The Nation 1909-12-09: Vol 89 Iss 2319
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nati®s
VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2319. : THURSDAY, DECEMBER 9, 1909. PR
" BEWERAL LIBRARY, UNIV. OF MICH. DEC 10 1909 ICE TEN CENTS. —__s—
A FASCINATING AND IMPORTANT WORK SVEN HEDIN’S new book Trans-Himalaya DISCOVERIES AND ADVENTURES IN TIBET With 388 illustrations from photo- graphs, water color sketches, and drawings by the author, and ten maps. In two handsome octavo volumes, $7.50 net (carriage extra) The travels of Dr. Sven Hedin across the forbidden country of Tibet will undoubtedly take a high place as a record of explora- tions more adventurous, and, in their results, more valuable to science, than any of recent years. Up to this latest journey of the distinguished explorer the grandest problems yet unsolved in the physical geography of Asia lay in the unexplored plateau of Northern Tibet. There must exist one or more mountain chains parallel with the Himalayas; probably there were wandering tribes; but if there were large rivers, lakes, or cultivated fields; if there was a settled population—or monasteries where a lama punctual as the sun gave the daily call to prayer from the roof by blowing through a shell that no one knew, and this Dr. Sven Hedin undertook to determine. The hardships of the journey were excessive; in threading mountain passes in bitter cold and piercing winds, he found such difficulties of transportation that he rejoices over securing Tsangpo boats as if they represented the luxury of travel. He describes them as “both simple and practical. <A skeleton or, rather, framework of thin tough boughs and laths is tied fast together, and is covered with four yak hides sewed together, which are attached to a rim of wood, forming the gunwale—and the boat is ready.” He was so fortunate as to reach the monastery town of the Tashi Lama, the highest prelate in Tibet, just before the great annual festival of Lamaism, and witnessed its celebration. The book is a graphic description of one of the most remarkable journeys in modern times, and no more entertaining and valuable work of travel could be desired Published by THE MACMILLAN COMPANY
64-66 Fifth Ave. New York
Page 2
ae a The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 18665. [Entered at the New York City Post Office as second-clasa mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Megwvico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Unton $4.00 iddreas THE NATION, Bow 794, Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. New York. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tuk WEEK : 96eséesGenesenenan Ge EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Socialism and Human Nature........ 560 Booker Washington’s Greatest Ser- vice . sucieebaneese 060080 6s60080008 560 The English Criais.. pousiseeen 561 PORE GOP CRN ODD ce cccccovcscosccess 562 Good Letter-Writing .............. £63 SPECIAL ARTICLES: Jessie White Mario cesoceeesoude 564 Contemporary Literature of Spain.... 566 CORRESPONDENCE: The Law's Delay. - peieenobus 567 The Ferrer Affair. er es The Discipline of Naturalism. peovcese 568 \ Sea-Change in Spelling............ 568 E®. PORGNED oc'evcevedocecersesocesséed Pr re Green Eyes LITERATURE: Notes on Holiday Books............... A Memoir of W. E. H Lecky 586 wees Seymour Charlton ....... ree The Severed Mantle PP 2 i reer re The Paladin p600s0den soebocw be Chinese Immigration .. on oun atva O The Evolution of the Messianic ‘Idea The Bretons at Home La Sardegna Medioeval NOTES SCIENCE The Natural History of Igneous Rocks 578 DRAMA rhe Incomparable Siddons wane ae Musi Hande oes 580 ART: The Isolated Art of Design - .. 581 FINANCE: Stock Exchange and the Opening of Congress seccess Gee Books OF THE WEEK 584 ***Coples of The Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenve de l'Opéra; in loodon of BB. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross, Reading Case for the Nation
2 A Park Street. Boston 208 Mich. Ave.. Chicego
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319
‘Educational.
THE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Everert 0. Fiex & Co., <yeeritare. 1505 Pa. Ave., Washingto: 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Rid. Minneapolis 202 swetland Bid.. Ly A 238 Dougl’sBid., Los A Berkeley eley 405 Coo Bid., Denver 618 Peyton Bid., Spokane 2142 Shattuck Ave. Ber Send to any address above for Agency Manua
ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of al) grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y.
A HARVARD PROFESSOR with twenty-five years’ experience as a teacher in high school and university, will take complete charge of two or three boys, preparing them for college or otherwise aiding them in their linguistic and scientific education. Address W. L., Care of the Nation.
Fowler & Wheeler’s Handbook of Greek Archaeology 82.00 Presents the essential facts of the subject, treating the latest phases. Carefully selected illustrations, 412 in number, accompany full discussions of Prehistoric Art, Sculpture, Terra Cottas, Bronzes, Gold and _ “Silver Work, Coins, Gems, Vases, Painting, and Mosaic. A short but authoritative manual. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston
FUNGOUS DISEASES OF PLA‘ TS By Benjamin M. Duggar. N. Y. State College of Agriculture, Cornell University. Price 82.00. The first text or reference book to be which is now as- published on a subject suming the greatest importance Adopted in advance of publication for use in the University of Vermont, the New Hampshire Agricultural Experiment Station of New Hampshire College, and the Agri- cultural Experiment Station of the Univer- sity of Nebraska PO By HENRY BARRETT HINCKLEY Mr. Hinckley is a Yale te, class of 1892, and a ized Chaucer scholar. Of his latest publication a critic has said: ‘‘Pre®minently Mr. Hinckley's poetry is charming and well-wrouglit. It will be read by all who are interested in the progress of American poetry. Whether or nut here is ‘the great American poet’ is not the «aucs- tion. Lovers of this form of literature cannot afford to be ignorant of ‘Oberon and Titania.’ ** An attractive octavo pamphlet of nearly forty pages, ‘‘Old Stratford"’ yr with wide margins. An elegant and inexpensive gift-book. Price 50c¢ Send your order by postal card directly to us, and we will send a coln-card to remit the ~rice with. THE NONOTUCK PRESS. Box 267, Northampton, Mass.. U. 8. STORIES WANTED BOTH SHORT AND SERIAL Short Stories, 2,000 to 4,000 words Serial Stories, 20,000 to 49 090 words What have you ready or in preparation? PHELPS PUB. CO.., Popular Fashions Dept SPRINGFIELD, MASS. A SUMMER IN TOURAINE By FREDERIC LEES. “‘An ideal companion for the tourist as well as for the armchair traveler.’’ —Chicago Record-Herald. With twelve plates in full color and many other full-page illustrations, and a map. Large 8vo, $2.75 net. By mail, $2.92. A. C. MeCLURG & CO., Chicago.
“TONO- BUNGAY” "TWE RELIGION se FUTURE” By CHARLES W. ELIOT, and other ‘EX terature sent free on request. Address Box 7/4, Barnstable, ass.
FOREIGN scvoenior aooxca, “AUGHN!TZ 128 Tremont Street, AUTHORS BOSTON, MASS.
GINN AND COMPANY DANTE’S INFERNO Edited with introduction, arguments, and footnotes by Professor C. H. GRANDGENT, of Harvard University. $1.25. Unnecessary erudition has been discarded, but il! information requisite for the understanding of Dante and his poem has been Included, D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers New York Chicage London
&4e Astor Edition of Poets schools and colleges. 09 vols. List price to schools, 40c.
ia the best for price, 60c. per vol.; SEND FOR LIST. Thomas Y.Crowell &Co., New York
INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS WHY WORRY ? and THOSE NERVES! Ry GRORGE L. WALTON,M.D. Cloth, §1 get, each J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia.
To receive the current numbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, with The Nation stamped on the side in gold Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents.
of Celebrities t and Gold. Send XL liste. AUTOGRAPH LETTERS
¥ Pub."THE COLLECTOR.’’$1 « vr
AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis.
Letters and Memorials OF Wendell Phillips Garrison Late Editor of The Nation 1865—1906 In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. Price $1.50 net, postpaid Houghton Mifflin Company BOSTON NEW YORK
A ie ole ee
Page 3
Dec. 9, 1909] The Nation. — NEW BOOKS OF IMPORTANCE—ART, SCIENCE, BIOGRAPHY, ESSAYS BEAUTIFUL CHILDREN IMMORTALIZED BY THE MASTERS By C. HALDANE McFALL. With Fifty full-page illustrations, printed in four colors, reproduced direct from the original paintings of the Old Masters. Edited by T. Leman Hare. Large 8vo, bored . . . net, $5.00 This is the largest and most beautiful collection of world famous paintings of children ever collected in a moderate priced volume. INTIMATE RECOLLECTIONS OF JOSEPH JEFFERSON By EUGENIE PAUL JEFFERSON. of the pictures being 8vo, cloth . . Profusely illustrated, many from photographs taken by Joseph Jefferson. ° . i. e net, $3.50 An intimate and charming account of Joseph Jefferson's personal side and his home life, written by his daughter-in-law. It tells much that no one outside the family circle could tell; it mentions many things that Mr. Jefferson, from feelings of delicacy, or modesty, could hardly have mentioned In his autobiography. SOME WONDERS OF BIOLOGY By WILLIAM HANNA THOMSON, author of ‘‘Brain and Person- ality,’’ ‘“‘What is Physical Life,’’ etc. 12mo, cloth net, $1.20 KNOWLEDGE, LIFE AND REALITY An Essay in Systematic Philosophy By GEORGE TRUMBULL LADD, Professor of Philosophy in Yale University. Author of ‘‘rhilosophy of Knowledge,’’ ‘‘Psychology, Descriptive and Explanatory,’’ etc., etc. Svo, cioth net, $3.50 INTRODUCTIONS TO NOTABLE POEMS By HAMILTON WRIGHT MABIE. bound with thirteen portraits of the poets. printed and net, $2.00 Handsome!y 8vo, cloth A collection of some of the greatest poems of the English language —poems which every one ought to know, which most people would be glad to know, but in its entirety a collection which, as a matter of fact, most people do not know. Each poem is introduced by a graceful essay which not only throws light upon the life of the poet, the subject of the poem, the circumstances under which it was written, ete., but which also gives the results of the latest and ripest criticisms After one of these Introductions, you are eager to read the poem referred to, and ready to enjoy its beauties. THEIR HEARTS’ DESIRE By FRANCES FOSTER PERRY. the season's Holiday Gift Books. Numerous illustrations in color by Harrison Fisner; decorations by T. B. Harcoop. A delight- ful story worthy of its beautiful setting. Svo, boxed net, $2.00 A GUIDE TO MODERN OPERA One of the most beautiful of By ESTHER SINGLETON, author of ‘‘A Guide to the Opera,’’ ete Illustrated with portraits of famous operatic stars. 12mo, cloth. net, $1.50 TREMENDOUS TRIFLES A New Volume of Essays By GILBERT K. CHESTERTON, author of ‘‘Heretics,’’ ‘Varied Types,"’ ‘‘Charles Dickens,"’ ete. 12mo, cloth net, $1.20 THE BOOKMAN, a Magazine of Literature and Life DODD, MEAD & CO., NEW YORK THE NEW INTERNATIONAL ENCYCLOPAEDIA Libhography of Economics PLAN OF MONTHLY ISSUE: In each number of the Journal of Political Economy there appear 20 to 30 pages of carefully selected and classified bibliography of current writing in economics. The field covered includes books, government publications of the leading countries, state and mu- nicipal reports, and nearly 100 periodicals. Monthly publication secures timeliness. PLAN OF CUMULATION: The first annual cumulation will be ready about March 1, 1910, and will contain much new matter. Terms: eee $2.50 net, postage extra “Journal of Political Economy,’ per year...... $3.00 First Annual Cumulation........... PS EET Te ae 5 a adhs $4.25 (both postpaid) To present patrons the cumulation will be furnished at above combination rate, if ordered on renewal. Payment to be deferred till publication date. Each issue of the Journal has also several leading articles, Notes upon Current Topics, The Washington Notes upon the Current Activities of the Federal Government, reviews and book notices which are timely. The current volume will be 160 pages larger than last year’s. Subscription Price $3.00 a Year; Single Copies 35 cents. Address Department 21 curcaco The University of Chicago Press new vork
Page 4
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 Now Ready A vital historical work The German Element in the United States By ALBERT BERNHARDT FAUST Assistant Professor of German in Cornell University. 8vo, $7.50 net. Postage, 40 cents. In two volumes, fully illustrated. An important historical work of great popular interest to many readers. The first volume deals with the history of the Germans in this country from the earliest times to the present. Beginning with an account of the first Germans who came to America with Leif Ericson in the 11th century, Professor Faust carries the narrative down through the founding of Germantown and the large German immigration to New York, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, Virginia, and South Carolina in the early 18th century, to the notable part played by them in the pushing out of the Western frontier, the “winning of the West.” He then proceeds to take up the role of Germans in the later wars of the 19th century, e. g., War of 1812, Mexican War, Civil War, and Spanish War, and concludes with a general summary of German immigration through the 19th century, with an account of the location, distribution, and general character of the immigrants. This volume is based upon the re-examination of a vast amount of material and draws likewise upon numerous sources hitherto unstudied. It is well arranged and thoroughly documented, yet it is so full of picturesque detail and illustrative anecdote that it is readable from start to finish. The second volume makes a searching analysis of the influence of the German element in our American civilization, and traces in the most interesting way the influence of the Germans on the material development of our country in both agriculture and manufacture, upon our political institutions, education and social life, and music, literature, and the drama. The book is lavishly illustrated with maps, portraits of eminent German- Americans, both pioneers and contemporaries, facsimiles of important docu- ments, historical scenes, etc., ete. " In short, the work is the first to deal exhaustively with this impor- tant subject, and will be indispensable for historical scholars, and of great value and interest for the general reader, while its appeal to readers of Cerman birth will be unique. BOSTON HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY NEW YORK
Page 5
The NEW YORK, THURSDAY, DECEMBER 9, 1909. The Week. Several important topics which Presi- dent Taft was expected to deal with in his first annual message he reserves for later and special communications to Con- gress. The conservation policy is one of them; others are the Anti-Trust law and the Interstate Commerce act. The first result of this deliberate omission of exciting subjects is to cause the mes- gage to appear routine and unemotional. That of itself is not a bad thing. The country has not yet recovered an appe- tite for the highly spiced message of which it had more than enough in recent years. The proverb might be amended to read: “Happy the nation whose Pres idential speeches and messages are dull.” Yet there is, after all, one theme, and the chief one, in President Taft’s mes- sage, which is so great a novelty that it might almost be called startling. We re- fer to his urgent demand that public ex- penditures be cut down. Not since Pres- ident Cleveland has Congress heard any- thing like this from the White House. Moreover, he does not stop with singing the praises of economy merely in the abstract. He not only declares that sav- ings are necessary, but shows how they may be made. By means of the so-called “budget committee” of the Cabinet, and through imperative directions to heads of departments, he has caused the knife to go deep into the estimates of public expenses. This total, as submitted to Congress by the Secretary of the Treas- ury, has been decreased from the last estimates of the Roosevelt Administra- tion by more than $90,000,000, and is $42,- 000,000 under the actual appropriations for the current fiscal year. Even to have set such a mark for Congress to attain is a great political event. It gives firm Pres- idential sanction to retrenchment, aad may help to bring back again the home ly virtues of prudence and thrift in gov- ernmental affairs. Economy and efficiency in the public service are the real watchwords of the message, though many other matters are touched upon. Of these, we shall here refer only to what the President says upon the tariff. First of all, he utters a reassuring word about the application ~\of the maximum tariff in a retaliatory sense. Mr. Taft is not spoiling for a tariff war with other nations. Quite the reverse, he informs Congress: “I beg to express the hope and belief that no such result need be anticipated.” Fur- ther, in dwelling upon the powers of the Tariff Commission, which the President thinks are ample, he says that “if the facts secured by the tariff board show generally that the rates of duty imposed by the present tariff are excessive, I shall not hesitate to invite the at- tention of Congress to this fact, and to the necessity for action.” This is a great advance over the Winona speech. It may not be a promise of definite tar- iff relief, but shows how it can be got, and faces in the right direction. It ap- pears from his concluding paragraph that the President is troubled by the continuance of high and prices. But he does not admit that this high cost of living is due to the tariff. Nor is it, in its entirety, for some prices increasing have risen all over the world. But the President would not deny that the tar- iff on woollen goods, which he has pub- licly declared to be indefensible, com- pels Americans to pay exorbitant prices for woollen clothing or else wear cot- ton or shoday. There we have at least one set of high prices for which the tariff is directly responsible. The executive order providing a sys- tematic method of appointments and promotions in the diplomatic marks an important step toward mak- ing that career attractive to qualified young men. The scheme laid down contemplates more than the mere intro- In- service duction of an examination system. itial appointments from outside the ser- vice are to be made only to the lowest grades, and the Secretary of State is dl- rected to report from time to time to the. President the names of those who have demonstrated special capacity. Careful records of efficiency are to be kept, as a basis of recommendations for promotion; and all the secretaryships in the diplomatic service are to be graded according to their importance and dif- ficulty, so that a transfer from one to another shall have a definite signifi- cance. The entrance examinations Nation. themselves will, of course, be of a char- acter bearing expressly on the special needs of the diplomatic service; and pro- vision is made for preventing the ap- pointment of those who may have the ability to answer examipation questions but have not the peculiar personal qual- ifications required, by ljmiting certifica- tions to persons specially designated by the President, subject to examination and other tests. A man has been found brave enough to dare to accept the mission to China. Marvelious to say, he, like Mr. Crane, comes from Chicago, and his heart is yet undeterred within him. The new ap- pointment seems promising. Mr. W. J. Calhoun is not merely a lawyer of high repute; he has several times rendered governmental service. As special com- missioner of President McKinley to Cuba, just before the outbreak of war, Mr. Calhoun made a report which did much to increase public indignation over conditions in that island. It Is only fair to say, however, that this was written in a judicial tone, and criticised Cubans and Spaniards alike. For some time after the outbreak of war, he was a valued adviser of President McKin- ley, who, on March 8, 1898, appointed him Interstate Commerce Commission- er. This office he resigned in 1900. In the year 1905, President Rooseveit ap- pointed him special commissioner to His judicial report is believed Roosevelt's intention to be very drastic with the ill-behaving Mr. Calhoun is, therefore, Venezuela. upon conditions there to have changed Mr. Venezuelans. qualifications not without diplomatic for his new post. We regret to note that the Secretary of War supports in his annual report the pending bill to increase the army by 612 officers. That there is serious absen- teeism is admitted—he reports 709 of- ficers who are away from their organiza- tions, among them not less than one- third of the captains of companies. Un- fortunately, Secretary Dickinson, like his predecessors, believes that the only remedy is increasing the total number of officers. The history of the army has demonstrated, however, that this is no remedy at all, so long as the War
Page 6
558 Department fails to set its face against useless and unnecessary details. When the number of officers for each regiment of cavalry and infantry was increased, on the reorganization of the army in 1901, it was on the distinct assurance of the War Department that the surplus of- ficers would take care of all necessary details. If the Department continues to lend officers to committees of Congress, to se-called military schools, and for a dozen other non-military furposes, as instructors, the drain wil! continue. ‘lo- day, no less than twenty nine officers are with the Panama Canal Commission, 105 on recruiting duty, ani sixty-thrae at private schools. Seeretary Dickinson is on the right track in asking that ca- pable retired officers should be assigned to active duty temporarily. This he can do now only if the officers consent. Be- fore deciding on an increase in officers which would be without parallel in any European service, Congress should begin by giving him this permission, letting him understand that unnecessiry details should be cut off. One recommendation for reform ts not to be found in Secretary Meyer's prelim- inary statement of the coming reorgan- ization of the Navy Department. There is no suggestion that the “political navy yards” which exist only by grace of the Senators and Congressmen States they are located, be done away. The Secretary or the President with the moral courage to grapple with this ques- tion has not yet been found. Yet there lies an opportunity for enormous sav- in whose ing, to say nothing of the release of of- ficers for other duties than policing ob- scure naval stations, such as that at New Orleans, or the one at Port Royal, South Carolina, whose useless drydock | no battleship can reach on account of. insufficient water in the channel. If manufacturing efficiency calls for the concentration of power plants in navy yards, the efficiency of the whole ser- vice demands the concentration of naval work at four or five yards at most. The reorganizers of the defunct United States Shipbuilding Company speedily found that the most economical way to handle those ship-yards which were worth keeping up was to let each yard do a specific work. Thus, one or two build large ships, one small vessels, an- other concentrates on repairs, and still n. The Na tio [Vol. 89, No. 2319 =— . — The Government should do likewise. There is nothing in the argument that in the event of war, it would be well to have a number of yards in case one might fall into the enemy’s hands. To most people, the news that J. Pier- pont Morgan has purchased from Thom- as F. Ryan the majority interest in the Equitable Life acquired by Ryan from James H. Hyde in 1905, has doubtless come as a great surprise. Those, however, who were fully conver- sant with the nature of the Ryan con- trol knew that a change of some sort was inevitable. The deed of trust, whereby Ryan placed voting power over his Equitable stock in the hands of three trustees, was due to terminate on the 15th of next June. One of the three trustees, ex-President Cleveland, had died, and his place in the trust had not been filled. Ryan himself had been with- drawing from active business, and a be- lief had long existed that his Equitable holdings were for sale. The arrange- ment whereby control of the life insur- ance company should be independently exercised by Mr. Cleveland, Mr. Morgan J. O’Brien, and Mr. George Westing- house was, in other words, a necessarily temporary expedient, and only a few months more remained to it. Conver- sion of the Equitable Life into a mutual organization, either through alteration of its charter, or through purchase of the Ryan stock by the company itself, had apparently been prevented by the courts, at the instance of minority shareholders. Mr. Morgan’s purchase of control is a not unnatural sequel. The President’s recommendation con- cerning the Naval Observatory is emi- nently sound. He urges that the official | head of that great astronomical estab- lishment should be an eminent astron- omer, and not a naval officer detailed for service for a shorter or longer term. | This mode of filling the post of head of the Observatory could not have surviv- ed so long as it has were it not for the false notion conveyed in the name of the institution. As the President truly says, all the uses of the Observatory specifi- cally related to the needs of the navy might be subserved at a small fraction of the present cost. The Pres‘dent calls it “the most mag- nificent and expensive astronomical es- tablishment in the world.” Together with its important observational work is carried on the Nautical Almanac, in con- nection with which the labors of Simon Newcomb and of George W. Hill have made American mathematical astronomy illustrious the world over. Importers of works of art are suffer- ing the necessary inconveniences that accompany a reform, as well as some that are wholly unnecessary. That it should take a fortnight to get an old picture through the customs is perhaps due to the sudden increase of importa- tion. Yet when one recalls that a skilled examiner should generally know offhand whether a picture is or is not twenty years old—the really ambiguous cases being very few—it seems certain that the organization of the customs is not adequate to the new work. If it were merely a question of waiting, doubtless the importers would possess their souls in patience. But an old painting on panel is about as perishable an import as a pineapple. What must have been the feeling of that dealer who, after waiting a month, received three old Dutch paintings which had entered the public stores intact, cracked from top to bottom? It is idle to say that he may sue the Government. That may or may not indemnify him for his loss. But damage of this sort cannot be reckoned merely in dollars. To deface a fine pic- ture diminishes the resources of civiliza- tion itself. We know of four notable pictures that have been thus injured— in every case it seems through heat— while in the custody of the government. ‘For these delicate objects either a spe- cial storeroom at a low and equable tem- perature should be provided, or, if that be impracticable, some system of prompt release under bond should be devised. The brusqueness of Secretary Knox's dealings with Nicaragua would appear heightened if it should prove to be true, as reported, that the Mexican Govern- ment was not consulted and does not _wholly approve of the steps that have been taken. Mexico as well as the Unit- ‘ed States was interested in the Central The part it real-| American treaty of peace and amity ly plays is that of a great national| which was signed at Washington in observatory, and its material equipment | 1907. another on equipments of various kinds. is of a character befitting such a part.| which Secretary Root conducted the ne It was a part of the skill with
Page 7
Dec. 9, 1909] gotiations that he was able to induce the Mexican Government to appear alongside ours in urging the five repub- lics to agree to leave off their chronic revolutionary and filibuster habits. Mex- ico is their nearest neighbor. territorial- ly, and her joining with us gave the movement for assuring peace in Central America an air of sincerity which oth- erwise it might not have worn. And it was so obviously the thing to do to keep the Mexican Government fully ad- vised of the whole situation and of the intentions of the Administration that we can hardly believe that Secretary Knox omitted this precaution. If it be true, as Napoleon said, that imagination rules the world, it is nowhere more true than in the world of diplomacy. No for- eign minister should fix his eyes on business to the neglect of sentiment. And it is already plain from the expres- sions of those entitled to speak for the feelings of South Americans, that the effect of Secretary Knox’s proceedings may be greater upon their imagination than upon actual conditions in Nica- ragua. Mr. Asquith’s followers are much en- couraged by the promise of hearty co- operation held out by the spokesman) of the Labor party in the House of Commons. The Labor influence is im- portant not only on account of the fifty and odd seats it now controls in Parlia- ment, but because of the many doubtful constituencies it can swing to either of the two great parties. The question is whether the Labor leaders feel that the present constitutional crisis threatens their own ultimate interests to an extent warranting the sacrifice of immediate party advantages to the common Liberal cause. It has been argued, for instance, that the Labor party, like the Irish par- ty, would be happy to see a large reduc- tion in the present Liberal majority; that would mean the balance of power in the hands of the small third parties. It may also be argued that if the Labor- ites can increase their own Parliamen- tary representation by a score of votes, they can even afford to see a Conserva- tive Ministry in power. That would be a policy of indifference as to who rules the roost until the time when the Labor party is itself strong enough to think of office. But, on the other hand, the Labor leaders cannot overlook the fact that a victory for the House of Lords The Nation. would mean a reaction which would take years to stem. it has repeatedly been shown that peo- sle can be more royalist than the King 1imself. Hungary is now in the midst of a political crisis centring about the juestion whether it is possible for a politician to be more Kossuthian than Kossuth himself. In 1906 the Indepen- dent party, under the leadership of Francis Kossuth, a son of the patriot leader of 1848, secured a majority in the Hungarian lower house, and Fran- is Kossuth became practically the lead- ng spirft in a coalition Ministry of In- ependents and Liberals pledged to the stablishment of universal suffrage and the reconstruction of the economic ar- angements with Austria. No serious ndeavor was made to redeem the prom. se of electoral reform, and the prestige of the majority also suffered from dis- sensions within the Independent ranks. \s a result, the Wekerle Cabinet resign- od early in the present year and an in- terim Ministry was installed. The break within the Independence party has come over the question of a separate Hungar- ian Bank which the extremists, led by De Justh, the former president of the Chamber, wish to see established by January 1, 1911. The project was oppos- ed as impossible by Francis Kossuth, who, however, has been unable to carry the majority of the party with him. Kos- suth accused his followers of treach- ery and declared that without the pres- tige of his name most of them could not have made their way into Parlia- ment. Whereupon the Justh faction ac- cused Kossuth of being recreant to the principles of his famous sire, because of his lukewarm defence of Magyar in- terests. There are now, therefore, an Independence and 1848 party, led by De Justh, and an Independence, 1848, and Kossuth party under the old leadership. The prospects for a stable Ministry in the immediate future are not bright. Premier Giolitti, who resigned office last week, has been the dominating fig- ure in Italian politics since 1901, when he entered the Zanardelli Cabinet as Minister of the Interior. In 1903 he formed a Cabinet of his own, and with a year’s interval in 1905-6 he has re mained at the head of the Government. The combination agains: Giolitti shows an odd alliance of Constitutional Liber- _ . HDdDY als, Republicans, and Socialists, rein- forced probably by the “fluid” vote that always inclines towards the victorious side. The specific question on which the Government has found itself weak is its ship-subsidies bill, in which it is accused of having made favorites of certain shipping interests. Giolitti might have saved himself by throwing over the unpopular members of his Cab- inet, the Minister of Posts and Tele- graphs, who negotiated the subsidy ar- rangements, the Minister of Instruction, who has antagonized the Anti-Clericals, and the Minister of Agriculture and In- dustry, who has against him popular opinion in Sicily. The chances are, how- ever, that Giolitti’s retirement means only a brief vacation. The Opposition may form a temporary coalition Minis- try, but it is evident that the Anti-Cler- ical Socialists and Republicans cannot work together with the Constitutional Liberal leader, Baron Sonnino, who is strongly opposed to a hostile policy to- wards the church. a contributor to the Revue Bleue writes that, with the exception of the nobility and the purveyors to their Christian majesties, “no one in Spain is interested in King or Queen, or royal infants.” He recalls the words of Ferdi- nand VII: “Spain is a bottle of beer, and I am the cork,” and puts them into the young King’s mouth. It may be granted that the patience of the country has been sorely tried; that cynicism is, perhaps, a natural enough philosophy for the Peninsula. But let it be noted that “the protests abroad prove that there is a common patrimony of liberty and democracy,” as the Madrid Impar- cial has declared. The Pyrenees are no longer a perfect insulation. If the pres- ent situation does not inspire overpower- ing optimism, yet the throwing down of the barrier is itself evidence against generalizations of a too sombre kind. During the regency were realized im- portant domestic reforms. Under Maria Christina revolution was subdued to evo- lution: the Anglo-Saxon method, as we like to think. There is no need to be too despondent over Spain’s future. The good work of years is not to be effaced in months. Already the new Liberal Government is at work, and the wide ex- tension of local rights and home rule just announced by Premier Moret may be an earnest of good things to come.
