charges relating to the sales of friar lands in the Philippines. It was Mr. Mar- tin agitation of the the appointment whose subject brought about of a Congressional committee to investigate the whole subject; and his statement in the World will reads it with the necessity of such in- vestigation. Whether the he will be substantiated in quiry remains to be seen; but it cannot impress any one who charges makes upon be denied that they are clear, straight- forward, and specific. That the provision of the organic law of the Philippines forbidding the disposal of more than 2,500 acres of the public domain to any corporation was interpreted by Secre tary Wickersham as inapplicable to the friar lands, though there seems to be no sound reason why it should be so in- applicable; that this was to the benefit of the Sugar Trust; that the character of the sale of 55,000 acres of the friar land in the San José estate was conceal- ed through the use of a dummy as pur chaser; that, after inquiry began, re- sort was had to various shifts of eva- sion and denial; that even if Mr. Wick- ersham’s opinion was correct, another provision of the organic law forbids the holding of more than 2,500 acres of land by that this provision is evaded by the land be any agricultural corporation; ing in the names of individuals connect- ed with the Sugar Trust—these and oth- er charges are set forth in Mr. Martin's statement. One of the greatest difficulties stand- ing in the way of a peaceful compromise on the House of Lords is the lack of a definite scheme for modifying the com- position or organization of that House. Hence, a suggestion on this point made editorially by the London Economist 1s decidedly interesttng. Under the plan it brings forward, the membership of the House would be left undisturbed; the double object of correcting its party one- sidedness and of improving its working quality would be accomplished by a del- egation of the powers of the House to a legislative committee of 100 or 150 mem- bers. Even the “wild Peers’ would not be excluded from the right of speaking upon any question on which they might wish to be heard; but the anomaly would be avoided of a host of members -_ , > 2 who are habitually absent from the House, and who have given no serious attention to public questions, rushing in to vote on grand occasions and over the The method of choice of this committee whelming body by their numbers. which would completely take the place House so far as action is be both of the entire concerned—would designed to put the two great parties on an equal of ability, the plan being that each party of footing and to secure a high order should elect one-half the committee, while the Government of the day would have power to “add siightly to its mem- bers.” The campaign against depopulation is almost as old in France as the fact of depopulation itself. Its results have not been encouraging. Till within a year or two ago, there was a trifling margin of births over deaths; this has now dis appeared, and France faces actual, as well as comparative, retrogression. Nev ertheless, the agitation for larger fam ilies goes on. A bill just introduced in the Senate, and supported by men like Léon Bourgeois, Alexandre Ribot, Rich Alfred Francis Charmes, sought to combine ard Waddington, Méziéres, and the various schemes that have been sug- the problem, is gested for dealing with The underlying principle to combat depopulation through the state’s em ployees, who constitute so large a part of the population. The bill provides that no employee of the state over the age of twenty-five shall be retained in the ser- vice if unmarried. If a government em- ployee is the father of at least three liv ing children, he shall have preference in promotion and receive an annual bounty of 200 frances for every child after the third and under the age of fifteen. Civil service pensions will provide a bounty of 100 frances annually for every child third. It vided that every Frenchman who is un- after the is furthermore pro- married at the age of twenty-nige shall be called upon to render extra military The laws regulating the distribution of per- service for a long ierm of years. sonal estates at death will be repealed. Here is a comprehensive programme which, in spite of the seriougness of the situation that has called it forth, stands little chance of enactment. Its drastic thoroughnees is almost as characteristi cally national as the fact of depopula- tion itself.
Page 6
26 LOOKING FOR ABLE MEN. In severa) States just now there is a sort of Diogenes search not for merely honest but for able men in public life. Massachusetts is said to have gone so sterile in statesmen that there is no one to stand against Senator Lodge except In Pennsylvania the rival the scarcely known outside their own coun- Butler Ames. nominees for Governorship are ties,and are without much honor there; while in Ohio the Republicans are sore put to it to find a man to run against Gov. Harmon who shall not appear ridic- by The New York is reduced need only For months the anxiety ulous comparison. straits to which be of politicians has been to discover a suc- mentioned. cessor to Gov. Hughes who should not provoke all over the State Hamlet’s in- cignant question,“What judgment would step from this to this?” Now, from all this seeming dearth of of leading, at the very time when they are said to be most in men capable demand, it would be rash to conclude that Ability is one thing, and the emergence of able men in public life is quite another. The lat- ter is more a matter of chance or doubt The conditions tem- they do not exist. than the former. porarily affecting government service may so discourage citizens with high talent for it that they do not come for- ward—are perhaps not allowed to come forward. Complaints that we were with- out a supply of vigorous and compelling statesmen have often been heard in this country; sometimes, just on the eve of a new flowering of political genius. In delivered “The Independent in Politics,” in which 1888, Lowell his lecture on he referred to the “growing doubt” whe. ther we were not losing the power to produce men of real initiative and prac- tical sagacity in the sclence of govern- ment belle ve Hiis conclusion was, however: “7 that there is as much of the of statesmanship among but the raw material there duties the us AR ever levied was, by local rings of majority manufacturers are so high as to pro hibit ite entrance into competition with the protected article.” Similarly to-day no competent observer really questions of the is to render the career the existence political talent; main difficulty for it open. Without fortable but fallacious assurances that falling back upon the com the hour always produces the man, the The Nation [Vol. 91, No. 2350 crisis the hero, we may yet gain a cer- | tain confidence from noting that we do now and then find hid treasure in un- expected places; that men whose fame becomes nation-wide start up suddenly out of obscurity. The country is just now called upon to mourn a Chief Jus- tice who had been for twenty-two years at least a capable head of our highest Yet when he was appointed the scornful cry was pretty general in the “Who is this man Fuller?” Be- fore, when President Grant named a Chief Justice, it had been: “Who is this The two cases show that court. press: man Waite?” we have undeveloped resources of abil- Take the in- Ten years ity as well as minerals. stance of Hughes himself. ago he was absolutely unknown, except to a small circle of friends who were aware of his extraordinary powers. But that they should ever be put at the ser- vice of the public appeared then wholly improbable; and that they really came to be must be regarded as in the na- ture of a political accident. Yet it is entirely credible that ability like his exists in many a law-office, or in some study or counting-room, which we could draft for government work if we only knew how to find it and set it free. True genius is said infallibly to fight its way to the front, in politics as every- where else. This, of course, is merely to confuse genius with success; yet we are bound to take knowledge of the fact that able men with honorable political ambition have the struggle made easier for them by examples of success—or of failure. The trail which Hughes has blazed is so plain that even a wayfaring New York politician cannot err therein. Any man in the State who aspires to rise to anything like the popularity and the power that Gov. Hughes has conquered, cannot fail to see along just what road opportunity beckons. And, conversely, in Massachusetts, the present intense dis- like of Lodge and the search for a real Senator to displace indicate the things that must be avoided if a secure place in the honor and affection of that) State is to be won. Should the coming contest result in the election of a Sena- tor as little in the public eye now as Sumner was when first chosen, he would | know, from the unpopularity of Mr. Lodge, that Massachusetts desired a rep- | resentative in the United States Senate | who would treat his work there with | less of the air of a literary trifler, and | him who would not wreak so much of his strength upon the creation of a personal machine that he had little left for the drudgery of legislation. Among the circumstances that help to bring forward extraordinary men is dissatisfaction with the commonplace type. Discontent is often, even in poli- tics, a condition of achievement. And it is evident that there never was a time when the people were more out of humor with the ordinary run of politi- cians than they are to-day. The very fact that the electors are so generally looking for public servants who shall tower like Saul from the shoulders and upwards above the hacks and the time- servers, is a ground for hope that such exceptional men will be found. Certain- ly, the appeal and the rewards were never greater in our public life. This being so, we may reasonably expect that here and there throughout the country men of unusual ability will grasp the skirts of circumstance and show to their grateful fellow-citizens that there is a sure reserve among us of courage and force to apply to our governmental prob- lems. RUSSIA AND JAPAN IN MANCHURIA Behind the Russo-Japanese conven- tion which was signed at St. Petersburg on Monday of last week, rumor persists in scenting a treaty of alliance between the two nations. It is not necessary to accept such an hypothesis as a fact in order to recognize that harmonious rela- tions between the two late antagonists in the Far East are now clearly reéstab. lished. Against the probability of a Russo-Japanese defensive and offensive alliance are the two reasons that such an arrangement is neither necessary, nor, at such a short remove from the Treaty of Portsmouth, conceivable. Al- liances are not cemented as rapidly as the political wiseacres would have us believe. It is one thing for a defeated nation to accept the results of war as a fait accompli. It is another thing for two combatants to execute a com- plete about-face and join hands for war against those who are now their friends. For that is what an alliance necessarily means. It must be an alliance against somebody, whether that somebody be nominated in the bond or left to be un- mistakably understood. But, in spite of all that has been said about the cool- ing friendship between Japan and Great
Page 7
July 14, 1910] The Nation. Britain, it is unimaginable that the lat- a very natural procedure. True, there is a clause in the agreement which to the suspicious eye might suggest some- thing like an alliance. It is provided that “in case events occur of such a na- ture as to menace the status quo, the contracting Powers will enter into com- munication, with the object of agreeing est convention between Japan and Rus- on measures for the maintenance of the status quo.” But it is necessary only to sia for just what it purports to be—an i turn to the Takahira agreement between agreement for friendly codperation in this country and Japan to find anal- Manchuria, where the two Powers hold ogous proof of a Japanese-American al- so predominant a position. The com- liance: “Should any event occur threat- pact is the latest step in a series of ening the status as above described, or agreements following upon the Treaty the principle of equal opportunity as of Portsmouth. That instrument left important commercial and other eco governments to communicate with each nomic questions for later settlement. ch ; ai , ; r in order to arrive ¢ Among these was the Pacific fisheries P wi , net cule . a a F S “s question, which was disposed of in the P he 4 ihe : ine yi a peas convention of July 30, 1907, the terms we wa i ener _ - eee of which are now explicitly reaffirmed. ran pastries A “ “~ ang pe at , The complexities of the Far Eastern sit- Oe ” ways. uation require that, in any formal agree- ba bet — — ment between two Powers, the basic oth say v9 oo a ri pein principles of China’s territorial integ- OF CEO Waee See Che paerents Aaner ican trade in Manchuria, it is no treason rity and of equal opportunity for all na- " + nt the 6 - tions shall be reiterated. This was done eae ; ee in 1907, and is done again to-day. It is ets i ae . a formula; but in the absence of spe- ainialiensains tions can cause only the widest satis- cific evidence of an intention on the part faction. That the two nations mean to of the contracting parties to violate its discriminate against American enter- terms, the formula must be accepted as as Ot masa ais th sufficient. It is a formula that we meet |>™#° '™ Mancauria has yet to be prov: ed. That the two nations have turned in all diplomatic arrangements regard- their backs on all wild talk of a re- ing China. It occurs in the 1907 agree- sumption of hostilities in the Far East ment between Japan and France and in , etnies hiehel Te the exchange of notes between this coun- : ays maaan P : 2 ‘ ° try and Japan in November, 1908. Fol- ERED DRG) may cemuenes te Caren , and lowing upon Japan’s arrangements with , , presi France and the United States, this new POCHEEE IAG CURSE Sor Rew VeRWeED in Manchuria. The two Governments agreement with Russia comes, evidently . elk aed a viene not as a menace to the peace of the i — ha 2 aviga sis ye pa world, but as the latest link in a chain ma a, ny “haan OF. a of international ententes that are work- again, at the risk of stirring up anew the fires of revolution. Japan needs ing decidedly for peace. time to assimilate what she has already The Russo-Japanese agreement of won. There is significance, for instance, July 30, 1907, left the Manchurian rail- in the fact that the ways question undisposed of. With this agreement with Russia should come al- subject the present convention deals. If the anxious gaze of a critic discerns therein only another “of a series of doc- uments by which the two Powers seek to apportion Manchuria for exploitation by themselves to the exclusion of other na- tions,” proof of this must be directed to- ward specific acts and policies. The fact remains that Russia and Japan are con- tiguous railway owners in Manchuria, and that the formulation of an harmo- nious railway policy between the two is ter should be the Power Japan aims at. For one thing, Russia would be a broken reed to Japan in a contest with England. For another thing, Russia and Great Britain are now on the most amicable terms. It is safest, therefore, to take the lat- above defined, it remains for the two - an under- For that reason the steady in Russo-Japanese rela- a war of revanche, the Japanese conclusion of an most simultaneously with the complete assumption by Japan of the task of pre- serving order in Korea. The latter step has been regarded as tantamount, or at least as preliminary, to annexation. That Russia, far from protesting, should be engaged in treaty-making with the mas- ter of Korea, shows how completely the Czar’s Government has accepfed the re sult of the late war. — aU 6 THE FIGHT ON THE COLLEGES “There is no spectacle in American life today more pitiful than the con trast between what the college adver- tises to do and what it performs.” “The teaching by our college professors is the poorest in the country.” “The aver- age third-year boy in the high school ts more able to think, discuss, and express an idea than the average college stu- dent two years older.” “The young man learns in college that he need not work, he comes to regard his college as a so- cial and sporting club.” “Colleges with their narrow and false ideals of culture, their domination has reached a degree of intolerable impertinence. “The high schools in desperation have been drawing a line of cleavage between those fitting for college and those who are not. This is unnecessary, unfitting, and undemocratic.” These are not extracts from an article in a muckraking magazine; they are tak- en from two addresses delivered last week at the meeting in Boston of the department of secondary education of the National Education Association; one by the principal of a New York high school, the other by the State superintendent of public schools in Wisconsin. What was in view in the last of the above quota- tions may be judged from a resolution, almost unanimously adopted at the meet. ing, declaring in favor of the recogni- tion as electives in college-entrance re- quirements “of all subjects well taught in the high schools”; some of the sub jects especially mentioned in the pream ble being manual training, “commercial branches,” and agriculture, and the re- quirement of two languages other than English being expressly objected to. And the situation presented both by the ad- dresses from which we have quoted, and by the resolutions adopted with virtual- ly no dissenting vote, is one with which our college presidents, and all persons interested in college education, will do well to reckon promptly and seriously. For that situation represents the cul- mination of a wave of criticism and rest- lessness which in large measure owes its strength and volume to what we can- not but feel has been a want of percep- tion, on the part of many of our leading college presidents especially. To be con- scious, of deficiencies, ready to admit them and anxious to remedy them, is one thing; it is quite another thing to assume a position of apologetic defence,
Page 8
