The Nation 1910-06-02: Vol 90 Iss 2344

Page 1

GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH, JUN & 198 _ ee VOL. XC—NO. 2344. THURSDAY, JUNE 2, 1910. PRICE TEN CENTS. June Publications of Small, Maynard & Company novelist. The , A of a Rebellious Ready shortly. Wife 50 cents net; postage 6 cents A remarkable human document, written from the inside, voic- ing a real heartache, a real puzzle, a real resolve. The story stands out in its fullmess, and the reader gains a deep knowl- edge of the nature of this one woman, and through her of that of many. A book that will command a wide reading, it is so -deep, so personal, so typically American. From Irish Castles When Love Calls Men to Arms to French Chateaux By STEPHEN CHALMERS Illustrated by HOWARD CHANDLER CHRISTY. $1.50 postpaid Ready June 18 From the time when Don John escapes from the Spanish galleon in Kilellan Bay until Rorie comes to the end of his story of Don John’s daughter,the winsome but wilful Mariposa, there is breathiess action in this fine Scotch romance by The book is full of big scenes and alluring characters, not the least of whom is Bordeaux, as he calls himself, the friend of “Will Shaxper.” wrought with the fine touch of a true literary artist, so that the telling delights the reader almost as much as the galloping ‘tale itself entertains him. the new romantic The author's style is Ready June 18 The Gossamer Thread Being the Chronicle of Velleda, who understood about “‘the Different World. By VENITA S IBERT. § /llustrated by W. T. BENDA #100 net; postage 10 cents Velleda is an exquisite little German-American girl—sensitive, dreamy, imaginative. She is “one question mark.” Miss Seibert’s delightful book—some of the chapters of which have been published separately with great success in the American Magazine—is imbued with fine humor and human nature, Ready June 18 By NORMA BRIGHT CARSON, Editor of “ Book News Monthly” Profusely illustrated from photographs, many of them taken by the author. The value of this book to the traveller ie that, while covering no new fields of travel, it gives the better service for that very rea- son. It takes the traveller over the journey he will inevitably desire and expect to take, however far afield he may go here and there, and suggests to the would-be traveller or recalls to him who has travelled what is most interesting and indispensable. From its fine atmosphere of culture the book might be called a “literary pilgrimage.” $1.50 net; postage 12 cents The Coming Religion Ready June 18. By Rev. CHARLES F. DOLE An important book, bringing a message to all mankind. Its influence among man of every faith will be for good, as em- phasizing the central, universal truths of religion, as offering a gospel of hope, joy, work, progress, as making life more, not less, significant, the continuance of life hereafter more, not less, hopeful. The author’s style is quotable, and his manner in presenting his subject is characterized by illuminating illustra- tions and comparisons, and by fine moderation and charity towards all men of all creeds. It is a book of big qualities for -all thinking men. #1.00 net; postage 10 cents Astir: A Publisher’s Life Story By JOHN ADAMS THAYER Keady June 18 Retiring from part-ownership in Everybody's a few years ago, Mr. Thayer has devoted the leisure of this welcome breathing- space, after his thirty years of business life, to writing his auto- biography. It is a singularly interesting book, the work of a man with high ideals and wide knowledge of affairs. His work as advertising manager of the Ladies’ Home Journal, the Delineator, the Munsey publications, and his experiences as one of the owners and up-builders of Hverybody’s are full of interest for every man and woman in every branch of the publishing business, and his modest story of success is an inspiration to every young American. $1.20 net; postage 12 cents RECENT SUCCESSFUL NOVELS The Achievements of Luther Trant By EDWIN BALMER and WILLIAM MacHARG Luther Trant is the great psychological detective whose name as a character in fiction bids fair to become a household word. “Here at last,” says the Boston Transcript, “is something new under the detective story sun. Not since Conan Doyle first made Sherlock Holmes the most famous detective in the world of fiction has there come to light a rival until this appearance of Luther Trant.” Illustrated. 81.50 The Scar: A Story of the New South By WARRINGTON DAWSON “This author,” says Mr. Roosevelt in The Outlook, power and interest of vital matters.” “writes with “*The Scar’ is the most graphic story of the South yet writ- td. p ten.”"—Grand Rapids Hera $1.50 The Seventh Noon By FREDERICK ORIN BARTLETT “Those who read ‘The Web of the Golden Spider’ will recall how they sat up late to finish the story; Mr. Bartlett's latest story is even more absorbing than the other.” Portland (Ore.) Telegram theme worthy of Hawthorne.”—-New York Times Iliustrated. 81.50. Third Edition. Happy Hawkins By ROBERT ALEXANDER WASON “One «f the best planned and best told of all the stories of Western ranch life."—The Churchman. “Happy is a character in fiction that will live.” —Brookiyn Citizen “American humor in its best estate.’"—The Nation. Iliustrated. 81.50. Fifth Edition. = SMALL, | MAYNARD & COMPANY PUBLISHERS ‘BOSTON

Page 2

*-e. Tl N ba ie Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. IEntered at the New York City Post Office aa cond-clasa matl matter.) The Nation \a published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard resident; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in imy part of the United States or Mewvico; to Canada £3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Poatali Union £4.00 iddreass THE NATION, Bow 794, Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street New York. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. WE cccceccccccecccccccccsonseess EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Political Leadership The Ballinger Inquiry Deserters from Fiction seecceseee The Loneliness of the Retired ...... SPECIAL ARTICLES: News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE: Mark Twain, Sir Thomas Browne, and Ce CEG TERCRMRGN cece cccccccccccces Capt. Alden Partridge ovccseecors The Hetch Hetchy Water Supply .... A Source of Shakespeare's “Julius CENT” cccdecenccceseccncoscccseeeedete The American Federation of Labor.. College Debating secesccecceoetese BRO “AUBUSURE” ABD o coc cosccccsccccces LITERATUR! The Life of Daniel Coit Gilman ...... The History of Mr. Polly ........+.... The Fascinating Mrs. Halton TRO TeRE CORED ccc ccccccccccccescases Jacqueline of the Carrier-pigeons.... University of Pennsylvania: Publica- tions of the Egyptian Department of the University Museum—An Egyp- tlan Oasis English Literature Religion—The Religion Wells, and Other Essays Histoire de la Langue Francaise des Origines A 1900 2... ccccccccecceceecees Report of the Work of the Commis- sion Sent Out by the Jewish Terri- torial Organization to Examine the Territory Proposed for the Purpose of a Jewish Settlement in Cyrenaica The Great Pacific Coast..... lure in Account with of H. G. Nott Screnci DRAMA Music Boston Symphony grammes Orchestra Pro- ART: The Two Salons BOOKS OF THE WEEK... .ccccceecceeeeees . 553 557 558 . 559 . 559 559 . 567 *** Coples of The Nation may be procured in Rrentano’sa, F. Charing Cross. Paria at London of B Square 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar The Na [ Vol. 90, No. 2344 Educational. TYHE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2 A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fitth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 203 Mich. Ave.,Chicago 611 Swetiand Bid., Portiand 405 Cooper Bid., Denver 238 DougiasBid.,LosAngeles 419 Hyde Bid., Spokane 2142>hattuck Ave. , Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Bayn, Mawr, Pennsylvania. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other colleges for women. Small classes supplemented by careful indi- vidual instruction. Teachers all thoroughly familiar with Bryn Mawr requirements. Tennis and basket- ball. Twelfth year opens Oct. 5, 1910. MR. SARGENT’S TRAVEL SCHOOL FOR BOYS A combination of school and travel. Individual instruction in preparation for college or business. Seventh year. Illustrated catalog. PORTER E. SARGENT, Cambridge, Mass ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St.,Albany, N.Y. Books for the Horticulturist Fungous Diseases of Plants. By Ben- JAMIN Mince Duaear. Price $ .00. Soil Fertility and Permanent Agri- culture. by Cyrit Georer Hop- KINS. Price $2.25. Essentials of Botany. By Josern Y. Bercey. Price $ .50. GINN AND COMPANY 29 BEACON STREET BOSTON 28 VOLUMES READY THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE Ed, by PORTER-CLARKE. Text of 1623. Full notes and variants. Ready :—‘‘Midsommer Night's Dreame,"’ ‘‘Love's Labour's Lost,’’ “Comedie of Errors,’’ “‘Merchant of Venice,"’ ‘‘Macbeth,”’ “Julius Cesar,”’ “‘Ham- let."’ “King Lear,”’ ‘““‘Twelfe Night,’’ ‘“‘As You Like It," “Henry the fFift,” “Much Adoe Abou Nothing,”" ‘“‘Romeo and Juliet,’”” “ “od “Othello,”’ ‘‘Winter’s Tale,’’ “‘Shrew,’’ ‘““‘Two Gen tlemen of Verona,’’ ‘‘Coriolanus,’’ *‘Merry Wives,’’ “All's Well,"’ “‘Measure for Measure,”’ ‘Antonie and Cleopatra,’’ ‘‘Titus Andronicus,’’ ‘ of Athens,” “Pericles,” ‘“‘Cymbeline,”” ‘ lus.”’ Cloth, 75 cents; limp leather, $1.00 per volume, postpaid. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., New York THE TEMPLE CLASSICS 233 VOLUMES Generat Epiror: Isramt. Gottancs, M.A. Each volume contains a photogravure frontispiece, a decorative ti » and a ribbon bookmark; where advisable, editorial appendices and marginalia, also. PRICES: In cloth, each volume 45 cts. Net In limp leather each volume 65 cts. Net E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORK. ‘(Do you knowthe Beacon ? The only authoritative lives of twen- |@ ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 50 cents net; by mail, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. M & 21 Beacon | Read L. M. Montgomery’t New Book By the author of “ANNE of GREEN GARLES” Biet Printing) a “ANNE OF AVONLEA” (10th Printing) Dewey’s How We Think An exposition of the belief that the need- ed steadying and centralizing factor in edu- cation is found in adopting as the end of endeavor the scientific attitude of mind By JOHN DEWEY, Ph.D., LL.D., Columbia University. Cloth. 230 pages. Retail Price, $1.00 D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO A new book on Games PLA e GAMES FOR THE KINDERGARTEN, e SCHOOL ROOM AND COLLEGE By Emmett Dunn Angell. The most practical book on the subject, describing over 100 carefully graded games, many entirely original. With over 50 illustrations. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.63 LITTLE, BROWN & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON BOOKBUYERS and students wishing to receive interesting catalogues of second- hand books should send a card W. HEFFER & SONS, Ltd., Booksellers, Cambridge, Eng. 100,000 volumes in stock. 128 Tremont Street, FOREIGN TAUGHNITZ E= s tronot Sct, A A AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis. Bend for catalogue. CATALOGUE NO. ST OF ING BOOKS now ready. Send fo any books, write to FE. W. JOHNSON, 121 KB. 234 Street. Good books bough tr one. ‘ Bookseller, WANTED—Some recent unbound vols. of The Nation. A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. INTEREST-| For | WILLIAM J. TUCKER’S | PERSONAL POWER I ay Ay Star. - “A stimulating volume.’"—San Francisco Chronicle. | School Advertising THE NATION The ation, in its special field of political and literary criticism, is un- ‘like any other periodical, American or foreign. It is taken by read- ‘ing clubs and literary associations in a large number of places, and may be found on file in every library of importance in the country. There are probably few weekly periodicals whose columns offer so favorable an opportunity for reaching an audience interested in educational matters. 40 conts a line for 13 times, The Nation ‘20 Vesey St., New York City

Page 3

June 2, 1910] facilities for supplying i=" BOOKS Catalogues free. Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 years. 30-32 West 27th St., New York The only biography of the founder of modern Socialism, KARL MARX: HIS LIFE AND WORK, by John Spargo, $2.50 net; $2.70 carriage paid. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth avenue, NEW YORK SAMPLE COPIES OF THE NATION will be sent to any address for three weeks WITHOUT CHARGE ADDRESS THE NATION New York City 29 Vesey Street The Nation. — ae eee “Morals are perpetually being trans- formed by successful crimes.” —NIETZSCHE. ‘Nietzsche in Outline and Aphorism By A. R. ORAGE. Mr. ORAGE prefaces each section of his selected aphorisms with an expo- introduction, which taken to- gether form perhaps the best account of any philosopher existing in so short a compass in English. Any one de- siring to get an insight into Nietzsche sitory cannot do better than begin with Mr. Orage’s excellent little book.—New York Times. Boards, 75 cents net; postage, 7 cents. AT ALL BOOKSTORES A. C.McCLURG & CO., Publishers New York CHICAGO San Francisco LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra ries. Ancient and modern languages. Translation, revision of manuscripts, etc. MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. STENOGRAPHER GEO B. COCK FRANKLIN BANK BUILDING. PHILADELPHIA J Theism and the Christian Faith By CHARLES CARROLL EVERETT Late Professor of Theology in Harvard University Octavo, Cloth. 491 pages. $2.50 The Nation says Dr. Everett's theological system has points of contact with current theory an interesting study; book ar literary and re- which make it but scattered through the sentences of insight ligious, touches of quiet and delicious humor, appreciations of the masters of thought and poetry, which mak« the book worth reading altogether apart from philosophical or theolog! cal doctrine rhe editor has succeeded not only in accurately re producing the Everett thought, but also rin suggesting the charm of delivery PUBLISHED BY THE MACMILLAN COMPANY For sale by all dealers INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS WHY WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! By GEORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth,$1 net, each - B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. LETTERS AND MEMORIALS OF Wendell Phillips Garrison Editor of the Nation (1865-1906 ) In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. Price $1.50 net, postpaid. During the forty-one years in which he edited the Nation, with a thoroughness, ability, and conscientious devotion unsurpassed in the records of American journalism, Mr. Garrison was an indefatigable correspondent, never employing an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who embraced practically all the leading American scholars and critics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a sufficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the relations between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exercised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes and sympathies. The volume also contains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and several of his characteristic editorials, reviews and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. It likewise preserves the notable letter of appreciation addressed to Mr. Garrison by more than two hundred contributors to the Nation on the completion of his fortieth year of service, and his acknowl- edgment thereof. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY. Boston and New York

Page 4

The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2344 Important New Macmillan Importations Professor Frazer’s Totemism and Exogamy . Treatise on Certain Early Forms of Superstition and Society, by J. G. Frazer, D.C.L., LL.D., Litt.D., B.A. Fellow of Trinity College, Cambridge Professor of Social Anthropology in the University of Liverpool. In four 8vo volumes. IL, xiv-+579 pp.; IL, 640 pp.; IIL, 583 pp.; IV., 319 pp., with Index and Maps. Price the set, $16.00 net; carriage extra. \bout 175 pages of the first volume are given to an introductory discussion of Totemism, and of the Origin of Totemism. The remainder and the whole of the second and third volumes contain an exhaustive thnographical survey of Totemism, including all parts of the world. The fourth volume contains a and the conclusions reached as to both institutions, with full indexes and maps. R. H. I. Palgrave’s Dictionary of Political Economy Edited by R. H. Incits PALGRAve. In three large 8vo volumes. $15.00 net (carriage extra). Besides many able English writers, there are among its contributors some of the most distinguished \merican and foreign Economists, whose co-operation has given to this valuable work that international or cosmopolitan character which should mark any work on economic science. The work covers, under separate heads, an account of the labors of the principal economic writers and the characteristics of the different schools of economic thought of the civilized world, the development of the history of econ- omic methods, ete. In brief, the Dictionary shuuld be of the greatest assistance in any special investiga- tion, by supplying preliminary information and references to the best sources of extended treatment. Prof. Saintsbury’s History of English Prosody Completed \ History of English Prosody from the Twelfth Century to the Present Day. By Grorce SaAIntssury, M.A. (Oxon.), Hon. LL.D. (Aberd.), Hon. D.Litt. (Dresden), Professor of Rhetoric and English Liter- ature in the University of Edinburgh. The third volume, just ready, completes the work. Vol. I. From the Origin to Spenser. Vol. I1., From Shakespeare to Crabbe. Vol. III, From Blake to Mr. Swinburne, Three volumes, octavo. Cloth, each, $3.75 net (carriage extra). W. J. Courthope’s History of English Poetry Completed By the former Professor of Poetry in the University of Oxford. Completed with the recent publication of the sixth volume. The volumes deal in succession with The Middle Ages, Renaissance and Reforma- tion, The Intellectual Conflict of the 17th Century, The Development and Decline of the Poetic Drama, The Constitutional Compromise of the 18th Century, and The Romantic Movement in English Poetry. The latter is a most interesting companion to Professor Saintsbury’s new volume, which naturally touches on the same period from different points of view. Six volumes, cloth, &vo. Each, $3.25 net; by mail, $3.42. Mr. Maurice Baring’s Landmarks in Russian Literature “His point of attack is fresh and interesting. . . . Altogether a capital little book, which no one inter- ested in literature should miss."—New York Tribune. Cloth, t2mo, $1.75 net; by mail, $1.84. Sir Horace Plunkett’s The Rural Life Problem in the United States Che results of ten years’ ranching and farming in this country by a man who has been a close student of rural life in this country, especially as it is now, or may be in the future, affected by the Federal and State Department activities for agricultural development Cloth, xii+180 pp. $1.25 net; by mail, $1.35. C. G. Montefiore’s The Synoptic Gospels, Vols. I and Il \ translation and commentary on the first three gospels, of special interest as being the first work to treat of the New Testament in any detail from a Jewish point of view, which is often illuminating. Two volumes, 8vo, with bibliography. $6.00 net (carriage extra). by rout = THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “#R% ~~ j

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JUNB 2, 1910. The Week It is announced that when Mr. Roose- velt reaches the port of New York, his. baggage will enjoy Ambassadorial priv- ilege. None of his trunks or of those of members of his party will be subject to examination by customs inspectors. Now, personally, we have no objection to this favor being shown Mr. Roosevelt. | We congratulate him, rather, on his good luck. But we still think that he will be missing a part of his education as an influential public man. If we could have our way, no American, however eminent or well deserving, should be de- prived of that intimate knowledge of our barbaric tariff laws which is stamp- ed upon the mind of every “resident of the United States” who comes back from Europe to find himself exposed to an- noyance and insult which he could en- counter in no other custom house in the world—not even in Turkey. It is in the public interest that every man who has to do in any way with the making of our tariff laws should be put into the same suffering category with the hun- dreds of thousands of Americans who find themselves every year treated on the docks of their own land as suspected smuggiers and liars. So while we wish Mr. Roosevelt every personal comfort on his home-coming, we should be very glad if his stern sense of public duty, or even his insatiable curiosity, were to lead him to renounce his privilege and to find out by individual experience just what is the nature and the administra- tion of the American tariff laws. Now, in this matter of personal bag- gage there is no way of abolishing the abuse except by abolishing the foolish law. The system of advance declara- tion on shipboard, which we owe to Mr. Cortelyou when he was Secretary of the Treasury, is a great improvement over the old method, but it is necessarily only a palliative, as must be every oth- er plan to render more easy the enforce- ment of a law which cannot be enforced at all without being made onerous and humiliating. We ought rather to assim. ilate our practice to that of all other civilized countries. For the detection of ~ secret service. {real smugglers we have an organized If it does its work properly, there can be no serious eva- sions of duty on articles brought in for sale. But to persist in harassing a hundred thousand innocent people so as to catch one rogue is an exhibition of “helpless folly which ought to be charac- terized by words in Mr. Roosevelt's vo- cabulary. It is said that we have no privileged class in this country, but this is to over- look the private secretaries of Gover- nors and Presidents. They are as regu- larly taken care of with a good office as ‘if they had an hereditary and indefeas- ible title thereto. Gov. Hughes has sim- ply anticipated matters a little in ap- pointing Mr. Fuller to a State office, while Mr. Carpenter, the private secre- tary to President Taft, no sooner shows signs of breaking health than he ig named as Minister to Morocco. In both cases there was simply a following of a ‘long precedent. If we have anything like a permanent office-holding class in the United States—that dread thing which so frightens the spoilsmen—it is to be found among private secretaries to executives, and they get their start without coming under the abhorred civil service rules. There is the less objec- tion to this because it seems to be felt that they have so many disagreeables to put up with while serving as private secretaries that they deserve recognition and reward afterwards. Everybody will sympathize with Secretary Carpenter in his break-down, but that will only in- crease the wonder at Mr. Loeb’s uncom- mon robustness. If it prove true, as has been stated in the Washington dispatches, that the ap- propriations in this session of Congress will be considerably beyond the billion- dollar mark—that is, fully as large as before, if not larger—President Taft cannot fail to be chagrined. Whatever “policies” he inherited from his prede- cessor, economy was not one of them. That was his own. In dealing so plain- ly as he did with public extravagance, and setting out to reduce the national budget by $60,000,000 or $75,000,000, he took an original and promising lead. In fact, the estimates submitted to Con- gress by the heads of departments were cut much lower than in recent years, and it seemed reasonable to hope that the first steps in national retrenchment would be taken. But now it appears that the old total of outlay is to be reached again, if not surpassed. The leaders in Congress confess themselves unable to keep down the appropriations. Chair- man Tawney puts his finger on one chief cause of this inability, so far as the House is concerned, when he says that there is no concentrated control of the public expenses. The appropriation bills have been more and more taken out of the hands of the Appropriations Committee, until now there are a dozen committees each entitled to bring in its own bill for money, Such a breaking- up of financial control, and such a break- ing-down of responsibility, lead inevit- ably to wastefulness, As high as $16,000,000 run the vary- ing estimates of the cost of each of the two 26,000-ton battleships just author- ized by Congress. When there is not a war-cloud on the horizon; when the navy is larger than ever before in its history; when the whole country is groaning under the increased cost of! living and steadily increasing burden of taxation, Congress is content to waste perhaps $32,000,000. When it is con sidered that there were years before the Spanish War when our total naval ex- penditure was annually only $9,000,000 or $11,000,000, and no harm came to the country, the present insensate folly is inexplicable. We firmly belleve that if the fact could be got into the head of every citizen that the United States is spending 70 cents out of every dollar upon expenditures for wars, past or fu- ture, this colossal waste would stop. Naturally, Congress refused to appropri ate on the same day $100,000 for a com- mission to inquire into methods of econ- omy in the administration of govern- ment. To have done so after the naval appropriations would have been to stul tify itself. Senator Lorimer made last Saturday his expected denial that he had bribed his way into the United States Senate, but, unfortunately, almost at the very moment he was speaking, legislators

