The Nation 1910-06-30: Vol 90 Iss 2348

Page 1

- GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH. — PRICE TEN CENTS. ‘The THURSDAY, JUNE 30, 1910. VOL. XC.—NO. 2348. Little, Brown & Company's New Publications A powerful new novel by the author of ‘‘Quo Vadis,’’ ‘‘ With Fire and Sword,’’ etc. “Henryk Sienkiewicz has added an- “A novel that will command a careful WHIRLPOOLS other epic of his native land to current reading from thoughtful people. It has By HENRYK SIENKIEWICZ. fiction. ‘Whirlpools’ deals with all the brilliancy of dialogue, of nar- WHIRLPOOLS the agrarian strikes and socialistic re- rative and description that character- By HENRYK SIENKIEWICZ. volts that are agitating Poland. The izes some of this writer's best work.” romance of the book is developed with Boston Herald, intense realism.”—Baltimore Sun, “*Whirlpools’ is full of the spirit of “Never has Sienkiewicz created 4 mohind y* . ; sweeter or more natural girl than *oland, and follows the grcping of the Marynia. The mature and thoughtful WHIRLPOOLS new thought through the darkness of an intellectually chaotic transitional pe- riod. The book is one of great power.” —Philadelphia Ledger. will find in it both emotional and in- tel'ectual interest of unusual quality.” —Chicago Record-Herald. HENRYK SIENKIEWICZ. Cloth, $1.50 By ** By far the best and most important book Mr. Oppenheim has written.’’ THE ILLUSTRIOUS PRINCE By E. PHILLIPS OPPENHEIM. THE BOSTON TRANSCRIPT says: “A new Oppenheim book has come book. It means a story that will be read One literary editor in a personal letter to the publisher, says: “Let me thank you for the personal than one more Even the to mean something more enjoyed and remembered. — Fm — = = villain in this tale is a very fascinating figure.” written and swiftly-moving story, “The enue sie — wanes a _ . Illustrious Prince.’ It is one of the few THE NEW YORK TIMES says: “Mr. Oppenheim has won the high regard in which he is held among readers of his $1.50 bits of present-day fiction that I have actually read with a keen sense of in- terest.”’ and he has told no better story than this Fully IJtustrated. Cloth, as a story-teller, by his gifts latest book.” By the Winner of the Nobel Literary Prize of 1909 THE GIRL FROM THE MARSH CROFT By SELMA LAGERLOF. A Book of Legal Reminiscences REMINISCENCES OF A K. Cc. By THOMAS EDWARD CRISPE. Mr. Crispe, King’s Counsel, is a well-known member of the English bar, who has been associated with the famous judges of the Victorian Era, and with celebrated wits whose personalities and bons mots make excellent literary material. Crown 8vo. 850 human Cloth, $3.50 net honor her fellows can bestow.”—San Translated by Velma 8. Howard. “A writer who can so adorn lowly life, who can penetrate unfalteringly to the soul of the good, and can ennoble existence in its humb'‘est stratum, is worthy all the Argonaut. Cloth, $1.50 Francisco AN AMERICAN BABY ABROAD By MRS. CHARLES N. CREWDSON. This romance of a Kentucky beauty “has the charm of novelty and is just the book for summer reading.”—Phil- adelphia Inquirer. Illustrated, $1.50 OVER THE QUICKSANDS By ANNA CHAPIN RAY. “Undoubtedly the strongest novel she has written.”—Boston Transcript. Frontispiece, $1.50 PASSERS-BY By ANTHONY PARTRIDGE. “An unusually clever and interesting mystery story, moving between Paris and London.”—Independent, »n . ad Le P Ittustrated, $1.50 Illustrated by F. C. Yohn. $1.50 By EMMETT DUNN ANGELL. CALEB TRENCH “Tus book meta every_reqaltemen THE UP-GRADE completely There are more than 100 By MARY IMLAY TAYLOR games adapted to every phase of activity , . = ee . - ? of children and yonth for indoors and By WILDER GOODWIN. “It is a p easure to commend a novel out, from the kindergarten to the col “Good as a life story, good as a love so wholesome and of such genuine in- lege.''—Journal of Education, Boston story and good as a story of adventure.” —Washington Star. IWustrated, $1.50 THE SNARE OF CIRCUMSTANCE By EDITH E. BUCKLEY. “One of the most novel and enter- taining tales of mystery that have been put between covers.”—Pittsburgh Post. Illustrated, $1.50 THE PURSUIT By FRANK SAVILE. “A tale of adventure as rich in thrills as Dumas’, and almost as readable.” —Chicago Inter Ocean, Illustrated, $1.50 THE RED SYMBOL By JOHN IRONSIDE. “A remarkable story of Russian in- trigue and underground politics.”—Phil- adelphia Ledger. terest and merit.”—-N. Y. Times Frontispiece, $1.50 THE RED HOUSE ON ROWAN STREET By ROMAN DOUBLEDAY. A mystery story that “has fun as well as thrill, and is original.”—The Outlook. Illustrated, $1.50 JUST BETWEEN THEMSELVES By ANNE WARNER. “Deliciously fresh and sparkling. The best effort of the author of ‘The Re- juvenation of Aunt Mary.’ "—Philadel- phia Ledger. Frontiapiece, $1.50 PLAY: GAMES for the KINDERGARTEN, PLAYGROUND, SCHOOLROOM AND COLLEGE ") pictures $1.50 met; poatpatd $1.61 LITTLE, BROWN & COMPANY, 34 Beacon St., Boston, Mass.

Page 2

ii The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2348 The Nation Educational. | THE TEMPLE CLAssics 1G ANE “ 233 VOLUMES HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. | aweeat Rorron: Ismam Gozancs “an 2 A Park Street np ty Ss Washington — o aa ree n ve., coor | 166 Fifth . New York 414 Bid., Mi Deapolia | | frontispiece, a decorative title-page, and a A WEEKLY JOURNAL. 203 Mich. Ave, Chicago 311 Swetiand Bid. Po rtiand | ribbon bookmark; where advisable, wa of iretnacees icecemen ieee | | cemeew ne seen oo | Bead to any address above for Agency Manual. | .: te Goth, cach estame boy yet “OUNDED IN 1865. - . r Bary, Mawr, Pennsylvania. | 31 = fh nn geen 5 & COMPANY (Entered at the New York City Post Office os| The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School ust STREST. NEW YORE. second-class mail matter.) Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other colleges for | women. Small classes supplemented by careful indi- vidual lnstepetion. Seatmese aa Tenwie ana basket. | PASSION Pa ay OBERAMMERGAU. with ryo awr requiremen ennols basket ball, Twelfth year opens Oct. 5, 1910. mm , B-- best Py GF gg The Nation |e published and owned by the New | of Anton La i seat); Ist class rail re- York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY | } Eo ; text-book; all tips; President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul | Supplies schools of all — | Passion Play and driving tour to Royal Castles Elmer More, Editor pee. Se ee & es tions. | tn Bavarian lands, best accommodation; alto HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St.,Albany, N.Y | Rete 4 fore, SO r. Crocker Bester - Ente meee sores = . ‘ copal Chureh rk City. Ad- Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in E ETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL. | dress MRS, rch of ppb SOURDAN. Leopoldstr. as sere the United States or Mewico; to Canada Bethlehem, Pa. Prepares for leading col | 9 Ill, Munich, 93.60. end to foreign countrice comprieed tm the leges. Catalogue. H. D. Foering, B.S., Pri pecipal Postal Unton $4.00 iddresa THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. FOREIGN sine noo. "Saat Publication Office, 20 Vesey Strest. JUST PUBLISHED ~ Stet, ESSENTIALS OF CHEMISTRY — CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. By RUFUS P. WILLIAMS, Instructor INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS in Chemistry in the English High THE WREK ....cccccseeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeees 641° Stnool, Boston, Mass. | WHY WORRY? and THOSE NERVES? By GEORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth,$1 net, each. Price $1.25 EDITORIAL ARTICLES J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. ee oe is on A complete survey of elementary Performance and Credit eeeee chemistry, gradually giving the pupil, Plain Honesty Inspiring vesees 646 by means of easy but stimulating STENOGRAPHER Serious Humorists : -+ 645 steps and many questions, a thorough GEO. B. COCK rhe Case of George Meek -» 646 knowledge of the subject. FRANKLIN BANK BUILDING, PHILADELPHIA SPECIAL ARTICLES GINN AND COMPANY Mee A EE et William Lloyd Garrison COnRESPONDENCE: Soils and Crops 1805-1879. Lest We Forget English Romanticism ...se. 651 By D. O. BARTO, College of Agriculture, Party Platforms ‘ ; 651 University of Illinois. Cloth. 103 pages. The Story of his Life told by his (har-A-Ban sees 651 Price, 50 cts. . ’ 2 A brief laboratory manual of agriculture that; Children. Illustrated with over oe whe ee 8 — te ey | — and aims to it ‘- 1 , - place this most modern of ail sciences on a par 3 LITERATUR with physics, chemistry, and other high school | 40 portrat 8, views, etc 4 vols., Cruises in the Bering Sea, being subjects. 8vo, gilt top, $8.00 net. Records of Further Sport and D. C. HEATH & yee Publishers rave Tr ind Camping 1 BOSTON NEW Y CHICAGO Alask The Ne “ 7 North " pale _ | “It is, for the anti-slavery record, final; }and the service done to our national history Some Account of a Woman's Jour- ney Through Canada to the Arctic Sehool Advertisin jis as great as that to a father’s memory. Handbook of Polar Discoverles- ‘Its one eminent trait, however, is its jus- rent Life in Siberia An Explorer's a adventures tn Tibet PKR | tice.”"—Atlantic Monthly. : See ‘oh tele dr a | “In fact, Southern history is not complete Ml eee ie NATION [without this work.”"—Atlanta Conatitution The é « © " ’ sittes ‘ ze 5 + eeeenee an Contets sate Wan as “A masterpiece of modern historical bi- Central America and Its Problems 654 The ation, in its special field of |ography. . . . To call the work a mine of The Life of Mary Lyon --. 654 . information would be to convey a false im- Sumerian Administrative Documents political and literary criticism, is un- | preaston it is rather a well-arranged li- 0 7” Fer? f as oa J 55 from, tne Second Dynasty of Ur. ei like any other periodical, American| brary in which attendant hands are always | sresene to point the way to the exact thing or foreign. It is taken by read-| 7 Stantiy. the eats. chile on ing clubs and literary associations | instructive as the driest manual, is as in- ‘teresting as a romance.”—Boston Advertiser. *,* For sale by booksellers. Sent, postpaid, be found on file in every library Of on receipt of price by the publishers. NoTES ..» 656 ScIENCH 658 in a large number of places, and may | DRAMA AND Music A Garland to Sylvia _.... 669} importance in the country. There i tQUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY pea are probably few weekly sees pemnen ae uae ane Sine, ‘Winiiinnee: inikaiid ih! aimed aia geo Whose columns offer so favorable ar opportunity for reaching an audience, SARPLE COPIES OF FINANCE: . . . tobe Ser gO a interested in educational matters. THE NATION three weexs WITHOUT CHARGE. | ***Coples of The Nation may be procured tn Th N ° | Parle at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Op@ra; to ation | ADDRESS London of B. F. Stivens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar | ! Square, Charing Cross 20 Vesey St., New York City THe Nation, 20 Vesey Street, N. Y, Books OF THE WErEEK.. Jaee 661 eye

Page 3

June 30, 1910] The Nation. NOW READY ae a ae Conditions of Progress in Democratic Government By Hon. CHARLES EVANS HUGHES Governor of the State of New York. To every man who appreciates his civic responsibility this volume, containing the Dodge Lectures of 1909-1910 at Yale University, will be most welcome. of the distinguished author. It is inspired with the statesmanlike character “No person is better fitted to give advice or to point out practical ideals in American government.” —Lowell Courier-Citizen. “One feels confident that it is likely quite to serve its purpose—since it puts the case ‘of decency and justice’ in a manner clear and eloquent through unpretentiousness.’’- Price, $1.15 net; postpaid, $1.25. (IN THE SAME SERIES) Chicago Inter Ocean. The Hindrances to Good Citizenship By Right Hon. JAMES BRYCE British Ambassador to the United States. “Mr. Bryce has written much excellent political literature; but we doubt whether any wiser words have come from him than those in which he describes and analyses enemies of self-government disguise themselves.”—London Times. “There is no American citizen who would not be the wiser for reading this book.”—New York Sun. Price, $1.15 net; postpaid, $1.25. AT ALL BOOKSTORES. the many forms in which the YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS 70 Fifth Avenue, New York City 135 Elm Street, New Haven, Ct. High Grade Law Pninting Briefs, Corporation and all other Legal docu- ments printed accurately and with dispatch at prices below those of most other offices—for particulars apply to The Nation Press Hew Pork Cvening Post Co., Prop. 20 Vesey Street, New York City SHAKESPEARE’S LOVE STORY By ANNA B. McMAHAN. A most original study of the lover and his sonnets. Beautifully bound in decorated boards, with Serretions, oe rice paper. Boxed net $ lo A. C. MeCLURG & CO., CHICAGO. The only biography of the founder of modern Socialism, KARL MARX: HIS LIFE AND WORK, by John Spargo, $2.50 net; $2.70 carriage paid. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Filth avenue, NEW YORK Read L. M. Montgomery's New Book KILMENY OF THE ORCHARD By the author of “ANNE of GREEN G ~~ ll (23d Printing) a “ANNE OF AVONLEA” = (12th Printing) WILLIAM J. TUCKER'S PERSONAL POWER “Vigorous and wholesome talks to college men.""——Kaneas City Star. “A stimulating volume."'—San Francteco Chronicle. Reading Case for The Nation To receive the current oumbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Sub- stantially made, bound in cloth, with Tag Na- | TION stamped on the side | {n gold. Holds about one | volume. Papers easily | and neatly adjusted Sent, postpaid, on re ceipt of 75 cents, THE NATION, 20 Vesey St., N. ¥. City” 28 VOLUMES READY THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE Ed. by PORTER-CLARKE. Text of 1623. Full notes and variants. Ready :—‘‘Midsommer Night's Dreame,"’ ‘‘Love's Labour's Lost,’’ “Comedie of Errors,’’ ‘Merchant of Venice,"’ ‘‘Macbeth,"’ “Julius Cwsar,"’ “‘Ham let," “King Lear,"’ **Twelfe Night,"’ ‘‘As You Like a” Henry the Fift,"" ‘“‘Much Adoe About Nothing,”" “Romeo and Juliet,"’ ‘‘Tempest,’’ “Othello,” *‘‘Winter’s Tale,"’ ‘‘Shrew,’’ ‘“‘Two Gen tlemen of Verona,’’ ‘‘Coriolanus,’’ ‘‘Merry Wives,'’ “All's Well,”’ “Measure for Measure,"’ ‘Antonie and Cleopatra,’’ ‘Titus Andronicus,"’ “‘Tymon of Athens,"’ ‘‘Pert ." “Cymbeline,"’ ‘*Troylus."’ Cloth, 75 cents; Iimp leather, $1.00 per volume, postpaid. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., New York A new book on Games PLAY: GAMES FOR THE KINDERGARTEN, e SCHOOL ROOM AND COLLEGE By Emmett Dunn Angell. The most practical book on the subject, describing over 100 carefully graded games, many entirely original. With over 50 illastrations. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.63 LITTLE, BROWN & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON Do you knowthe Beacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 cents net; by mall, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphiet. Small, Maynard & Co., 21 Beacon St, Boston AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis Some recent unbound vols. of A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. WANTED The Nation

Page 4

iv The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2348 THE NEW MACMILLAN BOOKS THE BEST NOVELS TO TAKE AWAY WITH YOU Winston Churchill’s “A Modern Chronicle” lhe best picture in fiction of New York’s leisure class, in the city and its suburbs, at country clubs, and at Newport, etc. “Nathan Burke” “Unquestionably powerful.” By Mary S. Watts Illustrated, cloth, $1.50 “One might read novels till the crack o’ doom, and then some, but he would find few, if any at all, as fine as this,” says a well-known editor. Gertrude Atherton’s F. Marion Crawford’s Cloth, $1.50 “Tower of Ivory” “Its author has done no more remarkable work for sustained intensity.” Cloth, $1.50 “The Undesirable Governess” A delightful book for the holiday-maker, full of unexpected, amusing situations, infectious in its light-hearted gayety. Robert Herrick’s “He paints a picture . It is a strong book, and one that will arrest attention.”—Brooklyn Eagle. Illustrated, $1.50 “A Life for a Life” . that stands out from its surroundings and burns itself on the vision Cloth, $1.50 by | NEW MISCELLANEOUS BOOKS American Government and Politics By PROFESSOR CHARLES A. BEARD. Assoc. Prof. of Politics, Columbia Univ. A capital book, not too elementary nor yet too technical for educated citizens who de- sire to review our political system. Cloth, 12mo, $2.10 net Social Insurance A PROGRAM OF SOCIAL REFORM. The Kennedy Lectures for 1910, delivered in the School of Philanthropy by HENRY ROGERS SEAGER, Professor of Political Economy in Columbia University. Cloth, 12mo, $1.00; by mail, $1.08 Wage-Earning Women By ANNIE M. MACLEAN, Ph.D., Pro- fessor of Sociology, Adelphi College. The collected results of the work of 29 inves- tigators in all parts of the country during one year—June, 1907, through May, 1908. Cloth, $1.25 net; In the Crtisen’s Library. by mail $1.35 A New Edition of Walter Pater’s Works Now Ready. The Renaissance Marius the Epicurean Volumes II. and II]. The ten volumes of this handsome set in decorated cloth and gilt tops are appearing monthly, beginning with June, 1910. $2.00 net per vol. (carriage extra) The Autobiography of Princess Helene von Racowitza The life-story in her own words of the fa- mous heroine of Ferdinand Lassalle’s tragic love-story. Illustrated, cloth, $3.50 net; by mail, $3.65 Governmental Action for Social Welfare The Kennedy Lectures delivered in the School of Philanthropy by JEREMIAH W. JENKS, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor of Economics and Politics, Cornell University. Cloth, $1.00 net; by mail, $1.09 Volume I. Published THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “*:"%!** een —-

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JUNB 30, 1910. —— The Week. Fifty years ago there was held at the old Front Street Theatre in Baltimore a session of a party convention that made world history. The Democratic National Convention at Charleston, which had failed to nominate a candi- cate for President, and which was al- ready plainly facing the prospect of a rupture in the party that would mean @ rupture of the Union itself, had ad- journed to meet again at Baltimore on June 18. But—as had been expected by all who looked the gravity of the crisis in the face—conciliation proved impos- sible, and on the fifth day of the con- vention the Southern members walked out and held a meeting in another hall. The regulars nominated Douglas, the seceders Breckenridge, and the die was cast which resulted in making the “irre- pressible conflict” a bloody reality. The great party insurgencies of those thrill- ing times make present-day struggles over postal savings banks, or the de- tails of railway-rate regulation, seem tame and innocuous. But each age has its own problems and conflicts, and there may be enough perilous matter underlying our economic tussles to de- velop all the stature of heroic conflict in the fulness of time. Meanwhile, we can afford to smile at some of our own excitements when we contrast them with the events of fifty years ago. It will not do to take the endorse- ment of Gov. Harmon for the Presiden- cy, by the Ohio Democrats, as merely a good-natured and unmeaning bringing forward of a “favorite son.” There can be no doubt that the Ohio Governor stands as the most promising Presiden- tial candidate of his party now in sight. His firm and clear attitude on the tar- iff, his vigor and honesty and skill as administrator, his success in run- ning down rascals and making political an corruption in Ohio unsafe as well as odious, mark him as a man to be reck- oned with. In presenting him before the country the Ohio Democrats called spe- cial attention to his own phrase, “guilt is personal.” These were the words he used when, as special counsel appointed by President Roosevelt, he urged a legal process against Secretary Morton of Roosevelt's own Cabinet. It will be re- membered that the delicate Roosevelt would not permit such rough methods to be used against a friend. As he is said to have it, he “would not throw Paul Morton to the wolves.” But it is certain that Gov. Harmon's rugged expressed honesty and directness on that occasion he Demo- recalled to his credit if of the crats two years from now. The diate question is that of his reélection would be were to be the nominee imme- as Governor; but national questions cer- tainly will be injected. That it took cover corruption in a pending bill, is not a blind senator to dis- wholly to the credit of the senators with normal vision. Yet the charges made vy Senator Gore were too specific to be ig- nored. The evidence that interested par- ties were trying to get scandalous and fraudulent contracts of theirs with the Indians of Oklahoma validated by Con- gress, and that they used, or offered to use, bribery in order to compass their ends, was too strong for Congress to disregard. It was a good thing to or- der a thorough investigation of Senator Gore’s detailed allegations. Stealing money from Indians is a shade worse than robbing children. Children have parents to look after them, but the In- dians have no one—unless they can find real guardians in the government whose wards they are. It is for Congress not merely to clear its own skirts by dealing rigorously with the members implicated, but also to show that the defenceless In- dians need not appeal in vain for their rights. A voluminous report has been made by the Senate committee on the increas- ed Lodge is chairman. The full document is not yet available, but a somewhat comprehensive summary has been given cost of living, of which Senator in the press dispatches. There is to be a minority report later on, made by the Democratic members of the committee, who are not content with the conclu- sions drawn by the majority members from the figures. To pass judgment on the report upon the basis of the sum- maries given in the press dispatches, would be rash. One statement, for ex- ample, that appears in the epitome giv- en in many papers is on its face absurd. Speaking of who'esale prices of food- products, it says: A comparison of meat prices in the United Kingdom and the United States shows that bacon in 1900 73.4 per cent. higher in the United Kingdom than in the United States, and that in 1909 it was 31.5 per cent higher in the United Kingdom than in the United States About the ex isted in comparing beef, mutton, wheat, and was Same ratio corn, The members of the committee may not be great economists, but they can scarce ly have made just this statement. Cer tainly, the price of wheat and corn, and of beef cannot the wholesale price and other have been, higher by meats, either in 1900 more than the merest trifle in the Unit- ed Kingdom than in the United States; is possible for the English refrigerator or in 1909, though it price to be somewhat lower than the American price, owing to our tariff. In the main, however, the report is doubtless sufficiently represented by As might have newspaper accounts. been expected, the influence of the tar- iff in the matter is wholly denied; but it is surprising that so extremely subordl- nate a place should be given to the in- creased production of gold as a cause of the high prices. This latter circum- stance must be accepted as in some de- gree an evidence of good faith; some persons of muck-raking proclivities, it may be remembered, have been seeing in the propagation of the doctrine that gold production is the main cause of the high prices a deep conspiracy on the part of the Trusts and the tariff-pro- Had suspicions, we tected interests. we entertained these dark should now be ready to make a humble apology, and accept the Lodge report as a complete exculpation. But since tnat is not the case, we are constrained only to remark that, however complete may be _ the bona fides of the committee in this mat ter, we have no reason to belleve that their judgment on the subject of the in of is entitled to a particle of weight. prices If matter fluence gold production upon the full should contain calculated to alter this estimate of their authority in such a matter, we shal! be report glad to acknowledge the fact.

