The Nation 1910-06-23: Vol 90 Iss 2347
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
a te a ae eee GENERAL LIBRARY) UNIV. OF MICH, Peo ‘4 JUN 24 1910 Neuingl he, Ae VOL. XC.—NO. 2347. THURSDAY, JUNE 23, 1910. PRICE TEN CENTS. letters and Memorials ||| Library Orders We have conducted a special department for many years that has been exceptionally successful in hand- Wendell Phillips Garrison ling book orders from Editor of The Nation 1865-1906 PUBLIC LIBRARIES —— SCHOOLS, COLLEGES | In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 ano UNIVERSITIES pages, with photogravure portrait. ' Our Monthly Bulletin of New Books, with annota- ioe io tions and brief descriptions of each title recorded, is During the forty-one years in one of the most helpful aids in book selection. which he edited the Nation, with Library Department a thoroughness, ability, and con- ‘oim wvomw unre TALC, MCCLURG & CO. the records of American journal- CHICAGO ism, Mr. Garrison was an indefat- igable correspondent, never em- : ploying an amanuensis, but writing || INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS Send for catalogue. TAUCHNITZ ] tens of thousands of letters with || WHY WORRY? and THOSE NERVES! FOREIGN SCHOENHOF BOOK CO. BRITISH 8 his own hand to his contributors, By GEORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth.61 net. each. Seen man” |6e who embraced practically all the | leading American scholars and critics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a e ° . | sufficient number of selections has High Grade Law Printing been made to illustrate the rela- Ea _tions between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exer- . ° al SaeRiihs ‘Wisi. eink ‘tos Welle Briefs, Corporation and all other Legal range of his interests, tastes, and documents printed accurately and with sympathies. The volume also con- . t ° b | w those of most | tains a brief sketch of his life, a dispatch = prices eee | dozen of his best poems, and sever- other ofices—for particulars apply to al of his characteristic editorials, reviews, and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. Price, $1.50 net, postpaid The Nation Press Aew Dork Cvening Post Co., Prop. Houghton Mifflin Company || 20 Vesey Street New York City BOSTON NEW YORK -_—_—_oeoeooe
Page 2
The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2347 *-e Tl 1e Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post Office as second-clase mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Poatal Union 84.00 iddreas THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. TUE WE iccccccvcccccccscticsccceseeees 617 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Railway Regulation .......cceeeseeees §20 TO WOW BOBS sccococeeseccedonesess 620 American Peace Diplomacy ........... $21 Swelling Public Expenses 622 Going Fishing vs. Angling .......... 623 Business and Pleasure 323 SPECIAL ARTICLES: Historical Licerature in Australasia. 621 CORRESPONDENCE: The Source of Poe's “Some Words with a Mummy” - 626 Misrepresentations of Spain. cecccoeces §26 The Earth of ee It In- dian? eccecseceecseuce Debating at Se hool The Tariff and Wages ........scccseees A Rare Pamphlet eee 627 Gen. Grant's Fether 527 LITERATURE: Gathorne Hardy, First Earl of Cran- brook : ee 628 Bamswes the BOCMOP cccccccccscccecces 629 The Taming of Red Butte Western... €.0 Maurin the Illustrious ..........es66. ®0 The GasGem BC BD ccocovccvecceevcesoces Gee Leading American Novelists ........ 630 Leading American Essayists ........... 630 Ezra Studies senbaes . 631 BOS TITRE ccvcccoccoesseeccecesece 632 Confessiong of a Barbarian sescesanet 633 A History of Medimwval Political The- ory in the Weat 33 CC eer eee ee 534 SCIENCE: Rara Arithmetica 636 DRAMA AND Music . 637 AnT \ Catalogue Ralsonné of the Works of the Most Eminent Dutch, Flem- ieh, and French Painters, etc . “38 FINANCE The Autumn Money Market . 6 Books or THE WEEK . 640 *** Copies of The Nation may be procured tn 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in 4 Trafalgar Parise at Brentano's London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Square, Charing Cross. Educational. 7 “WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. | Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2 A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Se 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., tInneapo 203 Mich. Ave.,Chicago 611 Swetiand Bid., Partiand 405 Cooper Bid., Denver 238 DougiasBld, .LosAngeles 819 Hyde Bid.. Spokane 2142shattuckAve. , Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. HE PRINCIP. 4L OF A COED. prep. school, perfectly accustomed to en- trance work for all colleges, and to college teach- ing in classics, would take charge of a coaching or reading party for the entire summer. sake George or Eastern seacoast preferred. Is free from mid-June to mid-September. Address W. C. L., 29 Quincy Ave., Scranton, Pa. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with com t teachers. Assists teachers in obtaining tions. Send for Bulletin No. 20. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St.,Albany, N.Y THE APOLLO SONG BOOK FOR MALE VOICES By FREDERICK E, CHAPMAN, Direc- tor of Music for the Cambridge Public Schools, and CHARLES E. WHITING, formerly Teacher of Mu- sic in the Boston Pub:ic Schools. An attractive and beneficial collec- tion of songs prepared especially for boys, and intended for use in prepara- tory schools, colleges, and glee clubs. STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Balzac, Bronté, Browning, Bulwer, Car- | Lyle, Cooper, Dickens, Dumas, De Foe, Eliot, Gibbon, Guizot, Hawthorne, Hugo, Irving, Macaulay, Plutarch, Poe, Prescott, Ruskin, Scott, Shakespeare, Thackeray, Tolstoi. Send for Descriptive Booklet. THOMAS Y, CROWELL & CO., New York A new book on Games PLAY: Sthoo koom ann couitcr By Emmett Dunn Angell. The most the pra describing over 100 carefully graded games, many entirely original. With over 50 illustrations. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.63 LITTLE, BROWN & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON The only biography of the founder of modern Socialism, KARL MARX: HIS LIFE AND WORK, by John Spargo, $2.50 net; $2.70 carriage paid. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth avenue, NEW YORK Read L. M. Montgomery's New Book KILMENY OF THE ORCHARD By the author of “ANNE of GREEN GAMES” (21st Printing) a “ANNE OF AVONLEA” (10th Printing) GINN AND COMPANY Boston NewYork Chicago London How We Think By DR. JOHN DEWEY, Columbia University Cloth. 230 pages. $1.00 A practical application of modern psychol- 5 ogy to the problems of education, by a lead- er of thought in both flelds. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO LONDON THE TEMPLE CLASSICS 2233 VOLUMES Guwerat Epiron: Isramt Gottancs, M.A. Each volume contains a a Spentenseee. a decorative title-page, and ribbon bookmark; where advisable, editorial appendices and marginalia, also. PRICES: In cloth, each volume 45 cts. Net In limp leather each volume 65 cts. Net EK. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORK. PASSION PLAY, OBERAMMERGAU. American lady personally accompanies select party of ten; best tickets; days’ board at house’ of Anton Lang; (reserved seat); Ist class oo turn from Munich; text-book; all tips; clusi ve. Passion Play and driving tour to Royal Castles in Bavarian So best accommodation; alto- gether 4 days Reference : howe wv. a MG ~ 2 Rector of Epis- copal Church ¢, wp! New York City. Ad-. dress MRS. I iE SOURDAN, Leopoldstr. 9 Itt, Munich.” The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nineeminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 cents net; by mail, 54 cents. Bend for a descriptive pamphlet. & 1 Beacon SL, Boston BOOKS—All out of print books supplied, matter on what subject; write me, stati wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call and inapect my stock 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S ¥ - AT BOOKSHOP, John Bright St., Birmingham, and. AMERICANS: An Impression | By Alexander Francis. De yeu knowthe Beacon Biographies? no books | WILLIAM J. TUCKER’S PERSONAL POWER ‘Vigorous and wholesome talks to college men."’—Kaneas City Star. “A stimulating volume.’""—Saen Francisco Chronicle. STENOGRAPHER GEO. B. COCK FRANKLIN BANK BUILDING, PHILADELPHIA School Advertising THE NATION The ation, in its special field of ‘political and literary criticism, is un- like any other periodical, American or foreign. It is taken by read- ing clubs and literary associations in a large number of places, and may be found on file in every library of ‘importance in the country. There are probably few weekly periodicals whose columns offer so favorable an opportunity for reaching an audience ‘interested in educational matters. 10 cents a line for 13 times, The Nation 20 Vesey St., New York City
Page 3
7 The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JUNB 23, 1910. The Week. Mr. Roosevelt could not have made a better beginning in the renewal of his American life than by the wireless mes- sage he sent as he neared shore. He will place an interval of more than two months between his landing and his first public speech; and he “will have no- thing whatever to say in the immediate | future about politics, and will hold no interview whatever on the subject with any one.” During his absence in far- away lands, home affairs have gone through many phases. Some of the de- velopments, political and personal, have been of a sort to engender bitter con- troversy, some to provoke differences of opinion on complicated questions of fact or of policy. The tariff, and “Cannonism,” and Ballinger, and railway control have suc- cessively had the centre of the stage; and Mr. Taft’s personal part in these affairs has been a special thread run- ning through the whole story. Of all this, Mr. Roosevelt has of course ac- quired, by this time, very considerable knowledge; but nothing can take the place of actual contact with the situation on the spot, and he is wise in waiting awhile before he puts his influence into the scale on the one side or the other of any of these disputes. Apart from this declaration, too, Mr. Roosevelt’s mes- sage was all that could be desired in point of simplicity and good taste. and conservation, The new rule adopted in the House of Representatives, with but one dissent- ing vote, involves momentous possibil- ities. It may alter the entire business of law-making by committee, a system which has been bitterly criticised as anti-democratic and inimical to honest legislation, and defended as an absolute- ly necessary development of parliamen- tary government, and which, whether we approve it or not, is a very solid fact that calls for recognition. The new rule provides that upon petition by a member of the House that body may, by a majority vote, discharge a committee from the consideration of any bill it has | tor action in the House itself. The great argument in favor of the new rule is that it will prevent the killing of bills in committee, a procedure with which the bulk of legislative graft is intimate- ly bound up. And there may be suffi- |cient additional reasons to overcome the lobvious argument that the process of |committee-taming, if carried to excess, would swamp the House with business. In passing the bill authorizing the President to withdraw from entry any public lands of the United States which he thinks should not be open to sale or settlement until Congress has decided ‘how they are to be disposed of, Congress ‘has done a good day’s work. This Executive power, under previous legisla- tion, has been in dispute. Roosevelt and Garfield believed that it existed; Taft and the Attorney-General did not. In his letter to ex-Secretary Garfield of last November, President Taft consented for the time to allow many of the with- drawals to stand, though he feared that “a considerable stretch of the Secre- tary’s power” was involved. It was of the highest importance that such doubts should be set at rest. This could be only by an act of Congress expressly granting the needed authority. In ob- taining it, the President has not only procured one more item in his legisla- of much greater consequence—has taken tive programme, but—and this is a long step forward in fortifying and making impregnable the whole policy of conservation. The full text of Senator Dolliver’s tar- iff speech appears in the Congressional Record of June 15, and we advise all 'to read it who like a demonstration of ‘the fallacies which lurk in lump sums and general percentages. It was in it- ‘self a specious argument for Mr. Payne jand Republicans who cited his figures ‘to base the claim of large tariff reduc- tions upon “consumption values”; but jeven accepting that basis, Senator Dol- ‘liver has shown how misleading is the inference drawn when lower taxes on | bituminous coal which we import in but | small quantities, and on agricultural products which we do not import at all, in hand, and that the measure shall are reckoned as actual remissions of then be placed upon a special calendar | money paid by the consumer. In his) elaborate analysis of the cotton sched- ule, of which in the special session last year the Iowa Senator showed that he had made himself a master, he is partic- ularly damaging to Senator Aldrich and the tricksters who worked through him. Judge Grosscup sees no stopping place in the movement to deal with the mo- nopoly problem short of accepting the great industrial concerns as monopolies de jure, as they are de facto, and regu- lating their profits and their prices. “Some think,” he said in his address at Philadelphia the other day, “the great corporations of the country can be made by law to compete. To compete with whom—when that particular tion already has a monopoly of the field?” That may be the conclusion to which we shall all be driven at some time in the future, but there will be a good stout fight for the principle of com- petition before it is abandoned. Strong as is the grip of the monopolistic cor- porations, most of them have to keep within pretty definite bounds to ward off competition; and who can say what future developments in the way of me- chanical changes, and in the changes in patent and other laws, may effect? corpora- way of At a time when chances for Demo- cratic success would appear to be bet- ter than usual in most parts of the Union, the situation in Tennessee pre- sents many disquieting Pri- marily the difficulties are not political at all. Hostility to the renomination of Gov. Patterson has resulted, it was manifest that it would, in a split in the Democratic party and the likeli- hood that two State tickets both bearing the Democratic stamp will be in the field this autumn. Opposition to Patterson is based on his action in the pardoning of the Coopers, father and son—the con- victed slayers of Senator Carmack—and in his pro-saloon attitude. The Carmack faction is active and bitter, and with an alliance with the “State-widers” the re- sult of the election would certainly be in doubt. But Patterson is apparently counting on Republican support to offset this defection. He has always been con- siderate of the negroes, and no Demo- cratic Governor since the war has had aspects. as
Page 4
618 so strong a following among them. On this fact and the feeling among negroes that they have not been rightly treated by President Taft, he is doubtless count- ing to carry him again into office. The city of Tacoma, dreaming dreams of empire on the shores of Puget Sound, built itself a high-school stadium which is said to be capable of holding than Harvard's great am- has more people This magnificent monumeat to pride and her ambitions was dedicated last week with appropri- which drew “24,000 within the spacious the aud phitheatre. Tacoma's ate ceremonies cheering Tacomans” Properly enough, concrete arena. school children, whose nickels went to the making of the stad- the Four thousand of them were dimes ium, played principal part in the festival grouped in a great American flag. Seven of went through pic- drill and dances. The flags in hand, playing of the “Star- thousand them turesque climax when the children, to the came kept time Spangled Banner.” Thereupon, says the racoma Daily News, “with one accord the entire audience rose to its feet, cheered the mass of waving flags, and joined in singing the national air. Men doffed their hats and all were thrilled with a new feeling of patriotism. Ta- coma will probably never in her history witness such a patriotic sight as that of esterday afternoon when the living flag was presented.” Having thus dedicated her unsurpassed stadium, Tacoma forth- vith telegraphed an offer of $101,000 for “pulling off” the Jeffries- johnson fight on that splendid field. the privilege of Iwo and twenty Mayors are taking part in the two-days’ discussion of mu- nicipal health problems at the confer- ence which is meeting at Schenectady. There will be specialists there to in- struct them in the various phases of a question that is as important as any that confronts the chief executive of a rest and rec- the city Housing and health, reation, the city and life-waste, city and tuberculosis, and city among the problems that organization, city sanitation, food-supply are are to be taken up for consideration. Why, asked, should Mayors it may be spend time and the public money In listening to information that is access- ible printed form? The an- is that personal contact among 4a enough in awer , health-department | ,self of race prejudice. _The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2347 group of men debi the same work is a| man species that may eventually devel- way of stirring the enthusiasm that be- | gins to flag under the strain of daily routine. The Mayor has hundreds of printed volumes to read if he so desires; but has he either the time or the in- clination? From a two-days’ threshing out of problems, theories, and remedies, the Mayor may bring back a vivid real- ization of duty and need that no amount of printed pages can supply. The con- ference of Mayors may supply just the right spectacular spice which is fre- quently so necessary to the whole-heart- ed attack of a problem. Any one who in a telephone booth has been disturbed by loud talking out- side, or some other noise to interrupt the electric conversation, will be inter- ested in an article in a German period- ical, Der Gesundheitsingenieur. The writer tells how he dealt with this dif- ficulty. He had been making some acoustic experiments which convinced him that if a wooden telephone booth were lined with tin, all noises would be excluded. He nailed sheets of tin on the wooden walls with the result that an expert, who had laughed at his was so impressed that he forth- with proceeded to construct a number of such booths. ers the only ones who may profit by this The referred to appeals to architects to introduce tin, the walls of houses generally, to deaden sounds. He is con- vinced that if this were done, the neighbor's daughter’s piano and voice idea, Nor are telephone us- experiment. writer or aluminium, in would cease to be a disturbing factor in life, except, of course, in summer, when all the windows are open. The tin-man- ufacturers may be trusted to see to it/| that this plan is properly pushed and | amiss if the United States, returning good for evil, were to offer its services advertised. Missionary literature, in general, has been slow to admit any dark side to the American occupation of the Philip-| ithe task. The mere offer on our part pines. In a recent number of Missions, however, the official Baptist missionary | organ, certain unpleasant phases of the | 800d in depriving Estrada of all excuse situation are set forth with candor and vigor. A missionary writing from Jaro finds the chief difficulty to le in the ut- ter inability of the American to rid him- “The American in the Orient has the air of being the sole representative of the human race, and the Oriental] is classed as a sub-hu- op, through long periods of progressive development, into the genus homo.” It is a pathetically rare thing, he says, to find any American resident among the Filipinos who is not continually berat- ing, in both public and private, the en- tire Filipino race. The natives had at one time given themseives over to a whole-hearted acceptance of American intervention, and set themselves en- thusiastically to the task of acquiring American methods of government, in- dustrial development, and education. But the supercilious air with which their aspirations were met convinced them that “there was only social and moral peonage and serfdom along this way.” The charges of American violation of neutrality made by President Madriz may be impertinent. It may be true, as Secretary Knox declares in his reply “that the policy of the United States re- mains as set forth in the Secretary of State’s letter of December 1, 1909,” wherein this Government announced that it would recognize any Nicaraguan faction which succeeded in organizing a stable government and pacifying the country. It may be true that in prohib- iting the bombardment of Bluefields by a Madriz war-vessel, we only followed the example of the British at Greytown. It may be that we are in the right on ‘every point against President Madriz; but there is something that we may owe to the people of Nicaragua as opposed to its Presidents or would-be Presidents. The war there has resulted in a dead- lock of exhaustion. The economic con- dition of Nicaragua is described as very bad, and as getting rapidly worse. Un- der such circumstances, it would not be for the attainment of peace, or even ‘express the wish that some other agent than ourselves might be entrusted with would in itself do a great amount of for holding out to his deluded followers 'the chance of American intervention in his behalf. Another Mexican revolution has been nipped in the bud. It was planned to come off next Sunday, when that blush- ing young Presidential candidate, Por-
Page 5
June 23, 1910] The Nation. s 619 firio Diaz, is to appeal for the suffrages Political Union—have officially accept- publicanism, the old Catalan solidarity of his fellow-citizens, or know the rea- son why. Mexico's revolutionists must be either criminally foolish or criminal- ly reckless in picking out just the week and the day when Porfirio Diaz is likely to be widest awake and to have most troops at his disposal. One would imag- ine that a revolutionary coup would be best set for the day after election, when the victor is a bit dazed with his tri- umph and the vanquished are sore with defeat. The other hypothesis is that the Mexican revolutionists were neither reckless nor foolish, that no outbreak had been set for election day, and that the entire dreadful plot was the discov- ery of Diaz and his zealous agents. it is, to say the least, unfortunate that the man who holds Mexico in the hollow of his hand should be so badly frightened by his enemies’ plots just a few days be- fore election day. Amid all the rumors of conferences and an agreement, on the Constitution- al issue, between the two parties in England, little has been heard of anoth- which may have conse- quences almost as important. We refer to the non-partisan committee in the House of Commons which has been la- boring to make a beginning of woman suffrage in England. Called a Concilia- tion Committee, and composed of 16 Liberals, 11 Conservatives, 5 Irish Na- tionalists, and 4 members of the Labor party, it has worked out a bill which, it is hoped, may prove non-contentious, and may pass at least in the Commons during the present sitting of Parlia- ment. The proposed measure is consid- erably short of complete enfranchise- ment for woman, yet would, if adopted, put the names of many female voters on the register. In brief, two classes of women would be made voters: house- holders and the owners of a £10 oc- cupation qualification—that is, occupiers of lands, offices, or shops of that rent- ing value. Not many married women would be admitted to the franchise un- der this plan, since they could not qual- ify for the same property as their hus- bands; but, on the other hand, they would not be disqualified. To this mod- erate proposal all sections of the com- mittee have agreed; and both the great suffrage societies—the National Union and the National Women’s Social and er movement ed it as a payment on account. The system of proportional represen- tation has had its most extensive trying- out in the recent general elections in Belgium. It has operated acceptably well, but without removing all the anom- alies of the ordinary system. The anti- Catholic parties in the Chamber have registered a popular vote of 1,125,000, against 1,063,000 for the Catholics; yet the latter hold a majority of six in the Chamber. At Malines, 24,818 votes gain- ed a single seat, while 41,632 votes gain- ed three seats. At Nivelle, it took only 15,419 votes to elect a Liberal but 24,- 818 votes to elect a Clerical. At Arlon, 20,521 Liberal votes gained a single seat, and 25,294 Catholic votes won two. The failure of the proportional-representa- tion machine to function perfectly is due, in Belgium, partly to the exist- ence of the plural vote which counter- balances the effect of the proportional distribution. But partly the cause is to be found in the mathematics of the par- ticular system used in that country. There is no denying, however, that R. P., as the French-speaking people call it, is effective against gross misrepresenta- tion. In Belgium, where the Catholics in 1900 had a Parliamentary majority of 29, the rectifying influence of propor- tional representation has cut down their swollen majority to 26, to 20, to 12, and to 6, successively. The open advocacy by the Prime Min- ister of entire religious liberty in Spain, and the firmness with which he is pro- ceeding from step to step in order to procure it, are only parts of the large and comprehensive policy which Sefior Canalejas is pursuing. This he explain- ed in person and with great directness to the Madrid correspondent of the Frankfurter Zeitung. said, was the restoration and quicken- ing of the Liberal tradition, On the one side, this would lead to a vigorous op- position to overweening Clerical preten- sions, while on the other it would work jagainst the extremes of the Socialists and Republicans. As regards the latter point, Prime Minister Canalejas may 'point with satisfaction to some of the results of the recent general election. His great aim, he Although Republican successes were un- | expectedly won here and there, in Cata- ilonia, so long the seed-bed of Spanish Re- 'was rudely shattered. Whereas in the ‘previous Cortes there were eighteen Re publican Deputies, working hand ‘hand with fourteen “regionalists,” in the new there will be only ten Republi- cans and seven regionalists, the Liber- in als having made great gains and car- ried thirteen seats. One remark of Ca nalejas in the interview is striking. He said of the King: “Alfonso XIII is thoroughly Liberal a and a I laid before him my entire programme, convinced monarch with modern ideas. have without any concealment of the difficul- ties in the way of its realization, yet he has given me his full confidence and co operation.” like has just had a Parliamentary election. Hungary, France and Belgium The results are toore significant than in The Independent or Kossuthite party, which either of the other two countries. for a half-dozen years has been suffi- ciently in the ascendant to make gov- ernment by any other party impossible while not governing very well itself, has And its defeat has come not at the hands of any other but of the Crown itself. been decisively beaten. great party, The Liberal party, after holding power for many years, was overwhelmingly de- feated in January, 1905, by a combina tion headed by Francis Kossuth and Count Albert Apponyi. Confusion fol lowed, and it was not until April, 1906, that a compromise or “functionary’”’ Cabinet was organized, with Wekerle at its head and Kossuth and Apponyi in important Ministerial The question of universal suffrage and a sep- arate state bank for Hungary brought in 1909 the Coalition The only remedy was positions. dissension, and split wide open. the usual one in the Hapsburg domains —the appointment of an interim Minis try of officials to carry on the necessary business of government. Count Khuen- Hédervary was chosen Premier, and he made preparations for the recent gener- al election in which the country gave him a rousing majority, thus indicating its weariness of party strife and tur- moil. Inasmuch as the Independent or Coalition party was bent upon greatly loosening the ties with Austria, its de- feat has been hailed by the Premier as 'a return to the principles of the dual ar- rangement of 1867, “which form the ‘basis of the country’s international pos!- tion.”