Page 6

5448 were being indicted and arrested in | having taken bribes to vote This be only an un- lucky coincidence. Mr. Lorimer has call- ed investigation of the charges against him, and the Senate Committee | linois for for him. may for an on Elections is bound to take the mat- ter up. Pending the result of such in- quiry, final judgment must be withheld. There can be no reasonable question, af- ter what has been already shown by the prosecuting authorities in Illinois, that the Senatorial that State was corrupt, but it may not be possible to connect Mr. Lorimer personally and election in directly with the wickedness. It may be said that he was the victim—or the beneficiary—of over-zealous and _ too wicked friends. But even he himself is that the presumptions are heavily against him, and that he has evidently aware no time to lose in showing, if he can, that his title to a seat in the Senate is not tainted. The first thing he should set himself to clearing up is the mystery of confessed bribe-takers without any briber Che doctrine of States’ rights has been invoked to very poor purpose, indeed, by Southern Congressmen who have those come out in opposition to Senator Dick's bill for the establishment of an addi tional number of mine rescue stations in the Middle and Far West. At pres- nt there are only four such central iergency camps, situated at Pitts purgh, Knoxville, Urbana, LIL, and Seat t Following upon the Cherry disas a report of the Secretary of the In ascribed the great loss of life in in part to the distance terior ining disasters ‘ the rescue stations trom the mines. cretary recommended the estab ment of twelve additional branch all over the country at a cost of But inasmuch as such emer Seer cee geney depots would necessarily have to State boundary lines, where are under the police power of tate the States’ rights shibboleth wen raised against a measure call of sound busi by every Iinatinet humanity and every argument from ness policy After the Courrléres disas in France a tew years ago, a rescue part from the German mining flelds came to take part in the work of human If the Frenchmen salvage very real frontier that from Germans separates could be wiped out under the influence The Nation. of a common pity and common human- ity, it would be the very height of crim- inal absurdity to let State boundaries stand in the way of so imperative a re- form Shorter than Paulhan’s last and long- est flight by some forty miles, Glenn Curtiss’s aerial dash down the valley of the Hudson last Sunday surpasses Paul- han’s feat in actual difficulties overcome, clean-cut demonstration of the of the aeroplane, and in To Americans, in the possibilities dramatic interest. cer- tainly, Curtiss’s achievement gains a special intensity of interest because the scene of it was the river upon which the Clermont sailed a hundred years ago. That circumstance forces upon the mind solemn recognition of that human prog- ress which we so easily talk about with- out realizing it to the mind’s eye or the emotions. Curtiss's triumph is none the tess emphatic because it was preceded the doubts and hesitations that a crowd eager for a spectacle is none too patient The right in saying that the very people who insist upon the show being carried off at all costs would be the ones to shake wise It was a doubly dramatic event for Glenn by with. aviator was quite heads in the case of disaster. Curtiss, theretore, that his record-mak- ing flight should have lain along the his- trial course of the Hudson, ana that his landing should have been on the very spot where less than a year ago toric he gave a certain excuse for bitter com- ment on his abilities and his motives. Robert Koch was born the same year Louis Pasteur entered the univer- It difficult to decide which of the two men has gained the Certainly, Koch and Pas- names in the that sity. would be wider fame. teur are the two great science of bacteriology which has revo- lutionized modern medicine. In range of achievements, Koch was probably the His discovery of the germ of tuberculosis would in it- greater man of the two. self constitute a service of transcendent importance. But in addition, he had studied malaria, cholera, and, newest of all to European knowledge, that sleep- ing sickness which has been threaten- ing negro Africa almost with depopu'a- Associated with his name is one tragic disappointment which detracts nothing from his reputation as a scien- tist or a man, Everybody over thirty tion. must recall the vast stirring that fol- juuxiety in Russia. [ Vol. go No. 234 lowed the announcement from Berlin of the discovery of a specific for tubercu- losis. Science and the millions of af- flicted who looked to science for aid in their affliction turned expectant eyes towards the Prussian capital. Pilgrim- ages were made. It was a vast upward surge of hope that failed of realization. But whether the dread white plague is to be conquered by a sudden discovery or by the slower hand-to-hand methods which we are adopting to-day, Robert Koch’s share in the ultimate victory will be unquestionable. Every patriot heart from the Atlantic to the Golden Gate and from the Gulf of Mexico to the forty-ninth parallel of north latitude so recently eulogized by Mr. Cannon, will thrill with pride at the news that our epic scramble for the privilege of lending China some money has succeeded. The Hankow-Sze-chuen railway matter is settled, or at least al- most settled. After years of furious contention, we have won the right to participate with Great Britain, France, and Germany in the $30,000,000 loan which it is now only a question of in- ducing China to accept. For it would appear that at the last moment the Chinese have been seized with sore doubt. The beautifully altruistic spec- tacle of the four leading nations of the West fighting for the right of giving away their money has somehow failed to impress the bland Celestial mind. That the struggle for the privilege of |forcing money on China was accompa- ‘nied by a struggle for such sordid things as a share in supplying the necessary railway material and engineering skill, was probably only a coincidence. To the pure all things are pure. But China has had so rich an experience of the im- plications that go with a European loan that her hesitation is, after all, compre- hensible. All the more reason, therefore, why the four allied and altruistic na- tions should now concentrate their ef- ‘forts, and, with one eye on the main chance and one eye on each other, pro- ceed to lend money to a heathen foreign government by hypodermic injection. The death of Edward VII has arous- ed profound regret and actually some One correspondent relates that when the order for court mourning, usual in such circumstances,

Page 7

June 2, 1910] was presented for the approval of the Czar, Nicholas II with his own hand struck out the traditional three weeks The Novoye Vremya printed, in heavy type, imme- diately after the dispatch announcing the King’s death, the single sentence, “The death of King Edward VII is a day of sorrow for Russia.” The Russkoe Slovo of Moscow declared that in Kd- ward the country had lost one of its sin- cerest friends. The Polish press laid stress on the fact that, as a result of the Anglo-Russian understanding, of which Edward VII was the author, Russia had been saved from her humiliating depen- dence upon Germany. Such expressions of regret were probably as sincere as formulas of this kind usually are; and perhaps a little more so, because at the present moment the Anglo-Russian en- tente in Persia is being put sharply to the test by German diplomacy. It is the and inserted three months. misfortune, however, of Russia’s blun dering autocratic system that her Czar will often pull one way and his Minis ters another. It may be that Nicholas II was really moved by the death of the English monarch and its possible ef- fects on Anglo-Russian friendship. But on the other hand, there is no guaran- tee that the Czar may not be soon mak- ing another little Baltic trip with his good friend William Il, and soliciting his advice on vital matters of state. The Prussian Government has been compelled to abandon its franchise bil! after carrying it through one house, which is gratifying proof that even in Prussia obstinate officialdom cannot pre- vail against popular opinion. The effect of those wonderful, peaceful demonstra- tions of the Socialists in Berlin could not be withstood, nor the sentiment created elsewhere by the clashes between police and people. According to the dis- patch, the Chancellor bas declared that the measure failed because it gave to the wealthy and middle classes a great- er influence in the elections and that there would doubtless be a continuance of the bitter agitation against the suf- frage system until the Government sub- mitted new legislation. But if the Chan cellor sees that now, why was he not aware of it when he drew the bill and announced that it would go through whether the people liked it or not? If the agitation has really converted the fact, by itself, is a Chancellor, that The Nation. great gain, but the price seems high if one considers that all the ill-feeling and aroused among the could been avoided by a greater intelligence on the part of the rulers. The bound to suffer, for this was his first So far as suf- populace little anger have Chancellor's prestige is measure of importance. frage reform is concerned, the attitude of all enlightened people in Prussia has oeen that it would be a great deal better to have the present intolerable condi- tions continue than to accept the pro- posed legislation. Even in the House of Lords the Chancellor's bill met with the greatest opposition, steadily increas- ing until even the Chancellor abandoned it as hopeless. A conversation about Turkey with Arminius Vambéry at Buda-Pesth is re ported in a letter to the Manchester Guardian by Sir William Ramsay. The veteran traveller and professor—he is now new eighty-nine—holds that the Turkey five years of peace in order to have a What Vambéry régime in must enjoy twenty good chance of success. most fears is not attack from without, but bitter race and religious dissensions within the Empire. The Albanian trou ble he regards as serious, but as really the least threatening of many probable of ion of the former Sultan is interesting He agrees that Abdul Hamid into a condition of listless cruelty, but about causes dissension. Vambéry’s opin with the general view in his later years sank twenty years ago, ability and tireless energy, often working thir affirms that earlier, say, he displayed great on a ty-six or even forty-eight hours stretch. It is well known that Vambéry was once in the employ of the Turkish Government, to which he made confiden tial reports. One of these so plainly enumerated the causes leading to the ruin of Turkey that the Sultan in a tow- ering rage ordered all allowances to Vambéry stopped. Afterwards, narrates Sir William Ramsay, on the authority of a friend in Constantinople, when the Sultan discovered that Vambéry had been entirely right, he made tempting offers to him to resume his connection, but they were all declined. The first Cabinet for United South Af rica has been organized, Pessimists who see in old everything England going to ruin be asked for a momen! might © look at South Africa. After all, there must be something of the ancient virtue left in a nation which can accomplish what England has accomplished in South Africa in the last seven years. In that space of time, a conquered popula tion has been not merely appeased but concillated and won over. Civil govern- ment has been reéstablished in the for- mer Boer republics, and such govern ment has been placed in the hands of the conquered element. Superimposed the four separate colonial govern- ments of Cape Colony, Natal, Orange River Colony, and the Transvaal, comes now a general government for South Af on rica, which, too, has been handed over to the men who only eight years ago Gen. of were in the field against England. Louis Botha first United South Africa, and Gen. Smutz is Nor is the Premier his leading associate. is it less eloquent testimony to the English genius for using the dead past only as a foun dation for the present, that the son otf the English statesman who was respon sibie for the “disgrace” of Majuba Hil! hould be the first Governor-General of the new nation. The fact that the Premier and tl Minister of the Interior in the fir South African Cabinet hold the same positions in the Transvaal Ministry raises the natural expectation that to the Transvaal will fall, if not a predom inant voice in federal affair ertainly a degree of influence greater than would be its share on a strict population basi The population of Cape Colony is near Ty twice that of the Transvaal, and the proportion holds for whites as well as for the colored races. In the Transvaal, too, the Boer element predominates de cisively over the English element, whereas in Cape Colony the two are pretty evenly balanced. The Trans vaal’s economic importance, of course, outweighs the mere factor of population, put it is doubtful if even then Cape Col ony would have foregone its claim to the leadersnip in the first federal Min istry, if it were not for the manifest de sire in Africa make the point that the loyalty of the England and South to Boer population conditioned the success of that though it may well be that racial influ will African many experiment. Of doubt, the great political loyalty there can be no ences color South politics for years to come,

Page 8

95O POLITICAL LEADERSHIP. > The startling change in the national Republican prospects within a year, the even swifter alteration in New York State within the last few weeks, are among the most recent and conclusive demonstrations of the fact that, how- ever intelligent an electorate may be, without some sort of leadership it can- not prosper. For the apparently irrecon- cilal differences within the Republl- can party are not sudden developments. It is only their revelation in all their n il pugnance that is novel. While NM nl lived, divergences of view ized by a spirit of peace- pri compromise, for the sake of p Roosevelt smashed op- | ! he he could, yielded to it compelled, actuated by na ell as by party success; Hug corning compromise, has tri iking use of the only legit ima pon, the power of public opin ! three m« two Presidents and a Governor, represent three stages litical leadership. The first organization. Whatever theory of government he may have held, his p ilted in the victory of the pra politician, of the man who lk t and chiefly for the purely political effect of measures and appoint- mer t man who was thinking al wa the next el ion. That Presi- dent } iley was himself the preémi ! pe in of his day may prove to b j tle to enduring fame. Our fa 1 to have feared the dema gorue | than the tyrant; the politi clan who combines the hypocrisy of the ol ! pression of the other is to be feared more than either. I quel of Melhinley’s succes for ja in the circumstance that the ‘ ner hi giving him its enthusias th ipport yas uncertain whether to cn i politician or statesman His alr re high; his means “practical All tl of the demagogue, all the re soure of the tyrant, he employed with col i kill Those who did not tr | feared him Many who fa vi | his ends censured his means, But it , ch a relief to see old-timers completel beaten at their own game { i intrymen generally overlook thed for the eake of the result hoo ] blazing seven ‘ 1 onl t middle tage It vas ré¢ rved for another New Yorker The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2344 to take the final step; to do, after all these years, what the plain citizen would naturally have supposed all public offi- clals would do of their own accord—to refuse unworthy means as quickly as unworthy ends, to think of party as no more than a means, and to act as if genuine statesmanship were its own suf- ficient justification. To withhold adora- tion from the great god Success is to run the risk of being sneered at as un- American; but there are few more suc- cessful careers than that of the Gover- nor who has despised any success ex- cept the highest. These three stages in democratic lead- in kind rather ership are progressive than in time. They exist simultaneous- ly; and, while it is not difficult to rank them, it is very difficult to find leaders belonging to the last one. Leadership, nevertheless, democracy must have, and, find it will It is this aspect if it cannot one sort, per- force turn to another. of the Republican break-up that is seri- The with from the special session of Con- ous. only party to emerge credit gress last summer was the group of par- tyless insurgents; the only respectable party in New York for some years has been the party-scorned Hughes Republi- Neither of the se groups now has cans. a leader. If the nation, in order to pun- ish the long-dominant party for ifs inex- cusable derelictions: if the State of New York, party, entrusts itself to a long-discredit- ed in order to discipline the same guarantee is there will character of our political fact, rarity of the high- of the Democracy, what the transfer be an improve ment in the leadership? It is a as ominous as obvious, that the of it j t kind leadership is one prime causes of the existence of the low- er kinds. If a people lack real leaders, the reins will slip into the hands of those who substitute organization for opinion for principle, power for right. The party of votes, the dealing buying out of offices, the suppressing of primary reform, even the juggling with the tar- iff, are only phases of the situation. They one and all range themselves on the side of organization, as unrespon- ive as they dare to be to the legitimate overeign, public opinion The ground for hope is the memory of what is notable in these last ten n the rise of a new leadership, the assertion of an awakened popular will, the realization in actual politics of lofty ideals, the sight of living flesh-and-blood men of the highest ability and respecta- bility out in the struggle, fighting with the superb skill long consecrated to bus- iness for the attainment of a truer de- mocracy, and fighting with a success that makes their baffled opponents look like tyros. The people can be trusted. Give them a man possessed of a modi- cum of ability, fired with a desire to serve them, and their ready spirit of hero-worship can be counted upon to do This is the hey-day of the He has before him a richness of opportunity that, in its rewards no less than in its be matched by nothing short of the most dramatic moments of the rest. statesman of the new school. demands, can our history. THE BALLINGER INQUIRY. The Ballinger investigation came to an end ot long-protracted hearings in the the oral On last week with arguments the attorneys. neither side was an attempt made to cover with convincing precision all the points in dispute. This limited time at the disposal of counsel, as would indeed was impossible in the be shown by the attempt of any impar- to settle one of Not until briefs have been submitted, and the evidence studied in the light that they should turnish, will a trustworthy conclusion tial student a single these questions. the on the whole case be possible. Never- theless, the survey of the case afforded by the oral arguments makes the pres- ent an appropriate time for weighing the general controversy. the first points about the nature and genesis of In place, there are some the case of which the public needs to be reminded. Especially as regards Mr. Glavis, it is necessary to recall to mind initial connection Whatever character of his the basis there may be, or may be alleged the with matters involved. to be, for supposing that the animating behind past ten or twelve months is of a politi- loree the developments of the cal or personal nature, no such allega- tion can be made as to Mr. Glavis’s first resolute interposition in the Alaskan coal claims. No Rooseveltian plot can have been at the bottom of his zealous inter- ference in the year 1907, to prevent the patenting of the Cunningham and oth- er claims without searching inquiry. Mr. Ballinger was at that time Commission-

Page 9

June 2, 1910] er of the General Land Office; but Mr. Garfield was Secretary of the Interior, and Mr. Roosevelt was President. An intense desire to preserve for the nation valuable lands to which the private claimants were not in his judgment law- fully entitled is the only motive which could at that time have actuated Mr. Glavis. ity of a political motive, but personal Not only was there no possibil- animus was equally out of the question. His efforts were made within the Land Office, and they were successful. There arose at that time no complaint or scan- dal. was It is not impossible that Mr. Glavis over-zealous or that his judgment but the fact is that for was at fault; two years, unremittingly, he stuck to this line, no matter who was Land Com missioner, or Secretary of the Interior, he had course to Attorney-General Wickersham, and finally to President Taft. suance of his formal statement to the or President. Eventually, re- In pur- President, Mr. Taft called upon Secre tary Ballinger and others for replies; and, having examined these replies, he exonerated Mr. Ballinger and his subor- dinates and authorized the discharge of Glavis. Only after his discharge, and more than two years after the begin- ning of his activity, did Mr. Glavis en ter into a public agitation of the case through Collier's. A second point, which should be clear- ly apprehended, is that the question be fore the committee, the President, and the people, all along, has not concerned corrupt conduct on the part of Mr. Bal- The whether he is and always has fulfilled the linger. question has been, peculiar responsibilities of his office with single-minded fidelity to the rights and interests of the nation. To show that safe interests have not been in it those hands, is not necessary to con- vict him of a pre-conceived purpose to betray them, or to prove the existence of any corrupt motive. If, in point of fact, he has been eager to facilitate the patenting of doubtful if, in point of fact, he has been conspicuous- claims; ly wanting in zea! for the protection of the nation’s rights—the charge made by his opponents is established. The accus- ations against him under this head re late on the one hand to his attitude to ward the Forestry and Reclamation Ser vice, and, on the other, to his conduct concerning the Alaskan coal lands, espe the claims. The cially Cunningham The Nation. questions of fact and law involved are anything but simple; but as regards the coal lands, some indication of the sit- uation may be given. It is agreed on all hands that the ex- isting law on the subject of Alaskan coal lands is utterly unadapted to the That is signed to prevent the taking up of large the situation concerned. law de- tracts by private owners normal amount permissible being limited to 160 But these worked profitably 1n small parcels; and acres. lands cannot be everybody agrees that a radical change Meanwhile, atti- One should be made in the law there are two opposite be however, tudes which may adopted is, that so far as possible the land should remain the possession of the nation un- til such time as legal provision shall be made whereby large holdings can be worked, with the people coming in for their full of the benefit of such working: the other is, that inasmuch as share the land cannot be worked in small par- the with while cels, Government should look leniency upon devices whereby, superficially observing the law, private interests may contrive to get possession of upon the easy terms designed for small large and extremely valuable tracts holders. That there is a certain amount of sentiment in the far West in favor of that it {is the view taken and promoted by the cap- this latter view is probable: italists interested in getting possession of the lands goes without saving. And what seems established with a fair ap- proach to conclusiveness, in spite of the complexities and contradictions of the mass of evidence, is that Mr. Ballinger’s acts were largely influenced by this view o” the case, and that, but for the dogged opposition of Mr. Glavis,this view would have prevailed long ago in the Cunning- ham claims. To substantiate this assertion it would be necessary to adduce a number of spe- cial circumstances, all pointing in that direction, which have been brought out in the evidence. There is hardly one of has the them for which some explanation not been offered, and to examine pros and cons thus presented ts here out ot the question. It fs only by consider- them in conjunction, and getting ing their net result after all criticisms and explanations have been allowed for, that one can estimate their true significance For this reason, it is so regrettable from the standpoint of Mr. Ballinger that the er OL extraordinary series of inaccuracies and concealments took place which was the two weeks centre of public attention ago. In consequence of these develop- ments, the President's letter of exonera- tion and the Attorney-General’s sum- mary and opinion have been largely de- prived of the weight that would natur- ally attach to them. In default of a read ing of the evidence—an impossible task to all but one person in a hundred thou- sand—it is upon the judgment of such referees that people naturally rely. That the the General were themselves fully assured of both President and Attorney- of their conclusions, we en- doubt; the justice tertain not the slightest but it by no means so certain that in arriv- at these conclusions they were not duly guided by ez-parte information id assistance. No survey of the case, however broad ind general, can omit a reference to Mr. Ballinger’s conduct on the _ witness- nd. In several instances, when ques- tioned by Mr. Brandeis concerning ex tremely simple matters of fact, he made a pitiable exhibition of shiftiness, eva their righ and—to call things by To deny s810n, name—untruthfulness a thing and almost in the next breath to admit it when denial was plainly useless; to say he knew nothing about a matter, ind, after a little prodding, to show that he remembered it quite accuratel to presetit the appearance of one willing to lie, and yet afraid to stick—this is showing not only lamentable in itself, ut doubly significant in its relation to he case. It is significant in regard to the trustworthiness of his statements in is significant as bear- of general; and it ing on the question his fitness for the custodianship of the great national nterests of which the Secretary of the interior is the trustee. We would not agnify the circumstance; we would ot say that Mr. Ballinger’s character is » be measured by these manifestations. ome men, not particularly dishonest, is instinctively at straws when £Trasp ed in an uncomfortable position; and would not say that more than this is true of Mr. Ballinger. But it is not to keeping of such men that we en ust great national possessions for the zure of which shrewd and unscrupu ious and powerful private interests are constantly on the alert: nor is it to the statements of such men that we ive the benefit of every po ible

