The Nation 1909-11-25: Vol 89 Iss 2317
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
: UNIV. or mictt, DEC @ 1909 ‘The Nation VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2317. ef THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 25, 1909. ef PRICE TEN CENTS. “company. MEW BOOKS OF UNIQUE VALUE “rcomeany “A BIG AND BRILLIANT NOVEL OF LIFE IN NEW YORK,” BY Second Large Printing. ELIZABETH ROBINS = Second Large Printing. THE FLORENTINE FRAME Her new novel, which is one of the greater fiction events of the year, deals with life in a University circle in New York City. q It is unusual in plot, with a climax of great power. A novel of the New Theatre and a very uncommon love story 12mo, $1.50, Ready Prof. ROBERT McNUTT McELROY’S Ready : »""" KENTUCKY IN THE NATIO..’S HISTORY “” Ten years of research preceded the writing of this work and explain the very large proportion of its material now first made generally available. The public and private collections of Kentucky, searched for the first time by a diligent historian not limited to the needs of a strictly state-history, proved wonderfully productive mines of invaluable fact. } Dr. McElroy frequently was able to develop considerable areas of practically virgin soil, besides adding materially to $ many historical pictures and incidents of renown; in this way, for example. he enlarges our knowledge even of the much-ecx 3 ploited Louisiana Purchase, and the foreign plots growing out of the question of the navigation of the Mississippi. which led é up to it. He furnishes new and interesting material with reference to the Aaron Burr conspiracy; the much-studied career of Henry Clay; the conquest of “the Northwest Territory” by George Rogers Clark, et The famous Kentucky Resolutions of 1798, the original text from which Calhoun and+his fellow nulliflers claimed to draw their inspiration, are carefully studied in the light of ccntemporary documents and newspapers: and a facsimile of the original, so often misquoted, is presented. In brief. this work is one of distinguished original research, of broad and de+ verspective, and of permanence Illustrated with maps and historical portraits. Svo, $5.00 net By mail $5.40 THE SURVIVAL My [en THE OF MAN shail ane al CHRISTIAN A Study in RELIGION Unrecognized AS A Human Faculty HEALING POWER By By ELMWOOD WORCESTER, D.D, Sir OLIVER LODGE 4 SAMUEL McCOMS. D . 4 .D. This is the book that has been looked for -_ ’ from Sir Oliver Lodge, on both sides of the sea, This is a new Emmanuel Movement book, for three or four years—the book that shall und it is a great deal more, also. It makes it ¢ tell the world exactly what science has disco clear in a way never before done how Christi ered and what it has not discovered in Psychi unity possesses therapeutic power in many cal Research. CUSES, Sro, $2.00 net. By mail, $2.20 L2mo, S100 net. By mail SU 10 Prof. A. LAWRENCE ROTCH’S ; } American Primitive | s:cond Printing THE CONQUEST OF THE AIR Social Service and ° Second Printing Now Ready. A brief and complete history of the . 2 Music new art of flying from its begimmings scientifically explained Art of Healing t By FREDERICK R. BURTON with many illustrations. 16mo, $1.00 net. By mail $1.16 ; ss ¥. §. G. TALLENTYRE’S THELIFE OF MIRABEAU [| "© Bictano® Canon MED The first general survey “No popular biography of Mirabeau so good as this has been Harvard University of the whole subject A written.”—New York Tribune 8vo, $3.00 net. By mail $3.25 ; book of high selentifte 1 GEORGE WHARTON EDWARDS'S \ book which stands in value, carefully studied Second Large Printing HOLLAND OF TO-DAY the very van of one of the é —_ tic : - - mi asive move ; from years of practical in “A volume touched with the true spirit of Holland New York most progressiy . i vestigation. Art values of Tribune Elaborately Illustrated in Colors, 74x10% inches Box ments of the day by aman : Indian days carefully con- ed. $6.00 net. By mail $6.46 who, more than any other, ; sidered. Large 8vo. With DR. e. Ww. SALEEBY’S has harnessed medicine b 28 Ojibway songs, words PARENTHOOD AND RACE CULTURE | #0 sia! servic : and music. The first general work on Eugenics. “As epoch-making as Dar- i 4 . ; win's first announcement to the world.”—Charleston News and $1.25 net By mail $1.35 ; $5.00 net. By mail $6.24 Courter. Svo, $2.50 net. By mail $2.75 NEW YORK | MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY -
Page 2
rk Evening P The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 18665. the + at New econd-clasa mail matte York City Poat r.] n is published and Office owned by the ae New Paul in to Canada Y st Co Oswald Garrison Villard, President Willlam J. Pattison, Treasurer; Filmer More, Editor dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in of the United States or Meaico; *% nd to foreton countr comprised in the P | Unton, £4.00 tddresaa THE NATION, Bow 794, New York Publication Office 20 Veasew Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. ivi \\ EK EDITORIAL ARTICLES The Senator and the Subsidy The Standard Oil Decision The Reforms in India lapan in Manchuria Richard Watson Gilde SPECIAL ARTICLES \ustralasian Litera New for Bibliophil: CORRESPONDENCE The Burial of Sir John Moor sum School he Bodleiatr rT) ! ling of V« Li RA ! Th \utobiography of 8 Henry Mor ton Stanley, G.C.B r? Southerner \ Novel Old R ind Silve \ f tle of Dreams Le Borders r) Short Story English The Au ooo xT iphy Studies in Mystical Religion WW main Histor il Commission Orig | Paper \ Manual of Welsh Literature Mex I rrail t Record of Thre \ n Mexico, 1904-190 r French Revolution 1 ! ad plogy [ Plants an Introduction } ily of Plant-Communiti lL) ‘ ‘ 5 } Strif Mv Al I'w Kind f Realism rhe af y of Dutch Paintine FINANCI rr Vhole W Id Ha it rus WEEK NEXT WEEK THE NATION WILL CONTAIN 499 302 503 504 505 506 507 508 509 510 10 510 516 516 517 19 Notes on Children’s Books Educational. Professeur Universite de France, ancien Directeur d’Ecole normale regoit éléves pour langue et littérature fran: caises, promenades, voyages et conver. sation. C. SCHUWER, O.L, M.H., M.M., 11 RUE LIANCOURT. PARIS, XIV. HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Everett 0. Fisk & Co., Kyeerietens. 2 A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washi 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid. Minneapotts 208 Mich. Ave.. Chicago 292 Swetiand Bid., Portland 405 Perton Bid., Denver 238 Doug!’sBid., Los A le, a A Peyton Bid., Spokane 2142 Shattuck Ave.,Berkele: to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N.Y. Just Published FARNSWORTH’S EDUCATION THROUGH MUSIC Charles Hubert Farnsworth. Adjunct Professor of Music. Teachers College, Columbia University. 81.00. Sets forth clearly methods of music teaching applicable to any system The work for each school year is sys- tematically presented. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston Hy» The New Hutson Shakespeare Professor Edward Dowden of Dublin gives an interesting and suggestive estimate Dr. Hadson’s work of He says th muprehensive and penetrating , to the ethical and the wmsthetc¢ ts of Shakespeare's work: and he en ters in a genial way into the study of character in the tragedies historical plays, comedies Few persons have done so as Hludsen to make the study of e a part of education GINN AND COMPANY ooo THE MECHANICS OF WRITING By EDWIN C. WOOLLEY, Ph.D. A new and adequate treatment of punctua- tion and paragraphing, by which mastery of fundamental principles and facility in their use may be readily secured. Cloth. 427 pages. 81.00. D. C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere, 155 vols., pocket size List prices, cloth, 35c. per vol.; limp leather, 75s. per vol (Special prices to school and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y.Crowell &Co., New York HOW TO STUDY By Prot. F. M. McMarry of Colambia University. Published Aug., 1909. 12th Thousand sow printing. $1.25 met. Postpaid. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY “THE RELIGION ive FUTURE” ELIOT, and other Onttarine Address Box 74 By CHARLES W. literature sent free on request. Barnstable, dass. The Nation. ; [Vol. 89, No. 2317 “Piques Curiosity,” suys the Literary Digest of The Journal of A Recluse (Translated from the Original French) $1.25 net. By mail $1.37 The Digest adds: “The reader will feel, however, that the Journal might never have been penned had the author thought there was a possibil- ity of its reaching the public s¢ eye. “A Most Remarkable Book,” says the Journal of Educa- tion. “There is seareely a page that has not some sen- tence that makes one pause to think.” “Since ‘Il Cuorel’ says the Living Age, “neither the English nor any European tongue has laid so important a fictitious Journal before the American reader.” The New York “The interesting story interesting life.” Sun Says: of an Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. NEW YORK Letters and Memorials Wendell Phillips Garrison Late Editor of The Nation 1865—1906 In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. Price $1.50 net, postpaid Houghton Mifflin Company BOSTON NEW YORK