Page 6

‘The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2348 642 Now it is the ultimate avant ownership of ships that Mr. Bryan advo- cates. In an article contributed by him American Exporter, he ar- but takes the to the July gues against subsidies, view that, inasmuch as it is essential to do something to restore the American the government business. “Govern- ment ships,” “would help our “Our Government can own a commercial marine, should go into the he writes, trade.” few transports and use them in time of peace to develop trade. They could be ised to carriers on conditions which the Government to train seamen and the policy could be opped any time if found unprofita- bli Nothing could better illustrate the happy-go-lucky nature of Mr. Bry- an's mind and statesmanship. Here is a subject upon which it is evident that he has thought little, yet he throws out a large and revolutionary suggestion with the cheerful air of a man for whom such things as details do not exist, though in such a matter the details are every- (hing. But none of these things troubles Mr. Bryan. In his finest happy-thought manner, he advises us to embark light- heartedly upon the great venture, and then if we find that it does not prosper, to abandon it with equal light-hearted- ness. And yet people complain that there ig a dearth of Democratic leaders! would enable There are encouraging signs that the agitation against technical absurdities and unnecess having its effect. the court made short work o justice ts recently, a contention in the Lorimer case, whic amounted almost to a plea laws of Illinois brib virtually that under the ery is not a crime. discourage the worst type of modern de fence—that built entirely on technicali ties and not at all on a real denial! of the has taken the Kiernan case, clouded with fictitious by a of pettifogging lawyers, and dis- crime. In Oregon, issues score posed of it in an hour and a half. Now comes a case in Kansas which exhibits true Western audacity. A Kansas stat- ute defining embezzlement had been printed with the word “State” spelled “estate.” A lower court held that, as the word “State” was not in the statute, embezzlement by a State officer was not a crime. But the Supreme Court of Kansas held that the illiteracy of the people, and that the manifest intent of the statute should be adhered to. The law is common sense. This is a sound ideal of justice, but one with too little of the refinements of quibbling to suit many of our courts. The bribery trial at Chicago in con- nection with the Lorimer case has also brought out into striking relief that cther curse of our judicial system—the abuse of the right of appeal. It has been morality and common sense of the whole | ‘typesetter should not prevail over the | standards and methods of Tom John- son’s Mayoralty which set in with the election of the present Republican May- or; and the vindication of Kohler is therefore matter for congratulation in its bearing on sound municipal gov- ernment in Cleveland. But the wider in- terest in Mr. Kohler turns on his extra- ordinary initiative and efficiency in car- rying out his special views of police ad- ministration. His work in this direc- tion, whether open to criticism in some of its aspects or not, is worthy of study by municipal authorities everywhere. made manifest that counsel for State Representative Lee O'Neill Browne, charged with giving $1,000 for a Lort- mer vote in the Legislature, have not done all they could to secure a favorable verdict for their client. The reason ap- pears in the position taken by Browne’s principal lawyer, who “has insisted from ‘the beginning that he is not concerned ‘materially over the outcome in the crim- | The English playwright, Henry Ar- thur Jones, has lately been making re- ‘marks that deserve attention. He as- iserted, what is indeed matter of com- ,mon knowledge, that there has been a ‘marked “decline in the art of speaking ‘blank verse on the English stage.” Yet this is the very foundation of any toler- ‘able school of Shakespearean acting. Mr. inal court, as he has made out a legal | Jones recalled his own experience of case for his client to stand on ina bigh- | Shakespearean productions during the er court.” Here is as frank ang as out- | last thirty years, and declared that the rageous an affirmation as we can recall rule was to hear the great passages of a lawyer's intention to take advan- | “merely mangled and mumbled.” Too of- tage of the technicalities which may win | ten a similar verdict would have to be a circuit judge which was 'as Chief of Police of Cleveland, will be | ‘him his case in a higher court without regard to the essential merits of the question. According to this view, which regards conviction or acquittal in a low- |er court with indifference, the jury sys- tem is reduced to absurdity. For if ‘the higher court may be confidently accused is only a survival that has long | as an expensive rudimentary organ in lour system of judicial procedure. The news of the unqualified acquittal of Chief Kohler, and his reinstatement received with sincere pleasure through- out the country. There was abundant reason to suspect from the beginning that the charges against him were the result of malicious fabrication, but it was a good thing to have them brought out into the open and disposed of by/ full legal inquiry. It appears, further | —what was also fairly evident from the beginning—that the attack on Kohler. was part of the reaction against the lost its meaning. And not only the jury, | This did much to Ut the lower court itself, stands forth | “passed upon the rendering of significant prose on the modern stage. The failure to grasp accent and pause in verse passes over into prose dialogue, and re- sults in that entire displacement of em- phasis and absence of articulate and ex- pressive delivery which so frequently gsary delay in our courts of | counted upon to undo what the lower/|torture the ear of a sensitive theatre- In Chicago, | court has decided, it is obvious that the goer. Whether it be the “star” system or f| icalling in of twelve good men and true h ‘to pass on the guilt or innocence of the atre or the extinction of stock compa- ithe disappearance of the repertory the- nies that is chiefly at fault, the melan- choly fact remains that an art which is based upon good speaking seems more ‘and more to neglect it in ways that de- serve worse reproaches than those ad- dressed by Hamlet to the players. The Chicago Record-Herald is excited over what it calls the “ridiculous honor- ary degrees,” not because it thinks them lout of place but because it finds them ‘badly named. “Has not the time come for a little modernity and vitality in the system of honorary degrees itself?” Miss Addams, the Record-Herald argues, is an author and public educator, but such a | degree as, say, master or doctor of practical paranctpnad and applied social science would |mean much more in her case than that of | master of arts. Here is Oberlin giving de- grees of doctor of laws to the Wrights, pion- |eers among air conquerors, The Wrights

Page 7

7 « ' June 30, 1910] deserve all the honors that Oberlin can con- fer, but nothing can make them doctors of laws. They were repairers of bicycles a few years ago. Why should not a degree be established to apply to such inventors, mechanical geniuses, daring apd resource- ful experimenters, as they have shown themselves to be? This is pretty heavy girding at nothing in particular. Once the degree is admit- tedly “honerary,” what difference does it make what its two or three letters spell if behind them is simply the desire to confer generous recognition? In Eng- land, distinguished chemists, states- men, brewers, soldiers, ship-builders, and poets, all end up as lords. In France they all become chevaliers or command- ers of the Legion of Honor. Here we do the best we can with an M.A. or an LL.D. Master of Practical Sociology would be an attempt to define that in- definite thing we mean when we give Jane Addams a degree. It is all causd honoris. Among the more important laws enacted were those giving greater advantage to foreign mining interests; facilitating the colonization of public lands; validating for- eign educational degrees conferred upon native students; improving the consular and diplomatic services; encouraging the construction of artesian wells throughout the country, and providing for the coinage of 18,000,000 bolivars in gold and silver. What country can it be, the work of whose Legislature is thus recapitulated upon its adjournment? But for the word “bolivar” we should not look for it in South America at all; and even so, it must be outside that terrible Caribbean area in which revolutions and counter- revolutions are the only public events of interest, unless it be the robbery of the people by the government for the time being, and the imprisonment and execu- tion of those not content with the pro- cess. But the date-line of the dispatch from which we have quoted is Caracas, Venezuela, June 27; and the body that itself peaceful and apparently virtuous meas- has been occupying with these ures is the Venezuelan Congress. Cas- tro’s country was unquestionably for years a horrible example of the depths to which South American misrule and violence were capable of descending; and yet it now seems that it was a wise thing to let Venezuela live and work out a better state of things, rather than gob ble her up and make her an everlasting problem. In a letter to the London Economist The Nation. Lord Eversley—better known as George John Shaw-Lefevre, long one of the lead- ing public men of England—subjects the increase of naval expenditure to a searching criticism. The cost of the navy for the current fiscal year, 1910-11, will exceed that for the preceding year by about $28,000,000, and that for the year 1908-9 by about $38,000,000, the to- tal naval appropriation in the present budget being nearly $200,000,000. This is four times the amount annually ex- pended during the decade 1870-80, and double the amount of the expenditure during the years 1880-1890. But Lord Eversley falls foul not only of th!s enor- mous increase taken as a whole, but of certain of the particular applications of the money. He points out that the big spurt made by Germany in naval con- struction has been largely provided for out of borrowed money, with the object of making up for past deficiencies, and that after 1912 the annual increase of the German navy will shrink to modest proportions, while the British pro- gramme is based on the idea that Ger- many is to keep up the present pace. Again, if enormous increase in the con- struction of new ships is justified on the ground that existing ships are becoming obsolete, Lord Eversley asks why the old vessels are not put out of commis- sion, thus reducing the expense of up- Indeed, it is in the vast cost of the personnel of the navy keep and personnel. that he finds perhaps the greatest griev- ance; the number of men in the navy is now 132,000, a great force maintained at the cost of the nation and withdrawa from industrial work. The programme for future years is kept a secret; a new policy by which, says Lord Eversley, “the only persons hoodwinked are the taxpayers of this country, for foreign governments have no difficulty in getting underhand information;” but it is cer- tain that 1911-12 will make a large ad- vance over the swollen figures of 1910-11, the prospective increase in the appro- priations on account of the building of Dreadnoughts already undertaken being, in itself, at least $13,000,000 Announcement of a new treaty be- tween Korea and Japan tends primarily to raise the wonder that Korea should still treaty,or Japan should still have any have anything to give away by thing to take. The latest convention con fides to Japan the entire Korean polic: 643 administration. A unified police system is to be created under the autbority of a commander of gendarmes. This move would indicate that despite the lack of disturbing news from Korea recently, the grim work of “pacification” has by no means been brought to an end. It is one of the marvels of folk-psychology that a people so notoriously lacking in cour age as the Koreans when it comes to open fighting at fair odds, should be so steadfast in carrying ona guerrilla war their Japanese masters fare against when the odds are so hopelessly against them. Japan's methods of maintaining peace and order in Korea are d ribed in the handsomely printed and bound “Second Annual Report on Reforms and Progress in Korea,” issued by the Japa nese Resident-General’s off at Seul The basis of Japanese authority in the peninsula is the garrison army of a di vision and a half. A garrison gendarm erie force of some 2,200 Japanese and 4,000 Koreans, under the command of a major-general and charged with func tions of “high and ordinary police,” cov ers the country like a network. The regular police force in Korea con- sisted in 3,171 natives. Our report state 1908 of 1,837 Japanese and that, in view of the “complicated” conditions ex isting in the country, a policeman in Korea is a good deal more than what the name ordinarily signifies. He some times acts as public bailiff “in the mat ter of distraining properties,” and a po lice inspector or sergeant may serve as court prosecuting officer in a district where no such functionary exists. If in spite of garrison army, garrison gen darmerie, and police, aided by such mod ern devices as “political telephone-lines” designed for use against the Korean in surgents, the latter persist in holding the fleld, the that their ranks are conclusion is ur scapable made up of others than brigands, pirates, and “forest rob bers,” as the report asserts. With char acteristic Japanese precision, promi nence is given to a detailed table of casualties in the campaign again Korean insurgents. It shows tha rou July, 1907, to the end of 1908, the Jap anese lost 179 soldiers, gendarm« and policemen killed, and 277 wounded. Of the insurgents, 14,566 were killed, and 8,728 surrendered. The figures quent testimony to Korean courage and resolution

Page 8

644 PERFORMANCE AND CREDIT. Mr. Wade Ellis, chairman of the Re- publican Executive Committee of Ohlo, is promptly out in an interview with the assertion that Congress has kept all the Administration’s pledges, and that nothing remains but to count up the big majorities by which President Taft will be sustained in Ohio and everywhere else. This is a trifle premature. There can be no doubt, however, that the un- expectedly good record of the session has led to the revising of a great many political figures. Mr. Taft unquestion- ably came off with a much better show- ing of laws enacted than for a long time emed possible. For this result his per- sonal activity is conceded to have been largely responsible, and it cannot be denied that his prestige, both personal and political, is correspondingly height ened. They are not very delicate scales of justice in which the people roughly weigh such things; and as politics go, Mr. Taft will get most of the credit for what Congress did, just as he would have received most of the blame if it had failed to do anything. But those who strive to make a nicer estimate of performance and credit therefor must see that there is something to be done besides lumping the whole thing. In the matter of the railway bill, for example, it has to be noted that the measure which finally passed bore very little resemblance to the bill which the Attorney-General kindly drafted for Congress. In the course of debate many of its clauses were entirely rejected, oth- ers radically made over, while several new provisions were inserted. Thus, if there were to be a strict apportionment of credit, a great deal would have to be set down to the account of the insur- gent Senators, who, with the Democrats, really shaped the law in many of its main features. Nor should the exer tions of the House insurgents be over- looked. They broke down the autocrat- ic power of the Speaker’s machine, and undoubtedly contributed in that way to the passage of the railway bill in a form much more satisfactory than we should otherwise have got. Moreover, they demonstrated that it Is not neces sary to have a little clique in absolute control of the House in order to “get things done.” In praising, as he does today, the past session as one of the most fruitful in legislation that he has ever known, Speaker Cannon is tacitly The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2348 giving the lie to his former protest that the destruction of his individual power would make it impossible for the Ad- ministration to get any laws passed at all. , In referring to these aspects of the case, we have not the slightest thought of taking from the President what is his due. The general opinion in these mat- ters is likely to be pretty nearly right, and there can be no question that the general opinion about President Taft has changed very much during the past few weeks. Perhaps his fortunes were not actually at so low an ebb two months ago as most people thought, and possibly all is not so clear sailing for him now as his friends assert; but there is no dispute that he stands much better with the country, and that this is to be ac- counted for largely by his success in inducing Congress to enact so many of | the bills he favored. In the language | of his favorite sport, the President has made a fine “recovery,” after slicing badly into the long grass. but it still re- mains to be seen how skilfully he will be able to approach the November green and hole out. It is needless to go again over the list of bills which are displayed as so many Presidential trophies. To them was add- ed in the dying hours of Congress a law to compel the publishing of election expenses. This, too, was a measure to which the President stood committed, and it was presumably owing to his urg- ing that it was finally passed. It is a novelty in Federal legislation, but is in line with the most progressive State laws, and ought to prove a useful check upon inordinate or corrupt expenditure in national elections. To have been able to add this important act to the railway bill, a conservation bill, the postal-sav- ings law, the Statehood bill, with sever- al minor measures, certainly entitles the President to the felicitations which he is receiving. At one point he confesses that his programme has failed. He has not been able to compass the economies in gov- ernment which he strove for. The esti- mates vary as usual, but it seems certain that the total appropriations of the Con- gress will exceed those of the past fiscal year by from $10,000,000 to $40,000,000. If the President had vetoed the river and harbor bill, carrying more than $50,000,- 000, he would have turned the balance on the right side. And a veto would | have been highly popular. It would /have served also to deepen the impres- ‘sion of his political force and cour- age. He himself frankly says that at one time he thought it would be his duty to veto the bill, but careful consid- eration inclined his judgment the other way. He concluded that the meritorious and indispensable projects so far out- weighed the doubtful or indefensible ap- propriations that the good ought not to be sacifice1 in defeating the evil. We have no doubt that Mr. Taft took pains to reach a judicial decision in this mat- ter; and to stand by it may have re- ,quired more courage than would have been demanded by a veto sure to be ap- plauded. His determination to sign the bill, however, accentuates the bad prac- tice of holding back such log-rolling ‘measures till the final days of Congress, when there is no chance to reconsider them after a veto. If the President |could have vetoed separate items, it is ‘clear that many of those in the river 'and harbor bill would have fallen before |his pen; and in reluctantly deciding to approve, Mr. Taft knew that he was fix- ing the charge of extravagance upon a Congress legislating in a time of Treas- ury deficits. All this balancing of performance and credit is usually the preliminary to con- fident prophecies. In fact, sweeping pre- dictions are made in the press: the Pres- ident will be triumphantly vindicated at the polls; his eleventh-hour recovery will not avail to save him, and the Democrats will win a great victory in the autumn elections. The reader may make his choice according to taste and fancy. However, after a time of such political confusion as we have been going through, the wise man will be chary of He will first demand a present conditions and before deciding that the record of Congress. will be sufficient to carry the Adminis- tration through, he will want to be as- sured that the voters are going to make that record the chief issue. They may possibly vote in resentment of high prices, which Congress did nothing to lower. All told, there never was a bDet- ter time for prophets to hold their peace and to wait for that infallible wisdom which comes after the event. prophecies. guarantee’ that will continue; to Re

