The Nation 1909-12-30: Vol 89 Iss 2322
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH. The Natiéa ~ % % is PRICE TEN CENTS. — > — On the Mexican Highlands BY WILLIAM SEYMOUR EDWARDS 100 Illustrations. $1.75, Postpaid in United States A most interesting and intimate description of that wonder country, the Treasure House of the “Vorld, Old Mexico, its ancient customs and quaint people. ey @ “Not since we | | @ “A pleasant, in- read the Travels of teresting, and mod- Edmondo de Amicis have we enjoyed a book of the same class as much as this. It is about the best book of travel we have read for twenty years.” —The Newark (N. J.) Advertiser estly written account of travels in Mexico. There ought to be a sale for the book over here.” The London ( Eng.) Publishers’ Circular ¢. “A travel book of peculiar charm and @ A traveler’s story which is a model of directness and sim- plicity in the tell- ing.” —The New York World interest to the reader “Full of valuable information and well illustrated.” The Toronto Mail and Empire A VISTA OF MEXICO BY THE SAME AUTHOR In to the Yukon Through Scandinavia to Moscow 12mo, cloth. $1.75, postpaid 12mo, cloth, illustrated. $1.75, postpaid Mr. Edwards has a _ straightforward, Not to travel at leisure through that part graceful style in writing, and in this is at of Europe so full of romance and legend his best, telling of the wonderful Valley of with such a delightful writer as Mr. the Yukon in a way most pleasing. Edwards is an opportunity lost indeed. ° ff q—With the knowledge that the readers of the Nation are much interested in 5 00 express Special 0 CFs books of travel, we make a special price for the three splendid volumes of ° prepaid JENNINGS & GRAHAM, Publishers, Cincinnati, Ohio Your courtesy in mentioning the Nation wien writing will be appreciated
Page 2
The Nation. JOURNAL. A WEEKLY FOUNDED IN 1865. [Pute 3 t the Vew York sa mail City P matter. ] st Office ase The published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, I I om is esident; Willlam J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul mer More, Editor Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Unton £4.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tue WEEK . 639 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Economic Science in America . 642 Belatery O06 GR APE ccccccsccccecccesccs 643 Little Tim” and Tammany ~» $43 The Issues in England -++ 544 The World's Literary Centre . 645 SPECIAL ARTICLES: Recent German Fiction ....... oees Ge Bibliographical Notes on Poe.—Il.... 647 CORRESPONDENCE: The Party System 648 Aviation in 1783 .... be betes eeenel b48 Putictlogs and Criticism .... 619 ollege English and a Propos 4 Rem- edy 649 Early References to Robin Hood ‘and Little John . aa .. 64 LITERATURE: American Prose Masters . 649 The Ball and the Cross seneee ae The Beggar in the Heart ............. 661 The Sinking Ship . 6A The Backwoodsmen . 652 Home Letters of Gener: al Sherman.. 952 The Catholic Encyclopedia . , 653 Essai sur les Principes de la Mé trique inglaise 654 Wayside Wisdom st 655 tichard Jeffer\« His Life and Work €55 NorTres 655 SCIENCE The Survival of Man 658 Fusapia Palladino and Her Phenom ena 658 DRAMA 659 Mvaic 660 ART Scottiah Paintings. Past and Present 660 FINANCE After the “Loan-Shifting” 662 Books or THE WEEK. 663 ***Coples of The Nation may be procured tn Parise at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in Trofalgar London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Square, Charing Cross The Nation. Educational. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies sehools of all grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Seu’! for bulletin HARLAN P, FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N. Y. THE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES FEvererr 0. Fisx & Co., Proprietors, 2A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 1 “) Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis m Mich. Av*,Chicago 202 Swetland Bid., Portiand rat Cooper Bidg., Denver 238DouglasBid. Los Angeles 61S Peyton Bid tpokane vl42shattuc k Ave. Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual, Just Published SAND. LE MEUNIER D’ANGIBAULT Edited ty J. W. Kuhne Instructor in Romance Languages, western University. North- 40 cents. In this edition of George Sand’s in- teresting story, the dogmatic portions have been omitted without altering the original text, which contains much dialogue that adds to the liveli- ness of the plot. The notes and vo- cabulary are sufficient for every need. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston COUNTRY LIFE EDUCATION SERIES Types and Breeds of Farm Animals . $2.00 By CHARLES 8. Principles of Breeding PLUMB. ee ee we oe $2.50 By EUGENE DAVENPORT. Fangeus Diseases of Plants .. . . . $2.00 By BENJAMIN MINGE DUGGAR. Soil Fertility and Permanent Agriculture Ry CYRIL G. HOPKINS (In Press). GINN AND COMPANY ’ THE MECHANICS OF WRITING By EDWIN C. WOOLLEY, Ph.D. A new and adequate treatment of punctua- tion and paragraphing, by which mastery of fundamental principles and facility in thejr use may be readily secured. ~ Cloth. 427 pages. 81.00. D. C. HEATH & CO., B ston, New York, Chicago The Nation and The Review of Reviews FOUR DOLLARS New subscribers to The Nation may obtain these two magazines at this special rate. Regular Price Review of Reviews . $3,00 Regular Price The Nalion. . . . . $3.00 SPECIAL OFFER SAVES YOU $2.00: The Nation 20 Vesey St., New York City Me bebe 89, No. Bi ta Letters and amie | OF Wendell Phillips Garrison | Late Editor of The Nation 1865—1906 In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. During the forty-one years in which he edited the Nation, with a thoroughness, ability, and con- scientious devotion unsurpassed in the records of American journal- ism, Mr. Garrison was an indefa- tigable correspondent, never em- ploying an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who embraced practically all the leading American scholars and crit- ics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a sufficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the rela- tions between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exer- cised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes, and sympathies. The volume also con- tains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and sev- eral of his characteristic editorials, reviews, and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. It likewise preserves the notable letter of ap- preciation addressed to Mr. Gar- rison by more than two hundred contributors to the Nation on the completion of his fortieth year of service, and his acknowledgment thereof. The book has been privately printed at the Riverside Press, but as it is believed that it will be prized by many who long had lit- erary or friendly relations with Mr. Garrison, or who have been readers of the Nation for many years, the opportunity is given to such to secure it. It would also find fitting place in public and pri- vate libraries which possess and treasure the bound files of the Nation, Price $1.50 net, postpaid ae Houghton Mifflin Company BOSTON NEW YORK
Page 3
Dec. 30, 1909] The Nation. iii IMPORTANT BOOKS THE TREATMENT OF NATURE IN ENGLISH POETRY. By Myra Reyno.ps. When Dr. Johnson declared that “a man tired of London is tired of life,”” he epitomized the attitude of his age. The effect of this narrow artificiality on English poetry is ably described in this book. It is an exhaustive investigation into the works of the greater and lesser poets who wrote between the middle of the seventeenth and the end of the eighteenth centuries. The beginning and slow development of a real nature-sense are acutely traced and brought into relation with other activities of the time. The book is illustrated with copies of contemporary paintings which show more clearly than words the extent of the artists’ feeling for nature. 410 pages, 8vo, cloth; net $2.50, postpaid $2.70. ENGLISH POEMS: The Elizabethan Age and the Puritan Period. By Water C. Bronson. So favorable has been the reception accorded “The Nineteenth Century” and “The Restoration and the Eighteenth Century” that the present volume needs little introduction. It follows the same general plan as its predecessors, with the added advantage of an especially fascinating field—the most spontaneous and exuberant period of English poetry. The notes contain elucidation of difficult passages and illuminating commentary—the index and bibliography are un- usually elaborate and detailed. 550 pages, 12mo, cloth: library edition, net $1.50, postpaid $1.66; school edition, net $1.00, postpaid $1.15. THE AMERICAN NEWSPAPER. By James Epwarp Rocers. This book is an intimate study of the American newspaper, and a reply to certain severe criticisms that have re- cently been made. The author has tried as far as possible to see both sides of the question, the subject of discussion being treated as one of concrete fact, and he has therefore examined some fifteen thousand newspapers from all sec- tions of the country as a means of getting acquaintance with the necessary basis for an accurate judgment. The book discusses in succession the following topics: The Historical Evolution of the Modern Newspaper; The City and the News- paper; The Nature of the American Newspaper; The Influence of the American Newspaper, and the Causes of that In- fluence. 228 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.10. SOURCE BOOK FOR SOCIAL ORIGINS: ETHNOLOGICAL MATERIALS, PSYCHO. LOGICAL STANDPOINT, AND CLASSIFIED BIBLIOGRAPHIES FOR THE INTER- PRETATION OF SAVAGE SOCIETY. By Writiam I. THomas. The papers forming the body of the book are by such eminent modern anthropologists as Boas, Tyler, Westermarck, Spencer and Gillen, Haddon, and Rivers. The author has an introductory chapter on the standpoint from which the ma- terials are to be viewed, and critical comments are appended to each part. There are seven parts: (1) External En- vironment (Anthropogeography and Primitive Economics); (2) Primitive Mind and Education; (3) Early Marriage; (4) Invention and Technology; (5) Art, Ornament, and Decoration; (6) Magic, Religion, Ritual, and Ceremonial; (7) Social Organization, Morality, and the State. The extended Bibliographies form the chief feature of the book. 920 pages, 8vo, bound in buckram, gold stamped, sewn on tape; net $4.50, postpaid $4.77. THE ARMENIAN AWAKENING. By Leon Arper. This book will be found singularly interesting and appropriate in the light of the occurrences of the past few years. Beginning with the “Dark Ages” of Armenian history, the author traces the religious attitude and the strug- gles of this people from the time of the introduction of Christianity. It is a matter of common knowledge to all who are familiar with the Armenian struggle for religious freedom, that political forces have been a strong factor in the persecution to which this people has been periodically subjected. All the sidelights which the condition of European politics could throw on the situation have been employed by the author, and his sympathetic treatment leaves the reader with a clear understanding of the various motives for the frequent outbreaks against the Armenians which have aroused the Christian world. 240 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.25, postpaid $1.36. BIBLICAL IDEAS OF ATONEMENT: Their History and Significance. By Ernest DeWirt BurRTON, JOHN MERLIN Powls SMITH, and GERALD BIRNEY SMITH. This book sets forth the content of the biblical teachings upon the subject of Atonement, and suggests the point of view from which these conceptions may profitably be studied at the present day. The attitude assumed toward the records throughout is that of historical interpretation rather than of theological systematization. Consequently, the ef- fort is to discover precisely what ideas of atonement are reflected by the biblical laws, institutions, and utterances. The authors employ the historical method throughout. To trace the history of an idea is to discover the forces that have coéperated to produce it and to transform it from age to age. The history of the idea is thus its best explanation. Yet as many readers will desire, not only a historical statement of what was believed and taught by the prophets and teach- ers of old, but also some indication of the value of those teachings for the present day, the closing section of the book (Chap. xii, xiii) is devoted to this aspect of the matter. 338 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.11. THE CHILD AND HIS RELIGION. By Georce E. Dawson. The aim of the book is to suggest the principal elements in the child's religious nature and training. The first chapter treats of interest as the fundamental dynamic factor in life and growth. The second chapter considers the child's natural religious reactions to its environing world as modes of such interest. The third chapter gives the results of an inductive study of children’s interest in the Bible. And the fourth chapter applies the principles thus brought to light to the general problem of religious education. The book is not a systematic treatise on the psychology of the child nor on religious education. It is believed, however, that it presents many essential principles that have not else- where been so fully worked out. 130 pages, 12mo, cloth; net 75 cents, postpaid 82 cents. ’ STUDIES IN GALILEE. By Ernest W. Gurney MASTERMAN. Besides the Memoir of the Survey under the Palestine Exploration Fund, and the relevant chapters in works deal- ing with the whole country, several learned monographs have been written in English and German upon the geography, the history, the archmology, and the present dialect of Galilee. Among these Dr. Masterman’s book will take a place of its own. It furnishes fresh and notable contributions to our knowledge of so famous a region. It is richly stored with facts; it is lucidly written; and cannot fail to prove alike valuable to the expert and interesting to the ordinary reader. Dr. Masterman has labored for sixteen or seventeen years in the East. His numerous papers in journals devoted to the history or the geography of the Holy Land prove his acquaintance with the literature, ancient and modern, and have been largely used by experts. Very few know the recent history of the land or the life of the people as well as he. The book is profusely illustrated. 170 pages, 8vo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.12. 7 ADDRESS DEPARTMENT 21 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO NEW YORK
Page 4
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2322 NU eager y Ey. cs = Li Rich Gunes for Will be found in Tur Century Macazive. To it, like a great port, come the choice of ge reson produc- tions in many fields of thought throughout the world. Here are brought the most entertaining fiction and delightful stories by the most brilliant writers. Here, too, come travelers with strange tales from far-off lands, distinguished men of science with important discoveries and | artists with their noblest work. The Vast Wealth of the T™ verre | 5 35 cents a copy, $4.00 a year. A year’s subscription makes an ideal present. M4 isto Las READ . ° ANNE OF AVONLEA Reading Case for The Nation Neue 6 To receive the current numbers in a convenient “ANNE OF GREEN GARLES.”’ Cemporasy? form. Substantially made, bound in ' IT cloth, with “The Nation” stamped on the side in a gold. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and INSPIRING Y?. i Teese | RVES! neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75c. WHY WORRY? and THOSE NERVES! | Tie NATION 20 Vesey Street, N. Y. City By GEORGE L. WALTON,M.D. Cloth, $1 net, each J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. SO Ae
Page 5
Dec. 30, 1909] The Nation Vv Historians, naturalists, financiers, sportsmen, politicians, schol- ars and poets are among those who fill its numbers to overflowing. And all these represent but a part of those who carry their diverse and interesting cargoes to enrich the pages of Tue ™ Century Macazine. Bring these delightful sources of entertainment to your own home through Tue Ceyxrury and widen your intellectual life with World’s Best Thought i At all the best book-stores, or Tue Century Co., Union Square, New York. co | ¥ 1919 | - i, . . ~F\ { \ ee Im ) y Ey) C.W.E jior ee a BOOK S—All out of print books supplied, no | . matter on what subject; write me, stating books il C wanted; I can get you any book ever published ; | A SUMMER In TOURAINE | andy Volume lassics when in England, call and inspect my stock of By FREDERIC LEES. 5 Ope by Raa gs Pe ~~ omeyoten, 155 50,000 rare books, BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP. |] AB, Meal companion for the tourist as | vol.; limp leather, 768, per vol. (Spectal prices John Bright St., Birmingham, Engiand. —CMeago Record-Herald. © Ce and extagen.) With twelve plates in full color and SEND FOR CATALOGUE. AUTOGRAPH of Celebrities Bought and Bold. —— ffl. set Ey aati, $202 | 2 Romas Y.Crowell&Co.,New York LETTERS walees R. BENJAMIN, A. C. MOCLURG & CO,, COhfeage. MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) Pub."THE COLLECTOR.''$1 a yr bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y.
Page 6
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2322 Among the Important New Books of 1909 BOOKS ON ART, MUSIC AND POETRY The French Pastellists of the Eighteenth Century By HALDANE MACFALL Cloth, dec. cover. Col, ill., $10.50 net. (carriage extra) A Book of Operas By HENRY E. KREHBIEL Cloth, illus., $1.75 net, postpaid $1.87 The Playhouse and the Play By PERCY MACKAYE. (Essays) Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 Poems By PERCY MACKAYE Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 Dorian Days (Poems) By WENDELL P. STAFFORD Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.82 The Great Divide (A Play) By WILLIAM VAUGHAN MOODY Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 The Melting Pot (A Play) By ISRAEL ZANGWILL Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 BIOGRAPHY The Life and Times of Laurence Sterne By WILBUR L. CROSS, Yale Uni- versity. Cloth, 8vo, illus., $2.50 net, postpaid $2.70. A Lady of the Old Régime By ERNEST F. HENDERSON Cloth, illus., $2.50 net, postpaid $2.67 My Day Reminiscences of a Long Life By MRS. ROGER A, PRYOR Cloth, illus., $1.50 net, postpaid $2.40 ON CLASSICAL SUBJECTS The Roman Assemblies By GEORGE W. BOTSFORD, Colum- bia University. Cloth, 8vo, $4.00 net, poatpaid $4.29 Social Life at Rome in the Age of Cicero By W. WARDE FOWLER Cloth, illua., $2.25 net, postpaid $2.89 Greek Architecture By ALLAN MARQUAND, Univeraity Itluatrated, cloth, net, poatpaid $2.45. Princeton 2.25 ON EDUCATION The American High School By JOHN FRANKLIN BROWN Cloth, 12mo, 81.40 net, postpaid $1.52 A History of Education Before the Middle Ages By FRANK PIERREPONT GRAVES Cloth, 16mo, 81.10 net NEW NOVELS The Bride of the Mistletoe By JAMES LANE ALLEN Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 Stradella The White Sister | ON PLANETARY SCIENCE The Evolution of Worlds By PERCIVAL LOWELL, Mass, Inst. of Technology Cloth, 8vo, illus., $2.50 net, postpaid $2.70 The two last novels by the late F. | ON SOCIAL QUESTIONS The Approach to the Social MARION CRAWFORD Each, Cloth, Illus., $1.50 FriendshipVillage LoveStories By ZONA GALE Cloth, $1.50 The Romance of a Plain Man By ELLEN GLASGOW ___ Cloth, $1.50 Martin Eden By JACK LONDON A Gentle Knight of Old Brandenburg By CHARLES MAJOR A Certain Rich Man By WILLIAM ALLEN WHITE Cloth, Poppea of the Post-Office By MABEL OSGOOD WRIGHT Cloth, Cloth, $1.50 Cloth, $1.50 $1.50 HISTORY AND POLITICS The Promise of American Life By HERBERT CROLY Cloth, $2.00 net, postpaid $2.14 The Government of European Cities By WILLIAM BENNETT MUNRO, Hervard University. Cloth, 8vo, $2.50 net, postpaid $2.69 Historical Essays By JAMES FORD RHODES Cloth, 8vo, $2.25 net, postpaid $2.40 History of the City of New York Question By FRANCIS G. PEABODY Cloth, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 The Spirit of Youth and the City Streets By JANE ADDAMS, Hull House, Chi- cago Cloth, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.35 Misery and Its Causes By EDWARD T. DEVINE Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.85 TRAVEL AND ADVENTURE Mexico: The Wonderland of the South By WILLIAM E. CARSON Cloth, illus., $2.25 net, postpaid $2.45 $1.50 | Labrador: The Country and the People By WILFRED T. GRENFELL Cloth, illus., $2.25 net, postpaid $2.44 Trans-Himalaya: Discoveries and Adventures in Tibet By SVEN A. HEDIN 388 lllus., 2 vols., $7.50 net (carriage extra) A Wanderer in Paris By E. V. LUCAS 16 illus., in color, $1.75 net, postpaid $1.89 In the Grip of the Nyika By Lieut.-Col. J. H. PATTERSON Illus., cloth, $2.00 net, postpeid $2.20 in the Seventeenth Century The Old Town By MRS. SCHUYLER VAN RENSSE- LAER Cloth, 2 vols., $5.00 net (carriage extra) Cambridge Modern History Volume VI. The Eighteenth Century. Cloth, 8vo0, $4.00 net, postpaid $4.30 ON RELIGIOUS SUBJECTS The Temple By DR, LYMAN ABBOTT Cloth, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.83 The Preacher By ARTHUR 8. HOYT Cloth, $1.50 net, postpaid $1.62 The Laws of Friendship By HENRY C. KING, Oberlin College. Cloth, $1.25 net, postpaid $1.85 Modern Thought and the Crisis in Belief By PROF. R. M. WENLEY, University of Michigan. Cloth, $1.50 net, postpaid $1.63 A Valid Christianity for To-day By the Rt, Rev. CHARLES D. WIL- LIAMS Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net, postpaid $1.62 | | | | By JACOB A. RIIS Cloth, illus., $2.00 net, postpaid $2.15 The New New York By J. C. VAN DYKE. Illustrated by JOSEPH PENNELL. Cloth, 125 illus., $4.00 net, postpaid $4.22 BOOKS TO BE KEPT AT HAND FOR REFERENCE The One-Volume Bible Commentary Edited by J. R. DUMMELOW Cloth, 8vo, $2.50 net, postpaid $2.82 Cyclopedia of American Agriculture Vol. IV., completing the work Editor, L. H. BAILEY, Cornell Unt- versity. The set, 4 vols. cloth, 4to, illus., $20 net, half mor. $382. (carriage extra) Games for the Playground, Home, School and Gymnasium By JESSIE H. BANCROFT, Asst. Di- rector Physical Training, New York City Schools. Cloth, $1.50 net, by mail $1.67 Before the long winter evenings ta the time to look over your shelves and order new books. Published 64-66 Fifth Ave. N. Y. by THE MACMILLAN COMPAN
Page 7
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 30, 1909. water itself can be conferred only by re the State, the Secretary urged thac the The Week. States should be asked to “trans‘er to the United States” the Mr. Pinchot’s address of Monday con- ter-rights” to go with the permits for tained undeniably words of warning. the use of the abutting land. Against He evidently believes that the work of this, Representative Mondell protested conservation is endangered. With with the utmost earnestness, and declar- much intensity of language he spoke ed that such Federal control would not of schemes to defeat the ends aimed at @ tolerated, first, because it was with- by the Forestry Bureau and to fasten out Constitutional warrant, and, sec the clutch of corporate hands, by secret ondly, because “the people of these States and unlawful means, upon what should have clearly and definitely assumed and be kept for the general use and enjoy- do now exercise full and complete con- ment. We take it for granted that Mr. trol over the use and distribution of wa- Pinchot can produce the evidence for ter, and can manage their domestic af- his charges, and that it will be laia in | ‘!'S better than they can be managed due time before the Congressional com- | * them.” This whole policy of con- mittee that is to be appointed to look servation must be written in statutes into the whole matter. There need be|W2ich the wayfaring man can under- no doubt that public feeling is now such *t@"4, which the trickster canno: vio- that it will stand by any official who late without incurring swift and ade- seeks to beat off from government lands %¥4te penalties, and which the Adminis- all dishonest and greedy iutriguers. It tration can enforce as the deliberate will be wise, however, for Mr. Pinchot | ¥!!! of the people. and all who are heartily with him in| tr theee ee, his important work, to perceive that the whole difficulty does not lie in self-seek- report shows that he is alive to the ne- ing and fraudulent opposition to the cessity of increasing the postal revenues, conservation policy. There is an an- but it offers no clear-cut plans for re- tagonism which is honest. In many of form. The chief sources of loss are the the Western States the people feel that rural delivery routes and the low rates their legitimate development is hinder-|°" Magazines, to which Mr. Taft re- ed by too narrow restrictions upon the | ferred in his message. Mr. Hitchcock's preémpting and use of public lands. | Suggestion that distance zones be estab- |lished for the magazines, with varying This Western point of view was well | postal rates, will scarcely prove practi- set forth in the speech which Repre- cal. And if it did we should see the mag- sentative Mondell of Wyoming made in azines moving to the centres of their the House the other day. As printed in circulation. Interference with printed the Congressional Record, it had the matter of as great educational value as caption: “Shall the People or the Bu- these magazines will hardly be possible reaus Rule?” That suggests the line of without arousing violent popular feel- argument. Mr. Mondell spoke with good ing. But an inquiry into the prices paid knowledge of conditions in the public- to the railways for carrying second- land States, and affirmed with energy class matter might be profitable. A their determination to administer their more hopeful field would seem to be own affairs without any “Federal land- the rural delivery routes, into which lordism.” His speech dealt specifically branch of the service, as Mr. Hitchcock with the water-power question. Over admits, serious abuses have crept. The non-navigable rivers in the States, Con- loss here is no less than $28,000,000 a The waters of all year; but when Mr. Hitchcock touches The extension “necessary wa- Postmaster-General Hitchcock's annual gress has no control. natural streams are State property. This this, he touches politics. was fully recognized by Secretary Bal- of the routes has been due largely to linger in his proposal that the Govern- favoritism, so that often in thickly set- ment should not alienate, but only 'ease |tled communities, in which the rural temporarily, lands which may be used | delivery would pay, there is none, and for power-sites. As the right to use the'in the sparsely settled regions repre- zs The Nation. sented by some influential Congressman, rural delivery is general. Hitchcock has no definite suggestions, though he is certain of making consid- and Here, too, Mr. savings by readjustment In that direction seems erable modernization. for the moment to be the best hope of cutting down the deficit of $17,479,- 770.47. Ohio Republicans are saying to ithem- selves with a mixture of apprehension and complacency that their State bids fair to be the chief political battlefield next year. This is partly because we have an Ohio President again, and part ly because, if Gov. Harmon is reélected next November, he may easily become the Democratic candidate for the Presi- dency in 1912. It is felt that it would be a serious blow to Mr. Taft's prestige if his party were to lose his own State before his term was half over. And despite the condescending Republican talk about the need of a strong and re- spectable Opposition party, there is a natural dread of making it so strong and respectable under the leadership of Judson Harmon that it would stand a good chance of carrying the next Presi- dential election. Hence the present flut- ter in Ohio. Its Republican citizens are not a little elated to see their State again made “pivotal” in the old absorb- ing way, but cannot repress a fear lest their party’s fortunes should turn the wrong way on the pivot. The setback to the anti-liquor move- ment in recent local elections in Massa- chusetts and elsewhere has led, accord- ing to the Chicago Inter Ocean, to a re- newal of hostilities between the Prohi- bition forces and the Anti-Saloon League. In a circular issued by the chairman of the Associated Prohibition Press, the argument from Massachusetts is driven hard. In that State, as a whole, an aggregate majority of 26,000 has been registered for no license with- in three years. Yet in the election of two weeks ago four cities with a popu- lation of 220,000 deserted the no-license column, while only one city with 32,000 population entered it. The argument proceeds: Were the same tremendous amount of energy, enthusiasm, money, and political
Page 8
640 wisdom and experience which has been lav- ished in these local contests now to be fo- cussed upon the adequate and sufficient goals of State and national prohibition, backed by an organized political uprising of the people who believe in it, the liquor traffic would see a nation-wide doom within twelve months. With the seesaw activities of the present hour, nothing permanent will ever be accomplished In other words, communities that have once declared against liquor and want to change are to be kept in the straight and narrow way by majorities elsewhere in the State. How far such a system carries an unwilling community towards real prohibition, Portland in Maine and Atlanta and Savannah, Georgia, are still with us to testify. It would be unfair to hold President Taft responsible as yet for the plan of a new government for Alaska which is now being outlined in the newspapers, since he has not officially recommended it. Yet there are marks which indicate his interest in it. The government fore- is based on the Philippine Commission, for there are to be nine councilmen or commissioners, of whom a minority, four, are to be elected; Mr. Taft's plan is, according to report, a “strongly centralized government ad- ministered by comparatively few inen.” We need not discuss now whether the only alternative left in dealing with Alaska is this abandonment of the dem- ocratic theory of government, and even the historic form for the administra- tion of a Territory later to become a State; but we must point out the dan- shadowed ger accompanying our departure from republican in the Philippines. When we first took our rash plunge into Imperialism, we heard much of benefit forms to our own political life to be derived from governing others for their unadul- terated good. But here is about the first case we can record in which the Philippine affected home conditions, and it is in quite the People scoffed a: the experiment has wrong direction. idea that ruling by generals or by com-, missions in Cuba, Porto Rico, in Fana- ma, and the Philippines could react on our own political ideas, but now w: see that it may. Congress will, we truat, be careful not to adopt any plan for auto- eratic government in Alaska without the most careful consideration of what this means and whither it leads. According to cable dispatches from The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2322 Hawaii, “Prince Cupid” has committed the unpardonable sin of attacking Gov. Frear of that Territory, charging that official with falsehood and with holding his office “solely in the interest of the sugar planters.” This incident will prob- ably end, the dispatch says, in the “elim- ination of natives as representatives in Washington,” “Prince Cupid,” or Mr. Kalanianaole, as he is officially knewn, being now Delegate to Congress. The Prince did not even stop with this de- nunciation, but treasonably deciared that the administration of public iands had not been in the interests of the people, but of the sugar planters. “We must do something,” he declared, “to get the land back among the people.” This treason to the sugar planters mer- its, we submit, a much worse peralty than mere deprivation of office. Bread and water for forty days in solitary con- finement strikes us as about the proper punishment for questioning the divine right of capital in Hawaii to continue to control the islends and to exploit the natives precisely ‘as it sees fit. If Cook is insane, that is a matter for regret and sympathy on the part of his personal friends, and a matter of inter- est from the standpoint of the alienist and the psychologist; as a public figure, he ceased to have any interest whatever from the moment that his claim was proved to be fraudulent. It is absurd to treat his case as though he had won great honor in other ways, and after- wards committed acts which were ascribed to moral defects, but which might be explained on the ground of mental disease. Cook had no title to the world’s attention except the perform- ance that is now exposed as a prepos- terous hoax; and whether the fraud was committed by a man who was alto- gether sane or by a man who was more or less insane, is surely a matter pos- sessing very limited interest. When it is further borne in mind that Cook’s past, as shown up in the course of the inquiry, is quite in keeping with the fraudulent and money-grabbing propen- sities exhibited in this matter of the Pole, a last touch is put to the absurd- ity of giving him any further attention as a serious subject of public concern, If a Roman draughtsman had accom- panied Cwsar’s legions to Gaul, and there set down with fidelity the semi- | barbaric warriors, the weapons they bore, the horses they rode, the whole ‘circumstance of aggressive civilization beyond the Alps, we should treasure his work, quite irrespective of any precious quality as art. The faithful picturc of the winning of the West by the late Frederic Remington is marked by a singular vivacity and comprehensive- ness. His curiosity was unbounded, he lived the life he depicted, and enthusi- asm supplied a technique suitable for his peculiar sort of stalwart expression. His business was with action. To con- vey the vivid sense of taut muscle in man or beast he willingly sacrificed what he rightly regarded as the smaller qualities of harmony and surface. Em- phatically the illustrator, the sheer energy and zest of his workmanship make it in every way more important than much that passes as exquisite. He was one of the very few able artists of our time who managed never to be clever, preferring instead a quite mag- nificent audacity in truth-telling. It is not necessary now to pass upon his copious production as art. Presumably, it will mean a little less to a generation for whom Col. Cody and Col. Roosevelt will be half-forgotten legends. But we cannot imagine a time when a lover either of art or of humankind, happen- ing on a portfolio of Frederic Reming- ton’s designs, will not find them tonic. Without him posterity would be at a loss to know what the West looked like, for no photographs have the drastic fa- cility that dignified alike his casual scribble in a notebook and his finished group in bronze. That a little learning is a dangerous thing is a maxim which finds illustra- tion in many ways. One of these is the readiness with which the mass of easy- going up-to-date people accept as a final- ity what they are given to understand is the latest word of “science”—whether in *’~ory, philology, ethnology, phy- sic., wiology, or what not—as to the worthlessness or error of the results ob- tained by the great men of former days. In his address at the opening of the Palmer Physical Laboratory at Prince- ‘ton, printed in the current number of Science, it is pleasing to find Dr. Elihu | Thomas laying down the law in one such case. Speaking of Franklin and, the lightning rod, he says: “In these |later years it is not unusual to meet
