The Nation 1910-02-17: Vol 90 Iss 2329

Page 1

CEWERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH, The Ni&on VOL. XC.—NO. 2329. THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 17, 1910, PRICE TEN CENTS. } | | Important New Macmillan Books Mrs. Atherton’s sew novel Tower of Ivory The points of life’s triangle in this novel are: two young American women, one a singer in the royal opera of music‘toving, mad King Ludwig of Bavaria, the other an heiress in London, and an Englishman with a future in the diplomatic service. By the author of “The Conqueror.” Cloth, $1.50 Francis L. Wellman’s Day in Court The Subtle Arts of Great Advocates is the subtitle which the author of “The Art of Cross-Examina tion” gives his new book. Mr. Wellman has an inexhaustible supply of capital stories and uses each to point a hint which should be invaluable to any young lawyer and many older ones—and incom parably entertaining to jurymen or witnesses. Cloth, Svo, $2.00 net, postpaid $2.1 William Lyon Phelps’s Essays on Modern Novelists “A volume that bids fair to form a distinct and permanent landmark in the history of fiction,” says The Boston Transcript, adding that these twelve essays “are as vital considerations of literary prob lems as have been brought to the eye of the thinking public in many a long day Cloth, $1.50 net, postpaid S161 George E. Woodberry’s The Inspiration of Poetry There has been no other critic in recent years with quite Mr. Woodberry’s skill in interpreting the deeper meanings of literature and the subtle beauties of poetry In his new book, as in Makers of Modern Literature and Heart of Man, he shows an instinct for what is the inspiration at the heart of the work of one writer and another, and describes it with warm sympathy Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 Dr. Henry van Dyke’s sew 400 The Spirit of America French audiences made no attempt to disguise the hearty sympathy with which they received th: lectures which, as now issued in book form, will prove scarcely less enlightening to Dr. Henry Van Dyke’s own countrymen. He has no axe to grind, no political theory to prove; he writes quite simply of the spirit which determines American character as he sees it in life and in literature Cloth, $1.50 net, postpaid S14? Dr. Andrew M. Fairbairn’s xew 600% Studies in Religion and Theology Dr. Fairbairn's “The Philosophy of the Christian Religion” was greeted as a master work, easily pla ing him at the head of modern theologians writing in English, and the inquiries for this new book since it was first announced indicate the deep interest with which it has been awaited. Taken to gether the “Studies” are a significant work on the Church in Idea and in History Cloth, Svo, 83.50 net, postpaid, $3.4 ies 30 THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “i 4"

Page 2

— ae The Nation. A WEEKLY FOUNDED IN 1865. Rnteved at the Neu York City Poat nd clase mail matter.] The Nation Is published and owned by York Evening Post Co resident; William J Kimer More, Editor Pattison, Thre lollare per year in advance, ny part of the United Statea or Mewico; £3.50. Postal Union $4.00 iddresa THE NATION, Bow 79}, Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THe WPEK EDITORIAL ARTICLES The Country and the Trusts The Value of Debat« A New Academic Career The Fame of “Chantecter” SPECIAL ARTICLES: Shelley I! CORRESPONDENCE An Unpublished Browning Letter The English Elections \n American Poetess of 1759 The Carnegi Foundation Edouard Rod's Patriotism Rostand and Tom D'Urfey LITERATURE lrans-Himalaya The Journal of a Recluse Old Harbor Sailors’ Knots (ireat Possessions Garibaldi and the Thousand The Farliest Cosmologies Salling Ships , Francesco Petrarca Poet and maniat NoTE# SCIENCE \ History of Botany, 1860-1900 LIRAMA Ibaer Literary Remain Miran Mus rlowmy The Nature of Musk Ant FINANCT lilusions of the Day hooks or Tie WREK Oswald Garrison Treasurer JOURNAL. Office th New Villard, Paul postpaid, tn to Canada md to foreign countries comprised Hu- the New York THIS "NUMBER. 151 154 155 156 157 159 159 160 160 160 160 168 170 The Nation. Educational. [Vol. 90, No. 2329 The University of Chicago Summer 1910 The scope and methods of instruction during the Summer Quarter rank in every respect with the other quarters of the academic year, and are widely taken advantage of by college professors, teachers in normal schools secomliary and elementary schools, cler gymen, lawyers, physi clans, and members of other professions. Ist Term June 20 to July 27 2d Term July 28 to Sept. 2 Detailed announcement, ready early in March, will be sent on request Spring quarter opens March 28. The University of Chicago, Chicago, Illinois JUST PUBLISHED MARTIN'S FRENCH VERB By LIEUTENANT CHARLES F. MARTIN, Instructor in Modern Languages, U. S. Military Academy. 81.2 Shows the student how to use the French verb at the same time that he learns how to conjugate it. Complete conjugations of all types of French verbs are given, and their idiomatic use is fully illustrated. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers Vacancies occurring throughout the year Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St.,Albany, N.Y 7 HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Evenrert 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2 A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave. 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., “Minneapolis 208 Mich. Ave, Chicago 292 Swetland Bid., Portland 405 Cooper Bidg., Denver %38DouglasBid. ,Los Angeles 618 Peyton Bid., Spokane 2142shattuckAve.,Berkele y Send to any a idress above for Agency Manual. , Washington Instruction. A GRADUATE OF THE MASS. INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY, and Ph.D. of the Johns Hop- kins University, desires to hear of a position for teaching At present engaged, and for the past ten years an instructor in chemistry in two promi nent Eastern medical schools During the entire time, has taught physiological and clinical chem stry, and for most of the time general, analytical ind) su6erganic «chemistry and = tox cology During four years has acted as substitute for the profes ser in the class work and had charge of the lab oratory courses Has had also wide experience in sanitary chemistry, especially in positions of responsibility in chemical and biological exam na tion of water supplies, and for the past five years has given a course in sanitary chemistry and an alysis as part of the course in hygiene Address S. F., care the Nation JUST PUBLISHED Handbook of Parliamentary Law By Fred Marion Gresge iate Professor of Psychology and Teacher of liameatary Law, Nebraska State Normal School, nO cents A complete, systematic and concise manual rules and regu covering all possible forms. lations employed in modern parliamentary practice It can be used elther as a texthook In courses on parliamentary law or as a refer ence beok for club use or for general information. GINN AND COMPANY] ., Introduction to Economics By Alvin 8. Johnson, Ph.D., Professor in University of Texas and Lecturer in University of Chicago. Balances theory with practice; contemporary interest and value; dent and citizen 116 pages. $1.50 D. CC. HEATH & CO., NEW YORK full of for stu- hos TON CHICAGO 128 Tremont Street, HOSTON, MASS AUTHORS i Es sewer soo co, “AUGHAIT ***Coples of The Nation may te procured In aris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de Opéra; tn lomion of B. FF. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Squere, Charing Cross MARX'S CAPITAL, »" compete. CHARLES H. KERR & COMPANY, Chicago. THE NATION) | MAGAZINES (including bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. Letters and Memorials Wendell Phillips Garrison Editor of The Nation 1865-1906 rolume crown Svo, 300 with photogravure portrait. Jn ane pages, forty-one years in Nation, with and con- During the which he edited the a thoroughness, ability, scientious devotion unsurpassea in the records of American journal- ism, Mr. Garrison was an indefat- igable correspondent, never em- ploying an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who embraced practically all the leading American scholars and crit- ics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a sufficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the rela- tions between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exer- cised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes, and sympathies. The volume also con- tains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and sever- al of his characteristic editoria's, reviews, and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. It likewise preserves the notable letter of ap- preciation addressed to Mr. Gar- rison by more than two hundred contributors to the Nation on the completion of his fortieth year of service, and his acknowledgment thereof. Price $1.50 net, postpaid Houghton Mifflin Company BOSTON NEW YORK ii tia ale SE Ces nl a Re

Page 3

Feb. 17, 1910] The Nation. ili The Most Readable Book of the Season THE TOP OF THE MORNING By JULIET WILBOR TOMPKINS, Author of “Dr. Ellen” and “Open House”’ Of this book JAMES L. FORD says in the New York Herald of February Sth: ‘It would not surprise me were ‘The Top of the Morning’ to prove, if not a best seller, a remarkably good one.”’ - and yet it is that very chapter that is going to give the book its sale, for it describes a society that exists in thousands of eager, imaginative brains, a society that in point of brilliancy and epigram and artistic feeling and mad abandon is infinitely better than the real thing "’ q Says the reviewer in the Philadelphia orth American: ‘‘ Delightful people, . one and all. A minor comedy of manners, in which there is not a dull moment nora meaningless character.’’ 12mo. Frontispiece in Color. $1.50 Retrospections of an Active Life A History of Architecture By JOHN BIGELOW By RUSSELL STURGIS Voits. I and II now ready; Von. II (just pub- lished) treats of the architecture of India, China, Japan, and Persia, the early Christian monuments, the Byzan From a two-page review in 7he Nation of January 27, 1910: ‘* Nowhere else, probably, has there been ‘ brought together in one book so much material indis- | pensable to the historian of our relations with France tine and Moslem architecture, and concludes with an ex : perhaps one might even say, our relations with Europe haustive treatment of the Developed or Later Romanes«ue 4 during and immediately following the Civil War. _— Three vols. (Vor. II] in preparation), each volume 4 We have wished more Americans might read it and gath ‘ontains 500 payes and 400 illustrations. Cloth, net, pet 3 er, from the cheerfulness that pervades it and from the vol., $5.00 Half morocco, net, per vol., $7.50; carriage > long patriotism it reveals, fresh zeal and fresh hope fo extra : their country, as well as for mankind.’ ‘* No history of architecture has ever before appeared ] in the English language that can even be compared to ; 3 Vols. Imperial 8vo. 40 portraits. $12.00 net it.'—The Architectural Record THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., 33 East 17th St., New York are invited to examine the resources of our retail store. Here will be found NOTABLE PAPERS AND OTHER FEATURES a large stock of current and standard works from American and foreign Appearing during the quarter embracing December, 1909, January and February, 1910 presses. Teachers or students prepar- ing for courses of reading will find an : . : = . - enecitent Ghatee of tmaiusnte-netees Proceedings of a Conference on the Teaching of Elementary Economics editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE Papers rhe Aim and Content of a College Course in Elementary Economica’’—A. B. Wolfe : oP Ee ro : ” Oberlin College “The Aim of a Course in Elementary Economics’’—Simon Litman, Univer SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- sity of llin = “Methods of Teaching Elementary Economics at the Unive ratty of Mich! 1 oguen. gan’’—F. M. Taylor. Verbatim Report of Discussion of these papers E. P. DUTTON & CO., the Tariff of 1909. ne die eel 31 West 234 Street. New York The Rationality of Economic Activity . een ee Wesley C. Mitchell ob Tobacco Pools of Kentucky and Tennessee .. Inna Youngman : a old and Silver from 1493 to 1905 ! D. Magee Industry Among the French in the Illinois a I. Lippincott WHY WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! Labor Unions and the Anti-Trust Law........ C. J. Primm 4 By GEORGE L. WALTON, M.D. Cloth, $1 net, each Washington Notes ry it c , * J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. (A terse monthly summary of legislation and legislative plans and comment on financtal and economic happenings.) ; e views and Notices of Important Economic Literature AMERICANS: An Impression | 200% Reviews. and N 4 By Alexander Francis. a graphy : : (Fach issue contains 20 or more pages of an exhaustive bibliography of current lterature-—books q periodicals, government documents, and pamphlet n economic subjecta—tn English, French German, and Italian.) SAMPLE COPIES The Cumulative Bibliography from the issue { the past year will shortly be published in book form; price $2.50 net OF The Journal of Political Economy is edited by the Faculty of Political Economy of the University of Chicago, and is published monthly except in August and eptember m Subscripti ice $3.00 ; Single copies 35 cents. THE NATION ubscription price per ms i — c In combination with the ° Dept. 21 Will be sent fo any address for three TH UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS, Chicago and New York weeks The a orit« "e ‘ ‘ - Top of all kind 1 - 2 ” looked ADDRESS my. An Tenmadees ae tore at =» ts the Boston and Harvard libraries or sebol gps aS Each volume 50 are, writers, and others Abstracts, copies, trane oa . _— _ the same tim prie). 2acn ations, and bibliographies made Proof-reading | | | I N \ | ] () N cents net; by mail, 54 cents. snd revision of manuscript Highest university “4 + Send for a descriptive pamphict. ind library references MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass Smail, & Co., 21 Beacon St, Boston 20 Vesey Street New York City

Page 4

[ Vol. 90, No. 2329 iv The Nation. LONGMANS. GREEN, & CO.’S LIST THE STRENGTH OF ENGLAND: A Politico- Economic History of England from Saxon Times to the Reign of Charles the First. By J. W. WELSFORD, M.A., formerly Fellow of Gonville and Caius College, Cambridge; Author of “The Strength of Nations,” & With a Preface by W. CUNNINGHAM, D.D. F.B.A Archdeacon of Ely. Crown 8vo, pp. xvi—362. $1.75 net This contribution to the economic interpretation of English political history should command the attention of serious stu- dents of present-day political issues. MODERN CONSTITUTIONS IN OUTLINE: An Introductory Study in Political Science. By LEONARD ALSTON, M.A., Director of Non-Collegiate Students in Economics and History, Cambridge. New H#di- tion, Revised Crown &vo, pp. vill+79. $06.90. THE INDIVIDUAL AND REALITY: An Essay Touching the First Principles of Meta- physics. By EDWARD DOUGLAS FAWCETT. Medium 8vo, pp. xxiv+450. $4.25 net This book, which may be regarded as a reply to the Abso- PRINCIPLES OF POLITICAL ECONOMY: With some of their Applications to Social Philosophy. By JOHN STUART MILL. Edited with an Introduction by W. J. ASHLEY, M.A., M.Com., Professor of Commerce in the University of Birmingham, sometime Fellow of Lin- coln College, Oxford. Crown 8vo, pp. liv+1014. $1.50 net. It is seldom realized how considerable were the changes and additions made by Mill himself in the six editions of his Treatise which appeared in his life-time after the first in 1848. It is a main purpose of Professor Ashley's edition to indicate, with their dates, all those changes in the text which show any variation or development in Mill's opinions. HUMAN ECONOMICS. Books I. and II.: Natu- ral Economy, and Cosmopolitan Economy. By A. H. GIBSON, F.C.A. 8vo, pp. viii+406. $3.50 net. The professional experience of the author has brought him into close connection with the actualities of human eco- nomics. In this work he investigates the laws, both natural and human, controlling production and consumption, and, to that end, lays down new divisions of the Science of Economics, viz.: (1) Natural Economy, (2) Cosmopolitan Economy, (3) Communital Economy, (4) Individual Economy. THE INDUSTRIAL SYSTEM: An Enquiry lutist idealism of Mr. F. H. Bradley's “Appearance and Real- into Earned and Unearned Income. ity.” seeks to show that a satisfactory metaphysics flows naturally from “radical empiricism.” By J. A. HOBSON, Author of “The Evolution of Modern Capitalism,” ete. 8vo, pp. xx+328. $2.50 net. RECENT ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL AND INORGANIC CHEMISTRY. CHARLES DARWIN AND THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES. Addresses, etc., in America and hv A. W. STEWART, D.Se., Lecturer on Organic Chemistry . o a in the University of Belfast; Author of “Recent Advances England in the Year of the two Anniversaries. in Organic Chemistry.” ete. With an Introduction by Sir By EDWARD BAGNALL POULTON, D.Sc., M.A., F.R.S., WILLIAM RAMSAY, K.C.B., F.R.S. 8vo, pp. xii+268. $2.50 Hope Professor of Zoélogy in the University of Oxford, net Author of “Essays on Evolution,” etc. 8vo, pp. xvi+-302. $3.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 4th Avenue and 30th Street, New York Memoirs of Henry Villard Journalist and Financier Library Orders We have conducted a special department for many years that has been exceptionally successful in hand- ling book orders from PUBLIC LIBRARIES SCHOOLS, COLLEGES and UNIVERSITIES 1835-1900 Two volumes, with Portraits and Maps, $5.00 net. Postage, 35 cents. An autobiographical record of the varied and romantic career of the war journalist > > sti Y eau — of 2 a. (ul Monthly Tbulle tin of New Books, with annota who subsequently became a power in the tions and brief descriptions of each title recorded, 1s financial world, and carried the Northern of ' aids in book selection, one of the most he Ipful aids in book selection Pacific Railroad to completion. Full of in- Library Department leident and | valuable for its reminiscences of Lincoln and other prominent men of the A. C. MCCLURG & CO. fires: setae siete aeseritions o CHICAGO portant battles of the Civil War. “A book of extraordinary Interest. It is written with great ability, in a clear and flowing style; it detalles with perfect candor the incidents of a great career; it is an admirable report of great events, all of which the 2a 99 jaeng | cow, gna ® lenge pee of — (afer LA ge he “é was; it ex ta the rise and growth ofarich and pow- AIX Ss NOVEL erful personality and a character at once remarkable for its simplicity and its variety.""—Joun W wicK, in the New York Times Saturday Review. STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Ralzac, Bronté, Browning, Bulwer, Car “Adventuresola Nice Young Man” lyle, Cooper, Dickens, Dumas, De Foe, Eliot, : “This posthumous asutoblogra; ny of ene, tate Henry Gibbon, Guisct, Hawthorne, Hugo, srving, “It has the picturesque quality pj WFO . _ eeegslitctamaal a cr > ‘ 2 i” ” “¢ @ J . . . Scott, Shakespeare, Thackeray, Tolstol. which makes Gil Blas a joy forever. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY BOSTON AND NEW YORK Send for Deacriptive Booklet. DUFFIELD F-= COMPANY THOMAS Y, CROWELL & CO.,New York = 90WESTS7” NEW YORK

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 17, 1910. The Week. Few United States more attention on a great Constitution- members or ex-members of the Senate would command al question than ex-Senator Spooner, and his emphatic assertion that the pro- posed Federal corporation law would be a radical violation of the Constitution has, The great scope of the Federal Government therefore, unusual interest. in the domain of interstate commerce is unchallenged, but to create manufac- the several States, would be, according to turing corporations, operating in Senator Spooner, an extension of Feder- al power which finds no warrant in the Constitution, and would be subversive whose consequences of the State sys- tem under which we have lived. In the Knight case, which has played so im- portant a part in the history of the Sherman Anti-Trust law, the Supreme Court made be- tween the regulation of manufactures to a sharp distinction which interstate commerce was inciden- tal and the regulation of interstate com- merce itself; and now, in this broader question of Federal corporations, Sena- tor Spooner invokes the same distinc- tion. It was, by the way, with a view to avoiding this kind of difficulty that the idea of a Federal license, instead of Federal incorporation, was brought for- ward; a system under which the corpor ation would not be a creature of the Federal Government, but would have to comply with certain conditions in order to be permitted to participate in iuter- state commerce. Whatever may be the merits of this proposition, it is certain- ly not open to the most serious part of the attack made by Mr. Spooner upon the project of Federal incorporation. President Taft, in his speech of last Saturday, to the sudden ex- pression of acute misgiving, principally in Wall Street circles, over the so-call- ed “corporation policies” of the Admin- istration and the courts. Yet there never was a stock market more sus- referred, ceptible of ready explanation than that of the past five weeks. Last year, the financial community was only emerging from the after-effects of a very disastrous financial and commercial pan- ic. The country’s trade had recovered, but it had not reached the level of its As a result of these trade conditions, idle money was piled former prosperity. up in the banks, and it was this idle money which the Stock Exchange specu- lators borrowed to promote their own undertakings on the market. Prices of stocks, which had already made very large advances during 1908, were bid up 20 or 30 per cent. more in 1909, many of them reaching higher figures than the the panic. were attained even in great speculations before Based, as these stock speculations were, on cheap and abundant money at New York, their successful continuance required either continued easy money, of the speculators by the or purchase the stocks from investing public, or abroad to the raising of capital sup- port the high New York prices. None of these expectations was fulfilled. The demands for stock speculation brought the New York money market into a pe- riod of stringency and depleted bank re serves; the home investing public re- fused to buy at the high prices; while authorities the Steel and the took the French “list” as for Europe, blockaded shares Paris Bourse, Bank October, strong measures to prevent recourse to Street New York borrowers. not a scheme to on the of England, in by It strange that the topheavy structure of Lombard speculative was surely speculation should have fallen to earth So far, the affair is in no respect dif- a hundred other similar The pres- ent case is singular only from the ob- ferent from Stock Exchange occurrences. stinate insistence, even in respectable Wall Street circles, on the theory that the Government's “corporation policies” were the cause for the break in stocks, and, inferentially, that stocks would not have broken but for those policies. Now, we shall not pause to indicate how com- pletely such a theory ignores the facts which we have recited, or to suggest the rather obvious inconsistency of suppos- ing that the market will rise violently (as it did last September) on the Presi- dent’s public announcement of those pol- icles, and then break violently because of his repetition of the same announce ment, four months later. We base our disbelief in any such fundamental influ- ence by the “Washington policies” on the nature of those policies themselves Some of the comments on the matter, in and out of Wall Street, are so extraor- dinary as to lead us charitably to sup pose that their authors must be ignorant of the facts. President Taft's speech on Saturday night was amazingly frank in its v«fer- ences to the party situation and out- look. He said, almost in so many words, that his lar; that many Republican newspapers Administration was unpopu were outspoken party in criticism; that the at Washington and throughout the country was torn by factions; and that the general expectation was that the Democrats would carry the Congres sional elections, would this year, and win in Ohio and New York. For 4 par- allel to such astonishing bluntness in a public address by a party leader to his followers, we think the records of Pres idential vain. oratory would be searched in The ordinary way is to aliuue to such doubts and fears as inventious of the enemy, and to affirm with a confi dence not really felt that the glortous old party will rally and smite its op- ponents aip and thigh. But what other men reserve for private conversation or their self-communings in a dlfary, Mr. Taft blurts out in a speech. for He re ferred to the trials which Lincoln had that in the dark days of 1864 Lincoln wrote in his to go through. It is true diary that it seemed to be certain that he would be defeated. Yet it would impossible him Mr. Taft, however, apparent- be to imagine saying so publicly. ly would have done it! His honesty and he Does this argue a downrightness are so great that keeps nothing back. kind of simplicity or even innocence in him, or is it consistent with a settled view of wise policy? We shall bave to wait for time to give us the answer. that the Payne-Aldrich law cut down the aver- age rate on dutiable imports by 12 per of Not content with showing cent. and enlarged the proportion goods coming in free by about the same percentage, President Taft went on to