Page 6
RAILWAY REGULATION. Most of the comments upon the rail- road bill, as now signed by the Presi- dent, play upon the surface of the mat- ter. They refer to Mr. Taft's pleasure very natural under the circumstances at having persuaded Congress to do what it long appeared probable that it would not do. There is also much said about the due apportionment of credit or blame—for the final form of the law, az between Republicans and Democrats, insurgents and regulars. The political effect of the new statute is likewise much discussed. What part will it play in the coming Congressional elections? Will it prove to be a winning card for the Administration? Such questions are inevitable; and the personal equation is brought in as a matter of course; but none of the things goes to the heart of the business It is apparent at once that the law represents an enormous advance upon When Mr. Roose- velt’s modest proposals, a part of which what has gone before the Hepburn led bates and prolonged strug- were finally embodied in bill, raised such an outcry and to de such flerce gles, few could have supposed that we hould so soon and so quietly be adopt recommenda- lead and writ much more radical Th ili r of current events event would certainly he tions Machiave if were alive to renew and re- inforee his sagacious remark: “Let no one who begins an innovation in a state expect that he shall stop it at his pleas- ure, or regulate it according to his in- fention The ise “intention” of the fram- pret ers of the original Interstate Commerce Act has bee varmly disputed, but there can be no dispute that their handiwork n has now been made over so as to be 1imost beyond their recognition The control of the Interstate Commerce Com- mission over the business of railways has been made both more sweeping and more minute, We say nothing of the reg- ulation of the Issue of securities, for that has been put aside for the time being by But vhat stands we have a great expan- nee to a special commission. in sion of the supervising and regulating power of the Commission. It may, on its own initiative, and without walting for a complaint, of rates or practices that seem unreason- Chief in im- making all take up any case able, and issue its order. is the provision portance The Nation. increases in railway rates ineffective until approved by the Commission, and squarely putting upon the roads the bur- den of proof that the advances are reas- Other clauses onable and warranted. hedge about what the railway mana- gers have hitherto regarded as their liberties; and the whole act constitutes a more drastic scheme of government regulation than would have seemed con- ceivable—to say nothing of being prac- ticable—ten years ago. Even those who argue that this vast extension of the powers of the Interstate Commerce Commission had become nec- that it may be We will not say, with the president of the Baltimore and Ohio Railroad, that tt leads inevitably to the government own- ership of railways, but it cannot be de- nied that, if there is a genuine move- ment for such ownership, it will be greatly by what has now been done. Happily, Americans remain, the English, highly illogical Because one step seems essary, will not deny fraught with grave consequences. accelerated with in their politics. to demand an immediate next step, it does not at all follow that we shall take the latter. We are still fond of partial experiment, and are very much rule-of- public business. The that this new thumb in our chances are, therefore, venture in railway regulation will have a long trial before anything further is attempted; that a modus vivendi will be worked out between the Interstate Com- merce Commission and the railways; and that we are not going to see the property of the great transportation companies either confiscated or nation- alized. It is noteworthy that the railway pres- at all about the new tone, idents who talk measure assume an optimistic Their cheerfulness may be partly forc- ed, but it is certain that any sound rail- conducted has It is to be assumed, to way company honestly little to fear. begin with, that the members of the In- terstate Commerce Commission are up- right and capable men. They have Lo desire to harry the railways. Abuses and illegalities it is their function to repress and punish, but the normal and lawful prosperity of the business they would wish to cherish and cultivate. Moreover, in all the new publicity and compulsion to prove that their rates are reasonable, no substantial right of the) railways is imperilied. They may always’ 2347 take their appeal from unjust decisions to the courts; while all that they ought to ask is the privilege of demonstrating to an impartial tribunal that what they propose is proper and necessary. If, for’ example, it can be shown that the rail- ways, in order to obtain adequate re- turns, must raise their freight rates, there is nothing in the new law to pre- vent its being done. Only, it must be done in an orderly and deliberate and public way. No one supposes that in- exorable financial laws can be set aside by statute. All that President Taft and the other champions of the new law have contended for is a kind of working agreement between commercial neces- sities and the rights of the public. And now that the great experiment is to be entered upon, every one must hope that it will be carried through in a spirit of mutual forbearance and with a de- sire that justice be done to all concerned. THE NEW STATES. Arizona and New Mexico have at last been admitted into the Union as sepa- rate States, and their peoples must now set to work at Constitution-making. The addition of two more stars to the flag has peculiar significance in the pres- ent instance, because they are the last two stars that the present continental territory of the United States, omitting Alaska on the ground of “non-con- tiguity,” can supply. The process of commonwealth-building between the At- lantic and Pacific Oceans is now round- ed out; and with it an historical epoch is completed. From unorganized terri- tory to organized territory, from organ- ized territory to Statehood, the process has pursued its play for one hundred aud twenty-three years, since the poor, decrepit Congress of the Confederation xave the first solid pledge to the future in the Northwest Ordinance. New Mex- ico and Arizona enter the Union very much in the same fashion that Tennes- sce and Ohio came in. This unbroken process is one more striking testimonial lo that stability which has gone hand in hand with democracy in this country. Statehood for Arizona and New Mex- 1c Closes also a secondary epoch in the ‘process of commonwealth-building, a pe- ‘riod in which the process has moved forward more rapidly than it ever did in the history of the country. In the twenty-two years since the election of Benjamin Harrison to the Presidency,
Page 7
June 23, 1910] The Nation. a — = nine States in all, counting Arizona and New Mexico, have been added to the Union. The only two periods that can show anything like the same record were the years 1812-37, when seven States were admitted, and the years) 1840-61, when eight States entered the Union. Of the fourteen States that have been added to the sisterhood in the haif- century since the outbreak of the civil war, four were admitted before 1867; then came a pause of nine years, till Colorado, the centennial State, entered; then comes a longer pause of thirteen years, a gathering of strength and wind for the final effort, and the Dakotas, Montana, Wyoming, Idaho, Washington, Oklahoma, and now the two southwest- ernmost States, are brought within the circle. It is a _ political growth that has resulted from and kept pace with the marvellous economic development of the last twenty years. And in a way the passing of the territorial form of government from the continental Unit- ed States suggests that passing of the limitless land areas and limitless re- sources to which we are just beginning to awaken. The nation has completely | grown up and been brought to face the responsibilities that go with maturity. The child ranges free; the man seeks his resources in himself. We speak to- day of such things as dry-farming and intensive cultivation. What have these new States to con- tribute to the Federal partnership? Ari- zona has 113,000 square miles of terri- square miles. Arizona had in 1900 a population of 123,00C, but a Federal esti- mate for the year 1909 places the pop- ulation at about 155,000. New Mexico has grown a little more slowly and has risen from 195,000 in 1900 to some 227,- 000 in 1909. It may also be in order to mention that a Federal estimate of five years ago places the value of property in New Mexico as $332,000,000, and in Ari- zona at $306,000,000, a per capita wealth which is almost the same as that shown in a prosperous old State like Iowa. The public school has kept pace with material prosperity. Arizona’s popula- tion is one-fifteenth of Iowa’s, and so, very nearly, is her school-attendance. New Mexico's record is still better. Her population is one-tenth of Iowa’s and her school-attendance is one-eighth. Arizona’s fervid objection to Statehood wedlock with New Mexico cannot be jus- ‘tified on the ground that it would be marrying down in the social scale. Of the two, New Mexico, as much the old- er community, is apparently the more advanced in culture. The prejudice be- tween Arizona and New Mexico is part- ly racial and partly political. Politically the admission of the two States will not affect the party strength greatly in either branch of Congress. Arizona sent a Democratic delegate to Congress from 1900 to 1906, and elected a Republican by 700 in 1908, a Presiden- tial year. The Legislature, which had its biennial session last year, stood 27 Democrats to 9 Republicans. New Mex- ico has sent Republican delegates to Congress, though by majority of less than four hundred votes, but the last Legislature showed a Republican major- ity of 20 on joint-ballot. Two Democrat- ic Senators from Arizona and two Re- publican Senators from New Mexico would seem to be the most immediate prospect. The case of Arizona would seem to be the surer one, because in that territory the delays and disap- hands of a Republican Congress have engendered sharp resentment. The sen- timent has been repeatedly expressed that “the Republican Congress is doing | everything in its power to make Art- zona overwhelmingly Democratic.” AMERICAN PEACE DIPLOMACY. Secretary Knox’s address at the Uni- |versity of Pennsylvania on “The Spirit tory and New Mexico has nearly 123,000 and Purpose of American Diplomacy” had a peculiar timeliness. He shows that the whole course of American diplomacy has made for the promotion of peaceful methods of settling interna tional differences, and peaceful means of advancing international welfare; and his words come at a time when attention has been directed to one of the most notable specific developments of these efforts. The permanent arbitration tri- bunal at The Hague has begun the con- sideration of the age-long fisheries dis- pute between this country and Canada; and the fact that two of the leading the world have submitted this extremely complex problem to ju- Powers of dicial determination is justly regarded as an event of the highest significance. The great international jurist who pre- in opening the expressed the is felt, sides over the tribunal, proceedings, profound satisfaction which throughout 621 the world by those who have worked for the promotion of pacific methods, in this signal proof of the progress ac- complished in the few years since the first survey shows how this recent develop- Hague Conference. Mr. Knox's ment, extraordinary as it has been in scope, and in promise for the future, is a consistent sequel of a long history, in which our own country has a right to feel that it has borne the leading part. It is interesting to note the source to which Secretary Knox ascribes the ear- ly addiction of the statesmen and dip- lomatists of the United States to peace- ful settlement of international con- troversies. ‘“Representing,’’ he says “a small and weak belligerent nation, beset with difficulties of discipline, organiza- tion, equipment, men, and finance, and realizing in the fullest measure, as they did, how near they were to losing, be- cause of these deficencies, their own struggle for what, in their opinion, was a just and righteous cause, it is not strange that these men should have , later sought for some method of ad pointments it has experienced at the justing their international difficulties other than by the lawless uncertainties of war.” John Jay’s treaty of 1794, for the settlement of boundary and other disputes with Great Britain, ushered in “the modern era of arbitration,” and to the mother country Mr. Knox assigns high praise for assenting to this ar- rangement when the advantage in an armed conflict seemed so likely to be hers. From that time to this, in a hun- dred ways, our dealings with a great affairs have variety of international 'shown a constant tendency in the same direction. Nor has the example of our country in this direction been limited to the promotion of arbitration; the success of its endeavors in promoting various useful ends in China, Japan, Korea, Turkey, and elsewhere, with no threat of force to back its representa- tions, has been a potent factor in the furtherance of the idea that a nation may effect great international results without resort to warlike measures. A chapter of American diplomacy that has a character apart from all the rest is that which relates to the republics of To the ad- vance of those republics towards their South and Central America. present condition, the United States has contributed chiefly by licitude for the preservation of their in- dependence and for the inviolability of its constant so0- 2S eee atten 0
Page 8
622 their territory. Mr. Knox What the condition is, expressed in his statement that, with some exceptions, they “have achieved government as stable, as en and responsible as our lightened, as own.” It is not very many years since such a statement by an American Sec- of State, would retary if made at all, have been regarded as a mere bit of conventional politeness. We were in the habit of using the generic term South American republic as synonymous with racked by revolution, falling ad- incapable a country prey, in rapid succession, to one venturer after another, and of making steady economic, political, or S¢ cial progress. Now all that is changed; and there could hardly be a more im- pressive lesson as to the folly of im- patient judgment and impulsive action in dealing with the difficulties or im- perfections of backward nations. One landmark in the history of our country’s relations with the outside world is conspicuous by its absence in Mr. Knox's address. It has become so customary, in many quarters, to speak of the war with Spain as marking not a turning-point in our country’s ory, but the beginning of its impor- 3 an influence among the nations, somewhat curious to find no of kind almosi it 18 indication anything of the in this historical survey. One is tempted to think that the United States was not an altogether insignificant fac- tor in the affairs of the world even be- fowe Dewey smashed the Spanish ships in Manila Bay. Perry's opening of Jap an to the world’s commerce, for in- stance, “was justly hailed, both in Eu- rope and America, as a great triumph of peaceful diplomacy”; and—to choose an example that has to do with interna- by bringing about tlonal wars—the action taken our Government in 1595 In the restoration of peace between China though it Of the and Japan is set down as were a respectable achievement. ignal part played by the United States, its earliest days, in in- from almost fluencing international law and custom on the subject of the rights of neutrals in time of war, Mr. Knox does not hap- pen to make mention; but the current of American diplomatic effort appears, from his story, as one that has flowed steadily and strongly, and that has made of Jay's negotiation of the treaty of 1794 itself felt effectively, from the time to the present day. Its latest phase is The Nation. represented by the effort Mr. Knox | himself is making, with every prospect | of final success, to enlarge the present | arrangements at The Hague into a true | court, having a continuous life and per- | manent membership, and developing its | own body of authoritative rules and) precedents—a court to which, in all or-! dinary conjunctures, the nations of the world will submit their differences just | as individuals now submit theirs in an ordinary court of law. SWELLING PUBLIC EXPENSES. Gov, Hughes has lopped off nearly $5,- 000,000 from the appropriations made by the New York Legislature, but even so the total left in force is some $5,000,- 000 greater than last year. These two facts, taken together, are a telling com- mentary on the enormous difficulty of keeping public Not everything can be charged to the reck- lessness of the Legislature. It did, in- deed, display a cool disregard of the probable revenue of the State, and ap- parently took no thought for making both ends meet; and it hid away in the bills many suspicious through the Governor thrusts his discriminating pen. There was evidence of a good deal of log-roll- ing in the make-up of this year’s appro- priations at Albany; a surprising num- ber of armories were to be built here and there throughout the State, and sev- eral local grants in aid of politicians were proposed. Most of these Gov. Hughes has disallowed, and has done it on principle, so that supporters of his in the Legislature suffer as well as his op- ponents, though the latter are naturally | more numerous since more of them had legislative favors promised them for en- tering into the combination against the Governor. But making allowance for all this, and taking it for granted that Gov. Hughes has cut off every dollar possible, we remain confronted with the unpleas- ant truth that the necessary expenses of the State have increased $5,000,000 in a single year—or more than 10 per cent. down expenses. supply a great items which | Yet all of this increase, the Governor shows, falls within the provision of mo- ney for the educational, the humane, the reformatory work of the State. The | added sum of $540,000 had to be appro: | priated in order to carry out the Con-| stitutional amendment adopted by the people raising the salaries of the judges. An increase of $325,000 was made in the | [ Vol. go, No. 2347 appropriation for public schools. Hos- pitals and prisons came in for a pro- vision of needed funds larger by up- wards of $2,000,000—though half of this is really arrears. The money required for keeping up with the work of abol- ishing grade crossings and enforcing |the law relating to motor vehicles eats up an additional $850,000. None of these public expenses could be cut off without diminishing the charitable and progressive activities of the State, And the experience of New York is but the same as that of other States and of mu- nicipal governments. The public outlay shows everywhere a distinct and seem- ingly irresistible tendency to increase faster than the growth of population, faster perhaps than the accumulation of wealth. This, of course, against making constant and valiant ef- forts to keep down public expenses. On the contrary, it is a powerful argument for doing it. With so many new de- mands upon the public purse, that are so hard to refuse, the need of withstand- ing every form of extravagance and waste becomes all the more imperative. So does the call for perfecting and en- forcing better systems of financial con- trol. Of one such we have a happy ex- ample in the power bestowed upon the Governor of New York to veto separate items in appropriation bills. The gen- eral practice is to compel an Executive to take or reject a measure in its en- tirety. Under that plan, the temptation to slip all kinds of indefensible pro- jects into an appropriation bill is obvi- is no argument ‘ous. Once get them safely tucked with- in its four corners, and the veto cannot reach them without causing the whole act to fall—and that would often mean serious embarrassment to the public business. Hence the vast importance of being able to strike out dubious items. If President Taft, for instance, had the power of the Governor of New York to single out and refuse to sign bad clauses or vicious details in the money-bills sent to him by Congress, he would be much nearer in sight of effective control of the national expenditures than the Admin- istration can now be said to be. In- deed, at Washington as at Albany, there is much concern over swollen appropria- tions. Despite the fact that the official estimates were $40,000,000 less this year than the appropriations last year, and notwithstanding all the talk in the Sen-
Page 9
June 23, 1910} ate about economy, and the actual for- mation of something like a budget com- mittee, Congress has been voting mo- ney very much in the old fashion, so that the outlook now is, not for a large saving, but for an actual increase in ex- penses. Lord Cromer once made a speech on financial administration in which he said that he had always held it a rule in Egypt, whenever the question arose of making a new governmental outlay, to insist upon being shown first where the money was to be found. He added that, of course, the problem was different in a country where elected representatives might force the hand of a Finance Min- ister, But he said, dryly, that while this altered the political problem, the arith- metical problem remained precisely the same. Money voted has still to be found. And the only place where it can be found is in taxes. Hence before citizens settle down comfortably in the conviction that the increase of public expenses is bound to go on, and that no man, no party, no system can prevent it, they ought to ask themselves whether they will be equally comfortable in the thought that there is to be a like and unavoidable incrcase in taxation. GOING FISHING VS. ANGLING. Only a very dull or untrained reader— of the kind that would confuse fox-hunt- ing with shooting foxes—will stumble The angler and the man who goes fishing inhabit different over this title. worlds, profess mutually incompatible morals, and reciprocally must misun- derstand each other. Your angler is es- sentially an uneasy man, a stickler for form. The mere taking of fish is a trifling incident in a long and compli- cated process. For months he has weighed the merits and demerits of rod- makers, all winter he has put by with the eye of the critic featly tied flies, has considered the mechanism of reels, by taking thought has cut an ounce from the weight of a rod, and finally, when he reaches lake or stream, he not mere- ly wants fish, but wants them according to an elaborate code. They must be taken on the top of the water, with the lightest tackle. The angler, like a pseudo-classical dramatist, has his uni- ties and scorns mixture of the genres. He abounds in distinctions. Under cer- tain circumstances, but carefully re stricted, an artificial minnow may be The Nation. substituted for an artificial fly, but only contempt would be his portion who should add to fly a tiny revolving spoon, or tip the combination with a bit of the loathly earth-worm. In short, the angler seeks not fish, but an engrossingly cere- monious pursuit of them; not relaxa- tion, but a fine and exacting avoca- tion. Imagine pretty nearly the opposite of this character and you have that of the man who goes fishing. He prefers the coarsest and most handy tackle. Any lure serves him, and a line hitched for security to a tholepin at one end, with a hook at the other, is often his entire out- fit. His from that of the angler. neo-Waltonian plans an aggressive cam- whole mental attitude differs Whereas the paign, the man who goes fishing waits passively until destiny provides fish or belief that anglers Izaak Walton gave some comfort to such a fallacy on night. There is a are contemplative men; his title-page. The error is radical. No one can be more incapacitated for vagrom meditations than he who is con scientiously whipping a stretch of water. After the business of angling, in eve- ning lassitude, an angler might possi bly be contemplative; the strength of the mere fishing man’s position is that he is never on duty, always free to slumber, to muse, to indulge hazy phil- osophies, for in so doing he fails in no duty and loses no tactical point. The fish that is simple enough to bite at the crude bait covering a massive hook is doomed to stay on until he is wanted, though a system of morals were evolved the while. It is, in fact, the simple, instinctive love of vagabondage that takes men fishing. To be for a space dissolved in the flux of things, to escape the calcula- ble, drop a line into mysterious realms above or below conscious thought—this is the privilege of the man who goes fishing. One bond unites him with the angler—neither primarily desires fish, but a special experience; and here the man who goes fishing has the advantage of setting forth impromptu whenever the spirit moves, and of always coming back with some kind of catch. For it cannot be denied that, while the angler, for the sake of a maximum of form, cheerfully puts up with a minimum of fish, the total lack of fish disconcerts Here his evinces a superiority, a purer amateur him. humbler colleague 623 ism. Knowing that the inner rewards are his, he has no shame at being out- wardly “skunked.” It is enough to have restored the unity of his spirit; he has been a-fishing. A fair consideration of the man who goes fishing will do something to extend the tolerance and reduce the spiritual of the lends itself to strange perversions; the pride angling kind. Angling lowlier pursuit is ever integral and wor- thy. There are insensate, demoralized anglers who, borrowing the profession- al fisherman's quite legitimate desire of fish, employ strange artifices. Bottom baits, spinning, or twirling; likenesses of creeping and hopping things there are; nay, one reprobate we have met who shamelessly displayed a moleskin twitched on a lake, he mouse which, held was infallibly appetizing. Such fa natics pursue fish with the ungraceful ardors of a Calvinist doggedly treading They lack the deli cacy of the angler, the geniality of the the primrose path. man who goes fishing, and the economic warrant of the pot-fisherman. It may be urged and should be frank ly admitted that the man who goes fish- ing has the defects of his qualities. Whereas the angler is usually temper- ate, keeping training as it were, the man who goes fishing is likely to accelerate with stimulants the oncoming of cosmic sympathy. In fact, there is something receptive and sponge-like in his texture; he absorbs either from within or with- out. To many, on the other hand, the narcotization of sun suffi- mild progressive and wind and lapping water is cient. These are the elect of the class. There must be times when the angler, substituting laboriously the niceties of his recreation for the rigors of his daily task, envies just a little some motion- less vague figure squatted in a punt from the side of which depends Inertly a mighty cord. Yet there may be rarer moments, when the trout are leaping, in which the man who goes fishing like wise envies just a little the finished art of the angler. BUSINESS AND PLEASURE. A few item of news which attracted considerable attention days ago, an told how a man who had begun life as a bank messenger at the age of four- teen rose to the presidency of the great- est bank in Chicago. Mr. Reynolds, it