Page 9
Dec. 30, 1909] with statements of discredit or denial of the efficacy of this simple device. There seems to be a tendency arong the uninformed to regard it as an old- fashioned and useless if not a danger. ous contrivance.” And he proceeds to assert with emphasis that, while ignor- ant or dishonest lightning-rod men have made worthless installations, ‘the Franklin rod when properly installed undoubtedly immu- nity from lightning damage”; and, fur- thermore, that the best vindication of Franklin is found in the “reliance placed by the trained electrical engineer upon the provision of an easy path for the electricity of lightning to reach the ground.” There are a hundred direc- tions in which there is altogether too much of a “tendency among the unin- secures practical formed’’—and among the well-informed, too—to accept with cheerful alacrity the verdict that this or that achievement of the past must be thrown into the scrap- heap. It is good news to hear from Wash- ington that Zelaya is not to escape us, after all. We had begun to fear that this miscreant, being on Mexican soil, might avoid trial for murder by our Government. lieved learn from Washington dis- patches that Mr. Knox is not worried; that he can bring Zelaya to the bar at any moment. The State knows just what it can do, there being so many precedents for putting on trial Hence we are really re- to Deparunent in his individual capacity the head of one sovereign state for behavior un- satisfactory to another sovereign state. What is the last precedent? Why, Abra- bam Lincoln returned to Spain a slave- ship captain, a subject of Spain, who fled to this country. What analogy could be All Mr. Knox will have tw do closer? will be “Dear Diaz: Please deliver Zelaya to the United States troops at El Paso and let to write to President Diaz: us reciprocate at any time. We expect to try Zelaya at Pittsburgh for his cruel- ties committed in Nicaragua. With best New Year's wishes, Knox.” Seemingly, in international law the Pittsburgh law- yer is hereafter to be as famous for in genuity as the Philadelphia lawyer has long been. Not the least unfortunate aspect of the Nicaragua mixup is the growing strain upon our relations with Mexico. It ‘The is disappointing that, only a few months Nation. after the elaborate show of friendship between Presidents Taft and Diaz on the banks of the Rio Grands tries should have fallen the two coun into a stace of mutual irritation. Mexico is angry and anxious, and shows her resentment by constituting herself Zelaya'’s protector in the hour of his adversity. Our own State thereupon loses its temper and, looking about for something Department to quarrel over, hits upon the case of an five months in a Mexican jail under a crim- inal indictment, without being brought American citizen who has spent to trial. Department, in a tone of moral indigna- tion peculiarly appropriate in a people who, like ourselves, do not know w).at is! meant by the law’s delay, or the occa- sional miscarriage of justice. Certainly the Civis Americanus sum has never been sounded so sonorously as during, these last few weeks of excitemeut in the Caribbean. Belgium under King Albert I enters upon a phase of her national career that full the world at large. To the peoples and poli- may be of high interest for ticilans of Europe there is new food for speculation in the presence of a sover- eign of known German sympathies on the throne of one of the two little mari- time nations that German Imperialistic to have marked Outside of Eu- the rdéle that ambition is supposed ultimately for its own. rope, interest will lie in Belgium under her new King will now play in the Congo. Up to the present the Congo has been a stain on the national honor of Belgium, without the compen- It re- sation even of material profit. mains to be seen whether the new régime will succeed actually in accom- plishing what has been so loudly claim ed in behalf of the late King roots of civilization the plant- ing of the the the Dark Continent. It is a splendid opportunity offered to a small The the low stage of civilization its inhabi- in heart of nation. Congo colony, because of tants have reached, because of the great difficulties it more peculiarly a white man’s burden administrative offers, is than almost any other possession of the European nations High testimonials the efficiency civil excel- been paid to of the have often Belgian ser- the Congo. They the clutch and devotion vice in were lent men in of an evil sys- How about it, asks our State. . O-+1 tem. These men should now have an opportunity to show what they can do when they work, not for rubber, but for civilization. it is impossible for Americans to point to assassination of high officers of gov ernment as a product of despotic con- ditions exclusively, in view of our own record of Presidential assassinations; but when three such events are given in the telegraphic dispatches of a single day, and al] of them are based on essen- tially similar conditions, the concurrence is too striking to be passed over. The blowing to pieces of the chief of the secret police in St. Petersburg is but the latest incident ina long story of des- perate des- potism; the killing of the Prime Minis- ter of Korea, as of a British chief mag- revolt against intolerable istrate in India, is a manifestation of a state of things that is more recent. But in all three cases, the fundamenta] fact is the same—the unrest of the people of our time, whether in Orient or Occident, under conditions which are a denial of the right of self-government. It to take note of such indications of the is well state of mind of subject peoples and re- member them when smooth things are prophesied of the future of our own re- lations with the people of the Philip- pines. Mr. Wu Ting Fang's promise that he will be with us again fifty years from now gives the people of the District American Mr. of Columbia and the entire press something to look forward to, Wu's Minister entrances and exits as Chinese at Washington constitute one of the most legitimate and real subjects of permanent newspaper interest. He has been in the flesh the imaginary trav- whom of eller from China or the Indies eighteenth-century writers were fond making the vehicle of satire against Eu- The in the Chinese diplomat’s acts and sayings ropean civilization. tone which have been chronicled shows plainly that we credit the bland and open-eyed ob server from the East with a sense of hu- mor equal to our own. If Minister Wu carries out his intention of living two hundred years and comes back as Min 1959, in may it be of ister at Washington as the representative a constitution- al, well- governed, and prosperous China dis-Aldriched United States to a free, self-overning, and un‘annonized
Page 10
642 ECONOMIC SCIENCE IN. AMERICA. The American Historical Association and the American Economic Association celebrating in New York this week twenty-fifth of their That the Historical Associa- are the anniversary formation. tion should date back only a quarter of a century seems surprising, in view of the extensive pursuit of historical study from of our national life; an early period but in the case of the Economic As- sociation, the foundation of the society was almost coeval with the beginnings of important and widespread activity in our country in the fleld whose cultiva- tion it was designed to promote. Indeed, formation of the American when the Economic Association was proposed, twenty-five years ago, few persons real- ized that body existed in America a able economics adequate to maintain such an there of earnest and students of association. And in fact such a body of economic scholars and investigators in our country had at that time existed only a very few years. Great as have been the material changes in America in the past three the applications of invention, the tion of industrial and financial power— decades the growth of wealth, concentra- there has been quite as striking a change in the development of special- ized research there has been, since the foun learning. In every department of dation of the Johns Hopkins University in 1876, a radical change of the sratus of American science and scholarship as related to the intellectual activities of Old World. Before that time, with of re of some isolated man of extraordl- exception the work here and powers, America was content, in y every field, to be a receptive fol to European § investiga- of ment of sclence leaving the task maintaining the ad and the pro,ress cholarship; in almost every h, she now, contributes, at least in quan and in many instances in quality her full share to the great stream entifie research and publication. might have been thought, a priori, economics would naturally be an eption to this rule; that, In view of the prominence of economic factors in the making of our history, the study of such phenomena would have at tracted adequate attention at an earlier of by no means the case inquiry; On date than other branches but this was 'among us. The Nation. the contrary, there is perhaps no de- partment of research which—aside trom the work of a few notable individuals— had been more completely neglected And among the very few ex- ceptions that did exist, two were of the kind that eminently prove the rule; for the work of both Henry Carey and Henry George, whatever may be one’s judgment of its merit or its value, was precisely of the kind that does not spring from a general or systematic cul- tivation of scientific study. In the common advance of specialized study that has taken place in America, no department of inquiry has shared more conspicuously than economics; in- deed, it may be doubted whether there is any other subject in which so marked a development has been shown. And this is not surprising; for in the case of economics there has been present an in- citement special to this province. Thir- ty years ago, with the exception of the currency and the tariff, there were no economic problems felt by the nation at large to be pressing. Labor questions | economists in the carrying on of govern- there were, to be sure; but they had not assumed anything like the definiteness of the questions of to-day. Our nation- al resources still seemed inexhaustible. We were only beginning to realize the and significance of corporation the giant combinations of scope problems; capital that are in the forefront to-day Our people were and were in the future. still predominantly agricultural; Socialism was only dimly thought of as a question that might some day come home to us. With the growing complex- ity of our conditions and the growing urgency of economic questions of every kind, there has been a demand fcr a vast amount of close study, both of gen- eral problems and of specific conditions; and the publications of the American Economic Association bear witness to the fact that this worthily responded to by the professors universities and by other stu- demand has been in our dents. to It would be a mistake, however, attribute solely to these practical de- mands the growth of economic study in our country. In the domain of theory there has been a notable activity, and several of our writers have won high in- ternational recognition in this field. In- deed, it is interesting to recall that, in its early years the American Economic Association interested many chiefly for [ Vol. 89, No. 2322 its attitude toward the controversy, then at its height, between the “orthodox” English political economy and the views of the German “historical school.” It was soon made plain that the Associa- tion was not to be identified with any dogma or faction; and the controversy itself now seems a vague and distant memory. As to the work of American economists in general, it may fairly be said that some of them have pushed the refinements of theoretical analysis as far as they have been carried any- where, while others have gone into the most painstaking and laborious examin- ation of concrete facts. If some of this labor, in both directions, has passei be- yond the limits of what is profitable, that is but the price which must always be paid, in this world, for the energetic and whole-hearted promotion of any large object. There is one important aspect of the growth of scientific study of economics in our country which is too gratifying to be passed without mention. This is the utilization of the services of trained ment work, and the influence that has been exercised by them on the course of legislation and administration. With professors of economics drafted into the public service for such tasks as the straightening out of the finances of Por- to Rico and San Domingo, the investiga- tion of tariff schedules under the provi- sion of the new tariff act, the organiza- tion of the work of the National Mone- tary Commission, and other things too numerous to mention, the epithet “aca- demic” will hardly any longer be ap- plied to our scientific economists as a term of reproach. But these govern- mental appointments by no means fur- nish a measure of the practical influ- ence that our economists have been ex- ercising. The remarkable development of governmental efficiency in the State of Wisconsin, in its dealings with cor- porations and in other matters, is a sig- nal example of the kind of thing we have in mind. And, aside entirely from governmental activities, there is the in- fluence of our economists upon the for- mation of public opinion on the great questions of the day, an influence which is sure to be manifested in increasing degree as the years go by. It is a na- tfonal gain that, at a time when we shall need all the resources of trained intelligence and impartial investigation
Page 11
Dec. 30, 1909] for the wise treatment of economic prob- lems, there has grown up among us a body of men properly equipped for such a@ task. ° HISTORY AS AN ART. The works of the Neapolitan philoso- pher and critic, Benedetto Croce, are well known to special students. He has the gift of clear and trenchant utter- ance, and the translation just issued of his first extensive work, “A®sthetic,” will interest any one who can read real books of any sort. Many who are in- different to the main argument wiil be stimulated by incidental comment that touches vigorously pretty much every field of intellectual activity. ple, Signor Croce discusses in passing For exam- the much-disputed point whether his- tory is a science or an art. Here he goes immediately to funda- mentals. What counts for him in the case is not any display of method, but the nature of the affirmations made by the historian. These, when they tran- scend mere annalism, are not affirma- tions of the intellect, based on general- ized experience, but intuitions based on the memory of other persons. More- over, history never permits real gener- alizations. It deals always with the par- ticular. We talk of heroes but mean Antony or Napoleon; we discourse con- cerning nations but mean always Nome or England. The generalizations of his- tory are either illusions or pretence. At times they are valuable. we have philosophy In such case, says our guide, masking as history. have merely the complicated and ex- tended intuitions of the artist-historian borrowing the airs and phrases of the sciences, That history, if a science, is on a dif- ferent basis from any that admits di- rect observation and experiment has frequently been remarked. Signor Croce lays smaller stress upon the inherently uncertain nature of the data of history than upon the manner in which such materials inevitably are transmuted into the written page. He might have alluded tellingly to the fact that the his- torians who most affect the manner of science have generally declined to at- tempt this transmutation, occupying themselves merely with the arrange- ment and publication of archives. And the timidity of such scholars throws much light on the whole matter. What More often we The Nation. do they fear except to fall into what they scornfully style “mere literature,” that is, history—and art? Whenever history, as distinguished from source-books, is written, we are in the field of the intuitions. Out of a variety of possibilities we get the one that has vividly appealed to the taste of a given historian. This is true of what we or- dinarily call the facts of history; and evidently its interpretations are even more deeply colored by simple personal preferences. This view has been objected to as be- littling one of the most fascinating of pursuits. Signor Croce, on the contrary, claims to be the very good friend of history. As an art greater respect than it may arrogate as a pseudo-science, and if its affirmations are often divinations, they are thus all the nearer to the kind of intuitions by which we perforce direct our own lives. Here he takes strong ground against the skeptics for whom history is “the fable agreed upon.” The historian an artist, but he deals in an authentic and even authoritative art of life: real it deserves even is Historical certainty is composed of memory and of authority, not of analyses and of demonstration. To speak of his- torical induction or demonstration, is to make a metaphorical use of these expres- sions, which in history bear a meaning quite different from that which they bear in science. The conviction of the historian is the undemonstrable conviction of the juryman, who has heard the _ witnesses, listened attentively to the case, and prayed Heaven to inspire him. Sometimes, with- out doubt, he is mistaken, but the mistakes are in a negligible minority compared with the occasions when he gets hold of the truth. If this view of the procedures of his- tory is true, there remains to be in- ferred a rather important corollary. If the method of history is wsthetic, then the absence of acceptable form in its composition is simply intolerable. To say that a history is good but badly written and composed is as foolish as to remark that a sonnet is beautiful but clumsily turned. A general acceptance of Signor Croce’s theory would rule out of court hundreds of ill-digested books in which the historian has rashly claim- ed the scientist's immunity from the re- quirement of form. The loss of these books would be slight. Indeed, a gen- eral clearing out of pretty much all the thicket that lies between avowed archiv- ism and real history would be benefi- cial not only to the public but also to the historian. 643 “LITTLE TIM” AND TAMMANY. In the career of such a man as Tim- othy P. Sulivan, and in the extraordi- nary manifestations of personal affec- tion for him which his death has evok- ed on the East Side, we get a vivid glimpse of the secret of Tammany's power. It is an old but fresh illustration of it can fail to fix the attention. Politics and governmen- tal questions are involved, but there is something more—the human The name of Sullivan has been some- thing to conjure with in thickly popu- lated districts of New York, not merely because the bearers of it were Tammany leaders and influential politicians. They have been, in addition, a sort of earthly story, no element. Providence to thousands of men and women and children with whom they have lived in close contact and on terms of fellow-feeling, and whom they have thoroughly understood. Tammany is a wonderful political machine, but the true hiding of its power lies not in organization, but in the man-to-man dealing, the intimate personal relat ‘ons, which exist between so many of its leaders and the vast concourse of peo- ple of all races, with their shifting so- cial conditions, which make up so large a part of the voting strength south of Fourteenth Street. Among them the dead Sullivan lived and grew rich and politically powerful, but never lost the reputation of being a man of the people, a “good feller,” a kind neighbor and friend. This ¢x-sa- loonkeeper, this gambler, this politician who rose rapidly to large wealth by was at least an questionable means, the which human problem meant so much He had name of being a brother of the poor. In in adept in for him. the their good fortune he rejoiced and their calamities he was ready with his sympathy. He made himself easily a: cessible to the troubled, the friendless, the needy. Not only by gifts and as sistance in times of emergency, but by acting as a general employment agent, a counsellor, a champion, an intervener between the law and offenders, did he steal away the hearts of the people in his district and hold their political sup port in the hollow of his hand. We are not saying that this is admir- The dark side of the picture must never be forgotten. Sullivan knew how to live upon the vices and the misery of It able. the people he ostensibly befriended
Page 12
644 is said that he never drank himself, but coined money out of the perverted appe- tites and degradation of slaves of li- He himself, for all dence is strong that quor may have been a clean liver we know, but the evi- he levied tribute, directly or indirectly, upon those who made barter of womanhood and domesti- hell-fire East Side. And with all his airs of good-fellowshiv and cated on the human kindness, a Tammany leader like Sullivan is really bent like Croker upon the removable his own all of causes of the wretchedness around him. working for pocket time, in disregard the What true and lasting improvement in the lot of the poor in New York is due to the initiative of a Sullivan? Christ- mas presents and picnics represented merely a largess skimmed from the top of his large winnings. What have such things to do with better tenements and Streets, sanitary advances, school priv- ileges, a lowered death rate, and ali the general struggle of poverty against ad- verse conditions? In that long battle, the Sullivans are merely camp-follow- ers, who may indeed relieve now and then a sick or give have injured man, but who away only a part of what they first stolen, and who never get the bad environment into the real fighting line agains‘ evils and vices and and misgovernment which keep the poor down and rob them of opportunity and of hope. All this must not be overlooked as a fearful offset to the charities and friend- ly activities of Timothy Sullivan among The bly against him; and all that we say Is his constituents. balance is terri- that his traits and methods go far to making intelligible the political power which he won. In his person, we see how Tammany ceases to be a faraway system, a political organization, and be- comes, to the streets and homes of the teeming East Side, both near and in tensely human To comprehend ts not, in this in stance, to forgive. But it is certainly not to scorn, elther. Let prouder political leaders, and public men who hold them- selves much higher in the world than “Little Tim” before disdaining him, whe Sullivan, pause and ask themselves ther their motives are essentially dif- ferent from his. If he was ready to build up a political following by an unscru pulous use of the offices, are not they? Was it any worse for a Sullivan to “dig The Nation. up something” for a henchman in a city department, than for a Parsons to hunt jobs in the custom-house for his helpers? Extremes meet when we get down to the fundamental instincts of politicians. Nor is the question of comparative hon- esty so easy of solution. We can imag- Protectionists drawing away their garments from a ine many complacent grafting and gambling Sullivan, in poli- tics to make money, but are they really any better? Is Tammany actually more mercenary than the Home Market Club We know of no satisfactory proof that it or the Protective Tariff League? is. If to seek to get control of the of- fices and to make laws, for the purpose of putting the public money in private pockets, be the animating motivs of Tammany, those who are actuated by it in other fields and under other names cannot escape the condemnation which inevitably falls upon political selfishness In this view, there is no essential difference between getting and corruption. rich by buying city privileges from the Aldermen, and by buying protective laws from Congress. Pursuing the analysis to the bitter end, it is hard to distinguish the of an Aldrich or a Cannon. methods of a Sullivan from those THE ISSUES IN ENGLAND. Evidence is piling up that the Eng- lish Conservatives are not pleased with the way in which the electoral campaign is going. What troubles them most is that the issues are not in the popular mind what they are in the Conserva- tive mind. It is a common experience in democracies; the voters have a per- verse way of deciding for themselves what chiefly interests them, with a cool disregard of what party leaders assure them is the main issue. The Conserva- tive managers would have a protective tariff put into the forefront of discus- with emphasis laid upon the vicious features of the budget; but to their disgust and dismay they find everybody talking about the House of Lords and the necessity of destroying sion, minor its veto. On this point we may quote the Morning Post, which says ruefully that “the campaign against the House of Lords is an attempt to prevent the nation from speaking its mind on the great question. If only the mind of the public can be riveted on the fiscal issue during the next few weeks, vic- [ Vol. 89, No. 2322 tory will be assured.” In line with this is Joseph Chamberlain's declaration, in the preface which he has written for a political pamphlet, that the Liberals are trying to raise a “false issue.” He would have the Conservatives stoutly with- stand this effort to “shift the ground”; and concludes with a sentence which certainly does not betray very high con- fidence in the outcome: “If the issve of tariff reform were submitted by itself, there would be no doubt whatever of the reply.” The Conservatives, however, have no reason to be surprised at the trend of the campaign. They were distinctly warned in advance of precisely what would happen. Lord Rosebery pointed out with the utmost plainness, as did such Conservatives as Lord Cromer and Lord James of Hereford and Lord Bal- four of Burleigh, that if the House of Lords threw out the budget the elec- tion would be fought primarily on that issue, and that the rights and very ex- istence of the upper chamber would be at stake. It was abundantly predicted, and was, indeed, inevitable, that th»: bat- tlecry made possible by the action of the Lords would at once unite and heart- en the Liberals and draw to them the aupport of the Labor party and the Irish. All this has come to pass. In- deed, the Conservatives themselves have been unable to avoid meeting the issue which they dread. Peers have taken the field in their own defence, and the ablest Unionist orators have been com- pelled to speak about the topic upper- most in public thought. Even Joseph Chamberlain, like Mr. Balfour, is forced to give attention to the “false issue,” and makes an argument in behalf of a Second Chamber. This, of course, ex- poses Mr. Chamberlain to the terrible retorts taken from his own speeches of twenty-five and thirty years ago, when he was a flaming Radical and indulged in harsher language about the Lords than even Lloyd-George’s to-day. Here, for example, is an extract from a speech made by Mr. Chamberlain in 1884, in which he asked whether the Lords were to “dictate to us, the people of England, the laws which we shall make,” and called upon his hearers never to submit to “this miserable minority of individ- uals who rest their claims upon priv- ilege and upon accident”: I have no spite against the House of Lords, but I have an account to settle with them, and I promise I will not forget the
Page 13