Page 10

8! | 7~ 52 doubt when confronted with oppos ing evidence DESERTERS FROM FICTION. al of half a dozen numbers of half a dozen leading A statisti comparison magazines today and five years ago would probably show a marked decrease in the relative number of short stories printed. A critical comparison between the short fiction of to-day and of five years ago would probably show a de- cline in quality fairly parallel with the quantity. Fiction has fared decline in best in the older type of magazine. Where the appeal is to the esthetic and the short has the better chance. not to the militant virtues, story naturally Th our newer and more popular magaziner special article which has turned into gory battlefields of humanity hag naturally served to crowd out the mere idle issue of al- three of tales. The June older teller one of the magazines prints as man short stories as most among the best-known of the monthlies whose reputation has been made in the fight for God, country, and circulation. By so much as the popular monthlies have absorbed the functions of the news paper and won thereby the unrestrain ed admiration of Mr. William Archer, by so much have they naturally nar rowed the fleld for the older kind of imaginative literature If quality gone down with the supply it is largely because of facts that lie in our native psychology. No one has ever denied that in imitating, adapt- ing, and improving we are enormously Mr. Willlam natural that there should be good short clever Archer thinks it story writers in America because Amer ica is the original home of the short story. Mr. Archer is wrong when he imagines that the marketable magazine story of the last dozen years has any perceptible relationship with Edgar Al- It is an Englishman, Rudyard Kipling, that lan Poe and Nathaniel Hawthorne has conditioned and shaped the prevail ing of the American short story. It Kipling’s terrifically nonchalant grown type is Kipling’s plots, Kipling’s dash, upness, Kipling’s tricks of style and very phraseology that stand out as the one powerful influence in our newer magazine pages And as we have imi tated Kipling, we have imitated such minor influences as have appeared from The Nation. time to time. In other words, we have an enormous writing class in this coun- try who write less from impulse than for business reasons, and who write less what they want than what the editors want. With our native cleverness it is possible for us to turn out excellent Kip- ling stories when the editors desire Kip- ling, excellent dialect fiction when that is what the public desires, excellent cow- boy fiction, excellent “uplift” fiction, ex- cellent detective and murder stories. It follows that when the editors want no stories, or few stories, of any kind, ex- cellent stories will cease to be written in such numbers, and the adaptable American mind will turn to what the editor does want. Hands that the enchanted wand of fic- tion might have swayed are now busy turning out special copy, and fairly good copy at that, such being our incredible cleverness and adaptability. It is pos- sible to cite from this month’s maga- zines nearly half a dozen concrete in- stances of men and women who, having made their first appearance as writers of short stories, have been hired by the editors for service on the firing line. One woman has been detailed to expose the horrid evils that inhere in the five and ten-cent stores, gigantic nurseries of wo- man's extravagance. Another woman in another magazine assails another form of the same shopping evil. A writer of short stories, strongly impregnated with the atmosphere of the East Side, now girds at wicked Pittsburgh and now at the horrors of the State workhouses. Two years ago a novel of brilliant prom- ise came from a young man in Boston Since then his decline has been steady. First he began to write for the maga- zines the kind of stories the magazines at that time liked. Then he was drafted for muck-rake duty. He is now pretty far from the fine originality of his first book making a good many thousand dollars a year. His case and is probably exemplifies strikingly the workings of | the average editorial mind. It is in the nature of the editor to like live topics, it is in his nature to like live names. What more reasonable, there- fore, than to take this young man who and writes such excellent stories, which un- fortunately have gone a good deal out of style, and set him to work on some- thing statistical, brisk, and terrifying that Is in style? It is an editorial point of view which in its ultimate manjifesta- [ Vol. go, No. 2344 tion would write, “My dear Mr. Kip- ling: We foresee a hit in a series of articles dealing with brutality and un- derfeeding in the Indian army, at your own terms, of course”; or cable: “Ros- tand, Paris: Could use four articles showing connection French Prime Min- ister theft church property; wire accept- ance and text.” So much fiction as survives in the militant monthlies is of a lower order, on the whole, than the fiction of the pe- riod before the moral awakening. After half a dozen special articles detailing the horrors of graft, smallpox, intermar- morphinism, tight-lacing, and over-study, the reader must have his fair measure of relief. There is very little chance, consequently, for anything but the lightest of fiction. The detective story flourishes like a green bay-tree in the company of the wildest of Wild West stories and the frankly farcical ad- cannibal riage, ventures of missionaries in lands. Not that the appetite for fiction is declining. This is shown by the up- growth of a large number of magazines which print nothing but fiction, and vast quantities of it. Apparently, the aver- age reader has let himself be persuaded that the real magazine must be chiefly social and strenuous; to quench his long- “all-story” thus learning to take his ing for fiction he buys an magazine, recreation and nis excitement in separ- ate doses. That this condition of things will be permanent or even lasting, we refuse io If the editors do not get ex- hausted, the field of human interest is pretty sure to be. And then there will be a return to the older type. Already the pioneer magazine of the militant cast is gravitating towards earlier con- believe. ditions. THE LONELINESS OF THE RETIRED There passed through New York last week, bound to London, a former resi- dent of Kansas City who, unlike most Americans, decided that he would not die in harness. He had made enough money some ten years ago to supply his wants, and the mere piling up of more dollars had no interest for him. So he turned over his business to younger men and sought to enjoy quietly the remain- der of his years. What was the result? Chis typical Westerner, who had liter- ally grown up with Kansas City, found

Page 11

June 2, 1910] himself ere long a permanent resident of the capital of a foreign country. No snobbishness took him to London, how- ever, and no desire to force his way into foreign society. Unlike some ex- tremely rich Americans who had preced- ed him to the other side, he was in no- wise dissatisfied with being an Ameri- can, or convinced that England is a better country than that in which he “made his pile.’ Why, then, does he reside in London? The question was put to him by a re- porter, who plainly could not conceal his amazement that anybody would live in London who might live in Kansas City. We give the answer precisely as the re- porter printed it: Well, there is no place in America for a man out of a job. Over there you will find more people in the same position and you can associate with them. Here, after I go in and shake hands with my friends, they wouder how soon I am going to leave, so that they can get back to work. Every Englishman, no matter to what class he belengs, gets to a certain point when he scops work. There it is, in a nutshell; it is the un- utterable American with leisure on his which has made this man turn his back on Kan- sas City, its heights, its river, its cattle- loneliness of the hands yards, and its turreted homes. He could not spend the whole day watering his lawn or watching the trains come into that horrible Kansas City pigsty mis- named a station, or driving an automo- bile, waiting for his triends to come back from work. or in We are inclined to think, too, that, in addition to his loneliness, a sort of sociaf stigma heip- ed to drive him to another clime. It is still felt in many communities that there must be something wrong with one who will not earn money when he can. A man of leisure, it is instinctively under- stood, must turn to the Devil for aid in passing his time; as a matter of course, he is also a “man about town.” Now, it must not be thought that the ease of this wayward Kansas City citi- zen is altogether exceptional. The plaint he utters reaches us quite frequently. The man whose health does not permit of strenuous office labor, the man otf moderate income with bookish taste, the retired capitalist, the superannuated bank president, are all hard put to it to obtain sufficient human companion- ship. This is particuiarly true of retir- ed army and navy officers. A fixed day, their sixty-fourth birthday, finds them rym 7 : The Nation. promptly sheived. regiments or the command of depart ments or of fleets at the stroke of noon the fatal der homewards to the towns they on anniversary. They wan came trom, only to find that after the first week’s issue of the Daily Watchword recounting their gallant services on land and sea, their friends can hardly conceal their impatience if these veter their of second time at it is that ans appear a fices. Hence for the retired He can- with- officer Washington is a Mecca. not walk down Connecticut Avenue out meeting a score of men he knew in service. Colonel, general, and ad- one of these titles he applies to almost every man he meets. The Army and Navy Club or the Metropolitan al- Somebody is the miral- ways has its occupants. sure to ask the veteran how he swam ashore in that gale at Samoa, or charged down the road in the Wilderness the time poor Harry Smith got that bullet in his brain. The human touch that makes the whole world kin is there. But not officers alone find Washing- ton the ideal city for men with plenty of time on their hands. Even our Kan- sas City wanderer would have discover- ed associates. For side by side with of ficial Washington is growing up another Washington, comprising men and wo- men of wealth or social leanings who like the capital’s cosmopolitan flavor, who enjoy meeting the Chinese Ambas sador, the colonel fresh from the Philip- pines, and the titled attaché of the Brit ish Embassy, at the endless teas and innel of the seasot kor tho-e of m sober tastes there are the vast treasu! in the Library of Congress and the oth er storehouses of learning and science for which Wasnington is famous, and the companionship of the growing body and but starve in the Government bureaus. of scientists who slave all A leisure class, indeed, whatever the age of its members, is not altogether an evil. Perhaps the men in it will help 'to redeem their sex from the old slur that only women keep alive in Amer- ica the handsomer things of life, But first they must learn the difference be tween mere restless idling and that hap- py leisure which means the opportunity for many finer activities. fhey give up their _— — . edede NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES Frederik Muller of Ams } " teworthy f ma ay | r Jui ] and 17, wh sl d 8} al & t of those in- ' arli of the city i Island. A d riptive cata- of th collections to be disposed of ‘ y ple l autographs and pe on of Jhr. Ridder an Rappard and others The tale is en- fr the collector's point of view. Ther are the signatures of Charles V, Wil he Silent, Napoleon; of scientists Boerhay Galileo, Franklin: of giat philosophers, and writers of last three centuries But the auto- rapl i ly examples of others of their kind; the letters do not, apparently, offer new intormation Bundle 1,795 is another matter, Herein are found seven documents relating to New Nethe 1624-26 They purport to be originals, but copies at the time. Of the originals trace, so that the contents are new to us; and the rland, do not made have we no comments are certainly valuable if they fulfil the promise of the catalogue. It is curious that documents pertaining to New ming to light. the Michaelis Netherland are so slow in « Before the discovery (1904) of letter of August, 1628, nothing had been found for about forty years. Now this re- port of 1626 suddenly appears. The list is as follows: A. Rule for colonists to the West Indies on t) hip Nieu Verdriet, “The New Sor- row {not an auspicious name to nvite gration]. ) pl I I ter oO Ja va R ! \ 20 \ l I Wiap o f het for h i a 625." 5 pp ( Instruction for Wille Val H st ( ol the voyage to New Netl ind p iat 1625 (7). 22 pp. D>. Further nstructions for this ime Willem van Hulst. Amsterdam, Ap. 22. 1625 ' Part tla nstructions fo th ind land irveyor Crvn Fr af nstruction of a fort in ‘ r j | An 4 lf , 19 nn | tiled f rt Isaa | i re ] ] t \ | Cs; r the +} Palama ; Mar ‘ Th tair | | of > 30 effor sh 1 b | ) | } i f< y K i { r ; r} } wot ?} i! r i ate | yn ely a ind led ( ‘orrespondence., MARK TWAIN, SIR THOMAS BROWNE, AND THE OLD TESTAMENT TO THE EDITOR ¢ rut NATION Sin: Prof. William Lyon Phelps, in an interesting article in the Independent for May points out a parallel to Mark Twain's delightful story of “Isaac” and the prophets of Baal and how the water poured over the altar turned out to be petroleum. It certainly looks, at first sight is though the same devil that w! ered » the disquieting of Sir Thomas Browne had reappeared for the comforting of Cz

Page 12

554 Wakeman (alias “Hurricane Jones”). As Browne’s “Religio Medici” says (I quote from Professor Phelps'’s article): Again, . . having read far more of Naptha, he [the Devil] whispered to my curiosity the fire of the Altar might be natural: and bid me mistrust a miracle in E:..8, when he entrenched the Altar round with Water. But it Is probable that this explanation of the origin and recurrence of the petro- leum idea gives the devil more (or less) than his due For some time past I have had in mind ll older parallel, which has occurred a sii to me whenever I have thought of Mark Twain's story It is a bit of narrative which is to be found in the Old Testament, though In a portion of it which is not as familiar to Bible readers now as it was a few generations ago. In II Maccabees |, 19 ff. we read how the sacred fire on the Jerusalem was rekindled, after of the exiles. Nehemiah had from Babylonia, bringing with him the secret of the place where the fire had been hidden by the Jewish priests, many years before. He sent some of the of those priests to find it, but they returned with the news they found no fire, but only “thick wa- “he commanded them altar in the return great come in a deep well, descendants that ter." Then (vs. 21) to draw it up, and to bring it; and when the icrifices were laid on, Neemias com- manded the priests to sprinkle the wood und the things lald thereupon with the water. (22) When this was done, and the n " that the sun shone, which afore wa hid in the cloud, there was a great fire kindled, so that every man marvelled.” But th was not all After the sacrifice had been umed, (vs. 31) ‘“‘Neemias ‘ nanded the water that was left to be poured over certain great stones. (32) When this wa ) there was kindled a fla but it w extinguished by the light that shone f ) the altar.” The obvious purpose of tl 1 episode is to show that r t water,” while always capa- ble of produ fire when greatly heated did not of itself produce sacred fire The flame on the holy altar at once quenched the rival blaze, though the two had been kindled in the same way And finally, that there may be no doubt as to the na- ture of this water,” the narrator adds in ve. 36 that Nehemiah (following a seduc tive etymology) “‘called the stuff Naphthar though most men call it Naphtha.” Now, it may well be that Capt. Ned Wakeman was not acquainted with this leg end: though it is in the inherited family Bibles of just such old stagers as he that the Apocrypha chiefly survive among us to- day, and we may be sure that he would have read or heard such narratives as this with especial satisfaction At all events, we may give hia inventive faculty the benefit of the doubt But in the case of Sir Thomas Browne there can be no doubt at all. He was perfectly familiar with the account of how Nehemiah watered the great altar with petroleum, and thus re stored the perpetual fire. What the devil whispered to him was merely the sugges- tion that perhaps this had been the stan- dard method of renewing the sacred fire whenever the altar had been rebuilt, and that therefore Elijah himself, in his great The Nation. encounter with the priests of Baal, had only made use of this same old oil. CHARLES C. TORREY. | Yale University, May 25. CAPTAIN ALDEN PARTRIDGE. EpITtoR OF THE NATION: In your issue of May 5, under the ambiguous heading ‘“‘West Point in 1824,” you print an interesting old letter, written from Norwich, Vt., under date of July 9, 1824, by Theodore Sedgwick, jr., to Harman- us Bleecker of Albany, N. Y. It is per- fectly clear that Sedgwick’s detailed de- scription of the routine and curriculum of “the academy” refers to Captain Alden Partridge’s famous school, known at the | time of its foundation (September, 1820) as “The American Literary, Scientific, and Military Academy”—the forerunner of Nor- wich University, now situated at Northfield, | Vt. For reasons not easily discoverable | Captain Partridge’s “Academy” was remov- | ed from Norwich, Vt., to Middletown, Conn., in August, 1825, and remained there until | 1829. Then, not being able to obtain from | the Connecticut Legislature such privileges | as he thought that he deserved, Partridge removed back to Norwich. The buildings at Middletown, which had been carefully con- structed under Partridge’s supervision, later formed the nucleus of Wesleyan University, an institution chartered in 1831. Inasmuch as Alden Partridge left an impression as an educator on his generation that is deserv- ing of more careful record than it has yet received, will you allow me briefly to re- call hig career? Alden Partridge Vt., in 1785. He died there in 1854. For a brief time he was a student at Dart- mouth College, but he gained admission to the academy at West Point and graduated there in the Engineer Corps in 1806. Receiv- appointment on the teaching staff West Partridge was known soon as an exceptional teacher of mathematics and was deeply interested in the education- al features of tactics and military drill. Be- To SIR: THE was born in Norwich, ing an at Point, fore he was thirty years old, he was pro- moted (1813) to a professorship of civil and military engineering; later, for up- wards of three years, he occupied the posi- tion of superintendent of West Point. His administration, however, did not satisfy the national authorities, and he was vir- tually forced to leave his place. After aid- ing as a practical surveyor in striking out the Maine boundary in the summer of 1819, he to turn his enthusiastic na- ture to the work of establishing a school in his native town of Norwich. This school he opened in September, 1820. Boys from the best New England homes came to it. Among the early catalogues, one finds the names of boys from Michigan, from Ohio, from Charleston, 8. C., and elsewhere in the South, and occasionally from Cuba and parts of South America. In later years, | Partridge was sufficiently encouraged or | persistent to try to found similar private schools along the Atlantic slope—at Pem- broke, N. H., at Brandywine Springs, Del., at Harrisbure, Pa., at Portsmouth, Va., and even as far south as the State of Missis- sippl. Devoted to his school projects, he was able for a time to be useful as sur- | was free yet veyor-general of Vermont, Between 1830-40, he was four times chosen a member of the Vermont Legislature. | ics, ‘and in a knowledge of military tactics. {Healthy boys |} thought, at all times of the year. [Vol. 90, No. 2344 Partridge, in truth, stood for certain rational and—for his day—very advanced ideals in education. In the first place, he was among the earliest protestants against too conservative classical modes of train- ing. While willing to admit Latin and Greek into the curriculum, he had firm faith in the discipline to be gained from mathematics and from what would gener- ally be called scientific studies—from jhys- chemistry, geology, and mineralogy. He was careful to provide instruction in the modern languages, notably in French, Spanish, and even Italian. Sprung from a line of colonial fighters, trained to some extent at West Point, he believed in the value to every youngster of military drill To long idle vacations he was sternly opposed. should be occupied, he They should be subjected, moreover, to the open air in all sorts of weather. One of the most characteristic features of his school was the trips which he made with the cadets, trips which always in- cluded places of historic or scientific in- terest, not too far removed from Norwich or Middletown. On these trips records of a casual or scientific nature were kept: heights were calculated; observations of the weather were taken; notes of the scen- lery and of the occupations of the inhabi- tants of various regions were set down. Usually a printed Journal was published. These old Journals contain the names of the cadets and general accounts of the en- tire course of the trips. There was, for example, a corps of 115 boys organized in June, 1822, which went from Norwich to Concord, N. H., where the Legislature of New Hampshire was then in session, and which returned by a different road, Capt. Partridge addressed the Legislature on the subject (a favorite one with him) of the Battle of Waterloo. The Governor review- ed the corps. In June, 1824, a similar corps of students went from Norwich across the State of Vermont on foot to Whitehall. There they took the boat for Burlington and Plattsburgh, passing Ticonderoga and Crown Point, and returned to Norwizh by way of Vergennes. It is to this trip that the letter of Theodore Sedgwick refers. In the autumn of the same year some fifty cadets, among whom was Gideon Welles, years later Lincoln’s Secretary of the Navy, went to the White Mountains, where they climbed Mt. Washington and camped on its side. The longest expedition of which I have discovered a record was made in De- cember, 1826, from Middletown, Conn.— then the temporary location of the Acad- emy—when a corps of cadets embarked on the Oliver Ellsworth for New York city. Thence they crossed New Jersey via Tren- ton on foot, passed through Philadelphia, and over a portion of Delaware to the head of Chesapeake Bay, where they were trans- ported to Baltimore. From there they tramped to Washington, D. C. At Wash- ington the corps visited the Capitol, where they saw the Senate and the House in ses- sion. They were cordially received by President John Quincy Adams. The Secre- tary of War (James Barbour) addressed to them a few remarks in the nature of a homily. At Mount Vernon Judge Bushrod Washington showed them the points of spe- cial interest, and opened the vault that, in 99 ve ‘the language of their Journal, “contained