Page 10
G24 was stated, “has never lost a day from sickness; he has never taken a vacation did have does not drink; he does not play bridge; he does not play golf; he no hobby but banking; he has no coun- that not business inside; he does not smoke; he has no favorite author; he has iry residence; he does not even take ex- he works nine hours a day.” Mr. Te ise: Reynolds himself declared that he had adopted as a rule of life the maxim, “Make your business your pleasure.” Putting this and that together, one might pleasantly conclude that bril- liant outward svccess and complete in- ward satisfaction were both within the reach of all of us: work all the time and have unbounded love for your work that is the sovereign prescription to procure not only success, but also hap- piness. Of course, this illusion can be enter- tained only for a moment; the problem of life obviously admits of no such sim- Even if we were to sup- the chose, and that it ple solution. that could follow everybody prescription if would be a good thing if everybody did follow it, we should be confronted, first of all, by the manifest impossibility that pose he the result should be similar to that re- corded in the case of Mr. Reynolds. High distinction for everybody is a contradic- tion in terms. It is only in comic opera that the prospect is held out for ail to become rulers of the Queen’s Navee as the reward for sticking close to their desks life as messengers or the like; there are There are millions who start in tens of thousands who are faithful, com- petent, and industrious; but those who reach the top must of necessity be count- ed only by the hundreds. To tell every- body, therefore, to follow Mr. Reynolds's example, with the expectation that this will lead to like achievement, would be obtaining business virtue on false pre- tences., As for the maxim, “Make your busi ne your pleasure,” it is In itself excel lent. To take pleasure or satisfaction in one work is a prime requirement of contentment; and if a man can have an absorbing love of his work he has gone far toward solving the problem of hap piness. In some pursuits, too, it is pos sible for large numbers of persons to have this unbounded absorption in the labors to which thelr lives are devoted. The whole tribe of German university they were, at least, be pi ofessors as [Vol. 90, No. 2347 The Nation. fore the commercialization of German life in these latter years—might be reck- oned in this class; and there are many artists and musicians who, without achieving high rank or notable artistic success, find a like joy in their labors. But in most fields of activity, such keen satisfaction in the pursuit of the daily business is possible only if a man feels that he is exercising unusual powers and accomplishing unusual results. A man may well be satisfied to be simply an in- dustrious and competent cashier, or fore- man, or manager, or what not; but, un- less he has a sadly limited range of thought and feeling, he can hardly find that this occupation of itself supplies all the pleasure and gratification that he has reason to look for in the world about him. There is nothing, therefore, to regret, in the fact that we are not all equally great lovers of work. There is room in the world for an indefinite number of comfortable, easy-going people—people who do not shirk work, but whose appe- tite for it is limited. But for people of the other kind, who find unfailing joy in ceaseless toil, there is only a limited amount of accommodation. It is for them, indeed, the saying has been in- vented that there is always room on top; but the saying is rather a truism than a truth. There is always room on top for those persons who can get there; but for those who cannot, it would be folly to order their lives on a plan ex- pressly based on the supposition that they can. Here in America, we are quite as much in need of encouragement to make pleasure a business as to make Both rules are good in their degree; neither is abso- Keep your nose to the grindstone by all means, if you enjoy it; but don’t tell everybody else that he must enjoy it as much as you do. There is difference of tastes the difference business a pleasure. lute, room for a vast in this matter; and of tastes is in itself a good. No one type of man, and no one attitude to- ward life, should suffice for a whole peo- ple; and if there is one thing more than another in which we should benefit by the infusion of a somewhat alien spirit, it is in the appreciation of those pleas- ures of life which are to be had from a free-hearted use of leisure. HISTORICAL LITERATURE IN AUS- TRALASIA. Sypney, June 1. Some twenty years ago, the Govern- ment of New South Wales decided to publish its early manuscript records. The gentleman commissioned conceived his duty to consist in the composition of an historical narrative from those documents. After the printing of two volumes on these lines, the work was arrested, and the publication of the docu- ments began in 1893. They fill seven considerable volumes, which must re- main the foundation of a critical history of Australia. It is fifty years since New Zealand collected in a volume of par- liamentary papers the instructive re- ports of select committees of the Brit- ish Parliament and other official docu- ments connected with the early coloniza- tion and settlement of the islands. At | that point, for half a century, the task was left. Then, more than ten years ago, an instructed and capable inquirer, Robert McNab, barrister and farmer, latterly legislator and minister, devoted himself to collecting all discoverable documents relating to the early history of the most southern part of New Zea- land. Not only Southland itself, as the | portion is termed, but the adjacent isl- ands were his objective, though not the ‘fields of his research, since no docu- ments were to be found there. In Tas- |mania, Sydney, and London, where he ransacked the Record Office and the Brit- |ish Museum; in many American cities —Salem, Boston, and New Bedford, Nan- tucket, Providence, and Newport, Balti- more, Philadelphia, and Washington; /and in Madrid and Paris—not yet in St. | Petersburg, though he does not despair of it—he found the precious materials of his historical labors. What was it he found, and what did it tell? Such documents as have never before, perhaps, been regarded as ma- terials for history—chiefly the log-books of ancient voyages. Of one such find, he tells with the subdued enthusiasm of the fortunate collector. In “the magnifi- cent collections of the Essex Institute,” Mass., Mr. McNab had the good luck to discover a volume, “got, no one knows where,” containing three precious logs, especially that of the ship Britannia, /which landed the first sealing gang on the coast of New Zealand in 1793. How far afield this indefatigable researcher has gone appears from the facts and |scenes now first drawn from the narra- | tives of two great navigators—the Span- lard, Malaspina, and the Russian, Bel- lingshausen. All these documents he has printed copiously in his “Murihiku and the Southern Islands,” published in 1907 after nine years’ research. Two years of further research brought within his command such a mass of additional ma- terials as compelled him to reconstruct his work. It now appears under a s!m- ilar titlee—“Murihiku: a History o% the
Page 11
June 23, 1910] Islands adjacent from 1642 to 1835” (Christchurch:. ‘Whitcombe & Tombs). He has extended the scope of his work in both time and space. He now carries it back to the visit of Tas- man and brings it down to the early days of British colonization. Mr. McNab has the merit of discovering the fact that New Zealand had a remarkable ear- ly history, and to him it is the most fas- cinating period of her annals. Few will agree with him, but all will admit that he has revealed a wonderful unknown period, when the sea-elephant hunters and the whalers lorded it over the shores of a new land. He has first described their methods and daily life, told of the discovery of the various islands, and nar- rated the genesis of antipodean com- merce. A book so completely original, containing matter so absolutely new, and so thoroughly documented, is seldom published, and much of it concerns American readers, who will find in it new lights on their early maritime his- tory. National bibliography follows in the wake of the publication of national doc- uments. It is long since the second French Empire issued a bibliography of its history. More than twenty years ago the librarian of the London Atheneum, amid the laughter of his confréres, quixotically undertook to produce sin- gle-handed, if aid were not forthcom- ing, a bibliography of English history. The British colonies, which are ahead of the Motherland in so many other things, are ahead of her in this. Many years ago the Public Library of Sydney brought out a bibliography of the seven colonies. In 1889 New Zealand took a step in advance. Its then parliamen- tary librarian, James Collier, publish- ed under the auspices of the Govern- ment a bibliography of the literature relating to the colony. It had some special features. Appended to each title in the chronological catalogue there were notes, sometimes lengthy, containing a précis of the work, and embodying information, sometimes re- condite, relative to the book. Next, be- sides the author and the title indexes, there was a classified catalogue, scien- tifically arranging the contents of all the publications catalogued under thir- ty-four heads, so as to make them at once available for historians or stu- dents. Dr. Hocken of Dunedin has now pub- lished, under his own name, an enlarg- ed and improved edition of his prede- cessor’s work.* He has closely followed Collier’s plan, down ever to the details of the typography. He has also sup- plied the unavoidable deficiencies of Col- lier’s work, and he has brought it up to date. How considerably the subject ***A Bibliography of the Literature relating to New Zealand.’’ Wellington: Government Printing Office. The Nation. | has grown on his hands will appear if we compare the bulk of the two wholes and of one of their sections. Collier's volume consists of some 1,200 titles; Hocken's, of perhaps 6,000. Again, the number of works or portions of works relative to missions in Collier amounts to 59, while in Hocken it exceeds 130. The disparity is, however, exaggerated by the inclusion in the later work, not only of publications relating to New ‘Zealand, but of all works published in that country. This, as well as the in- clusion of works not relating to New Zealand by authors well-known in con- nection with New Zealand, seems a mis- taken policy. Similarly questionable is the long list of publications in the Maori language. Yet this has its value, and a similar defence might be made for the other illegitimate inclusions. Where Dr. Hocken’s policy seems al- together indefensible is his verbatim ap- propriation of his predecessor's notes, sometimes long and elaborate, on works which the doctor has often not seen, and this without using inverted commas or appending the name of the author. Analyses of ethnological theories traced through a series of erudite works, such as those of Lesson and Quatrefages, For- nander and Lang, and ascertainments of authorship in the case of anonymous or pseudonymous treatises, have been “conveyed” without a word of acknowl- edgement. They will in consequence be read in future as the offspring of Dr. Hocken’s research. These criticisms being made, the work may be strongly eulogized. It is accur- ate, comprehensive, and complete. The excellent notes often embody informa- tion, personal, literary, and historical, accumulated during half a lifetime of unintermitted labor. It may be doubted ‘if a more exhaustive bibliography ex- ists. We ave still on historical ground when we turn to A. St. Ledger’s “So- cialism in Queensland” (Macmillan). For, if in purpose it is a keen and un- sparing polemic against Socialism, the work is historical in form, and pro- fesses to give a truthful account of the origin and developments of the social- ist movement in Australia and New Zea- land. That had its origin in two fa- mous American books — George’s “Progress and Poverty” and Bellamy’s “Looking Backward.” The first gave birth to the movement for the national- ization of the land in New Zealand, where it has had many legislative de- velopments, and whence it has spread to Australia and now to England. This phase of Socialism the author omits, and devotes himself to that aspect of it which consists in the nationalization of the agencies of production, exchange, and distribution. This form of it had its origin in Bellamy’s romance, which converted William Lane into a social- ist. Lane was the uneducated son of a _ GOL5 Warwickshire farm laborer, but no one would discover the fact from his crystal- line and sometimes dainty English dk tion. A journalist, he the Worker to spread his new faith. He it was who devised the motto of the bor party in Queensland: “Socialism in our time.” From Queensland the gos- pel passed to the other States, largely pervading the Labor policy in them and in the Australian Commonwealth. How all this happened is vividly told. One or two criticisms reduce but slightly the value of the book. It does not take ac count of the tendency towards Social ism inherent in all the Australasian States. Particularly, it gives no adequate statement of its multifarious manifes tations in New Zealand. And the author, who is a Senator for Queensland in the Federal Parliament, naturally exagger ates the part of Queensland in the move ment, and perhaps the part played by Lane in Queensland. Otherwise, the volume is as instructive as interesting. We are still exploring the field of his- tory when we accompany Dr. T. S. Hall in his “Geological Rambles in Victoria” (Melbourne: T. C, Lothian), though now it is very ancient history. Dr. Hall is everywhere the geologist. To him the aspect and the flora of a district are the natural expression of the structure and composition of the rocks. Geology must supply the key to physical geography and botany; may add, to biology, ethnology, and sociology. There are many instructive lessons to be learned from our field geologist. While he ad mits that “the great moulding agency is running he finds districts in Victoria where catastrophes must be In- voked to explain the fractures of the earth’s crust. In Victoria, too, he finds evidence of a long and severe glacial period compared with which the age of Northern Europe and America is a thing of yesterday. The variety of the ice-borne rocks wonderful, and proves that there were, not one, but sev- eral, glacial periods. The simply writ ten volume is rendered attractive by 39 illustrations and maps. J. C. founded La we water,” ice is (' orrespondence. THE SOURCE OF POE'S “SOME WORDS WITH A MUMMY.” To THE EpiTror or THe NATio SIR A dozen or more of Poe's tales have been traced to their sources Gris- wold a good many years ago made it clear that the original of “The Pit and the Pendulum” was to be found in a tale in Blackwood's. Professor Woodberry, collab orating with Stedman in their well-known edition of Poe's works, pointed out the sources of “King Pest,” “Hop Frog,” “Metzengerstein,””’ and “The Masque of the Red Death,”’ and indicated partial sources other stories; and volumes, touched four or five the same for some Stedman, in
Page 12
626 Poe's indebtedness to the German E Within the last few years Professor Palmer Cobb of the University of North Carolina has examined more minutely the problem of Poe’s indebtedness to Hoffmann And there have been oth- in the magazines. But no appears have suggested a source for Por extravagant tale “Some Words With a Mummy.” The original of this tale be found, I believe, in R. M Bird novel “Sheppard This novel was published anonymously at Philadelphia 1836 wed by Poe in Septem- the “Poe's upon Tr. A. Hoffmann. er notes one to to Lee.” ind was revi Southern Works,” 126-139) “Some first appeared in 1845. will of an galvanic in ber f the same year in Literary rgit i Vessenger (see IX, pp Mummy” Whig Review for April tale, it ration to life Edition With a the American rt chief incident in called, is the rest by Bird's novel recounts of the who had met death by acci- night for the of Captain His spirit be- ke tself first the body of asthmatic old squire of the neighborhood, then into the body ofa Philadelphia dandy, and after other such feats of metempsychosis brings up finally in the person of a slave, Nigger on a Virginia plantation As Nigger the hero of the story ted of having taken part in a slave and is hanged and buried after burial, his body is taken up medical students, who wish to t their skill with the dissecting knife. before beginning operations, one of helr number suggests that they first ex- on the body with an electric and, this suggestion being adopt- ed, the experiment is made as in Poe's tale and with like results. The spirit of Sheppard Lee then takes possession of the body of one of the students who had en- gaged the experiment and had been frightened to death by its outcome; and the guise of this young man it soon the good fortune to come across the which it had originally occupied, however, reduced to a state of com- plete mummification and on exhibition in a collection of curiosities displayed by an old doctor who had lived in the neighborhood of Sheppard Lee's searches after hidden treasure. The spirit, acting in of this student, manages to the in which the to make its way time life Word Poe's in mummy means of a a series of itions soul of its hero rd Lee, digging one Kidd into NV le ure an Tom, Tom, is Sus pe insurrection, Shortly some by te But t periment battery in in has body now German the break mummy back its Sheppard Lee and the person open glass case is enclosed and the same to an end of correct, into body, and at fully comes to is restored story of the my theory tal lea of restoring a body to life through of the notion resurrection again It these that furnished wis two vl if ‘ ompounded out his electricity, other sup- of the of a two episodes are juxtaposed agency 1 the jummy rhe bird in hy Poe obtained the neces novel, and are summarized im paragraph in Poe's review r th two of of hi VAZAnNZA and also increased the id action, story —ev ntly meant as thers are details these episode in minor which Poe These Bird's two have romance suggested his to similar situa first, the may ions in story are s [Vol go, No. 2347 The Nation. snapping, or batting, of the subject’s eyes as it begins to show signs of restored | animation; and, secondly, the bestowing by | the half-resuscitated body of a prodigious blow upon the stomach of the ring-leader of the experimenters. But these minor sim- ilarities may be mere coincidences, and of no significance for my purpose—what is al- most surely the case with a further coin- cidence, in that the improbabilities of both | stories are explained away on the theory that all had happened in a dream. I may add that certain parallels between Bird’s novel and Poe’s more famous story, “The Gold Bug,” are also, in my judgment, accidental; though we find in Bird’s story only the digging for Captain Kidd's gold under a large tree in the depths of a but also in Jim Jumble, with his fears to his master’s sanity, and in Sheppard Lee, with his attempts to give he faithful old darkey the slip on the oc- easion of his excursions in search of gold, faint suggestions both Jupiter and Legrand in Poe's story. KILLIS not forest, as of CAMPBELL. The University of Texas, June 10. MISREPRESENTATIONS OF SPAIN. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: May I be permitted to disagree with an opinion recently expressed by one of your critics in regard to Mrs. Villiers-War- dell’s “Spain of the Spanish?” ‘In all mat- ters connected with the newer intellectual and artistic movement in Spain,” we are, told, “Mrs. Villiers-Wardell is an intelli- gent and diverting guide.’”’ Diverting the book frequently is; but that its author is an intelligent or safe guide to things intellectual and artistic in Spain, any His- panist will deny The chapter on Modern Literature, by far | the worst in the book, betrays a lack of | knowledge which is abysmal. For exam- ple, om page 48, the author naively re- marks of Menéndez y Pelayo: “The writ- er has already produced a number of im- portant works.”’ An encouraging pat on the back which ought to inspire the dean of Spanish criticism and the autho> of “Las ideas estéticas en Espafia’’ to renewed ef- fort. We are further told that he has com- pleted eight volumes of his edition of the works of Lope de Vega. Thirteen is the correct number. This error would be too insignificant to mention if it did not re- | veal the method employed by the author the compilation of this chapter. The| statement is taken from a ten-year-old | edition of Fitzmaurice-Kelly’s “History of | Spanish Literature’ (New York, 1900, p. | 109). The whole chapter is largely a re- | hash of this well-known text-book. Un- | fortunately Mrs. Villiers-Wardell fre. | quently departs from her authority and it is that she is prone to fall into er- in | then | ror A serious oversight may be noticed in the short blography devoted to Pareda. The greatest of modern Spanish novelists is ev- spoken of in the tense, only too evidently un Pareda died in March, important a chapter which comments upon so recent a work as Blasco Ibafiez’s ‘Los muertos mandan.”’ Again the antiquated edition of Fitzmaurice-Kelly erywhere present the aware of his death The is and author jis 1906 failure to notice so a fact inexcusable in | stitutional | good and bad alike. has proved a broken reed, and the author's lack of first-hand information stands re- vealed. Although somewhat more familiar with the bull-ring than with Spanish lit- erature, Mrs. Villiers-Wardell makes a similar error in the chapter devoted to Sports and Pastimes. She had not heard of the tragic death of Machaquito. If errors of fact are frequent throughouc the book, errors of judgment are no less numerous. The chapters relating to Span- ish politics, for example, are especially misleading. We are told that the King and Queen have won the affections of the Cata- lans; that “Catalufia as a storm-centre of revolution has fallen into disrepute’; that “the people have confidence in Maura’s government, and sooner or later the Re- gionalists will, in all probability, join forces with the Monarchical party,” etc. Last summer’s revolt gave a decisive an- swer to these and similar optimistic state- ments. The tragic events of last year could not have been foreseen; yet the most elementary acquaintance with real condi- tions would have prevented the utterance of statements so contrary to the truth Sefior Maura, now happily out of power, is spoken of as a progressive, enlightened statesman. One would almost imagine him to be a reformer instead of a bulwark of reaction. Is Sefior Maura’s repeal of the civil marriage law so soon forgotten? But most remarkable is the author’s apparent approval of the infamous Conde de Ro- manones (p. 99-100) who, with other politi- cians of high rank, long enjoyed the uncon- privilege of private coinage, thus doubling the value of the yield of the silver mines which they controlled. So | flagrant did this abuse become that in the |}summer of 1908 an honest minister of the | treasury felt obliged to withdraw from cir- |culation nineteen issues of the silver duro, Of this official free- booter Mrs. Villiers-Wardell naively re- marks: “He is a man of untiring energy and enterprise, and already he has, by suc- cessful speculations, greatly augmented the very considerable fortune left him by his father.” Although many more errors might be pointed out, enough has now been said to show that Mrs. Villiers-Wardell’s book is not a trustworthy guide. More than al- most any other country of Europe Spain has been misrepresented and misunder- stood. The dilettante traveller has claim- ed the land as his own. Théophile Gautier, Washington Irving, George Borrow, and De Amicis are not guiltless, but charm of style has deservedly caused their books to rank ag classics. Most recent writers of books of Spanish travel are neither conscientiously accurate in the presentation of fact nor possessed of a literary touch sufficient to bring pardon for other shortcomings. Honorable excep- | tion must be made of René Bazin’s charm- ing and sympathetic “Terre d’Espagne”’ and Havelock Ellis's admirable “Soul of Spain.” GEORGE TYLER NORTHUP. Princeton, N. J., June 15. THE EARTH OF APOLLONIUS—WAS IT INDIAN? To THe EpiTror or THe NATION: Sir: Since calling attention in your col- umns to the perfect manner in which the
