The Nation 1910-05-12: Vol 90 Iss 2341

Page 1

Univ. MAY VOL. XC.—NO. 2341. ‘The WARY, “Vi° Dali 13 1910 o> s « as 00 TEN CENTS. MAY THURSDAY, 12, 1910 PRICE THE NEW BY THE . Mr. AUTHOR OF “RICHARD CARVEL,” WINSTON CHURCHILL’S new novel MACMILLAN NOVELS “THE CRISIS,” “CONISTON, “A Modern Chronicle ” “Intensely The critics are saying that Mr. Churchill's modern.” “quite the strongest, truest and best reer he has N. Y. Tribune. eresting, it is a performance emotional] “Intensely leclare that his picture of rich and smart New Y interesting.” ing exaggerated, adding: “N h Phila. Ledger. A NOVEL “WHOSE GREATNESS N‘ “ Nathan Burke” urke VE CAN "By Makes S. Watts is an exqu isitely delightful pir “A great Vathan novel.” ‘*ommon nowadays; “infinitely interesting’; “a | * “Great, spirit’; “The character of Mrs tha y alor | k notable, [he story is a masterpiece likely to b readable.” he A POWERFUL NEW NOVEL BY THE AUTHOR OF “THE CONQUI Gertrude Atherton’: S “Tower of Ivory” le book of this remarkable | , agreeing t Notably The critics write in praise g that powerful, author presented with such extraordinary clearness and power s I brilliantly portrayal of impulses and inspirations as is unfolded in this brilli record interesting. love of a real man and a great woman told as no other Ar: n livi 1 it” (New York Evening Mail) Clot NOVEL BY THE AUTHOR OF “SARACINESCA,” “PAUL PATOFF,” A NEW F. Marion Crawford’s “ The Undesirable Governess” His last imost unexpectedly full of rip ppling humor; a » his fr reg unpublished he did not more often drop into such li ‘cht, keen, irre sistib! amusing ial sh fiction. Cloth AN UNUSUALLY IMPORTANT NOVEL TO BE READY VERY SHORT Robert Herrick’s “A Life for a Life” k has held the rank of being tl By the Author Ever since “Tite Common Lot” appeared, Mr. Herricl of “The most authoritative analyst of mo one social conditions in the United Stat | Common totally different field from his book, “Toget " his new nove equally forci Lot,” etc. Rea about May 25. Cl $1.50 Published by equally interesting THE MACMILLAN 64-66 Fifth Ave. 7 ve COMPANY

Page 2

li The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. [Bntered at the New York City Post Office as second-class mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, President: William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Merico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Poatal Union $4.00 iddreas THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. Three CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WEEK Epit: ARTICLES The Progr Al It The RIAL Death of Edward VII n China piring Career _ Rhode Scholarships noenéceee GEE Spr Mark NAL ARTICLES r'wain 477 CORRESPONDENC! Welle Schem¢ 480 {80 oo San . 481 482 482 482 TI f Gideo r Philippine Land Thoreau and Confuciu A Memorial to Professor Slavery in Vi Questior Photogra Mau. gin Answered yhing Ma LITERATURI uuth African Memo I ! Amor 4 pouthn Se i wre P Borneo and the pine Through Pe from the f Caspian—The C . t Beachcomber Sav- Philip- rsia 482 onséen Se \ Romance is4 484 of an A.D.C ees No York Life .. 484 Ch 184 iS5 .. 485 . 486 487 495 » procured in ‘Opéra: ina The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2341 Educational. ‘HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES veRetr O. Pee & Co. , Proprietors. A Park Stree t, Boston 1505 Pa. , Washington toe Fifth Ave., “Wew York 414 Cen. Bid,, Minneapolis 206 Mich. , Chicago 292 Swetiand Bid., Portiand 405 Cooper Bidg. Denver 238DouglasBid. sap ngeee 618 Peyton Bid., “kpokane 2149shattuck Ave., eley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all —_~ with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St.,Albany, N.Y. IT IS THE DESIRE OF THE ADVERTISER TO OBTAIN INSTRUCTION IN SPANISH, AFTERNOON OR EVENING, IN NEW YORK CITY. ADDRESS, B. C. D., Care or THE NATION. ELEMENTS OF ENGLISH VERSIFICATION By James Wilson Bright and Raymond O. Miller SO cents A text-book for use in connection with | general courses in literature which presents j all essentials for an understanding of verse from the simplest definition to the construc- tion of the complete poem GINN AND COMPANY 29 BEACON STREET BOSTON How We Think By DR. JOHN DEWEY, Columbia University Cloth. 230 pages $1.00 A practical application of modern psychol- to the problems of education, by a lead- er of thought in both fields. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers ROSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO LONDON THE TEMPLE CLASSICS 233 VOLUMES o2ryv GeneraL Eprror: Isragi GoLLancz, M.A. Each volume contains a photogravure frontisplece, a decorative title-page, and a ribbon bookmark; where advisable, editorial ippendices and marginalia, also. PRICES: In cloth, each volume 45 cts. Net in limp leather, each volume 65 cts. Net E P. DUTTON & COMPANY 31 WEST 23D STREET, NEW YORK. A new book on Games PLAY: GAMES FOR THE KINDERGARTEN, e SCHOOL ROOM AND COLLEGE By Emmett Dunn Angell. The most practical book on the subject, describing over 100 carefully graded games, many entirely original With over 50 illustrations. $1.50 net; postpaid $1.63 LITTLE, BROWN & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere, 155 vols pocket size List prices, cloth, 35c. per v limp leather, 7T5c. per vol. (Special prices to schools and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE, Thomas Y.Croweil&Co., New York ANNE OF AVONLEA SEQUEL TO “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES.” Situation Wanted. WANTED, position as cashier or general office manager; execu- tive ability, thorough office ex- perience; references. W.L. S., care of The Nation. THE HARVARD THEOLOGICALREVIEW FOR APRIL includes the following articles: Concerning Miracle..Borden P, Bowne The Theology of William Newton Clarke....William Adams Brown The Religious Environment of Early Christianity.... Bphraim Emerton New Forces in Religious Education....... Henry W. Holmes Religion and Socialism.Vide D. Scudder The Harvard Expedition to Samaria........: George A. Reisner PUBLISHED BY HARVARD UNIVERSITY FOR SALE AT THE NEWS STANDS. Do you know theBeacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 50 cents net; by mail, 64 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. Small, Maynard & Co., 21 Beacon SL, Boston STENOGRAPHER GEO. B. COCK FRANKLIN BANK BUILDING, PHILADELPHIA WANTED—Some recent unbound vols. of The Nation. A. 8S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. William Lloyd Garrison 1805-1879. The Story of his Life, told by his Children. Illustrated with over 40 portraits, views, etc. 4 vols., 8vo, gilt top, $8.00 net. “It is, for the anti-slavery record, final; and the service done to our national history is as great as that to a father’s memory. Its one eminent trait, however, is its jus- tice.”"—Atlantic Monthly. “In fact, Southern history is not complete without this work.”—Atlanta Constitution. “A masterpiece of modern historical bi- ography. To call the work a mine of information would be to convey a false im- pression; it is rather a well-arranged li- brary in which attendant hands are always present to point the way to the exact thing wanted. Finally, the work, while as instructive as the driest manual, is as in- teresting as a romance.”—Boston Advertiser. *,." For sale by booksellers. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of price by the publishers, HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY BOSTON AND NEW YORK

Page 3

6 Se aS bh eT Pht BP ly # May 12, 1910] The Nation. IMPORTANT NEW PUBLICATIONS OF D. APPLETON & COMPANY 29-35 West 32nd Street, New York City. Ready This Week By ALBERT BUSHNELL HART, Ph.D., LL.D. Professor of History at Harvard University. Professor Hart spent nearly a year in the cities, towns and country districts of the Carolinas, Georgia, Alabama, Florida, Mississippi, and Louisiana; and in the mountains of Virginia, Tennessee, and Kentucky, gathering material for this book. It is a careful, accurate consideration of the condition of our Southern States four decades after the close of the war between the States, with philosophical conclusions which the author has arrived at as to the outlook for the future in commerce, agriculture, and sociological conditions. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net. THE PSYCHOLOGY OF REASONING By Professor W. B. PILLSBURY University of Michigan. An effort to determine the ways in which reasoning has grown and to discuss the uses that have been made of the materials in reasoning. This, however, has been done in a popular manner, and no attempt has been made to study the psychological interpretation or to go deeply into logic or psychology, or, in fact, to discuss, or even to mention, many phases of the reasoning process. Large 12mo, gilt top, rough-cut edges, $1.50 net UP THE ORINOCO AND DOWN THE MAGDALENA By H. J. MOZANS In this book the author relates his travels to South American countries and across the Andes under unusual conditions. Most of the time he was alone, except for a guide or two. The writer is an experienced traveller, was a long time on this journey, and had an opportunity to study the people, the country, and the fauna in an unusually intimate way. He travelled largely by foot or by pack mule, frequenting unknown and little-visited places and following the trails and unbeaten paths rather than familiar roads. 16 half-tones, 8vo, gilt top, rough-cut edges, $3.00 net s & The Reconstruction of The American Hope © eeady May 2 the English Church By WILLIAM MORSE COLE, Harvard University By R. G. USHER, Ph.D., Instructor in History, [his book is an attempt to look below and beyond ey , " ' : the unfavorable symptomis of American life, and t Washington University. These volumes describe in ae me ra great detail the administration and legal history of the later English Reformation, and bring Archbishop Bancroft into prominence for the first time.. 8vo, cloth, gilt top, rough-cut Ready Soon. all edges, 2 vols. in a box, $6.00 net. Travel and Sport in Turkestan The Drama of St. Helena By Captain J. N. PRICE WOOD. 100 Iilustrations Se e a Sue OE Os Me tant Cie from original photographs and an itemized expense- of Napoleon has never been more graphically told account of the journey. 8vo, cloth, handsomely see whether in the chaos anything is at work that may be utilized to improve the situation. It does not suggest specific remedies, but applies a general philosophy to the problem of twentieth century living 8vo, cloth, gilt top, rough-cut edges, $1.50 net. than in this book. 1I2mo, cloth, handsomely bound bound and printed. $3.50 special net. and printed. 93-00 spectal net er The Real Francis Joseph Queen Christina of Sweden THE PRIVATE LIFE OF THE EMPEROR OF AUSTRIA By I. A. TAYLOR. Author of “Lady Jane Grey By HENRI DE WEINDEL. English version by and her Times.” Photogravure frontispiece and 16 PHILIP W. SERGEANT. Photogravure frontis other beautiful portraits. 8vo, cloth, gilt top, rough- piece and 4o other portraits and illustrations cut edges. $4.00 special net. 8vo, cloth, $4.00 special net.

Page 4

The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2341

China and the Far Eas

Edited by Professor Grorce H. Brakestre 8vo, cloth, xxii+455 pages.

CONTENTS: “China in World Politics,” by Archibald Cary Coolidge, of Harvard University; “China and the OF CLARK UNIVERSITY

$2.00 net; postage 20 cents Western World,” by Hon. Chester Holcombe; “The United States and China,” by Dr. F. W. Williams, of Yale University; “Monetary Conditions in China,” by Dr. J. W. Jenks, of Cornell; “The Chinese Army,” by Major Eben Swift, U.S.A.; “Christian Missions in China,” by Professor Harlan P. Beach; “The Awakening of Korea,” by Hon. Horace N. Allen; “The Japanese Administration in Korea,” by Professor George Trumbull Ladd; and twelve other lectures by authorities of equal repute. Such a symposium as this cannot fail to touch every vital point in the questions at issue to-day on the trans-Pacific Coast, and either for general reading or for special research, this volume will appeal to many.”—Boston Evening Transcript. o . « The authoritative character of the book may be inferred from such authorship as that of Dr. Wright on the history and present condition of the opium question. He was the representative of the United States at the recent Interna- tional Opium Conference at Shanghal. , His lecture has the reliability of an official report.”—Hartford Courant. “There is scarcely a matter of importance which has not been touched upon. The fact that the lecturers were men PRESS COMMENTS

who are recognized authorities in their separate fields makes the work a noteworthy contribution to our literature upon the Far East.”—San Francisco Evening Bulletin. “A volume of special timeliness and importance, giving a group of expert opinions, separately expressed, but forming as a whole a remarkable consensus upon this ‘kingdom of mysteries.’""—Montreal Daily Star. “No one who has followed with attention the movements toward constitutional government in progress in China, in India, and in Korea can read without interest, or indeed without emotion, the volume entitled ‘China and the Far East.” . . . This is a book of first-rate importance upon a subject of urgent and growing interest.”—The Living Age.

THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO., Publishers, New York

LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S LIST

The History of the Irish Parlia- mentary Party from 1870 to 1890 By F. HUGH O'DONNELL, M.A., Q.U.I. Formerly M.P. for Galway and Dungarvan; ex-member of Council of Home Rule League of Ireland, etc., et With Portraits and other Illustrations 2 vols., 8vo. Cloth, $5.00 net. The book relates the origins of the Home Rule movement; the rise and authorship of the Active Policy commonly known as Obstruction; the intervention of the American Irish, which produced the Land League; the rise, progress and fall of Mr. Parnell, and his relations both with English parties and with American organizations New and strange light, illustrated by much documentary evidence, is thrown upon the Land League and the Invincible Conspiracy East London Visions By O'DERMID W. LAWLER. Crown 8vo. pp. x+305. $1.75 net. The early life of an “East Ender” born and bred. In many parts founded on fact, the book aims at showing the gradual revelation of the high and essential things of Life to a poetic youth, by experience of want, by excellent hum- ble teachers, and by vision. It contains description, incident, and original symbolism; passages of romance and humor, criticiams of Life and of contemporary religious and social forms French Secondary Schools An Account of the Origin, Development and Present Or- ganization of Secondary Education in France. By FRED- ERIC ERNEST FARRINGTON, Ph.D., Associate Pro- fessor of Education, University of Texas. Author of “The Public Primary School System of France,” etc. Crown vo. pp. vill4+450. Price, $2.50. Landmarks of British History By LUCY DALE, Author of “The Principles of English Con- stitutional History.” With 8 Plates in Color and 72 other Illustrations. Crown 8vo. pp. x+256, price, $0.90 net. This book contains a general survey of British History from the earliest times to the accession of Edward VII. Broad outlines only are given, and no attempt is made to furnish a detailed account of the reigns. The history of Britain is therefore treated rather from the social, industrial, and commercial standpoint than in its political aspect. A History of Malta During the Period of the French and British Occupations, 1798 to 1815 By the late WILLIAM HARDMAN, of Valetta. Edited, with Introduction and Notes, by J. HOLLAND ROSE, Litt.D. (Cantab.). Illustrated by Documents, with an Epitome of Subsequent Events. 8vo. Net, $6.50. The Letters of John Stuart Mill © Edited, with Introduction, by HUGH ELLIOTT, and a Note on Mill's private life by Miss MARY TAYLOR. With Portraits and other Illustrations. 2 vols. 8vo. $6.50 net. On his death, in 1873, Mill left behind him a record of his correspondence which is almost unique in biographical literature. During the greater part of his life he was in the habit of taking copies of every letter he wrote; and the copies have been carefully preserved. The letters extend from 1829 to 1873, and are of wide general interest, political, literary, and philosophical.

—$—=[—=_—_—_=_ _———=—=—=_ _=_=_{_ = —~—s~>—" LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 4th Avenue & 30th St., New York

Page 5

The Nation. SS Eee —s = = NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 12, 1910. The Week. It is not often that the prospects of a legislative proposal are involved in such confusion as seems at present to sur- round the Administration’s Railway Bill. The matter is especially compli- cated by the difficulty of discovering what is the definite purpose either of In a general advocates or opponents. way, it appears to be true that the reg- ulars in Congress are supporting the bill because it is an Administration measure, and because they are pledged to do so. This is strongly indicated by the appearance of Senator Elkins as the negotiator in behalf of certain clauses for which he can hardly be supposed to entertain great personal enthusiasm. The position of the insurgents is less clear. That their hostility to the bill is partly inspired by the fact that it is an Administration measure, and that the Administration has provoked a general spirit of hostility on their side, is not improbable. the provisions enlarging the powers of | railways, in regard to rate-making and purchase of interest in other railways, were unpopular in the constituencies whence most of the insurgents come. The clause, for instance, providing that, | notwithstanding other prohibitions, a railway holding 50 per cent. of another company’s stock might be permitted to acquire the rest, was disliked in the West, and by no means understood even in the East. Political experience suggested the ne-| cessity of tact and maintenance of good feeling, if Congressmen from such dis- tricts were to be held in line for all provisions of the bill. When, therefore, Telations between the doubtful Con- gressmen and the Administration be- came so seriously strained, it was not surprising that the clauses in question should have failed of enactment. The more perplexing aspect of the matter is the insurgent hostility to clauses re- straining the power of railways to con- solidate. In the minority report of the Senate Committee on Interstate Com- But, on the other hand, it | has been manifest from the outset that | merce, signed by two insurgent leaders, it was declared in March: Section 12 of the bill, as reported by the committee, begins with the laudable at- tempt to prevent the consolidation or com- bination of railway lines which “directly and substantially” compete with each other. But before it reaches its end, it not only nullifies the prohibition with which it started out, but actually takes the back track, and if it were to become a part of the law, it is our opinion that consolida- tions and combinations could be lawfully ef- fected that are now forbidden. But instead of the “laudable attempt’ being now facilitated, through an in- surgent amendment striking out the 50 per cent. stock ownership proviso and retaining the general restriction on own- ership in other lines, the section as a whole seems to be going by the board. Not only so, but we have just seen the curious spectacle of Senator Elkins la- boring to save the prohibitory clauses of Section 12 without the exceptions to which the above-cited report objects, while Senator Nelson of Minnesota op- poses the section, root and branch. This is at least an illogical situation, and un- less both sides have made up their minds for the complete failure of the Railway Bill, it should seem that some |'more definite realignment of opinion is | inevitable. When Congress appropriated seventy- | five thousand dollars last year for the President's Tariff Board, it builded bet- ter than it knew. The Tariff Board at |the time was not meant to be taken very ‘seriously; its powers were not defined; _the renewal of the appropriation was | not guaranteed; the thing was sporadic, _extra-legal, and a sop. But within a | year a change has come over the spirit of the dream. The tariff, instead of an issue put to sleep, is an issue more alive than ever, and the leaders in Con- gress, sobered and instructed by the ex- periences of the last few months, have learned that the time has come to bend before the storm or go down. It was a case of bending before the storm when the House last week appropriated $250,000 for the expenses of the Presi- dent’s Tariff Board, conferring upon it at the same time extensive powers of study and investigation, at home and abroad. We are thus brought measur- ably nearer to that essential factor in ‘any real revision of the tariff—a tariff commission to supply the groundwork of knowledge and fact upon which Con- gress May base its action. It means a terrible wrench with the past, a momen- tous departure from the time-honored system of tariff-making by codéperative plunder. Yet in that direction point the signs of the times. In his strictures on Mr. Bryan's crit- icism of the appointment of Gov. Hughes to the Supreme Court, Mr. Taft spoke with emphasis, and yet with the kindliness and candid simplicity char- acteristic of him. The fact is that Mr. Bryan's attack has fallen particularly flat. It was not only discredited at its source, in view of the hard knocks the candidate of the Denver platform recely- ed in 1908 at the hands of Mr. Hughes, but still more because it carried its refu- tation on its face. Both in the matter of insurance legislation and in the crea- tion of the Public Service Commissions, Mr. Hughes has shown himself to be as far removed as possible from the type of the corporation standpatter against |which alone any such criticism as that of Mr. Bryan has force. The accusation of partiality to corporations based on his veto of the two-cent fare bill is mere- ly evidence of shallowness on the part of the accuser; and, what is more, is recognized as such by intelligent per- sons generally, however radical their po- litical or economic views. The very idea of the public-service commissiors is that these questions must be settled by a thoroughgoing by a truly competent authority, not by the caprice of the Legislature. Mr. Hughes is preéminently the kind of man whose judgments, in the highest court of the nation, will carry weight with all classes of people, whether ren dered in favor of or against the inter- ests of corporations and men of wealth. inquiry and In his address before the Nobel Prize Committee at Christiania, Mr. Roosevelt spoke for a world federation, limited at present to the maintenance of peace and with the ability to enforce the de- crees of its Arbitration Court by some form of international police action. That is also the proposal now pending in the

Page 6

472 form of specific resolutions before our) Senate Committee on Foreign Affairs. These call upon the President to ap- point a commission of five members to report to Congress a draft of such a fed- eration, and to urge upon other govern- ments this method of relief from mili- tary burdens. By the terms of the reso- lutions the federation draft is to pro- vide that the decrees of its international court shall be executed, if necessary, by the “arms of the federation.” Here at least is a practical step forward with infinite possibilities—even of war; but behind the international decree would be the almost irresistible moral power of international opinion. That the peace movement in this country is gathering important impetus is shown by largely increased membership and the number of peace conferences and meetings an- nounced for the next few months. In Europe far-reaching political and social agencies are slowly doing their work. Colossal powers of destruction may, af- ter all, be neutralized by a colossal in- ternational will that they shall not be brought into play. Senator Lorimer, so the reports read, “may resign.” The news is alarming, when everybody is wondering why he did not resign a week ago. Five mem- bers of the Illinois Legislature, includ- ing the minority leader of the House, Representative Lee O'Neil Browne, have now been indicted for bribery or perjury, or have confessed their guilt, and Mr. Lorimer has had nothing to say since he denounced as a crazy sensationalist the first who turned State’s evidence. When an associate of Senator Lorimer’s, the new Senator from Misssissippi, Mr. Percy, found himself in a similar posi- tion, he hastened back to his State to confront the legislator who asserted that he had taken a bribe, and announc- ed to everybody that he would not hold his office a minute if there was the slightest taint upon his commission. The Mississippi Legislature confirmed his right to that document, but, not content with this, Senator Percy asked that the matter might be submitted to the voters of the State at a primary, in order that everybody might say whether he should or should not continue to represent Mis- sissipp! in Washington. And Senator Lorimer may resign! Yet three men have sworn that they took money to elect him. The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2341 “Grossly unbusinesslike conduct” is the charge made by the Indian Commis- sioner against one of Gifford Pinchot’s subordinates in the Bureau of Forestry, and if the facts are as stated most peo- ple will wish that some dramatic pun- ishment could overtake him even though no criminality attaches to his actions. For eighteen years, the Menominee In- dians worked hard at lumbering on their reservation, making a profit of) $2,500,000, which, with other revenue, gave them a tribal fund of $3,000,000. | Then came a decision to place these lumber-making Indians under the con- trol of the Bureau of Forestry. Edward | A. Braniff, a recent graduate of the Yale Forestry School, soon made the money | fly. An injurious act passed by Con- | gress cost the Indians about $700,000 of their profits, and then Mr. Braniff help- ed on the good work. For unnecessary roads, $40,000 was expended; for im- proving a stream, $50,000. The stream was to have floated logs down to the sawmill erected by Mr. Braniff, but after the $50,000 was expended, 65 per cent. of the logs carelessly declined to float, or lost a large part of their value while in the water—such are the advantages of science when given to Lo! Mr. Bran- iff’s lumber-mill cost $254,700, with a capacity of 48,000,000 feet of lumber, although the law permitted the cutting of only 20,000,000 feet; unnecessary ex- pense here, $129,000. The sawmill being carefully erected alongside of a marsh, $56,000 was spent in piling to make it a good lumber-yard, and $32,000 worth of lumber used in piling will soon have to be replaced. Now it would be unfair to the Fores- try Bureau to condemn it generally for one such ghastly mistake—particularly scandalous because the Government abused a sacred trust when it forced such a loss upon its own wards—but it is just this sort of blundering that is, we believe, responsible for much of the feeling in the West against the Forestry Bureau. With all due regard for Mr. Pinchot’s eminent service, which we have always fully appreciated, we be- lieve that abler executives can be found for his office. They may not appeal sim- llarly to the imaginations of the peo- ple, nor inaugurate such far-reaching plans of national beneficence, but the opportunity is there, we are convinced, 'to better the actual working of the ser- vice and render it more truly helpful. Mr. Pinchot seems to have relied on Braniff and accepted misinformation precisely as he did in the Ballinger case. The statement that in the past year \five hundred thousand workmen have been injured in this country while per- | torming their daily tasks is appalling, and it is eminently right that the pre- vention of these accidents should form a chief topic of discussion when the Manufacturers’ Convention meets in this city next week. In our rush for ma- terial progress the claims of humanity have too often gone unheeded, and it is ‘only when statistics of this startling na- ture are brought before us that the ne- cessity for radical reform strikes home. |The picture of death and _ suffering which is made plain when we learn that half a million laborers were broken on the wheel of manufacture in one year should arouse a country-wide support of any earnest effort to ameliorate the con- ditions of work. In the words of one of those who will attend the convention, the “fact that half a million workmen are injured annually in this country is an insult to our intelligence.” The text of the decision of the Illi- nois Supreme Court upholding the law limiting to ten hours the working day for women “in any mechanical estab- lishment, factory, or laundry,” shows that it is far-reaching. The court re- versed not only the Circuit Court, but also its own decision of fifteen years ago, when it took the ground that an eight- hour Jaw for women workers was un- constitutional. Now it restricts the free- dom of contract in the interest of health, morals, and general welfare. It justi- fies this regulation of property rights squarely on the ground that the State may exercise its police power with re- gard to the health, morals, and general welfare of the public. The difference be- tween the law of 1893 and the present law, in the court’s eyes, is that the for- mer did not state that its purpose was to promote the health of women, where- as the motive of the act in 1909 was | distinctly stated to be to safeguard the |health of women employees. If this |seems to the layman a fine splitting of hairs, there can be no doubt that the | decision is in line with the movement of the day. The court itself, as an addi- ‘tional justification, quotes the saying of Ay Sg

Page 7

, 2 N *, 3 | : Pia rae ae 3

May 12, 1910]

the Supreme Court, that “law is, or ought to be, a progressive science,” bas- ed upon “changing conditions of society and the evolution of employment.” Nat- urally, labor circles are delighted, and with reason. It is a special triumph for Mr. Louis D. Brandeis of Boston, who argued the case with unusual skill.