Page 13

June 2, 1910] the mouldering remains of the greatest and best of men.” After this sort of evidence one may fairly assume that, were Alden Partridge alive to-day, he would be deeply interested in many phases of the movement toward a more rational system of education, particu- larly in out-of-door observation and ex- ercise, of which he was one of the earliest American exponents. Many of his students found, as time went on, useful places in the work of the world: and some of them gave evidence of their sound military train- ing under him in connection with the Mex- ican and the civil They were to be found in high and low places in the and the navy. It young as Gideon Welles, Josiah Tatnall, George M Colvocoresses, Horatio and Thomas H. Sey- mour, Theodore Sedgwick, Thomas Ruther- ford Trowbridge, William H. Russell of New Haven, into close touch with much that was admirable in Capt Partridge’s spirit, and were the means of earrying his to a later gen- eration. wars. army men was such and who came influence on In an early manuscript diary kept by the late Secretary of the Navy, Gideon Welles, the writer speaks of meeting Capt. Part- ridge in Hartford, Conn., in the spring of 1842. Partridge had given a lecture on the subject of the “National Defences.” Mr. Welles found the lecture interesting and instructive. “Capt. Partridge,” he re- marked, “condemns a standing army as inconsistent with public liberty, and would rely for national defence on the people themselves. These he would educate to be not only scholars, but soldiers.” Of the man himself, Welles set down this ma- tured judgment: “He still possesses and exhibits that strong, marked, and honest good sense for which he was uniformly dis- tinguished, and I find the high admiration and regard of early life was not in this instance, certainly, an over-estimate of the man.” HENRY BARRETT LEARNED New Haven, Co May 26 THE HETCH HETCHY WATER SUPPLY. To THE Epiro! me TH Na SIR: In your issue of April 21 there appears a communication from Mr. George Edwards, Berkeler, Cal., in which he un- on the Hetch to make supply of San dertakes to throw “new light’”’ Hetchy water supply. He endeavors it appear that the water Francisco and adjacent cities is a matterof when it preéminently a of flood waters which would otherwise go to waste. He attempts to make it appear that Cherry Creek and Cherry Valley are in the reservation called area drained, is matter of storage “Yosemite National Park,”’ when they are beyond the limits of that reservation; also that Cherry Creek drainage basin and the reservoirs therein are “conceded”’ to San Francisco, when they are all in the hands of a private corporation by appropriation and grant under the laws of Congress, and if acquired by San Francisco, will have to be acquired at great cost, but to the bene- fit of those corporations who have acquired them at slight cost and by “appropriation” and “filing.” Mr. Edwards not only advocates the de- privation of San Francisco of her ultimate right to store waste waters in the Hetch and individuals The Hetchy reservoir, of which she owns more Nation. than one-half by purchase reating upon patents issued by the United States govern- prior to the establishment of the res but also wishes to deprive right the remainder cf «ranted elty, a single Tuolumne, ment her this and of waste flows he to ust rvation, of reservoir of the water the already to the to main gallon which all right of the to the sea each year of ble der Now, which subject n excess possi- inds instead of the so-called “‘new light Mr. throw «n old Edwards let truth and fact ot ent of attempt o us have a little of the ot ISSS reservoirs surveyed by the government charged duty were set apart to public use law of October 1, 1890, a reservation Yosemite National and ri regulations the of natural curiosities of ubsequently known as Park,’ was defined, gid provided regarding injury timber, mineral deposits, or wonders, within the limits said reserva- tion and their retention tn their natura) ondition. (26th Stat. at L., 651) In 1898, the reservoirs in this reserva- tion were surveyed by the United States Geological Survey, the storage at various evels estimated, and types of structures inned for their utilization Among these were both Hetch Hetchy and Lake Eleanor reservoirs (See I S. Geol. Survey, 2ist Annual Report, page 453.) On February 15, 1901, after an experien- of more than ten years with the law just referred to, and in the light of the re- searches of th United Stat Geological Surv Co s assed ‘ ict empow- ering the > iry 0 t Interior to rermit the u f rights of way through lic lands, Yosemit Sequoia, and Gen cral Grant National Parks, for canals and ervoirs f he pply of water for do ti publ r any other beneficial se (31 Sta at ‘4 790) By the law of Feb ruary i ! of way wer presented. by Congress to San Francisco for municipal purpose and under this law are revocabl iuring tl od of their eneficial use (33 Stat at | 28) Under the law of 1901 San Francisco surveyed aad pplied for reservoir rights of way fo wo of the reservoirs designated and covered b the provisions of the abov law th rights were granted, and ther no ju yossibility of their revocation Secretary of the Interior Hitchcock, under the able tutelage of the chief engineer of the Spring Valley Water Company, denied these rights, mder the law of February 15, 1901, both upon original anplication and a subsequent rehearing, but Secretary Garfield, whe ot an apt pupil! of “the interests,” after an opinion rendered by the attorney-gen- eral of the United State and a areful hearing both in San Francisco and n Washington, granted these reservoir rign f way to San Francisco, subject to certain vtipulations, among which was one requir ing the development of Lake Eleanor res voir to its maximum extent before the Hetch Hetchy reservoir should be under taken Under this grant, more than one- half the reservuir area in each r rvoir has been purchased and is held in fee sim- nle by San Francisco, under patents gran ed by the United States government prior to the establishment of the reservation The cost of these purchases and of land for exchange for the remainder of the res — Oe ede de ‘rvoir areas and of their survey and 4 velopment to date, is in excess of $600, m0 These ownerships and the gra at mentioned constitute vested the manifest purpose of Mr. Edwa iegations to effect a withdra Francisco's rights to such a " ) remove an adeq ba f s ‘ the Stat f lifornia f 1 | \ pply San F sco is prepared to t the provisions of th tipula 1 the rant of May 11, 1908, provided h wi ! h ‘ voir a 1 ind t eto hall e mutilated ’ < nt of depriving her {f that jf ype es wi } s th x | i of $45,000,000, 1 itl oO 1 for n k y & majority « I tha “ y I any i ind fats te should ip] r tro h i y iain i ment of the y it San Fra vested rights of which she canno ) 1 prived if the Federal Ad histration s faith with this city Mr. Edwards misstat« the prior rigl f the irrigation d 3 He would t appear that they i i x 00.000 gallons a da r i nly when the natural flow of } equal to or beyond h 1 t i they, under the laws of th: " eficial 18¢ thereof These l lave legal rights to water to t ex capacity of their diverting inals, wh the natural flow of the river apabl yielding this amount San Fra ) is recognized their hts to an ext far greater tha th legal " | to the full « second f r ig ‘ » prop to ake l 1 wa + n ex of this natural flow, l otherwise be wasted The at M Edwards to apportion and 4 | ! ater rf ruolu River |} reen f irea lrained ly n th x ‘ the proble t o f ‘ lraina e ¢ , Frat oO to h ! n ree ) id f " it La Grang i a net ain Ww } t | for in pal i i and use will not in the | the rights of the irrigat ! I representatives of th | I ‘ussion held at Modesto in J ] r ognized that it was not a prol f ad version and use of water or f flood waters for storag but a probl f storage alon They have t i ! that San Fra » does not intend » di vert, and will not divert waters except in excess of 2,350 nd f which is the ultimate limit of their right is fixed by their own filings The chare therefor that a few dis honest men are maturing in secret a p so atrocious that thev hay not yet dared to whisper it in public, and that they ar in cold-blooded villany preparing to rol the irrigationists and to convert their homes into a desert waste,” are ignorant and vicious It would be well for the pul iM Edwards knows of any such utr plot,” for him to state it, instead of timating the existence of such a plot wit out a clear and distinct statement of what it js and who are its originators. The con-

Page 14

SHAKESPEARE’S CASAR.” oO THe NATION uld like to bring to Shakespeare rian which of the riraboschi but é there stories drama, in of are a found merit, is later Shakespeare Plutarch, the common dramas f these passages id., il, and 1-9 Ces., Pp. 3, 3 75, 1. 20-28, i , 6-8 187-190 62-63 Ces., p. 2 Ces., l li 126, 1 tiranno lodegne somma giorta, nel sacro sangue gilt Kuripid! non teatri eventure j revenged ! About! Seek! Burn! Kill! » traitor live! l. 3-5 the students lo Pescetti, published In p 7. & i, 11, 106-1 20-21 source +_° 1-1 porga Slay! “JULIUS at- the has been overlooked though The tragedy particular number in the “‘Jul- though they are of i 1 | The Nation. Ar Degli empl arme, sangue, ammazza, ammazza, traditor non restl razza,. sangue, verbal yincidences, but the exclazsatory style There are points in used in both dramas in deciding and used the No mily the similarities in worth noticing the ibject matter value knew which will also have whether Shakespeare of Pescetti. I hope to find time and strength to pub- lish the work I have prepared on Orlando Pescetti in the more exhaustive form he fully deserves, for all his writings merit recognition. List CIPRIANI. Cesare”’ New York, May 27 THE AMERICAN FEDERATION OF LABOR. rue EpiTtror or THE NATION: Sir: I misstatement would call your attention to a of fact appearing in the comment upon the death of Mr. James Van in the Nation of May 19. In this article the statement appears: “The officials of the American Federation of La- announced that they were superior to decrees of the Supreme Court of the United States and continued to violate its injunct'on,” The Supreme Court of United States did not issue the injunc- n question. It was issued by Federal Court of the District of And further, the Court of Ap- peals of the District of Columbia has since held that the Federal Court in issuing the Cleave for any etc. Columbia in eeded njunction. This difference may seem a small matter, of many in ch misrepresentations have been made— without doubt, unintentionally—which placed the officials of the American Federation of Labor, their acts, and their utterances, in a false light before the gen- this some respects ext its authority but it is only one instance whi sften have public, especially when case has consideration. eral been under E. C. MORRIs. New York, May 26 COLLEGE DEBATING. EDITOR OF THE NATION: May 5 Writing” cens Your editorial of Debating book” the upon and ires method of debating, and value the debater problem A to of dis rrent wrong im b toria which en- gained from the ed of in college ay the forensics ‘ hool l s the nature and students are that iakes a mere parrot of the pupil is worthy of nothing but Yet it is ilso true that legitimate means of assist- should encouraged To the ob- erver the change the old to the new of teaching forensics doubtless seems The but a the teaching—a article suggests, any system condemnation ince be from way dd nothing alteration, however, as been of the scholastik general transi- from the empirical of change that has iken place in every department of higher This other similar One part tion to nethod education change in forensic meth- like i onception conclude from reading the the object of presenting a brief to the debater is to save ods changes, is open to might editorial, that [ Vol. go, No. 2344 him the labor of making one. Such an as- is entirely wrong. The brief merely as a model for orderly ar- rangement of argument. Any one who has engaged in debating knows that it is sui- cidal for one side to follow blindly a brief with which their opponents are, in all probability, familiar. To the statement that the modern method of brief-making has no place outside a court of appeals, a reasonable answer is that if the system is not used elsewhere, it manifestly ought to be. Brief-making teaches accuracy of thought, systematic arrangement, and the ability to discern the essential from the non-essential—all acquisitions that are desirable, whether one be in the courtroom, on the platform, or simply reading a book. After commenting upon the value of brief-making, the editorial asks: “But why, after all, should the high-school stu- dent or college student debate corporation taxes or central banks?” Why, one imme- diately wonders, should they not discuss these questions? What harm can result? Who is more willing to attempt an earnest study of corporation taxation or the prob- lem of the central bank than the college student? He has every inducement to make that study thorough. His library facilities are adequate. His work is done under su- pervision of men competent to direct. Hav- ing no cause to play the demagogue, to make the worse seem the better reason, he discusses faithfully the issues before him. His general qualifications for the task are not to be made light of. Probably at ao other time has one so good an opportunity for thorough research as during one's col- lege days. Moreover, a study of the average intercollegiate debate will show tuat it is likely to contain in one or two paragraphs kernel of a proposition that not in arranging argument would take to expound. Since men are ntering and more our legisla- halls, such training is desirable. They should in such a manner that it will not be necessary go home dinner while of the is being de- sumption serves he one rained pages college more into tive be taught to write an argument for listeners to to the main red. body speech live Inference the might be readily drawn from that the “text-book” method gnores training in delivery. Modern meth- ds teach the speaker to have something to say, they also teach him how it. What can more truly inspire a “to plead with passion” than the ousness that what he is saying con- rms to logic and fact? What can be more asily shown to be untrue, by present re- search methods, than an argument that does conform to these essentials? If sin- cerity, simplicity, and passion are desir- able elements in debate, surely the present- day method offers every inducement for their successful operation. E. CLYDE The State University of lowa, May 21. editorial not only oO Say debater ons¢ not ROBBINS THE “AUGUSTAN” AGE. To THE EDITOR THE NATION: Sir: How old is the word “Augustan” as applied to the literature of the eighteenth century? The Oxford Dictionary’s first ref- erence js 1819, and that from a dictionary, where it ig stated that “The reign of Queen often called the Augustan age of or Anne 18

Page 15

June 2, 1910] England.” Horace Walpole, William Mason, July 21, 1772, What a figure will this our age make; Garrick’s prologues, epilogues, library f writing to says: Augustan and verses What a of poetry, taste, good sense, veracity, and vi- vacity! ungrateful Shebbear! indolent Smollett! trifling Johnson! piddling Gold- smith! how little have they contributed to the glory of a period in which all arts, all sciences, are encouraged and rewarded . « « The retrospect makes one melan- choly, but Ossian has appeared, and were Paradise once more lost, we should not want an epic poem. All which is delightfully bad criticism, in addition to being an early reference to the word in question. JAMES W. TUPPER. Lafayette College, May 24. Literature. THE MAKER OF JOHNS HOPKINS. The Life of Daniel Coit Gilman. By Fabian Franklin. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. $3.50. Some or other the historian of America in the nineteenth century will mark the rise of a new and exacting profession that broke many mediocre persons and greatly exalted a few per- sons of uncommon parts. To be a uni- versity president in the period of ex- panding science, implied the negation of academic ease. Where a rector mag- nificus, a provost, or other traditional academic chief merely administered small and carefully husbanded revenues and ruled a compact body of teachers, the American university president had to be competent in numerous extra-aca- demic functions. Besides the duty of administration within the _ scholastic family, a sufficiently difficult task, he had to deal on equal terms with men of great affairs, trustees, donors, and the like. Frequently he had to beg for the growth or the very maintenance of his university from more or ignorant and hostile legislatures. Constantly he must make ideals of disinterested schol- arship both explicable and acceptable to communities and individuals frantically given over to immediate and palpable gain. In short, he was required to add to the well-balanced imagination of the scholar, the plausible audacity of the popular evangelist, and the _ effective tact and energy of the captain of indus- try. In every sense, he was compelled to convert his thinking promptly into cash values, and this with no compro- mise of the dignity of his office. For such service he received a tenth of the salary that men of like abilities received as officers of business corporations. The challenge of this new and ardu ous profession enlisted many notable time less personalities. Among them incontesta- bly the first was the late Daniel Coit Gilman. Others may have equalled him in the quality of their service, but none conducted so many important enter prises so successfully. Deeply associat- The Nation. ed with the organization of the Sheffield Scientific School, at New Haven, with the upbuilding of the University of Cal ifornia, the foundation of Johns Hopkitis University, and of Medical School, he found energy at seventy to inaugur the work of the Carnegie Institu tion, an unprecedented organization for the fostering of research, and in the last year of his life he practically gave shape to the Russell Sage Foundation for soci ological and charitable’ investigation. In treating such a career, the biograph- er had no choice but to merge the hero in his causes. This Dr. Franklin, a for- mer Johns Hopkins colleague, has done, making so many chapters out of Mr. Gil- man’s chief activities, and then adding as a sort of supplement a selection from his intimate correspondence, and a brief sketch of his family life by Mrs. Gilman. The man appears so transparently in his administrative efforts that in the in terest of symmetry, one could wish that the more essential portions of these sup- plementary chapters might have been interwoven with the general narrative. On the other hand, a large circle of Mr. Gilman’s friends—and he had the facul- ty of endearing himself to the most casual associates—will undoubtedly wel- these collected materials of inti- mate import. As to the larger issue, Dr. Franklin has set forth with admirable orderliness and lucidity the chief activi- of a varied and complicated life, and his book will be necessary not only also to all its ate come ties to admirers of the hero but students of higher education in Amer- ica, Mr. Gilman scored more, and more various, successes than any other man with education in Amer the training this ideal administrator and his fundamental who ever dealt ica. Accordingly, of of It would be foolish to deny that personality are subjects uncommon interest. his intimates found a certain mystery in his power. masterful manding officer. His was never the obviously of the conventional com His suavity in all rela complete. How the genial “I'nele Daniel” of the Johns Hopkins undergraduates did so many things and did them so infallibly well was a poser. It easy to miss the incredible industry of one who was never in a hurry, and to underrate the sterner qualities of a chief worked mostly by and persuasion. One remarks the swiftness of his judgment, his sympathy with other points of view, the measured but these are inert phrases for a vital thing. Per- haps a fine confidence in other men was his strong point. His highest praice for a friend call him remarkable sense not merely of policies, but of what could or could not be with indi vidual people. This helped him in choos ing He had the gift of being discreetly personal in matters of way tions was was suggestion who ready economy of all his processes; or colleague to He had a was “cooperative.” done his associates. ~ eed § Many a student could tell of timely admonition as to crudity in work routine, r demeanor, and such criticism n¢ eemed made by a superior but add ed to a the better judg higher court ment of the unconscious offender. Know ing his personal capacity, Mr. Gilman very reluctantly left any negotiation to the written word. He was a born com mittee chairman, and at his best in small groups with work to do. A ful speaker and writer, his impact comparatively weak in No man of our times, probably, has left so deep an impress on higher education, but many others have aroused more dis cussion and launched more theories. grace Was those regards It was part of the genius and recti tude of the man always to seem less im portant than his work. If you had visit ed Yale about 1870 and asked about Pro fessor Gilman, probably you would have got the picture brilliant dilet tante. Here was a ready man endeavor ing against official indifference to make He had everywhere with of a a workable university library travelled much, and eager curiosity for educational and char itable institutions. At twenty-thre« had spoken at Manchester and Bright, on American public schools, and had taken a heckling well. He had for a space been a diplomatic attaché at he for Cobden St. Petersburg, and transiently a maga zine editor. He had seriously considered entering the Christian ministry. A New England patrician by birth and train ing, he worked well with all manner ot men in college and out. He was in all kinds of charities and semi-public activ ities. He had organized an art loan ex hibition that paid its own expense Just the conventionally usetul and ver atile person, one would have said A shrewder observer would have noted that a new system of study had been quietly introduced into the Sheffield Scientific School, And here we face an odd and characteristic paradox, tl this orderly method of grouped ile which Mr. Gilman introduced first at Yale and afterwards at Johns Hopkir while it i teadily prevailing, has been little discussed, whereas the elective sys bank ar fact tem ed of The respective tem, which is nearly in confe ruptcy to-day, was the object an dent and diffused propaganda. the peraments of two great university presi dents. In his hour of discouragement in California and periodically at other Mr. Gilman leaned jour nalism. We think he was of it His public were conciliatory, if he words. gives a sidelight on times, toward well out utterances feared It that spoke cogently. as the emphasis of mere was his accomplished deeds There are ad lresees and writings of Mr. Gilman that of his favorite idea of scientific research in Amer lle University, no seem monuments cause the simply started Johns Hopkins America itself compelled to a stern chase ica, saw This and academic

Page 16

558 highly characteristic of the man. was He was nothing of an idealogue, nour- ishing the theory for its intellectual fascination, but rather a potent evoker of sane ideas to guide the next forward step. Thus, in spite of an absolute and selfacrificing devotion—while prest- dent of Johns Hopkins he added the di- rectorship of a great hospital to fixed duties already oppressive—he gave to many some sense of facile opportunism. On the contrary, loyalty was his strong est instinct. During his brief but effec- tive term as president of the University of California he met with an ignorant political opposition that threatened the very of the university, and with the demagogic shifts of certain of His correspondence existence own vrotessors. vs how keenly he felt the lack of un- As a matter of fact, the event that he the peril of agrarian interference, but it is plain that he could not be spiritually at ease in an air where competence might mercy of charlatanry, and an- would not even play fair. Baltimore proposed Uni As the trustees made a tour ot his sho derlying trust. showed exaggerated be at the tagonists His mind the on Hopkins was already and Johns versity. information to existing universities, tour college presidents, Eliot, Porter, Angell, Andrew D. White, independently recommended him for What he proceeded to do now and the position. eems the What most natural thing in the world, could be more obvious than to natural ize in America the German university tem, admittedly the best in the vorld? We have even got to the point of q tioning whether it was really for best Would not a finer foresight have seen a greater flexibility in some day ion of the more humane univer ity organization of France? As a mat ter of fact, to found a university more feutonico was by no means an obvious course. Many people who were not fools doubted seriously if advanced students would be forthcoming in sufficient num the One Bal while genially admitting trustees to bers to justify enterprise. timore paper, the right of Johns Hopkins’s commit such a quixotry, opined that in fifty years there might be a genuine de mand for this new-fangled institution. The success of Johns Hopkins Univer sity was instantaneous and signal Its beyond the Everywhere reverberation extended far range of direct emulation. among us scholars held their heads high was being done in If Whitney Child in England relleved from ele drudgery borne for years, it was because it was known that Johns Hopkins University had desired their distinguished services. Hardly less mer itorious than the institution of facili ties for research was the generous pro vision that President Gilman made for the publication of the results of Ameri That Ameri er because of what Baltimore. and New were mentary cau scholarship generally. The Nation. can research began to bulk impressive- ty in Europe, no longer as an exception- al and individual phenomenon but as a collective fact, is largely due to the journals that Mr. Gilman encouraged, apparently in advance of any demand. The early fluid days of the university he has described charmingly himself. In shabby temporary quarters his young enthusiasts learned that not bricks and mortar counted, but the work and the spirit of the work. With the wisdom ot hindsight we can now see that the uni- versity somewhat hardened as it grew, and that the wholesale imitation of its example by the older universities was by no means an unmixed good. Yet the tault, if fault there be, lies not with Mr. Gilman, but with his emulators. It was inevitable in a land of ill-organized scholarship that the first emphasis should be set on simple thoroughness, that Original Research should a little flaunt its lordly capitals. Mr. Gilman had to combat a disgraceful laxness. As late as the founding of the Medical School of the university it seemed a rad- ical thing to insist that should first have been liberally educat- ed. Most medical schools were taking students who could not have entered the freshman class of an old-style col- lege. In fine, while it is now patent that the country did not need a score of universities on the Johns Hopkins mod- its students | superintendency of the New York schools. What tempted him was doubt- less the prospect of a great confusion to be set in order. Such service as he constantly rendered to civic and char- itable organizations of all sorts, from the Village Improvement Society of his summer home at North East Harbor, Me., to the Venezuela Boundary Commis- sion, was simply in his day’s work. Probably few men of our times believed more fervently in the value of organiza- tion, or lent to what may be called bu- reaucratic activities a more personal touch. When past seventy he undertook the management of the Carnegie Insti- tution, and our sole quarre) with the biographer is that he has failed to show how the work of encouraging research grew and broadened under Mr. Gilman’s hand. It is Mr. Carnegie who has giv- en the most terse expression to that mild and reasonable forcefulness which was Mr. Gilman’s most marked trait. On the occasion of Mr. Gilman's resignation the founder of the Carnegie Institution wrote: All great men have their special feature. If I were asked what yours was, I should say, that which draws all men after him, | pleasing everybody, and offending nobody, el, it is equally clear that precisely the | impulse it gave was most timely and necessary. We feel that a new univer- sity could hardly have started then and on any other basis, and regret that the older colleges followed too little imagination, and left unsettled the adjustment be- tween different orders of research and between these and the claims of higher there merely its leading with discursive education. It was we repeat, the fault of Johns Hopkins if its admirers suppos- ed it had attained a kind of doctrinal finality. President Gilman himself never held any such opinion. On scanty and shrinking means he endeavored to liberalize its teaching. By introducing open lectures of the highest class he took a leaf from the French book. He wished to give the poet Sidney Lanier a professorship, and did get him a lecture- ship. He would have had Child from Cambridge; barring that, he arranged a succession of literary courses by the best critics of both worlds. In short, if other college presidents had copied not his catalogues, but his spirit, the exces- Germanization of our universities not, sive doing the absolutely necessary ungentle things in a gentle way. With this trioute we might well leave Mr. Gilman, but it may be permissible in view of the peculiar importance and difficulty of the profession he so sig- nally adorned, to note that not merely his personality, but his apparently des:1l- tory training made him the ideal uni- versity president. And first, he never was a finished specialist in any sub- ject, though his attainments in his fa- vorite science of geography were con- siderable. He represented rather a ready and unbounded intellectual curiosity and sympathy that swiftly caught the significance of other men’s specialties. To old age, he kept his zest and alert- ness for new knowledge and untried ex- periences. His mind was equally attua- ed to the recondite erudition of a Henry Rowland and to the personal fragrance of a Sidney Lanier. Mr. Gilman was pre- eminently the astute and forceful ad- ministrator, but he was, apart from this, |as few men of our times have been, a would have been tempered by some re-| spect for the experience of France and for the finer part of our own English tradition. A new enterprise always appealed to the imagination of this indomitable leader: a difficult problem merely set his resolution on edge. There was a mo- ment, in 1896, when he was tempted to true professor of things in general. And this capacity, if not the absolute requis- ite, is surely the ultimate grace of that character which makes for acceptable leadership over the irritable race of cre- ative scholars. CURRENT FICTION. The History of Mr. Polly. By H. G. Wells. New York: Duffield & Co. Mr. Polly's story is roughly analogous, in setting and atmosphere, to the “Old Wives’ Tale” of Mr. Bennett. It is plac- ed, that is, in the dingy and unhopeful