Ss ) talk as though the faults of the col- lege were all there was in the institu- to declare that the college is use- it devotes itself to a task than that for which it has past. Yet this is essentially tion, unless less other quite stood in the attitude in which a number of our leading college presidents have allowed themselves to be placed. They should have hardly think they can have actually realized it—that such talk is this means not the improvement of known—we the college, but its abolition; not great- efficiency in attaining the aims to has historically been devoted, of School superintendents and high-school vhich it but the abandonment those aims. principals who regard the ideals of cul- ture nourished at our colleges as “nar- row and false,” may perhaps be right; they at least have the courage of their onvictions when they say so. But what is when college presidents and oth is quite certain that the time has ome not prepared to accept this ers who are loctrine should look the question in the face and show the courage of their con- victions also. Now, in simple truth, a great deal of the talk about colleges by such persons t! from whom we have quoted is as IOs merely rubbish. There are, of course, young men who go to college and don't vork but to talk as though this were true of all of them, or of a majority of them, is to fly in the face of the sim- plest observation. The greater part of the young men in our colleges work as hard at their studies as can reasonably be expected. As for the superiority of the third-year high-school boy to the col- lege youth two years older, this is, of ourse, & mere ex parte assertion. And terrible hardship of differentiating between courses designed to be followed the by a college training and those that are not reste, so far as we can see, upon the idea that a college has no rights that a It objects which a col- democrat is bound to respect. be that the pursues are true may not lege worth pursuing; but so long as it does pursue them, it must of necessity demand, on the part of entering students, such preparation as is necessary for their attainment. On the subject of the injury done to secondary schools by the dominant part played by college entrance exdminations The taking the examinations into might reasonably be said. of account much need does unquestionably hamper | a [Vol. 91, No. 2350 ee many an earnest and enthusiastic teach- tion. er, and prevents him from giving to his students all that he might give through a freer play of his individuality. probable that ways and means might be found by colleges to lessen this evil. But to which these out- bursts of hostility or contempt direct attention is far deeper than this. They touch not college methods, but college They challenge the underlying idea of college education. And they are but a proclamation, in plain language and in loud tones, of what has been vaguely implied or timidly or uncon- sciously expressed in many an utter- ance of men in the highest places in the college world. Like all human in- stitutions, the American college is full of imperfections; like them all, it has to undergo change with the passage of But it should not bow humbly to the question aims. time. every passing wind of popular doctrine. It has a history of which it has ample reason to be proud; it has deserved well of the country, and the work that it has been doing there is still need for it to do. Agricultural schools, indus- trial schools, technological schools, have | and other | grown up alongside of it, kinds of schools may be equally neces- sary, and may mect the needs of a far | greater number of individuals. There is no compulsion on any one to go to college, nor is it desirable that every one should have a college education. But | out of the thousands who have had this opportunity, a very large proportion have derived from it something that they could not otherwise have got, some- | thing that they have prized as an in- valuable possession to themselves, and that has supplied to the country an element without which American life would have been im- Nor do the confi- something measurably poorer. dent but reckless assertions of educa- | tional muckrakers furnish any reason for believing that the day of its useful- ness Is past, or for abandoning that spir- it of loyalty to the traditions of culture which, until very recently, has been the general possession of our college men. AN ATHLETIC SCHOLAR. Dr. Frederick J. Furnivall, whose death we had to record last week, had been for two generations a frequenter of the reading-room of the British Museum, Perhaps no scholar of the age was 80 widely acquainted and so generally be- It is) lloved. He added to the diligence of the text-critic the enthusiasm of the admin- istrator. Publishing societies sprang up in his wake. The Barly English Text Society, the New Shakespeare Society, the Chaucer, Browning, and Shelley So- cieties represent merely a part of his activities in this field. As general edi- tor for these bodies he associated with himself the best talent of England, America, and the Continent. Toward his fellow-workers he was of unfailing helpfulness. Stationed at the British Museum, he was the eyes for scores of students and their ultimate court of ap- peal. A sound instinct led him to lay chief stress upon the literal reproduc- tion of manuscripts. The work done under his charge is of permanent value, since it avoids both the dilettantism of the Old English publishing societies and the perverse ingenuity of the German compilers of bedevilled texts miscalled critical. The judgment of the man was as remarkable as his friendliness and diligence. His personality was indomitably pic- turesque. In the sober precincts of the British Museum his ruddy face and sil- ver hair and beard, surmounting a searlet tie, were about the most stimu- lating spectacle there offered. A life- time spent largely in the close labor of reading proofs and collating manu- scripts had not subdued him. Toward his antiquarian researches he kept an ‘always fresh romantic enthusiasm. In the unpublished records and literature \of old England he saw a duty to be ful- filled, but what really fascinated him was the glimpse of a life more racy, freer from cant, more variously interest- ing than our own. The sense that we |\may learn much from what we regard as the crude conditions of our English ‘ancestors he expressed in a hundred prefaces. It was a faith that he shared with William Morris, a conviction that made him throw himself into Ruskin’s movement for a working man’s college. |Many will regret that he never publish- ed at length his opinions on the exem- \plary value of medieval crafts. A life spent in superintending and often in do. ing other men’s work made such a study impossible. Perhaps it was better, af- ter all, to strike a spark here and there amid the dry material of scholarship. A part of Dr. Furnivall’s youthfulness of spirit was due to his love of the open. There was no more familiar figure on
Page 9
July 14, 1910] The Nation. the Thames above Richmond, or, in sum- mer-time, on the Isis. As he sculled vig- orously past he was smilingly greeted as Father Thames. Characteristically, he combined his favorite recreation with a philanthropy. For years he directed a rowing club for shop-girls. By way of this club some of his foreign associates have made a perplexed entrance into! English society, for it was not Dr. Fur- nivall’s way to vouchsafe unnecessary explanations. When his friends desired to celebrate his seventieth birthday they naturally provided the customary Fest- schrift, but they could think of no more acceptable personal gift to add than a Clasper double scull. Some of them had the good luck to occupy the forward seat, and we warrant it was no easy task to follow the stroke of the octo- genarian host. He was an unconven- tional spirit, with a vivid sense of real- ity. His very writing had something bristling about it; his zest, more rarely, his scorn, through the orderly surface of his ar- gument; he was Volcanic after the fine Victorian tradition. Yet with the friend- liness he so readily showed to all com- ers, he was essentially a reserved man. His contacts were by preference pro- fessional, but surely there was scope enough for delightful if impersonal in- timacies in a profession that comprised all English antiquity. For many a visit- ing scholar the pleasantest thing in Lon- don was to stroll out from the Museum and take tea with Dr. Furnivall. Now that he is gone, the pull of the great city will be for scores of his associates or, frequently sensibly weakened. By a sort of irony, his least valuable work is that which most fully enlisted his arfor—his Shakespearean investiga- His real monument is the publi- He not tions. cations of the Chaucer Society. merely accomplished almost single-hand- ed the editing of the chief manuscripts, but arranged the reprints with utmost ingenuity to serve the ends of compart- son. Of its sort, the work is definitive, and Dr. Furnivall’s name will not be forgotten until Chaucer himself fails to attract scholars. A STUDY OF THE JESUITS. Paris, July 1. “Les Jésuites” (Armand Colin, 387 pages, 4 francs) is a French transla- tion of the German work of H. Boehmer, professor at the University of Bonn. It broke | demands particular mention because of the eighty pages of introduction and the notes by Gabriel Monod of the Insti- tut de France. These constitute a verit- able pronouncement: A very large number of questions of re- ligious history remain little or ill-known In the front rank of the ill-known should be placed the history of of Jesus. Hardly ever has it been spoken of with serenity and impartiality; and nothing is more difficult than to know its history with exactness (vi, vii). the Society Professor Monod's Protestant heritage, nis relation to Michelet, his work on the Revue Historique, his two dozen years of forming university professors of history in the famous Ecole Normale, his lectures at the Collége de France and practical instruction at the Ecole des Hautes Etudes, and countless writings of historical research have given him a unique position among students of history. Little or much as one may agree with him, the initiative he has taken 30 courageously is sure to have conse- ‘quences far beyond the present signifi- cant, but still essentially defective, work. In truth the fact so frankly acknowl- edged by Professor Monod enters into a larger fact of immensely wider import. The particular existence of the So- ciety of Jesus comprises altogether less ‘than four centuries; and it has never been more than a single phenomenon of the general existence of the Church in which the Roman Catholic religion is embodied. Its birth ann in- heritance from the past, its principles, inspiration, and practice, its works, con- flicts, triumphs, and defeats, are only subordinate incidents in the history of Roman Catholicism. It is not too much to say that all such history—and not that of the Jesuits alone—-has regular- ly been written tor edification or for controversy, always by a friend or by a foe, never by Plato's of all time and all existence.’ Professor Monod assigns to the Society of Jesus, for the whole course of its history, “millions of members.” From his own and Professor Boehmer’s scattering statistics, it is mathematically impossible there should have been one half-million of Jesuit priests all told from the foundation of the order until now, while students be longing to the order (who are apt to be counted twice, since vhey regularly be- came priests), and lay have not been numerous enough to make up with the priests a single million in the four centuries, The total] number for any one year, in times of prosperity and ac- tive foreign missions, has ranged from 10,000 to 25,000. These are the only Jes- uits whose existence has been sanction- ed by the church in the constitutions of the society. Professor Monod lays too much stress on the in which the Jesuit ar- chives are kept: “No one, outside of the Society, knows even where they are to “spectator brothers secrTrec y 29 be found” (vii). As a matter of fact, it is surprising how much of the matter in the volumes which the society itself is now publishing of its history in Spain France, Germany, and Italy is drawn from sources accessible to any student properly prepared for the study of such subjects. Yet the singularly incomplete bibliography in the present work notes this as “a sort of official history of the society, composed from documents of its archives and of very scientific charac. ter.” Professor Boehmer has used the only volumes yet published in his chap ters on the early society, after he skips over whole centuries, perhaps from lack of material. Fundamental works, such as Suarez's “De Religione Societatis Jesu,” seem not to have been consulted by Professors Boehmer and Monod. They even leave aside the form ula Quicumque (“Whoso wishes to serve as a soldier under the standard of the Cross”), which was presented to the Pope by Ignatius of Loyola and inserted in the bull of approbation as express ing the essence of the Society of Jesus Perhaps the most striking effort made by Professor Monod to be fair the Jesuits is found in his section on “casu- istry and their moral teaching” (xliv- lii). This is the oldest and most no torious subject of controversy in Jesuit history. Traces of it are found in the English king’s public repudiation at his coronation of all “evasion, equivocation, mental reservation,” or any possible Pope’s “dispensation” for calling him- self a Protestant without really being which to so; in Shakespeare’s Macbeth, where Maeterlinck (like Voltaire, a Jesuit college boy) turns English “equivo cator” into French “jésuite’; in the popular idea that a Jesuit is a man holding that the end jus tifles any means; in the Terror of the French Revolution when a partisan of Robesplerre with em ploying “Jesuitical means”; down to the French political elections of May, 1919, when Professor Painlevé of the Institut de France, to win his seat in Parlia ment, hurled against the rival candi date as his last electioneering epithet— triste et repugnant jesuite was charged Boehmer's text of his elsewhere there In all this Professor shows little understanding sub ject, and here enormous gaps in his knowledge of the facts. Professor Monod recognizes that casuistry is not an the Jesuits; that it is not enough to bring into Parliament, Bert did, a manual of moral theology written by a Jesuit but used the world over in count less Catholic seminaries where no Jesu its teach, and to extracts chosen baldly from it ‘Morale Jésuites”’; and that there have casuistes lazvistes like Alphonse Liguori who were not Jesuits Bert's manuals, by the way, Liguori technically, between as are invention of as ,Paul ever style des been de Paul classify “proba
Page 10
30 biliorists” and “probabilists,” as an equi-probabilist,” whereas a “laxist” in their sense ought to be an extreme prob- abilist; the manuals admit the probabilis opinio (which Professor Monod limits to the anti-Catholic con- troversial sense approuvable) only where there is no certain knowledge on which to base a judgment of what is right and what is wrong. A thousand years before Jesuits existed this had been a universal axiom in law—Lez in- erta non obligat. Newman has intro- duced Liguori to English readers in his “Apologia”; and the Anglican Bishop Butler long before familiarized English thought with probability as the guide of life; John Stuart Mill insists on the of probable judgments as es- sential in all moral sciences, while in Pascal's “Provinciales” would to Dr. Johnson equally with and and use much apply Jesuits. Professor Boehmer is faithful to the habits of mind against which Pro- fessor Monod’s Introduction is a pro- test. Liguori’s canonization (1839) and hie elevation to the rank of Doc- tor of the Church (1871) have “conse- crated officially the traditional methods of the society's casuistry, as models for the science of moral theology”; and these two events are for him “results of the indefatigable activity of the or- der” (page 283). This ignores the rival society of Redemptorists, founded by Liguori himself, and, from the history of Bismarck'’s Culturkampf, apparently active enough to take care of its own glories. But—and this is the real les- son for all who can read between the lines of Professor Monod’s Introduction Jesuits still crop up as the deus ez all controversies, political religious alike, Roman machina in and against Catholics In the particular history of Jesuits, distinct from that of Roman Catholics eneral, the chief value of the present again to be found in Professor od's few pages. Even he uses, though the controversial word French Catholics call the English that is, the person who follows the of St s not so bad as Carlyle cast into certain magical “exer it makes a mystery of commonplace wherever their ministry of “re- “missions.” Even Catholic writers have not noticed the historical descent of John Wesley's “revivals” from such retreats and missions. It ia probably due to preconceived gen eral principles that neither Professor Monod nor Professor Boehmer adverts something which drew the attention of Sir James Mackintosh a century ago and appears in our own time in the dl- rection given by Leo XIII to Catholic po- litical teaching, namely, the intreduction Mor th apologies, for what ererct tifant and piritual exercises” Ignatius Loy i This Wernet tations but something very Jesuits perform treat or to The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2350 into modern thought by Jesuit authors like Suarez, in spite of the determined opposition of Sorbonne and Parlements, of a fundamental modern idea. This is that, however much all authority may come from God, all national sovereignty receives its authority through the peo- ple. The influence of such Jesuit writ- ers on European thought from James) I of England to Grotius, seems unknown to our authors. They similarly pass over the stimulus given to physical sci- | ence by Boscovich’'s centres of force. In| education they do not recognize that) the formation of nearly all modern prose | dates from the Humanist teaching of Jesuit colleges. In all this, the necessity | of reducing Jesuit activity to the nega- tion of liberty of every kind (Ixxvii) stands in the way of that impar-| tial judgment which Professor Monod | desiderates. Lalande, who has seen the Jesuit at work, in a curious discourse indexed by Aulard, took up the defence of their teaching before the Revolution was fairly over in France. Professor Monod has had the intel-| lectual courage to give this introduction to the world. He need not be surprised if it should have far-reaching results, not unlike those which followed the publishing of a like courageous essay in English literature—Newman’s Tract Ninety. If, like that celebrated docu- ment, Professor Monod’s introduction is the sign of an intellectual reaction against anti-Roman Catholicism, it is because history, which has been written as controversy, will always have such | rebounds when found out. Macaulay, in | the famous passage cited entire by Pro-| fessor Monod, gives out first, all that he | has heard in favor of the Jesuits and | then all that he has heard against them | -~and asks you to believe the two can exist together in the same human in- dividuals. The general reader and the his- torical student find it, difficult to accept such identity of contradictories, and Professor Monod, although he repeats the accepted anti-Catholic formulas, seems to agree with them. s.D. | LIBRARIANS AND BIBLIOGRA- PHERS AT MACKINAC, Cuicago, July 7. “How is it with codperation in the handling of human beings?” asked Mr. Hodges in his presidential address to the assembled members of the American Library Association last Friday; and he continued: The public libraries have been called into existence in industrial communities appa-| rently to assist In relieving the strain aris-| ing from the monotony of modern indus- | trial employment. Playgrounds, sensational | Journalism, dance halls, moving-picture) shows, ball games, sunshine societies, social) settlements, are all coadjutors. It would) be well if some day we were to have a co-| operative conference, at which we should lay aside, for the most part, consideration of our administrative snags, and have heart to heart talks with those who are answering in such varied ways the unspoken appeals of the lever haulers and the pedal kickers. As a matter of fact, the present confer- ence was in a measure an attempt in the indicated direction. A large part of the general session was devoted to mat- ters of recreation, for librarians and others, and an illustrated lecture on Playgrounds was given by Graham Romeyn Taylor of Chicago. The most notable address given before the libra- rians in session was that of Prof. Charles Hubbard Judd, of the Univer- sity of Chicago School of Education, on “The Library and the School.” He came as a representative of the National Edu- cation Association, and spoke in no un- certain tones of the great value of the library to the pupils in the public schools, and the importance of their learning thoroughly how to use a li- brary. He wished that the present study hours in the class-rooms, in the pres- ence and under the supposed supervi- sion of a teacher, could be changed to library hours, where the pupils, under the guidance of a school librarian with wide knowledge of books, could be led away from the thralldom of the text- books and learn to use books as tools. Professor Judd’s address evidently made a deep impression and gave the library workers much encouragement, particu- larly in view of the lack of interest in the subject that had been shown at the latest meeting of the National Educa- tion Association. Mr. Hodges remarked, in opening one of the general sessions, that, whereas the keynote of the Bretton Woods Confer- ence last year was coérdination, that of this year’s might be said to be affilia- tion; and, truly, the affiliated societies were very much in evidence: the Nation- al Association of State Libraries held two sessions, besides one in conjunction with the American Association of Law Libraries; while the latter had not less than three sessions in addition to this; the Special Libraries Association had also three sessions, the League of Libra- ry Commissioners two, and there were two meetings of the Agricultural Li- braries’ Round Table; two informal dis- cussions were held outside the official programme of those interested in branch libraries. It is apparently increas- ingly difficult to keep a hold on the various interests and movements centred in the American Library As- sociation, even if the ramifications of librarians into the other fields of sociological endeavor be left to one side. Besides the independent associations affiliated with the American Library As- sociation, meetings were held by the various sections of the association it- self. The Children’s Librarians’ Section discussed not only books for children,
Page 11