An increase of 20 per cent. in fares for the New York commuter is only another illustration of the way that mysterious force called the increased cost of living impinges upon a class which does not usually come in for the sympathy be stowed upon the “submerged tenth.’ The commuter as a class goes far to- wards substantiating the theory held by many psychologists and students of hu- man nature, that humor is a sense of exaltation aroused by the misfortunes of others. That is why the commuter is one of the favorite subjects for the paragrapher and the comic artist. His horticultural misadventures, his hur- ried breakfasts and late dinners, his sprinting after trains, his paper pack- ages, and his shopping expeditions—all these make up a vast contemporary lit- erature, which, however, only serves to withdraw attention from the sober real- ity. Actually, the commuter is a man who, between sacrificing the welfare of his children and sacrificing much of his own comfort and convenience, has chosen the latter. To that purpose he travels long hours, denies himself the company of his family, pays more than city prices for food, for service, and, of course, for travel—and gets in return only ridicule. He does not organize into unions and go out on strike, and he does not send lobbyists to Washington to “see” somebody. When the railway company raises commutation rates, he protests, and submits. He has more than his share of troubles and bears them with more than average dignity, even in the presence of hilarious ac- quaintances who slap him on the back and ask how the rubber-plant is getting on.

A new organization is the Naval His- tory Society. Its object is to collect and make available the vast amount of ma- terial bearing on the history of the American merchant marine and the cre- ation and development of the American navy, which is now scattered all over the country in the form of letters, jour-

The Nation. a lallatacadare nals, log-books, etc. The headquarters of this organization are to be in New York, with branches in the principal cities. It will not, however, be limited to the experiences of American seamen, but will devote itself to a “wider theme, that of the sailor in all times.” The Society ought to have a large member- ship—the secretary is Robert W. Neeser, No. 1076 Chapel Street, New Haven, Conn.—for its field is inviting. The story of the merchant marine is yet to be told with fulness and authority. In view of the present disappearance both of our sea-going ships and of the desire of Americans to take to the sea, the more that we can learn about the men who actually carried the flag into all the harbors of the world, the ships they sail- ed, and the conditions under which they operated, the better it will be for us. In Congress there is, for instance, en- tirely too strong a feeling that you can legislate about the merchant marine as you could about a railway, and some one ought to bring home to the country the paralyzing effect upon our shipping of the present antiquated navigation laws. We do not say that this should be the function of the Naval History Society; if it merely collects information upon | which scientific studies may be based, or with which they may be reinforced, it will more than justify its existence.

If all comets were like this of Halley, a suspicion would arise that the terror of the comet which, we learn, period- ically seized upon the medieval world may have been largely the invention of ‘the monkish chroniclers and wood-en- gravers of the time; those quaint cuts of people huddled together on the hilltops under a sky ablaze with the path of the awful visitor would be classed as imag- inative. For if it is necessary to get up at 3 A. M. and stare hard at the eastern sky and call eagerly upon one’s fancy before a comet can be sighted, how did the mediwval peasant ever manage to break his slumber, after a day of dread- ful toil, to go staring at the sky, and how did he ever get himself sufficiently awake to be in any measure impressed? Is it Anatole France who proved that the midnight highwayman is really a great force for morality, since his victims are as a rule men who make their way home in the small hours befuddled with drink and debauchery? The only persons sub- ject to the terror of this comet are men 473 * —$<—<—_—= — like the hero of Bronson Howard's play, who says, “I remember the prayers my mother taught me, and I say them every morning before I go to bed.”

The earthquake at Cartago will serve to recall the part played by the consid eration of danger from that source, tn determining the location of the Isth mian canal. The Nicaragua route had been all but definitely chosen, when at the eleventh hour a reconsideration was effected; and among the arguments that brought about the final conclusion per haps none played so decisive a part as that of the great liability of the Nica raguan region to earthquake. This con- sideration was presented to the commit- tee with great force by the late Prof. Angelo Heilprin, an authority on the phenomena of volcanoes and earth- quakes, and very probably turned the scale in favor of Panama. The present site of the canal is far from what ts known as the earthquake belt, and the upheaval of last Thursday, near the re gion which experience had shown to be extremely subject to these disturbances, should remind us of the wisdom of tak- ing thought in matters of such moment

The Kaiser’s recent warning against excessive beer-drinking is surprising both for its form—a letter to a young student at Freiburg University, who ts not even of the nobility—and its con tents. True, the Kaiser some years ago made it good form for officers to drink his health in water at official banquets, and he has in his own private life set an admirable example, not of abstinence, but of moderate indulgence in beer and wines. This preachment is of enormous importance, however, in that it is aimed at those corps students to whom life at a university means chiefly all-day beer- drinking. The temperance movement in Germany is making rapid strides, as it was bound to do. The most efficient of industrial nations, Germany is sure to find out not only that excessive beer drinking dulls the intellect and injures the physique, but that even what many Germans have regarded as moderate regular drinking has that effect. Em ployers of labor who have utilized the services of North German and South German workers do not hesitate to say that the wits of the former are quicker and clearer, and to lay the difference to the greater beer-drinking in the South.

Page 8

The Nation. [Vol. go, No. 2341 4°74 THE DEATH OF EDWARD VII. The death of King Edward has come with startling suddenness, and at a moment when it constitutes a political event of unmistakable importance. At no other time in the course of his nine years’ reign would his departure from the scene have aroused speculation at all comparable in keenness and interest with that which is to-day filling the minds not only of his own people, but of all who are interested in the affairs of England. Yet his activities since he ascended the throne have been of far from insignificant importance. Although the expectations have not been realized of those who looked forward to the exer- cise on his part of great influence upon the conduct of home affairs, his influence has been a leading factor in the external relations of the Empire. The entente cordiale with France is acknowledged to have been chiefly his work, and to his activities the improv- ed relation between England and Rus- sia is largely due. Indeed, in the case of every country except Germany with which England has important contact, King Edward's tact, his skill as a man of the world, his knowledge of men and familiarity with the world’s affairs have been instrumental in bringing about or consolidating good relations. And it is probably with justice that he is credit- ed with a most important share in pro- moting the establishment of that excel- lent condition of feeling in South Africa which, at the end of so short a period after a desperate war, has become one of the finest monuments of British statesmanship. If the words attributed to him in the dispatches—‘“It is all over, but I think I have done my duty”"— were uttered by him as he felt the end approaching, it is upon this record of true and high service to his country and to the world that his thoughts may | have been dwelling. And if in the domain of home politics King Edward falled to make a signifi- cant impression, the criticisms that in these last weeks have been passed upon him on that account may serve quite as well to remind us of the enlarged estl- mate now placed upon the possibilities of the throne as to point to any de ficiency on the part of its recent occu pant Thirty or forty years ago the customary view of British royalty—in this country at all events—was that the sovereign served as a figure-head, or at /most as a symbol in which the senti- ment of loyalty and patriotism might find a centre. In the later portion of Queen Victoria's reign this notion un- derwent a marked change. It came to stricted singlechamber government might, in these times, at any moment make possible. The working of the Socialist leaven has wrought a great change. There is no doubt that the es- | be recognized more and more that while | sential conservatism of the English peo- all power was ostensibly in the hands of the Ministry, there were many ways in which the personal influence of the sovereign might make itself substantial- ly felt, and that the extent of this in- fluence was largely a question of the personal force of the King or Queen. King Edward quite fulfilled this idea of the power of the crown so far as re- gards foreign relations; and if he fell short of its possibilities in the domain of home statesmanship, that is hardly more than saying he was not a man of commanding qualities. Of such quali- ties no one ever supposed him to be the possessor. He was an all-round man of the world, a gentleman of tact and shrewdness, of kindliness and courtesy —such a type of man as to command the good will and esteem of the Eng- lish people, in spite of any faults or | weaknesses which during his life as, Wd will have upon the Constitutional | question soon to come before the people Prince of Wales he may have displayed. This combination of qualities might go far in many matters; but it is not sur- prising that it was unequal to the task of making the King a decisive factor in the Constitutional crisis which his de- parture leaves approaching its climax. With the passing away of King Ed- ‘ward, there disappears almost the last of the conspicuous figures associated 'with that great epoch in the story of |England which will go down to history | as the Victorian age. Whether his death ‘will be pointed to hereafter as marking the beginning of an era departing pro- ‘foundly in character from that covered by the three-quarters of a century over which his mother’s reign and his own extended, is a question on which con- jecture may take a wide range. In the ‘opinion of the most earnest and serious- minded of those who are opposing the | ple still persists; but it cannot be reck- oned on as of old to withstand firmly, in all situations, the onset of any sudden and powerful wave of radical innova- tion. “Where Freedom slowly broadens down from precedent to precedent” does not reflect the ideal of the typical Eng- lish mind by any means as accurate- ly as it did when Tennyson wrote the line. And so it is easy to understand that men who have been brought up in the Victorian traditions of conservative progress feel profound misgivings at the possibility of radical innovation brought about by a House of Commons acting on a single real or supposed mandate of the people, unchecked by any body spe- | cifically representing the forces of con- servatism or the ancient traditions of the country. What influence the death of King Ed- for decision cannot be foretold. Though the new King is in his forty-fifth year, he has been little in the public eye; and, furthermore, the effect of the change from heir-apparent to King is proverb- ially uncertain. In the present instance, no such transformation as that which turned Prince Hai into Henry V is call- ed for; the Prince of Wales is known as a man of serious mind and sober char- acter. He assumes the crown at a time when, if he possesses the right qualities, it may be permitted to the monarch to play a memorable part in the settlement of a great Constitutional question. Cer- tain it is that the affectionate reverence in which Englishmen hold the memory of Victoria, and the popularity and good will which have been enjoyed by Ed- ward, will insure to King George, as he ascends the throne, the sincere and loy- contemplated reduction of the powers of | #! 800d wishes of the nation. the House of Lords, the question to be | in the coming Parliamentary decided elections is in essence that of conferring upon the House of Commons virtually | unlimited power. But, whether or not it is expressed in the words, or even consciously entertained in the minds, of these objectors, what is really at the bottom of their fears is a knowledge otf the kind of legislation which an unre-' PROGRESS IN CHINA. The recent presence among us of the brother of a Prince and the uncle of an Emperor who rules over 400,000,000 souls has naturally renewed the ancient talk of what will happen to civilization and the Western world when these 400,- 000,000 souls set to doing whatever it is that they are just about to do. The

Page 9

May 12, 1910} most obvious duty of a nation of 400,- 000,000 people, according to our enlight- ened Occidental standards, is to build up an army bigger than all of Christen- dom’s combined, and to lose no time in making use of it. It is China’s future army, rather than her future Constitu- tion or her future administrative and financial reforms, that has been declar- ed to be the destined instrument China’s regeneration. ot As the head of China’s armed forces, Tsai-Tao world for the purpose of studying its Prince is now circling the and his journey is The dis patching of gorgeous and highly expen- military quite in the Chinese tradition. systems; sive missions for purposes of foreign of the tions of the Peking Government. one principal occupa- It is study is the complement to the frequent publica- tion of elaborate reform edicts at home, both ceremoniais in conjunction serving to create an impression of progress which the facts hardly justify. All that Prince Tsai-Tao and his suite will learn of Western military methods, the Chi- nese Government might have learned by calling into requisition the services of a few Japanese and German officers, just as a few years ago it might have purchased a copy of the Constitutions the of West, authoritative commentaries of different nations the with a few on each, instead of sending a very dis tinguished and large mission to study But of missions is governmental problems abroad. course the object of such much less to learn than to make friends for China by showing her willingness to learn. In that there is nothing repre hensible. she can win them by elaborate use otf China needs friends, and it the press-agent’s art, she is welcome to do so. And the outside world, if public opin- ion in this country can be taken as an index, has duly succumbed to the press agent’s arts. It is not that we have been unwilling to be impressed. Unselfish and selfish reasons have combined to make many people hope that all that has been said of China’s awakening might be true. In the first place, it appeals to the dramatic sense to have a nation of 400,- 000,000 people leap out of the sleep ot several thousand years into the full blaze of modern life. And in the second place, perhaps there is something in this talk of the unlimited quantities of cotton goods and railway ties, and possibly The Dreadnoughts and machine guns, which Nation. the Chinese are sure to clamor for when The not deal in subtleties. His reasoning, for they wake up. average man does instance, in matters of international pol- itics is largely geographical. If Japan has modernized itself in fifty years and won a great war, why cannot China, which is only a few hundred miles away, do the same? The argument is not far different from saying that if everybody why cannot in France speaks French, the English, who live only forty miles away, do the same. It does not matter that in race psychology and in the en- tire nature of their civilization and their social organism, the Japanese and Chi nese stand almost at opposite poles Japan has become modern and China is unmistakably breathing in the modern spirit; but to speak of the new China, Parliaments and her armed with her tens of millions, as a matter of next year or even the next ten years is ab surd. There the horizons that are opening up in China half-a-dozen things which the are facile orator on magnificent might do well to remember. He might start by recalling that Rome was not built in a day. He might pass on to the much broader principle that no nation was ever modernized and constitution- alized into something alien to its own that a _ constitutionalized nature, and and modernized China would still be a laborious, peace-loving, heavily progres sive China. But it would be of most use, perhaps, to take to heart a specific cau tion or two: and first, the fact so fre quently insisted upon by the writers on China and so frequently overlooked by fact China is not, in practice, a single gov nearly everybody else—the that ernment, but a fairly lax confederation of provinces, none of which would prob ably think of cutting loose from Peking, and none of which would dream of obey ing orders from Peking unless it suited its own purpose to do so. Such manifes tations of strength as China has shown since its defeat by Japan fifteen years ago have been local manifestations. In Shan-tung, the viceroy Yuan-shi-kai built up a fairly efficient army. In the Hoang-ho provinces, a viceroy has devel oped mines and arsenals. In Canton, a viceroy has cast a favorable eye on the Before the threaten the peace of the world, must solve the problem of making ecigh reformers. new China can she 475 teen semi-independent provinces, each as large as a kingdom, march in some thing like common step. Progress in China there undeniably is. The long succession of reform edicts means something. The rush of the Chi- the foreign universities hese youth to means a good deal. The growth of a na tive press has been rapid indeed. South China especially has caught more than the echoes of Western revolutionary tra ditions. The Marseillaise has been trans lated and aaupted to local needs. John Stuart Mill and Herbert Spencer are eagerly read. Washington and Napol eon, “the two sons of Liberty,” are fre- quently invoked. Among the more sober classes, the gentry and magistrates, the of progress. spirit nationalism has also made Nevertheless, these are but taint beginnings. We are still far away from the China that will threaten the peace of the world with its ten million armed men, or sweep clean the markets its vast of the world by purchases of cotton goods. AN INSPIRING CAREER The celebration of Dr. Abraham Ja cobi’s eightieth birthday by the New York State Medical Society was only one of many extraordinary tributes to His half century of service in Mount Sinai Hos the man and the physician. pital is in itself quite unparalleled, if one considers in connection with its length the devotion, the skill, and the science that have accompanied it. But as was shown ten years ago, at the pub lic demonstrations upon his seventieth birthday, -it is impossible to laud the physician or man of science alone. In evitably, there has been celebrated as well Abraham Jacobi, the broad-minded, citizen, always a far-seeing, patriotic sturdy foree for good government, al- ways a leader in philanthropic and hu manitarian enterprises, albeit so mod estly that too few have realized the ex tent of this man’s usefulness to the com munity, or the value of the example he has set to his profession and to the lay world. To say that Dr. Jacobi, like his clos est personal friend, Carl Schurz, was a product of the 1848 is to explain fully both his ideal German revolution of ism and his breadth of view. Never was there a popular uprising inspired by higher or more unselfish aims, or con- ceived in a purer spirit of humanity.

Page 10

4A76 It liberalism fine flower of that wave of and was the democracy that swept over Europe in the forties, the effects of which are not yet spent. The failure to upset the German monarchies was America’s gain, since it sent to this country as exiles a host of men like Schurz, Jacobi, Blenker, and Sigel, who brought to their new allegiance all that devotion and loyalty which their Jacobi paid dearly for passionate they had lavished so freely on lost cause. Dr. his devotion to liberty; he spent his nineteenth and twentieth years in prison a part of the time in darkness and in chains ed terrupted his medical studies! Of this he has often complain- only on the ground that it in- Certain but it is that this hard and trying experi- of early manhood, so far from ence crushing him, only fortified his charac- ter It_ taught him, perhaps, the meas- ure of his own soul, and discovered to him that his reliance was not upon the but upon the praise of praise of men, his own conscience. Imprisoning peo- ple for their opinions has almost gone If the lonely self-communion of the cell forges out of fashion, except in Russia. out such characters as Dr. Jacobi’s, it would almost make one wish to turn back the hands of time. all, character of Dr. be- lonely But, after the elements Jacobi's were developed fore the introspection of those prison hours, with their nearby possibil ity of ignoble death. Love of truth, de- votion to science, self-dedication to the general welfare, led him to that place, as they led many another; and in Dr. Jacobi they have never been shaken. With this broad foundation a narrow outlook, particularly in professional matters, was never possible. None of the many lessons of his life is more valua- ble for the younger generation of physi- clans than his refusal to lose himself in his profession, his unwillingness to look upon humanity as only so much surgical At dinner given in his material the honor on his seventieth birthday, soon after the war with Spain, he declared that he had no “enthusiasm for the doctor who is occasionally puffed for leaving his humane work to participate in the killing, nor for the Injustice of history, that mentions a thousand gen- erals to one physician.” And from the practice to make who is in Jacobi is as far removed as physician Dr. are the poles front one another. money The Nation. To appraise fully his services to medi- cine, particularly in the noble field of children’s diseases, is not for laymen. But we may venture to dwell upon his great work as a teacher. There has lecturing in this city of late a teacher from Balliol to whom some of England's greatest men go for advice and counsel before shaping the destinies of the nation. He is puffed by no news- he has denied himself by his teaching the time to write the great historical works of which all scholars He finds in his the op- portunity of moulding men who mould the world is all he asks. In his sphere Dr. Jacobi has been much the same. The number of his students is legion; who can estimate the effect upon them of the character of their teacher, of what Carl “personification of been papers, know him capable. teaching complete satisfaction; Schurz called his scientific conscience and personification When he landed fifty-seven years ago, American medical literature was at its beginning; if there were the students were ordinarily immature and but half prepared. Against the tendency to be- comeé a specialist without first being a physician, Dr. Jacobi’s voice has ever been raised, and ‘he has likewise oppos- ed the separation of research ltaborator- ies from hospitals and of researchers from students. A great teacher, he knew of civic conscience”? notable teachers, long ago that men learn best through teaching; that he who would press for- ward into realms of undiscovered science advances best in company with young, fresh minds thirsting for knowl- edge of every kind. So New York, we think, honors itself by honoring Dr. Jacobi. Had he accept- ed the professorship in Berlin once of- fered him by that same Government that had loaded him with chains, the Kaiser would now be the first to honor him, and the world of science and Ilet- donning its dress-suit Unter den Linden to pay its respect, the students would be planning a torch-light proces- We have not yet reached the point | where we properly gauge or reward the We still listen too ters would be and driving down while sion, services of scholars. readily to the politician’s sneer at the “closet philosopher,” but a_ different time is coming. Dr. Jacobi, at least, has seen, during his long public service, a'| great change for the better, but others than he will know just how much he [Vol. go, No. 2341 ‘has himself contributed to it by profes- sional faith, loyalty, and unselfishness. THE RHODES SCHOLARSHIPS. A former Rhodes scholar, now a Fel- low at Oxford, attempts in the last number of the Ozford and Cambridge Review an estimate of what has been accomplished in the first six years of the Rhodes Foundation. The trustees of the Fund have refrained from pass- ing judgment on the merits of the scheme. Their annual reports deal with bald statements of fact. Evidently, they feel that “the time is not yet ripe for telling how far the scheme is carrying out the objects which Mr. Rhodes had in view.” The unofficial world, how- ever, is more impatient; the silence of the trustees has been interpreted by some people to mean dissatisfaction or the acknowledgment of failure. The present article tries to show that there has been neither striking failure nor striking success. In other words, the trustees are justified in believing that the time has not yet come for casting a balance. It is a somewhat disillusion- ing account, and one would be tempted to ascribe it in large measure to the disintegrating influence of the English climate upon an ardent Colonial tem- perament. But the tone is fair and sober and the story carries the impres- sion of truth. The influence of the Rhodes scholars upon Oxford has been exaggerated. We are reminded that the Rhodes scholars in residence at any given time cannot exceed 180 men in a college community of three thousand. In addition, these 180 men are distributed among the various colleges and meet as a body only once a year at the Rhodes scholars’ banquet. Our writer is rather tempted into hair- splitting when he argues that “as Rhodes scholars their influence can be practically nii, whatever may be their influence as individuals upon the small circle of undergraduates with which they come into contact.” The fact re- |'mains that the individual is a Rhodes scholar with all the qualities of foreign birth, training, and outlook that fact connotes. It is even open to question _ whether the lodging of all the Rhodes scholars in a single college would ulti- mately affect conditions at Oxford as the present method of casting the seed wide is likely to do. Of effects already visible, the first is a tendency to accel-