Page 8
560 SOCIALISM AND HUMAN NATURE. “After all,” says an able and effective in the Contemporary Review, “those who want Socialism want it be- cause they want liberty, because they are tired of being crushed and thwarted in a confused and planless world where writer men and peoples struggle and die with- out knowing for what they struggie or why they live.” The sentiment is fine, and it undoubtedly underlies the atti- tude of the finest and highest spirits among those who to-day range them- selves more or less completely on the side of Socialism. But what assurance have they that any socialistic reconsti- would furnish that basis of life which they crave? What reason have they to think that, in the new world they dream of, men would be penetrated with a knowledge of “what they struggle for and why they live”? In Edward Bellamy's phantasy, to be sure, there was to be nothing that could properly be called struggle at all; and it tution of society is the unattractiveness of such a world to men of vigorous nature which part- ly accounts for the rapid dying out of interest in that kind of Utopia. But, struggle or no struggle, how are we to infuse into the material world around us, or into the institutioas of society, that which will give to human life foundation? That no such foundation exists to-day, Socialist an absolute enthusiasts have no difficulty in show- ing; but that any change in social ar- rangements will bring about a state of things in which men will know a whit better than they now do “for what they struggle and why they live,” none of these writers gives us the faintest rea- son for belleving. Men may be happier or less happy; they may be better or worse; but the meaning and purpose of life will remain, just as it has always been, a mystery illumined only by the inward experiences of each individual. To Imagine that any contrivance can supply us with a full solution of the problem of human existence is to Iin- dulge a childish delusion. Perhaps the one man who has most consistently held up an ideal of life freed from the meaningless complexities of modern civilization is Tolstoy. The typical Socialist is set aglow by dreams of the beauty that might be breathed into the lives of all men if only the conquests of science and invention were properly utilized for the broadening of The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 every man’s horizon, the enrichment of every man’s opportunities! Tolstoy sees hope only in the abandonment of all the | vanities of learning ané art, all the end- | less developments of scientific progress, | and in the devotion of mankind to the) pursuit of the simplest duties and the cultivation of the simplest virtues. The ordinary Socialist holds that when prog- ress has done her perfect work, all man- kind will be emancipated, as a fortunate minority now are, from the dull pres- sure of exacting toil; and he assumes that this freedom will carry with it true felicity. Tolstoy believes that only in the common performance of homely | tasks is the salvation of men to be) found. The two views differ diametrical- | ly as to the means by which the goal is to be attained; but the goal in both cases is the same. That goal is a con- dition of the world in which the activi- ties of life shall give to the soul of man | a satisfaction different not merely in de- gree, but in kind, from that which man has hitherto enjoyed; different in kind because the satisfaction is definite where absolute it is now vague and elusive, where it is now relative. An interesting exposition of Tolstoy’s attitude, in the form of a letter to a peasant, appeared recently in the Times. That science is not only vain, but harm- ful; that its development has been but part of the exploitation of the poor by the rich; that the only true science is that which teaches man “how to live true to conscience, before God, his ap- pointed term of life’—these familiar Tolstoyan doctrines are, of course, set forth. “People need only cease to believe in the science introduced by force and by rewards, and not study it, but keep to the one free science” of right living, and the existing wretchedness of the great mass of mankind will “vanish of itself.” How purely this belief of Tol- stoy’s as to the future is an act of faith, may, perhaps, be best inferred from a single instance. He has been bit- terly denouncing the desire of any work- ingman for education, based upon the deceitful plea that this education will be used in the service of the people; what really happens, he says, is merely that one of the oppressed becomes one of the oppressors. The poor he describes as, “the half-naked, half-famished, dirty, never-resting, illiterate men, made de-| pendent for life by poverty, who work week.” And it does not seem to occur to Tolstoy that it is only in Russia, where popular education is unknown, that even the most extravagant agitator would dream of so describing the con- dition of the working masses; nor that the superiority of the state of the peo- ple in countries in which modern ideas of science are predominant has any bear- ing on his notion that science is the handmaiden of robbery. The usual Socialist millennium cen- tres, as does Tolstoy’s, upon the thought of a fundamental harmony running through the whole life of society and giving to human existence a significance to which, under present conditions, it can lay no claim. But whether such harmony as is aimed at in either case, supposing it attainable, would truly sat- isfy the longings of human nature is a question on which either gives us little help. In this same letter of Tolstoy’s may be found an unconscious confes- sion that his own idea does not satisfy his instinctive feeling of the needs of human nature. There will always, he tells us, be plenty of work to do: That work will consist of making clear to every man what he must do that none should be hungry or deprived of the use of the land on which they were born, that there should be no women giving up their bodies to dishonor, that the temptations to intoxication, alcohol, opium, and tobacco should not exist, that men should not be divided into hostile nations, that there should be no murder of foreigners in war, and of one’s own people on gallows or guil- lotines, that there should be no religious deceptions, and many other things. What is this but an admission that not a state of perfection, but of imperfec- tion, nota grand unbroken harmony, but struggle and trial, not the absence of temptation and hardships, but the fight to overcome them, is necessary to the ‘exercise of man’s vital forces, the work- ing out of man’s nature? And this once admitted, what becomes of the arraign- ment of the present condition of society because it does not give life an absolute meaning, does not enable men to know “for what they struggle and why they live”? == ‘BOOKER WASHINGTON'S GREATEST SERVICE. The remarkable success of Booker T. Washington's latest speaking-tour in the South emphasizes again his usefulness to the whole country. In this réle as sixteen hours a day for two rubles ajan interpreter of one race to another,
Page 9
Dec. 9, 1909] pleading tor ciaeeedaine mateal reapect, | and justice, he is performing a patriotic service which it would be hard to over-| estimate. One of the foremost white educators now at work in the South ex- claimed on hearing of the details of Mr. Washington's recent trip through Ten- nessee: “Now I believe there is going to be a revolution in the South in favor of the negro.” Of the fifty thousand per- sons who, it is estimated, attended his meetings, nearly one-half were white; and in every case he was received with an enthusiasm which would have turn- ed the head of any less balanced and sa- gacious leader. Lest we be accused of exaggeration, we would remind our readers that Judge Floyd Estill, at Winchester, Tennessee, introduced Washington the negro, once a homeless and destitute wanderer, as “a fine type of the true Southern gentle- man”; that Judge J. H. Price, another typical Southerner of high position, classed Booker Washington with the first President, with Thomas Jefferson, Madison, and Monroe, Lee, and other Virginia worthies, as among that State’s most distinguished sons; and that Judge J. M. Steen of the Circuit Court intro- duced him with these words: We believe that as the patriarchs of old were inspired by God to lead their people out of darkness into light, to guide them on the right road to right living and suc- cess, so he who is to speak to us to-night is inspired to lead his race to higher, better things. But his message is not for you alone. It is not alone for this city or this State. By helping you he helps us; by helping you he helps every man, woman, and child in all this broad land of ours. All of this is enough to make any man accustomed to the ravings of the ordi- nary Southern office-seeker, or firebrand lecturer of the Tillman order, rub his eyes and ask whether a revolution is not actually at hand. Yet these com- pliments to Mr. Washington and his work were received with the heartiest approval by thousands of earnest white listeners. Still, this turning to Mr. Washington by such men of prominence ought not to surprise us. It is just the better self of the South coming to the front. Men like the judges we have quoted have come to see that if the races are to live in peace and comfort, the negroes who are progressing, who are laboring in because he is an American. jalso long battled for fair play; }it has incurred unmerited criticism for The Nation. the obligation the South owes to the negro. Speaking at Brownsville in Mr. Washington’s presence, Judge John R. Bond of the Tennessee Circuit Court said: “I was born and reared here in the South, and have associated all of my life with negroes. I feel that as a Southern white man I owe a debt to the negro I can never repay.” His gratitude was specially for the way in which the negroes protected and cared for the white women and children who were left at home during the war. But there is even a higher and more sacred obli- gation than that—the duty of caring for a backward race because it is backward, and of helping it onward and upward. The man who would injure a defective or crippled child must be an outcast from society; the time will come when all nations will take a similar attitude towards those human beings who are handicapped, particularly if, as in the case of our negro, their plight is large- ly no fault of their own. To this quiet but ever-present appeal the true Southern gentleman is bound to respond, because he has a heart, because essentially he believes in fair play, and Further proof of this lies in the space given to Mr. Washington’s trips in South Caro- lina, in Virginia, in Mississippi, and by the newspapers cf those sections. The Tennessee has yielded to Mr. Washington its first pages and reported his speeches in full, in Tennessee, press even where the prozeedings called for four or more columns. At Charleston, last winter, the prominent editors joined the Mayor in welcoming the colored orator; sat upon Mem- recently in Tennessee the editors have his platforms. More than that, the phis Commercial-Appeal has honored itself and its profession by in- structing its correspondents to bear down as lightly as possible upon negro crime and to say as much as possible about negro strivings for betterment. The Nashville Banner is another jour- nal that is doing its best to be the negro, and trying not to lay undue just to stress upon the crimes of the rascals who disgrace their race—just as are plenty of white men who do the devil’s work. The Columbia State has recently there Mr. Washington's spirit, must be sus- | denouncing the unjust punishment of a tained and upheld. More and more, too, men of standing are bound to recognize | | negro because he was a negro. To come back to Mr. Washington, the O61 greatest service he can render to-day is plainly not at Tuskegee, and not at the White House conferring as to appoint- ments, but on the stump in the South. His bearing and popularity enable white it would sometimes be difficult to do so men to speak out freely where if the negro endorsed were less well known. Public opinion is far dreaded in the South than in the North; it takes vastly more courage there to break the habit than anywhere else in this country, more bonds of custom and for is Let this read Walter Page's new novel, social ostracism more quickly him who doubts “The The reason why the edu- brought to bear. Southerner.” cator we have quoted sees a revolution coming is because Southern men every- where are beginning to break away from the conventions, even the terrorisin, which have kept them silent heretofore At any rate, Mr. Washington is to-day u great inte,preter and leader. This must be recognized, whether one agrees witi It is justi death of Brown; who could have thought in 1859 him in all his views or not. fifty years since the Joha that a colored man in 1909 would have so won the gratitude and esteem of the nation? THE ENGLISH CRISIS. Thoroughly discounted as last week's vote in the House of Lords had been, it yet came at the end with the sense of a great historic event. It marks the imminence of a vital change in the Eng- lish Constitution. Say what one will, the Lords have violated the unbroken prece- dent of years. They have laid rude nands ou a Money Bill. all the text-book party, and a long line of statesmen, This is an act which writers, of whatever whe- ther Liberal or Conservative—including among the latter Lord Salisbury and Mr. Balfour himself—-have declared to be be- yond the competence of the upper. cham- ber. Constitutionally, in the we are presence of an indubitable revolution. The Lords have the legal power to throw out the budget, in the sense that without their consent,and the King’s, it cannot become law, but the constitutional doc- trine is firmly established that they have no longer the right to withhold their consent to a money bill which has passed the Commons, any more than has the King. From the standpoint of the the English Constitution, Lords
Page 10
= . N62 are wholly and hopelessly in the wrong. If that Constitution were written as ours is, and enforceable by a suit in a Supreme Court, there can be no doubt that the action of the Lords would be declared null and void. In tion is not only unwritten, but fluid and The of last English democracy. This recognized by the terms of England, however, the Constitu- changeable. English court resort is the is shrewdly the motion adopted by the Lords, name- ly, that they would not accept the bud- get until it had been passed upon by the the aristocratic house peopl Thus vould seek to appear more democratic than the Commons. But it may be etorted that this semblance of defer- ence to the democracy is a sham. The Lords profess to appeal to the mass of oters, but in reality they are acting in 1 way to deprive one-half the voters of the effectiveness of their ballot. Tnat is to say, Liberal votes will not hereafter ount, in the matter of taxing, if a per- manently Conservative and non-elective of Lords may reject any taxes of The sort of House hich it does not approve. referendum on the budget which the Lords are blandly proposing is only a is logically and po- The half-way thing It litically necessary to go further. electors will pronounce on the whole Constitutional issue, which runs far be- wil, if Liberal party, make it yond this year's budget; and they sustain the rtain that sweeping guarantees against meddling by the Lords will be exacted. his, then, Is the far-reaching question which will soon be passed upon in a general election. From it, the House of Lords may emerge, either with its pow- ers enlarged and its prestige enormous- so discredited that it ly enhanced, o7 emain in the English system as lit- tle more than a gilded nullity. Yet we must be on our guard against exaggerating the crisis by taking it for will suddenly granted that the English doctrinaire and apply root-and branch Walter thanked God that his countrymen methods Bagehot pub- licly never mixed logic with their politics, and we may be sure that they wiil not begin to do so overnight. Extremists on both sides will prophesy dire things of paign, but it may well prove that the in- not in the course the impending cam- grained English moderation will permit violent extremes in either direc- tion. On the one hand, we have the pic- The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2319 ture, in the event of Liberal stccess, of a single-chamber government driven into wild Socialistic excesses. But no elec- tioneering oratory will persuade sober Englishmen that anything like that can result. The other picture is of an hered- itary House of Lords, emboldened by its great triumph, if the Conservatives win, itself up haughtily above the Commons in all matters. But that is also too lurid. Mr. Balfour himself, if he were to become Prime Minister again, be the first to read the overweening Lords a severe lesson, and to threaten them with all kinds of pains and penalties if they thought to ignore or over-ride the wishes of the directly elected representatives of the people of setting might easily England. It is evident, too, that this practical English good sense will be applied to the immediate problem of the financial confusion caused by the rejection of the budget. This has been called “chaos,” and it might easily be made so by the Ministry. With the failure of the bud- get, all the annual and increased taxes collected since last April are illegaliy in the Treasury and could be recovered by a suit at law. Their total amount the Economist reckons at more than $250,- there would also be the rest of the fiscal year to provide for. To 000,000; and raise this large sum by a loan or Treas- ury Bills would be awkward. But the Government has already notified import- ers of tea that the tea duties will sure- ly be validated, and it is reported that the income tax will go on being collect- ed without protest. It might be thought good tactics for the Liberal Cabinet to make the financial situation created by the Lords appear as bad as possible; but the leaders of a party which stands for good sound finance do well to show that they are prepared to do everything in their power to mini- mize the disturbance. Liberal hopes and the Liberal cause do not depend upon inflaming men’s minds about disordered order and finances. The coming contest is one into which enter unitedly and They could not have the Liberals will with high spirit. asked better ground on which to fight. to our acceptance of children as the Six months ago, everything was going heavily. But the budget and the con- flict with the Lords have changed the whole face of the political sky. Where the election prophets were saying a year ago that the Liberals were certain to be severely beaten at the next gen- eral election, they now forecast a Lib- eral majority—though, of course, much reduced from that of 1906. Whatever the outcome, the struggle will be of intense interest because such great issues and momentous consequences are involved. The thrilling watchwords which the Lib- erals now have at their command have not echoed in England since 1832. Amer- icans have special reason to follow the political battle with eagerness, since it is certain that the high debate on pop- ular rights and on taxing accumulated wealth cannot fail to have a powerful in- fluence in this country. We in the Unit- ed States shall soon have these burn- ing questions thrust upon us also. READING FOR CHILDREN. We assent, shamefacedly enough, to the reflections made by foreign criticism upon our con- Americans are wont to duct of the business of parentage. Our children are seen and very much heard, they are ill-mannered, conceited, insub- of the household. Their chief hope, not, to be sure, of ordinate—tyrants good manners, but of decent citizensh!p, lies in the curiously strict discipline pro- vided by our public-school system. Con- fessing our individual inadequacy, we appoint a formidable pedagogue whose duty it is not merely to teach the young but to teach the Later, the business is taken up by experience—by the exactions of business and social life. In the end our children turn out much idea how to shoot, young will how to submit. better than we have any reason to’ ex- pect, much better, certainly, than we de- As individuals, we have done what we could to make nuisances of them. In some such guise we must see our- selves as others see us; and how shall serve. we make denial of it as a totally false presentment? There is, no doubt, a tit for tat. Our feebly good-natured hand- ling of children is, we may retort, due against the party in power. As Lord | staples of domestic life. Among other Morley is reported to have said in pri- peoples, it seems to us that they are vate, whatever the Government under- oftenest regarded as necessary but in- took to do seemed to be unpopular. Bye- convenient incidents. The English child elections were running against them | of the better class,as we see him in fic-
Page 11
Dec. 9, 1909] tion, is pretty strictly confined to the nursery and the playground until the wished-for hour arrives of his dismiss- al to the public school. At intervais his “gov'nor’” recognizes his existence with a pat on the head, a platitude, or a fiver. childhood are “the And his memories of touched with dreamy visions of mater” in a ball-gown momentarily (and not without sentiment) inspecting her safely dormant offspring as she passes to the This sort of casual acquaintance between parent real business of life. and child does not seem to exhaust the of the We flatter ourselves that the American child possibilities relationship. knows its own father, at all events, and we look askance at the importation of the foreign method among our “best people.” But we confess certain misgivings as It is to be hoped that the alien observer may have noted to our own wisdom. a cheering sign or two of late, as, for example, our growing sentiment against the Comic Supplement. This offence has become so extreme as actually to bring But the which it springs, and which it brings to a horrid itself home to our nostrils. source of it, the root from efflorescence, is perhaps less generally perceived. Much nonsense has been put forth about the regulation of children’s read- ing. This is a late day to attempt a rigid censorship of an urchin’s literary acquaintances, and as for leading him, there is probably no method better than that of our grandfathers—to turn him loose in a man’s library and let him taste its strong fare. For the rest, any normal boy ought to relish the absurdi- ties of the dime novel,and any natural girl ought to be able to wallow in the Blood-curdling adventure is as necessary to the diet of sentimental fairy tale. the one as sugary romance is to that of the other. Even the watery pap pro- vided by the average Christmas book or in the pages of the ordinary childien’s publication, probably does little harm if less good to the adolescent morale. But we have a class of writers “for youth” whose influence is really demor- alizing. It is their postulate which the Comic Supplement develops to the point of nausea. We mean that order of scrib- bling parasites who make a business of flattering children into the belief, or the “working hypothesis,” that they are wiser and better than their elders. The Nation. Honest parent, do you know why your boy likes Horatio Alger? Did you ever read “Do or Dare,” or one of its con- geners? If so, you realize that a iarge part of the charm lies in the superiority under all circumstances of the youthful His father is a grown hero. or guardian, or em- ployer, man, and, as such, either a fool or a tyrant—preferably a little of each. The boy himself, from the first page, is exhibited in the envia- ble act of doing or daring his elders at There ger for him in “sassing back.” gle is ever permitted to fall upon his he is immune from alli is no dan- No shin- every possible turn. sacred person; the ills that a mortal puerility is natur- In short, he is the kind of The ally heir to. fellow a fellow would like to be. same bauble of triumphant adolescence is dangled before the fancy of the gir! We remarks by chance contact with a new reader. have been moved to these story by a popular writer for girls. The heroine has always been downtrodden by a heartless and stingy mother. We have the advantage of admittance to the the moment when the worm turns. After the have nothing to fear for the daughter who thereafter has everything her own selfish, greatly admired, to all appearances, by her describe her as “living the Rule.” It is hard to believe in the hon- esty of the purveyor of this sort of com- modity. We do not see that he is to be distinguished in kind from those notor- ious offenders who are guilty of the red and yellow enormities of the Comic Sup- scene at first few pages we way—a vain, saucy little prig, creator, who does not hesitate to Guiden plement. GOOD LETTER-WRITING. “Authors, my altogether dear woman, can't write letters. At best they squeeze out an essay now and then.” James Rus- sell Lowell wrote to this effect precisely forty years ago, in addressing Miss Nor- ton; and he added: “They are thinking of their punctuation, of crossing their t's and dotting their i’s, and cannot al- together forget themselves in their cor- respondent, which I take to be the true recipe.’ The enough: the writer of good books is not necessarily a good letter-writer. He is even apt to be, like Dr. Holmes, only “a very good correspondent as a reader of But with Lowell's explanatory assertion of fact is true letters.” NG3 principle one is tempted to quarrel. The best letter-writer does not forget him- self in his correspondent: he leaves it to his correspondent to do the forget- ting. And while on the subject of rules for letter-writing, let us not overlook Howell: “a be a Hungerlin becomes a Letter James Letter or Epistle should short-coated, and closely couch'd; more handsomely than a gown.” Such recollections come to one who Lafcadio Hearn’s “Japanese Let- Monthly. Bis other reads Atlantic Elizabeth letter-writers, like Miss Bisland, ters” in the current with an introduction by land. “Great artists,’ observés “must needs have the original birth-gift; but this gift, to ripen to complete fruition, requires certain fostering circum- stances.”” Some loneliness of character or of condition is one of these “fostering either or a circumstances” shyness, lack of ease in oral expression, or want of sympathetic companionship. “Madame de Sévigné and Lord Chesterfield were both reported stiff and dry in conversa. tion,’ says Miss Bisland; “FitzGera'd was exaggeratedly diffident. Lamb's fam. ily sorrows forced him to turn to others for intimate intercourse; and the same was true of Thackeray Stevenson's long exile made his pen his best means of fellowship.” All this is not pure theory. To expect the ordinary “liter- ary man” to write letters is, commonly, much like expecting the carpenter to spend his holidays (as Gautier express- ed it) “planing boards for the fun of it.” He demands a special provocation, an eloquent incitement. Such an incitement or inspiration was Lafcadio Hearn's. “His shyness was ex- treme,” as one testifies who knew him well. “His life, vear, was a sojourn in foreign lands from his nineteenth Without family ties for twenty years, those ties, when formed in middle age, bound him to aliens in race and tongue.’ He attained to a greater intuitive know! edge of the Japanese than it has been given to other Occidental men to have. Yet he never so mastered the language as be able freely to express his thoughts in the tongue of his wife and children. “I'm writing,” he told Professor Chamberlain of the Imperial University, in one of the newly published letters, to “just because I feel lonesome. However, if I can amusg you at all, you will forgwe me” Forgive him? One may easily afiswer for Chamberlain as to
Page 12
y64 that. What is more, it is easy to pity him, that subt'e colorist and etcher: The illusions are forever over; but th memo of many pleasant things remain I know much more about the Japanese than I did year ago; and still I am far from ider inding them well Even my own ttle wife is somewhat mysterious stil! to , though always in a lovable way Hearn is not, we think, one of the greatest Engiish letter-writers, although some of his letters written from New Or- eans shake us in that opinion. Certainly his letters have always a_ fascinat ing subject-matter; it was his to live in strange places, to read strange books, to eat forbidden fruits. His correspond- is. finally, to be treasured as no other writer's since Edward FitzGerald. In it, one finds the same vivid color which in his tales of ind flexible craftsmanship with made acquaintance old Japan, and in his essays and travel- When other letters were pub- sketches lished, three years ago, we called his ouch “magic,” and we reiterate the vord. Nor was he writing for the pub- li only out of his great love for friends, and out of his pitiable lonell- ne Here was one letter-writing au- ther unpreocecupied with his punctua- one whose thought went farther tion; than the “crossing of his t's and dotting of his i's.” And yet, in him, we have me of our rare writers with an artistic conscience: a faculty that we have lost in this era of “virile” style, masking a literary anemia JESSIE WHITE I. MARIO, The historian of the great modern na- tional movements finds himself perplex- ed by being obliged at every moment to discriminate strike the balance Emotion—the elements out of which human events are They be but more they antagonists; an! al- though either may give the impetua to a political revolution, the other finally control it. As mankind in the mass has always acted from the emo- much more than from reason, to be lifelike, should be rich In Needless to say, how- or to between Reason and two pun. may allies otten are oclal or may tion history emotional data. ever, these are usually the hardest to recover. The result is that most writ- ten histories have an orderly, almost cut-and-dried character which rarely be- longed to history in the making. Rare- ly, too, would the actors in an historic movement recognize themselves as mov- ing from point to point with the im- posing inevitableness with which the logical historian endues their action. ‘The Nation. No recent historical period, not even that of the French Revolution, was so surcharged with emotion as was the Jtal- To understand the course of its events, at least from 1815 to 1848, one needs, above all, to know the emotions which underlay Italian pa- fashion, we may de scribe the struggle as a conflict between the New, intoxicated with Emotion, and the Old, shut up in a strait-jacket of longer served the common needs. For though Reason may be infinite and eternal, those special bits for the pur- ian Risorgimento. triots. In some Reason which no of it which men isolate poses of a party or for a time, are not: and the Reason which ficed to make absolutism acceptable hideous perversion. It is just because Jessie White Mario emotions which ruled one of the great divisions of Italian patriots that her life has a typically embodied the so important than Perhaps the far more actual deeds. significance any of her fact that she was an Englishwoman who adopted the cause of Italy with all the fire of an unusually vehement nature, makes her Italianism a little more salient than that of the Italians them- selves. verbially thorough; Jessie White was not, in one sense, a convert, for her love of freedom hood and equality were inborn; lavished her devotion to these ideals, and which she felt doubly bound to de- fend Her last volume, which has been ad- mirably compiled by Duke Litta*, is less autobiographical than those of us who knew Signora Mario would like to have it. Until she appears on the scene in 1854 it is, in fact, an informa) his- tory of Mazzini. She states in her own way the gospel of the great agitator; she tells the story of his apostolate—of the seemingly futile expeditions, of the years of exile, sometimes dark to the verge of suicide, and always filled with indefatigable conspiring. This storv she has told before in Italian, but she adds here many touches which will appeal to American and English readers. Of Maz- zini’s life in London, for instance, of his friendships with the Carlyles and cther English men and women, she writes in- timately. If any one still doubts the personal charm—yes, the lovableness also—of Mazzini, he need only read these glowing pages. II. Jessie White, born at Gosport, May 9, 1832, was the daughter of a prosperous English yacht-builder. From her youth *''The Birth of Modern Italy."’ Posthumous Papers of Jessie White Marlo, edited with Intro- duction, Notes, and Epilogue, by the Duke Litta- Viseconti-Arese. lUllustrated. New York: Charles $3.50 net. Seribner’s Sone had once suf- to entire nations, was now regarded as a The zeal of the convert is pro- and her belief in brother- but Italy became the object on which she [ Vol. 89, No. 2319 up, she was a “heretic,” whether in her attitude towards the effete Anglicanism of the time, or in her social and politi- cal ideals. At twenty-one, she was seup- porting herself by teaching and writing —a remarkable achievement for a young Englishwoman in that period. At twen- ty-two, she lived in Paris; and the next year she visited Italy as companion to a lady who became engaged to Gari- baldi. On that journey, the young zealot met Garibaldi—indeed, she and Lady X. travelled for six weeks with him as their guide in Sardinia. Thenceforward, Jessie White dedicated herself heart and soul to the cause of Italy. In England, she went about giving lectures; she translated Orsini’s “Memoirs”; she felt the spell of Mazzini and sought him out. She says: Being at liberty, with my father’s hearty consent and blessing, to dedicate myself to the cause of Italy, fully conscious that it was a question of “all in all or not atall,”... I decided to put myself under the guidance of its chief apostle, Mazzini. My first visit to his tiny room in Cedar Road, remains ever present to my heart and vision. Birds were flying about the apartment, a few lilies of the valley stood in a vase on the mantelpiece, books and paper were scat- tered everywhere, and there, writing on his knee on the smallest fragment of the thinnest imaginable paper, sat Mazzini. He at once: his hand-grasp and lumin- ous eyes fascinated and encouraged you, yet filled you with momentary awe. But the simple greeting, the gladness shown in welcoming “one more volunteer to the noble band of English workers and lovers of Italy,” put all fears to flight, and soon he was talking, and I was listening as a student a master anxious to convince, but not in the least desirous of imposing his convictions (p. 260.) rose to Henceforth, she was in that happiest state of zeal, in which the young disciple yearns for an opportunity to be put to the test. That opportunity came in 1857, when Mazzini planned a stroke at Genoa. Miss White went there, os- tensibly as correspondent to several Eng- lish papers, but in reality to engage in preparing the fina? stage of the plot. The Mazzinian conspirators, into whose in- ner circle she was introduced, seemed to her unjaded enthusiasm demigods and heroes; nor did she ever lose the glamour of that first initiation into the ranks of men who were willing to give their lives for their belief. Disillusions, only too many! came later, but they could not shake her conviction that the enthusiasts of 1857 and their plans were perfect. Mazzini himself glided noiseless- ly into Genoa, where, to the despair of the police, he stayed many weeks and di- rected a three-headed movement, which embraced the conquest of Naples by Pisacane, the seizing of Leghorn and revolutionizing of Tuscany by Quadrio, ,and the capture of Genoa itself by Maz- zini and his immediate staff of con- .spirators. Miss White, being a British subject, had the advantage of going