July 14, 1910] The Nation. but children’s gardens and other means of recreation that apparently had no connection with library work; the Col- lege and Reference Section discussed the relations between college libraries and public libraries; and the coépera- tive cataloguing of serials carried on by five large libraries under the aus- pices of the A. L. A. Publishing Board was presented to the assembled college and university librarians by Clement W. Andrews of the board. At the Pro- fessional Training Section an animated discussion took place concerning the es- sentials of a good library school. Where- as one speaker would have technique and business methods the _ essential studies, another opined that the essen- tial thing might be books; and the sug- gestion was thrown out that the schools might well demand more than mere col- lege degrees for admission: a few years of university work would not, it was thought, hurt a prospective librarian. The Bibliographical Society of Amer- ica held, as usual, its annual meeting at the same time as the American Library Association. The president of the so- ciety, Azariah S. Root, after calling the society to order at its first session, de- livered an address about the “Present Situation as to the Origin of Printing,” in which he surveyed the results of the investigations of the last thirty years, beginning with J. H. Hessels’s book on Gutenberg, published in 1882, and the first really critical examination of the documents, and ending with the very re- markable discoveries made since the celebration in 1900 of the five hundredth anniversary of the inventor’s birth. It would be important, the speaker said, if the same kind of minute typological in- vestigation that has been given to the Gutenbergiana could be given to the so called Kosteriana, and he added that, if else took up this matter, he should do at the first opportunity. Prof. Colbert Searles of Stanford Uni- versity sent in a paper on “The Library of Jean Chapelain and its Catalogue,” and L. J. Burpee read a paper on “The Literature of the Fur Trade.” The second session of the society was devoted to a discussion of the Bibliog- raphy of Modern Languages and Liter atures, and was preceded by a state- ment, by J. Christian Bay of the John Crerar Library, entitled “A Survey of Periodical Bibliography,” in which he deprecated the duplication of biblio- graphical efforts in so many subjects, al- though, at the same time, many gaps may be found in these same subjects, while other subjects are entirely neg- lected by the bibliographer. The prin- cipal contribution to the subject under discussion was a paper sent in by Prof. Clark S. Northup of Cornell University, entitled “The Present Status of the Bibliography of Modern Philology.” Af- ter enumerating the principal retrospec- tive as well as current bibliographies, ne one so and giving for some of them the classi- fication of the material used in them, Professor Northup turned to the future. “Obviously,” he wrote, “if we are to make, in modern philology, progress commensurable with our progress in other branches of science, the present largely unsatisfactory bibliographical conditions cannot continue.” Among the unsatisfactory conditions he, too, mentioned duplication. He doubted whe- ther the present existing bibliographies could be made better. “We need, it seems to me, a new bibliographical en- terprise, in which some twenty-five or fifty scholars and professional bibliog- raphers should join, and which should have its headquarters at some great geographical centre, American rather than British or German, and, in Amer- ica, in Chicago rather than in New York.” A number of representatives of modern language studies at leading American universities had submitted, at the request of the secretary of the so- ciety, short, written statements of their views regarding the bibliography of their particular field. W. N. C. Carlton read a summary of these statements. Among the desiderata brought out in these letters may be mentioned the fol lowing: J. F. Spingarn and F. I. Car- penter desire a comprehensive biblio- graphical history of English literature, on the pattern of Goedeke’s “Grundriss” or Teuffel-Schwab’s “Geschichte der Rémischen Literatur’; J. M. Manly puts in the first place a bibliography of bibli ographies of English philology, and in the second a bibliography of current philological publications; this latter de sideratum is also brought forth by H P. Thieme, while W. V. Lawrence de sires the same for his particular field, “ the history of the drama. J. W. Cun liffe and W. P. Trent want a new Lowndes on modern lines, perhaps ac companied by a new edition of Halkett and Laing; A. C.. von Noe desires better treatment for the output of American scholars; J. F. Spingarn and A. R. Hohl feld ask for more attention to transla tions; J. Scott Clark says that literary criticism is the department that is “in most serious need of attention’; and, finally, A. P. Thieme and A. C. von Noe see the solution in a central bureau. Professor Northup suggested a joint committee of the Bibliographical Soci ety of America and the Modern Lan guage Association to work out the finan- cial and other details of his plan; Mr. Bay closed his paper by suggesting a committee “to investigate the scope, manner of publication, and relative util ity of existing bibliographies, ‘Jahres- berichte,’ and reviews.” Both recom- mendations were accepted by the soci- ety and referred to the council for con- sideration and action. The council af- terwards decided to make only one com. mittee, to charge it both with the in- vestigation of existing bibliographies 34 and with the study of the ways and means for a bibliographic bureau for modern philology; the committee will be asked to begin its investigation of the bibliographical field with a study of modern philological bibliography. W. Dawson Johnston was elected president of the society, and A. G. S. Josephson, Carl B. Roden, and W. N. C. Carlton re- elected, respectively, secretary, treasur- er, and librarian. Axset G. S. JosErPHson. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. A Bibliography of the writings of J A McNeill Whistler and the books about him by a New Yorker, Don C. Seitz just been printed and published in Edinburgh It is a 16mo volume of nearly 200 pages, printed in an edition of 350 copies on hand- made paper. Among other facts of inter- est, the introduction contains an account of the first publication of “The Gentle Art of Making Enemies,” which Mr. Seitz calls “the true starting point in Whistler litera- The book was first put in type for a one-time close friend of has ture.” Sheridan Ford, Whistler, at the Leadenhall Press, by Field & Tuer; and plates were made. No impres- had taken, when the learned that Mr. Whistler objected of the book, and it was pressed Next, Ford carried his n script to Antwerp, and there found a print- and two printer to the sup- sions been publication anu- er who once more put it into type, copies were printed, when du Rol both and paper. No copy of either of these two editions is known to exist. Next, was printed the first edition of which any extant, This the imprint Delabrosse & Cie, 1890." Mr. Seltz’s he although thousand the Procureur types confiscated in Ghent, copy is had Paris own copy is says, the only one he has seen 4000 were printed rhis for copies probably an market ‘Frederick Stokes included the coples the New & Broth have number the Ameri York imprint of A few but with copies with this imprint urvived, many were destroyed in a fire. These printings were all sur and however bindery unauthorized Ford's compelled Whistler elf to print the book, and this he did There and small paper Wh (books reptitious per- him the copies on both stence same year, 1890 are arge The thirty-one Writings by tler” include only editions) Wh run numbers and but the books about to him total and articlh tler far number of of which refer containing references the The entries in the Bibliography is 772, hundred magazines or into hundreds about five are articles or ences in and newspapers A misprint, “Joseph Parnell” for Pennell such a bibliography, but easily overlooked Bishop Gott’s Four Folios of Shakespeare, £2,850 when his was in March, be the same rooms in a sale to take place on July 21 and It is probable that this time they will be sold without reserve. The First Folio isa the leaf of verses is guard- Joseph whose name appears so often in is an extraordinary error, which were bought in for library sold at 1907 Sotheby's will again offered in 99 “ae goed sound copy ed, one corner of title is in fascimile, and some other leaves are mended, The Third Folio Is the 1663 issue, without the por-
Page 12
The plays i—they do not properly be- The and leacribed as good copies books from the Gott library apparently, bought in at the sale, re now offered again, are: “The yf Vv (1600), the Roberts (1591) three Book, seven spurious Second issue nice enser’s “Complaints” on supposed to be unique; Edward VI works. the the Prayer liturgical operties in sale include a Book of of the fifteenth enth century, done by an Eng- ontaining forty-three fine Historie of (1624); the first edi- Hypnerotomachia Poliphili” ancient manuscripts of Waltham Holy of St. Ed- Shake- verses Hours and Smith's “General Virg lition tion (Aldu on) \bbatial library several from tl library Folio leaf of n facsimile; and a very the first edition of (1813), in the original with slip Monasttl First the Cros amd the mundsbury nother apeal his one with leaf pamphiet Abydos" wrapper tith ind last rar Byron hi Bride of blue pape! found, i the errata which is said, in only one other copy Im the ibled reports of the Thomas Gray 28. one very omitted This consisting of twenty- “ribbon let- brought it Sotheby's on June tant item was was a Book Alphabet ettera and the letter A large price of The are leaves of dated 1464 It £1,520 prices Six for Shelley, following paid auto- Sotheby's sale of July 6 two and one-half pages quarto Medwin. £43: Oliver Cromwell, A page folio, 1646, to his daughter, £52: Franklin, A. L. SS. four pages folio, March 14. 1764, relating to the anti-Quaker und =the uprisings, £33 10s.; Bronté, a collection of ninety all to Ellen Nussey, mounted and volume, £102; Alexander Pope, even A. L. 8. and autograph 29 pages 4to £155; and Thacke L. S.. four pages 8vo, written from Buffalo, December addressed Mammy graphs at A. L. 8 to Thoma i & yn riots Indian Charlot AL 8 bound in a 1852 £35 29 to (his mother) (4 rrespondence. AN VISITOR TO COLERIDGE IN \MERIE 1832 Tue NATION in a little account of a visit paid in 1832 m O18 known Boston ng a young American view to pub for ten with any all the wives the more valuable impression made fresh and sympathetic na was born at Maid 16 Eliza grandson of Maas After Lellan (‘ounty Vt September Isaac and Roston the 1 Hull of Newton the son of and firitieh Museum catalogue entry eory Blake) nd Tor zerland Journal of a Residence France Memotr Religious Boston England With a His lam Jr through amd Italy Extracts from Ieane Mela [Vol. 91, No. 2350 The Nation. a preparatory at the McLellan entered Harvard Univer- sity in 1825, and graduated in 1829. He studied for the ministry at Andover, 1829- {1, and then went on a tour, which included Britain, France, Germany, Italy, and Switzerland He left America September 16, 1831; started on his return April 18, 1833, and landed at Boston June 12. Then came the tragic ending to a bright young life. Eight weeks after his return he was stricken typhus, and died twenty-third year. the ardent who went to the spirit in which a disciple might have sat at the feet of an ancient philosopher. He writes this simple and affecting account of interview : course School, Great by later, in his Such spirit filial was young and see Coleridge in the Saturday, April 27th, 1832—Walked_ to Highgate to call on Mr. Coleridge. I was ushered into the parlor while the girl car- ried up my letter to his room. She present- ly returned, and observed that her master was very poorly, but would be happy to see me, if | would walk up to his room, which | gladly did. He is short in stature, and appeared to be careless in his dress. I was impressed with the strength of h's ex- pression, his venerable locks of white, and his trembling frame. He remarked that he had for some time past suffered much bodily anguish. For many months (thir- teen) seventeen hours each day had he walked up and down his chamber. I in- quired whether his mental powers were af- fected by such intense suffering; ‘Not at all,”” said he. “My body and head appear tu hold no connexion; the pain of my body, blessed be God, never reaches my mind.” After some further conversation, and some inquiries respecting Dr. Chalmers, he re- marked, “The Doctor must have suffered exceedingly at the strange conduct of our once dear brother laborer in Christ, Rev. Mr. Irving. Never can I describe how much it has wrung my bosom I had watched with astonishment and admiration the won- derful and rapid development of his powers. Never was such unexampled advance in in- tellect as between his first and second vol- ume of sermons The first full of Gal- licisms and Scotticisms, and all other cisms. The second discovering all the elegance and power of the best writers of the Elizabethan age. And then so sudden a fall, when his mighty energies made him so terrible to sinners.’ Of the mind of the celebrated Puffendorf he said, “his mind is like some mighty volcano, red with flame, and dark with tossing clouds of smoke, through which the lightnings play and glare most awful- ly." Speaking of the state of the different classes of England, he remarked, ‘“‘We are in a dreadful state. Care. like a foul hag, sits on us all; one class presses with iron foot upon the wounded heads beneath, and all struggle for a worthless supremacy, and all rise to it move, shackled by their expenses; happy, happy are you to hold your birthright in a country where things are different; you, at least at present, are in a transition state; God grant it may ever be Sir, things have come to a dreadful pass with us; we need most deeply a reform, but I fear not the horrid re- form which we shall have Things must alter; the upper classes of England have made the lower persons, things; the people in breaking from th's unnatural state will break from duties also.’ He spoke of Mr. Alston with great affec- tion and high encomium; he thought him in imagination and color almost unrivalled (pp. 230-232.) to so! Coleridge's gloomy view of the condition of was in the of the first legis- Reformed Parliament, he was opposed to the measures which poured healthy blood along the of politte In Disraeli’s novel, there is a vivid of the the poor—tnto The as it England year lation for a yet new and veins the body Sybil,’ pieture and the divided bitter nations” rich the atrife two people of which were litical po- to-day some- Boston Latin four weeks times seems, is tame indeed when compared with the hatred that raged between class and class in the first half of the nineteenth century. Of the very mild measure of elec- toral reform Coleridge could say: “The bill is bad enough, God knows; but the arguments of its advocates and the manner of their advocacy are a thousand times worse than the bill itself; and you will live to think so.” WILLIAM E. A. AXon. Manchester Eng., June 30. LIBRARY RESTRICTIONS. To THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Sir: Recently I have had occasion to make inquiry as to facilities offered by historical societies and other great li- braries containing historical material, not to the general public, but to special inves tigators. Without doubt all the purely his- torical collections were formed to preserve the history of the field they cover—preserv:- the material and encourage its transmuta- tion into actual history. It should seem. however, that some of them, cr, for that matter, all of them, are in danger, as they wax stronger and grow older, of losing sight of this end, and making the collection an end in itself. They thus acquire a species of society or library rheumatism or a hardening of the joints, and they become less flexible and less useful. It has been known to become so serious as to iay virtually prohibitive burdens upon authorship, resulting in a reversal of the true aim of the collection. An illustration of this reversal is in the rule regarding the use of ink. I do not refer to its use by the general public, many of whom would not appreciate the dangers in the use of ink to precious materials, or would not have the careful habits of the trained scholar. I refer only to scholars engaged in special extended investigation to result in some serious written work, and who are properly known. To forbid such men the use of ink even under prop- er circumstances, is not simply not to en- courage; it amounts to virtual pro- hibition of production in some cases. Strange as it may seem (or, should I say, naturally, and as one might ex- pect) the only institutions in which this condition obtains, so far as I can learn from experience or extended inquiry among historians, are the splendid, old, strong his- torical societies of Massachusetts and Penn- sylvania, the latter having succumbed com- paratively recently. Every historian must confess to a certain idolatry for the rare od manuscripts and volumes in these and like collections, but when it extends to pre- vention of the natural use of them by trained men who them, one is re- minded of that sepulchral front parlor in the farmhouse into which weddings and funerals may enter. The rules of societies and libraries are uniform, but if their aim ts to the needs of scholars engaged in extended investigation, a flexibi‘ity and permissive discrimination must lodged somewhere Mr. Putnam of the Library of Congress has rules that are nearly ideal in this matter. and the New York Historical Society lodges this flexibility of Judgment in tts librarian with other societies and libraries with historical collections in this country, and, as Professor Andrews of Johns Hopkins in- value only meet not be So
Page 13
