The Nation 1909-12-16: Vol 89 Iss 2320

Page 1

THURSDAY, DECEMBER 16, 1909 VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2320. _ TEN CENTS. —— | RECENT IMPORTANT PUBLICATIONS Rodolfo Lanciani’s WANDERINGS IN THE ROMAN CAMPAGNA ‘ “Noteworthy for scholarship, style, and interest for all classes cf tourists and students. He shows wonderful skill and judgment in his subject matter, and his command of English is remarkable for a foreigner.”—Dr. W. J. Rolfe Fully illustrated. $5.00 net Postage 40 cents _ || Henry James’s ITALIAN HOURS “One of the most beautiful and most enjoyable books of the holiday season . One of the very few ‘gift-books’ that make an appeal to the true bibliophile.’—Providence Journal. “Mr. James is at his very best here, for in the first place he loves Italy.”"—New York Sun. With 32 illustrations by Joseph Pennell. $7.50 net Postage 40 cents | Francis G. and Anne C. E. Allinson’s GREEK LANDS AND LETTERS “A useful and valuable aid in culture acquirement. . . . The plan of the work is well conceived and thoroughly worked out. One finds full information on many diverse topics.”"—Philadelphia North American Fully illustrated. $2.50 wet. Postage 18 cents The Life and Letters of George Ticknor “A fascinating and genuinely important Wer, « ~«: pa every way a worthy library edition of a book that richly de- jj serves to stand among the choicest of American classics.".—Newark Evening News. New illustrated edition, with Introduction by Ferris Greenslet. Two volumes. $5.00. Postpaid. The Autobiography of N. S. Shaler With a Supplementary Memoir by his wife. “It is an inspiring life record, written with rare literary charm, and which every American who takes pride in his country’s great men must read with a feeling of enthusiasm and admiration.”— Brooklyn Eagle. Illustrated. $4.00 net. Postage 25 cents. | The Life of Richard Brinsley Sheridan By WALTER SICHEL. “A brilliant achievement.”—Pall Mall Gazette, London. “The achievement of Mr. Sichel’s biography is that it restores Sheridan to human size and brings him to life again."—London Times. Two volumes. Illustrated. $7.50 net. Postage 40 cente Recollections of Washington Gladden “There is much that is entertaining as well as instructive—in the finest sense of the word—in these reminiscences It bears from cover to cover the stamp of a noble individuality.” . . Providence Journal. With frontispiece. $2.00 net. Postage 15 cents Diplomatic Memoirs. By John W. Foster “A book containing much interesting and valuable information.”—Chicago Tribune. “Of unusual value to the diplo- mat, the student of political and social conditions and the reader of American history,”"—Richmond Times-Dispatch. Two volumes. Illustrated. $6.00 net. Postage 40 cents. Emerson’s Journals Now Published for the First Time These journals will make an important addition to American literature. The first two volumes now ready cover the years 1820-1829. “Contain the beginnings of some of the Concord sage's finest thoughts.”—Chicago Tribune. . Illustrated. Each $1.75 net. Postage 13 cents The Life and Letters of Josiah Dwight Whitney By EDWIN T. BREWSTER. “One of the most interesting and valuable biographies of the year.”—Springficld Repub- lican. Professor Whitney probably did more than any other one man toward the development of the mineralogical resources of the United States. Illustrated. $2.00 ne?. Postage 20 cents. Boston HOUCHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY _ new York

Page 2

The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. the New York City Post Office as second-class mail matter.) [Batered at The Nation \s published end owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor Three dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Canada 43.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union £4.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. QO eee 587 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Working Up Patriotism ..... -+. 590 Free Trade and British Shipping | sees 590 More News from the Pole ....... . 591 Harvard and the Elective System. . 592 The Gay Science of peneyptorsits - 593 Games and Talk ...... e+e 598 SPECIAL ARTICLES: Recent French History . 594 CORRESPONDENCB: The Oracle of Love in the Twelfth Chapter of “La Vita Nuova’ : French Accents on Froper Nouns Turner and Claude Lorrain Names in “The Southerner” LITERATUR! Boones fer Children, Fh. cccccccccvccece The Last Days of Papal Rome ......... Priscilla of the Good Intent ........ Posson Jone’ and Pére Raphaél ...... ¢ Aunt Amity’s Silver Wedding, and -_— a The Wiving of Lance Cleaverage pes Gi Ge wacovnscencenceseetaus The Exile of St. Helena “The Last Phase in Fact and Fiction.—Napo- leon's Marshals esbenadeses 'S CO rr earerr ty ee Relics and Memorials of London City The Private Palaces of London, Past and Present .. non veséetbaves Onn Drei Jahrhunderte deutschen Lebens in Amerika 60 - POUL écdincecdbiesteeiesebcancee ieee 603 SCIENCE: The Place of Animals in Human Ge ~©§«=—§>.s-. srs batbaaberbélelan teen 605 DRAMA: The Piper . 606 Music: Stories from the Operas A Guide ta Modern Opera -+» 506 ART: National Academy Pictures . 607 FINANCE: Plans for the Government Finances. 609 Books or THE WEEK.. . 611 ***Qoples of The Nation may be procured io Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Hrown, Trafaicir Square, Charing Cross The N ation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2320 Educational. for bu HARLAN r. "FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N.Y. | HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Evaurert 0. Fisx & fo, & Proprietors. 2A Park 8 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid. inseasaiie. peapolis 208 Mich. Ave.. Chicago 2925 ee 318 Peston Bid.’ Spokane S144 Guurteck Ave Berkeles L n ac ve., e send to any address above for Agency Manual. | A HARVARD PROFESSOR with twenty-five years’ experience as a teacher in high school and university, will take complete charge of two or three boys, preparing them for college or otherwise aiding them in their linguistic and scientific education. Address W. L., Care of the Nation. LEWIS'S PUPIL’S NOTEBOOK AND STUDY OUTLINE IN ORIENTAL AND GREEK HISTORY 25 cents A helpful and ear book, leading the pupil to think for him- self, to co-ordinate and subordinate properly the various events, and to study and read on collateral topics. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston FUNGOUS DISEASES OF PLANTS By Benjamin M. Duggar. N. Y. State College of Agriculture, Cornell University. Price $2.00. text or reference book to be published on a subject which is now as- suming the greatest importance. Adopted in advance of publication for use in the University of Vermont, t New Hampshire Agricultural Experiment Station of New Hampshire College, and the Agri- cultural Experiment Station of the Univer- sity of Nebraska. GINN AND COMPANY The first - Introduction to Economics By Alvin 8. Johnson, Ph.D., Professor in University of Texas and Lecturer in University of Chicago. Balances theory with practice; full of con- temporary interest and value; for student and citizen. 416 pages. $1.50. Db. C. HEATH & CO., BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO BOOK S—All out of print books supplied, o matter on what subject; write me, stating bovk- wanted; I can get you any book ever published when In England, call and inspect my stock o' 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP Joba Bright St., Birmingham, England. INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS WHY WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! By GRORGE L. WALTON,M.D. Cloth, $1 net, each B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia, MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. MARX’S CAPITAL, }°*. CHARLES H. KERR & COMPANY. s be.06 OLIVER DITSON Co., Ditson Bidg., Boston, Mass. Visitors in New York are invited to examine the resources of our retail store. Here will be found a large stock of current and standard | works from American and foreign presses. Teachers or students prepar- ing for courses of readingwill find an excellent choice of moderate-priced editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE |SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- | logues. E. P. DUTTON & CO., 31 West 234 Street, New York. Are You Plus or Minus ? Answer after —a. the little book whose fame is spreading like wild-fire: SELF-MEASUREMENT A Scale of Human Values, with Directions for Personal Application. By WILLIAM DE WITT HYDE, President of yee College. All bookstores, 50c. + by pen, Se B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher: New York. Do you know theBeacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 cents net: by mali, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. Smell, Mayserdé & Co.. 31 Beacon St., Boston “TONO- BUNGAY” ANNE OF AVONLEA SEQUEL TO “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES.” “THE RELIGION rm FUTURE” By CHARLES W. ELIOT, and other Ce Uterature sent free on request. Address Box Barnstable Bend for Catalogwe, TAUCHNITZ | FOREIGN schoennor sooxco. "gp ITISH | BOOKS sieron"ase’ AUTHORS | A Good Christmas Gift A YEAR’S Siar’ The Nation

Page 3

— — pute Dec. 16 1909] The Nation.

RECENT PUBLICATIONS OF “sea D, APPLETON AND COMPANY ““<c,*

PSYCHOLOGY AND THE TEACHER By HUGO MUNSTERBERG, Ph.D., M.D., LL.D. Professor of Psychology at Harvard University. This book aims to take up the study of the school child, and to present the modern psychology of imitation, sug- gestion, memory, attention, emotion, intellect, fatigue, and so on. Still further, it aims to be of practical use in the choosing of subjects, and for the teaching of all studies, elementary and higher, for both zxsthetic and manual educa- tion. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net.

The New North Girl and Woman By AGNES DEANS CAMERON. The travels of two women down the Mackenzie River, from Athabasca Landing in Alberta Canada, to the Arctic Ocean and By CAROLINE LATIMER, M.D., M.A., formerly in- structor in Biology, Women’s College, Baltimore, Md. A sane, wholesome, optimistic text-book for the guid- back by the Peace River. 100 illustrations from photographs, 8vo, cloth, $3.00 net. Romanticism and the Romantic School in Germany ance of mothers and daughters. 12mo, cloth, $2.00 net. The History of French Literature By ANNIE LEMP KONTA. Mrs. Konta takes up the By ROBERT M. WERNAER, Ph.D., formerly lectur- er at Harvard University An historical exposition and a comprehensive study of the writings of the Romantic School ir Germany. 8vo, cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net. discussion of French literature chronologically from the oath of Strasburg to the publication of Rostand’s “Chantecler.” 8vo, cloth, gilt top, uncut edges, $2.50 net. —

FRANCIS JOSEPH AND HIS TIMES By The Rt. Hon. SIR HORACE RUMBOLD For many years British Ambassador to the Emperor of Austria A very important contribution to the political history of Western Europe during the oth century, written by a man probably more conversant with the subject than any other English-speaking person alive Illustrated with a portrait and 16 other sumptuous pictures. Demy 8vo, cloth, $4.00 net.

Florence Nightingale Louisa May Alcott By LAURA E. RICHARDS. While the name of “The Angel of the Crimea” is a household word, the pre- cise nature and scope of her work, and the difficulties and discouragement under which it was accomplished, are unknown to many children of the present genera- tion. All this is here beautifully and completely re- lated by a famous writer whose own father was in By BELLE MOSES. An admirable story of the child hood and womanhood of the celebrated author of “Lit- tle Women,” told especially for girl readers. Miss Moses has excellently caught the beautiful home spirit of the Alcotts’ family circle, and this biography is not only charmingly written but is in every way an au- thoritative account of the interesting life of Miss Al-

cott and the New England scenes in which her days part responsible for confirming Miss Nightingale in were spent. Illustrated, 12mo, cloth, $1.25 net. her determination to devote her life to nursing. Illustrated, 12mo, cloth, $1.25 net. The Junior Republic: Its History and Ideals By WILLIAM R. GEORGE. The founder of the Ju- nior Republic tells of the inception of the idea, the devel- opment of the Republic, and its successful fulfilment. Illustrated, t2mo, cloth, $1.50 net. Army Letters from an Officer’s Wife By FRANCES M.A. ROE. An excellent record of the daily and eventful life of the wife of an army officer in the far west thirty years ago. Many il'ustrations, 12mo, cloth, $2.00 net.

WOMEN IN INDUSTRY By EDITH ABBOTT, Ph.D. University of Chicago. The author traces the growth and development of the employment of women from the earliest periods through the establishment of the factory system, and down to the present day. She deals at length with women in all the various trades, and discusses the problem of their wages and of the present status of the working woman. Large 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net.

Page 4

The Natio n. [ Vol. 89, No. 2320 vn eet“) The Macmillan Holiday Books | “ise sure de SS Van Dyke’s handsome volume The New New York Illustrated by JOSEPH PENNELL. An illuminating book even to those most familiar with the city; the most interesting of the sea- son's beautiful illustrated books. Attractively bound and boxed Dr. Wilfred T. Grenfell’s Labrador The Country and the People The whole b ok is full of the attraction of Dr. Grenfell’s contagious conviction that Labrador tremendously interesting Illustrated from photographs in his collection William E. Carson’s Mexico The Wonderland of the South An exceptionally readable book about this cur- ious, many sided bright-colored land, just now the subject of so much discussion. Jacob A. Riis's The Old Town It was a happy thought to write of the quaint Danish town; there is an unescapable charm in even reading of its high-pitched red roofs, of the black daws circling the grey domkirke, and of the old, old customs of its kindly folk, Mrs. Roger A. Pryor’s My Day Reminiscences of a Long Life The whole atmosphere of the book is as charm- ing as it is unusual Illustrated with portraits, etc. Dr. Ernest F. Henderson’s readadie A Lady of the Old Regime Altogether the best life of the famous “Madame,” sister-in-law of Louis XIV, based on her own racy letters. Illustrated from prints, etc. Mr. Henry E. Krehbiel’s »ew doox A Book of Operas Each of his chapters so deals with the story, music and presentation of a given opera as to make the book indispensable to opera-goers. The French Pastellists of the Eighteenth Century Their Lives, their Times and their Art, and their Significance By HALDANE MACFALL. The illustrations are wonderful reproductions of the delicate medium of the originals. Poems By Percy MacKaye Containing the ballad “Ticonderoga” and other recent poems by the author of “The Canterbury Pilgrim,” ete. Justice Wendell P. Stafford’s Dorian Days A volume of graceful verse, classical in spirit and theme, and of notable beauty. A. J. Church’s The Faery Queen for Boys and Girls gives them the tales from Spenser as he has al- ready given them the Iliad and Odyssey of Hlomer Iiluatrated in colors. Miss Jessie H. Bancroft’s Games for the Playground, Home and School Wherever any group of old or young seeks to join in social play the book is invaluable. 124 illus., $4.00 net; postpaid, $4.22. Cloth, illua., $2.25 net; postpaid, 2.39. Cloth, illua., $2.25 net; postpaid, $2.39. Cloth, illus., $2.00 net ; postpaid, $2.14. Cloth, $2.25 net; postpaid, $2.9. Cloth, $2.50 net; postpaid, $2.67. Cloth, illus. $1.75 net; postpaid, $1.77. Demy qto, $10.50 net ; 40 illua. in colora. Cloth, $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.34. Cloth, $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.32. Cloth, iliua., $1.50. Oloth, illua.,~ $1.60 net; poatpaid, $1.67. * Dr. Sven Hedin’s fascinating book Trans-Himalaya Discoveries and Adventures in Tibet Two vols., A marvellous record of perilous adventures, of #llus., the curious customs of a practically unknown 47.50 net; land, and of valuable discoveries. With 388 illus- carriage trations, eight plates in colors and ten maps. extra. Col. J. H. Patterson’s most interesting book In the Grip of the Nyika Cloth, By the author of that absorbing account of fight- iilus., : ing lions while running a railroad line through #2-90 ae Eastern Africa, entitled, “The Man-Eaters of ?08tpaid, Tsavo.” $2.15. Dr. James Ford Rhodes’s new votume bi . . ‘oth, Historical Essays 8vo, An exceptionally interesting discussion by a on - master historian of his own field in literature > , and of other eminent writers in it. 40. Mr. Herbert Croly’s incisive new book The Promise of American Life Cloth. Is a striking analysis of the forces influencing #2.00 net; our development, both material and personal. Postpaid, A book of permanent importance. $2.14. Dr. Percival Lowell’s new book The Evolution of Worlds‘ Cloth There is fascination to the point of awe in fol- $2.50 net; lowing this account of life history of worlds. postpaid, By the author of “Mars and Its Canals,” etc. $2.68. Miss E. B. Dewin ’s remarkable novel Other People’s Houses Second A well-known critic naming the four best novels edition, of the year included this—the only one of the cloth, four by an American writer. $1.50. Miss Zona Gale’s stories of youth Friendship Village Love Stories By the author of “The Loves of Pelleas and Cloth, Etarre,” and “Friendship Village.” $1.50. Mr. Charles Major’s A Gentle Knight of Old Brandenburg Niue. By the author of “When Knighthood Was in cloth, Flower,” “Dorothy Vernon of Haddon Hall,” etc. $7.50. Mr. F. Marion Crawford’s iast novei Stradella (/iustratea) Is one of his best stories of his favorite field— Cloth, an old Italian romance. $1.50. ’ Cloth, Dr. Lyman Abbott’s TheTemple §/9:',:: is an inspiriting book closely related to his “The postpaid, Other Room” and “The Great Companion.” $1.35. Prof. F.G. Peabody in The wis Approach to the Social Question $1.25; provides an uncommonly interesting introduction postpaid, to social ethics. $1.25. E. V. Lucas’s Some Friends of Mine ¢;o;,, Is a companion to “The Ladies’ Pageant,” be- $1.25 net; ing “a rally of men” of all types and from postpaid, literatures. $1.35. vio sr’ Hamilton W. Mabie’s A book to be enclosed with every Christmas hamper, so rich is it in all the true old associations of the season. decorative drawings, reproductions from famous paintings, and a simply ideal introductory essay. The Book of Christmas jini Yin With

Page 5

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 16, 1909.

The Week. Secretary MacVeagh was certain to be attacked by the straiter—not exclud- ing the crookeder—sect of Republicans, and rumors of the coming fray are al- ready heard in Washington. The Sec- retary’s low-tariff speech at Boston is his latest offence. Just fancy having a man in a Republican Cabinet who does not believe that the Payne tariff is a blessed finality! This is sad enough, but Mr. MacVeagh goes from bad tariff doctrine to worse principles of admin- istration. Senators grow purple with rage as they say to each other: “Why, the man is trying to run the Treasury just as if it were a first-class business house!” He is making his own appoint- ments, and making them, what is more, on the ground of efficiency, and with cool disregard of the politicians. The grossest outrage of which he has been guilty consists in selecting an Assistant Secretary who comes from Boston, and in neither consulting nor notifying the Massachusetts Senators. This is almost enough to make Lodge lose faith in re- publican institutions—of which, natur- ally, he reckons his discredited State machine a necessary part. We presume that the fight on Secretary MacVeagh will not be so open or ferocious as some of the Washington correspondents are predicting, but the mere threat of it sho.vs what a red rag to the standpat- ters is any programme of reform.

Not long ago, an Ohio Democratic <ommitteeman wailed in this city over the lost opportunities of Gov. Harmon. With Republicans still in appointive of- fices all over the State, and hungry poli- ticlans of his own party unfed, what hope could there be for Democrats in the elections of next year, or what chance that he could control the delega- tion of Ohio in the next national con- vention? But the people of Ohio have just found out how their Governor has been using his time. The grafters who have been filling their purses and pay- ing political debts through the manipu- lation of State funds have discovered in Gov. Harmon an official whom thev can neither deceive nor frighten. He now arguments on the other side ¢ has in his office safe incriminating doc- uments which legislative committees had been powerless to unearth, show- ing the loan of State funds carried on the books as in the vaults of the treas- urer’s office, the payment of private commissions to officials purchasing sup- plies for the State, and other frauds upon the people. No Ohio Republican with a reputation to preserve is any longer scoffing at the demand for acom- plete exposure of recent Republican Ad- ministrations. To the State against Gov. Harmon in 1910 would be carry no easy task under the best circum- stances, but to go into the campaign un- der the burden either of a denial of the frauds which he has established, or of an attempt to impede further disclo- sures, would mean the sure sacrifice of Republican hopes in Ohio for years to come.

Attorney-General Wickersham’s speech at the Pennsylvania Society’s dinner, in New York Saturday night, contained this interesting passage: As the statutes of the United States vest in him complete control over all such prosecution, he is constantly importuned to interfere with indictments or prosecu- tions, particularly in cases where proceed- ings are brought or threatened against per- sons of high social standing or of con- spicuous political or business position That the prosecution of crime cannot b» properly influenced by considerations of’ the wealth or position of the offender is of course, axiomatic. Mr. Wickersham’s reference to the re- quests to keep his hands off, because of the social or political position of the parties concerned, piques curiosity. Which Trust has indulged in “importu- nity” on this broad ground? The Attor- ney-General may have had the Sugar Trust in mind; or he may have been dropping a quiet hint to certain other projected combinations of which the plans were awkwardly upset by last month’s Circuit Court decision, and which may have been fishing for assur- ances of immunity from interference, if they go ahead with their undertak- ings. To describe the argument for ignoring such appeals as “axiomatic” ts to put the case, from the Department's point of view, about as plainly as cou/d be done. It means that there are no ~The Nation. o which intelligent men will listen. Last Friday's estimate on the cotton crop of 1909 by the Department of Ag- was a somewhat startling 10,088,- to the riculture surprise. The figure reported, 000 bales, was virtually down level of the crop of 1903, which was it- self inadequate for the spinning trade's needs of that period—this in face of the fact that the estimated “world’s annual requirements” of American cotton are 2,000,000 Not only was this esti- to-day nearly bales larger than in 1903. mate lower by haif a million to a mil- lion bales than had been generally ex- pected, but it was a quarter of a mil- lion bales below the persona! estimates ‘previously given out by the leaders in the cotton market's “bull speculation,” who had every motive to spread belief But hard- ly less surprising than the estimate it- in the lowest possible figure. self was the cotton market's reception of it. ton had been selling close to 15 cents a When the estimate appeared, cot- pound, and speculators had been excit- edly predicting 17 to 20 cents. But in- stead of rushing up sensationally on the after a brief advance on Friday, actually declined next day. This could hardly be inter- preted except as meaning, first, that the news, the cotton market, abnormally high existing price had “‘dis- counted” very much in the way of low estimates, and, secondly, that the Govy- ernment’s figures were distrusted

There is some reason for distrusting them—quite apart from the fact that they fall so far below virtually every other forecast. For one thing, the Ag- ricultural Department almost invariably underestimates a cotton crop, and its errors have of late years been very large. Its estimate of last December ran a million bales below the subse- quently ascertained crop; in 1906 it was also a million bales below the facts; in 1904, a million and a half; in 1901, a million. In 1907 and 1903 its guess was fairly accurate, but those were conspicuous exceptions. In the present instance, there is reason to look skeptically at the Government figures on other grounds, particularly because of the small yield which it allots to cot-

Page 6

nh. 5 88 The Natio [ Vol. 89, No. 2320 seaboard, influ- ton States on the Atlantic might be connected with the killing of two white women and with the mortal injury to a third. The injured woman lived long enough to accuse her own husband of the crime and the evidence against him is multiplying. This, we must say, leaves the Savannah officers of the law in a singularly unfortunate position. If colored persons had in the courts there the standing to which they are entitled, there would be many suits for illegal arrest and imprisonment of innocent persons. But being only “nig- gers,” the injured know full well that this redress is denied them; they can take satisfaction only in the fact that they are still unlynched and that the superior race is itself indicted., where the damaging weather ences which impaired the crop of the Gulf States and the Mississippi Valley did not prevail at all. That the crop as a whole is actually short, nobody doubts; and the state of the cotton trade is difficult enough without any over- calculations. emphasizing of gloomy Had the stock of cotton on hand at the opening of the season been so low as it was in 1903, and had foreign produc- ers, such as Egypt and India, done as conditions poorly this year as then, would be disastrous. Fortunately, sup- plies of old cotton were this year near- ly a million bales above those of 1903, and foreign crops appear to have turned out exceptionally well. The necessity of a law making it a criminal offence, subject to heavy pen- alty, for the driver of an automobile to run away after knocking down a hu- man being is once more brought out by a distressing occurrence, when a faith- ful trolley switchman, who had been in the employ of the Brooklyn company for thirty-five years, was killed at his post of duty. The chauffeurs, fortunately in this case, and thanks to the energy of the police force, have been caught; and their explanation, so far as the run- ning away is concerned, is that they were too frightened to stop. That is just where a proper law in the case would come in; it would make them too | frightened to run away. It should pro- vide a punishment of a long term of imprisonment for that act taken in it- self, and irrespective of the seriousness James J. Hill’s continued warnings about our failing food supply are really a plea for scientific farming. Inteusive culture and the utilization of every ounce of energy stored up in food, must make up for the increasing pressure of population and the diminishing areas of cheap and unoccupied land. ‘This subject was touched upon in the presi- dential address delivered before the Society of Animal Nutrition at Chi- cago last month, and just printed in the last number of A strong point was made of closer attention to what may be called the by-products of the Just as the miner seeks to work low-grade ore, so will the farmer of the future endeavor to prevent the waste of “available energy contained in oat hulls, corn cobs, and the like.” It | Science. farm. is somewhat anomalous to have such of the injury inflicted on the victim. minor savings urged upon us at the Then there would be some hope that very time when, as the President as- what common decency does not effect sures us, the country is in a “high state would be accomplished by fear of con- of prosperity.” But the true moral is sequences. Of course, this is not all that needs to be done. Real punish- ment for violation of the speed laws is imperatively demanded; and _ there must be more effective regulations to enable people to identify swiftly-mov- | ing automobiles, especially at night. that upon which Mr. Hill insists, name- ly, that no prosperity can long endure which depends upon exhausting the soil and ignoring the applica((ons of science to agriculture. It has for years been the rule in the event of a crime in certain portions of the South, to arrest the nearest ne- groes, and examine them afterward, if they are not previously lynched. But we do not recall, outside of Russia or Turkey, any happening similar to that Savannah, where two hundred ne- Cornell's ultimatum to the football magnates that the game must be re- formed or abolished, coming as it does on top of a similar decision by the twelve Eastern Jesuit colleges, must send cold shivers down their spines. Never before has the opposition to the game been so earnest, so determined. | The old absurd theories that this is not in groes have been rounded up and placed in jail merely on suspicion that they , | peace prize, ‘a matter for faculties and presidents to meddle with; that a college could not afford to do away with football for fear of driving its students elsewhere; that the risks of football enhance its value and are inseparable from any manly sport, have entirely lost their utility in misleading the public. Cor- nell, like the rest of the university world, has seen Columpia flourish with- out football. Its faculty is, moreover, wise enough to see that, bad as the evils on the playing fields are, they are no worse than the physical and men- tal idleness among the students who look on, and the false standards of what is really worth while set up among the undergraduates. The Jesuit | colleges have at last found their voices ‘to denounce the recruiting of students |expressly for athletic purposes, and the other evils of professionalism. They could have pointed them out years ago. But we who have so long called for this. uprising against football would not now lament the delay. We must, however, point out that what we are really wit- nessing is the long-desired awakening, not so much of the public as of the col- legiate governing bodies. It is gratifying to find that in the Nobel prize distribution for 1909, the names of people well-off in worldly goods are not over-plenty. William Mar- coni, who gets half the physics prize, could probably get along without the twenty thousand dollars, and the Baron d’Estournelles de Constant, who re ceives, and deservedly receives, the is described as fond of yachting and automobiling. The other beneficiaries are two German professors, a Swiss professor, and a Swedish au- thoress, none of whom is apt to be roll- ing in wealth even when the persons in. question are of such international re- pute as Wilhelm Ostwald, or of such wide European fame as Selma Lagerléf. The latter is the third woman to receive: the Nobel prize since its foundation. Bertha von Suttner won the peace prize a few years ago, with her anti-militarist novel, and Mme. Curie shared the annual physics prize with her husband and Pro- fessor Becquerel. To Selma Lagerlif, who is known in this country by a vol- ume or two of short stories, the prize for idealism in literature goes more appro- priately, perhaps, than to some of the- men of far greater reputation upon