Page 9

: : ; June 30, 1910] The Nation. PLAIN HONESTY INSPIRING. Two public men have recently been subject to the same criticism. They do not closely resemble each other, whether in their personal traits or their political convictions, but the objection has been made to both alike that they are unin spiring. Of Gov. Harmon of Ohio it is admitted that he is upright and able, a hard worker, an enemy of rascality, a vigorous hunter down of corruptionists, but, it is added, there is nothing stir- ring or thrilling about him. A Westerner when asked what he thought of Harmon as a possible Democratic candidate for the Presidency, replied: “Oh, he’s a good man, but archaic. He is not capa- ble of uttering a note of spiritual sum- mons.” Our readers must know how often similar remarks have been made concerning President Taft. “Oh, yes, a solid and steady man, no doubt, but too easy-going and humdrum, no dash about him, no clarion appeal.” Now, we do not wish to write a word against enthusiasm in public life or bril- liant leadership and magnetic personali- ties. These things are of the highest value, and at times they are absolutely indispensable. When mighty abuses are to be attacked and uprooted we are thankful enough if some man of native energy and audacity and infectious zeal comes along to get up an excitement and rouse the masses of the people and build up a great personal following and call forth the driving forces without which radical reforms cannot be carried to completion. But such political geniuses are rare. Their rarity is one proof of their genius. And the fact that we some- times fall upon a period when there is a dearth of such men, or of the crises which call them into activity, is no ex- euse for shutting our eyes and hearts to the sturdy if less showy qualities of other men. It might be argued, in fact, that one of the evils which follow in the wake of a captivating and spectacu- lar leader is that he spoils a certain number of men. They must always, af- ter their experience with him, be set vibrating with emotion and be thrilled by spectacles of political daring, or they lose all interest and refuse to budge. If one good custom may corrupt the world, one public man all fire and dy- namics may leave behind him a set of citizens with jaded but yearning sensi- bilities, who will not be satisfied until they again have a leader ready to drink “up Esel and eat crocodiles. It is, in a word, dangerous for the public palate to be fed so long on highly- spiced food that it rebels at good bread. Moreover, the very susceptibility to polit- ical emotion has, by the process, been nar- rowed in range. For our part we should think it a very bad sign if men like Harmon and Taft lost their peculiar ap- peal to Americans. Is there nothing to move us in the sight of a Governor push- ing aside the selfish promptings of the bosses of his own party, little and big, and going straight on to do what he thinks right? Have we lost our power to respond to displays of downright hon- esty and independence? If we have, we had better look to the state of our own souls before complaining that men in public life have become very flat, stale, and unprofitable to us. We pity that man who did not feel his pulses quicken as he read the calm but determined re- ply of President Taft to the labor lead- ers. There was no firing of the Ephesian dome about it, but there was a quiet courage in it, and a manly note, that are really as thrilling as the sound of a trumpet. We would also ask those who impa- tiently demand grand spiritual uplift and passionate appeals from their lead- ers, to note the fact that the great mass of government work is not theatrical, but plodding. It will not do for high officials to be always in a condition of lofty exaltation, seeing visions and warning the people and leading on the valiant host. There immense amount of humdrum labor which they must attend to; and what they need is not shouting and triumphant song, but the sober qualities of industry, thor- oughness, sagacity, honesty as long as the day, and sincerity as transparent as light. We cannot be always storming breaches and slaying dragons; therearea thousand and one bills to be drafted and scrutinized, appointments to be made, scoundrels to be unearthed, public char- ities to be sweetened and made more ef- ficient, leaks in the Treasury to be stop- ped, assaults on the public honor to be repelled—in short, a vast and complex work of administration to be done. And we maintain that the honest, the cour- ageous, the indomitable man sticking to these thankless but necessary tasks is really as much of a hero there in the routine dust of his official duties, and is an 645 is truly as inspiring a figure, as the other who charges the battlements and sets the crowd to huzzaing. We repeat that we are not averse to political ex- citements when there is fit occasion for them. The alarm-bell must be rung, as Burke said, and a clamor raised, when the house is on fire. But we should be ashamed to ask for glories every day, on pain of becoming indifferent, or to refuse our meed of admiration to the ex- hibition of the homely virtues which, after all, make up nine-tenths of what is important in our public life. SERIOUS HUMORISTS. Mark Twain’s memory may suffer from a certain paradoxical habit we have fallen into when passing judgment on the illustrious dead. The habit con- sists in picking out for particular com- mendation in the man what one least expects. If the world thinks of him as a great humorist, the point to make is that at bottom he was really a philoso- pher. If his shafts struck at everybody and everything, the thing to say is that he liked best what he hit hard- est. If one of his books sold five thou- sand copies, the attempt is made to base his future fame on the comparatively unknown book. The motive behind such reasoning is commendable enough. It is the desire not to judge superficially, the desire to get at the “real” man be- hind the mask which all of us, according to tradition, wear in life. It is a praise- worthy purpose, but, in the hands of the unskilled or the careless, a perilous one. And worse than either is the intellec- tual snob whose business it is consti- tutionally to disagree with the obvious. We make no attempt to classify the writer who has declared that Mark Twain, “Innocents Abroad,” was terribly in earnest; that he set out to satirize and was funny only because he could not help it, This represents the extreme of a tendency that is made manifest on every side, to turn Mark Twain into everything but what he was—a great compeller of laughter. One gets dreadfully weary of such topsy-turvy criticism. There are times when one would like to believe that Na- poleon will be remembered because he won Austerlitz and Marengo, and not because he divided up France into a vast number of small peasant holdings; that Lincoln was a great man because when he _ wrote

Page 10

646 he signed the Proclamation of Emanci- pation and wrote the Gettysburg ad- dress, and not because he kept his tem- per under criticism and in adversity. It is well to try to pierce behind the veil of Maya, but no amount of analysis can do away with the popularly accept- ed beliefs that mothers are primarily maternal, that actress s’ talents lie in the direction/ of the stage, that joyful people laugh, and that people who make wry faces are either pessimists or dyspeptics. What use is there in try- ing to make a serious book out of the “Innocents Abroad,” when we know well that the Mark Twain who wrote it was primarily a fun-maker? For ourselves, we confess that we have been unable to find any grave purpose in the “Jumping Frog of Calaveras.” We recall the Ha- wallan stranger whom Mark Twain kissed for his mother’s sake before rob bing him of his small change. We re call the horse he rode in Honolulu; it had many fine points, and our traveller hung his hat upon one of them. We re- call that other horse behind which he went driving one Sunday with the lady of his choice; it was a milk-dealer’s horse on week-days, and it persisted in travelling diagonally across the street and stopping before every gate. These adventures are easy to recall, but the hidden serious purpose within them re- mains hidden from us. The serious element in Mark Twain the man and the writer, it would, of course, be futile to deny. His hatred of sham, his hatred of cruelty, his hatred of oppression, appear in the “Innocents Abroad,” as they do in his “Connecticut Yankee" and in his bitter assaults on the Christian Scientists and the Ameri- can missionaries in China of the Boxer days. But to say that Mark Twain was a great humorist because he was an in- tensely serious man igs not true, what- ever truth there may be in the formula that humorists are humorists because they are men of sorrow. We would re- verse the formula. We would say that humorists are often sad because they are humorists, and that from much laughing the rebound must necessarily be towards much grief. If it is com- monly asserted that the humorist laughs because of the incongruities of life, it is, nevertheless, just as safe to maintain that the man born to laughter will be driven by his instincts to search out incongruities. Phere was no fundamen. The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2348 == — - tal pessimism in Mark Twain. As Mr. | portant one, and we are willing to take Howells brings out in his chapter of | reminiscences in the last Harper’s, Mr. Clemens had the soul of untamed boy- ishness. He was boyish in his exuber- ance of manner, in his taste for extra- ordinary clothes, and in his glee at earning a great deal of money: The postals [announcing his share of the daily profits from the “Gilded Age’”’] used to come about dinner-time, and Clemens wou'd read them aloud to us in wild triumph. $150—$200—$300 were the gay figures which they bore, and which he fleunted in the air before he sat down at table, or rose from it to brandish, and then, flinging his napkin into his chair, walked up and down to exult in. One thing there was in Mark Twain that was not apparently boyish or sim- ple. Mr. Howells asserts positively that in his later years Twain believed neith- er in the Christian theo'ogy, in God, nor in immortality: All his expressions to me were of a cour- ageous renunciation of any hope of living again, or elsewhere seeing those he had lost. He suffered terribly in their loss. and he was not fool enough to try ignoring his grief. He knew that for that there were but two medicines; that it would wear itself out with the years, and that mean- while there was nothing for it but those respites in which the mourner forgets him- self in slumber. I remember that in a back hour of my own when I was called down to see him, as he thought from sleep, he said, with an infinite, an exquisite com- passion, “Oh, did I wake you, did I wake you?” Nothing more, but the look, the voice, were everything; and while I live they cannot pass from my sense. Here at last we have the disillusion that | is said to dwell in the innermost soul of the great humorist. But here, | too, we seem to feel that the gray vis- ion of the future was with him not a} cause, but a result. When the buoyant soul sinks back upon itself it is apt to feel the riddle of life very keenly in- deed. THE CASE OF GEORGE MEEK. jJeorge Meek had been eighteen years a bath-chair man at Eastbourne, Eng- land, had suffered from the uncertain- ties of his calling, contributed to the So- clalist press,and nourished more ambi- tious plans of books on ethics and scien. tific progress, when, falling in with H. G. Wells, he was induced to write in- stead his autobiography. The book, “George Meek, Bath Chairman, by Him- | self’ (Dutton) has no great literary | merit; but it does tell a varied and piti- | ful story simply and with unsparing| self-revelation. Mr. Wells insists that | it is a genuine document, and an im-| him at his word. For, after all, whe- ther this particular Mr. Meek (and we confess that the very name bears the suspicion of a hoax) was ever born in the flesh, or is the creation of Mr. Wells’s exuberant and _ self-complacent fancy, he has all the pungency of life and raises questions that are very real. Society must sooner or later answer the question, “What is to be done with our Meeks?” It is easier to put such a question than to answer it. Candor will some- times impose the acknowledgment that no answer can be found. Let us assume that Mr. Meek’s miseries are, as Mr. Wells declares, highly typical, and ask what society could have done. First, plainly, we have to know Mr. Meek’s vicissitudes. Under the lax bringing up of an indulgent grandfather, he passed a happy boyhood. Handicapped at the outset by defective sight, due apparent- ly to his mother’s ignorance and neg- lect, he had a desultory schooling, but learned no trade. As opportunity offer- ed, he passed from employment to em- ployment, always of a casual sort. He was by turns a helper in a Liberal club, a baker, a theatre dresser, before he set- tled down to piloting a roller chair. At \intervals he got several kinds of relig- ‘ion, relapsing ultimately into a fatalis- |tic agnosticism. Happening upon a cou- \ple of Socialist books, he became a Fa- ‘bian. At the visionary task of blend- ing the oil of Fabianism with the vine- gar of Social Democracy, he worked with self-abnegating devotion. Idyllic intervals in an existence mostly dis- tressful were an inconclusive love af- fair and a visit to American farmer- cousins where peace and plenty reigned. Marriage taxed his very slender earn- \ing capacity. He lived much in a squalor and amid neighbors singularly ‘repugnant to a man whose tastes were essentially gentle, and on one occasion he was imprisoned for what, but for the fine name “contempt of court,” was good old-fashioned inability to pay a debt. ‘Through all his troubles he maintained a kindly and quizzical attitude towards life, consoled himself by much reading, and kept unquenched some tenuous ‘spark of literary ambition. To complete the story, a well-to-do American uncle turned up opportunely, and the Meeks will henceforth have a surer support than the chair business or mere litera- SOREN MEM eae

Page 11

. . : June 30, 1910] The Nation. ture affords. The question, What shall we do with our Meeks? is thus aca- demic, unless Mr. Wells is right that the instance is typical. George Meek is the unskilled work- man exposed to the hazards of casual employment. Yet he is both more and less than this. He has none of the stolidity that helps such unfortunates to bear their lot, nor any of the instinc- tive resourcefulness that blindly moves such laborers towards work. Being a su- perior person, in his measure an intel- lectuel, his lack of initiative is amazing; so is his lack of thrift. Mentally, he is an avowed vagabond and dilettante. Im- pelled by a desire for experience and a royal disregard for ways and means, speculative and devoid of practical in- genuity, he really belongs to a class that thrives only under parasitic conditions; is somewhat in the isolated and pre- carious position of a windflower to whom no foster-parent tree has been assigned. Temperament more than cir- cumstances is responsible for his sor- rows, and as successful dilettantism in every sphere implies a patron, the real solution of Mr. Meek’s case has prob- ably been found in the American uncle ex machina. Unhappily, this remedy cannot be gen- erally applied. Moreover, against the misfortunes of casual employment so- ciety can do something. Even a Social istic régime probably could not have prevented Mr. Meek’s father from choos- ing a worthless wife, but government as it is can help to insure to babies the use of good eyes, and by practical education may raise the general average of effi- ciency; it can improve the conditions of poor relief, and even the manners of prison warders. But it might as well be avowed that these things are pallia- tives, not remedies. They must be striv- millennial Collective without indulging Even the en for hopes. fatherly State could not reach those profounder dissonances between duty and tempera- ment, ambition and capacity, which are of the essence of Mr. Meek’s pale trag- edy. Of course, there are those who cherish the dream that the Socialist State may play the veritable American uncle-to all good fellows in distress. Even Mr. Wells, however, will admit that the question, Who shall pay? would | in that case soon cry down the futile challenge, What shall we do with our Meeks? POPE. After all this, it is surely superfluous tu answer the question that has once been asked, whether Pope was a poet? other- wise than by asking in return, if Pope be not a poet, where is poetry to be found? To circumscribe poetry by a definition will only show the narrowness of the definer, though a definition which shall exclude Pope will not easily be made. When Dr. Johnson handed down that famous decision he had no means of foreseeing, and indeed would not have cared to see, the great romantic revival which was to ask a good many times whether Pope was a poet, and was to circumscribe poetry with innumerable definitions. Even so cautious and classi- cal a critic as Matthew Arnold was re- duced by his Wordsworthian fervor into saying that, “though they may write in verse, though they may in a certain sense be masters of the art of versifica tion, Dryden and Pope are not classics of our poetry, they are classics of our prose.” Probably the majority of read- ers of verse to-day, certainly the lag- ging “official critics,” still talk of Pope in an off-hand way as a great writer, perhaps, but as at bottom scarcely a poet at all. Yet there are signs that the sounder taste of the present, grown a little weary of the old romantic presumptions, borrowed from Germany, is tending rather to re habilitate the neo-classic school. A pleas ant witness of this returning sanity may be found in the new life of Pope* by Miss Symonds, measured judgment shows by its very lack of originality—I mean nothing disparaging by the phrase the new set of the tide. E. No doubt the character of the poet and the indecorous squabbles in which his whose life was passed have had something to do with the critical obloquy that has occasionally fallen upon him If you wish to hear the worst of him—and it is pretty bad—you have only to read Professor learned in which the between and Theobald over the “Text of Shakespeare” is made the excuse for raking together half the _ scan- dalous doings of the little bard. Pro- Lounsbury’'s work, quarrel Pope fessor Lounsbury, as an eminent and honest scholar, may show just a touch of partiality for the able editor and poor poet against the slovenly editor and great poet, but, with the best of allow- ances, his exposition of Pope’s treacher- ies and endless machinations leaves the would-be moralist a sorry figure to con- template. Well, let us admit that in stooping to Truth, as he boasted, Pope showed rather a magnificent contempt for the prosaic precepts of that God- dess. As a claimant on eternity he was ° -“ ***Mr. Pope: His Life and Times."’ By George Paston (Miss E. M. Symonds]. Two volumes. ‘New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $6.60 net. 647 ready to treat the periods of passing t'me most cavalierly, antedating and post-dating his satirical thrusts quite as it suited him. All this can be admitted, yet much is left to be said on the other side. Wit was a recognized warfare in those days, and the honors went too often, no doubt, to the ablest and not to the most honorable; but the reverse is also true that dishonor has now overtaken Pope, not because he was more treacherous than his rivals, but be- cause he was cleverer—time is likely “*o take this revenge on a man for lying too successfully. Outside of that warfare Pope had his admirable traits. His filial piety was scarcely less beautiful because he made poetical capital of it. His friendship, barring the grievous and deplorable feud with Addison, was with his real rivals to fame; and the correspondence of these men, though its frank moralizing may sometimes offend an age grown dull to the distinction between reflection and affectation, is one of the great docu- ments for human nature. When Pope lay “dying of a hundred good symp- toms” he said to the priest, after taking the last sacraments: “There is nothing that is meritorious but virtue and friendship, and indeed friendship itself is only a part of virtue.” It was indeed Warburton, possi- bly as much to affront the world as to so accounted to him elevate Pope, called him “one of the no- blest works of God an honest man.” And Spence, in his Pope’s last anecdotes of moments and of Boling broke’s tenderness, raises their friend ship into something almost as beautiful faith that gave death-bed scenes of the previous cen- as the sanctity to the tury. T suspect that we should be indifferent enough to the blamable passages of his life—for it needs a rare literary detec- tive to trace his winding satirical course were it not that his greatest poems have become to us what Johnson called one of his letters, “nothing but tedious malignity.” We might forgive the man his irritable tricks, if for no other rea son, for his poor, crazy body and raw nerves; but as a poet he needs, as he gave, no mercy. There are, of course, aspects of his work which can arouse no resentment in the reader of to-day. Mr. Courthope has made a strong plea for the variety and beauty of the heroic measure in his hands; and it is certain- ly a dull taste that will not respond to the sweet felicity of that couplet in the “Rape of the Lock”: The meeting points the sacred hair dissever From the fair head—for ever and for ever; or feel the passion of Eloisa’s solitary ery: Shrines! where their vigils pale-eye1 vir- gins keep, And pitying saints, whose statues learn to weep!

Page 12

648 [Vol. 90, No. 2348 Though cold like you, unmoved and silent grown, I have not yet forgot myself to stone. II. But dexterously wrought out as such | gems may be, we shall have a feeble case for Pope if we rest his claims on work in this genre; magnificent as it is, it lacks the glamour, the last touch of magic, which even the little poets of an- other school could command in isolated passages. And for the same reason true admirers of Pope will feel a touch of im-| patience at the extravagant praise so often bestowed upon “The Rape of the Lock,” as if his consummate success in this filagree of the mock-heroic should be held up as an excuse for his failure in the more serious style. There is only one honest way to deal with him; we must treat him squarely as the poet of satire, and, unfortunately for his fame, the world has come to regard satire as scarcely poetry at all. If it is not poetry, then, indeed, Pope was but the fragment of a poet. There are, no doubt, special reasons why such a satire as the “Dun- ciad,”” which by reason of its size and scope comes first to mind, should find few and painful readers. All great poems, even those most universal in their human appeal, require a fairly high-developed historic sense for their appreciation, and it is idle to suppose that the Atneid will mean much to those who have not trained themselves to live in the Latin world, or that “Paradise Lost” can ever be interesting except to the scholar. No poem of the past is really popular, but the “Dunciad” de- mands for its comprehension an alto- gether exorbitant acquaintance with men and manners of a brief particular age. And even after the necessary minute knowledge has been acquired—and to the scholar this local habitation and name of the “Dunciad” may have a spe- cial though somewhat artificial attrac- tion—there remains the fact that the cur- rent of historic sympathy has set strong ly away from Pope, and that most of us in our hearts are stung by his ridi cule as were his living enemies. For that battle of the wits was no causeless or merely bookish event, but was part of the great political war of the land, It grew inevitably out of the ruinous divi- sions. as It echoed the drums and tramp lings, of the previous century; and if ink now flowed inetead of blood, the con teet was hardly the lesa venomous for that, or the consequences less serious. It all goes back to that terrible mis- chance which In the days of the Stuarts divided the Imagination and the practi cal sense of England Into irreconcilable camps, and separated the loyalty to symbols of authority so far from the ac tualities of force. That separation kept its character through the following cen tury, if it has not continued down to this day. Bolingbroke’s vision of the The Nation. Patriot King was a reassumption of the faith of the Cavaliers, and as it was a product of the imagination divorced of practical sense, we see its working out in the follies of George III and the loss of an empire. Walpole’s policy was at bottom a continuation of the empire of Cromwell, and as it failed to make a place for the imagination in its practice, we see the result in the gradual lower- ing of England's ideal life. At the be- ginning of the eighteenth century she was the intellectual leader of Europe; at the end she followed at a distance, I know of no more distressing fact in history than the situation which, at the critical moment of 1714, set almost all the notable men of letters on the losing side—all of them, I should say, with the exception of Addison and Steele, for De- foe at least served Harley and fell with him. Consider the consequences to lit- erature of the coming of the Hanover- ians: Harley himself imprisoned and tried for his head; Bolingbroke fright- ened out of the country; Atterbury ex- iled; Swift confined to Dublin; Parnell also kept in Ireland; Pope cut off from political life and retired to Twicken- ham; Gay nursing the insult of an offer to be gentleman-usher to the infant! Princess Louisa; Prior imprisoned for | two years, and then sinking to a frowsy degradation; Arbuthnot removed from St. James’s, and at the end writing to Pope his pathetic plea for euthanasia. It was with no mere poetic license that Pope painted the new sovereignty: She mounts the throne: her head a cloud conceal’d, In broad effulgence all below reveal’d (‘Tis thus aspiring Dulness ever shines); Soft on her lap her Laureate son reclines. Beneath her footstool Science groans in chains, ind Wit dreads evile, penalties, and pains. There is personal spite aplenty in the “Dunciad,” innumerable strokes of mean retaliation and wanton offence—these faults cannot be severed from the char- acter of the author; but beneath these motives of personal satire we shall miss the whole meaning of the poem if we fail to see the passionate warfare of the losing party of wit against the trium- phant party of practical, not precisely common, sense. Picture to yourself one of the dinners at Lord Oxford's, the guests that met there and what they stood for, or call up one of the more in- timate evenings in the apartments of that great talker and gourmand, Dr. Arbuthnot, at St. James's, and in com- parison with these think of what passed in the palace of George I and his son, or even in the chambers of Caroline, and what these things meant to letters. There is no doubt much to admire in the deistic society that Caroline affected, and an evening at St. James's, when the Queen and perhaps Mrs. Clayton drew out the conversation of Berkeley or Clarke or Butler is one of the things I ‘like best to contemplate in those days, even though, as Chesterfield and Wal- pole unite in saying, the mistress of the palace only bewildered herself in meta- physical disputes which she did not comprehend. But the master of the pal- ace, like his own master, Sir Robert, had, I know, “a contempt for Belles Let- tres, which he called trifling,” and the Queen herself, I remember, in place of 'the poets she frowned upon or neglect- ‘ed, showered her favors upon the sad 'thresher-poet Stephen Duck, whom she -made librarian of her grotto, “Merlin’s 'Cave,” in Richmond Gardens. George called the grotto “silly stuff’; what he ‘thought of the poor favorite who was | patronized to suicide, I do not know. | In the contrast of Queen Anne’s reign with that of the Hanoverians lies the |real meaning of the “Dunciad,” and therein is the excuse for its bitterness. The pity of it is that politically, at least as we contemplate affairs within a nar- 'row range of years, the Hanoverians were right, and as they seem to us right, we are drawn away from sympathy, even ,of a literary sort, with the satire that |exposed the intellectual bareness of the land. III. But there is still a deeper cause of (our distaste than the old echoes of fac- | tion and our political incompatibility. A great change has come upon us in our attitude toward human nature itself, and, curiously enough, Pope himself is one of the prime movers of this revolu- 'tion which has carried us away from the very comprehension of his own princi- pal works, For there is this paradox in ‘the philosophy of Pope. On the one hand, we have his contemptuous treat- ment of mankind, as if his satires were no more than a long development of the text of Machiavelli that “ail men are caitive |cattivi, captive to the base im- pulses of egotism], and are ever ready to use the malignity of their spirit, when they have free opportunity.” While on the other hand, in his “Essay on Man,” inspired by the dubious optim- ism of his friend Bolingbroke, we have |the deistic conception of the world as the best possible creation and of men 'as naturally altruistic in desire and as needing only liberty from restraint to develop into unselfishness of action. Now deism, which, it should be noted, was the express theme of the philosophers and divines who hung upon the court ‘of Caroline, won the day, altering our whole conception of society and our maa- ner of judging the individual. We, have in the course of the last two hundred years acquired a kind of tenderness for humanity, which causes us to shrink from the old _ theo- logical notion of absolute evil in the world, and also from the literature of _the moralists which was based on the |same belief. With that tenderness, if it | be not the source of the feeling, our in- 0 ae a pect