Page 13
Dec. 9, 1909] The Nation. about without being dogged by detec-_ tives. The plot failed in all of its three pur- poses; and, except for the sacrifice of Pisacane and his companions, it failed fatuously. His slaughter, like that of John Brown, impressed the imagination o? millions, and had its share in has- tening the crisis that soon followed. Nei- ther then nor afterwards, however, did Jessie White admit that the project was ill-advised. To hear her describe those days, was like listening to a fairy story, in which each particular detail is viv- idly real, but the plot appears to the eye of reason unsubstantial. She would recall the gladness with which she and two or three Italian young women deck- ed Mazzini’s chamber and bed with gar- lands on the day of his arrival in Genoa; they were as blithe as if death were not the penalty that awaited his discovery. She would laugh ironically at the stupidity of the police. Once, when they came to the Pareto Palace to ferret him out, he himself opened the door, having hastily put on the cook’s white cap; after they had gone inside, he slipped out. “It was the upper half of Mazzini’s head that distinguished him,” she used to say; “the cook’s cap hid that.” She laughed scornfully when she learned, long afterward, that Cavour sent to Paris for detectives who knew Mazzini by sight. That Mazzini came and went untouched during ten weeks proves the extent of his own coolness and the loyalty of jis confederates. Being arrested for complicity in the attempt to seize Genoa, Jessie White was imprisoned for several months, un- til Cavour finally set her free, because he thought it more prudent to let her go (although he had conclusive evidence against her) than to rouse a storm of protests from the English Friends of Italy, who would have branded her pun- ishment as persecution. Unqualified zealot that she was, she hankered for this crown of martyrdom. Thencefor- ward, she hated Cavour with a thorough and frank hatred, wnich envenoms her criticism of him in this book and in her other writings. And here, we see how finely she embodies the emotion of her cause. Reduced to its essence, the Mazzinian plea ran thus: “We are bent on freeing and uniting Italy. We are disinterested and absolutely unselfish. Our hearts tell us that justice, right- eousness, and human progress hang upon our success. Whoever opposes us, up- holds injustice, wrong, and reaction.” Mazzini decided that, for strategic pur- poses, he must control Genoa for a time: that was reason and excuse enough for attempting to seize it, and to justify Jessie White in denouncing Cavour for preventing them. What right had Cavour to thwart zealots whose purpose was absolutely patriotic? He also pretended to promote the Italian cause; but if he were sincere, he surely would not ar- rest these fellow-workers in the cause. Forty years later, when I discussed this episode with Signora Mario, she had not budged an inch from her posi- tion. The idea that a constitutional government must employ constitutional methods, though these be slow or par- tial, never moved her. Naturally, there- fore, she would not recognize that a prime minister, responsible for the peace of his country, cannot permit any group of citizens to seize and govern one of its cities for the benefit of their particular scheme of salvation. The right to levy private war she might not defend in words, as she did in practice: but she always took it for granted that con- spiracy and rebellion had a holy aim. Like Garibaldi, she denied that any regard for international diplomacy ought to influence the action of the Italians. She firmly believed, though she never explained how this could be done, that Italy could have been united without the coédperation of Napoleon III, and that consequently the cession of Savoy and Nice was treachery and a crime. So Garibaldi was continually calling for the appointment of a dicta- tor—himself—to hasten the solution of the most intricate political problem of the age. So Mazzini, in spite of thirty years of unvarying proof to the con- trary, kept insisting that the Italian Common People could not only rid them- selves of their native despots, but also could confidently face a coalition of hos- tile Europe. This is the sphere where Emotion rules—the sphere where poetry and re- ligious consecrations and the dazzling examples of uncalculating and appar- ently fruitless self-sacrifice originate In this sphere Jessie White dwelt. Hav- ing heard the voice of her heart, she would not listen to her head. You must understand this, in order to value right- ly her books. III. Shortly after her release from prison she married Alberto Mario, a man of keen, though rigid, ideas, and of inflex- ible integrity. He was Mazzini’s best penman in Italy. The young couple came to the United States in 1859 to arouse sympathy in the Italian cause, but their tour was cut short by news of the war with Austria. Signora Mario used to relate with great satisfaction how, during her lecture in Washington, when she found a prominent Southern Senator sitting in the front row, she launched into a denunciation of slave- holders. She seems on this trip to have met Garrison, for whom she felt great reverence; and when, in 1865, Garrison’s second son became one of the founders of the Nation, she began a special cor- respondence for this journal which last- ed forty years. Her letters to the Na tion, to the London News, to the New- castle Chronicle, and to other papers HGHd5 contain much material that the histor- ian will prize. The Marios reached home too late to take part in the campaign of 1859, but during the exciting patriotic crisis of that winter and the next spring, and during Garibaldi'’s Sicilian Expedition, they were deep in the council of the Party of Action. Signora Mario served as army nurse, At the battle of the Volturno she went fourteen times under fire to bring back the wounded, and she spent thirty-six consecutive hours in the field- hospital. Ten years later, when Gari- baldi offered his services to Republican France, she accompanied him and cared for the wounded. Thenceforth, until her husband's death, she in the stormy politics that than once the peace the monarchs Mario himself refused to acknowledge the King; she was a Radical. The disen- chantment that followed unification—the inevitable disenchantment that comes when the decades of prose succeed the years of poetry—she attributed to the failure to establish a Emo- t'onal to the end, she put her faith in Mazzini's formulas. But her chief a tivity was in exposing abuses. She wrote with anguish of the frightful condl- tion of the Sicilian sulphur-miners; she laid bare the horrors of organized in- fanticide in the charitable asylums of Naples; she described the misery of the indigent peasants; she scathed sleek bu- reaucrats and political grafters. Wherev- there was a wrong, she attacked it fearlessly; wherever there was suffer- ing, she strove to relieve it. Like every one who realizes how much of the enor- mous total of sin and cruelty might be prevented, she out the law's delay, against the agents of gov- ernment who seem leagued with the wicked, against technicalities and quib- bles which protect the evil-doer, against the inertia of tradition, against customs which give the unscrupulous a vested right to exploit the weak. Here, ways, she listened to her heart When her great companions vanished, she dedicated herself to speiking them fair in death. She wrote a life of Mazzini, which, despite its obvious drawbacks, wi'l remain for posterity to consult, because it shows him as one of his intimates saw him. Garibaldi, too, she portrayed, perhaps even more satis- factorily. She edited Mario’s writings, and Cattaneo’s; she eulogized Nicotera, for whom, of all the younger genera- tion of conspirators, she had the high- est admiration; finally, she surpassed herself in her biography of Bertani, whom history will come at last to rec- ognize as the wisest of the advisers of the Party of Action in the critical vears from 1857 to 1861. What greater tri- bute could one pay to Jessie Mario's character than to state that she, an alien, was the chosen confidante and biographer of so many of Italy's patri- took threatened part more of republic er cried against as al-
Page 14
66 otic sons? As a young woman in Flor- the friendship of Mrs. Browning. In her later years, no one was more devoted to her, no one appre- ciated more justly her services to Italy, than Carducci. What was the secret of her hold over these Italians? Was !t her loyalty? her outspokenness? her vigor of mind and deed? her amazing cour- age? Was it the something different that she as an Englishwoman had from what any Italian woman could have? No could be more independent than she; no one, probably, ever told Maz- zini and Garibaldi more frankly than she did when she disagreed from them. Her awe of the Prophet did not blind her to his personal side. Her worship of the Hero did not prevent her from making fun of his amorousness and oth- No, her power of attraction was as potent with Anglo-Saxons as with Italians; it was the power that springs not from racial traits, but from primary human qualities. You could not spend an hour with her without being conquered by her single-mindedness, her devotion to friends and principles, her scorn for all things base, her abso- lute fearlessness. In a society that was sophisticated, artificial, and insincere, she remained herself, as refreshing as a sudden rush ef mountain air through the fetid streets of a city. ence she won one er foibles. IV. During the last ten years of her life, she earned a bare subsistence as teach- er in the Normal School at Florence. Pegasus in harness seems not more con- tradictory than Jessie White, the con- fidante of conspirators and the comrade in war of Garibaldi, impounded in a school-room. But she accepted the task bravely. Her noble self-reliance refused help, though offered most delicately, from her friends, and she had a haughty dis- of accepting anything from the Government. Her scorn for the old Re- publicans who not only became recon- ciled to the monarchy, but served under it, got honors and made fortunes, was terrific I have heard her speak con- temptuously of Crispi’s care not to come within range of bullets in Sicily; but when she referred to his defection from Republicanism, her words bad vitriol in dain them. It was not envy of the prosper- ity of the renegades that aroused her; it was the abhorrent realization that spirits that had once obeyed the call of the highest could find In worldly hon- ora, wealth, or comfort, anything to lure them into the mire She died in Florence on March 5, 1906 and friends, besides the official dig nitaries whom in life she had shunned, pa'd tribute at her funeral. Some day, Italy may remember to honor her with a monument. But her memory is se cure, because her life is tnextricably interwoven with the friendship of Gart- baldi and Mazzini, two of the imperish- The Nation. ables, and with their nearest disciples. To make her acquaintance through her books is to feel the very pulse of the cause to which she consecrated herself. Through her veins throbbed the great Emotion which was the lifeblood of the Italian Risorgimento. WiLtt1aM Roscoe THAYER. CONTEMPORARY LITERATURE OF SPAIN. Maprip, November 25. An event in the industrial world, the Exposition at Valencia, has had a cer- tain connection with Spanish writers. In Valencia, a Congress of Poetry is about to assemble, and there, too, the old poet, Teodoro Llorente, is to be crowned. This patriarch is a félibre, who has written in both Castillian and Provencal. To him, also, do we owe the best translations of foreign poets yet made in Spain. The honors paid to Llorente have provoked no opposition, but the Congress of Poetry, as a whole, has aroused much debate. The nature of poetry is not of a sort to go well with public assemblies, nor is the title of poet to be won by skill in them. Not even the writing of few or many pages of verse constitutes an author a real poet. To be that, he must have suc- ceeded by his art in interesting and moving and in producing a deep spirit- ual impression. Hence there has been ne lack of satirical references to this Congress of Poetry. It would have been wiser to make it coextensive with all literature, in which, indeed, lyric poetry might have had the post of honor. Controversy has also arisen over the philological works published by Father Julio Cejador. This industrious schol- ar has his passionate admirers, but de-| tractors no less impassioned who at- tack him with the roughness charac- teristic of Spanish wars of the pen. Even in intellectual affairs, the Spaniard is bellicose. For myself, so far as my slight attainments in philology go, I think it would be unfair to ignore the value of the unflagging labor of Father Julio, who is still a young man. He has al- ready seen through the press six vol- umes on the structure and growth of language, besides his two solid vol- umes on the “Language of Cervantes,” a highly esteemed Greek Gram- mar. Cejador is of the family of the indomitable workers of the Renais- sance, ingatiate, as they used to say, 'n burning up their eyelashes and wear- ing out their elbows. Nevertheless, as our well-known critic, G6mez de Ba- guero says, in the technical positions of Cejador one feels an instinctive want of confidence. He inclines to the view of Astarioa, another Spanish priest, ac- cording to whom Basque is the first lan- guage ever spoken on earth, and the key to the understanding of all the rest. and [ Vol. 89, No. 231 Some savants hold that Basque is al- lied to the native tongues of Mexico. Not long ago, I heard the eminent Mexican- ist. Paso y Troncoso, expound this view. There is no manner of doubt that at the present moment the literature of science has got a great impetus among us, while that of pure imagination is suffering from uncertainty and fatigue. This crisis was slow in coming, but was inevitable in view of the movement which, since 1898, has been driving Spain to make up for lost time, and in view also of the utilitarian impulse which has impressed all minds in the presence of economic and social de- mands. These are felt in Spain with peculiar force, as are also the agita- tions growing out of the anarchist ten- dency, marked by all the vehemence of our race. Translation of foreign works has helped on the study of sociology and an- thropology in Spain. Lombroso had some brilliant disciples among us, Salil- las, for example, who applied the doc- trines of the Italian to the analysis of our ancient picaresque novels. History has always had diligent cultivators in Spain, and continues to enrich itself. Among recent publications I will men- tion Altamira’s “History of Spain and Spanish Civilization,” the “History of the Cathedral of Santiago,” by Lé6épez Ferreiro, the “Discurso Histérico” of the Marquis of Cessalbo, and the erudite works of Menéndez Pidal. The most re- cent of the latter is on the jester of Charles V. In the history of art, too, there are many active and serious work- ers. Besides the infinite number of monographs in the Boletin de la Socie- dad de Excursionistas, important pub- lications are the “History of Christian Architecture in the Middle Ages,” by Lampérez, the “School of Madrid,” by the younger Beruete, and “Velasquez,” by Beruete the elder, besides “Painting in Madrid,” by Sentenach. Under the head of the history of literature are to be cited the “Origins of the Novel,” by Menéndez y Pelayo, Padre Mir’s study, “Autobiographies and Memoirs,” and the “Legend of Don Juan,” by Said Arnesto. The Ateneo has given a prize to “The Spanish Novel,” by Gonzélez Blanco. Nor should one forget, in philosophy, Bonilla’s “The Myth of Psiquis” and the learned work of Father Arintero on the “Evolution of Mysticism.” The novel, alternating between the old naturalism and the neo-romantic spir- itualism, has been losing vogue. Our most famous novelist, Pérez Galdés, af ter having sought a greater glory ip writing for the stage, has left off pub- lishing and has gone ardently into poli- tics. His name is one of the four or five which are mentioned in the hypo- thetical case that a Spanish republic should ever want a President. On the other hand, Blasco Ibéfiez appeara to have given up his réle as political agi-
Page 15
Dec. 9, +909] tator, and is travelling in search of new subjects and impressions for his books. The Jesuit Father Coloma, abandoning the ground whose conquest won him fame with his novel, “Pequefi«ces,”’ which pictured aristocratic society, is devoting himself to-day to historical nov- els. One of them, entitled “Jeromin,” has to do with the life of Don Juan of Austria, and is agreeable reading. The protagonist of the novel on which Co- loma is now working will be Cardinal Cisneros, confessor of Isabel the Cath- olic, and Regent of Spain. The novelist who most closely reflects the present day is Pio Baroja. One of his latest books introduces the crime of bomb- throwing on the day of King Alfonso’s marriage. Baroja’s style is the absence of style. At the opposite pole is Valle Inclan, the painter of rural life in Ga- licia, a region which I too have describ- ed. He is an exquisite stylist. I ought to name another novelist, Felipe T . very popular with young readers. Yet I must. add that Spanish youth does not to-day demand innocent stories, and Trigo’s are somewhat erotic. In lyric poetry a noteworthy move- ment should be recorded. The great Spanish poets are either dead or aged. In their place the public is bestowing its favor upon poets who-.came to us from South America, either as diplo- mats or travellers. At their head stands Rubén Darfo. But there is an entire pleiad—Amado Nervo, Santos Chocano, Balbino Davilos. They have brought the note of modernism into Castillian poetry. We are not without young Span- ish poets, but many of them adhere to the school of “the divine Ruben,” as they call him. In the Madrid Ateneo there are continually readings by Mexican, Co- lombian, and Argentine poets. Also are they heard in the salons, where they reap a great harvest of—applause. From dramatic literature, Echagaray, honored with the Nobel prize, has now definitely retired. He had filled our stage, like another Lope de Vega, for more than a quarter of a century; yet to-day his plays are not presented. To explain this anomaly—an author apo- theosized but not produced—it would be necessary to write a critical article. At present, the leadership is held by Ja- cinto Benavente. A talented and fertile writer, he seldom attacks social prob- lems. When one has mentioned the Quinteros, humorous and inexhaustible dramatists, and a couple of names more, one has really covered our actual dra- matic production. Yet last year there were presented in Spain more than a thousand theatrical pieces—flowers of a single day. The public—always the same—demands novelty. That being s0, it cannot expect to have masterpieces. Countess Parvo Bazan. : The Nation. Correspondence. THE LAW'S DELAY. To THB EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The instance referred to in your article on “The Reform of Judicial Pro- cedure” (the Nation, September 2), where an Indiana judge deferred ruling on a murrer for two years or more, though statute required disposition within months, could hardly have occurred in Philippines. Under Act 1552, passed by Philippine Commission October de- the six the the 1906 : Justices of the peace and judges of the Courts of First Instance, of the Court of Land Registration, and of municipal courts shall certify on their application for leave . . . and upon salary vouchers presented by them for payment, and upon all pay rolls upon which their salaries are paid, that all special proceedings, applica- tions, petitions, demurrers, motions, and all civil and criminal cases which have been under submission for decision or deter- mination for a period of ninety days or more have been determined and decided on or before the date of making the certificate, and no leave shall be granted and no salary paid without such certificate. The difference between this and the In- diana will probably be found in the penalty attached to the former. So far as appears from Sour article the Indiana statute merely a directory provision and imposed no penalty for its non-observ- ance or, at least, none which so vitally af- fected the official in question. The effect of the Philippine statute in forcing an ex- pedition of judicial business may be seen by observing the difference in this regard be- tween the courts affected by the act and one to which it is inapplicable, and in which it is still not uncommon for cases to remain undecided for considerably more than ninety days after submission. The statute in question is one of the many improvements which Americans in the Phil- ippines have made over corresponding con- ditions at home, and when such improve- ments are known and adopted even our anti-Imperialist friends will that good has resulted from our Philippine be Statute was there concede policy. CHARLES 8S. LOBINGIER Audiencia, Manila, October 10 To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION Repeated efforts have been made to results of of articles SIR: inform the public of the grave “the law's delay.” A number have appeared in current periodicals, and in his recent speech in Chicago President Taft spoke in no uncertain terms on the subject. I wish to speak of an ill effect of “the law's delay” to which attention has not been call- ed, which is not less serious than any hitherto discussed and, probably, more wide- spread. I refer to the disastrous effect upon the health of the litigant. It has been stated that one-half of human ailments are of mental origin. The most harmful influences of this order the depressing and painful emotions, of which I need now only mention fear, worry, anxiety, and mental strain. It is through such influ- ences that litigation so frequently impairs or destroys the health of the litigant. The importance of the matter at issue, anxiety as to the outcome, dread of the court, per- haps a sense of injustice—any or all of these may be a strain upon the nervous system sufficient to destroy its health. Such conditions are incident to all litiga- one are e G7 tion, and so any lawsuit may be fraught with danger to health. But the delayed lit- igation with its trials and retrials, its hopes and fears and bitter disappointments, and the protracted strain upon the nervous sys- Thess especially calamitous m is nh sequences are particularly disastrous § in lamage cases, many of which turn juries with, apparently, passing symptoms due to shock of the nervous system Now, anxiety over the outcome, dread of the court, and the like, produce their most lepressing effects in just these nervous ases, because they are acting upon al eady weakened nerves When nervous Symptons are present, symptoms due chiefly to shock, the most important part of the ical treatment consists in rightly n fuencing and directing the patient's mind The effort should be by eans of enter tainment, occunation, diversion, and the like troubles rful to get his thoughts away from his ind symptoms, and to make him é and hopeful. But litigation has just th posite tendency. The examinations of phy siclans, consultations with lawyer solici tcus ‘nquiries, and advi of frien! nd to fix the patient's mind more and more upon himself, and thereby to exaggerat: his symptoms and increase his suffering There comes into play, also, that subtle influence suggestion, which is likely to give se to new symptoms, and intensify those already present, If a better and a quicker way for cn tlement of damage cases than the ordinary court procedures were devised it would be a Meanwhile blessing to tiars these should help to fasten the attention of the public on “the law's delay.” PHILIP ZENNER. University of Cincinnati, December 2 THE FERRER AFFAIR TO THE EpITrorR or THE NATION Sin: Is it in the Nation or in the Civilta Cattolica that I have just read with amazement an article entitled “The Ferrer Affair’ (Nation, November 11)? The irticle in question is dated Paris, October 18, just the day before the Figaro publ shed the dossicr of the Ferrer trial, communi cated by the Spanish embassy Now as everybody who has eyes can ser that dossier contained no proof whatever of Ferrer’s action in the riots at Barcelona, but only wretched hypotheses founded on his previoug life and his acquaintances Moreover, the address of Ferrer's lawyer has not been published, so that the litth even which is stated in the act of im peachment and the réquisitoire may rest on falsehood I have seen several of the leading Spanish Liberals, who are by no means anarchists; they have told me that Ferrer’s sole crime was the Escuela Moderna, that he was absolutely incapa- ble of any violence, incapable of leading wr stimulating a riotous mob. Quite re- cently my colleague in the French Insti- tute, Louls Havet, published a letter writ ten by Ferrer to Cyvoct (himself unjustly ondemned, some years ago, anarchist), in which violence of any kind s positively and emphatically deprecated Your correspondent's article is nothing but the rehearsal of the perfidious sayings which filled the organs of the Vatican— especially the Osservatore Romano—ebout the 13th of October last. Now, there are as an
Page 16
two proofs that Ferrer was no criminal in the ordinary sense of the word. The fir is that if his hand had been detected in the burning of convents and ill-treat- ment of nuns, the Maura ministry would have made it known wurbi et orbi. The second proof is the positive statement from Rome, by the Stampa, as well as by the Rerliner Tageblatt, after Ferrer’s execu- on. that the Pope had wished to inter- fere to save his life—a thing that would be quite unthinkable if Ferrer was be- eved to have actually committed or in tigated bloodshed These reports have not been denied by the Vatican Your correspondent wishes Americans to believe that many innocent nuns were killed in the streets; he, indeed, speaks of 138 dead, and adds “The nuns were the chief victims All the Spaniards I have seen deny any statement of that kind, The burn ne of convents was not accompanied by iolence against individuals, unless with 401 exceptions due to the inevitable hoo- but all Spaniards know that the con- and else- ligan ents in Barcelona, as in Bilbao vhere, simply reduce workmen and work to starvation, because the nuns work rtual for nothing, and use their influ- » monopolize the best customers, That tate of things should, in due time ted public wrath, is only too easy lerstand \ r corr pondent goes on to speak of international conspiration, of a chef lorchestre, and the like We know that tuff ever since 1898; it is the equivalent of the or famous, though always non-exist ing Dreyfus syndicate.” The Osaservratore Nomano was, I think, the first to start the theory of a “Ferrer syndicate,” and that stupid invention has found a hearing among th o-called better class of the unem ployed. But I may regret to have found an echo of it in your columns; nay, more, if ou will allow me some frankness, to have read in the Nation, a few days only after our great H. Ch. Lea's death, the Jesuitical of an inquisitorial trial and crime SOLOMON REINACH. apology [Despite the violence of M. Reinach’'s assertions, think the letter of our correspondent presented an aspect of the which, amid the general deserved considera. we Ferrer case clamor of passion, tion In this country Sp. Nation.] THE DISCIPLINE OF NATURALISM To THe Eprrorn or Ture NATION: Sin: Among the critical voices raised against the dominance of romanticism I miss one to assign ite due welght to a re- action that has already taken place. To separate the essentiala from the accidents of naturalism is, perhaps, dificult Once effected, however, the separation enables us to see that modern literature has a! ready undergone a d'acipline whose aims have been the very sobriety, structural co herence, and essential sanity of method, if not always of result, that romanticiem lacks A return to pure classicism is unthink- able An ideal so faintly related to the rough welter of the world can scarcely be nor are the taste for the specific, endured The Nation. the impatience of the merely typical, like- ly to pass out. We shall demand, increas- ingly, I think, the illusion of reality, though of a nobler aspect of reality than the early naturalists cared to give. Fidelity of observation, however, simplicity and stringency of technique, impersonal work- manship—these naturalistic virtues, when practised in the service of a larger phil- osophy, are more likely to lead to a new humanism than any theoretical appeal to the practice of the Augustan ages. To cbserve, for a moment, the extraor- dinarily sensitive temperament of Gerhart Hauptmann is to see the development of modern literature in epitome. He begins with an amorphous romanticism (‘‘Prome- thidenlos’’), turns ruthless naturalist (“Vor Sonnenaufgang,”” “Das Friedens- fest’’), and acquires the classically severe technique of the best naturalism. Next he succumbs to the allurements of symbolism, “Die Glocke” and “Hannele.” But always, at intervals, he harks back to the fundamental austerities of naturalistic art (‘‘Fuhrmann Henschel,” Rose Berndt’). At last he applies the virtues learned in that harsh school to a legendary historica] subject nobly envis- aged and produces in such a play as “Der arme Heinrich,’ a poetic drama that is the and writes versunkene forerunner, at least, of f new kind. He achieves there the restraint, the imper- sonality, the sanity of classic art. He achieves an idealism, too; but an idealism wrung from reality, not spun from a pat- tern of conventional nobleness. It is at this point that classicism and humanism, trained by the naturalists, diverge. Ra- cine, upon a visionary preconception, pre- sents a pantomime, plastically beautiful. That noble. But Hauptmann spares us nothing of that dread mediwval agony, yet here a high beauty and an aus- 18 shows us tere joy. That is more noble. The tech- nique of the two (allowing for difference of time and place and circumstance) is impersonal, coherent, guided by exquisite economy—in a word, unro- mantic. LUDWIG LEWISOHN. New York, December 3 identical: an A SEA-CHANGE IN SPELLING. To THE EpiITorR or THE NATION: Sik: One natural result of the agitation in favor of so-called “simplified spelling” would be a tendency the part of the careless, inaccurate, and anarchical to be more lawless, inaccurate, indifferent still as to spelling in general. Such a ten- dency would be shown in many places, one of them obviously being the classroom. | submit to teachers of English whether the spelling of students has not deteriorated since Mr. Roosevelt and others began open- ly to inculcate the belief that tradition and good taste in this matter are of less im- portance than an imaginary practical con- venience. When, however, the professors in our technical schools are willing to print such caricatures of English as the follow- ing, it Is time for all persons of good sense bethink themselves. These sentences chosen at random from an address delivered before a gathering of appren- in Pittsburgh: on and to are tices Liv for the realization of hy ideals. He shoud hav abstaind from reviling the faricees. A man brings out... pearls in her soul that she herself never dremt of. So are man’s curage and generosity dubid and tripld thru a woman's presence. Liv constantly in the atmosfere of beauty. The laws of good taste 'n regard to or- thography have perhaps never been better enunciated than by the first great English lexicographer. I venture to quote a pas- sage of some length from Dr. Johnson's “Preface to the Dictionary” (Osgood, “Se- lections from Johnson,” pp. 33, 34): In this part of the work [orthography], where caprice has long wantoned Without control, and vanity sought praise by petty reformation, I have endeavored to proceed with a scholar’s reverence for antiquity, and a grammarian’s regard to the genius of our tongue. I have attempted few altera- tions, and among those few, perhaps the greater part is from the modern to the an- ‘ient practice; and I hope I may be allowed to recommend to those, whose thoughts have been perhaps employed too anxiously on verbal singularities, not to disturb, upon narrow views, or for minute propriety, the orthography of their fathers. It has been asserted, that for the law to be known, is of more importance than to be right: “Change,” says Hooker, “is not made with- out inconvenience, even from worse to bet- ter.” There is in constancy and stability a general and lasting advantage, which will always overbalance the slow improvements of gradual correction. LANE COOPER, Ithica, N. Y., December 5 THE BODLEIAN. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The Bodleian regulations as forth in their Staff-Kalendar and discussed by your correspondent, “Lector,” of Novem- ber 25, are indeed a marvel of minutize. Their detail, however, is not due solely to the present librarian or his immediate pre- decessors, as “Lector’” seems to intimate. If he will consult “The First Draft of the Statutes of the Public Library at Oxon,” as drawn up by Sir Thomas Bodley bimself, he will find there a quantity of details which time and expediency have legitimate- ly expanded into the present rules. True, the regulations laid down in the Staff- Kalendar do not entirely cover the same needs as Sir Thomas's Statutes, but the principle of foresight and minuteness of detailed decision are the same. Sir Thomas gives an oath for the electors of the li- brarian, and as well one which the librarian or “keeper” must swear himself to keep “by God’s infinite mercy.” He specifies the hours of opening, the assigning “to every faculty their catalogues and tables,” even requiring an alphabetical arrangement of the authors in the “Tables.” The appointed visitors, or inspectors of the library, are assigned perquisites of a “refection” and gloves of a given cost, etc., etc. May I trespass further on your space to quote the following passage which well illustrates Sir Thomas's insistence on de- tail, and in its subject matter is somewhat apposite to militant discussions now taking place without as well as within libraries: It is deemed expedient, that some one be deputed to the custody of it [the Bodleian Library], that is noted and known for a diligent Student, and in all his Conversation to be Trusty, Active, and Discreet; a Graduat also, and a Linguist, not encumbred with Marriage, nor with a Benefice of Cure. For it cannot stand with Piety, that such a charge should admit the continual Society of other publick Imployments; and Marriage is too full of Domestical Impeachmertts, to afford him so much time from his private set