Page 7

Dec. 16, 1909 whom it has been bestowed, Kipling or Sienkiewicz, for instance. Her studies of peasant life in her own country have the glow of patriotism and piety which seems essential to give a writer national rank. By the will of the late Francis Lath- rop, the Metropolitan Museum’ gains conditionally a new department. His Japanese prints and wood-block books were collected long before the present rise in prices, but he never hesitated to replace a fair by a better example, nor to pay lavishly to fill a gap. This artist- collector combined, as few amateurs of our time, studious habits with instinc- tive taste. Thus his collections, in what- ever field—Italian painting, Moorish pottery, or objects of Far Eastern art— were finely selected and contain a mini- mum of dross. A man of retiring dis- pesition and averse from all forms of display and self-advertisement, the rich- | ness of his accumulations will doubtless surprise even his associates. The be- quest to the Metropolitan is made sub- ject to certain annuities, which, one may estimate, would be more than covered by the annual appreciation of the value ot the collections. Mr. Lathrop also set a good example by leaving a collection which well deserved separate exhibi- tion absolutely at the disposal of the Museum authorities. But here his dili- gence will frustrate his modesty, for as long as students seek Japanese books and prints at the Metropolitan Museum they will speak of the Lathrop collec- tion. Mr. Asquith’s Albert Hall speech is a ringing manifesto of the Liberal Party’s rights and purposes. It does not err on the ground of timidity. It does not hesi- tate, for instance, to come out strongly for self-government for Ireland. It dis- claims any intention to do away with the House of Lords, but makes it very plain that its survival is to be condition- ed on repentance and good behavior. The supremacy of the Commons is no longer to be left to the uncertainties of custom and precedent, but will be written down in black and white into an act of Par- liament. The Liberal Premier's speech contains the ready answer to Mr. Bal- four’s argument that such action as the Lords have taken on the budget is the nation’s only resource against the tvran- nies of an unbridled Lower House Mr. The Nation. Asquith asks that the life of a single Parliament be restricted to five or even four years. A House of Commons that runs wildly counter to the will of the people can thus be brought to speedy ac- count. It remains for the Liberal ora- tors to drive home the point Mr. As- quith insisted on Monday night, that under present circumstances no Literal Minister can assume the burdens of government without assurance that his labors will not be nullified by the Lords. There is a beautifully mathematical simplicity that is almost un-English about the first forecasts of the kind of tariff the British Unionist party will enact, if it is successful in next month's elections. All imports not regarded as raw materials will be moderately taxed —a 5 per cent. duty on partly manu- factured goods, a 10 per cent. duty on goods in a more advanced stage of com- pletion, a 15 per cent. duty on com- pletely manufactured goods. Now we come to specific instances. Foreign wheat will pay a duty of two shillings a quar- ter or about six cents a bushel; from which we gather that wheat under the new tariff dispensation will take on the nature of a partly manufactured com- modity. Other imports, partly or com- pletely manufactured, that will pay duty, are flour, bacon, and maize. Inasmuch as, under the present system, tea, cof- tee, sugar, tobacco, dried fruits, and wine already pay a tax, it is quite ap- parent how tariff reform is going to put more bread and meat into the mouth of the British workingman. The way of all tariffs is uniform. They set out to cre- ate a dozen blessings and do away with a dozen evils, and their end is always that the daily pursuit of bread and meat and clothes for the masses of the people grows arduous to the point where the cry for relief can no longer be stilled— as in “protected” Germany, or in “pro- tected” America. The first speech of the new German Chancellor in the Reichstag bore out the indications of h's policy that he had privately intimated. Herr Bethmann- Hollweg announced tha. he would not attempt government by party—meaning, of course, groups of parties. He declar- ed that the Empire needed steady and consistent policies which would be im- possible if the Government had al! the 589 while to be making arrangements with shifting parties in order to get its meas- ures adopted. This must not be taken as too serious an assertion of absolutism on the part of the Kaiser and his Min- isters. It is, indeed, a definite turn- ing away from the bDiloc strategy of Von Bilow, but the practical question re mains, “How is the Government to get its majority in the Reichstag?” We are not speaking now of a vote of confi- dence or of a responsible Ministry—both as yet out of the question in Germany ——but of obtaining supplies. Neither its taxation nor other schemes can the Government carry without somehow ral- lying a majority of the Deputies; and when the time comes to do it, we shall probably find the new Chancellor forced to adopt the party bargain- ing from which not even Bismarck could escape. The latest step in the Russian Gov- ernment’s campaign against Finland is the appointment of the Grand Duke Nicholas, one of the firmest pillars of Russian reaction, to the supreme control over affairs in that land. Under him will be the governor-general and the crowd of military officials whom the Czar’s Government has foisted upon the people of the Grand-Duchy precisely as in Von Plehve’s day six years ago. The conflict has been raging for some time, and the Finns have shown their usual courage and resourcefulness. ‘Their diets have been dissolved three times in four years; their Senates have re- signed rather than play into the hands of Russia, and it may even be that in the last resort the people will venture to try their strength against the Cossacks. At the same time, the Government at St. Petersburg, flushed by its success in stifling a revolution and taming a Par- liament, is pretty sure to go to ex- tremes. The right of the Czar’s Cab inet to legislate on matters of common interest to Russia and Finland is now to be extended so as to include not only the army, posts and railways, and cus- toms, but the maintenance of public or- der, the regulation of judicial proced- ure, and all legislation affecting the rights of association, freedom of the press, and public meeting. Russian “or- der” and “freedom of speech” for Fin- land would mean the extinction of the last spark of liberty in the Czar's domains. 1

Page 8

OVO WORKING UP PATRIOTISM. The American people, said Senator Rayner in his speech in the Senate last yet of the Monday, “have not fully absorbed the significance” Nicaraguan im- broglio. But they are in a fair way todo The stu very proposals of the Maryland Senator will enlighten them. When Representative Sulzer rose in the House to demand that President Taft “arrest” President Zelaya and try him for mur- der, most people only laughed. That was merely one of the amusing ways of the “peepul's” William. But Senator Rayner is a real lawyer, with a reputa- tion to sustain. Yet he commits him- self to doctrines and policies fully as wild He and as Sulzer's. would have Con- authorize virtually direct Taft all necessary apprehension” of Zelaya, for the mur- American citizens. And this is put forward in the name of the well- of justice and the gress President to “take steps for the and to “bring him to trial” der of two settled principles established canons of international law! We to answer the man of Senator Ray- can tie himself up to The charitable that learning about Zelaya’s outrages hath made him mad. Mr. Rayner has made himself known as a man of warm hu- His arraignment of cannot pretend question how a standing amazing doctrines. ner's such most supposition is much mane sympathies. Zelaya sounds like an expression of sincere indignation. And it may be granted that the Nicaraguan dictator can scarcely painted in colors too black. From all the evidence available, he seems indeed to have run a career of unspeakable oppression and cruelty. But even if we concede his lawlessness and villany to be worse than King Bomba's, the fact remains that he is a foreigner entirely outside the criminal jurisdiction of the United States, and, moreover, is the de facto chief of state of a neighboring and friendly republic. To punish his disregard of law, are we ourselves going to fling legal procedure to the winds? To show our detestation of his flouting of the rights of our citl- zene under international law, are we to deny that his country have rights under the law of nations? Sen- ator Rayner promised to produce later the precedents for the absurd course which he war on Nicaragua which is yet not to be war. We shall await his precedents with curtosity, but be he and advocates ‘The Nation. fear that the- fendesieakil cihanitian’ underlying them will be found io be that the people and government of Nica- ragua have no rights which w2 are bound to respect. What is most disquieting and even alarming about all this is the evidence it yields that an attempt is to be made to work Americans into a “patriotic” frenzy over Nicaragua. They are told that they have not yet perceived the full “significance” of the affair. So we have an agitation stirred up in Con- gress and the press. The aim seems to be so to inflame public sentiment that unwise and extreme and illegal meas- ures may be condoned if not demanded. Thus far, the country has not been ex- cited about the matter. The general opinion tras not yet gone beyond believ- ing that Zelaya is a great criminal, that conditions in Nicaragua are deplorable, and that our Government ought to see that the rights of Americans in that country are upheld. But we see what happens when a thing of this kind is let loose with clamorous publicity. The State Department does well to take a firm stand for what it believes to be the due protection of Americans abroad, but when its vigorous language is at once given to the press, along with its denunciations of a foreign ruler, a flame is kindled which may easily grow into a conflagration. Irresponsible poli- ticlans instantly throw on fresh fuel; and sensational newspapers try to flog the people into hysteria. No prudent statesman will fail to reckon with this new danger of American inflammabil- ity. ster’s day to send and publish a dis- patch, as he did in the Koszta case, in which, as he complacently wrote to a/| friend, he “let the eagle scream” a lit- tle; change since then. We have had the war about Cuba, for one thing, brought on by methods of political chicane and | newspaper excitement undreamed of by Webster. And this is what so alarms the | people of South and Central America, as we see their concern reflected in dis- patches to foreign newspapers. It is none of Senator Rayner’s “precedents” that they dread, but the precedent of the Spanish war, when Americans were gradually and artfully whipped into a delirium. A repetition of that mania ts what some are to-day trying to force upon us It was comparatively safe in Web- but there has been an encrmous | Hl ‘{Vol. 89, No. 2320 We are told that it is a patriotic ety to fall into a passion over the out- rages in Nicaragua, and to resolve to go down there and “clean things up.” Well, we also believe in patriotic fer- vor, but we would have it directea to the true objects of national pride. We have no objection to people getting ex- cited in demanding of the Administra- tion that it shall not get so excited as to lose its head and do an act of folly and injustice. Let there be as flaming a zeal as you please, but let it be a zeal for the real national dignity and for international fair dealing. Let the pub- lic be heated in calling upon the Gov- We do not yet Until we do, we cannot decide what law or policy we ought to apply to them. Under these circumstances, the truest patriot is he who will burn with indignation at the suggestion that the nation should do a reckless and illegal thing in the name of patriotism. ernment to keep cool. know all the facts. FREE TRADE AND BRITISH SHIP. PING Those advocates of ship subsidies who are fond of asserting, in a conveniently broad and general way, that the great shipping business of Great Britain is maintained by a system of subsidies /might profit by a discussion which ap- pears in a Liverpool paper. The discus- ‘sion turns on the probable effect of the protectionist proposals known by the name of “tariff reform” upon the prosperity of the shipping business; and the case is stated chiefiv in the words of Mr. Charles’ Booth, chairman of the Liverpool Steamship Owners’ Association, himself one of the leading shipowners of Liverpool and 'a recognized authority on the whole sub- ‘ject. As Mr. Booth’s statement was cer- |tainly not intended for American con- ‘sumption, it is interesting to observe that there is only a single passing refer- }ence—and that in a few words—to the | subject of subsidies. From this fact alone ‘it might be inferred that British ship- ping prosperity does not, as a rule, rest in any way upon the support of Gov- ernment gratuities; but when it is seen what the reference is, a stronger infer- ‘ence may be made. This is the passage in which it occurs: Tariff reform would increase the cost of building, equipment, and repairs; it would swell working expenses; it would diminish cargoes both out and home; and it would

Page 9

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nation. 591 reduce freights. The cumulative effect of the increased charges and expenses on the one side, and of diminished earnings on the other, would be simply disastrous. Ship- owners generally admit this. Those who support tariff reform as a policy hope to profit by a system of bounties. Nobody would thus incidentally speak of people “hoping to profit by a system of bounties,” if a system of bounties were already in operation in the busi- mess he was talking about, and of which he is one of the leading representatives. Many persons will find this little side- remark more convincing than elaborate citations of statistics. The note of the whole discussion is the crucial importance of the advantages that free trade has given to the British shipping business. All that Mr. Booth and his associates in that great interest in Liverpool ask for is a continuance of free access to the best opportunities that the world affords. The best ships, bought at the lowest prices—that is the explanation, according to Mr. Booth, of the ability of British shipowners to keep a preponderant share of the world’s carrying trade. says Mr. Booth, “the cheapest ships in the world. Even Germany, with considerably cheaper labor, cannot beat us here. The difference in first cost between a ship built in Great Britain and a ship of similar tonnage, material, and equipment built in the United States is anything from 30 to 460 per cent. The importance of this ad- vantage can hardly be exaggerated.” The competitor, he points out, who has to bear the burden of an unnecessarily ex- pensive ship, is handicapped not only by the greater amount consequently re- quired to pay interest on the capital, but also by a proportional increase in the allowance that must be made for de- preciation and in insurance charges. The failure of American efforts to re- “We build,” | | leave nothing to be desired. | that the difference in the cost of ships by the practice of “the Steel Trust and other suppliers of material for ship- building of selling dear at home and cheap abroad.” He does not at all relish the prospect of this charming device be- ing introduced into England, as it might be if the Chamberlainite proposals were adopted. Evidently there is still a good deal of toughness in the English hold on free-trade principles, and it will take some work yet to loosen their grip on the minds of men of the Booth stamp. To hold your own against competitors by being able to deliver the goods at a lower price and still make a reasonable profit—that isthe genuinely British way of looking at the matter. To hold your own against competitors by ruling them out at home and making an exorbitant profit, and underselling them abroad by giving foreigners better terms than your own countrymen—that is the modern protectionist idea. Before the people of the United States will add on to this scheme the additional feature of direct bounties out of the national treasury, they will wish to know a thing or two. And among other things, they will prob- | ably wish to know whether it wouldn't be well to try the plan of simply giving our shipowners a chance to get their ships at a fair price, before entering on a subsidy policy which is sure to bring with it demoralizing consequences. MORE NEWS FROM THE POLE. Whatever may be the case as regards history in general, no one can deny that in the affaire Cook history is repeating itself with a rapidity and exactness that One im- probability doth tread upon another's heel, so fast they follow. Moreover, they keep coming in pairs, so prettily match- ed that, like the spellings of Tony Wel- vive shipbuilding and shipowning for | jor’ name, a choice between them is the foreign carrying trade he ascribes to our protectionist policy; while Ger- many’s phenomenal advance in the game line, in spite of her general pro- tectionist system, is explained by the fact that an exemption from the bur- den of that system has been made in favor both of shipbuilders and ship- owners, who have been enjoying all the benefits of free trade. Another tender spot in the protection- ist system in this country is incidental- ly touched by Mr. Booth, when he says ' sented? ‘left to the taste and fancy of each indi- vidual. The first story of Cook’s conquest of the Pole was improbable; but what could have been pronounced more im- probable in advance than that a great juniversity should incontinently confer upon him a doctorate for the achieve /ment unless ample proof had been pre- The episode of the Eskimo /youths presented just such opposite im- probabilities; and so did the Barrill af- fair. And now come an able seaman and his business-man friend, and make affidavit that they supplied the doctor ‘in the United States is greatly increased with a complete set of “faked” observa- tions covering his dash to the Pole. The affidavits are so circumstantial that it is difficult to doubt their truthfulness; but why did Cook fail to pay them their price, when the betrayal of the secret was sure to follow? There is more in all this than is natural. Even the very names involved in the Cook affair are so strange as to seem to belong to the world of fiction rather than of fact. Not content with Wake and Wack, he must consort with Dunkle and Loose, regard- less of the suggestion of ways that are dark and tricks that are vain which the conjuncture can hardly fail to provoke. But with the plot thickening as it now is, and a conclusion likely in the near future, it is hardly worth while to weigh too solemnly this particular addi- tion to the evidence in the Cook case. On the face of it, the matter looks very bad for the doctor, and it seems almost a duty of charity to point out a way of escape for him if the net tightens. If worse comes to worst, and it should be proved beyond the possibility of doubt, by the identity of the Copenhagen fig- ures with those of Dunkle and Loose, that the records have been doctored and cooked, there is still a way out which may not occur to the Brooklyn man’s champions. There is eminent psycho- logical authority for the view that to be found out in a cheat of this kind should not be regarded by the eye of science as seriously damaging; that, in- deed, it may, under certain circum- stances, be looked upon as evidence of general honesty. Cook, let us suppose, is a perfectly honest and exceptionally guileless man. He has reached the Pole; he knows it himself beyond a doubt, atid he is pained to find himself in a difficult position owing to the per- verse skepticism of an unkindly genera- tion. This difficulty, he feels, cannot be removed by the presentation of his gen- uine observations, which, though good enough for all practical purposes, will be picked to pieces by cold-hearted scien- tists because he is not enough of a nautical expert to have made them with the requisite accuracy. What more nat- ural than that he should accept the aid of a kind navigator who will give him a better sef of observations? He doesn’t want them for the purpose of deceiving anybody, but simply in order to estab- lish what he knows to be the truth. And

Page 10

592 > the very fact that he is not afraid to do all this in the dark, and thus run the risk of the most cruel accusations of fraud, only brings out the simplicity of his nature. The story told by the two worthies has a great deal of interest, quite aside from its evidential bearing on the North Pole question. Here is a bit of conver- sation between Dr. Cook and Captain Loose: “Do you think you could help me work out those altitudes?” “Of course I could,” replied the captain “How could you do it?” asked Dr. Cook “Why, that’s easy,” said the captain. “I'll work them out backwards.” Dr. Cook asked if he really knew how to work out observations backwards and Capt. Loose assured him that he most ertainly could. “Then,” replied Dr. Cook, some service to me.” “you can be of ‘lois is Silas Wegg and Mr. Boffin over again, with the same wonder on the part the er of his helper to “work them out back- as Mr. Boffin felt at Mr. Wegg’s he found that “all And the busi- ness man is as notable in his own way of patron at the mysterious pow- wards” attainments when print was open to him.” as the sailor man in his. When Dunkle named the price at $4,000, and Dr. Cook “gasped some,” Dunkle showed true American quickness and humor: “I as- sured him,” he says, “that we thought we had the market cornered,” a remark which must have struck the doctor as eminently correct. An interesting fea- ture, too, is the sublime self-confidence of Loose, real or assumed. “Dr. Cook,” he that the tions which you had wouldn't prove any- But if you stick to this set, they will carry you through any uni- says, “you know observa- thing to anybody. versity in the world. Don’t you be afraid that they will not pass those scientists it did not occur to either of the parties that the at Copenhagen.” Apparently, Danish scientists might know as well as the captain did that observations could Fi- interesting to notice the be fabricated without any trouble. nally, it is delicacy of the language employed on both sides throughout. Never was there anything more than an implication that the observations of Dr. Cook himself might be non-existent or worthless. Some of the high officials in charge of our relations with countries might take pattern by these unprofes- sional diplomats in the observance of euphemistic forms to cover unpleasant foreign realities. associates in the movement cared least The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2320 HARVARD AND THE ELECTIVE SYSTEM. The action taken by the Board of Overseers of Harvard University in re- lation to the elective system furnishes an overvaluation, of such accumulation, that formed part of their motive in throwing overboard the old curriculum. What they wished to accomplish was to put life into the student's interest impressive evidence both of the ripeness | ' his studies by giving him freedom of the time for the contemplated changes °f choice; what they aimed at was and of the firm grasp with which Presi. Teality and significance in college stud- dent Lowell has taken hold of his new ‘es, im direct contrast to the meaning- duties. It is in response to a sentiment !ess accumulation which they felt that that has been steadily growing for some | the old curriculum represented in the years, and which is now predominant in ©ase of a large proportion of the stu- educational circles, that a radical modi-| ents. Their error was not in seeking fication of the system is being made at 'was that, in a too close concentration of their thoughts upon a single desider- Harvard; but that action so definite and thoroughgoing should be taken so soon after the inauguration of the new presi- dent is a remarkable testimony to the effectiveness of his personal influence. | As for the significance of the step in itself, it is within bounds to character- it as among the most important events that have come about in the col- lege world for many years, and one ize which will rejoice the hearts of nearly | all who have given serious thought to that “problem of the college” of which we hear so much nowadays. It means much to thousands of individual young men whose choice of studies it will di- rectly affect; it means more as an as- sertion of the attitude of the foremost of American colleges toward the under- lying questions of college education. In saying this, we do not wish to be understood as subscribing to some of those extreme forms which attack upon the idea of the Harvard elective system has taken. Thus a professor in the Co- lumbia School of Law, in an article just printed in the Columbia University Quarterly, says: “It was upon the mis- conception that education meant an ac-| cumulation in the student’s mind of a) heterogeneous mass of undigested facts | and of disassociated ideas that the very | liberal elective system in colleges was,| The purpose is plain enough. The based.” This is so far from being true | choice of a college course may be made that it is almost the opposite of the truth. When a reaction takes place against a system which was at first hailed with enthusiastic applause and which has been tried and found want- ing, it is curious how ready people are to call the men of the preceding gener- ation nothing better than fools. The accumulation of a “mass of facts,” heterogeneous or homogeneous, was the very thing that President Eliot and his something that was not worth while; it atum, they lost sight of other aspects of the question of education which are even more important, and the neglect of which is now recognized as having dis- astrous consequences. Their hobby was not a bad thing in itself; but they rode it too hard, as many have thought all along, and as almost everybody sees now. The system that is to be substituted for the complete freedom of choice that has hitherto prevailed at Harvard is in- dicated with sufficient definiteness by the resolutions of the Overseers. A com- mittee of the faculty is to be appointed, with the president as chairman, to “pre- pare general rules for the choice of electives, to be approved by the faculty, based upon the principle that a student must take a considerable amount of work in some one field and that the rest of his courses must be well dis- tributed.”. This is the kernel of the whole matter; all the rest is subsidiary, including the provision for the appoint- ment, out of the faculty, of “a large number of advisers for the students.” It may safely be assumed that the details of the plan will be worked out by the committee in a practical manner. sufficiently elastic to give due considera- tion to a student's proclivities and to his prospective occupation, without the sac- rifice of the primary idea of a college education; but that idea is completely lost sight of when mere number of hours in the classroom is regarded, as it has been, as a full measure of value. Even supposing that the choice was made in good faith in every instance, there are a score of fundamental ob- jections. The want of codrdination is of for; and it was ap undervaluation, not itself an almost fatal defect, but there