Page 6

152 say that “for the production of revenue the Payne law is even more an improve- ment on the Dingley bill.” This he pro- ceeded to demonstrate by pointing out that during the six months that the present tariff had been in force (from August 5 to February 5) customs re ceipts amounted to $166,000,000, while “the semi-annual average” under the Dingley tariff was $130,000,000. But this thought must inevitably suggest itself: if the rate on dutiable imports has been materially cut down and the percentage of imports coming in free has also been the only possi- ble Way in which the revenue can have considerably enlarged, been increased is by a very great in- crease in the total of importations. And yet we all know that (leaving out of ac- count the panic year) no such great in- crease has taken place. What, then, is the explanation of the President's fig- factors conspire to ac- The Dingley act was ures? Several count for them passed a long time ago, and our foreign trade has been growing enormously in the interval; to compare the six monihs just past with the semi-annual average for the preceding dozen years is not very instructive. Secondly, we are now in a time of high prices, and especially of high American prices, a double reason And thirdly, the first six months of the tar- iff indication of its normal working, since imports muy have been held back for its enactment. for increasing customs receipts. are a very unreliable Spitzer, the convicted dock superin- tendent of the Sugar Trust, persists in As he started on his journey to the Atlanta he declared that he or indirectly, asserting his innocence to the last. penitentiary, was not responsible, directly for any weighing frauds that may have been committed. From the artistic standpoint, we should be inclined to say that he overdoes the thing a little when he not only insists on hia own innocence but famous apparatus of the and ignorance, is careful to refer to the now frauds as “the steel springs and holeg al- leged to have been found in the scaies.” Such beyond the limits of reasonable caution, careful guarding of a case goes and thus tends to defeat its own object. In justice to the Sugar Trust, however, it must be admitted that the failure of Spitzer and the four convicted weigh- ers to incriminate anybody “higher up” ia disappointing. There is no room for The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2329 reasonable doubt of the Trust’s guilt, but the guilty man’s explanation of how he the consistent silence of its subordinate | was able to steal the money undetected agents is a mystery. hand, the case of Heike, the secretary of the Trust, who has been indicted in con- nection with the same frauds and whose On the other'| plea of immunity is now denied, pre-| sented a very sinister aspect. Whatever might be the effect of that plea in the eye of the criminal law, it could have but one meaning in the forum of pub- lic opinion. It must necessarily be re- garded, under all the circumstances, as equivalent on its face to a confession of guilt. There are situations in which such a plea could be made without any such implication, but this was not one of them. In the first place, the offence charged was fraud of the simplest and most unmistakable kind; there was no- thing doubtful, subtle, or intricate about the nature of it—nothing that might make it bear one aspect in the mind of the person committing it and an- other in the view of the law. Sec- ondly, the immunity plea was extreme- ly far-fetched; the testimony given by Heike before the Federal grand jury had reference to violation of the anti- i'rust law, and had nothing to do with the weighing frauds. In deciding against the Sugar Trust secretary's plea for im- munity and ordering him to ‘rial with other employees of the company on the charges formuiated by the grand jury, Judge Martin of the United States Cir- cuit Court has done a notable service to the cause of justice and of popular re- gard for the law. The “immunity bath” has become almost as notorious a fea- ture of our criminal law procedure as the insanity plea. The United States Treasury has long boasted that it was “thief-proof,” but recently its authorities had to confess that a small sum of currency had been does not help matters. He simply ab- stracted certain sums from the receipts of station agents, and although the lat- ter sent in duplicate returns to the audi- tor, the latter did not take the truuble to compare them with the treasurer's , books. stolen from them. Some bold and in-| genious rogue had broken’ through their system of checking off and certify- ing and registering and guarding. This, however, was somewhat of the nature of which must be of rare vccur- rence. Compared with it, the long-con- tinued embezzlements of the treasurer of the Big Four Railroad seem start'ing a feat, and inexplicable. could have a “shortage’’ of several hun- dred thousand dollars, and the company none the wiser, appears to be a terrible indictment of its business methods. And The progress of the nation-wide cam- paign against race-track gambling is summarized in the report of a hearing held last December before a sub-commit- tee of the United States Senate’s Judi- ciary Committee on Senator Burkett’s bill, “to prevent the nullification of State anti-gambling laws by internation- al or interstate transmission of race- gambling bets or of racing odds.” The great bulk of expert testimony was pre- sented by Mr. Henry Brolaski, who has listened to the lure of the real estate business after twenty-one years as “a gambler, »oolroom proprietor, bookmak- er upon race-tracks, and hand-book mak- er.” In New York our specialist esti- mates that there are now fifty pool- rooms and 500 handbooks in operation, with a clientéle of 100,000 players. The percentage against a player in tuese handbooks is from 5 to 15 per cent., and “common sense will tell you that trom 5 per cent. up will eat up any man’s capital if taken out six times a uay.” The number of race-tracks destroyed by recent legislation is given as fifty-eight, although by “destroyed” is evidently meant crippled for betting purposes. There are still in operation twelve tracks, of which two, in Florida, are to be suppressed at the end of the present year. The tracks in active being are situated in Kentucky (3), Oklahoma (2), Nevada (2), Maryland, Virginia, and Montana. The decision by the Princeton trustees last week seems to have met the ques- tion immediately at issue in a way both happy and just. Few details are as yet published, but the main points are clear. Two gifts for the endowment of a grad- “uate college had been offered, one ap- | parently conditioned upon a site on or 'near the campus, the other contemplat- That such an official | ing a location at a distance frum it. There were also questions about the con- trol of the new institution by the aca- demic governing body of the univer- sity. Because it was found impossible

Page 7

Feb. 17, 1910 to unite the two foundations, or other- wise to reconcile the differences about administration, the larger gift was with- drawn. While regretting this, and hop- ing that an adjustment may yet be found, the trustees distinctly uphold President Wilson. He was right, they decide, in insisting upon a proper uni- versity control of the proposed gradu- ate college, and upon its being absorbed into the common academic life at Princeton. President Wilson has left his attitude in no doubt. He is for the freest and fullest play of the democratic spirit in colleges, and as a means of se- curing it at Princeton urged a sys- tem of dormitories in which al) the students should live. This the abolition of the expensive and ex- clusive clubs which have been so mark- ed a feature of life at Princeton. But though the faculty approved a propos- al which many considered revolution- ary, the trustees have thus far declined to give their assent to it. This is clear- ly the question about which the “dissen- sions” have sprung up, involving, as is known, a great deal of bitter feeling with rumors that President Wilson would be forced to resign. Now, if this were an affair that concerned Princeton alone, it would be tant, but not nearly so important as it appears when we reflect that the involved same question is troubling college au- thorities all over the country. resist the invasion, not of luxury, but of the spirit of caste that so insidiously attaches itself to luxury, and how to preserve that democratic mingling young men which many still think as the best thing that college life nas give them—these are problems vexing professors and presidents from East to West. How to of ot to Commander Peary’s prompt turning over of the $10,000 presented to him to the fund for South will disarm those who have accused him Polar exploration of mercenary motives. Nor can there be any question of trespassing upon a British preserve. As the National Geo- graphic Society explains, the expedi- tion of Capt. R. F. Scott of the English navy will be making observations on “the other side of the Antarctic area, while the American party would pro- ceed by way of Coats Land. Assurances impor- The Nation. from British explorers, including Shuck- leton, make it plain that there wouid be only a spirit of friendly rivalry. Peary, as Gov. Hughes said last night, has come late into the full measure of the acclaim due him, but there is no iack of heartiness in it now. Congress should not delay in taking, as President Taft suggests, “substantial notice”’— such as a vote of thanks and a medal— some of an achievement which has heighten- ed our national fame. There is little reason to doubt that the budget will be the first measure brought in by Mr. Asquith, and that, with certain modifications to please the Irish, it will pass the Commons and be approved by the Lords. The must be made the March if the country is to be spared a budget law before end of condition approximating financial chaos. Mr. Redmond’s speech before the executive committee of the Nation- alist Party may lend itself at first read- ing to the interpretation that the ‘trish will insist on Home Rule before every- thing else. “For pass the budget and postpone the veto the Government to question was a policy that Ireland could not and would not approve.” But that, as the context shows, can be taken to mean only that the veto question and Home Rule must be taken up in the very near future, and possibly after the budget, but certainly not before. If the financial bill were to pass with the aid of Irish votes, and Mr. Asquith should then ignore his pledge to the Irish, the latter could, of course, inflict instant punishment by turning the Government out. The Parliamentary prospect, there- fore, is for a speedy of the financial question, to be followed by a disposal long and uncertain struggle over the mending or the ending of the Lords. The Government of India lives up to the traditional British practice of lend- ing * clemency with firmness. It an- nounces an amnesty for native prison- ers deported last year on the charge of sedition, and at the same time puts into effect a severe press censorship law. Newspaper publishers and printers are required to deposit sufficient funds to guarantee the payments of any fine that may be imposed for the publication of seditious matter. Any amount declared forfeit made good against a recurrence of the on the stated charge must be 1538 The penalty for a third viola If, as the offence. tion is complete suppression. Viceroy declared, it is true that the anti British movement has now degenerated into mere anarchism, and the Govern ment has nothing to fear from the more responsible Indian leaders with whom it has dealt in the past, it is hard to see why there should be any need of a muzzle for the Indian press. The rabid anarchist will run his course, press or no press, or, if anything, will only profit the of of speech. It is probably true that terror by suppression freedom ism has struck no deep roots in India But the way to eradicate it is obviously not by a policy which may drive calm spirits into the arms of the extremists The Prussian Government is guilty of almost incredible short-sightedness in its new franchise bill which fails to re move the chief objection to the present suffrage system that Bismarck denoun The sian masses are thirsting for more de ed as the worst conceivable. Prus mocracy, primarily for equality at the ballot-box. They have made their wishes known in orderly mass meetings and by disorderly rioting. The educated classes have spoken through their press and in Yet the bill new Chancellor retains numerous ways. franchise proposed by the the three-class system, by which electors are divided according to the taxes they and increases the first and pay, even second classes. Direct voting instead ot indirect seems about the only reai con bill. Chancellor in the To make matters the cession worse, decried govern ment by Parliament and said that “one of the results of the democratization ot parliaments in all countries was to ren der the political sense of a people coarse, superficial, and a hindrance to progress.” The Government, he declar ed, would oppose the democratization of Prussia and the German Empire. All of this means two things: that Von Beth mann-Hollweg is not the man for the place he holds, and that, in opposing the desire of the people, he is ready to play with fire. It may be reassuring to the complacency of the Government that So clalist demonstrations in Berlin should be kept so firmly in hand by the mili- tary and police. But it is not so reas suring to think that those demonstra tions should continue, and with increas ed enthusiasm, in spite of the military and polies.

Page 8

154 THE COUNTRY AND THE TRUSTS. ’ The speech last Saturday, that if “the pres- President's declaration, in his ent methods of carrying on business’ are in violation of the law, “they must be changed to conform to the law” has evoked the arrogant and supercilious criticism from the organs of the Trusts which any such assertion always has to It is treated as the talk of an ignoramus or a doma- expect in those quarters. of a man unable to measure the On gogue; significance of his own utterances. the same principle, we are told, the President might have stood by a law that brought business to an absclute standstill; if you are going to stand by a law just because it was once enacted, look well, say and never to consequences, you may as these critics, let the country go to the dogs altogether. Well, Mr. Taft is not quite so reckless as all that; moreover, brief as was his reference to the enforcement of the Anti Trust law, it was long enough to show explicitly that he is not so simpie as all that. He is standing by the law not merely because it is the law, but be cause he emphatically approves of the law, or at least of its general purpose He does not say merely that business must conform to the law because the law is on the statute books; he says it must conform to the law because the country demands that either that law, or some law more effective for the same purpose, shall remain on the statute books. This is what the President said: if the enforcement of the law is not con- sistent with the present methods of car- rying on business, then it does not speak well for the present methods of conducting business, and they must be changed to conform to the law There was no prom ise on the part of the Republican party to chang the anti-Trust law except to strengthen it, or to authorize monopoly and a suppression of competition and the control of prices That is the nub of the matter. What the resident says of the Republican party is, of course, still more true of the Op position; tt is true of the nation as a and it ie true of the most sober of whole thinkers the nation, that they have intention “to authorize mo of no desire or nopoly and a suppression competi tion and the control of prices.” The im portant thing about the President's state ment is not so much his declaration that the law will be enforced, as his asser tion that the law ought to be what It is, or stronger; and those Trust magnates ‘The will show themselves wisest who.aimit Nation. that in this assertion he represents the people of the United States, and who’! In- stead of threatening blue ruin in case the to their wishes, they will do well so to arrange govern their conduct accordingly. country does not bow their affairs as to avoid the disastrous consequences, to themselves as we.l as to the rest of us, of a policy of obstinate resistance. ' The wisdom so often exhibited by the cham- pions of the Trust is closely connected with their addiction to a body of doc- trine that has many of the earmarks of We sure, in a rather loose and broad way; jaunty assumption of superior superstition. use the word, to be what we mean is a belief, real or pre- that complex subject by a simple dogma, and then sees all facts in the light of that tended, disposes of a large and dogma. No sooner had the tendency to gigantic combinations become a mark- ed of than there sprang up a great number of feature the economic situation writers and speakers who read not only into the future but into the past cf the industrial and commercial development of the world the character necessary to sustain their dogma of manifest des- tiny. All attempts to preserve competi- tion as a really important element in great economic activities were absurd; any one who could not see the hand- writing on the wall wrote himself down a back number. Competition had been a good enough thing in its day, bat its day was evidently over; now let us wel- come the new order, since it was vain to strive against its coming. But, con- fident as these prophets were, and ready their that consid- erable class of persons who fear, of all as was acclaim by things, to be counted among the “back something more was needed the Trust To make their predicted future acceptable, numbers,” to bolster up position. it was necessary to show their benefi- cence or their indispensableness in the present and the past. But the present and the past are some- what more refractory material than the future; and it is perhaps to this cir- cumstance more than to any other that the failure of the Trust propaganda to make greater headway is to be agscrib- ed. memory It requires something of an effort of the time—though it when the plea to recall is not many years ago that was most conspicuously made in be- | half of the Trusts was that of the enor- | Vol. 90, No. 2329 mous cheapening of production which they brought about. might justly be claimed in this direc- That something tion no one could dispute, but there were, all along, two criticisms of the Trust contentiun: first, that the degree of economy of production was grossly exaggerated, and second, that there was no guarantee of the economy inuring to the benefit of consumers. In the early | days, to hear the Trust advocates, one would have thought there had been no such thing as cheapening of manufactur- ed goods, from the days of Arkwright and Watt, until the advent of Rockefel- ler and Morgan; but the claim was so riddled to pieces in the course of a few years that it has almost dropped out of sight. In its place, however, has come the pretension that “the present methods of doing business’’—that is, the monop- olistic methods of law-breaking ‘Trusts —are the only methods on which busi- The pretension is absurd, and rests, like the ness can be carried on in our time. other, on an ignoring of the facts ot business history. It is as baseless as the preposterous claim that the prodig- lous cheapening of production that had taken place in a hundred years of un- precedented industrial progress without monopoly was a matter of no conse- quence alongside the wonderful gains achieved by the financial consolidations of our Trust magnates. THE VALUE OF DEBATE. The tendency to underestimate Con- gressional debate has been growing in recent and obvious causes have contributed to it. There has years. Various been, for example, the weariness with long “set speeches,” either purely for buncombe or for time-killing. Then peo- ple to have an increasing impatience with deliberation in matters of legislation about which they have made up their minds. The famous max- im of the corporation manager: “Vote first your discussing alter- have come and do wards,” has insensibly crept into our view of the way to dispatch public busi- ness. Furthermore, the chief dependence seems to be placed upon those who draft bills, instead of those who debate them. When able lawyers and skilled public men and Administration officials put their heads together and frame a reas- ure to accomplish a given end, the im-

Page 9

Feb. 17, 1910] pulse is to take their cachet as final, and to dismiss all inquiry or criticism as captious. After Rome has spoken, who are you to raise your voice? Now, it is not necessary to appeal! to our past or to general theories of gov- ernment by public discussion in order to show the folly of this undervaluing of keen and full debate in Congress. We have under our eyes, in the Senate ar- gument about the postal savings bill, which is going on from day to day, an excellent and conclusive example of the great importance of subjecting legisla- tive proposals to the closest scrutiny. These Senate debates have not been, un- fortunately, reported in the press with anything like adequacy, but no one who will follow them in the Congressional Record can fail to be impressed by their utility and fruitfulness. The postal sav- ings bill was reported with a fine air of completeness. The people wanted it; it was “sure to pass”; obstructionists were to be swept out of the way. Sena- tor Carter, who was in charge of the matter, pressed for an instant vote. But full debate was insisted upon, and it has been of the greatest use. Besides the attacks on the constitutionality of the bill, made by Senators Rayner, Bailey, Bacon, and others, the texc of the measure itself has been merciless- ly analyzed and such defects brought out that Senator Carter himself was forced to admit the necessity of many amendments and much recasting. It ap- peared that such vital points as the method of withdrawals by depositors, the liability of funds held in one State being drawn upon to meet demands in another, the whole question of the re- serve which banks must nold against de- posits of postal savings, had been entire- ly forgotten or slurred over by those who drafted the bill. Holes were knock- ed in it by one Senator after another, and the fina’ form of the measure will be very different from what it would have been but for this most enlighten- ing debate. It was a striking instance of the way in which the truth is brought out and the public interest served by free argument and the impact of mind on mind. Not only is the worth of Congression- al debate held too cheap by the general public, but the capacity of Representa- tives and Senators is grievously under- Of course, there are wind- It estimated. bags and dunderheads among them. The Nation. is often exasperatingly difficult to get to the real points at issue. But when large matters are up and free play is given to intellect, there is as much of it avail- able in Congress as in any place we know. It naturally takes a measure which is not made one of party to bring out the full force of the reasoning pow- ers which Congressmen can apply to it. This is the case with the postal sav- ings bill. Registering the decree of no caucus, it has to take its chances with the acute criticism which unfettered minds may pour upon it. Any one who studies its full report in the Record will get a new idea of the intellectual sources of the Senate, and of the enor- mous advantage to the public of having such men as Congress possesses to sift and try important bills. re- It is inconceivable that the Adminis- tration should expect that its darling this wholesome searching in the course of their passage through Congress. The Federal Incorporation bill, for exainple, measures can be exempted from appears to have been drawn with great care and skill. Beyond question, able lawyers, skilled in corporation affairs, have got their minds together in its construction. But there is nothing like the cross-fire of debate for revealing un- suspected weaknesses or oversights. The most capable draftsmen think We are not contending cannot of everything. for any abuse of the privilege of de- bate. There must some time come an end of argument, and the vote be taken. But within reasonable limits, the tree- dom of debate should be cherished and exalted, because only by such pub'ic ex- amination of public measures, such at- tack and defence, such sharpening of iron upon iron, can the democracy be made certain either that people in a the end sought in a given law is one that should be sought, or that the prop- er més to attain it have been selected. A NKW ACADEMIC CAREER. The selevtion on Monday of Mr. Fred- erick P. Kep.el as dean of Columbia Col- lege has calléy forth many congratula- tions for the finiversity. The new dean's ability and fine personal qualities are 1ized. At thirty-five, he suc- 155 the university dates from 1902, since which time he has been secretary. By virtue of that office, he was in charge of publicity work and other administra- tive details, with a success to which bis promotion now testifies. Uniike Dean Van Amringe, for years professor of mathematics, Mr. Keppel has never been a member of the teaching staff, but has confined himself exclusively to execu- tive work. It is this fact in connection with Dean Keppel which will, we fancy, attract the widest attention in academic circles. True, Columbia has another dean— Goetze of the School of Science—who is not a teacher; he was promoted from the superintendency of grounds and But Mr. bulks larger in the college world, and buildings. Keppel's position his appointment seems a deliberate af- firmation of this new policy of choosing deans solely for their executive experi- ence and talents. Since time immemor- ial the college dean has been thought of not only as a disciplinarian but as a teacher and as shepherd of the faculty. However his duties may have varied from time to time, or in this or that place, the ideal of the dean as a man of deep learning and a of the youth over whose conduct he watches teacher parentally, has usually prevailed. At Harvard to-day Dean Hurlburt is pro- fessor of English, though his actual teaching is limited. His predecessor, Dean Briggs, was also in the English Department. At Princeton, Dean Fine teaches mathematics, and at New Haven Dean Wright gives courses in Latin; and such professorial activity of deans is the rule in practically all the col- leges. Plainly, therefore, Mr. Keppel’s selection is a marked break with tradi- tion. Indubitably, the vast increase in the size of a college like Harvard or Colum- bia carries with it such an enlargement of the duties and responsibilities of a dean as to have long ago foreshadowed absorption of the time of Even with the creation their total any one man. of special deans for the various grad- undergraduate schools, the uate and work has grown apace. But more im- portant than this is a marked tendency the country over to create solely execu- tive positions in colleges and universt- ties. It is a new academic career which is drawing into the life who may or may not have ability college men to