Page 13
June 23, 1910] The Nation. ! , Sirya Siddhanta’s conception of the earth,|ing these questions is not only fitted for with its two heaven-reaching polar mountains, interprets the peculiar terms employed by Apollonius in ‘“‘Argo- nautica,”’ iii, 158, I have seen Bergk’s re- marks on the passage as found in his “Kleine philologische Schriften,” II, 704. “That two mountains should be mention- ed,”” he says, “is peculiar.”” He confesses his inability to explain the point. He raises the question whether an “error,” or a “misunderstanding” on the part of the poet, must not underlie his language. But the words to which Bergk pays no atten- tion, So médnx, are as plain as words can be, and they fix the location of the two mountains, not in the East or in the West, or in “the East and West,” but at the earth’s two poles. (Permit me to refer to my recent book, “The Earliest Cosmologies,”’ pp. 79-8:, 174, 205). Bergk’s difficulty in dealing with the ‘“‘Mountain of Sunrise’ and ‘“‘Mountain of Sunset”’ is pre- cisely the one which troubled the Assyri- ologists until Professor Sayce reached the correct conclusion that the two were ‘one and the same.”’ See his “‘Hibbert Lectures,” p 361. Since that time he has come to see that this one identical mountain, be- hind which the sun disappeared every eve- ning, and from behind which it emerged every morning, was in the highest north, even at the pole. And the moment one comes to this insight, the strange assertion of Maspero, to the effect that, in their earliest periods, both the Babylonians and Egyptians “‘believed that the sun and moon revolved round the earth in a horizontal plane,’’ becomes perfectly easy of explana- tion, for the sun and moon do so revolve at the pole. If any of our masters in Greek litera- ture have lighted upon a second passage similar to this in Apollonius, all students in comparative mythology and comparative cosmology will be delighted to learn of it. What would not one give for the lost verse from Ibycus, referred to by Bergk? WILLIAM FAIRFIELD WARREN. Boston University, June 14. antipodal DEBATING AT SCHOOL. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: service in its conservative treatment of current ‘endencies, but now and then it makes an error in condemning that which is new. Such an error, I believe, was made , citizenship in his own country, and in the world, but he at the same time becomes familiar with the best sources of informa- tion upon current questions. For the great majority of students in the secondary schools, who cannot go to college, this reference work upon topics of present-day importance will mean the formation of a habit of reading in periodicals which have in them many of the essentials of a liberal education. Such work in the schools will make the public libraries educational cen- tres instead of dispensaries of the latest popular fiction. It will give the nation that which it so much needs—intelligent citi- zens who are not to be deluded and the yellow press and the curb- stone orator. Then, too, there are the pupils and stu- themselves; surely considera- tion should be given to their preference From my own observations I believe that they prefer to study the vital questions of the present rather than the dead issues of the past. One of the most inspiring reci- tations I ever conducted was a general discussion by high-school students in a class in modern history of militarism vs arbitration. The students had prepared themselves carefully by reading magazine articles, international conciliation bul- letins, and reference books in the public library, so that they had a fairly intelli- gent idea of what they were talking about. This book to which you refer in the edi- torial mentioned may be all that the edi- torial would indicate, and more, but your condemnation of the principle associated with it is unjust. Does the Nation aim to support worthy and well-qualified progress, or is it so bound to the past that it can see no good in anything new? CLARENCE GREEN. de- ceived by dents some Tacoma, Wash., June 11. THE TARIFF AND WAGES To THe Error of THE NATION: Str: For as many years as any of us lean think back, we have been told that The Nation performs an excellent | | Where European manufacturers employ fe- | procuring of revenue, was the protection of the need for high tariff duties, besides the American against foreign “‘pauper’’ labor. male labor principally, especially in the so-called “house industries,”” the wages | paid are really so far below any prevailirg in the editorial of a recent number which | |} ing that sort of manufacturing, competition attacked the present custom of having stu- dents debate modern topics in prefer- ence to questions concerning the ancient world. Training for citizenship is undoubt- edly one of the primary purposes of the public schools. This being granted, will it not be necessary to concede the corollary, that the discussion of present-day topics by students in schools ‘and colleges will tend to realize this important purpose? Every one who has given the subject much thought will admit that educational! methods are, as a rule, most conservative. The average pedagogue is prone to teach in the same way as he was taught. He clings reverently and firmly to the pedagogic prin- ciples of the medigval schoolmen. This tendency, however, to have the students de- bate live questions rather than thoroughly dead ones has in it the elements of pro- gress and promise. The student by study- /pumbers of hand-workers skilled | making, in the United States that were we attemp:- on equal lines would be hopeless. How- ever, such ig not the case; we have no larg in lace- embroidering, and the like—the great industries of the United ‘States are built up by means of labor-saving machin- ery, and it is their products that must com- pete in the world’s markets... Why we are able so to do, our higher wage rate not- withstanding, facts that have come to my knowledge will illustrate A New York manufacturing engineer placed in charge of its English branch by on American firm, told me within the week ‘hat the 200 employees under his control receiving less than half American wages, turned out less than half the amount of work that the same number engaged in similar work on our side do. The profits over her averaged so much less on than the output G27 with the home company, that he was sent over for the very purpose of endeavoring to make this “pauper labor” as productive as that of the high-priced workers in the United States. A few years ago an Anierican in charge of a similar industry in Berlin employing upward of a thousand men put turn as two-thirds that of Americans in the same line It has been pointed out, time and again that comparisons ments of what their out- without stat of wages such wages represent in production are valueless and misleading Also, it is necessary to know what the money wages procure in the way of the ecessities of life in the countries betwe which comparisons are made. Modern brick four-room cottages were pointed out to m rp English villeges, of which the rent five shillings a week, $1.20; and they had ground attached, large enough to furnish ihe family vege ables. A tariff commission can do no more tightening and useful work than to bring out the facts which will make possib! real and intelligent comparisons on the above lines. Max LOWENTHAL London, June 9 A RARE PAMPHLET. To THE EpItTroR OF THE NATION Sir: The writer of News for Bibliophiles in the Nation for June 16 calls attention to the discovery’ of a fourth copy of “The Humble Request of Hig Majesties loyall Subjects,” issued by Winthrop and others from Yarmouth, “aboard the Arbela, April 7, 1630,” and he justly lays stress upon the value and importance of the pamphlet. He and others interested in our colonial his- tory will be glad to know that there is a fifth copy, in perfect condition, in the library of All Souls College, Oxford CHARLES M. ANDREWS Johns Hopkins University, June 17. GEN. GRANT’S FATHER. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: In November, 1865, I was on a Penn- sylvania Railroad train, eastbound from Pittsburgh. In the next seat was an old fellow—that’s the way you would describe him—with “country” written all over him. He opened a conversation with our party, and asked if we were going to Washington; said he was going there; and added, with “I've got in Washington— Grant.” Of course, the response was, “Indeed,” etc.; and so, feeling encouraged he turned about arm the back of the seat and proceeded to ‘‘tell all about” his son. I remember it all as plain as yesterday, though I down till now. “Yes, he’s my and he's a name for himself.”” Long pause and med- Speaking slowly and with a great country manner, pauses, a son Gen with his over have never written it son, made quite itation. deal of repetition and a but much earnestness: “They are talking about making him President They don’t want to make him President. He's no man for President. He'd be no good in that place. A soldier is what he’s fit for. He ain’t good for anything else but a soldier Why! I’ve had to set him up in business more than once. He was never any good eee
Page 14
628 in business. He’s just a soldier; he’s good at that No, he ain't the man for Presi- dent. He wouldn't make a good one.” And so on, to this effect and substantially in these words. I remember too many of the words and phrases to be mistaken. It was a striking incident, and I have often thought of it since. straight-forward, simple-minded old man! That was Jesse R, Grant; and it was six months after the war. E. R. Good, FRENCH. Sheridan, Wvro., June 10 Literature. A FINE OLD ENGLISH TORY. Gathorne Hardy, First Earl of Cran- brook: A Memoir, with Extracts from His Diary and Correspondence. Edited the Hon. Alfred E. Gathorne- Hardy. 2 vols., with portraits and other illustrations. New York: Long- mans, Green & Co. $7 net. One by one the biographies of the later Victorian statesmen of the sec- ond rank are coming to light. Within a few years, Dufferin, Northcote, Ran- dolph Churchill, Northbrook, Lytton have had their lives written, some of them with such speed as to suggest that realize the necessity of the brief immortality ac- most public men. Salis- still uncommemorated, and probably years will elapse before the documents are released which alone can give permanent interest to his unsym- pathetic personality. But Gathorne Har- dy, although he died as late as 1906, al- ready belonged to the past generation, and he was not sufficiently at the heart of things to share exclusive confidences and politica] secrets which it would be indiscreet to publish now. Doubtless, as his son and editor announces, passages have been suppressed and names with- held in the material printed; but there can be little left out that was essential. As to Gathorne Hardy himself, we have here all the elements for a full- length life-like portrait of the most typli- cal, enlightened Tory of the Victorian era. If only one book could be preserv- ed to exhibit to posterity modern Tory- ism in its most comprehensive and convincing embodiment, that book this memoir of Gathorne by biographers at to grasping corded 18 bury should be Hardy He was born In 1814, of a middle- class family, which traced ita origin to an Irish laborer living in Yorkshire in 1670. The statesman’s grandfather laid the basis of a large fortune by buy- ing the Lowmoor Iron Works in 1789; his father was a successful barrister, a judge, and a member of Parliament. He himself went through the brutal school- ing which was then supposed to be necessary to the cducation of English gentlemen. In 1833, he entered Oriel College, Oxford, where he acquitted him- '—his side. The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2347 self creditably; “he read law and was admitted to the bar in London, and soon established a lucrative practice. In 1855, he was elected to Parliament from Brad- ford, and thenceforth until the general | election of 1895, he was continuous- ly in public life, either moner, minister, or another important commission. In the | course of his career he was offered every portfolio, and at different times he served as President of the Poor Law Board, Home Secretary, Secretary for | War, Secretary for India, and President | In every position his | chief characteristic was his talent for) of the Council. routine work. No better bureaucrat ever sat in an English cabinet. He was nei- ther a great legislator nor a great ora- tor; miers under whom he served, because he could be relied upon to defend their platform with unfailing loyalty and dis- cretion, and to carry out their meas- ures with promptness, honesty, and thor oughness. He had “no nonsense about him,” which is the highest praise that | an Englishman, be he peer or potboy, | can bestow. Gathorne Hardy lacked magnetism, but that is a quality which modern Tory statesmen have been so proud to dispense with that they final- ly chose for their leader Salisbury, who had not only no magnetism, but not even manners, The most pertinent part of Hardy’s memoir covers the thirty years from Disraeli’s reéntrance to power in 1874. The Eastern Question and Turkish War, the Berlin Conference, the Bulgarian atrocities, Afghanistan, and Gladstone’s unprecedented Midlothian campaign, are the topics that come uppermost dur- ing the earlier years of this period; Home Rule, with its collateral prob- lems, occupies the last two decades. Amid the tides and tempests of every crisis, he stood inevitably on his Tory- ism, like ‘“‘Teneriff or Atlas unremoved.” He had no doubts; from first to last the | question presented to him only one side insane or deliberately wicked; so that he seemed to himself to be thwarting the subversive efforts of hordes who had broken loose from prison or from an/| asylum. And it cannot be denied that he defended his cause as stanchly as any Crusader. Nevertheless, we fail to thrill at his devotion, not because it was not sincere, but because it was tainted with that class selfishness which is the essence of Tory, Junker, or Bour- bon ideals. Hardy, indeed, never suspected that he was not unselfish. A long experience in caste control has bred in England a peculiar form of cant. In Amer- lea your protected manufacturer can hardly restrain a smile when he de- clares in public that the protection which makes him a millionaire is whol-'. as com-| or member of one) but he was invaluable to the Pre- | He looked upon the Liberal | proposals in regard to Ireland as either | ‘ly for the benefit of the American labor- er: he knows that nobody believes that | he believes that. But in England, cant has so sunk into the very marrow of the privileged classes that some of them honestly deceive themselves in their at- titude towards politics, religion, and so- clety. Gathorne Hardy was one of |these. During his ninety-two years he never seems to have questioned the di- |vine sanction of Toryism, either as a | system, or in any of its parts. We see at once how homogeneous he was if we contrast him with Malmesbury, among the elders, or with Balfour and Curzon to-day. Liberalism and Radicalism have ‘also their special forms of cant, but these although they may be equally ob- |jectionable, are different. One of the chief charms of memoirs like this is the sidelights they throw on |public men. Much depends, however, on |the memoirist’s gift for reading char- _acter and his skill in depicting it. Hardy |} was neither subtle nor vivid. In most of his records and letters here quoted we find him using, even for expressing his inmost emotions, that impersonal, not to say sterilized style, which Eng- lish newspapers adopted long ago for reporting public speeches. Nobody would be surprised to read in the London Times that “the noble lord rose and said that he regarded it his duty, in re- ply to the Right Honorable Gentleman who had last spoken, to express the opinion boldly, but always subject to correction, if later reports from His Majesty’s Meteorological Bureau should fail to confirm his honest conviction, that it was going to sprinkle.” Thus guardedly does Hardy commune with himself in the earlier sections of his journal. It is only in denouncing Glad- stone that his language approaches the | picturesque. Every historian who aspires to know the state of mind of the un- adulterated Tory towards Gladstone—a state of mind which became an obses- sion, and greatly influenced British poli- tics—will have to read Gathorne Hardy’s criticisms of him. We hold no brief for the People’s William, but we confess that we are surprised at some of Hardy’s remarks. “Having broken in upon the principle of property, sacred, and private,” he writes, December 19, 1885, “he [Gladstone] will probably try /his hand at severing the United King- dom.” In another place, Gladstone’s |“appointments roused an instinctive ab- |horrence in every gentleman.” And again: “The conscience, which Mrs. | Gladstone assured me, always guided /him, and allowed him to sleep tran- |quilly, was not a light but a darkness, and misled him, to the permanent in- jury of his country.” (The italics are |ours.) And as a sample of the Tory’s historical acumen, we commend his con- 'trast between Bismarck and Gladstone | —“construction versus destruction. One made an Empire, the other
Page 15
June 23, 1910] The Nation. er ete | nearly destroyed one.” Nevertheless. | Lord Cranbrook, as Gathorne Hardy be- came in 1878, seems to have entertain-. ed the belief, we will not say the hope, that Gladstone might possibly get to heaven. They were, for many years, the foremost lay members of the Anglican Church, but Cranbrook was a hardhead- ed, “practical” churchman, while Glad-| stone delighted in weaving theological subtleties and in settling ecclesiastical quibbles. Quite different is Cranbrook’s verdict on Disraeli. The versatile Jew’s appar- ent flightiness and flamboyance trou- bled the “no-nonsense” Britisher a little at first; but from the moment when Disraeli became the mainstay of the Tories, and the Queen’s favorite min- ister, Cranbrook came to have an al- most unlimited admiration for him. He still maintained his private opinion in matters of detail, but, so far as ap- pears, he accepted the “Chief's” guid- ance on general policy. How little either of them really possessed the states- man’s foresight is shown by the im- mense surprise with which each beheld the shipwreck of the Tory government in 1880. Yet what could be expected of a flippant Premier who could write to his colleague on December 10, 1879: “It certainly is a relief, this drenching rhetoric has at length ceased, but I have never read a word of it.” The “drench- ing rhetoric’ was Gladstone’s Midloth- lan speeches, which drove Beaconsfield from office; yet, with characteristic in- souciance, the Tory chief and his lieu- tenants did not think they were worth paying attention to. That is the very strawberry mark of Toryism—to despise your opponent to the point of ignoring his strength; and then your enemy gives you an unpleasant shock—as the Gladstonians gave the Conservatives in 1880, as the Boers gave the British Jin- goes in 1899, and as the Germans have more recently done. Hardy’s pages give so true a picture of Tory environment that one sees clear- ly why it was that Disraeli held for twenty years the ascendency in a par- ty whose leaders should have had @ priori only distrust or contempt for a Jew, a cynical infidel, a writer of ex- travagant novels, a glib and shifty talk- er, a politician without convictions and without scruples. Disraeli possessed what they lacked—wit, mobility, audac- ity, and the art of getting returns. So a party which had floundered and gone down under the leadership of such aris- tocratic respectables as the Scotch Earl of Aberdeen and the English Earl of) Derby did well to turn to Israel for its salvation. Scores of other persons, great, small, and mediocre, are mentioned by Hardy, but very few of them stand out dis- tinctly. Most of his associates he speaks of in non-committal phrases; occasion- ally, however, as in his references to Carnarvon and to the Fifteenth Ear! of Derby, he allows his personal antipa- thy to peer out. His devotion to roy- alty was so unquestioning that he de- plored, in 1889, the niggardliness of |Parliament’s provision for the Queen's large family. “It augurs ill for monar- chy to be so thriftily treated,” he re- marks. The paradox did not occur to him that the two British sovereigns who had laid the heaviest permanent bur- dens on the British taxpayers were Charles II—the most profligate—and Vic- toria—the most virtuous. Like all other court writers of this period, Hardy takes so much care to state, in mention- ing the Queen (or the Tecks or other members of the Royal Family), that she was “most gracious,” or “most po- lite,” that one cannot help suspecting that politeness was the exception and not the rule in that circle. Once, in- deed, Hardy lets slip the interesting news that the Duke of Cambridge went to sleep at a dinner-party and that pro- ceedings had to stop until he woke up. We lay stress on the great value of these memoirs as a revelation of the highest type of English Tory in the Vic- torian era, because that is, we believe, their chief distinction. Through Ga- thorne Hardy we understand an entire species. What would we not give for a similarly exhaustive autobiographic