Page 17

The Nation. scene of lower middle-class activity in a|relled over; and may turn out to have provincial English town. But Mr. Wells is anything but a realist: he is not con- tent, like Mr, Bennett, with setting down scrupulously the facts, physical and spir- itual, connected with an average shop- keeping and housekeeping experience on that plane—interpreting them only through the luminous diffusion of sym- pathy we call humor. Mr. Wells must have his definitive objective, and subtle- ty is not his favorite means of convey- ance. There is perhaps less of mere sparkle and more of humor in the pres- ent tale than is common with him. But his theory of the life he portrays has not left his mind clear for mere vision. He has set out, as usual, to demonstrate a particular thing—the possibility of the existence, even in that bog of servile and conforming tradésmanship, of an ardent if baffled idealism. Mr. Polly’s father was a small trades- man; his mother died when he was seven. At fourteen, after attending a national and then a private school, his studying was over. “By that time,” here speaks the caustic, reforming Mr. Wells, “his mind was in much the same state that you would be in, dear reader, if you were operated upon for appendicitis by a well-meaning, boldly enterprising, but rather over-worked and _ under-paid putcher boy, who was superseded toward the climax of his operation by a left- handed clerk of high principles but in- temperate habits—that is to say, it was in a thorough mess.” Shortly thereafter he became apprentice to a “gentlemen’s outfitter,” and for some subsequent years drifted toward the misguided owner- ship of a shabby hose and necktie shop in a town as forlorn as that of his birth. Marriage had intervened, with a narrow- souled slattern who ministered to his now chronic indigestion and discontent. Finally bankruptcy arrives, and what with the wife, and the stomach, and the debts, and the general dinginess of life, Mr. Polly is at the end of his rope—or thinks he is. His real trouble, and his real salvation, lie in his inborn and un conquerable love of beauty and desire for grace of living. The episode of his achieved arson and attempted suicide, with the incident of the criminal turned hero, and the irrepressible old woman whom he saves, is upon a plane ot true humor. And the further action —the secession from wedlock, the cheer- ful wandering of a delivered Mr. Polly, and the final discovery of the home and the companion in which his soul (no longer hampered by convention or indigestion) may find rest—all this part of the narrative is in Mr. Wells's best mood. The book will not breed the controversy awarded (to the amusement of her creator, no doubt) to “Ann Veron- ica.” Mr. Polly does desert his titular wife, to be sure, but that act is inciden tal rather than climacteric. Mr. Polly is a person to be loved rather than quar been the inventor of a new sort of art tongue, The Fascinating Mrs. Halton. By E. F. Benson. New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. Mr. Benson has an advantage over many current novelists in being sure of his métier. He never attempts too much. His plane is that of the social-humor- ous romance. He is content with few characters and simple plot. After a few of these pages, it is perfectly clear what the fascinating Mrs. Halton is going to do. Her task is an unusual one, though not unheard of: there is a very passable stage plot involved in the narrative. Mrs. Halton is a young and not over- mournful widow. She is, indeed, when the story opens, already pledged to a second mate, and on the way to a first happiness. But an unpleasant duty inter venes. Returning to England from season of mourning and recuperation abroad, she finds her favorite niece and companion almost engaged to married to a certain young lord (of course a lord). He is a pretty fair sort of lord, but he has had his ex- periences, one of them connected with a lady in Paris, whom Mrs. Halton knows to have been the sister of Daisy, the girl. There is your situation. It is im- possible for Mrs. Halton to tell Daisy, for the sake of her memory of the err- ing sister, who is now dead. And she cannot bring herself to tell the noble- man, since she regards him as a rascal Evidently, there is only one thing do. Mrs. Halton is almost as young and quite as beautiful as the fair Daisy. She determines to steal away Daisy’s lover before Daisy actually promises herself to him. The thing is easily done: the gentleman is quite ready to change his objective. As soon as his fickleness made clear to Daisy, Mrs. gagement to the other man is announc- ed. Her game has been open, and both Daisy and his lordship demand an ex- planation—which the fascinating Mrs. Halton is forced to give. They agree that she has done right. Daisy promptly pairs off with her original second choice; milord is content to remain the adoring friend of the no longer Mrs. Halton. For her part, she has come to like and admire him very much: there is a touch of pure Briticism in the toler- ation with which she looks upon him as a man who has had a mistress, though the thought of his marrying the sister of that deceased mistress is a horror to her. a be to is Halton’s en- The Head Coach. New York: Here Mr. Paine has succeeded in creat- ing a sabbatical atmosphere in a story about football, with its familiar accom paniment of mud, blood, and manly By Ralph D. Paine Charles Scribner’s Sons = DdD9 His head coach, Kingsland, is an eminently—we are tempted tears. to say ag- At Yale, he “got out and showed his college spir- it As all college people know, there is no greater praise than this. When, to the surprise of the reader, h enters the School after grad gressively—righteous person on every possible occasion everyone, including e Divinity uation, his football training enables him handily to thrash ruffians who try to take charge of mission meetings. Then he is called to a backwoods pulpit in Maine, and the team of a nearby col lege offers a field for his abilities as a coach. Here he has trouble with the stu- dents, who have ideas of their own about running the team. Needless to say, the Yale veteran smites the rebels hip and thigh, and creates a winning team out of chaos. He comes from the struggle crowned with such glory and honor that the hearts of his hitherto unfriendly parishioners are completely won So is that of the necessary girl, and ! hold a tale that is told. In reading it, those of us who not play football must feel a sort of wistful regret that we can lay no claim to the many and marvellous virtues that seem over do insepara ble from the football hero of fiction. But when we look upon him in the flesh, strolling about the campus with his Olympian air, or in later years getting “logy” the wonder read also neck—we of a a rising still more and creased about And when coach we pro is wonder fessional who young divine—we of the Carri Augusta Huiell Sturgis & Walton Co Jacqueline r-pigeons, By Seaman New York: This agreeable little story of the sieg of Leyden is introduced by William El liot Griffis, whose intimacy with the Netherlands makes authoritative his tes timony to the book’s general historic ac curacy as well as to its human interest He calls attention to the reasons that make the topic especially impressive for American readers. We, he says, “can not know Leyden too well, for no city in Europe so worthily deserves the name of Alma Mater,” it did the Walloons, the Pilgrim Fathers, and the Huguenots; and in the move- ment to recognize America’s independ- A boy and girl are the hero and heroine of the story, which gives glimpses of some of the great person ages of the time, and pictures the mis eries of the siege, the heroism of the defence, and thrilling conversion land into that brought the Dutch men-of-war to the rescue A excellent little preparatory is to the moving story of the Republic for young readers, their elders sympatheti« The book is admirably printed and pret tily with the drawings of George Wharton Edwardes sheltering as leading ence, the of ocean study Dutch for reminder very if and a fitting decorated quaint,

Page 18

H60 r NUBIA AND THE FRON TIERS OF EGYPT ! Publica an Department of ity Muse Eckley B Junior Expedition to Nubia: Areika, by D. Randall Mac Woolley, with a inscriptions, win Leonard Meroitic FY. L. Griffith. Oxford: ind plates, printed by Horace Hart, at the Press. MCMIX. 56 pp. and An Egyptian Oasis: An Account of the Oasis of Kharga in the Libyan Des ert, with Special Reference to its His Physical Geography, and Water- By H. J. Llewellyn Beadnell, F.R.G.S., Assoc. inst. M.M. For- of the Geological Survey of With maps and illustrations. New York: E. P. Dutton by Letterpress University 13 plates. tory, supply F.G.S., merly Egypt $3.50 net & Co As the ancient sites in Egypt are one after another exhausted, and it becomes more and more difficult to secure prom- for excavations, modern has pushed out into the outskirts of Kkgypt, or even its widest limits. We therefore find expeditions now active in Nubia, and the of the Eastern desert. The University of Chi seasons ising territory enterprise re- gion lying on the far beyond Ethiopia, oases cago expedition spent two (1905 in completely all inscribed Nubia or the Sudan. was chiefly recover monuments of Its work, to 07) endeavoring to ancient however, devoted monu- till north ibove ground the inundated ments Nubian-Nile when The rn end of ? lhe will be deeply the A feet hig twenty with the water, ian dam has been raised her under virtually accordance At disappear, and the remains above flooded hundred two in plans now way. high Phila cemetert will and ancient iutiful island the rs of a great lake a Are d by the of the thing the |} will be by mille long outraged Europe, peculiarly of beautiful beauty it appropriated survey, publle sentime loss of has sensitive after Phila for as a loat—th« 18 government archmological money for an past has been excavating the cemeteries and making exhaustive ords of the monuments which would be injured by the flood. These excavations have already ylelded most important and results, among which the most is the fact that in pre historic times the population of North- Nubia was Egyptian and that this by which for two seasons endangered rec- thoroughly interesting notable ern population was d'splaced Nubian (or Bega) tt from the south. This shift of the Nubiana, or possibly Bega, towards the north must have taken place at an extremely early records Egyptian immigration date, for the earliest inscribed which we possess disclose Northern Nu bia to us already in the possession of The Nation. the southern barbarians, creating a rontier inthe fourth millennium before Christ, the dangers of which have only been removed within the last few years. is, therefore, the oldest frontier in world of which the history is known to us, it the Under these circumstances, it was a wise decision on the part of the Uni- of Pennsylvania expedition to devote their efforts to excavations in Northern Nubia, and their first volume, entitled “Areika,” is a report of their work in a region lying at the head or upper end of the great lake to be created raised dam. Dr. Maciver, who charge of the work, has pro- a careful report of a carefully and successfully executed cam- paign. Perhaps the two most important finds which he made are, first, the rough masonry castle of a Nubian chieftain under the Eighteenth Egyptian Dynas- ty (1580 to 1350 Bp. c.), and, secondly, a large number of stone offering tables bearing inscriptions in ancient Meroitic writing. This new material, together with further examination of older docu- ments already known, has enabled the able Oxford Egyptologist, F. L. Griffith, the decipherment of the ancient Meroitic writ- versity the in by was duced planned to undertake still unreadable ing The Nubian country has furnished three different systems of writing: an ancient hieroglyphic system, the signs of which are largely of Egyp- derivation. This system is the oldest and goes back several centuries before Christ, continuing then into the Christian age. The second is a cursive writing evidently developed by the use but preserved to us only in specimens on stone. It closely resem- bles the Egyptian demotic and develop- the early Christian centuries, or the date of the speci- to us. The third sys- up after the Christianization of Nubia in the sixth century a. pv. It lg made up of Greek and Coptic letters used for the translation of an literature into Nubian. All these systems of writing have now dis- and Arabic is the sole pres- of Nubian speaking peoples. Some recently discovered por- tions of the New Testament in the third or Greco-Coptic, system of writing have enabled Professor Schaefer of Ber- lin to demonstrate that the language for which this system of writing was em- ployed in the early Christian centuries, was the Nubian still spoken on the Nu- Nile This important fact, to- with some other scattered indl- cations, has led Schaefer to the con- clusion that the people who wrote the other earlier systems, the hiero- glyphic and the cursive, was also Nu- that is to say, that the Ethiopians that distant and mysterious of the South, towards whicao us first, tian if pen and ink, ed in it i ens preserved ast this is rrew and was Christ appeared ent writing these bian gether two bian of Meroé, kingdom | Vol. go, No. 2344 the Greeks as far back as Homer's day looked with so much curiosity, was a Nubian kingdom. Lepsius had also reached the same conclusion in 1843, while on his great expedition in Nubia; but he later changed his opinion and held that the people who left us the earlier monuments in hieroglyphic and cursive, were Bega—a people now in- habiting the eastern desert between the Nile and the Red Sea. Attacking this problem with great skill, in a chapter which he has con- tributed to Dr. Maciver’s book, Mr. Griffith shows that the cursive is an al- phabetic system of writing, containing twenty-three letters; and that where the identity of the materials will permit, the cursive corresponds, letter for let- ter, with the hieroglyphic. He has, in- deed, established with certainty the hieroglyphic equivalents of ten of the cursive letters. He has as yet not been able to read this cursive writing or to decipher more than a few proper names in the scanty examples of hieroglyphics which survive; but he has reached one conclusion, which, if established, will prove of great importance. The Nubian of the third, or Graeco-Coptic, system of writing, as shown by Schaefer, is in- flected solely by means of terminations. Mr. Griffith finds indications of the ex- tensive use of prefires in the cursive documents. If such be the case, the lan- guage of the cursive is sharply distin- guished from the Nubian of the Graeco- Coptic system of writing. The language of the cursive will not have been Nu- bian, but, as Griffith concludes, Bega. If this conclusion is right, the Ethiopian kingdom of the South in the early Greek days will have been a kingdom of Bega tribes, who, as already stated, still in- habit the eastern desert; while the Nubians of Christian Nubia will have pushed in from inner Africa at a later period. Mr. Griffith is to be congratulated on his contribution to a highly important subject. On the basis of fuller materials which it is hoped future excavations may furnish, we may confidently expect that he will accomplish the decipher- ment of this long-lost language. ‘The other finds of the Pennsylvania Expedi- tion, while not of great artistic interest or importance, are nevertheless valua- ble and have found their way chiefly into the museum of the University. Mr. Beadnell’s volume on “The Oasis of Kharga” is the work of a trained field observer and geologist, and fur- nishes a very interesting account of the largest of the Egyptian oases. His de- scription of the geological conformation of the country, of the ancient wells, and the methods of boring new ones at present employed, as well as his account of the resources of these strange depres- sions in the desert, should make the volume the standard account of a Sa- hara oasis. In his discussion of the his-

Page 19

June 2, 1910] tory of this and the other Egyptian oases he has been unfortunate in the choice of his secondary sources, as the oases are far older in the history of Egypt than one would conclude from the reading of his book. The volume is excellently illustrated and accompanied by useful maps. , —$—————— English Literature in Account with Re- ligion. By Edward Mortimer Chap- man. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $2 net. The Religion of H. G. Wells and Other Essays. By Alexander H. Craufurd. London: T. Fisher Unwin. No great while ago the eyes of lay readers would have turned, after one incurious glance, drearily away from the titles above; every one would have known exactly what dejecting banality to expect. Meantime, we have been suf- fering a sea-change. The spiritual wel- kin, long befogged and breathless, now quivers with uncertainties, faint flushes of promise, new hope of adventure—the wind of thought finding its wings once more. The literary, the philosophical, and the religious are cautiously pluck- ing up heart together. Something im- portant seems about to occur—perhaps has occurred already. Neither Mr. Chap- man nor Mr. Craufurd knows precisely what it is; but both are conscious of a novel and significant breath stirring the face of the waters. For this reason their books have a symptomatic and barometric interest independent of their considerable literary virtues. It has been common to speak of the nineteenth century as the era in which the warfare of science and theology ter- minated in religious and philosophical despair. But as we draw farther away from it, see more clearly its links with the past, see it linking itself quietly enough with the future, we begin to re- gard it, like every other age since the world began, as merely an “epoch of transition”’—not hopelessly ultimate, after all. We begin to look upon its desperate and apparently sanguinary conflicts as the perennial contentions over form and vesture, in which there is much rending of garments but little loss of life. Thus Mr. Chapman, after examining the literature of this skepti- cal age, is profoundly impressed with its debt to religion and religion’s debt to it. He admits great carnage among the shadows of faith, but he is resolute that the substance has got off unscathed. In order to make good this position, he looses the irrational knots of church vesture and entirely unclothes religion of theological dogma. His preliminary attempt at defining the residual sub- stance is broad, and his subsequent ap- plications make the limits of his mean ing still broader. Religion is that “faith or experience” which suffices “to make life coherent and harmonious”; it is the ‘Lhe sense of obligation and responsibility; it is the sense of wonder, pity, tender- ness, awe, sacrifice, and consecration. All these things are within the meaning of religion, and are under the special covert of its wings. They are present, too, in all great literature as indispensa- ble elements in its greatness. They were incorporated in the various substi- tutes proposed in the last century for outworn Christianity. They were left unmolested even by the utilitarians and the militant men of science, who declar- ed war on what they regarded as the misleading poetical fictions of the Bible. They must continue to be present in life and literature, or the coil and tumult of existence will be reduced to the propor- tions and significance of Carlyle’s vase of Egyptian vipers. They are real be- causé they persist; they persist because they are indispensable. These things substantially Mr. Crau- furd finds in the writings of H. G. Wells; on the strength of them he speaks of the “religion of H. G. Wells’ with the greatest respect. A clergyman issuing from Oriel College, he declares that Christian thinkers who would min ister to the wants of this inquiring age “must do so by addressing themselves chiefly to the vivid thoughts and feel ings of detached, unsystematic, and more or less representative minds, rather than to the dry-as-dust profes sors of an antiquated learning that has well-nigh lost all true vitality.” Accord- ingly, he goes a long way with the writ er he criticises. He agrees with Mr. Wells that we should form our beliefs to suit our needs, and make our relig ion answer to the highest aspirations of humanity. But he finds Mr. Wells’s un- derstanding of the aspirations of hu- manity defective; he finds his distaste for the character of Christ, his ignoring of God and immortality, sure indica- tions of his failure to perceive some of the most fundamental human needs. “It God and a future life do not exist,” urges Mr. Craufurd, “we must, it would seem, invent them, if we seek to evoke from humanity its noblest and most per- sistent efforts.” This is also the posi- tion of Mr. Chapman. The point of interest in both these books is the ground on which their au- thors hold to Christian orthodoxy. Like G. K. Chesterton, they are orthodox with a difference—in an untraditional and exhilarating fashion. Like him they have rejuvenated their understand- ings in the waters of philosophical Pragmatism. Mr. Craufurd’s book is suggestively studded with references to Theodore Parker, Emerson, Whitman, John Fiske, and William James. Com menting on Wordsworth’s famous Nation. Something far more deeply interfused, Whose the suns— dwelling is light of setting Mr. Chapman says: “I would not dog O61 matize here. If any reader prefer to say that there only seems to be some- thing, I am content for the moment to have it so; simply remarking that the seeming is one of the vital facts of life.’ (Quoth Touchstone, “the truest poetry is the most feigning.”’) The return to orthodoxy represented by these writers is like the return to Elizabethan liter- ature on the part of the romanticists. They feel that the various rationalistic isms of the nineteenth century—Posi- tivism, for example—is to Christian- ity as the poetry of Pope is to the poetry of Shakespeare. They reject Positivism, as Wordsworth and Coleridge rejected Pope, not because it isn’t sound so far as it goes, but because it is hopelessly inadequate to represent the height and depth of man’s desire—the “vital facts of life.” They try God and immortality as hypotheses, and they stand the test prescribed by the scientific age; they work—they fit the facts. Such is the hope of the new orthodoxy. Histoire de la Langue Francaise des Origine 8 a 1900 (III, 1600-1660 premiére partie). Par Ferdinand Brunot. Paris: Armand Colin The publication of the extensive work of Ferdinand Brunot on the history ot the French language, which is the sub his professorship in the es a material ject matter of University of Paris, advance step further. The first volume (548 pages; 15 francs) reached from _ the Latin epoch to the Renaissance; the second (510 pages; 15 francs) dealt with the sixteenth century; the third, when completed, will give the formation of the language 1600 1660, and of this volume the first part is now published separately (456 pages; 12.50 francs). It is divided into three books, of which the first is eminently classic from to readable by anybody interested’ in French history and literature; and one need not be a special student to find savory mental food in the remaining and more technical pages. Paris literary opinion shock at the opening of the seventeenth century when the newcomer Malherbe began his reforms, weeding out the vo- cabulary and reducing the language to rule. His typical adversary was that erudite and entertaining old maid, Mademoiselle de Gournay, fille d'alli- ance of Montaigne and editor of his works. Even she had to yield to her printers so far as to change in his sa cred text “a few words of no conse quence, such as adverbs and articles which seem to them somewhat crabbed for the taste of certain over-nice persons of this century.” Malherbe’s influence and the number of his influential follow- received a ers grew apace. A fury for grammar raged in the salons. Voiture wrote to Mademoiselle de Rambouillet on the suppression of the conjunction car