Page 10

156 teach, but are primarily interested in | executive work—men like Anson Phelps Stokes, jr., of Yale, and of Jerome D. Greene, secretary to the president of Harvard. Mr. Greene’s record in this! position gained him a vote for the pres!i- | dency of*the university when Mr. Low- ell was the successful candidate before the Board of Overseers. If men of Mr. Stokes’s type, men of means and social position, were to devote themselves to this new career instead of leading empty lives or spending themselves in the pur- suit of riches, the country would be far better off. Be this as it may, at Har- vard there are now two or three :nen besides Mr. Greene who are devoting themselves exclusively to executive work of a weighty character. Treasur- ers, bursars, and secretaries who were business men there have long been; but the man who performs executive duties alone, yet ranks with the instructors and sits with the faculty, is distinctly a modern development. From the point of view of the teach- er there can be no complaint about this Many pro- fessors are overburdened with executive work; they must run their department organizations, sit tees of every sort, and perform aamin- Some, new academic reinforcement. in faculty commit- istrative duties that never end. of course, enjoy this as an offset to the routine of teaching. For others with a distaste for business and fully absorbed in the dreams of the scholar or the re- search of the scientist, the coming of the practical man of affairs is certain To hitcha genius to a plough is ever an act of collegiate world to be a cause of satisfaction. folly—how great the recognized when Columbia University lost George E. Woodberry and could not use the talents of MacDowell. Men of this type are too precious to be wasted in the routine of administra- tion; a college could well afford to hire others to do the kind of work from which the teacher who lives in his books and in his classes shrinks. At the same time, it would be a mis- fortune if too many of a college's teach ing staff should be freed from all touch with the business side of The scientist who devotes himself ex- clusively to research and abandons all college life. teaching, ment. But if teaching reveals to a man the extent and solidity of his own knowledge as nothing else can, a certain handicaps his own develop: | Na [ Vol. 90, No. 2329 The tion. amount of executive work, the give-and- take of the faculty debate and commit- tee discussion, the facing of practical problems, the coming into contact with the undergraduate from another point of view than that of the classroom—all these have their great benefit for the average professor. Where to draw the line is the question. At Harvard Pres- ident Lowell’s programme looks to re- lieving men of promise both as regards their teaching and administrative cares, in order that they may have time not | with all the more gusto because it of- | fered relief from the horrors they had just escaped. ' Yet it would be quite wrong to speak of the new play or its author as if they | would only profit by the enormous ‘notoriety they have come in for. The |money returns will undoubtedly be great. Given the réclame that “Chan- tecler” has enjoyed, and it is useless, from the manager’s point of view, to at- ‘tempt to discuss the play on its merits. London and New York and Milwaukee only for research, but for creative writ- | ing. Dr. Lowell is probably not un-| aware of the criticism that few telling books are now coming from the Har-| vard faculty, when one considers its ac- knowledged ability; and what is true at Harvard is true elsewhere. If the new academic executive can help to lift the burdens from the men who have a mes- sage to convey or genuine knowledge to set forth, he will speedily appear in all our college communities. THE FAME OF “CHANTECLER” That part of the world which points an accusing finger at M. Edmond Ros- tand and calls him a consummate eself- advertiser, can scarcely be blamed. The history of “Chantecler” carries about it all the earmarks of the press-agent’'s art as it was elaborated more than a hun- dred years ago by Mr. Puff in Richard Brinsley Sheridan's “Critic.” Rostand’s latest play has profited by the puff di- rect, the puff preliminary, the puff col- lateral, the puff collusive, and all the other forms of stimulating a sluggish | public interest that the long experience of mankind has developed. fore the play was staged Coquelin went about reciting entire half- pages from the text. From the Gascon village where Rostand was at work came stories of heroic effort and heroic | despair that prepared the world for the | birth of a masterpiece. Rumor spoxe of | incidents reminiscent of Virgil’s throw- ing his “Aeneid” into the fire. The lat- er developments are a matter of contem- porary and universal fame—Coquelin’s death, the search for a substitute, the painful and palpitating series of re- hearsals and postponements. There was not even wanting a great national ca- lamity to serve as a sombre background for the great national play. Parisians must have turned towards “Chantecler” Years be-| the elder) | would accept it even if it were entirely |lacking in dramatic action, in human interest, and in poetic appeal. London and New York and Milwaukee would accept it even if it were the greatest |dramati¢ poem in all literature. But the perils of swollen publicity are as heavy as its financial rewards. Unavoid- ‘ably, it creates among the better class of readers and theatre-goers a prejudice |against the much-acclaimed masterpiece |/which it will find hard to live down. Publicity is a beast that turns upon its own children and rends them. The newspapers reduce all subjects to an ap- parently common plane of turbid puff- ery. If the newspapers the world over go mad over “The Merry Widow” and go mad over “Chantecler,” the natural result is to reduce Edmond Rostand’s play to the level of Franz Lehar’s. The grosser attributes of fame will be the portion of both men, just as they were the portion of the author of “Trilby.” There will be “Chantecler”’ hats and storm shoes and neckbands. There may even be a “Chantecler” cocktail for gen- tlemen who are not accustomed to go home until morning. It may be argued, however, that such temporary and tinselled fame cannot ,harm a real work of art. When the shouting of the multitudes dies, the quieter spirits will come out of their hiding place and render their verdict. If “Cyrano de Bergerac” was a great | work of art, it was none the less a work |of art because it swept around the world | like wildfire. We may go further. We may assert that no amount of adver- | ising can create the tremendous en- thusiasm with which Cyrano was re | ceived, and that such enormous vogue is in itself proof of exceptional merit in a play or a book. All this may be con- ceded, and yet the difference pointeé out that “Cyrano de Bergerac” made its own

Page 11

Feb. 17, 1910] way, while “Chantecler” will make its | way, so far as the multitude is concern- | ed, because it is by a famous author who spent seven years in writing the play. By all accounts, “Chantecler” has nothing of the melodramatic swing, the romance, the sentiment, or the boister- ous humor that brought the worid to Cyrano’s feet. When the new play was written, Rostand, who is credited with a shrewd insight into practical things, must have known that it might daze the crowds but could scarcely win them. He wrote for his own Parisian audicnce and for the select few the world over. It was the higher taste of his age that he aimed at. If, on the way, there was an honest penny to be picked up, where was the harm? But it would be unjust to take it for granted that M. Rostand reasoned after such a mercantile fashion. How much of the réclame that surrounds “Chantevler” is due to the poet’s efforts and how much to the efforts of his business agents? We can assign the latter their full share without holding the author blameless. It is absurd, on the one hand, to imagine that the years’ delay in the production of “Chantecler” was a mere device to tickle the public palate; if Rostand’s motives were mercenary, he would have made the greatest haste to reap the profits that were his in any case. On the other hand, there is no denying that the writing ot the new play was carried on to the ac- companiment of an extraordinary num- ber of cymbals and lutes, of sackbuts and psalteries. Did Rostand bare his heart to the world for commercial rea- sons? We need not go so far. We find an adequate reason in the traditional conceit and vanity of the man of genius. Whose head should have been turned by success if not Rostand’s? To leap from comparative obscurity into fame, wealth, a seat in the Academy, an the acknowledged successorship to Victor Hugo was enough to make any man ac- cept himself as a favorite of the gods. If henceforth he assumed that the world must be interested in his daily progress, the ailment was a very human one. But whereas formerly the excesses of genius were a natural and commonplace thing, upon by the turned to to-day they are seized genius of publicity and gain. The Nation. SHELLEY.—II. V. I am aware that my criticism of Shel- ley may seem harsh and prosaic, yet 1 am really saying nothing which cannot be confirmed by the words of Mr. Clut- ton-Brock, and even by the opinions, less openly avowed perhaps, of the more whole-hearted Shelleyans. It is scarce- ly doing violence to draw such support even from a critical work like Arthur Symons’s “Romantic Movement,” which is written with the avowed purpose otf exalting the work of Blake and Cole- ridge and Shelley as the final criterion of poetry. Mr. Symons does indeed Jook upon Shelley as an enchanter who “never mistakes the images which he calls up for realities,” but, with that ex- traordinary contradiction which dogs all such critics, he adds immediately that “Prometheus” is “a cloudy proces- sion of phantoms, seen in a divine hal- lucination.” Even more significant is that strangely-fated essay on Shelley by the late Francis Thompson. Dithyrambic praise has never poured itself out in more intoxicated language than in some of these paragraphs: It (‘Prometheus Unbound’’] is unquestion- ably the greatest and most prodigal exhibi- tion of Shelley’s powers, this amazing lyric world, where immortal clarities sigh past in the perfumes of the blossoms, populate the breathings of the breeze, throng and twinkle in the leaves that twirl upon the bough; where the very grass is all a-rustle with lovely spirit-things, and a weeping mist of music fills the air. The final scenes especia!ly are such a Bacchic reel and rout and revelry of beauty as leaves one stag- gered and giddy; poetry is spilt like wine, music runs to drunken waste. The chorus- es sweep down the wind, tirelessly, flight after flight, till the breathless soul almost cries for respite from the unrolling splen- dors. Yet these closing scenes are “neverthe- less the artistic error of the poem’; yet Shelley wrote “with some misdirected view to truth’; yet in religion and mor- als “his methods were perniciously mis- taken”; yet “his theory was repulsive but comprehensible”; and “the spell on which depend such necromantic castles is some spirit of pain charm-poisoned at their base.’ That charm-poisoned spirit was nothing less than the peculiar ro- mantic illusion of the Revolution which ignored the native impulse of evil, ever lurking in the heart of man, ready to leap forth when its chains are shaken, and which valued the emotions in ac cordance with their mere spontaneity and intensity. If, notwithstanding these admissions, the true Shelleyan still cherishes the “Prometheus” and “The Revolt of Islam” as great and beautiful powers in the intellectual world, the issue becomes a matter of emphasis, or, rather, of ex- clusions in taste. What really appeals to the romantic idealist in the spirit 157 of these poems, in their total effect, is a kind of elusive, yet rapturous, ema- nation of hope devoid of specific con- tent. The poet may look upon the world of living men with perverted gaze, but his truth is faith in the fu- ture; he is “a being prophetic of some higher state to which mankind shail at- tain”; and from the intoxication otf this sheer hope the destinies of man- kind become like the vision of the char- iots of the Hours: In each there stands A wild-eyed charioteer urging their flight. Some look behind, as flends pursued them there, And yet I see no shapes but the keen stars: Others, with burning eyes, lean forth, and drink eager speed, As if the thing they loved fled on before, And now, even now, they clasped it. Their bright locks Stream like a comet's flashing hair: they all Sweep onward. With lips the wind of their own There is at least something in this that seems dynamic, a power to make man hope till Hope creates From its own wreck the thing it contem plates. And indeed it is on this power, without of its direction, that Mr. Clut ton-Brock bases his admiration; Shelley “in his worst errors account to him . Was far more admirable and less mischiey ous than those who persuade us to sub mit to the mere mechanism of life by their own comfortable submission to it." Shall we, then, end here? The right comparison, I maintain, is not with those sunk in the comfortable mechanism of life, but rather with those strong poets of the true romance, who can hope and still maintain the balance of common-sense. I am bold to assert that this surrender hope without thought of the thing it contemplates is possible only to a mind which has, in a sense, been debauched by false ideas and vain reading; that a mind deeply nourished on the true poets may for a time and by a sort of self-violence suf fer itself to become inflated with this wind of vanity, but cannot long forget the actual outcome of that spirit in the poet's own life and its sterility or false ness in dealing with the actual motives of mankind. It is no sufficient answer to say that the veritable of Shelley's hope is love, for the scope of to content this emotion is left equally vague, it not morbid, as the other. It is a long hope to build on the power which ‘makes the reptile equal to the God"; nor will that power convey much satis- faction to the heart that has sustained itself on the amor of Catullus in this world or on that of Dante in the vision- ary spheres. Love without a true un- derstanding of evil is meaningless. VI. Or it may be that your Shelleyan

Page 12

158 eschews philosophy and ideas altogeth- er, caring only for the poet’s musical evocation of beauty. To such a one, as to Francis Thompson, the “Prometheus” is like a magical incantation, under the spell of which forms of fleeting iri- descent loveliness float before his dream-open eyes: Dim twilight-lawns, and stream-illumined caves, wind-enchanted shapes of wandering mist. And That is an innocent and blissful kind of inebriation, very desirable, no doubt, in a world too much given to seeking its escape from prose in quite other and baser ways; but he who indulges there- in should beware of speaking of this phantom realm as if it were peopled with ideas. There is a beauty of dream- ing and a beauty of waking; they are sisters both and daughters of the gods, but only one is acknowledged on Olympus. If you desire to know them apart, read in “Prometheus” of the voices that emanate from those wind- enchanted shapes: Canst thou imagine where those spirits live Which make such delicate music in the woods? ’Tis hard to tell: I have heard those more skilled in spirits say, The bubbles, which the enchantment of the sun Sucks from the pale faint water-flowers that pave The oozy bottom of clear lakes and pools, Are the pavilions where such dwell and float Under the green and golden atmosphere Which noon-tide kindles thro’ the woven leaves; And when these burst, and the thin flery air, The which they breathed within those lu- cent domes, Ascends to flow like meteors thro’ the night, They ride on them, and rein their headlong speed, And bow their burning crests, and glide in fire Under the waters of the earth again. Read that and then recall Adam's ac count to Eve of the music that haunted the woods of Paradise: How often from the steep Of echoing hill or thicket have we heard Celestial volces to the midnight air. The change is a transition from dream ing to the sober certainty of waking bliss; from a bubble-blown phantasma- goria to the ecstasy of intellectual beauty. The fact is that if you press the mean- ing from all but the very few unreagon ing worshippers of Shelley, you will find that they regard his long poems, organically conceived, as of a_ kind which the world would willingly let die, and that they really cherish him for the strains of lyric ecstasy caught up In the amorphous mass. criticism, That is fair and a man may pass over The Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2329 much in the waiting expectation for those scattered strains of music, Clear, silver, icy, keen, awakening tones Which pierce the sense and live within the soul. Of Shelley, taken merely as the author of a group of lyrics, brief in compass but exquisite in melody and feeling, quite another account might be given than this I am writing. Here, whether in independent songs or in _ sbort strains that can be detached from their context without any mark of in- completeness, here, when he expresses a purely personal joy or sorrow, love or regret, his genius suffers no let or thwarting; it is even strengthened by that romantic acceptance of the emo- tions. That is the Shelley of the young man’s and the maiden’s passionate ad- miration: Music, when soft voices die, Vibrates in the memory— Odors, when sweet violets sicken, Live within the sense they quicken. Rose leaves, when the rose is dead, Are heap'd for the beloved’s bed; And so thy thoughts, when Thou art gone, Love itself shall slumber on. VII. But it is necessary to add that even this wonderful lyric vein is subject at times to a kind of defeat from excess of the very power that produced it. “Adonais” is commonly reckoned, and no doubt is, the most perfect of his longer lyrics; yet the best stanzas of that poem, those that contain lines which have sung themselves into the memory of the world, are almost always marred by lapses into the vague and inane. There is no greater stanza in the elegy than the forty-fifth: The inheritors of unfulfilled renown Rose from their thrones, built beyond mortal thought, Far in the Unapparent. Chatterton Rose pale, his solemn agony had not Yet faded from him; Sidney, as he fought And as he fell and as he lived and loved Sublimely mild, a Spirit without spot, Arose; and Lucan, by his death approved: Oblivion as they rose shrank like a thing reproved. The literary inspiration of those lines (and in pointing to this I mean no dis- paragement of Shelley's originality) is clearly born from a kind of mystical blending of Virgil's Heu, miserande puer! si qua fata aspera rumpas, Tu Marcellus eris and of Milton's So were I equal'd with them in renown, There are lines in Shelley's stanza—the first and the eighth, particularly—which are in no wise diminished by this asso- clation with two of the most celebrat- ed passages in literature; yet a com- parison of the stanza as a whole with the full parts of the “Acneid” and “Par- adise Lost” shows quite as clearly the | weakness of Shelley. It is inconceiv- able that Virgil or Milton should have | held so loose a rein on his genius as to sink from “The inheritors of unfulhlled | renown” to the vapid “Far in the Unap- parent,” or should have dropped imme- diately from the magnificent directness of Shelley’s eighth verse (which rings like Lucan himself when most Roman) to the vague allegory of Oblivion shrink- ing reproved. It would not be difficult to extend this kind of criticism to a considerable num- ber of Shelley’s most admired lyrics— to show, for instance, that the throb- bing and tumultuous music of the great “Ode to the West Wind” straggies here and there to unmelodious conclusions, chiefly because the poet—like all his English compeers—disdained the irher- ent laws of the terza rima as these are exemplified in the works of Dante and the lesser Italian masters of the meas- ure. There is no other metre in which it is so imperative to mould the thought to the pauses of the rhythm, under pen- alty of letting the rhymes hang as an impertinence instead of a support; but this lesson none of the English voets learned, and least of all was Shelley capable of such wise docility. Nevertheless, granted that “Adonais” may occasionally descend into bathos, if it contains also images of pure and radiant beauty, why not give ourselves to these, and pass the errors by? Doubt- less that is the part of wisdom, se far as it is feasible; but here again we are blocked by certain insurmountable ex- clusions of taste. There is a pleasure, the highest critical joy, in the perfec- |tion and harmonious unity of such work as Milton’s “Lycidas,” and he who has trained his mind to respond to that joy has by the very process rendered him- self sensitive to false and obtrvsive /notes. He simply cannot read the stanza quoted from “Adonais” without suffer- |ing from the spirit of perversity en- 'gaged within it. It is true, no doubt, |that there are blemishes—occasional awkwardnesses of execution, failures of | the imagination, even lapses of taste of |a kind—which may not affect essential- ily our attitude toward an extoasive work of art; but they are not the taults | which throw a suspicion of obliquity or | vanity upon the very sources of the art- ‘ist’s inspiration. These, I say, are the inevitable exclu- sions of taste. If a man avers that the thorough appreciation of “Lycidas” |}does not exclude for him an unmarred | pleasure in “Adonais,” I can only sus- | pect that he has never felt the full force of the former. This is by no means to say that the enjoyment of Milton deadens a man to all lower forms of lit- erature. The commonplace or the small may in its own sphere be commendable and may afford a true relish to the fin- ‘est palate; and, indeed, one of the func- tions of criticism is to set forth and so

Page 13

Feb. 17, 1910] far as possible rescue from oblivion the inexhaustible entertainment of the !ess- er writers. But the humble is another thing than the false, the false is nox- ious just in proportion to the elevation of the genius to which it adheres. ‘l here is nothing mutually exclusive in the complete enjoyment of both Milton and Crabbe; it is at least questionable whe- ther the same man can heartily admire both Milton and Shelley. P. E. M. Correspondence. AN UNPUBLISHED BROWNING LETTER. To THE EpITorR oF THE NATION: Sir: Not long ago, while hunting for something else in a heap of old letters, I happened to find a letter from Robert Browning which, I think, I had not seen for twenty years or more. It is dated at “19 Warwick Crescent, London, April 8th, 1887,"" and is a reply to one of mine in which I had asked him about certain ap- parent misprints in “‘Colombe’s Birthday,” and had criticised his use of “demean”’ in the sense of “degrade’”’ or ‘“‘debase,”’ where Berthold says of the chamberlain: He'd hesitate A doubt his lady could demean herself So low as to accept me. One of the misprints was “crowding” in the phrase “crowding attestation,” as printed in the English “library” edition of 1888 (Act i, line 175). I had no doubt that it should be “crowning,” as in the first edition (1844), and printed it so, with the approval of Miss Hersey, in our edition of the play, published just before I wrote the letter to Browning. I also called the at- tention of Mr. Scudder to it, as he was then at work on the “Riverside” edition of Browning; but he declared that “crowd- ing’ must be the poet’s own alteration, and insisted on retaining it in the first issue of his edition. If the reader will look at the context in the play, he will see that there was a certain plausibility in the editor’s opinion. The other misprint to which Browning alludes is “‘conjecture” for “conjuncture” (Act. v, line 189: “For each conjuncture was she great enough’); but there could be no doubt about that. Now for the letter, which reads thus: Dear Mr. Rolfe: “Crowding’’ and ‘“con- jecture”’ are two vile misprints in the stereotype English edition—full of such They come of the printer’s laziness, who, if the’ type gets misplaced, prefers to re- place it as he best can, without troubling the “Reader” [that is, the prvofreader], who may not be at hand. The “grey, smooth chamberlain” is rightly given, how- ever. {[This, by the way, which occurs in the line preceding “‘demean,” was right in the stereotype edition, but not in the first edition, which misprints “grew’’ for “‘grey.”’ I was sure that it was a misprint, though somebody had suggested that it might be equivalent to “grewsome.’’] I take “demean herself’ in the sense of the familiar French word whence it is de- rived—‘"se démener’’—to behave in an un- usual manner—‘‘se démener comme uh possédé"; and qualify it accordingly by the adverb “low,” not “much,” as would be proper if the word “‘demean” could ex- plain itself sufficiently. ‘The Nation. I had occasion only yesterday to point out to a correspondent the particular mis- fortune to which verse—rather than prose is subject. A stop drops from the end of a iine, which thus is suffered to run into the following one, making nonsense enough. There are dozens of instances of this in my own poems, and I never remem- ber one which was corrected by a critic In my own case, there has been no care- lessness in proof-correcting; but after the author's best is done, the printer's worst may indulge itself. In my last poem the word “palette” is given once correctly, and a second time as ‘palate.’ Believe me, Dear Sir, yours very sin- cerely, ROBERT BROWNING Browning's “last poem,” mentioned § in the “Parleyings,” “Furini’—the “palette” occurs twice; but it is printed correctly in all the editions I That book published in 1887, before wrote to me. his where- letter, was probably in the word have was apparently he So far as I am aware, Browning was the only man on earth who ever attempted to justify the misuse of “demean” when his attention was called to its origin and the related noun “demeanor”; and his defence of it is very lame It is derived, as he says, from the French démener; but that word has not, and never did have, the sense of “degrade” or “debase.” I do not know where he found his definition, “to be- have in an unusual manner”; but that is not necessarily a bad or disgraceful man- ner. The word does sometimes mean to be “agitated” or “excited,” but, whether that is “unusual” or not, it not in itself imply anything base or degrading But, if we look into the history French word, we find that originally it meant to “lead,” “conduct,” or “guide,” thence, to “drive” (animals or vehicles), and reflexively to conduct or behave one’s self—coming to refer to “behavior,” just as “conduct” (with the similar original mean- ing) has done Etymologists have times been puzzled to explain its connec- tion with the early Latin minare (classical minari), from which it is but which came to mean does of the some- derived " But clearly “threaten that word originally meant to “lead,” “con- duct,”” and the like; but being specifically used with reference to the driving of cat- tle, which involves threatening cries or ejaculations, it came to have the idea of threatening associated with it. This is the only explanation that seems to have been suggested by Latin, French, Italian, and English lexicographers, including the edi- tors of the New English or Oxford Dic- tionary As to the misuse of ‘‘demean,” the Eng- glish etymologists all now agree that it arose from the erroneous supposition that the word was derived from “‘mean."’ As long ago as 1847 Sullivan pointed this out in his dictionary: but the revised quarto We! ster, about forty-five years ago (in 18647) gave “‘debase,”’ ‘‘degrade,”” as one sense of “demean"”; quoting Shakespeare for it in “The Comedy of ‘ Errors” (iv, 3,83), whe re Luciana says Antipholus is mad Else would he never so demean himeelf that is, behave himself, as it mear t every instance in which the dramatist it. If the dictionary editors had turned to “3 Henry VI" (i, 4, 7), they would have found this passage: Rot this I know, they have demean'd ’ Like men born to renown, by fe or I called their attention to this, among 1 in their ” t am -_ other errors, and it was corrected next revision Another bad slip of Browning's was his assumption, in a note to “Paracelsus,” that had in the turgid style of the lectures of Para- the modern word “bombast” its origin celsus. It was actually suggested by the original meaning of the word, namely. cot- ton, or “cotton wool” (from the Latin hbombyar) The earliest instance of bom- bast,”’ or “‘bumbast.”’ cited by the Oxford Dictionary, is in 1568; and in 1572 it is mentioned as used for stuffing doublets, the ld padded coats for men It soon came to be used figuratively of inflated or turgid language; as in ‘‘Love’s Labour's Lost" (v. 2, 791) pleasant jest and comedy, \s bombast and as Haing to the time Wher ] ng ex] saive i iffed s in “Othello” (i, 1, 13) A bombast circumstar iH biy stuff’d with epithets of war Sundry other etymological slips of Brown- ing could be cited, if space permitted; the worst one, the monumental one, we might call it, being his use of twat, Pippa Passes.”’ W. J. Ror ( ubridge, January 18 THE ENGLISH ELECTIONS Te THE Epitor or THR NATION SIR The general impression eem be that the Parllamentary elections in Eng land have resulted in a drawn battle 1: tween the Liberals and their Conservat!v opponents. This view overlooks some sig nificant facts It ‘should be remembered first, that this was no ordinary battle, but a distinct fight against hereditary pri for radical « changes which were universally recognized as strik llege and onomi ng at the very root of the special advan tages enjoyed by the great landowner f Great Britain On this issue the Lib eral party was undeniably the econ choice of virtually all who voted for th: Labor candidates. While the policy of the Irish Nationalists subordinates all other | sues to Home Rule, no person acquainted with the history of landlordism in Ireland can doubt that on the Budget as a ep arate issue the Irish sympathies are with the reform of Lloyd-George On face of the returns, therefore, the vot have declared unequivocally for the prin ciples on which the Liberal party has ap pealed to them To realize the full force of the Li'beral ' or however, it Is necessary to go be hind the returns In a conflict betwee. the privileged and the disinherited clas it should be emphasized that privileg: must profit largely by the limitatior m posed on the franchise in the British Isles Where property, and hot manhood, ig the ba if suffrage, conservatism has an un fair advantage It is alleged n { lia of the British property qualifi that a very low limit mposed mount g » about fifty dollars a yea s rent for householders, occupiers, and nigers The ystem of registration, however, re quires a continuous residence of eight months in one place for this class, failing which the vote ia loet Thia strik rl leadly blow at the immense body