Page 11

The Nation. Dec. 16, 1909] -) 93 are others fully as serious. Most fal- fun really comes in is not in the right- lacious of all is the notion that one ness or wrongness of the partisans, but study contributes as much as another in the fact that half a dozen scholars of to that general development of the repute, professing to translate this poem mind which must be the primary aim for us laymen, have so garbled the mean- of any college education worthy of the | ig as to prove that the pearl was a name. And when it comes to the ob-|Teal girl. Professor Schofield of Har- jections that are not inherent but|Vard, who is of the other opinion, has which experience shows to be of the relentlessly shown them up in the vi- utmost practical importance, we are Vacious periodical published by the Mod- confronted with the fact that in thou- @™® Language Association. One of them sands of cases studies are chosen with ad inferred from the reality of the be- no other measure of their attractive. Teavement—itself an inference—an en- ness than that furnished by their stand- tire domestic tragedy. Somewhere, if ing in the scale of “soft snaps.” All this he is rightly translated, the poet de- the Harvard authorities are preparing ©/@Tes that he has been two years alone. to do away with; and to substitute for Clearly, his wife has left him, and. that it something approaching the coherence %eing so, she may have gone off with and balance of the old college course, ®Nother man, accentuating the hus- which, whatever its faults, was success- and’s grief for the loss of his daugh- ful in building up, generation after gen- eration, men who justly bore the title of ter. The peat:, or is it the girl? is once spoken of as “secret,” which gives only gentleman and scholar. THE GAY SCIENCE OF PHILOLOGY. Philologists pass for duil dogs. Deeply immersed in severe studies, they preach and are supposed to practise a scien- tific method of Many of them admit this, and the sol- emn occasions on which they convene are frequently enlivened by discussion for the good of the feeble- minded greater number, philology ought inhuman exactitude. whether, not really to loosen up. But it can eas- ily be shown that, far from being the most precise of the sciences, philology is, in actual practice, one of the most romantic of the arts. These grave men are inwardly fond adventurers and their trade as hazardous as the quest of samphire. Only consider the interpretation of that charming Middle English poem, “The Pearl,” which Professor Gollancz first rescued from the files of the Karly English Text Society. Five transla- tions and commentaries have ensued. Now, the especial point about this very | pretty poem is that it either is or isn’t that quite slippery thing, an allegory. It appears to be a lament for a little) /his theory must remain in the limbo of bolized by the pearl. It is certain, that | girl who is dead, whose purity is sym- is, that the pearl means the girl, and it may well be that both, after approved medieval fashion, mean something else. Hard words have passed on this issue, and in more robust days blood would doubtless have been shed. Where the too much reason to suppose that the in- nocent heroine of the poem was illegiti- mate. So philology has dealt with one piece of literature, and yet they say the philologists are prosaic fellows. Turpin himself never more deftly lightened a heavy purse of its superfluous cvuin than these translators, quite unconsciously and after the manner of genius, depriv- ed the “Pearl” of all evidence contro- verting their theories. If the gayety of a science depends upon the temper of its devotees, evident- ly philology will not fit into the dismal eategory. But romance requires also the air of varied circumstance. Here, too, the phi'ologer walks in wide- eyed expectancy. From the sands of Turkestan have come recently the frag- ments of a new Aryan language. The discovery of an inscribed spear-head might any day establish a new theory or mortally smite an old one. Years ago Professor Sievers declared that cer- tain portions of the Anglo-Saxon poem of the Creation abounded in Continen- tal words and phrases, and must be a translation from an Old Saxon original. For some time his rivals cheerfully demonstrated that he knew neither Old Saxon nor Anglo-Saxon. It looked as if unproved hypotheses. But one day an- other German scholar was rummaging in the Vatican library, and that day, in William James's pregnant words, “truth occurred” to Professor Sievers’s theory —a sheet from the posited Old Saxon poem turned up in a book-binding. Here are suggested hazards of scholastic for- tunes with which mere prospecting for gold or cornering cotton cannot vie. With philologists one 1s ever in the realm of the imagination. Prof. Bran- der Matthews takes occasion in his re cently published essay on the Speech of the People to praise King Alfred’ for his “intuitive knowledge” of the pro- found truth that language “lives in common speech and in daily use, rather than in grammar and in dictionary.” See how the philological fancy glorifies Alfred for what the common man would suppose the great king couldn't help doing. But Professor Matthews sees vividly the insidious perils that hung over the grave origins of English prose. Had not Alfred had that instinct for colloquialism, he might easily have been perverted through reading: the Enzlish pedantry glossaries in Sweet's Earliest Texts or similar organs of Thus the infant English language might have been broken down at the outset by of its polysyllabic the sheer weight swaddling clothes. And note that it takes the trained philological imagina tion to perceive this service to England and the world. All of which brings us back to our original contention that, as in sciences go, philology is distinct!y the gay division. If a philologist ever seems a dull dog, look out for him. He really is bursting with romance, and if you thwart him he may do you an in- jury. GAMES AND TALK. In formally opening the new links at Gravesend, the other day, Mr. Arthur Balfour made a short speech golf. Even his oratorical genius was unequal to saying anything new on the subject, but he did say something that appears not to be true. Deprecating the practice of calling upon a public man—already sick unto death with much speaking—to make an address on every conceivable occasion, Mr. Bal- four contended that speech-making was peculiarly inappropriate to golf, since it was “a game to be played and not to be talked about.” If this was meant for satire, nothing is to be said except that it was too sub- tle. As a matter of fact, talking about golf is one of the great and estab'ished features of the game. Ask the despair- ing wives who have to listen to all the about

Page 12

594 details of the match fought over again at dinner! Freeman's disgust at the “chatter about Harriet” was no greatei than that of many a non-golfer com- pelled to listen to endless explanations of the in which the ball became the thirteenth and hung on the edge of the cup on the last hole. their a circumstance to the way unplayable o Veterans fighting battles over again are not long explanations of golf strategy and the “most wonderful shot I ever made,” which go on with inexhaustible zest on club plazzas and around the tables in the café. Condemn the inveterate golf- er to silence about his favorite sport, and it would lose half its charm. What Mr. Balfour seems to have con- fused is the rule of taciturnity while actually playing, and the rule of limit- less discussion and living the scene over again when the match is finally lost or won. Strict observers of golf etiquette go over the course like so many Trap- pists. The tradition of silence on the links is ancient and severe. Stories and facts without end illustrate it. There were the two old Scotchmen who played a closely-contested round with- out a word or whisper, until one of them uttered a golfer’s oath as his ball jumped out of the cup on the eighteenth hole. The other turned upon him in a fury at his “unbridled loquacity.” The is generally held that the players are the most close-mouth- conviction best ed. The man whom Walter Travis de- feated in the finals for the British ama- teur championship wrote afterwards that the American was the most silent golfer he had ever encountered. His single remark to his opponent during the whole thirty-six holes was: “You are This is the the links driving a very long ball.” kind of golden silence on which Mr. Balfour may have had in mind. There is, to be sure, what is known as “conversational golf,” in which con- | testants are privileged by agreement to keep up a ceaseless patter of guying and banter between strokes, but that is admitted to be a shameless departure from the rigors of the game. Yet the most punctilious player, who holds it a sacred obligation let his words be few in the course of actual play, feels at liberty to overflow when it is ended. Then come the joyous recollections of the exact difficult lie and the astonish- ing recovery, the long and absorbing to The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2320 post-mortems, the nice pointing out just where the match was lost, the conclu- sive demonstration that if a wooden club had only been taken instead of an iron, or the ball not fallen into a heel- print in the hazard, a glorious victory would have resulted. There is also the utterly illimitable talk about the make of clubs and style of shoes and stance and swing and grip, which flows on no less fatedly and in much greater vol- ume than Tennyson's brook. Golf not to be talked about! Why, it is one of the greatest provocatives to conversation ever brought into this tongue-wagging world. It is true of all popular games that talking about them is inseparable from playing them. Fancy what would happen to academic conversation if its one great theme for a large part of the college year were to be taken away. Football gives its chief color to the speech of thousands of undergraduates for weeks and months. Before the season opens, there is the vast discussion of plans and possibilities. While the games are playing, the rising hope of American culture can talk of nothing else. After the last struggle has been fought out, there come the long regrets that its strategy or personnel had not been differ- ent; and the undergraduate mind carries the matter well into the winter, until it is time to enliven the conversation by speculating on the chances of the’ nine and the crew in the spring. If it were not for games and talk about them, we should not have any of that play of wit and fancy, and that mind sharpening mind, which this athletic age has made such a social staple. No games, no conversation. A young lady of our acquaintance put the case exact- ly as it is. She was thrown into the company of a college senior, with whom she endeavored to make talk. “I tried him on books,” she said, “but only made him uncomfortable. I asked him about the theatre, but he merely looked blank. I inquired what he thought about politics, but found that he had no thoughts. Then I saw what had to be done, and suggested athletics. Instantly he brightened up, ran on fluently for an hour, and concluded that I was not such a fool as he had feared.” So we see that the game may not be worth the candle, but is certainly worth the talk. RECENT FRENCH HISTORY. Paris, December 2. The latest of the many volumes which Emile Ollivier has in his old age writ- ten on “L’Empire Libéral” (Garnier), in which the history-making activities of his prime were spent long ago, prac- tically concludes his Apologia pro Vita sua. It must be said that time, with its appeasements, had already proceeded to his essential justification. Never was a French minister more vituperated by his countrymen of every degree. After their crushing defeat by Germany, they were bound to find scapegoats. In 1867 Republican agitators had prevented the efficacious army reform urged by Mar- shal Niel. In the fatal July session of Parliament in 1870, Gambetta shouted loudest for war and branded opposition as scélérate. They profited by the Em- peror’s defeat, which was at the same time a national disaster, to work their Revolution; and when this, instead of mending matters, ended them by the loss of two provinces, they turned first, ungallantly, against the Empress Eugénie—it had been “her war” all along—next against Emile Oliivier, Prime Minister when they forced the Emperor to war against his own feel- ing and judgment. Ollivier’s unhappy phrase of the ceur léger, with which he looked forward to the war he had in reality opposed, was taken from its con- text and for many years he sank under its opprobrium. He has bided his time. Has he justified himself now? Ess-ntial- ly, yes—and, along with himself, the Empress, who was never a friend of his, but whose réle was grossly exagger- ated from social and religious as well as political hatred. Her utterance as she escaped from the Tuileries still best sums up that closing of an historical epoch: “We have been dupes!” The story is long, but it is well told by this too theoretical statesman who was a chief actor in it and who re mains a master rhetorician. The impor- tance of these volumes extends far be- yond the defence of their author and the rectification of still burning dis- putes. The “Liberal Empire” was a spontaneous progress of the French peo- ple toward representation by an execu- tive power. Its utter failure has left France under the absolute sovereignty of the legislative body in the present Parliamentary Republic. The detai's of the diplomacy at Ems and the political | workings at Paris are here told by one | who knows, and, on the whole, with sur- prising impartiality. | “Napoléon III, devant l'histoire” (Dujarric), by Pierre Gérard, is a pop- ‘ular volume intended to lift the clouds from the memory of the grand méconnu. 'The undoubted progress and material ‘prosperity of France under the hapless | Emperor furnish easy arguments,

Page 13

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nat ion. which, moreover, deserve a place in ser- fous history. The preface is by the Marquis de Dion, progressive leader in the automobile industry and in the plebiscitary political party. G. Weill, professor in the university faculty of Caen, writes from the outside the “Histoire du Catholicisme Libéral en France (1828-1908)”"—a movement which prepared Conservative minds for the successive acceptance of four essen- tially revolutionary governments: King Louis Philippe, the Republic of 1848, the Second Empire in its Liberal phases, and the Third Republic, so long as this last tolerated the “rallying” of Cath- olic Frenchmen to itself. Although its formule are now discredited by both sides, this movement had consequences which endure in the social constitution of to-day. In this it is like the other defunct Liberalisms of the Continent. Its history in the main had already been written from the inside by the biograph- er of Montalembert, who was so long its leader. The present volume is ‘rom the publisher of philosophy, Alcan. With it should be noted a book on a new movement from Georges Goyau, Cath- olic editor of the Revue des Deur Mondes—his fourth series, “Autour du Catholicisme social” (Perrin). It treats discursively of the church of the peo- ple (in Ireland); Gladstone’s State Church; the church and political novel- ties (illustrated by Cardinal Consaivi) ; and various present-day “Catholics of action.” Maurice Quentin-Bauchart, born a citizen of Paris and long one of its mu- nicipal councillors, publishes the notes of his impressions as a grown boy of the Siege and Commune—‘“Les Evéne- ments de 1870-71" (Juven). They are prefaced by the Napoleonic authority, Frédéric Masson of the French Acad- emy. Gen. Kirkpatrick de Closeburn, who is of the same cosmopolitan Scot- tish clan as the Empress Eugénie, pub- lishes his remembrances of youth fight- ing for a predestined lost cause—‘Sou- venirs Carlistes’” (Alphonse Picard). The death of the last Don Carlos gives them a shadow of actuality. “Fachoda” (Flammarion), by ex-For- eign Minister Hanotaux, is an instruc- tive revelation from diplomatic cocu- ments and inside knowledge of one ol the most distressing incidents of recent French history. The international pre- liminaries of the brilliant Marchan‘ ex- pedition; the hesitating utterances of the British Foreign Office, which did not venture to claim exclusive rights in the Sudan until forced by that handful of Frenchmen; and, quite disregarded by a world which attends only to sensa- | tional history in the making, the final recognition by England, as a conse- quence of that humiliation of France, of the vast colonial empire which | France has taken for herself from the) Niger and Congo to the Mediterranean | —these are substantial additions to our knowledge of contemporary history. It is natural that M. Hanotaux should in- sist on the ignorance of the situation which he had prepared, or the neglect of it, on the part of his successor, M. Delcassé. The Fashoda incident was the immediate and condign punishinent; but it is not sufficiently brought out that it was Minister Delcassé’s subse- quent profiting by England’s need in the Sudan which secured the consolida- tion of French rights in Africa. Here, too, as if a republic can have a suc- cessful foreign policy only by accident, the Delcassé negotiations ended in the seeming humiliation of Algeciras, which again has worked beyond all expectation for the recognition of the African rights of France by Germany. Delcassé has now downed Clemenceau, who thus drew final victory from defeat; but the Re- public has taken back neither Delcassé nor Hanotaux to direct its policy. It is lucky for future history that the ex- minister concerned should elucidate all this first period. It makes possible a clear understanding of a movement that otherwise would seem made up of in- coherent leaps backward and forward. The substance of the book first appear- | ed in the Revue des Deur Mondes. “La Politique réaliste a l'extéricur” (Fasquelle), by Pierre Baudin, explains what that ex-minister of public works would have the foreign policy of France, now that the Republic is not profiting by his counsels. It is the book of a Moderate Radical, who has a patriot’s good will with some knowledge of in- ternational events as they really hap- pen, and not as newspapers report them. In name his “realist” policy is that proclaimed by Prime Minister Briand as his own “policy of realizations.” This leaves the mind of Englishmen and Americans blank, for they hardly ever allow ideals or ideas to intervene in prac- tical politics, but always and everywhere realize whatever is in sight. The read- ing of a book like this of M. Baudin ts therefore a help to the understanding of French policies—no easy thing for the Anglo-Saxon. “Terroristes et policiers” (Juven), by | Jean Longuet and Georges Silber, ‘s an evidently inspired book on a most pain- ful subject of contemporary histury— the underground working of the Rus- sian police. The preface is by W. L. Bourtsev, whose accusations hav2 so notoriously interrupted the operations of the Russian police abroad. The sym- pathies of freedom-lovers are inevitably torn between their dislike of bureau- erats striving desperately to save an autocracy at bay and their distrust of a Nihilism sticking at no crime in the pursuit of its own ideal of liberty. 8. D. Correspondence. THE ORACLE OF LOVE INTHE TWELFTH CHAPTER OF “LA VITA NUOVA.” To THe Eprtror oF THE NATION Str: After Beatrice had her salutation, Dante declares appeared to him in a vision, and sighed, and said: “Fili mi, tempus est ut preter- mittantur simulacra nostra—my son, it is time for us to lay aside our counterfeit- ing’; and that, having so said, Love wept for pity, and to Dante, asking, “Lord of nobleness, why dost thou weep?’ replied “Ego tamquam centrum circuli, cui simild modo se habent circumferentia partes; tu autem non sic—I am as the centre of a cir- cle, for which all parts of the circumfer- ence are alike; but thou art not so." Per- plexed, Dante again asked: “What thing is this, Master, that thou hast spoken thus darkly?” Love only replied: “Demand no more than may be useful to thee." Love's injunction, “it is time for lay aside our counterfeiting,” denied to him that Love us to is clear Beatrice, and others, had misunderstood Dante's “screening’’ homage to another lady; it is time, therefore, to confess the truth to his real lady. Obediently, Dante addresses to Beatrice a ballata, which says of its maker: Lady his heart bas been of such fixed constancy that his each thought incites him to early ‘twas thine, hath it serve thee and never strayed Apparently, this obedience, though due, is to entail disaster for Dante, he is not, like Love, ‘‘as the centre of a circle, for which all parts of the circumference are alike.” Also, present understanding of what Love means would not avail to avert the disaster, otherwise an exp‘anation would be “useful.”” We should expect cordingly, to find the key to the oracular because ac- utterance in the direct consequences of Dante's obedient “‘laying aside of counter feiting.”’ After this above written vision [Dante writes}, when I had already said those words (to Beatrice} which Love had charg- ed me to say, many and divers thoughts be gan to assail and tempt me,each one almost irresistibly, among which thoughts four seemed most to disturb my life's repose The first whereof was this: The lordship of Love is good since it draweth the mind of his liege from all evil things The next was this: The lordship of Love is not good since the more faith his ‘iege beareth him, the more heavy and more grievous straits must he pass. The next was this: The name of Love is so sweet to hear that it seemeth to me impossible that its action in most things be other than sweet The fourth was this: The lady for whom Love constraineth thee thus is not as other ladies that her heart be lightly moved. And each assailed me so, that it made me stand like one who knoweth not by which path |}to take his way, and who fain would go, | yet knoweth not whither to turn. And if I | thought that I would seek a way common to /all, namely, where a!!l might be in accord, | this way was most inimical to me, namely, }to call upon and yield me to the arms of ‘pity. | Drawn “irresistibly” four ways in turn, | Dante is obviously in a position unlike ‘the jeentre of a circle, for which all parts of \the circumference are alike.” Concerned jas he is for his own welfare, he can see |/no way out, no centre of accord, except in ‘his lady’s pity, which he forebodes must be | ‘intmical.” oe

Page 14

596 The foreboding is immediately justified. From Beatrice he finds not pity, but mock- So far from pity making accord be- ery tween his four conflicting thoughts, his appeal to pity only involves him in a new fourfold mystery— whereof the first [matter] is, that ofttimes I grieved when memory moved my fancy to imagine how Love dealt with me. The sec ond is how Love did many times suddenly assai] me so mightily that there remained naught in me of life save a thought that spake of this lady; the third is, that when this battle of love assailed me thus, I set forth, as ‘twere all pallid, to behold this lady. believing that the sight of her wou'd defend me from this assault, forgetting what befel me through drawing nigh to such gentleness; the fourth is, how that such sight not only did not defend me, but finally discomfited the small remnant of my life. Thus the lover seems at the point of spiritual death, when suddenly al! is chang- ed. Dante presently announces ‘‘a new mat- ter and more noble than the past."’ Ques- tioned as to the end of his love, he re- plies: “Ladies mine, the end of my love was once this lady's salutation But since it hath pleased her to deny it to me, Love, my lord, by his grace hath placed all my beatitude in that which cannot fail me,”” namely, as he says presently, “in those words which praise my lady.” Love, “lord of nobleness,” has at last re- vealed himself to Dante, whose own love to now has been ignoble, because self-cen- tred, craving reward in the salutation. The four thoughts which drew him from his repose were all for his own welfare. Hence- forth his love is to be centred in self-ef- facing service, in pure homage. He will give all, asking nothing; and therefore he ean lose nothing. Not pity, his “ene ny” indeed, but renunciation, was signified by that “centre of indifference” to which Love, “lord of nobleness,” had likened himself. Such love Dante joyously believes he has now found, and declares in the sonnet, “Love and the gentle heart are but one thing.” In the canzone, “Ladies that have intelligence of love,” he first expresses this “new matter and nobler” of love, this self- lees homage. It is significant that Bona- giunta cites (Purg. xxiv, 51) this canzone as demarking the “sweet new style,” when asking Dante to define that style. To him Dante replies: I am one who, when Love me Inepireth, note, and In such wise as be dictates within, go setting forth. of Love” in the twelfth chap- The “oracle ter of the “Vita Nuova” is just such a dictation Love’s obscurely declared na- ture, when realized by Dante through mis- take and suffering, is what turns Dance’s “young life’ into his “new life,” his re- generate life, when hia selfish love is born again in the new Intelligence of the love which is nobleness. But fulfilment of love through self-re- nunciation is not yet perfect. While Bea- trice lives, Dante oas at least the reward of her presence. Presently, death robs him of even that He despairs, and turns for comfort to the Pitiful Lady (la donna ple-— tosa). Again forgetful of the nemesis which appeal to pity brought, again misunder- standing the love which Is nobleness, he’ said within himself: “It cannot be but! that noble love is with that pitiful lady.” | And he thought of her: “This is a gentle) lady, fair, young, and wise, and hath ap-| The Nation. | Vol. 89, No. 2320 peared perchance by Love's will, in orier that my life may find rest.” But such was not the will of Love, “lord of nobleness.” His life doeg not find rest, but is distract- ed by a new “battle of thoughts,” by one justifying selfish solace, another command- ing unselfish loyalty. For a while the sel- fish thought dominates, until “a mighty vision” of young Beatrice leaves him peni- tent, and filled with “tribulation” such that his eyes weep so that Love encircleth them as with a martyr’s crown. Thus this spiritual crisis recorded in the forty-first chapter exactly repeats that already recorded in the sixteenth. In each) case, centring his love in pity, he is at) once drawn opposite ways by contrary) thoughts, and is then suddenly confronted with Beatrice, first in the flesh, the second time in “a mighty vision” (una forte im- maginazione). On the one occasion her girlish mockery, on the other the silent reproach of the girlish figure he had first seen and loved, utterly discomfits jim. From each discomfiture springs the reali- zation that the true “centre” of the love which is nobleness lies not in the solace of indulgent pity, but in the self-devotion of the “gentle heart.” The ignoble lover seeks to realize his own self-will, and finds only unrest and despair; the noble lover submits his own will to the will of his beloved. After the first crisis, Love, by his grace, had taught Dante the un- failing beatitude of selfless contempla- | tion and praise of his lady morta!; so aow, after the second crisis, Love will teach the still higher beatitude of praise and ideal contemplation of her immortal. In the; last sonnet of the “Vita Nuova” this “new intelligence” is dictated by Love. Drawn | ever upwards by a “new intelligence that Love, weeping, implants in it,” his “pil- grim spirit” soars to the Empyrean, where it beholds Beatrice in glory, yet is inca- | pable of rightly declaring that glory. Love, dictating this new intelligence of) himself, weeps—as he had wept when first, after the denial of the salutation, he had de-| clared darkly his true nature. Evidently not even yet is Dante’s love fully subdued to the love which is nobleness. Before his. “pilgrim spirit” may fully realize and de-| clare the glory of Beatrice, that Is of Love himself (the identity had been revealed by) Love in chapter twenty-four), it must pass | alike,”’ | 73-5): the beatific vision; but not until already his desire and will were rolled, even as a wheel that evenly is moved, by the Love that moves the sun and other stars. That is to say, having at last realized the Divine Circle, the one ray, the virtual cen- tre of which is Love, Dante’s whole moral nature is subdued to harmony with that Love, aad becomes concentric with it. Selfish desire and self-will are quenched; he is able to say with the blessed, in Pic- carda’s words: In His will is our peace. Now Beatrice’s seemingly “inimical” de- nial of pity is explained. In the “Vita Nuova” (chap. xxiv) Daunte had foreshadow- /ed her relation to him as that of Christ to the sinner. ‘“‘Whom the Lord loveth he chas- teneth”; it was Beatrice’s chastening which at last made Dante’s love also ‘‘as the centre of a circle, for which all parts of the cir- cumference are alike’’—that is to say, as we may now interpret, not a selfish passion blown hither and thither by the four winds of desire, but a joyous acquiescence in the will of the loved one, a “centre of indiffer- ence,” such as Piccarda intends when she answers Dante (Par. iii, 70-2): Brother, the quality of perfect love (caritd) stilleth our will, and maketh us desire but what we have, nor giveth other thirst. But while seeking nothing for itself, this perfect love is a radiant centre of loving charity equally for all. In heaven, where all /are such radiant centres of love, there is, in- deed, no distinction between giving and re- ceiving; all are as “centres of circles, for which all parts of the circumference are since, as Virgil says (Pure. xv The more on high who one another know, the more are to love well, the more love is, and like a mirror each to each gives back. As if to symbolize visually Love's self- | description, Dante represents the spirits of the more blessed as literally centres of flam- ing circles. The spirits in the Moon appear |}as merely shadowy human forms; in Mer- |}eury the shadowy forms begin to glow; in the higher planets the glow hides the en- closed form, and the spirit voices sound from the centres of these “torches” or |“‘suns” or “splendors.”” One spirit, San Pier Damiano, is explicitly described as “love” at the centre of a whirling circle of through Hell and Purgatory; must again,| lieht (Par. xxi, 79 ff.); and the Virgin Mary Bea after its errancy, be confronted with - trice, and, appealing to pity, seem to find pity an “enemy” still. Though angels are moved to pity by his misery, Beatrice is sternly unrelenting. In his manhood, as in his “young life,” he must pay the “scot that sheddeth tears.” At Beatrice’s re- buke. Then at my heart there gnawed so great remorse that I fell stricken (Par. xxxi, 88-09). But after this third and last crisis, Love finally reveals himself fully in the knowl-| becomes the centre of “‘a radiance circle- formed around her,” by “‘the angelic love” of Raphael (Par. xxiii, 94 ff.). Finallv the Godhead appears as a threefold circle, with- in which Dante seems to see the image of Christ, that is to say, of Love himself. Vis- ually regarded, Love’s dark words in the “Vita Nuova” could not be more fully jus‘i- fled. If the above interpretation of these dark 'words be correct, they are by no means the mere obiter dictum or even unexplained edge of his kingdom, Paradise. Drawn up- mystification that the commentators have ward to the Empyrean again, as his “pilgrim left them, but form the dramatic announce- spirit’ bad been drawn in the “Vita Nuova,”| ment, and contain the essential tenet, of the Dante now sees not only Beatrice in her religion of love embodied in the “sweet, new glory, but the Godhead also—this last as style” ef both the “Vita Nuova” and the “three circles of threefold color, and of one “Divina Commedia.” dimension,” of which the third seemed to be “fire that was breathed forth equally by! both” the other two. This third circle sym-| bolizes the power of the Holy Ghost, or Love. Dante's mortal faculties failed to sustain JEFFERSON B. FLETCHER. Columbia University, December 10.