Dec. 30, 1909] reckoning. I boast a descent of which I am as proud as any baron may be of the title which he owes to the smiles of a king or to the favor of a king’s mistress, for I can claim descent from one of the two thousand—one of the ejected members who, in the time of the Stuarts, left home and work and profit rather than accept a State-made creed which it was sought to force upon them. And for that reason, if for no other, I share your hopes and your aspirations, and I resent the insults, the injuries, and the injustice from which you have suffered so long at the hands of a privileged assembly. We have been too long a peer-ridden na- tion, and I hope you’ will say to them that if they will not bow to the mandate of the people they shall lose for ever the authority which they have so long abused. Mr. Chamberlain is, of course, like all statesmen, entitled to change his views on mature reflection, but nobody knows better than he what ammunition for the Liberals may be drawn from his old And he would be one of the first to perceive that the action of the arsenals. Lords could not fail to arouse resent- ment among the working classes and cause the Labor Party to seek a closer working agreement with the Liberals. This last is, in fact, in the way of being perfected. It is one of the ominous clouds on the Conservative horizon. There is no hard and fast arrangement between the Labor leaders and the Lib- eral managers, but many signs of a good understanding. It is not that La- bor candidates will not seek election to Parliament in as great numbers as in 1906, but that many Labor candidates will be withdrawn in constituencies where they could not hope to succeed, and where a_ three-cornered contest might give the seat to the Conserva- tives. Several members of the Labor Party Executive Committee have recent- ly made significant addresses, in which they have said that “the rights uf the nation over-ride the fortunes of a par- ty,” and that “we do not want to do anything to help to return a candidate who is on the side of the Peers.” Con- sequently, many an expected Labor can- didacy will be abandoned, on the conve- nient ground that neither the party pol- icy nor the party treasury will admit of it. The recent decision of the law Lords that members of a trades-union can- not be compulsorily assessed to pay Par- liamentary expenses, will not make the Labor Party fall suddenly in love with the Peers. Funds will, no doubt, be raised by workingmen voluntarily, but all the greater care will be taken to The Nation. spend them so as to tell most heavily against the Conservatives. THE WORLD'S LITERARY CENTRE. Now that the North Pole has been dis- posed of, we may turn our attention once more to the one really legitimate field of geographic interest, which has all this time been located in East Africa. While the Arctic Circle has been spin- ning through its brief day of glory, East Africa has bided in patience and the men who write about East Africa have stuck grimly to their typewriters. They are now laughing last. We shall have just one book about the North Pole. Already we count, upon the shelf,a full half-doz- en books about East Africa. It is extra- ordinary how many people seem to know so many things about what has been usually spoken of as an unknown coun- try. Yet the region between Victoria Nyanza and the Indian Ocean has drawn visitors from all corners of the civilized world for all sorts of reasons. Baedeker, when he takes up East Africa, will find undeniable evidence that the country of- fers attractions, as the advertisements say, for the missionary, the big-game hunter, the health-seeker, and the jour- nalist. All of them are now publishing their experiences. It is obvious that but for Mr. Roose- velt, most of these books would never have seen the light. It is not a ques- tion of merit; almost without excep- tion, the books make very good reading. But it is not merit that unlocks the publisher’s heart when there is no mar- ket for a particular brand of goods. Mr. Roosevelt has opened up such a market. He has recently been described as a dy- namic geographer, as a man who takes obscure places and puts them on the map. Having done that service for Oyster Bay and Rock Creek Park in Washing- ton, he now comes to the aid of a large section of the Dark Continent. But if the present flood of books on East Africa keeps up, Mr. Roosevelt will inevitably rank high as a dynamic literary pio- neer as well as a geographer. The path- ways of Mt. Kenia may become more fa- miliar than the streets of the national capital. Every school-boy may soon have at his fingers’ ends the annual rainfall, and barometric at Mombasa. But literature will share in the triumphs of science; the library temperature, pressure 645 shelves keep groaning as the lions and rhinoceroses fall. Mr. Roosevelt can afford to take his time while smaller people write their books. They cannot compete with him. His methods are not their methods and his appeal is not their appeal. Though a thousand volumes be written on the sub- ject, the world is sure to wait for the final word to be spoken by the only man qualified to utter it. No blame to the minor writers if they make hay while the sun shines. There is a popular im- pression that the books have come from men who sped to East Africa after Mr. Roosevelt's plans for visiting that coun- try were announced. Of the half-dozen books we have referred to, all deal with experiences antedating Mr. Roosevelt's by many months or many years. The fur- ther back we go, the more interesting do we find our book as a rule. In recent years, East Africa has suffered from a monotony of big-game hunters, who come for the same purpose, travel up by the same line of rail from Mombasa, and either shoot a large number of lions and There variety in earlier days when travel was elephants or do not. was more by caravan and the route was not mark- ed out so rigidly. The earlier travellers, too, were much more interested in the human inhabitants of the country than in its fauna. No present-day author, of course, can avoid referring with toler- able frequency to the people about him, even if these appear in the rather arti- ficial réle of game-beaters and carriers But in too for the white adventurer. many books the main interest lies in discussions as to the relative danger of hunting lions, buffalo, leopards, and rhinoceroses. One writer grows very warm on the subject: There is one other beast which is not often considered in the discussion of the most dangerous animals, and yet men who have had experience look upon him, when he is wounded, with a degree of respect that places him not even second to the lion. I mean a wounded leopard He is the sneakiest, meanest hunter, and the most cruel, ferocious fighter of possibly any of the cat tribe Considering to what trouble and expense the hunter has gone in journeying to East Africa after his skin, how inexcus- ably thoughtless in the leopard! the risk down in the scroll of the mollycoddles, Hence, at of being written we express our preference for the old- fashioned books of travel, the straight out-and-out account of the trained eth-
Page 14
646 nological observer, or better still, the story told by some missionary worker the on basis of long years of experi- ence. There are books of this type in the whiff of the old delight when some of new crop, and in them we catch a us were younger than we are now, and Du Chaillu wrote of Gorilla Land and Stanley was new and Livingstone was still fresh. We come back with joy to those terrifying Masai and Nandi wo- men with heavy wooden billets distort- ing lips and nose and ear-lobes almost The young bucks doing their war-dance; the to the size of a merry widow hat. witch-doctor whose efficacy is considered as varying with the amount of noise he makes, as is sometimes the case among doctors outside of Africa; the songs and the games and the queer funeral cus and the the do these things still fall within toms initiatory rites for boys the ken of the boy of to-day, or have they been totally eclipsed by the dime hand and the Henty novel on the one and Alger books on the other? Does the own familiar texts sound in the heathen modern boy know how queer his Has he ever read that in the dialect, tongues? Lumasaba “Onward, Christian Soldiers” begins: Babana ba Yesu mivinyuke mwesi Mulole Yesu, ayu worangiye into the of treasures of the If these falling the lines, proper hands, shall be means leading some boy to the old- fashioned book of travel, they will not have been written in vain, RECENT GERMAN FICTION, Amazing originality and variety of motives characterize recent German fic Adventures surpassing in imagin flight anything Jules Verne ever invented; the mystery of crime wrought with the craft of Sherlock veychopathic problems, marriage tion. ative Holmes; con- flicta, and tragedies of conscience: sure respectable array of vital the whether the equals the ambitious ef answered in the affirma ly a topics. Hut achievement question accual fort cannot be Live Most of the books are of a nature to rouse a curlous human Interest rather e an harmonious esthetic more documents than works of art, is significant that for the which is derived from a well constructed and well told narrative one has to turn to writers not identified with the modern than to produe T hey effect are and it enjoyment too closely movement. One of the most remarkable works is “Die Seite,” Alfred Kubin andere by The Nation. (Munich: Georg Miller), the first novel of an artist whose illustrations for a volume of Poe recently gave evidence of striking individuality. His story of life on the other side of the wall which separates the world of reality from that of dreams is a tour de force; yet he adds illusion to the fabric of his ex- uberant fancy. His story of a journey to some remote corner of the world, where his mysterious hero rules over his heterogeneous people in a weird, hypnotic manner, is built up wita re- markable consistency. The events oc- curring in the fictitious capital of that dream kingdom, which is appropriately placed in Asia, are touched with enough of realism to seem possible, even in a more tangible world; but they do not lack that touch of the incongruous which is an essential feature of dreams. The annihilation of the king’s power by a clever American, and the destruc- tion of the city by an earthquake, form the strong climax. Karl Bleibtreu, the champion of the “Revolution der Literatur” twenty-five years ago, has become so compictely estranged from the younger generation that he lets no opportunity pass to vent his wrath upon it. This seems to be the purpose of, and perhaps the sole excuse for, his new: novel, “Die Vielzuvielen” (Georg Miiller), in which he ridicules the Nietzschean proclivities of the time by dividing his people into “Vielzuviele” and supermen. The result is less than one has a right to ex- pect from a book bearing the author's name on its title-page. The delineation of the characters lacks that touch of truthfulness and vitality which would make them portraits of real men and women. Yet some of his sidelights upon social and political conditions show that the author had the material for creating a convincing picture of life in certain cir- cles of Berlin, had he chosen to do so. Johannes Schlaf is slowly approach- ing a similarly dangerous attitudc to- wards his time, and seems to see no- thing in the life about him but its tran- sient excrescences. In his new rovel, “Am toten Punkt” (Georg Miiller), he has returned to a psychopathic prob- lem which he treated some years ago in “Der Kleine.” The hero is a young college graduate, who serves as eecre- tary to his uncle, a physician engaged upon a work similar to that of Krafft- Ebbing. The investigator sets out to substantiate his theorles by personai ob- servations and experiments upon the people about him. The youth becomes the object of his investigations, whose results are carefully recorded; the book closes with the youth’s departure ‘rom the scene of his ordeal on the death of his mother. The character of the hero is drawn with great firmness, the only inconsistent stroke being his surrender to the fascination of the Baroness Hils- bach, who presides over a salon of in- No. 232 [Vol. 89, tellectuals. The figure of the physician is slightly overdrawn, although exclu- sive devotion to any one subject of re- search that lies in the regions of the abnormal, is likely to foster idiosyn- crasies of a morbid character. Somehow the writers of Switzerland, though by no means lacking in under- standing of modern problems, do hold aloof from their unhealthy manifes- tations. This is as true of Ernst Zahn and Maria Schlumpf as of Emil Ermatinger, who, for some years ‘known as a writer on philological and literary topics, is nagy to be ranked as a promising newcomer in German fic- tion. There have been many novels of school and college life in its serious and even tragic phases, but none more thoughtful and few more wholesome in spirit than “Der Weg ins Leben” (Ber- lin: Egon Fleischel & Co.). The son of a widow earning her scanty living as a small shopkeeper in a little Swiss town with the typical population of well- meaning busybodies, is the hero of this story. The boy is destined for the theo- logical career, and his struggles with a curriculum for which he is poorly fit- ted, the unsympathetic attitude of nar- row-minded instructors, and the petty tyranny of a cruel guardian, furnish the incidents of the plot. Love, which looms so large above the horizon of average fiction, enters only as a secondary fac- tor. Ludwig Thoma, hitherto identified with the short story of Bavarian village life,has written his first novel, “Andreas Vost” (Munich: Albert Langen), and a story of unusual power it is. The rude but honest rustic, fighting bitterly and stubbornly for justice before the law, has been so effectively handled by An- zengruber and other German and Aus- trian writers, that it was no small task for the author to re-create and indi- vidualize the type. Thoma’s sympathet- ic understanding of the Bavarian peas- ant and of rural conditions throughout the province never showed to better ad- vantage than in this work. Rudolf Herzog impressively portrays in his novel, “Hanseaten” (imported by G. E. Stechert & Co., New York), repre- sentatives of the old families of ship- builders and shipowners in Hamburg, which form a sort of aristocracy within the bourgeoisie of the old Hansa iown. He has created three distinct types of striking truthfulness and vitality. Karl Tersten, the stern man of duty, is the faithful guardian of the name and the fortune bequeathed to him by his re spectable forebears. Theodor Bramberg is typical of a degeneracy which seals the fate of a race of hard workers whose strength is exhausted. Between these two the author has placed Vanhelil, the man with a capacity for work and for joy, the exponent of a wholesome phil- «wsophy and art of living. There is a peculiar symmetry in the grouping of
Page 15
Dec. 30, 1909] Herzog’s characters, for the three wives stand in a similar relation to one another: Frau Angele Tersten, the fas- cinating Cuban beauty, light-headed and light-hearted and unscrupulous; Inge- borg Bramberg, a woman of rare intelli- gence and independence of character, forced into an early marriage; and the charming Frau Vanheil, an artist's daughter whose sunny disposition, no less than her tact and taste, make of her modest home a sanctuary of happi- ness. The novel which bids fair to become the most successful book of the sea son is Gustav Frenssen’s “Klaus Hin- rich Baas” (Imported by Lemcke & Buechner, New York). It is likely, too, to give the author a higher and less dis- puted rank in German fiction than he has heretofore enjoyed. For while he has preserved in it all the qualities that made “Jérn Uhl” the most popular German novel of the last twenty-five years, he has outgrown some of the de- fects that marred the harmony of his earlier work. The new novel has the charming flavor of the native soil, the admirable simplicity of style and direct- ness of speech that distinguished “Jérn Uhl,” but it has little of its predeces- sor’s prolixity. Nor does the author any longer force his radical views on religion and the sex problem upon his reader. In the greater part of the book, the hero’s mother, unprepossessing in appearance, gruff of manner, but of unbending energy and sterling honesty, is the most conspicuous figure. There is no doubt that the strong woman who had brought out the best there was in Jan Baas proves also the main power that moulds the personality of his son; for the mother’s doubts in his efficiency are a mighty spur to the ambition of Klaus Hinrich. The development, from the little dreamer, who “saw things” whenever he closed his eyes in the obscurity of his bedroom, to the practical business man whose foresight, perseverance, and devotion save the old respectable firm of A. E. Eschen from bankruptcy, is a remarkably strong and consistent piece of work. Throughout his Lehrjahre as clerk, his military service, his expe- riences in India,and his work in a pro- vincial banking-house, the individual Klaus Hinrich Baas is subconsciously fighting the Baas type; but with few digressions, he follows the direct line to- wards the goal he has set himself. Once only does the family susceptibility to pleasing sensuous impressions overrule his reason and cause him to drift into a by-way; but when the vague idealism and morbid sentimentalism of Martje opens the breach between them, he re- sumes his old course. With the dissolu- tion of that ill-starred marriage and his return to Hamburg, Klaus Hinrich is himself once more and finally finds in Sanna Eschen the wife and companion The Nation. he needs in the strenuous life before him. This is the outline of the plot, rich in incidents which are firmly knit into a narrative of absorbing interest. There are some delightful bits of de- scription: the pictures of rural condi- tions on the Holstein heath, the glimpses of life under the tropical sun of India, the animated panorama of Hambure’s streets, are full of color and atmos- phere. The character drawing is excel- lent; the members of the Baas house- hold, as those of the Eschen family, and even characters of minor importance, stand out against their background in striking outlines. The story reflects the author’s personality and wholesome phil- osophy with a more mature and refined art than his previous works, and is al- together a notable achievement. A. VoN ENDE. BIBLIOGRAPHICAL NOTES ON POE.—II. Last week I called num- ber of brief essays by Poe that have been overlooked by Poe's editors. In this second and final instalment of my article to direct attention to some neglected ver sions of certain of the poems and tales. Of these the most thos« to be found in the Flag of Our Union for 1849. This periodical, a kly at Boston, is, for 1849 at least, of little in- attention to a I wish interesting are wer pubtished terest except as being the place of first publication of most of Poe's best produc- tions during his final year. But this inter- est has been enhanced by the fact that files of the paper had eluded the search of all Poe’s wold, who, however, it. The copy that has at last turned up is to be found in the Library of Congress, to which it came, I am credibly through an exchange a few with one of the Boston libraries. editors, except, perhaps, Gris- makes no mention of info;med, years back Poe’s letters had made it clear that at least one of the tales (“Hop-Frog”’) and three of the poems (“A Valentine,” “For Annie,” and the sonnet “To My Mother’) had appeared in the Flag in the spring or summer of 1849; but it not clear in what numbers they had appeared. It now develops that “Hop-Frog” appeared in the issue of March 17, and that the poems ap- peared, respectively, on March 3, April 28, and July 7. It further develops that not only these, but five other of Poe’s poems and tales appeared there, as follows: “A Dream within a Dream,” March 31; “Von Kempelen and his Discovery,” April 14; “Eldorado,” April 21; “X-ing a Paragrab,” May 12; and “Landor’s Cottage,” June 9. All of these are duly advertised as “By Edgar A. Poe,” each of is formally announced in the number immediately pre- ceding that in which it appeared, and af- ter the first or second of these ments Poe is proudly proclaimed regular contributor.” Of the nine tales and poems thus brought out in the Flag of our Union, only one, “A Dream within a Dream,” had appeared previcusly (in the “Poems” of 1827, 1829, and 1831). One outcome, then, of the un- earthing of a file of this paper is to re- veal the place and the exact time of first publication of eight of Poe's poems and was them announce- ‘ as “our G47 tales. Another is to establish the authen- ticity of “Eldorado.” This had been doubt- ed, and by no less an authority than the late W. M. Griswold (see Woodberry’s‘ Life of Poe,” IT, 417). Still another gain is to acquit the elder Griswold of having coined the title, “A Dream within a Dream.” The text of Poe's publications in the Flag differs but little from the text of Griswoltl. In the tales, the only noteworthy variation that I detected in a hasty examination was an additional sentence at the end of “Lan- dor’s Cottage,” in which Poe mentioned the possibility of bringing out a third number of the series to which this belongs. Of the poems, “For Annie” is farthest of all removed from Griswold, showing differ- ences not only in phrase, but also in line- division and in the order of stanzas; but it will remembered that Poe complained in a letter to Mrs. Richmond that the text of this poem had been garbled by the Fleg, gave this as his reason for Willis publish a corrected copy in the Home Journal.* “A Valentine” also displays sev- eral variations—seven or eight in all. But To My Mother” has only one variant read- ing—sweet instead of dear in the fifth line; and “Eldorado” and “A within a Dream” differ in no respect from Griswold The other variants of the poems to which I desire to call attention are (1) an early draft of the sonnet “Silence” in Gentleman's Magazine for September, (2) a version of the sonnet nce” Graham’s Magazine for June, 1841, being prefixed there to “The Island of the Fay”;t (3) a reprint of “Ulalume” in the Literary World of March 3, 1849 (see Poe's letters of February 16 and March 8, 1849, to FE. A, Duyckinck, then one of the editors of the Literary World); and (4) a version of the sonnet “To My Mother” of Memory” for 1850 (an annual edited by R. Coates and published Philadelphia in the autumn of 1849). Of these the reprint of “Ulalume” important, since it exhibits only tion not found elsewhere—"till” “until” in line 57. The versions of the sonnets “To Science” and “To My Mother,” however, are interest, each of them dis- of half a unique more noteworthy still Is the early version of “Silence.” This differs radically from all of that sonnet, and should perhaps be account- ed independent of this, and because it is not accessible in tale be and having Dream Burton's 1839; “To Sele in in “Leaflets at is least one varia- for of considerable playing upwards dozen readings. But subsequent forms an poem. In view easily the magazine in which it appeared, I ven- ture to present it here in its entirety: There Is a silence where hath been no sonnd, There is In the cold grave Or in wide desert where po life is found, Which hath been mute, a silence where no sound may be, under the deep, deep sea, and still must sleep pro found; No voice is hush'’d—no life treads silent!s But clouds and cloudy shadows wander fre« That never spoke—over the idle ground; But In green ruins, In the desolate walla Of antique palaces, where Man hath been, Though the dun fox, or wild hyena, ca *It ls open to question, however, w ! Poe's explanatior s to be accented, «ince he wae published onder the same dat 1 both periodicals April 2%, 1849. This was publiehed tn the ‘‘Virginia Poe’ tn connect! with the variant readings f °**The Island f the Fay (1V, 307), but was over- looked by both Profeaxsor Harrison and I femsor Woodberry in their ibliographies and in their iets of variant readings for the poems
Page 16
648 And owls that fit between ek to the echo true Slience is yntinually and the low winds moan, self-conscious and alone Comparison of these lines with “Silence” it in the collective editions of makes obvious the difference between they treat their subject differently, nothing in in is in this difference, perhaps, as we know Poe the two and they common posse 55 phrasing. It that neglect we the has been visited that been For Poe I that of Professor Woodberry of life of 115), mentions a sonnet, Burton's for [Poe's], although never afterwards acknowledged”; and even thig bare mention Professor Wood- edition of his It that has version upon earlier in all written about allusion to it the first his in edition (p where he 1839, “conjecturally omits in the revised But the Poe's that it by “P.": but so, too, were Poe's “Fairy and the “To the River a for month ; berry work poem is surely is true was signed merely initial land” in 80 lines and “Si- the later preceding perfected republished the Broadway Moreover, appearing ag it Poe was one of its had published in the that Poe, somehow made as he did with Burton’a also was the and lence” in Journal in 1845 did editors as while he signed Burton's after in and same if the have things help feeling his, other annot not would it clear that they more than one thing wrongly attributed t it is not difficult this early draft a parallelism were were not him Finally, to cover in substance notably his “Spirits of the Dead” Valley of the prose ence \ Unrest” and essay Fable.” KILLIS CAMPBELL. University of Texas ( ‘orrespondence. THE PARTY SYSTEM. NATION: misfortune that of late years in na- it of control of our government, THe EpiTror or THE The Democratic To Sim: the tional the has party elections, depriving of three departments been attributed one of being overlooked. That is the fact that the party has been making itself the mouth acts proper political demands for particular abandoning of the means of which pie of legislation thereby its pos the r? s by country is two great the government m ans one carried on of party countries Continental Europe developed England not has in Political and each particular nt by has he same lines as it od the United States are numerous in those countries, represents demands for some legislation the establishment of a particular family or of the established govern- ure a working majority for necessary. This parties, which are person in To ministry a place ment. Ber the formed by willing to sink the purpose of results in which bloe is two or more individual certain general all interested. achle they ving are are to seek an explanation of the ' can discover only one | Poe in | the | | however, there | way, I) lines | The Nation. The bloc takes in a manner, and for a time, the place of one of our two major parties, the one in power. And this sinking of indi- is the only way to «ac- results in politics. In England and the United States, how- ever, for reasons which it is unnecessary to discuss here, the electorate has divided itself into two bodies, based upon a funda- mental difference in human nature, one party being broadly the party of Personal Rights, the other that of Order. vidual differences complish general its organization the Democratic party has upheld principles which it has believed favor the liberty of the individ- ual, even at the expense of governmental efficiency; the other party seeks *o attain the object of government by strengthening the arm of the Administration, even at the sacrifice of some individual liberty. Each party appealed to those voters who favored one set of principles as compared with the other, and this divided the voters into two practically even parties. Of late years, the Democratic party has aban- doned its position as the representative of principles with which the difference in human nature endows half the world, in ils advocacy of particular acts of legislatioa, thereby taking a new position, which neces- sarily appeals to a smaller number of per- It no longer represents the party oi Rights as to the party but by limiting its support of liberty to certain specific tenets From sons, Personal opposed of individual Order, dis- it has effected a displacement of the line in | with several other things by Poe, | and “The | separating the two parties. Had these de- mands and promises for particular legisla- tion been presented merely as subordinate | features of the party's platform; had they been so treated by the candidates, the ora- tors and the newspapers of the party; had the main appeal of the party been made }on the strength of its general principles, |}aeceptance of j}and had these special demands and prom- ises been presented as incidental to those instead of making the tenets a principles, these particular general | shibboleth to good standing in the party, | then has befallen | | ciples to various causes, but cause which may be vital is in danger | of | the Democratic party would have continued to be a true political party. It would also have been in a position to ac- complish more in furtherance of its prin- than, with what superficially ap- pears to be greater effort, it has accom- plished, The Republican party does not fall into this error of depending upon promises of legislation instead of general and it has certainly accom- in the way of progressive particular principles, plished more legislation than its rival. That party means | certain parties | or it may even be a demand for differences for | to the public a genera! tendency in favor of things, and it wins its victories reason of the general appeal it thereby makes. Nor did it come into power be- cause it advocated the abolition of slavery. It represented one of the broad tendencies of politics, of which demands for repres- sion of slavery and polygamy in the Ter- ritories by the national government, na- tional homestead laws, internal improve- by ments to be made by the national govern- | ment, a protective tariff, and opposition ts disunion were typical manifestations. The Abolitionists and Freesollers accomplisbed their purposes through the success of the Republican party, which by representing a general tendency was able to become a majority party, and accomplish what the [ Vol. 89, No. 2322 propagandist parties had not been able to obtain for themselves. Wm. P. MALSBURN. Denver, Col., December 20. AVIATION IN 1783. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Though it has perhaps occurred to many of us that the present is only the second of two periods of intense interest in the problem of aerial navigation, we do not all remember, perhaps, that the earlier period was for several reasons one of much greater excitement. When Etienne and Joseph Montgolfier, on June 5, 1783, filled a linen bag with hot air from a straw fire, and sent it into the air to a height of a mile and a half, and when, in November of the same year, M. Francois Pilatre de Ro- zier and the Marquis d’Arlandes made an ascension from the Bois de Boulogne, re- mained in the air half an hour, and came down uninjured, a new path was opened for human travel; and as the difficulties which caused invention in that direction to lan- guish for a century were not at first evi- dent, at least to the lay mind, speculation as to the possibilities of aerial travel had in 1783 all the scope of ours and more of nov- elty. The recent International Exposition of Aerial Locomotion, held at the Grand Palais, in Paris, had a section devoted to reminders of the earlier period, and their number and variety attest an enthusiastic interest in the wonderful new discovery that must have thrown all other preoccupations into the background, even at that troubled time. There was, first, a model of the Montgolf- ier balloon. Then, in a corner by itself, the remarkable Tissandier collection. I translate from M. J. Saint-Alban, who writes of the exposition in a recent number of Les Annales Politiques et Littéraires: After the first experiments of the Mont- golfiers, of the Robert brothers (December, 1783), and PilAtre de Rozier(see above), the globe volant became the most fashionable of all emblems. Everything was au globe; | gloves, handkerchiefs, clothing. Artists and artisans taxed their ingenuity and their im- aginations. Seamstresses embroidered no- thing but balloons, manufacturers of woven stuffs and print goods demanded aerostatic patterns and nothing else. Dealers in bibe- lots exposed to the public gaze only crea- tions au globe volant, and the cabinet-mak- ers were not slow in joining the procession. This movement of industrial art lasted for several years. Interrupted by the Revolu- tion, it appears again with the Directory, in the ascensions of Mme. Blanchard (her last attempt resulted in her death, June, 1819), of Mile. Gamenin and of her brothers. It, of course, gives pleasure to a young dandy who is interested in aviation, to wear a balloon as an ornament, to cover his head with a round hat—chapeau au ballon; of course, a lady of fashion appreciates a hand- kerchief and a pair of gloves embroidered with balloons; of course, she enjoys reading on her fan quatrains composed in honor of the heroes of the air, or seeing on it a rep- resentation of Pilate de Rozier in the act of falling on the French coast. But it is still greater pleasure to He down in a bed sculptured in the form of a balloon-basket and adorned with attri- butes of aerial navigation; to read the hour from a watch in the shape of a_ globe, whose balance-wheel carries little aeronauts in their baskets. And even this does not satisfy our snobs. They insist on sitting in an arm-chair of which the wood as well as the upholstering speaks of aviation; on eating from plates which repeat the triumphs of the first con- querors of the air; on dipping their goose- quills into an ink-weil in the form of a bal- loon. . .