Page 13

June 30, 1910] dividual sensitiveness has increased enormously, so that we take in a quite personal way the attacks of moralist and satirist on mankind in general. We can listen to the singing of the still sad music of humanity with a delicate self- pity, but from the philosophy of a Roche- foucault or a Machiavelli we start back as if a hand were laid on a concealed sore. It is certainly true that he who has imbibed deeply this modern human- itarianism will be repelled from the literature of which Pope’s satires are 80 perfect an example; in those attacks on the meanness and folly and dulness and venality of the world he will suf- fer a kind of uneasiness, and, taking his revenge by decrying them as a base form of art, will turn for consolation to what Cowper calls the charity that soothes a lie, And thrusts the truth with scorn and anger by. I would not that Machiavelli ex- pressed the whole truth, any more than did the deists, but it may as well be recognized that, without some lingering suspicion of the eternal deceitfulness of the heart and some malicious glee in the unveiling of the deceit, no man shall feel at home in the old battle of the wits. Only the absence of that sus- picion and glee can account, I think, for the apathy toward Pope’: masterpiece, the “Epistle Dr. Arbuthnot,” which is at once pro- logue and the consummation his satires. say common to the of IV. For myself I will admit frankly I have read the “Epistle’’ oftener, haps, than any other English poem ex- cept “Lycidas,” and that long familiar- ity with its lines has given me always a deepening admiration for its art. If it is not poetry, I do not know where poetry is to be found. That Pope’s in spiration moves on a lower plane than Milton’s, I should be the last to deny. Yet in a way their themes, despite the great difference of their age and faith, have an odd similarity. Milton, like the poet Queen Anne, wrote in the heat of battle, and with him, too, fecit indignatio versus. In a way, one is complementary to the other, and no thing can better show the mischievous nature of the division in the Stuart days than the fact that the practical party which Milton represented—so far as he can be said to have represented anybody but himself the peo ple of Dullness, while the party of the imagination, as we see it in the writings of Swift and Pope, was divested of all the old magnificences of morality. Yet if the “Epistle to Dr. Arbuthnot” lacks Milton’s mighty impulse of religion and draws from lower springs of Helicon, it still has its great compensations. The indignation is as terrible, if its causes are more mixed. Here, even more ruin- that per- of was now The Nation. ously than in the “Dunciad,” and with- out the longer poem's tediousness of obscure detail, the dreaded secret is re- vealed— That secret to each fool, that he's an ass. We may doubt what was the exact nature of that two-handed engine which Milton suspended against the enemies of Puritanism, but there is nothing am- biguous about the revenge of Pope, whe- ther with one blade he hews down open enemies of with the other attacks his pretended friends. From the open- ing appeal to the poet’s old and faithful servant: his Shut, shut the door, good John! fatigued I said; Tie up the knocker, say I'm sick, I'm dead. The Dog-star rages! nay, "tis past a doubt, All Bedlam, or Fire in each eye, and papers in each hand, Parnassus, is let out: They rave, recite, and madden round the land to the last fling at the hypocrites: One from all Grub-street will my fame defend, And, more abusive, calls himself my friend— there is a succession of lines of almost dazzling wit, and every line a_ stab. Thackeray, as the father of Pendennis and the half-ironical patron of the Grub Street of his own day, has some pretty words of abuse upon Pope for fixing in the public mind this notion of the snarling, starving attic-world of au- No doubt touched up the picture with hig! acquaintance with the of the day, and with the periodicals, not omitting own blackguardly Grub Street Journal, gives all the justi- for the portrait. And the : purely Pope has lights, but an thorship. literature lesser Pope's fication needed again we shall take this fury There were principles involved, though here miss point we as personal. Pope himself, I dare say, never really knew the difference between his princi- ples and his spite. Something more than the deadly the de sire to “flap this bug with gilded wings.” personal hatred envenoms caricature of Lord Hervey and With the culmination of the satire, Or at the ear of Eve, familiar toad, should be read Jonathan Richardson's comment: I have heard that this lord had actually 1 seat managed behind the queen's hunt ing chaise, where he sat perched behind her close at her ear, but he could never stand it above three or four tin Beside th ridicule of his friends, folks hooted at hi as the machine passed alone The real animus of the attack is the re lation of Hervey to Caroline and the Hanoverian court, and all that this meant to the intellectual and imagina- tive life of England. This, too, must be the for the portrait of Addison, though it may scarcely palliate the au thor’s shiftiness in regard to the date of writing the lines. They must be quoted: excuse 649 there to all such! but whose fires True genius kindles, and fair fame inspires; Peace were one Blest with each talent, and each art to please, And born to write, converse, and live with ease Should such a man, too fond to rule alone. Bear, like the Turk, no brother near the throne, View him with scornful, yet with jealous eyes, And hate for arts that caused himself to rise; Damn with faint praise, assent with civil leer, And, without sneering, teach the rest to sneer ; Willing to wound, and yet afraid to strike, Just hint a fault, and hesitate dislike; Alike reserved to blame, or to con A timorous fo ne nd, nd; erers besieged and a suspicious fools, flat And so obliging, that he n irk Dreading e’en by Like Cato, give his little Senate law And sit attentive applause; While wits and raise, to his own Templars ry sentence And wonder with a foolish fa of Who but if ich a be? Who would not praise— must laugh an there weep, if Atticus were h Of the exquisite finish of these there can, I suppose, be no question, un less De Quincey’s frivolous criticism i to be listened to. The other day, while they were fresh in my memory. a friend of mine who loves and gather beautiful things was showing me his collection of Japanese yvord-guard and as I looked at those wonderfully wrought plates of steel and considered their ancient place on the instrument of battle, it occurred to me that their craftsmanship was not unlike that which had gone into the making of this detached of word And it masterpiece seemed to me that the rectitude and pa tience of the work in each « as o1 of the causes of their perpetual cl I have a prejudice in favor of geniu an invincible feeling that i in ome way based on truth And so he ther this portrait of Addisor a rit ten, as Warburton declar in 18 cause the Earl of Warwick, Ad stepson, had arned Pop: of Addi son’s jealousy and of his instiga of Gildon to publish a scurrilo | against his supposed friend, or becaus Pope believed Addison to be res} bl for Tickell’s rival translatle t! Iliad—whatever may have been t devi ous ways of Pope in explainir ind spreading abroad tl tis I cor vinced that Addison i ot nti blameless In some wi the jealon of his trade had set free the deceitful spirit of egotism that lurks beneath the fairest character. It must b membered also that in the year hen was written, and when the circle of Pope was suffering in many ways from the death of Queen Anne, Addison as Chief Secretary to Ireland was enjoying the -ruits of his service to the Whigs. the satire 80

Page 14

650 That, indeed, may be to his credit polit- ically; it will help to explain, neverthe- less, why Pope placed him, not among the dunces, for that would have been to stultify the writer, but among those who in the desperate battle of the mind fol- lowed the false standard—the one lost leader, when so many lesser and more ignoble men were faithful. I think Pope had loved, and did always admire, Ad- dison. There is the true pathos of wit— and wit may have its tears—a cry of grief from a very great bitterness and regret in the last line, Who would not weep, if Atticus were he! I? the emotion here is not genuine, we may as well shut our bosoms to every appeal of books. V. Rut there is in this satire something besides sorrow for the perversion, or at least the failure, of a noble friend; it must be read in connection with Pope’s own feeling of weariness, if not of degradation. By the side of this scorn of the dull and the base, runs the con- trasted note of friendship, which was always the finest trait of his character. Nowhere else does he express the union that bound together this body of defeat- ed wits with so exquisite a charm as in the lines to the genial, much-beloved physician: nd to 1 lif which did you _ not olone orld had wanted many an idle song In comparison with that peaceful bond, ‘ it profit was the long-protracted ind in the end losing enmity which in pired hi itire? What evil genius projected him into this hateful air of wl lid I write? What sin to me unknown | ! n ink, my parents’ or my own? To understand the “Epistle” we must rend it as at once an excuse for the warfare in which his days had passed and an ac knowledgement of their waste and bitter fruit With a kind of childlike and, I regret he com Pope's apologia pro vita sua, think, utterly sincers pares the quiet tenor of his father’s life ith tl discordant ambitions of litera ture. and counts as the one Indisputa ble bleasing to himself the homely re aspect for that life which he had pre served against all the Itmroads of the world’s malice O friend! Ma each dort t{ bliss be Be inpleasing melancholy mine: Me, let the tender office long engage To rock the cradle of reposing age, With lenfent arte extend a mother’s breath Make languor smile, and smooth the bed of death Explore the thought, explain the asking eye, And keep awhile one parent from the sky! The Nation. Preserve him social, cheerful, and serene, And just as rich as when he served a queen. Not Goldsmith himself painted a sweet- er picture of resignation and piety; and, whatever else may have been true of Pope, these lines also speak the truth of him. VI. It may seem that the beauty of these contrasted notes in Pope’s greatest poem is lost to the world to-day, because one of them at least, the warfare of the wits, was a temporary thing, now long forgotten and of interest only to the special student. To a certain degree and in form this is no doubt the case. Yet the warfare substantially is not ended, and shall not end while the dif- ferences of human nature remain un- reconciled. Men in this living age, al- ways a few, are still fighting for the rights of the mind against a dull and delusive materialism, for the freedom of the imagination against a prosaic tyranny, for a pure and patient am- bition against the quick successes of vanity and pliant cleverness, for the reality of human nature against a fatuous self-complacency. To these the triumphant satire of Pope is a_ per- petual encouragement, while his pa- thetic apology expresses for them the relief needed when success appears far away, or, even if near, not worth the cost in the humiliating wager of soul against soul. Nor is the theme of the “Epistle” without its more universal aspect. For after all life itself, not for the wit only, but for each man in his place, is a contest, and poetry, from the time when Homer portrayed his heroes battling with sword and fire on the banks of the Simois, and longing for the peace of hearth and kindred and friends across the seas, has been the expression, varying in form and instru- ments, of that inevitable fate. The pre- sentation of this truth may in Pope be narrowed to a particular manner and time, it may assume ignoble images and speak too often in reprehensible lan- guage, nevertheless he who does not re- spond to the deep emotion and human- ity underlying the “Satires” has travel- led but a short way into the realm of letters: he has even, I dare assert, felt but a little of the great realities of P. E. M. man’s life. Correspondence. “LEST WE FORGET.” To Tue Eprror or Tire NATION: Sin: Authors are apt to be strangely for- getful of facts in their own literary his- tory, and have therefore sometimes misled editors and critics in their comments and On cares like these if length of days /| annotations Your keen-eyed bibliophile attend, May Heaven, to bless those days, preserve | these lapses, as in the Nation for July 22, my friend, has more than once called attention to 11909, where he {Illustrates them by Lowell's [ Vol. go, 0. 2348 inaccuracy in his note on the final edition (1890) concerning the composition of the “Fable for Critics.” Lowell there says: This jeu desprit was extemporized, I may fairly say, so rapidly was it written, purely for my own amusement, and with no thought of publication. I sent daily in- stalments of it to a friend in New York, the late Charles F. Briggs. He urged me to let it be printed, and I at last consented to its anonymous publication. And in a letter to R. W. Gilder (February 9, 1887) he had said of the poem: “I wrote it (slap-dash, in less than a week, I think) with no notion of publication.” The fact was that in November and De- cember, 1847, Lowell sent “about six hun- dred lines’’ to Briggs, with instructions for its publication. From that time he worked upon it irregularly, with much prodding from his friend and the print- er, until October, 1848, when the poem was completed and published. Tennyson was more surprisingly forget- ful in regard to the date of his first book, the “Poems by Two Brothers.”’ It was cer- tainly published in March, 1827, as all authorities agreed down to 1892. Dr. Van Dyke so gave the date in the “Chronol- ogy’ appended to the first edition of his excellent “Poetry of Tennyson” in 1889 and to the second in 1891. But in the third (1892) it is changed to “1826,”" with the following note: It was post-dated according to the com- mon custom among publishers at that time. For this true date of its appearance, which has I believe never before been given cor- rectly, I am indebted to Lord Tennyson. He had visited the poet in 1892, “a few weeks” before this third edition went to press. I noticed the error as soon as I saw it, for I remembered, though Tenny- son forgot it, that the preface of his book is dated “March, 1827,” and the “Memoir” by his son so states it. Title pages are often “post-dated” (particularly in the case of holiday books brought out late in the year, compelling cataloguers and bib- liographers to print two dates), but pre- faces are likely to give the true date. The book was doubtless sent to press in 1826, and many of the poems in it were written some years earlier, as we know, but Tennyson confused the facts. The er- ror, however, is not corrected in the seventh (1896) edition of Dr. Van Dyke’s book, the latest that I have seen, Within a few months I have accidentally discovered that Tennyson led me into a similar mistake in my notes on the second poem entitled “Freedom,” which was first printed in this country (from “advance copy’) in 1884. The second line then had “column’d Parthenon” instead of “pillar’d Parthenon,” the reading in the “Tiresias” volume, published the very next year (1885), which I followed in “Enoch Arden and Other Poems” (1887), referring in the notes to the earlier reading. I sent the book to Tennyson, and, when acknowledging it, he said I was wrong in ascribing “‘column’d” to him, and intimated that it was a blunder in the Independent. I took his word for it, without looking the poem up in Mac- millan’s Magazine (where it first appeared in England in December, 1884), and “‘cor- rected” the note accordingly in my next edition, as also in a revised and enlarged edition in 1895, in Vol. VIII of the de luge twelve-volume edition of Tennyson's works (1896), and in the “Cambridge” edition

Page 15

June 30, 1910] (1808). Put, having occasion lately to look into Macmillan’s for something else, my eye chanced to fall on the poem there (print- ed of course from the poet’s manuscript), and found “column’d Parthenon.” So much for an honest effort on my part to be accurate! I may edd that the fifth stanza in this poem (“Of Knowledge fusing class with class,” etc.) was added in the ‘“Tiresias’’ volume, and some minor changes were made. Tennyson also wrote to me once—or told me at one of my visits to him—that often what were supposed to be new readings in his poems were really the original ones I am quite sure that in some cases of the kind they were not the first readings in print, though they may have been in the first manuscript to which he subsequently returned. It is well known that occasionally he altered his printed text, and war led by the criticisms upon the new reading to re- store the earlier one. In “Lady Clara Vere de Vere,” for instance, he changed “The gardener Adam” of 1842 to “The grand old gardener,” which was generally condemned, and in 1875 Ke returned te the first reading. The extensive changes made in “The Charge of the Light Brigade’’ were more vehe- mently resented by the critics, and the poem now varies only slightly from the earliest printed text. The reader may remember that in a for mer letter to the Nation (May 6, 1909), I showed that the poet printed no less than four considerable variations of a passage in ‘Merlin and Vivien,’’ one of which ap- pears only in the first American edition (1857); and three forms. of some passages in his works are by no means rare. I am strongly inclined, moreover, to think that Tennyson sometimes forgot (as Brown- ing occasionally admitted that he did) what he meant in certain figurative passages in his earlier poems; but “that’s another story,” end I will not dwell upon it here. Another eminent author, Mr. Gladstone, caused me more than one “bad quarter of ; an hour,” on account of a supposed in- justice I had done him, in the notes of my edition of “In Memoriam” (1895). Among the tributes to Arthur Hallam which I had quoted therein, was one of considerable length, ascribed to “W. E. Gladstone”; but when I sent him the book, he wrote to me somewhat curtly, asking on what authority I had mentioned him as having written it. After search through twenty or more books on Tennyson, I found it in Mr. E. C. Tainsh’s capital lit- tle “Study,” of which three editions ap- peared (1868, 1869, 1870). Then I wrote to Gladstone, referring him to Tainsh, and begging him to inform me whether the pas- sage had been wrongly attributed to him, in order that I might make the necessary correction in my next edition. He did not write in reply, but two years later, when the “Memoir” of Tennyson, by his son, appeared, I found the passage quoted there (Vol. I, p. 299), as from a review of “In Memoriam,” “by Mr. Gladstone,” which the poet “thought one of the ablest.” The quotation was said to be from “Glad- stone’s ‘Gleanings of Past Years,’ Vol. II, pp. 136-137.” There it is credited to the Quarterly Review, October, 1859, with a foot-note stating that the sentence begin- ning “The writer of this paper,” and end- The Nation. ing with the quotation, “I marked him,” etc. (from De Vere’s “Mary Tudor”) “has now (1878) been added.” Tainsh had evi- dently taken it from the “Gleanings,” with one slight accidental change (“the rapid, full, and rich development,” instead of “the rapid growth and rich development”). It is curious that Gladstone, after reprinting the paper and adding to it in 1878, should have forgotten that he wrote it. His note to me, however, was written when he was eighty-five years old; and he died in May, 1898, less than a year after the Memoir of Tennyson was published. I had not troubled myself to write to him again about the matter W. J. ROLFE, Cambridge, Mass., June 21. ENGLISH ROMANTICISM To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sin: Mr. Mather’s able essay on Pro- fessor Babbitt’s “New Laokoin” raises many points of interest. The doctrine that art should be governed rather by reason than by the emotions is unquestionably a sound one for America to-day. A _ public which prefers Tchaikovsky to Bach, which dotes on Puccini and neglects Mozart, is in urgent need of higher intellectual stand- ards Yet it is unfair to let the reader infer that the so-called romantic movement in English poetry about 1800 was a mere wor ship of emotionalism. It was rather a loosening of conventional strait-lacings which allowed the poet not only to breath but also to think more freely. The result was, as Mr. Courthope shows in his “His tory of English Poetry,” an individualism according to the temperament of the given poet; and although each of them went some extreme, each made a valuable con tribution to the future possibilitt of tl literature by opening a new field of thought or developing a new method of expression Thus Wordsworth enriched our contemp a tive joy in nature for all time, and Shelley gave us visions of political perfection, many of which have come true since he wroté These two poets widened the thought as well as the emotional range of posterity Nor should we forget that this was the pe riod of our most inspiring critic: Cole- ridge, Lamb, Hazlitt, De Quincey. Perhaps we can best gauge the value of the romantic poets by observing their in fluence on the more classic of the Vic- torians. Tennyson and Arnold till the soil broken by Keats and Wordsworth; or we might call the romanticists the pioneers and the Victorians the settlers. Again what a charm is added to Augustinism by a fresh personal impulse, as in the lyrics of Mr. Austin Dobson! In his rondeaux and ballades we have all the dainty per- fection of “teacup times,” combined with a wistful touch of feeling that is original and captivating CHARLES WHARTON STORK. University of Pennsylvania, June 22 PARTY PLATFORMS To THE EpItoR or THE NATION: Str: I have long been contemplating the suggestion that our political parties are too diffuse in their platforms, and that only one or two issues should be iset forth and continued until they are 651 fought to the fnish. The old parties will hardly consent to this—the present old party leaders I mean. Why not the Progressive party? Let the tariff issue or the conservation issue or the corporation issue be taken up—perhaps all three—and placed in the platform of each Congressional district this autumn. Then have the general statement made that all other issues which happen to come up in Congress wil! be referred to the Progressive constituen es for their approval before final ax tion is taken upon them by the Pro essives In addition then to the one—or two issue platform, we would have the referen lum introduced Here is a solution of our present polit al diMficulti CHARLES A. WENFIELD Providence, R. 1! J 20 CHAR-A-BAN‘ TO THE Epit« o rue N 10 Sir: What is the earliest date of the a pearance of char-d-banc in an English book? The first example cited in the Oxford Dictionary is dated 1832. But the follow passage from James Edward Smith's “Sketch of a Tour on the Continent II 174-5 (second edition, London, 1807) ow that the word was used in England at lea a generation earlier Sept. 4, [1786] From hence I sent ba the mules of Chamouni, hired at Sak with their owner, and proceeded to Vill ul na che a-ban i r ’ f we yw h | " ] i a a I ( ind q ‘ 4 ] ! M M Literature. ALASKA AND THE FAR NORTH Cruises in the Bering Sea, being ords of Further Sport and T% by Paul Niedieck. Translated f1 German by R. A. Ploetz, New York Charles Scribner's Sons. $5 n Trailing and Camping in Alaska. By Ad dison M. Powell. New York: A. W sels. $2 net. The New North, being Some Account of a Woman's Journey through Canada to the Arctic. By Agnes Deans Came on. New York: D. Appleton & Co. $3 net. Handbook of Polar Discoveries. By A W. Greely. Boston: Little, Brown & Co, $1.50 net. Tent Life in Siberia. By George Ken nan. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons $2.50 net. An Explorer's Adventures in Tibet. By A. Henry Savage Landor. New York: Harper & Bros. $1.50. Mr. Niedieck describes a journey to Kamschatka and Alaska, in the sum mer of 1906, with a passing glimpse at Japan. About half the book is devoted