Page 15

Dec. 16, 1909]

The Nation.

FRENCH ACCENTS ON PROPER NOUNS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The spelling of the name of the poet Heredia (without any accent) in your article on Father Tabb in this week's Nation tempted me to send you, for your mext list of errata, a corrected Hérédia. That, at least, was the spelling finally agreed upon by the revising editors of the “New International Encyclopedia,” after a good deal of doubt and careful consulting of the best authorities. The busy lexi- cographer cannot always lay his hand on the works of the author whose fate he is deciding, and an American encyclopedia may be pardoned for erring once in a while in good company. To this day, not to mention lesser lights, Brockhaus (1902) has Hérédia, and go has the almost infalli- ble Garollo (“Dizionario Biografico,” 1909), while the last Meyer, though it has dis- carded the accents in the article “Heredia,” retains them under the rubric ‘“Franzé- sische Literatur.” And to add to the per- plexities of cyclopedia-making, there ap- pears an apparently unquestioned Hérédia (the maiden name of Mme. Henri de Régnier) in “Qui @6tes-vous?” for 1909- 1910. But, for all that, if we turn to the works of the poet, we find that Heredia it is, or rather seems to be, for the skep- tical lexicographer may be pardoned for thinking that nothing is certain in his spe- <ial pursuit. Breathes there a man who can positively assert that so recent a celeb- rity as President Casimir-Perier never spelled hig name with an accent over the first e? Here is the “Grande Encyclo- pédie”’ with only Periers, while the ‘‘Nou- veau Larousse” has only Périers, though the President, still referred to in a head- ing as “Périer (Jean Casimir),” is taken out of their list and treated, unaccented, under “Casimir-Perier.” A still more mod- ern man, ex-Premier Clemenceau, appears as Clémenceau in the “Grande Encyclopé- die,”’ as well as in Vapereau’s authoritative “Dictionnaire universel des Contemporains” (1893) and as Clemenceau in Larousse. It is only within the last tew years that the latter spelling has been generally adopted by newspapers in France and elsewhere. But there is still some uncertainty con- cerning the spelling of a more famous Mame than has as yet been mentioned. Most encyclopedias write Fénelon nowa- days, but the doubts that preceded the adop- tion of this spelling for one encyclopedia, at least, are still fresh in the minds ofsome of us. For what do we find when we turn to some standard editions of “Télémaque”’ or to various important works contain- ing the name of its author, in the Columbia Library? Here is Voltaire’s “Siécle de Louis XIV,’ in the 1785 edi- tion of his complete works, with Féné- lon; a copy of “Dialogues sur |’éloquence en général” has appended a letter “written by the late Fenelon,” without any accent on the name, either on the title-page or in the text (the distinction is important) ; here is an edition of “Télémaque,” by Fénélon (Paris, 1835), and here one by Fénelon, 1836, and again Surenne gives us an American Fénélon, 1856, and so on. It is, indeed, greatly to be regretted that the French Academy has never spoken its flat concerning the spelling of the great names that adorn French literature. ‘Though we find in the preface to the last

edition of the “Dictionnaire de l'Académie Francaise” the incidental mention of Féne- lon, we are warned that the Academy does not concern itself with words pertaining to cyciopadias. Is it, then, to return to Heredia, unrea- sonable to surmise that the poet, coming tc France when very young, at first natur- alized his name by accenting it, and after- wards, as a famous writer, dropped the ac- cents? Perhaps one of your learned con- tributors may throw some light on this subject. GuS8TAV POLLAK. New York, December 4.

TURNER AND CLAUDE LORRAIN. To THE EDITOR OF THY NATION: Sir: Permit me to add to your interesting article on “Claude Lorrain, Teacher” (No- vember 4), some hints which may be of ser- vice to students of painting and to visitors to the National Gallery in London. Turner made his great mistake when he willed to the English nation (the National Gallery) his best evening and morning pic- tures, with the proviso that they should be placed side by side with the best morning and evening pictures of Claude Lorrain owned by the Gallery. The result is an in- structive and wholesome lesson in the di- rection pointed out in your above-mention- ed article; and it is of special value to the devotee of the present style of painting for effect, however achieved. Indeed, this style of “however achieved,” whether by loading color or by rough canvas or paper, is the least permanent ‘and the least instructive. The true mission of painting is to deceive the eye by careful and true perspective painting, and not by semi-plastic methods, as may be clearly seen by comparing Tur- ner’s paintings with those of Claude Lor- rain. While Turner’s evening canvas is bril- liant in color and manipulation, showing the great colorist, it loses immensely by the immediate proximity of Claude Lor- rain’s clear, bright sunlight, with its trans- parency of atmosphere attained by the sim- plicity and purity of the painter's palette, and by smooth, plain painting. Claude Lorrain’s Morning is the morning of south- ern Europe; it has the cool crispness of the early hours, when the clear outline of the crescent moon shows the recent retreat of night. Turner’s Morning shows the dirty grayness of an early, misty English morn- ing. The heavily loaded colors in Turner's paintings have in time assumed the dead cover of dry paints, to which has been added the gray dirt which unavoidably settles on projections. The smoothness of the well- covered canvas of Claude Lorrain and its purity of colors have preserved it from the havoc of time. EDWARD TAUSSIG. St. Louis, Mo., December 1 NAMES IN “THE SOUTHERNER.” To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sir: I wish to correct a misstatement of fact made by your reviewer of “The Southerner,” if you will be so kind ag to permit me. He named a number of men and several newspapers in North Carolina which (he said) I had used, under thin disguises, in the story. This I wish to disclaim, for the book is made up of fiction from beginning to end.

S97 There are only two persons whose charac- ters or careers suggested anything in it, and your reviewer has happened to guess only one of these two, and he is dead. I should much prefer, and I think it is fair to ask, that the gentlemen whom he named should not think that I have been guilty of what I should regard as very bad taste. It may interest your reviewer to know that the places and some of the persons named in the book are declared by an Alabaman reviewer to be places and men in Alabama; and I am informed by a Texan gentleman that he recognized in the story one character as a well-known man in public life in Texas. THE AUTHOR OF “THE SOUTHERNER.” New York, December 2. Literature. BOOKS FOR CHILDREN.—II. The wisest men in some directions are oftenest the most genial men in others; Charles Perrault, the Rev. Charles Dodg- son, and Edouard Laboulaye were all as- sociated in their several lines of thought with learned societies. The last-named was citizen, jurist, and scholar, but is perhaps best remembered, as were also Per- rault and “Lewis Carroll,” for his imagina- tive work. A volume of his “Fairy Tales” (Dutton), illustrated by Arthur A. Dixon, has been issued, in an artistic Nister edi- tion, with a most sumptuous cover, which such excellent internal wealth deserves, The publishers of the new issue of “Through the Looking Glass” (Dodge) have curiously omitted Mr. Dodgson’s name from the red, white, and blue cover which, in its loudness, belies the refined humor of this classic. Mothers will be especially indebted to Alicia Aspinwall for her “Can You Believe Me Stories” (Dutton). While these do not all maintain the same high level, the non- sense is, on the whole, of exceptional cleverness. The professional story-teller will find distinctive material in such a piece of fancy as “The Irrepressible Pie.” On reading “The Land qf Nod” (Crowell), one is impressed by two facts: Mr. McSpadden has enjoyed the telling and has engaged an artist, Edward L. Chase, whose drawings indicate an equal amount of zest. Mr. Mc- Spadden has also been an excellent student of “Lewis Carroll’; the adventures of Tin- kie and Tess, while not as poignant as those of Alice, are rich in the novelty which childrem like. Mrs, Frances Hodgson Burnett's “Barty Crusoe and His Man Sat- urday” (Moffat, Yard), in excellent type and with line drawings, artistically arrang- ed even though crude, is inferior to most of her recent children's work. It js a con- tinuation of “The Good Wolf.” Lured by the name of Mary Raymond Shipman Andrews, we are disappointed to find her story of “The Enchanted Forest” (Dutton) rather commonplace in its effort to be uncommon. The different tales con- tain a large amount of the incongruous, which is forced and imitative. In this type of book, it is not enough that one should scatter throughout the pages such names 4s the “Whang-Doodle Pup,” but the art rests in making the fantastic instinct with life. Dr. Charles Eastman, otherwise known

4‘

Page 16

598 as “Obiyesa,” has retold, with the aid of Elaine Goodale Eastman, some Sioux tales. The volume ig entitled “Wigwam Evenings” (Little, Brown), and is full of the Indian spirit, as well as the Indian manner. E. W. Deming, whose familiarity with Sioux life is as unquestioned as Dr. Eastman’s knowledge, has drawn the pictures, We cannot help feeling that the multi- plicity of new fairy tales and folklore only serves to distract attention from the really notable imaginative books of this char- acter. It is partly for this reason that Rackham’s “Grimm,” as well as “Grimm's Animal Stories’ (Duffield) with John Rae's effective pictures, should find a hearty wel- come. In passing, G. E, Theodore Roberts's Flying Plover” (L. C. Page), deserves eommendation for its atmosphere, born of lose intimacy with life in the Far North Frederick A. Stokes Company has Hiinsel and Gretel,” adapted from libretto of Adelheid Witte, and embel- color plates by M. L. Kirk, the distinction of being full of imagination and of realistic child humanity This is the first time, so it is asserted, that any version of this fairy tale has been published in English purporting o follow Humperdinck’s opera. Guides to appreciation are most difficult to write attractively, since the purpose is avowedly didacti But Dr. Daniel Gregory in his “Child’s Guide to Music” rhe issued the lished h have with vh lively Mason has (‘Baker & Taylor), discussed most enter- tainingly the essentials of piano, orchestral, and vocal work, mingling anecdote and his- tory with acute and vivid analysis. A sumptuous volume, “The Children’s Book of \rt’’ (Macmillan), contains a cursory sur- vey of the art of all ages, and A. E and W Martin Conway, who are the authors, adopt the reproductions are a narrative style; strikingly rich. But we doubt whether this book is as vital in its method as Charles H. Caffin's “A Child’s Guide to Pictures” (Baker & Taylor), an _ ideal course of instruction Macmillan is also the publisher of “The Children’s Book of Gardening,” by Mrs. Alfred Sidgwick and Mrs. Paynter There is no need of emphasi+ing the mean- ne of “What's in a title?’ when that title is Around the World with the Battle- ships’’ (McClurg), a “log” story and a sketchy guide all in one. The book is by Roman J. Miller, chief turret captain, U. 8 Vermont The text is fragmentary, but none the less full of incident and instruc- tion, James B. Connolly has written a vig- orous introductory note. The “make-up” of the book is startlingly gaudy. Franklin Mathews follows his successful “With the Battle Fleet’ with a record of the home- ward journey, which began July 7, 1908, and ended February 22, 1909. The new volume in entitled “Back to Hampton Roads’ (Huebsch), and is full of the acute obser- vation of a very clever newspaper man. In a survey which is necessarily limited in seope, the variety of fiction can only be suggested; at least, a conservative 60 per cent. of the year's literary output for children consists of this special genre. The series class is as strong as ever, and will sell, despite the disfavor of the librarian. Among these books we believe Marion Ames Taggart's “Six Girls and the Seventh One” (Wilde) is most successful in re- taining some of its Initial freshness. The! “faery world,” whose borders touch the thin The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2320 cheerful tone of the character work and the simple introduction of love add dis- tinction to the story. There is a large amount of pleasing vigor in Winifred Kirk- land's “Introducing Corinna” (Revell), which is intended for older girls and deals with the trials of a young woman who be- comes head of a boarding school, and who is as refreshing as her picture, used as a frontispiece. The plot is defective in places, but the general tone is wholesome. Another story deserving of special con- sideration is “When She Came Home from College’’ (Houghton Mifflin), in which the authors, Marian K. Hurd and Jean B. Wil- son, depict the home trials of a college graduate who has ideas as to how the work-a-day world should be run. The book contains humor and distinctive character sketching. We are never disappointed when we turn to children’s books of practical scope. The ingenuity of D. C. Beard shows no abate- ment in “The Boy Pioneers” (Scribner), which is not a story, though the pages are plentifully scattered with facts about Boone, Crockett, and others of the same character; those boys who have the spirit of pioneers in them are told how to live the lives of pioneers, and that object alone should at- tract an enthusiastic army of “campers.” Joseph H. Adams is the author of another handy volume discussing important ma- chinery and the power that moves it (Har- per). The young mechanic will welcome its full descriptions and its tables and defini- tions. The experimenter who must exist in every household will find certain delight in T. B. Russell's “Science at Home” (Fenno), which gathers together a number of easy scientific “tricks” readily performed with the aid of home-made devices. The diagrams might have been more carefully reproduced. In Carrie S. Newman's “Kindergarten in the Home” (L. C. Page) the author attempts to train parents in the intricacies of Froebel’s gifts Attempting a narrative style, the book, nevertheless, is a “manual” in spirit, and will no doubt be suggestive, though it is in no way brilliant. In their Romance Series,” the Lippincotts have this year imported Dr. James C. Philip’s “Ro- | mance of Modern Chemistry,” best described | in the words of its sub-title: “A descrip- tion in non-technical verse and wonderful ways in which chemical forces are at work, and of their manifold application in modern life.” The text reads like a narrative. Of a more strictly entertaining character for young people from four to ten is Elsie Duncan Yale's “When Mother Lets Us Give a Party” (Moffat, Yard), a suggestive little guide which will bring fun to many boys and girls at a loss “what to do” on such occasions. In this same series, Frances Duncan, who edits the Garden Department in the Ladies’ Home Journal, tells little folks what is best to plant, “When Mother Lets Us Garden.” Could the publishers sug- gest some ways in which fathers might be advised? | Fairyland we enter through the portals of |pcetry, contained in Alfred Noyes’s “Magic Casement” (Dutton), an excellent anthology \for old as well as for the “mediumly” young; the compiler analyzes in an attrac- tive manner the wide realm known as the language of the di-| | tine separating it from “delicate reality.” |In that realm there are both the spirit of pure fancy and the essence of the heroic ‘which is partly national tradition. In the |latter class, we find E. M. Wilmot-Buxton’s “Stories of Norse Heroes” (Crowell), told in }a direct style with some of the Saga spirit; this is more dignified, even if it is less simple, than John P. Edmison’s effort to cover much the same territory in his “Stories from the Norseland’’ (Penn Pub. Co.). Kate Stephens’s “Stories from Old Chron- icles” (Sturgis & Walton Co.) bears evi- dences of careful planning and in scope is |very suggestive; the collection is a com- mendable introduction to Froissart and other recorders who are too little knowm these days. To a certain extent Spenser, in the midst of his Allegory, might be re- garded as a poetic historian, and so “The Faerie Queen” may be approached as re- flective of royalty in England. A. J. Church has retold some of these adventures in a way entertaining to young people (Mac- millan), but he has not accomplished his task as distinctively as Lawrence H. Daw- son (Crowell), who has been fortunate enough to retain much of the ancient virili- ty and romantic flavor of the original. This edition cannot be passed by without special congratulations to Gertrude Hammond, some of whose color plates are of pleasing richness. The Crowells are likewise to be thanked for their edition of Douglas C. Stedman's “Story of Hereward,” which not only may serve as an introduction to Kings- ley, but will also prove excellent reading as a chronicle-romance. Every country has its quota of legend, and each year brings to our desk stories re- told, perhaps with the idea that amidst the |rush of modern things it is difficult to keep in touch with the original flavor of other ages. H. L. Havell has written a critical introduction for his “Stories from the Iliad” (Dodge Pub. Co.), in which he re- veals the sincerity which prompts his task; the text is conscientious and compact in its desire to be faithful. In the same spirit, Elizabeth D. Renninger apprcaches “The Story of Rustem and Uther Persian Hero Tales from Firdusi’ (Scribner), with effec- tively lined and tinted drawings by J. L. S. Williams. The Century Co. in a series of stories |“Retold from St. Nicholas” is catering |partly to the heroic in all children. This year they have published “Stories of Chivalry,” “Stories of Greece and Rome,” “Stories of Classic Myths,” “Stories of the Ancient World,” “Stories of Royal Chil- |dren,” and “Stories of the Middle Ages,” |a sufficient assortment for every taste. | THE LAST DAYS OF PAPAL ROMB. 'The Last Days of Papal Rome. i850- 1870. By R. de Cesare. Abridged with the assistance of the Author and Translated by Helen Zimmern. With an Introductory Chapter by G. M. Tre- velyan. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $3.50 net. ’ Dr. Raffaelle de Cesare has steadily risen in authority on the later history of the Risorgimento. His first impor- tant work, “The End of a Kingdom,”

Page 17

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nation. 599 described the last years of Bomba’s régime at Naples. His present book, written on a similar plan, tells the story | of the last twenty years of Papal Rome. His method is to collect all possible ma- terial ani then to classify it according to topics. So we have one chapter on the aristocracy, another on theatres and newspapers, a third on the Sacred Col- lege, and so on. Much of the evidence has been collected from survivors of this period; some has come from inedit- ed private correspondence; and Dr. De Cesare’s own memory, which goes back to 1860, supplies a part. The rigid historical student may com- plain that there are few documents, and no chronological narrative; he may ask for authorities, and find no footnotes. But if, on this account, he concludes that the book is not worthy of his seri- ous attention, he will make a great mis- take. From the nature of the case, it was impossible for Dr. De Cesare to cite many of his informers by name. The point is, does any special statement seem alien to the men or to the society that he describes? No one who knows those twenty years intimately can doubt that Papal Rome is here drawn to the life. On reflection it will also appear that this method serves well for giving the very heart of a period which had no regular parliamentary development. The Papacy of those decades was like a water-logged vessel drifting towards a cataract: its crew, instead of observ- ing the direction of the current, manned the oars and rowed frantically down- stream. If any one kept the log, it has not been published. The historian must trust, therefore, to the testimony of spectators on the banks. It is these spectators whom Dr. De Cesare has pumped to so good purpose, that, although we have not now, and may never have, the inside history of what went on in the Vatican between 1850 and 1870, we know what is to be known, and we can surmise as to much that has been hidden. Merely on the personal side, his book is notable. Here are portraits of Pio Nono, who was not at all the mild saint that latter-day beatifiers make him out; of Antonelli, who held the rudder and bade the oars- men row with all their might to perdi- tion; of Mérode, the Belgian fanatic, who beguiled Pius for a time, and was then thrown over by him; of the Duke of Sermoneta, of Prince Alessandro Tor- lonia, and of many others who played their part, on one side or the other, in those fateful years. reign and the collapse of the Bourbon | items may not seem important; but their cumulative effect cannot be gain- ‘said. All the evidence, whether special or general, proves that the Papacy, as a form of secular government, had com- pletely broken down. There was little or no justice in the courts; neither hon- esty nor dispatch in the bureaus; no check on immorality, lay or clerical, in the capital; no help for agriculture in the provinces; no tolerance; no educa- tion. These facts Dr. De Cesare tells without invective, and without even partisan bias. He recognizes that, since they speak for themselves, he does not need to expound or denounce them. On the growth of Papal intransigence in political and mixed affairs, this book furnishes much information. It shows us how, in 1850, Pius IX returned to Rome an immutable reactionary; how, being in this frame of mind, he became an easy tool for the Jesuits to use; and how they formulated their intransigence in the dogmas of the Immaculate Con- ception and of Papal Infallibility, and in the Syllabus, which, until Pius X’s imitation of it appeared two years ago, was regarded as the ne plus ultra of obscurantism. On the political side, we have an informal account of the Pied- montese efforts at negotiation; followed by the Garibaldian expeditions, by the departure and return of the French, and by the downfall of the Papacy on Sep- tember 20, 1870. In this field should also be classed the methods and at- 'tempts of the conspirators, about whom Dr. De Cesare has a good deal to say, and such an episode as the kidnapping of the Jew boy, Mortara, which did more than any other single Papal act to horrify the conscience of the civilized world. The reader needs to be inform- ed that all these matters are treated at much greater length in the original. The condensation has been made with an eye to what is most significant for the English-speaking public; and it has been done well: but the student should consult the two large volumes of the Italian work, for much collateral evi- dence and for such documents as were available. The total impression left by Dr. De Cesare is that of comprehensiveness. Papal Rome is all here, inglorious, pic- turesque, immoral, cynical, moribund— a system which originated amid medi- @val conditions, and projected itself through seven decades of the ninetcenth century, amid conditions which it could not live in and which it therefore curs- ed. Through these pages pass and re- |pass the monsignori, the prelates, the Besides much information about the | Papal system of finance—if that may be | Jesuits, the worldly cardinals, the un- yielding ecclesiastics, the seeming-genial here is that eoaisediten society, easy- going and irresponsible, that no scan- dal could shock. And here are the patri- ots, working steadfastly in the shadow of the gallows, or, as at Perugia and in the Romagna, coming into the open to face death in actual combat. The French garrison in Rome, the Austrians in the Legations, add to the paradoxes with which these years are strewn. It is well that so true a book, written sv attractively, should he read by Amert- can Catholics, who have been taught, by the recrudescent Ultramontanism which prevails just now among the American hierarchy, that the Rome of Papal times was a sort of Paradise, where virtue and piety held unbroken sway in all hearts. In Dr. De Cesare’s unvarnished tale, they will come to understand what that Temporal Power was, the recovery of which is no more seriously thought of in Italy than is the restoration of the Brit- ish sovereign in New York. It is twenty years since Cardinal Hohenlohe wrote the memorable letter to Leo XIII in which he said: “God has so ordained that the Church can never again get back her temporal power. The salvation ot souls requires that we resign our- selves to this fact, that we keep quietly within the ecclesiastical sphere, and per- form charity by giving of our substance and by teaching the faithful.” But in fairness, we must repeat that Dr. De Cesare (who is, we believe, a Catholic) is never polemical; his skill lies in unfolding a series of moving pic- tures in which the reader sees for him- self what was going on. To those who study the history of institutions dispas- sionately, as the naturalist studies the evolution of species, this panorama of the decrepitude and dissolution of the Papal institution may be recommended. Nero fiddled when Rome was burning. This is what Pius IX did on September 20, 1870, when the Italians were entering the Eternal City: At half-past ten the diplomatic corps left the Vatican. After their departure the Pope resumed his easy good humor, and seating himself at his writing-table, composed, in all tranquillity, a charade in three verses upon the word tremare (to tremble). One of his chief amusements was the composi- tion of charades, which he thought of easily, and which were not difficult to guess. The “whole” of thecharade of September 20 rep- resented a weakness he did not feel in that moment. The charade was passed from hand to hand among the monsignori of the court. Il tre non Oltrepassa 1] mio primiero; E Valtro molto vasto e molto infido Che spesso spesso fa provar l'intero. Significant episodes of this kind, scatter- ‘ed plentifully throughout Dr. De Ce sare’s volume, make it not only very called a system which had none—of ju-| Pius, handsome in face, soft of hands, |entertaining, but historically valuable. dicial and municipal administration, but with that capacity for bursts of | Occasionally, he stops for a moment to and about economic and commercial con- rage which belongs to very amiable per- | pass ditions, the reader will find scores of sons when they are thwarted. Here are be appears in the following summing sidelights on the actual life of the vari- | the artists—the painters, sculptors, and up of the effect of the Roman environ- ous classes. Taken one by one, these musicians—from all over the world; | ment on Italian political progress: pass judgment. How profound he can