con- fession of a Spanish grandee under Charles V, or of a Venetian procurator under Tommaso Mocenigo, or of a Ro- man patrician under the Antonines? The contribution to the political history of his time which Hardy makes is not to be disparaged; but it is of secon- dary importance compared with the bio- graphical and caste considerations. His son has so selected from his father’s mass of memoranda that we cannot fol low consecutively any event or meas ure to its conclusion. Even the records for the first months of 1878, when, as Beaconsfield wrote him on March 27, “we are drifting into war,” have so many gaps, that one must seek where in order to learn what the Tory Cabinet itself was doing. At almost every step throughout the two volumes the editor refers the reader to Morley’s “Gladstone” for a clear and fair state- ment of the matter in question. This is a deserved tribute to John Morley, but a serious defect in biographical con- struction. The humor of elucidating Hardy by means of Gladstone, whom Hardy regarded as a fearful incarnation of the Spirit of Darkness, seems to have escaped the editor’s notice. A few of the confidential letters that passed be- tween Cranbrook and his colleagues have real importance. The long private dispatch from Lytton, describing the situation in India in the summer of 1878, may be regarded as an “original source.” But, in general, the representa tive character of these memoirs gives them their highest value. else G29 In emphasizing this fact, we have nec essarily passed by some of the more personal matters. Gathorne Hardy had many excellent traits which are not the monopoly of Tories, but the possession of all sterling natures. His virtues, however, were almost exclusively prac tical. There is in the two volumes hard ly a smile, or a twinkle of the eye—and that, in spite of the Irish peasant an cestor. So, too, there are few refer- ences to books, and none whatever to ideas: but a prevailing mastery of busi ness facts and an unflagging interest in political administration. Although not born in the purple, Gathorne Hardy was predisposed to accept the aristocratic régime as the highest manifestation on earth of the Divine will. His talents and party service entitled him to a peer age, and the profits from the family iron works enabled him to accept it, in stead of his being obliged, as he tells us Monty Corry was, to rely upon a rich aunt to finance his ascent to the House of Lords. There will always be Tories, but there will be no more Tories like him. A peerage recruited from the pro prietors of yellow journals and of brew- eries, from successful promoters, and from transportation managers, has al- ready gone far towards losing that glamour which used to wrap the Brit- ish lords. Every one understands now that money is as indispensable for the maintenance of an aristocracy in Eng land as for the creation of a plutocracy in America. The first Lord Cranbrook belonged to the earlier period, when the glamour had not yet been stripped off. What that glamour was—what the ideals and beliefs were which exhaled it nowhere be more than in his Memoirs. can concretely observed CURRENT FICTION Samuel the Seeker. By Upton Sinclair New York: B. W. Dodge & Co. The childlike youth, upon whom the world dawns as an object not hitherto observed, seems to be fairly taking his place as the most popular of modern heroes of fiction. Three recent examples, notable out of many, are Mr. Locke's Septimus, Mr. Herrick’s Hugh Grant, and Mr. Sinclair’s Samuel. Between the two latter there are especially strong resemblances. Samuel, like Hugh, is a farmer’s boy, who has reached man- hood before setting out to make a liv- ing, and to learn the meaning of life, in the cities. Like Hugh, he has grown up in a state of guileless innocence of the ways of the world such as may have been possible for rustic youth before the era of the telephone and the Sunday newspaper. Like Hugh, he must be ac- cepted as the central figure in a parable, rather than a portrait drawn from the model. The day comes when, eager and in- genuous, he sets out for New York from Soaliisiadeemaneneanne
Page 16
630 his native village. He is lured into dan-| ger by the first man he meets, robbed by the second, and cast forth, penniless and starving, into the busy town of “‘Lock- This is a city built upon the sands of dishonor and selfishness. The arraignment of old man Lockman a burglar acquaintance of Samuel's be the basis for Mr. Sinclair's tale: manville.”’ by may quoted as cheating his sisters out Then he foreclosed factory and went they he down for the insurance a crooked deal with some them stock, And he had and and when bought them out had everything tired of paying of the union Then he brought and ordered some yegan by inhe ortgage ‘ the 1 the He ra lroad ritance mm a glass business say plant made people—gave rw, and got rebates inion leaders on his pay rolls on his rivals, ruined he And when he lled strire had g them ong h hand and wages he fired ind forced a strike ome strike-breakers to slug them, and turned the police and that was the end unions Meanwhile he'd politics of the town, and he’s all the got gh some thug loose on the men of the been running the 1 himself franchises. give! Nothing is omitted from the indictment of this all-round villain, And his wealth, Samuel finds, gives him power over all the supposably better element in Lock- In the end, Samuel makes up his mind to expose the rot- tenness of the place. His method is naive to the point of ludicrousness— the method of the socialist agitator— to make a speech in public. The police forbid, but, backed up by the local social- ist body, a meeting is attempted, which is quickly put down by the police, Sam- uel himself being knocked in the head by a “thug.” And so the action ends with an inconclusive street squabble which evidently seems to Mr. Sinclair a mean- ing battle for the right. Mr. Herrick’s Hugh Grant had no solution for the po- litical industrial corruption of American Mr. Sinclair's solu- tion is Socialism. manville society. and society: Taming of Red Butte Western. By New York: Charles The Francis Lynde. Scribner's Sons It little dificult to see how a self-confessed coward could be brave to go through all the dangers triala endured by Lidgerwood, su- perintendent of the Red Butte West- The author, however, is not trou- bled by this at all. He sets forth the con- dition of the railway, and then de- ascribes Lidgerwood's attempts to better Without a doubt it was much in need betterment. The engineers were desperadoes, the firemen brutes, ghouls, the dispatchers convicts. The line was laid across the Red. Desert, the chief town was named Angels, and wrecks happen- ed every day. With all that we can un- is a enough and ern if of mostly the switchmen escaped The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2347
derstand why Lidgerwood shied at the appointment, when Ford, vice-president of the system, offered it to him. He told Ford candidly he was a coward. To prove it he related his experiences at the hold-up of a stage coach, in which he was riding with the girl he loved. After the highwaymen had departed with his money and the lady’s rings, she asked why he had not shot the robbers dead with his revolver. He failed to show cause, whereupon she spoke bitter words and left him forever—or rather, for a year. But Ford still thought he could do it, and Lidgerwood spent the above-mentioned year wrestling with the Red Butte Western and his rascally subordinates. During this time, we are supposed to trace the transformation of the coward into the brave man. But Mr. Lynde’s psychology is lame. He keeps insisting on Lidgerwood’s cowardice, while he is making him do all sorts of courageous things. Not till the end, when the author realizes the responsi- bilities of the modern novelist, does he abruptly change front and admit that Lidgerwood is a hero after all. Vaurin, the Illustrious: A Translation from the French of Jean Aicard by Alfred Allinson. New York: John Lane Co. Dr. Mitchell and Mr. Hewlett were none too successful in their attempts to revive the picaro, perhaps because the one turned to eighteenth-century Italy, | “fool-errant,” the oth- French Revolution. English the great and er an to For M. Aicard has drawn something of | a picaro, too, in his woodsman Maurin; and has been better rewarded for his pains by wisely eschewing historical ro- mance. The present is his time, a cor- ner of Provence his scene. And his Maurin is the happy result: a Provencal who comes near to rivalling Tartarin. Like Daudet with his Tartarin, M. Aicard has found it profitable to devote more than one volume to his hero’s for- tunes. And such volumes! This sequel to “The Diverting Adventures” runs to more than four hundred pages. The characters in the new volume are those of its predecessor. Maurin is the same “Don Juan of the Woods” to the end, dying of a wound inflicted by the hand of woman. His anecdotes are, perhaps, a shade less piquant. The au- thor is grown almost moralistic; though when Pastouré, Maurin’s best friend, waxes metaphysical, his philosophy tis ever of the simplest: and not the less sound for that. Best of all, however, are the accounts of weddings, funerals, and political re- unions, in this vivid Southland; where men are, as Daudet expressed it, forever drunk with the alcohol of the sun. A fine, earthy story, wholly dependent upon incident and character, with no plot to speak of, but redolent of the woods and marshland where its hero fills his game-bag so easily and so well. A novel—if one may so name it—spicy with love and sport and apt escapes from constables. Mr. Allinson is to be praised for his competent Englishing of these lively occurrences. The Garden at 19. By Edgar Jepson. New York: Wessels & Bissell Co. A London bachelor who has come into a little money buys a house in Hertford Park. He soon discovers that an air of mystery hangs about the place, and that the other houses in the street, with the exception of No. 19, are empty. Strange sounds and odors, and stranger emana- tions of an indefinable nature, assail him from this garden. He finds the house is occupied by a young girl and her morose uncle. The former he, of course, falls in love with; the latter turns out to be a necromancer, from the terror of whose influence the girl is to be rescued. The subject, baldly stated, may seem rather puerile. As a matter of fact, Mr. Jepson has surrounded the proceedings of the necromancer and his group of adepts with a sense of mystery which is likely to stir a creeping of the flesh on most readers. The first coming of the terror in the invisible beast is thoroughly effective, and the rites in the garden about the statue of Pan are veiled with just the right amount of ambiguity, leaving the reader in doubt whether the effect on the performers is ithe work of hypnotic suggestion or of |some real emanation from the abyss. ' Unfortunately, the terror does not main- \tain itself quite to the end of the book.
—_—— = — —<—— — LEADING AMERICANS. | Leading American Novelists. By John Erskine. New York: Henry Holt & | Co. $1.75 net. (Leading American Essayists. By Wil- liam Morton Payne. The same. These two volumes in the Biographies \of Leading Americans do not ask to be |taken over-seriously. Dr. Erskine says ‘frankly: “In so far as each biography |pronounces any final judgment on the writer, I have tried to render the opin- ion of the best critics of to-day, rather ‘than my own impression.” And Mr. |'Payne, in his turn, asserts: “In the |preparation of the present volume, the /author has relied almost wholly upon ‘the work of his predecessors.” It would almost seem that the writers have been coached to attempt nothing original, ‘and are putting their work before the public with some nervousness lest a trace of personal bias or conviction may here and there be discoverable. This is not an attitude which can be expected to produce biography of a high order, but it is an excellent working attitude for the bookmaker. We do not know to
Page 17
June 23, 1910] The Nation. what specific audience this series is ad- dressed, but it is evidently an audience which publisher and editor wish to in- struct rather than to reason with; and a process of bookmaking, very good bookmaking, is the result. It is, perhaps, as well not to question Dr. Erskine’s choice of “leading Amer- ican novelists.” A strong emphasis on the word “American” is the key to it. But for their Americanism, and for their interest as landmarks along the relatively obscure trail of American lit- erature, Brockden Brown and Simms would appear to have no reasonable place in a book of this kind. Their works are dead: they have long been no more than material for the literary historian. Mrs. Stowe was a great pow- er, but hardly a great novelist, and Bret Harte was not a novelist at all. We may best take the book as a series of brief biographies of certain American story-writers. Whatever the choice of minor names, Cooper and Hawthorne would still stand head and shoulders above them. Taken by itself, the chapter on Brown 3 an interesting study of a man, though it does not make out very much for the author. He was not by temperament a novelist; he could neither tell a vital coherent nar- rative, nor draw a true picture of manners. That he wrote stories at all was due to his need of a medium for his speculations about life, and as Godwin had used the novel effectively to attack domestic tryanny, it was easy for Brown to exploit his psy-. chological notions through the same form. Godwin was Brown’s master and su- perior, but “Caleb Williams” would scarcely give him place in a group of leading English novelists. Brown’s real | pewer, as Dr. Erskine says, lay in his| character of publicist. “It is to his cred- it as a citizen that Brown probably never wrote without the welfare of men, especially of his countrymen, in mind.” In short, we are to cherish Brown’s memory as a bad novelist, on the ground that he was a good citizen; though his apologist would hardly include him in a study of leading American citizens. The valuable and original portions of this paper, as of the chapter on Simms, are the passages which analyze and crit- icise the more important works of these half-forgotten novelists. In the chapter on Cooper, too much space is given to the analysis of books which “every school-boy knows.” The résumé of plot is unnecessary, and the criticism, if, as we suppose, the volume is intended for the school-boy, is often over-subtle—as, for example: He makes the dim moonlit forest seem to close in upon the human adventure and supplant it; had his temperament been less sane, so much susceptibility would have endowed the northern pinewoods with sylvan deities out of hand The chapter on Hawthorne, inevitably the most important in the book, is un-| commonly good: here, certainly, Dr. Erskine belies his waiver of critical originality. The analysis of New Eng- land Puritanism, and of Hawthorne's interpretation of it in his art and em- bodiment of it in his nature, is much more than an echo or a variation. He finds the secret of Hawthorne's charac- ter and work to be “the subjective habit of Puritanism.” “The Puritan vision in him is his only reality, and by comparison the outside world seems to him a thing of phantom and allegory. He is the child of the author of the ‘Faerie Queene. ” It is doubtless be- cause of one’s interest in the writer's study of Hawthorne's life and character that one feels here especially a certain obstructiveness in the long critical analyses of the romances which so fre- quently bar the narrative. One notes a little over-severity in the treatment of “The Blithedale Romance”; but its real weakness is fairly explained. This is due, says Dr. Erskine, to the subject it- self: “Hawthorne was at home only in the moral world, and only in problems of such gravity as to involve the saliva- tion of a soul. Here there is no sin, no ancient wrong, nothing that connects itself with the idea of retribution.” Mr. Payne’s volume is furnished with an introduction of some forty pages which gives not so much a discussion of the essay in America, as a series of Who’s-Who-like sketches of the chief American essayists born before 1860. The make-up of the book proper has suf- fered greatly from the fact that it is one of a series. One must question the |editorial policy which excludes Holmes and Lowell from a book of this title, even if one agree with the doubtful premise that the place of either is pri- marily with the poets. As matters stand, the team of essayists chosen to repre- sent us (to use a vulgar figure) is neces- sarily small. It would still have been easier, however, after all concession to the poet and novelist, to find four essayists to consort with Irving and Emerson than it was to find four nov- elists to figure worthily in the same vol- ume with Cooper and Hawthorne. Mr. Payne’s style is conscientious rather than animated. He has diligently stud- ied the authorities, and here sets forth, as it were, in a fair round hand, the re- sults of his investigations. The treat- ment of Thoreau and Curtis seems fresher, largely, no doubt, because they. nave fallen less frequently into the hands of the minor biographer. Emer- son and Irving have figured repeatedly as matter for the short biography of the present type and scale; and Mr. Payne has little or nothing to add to the pic ture thrs afforded. The sketch of Thor- eau, on the other hand, is the first, or among the first, of its kind, and very good of its kind. He has the advantage over Dr. Erskine of simplicity, and by 631 dealing less iu criticism and more in biography, better fulfils, we suppose, the purpose of the series. Taken by itself, each of these brief “lives” has its ster ling qualities. i Studies. By Charles C. of Semitic Languages The University $1.50 net. The Chronicler—the author of Chron icles, Ezra and Nehemiah—is rather an imaginative reconstructor than an his torian; he transfers the ideas and us of his time (the third B.C.) to the past, and in addition freely embellishes his material. But, in Chronicles he takes material from Sam Ezra Torrey, Professor Yale University. Chicago Press. in ot ages century as uel and Kings, it is possible that in Ezra and Nehemiah also he has pre served good historical matter. This is admittedly true in the case of Neh. i-vi, out in regard to the rest of these two books there difference of opinion among critics. Holding, apparently, that the land was practically depopulat ed by the Chaldeans (2 Kgs., xxv), he represents the building of the temple and the introduction of the complete ritual law as having been accomplished by the exiles who returned from Baby lonia—and this statement is accepted as historical by the majority of critics to day. Professor Torrey’s volume is a pro test against this view. He maintains that the Chronicler was himself the author of the Ezra story (Ezr. vii-x, Neh. vii-xiii), and that his object was not to write history, but to champion the Jewish sacred institutions, especial ly against the Samaritans, who ciaimed to have a share in them; therefore, Tor rey concludes, “there was no return ot exiles, no scribe-potentate Ezra, no law brought from Babylonia, no wholesale expulsion of Gentile wives and chil dren.” The larger and more important tact elicited by this treatment of the Chronicler is that the religious develop- ment from Deuteronomy to the time of the Roman rule was continuous—the in fluence of the Dispersion on the Jews of the home-land was broadening and salutary, but “Judaism grew up in Judea, it was not transplanted from for eign soil.” As regards the continuity of the re- ligious development Dr. Torrey’s con- tention must be accepted as correct—it is proved by the great Prophetic writ ings (parts of the Second Isaiah, etc.), the book of Job, and certain psalms. It is no longer possible to make the exile a dividing fact between a higher and a lower literature. Nor there conclu sive evidence that the later legal devel opment was made in Babylonia. On this point data are lacking. And, it must be added, so far as the growth of Jewish thought is concerned, it is immateria! whether the contributions it from Judea or from Babylonia or Egypt is is to came ein i ah mt ge tl rapa
Page 18
632 The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2347 The logical and chronological disorder in Ezra and Nehemiah Torrey proposes to remedy by a couple of transpositions and insertions. First, he puts Neh, villi (more precisely vii, 70—viii, 18) be- tween Ezra viii and ix; thus the great movement for putting away foreign wives (Ezr. ix) is explained by the pub- lic reading of the law (Neh. vili), which presumably aroused the conscience of the people, and in Neh. ix is followed by a general separation between Israel- ites and foreigners. This transposition certainly makes the narrative clearer, and it is not difficult to suppose that the original order of sections may have been changed by a scribe. The other re- vision defended by Professor ‘Torrey is more revolutionary, and has given rise to much discussion: it is to insert after Ezra la passage (iv, 47b—v, 6) from the apocryphal buok known as First Esdras, Third Ezra, which (after “Darius’ has been changed to “Cyrus”) gives a detailed account of the provision made Cyrus for the building of the tem- ple, and thus fits in with the statement of Ezr. iv, 5 that adversaries hindered the building from the time of Cyrus to the time of Darius. Torrey’s view, set forth with great skill and learning, is that First Esdras is not an apocryphon, but a fragment of the old Greek trans- lation of Chronicles-Ezra-Nehemiah (a view previously held by Sir Henry Ho- worth, but elaborated by Torrey). The not affect the historical material, Ezra and First Esdras virtually identical in_ historical content. The latter, however, contains interesting story of the three youths at the court of Darius, a discussion of the question, “What is the strongest thing in the world?” This Torrey prop- as a popular story insert ed by a scribe. Probably there were in circulation different forms of the Ezra story, and one of these is preserved in First Esdras; Torrey is right in holding book properly an apo or by question does since are the erly regards that the is not cryphon To the perplexing question as to the genuineness of the royal decrees and certain letters in Ezra (all, except the decree of Cyrus in ch. 1 and the letter of Artaxerxes in ch. vil, written in Aramaic), Torrey’s answer is that they wholly the invention of the Chron- icler. The current opinion Is that they are trustworthy documents, though col ored by Jewish scribes. It is urged that they are too full of details to be inven and that no can be as for their invention. Torrey re plies that free compositions are found elsewhere in ancient historical writings (in Thucydides and Livy, for that they are quite in the Chronicler's manner (see Abijah's speech in 2 Chron. xii, not found in Kings), and that his obvious motive in inserting them was to glorify his nation representing it as honored by great tions, motive signed such example), by ' princes. In view of these facts, the pos- which was answered by about twelve sibility must be admitted that the docu- ments in question are pure inventions. On the other hand, it is equally suppos- able that they contain real historical facts, good traditions of favors shown by kings (so Artaxerxes was very friendly to Nehemiah), dramatically elaborated and dressed in Jewish lan- guage by the imaginative and clever Chronicler. Until we get a_ better knowledge of this obscure period of Jewish history it is hardly possible to decide between the rival theories. Also there is much to say in favor of the view that the second temple was built by the people who had remained in the land, and not by returned exiles; this point, however, does not affect the final result or the course of the Judean relig- ious development. In addition to these historical discus- sions Professor Torrey has done admir- able work on the Greek and Aramaic texts involved. He makes it probable that our received Greek translation is that of Theodotion, and shows that the Alexandrian codex is in the main here superior to the Vatican, which is the one generally adopted. He publishes for the first time a part of the Hexaplar text of Nehemiah. He has made a care- ful study of the Aramaic of the book of Ezra, with comparison of other Aramaic writings of the period. His concluding chapter is a suggestive sketch of the fortunes of the Jews from the deporta- tion to