Page 11

May 12, 1910] erate, “however slightly,” the movement towards a democratization of, the Uni- versity at large. The movement orig- inated before the advent of the Rhodes scholars, “but the fact that they do come up to the University filled with the new ideal, enables them to press forward the general movement of their age and gen- eration.” And utilitarianism runs par- allel with democracy. The scope University teaching will be widened to meet the needs of the new men from across the seas. A School of Rural Econ- omy has been established and Rhodes scholars have taken courses in Fores- try there. A School of Domestic Econ- omy is under discussion. What does Oxford do for the Rhodes scholar? Well, in the first place, let the patriot’s hot heart be at rest; the Rhodes scholar “is not really anglicised to any serious extent or taught to de- spise the country of his origin.” Of 82 Americans, 81 have returned home, and one has accepted a university appoint- ment in England. Those Americans who have returned have taken back with them chiefly “a higher conception of sport.” Not that this implies any “in- herent moral superiority in the English undergraduate.” It is simply a differ- ence between playing for exercise and playing to win. And while this makes British sport truer to its name, the fact is by no means a cause of unmitigated satisfaction to the Englishman. “The primary cause is that absence of enthu- siasm for any ideal, be it great or small, which is settling like a blight upon the whole of English life.” Here, evidently, our Colonial has caught just the tone in which it is fashionable for Englishmen nowadays to speak of them- selves. But however indifferent in the mat- ter of winning games, a good many Englishmen still go in for hard work at their books; whereas the Rhodes men, our present writer insists, do not. A vast majority of them come up with the fixed intention of making the most of their opportunities and fail to do so. It is not enough that they should do as well as the average undergraduate. Be- ing picked men, they should do better. If they do not, it is for various reasons. Compulsory Greek is one. The Oxford climate is another. But perhaps the most serious is the failure of the aver- age Rhodes scholar to make use of his vacations. To do well at Oxford, one = ot The Nation. must read between terms, whereas the American Rhodes men in particular have gone in for Continental travel. “Many of them appeaf to look upon the Rhodes scholarship primarily in the light of an endowment for selected tourists from the United States." A bitter touch this, but in place; and the point is driven in “One may affirm without much the again: fear of contradiction that Rhodes scholars would do well to refrain from regarding themselves quite so promi nently as students of mankind at large.” Evidently, then, we are still in the ex- perimental stage; and particularly so when we recall what was the main ob- ject of the bequest. Cecil Rhodes was not interested primarily in what the Rhodes scholars would do for Oxford or Oxford for the Rhodes scholars, but what the two in combination could do to promote the cause of Imperial and English-speaking fellowship. To judge of the success or failure of a Rhodes scholar from this point of view, we must look for him not in the examination schools or in the Oxford boat, but fif- teen or twenty years later, on his native soil and in the life’s work he has chosen for himself. The results may show only in the second generation. And even then it may be very hard to distinguish between the effects of the Rhodes schol- arship and the general movement to- wards a closer knowledge and under- standing among the nations. MARK TWAIN. I. No American writer has ever enjoyed a more purely democratic reputation than Mark Twain. From village celebrity to international renown, he has been ad- vanced stage after stage by popular suffrage. The plain, unbookish burgess holding both his sides at a public lecture has helped roar him into eminence. The freckled, brown-legged pirate who finds Tom Sawyer nearer to his business and his bosom than Robinson Crusoe has played no negligible part in the cam- paign. The vote of the retired merchant reading “A Tramp Abroad” in prepara- tion for a European holiday told deci- sively in his favor before the tardy voice of the professional critic assented. When an overwhelming majority of his fellow countrymen had established his position, the universities recognized the fact, so that one day not long ago, he strolled into the Sheldonian Theatre, clad in scarlet, and, after a “very satis- factory hurrah” from the audience, was created doctor of letters by the Uni- versity of Oxford. AGT During the last few years of his life, he attained a still higher honor. It is to be hoped that no one will attempt to distinguish the customary “three per iods” of his development, because, con trary to custom, he was essentially the same in all parts of his career. One may distinguish, however, three aspects of his reputation. Like a political orator making his maiden speech or invading hostile territory, he broke through the reserve of his audience with a string of irresistible stories. Handicapped by up roarious laughter, he produced two or three pieces of fiction which demanded serious attention; but his leonine head had grown gray before he lived down his record as a “plattorm humorist.” At his seventieth birthday, he obtained a reconsideration of his case, and the highest tribunals decided that he indub itably belonged in the history of litera- ture, if, indeed, he was not the “fore- most American man of letters.” After that, national feeling about him crystal- lized rapidly. He appeared in white flannels in midwinter, declaring that white was the only wear for a man with seventy clean years behind him; we were significantly pleased. After our newspapers had made one of their little breaks, he sent word to us that the re- ports of his death were “greatly exag- gerated.” It was a phrase that we all envied, from the President down; we saw that he was no mere literary man he was a public man. When he died, we abandoned the last reservation. We said with one voice: He was an American To the foreign critic this ultimate tribute may seem perplexingly cheap and anticlimactic That ‘s, of course, due to the mistaken notion that we num ber some four score millions of Amer! As a matter of fact, we number our Americans on our ten fingers: the rest of us are merely citizens of the United States. Any one who will take a the alphabet may American more cans little pains with be come a citizen: to become an demands other talents. We than doubtful about Washington. Lowell said that Lincoln was the first Ameri can, but he forgot Franklin. There have been Lincoln's time From certain indications, it looks if Mr. Roosevelt might turn out to be an American. Only the other day, he sent us a message to this effect: “I know that the American people will agree that I could have acted in no other way than I did act.” The American is a man of destiny. His word and deed flow inevit- ably out of the American character. On the one hand, he does a thing because it is right; on the other hand, the thing ia right because he does it. Revising the thought of Henry V, we may say, Nice customs curtsy to great Americans II. The point is strikingly illustrated by a story which Mark Twain tells on him- self in one of the chapters of his auto- are one or two since as

Page 12

478 biography. company It was in 1877, before a including all the leading geniuses of New England, banqueting in honor of Whittier’s birthday. When Mark Twain's turn came, he rose and entered upon a fictitious “reminiscence,” Out in southern California he had knocked at a miner's cabin, and an- nounced himself as a literary man. The miner replied with marked ill-humor that he had just got rid of three of them, “Mr. Longfellow, Mr. Emerson, Mr. Oliver Wendell Holmes—consound the lot. Mr. Emerson was a seedy little bit of a chap, red headed; Mr. Holmes was as fat as a balloon; he weighed as much as three hundred, and had double chins all the way down to Mr. Longfellow was built They had And his stomach. like a prizefighter. been drinking, I could see that.” 80 on. At the words “consound the lot,’ Twain had expected a peal of laughter, but to his amazement “the expression of interest in the faces turned to a sort of black frost.” The whole story was a dismal failure; it was years before the author recovered from the shame of it. Speaking as a mere reader of Lamb, Jane Austen, Thackeray, O. W. Holmes, I am not in the least surprised at the New England frost. I know very well that Congreve or Addison or George Meredith would have agreed with the New England geniuses that Mark Twain's reminiscence was a piece ol crude, heavy, intellectual horse-play— an impudent affront offered to Puritan aristocracy by a rough-handed plebeian jester from Missouri. But hear Mark Twain thirty years later: I have read it twice, and unless I am an idiot, it single defect in it from the first word to the last. It is just as good as can be. It is smart; it is saturated isn’t a suggestion of coarseness or vulgarity in it anywhere What could have been the matter with that If 1 had those beloved and immortals back here them till they’d run hasn't a with humor There house” old I would literary melt revered all over that stage! In his mellow Indian summer Mark Twain himself grew conscious that he had become an American. He knew, therefore, that the speech was right, because he had made it. I confess to a doubt whether those “old literary im mortals” would laugh at it even now; if they would not, as a countryman of Lincoln I should be ashamed of them. The man who cannot laugh with Twain must be either better or worse than the “overwhelming majority” of his fellow citizens. To accept him is almost equiv alent to accepting the American flag When once you have sworn allegiance, you may find fault with both for the rest of your life without impeachment of your patriotism. “I paint myriads of heads,” cried Walt Whitman, “but I paint no head without its nimbus of gold-colored light.” He was prophesying The Nation. the golden mean, which he called the “divine average,” and which he knew! was actually rarer than either extreme. He was prophesying Mark Twain. “Who are you, indeed,” he exclaims, “who would talk or sing in America?” The antiphonal voice replies: I swear I will have each quality of my race in myself, Talk as you like, he only suits These States whose manners favor the audacity and sublime turbulence of The States. IIT. Humor, it is agreed, consists in con- trasts and incongruities, and the essence of Mark Twain’s most characteristic humor consists in contrasting this typi- cal, nimbused American, compacted of golden mediocrities, against the world— consists in showing the incongruity of the rest of the world with this nimbused American. It necessarily follows that the heights and depths of humor are beyond the reaches of Mark Twain’s soul. It necessarily follows that his laughter is burly, not fine; broad, not profound; national, not universal. When he that sitteth in the heavens laughs, he is not contrasting the year 1910 with the year 1300, nor the President of the United States with Louis XVI, nor the uncrowned sovereigns of Missouri with the serfs of Russia, Germany, or Eng- land. The comparison is intolerable— let us mark a lowlier difference. When Puck in the “Midsummer Night’s Dream,” looking out upon the bewilder- ed lovers exclaims, “Lord, what fools these mortals be”; when Titania, wak- ing from magical sleep, murmurs drows- ily, “Methought I was enamoured of an ass"—the mirth of these subtle crea- tures is kindled by the contrast between sentimental and bottom humanity, re- spectively, and the exquisite manners and passions of elfland. If Twain had written the play, he would have put Puck into overalls and Titania into a’ hoop-skirt. For he ignored the ethereal hunger which troubled the creator of Falstaff, and never entered into the secret laughter of the idealist. Let us descend once more. It is said that the last book Mark Twain read was Car- lyle’s “French Revolution.” I suppose he loved it incidentally tor its pictur- esque and savage energy, but mainly | because it proclaims that a man’s a man for all that. He shows traces both of its style and of its central thought in his own work. But so far as I know, he never shows a trace of its heart-search- ing irony, of that universal world-humor which arises when the upstart, red- blooded pageant of time’s latest hour ia confronted with the grim, dim phan- | tasms of eternity— Charlemagne sleeps at Salzburg, with | truncheon grounded, only fable expect- | ing that he will waken. Charles the Ham- | mer, Pepin Bow-legged, where now is their eye of menace, their voice of command? | Rollo and his shaggy Northmen cover not | [Vol. 90, No. 2341 the Seine with ships, but have sailed off on a longer voyage. The hair of Tow-head (Téte d’étoupes) now needs no combing; |Iron-cutter (Taillefer) cannot cut a cob- web; shrill Fredegonda, shrill Brunhilda, have had out their hot life-scold, and lie silent, their hot life-frenzy cooled. They are all gone; sunk—down, down with the tumult they made; and the rolling and trampling of ever new generations passes over them; and they hear it not any more forever. Carlyle makes ducks and drakes of Charlemagne and shrill Fredegonda, but he laughs with a by-gone eternity. When Whitman asks that stupendous question, “Whom have you slaughtered lately, European headsman?’ millions of strange shadows tend on him. He, too, is a humorist, and a grave one. He makes ducks and drakes of the “old lit- erary immortals,” for he laughs with an eternity to come. Mark Twain can- not be persuaded that we are such stuff as dreams are made of; looking neither before nor after, he laughs with the present hour; and he cannot stand the comparison. IV. Not by his subtlety, then, nor his depth, nor his elevation, but by his un- derstanding and his unflinching asser- tion of the ordinary self of the ordi- nary American did Mark Twain become our “foremost man of letters.” He was geographically an American; he knew his land and its idioms at first hand—Missouri, the Mississippi River and its banks, Nevada, Califor- nia, New England, New York, the great cities. It is insufficiently recognized that to love one’s country intelligently one must know its body, as well as its mind. He had tne good fortune to be born in the West; so that, of course, he had to go East-—otherwise he might, instead of becoming an American, have remained a mere Bostonian or New Yorker all his life, and never have learn- ed to love Chicago and San Francisco at all. At various times and places, he was pilot, printer, editor, reporter, min- er, lecturer, author, and publisher. But during the first noalf of his life, he went most freely with “powerful uneducated persons, and with the young, and with the mothers of families.” The books in which he embodies his early experiences —“Tom Sawyer,” “Roughing It,” “Huck- leberry Finn”—are almost entirely de- lightful. They breathe the spirit of ‘eternal boyhood, they are richly pro- vincial, they spring out of the fresh earth. There is a touch of melodrama in the first and more than a touch of farce in the last, but in the main, they are as native as a bluff to the Mississip- pi or a pine tree to a red spur of the Rockies. It is when an American carries his virtues abroad that the lines of his ‘character become salient. Mark Twain was a self-made man, of small Latin and

Page 13

May 12, 1910] less Greek, indifferent to abstractions, deficient in historical sympathy and imagination, insensitive to delicate so- cial differences, content and at home in modern workaday realities. I confess with great apprehension that I do not much care for his books of foreign travel. Like the story told on Whit- tier’s birthday, they are “smart and sat- urated with humor”; but for some al- most indefinable reason my emotions fail to enter into the spirit of the occa- sion. An uneasy doubt about the point of view binds my mirth as with a “black frost.” I find myself concerned for my fellow-citizen, the author behind the books; beneath the surface gayety the whole affair seems to be of appalling seriousness for us both. Ostensibly light-hearted burlesques of the poetical and sentimental volumes of travel, these books are in reality an amazingly faith- ful record of the way Europe and the Orient strike the “divine average’’—the typical American—the man for whom the world was created in 1776. Wander- ing through exhumed Pompeii, he peo- ples its solemn ruins with the Ameri- can proletariat, and fancies that he sees upon the walls of its theatre the plac- ard, “Positively No Free List, Except Members of the Press.” He digresses from an account of the ascent of Ve- suvius to compare the prices of gloves, linen shirts, and dress suits in Paris and in Italy. At length arrived at the summit of the mountain, he describes its crater as a “circular ditch’; some of the party light their cigars in the fis- sures; he descends, observing that the voleano is a poor affair when compared with Kilauea, in the Sandwich Islands. He visits the Parthenon in the night; obviously, the memorable feature of the expedition was robbing the vineyards on the way back to the ship. ‘The most famous picture galleries of Europe are hung with “celebrated rubbish”; immemorial Mosque of St. Sophia is the “mustiest barn in heathendom’”; the Sea of Gallilee is nothing to Lake Tahoe. The Mississippi pilot, homely, naive, arrogantly candid, refuses to sink his identity in the object contem- plated—that, as Corporal Nym_ would have said, is the humor of it. He is the kind of travelling companion that makes you wonder why you went abroad. He turns the Old World into a laughing-stock by shearing it of its storied humanity—simply because there is nothing in him to respond to the glory that was Greece, to the grandeur that was Rome—simply because nothing is holier to him than a joke. He does not throw the comic light upon counter- feit enthusiasm; he laughs at art, his- tory, and antiquity from the point of view of one who is ignorant of them and mightily well satisfied with his ig- norance. And, unless I am very much mistaken, the “overwhelming majority” of his fellow-citizens—those who made the | for the social contract ‘The Nation. the success of “Innocents Abroad” and “A Tramp Abroad”—have laughed with him, not at him. So, too, unquestion- ably, in the nearly parallel case of that bludgeoning burlesque, “A Connecticut Yankee at King Arthur's Court.” Vi What endears a public man to us is what he has in common with us—not his occasional supereminences. It does not damage Franklin to say that he was not so graceful as Lord Chester- field; nor Lincoln to say that he was not so handsome as Count D'Orsay; nor Mr. Roosevelt to say that misses in his literary style I know not what that one finds in the of Walter Savage Landor. Writing from Khartum, the hunter tells us that, in consequence of hard service in camp, his pigskin books were “stained with blood, sweat, gun oil, dust, and ashes. We have a mystical feeling that this is very appropriate and beautiful—that a good American’s books ought to be stained with gun oil and ashes. “Fear one style grace—fear delicatesse,” cries the au thor of “Chants Democratic.” It does not damage Mark Twain to say that there was not a drop of the aristocrat in his veins. In politics he was an intelligent but unspeculative democrat, committed to the principles of the preamble to the Constitution, preserving a tang of Tom Paine’s contempt for kings, and not without a suggestion of the republican insolence caricatured by Dickens in “Martin Chuzzlewit.” I do not think that he gave a “square deal” either to Europe or to the Arthurian realm; but within his own territory he had a very genuine sense of the brotherhood otf man. He was not, like some more ex- quisite men of letters, a democrat in his study and a snob in his drawing- room; he was of the people and for the people at all times. His tender regard permeated his humor. It will be remembered that Pudd’nhead Wilson earned his nick- name and ruined his chances as a law yer for twenty years by an incompre hensible remark about a howling dog “IT wish I owned half of that dog,” said Wilson. “Why?” somebody asked. “Be cause I would kill my half.” No one understood him—the sensitive, symbol ic democracy of the expression was too compact for their intelligence, and they fell into a delicious discussion of how one-half could be killed without injury to the other half. That, to be sure, is also one of the problems of democracy; but Wilson’s implications were, I be lieve, both simpler and deeper than that. In not molesting another man’s dog he showed the American reverence for property. The American desire to be moderately well-to-do (Mr. Roose velt’s “neither rich nor poor”) he indl- cated by desiring to own only half the dog. in saying that he would kill his AT9 in own and his half he expressed his sacred alienable right to dispose property as he chose, while at the same time he recognized his neighbor's sa cred and inalienable right to let his half of the property howl. Indeed, | am not sure that he did not recognize that the dog itself had a certain prope: ty right in howling. With almost every qualification for a successful political career, Mark Twain could never have aspired to the Presi dency, for he was not a regular attend ant at church—a shortcoming, by the way, which interfered seriously with Mr. Taft's campaign till his former pas tor testified in the public prints that the candidate had once at a church social taken the part of a fairy. In relig’on, Twain appeared to be a mugwump, or, more classically speaking, an agnostic over whom had fallen the shadow of Robert Ingersoll of pious memory. The irreligion of that generation is touched of with a raw, philistine rationalism, but s thoroughly honest. Like all Ameri- cans, the author of “Tom Sawyer” re- ceived his religious culture in the Sun day-school, but stumbled over the book of Genesis and kindred difficulties, and was “emancipated.” The loss of faith which, in proper conditions, is a terrible bereavement, was to him a blessed re lef; when the God of the Sunday-school and the camp meeting ceases to terri- fy, he ordinar!ly becomes a deadly bore. Having never known the magnificent poetry of faith, he never felt the mag nificent melancholy of unbelief. His ex perience was typical, however, and his unspirituality was social. In his examination of Christian Science, he admitted that every man is entitled to his own favorite brand of insanity, and insisted that he himself was as insane as anybody. That was enough to assure most of us that he “all essentials.” very was sound on and will be lonesome” is, I suppose, one of Mark Twain's widely quoted utterances on moral top ics. At why this apparently Bohemian apothegm should have taken such hold upon the heart of a nation which all things else adores virtue. But the dif ficulty disappears the instant flects that these seven words express as in a nutshell] precisely the kind and temper of virtue that the nation adores Like Wilson's on the dog, the saying is cryptic and requires ex plication. Twain tells us in his autobiog- raphy that when he was a boy his moth- er always allowed about thirty per cent aid for “embroidery” and “struck his average.” The saying means, as I take it, first of all, Don't your sense of humor as those do intatuated with their own particular hobbies goodness. late to keep about in the middle of the road, but make allowance for all rea- “Be good you most first thought, one may wonder above one rTe- observation on what he 80 lose who become in Calcu-

Page 14

480 sonable shades of difference in taste and opinion. Don't you will find yourself in a barren and uninfluen- In America, what- ever not When he put his shoulder under the debts of his bankrupt publishing house, the au- thor of the apothegm himself explained its meaning. Natively fond of strong language, careless of peccadilloes, toler- of all frailties though he kin-making touches of nature—his in be too good or tial minority of one is social is not virtue. ant human was feet domesti« ity “We cannot heights of the stifles’—I have We ardor tion “mortised and tenoned” were rectitude and common moral the cold thin air said it. with the high signers of the Declara- the level of the ad continual- Yet, in these always on the who live sublime forgotten flush always the remain at cannot of nor dress at ly. “O Beautiful! the long dull red moments need some one to remind that nation. For in the dead vast and middle of the years insidious foes stirring—anemic re- finements, cosmopolitan decadencies, the egotistic and usurping pride of great the cold sickening the heart reiterated of giant corruption. When our coun- because we have no castles, we are thankful to who will tell us what we can When they complain that our the humanity essential to great literature, are grateful even for the firing of a national joke heard the And ~when Mark Twain, robust, big-hearted, gifted with the divine power to use words, makes us all laugh together, builds true romances with prairie fire ana Western clay, and shows us that we are at one on all the main feel that he has been appointed Providence to see to it that the precious ordinary self of the Republic shall suffer no harm. Sruart P. SHERMAN. Gettysburg, nor cry My interspaces country: between we Sat us we are a are cities, of at the fraud trymen kings any exposures and migrate or one count on soil lacks we round world points, we by Urbana Correspondence. rHE DIARY OF GIDEON WELLES Tue most To Tue Epiror NATION sin or Among the Cabinet meetings of which there are records is the meeting of September 22, 1862, at which the Proclamation of Emancipation before its issu- Mr. Rhodes char- “a point in the history of civi- The amount of printed evidence upon Chase's Diary affords II- luminating details, and the Diary of Gideon Welles (Atlantic Monthiy, March, 1909, p 869) corroborates Chase's longer Having had occasion recently Welles’s Diary with care, I over some features of famous preliminary was read and discussed ance s meeting which acterizes as lization it Is amall and more vivid record to Mr. have been read puzzled The Nation. text which records the doings of the well-known meeting. Students of the war period are well aware that Nicolay and Hay access to the original manuscript of Welles Diary, at least in places; and authors print the passage giving the of this meeting. If record of and Hay may be taken as correct, text in the Atlantic Monthly would in- rather a ruthless editorial hand, The follow: the had the thes account Nicolay the licat two accounts Ineet- was con- a spectal Cabinet ing The subject the Proclamation cerning emancipating slaves after ai certain date, in States that should then be in re- bel lion For several the subject has suspended, but, the President says, nev- er lost sight of. When the subject was sub mitted in August, and indeed in taking it up, the President that the question was finally decided, but that he felt it to be due to us to make us acquaint- ed with the fact and to invite criticism on the Proclamation. There were some differences in the Cabinet, but he had formed his own conclusions and made his own decisions. He had, he said, made a vow, a covenant, that if God gave us the vie- tory In the approaching battle (which had just been fought), he would consider it his duty to move forward in the cause of emancipation. We might think it strange, he said, but there were times when he felt uncertain how to act; that he had in this way submitted the disposal of matters when the way was not clear to his mind what he should do. God had that it was duty to decided this question in move forward in the favor of the slave cause of emancipation. « It might be thought strange, he sald, that he had in this way sub mitted the disposal of matters when the way not clear to his mind what he should do. God had decided this question In favor of the slaves e Nicolay and Hay text. Abraham Lincoln: History, V1:160. ial Cabinet meet ing The subject was the proclamation for mancipating the slaves, certain that in several weeks A spe afte au date, States shall toe lon lor the subject has been sus but the says hever When it and now rebel weeks wended resi been lent lost sight of submitted, was in taking up the proclama tion, the President stat that finally ed the question decided and the were his, but felt it to acquaint was the act conse quences that he us to make ed with the fact and to invite the paper which he had pre pared There had found, not unexpect- some differences in but he had, due us eriticisms on were, he edly, the Cabinet ; after ascertaining in his way the views of each and all, individual ly and collectively, form- ed his own conclusions and made his de- cisions In the course of the discussion on this paper, which was long, earnest, and, on the general principle involv- ed, harmonious, he re- marked that be had made a vow—a covenant that if God gave us the victory in the approach- ing battle, he would cousider it an Iindica- tion of Divine will, and own own Atlantic Monthly text. March, 1909, p. 369. was A The reader who examines these parallel records carefully, will, besides alterations in punctuation, discover changes in numer- ous words and phrases, additions, and con- The phrase “in Au- gust,” given in the latest text of the Diary, would seem to original. At any rate it is in accord with the fact that Secre- tary Welles (like Lincoln) did not clearly remember just when the original draft of an emancipation proclamation was first read to the Cabinet (See the Galary, Decem- ber, 1872, pp. 844, 851. Lincoln's “Complete Works,” II, 479). The date has been long since established as July 22 (Nicolay and Hay’s “Abraham Lincoln,” VI, 126). The in the latest text amount to six passages, some of which are really im- portant. The absence of these passages | should certainly have been indicated. As’ spicuous omissions. be omissions stated | [Vol. 90, No. 2341 the record now appears, it is unreliable, and, from the standpoint of the seeker af- ter historical truth, unsatisfactory. It may be reasonable to assume that space be considered in the publication of any long diary in a monthly magazine where only portions of the record are likely to in- terest any large number of readers. I fail, however, to find any sound principle for the alterations or omissions here indicated. Every scrap of good evidence on Lincoln's emancipation policy should be preserved. The secretary of the navy tried hard to be accurate, It is certain that he would never have sanctioned this ruthless editing of his illuminating commentary. One wonders what proportion of the original manuscript subjected to this high-handed alteration and excision. HENRY BARRETT LEARNED. April 25. must been of has process New Haven, Conn., EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The version of the Welles Diary, now appearing in the Atlantic Monthly, consists of excerpts taken from the MS. and makes no pretense whatever to complete- ness. The original Diary consists of some 650,000 words, of which perhaps one-fifth can appear in the Atlantic. Any one with the smallest knowledge of magazine conditions will realize that the publication of much more material of this description in a periodical of general interest than the gen- erous portion published by the Atlantic is impracticable, and in its various announce- ments the Atlantic has repeatedly laid stress upon the fact that the articles have been cut from the Diary. The use of asterisks to indicate omis- sions would have greatly burdened the text and has therefore not been employed. It seems unnecessary to add that in mak- ing selections for this series care has been exercised to avoid any distortion of the views of the diarist, and to retain passages of marked historical importance. Regard- ing possible verbal discrepancies between the Atlantic version and the original Diary, I may add that the present series of articles has been set up from a typewrit- ten copy of the Diary, made a number of years ago, compared with the original, and supplied by Mr. Welles, who was unwilling to allow the manuscript itself to leave his possession. Such examination as I have been able to make in person leads me to believe that there are no variations of im- portance. The Atlantic is published for the general reader. In the forthcoming publication of the Diary in book form every effort will made to present a faithful text of the Diary in its entirety. ELLERY SEDGWICK. Editor the Atlantic Monthly. May 5. To THE be Boston, THE PHILIPPINE LAND SCHEME. To THe Eprror or THe NATION: Sir: Permit me to protest against your eaitorial on The Philippine Land Scheme, which appears in the Nation for April 25. You say: Whether the Sugar Trust is or is not the purchaser, whether the Henry W. Taft law fim is or is not involved, the sale of the £5,000 acres is indefensible morally, a shock- ing violation of trust, incredible from Mr.