Page 18

600 Rome has carried even into national life her keen and characteristic skepticism, be- fore which the strongest impetus dies down, and the most rooted convictions yield to the temptations of opportunism, and, still more, to that law of adaptability before which the city, at all times, has bowed, and caused its conquerors to bow. There is the text for a volume in those last two lines. The translation has been well done by the practised hand of Miss Helen Zim- mern; G. M. Trevelyan contributes a brief historical preface; and among the illustrations are portraits of Pius IX, Sermoneta, Mortara, Mérode, Antonelli, Lamoriciére, Cardina] Altieri, and Prince Doria Panfill. CURRENT FICTION, Priscilla of The Good Intent. By Halli- well Sutcliffe. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. This “Romance of the Gray Fells” has all that goes to make up an English rural novel; vast abundance of scen- ery, of dialect, of agriculture; a black- smith’s forge; a village “natural”; yeo man and shepherd; wild-rose maiden and moorland gypsy; faithful dullard and flighty woman-enslaver; the black fever, and many times four seasons— the whole lavishly decorated with bird, beast, and flower. The usual order of things, however, suffers reversal, in that it is the butterfly who undergoes regen- eration, the hare who wins the race from the tortoise. The rustic folk of this book are endued with vigorous reality. One who reads may feel at moments an inclination to run swiftly up and down the landscape, yet the pastoral setting has charm and significance, the story holds interest in suspense to the last, and the tone never swerves from its high pitch. Posson Jone’ and Péire Raphaél. With a New Word Setting Forth How and Why the Two Tales Are One. By George W. Cable. New York: Chas. Scribner's Sons. With respectful sympathy one reads Mr. Cable's newly inscribed introduction to his Creole stories of Parson Jones, the Parson's “Colossus,” Jules, Jules’s Baptiste, the sweethearts of these last, the Judge, 'Sleur Davezac, et al. One easily agrees that to print these two familiar tales together “is a require- ment of their veritable unity, thelr es- sential oneness, a genuine love-match, made in heaven, as lovers say, and bred of an affinity back of all time.” These admirable fragments of romance, finely colored throughout, albeit not pellucid, make a brave showing in their new holiday dress, gayly illustrated by Stanley M. Arthurs. One is glad to re- new his friendship with Jules St. Anges, “that elegant little heathen”; with the delicious Creole maiden whom The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2320 he loves and who loves him no !ess; with Abby’s sugar-country bridegroom, in buckskin breeches above exquisite top-boots, “and a fawn-skin vest vuder his voluminous coat, giving an effect half-pioneer, half-Incroyable.” Creole New Orleans has all but passed away, and even in the New Orleans of Jules St. Ange such a get-up as that of M. Dimitry Davezac, from the sugar-coun- try, “was odd,” confesses Mr. Cuble. With the passing of an old-time pro- vincialism, much needed in our monot- onous land of literary prairie, departs a fine subject-matter for artist, liter- ary or pictorial. Mr. Cable has worked in that field, and his delicately rendered | studies and sketches we are proud to garner. Even our dislike of dialect— a relative dislike, after all—does not de- ter us from tasting his conversations with real pleasure. Aunt Amity’s Silver Wedding, and Oth- er Stories. By Ruth McEnery Stuart. New York: The Century Company. Interest never sleeps in Mrs. Stuart’s stories. Each one furnishes an addi- tion to the reader’s circle of friends or cabinet of curios. The characters play their parts with such lively plausibility that one thinks of them as photographs and of the stories as folk-lore. In so do- ing, there may be an injustice to the author’s powers of invention. She may have largely created her queer folk and the likenesses may be “hand-painted.” If so, it is an historical imagination that has conceived them on lines truer than those of mere facts. Mrs. Stuart reads deep into the African nature. She sits at home within; she looks with her sub- jects’ eyes and feels with their own feelings both their joys and hurts. And, more than that, she conveys a sense of pain in the laugh, which is the real note of the situation. Aunt Amity, planning | her droll silver wedding, “Petty Lar- ceny’s” thieving little sweetheart, lying Levi, lawless “Free Jane”—each raises an inevitable laugh, but it is a laugh with a sigh at its centre, and a question peint at its end. No writer better blends the contraries into an impres- sion which sinks deep without for an instant calling itself a lesson. The Wiving of Lance Cleaverage. By Alice MacGowan. New York: G. P. Put- nam's Sons. To the highlands of Tennessee this story takes us, and under competent guidance. Back and forth through the Cumberlands and up and down Big and Little Turkey Track Mountains go we from cabin door to mountain cave, through woods and farm-lands to wed- dings, infares, and sorghum-makings. We form varied acquaintance with the mountain people and find them courteous yet austere folk. The difficulties that beset Lance and j Callista before they reached a happy married haven are of general human interest, but in the case of the hero, take on especial coloring from his tem- perament—which is distinctly a Tennes- see mountain product. A mere South- erner might have been as gayly debon- air, but hardly as dreamy a cloud-dwell- er. A Yankee might have been as flag- |rantly self-assured, but he would have been insufferable where the mountain- eer’s airy insolence only drew to him all ;}men, women, and children. With Callista it is otherwise. Hers is the case of many a spoiled beauty who does not know how to cook. Her regen- eration by fire—the kitchen fire—is of |no geographic significance; and her sec- ‘ond desertion of her post seems more /& means to prolong the story than an | inevitable step. There are most excellent character portrayals all along the way, }one of the prominent actors being a marvellous “gospel quilt.” Debit and Credit. By Gustav Freytag. Translated by L.-C. Cummings. With a Preface by Chevalier Christian C. J. Bunsen. New York: William Abbatt. This is not a new translation of Frey- tag’s masterpiece, but a reprint of the original English version, first issued half a century ago, and still in no need of supersession. “Soll und Haben,” pub- lished in 1855, was the most popular German novel of its day, and the English translation, though sold at 15 shillings, ran through six edi- tions in two years. Its success was due in large part to its timeliness. It cele- brated the emergence of the mercantile classes from a position of inferiority to one of influence and dignity in social and political life. Elsewhere, as in “Dombey and Son,” published some years earlier, the note had been heard; but Freytag sounded it with an aggres- siveness which caught the ear of Eu- rope. To the present translation, issued in 1857 by Constable, a long letter by the Chevalier Bunsen was prefixed. This is reproduced in the present edition. Bun sen warmly eulogizes the novel, and claims for it an epical quality which, he says, belongs to all romances of the first order. But it has also, he contends, a prophetic function: it conditions the fu- ture progress of Europe upon the fu- sion of the educated classes, their “just and Christian bearing” toward the work- ing masses, and the final dominance of “the educated middle classes of all na- tions,” not as constituting a democracy, ‘but as advancing “along the legal path to a perfect constitutional monarchy.” It is doubtful if we so clearly foresee the changes of the coming half-century. Certainly Freytag’s story has a vitality unlikely to be recognized fifty years ‘hence in the prophetic writings of Jack | London, H. G. Wells, et ai.

Page 19

Dec. 16, 1909]

The Nation.

TWO NAPOLEON BOOKS. The Ezile of St. Helena: The Last Phase in Fact and Fiction. From the French of Philippe Gonnard. Illustrated. Phil- adelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $3.50 net. Napoleon's Marshals. By R. P. Dunn-Pat- tison, M.A. With twenty illustrations. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. $3 net. Napoleon showed his usual insight when he remarked to O’Meara: “People are curious to know the most trifling circumstances in the life of a man who has played a great part.” The details of his life at St. Helena, his conversa- tions, and supreme regrets, his Passion (as Heine would have said) under Sir Hudson Lowe, have all been set forth for eager readers in Napoleon’s own memoirs and in the memorials of his fellow-exiles. They have also been told ponderously by Forsyth and charmingly by Lord Rosebery. M. Gonnard has been wise in refraining from trying to give another general picture of Napoleon as he was at St. Helena. Instead, he stud- ies what Napoleon desired France to think he had been—in other words, the Napoleonic Legend. By legend we do not mean merely the popular exaggera-| tion of his military glory, of his love for his soldiers, or of his part in the Civil Code. evitable, but, unless reinforced, would never have deeply influenced French politics. The real Napoleonic Legend, so M. Gonnard thinks, was manufactured at St. Helena. By his very martyrdom on the lonely rock, Napoleon knew that he would arouse sympathy for himself and for the cause of his son. But by his writings he saw that he could do much more. So he began his memoirs. His method of work was to have one of his | This exaggeration was in-| <ompanions collect the facts, figures, | dates, etc., for a certain period, and ar- subject, and dictated very rapidly a chapter or the fragment of a chapter. “only one of fourteen.” Tange them. Then Napoleon looked over dozen other marshals were created. these notes, saturated himself with his | poleon made them all feel plainly that that all the members of his family were unusually talented and fond of him, but did him much harm through well-mean- ing errors. Such are some of the ele- ments of the Legend. To each the au- thor devotes a chapter, fortifying his opinion with countless quotations, and explaining away St. Helena utterances which seem in contradiction to the Legend. His conclusion is that the man of St. Helena equalled the man of Aus- terlitz. The Legend then passed to Eu- rope, where it was powerfully swelled by Thiers and Norvins, by Béranger and Victor Hugo, and helped to seat a second Cesar in the saddle. Yet it was one of the strange ironies of history that the crown which had been so patiently pre- pared by the captive of St. Helena for his own son was actually worn by the son of his hostile brother Louis. The great value of M. Gonnard’s interesting study lies in the thoroughness with which he has analyzed the St. Helena literature and shown its relation to the later history of the Bonapartist party. One understands better how such 2 Ro- man Catholic as Montalembert could join hands with the Bonapartists in 1848, and how Napoleon III could say at Bordeaux: “The Empire means peace.” The author’s estimates of Gourgaud and Las Cases are much truer than Lord Rosebery’s, and his bibliography much better than that in the Cambridge Mod- ern History or that in the pretentious compilation of Kircheisen. When Napoleon assumed the crown he revived the old title of Marshal of France as a means of binding more per- manently to his cause the men whose swords had helped to establish his pow- er. In the first batch of appointments he gave the baton to fourteen men, some of whom seemed scarcely to deserve it, and some of whom, on the other band, like Masséna, felt it small honor to be Later on, a Na- they were his servants, created by him, ‘and dependent on him. The title of From it there was made the next day a. second version: fuller, riper, better ar- ranged. times corrected and altered by pencil- lings in Napoleon’s own hand before it was given to Europe. With great indus- try and ingenuity, M. Gonnard has analyzed all these writings, as well as the memorials of Las Cases, Montholon, O'Meara, and the others, and finds a cal- culated purpose to establish in men’s minds the following ideas in regard to Napoleon: that he was the convinced and disinterested representative of the ideas of 1789, but was forced by sheer necessity to assume dictatorial power; that he favored the idea of nationality; that he believed in God; that he wish- ed for peace, but was constantly forced dnto war by the European coalitions;

This in turn was often many | This was only the first rough draft. marshal was merely a civil distinction “which gives you the honorable rank at my court which is your due, but it car- ries with it no authority. On the battle- field you are generals; at court you are nobles.” Of each of these marshals Mr. Dunn-Pattison, late lieutenant of a High- land regiment and sometime lecturer at Magdalen College, has given brief, sharp- ly-lined pen portraits, with many judi- cious military observations, showing in- dependence of thought and no more than normal British prejudice. But it is a bit tiresome to march through all the Napoleonic wars twenty-six times in succession. To those readers who have small knowledge of Napoleonic military history many of the allusions and comparisons will lose their point; and those who know this period well will find here little that is really new.

GO1 Kashmir. Described by Francis E. Younghusband and Painted by Ed- ward Molyneux. London: Adam and Charles Black; New York: The Mac- millan Co. $6 net. In this book the series of geographi- cal volumes aptly described by the pub- lishers as “Black's Beautiful Books,” reaches what may be described as Himalayan heights of excellence. Here are exquisite colored pictures of the most beautiful country in the world, supplemented by a verbal description of Kashmir which includes the latest geological and historical data. The specialist will find here the gist of Stein’s work and of the still more re- cent geological treatises of Burrard and Hayden, not mentioned only but discuss- ed. Sir Francis Younghusband is him- self no mean authority on the subjects he treats, though, curiously enough, for any save the most superficial read- er the volume is logically to be read backwards. It ends with the beginning of things, some millions of years ago; then, retrograding through the pages, one comes to human history; until, finally, at the beginning, the author himself appears, and wanders through the “paradise of the gods.” The author is least at home in the historical background of his sunject. Here one misses the little touches that show special knowledge. Thus it would not have been amiss, apropos of the bare allusion to saffron, to mention that in ancient days the saffron of Kashmir sur- passed that of Balkh as much as the latter surpassed that of Persia. Again, in the author's justified sneer at a peo- ple capable of making a reputation only by making shawls, it might have been noticed that it was not shawls, but race- horses and literature, which made Kash- mir famous two thousand years ago. To digress only for a moment—since these fourteen chapters have not been made a mere excuse for paint, but offer, to say the least, a useful condensation of data not easily to be obtained elsewhere— it is to be noted that Major Molyneux’s pictures, seventy in number, are on a par with those of precedent works in this series. This is, indeed, saying too little. The scenery of Kashmir is un- surpassed, and the present artist has been equal to his opportunities. But, because of the obvious attractiveness of the illustrations, the text should re- ceive no whit the less encomium. And a curious fact, often noticed before and corroborated by Sir Francis in this book, may be mentioned as a possible subject for examination at the hands of competent observers. Living as he does amid scenery sublime as well as heau- tiful, man in this “Land of the Sun” ts the greatest coward on earth. Nothing is too ignominious for him; even in the presence of his wife or sweetheart the Kashmiran will burst out crying at the _mere bark of a puppy. To make a sol-

Page 20

[Vol. 89, No. 2320 dier of him is impossible. Though often a fine figure personally, he is unexcelled in shameless pusillanimity. This can- not be attributed to the effects of the re- ligion of Buddha, since the Kashmiran been free of that for a thousand nor to cruel treatment, for the Hindu of the Plains has suffered as much; nor to the climate, which is not Why is it (Sir Francis of- fers no explanation) that where every has years; bad. very The Nation. les. The old Duchess, lying in Marl- borough House and exclaiming, when told that she must be blistered or die, seems but a tragic and articulate sym- bol of that greatness. taste we take leave to differ from Mr. Chancellor. Speaking of the changes that have been made in the drawing room of Chesterfield House since its stately decorum under the great Lord prospect pleases most, man is most Chesterfield, he remarks: vile? As for the Kashmiran’s ethics : What has since been added by the care he is humane and kindly; but where 2 y morality demands courage, he is as he “having so great a respect for truth that he is unwilling to make common use of it.” is, Relics and Memorials of London City. By James S. Ogilvy. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $7 net. The Private Palaces of London, Pcst and Present. By E. Beresford Chan- cellor. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $5 net. Mr. Ogilvy’s work has one advan: tage over most ornamental books, in that text and pictures, being from one hand, have a real relation to each oth- er. All the buildings of the City chosen him for illustration and comment were standing when the present century began, yet, as he remarks, a considera- ble number of them have already been pulled down or altered, so that in a few years his book will not be so much a present record of the past as a past record of a greater past. In general, the anecdotes or fragments of history given by the author to vivify his mem- orial buildings are pretty obvious, but that, for his purpose, is scarcely to their disadvantage. The pictures, six- ty-four in number, are full-page (quar- to) color plates, and are sufficiently real- istic to recall the actual scenes to any one familiar with the City streets and They are artistic, too, save that they suffer, as do almost all color prints, from too elaborate shading and blending. As the process of printing now stands, the attempt to reproduce complicated shades and blends general- ly results in muddiness. This criticism, however, is directed more to a whole class of books than to the particular volume under review. Mr. Ogilvy has succeeded in making an attractive com- bination of description and illustration. Mr. Chancellor writes not as a dilet- tante of the picturesque, but as a verita- ble antiquary, and his latest book on “The Private Palaces of London” Is a work substantial both in form and mat- ter. His accounts of the various houses by lanes. are orderly bits of historical writing, although the lighter entertafnment of anecdote is by no means neglected. Be- tween the lines one can read of the great pageantry and the great ambi- tions of life for more than two centur- and discrimination of the present owner gives just that touch of comfort and home- liness which is more characteristic of our day than it was of those of the earlier Georges, when the great ones of the earth seem always to have existed en grande tenue. Now the magnificently dec- orated walls and ceiling look not down on an almost empty room, with chairs and settees set formally against the walls, and perhaps a solitary escritoire or commode standing isolated in its vast expanse, but on a room filled with rare French furni- ture; tables loaded with costly bric-Aa-brac; chairs covered in valuable tapestries, which seem to invite familiar intercourse; cabinets filled, etc., etc. With due respect we submit that a glance at the picture of this overluaded drawing room makes one sigh for a simplicity that inclined even to rigid- ness; not in this china-shop can the true graces of conversation ever flourish. As for mere comfort, the great Chesterfield sought that and but for failing health found it in the library with its famous motto and pictures. The forty-four photographic illustra- tions of Mr. Chancellor's volume are, for the still existing houses, chiefly of interiors. That is no doubt right, as the interiors are hidden from the common sight-seer; yet he would have added to the interest of his work if he had given more views of exteriors also. Drei Jahrhunderte deutschen Lebens in Amerika. Von Rudolf Cronau. Berlin: Dietrich Reimer (Ernst Vohsen). Undeterred by the recent publication of Georg von Bosse’s “Das deutsche Element in den Vereinigten Staaten,” and inspired, very likely, by his own “Amerika: die Geschichte seiner Ent- deckung,” Rudolf Cronau has undertak- en, in a large-octavo of 640 pages, *o' sketch the fortunes and m'sfortunes, the endeavors and accomplishments, of Ger- mans in the United States during the past three hundred years. With more system and with far more thoroughness | than Von Bosse, he divides his work | into two main parts, the first tracing “the Germans” in America during the Colonial period, the second following “the German-Americans” in their par- ticipation in the development of the Union. Since 1885, a resident in and traveller through the United States, and ‘the author of several works in German “I won't be blistered and I won't die,” | In one point of. and English on America, even including |a severe criticism of forest mismanage- ‘ment (“Our Wasteful Nation,” 1908), Cronau comes to h's work fairly equip- ped and evidences an intelligent under- standing of most of the problems before him. There are interesting notes on the first Flugblitter regarding America which drew the earliest Germans to us, and equally interesting information, not so commonly possessed, about Her- mann of Virginia and New Amsterdam, “the first German to make American maps,” and about Lederer, the first German explorer of America. There are also chapters on the various communal sects, such as the Mennonites, Tunkers, ‘and Herrnhuters, and on the exodus to Pennsylvania and elsewhere of the na- tives of the Pfalz. In rather strong col- ors, perhaps, he portrays the Germans who fought in the Revolution and whose bravery and intelligence have long been recognized by American historians. The political exiles of '48, and the good they brought to our country are recognized, Carl Schurz standing conspicuously, al- most alone, in the chapter on the Ger- man in American political life. Two hundred and twenty-nine pages are de- voted to the part taken by Germans in American culture—to their influence on schools, agriculture and forestry, indus- try, commerce, engineering, journalism and authorship, medicine, music, paint- ing, sculpture, architecture, and the the- atre. In the discussion of the Turn- verein much is claimed that should not be forgotten by Americans, but too lit- tle is allowed by the author to the over- powering influence of English sport on physical culture in America. The Sources for a History of the German Elements in the United States should prove to be a chapter of particular value—timely, too, now that Professor Learned is at work for the Carnegie Foundation on an exhaustive research along the same lines. Two hundred and ten exceptionally good illustrations, from photographs and drawings, make the work the best of its kind yet produced. The shortcomings of the book are em- phasized by its general excellence. There is, we think, a little too much attention in text and illustration on the commercial aspect of German successes, and for a true history of the German in the New World, there should be a boid statement, here and there, of misdoing on the part of an occasional Altgeld, Schmidt, and Hummel, if for no other /reason than as a salutary correction of the idea all too prevalent in Germany that the German element has always been the best in America. The most serious defect in the volume, however, is the omission of notable names. Among those conspicuous by their absence, are Dr. Frederick W. Holls; Isaac Thomas Hecker, the Paulist Father of Brook Farm celebrity; Lenau, the poet, who roved the Western plains; the Tafels,

Page 21

Dec. 16, 1909] 603 and Dr. Gescheidt of New York; Dr. Julius, of Hamburg, the traveller and translator of Ticknor; and Von Schlagintweit, the explorer of the Pa- cific Coast. Much is said of Busch, the St. Louis brewer, but nothing of Louis Soldan, the head of the city schools. The accomplished Fraulein von Wencke- bach of Wellesley receives due credit, but there is no mention of her accomplished colleague, Friulein Miiller. These names come to the reviewer al- most instantly, and arouse the suspicion that the total number of omissions may be very great. And this suggests the question: Now that several attempts have recently been made by private in- dividuals, and at much expense, to write and publish the history of the Germans in America, and always with imperfect success, is it not time that representa- tive German societies should combine, once and for all, to undertake an of- ficial record covering this ground? Oniy by such a _ thorough investigation, scarcely to be expected from a pri- vate author or publisher, can we hope ever to have a full and satisfactory his- tory of German life and culture in America. Notes. Frederick A. Stokes Co. announce for early publication “The Child's English Literature,” by H. E. Marshall, a book written primarily not for use in the schools, but for home reading. An at- tempt has been made to bring within the ken of children something of the actual relation between history and literature. On December 28 the University of Chi- cago Press will issue “The Treatment of Nature in English Poetry,” by Myra Rey- nolds. Not confining herself narrowly to the subject suggested by her title, Profes- sor Reynolds will include in the book a chapter dealing with the art of landscape and with landscape in English portraiture J. M. Barrie wrote for the Westminster Gazette, last May, an article on George Meredith, which, among the many essays inspired by the novelist’s death, is one of the very few worthy of preservation. The Chiswick Press is to reprint Mr. Bar- rie’s article on hand-made paper, and the booklet will be published by the Messrs. ‘Constable (London). The Constables are, too, the publishers of the anthology announced long since, “In Praise of Oxford.” The volume will be published early in 1910, and is the re- sult of collaboration by Thomas Seccombe and Spencer Scott. To the Arthur H. Clark Company, Cleve- land, we look for the new and first-pub- lished biography of Timothy Flint: pioneer, missionary, author (1780-1840). The book is by Prof. J. B. Kirkpatrick of Wash- burn College, Topeka, who has, it is said, brought to light a great deal of new ma- terial of more than purely personal sig- nificance. W. Dawson Johnston, librarian of Colum- bia University, is preparing for the United The Nation. States Bureau of Education a report on special collections in libraries in the Unit- ed States. The publication is to be a ‘record of all collections in public libraries which are of extraordinary value by reason either of unusual completeness or rarity. Eight volumes of verse in one week is a publishing record, or very near one; and is seored by Richard G. Badger of Bos- ton. The list includes W. H. Venable’s “Floridian Sonnets’; O. C. Auringer’'s “Death of Maid McCrea”; “The Oak Amongst the Pines,” by J. D. Henderson; Ernest Powell's “Poems”; T. C. Whitmer’s “Symbolisms”; Effie Smith’s “Rosemary and Pansies”; Wilson Jefferson's ‘‘Verses,” and “The Silver Lining,” by Nelson Gla- zier Morton. Madison C. Bates is preparing a biblio- graphical study of the poet Cowper, and would be glad to receive communications from collectors and students of the material. He may be addressed at No. 457 West One Hundred and Twenty-third Street, New York city. At once the poorest thing and the “best thing” in the volume of “Milton Memorial Lectures, 1908: Read Before the Royal So- ciety of Literature’ (Frowde) is the lec- ture by the Rev. H. G. Rosedale, D.D., upon Milton's religion and polemics. We prefer to consider Dr. Rosedale’s offering rather than the paper by William Henry Hadow on Milton's knowledge of music, Professor Saintsbury’s on “Milton and the Grand Style,” or Professor Dowden's on “Para- dise Regained.” For even the best of these is merely a collection of “re- marks"; and the whole book is ludicrous- ly inadequate to its occasion. What will most interest the student of Milton is, however, likely to be Dr. Rosedale's cool assumption of the poet’s authorship of the “Nova Solyma” (p. 123); or his ref- erence to Nathan Drake—b. 1766; d. 1836— as a writer of Milton’s period (p. 133); or his allusion (p. 131) to Savonarola as hav- ing lived about the year 1545; or his casual grouping (p. 118) of “Spenser, Giles, and Fletcher.’’ We pass over errors in his Eng- lishing of foreign tongues; perhaps we should not expose, either, his quotation (p. 160) of Milton’s Latin preface to “Samson Agonistes”: “Trageedia est imitatio acti- onis seriw, etc., per misericordiam et me- tum perficiens talium affectuum lustratio- nem,” as original with Milton, obviously unaware that it is a litera) translation from Aristotle’s ‘“‘Poetics.”” Though in these few sentences the tale of Dr. Rosedale’s blunders is by no means exhausted, his qualifications for treating the subject un- dertaken are, perhaps, sufficiently sug- gested. This volume is worth preservation, however; it contains reproductions of four excellent portraits. In “Romantic Germany” (Century Co.) Robert Haven Schauffler fights constantly against the dulness that pervades so many modern books of travel, but not quite vic- toriously. Again and again he endeavors to bring his own personality into his de- scriptions, yet somehow that personality melts vaguely awaylikethe ‘‘Eitel Schaum’”’ of Heine’s poem. Perhaps no writer, what- ever the charm of his style, could manage gracefully the mass of material which Mr. Schauffler has brought into his book. Twelve ancient and opulent cities the writer has chosen, from Danzig to Rothenburg, from Berlin to Hildesheim, and for each he tries to be, literally, guide, philosopher, and friend. The guide repeatedly overwhelms the friendly philosopher, and the author's impression is lost under the many names of streets and buildings. It has been said that one influence of Stevenson was to make even the suburban journalist write with something like ease. Perhaps an other of Stevenson's influences was to in- fuse clearness and charm into books of travel. Mr. Schauffler, though undoubtedly a Stevensonian and nice in his choice of words, leaves everywhere a blurred impres- sion, as if he had been unable to escape the proverbial heaviness of the land he studied Sixty-four full-page illustrations by a num- ber of artists embellish this volume, and typographically it leaves nothing be desired. to There is a good deal of keen and thought- ful criticism in Alexander Francis’s “‘Amer- icans: An Impression” (Appleton) The author, a Scotchman long resident in Rus- sia, and approaching his task with a gen- erous cosmopolitan detachment, seems to have given most of his one year in this country to a study of such social ques- tions as foreign immigration and race feel- ing, the work of university settlements and higher education. While in all these matters he is confident that we shall come out right in the end, he finds in our poll- tics an ominous trend towards an “elective despotism”; though his view of Taft's elec- tion, “as a guarantee that the cure of the evils of democracy will be sought in more, not less, democracy,”’ plainly belongs to the period before the enactment of the Payne-Aldrich tariff. Of a socialistic over- turning, however, he hag no fear, partly because Socialism means so many different things to the people who the term, and partly because incoming foreigners show rapid assimilation of American ways, including the deliberate restriction of fam- ilies. There is special praise for the Jews, in whose intellectual superiority Mr. Fran- cis seems heartily to believe; and he con- stantly recurs to the evidences of their gain in commercial, educational, and phil- anthropic influence. Yet he recognizes the tendency of Jews of the second generation to depart from their historic religion with out embracing another; and sees in this tendency a moral problem with which the leaders of the race cannot too soon con- cern themselves. Over American colleges and universities he is not enthusiastic, though his strictures are directed chiefly to fraternities and clubs, athletics, coedu- cation, and the pervadingly secular atm»- sphere. To have written a book of ‘“‘im- pressions’’ without mentioning hotels, or railway trains, or young women’s manners is in itself a feat; but this, also, Mr ; cis has done, and to the immense advan- tage of his suggestive pages. use The Riverside Press has printed for the Essex Book and Print Club of Salem, Maass., a small edition of the “New-Englands Plantation with The Sea Journal and Other Writings,” by the Rev. Francis Higginson, “First Minister of the Plantation at Salem in the Massachusetts Bay Colony.” The tract called “New-Englands Plantation,” published in London early in 1630, has not been reprinted since 1846, and contains the earliest printed account of the colony es- tablished by Endecott in 1628. at Neihum-