July 14, 1910] The Nation. forms me, in England. And is not this as it should be? Historical collections are made for man, not man for historical co!- lections BURTON ALVA KONKLEL. Swarthmore, Pa., July 5 ASTROPHEL. To THE EpiTrorR oF THE NATION: Sir: The Oxford English Dictionary in less mature days, culled from two passages in Spenser the word “Astrophel,” defining it as the name of a plant hitherto unidenti- fied. Truly, it is of a kind unknown on land or sea, being compounded, as the poet avers, of the personality of Sir Philip Sid- ney and his lady love. It first growes red, and then to blew doth fade, Like Astrophel which therinto was made. And in the midst thereof a star appeares, As fairly formed as any star in skyes; Resembling Stella in her freshest yeares * Spenser, ‘‘Astrophel,’’ 174-8 The transformation of Astrophel into a flower may have been suggested, I submit, by the fate of Adonis, who was likewise slain while hunting (Cf. F. Q., ili, i, 38). The source of this plant name is diffident- ly stated by Sir James as ‘“‘perh. corrup- tion of astro-phyllum—star-leaf; Nares sug- gests of Aster Tripolium.”’ The context, however, implies that it was named “for that shepheard’s sake.” Just how Sidney hit upon his pastoral name, eternized in “Astrophel and Stella,” has long remained untaught; for the erstwhile explanation of it as a play upon his name is unanimously passed over by his editors and biographers. Yet as Phillisides is repeatedly used for Philip Sidney, and sidus is reasonable—Astrophel, the lover of the star Stella. Conceivably the name was not original with the circle of Sidney. In Rabelais (iv, xviii), we read of “maistre Astrophile” in connection with Pantagruel’s escape from a tempest at sea. The significance of the name to Rabelais is clear from the preface to ‘‘Pantagrueline Prognostica”’: adotpov, the conceit I'ay reuolué toutes les Pantarches des cieulx, calculé les quatratz de la Lune, crocheté tout ce aque iamais penserent toutes les Astrophiles, Hypernephelistes, Anemo- phylaces Uranopetes, & Ombrophores, & confreré du tout auecque Empedocles. de- Ch. Marty-Laveaux, in his glossary, rives this from *‘** Agrpov, astre, et diAes, ami.” The word then must have been encountered by members of the Areopagus, and may have been adapted, rather than coined anew, by Sidney. Percy W. LONG. Harvard University, July 2 A FREE ACADEMY OF GRAPHIC ARTS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Opinions vary as to the respective merits of the several systems of artistic education. The following of an academical course for instance is advocated by some and disapproved of by others. Education in a studio again and private teaching labor under the possible disadvantage of too great a predominance of the teacher's manner. There are partisans of self-education, so- called, who follow no other teaching but that of nature, as the phrase is; and, fourth- ly, there are those who consider copying the old masters the best education. Each of these systems may be said to have its merits and its defects In any case and whatever }seems desirable to me, though | the system followed, even the best teaching will be rendered futile by a want of recep- tivity in the pupil. Codperation of master and pupil is the conditio sine qua non of success. Academical education, however, am ready to admit the objections that can be urged against it. The great advantage lies in the working together of so many young artists, whereby an undue preponderance of the teacher is counteracted, while constant com- parison with the work of his co-pupils stim- ulates ambition and enlarges the horizon. The disadvantage consists in a certain nar- rowness and dogmatism to which this kind of training is prone; it confine effort in one direction Messrs. Hart, Nibbrig and Moulyn, who intend to open an art school this autumn in Laren (North Holland), aim at combin- ing the advantages of academical teaching with those of a freer and inspiring study after nature. Mauve's fascinating country will enable them to keep away from their school the depressing influences of academic work. The range of studies can be easily made to comprise the living model and landscape. In order to render the pro- gramme as extensive as possible a course in is apt to more applied art, to be given by Jan Eissenlof- fel, is to be added to those in drawing, painting, etching, and modelling. For the history of art and @sthetics, they have en- gaged the services of the art critics H. P Bremmer and Plasschaert, and the well known author Adriaan van Cordt, who will lecture on their special subjects The American and English art students who resort to Laren should not fail to avail themselves of this opportunity AUGUSTA DE WIT Amsterdam, Holland, 30 June ATTENDANCE AT FRENCH TIES. UNIVERSI- To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The recent report of the minister of public instruction of France gives some in- teresting statistics concerning the universities of that country. On the January, 1910, the total number in attendance at the French was 40,131. Paris leads the sixteen 14th of of students universities universities of the world with an enrolment, excluding students in the lycées—which correspond to our colleges—as well as those in the technical and summer schools, of 17,512 The provincial universities rank as fol- lows: Lyons, 2,922; Toulouse, 2,828; Bor- deaux, 2,552; Montpellier, 1,965; Nancy, 1,- 899; Lille, 1,675; Rennes, 1,602; the new uni- versity of Algiers, 1,442; Aix-Marseille, 1,- 236; Grenoble, 1,156; Poitiers, 1,111; Dijon, 992; Caen, 722; Clermont, 275; and Besan- con, 242. Of these 40,131 students, 7,038 are foreigners, of whom 3,500 are in the Uni- versity of Paris. Of the 17,512 students in this university, 7,688 are taking law, 3,115 are in literature, and 1,845 in the sciences Another noteworthy fact is the remarkable increase in the number of wo- men studying in the French universities There are 3,830 women enrolled, of whom 1,300 are studying in Paris: while of the 7,038 foreign students, 1,707 are women. The Parisian newspapers take especial in noting the remarkable in- crease in the number of foreign students in the of Paris, the of the pleasure University which now leads universities world in that rs 33 (1888-89) were 457 foreigners enrolled in this uni- spect. Twenty years ago there versity. Ten years later (1898-99), the number had increased to 1,174, while five years later (1904-05), there were 1,633; and in 1908-09 the number was doubled (3,326) The 3,500 foreigners now studying in Paris are apportioned as follows: England, 115; United States, 107; Egypt, 165; Rumania 233; Germany, 231; Austria-Hungary, 139; Russia, which has the largest delegation 1,356. South America, as well as Mexico and Panama, Turkey, and the Orient are also well represented. Among the reasons for this astonishing affluence of foreign students to Paris are the exceptional li- brary facilities—there being sixteen libra- of which at least six contain than 200,000 volumes each—excellent labora- tories, and free to all Joun L New York ries, more tuition GERIG Columbia University, July 2 Literature. RECENT VERSE. The Younger Choir. New York: Moods Publishing Co. The Frozen Grail and Other Poems. By Elsa Barker. New York: Duffield & Co. The Poems of James Ryder Randail. New York: The Tandy-Thomas Co. Flower o' the Grass. By Ada Foster Murray. New York: Harper & Bros. Monday Morning and Other Poems. By James Oppenheim. New York. Sturgis & Walton Co. The Enchanted Island and Other Poems. By Alfred Noyes. New York: Freder- ick A. Stokes Co. Odes the Generations of Men. By Hartley Burr Alexander. New York: The Baker & Taylor Co. New Poems. By Madison Cawein. Lon- don: Grant Richards. The Shadowy Garden and Other Plays. By Madison Cawein. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. on Collected Lyrics of Boston: Happy Ending: The Louise Imogen Houghton Mifflin ¢ Mingled Wine. By York: Longmans, Guiney. ‘0. Anna Bunston. New Green & Co. Verses and Sonnets. By Julia Stockton Dinsmore (F. V.). New York: Double- day, Page & Co. It was a good idea to issue, under the title of “The Younger Choir,” a small selection of more or less representative verse by the new poetic generation. Such a mode of publication has one advantage so obvious that it is surprising not find it used more often. It spares the poet with or two good verses the embarrassment of putting out an entire book; and, what is even more to the it saves the reader the trouble of ransacking the whole haystack. To sure, Mr. Markham’s “word of intro with its references to the “Lyv- to one point, be duction,”
Page 14
34 rical Ballads” and “The Ancient Mari- ner,” is not particularly felicitous. But prophecy is rash work at best; and it is enough to say that the spirit of the af- fair is a kind of modern romanticism — neo-romanticism, we are learning to call in which the nerves are beginning to predominate over the senses. From among the work orf such contributors as Zona Gale, Elsa Barker, Viereck, Ridge- Torrance, Lewisohn, and Richard Burton, whose name in this connection sounds like an anachronism, a single scennet by George Sterling will serve as an illustration of the skill and the dis- position of the group. : ley Sargon is dead, Semiramis a clod! In crypts profaned the moon at midnight peers ; The owl upon the Sphinx hoots in her ears, scant and sear the desert grasses nod once the armies of Assyria trod, on And Where With the younger sunlight splendid spears, The lichens cling the closer with the years, And seal the eyelids of the weary god Where high the tombs of royal Egypt heave, The vulture shadows with arrested wings The indecipherable boast of kings, As Arab children hear their mother’s ery in mockery their toy—they leave of Pharoah staring at the leave skull nd rhe sky Heroism, it may as well be acknowl- is not much in the way of this Their tone is either mol or mu- It is only exceptionally that the virtues—fortitude, endurance, and courage never to submit or yield”— find such celebration as Elsa Barker in her “Frozen Grail” reserves for the ad- venture of the pole: edged youth finous austere | against the spirit of 1 and searching wolf of Soli mailed rhostiv-footed F« n hell like ig ar in his froze blackness the rhe ' their back doubt, and in their death shall be the that will assuage their ill, and stagger toward the road whereby they for a franchise Does He of the boreal lights’ of nd the lattice that grail chapel thelr stern-vowed quest vy of God's long paces toward the North I] they behold the splendor of His face? As for war itself, once the schoo) of [Vol. 91, No. 2350 The Nation. manly virtue, it is slightly out of fashion | just now; but none the less are the ro- bust sentiments of a war-poet like James Randall a good deal of a relief after sundry of our modern chorusings. Ran- dall, it will be remembered, was the au- thor of “Maryland! My Maryland!” And while his polemics do not, as a whole, meet the expectations raised by this pop- ular and spirited performance, the ad- mirers of “the Poet Laureate of the Lost Cause” will be glad to have all that sur- vives of his writing. Of his more pa-| cific manner, which is very much that | of his period, the following stanza from “Silver Spring” will give a pretty fair idea: When the sad and solemn moon Muses o’er the lone lagoon, And laughs the melancholy loon; When the crooning winter breeze, Hapless from the Hebrides, Chafes the dead cathedral trees "Mid the vultures’ muffled wails, Stifled by the panther-hails Shuddering up palmetto trails; When the globe is wrapt in sleep, And the gnomes their vigils keep By the mountain and the deep— I can fancy phantom things, On their thunder-tarnished wings, Soaring with a fallen grandeur over these enchanted springs! This is not wholly unfamiliar; but it is as far away from our peculiar preoc- cupations as crinoline and hoopskirts. After all, if there is any poetic move- ment in progress among us just now, as many are inclined to doubt, it would ap- pear to consist in an effort on the part of the muse, like Browning’s person of quality, to leave the country and estab- lish herself in town. On the one hand there is a certain impatience and dis- trust of solitude and the rural deities, the familiars of wood and water and field, even among those who still sing albeit rather despondingly, like Murray in her “Flower * the them, Miss Grass”: Oo knew world’s dawning the glad deities we long day pallid astray Are thes Long, young ago in the These shapes that wander here In the gray vapors and the glimmering dew” Where are the fay, The flash of wings in the descending blue, The wild enchantments that about us grew When first the of Pan aplay? forms of satyr, nymph, and we heard pipes Silent is Ida with great Jove asleep; No more a garlanded, soft-footed throng Thrills the wild aisles with laughter, dance, and song; Nalad and faun their dreaming vigils keep. Dried are thy dews, Olympus; dust is deep On Enna’s fields, and where the gods so long their young sway—how jubilant and strong! shapes and ghostly, creep, Held Vague alien shadows | | And On the other hand, there is a gradual yielding to the lure of the city—a mani- fest admiration, in the manner of Mr. Lewisohn, for its ready impressionism, ‘its violent contrasts and spectacular in- versions of drab and purple, of glare and |obscurity—or, more significantly still, a dim instinctive yearning to the masses. of street and slum, the vague unrest of ‘the animal in the presence of the herd. Such is the burden of Mr. Oppenheim’s “Monday Morning.” Listen to the crude appealingnegss, the elementary pity of his. rhythms in “An Italian Funeral”: Humbly, O humbly, in slow procession, the hearse and horses, the drivers and mourners Trail between tenements hung with dark faces and eddying crowds at the gray street corners— Clouds hold the skies in, muddy, workmen are ripping streets for a sewer, lo, to a drum-throb musicians are leading the dead, the dead to a church of the poor. the gutter is the And lo, to that music yon swarthy Italians between them are sawing a pine- beam in half, The dead-march rhythm runs through their labor; they swing, they sweat, they grumble and laugh; Hurrying men greet each other and justle on errands of business: all are alive: But the dead trails through the red storm of living, and the mourners are cumb in the loud man-hive. is gone: one mouth less now to be filled; but, oh, one toiler less: he is gone! A month shall you nearly starve for the burial: must pay, pay dearly for leave to mourn. And why do you do it? Is there love among shadows, in cellars; have you dreamt of eternal life? you led, after all, by the flaming Vision O son, O brother, O mother, O wife? He you Were That, like it or not, is the most sig- nificant verse that gets written nowa- days—and the amount is constantly in- creasing. Even Mr. Noyes in his new volume has abandoned his lofty rhyme to some extent for the elegy of the streets, as thus of the “Rank and File”: Drum-taps! Drum-taps! Who is it march- ing, Marching past in the night? Ah, hark, Draw your curtains aside and see Endless ranks of the stars o’er-arching Endless ranks of an army marching, Marching out of the endless dark, Marching away to Eternity. . e Count as they pass, their hundreds, thou- sanda, Millions marching away to a doom Younger than London, older than Tyre! Drum-taps, drum-taps where are they marching— Regiments, nations, empires, marching Down through the jaws of a world-wide tomb,
Page 15
July 14, 1910] The Nation. strange mishaps. Its pursuit requires an imperturbable gravity, a stern insensi- . . . - bility to the suggestions of humor, which occasionally exposes it to the lev- ity of the Philistires. But, fortunately, there are other voices —feebler, perhaps, but insistent, like the faint familiar sounds of nature, with the still persuasiveness of old association. In particular, Mr. Cawein has a way of *\quickening inanimate objects with a kind of fanciful spell, of awakening si- lence and peopling solitude with a swift and transient spirit: Doomed or ever they sprang from the mire. Wearing their poor little toy love-tokens Under the march of the terrible skies! Is it a jest for a God to play? Whose is the jest of these millions marching, Wearing their poor little toy love-tokens, Waving their voicelessly grand good-byes, Secretly trying, sometimes, to pray. Marching out of the endless ages, Marching out of the dawn of time, Endless columns of unknown men, Endless ranks of the stars o’er-arching, Endless ranks of an army marching Numberless out of the numberless ages, Men out of every race and clime, Marching steadily now as then. I saw the acolytes of Eve, the mystic sons of Night, Come pacing through the ancient wood in hoods of hodden-gray ; Their sombre cloaks were pinned with stars and each one bore a light, A moony lanthorn, and a staff to help him on his way. The most thoroughgoing attempt, how- ever, to write the epic of humanity is that of Mr. Alexander in his “Geners- tions of Man.” In spite of a certain clut- ter of materials, unavoidable, perhaps, in such a plan, Mr. Alexander has a breadth | of horizon, an acquaintance with the shifting symbols in which human exper- ience has successively clothed itself, and a power of abstraction, which give the varying movements of his poem some- thing of the impressiveness of a vast cosmology. A quotation from his second ode, which has to do with the develop- ment of the religious feeling, will supply as good an instance of his style as can be expected of a short extract: I heard their mantles rustle by, their san- dals’ whispering, sweep, And saw the wild flowers bow their heads and close their lovely eyes: their shadows pass and pass, with them Dreams and Sleep, Like children with their father, went, in dim and ghostly guis« 1 saw and Something of this same attitude to ward “our mother the earth’—a spirit at once earnest and playful like a riper childhood—has always made one of Miss Guiney’s attractions, though touched in her case with something more of a Celtic Strange prayers ascending up to God melancholy: Through all the aching #ons, year on year; Strange tongues uplifting from the sod The old antiphony of hope and fear: Strange if He should not hear! Open, Time, and let him pass Shortly where his feet would be! Like a leaf at Michaelma Swooning from the tree Ave, men have prayed ew - . Take him, weak and overw Strangely to God: - Fold about his dying drean Through thousand ages, under thousand a ' Boyhood, and the April m skies, : ' . And the rolling stream Unto His thousand strange theophanies, Men have prayed . With rite fantastic and with sacrifice He hath done with roofs ar inen Of human treasure, scourged with the Open, Time, and let him pa heavy rod Vague and innocent again, Of their own souls’ torment, men have Into country grass. rayed - . . . : pres " The line where this feeling for nature Strangely to God , = x r ki — boli “a East. North. South, West, passes over into a ind of symbolism, is The quartered Globe, hard to define. It is then that objects Like a prone and naked suppliant whose begin to take on a life of their own, in- breast dependent of ours or even hostile to it, A myriad stinging memories improbe— Hurt of old faiths, and that poetry retraces the steps wf mythology, or shelters under its images, an Ce ys cone as in Miss Bunston’s “Ad Extremas Of dead men's anguish, slow-dissolvent Tenebras:” wraiths Of long-gone yearnings, and delirious dream ! hear the lapping of the waves of death Of sacrificial pomp and pageant stream: In Stygian wells, Gods of the nations and their avatars '— I see the white-winged moths that bring East, North, South, West, the breath The suppliant Globe Of Asphodels; Abides the judgment of the changeless - . . ‘ . . a Yet if, oh dread Aidoneus, one like me Abides the judgment and the answering aid Of Heaven to the prayers that men have prayed Strangely to God. May ask a boon, I pray it may not be Persephons Who meets me soon: Naturally this anthropological and so- ciological verse is liable at times to She doth but winter in thy realms O Dis, Not nest with thee, 35 Her regal mouth still haunted by a kiss Would weary me. ————S———=_ - let there meet me one, scorn, Dim-eyed and hoar, Wan as Demeter when she sat forlorn By Celeus’ door. But too poor fer let Tiresias come, who, shrinking knows 4 woman's heart, To guide my feet where Lethe coldest flows, And pitying yew its deepest covert grows Far off, apart. And It is rather odd that in spite of the recent fad for the dramatic mould cur- rent verse should show so few dramatic effects, even of the simpler and more in- cidental sort. Confrontation, mise-en- scene, situation, passion, are uniformly weak or bungled. All is subjective, se'f- communing—and not only so, but there seems to reign a kind of divine confusion upon the poet’s composition as upon his spirit. Now and then, however, it is pos- sible to find a pretty good lyric imper- sonation, such as Browning well nigh turned into a poetic convention. Miss Dinsmore’s “Verses and Sonnets” con- tain several, of which the best is prob- ably “Sappho:” How I could love, if gods but walked this shore, And I might meet them wander'ng, face to face! But when I speak of it with awe profound, They mock me with ‘Too late” and ‘“‘Nevermore.”’ Too late—alas! What do vain words avai!? “The gods themselves cannot their gifts re- call.” Wail, ineffectual lyre, a last, long wail: There igs no place for me—earth is too small But toward the immeasurable regions of the dead, One open, trackless way remains to tread That leaves no trace behind: the bound- less deep Shall roll its shelter o'¢ my hom 4 head There shall my lyre with m in sleep Our fire quenched in death’s tranquillity I, who have borne the earth, why should I dread The awful, the immitigable sea? CURRENT FICTION. Fortune. By J. C. Snaith. New York: Moffat, Yard & Co, The moving finger of Mr. Snaith has so long been accustomed to write in un- wonted ways that whimsical novel ty on his part should amaze the reader. It was a far cry from “Fierceheart the Soldier” to “Broke of Covenden,” al- though the two Spartan fathers furnish- ed in some sort a bond of unity. It was yet further from the gloom and blood- shed of both to the gentle if somewhat satirical cream-bun cheer of “Aramin- ’. and one opens “Fortune” with that sense of entire uncertainty what to ex no ta’
Page 16