Page 17
Dec. 30, 1909 The Nation 649 It is true that the aviators are influencing| there is no danger here; these are gen-|to the Lord Abbot, for the Feasts of Easter the modern art of the bibelot—are we not told that one of our prominent journalists | wears shirts with a figure representing aeroplanes? But this craze is mild, com- pared with that revealed to us by the cu- rious collection I am discussing. It may be added that M. Gaston Tissan- dier, whose collection is thus furnishing the most eloquent commentary possible on the hopes which France conceived from the suc- cess of Etienne Montgolfier, is a brilliant French scientist who has himself invented a dirigible, and who is an authority on the subject of aeronautics. Roy TEMPLE Weatherford, Okla., December 16. House. PHILOLOGY AND CRITICISM. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: It has been borne home to us pretty cften of late that philology is no better than she ought to be. It was becoming clear that philologists were a sorry lot. Bur now it appears (see the Nation of Decem- ber 16) that all this is a mistake. Philology really a gay science, so gay as to he hardly more than the playground of ro- mancers. With this settled, there is no- thing for the strictly practical-minded but to turn to the workshops of the critics. Here the bright tools of epigram, paradox, and trope are in ceaseless play: obviously things are being done. The very fertility of criticism can bring but shame upon ths poor philologist with his occasional article and his unprofitable dalliance with Paul's “Grundriss”’ and Professor Sievers. With- out question he has wasted his time—a sad certitude which is only emphasized when he passes from the critic’s shop to the gay bazaars where the critic’s wares are dix- played. Here is the meed for cultivating that turn for style which cuts so clean aul so often to the very heart of the matter. Why, tren, bury one’s talents in the pro- ceedings of learned societies? But one must not suppose that the schol- ar’s romantic life is a life of unreproved pleasures free. On the contrary, it is en- compassed by innumerable fears. To-day’s victory may be to-morrow’'s disaster. A new manuscript may quickly upset the most carefully managed argument and turn joy to grieving. Clearly the game has its haz- ards. Worst of all, the scholar can never forget that facts are relentless; sooner or later they will out. Do what he will escape, he is always within their danger and too often discomfited by them. How, then, can he ever know the sweet securities | of criticism? How can he ever attain to that serene intelligence and bland confi- is to tlemanly differences, which work no harm and St. Michael in the first year of the H. 8S. V. JONES j}reign of King Edward “after the Conquest | Urbana, I1., December 18 the Third,”’ on Friday after the said Feast of St. Michael, and for other busi t | | ness of the village of Faversham in th: COLLEGE ENGLISH AND A PROPOSED) time of Robert le Hert, Mayor of the same REMEDY. there occur these names, among others under the heading Portatrices (the gender To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION being accounted for by the fact that the Sir: We have lately heard much of the| gre: tw difficulties of teaching English in our col-| . | Petyt Johan (paying 6 pence) leges. In my opinion the chief difficulty Lytyl Johan (paying 4 pence) is that the student of composition bas/ Suatene nothing to say, no meaning to express. His| ‘/O”#@é@rices is to be oO mentioned are women) rendered carriers or exercises in composition are purely for on OES and we may, therefore presume sake of expression. His problem is then, | ¢ at Rere, as in Little John’s case, the name was given ironically. The document not to find an expression for his meaning, s described in the Hist. MSS but a meaning for his expression; and Commission meanings, of course, are born, and not|*?pendix to VI Report, p. 505 made. There is thus an absence of thefun-| The Robin Hood passage, which is only damental condition of good writing -which | @utedated oy Ge Smo page & is to have something you wish to say ena! “Piers the Plowman,” occurs in a MS, also of a basis for the most stimulating of the first half of the Afteenth century of Chaucer's “Canterbury Tales.’ The and effective criticism; for it is rather | | MS. belongs to the Royal College of Physi useless to accuse a student of failing to! express his meaning when his meaning is| “#28, in London. On follo 258A the copy of no consequence. | ist (or an earlier one) altered Chaucer’ Now there are many occasions within|/imes in “The Tale of Sir Thopas” so as to the range of the college curriculum nhel read: the student’s meaning is genuine and un-| Men speken Romaunces of price forced—when, for example, he answers a OF horachielé and Ipotice, : . , Of Robynhoode and goode ser Guy question in examination or writes an es- say to test his knowledge of some special This substitution of Robin for Bevis of subject. Here he has a spontaneous mo-| Hampton indicates little as to the scribe's tive for expression, and for making his| "espect for the Gest, or the ballads; but meaning clear. And just here are his defi-|it is impossible not to believe that he ciencies in language most obvious and ex-|4ppreciated Chaucer's satire keenly; for asperating. Instructors are apt to en-|'® many places in the MS. opposite courage these deficiencies by telling the| Chaucer's best jokes, he notes on the student that in examinations matter is |'"@rsin: Nota, nota optime! everything and style nothing. It is, how- Henry NOBLE MACCRACKEN ever, out of the question for an instructor Yale University, December 22 in history or physics or philosophy to give | ; ie more than a passing attention to expres-| sion. Why should not the department of | composition utilize these examination | papers and essays as a basis for its work? | Why should the student be called upon to invent meanings when he already has meanings badly expressed? to write fiction when he is unable to state a fact? Exam- ination papers in particular are necessar- ily written in more or less hurry and con- Literature. MR. BROWNELL ON AMERICAN PROSE. Prose Masters. New York: $1.50 net. imerican Brownell. ner’s Sons. By W. C. Charles Scrib- fusion. Just for that reason they should furnish an excellent basis for practice in| ~!hose who have had the pleasure of careful writing; for there is no more|reading Mr. Brownell’s’ stimulating studies of the “Victorian Prose Masters” need only be assured that this volume is in no way inferior to its predecessor profitable exercise for the practical or for the artistic ends of composition, to take something you have already tried to say, and said badly, and say it again so as than dence which led a distinguished living critic to give chapter and verse for the high-water mark of English prose? Yuu may say, if you dare, “Tide is not quite high there, Professor Saintsbury.”” But you should see that the professor's position is unassailable. If you threaten him, he will only ridicule you from behind the shining vee |The praise is high, for its author is Py Se eet Yon mean one of the few American writers to We Bloomington, Ind., December 21 whom literary criticism is a matter of | profession, of conscience, and of art. He sets to work adroitly; he exacts of him- EARLY REFERENCES TO ROBIN HOOD |Sself a rigorous candor; his report is AND LITTLE JOHN definite, perspicuous, symmetrica]. In an unusual degree—we shall use the an- cient phrase reluctantly but necessarily -he has the defects of admirable quali To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The recent publication of an elab- ramparts of his style. Was it not Swin- burne who said with impunity that Mua- set’s poems were but “‘decoctions of water- ed Byronism"’? Not that criticism has not its passages at arms. Mr. James, for in- stance, did not in the least approve that/| phrase of Swinburne’s And how often have we heard that Dickens's characters both are and are not caricatures. But orate and valuable study of “The Gest of Robin Hood” (by Dr. W. H. Clawson, | tles. | University of Toronto Studies, Philological|; His method is almost inflexibly sys Series, October, 1909) makes pertinent this note, in which I present the earliest refer- ence to the name Little John, and the second earliest reference in poetry to the | Robin Hood ballads. Neither was known, | [ believe. te Prefesser Child. or has ever culture, and style. He does not, as has been called to the attention of scholars been said of Sainte-Beuve, draw all men In the tallage made towards the fine |8ix feet tall; he thinks, however, that all |tematic—for example, he subjects Coop- jer, Hawthorne, Emerson, and Henry James to substantially iden tical tests for substance, philosophy, Poe, Lowell,
Page 18
650 who are less than six feet are some- chological, Latinate—the style of a man thing less than men. Cunsequently, he is able to say of Poe: “As literature his writings are essentially valueless”— though he regards Poe as the “one ab- solute artist of our elder literature.” Hlowever wholesome as an antidote for the excesses of the Poe idolaters, this is establishing standards with a_ven- geance, His point of view is studiously imper- sonal. subtly phrased comment on French so- cial tntercourse in “French Tra‘ts”: “The speech and action of each commu- nicant encounter those of the other without in any degree involving either individuality behind them.” The with- drawal of the critic behind his stan- dards is in the case of Mr. Brownell al- most complete. He scorns the reader who judges with his nerves. self is unwilling to judge even with his character. He is all but successful—far more successful than his admired Arnold in producing the illusion that he is representing “things as they really are.” Like many writers of fiction who have aimed at a philosophically impossible “objectivity,” he has sacrificed some- thing of force and vitality. Furthermore, the unmistakable man New Yorker, cosmopolitan, rationalist, peers here and there over the He is visi- Hloratian edge of his entrenchments. ble behind the sharp thrust at New Eng- land as the “incubus of our civilization,” and at the self-complacency of her lit- erary historians, particularly Professor Wendell, who “tucks” American litera- ture “into the confines of Harvard Col- lege.” He is visible again in the re- minder to Professor Lounsbury, apropos of Cooper's heroines, that “in the quiet of New Haven no a little more ginger, than palates more closes like scholastk doubt they ‘in fiction at least,’ They help us to understand the un- warmth of Mr. Brownell’s of Cooper, who was not ed accustomed appreciation bred by the frog pond of Boston Com-| They throw some light upon his resolute depreciation of Hawthorne, who, he is lacking in substance, and is seldom re-read His style ia an effective instrumegt for what he regards as the business of characterization. Disciplin- mon BAYS, the critie It may be suggested by his own | He him-! jand he does not because he has not ‘into definition.” It appears in his sty'e; | ed, pondered, slightly hesitant, its vir-|it is praised for its brilliant and fe- The Nation. [Vol. 89. No. 2322 cess: “Criticism is not the product of reading, but of thought. To produce vital and useful criticism it is neces- ‘sary to think, think, think, and then, when tired of thinking, to think more.” Thus Mr. Brownell, conspicuously ex- emplifying his own principles, niain- tains a masterly unity in variety; he attacks truth from every point of the compass, but his arrows all fly to the | samme mark; his own detail, frequently a a potentially discoverable clue | polished to brilliance, is not idly orna- : / mental but organic, like links in chain If we dwell at some length upon Mr.|@rmor. The workmanship in general is Brownell’s procedure, it is because he | 80 admirable, the principles so explicit, himself keeps us constantly reminded | 80 sound, so classical, that the essay that criticism is a fine art. Irritating | might well serve both as a model of as his air of premeditation may become, | criticism and as a brief manual of crit- it is the comment of a consciously ex-| ical theory. igent and accomplished connoisseur; What we miss in the equipment of upon a genial improviser that makes|this “impeccable Aristides” of crit- his study of Lowell not merely enter-| icism—to adapt one of his own phrases taining, but finely instructive, and, in|—is perhaps a power that is, after all, its way, definitive. Though he dissents extra-critical. It is the power to con- with refreshing spirit from the recent vey along with his acute judgments of depreciation of Lowell's scholarshig as men anc things the ardor of the schol- “not up to current standards’—praying ar of whom Giuseppe Caponsacchi that belles-lettres, at least, may “hold | Speaks—the scholar lost in his books, out a little longer before it is trans-| Who yet knows that life is greater than formed into scientific feudalism or de-| all the books ever written, and who, clines in Byzantine decadence”—he does | While he reads, dreams, “Thus should | find the man essentially of the dilet-| fight, save, or rule the world.” Mr. tante temperament. His definition of| Brownell probably has no desire either this variable term and his application | to fight or to rule the world. We doubt even whether he would care to save it, , if it had to be preserved en masse. Yet He was a dilettante of an original type | tn the veliiehie sanmenit he feels & tam: in being so thoroughly American. He had} ; the disinterested delight in the delectable Perate interest, and points out, though that characterizes the dilettante as dis-| With marked freedom from demonstra- tinguished from the artist, to whom the| tiveness, the way of salvation, through delectable is material. His singularity—|culture. One feels tempted to apply to as a dilettante, not as an American—con-| him his penetrating remark on Emer- sists in his being attracted by the elemen-| gon jn the most deeply sympathetic of tary quite as much as by the differentiated ‘these studies: who picks his way gingerly through the dictionary, abhorring carnal odors and | the touch of the agricultural implement. Henry James, for example, he says, has clearly preliminarily mastered his com. plicated theme in its centrality. His work, he seems to say, is done when he has constructed his labyrinth in emu- lating correspondence with the complexity of his model, life, and at the same time of it are worth recording: This clearly defined central concep-| 44), feelings really glowed, one may say tion Mr. Brownell—who is much at-| within extraordinarily narrow limits. When tracted by the differentiated and scarce-| he could exercise his Vernunft in complete accustomed to it demand.” Though these | ly at all by the elementary—elaborates | neglect of his Verstand, he reached the vivacities are exceptional and incidental,| through sixty pages. they are significant, breaking as they do| Lowell’s temperament appears the suave decorum generally maintain-| culture; The quality of|acme of his exaltation. in his; But the application would be unjust. though he reads with the in-| tndeed, he is bent on showing how dustry of a Chinese scholar, he always! pmerson himself became an apostle of follows his natural bent, and so fails| oyjture in spite of his disdain for cul- of an adequate discipline. It appears|tyre and a kind of divine democrat in in his criticism; for example, he im- spite of—or rather because of—his mensely admires Dante and knowS| patred of the mob and his shrinking everything about him, “but he does not/ from the vulgar: communicate because he does not on| se i re c rmt press his general conception of Dante,| 'f 5! emotional nature lacked warmth what eminently it possessed was an ex- quisite refinement, and a constituent of his refinement was an instinctive antipathy to ideas of dominance, dictation, patronage, 'easte, and material superiority whose es- himself, one feels sure, thought it out tues are not those of Thackeray, whose | licitous detail, but “its defect is that it | sential grossness repelled him and whose prose he extremely admires, but rather) is detail, and so accentuated as to nul-| ultimate origin in contemptuousness those of Henry James, whose comolex-|lify the ensemble, on which style inex-| Probably the one moral state except cra ities he deprecates. It aims degree of expressiveness. not at) orably depends.” fluency and directness, but at the last/ read than to think, to color than to de-| It is both am- sign, to decorate than to construct, he venness that chiefly he deemed contempt | ible—-was plain enough to his penetration. This is paradox put to some purpose. Preferring rather to ple and precise, but it is somewhat de- falls short through temperamental in-| From it is deduced one of Emerson's ficient in color and tang. is checked by a fastidious concern for shading. Its movement | dolence of the great architects of prose greatest services both to America and —of the great critics. The key to crit-| to the rest of the world, a service, as Its vocabulary is select, psy-' icism is as simple as the key to suc-| Mr. Brownell says, subtly rendered, “be-
Page 19
Dec. 30, 1909] ing, in fact, rather an implication of his writings than anywhere explicit in them—the rationalization of democracy through the ideal development of the individual.” It would be impossible to put in more concise form the integrat- ing principle of Mr. Brownell’s own thinking: it is the democratic justifica- tion of Brahminism. What distin- guishes his Brahminism is its intense- ly intellectual and rational quality; it outcasts all emotions situated lower than the head. But in the “positive perfume of sensitive intellectual refine- ment” it becomes almost—not quite—in- toxicated. If in its survey of literature, British as well as American, it under- values the elemental, the spontaneous, the old-fashioned “spiritual,” these vir- tues have already had their enthusiastic appraisers, and perhaps may generally be trusted to look out for themsvives, anyway. If it sets a very high price on pure intelligence, self-conscious refine- ment, and the new-fangled “reality,” there is an idea affixed to every esti- mate, which compels the reader either to defend or to abandon his prejudices. If it frequently points to an unattain- able excellence, we can—as Carlyle re- luctantly admitted to Emerson after ex- pressing some regret that the Concord sage was not doing precisely what he himself was doing—we can “spare a man for that, too.” CURRENT FICTION, The Ball and the Cross. By G. K. Ches- terton. New York: John Lane Co. It has long filled Mr. Chesterton with fiery indignation that the devil should have all the good music, art, and liter- ature. If a mediwval juggler could stand on his head in honor of the Vir- gin, if Luther could smoke tobacco to the glory of God, he can see no reason why a twentieth-century journalist with a command of epigram and paradox should not write a rollicking allegorical romance in defence of the Cross. And that is why the crash of glass in the of- fice-window of the atheistical Turnbull is the challenge to a series of duels—with long swords out of a curiosity shop— between him and the Roman Catholic Highlander Maclan—a series of duels which carries the participants hotfoot all over England, and the reader, not quite so rapidly, through a book of four hundred pages. In the course of their fighting flight, the duellists fall in with a number of more or less realistic sym- bolical personages—a Nietzschean, a Tolstoyan, a French rationalist, ete.— who, according to their several disposi- tions, further or hinder the combats for the vindication of the honor of God. In the end the atheist, the Catholic, and most of their abettors are rounded up in the mad-house; the mad-house is fired, and the devil, its superintendent, escapes in an airship; and the swords The Nation. of Turnbull and Maclan form a cross in the ashes. The burden with which this romance is freighted is that unbelief is madness. Turnbull and Maclan are the only sane men in England. Turnbull is sane, be- cause he believes that God does not ex- ist; he is eager to fight for his faith— therefore his author respects him. Mac- Ian is sane, because he believes that God does exist; he is eager to fight for his faith—therefore his author loves him. It is perhaps the most interest- ing aspect of this book that a Roman Catholic is its hero. In Evan Maclan, Chesterton is manifestly drawing his own idealized portrait, and he does it in his happiest manner: like a man walking on a the borderland between this Like so many men and Evan lived borderland, world and another. nations who grow up with nature and the common things, he the super- natural before he understood the natural. He had looked at dim angels standing knee- deep in the grass before he had looked at He knew that Our Lady's robes the understood the grass. were blue before he knew wild roses round her feet were red. The deeper his memory plunged into the dark house of childhood the nearer and nearer he came to the things that cannot be named. All through his life he thought of the daylight world as a sort of divine débris, the broken remainder of his first vision. That is effective writing. Yet Mr. Chesterton had said the thing quite as finely in “Orthodoxy”’—*“according to Christianity, we were indeed the sur- vivors of a wreck, the crew of a golden Ship that had gone down before the be- ginning of the world.” And not merely this, but most of the best things in the later were anticipated to some extent in the earlier book. It is not necessary to explain the sometimes obscure sym bolism of the “Ball and the Cross,” for the reason that “Orthodoxy” explains it. Mr. Chesterton wrote his annotations before he composed his text. He made a key and then constructed a lock to fit the key. For example, “The spike of dogma fitted exactly into the hole in the world” (“Orthodoxy’’) is the only thing that makes intelligible to us the ex- clamation of the idiot monk in his cell (“Ball and the Cross”), “Spike is the best—it sticks out.”” This reversal of the customary process suggests the lim- its of the author’s success in this field of fiction, Fine phrases, paradoxes, happy metaphors, even long chains of argu- ment burst into his mind spontaneously in a flood of light. But he sustains his narrative and his allegory by sheer force of will and intelligence. His logi- eal processes are inspired; his romance is excogitated. It is necessary only to compare the exquisitely veiled malice of Anatole France's little masterpiece, “Putois,” with Chesterton's brutal Eng- lish reformation of it to feel how un- equally the men are matched with this kind of weapon. And yet can all French 651 literature supply a sentence quite so satisfactory in its way to the Anglo- Saxon spirit as this?—it is, if we may be permitted the figure, the Sancho Panza half of Chesterton in a nutshell: “Everything his eye fell on it fevsted on, not wsthetically,” (there is a ‘hun- derbolt between the commas), “but with a plain, jolly appetite as of a boy ecting buns”! The Beggar in the Heart. By Edith Rickert. New York: Moffat, Yard \ Co The Heart belongs to Miss Tyrrhena Sidonia Pickersgill, daughter of an American parson. She goes abroad to study art, and in Paris acquires the nickname “Petty-Zou.” There and in London she spends a good many more years than there is any for, making little statuettes for tain pittance, and dodging the altogeth er proper and desirable advances of the naturally-to-be-expected lord-in-the-case She is. in short, one of those sprightly, youngish in the ern feminine audience so much rejoices Her littie audacities and rebellions, her reason an uncer- heroines whom mod pouts and subterfuges, will have their appeal for those who admire the “bach elor maid.” In fiction, at least, the charm of that young person depends on the ultimate triumph of her femininity her theory of independence and equality. “Petty-Zou"’ is, with prettinesses over pe rhaps, too consciously bedizened greatly to please any other than her own doll-loving sex. Of course, in the end the beggar in her heart gets what it wants in the person of the lord in question; and matters are made alto- gether comfortable by the discovery that “Petty-Zou” is a near descendant of the Earl of Uxminster, a per‘ectly eligible old rascal. The marrying lord better than the woman's hero: at all events, he is no pale shade of Rochester. But it is to be doubted if many men are able tread the hook without irritation at the almless spright- liness with which many of its pages are filled. is average to By Eva Lathbury. Holt & Co. endeavored The Sinking Ship New York: Henry The writer has in this story to accomplish a very difficult feat ~endeavored with an intensity of ef- fort that results in occasional crudity and bathos, but that achieves its result to a praiseworthy degree. The theme of the regeneration of a worldly group by the introduction among them of a be- ing of higher fibre has been treated with varying degrees of beauty and success by the obvious methods of the Morality In the present instance, this theme has been approached more subtly, the inten- tion being to present it, not in a sym- bolic masque, but by means of 4 cross- section of the actual world of every-day. It is a more exacting business to deal
Page 20