Page 22

604 kek, now Salem. A quaint statement of the natural conditions surrounding the new set- tlement is also preserved, the narrative presenting, in the phrase of the original, “a short and true description of the com- modities and discommodities of that coun- try.” The tract and its title-pages are re- produced here in facsimile of the editio princeps; too much cannot be said of the excellent presswork and paper which go to make this volume, thé first of the Essex Book and Print Club’s publications, a re- print which the collector of Americana will have every wish to own. In the preface to the English edition of his “Life of Joan of Arc”’’ (John Lane) Ana- tole France had an opportunity to reply to his critics, and chiefly to Andrew Lang. Th» amazing softness of M. France’s answer has not dissipated Mr. Lang's wrath: “My Eng- lish critics have a special claim to my gratitude. To the memory of Joan of Arc they consecrate a pious zeal which is al most an expiatory worship. Mr. Andrew Lang's praiseworthy scruples with regard to my references have caused me to correct some and to add several.”” The corrections bave not been applied to the apparently baseless charges that the Maid was subjec: at Vaucouleurs to “‘les outrages de la garni- son,’ that she feigned ecstasy to deceive the King, and that her squire d’Aulon wis a creature of La Trémoille, though a qual: fication is made in a note on the last ma; ter which destroys the meaning of the tex: The purely clerical errors have been cor- rected, but such slight changes and addi- tions as have been noted show that V France Is of the same opinion still. The translator, Winifred Stephens, has done her work well, though this book gave her an exceptionally difficult task. The great charm exercised by the original depended largely on the purely technical skill with which M. France developed a style to suit his purpose, a style partly archaic and naive, but never labored. The English ver- sion imitates this manner pleasantly enough, means a somewhat weari- but uses as a some parataxis. The book contains some excellent illustrations, which were not included in the French edition “The Last Journals of Horace Walpole, During the Reign of George III, from 1771- 1783," were first given to the world, in 1858, by Dr. J. Doran, with notes after the manner of that popular editor and collector of literary anecdotes. A new edition in two agreeable volumes is now put out by John Lane Co., with an introduction and some revision by A. Francis Steuart. These journals are a continuation of Walpole’s “Memoirs of the Reign of George III"’; and, if they lack the general finish and, above a‘l, the clean-cut portrait-characterizations of the memoirs, they have interest of an- other to compensate. The central theme the marriage of the Duke of Gloucester, brother of the King, with Lady sort is Marion Waldegrave, Walpole’s niece, and the struggle to get the marriage acknowl- edged by the court. There is also a run- ning account of Parliamentary doings dur- ing those stirring years, which include the American war and the successful contest with the court party. The present edition contains a number of portraits reproduced from contemporary pictures The Manorial Society of London has is- sued as its fifth publication the text of a [Vol. 89, No. 2320 manuscript found in the Harleian collec- examination of Argentina as a great ex- The Nation. ——=_»—— tion in the British Museum entitled “A porter of wheat, and has an introduction Mannor and Court Baron.” The work is | by Charles Pellegrini, former President of edited by the antiquarian, Nathaniel J.| ‘he republic, and a preface by Emile Le- Hone, and a preface has been written by | Vasseur, member of the French Institute. J. Samuel Green, a barrister member of | In this series are volumes on “Le Brésil au the society. It is a legal treatise dealing | XXe siécle,” by Pierre Denis, and on “Les chiefly with the functions and procedure of Etats-Unis au XXe siécle,” by Pierre Le- | the Court Baron, and is of date probably | "°Y-Beaulieu. not later than the reign of Elizabeth. It | Prof. Erich Schmidt’s address on “The is couched in technical phraseology in- telligible only to an expert in legal terms, and is written in a style that is often uncouth and confused. We cannot see that it adds anything to our knowledge of the history or constitution of the Court Baron, and it seems to be of little worth either to the lawyer or to the historian. The edi- tors have done nothing to lighten the dark- ness of the text, for Mr. Hone has eon- tented himself with securing an accurate reading, and Mr, Green with contributing @ meagre and elementary essay on the manor in law and history. The treatise is sufficiently obscure to render com- mentary and footnotes eminently desir- able, but neither has been furnished by the society. The “The New Schaff- fifth volume of Herzog Encyclopedia of Religious Know- | ledge,” to be completed in twelve volume:;, follows its predecessor after an interval of three months. (New York; Funk & Wag- ralls Co.). Articles from “Saint Goar’’ to ‘Innocent’ are found in the present is- sue. None of the contributions is lengthy or exhaustive, but most of them are ad- equate for a book of convenient reference, and the work as a whole is marked by sound scholarship. In the present volume Prof. George H. Gilmore adds to his former valuable contributions. articles on “Hammurabi and his Code,” “Herod and his Family,” and “The Hittites.” Of ex- ceptional interest are articles by Prof. Im- manuel Benzinger on “Hebrew Handi- crafts” and “Hunting among the He- brews."" The topics in the department of aoctrinal theology, assigned to Prof. Charles A. Beckwith, are well treated, in striking | contrast to the mediwvalism exhibited by l’rof. B. B. Warfield in his discussion of “Imputation.”” It is unfortunate that a moderate and cautious description of the bistorical view of the ‘“Hexateuch,” by Prof. Hermann L. Strack, should be fol- lowed in the same article, without adequate | Study of Literary Personality,” delivered |on October 15 at the occasion of his offi- ‘cially assuming the Rektorat of Berlin Uni- ‘versity for the current academic year, ts a confession of faith which literary histo- |rians of whatever creed will gladly wel- /come. His protest against the ‘“exhaus- tiveness of rubbish gathering,” which pseudo-philologists so often have mistaken | for scientific accuracy, is most refreshing. His appreciation of Taine’s method of lit- |erary analysis according to the three prin- ciples of race, milieu,and age,is a timely |rebuke administered to the recent sensa- tional detractors of the scholarly reputa- | tion of the great French critic. And Erich Schmidt’s own summing up of the literary personality under the three heads of “das Ererbte, das Erlebte, das Erlernte,”’ is a remarkably liberal and fair-minded appli- /eation of maxims forcibly preached, if not }always wisely practised, by his master, | Wilhelm Scherer. Altogether, this ad- dress gives assurance—if there were need of it—that the new rector magnificus will conduct the coming jubilee of Berlin Uni- |versity in a spirit worthy of the great traditions of German scholarship Dr. Wiegand, head of one of the depart- ments of the Royal Museum in Berlin, has entered into a compact with the Prince of Samos, according to which the Royal Mu- seum will for ten years enjoy the privilege ot making archeologica) investigations in the island of Samos. The expenses will be borne by wealthy art enthusiasts. Dr. Max Oelhiuser has already contributed the /sum of 20,000 marks for the purpose of | laying bare the heraion. Strange enough, when one recalls how |Scherer, in edition after edition of his |“Geschichte der deutschen Literatur’ sug- gested more search for antecedents in Goethe’s prose, no one seems previously |to have accomplished what Eugen Wolff, the Kiel Shakespearean, now presents in | his substantial volume modestly entitled warning of an entire change in the point | “Mignon: a Contribution to the History of view, by a reactionary defence of the |of ‘Wilhelm Meister.’” (Munich: C. H. abandoned positions by Prof. J. D. Davis.| Beck’sche Verlagsbuchhandlung.) Some- Since the bibliographies in this encyclo-/| thing had been known of a real forerunner pedia are usually excellent, it is surpris- of the little maiden who won Goethe’s ing to find no mention of Prof. George H. heart, supposedly on the mountain pass Palmer’s edition of George Herbert in the | leading into fruitful Italian valleys; but t'tle bearing his name, and no indication of Professor Wolff was first to follow her the English translation of Prof. Wilhelm | footsteps through Cassel and Frankfort Herrmann’s “Der Verkehr des Christen mit Gott,” a work which has had wide circulation in ite English form. On page 463 mention is intended of the Rev. Dr. S. D. McCon- nell’s term “immortability,” but the word is printed “immortality.” Albert M. Martinez, sometime Under-Sec- retary of State at the Ministry of Finance of the Argentine Republic, and Maurice Lewandowski, doctor in law, are the au- thors of the study of “L’Argentine au XXe siécle,” which is now issued in its third and very much enlarged edition (Paris: The volume contains an economic Colin). as she played her part—for all we know, before Goethe’s very house—and to learn her real name: Elizabeth Schmeling-Mara. It was Professor Wolff's good fortune, also, aided by the Leipzig Museum and by his publisher, to get together a sketch of Elizabeth, and an oil portrait of Karl Philipp Moritz, Meister’s Doppelginger. The Nobel prizes will be distributed this year as follows: For chemistry, Prof. Wil- helm Ostwald (Leipzig); for medicine, Prof. Emil Theodor Kocher (Berne); for literature, Selma Lagerléf, the Swedish novelist. The prise for physics will be

Page 23

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nation. GO5 ‘men, enter at death a soul-world in which they preserve their identity, does not commend itself strongly to modern conceptions. Yet to Asiatics the destruc- tion of spirit seems quite as impossible as is the destruction of matter to a nine- \teenth-century biologist. The horse and the goat that were immolated at a Vedic ‘funeral were intended to precede and announce the coming of the soul of the deceased. Therewith went the idea that the human spirit would need the ser vices of its animal companions in the spirit-world, and would there be served by them. This, of course, implied the immortality of the animal as well as of the human soul. The Suttee, which withstood the pro- gress of Christianity and modern West- ern ideas so strenuously, had its origin in the wish that the wife might accom- pany and serve her husband in the fu- ture life, as in the present. As illustrat- ing the wide diffusion of like ideas, and the strong hold that it takes on primi- tive minds, our author cites the case of an old Irish woman, within her own knowledge, who, on being remonstrated with for having killed her husband's horse, replied. “‘Do ye think I would let my man go on foot in the next world?’ Coming down to the Sutras and Upani- shads, one finds the belief expressed therein to be that the same soul in its wanderings may occupy the body of a Brahman, a worm, an insect, a begging tramp, a dog, an elephant, a cow. The Grecian philosopher, Pythagoras, who interpreted transmigration to European minds, and who may have borrowed it from Egypt, believed that he had been one of the Trojan heroes, and at once recognized his shield among the votive weapcns hung up in the temple of Juno. Tr Lucian’s satire upon the Pythagorean —— theory, which is better known to modern Science. readers by the use which Erasmus made of it with such gusto, presented a Py- thagorean cock which had been success- sively & man, a woman, a prince, a sub- ject, a fish, a horse, and a frog. This varied experience was summed up in the judgment that man was found to be the most wretched of all creatures! For all thrown new light upon one of the oldest others patiently grazed within the allot- of subjects. The ordinary reader, per-|ted enclosures of Nature, haps, will not be attracted to the perusal alone broke out and strayed beyond of this book by the title alone. It is, those safe limits. Doubtless, many of nevertheless, safe to say that few in- Lucian’s Roman admirers eschewed the telligent persons will begin the reading a¢mirable moral, and held the doctrine without pushing through to the end. thus parodied as the height of absurdity. From the ancient Vedic theory of “soul- Put in the essential feature of a trans- wanderings,” in which one follows the migration of spirits, it still appeals to procession of the human soul from death a great multitude of human beings, as a to life through sundry animal forms, to most serious truth. the ideas of Descartes and Darwin, and After Pythagoras, the Greek Em- the kindly moderns who would apply pedocies thought that he had passed humane principles to the lower animals, through many forms, among others those the subject is treated with a degree of of a bird. Could such fancies have orig- learning and with a clarity and spright-| inated from dreams? This reviewer re- liness of style that hold unflagging at-|calls how the dream of flying like a tention. | bird came to him night after night, and divided between Guglielmo Marconi and Prof. Ferdinand Braun (Strasburg), and the Peace Prize will be shared by Senator the Baron d’Estournelles de Constant, president of the French parliamentary group for international arbitration, and M. Beernaert, sometime Minister of State and Belgian representative at the last Hague peace conference. This last prize, which was, three years ago, voted to Theodore Roosevelt, has been awarded annually for nine years, and has on five occasions been divided. The prizes amount to about $40,000 each. Leonard Augustus Jones, for twenty years (1884-1904) associate editor of the American Law Review, died December 9 in Boston. He was born at Templeton, Mass., in 1832, and was graduated from the Harvard Law School in 1858. Since 1898 he had been chief justice of the Massachusetts Land Court. His writings include legal treatises of rec- ognized value. The Rev. John McDowell Leavitt, merly president of Lehigh University, South Bethlehem, Pa., and of St. John’s College, Annapolis, died in the latter city December 12, in his eighty-sixth year. For several years after his graduation from Jefferson College (1841), he studied and practised law. Later, he entered the theo- logical seminary at Gambier, Ohio, and was cerdained in the Protestant Episcopal! Church in 1848. Subsequently he held a rrofessorship in Kenyon College and later in Ohio University and in the Reformea Episcopal Theological Seminary (Phila- delphia). After identifying himself with the Reformed Episcopal Church, Dr. Leavitt went to Lehigh University, and for many years was president of that institution. He was, also, editor and publisher of the Church Review and the founder and editor of the National Review. His writings com- prise “Reasons for Faith in the Nineteenth Century” and other religious works and a number of poems. for- at The Place of Animals in Thought. By the Countess Martinengo-Cesaresco. New Chas. Scribner’s Sons. The Countess Cesaresco has here Human Evelyn York: ;as many of the 398 species while map | breeding The Vedic theory that animals, like persisted during much of his youth. He) would awake from sleep with the im- pression deeply set in his mind that he had been a flying creature. How easy the step from this vision-estate to the be lief, at last, in @ past where one had wandered in a bird-soul. That some such conceptions ag the above had decided lodgment among early Christians is manifest not only from the views ex- pressed by Origen, but by the deliver- ance of the Council of Constantinople, A. D. 543: “Whosoever believes in the fabled prior existence of souls, let him be anathema!” Not the least interesting part of this volume is that which relates to the Christian period, and the strange views held in various parts of Christendom about animals. The attractive charac ter of St. Francis of Assisi, the saint- ly enthusiast who preached to the birds, his “brothers,” and of many another recluse, driven by irrepressible longing for society to friendly companionship with animals, presents one side of the subject. On the other side, the author has uncovered no less than 144 cases of the judicial and ecclesiastical trial of various animals for alleged misde- meanors, dealing with them as though they were moral and responsible crea- tures. Think, for example, of the for- mal arraignment and deliberate and se- rious trial of a fly, with all the solemni- ties of a judicial tribunal. In summing up, one may commend such writing as is found in this book for its influence in giving to our animal associates a fairer chance in life. What- ever one may think of the doctrines of some of the Oriental religions anent anl- mal immortality and transm'gration of souls as here unfolded, it is certainly true that many Western Christians have much to learn from Asiatics in the matter of humane treatment of beasts. Although Charles B. Cory’s “Birds of Il- linois and Wisconsin,” In the Zodlogical Series of the Chicago Field Museum of Nat- ural History (1X, 131), deals avowedly with the birds of but two States, its usefulness is far wider than the title itself suggests, of birds of which it treats are found throughout the East and South. This volume gives full descriptions of the plumage of these birds, their nests and eggs and geographical dis- tribution, together with more or less brief biographical accounts. This material has been so painstakingly treated that there is very little criticism to offer. Two hun- dred and fifty of the 750 pages are devoted to keys to families, genera, and species, and most of the rest of the book to the systematic account. At the conclusion is a careful key to the eggs of the birds in Illinois and Wisconsin, a bibliography, and an index. The keys are, on the whole, not new, but adapted from the author's “Key to the Birds of Eastern | North America.” Perhaps the most impor- tant part of the whole is the illustrations, which include figures not only of the struc- tural parts such as wings, bills, and feet,

Page 24

606 The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2320 full-length drawings of the entire bird. The dedication of the new building of the Harvard Dental School occurred Degember 8, the exercises being held in Sanders The- atre. The building is in Longwood Avenue, Poston, adjacent to the Harvard Medical School, Charles B. Withington, inventor of the first automatic grain binder, died Decem- ber 12 at Janesville, Wisconsin, in his sixty-third year. Early in the sixties he began to experiment upon an improved grain binder; and, in 1870, he obtained a patent for an invention which has revolu- tilonized the agricultural industry. Drama. The Piper. By Josephine Preston Pea- body. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $1.10 net. This is a little poetic play of uncom- mon quality, having distinct literary and dramatic value. It is a new and delicately imaginative version of the old Pied Piper of Hamelin legend, en- riched with a romantic love story, much tender and humane _ sentiment, the grace of true childhood, and an inspir- ing moral. The piping hero now ap- pears in the guise of a vagrant idealist, a strolling mummer filled with a pas- sionate worship of nature, children, and all wild, innocent creatures, and a con- suming hatred of the greed, hypocrisy, and social and religious intolerances that kill the joy of life. His mission is to give freedom to all caged things, and his spell is love. The story is told with admirable simplicity. It is genuinely and consistently, if never brilliantly, poetic. The rats and mice have been charmed away before the first curtain rises. Action begins when the Piper, Reynard the Fax, in a band of wander- ing pantomimists, is refused his prom- ised guerdon. Kurt, the Syndic, and Jacobus, the burgomaster, denounce him as a masterless dog, incapable of civil rights, outlawed, and powerless. They give the credit to St. Willibald, holding that a mass is a more dignified and less expensive way of discharging the debt. Thereupon the Piper, while the parents are in church, lures away the children, as in the old tale, with the Syndic’s crippled stepson, Jan, at their head, to an ancient cavern in a haunted glen, whither, he knows, the superstitious crowd will not dare to follow. There he feeds and entertains them in a charm- ing scene. When the town authorities, including the priest, decide that the mayor's daughter, Barbara, must be made a nun, as a sacrifice to an offend- ed Heaven, he rescues her with his magic pipe, and restores her to the lov- er of her choice, the handsome sword- swallower, Michael. The children, he swears, shall never be given back to be reared in the grinding, soulless Hame- of almost every species, but also half or | /tury, which Booth Tarkington and Harry lin tradition; but in an encounter with Veronica, the stricken mother of the crippled Jan—a finely imagined and written scene of tense spiritual conflict —he realizes that her indomitable love, rooted in patience and self-sacrifice, is loftier and more potent than his own, and he abandons his vengeance. With | this enforcement of a high and wise) morality, the way is opened to a logical | and happy ending. The Piper leads the | = children home, recalls the now dying. Veronica to life and happiness by the gift of her lost boy, and then, amid gen- | eral rejoicings, departs to pipe else-| where. Properly acted upon the stage, the play could scarcely fail of popular suc-| cess, for it makes a strong appeal both | to youthful sympathies and mature in-| telligence. But the dainty bloom of it would almost inevitably perish in a) merely commercial production. It well | deserves, however, the earnest consid-| eration of the directors of the New The-| atre. A better Christmas piece it would | be hard to find. | The “Penelope,” of W. S. Maugham, | which was produced in the Lyceum Thea- | tre on Monday evening, is a very light | piece, more nearly allied to farce than | comedy. It is like other inventions of the | same author, smartly written in places, and | it contains some ingenious and amusing | situations, but drags occasionally and re- | veals many signs of haste and carelessness. | Of dramatic substance it has little, and. such moral as it implies is of doubtful truth | or wisdom. Briefly, it is the tale of a lov- | ing wife, who re-wins an errant husband by pretending an indifference which she does not feel. Her final victory is due clearly | to theatrical predestination, not to any) logic arising from the facis. The whole) scheme is deficient in reality and credibil- ity, but there are some very funny scenes, | notably one between the rival women, in| which the injured wife routs her adversary | in most entertaining fashion. But Mr. Maugham’s humor is apt to be of a some- what cheap and common kind, and some- times is not altogether free from a tinge of vulgarity. The piece was only moderate- | ly successful with a first-night audience, but it is only fair to say that it might eas- | ily have been much better acted. That)| sprightly performer, Miss Marie Tempest, | had, virtually, to carry nearly the whole | weight of the performance upon her own | shoulders. Her method does _ not vary | much. To see her in one piece is to see her | in all, but she is a neat workwoman, and | her mixture of archness and audacity, her mercurial movement, her power of mis- chievous suggestion, and her mock senti- ment rarely fail to excite the laughter, which is her main object. Dustin Farnum is to be the “leading man” of the Hackett Theatre production of “Cameo Kirby,” the engagement beginning December 20. This is the play of New Orleans, in the early part of the last cen- Leon Wilson wrote around the character of a gentleman gambler. The plece was pro- duced in Chicago early last spring, and has Unwin is the London publisher of “Napoleon—A Historical Tragedy,” by Al- gernon Boyesen. The piece is to be played this season in several Continental cities, including Paris. It is written by a fervent admirer of the Emperor, and “aims,” we are told, “rather at poetic truth than at historic realism.’ If we are to have more Napoleon dramas, this is, by all means, the preferable approach. Music. Stories from the Operas. By Gladys Davidson. Philadelphia: J. B. Lip- pincott Co. A Guide to Modern Opera. By Esther Singleton. New York: Dodd, Mead & It is commonly supposed that most people go to the opera solely to hear the music. If that were so, how ac- count for the dozens of boys near the opera-houses crying: ‘“Librettos, only fifteen cents; cost you a quarter in- side’? and how account for the ‘targe number of books telling the stories of the operas? Every year brings new ones, with new editions of the old (in one case, the nineteenth). Evidently, the change in the style of opera, be- coming less ornamental and more dra- matic, has made music-lovers more in- terested in the plots. As a matter of fact, not only in the case of Wagner, but of such Italian operas as “Tosca” and “Madama Butterfly,” it is impos- sible to enjoy the music fully unless one knows the substance of the famous plays on which they are based. Even the older. operas, in many of which the plot merely served as an ex- cuse for the tunes, are coming in for their share of attention. This accounts for the appearance of a book like Gladys Davidson's. It is concerned with a dozen operas, all but two of which (“Otello” and “Romeo and Juliet’) be- long to the old style. The others are “The Lily of Killarney,” “Lucia,” “Lu- crezia Borgia,” “The Daughter of the Regiment,” “The Masked Ball,” “Er- nani,” “The Barber of Seville,” “Lur- line,” “I Puritani,” and “The Merry Wives of Windsor.” This last and “The Barber of Seville’ may be taken as links between the old and the new. Short biographic sketches of the com- posers are included in this volume. As the title indicates, Miss Single ton’s book is concerned with operas of our day, in which the libretto is often almost if not quite as important as the music. Here we find twenty-six favor- ites of the hour, including “The Barter- ed Bride,” “La Giloconda.” “Otello,” '“Tosca,” “Madama Butterfly,” and par- ‘ticularly also the operas which owe their present vogue in this country to Oscar Hammerstein, among them been on its travels ever since. “Thais,” “Le Jongleur de Notre Dame,”