Page 17
Dec. 9, 1909] Affairs, as almost every Day's necessity of his private Presence will require. The italics are mine; the passage may be found on page 66 of “Bodley’s Life and Statutes,”’ edited in 1906 by Miss Ruth S. Grannis, and published in the series, Litera- ture of Libraries, edited by J. C. Dana and H. W. Kent. HARMON VIRGIN. New EDWARD General Theological Seminary Library, York, November 29 KARL HAUPTMANN, To THE EpITroR oF THE NATION: Sir: Permit me to correct the impres- sion conveyed by a statement in the last number of the Nation to the effect that “Karl Hauptmann has in the meantime made his appearance as a dramatist.” Karl Hauptmann has been known to students of German as an able and virile dramatist for nearly fifteen years. In many respects he is rather a better dramatist than his weak and brother, Gerhart. His characters are always drawn with a firm hand and developed with a sure psychologi- cal insight His plots are almost carefully constructed and _ convincingly sentimental always evolved. Of course, like Sudermann and al- most all the other playwrights of modern Germany, he shows the unmistakable influ- ence of Ibsen and Tolstoy His best-known dramas are “Marianne “Waldleute” and “Ephraims Breite.” The iast named has been the most successful ard populat uvor the German stag It shows rather a strik- to Yelstoy’s “Power of like and somewhat sensetional study ing resemblance Darknes is a grapnik in moral depravity. EDWARD STOCKTON MEYER. , and its prohaLle prototype December 1 Western Reserve University, GREEN EYES To THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Sir: In connection with the subject of green eyes, which has been brought up several times recently in the Nation, I should like to call attention to a passage in my play of “Pyramus and Thisby,”’ per- formed before Duke Theseus on his wed- ding day at night: His eyes were green as leeks See “A Midsummer-Night’s Dream,” V, i PETER QUINCE Athens, November 22 Literature. HOLIDAY BOOKS 1. “A church is a piece of history,” Stevenson writes, and, somewhere else, adds that ca- thedrals are his “favorite kind of mountain scenery.” Both sayings are recalled by Mrs. Joseph Pennell in her book of the “French Cathedrals,” with its sub-title “Monasteries and Abbeys and Sacred Sites of France” (The Century Co.). For fifteen years Mr. and Mrs. Pennell have contributed occasional illustrated articles to one of the magazines on the cathedrals and cathedral- towns of a land that they have come to know and to love better and better in studying The route of their architectural pil- NOTES ON it. The Nation. grimage was first Mrs. Van Rensselaer, author of the study of English cathedrals; and it took them, long ago as the late eighties,” to the cities of Prov- outlined by “as ence. Since then, they have described and drawn in black and white churches in al- most every French province, if one except Brittany, Touraine, and French Flanders Since it was begun, provincial France has become much more travelled; thanks, in part, to the charm of the one’s drawings of the other's very gracious and efficiently documented narratives of travel. The writer only half congratulates herself on the achievement Now that more folk enjoy France there is, correspondingly, less to enjoy. The motorist, she writes, has de stroyed forever the romance of travel He more exacting than his humblk “Already, before the is, alas! pathfinder, the cyclist motor was heard of, money had reduced the large towns of the Continent to on level of dull uniformity; soon money, with the motor, will have worked the same dis aster in all the smaller towns and all the little inns.” The Ritz and the Plaza ars your motorist’s ideal—if he has ideals worth mentioning at all; and inns, as well as cathedrals, contribute to the charm of Con tinental journeyings But a plutocracy can not spoil these same cathedrals. Their only is zealous restoration Mrs. Pennell of whole-souled grave danger too which protests with fervor the from igainst all the And yet away conviction total impression one carries the of got-up book is not of protest against abuses but bl just reading her handsomely for beautiful and venera The the enthusiasm and which Mrs subject; of style is monuments. of writings plac es that readers Nation ad mire Pennell’s whatever the the many examples of the excellent work which in ir illustrations include we look for in drawings signed Joseph Pennell And most of these drawings hav been acquired by the French government for the Luxembourg Museum Among the two or three handsomest travel books of the season must be placed Henry James’s “Italian Hours,’ illustrated by Joseph Pennell (Houghton Mifflin Co.). The chapters on the various cities were for the most part written at earlier dates (those on Venice, for instance, go back to 1872, 1882. 1892, and 1899), but they are now first brought together so as to give a picture of Italy as a whole. The character of the pages need not here be criticised. They have Mr James’s customary “note of the haunted over-charged consciousness,”” to use one of his own phrases; but they are free from the involved ambiguity of hesitation that makes of his later writings, such as his recent im- pressions of America, a task rather than a pleasure. As always, one of the attractions of this impressionistic manner is its arbi- Thus as read Mr. James's reaction Ravenna, looking deadly provincial of the street,”” we recall the very say, Oscar Wilde or we in trariness. emotional “down the empty, sunny different tone of, vista But thou, Ravenna, better loved than all, Thy ruined palaces are but a That hides thy fallen greatness pall For the same city Mr. Pennell gives one of his simplest, but to us most charming, pic- a quick sketch of the famous Pineta The drawings are in crayon, and for the most part a dark reddish-brown back- ground, which gives a little too strongly the effect of New York's brownstone epoch. They tures on n6Y) are true illustrations, however, of the ro mantic text book by turn from a Hours sacchat it is interesting to Mr of « mos “Ttalian and way the other James's from ne inanities the the mtrast of of av ellers, to bra his contemporary tr “Legends of the Alham Washington Irving in lignified e B conceived by fine of thusiasm. 7 book with spirit n is issued through J Lippincott Co by H. W. Mabie Hood In his reminiscent Maxfiela introduction and by George Hood we an pictures work Mr Parrish; is of shall not, however sugeg invidious because Messrs comparisons, partly Lippincott have not here altoget led Yet and « le certain crudity « a in reprodu the illustrations are, in And palaces cl ven admirabk and and ily enrich each white orations gardens, for the most par printed page felicity pen s d his t Pr cruises ed motoring h gene mention Ernest Peixotto'’s the ake esteemed wit and that ching writing 80 rally we me only the ewest example the French Motor-boat seldom of Through er) on chateaux near ps lise Visit 1inebleau, tr mours, Chartres, halt ts marvellous enamels and at Limoges, with an app various wanderings devoted chiefly this in brief the basis of a very charming book pen br discreet elimination n Provence and Gascony to unhackneved cite drawings are v ant very ereby in pictures ithfulness to tl radit false book illustrator thi ine on juenes ind « itial tr e ffs ona modesty of own China described on page Mortimer Menpes Sir Henry Arthur Blake Books before which is ope nly ove if thie y as by “ have the to ¢ been this in intended put out letter press only arry the pictures, yet always described as by Some body In the ably reach length fifty The sixteen plates in color and four times with illustrations by Somebody Els« present volume the thousand the text would prob of forty illustrations respectable yt words are as many marginal pen studies in black and white. Mr their Menpes’s Chinese water views in predominant blues and of human atmos The pictures the text The volume square demy and comes from the Macmillan “Holland” is fat and outwardly gor volume, written and illustrated by George Wharton Edwards and published by Moffat, Yard & Co. The text substratum of Baedeker with a fairly plen ful covering of sympathetic personal ob- servation. The fifty-six number, and of these several in color, are something of a vindication for the physical attractiveness of the Dutch people Ap it is not all a nation of very clumsy bipeds struggling against a handicap of breeches and kirtles. Mr. Edwards's fish- ermen and milkmaids seem quite capable of locomotion and of otherwise looking themselves. We gather that Dutch has been exaggerated—as is bound erises are startlingly effects Where appears the phere is brought close to us suggestive the Oriental Venetian figure only connected with are loosely is in Company a geous consists of a illustrations, in parently rapid after thrift American not the traveller to discover
Page 18
= Py oO There is an amusing anecdote about ) ler Arthur Guthrie, the writer of “Letters ym France and Italy’ (A. C. MeClurg traveller, * Co), is emphatically a good ng sparing of comment on the standard ghts and whimsically sensitive to the sual encounters of the road. The letters bound in a ripe Scotch “‘pawkiness”’ not nixed with sentiment. The book is pretti- printed and provided with line drawings George Houston, which befit the letter nuch better than the customary half- The manner is old-fashioned, and, haps, the more agreeable for that. The acerbities of the painter Gauguin seem un- lonable to the gentle traveller To- is more tolerant observation, irds the newer music he borrow a characteristic h is not without symbolic import. Mr. Guthrie saw in a confectioner’s shop at the following dual notice Ou English visitors are cordially in- ed to enter and taste our wholesome weetmeats On another card Our American friends are asked to walk zht in and sample our elegant candy. For a friend afflicted with Wanderlust is unpretentious little book would make appropriate offering Francis Miltoun’s travel book this yea oncerned with the “Castles and Chateaux f Old Burgundy,”’ and contains the usual umber of excellent illustrations from paintings and sketches made by Blanche Mec Manus As always in this series there a judicious mixture of history, anecdote, irt, and personal impressions The vol- ime will serve well as a guide book or a fireside peau de chagrin to carry the magination into the land of romance. (L (. Page & Co.) Hrentano is the American publisher of folio volume called “London,” being a se- +s of beautiful photographs of London scenes, chiefly, perhaps, of architectural onuments, by Alvin Langdon Coburn, with in introduction by Hillaire Belloc The white paper on which M. Belloc’s essay is orinted is of the finest, and the art-mat (if that te the proper term) upon which the impressionistic” photographs are mounted of unexceptionable the most Il himself ercellence ot fairy and his work this wk marked Rackham has established the illustrator pea ful books adaptation ind fan ir, for an by Courtney Undine,” is with his of f Fouqué’s ml charm vivid imagination, with of some in of much messy one grotesque than he The reinforcement the pure permits himeelf pietures, with lend than book Is of the m line drawing fiat t to nost colors themselves printing the usual The he most attractive Page & Co.) years ago Aubrey Beardsley fin ambitious work, the illus ‘Morte d’Arthur.” Since artist's fame has be his original edi sought by col- then, that of this Opin plates altogether season. (Dou lay Sixteen hed ation of Malory's the international, and have been eagerly lectors. One can hardly doubt, the Duttons’ volume reissue famous Malory find a welcome differ widely the value of illustration. The pres- his most hen precocious ome tions one will as to ons will hie work as sheer [ Vol. 89, No. 2319 The Nation. ent reviewer finds Beardsley’s decadence in rather flagrant dissonance with the riper mysticism of the knightly author. As to the value of the drawings there is In spite of an occasional per- functoriness—the work was long and the illustrator mortally stricken—among_ the decorated books of our time this is one of the original and fascinating decorative no question most \ sumptuous volume is the Rubdiyat, il- lustrated, decorated, and printed (the art- are told, has drawn with his own hand every word of the text) for Thomas Y. Crowell & Ca. by Willy Pogany. The vol- is intentionally, orientally over-elab- orate with color and design after the Per- sian manner, and with typography as near to the scroll-like Arabic as English letter- ing may be ist, we ume brought, so near, in fact, that in One or two places it is hard to make suit the word. The temptation to read trom right to left is always present. Th olume is in quarto, with one verse to the page, and twenty-four charming pictures in color, steeped in their proper atmosphere. A very handsome book, indeed. Paul Elder & Company's edition of Omar the final FitzGerald text with a lit- eral version of the quatrains upon which FitzGerald’s work was by Arthur Guiterman The page is wide-margined and rough-edged, with type of a fine black- letter effect. Gilbert James has eight pic- tures in black and white. has based, James has done the illustrations for still another Omar, this one from tho Macmillan Co. Typography here plays a aecidedly minor part, but the sixteen pic- tures in color are unusually pleasing, an‘ the volume, a solid and square quarto, has «a charming front cover in gold, blue, and green scrollwork. By the lightness in weight of the de- ceptively large new edition of “Selected Tales of Mystery,” by Edgar Allan Poe, is- sued by J. B. Lippincott Company, one knows at once that here is a book printed in England, with the clearness of type and amplitude of margin which we associate with the better sort of English bookmak- ing The colored illustrations by Byam Shaw lend distinction to the volume, which is throughout handsome in makeup. Poe is not an author to illustrate; it is a pity the morbid imagination of Aubrey Beardsley was never directed that way. Mr. Shaw's work in the book before us is ex- cellent; but it certainly not attain equality with the text, and, to our thinking, it does not chime in with it pleasantly in the minor key Another edition of Poe's tales is published at this season by G. P Putnam's Sons. Here the price is decided- ly less and the bookmaking quite incon- splcuous; the volume of “Tales” is uniform Gilbert easy does with that of the “Poems” issued a year ago, with an introduction by Professor Richardson. The Putnam edition is illus- trated in black and white by F. W. Coburn. In order to make a book out of a poem, and a short poem at that, Houghton Mifflin printed James Russell Lowell's “The Courtin’'” three times over in the Jit- tle volume in which it now appears, charm- ingly ilustrated by Arthur I. Keller. First, ic Is printed seven stanzas to the page, then two lines to the page (in the interests of illustration), and, finally, a facsimile of the original manuscript is given. The Yankee idyll has always deserved its popularity; Co. have and this new edition of it, with only the p-ctures to distract one’s attention from its humor and pleasant sentiment, makes one of the prettiest Christmas books of this year’s offering. III. From Funk & Wagnalls Co. we receive ten cloth-bound volumes, entitled “The Best of the World's Classics,” the selection being that of Henry Cabot Lodge and Francis W. Halsey. From the introduction contributed by the former, we learn that the word “classics” is used, “not in the narrow and technical sense, but rather in that of Tho- reau, who defined classics as ‘the noblest recorded thoughts of mankind.’” We has- ten to add that, to judge by the present se- lection, these thoughts are habitually ex- pressed in prose alone. We do not, how- ever, complain; for, in the publishers’ words, here are “over 500 of the best prose writings by more than 200 of the world’s best authors.” These selections are ar- ranged chronologically, by countries, be- ginning with Greece and ending with Amer- ica (two volumes). Let us add—for there are those who insist on taking their belles- lettres and history in microscopic doses— that the paper used is opaque and that the printing is admirably clear. “Days with the Poets” is the title given to a series of booklets published by Hodder & Stoughton, of which six volumes lie be- fore us. The series gives some one un- named the opportunity to write some rather commonplace yages of text, connecting po- ems and fragments of poems by the author who, in any particular volume, is under con- sideration. The pictures are no doubt the chief attraction here. With some success, color reproductions from paintings by Neatby illustrate “A Day with Keats,” while Tennyson's book is decked out with similar illustrations after Haslehurst and Margetson. The same painters, assisted by Lewis Baumer and W. Russell Flint, “do” the Wordsworth and the Browning; Dudley Hardy illustrates the Burns, and several combine to beautify “A Day with Longfel- lew.” In so far as these volumes enlarge the public of the poets treated, they are to be most heartily welcomed. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., in their thin- paper series, now put out a George Eliot in eight volumes, and Wordsworth’s poems and James Russell Lowell's in a volume apiece. The binding is a plum-colored, really flexible leather, which bends as eas- ily with the 480 pages of “Adam Bede” as with the 950 pages of the Wordsworth. In the same series is issued a volume of “Poetical Quotations’—a new edition of the American version of Bohn’s “Dictionary of Poetical Quotations,” edited by Anna L. Ward. Here are generously represented American and English authors, whose lines are classified according to their subjects: Actors, Adieu, Adversity (see Affliction); Homer, Honeymoon (see Moon), Hope, etc. The thinner volumes in this collection show, of course, the better page. There is a limit beyond which a reduction tp bulk can be gained only at the cost of an imperfectly opaque page. The type is sizable and clear. George Eliot, traditionally a two- shelf author, certainly bears the aspect of novelty where condensed to eight Inches. Frederick A. Stokes Company offers an excellent reprint of Reade’s “Cloister and the Hearth,” with illustrations in color and black-and-white by Byam Shaw. The artist
Page 19
Dec. 9, 1909] has caught well the romance of that great historical novel. Thomas B. Mosher's holiday-books have become standard Christmas-gift literature. This year we have from the Portland book- shop a fine array of poets: Eugene Lee- Hamilton's exquisite sonnet sequence, “‘“Mim- ma Bella,” 20 pages in vellum; W. E. Henley’s “Khymes and Rhythms,’’ 70 nar- row and unadorned pages in bluish-gray cardboard; “Rabbi Ben Ezra,’ showing a short and wide page, with a large-faced type; an exquisite group of lyrics by A. C. Swinburne (‘‘Félise’’); reprint of Mr Yeats’s “Land of Heart's Desire’; “A Branch of May Poems” and “A Wayside Lute,” by Lizette Woodworth Reese Among the smaller volumes is a fine re- print of Milton's “Ode on the Morning of Christ’s Nativity’; and in besides Francis Thompson's Essay on Shelley, iu seventy very handsome pages; Arthur Sy- mons’s translation of Baudelaire’s ‘‘Poems in Prose,” and his own “Silhouettes”; “A Little Book for John O’Mahoney’s Friends,” by Katharine Tynan; Olive Schreiner's “The Lost Joy,’ and Pater’s “‘Child in the House.” For lovers of the real book, we may rec- ommend two new additions to the green- and-gold Library of Prose and Poetry, is- sued by the Oxford University Press. One of these is an exact reprint of Keats's volume of 1820, containing “Lamia,” “Isa- bella,” “The Eve of St. Agnes,” the and “Hyperion”; the other reproduces Gray’s volume of 1768, containing, with the few pages of the appendix, all the published in the poet’s life-time. if anywhere, we have combined the of a gift-book and the substantial of literature. In a pocketable volume, H. S. Krans has gathered a chain of “English Love Poems, Old and New,” admitting, as he says, “only poems that are, beyond all dispute, lyrical —-brief, spontaneous, song-like, impassioned aglow with feeling.” The selection is good, and indeed has no need to go beyond well-trodden lines. In only a few instances g.. Where he accepts Hood's “I love thee” and rejects “Fair Ines’’—do we feel have just cause for quarrelling with his taste. The format of the book is not unlike that of the Golden Treasury Series, with, however, an ornate cover. The illus- trations were better omitted. (G. P. Put- nam’s Sons.) A quite charming edition of Mrs. Brown- ing’s “Sonnets from the Portuguese’ has been printed by G. P. Putnam's Sons, with decorative designs by Margaret Armstrong on alternate pages. In each of these illus- trations is inscribed a brief and appropriate quotation from some other poet. Duffield & Co. for the holidays a collection of texts which they appropriate- ly call The Rubric Series, since the print- ing is in red and black The marginal decorations are in excellent taste and do decorate—and not obliterate—the text it- self. The Rubric Series is published at a reasonable price, and, so far, includes no books which it diffieult in other editions; but heartily commend as pleasant to the eye and light to the hand the volumes which we have received: Browning's “Pippa Passes," Emerson's “Nature,” Mrs. Browning's ‘Sonnets from the Portuguere,”’ and the Dickens “Christ- mas Carol.” a prose, odes, poems Here, grace value -¢. we issue is to secure we ion. The Nat W. E. H. LECKY. A Memoir of W. EB. H. Lecky. By his wife. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $2.50 net. Mr. Lecky, we read, never encouraged the idea of a biography, but we fancy his shade must be indulgent to a memoir that embodies so many of his own qual- ities of tact, proportion, and reserve. His career was uniformly brilliant; his relations included the best minds and wits in many nations. Nothing would have been easier than to stitch his letters together with perfunctory com- ment, and thus produce more of those obesely formless biographies in two volumes. Mrs. Lecky has chosen in- stead to give only the significant mate- rial. Hundreds of letters are represent- ed only by a single nugget of wit or wisdom, washed out of the imprisoning detritus. To such discretion, al! grati- tude is due. The life of Mr. Lecky was an extraor- dinary example of economized forces. In him, the vital stock of sturdy landown- ing families had run low. How un- British is the first picture we have of him as “a fair, quiet, gentle boy. He used to ride on a pony, write poetry, and sermons, and was much occupied with religious controversy.” Of his school life at Cheltenham, he wrote twenty years later in terms that a Frenchman might use of the bondage of the Lycée: “I hated public-school life greatly, never playing any games, and being driven to the very verge of dis- traction at living always with other boys.” There was, indeed, nothing of the wholesome young barbarian about Ed- ward Lecky. Immediately after a town and gown riot on the green of Trinity College, Dublin, he writes: “My personal recollections are few, as I was so hor- rified at the faces streaming with blood and men half insensible that I was rath- er glad to turn away.” And the further comment bespeaks the future judicious historian: “There seems but one opin- ion here, that the provocation in no re- spect justified the charge’ (of the police force). Throughout his life city noises distressed him beyond endurance, and also the routine of society. Periodically and frequently he took refuge in travel: one of mor- usually When I have got into a state bid, feverish excitability, 1 with some long and books which require minute and patient study, somewhere far from every one I know, an have there, in long solitary mountain walks, calmed my mind systematized thoughts. The last phrase is significant. Sys- tematizng his thoughts became _ the chief business of the man, and of it he made a very fine art. At Trinity Col- lege, Dublin, he became the paragon of an intellectual circle, including David Plunket, now a Peer; Mr. Fitzgibbon, have gone, serious and my 7 571 and his life-long correspondent, Ar- thur Booth. Dowden, Traill, and Ma haffy were later college contemporaries and friends. Lecky was the best orator of the Historical Society and admitted- ly the most brilliant talker of his aca- demic generation, but, moderate in all things, he was content to rank ten in a class of forty, to publish anonymously the Inevitable thin volume of poems, and to prepare himself for a career in di- vinity. There followed several years of travel and research through the greater and lesser libraries of Europe, and grad- ually, it became clear that he was to have not the spiritual cure of a parish, but the intellectual cure of an epoch. Be- fore the two great Histories of Ra- tionalism and of Moral Ideas, he had given hostages in a small volume of “Irish Leaders.” It fell still-born from the press in 1861, the author’s twenty- third year, only to be revived into poic- nant actuality a score of later during the Home Rule agitation. One would gladly know the stages that drew him away from the pulpit. Just what was his working balance between in- creasing rationalism and residual faith we shall never know, but it seems un likely that this hidden struggle had the tragic cast so common among the great Victorians. Towards the end of his lire when questioned as to h!s religion by his constituents of Trinity College, he re- plied “IT am a Christian,” and resolutely refused all ulterior explanations. It is pleasant to recall that the \eter- an George Ticknor was one of the first Americans to praise the “History of Ra- tionalism,” 1865. From this time dates the correspondence with H. C. Lea, the historian of the Inquisition. Still later James Ford Rhodes became something between a pupil and a counsellor. The two great treatises on Rationalism and European Morals established Lecky's fame. Achieved before his thirtieth year, involving prodigious research over a period of nearly two thousand years, the mere athleticism of the task would have contented a more ordinary man. But Lecky had worked out as well 2 fine and individual way of writing history, a manner which he once again exemplified in the more restricted and likewise more dificult task that virtually rounded off his life-work, the “History of England in the Eighteenth Century.” What his attitude was we must now briefly in- quire. Everybody knows that he brougat actual composition a singular amenity, clarity, and sense of proportion—quall- ties rather French than English. More important was a crystalline impartiality not incompatible with sympathy. “He had,” writes a Trinity friend, “an invet- erate habit, which exposed him to a great deal of misunderstanding, of de- fending in conversation whatever posi- tion happened to be attacked.” Note clearly that his impartiality was not years to
Page 20
oO G2 merely negative; there was in it no shred of indifference. Imaginative sym- pathy was, he held, the prime quality of, the historian. He must be able to live along with every faction which he de- scribes. Thus readers of the Morals alternately accused him of Popery, or more specifically, Jesuitism, and of athe- ism. Candor, literary tact, and sympa- thy form a large part of his equipment, but this perhaps would hardly set him Green and lesser scholars. an especial ardent faith in of the generalizing process, he is the only English his- who has the full flavor of the Victorian mood as best represented in the He believed that the motley chronicle of the past could not merely be organized and described, but also ex- plained. The search for causes he knew to be desperately difficult, and this serv- ed not as a deterrent, but as a challenge. In a letter to a foreign correspondent he has given an account of his aims, which, if closely read, will go far to explain his peculiar excellences, Tracing his descent through Vico, Condorcet, Hegel, Herder, Comte, and Buckle, he adds: apart from He brought the validity and thereby torlan poets. What characterizes these writers is that the try to look at history not as a serivs mraphies, or accidents, or pictures, but as a great organic whole; that they ler the social and intellectual condi- tion of the world at any given period a problem to be explained, the net result of nnumerable influences which it is the bus ir of the historian to trace; and that the especially believe that intellectual belief has not been due merely to argu- other intellectual causes, but has n very profoundly modified in many cu- ways by social, political, and indus- trial influences. riou Mr. Lecky deliberately compli- the task of the historian in the direction of intimacy. One might al- most have predicted that the young his- torlan of Rationalism and European Morals must end as the author of the “Map of Life.” This assertion of the will to interpret required prophetic courage, and we think it noteworthy that the fin- That cated is, est and tersest eulogy of the Morals came from one Alfred Tennyson, who said: “It is a wonderful book for a young man to have written, a great book for any man to have written, and proves that he has genius, true genius.” There was a polished suavity in Mr. Lecky'’s manner as a writer that possi- bly told against his authority. He arous- ed the British prejudice against the clever person, and hardly got his due recognition as a laborious scholar. If any one still has such doubts, this biog- raphy will disabuse him. The digesting of two hundred volumes of manuscripts and one hundred of pampniet collections for the Irish history is the partial rec- ord for one summer when he was “not exactly idle.” It is his triumph to have concealed this labor by the grace of the finished product. His health, never ro- The Nation. bust, was seriously affected by his early tasks, and he held his own through a fairly long and most useful life by an elaborate system of evasion. London in- evitably drew him, but he found a haven out of sound of the roar. Society claim- ed him, but had him rarely. He declined a Regius Professorship at Oxford in or- der to finish his “History of the Eigh- teenth Century.” Nor would he con- tribute to Lord Acton’s Cambridge His- tory, except perfunctorily, disapproving as he did of the underlying coéperative idea. At thirty-three he married a lady-in-waiting of the Dowager Queen of Holland. It was then that he hu- morously envied the luck of Adam, who was “married in a deep sleep.” The wed- ding reception was in the historic House in the Wood, in the Orange Hall, where later the Leckys were to see the body of their friend the Queen lying in state while her favorite swans swam untend- ed outside. The gentler side of Lecky which is suggested in such a reference it would be interesting to exhibit fully, but a pair of examples must suffice. One recalls vividly his loyalty to Carlyle in mental dissolution. To Gavan Duffy Lecky writes quite simply: The last year or eighteen months of his {[Carlyle’s] life was very sad. ... I used to drive with him regularly once a week, chiefly to ifent his pipe and lift to had to take—as and he used his lips a tonic which he he could do neither to sink into long unbroken silences. Is there any picture of the stricken Titan like that? In a different way one rel- ishes equally the view of Herbert Spen- cer, who has just finished the “Sociol- ogy,” and “seems very confident that it will be a complete explanation of human life.” The work was running longer than the author’s expectation, as “he had quite forgotten” the existence of one part, “domestic relations.” However, adds Lecky, “these, too, will be ex- plained.” It was inevitable that politics should claim Mr. Lecky as soon as the Irish question became urgent. He simply was the best informed contemporary on the history of that unhappy land, he had predicted the breakdown of the first land purchase bill, his friends included Irish- men of every tinge of opinion. By the himself, 'winter of 1895, he was sitting in Par- liament as member from Trinity Col- lege, Dublin. His seven years of this service were hardly happy ones. To Mr. Lea, he writes: “The work is physically very tiring, and I often feel that a good deal of it might be done equally well, with a little training, by a fairly intel- ligent poodle-dog.” As a Liberal Union- ist, wards the idea of Home Rule, he was stead'!ly opposed. Parnell and his ter- rorists, he cordially detested. A separ- ate Catholic university seemed to him) needless. He advocated an extension of | local self-covernment. It was unfortu- | he steered a consistent course. To-| [Vol. 89, No. 2319 nate, perhaps, that his brief public ca- reer fell upon a time of declining health and sptrits. He betrayed just a little of the old man’s tendency to despair of the republic. To judge the recent Irish policy of England, which was virtually that of Mr. Lecky, would be hazardous. To us it seems deficient in humane au- dacity and imagination. Mr. Lecky in- sisted that, except to an orderly Ireland, nothing could be conceded, but it is rarely the part of political wisdom to treat ignorant and inflamed folk simply as they deserve. Here, many will think, was the chance for that instinctive and illogical idealism to which Mr. Lecky accorded so large a part in history. Through the genial caricatures of F. M. Gould, all the world knows Mr. Lecky, the Parliamentarian. The deprecating stoop, the craned neck, the general as- pect of a benign human giraffe, have perhaps unduly robbed his presence of its real dignity. One likes better to re- member him as he spoke at the ter- centenary of his own college in 1892. ‘Clothed like the scarlet woman,” he once wrote whimsically to a corre- spondent, the tall self-contained figure concluded with words that needed no emphasis of gesture: as Whatever fate may be in store for us, whatever new powers may arise, may ths University at least be true to itself. Ina country torn by sectarian and podiitical strife, may it continue to bring tog-the in friendly competition students of differ- ent creeds and different political colors, and teach them to respect each other and teach them to respect themselves. In an atmosphere hot and feverish with over- strained rhetoric and passionate exagger.- tions, may it continue the home of sobe: thought, of serious study, of impartial judgment, of an earnest desire for truth. building up slowly, steadily, and labori- ously the nobler and more enduring ele- |ments of national life. With this utterance, we may take leave of Mr. Lecky. It is in a manner his testament. It embodies the spirit of his great histories, of such tracts as “Democracy,” or his ultimate and most intimate contribution to the literature of morals, “The Map of Life.” In the later years his invalidism increased, and he died suddenly and painlessly in his own library on October 22, 1903, midway in his sixty-fifth year. Mr. Lecky possessed a tact and in- dustry that amounted to genius. He commanded a flexible and persuasive style. Constantly at grips with physical weakness, he conquered peace and op- portunity for the effective employment of an indomitable mind. The element of tragedy and moral storm and stress which was so marked in his Victorian contemporaries is hardly perceived in him. He recalls rather the stalwart, in- tellectual optimism of the eighteenth century; but, an indefatigable investiga- tor of the concrete and particular, he betrays nothing of the doctrinaire su-