Babylonia down to the time of Nehemiah (586-444 ps. c.), and valuable observations are scattered throughout the volume. Whether or not all his re- sults be accepted, it remains true that his scholarly investigations offer a note- worthy contribution to our knowledge of Jewish life in the period under dis- cussion and to the criticism of a con- siderable part of the later Old ‘Testa- ment writings. Equal Suffrage: The Results of an In- vestigation in Colorado made for the Collegiate Equal Suffrage League of New York State. By Helen L. Sumner, Ph.D. New York: Harper & Bros. $2 net. The subject matter of this volume is accurately indicated in the sub-title. The investigation was undertaken under a stipulation creditable alike to the League and the author, that the inquiry |. should be prosecuted without bias and with scientific impartiality. With no “formulated conclusions” upon the ques- | tion of equal suffrage, Dr. Sumner in September, 1906, began fifteen months of field work in Colorado. The investi- gation proceeded “on the assumption that the answer to the proposition, Shall women vote? is to be found in the good or evil effects of equal suffrage The methods chiefly em- first, the issuance of a in practice.” ployed were, rather comprehensive questionnaire, hundred out of five thousand persons addressed; secondly, the examination of newspaper files, registration books, and official reports, both State and local; thirdly, the attendance upon nominating conventions and other public political meetings; and, lastly, the frequent inter- view. The good faith and scientific im- partiality of the investigator are un- doubted. She has not concealed or minimized evidence adverse to equal suffrage, although she has personally emerged with a conclusion favorable thereto, largely on the grounds that “while the effect on party politics has been slight” (p. 258), the ballot has enlarged women’s interest in public af- fairs and developed “the spirit of com- 'radeship between the sexes” (p. 260). Two questions suggest themselves af- ter a perusal of the volume: how may Dr. Sumner’s significant findings be epitomized; and how far ought these findings to weigh in assuming an atti- tude upon the whole matter? As to the first, it may be said that in Colorado, where women have had full suffrage since 1894, about 40 per cent. of the vote cast is cast by women. Their activity in the primaries is very much more limited than at the polls. Over a tenth of the men who answered the questionnaire declared that “no women attend” the primaries. Certainly, less than one-fourth of those at primaries throughout the State are women. It ap- pears, too, that political activity among the women is very much more notice- able in the cities and towns than in the rural districts. At nominating conven- tions a few women delegates frequently appear, although in this réle, as well as in the réle of nominee for elective of- fice, women are somewhat less in evi- dence than when equal suffrage was first tried. In the cities a greater per- centage of the women in the better resi- dence districts register and vote than in the slums or cheap tenement-house dis- tricts. On the other hand, “prostitutes generally vote, and their vote is cast sol- idly for the party in control of the po- lice force. This is true not only in Den- ver, but usually in Pueblo, Cripple Creek, and Trinidad, and often in other cities. Neither is it surprising to learn that the prostitutes vote not only once, but often more than once {for] registration books are most easily and unobtrusively ‘padded’ in the red-light districts’ (p. 84). So far as the influence of the women voters on politics and the resultant type ‘of government is concerned, it appears incontestable that the party managers have grown chary of nominating “men of notoriously unclean lives and men connected with saloons” (p. 47). “Out- side of the question of personal morality and relation to the liquor business women take little interest in the char-
Page 19
June 23, 1910] acter of candidates” (p. 47). Apart from these two points not a dozen of all who testified to the improvement of the char- acter of candidates by reason of equal suffrage “even so much as mentioned the standard of ability, business hones- ty, and public honor” (p. 48). Though several women have sat in the Colorado Legislature, no particular preéminence is claimed for legislation passed since i894 in the interest of women or children. Women’s property rights in Colorado had been well secur- e:l by law prior to the extension of the suffrage (p. 181). “On the social evil, too, it is impossible to see that equal suffrage has had any effect” (p. 205). On the other hand, in the administration of schools and charities women in increas- ing numbers have shown marked capac- ity as public servants. The effect of equal suffrage on the economic status of women in Colorado in the last dozen years “has evidently been slight” (p. 178). The effect of suffrage upon the character of women themselves has been imperceptible. Certain types of women, ambitious and imperious, have, at times, been prominent in politics. They have sometimes not kept aloof from corrupt political practices, such as repeating. On a list of fraudulent registrations, pub- lished in 1900 by the chairman of the Arapahoe County Republican Central Committee, there were the names of 3,- 512 men and 1,772 women (p. 85). Dr. Sumner concedes that “the one direct evil of equal suffrage” is that it imbues some women politicians with the per- nicious “tricks of the trade” (p. 258). So far as any net effect has been exer- cised by equal suffrage upon the care of the home and the children therein, it has been exiguous (p. 250). On the whole, our author is inclined to think equal suffrage has exercised a good in- fluence. It ought to be credited, we are told, with cultivating intelligent pub- lic spirit among the majority of w>2- men, with enlarging their interests, with developing in many cases public admin- istrative ability of a high order, and with broadening the comradeship be- tween men and women. How far the crucible of political ex- periment can avail to solve the issue of equal suffrage is perhaps doubtful. If our author is correct in her contention that “to fully perform, under the exist- ing system, the duties of an enfranchised citizen requires not only an inflexible moral code, but the public spirit, the self-immolation, and the unselfish devo- tion of a martyr” (p. 258), there will be some who will still incline to argue that so heavy and so universal a “public responsibility should not be laid upon the already overburdened shoulders of mothers.” Many a thoughtful citizen will echo the bull that the only weak brother he cares much about is his wife. The Colorado practice of excusing women, though legally liable, from jury service, lon the ground that “the duties of a housewife cannot be postponed during her service on a jury” (p. 129), would seem to be in point here. Upon one truth there can hardly fail to be agreement. If men are going to confer politicil power and responsibility upon women, the men voters would do well first to pro- cure both for themselves. If the condi- tions of machine politics are such that virtue has gone out of the nominal sov- ereigns; if even in Colorado, as Dr. Sumner tells us, “equal suffrage serves to show, in the most striking way, the essential rottenness and degrading character of the present [political] sys- tem” (p. 96), it should seem almost a worthless gift to convey to women this hollow shell of decayed political power. One is inevitably reminded of the young woman in class meeting who confessed that when she found her jewels were dragging her down to perdition, she gave them to her sister. Confessions of a Barbarian. By George Sylvester Viereck. New York: Moffat, Yard & Co. $1.25 net. The name of young Mr. Viereck is doubtless known to a good many read- ers of the Nation as author of certain well-advertised poems, not, as we sup- pose, very widely read, but generally un- derstood to be of rather a shocking char- acter. In the present volume he shows himself proprietor of a prose manner oddly compounded of Shaw, Chesterton, and George Moore. He _ struts, he sparkles, he belabors; he waves his cap- ital I with happy abandon in the face of a startled world. Like his great orig- inal, he disdains not the cart-tail or the drum. Bumptiousness is the god of whom, to take him literally, he is the delighted prophet. “This book,” he an- nounces with triumph, “reveals America to herself by interpreting Europe. 1 stand in symbolic relation, so to speak, to both hemispheres.” That is, Mr. Viereck was born in Germany, and en- tered this country with his teens. The book records a series of impressions evoked by a return to Europe, some doz- en years later, as an American. The timeliness of the performance is, he de- clares, no limitation—for him. The book “is journalism only in the sense in which that term may also be applied to the ‘Reisebilder’ of Heine. Only those are of all time who, like Rabelais, Cervantes, and Voltaire, are in imme- diate touch with their own time.” Cheer ed by this reflection, he goes on to state, with much enthusiasm, if less coher ence, the upshot of his present work: I urge Europe’s gospel of lead those whe follow me out of the Baby- tolerance. I lonian captivity of Puritan prejudice I have been accused of posing, because, in a world of antinomies, I am an invete- rate truth-teller, This is my flesh and blood. 1 could not more frankly denude The Nation. 633 myself in the sanctity of the Confessional! I speak with the truthfulness of Saint Au gustine, of Rousseau, and of George Moore Also, we observe, with the impudence of Shaw. Miching mallecho! let us look out for ourselves. Something a bit “racy” is, no doubt, to be divulg ed: something connected with the liber ality observed by European society in relation to—we know very well what Let us hasten to offer our tribute the form of a confession that certain in + passages in the book have revolted us not a little. We have been able to en counter without excessive perturbation the not altogether novel theory that mat ters of sex have nothing to do with mor als. But a “tolerance” which permits the poet’s fancy to busy itself ardently with the horrors of sexual perversion is a thing to be loathed. The author's command of paradox doubtless enables him to acquit himself on this head. The Kaiser is “logical, because he is illogi- cal.” So-and-so is a perfectly’ healthy man, because he is morbid; and so on. Apart from the passages in question, there is nothing shocking or even sur- prising in the book. When Mr. Viereck is able to get away from the concerns of sex he is often better than brilliant. The chapters on “The Philosophy of Mil- itarism"” and “Inspired Bureaucracy’ give a sympathetic interpretation of the German system. His pronouncements on art and life commonly fall too far short of dignity to deserve serious appraisal. There is little to be said for the critic who is pleased with himself for declar- ing: “We shall never have a full-blooded art until we develop the liaison”; or who, far less tolerably, announces: “I am fully aware that all art is a form of exhibitionism.” A History of Mediaeval Political Theory in the West. By R. W. Carlyle and A. J. Carlyle. Vol. II: The Political Theory of the Roman Lawyers and the Canonists, from the Tenth Cen tury to the Thirteenth Century, by A. J. Carlyle. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $3.50 net. The second volume of this painstak ing work is devoted to an analysis of the legal and political conceptions of the civilians and the canonists belong ing to the period under review. In Part i certain mediw#val manuals of Roman law (the “Brachylogus” and “Petri Ex ceptiones”) are referred to, and then the views of jurists of the Bologna school are given, Irnerius, Placentinus, Azo, Accursius—a mention of whose dates might assist the non-specialist reader. Mr. Carlyle discusses the sig nificance of definitions of mquitas, and justitia, which these Glossators bot rowed or adapted from Justinian’s 1)! gest; then their theory of the jus nat urale, and of slavery which existed in apparent opposition its mandates us to
Page 20
654 Next their ideas as to the source of po- authority are discursively pre- and their views forth upon the mutual relations and respec- of the ecclesiastical and secular governments and courts. Part il somewhat lengthier and treatment of like Canonists—their theory in general, of natural law, slavery, property, of secular authority, of the nature and character of canon law,and of the relations between Church In part of his volume Carlyle emphasizes two points: ‘The with the Canonists, Scrip closely contain that whe litical sented, are set tive prerogatives adds a suggestive the more matters by of of law and State this Mr first is and that the Scriptural ture us naturale so precepts, of and ordainment, related to the peremptory law God, every contravening ther emanating from a secular or an ec void—Constitu tione vel ire i naturali jure contrari@ proban penitus sunt excludendew. According which is Gratian’s, clesiastical source is ergo vel ecclesiastice secu ! vi the State: hurch belong to 1 law of the final of absolutely the expression and its of the authority are lety: 1 the church overnment the ety But to they 80OC ers of the o refuse to recog- God, from whom this lerived (p. 177). makes evident left an exposition how many things that view open to dispute ’ rhe nove 4 second is perhaps more of relations emperors point far to students mediwval kings The author says: sound, much the 80 as importance of between and the papacy It | ecessary to distinguish carefully and sometimes hasty the en incidental stre nade under ontroversy and judgments expressed in legal and other works which were compiled n cold blood and considered conclusions and represent reasoned (p 93) then proceeds to show that the state in authori He ments were embodied of canon supremacy of the papal states, and of secular which compilations the tative law, re garding church and nature rulers sintul considerably over touching the were less extreme the language for Hildebrand (before or after he be Gregory VII), or Boniface utterances power than used, example, by a by a the discuss came Vill vy home thia work volume authors of to in a later meanwhile, the conclu expec t In the sion is thus stated: And finally, we think that an examination of the subject will have made it clear that church had come to claim a tre- authority relation to the em- pire, it is not the that the church as represented in the deliberate Judgments of supreme over while the mendous in case the canon law claimed to be The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2347 the state. The norma! doctrine of the canon law down to the time of the Decretals [of Gregory IX, completed in 1234] is the same as that of the fifth and the ninth centuries, that the two authorities, the ec- clesiastical and the civil, were equally and separately derived from Christ, and that strictly each was supreme in its own sphere (p. 254). As the present volume sets forth but the first part of the argument of our authors, it would be premature to offer a decision—at least one adverse to their contention. Yet if the matter were to pe judged on the evidence given in this volume, we should say that a good deal of stress is laid upon the omission of extreme pretensions from certain papal documents, and a disclaimer is inferred from their silence, where there call to Moreover, the position counter the conclusions, or generalizations, of Dr. Otto Gierke's “Deutsche Genossenschafts- which was trans- Frederic William and made by him into that little book (multum in par- “Political Theories of the fl to 16 of the with the corre 39), bear on this was no speak. authors’ seem to section of the late recht,” a lated Maitland, wonderful entitled Middle Age.” Maitland-Gierke by vo!) Pages book, sponding notes (9 to matter. In conclusion, a duty to the craft of book-making compels a dis- approval of the way in which the pref- and some the “Texts of Authorities referred to in Volume II,” give a list, meagre enough, of modern works without stating the dates of their publication. And we must remark that the awkward language (style we cannot eall it) of the author not infrequently retards the reader's apprehension of his reviewer's ace, to extent meaning. Notes. ss of some great Theodore Roosevelt's book about his Af- rican trip, which will be published by the August, will contain some has not yet appeared in magazine form. The book wil! be a large octavo of about 500 pages. in which Scribner material Mifflin Co Citizen: yr. publishes this week The Life of Wil- by John Graham Houghton “An American liam H. Baldwin, Brooks A volume of essays on English language and literature, by members of the English Association, is for publication next autumn by the Clarendon Press, The be A. C. Bradley; the contrib utors will be Dr. Henry Bradley, Robert Bridges, Prof. W, P. Ker, Dr. George Neil- Prof. George Saintsbury, Miss Edith hel, and Prof. C. E. Vaughan. announced editor will son, 8S! \ correspondent informs us that the late Goldwin Smith left upon his death a volume of “‘Recollections,”” ready for the press. These will make a work of about the size of Mr. Smith's “United States.” 4 selection of poems from the manu- scripts which the late Father Tabb left is announced for publication next week by Mitchell Kennerley. Publication of a volume of speeches of the late Samuel L. Clemens (Mark Twa‘n) is announced by Harper & Brothers. The book will cover some forty years of his life, and will appear late this month. The Putnams announce for immediate publication “The Real Roosevelt,” a volume of selections from his speeches, arranged by Alan Warner; “The Government Ownership of Railways,”” by Judge A. Von Wagenen; and “The Commercial Power of Congress Considered in the Light of Its Origin,” by David Walter Brown. Henry Frowde announces for early pub- lication ‘“‘The Oxford Book of Italian Verse, XIIIth Century—XIXth Century,’ chosen by St. John Lucas; ‘“Wood-Carvings in English Churches. I, Misericords,” by Francis Bond’; “Selections from the Latin Literature of the Early Empire,” edited by A. C. B. Brown; and “Gesenius’s Hebrew Grammar,” edited and enlarged by E. Kautzsch, and translated by A. E. Cowley. as Henry Holt & Co. announce the addition to their foreign language texts this month of three volumes: “La Barraca,” by Ibafiez, edited by R. H. Keniston; Ludwig's “Der Erbférster,”’ edited by Morton Stewart; and a new edition, with vocabulary, of Heyse’s “Anfang und Ende,” edited by Professor McLouth. A comprehensive summary of “The Iron Ore Resources of the World,”’ which has been compiled under the auspices of the executive committee of the eleventh In- ternational Geological Congress, and edit- ed by J. G. Anderson, general secretary of the congress, is now nearly ready, accord- ing to an announcement of the publishers. The volume may be had from Lemcke & Buechner of New York. In the Geographical Journal for June, Dr. T. G. Longstaff gives an account of his recent explorations in an unsurveyed part of the Himalayas. The most important geographical results were the fixing the ex- act position of the greatest watershed in Asia—that which divides the rivers flowing to Central Asia from those which flow to India—and the discovery of a peak which to exceed Mount Everest in height. His rough observations made it ubout 30,000 feet. An American traveller, Hamilton Rice, in describing two trips on a South American river, the Uapés, in Co- lombia and Brazil, gives most interesting facts in regard to the life of the Indians living on its shores. Attention is directed by Prof. J. W. Gregory to the undeveloped wealth of northern Australia, and its fitness colonization by white races. It has tracts of fertile land, considerable and a wonderful stock- ra’sing capacity, while its magnificent harbor, Port Darwin, is only six days” voyage from the great markets of Southern China. may prove for large mineral deposits. “La Transhumance,” or the migration of sheep between their summer and winter pastures, according to A. Fribourg in the Annales de Géographie for May, has exert- ed a influence on Spain for a thousand years. Up to recent times they traversed the country in every direction by regularly prescribed routes in herds 10,000 strong, led by a mayoral. In 1347 profound
Page 21
June 23, 1910] The Nation. the owners formed a union called La Mesta, which obtained from\the government certain privileges, especially that of feed- ing their flocks in the lands adjacent to these routes. Consequently, in extensive regions agriculture became impossible, for- ests disappeared, and a large part of Cas- tile was turned into an arid desert. This privilege was taken away in 1837, and now the railways take the larger part of the “transhumants.” In this number attention is called to the opening in April of the railway connecting the capital of the Chi- nese province of Yun-nan with the sea at Haiphong, Tonkin, thereby shortening a journey of a month to two days and bring- ing within reach of the markets of the world a region rich in deposits of coal, cop- per, and tin. And interesting facts are given as to the great increase at the pres- ent time of the rubber cultivation in the Federated Malay States. There are now plantations of about 200,000 acres, with be- tween forty and fifty million trees cared for by 80,000 coolies. The Prix Delalande-Guérineau, which is at the disposal of the Académie des In- scriptions et Belles-Lettres has been divid- ed in two parts and awarded to George Doutrepont, author of “La Littérature fran- caise a la cour du Duc de Bourgogne,” and René Sturel, author of “Jacques Amyot, traducteur de Plutarque.”” Of the Prix San tour, which has been divided in portions, the larger shares have been award- ed to M. Masqueray, for his ‘Euripide et ses idées,” and to Paul Vilatte for his “Apologie d’Apulée.” several Those who have graduated from bridge to auction bridge, or are contemplating that promotion, will find help in a volume on the game, with cases and decisions by the committee of the Portland Club, reviewed and explained by “‘Badsworth.” The book is published by G. P. Putnam's Sons. Duffield & Co. have added two volumes to their complete edition of the writings of Fiona Macleod (William Sharp), brought out under the supervision of Mrs. William Sharp. The present instalment embraces the stories collected under four titles: “The Dominion of Dreams” and ‘‘Under the Dark Stars,”’ “‘The Sin Eater” and “‘The Washer of the Ford.” Mr. Sharp had before his death set about a revision and rearrange- ment of his works, and the changes, includ- ing some rather drastic omissions, now in- troduced, are in accordance with his ex- press directions. The volume of “The Sin Eater” contains the interesting introduc- tory letter written to George Meredith from Iona, in which Mr. Sharp sets forth his notion of the Gaelic spirit, and the part it is destined to play in English literature of the future. On the whole, the contents of these two volumes are rather further re- moved than were those of the first volume, “Pharais and the Mountain Lovers,” from the ordinary passions and imaginations of mankind, and strike us as less successful artistically. They are, however, a rare ad- dition to letters. We wish the word “lost” might have been omitted from the title of Horatio S. Krans’s “Lost Art of Conversation” (Sturgis & Walton), for the contents of the book no- where take so desperate a view of the art. The editor, to be sure, says in his intro- duction: “The assertions that present-day conversation has sunk far below the high levels of the talk of the past; that our con- versational performances are flat, thin, and poor; and the even more sweeping asser- tion that conversation is indeed a lost art —these are commonplaces that challenged, and can hardly be The book is made up of essays versation by Bacon, Swift, De Quincey, Mahaffy, Hazlitt, and Stevenson. It would hardly be maintained that conversation has become a lost art since the day of Hazlitt and De Quincey. The latter, in the essay here published, plainly treats conversation as an art still in its infancy. It had, he argues, hitherto lacked the regu- lation of which other arts had the ad- vantage: gainsaid.” on con- gradually regulate A corresponding change will take place in the usages which conversation. It will come to be consid- ered an infringement of the