Page 16

652 The Nation. — = [ Vol. 90, No. 2348 to Kamschatka, and the balance to Alaska. While the primary object of the expedition was to hunt bears and big- horn along the Siberian coast, and moose on the American side, its chief value lies in the author's interesting notes on the geography, fauna, and ethnology of the region about Bering Sea. His account of the Siberian coast is particularly welcome, the available literature on that subject being very meagre. We have had better opportuni- ties of becoming acquainted with Alaska, but this book offers an excellent sum mary of the history and development of the territory, and at least in the chapters on the manners and customs of the aborigines, and their mythology, contains much that has not hitherto ap peared in print. A synopsis of the ani mals collected during the expedition is given in an appendix, and the book i illustrated by a large number of excel lent photographs, as well as a chart. With every desire to see the good points of “Trailing and Camping in Alaska,” the reviewer fails to discover the reason for its writing. It is almost everything that a book of description and travel should not be. In his intro duction, Mr. Powell tells us that “many incidents which were commonplace to the author, but which might have prov ed interesting and unusual to the read er, have been curtailed or withheld in order not to interfere with the general character, or to become tedious by their added length.” Unfortunately, his book is packed with commonplace incidents. That in itself is no fault. Commonplace incidents may be made highly enter taining. These are not. That Mr. Pow ell knows Alaska one can have no rea sonable doubt; but he lacks the gift to make his knowledge either serviceable or interesting to others One gets the impression of a collection of unrelated notes strung together in narrative history that is form: a fumble ol common knowledge, anecdote that is lifel ind facetious comments that do not amure The one redeeming feature is the photographic illustrations, many ot hich are admirable | extent to which a writer may make or mar a good subject is striking ly illustrated in the book just mention ed and in Miss Cameron's “New North.” The same elements are present in both, but the result is very different. Miss (Cameron describes a journey from Ed monton to Athabasca Landing, and down the Athabasca, Slave, and Macken ie rivers to the Arctic. The Incidents of the journey are often commonplace, but ashe has made them Intensely Inter ting fer history and anecdotes are alw ell told, and to the point; the narrati is enfivened by touches of humor that is spontaneous and real; presented in a style and the whole ts that lifte the book well above the aver age story of travel. She describes the life of fur-trader and Indian, mission- | ary, Eskimo, and whaler, with a touch that is sympathetic, vigorous, and com- pelling. She reveals to us a new field of achievement, full of human interest; and incidentally opens to the traveller a virtually undiscovered country, read- ily accessible, and most attractive from every point of view. In the fourth edition of his well-| known handbook, Gen. Greely has add- ed the results of Arctic and Antarctic discoveries within the last few years. One scarcely realizes the extent and im- portance of recent explorations un- til one compares this with the previous edition. The twentieth century has al- ready been marked by achievements in these fields surpassing those of many previous centuries. Abruzzi, Amundsen, Ericksen, Peary, and Sverdrup, in the north, and Bruce, Charcot, Nordenskiold, Scott, and Shackleton, in the south, have thrown a flood of light upon hitherto unknown regions; the North Pole has been actually reached, and the South Pole brought within measurable dis- tance. Generally speaking, comment is unnecessary upon the character of the book as a work of reference. It has long since taken its place as an indis- pensable companion to the student and general reader. It must, however, be matter of regret to the compiler that he did not await the issue of the dispute touching Dr. Cook’s alleged polar dis- covery. The standing of his work is eriously impaired by the unreserved ac- ceptance of Dr. Cook’s claim to the dis- covery of the North Pole. As long ago as 1870 Mr. Kennan is- sued his narrative of life and adven- tures in Siberia, and because of the readable qualities of the book, as well as the interest of the subject, it has never since ceased to find readers. He has now revised and enlarged his narra- tive, and added a considerable number of excellent illustrations, “Tent Life in Siberia” embodies a history of the ex- plorations and surveys of the Russian American Telegraph Company, on the Siberian side of Bering Strait. Although first issued so many years ago, Mr. Ken- nan’s account of the country, its scen- ery, and the manners and customs of its people, Is still valuable, and has been made more so by the addition of several new chapters, notably one embodying the incidents and adventures of a win- ter journey overland from the Okhotsk Sea to the Volga River—a “straight- away sleigh-ride of more than five thou- sand miles.” In his larger work, “In the Forbidden Land,” Mr. Landor gave a detailed ac- count of the scientific results of his memorable journey through Tibet In 1897. The tntensely dramatic story of the journey itself, stripped of scientific data, is now made available in “An Ex- plorer’s Adventures in Tibet.” Seldom indeed has any traveller livell to tell such a tale of privation, suffering, and hairbreadth escapes. The story is one of unconquerable pluck and endurance, under extraordinary difficulties. Al- though his presence in Tibet was known from the moment he crossed the boun- |dary, and troops of soldiers were con- \stantly searching for him, Mr. Landor almost succeeded in his mad attempt to reach the sacred city of Lhassa, before he was finally captured. He was cruel- ly tortured, but by rare good fortune his life was spared, and he was con- ducted back to the boundary. Of the many important geographical results of his journey, perhaps the most interest- ing was the discovery of the sources of the Brahmaputra and Sutlej Rivers. CURRENT FICTION. East London Visions. By O’Dermid W. Lawler. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. Imagine a combination of “Sartor Resartus” with the “New Arabian Nights,” the blend slightly tinctured also by the “Vita Nuova,” and you will gain some notion of the most oddly fas- cinating book that for many a day has come under one reviewer's eye. Osten- sibly, this is the autobiography of a star-gazing young poet struggling with the conditions of East London. Many of the characters are plainly drawn from the life. Admirable is the picture of the hero’s sardonic, friendly, irascible father. Even more massive is the ef- figy of the Jew Abzedion, lord of his alley and keeper of a fried-fish bar. Vastly amusing and pathetic is the con- fession of an evangelical clergyman who without a faith, by the shifts and turns of the comedian, “keeps the show going.” The women, however, are al- most without exception symbols of the religious life. Indeed, the book, taken broadly, is an allegory of the search for a faith. What redeems it from the aridity of ‘its kind is the foundation of urgent real- ism and the passion with which the symbolism is created and unwound. This book has eloquence and emotion, and its texture is of a cunningly varied interest. It is humorous withal, with something of the rich extravagance of a Sterne or a Carlyle. We have found its mixture of the sublime with the topsy-turvicai always refreshing. Ob- viously, the widely assorted ingredients of the work make the task of the critic a difficult one. What strikes him as racy and enjoyable in an esthetic sense, |may to another reader seem of oracular importance; to a third, sheer nonsense. We prefer, then, to avoid the judicial duty, merely recording a keen personal jenjoyment and representing the temper of the book by an extract. The author, metamorphosed in a vi- ‘sion into a bird, filts above the haunts Se en

Page 17

June 30, 1910] rh The Natio of three religions. He tries in vain to catch the ear of the ritualists, and final- ly gets the answer from a priest, “I neither see you nor understand you; but I am quite willing to admit anything you say.” Wholly failing to get the at- tention of the evangelicals, a folk who seemed to lack a social language, he next tried the religious nurslings of the gentle skeptic, Matthew Arnold: Then I flitted to a third group between the two others, and repeated my operations, desiring to call their attention to the stel- lar arrangements. But they were talking of Religion. “Religion,” said one, “is Mor- ality touched with Emotion.” On this, with au effort, I found my speech: “What a cul- inary definition!” I exclaimed. ‘You take a little Morality, and you touch it with a lit- tle Emotion (kind of Emotion not stated— Query, Spite?) and behold—you produce Re- ligion! How little you comfortable peo- ple know about it! I tell you Religion is— Life!""—“But what is Life?’ asked a gen- tleman. I was glad of the interruption. ... “You People put,” I said, “the cart befcre the horse. Steam is—Locomotion—touched with Explosiveness. What do you think of that absurdity? Are you totally unaware of the Threefold Arch of Being?—THAT WHICH IS—THAT WHICH MAKES—THAT WHICH IS MADE!” To this there was no answer. Perhaps it sounded to them perilous nonsense, just as their high-class words had sounded to me. They disregarded me, and I flew back to my roof. A Marriage Under the Terror. By Pa- tricia Wentworth. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. As a story which won first prize in an English novel competition, this has a certain preliminary claim upon the curi- osity of the reader. Three competeut woman-judges, it is announced, all well- known writers of fiction, independently chose this as the best novel submitted. Of course the choice under the given con- ditions might naturally lie between worse and the better, rather than tween better and the best. Certainly the three judges in question could hardly have been expected to pick an historical romance. Such, however, on the face of it, is “A Marriage Under the Ter- ror,” and a highly respectable achieve- ment of its kind. The action begins on the very eve of the Terror. A convent- bred girl of noble birth is brought to Paris to marry a middle-aged roué to whom she has been betrothed as a child. She has barely been presented to her af- fianced, when he and his worldly mis tress and all the circle to which they belong, are arrested and imprisoned in La Force. The girl, Mademoiselle de Rochambeau, follows them to the jail, but is refused admission. A stout bour- geoise rescues her from the street, and she becomes a seamstress, taking a pleb- eian name. When we say that one of her housemates is Dangeau, young and hand- some champion of liberty, of ordinary be- blood, but a heart of gold, we have told the rest of the story. They love, but aristocratic prejudice forbids her suc- cumbing; they are nominally married under dramatic necessity. Thereafter they are separated, and after many ad- ventures connected with the rise and passing of the Terror, after they have been brought side by side to the scaf- fold, Fate kindly, if not unexpectedly, rescues them. In fact, Robespierre takes that appropriate moment -for falling, and thereby makes two lovers happy. There is, it will be seen, a good sort of plot for this sort of story; and the historical part of the tale, the picture of that per- turbed and finally obsessed Paris of the Revolution, is managed with a good deal o? vividness. By E. Phillips Little, Brown & The Illustrious Prince. Oppenheim. Boston: Co. The first few pages of Mr. Oppen- heim’s latest production promise a de- tective story of thrilling quality. At the very start, a mysterious American trav- eller, who has sufficient influence to command a special landing when the Lusitania is unable to put her passen- gers ashore at Liverpool, and to con- jure into being a special train for the run from Liverpool to London, is mur- dered in that train in a peculiar man- ner, and to the bewilderment of the guard. Only a chapter or two further on, another murder in a London taxi- cab thickens the plot, and makes the lover of the detective story settle down more comfortably in his easy chair. But his hopes are dashed, for from this point the story seems to go to pieces; motives spring up apparently without reason, characters develop to fill vacan- cies with surprising readiness, and all the while the reader, being entirely cer- tain of the identity of the criminal, is only annoyed, not mystified, by the at- tempt to divert suspicion to new char- acters. Meanwhile the heroine falls in love with the paragon of all heroes, Prince Maiyo of Japan, after first believing that she hates him; and even when she realizes her true feeling, she becomes engaged to an athletic young English- Under conditions she is the proper champion of the Prince’s cause, whom all the while she believes to be the murderer! man, these scarcely Altogether Mr. Oppenheim has given us an unsatisfactory and aisappointing book, which is not saved as a detective story by an ending which lacks convic- tion. It is possible that it was not meant for a detective story at all, but for a serious warning to England to beware ar alliance with Japan. Evidently the Prince is made the spokesman of the author’s theories of European politics; as he denounces the death of true pa- triotism in England—due, he says, in 6 » 3 large measure, to the British love of “sport”—and predicts the world domina- tion of Japan and China, when the Unit- ed States shall have been fought and conquered. The Messenger. By Katharine Holland Brown-—-The Lifted Bandage. By Mary Raymond Shipman Andrews. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. Though by different writers and not in the same volume, these are compan- ion stories, and the publisher has recog nized the fact by printing them in al most identical form. They have to do with the same theme: the hunger of the modern skeptical or worldly mind for a belief in the hereafter. In the first tale, a young widow struggles in vain to feel that death has not cut her off forever from her husband. They have never talked of death; she does not know what he has believed about it. Her quandary has become almost an ob- session, when chance brings to her proof that he has been absolutely certain ot a future life; with the knowledge, the cloud lifts from her spirit, and feels herself once more united to dead. Mrs. Andrews’s sufferer from doubt is an old man whose dead son has accused of murder by a coroner's jury In default of a belief that he is to be reunited to his wife and son, his only possible reason for continuing would be a belief in the son’s innocence of the charge. But he admits the evi dence, and is on the to when a sudden revelation comes to him of the continued existence of those he has loved, and of the beneficent natur: of things which have hitherto seemed to him cruel and unjust. toth are effectively told; curiously the style is so similar in the two tal that they might easily have ' ten by the same hand. she her to live way madnes stort enougn been THE CIVIL WAR. The History of By George Cary I the Confederate War Sgzleston. New Yor! Sturgis & Walton Co. 2 vols. $4 net Mr. Eggleston has here set himeseil the large task of telling the story of the civil war with “absolute loyalty to truth.” He believes that the time ha come when this may be done, and that no fair-minded American desires any longer a perversion of facts. The im plication that some, at least, of th: host of previous historians of the w inclined to distortion sion of facts is, unfortunately, not with out foundation, though whether North ern or Southern partisans have been on the whole the more culpable is not apparent from these pages. Be that as it may, Mr. Eggleston himself has sought to lay aside prejudice, to forget the chagrin of defeat and the joy have or suppres- of

Page 18

2 654 victory, to reckon no participant as either friend or foe, and to set down, in the clear, dry light of nearly a haif- century of peace, the history of the greatest of all wars as that history really is. It would, indeed, be gratifying if criticism could give to the substance of these well-printed and attractive vol- umes as high praise as must be accord- ed to the spirit in which the writing of them was undertaken. ‘'nat the book is readable goes without saying. In the appraisal of the motives and conduct of the South and its leaders, there is notable restraint, and the really heroic character of the Southern resist- ance, both in the fleld and on the lonely plantation, is so delicately touched es hardly to do full justice to it. If Mr. Eggleston has had any expectation that his book will warm the Southern heart, or make the present generation proud- er than it now is of the deeds of the fathers, we fear that the response will be less enthusiastic than he has hoped; for the balance of commendation, !f balance there be, inclines to the North. As a serious contribution to history, however, the work cannot be called weighty. The absence of footnotes makes it, to be sure, impossible to say what authorities Mr. Eggleston has used, but the text gives no evidence of special esearch, nor even of an altogether care- ful study of secondary narratives. From time to time, we are assured that this or that view of the matter in contro- versy is sustained or disproved by the cuments”: but since the conclusions of the author do not differ from those already familiar in the pages of other historians, one cannot help questioning whether Mr. Eggleston has examined the authorities for himself. Some loose and inaccurate statements could have been avolded had even the secondary orities been more carefully follow- of impartiality, too, must at tim be challenged. The adminis itive incapacity of both Federal and ( f rate fficials is severely scored, though with little apparent recognition f the difficulties, political and other, vhich attended the conduct of the war on both slide while the denunciation Halleck, especially for his treatment of Grant, Is so insistent as to pass the bounds of scholarly disapproval In its discursiveness and emphatic it- eration, Mr. Eggleston's writing sug geste the later manner of Mr. Roosevelt. The inevitable antithesis of good and evil is heightened by a strenuous appli cation of adjectives. Neither men nor actions appear in simple, unadorned re lations, but as “absolutely” this or “un questionably” that. All the great are colossal, all the small contemptible. There are a few good descriptive pas-| sages, but, in general, the accounts of military operations, though commend- | ably clear, are not inspiring; while the| The Na tion. [ Vol. 90, No. 2348 most touching scene among them, the surrender of Lee, is not described at all. Of other than strictly military matters, the narrative as a whole takes only inci- dental notice—an omission the more re- grettable because of Mr. Eggleston's in- timate acquaintance with Southern life, both before and after the war. The summary account of American history down to 1861, with special reference to slavery and the relations of the sec- tions, which fills nearly half of the first volume, might well have been dis- pensed with in favor of a fuller treat- ment of economic and social conditions. The value of Mr. Eggleston’s work consists in its exposition, first, of the inevitableness of the war, in view of the divergent history and interests of the two sections; and, secondly, of the sincerity of those who fought for the success of the Southern cause. While for legal purposes the struggle is per- haps best described as a rebellion, it was rebellion of so large and funda- mental a sort as to elevate the contest to the plane of public war, and give to it the character of a war for inde- pendence. Mr. Eggleston would have us believe that those who fought to dis- rupt the Union were, after all, patriots, and entitled, now that the strife is over, to be held in honor for their principles, as well as for their courage and con- stancy. We cannot take this view, but we can at least rejoice with him that slavery was abolished and the Union saved, and praise the chivalry that es- says a story which the victor may read without glorying, and the vanquished peruse without pain. Central America and Its Problems: An Account of a Journey from the Rio Grande to Panama, with Introductory Chapters on Mexico and Her Rela- tions to Her Neighbors. By Frederick Palmer, F.R.G.S. New York: Moffat, Yard & Co. $2.50 net. In these days of subsidized official “boosting” one cannot help being grate- ful for the presentation in book form of Mr. Palmer’s Chicago Tribune corre- pondence. Let it be admitted at the outset that the book has the defects of its journalistic origin. Snap judgments, brilllant generalities, and startling em- phasis are not the qualities which go to make a standard work. At the same time, Mr. Palmer is a clever writer and a discerning observer, and his book is decidedly readable and entertaining. The first two hundred pages, devoted to the narrative of his hurried journey from one Central American capital to another, are really fascinating. Nothing so interesting has been written about Honduras since Richard Harding Da- vis's “Three Gringos” journeyed across that debt-laden republic. It is a pity that Mr. Palmer thought it necessary to fill out his volume with so much theorizing and preaching about matters for which his short trip did not qualify him to speak with authority. Nevertheless, many of his observations show good judgment and keen penetration. Such remarks as the following deserve repe- tition: “Waste your money in any way you please, but do not put it in a rub- ber plantation in Mexico”; “Let it be repeated without equivocation that any- pody who invests in any land or planta- tion scheme south of the Rio Grande, when he has not seen the property or does not know his men, may consider his money lost”; “Too frequently the American concession-hunter judges the country’s possibilities by its natural wealth, rather than by the human han- dicaps.” Apart from these astute warnings, the most noticeable work which Mr. Palmer has done is the presentation in a graph- ic fashion of incidents and conditions which lead him to the conclusion that if we are going to stand by the Monroe Doctrine we must take the con- sequences. The diplomats we send to tropical America should be the ablest men in the service and their hands should be strengthened, not weakened, by a badly informed State Department. It should be their aim, says Mr. Palmer, without arousing local animosity, to keep the bellicose republics from falling foul of each other and to prevent the in- evitable dictators from taking advan- tage of our protection to give their tyrannical tendencies free play. With- out for a moment implying that we should annex any of that territory, the inference is that we must do something to make it possible for the unfortu- nate inhabitants of Central America to enjoy the blessings of civilization which have been denied them hitherto as one of the results of our dog-in-the- manger policy. In a word, we must face squarely the responsibilities which logically follow our adherence to the Monroe Doctrine in the form in which it has been put by recent presidents. Mr. Palmer has done a distinct service to the cause of Pan-American peace by enabling his fellow-citizens to see this side of the question more clearly. His book deserves to be widely read. The Life of Mary Lyon. By Beth Brad- ford Gi'christ. Boston: Houghton Mif- flin Co. $1.50 net. One catches in this enthusiastic book bare glimpses of an ardent personality, a teacher of apostolic hopefulness and energy, a prophet of sound and practi- cal education for her sex. Yet somehow the individuality only half defines itself. There is nothing in her letters and very little in the notes that rapturous stu- dents took of her Mount Holyoke talks to explain the spell that Mary Lyon cast upon her contemporaries. This deficien- cy cannot be laid wholly at the biograph-