Page 15

May 12, 1910] The Nation. +81 Taft’s Administration, in view of his atti ound in Tammany Hall than in the col- tations from Confucius in the wh book tude when Governor-General mns of the Nation The B’bliophile edition is likely to | rin HirnaAM BINGHAM the accepted standard for the text of the Ths is a serious charge to bring against book, when the copyrights of the earlier ed the Administration. It begins with an in Yale University, April 30 nuendo which is unworthy of the Nation . tions have expired ts two volu » are and it ends with an implication that {Our corresponaent is mistaken in now inaccessible to the general publ the pot true. You imply that Mr. Taft, when thinking there was a slur upon Mr. "%™ber of copies being less than 600, and Governor-General, favored the insertion Taft or the Taft 1 fi in th those only in the hands of subscriber It a ( 1e a aw rm 1 the sen lac} ' et fe » an that clause in the organic act which for : lacks a full index, but is copiously ann bids the sale of more than 2,500 acres ot tence he quotes. The matter was men- tated, and contains many explicat-ons and ; rarior ‘ zs of the passages land to a corporation. As a matter of fa:t. tioned merely to be brushed aside. We . am readings of passag \ pol ; : ! t of it would be valuable; f he vigorously opposed it as being contra’y , a Mr. Taft ae nt -_ mn lar reprint of it would valua Ms 4 i AnOW J . ail well enougn » De SUPre Wald ’ continues to be he “best sell te the best interests of the Filipinos. You “ iGen =6contnu be th aamit in this very editorial that Mr. Tat that if his brother’s law firm were con- 4 & the books of Thorea . . , 3. SAD RN was “the man whom, of all the America” nected with this matter it would preju I I " sent to them, the Filipinos loved best, t , , - , , : 1, Mas AY - om ‘ : = dice him against its side of the case. We cause of his freedom from race prejud . ‘ or . > 7 , arti » zpd his insistence upon the doctrin , had overlooked the Outlook's article, to ign sgl ices ogee \ MEMORIAL TO PROFESSOR MAL ‘the Philippines for the Filipinos You which our attention is called, but see no > aa » gic a attitude | ! I i l N imply that he has changed his attitud reason to change our opinion. Twenty | 1% irds the Islanis in a disgraceful mann > Shortly after the death of Prof wet us look at the facts thousand acres are not 55,000 acres, for Aus Mau the suggestion was made that In May, 1902, while still Governor-Geu- one thing, and if the Taft Administra bust f him should t ‘ eral, and while still devoted, as you admit, tion approves the sale of the latter lot nemorial the Forum of Pom ! to the best interests of the Filipinos, Mr 7 F ; igs on has now tak f f n Taft published an article in the Outlook of land to any cor; illon, We Say again and a mm R ilian 41 Which he took occasion to criticise ie it is a morally indefensible breach of the ®"ch#ological interests , . : he . ; lan *nglis) nd r jeat ‘ ; two versions of the organic act then under tryst imposed upon us in the Philip :, engi sad An , censideration in Congress. Allow me to. aaa iO Rome, ha pen appo t ; ines Dy 1e ar act ¢ > repeate fle he committs e fol ~) quote his words: I os Var at and the repeated I ymmitt , llow . . : , “a ; assurances of our unselfis! tentions g add 0 ‘ vi i yw | Both bills lim't the power of acquisition ; ? . an, a. meee feiemenell ‘Te of land by a corporation, foreign or domes- The cap'talistic devs lopment of our : ; tic, to five thousand acres. /t seems to me Rom March 30 1 that this limitation is too low, and that it Conquered over-sea lands will make im On March 6, 1909, August Mau died aft« ought to be raised to twenty thousand . ; a life of ceaseless activity. We do not need ‘ . 08S ble > ‘arry 84 ) a acres, for the reason that, in order to at possible the carrying out of those in to emphasize 1 value of h life-work ivact capital and to induce agricultural de- tentions.—KEp. Natton.} Suffice it to mention one thing alon .clopment on the best lines, especially ‘n which assures him for all time a place tn the production of sugar and tobacco, th the foremost rank of scholarship: h | cultivation must be of estates at least :s covery of the evolution of Pompeian pain iarge as fifteen or twenty thousand ac! THOREAU AND CONFUCIUS ing, with its valuable deductio for the {The italics are mine.] history of human cultur Remarkable as ro TH EDITOR oO Tue Nation were the r i] of his scholarshi he ef In view, then, of his attitude when Gov . “ fect of his personality on those who were . r > SIR Mr. Charles Franc's Adams, whose . . ; thi Peng t . t nor-General, and of his well-known desi: al : é ivileged to know him wa il more 80 3 os letter on Thoreau and Confucius was printed His manly straightforwardnes his sim te see the Filipinos prosper and advance, , . a ‘ ~ agtalgnt or , . that } t ld } ‘ in the Nation of April 21, was perhaps un plicity, his purity of motive, but above all > 2 ay Oran ee ye oe mes aware (not having been an early reader of ' lelight in ~ work, 9 ver failed t ( inc ay te iminate the stacles , ‘ : upress themselves upo t 4 who came to find a way » elimina 1e obstacles the Dial) that Thoreau, early in 1843, when om 4 se: ann ° " = - a = to progress which Senator Hoar, albeit wit! i > the : oe cart ; copia , m non woe & . : ‘ : td ' ' editing that quarterly in Emerson's absence, |i ved This love of his work kept him al ihe ast nté icns i the y le acer 3 ‘ he best intenticns in th yorid, plact i began to print in its pages what he called Ways young and joyous His joy was coh t.eir path. It is not necessary here for «pennical Scriptures,” in which many of ‘@8!ous and communicated itself to tho 4 é . i i ’ é ) y niarge on the large cos ey . who met him, so that they left him full me to enlarge on the large cost of mode! ' the quoted passages from Confucius and fo wratitude sugar plants, and the many difficulties in yonciys were first made known to most all those who knew him will rejoice in the way of making progress in the tropic New England readers Among his selec- ®“" Opportunity to give to their feeling of They are well known and appreciated DY tions was the passage which, a dozen years gratitude a lasting expression In this Fe ae : ~~ spirit, in the desire to establish some those like Mr. att. who have lived ou later, appeared in his “Walden,” and made jasting token of personal friendship and worked in the tropics, but they seem to be guch an impression on Mr. Adams. No au- devotion, and with no wish for a merely it: formal and official recognition (which ~ = , " : — _ s . " wouk e uite « trary t his «dé re) live in a land where cold and hunger drive put to those familiar with his Dial chapters ~ . = enere I J wa , . 1as been proposed to erect a b o ro etherwise indolent drones to do their work the turn of the phrases disclosed it as at- fessor Mau in the place where generations in the world. tributed to Confucius. The Concord group of scholars of all nations have learned 5 , ) de gi e word the in Your slurs on those who wish to help the o¢ authors and the American missionaries "©W under the magic of his word the rult absolutely incomprehensible to people who thor was named by Thoreau in citing 2 Diet -§ i} P ' became eloquent witnesses to the history Filipinos forward by making possible th were the first in this country to read and ,, man entry of Americar capital are thorough!y quote the sayings of the Orientals; and Em- The undersigned have reason fo hope characteristic of that point of view. In erson was for years one of the very few that the Ministry of Public Instruction of ; ‘ ; ¥ : 3 é r th . yr of Italy will not re fairness let us hear the other side. Gov. Americans who owned a copy of the Bhaga- His Majesty the King of Italy ae : Bes P fuse consent to the erection of the pro Taft went on to say: vad Ghita. He lent his copy freely, and it posed bust. Otherwise the money will be The investment of American capital ‘n WS more read than the contemporary copy expended for a worthy publication of the F . , Pompeian wall paintings which were copied the islands is necessary to their proper de- in the Harvard College Library. ag :, tes 7 . sary t 2 : _ : coun - unde Mau's direction velopment, 1s ‘th essary ae — tie The mention of “Walden” leads me to say We appeal to all of Professor Mau's lg i ‘refcre es tual, ifting , : ‘ . . sone ass terial, and there‘cre the spiritual, up that a long and minute examination of the friends and admirers for support in th of the Filipino people. It means the con : ; manuscripts of that book left by Thoreau carrying out ag this undertaking struction of railroads, the needed inter ‘ , communication vetween the people and ithe and now owned by Mr. W. K. Bixby of St. ewe 2 aie Sirus. aan tonewen pte hg: sage paar ne Bgl epee 0 ro by the Bibliophile JESSE BENEDICT CARTER, Rome comparative intelligence and wealth Society of Boston, with many additions to WOLFGANG HELBIG Rome the author's published work—showed me ANTONIO SOGLIANO, Naples You reply: “They make a livelihood, bare’ that early and late journal-entries were Contributions to the amount of $9! ars at times, and why must they do otherwise used by Thoreau in compiling it. Passages already on deposit with the treasurer of at the behest of outsiders?” Why, indeed? occur which were written as early as 1838, the Archwological Institute of America That was what the Spanish government and others as late as the spring of 1854, the for this worthy purpose. They were ré said for over three hundred years. The year of its publication. This special passage ceived from the classical staffs of the Uni 4ame spirit is not absolutely unknown ‘» from Confucius stands at the close of the versity of Wisconsin: Johns Honkins and New York; but it has been more commonly eighth chapter, and there are five other quo- Yal: Universities; the Universities «

Page 16

482 Pennsylvania Chicago Michigan; and Harvard, Cornell, Princeton and Columbia Universities. Professor Mau lectured each yea » the students of the American School f Classical Studies in Rome from its founding to his death; and if these should contribute on the average a dollar apiece, the im, in addition to that already on hand vould 1 ample a the share of Am I hall be glad to receive and forward contributions FRANCIS W. KELSEY Ann Arbo Mich., April 2o SLAVERY IN VIRGINIA. To THe Epiror or THE NATION Sir: In your notice of Mr. B. B. Mun Yord’'s book, “‘Virginia’s Attitude Towards Slavery and Secession” (Nation, February 17), is seen this sentence if, as Mr. Munford insists, Virginia se ceded simply because the Federal govern ment resorted to coercion, the conclusion is unavoidable that the State preferred to con tinue on a low social plane under its own guidance, rather than to atta'n an admit tedly higher one by Federal aid Permit me to say that President Lincoln gives a final answer to this charge of neg- lect of duty by Virginia and the South in his speech, delivered at Peoria, Ill., Octo- ber 16, 1854 “When the Southern people tell us that they are no more responsible for the origin of slavery than we are, I acknowledge the fact."" “When it is sald that the institution exists, and that it is very difficult to get rid of it in any satis- factory way, I can understand and appre- clate the saying. “I surely will not blame them for not doing what I would not know how to do myself.” “Jf all earthly power were given me, 1 should not know what to do aa to the exriating inatitution.”’ The results of the emancipation procla mation confirmed Mr. Lincoln’s statements Mr. Munford calls attention to many in- stances of deep concern and perplexity of the best hearts and heads of whites at the South in regard to the disposition of their personal slave property, and of that of the South at large In all charity, we are compelled to state that Mr. Lincoln's enforced ‘‘Federal aid’’ unfortunately left the negroes still among the vanishing races, while the country was deluged in blood. Northern intelligence and devotion have failed to rive ie ‘problem nee Mr. Lincoln's day Far removed from the black belt’ the North, especially in ite o.the finds the race problem the most vexing and persistent demand upon the whites rhe differences in the two races were distinetly recognized and stated by President Lincoln in strong, unmistakable tern Had the war President foreseen the at tilling suffering and deaths by tens of thousands among negro infants, children, the mother and the weak and aged who flocked » th freedman'’s @ettlements”’ and i refug under the Stars and Mr Lincoln would have insisted ! hap deluded folk should r¢ ma tt ilantations until th war was over. The able blacks he needed to fill his i! ! ! rroductive class, left at mn yuld ive Iped on the juse of nt oid ma ro if hous ' ’ i r. GeorGe T. C, BRYAN The Nation. QUESTIONS ANSWERED. To THe Epitor or THE NATION Sir: Permit me to reply in the greates3t possible candor to the questions asked :n the review (Na/ion, April 28) of my book, Die neue Form (1) No, I do not thiak it advisable in an American teacher to et up any new literary standards. How- ver, I do think it advisable in a critic to interpret objectively the ever new literary andards which are continually set up by reative artists; (2) No, I do not advocate he production of ‘“Sonnenfinsternis” by (or for) American college. students; nor do I vocate the production of Sophocles’s (Edipus,” Schiller’s ‘“Braut von Messina,” Snelley's “Cen Wagner's “Ring des Ni- belungen Ibsen's ‘Rosmersholm” and Ghosts."" But I do advocate the produc- tion of such masterpieces, by first-class ar- sts, for mature men and women, j. e., for that unprejudiced, intelligent, and ewstheti- cally appreciative public for which alone my book is intended. “Sonnenfinsternis” as as lofty an ethical height the novel. It through un- a play stands on as “The Scarlet is a of selfish sacrifice. It Letter,” guilt and atonement story s a story of the purifi- cation of a soul 0. E. LESSING. Urbana, Il April of PHOTOGRAPHING MARS. To THE EpiTror oF THE NATION: Sir: In reference to the account of -he nnual session of the National Academy of issue of April 28, it seems sciences in your but fair to call attention to the fact that Dr. Hale's failure to photograph the fne lines on Mars was made with a reflecting 1¢ lescope That such a suited planetary photography was shown at Flaz- staff last Dr. Lowell had installed not to elescope is autumn a reflector by Clark & Sons to be used at the last opposition of Mars. It proved vo unsuited either for the visual or phot»- graphic study of that planet, that no se- rious attempts were made to use it for uch purposes G. R. AGASSIZ. Boston, April 29 Literature. TRAVEL IN FOREIGN LANDS. War- diaries Memories: Social, Sporting. From at the time. By Lady Sarah With illustrations. Arnold. South African like, and written Wilson Edward London: Wanderings Among South Sea Savages Philippines. By H. Wilfrid Walker, F.R.G.S. With 48 New York: Scribner's Sons. and in Borneo and the plates from photographs. Imported by Charles $2.50 net Persia the Gulf to the Caspian. By F. B. Bradley-Birt, LC.S. With 31 illustrations and a map. New York: KE. P. Dutton & Co. $3.50 net The Scenes and an Through from Confessions of a Beachcomber the career ot in incidents in unprofessional beachcomber [ Vol. go, No. 2341 tropical Queensland. By E. J. Ban- field. With a map and 53 illustra- tions. New York: D. Appleton & Co. Scenes and incidents connected with the Boer war torm the larger part of Lady Sarah Wilson’s interesting “South African Memories.” The daughter of the Duke of Marlborough and sister of Lord Randolph Churchill, she had every opportunity given her during her four visits to South Africa to meet the most notable people and to see that which was most worth seeing. At her first visit in 1895 she was the guest ot Cecil Rhodes, then Prime Mmmister of Cape Colony, and she gives a delightful description of his home on the slope of Table Mountain: a low rambling house with a thatched roof, filled with choice art treasures and surrounded by plateaus bright with flowers, while an- telopes of many kinds roamed through his woods. It was “a meeting-place for all the men of the colony.” He was al- ways in favor of doing things on a large scale. “Sometimes a gardener or bailiff would ask for two or three dozen rose or fruit trees. ‘There is no use,’ he would exclaim impatiently, ‘in two doz- en of anything. My good man, you should count in hundreds and thou- sands, not dozens.’ ”’ During her stay of six weeks she was detained for some time at Kimberley by the Jameson raid, but succeeded in reaching Johannesburg and Pretoria, where she saw President Kruger, who “with a venerable white beard, in a somewhat worn frock-coat and a rusty old black silk hat, did not look the stern dictator of his little kingdom, which in truth he was. Our Dutch friend told us Oom Paul was in the habit of commenc- ing work at 5 a. m., and that he trans- acted business, either at his house or in the government offices, with short inter- missions, until 5 p. mM.” Her second visit was three years later and lasted for fifteen months, two of which were spent in Rhodesia. At the outbreak of the war she attempted to join her hus- band, the aid-de-camp of Col. Baden- Powell, the heroic defender of Mafeking, but was taken prisoner by the Boers, and after tedious negotiations was ex- changed for a horse-thief. Her account of her experiences in the Boer laager, and particularly of her life in the be- leaguered town, is especially interesting. The most formidable weapon of the Boers was a big siege gun every motion of which was watched through a tele- scope, notice being given by a bell to the townspeople that it to be fired. Often her telephone would ring up with the message: “The gun is load- ed and pointed at the town. A monkey belonging to the post-office, who generally spent the day on the top of a chained, would, rapidly de- was about pole to which he was on hearing the alarm-bell, scend from his perch, and, in imitation of the human beings whom he saw tak-

Page 17

May 12, 1910} ing shelter, quickly pop under a large empty biscuit-tin.” But on Sundays, “thanks to the religious proclivities of the Boers,” there was an absolute cessa- tion of hostilities on both sides, “and from early dawn to late at night the whole population thoroughly enjoyed themselves.” On the relief of Mafeking, she went to Pretoria, where she met her nephew, Winston Churchill, and the “hero of a thousand fights,” Lord Roberts, of whom she says: “I shall never forget how kindly he spoke, nor the inexpressible sadness of his face.’’ On her return home the Red Cross was awarded her, and the medal for service in South Africa. The third visit was in 1902, when she was the guest of Lord Milner at Johannes- burg. The next year she went to Rho desia, camping for a short time at Liv- ingstone, Victoria Falls, which she de scribes as “one of the fairest landscapes to be seen on God's earth.” The attrac tiveness and value of the book are in- creased by the twenty illustrations, which include portraits of most of the noted persons mentioned in her narra- tive and a humorous sketch by Col. Baden-Powell. The author of “Wanderings Among South Sea Savages and in Borneo and the Philippines” has been a collector ot birds and butterflies, and gives in this book a readable account of some of his collecting trips. Our only -crit- icism is that he dwells too frequent- ly and in too much detail on the re- volting customs of the people among whom he travelled. It does not add to the interest of his narrative to be con- stantly reminded of the cannibalistic practices of the Papuans, nor to have one’s attention continually directed to the ghastly trophies to be found in the house of the Borneo head-hunter. Life in the home of a Fijian prince and adven- tures in company with him are describ ed in the first chapters. Then follows an account of a visit to the Philippines, evidently at the time of the Taft ad ministration, for in his preface he ac knowledges his obligations to him. The Negritos, among whom he passed most of his time, are set down as “certainly the merriest and yet the dirtiest peo ple I have ever met.” While with them he heard rumors of an extraordinary mountain tribe, named Bugquils, “whose women were reported to have beards,’ but his journey in search of them fail because of the intertribal enmities, and he was unable to prove whether or not the While in North Borneo, in whose torests he spent seven months, visited edibl birds’-nest caves, and his description of ed story was a myth. he some them is by far the most entertaining part of his book. After a somewhat hazardous exploration of one which was more than 500 feet in height, with an opening in the top which from be low looked like a distant star, he re The Nation. ‘turned to his hut. About dusk he “heard a noise like the whistling of the wind, and, going outside, I saw a truly won derful sight. The millions of small bats which share these caves with the birds {swallows] were issuing forth from the small hole in the very top of the rock. As far as the eye could see they stretch- ed in one even, unbroken column across the sky. They issued from the cave in a compact mass and preserved the same even formation till they disappeared in the far distance. They resembled a thick line of smoke coming out of the tunnel of a steamer, and the thick line twisted and wriggied across the sky for all the world like a giant snake. They were still coming forth in the same manner till darkness set in, and then I could only hear the beating of myriads of wings, like the sighing ot the wind in the tree-tops.”. They return in early morning in much the same fash The swallows, he was told, usual the 10n. ly did the same thing; came out, the swallows and when the bats swallows came out. But at their nesting season, when they went in and out of the caves irregularly all day. The book is attractively made up, and the 48 plates from photographs, some of rare beauty, give vividness to the narrative. The most interesting part of F. B. Bradley-Birt’s “Through Persia” is that descriptive of the southwestern region in which lie Shiraz and the ruins Persepolis. It gives a vivid impression of the ancient empire of the Sassanians. His admiration for the “most fas cinating city in the East” with its blue domes and golden minarets, its many gardens of cypresses and roses, is partly due to the approach through monotonous and over parren heights and also to the influence of its great poets, Sadi and Hafiz, whose memory is cherished at the present day, thousands of pilgrims coming to their tombs. In the garden in which Sadi lies he found the keeper holding school with half a dozen tiny scholars, from four to seven old. They were “writing with their quaint wooden pens on square-cut plaintain leaves that serve They are copying laborious bats entered the in, the there when caves, went he was ot desert years for paper. ly a famous line of Sadi’s, a copy of whose poems, beautifully illuminated lies open on the old man’s knees, and no line could well be more appropriate to this restful spot beside the beautiful city that Sadi loved——If there is a Para dise on earth, it is this, it is thi The first impression of Persepolis with which, according to the ancient writers, “no city could be compared either in beauty or in wealth and which was called the “Glory of the East vas its vast lonelins “Man and every living creature seem to hav deserted the fallen city jut this feeling was soon overcome by the fascination 483 of its marvellous remains In strik- ing contrast to these relics of a glorious past is a village hanging on the top of an enormous rock island, tier on tier of houses rising to a height of a hundred and thirty feet the The only approach is by a narrow foot to a small doorway cut the face of the rock. So are the villagers to. their quarters “that they pursue their daily avocations with unconcern, while children play in the hanging verandahs regardless of the yawning drop below above river-bed bridge in accustomed exalted the His account of the remainder of his journey through Ispahan and Teheran to the Caspian is lacking in interest the hold calls atten When he passed through the capital Mejliss, the new parliament, was ing its first sittings, and he tion to the part which the Indian agita tor played in the revolution. A weekly paper printed in Calcutta was on sale in the and the eagerness with which it was bought and read by the crowd, which always gath streets, “no one who saw ered round the palace in which the Mejliss sat, could doubt its influence. It was from its columns that the Te heranis first acquired the word ‘consti tution. Illustrations of some of the most interesting scenes described and an excellent map add to the value of the book. Bg. J. Banfield, in the “Confessions ot a Beachcomber,” tells of his search for the “simple life’ in a tropical island of the coast of Queensland. Though but three and a half square miles in area, it contains a wealth of fauna and flora, which is described with all the enthusi asm of a true lover of nature. Especial attention is paid to the birds, the num ber of which may be imagined from the tact that he gives a of 131 dit ferent species, “all permanent residents familiar to him He also gives a glowing descrip Interesting ‘census” as well as casual visi tors.” tion of his garden of coral too, is his account of the different trees, one of which, the umbrella tree, is a “distillery of nectar of crystal purity and inviting flavor. The chapters de voted to the natives, “stone-age folk are somewhat disappointing; the pet sons particularly portrayed are unin teresting, and the numerous anecdotes of them are told in almost unintelli gible pidgin-English. The 53 Illustra tions are reproductions of photograph some of them, especially that of the coral garden, being of great beauty. T lack of an index in a book treating of so many different subjects is to be 1 gretted CURRENT FICTION T) Tl ndesirable Gaver ¥ By } la ion Crawford. N Yor} The Mac millan Co For the last time, by admission of the publishers, we are called upon to com