general rights for any man to detain the conversation, or arrest its movement, for more than a short space of time—which gradually will be more and more defined. This one curtail- ment of arrogant pretensions will lead to others. In the preface to his treatise on “The Principles of the Art of Conversation,” Professor Mahaffy states it as one of his qualifications that he lives “in a country where the practice of it is confessedly on a high level, and where the average man is able to talk well.” Clearly, it does not occur to him that it may be a dead art of which he is about to discourse. Hazlitt, in the papers here reprinted, speaks of conversation as if it were a stable thing in all ages, chiefly varying in quality in accordance with the classification of the speaker—author, lord, or what not And in the three essays by Stevenson, which bring the gestion volume to a close, there is no that the of phrase which, to be sure, he does not use) obsolete But the title of the collection is less important than the essays themselves. Mr. Krans has supplied a good text, and in his introduction has a few appropriate comments to make upon a somewhat casually assembled group. sug art conversation (a is or obsolescent. The career of “Edward Bulwer, First Ba ron Lytton of Knebworth,” has the elements that go to make an interesting book, and these have not been neglected by T. H. S. Escott in the volume now published by E. P. Dutton & Co. Bulwer’s novels, if publishers’ figures are a proof, have by no means lost their favor with the larger pub- lic, but they are probably little read by those to whom a solid biographical study like this of Mr. naturally appeal. Toward the close of Bulwer’s liter- ury career Routledge (the London publisher of the present biography) paid £20,000 for a ten years’ right of producing nineteen of his novels in cheap form; and the ventur many 0j Escott’'s would was a success. Such a transaction we can understand, but it igs not so easy to-day to put one’s self in the place of an in telligent critic like Plumer Ward, who said of Bulwer: “He most accomplished writer of the accomplished English letters, styles of composition, poet, historian, moral philosopher is the most in practising all novelist, era classes and dramatist, essayist critic, political pamphleteer—in each su perior to all others, and only each by himself.” Critical readers younger generation are, on the contrary likely to forget the large amount of genuine entertainment his books provide. rivalled in of a too pass un-, — ee at mami 635 and to overlook the fact that, with all the melodrama and despite the cheapness of tone that mars so much of his work, the pages of “My Novel’ and its companions are packed with the shrewdest remarks on politics and life in general ’ In hic biography Mr. Escott gives a full account of Bulwer’s political career, with a sufficient number of anecdotes. Perhaps the most entertaining of these is the rs mark of Disraeli when at Bulwer's house he was asked to take Mrs. Wyndham Lewis down to dinner. “Oh,” was the answer of Mrs. Lewis's future devoted hus and, “anything rather than that insufferable wo man But Allah is great.”” The polit'cal careers of Bulwer and Disraeli were not without resemb‘ances, but their matrimor ial ventures were sufficiently diverse M Escott naturally, and no doubt purposely takes the part of Bulwer in the long dis he called his marriags Perhaps, howevet the character of Bulwer on this side was not fairly presented without some mens of the superlatively foolish 8 to his wife, which Mr. Escott virtually gnores rhe most interesting part of the book is that which gives the youthful years of Bulwer with their broken educatio | nelodramatic pa on Phe child i ase was truly father of the nove rhe Univer of Berlin ia I ator letter on the fiftieth anniversa f the late Prof. Philip Schaff career a a icher, pronounced h Histor Christian Church” ‘“‘the most notabl nent of universal histor:cal learn duced by the school of Neandet Lr ff lid not live to complete the work, ant it was left for his son, David 8. Scha fessor of church history in the Ws n rheological Seminary of Pittsburgh, to treat the period from 1050 to 1517 rhi filial duty he has now performed, a former vol ume, published in 1907, having covered the per.od to 1294, and the present volume (‘V, Part ii; Scribner) bringing the narrative to the opening of the German Reformation rhe son has written in the manner of the father. There is the same wealth of fact the same caution of opinion, the same mild Protestant prejudice, the same _ graphi characterization of periods and persons with parallels from all ages. The historian is still of the “school of Neander,”’ not of the modern scientific historians. One does not find new judgments of men or move ments, based on newly discovered documents or new interpretations of the sources, but there is always wise selection of the best judgments wrought by others The period treated is that of the decline and corrup tion of the papacy, the reformatory coun cils, the great mystics, the early reformers ind the Renaissance The bibliographical references are full and valuable, the vol- ul has a good index, and is published in t! stvle of the series to which it belongs In the New International Year Book for 1909 (Dodd, Mead & Co.) we find a work adapted to the uses of the newspaper office as well as the general reference library It is a bulky volume of nearly 800 quarto pages, and it makes good use of its gens ous elbow room of nearlya millionwords. An exception, however, is the article on Polar Research, which, in view of the dramatic and essential importance of the facts it has easily have been two We atill find the r or ost to record, might three times as long
Page 22
valuable single feature in the historical for the year accompanying the articles on the States and foreign countries. If vigorous precautions be taken against error, these summaries are bound more valuable from year to year, file of the International Year Book will serve the historian as appreciably as long chain of Appleton’s Annuals now Specialized tables like those given Necrology under Gifts and Be- particularly useful. Packard, in his Paths” Maynard & Co.), the oncoming of spring with the trying im- perturbability of the professional nature lover. He sees muskrats and crows fighting for their lady loves, dates you the return- ing birds by the calendar, greets the moths and butterflies by their Latin names. All this he does with a certain whimsicality and humor, but the stride of his fancy is pretty and the little book contains long, tedious passages to all who are not en- thralled at the budding of simple prim- roses or the antics of “Grapta interroga- But, of course, the book is in- tended for the devout observer of times and For him it even provides several index well stuffed with birds, beasts, insects, trees, herbs, and flowers. The uninitiated, if, indeed, any one has escaped the teaching of the “how-to-know” books, will find more to their purpose a capital sketch about the manly art of bob- bing for eels, terization of grotesque young night-herons unadvisedly adopted as pets. tang to these things that we miss when the author muses on clouds and butterflies, He conveys an enormous deal of nature, to be sure, but usually with rather slight personal contribution of imagination. Six pen drawings, by Charles Copeland, have a pleasing old-fashioned quality, To all ap- pearances they might have come out of the portfolio of some patriarch of the Hud- River School summaries only to grow and the the extinct under and quests aré “Woodland describes Winthrop (Small short, tionis.” seasons. pages of son The last publication of the Pali Society is by Mrs, Rhys Davids, entitled of the Sisters” (Henry Frowde), be'ng verses attributed, in the tradition of the Pall Canon to certain eminent sisters (Ther!-Bhikkhunis) of the Buddhist Order, and forming the second and smaller portion of the work known as Thera-theri-githa a * the Elders, Brethren, and Sisters), which wag first committed to writ- 80 wn. c. In her labors Mrs. Rhys Davids has derived great assistance from the Commentary of Dham- mapfila of KAficipura, and it is because the MSS that on the psalms of the Bro- and harder to the Theri-githé, not wish to invert the ancient order, a volume “Psalms verses of ing in as a trans- lator of the first part of this work Thera-gatha, or there--are less numerous obtain than those on from any the latter division, has been put While plous Buddhist, any longer believes that that this into English earlier no one, not even the ; these poema contain the actual words of the n to whom they are ascribed, or that the Bhikkhunis in question conversed in Pall the registering for us the thoughts and aspira- wor sliokas, they are none less valuable as tions which large congregations of bel'evers for centuries ascribed to saintly build- of ideals, and forming of a which has for so long riod holy Al- the and have ers-up certain as part literature a pe been revered as writ low'ng for variations in history or an amusing charac- | There is a) The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2347 temperament of the heroine, the theme of these poems is everywhere the same. It is the thanksgiving of the enlightened, the joy- ous utterances of one who “having made a (to escape the round of rebirths) under former Buddhas, and heaped up merit in this and that state of becoming,” has under this Buddha dispensation severed herself from earthly ties, has overcome all unholy desires, and, having attained to “thorough knowledge of the Norm in form and meaning,” has Nirvana already within her grasp. Mrs. Rhys Davids’s rendering is masterly—in places it reflects what seems to be very fine poetry—and her notes and introduction sustain her high reputation as a scholar. resolve “En Haiti” (A. Colin, 380 pages, 32 pho- totypes, 2 maps, 5 francs), by Eugéne Aubin, is the well-written description of present-day Hayti by an experienced trav- eller who had eighteen months’ close ob- servation in the interior of that not easily accessible island. To this the author joins a minute knowledge of the colonial history; and he writes with the personal photo- graphic sprightliness of French corre-| spondents. Landscapes, fétes, Voodoo wor- | ship, the manner of common life, are vivid- ily and authentically portrayed. “Les Finances des cités grecques” (H. Champion, 315 pages, 7 francs), by Henri Francotte, professor in the University of Liége, is a collection of learned studies | which show agreeably that Greek cities, | quite like our own, were not without their money worries. The taxes of the au- | tonomous cities are first explained, includ- | ing separately the Hisphora at Athens; | next, subject or allied cities; then finan- | | cial administration as organized, and in its | |history from Pericles and the Pelopon- | nesian war down to the third century B. c., with a special chapter on the finances | of the temple at Delphi; a few pages of | conclusions regarding the effect of finances | on Greek history; and a good index of proper names, subjects, and Greek words. | journalist, died on Monday in New York city, aged seventy- nine years. He contributed social and financial articles to the Sun for many years, signing hims®lf “Matthew Marshall,” and was author of one book, “Unhappy Loves of Men of Genius.” Thomas Hitchcock, John Austin Stevens, founder and some- time editor of the Magazine of American History, died at Newport, R. L, last week, aged eighty-three years. Mr. Stevens was graduated from Harvard in the class of 1846. He was active in public affairs at the time of the civil war, and was elected secretary of the Chamber of Commerce in While in this office he had charge publication of the colonial records of chamber, and was, some years after- ward, elected librarian of the New York Historica] Society. Always interested in the affairs of patriotic societies, he found- ed, in 1876, the order of the Sons of the Revolution, and one year later the Maga- rine of American History, which he con- tinued to edit until 1882. Mr. Stevens wrote yn the colonial and Revolutionary | history of this country. His principal works are “Memoirs of George. Gibbs, Li- brarian,” “Progress of New York in a Century,” “The Burgoyne Campaign,” “The Expedition of Lafayette Against Arnold,” ‘The French in Rhode Island,” “Memoirs 1862 of the much of William Kelby, Librarian,” “New York City in the Nineteenth Century,” and the “Life of Albert Gallatin.” Sir William Butler, writer of many books of travel and adventure, died last week in Ireland, aged seventy-two years. His writ- ings, which enjoyed great popularity among English readers, were a historv of the Sixty-ninth Regiment, “The Great Lone Land,” “The Wild North Land,” “Red Cloud, the Solitary Sioux.” “Far Out,” “Akim-Foo, the History of a Failure,” “Life of Gordon,” “Life of Sir Charles Na- pier,” “The Life of Sir George Pomeroy- Colley,” “From Naboth’s Vineyard,” and “The Light of the West.”’ Julius Wolff, the popular voet of the school of Victor Scheffel, died recently in Charlottenburg, at the age of seventy-two. He wrote many military poems, besides his lyrical verses. Among his works are the “Rattenfanger,” “Till Eulenspiegel Redi- vivus,” “Wilder Jager,” “Der Raubgraf,” “Das Recht der Hagestolze,” and “Die Hohkénigsburg.”’ Georg, Freiherr von Oertzen, died recent- ly in Freiburg im Breisgau. He wrote ex- tensively, but was best known for his poems and satires, some of which are “Aus Kiam- pfen des Lebens,” ‘Deutsche Triaiume, Deutsche Siege,”’ “Lieder und Leute,”’ and “Zwischen Runen und Rogen.” Science. Rara Arithmetica: A catalogue of the arithmetics written before the year MDCI, with a description of those in the library of George Arthur Plimpton of New York. By David Eugene Smith of Teachers College, Columbia Univer- sity. Boston: Ginn & Co. $5.50 net. The collection of fifteenth and six- teenth century arithmetics owned by George A. Plimpton of New York is the largest of its kind ever made, not ex- \cepting the famous private libraries once owned in Italy by Libri and Prince Bon- ‘compagni. Professor Smith has made a genuine contribution to the history of science by cataloguing and describing the books in this collection, stating briefly their contents, and adding a list of other arithmetics published before 1601. Altogether 550 different works are mentioned, which aggregate to about 1.200 books, if all the editions are in- cluded in the count. Besides this, a large number of manuscripts on arithmetic are catalogued and described. It is the most complete bibliography of eariy arithmetics yet attempted. The volume as a whole is a remark- ably fine example of the modern art of book manufacture. There are nine plates, illustrating certain interesting parts of manuscripts and books, Moreover, the title pages of the more prominent texts are reproduced by photography, as are also many pages illustrating the nota- tion and the methods of computation in use during the Renaissance. Not only is this publication of inter-
Page 23
“June 23, 1910] The Nation. est to teachers and lovers of old books, but it contains material which will be - of marked service to the historian. Thus, a book of 1483 contains a passage be-| lieved to be the first reference to a slate. The rhyme beginning -days hath September” is given in Latin as early as 1488. A very close approach to the invention of decimal fractions, which are usually attributed to Stevin (1585), occurs in a book dated 1492. There appears duction the finger symbolism for num- bers, published by Paciuolo in 1494. Pas- cal’s arithmetical triangle, so-called, is shown in an engraving made a century before Pascal. One pnotograph exhibits symbols which may throw some light on the disputed origin of the dollar sym- bol, $. The reader may, at times, wish that Professor Smith had given a still great- er variety of arithmetical detail, even if some facsimile illustrations of title pages had been forced out in conse- quence. Bibliographically the title page may seem the most important page of a book for facsimile reproduction, but historically the case may be quite dif- ferent. We have looked in vain, in this volume, for an illustration of the old “scratch method” of extracting square and cube roots. Professor Smith exam- ined the mathematical works of Maurol- ycus, but, by confining his attention to elementary matters, he missed the capi- tal discovery that in this book occurs for the first time (so far as now known) the method of “mathematical induction,” a method of vital interest, which has been variously attributed to such later writers as Kaestner, Jacob Bernoulli, Fermat, and Pascal. No doubt many such points will be brought out in a work on the history of arithmetic during the Renaissance, which Professor Smith has now in preparation. Wilhelm Ostwald reiterates in the intro- duction to his new work, “Die Entwicklung der Elektrochemie” (Leipzig: J. A, Barth), his theory that “the history of the sciences offers the best and most authoritative ma- terial for the study of law in the evolution of mankind.” The history of science, as Professor Ostwald sees it, is not merely history for history's sake, but a new method of study, a new way of getting at the re- sults of research. The nineteenth century was too full of creative work in the var- ious fields of science to give historical studies their full play. The new century, on the other hand, though it has achieved already some very remarkable results in the way of positive additions to our knowl- edge of the forces of nature, will offer a larger field for historical studies, for the reason that the practical value of such studies will be more clearly demonstrated. | The author deprecates the idea that pure science can have no connection with life. The great investigators, he says, “were al- | most without exception in their younger days passionately enthusiastic over some concrete, practical aim, and it was in the course of the further and higher develop- “Thirty | in photographic repro-| | nent of these problems (which indeed fol- | lowed rapidly one upon the other) that they themselves attained a wider and higher point of view. The tree of knowledge raises its crown high in the ether of pure science, but it is rooted in the firm ground of hu- |}man needs and activities.” Electrochem- istry is particularly adapted to the sub- ject of historical study in this sense. Its history is not yet more than a century old, and it has received a powerful impetus from men still living. Its documents are all easily available, and require no special lin- guistic or diplomatic :riticism in order to be unearthed and interpreted. Further- more, its technical importance is evenly balanced with its scientific. In an inter- esting paragraph the author sets up against each other the great books, works of men of genius, and the text-book writers who usually are men of moderate stature. We find, he says, so much in the original works of the great scientists that has not become part and parcel of the text-book litera- ture. The selective work of the text-book writer is the result of his deliberate judg- ment, and the mere fact that he has profit- ed by the advance of science does not nec- essarily give him the requisite critical faculty. He acts as a sieve which retains the wheat but lets the gold sand slip out. “La Vie du language” (A. Colin, 210 pages, 3.50 francs), by Albert Dauzat, reasons very readably about the various evolutions of sounds and words, the psychological and so- cial phenomena with which they are con- nected, and their literary influences. The book goes from phonetics, Greek and Roman formations, the “noble” style, to popular reactions. One of the latest of these was the Parisian common people's effort to pro- Wilbur Wright, resulting in ‘“‘vil- burétt” which they promptly turned to ‘vieille burette” (old oil-feeder) The Janssen gold medal has been award- ed by the Académie des Sciences to W. W. Campbell, director of the Lick Observatory, nounce in California. The Prix Boudin, of 3,000 francs, goes to 1. G. Chauveaud, for the “Etudes sur les tissus des plantes vascu- laires”; the Prix Hébert to Professor Bar- billon of Grenoble, for his works on elec- tricity; and the Prix Lalande to Messrs Cowell and Crommelin for their work on Halley’s comet. Drama and Musie. “Glass Houses’”’ is the title finally chos- en for the adaptation of the ‘“‘Connais-toi” of Paul Hervieu, made by Kenneth Barnes, and recently produced in the Londouw Globe Theatre with a fair measure of suc- cess. Robert sonian Comedies at Arthur’s revival of the Robert- the London Coronet Theatre has begun, apparently very suc- cessfully. The first piece, “M. P.,”" had a most cordial reception and seems to have been well acted. Cyril Maude, the well-known English comedian, is to try his hand at Rip Vau Winkle. He is a player of intelligence, humor, and delicacy, and therefore has some obvious qualifications for the under- taking. An entirely new stage version ol | Irving’s tale will be made for him—by ‘Austin Strong—in which special stress will 637 be laid upon the preternatural scenes in the Catskills. There certainly ought to be no difficulty in making a better play than the bit of dramatic patchwork employed by Jefferson, but Jefferson's Rip himself was a creation which is not likely be equalled, let alone improved upon to Lewis Waller will make his first appear- ance here in September in “Henry V." His impersonation of that gallant monarch is said full of nobility and eloquence Old playgoers will remember the popularity which George Rignold won in the part thirty-five ago. Richard Mansfield, actor higher degree, was far successful it Mr. Waller will! several other plays with him. to be years of in less bri an ng The revival of Henry Arthur Jones's com- edy, ‘“‘The Case of Rebellious Susan,” at the London Criterion Theatre been a decided success. Sir Charles Wynd- Sir seems to have ham is once more seen at his best as Richard Kato, Mr. Bishop is as richly hu- morous as ever as the old Admiral, while Miss Mary Moore resumes her old part of Lady Susan Harrabin with all the old effect. Owing to the demand from many parts of Great Britain, the colonies, and America from persons who were unable to witness the annual Shakespeare birthday celebra tions, it has been decided to hold a sum- mer festival at Stratford-upon-Avon of three weeks from July 25 to August 13. Mr and Mrs. F. R. Benson and their Shake spearean company will present many oft plays of Shakespeare, several being given in the open air “The Piper,”’ the priz play by Josephine Preston Peabody, will be produced on Wednesday, July 27, it been postpone l M +) original production having wing to the death of King Edward Marion Terry part of Veronika has been engaged for The festival programm: will also include concerts—arranged by Mr and Mrs. Albert Mallinson—Morr lar ountry dances, folk songs, and old Eng- lish games. The Irish Abbey Theatre Company has been drawing good audiences and attract ing much favorable critical attention at the London Court Theatre, but some of their pieces are puzzling even to the most ardent admirers. They show a irift toward the merely extravagant oi: grotesque—a common weakness of such or- ganizations. In their plays of peasant life they are almost always delightful their more ambitious efforts they are le happy. The scene of one of their latest pro ductions—“‘The Glittering Gate,’’ by Lord Dunsany—is laid in hell, whence wo burglars, one killed during a robbery and the other hanged, break into heaven; only to find it empty space. Another pla) “Harvest,” by 8S. L Robinsor pur porting to be a study of the effects of bad system of education upon 4 particular family, seems to be too extravagant, de- pressing, and illogical, to be valuable either as entertainment or suggestion “The Eloquent Dempsey,” by William Boyle, a study of modern municipal poll- tics, in which the hero strives to be all things to all men and is finally repudiated by everybody, is described as an amusing piece, full of native humor, but somewhat deficient in variety and action. ‘The Image,” a three-act comedy, by Lady
Page 24