- ) ; - ( De ) ~ with wayward human beings than with labelled SSiy it abstractions, but those their while “The Sinking Ship” falls far short clearly vho e have reward, and dramatic power of “The Servant the House” and the quaint of the “Third Floor Back,” it has strength of reality. The setting is in the atmosphere of the stage, that revolu- of the in sweet- ness the entirely and the tionizes life for the player-folk concern- ed is the The mysterious influence of this young girl is due wholly to the fact that the Christ of the Gospels is the constant master of her house, and teachings are the mainspring of her uni- Her simple and vital faith grad- ually convinces those who surround her, regenerative force daughter of the star mental His spirit and verse her mother being the last to surrender. The opportunities for weakness in the presentation of such a story are many, and the writer has availed herself of them to an unfortunate extent, especial- ly in the portrayal of the mother, who is too much the conventional siren of the the young playwright, represented as a consequential oulisses, and who is but, in the character of Sibyl her subject, the weakling; she has been inspired by nd has transmitted at moments girl's atmosphere of quiet strength Charl G. D The Macmillan smien By York: New \ll but one of these tales include ani- mals among the dramatis persona, but fissures; that Mr. new vein yield magazinable After all, animal biog- however imaginative, has its lim What with Mr. Roberts Thompson Seton and Mr. Long and seem to have have their human will be ered upon a all of them from which It Roberts has ent seen which ht to sto oug ries indefinitely, raphy itation and Mr ir host of imitators, we all the rung upon the every-day exper had pretty much profitable hange lences of the bear and the lynx and the and the other wild,” as Mr. Roberts is fond of calling them. But begin to combine them, singly or In groups, with the mantfold of the human nus, and you have evidently provided an Indefinite extension of the game. it must be sald that Mr. Roberts's crit are better than his humans that ts, individuals “MacPhairrson’s Happy types, not krat and the beaver kindreds of the varieties for more nvineing,” as men in example, are Roberts manipulates them but they have no mo- tion of thelr own. “Red MeWha’'s” con- version from brute to seraph Is a fiction Mrs. Gammit and her sporting adventures are incompe- tently farcical; and little Melindy, who with her little hatchet Is too much for lynxes and bears In the open, is incom- The best thing for on Mr everly enough, stranger than truth petently melodramatic. The Nation. in the volume is the description of a fight between a mink and a raccoon—or so it seems. Can this be because the reader does not know the difference be- tween a mink and a raccoon, and does know the difference between a human being and a story-teller’s mannikin? GENERAL SHERMAN, Home Letters of General Sherman, Edit- ed by M. A. De Wolfe Howe. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2 net. It is long since the biographical side of American history has received such enrichment as is furnished by this vol- ume. Readers of the “Memoirs” and the “Sherman Letters” will not, of course, look to the present selection of personal correspondence for large sub- stantive additions to our knowledge of Sherman's public career, though of in- forming supplementary data there is no lack. Neither does Mr. Howe oper for us that inner sanctuary of personal and family life which, notwithstanding its mortal fascination for many a modern biographer, is best kept sealed. What we have, instead, is a picture of Sher- man the man: ambitious, energetic, re- sourceful; chafing often at his limita- tions, and resenting hostile criticism and misrepresentation, yet faithful to his duty and his friends; keenly ob- servant, tender-hearted, affectionate, and modest. With comparatively few excep- tions, the letters are addressed to his wife, to whom, from the beginning of the acquaintance which resulted in mar- riage, he opened his heart and his career without restraint. How Sherman found time, amid the engrossments of a busy life, to write so much, is less of a wonder than that he could write so well. These letters have a literary distinction which entitles them, quite aside from the prominence of their author, to high regard. H2 pos- sessed, in a notable degree, the power of description. The life of a cadet at West Point, a social function at St. Louis or New Orleans, a Spanish play in Call- fornia, a storm at sea, or a battle, is sketched with equal facility. He shows, too, a dramatic effectiveness unsurpass- ed by any of his military contemporaries whose letters have been made public. Only after the civil war, when he was less often separated from his wife for long periods, do the letters become brief notes. ven intimate rather matter-of-fact then they essentially and detalled. Sherman frankly loved a military ca- reer. In 1842, with as yet no experience bevond the routine duties of an officer in time of peace, he resisted stoutly the suggestion that he should retire from the army, feeling sure that the time was ap- proaching when a soldier would have an opportunity to distinguish himself. Although he was, during the Mexican War, depressed at the unimportance of and remain | Vol. 89, No. 2322 his California service, he nevertheless accepted it as part of the necessary preparation for more responsible com- mand. His later short experience as a lawyer and business man, the latter of some importance and distinctly credita- ble, only confirmed him in his judgment that civil life was not for him; nor did he, in the subsequent period of his great- ness, look with favor on the suggestion of a Presidential candidacy. “I would receive a sentence to be hung and damned,” he wrote in October, 1864, “with infinitely more composure.” Impressions of men and events, to- gether with speculations as to the fu- ture, are set down freely in these let- ters. He had a poor opinion of Fré- mont’s volunteers, and deprecated the unstinted praise of Frémont by Polk and Marcy. Of Stockton, the “Sailor Gen- eral Grandioso,” he wrote: “He is a great blatherskite, talks too much and does too little.” His keen perception of the public opinion of the enemy, con- spicuously shown throughout the civil war, appears in his California expert- ences. In May, 1847, he wrote that, while “no one here now dreams of 2 retrocession to Mexico, all admit that these Guachos or Rancheros are not afraid of us, and if encouraged from Mex- ico would try again the chances of war, more for the fun of the fight than with any ultimate design of securing their own independence.” Naturally, he was not averse to territorial expansion, writ- ing from New Orleans in November, 1852, where “Cuba is all the go,” that “if Cuba can be got fairly, it will be a beau- tiful state, and I would not object to a station at the Havannah as commis- sary.” Only once does his judgment seem to have gone entirely astray, and that was in 1859, when he wrote: “I have with you my doubts about Kansas. It has not the elements of permanent prosperity—a hard climate, neither one thing or other, poor timber, stone, no fuel, and no prospect of manufactures.” Late in 1859 he went to Louisiana to assume the direction of a new military school. As a schoolmaster he had his full share of trouble with turbulent pu- pils, but from the outset he quelled dis- turbances with a firm hand, and con- trived to keep on good terms with the politicians. He knew the South well from previous military service at Mo- bile, Charleston, and New Orleans; and he felt, both then and afterwards, no confidence in the capacity of the negro for citizenship. He was loath to be- lieve that secession would become an ac- complished fact, though he wrote re- peatedly that, if it did, he would side with the North. His military judgment taught him that, in the event of war, the great struggle would be for the con- trol of the Mississippi, and that the South, destitute of a navy, would be un. able to raise a blockade without the as- sistance of England—an assistance
Page 21
Dec. 30, 1909] which he was certain would never be re- ceived. Sherman’s part in the civil war has been so fully exhibited elsewhere that his accounts of military operations in the present letters, though exceedingly interesting, must be passed over. He felt from the first that it would be a long war, and had little patience with Lincoln's cautious policy and the halt- ing steps of Congress. Of the volun- teers allotted to him he had a poor opinion, complaining bitterly of their lawless plundering, their insubordina- tion, and their insistence upon leaving the service the instant their term of en- listment expired. “No Goths or Van- dals,” he wrote after the first battle of Bull Run, “ever had less respect for the lives and property of friends and foes, and henceforth we ought never to hope for any friends in Virginia.” His bitter- est reproaches, however, are reserved for the Northern press. This he repeatedly charges with responsibility for bringing on the war; and he complains that its detailed accounts of military operations and plans hindered every movement of the Union forces at the same time that they kept the enemy fully informed. “I will never again command an army in America,” he wrote in 1863, “if we must carry along paid spies. . . . I shall votify Mr. Lincoln of this if he attempts to interfere with the sentence of any court ordered by me.” Naturally teuder- hearted and considerate, he could bever- theless yield to military necessity, as he understood it, and sacrifice men and desolate the country without a qualm; yet he retained throughout the war a kindly feeling for the South, wondered that people should think him a monster and try to kill him, and opposed the en- listment of negroes largely because of its irritating effect upon the Southern whites. Sherman bore the inevitable lionizing of his later career with mixed modesty and restlessness; but he found no pleas- ure in public functions, and avoided them when possible. His amusing ac- count of his sufferings at the dedication of the Burnside monument in Provi- dence will strike a sympathetic chord in many an official bosom. For the Re- publican policy in reconstruction he could not feel approval. “The negroes don’t want to vote,” he wrote from his camp opposite Richmond in May, 1865. “They want to work and enjoy proper- ty, and they are no friends of the negro who seek to complicate him with new prejudices.” The sober judgment of the historian must approve the judgment of the great commander, who, writing in February, 1868, after the breach between Johnson and Stanton, summed up his hopes and desires in these words: “I do want peace, and do say if all hands would stop talking, and writing, and let the sun shine, and the rains fall for two or three years, we would be nearer re- “of frontispiece, and a full index. The Nation. construction than we are likely to be with the three and four hundred states- men trying to legislate amid the preju- dices begotten for four centuries.” The editorial work has been done with intelligence and discretion. A brief con necting narrative binds the letters to- gether wherever necessary, omissions are carefully marked, and names or allusions in the text are identified or explained. There is a good reproduc- tion of the Saint-Gaudens bust by way The date 1904 as the year of the publication of the “Sherman Letters” (page 1) is obviously a misprint for 1894. The Catholic Encyclopedia: An inter- national Work of Reference, the Constitution, Doctrine, Discipline, and History of the Catholic Church. Edit- ed by Charles G. Herbermann and oth- ers. In fifteen volumes. Vol. VI. New York: Robert Appleton Co. on The successive volumes of this great work appear with unfailing regularity. The sixth volume, as it happens, is un- usually rich in important articles. It opens with an elaborate discussion of Fathers of the Church, which contains a very useful bibliography and is partic- ularly interesting for the careful dé«fini- tion of the phrase understooa by Catholics. The articles on France and Germany, dealing with their history and literature, with especial reference to the influence of religion and the church, fill respectively thirty-nine and forty- four pages, and are exceedingly valua- ble. The account in the former article of the recent separation of Church and State in France is very instructive, and, while written from a Catholic point of view, is commendably fair and sane. The following judgment is worth quot- ing as representing the common Cath- olic opinion: as are due to by the when, wishing to All the evils of the situation the fundamental error committed State at the very outset, reorganize the life of the church in France, it brcke with the Holy See instead of open- ing negotiations. Hence the impossibility of the church actively coéperating in the ex- ecution of laws enacted by the civil au- thority in a purely one-sided fashion—laws which took the place of a concordat never regularly annulled. The article on Gothic Architecture is also interesting, and finely illustrated. The illustrations, in fact, form a strik- ing feature of this volume, as of al) the preceding. There is an elaborate and careful treatment of Biblical Geography, and a briefer article on Geography and the Church, setting forth the services of the church in the discovery and set- tlement of new lands. The lives of Fénelon, the great mystic, and of St. Francis of Assisi, the most attractive of all Catholic saints, are recounted sym- pathetically, and in the latter case with G53 enthusiastic appreciation. The article on Galileo strives to be fair and judi cial, but there is a natural inclination to minimize the hostility of the church and to magnify the faults of the great physicist. In view, however, of th mon and largely erroneous tradition of the relations between Galileo and the Catholic authorities, the atti tude is not altogether unjustified. There is an annoying lack of exact references in this as in some other articles. Quo tations favorable to the author's conten tion are made from various Protestant writers with no indication of the place from which they are taken reprehensible practice, and particularly so in an encyclopedia. In the article entitled “Fundamental Articles” there is a capital statement of the difference between the Catholic and Protestart, rather between the and Liberal, attitude toward dogma. The fol lowing quotations illustrate the Cath olic position: ‘com, writer's alwuys a or Conservative In the first place the theory [of Funda- mental Articles] is repugnant nature of Christian faith as the church. According to her teaching the es- sential note of this faith lies in the com- plete and unhesitating ac: of the whole depositum on the ground that it is the revealed word of God. The rejection of a single article of this deposit is sufficient to render a of heresy. The question is not as to the rela tive importance of the article but solely as to whether it vealed by God to man. church knows of one and only one test to determine this question of membership Christ's body. This test acceptance of this or that trine, but in communion with the apostolic hierarchy. ... o the understood by eptlance conscious man guilty in question, has been r« The Catholic in does not He in the particular doc- To sum up: the system of fundamental articles is repugnant to the religion of Christ. It is a stage in the dis- integration of religion, conse quent on the admission of the principle of private judg- ment in matters of faith; and it is a stage which is necessarily destined to lead on to the complete rejection of revealed truth The article on Gospel and Gospels is superficial, apologetic, and anti-critical. In the bibliography not one of the great German discussions the mentioned. The article on Gnosticism, on the other hand, while equally biassed, is much more adequate and contains an of subject is admirable bibliography, as is true of most of the articles. The article on God is genuinely scholastic in form and treatment, but it gives an excellent sum- mary of the various traditional argu- ments for God's existence, Anselm's on- tological argument, for instance, being correctly stated, as it seldom is. Ia this article there is an unfortunate slur the Modernists: “If ple be needed to show how, of logical necessity, the substance of Clirristian- ity vanishes into thin air once the ag- nostic principle is adopted, one has only to point the finger at Modernism.” This sentence suggests, what seems on a concrete exam- to be
Page 22
borne out by not a few of the articles, that the pressure of ecclesiastical au- thority has begun to make itself felt, and that the Encyclopedia is becoming less liberal in spirit than it was at first. This may be a mistaken impression, and it is hoped subsequent volumes will show it to be so; for the work is of so important a character and is bound to be so widely influential that it would be a great pity if it were anything but perfectly fair and controlled by aught but the scholarly spirit. to be were les Principes de la Métrique Métrique auditive. II, Théorie générale du rythme. Ill, Notes de métrique expérimentale. Par Paul Verrier, Agrégé de l'Université, Docteur és Lettres. Paris: H. Welter. achetés ensemble, Essai sur anglaise I, Les trois volumes 30 fr In these voiumes, of which the third is still in press, are sig- nificant. They belong with the series of recent French books, noticed from time to time in these columns, which deal seriously with the best English and American authors of the last century. They give evidence also that out of the welter of conflicting notions on English metre there is slowly arising a general consensus on the fundamentals. A great Hellenist lately remarked that no one can quite appreciate the distinc- tive qualities of Greek metre who has not learned to enjoy the delicate charms of French verse. The remark was just, and suggests other comparisons and con- trasts. The report of a competen* an- cient Athenian on English versification would be immensely interesting. Since that is out of the question, perhaps the report of a competent Frenchman is the next best. The subtle and far-reach- ing differences between his idiom and along with the underlying like- ness, give a Frenchman who has mas- tered our speech an advantageous de- tachment and freedom from preconcep- tions. M. Verrier seems to possess these advantages. He began to publish on the subject in 1891; he has explored many avenues of approach; he asks his read- er to accompany him along several of these avenues. The pace may appear rather too leisurely, but it is easy to fol- low. The inadequacy of the traditional seanning being shown, Verrier next ex- plains his own way of studying the prob- Analysis of facts, then investiga- tion of causes—these are the two parts of all scientifie method. First, all pre- conceptions cleared away, what is the report of the trained ear on the sound- combinations that constitute English verse? In the matin its report is self- sufficient and final, though on some experimental analysis must be of course, too, the ear its training ade- several ways ours, lem, points called to its ald; must be competent The Nation. quate. All that we can learn of the psy- chology of rhythm must be brought to bear. And in a complete description of English verse its historical development must be traced, it must be duly compar- ed with the verse of other races. But life is short; of the five sections, audi- tive, historical, comparative, and exper- imental metric, with the psychology of rhythm, the second and third are omit- ted by Verrier; nor does he attempt any description of the vast variety of verse-forms exhibited in English. Vol- ume I is devoted to setting forth the facts as heard, an analysis of good na- tive rendering of English verse. This involves the analytical statement of a mass of scientific observations of ordi- nary English utterance, first in prose and in conversation—of the qualities of speech-sounds, syllables, phrasing, vari- ation in stress, shifting of word-accents according to collocation, elasticity of duration. It is impossible to give in a brief notice a just idea of the wealth of details here brought together, or of the skill with which these are shown to bear on versification. Much that is pop- ularly supposed to be “poetic license” is found to be as common in daily speech as in verse, which is, indeed, on the phonetic side, merely an artistic treat- ment, a comparatively slight regulation and idealization, of good talk of an ele- vated character, especially of an emo- tional nature. In Volume II our verse is examined in the light of the general theory of rhythm. Here, too, the author is well acquainted with the best work, from an- cient Greece to newest America. That he has sometimes followed the wrong authority on disputed points of Greek theory does not affect his conclusions on English. First he compares rhythm with what he chooses to call “rhythm in space.” How does the eye measure equal or proportional intervals in space, and what enables the ear to measure in like manner the intervals of time that constitute rhythm? Is there any rela- tion between the functional rhythms of the heart and of respiration, and the rhythm of art? What is the relation between the rhythms of labor and those accompanying songs of the workman that are so prominent in Biicher’s well- known study? What are the relations between labor-songs and the fully de- veloped verse-forms? These are some of the questions examined. Musical rhythm is rather fully analyzed, and the nature and office of rhyme considered, though on the latter subject there is lit- tle that is novel. Each volume is sep- arately indexed, but scantily. Perhaps the most important feature of Volume II is the fulness with which the fact is brought out, and its sig- nificance made clear, that in all rhythms of art, as analogously in the correspond- ing relations of space, we have to do with the subjective sense of rhythm, not [Vol. 89, No. 2322 with the actual duration of the inter- vals. Perfect accuracy of measurement is impossible, both for performer and for listener; perfect regularity would be intolerable if it were possible; de- partures from the exact pattern are both unconsciously and consciously made in obedience to the artistic sense. Joa- chim'’s “agogic accent” is one example of this, not mentioned by Verrier. Such departures are wider than one would believe without proof. But underneath all these departures the regular pat- - tern is felt and kept in view, as an ideal not to be sought too rigorously. The re- ports of experimental study in Volume III will perhaps throw more light on these variations; but Verrier is well aware, though not all experimenters have been, that our mechanical meth- ods and apparatus are not yet so per- fect that we can on critical points ac- cept their report without hesitation. Altogether we do not know of any clearer or more convincing analysis of English verse-rhythm. Yet there is one unfortunate error, in the definition of rhythm itself. Rhythm is said to be constituted by “a perceptible division of time into sensibly equal intervals.” But this makes no provision for what Verrier expressly recognizes as of great importance (I, 160), the ratio between the parts of the single foot. This is what determines the genus of the foot and of each specific rhythm, the same relation that determines the time-signa- ture of a piece of music, as 2-4 or 3-4, etc. In many of his examples Verrier notes this relation accurately. In truth, there can be no artistic rhythm which does not in general make this relation clear. There must be not only equality of the larger intervals, the feet or bars, and a succession of equals; there must be also in the series of feet a sensibly regular relation of parts within the foot. This regular relation may be varied within limits, but it must be there, an arrangement of parts,a temporum ordo inter se, as the Latin metricists put it. What still prevents many observers from seeing that this is the case in English verse is the fact that these re- lations within the foot are so subtly and infinitely varied, and that whaz the Greeks called irrational feet are so nu- merous. These can be specially numer- ous in English without destroying the general movement, because the main ictuses are so marked by our strong word-accent. No theory that does not note this ordo temporum inter se can ever satisfactorily note examples like some of our familiar nursery rhymes. Two which Verrier cites together are “Little Jack Horner” and “Little Tom Tucker.” Taken alone, those phrases that begin the two might have the rame rhythm. But ask any child to recite each jingle as a whole, first one and then the other. Every hearer must feel a difference of movement; but for this
Page 23
difference Verrier’s definition makes no provision. Some expressions suggest that Verrier is uneasy on the subject; we believe he will ultimately recognize that the distinction is fundamental. Minor errors of the press or differ- ences of opinion are hardly worth not- ing, but three may be mentioned. Ver- rier takes the beginning of Tennyson's song, “Sweet and Low,” as in even time (II, 163); surely, Barnby’s well-known setting in 6-8 time is the exact musical counterpart of the poet’s reading. It looks odd to see the name of “Philip Ray, the miller’s only son,” repeatedly printed as Rey. And Browning's “Praise God, sang Theocrite” is robbed of both rhythm and rhyme by the spelling Theo- critus. But such accidents are few. Wayside Wisdom. By E. M. Martin. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $1.50 net. One is a little doubtful whether to say that Mr. Martin has tapped the vein of A. C. Benson, or merely that Himself drank water of the wel, As did the knight Sir Percivel. At any rate, he writes for “quiet peo- ple” concerned about old houses, dreams, gypsies, country hedge-rows, being in love, growing old, and death. He com- poses, too, in that mood of mild and pensive melancholy which expresses it- self in prose free from point and para- dox, simple, limpid, and musically ca- denced. Although he speaks without petulance or irritated self-consciousness, he is pretty much out of sympathy with the turbulent main currents of these days. With George Eliot, he “laments the death of leisure, a death that has affected the world more deeply than any other since the sun was darkened over the hill of Calvary.” He regrets the lost art of tender recollection, the lost pow- er of tranquil emotion, the lost delight in solitude. Like many other people of old-fashioned affections, he feels that some of the most important realities be- come invisible or seem insubstantial in the garish light of the modern scien- tific day. He puts his faith in common men, fishermen, and peasants, who have kept their faith in the supernatural, and who know the joy in common things. The pilgrim with staff in one hand and book in the other, stamped in gold on the cover of these essays, is plainly go- ing back to nature, asin eighteenth-cen- tury England, before the romantic movement became involved with a po- litical gospel, the scholarly dons of Cambridge and Oxford went back on short excursions to kick their feet through the dewy grass of country lanes, dreaming of the golden age of pastoral poetry, and ruminating on the superiority of the lark to Locke “Op the Human Understanding.” Mr. Mar- tin’s pilgrim, though he has many Ben- sonian characteristics, is not without The Nation. his own distinctions of style and tem- perament; but, like the poetry of the Wartons and their friends, his wisdom is perhaps mainly interesting as a symptom and a protest against the dry rationalism of the latest age of enlight- enment. Richard Jefferies: His Life and Work. By Edward Thomas. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. $3 net. A Jefferies cult has been in the air, so to speak, for some time, waiting to be precipitated by some literary wind. His admirers have been heartening one an- other in secret, and waiting for an op- portunity to make their sally on the world. At last comes Mr. Thomas, with thi. solid book, composed of a small amount of biography, a large amount of quotation from Jefferies’s works, and long draughts of enthusiastic encomium, He brings to his task a full knowledge of his subject, both of the man who wandered and dreamed on the Wiltshire Downs, and of the land itself. He is able to enlighten a rational curiosity about an author still more talked of than read: it is a pity that, by emphasizing the pseudo-prophetic side of Jefferies, he presents a second-rate writer as a sub- ject for worship rather than for sensible enjoyment. It is likely enough that Jef- feries may some day be lifted into a cult to supplant Meredith, who supplant- ed Browning, who supplanted, etc.; but this attempt is certainly premature. Meanwhile, it is not doing hima service to quote with evident commendation the wilder extravagances of that rhapsodical autobiography which he called, ‘The Story of My Heart.” “I see now,” says Jefferies, speaking of his youthful rev- eries on the Downs, “that what I labored for was soul-life, more soul-nature, to be exalted, to be full of soul-learning.” The ordinary processes of thought were in- adequate to the swelling brain of this farm lad, and he, in retrospect at least, yearned for a brand new process which he calls “soul-thought.”’ Neither was God high enough. While he lay on the earth and fingered the grass and the dust, he prayed that he “might touch to the unut- terable existence infinitely higher than deity.” Mr. Thomas does not seem to see the hectic provincialism of this sort of talk; that, like wild dreams on an empty stomach, it sprang from lack of intellectual nurture. To him this lan- guage is the mark of a prophet, of one who “fought in the dim, far-off, wavering van, of which we have yet no sure tid- ings.” The simple fact is that Jefferies was a man of morbid sensitiveness brought up in dull surroundings, which exasper- ated his nerves and starved his mind. The story of his life on the farm, as journalist in a small town, and as strug- gling author in the suburbs of London is in a way pitiful, even without the OD5 tragedy of his broken health and pain- ful death. So many hopes were frustrat- ed; so many ambitions were marred; so much talent was distorted to shrill clam- or. Talent there undoubtedly was, and when he was content to range in his own sphere, he could write with rare beauty and even penetration. His novel “Amaryllis at the Fair” just misses, by its lack of form, being one of the finest idyls in English; some of his purely de- scriptive essays show a rare love of na- ture and a beautiful intimacy with her moods. One is struck, in a writer given at times to such self-tortured introspec- tion, by the sanity and largeness of his better work. When most himself, he knows, as Thoreau and Wordsworth knew, that nature has no meaning when she disturbs, but only when she calms. If Mr. Thomas had, to his sympathetic life of Jefferies, added a critical discrimina- tion between what was false and true in the man’s outlook, he would have per- formed a useful service to letters. As it is, he has merely confounded the con- fusion already created by Walter Besant. It may or may not be to the advantage of Jefferies that this critical biography quotes so extensively from the author's works, both good and bad, as almost to make the purchase of the works them- selves unnecessary. Notes. —_—_— The index of the Nation, July 1 to De- cember 31, will be printed with the issue of January 6. Early in the new year Longmans, Green, & Co. will publish, in two volumes, a “His- tory of the Irish Parliamentary Party from 1870 to 1890’"’—the period of Butt and Par- nell The author is F. Hugh O'Donnell, M.A., sometime member of Parliament. B'aickie & Son, the Scottish publishers, celebrated on December. 10 the centenary of their establishment The playwright Hauptmann’s first novel, “Emanuel Quint,” is to be published at an early date. A selection of Praed’s has just appeared in a special Riverside edition (see the Nation, December 23), and now comes another selection, edited by A. D. Godley, in the Oxford Library of Prose and Poetry (Henry Frowde). For the price, this later book, like all the volumes of the series, is surprisingly well made and printed, but it has not, of course, the beauty of paper and type of its more costly Mr. Godley has disinterred from periodi vals one included in poems prede« essor or two pieces which were not the standard two-volume edition of Praed's poems, and one piece, “One More Quad- rille,” which bas never before been printed. It does not seem to us that the collection is benefited by those stray accessions. Otherwise, Mr. Godley’s selection is good. defective education who to dedicate early now desire their leisure tellectual pursuits will find in Scott's “The Pleasure of Reading’ (Mitchell Kennerley) just about what they want. The Ladies of to in- Temple