Page 19

ae ee June 30, 1910] The Nation. er’s door. It is more or less in the na- ture of the case, Mary Lyon belonged to that class of artists who deal imme- diately with mankind as their material. Such artists, unless they evoke a Plato or a Boswell, slip away quickly, are merged in their specific work. In fact, the conditions of such dominant person- al influence are not quite those of art. The tactful shifts that a Mary Lyon had to make before a generation skepti- cal about solid education for women, the deft repetitions implied in persuasion, the genial commonplace of encourage ment and exhortation to her girls—all this is refractory material, cold star dust in which the glow refuses to be re kindled. As far as the facts of her life go, and in recalling the temper of the New Eng- land in which she worked, this biogra- phy is excellent. The descriptive part is carried off with animation; the au- thor has a sense of the relevant inci- dent. How eloquent are the mere sta- tistics of the first fund for Mount Holy- oke Seminary. Largely through the per- sonal appeals of the founder $27,000 was collected from 1,800 people living in ninety-one towns. Certainly, few bag men of great causes have paid so gen- erously with their persons, and Mary Lyon herself was so exhausted in these solicitations that she reigned only a few years over her Academe. We think that, despite the defective materials, a keen- er analysis might have done some- thing to make the woman clearer. She was obviously far finer than anything she wrote or said, Her biographer, while adequate on the descriptive side, lapses into rather lifeless technicalities in her brief attempts at interpretation, de- pends too much upon documents from which the savor has departed and too little on her own insight. We have to do with a singular flowering of the New England temperament, its doggedness ennobled by a great and central cause, its rather ungentle shrewdness become fine worldly wisdom, its narrow and in- dividualistic religion raised to social passion, its “closeness” converted into that administrative prudence that guid- ed a lavish generosity. Out of her little savings Mary Lyon gave and lent reck- lessly to her seminary, and, when bet ter days came, she devoted a large share of a tiny income to missions and chari- ties. People criticised her public speak ing and begging for her cause. She wrote, “My heart is sick, my soul is pained with this empty gentility, this genteel nothingness. I am doing a great work. I cannot come down.” Such outbursts are rare, but they bring us near the real mood of the smiling advo- cate of what passed for a dangerous in- novation. With its partly inevitable shortcom- ings, this book is a valuable one both for the student of woman’s education and of New England in its constructive moment. All the facts are well deployed | and the stage is well set. If the hero ine’s voice only rarely carries across the footlights, that may be small fault of the stage management. Those who talk themselves out fully to their con temporaries seldom possess cadences ad. justed to the more difficult ear of pos terity. {dministrative Documents from the Second Dynasty of Ur. By David W. Myhrman, Ph.D. 146 pp. and Philadelphia: Department of Archeology of the University of Pennsylvania. $6. Sumerian 72 plates. The 171 tablets and fragments in this volume represent part of the material obtained from the first three expedi tions sent out to Nippur by the Uni- versity of Pennsylvania. The excava tions were conducted by Dr. J. P. Peters and J. H. Haynes, with the result of en- riching the collections of the university with thousands of tablets coming from various periods and representing chief- ly business documents. Dr. Myhrman is to be commended for the admirable copies that he has furnished of these difficult texts. He has avoided the mis- take made by some copyists of follow- ing too closely the shadings and pecu- liarities of the scribes, and thus merely increasing the labor of those who are to study the copies. We cannot agree with Dr. Myhrman in his use of the phrase, “Second Dynas- ty” of Ur, and he fails in his in- troduction to justify his view that there were two such dynasties. Not so many years ago Assyriologists suppos ed that there were three, or even four, Ur dynasties, but the general consensus now holds that there was only one. Dr. Myhrman is inclined to place the five rulers of Ur, who constitute what he calls the “Second Dynasty,” from 2408 zn. c. to 2291 pn. c. In this respect he differs from Prof. Eduard Meyer and others, who place the beginning of the Ur Dynasty about a century later. It all depends upon the question whether the so-called First Dynasty of Babylon was immediately followed by the Kas- sites or not. Dr. Myhrman thinks that there must have been a considerable in- terval between the two; but satisfac- tory evidence for this is wanting; and until further material of a definite char- acter is forthcoming the problem will have to be kept in abeyance. The most valuable part of Dr. Myhr- man’s introduction is in the chapters on the date formulas, and on the names and orders of the months, according to the tablets published by him. He has given a cumplete list of the dates at tached to the documents, which are en tered according to events in the careers of the reigning kings. The custom of dating according to the years of rulers was not introduced into Babylonia until -_ 655 the days of the Kassites. Supplement- ing the material furnished by his text from that to be found in other publica tions, we have now a complete series, with the exception of sixteen years in the rule of the fire’ member of the dynasty, and ten years in the rule of the second member. In his chapter on the names and orders of the months he has shown that during the Ur Dynasty no less than four different series of Sumerian names were used. From oth er sources we know that each month had even a larger number of names than four, and there is a problem con nected with this rather bewildering state of affairs that remains to be solv ed. An advance towards its solution has been made by Dr. Kugler in the second volume of his great work on Jabylonian astronomy, which unfortu nately came out too late to enuble Dr Myhrman to discuss the points in which he differs with Dr. Kugler. There ap pears to be even some question as to the order of the months, though it is doubt ful whether Dr. Myhrman is justified in raising the question whether one order was used at Ur and another at Nippur. The names, or rather the various series of names, being the same, the presump- tion is in favor of a uniform calendar at this period throughout the Euphrates Valley. There was apparently, how- ever, a shifting in the order of the months, for a designation that appears in one series as the seventh month ap- pears in another as the eighth. The question is a most important one, and deserves a fuller treatment than Dr. Myhrman was able to accord it in his summary introduction. The Works of James Buchanan, Collect ed and edited by J. B. Moore. Vols. IX, X, XI. Philadelphia: J. B. Lip- pincott Co. With the eleventh volume the publica tion of Buchanan's works is complete, so far as the text is concerned. There remains only an index volume. The last three volumes cover his service as Min ister to the Court of St. James, his Pres idency, and his retirement. An appen dix contains the comparatively small number of letters which had escaped the search of the editor. When in London he was concerned with the occupation of a part of Central America by Great Bri tain, in contravention, as was suppos ed, of the Clayton-Bulwer treaty, and with trade between Canada and the United States. His relations with the Aberdeen Ministry were cordial, and the points at issue were about to be settled when Aberdeen gave place to Palmers ton, and at once Buchanan saw that the probability of coming to an agreement was remote. His voluminous letters to Marcy contain much that is of interest from court-dress to the war in the Crimea, and mark the real ability of the

Page 20

656 man to deal with the conditions. He went to the Ustend Conference reluctant- ly, and, although the report was prepar- ed by him, he did not place a high esti- mate on the value of the performance. All this time he denied that he was seeking or desirous of receiving the nomination to the Presidency. His par- ty called him, and he was elected. It cannot be said that this series of vol- umes will materially alter the general opinion of Buchanan’s character and capabilities He was first a politician, and not un- til he returned to England did he devel- op a statesmanship which stood him in good stead at the time, but proved to be inadequate when the real test came. The slavery question hampered him time and again, and necessarily nar rowed his range of vision as well as of action. He never realized the greatness of the question involved, and could not lay aside his opinion formed in Jack son's day, never seeing that in more than thirty years the problem had be- come a moral as well as a social ques- tion. He believed no one understood his policy as President, and gathered ma- terial for a defence of his conduct. But he could not agree with Black, whom he selected to prepare this defence, and so the material came to naught. He lived long enough to see the end of the war, and the first experiments of reconstruc- tion, but he contributed nothing to the history of the times after his retire- ment. Mr. Moore has been very indus- trious in gathering his material and skilful in its use. The number of prt- vate letters is astonishingly small, and they are not rich in historical material. It ie much to have this well-arranged set of papers, for the growth of Bu- chanan is more readily measured. We wish the editor had not been so sparing of not and that he had more often given his experienced view of the course of diplomatic relations coming under Buchanan's direction, Notes. The Index of the Nation, January 1 to June 30, will be printed with the issue of July 7 J. F. Taylor & Co., New York, announce for publication early in August “Ingersoll: A Biographical Appreciation,” by Herman Em. Kittredge. This volume will be uniform with the Dresden edition of Robert G. In- gersoll’s works “The Ships and Sallora of Old Salem,” by Ralph D. Pain:, was credited in our re- view of June 16 to the Outing Publishing Co. It should have been noted that the books of this house have been taken over by A, C. McClurg & Co. of Chicago. Sturgis & Walton Co. announce for pub- lication next autumn “The Suffragette,” by Miss E. Sylvia Pankhurst; “Leopold II, King of the Belgians,” by Angelo 8. Rap- poport; “Hunting Camps in Wood and Wil- The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2348 derness,” by H. Hesketh-Prichard; ana | “Famous Impostors,” by Bram Stoker. George H. Doran Company has obtained | the exclusive selling agency for the book | and calendar publications of the Life Pub- lishing Company. The Society for the Preservation of New England Antiquities, which has for its ob- ject the purchase and care of places of his- torical or other interest, has just issued the first number of its illustrated bulletin. The society invites applications for member- ship. Information may be had from W. §, Appleton, No. 20 Beacon Street, Boston. The Société des Gens de Lettres has awarded the French Bourse Nationale Littéraire, 3,000 francs. to the poet, Maurice Levaillant. Two books of verse, “Le Miroir d’étain”’ and “Le Temple intérieur,”’ have been published by M. Levaillant, who is a native of Normandy. “Federal Fish Farming” is the suggestive title of an interesting account of our fish cultural work by Deputy Commissioner Hugh M. Smith in the National Geographic Magazine for May. Beginning nearly forty years ago with the investigation of the re- ported decrease of food fishes in New Eng- land waters, the bureau now puts out year- ly more than three billion fishes—the perch being the largest number. Among its sub- sidiary contributions to our national wel- fare is the discovery of widely prevalent fish cancer, which may be of great and far- reaching consequence because of its bear- ing on the cause of human cancer, and the improvement of the fishing vessels. By the introduction of a type of craft which com- bines large carrying capacity and great speed with enhanced safety, the loss of fish- ing schooners from the port of Gloucester alone has decreased from 82 vessels and 895 men in the ten years ending in 1883 to “only a fourth as many vessels and men” in the ten years ending in 1907. “One of our worst enemies.’ the house-fly, is described by N. A. Cobb, with enlarged photographs, and Harriet C, Adams tells of a trip by the recently opened Transandine Railroad from Buenos Ayres to Valparaiso. All the arti- cles are illustrated in the admirable manner now characteristic of this magazine. Hutchins Hapgood shares with Gilbert | Chesterton an odd philosophy of com- monness, but illustrates it in a fashion at once more vague and less paradoxical. He holds that in mankind brought through poverty or vice near to the limit there | inheres a distinction born of complete | spontaneity. The lowly (like aristocrats, who are also brought near to the limit by | the opportunities of wealth aiding a strong sense of life) are the “real thing.” They know how they feel, and say what they mean, are open hearted and unvexed by small scruples. the tough are akin in being infinitely su- perior to the bourgeois, who is par excel- lence the unspontaneous man. Already the thesis of the book begins to look familiar. We have the romantic craving for ex- tremes, the romantic scorn for qualified or middling things. But readers generally of Mr. Hapgood’s “Types from City Streets” (Punk & Wagnalis) will bother rather lit- tle about the thesis. They know that Mr. Hapgood has thoroughly coasted his Bohe- mia and Alsatia, and that his discoveries glamour that looks like that of life, and Is! Thus the aristocrat and | perhaps the more attractive because it is | nothing of the kind. Such readers will hold high expectations of a book that presents not merely a single thief or a small group of anarchists, but a full hundred of eccen- tric types. In the eating of the pudding, however, there may be some disappoint- ment. Most of this work is early and sketchy. A great enthusiasm, a fairly re- ligious zeal for the morally unbraced in- dividual, is everywhere apparent; but the types themselves are of a disconcerting sameness. They seem dissolved in the au- thor’s admiration of them, so that what one really gets is not a vivid and various picture of the low life of New York, but a continuous revelation of a soul privateer- ing among phantoms which it generously takes to be tall fellows. The reason for a kind of “‘woolliness”’ in this book is prob- ably that in these early explorations Mr. Hapgood’s eye was less on the object, than on the general gorgeousness of the quest. There may have been a still sorer obstacle to clear vision. Just as the too sympathetic physician may actually induce all manner of symptoms in a sensitive pa- tient, so it seems possible that Mr. Hap- good so captivated his types that they in- sensibly assumed the colors of his expecta- tions. However that be, the book is of a beguiling enthusiasm, and that read- er who should explore the East Side in the hope of seeing it with Mr, Hapgood’s eyes would have to blame for a disappointment merely his own lack of critical psychology. The latest section of the “New English Dictionary,” prepared by W. A. Craigie (Clarendon Press), carries the story from round-nosed to ryze. It is interesting to notice that in the last three sections the language has been almost equally indebted to the Teutonic and to the Romanic tribu- taries." Among the words of obscure ori- gin, rowdy is one of the most piquant. It is of pretty recent coinage, and it is assign- ed to America. In the first instance, 1819, it was a term for American backwoodsmen— “the hunters, or Illinois Rowdies, as they are called, are rather troublesome.” In Queensland, in 1872, one could speak of a “rowdy bullock.” In England, in 1862, the term was applied to the brawlers at an | election. The leviathan of this gathering ig the little word run, a rich idiom-maker, which, with all its forms and senses, oc- |eupies thirty-seven columns—simple read- | ing for one to the manner born, but appal- | lingly difficult for a foreigner. Fancy, for | example, the sorrows of a French school- boy pondering on the difference between running up a road and running up a bill; running for office or running for the office, and running for life or a silver cup; run- | ning off a race and running off the track; running down a hill and running down a pe- destrian or a rival; looking run down or letting a clock or a house run down. The historic vista which this section "opens and the change which has taken place in the ideals of dictionary-makers may perhaps be suggested by saying that it 'earries the story from Round Table to rub- | berneck. Even though the material had | been accessible, it would have appeared to | the classical Dr. Johnson sheer idleness to /wade through medimval romance, blazing | his way to Wace’s Roman ve Brut (1155) to lare usually interesting, invested with a | find the first mention of the Arthurian board. To-day a student wishing to Iinvesti-

Page 21

June 30, 1910] The Nation. ' gate that famous institution may turn to. the dictionary for a fairly extensive direc- tory of original sources. Chesterfield, who, though not essentially frivolous, had a keen relish for frivolity, urged Johnson in a periodical of the day to include in his forthcoming dictionary a list of the gay cant words of polite society, including “flir- tation,” at the birth of which he had himself assisted. But, alas for the earl, the lexi- cographer, with a thunderbolt in his sleeve, was meditating at that time on the meaning of literary patronage, and was in no mood for the cant of polite society. Tempora mutantur—hence the indecorous act, and the atrociously indecorous word for the act, of “rubbernecking,” and their record in the treasury of our speech. The reflection that many of us here at this hour assisted at the birth of this ill-featured monster should lead us to set a guard upon our lips. The indiscretions of yesterday become the pre- cedents of to-morrow; the hapless purist must be prepared to hear the schoolboy’s irrefragable retort, “It’s in the dictionary!” “An Outdoor Breviary,” by M. Jourdain (London: The Academy Press), is one of those rather numerous books about nature in which preciosity of phrase and plenti- ful literary allusion serve to cover essen- tial thinness and vagueness of feeling. Thus the annual round in England is trick- ed out with oddments of a somewhat ro- coco sort, the result being perhaps en- trancing to the more sophisticated read- er of to-day. A stray figure or two may serve for allurement or warning. Cherry blossoms ‘“‘shine like the silver veins of a niello’’—such reversion from nature to art is characteristic. ‘The sun, from beneath a blue cloud pours his rayed water-carriers, regular as the pale amber sticks of a delicate fan, upon the heavy-headed elms steeped in a film of blue, and upon the infinite distance built up of wet light and pale cloud-like forms of hill and plain.’’ Here is distinc- tion, of a sort, but the sort is pretty fa- miliar. To the attractive uniform edition of the works of Vernon Lee, the John Lane Co. has added the volume of essays on social sub- jects entitled “Althea.”” Sympathy and fru- gality on the part of the favored class is the sum of the matter as threshed out by the amiable figureheads who speak the author’s thoughts. One or two of them have a cer- tain life of their own. The dialogues are an eloquent plea for a discreet undoctrinal So- cialism that implies rather change of heart than overturning of political forms. From English writings of the thirteenth and fourteenth centuries the Rev. W. W. Skeat has collected 302 proverbs. These are illustrated by parallels from English and other literatures, so that the toral mass of proverbs is large and instructive. Professor Skeat remarks the scarcity of such “bywords” in Anglo-Saxon literature. This is due surely only to the fact that we have almost nothing of a truly popular sort transmitted from thi: period. The prov- erbs must have existed, they merely did not get written down. Recent criticism has Fuggested that such thirteenth centucy documents as the “Ancren Riwle”’ aad much of the material in Morris’s “Old Eng- Jish Homilies” are really transcripts of originals neary two centuries older. If so, a certain amount of the proverbial stuff in this book should be credited to Anglo- Saxon times. But Professor Skeat is sileat 28 to these redatings. Chaucer is naturally the chief source of proverbial wisdom, pro- viding more than a third of the whole. His sapient Pandarus in “Troilus and Cres- sida” is full of sententious examples, but the fair Cressida herself is skilful in gloz- ing her own frailty by these moral com- monplaces. Civilizations are pictured ' proyerbs. We say to-day, “Don’t crack a hazelnut with a triphammer.”” The four- ‘eenth century equivalent of this maxim is “Don’t start a falcon at a fly” (No. 102) This learred little book, called “Early English Proverbs” (Henry Frowde), it schol readers of which is represents the ations of a gr It will not fail to interest antiquarian bent. recre ir In one of the last letters Grover Cleve- land ever wrote he expressed the belief that the man to lead the Democratic party back to and its old John A. Johnson, thrice elected as a Dem- ocrat Governor of Republican Minnesota. When Gov. Johnson died last autumn Theo- dore Roosevelt wrote from Central Africa to Mrs, Johnson that her husband’s death was a “loss to good citizenship,” and char- acterized him as “one of those Americans who we like to believe are typical of our people as a whole.” Few Americans in pub- lic view in the past decade have so striking- ly illustrated the opportunities of Ameri- can life as Gov. Johnson. The story of his career is interestingly told by Frank A. Day and Theodore M. Knappen, two of his close associates, in their “Life of John Al- bert Johnson” (Forbes & Co.). The book, as the authors explain, is not intended to be a critical biography. Their hope is “to extend as widely and as soon as possible the influence that Gov. Johnson would have continued to exert in person had he lived.” As far as any memorial biography can ac- complish such an end, this will probably accomplish it. It is too early to measure the man’s influence or determine his place in the history of the nation, but the sym- pathetic picture here presented by those who knew and loved him is well worth pre- serving. That this son of poor immigrant parents, who was born in a frontier £tate in one of the civil-war years, and spent al- most his entire life as the editor of a lit- tle country newspaper, should in so brief a time have overcome both political and social obstacles and stood forth as a Pres- idential possibility, is reason enough to make the story of his life worth telling. Prof. J. H. Wigmore, not content with the contribution made in his elaborate “Treatise on the System of Evidence,” hae now rendered the trial lawyer a further service by compressing into a compact code the essential rules of the subject (‘A Pock- et Code of the Rules of Evidence in Trials at Law”; Little Brown & Co.) In this handbook of 485 pages of text (and 80 pages of index) the law of evidence is stated in the form of some 230 leading propositions, with their various qualifications running into more than 2,000 sections, with no cita- tion of authorities but with a multitude of cross references and of citations to the cor- responding discussions in the “Treatise.” its old creed policies was We can agree that the usefulness of Stephen’s “Digest” has been “barred by limitation,” and may add that, even if such were not the case, its usefulness will lessen 657 appreciably with the appearance of this The make-up of any such book ts an There ts here the ordl- code. important matter. nary device of blank alternate pages, and a system of brackets gives real guidance to the fast worker. The recognized rules of evidence are stated in ordinary form. Those rules, or modifications, which prevail in some, but not all, jurisdictions, are placed within single brackets, while propositions which are nowhere recognized as law, but should be, are. within double brackets. The curved brace to identify a rule which “is the law in every jurisdiction, but is used ought not to be law”; only two instances of this last notation are found, although ts place seems sometimes to be taken by a footnote (#§ 710, 7i2) Where the single bracket is used, in addition to the tation to the discussion in the “Treatise,” a foot-note often indicates the jurisdiction of dissent. The bracket may enclose only one word, often “not,” in a rule, but it at once puts one on inquiry. That a careful use of this code will guard the prudent trial law- yer against proceeding on a chance is shown by the fact that the single bracket appears in more than In some cases, the single bracket seems wrongly super seded by the double, as in the proposition ($16) that the “judge may express to the jury, after the close of evidence and argu- ment, his personal opinion ag to the credl- bility or weight of the evidence or any part thereof,” the foot-note adding: ‘‘This is not the law to-day in any jurisdiction, except in New Jersey and in the Federal courts. But it ought to be."’ Professor Wigmore files a claim on his quarter-sec- tion of legal authorship by the notice that he proposes to bring out a series of the code with special annotations suitable for each of the jurisdictions “having volumin- ous authorities.” It is to be hoped that the New York edition will be widely used His preface points out truly, with unpleas- ant candor, that “an accurate familiarity with the local rules of evidence is to-day lacking among practitioners notably in metropo!!- 500 instances. lamentably who try cases (most tan courts).”’ In the Nation of February 17 reference was made to the approaching completion of the Weimar edition of Goethe. Since that date two of the promised volumes have ap peared, the final volume of the “Gedicht: (V2) and volume XLIX of the “Brief The volume of the poems, edited by Juliu Wahle, is composed for the most part of the critical apparatus, with some neces commentary, to volumes IV and V!. It cludes also the corrections and additions essential to offset the errors and oversights arising out Of and revealed by the chang: of editors, Loeper having died in 1891 and Redlich in 1900, with the difficult editorial ar in- task still far from completed, Under th: head of “Nachtrige”’ there is given but one poem by Goethe, viz., “Das Tagebuch,” which doubtless would not have been included in this edition at all, if had rot already appeared elsewhere. Goethe probably intended that it should never be published, because, as he said, “the world is accustomed to call such things immoral.” His own manuscript was sealed up some years ago, never to be opened, not even for this edition. But Hirzel published his un- authorized copy of it privately, in 1861, for a small circle of Goethe admirers, and one