638 Gregory, relates to the determination of a group of village gossips to devote certain be raised by the sale of two to the erection of an image. While matter, one whale is appropriated by and the other washed away The plot the thinnest thing in the world, but the characterization to be money to whales, they the rivals, are debating is is sald admirable. The tion Pre decree by French minister of public instruc- ind of fine arts has submitted to the { the republic for signature a virtue of which the “reading of the Comédie Francaise, which abolished in 1901, is to be re- established For the last nine years the of accepting or rejecting new plays vested the director of the The committee is to consist of gular members and two deputy mem- new plays under director. The ten to comprise the six managing commit- together with two the general body of two senior female mbers of the It is provided that it least seven members, in addition to the president, must be present at meetings of committee. New plays are to be read either by the author himself or by his rep- by a member of the com- in the presence of the author, if sires to attend. The committee will ss its views by ballot, and the presi- lent will have a casting vote. The aboli- tlon of the reading committee constituted of the grievances which M. le Bargy as reason for his resignation Francaise. Le Drame au XVIIIe siacle” (A. Colin, 600 pages, 12 plates, 10 francs), by ’. Gaiffe, docteur és lettres, is a very com- study of an important subject in the history of French literature, It begins from the decadence and transformation of tragedy and comedy in the eighteenth century; the nfluence of foreign literatures, and the so- il reated by ident committee” Was power has been in the ten re bers, the atre consider of the members are members of the of the theatre, socictairesa elected by the will sidency who pre regular tee the fellows, and me socle ty the resentative, or mittee he de expr one illeged the a from Comédie en France plete “Drame"™ party to soften origins of the a new genre the philosophic ind moralize bourgeoisie and people by pre- senting to them touching scenes from their adventures. The second part takes up hronological order the history of this from the “Fils naturel” and Diderot as leader of a school to transformation of the Comédie Italienne proclamation of the liberty of thea- The third part studies the mat- “Drame” philosophic and characters, portrayal of senti- sensibility (that eighteenth century liscovery); its scenes of contemporary so- ty, historical truth, and local color. The fourth and last part deals with the form of romance, wh lramatt (li the and the in 1791 of the leas ; aqenre, tre ter its moral ment the “Drame”"’—its classic rules, and mingled tones; the verse, language, and tyle; the representation, declamation, pan- ime, costumes, and stage decoration, and a summing up of ite Influence on melodrama it, and its success in foreign countries; ite connection with ro- mantic drama and modern comedy, and four complete indexes. ton which sprang from William R. Chapman announces that the next Maine Music Festival will open in Bangor on October 6 and close at Portland later. The list of soloists in- six days The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2347 ' telle Harriss, Mary Desmond, Pearl Bene- dict, Luigi Samolli, besides Cecil Fan- ning who sang also at last year’s festi- val. The programmes will be made up largely of excerpts from operas—‘‘Lohen- grin,” “Samson and Dalila,” “Carmen,” ‘Mefistofele,”” “Queen of Sheba.” Italy’s leading opera house, the Scala of Milan, kept its doors open the past season considerably longer than usual. Formerly the season always ended with the carnival; this time it extended even beyond Easter day, the object being to reduce the deficit, which in the previous operatic year had been 270,000 francs. This sum was reduced to 100,000 francs by the extra spring performances. The outlook for the future is encouraging, as the city fathers have voted to increase their annual con- tribution from 60,000 francs to 150,000, for a period of eight years. The chief dimi- culty is the scarcity of singers, as the best continue to migrate to North and South America, where salaries are high. class conductors also are becoming scarce, the music-lovers of Milan mourn the loss of Vitali, who has gone to Buenos Ayres. The number of performances given during the past season at the Scala was seventy- two. Only eight operas were included in the repertory. “La Damnation de Faust” led with 15 representations, followed by “Sonnambula” with 13, ‘“‘Walkiire” 12, “Medea” 11, “Samson and Dalila” 8, “L’Africaine” 8, “Rhea” 3. Two perform- ances were also given of “Margarete,” a new by Alfred Briiggemann, whose music suggests, it is said, the influence of Puccini, Strauss, and Debussy. opera Art. A Catalogue Raisonné of the Works of the Most Eminent Dutch, Flemish, and French Painters, Etc. By John Smith. Eight volumes and supple- ment: A textual reprint of the orig- inal edition, imported by E. P. Dut- ton & Co. $25 net. In the year 1839, John Smith, picture dealer of London, published tentatively with one of the longest title-pages on record the first volume of this remark- able catalogue. Its usefulness was ap- parent, and volume succeeded volume until the series was concluded by a sup- | His aim was to in-| plement, in 1842. clude only important artists and paint- ings of a certain consequence. His taste was that of his time. he disregarded all Dutch painters be- fore Rembrandt, and all Flemish paint- ers before Rubens. Of the French school only three French masters seemed wor- thy of record, Poussin, Claude, and Greuze. diligence was extraordinary. He con- sulted thoroughly the sales catalogues lof the seventeenth and eighteenth cen- turies, thus catching many pictures be- fore the dispersion of the old galleries. He travelled much, and watched closely the greatest picture market of the cludes Alma Gluck, Marie Rappold, Es- | First- | Systematically | Within his chosen limits his | So faithful was his search that even now, after seventy years, of the artists whom he treats only one work out of five, on a rough average, escaped his notice. We have said his taste was limited. Frans Hals did not seem an artist impor- tant enough to be fully listed. Vermeer of Delft makes a bare appearance as an imitator of De Hooghe and as a painter of street scenes. Several of the signed works of this incomparable artist are set down to the mediocre Eglon van der Neer. To do Smith justice, Vermeer impressed him; considering the scarcity of works by this painter, he writes: “It is quite inexplicable how he attained the excellence many of them exhibit.” Yes, Smith’s taste was pretty restricted, but a narrow taste may be remarkable within its range. Smith’s was that. His observations on the quality of the Dutch little masters are as keen as they are unpretentious. It would be an interest- ing exercise to note the many instances in which he has anticipated the crit- icisms of Taine and Fromentin. He was not merely an excellent connoisseur, but an enthusiast; and it still is a comfort- | ing thing to dealer or collector to be able to identify a favorite picture as “Smith, No. —,” and to quote a word of praise. He came upon the end of an exclusive enthusiasm. Before his catalogue was finished a little book, called “Modern Painters,” by a “Graduate of Oxford,” had, though no one knew it, announced a new period of taste. Still, the half- gods with whom Smith chiefly dealt sur- vived the coming of the primitive gods, and his work is still valuable enough amply to justify this handsome reprint. Not that the catalogue is ideal. Smith himself frankly admitted its limitations. Frequently, the measurements are only approximate. Sometimes the ambiguous “right” and “left,” that bugbear of cata- loguers, makes trouble. Signatures are neither facsimiled nor located on the pictures. But with all its faults it re- mains the completest census we have of a national school. The reissuing of a standard work of reference of this sort is always some- ‘thing of a poser for a publisher. He is under pressure to revise it and bring it up to date. Unquestionably, if a con- noisseur of, say, Dr. Bode’s competence would give us a revised and enlarged Smith, tracing the fates of the pictures, and adding the works and the artists that were omitted—such a catalogue would be invaluable. On the other hand, such a revision could be undertaken with more confidence twenty years from now, on the basis of monographs on the single artists. Within the short mem- ory of the reviewer at least ten unlisted ‘pictures by Frans Hals have been pub- lished. Evidently, the situation as re- world, London. ‘gards the painting of the Low Coun- ‘tries is still fluid, and no list made now ‘could pretend to definitive character.
Page 25
June 23, 1910] The Nation. wknicl. — Accordingly, the publishers, avoiding | querade is often a dignifier. Miliais could the temptation of partial revision, which have been a better is generally worse than none, have sim- ply reprinted textually the original cat- alogue, bringing it into the more con- venient form of nine volumes, and add- ing, beside the original engraved illus- trations, an excellent photogravure for nearly every artist mentioned. It is a minor defect that the location of these paintings is not given. however, are in famous galleries and Most of them, | Baron Leys had he chosen to take the pains. His elaborate confections are always engaging after the friendly fashion of Leigh Hunt's “Fran- cesca da Rimini” or Tennyson's “Princess.” But the root of self-discipline was rarely in the man, and he breaks the level surface of British pictorial] achievement only in virtue of a technique which after all was not superlative. We think the future will value the few fine drawings he made for ‘engraving longer than it will his pictures readily recognizable by those interested. | Since the origina! edition is both scarce and dear, this seemly reprint, with its white labelled backs, is very welcome. These extra tall octavos would lend themselves to the purposes of the extra- illustrator, and, in fact, the serious éstu- dent of the painting of the Low Coun- tries could probably take no better course than to make this catalogue the | basis of an album. A committee, headed by Lawrence Alma Tadema, asks subscriptions to a memorial fund with which to purchase from the ex- ecutors works of the late John M. Swan, for presentation to the British people, through the National Art Collections. The committee wishes to place several exam- ples of Mr. Swan's drawings or paintings of animal life in the British Museum, the Tate Gallery, and perhaps elsewhere. Sub- scriptions will be gratefully received by J. C. J. Drucker, No. 24 Grosvenor Street, London, W. “Sir J. E. Millais, P.R.A.,” by J. Eadie Reid, is the latest addition to the “Makers | of British Art” (Scribner importation). It is conceived in a mood of excessive and un- modulated enthusiasm and is commonplace ‘in style. The method is annalistic with one or two semi-critical chapters to top off with. If one wants pretty much all the facts about this eminently British master, here they are. Mr. Reid, as a brother paint- er, holds firmly to the faith that Millais’s development was perfectly normal and tem- peramental. There is no question of a great refusal of Pre-Raphaelite faith, or of recreancy. Here the fellow worker sees more clearly than most critics. The Pre-Raphael- As an illustrator of Tennyson and Trollope he was ideal. His line was singularly ex- pressive, his method concise and austere. A discipline was forced upon him from without by the requirements of old-style wood-cutting. One almost regrets a pros- perity that made this work exceptional As a man he is a very amiable and charac- teristic figure. He represents that facile sympathy and quick response to obvious sentiment which England gladly accepts as an equivalent for artistic inspiration. He was the commen man’s ideal of a great artist, and his gift was specific enough to content the critics, large enough in fact to suggest that had any capacity for self- 'eriticism been granted him he might indeed ite gospeller Holman Hunt caught Millais— at a young and impressionable age. Mil- lais succumbed, as at seventeen a sym- pathetic lad will to any stronger nature. | It was mere luck that he trooped with the) Pre-Raphaelites. But for this fortuitous enthusiasm he would have placidly started in to be the continuer of Sir Thomas Law- rence in portraiture, of Stothard in illus- tration. When he came to man’s estate he shook off a false entanglement and followed his star. Possibly he had gained something by the minute naturalism of his apprentice- ship, but we th x not much. His gift lay elsewhere, and was of an essentially insular sort. Outside of England his pictures look oddly insignificant. With the technical fa- eility of the eighteenth century masters he united a peculiarly Victorian sentiment, fresh, unsophisticated, and without distinc- tion. Essential seriousness was denied him at all times. His juvenile pictures are his best, simply because his kind of nature is chastened by the requirement of an elabo- rate and painstaking make-believe. Mas- have become a great painter. The present volume gives many details as to date, own- ership, and even prices of his pictures, and is illustrated with twenty-one cuts. Finance. THE AUTUMN MONEY MARKET. No one who reads, marks, and inward- ly digests the New York bank state- ment can fail to discover what the mat- ter is with the financial situation in the United States. It is doubtless comfort- ing to be told that last week the surplus reserve of the New York banks was materially larger than for any corre- sponding period in ten years, with two exceptions. But there is a fly in the oint- ment, for these exceptions were 1904 and 1908. The first half of 1904 and the whole of 1908 were periods of hard times when money piled up in the banks for want of confidence. Obviously 1910 is not without resemblance to two and six years ago. But even more interesting as an ob- ject of study than the surplus reserve is the variation in the total amount of specie and legal tenders held by the banks—that is, in the amount of law- ful reserve money. At the close of busi- ness last Saturday, the New York Clear- ing House Banks held in round numbers $327,500,000 of gold, or its equivalent, as against $382,200,000 on June 19, 1909. That is, they had something like $54,- 700,000 less money for reserve purposes than twelve months earlier, and, as a consequence, they had almost $220,000,- 000 less deposits. Other things being equal, this would imply that they had reduced their outstanding loans by vir- tually $220,000,000 also. But, as a mat- ter of fact, they cut them down by only’ about $147,000,000. Obviously their loan item has in the first half of 1910 eaten much more heavily than usual into their capital and surplus. The loss of $54,700,000 gold in the past year is easily accounted for—the metal has gone abroad. On the face of it, this is not a light matter. In the first place, there is. no evidence that the country has derived any general benefit from buying more than it sold abroad; for that is what the movement amounts to, virtually none of this $54,000,000 being sent out for the purpose of bringing back interest. A large part of it, no doubt, represents unproductive expendi ture. The long and short of the matter is that our manner of life has been such during the past year as to cut into our principal, and we have had to borrow of Europe, in order not to sel] our assets for what they would bring. Of late months, Europe has wished to see some o! her money, and we have had to liqui- date, in order to satisfy her. The result is that we are not to-day in the best condition to take care of this year’s crops. But, of course, the crops must be harvested and marketed, and money must be found somewhere for these purposes. There seem to be but two sources—further liquidation at home or renewed borrowing abroad, or both. Each of these contingencies is sufficient- ly near at hand to merit careful con- sideration. Seldom have the banks of this country been to a greater extent “loaned up” than during the last twelve months. Capital has lost a large meas- ure of its fluidity and acquired a fixed character. Several months ago, the Eastern banks saw the necessity of get- ting it once more into a state of flux, and more recently the Western banks have set themselves to the same task This is always, however, a thankless ef- fort. So far, the result has been a heavy liquidation in securities and a pretty general and pronounced recession in commodity prices. Unless money can be borrowed in unusually large amounts abroad, this process must go on, for there is certainly not enough floating capital in the United States to-day to take care of this year’s crops and finance Financial. Letters Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits s Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 69 Wall Street, New York Certificates
Page 26
640 general business on a liberal scale; were it not for the fact that the demand for money from merchants and manufactur- ers is abnormally light, it is quite con- ceivable that we might now be confront- ed with a really acute situation. Two contingencies are at present re- ceiving a good deal of consideration—a in the Western land speculation collapse and a wholesale unloading of surplus stocks by agriculturists. The amount of capital tied up in land at enhanced prices and in products of the soil that are being held for higher quotations than are now current, is believed to be altogether larger than can be spared at this time from the industrial operations of the nation. But this aspect of the situation can- not be treated apart from the question of Europe’s attitude toward us. Will she have the money to finance us in case of need this autumn? And what is equally important, will she have the inclination? It is fairly safe to answer the first question in the affirmative, The exceptionally large proportion of reserve to Hability which the Bank of England has shown of late weeks, when taken in connection with the Bank’s extensive holdings of bullion, is auspicious for us. The indications at the moment point to an unusually comfortable state of affairs in the European money market during the balance of the year. Several months ago Paul Leroy-Beaulieu declared L’Economiste Francais that Western Eu- rope was in danger of being burdened with an excessive amount of capital, for which it would be impossible to find em- Henry Holt & Company 3 ¥; HAVE JUST IBSUED: Helen R. Albee’s HARDY PLANTS FOR COTTAGE GARDENS 444466464 « (American Nature Series.) With some 60 Illustrations from photographs. 309 pp. With Index. 12mo. $1.60 net; by mail, $1.73 \ practical book for a woman who her own garden, written in an in- a! manner not devoid of human in- and based on much practical ex- perience Chas. D. Hazen’s EUROPE SINCE 1815 erent #EAEEEBEDEDEDADAAAASALEDS AAEODEDEEESS
With 14 Colored Maps. 8vo. $3.00 net. An account of Leading Events on the Continent in Great Britain, and in the Colonies of European Nations, from éhe fa | of Napoleon to the Finnish trou- bles of 1909 The alm has been to make the narrative so interesting in style as to attract the student, without sacrific- ing accuracy or proportion. The atten- tion | oncentrated upon a relatively emall number of topics, but it is hoped that no important step in the develop- ment of modern Furope has been slighted. WANTED—Some recent unbound vols. of The Nation. A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. in | The Nation.
[Vol. go, No. 2347
ployment at home. He looked the world over pretty carefully to discover outlets, and reached the conviction that the only | thing that could prevent a drop in the return on capital similar to that of the closing years of the nineteenth century was a strong demand for money from America, or from national governments in pursuance of large financial schemes. For some weeks after M. Leroy-Beau-; Iieu ventured this prediction, the inter- national money market seemed bent on giving the lie to him. had then any justification for saying what he did, he has perhaps even more justification for such a prophecy to-day. America will no doubt need money bad- ly enough three months from now; but there is more than a little ground for the hope that she will be able to get an adequate supply in Europe at a price which she can afford to pay. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Butler, E. P. The Water Goats, and Other Troubles. Doubleday, Page. Butler, S. Unconscious Memory. New and revised edition. Intro. by M. Hartog. London: Fifield. Cervantes’ Fregona. Edited, with notes, by F. A. Kirkpatrick. Putnam. $1 net. Colonial Society of Massachusetts publica- tions. Vols. IV and XI, Boston. Crispe, T. E. Reminiscences of a K. C. Boston: Little. Brown. $3.50 net. Curtis, E. L., and Madson, A. A. Chronicles. | International Critical Commentary Series. Scribner. $3 net. “Dr. Coggs.””" Teddy in Darkest Africa, or. the Daring Exploits of Bwana-Tumbo. Private:y printed. Eastman, C. Work—<Accidents and the Law. | Charities Publishing Company. $1.50 net. | Everyman's Library. 53 new volumes. Dut- ton. 35 cents net each. If, however, he) Facsimile Queen Alexandra's message, en- graved. London: Raphael Tuck & Sons. Feldman, E. Intermarriage Historically Considered. Formby, J. The American Civil War; Maps. 2 vols. Scribner. Frazer, J. G. Totemism and Exogamy. A Treatise on Certain Barly Forms of Superstition and Society. 4 vols. Mac- millan. $16 net. Galsworthy, J. A Motley. Scribner. $1.20 net. Hill, J. J. Highways of Progress. Double- day, Page. $1.50 net. | Hughes, Cc. E. A Book of the Black Forest Dutton. $32 net. King, L. W. A History of Sumer and Akkad. Stokes. Lyle, E. P., jr. Blaze Derringer. Double- day, Page. $1.20. Macewen, H. A. Food Inspection. Vana Nostrand. Bh net. Macnamara, N. C. The Evolution and Func- tion of Living Purposive Matter. D. Ap- pleton. | Martinez, J. Método practico para aprender 4 escribir por el] tacto. Underwood Type- writer Co. Oakenfull, J. C. Brazil in 1910, Second edi- tion. Commission for Economic Expansion of Brazil. Paul, N. B. Parliamentary Law. Century Co. 75 cents. Reid, G. A. The Laws of Heredity. Mac- millan. $5.50 net. Rings, F. Reinforced Concrete. Van Nostrand. $2.50 net. Saintsbury, G. A History of English Prosody. Vol. III. Macmillan. $3.75 net. Sanday, W. Christologies Ancient and Modern. Frowde. |Schwarz, E. H. L. Causal Geology. Van Nostrand. $2.50 net. | Skinner, J. Genesis. International Critical Commentary Series. Scribner. $3 net. Stacpoo e, H. de V. Fanny Lambert: a Novel. Fenno & Co. $1.50. Stopes, M. C. Ancient Plants. Van Nostrand. $2 net. | Us her, R. G. The Reconstruction of the English Church. 2 vols. D. Appleton. $6 net. | weigall, A, E. P. A Guide to the Antiquities of Upper Egypt. Macmillan. $2.50 net. Wisdom of the Apocrypha. Wisdom of the East Series. Dutton. 60 cents net.
FOR THE SUMMER LIBRARY | GWENDA. By Mabel Barnes-Grundy, | author of “Dimbie and I," “‘Hilary on Her Own,"’ “Hazel of Heatheriand.” An inti- mate, intense storr, relleved by humor anda | dash of worldly wisdom. i12mo. 350 pages. Frontisplece. $1.50. THE TOP OF THE MORNING. By Juliet Wilbor Tompkins, author of “Dr. | Ellen” and “Open House.”’ A sparkling, wholesome story, full of humor, vivacity and charm. 12mo. Frontispiece in color. $1.50 IN PRAISE OF GARDENS. Compiled | by Temple Scott. Poems and verses about | gardens from the whole range of English poetry. Charming in contents and in form. $1.25. | THE GARDEN IN THE WILDER- NESS. By “A Hermit.” A felicitous mingling of gardening and sentiment. Many iNustrations, decorative end papers, etc. | $1.50 net. WOMEN Kadited by Ada M. written by women uotil our own time. portraits. $1.25 net. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., NEW YORK AS LETTER WRITERS. Ingpen. The best letters from the 16th century i2mo. 9 full-page |
SAMPLE COPIES OF THE NATION Will be sent to any address for three weexs WITHOUT CHARGE. ADDRESS Tue Nation, 20 Vesey Street, N, Y. The Best Books A Reader's Guide to the Mg of the Best Avai oD. (About 100,000 By William Swan Scenics Third Edition Entirely Rewritten To Be in Three Parts. Part I. 83.50 net. Ready. “It would be difficult to exaggerate the usefulness of this work or to praise too highly the industry of the compiler. Turn to what subject we may, we find the best current books | | which the reader may consult, and | | their prices.”—London Spectator. G, P. PUTNAM’S SONS, *toxcon BACK TO THE LAND: A MEDLEY | By Ce Crown 8vo. Pp. xii-}+ 196. $1.50 net. ***Adventures in search of a country estate with pertinent reflections and anecdotes. | “A wholly delightful and irresponst- ble story.”"—Church Times. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York