Page 21
Dec. 9 1909] The Nation. pestatality of the Aufkidrung. Like his friend, Herbert Spencer, but with far more varied and imaginative insight, he exemplifies a peculiarly loyal courage of the mind. The value of strenuous re- search and honest generalization, he seems never to have doubted. In our time, this quality is rare and fortify- ing. Mr. Lecky lived to hear Brunetiére proclaim the bankruptcy of science; he died before William James and Bergson had intimated the futility of intellection itself. CURRENT FICTION. Seymour Chariton. By W. B. Maxwell. New York: D. Appleton & Co. Seymour Charlton, the younger son of an earl, finds himself, at thirty-five, a lonely and useless member of society. For a time his noble father has regard- ed him of importance as the possible heir to the title. The elder brother was a renegade—a socialist, and, unfortu- nately, a cad: there was felt to be a chance of his disposing of himself. He had, indeed, disappeared for a time in Australia, only to emerge with a wife and progeny; whereupon Seymour be- came a cipher in his father’s eyes, and nearly that in his own. He now seemed destined to be a “little brother to the rich” for the rest of his life. But at this moment a saving thing happens. He falls seriously in love with a poor girl, and determines to drop the empty non- sense of fashionable life and be simply busy and happy with her. Then the father and the elder brother are taken off, the Australian offspring are discov- ered to be illegitimate, and Seymour Charlton finds himself the Ear! of Brent- wood, with huge wealth and many re- sponsibilities. He marries the girl, but there is no quiet life of the affections for them. He is swept into political life, as a nominal leader but a virtual pawn, and is quickly involved in a mesh of petty cares and worries presented to him in the guise of public service. A Cabinet position is dangled before him, and he becomes a very little man in scheming to be a great one. There is estrangement between him and his wife. The man has become a manikin, and eventually allows himself to be actually unfaithful to her. But there is a strain of reserve force in him, and the moment is to come when, by the exercise of a real magnanimity, he is able to free himself from the toils of pseudo-great- ness, and begin at last a reasonable life with the woman he really loves. Readers of “Vivien” and “The Guard- ed Flame” will be prepared to find this theme treated by Mr. Maxwell in no merely conventional way. In Copland, the young earl's father-in-law—Cooland the ingenuous, the exuberant, the peren- nially young, and, alas! the incurably tricky—there is a strong though no ——— doubt chance resemblance to the irre- pressible compounder of “Tono-Bungay.” The Severed Mantle. By William Lind- sey. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. Mr. Lindsey will be recalled by a few as author of a volume of respectable minor verse, and by many as author of a book of robustious youth called “Cinder- Path Tales.” He would now seem to have turned his hand to historical ro- mance rather in a spirit of adventure than from inner compulsion. Even his- torical romance is not a trick to be turn- ed offhand, and there are not a few traces of the tyro in the present per- formance. It is a creditable tour de force, but it is far from a masterpiece. Provence in the time of the trouba- dours offers a tempting theme for the romancer, but a theme which has its evident perils. The brusque modern mind finds something approaching the affected and silly in that cult of “l'amour” upon which, after all, mod- ern civilization is founded. When Mr. Lindsey tries to show “the land of the nightingale and rose when Idealism reigned supreme, with Love, Joy, and Song her counsellors,” he sets himself a difficult task. He has simplified the matter by approaching the troubadour from the Puritan point of view, repre- senting him not “a shallow fellow who wandered about twanging a lute, and singing pretty songs to foolish wo- men,” but as an earnest liver, a tofty dreamer—often a martyr even. He of the severed mantle sets out early in life in quest of “the Perfect Love.” He has the familiar heroic ad- ventures—hair-breadth escapes, doughty encounters, sentimental conquests. He does wonders in the lists and in the pub- lic contests of the masters of song. He is tempted by light loves, and finally by the summons of a great passion. But the spiritual side of his nature remains dominant. He wins through it all un- scathed. A time of Crusade comes, and, with the Cross on his breast and the con- secrating kiss of his lady on his lips, he finds the Perfect Love. The narrative is elaborately furnished with the detail and color of Provencal life in the twelfth century, but, unfortunately, the genera! effect is rather of ingenuity than of strength. Whatever the book has of intrinsic in- terest is due to Mr. Lindsey's happy bits of translation from the Provencal song of the period. as The Red Saint. By Warwick Deeping. New York: Cassell & Co., Ltd. This writer has completely mastered the formula of the historical romance. He knows the right proportion of spec- tacle, intrigue, blood-letting, love-mak- ing, and authentic fact. He has had his previous successes (“Mad Barbara” and the rest), and the legend “Fifth Impres- Jt 73 sion” to be found upon the present title- page indicates that “The Red Saint” is going the way of the popular novel. Tak- en in cold blood, the result is, of course, more or less preposterous; but historical romance, like melodrama, is hardly worth approaching at all unless in a child-like spirit. The “red saint” is a red-haired amateur hermitess who lives in a wood and works marvels of healing among the surrounding peasantry. She is bound by no vows, and love springs up between her and a neighboring no- ble. He is on the side of the barons in their struggle with Henry III; and dur- ing his absence in the fleld the red saint is violated in her cell by a Gascon fol- lower of the King. The fact remains un- known, and the girl allows herself to be taken under the protection of the Abbot of Battle. She is welcomed with pomp as an accession to the abbey be- longings; but her miraculous powers are gone, and she becomes a cause of humil- iation to the monks. Finally her ap- proaching motherhood is discovered, and she is driven forth with violence. She wanders helpless until she finds refuge under the wing of a camp-follower, a common woman of the road, but a good heart. The Gascon comes upon them and it seems that she is to fall into his hands; but with the aid of the woman and of her undeclared lover of former days, she is rescued. Of course one sees them eventually united from the ; but the end is not yet. Mr. Deeping, we say, knows the game He makes fluent of that quaint idiom which joins a modern syntax to an archaic vocabulary, with and then a frank lapse into modern vernacu- lar—as conventional a dialect as that with which the hero of melodrama edi- fies the gallery. very outset use now The Paladin. By Horace Annesley Vach- ell. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. This clever story is dedicated to the author's little daughter “and to other maids of high and low degree who, by a perusal of its pages, may learn, per- haps, that seeming paladins cannot be taken with impunity at their own valua- tion.” Strictly, the book should have been called “The Seeming Paladin," for Harry Rye was a man who played the hero intermittently only, and made his acts of heroism deliberate and safe by “marking time” while he meditated them. On two or three occasions he did the right thing at the right moment. Usually, however, he achieved his chival- ries too late. Thus did he fail to hold the woman for whom he achieved them: and his history becomes the record of that unpopular being, a careful man. One cannot escape a feeling that the author, consumed as he is with just in- dignation, is yet hardly fair to his hero in his better moments. It ts not surprising that weak human nature
Page 22
T+ should be a little complacent at dcoing the honorable thing when the honorable thing means defiance of family and tra- dition, The heroine and her friends may well have been annoyed, but from the one for perfect justice. Esther—labelled “a woman of temper- ament”—is a happy compound of sensi- tiveness and sense, kicking against the author looks pricks but always stable in loyalty and kindness. Her defection from Harry is quite as much due to her own enlarging vision as to his shortcomings. The tan- gle here is one of unusual originality. The author admirably understands how far to give detail and how far to omit it. The side characters are particularly in- dividual and the march of the story is conducted in a masterly way. The im- pression survives that it is not only the liarry Ryes who are arraigned, but the whole sex, especiaily such of them as play untimely golf on honeymoons. OUR TREATMENT OF THE CHINESE. Cc) Immigration. By Mary Roberts Coolidge. New York: Henry Holt & $1.75 net. Just why Mrs. Coolidge’s book should have been withdrawn from sale (a few days after publication) for several weeks is not altogether clear. The author is a well-known student and teacher of eco- nomics, not given heretofore to sensa- tionalism, and of standing among schol- ars Every material statement in the volume is vouched for as based either upon personal observation or upon au- thorities specifically cited; while a large part of the data is drawn from official publications bearing the imprint of the United States Government. The explana- tion offered by the publishers, that the book “contains so much criticism of of- ficlala concerned in our Chinese policy, ime Se (Co. that since the first objection, some weeks s nee, it has been kept out of the market awaiting others,” Is at least surprising, in view of the care with which publishers usually examine works deal- ing with living persons or matters of current discussion; and it is equally hard to believe that the publishers could be induced to yleld to pressure from Washington, simply because a book Is- sted by them reflected upon the charac- ind work of government officials. Yet If ever a book contained a damning arraignment of a governmental policy ite administration, Mra. Coolidge’s volume is such an one. We must pass over entirely the chapters devoted to discussion of the character and econom- ic status of the Chinese, and the mo tives which have prompted thelr migra- tion to the United States; merely re- marking that, in thoroughness of obser- vation and fulness of detail, they easily surpass all previous treatments of these topics and are tn the highest degree in- forming. The leading feature of the book fs ite account of the development ter and The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 and administration of the exclusion laws. Here is set forth the whole long story of political chicanery, abuse, fraud, misrepresentation, coercion, il-' legality, and indecency in which the rec- ord of the treatment of the Chinese in this country is enshrined. In the evi- dent willingness, and at times the pur- pose, to pass laws difficult of enforce- ment because intricate or obscure, and at the same time deliberately repugnant to treaty obligations and the common rights of individuals at law; to construe the law with the utmost strictness, and always against those claiming under it; to deny appeal to the courts, or so to impede it as to make appeal virtually impossible; to browbeat witnesses, at- torneys, and friends, confine and deport immigrants without warrant or trial, and subject innocent persons to indig- nity and hardship without possibility of mitigation or redress; to mob, drive out, or kill inoffensive persons lawfully resi- dent in the country and not even sus- pected of any crime; and to distort and falsify evidence in order that the acts of politicians might receive official sup- port at Washington—the story of the Chinese in the United States recalls no- thing so much as the Dreyfus case. Sub- stitute for the Government and a cor- rupt officialdom in France a venal la- bor vote and corrupt immigration ser- vice in this country, and add in each case the bitter element of race hatred, and the historical parallel is singularly complete. It would be some palliation if the re- sponsibility for our national disgrace in the matter of the Chinese could be charged entirely to petty officials; but such, unfortunately, is not the case. It was Secretary Bayard who, after leaving unacknowledged for months the protests of the Chinese Minister against the Seott Act, declared that the act was passed in accordance with the wishes of China. It was Secretary Blaine who ignored repeated diplomatic protests against both the Scott Act and the Geary Act, the latter of which “not only vio- lated every single article of the treaty of 1880, but also denied bail, required white witnesses, allowed arrest without warrant, and put the burden of prouf on the Chinese” (p. 221). It was Acting- Secretary Wharton, an eminent author- ity on international law, who in Decem- ber, 1892, replying at last to protests of four years’ standing, evaded the ques- tions at issue, laid the blame on the Chinese, and Insultingly reproached Min- ister Tsui for not adopting “an attitude of amicable concurrence toward a ra- tional and practical end.” Even Secre- tary Hay, of all our great diplomatists the most enlightened and liberal in the treatment of the Chinese question, up- held the ruling Griggs, in. 1898, that the true meaning of the treaty of 1880 was “not that all) ‘greater difficulties than the problem of Chinese persons may enter this country of Attorney-General | who are not forbidden, but that only those are entitled to enter who are ex- pressly allowed"—a ruling which re versed the substantially uniform prac- tice of sixteen years, and under which the Secretary of the Treasury “at once made a regulation denying admission to salesmen, clerks, buyers, bookkeepers, accountants, managers, storekeepers, ap- prentices, agents, cashiers, physicians, proprietors of restaurants, etc.” (p. 283). To any one familiar with the pulitics of California, the attitude of Congress- men and Senators from that State to- wards any question in which “labor” is concerned is rarely a matter of sur- prise; but the character of both the men and the methods employed to further the policy of exclusion gets startling il- lumination at Mrs. Coolidge’s hands. The famous Congressional report of 1876, on Chinese immigration, is left without a leg to stand upon, so inaccur- ate and biassed are its statements snown t» be. The reports of the United States consul at Hongkong from 1871 to 1879, D. H. Bailey, on the coolie trade and on slavery in China, were (in an article in the North American Review) cited as authoritative by Senator G. C. Perkins as recently as 1906; yet these reports were utterly misleading, and _ Bailey himself is declared to have been an embezzler, during his office, to an amount of at least ten times his annual salary; while T. H. King, one of the “star” witnesses before the investigating committee in 1876, aided him in his dishonesty. The two Com- missioners-General of Immigration who held the office from 1889 to 1902, Her- mann Stump and T. V. Powderly, were chosen solely in the interest of “labor,” as was also Commissioner Sargent; while the Secretary of Commerce and Labor in President Roosevelt’s Cabinet, Victor H. Metcalf, was a California politician heartily in sympathy with the trade unions in their advocacy of exclu- sion. The policy of brutality in the treatment of Chinese immigrants reach- ed its climax in the career of the notor- ious James R. Dunn, sometime chie: in- spector at San Francisco, who, accord- ing to Mrs. Coolidge, “suggested rules and secured their adoption, and then under their sanction refused landing”; and in case of appeal to Washington, “presented the testimony in any shape he chose, colored with his own interpre- tations” (p. 322). Dunn was eventually transferred to Canada, and thence to St. Louis, from which place “three cases of arbitrary and outrageous procedure” by him and his subordinates have been re- ported to the State Department erince this book was written. Painful and humiliating as is the story which Mrs. Coolidge has to tell, the book must nevertheless prove a pow- erful agent for good. Of all our social problems in this country, none presents
Page 23
Dec. 9, 1909] The Nation. that in so far as the Hebrews made use of the myth they borrowed from the Babylonians, substituting their own na- tional God, Jahwe, for the victorious Marduk in the great struggle with the primeval monster. The parallels found among non-Semitic peoples are very vague, and we doubt if Professor Oester- ley would have discovered them with- out the spur given to his imagination by his theory. It is surprising how many mythic allusions are found scat- tered throughout the Old Testament and in the Apocalyptic portions of the New. Nevertheless, the writer’s insistence that these myths in their entirety were matters of common knowledge among the people when the Old Testament books were written is not well support- ed. In seeking to strengthen his case he proposes many emendations in the Hebrew text and makes a number of badly strained interpretations. The de- velopment of the idea of “Tehom, who was the mythical adversary of Jahwe, into the Jewish and Christian Satan is interestingly and convincingly set forth and forms one of the béest chapters of the book. In the same way, though less clearly, the author traces the develop- ment of the “Messiah-Saviour” idea and the full conception of the “Messianic the treatment of alien races; and com- ing, as this volume does, at a time when the feeling of the intelligent classes on the Pacific Coast towards the Chinese has changed from opposition to out- spoken friendliness, and when a de- mand for administrative honesty and ef- ficiency is loud and insistent in all parts of the country, it cannot but help on the work of adjustment, if in no other way than by showing how dreadful have been the mistakes of the past. If the of- ficials of the immigration service have anything to say in reply to Mrs. Cool- idge’s specific allegations, they cannot too soon make their defence public. The Evolution of the Messianic Idea: A Study in Comparative Religion. By the Rev. W. O. E. Oesterley, D.D. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $1.25 net. “Messianism,” according to Dr. Oester- ley, is not confined to Hebrew life and thought, although in them and Chris- tianity it has attained its most perfect development. He holds that the leading conceptions comprised under this term, used in its broadest sense, can be traced back to the earliest dawn of the human understanding. The Messianic idea is grounded in some of the elemental char- acteristics of man’s nature, and was fra” and the “Jahwe” and “Paradise” originally expressed in certain world- myths. wide myths, traces of which may be professor Oesterley naturally relies found among all primitive peoples. The feeling of fear, the sense of dependence, and the desire to be happy are declar- ed by Dr. Oesterley to be the back- ground of the three great myths, by means of which he thinks primitive man gave expression to his ideas. The “Tehom” myth (so-called from the He- brew word in the second verse of Gene- sis) arose out of man’s dread of natur- al forces, especially the sea, with which were associated early speculations re- garding a primeval cruel monster inimi- cal to gods and men. The feeling of de- pendence found expression in what Dr. Oesterley terms the “Jahwe” or “Heil- bringer” myth, and the desire for hap- piness gave rise to the myth of “Para- dise” or the “Golden Age.” This essay consists of a careful investigation into the origin and development of these myths, their prevalence among vafious peoples, and their influence on Hebrew thought. The author finds most of his material for the reconstruction of these primitive myths in the Old Testament, and most of the hints in regard to their develop- ment, although Babylonian literature proves also to be a fruitful fleld. Many of the Biblical allusions become clear in the light of the more primitive and fuller forms from Babylonia, and, in spite of Dr. Oesterley’s contention for independent origin among the Hebrews, one cannot help thinking that the great “Tehom"” myth was entirely and solely a product of the Euphrates valley, and much on the investigation of Gunkel, Gressmann, Breysig, and others, but his book is a distinct and original contri- bution to the study of religion. He has brought together a great mass of mate- rial, and thrown new light on many ob- scure passages of the Old Testament. In the form of a dissertation his work was accepted by the University of Cam- bridge as sufficient for the degree of doctor of divinity, and in publication but few changes were made. It is a book principally for the scholar and the teacher of religion. By Mrs. F. M. A. C. McClurg & The Bretons at Home. yostling. Chicago: Co. $2.50 net. This thick octavo volume, with its wide margins and clear, large type, is an unusually agreeable book to see and to handle. The twelve illustrations in color by Gaston Fanty Lescure are, many of them, poetic and suggestive, and the larger number of photographs made by Mrs. Gost'ing and her husband are pic- turesque and not at all amateurish. An introductory chapter in French, con- tributed by Anatole Le Braz, the distin- guished Breton folklorist, pays an ex- quisite tribute to the author, her book, and her nation, and incidentally reveals one of those beautiful esprits de savant, more often met with in France than elsewhere, in whom love of la douce France—or even, perhaps, of one among her provinces—seems to refine away all STS petty ambitions and rivalries, and ive to their work almost the character of a religion. Thus heralded and adorned, Mrs. Gost- ling’s book itself is a little disappoint- ing. In the course of the long journey, extending over nearly month, and taking us from one end to the other of the Armorican peninsula—‘la Bretagne bretonnante”—we have to confess that our interest flags repeatedly. The jour: ney is accomplished sometimes in wag- ons, sometimes in antiquated chariots and, for the most part, in a comforiable modern automobile; but the persons who occupy the “George Richard" main rather tantalizingly vague and un- real to the end. Madame is always Mme. l’'Anglaise, who loves’ Brittany and is interested in folklore and ruins, while M. le Docteur has not even thus much recognition, but is left more shadowy than the phantom saints and outworn gods, who people the strange land through which the motor speeds. Indeed, we cannot avoid the suspicion that it is for lack of this personal note, the slight, yet vivifying touch, evoking the living man and woman from printed page, that so much of the book seems heavy. Mrs. Gostling is evidently a scholarly, as well as a cultivated woman. She has travelled widely, and her acquaintance with folklore and legend, comparative mythology and ethnology, is considera- ble. Moreover, the austere beauty of the coast of Brittany, the fleeting glow of color in its autumn fields, and, above all, the primitive old-world life of its peculiar people, make the strongest ap- peal to her imagination. Occasionally, a passage of description or of reverie brings to her usually straightforward speech a certain sudden freedom and up- lift, and for a moment we feel with her the strong sense of mystery and of doom which broods over the Breton country. We catch an echo of the inex- orable decree that nothing achieved by the hand of the Celt shall endure, but that his frustrate spirit shall haunt for- ever the lands which in !ife he was im- potent to hold. Possibly, the wide range of her read- ing and her interests has tended to im- pair the unity and effectiveness of Mrs. Gostling’s book. She makes too great a demand upon the flexibility of her read- er’s mind. Among the many who would delight to journey with her across the en- chanted land of Merlin,stopping at noon or in the evening at little ghost-haunted inns (which provide, nevertheless, ex- ceedingly good dinners), drinking in the beauty of the landscape, the wonders of its old ruined civilization, there are probably not a few to whom her long and learned excursions into folklore and myth, Christian legend and Pagan super- stition, would appear a tiresome inter- ruption and delay. It would probably have been better if all these legends a re the
Page 24
N76 in prose and verse, many of which are in themselves well told, had been col- lected and printed by themselves as a section of the book. On the whole, in spite of M. Le Braz’s words of fervent approbation, we must persist in believing that neither he, nor any other of the Latintradition, would have giv- “The at Home” in pre this arrangement. separate en us Bretons form and cise La Sardegna Medioevale. By Enrico Besta. Vol. I: Le vicende politiche dal 450 al 1326. Vol. II: Le istituzioni politiche, economiche, giuridiche, so- clali. Palermo: Alberto Reber. In the volumes before us we have what we believe to be the first really serious attempt to write the history of Sardinia during that obscure period which, beginning with the invasion i¢ Vandals under Genseric, ends with Aragonese conquest in the Trecento oO. ¢) the That such a work supplies a very real will hardly be denied by any stu- dent of things medieval; and pect that a very limited amount of self will convince the vast mt that know!l- we sus- amination jority of our readers such edge as they possess of the vicissitudes of Sardinian story, from the fifth cen tury to the fourteenth, is not only ex tremely meagre, but also more than a little insecure. For most of us vagu: notions of Saracenic and Ostrogothic incursions, dateless and _ undetailed, gradually merge into slightly more det: ideas of Pisan and Genoese victor- combined, perhaps, with some gen impression—gleaned, most likely the commentators of Dante—of a of the island into four judge- Then, the figure of King Enzo largely, golden-haired and debo- if, by further cudgelling of we succeed in calling to re ’ whom nite les, eral from division ships looms nair; and our brains, membrance “noble judge Nino,’ the poet rejoiced so greatly not to find imong the damned, and frate Gomita, Quel di Gallura, vasel d'ogni froda, we may probably flatter ourselves that ve have recollected all we ever knew about the matter. Moreover, until Pro- fessor Besta wrote this book, it was al- vays extremely difficult to find any rem- our ignorance. KEarlier histor- of Sardinia, from Fara and Cam- onwards, there have no doubt but most of them are entirely out of and none of them is accurate enough to satisfy the requirements of modern criticiam and modern research, while the learned monographs of Solmi, Brandileone, and Mondolfo are too re- stricted in their scope to be of any great use to the Inquirer who starts without some antecedent knowledge of his own. At however, all this is changed, and can henceforward follow the edy for lane biagl been date, last, we story of mediwval Sardinia, in its main outlines at any rate, quite as securely The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 as we can those of Florence, Rome, or Naples. That there are still byways to be explored will only add to the pleas- ure of the student, now that the high- ways are made practicable. Of Professor Besta’s two volumes the second is undoubtedly the more inter esting; but, although they are procur- able separately, the judicious reader will not fail to buy them both, since it is obviously impossible to understand the political, economic, and juridical in- stitutions of a people without some knowledge of its history. One warning only is necessary. Learned, accurate, and profound, a perfect mine of refer- ence for further research, “La Sardegna Medioevale” is nevertheless none too easy to read. Like nearly all modern Italian historical works of any value, it is written by a scholar and for schol- ars. There is not the slightest attempt to gild the pill. Verbatim quotations from the old Sardinian documents, con- tinual interpolations of untranslated Greek and Latin passages in the body of the text, and footnotes which often cover a liberal half of the entire print- ed page, will hardly, we imagine, appeal to the mere tourist, however thoroughly he may understand Italian. Notes. The Malone Society is now in its third year, and will, it is hoped, by the end of eighteen volumes of in return for the guineas of its members. Notice has been given that the roll of the society will be closed on March 20, 1910, after which can- didates will be admitted only as vacancies occur and on payment of an entrance fee. Any one interested in the early English drama, and wishing to join before the roll is closed, or desiring further information, is invited to communicate with the honorary secretary, Mr. Arundel! Esdaile, at the Brit- ish Museum, London, W. C. The Germanic Museum of Harvard Uni- versity has received a gift of $150,000 from Adolphus Busch of St. Louis for the hous- ing of collections, now inadequately shown in the old building which was for- merly the college gymnasium. A conference of the recently organized American Institute of Criminal Law and Criminology was held at Madison, Wis., No- vember 26 and 27, to consider alleged de- fects in our system of punitive justice. This conference was attended not only by law- yers and judges, but by physicians, clergy- have produced and 1909 plays collections its men, social workers, and students. It was divided into eight committees for the discussion of topics relating to the Jury, Trial Procedure, Trial of the Issue of Mental Responsibility, Appeals and Reversals, Organization of Courts, Juvenile Offenders, Probation, Parole, Pardon and Sentence, and Causes and Prevention of Crime. The main purpose of the confer- ence was educational, and in this it suc- ceeded in calling attention to a number of problems connected with the administra. tion of criminal law in Wisconsin. The senate of the University of Cam- bridge has accepted a gift of £20,000 from the firm of Schroeder & Co. of Hamburg, for the endowment of a Germanistic pro- fessorship. The new chair will be termed the Schroeder professorship of German. W. S. Braithwaite’s “Book of Restoration Verse” (Brentano’s) belongs to a _ se- ries which will form a full anthol- ogy from 1557 to 1910. It falls be- tween the Elizabethan and Georgian pe- riods, and receives its name because “the year, and those succeeding 1685, when the restored monarchy came into power and ruled, gave to the group of writers who were at the height of their powers under the influence of Charles's court a definite and unusual character.’’ Mr. Braithwaite’s principle of selection is, it must be admit- ted, fairly arbitrary. Waller is left for the Elizabethan poets because he is “the product of a declining epoch,”’ whereas Mil- ton is placed in the Restoration because he points forward. It would be hard to be critically more perverse than this; do Dryden and Pope flow from Milton or Wal- Again, it introduces a totally incon- gruous matter to include the ballads in this volume. Surely, the ballad of Percy and Douglas, which moved Sidney’s heart like the sound of a trumpet, belongs not here, but with the Elizabethans. Other in- congruities might be pointed out, but after all, we do not look for homogeneity in an anthology. Mr. Braithwaite has brought together a mass of beautiful and characteristic poems, some of them little known, and the publishers have given his the temptation of fair pages and binding. ler? work neat In the latest of his anthologies, E. V. Lucas has gathered together from the rich gallery of English literature a pleasant galaxy of portraits of “originals.” This is, too, as handy a little volume as all the rest, and he calls it, “Some Friends of Mine” (The Macmillan Co.). All the por- traits are painted by natives of Great Britain and Ireland, or of these United States, except a group credited to those cosmopolitan geniuses, Plutarch, Vasari, Heinrich Heine, and the elder Dumas; and the volume is almost altogether made up of prose passages, though the last piece of all is Oliver Wendell Holmes’s, “Our Last Friend.” Perhaps it is worth while, now that we have mentioned Holmes, to enu- merate the other Americans to be met with here, as authors: name Lowell, anil Washington Irving, and Joaquin Miller, and Leland, and the list is told. There has beem no straining after esotericism in the selection of the English representatives, either; yet the range is a generous one. And the classification is one to whet one’s literary appetite: Chance Acquaintance, Urban Humorists, Country Gentlemen, Men of Law and Sportsmen, Wild Irishmen and Six Painters, Bookworms and Teachers of Youth, make a pageant whose passing one is the happier for. Mr. Lucas’s modest volume contains a fine collection of pages apt for reading aloud; and so we hope that genial fireside art is not yet wholly lost. In his “Last Days of Charles II" (Henry Frowde), Dr. Raymond Crawfurd has made @ most interesting contribution not only to what he calls the “medicine of his- tory,” but to history itself. The last ill-