Page 25

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nation. “Louise,” “Pelléas et Mélisande,” and “Salome.” Even Strauss’s latest work, “Elektra,” is included, although it ts not to be produced here till next month. One could not be more contemporary. Miss Singleton is an expert writer, and she tells the stories clearly and with aDundant detail. Pictures of a dozen opera singers adorn the volume. A prima donna war is raging at the Met- ropolitan Opera House over the rdle of Tosca in Puccini's opera. When this work was first produced, in 1901, the titular part was sung and acted by Milka Ternina with a considerable display of temperament. Some years later the part was assumed by Emma Eames, who lent it the aid of her beauty of person as well as of voice. and surprised every one by the unexpected realism of her acting. This year she is not a member of the company, and three singers are struggling to be her favored successor. Geraldine Farrar had the first chance. Nervousness marred some of her vocal measures, although for the most part she sang the music beautifully and--what is more important still in this opera—emo- tionally. In youth and beauty supreme, she also surpassed her predecessors in natur- alness of action, and particularly in the fascinating variety of facial expression. In these respects she vividly recalled Sarah Bernhardt. On Saturday night came Tosca number four—Olive Fremstad—another wo- man beautiful to behold and to listen to. She was far better vocally than in her act- ing, which was crude and unsatisfactory, especially in the matter of facial eloquence. These Tosca experiments have their chief value in the demonstration of the great importance of facial expression in mod- ern operas, especially those of Puccini, which are based on famous plays. Miss Farrar plays the rdle again to-morrow night, and later Mme. Destinn is to as- sume it. Gustay Mahler is the lion of the day in the local concert world. The reconstructed Philharmonic Orchestra plays under him as it never has played in its history. It is worth while to make a long journey to hear one of these concerts. The prograr me is immaterial. Mr. Mahler has made a Bach suite the sensation of the hour! He has put new life into the Beethoven sym- phonies, making audiences applaud them as they applauded Safonoff’s conducting of Tchaikovsky's. He makes his men play the “History of Mendelssohn's ‘Elijah,’ ” and was a contributor to the new “Grove” dictionary, and to the “Dictionary of Na- tional Biography.” Charles Bordes, one of César Frayck’s most brilMant pupils, has just died a‘ Toulon, aged forty-six years His tal- ents were first recognized in a com- mission from the French government to collect the folk songs of the Basque coun- tries. In 1890 he founded the society of the Singers of St. Gervais, which devoted itself especially to the old church com- positions of the fifteenth, sixteenth, and seventeenth centuries. Ip the organiza tion of the Schola Cantorum Alexandr Guilmant and Vincent d'Indy were asso ciated with him, and he continued ais propaganda by founding organizations for he cultivation of the old’ music in Lyons Montpelier, Marseilles, and Toulon. His name was made widely, known through his ‘Archives de la Tradition Basque,”’ 1889. Art. NATIONAL ACADEMY PICTURES. Having been away for a matter of three years, the present writer is un- able to make the prescribed compari- sons between this and recent Academ- ies. As measured by those of a few years ago it is more varied. Figure painting and portraiture of a decora- tive sort have come to relieve the stereo- typed alternation of portraiture and landscape painting. Barring the front room, it is better hung than was usual. In the Vanderbilt gallery the arrange- ment is admirable. Of course, this ease is won only through sacrifice. One hundred and seventy paintings were ac- cepted only to be sent back for want of wall space. It seems to us that a con- solation list of such disappointed artists should be printed in the catalogue. With | those who blamelessly remain in outer darkness should be commiserated those forty-odd painters whose contributions, crowded frame to frame in two tiers, }are seen in the academy room by elec- Richard Strauss and the tone poems of the |}against a sweep of plain, seems one of |the most vigorous and self-contained |landscapes of the show. But one can- contemporary French school with a bril- liant virtuosity that has heretofore been a monopoly of the Boston Symphony Or- chestra. He will conduct his own first symphony to-night and to-morrow after- noon. He is reviving old favorites, like the “Scherzo Capriccioso” of Dvorak, a piece often on the programmes of Theodore tric light. Here no one may be certain of the quality of what he sees. For ex- ample, Ernest D. Roth’s The Yellow House, standing so upright on its bluff not venture to decide how much the |electrician has made or marred Mr. Thomas, which has been unduly neglected — since his departure. It anticipates some of Richard Strauss’s humorous features and adds to them what Strauss lacks—sponta- neous melody which speaks to the heart. Strauss is clever, Dvoraék inspired; and Mahler’s interpretation makes it clear why the Bohemian is superior to the German. The death is announced of Frederick George Edwards, the editor, since 1897, of the Musical Times. He was the author of “The Musical Haunts of London” and of Roth. If the present show differs from those of some years ago in variety and im- proved hanging, it is painfully true to type in the prevalence of absenteeism. A dozen of the more prominent among the older men, and perhaps as many among the growing talents, have not thought it worth while to exhibit. A dozen more of the men who count have sent rather mediocre contributions. Lat- er in their personal shows, or in those of the smaller groups, we shall see what ——— | 607 has really interested them this year. Now the Academy, through its reor- ganization and in its present policy, has put itself in a reasonable and lib- eral attitude. The old feuds are now outlawed. Why, then, is there not greater loyalty among its members? Partly due to American individualism, much of this abstention hardly de- serves so fair a name. Ranging as it does from monumen- tal decoration to genre or mere illus- tration, figure painting is the surest in- dex of the condition of a national art. What is our kind of figure painting? Is it Kenyon Cox's intelligent revival of the Venetian manner—without, how- ‘ver, the Venetian sweep or glow —in the big oval composition, Passing Commerce Pays Tribute to the Port of Cleveland, or is it Mr. Sewall’s pre- Raphaelite medallion, Psyche Seeks Love Beyond the River of the Dead? Both these decorations have engaging details. Mr. Cox's Danae-like Cleveland is calculated to detain the hurrying god of trade; Mr. Sewall’s shades of the dead are winsome folk and their atti- tudes charming and pathetic, yet neith- er composition invites the mind to step in and be at rest. A painter’s world should be inviting and habitable. That Elliot Daingerfield’s emphatically is in such a picture as Pearls of the Morn- ing, and this by no means through the obvious prettiness of nacreous flesh, soft virginal forms, water lillies in a mountain, shrubs and saplings screen- ing a silvery sky. These ingredients are in a way nugatory. What counts is a demure and yet passionate vision, a reflective but ardent consummation of an ideal. Mr. Daingerfield is frank- ly in the line of Giorgione and Fantin, and thereby more himself perhaps than the restless individualists that know no past and acknowledge no master. The few remaining nudes want rather little attention from the fastidious visitor. F. D. Marsh's two figures in the Golden Cup suggest a tonal beauty which the electric light undoubtedly minimizes unfairly. There is vivacity and joy of life in Lillian Genth's two bathers in a shaded pool, but the slipperiness of the touch is unduly prominent, while unexpressive, and the invention barely escapes banality. Childe Hassam’s big Aphrodite raises the whole question of the value of his accomplishment in this vein. To many it will seem less spontaneous and compelling than his prize picture of a few years ago, Laurel. To pose a model studio-fash- ion in the open air and there paint her atmospherically is in itself a conven- tional and inconsequential procedure. Convention for convention, it is a pure assumption, and a doubtful one, that open-air formulas are preferable to those of the studio. The surfaces of Mr. Hassam’s picture are charming, but Aphrodite has a casual, nay, a wan-

Page 26

608 dered, look in the world here provided for her. In spite of unassimilated spots of local color, Sergeant Kendall's Psyche is charmingly placed in her oval, distinguished in line, and quite masterly in modelling. The president’s contribution, Sun- light, which holds the place of honor worthily in the centre of the big gallery, might be reckoned to portraiture, but the title and the intentionally slight characterization make it rather the fin- est example here of the painting of the draped figure. Mr. Alexander, always faithful to his love of the Hogarthian line of beauty, makes a great bow of the girlish figure which bends over to enjoy the rays of sunlight that fall athwart the skirt of a greenish yellow gown. It might be argued that the Tanagrine in- ventions in which Mr. Alexander is so fertile would be more effective on a smaller scale. What is indisputable is the thoughtful spontaneity of arrange- ment, beauty of tone, and massiveness of construction of this unpretending pic- ture. To note how flimsy it makes near- ly all the purposefully robust portraits look is to take a lesson in real draughts- manship. With M. Jean McLane’s The Hill Top, a picture which received high exhibition honors at Paris, we have reached our modern sort of thing. The expression of the upturned faces watch- ing soap bubbles float away toward the clouds is vivacious and truthful, and the composition has a certain freshness and spaciousness, It is sturdily painted with- out doubt or fears. In the nature of the case, considering the conditions and limitations of the ar- tist who must live by depicting his cli- ents, portraiture will only rarely rise above what Hogarth called “portrait manufacture.” It would be hazardous to declare that any portrait in the present exhibition escapes this classification. If so, George de Forest Brush’s seated figure of Henry George, painted in 1893 and worked oven ten years later, Ser- geant Kendall's Dr. Alger, John W. Alex- ander’s Richard Watson Gilder, and Montague Flage’s Portrait of My Wife amack least of the face-painting shop. It is needless to dwell upon these sound traditional works. They have in common fine arrangement, attractive quality of paint, serenity of mood, and patient in- terpretation of character. It is emphatically livelier below the gangway among the manufacturers. Here Boldini lords it supreme. His Mrs. Clarence Mackay tossed by an unexplain- ed tempest and fearfully enveloped in an electric blue gown down which shoot baleful zigzag reflections, may or may not be a caricature of a masterful great lady. It has the merit, whatever that may come to, of being unforgettable. It marks the acme of modern restlessness, end cannot be recommended as a model, for that eminence is only big enough for one man, and is already triumphantly [Vol. 89, No. 2320 which is the attribute of a ‘sii bed, but also, out of the lines of floating ice cakes and intervening spaces of blue water, the verticals of bordering sap- lings, and the plunging lines of the river bank, has woven an agreeable pattern. But, of course, there are many ways, and Frederick Ballard Williams, with Hills of Purple and Rose, is here to remind us that romantic coloring and beautiful textures are not obsolete even in this day of uncompromising natural- ism.* In its depth and largeness, in its romantic alternation of light and shade, this glimpse down a mountain valley has in it some suggestion of Constable and Barbizon. It is the work of a man who, while valuing his eye and hand, does not share the prevailing dis- trust of the back of one’s head. Among the younger river men there is no more interesting figure than George Bellows, A.N.A., elect. Both his pictures in this show, The Palisades and Excavation at Night, are of ex- traordinary force. The city scene has fine pictorial quality as well. The very buffet and shiver of the arc-light on 'gashed rock are suggested, and the glow of old brick basements in the penum- bra above gives the necessary element The Nation. occupied. Possibly the future will re gard it as a pathological exhibit. How tame and traditional in comparison seems not merely the Gitana of John Sargent, a relic of his earlier and better days, but also his portrait of Miss Car- | ter. That reversion to early English modes which has marked his later work is betrayed clearly in the latter por- trait. It has with the winsomeness some- thing of the insubstantiality of a Rom- ney. In the filmy scarf covering 4 stri- dent harmony of green and crimson there are passages that only the magic hand of Sargent can paint; but, in the main, like most of his productions for a matter of ten years, it suggests that he no longer pays extravagantly with his person. Robert Henri, on the contrary, seems to be engaged in the difficult and superfluous task of underlining himself. His Girl with Parasol has more than the old emphasis but less than the old stability. The portrait of Mrs. Rockwell has style and fine painting in the blacks, but hardly structure enough to support the over-accented head. At bottom, all painters of natural scen- ery deal either directly with water or indirectly with its effects upon the earth; hence, a truer distinction than that of landscape and marine would be the art of the river and of the sea. Here, of repose in a composition of demonic admittedly, we find our art at its best. energy. Mr. Bellows’s inspiriting work In landscape, in the narrower sense, is so unfamiliar to the present writer however, this exhibition barely holds| that with diffidence he alludes to the its own. Bruce Crane, F. B. Williams, gen- Redfield, Gardner Symons, and Ernest | tlemen call “guts” and ladies “good red Lawson give a distinct fillip. From) blood.” If one is grateful for the pow- such variously accomplished men as | er of Mr. Bellows one welcomes also the Alden Weir, Ochtman, Ben Foster, tranquil ease with which Charles War- Groll, Ranger, Walter Palmer, Cullen ren Eaton brings off a decorative effect Yates, one gets the customary impres- | |from the random data of nature. The sion with perhaps a little less than handful of American subjects here ex- the customary intensity. It is fair to| hibited show how much this is a per- say that at least two of these men have sonal gift, and how little in his better merits unadapted to exhibition ordeals.| known foreign subjects he has really A better Bruce Crane than Woods and | depended upon conventional picturesque Hills the present writer does not re-| ingredients. call. It has peace, a refined topo-| European painters of the sea have graphical sense; the sweep of pas- mainly dealt with its mottlings and ture and density of woodlands are deli- | iridescences in calm. Our painters have cately indicated; everything is crisply studied it rather in action as it gaaws in place; its accord of tans and grays at the coast or surges in midocean. Ged- is tenuous but satisfying. It is a pic- | ney Bunce is of the European mood, ture in which, through selection and and his work has an exotic look. A sacrifice, naturalism attains to style. Of single and minor excellence, that of similar temper, but more robust, as tone, is carried to the superlative in his befits his theme, is Redfield’s The Ris- pictures, which have just enough frame- ing River. Here the emphasis is on work to explain the tonal display. This motion—in the saplings that have fol-| time one is a sunset and the other a lowed while resisting the flow of the | sunrise, but the labels might be ex- river, and in the drive of the blue river changed without greatly troubling the itself. There is zest in the workman- visitor. In both, thin lifting clouds ship, and a kind of classic restraint, with their reflections form a sort of too, not common in work of this in-| chevron, in which like a shaft is in- tensity. Unless surface indications fail, | sorted an indication of the skyline of Gardner Symons, whose Opalescent ‘Venice. What counts is the brocading. River has handsomely won the Car-| Winslow Homer, the most American negie prize, has come under Mr. Red- and the greatest expresser of the might field’s influence. fair to outdo the master. not merely gives the sense of cleavage, work of several younger painters. If so, the disciple bids of the sea, is unhappily absent, but his Mr. Symons spirit is represented in the masculine ofr

Page 27

Dec. 16, 1909] these Paul Dougherty seems to have the most matter in him. His single contri- bution, The Black Squall, is a study of opposed forces—a shattered wave re- coiling from the rocks, while behind the racing sud outruns its slower parent billows. There is motion and clamor in it, more, perhaps, of the anarch quality of such a scene than of the majestic order that overrules bat- tling wind and wave. Less energetic and more pictorial is Emil Carlsen’s The Meeting of the Seas. Converging breakers spout in a miniature geyser down a shelving beach amid the ambers, browns, and olives of an overcast day. The composition is sparse but unified and grows in effectiveness the longer it is viewed. Mr. Waugh’s study of ucean rollers gives a sense of their weight, but not of their motion. The searching modelling of the surfaces results in a kind of paintiness. The man who has the knowledge such a _ study implies should be able to do something much more pleasurable. The most novel and perhaps most promising variety of our painting—the portrayal of the town—is either relegat- ed to the tender mercies of electric | light, exemplified, as in C. C. Cooper's | case, by rather unrepresentative in-| stances, or lurks sulkily in the stu-iios. | W. J. Glackens’s vivacious Italian Pa-| rade is about the only composition of this type that fulfils the requisites of being good, present, and visible. The scanty showing in this branch may be due to conditions ever which the Acad- emy has no control, but the absence and poor placing of the New Yorkers mean a distinct subtraction from the vitality of the show. This kind of work seems the most idiomatic part of our produc- tion—being merely the fine flower of our most solidly grounded art—that of illustration. Sculpture, as the limited accommoda- tion of the galleries dictates, is present only incidentally and in a decorative capacity. Chester Beach’s Young Nymph catches the gracility of ado- lescent forms, though there is some- thing amiss in the joining of the nymph and the tortoise on which she balances. Otherwise, on superficial inspection, the animals of Lila A. Wheelock, and the portraits of Chester Beach, Grafly, Hart- ley, Edmond T. Quinn, and Robert I. Aitken seemed most attractive. M. Frederick S. Keppel has assembled more than thirty reproductions from rare prin‘s or pictures and has accompanied them by « running commentary, including a bit or two of original verse. The result is an at- tractive gift book under the descriptiv? title “Christmas in Art: The Nativity as Depicted by Artists of the Fifteenth an‘l Sixteenth Centuries’ (Duffield & Co). There are rare examples of German and Spanish masters, and one or two charming cuts from miniatured manuscript. But Direr really ought not to be held respon- The Nation. sible for the crowded Adoration in the Naples Gallery (p. 66). Henry B. Wheatley was well inspired when he decided to gather together out of the older commentators of Hogarth and his own researches the volume now hand- somely published as “Hogarth’s London: Pictures of the Manners of the Eighteenth Century” (Dutton). Here is an elaborate explanation of all the chief compositions. One gets the gist of Ireland, Nichols, Steev- ons, etc., without their superabundant dross. Mr. Wheatley is commendably cautious in accepting thia older testimony as to por- traits in Hogarth’s character studies. Given his remarkable memory and inquisitive observation it seems impossible to us to fix the bounds of portraiture in his pictures. A kind of half-portraiture is probably the universal method. Through high life, low life, taverns, hospitels, prisons; to the hustings and suburbs; to church and to the theatre, Mr. Wheatley follows Hogarth. We share in his feuds with Pope and Wilkes and “Bruiser” Churchill, and in his friend- ships with Fielding and Garrick. The book is quite frankly given over to the antiquar- ian side of the subject, but Hogarth him- self undoubtedly thought his function as an historian of manners all important. The marvellous technical accomplishment which we are only now coming to value at its true preciousness, he quietly took for granted. With its many fine plates, fortunately most of them after the pictures and not after those coarse engravings which have unduly obscured Hogarth’s artistry, this book will be a useful companion to the standard life by Austin Dobson. We have here pretty rmouch all the relevant material, a consider- able amount of which has been added by Mr. Wheatley’s industry. It naturally lay apart from his theme to treat the consid- erable Continental literature on Hogarth, but Julius Meier-Graefe’s excellent mono- graph should have been noticed, if only be- cause it is too recent to be included in Mr. Dobson's exhaustive bibliography. Hermann Kaulbach, the German painter, has died in Munich. He was born in that city in 1846, and was the son of a painter of reputation. He was a student at the University of Munich, and later a pupil of Piloty. He became a royal professor of the fine arts in 1889. Of his works a large proportion were historical paintings. His “Immortality” hangs in the Pinakothek, at Munich; and he was the recipient of many. prizes, including medals awarded at Chi- cago in 1893. Phe Finance. PLANS FOR THE GOVERNMENT FI- NANCES. To say that Secretary MacVeagh’s first annual report for the Treasury De- partment is such a statement as an in- telligent body of shareholders would welcome from the president of their company, is to express very high praise. Treasury reports in past years have tended to pass lightly over, or to ignore entirely, the practical questions of effi- ciency in administering the public ex- chequer and of scientific adjustment of 609 expenditure to income. One or two ex- ceptions were, however, noteworthy. Those considerations were always fore- most in the mind of that eminent finance minister, Secretary Hugh Mc- Culloch, and it was his lucid and prac- tical handling of them, in his annual reports, that made those documents, so to speak, classics among our govern- ment papers, sure to be read with profit by students of the fiscal problems of to-day. Mr. MacVeagh’s report takes rank, in this respect, with those of his eminent predecessor. With the aggressive attitude o/ the Government in holding down estimates of expenditure to what the Secretary calls the “actual and irreducible needs of government,” the President's message has made the country familiar. Mr. Mac. Veagh points out the reasons for the looseness and extravagance of our past policy in that direction. Our Governinent submits no budget. That is to sav, its finance minister does not, like the Chan- cellor of the British Exchequer, rise in his place on “budget day,” outline his projects for the year’s public expendl- ture, estimate what money will be reed- ed for such outlay, explain the estimates, and, finally, submit his own plans of tax- ation whereby the requisite revenue may be raised. Hamilton began with such a budget, but, as Mr. MacVeagh points out, the plan “was never fully realized, could not have lasted, and cannot now be instituted.” In a measure, the haphazard calcula- tions, the series of unnecessary sur- pluses and unnecessary deficits, which have resulted from our plan of arrang- ing public income and public outlay through different legislative chambers and through separate committees in each of those chambers, may be averted by the new provision of last March for a supervising “budget committee.” This body has for its duties the thorough re vision of estimates by the Cabinet as a whole, before they go to Congress, and their further consideration by the chalir- men of the several appropriation com- mittees, acting in concert. The plan iz as yet experimental; but the result to date, even before the estimates have been formally taken in hand by Con- gress, has been the asking of $94,000,- 000 less than was asked for the current fiscal year, and $55,663,000 less than was actually appropriated for it. The Secretary rightly declares that it is neither necessary nor proper for him to discuss at this time the general prob- lem of currency reform. That problem has been referred by Congress, for in- vestigation and report, to the Monetary Commission, and pending its action the matter is in abeyance. The much-moot- ed Central Bank expedient is not so much as mentioned in the Treasury re- port. The Secretary merely observes that to-day we have “neither an adjust- able currency nor trustworthy surplus

Page 28

610 reserves"—students of certain recent bank statements will read the last four rise on the use of such bonds to secure city’s 3 and 4 per cents—namely, the words with Interest—and he appeals for the present banknote circulation. The prospect of very large additional is- the laying aside of “politica) partisan- 2 per cents, into which the bulk of the sues, and the general rise in the price ship, special interest, and pride of opin- public debt was converted in 1900, and of capital. But the depreciation in the ion,” in future consideration of the which to-day make up nearly seven- United States bonds is more awkward problem. eighths of the entire collateral behind than in the New York bonds; first, be- But there are some banking prob- the $680,000,000 outstanding banknotes, cause many of the government 2 per lems which the Treasury is forced to are selling virtually at par, and have cents were bought by national banks at confront at once. One of them is the been below that price. The cause of a higher price to take out circulation, rise in the interest rate on government this is similar in the main to that of and, secondly, because a fall below par on the part of bonds thus pledged may — be followed, under the Banking Law, by Financial. Financia. demand for additional collateral against banknotes now outstanding. Secretary MacVeagh says, quite cor- rectly, that “no government, however 7 ee rich, has a 2 per cent. borrowing pow- Farm Lien Securities er.” A glance at the London market's daily prices shows that French and Eng- lish government bonds, at the current valuation, yield 3 per cent. net to the in- Interest 6% vestor, and German Imperial bonds >] 3%. The Secretary intimates his ewn re- ae gret that 2 per cent. bonds should ever have been issued by our Government. Among all the bonds that we handle, The demand for irrigated land, because there are none so attractive to men who of its enormous fertility, greatly exceeds figs criticism is probably sound, though know, as Irrigation bonds the supply. Irrigation projects are pro- These are among the reasons: fitable; and, if rightly conducted, are free it is fair to say that when Secretary Irrigation bonds are secured by first from risk. So there is great demand ae Gage’s proposed conversion plan of 1900 liens on the most fertile lands in Amer- money to help finance these projects, an — six per cent. is paid to obtain it. _was adopted, neither the costly Panama Canal undertaking, nor the general rise The liens are given by individual land owners in payment for water rights. The — _ water Immediately multiplies the land's $100— $500 $1,000 in the value of capital, nor a concrete value. The first crop from the land will aretention thande ere touch. $6 socio. plan for dispensing with a bond-secured usually pay the whole lien, and sometimes some due in two years, some in twelve banknote circulation, was in sight. The by__ several times over. years, some due every year between. One | conversion to a 2 per cent. basis, with The liens are conservative. Bonds are 1 -ti short-time invest- rarely issued to more than one-fourth the mr Pang mee ht. ~ amen the the subsequent fixing of that rate for land's value. The liens are paid off in annual in- security back of the rest. Panama Canal loans, was designed to stallments, so the indebtedness constant- Lg Sy “wosey — yo 4 avoid the very situation which altered ly decreases. $100, $ and $1,000, so they appeal to | -ircumstances have brought upon us, The bonds are additionally secured by oth small investors and large. a first mortgage on all the property Irrigation bonds have become the most and to avoid it through holding down which the Irrigation Company owns. So popular bonds that we handle. They are the market premium on the bonds, so we have a corporation, with large in- the safest six per cent. bonds that we as to give small scope for depreciation. terests at stake, to guard against any know. Be this as it may, the Secretary now delinquencies. Seme Are Municivel 73 Issues Sold proposes that, if the 3 per cent. bonds In the past 15 years we have sold 73 contemplated be used as a basis for bank- 4 ——— —— are aay separate issues of Drainage and Irriga- note circulation, the notes shall be tax- Senda, ao ty send fems @ tan ten on a bey Doge A, Rey Bn ob ys “a ed 1% per cent., as against the present all the taxable property in the commu- investor. tax of one-half of 1 per cent., which he stele eoometan. a ee ee We are now the largest dealers in bonds would maintain in the case of the gov- Other Irrigation bonds are issued under °f this class. We have our own engineers | ornment twos. The result would be to the “Carey Act.” Such projects, until and attorneys to pass on every detail. 4 . D ~ An officer of our Company constantly re- (give no advantage to circulation base they are completed and turned over to sides in the irrigated sections, watching lon the 3 per cents, ex ton of aneh settlers, are under the constant super- vision of the State Engineer and State. ‘B¢ projects we finance. advantage having been at least one Land Board. Because of these facilities we get our | the t Behind every Irrigation bond that we pick of these bonds. There are very few cause for the weakness of presen handle there is ample and ideal security issues which are not offered to us. outstanding government bonds. We have now written a nook based on | Six Per Cent. all this experience. It will give you a | The argument for a provision of this clear idea of all that pertains to Irri- | sort is convincing. The Secretary fur- Irrigation bonds pay six per cent. in- gation and Irrigation bonds. Every in- ther guggests that if a sale of “Panama terest. That is a higher rate than can vestor. small or large, owes to himself | mye now be obtained on any large class of its perusal. The book will be sent on | threes’ should produce more cash than bonds based on equal security. request. ‘the Treasury balance needs, there might “be bought in the market for the sink- Srowtridge S Naver: | ing fund some of the 2 per cent. bonds.” January Investments ‘This, he reasons, should sustain the For January investors we have on hand 50 Congress ‘ee Rend ae, Cine New York] | DTice above par. It is doubtful if this 100 varieties of bonds. They include Mu- Please send your free book on Irrigation Bonds} plan will be so readily accepted as a nicipal, Public Utility, Water Power, idimesed sateen /sound economic proposition. It is, Corporation and Irrigation Bonds. Please | however, not without pertinence to ob- ask for our list. Cut out this reminder | serve that, as the law now stands, the so you won't forget. ss ‘Secretary not only has the power to re- ‘deem outstanding debt, regardless of Fist Untlons! Bonk Bids. Sroulridge ENiwer"be: 50 Congress St., BOSTON =. borrowing, but is instructed so to wr ¥ 18) Beate, Haw TORE | oo. The Federal statutes explicitly re El” wire purchase or payment of one Per