Page 22

658 or more of the copies passed into strange hands, publishers as an to be seized upon by unscrupulous irresistible lure for the The later included in some of the editions of Goethe. pathological public. poem was Among the “Paralipomena” a consid- erable number of scraps from the poet’s workshop, which Wahle endeav- are interesting ors, with rare knowledge and insight, to bring The alphabetical index of first lines includes not into their proper connection only the poems of the first six volumes, but also all the lyrics scattered throughout the many volumes of the edition, except those to be found in the dramas Why the latter should have been omitted, we are not told. rhe index is the work of Hans Gerhard Grif, and will be of great service to all who use the edition, especially as conven- lence for reference was not the fundamental purpose of the arrangement of the early volumes The Weimar edition being the only complete one and the only one that at- tempts to give full inforination as to manu- scripts, first publication, and variant read- ings, scholars are now for the first time ia possession of all the critical material bearing on the poems. The volume of the letters, edited by Max Hecker, covers the period from July, 1831, to the poet’s death 1a March, 1832. It contains 194 letters, of which 65 are here published for the first time in their entirety, though extracts from some of them have previously appeared in other publications. The letter of the ries is the important and oft-quoted one of the 17th of March, 1832, to Wilhelm von Ilumboldt Goethe died five days later. By a pecullar slip of the last pen, or oversight in proof-reading, Hecker gives the date of his death the 9th of March (p, 287), haps a confusion of the 9th of May, death 1805), as per- the with the late of Schiller’s ! of March (in George A “atisfactory Hubbell has given us the most of Horace Mann been under the title Mann Educator, Patriot and Re- (Philadelphia: Wm. F. Fell Co.). the teaching a village in Ohio, a of inaugural of Horace Mann as president of College fel] into his hands and him Later a a student h he tudied work former. paration of posal Mann. It n by Mann and loved of his reformer In in biography that has Horace ormer” written, i When author was hool vddre copy the uN greatly moved nd as a professor at Ant id was greatly influenced by the life our great t educat nal re i ha pent xX vear il f the blog pre raphy i! al amount his dil Mr appreciative ! were writte or who had known Hora ‘ not unmindful fault Not n tl Mas und mly h career as a achueetta Legislature and the of struggle work for has ever peaceful final y¢ ndequately portrayed year which he did the greatest Amer!|- done, at see ition that been more irs We a great is told ina inat personality and The direct neg levoted leader story atyl mple and of la littérature francaise,” “L'Age Loulse The value such a manual a’Or de Delpit students are as by (Heath), is questionable American likely to to still turn, if they French, Lanson or Pellissier, to read The Nation. 2348 Zz [Vol. go, No. which this book adds little. A manual in English, based upon such substantial works, would probably have a better chance. In “Education for Efficiency’ (Heath & Co.) Prof E. Davenport of the University of Illinois makes a vigorous and convinc- ing argument for such changes in our schools, and especially in the high schools, as shall make all the people in their needs for everyday life. He thinks that through vocational studies in the al- ready established institutions, and not through separate trade schools, our youth should obtain that education for efficiency and service which is and more de- manded. He would give one-fourth of the time of the high-school pupil to this vo- cational work. Professor Davenport writes from the agricultural standpoint and points out very clearly and definitely how voca- them serve more tional work in agriculture can be made a part of the course of schools which draw their pupils wholly or in part from the country. We wish that he or some one else would indicate how vocational training for every one can be given ina city high school, which draws its pupils not from a single occupation like farming, but from a multi- tude of occupations. “L’ Invention la composition dans de Rabelais” (H. Champion, 400 pages, 8 francs), by Jean Plattard, docteur és lettres, has a trinle interest—in history, in university matters, and in language and literature. with the the romance et l’uvre relations of Rabelais’s work to literature of his time; of moinage and the Respublica Scholastica; law studies and legists: medical science; humanism; popular wit; and the general characters of Rabelais’s style. “Les Civilisations de l'Afrique du Nord” (Armand Colin, 400 pages, 4 maps, 4 francs), by Victor Piquet, treats with suc- cinct erudition of the past history of what is now a French sphere of influence—Tunis, Algiers, and Morocco. Except for Tripoli, this answers to the former Barbary States. The present volume has to do with Berbers the primitive, and still the most numer- Arabs and Turks, by the way such adventitious Pheenicians of Carthage, Ro- mans and Byzantines, and Spaniards. It stops short of present French “Berberie,” to which a future volume is to be given. ous race—conquering and notes elements as Ludwig Rapp, the historian, died recently at Innsbruck, at the age of eighty-two. Among his works, which deal chiefly with Tyrolese history, are “Kénigin Magdalena yon Oesterreich,” “Hexenprozesse in Tirol,” and “Eine Jakobiner Verschwérung in Tirol.” — science. Frederick A. Stokes Company will pub- lish, early in July, “Common Weeds of the Farm and Garden,” by Harold C. Long. At the of the of Cornell University day, June 23, Burt G. Wilder, tive of the original ing resigned after a emeritus of trustees commencement the last ac- faculty, hav- of forty-two professor of meeting board on member service years, was made neurology and vertebrate zodlogy. The “History of Gardening In England,” by the Hon. Mrs. Evelyn Cecil (Dutton), In successive chapters it deals| /undertakings at noblemen’s ‘has now, after a lapse of fifteen years, ap- peared in a third edition, enlarged and re- vised. It is an interesting book, appro- priately illustrated, and made with the un- usual combination of industry and taste. Its multitudes of facts are almost bewilder- ing, but the general impression is curiously the same as that made by Curtler’s “Short History of English Agriculture,” lately re- viewed in these columns. For centuries af- ter the period of stability under the Ro- mans, agriculture and gardening in England flourished in peace, languished in domestic war. There were, for the simple home folk, dreadful periods in the dark ages, when neither prosperity nor glimpses of beauty could be counted on, sometimes for gen- erations together. Taste was not known; gardening was scarcely undertaken outside of monastery walls. But when these walls were thrown down by Henry VIII we mark the commencement of England's internal prosperity, which, except at two epochs under the Stuarts, has continued till this day. Then first began the general home- gardening, which meant comfort to the householder; next followed the develop- ment of styles. To Americans the glimpses into English gardening are interesting, chiefly for the thoroughness with which changes in taste were accepted by the nation, and the great scale on which improvements were made. Enormous gardens made for fétes to visit- ing ambassadors were but temporary; large country seats seldom lasted longer than from father to son. It is only the gardens of the eight- eenth century, and very few of those, which have lasted till our day. When we read of the five-hundred acre garden at Stow, we marvel. If an imitator’s garden of but twenty-eight acres cost, with its walks, ponds, fountains, and bridges, its statues, temples, and columns, the greater part of the great fortune of its owner’s wife, what must have been the outlay on the larger place? Every change of style produced similar expenditures throughout the kingdom. And the changes were wide. When the excesses of the Dutch style, with its formal designs and sheared trees, brought about the imitation of landscape (it was Kent, says Walpole, who “leaped the fence, and saw that all Nature was a garden’’), the extreme of fashion was as great. “Capability” Brown made the final developments of a style according to which an avenue of trees was a blemish, and a flower visible from the house a painful dis- crepancy. It is interesting to find that in the changes from these two excesses of taste an influence was exerted by men of let- ters, in the first case Addison and Pope, in the latter, Scott. The landscape style was eventually followed by the bedding system, by which for three months the garden flared with the brilliant hues of hothouse plants, and for the remaining nine was a withered waste. William Robin- son, late in the nineteenth century, brought about the beginning of the change to the old hardy plants which now, in a combina- tion of wildness and formality, procure for English gardens (alas, not for ours!) flow- ers for every month. This is made pos- sible, of course, partly by climate, partly /by the wonderful plant discoveries of the | nineteenth new found, Innumerable were century. varieties, and even species,

Page 23

June 30, 1910] The Nation. imported, and propagated, so that now, with bulbs and shrubs, and new hardy an- nuals and perennials, the English garden is at a far remove from the monastery herbarium. When we read the list of plants recently discovered, but not yet propagated im England, we realize the further possibilities of the English garden —and of our own. “Mosquito or Man” (Dutton) is the title of a handsome and attractive book by Sir Rubert W. Boyce, a professor of the Uni- versity of Liverpool, who has extended per- sonal knowledge of his subject and writes charmingly about it. As indicated by a secondary title, the author’s purpose is to show the relation of the mosquito to the diseases of man, and to make clear what may be done to exterminate the mosquito or limit its harmfulness to man in tropical countries. The point of view is that of the British schools of tropical medicine, and the problems considered are those of British residents in the tropics, but the writer is thoroughly and appreciatively familiar with the important work done by Americans, more especially that in Cuba and at New Orleans. Less attention is paid to the problem as it presents itself in the temperate z nes, but here the solution is essentially the same. The practical work in other countries is briefly treated. These qualifications do not impair the value of the book, which is one of the best for the general reader, well calculated to give him a clear idea of what man mav do for his own protection. In a few short final chap- ters some other diseases due to insects, or other causes controllable !y hygienic measures, are considered most suggestively, but almost too briefly Boyce calls par- ticular attention to the fly, the common house fly (Musca domestica), proposing to name it in general the “septic fly.” How- ard’s name, the “typhoid fly,” he holds to be unsatisfactory in its apparent limitation of the vast variety of harm done by this animal, which is the disgrace as well as the pest of domestic economy. The thought- ful reader will quickly perceive that when the community really recognizes what the fly can do there will begin a campaign far more remarkable than that against the mos- quito, wonderful as that has been. The book has many interesting illustrations, ex- ceptionally well reproduced. Although not so stated, either on the fitle page or in the preface, the “‘popular’’ edi- tion of Prof. Elie Metchnikoff’s ‘‘Prolonga- tion of Life’ (Putnam), translated by P Chalmers Mitchell, is a reprint of the edi- tion published in 1908. There is therefore nothing new in it except the introduction by Prof. Charles S. Minot of the Harvard Medical School. Professor Minot says that Metchnikoff’s greatest contribu- tions to science are his two _ vol- umes, “Lessons on the Comparative Pathology of Inflammation,” published in 1892, and his “L’Immunité,” which appeared in 1901. Professor Metchnikoff’s discovery that the white blood cells (leucocytes) are the scavengers of the body has exerted a tremendous influence in promoting experi- mentation with sera and anti-toxins. This discovery alone should be sufficient to award him a lasting place in the history of medical experimentation. The optimism of Professor Metchnikoff is evident in all his work, and as Professor Minot puts it, “One feels that here fs a man to whom hope !s a habit of mind.” For more than forty |years (he is now sixty-five) Metchnikoft’s great gifts have been employed in the cause of science, and, unlike some of his less ; fortunate predecessors and colleagues, he has seen these gifts bear rich fruit in the ervice of mankind. Drama and Musie. A Garland to Sylvia. By Percy Mac- Kaye. New York: The Macmillan Co. $1.25 net. This is an early work begun original- ly in 1897, when Mr. MacKaye was a senior in Harvard, and completed in 1899, when he was a student in Italy. He now publishes it with an explanatory preface, or rather two prefaces—his present introduction including one writ- ten at a much earlier period—and af- ter some editing, the extent of which is not indicated. On the title page, it is called a dramatic reverie, which is, per- haps, as good a definition as any other. {Its dramatic value is nil and its purport vain, but regarded as a poetic fan- tasy, born of youthful speculation in unfathomable metaphysical and psycho- logical mysteries, it is fanciful and in- teresting. Briefly it is a tale of a Har- ;vard undergraduate of mystical tenden- cies, who has chosen for the heroine of his first play the subject of Shake- | speare’s famous song, “Who is Sylvia?” He pictures her as a daughter of Pan, the spiritual essence of all loveliness in Nature, and having embodied her in his peetic vision, falls in love with his |Own creation and has moments of illu- 'sion when he can see her and speak with ‘her. In the play she is the object of ‘general adoration, but can be won only 'by that suitor who shall be able to di- |vine her secret, which is that, although | apparently mortal, she ‘s actually a jspirit. The riddle is solved only. by the | villain, Sandrac, a dealer in magic; and the problem is how she may be saved from him, without the violation of dra- matic truth, which te the pcet lover ts sacred. Finally, in despair, after a hint from the apparition of Sylvia herself, the author, as a last resource, burns his manuscript. Then in a vislon—the reverie is a play within a play—he sees his plot enacted, and discovers that the fanciful creatures whom he has willed into existence have become persistent entities in the realm which they inhabit, and that he no longer has the power to divert them from their destined course. They are the living beings while he is a futile ghost. Then he is compelled to stand by in impotence and see his adored Sylvia delivered into the power of the hated Sandrac. In the end, however, Sylvia teaches him how even dreams must perish in the waters of oblivion, and Sandrac and his mates having been beguiled into drinking of Lethe’s stream, |H 659 the lovers are happily united and the curtain falls. Such a scheme could not be work- ed out with any great semblance of logical coherence, even on the theory of which the young poet seems have been enamoured—that men are as insub stantial unrealities as the fancies be gotten of them. Inconsistencies in the workmanship weaken its effect, either as fairy tale or allegory. But under- lying it all is-a pregnant suggestion of the of the uttered thought and of the incalculable influence of the of the inventions to persistency personality dramatist, not on'y upon the of his fancy, upon the actors who interpret them and the individual minds of the spectators but The idea of the play originated, Mr MacKaye says, in some such considera tions as these, which, of course, are not entirely new. But in his more ma- ture preface, Mr. MacKaye is careful to disavow present responsibility for eith er the philosophy or the fallacies of this juvenile product, which, however, is well worthy tre dignity of print. With all its occasional crudity, imitativeness and temerity, it is often amazingly clev- er and contains much charming poetry Many of the conceptions of nature are particularly striking. Daniel Sully, the actor, died on Satur- day at Woodstcck, N. Y., at the age of fif- ty-five. After some years’ experience in music halls he wrote, in 1884, “The Corner Grocery,” playing the leading part in this for five years. He produced several other and, in 1889, “The Parish Priest.” In this and in a number of subsequent pro ductions he always appeared in the rdle of a priest. He was well known through out the United States. He retired in 1907 pieces, A monograph upon the life and work of the late Edward MacDowell, by Mrs. Eliza- beth Fry Page, is announced for immedi- ate publication by the Dodge Publishing Co., New York. This house will also pub- lish, in September, a work costumes, coveringnineteen centuries,by Mrs. Charles Ashdown. The revival of the “Mikado” in New York has been rewarded with house and its run has been extended two weeks The theatrical managers should be the moral to heart. They constant y telling us that the public gets what it serves; they say they would be glad enoug put on good things, but things never Their mistake is to | seen. that good things that the inner circles rave about have no attraction for the of men they conclude that it is their goodness that works their undoing. But is not fn the least true. To be sure, there are many out-of-the-way things that are excellent of on crowded laying are Ar to good plain thing pay. Finding many mass this their kind, and yet do not win large popu- larity. But that is not because they are good, but because they are of a certain kind. As Chesterton says, “the public does not like good introspective sonnets, but neither does it like bad introspective son- nets.” Similar'y, the public may choose bad comic opera rather than good grand

Page 24

660 opera, but it had still rather, any day, have good comic opera. Certainly, there is 4 very large public that has been craving the Gilbert and Sullivan repast—many have been craving it without even knowing of its existence And their hunger is not sated. Besides, the “Mikado,” with all its abound- ing fun, is a good deal less delightful than “Pinafore,” and a good deal less clever than “Patience.” Surely, the much-abused public has proved that it deserves to b subjected to these tests, too! There is great satisfaction in England over the appointment of Henry J. Wood as conductor of the Birmingham Festival in succession to Hans Richter. Owing to the glamour which still attaches to the foreign- er, where the British musical public is con- cerned, it was feared that English conduc- tors would be overlooked. In Germany alone there are 373 com- posers who belong to a society formed six years ago for the purpose, chiefly, of col- lecting fees for performing rights. Such fees were gathered in 1909 to the amount of $62,500, an Increase of $15,000 above the receipts of the previous year. No less than 80 per cent. of the sum collected went to the composers, librettists, and publishers, who are included in the society to the num- ber of seventy-six. The number of libret- tists is not given. Since 1904, the society has collected altogether $220,000. Among the members are Richard Strauss, Engelbert, Schumann. A similar organization has been founded in England. Humperdinck, and Georg It is reported from Dresden that Rich- ard Strauss’s next opera, “Cavaliers of the Rose,” will be produced for the first time there early in December. The libretto is by Hugo von Hofmannsthal, and the subtitle for the opera is a “comedy for music.” The plot is the hackneyed one—a young elegant, entrusted with a proposal of marriage on behalf of an elderly, rich suitor, falling in love with the lady, and having his love re- turned. The scene is laid in the middle of the elghteenth century, in Vienna, at the time of Maria Theresa. The story of Mascagni’s new opera, “Yso- bel,” which is to be produced for the first time In any country in America next autumn by the newly organized Bessie Abbott Opera Company, is taken from the legend of Lady Godiva, the oldest known version of which dates back to the thirteenth century, but which is most familiar through Tennyson's poem. The action is set in the town of Coventry, in the eleventh century. Luigi Illica, the librettist, who also wrote the librett! of “Tosca” and several other stand- ard operas, has departed from the origi- nal legend in many Instances. It is “Yso- bel,” the daughter of the Earl of Ches- ter, who makes the famous ride to save her townfolk. To protect her during her act of sacrifice, an edict Is lasued condemning any to the loss of eyesight who do not remain behind closed doors, while Ysobel makes her ride The hero of the opera, a young hunts- man who has worshipped Lady Ysobel from afar, takes advantage of the only chance to bring himself to her notice by defying the edict. He remains on a balcony and pelts her with flowers as she passes. Here begins, the love story around which the opera is built. A descriptive Intermezzo will depict the ride. Signor Mascagni will himself con- duct each performance of the new opera. [Vol. 90, No. 2348 The Nation. Art. The Boston Museum of Fine Arts. By Julia de Wolf Addison. Illustrated. Boston: L. C. Page & Co. Since the New Art Museum at Boston has been opened barely six months, this book has a topical character un- usual in its class. At times it betrays the haste of its preparation, but in gen- eral it gives about the technical, histori- cal, and biographical information that a visitor will wish. It is more discursive than most of the series to which it be- longs, and, in a way, less business-like. It is readable without much sense of proportion. For example, the Wedg- wood potteries are quite preposterously overwritten, while Chinese porcelains are treated quite inadequately. The work is planned for the longitude of Boston, which, since there will be its best reading, should perhaps not be counted a defect. For anybody but a Bostonian the story of the disputable Velasquez, and the famous referendum to a lot of more or less competent art- ists is unduly amplified. It would be enough to say that this was a transi- tional work, presumably genuine, but of rather slight artistic importance. The matter of this book, barring ex- ceptions which will be noted later, is much more satisfactory than its man- ner, which is, in a word, the New Eng- land amateur literary style. It is a dic- tion as marked and worthy of investiga- tion as, say, African Latinity. The car- dinal maxims seem to be, When you have nothing to say, say it pretentious- ly, and when you have very little, say it repetitiously. A fair example is the phrase in which the author praises the installation of the Far Eastern depart- ment. “Not until such a museum as this is seen, may a visitor fully under- stand the message of Japanese art as displayed in this way.” Here is merely an extreme case of a frequent defect. In spite of these drawbacks, the book contains a considerable amount of rele- | vant illustrative material, and with a) little overhauling can be made very use. ful. A few suggestions are offered for a second edition. David Cox and D. Rob- erts are apparently taken to be Ameri- can artists, and furthermore no mention is made of Cox’s importance as a techni- clan. The Museum’s remarkable collection of drawings by William Blake is not properly emphasized. Hokusai’s Thirty- six Views of Fuji, the large colored ser- les, is erroneously described as a first stage towards the unduly famous Hun- dred Views in monochrone and small dl- mensions. On page 209 Diirer receives credit for a woodcut, Death in the Bel-| fry, which must be Rethel’s well-known | composition. On page 116 a rug ts dat- ed 1640, but the corresponding illustra-| tion reads “sixteenth century.” Spag- noletto, page 63, Is a very ugly misprint for Lo Spagna. A number of the for- ‘eign names have been distorted in the ‘types. Mezzotint engraving might have ‘been treated more at length, but toward the merely charming in art our author is inexorable. Of Boucher’s tapestry de- \signs she says that they are “lacking in | dignity as the type of a noble art.” This ‘is uncontrovertible, and she proceeds, '“It would be as justifiable to treat the ‘mane of the British lion with Marcel |waves as to cover these textile monu- ‘ments of human industry with these fluttering idiocies.” At this point it ap- ‘pears unmistakably that Boston disap- proves of Trianon: “It was ail part and parcel of the smirking sentimental folly of that France which could not hear its own death-knell ringing in the groans of the oppressed who were compelled to suffer that the court might scintillate.” | We agree that these were feckless folk, but are as glad, from the point of view ‘of art, that instead of pursuing the mel- ancholy duty of listening for their ‘death-knell, which our author retro- ‘spectively advises, they thoughtlessly ‘employed such artists as Watteau, Boucher, and Fragonard. Feeling that it is a mistake to try to see all the pictures of the chief European galleries in a single season, Mrs. Lorinda Munson Bryant has prepared a book called “What Pictures to See in Europe in a Sin- gle Summer” (John Lane Co.). Her coun- sel of moderation and selection is pretty well vitiated by her lack of knowledge, taste, or confidence in the teachableness of her readers. They are sent out of Italy without having seen anything of Giotto but | the Dante portrait still falsely ascribed to him in the Bargello. They quit the Berlin Museum without seeing the Van Eycks or the Holbeins that are its glory. In the Louvre the book makes no mention of Watteau. For the author no working dis- tinction between various Ghirlandaios and Vivarinis exists. The comment throughout is thoroughly philistine and poor in ex- pression. On the other hand, it may for that reason be better adjusted than a bet- ter guide could be to the capacity of those whom it addresses. Charles A. Lasar, in “Practical Hints |for Art Students” (Duffield), sets forth in brief maxims, which are frequently repeat- |ed, the law and gospel of the modern neo- | smpresntontetie method of landscape paint- | ing. Purple is the great harmonizer. Blue | —shades of Sir Joshua!—is an advancing |eolor; red a retreating one. Of course this is only true when painting is a purple | feat. Perugino’s distances, perhaps | the loveliest and remotest we have, }are in blue untempered by warmer color. | But then the artless Umbrian laid in his | foregrounds in the despised browns and | went back through cool grays. We fear that to take Mr. Lasar’s color hints literally would result in a generation painting uni- |formly Ike Mr. Redfield. Still the maxims are wholesome as to simplicity, elimination, jand concentration of effect. The initial chapter on linear design and the expres- ision of the figures, though eccentric in | phrase, should be useful. It hammers into