Page 3
Nov. 25, 1909) : The Nation. 11 The New Serial in SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE beginning in January, 1910 Rest Harrow By Maurice Hewlett The author is one of the foremost and most widely read and admired writers of to day. his story possesses all of his fascinating qualities of poetry and romance and the interest of character revelation, together with a ae original point of view that will attract and hold the atten tion from the very beginning. It is a modern story, a view of life as the author sees it to-day, and its truth, beauty of style and fearlessness, with a characteristic note of unconventionality and humanness, will make it one of the most remarkable serials the Magazine hee ever published SCRIBNER’S MAGAZINE 1910 HEODORE ROOSEVELT’S own and exclusive account of his African Trip will continue to be a very important feature of the Magazine during a greater part of 1910. The articles already published have met every e gente m with regard to their exceptional interest and value, and the extraordinarily large editions re quired to meet the demand have had to be increased with each nb Nothing he has ever written has better revealed his own at nN tractive person ality, his remarkable faculty ior observation and appreciation of the picturesque and unusual in both humanity and nature. The Boston Transcript says “Mr. Roosevelt has a unique way of feeling as the Americar tion feel His general pathi f hought and emphasis, and even his prejudices are largely their That fact \mericat witl zest the story of his hunting in the wilds, told with tl t th that 1 itical itteral » far-reaching ences,” In the January number he will describe hunt Juja Farm: Hippo and Leopard These articles are not only fascinating narratives of adventure, they are also authoritative accounts of the natural history of many animals but little known to most readers. The illustra tions by Kermit Roosevelt and other members of the expedition are especially interesting. SUBSCRIBE NOW $5.00 PER YEAR CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153 Fifth Ave., New York
Page 4
The Nation [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’"S NEW BOOKS | RECENT ADVANCES IN PHYSICAL AND INORGANIC CHEMISTRY By A. W. STEWART, D.Sc. the University of Belfast; Organic Chemistry,” ete. WILLIAM Ramsay, K.C.B 267. $2.50 net THE RELATION OF MEDICINE TO PHILOSOPHY Lecturer in Organic Chemistry in Author of “Recent Advances in With an Introduction by Sir F.R.S. With Diagrams Svo pp. Xtv By R. O, MOON, M.A., M.D.Oxon., F.R.C.P., Physician to the National Hospital for Diseases of the Heart, etc. Crown Svo, pp. Xiv-221. $1.50 ne? \ historical review, showing how at different epochs—from early Greece to the 19th century—medicine has been bound up with the current thought of the day, and how medicine, no more than art, can work uninfluenced by its intellectual milieu.” THE COMMONWEAL: A Study of the Federal System of Political Economy af -¢-% P. HILLIER, B.A., M.D. Crown 8vo, pp. xii-162. NEW BOOK BY THE LATE REV. GEORGE TYRRELL CHRISTIANITY AT THE CROSS ROADS By the Rev. GEORGE TYRRELL Medievalism,” ete. Crown 8vo, pp Author of “Nova et Vetera,” xxii-282. $1.50 net. “The purpose of these pages is in no wise to make an apology for Christianity and Catholicism; nor yet to defend Modern from the attacks of its prejudiced enemies; nor to defend it at all: but rather to save it frem its friends—from those amiable Liberal Critics, who welcome it for pre« isely the same mistaken reasons as for which ultramontanism condemns it From the Preface. those MEMORIES OF FIFTY YEARS By Lady ST. HELIER (Mary Jeune). With 8 Illustrations, Svo, pp. vill-368. $4.20 net. Lady Jeune’s salon was a rendezvous of all that was best in English society during the last thirty years of the nineteenth century. To her house in Harley Street flocked notables in every walk of life—statesmen, politicians, men distinguished in literature, science, and art, famous generals and naval offi- cers, legal luminaries, and apostles of culture. It would prob- ably be difficult to mention a single person of distinction of either sex whe had not at some time or other been present at her receptions, sure of meeting there the most interesting “lions” of the day. Her American trip across the continent is described in two chapters of the book, and several pages are devoted to her American friends, including Theodore Roose- velt, Chief Justice Daly, John Hay, and Mark Twain. THE INDIVIDUAL AND REALITY An Essay Touching the First Principles of Metaphysics By EDWARD DOUGLAS FAWCETT. Medium 8vo, pp. xxiv-449. $4.25 net. “I hail your book as a great and powerful agency in the spreading of truth.”—Professor WILLIAM JAMES. SOUTH AFRICAN MEMORIES: Social, Warlike and Sporting From Diaries Written at the Time. SARAH WILSON. With $4.20 net. By M. EDITH DURHAM, Author of “Through the Lands of the Serb,” “The Burden of the Balkans,” etc. With 29 [Il- lustrations by the Author and a Map _ 8vo, pp. xii-352. By Lady 20 Illustrations. S8vo, pp. xii-331. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., Publishers’ - $4.00 ne é. New York The Conclusion of a Great Work A Literary History of The English People FROM THE BARLIEST TIMES TO THE CIVIL WAR. By J. J. JUSSERAND Three volumes. Vol. III. Work) (Completing the Svo, with Frontispieces. From the Renaissance to the Civil War. Rach $3.50 net. Part II. Now Ready. Previously Issued: Vol. IL. Vol. Il. From the Origins to the Renaissance From the Renaissance to the Civil War. Part I. “Mr. Jusserand’s qualifications for the task which he has undertaken are of a high order. There are few foreigners, and certainly very few Frenchmen, who have so intimate a knowl- edge of English life. Hie has already gained great distinction as an original investigator in more than one period of English literary history, and, although his point of view in the present work is unmistakably that of a Frenchman, he shows a degree of sympathetic insight which is sehiom met with in foreign crities of our literature. —DLondon Athenacum. Putnam's Magazine G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS, NEW YORK AND LONDON The Knickerbocker Press
Page 5
The Nation. NEW YORA. THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 25. 1909. The Week. The Isthmian Commission's annual re- port on the Panama Canal never lacks By of cost moved still further from the orig- inal estimate of $144,000,000? one delightful element of interest: how much has the latest estimate Progress of course, being made towards the The excavation The 1s, completion of the vast enterprise. of of may vary from year to year. millions cubic yards ad- ministrative and engineering systems may come in for frequent reorganiza- tion. But the one permanent, undeviat- ing, unfluctuating factor in the construc- tion of the canal is the rapid march of the final cost straight upwards. In 1902 the canal was to cost $144,000,000, inclu- sive of police and sanitation. In 1906 it was to cost $139,000,000, exclusive of police and sanitation, which will swell the total some seventy-five millions be- fore the end. Now Col. Goethals’s latest re_ port, for the fiscal year ending last June, forecasts a total expenditure of $375_.000,- ®. The increase js explained as due, in the first place, to an addition o: 50 per cent. to the amount of work neces- iry to be done, and of 20 per cent. to the cost of labor due to the enhanced t of living, the difficulty of attracting labor from the United States, and the introduction of the eight-hour day there is any prevailing idea that civil service reform means the keeping in office of the organization | shall find there I will give the community a new idea of civil service reform This statement by Mr. George Mce- Aneny, president-elect of the Borough of Manhattan, was, of course, not design- ed to have any bearing on matters out- side his own province, but it is never- theless peculiarly timely in connection with the crookedness in the customs service. Whenever it happens that dis- honest persons occupy places in the classified service, there arises, in cer- tain quarters, a wail about the difficulty of the heads of the offices in getting rid of undesirable employees who are pro- tected under the civil service rules. Many persons are doubtless under the impression that those rules interfere with the power of the appointing au- thority to make removals, but The only that the cause of the removal shall be and shall have a chance to protest, if he sees fit. is is that not the case. requirement stated, the person