Page 18

484. ment upon a ne work by the most natural story-teller of his generation. When Crawford's life comes to be writ n, we shall no doubt find out in what three posthumous novels were ihe the com posed | ndesirable Governess vford’s lightest mood. It well toward the etting The Lady Jane her sus mes to Cra on Hit of come dy I'he ultra-Englisn. f farce and atmos ure pains to protect from virtuous, at sucn and sons attrac is the stern, Briton of long tradi neil ' ib husband housemates nd snobbish lady The mainspring of the indispensable consideration in Kng fiction—the duty of getting your money's worth when you marry. From Richardson to Trollope, and from Trol to (though strangely not includ De Morgan, the absurdity in mar rying an inferior in rank or fortune the natural key to the romantic action. How of Algernon to waive, though of course not ignore, the fact that Alice's grandfather was a tradesman, or that her income is a pal story is } 1 1iSi lope ing) is magnanimous try thousand a year! How wonderful of Lady Edith to give herself to the younger son—with only blood, health, brains, and a heart to recommend him: We must he might have had the Duke! gue that Crawford took a sly satisfac tion in playing once more upon this vell-worn string. The “undesirable gov ern makes herself desirable, even to the fastidious Lady Jane-—as a gover ne As a prospective daughter-in-law being supposedly poor and of no social standing, she is, of course, an object olf execration, a thing to be insulted and cast into outer darkness with all dis patel The machinery by which the poor and nameless girl is shown to be a rich girl and a well-born girl need not be described No novelty of design is striven for in its construction. Nor is subtlety employed in the framing of Lady Jane's recantation. The story is only a trifle, but a perfect trifle in its Crawfordian kind. Cavanagh, Forest Ranger 1 Romance of the Mountain West By Hamlin Garland. New York: Harper & Bros ‘Author of “The Gray-Horse Troop, Viain-Travelled Roads, et« reads the title page Hiow little of the “and so forth” has come up to the promise, or even the achievement, of those early tales' In “Main-Travelled Roads” Mr. years ago, work twenty his later Garland, now nearly sounded a note of which has given, for the most part, a series of diminishing That volume will stand belleve, as one of the classics of American fiction And it is because we believe this that each book of Mr. Garland’s continues to arouse in us a now rather forlorn hope. The present book is earnestly and painstakingly written. It sets forth with much detall echoes we new the life and the problems of the forest The Nation. ranger in those parts of the West where the old lawless traditions still linger, and sheep and cattlemen alike are on the offensive against the national pro- tector of the forests. “Roaring Fork,’ the scene of most of the narrative, is a little town sixty miles from a railway, where “the air of the reckless old-time range still clung rancidly about in the groggeries, as a deadly gas hangs about the lower levels of a mine.” To this community has come one Cavanagh, a naturalized Englishman and forest ranger. Though a subordinate even in the local forest service, he has ward over a large stretch of country, and as representative of the law, is at once un- popular among the worthies of Roaring Fork. The narrative recounts his strug- gles to uphold his authority almost sin- gle-handed. In the end he escapes de- feat, and is recognized as harbinger of a new day and new methods. This is a good and natural plot for a novel about the new West. Unluckily, Mr. Garland has not been able to get away from his As fiction, the book belongs to a The girl who is duly supplied for Cavanagh—the refined Eastern-bred daughter of a Roaring Fork mother—has little reality or de- sirability. The other persons in the except perhaps the older woman— are but pale figures. The fact is, the writer has had a speech to make, not a story to tell. He has wished to express his indignation at the dismissal of the recent chief of the forestry service, and nis belief in the system originated by that officer. The dismissal has its part in the story; and Mr. Pinchot himselt supplies a discreet introduction. low text. mediocre sort. tale idventures of an A.D.C. By Shel- Bradley. New York: John Lane he land Co. This book is delightfully light in the literal and vot unpleasantly so in the figurative. “Adventures” is a mis- the aide-de-camp has no more than the Needy Knifegrinder. As a scrap-book, however, the volume pre sents good entertainment, the gems ot the collection being unquestionably the native letters—vouched for in a preta tory note as substantially genuine—re ceived at Government House. What magnate could resist an appeal which closes with the benediction, “And may the Almighty (whom Your Honor much sense, nomer; resembles) grant you long life, etc.’’? Many of us have at some time the trying experience of finding that we have included the dead in our invita- tions, but seldom is the fact so un- equivocally brought home to us as by the polite reply: “I regret to inform you that my late father is now resi-| dent at Heaven.” One letter we make no apology for quoting in full; it should have been addressed to Mr. Roosevelt: Honored Protector of the Poor: Having heard of your almighty mercy and loving | Vol. go, No. 2341 kindness to us worms, I make bold to tell you my circumstances, By the grace of God, your Lordship, I have seven children, all babes and suck- lings. Besides this abominable litter, I have many relations, male and female, all de- pendent upon me. What have | done that I should be blessed with such cursed trials? As your Lordship is my father and my mother, I would require that you take this worm and wife and suckles and relations, both male and female, and provide for us from your bounty at a remuneration of rupees twenty per month. 1 cannot read or write, and have only the suckle qualifications and male relations and feminine, but, by the grace of God and your Lordship, I look forward to years of prosperity and happiness. We all sing loudly of your praises, your justice. and your mercy; therefore, call us all that we may fatten on your love and gentleness. Call quickly. Your faithful worm and beast, Pindari Das (despicable brute and unwilling father of babies). Predestined: A Novel of New York Life. By Stephen French Whitman. New York: Chas. Scribner’s Sons. Mr. Whitman has treated a dangerous theme with delicacy and strength. A rich widower, who has worshipped his wife's memory, discovers that the young man he has regarded as his only son is real- ly the child of another father; he con- verts his wealth into bills which he burns; the son, brought up in luxury and with wealthy associates, is left in poverty and sets out to earn a living by his wits; from newspaper work he turns failing in this he takes to drink, becomes entangled with wo- men whose homes are near the Great White Way, and sinks through various stages of degradation to an ignominious death. It is a sordid subject, relieved by little humor, but in Mr. Whitman’s treatment is not repulsive. The vice of the streets and of the flashy underworld is exposed with all its tragic lessons, yet the reader is neither offended by preach- ing and moralizing nor disgusted by nauseous details. It is realism with re- straint and human sympathy, and on the whole gives a juster and more vivid picture of certain aspects of life in New York's “tenderloin” than does any other novel we can recall. One minor point deserves mention— the psychological skill with which the degeneration is noted from the hero’s father, who is a Parisian poet of a few exquisite but sterile works in his youth, to the hero himself who has all the vel- leity of artistic production without the effective will. to authorship; The Green Cloak. By Yorke Davis. New York: Sturgis & Walton. Nothing is more amusing to the habit- ual reader of detective stories than the eagerness of the writers to seize on some method of varying the old themes. When Professor Miinsterberg’s articles on the detection of crime by the new in- struments of the psychological labora- tory were printed, it was perfectly safe to predict that we should have a flood of detective stories on the method. The

Page 19

May 12, 1910] viher day we noticed “Luther Trant’; to-day we have such another, in this case, however, the Sherlock Holmes otf the laboratory being an ancient profes- sor who has lived in Australia, where- as Luther Trant was a newcomer in the field. The sleuth-minded professor's life in the East is essential to the story, for the plot is compounded of Oriental pirates, the Maori speech, and other exotic flavors, though the scene is a very modern American suburb. The story is interesting, and the psychologi- ca! apparatus is worked in cleverly. NAPOLEON III. The Rise of Louis Napoleon. By F. A. Simpson. Illustrated. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $3.50 net. Kinglake and Carlyle and the great throng of English and American writers who, half a century ago, denounced Louis Napoleon would rub their eyes if they could read this book. For, when Mr. Simpson closes his chronicle with the election of Louis Napoleon to the Presidency in 1848, he leaves upon the reader the impression that the spu- rious Bonaparte was rather a commend- able person. The crime of the coup d'état had not been committed; and Mr. Simpson does not arrange his material with reference to that event, on which most historians have based their ver- dict. He simply tells the story of the first forty years of the Prince, untinged by what occurred afterward. This treat- ment is, we believe, both honest and correct. The result is that we see in the Prince a youth of unusual sensibility, and a man of extraordinary tenacity of pur- pose. His two attempted “invasions” of France appear no longer as ridiculous fizzles, but as carefully laid schemes which, in that epoch when every pro- posed revolution seemed possible, had some chance of success. Mr. Simpson's account of these affairs is well done, the best we have seen in English. He puts before you the situation as the Prince saw it, not as everybody can see, and judge it, in retrospect. Most interesting is the description of the rise of the Napoleonic legend. The main feature of the imprisonment of the great Napoleon at Saint Helena was not, as has been generally supposed, his eclipse and end; it was the opportunity it offered him—an opportunity he im- proved to the full—of creating the leg- end which was destined to produce the Second Empire, and to dazzle French- men unto the third and fourth genera- tion of those who had fought and died for the First. It was Louis Napoleon, after the death of his brother raised him to the dignity of pretender, who earliest saw the immense possibilities latent in the legend. It was he who ex- ploited those possibilities in all direc- tions; he whom preither failure, nor in- The Nation. difference, nor calumny, nor ridicule could cause to waver. It is startling to reflect that he, Mazzini, who were only three years apart in age, but as remote in from the other, showed during the thir- ties and forties equal inflexibility of purpose, equal readiness to stake every- thing to promote their respective causes But the parallel ceases when we exam- and Garrison, ideals as one pole is ine the character of the three After making what allowance we will, Louis Napoleon's aim was selfish; for nobody suggests that a mere philan to France the best possible government sustained him during his years of ill-fortune. Garrison and Mazzini had the of prophets or of Cromwellian Puritans like Luther, they “could not otherwise but cannot that the partist pretender would have borne and labored as he did unless he had hoped that he—and not some other member of the family—should enjoy the prize. Per- haps Mr. would have well to epitomize his chief work, “Les Idées Napoléoniennes,” thropical ambition give zeal Jewish we believe Bona- Simpson done which bears wit- ness to his skill as a writer, to his vi sionary intellect, and to his remarkable ability to coin concrete phrases which scon passed current, although they had only abstractions behind them. His L’Empire, c'est la pair—to cite a single example—was a stroke of genius and won him more supporters than a thou sand political orations could have done. As a fashioner of ringing manifestoes, both before and after he came to power, Louis Napoleon had, in our opinion, no superior, although among his contem- poraries were scores of brilliant rhetori- clans, Mr. makes it clear that the Prince had the happy knack of seeming to be a specialist in many fields modern government Simpson's study in the science of war, in his tory, in of being hospitable to new this happy knack denoted, as it does, superficiality, and left him less when he was brought face face with inexorable facts. Cobden found him ignorant of even the A B C of po litical economy; the battles of Magen ta and Solferino showed him a tyro in generalship; Cavour and after him Bis marck made a plaything of his state craft. But all this came later. Mr. Simpson has the pleasanter and easier task of describing the prospective des- pot’s formative years, in which he de- voted himself with might and main to self-culture in everything except char- acter. Only a rabid anti-Bonapartist could fail to do justice to the Prince's self-reliance, which urged him to per- petual efforts. Amateurs of political dexterity must admire the way in which he worked up what we Americans would call his “boom,” and glided as deftly as an eel among the complications of 1848 until he landed in the Presidency. and But often help comparative ideas. to 4AR85 This part of the story Mr. Simpson with commendable clarity. He short in not sufficiently impress readers who have no other source information that the Prince's hab and companions during exile were for the most part such as to justi the popular opinion that he not make a reputable sovereign. A ertine, a spendthrift, a nothing his as collateral, a liker of vulgar ed Napoleon magnetic qualities to offset these ot Do would, he could not the treats falls ing of its on his would lib fy borrower! with to onet talnt had except “prospects OI associates, Louis no in the he ot his sober critics. what ‘ ye s win support any respectable, much less dominant, class before 1848 Mr. Simpson hints at this, but, as we have said, he lays hardly enough stress on it. His chief one, in positive merit, and it is a high Na sympathet than it ha consists presenting Louis poleon’'s side ically hitherto more and more accurately been presented: and yet it would have been possible at least to out line the negative side more distinctly There are but few minor points on which we should challenge his state ments. His idea that Napoleon's mem bership in the Carbonaria may be doubt ed because there is no documentary evi dence to prove it, leads us to infer that he thinks the Carbonari signed thei oaths at initiation—which is wholly in correct. Nor do we agree with him that the question of the Prince’s pa ternity is now “purely academic’: we have yet to see strong presumptive ev! dence (much less conclusive proof) that he was the son of the Holland But and other atters are too slight to be debated here. Kxven King of these, similar m worth of if Mr. Simpson be wrong, the his book cannot be doubted. History of the Great American For tunes. By Gustavus Myer Vols. I and II; three parts. Chicago: Charles H. Kerr & Co. $1.50 each. The Economic Causes of Great For tunes. By Anna Youngman Vew York: The Bankers’ Publishing Co $1.50 Although the first volume of Mr Myers'’s work does not deal with the most recent phase of the process of American fortune-building, it is none the less full of that kind of bitter de nunciation which we are in the habit of associating with the “muck-raking”’ lit erature of the present day. Part i deals with “Conditions in Settlement and Co lonial Times,” part ii with “The Land Fortunes”; the era of Vander bilt and Gould, not to speak of Rocke- feller and Morgan and Carnegie and Harriman, accordingly, is still in the distance. But from the first the accus ing finger is pointed at the accumula tors of wealth; and, indeed, the impli cation is plain throughout that, bad as Great

Page 20

486 things are now, the standards and ideals and practices of older days were incom- parably worse. No golden age is pre- serited to our view in the days of the colonists; it is truly “old, unhappy, far-off things” that are the burden of the song. For it is not simply the history of the great for- tunes with which our author is concern ed; great eager as he is to bring home to the land-grabbers, and Indian trad and shippers the burden of every sin of greed and fraud and inhumanity that the records can furnish, he insists constantly the that their ra- pacity and unscrupulousness were but an on greater scale of what in the propertied and trading classes was doing according to his ability and his opportunity. Com ing to a later period, Mr. Myers devotes the major part of his space to the Astor fortune, though other great fortunes re ers, on lesson exhibition a everybody else attention than can be com who bear the names After making all al animus of the the great the whole society celve more fortable of for those builders. the only their lowance tor evident writer—not as against but as against of individualist enough remains of unquestionable truth the of abhorrent doings placed before us very depressing reading. That the picture of conditions as a whole is misleading, its unbroken darkness is sufficient to warn us; and if plutocrats, structure make to array one is armed against the acceptance ot it as anything more than a graphic pre sentation of one side of a case by an in tense partisan, he may derive much profit this account of ugly and often forgotten aspects of our history. The volume, comprising part iil of the work, opens with two chapters of general considerations, relating to the Seizure of the Public Domain” and to the contrast between the activity of government in behalf of the great prop- interests and its inactivity in mat- relating the of the masses fhe remaining chapters tell of the Vanderbilt fortune the Gould fortune tn that leaves no desired in point of pungency from REC ond erty ters to welfare ten and a way thing to be or dramatic interest different bal judicial care In Professor Young in those created by of Mr But this small measure to 1 of one of the representative fig en to Illustrate the three types Her pur- the even Though written in a wholly epirit, and marked by intellectual ince In discussion and tatement of facts book iry lone the produces some respects not unlike man Mvers is her fortunes that of the moralisat or American econo the primarily that of plan ia to proceed from the oclologist: her ideration of develop cor fortunes underlying causes certain typical great nent of the Her first subject ts the analysis of eir growth The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2341 fortune of John Jacob Astor, “the typi- cal American fortune of the pre-corpor- ate régime”; the next is that of Jay Gould, belonging to the day of public- service corporations, but preceding the era of the great industrial corporations and combinations; and after this comes an account of the great “group for- tunes,” particularly those of the “Stan- dard Oil” men and the “Morgan” men. It is in the account of the career of Jay Gould, naturally enough, that we are brought face to face with the black- est facts in these histories; and if there is a serious fault to be found with Pro- fessor Youngman’s discussion, it is that she has not adequately distinguished Gould’s unblushing robbery and corrup- tion from practices which, whether justi- fiable or not, cannot rationally be placed in the same category. This, however, may be classed as a side matter. in or- derly and compact array, the salient facts of these several cases are given; a task which, in the case of the “group fortunes,” involved much able and painstaking research. In two. clos- ing chapters, the rationale of the whole matter is discussed with much ability. Phat the distinction between “unearned increment” and earned increment is not as simple as is so often assumed—that the enhanced value of land due to causes outside the agency of the owner not inherently different from in- creases of fortune coming about in many other ways—is well pointed out. A much simpler thesis, which ought to require no demonstration, is that the ac- tual gains accruing to those who make their fortunes in the operations of mod- and industry do. not correspond the value of the social service they render. Still less, as the au- thor says, can any absolute ethical jus- tification be pleaded; it is only on the basis of social expediency that judgment can rationally be passed on the question of interference or non-interference with the workings of present-day distributive economics. 1s ern finance to The Indian and His Problem. By Fran- cis E. Leupp. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2 net. For many years a student of the In dian problem, and for seven, as commis sioner, the personal representative of the Great Father at Washington in his dealings with the race, Mr. Leupp speaks with an authority which he no vhere The book is delight- fully reasonable, full of excellent and significant anecdotes, humorous even in attitude to scatterbrained humani- tarians obstruct administrative traffic. Against the self-accusing phrase, “a century of dishonor,” Mr. Leupp pro- tests, substituting “a century of misun- derstanding.” The difficulty with our Indian policy is that we have too long delayed to deal with the individual In- imposes, who dian. We have legislated instead for the race, or for the tribe. The result has been to prolong the term of tutelage and actually to hold back the Indians who were ready to become citizens. Again and again Mr. Leupp insists that the Indian problem is an individual and a human problem. Treat every Indian as you would a white of the same class and you will not go far wrong. In- stead we have fed him, held his lands for him, sold them, and put the funds in trust—in every way made him a de- pendent. With the support of President Roose- velt, to whom this book is dedicated, Commissioner Leupp was able to intro- duce the individualistic method. Fer- merly it required an act of Congress to make an Indian a citizen. Now this is done at the discretion of the commis- sioner. The humors and flexibility of the personal method are shown in the fact that the assignment of title to land is, as the case may be, a reward for a good or a punishment for a bad Indian. The thrifty Indian acquires with a vote the control of his own property and the responsibilities of citizenship, whereas the worthless Indian is read out of his favored condition as a ward and forced to take his chances with the law. In general, Mr. Leupp wants the individual Indian to be put on his own feet. Give him his lands and his share of trust funds whenever there is even a pre- sumption that he can use them well. Encourage him to work, and give him an education suitable to his needs. As commissioner, Mr. Leupp estab- lished an empioyment bureau which proved the capacity of the Indian for a great variety of trades. Too often in the past the nation has assumed that he can only be a farmer. Mr. Leupp was also able greatly to increase and im- prove those primary local schools on which he sets his faith. The wholesale attempt to provide secondary and high- er education for the Indian has been pretty barren of results. There is prof- it for the boarding schools in the stipend which the government allots for each Indian pupil. The result has been an unseemly scramble for pupils, and their virtual purchase from venal par- ents. Many students have been alienat- ed from their own people without learn- ing to cope with the whites. Against making it easy for the Indian to acquire educational frills, therefore, Mr. Leupp sets himself firmly. The three R’s and the elements of some me- chanical trade will fit the Indian for holding his own in the community. More than this is usually superfluous. The exceptional Indian will always find the way to higher education open to talent. Within a few generations, as we make citizens of the Indians, the Indian problem will cease to be. The race will have been assimilated, and only an occasional name, the coppery