Page 14

i The Nation. [Vol. 90, No. 2329 chanics belonging to the more migratory trades, and disfranchises hundreds of thou- sands of them at each election. Domestic servants and bachelors living at home are further specifically denied thelr rights as citizens. It has been statistically shown that where manhood suffrage prevails, the proportion of voters at a general election in four. In Great Britain, however, average is about one in six At the general election, in 1906, the number of voters was 7,266,708. Under full manhood suffrage, the number would have been more than 10,000,000. It can scarcely be seriously contended that any consider- able proportion of the disfranchised 3,000,- would favorably disposed to the class which Is the cause of their depriva- tion of citizen The the is about one the last 000 be rights. also favored A man residence in in each landholders are of plural voting or nominal more boroughs may The law is thus made to favor the expense of misrepresenting great by system owning property two or vote of them wealth, at the real sentiment of the people The exact number of plural voters is not easy to determine; but it is sufficient to play an important part in a close election. In 1 campaign having the taxation of land values as its central issue, hardly one of these plural land-votes would be cast otherwise than on the side of the land- holders. Another most serious factor is found in the immense number of tenant farmers throughout England. While it is true that the old “rotten boroughs” have been large- ly formed out of existence, the oppor- tunities for indirect but none the less ef- fective coercion of votes by the great land- lords remain enormous. The intimidatory proclamation of the Duke of Sutherland to his tenants is but a single illustration of the degree to which an unprincipled landlord is able to interfere with the prin- ple of free and impartial suffrage. How many tens of thousands of votes were won to the Conservatives by this unscrupu- lous method, can never be known; but it can certainly not be negligible Other elements of the situation might be brought to attention, such as the natural hesitation of the English people in the face of novel propositions of taxation, the dread of Socialism so cleverly though dishonestly played on by the spokesmen for the Lords, the mistakes of the Under such 1 combination the 1ctual success of the Liberals at the polls the war scare, and Liberal party on minor issues of adverse influences, must be taken to represent the real de ire of an overwhelming majority of the ritish people If the Budget nvolving the taxation of land values, is deliberately ratified at the polls by the majority of an electorate confined to property-owners and those of the working population most fa yrably ituated and having least cause for complaint at the existence of special privilege, a full, honest, and unintimidated vote of the people of Great Britain would aseuredly have buried the Conservative party and the House of Lords so deep as to destroy all hope of resurrection BoLTOon HAL! New York, February AN AMERICAN POETESS OF 1759. To THE EpiTror oF THE NATION: Str: In a fragment of the Universal Magazine for March, 1759, I find this early fruit of the American muse: The RAK E. By a Lady in New England. Video meliora proboque, Deteriora sequor. Hor. An open heart, a gen’rous mind, But Passion’s slave, and wild as wind: In theory a judge of right, Though banish’d from its practice quite; So loose, so prostitute of soul, His nobler wit becomes the tool Of ev'ry importuning fool: A thousand virtues misapply'd, While Reason floats on Passion’s tide. The ruin of the chaste and fair; The parent's curse, the virgin’s snare; Whose false example leads astray The young, the thoughtless, and the gay: Yet, left alone to cooler thought, He knows, he sees, he feels his fault; He knows his fault, he feels, he views, Detesting what he most pursues: His judgment tells him, all his gains For fleeting joys are lasting pains: Reason with Appetite contending; Repenting still, and still offending: Abuser of the gifts of Nature; A wretched, self-condemning creature; He passes o’er Life's ill-trod stage, And dies, in youth, the prey of age!— The scorn, the pity of the wise Who love, lament him—and despise! Perhaps some American antiquary may be able to identify this apt quoter of Horace. WILLIAM E, A. AXON. Southport, England, December 11. THE CARNEGIE FOUNDATION. To THe EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching has issued some new regulations for the awarding of pen- sions (see Science, January 14, 1910). These regulations differ from the preceding ones mainly in the omission of the service pen- At present, a teacher in an accredited university cannot retire on a pension until he reaches the advanced age of sixty-five— unless, to sure, he retires under the disability of which it is needless sion. be clause, to relate here. Prof. Arthur O. Lovejoy has discussed these changes in the Nation for February 3. It is not the purpose of this letter to comment on any of the statements advanced him, but to draw attention to at least one other aspect of this important matter. Judging from conversations with profes- sors and from letters, the new regulations the teachers themselves with dis- couragement, if not with dismay. The opin- ion prevails that the Foundation will have accomplished at least one kind of advance- that of the age of full professors are still in the harness, In other if these regulations remain in ef- it is thought that the faculties of the will be filled with aging and aged men, who are clinging to their Jobs in an endurance test against time. It appears that this purpose is nearing accomplishment. In view of the wide difference of opinion evident between the directors of the Foun- dation, on the one hand, and the teachers on the other, may well believe that the new regulations would not have been adopt- ed had there been an abundance of funds If this by strike ment who words, fect, future we at the disposal of the Foundation. | be the fact, it is to be hoped that some | authoritative statement to this effect will | be issued by the Foundation, in order that ‘close and sympathetic relations may con- tinue to exist between the Carnegie Foun- | dation and its beneficiaries. Let me add, in conclusion, that I have |heard nothing but praise of the widow's | clause in the new regulations. RAYMOND WEEKS. Columbia University, February 10. EDOUARD ROD’S PATRIOTISM. TO THE EUVITOR OF THB NATION: Str: The name of Edouard Rod has been so identified with France and French let- ters that all except the Swiss are inclined to forget his Vaudois origin and certain things in his life and character, which bound him to his native land. His refusal to seek a place among the Forty, notwith- standing the advice of Comte d’'Hausson- ville, was inspired by patriotic sentiment. M. Charles Burnier says: One day when I spoke of the Academy to Rod, and asked him rather indiscreetly whether he had no legitimate ambition to enter it, he answered—it was at the time of the “Lys rouge’: “‘No, because I should be obliged to have myself naturalized as a Frenchman, and I _ consider’ that inélégant.” This attachment to his country was shown also by his custom of always spend- ing the summers in Switzerland, where he had residences in Valais and Vaud. ‘“‘The most beautiful object in the world,” he said, “is Lake Leman, between Rolle and Geneva.” A. A. Neuchatel, Switzeriand, February 1. ROSTAND AND TOM D’URFEY. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: The production of M. Rostand’s “Chantecler” gives additional piquancy to a notice, in the Dictionary of National Bi- ography, of a somewhat similar venture on the English stage two hundred years ago. In the account of Tom D’Urfey we find: In his burlesque, ‘“‘Wonders in the Sun; or, the Kingdom of the Birds,” a comic opera, he brought on the stage ac- tors dressed as parrots, crows, etc., and the business was farcical in the extreme. This justified the remark of Dryden, that “You don’t know my friend Tom as well as I do. I'll answer for it he will write worse yet!” JOHN M. CLAPP. February 7. Lake Forest, I1l,, Literature. -_-—_——— SVEN HEDIN’S EXPLORATIONS IN TIBET. Trans-Himalaya: Discoveries and Ad- ventures in Tibet. By Sven Hedin. With 388 illustrations and 10 maps. New York: The Macmillan Co. $7.50 net. In these two volumes which describe his latest journeys in Tibet, Dr. Sven Hedin carries us into a different re- gion from that traversed in his previous explorations: a region almost as little

Page 15

Feb. 17, 1910] The Nation. known as were Eastern Turkestan and | North Central Tibet before those explor- ations, ard not less remarkable in its physical character. Starting from Kashmir, he reached Ladakh, and, or- ganizing his party there, turned northward across the great Karakoram range of the Himalaya and travelled first northeastward, then eastward, then southeastward over the lofty plateau which lies at the back of the Himalayas, and is studded with small lakes, most of which have no outlet to any ocean. Far down to the east he reached the great river Tsanpo, or upper part of the Brahmaputra, and the famous Buddhist shrine of Shigatse. Thence he turned back west, up the Brahma- putra till he reached its source. Near it lie the sacred Mansarowar lakes, where he spent some time thoroughly explor- ing their neighborhood. Thence turn- ing north and determining the head stream and very springs of the indus where they issue from the ground, he turned west, and after almost reaching Ladakh, started back again on a second journey to the north and east, in which he crossed his former route, traversing valleys and crossing ranges hitherto unvisited, till at last he again reached the borders of British India and de- scended upon Simla, its summer capi- tal. To describe these wanderings in detail would be useless, because the names of the mountains, lakes, and rivers he passed are nearly all of them new, even to the scientific geographer, and the tracks followed could not be made intelligible without a map. Suffice it tosay that Dr. Hedin traversed, along routes previously unknown to any but the scanty native population, and s.me- times running through pathless wilder- nesses, a region some six hundred miles long and fully three hundred broad, con- cerning nearly the whole of which scarce anything was previously known. This is a real service to geography, which well deserve the honors paid in Europe to this courageous and resourceful ex- plorer. If we say that Dr. Hedin is a better traveller than a writer, we do not mean to disparage his narrative style, which is simple, clear, and straightforward. He describes the incidents of each day’s march in a plain, unvarnished way which gives the reader a sense of what the actual conditions of travel are in a wild, lonely, dreary country, where the hardships of cold, dirt, and other forms of physical discomfort find compen- sation in the grandeur of snowy peaks, of vast prospects, and of brilliant at- mospheric effects. His occasional bursts of sentiment, which have the genuine naiveté of the Scandinavian spirit, as we know it in writers like Bjérnson and Jonas Lie, are altogether winning. But he has not the gift (or if he has, he does not use it) of presenting any gen- eral view of the phenomena he has ob- served. Two or three chapters, summar- izing the general results of his expedi- tions and describing in a broad way the features of the country and the life of the people, would have been both help- ful and interesting, for they would have put those features in a form which the reader would have found it more easy to comprehend and to remember. We must, however, recognize a _ difficulty which Dr. Hedin himself mentions. His publishers imposed on him limits of space which obliged him to omit parts of his narrative, so that here and there we skip over long stretches of country. The book was becoming already so large that the publishers were probably well advised but the work might certainly have been better planned as a whole. To the reader who is not primarily a geographer, eager to comprehend the mountain structure of this extraordinary country, the most interesting parts of the book are those which describe the life, and especially the religious life, of the Tibetans. These people are almost as unlike the rest of mankind as their dwelling-place is unlike other countries. Sir J. D. Hooker, who ranks with Darwin as the most vivid and instructive of sci- entific travellers, long ago, in his “Him- alayan Journals,” described Tibet as “the highest, coldest, driest, barrenest, wind- lest region on earth’; and the extraor dinary isolation in which the Tibetans have lived for many centuries, cut off by deserts on the East, North, and West, and separated from India on the south by the gigantic barrier of the Himalaya has favored the development of a pe- culiar type of semi-civilization, and of a still more peculiar ecclesiastical sys- tem. The church of Tibet and the monas- ticism of Tibet offer strange, even gro- tesque, parallels, to some of the forms which Christianity took in the early centuries and in the Middle Ages. But, even apart from this parallelism of their phenomena, they are in themselves well worthy of study. Dr. Hedin does not treat them sys- tematically, but he gives us some in- teresting lights on the external aspects of the Tibetan religion, in which Bud- dhism is curiously intermixed with spir- it worship and other forms of primi tive superstition. The centre and metropolis of the Tib- etan church, is, of course, Lhasa, the preéminently sacred city, in which the Dalai Lama resides, and which, down till the recent British expedition, had heen visited by no European, save the French Abbé Huc (in disguise) some seventy years ago. Now, however, the written by Englishmen who formed part of that expedition, have made it so well known, that curiosity began to fix itself upon another city of scarcely Inferior sanctity, Shigatse, with the famous mon- astery of Tashi Lunpo, where dwells the Tashi Lama, or Panchen Rinpoche (holy teacher), second in dignity cnly books 161 to him of Lhasa. At the time of Dr. Hedin's journey, the Dalai Lama, who had fled at the approach of the British forces, was st‘ll far away in the North, © so the Tashi Lama was virtually head of the church for the time being, and to see him was an extraordinary privilege. Dr. Hedin achieved it and his descrip- tion of this Buddhist Pope is worth quoting: We go higher up smooth, steep staircases to open landings, up more steps, higher and higher, to the Holiest of Hollies, in the Monastery of Tashi Lunpo. The conversa- tion is carried on in lower, more subdued tones. * We enter, not I make a deep bow at the door, and more before I stand before him. The Tashi Lama is sitting on a bench in a window re- and has in front of him a table with without feeling solemn. two cess a small teacup, a telescope, and some print- ed sheets. He is dressed as simply as an ordinary monk, wears a cerise costume of the usual style, coat, waistcoat, and vest, and the long scarf which is thrown over the shoulder and wound round the body like a toga. Between its folds peeps out a yel low under-vest, with gold embroidery. Both arms are bare, and the head uncovered His complexion is fair, slightly inclining to yellow. He is somewhat below the middle height, is well proportioned, looks healthy, and, having lately completed his twenty- fifth year, has every prospect of attaining a good old age. His short-cropped hair black, and there is scarcely any down on his upper lip. The lips are not thick and full like those of other Tibetans, but thin and gracefully formed; his eyes of a chest nut brown color There not a single idol, no wall painting, or any other decoration, scarce any furniture, not a thread of carpet, only the bare stone floor and through the window his melancholy and dreamy, but clear and open, glances wander ple dirt over the golden ter roofs, over the town below them, with its and sin, over the dreary mountains which bound his earthly horizon, and away through the azure blue sky to a Nirvana invisible to us, where his spirit will one day find rest But all the time he preserved a wonderful calmness, a refined, amiable politeness and dignity and spoke in a charmingly soft and sub- dued voice, modest, almost shy. We talked about all kinds of things in heaven and earth, beginning from his own religion, the which he the highest living prelates. He displayed an alertness, an interest in every in Pantheon of takes rank among thing, and an intelligence that surprised m« in a Tibetan at least (Vol. I, pp. 319 320.) the world does religion, of external bols bulk so in the eyes and minds of a people as Buddhism in Tibet. are in sight everywhere: a large part of the population dwell in them. The is, or was till the recent war gave the Chinese an opportunity for re asserting and making real their almost vanished suzerainty, the ruling power in the The tombs of saints and divers everywhere Nowhere perhaps in in the form observances, sym and largely does Monasteries church country. shrines stand

Page 16

162 [Vol. 90, No. 2329 The Nat along the tracks. Prayer flags and pen- but all sense of time itself is lost, and | nants float from poles on and around every building. Prayer mills are turned by the water of every stream, each flag, bearing the sacred formula, Hum" (Oh, the jewel so that every wav each mill, “Om Mani Padme in the lotus flower), ing of the flag, every revolution of the mill, repeats a prayer for the benefit in its future course of the soul of him who fixed the flag or the mill in its place. Nearly carries in his hand a a wheel everybody little which he turns round and round sits and talks, and which in each turn the by machine with as he mystic Nowhere, even the anchorites of the Thebaid in the fourth and fifth centuries of Christianity, or by the Cel tic hermits who placed themselves on isolated wave-washed rocks along the coasts of Ireland and Scotland in the sixth and seventh centuries, were the austerities of a life of solitude and pri- vation carried so far as they are to-day Tibetan lamas who immure in a or small stone which thereupon’ wall- leaving only one small aper- of tiny tunnel—through barely enough to sup- thrust in by some one from the nearest monastery. The soli- tary inmate, living in unbroken dark- ness, utters no word and hears none, It would be a deadly sin for the lama who brings his food to speak to him, and to speak, all the merit he has ing repeats again phrase. not by these themselves building up, a sort which food port life cave is ed ture is were he acquired by his mortification and se clusion would be thrown away. Dr. Hedin saw the outside of such a her- mitage, erected with very thick walls over a spring, the interior perfectly dark. Within it dwelt an anchorite who had already lived in silence for three years, and had vowed himself to perpetual seclusion. Should he _ not draw in the daily bow! of food, the lama who brings it might guess that he was ill, but not interfere. On'ty if ix days elapse without the bowl] being touched do the monks conclude that the dead, whereupon they break would inmate is open the enclosing wall, and bury him Dr. Hedin was told of a lama who had died fifteen years before, having entered this hermitage at the age of twenty, and spent forty years in it. A still more remarkable case was that of a devotee who had lived immured in the darkness of such a hermitage for sixty- nine years. It is hard to believe that the human frame can retain life for so long a period in a climate intensely cold In winter, with a supply of daily food extremely scanty, and always the same kind of food, and without a sin- gle ray of sunlight. One must suppose that the hermit, occupied solely in med- itation and in magic Om Mani, passes into a sort of stupor, In which not only day and night and summer and Winter pass unnoted, | the Nirvana which he seeks is practi- cally attained by a loss of individual consciousness itself as well as of all hu- man desires and passions. Intensely religious as the Tibetans are, after their fashion, and bent as they are on keeping all Kuropean strangers out of their country, they do to be intolerant. Muslims and move freely about among them, as well as Hindus; one of their most sacred spots is, in- deed, an object of equal veneration to Hindu pilgrims coming from the plains of India and to the Buddhist natives of the plateau. This is the Manasarowar Lake, called by the Tibetans Tso Ma- vang, a beautiful sheet of water, about sixteen miles wide, which lies between the source of the Brahmaputra to the southeast, and the source of the Indus to the north, at a height of 15,098 feet above sea level, three thousand feet higher than Lake Titicaca in Bolivia, and higher than the highest summit in the Rocky Mountains or the Sierra Ne- vada. Dr. Hedin, who prudently carried a small boat about with him, putting its pieces together when he had to use it, explored the lake to ascertain its depth, and had a perilous adventure on it in a storm, for this lofty plateau is a land of tempests. Indeed, his aquatic adven- tures om the lakes are the most thrill- ing in the book. North of the lake is the sacred mountain, which the Hin- dus call Kailas, and the Tibetans Kang Rinpoche. It rises from the plateau, here 15,000 to 16,000 feet in elevation, to a height of 21,818 feet, and may owe its especial sanctity not only to the proximity of the sacred lake, but to the peculiar form of its topmost peak, which resembles the Tib- etan shrine tomb consecrated to a saint. Immense numbers of pilgrims come from India, as well as Tibet, to make the cir- cuit of it. That circuit is twenty-eight miles long, and the path is in many places steep and rocky, but the wor- shipper will sometimes make it thirteen times in succession. The greatest mer- it is earned when the mountain is com- passed by a series of prostrations in which the devotee measures his own length along the ground all the way. Such a pilgrim body-circuit is equivalent in soul value to thirteen circuits made on foot. Whether the top of the moun- tain is accessible we are not told. Dr. Hedin does not seem to have ever climb- | ed any summits (as a regular Alpinist would have done), or to care about them; he tells us only about passes. not seem come up ' Perhaps the peak is deemed inaccesst- the repetition of the, ble; perhaps the spirits that dweli on it would repel a daring intruder. Any- how, it is, as Dr. Hedin observes, the most holy of all holy mountains; holier than Sinai or Ararat or Fuji Yama; hol- jer than any of the sacred heights of Europe, such as Monserrate in Spain or Croagh Patrick in Ireland. We have not space to dwell upon the endless difficulties which our traveller encountered in the constant efforts of the Tibetan authorities to turn him back. He evaded some of these by various stratagems and devices, but sometimes was forcea to yield and abandon routes he had hoped to take. It is all the more creditable to his tem- per and feeling that, in spite of these frequent struggles with the Tibetan of- ficials, he speaks warmly of the cour- tesy and kindliness of the people as a whole; observing with truth that it is far easier to succeed among semi-civil- ized or barbarous people by good hu- mor and gentleness of manner than by threats or violence. The name Trans-Himalaya, which he proposes to give to the long line of mountains separating the Upper Brah- maputra Valley from the isolated lake basins of northern Tibet, seems highly inappropriate. It suggests a _ region, not a mountain range, and his argu- ments in its favor leave us unconvinced. That is a matter for the scientific world to settle. Meantime, we congratulate him on a journey which reflects the greatest credit on his courage, his tact, and his endurance, and which has im- mensely increased our knowledge of this strange land and its people. CURRENT FICTION. The Journal of a Recluse. Transiated from the original French. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. The reading of this book leaves it easy to believe that the purported irans- lation is one of the tricks of the trade of authorship used to give a stronger ap- pearance of actuality to its origin. It is the story of a Scotchman born in hum- ble life who, having shown himseit of the stuff that meets emergencies, was privileged to receive an education on an equal footing with the young lord his master, and to share his travels and ex- periences so long as Lord Eliot Sived. At his patron’s early death he emigrat- ed to America and presently, under the influence of Thoreau’s writings, turned recluse on the Pacific Coast in the for- est lands of the State of Washington. Two thwarted love affairs strongly in- fluenced his life; one an undeclared af- fection for the sister of his young mas- ter; the other, a mutual passion be- tween himself and his niece, who first meets him when she is grown to wo- man’s estate. This temptation success- fully withstood, the hero turns his at- tention to education, agriculture, and to keeping a journal in French. There are few topics on which he does not dis- |course, bringing to bear on all a mix- ture of conservatism and free thought which would perhaps naturally result from the immersion of a Scotch brain