Page 24
~ G: 6 book is neatly bound, very well printed, and it opens in an easy and ingratiating way. Mr. Scott’s introductory defence of read- ing in general is a chivalrous and entirely performance. In of style, it spite frequently His of of nov- unimpeachable differences of commendation, certain in reminds on “Sesame and Lilies.” in subsequent chapters, the Bible, of poetry, of Shakespeare of eminently els, and history and biography seems sound; as he justly points there is stuff all His appended lists for reading and study contain, it is a pleasure to note, standard works of all sorts. In fact, nearly every book that he mentions might well be read the best people everywhere. Whea parts of a been of doubtful for example— he refers of It is impossible to see how any harm to us out, good in these de- partments by writer's output have propriety Byron's, merely to a volume selec- tions can come from such a book. Holt & Co. have included Samuel! in their “English Readings,” and have wisely secured Dr. Charles G. Osgood of Princeton to edit the Dr. Osgood's Introduction is a significant esti- mate of Johnson, worthy of being printed Henry Johnson selections. aS a separate essay. As an antidote to the familiar caricature by Macaulay, it might well receive attention from a circle of readers wider than that of the university classrooms for which it is primarily design- ed. It is sympathetic in the best sense of the word, for the editor is at considerable pains to support his sentiments respecting the life by a constant appeal to specific events and ut- terances. If there is a fault, it is a gen- erous one, and lies in a too frequent tone against traditional prejudices thanks to Carlyle and others, we to the reading of Boswell’s Notes are rather learned, at but nearly al- aad personality of Johnson of warning which, often bring “Life.” The times, for undergradyates, ways interesting The Elm Tree Press (Woodstock, Vt.) an- nounces a set of publications called The Li- brarian’s Series, to be edited by John Cot- ton Dana, of the Public Library at Newark, N. J., and Henry W. Kent, of the Met- ropolitan Museum of Art. If a sufficient number of subscriptions is secured, six books will be published, the edition being limited to one thousand copies, and five dol- lors being the subscription price of the en- tire series. They will be ;rinted in ten and twelve-point Cheltenham type, and bound in boards. The books chosen for issuance are: (1) “The Old Librarian's Almanack,” a pamphlej published in New Haven, Conn., in 1773. This is the first reprinting. (2) “The Rev. John Sharpe and his Proposal for a Publick Library at New York,” by Austin Baxter Keep (1713). (3) “The Librarian”: being selections from the articles contrib- uted to the Boston HLvening Tranacript un- der that heading during the last three years, by Edmund Lester Pearson, editor of volume one. (4) “Some of the Best Books on the History and Administration of Libraries Published Prior to 15800 An Annotated List,” compiled by Beatrice Winger, of the The Alexandrian Libra- Deleplerre, London, annotated by George Newark Library. (5) Hoax Concern- ing the Burning of the a a Octave 1860-61, Translated and Parker Winship of the John Carter Brown Library, Providence, R. [T. (6) “The Early History of Libraries,” by Karl Dziatzko, be- Joseph The Nation. ing a translation by Edward Harmon Vir- gin, librarian of the General Theological Seminary, of an article in Pauly’s “Encyclo- pedia of Classical Antiquities.” The first of the publications in this Libra- rian’s Series has already reached us, and is an altogether satisfactory reprint. With- in and without, the little book is one to give pleasure. Republication besides, the only means of passing on to a thousand of us a book which is now very scarce; only two copies of “The Old Librarian's Alma- nack" are known to exist. But, apart from the adventitious value of the pamphlet, it has a value of its own for every lover of curious literature. The humor of its pages is all the better for the difficulty one finds in deciding, now and again, whether it be intended. How delicious is such a passing phrase as this: Mr is, fan able tho a Papist) warns us Pope that “A litth The “Almanack” is signed on the title-page by ®:AéBiBaos, but there seems to be little doubt that its composer was one Jared Bean, born in New Haven in 1705 or 1706, and, from about 1754, curator of the Connec- ticut Society of Antiquarians. He is men- tioned in the “Literary and Genealogical Annals of Connecticut” of Sarah Gilman Bigelow, and seems to have died about 1788. The old librarian never accepted the Amer- ican Revolution, toasting King George to the end. A hint of his loyalism is contain- ed in his “Almanack,” dating from 1773. The wisdom of Pope's advice about drinking deep if at all is, he suggests, “seen now-a- days, when Demagogues and others of shal- low intellect seek to stir up sedition & re- volt.” There are many pages which cry out for citation. Specially eloquent are his expressions of scorn for the “Biblioklept or Thief of Books.” One would, too, much like to quote his passage upon “the Enemies of Books,” “especially the Cockroach.” Jared Bean believed most earnestly in ex- cluding from shelf privileges “any mere Trifler,” or “Person that would Dally with Books.” The young person and the female specified as “undesirable citizens” of the library. “Be suspicious of women,” counsels Philobiblos: They are given to the reading of frivolous Romances, and at all events, their presence in a Library adds little to (if it does not, indeed, detract from) that aspect of Grav- ity, Seriousness, and Learning which is its greatest Glory. You will make no error in excluding them altogether. “The Old Librarian's Almanack” concludes with “A Sure and certain cure for the Bite of a Rattlesnake, Made Publicke by Abel Puffer of Stoughton.” poct, learning,’’ ete are However much one may wish that the author had been more famillar with trop- ical Spanish-America before making his short trip across Guatemala, there are too few works in English on that interesting country for one not to welcome Nevin O. Winter's well-printed little hand-book with its fifty excellent illustrations (Boston: 1, C. Page & Co.). In the book, which he calls “Guatemala and Her People of To-day,” he has added to his own minute travel notes a careful compilation from the ordinary sources of information, and has made easy the way of the stay-at-home traveller. Al- though Inclined to look at matters political in the best possible light, the author i3 frank enough to admit that “there has never been a real President” In Guatemala. 89, No. 2322 a “Each one has been a practical dictator ond made the attempt, at least, to run everything in his own way.”’ To emphasize this, there is stamped on the cover Guate.- mala’s significant coat-of-arms: crossed bayonets and swords, partially con- cealed by the legend, “Libertad,” and a bird of gay plumage. Travellers in Rome who yield themselves to the subtle charm of the Campagna will hardly find the excellent Baedeker a suf- ficiently detailed guide. To them may be recommended the recently published volume, “La Via Appia A l’époque romaine et de nos jours,” by Sig. I. Ripostelli and Prof. Orazio Marucchi, of whom the latter at any rate needs no introduction (Rome: Desclée). The work is divided into two parts, the first, by Ripostelli, describing the Pagan memorials; the second, by Marucchi, the Christian. The traveller is conducted by these efficient ciceroni from the beginning of the “Queen of Roads,” at the Porta Capena in the vanished Servian Wall, as far as the sixth milestone, thus traversing the most interesting part of the highway. The information given is much more accurate than that usually put before the inexperienced visitor to Rome, and the book is very richly illustrated with views from photographs, old engravings, and architectural restorations. In numerous in- stances a view of the existent remains is confronted on the opposite page with its proper “restoration”; and though the spe- cialist will look askance at many of these achievements of a vivid imagination, they cannot harm substantially the tourist, who needs a tolerably strong stimulus for the quickening of his historical vision. He may even be led by such means to the reading of the more strictly scientifiC works by Ashby and Tomassetti, the latter of whom has just begun the publication of “La Campagna Romana, Antica, Medioevale, Moderna” (Rome: Loescher), which bids fair to be his magnum opus. H. Festing Jones, the author of “Di- versions in Sicily” (Scribner), is one of those lucky travellers who not only finds friends everywhere, but makes them inter- esting to others. His tall fellows are of all sorts—lottery playing coastguards, inn- keepers, a woebegone professor afflicted with the evil eye, actors, and above all the managers of puppet shows. In fact, the book is largely given up to the puppet stage, which the author saw from behind the scenes. He learned something of the year- long performances of Charlemagne and the twelve Peers, not to mention their numerous progeny. On the night when a favorite hero, Guido Santo, was to die, he found the theatre nearly empty. The kindly Sicilians could not abide the pitiful spectacle. The marionettes have been many times described, but rarely with such insight and humor. At Mount Eryx Mr. Jones saw the solemn descent of the Miraculous Madonna by St. Luke from her mountain home to the plain. In honor of the event, the Universal Deluge in seven episodes, from the dalliance of the angels with the daughters of men to the bow of promise, was represented on as many cars—a mediewval ceremony most spiritedly described. At Calatafimi the Arts (handi- crafts) gave the Parable of the Prodigal Son in twenty-nine groups, not omitting the allegorical interpretation. Here, the town being poor, the groups advanced on foot from point to point. In the course of a [ Vol.
Page 25
Dec. 30, 1909] discussion in police barracks concerning faith and superstition the following story was told of a village near Girgenti whose patron, St. Calogero, is frequently besought for rain. If he delays to send it the peas- ants threaten him with the alternative— “The cord or rain”: If he is still obdurate, they assume that he has chosen the first, put the threat into execution, take down 8S. Calogero, tie a cord about his neck, and reverently cast him into the sea, where they leave him until it does rain. .. . Then they pull the -oor saint out of the water, dry him, give him a fresh coat of paint, and carry him back to his place in the church with a brass band and thanksgiving—another form of the recur- rent death and resurrection of the god, imi- tating sunset and sunrise. For stay-at-homes there is a shade too much untranslated Italian in a delightful book which those who know their Sicily even superficially will find pure gold. Sir Horace Rumbold’s “Francis Joseph and His Times” (D. Appleton & Co.) offers an extremely pleasant blending of the memoir and the formal history. It has the light touch, the leisure, the intimacy of the one and the ordered, comprehen- sive forward movement of the other. The lives of great men, as told in connection with their age, are not very often what they set out to be; the figure is either lost in the background or else conceals it. In the present instance we find the propor- tions perfect. Without pretending to the réle of an original historian, the author has given us a correct and intelligible out- line of the last 120 years of Austrian his- tory. Without assuming the tricks of the professional word-painter he has drawn a vivid, sympathetic, and just portrait of the most historic figure among men of our time. Next year the Emperor Francis Joseph will have completed the eightieth year of his life, and his sixty- second on the throne of the Hapsburgs. The story of that career has often been told. Sir Horace Rumbold’s as am- bassador to the Austrian Emperor enables him to retell it with an air of unas- suming authority and a sureness of touch that we remember in no other book on the subject. The natural partiality towards his subject is modified by the diplomatic temper. What he has not got is the traditional obscurity of the diplomatic vernacular. If absolute clearness and ease are the marks of perfect style, our author has that Miss Lucy M. J. Garnett’s “Home Life in Turkey” (The Macmillan Company) a well-timed contribution to our knowledge of present Ottoman While a good deal that she new, minute details are interesting and statements may be relied on She is, to be sure, decidedly in sympathy with the people she describes, but her sym- pathy rarely, if ever, warps her judgment. Possibly she gives too favorable an account of the harem life point treated also in her previous work, “The Women and Folklore of Turkey’’), but in any case her report, which rests on her personal obser- experience writer's style. is conditions. gives not her her accurate is as (a vation, will serve to correct the view, very common, that this life is inevitably one of intellectual and moral apathy or stagnation. Not a few women, she points out, have been eminent in literature, and women, as is well known, took an active part in the revolution of last year To many readers her description of the edu- | The Nation. cational and genera! intellectual progress of the Turks, within the last fifty years, will be new. The fact is that a considerable circle of men and women in Constantinople interests itself in modern Christian, especially French, literature; it is true, however, that the Turks have hitherto shown little literary creative pow- er. Miss Garnett’s account of the exist- ing schools (which are mostly attached to the mosques and confined to Koran-study), and of the new ones in operation or pro- posed (military and technical) is worthy of special attention. As to the success of the new government, she thinks it too soon to hazard a judgment. She none the less agrees with Mr. Stuart-Glennie’s opin- ion, expressed in 1879, that the future of the Osmanli Turks will of necessity move toward the abandonment of European ter- ritory and a consolidation in their old home in Western Asia, with an empire extending from the Caucasus and the Caspian Sea to the Persian Gulf and the Indian Ocean. especially Among the numerous recent books with. in the field of transportation, one which contains an_ interesting if visionary scheme, is “An American Transporta- tion System,” by George <A. Rankin (G. P. Putnam’s’ Sons) The writer assumes most properly that the transpor- facilities of this should he such as to combine the maximum of effic- iency, safety, economy, and impartiality to all concerned. These prime requisites can- not attained, it is argued, long eur railways are subject to the conflicting regulations of Congress and of a multitude tation country be 80 as of State Legislatures. The author accord- ingly presents his theory for the bet- terment of existing conditions. This nvolves, in brief, an amendment to th Federal Constitution by which the individ- ual would surrender their present jurisdiction over commerce; the consolidation of States to Congress intrastate the more important rail and water transportation companies into one larg: yrporation, anl the replacement of the numerous railway commissions by a court possessed of the uuthority to enforce the rules of the cor- poration The rapid progress of the modern science of accounting has been marked by the re- cent appearance of several books dealing with the general aspects of the subject as well with the intricate in bookkeeping which resulted the wide expansion of corporat A valuable addition to the literature in this field has been by E. E. rison in his little volume “Accounting Every Business Man Should Page & Co.). The writer perience in handling the problems of which his work has confined as more problems have from enterprises with- mad Gar- Know” (Doubleday, has had wide ex- he treats; not been to a single business, but has extended to a diversity of enterprises banking, mining, wholesale hardware trad is well calculated to speak Beginning with the most elementary trans- actions and with the most fundamental prin- which are the Consequently, he among transportation, and with authority ciples, he proceeds to discuss, among other topics, the complicated ledger system, valu- ation and reserves, and the devising of accounting systems to sult department costs, the peculiar characteristics of particular businesses. He turns aside from his main theme occasionally in such a way as to im- Oe press the reader with the indispensability of the expert accountant. Thus, for exam- ple, he declares that to the average investor the services of an able professional account- ant are even more important than those of a lawyer. He urges that the responsibility of boards of directors could be materially increased by having on each board an expert in accounts to serve as the chairman of an auditing committee whose other members were directors. On ‘he whole, the various chapters are concise and to the point. The five thousand franc prize Académie Goncourt is awarded this year to the brothers Marius and Ary Leblond, for their novel of French colonial life, “En France.” of the In the series, Pages Choisies des Grands Ecrivains (Paris: Colin), has just appeared “Pages Choisies de George Eliot,"’ with an introduction and notes by H. Hovalaque. Through the initiative of the Société pour Etude des Langues Littératures modernes, a French of Chau- cer's “Canterbury Tales"’ has been publish- ed by the Revue Germanique of Paris. The French Academy, after “crowning” the first part of the translation, now awards to the translator a considerable part of the Prix Langlois. et translation “Les premiers Interprétes de la pensée américaine” is the title of a new book by A. Schalck de la Faverie, in which described the peopling of the North Amer- ican Continent, and the and tellectual evolution of America. Chapters are devoted to Cotton Mather, to Washing- ton Irving, Franklin, Longfellow, Emerson, other writers. This volume is contemporaneously with a translation of Emerson's “Conduct of Life,” by Mile. Du- gard, the author of a well documented biog- raphy of the Concord sage (Armand Colin). is moral in- and issued On January 3 certain letters exchanged by Alfred de Musset and a will be opened, at the Biblioth®que Nation ale be made lady unnamed (Paris), and their nature will no doubt known the Jules Troubat is responsible for the preservation of the to inquisitive correspondence, which was to have been destroyed at Musset’s death, but was saved on condition that the identity of the poet's correspondent should be con- ealed, and that the letters should not be published before thirty years had in i course revolved. Anatole France has recently returned to Paris from his South American lecture tour, and it is now stated that he is engaged upon a book in the genre of his recent “‘Penguin Island,” the subject of which is the fall of the angels. This work, together with his lectures on Rabelais, will probably appear early in 1910. The haps, that newest Parisian academy is, per- “Académie des Dames,’ a com- members, including the Mme Henri de Marcelle Tinayre Lesueur, Lucie awarded annual of whose Noailles, (née Heredia), Harry, mittee Comtesse de Regnier Myriam Delarue-Madrus, Daniel and has its prize of five thousand francs to a youth- ful pupil of Henri de Regnier, Edmond Ja- loux, for his novel, “‘Le Reste est silence the story of a child. The prize is called ‘le Prix de la Vie Heureuse.”’ In connection with the meeting of the American Historical Association city an exhibition of manuscript and
Page 26
658 books illustrative of historical writing has opened at the Columbia University Library. The earliest and most beautiful of the Hluminated manuscripts is a golden een gospel loaned by J. P. Morgan. It was written on purple vellum in letters of gold about 680 A. pD., and afterwards presented by Pope Leo X to Henry VIII Later manuscripts of special importance are Arent van Corlear’s Journal, 1634, which is the earliest historical MS. relating to Dutch New York, the original roll of the Concord Minute Men, the treaty between the United Netherlands and the United States in 1782, Gibbon'’s autograph notes for his history of Rome, and large por- tions of the original manuscripts of both Hume's and Macaulay's histories of Eng- land. The printed books which form the larger part of the exhibit contain a few remarkable examples, mostly from Mr Morgan's library The first book printed with movable type is represented by a beautiful vellum copy of Gutenberg’s Bible, about 1450. Near it are placed a Chinese book printed at least 100 years earlier, and the only perfect copy of Caxton’s “Re- cuyell of the Histories of Troy,’’ 1475, which is the first book printed in English Other European items are rare German pamphlets eof 1520-21, relating to Luther and the Diet of Worms, a unique copy of a broadside proclaiming the Common- wealth in England, the first Greek and Lat- and remarkable in editions of Herodotus, editions of Cmwsar, Tacitus, Josephus, and Augustine Relating to America are the first dated edition of Columbus's letter, 1492, rare coples of Vespucci, De Bry, Pur- chas, etc., the first view of New York in Van der Donck’s Beschrijvinghe, 1651, the first New York directory, and the first United States census Arthur Gilman, author and educator, died Atlantic City, N. J., December 28, aged He established in 1877 Mass., the Society for the Instruction of Women, familiarly known the Harvard Annex, which was later created Radcliffe College. ‘The great- number of his writings were of an his- at seventy-two years. at Cambridge, Collegiat« as torical nature ¥e science. The Survival of Man. By Sir Oliver Lodge New York: Moffat, Yard & (‘o $2 net Fusapia Palladino and Her Phenomena hy Hereward Carrington. New York lt. W. Dodge @& Co. $2 net lo judge by the number of volumes on piritism” put forth by the publish ers, such books must vie with the suc cessful novel as “best sellers.” Men of aclence have not, as a rule, felt that could afford the time and labor re phenomena which they con their re quired to study to which susceptible careful and late to processes often connected with deliberate fraud or misrepre- sentation. For this Sir Oliver Lodge's apologetic with- in fessediy, are not laboratory tests, innocent reason, is not although, very out exceptional interest; The Nation giving his excuse for leaving the field of effort in which his brother scien- tists feel that his talents might be of greatest service to the world, he tends to confirm the view of his fraternal critics. His book contains nothing new; but apparently aims to present a collection of the most strikingly convincing ¢xam- ples of the phenomena considered, and to suggest what seems to the writer to be the most reasonable hypotheses avail- able for their explanation. Here, in- deed, he gives evidence of candor and judgment quite compatible with his rep- utation as a scientist. The logica'ly minded investigator, however, looks with disfavor upon the multiplication of hypotheses to account for unexplained phenomena. The hypotheses suggested by the “spiritists’” imply that we have gained adequate conceptions of the meaning of life, of individual human ex- istence, of persistence in time, of the spirit as distinguished from the mind, of the processes involved in the manifes- tation of mental existence through phy- sical activities, and of many kindred subjects, none of which are thoroughly comprehended and all of which are un- der investigation by earnest students. The man of science will not be satis- fied entertain the hypotheses here presented until investigations have been satisfactorily advanced, nor then unless the facts leading to these hypotheses seem unrelated to any phe- nomena already explicable, as is sure- ly not the case. That the phenomena described are, in the present stage of our knowledge, mysterious, is, of course, to be granted; to argue from this that they are to be explained in terms for- eign to such scientific conceptions as have already been attained is as un- warranted as it would be to look for some non-physical hypothesis to explain, for instance, the still mysterious nature of electricity. The value of this type of research must therefore depend almost altogether on the character of the evidence and here the book does not appear convinc- ing. When we consider the facts as a whole, as thus described in epitome by one who is best fitted to present them cogently, can only be impressed with a sense ‘of doubt as to the reliabil- ity of the record. The class of peo- ple in whom the phenomena are dis- played are so emotional, so crudely un- critical, that one can but distrust their statements of the facts even when one does not question their honesty. As an example of “spontaneous telepathy,” for instance, Sir Oliver prominence (pp. 139 to 144) to a detailed deserip- tion of a dream by a certain attorney residing in St. Paul, Minn., in 1892— one Harry W. Wack. The name is un- usual, and we assume that the dreamer whose story is given so much weight Is the H. Wellington Wack (see “Who's to these we geves [Vol. 89, No. 2322 Who in America”), who lived in St. Paul from 1889 to 1895, and who has since then published a book which, it is asserted, was largely plagiarized: he has recently been before the public. The discrediting of one anecdote does not, of course, discredit all similar ones: but this example shows how difficult it is to escape untrustworthy evidence in this field, especially as very little account is taken by our observers of the possible occurrence of illusions of memory, which are immensely more common in the ex- perience of every man than is generally recognized. Of the evidence in favor of the spirit- istic hypothesis gleaned from the per- formances of Eusapia Palladino, Sir Oliver has nothing to say; a fact which is of no little significance when we turn to the book in which Mr. Carving- ton attempts to substantiate the spirit- istic hypothesis by this Italian medium. In fact, this particular medium seems to stand apart from others of her type only because a number of professors, and doc- tors medical and other, of more or less eminence are numbered with those who have given attention to her accomplish- ments; among whom we may mention Lombroso, Richet, and Sir Oliver Lodge himself. These important witnesses in general agree that Palladino has been detected in fraud, but they all also con- cur in the opinion that there are cer- tain manifestations during Palladino’s s¢ances that seem inconsistent with the physical concepts approved in our day, and that are inexplicable under any well established scientific hypotheses. It is unnecessary to describe these mani- festations in detail for they differ little from those given in séances with other less well known mediums. There is the same insistence upon dim _ lighting, which, at the demand of the medium, is reduced in intensity pari passu with the strangeness of the occurrences. There is the same black curtained cabinet Ta- bles are moved, rappings give replies to questions, light articles are thrown around, the observers feel mysterious touches, slaps, etc., etce., as of old. Cer- tain of the phenomena noted are, in- deed, new to the world of mediums, but few of these are of especial interest. The natural inference would be that Palladino’s manifestations must be class- ed with those of more commonplace mediums, who have deen frequently “exposed”; yet we are assured poy the well-known observers of these phenom- ena that we must look In some new di- rection for the explanation of what they have seen. It remains a question, how- ever, whether the learning of the wit- nesses cited fits them for passing judg- ments in these matters any more au- thoritatively than the average citizen may venture to do; whether, indeed, it is probable that they could explain the tricks of the clever prestidigitator who pretends to be no more than a skilfmi de-