Page 21

May 12, 1910] tinge of a fair cheek, the straight black hair of a few Americans, will tell of the race that was. We would gladly dwell upon Mr. Leupp’s analysis of the Indian charac- ter. The morose, phlegmatic, and sus- picious brave of fiction is with difficulty found in real life. The Indian has the primitive, the Homeric, qualities and defects. His family affections are the strongest. To a friend he is singularly open-hearted and companionable. His sense of honor is keen, and he keeps faith under trying conditions. He is a lavish giver, though with a shrewd bar- baric feeling that his bread is being cast on the waters and will return. He is humorous withal, and a good judge of the foibles of his white superiors. The grotesque ignorance that prevails about Indian matters may be illustrat- ed by that Senator who threatened to introduce a bill abolishing Hampton In- stitute—a private corporation; or by that other statesman who by the shift- ing of a decimal point discovered that the secondary education of the Red Man cost $1,700 per capita. Had the com- missioner not had the opportunity of privately eliminating a zero there might perhaps have been a motion for a Con- gressional investigation. The perplexi- ties and humors of that benevolent des- potism, the Indian bureau, are dis- creetly hinted at with abundant, and needed, charity for all. This book should be widely read, especially by amateur philanthropists, who at a safe remove of fifteen hundred miles and more are endeavoring to befriend the Indian. It will show them many things that they may do to help, and more that are inexpedient or quite useless. The Life of Principal Rainy. By Patrick Carnegie Simpson, M.A. In two vol- umes. London: Hodder & Stoughton. Robert Rainy was for forty years the leader of the General Assembly of the Free Church of Scotland. For thirty years of that time he was principal of New College, Edinburgh, the most fa- mous theological school of his church, and for twelve years previous he had been a professor of church history in that institution. He was the author of several considerable volumes, notably a treatise on “The Ancient Catholic Church,” and in earlier years he was pastor of an important church. But the chief occupation of his life was in the field of ecclesiastical politics, and his biographer has comparatively little to record concerning his administration of, an educational institution or his work as a teacher and scholar, whereas dis- cussion of his activities in ecclesiastical courts and controversies occupies nine- tenths of the volumes. In his forty years of church leadership Principal Rainy achieved at least one large and beneficent task: the union of the Free a.) he Nation. and United Presbyterian Churches of Scotland. In this long struggle he toil- ed with endless patience, consummate skill, unfailing tact and generalship, and with unquestioned devotion to the highest religious interests of his nation. Such a record could not have been made without great intellectual force and large moral power. That Principal Rainy was a great man was the testi- mony of all who came in contact with him. Mr. Gladstone once declared him the greatest of living Scotchmen. Dr. George Adam Smith described him mov- ing with quiet dignity in London amid affairs which brought together many of the foremost men of England, and was impressed with the feeling that “none was built bigger than he was.” During his leadership the Scottish Free Church came to be one of the strongest and most progressive spiritual forces of Christendom. Certainly the difficult field of church union has known no greater master. The strong United Free Church of to-day is his monument. In the religious thought and attitude of the Scotch people Principal Rainy’s influence was not so pronounced. It would be hard to mention a single be- lief or doctrine which 1s the clearer or worthier because of his labors. The Scotland of to-day has afar nobler creed than the Scotland of fifty years ago, but little of the improvement can be attributed to the leader of the Free Church during that period. In the Rob- ertson Smith controversy his influence on the whole was on the reactionary side. He tried to get rid of the prophet ic and brilliant leader of the new criti cal movement “on respectful terms,’ i. e., by casting him out uncondemned. He was more anxious to prevent a de- cision of the church on the critical issue than establish justice for a great scholar. His biographer has sought to justify his course, not altogether successfully. Doubtless the heretic was at times of fensive—heretics usually are—but Rainy was large enough to discern beneath the personal limitations the great cause which Robertson Smith represented. It is clear enough that he did discern the real issue, but’ his temper was conserva tive, and with his great powers of lead ership he preferred not to lead in the di rection of wider freedom. He was an ecclesiastical, not a religious, leader, but in the field of ecclesiastical states manship the nineteenth century produc ed no superior. Mr. Simpson has taken much pains in recounting the movements in Scottish Church affairs in which Principal Rainy was active. His volumes are really a history of church movements in Scot land for the last half century. He ts evidently an intense sympathizer with the organization whose history he ana- lyzes, as well as an ardent admirer of the chief actor in them. He has per to 48% formed his task with thoroughness, and his volumes are a contribution to the ecclesiastical history of the nineteenth century. Crete, the Forerunner of Greece. By C H. and H. B. Hawes, with a preface by Arthur J. Evans. New York: Har per & Bros. 75 cents net. Of the various handbooks which have appeared the subject of cavations in Crete this is likely to prove the most useful. The authors have su ceeded in furnishing what needed—a vivid picture of Cretan civilization. Anybody all familiar with the mass of brought to light in Crete during the last ten years will appreciate the dif ficulty of reconstructing from it a unt on recent ex was much the great who Is at material fied account which will bring out the essential features without neglecting the finer shades of the picture. As it is, “Crete, the Forerunner of Greece, will prove absorbing reading not only to the layman, bui also to the trained archeologist; for, though the story runs on bringing into contact this world, there are also many original sug stillawait easily, us intimate with wonderful Minoan gestions on points which ars ing final settlement—-such as the race problem, the significance of certain symbojs, and the system of chronology This Awofold value is due to the fact that, as Dr. Evans says in his preface to the book, the authors “have the great advantage of writing, ‘not as scribes but as active workers in the field that they describe.” Mrs. Hawes herself nas excavated the Minoan town ot Gournia in the eastern part of Greec: the results of which have been pub lished in a large volume entitled “Gournia, Vasiliki, and Other Prehistor ic Sites on the Isthmus of Hierapetra, Crete,” from which she has freely ed in her handbook; and Mr. Hawe made important knowledge of Cretan anthropology. The divisions of the subject adopted quot has contributions to our by the writers show us the various aspects from which they have treated their material. The Introduction gives a short history of Cretan excavations Then follow a survey of the various pe riods through which Cretan civilization passed and the of chronology adopted for these periods. The descrip of the Knossos, Triadha, Palaikastro give a goud idea of the com Minoan system tions sites Phe stos, Aghia and others plicated plans of towns and will prove invaluable to the visitor in Crete; while the chapters on Gournia, palaces and Physical Characteristics, Dress and Homes of the Minoans; Industries and Commerce; Minoan Art; Letters and Religion; Crete and Greece, give a good general survey of the manifold objects discovered on those sites. Except for plans of Knossos, Phwestos

Page 22

>. ry. , 488 The Nation. and Gournia, and a map of Crete, the following a burrow, the man reached a book has no illustrations. With the low p!ace where the dead every night resume price of the book this omission could possession of their bones. His wife greeted probably not be avoided: but the text ig »im affectionately, and hid him from the malicious dead. Plighting his word to re- turn, be unhappily plucked the fruit of the nether world on his way up, was thus delayed, attacked by the dead, and, losing the fruit, barely escaped with his life. The so good that it is to be hoped that a more expensive edition, fully illustrat- ed, will appear in the near future. N { - burrow which admitted him was then for- WWOLeS.,. ever closed. We recommend the story to —— experts on underworld folklore. The mere Houghton Mifflin Company publishes this '@¥™an can appreciate its macabre in- week “Notes on New England Birds,” by ‘¢®%ity. The author has induced the natives Henry D. Thoreau, which have been ar- ‘© Pose for certain incidents of the stories. ranged and edited by Francis H. Allen. The resulting photographic cuts make very effective i!lustrations for a book in every way out of the common These notes are taken from the volumes of rhoreau'’s Journal, and are arranged in ome scientific order, according to species. C. F. Tucker Brooke, who has already done Phetographs of birds in their natural sur- yaliant service in editing the “Shake- roundings illustrate the text speare Apocrypha,” has now prepared The survey of Bjirnsterne Bjérnson’'s life a similar volume for the Clarendon Press, ind work, by William Morton Payne, which containing “The Works of Christopher Mar- appeared in the International Quarterly in lowe.” As this publication is preliminary March, 1903 s now reprinted in a small to a more elaborate library edition already volume, with changes and additions, by A. in preparation, we shall withhold our com- C, MeClurg & Co., at fifty cents. This work! ments on Mr, Brooke's treatment of moot includes original translations of several of points of scholarship until we have before the lyri and of passages from Bjérnson’s us his fuller discussion of them. Except in prose-writing one matter there can be little but praise Publication of a complete history of the for the execution cf the present volume. Mr. Brooke, following the custom of the day, has elected to reproduce the spelling of the originals, although he has allowed himself ago, is announced by the trustees of the /iberties with the punctuation and capitali- Boston Atheneum, to appear May 15. This 7@tion. For our part we can see no better volume, which will include an introduction | reason for changing “‘unmeaning irregulari- by M. A. De Wolfe Howe. will contain much ties” in points and capitals than in spell- bibliographical matter concerning books re- ‘28. and we wish to protest strongly— viewed in the magazine. a list of all con- | ‘hough, no doubt, uselessly—against the tributor and all weekly records of the S?towing habit of reproducing the unsettled spelling of Elizabethan authors, except in cases where only the most special linguistic students can be concerned. What possible profit can there be in printing “towne” for town, or “quyuering” for quivering, and so on ad infinitum? The only result is to re- Wonthly Anthology and Roaton Revricw, one of the early American magazines which en- joyed a life for ten years, Just one century club of voung men who were editors The literary executors of Mark Twain, Mrs. Ossip Gabrilowitsch, his daughter, and Albert Bigelow Paine ire preparing bi- ographical matvcrial of the humorist, and wish to get all letters of personal or liter- iry interest. These should be sent to Red- ling, Conn The publishers (Harper & move Marlowe a step further from the busi- ness and bosom of the ordinary intelligent reader, and to render him—as all our older Brothers) call attention to a recent decision . ; authors are too tikely to become without of t cour concerning ownership of let- ter n which it was held that right of pub- | 2"’ such unnecessary propulsion—not a liv- ' vested in the writer. when liy- /28 factor in literature, but a bone for ing. and. after death. in the helt rhose Pedants to gnaw in the seminar, No sensible : * score were written are & man wishes to think of the spelling while barred fre ublishing, except by consent reading Faust’s great apostrophe: ‘ stor Was this the face that lancht a thousand shippes? And burnt the toplesse Towres of Jlium? i hine yea residence in Papua, sweete Helen, make me immortall with a kisse: \ Ket liligently collected the folk Her lips suckes forth my soule, see where it files: hich she now publishes under the Come Helen, come glue mee my soule againe. deseriptive tit’ Papuan Fairy Ilere wil | dwel, for heaven be in these lips, ete. alk (Maemiilan). Deluges, transforma- This, by calling attention to the unessential, of men, or their souls, Into beasts, '8 to reduce sublimity to quaintness, Such trous offepring of the loves of men and editing is serviceable in the case of a poet re some of the features that take like Spenser, in whom quaintness is part ! to the twilight of the mythologies, Of the legitimate attraction; to Marlowe It ‘ . " 1 frequent motive One does a grievous injustice. h meat,”’ eats in suc- We have dwelt overlong on this matter of ce on five wives. His children would spelling, not because Mr. Brooke is a par- have followed but for their eraft, and some ticular offender, but because the offence is sid of magi It was more or less the fault so widespread. For the rest his work is of the wiv for they let themselves be commendable for accuracy and judgment. wheedied into disregarding the plain warn- We note that he has given for the first ing of the wise wagtall. Generally speak- time a reprint of the 1594 quarto of “Ed- ing, the animals are closely allied to man ward II,” which offers a betterreading than and usually friendly. Some of the ta'es are the text of 1598, hitherto reproduced. With | simple fables, like that which explains how the “Hero and Leander” he gives, in small- *} re turtle got his shell. The masterplece er type, the continuation by Chapman; and n the collection is “How a Man Found His with the translation of “Ovid's Elegies” the | Wife In the Land of the Dead.” It tells how, '“Epigrams” of John Davies. For his la- borious care in collating the early and modern editions, and in noting in the ap- paratua criticus all the important varia- tions and emendations, he must have the gratitude of all scholars. We have observed only one fault in the text; in line 430 of ‘Hero and Leander,” As he ought not performe, not yet the aske, “she” should be substituted, or in some way indicated, for “the.” Mr. Brooke’s larger library edition of Marlowe will be awaited with interest. “An Admiral’s Log,” by Robley D. Evans, Rear Admiral, U. 8S. N. (Ap- pleton), necessarily lacks a little of the variety and spirit that made its predecessor, “A Sailor’s Log,” so engaging. The visit of Prince Henry of’ Prussia whose escort Admiral Evans was, takes up con- siderable space. Admiral Evans leaves no doubt that the royal guest is a good fel- low. A pleasant sequel of this service were the courtesies that Admiral Evans subse- quently received from German naval officers on many seas. On the eve of the Russo- Japanese war Admiral Evans was associated with the Pacific squadron which he later commanded. His account of the beginnings of sc‘entific target practice, of fleet ser- vice, and recreations in the Far East, of the humors of manceuvres with absurdly as- sorted squadrons, is interesting, though its appeal is chiefly to those who bave some knowledge of naval affairs of historical value is the testimeny as to the amazing infatuation of Russian army and /mavy people about the resources of Japan. Very vividly noted is an audience with the Empress of China, who talked freely of the Boxer troubles and dismissed her guest with the words, “After all my coun- try has suffered, I find she has but one friend in the world. That, Admiral, is the great country you represent.” Worth noting also is the wonderment of German officers when they saw boatloads of American sail- ors returning from sports ashore without an officer in charge. Less than an officer to a boat seemed inconceivable to the Kaiser’s captains. That American com- mander who near the close of the war be- tween China and Japan was asked to hoist the American flag in a Formosa port re- sisted a temptation, opines our author. to which a German or French captain would have succumbed. It is further suggested that had Theodore Roosevelt been President at the time, the United States would have gained a coaling station. Since Admiral Evans elsewhere admits that all our Pacific islands are sources of military weakness to us, we may be resigned to the fact that the Formosa offer was made before the strenuous life became national policy. Towards the bluejackets this book is al- ways generous. For certain “men in swivel chairs” it displays little charity. These se- dentary experts fail to provide a decent enlistment system. Sometimes they id'‘vtic- ally urge squadrons that have barely Jearn- ed the art of keeping line formation to in- dulge in battle tactics. We share the sea- man's despair at the devious councils of the bureaucrats, but confess we see no remedy. Take ten gallant captains from their quar- ter decks and immure them in Wash- ington offices, and what do they speedily become but so many “men in swivel chairs”? It was Admiral Evans's good fortune to lead the word-circling fleet as far as San Francisco, where iliness forced his resigna-

Page 23

May 12, 1910] tion of the command. Few naval men of our time have so completely and legitimately captured the people The reason is plain on every page of this the imagination of book. It has the gentlemanly plainspoken- ness that we like to think prevails in the line. It tan be pathetic, as when it touches the shadow that so unfairly dimmed the laurels of Admiral Sampson. It can be drastic, and even scornful, but it is always fair, and the expression is moderated to the tone of good company. All who wish to see the navy from the inside should read ‘t The humanitarian trend of British Liberalism may be studied very satisfac- torily in the twenty-cne addresses collect- ed by Winston Spencer Churchill, and call- and the Of old-age pensions, employment and disability and readjustment of land tenure, Mr Churchill convinced advocate. Of an Imperial tariff union, based on English pro- tection, he is a formidable foe. Though a believer in an adequate army and navy, his aim is rather to build up the manhood of the nation for the purposes of peace. He reckons the moral weight of England an important adjunct to her battleships and “Liberalism Social Problem” {Doran Co.) ed un- insurance, is a guns in maintaining international peace. The more recent speeches looked forward to a clear-cut contest with the Lords on the budget. Events have denied the drastic verdict that was hoped for on the issue of financial prerogative. Unhappily, the vote split upon a number of motives. The lure of protection and “taxing the foreigner”’— that “gospel of quacks and creed of gulls,” as Mr. Churchill justly terms it—was strong So the Lords got their lesson, to be sure, but with some- thing than exemplary emphasis. On the taxation of the land increment, Mr. Churchill is eloquent, but it is odd to see this tax proposed as a self-evident utility without the slightest mention of the erst- while agitator, Henry George. One George in the campaign have sufficient. recommend this earnest and able book to see how old- style Liberalism has been impelled upon a The noted, has come not from doc- upon the popular imagination. less recent seemed We to all who wish may mew course of paternalism. it should | pressure, trine, but from hard facts. In the face of alarming social and industrial disintegra- tion a party has had to reintegrate its principles and policy. Liberalism has been fortunate in such a weighty and moderate spokesman as Mr. Churchill. We copy a maxim which gives his temper as to that British shibboleth security of property:: “A society in which property was_ insecure would speedily degenerate into barbarism; a society in which property was absolutely secure, irrespective of all conceptions of justice in regard to the manner of its ac- quisition, would degenerate, not to bar- barism, but to death.” Dr. Julius Richter has translated, with much enlargement, Protestant complete revision and his German work in Mohammedan countries. missionary The Eng- work on lish title is “A History of Protestant Mis- sions in the Near East’’ (Revell). The work is of much interest and value to friends of the missionary endeavors of the American and Presbyterian Boards in Tur- key, Syria, Persia, and Egyp'. In no part of the world are such efforts more dif- ficult and discouraging, and in no mis- The stations have greater exhibited. irrespective of creed, may take pride in the character of the men who have conducted Protestant in Turkey and Syria, especially leaders of the educational institutions Richter has high for the the near East, founded and by for the Beirut, and He regard Nation. and All sion patience resourcefulness been Americans, missions he Dr praise col- leges sup- ported Americans ' especially ian Protestant Co'leg at Rober: a competent historian, although he with the work admiration for the still Sy: at Constantinople is of nowhere he men College careful for conceals facts, his sympathy describes, nor his who are responsible for its expanding in- flUuen*> ‘‘Goethes von Biedermann's published in 1889-1896 (Bieder- Woldemar Gespriache,”’ mann, Leipz.g), has for some time been out of print, and the first two volumes of a new edition, revised and enlarged by his son, Flodoard von Biedermann, have re- cently appeared The original edition was in ten volumes, the new one is to be in five, in spite of the fact that the amount of ma- terial is more than doubled. The new edi- tor has changed the outward form of the work, including the substitution of Latin for German type, and has reduced the num- ber of volumes in order to bring the price of the set within the reach of all who should own it. For this he deserves the spec al thanks of Goethe students it was the original aim of the elder Biedermann to include in his collection, ag nearly as possible at that date, all well authenti- cated conversations, and some of Goethe's sayings that had found a place among his posthumous wr.tings. As Biedermann’s volumes appeared, one after another, ris intention was somewhat modified. fis final plan is carried out by his son, and the new edition is to contain, in addition to con- versations, a great deal of other material bearing on the poet’s personality and work, and emanating from direct personal con- tact with him. This makes the new edition more comprehensive, and more valuable than the old, not only because the many omissions, intentional and unintentional, of the first collection have been supplied, but also because the enlarged scope of the work comprises an important body of subject- matter for which no more suitable place could be found. The editor has endeavored so to arrange his material, in the main chronologically, that it will show more or less consecutive unity. Certain items that would tend to disturb this impression, and are of interest only to specialists, have been reserved for the fifth volume, which is to contain further a list of sources, a brief commentary, and indexes. Volume I covers the period between 1754 and 1808, Volume II that from 1808 to 1823. In the collection of his material von Biedermann has re- ceived assistance from a large number of interested investigators. On the title page are mentioned the names of three scholare whose share in the work entitle them to recognition as associate editors, viz., Max Morris of Berlin, Hans Gerhard Graf of Weimar, and Leonard L. Mackall, an Amer- ican. Mr. Mackall’s connection with the work is due to his unrivalled familiarity with the literature on Goethe's relations to Fnglish-speaking foreigners. Gleason L. Archer's “Law Office and ARO Court Procedure” (Little, Brown @& Co.) is lesigned to meet “one of the gravest re- proaches of American law schools,’ that their graduates know nothing of how | practise law upon admission to the ba and to serve as a substantial basis for in struction In procedure and practice. Deta!! which to some may seem trivial, is there- tore properly included, even suggest touching the lawyer's first interview with his client and the office preliminaries before any litigious move The choice f courts and of processes : i issed briefly; the body of work | le voted, first, to the various steps from the lrawing of the writ and the various plead ngs to the marking for trial, with the va iety of incidental moves, and, secondly » the conduct of a trial from the marshal- ing of evidence and the choice of a jury lown to the summing up and to the appeal and bill of exceptions Such incidental material as the brief formal descriptions of parties to actions (pp. 56-59), the form of the various “common counts’ (p. 74), the forms of special counts (pp. 76-84), and even such a detail as a description of the caplas clause,” will be welcome to ery student of the history of pleading who does not care to be led through the case-books More than one-third of the space is g.ven up to extracts from stenographers’ minutes of actual trials, illustrative of the proper method of examining jurors and witnesses The conduct of a trial is worked out in a practical and clear manner, and much of his material is even very readable Much ise is made of the record in the recent ase of Commonwealth v Tucker but, oddly enough, it does not appear in the ndex of cases. The volume grows out of instruction in the new Suffolk School of Law, and is largely based upon the pro dure of Massachusetts as a typical om mon law” State although nearly two cases cited are from jurisdic Mas would b thirds of the tions other than sachusetts The range of usefulness much widened if, the Ma ations were u where sachusetts statuts ar cited, ade to ] jurisd rial tatute in similar ctions the States to analogous mate im the j in order to show to what ex pleading and p! the path regards abandoned atier have, ag followed or common law. We that the ond ed tion are glad to see Constant Lendoyro 8 rhe (Manila Printed t an improvemetr of Sefior no lagalog Language’ Fajardo) is great t the of 1902, as work Tagalog is the every knows, of probably the inhabitants of the Philippines, a Juan 80 over first, to be really a vernacular, as of d Don . for new 2 OOO OO0 one remain The first edi proved the unacknowledg- of of in ith present edition has 448 pages, as against not index the first; and an introduction of pp. cxvi, deal- ing with the origin of the language. Both key the exercia in two Constantinos treatis¢ must years to had source come a standard tion already ed We the other writers the inspiration note comparison Ww first that 387, counting an lacking in contain a to different editions these being To scholars, the introduction of chief interest. It cannot be fully here, but we may say that it is of sufficient importance to justify the acquisition of the by all the editions will prove noticed whole work considerable libraries

Page 24

490 The book may be got of E. C. McCullough & Co. of Manila \ Holiday with the Birds by Jean nette Marks and Julia Moody (Harpers), is fairly good children's book The infor mat ibout birds is conveyed by means logu between a party of children " du who guide them in their I icking, berrying, and other outdoor ! I In the main this talk is natural gh on tl part of the children, while th ruct of their elders imparted j manner which is simple without often t x ] Th rccompanying pictures of I rather stiffly and sometimes nons irately lrawn but thev serve to rate the text after a fashion rhe April number of the American Jour- nal of international Law opens with a paper rhom Willing Baleh on the Aretic iretic Regions and the Law of acu ng the question, recently ral 1, whether those regions are suscep- national ownership and control. Witl the mits of ten pages Mr. Balch | his own views, and opinions of t known writers on public law bear- g 0 his quest question essential ly different, he with good reason contends, wheth applied to \ntare the polar tremity of which the who have been farthest south think terra firma, or to th North Pole, where if Peary has cor- I y reported condition there is but a ma of} , Moving trom w t to east over veral thousand fathom depth of water He declare it wh no permanent oc cupation can b ! ined, no sovereignty ontrol in b required; het that the North Polar Sea at ist is free, and that, inasn ha it the other extremity there can be no permanent occupation, an asser on of dominion there would be untenable r next paper is Mr. Ion's, showing the iinty of the Cretan status; while the next three have direct reference to Ameri- in affair The first of these by Harry I Hunt liscusses§ the status of our (it Lake in the light of international iw pecially whether the effort to extend ) Federal jurisdiction beyond that in Imiralty merely in the process of which extension they have been de ominated “high seas,” is legally or con titutionally justifiable, or whether they do not, except in admiralty matters, properly com under State jurisdiction solely If they are high sea in the ordinary sense, h hou'd be open to world navigation hich admittedly they are not; for by tween the United States and Great rita the latter Power has been accorded ris of navigation through the 8t. Clair Fla Canal and Lake Michigan, which are wholly within our national limits, in return r which she permits our vessels to pass gh the W ind Canal and out through th Law rene rhe writer thinks the lew ons of our courte and the acts of our government have been more far-reaching in th t ilte than could have been fore ood that it Is essential to modify or revers ertain of them, to compel con- formity to earlier decisions and policy. The second paper, by H. 8. Knapp, relates to the real status of the Panama Canal in re- lation to neutralization It is a long pa- per treating the subject historically, with reference to several treaties, includ- ing the Clayton-Buiwer and the MHay- The Nation. [ Vol. go, No. 2341 Pauncefote; tracing the important changes | chickens they pick up. A popular error of claim and achievement, that have emerg- lis left uncorrected in the statement that ed. The third paper, having an especial bear- | ne carrier pigeon “is also sometimes ing on American policy, is that by Howard | called the homing pigeon”; for the — A gag ly Ema jearrier and the homer are different ) ine, > ine Lu- rope, tat variance wih the gonaraly [née Aes, the terinton oft rd understood doctrines of the common law | and with English and American statutes. the fact that he is an industrious and quite skilful fly-catcher, a very important char- S. Hastings Grant, who was for seventeen acteristic; while the purple martin is by years librarian of the Mercantile Library, | ,, means confined to the Southern States, as New York, and who, with Daniel C. Gilman, | tne text implies. organized the first librarians’ convention, lied om Monday at Elizabeth, N. J., The incompleteness of the selection of at the age of eighty-two. He compiled |>irds treated in the text has already New York City During the Revolution,” | been referred to. According to the index, and was a contributor to the Historical |°Dly seven warblers are mentioned, while Vagazine and one of the founders of the | ‘here are about sixty distinct species native Genealogical and Biographical Record. hes North America alone, and nearly half Dr. Horace B. Silliman, who gave Silliman na page Se So ee Hall to his alma mater, Union College, and Unites Gintes, Agnia, the tudes re had contributed to other educational and ee waeveen -—. Sone magn missionary enterprises, died at his home oightocn apecres in bie “Guide ed me ives t- Galhoes feet Weck, Ot the eae of Gees ot New England and esennte New sect four, One of his most notable benefactions Wilson's “Orntthoteny oan weet wate was his gift of about $100,000 to establish American plover, waite the present eck at Damaquete, on the Negros island of the epenks of but three American species. wens Philippines, a school after the plan of are about a dozen American sandpipers, Hampton Institute the commended during administration of Mr highly its work. Science. “Birds of the World, for Young People,” and Ella Hardcastle Charles R. Knight (Stokes), is certainly no more than its au- represent it be brief descrip- tion of such birds of the world as are usu- by thors to "a ally to be seen in zoélogical collections and in museums.” In fact, almost any museum which really deserves the name will contain in this text. “to give America, many not described And though the expressed purpose the birds of corresponding and allied forms Britain and on the Continent of Europe, and of the more re- markable and birds of other continents” is a pretty difficult undertaking, especially within the limits of the present volume (260 pages), it should seem that the selection might have been made more char- particularly Nor do we always succeeded in use of the limited space at their disposal giving “some of the and striking facts” of bird life-histories, or in supplying descrip- identification. It is specimens special attention to to species found in Great to certain interesting acteristic and representative, with respect to American birds. think making the best possiblé the authors hav in most significant in bit sharp-shinned tions which will aid insufficient, and that the the cooper’s hawk poultry”; for the first named ts a relatively bird, and practice of attacking any but chickens, a to say hawk and “are very small does not make a very small while the important fact about both of these | hawks is that they are ruthless and persist- ent destroyers of the small and very valua- ble birds, they themselves are entitled to nothing short of extermination. And the authors should have devoted at least a sentence to ex- plaining that the red-shouldered and red- tailed hawks called “chicken hawks”), by industrious destruction insectivorous wherefore or two (loosely their of harmful rodents and insects, repay the farmer many times over for the occasional This school was opened Taft, who misleading as well, | destructive to | but here we find only three mentioned Some of the colored illustrations are good, but most of them indifferent or bad; and none of them to be compared with the work of Mr. Fuertes and Mr. Horsfall, which, perhaps, has made American orni- thologists a bit fastidious. In short, though the book may serve the purpose of a rough enumeration of native and foreign birds, its actual ornithological value inconsid- erable, even for “young people.” are is A systematic survey of the Mediterranean, its biology, hydrography, meteorology, its tides, and its chemical and physical char- acteristics, has been undertaken Italian Society for the Progress of Science as its initial field of scientific research. The first number of the Bollettino del Com- itato Talassografico shows that ths com- mittee is made up of seventeen leading spe- cialists, representing the most important Italian bodies interested in the of the sea, such as the Instituto Idrografico of the Royal Navy, the Royal Geodet'c Com- mission, the Central Meteorological Bureau, the Reale Magistrato alle acque per le pro- vince Venete e di Mantova ‘a new body re- viving an efficient commission of the Vene- | tian republic, which provides for the proper |eontrol of the river and coast waters of those provinces, and which has already es- tablished a thorough system of marine ob- servations in the upper Adriatic, and is ex- tend'ng them as far as Brindisi), the Geo- dynamic and Mareographic Station, at Ischia the station of Pisciculture at Rome, | the Royal Accademia dei Lincei, and the ministries of Marine, of Education, and of Agriculture, Industry, and Commerce, with the active coédperation of their respective bureaus, The president of this society is, by tre study work undertaken by the Austrian govern- |ment, and by the Imperial zodlogical sta- | tion of Trieste, the Adriatic has been chosen jas the first fleld of research, which will be j-esumaneeed extended to all parts of the Med- iterranean. A suitably equipped boat will make four periodical cruises each year. | Preliminary excursions of two and three weeks each, were made in August and in | ex-officio, chairman of the committee. In lorder to concentrate all available re- | sources and so coéperate with similar !