Page 17

Feb. 17, 1910] in advanced ideas. Himself a man ot simplicity and integrity, he has an in- tellectual passion of curiosity which leads him to give ear to every doctrine that comes his way, with a philosopher's indulgence to most things—unless it be the American system of education. To this he gives some eloquently hostile pages. Other chapters of his journal are de- voted to creeds and causes, to nature and civilization, to man and woman. Now he is as practical as Franklin, now as introspective as Amiel. He is old- fashioned enough to know “from ob- servation that there is nothing so fu- tile as these so-called reasonings be- tween children and aduits. They are taught to argue expertly on their own side, and the argument finishes usually by the yielding of the adult, because he has no longer the capacity for blind persistence that is a trait of youth.’ He is enough of a free lance to say, “For me religion is nothing but poetry petrified into dogma.” Through- out he is ready to take pains in behalf of such of his kind as he has siftea out and found deserving. A pricker of the bubbles of pretence, instability, and cowardice, he reveals himself as a ma- terialist with a diligent working sense of honor. Old Harbor. By William John Hop- kins. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. A year or two ago, with “The Clam- mer,” Mr. Hopkins captured a pleased audience. Its plot was nothing; but its very insignificance gave a charm to a delicate and fanciful treatment. There was, to be sure, a touch of self-con- sciousness about it, and “Old Harbor” confirms one’s suspicion that the earlier story was the tour de force of an ama- teur—if there be such a person separa- ble from the motley rout of our “fiction- ists.” “Old Harbor” attempts a thing which has repeatedly been done with more or less success. Our New England coast villages with a past have been pretty thoroughly exploited by dealers in local color. It is an interesting type for America—the little old port, once active in shipping, and now, with its stately mansions and rotting wharves, but a monument of the past. Mellow de- cay is a phenomenon to be cherished on this side of the water. But Mr. Hopkins has little or nothing fresh to offer in his interpretation. He has provided a sufficiently varied assortment of char- acters—but he has provided them. They have not made themselves alive through him. Consequently, the best we can say for them, one and all, is that they are suggestive of familiar types. Eben, the prodigal brother, who is in a way the most striking person in the story, is a figure of some pathos. His sister Har- riet is the New England spinster of tradition. “Clanky Beg” is one of the most artful idiots ever seen off any The Nation. stage, quite the god from the machine from start to finish of the action. Dr. Ol- cott, with his property nag, is the gruff and kindly country doctor of tradition —what rustic tale can get on without him? And so on. There are a drunken ne'er-do-weel, a stately gentleman of the old school, two proud and poverty-strick- en gentlewomen, a young artist, and a young coquette—who is reformed. For broad comedy, you have an Irish “Yarb” woman, and a Scotch apothecary, who occasionally exchange dialects without ceremony. Altogether, it is the kind of book that if you know rural New Eng- land, will remind you of people and things you have seen. But it is artificial —a series of reminders rather than a veritable interpretation. Sailors’ Knots. By W. W. Jacobs. York: Charles Scribner's Sons. The constant reader of Mr. Jacobs looks, nor looks in vain, for a renewal of entertainment with each new volume of. his salt coast sketches. His original- ity in inventing situations seems with- out limit. His wharves where night- watchmen sit and remember are the scenes of a wit that loses not its savor. And his tidy cottages in clean little streets, his cosey interiors and deft housekeeping, offset the antics of his characters in such wise as to make his work seem like Howarth illustrations in type. His drollegy is so gladdening that cheerful for a may be ac- corded an pin sd into serious- ness. The preg emmy for example, of a feal haunted house Gs background for one of his stories, “The Toll-House,” quickly passes out of mind on the read ing of “Double Dealing,” a quite perfect specimen of the author's art. New Great Possessions. By Mrs. Wilfrid Ward. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. A noted general, Sir David Bright, has been killed in the Boer war, and his young widow, Lady Rose, is horrified by the discovery that the will left with his solicitor insults both her and his own memory by leaving a mere pittance to her and the bulk of his enormous for- tune to a Madame Danterre, of whose existence she has hitherto been ignor- ant. An enigmatic message forwarded from the front by one of Sir David's comrades adds to Rose’s bewilderment. Madame Danterre, who has been black- mailing Sir David for years by alleging that he married her while he was de- iirious with fever, many years before his marriage to Rose, dies and leaves to her daughter, Molly Dexter, Sir Da- vid’s fortune and a distressing tempta- tion in the form of the will executed just before his death, reversing the pro- visions of the former document. Our old friend, the device of the mis-sent let- ters, comes valiantly to the front at 16¢ this point. Of course, Molly suppresses the will for a time, and revels in her ill-gotten wealth, only to find tt ap ples of Sodom: equally, of course, her conscience is ultimately too strong for her, and she departs to a life of ex piatory service and sacrifice, leaving Lady Rose—a true British type of blond and fragile loveliness, and a com pendium of all the virtues—to th joyment of her rights, and a somewhat tardy appreciation of the merits of the high-minded and self-effacing hero, who has been her lover since her childhood en GARIBALD I, Garibaldi and the Macaulay Trevelyan. With maps and Thousand. By George numerous illustrations. New York Longmans, Green, & Co. $2.25 net. Garibaldi is most fortunate in hay ing found at last a biographer who its enthusiastic but not uncritical. The life of the hero of the Defence of Rome and of the Sicilian Expedition must be told with all possible glow and color in or der to reproduce for readers to-day some of the romance which held his contemporaries spellbound. He 1s, in deed, the theme for a young historian. Mr. Trevelyan, though young, has ready had experience, in histori cal writing, and this experience enables him to keep balance throughout. Without being himself beglamoured, he causes us to feel the glamour of Gari baldi’s person and exploits. His first work on Garibaldi (“Gari baldi’s Defence of the Roman Repub lic,” 1907) left his hero in exile after the astonishing retreat from Rome; this volume begins with a description of him making candles in Meucci's fac Island. Then follows a rapid sketch of his wanderings, and of the progress of the Italian movement until Cavour, having won the support of Napoleon III, forced Austria to de- clare war in 1859. In that campaign Garibaldi carried on a brief but bril- liant guerrilla warfare along the Lakes. Next he appeared in the autumn &s a general in the army of the Central Ital- ian League; but just at the moment when he seemed about to precipitate an untimely invasion of Umbria, he listen- ed to Victor Emanuel’s advice, threw up his command, and retired like a reluctant eagle to his island crag. Mr. Trevelyan, having now reached his cen tral subject, narrates in greater detall the preliminary agitatfons in Sicily, the assembling of the Thousand, their de parture from Genoa and landing at Marsala, their amazing march to Paler mo and its capture. This logically con- cludes the first part of their marvellous enterprise. In a second volume the au- thor promises to complete the story of the Thousand. Such is the substance of the book. What are its qualities? In the first al wide his tory on Staten

Page 18

164 r “he Nation. [ Vol. 90, No. 2329 place, it is written in a brisk and sin-! uous style; next, its perspective is well | kept; thirdly, it is judicial; and, final-| ly, it is based on acquaintance with all the principal printed sources, and also unpublished documents and reminis- cences. Mr. Trevelyan excels, as read- ers of his earlier volume will recall, in describing military operations, cspe- cially if they be of the irregular kind in which Garibaldi often showed himself a master. But, both for strategy and conducting an engagement, he rates Garibaldi higher than a partisan leader; we incline to think, however, that Gari- baldi belongs with the wonderful Boer commanders, or with a raider like Mor- rather than with the Stonewall and the Shermans of large operations. Still, we have yet to see Mr. Trevelyan’s account of the battle ot the Volturno, and we must not forget that, whether he be classed as a glori- fied guerrilla or not, Garibaldi’s achieve- ment in 1860 produced results which few modern generals have equalled. Among the questions concerning the Expedition, none has been more acri- moniously debated than that of Cavour’s attitude toward its organization. The tendency of the Garibaldians has been to deny that he helped, and they have cited this or that incident to prove his the Cavourians, on the oth have asserted that, although the Prime Minister would have pre- ferred that there should be no expedi- tion at that time controlled by the Party of Action, he saw that it was safer to let them start than to risk an upheaval at home; and that, having taken this posi- tion, he actually gave them as much ald as he could without bringing ail the of Europe down on Piedmont. Trevelyan in general accepts the view, and traces with much dis- cernment the swiftly changing phases of the affair. This may serve as an ex- ample of his care to establish the prop- er relations between the political and the active forces in the episode gan, Jacksons opposition; er hand, cabinets Mr. latter Another point to be remarked upon, because it is representative, is his ac- curate study of topography. He tiaces the course of the Thousand from Mar- sala to Palermo with the minuteness of a map-maker; indeed, he has been over the route himself, and having an eye for the picturesque, he relieves what might otherwise be a painstaking de- scription of a military march by charm- ing bits of local color. Yet In spite of this gift, he never indulges in fine writ- ing for its own sake. The throbbing passages come quite naturally and are not pressed. In construction, the work is well planned; one topic leads to the next, and unless it be in the account of the approach of the various detachments to Palermo, there is never a lack of ciear- ness. Mr. Trevelyan writes to be read, and those readers who believe that his- torical writers of the highest class must | be full of human interest, will rejoice | _that the sacred staged structure, called that he, who is equally a scholar, has proved that this can be accomplished. We await eagerly his concluding work on Garibaldi and Cavour: for his sense of the signifiance of the Ri-| sorgimento is constantly expanding, and it will have a worthy theme in the final conflict between the great states- man and the modern paiadin. The Earliest Cosmologies. By William Fairfield Warren. New York: Baton & Mains. $1.50 net. Dr. Warren holds that the ideas of the Hebrews, Egyptians, Greeks, ILran- ians, and Indo-Aryans concerning the form of the universe were derived from Babylonia, and he finds in the ancient texts the following data for the recon- sfruction of the Babylonian universe: (1) The earth occupied the central place; (2) the northern half of the earth was viewed as the upper, the southern as the under; (3) the north- ern half was regarded as having the form of a seven-staged pyramid; (4) the under half was held to consist in like manner of seven stages; (5) the earth was four-cornered; (6) there were seven heavens and seven hells; (7) above the seventh heaven was the “highest heaven,” that of the fixed stars; (8) this eighth heaven was di- vided by the Zoasht into two portions, an upper or Ardlic, and an under or Antarctic, and atethe pole of the furmer was Anu’s palaces (9) the north pole of the heavens was regarded as the zenith of the cosmic system, and con- sequently the sun and moon were sup- posed to move in a horizontal piane; (10) the order of the planets, proceed- ing from the earth, was: Moon, Sun, Mercury, Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn; (11) to pass from the upper half of the earth to its under half, that is, from the abode of living men to the abode oft the dead, it was necessary to cross a body of water; (12) according to Diodorus Siculus (ii, 31) the Babylonians be- lieved that twelve designated stars south of the Zodiac stood in the same rela- tion to the dead as do the twelve corre- sponding stars north of the Zodiac to the living. Dr. Warren’s conclusion is that the Babylonians conceived of the earth (the upperworld and the under- world) as composed of two seven-staged pyramids separated by a body of water; around it seven homocentric globes (the planetary spheres), and beyond these another sphere, the heaven of the fixed stars; and the other ancient cosmol- ogies he holds to be of the same char- acter. The difficulty in Dr. Warren’s learned and well-conducted discussion is that he constructs a symmetrical scheme from data too varied and too vague to ad- mit of such a formulation. It is true that the Babylonians conceived of the earth as a mountain, and it is possible zikkurat, was an imitation of this torm (though another explanation is possi- ble); but the number of stages in a zikkurat was not necessarily seven, and there is no proof that the earth-roun- tain was supposed to have just seven stages. Proof is similarly lacking for the assumption of this pyramidal form for the underworld. In support of his contention Dr. Warren (p. 35) quotes Jensen’s statement (“Kosmologie,”’ p. 175): “The seven tupukati of the uader- world are a facsimile of the seven tupukati of the overworld”; now, Jen- sen defines this term as meaning “earth- zones,” not “stages,” and understands the seven gates through which Ishtar, in her descent to the underworld, has to pass as indicating simply seven re- gions or divisions. For the assertion (quoted by Dr. Warren from Winckler) that in the Babylonian system there were seven heavens and seven helis, no proof is offered. There is no support in the Old Testament for a seven-staged pyramidal underworld—Sheol (Ezek. xxxii, etc.) is a single underground re- gion where all the dead dwell together; and, it may be added, the word “nell,” if it be taken in its later sense, is a misrepresentation of the Babylonian and Hebrew nether worlds, neither of which is a place of torment. Seven heavens there are in late Jewish works, such as the Slavonic “Enoch” (dating trom aear the beginning of our era), and there is a suggestion of such a scheme in the New Testament (2 Cor. xii, 2); but this is a late application of a sacred number to the structure of the celes- tial world, not an old cosmological con- ception. Some of the data in Dr. War- ren’s list are commonplaces of early thought and have no serious cosmologi- cal significance: the earth is necessarily taken as the centre of the universe, and might naturally be taken as quadrilater- al, though this latter point is not cer- tain. The belief that to reach the other- world it was necessary to cross water is found among low tribes—this is oue of the many lines of travel to the be- yond imagined by the ancients. Hades sometimes lay far off in the west, or in some other direction, and one had to traverse deserts to reach it; sometimes it was placed in the bowels of the earth, and a ghost, like Samuel, came up, or a living pilgrim, like Agneas, went down. In Egypt particularly the conception of the locus of the otherworld was vague and fluctuating; in Babylonia and Canaan it seems to have been always a subterranean region. It is probable that the Babylonian astronomy passed into India and Greece, but in none of these countries do the current astronom- ical beliefs support Dr. Warren's spe- cific thesis. If the northern half of the earth was regarded as the upper and

Page 19

Feb. 17, 1910] The Nation. the southern as the under part (and a northern people could not think other- wise), and if the sun and the moon were supposed to move in a horizontal! plane, this tells us nothing of a seven- staged pyramidal earth. Dr. Warren is of opinion that Homer regarded the earth as a sphere—the relation between this spherical earth and the pyramidal earth is not clear. We cannot here fol- low our author into his delineation of the voyage of Odysseus and other mat- ters discussed by him; his conclusions all rest on his theory of the earliest cosmologies. Sailing Ships: The Story of Their De- velopment from the Earliest Time to the Present Day. By E. Keble Chat- terton. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $3.75 net. This is a heartfelt book, the author's affection for his subject being manifest on every page. Since it embodies the results of painstaking and thorougl: re- search into records extending back to the era of the pyramids, and of consult- ing well-nigh all available sources of information, it will long hold first place as an authoritative work. It is very readable in spite of its encyclopedic character. Its parts are made to hang together by the author’s endeavor to explain the causes for the invention of each type of craft and rig and to make clear the influence exerted upon pauti- cal design by the early voyages between the Mediterranean and the North Sea, each locality profiting by the experience of the other. The former lively interest in sailing vessels has largely disappear- ed, except in the case of yachts, and is now historical rather than actual; but Englishmen, who owe so much to mari- time adventure, cannot fail to appreci- ate this endeavor to trace the origin, de- velopment, and decline of the sailing ship. With us, the subject ceased to be of primary importance when we turned our backs on the ocean and began the conquest of the lands lying west of the Alleghanies and the Mississippi; but we played a gallant réle once upon a time, of which we have good reasons to be proud. Written for his own people, Mr. Chatterton’s book gives but scant space to our California clippers and their mar- vellous voyages. It is to be hoped that some lover of American ships and sail- ors will do for our builders and naviga- tors what Mr. Chatterton has done for their European colleagues, and will tell us of the Forbes rig and his invention of the double topsail among other kin- dred matters. We note in Mr. Chatterton’s volume the absence of reference to the famous British East Indiaman Heather Bell, which in the 70's averaged 300 miles a day from just south of the line to the longitude of the Cape of Good Hope, a wonderful record. Although Mr. Chat- terton pronounces the sailing ship's vale- dictory, he seems to believe that com- merce will have to revert to its ancient practice when coal and oil become pro- hibitory in price. The bibliography is otherwise quite complete, but it is hard to understand how the author failed to consult Nic- olaes Witsen’s splendid work on ship- building, written in Dutch and publish- ed in Amsterdam in 1671. The index is exasperatingly inadequate. To ascertain when the square spritsail gave place to the jib and when vessels became wea- therly enough to make their way against the wind through “beating” or “tack- ing,” one must run through the text it- self; yet these are really critical epl- sodes in the sailor's art. The letter- press and the illustrations from authen- tic documents leave little to be desired either in scope or accuracy. Francesco Petrarca: Poet and Humanist. By Maud F. Jerrold. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $4 net. Here is a painstaking labor of love. The author has not merely read widely in the enormous mass of Petrarch lit- erature, but has thoroughly familiariz- ed herself with the original texts, in- 'cluding Latin works usually neglected, and generally has provided her own translations. She has shown tact in ar- rangement, and has, chosen a form of expression at once sufficiently enthusi- astic and self-effacing. It seems to us the best single work on the humanist poet in English, and not likely soon to be superseded. Naturally there are slips, and occa- sionally points where deeper study would have modified her opinions. The view taken of the poetry of the Trouba- dours seems to us far too favorable, bas- ed rather upon the old romantic crit- icism of Fauriel and Renouard than upon intimate acquaintance with the texts. Koeppel’s various studies on Petrarchism in England would nave been of assistance in preparing the chapter on the imitators of Petrarch. Since the right dates of Chaucer’s first Italian journey were established a doz en years ago in Modern Language Notes, XI, 210—and more briefly in the Nation in the autumn of 1896—it is disheartening to note once more the ven- erable error that the poet was in Italy the greater part of the year 1373. His absence from London was less than four months, from December 1 to April 28; his sojourn in Italy must have been rather less than two, and the chance that he had time to make the legendary visit to Petrarch is a very remote one. Had he seen the Laureate he could hard- ly have failed to be better informed con- cerning Boccaccio, whom he imitated so freely. The two charming impersona- tions of Music and Rhetoric which are 165 reproduced as works of Melozzo da For!) have been assigned by competent au- thority to Justus of Ghent. Fifteonth- century prints of the Triumphs are use- ful illustrations. Evidently no portrait of the poet has seemed worthy of pre- sentation, which seems a pity, for Gua riento’s repainted fresco at Padua is not without merit, while many of the early portraits are characteristic enough to inspire confidence. We would gladly dwell upon this ex- cellent book, but its subject is too large to be compassed in brief notice. In- stead let us present a passage which will give a fair idea of the author's manner. It is on love of nature, in which all the world knows Petrarch was a forerunner: Love of nature, as of all things else, can be of many kinds. There is the love of the artist, who seizes an effect and constructs a picture; there is intellectual love which is impressed by brightness, or sombreness, or savageness, by mystery or simplicity, ac- cording to the cast of mind; there is the love of association which marks out cer- tain scenes and places from all others, not because of what they are, but for what they suggest and embody; and then there is the spontaneous love of nature for her own self, the only love which is entirely worthy of the name, which is all-embrac- ing, which does not look for sympathy, but imparts it, which does not ask to be un- derstood, but understands. None of these loves was foreign to the soul of Petrarca, but the last was preéminently his, and in this he was a pioneer. In spite of Vaucluse, Italy was always the darling land of the poet. He was the first to express many modern feel ings, and he first uttered the longing that thousands of enthusiasts have felt long before Du Bellay, Goethe, Byron, and Browning gave to a universal nos- talgia classic sanction. “One should call every one an exile who is condemned to live out of Italy,” writes Petrarch once for all. The epigram is worth perhaps most of the subsequent poetic variations on the theme. Notes. The Revells will soon publish the auto- biography of the Rev. Dr. Henry H Jessup, under the title, “Fifty-three Years in Sy- ria.” Dr. Jessup became a missionary of the Presbyterian church to Syria in 1860 Dr. 8S. Weir Mitchell celebrated his eightieth birthday, on February 15, by pub- lishing a new book of verse, ‘‘The Comfort of the Hills,”” which includes besides the title poem the “Ode on a Lycian Tomb,” “An Ode to Battles,” “‘The Song of the Captured Confederate Battle-flags,"" ‘The Birthday of Washington,” and “In Memory of William Henry Drummond.” To the Tudor and Stuart Library has been added a reprint of the first authentic edition (1643) of Sir Thomas Browne's