Page 29

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nation. centum of the entire debt of the United States to be made within each fiscal year.” BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Allinson, F. G. and A. C. Greek Lands and Letters. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $2.50 net. Bancroft, J. H. Games for the Playground, Home, School, and Gymnasium. Mac- millan. $1.50 net. Burton, R. Masters of the English Novel. Holt & Co. Cambridge Modern History. Vol VI. The Bighteenth Century. Macmillan Co. $4 net. Coates, F. E. Lyrics of Life. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.25. Coffey, G. Guide to the Celtic Antiquities of the Christian Period Preserved in the National Museum, Dublin. Coolidge, A. C. Human Beings vs. Things. Watertown, N. Y.: Hungerford-Holbrook Co. $1. Draper, A. S. American Education. Bos- ton: Houghton Mifflin. §2 ner. Ellis, W. T. Men and Missions. Phila.: Sunday School Times Co. $1 net. Emanuel, W., and Aldin, C. A Conceited Puppy. Dutton: 50 cents. English Parnassus: An Anthology of Long- er Poems, with notes by W. M. Dixon and H. J. C. Grierson, Frowde. Faust, A. B. The German Element in the United States. 2 vols. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $7.50 net. Folwell, W. W. University Addresses. Minneapolis: H. W. Wilsen Co. Hackwood, F. W. Inns, Ales, and Drink- ing Customs of Old England. Sturgis & Walton. Hale, P. L. Great Portraits: Boston: Bates & Guild Co. $1.50. Harper, R. F. Assyrian and Babylonian Letters Belonging to the Kouyunjik Col- lections of the British Museum. Part IX. Univ. of Chicago Press. Women. Discoveries vols. Mac- Hedin, S&S. Trans-Himalaya: and Adventures in Tibet. 2 millan. $7.50 net. Jallade, E. J. A Vol D'Oiseau. Pfeiffer. Jeremias. A. Dag Alter der babylonischen Astronomie. Second edition. Leipzig: J. C. Hinrichs’sche Buchhandlung Johnston, A, F. The Little Colonel's Good Times Book. Boston: Page & Co. $1.50. Johnson, C. When Mother Lets Us Help. Moffat, Yard. 75 cents net. Johnson, 8. Selections, edited with an intro by L. G. Osgood. Holt & Co. Konta, A. L. The History of French Liter- Drysen & ature. Appleton. $2.50 net. ° Krehbiel, H. E. A Book of Operas. Mac- millan. Lewis. A. Wind O' the West. London: Elkin Mathews. Lodge, G. C. The Soul's Inheritance. Bos- ton: Houghton Mifflin. $1 net. Lodge, O. The Survival of Man. Moffst, Yard. $2 net. Lord Kelvin’s Early Home: Being the Recollections of His Sister, the Late Mrs. Elizabeth King, Macmillan 2.60 net Lowndes, M. E. The Nuns of Port Royal Frowde. Mackaye, P. Poems. Macmillan $1.25 net, Macy, J. A Child’s Guide to Reading. Bak- er & Taylor Co. $1.25 net, Mayes, J. S. Breezes from the Southland. Broadway Pub. Co. 75 cents. The Sacrament of Duty and Columbus Press. of Man and Other McSorley, J. Other Essays. Moore, A. Physiology Animals. Holt & Co. Morrison, F. W. Tres Comedias Modernas Edited with notes and vocabulary. Holt & Co. Morrison, Sarah G. Slossum. Cochrane Pub. (Co. 1.5¢ Ogilvy, J. S. Relics and Memorials London City. Dutton. $7 net. Pemberton, M. H. Reuben: His Broadway Pub. Co. $1.50. Polko, E. Musical Sketches the German. Sturgis & Walton. From Lotos to Cherry of Book. Trans. from $1.25 net, Jones’s Logic, Inductive and Deductive By ADAM L. JoNes, Professor in Columbia University. The aim of this text-book is to present, x+304 pp. 12mo. $1.00. in as concrete a form as is possible, the rudiments of Logic, considered as method. Exercises are supplied for most of the chapters: particular, uals; emphasis is put upon the application of the principles discussed. M. Wenley, University of Michigan: it is calculated to deliver the student from that bane of most logic man- the appeal to mere memory. At many points, too, Prof. Jones brings his chap- It seems to me an excellent book. In ters into touch with practical problems of the day in a way that can hardly fail to stimulate even the dull. Gordon’s Esthetics By KATE GORDON. V+315 pp. 12mo. $1.50. A college text-book, which aims to give a concise statement of some of the im- portant facts of esthetic experience and artistic activity and to stimulate an interest in the experimental treatment of wsthetic E. D. Starbuck, State University of lowa: and best tempered of the books that have appeared on the subject. use it in my classes. HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, problems. It is easily the most comprehensive I shall NEW YORK CHICAGO BEST faclties for supoiying Italian easise” BOOKS | tsiee gp oF free. Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 60 yeers. German 30-32 West 27th St., New York AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis 25 VOLUMES READY THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE Ed. by PORTER-CLARKE. Text of 1628 Full notes and variants. READY: —**Midsom mer Night's Dreame,’’ ‘‘Love's Labour's Lost,”’ le of " “Merchant of Venice,” “Ma b,”* ‘Julius Ceesar,”’ **Ham- let,”” “King —_, * “Twelfe Ni bt,"’ “‘As You Like It,’ My oe MO Fitt,’’ uch Adoe About Nothing, and Juliet,’ **Tempest,’’ **Othello,*’ Winter's Tale,”’ ‘““Shrew,"’ ‘Two Gen- t ** “Cortol anus,’’ “*Merr. Wives, Jemen of Verona, erry “All's Well, ** “Measure for Measure, " “Anthonie, and Cleopatra, " “Titus Andron icus,"’ “Tymon of Athens." Cloth iy cents; limp leather, per volume, postpaid Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., New York $1.04 O11 Fowell, A. M. Trailing and Camping in Alaska. A. Wessels. $2 net, Preyer, D. C. The Art of the Metropolitan Museum of New York. Page & Co Rand, B. The Classical Moralists: Selec- tions illus, Ethics from Socrates to Mar- tineau. Boston: Houghton MiMia $3 net. Report of the State Board of Tax Comm's sioners, 1908. Albany, N. Y Russell, G. E. Text-Book on Hydraulics Holt & Co. Saunders, M. ‘Tilda Jane's Orphans. Bos- ton: Page & Co. $1.50 Scott, F. N., and Denney, J. V. Paragraph- Writing: a Rhetoric for Colleges. New edition, rewritten. Boston: Allyn & Ba- con. $1, Sichel, W. Sheridan. With illustrations. 2 vols. Boston: Houghton MifMfiin. $7.50 net. Slouschz, N. The Renascence of Hebrew Literature (1743-1885). Phila.: Jewish Pub. Society of America Stokes’ Encyclopedia of Music and Musi- clans. Revised and enlarged by L. J de Bekker. Stokes Co. $3 net. Strack, H. L. The Jew and Human Sacri- fice. Translated from the 8th edition with corrections, ete The Bloch Pub Co $3 net Swanton, J. R. Tlingit Myths and Texts Washington: Gov. Printing Office ‘iennyson, A. In Memoriam. Illus. and decorations by ©. M. Burd Sturgis @ Walton Co. §$2 net. Thompson, G. B. The Kulturkampf: an Essay. Toronto, Canada: Macmillan Co $1.25 net Titchener, E. B. Lectures on the Experi- mental Psychology of the Thought-Pro- cesses. Macmillan. $1.25 net. Viking Club Year Book. Vol. Il. July, 1909 London “ederkind, F. The Awakening of Spring Trans. from the German by F. J. Ziegler Phila.: Brown Bros. $1.25 net Wilder, H. H. History of the Human Body Holt & Co. Zogheb. A. M. de. Etudes sur L’Ancienne Alexandrie. Paris: E. Leroux. Just Ready. Abraham Lincoln The People’s Leader in the Struggle for National Existence By GEORGE HAVEN PUTNAM, Litt.D., author of ‘‘Books and Their Makers in the Middle Ages,’’ etc With photogra- vure Portrait, $1.25 net (by mail, $1.40) With the above ts included the apeech de- livered by Lincoln in New York, February 27th, 1860; with an introduction by Charles C. Nott, late Chtef Juatice of the Court of Claima, and annotations by Judge Nott and by Cephas Brainerd of the New York Bar The volume presents the main events in the career of the people's leader, together with an analysis of the Constitutional issues which were fought out during the years of Lincoln's life. Bend for Descriptive Ctrouwlar. NEW YORK 6, P, PUTNAM’S SONS, & LONDON COLUMBIA STUDIES IN HISTORY, ECONOMICS AND LAW New Volume (Vo!'!. XXXV, No. 3) DIVORCE: A Study in Social Causation By JAMES P. LICHTENBERGER, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Pennesy!vania 8v0, 230 pages, price $1.50, paper covers; or bound in cloth, $2.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York 2nd Edition in Preparation. LETTERS FROM CHINA By SARAH PIKE CONGER (Mre. E. H. Conger) A native Chinese student writes: ‘It ts not only the latest, but the moat inter- esting of the many about my country.’’ Profusely illustrated; crown Svo, $2.75 By mail, $2.95. A. C. MeCLURG & CO., Chicage.

Page 30

: | : 12 A Christmas Book By the Nobel Prize Winner Christ Legends. By SELMA LAGERLOF. Translated from the Swedish by VELMA 8S, HOWARD. “Told with rare sweetness. A lesson in lit- erature to the young reader.”’—Boston Tranacript. (Decorated. $1.25 net.*) My Life in China and America. By YUNG WING. With portrait, $2.50 net.* The author's account of his early life in China, his education at Yale (A.B., 1854, LL.D., 1876), his return to China and adventures during the Tiaping re- bellion, his intimate association with Tsang Kwoh Fan and Li Hung Chang, and finally his great work for the “Chi- nese Educational Movement” furnish highly interesting and good reading. It Never Can Happen Again. By WILLIAM Da MORGAN. “There has been nothing else at all like it in our day. The best of our con- temporary novelists do not so come home to our business and our bosoms.” —H. W. Boynton in The Nation. (§$1.75.) Travels of Four Years and a Half in the United States of America (1798-1802). By jsoun DAVIS Reprinted from 1803 edition. With Introduction and Notes by A. J. MORRISON. “A really noteworthy nar- rative account of our young America. aq —Nation. “A veritable find.”—N. FY. Tribune ($2.50 net.*) The Life of the Honourable Mrs. Norton. By JANE GRAY PERKINS. An able and interesting bi- ography of Richard Brinsley Sheridan's brilliant granddaughter, Caroline Nor- ton, who scored in literature, society and politics. With portraits. $3.50 net. *Add 8% for carriage. Holiday Catalog on request Henry Holt and Company 34W 33 St. New York SUDERMANN’S The SONG 2¢ SONGS The Creat Novel of the Twentieth Century READ THIS: Sudermann’'s many drama md) =6povela may be regarded aa merely preliminary stud les for this, ble masterplece It is the story f a beautiful girl animated by high ideals by temptations on every elde “ts, remotely, Daudet's Sappho in a nobler embodi- ld, loving and sym she eneounters suc sordid poverty, wealth, and Iiber f lowe dagziing Hohemilantem perfect Dilea, then commonplace Philietiniam Hlow threads her way over high pea‘ ‘ through dark valleys, how ehe restates nt how she succumbs, are the actuating ring» f « novel incomparable in this acl The European Sensa- tion of the Past Year A mas of the Sudermann of to- day.’ The Nation Translated by Thomas Seltzer 640 pages; $1.40 net; postpaid $1.55 B.W.HUEBSCH Publisher 225 Fifth ave., New York treme tf suger lhumes’se Camille \iene In the we by disposition ttl Lilly and thent pat het le Coanlively min fale ahie The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2320 The Only Up-to-Date Book on Polar Discoveries HAND-BOOK Polar Discoveries By GEN. A. W. GREELY » Of the United States Army This authoritative résumé of polar explorations from the earliest voy- ages has been thoroughly revised, and includes the latest discoveries by Peary, Cook, and Shackleton. Written by one who has himself at- tained distinction as an explorer in the Far North, this handbook has long been the standard work on the subject. In this new edition there has been added an excellent colored map of the Arctic regions that gives accurate information, and there are new chapters on “The Conquest of the North Pole” and “The South Po- lar Quest.” Gen. Greely considers dispassionately the claims of Peary and Cook. pages, with fers on ‘price 336 pepesravny- Cloth. 81.50 net; postpaid, $1.62. LITTLE, BROWN & C0., BOSTON Science A weekly journal, established in 1883, devoted to the advancement of the natural and exact sciences, the official organ of the American Asso- ciation for the Advancement of Science, publishing original articles and notes on the progress of the different branches of science, the proceedings of scientific societies and academies, reviews of scien- tifle books and articles, preliminary accounts of re- searches and full discussion and news on all sub- , jects concerning scientific men and scientific and educational institutions. Annual subscription $5.00. The Popular Science Monthly An Illustrated magazine, established in 1872, de- voted to the diffusion of science, publishing arti- cles by leading authorities in all departments of pure and applied science, including the applications of science to education and society innual subscription $3.00. Single copies, 30 cents. The America’ Naturalist \ monthly journal, established in 1867, devoted to the biological selences with special reference to the factors of organic evolution innual subscription $3.00. Single copies, 30 cents. THE SCIENCE PRESS Garrison, NV. Y. Lancaster, Pa. Sub-Station 84, New York. Single numbers 15 cents Juat Published TERRY'S MEXICO Immensely useful | to the traveler who wishes | to see all there is worth seeing in Mexico in the! moet expeditious, satisfactory and economical way. : Modelied after the celebrated Baedeker Gul tooks. 824 pages, 26 maps and plans. This Guide to Mexico in Complete, Price $2.50 net, postpaid. Circular on request from | SONORA NEWS COMPANY up in tx writers, and |} and revision Calle de las Estaciones | 12, Mexico City, Mexico | «”4 brary HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY, 4 Park Street, BOSTON | Art. Medici Series OF COLORED REPRODUCTIONS THE ) Old ‘Thasters A series of reproductions by pho- tography printed in color, Endorsed by the art critics everywhere—and enjoying the patronage of the Muse- um of Fine Arts Boston, the Boston Public Library, and many of the Universities, Colleges, and Libraries throughout the United States and -Burope. Illustrated Prospectus on request FOSTER BROTHERS 4 Park Square, Boston Sole Agents for CHATTO & WINDUS'S MEDIC! PRINTS The Eruption of Pelee BY ANGELO HEILPRIN This work embraces the main scien- tific facts contained in the author’s “Mont Pelée and the Tragedy of Martinique” and the “Tc wer of Pelée,” together with the results obtained from his last visit to the volcano in 1906, when it was found practicable to descend into the crater, whence the giant obelisk of rock had been ex- truded to a height of 1,000 feet. A quarto volume, containing a remark- able atlas of plates from photographs. Price $4.00; postage 54 centa extra. THE GEOGRAPHICAL SOCIETY OF PHILADELPHIA 400 Witherspoon Building, Philadelphia, Pa. AN EXPERIENTIAL PSYCHOLOGY OF MUSIC By KARL FEININGER “There can be no doubt that this work will arouse much comment, some discussion, and we e- -e— —_ of fact, all of which w only prove that those qualities which make for fite and rogrees. The musical thought of the Amer- can people would be the clearer if more comprehensive studies, similar in scope, were brought out every year. —The Violin World. Price 82.00. Postage, 10c. per copy AUGUST GEMUNDER & SONS 42 East 234 St. New York City, U. 8. A. LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all amets and in looked the Boston and Harvard echol- and bibliographies made. Proof-reading of manuscript. Highest university MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, 5 lations, Boston, Mass

Page 31

Dec. 16, 1909] The Nation. Vv NEWLY PUBLISHED BOOKS THE AMERICAN NEWSPAPER. By James Epwarp Rocers. This book is an intimate study of the American newspaper, and a reply to certain severe criticisms that have re- cently been made. The author has tried as far as possible to see both sides of the question, the subject of discussion be- ing treated as one of concrete fact, and he has therefore examined some fifteen thousand newspapers from all sections of the country as a means of getting acquainted with the necessary basis for an accurate judgment. The book discusses in succession the following topics: The Historical Evolution of the Modern Newspaper; The City and the Newspaper; The Nature of the American Newspaper; The Influence of the American Newspaper, and the Causes of that Influence. 228 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.00, postpaid $1.10. SOURCE BOOK FOR SOCIAL ORIGINS: ETHNOLOGICAL MATERIALS, PSYCHO- LOGICAL STANDPOINT, CLASSIFIED AND ANNOTATED BIBLIOGRAPHIES FOR THE INTERPRETATION OF SAVAGE SOCIETY. By Witiam I. THomas. The papers forming the body of the book are by such eminent modern anthropologists as Boas, Tyler, Westermarck, Spencer and Gillen, Haddon, and Rivers. The author has an introductory chapter on the standpoint from which the ma- terials are to be viewed, and critical comments are appended to each part. There are seven parts: (1) External En- vironment (Anthropogeography and Primitive Economics); (2) Primitive Mind and Education; (3) Early Marriage; (4) Invention and Technology; (5) Art, Ornament, and Decoration; (6) Magic, Religion, Ritual, and Ceremonial; (7) Social Organization, Morality, and the State. The extended Bibliographies form the chief feature of the book. 920 pages, 8vo bound in buckram, gold stamped, sewn on tape; net $4.50, postpaid $4.77. A MODERN CITY: PROVIDENCE, R. I., and Its Activities. Edited by Witttam Kirk. A popular description, by experts, of the city of Providence, under the following heads: Introduction, Geography, Population, Industry, Labor, Government, Finance, Education, Art, Philanthropy, Religion. For the sociological study which has received so strong an impetus in our day, nothing more apt can be imagined than this thoughtful, illuminating book. And for those who are not sociologists, but who take an intelligent interest in the welfare of our cities, the vol- ume will have a value and a charm quite unique. It is confidently commended to the reading public, both in Providence and elsewhere in America. Illustrated, 374 pages 8vo. cloth; net $2.50, postpaid $2.70. THE CAMERALISTS: The Pioneers of German Social Polity. By Avsion W. SMALL. To readers of English only, cameralism is virtually a lost chapter in the history of the social sciences. Although everything now belonging to German polity has a part of its heredity in that type of social theory, not every reputable student of the social sciences in America could correctly define the term, and few could name more than one or two writers to whom it is properly applied. In this volume there is given to readers of English the first reliable and de- tailed account of the cameralistic school. 500 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $3.00, postpaid $3.18. ENGLISH POEMS: The Elizabethar. Age and the Puritan Period. By Water C. Bronson. So favorable has veen the reception accorded “The Nineteenth Century” and “The Restoration and the Eighteenth Century” that the present volume needs little introduction. It follows the same general plan as its predecessors, with the added advantage of an especially fascinating field—the most spontaneous and exuberant period of English poetry. The notes contain elucidations of difficult passages and illuminating commentary—the index and bibliography are un- usually elaborate and detailed. 550 pages, 12mo, cloth; library edition, net $1.59. postpaid $1.66; school edition, net $1.00, postpaid $1.15. THE ARMENIAN AWAKENING. By Leon Arpee. This book will be found singularly interesting and appropriate in the light of the occurrences of the past few years. Beginning with the “Dark Ages” of Armenian history, the author traces the religious attitude and the struggles of this people from the time of the introduction of Christianity. It is a matter of common knowledge to all who are familiar with the Armenian struggle for religious freedom, that political forces have been a strong factor in the perse cution to which this people has been periodically subjected. All the sidelights which the conditicn of European politics could throw on the situation have been employed by the author, and his sympathetic treatment leaves the reader with a clear understanding of the various motives for the frequent outbreaks against the Armenians which have aroused th: Christian world. 240 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1.25, postpaid $1.36. BIBLICAL IDEAS OF ATONEMENT: Their History and Significance. By Ernest DeWir BurRTON, JoHNn MERLIN Powrs SmitH, and GERALD BIRNEY SMITH. This bock sets forth the content of the biblical teachings upon the subject of Atonement, and suggests the point of view from which these conceptions may profitably be studied at the present day. The attitude assumed toward the records throughout is that of historical interpretation rather than of theological systematization. Consequently, the ef- fort is to discover precisely what ideas of atonement are reflected by the biblical laws, institutions, and utterances. The authors employ the historical method throughout. To trace the history of an idea is to discover the forces that have co operated to produce it and to transform it from age to age. The history of the idea is thus its best explanation. Yet as many readers will desire, not only a historical statement of what was believed and taught by the prophets and teachers of old, but also some indication of the value of those teachings for the present day, the closing section of the book (chaps xii, xiii) is devoted to this aspect of the matter. 338 pages, 12mo, cloth; net $1..', postpaid $1.11. THE PSYCHOLOGY OF PRAYER. By Anna Lovtse Strona. A systematic investigation from the point of view of modern psychology of the mental processes involved in prayer Prayer is described as the result of the “conflict between different selves.”” This conflict in turn is eliminated by the prayer process. Numerous examples from actual observation of children add vividness to the work, which has a deep philosophic interest and throws light on present-day religious problems. 125 pages, 12mo, cloth; net 75 cents, postpaid 83 cents. THE CHILD AND HIS RELIGION. By Grorce E. Dawson. The aim of the book is to suggest the principal elements in the child’s religious nature and training. The first. chapter treats of interest as the fundamental dynamic factor in life and growth. The second chapter considers the child's natural religious reactions to its environing world as modes of such interest. The third chapter gives the results of an inductive study of children’s interest in the Bible. And the fourth chapter applies the principles thus brought to light to the general problem of religious education. The book is not a systematic treatise on the psychology of the child nor on religious education. It is believed, however, that it presents many essential principles that have not elsewhere been so fully worked cut. 130 pages, 12mo, cloth: net 75 cents, postpaid 82 cents. ADDRESS DEPARTMENT 21 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO NEW YORK

Page 32

£ t h e N a tion ; [Vol. 89, No. 2320 THE BAKER @ TAYLOR CO.’S BOOKS RETROSPECTIONS OF AN ACTIVE LIFE By JOHN BIGELOW “From the historian’s standpoint, the most important book of the year.”—Chicago Record-Herald. “These most interesting and historically valuable volumes.”—New York Tribune. “He tells a story that is of exceptional interest, even in these days of a surplus of per- sonal reminiscences.”—Boston Transcript. “The intrinsic value of the matter adduced outweighs all secondary considerations.”— New York Times. “Mr. Bigelow’s work is remarkable throughout for its clarity, orderliness and definite- ness of treatment.”—Review of Reviews. Svo. 61,x9% inches. Three volumes, boxed, each 600 pages, 48 illustrations, map, appendix, etc. Per set, net, $12.00—carriage extra. A History of Architecture VOLUME TWO Published Dec. 18. By RUSSELL STURGIS Published Dec. 18. This volume treats of the architecture of India, China, Japan, and Persia, the early Christian monuments, the Byzantine and Moslem architecture, and concludes with an ex- haustive treatment of the Developed or Later Romanesque. The third and final volume will be written by Arthur L. Frothingham, A.M., Ph.D., who is thoroughly in sympathy with Mr. Sturgis’s point of view, and will be ready in 1910. THE WISTFUL YEARS LONGFELLOW’S COUNTRY By ROY ROLFE GILSON, auther of “Katrina” By HELEN A. CLARKE “The most dainty and tender of idyls.”"—New York Times. A sympathetic account of the scenes of Longfellow’s Illustrated in two tints by F. Graham Cootes. $1.50; post- poems. A delightful gift book. 31 full-page illustrations. age, 13 cents extra. Boxed. Net, $2.50; postage, 20 cents extra. THE GARDEN IN THE WILDERNESS Similar Gift Books by the same Author A record of the garden which an artist and his wife made BROWNING’S ITALY out of a wilderness up the Hudson. “Bentley,” the artist, 21 illustrations. Boxed. Net, $2.00 has illustrated the text with fifty line drawings, sixteen photographs, and end papers. BROWNING’S ENGLAND Net, $1.50; postage, 14 cents extra. 20 illustrations. Boxed. Net, $2.00 THE CHILD’S GUIDE SERIES A CHILD’S GUIDE TO READING. By Joun Macy. Published Dec. 11. An illuminating introduction to the world’s great books by a recent Associate Editor of The Youth’s Companion. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO AMERICAN HISTORY. By Henry W. Etson. A most readable story of the events of our national life, told by the author of Elson’s American History. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO BIOGRAPHY. puptishea Dec. uu. By Burton E. Stevenson, author and librarian. An inspiring book of American character and achievement. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO MUSIC. By Danret Grecory Mason. Mr. Mason is a composer, critic, and teacher of music, grandson of Lowell Mason, and an authority in the field. Author of “The Appreciation of Music,” ete. A CHILD'S GUIDE TO MYTHOLOGY. By Hexen A. Crarke, author of “Longfellow’s Country,” “Browning's Italy,” ete. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO PICTURES. By Cuantes H. Carrry, author of “The Appreciation of the Drama,” etc. Cloth, 12mo, with many pictures, each $1.25 net. Postage, 12 cents extra. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., 33 East {7th St... NEW YORK

Page 33