Page 25
Dec. 9, 1909 | ness and death of Charles II have been described frequently and minutely. But, however interesting and picturesque these narrations have been, Dr. Crawfurd justly declares in his preface that no historian appears to have described the events with any approach to accuracy, while the only considerable medical authority who has written on the subject has confirmed the errors of historians by giving his author- ity to a wrong premise, thus establishing wrong conclusion. The present author has based his account largely on the in- teresting and authoritative statement of the case and its treatment written by Si: Charles Scarburgh, first physician to Charles II, which is still preserved in the library of the Society of Antiquarians at a Burlington “House. This he reprints in an appendix, both in the original Latin and in translation. From it, from a mass of contemporary authority, and from his own medical knowledge, he reconstructs in mi- nute detail the progress of the case with all its attendant circumstances, arriving at the conclusion that Charles’s death was due to chronic granular kidney accompa- nied by uremic convulsions. Such a con- clusion has much value to the political historian, since previous accounts have not merely confused the subject, but have often left the impression that the darker sus- picions of the time regarding the King’s death were not wholly without foundation. No less interesting than the story of the peculiar circumstances attending this last illness is the account of the treatment of the case. The list of remedies and pre- scriptions, the diagnosis and the means by the fifteen attendant physicians to cure or relieve the unfortunate patient, give a vivid picture of seventeenth-cen- tury medicine. A pharmacopeia which in- cluded sal ammoniac, Jesuit’s bark or chona, as well as bezoars found in the stomach of an East Indian goat),and spirits of human skull, made from the skull of a man who died a Violent death, marks the transition from mediaeval to modern medicine in striking fashion. II lustrated with portraits of Charles II ani his physicians, King and Scarburgh, reproductions of Charles’s effigy and a mask drawn from it, the little essay makes a most interesting study, well worth read- ing. A clear and readable essay on Lincoln expanded from a popular address given in New York city on Lincoln Day, February 12, 1909, forms the body of George Haven Putnam’s “Abraham Lincoln; the People’s Leader in the Struggle for National Ex- istence” (G. P. Putnam’s Sons). While th: presentation of the subject is without nov- elty, the language is simple enough to ap peal to young people, and the narrative is enlivened by interesting reminiscences of the author’s army life. An appendix reprints the revised text of Lincoln's Coop- er Union speech, with the contemporary annotationg of Cephas Brainerd and Charles Cc. Nott, and some hitherto unpublished letters of Lincoln and Nott regarding the revision and publication of the address. used cin- (a concretion with The original inventory of the contents of Mount Vernon in 1810, filed in the Fairfax County Court House, was lost during the war; and its recovery was deemed so improbable that depend- ence was had on an imperfect copy, re- The Nation. tained in one of the branches of the Wash- ington family. The value of the document lay in its reasonably full list of the personal possessions of Gen. Washing- ton and a quite complete list of the books in his library Therewith it would be possible, in a general way, to test the many claims of Washington relics, and to prove the forging of the bookplate, and its insertion in books which were never in the Washington library. eame to light in a Middle and been very prettily printed limited edition by the owner, W. K of St It is thus accessible full form for the first The books had been already elaborately This inventory Western State, in a Bixby in a list of print- has Louis. time. ed by William C. Lane. It may be noted that in the Virginia Historical Magazine for October is published a list of the li- brary of Daniel Parke Custis, whose widow Washington married For the first few pages of the manuscript the books are di- vided between Washington and his step- son, Jacky Custis, thus showing the source of of the in the library, thought to be most indicative taste, such as Duhamel’s Bland’s “Military some volumes general's of his ‘Husbandry” and Discipline.’ “Italian Vignettes,"””’ by Mary W. Arms, is just one more of those perfervidly senti little which are provoked the books paradoxically that All customary glow is here, and not muc4 May it not seem ungracious, pass ing other inaccuracies, to that the well-known painter of Capri is not Henry but Charles Caryl Coleman, and he that tl “Albine’’ mountains are unknown to orog raphers mental enough inevitably by most sensible of people, Italians the else say is attractively The book got up by the publisher, Mitchell Kennerley. Edward Hutton has the and his book that title the tra of his dimvalist and romanticist of the he in the attitude of grudging Latin This temper is by heard it remains Yet found way to tome under bears \ purest es northern route m< wa- s often Rome its renown unusual. We for the Roman wholly delightful ter no means have sail that but would be Rome his is a1 unhappy view for a guide to take To on, 't the fragments of the Ara Pacis require hardihood; to fail to praise the Arch of Titus—one of the few delicately propor tioned monuments of Imperial times—su¢ gests prejudice In fact, numerous omis sions and inaccuracies bring the work be low the author’s standard. One may ima gine omitting Sta. Agnese fuori, but hardly the neighboring tomb of Sta. Costanza w'th its important mosaics. Again the Latin Tombs want at least a word, not to men- tion the Lateran Museum, if only for it splendid series of sarcophagi. Is Christ represented as “Pantocrator” in the apse of Sta. Pudenziana? If so, the intimacy of the composition, its significant differenc from later ones, should have been point- ed It is not true that all Cavallin!’s work in Southern Italy has perished, un- less, indeed, Mr. Hutton challenges Ven- turi’s plausible attribution of the frescoes in Sta. Maria Donna Regina, Naples. To slight the remnants of Arnolfo at Rome re- quires either courage or carelessness. The book is far from up to date. The new Dis- cobolus of the Terme Museum is unmen- tioned, as well as the lovely Temple Mini«- trant discovered three ago at Anz‘o out. years
_ -) ~-- ‘é The mighty figure of a stricken Niobid, ta the Banca Commerciale, is smilarly passed The rearrangement and augmentation of the Vatican picture gallery by is acknow!l- edged only in a not this book should have begun with edition However, it ig enthusiastically written the of those behind them. Fo indee!, Maxwell! here re- In short, second its , ant will doubtless warm hearts whose Roman days are such sentimental fireside we judge it chiefly intended Armfleld’s sixteen sketches, reproduced, have an eighteenth century serve and lack of fibre, but fairly cessful in evoking a mild glamour. Th is published by the travellers is color as are suc- bon Macmillans rhe founding fifth Université celebrated fore the Bru- De! seventy rsary f of the been re annive libre de xeélles h cently as gates from the various ign ut were in attendan and honorary egrees several of t of he Frer Dantes L rsity of conferred M. Poin Professors of the lI end Metchnikoff of the Professor Westlak« others; also upon the j| Verhaeren, odor lied were upon luding aré Le hive emy Paris Pasteu Lanson Roux stitute: of Cambrid and inck Charles and The Bava since then, When “Plato,” Philosophies of Prof Dodge A. E Publishing C Modern, that the reader les any the Platoni acquainted, we say Taylor's the Ancient in 0. 8 and it wil? mislead s than in- troduction to philosophy with this for style which we are we mean high praise Professor Taylor's and between the philos and method are a happy me of an con- ventional vagueness yphy tells the unavoidable pedantry } . popuiat which student nothing, the of specialization detail The philological which overwhelms him with and him with controve brev- of his apparatus, and neglects sone But in distribution confuses rsy any ity exposition omits passes over minor mat- ters, niceties of interpre- tation. and the due sentially perspective, proportion of emphasis it is es- sound and right, in refreshing contrast to some more ambitious attempts of recent years Plato's fundamental con- ceptions and aims, the meaning of his theory of ideas often miscalled idealism, the purpose of his ‘‘Republic,” and the true relation of his thought to the life of his time, to the criticism of Aristotle and the moderns, and the eternal problems with which it deals, are succinctly, correctly, and lucidly set forth Professor Taylor does ample justice to all the positive achievements of modern philological research in the determination of the probable relative dates of the dia- logues. But he is completely emancipated from the fantastic hypothesis of an earlier and later system of Platonic metaphysics which has introduced so much confusion into the recent literature of the subject in England and Germany. His book may be recommended without reserve as an intro duction to the study of Plato for the student and for the general reader who desire brief compass an intelligible and trust- worthy account of the life and teaching of the world’s most influential thinker and greatest artist in prose. While it cannot vie as a work of literary art with Pater’s “Plato and Piatonism,” or as entertaining reading with Emile Faguet’s “Pour qu'on
Page 26
~ * 78 lise Platon it is far more sane and true than either Its readers will have much ore to learn if they care to pursue the subject further But they will have noth- to unlearn Dr. William Newton Clarke's elaborate ind thorough treatise on “The Christian Doctrine of God” is followed quickly by changing views during his long of his Seripture narrative Holy personal regarding life as a Christian pastor and teacher. The new volume os entitled “Sixty Years with the Bible \ Record of Experience” (Charles Seribner’s Sons). With entire frankness, in which mistaken opinions and inconsistent udgments are recorded faithfully, he de- scribes the road he has travelled, from quiet onfidence in an infallible rule of doctrine to of a partial record of an ex- panding religious life. This is not the story series of catastrophes or cataclysmic Clarke moved very slow- aud kept sure hold of his critical use ota illuminations. Dr ly toward his goal faith through the entire process. Never- theless, the change from his early attitude toward Scripture to that from which he ‘rote his latest volume is nothing less than revolutionary, and in Dr. Clarke's treat- ment it appears absolutely necessary. It is dificult to see how any one can find him at fault at any point for yielding to the newer views, as they appeared before him, and equally difficult to believe that his high reverence for the Bible from his present position is unfounded This frank recital admirably as of his experience will serve a guide to less thorough and discerning minds The “Insel-Almanach auf das Jahr 1910” (Leipzig: Insel-Verlag), decidedly one of the best literary annuals issued in such abundance by German houses, deals largely with Schiller, but by no means confines itself to him and his recent jubilee. The rest of the contents are varied and well se- lected, both old and new matter being giv- en with rich illustrations An admirable series of photographs of the temples of India is given in the Netional Geographic Magazine November. The most striking impression gained from them is made by the wonderful ornamental carv- in one instance, rep- labor “such as never for ings in stone, which, resent an amount of was bestowed on any surface of equal ex- tent in any building in the world.” The contrast between the India of ancient times and of to-day is shown by the first picture of the series, the splendid Y. M. ©, A. build- ing in Bombay long managing editor of in New York Adolph Growoll, Publishers’ Weekly, died December 7, aged fifty-nine years. He the author of “The Booksellers’ Li How to Use It" (1891); “James Biographical and Bibliograph “The Profession of Booksell the elty was brary and Thomeon: a lcal Sketch ing” (two volumes, 1893); “Publishers’ and Other Book Exhibits at the World's Colum bian Exposition” (1893); “American Book Clubs Their Beginnings and History, and a Bibliography of Their Publications” (1897); “Booktrade Bibliography in the United States in the Nineteenth Century” (1808); “Frederick Leypoldt, a Biographical Sketch” (1890); “Henry Harriase, a Bio graphical Sketch” (1899); “Three Centuries of English Book Trade Bibliography’ (1903); “The Booksellers’ League: a History of Its Formation and Ten Years of Its Work” (1906) The Nation. Daniel Ayres Goodsell, the Methodist i:piscopal bishop resident in New York, died December 4 at his home in this city. He was born in Newburgh November 5, 15840, and was graduated in 1854 from New York University. For seven years, from 1880, he was the literary editor of the Christian Adrocate. In the course of his official du- ties he travelled to China, Japan, Korea, Italy, Bulgaria, Switzerland, Germany, Scandinavia, and Finland, and also visited nearly every part of the United States; ana he was the author of two books “Nature end Character at Granite Bay” and “The Things Which Remain” Willlam Alfred Packard, professor of the Latin language and literature at Princeton University, and formerly a professor at Dartmouth College, died in Princeton, N. J., December 2. He was born in 1830 in Brunswick, Me., and was a graduate of Bowdoin College and of Andover Theolog- ical Seminary, and studied (1857-8) at the University of Géttingen. He revised, witb translations from later editions, Curtius’s “History of Greece ” Charles Gross, professor of history at Harvard College, died in Cambridge, Mass., December 3. He was born at Troy, N. Y., February 10, 1857. His education was at Williams College and at Géttingen. From 1884 1888 he was engaged in literary work in London; from 1888 he was con- nected with the history department at Har- vard. He was the author of “Gilda Merca- toria’’ (1883); “The Exchequer of the Jews in England in the Middle Ages’ (1887); ‘The Gild Merchant” (1890); ‘Select Cases the Coroners’ Rolls" (1896); “Bibli- ography of British Municipal History” (1897), and “Sources and Literature of Brit- ish History’’ (1900). He was the translator of the “Political History of Europe,’ by Lavisse (1891), and of Kayserling’s ‘“Chris- topher Columbus” (1893); and was a con- tributor to the Political Science Quarterly, Historical and other to from imerican Review, journals. From Paris we learn of the death of Mlle. Renée Vivien, the author of various volumes of which the earlier “Etudes et “Cendres et poussiéres,”” and “Brumes de Fjord’ were published under the name René Vivien Besides several volumes of poems, suggestive, in the main, of Baudelaire, she published a romance, “Une Femme m’'apparut,” and collections of stories. “Les Flambeaux éteints,” a final volume of verse, is announced for post- humous publication. of verse, préludes, Science. The Natural History of Igneous Rocks. By Alfred Harker, M.A., F.R.S. Fel- low of St. John's College, Lecturer in Petrology in the University of Cam- bridge. New York: The Macmillan Co, $3 net. This is a book for the trained special- ist, but It has a message for the lay- man. With unexcelled completeness and force, Mr. Harker has presented the latest ideas ag to the nature and activ- ities of the fluid material emanating [Vol. 89, No. 2319 from the earth's interior. Most of us live far from the few openings in the crust of the globe where we may look upon liquid rock. It is difficult to realize that the earth is merely the nearest of the wandering stars, a star covered with a thin film of frozen matter. Even the catastrophes of Martinique and south- ern Italy hardly suffice to drive into our consciousness the fact that we are living on a heavenly body. Mr. Harker's book helps one to secure this broad, true view of the planet. Not only in the spectacular volcanoes of the present, but yet more notably in the fashioning of ancient granite or porphyry, in the im- mense werk of the internal gases through geological time, and in the mil- ons of ancient extrusions and intru- sions of once liquid rock, the earth shows its kinship with the sun. The work is not a treatise descriptive of the many species of igneous rocks, but is chiefly devoted to the problem of their origin. Molten rock is called mag- ma. That magma which reaches the sur- face bears the familiar name lava. The author wisely points out that the mag- ma, which has been intruded into the earth's crust and crystallized there, is quantitatively much more important than all the lavas together. The surface rocks of the crust are radio-active. No one can yet say how much of the earth's internal heat is due to this subatomic en- ergy, nor to what extent the inevitable cooling of the globe by radiation is thus counterbalanced. Mr. Harker evidently believes that most of the vast heat-en- ergy represented in the igneous magmas is an inheritance from a former, hotter state of the globe. The mechanism by which molten rock ‘s transferred from the depths to levels at or near the earth’s surface is referred by the author to two contrasted kinds of crustal movement. The transfer is a hydrostatic phenomenon, the magmatic fluid being displaced when blocks of the earth’s crust are notably moved. If the movement of blocks is vertical along faults, as in the formation of many pla- teaus, the magma may be squeezed through the fault-planes, which appear on the surface as lines of fissuring. If the movement of crust blocks is due to horizontal pressure, as in most moun- tain-ranges, the magma is displaced, but as a rule can reach the surface only at scattered points. Accordingly, volcanic discharges are divided into fissure-erup- tions and central eruptions. A similar distinction is attempted among the in- trusive bodies which never reached the earth's surface. An inductive study has led Mr. Hark- er to the division of igneous rocks into two great classes, called the Atlantic and Pacific branches. They are prin- cipally contrasted by their relative con- tent of soda and potash, these alkalies being, on the average, more abundant in the Atlantic branch than in the other.
Page 27
Dec. 9, 1909 | The Nation. The two names correspond to the pre- vailing division of igneous rocks into the “alkali-group” and the “sub-alkali” or “lime-alkali” group. The new naming was proposed by Mr. Harker in 1896 to emphasize his view that “the one type is found around the Atlantic and part of the Indian Ocean and in the Polar basins, the other, generally speaking, around the Pacific.” The appropriate- ness of the names depends on a knowl- edge of rock-distribution which is as yet very meagre, and especially so regard- ing the Pacific area. As this half of the earth is explored alkaline rocks are dis- covered in many regions, such as the Hawaiian Islands, the Celebes Islands, Tahiti, Southern China, Western Mex- ico, Western British Columbfs, Aus- tralia, Tasmania, and New Zealand. On the other hand, the sub-alkaline rocks are much more abundant than the alka- line rocks in the Atlantic-Indian-Polar area itself. It appears, therefore, that the new names are not advisable substi- tutes for the older non-geographical names of these two chief classes of erup- tive rocks. The most valuable portion of the book is a clear, detailed statement as to how actual igneous rocks have been formed from molten magma. The advance of physical chemistry during the last doz- en years has made it evident to the pe- trologist that rock-magmas are _ solu- tions, and that, in general, the same laws as those controlling the crystalliza- tion of water solutions, or of alloys, have governed their solidification. This new conception of the earth-stuff is outlined by Mr. Harker with great skill. He shows some of the ways in which magmas may divide into crystal-azgre- gates and mother-liquors, thus expiain- ing, in part, the diversity of the igneous rocks. For the rest, that diversity is chiefly explained by other causes of “magmatic differentiation.” The book is weak in the discussion of the conclu- sions, reached by many working geol- ogists, that large and numerous bodies of magma have been affected funda- mentally in chemical composition through solution of solid rock-matter. Since the natural history of igneous rocks should be based on a sound and full theory of their parent magmas, this failure of treatment is in contrast with the general excellence of the book. The last chapter contains a keen ad- verse criticism of the new “Quantita- tive” classification of the igneous rocks as developed in the well-known work by Messrs. Cross, Iddings, Pirsson, and Washington. The pity of modern science is that its most exciting hunts for the truth are made in a forest of observations and ex- periments into which the average man cannot follow. Only a few investigators have the power to show their prizes to the layman and to tell him of the rules of the hunt. This Mr. Harker has not specially tried to do. His engrossing study is young and difficult. He has done petrology a great service in writing so fully and clearly, though necessarily in a technical manner. Another twenty years of work may give us a similarly able “popular” book on the origin of the igneous rocks. Meanwhile the pres- ent work may be profitably undertaken by many readers of general scientific training. They will find a new “ethics of the dust” among these rocks, which are obedient to their own great code of social laws. Nothing more strikingly reminds one that the sport and business of flying have come to stay, than the serious at- tention given to the subject, especially in Germany, by those writers whose pride it is to strike while the iron is hot. The latest book for air-travellers is Dr. Her- mann von Schrétter’s “Hygiene Aéro- nautik” (Leipzig: Grethlein), illus- trated volume, crammed with footnotes and warnings for the navigator of the This book has an appendix and a bibliog- der an clouds raphy; but the “Flugmaschinen: Theorie und Praxis’ of Georg Wellner (Vienna A. Hartleben) deserves more respectful at- tention as a scientific production. Admit- ting that the kite type of machine has thus far been most successful, Wellner prophesies a still greater success for the propeller flyer, far though it is from the market. Zeppelin’s perform- ances receive very curt review here. An- other work, more popular, perhaps, and giving in some fifteen or twenty essays a history of the conquest of the air to date is “Die Eroberung der Luft” (Stuttgart Union Deutsche Verlagsgesellschaft); with an introductory greeting reproduced from Count Zeppelin’s autograph This is an even more fully illustrated volume than the others, and the chapters are by a vari- ety of writers The enthusiasm of this volume’s tone is suggested by the fact that D 4. Stolberg’s contribution is en- titled ‘Reaching the North Pole by Means of a Balloon.” Drama. The Incomparable Siddons By Mrs. Clement Parsons. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. 3.50 net. This latest work by Mrs. Parsons ex- hibits all the characteristics that dis- tinguished her “Garrick and His Circle.” It shows minute and comprehensive knowledge of the dramatic period of which it treats, is written with enthusi- asm tempered by critical discretion, and, although somewhat over-zealous in the collection of irrelevant or insignificant detail, is full of interesting matter. Naturally, it adds but little—nothing that is important—to the stock of com- mon knowledge of the public and pri- vate life of England's most famous actress, but it presents, in orderly and ‘attractive form, the essence of the mass of contemporaneous and later theatrical Oo ad ras) literature, in which she figured so large- ly. Wherever statements of fact are concerned, reference is madé to the quot- ed authority, and the book, therefore, will not only prove a boon to the ordl- nary reader, but a valuable aid to the more deliberate student of theatrical af- fairs. It is not necessary to give a descrip- tive or critical analysis of the book. Enough to say that it throws all the known traits, professional and private, of Mrs. Siddons, into bold relief, and so recreates, as it were, an extinct per- sonality. This constitutes its salient merit and charm. It recalls the almost unanimous testimony of credible eye witnesses the regal beauty, the matchless grace and dignity, the melt- ing pathos, and the majestic passion of this queen of the tragic stage. Of her in her own to towering préeminence era all rivals of her own sex there can be no reasonable doubt. This proved by the length of her reign, the crowds she drew, the fortune she amass ed, and the effects she produced upon her audiences. Women frequently shrieked and swooned at her most mov- ing passages. Remembering the habits of the day is tempted whether there may not trace of the alcoholic in these tations. there must been some marvellously poignant notes in her emotional But was she actually incomparable? Has the divine spark vanished utterly from the Have Rachel, Kean, Ma- cready, Cushman, Ristori, Janauschek, Bernhardt, Duse, Booth, Salvini place in her sphere? Genius is rare, but it was not a monopoly of the The is that it is futile try to estimate the genius of Siddcns or of Garrick Times dards, dispositions, points of view over is one to wonder have been some manifes Doubtless have utterances. modern stage? or no Kembles truth now to stan all was, in a balance have changed. Siddons, as she probably would*not be tolerated to-day. But the lesson of her career is none the less vital. Genius as she indisputably was, it is tolerably safe to assume that her triumphs were quite as much the result of conscientious and indefatigable study as of any special inspiration or physical endowments. She did not act, as Garrick appears to have done, wholly upon impulse and instinct. And here- in, perhaps, lies the one moral af her career that is of present practical value. It must not be forgotten that, in spite of her early and brilliant provincial suc- cesses, she failed, at first, to please a London audience. It was only after a prolonged and arduous second appren- ticeship in the stock companies of pro- vincial cities—notably at Bath—that she returned with developed and matured powers, to dazzle the metropolis. For- tunately, we abundant testimony, from herself and others, concerning her methodical and intelligent habite of work; and they are significant. Her have
Page 28
5SO measured diction and broad, free, sweep- ing gesture were in accordance with the tradition then prevailing. But in her impersonations and readings she copied no one. Moreover, it was her rule to study the whole play in order to get the true perspective of the character she was to personify. This degree of artistic in- tegrity was as uncommon, probably, in the Georgian era as it is now. That she was impressionable and imaginative is fully proved by her own account of the nervous terror into which she was thrown by the murder scene in “Mac- beth”; and her declaration, several times repeated, that she suffered in her own person the woes which she simulat- ed, is worthy of careful note. She even says that she never played distressed mothers so well as when she had ma- ternal griefs of her own to express. This confession of self-identification with her parts leads to the natural inference that although supreme along certain lines she was deficient in versatility. And this suspicion is strengthened, if not wholly justified, by the fact that her Lady Macbeth (probably her greatest achievement), her Katherine, Constance, and Volumnia, the chief jewels in her dramatic crown, contain practically all the emotional ingredients of her other popular parts, such as: Belvidera, Jane Shore, Mrs. Beverley, Lady Randolph, etc. As Juliet she was only partly suc- cessful, while in Portia, Rosalind, Be- atrice, and other comedy parts, she was distinctly unsatisfactory. But in tragedy she was a superb actress and a great artist, a noble prod- uct of the stock company, the only sys- tem that ever has produced, or ever can produce, a generation of finished play- ers. And she shed lustre upon the stage by the purity and dignity of her woman- hood. Mrs. Parsons’s volume is rich in illuminative details of her private life as wife and mother, of her fortitude in affliction, and of her prevalent sanity amid all the adulation of which she was the object. It contains also much inter- esting matter concerning her immediate family, her contemporaries and descen- dants, to which only this brief reference is necessary now. In short, it is a full and good book which no student of the- atrical Iterature can afford to neglect. production of Sheldon, reper Nigger.” the latest dramatist, Edward added the is 4 pretentious, The young has the juat been to of the New Theatre sensational and insignificant In a purely theatrical sense it Is effective, of and ant'i- which tory crude piece in spite ita Improbablilities climaxes: but Mr. Sheldon, like other be- ginnere, constantly mistakes violence for strength, and platitudes for profundity. He touches on only a few points, and those the most obvious, in the vast and intri- cate subject which he has selected, and his treatment of them is not remarkable either for perception or tact. Throughout, his play is far more theatrical than human. It is founded upon the almost incredible premise The Nation. | Vol. 89, No. 2319 Pe that a Southern gentleman would put even his own illegitimate offspring, by a col- ored woman, in the place of his legitimate white heir who had died. Some such in- vention was necessary to the central scene of the play, in which the hero, now the honored Governor of his State, and noted even among his intimates for pride of race, is suddenly confronted with the fact that he has colored blood in his veins, and threatened with instant exposure if he will not veto a prohibition bill which he | has resolved to approve. This is a poignant | situation, almost worthy of tragedy, but it is reached by such transparent artifice | that it can be ranked only as an ingen- | fous and effective bit of melodrama. A | later scene, also of striking theatrical qual- | ity, in which the Governor manfully con-| fesses to his betrothed bride the bitter) truth of his origin, ends with a stroke of crude realism which is as inconsistent as | it is inartistic, and chills the hitherto) sympathetic spectator. But the whole sec- ond act is full of stirring theatrical stuff. At the last the Governor, forestalling his enemies, resolves to publish the story of his ancestry, resign from office—he has al- ready refused to marry the girl wo would have shared his degradation—and devote his future existence to the service of the col- ored race. Undoubtedly the play makes a vivid representation of deplorable facts, but the exploitation of evils is not always the best way of abating them. “The Nig- ger,”’ with its somewhat lurid treatment of) both crime and sentiment, is more likely) to provoke prejudice than to promote thought. The representation by the New Theatre Company was one of all-round | competence. Melodramatic details were es-| pecially well done. Miss Billie Burke's next appearance upon the New York stage will be in the Lyceum Theatre, in January, when she will be seen | as the heroine of “Mrs. Dot,” the comedy | by W. S. Maugham, which had a year's | run In London, when it was produced there the season before last. A special performance of “Ingomar” in the Liberty Theatre, New York city, is promised for December 31, for the benefit of the Lincoln Association. Mabel Talia- ferro will then essay the part of Parthenia for the first time, while William Farn- um will appear as the barbaric chieftain. At Drury Lane Theatre, London, a bronze medallion of Sir Henry Irving was recently unveiled, being the gift of a committee of Italian actors and actresses, of whom Tomaso Salvini was a prominent member The next play to be produced at the Vaudeville, in Paris, will be M. Bourget’s “La Barricade.” And still we hear of those endless re- hearsals of Rostand’s barnyard drama at the Porte Saint-Martin, in Paris! Lucien Guitry, it seems, was unable to wear the machine devised for his beak and comb | and head, and it all had to be redesigned; it has been decided, too, that the Dog (who is Jean Coquelin) shall walk on his hind legs. “Chantecler” presents so many dif- ficulties as a stage production that we can- not help being very skeptical as to its ul- timate value Lavedan has won another tri- the ThéAtre Francais with his His heroine is Mile. de | Henri umph at new play, “Sire.” Saint-Salbi, an old aristocrat, who, in the troublous year 1848 is still convinced that her beloved dauphin—son of Louis XVI— is still alive, and her rightful king. She had seen the prince as a child, and her longing to meet him once more is so in- tense that it threatens life and reason. So her physician and her confessor plot a kindly deception. They have discovered a Bohemian actor. wonderfully like Louis XVI, and him they secure to impersonate the missing heir. The rascal plays his part well, and the old lady is in an ecstasy of blissful adoration. But he cannot help making love to a pretty waiting maid, and this leads to his detection. Mlle. de Saint- Salbi is broken hearted over her disen- chantment, and the trickster, too, is over- whelmed with shame. But what can he do to redeem himself? At this moment all Paris is in uproar as revolutionists march to the overthrow of Louis Philippe. The ancient royalist reminds him that he at least has a king, and bids him to die in his defence. Presently she hears that he has indeed laid down his life at the foot of the throne, and thus helped to ensure the escape of the fleeing monarch. M. Hugue- net triumphed in his exquisite presentment of the mock prince, while Mme. Pierson made of the aged heroine a real and a sym- pathetic personage. Handel. By R. A. Streatfeild. York: John Lane Co. $2.50 net. Why has England never been one of the great musical countries? One of the answers most frequent'y given is that New | musical effort was paralyzed by the ex- clusive worship of Handel, which pre- vailed for several generations, the Eng- lish public having no ears for any music beside his, except Mendelssohn’s. These two men, it has been said a thousand times, had a monopoly which throttled all competition, and which it took even a giant like Wagner many years to de- stroy. Under his influence, however, and that of Beethoven (whose first ef- fective missionary was the Wagnerian, Hans Richter), Schumann, Brahms, Chopin, Liszt, Grieg, and the modern Frenchmen, a revolution was presently brought about. The new ideas proved powerful fertilizers, and there has now grown up an English school which has some presentable names. As a natural result of this reaction, Handel was dethroned. There is no doubt, says Mr. Streatfeild, that at the present time in England “Handel is un- | popular with those who are the mouth- pleces of cultivated musical opinion.” Dr. Ernest Walker, in his “History of Music in England,” talks light-heartedly about consigning him to the rubbish- heap. Nor do the many performances of “The Messiah” prove that he is still beloved by the masses. Many thousands of Englishmen attend this oratorio sim- ply as a religious exercise. If Handel were really popular, his other oratorios