36 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2350 pect that is rarely the portion of a well: | known novelist’s following. As Miguel Maria de Sarda y Boegas sets forth upon his journey, we are touched Do history—and repeat themselves, be it whispered, with none too much originality in the _ repetition? Here begins, apparently, the ordinary swashbuckling romance, and with more than tang of Hewlett in its composition The setting is strongly reminiscent of “The Spanish Jade,” the young hero blood-brother to “The Fool Errant,” and surely Sir Richard Pendragon, as he first appears, is only another of the many disguises of Bra- zenhead the Great. It is not long, how- before the reader realizes that the smile of “Araminta” has swelled into Homeric laughter, and that this is a notable piece of burlesque. Perplexity dispelled, the book is food for hearty enjoyment. Mr. Snaith in not unloving caricature of his early gods, and the result is as delightful in its own way as Hichens’s memorable ex- plosion of “The Londoners.” The figure of the English giant assumes at times a vigor beyond the merely farcical: he is of the kin of Bardolph, Nym, and Pis- tol, with a dash of Porthos, and the visit of the three soldiers of fortune to the French court is of a quality to linger in the memory. Fortune is in- deed the Hege lady of these adventur- ers, the “sweet baggage with the moist lip and the enkindling eye,” and Pen- dragon strikes their keynote when he cries, “To Fortune will we wet our beards, good Spaniard, for we of Eng land court her like a maiden with a dimple in her cheek.” This proud and capricious Princess, invested for the purposes of romance with the winsome if somewhat choleric flesh and blood of the Countess Sylvia, touches a chord of truth at the climax of the tale, when she turns from all her suitors to woo the careless and masterful Pendragon, only to be consigned to the arms of an- that “Captain-General of the Jogalones"; but the delight of the book ia to be found rather in its obvious mirth than in its subtle philosophy. Jesus astonishment. Snaith—thus with Mr and a casual is ever revels other by Silent Call, By Edwin Milton Royle. Charles Scribner's Sons. The New York Reading this novel is like witnessing a apirited play. Much of the dialogue, moat of the situations, and all the cues bear the im The half Kerhill— for and exits press of the dramatist’s art. of the Earl of known to Mr. Royle’s public as “The Squaw Man” of an earlier work—has grown to maturity and figures in these pages as Harold Calthorpe. Like the father, the son is obliged to leave Eng- land for reasons not really discreditable, and the “silent call” of the wild strain in his blood lures him to the home of The tribal reserva- entrances Indian son his mother's people. tion is so faithfully described in its nat- ural aspects, and such liberties are tak- en with the names of local celebrities, that no one acquainted with northeast- ern Utah can be deceived by its thin dis- guise. Against this scene we find group- ed as dramatis persone a scheming agent; an unscrupulous trader who helps him to his ends; an army officer, brave, but sadly fettered by departmen- tal red-tape; a bluff mining prospector and his gang; an intrepid ranch-boss; a beautiful Indian maiden, beset by lovers both red and white; and a right-minded but wholly unconventional parson. Sum- moned back to England by news of his father’s illness, Harold has a chance, of which advantage is cleverly taken for the reader’s profit, to contrast the free- dom of the frontier with the artificiali- ties of an advanced civilization; of course, unfavorably to the latter. Under the romantic surface of this and the earlier story, Mr. Royle has given us not only an excellent picture of the untamed West, but also a glimpse of his own philosophy on the race ques- tion. In spite of an occasional resort to theatrical methods, he has set forth ad- mirably the serious side of attempting to change the Indian into something non-Indian through the influence of an alien environment. The Rust of Rome. By Warwick Deep- ing. New York: Cassell & Co., Ltd. For the reader who likes to be kept | shivery edge of apprehension | on the in an atmosphere of vast tragic portent blended with illimitable detail, Deeping is the man. The magnified epi- sode is the note of the book, although a definite story runs in and out among the episodes. The reader is asked to be interested in Benjamin Heriot’s every step, from the prison life he is quitting on the first page to the last incident on the four hundredth. His morals, man- ners, tastes, pursuits, clothes are of- fered with a confidence in the reader's interest which is almost naive. The reader meanwhile forges along, endur- ing repetition for the sake of many mer- its on the way and in anticipation of the supposed final tying up of threads. The end is complete and seems to satisfy the actors. But it may be doubted whether violence undetected, even violence in a good cause, will ever become a popular marriage portion for hero and heroine of a romance. Benjamin Heriot for an hour's irre- sponsibility paid the heavy penalty of two years in Reading gaol. Once more free, he is near to wrecking himself a second time from sheer reaction, In his self-disgust, he is meditating suicide when chance sends him on a Sunday morning into a beech forest. Under the spell of the trees, he is seized by a passion for Nature and finds himself taking heart. He buys a piece of English woodland, builds a shelter, digs, plants, Mr. | ‘and grows sane. The attempt to escape humanity, however, is vain. Men, boys, women, and a woman spring up in the wilderness. The author’s touch in de- scribing the forest atmosphere is that of a lover, and the earth is made no less fascinating to the antiquarian than to the agriculturist. Characterization is also a marked accomplishment of the writer. His portraits are in the round, anatomy and covering both well-consid- ered. Not a figure, great or small, that does not have its being in its own in- dividual way. The Professional Aunt. By Mary C. E. Wemyss. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. The “Helen’s Babies” order of fiction is, it seems, not yet superannuated. In- deed, the irrepressible infant is an in- exhaustible theme. The “professional aunt” of the present book is, of course, the person who sees the funny things done and hears the funny speeches made by the particular urchins who are to be |exploited. The author, Mrs. Wemyss, is an Englishwoman who has written one or two other books about children. That kind of thing has not been done so much in England as with us, and is still |rather stifly done. The humor of Mrs. Wemyss is over-broad and self-conscious for the American taste. She begins with a definition of the Professional Aunt, jas the spinster from whom devotion to her nephews and nieces is exacted as a primary duty. Then she introduces the particular children with whom the par- |ticular aunt is implicated, and the ser- jies of infantile exploits and “bright say- |ings” begins. It must be confessed that the point of a large majority of the say- |ings is due to their happy childish in- | delicacy. Of course, the random speech of an innocent child can sail far closer to the wind than the considered and actionable utterances of your barnacle- crusted adult. But there is, after all, a \limit to the enjoyment of a voyage un- der these conditions. The fun of little Johnny’s conception of religion and lit- |tle Sally’s notion of motherhood are capable of exhaustion. The perfunctory “love interest” injected into these art- less pages is quite helpless to turn a con- geries of anecdotes into a real story. CRETAN DISCOVERY. Scripta Minoa; The written documents of Minoan Crete, with special reference to the archives of Knossos. By Arthur J. Evans. Vol. I. Pp. xiv+302, with 13 plates and many illustrations in the text. New York: Henry Frowde. $12.75 net. The art of prehistoric Crete has of recent years become known in such a |way as to afford a wonderfully vivid pieture of the life on that island well into the third millennium before our
Page 17
July 14, 1910] The Nation. era. So far as it is possible to know an ancient people without an understand- ing of their own written records, we may now be said to know the ancient Cretans really well, for we have the material setting of life among them in uncommon completeness. There has come to light also the fact that for above a thousand years an evolution in the art of writing was going on. The characters used show a change from conventionalized pictorial forms to those of earlier and later linear types. More- over, the most advanced type of linear script (Evans’s Class B) reaches a high stage of development, while even the lat- est manifestations of it are considerably earlier than the earliest records of Phenician writing. When one remem- bers that only a short time ago the con- sideration of the antiquity of writing played an important part in discussions of the Homeric question, it is possible to realize how greatly in this respect the present point of view has changed. Fur- thermore, with these Cretan discoveries, the source whence the Greeks took the characters of their alphabet becomes comparatively a less simple matter to explain. Has not the part the Pheni- cians played in the transmission of the letters been too exclusively emphasized? Is there not a large element of truth in the old traditions given by Diodorus that letters were invented in Crete, and that the Phenicians merely modified them and passed them on, or may it not be that some knowledge of the Cretan script was transmitted directly to the Greek settlers there? It would indeed be difficult to enumer- ate the interesting questions which re- cent discoveries in this wonderful island have raised for students both of pre- historic and of Greek archeology; but the answers to these questions must in manky cases depend upon the nature of the language used by the early Cretans, and touching this point we are still largely in the dark. In the absence of bilingual inscriptions, as Dr. Evans re- marks in his preface, a comprehensive attempt at interpretation or translitera- tion is not likely to be attended with fruitful results, but this fact makes it none the less an urgent need that schol- ars should have before them in as com- plete a form as possible the existing rec- ords of the early Cretan script. This need will be adequately met in the pres- ent handsome publication. The whole work is planned in three volumes: the first includes the hiero- glyphic and primitive linear classes of writing, together with some general dis- cussion of pre-Phenician scripts; the second and third will be given to a de- tailed publication of the documents of the advanced linear scripts. The whole will therefore constitute a corpus of the early Cretan written documents. In Part. i of the first volume, Dr. Evans gives an exceedingly useful survey of his whole subject, taking up the question jof the antiquity and diffusion of picto- graphs and linear signs in Europe, the discovery and the nature of each of the types of Minoan writing, the survivals of the art of writing as the different phases of Cretan civilization pass away, and the influence that this art had in other regions. This leads to a discus- sion of the Cretan Philistines and the Pheenician alphabet, and to a statement of the theory that this alphabet is to an important degree of Minoan origin. The various tables of illustration supple- ment the text in a most valuable way. Part ii is devoted to a careful and com- plete presentation of the hieroglyphic or conventionalized pictographic script. The influences under which it grew up are discussed, and its use on seals and clay documents. Then follows an ex- tended catalogue of hieroglyphic inscrip- tions on seals and sealings, and one of similar nature for inscriptions on clay sealings, tablets, bars, etc. There Is further a catalogue of the hieroglyphic signs, and an analysis with extended discussion of the nature of the script. Part iii is a study of the so-called Disk from Phestos, discovered by Dr. Per- nier of the Italian Mission, in 1908. This is the largest single hieroglyphic in- scription yet discovered in Crete, and its nature is, of course, of high inter- est. Dr. Evans subjects its signs to a searching examination, showing how radically in most cases they differ from the Minoan classes, and coming to the conclusion that the script is the pro- duct of a culture allied to the Minoan, but “existing on the southwest coast- lands of Asia Minor and not improbably in the Lycian area.” At the present stage of our knowledge any interpreta- tion can hardly be more than an Iinter- esting suggestion, for one cannot be cer- tain how exactly the original form of a hieroglyphic character indicates its meaning at a given time. It seems as if a bilingual inscription was the only thing which could possibly clear away the uncertainties. Nevertheless, a sur- prising amount of information about the probable contents of the writings, both hieroglyphic and linear, is scattered through the volume. A decimal system was in use in both, and, especially in Class B of the linear script, it is possi- ble to make out the enumeration of vari- ous classes of objects stored in the chambers of the palace. The arrange- ment of the clay tablets was often very careful, and they were sometimes plac-| ed like books on a modern shelf, so that the edges showed; then the edge would be docketed with a summary of con- tents. It is superfluous to add that the book as a whole is of high importance—the | careful record of a considerable part of the extraordinarily able archeological work which has placed Dr. Evans in the front rank of really great discoverers. Charies Sumner. By George H. Haynes (American Crisis Biographies). Phil- adelphia: George W. Jacobs & Co. $1.25 net. Except Lincoln, no statesman of our civil war period has been so elaborate ly commemorated as Sumner. We have the fifteen volumes of his works, edited by himself, the four bulky volumes of memoirs by E. L. Pierce, the biography by Moorfield Storey in the American Statesmen Series, and less considerable accounts in large number. Professor Haynes thinks it worth while to add to the list a new life, not at all claiming to add fresh material, but undertaking to adjust the figure properly in the per- spective, after the lapse of a momen- tous half-century. Professor Haynes is thoroughly informed and an excellent narrator; while strongly sympathetic, he is by no means undiscriminating; he does not blink the faults of his hero's character or the mistakes of his career. Nevertheless, that he accords Sumner a place among the statesmen of his time which he did not hold, and which in the retrospect of history he never will hold. Professor Haynes adopts from anoth er the statement that “at the close of the civil war Abraham Lincoln and Charles Sumner were the most influen- tial men in public life.” Lincoln’s emi- nence no one will question, but as to Sumner? Did he outrank in influence the great military figures? or, if we re- strict our view to civil life, did he stand before the country so superior in wis- dom and service to Chase, Seward, Stanton, and Charles Francis Adams? Good men in those days believed Sum- ner to be intrepid, untiring, well-pur- posed, and adorned with statesmanlike accomplishments; but they also believ- ed that he gravely lacked patience; also the sagacity for measuring accurately great and difficult problems and dealing with them wisely in view of their rela- tions with other problems and with the facts of human nature; also, the invalu- able quality of tact, the faculty for get- ting on with men and winning out in the welter of varying temperaments, clashing judgments, and conflicting in- terests. Conspicuous though the service of Sumner was, we yet believe that in many contemporary eyes his leadership had the handicap of these unfortunate limitations; that his work, therefore, in behalf of his country and of humanity | was far less effective than that of Lin- coln; indeed, that several among his fellow-strivers were fully his equals in the accomplishment of good results. While to multitudes of his contempo- raries Sumner seemed thus to fall short, indications abound that a later genera- tion is not disposed to judge him more kindly. Ideas are broached to-day by voices of authority which are not in harmony with the views and anticipa- we feel
Page 18
38 The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2350 tions of the anti-slavery men of fifty years ago. C. F. Adams, for instance, makes declarations as to the negro problem which sound strange in view his antecedents and earlier associa- tions. Again, the Rev. Dr. W. 8. Rains- ford, in his recent “Land of the Lion,” with great emphasis that the urgent need of the African blacks is “that they shall be firmly, lovingly forc- ed to work.” Dr. Rainsford will not as- sert that there exists now among ad- vanced races any such warm and com- prehensive altruism as will engage, un- requited, in this firm and loving enforce- ment of labor upon black millions. What remains but to devise a scheme through which a body of uplifters shall find it to their interest to do the enforcing? And when that is said we come peril- ously near to the suggestion of a soci- ety of masters and bondmen—the mas- ters, loving, we hope, but performing their task with an eye to their own iIn- terests as well—the bondmen held to unwilling work for a benefit they have not craved and do not appreciate. More interesting still, Booker T. Washington, asserts (“Up from Slav- page 16): of asserts ery,” We must acknowledge that, notwithstand- ing the cruelty and moral wrong of slavery, the ten million negroes inhabiting this coun- try, who themselves or whose ancestors went through the school of American slavery, are in a stronger and more hopeful condition, materially, intellectually, morally, and re- ligiously, than is true of an equal number of black people in any other portion of the globe. American slavery then, in Mr. Wash- ington’s view, has been for its victims an uplifting influence of great potency, and how, in contrast with this view is the doctrine of the “Barbarism of Slav- in which Sumner pronounced the institution only brutalizing upon mas- ter and slave alike! Distinctly, we express here no. ap- proval of Mr. Adams’s depreciation of negro capabilities; nor are we accept- theorles of Dr. Rainsford and Washington. We cite them utterances that are signifi- of the present moment. They strangely out of accord with the utterances of the old anti-slavery men among whom Sumner was a chief. Cita- a similar character might multiplied: and they all indicate that a state of mind prevails now among many humane men not in harmony with that of the zealous combatants of the former time. It is not difficult to understand why the prestige of Sumner, much ques- tioned In his own days, has lost rather than gained in later years. As is well set forth by Professor Haynes, while a man of many foibles, he possessed in a high degree courage, sincerity, high pur- pose, and scholarly accomplishments. itis service was great, but, over-confident in his own wisdom, he set his hand ery ” ing the Booker simply as cant tlons of be 'to much reconstruction of ideas and in-'! stitutions, Often he made, but too often he marred. In the world’s judgment, he falls far short in beneficent leader- | ship of the supreme statesman of his era, and is doubtfully eminent even among the secondary figures. Great and Greater Britain: The Prob- lems of Motherland and Empire, Po- litical, Naval, Military, Industrial, Financial, Social. By J. Ellis Barker. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $3 net. Mr. Barker is a German who has been long enough in England to naturalize and Anglicize his name; to sit at the feet of Mr. Chamberlain, and imbibe the fiscal and economic and other Tory doc- trines associated with Mr. Chamber- lain’s name since 1903, and to become a member of the Constitutional Club. The English “Who’s Who” is silent regard-| ing Mr. Barker. It is therefore possible only to conjecture how long he has been a naturalized British subject. But it is clear that he has been in England a sufficient number of years to become possessed of the Tory idea—traditional now for a century or more—that Eng-| land is going to the dogs; and his devo- tion to his new country is so great that he appears to have made it his special | and peculiar mission to prevent the ap- palling catastrophe that is threatening not only England, but the British Em- pire. It is something of a reproach to the governing classes who have done so much for England, and for whom Eng- land has done even more, that they should have to welcome Mr. Barker’s aid in the task of saving the Kmpire from its threatening fate. But the wel- come has undoubtedly been extended to Mr. Barker. He and Mr. Garvin of the Observer and Mr. Blatchford of the Clarion, one of the organs of English Socialism, were the literary lights on the Tory side at the general election. The Daily Mail was open to Mr. Barker whenever he was ready; and many of the forebodings embodied in “Great and Greater Britain,” which is concerned with the problems of Motherland and Empire—political, naval, military, in- dustrial, financial, and social—have al- ready been published in the Nineteenth Century and the Fortnightly Review, both of which exist among other pur- poses to aid the governing classes of the Tory party in safeguarding the Empire. According to Mr. Barker, the situa- tion of the British Empire is to-day most critical, but not yet desperate. Everything depends on the British navy. Otherwise by the inexorable law of his- tory and of nature the British Empire must soon come in at the tall of the pro- cession of Phenicia, Carthage, Athens, Rome, Constantinople, the Arab Em- pire, Amalfi, Pisa, Genoa, Venice, and) would enforce on England, on Mr. Cham- berlain, to whom he dedicates hig book, and on the Constitutional Club, from whose house on Northumberland Ave- nue he dates his preface, is that “all the good things of this world, land, riches, commerce, and shipping, are not to the peaceful and feeble, but to the warlike and the strong”; that wealth and power can be preserved only by military strength; that wealth is a bad substitute for power; that money bags do not defend themselves; that “neglect of the army and of agriculture has been fatal to all great commercial states of the past from Phenicia to Holland; and that large towns devour the strength of the country.” Mr. Barker is convinced that Great Britain and the British Empire stand at the parting of the ways. The crisis has arrived. But he is confident of a safe and comfortable future for England if she will only build a navy equal in strength to the combined navies of the United States and Germany; adopt pro- tection, because free trade means cheap labor and cheap men; give the colonies a voice and share in the administration of the British Empire by means of an Imperial Cabinet, an Imperial Navy, an Imperial Exchequer, and an Imperial Senate; and establish an army based on universal military training. A year ago 'the Tory Quarterly Review celebrated its centennial, and a large part of two issues was devoted to the history of the Review and the lost political causes to which it had since 1809 attached itself. Had Mr. Barker bestowed a couple of hours on this history of Tory propagan- da for a century past, he might have realized that the cry of the Empire’s danger is an old and well-worn one with the political party with which he is now serving; that it was raised in 1832 and again in 1846, and again whenever the Tory party has found itself out of of- fice; and he would have realized also that he could expect no shock to the English people to result from his dis- mal forebodings. A Vagabond Journey Around the World. By Harry A. Franck. New York: The Century Co. $3.50 net. On graduating from the University of Michigan, Mr. Franck started out in a cattle ship “for to see and for to ad- mire.” Until he reached Marseilles his status was that of a tourist pedestrian of frugal sort. But already, in England, France, Germany, and Italy, he had ceme to know the gentry of the road, their resorts and resources. The last of his money found him a member of the beachcomber colony at Marseilles, wait- ing his chance to work or beat his way eastward. The chance came, and our gentleman vagabond debarked at Bet- the Dutch Empire, and all her greatness' rut, whence he visited the sites of the pass away. The lesson that Mr. Barker | Phenician cities and tramped to Da-