Page 20

a e>é J had achieved in his romance, “Polexandre.” A recomman- of wet nurses complained that, they ask if the nurse speaks French “which she guarantee, but only that which belongs to her state, that she has good milk, is and shall always be, please God, of good life, and shall die without which the monsieur do which Gomberville daresse in good houses, now well, cannot reproach—with content themselves.’ The discussion of the good use of the introduces us to the pédant lan to that of the Palais or lawyers Parlement, Jodelle de as “speaking of war in pur jar- and to court use. It was tter which was bound to prevail of French that “classic” lan- hose formation is the subject of The foundation the followed by its project onary; led by Le Vayer; the carrying on ot work by Vaugelas and was not aay LuUAgC, of the whom to city volume of closely the opposition rood preciosity, which always creating new and the burlesque, more instructive as it of all rule, sting book, “le Lexique,’ curious foreign of the day— lrench-Flemish, French French-Ger French-English (eight of the 1611 to 1673). In takes up words already sition; Was rases make up pages. ond uses eat advantage the ize dictionaries Fren: Spanish h-Latin, French-Italian, man, and latter from succes sion the old; trine author and réaliste the reprobation New England); and words; neolog cmantique; various and figures. This book has a biblographical appendix on the published during the the libraries in which improper words (poi- fell “leg” later dialect, under which incurred in trade fravail and pe the found them bool f tl parts of logical I of vord and of editions gives a very complete speech at the the al occuple pages which index, in thirty-six ot from erest of Work of the by the de ation to £& of the Commission Territorial the Terri Purpose ofa liy Lon Out wish raritne the in Cyrendaica ill vhich ject of they coloniz The Nation. ing the Cyrenaica was determined part- ly by its geographical position, highly convenient for persecuted Jews emigrat- ing from Russia and Rumania, partly by the fact that the region wears the Turkish suzerainty so lightly that prac- tical autonomy might be hoped for, though the word could not be used. Moreover, the Cyrenaica approaches Pal- estine asa sentimental goal, since it was once a home of Judaism, “the land that is in league” of Ezekiel. On the eastern frontier Egypt would be useful as a civ- ilized neighbor, and the Turks to the west were not unwilling that a country that they have had to abandon to the Arabs should be regenerated at the ex- pense of others. It was therefore with the countenance of the Turkish Gov- ernment, and with high hopes based on the glowing accounts of the Cyrenaica in classical literature, that the Ito kx- pedition set out in July, 1908. It con- sisted of an engineer who was to sur vey and to report on the water supp'y (a question naturally uppermost when you are about to colonize a desert), a medical man to consider the probabil- ity of epidemics, an expert on agricul- ture, and Dr. Gregory, the professor of geology at the University of Glasgow. Never has a project so visionary been safeguarded with precautions so scien- tific. Few people realize how great a role Cyrene and her distinguished sons played in the past before she became Jewish, lost her prestige, and disap- peared from history. Even Mr. Zang- will’s Report, concerned as it is with her Jewish traditions, ignores nearly all the associations that spring to the mind of the Greek scho'ar. Tennyson himself was not quite clear about Cyrene’s posi- tion on the map when he set the Garden of the Hesperides on a slope rhat ran bloom-bright into the Atlantic blue, unless, indeed, he intended to break with the prevailing tradition of the lo- cality of the famous apple tree with its golden fruit. It is, of course, the Medi- terranean that is the great commercial high-road waiting to be exploited once again in the days when the Cilician pirates called these waters ‘the golden sea” because they could al- waylay a rich cargo from the Cyrenaica. In Pindar’s day it would be a cargo of silphium, a plant now appar- ently extinct (it is ignored in the Re- which the merchant kings of fostered royal monopoly, Congo rubber to-day. Besides this which was used as a drug and for in shiploads to of by Cyrene as ways port), Cyrene as a like plant, and was sent we see from the “Rudens” Cyrene pottery and But it was her splendid horses hariots that made her the envy of cooking Capua, as Plautu exported hal and great games,and the swan of traders, the Greece at the one of that dynasty | habitants must be discarded. [ Vol. go, No. 2344 = Battiads, was sung by Pindar in the Fourth and Fifth Pythian Odes. Kingdoms lapse, and climates change, and races die, says Tennyson, but we are now told that the climate of Cyrene has not chang- ed, that the population can never have been more than fifteen to twenty thou- sand, and the inspiring legend that the Jews in that district once rose and mas- sacred 220,000 Greek and Roman in- The fact is that the rainfall is and always was quite insufficient. At the best, Cyrene could have had only a gallon a head per day for a population of fifteen thousand, and that allows none for those horses that were the envy of Greece. It seems likely, too, that wild animals were as searce then as now. One of Cyrene’s most agreeable legends is of the lion who met the first founder, Battus, when he landed, and fled into the Libyan wil- derness in terror of the hero’s stammer- ing tongue. But there were no lions to be dismayed by the accents of the Ito Expedition. “A dead jackal and a liv- ing hare were the only wild ani- mals”; but we are told that rats and mice “are said to be found in the coun- try. Donkeys are neglected. As a consequence they are small and dis- pirited. Crickets and locusts, fleas and flies are numerous.” The first Greek colonists brought no women, and the Ito explorers recommend that, if the colonizing scheme should be attempted, only a few men should be imported at first, and those “encumbered as little as possible with women and children.” But the Cyrenaica will not be colon- ized by Jews; Cyrene will remain a derelict, and all the gold of the Roths- childs will not people those Libyan wastes. There are two practical diffi- culties recognized by the Expedition, either of which would have been enough to blight their hopes. The Arabs are unfriendly, wellarmed with modern rifles, and evidently prepared to resent any intrusion. If that were not s0, Cyrene would long ago have been a cen- tre of archeological excavation. But still more fatal to the prospects of that agricultural life desired by the Ito for their immigrants, is the scarcity of water. What the Arabs would obvious- ly shed their blood to defend trom in- vaders is not their hearths and homes, for they are Nomads, but their entire- ly inadequate wells. “The absence of impermeable rock layers in the Cyre- naica explains the paucity of its sur- face waters, and renders practically im- possible the construction of storage reservoirs large enough for irrigation. The excessive porosity of the rocks also forbids reliance on wells.” The dry pones of Cyrene cannot live again. There is, however, another obstacle to any such project of an agricultural com- munity for tle Russian and Rumanian

Page 21

June 2, 1910] Jew, though it is one that Mr. Zang- will does not choose to face. ‘The life that he had planned for the North Afri- can colony involved incessant and vir tually unremunerative toil. The colon ists would need to have the outdoor tastes, the hardiness, the thrift, the self denial of the Pilgrim Fathers. Mr. Zang will seems to forget the existence of the United States and the total lack, as tar as we are aware, of any enthusiasm on the part of the Eastern Jewish immi- grant for the simple life of agriculture, even under the most favorable condi tions. The results of immigration to the United States have shown clearly that an oppressed agricultural popula- tion fleeing from Europe will always cling to the crowded life of large cities, and that these are the last persons whom you can persuade to make the desert rejoice and blossom as the rose. Mr. Zangwill, in his Introduction to Dr. Gregory's Report, declines to accept as necessarily final all the damaging evidence of the experts of the Expedi tion. He still believes that the Cy- renaica, with its Hinterland, combines a greater number of qualifications for an Itoland, as defined by the Russian Council of the Ito in 1907, than any country of the Old World. But the Re- port brought disillusion to the Council as a whole,and the costly experiments in buildings, roads, railways, and a harbor suggested by the experts are indefinitely postponed. The Report contains much that is of interest to classical scholars and archeologists, and is well illustrat- ed by photographs The Great Pacific Coast. By C. Reginald Enock. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $4 net, The author of this volume, who is an F.R.G.S., is an astonishingly persistent traveller, even for an Englishman. A score of times, he tells us, perhaps of- tener than any other European, he has stood on the white mountainous heights of Peru, and lived in large towns where the people pursue their daily oc cupation at an than that of the summit of any of the Ca'i fornian or Oregonian snow queens, or of Mont Blane. He has written books on the Andes and the on Peru, Mexico, and other countries. His latest volume covers twelve thousand miles ot has elevation greater Amazon, territory from Chili to Panama and Cal ifornia, thence through Oregon and Washington to British Columbia and Alaska He writes chiefly to entertain the reader, inciGentally also to tell him many things about the regions travers ed, and to dwell briefly on personal ad ventures, some trivial, others serious Among the latter were two hairbreadth escapes; one in Mexico, where a peon guide took him on horseback up a moun tain so steep in one place that only by urging the horse to utmost speed could a) > . The Nation. it be kept from overbalancing—the guide’s excuse being: “I came up here when a boy, on muleback, but the road has fallen away then’; another time, in Arizona, when he had to hang on to a rickety viaduct while a freight train passed over him. Mr. Enock comments on the difference between the black people who live under British and those who are under Ameri can rule; on the courtesy of the Mexi- can contrasted with the American, who is often aggressively uncivil, mere ly to assert his equality, not because ol inherent disagreeableness He offers much good advice to the English on the subject of emigration to Canada. He wonders what svurt of adults the Ameri can children will flake who are brought since as up on the colored supplements of our Sunday papers. Such moralizings, how ever, are incidental; the bulk of the 1uthor’s remarks relates to things seen y } and likely to be seen by tho ! d by his descriptions to follow in I or teps., , Notes. J 1 MecCar ! History f Ou 0 I I he reign of Qu 1 Vik ‘ ! ul to add that wor lu hich will il with th I 1 of I rd VII ( I As j 0 reparing a lift f itl Al ander A ju t! } a j } ) 1 t! M j ot tt ratiy Z | Ca ! Ma I } red t I ll be opied, 1 wu or ' 1 to the owner Oo ) vho are unwill ) ur with tl Is i! confer i ‘ i le at the exp of Mr. G nd sending the copies to hin ience ibeth Wager-Smith ho ha ilready ral manua ‘ reat Ger rd now rs i P 1 Illustr Games (Li r} book ) with an t ind entertair chapt on the O i Character [ ! Ga rl Y l versity Pr ! d in " littl V I Henr \ s befor ! M r Lat Clu of Yak Mi I i Ly ] I | n witlt I § ry It will be ficient barel to anno r I ra of four mo V J (VII xX fs ! I Memorial Edition of ( M lith TI ne 4 ] i \ ria’ nd “Ha Ri Of ! pog yhical excellence of ) ly spoken \ ‘ ome “Burdett’s H for 1910 (London: 7T 1 congratulat } t Henr Burdett, who, as ! 0 1 has borne the burd ir ty of the compilat The present issue ntalr o new ol orphanages ti other on state and Canada. been below year raised to 108. 6d., aid to hospitals in the t, having regard to its siz acter of the. information the cheapest the press.”’ We have alre Complete Edi translated by Dr ome to N. Foulls. his country the Macmillan TI Oscar Levy. us from has ady tion of various the hand! now fro 1¢ Co., hands London ing been m n OL it ce books of references had occasion t« Friedrich a Unit st and ntair N and pub the taken whom we elved the following six volumes: \ll Too-Human.” Institutions ducational Power,”’ Out of Season, “Or “The Birth of Part red in t Li with \ H vhen oO ’ 1 ] letts ‘ } ibout tft ed the | Ilo M . } rf Wa | I i | Unive ned i ped i , | ‘ [ i thy f Hi I rf t ly | | tfull that nd h q } Ww up I t I } ‘ i ‘ LA ‘ ’ a ¢ t dily fix 7 % 4 ul ‘ J } ig ga } ' i rng ' if : ‘ 1 ju if I a i tar | i t tho j 1 ror *s ’ | “a ‘ } t it t it ’ | " ‘ ris I! to p re i y 1 the Future of Our ‘The Will to Tragedy,’ Thoughts i 1 Spak Z } . \ | H \ i " i ’ ' W f the lif nooct ° ’ ? ‘ ] x ty i ‘ ich 1 ¢ ! \\ 2 ‘ I f DI i iry ma Li ] re lit " ed ! the nd ll +? to i i lit f \ } 1) f I f { M i , ' ‘ ly } rish } ket } sé ib ee ] Iris) ind ‘ , ] at ‘ ‘ al ) , it | ‘ | ak of it he i hea Mr ) NO8 ed &§ . ate } The price, which has hithert the cost of production, is this “which ill leaves the ch is ar issued > note ne etzsche edited by Hitherto the volumes have lisher, 1 books in over by have re- “Human,

Page 22

morrow and too, we learn re emphasis the the Barrie did sense of “I wager’ you did; : the do, oO t ie”: did, More suggestive of like “I believe you,”” and ail not to?" But it is unquestionably a surprise to find a Celtic heredity claimed for such appar- universal expressions of ready as- sent as “I don't mind if I or “Would a duck swim?” A common exclama- Ulster, we are told, is “No, but and it is a common Irish phrase, that our “never fear.’’ On the contrary, there would be danger of misunderstanding if, outside of Ireland, a visitor coming in and finding the dinner, should say, ‘“‘Much good do Mr. Joyce admits that people are “rather prone Hence, a chapter Redundancy It is with a per the say to a adding words “and no source comes or .that, the “I'll go bail’; “so he as “he hit and it is a “a engage’ you this in aye, is it” and repetitions did so |! with a in me stick, so he great shame, so it is.’ their origin are phrases “what would me ently do,” very tion in did you?” na bi ort us leagal has given at it you.” Ireland the to exaggeration.” and of a that he bushes.”’ family may in on Exaggeration ommon to say person ive tongue “would coax off the It 1! give my e a end,” to let fr is Irish to follow grow ! r : y¢ you to d's grass ghtened out of to be vallow ippre ation of William Morton ared in «che International made by M now Clurg ) contains additions and of of Payne ym, anecdote, later works after speaking acher Mr intimate relationships, in face-to-face con- home circle, the man different aspect; the become the friend, the impas- has become the genial shares the gladsome or the hour. Such a per- be analyzed: it defies One resorts to figures more other h sition of takes prophet ind the quite in on a has sioned preacher story-teller, and mirthful mood of sonality as this may any concise synthesis of apea h To Light Light be mass review Ralph Nevill's (Macmillan) the Come, to make of regarding gambling Go" would a selection from great infor mation and anecdotes and its forms, brought to- Wwe there betting in all gether in one book could, on a pinch here and from the England bulk of the material the the although there is nothing in the story but ance add a our be of France furnish own reading addition would no signifi and the century and the eighteenth of the startling and early years mime anecdotes book tudy of teenth offer moat more ireful Monte irio futil chemes to interesting than the pre sent-day gambling at ‘arlo and the analysis of the v The Nation. winning. Mr. Nevill mentions 4 dice craps common in the old ys of the Palais Royal and still played in Alaska, the very boards brought to California by French emigrants forties He seems not to have modification of the game play- cities, assure game ot reps or sometimes on in the heard of the ed in our Shilleto Smith has no new in- formation to bring in her life of “Dean Swift” (Putnam), and her manner of re- lating the known events is not more than moderately entertaining. The great crux Sophie of Swift's life and character, the question | of his marriage to Stella, she waives with a “What does it matter?’—and this in a long chapter which undertakes to set the Dean before the world as a Don Quixote and flower of chivalrous devotion ladies. But if our author has no new facts, she has abundant new interpretation of them. Swift was “an idealist’; as for his ambition, he merely “stood on a pin- nacle and demanded a reward to crown the citadel”; he in advance of his age in his attitude toward women; he allowed no coarseness before them; he was without reproach in the tragedy of Vanessa; he wri the “Tale of a Tub” in a spirit of genuine optimism”; “Shelley and Swift [was was tes there ever a more incongruous junction of are, the two best exam perhaps entirely misunder- hildlike Thompson altruist had the ed by Francis imagination child? It lifferent from the have a spirit yet the waters of baptism; it * to believe i loveli- to be so what it is to be a tl very It is to Know you some is ing to-day ve in it ~ reach to whisper ns rf to perversik difficul than re- find assimi- that of sensl- this f Swift with As existence, Thompson tlready in writing or sé We observe f Craik’s Life in bibliography appended to the range work ‘sent The hi the readers between the Ionian Dorian familiar to all of Thucydides, Arnold, Pater, Wilamowitz, and Eduard Meyer. But term of origins Ionian is as problematical as Pelas- Were there proto-Ionians Minor before the Were the Ionians storical contrast ind spirit is Curtius is a ethnical still gic a word Ionian the original dough or the later leaven of the population of At- Were they the survivors and in- heritors of Mycenman or A®gean or like the Achmwans and the Dorians iron-using invaders from the regions of the Danube? Did the Tonians make the fonilan migration, or did the migration them, lonian merely a name for of driven out from European Greece by the pressure from the North? David G. Hogarth’s six lec- tures “Ionia and the East” (Frowde) latest contribution to this elusive He claim have many conclusions, but merely to have collected new evidence that define and the truth theories. The elements which went tica? make and is mixed tribe colonists on ire the liscussion does not to propounded novel tends to clear up of old [Vol. go, No. 2344 to the making of the Ionians are those of all the Hellenes: “A mass of the old 7Zgean stock, which had long been par- ticipant in the prehistoric civilization of the A®gean Bronze Age, came to be leaven- ed by the infusion of northern blood drawn from the area of mid-European culture.” The A®gean element was relatively pre- ponderant in the tribes that came to oc- cupy the part of Asia Minor afterwards known as Ionia. But the territory in which they settled had not itself been a seat of Avgean culture. It had been closed to the A®gean civilization by the domina- tion, first of a Hittite, and then perhaps of a Phrygian inland power. The weak- 'ening of this power by Assyrian pressure to the | In Asia) colonization? | threw the coast open for settlement, and left free play for the first expansion of historic Hellenic civilization known as Ionian. By these hypotheses, Mr. Hogarth thinks he can account for the sudden outburst of this civilization—inexplicable if the Ionians were merely rude northern tribes —and for the traces of Oriental influence in the art of Ionia. The chief mediators with the Orient were the Hittites and the Phrygians, and probably not the Pheeni- cians, whose role has been greatly exag- gerated. For confirmation of these views, Mr. Hogarth appeals to the treasure of the earliest Artemision by him at Ephesus in 1904. These specimens of early dating perhaps from the eighth century B. c., he finds closely analogous to the “sub-A®gean”’ art of the Enkomi treasure found in Salamis on Cyprus, which date at the very end of the The traces of Oriental influ- are to be explained in the Mr. Hogarth recognizes the of all of this is not inclined dogmatize. It would perhaps be expecting too much to ask that Mycenologists and Minoans should refrain from speculation altogether and confine themselves to the bare state- ment of the Greek tradition and the facts of archmological discovery in these pre- historic matters. But it would release an immense amount of the Hellenist’s time for more profitable reading. discovered Ionian art, he would Bronze Age. both way. nee in same conjectures to uncertainty kind, and A valuable source for the study of po- litical and constitutional history has been made available by the publication, by au- thority of the State of New York, of the “Messages from the Governors” (Albany: J. B. Lyon Company, State Printers). There are in all eleven v ‘umes covering the pe- riod from the mecting of the first repre- | sentative Assembly of Colonial New York |in 1683 to the beginning of Gov. Hughes’s culture, | first Administration in January, 1907. Ten volumes are taken up with the text of mes- sages and accompanying State papers. The eleventh volume, perhaps the most valua- ble of all, is a comprehensive index of the whole with valuable tabulations of law cases cited and constitutional references, It is so rare to find works of this sort care- fully and fully indexed that it is a relief to discover with this compilation a key of such utility. The work of editing has been competently done by Charles Z, Lin- coln, whose experience for his difficult task comprised service as counse] for Govs. Morton, Black, and Roosevelt. He has pro- vided historical introductions for each vol- and in the earlier per'od has found ume,