Page 29
Dec. 9, 1909] The Nation. O81 —not to speak of his operas and instru- | mental works—would not be shelved so. completely as they are. Yet, in spite of the trend of modern criticism, Mr. Streatfeild looks for a return of popu- larity for this former idol, or at least of more general appreciation; and his" book is an attempt, clearly reasoned and | admirably written, to show in what way this appreciation will manifest itself. It is the inner meaning of his music that | will be sought for. Hitherto too much attention has been paid to mere ques- tions of form. The time is coming when people will grasp the truth that what a man has to say really matters, and that the way he says it is comparatively un- important; and when this point of view | is attained, our author believes there will be a reaction in favor of a man who had a great deal to say, even though the way in which he chose to say it now seems absolutely out of date. Thus far it is easy to accept Mr. Streatfeild’s thesis. Strangely enough, he does not draw the only sound con- clusion that follows from his premises. Handel’s forms are dead; they cannot be revived; and the only way to save the wheat from the chaff is to winnow it and present it in modern vessels. Rob- ert Franz and others have attempted to do this; Franz, in particular, made some of his idol’s scores palatable for mod- ern hearers, and he also selected from his obsolete works, particularly the operas (which are absaqlutely unknown to the public), a number of airs which, better than anything else ever written, prove our author’s main contention— that Handel had a great deal to say which would interest us if we knew it. Yet, instead of embracing the noble, en- thusiastic, scholarly, and judicious Franz as his strongest ally, he mentions | him only once, and then contemptuous- ly, in speaking of a certain pause in “The Messiah”: This pause Mozart filled up with mean- ingless chords, while Franz, not to be out- done in tastelessness and stupidity, actual- | ly added a passage for the clarinet, an- ticipating the vocal phrase and completely robbing it of its marvellous dignity and pathos. Apart from this blemish, the analysis | of Handel's oratorios is most commenda- ble. More interesting still is that of the obsolete operas. Mr. Streatfeild sees no reason why those who still have ears for G'uck’s operas should not appre-, ciate the beauties of Handel’s. In his own day they were extravagantly prais- ed, but their vogue was brief; a quar- ter of a century after his death they had passed almost entirely from the current repertory, and have been kept out ever since. Mr. Streatfeild not only tells about the librettos and the music of these operas, but also goes into the conditions, so different from those of our | day, under which they were performed. | He makes clear how political conditions | | Venezuela sometimes favored Handel, at other times ruined him. (An interesting book might be written on Politics and Music.) At one period his aristocratic opponents fought him by carefully choosing the evening of his oratorios for their balls and card parties, even violating the sanctity of Lent in their endeavor to crush him. His life was a succession of ups and downs, which are here narrated with the vivid interest of fiction. Nor are anecdotes scorned. One of the best is the incident at a rehearsal when a young basso blundered terribly; where- upon Handel turned on him savagely, with the words: “You scoundrel, did you not tell me you could sing at sight?” and the singer answered: “Yes, sir; and so I can, but not at first sight.” Heretofore, American composers, with the exception of MacDowell, have been scantily represented in Germany in the programmes of American vocalists, the marches of Sousa, and an occasional comic opera. Grateful, then, is the tribute paid to American music in the acceptance for production next February at the Royal Opera in Berlin, of the three-act opera, “Poia,” by Arthur Nevin. “Poia” is the legend of the Red Indian Mahomet, sent to earth by Natosi, the Sun God, and branded by him with a scar on the brow to expiate the sins of man. Pola loves Natoya, an In- dian maid, who rebuffs him of the scar, and favors the suit of Sumatsi, the Evil- loer. Nenhau, the medicine woman, tells Poia the origin of his curse, and bids him seek the Sun God and pray for its re- moval. It is a simple theme, simply told in lyrical language by Randolph Hartley. Seven’themes of Indian melody have been employed by the composer as Nevin uses seven four the of brass His opera lends eading movements. Mr. percussion instruments; Indian tamtam, a species ‘ymbal, and the xylophone tself to magnificent stage-pictures, and in such the Royal Opera Dr. Karl Muck is in charge of the orchestra, and the opera is already cast. It is tactful of the management to have placed the leading parts in the hands of the German members of the company; for the jealousy excited by he prominence attained by American sing ers like Miss Farrar, and Messrs. McC'en nan and Griswold, has reached such a pitch in Berlin that their allotment to Amer- ican singers might actually have endanger- ed the success of this the first American ypera to see the light in Europe. tympani, huge excels Music tovers—and those of this country in particular—are under obligations tuo for having given to the world the greatest of living pianists of the fair sex, Teresa Carrefio, who was the teacher of our greatest composer, Edward MacDow- ell, and who has done much to make Euro- peans admire his music. She seldom plays his second concerto anywhere without hav- ing to repeat the scherzo. She has now undertaken to do missionary work for his fourth sonata, the ‘Keltic,”” which the professional pianists have not heretofore deigned to put on their programmes. In- asmuch as not even Beethoven's sonatas were played publicly in London till two decades after his death, it may appear premature to bring forward MacDowell's greatest work; but the audience which heard Mme. Carrefio play it in Carnegie Hall last Saturday afternoon did not seem to think so. Such cordial applause as fol- lowed it is not often heard at a piano recital. In this sonata one finds the com- bination of virile energy with exquisite feminine tenderness which was a trait of Bach, Wagner, Grieg, and other European masters of the first rank; and in doing justice to both these attributes the Venez- uelan once more proclaimed her place among the leading pianists most elo- quently. Handel's oratorio, “Joseph,” will be per- formed on February 23, 1910, at Halle, the composer's native city. The date marks the hundredth anniversary of Handel's birth, and this will be the first rendition of this oratorio anywhere in Germany. The Austrian Government intendstogrant the Philharmonic Society of Vienna $600 a year. A more liberal endowment was made this orchestra not long ago by one Rudolf Putz, who left it his house, valued at $20,000. Inquiry disclosed the fact that Putz had been a Philharmonic subscriber for thirty years and that this was his way of expressing his gratitude the happy hours he had enjoyed. Twenty-two works of Richard will be produced during the season of 1910 at Munich, at the Theatre of the Princ Regent, and seven of Mozart's the Theatre of the Residence. Among the nov- elties included are Wagner's ‘‘Fairies” and Mozart's ‘Bastien and Bastienne” and “T tus.”’ The New Bach that its fifth Bach will take place June 4-7, io for Wagner at Society has announced festival, at Duisburg, inclusive Art. THE ISOLATED ART OF DESIGN. The London Trade Guilds are com- monly supposed to be addicted solely to dining and the wearing of cbsolete fin- ery.. Sometimes, however, they quit the gastronomic routine for charitable or other public purposes. For example, the Worshipful Company of Carpenters, per- ceiving certain defects in the building trade, last winter invited a number of architects and decorators to lecture on the needs of the situation. Their ad- monitions are now collected in a book called “The Arts Connected with Build- ing.” Naturally, there was considerable diversity of opinisn among these nine lecturers, a fact which lends significance to their agreement on one point— namely: that the building trades lan- guish because the designers are not practical workers, while the practical workers are incapable of design. Probably it occurs to nobody to con- sider how the bad stone work, wood work, furniture, and metal-work of to- day are created. That they are produced under factory conditions most of us vaguely know. What we do not realize is that they are commonly designed by
Page 30
O82 persons with no knowledge of the ma- terial. They are thought out not in hon- est stone, clay, wood, or metal, but in balanced curves and surfaces. Their design is not even workmanlike, but an isolated, nebulous abstraction called dec- oration. Their creators do not control materials, they simply create patterns. Good designs cannot come this way. It is actual contact with the material that gives raciness and idiom to any form of construction whether plain or dec- orated. Upon the worker the effect of academ- ically imposed design is even worse. Where proficiency requires that he should enter into the spir't of his pat- tern, he becomes at best a lifeless copy- ist and often a sullen executor of a de- sign which he knows to be unfitted for his tools and materials. Until the eigh- teenth century the artisan was largely his own designer. A carpenter, for ex- ample, not merely supplied but also in- vented the simpler forms of woodcarv- ing. The plasterer was a decorative modeller. Even the plumber adorned his pipe-head and cisterns with vigorous decoration that is now sought by the art collector. Nor was the demand on the artisan’s invention severe. Each trade had its inheritance of methods and patterns; even dies and moulds. It was the existence of this repertory that steadied the workman designer and made his humble inventions actually better than our more pretentious ef- forts. Of course, the factory destroyed utterly the traditions of the handicrafts, and since the factory has plainly come to stay, the question is how to reconcile fine designing with the hard conditions of modern manufacture. By actual reversion to handwork, something may be done. But it does not seem likely that the various crafts- men shops will be numerous or influ- ential enough to change the entire man- ufacturing situation. Evidently, too, routine factory conditions hardly per- mit of the inventive workman. One of the London lecturers tells of a work- man who managed to interest himself in the task of assembling machine-made parts into furniture. The standing or- der to the foreman was to change this man’s job whenever signs of interest ap- peared, for it was found that when he used his Intelligence he assembled few- er chairs. These things are a some- what doleful parable. Yet in the finer forms of manufacture something might be done. If our most creditable decora- tive design of a commercial sort to-day is wrought-iron work and terra-cotta, It is because the designers in these branches habitually work in the actual material. The lecturers before the Worshipful Company of Carpenters were especially anxious that reforms should begin with the architects, who were plainly re- garded as the chief obstructors of sound 2 The Nation. design. One lecturer insisted that every architect should serve a brief appren- ticeship in every art connected with building. Another suggested that by becoming moderately proficient in one craft the architect might obtain an in- sight into all. though based on British conditions, are possibly applicable here as well. The desired reform might, of course, come, theoretically at least, either through making the designer work, or encouraging the worker to design. To the former course there are serious ob- stacles. Your designer is more or less of a superior person, an incipient artist in his own eyes, and little inclined to soil his fingers. Besides, if he wanted to work, in many cases he would have to reckon with the trade unions. As an ideal, a certain amount of instruction of workmen in the art of design seems more promising. Through night-classes | and otherwrise some of the art schools already undertake this work; but, alas! too many of them practice the most at-| tenuate forms of pattern-making in vacuo. In the so-called decorative trades, there is already a nucleus of workmen who can draw a pattern or work out a| color scheme. Here might gradually re- establish itself the humane custom of apprenticeship. But here, too, the tyran- ny of the academic designer is heavy. Whenever workmen generally decide to | humanize their routine task, they will probably take steps to put the finer crafts once more on an independent | This implies the reéstablishing | basis. of the craft traditions in a form compat- | ible with modern life. With “Famous Cathedrals as Seen and Described by Great Writers” (Dodd, Mead These observations, | [Vol. 89, No. 2319 cluded. The pamphlet is No. 130 of Museum publications, Vol. VIII, No. 3, of the an- thropological series. To The Art Galleries of Europe (Bos- ton: L. C. Page & Co.) is added “The Art of the Belgian Galleries,” by Esther Sin- gleton. Like nearly all the work of that industrious writer, this is a careful com- pilation from approved sources. It affords a readable commentary for the teurist, and naturally betrays a few defects in scholar- ship. Having dug so deep among the minor painters, Miss Singleton should have men- tioned that echo of Gerard David, Adrian Ysenbrant. She appears to be unaware that the elder Joos van Cleef and the “Master of the Death of the Virgin” are presumably one and the same person. The Latin legends quoted from Jan van Eyck’s pictures lack the marks of contraction which make the text give sense. There are no Giottos at Antwerp. The lovely Madonna by Foucquet, which the Brussels gallery acquired a few years ago from the Huy- brechts Collection, is not mentioned. This confirms a suspicion that the book is based not upon a recent personal visit but upon /other books. There are forty-eight clear halftone cuts. With a somewhat more care- ful revision this ‘well-constructed book 'might be made very useful. Its blemishes are in details of a relatively unimportant | kind. “Home Decoration,” by Dorothy Tuke Priestman (The Penn Publishing Co.), will warn what it calls the “home maker” against the worst lapses in taste. It also «ives many practical suggestions for those who must furnish with limited means. Es- pecially commendable to us seems its cham- pionship of paint for furniture and wood- /work. It is the cheapest harmonizer and one of the most satisfactory. That bad | wall papers may be calcimined is news to lus, but it seems a quick and inexpensive |eounsel of despair. We cannot join the }author in urging the home maker to mould | pots and stencil her own walls. It is only | too true that “Those who have no knowledge & Co.) Miss Esther Singleton falls but one | of drawing may find some difficulty in mak- short of the second dozen in this manner of | '9& original designs.” What is written on compilation. Gautier, Hugo, de Amicis, are| the complicated subject of hangings is sen- ‘he most prominent European writers rep- | Sible, but it is surprising to find no men- resented. In general. reliance is laid upon| tion of the merits of kilims for portiéres. rather obvious English sources. Ruskin,| There are also useful hints for the utiliza- oddly enough, is not drawn on, possibly be- | tion of small spaces in city houses and cause he is less concretely descriptive than, | partments, on rug weaving, on staining say, the patient Hare. Miss Singleton, | Woodwork, and on elementary carpentry. presumably in the absence of suitable ma- | “T}uminated Manuscripts,” by John Brad- terial, does Cologne and Laon herself. This | ley, is the latest addition to the useful sort of stitchery does not lend itself to) series of Little Books on Art (McClurg). criticism, but possibly what Goethe had to} Mr. Bradley has labored valiantly with eay about Strassburg might still afford a the difficulties of his vast theme, and has tit-bit, while Viollet-le-Duc, if only for assembled skilfully a great amount of piety’s sake, should not have been ignored. jiterary and antiquarian information. This Still for those who take their reading In| p,iast of facts he carries lightly; the capsules there are few more intelligent and | book is good reading. We notice certain amiable pharmacists than Miss Singleton. ‘rather disquieting faults of omission and We have received from the Field Museum cisproportion. The supremacy of French of Natural History, Chicago, a “Catalogue illumination is fully admitted in the text, of Bronzes, etc., Reproduced from Originals | but this school is scamped as to space. in the National Museum of Naples.” This | The fine artist André Beauneveu, from list comprises 300 numbers, with full ar-| whom we have not only miniatures but chmological notes, by Prof. F. B. Tarbell | precious sketches, is not even mentioned and George A. Dorsey, curator of the de-/|in the text, though included in the list partment. It has numerous plates, and aside | of MSS. A similar silence prevails ag to from its anthropological value, will be use- | the Hesdin school and the even more im- ful to students of applied design. Everything | portant problem of the so-called Limbourg that is typical of the household utensils of | Illustrators, Mr. Bradley does not cite Pompell and its neighborhood is here in- | Durrieu’s standard editions of the famous
Page 31
Dec. 9, 1909] The N at 10 n. O83 Hours of the Duke of Berri, or yet the Eyckian miniatures at Turin, and is ob- livious of the whole Franco-Flemish con- troversy in which the late M. Bouchot played so militant a part. These may be intentional omissions. If so, they are un- fortunate ones. Into the crucial question whether the famous artists whose names are transmitted worked themselves on the vellum or merely furnished designs for artisan illuminators, Mr. Bradley does not enter, Italian titles in the bibliography are carelessly printed. Milanesi’s Sienese “Documenti” is cited, but, oddly enough, not his little treatise on Italian Miniatur- ists. Ongania’s facsimile of the Grimani Breviary should be mentioned as one of the cheapest and most accessible of color reproductions. By bringing the book up to date and adding further illustrations (there are twenty-one plates) it might be made over into a really excellent manual. Its defects are rather in minuter matters of scholarship than in judgment and taste. C. Haldane McFall’s chapters on “Beau- tiful Children Immortalized by the Mas- ters’”’ are more biographical of the painters than of the children painted; but they are written, if not exactly down to the child’s level, yet in a simple and easy vein. The full-page colored plates reproduce fifty fa- mous pictures of children and are well selected. The reproductions are general- ly good, though we notice occasionally the messiness that almost inevitably goes with this form of printing in its present state | of development; and we are repelled at times by a falseness in the color, especial- ly in some of the reds which tend to look dirty. (Dodd, Mead & Co.) The Bates & Guild Co. publishes a mono- | graph on “The Madonna,” by Philip L. Hale, with a series of photographic reproduc- tions of famous pictures. To the tiny albums of the Great Galleries Series (H. M. Caldwell & Co.) is added the Wallace collection. There are forty-five clearly printed half-tone reproductions of the most famous pictures at Hertford House with succinct explanations at the foot of, each plate. The publication and sale of illustrated postal cards has reached such astounding proportions in Germany that in favored 1o- calities the business in cards alone is often equal, for a bookseller, to his trade in books. Publishers of Prachtausgaben, or elaborate editions of the poets and masters of the brush, for which there is no long- er a paying demand, have discovered in the artistic postal a new use for their pre- cious plates, and art of the highest type is thus distributed widely at moderate cost. Now a German investigator shows that the illustrated postal is nothing very new. This Buchwurm has discovered that the Almanach de la petite Poste made the fol- lowing announcement in 1777: Printed matter in the form of cards is now in circulation which may be _ sent through the post, and which contains open and visible communications. This novelty is the invention of the printer Demaison, and caused much comment. The death of Henri de Morgan at Chateau d’Orliénas (Rhone), in the fifty-fifth year of his age, is announced. He was a recog- nized archmologist and numismatist. 'n recent years he had made far-reaching ex- eminations into the earlier history of upper Egypt. Finance. STOCK EXCHANGE AND THE OPEN- ING OF CONGRESS. On Monday, the Sixty-fifth Congress, whose deliberations during the recent extra session were restricted to the tar- iff bill, reconvened. It is an old tradi- tion of the Stock Exchange that mar- kets are likely to decline a bit when Congress assembles and to advance a bit when it adjourns. The tradition gained especial vogue in the eighties and the early nineties, when every one knew that chances favored introduction of a “silver bill,” over which a stormy controversy, with resultant uneasiness in financial circles, would presently arise. In the older days, the heat of the debate would evoke such highly reassur- ing remarks as, “What do we care for ‘abroad’?” or, “I am in favor of is- suing paper currency enough to stuff down the bondholders until they are sick.” It was little wonder that the opening of a session was a terrifying event to Wall Street. The fact that questions of regulating railway and industrial corporations were bound to come up on the calendar of Congress, has been the main cause of misgiving on the eve of recent ses- sions. Naturally, feeling of this na- ture was particularly widespread dur- ing Mr. Roosevelt’s Administration, when it was hard to say whether the ‘terror professed by great corporations with a vulnerable side to law was in- spired more by the prospect of new legislation, or by expectation of vigor- /ous denunciation in the President's mes- sage. We have a President to-day with }a less trenchant style of public speech. Nevertheless, that the same questions will play their part in the coming ses- ‘sion is a certainty, and it is legitimate to ask how Wall Street will be infiu- ,;enced thereby. On Monday, when Con- |gress assembled, prices on the Stock Exchange declined; on Tuesday they advanced, and nobody seemed able to |say whether the reconvening of Con- |gress had been an influence, or not. To what extent it will be an influence later 'on, depends in part on the character of | the new Congress, in part on the Presi- dent’s attitude, and in part on the na- |ture of the corporation situation itself. | Though elected only one year after a great financial panic, the present Con- 'gress does not represent an explosion |of general discontent. If it did, then ithe Opposition party would be in the majority—which is not the case. On the other hand, even the tariff debate has 'shown the existence of a powerful fac- |tion in the dominating party, which Is progressive in the sense of wishing to deal boldly with what it deems abuses. President Taft has already outlined his own purpose of suggesting legislation to control such railway financiering as made possible Union Pacific’s Stock Ex- change exploits under Mr. Harriman, and perhaps of outlining a proposed re- construction of the Anti-Trust law of 1890. There is left the question, whether the corporate interests do or do not need regulation and restriction of the sort proposed. If they do not, then Wall Street and the country at large would be warranted in misgiving over Con- gress. If they do, then not only every- day citizens, but the financial markets, should interest themselves in seeing the task promptly and judiciously per- formed. The fundamentally important consid- eration, so far as regards the attitude of the Stock Exchange towards Wash- ington, is that recent lawmaking has not been of a helter-skelter character, and has not been, like the numerous radical proposals of two or three dec- ades ago in currency legislation, the out- ,come of sectional jealousy, hard times, and popular discontent. The laws re- straining activities of corporations, de- bated in Congress during the past half- dozen years, have been drawn by men of thought and training. They have been subjected on the floor of Congress to thorough discussion, often on a very high plane, and have been carefully and liberally amended. This removes one of the apprehen- sions which surrounded the opening of a new session, a generation ago. There still remains, however, the dislike of great corporations to being restrained or regulated at all, and the argument is familiar that values on the Stock Ex- change are shaken because bills with that purpose have come up, or are about to come up, in Congress. On this point, there are two comments to be made. One is, that even Stock Exchange val- ues have not declined of recent years because of Congressional legislation. Their general course, during the period of such activities, has been upward, and there have been occasions—the season after the Hepburn Railway Rate Law of 1906 was passed, for instance—when a violent rise in stocks has been the im- mediate sequel. The other natural comment is, that the laws in restraint of corporations are in the main framed quite as much in the interest of investors as in the in- terest of the general public. The ad- vantages of a monopolistic combination in restraint of trade are never equitably distributed. The men in control of such an enterprise will have their pow- er increased, their tenure of office made permanent, and their private ends un- doubtedly subserved. The army of shareholders may find their dividends increased, as in the Standard Oil Com-
Page 32
584 Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits . Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 50 Wall Street, New York Letters Certificates The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 pany, or ow may find them decreased, as in the Amalgamated Copper. Chances, so far as recent experience has taught, are fairly even. But, in proportion as monopoly grows complete and capital- ization grows enormous, the sharehold- er certainly loses the power, by com- bination with his fellow-shareholders, to protect himself against incompetent management; and by no means all the new Trusts of the decade past have been competently managed. Investment brokers occasionally com- plain of great mergers of corporations, and welcome their dissolution, on the 6% Irrigation Bonds Secured by a Thousand Farms of Irrigation bonds lands—sometimes The security back is first liens on farm a thousand farms. liens are given by individual land owners in payment for water rights. They are paid in annual installments The land which secures them is generally worth four tir lien The trust« liens—given by thousand separate farms the bonds as a whole The most fe perp rhese nes the » may hold a thousand such a thousand farmers on a as security for lien are among the America And the which the lien se- land's value. The more than sufficient under farms in tual water right, cures, multiplies the fir crop is usually to pay the whole lien farms rtile fail- his large subject farmer earnings to crop controls are The ul because water and sure not the The land is supply a thousand such the safest sort \ bond isasue based on liens is. in our estimation, of security Additional Security Irrigation bonds are additionally se- cured by a first mortgage on all the prop- erty owned by the Irrigation Company. The investment in this property is often twice the bond tesue. Thus, in en ve have this ta property pledged to the all obligations to the many farm corporation and all fulfillment addition ome Irrigation bonds are issued, like ool bonds. by organized districts. Such nde form a tax lien on all the taxable ) of the community January Investments investors we have on hand 100 varietl f bonds. They include Mu- Public Utility, Water Power, and Irrigation Bonds. Please Cut out this reminder For January nicipal, Corporation ask for our tliat so you won't forget First National Bank Bidg., CHICAGO Some Irrigation bonds are issued un- der the “Carey Act,” where the State su- pervises the project. 73 Issues Sold During the past 15 years we have sold 73 separate issues of Drainage and Irri- gation bonds, all secured by farm liens. Every obligation under every bond has been promptly met. These bonds have become, with most of our customers, the most popular bonds that we handle. Now, we have first pick of these projects, because of our domi- nant place in this field. Our own engineers and attorneys in- vestigate every feature. An officer of our Company constantly resides in the irri- gated sections, watching the projects we finance. Thus, our customers secure only the very cream of Irrigation bonds. Ideal Investments Such Irrigation bonds as we handle are regarded as ideal investments. The se- curity approaches the absolute. They are serial bonds, running from two to twelve years, so one may obtain any desired maturity. The denominations are $100, $500 and $1,000, so one may in- vest either little or much. The demand for irrigated land great, and the projects so profitable, that the bonds pay six per cent. That is a higher rate than can now be obtained on any large class of equal securities. We have written a book on Irrigation bonds, based on our vast experience. Ev- ery investor, small or large, should read it. The book is free. Cut out this cou- pon, as a reminder to write for it. is so Trowlridge bNiver"Ge; First National Bank Bidg 50 Congress St., Boston vy New York Please eond our free book on Irrigation Bonds and list of other securities. Name City state Sroutridge L.NiverGe: 50 Congress St., BOSTON 111 Broadway, NEW YORK | Croiset, | 'ground that such combinations reduce the number of stocks that can be dealt in. This is an argument with some- what larger scope than the simple dis- like to curtailment of a broker’s com- missions. The more separate stocks the investor has to choose from, the better chance he will enjoy to separate the good from the bad. The greater the combination into which other corpora- tions have been merged, the less chance for selection he will have, and the great- er will be his difficulty in ascertaining the exact industrial outlook and invest- ment promise of the enterprise. This is perhaps one reason why financial markets have not looked with particu- lar dismay on conservative efforts of Congress, in the past few years, to regu- late great corporations. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Abbott, E. Women in Industry. Appleton. $2 net. Addleshaw, P. Sir Philip Sidney. nam. $3.50 net. Ash, F. A Trip to Mars. Lippincott. Baldwin, M. Muriel and Her Aunt Lu: a Tale of Paris. Lippincott. Baring-Gould, 8S. Family Names and Their Story. Lippincott. $3 net. Becker-Rhoades Elements of German. Re- vised edition. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co. Bennett, J. La Belle San Antone. Pub. Co. $1.50. Bierce, A. Write it Right: a Little Black- list of Literary Faults. Neale Pub. Co. Bingham, C. Come and Go: a Novel Book for Children. Dutton. $2. Browning, E. B. Sonnets from the Portu- guese. Illustrations by M. Armstrong Putnam. $2 net. Browning, R. Dramatis Person@ and Dra- matic Romances and Lyrics. Ill. by E. F. Brickdale. Browning, Robert. Selections from poems and plays, edited for school use by M. Reynolds. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co, Bryan, W. J. Speeches, 2 vols. Funk & Wagnalls. $2 net. Butler, E. From Sketch-Book and Diary. Macmillan. $2.50 net. Carrington, H. Eusapia Palladino and Her Phenomena. B. W. Dodge & Co. $2 net. Carus, P. Philosophy as a Science. Chi- cago: Open Court Pub. Co. [0 cents. Charles M. Sheldon Year Book, arr. and compiled by C. D. Crane. Topeka, Kan.: Crane & Co. $1. Chesterton, G. K. The Ball and the Cross. Lane Co. $1.50. Clegg’s Directory of 1910. Dodd, Mead. Cockshott, W. The Pilgrim Fathers. nam. $2.50 net. Collier, A. Clavis Universalis. intro. and notes by E. Bowman. Chicago: Open Court Pub. Co. Connor, R. The Angel and The Star; Be- yond the Marshes. Revell. 25 cents each. Connor, R. The Foreigner. G. K. Doran Co. Conway, J. P. The Question of the Hour: a Survey of the Catholic Church In the United States. McBride Co. $1.25 net. M. Aristophanes and the Political Trans. by J. Loeb. Put- Neale Booksellers. Put- Edited with Parties at Athens. Macmillan. Danny Dime’s Bank Book. Detroit: Advertising Co. Curtis | Davidson, G. Stories from the Operas. Third series. Philadelphia: Lippincott. Davis, C.G. Why Not Now? Boston: R. G. Badger. Dawson, A. J. Finn the Wolfhound. Lippin- cott. De Bunsen, Madame C. In Three Legations. Scribner. $3.50. Dykes, J. O. The Divine Worker in Cre- ation and Providence Scribner. $2.25. Echoes of Naples (Thirty Neapolitan Songs). Edited by M. Favillo. Ditson. $1.25.