removed There is no trial, public or private; the necessity of stating a cause (in so far as that necessity exists) is intended merely as a safeguard against No wanton removals. responsible officer need have the slightest fear of a crooked em ployee protesting if removed on some such general ground as that his work is not compatible with the good of the service; he will be glad enough to let it go at that. Collector Loeb is evidently not bothered in the least with the imag inary difficulty of the civil-service rules. The real protection furnished by the rules is in doing away with arbitrary r of giving movals for the purposs places to political or personal favorites That Boston has not yet abdicat: her ancient position as a source of civi leadership in the country is attested by the inauguration of a hopeful experi ment Nominations for the approacl ing Mayoralty election will, und new city charter, be made by petition only, and party designation wil, be wholly absent from the ballot It is plain, furthermore that the people of Bosten realize that a mere change of machinery, however excellent, wiil ac complish nothing without the active and intelligent interest of the best citizens 4 committee of one hundred and fifty undertook to name a candidate upon whom the people who desire good gov- ernment might concentrate their sup port, and the sub-committee to whom the finding of the right man was uele gated included such men as Richard Ol- ney, Attorney-General and Secretary of Cleveland, and Charles 5. State under Hamlin, ex-Assistant Secretary of the The nomination of the Com- Hundred and Fifty Their Mayor is James J. Storrow, president of the member of the firm of Lee, Higginsun & Treasury. mittee of One has now been made. candidate for Boston Chamber of Commerce, a Co., long president of the School Board, and the choice is indubitably a strong The Mayoralty of a big city is a great business oftice,and we must work, one. in all our cities, toward bringine the people to demand the same kind of qualifications for that post as in the conduct of a great business In announcing his company's acquisi- tion of control of the Western Union Telegraph, the president of the Amer ican Telegraph and Telephone—the old Bell Telephone Company——-points out that “the making of one business the auxiliary of the other business would result in large economies both to the public and to the companike He in stances the joint use of certain portion of the plant, meaning not the wire but the offices and general service in the matter of charges for telephone and telegraph service, Mr. Vail is guaraed; he merely says that telephone service nas been growing cheaper, and that t egraph servic ought to reflect the bene fit of cooperation Nevertheless, thi is from the public view, a crucial point it is hardly necessary Lo ay tia in advance in telephone toll follo ing-—-even at a distance of mont ea in announcement of this | be ill received. Even more serk eting is the bearing of ual 1 rger on the question of c« titive rat for telegraphing For ny years, the Western Union has had mly two sources of competition in the field---the Postal Telegraph Company, vhich was a direct competitor a the telephone compan) vhicl is an indirect competitor to thre exten 1 high telegraph tolls or poor telegrap! service would tead to drive patror from the telegraph to both short-dl tance and long-distance telephone Ti second of these, the indirect or poten- tial competition, is extinguished by present amalgamation. The other, that of the Postal Telegraph, has been active force in compelling reasonabl rates and efficient service. It cannot be described as aitogether reassuring, d: spite the announcement of the Postal s independence, that the Postal holds a interest in the telephone What attitude $10,000,000 the Stat« take company. Federal Government will in the matter is as yet by no means certain; that, also, will probably depend upon what construction is placed on the ul- terior purposes of the merger.
Page 6
500 Labor should acknowledge that jus- tice and the law's delays are not always on the side of the capitalist plunderers. It is some time since Mr. Gompers was , the and from boycott Bucks It is preaching Stove enjoined Range Mr. prison for against the Company. some time since was sentenced to of Yet Mr. Gompers is still at liberty and is still making public his views con- Gom pers contempt court. by the latest accounts cerning Mr. Van Cleave. Our system of and trom of appeals and stays appeals appeals and writs habeas corpus upon appeals from appeals works as ef- ficiently in keeping a captain of labor out of jail as it does many a captain in the service of Mammon. Only the othe. day Mr. Gompers’s lawyers ob- tained a stay of execution until No- vember 29 in order that they might ap- ply to the United States Supreme Court a writ of certiorari to bring the case The judge yranted the stay told the lawyers that, if fo! before that tribunal. who it shall prove impossible to secure such a writ on November 29, they may ob- tain even more time. Appeal and stay, habeas corpus and certiorari—in their inextricable intertwining they are a mystery to the layman whose impious shall not be raised against the en- voice tire beautiful system, lest he, too, be found guilty of contempt of court and be sent to jail—in the year 1945. It really begins to look as if the twen tv-six victims of football who have died since the opening of the season, mostly because of mass-play, had not lost their lives altowether in vain From every side come protests and demands that either thoroughly re- The Following the action of the game shall be formed or abolished schools have taken the lead the St. Louls and Washington high schools, it is probable that the game will New York revised city The be prohibited in the choola unless radically School, one of the large berkeley vate institutions of this city, has dis- banded its team in response to protests from parents. The annual game bet ween Montclalr Academy and the High when one team was already on the field, the Montclair School was cancelled for the reason that a number of mothers preferred their sons alive to their sons dead. And the colleges are also stirring. Those of the Middle West have instruct- ed their delegate to the Rules Commit- The Nation. tee to deliver an ultimatum, if they are to continue to play the game. This in- deed assures But revision alone will not suffice; if there is to be football, it must be reconstituted. revision. All this is in striking contrast to the which has marked previous ef- When the Nation first attacked mass-play some fif- apathy forts to reform the game. teen years ago, it was difficult to rouse Yet of those days was abolished, interest. the revolving mass-play and some three years ago the play was opened up by requiring a ten-yards gain, instead of five. For a time it appeared as if this change, reluctantly wrung from the Rules Committee, had, together with the onside kick and forward pass, opened up the game sufficiently. But this season has witnessed a further reliance upon mass-play. The Harvard team on Satur- day was well trained only in the “old- fashioned” game. It gained its ground by the deadly plunge into the line, the effect of which was shown in the very rush; it “knocked out” Lilley, the Yale tackle. The Yale would open up for the game’s sake proved first veteran expectation that the team the game groundless. It was as if, in this last im- portant contest of the season, both teams proving how impossi- were bent ble upon the present game is. The award of the Copley medal of the Royal Society to Dr. George W. Hill of West Nyack, N. Y., American that is not likely to get the The Copley medal is the highest distinction is an honor to an public attention which it merits. conferred by the Royal Society, and it is matter for national gratification that this honor at the hands of the oldest and one of the greatest of scientific so- cleties should have been bestowed upon And, while it may be in- vidious to make distinctions amony dif- yet a an American. ferent departments of research, certain primacy belongs to that domain which is at once the most ancient field of scientific inquiry and demands for its exploration the of the most abstract and most highly develop- all resources ed of sciences. Dr. Hill's work in ce- lestial mechanics places him not only foremost among the mathematica) astronomers of to-day, but marks him out as one of the extremely few men the of great results em- time Laplace, have the who, since earried forward [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 bodied in the “Mécanique céleste.” His honor is a refreshing change from the wearisome process of round-robin de- grees for college presidents. In reading such a report as that of the new anesthetic which enables a man to undergo an