Page 27
Dec. 30, 1909] The Nation. 659 ceiver. We should be grateful, to be sure, bution to either political or social sci- to the learned company of martyrs to ence. But, in view of existing conditions in science who give valuable time to such France—the attitude of the church toward wearisome business as that recorded; but, on the whole, we must confess that we remain unconvinced of the validity of Mr. Carrington’s claim that the Pal- ladino phenomena are explicable only by the adoption of the hypothesis of spiritism, and feel inclined to agree with the late Professor Sidgwick (p. 53), who, after his sittings, stated that “inasmuch as trickery had been sys- tematically practised, apparently, by Eusapia Palladino for years, he pro- posed to ignore her performances in the future as those of other persons engag- ed in the same mischievous trade were to be ignored.” Even if we do not go so far as this, we can but note that the vast mass of what were supposed a few dec- ades ago to be spirit messages have been shown by advancing science to be due to the medium’s automatisms, which are now fairly well correlated with nor- divorce and the scope of parental authority —it had some sort of excuse for its exist- ence. And it was a consistent and well- made drama. In New York, it has no rele- vancy and the only motive for its repre- sentation must be sought in its sentimental and theatrical interests, which are con- siderable. It is pernicious from the moral and silly from the social point of view. Here is the plot in a nutshell. A profligate, selfish, tyrannical father, a relict of the ancient feudalism, has two daughters. The elder, whom he prevented from marrying in youth, has become a subdued, spiritless, | patient, saintly, old maid, whose sole hap- mal psychical phenomena; and we may | believe that in some future day such explanations will be forthcoming of Pal-| ladino’s unfraudulent performances as will bring them into accord with well- established scientific conceptions. Lombroso is to be honored by a statue to be erected in the city of Verona, and an international subscription for the pur- pose is being organized. For the next year, the Sociedad Rural Argentina announces an international ex- position of agriculture, to be held at Buenos Ayres. The United States has been allotted 4,500 square metres of space, which will be chiefly devoted to the display of agri- cultural and industrial machinery. The death of Dr. Ludwig Mond is an- nounced from abroad. He was seventy years of age, and had been most successful for many years in his applications of chemistry to industrial processes. A German by birth, in 1862 he went to England and soon gained renown by his inventions connected with the obtainance of nickel and other metals. In 1896, he founded the Davy-Fara- day Research Laboratory of the Royal In- stitution. His collection of paintings by the Italian masters has a worldwide reputation. Drama. “The Lily,” which has just been produc- ed in the Stuyvesant Theatre, is an emascu- lated version of ‘“‘Le Lys,” by Pierre Wolff and Gaston Leroux, which attracted con- siderable attention and much adverse com- ment in Paris, by its open and bold ad- vocacy of the rights of free love. Like most revolutionary social dramas of its class, it based its arguments upon an imaginary case, barely possible even in France, whol- ly inconceivable here, where religious, leg- al, and social conditions are entirely dif- ferent. Moreover in its discussion of the sexual problem, it ignored the vastly im- portant economical side of it altogether. It was not, therefore, a very valuable contri- piness is to guard and cherish her much younger sister. The latter, shut out from the world in an old chateau, falls in love with a transient artist, and, when she finds that she cannot marry him—because he has a wife from whom he cannot get a di- vorce—becomes his mistress. When her fall is discovered, her father proposes to beat her first and disown her afterward, but the blameless old maid, the lily, comes to her defence, proclaims her inalienable right to obey her natural instincts and declares that any fate for woman is preferable to that of an enforced celibacy. The dramatic effect of this unexpected outburst is, of course, striking. In “The Lily” in the con- cluding scenes, certain concessions are made to modern prejudices, at the expense of both force and consistency, but the play is none the less unwholesome on that ac- count. It is beautifully mounted at the Stuyvesant, and well acted, especially by Nance O'Neil, who, in the crucial scene, touched such a note of tragic pathos as is seldom heard in the theatre of to-day. The success of the piece is ensured by her personal triumph, but the representation is a good one throughout. It is a pity that the play is not more worthy of the pains bestowed upon it. “The Next of Kin,” the latest play by Charles Klein, which was produced in the Hudson Theatre on Monday evening, and of which much was expected, is a melodrama of moderate quality and unequal effect. Although it professes to deal with a sub- ject of the gravest import—the influence of political and commercial interests upon a corrupt, judiciary—it is so general in its charges, so vague in its details, so theatri- cal and indefinite in its final outcome, that it is inconsiderable except as melodramatic entertainment. From this point of view it is not altogether unskilful. There are many effective situations in the first two acts, and several well sketched character studies, which afford opportunity for some excellent acting. Hedwig Reicher, as the heroine, against whom a wicked uncle em- ploys all the machinery of the law to rob her of wealth and liberty, depicts with much cleverness the progress of a harassed girl through various stages of nervous ex- citement to the verge of actual insanity. Frank Sheridan, as a political ex-judge, who bends judges to his will, and Frederick Perry, as an able young advocate, who suffers defeat because he will n6E Btéop to ignoble means to secure victory, both act- ed extremely well. So did most of the less prominent players. They made the The “Intimate Recollections of Joseph Jefferson” (Dodd, Mead & Co.), by his daughter-in-law, Eugénie Paul Jefferson, bears pleasing testimony to the high and affectionate esteem in which the famous actor was held by his family and by a vast host of personal iriends in and out of his profession. It has a definite charm as a loving and unaffected tribute to his mem- ory, but adds little to the general knowl- edge of him, either as man or artist, and contains nothing that is particularly valua- ble, or significant, in the way of critical appreciation. In many respects it is a work of supererogation. Such facts in it as are fresh are, as a rule, either cumulative or trivial. During the last thirty or forty years of a phenomenally prosperous and happy career, Jefferson may be said to have lived in a constant blaze of publicity. His unapproachable excellence in a single character, curiously reflective of all that was superfine in his art and of the domi- nant traits in his own winning personality, kept him at the head of his calling and en- deared him to millions of theatre-goers all over the English-speaking world. So it came to pass that his sayings and doings were chronicled in the press with a minute- ness that makes it almost impossible now to tell anything about him that has not been already recorded. That he was not spoiled by the favors showered upon him by fortune is, perhaps, the most substan- tial proof of the solid worth of his char- acter and the soundness of his intellect. He preserved to the end his democratic simplicity, his tender and genial humanity, his enjoyment of life, art, sport, and na- ture, and his spirit of habitual optimism. These recollections afford some fresh glimpses of him as the enthusiastic painter and shrewd collector, as the fond sire and grandsire, the ardent fisherman, the wide- awake man of affairs, the liberal host, and the occasional speculator in spiritual mys- teries. They speak, also, proudly but dis- creetly, of his close friendship with Grover Cleveland and other eminent men, who found in him the virtues of true compan- ionship. It is an agreeable book, if some- what over-zealous in its hero-worship. “The Travelling Companions,’ a story in scenes, by F. Anstey, which was orig- inally published as a serial in Punch in 1891, has now been reprinted by J. M. Dent & Co. of London and imported here by E. P. Dutton & Co. It is not a very bril- liant specimen of the author’s humor, and shows the marks of age very clearly, the conditions of European travel having changed greatly since it was first written. The sketches of the tourists concerned do not reveal much power of observation or invention, the English personages being eonventional and the American grotesque. It is mildly amusing in its way, and, in the absence of more substantial wit, might serve to while away a lazy half-hour, but the reason for its resuscitation is not par- ticularly obvious Meta Illing died December 26 at Frank- fort-on-Main. This actress had appeared in many emotional parts at the Lessing Theater in Berlin, the Thalia Theater in Hamburg, and the Schauspielhaus in Munich, of each of which she was a mem- bér, and at many other theatres in Ger- many and Austria. In 1906 she appeared best of the opportunities afforded them by /at the Berkeley Lyceum in New York, in a practical playwright. “Magda,” in English. Before this she had
Page 28
660 played in the West as a German star. Dur- ing the present season in Berlin she or- ganized a company for the performance of Shakespearean and other plays, including “She to Conquer,” in English. From Gross Lichterfelde is announced the death of the dramatist and novelist, Karl Béttcher, in his fifty-eighth year. This writer's plays, dealing frequently with mooted social and political questions, more than once were banned by the censor. Apart from books of travel, his works in- clude “Der Nabob auf Kapri,” ‘“Karis- bader Novellen,” “Die beriihmte Tragédin,” “Im Bann der Englainderei.” Stoops Musie. all the operas, that have in the regular repertories is Mozart's ‘“‘Le Nozze di Figaro.”’ There is one, however, twenty-three years older still, which tg occasionally revived—Gluck’'s “Orfeo ed Eurydice.” Its production last week was one of the most notable achieve- ments ever placed on record at the Metro- politan Opera House. There are no men in the cast; Louise Homer, Johanna Gadski, Bella Alten, and Alma Gluck (a recent re- erult from tke chorus, who bids fair to become a famous prima donna) imperson- ated the four roles in the cast; and Mme. Homer, on whom fell most of the burdens, raised her stature as an artist by several inches. Arturo Toscanini, who conducted with the utmost devotion and enthusiasm, had chosen for this revival neither the original Italian version of “Orfeo,” which was first heard in Vienna in 1762, nor the Parisian, which was produced twelve years later; but, profiting by the suggestions of Berlioz and Gevaert, he eliminated weak numbers and strengthened other places. In other words, he followed the example of Wagner, who believed that it was better to edit Gluck’s operas and save them than to leave them on the shelf, respectfully un- edited. The Metropolitan audience applaud- ed the opera so cordially that there is hope of its becoming again a favorite—a fate it deserves because of its abundance of good melody. The beautiful scenery provided by Mr. Gatti-Casazza will help to rescue “Orfeo.” It is exquisitely in harmony with the poetic conceptions of the infernal and paradisias which the story of Orpheus in quest of his wife is located “The Essentials of Pianoforte Playing,” by Clayton Johns (Oliver Ditson Co.), is a convenient summary, 84 pages, of the things a student of the piano and its litera- needs to know. It is not in- beginners, but for those who acquired facility in reading easy music; and there is much, too, that will belp teachers who have not the op- portunity to keep in touca with the latest developments in musical pedagogy. Mind- training, as well as finger-training, is what the author alms at; and In pursuance of this object a number of famous short pleces by Clementi, Bach, Schumann, Chopin, and other masters are printed, with analyses and directions for their correct render- The oldest of kept their place realms in in ture most tended already for have The chapters How to Practice and | [Vol. 89, No. 2322 oes ae music and verse” there is much food for thought for those who make all accents metrical, forgetting that notes, like words and syllables, have special emphasis ac- cording to their value and position. It is somewhat disconcerting, on the other hand, to find the statement that, as a rule, “ac- celerando in one place demands ritardando in another.” Why, in music any more than in the recitation of verse? To say that music is “the science of harmonical sounds” is to give a poor defi- nition of it, for music is an art as well as a science, and much of it consists of mel- odies that do not include “harmonical sounds.” It would be unfair, however, to condemn M. F. MacConnell’s “Some Es- sentials Students” this opening definition. the terms that needs to know about are clearly defined and helpfully illustrated in this book, which aims at being something more complete than the average musical catechism, (Oliver Ditson Co.) because of For the most part, of terms. The chief advantage of the plan here pursued is that the various words re- lating to rhythm, melody, sharps and flats, scales, keys, time, accent, embellishments, form, opera, etc., are brought together in- stead of being scattered throughout the volume. There is an appendix of noted names in music, brought up to the present day. It is altogether a very useful little book. One of the new operas at the Paris Opéra Comique, the “Cour du moulin” of Déodat de Séverac (“poéme lyrique en deux actes, paroles de M. Maurice Magre’’), is de- scribed as expressing most exquisitely the genius loci, which happens to be Languedoc. A peasant lover returns to his own country to find hig sweetheart married to another. They meet, and the sweetheart once again returns the passion of her lover. They plan to flee together—but the “voices of the vil- lage” speak to him, and, in the end, he departs alone. The piece is one of poetical merit, and has unusual spontaneity. There is to be recognized, also, richness of melodic Furthermore, the piece is mount- ed with fidelity and richness. It may none the less be doubted whether “le Cour du moulin” is a piece which we are likely to see transplanted. The thinness of its action would seem a sufficient obstacle.» With M. de Séverac’s opera is given a conte musi- cal in two acts, by Ernest Garnier, entitled “Myrtil.” Many operas have been written on the subject of Faust. It has remained for a Dutch composer, named Briiggemann, conceive and carry out the plan of writ- ing a “Faust” trilogy. His three operas are entitled “Dr. Faust,” “Margarete,” and “Mephistopheles.” The second of these is to be produced at the Scala in Milan ere long. It is said to resemble in plot Gou- nod’s popular work. The Berlin Signale fiir die Musikalische invention. | Welt announces the result of the competition for prizes offered by it last May. Altogether, 874 compositions were received, and the judges (Busoni, Hollaender, P. Scharwenka) gave the first prize of 500 marks to Emile R. Blanchet of Lausanne. “Hitherto absolute- Punctuation or Phrasing are to be spec- ly unknown in Germany,” writes the editor, jally commended, while In the section en-/|“he will soon be famous, thanks to his titled “A comparison between Instrumental | prize composition, ‘Tema con Variazion!,’ but | less elaborate than the usual dictionaries | to: | 'and the Signale has reason to be proud of having practically discovered this composer.” The second prize (400 marks) was won by /a young American, L. T. Griinberg, who has been in Berlin several years and begun to make a name for himself as a pianist. The third went to Willy Renner of Frankfurt, for a fugue. Altogether, eight prizes were awarded to men, two to women. Albert Niemann, who impersonated “Tann- hauser” at Paris during the three stormy performances of Wagner’s opera in 1861, recently sang the “Reiterlied” in “Wallen- stein’s Camp,” at the celebration of the 150th anniversary of the birth of Schiller, at the Schauspielhaus, Berlin. He is in his | seventy-ninth year. in Musical Definitions for Music | an amateur or a student) Scottish Paintings, Past and Present. By James L. Caw. New York: Fred- erick A. Stokes Co. $8 net. In this work Mr. Caw, director of the National Gallery of Scotland, has had /a two-faced task. In the century and a half before Raeburn is reached, al- _ though something is to be said for the cosmopolitan Allan Ramsay, the work is one of painstaking antiquarianism. As such it gives a favorable impression. Except as a few additional pictures by the older worthies may turn up, it is not likely that the early chapters of this history will be superseded. From Raeburn on, while retaining its histor- ieal tinge, the book becomes perforce ‘one of criticism. It concludes with such living young lions as Stuart Park and Muirhead Bone. Nor has Mr. Caw flinched from the almost impossible duty of unifying his studies in a final comprehensive essay. Of his somewhat discrepant tasks he has acquitted himself with ability. Nat- |urally the appeal of the antiquarian portions is small here, but American readers will welcome the discussion of 'Raeburn, of Wilkie, and of the Glas- gow School. Some of Mr. Caw’s ver- dicts seem adjusted to Caledonian lati- tudes, but in the main his standards are European. At times he presses doubtful points of priority with patri- |otic intent. Thus Gavin Hamilton, who managed to be a fledgling pseudo-c!assic as early as 1770, is called a precursor of David. The precursor of both, odd- ly enough, was a talented young eclec- ‘tie named Fragonard. William Allan, a temperamental affinity of the later Delacroix, was exhibiting Oriental sub- jects as early as 1814. His position as a precursor of the Urientalists seems secure. The most important chapters are naturally those on Raeburn and Wilkie, the only two Scottish painters who seem to have achieved anything like greatness on the European scale. A welcome addition to the biography of Raeburn is the fact that he began his
Page 29
Dec. 30, 1909] Oo The Nation. ——EE — ——- - — studies with the etcher Deuchar, an upon persuasion. For an artist this is a| eral museum is under consideration, and imitator of the Dutch masters. This hard law, but, at bottom, it is that of all may partly account for Raeburn’s mys- | professional practice that touches obvious terious assimilation of what seems best in the manners of the earlier Dutch por- trait painters. Though highly enthusi- astic, the estimate of Raeburn is also cautious. In serene certainty of point of view, as in simple directness of touch, he is far nearer the great mas- ters than any of the English painters save Hogarth. Wilkie, again, has no rival in Great Britain except the cre- ator of Marriage A la Mode. In fact, Hogarth, whom Mr. Caw prudently keeps pretty far in the background, may well serve as the measure of all British achievement in painting. What utilities. Concerning the battle of the | styles, Mr. Sparrow holds severe views, if is written about the still oscillating | vogue of the Glasgow painters is both | sympathetic and judicious. while fully appreciating the painter- like qualities of Hornel, Melville, Roche, Walton, Lavery, George Henry, others, does not hesitate to note the) lack of culture that limits the effect of all this work. Mr. Caw, | genially expressed. There is no hope, he holds, in the prevailing eclecticism. How to stop it he naturally does not know, but be wishes that everybody would continue one or another of the English transitiona! styles—Tudor, Elizabethan, or Queen Anne —choosing those phases in which the Gothic residuum is most prominent. It may be interesting to note our own tendency to solve the problem along parallel lines. Our tendency is towards later composite styles, in which the classic element is the ruling one—Georgian and Louis XVI. In the ab- sence of Gothic examples such a course seems logical. We doubt the possibility of the revival of Gothic style for monu- mental buildings. For domestic purposes its later forms seem still adapted. The dif- ficulty is that few are willing to pay for sincerity of construction, whether in half timber or in stone and brick. Towards the | classical revivals in England Mr. Sparrow Mackie, Lorimer, Austen Brown, and) | One feels, indeed, on) surer ground with the etchers, William | Strang, D. Y. Cameron, who is also a painter of parts, and Muirhead Bone. All Mr. Caw’s comment on recent and. living painters is as searching as kind- ly. the most interesting part of the book. To the average reader it will be) In summing up, the permanent char- acteristics of Scottish art are said to be limited intellectual range—portrait- | ure, landscape, and genre alone are seriously cultivated—a keen sense for workmanship, and, in particular, a love | of color. Mr. Caw suggestively draws the analogies between recent Scotch and Dutch painting, and emphasizes the real points of difference with the Eng- lish school. The art societies, ephe- meral and permanent, and the museums are duly recorded. The volume is a. stout quarto well printed and indexed, and contains seventy-six half-tone plates. “The English House,” by W. Shaw Spar- row (John Lane Co.) is primarily an his- torical essay in the popular style. Keenly alert to the social aspects of his subject, the author seeks novel and striking illus- trations. A charcoal burner’s hut takes us back to neolithic man; the peasant cot- tage recalls in miniature that communal life in hall which all classes led till late in the Middle Ages. Through the boldly printed text are scattered illustrations of typical homes, many of which, alas, have disappeared before the jerry-builder or, less pardonably, before the innovating architect. With Mr. Sparrow’s plea for sound-proof walls every one might sym- pathize. It seems a case, indeed, for legal compulsion. Especially good, also, is the advice to stake out floor plans at full scale before accepting them. What is writ- ten about the relations of client and archi- tect is sound. The ascendency of the archi- tect must in the nature of the case rest is frankly hostile. It seems to us that he is hardly fair towards that very exquisite designer Wren. Adam, too, though his quality was small, was something more than a decorator. On the whole matter of the classical revival it must be admitted that many of its monuments are stupid and that most are wofully small in effect, but the Neo-Gothic buildings are if anything worse. Wisdom seems, as usual, to lie between the extreme courses. The Roman, in:luding the Romanesque and Byzantine, evidently has its constructive lessons for us. More immediately useful seem the styles of Italy and France in their prime. The better modern buildings of Renaissance inspira- tion at least have scale and idiom. But we cannot pursue this issue. Mr. Sparrow's vivacious book igs calculated for lnglish- men, but all students of domestic architec- ture may read it with profit. “A Handbook of Marks on Pottery and Porcelain,” by W. Burton and R. L. Hobson (Macmillan), is a thin volume with rounded corners intended for the collector’s pocket. It contains twenty-three registers of marks arranged by nations, kilns, and dates. Each section is preceded by a brief technical in- troduction, and there are four indexes, in- cluding names (except Oriental), letters or monograms, symbols, and Oriental names. Only continued use can prove the accuracy of lists of this sort. We have now merely to note the compactness of the form and thecon- venience of the arrangement. The fact that experts on European and Eastern ceramics have here collaborated inspires confidence, and casual tests of the Italian and Japanese sections give a good impression of the work. We have received the first year-book of the St. Paul Institute of Arts and Sciences Like its Brooklyn forerunner this corpora- tion takes the whole of human knowledge |to be its province, and in the first year has attained a notable membership and has conducted numerous successful lecture courses, The city wisely came to its aid by permitting the use of school buildings for this truly educational work. The in- stitution under the presidency of Charles W. Ames, Esq., is highly organized into many sections, covering everything from astronomy to the milliner’s art. A gen- the beginnings of an art gallery have been ‘made in a few gifts of modern pictures. In all, an auspicious beginning of a great and meritorious enterprise. In “The Art of the Metropolitan Museum” (L. C. Page & Co.) David C. Preyer begins with a brief history of the museum and statement of its aims, and closes with a list of benefactors. The nineteen intervening chapters give brief histories or technical explanations of each branch of art, with incidental mention of examples in the gal- leries. Of the task of writing a brief uni- versal history apropos of a particular mu- seum, Mr. Preyer has acquitted himself |ereditably. The advisability of the plan is open to question. Something in the way ofa short, reasoned catalogue, after the plan of that published by the Boston Museum, would seem to us more needed. Certain sec- tions of the present volume—for example, that in which Chinese porcelain is discussed without directing the reader specifically to a single fine piece—seem clean wasted. How- ever, Mr. Preyer writes with enthusiasm, has the courage of his personal tastes, and has given what might be a routine book a distinct personal flavor. The shortcomings are less in substance than in style, proof- reading, and in an occasional erratic judg- ment. We offer certain corrections and suggestions, since the book evidently has vitality enough to carry it through succes- sive printings. The English is energetic, but undistinguished, and at times quite slovenly. A sentence like the following is typical: The greatest portrait painter of the Dutch school, the one who is placed ac- cording to individual preference as the greatest master in portraiture, was Frans Hals, of whom the museum shows sufficient examples to enable us to determine him a master of masters. No one who must deal with a sub- ject of this magnitude is likely to pass the proof-room unscathed, but the errors in this volume exceed the tolerable mean. In the Italian and Japanese sections misprints are frequent and disfiguring. We note only those that may make trouble “Klopas,” p. 44, is not recognizable as a Greek sculp- tor; read Scopas. ‘“Parmigiano,’’ pp. 78 and 108, is not a painter, but a cheese. “‘Dif- fidente’’ is a curious twist for Defendente, p. 87. We should be glad to see certain exaggerations toned and omissions repaired ‘in a second edition. That “the Romans created nothing” their portraiture and architecture remain disprove. Gothic sculpture is grossly underestimated. No mention is made of Claux Sluter, whose realigm won the admiration of Renaissance Italy. That Saint-Gaudens, the faithful stu- to dent of the early Italian sculptors, ‘‘liber- ated us from slavish dependence on the Italian Renaissance” is a paradox we should like to see explained. We are sorry to see the unpleasing, if authentic, exam- ple of Giovanni Bellini at the Metropoll- tan accredited either as a representative or important picture It was a pity to omit the exquisite portrait of a lady by Bernard Strigel. In ite small way it is a worthy pendant to the early Holbein, Rous- seau’s Gorges d’Apremont in the Vanderbilt gallery seems to certain people the finest | realistic landscape of the nineteenth cen- tury. At any rate, its quality entitles it to mention. In @ new edition we wish Mr.