Page 20

166 “Religio Medici,” together with “Observa- tions upon Religio Medici, occasionally written by Sir Kenelome Digby, Knight 1643." Editions of the “Religio Medici” are abundant, but none of them, to our knowledge, can compare with this beautiful reproduction from type made from dies of the seventeenth century. We have here, too, the assurance of accuracy that goes with the work of the Clarendon Press. The interest of Sir Kenelm Digby's “Observa- tions” is more curious than intrinsic, but it was a good idea to bind it up with the “Religio.”” One day in December, 1642, Digby, then lying a prisoner in Winchester House, received from the Earl of Dorset a letter recommending the “Religio,” which had appeared in a pirated edition. Digby immediately sent out his servant to obtain a copy of the book, and on the same night, the 22d (‘I thinke I may say the 23., for I am sure it is morning, and I thinke it his “Observations” on the work to Lord Dorset. Just how Digby found time to write his long review in one night, is day’’), sent as it appears he did, Digby's present re- viewer would give a good deal to know His praise of the book is well known: This good natur’d creature I could easily perswade to bee my Bedfellow, and to wake with mee as long as I had any edge to entertaine my selfe with the delights I sucked from so noble a conversation. “Town Planning; Past, Present, and Pos- eibl by H. Inigo Triggs (Imported by Charles Scribner's Sons), is a beautiful lit- erary expression of the civic spirit now abroad in England, a legal manifestation of which was the Housing and Town-Plan- ning bill of 1908. After considering ancient modern types of the town, Mr. Triggs in a practical way the subject of an ] 1sses town planning for the health, convenience, ar beauty of urban life. The book con- } illustrations, making an impres when and tain l7 exhibition of what can be done is well managed resources are ably administered. To the public business publi \merican reader the work may suggest sad regret that we do not possess institu- tions of government able to perform such noble functions of public service “Readings in American Government and Politics,” by Prof. Charles A. Beard (Mac- book of the political science inductive basis proceedings millan) a sources kind now reasingly employed by tabl It is a ine in « hing itself on an ord of events and of the actual characteristics government, national, State, The pathology of our poll attention and such morbid illustrative of and municipal American tics receives due traits as log-rolling, ‘Senatorial courtesy," party man receive the corporation benevolences to , Tammany junkets, etc exemplification The work is well-planned and ager ap propriat in records presented well-executed the intellectual movement which it has become usual to call the twelfth-cen- tury renaissance John of Salisbury is one of the central figures. An Englishman by birth, he spent many years with the great teachers of Paris and Chartres, in the leisurely days when there were neither courses of study nor de- grees and men were free to. study as they would; made no less than ten journeys to Italy, where he saw much of the court and came into contact with translationg of Aristotle; served papal new the [Vol. 90, No. 2329 The Nation. as secretary to three successive arch- | bishops of Canterbury, including Becket; | and died bishop of Chartres. No writer, of | his own age, or, indeed, of the whole me-| di@val period, shows so broad and accurate a knowledge of the Latin classics, and no-| where is the cause of classical learning | defended against the rising tide of the) scholastic logic more warmly than in his “Metalogicus.” His other principal work, the “Policraticus,”’ or “Statesman’s Book,” | is a discursive treatment of a variety of | political and philosophical themes, enriched | by a wealth of ancient examples, but not) devoid of references to the author’s own | times, as, for instance, to the itinerant | justices of Henry II, who are here first mentioned by that name. A critical edition of this interesting cyclopedia has just been published in two volumes by Clement C., I. Webb (Frowde). The text is based on the manuscript of Corpus Christi College, Cam- bridge, which is almost certainly the orig- inal presentation copy given by the author to Archbishop Becket. The annotation is judicious, and the effort to identify the sources of John’s citations has taken his editor on long excursions into the civil and canon law and the ecclesiastical writers of the Middle Ages, as well as over a wide range of ancient literature. “Virginia’s Attitude toward Slavery and Secession,”’ by Beverley B. Munford (Long- mans), is an attempt to show that the se- cession of Virginia was due, not to devotion to slavery and a desire to perpetuate it, and least of all to hostility to the Union, but to the adoption by the Federal govern- ment of a policy of coercion. This violated the compact theory which, in Vir- ginia as in the other"cotton States, had al- ways been regarded as_ constitutionally sound; because it would compel those States to remain in the Union after they had decided to withdraw from it. In sup- port of this contention, Mr. Munford ex- amines in considerable detail, and with much fresh and suggestive array of evi- dence, the history of slavery in Virginia, dwelling particularly on the comparatively small number of slave-owners, the injur- ious effect of slavery on the economic de- velopment of the State, the pronounced anti-slavery sentiment among all classes, and the humane treatment of the slaves themselves. Even the fact that every pro- posed scheme of emancipation seemed be- set with insurmountable obstacles, and that pro-slavery opinion grew markedly after 1833, did not prevent Virginians from freeing their slaves in large numbers down almost to the outbreak of the civil Mr. Munford’s temper is so admir- and his method so direct, as to make criticism seem ungracious. We but think, however, that he ‘has somewhat confused the cause of secession with its occasion. Granted that war was en- tered upon, as Lincoln sald it was, not to abolish slavery, but to preserve the Union, it is, nevertheless, hardly credible that re- sistance would have been so prompt or determined had there been a very deep or widespread desire to escape from a social system of which slavery was one of the chief bulwarks. If, as Mr. Munford iIn- sists, Virginia seceded simply because the Federal government resorted to coercion, the conclusion is unavoidable that the State preferred to continue on a low social plane under its own guidance rather than to at- war. able, adverse cannot tain an admittedly higher one by Federal aid. That such was the fact, not in Vir- ginia alone, but throughout the cotton States, is, we believe, the true explanation of secession; but we are not clear that Mr. Munford expects such an inference to be drawn. Maurice de Saxe, adventurer, soldier of fortune, royal bastard, avowed lover of Adrienne Lecouvreur and many others, is one of the shining figures of the wonderful eighteenth century. Having been brought into the world in total disregard of the ordinary observances in regard to mar- riage, he continued to go through life with a similar disregard for conventionalities. Although, perhaps, not equal to his father, Augustus the Strong, reputed by scandal and Carlyle to have been the father of three hundred and fifty-four bastards, Maurice still lived a life not devoid of affairs of the heart. As he left no memoirs, W. R. H. Trowbridge has un- dertaken to provide him with some, under the title “A Beau Sabreur, Maurice de Saxe, Marshal of France: His Loves, His Laurels, and His Times, 1696-1750" (Bren- tano’s). This supposititious autobiography, based on some historical study, is rather cleverly done. It is easier to recreate the eighteenth century atmosphere and to give a proper idea of Maurice’s remarkable career by letting him tell his own story, much as in an historical novel, than would be possible in a more serious biography written in the third person. So he de- scribes his extraordinary ancestors, his acts of bravado, his life in Paris, and his conquests over the fair sex. Incidentally, he repudiates the usually accepted state- ment that he persecuted Justine Favart with a lettre de cachet. Maurice was also a good deal of a soldier. Frederick the Great had the highest idea of his abilities. But with this side of his life—with his long campaigns and with the facts of po- litical history—Mr. Trowbridge does not allow him to weary posterity. It is doubtful if a more vexatious colon- ial problem confronts British statesmen to-day than that involved in the question of Asiatic immigration into the colonies. In recent years a widespread anti-Asiatic agitation has arisen, showing itself most clearly in the Transvaal; the opposition to Indian immigrants in British Columbia; the dispute between Japan and the United States concerning school regulation in San Francisco; the drastic anti-Asiatic leg- islation introduced in the Natal House of Assembly; the outcry in Jamaica against Chinese shopkeepers; and the hostility shown by Australia and New Zealand toward immigrants from China. An at- tempt is made to present a fair and im- partial summary of the question by L. E. Neame in his smal! book entitled, “The Asiatic Danger in the Colonies” (Lon- don: Routledge & Sons). For Great Brit- ain, the status of the Asiatic is an em- pire problem, according to Mr. Neame, because of the political changes of the last half-dozen years. It is rendered the more complicated by Britain's alliance with an Asiatic Power and by the fact “that millions of the Eastern races are British subjects and claim the privileges which the empire boasts it confers.” The author maintains that the colonial attitude toward Asiatic immigration is in no way

Page 21

Feb. 17, 1910} due to a lack of appreciation of Asiatic virtues, but is rather a testimonial to Asiatic capacity for attaining success, He aims to justify the policy adopted. The German public must long ago have mastered the elementary data in Baedeker's United States, if it is educated up to a hand- book on New York which devotes itself almost exclusively to the city’s history and an interpretation of the city’s life. The volume which Mrs. A. von Ende has contributed to the Kunst series, imported by Lemcke & Buechner of New York, is an admirable bit of work. We have nothingjust like it in English. Within 130 small pages Mrs. von Ende has brought together an extraordinary amount of information, and presented it with more than common charm and lucidity. The point of view is that of the sympathetic and philosophic foreigner. That will explain a certain distribution of light and shade which a native writer would hardly fall into. There is, for instance, the strong emphasis on Poe and Whitman, whose appeal to the European mind is traditional. In similar tone is the specific reference to our present school of radical publicists— single-taxers and Socialists—whom Euro- peans are apt to take as a more important factor in our politics than we regard them, and possibly with greater insight than we display. But as a matter of fact, all through her little book, Mrs. von Ende has laid stress on the social development of New York as affected by the appearance of new classes and new ethnic elements As part of a series devoted to Aunst the present volume goes to proper pains gather up all that can be said for our lit- erature, our art, and our music since early colonial days. to Some of the information heretofore avail- able chiefly to German students respect- ing the influence of Babylonian and Persian the development of Christianity presented in popular by Dr. Paul Carus in “The Pleroma: An Essay on the Origin of Christianity” (Th« Open Court Publishing Co.). The book is a sketch of the growth of the principal do trines and usages of Christianity from the point of view of those who hold that the influence of Hebrew thought and usages upon Christianity has been grossly gerated, and that religious current in the pagan world in the first centuries had far more to do with determining the char- acter of the Christian faith than has been popularly imagined. Dr. Carus holds that Judaism “did not bear or bring forth Chris- tianity, but that Christianity is, so to speak, a grandchild of ancient paganism, and the motherhood of Judaism is by adoption mere ly.” He maintains that Paul was the found- er of the Gentile church, and that he “took his building materials, not from the store- houses of the faith of his fathers, but from the wreckage of the destroyed temples of the Gentiles.” Like Delitzsch, Winckler, Jeremias, and Gunkel, among the Ger- mans, Dr. Carus calls attention to neglect- ed factors in the origin of Christianity, but writers of this school are inclined to do less than justice to the continuity in moral spirit and religious attitude between the faith of the Hebrew prophets and that of the Christian apostles, and to forget the disparity between the religion of Paul and of Augustine, and the pagan cults, whose vocabularies and fcrms they undoubtedly religions on early is form exag- ideas The Nation. employed to a greater extent than is com- monly allowed. Neither excellent paper nor handsome type has been spared in the making of Ed- ward J. House's ornate volume, “A Hunter's Camp-Fires” (Harper & Bros.). It is a collection of hunting adventures In North America and Africa by a well-known sports- man, who goes about his task in an unpre- tentious, straightforward way. The extent of Mr. House’s experience is seen by the fact that he describes the killing of nearly every important game animal from the walrus of Whale Sound to the equatorial elephant of Meru. If there be any particu- lar charge to bring against the book, it is that all such issues as the scenic, the eth- nographical, and the geographical are al- most entirely subordinated to that of the chase itself, and that the volume contains an inordinate amount of killing The charge will doubt lightly on Mr. House’s conscience, for he affirms that “the legitimate and sportsmanlike pursuit of big game has never required any apolo- gies,” and declares that he has found an element of excitement in hunting with a rifle hence no rest that he has always missed when using the camera. And records of his tures bear sufficient witness to an habitual of of the heart, for ast three separate chapters he relates these adven- State at lk that, at the crucial moment, he had forgot- ten to cartridge his rifle- breech be the light of frankness on of Mr. House for few course of defaulted to no very palpitation in throw a into regarded more in the part carelessness This may extreme than any ial of so extensive a career Mr. House of «di: standard espe i hunters temperament in the would have less makes no pre tion, and of to tence elegance perhaps exalted literary criti be but it may cism should applied books of this kind; to the ter nevertheless, be permitted record of slaugh the is even of a lack of of words by reviewer feeling for The book photographs to regret a meaning and value eighty There well illustrated made by the author The of issuing Goethe's “Werke” Kohlaus Nachfolger), pletion. The three new volumes just appeared, XLIV, XLVII, of the “Briefe,”” edited Carl Schiiddekopf, Graf, respectively, the plete is no index Weimar Hermann work the edition (Weimar: fast of is nearing com that have and XLVIII by Max Hecker Hans Gerhard ana under the supervision of editor-in-chief, Bernhard Suphan ym the of the poet's I rs to the end of June, 1831 Vol. XLIX Hecker, and containing Goethe's is in presg Schiiddekopf is now publication lett Gown edited by last let short ly ters, and will appear working on Nact conclud Volume L, whi the to compris trage,”’ and final ng volume of the series is promised Vol. V2 of 18 now index. This f tl pr for the current year the “Ge dichte,” and is to be Wahle, the ) or vegun so long awaited, in press issued at Easter Julius has finished two years ago by Gu the volumes of appeared 7, 1858 1893, respectively Th remaining vol edi index to of also editor this wo over twe ny tay the 1890, von Loeper, earlier poems having in 185 1891, and publication of these three monumental of the students is now umes will complete the with the *Tagebiicher,”’ will be glad under way The form a “stately tion, exception the Goethe which to hear edition, when of well om- plete will row” one 167 hundred and thirty-six volumes. The three yolumes just published contain 739 let- ters, of which 373 are for the most part new, as they have either never before been printed at all or only in part. In the crit- ical apparatus are included forty-five more letters and notes, in the writing of which Goethe had some part,and thirty-three of these are now for the first time made ac- cessible. Many of the new letters are, to be sure, of a purely business character, but a goodly number shed added light on mat- of importance to the student of the poet’s life and work. The total number of letters thus far published In this editioa, including in the “Lesarten,” is 13,- 193, which increased by a_ few hundred pear. ters those will be when the last two volumes ap of “Publica the the quasi-Christmas Instead of the volume issued annually by clety of Weimar, as a gift, there was sent to each December a set of the so-called ‘“Volks- ausgabe’’ of Goethe’s works, edited by Erich Schmidt, brief oductory notes, commentaries, and glossarics The ruling spirits of the society have for some been planning such an edition, in the tions” Goe So- member last with intr time hope that Goethe's popularity might not Iways be confined to the better educated and the rich. In order to achieve this end a liberal subsidy was paid to the Insel Verlag Leipzig to publish the popular lition and delive ymplimentary ts to the soclety’s members Besides the 000 nd mor necessary for this purpose, an edition of 20,000 sets was put on the mar ket at the low price of six marks for the six volumes, bound, and, to the happy sur prise of those who fathered the plan, the lition was soon exhausted The editor's ‘oduction of twenty-eight pages gives an outline of the poet's lif not a simple, popular narrativ as might, perhaps, have n expected, but a succinct statement of ! ilient facts, liberally erspersed with bits of author i led to keep the neophytes from being led stray by skepti and scandal-m Prof. George T. Flom ha ontributed an historical and bibliographica ntroduction and notes, to a new school edition of HMsalag Tegnér’s “Frithiof Saga Chicago Engberg-Holmberg Publishing ‘| ) I list of translations of the poem is based on the bibliography by Elof Tegnér in Vol. VII of the large 1885 edition of Teg nér’s ‘“Samlade skrifter,’’ and Mr. Flom has added the titles of those that have appval The text is accompanied by illu August Malm originals The and ed since. reproduced from Knut Ekvall's in trém’s and excellent historical archmological details as well as art ical been omit ly; the utter might well hat Semitic Study Series, edited by Professors Gottheil of Columbia University Jastrow of the University of Pennsy! two new numbers, x! and xii, have Stechert & Co.): the “Mish and v ania, appeared (G. E nah Treatise Sanhedrin,” edited, with in troduction, notes, and glossary, by Prof Samuel Krauss of the Israelite Theo ogical School of Vienna, and ‘Sele ns from the Arabic Writings of Maimon : edited, with introduction and notes, by Prof. Israel Friedlander of the Jewish The- ological Seminary of America, New York.

Page 22

The Nation.

168 These numbers maintain the excellent standard of their predecessors, and, like them, will be very serviceable to college students and others who are unable to get access to larger works or need guid- ance in the study of peculiar idioms. The selections are judicious. “Sanhedrin” is an important legal and ethical tract, and, though the Arabic writings of Maimonides have been translated into Hebrew, the stu- dent should know the original; for the guidance of the beginner a table of the Hebrew letters used in writing Arabic is given, and there is a list of the differences between classic Arabic and the Arabic of Maimonides, which, as Dr. Friedlander points out, was not a distinctively Jewish form, but the common dialect of the time (the twelfth century), the koin?. employed some times, though rarely, by good Arabic authors. The two editors of these numbers are authorities in their respective subjects and have done their work carefully. The proofreading is remarkably good, consider- ing the fact that the editors were at great distances from the place of printing (Lei- den) Arthur Munby, an English poet, whose Dorothy: a Country Story.” in elegiac verse, was republished in this country soon after its appearance in England in 1881, died last month at the age of eighty-one. He had also published “Vulgar Verses,” intended to be verses of common life, under the pseudonym of “Jones Brown"; “Susan,” “Ann Morgan's Love,” “Poems, Chiefly Lyric and Elegiac,” and, last year, ‘Relicta.”” He was one of the competitors for the prize offered in 1859 by the Crystal Palace Company for a poem on the Burns centenary, and his contribution was con- sidered one of the best offered. The Right Rev. John Dowden, Bishop of Edinburgh, died January 29, at the age of sixty-nine years. He was the eldest brother of Prof. Edward Dowden, and had served as Donnellan lecturer and select preacher at Dublin University, and as Pantonian pro- fessor of theology at Edinburgh University. He had edited ‘“‘Correspondence of the Lou- derdale Family, with Archbishop Sharp,” and had published “History of the Celtic Church in Scotland,” and “History of the rheological Literature of the Church of England.” Franz Rittweger, the German author and journalist, died recently at Frankfort, at the age of eighty-one. He at one time edited a paper in New York, and thereafter was on the staff of the Frankfurter Zeitung. His publications include “Aktenstilcke zur neus- ten Geachichte Frankfurts,” and “Frankfurt am Main im Jahre, 1848." ye science. A History of Botany, 1860-1900 By J Reynolds Green, F.R.S. New York: Henry Frowde. $3.15. This “History of Botany” is a contin- uation of the work by Professor Sachs, which covered the period from 1530 to 1860. It is interesting to note that the two volumes are of approximately the same size, although one treats of a pe- riod of above three hundred years, and the other one of only forty. But that Is

[Vol. 90, No. 2329

the ratio which prevails in many other fields of scientific activity, and indicates the rapidity of progress in the latter | half of the nineteenth century. Professor Green has wisely follcwed the method pursued by Sachs in group- ing the special subjects involved in bo- tanical advance under separate head- ings: as Morphology, the Anatomy of) Plants, and their Physiology. As to the general introduction, it is a master- ly presentation of a difficult matter. To give in forty pages an impartial account of the main features which characterize | the steady progress of the science de- | mands the exercise of a judicial mind familiar with all the evidence. not easy to apportion the credit due to | this investigation and to that, especially when the investigators belong to <iffer- ent nations. The author justly assigns to Sachs and to Darwin the honor of having by their own stimulating work and by that of their immediate follow- ers, caused the greater part of the mark- | ed progress during the forty years un- der consideration. Some of the chief matters which are | emphasized in the main body of the book are the following: (1) The great impulse given to morphology in its wid- est sense by the theory of descent and by a more scientific study of fessil forms; (2) the replacement of certain convenient dogmas by a statement of actual conditions in development; (3) the vast advance in all branches of plant |physiology. It is not likely that any botanist will agree with all that Profes- sor Grecn has stated in regard to these subjects, but it must be confessed by all that in general he has been impartial. Professor Green refers to Campbell, Farlow, Ganong, Jeffrey, and Webber, noting the substantial contri- butions which each one of these Amer- ican botanists has made to the science. Points which will strike the reader most forcibly when comparing this volume with its predecessor are these: (1) The great increase in botanical activity in England, during the period treated of, and (2) the comparative silence with which important work in systematic botany is passed over. And, further- more, e@cology, which is practically physiology in a wide sense applied to systematic and geographical botany, as explanatory of adaptations, does not re- ceive quite its due. But, on the whole, the treatise can be heartily recommend- ed as well-balanced and trustworthy. The “Text-Book of Anatomy and Physiol- ogy for Nurses” (Macmillan) is the third edition of the book compiled by Diana C. Kimber and first published fifteen years ago. This edition professes to have been | completely revised by Carolyn FE, Gray of the New York City Training School for Nurses. The revision might well have been | carried much further, for many funda- mental facts of physiological interest are neglected or quite inadequately stated. Com- It is) pletely neglected, for example, are foods and diet, although the digestive processes are perhaps sufficiently described. On the anatomical side, there is almost too abun- | dant, although uneven, material with very numerous illustrations well reproduced from | good sources. The book seems to assume | that all nurses are women and nurse only | their own sex. There is a liberal glossary, which contains many surprises. | | We have often wondered what use color- blind lovers of flowers can make of the | numerous handy little guides to plant names in which the species are arranged accord- ing to the solar spectrum. For those with normal vision the scheme works well, and to such persons the handy little book, with the amazing title, “Who’s Who Among the | Wild Flowers” (Moffat, Yard), will prove useful and interesting. The author, W. I. Beecroft, has given sketches of almost two hundred common plants of the Eastern |United States, and short descriptions of many more. Here and there, blank pages or parts of pages are left for notes to be made on the spot when one is collecting the plants, and this hint as to the utility of fresh notes ought to be taken by every user of the book. Descriptive notes, care- fully made at the time of collecting plants, |have much value, especially in these days when more attention than ever before is paid to slight differences of form and sur- face. The volumes of contemporary bi- ography entitled ‘““‘Who’s Who” are com- piled largely from material furnished by the people written about. The present vol- ume, on the contrary, gives its sketches without much assistance from the subjects described. It is strongly to be hoped that the amateurs who use this convenient manual will try to see what the plants de- scribed have to say for themselves. The author has shown excellent judgment in the selection of non-technical terms; the book is, even for the merest beginner, very easy reading, and the author has wisely chosen a conventional and international, and not a provincial, system of nomenclature for the scientific names of the species. Mrs. Fanny Bullock Workman and her hus- band describe, in the Geographical Journai for February, their sixth expedition to the Himalayas. This was to explore the Hispar glacier, which in extent, complexity, and grandeur exceeded every other ict ex- panse they had seen. Especially interest- ing were the snow columns, called nieve penitentes, of which pictures are given as well as of a camp at an altitude of 19,100 feet, and a peak 21,350 feet high with Mrs. Workman on the summit. This num- ber also contains the paper on the “Cycle of Mountain Glaciation” read by Prof. W. H. Hobbs of the University of Mich- igan at the last meeting of ‘the British Association, with maps and reproductions of photographs. The second volume of the ‘Missions au Sahara” (Paris: Librairie A. Colin), by R. Chudeau, treats of the region between the Niger and Lake Chad, the physical con- ditions, fauna, flora, the life of the natives, and the commerce of all the Sahara. The investigations seem to show that the old idea that the desert was encroaching on the fertile land {s incorrect. There are extensive districts which were formerly |sand wastes but are now covered with | vegetation.