Page 23

June 2, 1910] it necessary and useful to piece out the sometimes meagre records by extracts from other contemporaneous records, all of which work seems to have been done with a keen regard for historical accuracy. Throughout the volumes there are frequent footnotes, not only explaining the text but providing careful citations to cases and decisions mentioned, and a systematic analysis of constitutional questions and legal develop- ment as they arose. This makes the work of considerable value for students of the development of legislative and _ constitu- tional problems, whereas without it a searcher would have to grope largely in the dark. The books are printed in clear type on good paper and are well bound. For Samuel G. Camp's “Fishing Kits and Equipment” (Outing Publishing Company) there should hardly seem tobea need, since, though the chapters were well enough as contributions to a sporting magazine, they are not sufficiently important for a book, and contain nothing that is not already to be had in more valuable volumes. The illustrations are not wisely chosen. For example, there are no helping diagrams for such processes as the tying of leaders while a large half-tone shows four rods which vary in price from $5 to $30, but which, in the picture, appear identical. The English is slipshod. Not to speak of split infinitives and such minor weaknesses, the book is full of sentences like the follow- ing: “But the American angler who fol- lows the above plan is a very rare bird, however numerous they [sic] may be in Merry England”: “The cheap fly is a snare and a delusion to the angler only.” “Old Hallowell on the Kennebec,” by Em- ma Huntington Nason, published by the au- thor at Augusta, Me., is notable among town histories, both for its execution and for the inherent interest of the subject. This plea- sant town, opposite Augusta, was success- ively an Abenaki village, which was first Christianized by the Jesuits, and later ac- quired as a trading post by the Plymouth Colony. The foundation of the town goes back to 1771, its incorporation as a city, with which the story ends, dates from 1852. People of substance and education were among the early settlers. We find such names as Dummer, Sheppard, Merrick. The Vaughan family still occupy the house bulit for Dr. Benjamin Vaughan, M.P., just be- fore the close of the eighteenth century. A man of wealth, he treated only poor pa- tients, and free of charge; he had aided Franklin substantially in the peace settle- ment; his library of 10,000 volumes was put ar the disposal of borrowing neighbors, in a small way he was an author. Cardinal Manning was the nephew of Dr. Vaughan's wife. It was people of this stamp that gave the community its flavor. It has supplied two Governors to the State. Among its lit- erary citizens are Jacob Abbott of the Rollo books, and his brilliant son, Lyman Ab- bott; Prof. C. F. Richardson, the historian of American literature; Rev. J. H. Ingra- ham, a most prolific novelist of the sensa- tional order, and his son, Col, Prentiss In- graham, who, beginning as a Confederate officer, was a soldier of fortune under many flags, and wrote innumerable novels of a lurid cast. Such are a few of the claims of old Hallowell upon the read- er’s attention. Talleyrand visited it. Wil- liam Hazlitt, the elder, preached there on trial, but his Unitarianism was too radical The Nation. for the congregation. Charles Bulfinch de- signed the belfry of the oldest church. In short, the chronicle is variously interesting. It gains from the numerous illustrations based on early portraits or scenic photo- graphs. If the title “Britain at Bay’’ (Putnam) were pot enough to make the stolid Eng- lishman sit up, the fact that it is writ- ten by Spenser Wilkinson should cause dis- quietude from John of Groats to Land's End. With the peculiar solemnity and em- phasis that distinguish this writer's ante- mortem surveys of his fatherland, Britain is warned that Germany looms large across the channel, controls the politics of the Continent, and might, at a pinch, force united Europe to attack England. “In that case’’—a favorite phrase—England’s vaunt- ed supremacy on the sea, even if main- tained, would not help much. You can’t force enemies to make peace with you, even after the destruction of their sea pow- er, unless you get after them with horse, foot, and marines. The foe may be able to attack you, but their distressing sentiments of hostility may be indefinitely continued. The only real safeguard against can not ‘Germany is for England to have an army that can be sent over seas and make her, in contingencies, an aggressive ally on land, The way to get such an army is compulsory military service for a year— two for the mounted service. This can be done cheaper than the present army, the effective of which would be quadrupled. As for the inconvenience of sefving a year, that is a patriotic duty, and once right principles were instilled, every Briton would be delighted to become a Tommy Atkins, with pecket money “not to exceed fourpence” daily. With such an army, invaders could be repelled, and, at need, a Continental ally substantially reinforced We should hardly notice this ponderously harmful tract were it not that the Eng- lish, and on occasion ourselves, take a melancholy delight in mumbling the tidbit of national peril. That would be an in nocent recreation except that it has to be paid for heavily in guns, ships, and costly martial overprovision of all sorts To make his bugbear horrific, Mr. Wilkin- son piles up gratuitous suppositions indefi nitely. He fails to see that with or with- out British troops France and Italy have the strongest motive, that of self-pre vation, to oppose Germany. The idea of either being forced into anti-British coalition is preposterous. Moreover, there reason to represent Germany, in International Socialism is steadily potentially an enemy of the As for Mr. Wilkinson's paper that an ser an is no which gaining, human race army, it is by no means certain effective force can be obtained a basis of a single year’s service, especially if, as it is suggested, recruits who wish may live at home. But in a book of this sort one wide assumption more or less really doesn’t matter. as on From his “Critical Essays of the Seven- teenth Century” Prof. J. E. Spingarn has reprinted “Sir William Temple's Essays on Ancient and Modern Learning and on Poetry” (Frowde), in a separate small volume. The study of Temple's style (he was, according to Dr. Johnson. “‘the first writer who gave cadence to English prose’’) would be serviceable in our schools to cor- N65 rect the modern tendency toward an un balanced impulsiveness. To the Albion series of Anglo-Saxon and Middle English poetry, Frederick Tupper now adds in monumental edition “The Rid- dies of the Exeter Book” (Ginn). In a prefatory essay of some hundred pages he discusses the principles of comparative rid- dle-study, the sources and analogues of the Exeter Book Riddles, authorship, poem, manuscripts, etc. The sixty-seven pages of text are illuminated by 223 pages, includ- ing notes and glossary. If Professor Tup- per has not brought his subject into broad daylight, he has at least made darkness visible. The result of years of research in the most recondite territory, this vol- ume is an admirably organized mine opened in the fleld of enigmatography. The Oxford French Series (Frowde) con tributes four volumes handsomely printed, and well equipped with introductions and notes. Two are works of George Sand, “Francois le Champi,” edited by Alfred Mercier, and “Les Maitres Sonneurs,”’ edit- ed by Stéphane Barlet. The other two are the entertaining “la Société francaise au XVile siécle,”” by Victor Cousin, issued by Leon Delbos, and Lamartine’s “Le Tailleur edited by W de Pierres de Saint-Point,”’ Robertson. It is doubtful whether any of these books will make much appeal to American colleges, even the editions of George Sand, since “‘La Petite Fadette”’ and “La Mare au Diable”’ have long preémpted the ground E. B. Iwan-Miiller, journalist and author, died in London last week, aged fifty-seven He was engaged dt different times years upon the staffs of the Pall Mall Gazette and Manchester Courier, and from 1896 until! his death, as an editorial writer on the Daily Telegraph. He was editor of the Ox- llection of “Shotover Papers,” and author of “Lord Milner and South Africa,” and “Ireland To-day and To-morrow.” ford « Science. - Farming,” b to Practical (Macmillan), works have many, Its treatment scientific; and this both detriment. would 4 Manual of McLennan of general John belongs the now group of which we 80 is not ad like is an de« ply vantage and a One for instance, to have more attention to gen eral principles, connecting classes of phe nomena. There is in the book some undu compression: the chapter on ploughing contains no more than the average poo! farmer is content to know, and barely begin to answer the numerous questions of the be The of the important of manures is most One find the mendation plants ginner treatment subject barnyard cur sory. is amused to recom in for plants not to spray when appended to the directions spraying the which, of all needs such caution least, as its crop in no its flower. On the other apart from these defects, the book bas the advantage of being unduly technical; it is generally direct and sensi- ble, and gives much practical advice, Char acteristic of this better side are the marks on feeding the horse, and the care of the farm orchard as distinguished from the blossom potato, way depends on hand, not re commercial.

Page 24

566 Modern in children’s gardens, chiefly in cities, has produced a flood of books, of which two of the most interesting are “Little Gardens for Boys and Girls,” by Myrta Margaret Higgins (Houghton Mifflin) and “Children’s Gardens for Pleas- ure, Health, and Education,” by Henry G. Parsons (Sturgis & Walton). Although the accidental, these books The first is addressed to the child itself, and, in fifteen chapters, sometimes plain and practical, sometimes idealizing and stimulating, appeals to the two sides of child nature Put directly into the hands of any child of ten or more, it should fulfil its An excellent chapter treats of a subject usually neglect- ed, indoor winter gardening. Mr. Parsons’s book, on the other hand, Is addressed to the teacher. Like the first, it is the outcome of much experience, for Mr. Parsons has had the practical direction of the movement for children’s gardens in New York, started He confines himself to the work which he has done, but Its general and his remarks upon it are of interest. One is tempted to quote from this book passages on the relation- ship between gardening and citizenship. The instruction which the author draws from the making of a garden path and the seven lessons in the “pedagogy of the spade” are not merely novel, but signifi- cant. To one engaged in the work of chil- dren's gardening, even to a parent instruct- ing his child, this little book will give as- to one inclined to doubt modern progress it will bring courage and hope. “Explorations ih Bolivia,” by Major P. H. Faweett, is the article of greatest general interest the Geographical Journal for May. It an account of his work in the delimitation of the eastern frontier at the request of the Bolivian Government, togeth- valuable information about In respect to its natural is a commercial El- from the from the wood interest correspondence is are complementary mission by his mother, course great civic sistance; in is er with much the country resources he dorado of the whole Says it not simply wealth, but the hard areas of rubber trees. rub- future undeveloped mineral ensive pasture lands, ts, and the vast to the he ty the future exploitation of the doubtful, of the hos- avages to the white man, This for their treatment because he im the attributes to revenge last century, when they were “sacri- Though the terrible meth- a perpetual waged to-day. Among “usually cannibals” hostile to everybody outside their In the discussion of the paper read to the Royal Geographical So- Sir Martin Conway sald that Bolivia the remarkable in the because it contained regions of al- kind mountains covered giaciers and perpetual snow tropical forests There is also utter with expanses of white salts spread over vast areas, that it “resembles a of the surface of the Six illustrations and a map accompany the ar- fleed to rubber.” oda of colle reprisals ting have ceased, war of is the who tribes are dwarfs, are own tribe when ety war most country world from moat every with g#reat to desert RO portion moon.” ticle The Spirit of the West,” In the National Ceographic Magazine for April, is a résumé of the work of the Reclamation Service by its statistician, C, J. Blanchard. The vivid impression made by it is that never before in the history of the world have great des- been tfansformed in so short ert regions [Vol. 90, No. 2344 The Nation. ‘a time as three or four years into cul- tivated fields thickly inhabited. This is true of a large tract in Idaho, which in 1905 exhibited no sign of human life, but now is a garden rich and productive with pleasant homes on each 40 and 80 acres, while four prosperous towns, soon to be- come cities, have sprung up along the new railway. The strange sights of Mukden, the capital of Manchuria, and its won- derful art treasures are pleasantly de- scribed by Eliza R. Scidmore. Both articles are fully illustrated. George Frederick Barker, professor emeritus of physics at the University of Pennsylvania, died in Philadelphia last week, aged seventy years. He was gradu- ated from Sheffield Scientific School at Yale in 1858, and after holding chairs in several colleges was called to Pennsylvania in 1873. Professor Barker was the first to exhibit radium in this country. He served as Unit- ed States commissioner to the Paris Elec- trical Exhibition in 1881, and as delegate or commissioner to several other electrical exhibitions and congresses. Professor Robert Koch, the celebrated bacteriologist and discoverer of the germ of tuberculosis, died at Baden-Baden on Friday, aged sixty-seven years. Dr. Koch’s medical education was received at Gét- tingen, and, after several years of private practice, he was made director of the Cholera Commission to India and Egypt. In 1884 he discovered the cholera spirillum, regarded as the positive test for Asiatic cholera. He also traced the germs of the then incurable sleeping sickness to the tsetse fly, and prepared an antitoxin. It was in 1882 that he discovered the germ of tuberculosis; in 1890 the world was startled by the announcefment that Dr. Koch had discovered a lymph which would cure the disease. Thousands flocked to Berlin, drawn by the sensational reports, which, how- ever, did not come from Dr. Koch himself. He explained the nature of his discovery, its scope and treatment, in an article in 1891. The scientific world still questions value of the lymph in_ general practice. Dr. Koch continued his pene- trating studies of the disease, and founded the Institute for the Investigation of Tuberculosis, which bears his name. In 1908 he provoked much discussion at the Tuberculosis Congress at Washington, be- cause of his views on the transmission of the disease germ. He was for many years a professor in the University of Berlin, and director or member of . many scientific bodies.. He received the Harden medal and the Nobel prize. the Drama. Vanderheyden Fyles, it is announced, will take up at once the duties of literary di- rector of the New Theatre, succeeding John Corbin. This position carries with it the responsibility of selecting plays for pre- sentation, subject to the approval of a committee of executive heads. Mr. Fyles is a son of Franklin Fyles, the dramatic eritle and writer. One of the leading events of commence- ment week at Middlebury College will be the presentation of a Roman drama, “Tem- poribus Hominis Arpinatis,’ a representa- tion of dramatic moments in the life of Cicero. It deals particularly with the great conspiracy of Catiline, the play closing with Cicero’s triumphant return from banish- ment. The end sought is educational rath- er than entertaining. It is to give “‘a true | glimpse of the life of a civilization which has entered into and moulded all subse- quent history.” “Oberammergau,” by Josephine Helena Short (Thomas Y, Crowell & Co.), gives a |full summary of the Passion Play, and a |sympathetic account, profusely illustrated, lof the village and the villagers, by one who ‘speaks from intimate knowledge. The cir- cumstances attending the production of the play are pleasantly described, and the per- |sonal tone in which the author writes ac- ‘cords well with the attempt to bring out the importance which the play has in the personal lives of the players. A similar book by the Rev. E. Hermitage Day, “Oberammergau and the Passion Play; 'a Practical and Historical Handbook for Visitors” (Milwaukee: The Young Church. 'man Co.), dwells especially upon the spirit ‘of the production, It contains a useful syn- |opsis, and its practical guidance is accom- panied by considerable descriptive matter; |the historical background seems somewhat | remote. An abundance of good illustrations ‘and tasteful printing make this a neat little | volume. Sir Herbert Tree says that the play which Alfred Noyes has written for him is “a work of pure imagination, something be- tween ‘The Blue Bird’ and ‘Pinkie and the Fairies, with a distinctly Christmassy flavor.” A new play by Henry James will be pro- duced before long in Charles Frohman’s Repertory Theatre in London. Granville Barker is superintending the rehearsals. It begins to look as if Mr. Frohman were real- lv in earnest in his experiment with the literary and intellectual theatre. The rural theatre seems to be making some advance in England. The Aldbourne Village Players are filling a two weeks’ season at the London Coronet Theatre, They play every evening, with matinées on Wednesday and Saturday. The Aldbourne Village Theatre—‘‘the first village theatre for village players in England’’—was open- ed for Mr. McEvoy by Granville Barker on February 26. The play presented was “The | Village Wedding,” a cottage drama in three acts, which Mr. McEvoy had specially writ- ten for his company, Since the opening of |the Aldbourne Theatre “The Village Wed- 'ding” has been played sixteen times to crowded houses, thousands of persons hav- ing travelled to the little village of Ald- bourne to be present. The play has also been presented by the Village Players eigh- teen times elsewhere, including two per- formances at the Galety Theatre, Manches- ter. In London the whole original cast ap- pears. After the London season the company returns to Aldbourne for the hay-making and harvest, and in the autumn will fulfil engagements in the provinces and in Ire- lend. The Abbey Theatre Company of Dublin |has begun an engagement in the London Court Theatre, opening with “Deirdré of the Sorrows,” written by J. M. Synge not long before he died. “The Playboy of the

Page 25

June 2,1 Western World” will also be given. A num- ber of plays new to London are likely to be presented, including “The Green Hel- met,” a play in verse by W. B. Yeats; “The Image,” a comedy by Lady Gregory; “The Eloquent Dempsey,” by William Boyle; “Thomas Muskerry,” by Padriac Colm; “The Glittering Gate,” by Lord Dunsany; and two plays by a young dramatist, S. L, Robinson. The company will include Sara Allgood, Maire O'Neill, Arthur Sinclair, Fred O'Donovan, and J. M. Kerrigan. Musie. Boston Symphony Orchestra Pro- grammes. Boston: C. A. Ellis. One of the bulkiest books that come to a newspaper office is the annual vol- ume containing the programmes of the Boston Symphony Orchestra. The issue for 1909-1910 contains 1,860 pages. Many of these are filled with advertisements, some of which inconveniently interrupt the reading matter; but there is enough of this, too, to entitle the tome to a per- manent place in a music-lover’s library. The editor, Philip Hale, who, as a news- paper critic, can give free expression to his dislike of things that are good and great in music, must have suf- fered agonies in the attempt to write pleasantly about the concert pieces he has to comment on for these pro- grammes, and the soloists who help to interpret them; yet he usually succeeds surprisingly well. He has somewhat curbed his pedantic passion for foot- notes, and he generally avoids the fool- ish parsing in which some programme elucidators indulge. No less readable than his comments on the programmes are the “Entr’actes and Excursions’ which are inserted to keep the Boston brain agreeably exercised while the or- chestra has its intermissions. They are partly the editor’s own, partly culled trom diverse newspapers. Among the notable topics discussed are Bruckner, Therese Brunswick and Beethoven, Col- or Audition, Don Juan in Music, Leg- end of the Flying Dutchman, The Lore- ley in Legend and Music, Newman’s “Hugo Wolf,” Schubert's First Singers, Liszt in Rome, Grenville Bantock, Does Music Pay? Unopin, In Defence of Tran- scriptions, Music in the Theatre, Dau- det’s “L’Arlésienne.” There are sundry indexes, including one for the footnotes, and the programmes are given in full, with soloists, dates, and summaries of the number of times diverse composers were represented. The present conduc- tor, Max Fiedler, evidently has not much interest in American music, only three of our composers—Chadwick, Con- verse, and Loeffler—being represented, one each. Some oddly assorted pairs are Beethoven and Strauss, who head the procession with eight hearings each, and Brahms and Wagner, who come next, with seven each. The number of The Nation. composers altogether was forty-six. Max Fiedler’s programmes are not always models, but, on the whole, they include what the public particularly wants to hear; and Mr. Hale’s comments and erudite references will serve as a treas- ure-house for the editors of the pro- gramme books of the other American orchestras, the number of which has in creased surprisingly within the last ten years. Art. TWO SALONS. THE Paris, May 18. The artist in France cannot blame of his own failure on the Gov ernment with the ease of the British artist, who is now convinced that art in England needs but the encouragement of the state to wake up from its torpor Nothing strikes one more, on coming to the two Salons from the Royal Academy and the International, than the number of pictures and prints and sculptures bearing the label “commanded” or “ac- quired by the state.” The state orders pictures and buys them, it provides lay the wall space for the designs of its painters end buildings for the stat- ues of its sculptors, and the results scarcely justify the belief of the British artist that inspiration must come with encouragement, Neither Salon makes a sign of that awakening, or rebellion, or new movement, or whatever it may be called, that some people think has long been due. Of course, the mistake is in counting upon an awakening with every spring. In the last century the interval of stagnation was long between the romanticists of the thirties and the impressionists of the seventies; and again there was a pause before the mem- orable secession of 1890 and the wonder- ful series of exhibitions that followed for some few years afterwards at the new Salon. So high a level could not be maintained indefinitely, and, while the older generation gives evidence of exhaustion, the younger generation has not yet come knocking at the door loud enough to make itself heard. In the old Salon the vigor, the vitality, that was once the redeeming merit of the exhibi- tors there, seems to have weakened; the huge machin, of old its chief fea ture, has dwindled in numbers and threatens to shrink in size; and, more unfortunately, Henri Martin, who knew how to bring to it distinction and dec orative dignity, is this year among the absent. In the new Salon it is not the vigor, the vitality, alone of the artist, but in many cases the artist himself who has disappeared—for the time, any- way. You look in vain for such dis tinguished painters from abroad as Anglada and Zuloaga, Zorn, and Veber, ~~ _-_~ 6 é Sargent and Liebermann, who at one period were always represented. Th president, Roll, sends nothing, his forces this year reserved for Venice, and if Besnard does send, he is content to be represented by but one picture, and this one he has often surpassed. Alto gether, the absences are so numerous and so notable that the collection whole inevitably suffers in interest. I make this explanation at once, be cause, really, nothing is more character istic of either exhibition than the pre vailing dulness. However, a lesser « gree of interest does not mean no inte! est, and I have not passed through these endless galleries entirely without my reward. In the old Salon I was ed especially by the big series of panels Jean-Paul naturally, sinc: they Surrender at York destined for the Lavy It is suggestive after Abbey's Pittsburgh now at the Before the Frenchman's work as a attract by Laurens, represent the and at town are Courts Baltimore. to see them so0 soon de signs for Royal Academy. feel how tered technically the needs and uses ot mural decoration. He convinces you that he knows how to make his picture tell on the flat wall it is designed to cover, how to make his subject the motive for an effective arrangement lines and you much better he has ma of col ors. The windings of the road and th: red-coated troops through the bare landscape, the enclosing fences, the raised fort, the stretch of water beyond —all become parts of an ingenious pat tern, well-defined, well-balanced, restful to the eye. But so much is to be ex pected from the decorator who has learned his trade. More is looked for from the artist who should infuse th: spirit of life into the pattern. It is just here that Laurens fails. His officer and soldiers are puppets whose place in the pattern is their only reason for be ing there. The title of the design can not but recall another famous surrender that was made more famous still by the painter’s record of it on his canvas— the surrender of Breda. not heedless of his pattern, his record is splendidly decorative. But he ex pressed, too, the emotion, the tragedy, of the incident; the meaning of his two central figures is none the less poignant because the lances which give the pic ture one of its names group themselvs with such decorative beauty in the back ground. The central figures in Lau rens's Surrender are but puppets like the rest, they convey no emotion, not s« Velasquez was much as a hint of tragedy, they have not even a leading in the pattern.’ However, other work the same that can compare with it. In other kinds of work, it dinary to find how persistently Salon of the Artistes Francais repeats the same famillar features spring after spring. Here again are two fine virll« importance there is no on colossal scale is extraor the