Page 19
July 14, 1910] The Nation. 39 mascus, Jerusalem, and Jaffa. Every- where he was taken in and aided. From ne sheik who had started a collection for a railway ticket Mr. Franck escaped with difficulty. At Nazareth he stopped with the Kawar family, a most various- ly gifted and articled group. The father spoke only Arabic, two sons spoke Eng- lish, and one German, and were stout Protestants. Another pair knew, re- spectively, French and Italian, and were devout Catholics. The youngest son, well versed in Russian, held by his father’s confession, the Greek. The fam- ily showed Mr. Franck the sacred spots of the city of Jesus; returning from the visitation they pointed out “the house of the only Jew, thank God, who still dwells in Nazareth.” At Cairo there was a long wait under conditions made easy by the meeting of old comrades and new and by the liberal- ity of mission charities. Employment came after long search, and the wages were spent in a trip up the Nile as far as Wady Halfa. Here Mr. Franck could have gone on to Khartum as secretary to a Greek bishop, but, avoiding the cul-de-sac, he returned at public expense | to Port Said, where the beachcombing life was renewed. It was a question of stowing away or completing an indefi- nitely long postgraduate course at the vilest of Levantine ports. Between the canvas cover and the ribs of a life-boat on a British liner our author left the canal and got his first taste of the Red Sea. The reward for his hardships was Colombo, and that earthly paradise which is Ceylon. Here the white man, though a vagabond, is a king. Mr. Franck fell in with a sociable colony, in- cluding a Britisher, Haywood, badly wanted, on his own showing, by the American law; Marten of Tacoma, who excelled the natives as a pearl div- er and harried sharks in his morning swims, and Askins, M.A., of Dublin, en- gineer when luck served, and adept in half the dialects of the East. Here our author would have joined the police force had not his American nationality got known. Instead, by a friendly un- derstanding with the force, the Anglo- American fraternity of wanderers slept in the public garden, where they also smoked and chatted their days away. Tramping to the temples of Kandy, Mr. Franck made a remarkable deal in ba- nanas, and was opportunely relieved of twenty-eight of them by a holy pilgrim, a yogi. Whether because of this bene- faction or for other cause, the priests at the Temple of the Tooth received him with all kindness, displayed the sacred relics, and undertook his conversion. They used an argument that recalls the famous wager of Pascal: “Even if you are not yet convinced of the truth of it,” they said, “why not accept it now and run no risk of future perdition?”’ Such arguments had prevailed with U Damaluku, born Larry O’Rourke, and |widely experienced as an American roustabout. Him Mr. Franck met in In- dia in the guise of a Burmese bishop. U Damaluku gave a good account of the faith, or, to quote him, philosophy that was in him. With ease he put to flight a Christian convert. Upon the benefits of Buddhism he was eloquent. Refer- ring to his early monastic days, he said: Ivery blessed afternoon I sthudied the history of Buddha and Burmese with the ould priests. ‘Twas a foine thing fer me Before I found the thrue faith I was that blessed ignerent I cud hardly rade me ouwn tungue. To-day, bless ye, I know eight languages and the ins and outs of ivery religion on the futstool. I was a vile curser whin I was hoboin’ in the States, and ‘twas harrd te quit it. But ivery toime I start- ed te say a cuss-ward I thought of the revired Gautama and sid blessed instead, and I'm master of me own tungue now. Beside the admirable U Damaluku, an American priest met at a Buddhist mon- astery in Rangoon made but a poor im- pression. He was a horny-handed sailor and illiterate. His past was inscribed on his arms in tattooed figures that would have outdone “those on the raci- est posters of a _ burlesque’ show.” Though exact in observance, he was not ‘expansive as to his religion, which ap- parently he had adopted as a steady graft. At Rangoon, Mr. Franck and his com- panion, James, an Australian, being warned that, once in Singapore, no beachcomber ever escaped, conceived the audacious plan of cutting across the neck of Burma and Siam to Bangkok. This trip through the jungle affords some of the most interesting pages of the book. On the way the two tramps met strange isolated English engineers who had almost forgotten how to talk with a guest. From the villagers the wayfarers, after their money ran out, simply took what they need- ed. Such levies were impartially dis- tributed among many huts, and the villagers took the incursion as a joke. On the Siamese border a dif- ferent temper prevailed, and more than once the _ strangers had _ to fight for it. By a lucky chance they saved the bungalow of a European lum- ber king from burning, and were liber- ally rewarded. As deck passengers to Shanghai the two white men were mob bed, and gave a good account of them- selves, the officers of the ship being too cowardly to interfere. Here Mr. Franck caught in his hand the celestial blade that was intended for his heart, and James, with a strained back, was land- ed as a hospital case. Our author’s way through Japan was embittered by con- stant surveillance. The police took him for a Russian spy, the curious throngs molested him frequently. The formid able jiu-jitsu he never encountered, It is his opinion that one American col legian can handle several Japanese po licemen. Before accepting a verdict so flattering to our higher education one would like to know just what orders the Imperial police had in his case. A grim chapter is that which tells of the two months between Tokio and Victoria on the windjammer Glenalvon. Food, weather, and treatment were of the worst. Ten days Capt. Andrews beat about the Bay of Tokio to save a tug which he finally had to take. Once out twenty-seven sails were successively car ried away. It is a relief to be landed and out of such an atmosphere of sordid tyranny and resentment. About two years from starting author rode triumphantly into his na tive Chicago in charge of seven car loads of cattle. He brought back the camera which in the Siamese jungle had been pretty much his entire bag gage—and costume. The photographs are a very acceptable commentary on the narrative. The book is not based on journals, but is the yarn spun in the first flush of recollection. Mr. Franck writes with vividness and humor. He commands the arts of the mimic, and his vagabonds, exotic f our Americans of many tongues and hues, native digni taries of many rules and sects, fairly live before the reader. His achievement was extraordinary, calling for adroit- ness and courage at turn, and his book is no common one every Notes. Affair of Dis the Morgan's “‘An honor” has through final proofs, according to the announcement of Henry Holt & Co “Fables and Folk Stories,” Bur- William De passed stage of Scudder's roughs’s “Squirrels and Other Fur-bear- ers,” and Sherman's “Little Folk Lyrics are to be printed by Houghton, Mifflin ¢ in American Braille type for the blind Still another book on “The Tragedy otf Hamlet” is soon to appear Sherman French & Co. announce the author as Henr Frank. “The Birch Bark Roll,” by Ernest Thor ip- son Seton, and “Scouting for Boys,” by Sir Robert Baden-Powell, are to be combined into a single volume by Doubleday, Pag & Co. The John Lane Company is to issue this month a new volume of verse by Willian Watson. The book takes its name, “Sable and. Purple,” from a poem which offers tr!- bute to the late King and to his successor Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.announce ‘‘Sieg- fried,” a new volume in the list of transla- tions of Wagner's ‘“‘Nibelungen Ring’; au édition de lurve of “The Ancient Mariner and a volume of essays by Willian Trent. A complete biography of John Wilkes being prepared by Horace William Bleak- ley, who is best known as the author of “The Story of a Beautiful Duchess.” Sturgis & Walton will bring out {on the autumn “The Lady.” a series of imaginary
Page 20
40 The Nation. [ Vol. 91, No. 2350 portraits, by Emily James Putnam; and a study of New York playgrounds, by Esther The Children’s City.” \ translati Charles Recht of “The a Bohemian drama in three acts, is R. G. Badger. lisher, Eklund, of Stockholm, has national edition of the late King Oscar, which will various essays and notes travels, translation of and “Cid,” ballads. Singleton on by (‘louds ia announced The put by preparation a h the ontain, besides during his Goethe's made a “Tasso,” of Herder's ies and and ej to be by Henry are an annotated edition “Le Gentilhomme,” by Prof. Moritz Levi of the University of Michigan, and book by Dr. Crawford of the Unversity of Pennsylvania, Among the books issued Holt & C Bourge ols s00n 0 of Spanish composition rhe Lord ently changed hands, to a en- tcademy has re Alfred which By the having sold out will the Ww. Douglas henceforth the services of T yndicate have icademy H tire ontrol change 1s also lost Cros- nd 3 Oxford author, and editor of English Verse, nts of Birthday honors. He Liberal The newly made Dr. Alfred Hopkinson Man- Quiller-Couch Book of is one recipl trong also Include hancellor of Victoria University rhe publi Pater's Macmillan of a works. has begun the edition of Walter be in ten vol- 8 at two dollars the volume. The books and large, clear type, way made pleasant to to read. So far appeared, containing Marius the Epi- Company ation library to complete ime show wide margins and handle are in every and convenient three volumes have The ire Renaissance” and an.” furious suc- Thompson's posthumous that should have a papers. On the whole book including “A Renegade Poet edited by Edward J. the Ball Publish- was worth printing. Thomp- the titular paper, Is rhetorical imitation of De is rather imitation Poe in “Finis But of the critical and the essay on “Pagan- and New," its distinction real paganism of antiquity and Christian poets, is de- It was inevitable after the eas of on Francis Shelley we his stray the littl and Other Essays,” O'Brien, and issued by ng Company ons wit iD seen pretty thin, his Encomium” of some Quincey Moerstitia flat in as is the Coronat Opus.” papers are good jem: Old with etween the ts resuscitation by ldedly worth preserving Violet Clarke Heinemann), is a memorial volume to a tal- undertak- Indian Leaves,”” by (London: young gentlewoman, who, al of showed uncommon native point of view. Clarke, ented the sox duties an presi- ing dency tact and a rare apacity to grasp the Her has brought together some twenty sketches, of them hu- some of which Obvious- father, Sir George Sydenham English and colonial, moat morous and deacriptive, had appeared in London journals circle of friends may welcome Outsiders will, fresh humor and a widely diffused young women ly a large such a collection we feel, merely note a certain iiterary ambition among the of the author's class XIII Edition pretty more intelligent XIV of Secribners’ and of Volumes Memorial bring us to the middle of the complete set, which is calculated to run to twenty-seven volumes, and to the novel, “The Egoist,”’ which probably most Meredithians regard the centre of his work. may have special attractions, but in “The Egoist’” they think they come at the very heart of Meredith's views of life. The il- lustrations are three: The splendid photo- graph of the author taken by Harold Roller in 1888; Flint Cottage, Box Hill, Meredith’s home during the last forty years of his life; and View over the Gar- den to Box Hill. The last-named picture gives the view from an upper window of a room in Flint Cottage, where he wrote be- fore the building of the chalet. as Miinsterberg’s robust, if not vein of public comment bas its admirers. They will doubtless welcome his new book of essays, “American Prob- lems from the Point of View of a Psycholo- gist’ (Moffat, Yard & Co.). His subjects are The Fear of Nerves, The Choice of a Vocation, The Standing of Scholarship, Pro- hibition, and Intemperance, The Intemper- ance of Women—to wit, an undue pride in the frills of the mind and the milliner; Spiritvalism—the exposure of Eusapia Pal- ladino; the Market and Psychology, with Professor very subtle, especial regard to labelling and advertis- | ing; Books and Bookstores—the publishers urged to combine to revive the true book store; and, finally, The World Lan- guage—an admirable exposure of the cheap fallacies behind the simplified spelling movement and a destructive survey of the pretensions of language, artificial or are any traditional, to impose itself upon the world. | Here is surely topical matter in plenty, and, since the American Woman is involved, contentious issues of spectacular attrac- tiveness. In general, Professor Miinster- berg is on the of idealism against pragmatism, scholarship against dilettant- ism, rational moderation against fanatic- isms of all sorts. He traverses for America something of the ground that Matthew Ar- nold plotted for England, and in a not dis- similar spirit. The difference is in amenity. side Many will find a somewhat rasping quality | in Professor Miinsterberg’s literary manner, which is all the more trying because he is so much in the right of the questions he treats In part this unsympathetic effect may result from his writing in a language which, though astonishingly well mastered, is not his own; but were these essays put over into German there would still be, we feel, of delicate issues somewhat ruthlessly and at times superficially dis- patched, The most novel and valuable part of the book is the suggestion that by psychological experiment we can do much to detect aptitude, or its absence, for par- a sense tleular work tend a complicated loom is unfitted to man- age a trip hammer. Experiment can de- termine who will work most efficiently on a typewriter with switch-keys, who on one with the double keyboard. Simple tests would weed out the men who ought not to drive locomotives or motor cars. Evidently this is a possibility of real importance. Applied psychology might actually do for us in charting aptitudes and disabilities what the old phrenology pretended to do. One would be glad to see the idea developed lat greater length. Obviously, on Professor Other novels | The mind that can efficiently | | should be offered to all beginners at trade schools We find our author more inspiring in the laboratory than in a pulpit which he occupies with a somewhat incongruous mix- ture of dogmatism and jauntiness. It is well known to all who have occasion to use the earlier reports and appendices of the Historical Manuscripts’ Commission of Great Britain that some of the work was performed in a fashion not in accord with the historical standards of the pres- ent day. Consequently, a number of these volumes have been revised and reissued. Among the most important of them is Ap- pendix iii of the Ninth Report, first pub- lished in 1884, and containing a calendar of the Sackville Papers. The first part of the reissue was published in 1904, and now the second and final part has appeared, The nature of the papers thus calendared is too familiar to call for comment here. It |will be enough to say that they comprise the correspondence of Lord George Ger- main, secretary of state for the co’onies from 1775 to 1782; that the revision has been made by Mrs. S. C. Lomas, and that in the new volume are large numbers of important additions, to which ample ref- erence will be found in the preface. An addition to the list of source-books for the study of American history ‘3s made by Prof. Samuel B. Harding of Indiana University in his “Select Orations I[llus- trating American Political History” (Mac- millan). Professor Harding is undoubted- ly right in holding that “a great part of a people’s history, where self-government prevails, may be found in the speeches of |its public men”; and his volume of ex- tracts and abridgments will help some- what to make available a class of his- torical material whose portentous bulk, joined often to comparative inaccessibility, |bhas unquestionably repelled all but the most zealous teachers and students. With the way in which Professor Harding has performed his task, however, we feel less satisfaction. To say that the editor of a book of selections is entitled to the benefit lof the doubt in all questions of inclusion or exclusion, is, of course, to utter only a platitude of criticism. The range in this |case is certainly wide, reaching as it does from James Otis to Booker T. Washing- ton, and the work of condensation has been skilfully done. We frankly think, how- ever, that such documents as Washington's Farewell Address, and the inaugural aJ- dresses of Jefferson and Lincoln, are nardly to be classed as “orations” in any proper sense, or, for that matter, that they bear any such relation to the political history lof their times as do, for example, Web- | ster’s reply to Hayne or the Lincoln- Douglas debates. Neither can it be said that Henry W. Grady’s oration on the new South, or Booker T. Washington's Atlanta | speech on the race problem, interest!ug 1s | they are as examples of modern American | oratory, exercised any special influence on |the course of events, or contributed very | directly to the formation of public opinion | The inclusion in the volume of an introduc- ‘tion on oratorical style and structure, to- gether with some notes on the various speeches, both contributed by Prof. John Mt. Clapp of Lake Forest University, con- | firms us in the impression that the editor | has often been guided in his selection quite |as much by the oratorical interest of a George Meredith | Miinsterberg’s showing, psychological tests | piece as by ite political significance.