Page 23

Feb. 17, 1910] Nation. The 169 The little volume, “A History of the Ox- ford Museum” (Henry Frowde), by H. M. Vernon and K. Dorothea Vernon, is more than its name implies, being a brief his- tory of the fates of natural science at the most conservative of universities. For the century and a half after Bacon Oxford kept her theological skirts clean by the simple expedient of appointing, when pos- sible, to the chairs of science incumbents who had none of the dangerous qualifica- tions. As late as Acland’s time, in the mid- dle of the last century, the lectures were closely censored. Dr. Kidd, “after examin- ing some delicate morphological prepara- tion”, declared, first, “that he did not be- lieve it, and, secondly, that if it were true he did not think God meant us to know it.” The demonstrations were ordered stopped on the ground that the professorship called only for lectures. At last the Museum rose under the patronage of Ruskin, being the finest Gothic design of the talented Wood- ward. Here a lover of symbolism wight like to see an architectural expression of that keen idealism which for two centuries had maintained the feeble spark of science in chilling surroundings. The description of the building of the Museum is very in- teresting, and there are precious anecdotes of the eccentric stone-cutter, O’Shea, to whom some of the best decoration is due. When this fine structure was nearly up the university seriously proposed that, in order to save expense, the curator should be of the grade of a college butler. The tide may be said to have turned at the univer- sity in 1860, when Huxley, in the Museum library, made his monumental retort to Wilberforce’s burlesque of the evolution- ary theory. The liberal spirit of the present régime in Turkey is shown by the interest in archeological research. The first thorough exploration of the famous church of St. John of the Studium is being made by the Russian Archzological Society, which is bringing to light the remains of ancient buildings, one of which is thought be a temple of classical times, as well as sculptured stones, bas-reliefs, and ancient tombs. An English archzologist is inves- tigating the church of St. Irene, hitherto so difficult of access, and the remains of the Byzantine palaces on the Marmora are also to be submitted to his research. This modern spirit is shown, too, by the mag- nificent recent additions to the Museum galleries and the care with which its treas- ures are guarded. to John Ferry, an ornithologist connected with the Field Museum at Chicago, died in that city on February 11. He was born in 1877, graduated at Yale in 1901, and had served on the United States Biological Survey and as a collector for the Smith- sonian Institution. Sir Charles Todd, who had been govern- ment astronomer for South Australia for more than thirty years, died last month at Adelaide. He was born in 1826, and had served at the Royal University and the Cambridge University. Since 1861 he had been in charge of the Adelaide Observatory, where he had made many valuable astro- nomical observations. William Hillhouse, until recently profes- sor of botany at Birmingham University, died recently at the age of fifty-five. He was a co-founder of the Bedford Natural History Society, and of the Cambridge Re- view, and had published (with Strassbur- ger) a “Practical Botany.” Prof. August Meitzen, the German statis- ticilan and economist, died recently in Ber- lin at the age of eighty-six He became professor of political in Berlin University in 1875, and had published “‘Ge- schichte, Theorie, und Technik der Statis- tik,” “Internationale land-und forstwirt- schaftliche Statistik,” and “‘Siedelung und Agrarwesen der Westgermanen und Ostger- manen, der Kelten, Rémer, Finen und Sea- wen.” economy Drama. IBSEN’S LITERARY REMAINS The literary remains of Henrik Ibsen have appeared simultaneously at Copen- hagen and Berlin, making three bulky volumes in the original language and four slightly smaller ones in the Ger man version. The total number of pages in the Norwegian-Danish edition runs up to 1553, and yet this represents only a@ part of the voluminous deposi: of notes, drafts, corrected manuscripts, and parallel versions, now owned by the Christiania University. The editing has been done with laudable discernment by Dr. Halvdan Koht of Christiania and Dr. Julius Elias of Berlin, both of whom are already well known to Ibsen lovers through their editing of his letters. Their personal contribution to the pres- ent work includes an excellent anatysis of Ibsen’s working methods and a ser- ies of biographical and bibliographical notes that must prove highly valuable to all future students of the Norwegian dramatist’s work and life. Besides the 122 pages of preface and introduction, the first volume contains about ninety poems, most of which made their tirst— and hitherto only—appearance in Scan- dinavian newspapers during the fifties and sixties; a considerable number also of articles, reviews, speeches, prose sketches, notes, and aphorisms; separate versions of his early play, “Olaf Liljekrans,” one of which was meant to serve as liberetto for an opera; the trag ment of a prose version of “Love's Com- edy,” already known under the name of “Svanhild”; a couple of chapters ot a novel that was never finished, and one complete, hitherto unpublished, play, “St. John’s Eve.” The second vol- ume opens with the so-called “pic Brand,” previously published in a sep- arate volume under the editorship of Karl Larsen. The of this and the third contain extensive sketches, variants, corrections, “working manuscripts,” for all the later plays, from “Peer Gynt” to “When We Dead Awaken.” The bulk and scope of the maierial thus given to the world make it very hard to form any exact estimate of its quality. Even at a glance, however, it two rest volume notes, and seems evident that these volumes fail to offer a great deal that can be of interest to the general reading public. Throughout, their value is psychologi- cal rather than literary. As documents revealing the workings of a mind they hold a high position; but th: actual novelties which they bring are lit tle more than literary curiosities. This applies, for instance, to “St. John's Eve.” This romantic prose comedy in three acts, written in 1852 for the Ber gen Theatre and performed there twice is strikingly characteristic of that pe riod, just after the production of hfs firstling, “Catiline,’ when the young Ib sen had neither found a form for him- self nor discovered his own particular genius. In other words, the play 1s as little Ibsenesque as it could possiblity be Its sole interest lies in the fact that it shows Ibsen striving to write in prose at a much earlier time than we heretofore suspected. What has just been said ot this play applies also to all but a very few of the poems. They are youthful immature, and lacking in everything but a certain facility of language that always belonged to Ibsen when he ex pressed himself in verse. A conspicuous exception is formed by some verses writ ten as late as 1871 and entitled “Judas.’ They may be translated as follows master Among the disciples he stood apart Might surely be illed twelfth wheel o the cart. The motive is unknown, that pron 1 his act, For history nothing records but th i We know that, with ynscience nodding, he went And kissed the Saviour—as it was meant Both for heaven and hell thus his m sion was filled But what if Judas had otherwise willed Here we have the germ of that muivhts double drama, “Emperor and Galilean which Ibsen to the very last proclaimed his greatest work. And here we have, too, a laconic summary of the problem that overshadowed all others in his mind during the entire first half of his fifty years of playwrighting: the prob lem concerning the relation of the in dividual human will to that world-wil) which Ibsen found manifest in phase and form of existence. And airong the notes for “Emperor and Galilean we find this one: “When the world spir- it can find no more souls to tempt and lead astray—then the judgment day has arrived.” It is, of impossible to look through these volumes without being deeply impressed with the pains taking way in which Ibsen worked, thr careful attention he gave to the minut est details, and his habit of tryin: out the same idea over and over again un til, at last, he succeeded in getting ar it essence. every course, innermost pt for the opportunities which \t af

Page 24

Nation. 170 ‘The [Vol. 90, No. 2329 fords Madame Kalich, the reasons for the fcrd-on-Avon will this year occupy nearly production of “The Witch” at the New fcur weeks. For the twenty-second time Theatre are somewhat obscure. The piece ‘he performances will be under the direction as Nterature or °! F- R. Benson. The festival will be opened has particular merit drama, is not valuable as historical rem!- niscence or illustration, unpleasant in subject and depressing as entertainment. It is an adaptation by Hermann Hagedorn from a play by H. Wiers-Jenssen, a Scan- dinavian dramatist, and the scene is trans- ferred from Denmark to Salem, Mass., the action and personages, it is said, being as appropriate the other This can readily be believed, as, with one exception, the incidents and characters are entirely conventional. The real dramatic interest centres around the progress of an no “Hamlet,” given in curtains. Among other artists taking part in the festival will be Miss Geneviéve Ward, who will appear as Vclumnia and Queen Margaret. Arthur Beurchier and Miss Violet Vanbrugh have promised to appear as Benedick and Beat- rice, Otho Stuart as Clarence and Bassanio, Henry Ainley as Mare Antony, Lewis Waller and Miss Winifred Emery as Benedick and Beatrice, James Carew and Miss Ellen Ter- ry as Shylock and Portia. is to one country as The reported failure in London of “The Strong People,” C. M. S. McLellan’s latest illicit love story, to which the witchcraft episodes are largely subservient. Joan, the play, may be accounted for in more than heroine, a girl of Portuguese descent, has| °"@ Way. Apparently it is a vigorous and been married for nearly a decade to Ab- serious piece of work, but the improbabil- salom Hathorne, an old minister—an ex- | 't¥ of the plot and the fact that the scenes witch-hunter—who neglects her. She is sul- | #24 the conditions depicted are American may have had a good deal to do with the lenly eating her heart out, when her step- cool reception. a youth of her own age, re- conceives an over- having heard witch—begins to her powers, practising on her lover and her husband. Having be- mistress, she confesses her in a moment of reck- son, Gabriel It seems pretty plain from the criticisms in the London press that Comyns Carr, in his dramatization of Stevenson’s “Dr. Jekyl and Mr. Hyde,” has missed the point of it as completely—and vulgarized it as re- morselessly—as any of the preceding adapt- ers. It is pretty plain, also, that H. B. Irving, turns home. For him she mastering passion, hat test and soon her mother was a own abnormal come Gabriel's infidelity to Absalom exultation, and tells him that = she in his dual embodiment, has paid more at- wishes he were dead. Whereupon, stricken tention to the clumsier melodramatic pos- with heart disease, he expires at her feet. sibilities than the finer spiritual significance | and Gabriel plan to hush the matter of the story. but the dead man’s mother denounces Joan, proclaiming her a witch and mur- deress, and demanding that she be tried by the ordeal In the her husband's corpse the wretched woman She ip Musie. : of touch presence of in a state of semi-stupefac- truth of everything ollapses, and, Musicology. By Maurice S. Logan. New York: Hinds, Noble & Eldredge. tion. confesses to the alleged against her. The implication is Sd ; that she will be hanged in due course. The The Nature of Music. By Julius Kiaus-| whole story is melodrama, without much er. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. originality or any distinction, except in the “Musicology” is a word coined by Mr. | case of Joan, who, in the hands of Bertha Logan to designate the science of music. Kalich, becomes a significant and tragic, 'f Hig book is accompanied by a circular | figure. Her psychology It is impossible to de- her to be often unintelligible which contains the statement that “un- til now no one has produced a book teaching solely the science of music.” As a matter of fact, there are dozens of | books on the theory and philosophy of | this art. Mr. Logan’s, however, is more | comprehensive than most of the others. | It deals with rhythm, expression, keys, | intervals, chords, progressions, modula- | tions, counterpoint, acoustics, sources of musical sound, the ancient Greek modes, | temperament, etc. Expression, the most important of all the aspects of the art, is treated much too briefly, although the author includes under that head en-bel- | lishments, which are usually the nega- | is incomprehensible cide whether the author meant regarded as actually possessed, the victim delusion, or simply consclenceless and lewd. But the theatrical opportunities in her are large, and Madame Kalich makes very full—possibly, too full— use of them. The ignoble passions—hate, suspicion, abject fear, and low desire—have seldom been depicted vividly But her Joan is a thing apart from the play it- very low level of hysterical or insan¢ more which maintains a is off the self, when she stage Edmund Gosse, in a letter to the London “As all the biographies re- Ibsen lived in an apoth»- at Grimetad from 1844 to 1850, sixteenth his twenty-second year A national movement is now being made in Norway to purchase it, and to fill it with memorials and biographical objecta—to make an Ibsen House, in fact. which shall be to Norwegians all that the Goethe House in Frankfort is to Germans.” SAYS Henrik caury'’s hous Times, peat, to from his It is rather Utop-| may be commended. ian on his part, however, to expect it to be used in schools. He holds that music| should be studied as a science wherever | instruction is given; that every child should be taught its fundamental prin- ciples, whether or not he is to be a sing: | er or a player; and that as a means of | There is sald to be a possibility that Miss Anglin may abandon—temporarily, at any rate—the emotional drama with which she has been associated for so long The annual Shakespeare Festival at Strat- | education, musicology is as much entitled by Sir Herbert Tree, with a performance of | | University of Jena unearthed from known early symphony py Beethoven. | was in the form of manuscript parts for developing the mind, and rounding Out) strings, flute, two oboes, two bassoons, to a place as any other “ology.” This may be true, but school children are al- ready overburdened with subjects, and the little time given to music in the public schools should be devoted to it as an art, with just enough of the science to make it understandabie. Music as a science is also the subject of Julius Klauser’s book, but he treats of a few aspects only, and presents some startlingly novel theories and views. As the aim of contemporary musicians like Debussy and Strauss seems to be to sub- vert all the established laws of composi- tion, so Mr. Klauser starts out by con- tradicting the fundamental tenets of the musical historians—particularly the tenet that melody antedates har- mony by unknown ages, and that har- mony was discovered and introduced only a few centuries ago. On the con- trary, it is here maintained that “har- mony is and from the beginning al- ways has been an element of melody.” The author denies that the chord is, as everybody believes, the original form of musical harmony. To the establish- ment of these theses he devotes nearly three hundred pages. Whether he suc- ceeds in proving them, we are unable to say, the reasoning being often too deep for our comprehension. Had Mr. | Klauser lived to revise these chapters, it might have been otherwise. As it is, it |} seems likely that the chief value of the volume will remain the appendix, which notates the songs of eighty-six | different birds. Organists will be interested in the ar- rangement for their instrument of the dirge from MacDowell’s Indian Suite, just pub- lished by Breitkopf & Hartel. It was made by W. H. Humiston. The manuscript of three songs of Walter von der Vogelweide, has recently been dis- covered in the archives of Miinster. The music is being reduced to modern notation. A Munich bookseller is offering for sale the manuscript of Wagner’s early and un- finished opera, “Die Hochzeit.” The price asked is $5,000. The manuscript is in- scribed, “fragment of an unfinished opera, ‘Die Hochzeit,’ by Richard Wagner. Dedi- cated to the Musical Society of Wiirzburg.” It is dated “Wiirzburg, 1st March, 1833.” Since Sir Edward Elgar’s symphony was first heard at Manchester, on December 3, 1908, under the direction of Dr. Hans Richter, no fewer than eighty-four per- formances of the work have been given. Seventeen of these were in London and tion of expression. As a convenient com- | Suburbs, ten in America, and eight on the pendium for advanced students his book | C°Dtinent—Berlin, Vienna, Munich, St. Petersburg, Leipzig, Budapest, Bonn, and Rome. The symphony has also been heard |} in Canada, at Toronto, and in Australia, at Sydney and Adelaide. the its un- It Last summer Prof. Fritz Stein of archives what he believes to be an two. horns, two trumpets, and drum. The find-

Page 25

Feb. 17, 1910] er’s attention was first directed to it by noticing that the score for the second fid- dles was inscribed “Louis van Beethoven,” and that for the ‘cellos “Symphony by Bethoven” (sic). Art. The Chicago Art Institute announces an endowment by Mrs. Potter Palmer, from which will be awarded annually a prize of $1,000 for the most acceptable work in sculpture or painting executed by an American. Professor Garstang, who is excavating in Egypt, has discovered on the site of the ancient Meroe a sun temple by Egamenes mentioned by Diodorus. The structure is of great interest, and shows Greek influence. The building, which also inciudes a sanc- tuary lined with enamelled tiles, contains sculptures representing King Egamenes’s victories and a triumphal procession \ list of the tribes in the the southern Sudan is also given. ex- districts of Further cavations were made on the site of the tem ple of Ammon at Meroe which show that th« building was restored by Neteg Many inscriptions and statues were found Ammon The trustees of the Metropolitan Museum have decided to reserve the large central room, used during the recent Hudson-Ful- ton exhibition, for temporary exhibitions, chiefly of loans. These exhibitions will be- gin with one of Whistler’s works, which is to open about March 15. Only Whistler's oil paintings and pastels will be shown; nei- ther blacks and whites nor water-colors will be admitted. On this account, the ex- hibition will not be so large as that held some years ago in Boston, or as the London memorial exhibition, bur it will be larger than any collection of the artist’s works ever brought together in this city. Charles L. Freer of Detroit has promised to lend his collection of Whistler’s work, the larg- est in existence, all the paintings that the museum will need to fill up the room after it has collected from other sources—a most generous and public-spirited offer. Rich- ard Canfield will lend Count Robert de Mon- tesquiou, the Parisian poet, the Rosa Cord- er, the Ocean, La Napolitaine, and the seven pastels that make up the celebrated Vene- tian series. Frank J. Hecker of Detroit will contribute the Music Room; Mrs. Samuel Untermyer, the Falling Rocket which brought about the quarrel and law suit with Ruskin; J. H. Whittemore, L’An- dalusienne and the White Girl; John G. Johnson of Philadelphia, Lange Leizen; the Boston Museum, Little Rose of Lyme Regis and the Master Smith of Lyme Regis, and the Brooklyn Museum, the portrait of Flor- ence Leyland. Miss Birnie-Philips, the ex- of Whistler, has also promised to send two pictures from London. On Mon- day, February 21, the museum will celebrate the fortieth anniversary of its incorporation by holding the annual meeting of the cor- poration at four o’clock in the afternoon in the Bishop Jade room. Joseph H, Choate, the last surviving member of the original board of trustees, will address the meeting, to which the public will be admitted. famous ecutrix made in fres- A great the room improvement has been where are the Boscoreale The coes, which were acquired in 1903, Nation. A small the lery, just large enough to hold the frescoes extension has been built out of gal- of the cubiculum which used to occupy the of copy as near as possible the original room centre the gallery. Care was taken to of which photographs were taken before the frescoes were removed. An exquisite little flying Eros in bronze, belonging to J. Pier- pont Morgan, also found at Boscoreale, has been placed on a table, discovered at the same place, in the centre of the cubiculum The larger frescoes from now seen to Boscoreal much better advantage in the gallery. The glass has been removed from them, and they have been cleaned. It is proposed, now that the cubiculum has been removed, to devote the whole floor spac« to Greek sculpture, and some remarkabl specimens, recently have been placed there. a fine statue acquired One is a crouching Venus of Louvre is the type of which the version in the A Greek the statue the famous Nereid fragmen most copy. lion, similar the British Museum; a of a seated markably fine in the to lion in tary Philosopher, re- treatment of the drap- ery, and signed with the of the tor, Zeuxis: a female 1 Roman name culp charming torso, and bust of a of in portrait per fect the young man in an almost state preservation are among acquisitions to Statuary \ addition the treasures is a large water jar, with plates, very interesting museum's cups, and jugs of terra-cotta, covered with a black glaze, probably a dinner servic: belonging to the third century B. C., which were found together in a grave One of the most important of the more modern accessions is a Virgin and child in poly- chrome, the work of Verrocchio. It has its original coloring, and from its styl must be dated before 1470—an_ exquisite work, A fine bronze of Hercules slaying Bertoldo, caryatids a lion, ascribed to inkstand bird notice. Edward G. the museum of himself of William much and a Paduan with also deserve Kennedy has presented small study by Whistler, Mackay to with a portrait and Laffan, the museum Thomas F a group of Pygmalion in memory rendered he Ryan has and Galatea who when so service was one of its trustees given it by Rodin To open his new galleries at No. 550 Fifth Avenue, Mr. Montross has arranged an exhibition chiefly retrospective and, since all the pictures are lent, devoid of commercial implication. It is reassuring, of course, to meet those tried and favorite champions of establishment, Dewing and Tryon, in pictures which one already knows—pictures many of which are in their degree famous All but three of this group, which comefrom the collection of Col J. Hecker, form part of that lection which Mr Ww ledicated the Both unusual Tr you Frank notable Freer Dewing col- Charles has and the Tryon at to nation have it of commands a an measure sense tone and arrangement times rare poetic sentiment, and Dewing has a lovely quality of paint These merits, being pretty rare to-day have brought their possessers critical and even popular acclaim, and it becomes a species of blasphemy to scrutinize their work with the usual critical caution. If that bold attitude were to be taken it would possibly appear that these two painters have rather more than a due portion of defects of Both to sacrifice the their qualities are inclined significant structure iridescence or stylistic part : special Mr. Tryon's gift is his work more open-hearted, to robust but his t pris more and dency, possibly because his admirers hav: hailed his least substantial work, is, for the sake of tone and mood, to go into a kind of structural liquidation The thre Whistlers shown here, one the famous Va Chelsea, and two riations in Pink and Gray, sketches—all representing him quite in his most rarefied mood—have amazing stead ness. One can move about in them They are painted in a kind of divine prose which makes about half the Tryons suggest a psuedo-poetry Abbott Thayer is too rarely seen in New York Maybe he is alien to it, and holds aloof from a sense of fitness In any ase there is a refreshing absence of the stereotyped about him. He plays his own game Monadnock in Winter is, or ought to be, a very famous picture. It is amazing how so large and finely-balanced a thing an be done so simply It seems as if a house-painter could have painted it, if he could have seen it There, of cour lie the art Just a strip of keen pale blu white mamelons, seen loftily over t of tall evergreens, which impriso deeper sapphire emanation of a snow that is aquamarine in the foreground—tha!' all there is of it; but that’s enough to con vey the majesty of the forest, and he mountain, and a sense of cerulean depths beyond It lered n big symbol! strokes, quite as a child or a giant might have done it Beside it hang two portraits which look as if our child-giant had been leprived of honest paint and supplied with putty and refractory brushes. The mystery of Thayer is in this group of three pictures his occasional triumphs, his frequent in adequacies. To account for him will puzzle the future crith The most notable article In the Burling ton Magazine for January is Sidney Col vin’s report on an album of sketches by Tintoretto recently acquired by the Brit ish Museum. There are nearly one hundred designs, mostly executed with the brush Ir the freest manner. This find quite contra licts the tradition that Tintoretto painted his great compositions without previous tudy. These drawings are of the highest artistic importance, and it is good news that the album is to be reproduced. The frontispiece of this number ts the profil: portrait of a lad in the Gustave Dreyfus collection, which, after figuring as a lwo renzo di Credi and Alvise Vivarini, is now shown by Claude Phillips to be by Jacopo Bellini It is the only portrait we have from his hand, and it is hoped that its identification may lead to the discovery of other portraits which are recorded but gone astray R. L. Hobson's valuable ar ticl on “Wares of the Sung and Yuan Dynasties’ reach the sixth instalment Of timely note is an article on Cézann by Maurice Denis, the first of a serie Kenyon Cox continues his survey of the pictures of the Hudson-Fulton exhibition with appreciations of the Halses and Ver In our quite do justice to the exquisiteness of that early picture, A Girl Sleeping It seems to us not inferior the later works, but merely different, being more traditional meers opinion, he loee not to