Page 30
662 The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2322 Preyer could persuade himself not to en- hance by his authority the popularity of Cot’s sentimental The Storm. It will be news to Englishmen that the Royal Acad- emy has been “Ruskinized,” unless, indeed, the word is a trope meaning drubbed by Ruskin. One might wish finally for a fuller recognition of the merits of Homer Martin, whose sheer pictorial gift in many opinions far surpassed that of the great improvvisatore Inness. In the regards here suggested we believe that a good book might be substantially improved. Thanks to the activity and funds of the Diirerbund, a new and cheaper edition of “Ludwig Richter: Lebenserinnerungen eines deutschen Malers,” designed especially as a contribution to popular education, has been issued by Max Hesse’s Verlag in Leip- zig. A better choice in German biography scarcely could be made, for no one who ever put brush to canvas was so in sympa- thy with the German masses as Ludwig Richter, famous for what he did to revive wood engraving, but more famous as the painter of humble German life. These E£r- innerungen have been amplified by Hein- rich Richter, and there is an introduction by Ferdinand Avenarius. Judge Madill of Saint Louis commissioned Gifford Dyer to paint a series of forty pictures to commemorate the ruins and historical views of Greece as they now stand. Mr. Dyer has lived in the country for several years and has finished about half the set. Judge Madill gave the paintings to Washington Uni- versity, and they are now hanging in one of the galleries of the City Art Museum. The late It is not easy to combine artistic beauty with topographical drawing; but Mr. Dyer, while giving a true representation of some monument or historic spot of Greece, has attained pictorial beauty as well as utility. He paints in thin, flat planes, each object or spot of color being outlined with a dell- cately drawn line of brown or black. But such is his power of creating atmosphere by exact that nis pictures are flooded with air. value A photographic apparatus has recent- ly been invented by Dr. Carl von Arnhard of Munich, Bavaria, for the easy and exact production of coples of old manuscripts iu their original form without taking them out of the books in which they may be con- tained. The inventor, born in Munich July 16, 1850 philosophy and Oriental languages the university of his native and also in Leipzig. He is the author of a treatise entitled “Die Wasserwethe nach dem Ritus der mthiopischen Kirche,” published in the Zeitachrift der deutachen morgenldindischen Geaellachaft, in 1887. These studies im- him with the slow and painful process of copying old manuscripts with the pen, and led him to devise some means of avoiding it This desirable result bas been attained by a very simple photographic apparatus, which, without camera and lens, with the ald of a small electric 4antern constructed for this purpose, produces a perfect copy of a page of manuscript In about half a minute. Persons rticularly interested in this unique invention may ob tain further particulars from Dr. Hauberrisser, Dienerstrasse 19, Munich, Ba- varia. It has been patented in Germany France, England, and the United States. studied In city pressed Geore | Frederic Remington, painter, sculptor, and writer, died December 26 in Ridgefield, Conn. Though an Easterner, he spent much of his time in the West, living as well as depicting the life of ranchman, cowboy, and Indian. Born in 1861, he en- tered the Yale Art School, intending to become a painter; but his artistic career was interrupted upon his father’s death, though he enjoyed unusual opportunities for travel, his wanderings extending as far south as the interior of Mexico, and as far north as Hudson Bay. His more se- rious work in oils dates from his thirties, and later. Early in his career, he ex- pressed the wish to have some one carve on his tombstone, “He knew the horse.” And it was in the painting of the horse that he excelled. In execution, his most notable characteristic was, perhaps, the daring use of vivid, dazzling color. In the nineties, he visited Europe, the results of these travels being expressed in A German Infantry Officer, An Old Trooper, and oth- | In 1894, feeling that ‘‘the West er works. was all played out im its romantic as- pects,” as he expressed it, he made his home in New Rochelle. a year later that he turned his hand to sculpture. The most famous of the result- ant bronzes is the Bronco Buster. artist visited Cuba at the time of the Spanish-American war, and later returned to Europe. On one or more occasions he exhibited at Paris. Finance. AFTER THE “LOAN-SHIFTING.” Among the particularly interesting comparisons, made possible by the re- turns, just published, of the whole coun- try’s national banks, were the figures of the loan account, at New York and out- side of New York. Up to the end of summer the New York bank position was unusually comfortable. The wide- spread and thorough liquidation, after the break-down of 1907, had brought! bank liabilities to a low level. Simulta- neously, the releasing of currency from the channels of trade sent that currency ‘into bank reserves, where it found al- ready lodged the $100,000,000 gold, im- ported during panic times. The result on the New York banks, during 1908, was so striking that, by the middie of the year, surplus reserves had reached $66,098,000—the highest level ever at- tained by them, save for the similar af- ter-panic period, 1894. The present year had those easy bank conditions as a legacy. As recent- ly as the end of last July, the New York surplus bank reserves, at $34,000,000, stood at a height attained in midsum- mer during only two other years of the decade past—one being 1908. This seem- ed to be promise of continued easy mo- ney. But this high midsummer surplus crumbled away with astonishing rapid- ity. Recall of interior money from New It was not until} The | York, as harvest-time approached, oc- curred as usual; but no effort was made to reduce the New York loan account built up on the basis of those interior “reserves. On the contrary, Stock Ex- change speculation for the rise, on a 'scale of excessive magnitude, increased |the demand for credit. By September | 11, the New York surplus had declined to $3,166,000. Since reserve money was | still leaving the Associated Banks for | the West at the rate of five to ten mil- lions weekly, and since speculation was still rioting on the Stock Exchange, a deficit in reserves, below the 25 per cent. requirement, seemed unavoidable. | It did not come. The reason for its |mon-appearance was not the mainte- ‘nance of the New York currency hold- ings; that item fell from $351,800,000 on | September 11 to $298,900,000 on Decem- ber 4. What happened was a reduction between those dates, in loans of the Asso- ciated Banks, amounting to no less than $163,000,000. But since this enormous- ly large loan reduction was accompa- nied by no visible reduction in credits granted on the Stock Exchange or elsewhere, it follows that some one else besides the Associated Banks must have been taking over the loans with which those institutions had found themselves overloaded. The manner in which a good-sized block of our loans was transferred to London in October—$20,000,000 to $30,- 000,000, the bank statement seemed to show, in a single week—and the man- ner in which London threw back later a good part of those loans, makes up one chapter in the episode. The Canadian ‘banks took some; trust companies some; nvrivate lenders, in a roundabout way,’ took others. _ But the consensus of opinion grew to be that interior institu- tions were assuming the load, just as in 1906, when clearing-house authorities declared that out-of-town domestic banks were lending $300,000,000 in New York. Until the past few days, no one could say exactly how large was this shifted burden taken over by interior banks. Five weeks ago, the comptroller of the currency called for reports of all the na- tional banks as of date November 16. That was the height of the loan-shifting movement, and the next previous call of the comptroller had been on September 1, just when the process must have been beginning. Last week’s complete and detailed official figures, compiled from those returns, show that the national banks outside New York had in the period increased loans $141,000,000, while New York has reduced its own by $122,000,000. In the same autumn months of 1906, New York reduced its loans $27,509,000, while banks outside this city expanded | loans by $94,600,000. In the similar pe- riod of 1905—which very closely resem- ‘bled the season past—New York reduc-
Page 31
Dec. 30,. 1909] The Nation. — ed its loans by $95,500,000, against an expansion of $113,600,000 elsewhere. Here was the same process at work as in 1909, but in neither of the two other years was a shifting process indicated on anything like so large a scale as in this season. What the resultant position in New York was, most of us have for some time been aware. What it was in the banks outside New York, the comptrol- ler’s figures partially suggest. Accord- ing to these figures, Chicago ani St. Louis, which with New York constitute the “central reserve cities,” were on November 9 below the required 25 per cent. reserve against deposits. How the rest of the interior stands, as compared with the admitted periods of general strain on banking facilities at this date in 1906 and 1905, may be judged from the following figures: 1909. 1906. 1906. Per Per Per cent. cent. cent. Other reserve cities.. 25.56 24.32 24.77 Southern States . 17.87 18.16 18.58 Middle West ........ 16.82 16.60 17.22 Farther West -- 17.26 16.78 17.56 BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Abbey, H. The Dream of Love; a Mystery. Cambridge: Riverside Press. 76 cents. Allison, W. T. The Amber Army and Other Poems. Toronto: Williams Briggs. 8vo. $3.00. knowledge of details. the author. By ANNE Moore. vii+212 governed by the same laws. BASHFORD DEAN, Columbia University: and commend its arrangement and originality. Moore’s Physiology of Man and Other Animals An elementary treatment of pure physiology as distinguished from anatomy. emphasizes strongly the comparative idea and impresses upon the pupil the fact that physiological processes in man, HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, From the Nor. Bjérnson, B. Wise-Kaut. Brandu’s. $1 wegian by Bernard Stahl. net. Bond, F. Westminster Abbey. Frowde. Brand, R. H. The Union of South Africa. Frowde. Browne’s Religio Medici and Digby's Ob- servations. Frowde. Bulletin of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology. Vol. 45, No. 1. Boston. Burke, M. C. School Room Echoes. Book One. Boston: R. G. Badger. $1.50. Butler, E. B. Women and the Trades: Pittsburgh, 1907-1908. Charities Publica- tion Committee. Chadwick, F. E. The Relations of the U. 8S. and Spain: Diplomacy. Scribner. $4 net. Delacombe, H. The Boys’ Book of Airships. Stokes. De Vries, H. The Mutation Theory. Trans- lated by J. B. Farmer and A. D. Dar- bishare. Vol. I Chicago: Open Court Publishing Co. De Wulf, M. History of Medieval] Philoso- phy. Third edition. Longmans, Green. Falkiner, C.,L. Essays Relating to Ire- land, Biographical, Historical, and To- pographical. Longmans, Green. Farnell, L. R. The Cults of the Greek States. Vol. V. Frowde. Firth, C. H. The Last Years of the Pro- tectorate, 1656-1658. 2 vols. Longmans, Green. $7 net. Fraser, G. The Stone House at Gowanus Wittner & Kintner. $2.50. Garnett, J. M. Biographical Sketch of Hon. Muscoe Russell Hunter Garnett (1821- 1864). Reprint from William and Mary College (Maryland) Quarterly Magazine. Goddard, P. E. Kato Texts. Berkeley, Cal.: University of California. Goldsmith, O. Plays, together with The Vi- car of Wakefield. Edited, with notes, by C. E. Doble. Frowde. Green, J. R. A History of Botany, 1860- 1900: Being a continuation of Sachs’ His- Wilder’s History of the Human Body By H. H. Wiper, Professor in Smith College. tory of Botany, 1530-1860. Frowde. $3.15. Hawthorne, J. Lovers in Heaven. New Church Board of Publication. xii-+573 pp. This advanced text-book in comparative anatomy presents the results of modern anatomical and embryological research relative to the human structure, nishes students of technical human anatomy with 3 basis upon which to rest their It is fully illustrated, including many original drawings by and fur- —I have examined it with keen interest It is a very useful book. pp. 12mo. 80 cents. It in the lower animals, and in plants are NEW YORK CHICAGO The Conclusion of a Great Work. A Literary History of The English People From the Earliest Times to the Civil War. By J. J. JUSSERAND. Three vols. Svo., with Frontispieces. Each $3.50 net. Vol. III. (completing the Work) From the Renaissance to the Civil War: Part II. Now Ready. Previously Issued: Vol. I. From the Origins to the Renaissance. Vol II. From the Renaissance to the Civil War. Part 1. ‘Mr. Jusserand’s qualifications for the task which he has undertaken are of a high order. There are few foreigners, and cer- tainly very few Frenchmen, who have so intimate a knowledge of English life. He has already gained preat distinction as an original investigator In more than one of English literary history, and alt his Dae of view in the present work is un- mistakably that of a Frenchman, be shows a degree of sympathetic insight which ts seldom met with in foreign critics of our literature.'’—London Athenaeum. 6, P, PUTNAM'S SONS, S*¥,xoRx THE COMMONWEAL: A Study of the Federal System of Political Economy By AvrrRep P. Hivirer, B.A., M.D. Crown 8vo, pp. xii-162. $1.50 ne/. LONGMANS, GREEN, & C0., New York LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and in any —-y ~ looked up in the Boston and Harvard libraries for echol- ars, writers, and others. Abstracts, copies, trans lations, and bibliographies made. Proof-reading and revision of mavuscript. Highest university and library references. ’ MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. Lewisohn, L. A Night in Alexandria: A Dramatic Poem. Moods Publishing Co. Living Church Annual and Whittaker'’s Churchman’s Almanac, 1910. Milwaukee: Young Churchman Co. 50 cents. Lowell, J. R. Fireside Travels. duction by E. V. Lucas. Frowde. Intro- | McCabe, J. The Martyrdom of Ferrer. Ed- win C. Walker, 30 cents. Marden, O. S. Success Nuggets. Crowell. Methodist Year Book, 1910. Eaton & Maina. 20 cents net. Park, J. E. The Wonder of His Gracious Words: An Exposition of the Sermon on the Mount. Boston: Pilgrim Press. $1 net. Poulton, E. B. Charles Darwin and the Origin of Species. Longmans, Green. Praed, W. M. Poems. Edited with intro- duction by A. D. Godley. Frowde. Prentout, H. Caen et Bayeux. Paris: Li- braire Renouard. Read, C. Natural and Social Morals. Lon- don. A. & C. Black. Recollection of Léonard, Hairdresser to Queen Marie-Antoinette. Translated from the French by E. Jules Méras. Sturgis & Walton. $1.50 net. Report of the Commissioner of Corpora- tions on Cotton Exchanges. Parts IV and V. Washington: Government Printing Office Roeder, A. Symbol Stories for Children of All Ages. New Church Board of Pubil- cation Scott, W. Guy Mannering; Waverley. 2 vols. Frowde. Sonneck, O. G. T. Report on The Star- Hail Columbia, Amer- ica, Yankee Doodle. Washington: Gov- ernment Printing Office. 85 cents Strong, J. A History of Secondary Educa- tion in Scotland. Frowde. $2.59. The Daysman. Cochrane Publishing $1.50. Vernon, H. M., and K. D. A History of the Oxford Museum. Frowde. 50 cents Wheatley, P. Poems. Philadelphia: The Book Concern of the A. M. E. Church. Spangled Banner, Co. Second Edition Before Publication. indisputably the Book of the Year Retrospections of an Active Life By JOHN BIGELOW Three vols. Imperial 8vo. 48 illustrations $12 net; carriage extra A memoir of the classic type: copious in letters, documents, opinions, anecdotes. A record of great events, great scenes, famous men and women. Time—1817-1867. Historic characters —Lincoln, Gladstone, Queen Victoria, Seward, Thackeray, Lord Lytton, Du- mas, Guizot, Maximilian, Stanton, Lord Palmerston—appear in the ample pages. “He tella a story that ts of exceptional interest, even In these days of a sur-.-s of personal reminiscence.’’—Boston Transcript. “Mr. Bigelow's work is remarkable throughout for ite clarity, orderliness, and ~ ~~ Ser of treatment.’’—Review of Re- views. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. 33-27 Eaat 17th Street, New York The > * Musicians > Library 50 Volumes Issued The finest editions extant. Send for catalog giving portraits of editors and tables of contents. Special rates to Schools, Colleges and Public Libraries. OLIVER DITSON COMPANY DITSON BUILDING BOSTON, MASS.
Page 32
The Nation. | | | ~ You can add ‘ioe Hours Joys of T' By giving a ard s subscription to Sr. Mt —" Nicnonas to the children you love. y4q Sr. Nicnoras abounds in splendid. stories ~ for boys and girls and in articles full of the greatest interest. @ Sr. Nicuoras has many departments which } help as well as entertain their readers. @ Sr. Nicuoras is heartily commended by educatorsas a valuable influence for good, by parents as a never failing source of joy (Mrs SS St. NICHOLAS “ale at ~~ 'e @! Subscription $3.00 a year. Give your order to any book “™ i store or newsdealer or send to Tue Century Co., Union ) Savane, New Yorx Crry. If requested, a handsome gift card Do you know theBeacon Biographies? SAMPLE COPIES OF “THE RELIGION ie FUTURE”: A A ay THE NATION Ry CHARLES W. BLIOT, and other Unitarian | the same time brief, Each volume 60 literature sent free on request. Address Box 74, cents net; by mail, 64 cents. Barnstable, Mass. desoripti Tet. Send for a a , ? ve pamph + Will be sent to any address for . | three weeks WITHOUT CHARGE. 128 Tremont Street. * BRITISH | KETKAR’S HISTORY OF CASTE IN INDIA ' AUHTORS 2.00 Get; 93.09 Op cael. Tue Nation, 20 Vesey Street, N.Y. Bend for catalogue. FOREIGN TAUGHNITZ | The only reliable book in English on the subject. ph BOSTON, MASS : TAYLOR & CARPENTDR, Ithaca, N. Y.
Page 33
Dec. 30, 1909] countless to the Wonderful Childhood @ Gond reading is an essential for good chil- /// dren. It makes them better boys and girls. @ By what they read children may have their } / lives enriched and ennobled, their tastes made N finer, and their appreciations awakened. @ By what they read children largely develop their ideals and standards. and by all its boys and girls as the great- est friend that ever brought happiness into the life of a child. ForBoys.G! bearing the name of the donor and of the child will be sent with the first number of the magazine and delivered to the child on any day desired, making a very attractive gift package. Ww TU Are You Plus or Minus ? “TONO- se wu in ww, dd UDY nonres, aftr, mnding th . | ie Ww ame : 99 Published Aug., 1909. 12th Thousand now printing. | SEL oon asu aneae NT $1.25 net. Postpaid. - BUN GAY HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY A Scale of Haman Values, with Directions for Personal Appiication By WILLIAM DE WITT HYDE. AMERIC ° President of Bowdoin College. MARX’S CAPITAL, yp Ae sees, | CANS: An Impression All bookstores, 50c. net; by mall, 55e. CHARLES H. KERR & COMPANY, Chicago. B. W. HUEBSCH, Pablsher, New York.
Page 34
The Nation. >. Science A weekly journal, established in 1883, devoted to the advancement of the natural and exact sciences, the official organ of the American Asso- ciation for the Advancement of Science, publishing original articles and notes on the progress of the different branches of science, the proceedings of scientific societies and academies, reviews of ecien- tifle books and articles, preliminary accounts of re- searches and full discussion and news on all sub- jects concerning scientific men and scientifie and educational institutions. Annual eudscription $5.00. Single numbers 15 cents The Popular Science Monthly An iilustrated magazine, established in 1872, de- voted to the diffusion of science, publishing arti- cles by leading authorities in all departments of pure and applied science, including the applications of science to education and society Annual subscription $3.00. Single copies, 380 cents. The American Naturalist A monthly journal, established In 1867, devoted A rican English French to the biological sciences with special reference to the factors of organic evolution Annual subscription $3.00. Single copies, 30 cents. THE SCIENCE PRESS Garrison, N. Y. Lancaster, Pa. Sub-Station 84, New York. AN EXPERIENTIAL PSYCHOLOGY OF "MUSIC By KARL FEININGER “There can be no doubt that this work will arouse much comment, some ) . apd many acrimonious denials of fact, which will only prove it those qualities which make for life and progress. The musical thought of the Amer- can people would be the clearer if more comprehensive studies, similar in scope, were brought out every year.’ —The Violin World. Price $2.00. Postage, 10c. per copy AUGUST GEMUNDER & SONS 42 East 234 St. New York City, U. 8. A. BEST facilities for supplying BOOKS Catalogues free. Correspondence solicited. 30-32 West 27th St., Established over 50 yeers. New York TERRY'S MEXICO to see all there is ag Se sa This Guide to Mexico is Complet | Price $2.50 net, postpaid. Circular on request frens SONORA NEWS COMPANY Visitors in New York are invited to examine the resources of our retail store. Here will be found |a large stock of current and standard works from American and foreign | presses. Teachers or students prepar- German ing tor courses of reading will find an Italian Spanish editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE excellent choice of moderate-priced SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- LEMCKE & BUECHNER '**** E. P. DUTTON & CO., 31 West 23d Street, New York. The Nation in 1910 The foreign correspondence will be further developed. The Countess Pardo Bazan will contribute occasional letters from Madrid on literary and educational topics, and similar letters from St. Petersburg are promised by a scholar of wide information. French and Italian articles will be continued. AMONG CONTRIBUTORS WILL BE Prot. Francis G. Allinson Prof. C. McL, Andrews Prof, Irving Babbitt Frederic Bancroft Cc. William Beebe Bernhard Berenson Prof. J. L. Borgerhoff Prof, G. W. Botsford H. W. Boynton Gamaliel Bradford, jr. Prof. James H. Breasted William Garrott Brown Lawrence J, Burpee Prof. J. Douglas Bruce Prof, Chas. J. Bullock Prof. W. H, Carpenter Gen. W. H. Carter, U. 8. A. F. W, Coburn Prof Archibald Cary Coolidge Prof. Lane Cooper Kenyon Cox John Cotton Dana Prof. W. M. Daniels Prof. W. M. Davis Stoddard Dewey Prof. A. V. Dicey Prof, Frank H. Dixon Prof. Ephraim Emerton Mra. A. von Ende Hon. Wm, Everett Prof, Sidney B. Fay H. T. Finek Prof. George T. Flom Prof. Hy. J. Ford Worthington C. Ford Prof. William Trufant Foster Prof. J. BH. Frame Prof. Kuno Francke Prof. P. H. Frye H. Nelson Gay Rev. Charles R. Gillett Prof. G. L. Goodale Prof. T. D. Goodell Rear-Admiral C. F. Goodrich, U. 8S. N. Prot. W. W. Goodwin Prof, C. H. Grandgent Ferriss Greenslet Rev. W. E. Griffis Prof, Othon Guerlac Prof. A. D. F. Hamlin Arthur 8. Hardy Prof. J. M. Hart Prof. C. H. Haskins Prof. George Hempl Prof. Prof. Prof, J. Prof. A. V. W. Jackson Prof. Joseph Jacobs Prof. T. A, Jaggar Prof. Wm. James Prof. Morris Jastrow, jr. Prof. W. H, Johnson A. G. 8. Josephson Prof. A. G. Keller Prof, Francis W. Kelsey Prof. J, F. Kemp Prof. C. J. Keyser Prof. George W. Kirchwey Prof. G. W. Knox Wm. C. Lane Prof, Chas. R. Lanman L. 8. Livingston Prof. Gonzales Lodge Prof. A. 0. Lovejoy Prof, Charles Edward Lucke Rev. Henry C. McCook Prof. Wm. MacDonald Prof, J. H. McDaniels Prof. A. C. MeGiffert Prof. Allan Marquand Henry Rutgers Marshall Frank Jewett Mather, jr. Albert Matthews The German, Prof. Elmer T. Merrill Prof, R. B. Merriman Prof. Lawrence H, Mills Prof. Chas. H, Moore Prof. Geo. F. Moore Prof. T. H. Morgan Miss Mary Moss A, D. Noyes Prof. H, F. Osborn Mrs, Joseph Pennell Rev. John P. Peters Gustav Pollak Miss Ruth Putnam Mrs. G. H. Putnam Prof. E. K. Rand William Rankin Miss G. M. A. Richter Prof. F. N. Robinson Pref. Jas. H. Robinson Prof, L. 8. Rowe Prof. J. Royce Thomas Seccombe Prof. G. H. Schodde Prof. Stuart P. Sherman Prof. Paul Shorey Prof. J. T. Shotwell Prof, J. E. Spingarn Prof. J. R. 8. Sterrett Lindsay Swift Wm. R, Thayer Prof. Calvin Thomas Pres. J. M. Thomas Prof. C, H. Toy J. R. Towse Prof. W. P. Trent Prof, Eugene Wambaugh Dr. Joseph W. Warren Horace White Prof. Burt G. Wilder Capt. C. de W. Willcox, U. 8. A. Prof. F. J. E. Woodbridge Gen. A. A. Woodhull