Page 21
July 14, 1910] The Nation. Popular works on Pilgrim history are numerous, but with the exception of “The Pilgrim Fathers” of Dr. John Brown, which gives disproportionate space to the English end of the story, nearly all have been writ- ten by Americans with American interests in view. Miss Winnifred Cockshott, of St. Hil- da’s Hall, Oxford, had an excellent oppor- tunity, therefore, not of discovering new facts, but of recounting old ones for the tenefit of English readers. Her propor- tions are good, the pages devoted to life in England, Holland, and America standing, respectively, in the ratio of about one, two, and three, while her desire to give adequate setting to her pictures leads her to fur- nish rather a broader outlook, particularly in what relates to Holland and the Dutch, than the reader will find elsewhere. She has made an honest attempt to understand and describe the institutional and economic life of the Plymouth colony and to avoid an excessive devotion to merely biographi- eal details. Her work is to be commended as ir the main well-written and accurate. Still, it is always difficult for an English writer to handle our colonial history with precision, and Miss Cockshott has contrib- uted her sheaf of blunders. Her account of the settlement of Connecticut shows that she has not fathomed the mysteries of the Warwick Patent, the Saybrook colony, and the relations between Saybrook and Con- necticut, while her implication that Vane, Peters, and the younger Winthrop took part in the Connecticut settlement betrays the hand of the novice. Miss Cockshott is evi- dently not familiar with some of the minor questions under discussion, such as_ the identity of Capt. Jones and of the May- flower itself, and she manifestly knows no- thing of the Bradford letter of 1623 or the suit of 1624, to which the Plymouth colony was a party, the papers regarding which throw light upon the early history of the) colony. Her version of the passenger list of the Mayflower, intended to be an exact copy of that given by Bradford, shows many departures from the original manuscript. (“The Pilgrim Fathers”; G. P. Putnam’s Sons.) Prof. Henrik Schiick, who has been pay- ing a flying visit to this country as therep- resentative of the University of Upsala, where he holds the office of rector mag nificus, has been mentioned in these col- umns from time to time as the author of several volumes of essays. These he has grouped into two series, “Ur gamla papper,” and “Ur en resandes anteckningar’’; the essays collected in the former series, which has already reached the quite respectable number of eight volumes, deal with topics in Swedish and comparative literature, as well as with Shakespearean subjects, which have always greatly attract- ed Professor Schiick since in_ the early eighties he published his life of Shakespeare, the only comprehen- sive work about that poet in Swedish. The other series contains, as the name implies, studies resulting from or written during his travels abroad. In 1884 he visited Rome for the first time, and nearly ev- ery summer since then he has paid long- er or shorter visits to that city, always studying, always adding to his knowledge of its history. All the three volumes in this series contain Roman sketches; those in the two latest are to a certain extent connected, dealing with the excavation in the Forum, with legends about Virgil ana St. Peter, and with the Swedish saint, Bri- gitta, who lived in Rome for nearly a quar ter of a century. The last few volumes of Oscar Levertin's “Skrifter’’ contain his early short stories articles on Scandinavian and foreign lite- rature, and, in the latest volume so far is- sued, a number of editorials from the Stockholm Svenska Dagbladet, now re- printed under the title “Fér och mot.” Among the literary studies, most of them printed as book reviews in Svenska Dag- bladet, those of French writers are the most interesting, particularly series dealing with Anatole France |mot” we find Levertin’s indignant protest |against the awarding of the first Nobel | prize in literature to the late Sully-Prud- | homme, and two or three other articles jin which he pays his compliments to \the Swedish Academy and its lead jing man, C. D. af Wirsén. The vol |ume contains also an interesting 'of Swedish belles-lettres during the |of Oscar the second, and the prose-poem in which he surveyed the nineteenth century at its close. The opening essay is entitled | “To Henrik Schiick on hig Fiftieth Birth- | day.”” Levertin hails, and rightly, his friend and former teacher as the first to introduce | modern scientific methods into Swedish lit- | erary history, and as having taught the les- son that “in science there is nothing smal! except for him who sticks in the mud of |small things,”’ and, finally, as the preacher |}of humanism, who, though himself a mod ern kulturmdnniska with the critical point of view of the nineteenth century, can speak with warm sympathy of ‘‘the dreams of the pious friar, or the tracts of the aus tere Lutheran theologian.”’ the In “Fér och survey reign “L’Epopée castillane A travers ia littéra ;} ture espagnole”’ (A. Colin, 330 pages, 3.50 | francs), by Ramon Menendez Pidal of the Spanish Academy, is the French text in which the author delivered his lectures at j}the Johns Hopkins University The in- terest of the matter was appreciated the time. The book has a complete index of proper names and texts, and tabular lanalyses of each lecture, considerahly |} hancing its value for reference at en- Dr. William James Rolfe of Cambridge, Mass., died last Thursday at the home of his son, Charles J. Rolfe, in Tisbury, | Vineyard Haven, aged eighty-eight years. He was born in Newburyport, Mass.; spent his boyhood at Lowell, and was educated at Amherst, which he left at the close of his junior year in order to work in Maryland. He went back very soon to his native State 'as principal of Day’s Academy at Wren- tham. Here and at other schools where he | taught, he commenced what afterwards be- lcame his mission in life, the teaching of | English literature, a_ thing un- ‘heard of at that time. In 1859, Rolfe re- |eeived the honorary degree of A.M. at | Harvard, and in the following year went to |live at Cambridge, where he spent the rest ‘of his life. From 1869 to 1890, Dr. Rolfe was one of the editors of the Popular Science | News, and since 1890 he had had charge of “Shakespeariana” in the Critic, besides contributing to the North American Re- view, Poet-Lore, and other literary and scientific periodicals. As an editor of school texts he is best known. In addition to his almost 41 Shakespeare in forty volumes, a “Hand- book of Latin Poetry,”’ and the “Cambridge Course of Physics’’ in ten volumes, the last two works being prepared in collab- oration with other editors, he brought out annotated editions of selections from the poems of Gray, Goldsmith, Milton, Words worth, and Browning; the “Lady of the Lake,” “Marmion,"’ and “The Lay of the Minstrel,” and a complete edition of Scott’s poems; the “Sonnets from the the “Lays of Ancient Rome,” “Childe Harold,” ‘" The Princess,” “In Me- moriam,” and “Idylls of the King,” and two volumes of selections from Tennyson's other poems, besides a twelve-volume édi tion de lure of Tennyson, in the prepara- tion of which, as in his previous editions of Tennyson, he had valuable suggestions and assistance from the poet and his son He has also edited six volumes of a series of “English of a more elemen tary character, he the “Satchel Guide to Europe.” Last Portuguese,” Classics" and revised annually Prof. Julius Jung, the historian, died re cently at Prague, at the age of fifty-nins Among his works are “Leben und Sitten der Rémer” and “Rémer und Romanen den Donaulindern.”’ Georges Berger riti essayist and for merly professor of wsthetics and art at th Ecole Nationale des Beaux-Arts, died last Saturday, aged seventy-six years. He was a grand officer of the Legion of Honor " member of the Institute, and devoted most of his life to promoting the study of art Besides contributing frequently on this sub ject to the Journal des Déhbats, he wrot: in 1879 “L’Ecole francaise de peinture dé puis ses origines jusqu’A la fin du regne de Louis XIV,” and was a member of many public art committees Science. The small book on “The Family Health,” by Dr. Myer Solis-Cohen (Philadelphia Penn Publishing Co.), may be commended as a good guide for the individual as well as for the family. The hygiene of the community and the household is _ briefly touched on, most of the book being given up to personal care and conduct All the important points concerning clothing, f drink, rest simple and sensible fashion, well calculated to develop a rational attitude towards daily There also a brief but ficient statement of about all that the aver age layman needs to the treatment of disease. ne fads to advocate, ond and clear his presentation there perhaps a little more detail would be helpful, and an would the usefulness of an excellent book “How to Keep Hens for Profit’ (Mac millan), by C. 8. Valentine, is a disappoint ment if one expects systematic of fundamentals. The beginner who this book will find the plan fragmentary, while its phraseology will be beyond him, and most of its information obscure until! he has had not merely instruction, but also experience, in practical poultry raising When, however, he has reached the point where he begins to ask questions based on ood, exercise, and are treated in a problems. is suf know The author has unusually happy Here concerning 18 in and index add to treatment buys
Page 22
2 f observation, and when he has mastered the poultryman’s vocabulary, Mr, Valentine’s book will be of value to him. It discusses the breeds of hens—giving a fair the advantages of each—and new and unusual methods of many On and poultry ms the book is sensible and commands Mr. Valentine has no fads His the Indian is of much present interest. (‘onsidered Book of poultry- ng this is an excellent production, but leading statement of cons kind ders diseases present ropi fidence, for to advance chapter on Runner duck as a Second ra » beginner can depend on it a.one. An extract from Voltaire, “Madame, ongez A la santé surtout, c’est IA ce qu’ il faut vous souhaiter—la beauté, la grandeur, esprit, le don de tout est perdu, quand on digére mal; c'est l’'estomac qui fait was evidently well understood accomplished of Tilly- She left sixteen notebooks of recipes gathered lands and from many fs It her whenever any- good came upon the table to get the ict manner of cooking it from the maker; accordingly reliable, prac- an arduous to select the best from such a mass rial, but Miss C. F, Frere has com- book, indexed and admirably for the searcher after a particu- an article (‘The Clark of Tilly- & Co.). And the primarily for a will give the keeper ménage many new and de- It is rather noticeable that in these days of abstemliousness from sweets ilmost a fourth of the book is composed of recipes for and puddings, des the plaire, les heureux,” the mle mistress pre in several was custom hing cipes are It must have been ot mate piled a well arranged, manner of cooking Book of Lady P. Dutton though designed lat (Cookery pronie”’; E, re pe large establishment, of a simpler | ous dishes, sweet dishes cakes and ices, and Water Gardens,” by the late Meyer (Country Life Library, im- Scribner), in its opening chapter by its unsparing con- formless upheavals on Thus enabled to dispassionately, the are frequent gardening which The book a careful skill with which built up from its it concerns itself large, the householders Rock I W ported illay by all prejudice of the front the subject that landscape il nation too many lawns ipproach reader discovers there in couditions can best be met by rock gardens. written to its -illustrations, ily of which reveals the finished garden is beginnings Since mall gardens as well will as bring to many solving vexatious difficulties lot, and should help to unsatisfactory corners means of non the two-acre many bare or the 1 The ben most pleasing features of small management of water and the of liscussed hers book the wall are chapter has been heath garden, by itifvying average stone A vided to the on the WW Dhallis ore \ national works of the Giulio Cario in the current year, and will include got only the (now rare), but scientific and scientific papers in the Biblioteca Oll- In order that this edition complete, the committee in charge that information regarding the in any public or pgivate library edition of the Count will be issued some time Itallan mathematician, di Fagnano, Produzion! matematiche” both and important also other writings, polemical d veriana of Pesaro ecently scovered may be request existence The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2350 of manuscripts, including letters on mathe- matical or scientific subjects, by this writ- er, be sent to the chairman, Prof. Vito Vol- terra, Via in Lucina, 17, Rome. Dr. Johannes Gottfried Galle, the astron- omer, died on Monday at Potsdam, at the age of ninety-eight. He is remembered as the first man actually to see Neptune. In 1846, after Leverrier had calculated that it must surely exist, Dr. Galle began a search for the planet, and on September 23 of the same year announced that he had found it. He contributed frequent articles to scien- tific periodicals, especially on comets, three of which he himself discovered. Drama and Music. The Mystery of Hamlet, Prince of Den- mark. By Robert Russell Benedict. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $1 net. Although coming from tine hands of a self-confessed layman, this monograph forms interesting reading, and is en- couraging, because of the author’s habit of turning, in case of any doubt, direct- ly to the text of the play, instead of being influenced by preconceptions. For its main contention, the book expresses the belief that Hamlet’s procrastination is to be explained by his desire, before doing anything else, to awaken his mother’s conscience and to save her. To make this the chief cause for his dis- traction is doubtless to simplify Ham- let’s character too much, and to do vio- lence also to probability. For why should Hamlet not have believed that a speedy murder of the King would be the quick- est way to bring his mother to her senses? Mr. Benedict insists, further, that Hamlet, after having threatened “to put an antic disposition on,” never really feigns madness at all; that his thought of feigning madness was suggested to Shakespeare by earlier forms of the story, and that Shakespeare after hav- ing inserted this detail saw later that a highly strung temperament, like Ham- let’s, when wrcught upon by such dis- tressful circumstances, would of neces- sity furnish enough whimsicality of ut- terance to throw the King off the track without the help of any pose. In answer to this suggestion, one recalls Hamlet's words to the King with reference to the body of Polonius. It is hard to expiain them except by the theory of feigning. That Hamiet was well under thirty, the age ascribed to him by the grave- ‘digger, is another point urged by Mr. Benedict. He finds that throughout the |play, exceot for this one instance, the | Prince is referred to as young, and be- ‘lieves that only extreme youth, that of nineteen or twenty, will account for | Hamlet's idealism and impetuosity. He, therefore infers that the grave-digger’s |words are more than counterbalanced, ‘and that they may have been inserted later with reference to the age of. Bur- bage, the first reputed actor of this rdéle. Here, again, the author is on perilous ground, and seems not to be aware of the loose way in which both “young” and “old” were employed in Elizabethan days. Mr. Benedict tries in conclusion to prove to the world that he does not make an infallible idol of Shakespeare, and has strictures especially on the “To be, or not to be” passage: In the first place, we must acknowledge |} that it adds nothing to the development of | the story nor of Hamlet’s character. It is | plainly an interpolation, disturbing the con- | tinuity of the dramatic interest, for we last left the Prince planning for the play and intent upon the detection of the King and the performance of his duty. He now }comes before us dreamily meditating upon the cxpediency rather than the moral right of a distressed soul to end its earthly trou- | bles by suicide, ‘it has not occurred to the writer, ap- |parently, that Hamlet has for the mo- /ment sunk to the depths of despair and i3 contemplating the thought of actually taking his life, rather than live up to the part which he must otherwise play. This lack of understanding is of a piece with a confusion, earlier in the book, caused by ignorance of the word “hon- est” in the sense of chaste. In his “Studien tiber die Genealogie und Psychologie der Musiker’” (Wiesbaden: Bergmann), Oswald Feis discusses the ques- tion of the origin and nature of musical talent from genealogical and psychological points of view. The fact that the wonder- ful ability of many distinguished musicians, Handel, Mozart, Bellini, and Richard Strauss, manifested itself in very early childhood would naturally suggest that it was inherit- ed, but in scarcely a single instance have we any evidence of it, nor did these youth- ful marvels, in general, transmit to their posterity their own precocity. In only two or three families is such a tendency percep tible, notably in that of John Sebastian Bach, where it was operative in a greater or less degree for more than three cen- turies (1550-1869); also, on a much smaller scale, in the families of Puccini and Pfitz- ner. Neither Robert Schumann nor Richard Wagner belonged to the class of youthful prodigies, but it is hardly correct to state that their musical tastes and talents were recognized comparatively late in life, since both of them became conspicuous in this respect as students of the gymnasium. The assertion of Hegel that musicians are, as a rule, “poor in ideas,” is regarded by Feis as wholly unjust, and the facts which he adduces in refutation of it may be accepted as authentic and conclusive. A prominent characteristic of musical composers is their untiring industry, which accounts for their remarkable productivity, even when they are subject to severe physical sufferings, like Chopin, or die an early death like Mozart and Schubert. This interesting series of psychological studies criticises in the concluding chapter Lombroso’s theories of geniue and insanity, and finds them due in a great measure to the distinguished psychiator’s habit of observing the actions