Page 25

May 12, 1910] The Nation.

491

November. 1909. The plan includes the re- habilitation of the zodlogical station at Messina (on account of the peculiar im- portance of its fauna), the publication of appropriate monographs, and the issue of the Bollettino, in which will be reported accounts of these cruises and other trans- actions of this committee. An exhaustive review of previous explorations of the Med- iterranean, with a bibliography, will be printed in an early number. Within the past twenty-five years the teaching of geography has experienced a revolution. From a purely descriptive branch of science, dealing chiefly with countries as depicted on a map, it has been galvanized into new life by a wholesome infusion of geology. Mountains, plains, rivers, oceans, all the familiar features of the earth, are now regarded as the results of developmental processes, and, from this point of view, they are studied not alone for their own sakes, but also in their rela- tions to man. Foremost among the Amer- icans who have brought the change to pass is Prof. W. M. Davis, and his “Geozgraph- ical Essays,” edited by D. W. Johnson (Ginn), will forcibly bring home to every reader the large influence which he has exerted. The essays are divided into two groups, the first educational, the second physiographic. Together they constitute virtually an historical review of modern geography. The editing has been performed with excellent discrimination and judg- ment. Dr. Eugene Hodenpyl, a New York bacter- iologist, died at his home in this city last Thursday at the age of forty-six. He had made important investigations of the cause | of cancer, the results of which he published last February.

Drama.

Chantecler: Piéce en quatre actes, en | vers. Par Edmond Rostand. Import-| ed by Lemcke & Buechner, New York. It happens rarely in an age like the} present that dramatic imagination be-| <omes truly dynamic. The playwright, along with the artisan, hugs his fact, in a desire to present a life which shall | seem real. More and more the stage has | been usurped by literal studies of social | and political problems; and the sporad- | ie essays into thoughts and feelings of larger reach have issued usually from the authors themselves in the form of) mere fantasies. Under such conditions to attempt seriously to regulate the | present-day spirit by a drama in verse) with the power of poetry as its central idea will strike the multitude as quixot- ic. Such nevertheless is the plan and purpose of “Chantecler.” For “Chantecler” is not just a minute study of poultry life, nor a mere fan- tasy derived from transitory likenesses between bird and man. It is a direct gaze at the possibilities of human na- ture when touched by imagination. From this the reader is never for a mo- ment distracted, even by the great in- terest which the author has effected in

‘the creatures themselves. Chantecler | is a cock,a very life-like cock, who pre- fers a barley-corn to a pearl; but above all he is a poet. In his song lies the secret of the day-spring and of the changing beauty of the landscape. As the pigeon says of him: C'est Celui dont le cri perce l'horizon bleu Comme une aiguille d'or qui toujours enfilée Coudrait au bord du ciel le bord de la vallée. C'est le Coq! To the sun he himself chants: Tu prends un arbre obscur et tu l’apothé- oses! And later he confides to the hen-pheas apt, Quand on sait regarder et tout. soullrir, on sait This is the language of a poet who be lieves in tion. M. Rostand’s choice of the cock to ful fil this union of realism and idealism was a happy one. Traditionally, the cock has been a homely companion of man, well planted on earth; and tradi- tionally, too, he has been the poet's bird, with his eye much on heaven. This fitness of the cock as a literary device seems to have come to M. Rostand as a real vision. In the barnyard he observed a complete miniature world, the omnipotence of imagina |containing manifold foibles, poses, and ambitions; and in the cock both a prac- tical ruler and a transformer. We may now follow tlie play in some detail. The curtain starts to rise when a voice cries out, “Pas encor!” and the director of the theatre rushes out to pre- pare the audience for the strange scene about to be presented. The author is evidently very much in earnest and does not wish the audience to be sur- prised into a guffaw. The sounds which issue from behind the curtain are in- terpreted by the director to mean that it is Sunday on a farm, and that the human members of the household are leaving for a féte. A few more preparations, and finally the curtain rises. Meeting the eye is the clutter of a complete barnyard. Chickens, ducks, turkeys are chattering and taking attitudes. In addition, there is a blackbird in a cage among the vines, an old hen brooding in a market basket, a cat asleep on the wall, and a watch-dog chained to his kennel. Chan- tecler for the moment is absent, but we are not long left in doubt as to his po sition in the play; for a pigeon soon lights on the roof of the adjoining stable to inquire about the cock’s fa mous voice, and to add his own testi mony. Amid all the distractions of the barnyard the pigeon returns again and again to the matter with his pretty, beckoning “Poule blanche, vral que " or glorifies the cock, as in the following words, est-ce sa volx si rouge Qu’A son cocorico le coquelicot bouge Comme s'il s’entendait appeler par son nom After this excellent introduction Chan tecler enters. He is full of the wonder of the sun, and manages in spite of in terruptions to complete an ode, begin ning, Tol qui s@ches les pleurs des moind graminées, Qui fais d'une fleur morte un vivant pa pillon, Lorsqu’on voit, s'effeuillant comme ds destinées, rrembler au vent des Pyrénées Les a id rs 1 Rouss ] idor Soleil It has already become evident that in Chantecler’s crowing there lies a d secret. The hens are piqued into fan cying that it concerns his preference fo! one of them, but he puts them off with a “chut!” and keeps his own counsel As the into a spirited discussion, of which the act proceeds, we are plunged chief participants are the blackbird and Patou, the dog, Chantecler being for the moment but the moderator. A though the language is for the most part kept beautifully objective, it is clea that the discussion has to do with the power of poetic imagination. To Patou, it is given to enounce the elements of Chantecler’s as yet unconscious creed With the cock he shares fundamental! traits, especially a fondness for the soil and for the sun. He is a declared guardian of faith; he believes in the established order of things, and sesses a humble but courageous optim- ism. As such, he is an enemy of the blackbird, the smart, cynical, up-to-date pretender, who is termed offensive, be cause “on ne sait pas ce qu'il est’; he is black, and that means a negative bBe- ing, too timid to commit himself to colors. His black costume also provokes the charge that he is the agile undertak er of faith. The blackbird, lacking soul, sets up his rest on esprit, and is ever busy “with having the air of not being a fool.” Thus far, it is from the dog, chiefly, that we learn of Chantecler's outlook, though, to be sure, this assumes perspective and certainty by the vieill: poule, who fittingly speaks pithy folk lore. Upon her is the wisdom of the ages; she approves of her brave son. The development of the cock’s creed begins with the entrance of the hen- pheasant, who, in great fear of a pur suing poacher, now flies over the wall to seek protection. She is the adven- turess with the plumage of the Orient, just the creature to attract and give range to the dawn-loving Chantecler, who before long admits to Patou that “c'est une poule avec laquelle on cause! darkness falls, and his hens in the coop, and the hen-pheas ant In Patou’s kennel. Both heroine are obviously disturbed pos- Chantecler hous hero and

Page 26

492 The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2341 x = —— The second act is the most lyric and the most intense of the four. Here Chan- tecler confides to the pheasant his secret, which is that unless he crows the sun will not rise; that he, for some strange reason, in place of any other cock, has been chosen guardian of the day: Je me trouve indigne de ma gloire. pour chasser la Pourquol m’‘a-t-on choisi nuit noire? He now proceeds to exhibit his métier. At each cocorico a glory is cast over some feature of the landscape, and the world becomes vibrant with light and love: fais mieux chanter Collabore prés de lul.) Tu Viens plus prés (bond!issant Chantecler. me La Faisane Je t'aime! (‘hantecler. Oui! tous les mots que tu me dis tout bas Deviennent aussit6ét plus de soleil la- bas! La Faisane. Je t'aime! Et si tu dis seulement: “Je Chantecler. t'adore!”’ Je vais dorer d'un coup la montagne! La (hors d’elle.) Eh bien... Faisane. dore Chantecler. (lancant son cri le plus écla- tant.) (La montagne s'est dorée.) Cocorico! still clearer by the concluding scene, | in which the blackbird is scored for his prosaic outlook: Chantecler. Tu n’as pas vu trembler les cimes écarlates? Le Merle. Pendant que tu chantais je re- gardais tes pattes! The third act requires but slight men- tion, though its cleverness is supreme. The guinea-fowl’s five o’clock (A. M.) re- ception—a lundi—held in the kitchen- garden, under the sanction of the scare- crow who is supposed to keep away all but the very select, is, of course, a satire on modish patronage of empty titles and wanton display. Despite the harrowing features of the reception, chief among them being the duel to which Chante- cler is provoked by the game-cock, the guinea-fowl exclaims to her young, after the others have gone: C'est la plus belle féte encor qu'il y ait eue! The fourth act is scarcely behind the second in beauty. Chantecler, disgusted by the treachery and prosiness of his kin, has gone to the forest with the pheasant. Now deeply in love with him, the pheasant is jealous of his love for the dawn. She urges him to go one day without crowing. The way is clearing "|rapidly for the great disillusion, which is La Faisane. Ah! une pente engour- die Glisse un premier rayon. sur Chantecler. (joyeusement.) Tiens! je te le dédie! well motived by the pheasant’s profound jealousy and not by any mere whim on her part. She will wait until the night- ingale sings, and Chantecler may be _ 80 absorbed that he will forget to crow; J’écoute se lever le jour dans ta poitrine! J’aime avoir entendu d’abord dang tes poumons Ce qui sera plus tard des pourpres sur les monts! La Faisane, his belief in his control of the sun will be shattered, and his love will then be consecrated to her alone. The first part ‘of the plan works well. Chantecler, a, poet but no out-and-out egoist, is rav- ished by the nightingale’s superior note, - and hearkens while the East becomes Je fais mon devoir en te ren- dant plus belle: Je redore a la foils mon vallon et ton alle! Chantecler. To the pheasant he explains that the other cocks, who now begin to crow, get their cue from him; he is the first to They believe in the light when they can see it, but crow. J'ai chanté dans du noir. Ma chanson s'éleva dans l’ombre, et la premilére. Cest Ia nult qu'il est beau de croire A la lumilére! Once the sun has risen and the nolses of the day have begun, Chantecler is overcome by the thought of his great re- sponsibility: shall he be able to repeat the miracle to-morrow? The beauty of the scene has for the moment convinced the pheasant of Chante- cler’s power Here, again, as in the first act, the allegory is transparent. It is a question of poetic Imagination, and of the extent to which a poet can create the world in which he lives, if he believes himself to be truly inspired. The point is made worldly-wise dappled. He is further distracted by) the sudden death of the nightingale, who is shot by the poacher. The sun | has risen, and the pheasant turns tri-| umphantly to the cock: On est tout pour un ccur, rien pour ua horizon! But though crushed at first, he soon re- | covers and is inspired to a new and) safer belief by the note of another night- ingale, perhaps more beautiful than the first, and by a voice saying: Il faut un rossignol, toujours, dans la forét! To which Chantecler adds, perhaps a bit too morally: Et, dans l’'Ame, une fol si bien habituée Qu’ elle y revienne encore aprés qu’on I’a tuée! But the pheasant persists: Mais si tu ne fals pas se lever le matin? Chantecler. C'est que je suis le Coq d'un soleil plus lointain! Mes cris font A la Nuit qu’lls percent sous ses volles Ces blessures de jour qu'on prend pour des étolles! Chaque ferme a son Coq qui chante dans sa cour. | No longer can he believe himself to be sole guardian of the day; his horizon has broadened, he is one of many who together have power to illumine and recreate. On “Chantecler,” M. Rostand has ob- viously bestowed infinite love and pa- tience. His virtuosity is, of course, well known; but only inspiration and num- berless revisions could in this case have effected such keen manipulation of de- tail. The reader is again and again thrilled by the natural way in which simple actions are swerved to a high purpose. The cock, believing that his crow expresses the cry of the earth for the light, takes pains to scratch the gravel away so as to come into close contact with the soil before he utters a sound. Even the welter of divertisse- ment, such as the plot by the creatures of night against Chantecler, and the capers of the toads, rabbits, and others in the forest, is held to such strict ac- count by the central theme that one readily forgives numerous examples of wilful wit in the form of puns, slang, and a too wide allusiveness. There is splendid variety in the midst of insis- tent purpose. ' Mrs. Marie Walsh, a playwright and nov- elist who was widely known nearly a gen- eration ago, died in Brooklyn on Sunday. She began her literary career as writer for a Boston weekly, and dramatized a num- ber of novels, including “Three Times Dead,” “Griffith Gaunt,” “Archie Lovell,” and the novel on Mormon life, “Wife of Two Husbands.” She produced the two plays “Who is She?” and “Our City.” Musie. By E. Markham Chas. Scribner’s The Story of Opera. Lee. New- York: Sons. $1.25 net. Musical Sketches. By Elise Polko. New York: Sturgis & Walton Co. $1.25 net. Appendix A of Mr. Lee’s book consists of thirty-two pages of brief paragraplis on operatic composers, singers, and con- ductors. The names are arranged chro- nologically, and Mascagni, who was born in 1864, is at the end of the list. In that same year, however, was born Eugen |D’Albert, whose operas have been sung more frequently in Germany in recent years than those of any of the masters, excepting Wagner and Verdi; yet he is nowhere mentioned in this volume. The composers still living who kre deemed worthy of notice in it are ‘be Austrian Goldmark and two Germans: Humper- dinck and Strauss; seven Italians: Boito, Puccini, Mascagni, Leoncavallo, Cilea, Mancinelli, Franchetti; seven Frenchmen: Saint-Saéns, Massenet, Mes- ‘sager, Bruneau, d'Indy, Charpentier, and

Page 27

May 12, 1910] The Nation. 493 = — eee Debussy; seven Englishmen: Mackenzie, Stanford, Cowen, Bunning, Corder, De Lara, McCunn; and one Englishwoman, Ethel Smyth. The author's comments on these are, on the whole, sane and unbiassed by patriotic or other preju- dices. One reason, he thinks, why op- era is not so successful in England as elsewhere is that “it is not the hobby and delight of the man in the street, as it is in many Continental countries.” The worshippers of Strauss and Debussy will bear him a grudge for saying re- peatedly that since the time of Wagner there has been nothing which can lay claim to having advanced the operatic art; but he is right. Although the author is a “Mus. Doc., Cantab.,” his volume is not a scholarly treatise like Apthorp’s “The Opera, Past and Present,” or Streatfeild’s “The Op- era.” Its appeal is to a class of readers who desire a brief and lucid summary of operatic history, with chapters on the most notable schools. The three re- formers, Monteverdi, Gluck, and Wag- ner, are discussed in one chapter, and Wagner has another by himself. The chief opera houses in the world are de- scribed, and hints are given on the art of listening to an opera in such a way as to get the most pleasure from it. In one appendix, information is imparted as to the pecuniary aid granted to oper- atic schemes in various countries, and another gives a bird’s-eye view of the instruments used in the orchestras of composers of different periods of opera. A surprising number of English writ- ers harbor the delusion that the nomina- tive plural of Leitmotiv is Leitmotiven. Mr. Lee is one of them; he also em- bellishes the first e in Delibes with a superfluous accent; he allows Humper- dinck and Seidl to masquerade as Ham- perdinck and Siedl, and takes the liberty of hyphenating César Cui. The erroneous statement is made that there is in Puccini’s operas no definite char- acterization by means of leading mo- tives; the story of “Hansel and Gretel” ig attributed to Andersen, instead of to Grimm; and the author forgot “Siegfried” | when he assertea that “Die Meistersing- er” is the one work of Wagner embody- ing humorous touches. Finally, why per- sist in writing Monteverde, in disre- gard of the fact that the 113 autograph letters of that Italian reformer which have come down to us are, without ex- ception, signed Monteverdi? A “Mus. Doc., Cantab.,” ought to know such things. There are some things in musical his- tory and biography which nobody knows, but which many would like to know—minute details regarding certain famous episodes in the lives of the great masters. Where facts fail, the imagina- tion comes to the rescue. Elise Polko’s “Musical Sketches” are made up of such episodes, historically correct for the most part, but embellished and vitalized | national | by her fancy. Frau Polko was a sister of the well-known African explorer Edu- ard Vogel; she knew Mendelssohn, was \for a time an opera singer, and then devoted herself to writing books, mostly musical stories. For such there is al- ways a demand. Her “Musikalische Miarchen” appeared in three volumes (1852-1903), and have passed through fifteen editions. The English version in- cludes twenty-five of the best of them; Bach, Gluck, Mozart, Mendelssohn, Schu- bert, Paganini, Handel, Schumann, are among the masters one meets on inti- mate footing in these pages. Frau Polko has been decried as a sentimentalist, and undoubtedly there are oversenti- mental, “gushy” paragraphs in her books; yet this is just what many like, while those who do not, will frequently come across touches of genuine feeling which bring tears to the eyes. As a means of kindling enthusiasm in young folks for the great composers, nothing could be better than these “Sketches.” Luciano Conterno, the bandmaster, died last week at his home in this city, at the age of seventy, He was a native of Fe- rante, France, enlisted in the United States navy at the age of nine, as a cabin boy and drummer, served in Commodore Perry's Japanese expedition, and enlisted in 1860 in the Seventh Regiment, with which he served during the civil war. After the war he became bandmaster of the Twenty-third Regiment, and from 1873 until 1894 he was bandmaster at the Brooklyn navy yard. He was bandmaster of the Old Guard in 1882 and of the Ninth Regiment from 1883 until about 1898, when he retired. Art. THE PITTSBURGH EXHIBITION. By unanimous consent this season's dis- play, which opened on Monday of last week with an appropriate show of Presidential pomp, is more discriminating in choice and more truly representative of inter- artistic activity than any of its predecessors. While there are on these walls no canvases of transcendent merit, such as Whistler’s Sarasate, Ménard’s Judz- ment of Paris, or Simon’s Evening in the Studio, which were among the triumphs of former seasons, there is, in compensa- tion, greater variety than ever before, and a higher general average of merit The distinguishing feature of these Pitts burgh exhibitions is their international character, their placing side by side th best current American and European pain:- ing, and it would be difficult to conceive of any plan more stimulating to native production. It is clearly impossible to cover the entire field every year, and if, on th occasion, certain countries, notably dinavia, Austria-Hungary, and Spain, are slighted, it is with particular pleasure that one notes the fine representation accorded England, France, Belgium, and Russia. . The display begins with a single room 4: voted to the shimmering, sun-flecked palett: of Childe Hassam. The thirty-five subjects Scan ,of street } tists. by America’s most consistent exponent of impressionism show him in all his trams'- tions, from the spirited and sensitive painter scenes in the vein of De Nittis or Raffaéili, to the vibrant symphonist, who attains his climax in his views of turquoise sea and sun-bleached headland Considerable local interest, count of their handsome not a little general curiosity, manifested in the awards, which this year and, on ac- monetary value, is always have fallen to William Orpen, Karl Ander son, and Edward F. Rooks While it is the special privilege of the public to dis agree with the official jury, there should be scant reason for objecting to the d sion in the first two instances. Mr. Orpen, who, though an Irishman has lately permitted himself to be elected an associate of the Royal Academy, has here added to his prestige by capturing the first prize with his whimsical and cleverly has dled Portrait of the Artist, seen at last summer's Venice International The pi ture reveals a crispness of rendering, a truth of value, and a charm in its tonal modulations which readily justify its se lection for initial honors. And, finally, Mr Orpen has not failed to add a legitimate spice of humor to this version of his none too classic appearance, the immense pyra midal green hat not only fine color note, but also giving a welcom: touch of character. Equally satisfactory is the choice of Karl constituting «4 Anderson’s Idlers: August, for secoad place. Exhibited earlier in the season at the Madison Gallery, and also at Knoed ler’s, New York, this sumptuous piece of outdoor painting easily places Mr. Ander- son in the front rank of our younger ar- The surface is loose and broken, the coloring singularly fresh and vibrant, with lovely variations in green, yellow, and lilac, and the flesh tints suggested. As it is only a third prize winner, it ts unnecessary to take Mr. Rooke’s Laurel, which has already been seen at the Acad- emy of Design, with particular solemnity. Frankly, however, it is hardly a prize pic- ture. Though decorative in design, it lacks variety in its colors, and is also wanting in aerial perception. With those who re- ceive honorable mention, including Joseph Oppenheimer of Berlin, Charles Morris Young, Louls Betts, and Daniel Garber, no- tably the last, there can be little quarrel Mr. Garber’s highly specialized vision and individual sense of tone are evinced in his purpls, charmingly pictures, entitled respectively Horses and Hills of Byram He is of the most original of the newer men, and one who does not fail himself with increasing precision at appearance While there are certain notable portraits, that exhibition is in this particular province The likeness of President Taft, by which claims immediate at- the first large is more superficial than solid or masterful, than intensive. It is fluent, + ready Valencian’s work, but two one to assert each it cannot be said the strong seated Sefior Sorolla, tention on entering room, more extensive as is all the is fundamentally lacking in analysis Mr. Sargent, who Is represented by por traits of Miss Brice and Paine, is scarcely more successful than his Span Charles J ish colleague; the former work Is totally lacking in beauty of coloration, and the latter, while restrained and thoughtful