Page 33
Dec. 9, 1909] Ende, A. von. New York. (German,) Lemcke & Buechner. Faulding, G. M. Old Man's Beard-—and Other Tales. Dutton. $1.50. Flick, A. C. The Rise of the Mediwval Church. Putnam. $3.50 net. Forbes, G. History of Astronomy. Putnam. 75 cents. Fouqué, De la Motte. Undine. Adapted from the German by W. L. Courtney. II. by A. Rackham. Doubleday, Page. Garnett, R. The Life of W. J. Fox. Lane Co. $5 net. George, William R. The Junior Republic Appleton. $1.50 net. Goldston, W. Tricks and Illusions for Amateurs and Professional Conjurers. Dutton. $1.50. Greely, A. W. A Handbook of Polar Dis- coveries. New edition. Boston. Little Brown & Co. $1.50 net. Hall, F. O. “Soul and Body.” Boston: Uni- versalist Pub. House. $1. Harding, S. B., and W. F. The Story of England: Elementary history. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co. Hellman, G. 8S: The Hudson and Poems. Putnam. $1.50. Irving, W. Rip Van Winkle. Decorations by R. W. Sawyer. Boston: Luce & Co Jones, J. D. The Birthday of Hope. Revell. 25 cents net. Kroeger, E. R. Hand Expansions and Con- tractions. Boston: Oliver Ditson Co $1.25. Kropotkin, P. A. lution, 1789-1793. by N. Dryhurst. Leckie, J. H. Authority in Religion. ner. $2. Le Feuvre, A. His Birthday: a Christmas Other The Great French Revo- Trans. from the French Putnam. $2.25 net. Scrib- Sketch. A. C. Armstrong & Son Lémonon, E. L’Europe et la _ Politique britannique (1882-1909). Paris: Félix Alcan. Lenétre, G. The Tribunal of The Terror: A Study of Paris in 1793-1795. From the French, by F. Lees. Lippincott. Lessing’s Minna von Barnhelm. Edited with intro. and notes by O. Heller. Chi- cago: Scott, Foresman & Co, Liber Primus Communium Naturalium Fratris Rogeri. Edited by R. Steele Frowde. Lobinger, C. S. The People’s Law. Intro- duction by G. E. Howard Macmillan. $4 net. Lowell, P. The Evolution of Worlds. Mac- millan. $2.50 net. My Life in China By YUNG WING. able price, $3.00 net. This frank autobiography chronicles an unusual life. With portrait, 273 pp. and index, 8vo. The Nation. Macaulay's Essays on Clive and Hastings. Edited for school use by A. G. Newcomer. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co. Mcklroy, R. McN. Kentucky in the Na- tion's History. Moffat, Yard. $5 net Macfarlane, P. C. The Quest of the Yellow Pearl. Revell. 25 cents net, M'Fadyen, J. E. The City with Founda- tions. A. C. Armstrong & Son. Mackay, C. D. The House of the Heart and Other Plays for Children. Holt & Co. $1.10 net. Malone, P. J. Poems. Neale Pub. Co. Manley, E. Intro. and notes to Immensee (Storm), Germelshausen (Gersticker), Der Lindenbaum (Seidel). Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co. Meade, L. T. Betty Vivian: a Story of Had do Court School. Lippincott Meredith, G. Some Early Selected by M. B. Forman. Metaphysica Fratris Rogeri Steele. Frowde Migeon, G. In Japan. Lippincott Milmine, G. Mary Baker G. Eddy. day, Page. $2 net. Moore, C. F. Moore's History of the States Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 net. Appreciaticns Scribner. $1.59 Edited by R $1.50 net Double- Myth, M. Y. T. H. An Eastern Lion in the West; FEugenius, the Star-Child Broad way Pub. Co. 75 cents each. Nagel, O. The Transportation of Gases, Li- quids, and Solids. New York: Published by the author. $2. Parker, H. Ancient Ceylon. London: Lu- zac & Co. Pasture, Mrs. H. de la. The Tyrant. Dut- ton. $1.25 net. Patterson, J. H, In the Grip of the Nyika Macmillan. $2 net Peple, E. A Night Out. Moffat, Yard Ww cents Peyton, J. H. The Americin Transporta- tion Problem. Pirscher, J. Variations on an Old Theme. Boston: R. G. Badger. 50 cents net. Poe, C. H. A Southerner in Europe. Sec- ond edition. Raleigh, N. C.: Mutual Pub. Co. $1 Pollard, P The Case Their Day in Court: of American Letters and its Causes Neale Pub. Co. $3 net. Pottier, E. Diphilos et les Modeleurs de Terres Cuites Grecques. Paris: Henri Laurens. Preble, G. H. Did Your Chill lay This? Boston: Luce & Co. Reed, M. A-Roving He Would Go Bos- ton: Sherman, French & Co. $1.25 net and America Prob- The author’s account of his early life in China, his education at Yale, where he took two first prizes in English composition and graduated in 1854 (LL.D., 1876), his return to China and adventures during the Taiping rebellion, his intimate association with the great statesmen, Tsang Kwoh Fan and Li Hung Chang, and finally his great work for the “Chinese Educational Movement” furnish highly interesting and good reading. HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, 34 W. 884 Bt NEW YORK 585 Report of the Henry Phipps Institute for the Study, Treatment, and Prevention of Tuberculosis. Feb. 1, 1907, to Feb. 1, 1908. Philadelphia. Rhodes, J. F. Historical Essays. Macmil- lan. $2.25 net. Roche, C. E. Things Seen in Holland. Dutton. 75 cents net. Sanborn, M. F. The Canvas Door. B. W. Dodge & Co. $1.50. Shakspere’s Henry the Fifth. Ed. by W. A. Neilson. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co, Shumaker, E. E. God and Man Putnam. 2 net. Speer, E. Lincoln, Lee, Grant, and Other Biographical Addresses. Neale Pub. Co, $2 net. Spyri, J. Heidl: a Tale for Children. Dut- ton. $2.50. Stalker, J. The Ethics of Jesus. A. C. Arm- strong & Son. $1.75 net. Stevens, D. K Lays of a Lazy Dog, by Teddy. Boston: Luce & Co Stokes, A., and M. Hungary Macmillan. $6 net, Stovall, G. O A Son of Carolina Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 Sutherland, W. J. The Teaching of Geogra- phy. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co. Taylor, H. A. Tales of Travel. Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 net The Marvellous Year Intro. by FE. Mark- ham. Drawings by G. Huebsch. Huebsch. 1.25 net Thorpe, FE. History of Chemistry Vol. I. Putnam. 75 cents Timothy Trim's Clock Book Detroit: Cur- tis Advertising Co Townshend, A. F A Military Consul in Turkey. Lippincott, $3.50 Tyrrell, R. Y. Essays on Greek Literature Macmillan. $1.25 net Walsh, W. S The Story of Santa Klaus, Moffat, Yard. $1.50 net Washington, B. T. The Story of the Negro. Two vols. Doubleday, Page Way, N. Mary Jane’s Pa. From the Play of the same name, by F. Ellis H. K. Fly Co Wheeler, J. C. Captain Pete of Cortesana. Dutton, $1.50 Wiley, S. K. Dante and Beatrice. Macmil- lan. $1.25 net Wilson-Carmichael, A Lotus Bud. A. C, Armstrong & Son Words and Phrases Calendar, 1909-10. St Paul, Minn.: West Pub. Co Work, E. W. The House of Chimham American Tract Society Juat Ready Abraham Lincoln The People's ! eader in the Struggle for ational Existence By GREORGE HAVEN PUTNAM, Litt.D., suthor of ‘‘Rooks and Their Makers tn the Middle Ages."’ ete With photogra cure Portrait, $1.25 net (by mail, $1.40) With the above ta included the apeech de livered by Lincoln in New York, February 2Tth, 1860: with an iniroduction by Charles (. Nott, late Chief Juatice of the Court of Claime, and annotationa by ‘udge Nott and by Cephas Brainerd of the New York Bar The volume presents the main events In the career of the people's leader, together with an analysis of the Constitutional issues which were fought out during the years of Lincoln's life Send for Deacriptive Ctroular G, P, PUTNAM’S SONS, E*YoxDon 4 NOVEL By BELLE A strong story of the confederacy, hero a true nobleman of the lost cause. JOHN ARROWSMITH—PLANTER Illustrated by WALTER BIGGS in which and charm, which is finely tempered by the dash and chivalry of the south. Through your bookseller or from the publishers. THE TORCH PRESS, CEDAR RAPIDS, IOWA. The first distinctively Confederate novel since Linceln’s Proclamation. SOUTH BUSHNELL $1.50. Mrs. Bushnell has created in her The love of a sweet girl adds romance COLUMBIA STUDIES IN HISTORY, ECONOMICS AND LAW New Volume (Vol. XXXV, No. 3) DIVORCE: A Study in Social Causation By JAMES P. LICHTENBERGER, Ph.D. Assistant Professor of Sociology, University of Pennsylvania 8vo, 230 pages, price $1.50, paper covers; or bound in cloth, $2.00. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York
Page 34
586 MESSRS, ELLIS DEALERS 1N Old and Rare Books 29 New Bond Street LONDON, ENGLAND (Established 1728) now offer for sale fine copies of the following rarities: THE SECOND WARD VI PRAYER BOOK OF ED- Whitchurche, 1552 follo, Black Letter, old calf BRANDT'’S SHIiv’ OF FOOLS, by A. Barclay 1570 Follo, merous woodcuts, ruesia CHAUCER'S WORKES, in ~_e~ by W. Bonham ii d morocco COWPER'S POEMS, 1782-5 2 vole. Svo., morocco CRASHAW'S STEPS TO THE TEMPLE, the very rare FIRST EDITION of 1646. i2m n the original sheepskin DRYDEN'S ESSAY OF DRAMATIC POE- Sit FIRseT BDITION 1668 Sm. i fine copy in green morocco . EDEN'S HISTORY OF TRAIT AYLE. iit} WEST AND EAST INDIES i sua tto moreceo . FENTON'S rRAGICALL DISC ‘OURSES FIRST SDITIOR 1507 Sm. 4to., red More . ee eee FLOKIO'S FIRSTE AND SECOND FRULITES 1578-0. 2 vols. Sm. 4to Fins EDITION OF OLIVER GOLD SMITH'S VICAR OF WAKEFIELD, printed at Salisbury, 1766 2 vols i2mo., old calf gilt HALLE'S CHRONICLE Black Letter, rusela . e* HARDING'S CHRONICLE IN METER 1543 Sm. 4to., Black Letter, morocco. HERRICK'S HESPERIDES, the rare FIR ST EDITION, 1648. Svo. in contem- porary blue morocco eeccoes HOLL INSHI D'S CHRONIC LES, the FIRST ’ hakes~eare Edition, with woodcuts, 1577 2 vols. Sm folio, morocco . £68. BOLI AND'S HHERWOLOGIA ANGLICA, the ri liewt costes of engraved English por- traits [162 Sm follo, morocco 21. BEN JONSON 3 WORKES follo, FIR EDITION, t.cle and portrait, morocco ‘ JOSSELYN'S ACCOUNT OF TWO VOY AGES ro NEW ENGLAND 1674. Sm FIRST EDITION, calf gilt LYIMNIATE'S Lge Fagg PRINCES AND PRINCESSES 4 Folleo, Black Let ter with woork — morocco MILLION S&S POEMS, the rare F/RS7T Vio wit! Marshall's portrait, Sa SV morocco o° NOVA STATUTA Lmpry nied by Richarde l'ynaon 1407) Folio, Black Letter, mo receo es . £120, PURCELI ORPHEUS BRITANNICUS r nes with Music.) Fins ey , ) i ' 1Osv.1702 calf translated with nu- mot Letter, about 1545 7 FIRST EDITION, 1550 Folio, £50. £115 1616 Sm with engraved £18 EDI 1645 . ..- £118 £7 PORMS EDITION, hh the rar j rait nas Sim. Svo., morocco . £24. BITAKESI’RARE The Second Follo, 16382 Pine copy } moreeco I1TAKESVRARI The rare with the extra Plays. 1004 vuirth } Firs £180 Third Folle, red morocco, £420 BHAKESPERANI rv } with TT mooring 1685 wriginal calf “) ; £145 FAERIE QUEEN, and other git Follo, morocco : £10 RMOOKE OF FALOON- AKT OF VENERIBE. 1611, merocce COVERDALE'S reback SPENSER'S WwW . TURRERVILLE'S nil AND NOBLE In 1 vol Sm. 4to., TURNER'S HERBAL HOMISH APOTHECARYE; AND THE GRETE HEREBALL 1551-02 4 vole in 1, follo, Black Letter, a beautiful copy in contemporary stamped calf £ VIRGIL/S BNEADOS, translated by Gawin Douglas. 1553. Sm. 4to., FIRST BDI TION, Bishop Burnet’s & Horace with thelr book- plates, calf . osee £ WITHER'S EMBL, EMES 1635 Follo, FIRST RDITION, with frontiaplece, por- trait, and engravings, rossla £25 Binck Letter; Walpole's copy, Cablegrama reapecting any of these vol- umes will receive immediate, attention. The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 The Only Up-to-Date Book on Polar Discoveries HAND-BOOK Polar Discoveries By GEN. A. W. GREELY Of the United States Army This authoritative résumé of polar explorations from the earliest voy- ages has been thoroughly revised, and includes the latest discoveries by Peary, Cook, and Shackleton. Written by one who has himself at- tained distinction as an explorer in the Far North, this handbook has long been the standard work on the subject. In this new edition there has been added an excellent colored map of the Arctic regions that gives accurate information, and there are new chapters on “The Conquest of the North Pole” and “‘The South Po- lar Quest.”” Gen. Greely considers dispassionately the claims of Peary and Cook, 326 pages, with ave and full bibliography Price 81.50 net; . a, ris 62 LITTLE, BROWN & C0., BOSTON Visitors in New York a invited to examine the resources |of our retail store. Here will be found a large stock of current and standard | weeka from American and foreign presses. Teachers or students prepar- | img for courses of reading will find an excellent choice of moderate-priced editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- logues. E. P. DUTTON & CO., 81 West 234 Street, New York. | Are You Plus or Minus ? Answer after reading the little book whose fame tis spreading like wild-fire: SELF-MEASUREMENT A Scale of Human Values, with Directions for Personal Application. By } A a DE WITT HYDE, ident of tage College. All pookstores 50c. net; by mail, Sic. B. W. . Publisher, New York. | j Do you know theBeacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 650 cents net: by mali, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. & Co., 21 Beacon St., Boston HOW TO STUDY By Prot. F. M. McMurry of Columbia University. Published Aug., 1909. 12th Thousand now printing. $1.25 met. Postpaid. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY Mr. Sherman’s Publications Songs and Sonnets By Elizabeth Colwell Hand-lettered by the author. and numbered copies. S8vo. $2. paid $2.60 Verses that are full of the joyousness of youth, the music of love, and the dignity of life. Every plece is marked with some touch of distinction that warrants its preser- vation. When Yesterday Was Young By Mildred L. McNeal-Sweeney 12mo, $1.00 net; postpaid $1.08. ‘‘In her work reside a fineness, a light- ness of soul, and a rare exquisiteness of touch that put didacticism to shame."’ Boston Tranacript. Simeon Solomon, An Appreciation By Jalia Ellsworth Ford Illustrated in tint, 4to, $3.50 net; $3.70 “A beautifully printed book print guarantees." —New York The Literary Miscellany An Illustrated Quarterly for Book-Lovers and Collectors ‘A very attractive little visitor."’ Blisa Carman. Fifty cents for the four issues for 1910. $1.00 for the issues of 1909 and the num- bers for 1010 No single copies sold and subscriptions taken, direct only, by the pub- lisher Catalogue of Firat Editions and Rare Booka just ready and sent upon request. FREDERIC FAIRCHILD SHERMAN 42 West 39th Street NEW YORK 250 signed 50 net; post- postpaid as the im- Sun he Musicians Library |: Should be in every home— OLIVER DITSON CO., Diteon Bidg., Boston, Mass. ANNE OF AVONLEA SEQUEL TO “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES.” The Nation and The Review of Reviews FOUR DOLLARS New subscribers to The Nation may obtain these two: magazines at ‘this special rate. “Regular Price Review of Reviews . $3.00 Regular Price The Nation, . .. . $3.00 SPECIAL OFFER SAVES YOU $2.00 | The Review of Reviews le asta Ty it neither Lo at bor Dr. be . Wer pene te magna | didly uetra t clear, Gnely interpreted a t . of the men aad | events of the month. Reviews of the best articies | im the other of the world are so com- prehensively done that they have given the Re- | view of Reviews fame all over the world. Each | month the Review produces the most graphic, clever and striking cartoons that have appeared ja American and foreign papers. The Nation 20 Vesey St., New York City
Page 35
Dec. 9, 1909] Art. Holy Grail from the Boston Library decora- tions makes an extremely attractive Christmas gift. The full set, 15 panels, in very attractive portfolio, brown cloth, with title stamped in gold, $5.00. Each subject also sold separately, at 50 cents. Done by photogravure process, on plate paper about 8x10 inches, size of each picture averaging 4x5 inches. Approved by Mr. Abbey himself. The Nation says, “The pictures come out well in the process, and give a good notion of the romantic charm which has at- tracted so many sightseers to the originals.” At book and art stores. He CopleyPrints are exclusive reproductions of the best American art. “They have done more, perhaps, for the spread of art in this country than the art museums,” says the Art Review. A collection of them make a little museum of American art. They Make the Best of Christmas Gilts. NEW CATALOGUE, 320 ILLUSTRA- The Nation. V A New Book by Clark E. Carr STEPHEN A. DOUGLAS His Life, Public Services, Patriotism, and Speeches By CLARK E. CARR, LL.D. Author of “The Illini,” “‘My Day and Generation,” “Lincoln at Gettysburg,”’ etc. In his Preface Colonel Carr says: 66 HILE the author was and still is a Republican in politics, identified with the party that was indirect antagonism with Senator Douglas and his later policies, he became satisfied that but scant justice had been done to the Senator—that his nobility and purity of character, sublime patriotism, and tran scendent abilities have not been appreciated as they deserve to be. “Those who remember the potentiality of Senator Douglas, and who have a proper conception of his char acter and = statesmanship, are rapidly passing away. secause of this the publishers wished to have one whose memory went back to those ante-bellum times, and who knew both Lincoln and Douglas, to give some of his rec TIONS (practically a handbook of wit . . iTrino events i thic ’y acte ’ American Art) SENT FOR 35 CENTS: ollections of the stirring events in which they acted, and stamps accepted. This cost deducted so the author has consented to carry into execution the from purchase of the Prints them- work he has long contemplated.” selves, which range in price from 50 cents to $20,00. Special large sizes Illustrated. Net $2.00 for school decoration. At art stores, or sent on approval. m4 Family Portraits done on private A. C. McCLURG & CO., Publish: ES, io. sore ee EE mw Tome CERCAGO ci saan CURTIS @ CAMERON 8 Pierce Building, Opp. Public Library, Boston | THE GREAT WALL OF CHINA By WILLIAM EDGAR GEIL, F.R.G.S8., author of ‘‘A Yankee on the Yangtse,’’ ete This fascinating account of the author's 19004 mile journey along the Great Wall, from . . ° the Yellow Sea to Tibet, tells of the building of this stupendous and ancient fortification, of edici Series its purpose, of its architectural features, of the strange peoples about It. BKeguiling as a travel-narrative, it has a special interest to students of history, art, and = science ( 8 ve Cloth. 100 full-page illustrations. $5.00 net.) TENNYSON’S IN MEMORIAM OF 41 COLORED REPRODUCTIONS ) AFTER THE Illustrated and decorated by CLARA M. BURD Small jto. Cloth, bowed 12 full-page plates, and decorative borders $2.00 net. Edition de Luxe limited to 76 copies printed on Ruisdale hand-made paper, with Ulustrations on Japanese vellum Bound in full vellum, Iimp ribbon ties. Missal style. $12.50 net An appropriate gift for the year of Tennyson's cen tenary. BOSWELL’S LIFE OF SAMUEL JOHNSON This bi-centenary edition of one of the most popular books In the world has 600 tilluatra tions and on this score is unique. (2 vols. Small jto. Old Style boards. 86.00 nei.) INNS, ALES AND DRINKING CUSTOMS OF OLD ENGLAND By FREDERICK HACKWOOD. This fully-illustrated book makes a chapter in the social history of England A store- house of information on ail that touches it« subject, it t* entertainingly set with anecdotes and old drinking catches. (Demy vo. Cloth. 82.50 net.) |STURGIS & WALTON CO., 31-33 East 27th St., New York | FOSTER BROTHERS BOOKS—All out of print books suppited, ne MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) | ns:ter on what subject; write me, stating beoks A series of reproductions by pho- tography printed in color, Endorsed by the art critics everywhere—and enjoying the patronage of the Muse- am of Fine Arts Boston, the Boston Public Library, and many of the Universities, Colleges, and Libraries throughout the United States and Europe. Illustrated Prospectus on request 4 Park Square, Boston bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call and inspect my stock of werd onanaagind MARX’S CAPITAL, >’, rola ba.08 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, CHATTO & WINDUS'S MEDIC! PRINTS OHARLES H. KERR & COMPANY | Joba Bright St., Birmingham, England.
Page 36
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2319 THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO.’S BOOKS SECOND EDITION BEFORE PUBLICATION RETROSPECTIONS OF AN ACTIVE LIFE By JOHN BIGELOW ‘From the historian’s standpoint, the most important book of the year.”—Chicago Record-Herald. “These most interesting and historically valuable volumes.”—New York Tribune. ile tells a story that is of exceptional interest, even in these days of a surplus of personal reminiscence.”—Boston Ty isc? pt [he intrinsic value of the matter adduced outweighs all secondary considerations."—New York Times. “Mr. Bigelow’s work is remarkable throughout for its clarity, orderliness and definiteness of treatment.”—Review j k Ws 8vo. 6x9} inches. Three volumes, boxed, each 600 pages, 48 illustrations, map, appendix, etc. Per set, net, $12.00—carriage extra. THE WISTFUL YEARS LONGFELLOW’S COUNTRY By ROY ROLFE GILSON, author of “Katrina” By HELEN A. CLARKE York Tins most dainty and tender of idyls.’’ — New A sympathetic account of the scenes of Long- LY at. j fellow’s poems. A delightful gift book. 31 full- Illustrated In two tints by F, Graham Cootes. page illustrations. Boxed. Net, $2.50; postage, 1.50; postage, 13 cents extra. 20 cents extra. THE GARDEN IN THE WILDERNESS Similar Gift Books by the same Author. \ record of the garden which an artist and his BROWNING’S ITALY wife made out of a wilderness up the Hudson. 21 illustraticns. Boxed. Net, $2.00 “Bentley,” the artist, has illustrated the text with fifty line drawings, sixteen photographs, and end BROWNING S ENGLAND papers. Net, $1.50; postage, 14 cents extra. 20 illustrations. Boxed. Net, $2.00 A HISTORY OF ARCHITECTURE. Vol. IL. By RUSSELL STURGIS [he second volume in the most important general history of architecture published. Half morocco, net, $7.50. Cloth, net, $5.00. Imperial 8vo. 7}$x1o inches. 350 illustrations. THE CHILD’S GUIDE SERIES A CHILD'S GUIDE TO AMERICAN HISTORY. By Henry W. Exson. \ most readable story of the events of our national life, told by the author of Elson’s American History. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO READING. By Joun Macy. \n illuminating introduction to the world’s great books by a recent Associate Editor of The Youth's Companion. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO MUSIC. By Danret Grecory Mason. Mr. Mason is a composer, critic, and teacher of music, grandson of Lowell Mason, and an authority in the field. Author of “The Appreciation of Music,” etc. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO MYTHOLOGY. By Heen A. Crarxe, author of “Longfellow’s Country,” ‘Browning's Italy,” et A CHILD’S GUIDE TO PICTURES. By Cuaaces H. Carrry, author of “The Appreciation of the Drama,” etc. A CHILD’S GUIDE TO BIOGRAPHY. By Burron E. Stevenson, author and librarian. An inspiring book of American character and achievement. Cloth, r2mo, with many pictures, each $1.25 net. Postage, 12 cents extra. THE MODERN SPEECH NEW TESTAMENT. by R. F. Wermovurn, M.A., D.Litt. An idiomatic transla- tion into everyday English from the text of “The Resultant Greek Testament.” Cloth, net, $1.25. Limp leather, ed, net, $2.25 THE ROLFE SHAKESPEARE. In limp leather. Edited by Wm. J. Rotre, Litt.D. For twenty years the stand- ird. In point of text and notes it is unsurpassed for study or for pleasure reading. The volumes are bound in olive en limp leather, with decorated title pages in two colors. Per copy, net, 90 cents. Forty vols. Boxed, net, per t, $36.00 AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF GEN. 0.0. HOWARD. A soldier's record of faithful service in high place in peace ind war. Two vols., 8vo, 24 illustrations. $5.00 net. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., 33 East {7th St.,. NEW YORK