extensive surgical operation without pain and without loss of consciousness, one is impressed again with that steady, definite, and impcsing progress of physical science which has been held by some eminent scientific men to constitute the most significant difference between scientific knowledge and the sort of thing that has been re- cently claiming widespread attention under the name of psychical research. The argument is not conclusive, but it is worthy of attention. Here we have been, for fifty years and more, confront- ed with alleged phenomena of tabie-tip- ping, slate-writing, and the rest. Thou- sands of laymen, and not a few men of scientific ability and ingenuity, been interested in them. If they genuine, they open up to the imagina- tion boundless possibilities of develop- ment; and yet they are still at the stage of simply demanding to be recognized as true. Of course, it won't do to lay down laws to the powers of nature, still have are less to powers outside of what we com- monly call nature; yet one cannot but feel that if these things had really been there should by this time have been in the results brought out, at least faintly comparable with the advances that have followed upon every new cpeniog in the field of true, some advance electricity, chemistry, or bacteriol- ogy. or The Christian Science machine at Bos- ton functions with less ease than effi- ciency. It is a triumph for centralized authority that Mrs. Stetson should have found the backing of her own congre- gation, New York’s oldest and wealth- iest Christian Science congregation, avail her nothing. She is now outside the pale of the church and among the fallen angels. But it should be noted that, to bring this about, the guardians of the creed at Boston had to play their highest trump card. Mrs. Eddy herself had to break a silence and seclusion so profound as to have raised doubts whe- ther she was alive at all, and chasten the sinner into submission by direct re- proof. The culprit submits; it could not
Page 7
Nov. 25, 1909] be otherwise with Christian Scientists, while yet the founder of the faith is among them. It must be different in the future, when out-of-town congrega- tions are pretty sure to rebel against the rule of the Boston Camarilla. There will probably be an Eddy testament in be settled. But very few prophets have been suc- which the succession will cessful in warding off schism after they are gone. Last Monday’s debate in the House of Lords, with the significant declaration by the Lord Chancellor, made it clear that the turn on much more than the budget. coming general election will The Liberals will go to the country for a warrant not merely to pass the pres- ent budget without interference by the Lords, but to pass all budgets and all important legislation without it. The result of the Constitutional struggle, if the Conservatives lose in the appeal to the electors, will be to strike at the veto power of the Lords in general, and tc¢ make it nearly as inoperative as that of the King has become. This question Lib- eral statesmen have long desired to find a way of bringing directly before the people. Gladstone would have eagerly made it the issue in 1893, after the re- jection of the second Home Rule Bill, if he had not been so stricken in years. Even Lord Rosebery talked then of eith- er mending or ending the House of Lords. Sir Henry Campbell-Bannerman’s proposals, two years ago, to deprive the Lords of the right to veto a bill passed a second time by the House of Com- mons, were an indication of this per- sistent search for ground upon which to make a fight against the Lords. The Liberals have been steadily looking for a good occasion. Some thought they would find it in the rejection of the Edu- cation Bill, but they did not then ven- ture it. So with the killing of the Li- censing Bill by the Lords, and the bill for the abolition of plural voting many Libera's said, “Now is our chance!” but the leaders held back. To- day, however, the Lords are themselves furnishing the opportunity which the Liberals have so long sought in vain. The bringing about of so acuie a crisis, involving such immense conse- quences, is a great surprise. It does not look like the Especially does it appear as if English way of doing things. The Nation. the Lords had walked into a net openly spread in the sight of the bird. Why should the Conservatives do what their enemies were devoutly praying that they would do? We admit sincerity on the part of many of the members of the House of Lords. Lloyd-George has fright- ened them. They honestly think that they are facing the first onset of a de- termined Socia'ist movement. Knowing the great risks which they take in re- sisting, they yet resolve to resist. But this is only a part of the story. Selfish interests are at work. Sinister means are employed. There is, first, the influ ence of the manufacturers who have been induced by Joseph Chamberlain and his agents to supply funds to finance the campaign for protective taxes. We have heard it credibly stated that they have already contributed as much as $5,000,000. And they are getting impa tient to have something to show for their money. They are betraying some thing of the haughtiness of our own pro- tected manufacturers in demanding that legislation which they had bought and paid for should at once be enacted. Moreover, there are the brewers and keepers of public houses. They have peen faithful allies of the Conservatives. There was too much truth in the asser- tion that the latter won the election of 1900 on the issue of “Beer and the Bible.’ the budget because it contains licensing The “trade” is strongly against clauses and liquor taxes most obnoxious to it. In one way or another, Balfour's hand has been forced, and he has been compelled to go reiuctantly with his party into a fight which he would have avoided upon an issue which he would have evaded. The French Oficiel has recently pub lished statistics which must be depress ing reading for all Gauls who believe that a nation’s greatness depends on its size. The number of births during the first half of the present year is shown to be smaller by twelve thousand seven hundred than those for the correspond- ing period of 1908. At the same time, have twenty-five deaths increased by thousand. From these figures, ceitain American newspapers have already drawn their usual conclusions as to the terrible decadence of France. That the situation is, from the standpoint of the French there is no use in denying militarist, highly perturbing, Yet what HO1 if the French plight of to-day is also our own dilemma of to-morrow? At Ithaca, Professor Wilcox of Cornell Uni versity states that “the decline of the birth-rate in the United States has prob ably been as rapid as in any country of Europe, and if it should continue un checked for a century and a half, at the end of that time no births would take place.” No one quite expects this la consummation—so soon, at least-—but it is quite evident that the decrease is on: which should set to thinking thos» of us who cherish illusions, if they are il lusions, as to the virility of our “Ameri can” stock. Figures from Harvard Col lege, cited by the Cornell statistician, indicate that for each hundred gradu ates there are in the next generatio1 only seventy-three sons. This is a thin crop for Theodore Roosevelt's college and we may now look for a revivul of the ex-President’s “race-suicide” preach ments from almost any quarte The extraordinary series of Sovialist victories in Germany continues. Parlia- mentary and municipal elections show the same result. The tide runs much more strongly towards the Social-Dem- ocrats than any mere reference to the ordinary swing of the pendulum can ex plain. In Great Britain, it is pretty nearly the regular thing for a party to win a general election and then, trom the beginning, almost, to lose bye-elec tions. The greater its majority in the general election, the more rapid wi'l its losses be when the original enthusiasm has died out. But in the case of the German Social-Democrats, no matt«r-of- course reaction, no local conditions can explain what is taking on the propor- tions of an unheaval against the Govern- meat parties. Profound national discon tent is voicing itself in Socialist votes discontent with an Imperialism that is driven to tax the bread and lighc and air of the working masses, discontent with the traditional Government policy bloce ce of ruling with kaleidoscoplk mented, while they last, by very frank bargaining and log-rolling methods. Moreover, there is deep dissatisfaction with the so-called “Liberal” factions which, in their susceptibility to Court favor, and their exaggerated fear of So clalism, seem never to lose an opportu nity of betraying the cause of Conaetitu tionalism and anti-feudalism, for which they profess to stand.