Page 23
July 14, 1910] The Nation. of men of genius through a magnifying | glass and of thus making them appear ab-| normal and unsound. Art. Douris and the Painters of Greek Vases. By Edmond Pottier. Trans- lated by Bettina Kahnweiler, with a preface by Jane Ellen Harrison. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $2.50. The study of Greek vases has hith- erto been confined almost exclusively to the professional archeologist. The average layman interested in Greek art has devoted his attention mainly to the | appreciation of Greek sculpture and perhaps of Tanagra figurines; but Greek vases have not been popular. The rea- son for this cannot be said to lie in the vases themselves, since they con- tain rather the elements which one might have thought would make them appeal to any student. They satisfy the artistic sense, both by their beautiful shapes and by the spirited paintings with which they are decorated; and moreover the subjects of these paint- ings bring us into intimate contact with Athenian life, illustrating as they do the daily occupations of the people, as well as their mythology. And, though these vases belong to one of the “minor arts” of Greece, they are virtually our only means (with the exception of some painted gravestones) of obtain- ing any idea of the higher art of Greek paintings during that period, since none of the famous works of Polygnctos or Zeuxis have survived. The fault there- fore lies not with the material itself, but with the treatment it has received. The books hitherto written on the sub- ject have all been of so technical a na- ture that they have had little interest for the general reader. Edmond Pottier, whose book appeared in French in 1905 under the title of “Douris et les peintres de vases grecs,” has been the first to address himself to the reading public, and the success ot his attempt is the best guarantee for the potential popularity of Greek vases. In a volume of less than a hundred pages and with twenty-five good illus- trations, he gives a fascinating account o1 the life of the Athenian potters and of the methods of their work, and then proceeds to describe in detail the work | of Douris, one of the best known of Greek vase-painters, selected as repre- sentative, both for the large number of vases signed with his name (twenty-| eight), and because his work reflec's the contemporary art of painting most fully. Nor is the popular element of the book its only attraction. Coming from the pen of so distinguished an archeologist as E. Pottier, it carries | with it an authoritative weight which dent. Miss B. Kahnweiler has earned the gratitude of many for making this book accessible to the English-speaking public by her excellent translation. “A bibliography of American books relat- ing to prints and the art and history of en- graving,” by Howard C. Levis (London), is a privately printed book of eighty pages is- sued in an edition of 150 copies. The ma- terial was prepared for Bourcard’s Kesai de Bibliographie (recently noted in these columns), but is presented here with more bibliographical detail, such as full titles, with indication of lines, size of book, and notes. The entries are arranged on the dictionary plan, in one alphabet, with cross references from subjects to authors, twen- ty-six such references under “Book Plates,” for instance. Errors and omissions appear to be surprisingly few in this well compiled | and printed little volume. The ninth annual exhibition of the Penn- sylvania Society of Miniature Painters and the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts will be held at Philadelphia from November 12 to December 11. The jury of selection consists of Colin Campbell Cooper, Ludwig E. Faber, Clara F. Howard, Amy Otis, and Mabel R. Welch; the hanging committee of Herman Deigendesch, Sarah Yocum McFad- den, and Amy Otis. Finance. THE RECENT DECLINE. There is reason to hope that the financial situation has about reached its period of convalescence. It would be futile to predict an early return to satisfactory conditions, but that affairs are at last headed in that direction seems a warrantable conclusion. The ‘decline of anywhere from 15 to 50 points which the stock market has experienced in 1910 has a significance not to be ig- nored. Extraordinary measures have been applied to rectify an over-extension of credit, and the indications all are that the result is already highly bene- ficial. The recent fall in securities came at the most opportune period. The great hysterical movements in the stock mar- ket are apt to come later in the year. The 1907 panic occurred in October, just at the time when the marketing of the crops is most active and when general industry is making ite arrangements for a twelvemonth. The autumn of 1902 was another nervous occasion, owing to the fact that Europe had begun to dis- trust our credit and had served notice to our bankers, who were swinging a tremendous load of underwritings on foreign capital, that there must be wide- spread liquidation on this side of the Atlantic. The 1910 situation is an im- 'provement on both 1907 and 1902, not only because the process of rectification has begun considerably in advance of the period of the year when the sever- 43 ket, but also because Europe's attitude toward us is less austere. Europe has found not a little to criticise in our stock market methods in the last two years, but the things she has seen there have really borne no comparison with those that excited her apprehension in 1907 and 1902. Credit has been over extended here, but with no such disre gard of moral and economic considera tions as in the two previous periods. The expansion of credit since 1907 has, in short, been mainly for the attain ment of legitimate industrial ends, though we have not been wise enough to see that these ends could not be at tained in the time we set for the task. Our precipitancy has been clearly at tested by the events of the last few months, and particularly by the events of the last few weeks. Nevertheless, al though most persons, both here and abroad, are to-day convinced that such a readjustment of conditions is neces sary as will admit of a larger volume of business being done on a given amount of capital than in recent years, there is nothing like a general lack of confidence in the fundamental stability of our financial and industrial situation. It is that fact that differentiates 1910 from 1907 and 1902 and 1893. There has been a great amount of speculation in the past year, but it has been for the most part built up on solid expectations, rather than on the froth of some earlier periods. The earnings of our railways have been of such magnitude as to in cite speculation in Wall Street. It was a rash speculation, because it failed to take into account the coédrdinate facts of the financial situation, such as the inability of the banks permanently to finance an upward movement of such proportions, and the probability that higher wages and supplies would soon er or later deprive the railways of a very large part of the profit from their great increases in gross earnings. Never theless, the fact remains that the large railway earnings of the past year denote that we are a vast and expanding na tion, from which the largest economic results can be expected in the future. While it is regrettable that the West- ern land speculation should have been allowed to run to such extremes, it must be borne in mind that this, too, has been based on expectations of a most encour- aging nature. An, extraordinary amount of farm land has changed hands at greatly enhanced figures, resulting in a heavy drain on the supply of capital which 1s ordinarily at the disposal of general business. But this eagerness for \farm lands has sprung from the palpa- ble fact that agriculture is our most prosperous industry and seems likely to continue so. The margin between what our farmers produce and what our popu- lation consumes has diminished to such ‘an extent as to raise predictions that we will appeal to the more serious stu-|est strain is made on the money mar- must shortly cease to be an exporting
Page 24
$4 nation. prediction That may or may not be a safe Taking a broad view, the recent craze for farm lands is an en- couraging indication, for it undoubtedly points to a larger competition in agri- more intensive methods of farming, larger crops, and, in the end, it may be hoped, a decreased cost of liv- ing. Still, it is a fact that the move- ment has been at the expense of the general industry of the nation, more so than can be tolerated, despite the good results that may eventually be expected culture, from it. Mnough has perhaps been said to show that the financial situation of 1910 really differs in kind from that of 1907 and 1902 and 1893. There has been an over-extension of credit, but it has in no marked degree been the product of ras- or sheer folly. The people who made such large drains on the mo- market have for the most part sin- cerely aimed to “deliver the goods.” But it may be said of them, and of the banks liberally supplied them they have had zeal There has been an cality have ney who have so with funds, that without knowledge. altogether unequal distribution of the working capital of the United States in the past year; and not only that, but more loanable capital has been allotted to industry than was warranted by the amount of gold at the disposal of the Ready This Week The Poetic New World A companion to THE POETIC OLD | WORLD. Compiled by Lucy H. Humpurey. Cloth, $1.50 net; leather, $2.50 net; postage 8c. additional. autiful uniform popular A bh with the pocket volume, “OPEN ROAD.” to collect here life yesterday tried poems dealing rhe has the beast wry editor with and in our country, and While Explorers,” such “The Elevated” and “A Subway Express” are also sung Henry Holt & Company to-day the book opens with poems rhe as on up-to-date things 4W. 33 St. « « « « + « « oy >a oy « « « « oa « ¢ 4 « « « : « « oy « oa « * The Best Books 4 Hender’s Gaide to the Choice of the Beat Avatinhble Books (About 100,000), By William Swan Sonnenschein Third Edition Entirely Rewritten Te Re in Three Parta. Part I. #3.50 net. Ready. dificult to exaggerate usefulness of this work or to too highly the Industry of the Turn to what subject we find the best current books reader may consult, and London Spectator. “It would be the praise compiler we the their prices.” G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS, S*Yoxpon may, which |way for some weeks The Nation. [Vol. 91, No. 2350 banks. That we are now all prepared to admit. With such a drop as we have had in the stock market, with such a stoppage | as has been put of late on the money | drain to farm-land speculators, and with such a curtailment in manufacturing and general industry as has been under past, there is ground for the assertion that the na- tion is well on the way to a complete | rectification of its economic situation. No doubt, much still remains to be done in abridging the chasm that exists be- tween the purchasing power of the na- tion and level of prices fixed by the pro- ducers of the necessaries of life, but there is good reason to suppose that this can be accomplished without the accom- paniment of hysterical conditions. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Askew, A. and C. The Rod of Justice. Brentano. $1.50. Baron, E. D. The Inscrutable Woman; an Autobiography, 1896-1910. Broadway Pub. Co. Bridge, C. Sea-Power and Other Studies. London: Smith, Elder & Co Butler, H. C., and Prentice, W. K. Syria. Pub. Princeton Univ. Archgwological Exp. to Syria in 1904-5 and 1909. Leyden: E. J. Brill Carnegie, acter. Dutton Dawson, L. H Sieges. Dutton. W. H. Churchmanship and Char- $1.25 net. A Book of Battles and 50 cents. COLUMBIA STUDIES IN HISTORY, | ECONOMICS AND PUBLIC LAW New Volumes Just Published Volume XXXVI, No. 2, THE TRANSI- TION IN VIRGINIA FROM COL- ONY TO COMMON WEALTH By CHARLES RAMSDELL LINGLBYy, Ph.D., Instructor in History, Dart- mouth College. Price, $1.50. Vol struction in Texas, by CHARLES WIL- LIAM RAMSDELL, Ph.D.; No. Transition in Virginia from Colony to Commonwealth, by CHARLES RAMs- DELL LINGLEy, Ph.D. Cloth, $4.00 Volume XXXVII, No. OF REASONABLENESS IN LOCAL FREIGHT DISCRIMINATIONS By Joun Maurice Criark, Ph.D., Sometime Fellow in Economics, Co- | lumbia University, Instructor in Polit- | ical Economy in ‘Colorado College. | Price, $1.25. | Volume XXXVII, No. MENTAL TRAITS OF THE NE- GRO ; Research into the Conditions of the Negro Race in Southern Towns, A Study in Race Traits, Tendencies | and Prospects. By Howarp W. Opum, Ph.D. Price, Paper covers; $2.00; cloth, $2.50. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York &4e Astor Eaiioal ! of Poets in the beet for echoole and colleges. 99 vols. List price, 60c, per vol.; price to schools, 40c. SEND FOR LIST. | Thomas Y.Crowell &Co., New York 36, comprising, No. 1, Recon- 2, The} Complete, | 1, STANDARDS | 3, SOCIAL AND | Ellis, R. Professor Birt’s Edition of the | Vergilian Catalepton. Lecture del. at Corpus Christi College, June 3. Harvard University. Quinquennial Cata- logue of the Law School, 1817-1909. Cam- bridge, Mass. | Hawke's Systematic Telegraph Codes. Lon- don: Effingham Wilson. Keane, J, A. Brambles and Twigs of Song. Broadway Pub. Co. $1.50. | Kerlin, R, T. Theocritus in English Lit- erature. Lexington, Va.: Robert T Ker- lin. $1.50. | Lock, R. H, Recent Progress in the Study of Variations, Heredity, and Evolution. Second ed. Dutton. $1.50 net. ' Moss, F, The Fifth Book of Pilgrimages to Old Homes. Didsbury, England: Fletcher Moss. Phelps, R. S. Skies Italian. Minneapolis: Edmund D. Brooks. Ruley, C. N. The Confessions of Linda Poindexter. Broadway Pub. Co. Sachs, H. Merry Tales and Three Shrove- tide Plays. Trans. by W. Leighton. Lon- don: David Nutt. Sadler, S. H. Infant Feeding by Artificial Means. Third ed. Dutton. $1.25 net. Savage, E. A. The Story of Libraries and Book-Collecting. Dutton. 75 cents net. Scott, H, F., and Van Tuyl, C. H. A Cesar Composition Book. Chicago: Scott. Fores- man. Seymour, C. Speaking in Public. $1.25 net. Sieveking, I. G. A Turning Point in the Indian Mutiny. London: David Nutt |Thompson, R. E. The Historic Episcopate. | Phila.: The Westminster Press, $1.50. | Van de Water, V. T. From Kitchen to Gar- ret. Sturgis & Walton. 75 cents net. | Who's Who in America, 1910-11. Chicago: Marquis & Co. $5 net. Withers, H. The Meaning of Money. Dut- ton. 3d ed. $1.50 net. Young, D. H. First Aid to the Sick. Dut- toa. $1.25 net. j Dutton. =o | MR. OWEN JOHNSON’S Lawrenceville Stories | The Varmint | “It’s a wonder. ... And the joyful pathos of the last installment | | choked me all up—it was so true, and | generally and specifically bully.”— Booth Tarkington. | 12mo, 396 pages. Illustrated by Gruger. | $1.50. The Humming Bird One of the most amusing baseball | | slang stories ever written. 12mo, il- | | lustrated. 650c. The Prodigious Hickey | Originally published as “The Eter- nal Boy.” The First Lawrenceville Story. 12mo. Illustrated, $1.50. | THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., NEW YORK | BEST facilities for supplying engiss BOOKS Correspondence solici LEMCKE & BUECHN ER Established over 50 years. 30-32 West 27th St., New York S—All out of print BOOK books matter on what subject; write me, sta eet book ever German come John Bright St.