Page 26

568 landscapes by Harpignies, so like to his is impossible anything of them except that in one this year he shows—and shows superbly—Un Centenaire of the tree world, symbolic apparently of him- self in the world of painters. Bonnot again vies with the photograph in the hard exactness of the likeness he obtains Edmond Théry and Isidore Leroy this time his sitters. And once more Joseph Bail displays his skill in render- ing an interior filled with homely do- mestic detail elaborately carried out in his Kitchen of the Hospital at Beaune; and also is assured of his success by the most flattering compliment of all, for his imitators abound on every side and brass and copper are brought to such a glorification of polish in so many can- vases that Bail in self-protection should scrupulously shut his eyes forevermore to metal that is polishable. Also, the Spanish element is to the fore: Zo with a group of the dancing boys that bring previous pictures that it to say more the tourists in crowds to Seville at Easter, Ribera with Carmen, who is now an indispensable heroine of the modern exhibition; Salas with an equal- ly indispensable religious procession; Vasquez with the inevitable scene from the Bull Ring—though Sorolla shows not. But no convention survives trium- phant'y continual usage, and the radi- ance of conventional Spanish sunlight grows a little dimmed. Nor has the American element vanished, though per- haps it is quite so strong as in some recent exhibitions. Few things in the entire collection interested me as much as Richard Miller’s Statuette Cli- noise, rather for the rendering of still- life than as a portrait of the girl who sits before the idol and a mirror beyond it in which her face, with its clear rose tints and golden hair, is reflected. The beauty is in the gown of quiet but gor- geous plaid, in the figured bodice, in the reflection, above all in the little Chinese figure catching the light, and giving it out again as if the light shone but to express its subtle modelling and beauty of surface. Nothing could be better as a plece of painting, though there is no pictorial reason why the woman should be in the picture; she is a mere bit of still-life herself. Vonnoh is not so suc- cessful as he was with the portrait of his wife two or three years ago. In his Mr. Clifford Grayson, he has evidently sought to use his sitter as a motive for an arrangement in brown and black, the of the background repeated in the waistcoat, In the cane, In the gloves. That a portrait painter should spare a thought for color arrangement Is a fact that in itself arrests attention at the old Salon But Vonnoh’s thought for ar rangement has left him less time for the study of character. Another good por- trait, reticent in color, graceful in pose, is one of a young girl by MacCameron; and Hubbell’s La Sortie is an admirable not brown ‘landscapes, Charles W. [ Vol. 90, No. 2344 The Na tion. ‘full-length of a lady in street dress, who | stands well within her frame, with the quiet, almost austerity, of color, which the younger school of Americans have learned from Whistler. Among the Eaton's forest in winter and moonlight night in au- tumn make their effect by the refine- ment of color and light, the wonderful | gradation in the luminous sky, and the sympathy of observation. There is too e striking painting of winter by E. W. | Redfield, a relief after the sprawling countrysides of the usual exhibitor, with whom inappropriate size and screaming color are bids for notice. In the section of engraving, Pen- nell’s etchings of England at Work, Timothy Cole’s sympathetic reproduc- tion of Carriére’s Maternité with its en- velope of atmosphere admirably sug- gested, and Henry Wolf's print after Corot stand out with a good deal of dis- tinction, especially as year by year the old Salon devotes itself more exclusively to the big commercial print, to the enor- | mous reproductive etching and litho- graph, and spares less space and promi- nence to the original expressions of both these arts. In the sculpture section, it was no doubt partly prejudice that drew me particularly to Barnard’s La Vie Hu- maine, for not only are the two enor- mous designs, entitled respectively Le Fardeau de la Vie and Le Travail et la Fraternité, the biggest in the Sculpture Court, but both are to have their perma- nent place in my native country and, to appeal to me still more personally, in my native State. Whether from preju- dice or not, certainly I found nothing else so ambitious in subject and compo- | They are groups of nude fig-| sition. ures, heroic in scale, elaborate in ar- rangement, full of detail, and replete with allegory for those whose pleasure | it will be to unravel it from its symbols in stone. When it is a question of the more important question of the decora- tive value of these great groups, I feel, as I so often do with work designed for a special place and purpose, the difficul- ty, or perhaps I should say the impos- sibility, of judging it when in the dis- cordant setting of a modern exhibition. As seen at the Salon, the composition of each group strikes me as a little in- coherent; there is no fine outline, the separate forms hardly seem bold enough or simple enough or well enough sub- ordinated to the effect as a whole. But the sculptor knows, as I do not, the con- ditions for which he is working, and the probability is that the groups, on the bullding which they are to adorn, would spring. Too many of the others. like so many of the more distinguished mem- bers of the Artistes-Francais, show an ever-strengthening tendency to repeti- tion in subject and dependence on the same convention, with the consequent loss of the old spontaneity and fresh- ness, I feel this very much in the work of painters like Gaston La Touche and Aman-Jean, whose work varies slightly as one sees it spring after spring, except for the size of the canvas and for the |/new models and sitters they sometimes —though not often in the case of Aman- Jean—may find. Both these artists have the great advantage of definite com- missions to fill, but even this does not suffice to stimulate them to the point of facing fresh problems. In a new series of three panels for the state, La Touche gives but another variation of the old theme built up of swans and fountains, of sunlight and figures, ideal and real, so that I wondered if they might not be the same decorations I had seen in al- most the same place a year ago. In a new design for the Musée des Arts Déco- ratifs, Aman-Jean’s phantoms still wan- der and lounge in his phantom land- scape, so alike in form and feature that they seem but shadows of one another, faint blossoms still blooming languor- ously among the fainter foliage as if they had not the energy even to fade with time. His work always has charm, but he allows it no chance to develop more virile qualities in the pale land of ghosts to which he restricts it. Something of this same dimness, as well as the same repetition, is becoming as characteristic of the work of Barlow. But while his charm is no less than Aman-Jean’s, the forms in his paint- ings have greater solidity. There are real women under the long cloaks he wraps about them, real heads under the | white caps he always gives them to wear, ‘seen though they are through the haze with which he envelops his peasants and their life. His color schemes are as subdued as ever, the accustomed ‘sadness pervades the meetings of the quiet groups whom he once again ar- |ranges into so many new variations, ‘this time four in number, of the old | harmony. Frieseke has another series of small nudes in strong sunlight which filters through fresh green foliage, with a touch of rose or blue in the drapery ‘lying across the grass; he returns to ‘earlier motives in a group of two wo- ‘men watching a cage of little parrots, |though their real purpose is simply to afford him an opportunity for painting the sumptuous details he delights in, and for weaving a decorative pattern impress me very differently. ‘out of the lines and ornament of their The balance of interest still lies with the Salon of the Société Nationale des Beaux-Arts, though not in the over- whelming degree of its earlier days. 1 have said how many of the exhibitors | of greatest note have stayed away this gowns, the cage, and the wall behind them. It is by the elimination, rather than the emphasis, of detail that Mau- rice Denis gets his effect, and he al- lows no voluptuousness of line to his figures, no charm of ornament, no dain-

Page 27

June 2, 1910]

tiness of dress, whether the subject is Orpheus with his lyre or Christ among the children, Joan of Arc receiving the Sacrament, or modern bathers on a modern stretch of beach. He has no im- portant piece of decoration this year— important, that is, in size—but his Orpheus, with its arrangement of up- right lines in a grove of trees, repeated in the figures clothed in long straight garments of archaic and austere cut, and with its well-distributed spaces of green, looks as if it were a sugges- tion for a mural decoration on a larger scale. The growth of mannerism is no less marked among the portrait painters than among the decorators. One has come to know so well the water finish | which Dagnan Bouveret gives to his sit- ters and the fashionable elegance that Gandara and Carolus-Duran lavish upon theirs, that one scarcely stops to look upon the yearly portraits by these paint- ers, certain that if the modes they rec- ord have changed within the last twelve months their methods have not; though this year it is to Gandara the place of honor in the central gallery has been reserved, and Carolus-Duran has had an officer in the splendor of Italian uni- form for one of his three sitters. Life, or its semblance, is apt to vanish from many portraits of masters as accom- plished and of as established reputa- | tions. But not from Boldini’s. His are never without life; on the contrary they overfiow with life—in the sitter who is all vivacity and animation, in the paint- er who exults in the swift eloquent strokes of the brush that fill his can- vas with the sheen and shimmer of silks and satins, and the glow and glitter of jewels. But, as I have pointed out of- ten before now, his exuberance verges on caricature. His two ladies this year, one in a bewildering “creation” of gray, | the other in as elaborate an arrange- ment of brown, almost step from out the <anyas to meet you; their dress out- does the exaggerations of the passing mode, and in the angular affectation of their pose and the meaningless gestures of their hands they are not far from degenerating into caricatures of the im- possible ladies of the popular fashion plates. From both, it is a relief to turn to the little girl in his third canvas, not so much for the child herself, in simple frock and the long black silk stockings Boldini loves to paint, as for the great gray Persian cat she holds in her arms, rendered with a freedon! and power and truth that make one wish all his sitters were so little encumbered by the fashions that too frequently dis- tract him from themselves. Blanche is in less danger of becoming mannered, because he brings less character of his own, less sense of style to his work than either Dagnan Bouveret or Carolus- Duran, Gandara or Boldini. He has four portraits in the general ex-. and, besides, a _ little hibition to himself in one of the small galleries downstairs, and it cannot be said that he is a painter who gains by having so much of his work shown together. He is a good draughtsman, he has technical skill and vigor. He can see things for himself hibition, ex- and put them down as he sees them;: the trouble is in the way he sees them: his vision is commonplace. I think it is because of the lack of distinction that the series of portraits downstairs fail to make their effect. They are like the in- teriors he paints: true, exact, showing observation, but just without that in- definable quality that makes the little rooms painted by Walter Gay—six are now shown—such delightful master- pieces. Caro-Delvaille has a life-size full-length of Mme. Vallandri of the Opéra-Comique, but the figure is curi- ‘ously unimpressive, easily forgotten for pleasure in the delightfully rendered vase of flowers and sheets of music on the table by her side. Ostermann has a portrait of the King of Sweden, a half- length, that might have been interest- |ing if royalty nowadays did not seem to exact an uninteresting degree of finish from the painter when brought face to face with it. Because there is less fin- ish, there is more character in the same painter’s Archbishop of Lund. The fame of the sitter leads interest to Simonidy’s very unpoetic presentment of the poet, half American and half-French, Francis Viélé-Griffin. The straightforward real- ism of Renouard’s M. Binet, Architecte du Gouvernement, portrayed on the scaf- folding with his builders and workmen, |inspires confidence. Columbano also car- ries conviction by his uncompromising realism, almost brutality. I say nothing of J. J. Shannon because he shows ao portraits I have not already seen in London. But I cannot pass over those of the young Boutet de Monvel, who en- deavors to lend dignity to his sitters by an exaggerated effect of height ob- tamed from a touch of perspective ‘which is at least amusing. The people in the Place de la Concorde look up to his Comte E. de B., who stands there in the immediate foreground, as if he were a statue set on a high pedestal. Perhaps I should have included Si- mon with the portrait painters, but his large group, La Poursuite, has the air rather of an impersonal decoration than the family group en plein air, for which I suppose he meant it. bare-footed, in short-waisted pink slips, one with flying pigtails, running, but with an effect of arrested motion, strive in vain to attract the attention of the mother and the baby in her arms who both stare placidly into space. The painting is immensely fluent and learn- ed, as in his other two big pictures, one of Bretonnes battling and the other of Harlequin, Columbine, and Pierrot play- ing the Comedy, but it has hardly more Two little girls,’ -_ 569 suggestion of life than the splendidly gowned ladies of Gandara. No doubt there are portraits in Cottet’s Ceremony in the Cathedral of Burgos, but the like- ness in every case is subordinated to the spectacle, which would more gor geous than it is if he could have main- tained throughout the splendor of painting achieved in the golden cope of one of the chief celebrants. Hochard, like Cottet, has gone to the church for subject and he has depicted in many mediums the ceremony, and the particl- pants in it, of the canonization of Joan of Arc, but with hardly the eloquence inspired in him by the drama of the market place. Louis Legrand has no paintings, Charles Guérin but two, and both of comparatively small importance. Nor is there much among the land- scapes and marines to detain one. be Rodin sends, as to the International in London, a female torso, but here adds to it the bronze bust of a man, strong in character. He himself figures in the work of Bourdelle and Soud- binine, both of whom honor the master by giving him the head and expression of a venerable satyr. Bourdelle is seen to finer advantage in a large bronze, with the movement powerfully express- ed, its subject Heraklés Tue les Oiseaux de Stymphale. Bartholomé’s fragment for the tomb of Rousseau in the Pan- theon has not the big simple dignity of the figures and groups for his tomb at Pére-la-Chaise; neither has his nude, a young girl, Au bord de l’Eau, though graceful and charming in a simple way. Here and there a bust, as, for example, a portrait of a young man by Jedrzeje- wicz, suggests character, and a special exhibition is made of the work of Lu- cien Schnegg. Otherwise, not much need be said of the sculpture one way or the other. N, N. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Addison, J. de W. The Boston Museum Fine Arts. Boston: Page & Co. Aldrich, M. C. Sonnets for Choice. fat, Yard. $1 net. Babbitt, I. The New Laokoon: An Essay on the Confusion of the Arts. Boston: Hough- ton Mifflin. $1.25 net. of Mof- Back to the Land: a Medley. Longmans, Green. Baedeker’s Southern Germany, 1910. Scrib- ner. $1.80 net. Barber, M. Britz, of Headquarters. Mof- fat, Yard. $1.50. Baring, M. Dead Letters. Boston: Hough- ton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Barnett, Mrs. P. A. Drifting Thistledown. Longmans, Green. Barry, J. ©. Ideals and Principles of Church Reform. Scribner. $1.25 net Bartholomew, J. G. An Economic Atlas. Frowde, Bates, L., Jr. The Russian Boston: Houghton Mifflin. Berkeley, H. Mysticism in Road to China. $3 net Modern Mathe- matics. Frowde. Brainard, A. A Study of God, Man and Destiny. Cochrane Pub. Co, $1. Bray, H. T. The Living Universe. Chicago: Truro Pub. Co. $3.50. Brown, K. H. Philippa at Halycon. ner. $1.50. Bruce, H. A. Daniel Boone and the Wilder- ness Road. Macmillan. $1.50. Scrib-

Page 28

570 Bushell W. Description of Chinese Pot- tery and Porcelain. Translated. Frowde Bussell, F. W. Marcus Aurelius and the Later Stoics. Scribner. $1.25. Clark, C. H. The Great Natural Philadelphia: Jacobs & Co. Coleridge, S. T Poems of Nature and Ro- mance, 1794-1807. Edited by M. A. Keel- ing Frowde. 90 cents. Creamer, E. S. An Epic of Heaven and Other Poems. Broadway Pub. Co. $1. Cullum, R The Sheriff of Dyke Philadelphia: Jacobs & Co. $1.50. Davis, A. M. F. A Bibliographical Puzzle. Reprinted from Publications of The Co- lonial Society of Massachusetts. Cam- bridge: John Wilson & Son. Day, F. A., and Knappen, T. M. Life of John Albert Johnson. Chicago: Forbes & Co Dayrell, E . 5 Healer. Hole. Folk Stories from Southern NI- geria, West Africa. Longmans, Green. Dewey, D Problems of Your Generation Arden Press. $1. Free Library of No. 9 Godfrey, H. The Health of the City. ton. Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Gribble, F. The Passions of the Romantics. Scribner. $3.75 net. ‘faeckel, E. The Evolution of Man: a Pop- ilar Scientific Study. 2 vols. Putnam $5 net Haggard, Green. Hamilton, M. A. A Junior Rome. Frowde. $1.10. irings before the Committee on Agri- culture During the Session of the Sixty- first Congress, in three volumes. Vol. LU Washington. Philadelphia Bulletin, Bos- French H. R. Morning Star. Longmans, History of ve Henry Holt & Company 3 ¥ ISSUB THIS WEEK Max Vernon’s In and Out of Florence With 48 full-page illustrations from photographs and about 100 drawings by Maud Lanktree. 370 pp. With in- dex. 8vo. $2.50 net; by mall, $2.67. A reliable though delightfully informal book, liable to prove as attractive to fire- side travellers as to those who actually cross the sea Besides covering Flor- ence’s art treasures and the sights of interest to tourists, including the de- lightful excursions to Vallambrosa, and over the Consuma Pass, the Casentino, Prato, Pistoja, Luca, and Pisa, the au- thor treats of such practical matters as House-Hunting, Servants, Shopping, etc. They have “Vamba’s”’ The Prince and His Ants By LUIGI BERTELLI. Translated by SARAH F. WOODRUFF. With 8 col- ored plates and many text illustrations 12mo. $1.35 net; by mall, $1.48. This book, which has had a wide popu- larity among the children of Italy, is now tesued in a spirited translation. It is the engaging story of a boy who be- came an ant and had many thrilling ad- ventures with other ants, and wasps and bees, and of his sister who became a butterfly "The impossible ta euch delightful fancy and so frankly make-belleve-——while the possible is so true and so fascinatingly told.’’-—From the Introduction by Prof. Vernon L. Kellogg, Aw thor of “Inacot Btortes,’’ ete. M. Little’s At the Sign of the Burning Bush \ tale of to-day Though theologs are prominent in it, it is said to contain “not a word of preaching.” Karly British notices praise it highly, Claudius Clear” dev. ting nearly three columns to it In the British Weekly. $1.50 Times’ Review "Oharacters drawn with a eure bend, and with wnusual subtlety The story broadens and «trikes deep roots into be- man nature and human life . . a story that seeme as If it might have been made out | of the real experiences of flesh and blood, told! with hamor that te sometimes biting and some- times gentle, and with very great humanness."’ just published: Scotch : + « * + « « * + « * : * * + « + : « * « + : : « « * 2 « 5 « 7 « « + + + | « ® « + + + + « + « + + + + * * a + * The Nat 10 nh. Spirit and Matter Before Heysinger, lI. W Philadelphia: the Bar of Modern Science. Lippincott. $3.75 net. Hodges, G. The Year of Grace, Trinity to Advent. Thos, Whittaker. $1.25 net. hyde E. S Progress from Experience. Cochrane Pub. Co. $1. Ivimy, A. M. A Woman's Guide to Paris. Brentano Johnson, O Taylor Kerr, J The Humming Bird. Baker & 50 cents. Scottish Education, University. Putnam. $2 net. Knight, A. F. Mademoiselle Celeste: A Ro- mance of the French Revolution. Phila- delphia: Jacobs & Co. $1.50. Laufer, B. Chinese Pottery of the Han Dynasty. Leiden: E. J. Brill. Legge, E. The Empress Eugénie. $2 net. Little, M. Holt. Macbeth, M. The Winning Game. way Pub. Co. $1.50. Marczali, H. Hungary in the Eighteench Century. Putnam. $2.50 net. Medley, W. Interpretations of Horace. Edited by J. G. Skemp and G. W. Macal- pine. Frowde. Merwin, H. C. Dogs and Men. Houghton Miffilin. 60 cents net. Munn, M. C. Will Shakespeare of Strat- ford and London: a Drama. Dodd, Mead. $1.20 net. Norris, W. E. The Perjurer. Brentano. North, A. W. Camp and Camino in Lower California. Redlich, J. Commons: School and Scribner. At the Sign of the Burning Bush. Broad- The Procedure of the House of A Study of Its History and Present Form. Translated from the Ger- | man. 3 vols. Dutton. $10 net. Boston: [Vol. 90, No. 2344 Ryder, A. W. Women’s Eyes: Being verses translated from the Sanskrit. San Fran- cisco: A. M, Robertson. $1 net. Schlesinger, K. Instruments of the Modern Orchestra and Early Records of the Pre- cursors of the Violin Family. 2 vols. Scribner. $6 net. Selected Poems from The Harvard Monthly, 1885-1910. Cambridge, Mass: Harvard Monthly. $1 Short, J. H. Oberammergau. net. Sichel, W. Sterne: a Study. Philadelphia: Lippincott. $2.50 net. Smith, P. F., and Longley, W. R. Theoret- ical Mechanics. Boston: Ginn. $2.50. Sonnenschein, W. S. The Best Books: a Reader’s Guide. Third edition rewritten. Part I. Putnam. $3.50 net. Stanton, V. H. The Gospels as Historical Documents. Part Il. Putnam. $3.50 net. Crowell. | Stoll, E. E. Anachronism in Shakespeare Criticism. Reprint from Modern Philolo- gy, April, 1910. Univ. of Chicago Press. Trepoff, I. The Forsaken. Cochrane Pub. Co. $1.10. Underwood, J. C. The Iron Muse. $1.25 net. Vamba (Luigi Bertelli). The Prince and His Ants. Translated from the Italian. Holt. $1.35 net. Viallate, A. La Vie Politique dans Les Deux Mondes. Paris: Félix Alcan. Wahlert, E. Completion of Coleridge’s Christabel. Cochrane Pub. Co. Williams, H. N. The Fascinating Duc de Richelieu. Scribner. $4 net. Williamson, G. C. Portrait Min‘atures. Lane Co. $3 net. Winstanley, D. A. Personal and Party Government. Putnam. $1.50 net. Putnam. FOR THE SUMMER LIBRARY GWENDA, By Mabel Barnes-Grundy, | author of ‘“Dimbie and 1,” “Hilary on Her Own,"’ “Hazel of Heatherland.”” An inti- | mate, intense storv, relleved by humor and a dash of worldly wisdom. 12mo. 350 pages. Frontispiece. $1.50. THE TOP OF THE MORNING. By | Juliet Wilbor Tompkins, author of ‘Dr. Ellen" and “Open House." A sparkling, | wholesome story, full of humor, vivacity and | charm. 12mo. Frontispiece in color. $1.60) | IN PRAISE OF GARDENS. Compiled by Temple Scott. Poems and verses about gardens from the whole range of English | poetry. Charming in contents and in form. $1.25 THE GARDEN IN THE WILDER- NESS. By “A Hermit.” A felicitous mingling of gardening and sentiment. Many | illustrations, decorative end papers, etc. $1.50 net. | WOMEN AS LETTER WRITERS. | Exlited by Ada M. Ingpen. The best letters written by women from the 16th century until our own time. 12mo. 9 full-page | portraits. $1.25 net. | THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., NEW YORK Catalog 16, Books Aboul lowa Cataleg 17, High Grade Americana Just ready and sent to any address on receipt of a post card. They con- tain some extremely rare books. The TORCH PRESS BOOK SHOP, Cedar Rapids, lowa The Best Books A Reader’s Guide to the Choice of the Peet. tenon By William Swan Sonnenschein Third Edition Entirely Rewritten To Be in Three Parts. Part I. 83.50 net. Ready. “It would be difficult to exaggerate the usefulness of this work or to praise too highly the industry of the compiler. Turn to what subject we may, we find the best current books which the reader may consult, and their prices."—London Spectator. G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS, S*voxoom The Science of Life and the Larger Hope By the Right Rev. J. E. Mercer, D.D., Bishop of Tasmania. Crown 8vo. pp. vi+195. $1.20 net. | LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York cloth, with “The Nation” stamped READING CASE FOR THE NATION To receive the current numbers in a convenient temporary form. Substantially made, bound in on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75c. THE NATION 20 Vesey Street, N. Y. City

Page 29