Page 8
HO? THE SENATOR AND THE SUBSIDY. That the ship-subsidy advocates have again taken heart appears clearly from Senator Root’s speech at the New York They were defeated at the close of the last Chamber of Commerce dinner ession; but, like the boy in the adver- tisement, they can never be happy until they get a merchant fleet with the Gov- ernment as a side partner—at the ex- pense of every other American citizen, man or woman. Mr. Root’s speech was deliberately timed to affect the Cham- ber, which is to pass its judgment upon hl project within two weeks. I un- fortunately did not receive the full measure of publicity it deserved as an example of the feebleness of arguments which a bad cause can reduce even most skilled advocats In brief Mr Root's argumen was an shipping is now in an entire- artificial situation The blessings of ihe tariff have raised American wages he tandard of living so much that mpossible for Americans to com rent vit! foreigne! The latter are, 0 themselve on an artificial ! for the various nations, according herto unpublished figures reta by Root, are spending more than forty lol of dollar in ubsidie to keep hei hips going brain, brawn, and rteiti ol ie em are now abs ylutely discounted, the Senator assured his li re it has come to be merely a ques tior ho pours out the most money in ald of private enterprise; to him the nastery of the sea will go Hience, Mr ho besought his hearers, the members of » best. the wisest, the noblest, the most enterprising, the ablest, the rich hamber of Commerce, to join him in insisting that we should complete the clou ircle by extending the blessings of the protective tariff to our merchant marine. Only put that upon an artificial basie also, and our flag will be in every harbo We shall be the most ertifi- celal, and therefore, the happlest of na thor More than that, wherever ships xo they are, sald Mr. Root, the surest therefore let us pacify the harbingers of peace have American ships to world it is obvious that from any cther source-——Mr. Depew, for instance—these arguments would not merit the dignity of a reply. But Mr. Root, who has him- self opposed making a fetich of the pro-| tective system, may possibly, through The Nation. his prestige, induce some of the mem- bers of the Chamber to believe that he told the whole story and showe:! the only way to recovering our lost ship- himself witness to the incompleteness of the ping trade. Mr. Taft is a statement, for he has lately admitted frankly that subsidies mean the taking of the money of all the people from the Treasury for the benefit of a few; but justifies it by saying that this is, after all, what the tariff is doing for the protected manufacturers. If Mr. Root had a sense of humor, he must have been inwardly amused at urging the Chamber of Commerce to go after foreign trade when the very object of our protective tariff is to cut down as far as possible the number of cargoes that foreigners can ship over the seas to us. Apparently, as long as we show the flag in various harbors it matters not whether our ships of the future shall make their return voyages empty the Treasury will take care oi all that. Not one word came from Mr. Root’s lips on our abominable navigation jaws, which keep Americans from purchasing ships abroad and placing upon them the American flag. In the presence of the German Ambassador he spoke of the extraordinary prosperity of Germany's merchant marine, but naively overlook- ed the fact that German merchants, who have created their great fleet in forty years, have been free to purchase ships wherever they could get them cheapest. lle also laid himself wholly open to the retort that if ships per se are harbingers of peace, German ships are quite as much so as English, and English as American. Waiving that, Mr. Root, be- sides free ships, wholly forgot the ques- tion of free raw materials for shipbuild- ers. Yet Republican shipbuilders who have built up our navy by grace of Re- publican imperialism have solemnly tes- tified that the tariff makes a difference to them of 40 per cent. on “every con- celvable item that goes into the cost of a ship.” Here is artificiality with a vengeance. That Mr. Root argues primarily for a matl subsidy rather than a tonnage bounty, makes no difference. The prin- ciple is the same. Grant the first, and it is but the opening wedge of special privilege; there will be boomers in plenty to insist apon more artificialtty, upon the resewe of the tramp steamer [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 which, whatever its flag, is disappear- ing from the Atlantic much as has the sailing-ship. Another Senator, Mr. Bur. ton of Ohio, has denounced Mr. Rvuot’s proposed first step of rehabilitation as certain to be of no benefit to our marine interests and utterly un-American in principle. But most amazing of all is the fact that Senator Root should have urged upon shrewd business men the blunder of creating an economically wasteful business, the best argument for which is purely sentimental. Amer- ican ships everybody wants, but only if they can justify themselves on their Would Mr. Root ask New York city shippers to patronize the New own merits. York Central Railroad purely out of State pride, if it charged as high rates as the other lines and in addition «ach shipper were forced to contribute to the cost of maintaining the railway? Yet that is precisely the ship-subsidy trans- lated into land terms. Nor do ships in themselves create trade. If anybody doubts this, let him see for himself the great array of ships lying idle in Brit- ish docks because trade is so bad. ¥inal- ly, in the presence of distinguished for- eigners, Mr. Root joined the ultra-pro- tectionists in denying American capac- ity; to the Chamber which built up New York in earlier days through the enter- prise of its Peabodys, its Grinnelis, its » John Jacob Astors, its Peter Coopers, he announced the passing of all need for sea-capacity, for daring, for skill, for wetting the sails and running before gales after the fashion of those daunt- less Americans who did show our flag in every port and asked no grants trom the Treasury. THE STANDARD OIL DECISION. Careful perusal of the opinion in Sat- urday’s decision against the Standard Oil Company will, we think, convince most readers that it is not only suvund law as the statutes stand, but is con- servative interpretation of the law. The decision of the Circuit Court of Appeals is, like the Supreme Court's Northern Securities decision of 1904, levelled pri- marily against the holding-company de- vice, when employed for monopolistic purposes. This is shown alike by the reasoning of the decision and by the or- der whereby the court undertakes to remedy the situation. It ts, the court points out, the effort of every person engaged in interstate com- he ale Siluidodk acess tao ae
Page 9
™ De a ES Pee cw Nov. 25, 1909] merce “to draw to himself to the exclu- sion of others, and thereby to monop-| olize, a part of that trade”; and this is| not of itself illegal. But the oil com- bination goes further. violation of law is “the combination and The gist of its | The Nation, curities, indicated most plainly the evil against which the courts are acting, and the nature of the remedy which they are applying. It was a common crit- icism, after the Northern Securities dis- ‘solution, that since the same parties as conspiracy of the numerous defendants, | many of them formerly competitors, to restrain trade and to monopolize that) commerce,” and the achievement of such purpose through the contrivance of the holding company, without which such restraint “would not have existed and cannot continue. der, the court does not enjoin the con- stituent companies from continuing bus- iness, but decrees that the holding com- pany, the Standard Oil of New Jersey, In its concluding or- shall receive no further dividends from such companies, and exercise no fur- ther control or voting right in their af- fairs. If the Court decision, the Supreme were to uphold the natural out- come, as in the case of the Northern Se- curities, would be the return of the stock constituent in such companies to the parties entitled to it under the trust. In these conclusions, it is difficult to doubt that the Standard Oil decisicn is a logical sequel to that of the Northern The indeed, a Securities. language of the court interesting The Northern Securities decision, it wili be divided has, peculiarly bearing on the decision of 1904. recalled, was the verdict of a court. Four justices on the Supreme Bench ruled against the company and four in its favor. The deciding vote was that of Justice Brewer. He dissent- ed from the court’s opinion against the company in its larger scope, on the ground that “Congress did not in- tend by that [Anti-Trust] Act to reach and destroy those minor contracts in partial restraint of trade which the long course of decisions at common law had affirmed were reasonable.’ But he also held that “if the parties interested in these two railway companies can, through the instrumentality of a hold- ing corporation, place both under one contrel, like conceded on the argument by one of the then, in manner, as was counsel for the appellants, could the con- trol of all the railways in the country be placed in a single corporation.” On this ground, chiefly, he concurred in the decision Northern Se- against the curities. That Johnson admission by Mr. Northern Se- important counsel for the had controlled the holding company still controlled the stocks of Northern Pa- cific and Great Northern, therefor: the situation was not changed at all. Put a moment’s reflection should convince the that the been changed, and radically. situation had The hold- ing company, with the enormous facili- simplest mind ties for future acquisition provided by its machinery of exchanging stock for down, and the stock, had been struck natural order of things in the invest- ment market and among the railways had been restored. The holding company is in reality an invention of our day, and the courts have been compelled to deal with it as a new thing. Introduced ostensibly, in the excited “promotion era” of 1899 and 1901, for the purpose of restraining de- structive competition, it is still too re- cent an industrial contrivance to admit any confident prediction as to what con- ditions would ultimately be created by it. Tageanetes however, and the actual LIs- consideration of the problem, tory of some of the larger combinations, have established certain facts whica ars One is, that the far from reassuring. price of staple artic'es might, through the medium of such a holding company be advanced to extortionate heights in defiance of actual market conditions This has been proved by the history of holding the Amalgamated Copper, a company. Another is, that enormou power over industrial and financial con ditions might be exerted and permanent ly held by a very few men, controlling such a company though owning merely This was Mor- a small minority of its stock in substance admitted by Mr. J. P gan, who asserted it as a virtue in these enormous corporations that their capitalization might be made so great as to render impossible the unseating of existing managements. The formidable possibilities created by the general introduction of such in- dustrial machinery scarcely need to be pointed out. It was possible, even for economic writers, to argue that the pro- ducing costs should be greatly lowered friendly codperation of through the many allied produce rs. and that stability 5O83 of prices might be guaranteed through domination of one great corporation in a given trade. But it was also possible to picture a state of affairs, later on, in which not one industry, but all indus- tries, might be so dominated by a group of men behind the holding companies that domestic competition would be no longer an efficient safeguard, and the consumer would be absolutely at the mercy of the controlling interests. We do not believe that such a posi tion has yet been reached in any indus try. But the logic of the holding-com device unmistakably to pany pointed the possibility of such an outcome The courts, we believe, have had that their consideration always in view in application of the Anti-Trust law They the principle that combination in itsel! have, however, also kept in view is not illegal, and that the decision of the court as to its legality must depend on the nature, scope, and purpose of the power acquired through a given combin ation. The which the dard Oil Anti-Trust Act of unde! 1SuO Northern Securities and Stan decisions have been handed down, is an imperfect measure, in 80 lar as it makes in its language no ex press discrimination regarding the char acter of combinations which it pro scribes. Part of the present Adminis tration’s programme is to press for al teration or amendment of the statute on such lines. Meanwhile, however, it i clear from the language of Saturday decision that the courts are observing uch discrimination for themselve THE REFORMS IN INDIA Lord Morley has redeemed his prom ise to the people of India. The changes administra week in Indian legislation and tion which went into effect last are regarded by British opinion and b moderate opinion in decided the great mass of Hindustan as a step towards ultimate self-government A few ele mentary facts concerning the British 11 governmental system in india will make clear the nature and importance of Lord Morley’s reforms Leaving out of account the India Of fice in London, the country as a whole is ruled by a Viceroy, or Governor-Gen- eral. and a council of twenty member The press dispatches are in evident error when they speak of an increase in the Viceroy’s Council from 126 mem
Page 10
5OA bers to 370. all The Viceroy’s Council and the provincial councils together num- 140 members, and that the 126 ber only about the total to which The divided into two is probably applies Viceroy’s Council is sub- Seven members, all of whom up to last March were English- men, constitute a privy or executive council in whose hands the real powers o” government are vested. For the pur- pose of making laws and regulations, thirteen additional members, English- men and natives, are called in. In the full council the natives form one-half of the membership. But, as Indian opinion used to complain, the “making of laws and regulations” did not partake of the ‘ of real law-making or adminis- ssence tration. Government policy was shaped and Government secrets were discussed by the odd half-dozen of Ordinary Mem- bers among whom a native took his seat for tl rie first time only six months ago. For the purposes of administration India is divided into nine great prov- ces under governors, lieutenant-gov- ernors, or chief commissioners Seven of the provinces have teg'slative coun- cils made up, like the Viceroy’s Council, of Englishmen and natives, in about equal numbers. But the sharp division between Hindus and Mohammedans natives, and the natural pres- the ih ge of the ruling race, have given lish element control of the councils bons wo of the seven provinces, Madras and councils AS8 hiiombay, have small executive up exclusively of Englishmen. Vik eToy in the ; Council, the addicional members, English and native, are called regulations.” In all India to make “laws and ther words, the system over he legislative councils exist and na tives are admitted to membership, vir tually amounts to giving the natives privilege of debating and rat!fying icles and measures already decided This India pro- upon by the British administrators is the system against which tested and wh'ch Lord Morley's reforms ve profoundly modified Under the new régime, the provincial ounell enlarged, and to the non offi the “are il element, which means practically is given an absolute The native element majority in membership in'tlative itt legislation and administrative policy will still come from the Government, of course, but members have the right to bring forward “supplementary” ques- t'ons, or virtually to interpellate the The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 Government. An absolute majority in the Council, even if it were restricted to the making of “laws and regulations’ could force concessions by a policy of obstruction. But under the new régime the budget will come up for debate in the Councils. In any case, the British administrator will be driven to discard of the air of omnipotence and omniscience which Mr. Kipling so something rejoices to honor, and will have to ex- pla‘n and account, in increasing measure ay time goes on, to the representatives of the people over whom he rules. In Bombay and Madras, where the real power is vested in the inner or executive are to be eligible for council, natives membership in that body. The recon- stitution of the Viceroy’s Council, which is to number sixty members, and not 370 as reported in the daily press, is not to be put into effect for a few months. But that is because, in the case of the Vice- roy's Council, the most important step was already taken in March last, when a Bengali lawyer entered the innermost of English Member. citadel power as an Ordi- nary Undoubtedly, this entrance of natives into the executive councils constitutes the most important concession to India. It is not unfair to look upon the British rule in India as the rule of a handful of conquerors imposed on a submissive but by no means reconciled population. That is the view which British opinion and Hindu opinion of all shades openly or implicitly recognize. It is a momen- tous step, therefore, that the representa- tives of the subject populat’on shall be admitted into the innermost councils of the dominant race. Let us make the rath- e: wild assumption that the Viceroy's Ex- ecutive Council will have to take meas- ures next year against the danger of a general native uprising. Such measures will have to be discussed in the pres- ence of the Bengali member of the Gov- It well be will turn out the most But the sig- nificant thing is that the Viceroy’s Coun- Council. Sinha in the Council. ernor's Mr. loyal man may very that cil will no longer have the aspect of the general staff of an army of occupation. | It will be truly a Council for India, be-| cause India’s native sons will make | their voices heard in debate. There is little reason to doubt that the new system will work well. The aa. | mirable thing about the British char-| acter is that it loyally recognizes the! fait accompli. The London Times, which had fought concessions in India tooth and nail, is beginning to hope. “The capacity of the enlarged councils,” it says, “will be judged mainly by their methods of treatment of the budgets. If a businesslike attitude be adopted by the Indian members instead of the present practice of diffuse speechmaking, with much ill-informed criticism, the official finance of the governments may benefit by the change of procedure.” The princi- pal danger in the way at present seems to be the possibility that the Hindu majorities may swamp the Mohammedan minority and lead to racial oppression. But the Paz Britannica has grown weak indeed, if it cannot hold a reckless Hin- du majority under control. JAPAN IN MANCHURIA Our State Department's approval of the Chino-Japanese conventions con- cerning Manchuria signed on September 4,comes somewhat belated, but welcome nevertheless. We have it now authori- tatively laid down that the open door is still open, that Japan’s railway and mining concessions do not create a mo- nopoly in her favor, and that Chinese rights in the territory occupied by Ja- pan have been duly respected. Great Britain, Germany, and France, wh») pre- sumably are as interested in maintain- ing their foothold in China as we are, at once expressed their satisfaction with the agreement between China and Ja- pan. Questions which had been hang- ing in the air for years were dis- posed of, and that was an advantage for every one. We alone, in one of our sporadic awakenings tothe immense im- portance of our interests in China, began to scent a devilish game by Japan. We were going to protest, we were not go- ing to protest; we were going to send how to push American called him back before he got on board ship. Only after two and a half months of confused polemic, the State Department a man to the spot who knew commerce—-we | begs to state that there is no reason for | growing excited. The regular outcry against Japan's at- tempt to close the open door in Man- churia coincides with the regular out- ery about the decline of American trade in China. Naturally, the two must be related as cause and effect. If our imports into Manchuria go down while Japan's go up, it must be because Japan