Page 28

494 The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2341 by no means equal to the painter’s best | average. As a matter of fact, aside from Gari Melchers’s bust of Arthur T. Aldis and Frank Duveneck’s early likeness of John W. Alexander in brown velvet jacket and billycock hat, it is not the older but the younger artists who show the most vitality in this category. Miss Beaux confines her- self to two unconvincing costume studies Chase’s best efforts are expended on interiors Mr. Wiles’s Girl and Hors is conspicuously ineffective. In compensation, however, Mr. MacCameron and Mr. Betts, among the Americans, and ; ° Cottet, Augustus E. John, and the Fechin, all display individuality in their Mr ) His \olas power and yntributions lark in tive there is a Cottet’s which only the talent could restricted a compass. 4 similar severity is found in Mr, John's of William Nicholson, together a touch of that turgid strength which eldom absent the work of one to-day ranks as the most original force contemporary British art. The Portrait of William Nicholson was among the successes of last summer's ex- hibition of the New English Art Club in Suffolk Street, and loses none of its inter- est after the lapse of nearly a year. Yet it Is the Slav, Nicholas Fechin, with his Portrait of Mlle. Lapojnikov, who has attained the only distinctive triumph in this field, and seldom has the American public beheld a more individual and char- acteristic presentment. Fechin, who was born in Kazan, is a veritable mujik in art, possessing all the crude strength, directness of vision, and poignant depth of feeling so typical of the native-born Russian. He is absolutely un- tone, Monsieur Hat, rained rhough it tis in ibdued ichne the Rose and 50 with ibtl within rest achieve Portrait with is from who in heaven. God the Father extends symbolical- ly to Mary the rod of Ahasuerus, great doc- | tors bear witness to the stainless origin of ithe Virgin, whileakneeling monk, whom our |author identifies with Duns Scotus, thesub- | tle doctor, sees the vision in the sky. The four predella panelsrecount legends brought about by prayer to the Immaculate. The picture was painted for Maddelena Stiatta to adorn a chapel of the Conception some time after 1512. Iconographically Francia followed a picture formerly in S. Frances- co, now in the Gallery of Lucca, which Mr. Carmichael dates a matter of thirty years earlier. Opinions might differ as to the period of this which is regarded as, representation of | the earliest pictorial the theme. not much antedating the end of the century. Piero di Cosimo’s picture of similar compo- sition in §S. Francesco, Fiesole, is dated 1480, but Mr. Carmichael justly doubts the antiquity of the inscribed date. It seems likely to us that theré is an error for 1490, with which year the stylistic character of the Fiesole piece tallies very well. In any case we have in these three pictures types of the earliest form of the Immaculate Con- ception in art—a form far more mystical and admirable than that operatic version which the Spanish Jesuits of the seven- teenth century have made stereotyped. Mr. Carmichael’s researches are perhaps less novel than he imagines. Ten years ago, for example, Fritz Knapp saw through the blunder about the Fiesole picture and gave it its proper title. But Mr. Carmichael has studied the subject more deeply and loving- | ly than the other critics, and gives for the | first time a popular account of the fate of this subject in early art. He hints at fur- ther studies, which we shall await eagerly. Leonardo’s Madonna of the Rocks is for him an Immaculate Conception. This it can only be by an egregiously masked symbol- To the present writer it seems | a belated Ghirlandaioesque work, perhaps | languages at Syracuse University, and or- ganized the College of Fine Arts there, of which he was dean in 1873-1893. He pub- lished “Art Museums in America” and “Modern Languages in Education.’ Julien Dupré, the French animal painter, died recently in Paris, at the age of fifty- eight. Medals were awarded him in the Salons of 1880, 1881, and 1889. In the Lux- embourg are his Vache Blanche and Les Fauchers de Lucerne, which have frequently been engraved and lithographed. Finance. — PLACING OUR BONDS ABROAD. Under heavy and continuous selling, the New York stock market broke at the opening of last week, declines ruu- ning to 3% in Amalgamated Copper, 3% in Reading, 2% in Union Pacific, and 2 in St. Paul, all of these stocks touching on Tuesday their lowest prices for 1910. In the middle of the week came an up- ward turn of equal violence; Amalga- mated Copper recovered 3% points, Reading 5%, Union Pacific 6%, and St. | Paul 4%, while Steel common, which had dropped off 1% point in the two earlier days, advanced 4%. Interrupted |by the reaction which, last Friday, oc- ‘curred in every financial market of the \world on the news from the King of ‘England, strength was again displayed ‘on our own Stock Exchange, in the pres- ent week. | This rather remarkable change from discouragement to optimism resulted immediately from last week’s spectacu- lar fall in foreign exchange. We had just completed the shipment of $30,000,- spoiled by Occidental training, nor does he|ism, but it would be hazardous to predict |000 gold to London; yet sight sterling betray the sophisticated assurance of Alex- ander Benois, Constantin Somoff, and cer- tain of the St. Petersburg school. Less the mellowness of his manner and the fer- further outflow. brilliant and forceful than Maliavin, he is equally racial in his inspiration and more subtle and reserved in his chromatic scale. The likeness of this plain but appealing young peasant woman is supplemented by even more free and searching Por- trait of my Father, dressed in rough cap and coarse Mnen blouse. It is such canvases as these which give significance to the exhibition as a whole and emphasize that international note which is the proud of the Carnegie Institute. Cc. aon watchword B. We doubt if any Mving writer but Mont- gomery Carmichael could have made a tol- book out of the material in “Fran- cla'’s Masterpiece: An Essay on the Be- ginnings of the Immaculate Conception in Art’ (Dutton). He has unriddled to the end the secret of Francia’s famous altar- plece in 8. Frediano, Lucca. Most writers have called this loosely a coronation or an umption, and have seen in the predella compositions legends of the Augustinian order. Mr. Carmichael shows that it rep- resents the Immaculate Conception as for- mulated by Franciscag lovers of the doc- Esther, the elect spouse, was re- the antitype of the erable ar trine garded as queen of that the view is wrong. Readers of Mr. | Carmichael do not need to be reminded of vor of his religious sentiment. The sim- | plicity of his conviction wins those to whom his point of view is profoundly alien. He makes the whole past of a picture and | a doctrine most appealing. One lives with the great doctors who held this magnificent bit of Quixotic reasoning before a reluc- tant chureh until the dogma attained tol- eration and acceptance. One sees with sym- pathy forgotten monks who wrote out the first offices for which pious souls were wait- ing. Such is the winning effect of Mr. Car- michael’s artful artlessness. In vain you steel your heart against him. You disap- prove his complacent orthodoxy and long for his next book. Dr. George Fisk Comfort, founder and director of the Syracuse Museum of Fine Arts, died last Thursday at the age of sev- enty-six. He was graduated at Wesleyan University in 1857, studied art, philosophy, and history in Europe in 1860-65, and in 1868-72 was lecturer on Christian art and archmology at the Drew Theological Semi- nary. He was an organizer of the American Philological Association in 1869, and of the Central New York Society of Artists in 1901, and was one of the founders of the Metropolitan Museum of Art. In 1872 he became professor of wsthetics and modern ‘rates, at 4.88%, or close to the normal |gold export point, had been threatening On Monday of last week, however, the rate dropped down | to 4.87%; on Wednesday, a violent de- ‘cline brought it to 4.865%, the interna- | | tional parity. This meant, either that capital had been transferred in quan- tity from Europe to our money market, \or else that we had suddenly sold to Bu- rope something whose value on ex- change had offset the heavy adverse bal- ‘ance on merchandise account. In response to the eager inquiry in | Wall Street, as to the specific cause for ‘the sharp movement of exchange in |this country’s favor, statements were at once put out that negotiations for plac- ‘Ing new American securities at Paris /had been so far successful as to insure | the sale of $70,000,000 to $100,000,000 of our bonds to that European market. /Three inferences were drawn immediate- ly: one, that our own overburdened and congested bond market would be sub- stantially relieved; another, that the gold outflow from New York would be ‘checked, and, finally, that the enlisting of Paris capital in our market would ‘make needless any recourse to the Lon-

Page 29

os a tn ’ May 12, 1910] The Nation. aon money market, which had troubles” of its own. Rumors were rapidly dis- seminated as to the general unlocking of the French treasure-vaults for the benefit of New York; it was even alleg- ed, in Wall Street and in the Paris ca- bles, that the negotiations for listing Steel common on the Bourse had been resumed. All this was far astray from the ac- tual facts. Some of the loans included in the announcements of last week’s Paris negotiations had been placed in that city weeks ago; for others, negotia- tions were not finally concluded until this week. Instead of half-a-dozen new issues footing up $70,000,000 or $100,- 000,000, two bond issues only—$10,000,- 000 of the “Big Four” Railway and $50,- 000,000 of the Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul—have at this writing been an- nounced as newly placed with Paris. Both of these, when price and commis- sions are included in the reckoning, will probably be found to have been rather costly operations, and the same com- ment may be made, with greater em- phasis, on the sale to London of part of a $40,000,000 issue of Baltimore and Ohio three-year notes. The fact remains that the enlisting of foreign capital on such a scale oc- curs most opportunely, alike for the home money market, which is not in a position to spare the capital required; for the home bond market, which has found difficulty in disposing of such se- curity issues as it has already subscrib- ed for, and for the foreign exchange market, which has been driven repeated- ly, by the abnormal excess of imported merchandise, to heighis where gold ex- ports of unusual proportions were neces- sitated. In all these respects, the suc- cesstul comp'etion of the Paris negotia- tions is a matter in which American finance had important stake. While welcoming, however, this relief to an awkward situation, it is quite as well to point out also that it is not the relief which the permanent interests of the situation need. It is one thing fora young, poor, and undeveloped country to rely on foreign capital to sustain its in- dustries, and to accept such foreign as- sistance in the shape of merchandise imports which far exceed the value of the exports which the country’s strug- gling producers can contribute. That was the case of the United States during the fifties and the sixties, when our import trade always ran heavily beyond our ex- port shipments, and when stocks and bonds of our government, States, cities, and railways were sold as a matter of course in Europe But it is a very different thing for a rich and powerful producing _ state, whose natural resources have made it one of the greatest of all contributors to the outside consuming world’s sup- plies of grain, cotton, metals, minerals, and general merchandise, so to pervert the level of prices, and to hold so ob- stinately to the perverted level, that it arrests its own export trade, needlessly stimulates its imports, and then appeals to the foreign money markets to help it out of the consequent dilemma. Not only is this process, on the contemplated scale, an absurd anomaiy for the Amer- ica of to-day, but it is sure in the end to aggravate the very evils which it professes to avert. If there were no other reason for this conclusion, there would be the fact that dividends and interest on these foreign-held securities will be added to the sum total of our annual European obligations. It may still be regarded as certain that the existing problems in our trade sit- uation and our financial markets must work out their own solution. That such a solution will come, eventually, through the commodity markets themselves, there can be little doubt. In the meantime, all of us will be grateful if the imme- diately embarrassing aspects of the sit- uation shall turn out to have been re- moved by the French negotiations. BOOKS OF THE WEEK Adams, E. D. British Interests and Activi- ties in Texas, 1838-1846 Baltimore Johns Hopkins Press. $1.50 Angell, E. D. Play. Boston: Little, Brown $1.50 net. Bangs, J. K. Songs of Cheer Boston: Sherman, French $1 net jeach, R. Going Some Harper. $1.25 jergquist, N. W. Swedish Folk Dan Barnes Co. $1.50 net. Brandt, W. Die jiidischen Berlin: A. Tépelmann Browning’s Men and Women, 1855. Frowde Bruce, H. Letters from Malabar and on the Baptismen Way. Dutton, $2 net Burdett’s Hospitals wand Charities, 1910 London: Scientific Press Carlyle’s Essay on Burns. Oxford Plain Texts. Frowde Catalogue of the Flowering Plants and Ferns of Connecticut Hartford, Cont State of Conn Chance, F. L. The Bride and the Pennant Chicago: Laird & Lee. 60 cents Church, V. Commencement Days: Boston: Page & Co Clarke, F. W A Atomic Weights. enlarged. stitution. Cockerell, T. D. A. Scales of the Mormyr:d Fishes; Scales of the African Characinid A Novel Recalculation of the Third ed Revised and Washington Smithsoniar Fishes. Washington: Smithsonian IJ: tution Crane A M A Search After Ultimat Truth. Rostor Lothrop, Lee & Shepard Co $1.50 net Denney, J. V American Publie Addr Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co Department of Agriculture Year-Book 1999. Washington Dewey, J The Influenc of Darwin on Philosophy. Holt. $1.40 net Dickens’ A Christmas Carol I ensis style of phonography. Cin t Phonographic Institute Co Draper, A. 8S. The Rescue of Cuba Pr larged edition Silv Burdett Dudley, C. H And This is War. Coct Pub. Co. Eggleston. G. Cc. The History of the Con federate War Sturgis & Walton $4 Ethnological Dictionary f the Navah Language Saint Michaels, Ariz.: Frar an Fathers Feuchtersleben. E. V. Health and Sueges- the Dietetics of the tion Mind Trans by L. Lewisohn. Huebsch. $1 net Foeht, H. W. The American Rural School Macmillan $1.25 net a 495 Franklin, F. The Life of Daniel Coit Gil- man. Dodd, Mead. $3.50. Gompers, S. Labor in Europe and America. Harper. $2 net. Greene, M. L. Among Charities Pub. Co. $1.25. —— — School Gardens Hardy's Under the Greenwood Tree. Har- per. $1.25. Harris, M. H. Modern Jewish History. Bloch Pub. Co. Hart, A. B. The Southern South. Apple- ton. $1.50 net. Hewlett, M. Letters to Sanchia Upon Things as They Are. (Extracted from Open Country.) Scribner. 90 cents net Islandica. Annual relating to Iceland and the Fiske Icelandic Collection in Cor- nell University Library. Vol. III. Sagas of the Kings, by H. Hermannsson. Ithaca, N. Y Johnston, H. Africa, pository. Joly, J. Radioactivity and Geology Nostrand, $3 net. Jowett, J. H. Our Co. 25 cents net. Kautsky’s The Class Struggle. Britain Across the Seas London: National Society's De- Van Dead Revell Blessed Trans. by “* E,. Bohn. Chicago: Kerr & Co 50 cents. Ker, W. P. On the History of the Ballads 1100-1500. Proceedings British Academy Frowde. Lafargue’s Evolution of Property from Sav- agery to Civilization Chicago: Kerr & Co 50 cents oth rlog, Ss The Girl Croft. Trans. by V. §S Little, Brown. $1.50. Latta, N American Producer Ga Pra tice and Industrial Gas Engin Nostrand. $6 net. wton, W The Boy Aviators in Nica ragua Hurst & Co. 50 cents Letters to His Holiness Pope Pius X a Modernist. Chicago Open Court, $1.25 Lyon, D. E. How to Keep Bees for Profit Macmillan. $1.50 net Macaulay’s Lays of Ancient Rome with Ivry, and the Armada; Essay on Baco Oxford Plain Texts Fr MacKinlay, M. 8. The Singing Voice and Its rraining. Dutton. $1.25 net Marvin, F. R. The Excur f Lover. Boston: Sherman, French $1.50 from the Marsh Howard i owd: sions of a Boo Philosophy. Tran & Co $1 Gospel and the Mod $1.50 net Makers of Sorrow Trans. from the Fren Funk & Wagnal $1 Marx’s Poverty of H. Quelch. Chicago: Kerr lathews, 8S. The Man. Macmillan legari, D rs of Joy M. Lindsay. Vérimée’s La Chr mique du Rég Charles IX Ed by \ I B I ow le il, J. 8 Letters Edited with H. S. R. Elliot. 2 vols Longmans, Gr Mill, S. J., Principles of Political Econo Ed. by W. J. Ashley. Longmans, Gree: Montgomery, H B. Western Women Eastern Lands Macmillan: $1.50 net Morrissey, J. W Noted Men and Wo Klebold Press Mozans, H. J Up the Orinoco and Down t Magdalena D. Appleto Financia’. Buy and sell bills of letters exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money Credit International Cheques of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York on all foreign points; make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits available in all parts of the world. also Certificates

Page 30

The: Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2341

496 N. C. The Berkeley: Univ. of California. Nesbit. E. The House of Arden: a Story for Children. Dutton. $1.50. New International Year Book, Dodd, Mead Nicolls, W. J Philadelphia: Oxford English Round-nosed Payne, W. M sts Holt Pillsbury, W. B The soning Appleton Poe’s Raven, Longfellow’s Miles Standish, Whittier's Edited for school by Chicago: Scott, Foresman ¢, M. D The Gilded Chair: leton. $1.50 i i Dreams Nelson, snound 1909. The Daughters of Suffolk Lippincott. Dictionary. Vol. VIIL— Ryze. Frowde. $1.25. Leading American Essay- Psychology of Rea- $1.50 net Courtship of Snow-bound use G. Greener. a Novel. Boston: Poet Lore rt on Education in Alaska. Washing- Gov. Printing Office. B 4 Saint of the Poston R. Badger Twentieth Cen- $1.50 Henry Holt & Company 3% LEADING AMERICANS W. P. TRENT. Each $1.75 net 1 by John Erskine’ s Novelists the of ‘The Elizabethan Wil- Har- kden Brown, Cooper, Hawt and Bret Harte. horne, $444446644466666664664606 Wm. Morton Payne’s Essayists uthe The Greater English Century.” introduction of the Emerson pre- survey minor ‘ving, e separate and cal treatment. R. M. Johnston’s Soldiers By the author of Napoleon, ete. rom Wash rr f thirteen generals f Mr. and Mrs. Beebe’s Our Search for a Wilderness Beet irator of Birds in N. Y. cal Park of “Th ts and Function.” With net and author wildernesses in t will be very to compete with Mr. Bee in anything except the purely superficial condi > bird-lovers in particu- lar reveals people and customs and adventures in a thoroughly satisfv- ing as well as delightfully clever mau ner V. F Mra i¢ ription Aun John Dewey’s Influence of Darwin on Philosophy nd Other Essays in Contemporary rhought $1.40 net and co-author $1.40 net, Professor Tuft’s Ethics By a Columbia of Dewey and The Essays also include Nature and Its Good.—Intelligence and Morals.—The Experimental Theory of Knowledge.—A Short Catechiam Concerning Truth,—Be- liefs and Existences.-Experience and Objective Idealism.—‘Consciousness” and Experience.—The Significance of the Problem of Knowledge, et« + i ‘ ‘ ¢ ? ? eA e ¢ @ « | | | . ? . 4 4 j % ¢ + ‘ a ? ‘ * 2 ? «4 7 ? < . . . ? + + 7 ‘ ‘ a + . * . ? o + + . 7 ? ? 4 + ? ¢ ¢ ¢ * + * « ¢ Ellis Landing Shell- | Rochelle, P. de la. am ‘Stuay of French | Verbs. Guide to French Pronunciat’on. F. K. Kane. $1.50, 50 cents. Sabie, F. Pan's Pipe: 1595. Republished | with an and W. P. Mustard. go Press. Sainte-Beuve, C. A. Causeries du Lundi. 5 vals. 1849-1851. Trans. by E, J. Treck- mann. Dutton. 50 cents each. Savidge, E. C. The American in Paris; a Biographical Novel. Third edition. Phila- delphia: Lippincott. $1.50. Shedd, G. C. The Princess of Forge. Mac- aulay Co. $1.50. Shedlock, M. L. Collection of Eastern Sto- ries and Legends, for Narration or Later Reading.in Schools. Dutton. 50 cents net. Skeat, W. W. Etymological Dictionary of the English Language. New edition re- vised and enlarged. Frowde. Snider, D. J. A Writer of Books. Sigma Pub. Co. Spearman, F. H., Sutphen, Van T., Bigelow, P., and others. Making Good: Stories of Golf and Other Outdoor Sports. Har- per 60 cents. University of Chica- St. Louis:

FOR THE SUMMER LIBRARY GWENDA. By Mabel author of ‘“‘Dimbie and I,"’ “Hilary on Her Own,”"’ ‘“‘Hazel of Heatherland.’’ An inti- mate, intense story, relieved by humor and a dash of worldly wisdom. 12mo. 5350 pages. Frontispiece. $1.50 THE TOP OF THE Juliet Wilbor Tompkins, Ellen"’ and “Open House.’’ wholesome story. full of humor, vivacity and charm. i2mo. Frontispiece in color. $1.50. IN PRAISE OF GARDENS. Compiled by Temple Scott Poems and verses about gardens from the whole range of English poetry Charming in contents and in form. $1.25. THE GARDEN IN THE WILDER- NESS. By “A Hermit.’’ A felicitous mingling of gardening and sentiment. Many illustrat decorative end papers, etc. $1.50 net WOMEN Edited by Barnes-Grundy, MORNING. By author of “Dr A sparkling, ons, AS LETTER WRITERS. Ada M. Ingpen. The best letters written by women from the 16th century until our own time. 12mo. 9 full-page portraits. $1.25 net. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., NEW YORK

introduction by J. W. Bright | Seczepansk’ | Storey, G. A. The Theory and Practice of Perspective. Frowde. $3.25. Straus, R. Robert Dodsley, Poet, Publisher, and Playwright. Lane Co. $6.50 net. i, P. v. The Prussian Cadet; and | Wildenbruch, E. v. A Story of Cadet Life, Trans. by W. D. Lowe. Dutton. $1 net. Tabor, G., and Teall, G. The Garden Prim- er. McBride, Winston & Co. Taylor, I. Words and Places. Dutton, $1.50 net. | Weichmann, L. J. Testimony in the trial of John H. Surratt, 1867. In the report- ing style of phonography. Cincinnati: Phonographic Institute Co. Wheeler, E. R. Famous Blue-Stockings. Lane Co. $4 net. White, W. A. The Old Order Changeth: A View of American Democracy. Macmil- lan. $1.25 net. Wolff, H. W. People’s Banks. tion. London: King & Son. YAqat’s Dictionary of Learned Men. E. J: W. Gibb Memorial, Vol. VI, 3. London: Luzac. Yorke, C. Wayward Anne. Estes. $1.50: Third edi- Boston: Dana

Ruskin and His Circle By ADA EARLAND 16 illustrations. $1.75 net A graphic account of the develop- ment of Ruskin’s life, as well as intimate sketches of the artists and men of letters with whom he was on terms of intimacy. Send for New Illustrated Catalogue G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS,

=~ fess 3

Send for catalogue. foe SCHOENHOF BOOK CO. 128 Tremont Street, BOSTON. TAUCHNITZ BRITISH AUTHORS

MASS.

IMPORTANT ANNOUNCEMENT KARL MARX: HIS LIFE AND WORK By JOHN SPARGO For thirteen years the author has been engaged in getting his facts and writing this book. ists the world over. This is the first ind indexed. $2.50 net; carriage paid, $2 He has had the coéperation of Marx’ biography of m, and is indispensable to a full understanding of the 75. s surviving daughter and prominent Social- the founder of modern Social- movement, Fully illustrated B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, 225 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK

SOMETHING OF MEN I HAVE KNOWN By former Vice-President ADLAI E. STEVENSON There is a peculiar charm about this nes —New York Sun. Illustrated, $2.75 A. C. MeCLURG & CO., queen,

WILLIAM J, TUCKER'S PERSONAL POWER “Vigorous and wholesome talks to college men.''——Kanease City Star. “A atimulating volume Chronicle "San Franciaco

INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOK way WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! GRORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth.§ . B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia | 60, Ss BOOKBUYERS and students wishing to receive interesting catalogues of second- hand books should send a card to W. HEFFER & SONS, Ltd., Booksellers, Cambridge, Eng. 100,000 volumes in stock.

BOOKS—All out of print books supplied, no | matter on what subject; write me, stati books wanted: I can get you any —_ gd published ; when in England, call and inspect stock of 000 rare books. BA KER’S GREAT B KSHOP, John Bright St., Birmingham, England SAMPLE COPIES OF THE NATION Will be sent to any address for three weeks WITHOUT CHARGE. | | “4 ADDRESS ‘a,| LHe NATION, 20 Vesey Street, N. Y.

Page 31

~ ‘ 4 ' * . ‘ : 2 + i : - FS P . . = 2 . j 4 , ~ Fe . : ‘ . at Ae } j * > . . . : i a * ] * * 4 2 , * Fa ‘ ‘$ . . si ’ : j ‘ ‘ - ‘ I i : | oe ’ « * . : “ o . ye i , t