Page 26

and Rembrandtesque Mr. Cox's observa tions on the chronology of Vermeer are in- teresting and doubtless will be provocative of discussion We have received a “Guide to the Celtic Antiquities of the Christian Period pre- erved in the National Museum, [Dublin,” by George Coffey, keeper in th» museum and curator of the Royal Irish Academy Collection This little handbook, with itz 18 plates and $4 smaller cuts, is more than its title implies Together with I's descriptive list of objects, including such extraordinary pieces of metal work as the lara Brooch, the Ardagh Chalice, and th: Shrine for St. Patrick’s Bell, it presents a general discussion of the disputed ques- tion of Celtic ornament. Mr. Coiley ar- rivesa at the conclusion that both the sim pler ornament of the La Téne style and the interlacing bands of the finest period are drawn from Eastern sources, vt promptly developed in directions essential- ly Celtk In fact, the persisting glamour of the Empire, meaning Byzantium, is ac- sountable for pretty much all the early ap- proaches to civilization made by the Northern Celts and Teutons Rut these Barbarians borrowed in the spirit of con- querors As for the Interlacing band or pament, the cuts in Mr. Coffey's guide ha ent your reviewer to a small Coptic diptych of ancient but uncertain fate in which the painted cover design is in elah orateness if not in fineness atrue counter- part of the panels in the Book of Kells Byzantium mposed herself everywhere Whence she herself drew her forms is a larger matter, and at this point irrelevant The indigenous Celtic art was that of enamelling, of which we have abundant traces but few complete examples Ap- parently this beautiful art was transmiit- ted to the Romans, only to perish among its originators. The later medi@val objects the product of Mr. Coffey says of fine Celtic calculated to en- complex Museum are What qualities in the Dublin Limoges furnaces ibout the general dk lighten ign is excellent and those who see only its ingenuity He writes life of the curves, and their quickening as they or run to a spiral, of life comparable th a fineness and endow them with a The swing and perfection of completion feeling the approach give them a to skating, coupled w ureness of line which rare perfection be nailed “Cellle We these words might up na wish where or rnis hundred being of which shops nament” is listlesaly little book, geated the ricaia & Norwate produced we have merely sug interest, is published by Hodges of Williamea & London of Dublin, and the Co of at small orice hilliog and sixpence Her isures,”” by Douglas (Seribner) he ] the by Maud Otherwise be nphasize rre Hugh A is a pocket guide which and in distingu from ite predecessors ly by number and sharpness of its mere Crutwell note on the it ‘a a much what such chief defect te in beat of the later the remarkable pleture is Ita the example, 1 work haa to failing to « paintings For drawings by Tiepolo in the Correr Museum are the of the Carmine is recorded as an excellent barock with no hint that It contains the finest Tiepolos. It should a special guide should be at not mentioned, while School structure of that some seem The Nation least as comprehensive as Baedeker. In the list of painters the dates of Antonello da Messina are erroneously given as 1444- 1493. For several years it has been known that the right dates are 1430-1479. More justifiably no hint is given that the year of Titian’s birth is disputed. The average tourist needs to be told that the bronze Descent from the Cross in the Carmine is of the fifteenth century. The great Last Judgment, a mosaic, in the Cathedral of Torcello, is described as a “fresco.” the lists of artists, doges, saints and their symbols are convenient, on the whole the raison d@étre of such a book seems to be that there are so many tourists that some will certainly buy it. At a dollar and a half they will get a fair money's worth. Unusual qualities of concreteness, sym- pathy, and sobriety are shown in G. Her- Marius's “Dutch Painting in the Nineteenth Century” (London: Alexander Moring, Ltd.). The rather dreary stretch before the appearance of Jongkind livened by the discovery of survivals from the old tradition. Indeed, though varying greatly in quality, the painting of Holland in various classicisms hardly affected its se- rene stolid course. The chapters on the painters of a half-century ago, while reviving in the Bild- others a few alities, are on the whole, of local interest. A. G. Bilderses, as is proved by a fine ob- servation quoted on p. 84, was in theory far in advance of his times. For most of us the appeal of the book begins with Bos- the master of lofty interiors, Israels the Marises It is to be expected that a Hollander should treat Israels with reservations., To many foreigners the sentimental sub- stratum of much of his art will cause mis- givings. With the Marises—the superb construction and arrangement of Jacob, the silvery luminosity of Willem, the myster- ious fairy land of Matthys—we are on firm ground, Everything that is said about them is admirable. One misses only some brief account of the peculiarities of Dutch water- color painting, which has greatly influenced Except for the impas- sioned symbolist Van Gogh, the ultra-mod- ern movement in Holland seems rather a pale reflection of French eccentricities. The etcher, Gravesande, in spite of his inequal- ities, deserves something more than casual mention It to express an opinion concerning the Dutch revival. Some the stronger are still living and developing. the movement run rather narrow tradi- tional lines, and here perhaps may lie its strength We cordially recommend this genial and informing book. It has 131 good The translation by Alexander Texeira de Mattos reads like an original. On mine is en- themes and singularly consistent The romanticisms have has been and ideals and sometimes and more erses and interesting person- boom, Josef not and modern practice is premature of men In general seems to along illustrations p. 114 Is an ugly misprint of the name Swin- | burne, otherwise the proofreading ts worthy of the good typography From Jacques Reich of this elty we have an etched of John the same style as the other his series of Famovnge Americans. is that by Chester Marehall as a recelved ‘lar- shall traits The painting followed Harding, portrait in por- itt and represents younger man than he appears in the bet- ter-known painting by Innes. It is an ex- While | [ Vol. 90, No. 2329 cellent presentment of the great Chief Jus- tice, and well worthy of framing. A revised and enlarged edition of “Win- dows: A Book about Stained and Painted Glass,” by Lewis F. Day, imported by the Scribners. Like the two earlier editions, the scope of this handbook technical and historical. It abounds in dia- grams, detail drawings, and photographic euts of famous windows, and the writer in- cidentally sets forth principles on the laws of the craft, In what he says of the glass of the best periods a criticism of much modern designing is implied. We think it would have been useful to make that criti- cism quite explicit, and in particular to weigh in the balance the much admired ar- cheistic glass of the Holliday firm. What is said of John La Farge’s glass is inade- quate, and suggests that Mr. Day has not seen many good examples. It is quite be- side the mark to find in the accidental no- dosities of ancient glass the precedent for the purposeful manipulation of American pot metal. Whatever may or may not the merits of La Farge’s procedures, their essential originality will be evident to any one who will give them fair scrutiny. Mr Day’s manner is easy and picturesque, and his general sound, is is be ideas about design eminently This new edition of a book that has already proved its usefulness is welcome. Alfred Charles Whitman, for many years departmental clerk and superintendent the students’ room in the department prints at the British Museum, died February 2, at the age of forty-nine. had published ‘Masters of. Mezzotint,”’ “Valentine Green, Engraver,” “S. W. Rey- nolds, Engraver,” “Samuel Cousins, En- graver,” “Charles Turner, Engraver,” 1907. in of on He The death is announced of Eugéne Thiri- on, a popular French painter, at the age of seventy. He studied under Picot, Fromentin, and Cabanel. His Nuits Musset is at the Luxembourg, and his Lévite d’Epraim Moudissant la Ville de Gaabe at Perpignan. He also supplied a panel, L’Histoire, for the Hétel de Ville, in Les ce Le Paris. Finance. ILLUSIONS OF THE DAY. The sharp recovery in prices this week running to 5% points in Union Pa cific, as compared with the week's low est, to 74% in Reading, to 4% in Steel common, and to 6% in Amalgamated Copper—was nothing very surprising, when the violence of the preceding de cline was kept in mind. Nevertheless, to those of the simple outside public who had been led to believe that the “aiti- tude of Washington” was at the bot- tom of the break in prices, the fact of a favorable turn in the market may possibly have seemed curious. But the one thing which Wall Street does not ex- pect to have asked from it is consistency. There are times when Wall Street em- braces a fixed idea, and accepts it as the explanation of everything that happens in a market; but it is perfectly capable of rejecting the same idea overnight, and

Page 27

a Feb. 17, 1910] revives it. The great majority of think- ing people, in the financial community, are perfectly well aware of the absurdity of the “Washington argument” as a pri- mary explanation of the break in stocks. Nevertheless, they point to somebody —often a personage of importance or of seemingly unbiassed attitude—who holds that idea, and therefore has been se!ling stocks. But how do they know that this was the reason why the man in question sold his stocks? The man himself said so, we are told, and believed it. This would be convincing, anywhere but in Wall Street: but in Wall Street, strange as the state- ment may appear, it is not convincing at all. The experiences of many years bear witness that, when sagacious investors have realized through their subtle and usually correct instinct that prices were too high, or have bought because prices impressed them as low, they will, ‘ater on, attribute their action to which occurred after their decision, and which history have no real bearing on the market. The “election boom” of November, 1908, il- lustrated this. It is doubtful if any sen- sible financier bought stocks because Taft had been elected; indeed, his elec- tion was a certainty months before the voting. The market situation was ripe for an advance in any case; but there are people, even now, who will honestly say that they bought in 1908 because of the election returns. events subsequent proved to It is only when illusions of this sort have a larger scope that they may be come really dangerous. There are times when, by force of mutual suggestion, a whole financial community accepts its basis of action facts which are incor- rect and reasoning which is preposter- ous. In the case of the great financial manias of history—the South Sea Lub ble, the Dutch tulip speculation, and the Mississippi craze are instances in point —the record is absolutely explicit that the illusion was not limited to the sim- ple man in the street, but worked equal- ly upon powerful capitalists and great banking houses, Perhaps the most con spicuous modern instance was the illu- sion which possessed the Wall Street community in April, 1901, taking the shape of an absolute belief that the law and precedent of political economy had been superseded by new forces in American finance and industry. No one who did not happen to visit Wall Street at that time can have any pvoper conception of the readiness which seri as ous anciers turned upside down the Evolution. Frowde, i ' 18 Snan ier F I Boyce, R. W. Mosquito or Man The Con reasoning processes of their whole pre quest of the Tropical World, Dutton ceding life. Bradley-Birt, F. B. Through Persia, from In a very much less degree, the curl “tne Guif to the Caspian. Dutton. $3.50 ous “Sunshine movement” of 1908, when net nel _— y ™ Brigham a The olcanoes o ijlauea conventions were held and lodge: o1 and Mauna Loa Vol. If. No. 4, Memoirs ganized to preach the doctrine that if of the Bernice Pauahi Bishop Museum - : "OR 7) Honolulu Bishop Museum Press . ¥ . > re we , we thought ourselves prosperous cad Mingled Wine. Longmans, would be prosperous, was another case = Green, of laughing, next day, at any one who troducing such should improving the quality of goods; in some of them, exactly the opposite result may be shown to have been achieved. institution, have increased the stability of trade, or it have accomplished this poration seems to have done so. Others, however, like the Amalgamated Copper, have and lution ing as a calamity that nine-tenths of our prosperous rail ways had nothing to do with companies. once president of that holding company, who calmly asked, a ago, “What is the difference whether the owners have one green certificate to rep Aristotl Beerbohm, Bosher, K. L Bourne, G. C. The Nation. in point. It is rather early, as yor, to classify 1909; yet it is difficult not to be lieve that the “Steel speculation,” ar its climax, was an illusion of this sort. The argument, in its extreme form, was based on premises which all of the com pany’s previous experience contradicted, and on assumption of facts and figures which last year’s own official statements of the company repeatedly discredited Yet there were bankers talked “200 for Steel common,” of 6 per cent dividends, and of bond issues to fund a"! back expenditures for improvements. In that case, as in other similar, there is a possibility that some of the victims of the illusion began by trying to convince who of other people that such things were true, and ended by convincing themselves One sometimes wonders whether there not considerable illusion the matter of “holding companies.” The holding company device, in its present form, is a little more than ten years old Very few of such companies appear to is about have exerted the influence, predicted in the early days of “Trusts,” towards in sweeping economies as lower cost of production while As an the holding company may not. Some holding companies the Steel may Cor been engines of overproduction demoralization. The forced of the Northern Securities company, in 1904, this, in spite of the tact disso hold was dreaded holding Yet it was Mr. Hill himself, couple of weeks resent their interest, or two red ones? BOOKS OF THE WEEK Abram, A. Social England in the Fifteenth Century: a Study of the Effects of Eco nomic Conditions. Dutton. $1 net Aristophanes The Acharnians Greek text revised, with a translation into cor responding metres, etc., by B. B. Rogers Macmillan. $3.25 net Works. Translated the « litorship of J \ Ross Frowde. Max Yet nto English under Smith and Ww. bp ‘o Again Lane ¢ $1.50 net Mary Cary. Harper. $1 ne! Herbert Spencer and Animal $3.50 net rave 1733 Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble traasfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits available in all parts of the world. Letters of Credit International Cheques of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York Farm Land the Basis of Value investments the be the Certificates first cor characte making id should always of the security Every investor to whom neome is important should learn the facts about Irrigation bonds They form our estimation, the Way to earn 6 per cent Secured by a Thousand Farms Irrigation bonds are secured by first liens In leration in safest on good farm land—-sometimes a thousand farms The farms are worth usually at least four times the loan The farms are exceedingly fertile, and ar not subject to crop failures Any one sea on'’s earnings are generally uficient to repay the whole loan The bond ire additionally ecured by a fir mortgage on an irrigation y ) } vhich the investment often twice tl bond issue Some Irrigation bond ire municipa curities, which form—a do School bond 1 tax lien on the district Some are issued inder the Carey Act where the State upervises the project They are ied in denominations of $100 $500, and $1,000, so one may invest either little or much All are serial bonds, part of which are paid annually o one may make long-time or short-time investment 78 Issues Sold In the past 16 years we have sold 78 pa rate issues of Reclamation bonds, all based mn farm liens Not a dollar of loss ha esulted to any investor Our dominant place now give us the pick of these project They are passed on b our own engineers and attorneys And an officer of our Company constantly resides in the irrigated sectior watching the pro jects we finance We have issued a book based on all this xperience a book which every nvestor hould read. Please cut out this coupon as a reminder to send for it (16) > a First National Bank Building. Chicage 50 Congress St., Boston 111 Broadway, New York First National Bank Building, Sew Frenciece send your free book on Irrigation Bonds Please Name “tale Le

Page 28

174 Carmichael, M. Francia’s Masterpiece: an Essay on the Beginnings of the Immacu- late Conception in Art. Dutton. §$2 net. Chance, W. Poor Law Reform. London: P. 8. King & Son. Chouville, L. Histoires Courtes et Longues. Frowde. 60 cents Common-School Catalogue, Ginn & Co 1910 Boston Crane, R. T. The Utility of All Kinds of Higher Schooling Chicago: Privately printed Cullen, A Adventures in Socialism. Mac- millan $2 net Dargan, E. P. Hylas and Other Poems Boston R. G. Badger Dartmouth College Catalogue, 1909-10 Hanover, N. H Davenport, C B cents net Day, R. E. Dix, B. M tial Interludes. Duff, N. Matilda $3.50 net Everett-Green, M. A. Elizabeth, Palatine and Queen of Bohemia. $3.50 net Friedlander, L. Roman Life and Translated by J. H. Freese. Dutton Great English introduction, essays and C. W. Dawson. 2 net each Hardy, T paper Ilarpet A. P Hein, G Eugenics Holt 50 New Poems. Grafton Press Holt. of $1.35 net. Tuscany. Dutton. Electress Dutton. Manners. Vol. 111. Short-Story Writers. With and notes by W. D vols Harper $1 The Return of the Native. Thin edition Harper. $1.25 Handy-Book for Girls Paret. Harper. $1.75 Auswahl Deutscher Prosa der Ge- genwart. Frowde. 90 cents. Helm, W. H. Jane Austen and Her Coun- try-House Comedy. Lane Co. $3.50 net Edited by Henderson, J. Darl. The Oak Amongst the Pines. Boston: R. G, Badger. Hillern, W. von. Hdher als die Kirche. New edition, with intro., vocabulary, etc., by Fr. W. J. Heuser. Merrill Co. 50 cents Hooker, BEB, R. Study Book in English Lit- erature: From Chaucer to the Close of the Romantic Period. Heath. $1. HENRY HOLT & CO. 34 WEST S4ITH STREET PUBLISH THIS WEEK Miss Gertrude Hall's THE UNKNOWN QUANTITY A novel of New York to-day by an author whore ories bave appeared in our best magazines A tale of love, moral struggle, and baffling mystery There are’ vivid character sketches of many sorts of people ($1.50) E. Lawrence Dudley’s THE ISLE OF WHISPERS short at A highly picturesque yarn suggested by ru mors a mysterious No Man's Land," pear Nantucket Full of action and suspense, and impregnated with an atmosphere of the sea (81.50) JUST PUBLISHED: Miss Beulah Marie Dix’'s * ALLISON’S LAD $ and OTHER MARTIAL INTERLUDES POOOSSDDO6666666666666666666666 Ry the co-author of ‘‘The Road to Yeater day the author of ‘The Making of Christo pher Ferringham,"’ ete $1.35 net.* The one-act war epleodes, Alldaon’s Lad, The Hundredth Trick, The Weakest Link, The Snare and the Fowle The Captain of the Gate The Dark fi the Dawn = . T. Stephenson’s THEELIZABETHAN PEOPLE ty Prof. HENRY THEW STEPHENSON of Indiana University, author of ‘Shakespeare's Londen. ** With over 70 tUllustrations, largely from old prints $2.00 net.* James L. Kellogg’s THE SHELLFISH INDUSTRIES Ry a Professor in Williams College (American Nature Series.) Illustrated. $1.75 net* O4DO446666 664466664066 0606 *Postage 8% additional, Allison's Lad and Other Mar- The Nation. Hoyle'’s Games Modernized. Edited by Pro- [Vol. 90, No. 2329 Savage, G. H. The Harveian Oration on fessor Hoffman. Revised edition. Dutton.| , Experimental Psychology and Hypnotism: 75 cents. Delivered before the Royal College of In After Days: Thoughts on the Future Physicians of London, October, 1909. Life. By W. D. Howells, Henry James, Frowde Sorley, W. R. The Interpretation of Evolu- Jerningham, C. E. The Maxims of Marma- tion. From proceedings of the British duke. Brentano | Academy, Vol. IV. Frowde. Jordan, L. H. Comparative Religion; a Sur- | Stephenson, H. T. The Eliabethan People. vey of its Recent Literature. Second sec-! Holt. 2 net. and others. Harper. $1.25 net. | tion, 1906-1909. Edinburgh: Otto Schulze| Sumner, E. A. Abraham Lincoln. Tandy- & Co. | Thomas Co. 25 cents, Keatinge, M. W. Studies in the Teaching | Temple Dictionary of the Bible. Written of History. Macmillan, $1.60 net. and edited by W. Ewing and J. E. H. Kellogg, J. L. Shell-Fish Industries. Holt.| Thomson. Dutton. $4 net. $1.75 net. | Thackeray’s History of Henry Esmond. Ed- King, H. C. The Ethics of Jesus. Mac-| ited, with intro. and notes, by T. C. and millan. $1.50 net. | W. Snow. Frowde. Lasar, C. A. Practica] Hints for Art Stu- | The Fourth Dimension Simply Explained: a dents. Duffield. $1 net. Collection of Essays. Intro. and editorial Master-singers of Japan: Being verse; notes by H. P. Manning. Munn & Co. translations from C. A. Walsh Montgomery, D. H. the Japanese poets by | $1.50 net. Dutton. 60 cents net. | Thompson, J. M. The Synoptic Gospels, Ar- The Leading Facts of} ranged in Parallel Columns. Frowde. American History. Revised edition. Bos- | Turrill, S. M. Elementary Course in Per- ton: Ginn & Co. $1. spective. Van Nostrand. $1.25 net. Miiller, M. Comparative Mythology: an Es- | Underwood, H. G. The Religions of East- say. Edited, with notes, by A. S. Palmer. ern Asia. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Dutton. 50 cents. | Vance, L. J. The Fortune Hunter. Dodd, Murphy, T. D. In Unfamiliar England.| Mead. $1.50. Boston: Page & Co. | Venable, W. H. Floridian Sonnets. Boston: Norton, E. Q The Construction, Tuning, R. G. Badger. and Care of the Piano-Forte. Boston: | Villiers, A. Dictionary of Foreign and Ditson Co. American Literature. Dutton. 50 cents. Ositer, W. Address on the Nation and the! Wallach, I. R. A Second Book in English for Foreigners. Silver, Burdett. 50 cents. Washington’s Birthday: Its History, Ob- servance, etc. Edited by R. H. Schauffler Moffat, Yard. $1 net. Weale, B. L. P. The Human Cobweb. Dodd, Tropics, together with report of proceed- ings in connection with the opening of the winter session of the London School of Tropical Medicine, October, 1909 Frowde Palmer, F. Central America. Moffat, Yard. Mead. $1.50. $2.50 net. Wellman, F. L. Day in Court. Macmillan. Paxson, F. L. The Last American Fron- $2 net. tier. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Who’s Who, 1910. Macmillan. $2.50 net. Perrin, A. The Stronger Claim. Duffield. | Wicksteed, P. H. The Common Sense of $1.50. Political Economy. Macmillan. Yale University Bulletin General Cata- logue, 1909-10. New Haven, Conn. Zielinski, Professor. Our Debt to Antiquity. Translated, with introduction and notes, by H. A. Strong. Dutton. 75 cents net. Pope’s Essay on Criticism. Edited, with in- tro. and notes, by J. Sargeaunt. Frowde. 50 cents. Pulitzer, R Harper New York Society on Parade. $1.20 net Are You Plus or Minus ? Answer after reading the little book whose fame is spreading like wildfire : SELF-MEASUREMENT A Secale of Human Values, with Directions for Personal Application. By WILLIAM DE WITT HYDE, President of Bowdoin College. All hookstores, 50c. net; by mail, 5i5ec. B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, New York. NOW READY. The Biographical Story of the Constitution A Stady of the Growth of American Union, By EDWARD ELLIOTT, Professor of Poll- tics, Princeton University. Rro. $2.00 net. the 400 pages. Prof. Elliott’s work does not seek to deal with the finely elaborated doc- trines of the courts, but rather with the larger questions of constitutional interpretation, many of which lay be- yond the jurisdiction of any court. These questions have been fought out between men, and this “Biographical Story of the Constitution” attempts to picture, through the lives of some of the more conspicuous of these con- testants, the struggle and its result. G, P, PUTNAM’S SONS, An Interesting New Book of Travel. Greek Lands and Letters By FRANCIS G. and ANNE C.E ALLINSON Fully illustrated. $2.50 net. Postage 16 cents HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., Boston and New York BOOKS—All out of print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me, stating books wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call and inspect my stock of 50,000 rare books. BAKER’S GREAT BOOKSHOP, John Bright St., Birmingham, England. NEW YORK & LONDON A BIOGRAPHY FOR ALL LIBRARIES Richard Jefferies: His Life andWork By Envwaap Tomas. $3.00 net. “A full and sympathetic pageagtg.—A. L. A. Bookliat, December, 1 ‘ LITTLE, BROWN & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON ANNE OF AVONLEA SEQUEL TO “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES.” READING CASE FOR THE NATION To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, with “The Nation” stamped on the Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. THE NATION, 20 Vesey St., N. Y. City side in gold. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75c.

Page 29