Page 11
rg z) 4 fa & a : elite Ly BN Nov. 25, 1909] will have it so. We refuse to recognize that there can be any legitimate reasons why Japanese commerce should grow in Manchuria. Yet a moment’s candid re- flection would show that there are at least three powerful reasons. First, it is manifestly absurd to believe that such political paramountcy as Japan hoids in Manchuria does not inevitably carry with it a trade advantage. Americans, if we remember well, once had a good deal to say about trade fol- lowing the flag. Much more reasun is A good many there now for Japanese trade following the Japanese flag across scarcely a hun- dred miles of sea. Without infringing even the spirit of the international agreements concerning equal opportu- nity in China, the Japanese Government would be more than human if it di. not give its subjects broader opportunities for trade in Manchuria than the outsid- er can compass. Nor is any of the other nations in a position to throw stones. A second factor in the growth of Jap- anese commerce in the Manchurian prov- inces is the increase of the Japanese pop- ulation there. Korea has absorbed since the war possibly a half-million Japa. nese. Manchuria must have received a very large immigration. When we are told that the importation of Japanese cottons into Niuchwang has been mak- ing headway at the expense of the American product, it is well enough to remember that, other reasons aside, the Japanese immigrant is pretty sure to patronize the Japanese article. Here is a case where the Mikado’s Government might indulge in absolutely Aristidean impartiality and yet be compelled to witness a steady growth of her imports But neither the first com pare into Manchuria. nor the second reason can with the third great reason for the growth of Japanese trade—Japan's fit- ness to hold her own and more wit the other Powers in fair economic competi- tion. Again, it would be absurd to over- look Japan’s enormous advantage ir her proximity to the market, an advantage that did not count when Japan was in her industrial infancy, but one that must count tremendously when Japanese in- genuity and resourcefulness have mas- tered the processes and methods of in- dustrial success. The energies of a na- tion called forth by a successful Titanic war for self-preservation are inevitably industrial seeking an outlet in the sphere. The Nation. | What reasons exist under present con- |ditions in this country for the growth of American commerce in Manchuria? We held a predominant place in that region ten years ago, largely because of lack of competition and in spite of our bad trade there is Japanese competition to meet. notoriously methods. Now To overcome Japan’s advantage of an enormously cheaper labor market and much lower freights, what efforts have we made at home, what new resources have we brought to play on the Chi- At home the mockery of tariff-revision sends nese market? the cost of living steadily upward, and makes even the semblance of competition with Japan in the matter of labor-cost unthinkable. In China the American merchant clings to his fine antediluvian habit of carrying the stock he himself likes best, packing and labelling his wares to suit himself, and as for making himself familiar with the language and habits of his public— ridiculous! Is it not now as plain as a pikestaff that if Japanese trade in Manchuria is growing and American trade is declin- wicked who are behind it all? Hence, we have ing, it must be the Japanese piteous appeals to the State Depart- ment to keep the open door from vDeing shut on American thumbs. Then come heroic measures for stimulating Ameri- can interests with the strychnine and digitalis of railway loans forced down bottom, China’s unwilling throat. At how sincere are our great manufectur- ers in all this pother about the disap- If our tariff- one-tenth the pearing Chinese market? fed industries displayed ingenuity in China that they expend in separating the American consumer from his money, they would not be howling little while at the doors of the One fine that if the every State Department. Southern imagination has declared Chinese people would add one inch to the length of their shirts, the product of our cotton mills would be doubled. But only let our tariff barons add one cent to what the American citizen pays for his yard of cotton cloth, an | the Chinaman’'s shirt can go on lengthening till it sweeps the ground in sacerdotal folds, for all our manufacturers care. RICHARD WATSON GILDER Not often is the nation called upon to Richard been mourn a truer patriot than Watson Gilder; not often has it 5O5 better served by one whose career was that of letters. For the inspiration of ‘his pen was the desire to better not only the administration of the state, but the lot of every individual. So it has been that every civic movement of impor- tance in New York city has turned in- stinctively to Mr. Gilder for encourage- The frail, delicate physique was lashed from one ment, certain of his approval. public service to another by the same dauntless spirit which, at seventeen, had made him a cannoneer at Gettysburg amid the hardships of a campaign that overcame many a stouter body—and al- ways with a modesty so great that to far too many people the splendid charac- ter of the service rendered was quite un- known. Not, however, to those who had fol- lowed or participated in the battle fora better and worthier New York. They know that Mr. Gilder took up the cause of the poor unasked, because his heart against the conditions in lived work of the Gilder cried out which the poor and live; they know that in the Tenement House Commission he set himself a monument of which any man might be proud. To his initiattve and leadership more than to that of any man the three millions who New York's other one houses Riis live in tenement owe the reforms which, as Jacob A. has well said, “tore down a hundred ‘dens of death’ and gave the poor ten- ants’ children playgrounds where be- fore they had only the street and the gutter’; it was Richard Watson Gilder “who opened small parks and recreation piers, who compelled the building of new schools; who shaped the laws that made the tenant safe against the horrid peril of midnight fires thanks to him there were saved each year more than 12,000 infant lives. Yet great as was this civic achievement, the sum total of his many hundred others is even great- er. In campaign after campaign for city righteousness he would take assign ments to East Side meetings, cften speaking in the open fairly at the risk of his life and always with complete self-abnegation. The sam: votion to the highest kindliness and the same dé ideals, the same modesty, characterized Mr. Gil The those poems, lyrical and epigrammatic, simple der, the editor. inspiration for for which as a writer he will chiefly be remembered, came largely from his pub-
Page 12
5O6 cares of so full a life he ever neard comforting melodies and wedded his activities to rhyme. If he never reached the poetical heights, he had the rare fac- ulty of expressing popular emotion in graceful form. At dedications and other large public ceremonies his charm and tact rarely, if ever, failed him. In the volume of his collected verse, publish- ed only the other day, his poems of pa- triotism and civic duty are brought to- gether and printed in capitals to corre- spond in type to the clear-cut style of the lines—as if they were meant to be cut in stone Here, at times, he attain- ed to true gravity and force. Who now, we may ask, shall inscribe Mr. Gi:der’s own character in fit and measured verse? In his sonnet to him Mr. William Watson has just—alas! in vain—urged Mr. Gilder still to nz with note sincere And English pure as English air hath heard, ll the fops of style misuse anguage—tricking out with that no frippery needs iH | to save, while Time around him 1? glory of U Muse But the greatest usefulness of lives like this is, after all, the assurance they giv that, despite its shortcomings, in its finest citizenship America remains a land of ideals. There could be no inore fitting time than this moment of the exposure of corruption in high finance, to recall to the country where the true human values really lie. Mr. Gil- der owned no palace on Fifth Avenue; he had acquired no great means, and, in this “get-rich-quick” age, he had never taken care to cheat and bribe his way to the proud position of a multi-mil- llonaire patron of the arts and sciences It never occurred to his simple mind that greatness lay that way, that to serve one’s country one should debauch its employees, and filch from its reve nue Ile never even