Page 25

a j «, * June 30, 1910] The Nation. 661 the beginner the truth that composition is not merely an arrangement of the obvious lines, but of their projections in space. A few quotations will suggest the temper of this little manual: Civilize everything except the eye. Never economize knowledge, but econo- mize labor. Every scene has a principal sensation, multiply this sensation until the spectator can get at it quickly. This book is calculated to make the be- ginner think. Its defect is a too narrow contemporaneousness. The student should add to Mr. Lasar’s maxims the old pro- saic one—‘‘There are many ways.” The Société des Artistes Francais has an- nounced the award of four prizes, as fol- lows: The Prix Rosa Bonheur to Louis Désiré Lucas, for his Femme A la Quenouille; the Prix Marie Bashkirtseff, to Léon Cassel, for his Sortie du Salut: | Béguinage de Bruges (exhibited in this year’s Salon); the Prix Balin-Dolet to F. L. Duluard, for his original etching, Le Triomphe de Mardochée, and the Prix Raigecourt Guyon te C. L. E. Signoret for his two pictures which he showed in the Salon. Finance. BALANCE OF TRADE. The persistent hold of the mercantil- ist idea of the balance of trade on the general mind was never more strikingly illustrated than in the place given to it in the late Secretary Hay’s splendid eulogy of President McKinley. That por- tion of his speech which dealt with the economic advancement of the country under McKinley’s Administration reach- ed its climax in the following passage, relating to the extraordinary increase in the balance of trade—the excess of our merchandise exports over our mer- chandise imports: But, coming to the development cof our trade in the four McKinley years, we seem to be entering the realm of fable. In the last fiscal year our excess of exports over imports was $644,592,826. In the last four years it was $2,354,442,213. These figures are so stupendous that they mean little to a careless reader—but consider! The ex- cess of exports over imports for the whole preceding period from 1790 to 1897—from Washington to McKinley—was only $356,- 808,822. The most extravagant promises made by the sanguine McKinley advocates five years ago are left out of sight by these sober facts. The “debtor nation” has become the chief creditor nation. The financial centre of the world, which required thou- sands of years to journey from the Eu- phrates to the Thames and the Seine, seems passing to the Hudson, between daybreak and dark. Coming from a man of Mr. Hay’s broad culture and fine intellect, and upon so high an occasion, this bears singular testimony to the dominion exercised over men’s habitual thought by the old notion that to se'l more to foreigners than you buy from them is the great desideratum, the potent cause of pros- perity, the sure sign of commercial and financial dominion. To those who acclaimed in this way the balance-of-trade figures of the Mc- Kinley years—figures which, indeed, were highly remarkable end noteworthy —the showing of the fiscal year now drawing to a close ought to be extreme- lly depressing. The excess of our ex- ports above our imports during the elev- eu months ending with May is only | $179,000,000, and the final figure for the fiscal year will not exceed $200,000,000. To find as small a “favorable” balance as this in the past, we have to go back |fourteen years. In the fiscal year end- ‘ing June 30, 1897, the excess of exports was $286,000,000, and it has been above /$400,900,000 in every fiscal year since 'that time, with the single exception of ‘the year ending June 30, 1909. For leach of the four full fiscal years of Mc- |Kinley’s Presidency, the balance was |well above $500,000,000; the average _|annual balance for those years was nearly $600,000,000. On the other hand, for the four years 1907-10, the average will be but a trifle above $400,000,000, a falling off of thirty per cent. as com- pared with the four McKinley years, in spite of the vastly increased scale of business and the world-wide rise of prices. In 1909, we came down to $351,- 000,000; and this year, as already stated, we shal] have to record the melancholy figure of a paltry $200,000,000. In |twe of Cleveland’s years we did better jthan that—$237,000,000 and $286,000,000 in the years ending June 30, 1894, and June 30, 1897, respectively. But the worst remains to be told; for these results are only what we get on the face of the figures, and a mere glance at what is behind them suffices to show that the precious balance has suf- fered much more than appears on the surface. Even the most devoted believ- er in the saving grace of a “favorable” balance of trade does not hold that its | blessings arise from the mere existence of the figures in a statistical report; the beneficent fact to him is that we have actually sold to foreigners so much ‘more than we have bought from them. Well, we all know that to get at this surplus we have to make heavy deduc- tions from the figures of excess of ex ports above imports. The two most im- portant deductions are the amounts we pay out for transportation by foreign carriers, and the amounts expended by American travellers abroad. Neither of these big items enters into the govern- ment tables giving excess of merchan- dise exports over merchandise imports. It has long been customary to reckon these two items together at more than $200,000,000. But whatever they were in the past, it '‘s evident that both of them are greatly increased now. The habit of European travel] has been grow- ling rapidly and steadily, year by year; the amount spent by Americans abroad has been increasing by leaps and bounds. And as for freight charges, since the total volume of our foreign trade has increased enormously, it is certain that we have had to pay decided)y more to foreign carriers than in former years. It is highly probable that, if these two items of expenditure were duly taken into account, and allowance also made for undervaluations, our balance of trade this year would be found a pret- ty heavy “adverse” one, instead of being a “favorable” balance of $200,- 000,000; and in any case, so far as a comparison with the McKinley years is concerned, the falling off in the balance is much greater than that shown by the statistical figures, heavy as this is. Now, from the point of view of the financial expert the ups and downs of the merchandise balance are sometimes highly important elements in the cast- ing of the business horoscope; but they are but one factor in a complex whole, and their significance, such as it is,. varies with varying circumstances. A sudden increase in the “favorable” bal- ance, for instance, may mean that we are buying back our own securities, or that we are making investments abroad; but that does not necessarily mean that we are doing better, or saving more, than we should be if we utilized all our capital in enterprises at home and even invited fresh foreign capital for invest- ment. Again, if we kept on having enormous “favorable” balances, and made vast investments abroad, a time would come at last when the annual re- turns on those investments would be so great as to do more than balance the new investments made each year, and thus, while still increasing our holdings abroad, we should be having, year after year, large “adverse” balances; this has long been the condition of England. In fact, a nation’s economic status can no more be inferred from the mere figures of its balance of trade than the condl- tion of a corporation can be told by merely ascertaining the amount of its receipts end its expenditures, without inquiring how much of those expendi- tures were for running expenses, and how much for permanent betterments. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. About the Farm. Boston: J. R. Whipple Co., Young's Hotel. A. H. W. (Canada). He Restoreth My Soul. Putnam. $1.50 net. Albee, H. R. Hardy Plants for Cottage Gardens, Holt. $1.60 net. Apear, D. A. Betrayed Armenia. Yoko- hama: Japan Gazette Press. Aristophanes’ Knights. Greek text revised translated, ete., by B. B. Rogers. Mac- millan. $3.50 net. Beard, C. A. American Government and Politics. Macmillan. $2.10 net. Beers, H. A. The Ways of Yale in the Consulship of Plancus Enlarged ed, Holt. $1.20 net Bjérklund, G. J. Death and Resurrection Trans. by J. E. Fries. Chicago: Open Court Pub. Co

Page 26

662 The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2348

Irish Castles to Small, May- From Boston: Carson, N, B. French Chateaux nard., Corbett, J. 8. Lougmans. Crary, L. E. Phila.: Blakiston, Dawbarn, C. Y. C, Longmans. Dole, C. F. The Coming Religion. Boston: Small, Maynard. Earle, J. The Deeds of Beowulf. Done into modern prose by John Earle. Frowde, Eliot, C. W. The Future of Trades Union- ism and Capitalism in a Democracy. Put- nam. $1 net. Ellis, J. B. The Soul of a Serf. Laird & Lee, $1. Ferrero, F. The Valley of Aosta. Putnam. $2 net. Garesché, M. R. Educational Co, Garner, J. W. Introduction to Political Science. American Book Co. Gospe!, According to Saint Luke. With in- troduction and notes by A. 8. Walpole. Frowde. 40 cents. Grillparzer’s Kénig Ottokars Glick und Ende. Edited, with notes, by C, E. Eg- gert. Holt. 60 cents. Gulick, 8. L. and BE, Kingdom of God. Pilgrim Press 50 cents net. Hazen, C. D. Europe Since 1815. Holt. $3. Heredia, J.-M. de, Les Trophés,. Trans. by H. Johnson. Brunswick, Me.: F. W. Chandler & Son Hinchman, A. Poems. side Press, Hudson, H. B. Dictionary and Vicinity. Minneapolis: Pub. Co. 25 cents. Hulst, C. 8 St. George Legend and History. $3. The Campaign of Trafalgar. A Text-Book of Field Zodlogy. $1.25 net. The Social Contract. Chicago: Art of the Ages. Prang L. Growth of the Boston: Cambridge: River- of Minneapolis Hudson of Cappadocia in London: D. Nutt. NOTABLE RECENT BOOKS Published at 34 W. 83d St., by HENRY HOLTS& CO. A novel of to-day, $1.50 The Cave Woman. by VIOLA BURHANS At the Sign of the Bergtns Bush. A novel, by M. LITTLE $1.50. It Never Can Basqen Praered Dt MORGAN New Morgan leaflet on saptie ation, The Unknown Quantity. By rRUDE HALL. A novel. $1.50. In and Oat of Florence. By VERNON With 148 Illustrations. Boxed, $2.50 net.* The VPoetie Ol1d-World. Compiled by LUCY H. HUMPUREY Selected poems for travellers Pocket 16mo. $1.50 net.* Recollections of a Varied Life. By GEORGE ARY EGGLESTON $2.75 net.* The oat of the Theatre. By CLAY TON HAMILTON $1.50 net.* Eurepe Since 1815. Ry HAZEN With 14 colored maps. The Ways of Yale. By Further enlarged Ea $1.20 net. LEADING AMERICANS Pdited by W. P. TRENT Bach $1.75 net.* Novellata. By JOHN ERSKINE Piasayliatse. By WM. MORTON PAYNE. Soldiers. By Rh. M. JOUNSTON, NATURE BOOKS New Leaflet on Application. Hardy Piants for Cottage Gardena, by HELEN RR. ALBER With 60 Ils. American Nature Series. $1.60 net.* Our Search for a Wilderness. By MR. and MRS. ©. WM. BEEBE. Trips in Vene- roela and DPiritieh Golana. With numerous ilinetrations $2.75 net.* The Prince and His Anta. By “VAMBA.” Translated by SARAH F. WOODRUFF, with Introduetion by VERNON L. KELLOGG. and many tlluetrations, 16 in color, A ‘Nature’ fairy tale $1.35 net.* The Care of Trees tn Lawn, Street, and Park. By B. BE. FERNOW. Pro fusely Ulustrated American Nature Series. | $2.00 net.* Shell-Fish Indastries, KELLOGG Illustrated. Series. $1.76 net.® By WM. 32-page De GER.- MAX Svo. CHAS. D $3.00 net. A. BEERS. By JAMES L. American Nature : + « * * + © « * # « @ « + « <€ i J : : ¢« * 3 + « + « + + « ¢ + * + « @ * * « . * : : + + & *Postage 8% additional What to Do at Recess. & Co. The Gait of the W. R. Jenkins Johnson, G. B. Boston: Ginn Jordan, R., jr. Trotter and Pacer. $3.50 net. Lehman, E. Mysticism in Heathendom and Christendom. Trans. by G. M. G.| Hunt, London: Luzac. MacLean, A. M. Wage-Earning Macmillan. $1.25 net. Macphail, McCutcheon, J. T. Chicago: McClurg. |Mackenzie, W. M. Pompeii. A. Pisa. Macmillan. $2.50 net. Margetson, G. R. Songs of Life. Sherman, French. $1 net. Meredith Memorial Edition. Vols. and XIV. The Egoist. Scribner. vol. Sold by subscription. Miles, A. H. Original Poems, Tales in Verse. London: Mitchell, J. A. Dr. Thorne’s Idea. Co. $1 net. Mole, M. Vera of the Strong Heart. nam. $1.25 net. Myers, G. History of the Great American Fortunes. Vol. III. Chicago: Kerr & Co. Myers, G. W., and others. Second Year American Co. Women. ze. Ballads, and Doran | | | | ’ A. Essays in Fallacy. Longmans. | in Cartoons. | Painted by | | Silber, M. Boston: | XI $2 per | Students and the Present Missionary Crisis. | Stanley Paul. | Practical Real Estate Methods. Doubleday, Page. $2 net. Public Service Commission ere. Sec- ond District of New York. Vol. lL. July 1, 1907, to April 1, 1909. Albany. Reynolds, Mrs. B. Out of the Night. Doran Co. $1.20 net. | Scholl, J. W. Hesper-Phosphor, and Other Poems. Ann Arbor, Mich.: G, Wahr. Seager, H. R. Social Insurance; a Pro- gram of Social Reform. Macmillan. $1 net. Seibert, V. The Gossamer Thread. Boston: Small, Ma Jewish yeh St. Louis: Modern View Pub. Skues, G. E. M. wince Tactics of the Chalk Stream. Macmillan. Rochester Convention, 1910. Student Volunteer Movement for Foreign Mis- sions. $1.50. | Studies in English and Comparative Liter- Put- | By former and present students Boston: Ginn. ature. at Radcliffe College. | Stutfield, H, BE. M. The Sovranty of So- Mathematics, University of Chicago Press. | $1.50 net. National Lumber Manufacturers’ Associa- | tion, tion, he!d in New Orleans, April 19. Chi- cago. 60 cents. Nichols, A. B. Holt. 40 cents. Odum, H. W. Social and Mental Traits of the Negro. Columbia University. Oman, C. Peninsular War. Frowde. Pater, W. The Renaisance: Studies in Art and Poetry. Macmillan. $2 net. Ponting, H. G. In Lotus-Land Macmillan. $6 net. Report of Eighth Annual Conven- | An Easy German Reader. | Ww. C. Column and Line in the | ciety. London: Fisher Unwin. ‘Thayer, J. A. Astir, a Publishers’ Life- Story. Boston: Small, Maynard. $1.20 net. Twain. Mark Twain’s Speeches. Intro. by W. D. Howells. Harper. $2 net. Willcocks, W. P. The Way Up. Lane Co. $1.50. Williams, J. H. The Mountain That Was “God”: Being a Little Book About the Great Peak Named “Rainier.” Tacoma: J. H. Williams. $1 net. Winternitz, M. General. Index to the names and subject-matter of the Sacred Books of the East. Frowde. $5.75. | Wright, C. W. Wool-Growing and the Tariff. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin. $2 net. Japan. | Xenophontis Opera Omnia. Tomus iv, In- Frowde. stitutio Cyri.

FOR THE SUMMER LIBRARY GWENDA, By Mabel Barnes-Grundy, author of ‘“‘Dimbie and 1,” “Hilary on Her Own,”’ “Hazel of Heatherland.”” An inti- mate, Intense storv, relleved by humor and a dash of worldly wisdom. i12mo. 350 pages. Frontispiece. $1.50. THE TOP OF THE MORNING. By Juliet Wilbor Tompkins, author of ‘Dr. Ellen” and “Open House.” A sparkling, wholesome story, full of humor, vivacity and charm. 12mo. Frontispiece in color. $1.50. IN PRAISE OF GARDENS. Compiled by Temple Scott. Poems and verses about gardens from the whole range of English poetry. Charming in contents and itn form. $1.25. THE GARDEN IN THE WILDER- NESS. By “A Hermit.” A felicitous mingling of gardening and sentiment. Many illustrations, decorative end papers, ete. $1.50 net. WOMEN AS LETTER WRITERS. Edited by Ada M. Ingpen. The best letters written by women from the 16th century until our own time. 12mo. 9 full-page portraits. $1.25 net. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., NEW YORK | BEST Cacilities for supplying American engiish DOOKS French Catalogues free. Oorrespondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 years, 30-32 West 27th ay New York BOOKS—All out of print books matter on what subject; wae ss stati ted; I you 4

German Italian Spanish

books | when in England, call tir ‘of books. BAKER'S GREAT ‘r BOOKSHOP, Jobn Bright St., Birmingham, EB The Best Books A Reader's Guide to the Choice of the Best Available Books (About 100,000). By William Swan Sonnenschein Third Edition Entirely Rewritten To Be in Three Parts. Part I. 83.50 net. Ready. “It would be difficult to exaggerate the usefulness of this work or to praise too highly the industry of the compiler. Turn to what subject we may, we find the best current books which the reader may consult, and their prices.”—London Spectator. G, P. PUTNAM’S SONS, S*Yoxson

THE FOOD FACTOR

IN DISEASE Being an Investigation into the Humoral Causa- tion, Meaning, Mechanism, and Rational Treatment, Preventive and Curative, of the Neu- roses (Migrane, Asthma, Angina Pectoris, sy, ete.), Billous Attacks, Gout, Catarrhal and other Affections, High Blood-Pressure, Circula- tory, Renal, and other Degenerations. By FRAN- CIS HARE, M.D., late Consulting clan to the Brisbane General Hospital, Visiting Physician. at the Diamantina Hospital for Chronic Diseases, Brisbane; Inspector-General of Hospitals for Queensland, 2 vols. Medium 8vo. Pp. I—Sib pages, I11—644 pages. Net. $10.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York Six Months Subscription Free, THE NATION will extend SIX MONTHS the term of any subscriber who sends a name not already on our list with remit- tance for the new subscription for one year.

Page 27