deemed it desir able to purchase the highest legal calent to tell him how to circumvent the laws And so he lived no life of luxury and commercial power, but a life that made him justly respected and cherished of all whose opinions were worth having. The friendship of every one bravely de- voted to higher things was his, and rarely has any single New Yorker been beloved in so many places and circles. traordinary combination of gentleness and strength—the gentleness of right- eousness, the strength of the unselfish patriot. AUSTRALASIAN LITERATURE. Sypney, November 1. The literature of Australia and New Zealand is still largely merged in tha: of their Motherland. Australian authors often send their books to be published in London, desiring a wider recognition because they believe they are making contributions to English literature, or else despairing of such a sale at the Antipodes as will make the publication lucrative. Some of these have been au- thors before they relinquished academic or other positions “at home” to come out to Australia, where they have gain ed still higher positions, and where they continue the researches that have won them repute. The writings of Professor Hearn of the University of Melbourne, belong to English literature. At first professor of classics in Queen's College, Belfast. he issued a volume on Economics, called “Plutology,” which he afterwards re- cast and republished. About 1860 he published a work of greater importance, “The Government of England.” It was remarkable, as the earliest attempt to apply the cosmic principles of Herbert Spencer to political history. At tha: date Spencer had reached only the sec- ond and still imperfect form of those expounded in It was a yroof principles about to be his “First Principles.” of Hearn’s sagacity that, even so, he grasped their philosophical significance, and successfully applied them to the elucidation of English constitutional history Does Dr. Hearn, asked at the time the skeptical Saturday Revieu, really believe that he is throwing lighi on that history by explaining it asa pro cess of evolution, engineered by those two handy demiurges, integration and differentiation? No one asks so guile- less a question now. When historians; of the old school, like the late Samuel Gardiner, were confronted in the Acav- emy (by the present writer) with the evolution of English kingship as de- scribed by Hearn, they were astonished and discomfited. Ten years after its publication the book was shown to Her bert Spencer with the remark that his name was only once mentioned in a vol- ume of which not one line could have been written as it was but for his “Es- says.” The magnanimous philosopher seemed, however, more gratified witn the application of his ideas than disap pointed with the scanty acknowledg- ment made of their source. Soon after he arrived in Australia Hearn was tempted, as C. H. Pearson the historian was tempted, by the al- [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 lurements of politics and office. Unlike Pearson, he did not resign his professor- ship; but he was elected a member of the Legislative Council (or Senate), where his conspicuous talent soon made him a leader. He took an energetic part in the hot strife that waged for years between the first and second legis- lative chambers in Victoria over ths: right of the second to amend financial bills sent up by the first. He did not, however, sacrifice literature to politics. Always a secondary mind, deriving tue generative concept of each work from some original thinker, he now assim- ilated the chief idea of his third trea- tise, “The Aryan Household,” from Fus- tel de Coulanges’s “La Cité antique.” It was a remunerative loan, and it carried Hearn into fields of speculation far be yond the range of his primary author. His view of the origin of the state, in particular, was bold and novel, and showed that, if Spencer was his phii- osophical master, he was no slavish dis ciple. For the volume abounds in orig- inalities, and it was notable for con- taining the first application of the evi- dence drawn from Indian history to de- termine the course of political evolu- tion. Hearn left behind him no pupils to carry on his work. The problems he grappled with were, however, approach- ed from another point of view by in- quirers trained in a _ very different school. A circular issued by Lewis Mor- gan, who put a number of queries to missionaries, travellers, and residents among savage peoples, fell into the hands of a missionary, Lorimer Fison, and A. W. Howitt, an Anglo-Austral- ian. They unknowingly resumed the work of Sir George Grey in West- ern Australia thirty years before, when he discovered the system of exoga- mous clan-marriage. Fison and How- itt pushed their researches further, and discovered the unbounded privileges and the stern prohibitions attached to it. The subject had its comic sides, which excited derision. The black man on his travels could have, if a crov were his totem, a thousand miles of wives belonging, say, to the kangaroo- clan. These writers also completed the solution of the problem, initiated by the discovery of exogamy, why a man could have no relations with his mother-in law, though she might be his next camp neighbor. Howitt continued his inquiries; and the results of them, stat- ed in a work on “The Native Tribes of Southeast Australia,” and in papers read before the Anthropological Insti- tute, are recognized as first-hand sources of information on some of the most dis- puted points in anthropology. In those days McLennan was still the chief authority on primitive mar- riage, and his condemnation of the first- fruits of Fison’s and Howitt’s inquir- 2 ep ig ca «sa hg ier
Page 13
eS Aa erp ons SEA to 1 sak Seng De aeletieal, oS Nov. 25, 1909] The Nation. ies, as shown in the answers to Lewis Morgan's queries, was authoritative and severe. He described them contemptu- ously as “a tangle of mystifications,” as he had previously called Morgan's con- clusions the product of delusion. When the results of the Australians’ re- searches were afterwards published in a substantial form, they still met with little apprecition save from Tylor and Andrew Lang. Two new Australian in- ‘quirers were to confirm them in a de- cisive manner. Mr. Gillen had lived for twenty years among the Arunta tribe in Central Australia. Prof. Bald- win Spencer of the University of Mel- bourne had been trained by Tylor at Oxford. Both were believed by the blacks to be initiates. When, therefore, they engaged in the Horn Expedition of 1894 and the Syme Expedition of 1902, they were unhesitatingly granted access to all tribal ceremonies. The inner life of the tribes was laid open to them. Rites that had never before been wit- nessed by white men were seen and pho tographed. They gave the first accourt of the tribes between the Macdonnell Range of Central Australia and the Gulf of Carpentaria. They observed a grad- ual change in organization and beliefs as they passed from the more primitive tribes near Lake Eyre to the more ad- vanced tribes of the Gulf, but yet estab- lished a fundamental likeness among them all. Some of the more specific conclusions are striking. They ascertained the universality o° the belief that children are not procre- ated, or, at all events, that every liv- ing member of a tribe is regarded as the incarnation of a _ spirit ancestor. They extended the area of the belief that the members of a totem-group ar? held answerable for the increase of ths animal or plant that gives its name to a group. They have discovered that there is no radical difference in social organization between the tribes where female inheritance rules and those where descent is through the male line. But perhaps the most interesting of all their researches is that which has led them to the conclusion that the classifi- catory system of relationships first de- vised by Lewis Morgan, and confirmed as regards the Australian blacks br Fison and Howitt, is inexpugnable. The two latter inquirers the authors hold to be the founders of Australian an thropology. The structure that Gillen and Spencer have reared on that base in the volumes, “The Native Tribes of Central Australia” and “The Northern Tribes of Central Australia,” is of in- estimable value and high authority. While these researches were beings pursued on the continent, parallel in- quiries were prosecuted in the adjacen: islands of New Zealand. The “Poly- nesian Mythology” of Sir George Grey (of which a second edition, unrevised, has been issued by the Government) needed to be corrected and supplement- ed. John White had lived long among the Maoris in an official capacity, knew their usages and their beliefs as no other ever did, and had embodied frag- ments of his erudition in a fictitious narrative, “Te Rou.” He was no less deeply acquainted with their legends and myths, and he was commissioned by the Government to translate his accumu- lations and to put them in literary form. After exasperating delays, there at length appeared a succession of voi- umes (“The Ancient History of the Maori”; Wellington, N. Z.), which was brought to a close, not to an end, by the editor’s sudden death. The results are valuable, but perhaps need sifting. Of portions of the first-issued volume Sir George Grey declared to the pres- ent writer that White had sometimes mistaken obscene Maori songs for theo- logical myths. But he brought togethe= a large legendary collection, drawn from many different sources and de- rived from the very lips of priests and chiefs. The pen that Death struck from the hand of White has been taken up by Johannes Carl Andersen. Of Danish birth, but of New Zealand rearing, h> has come to the primitive Maori with a mind steeped in Scandinavian lore. A poet himself, his work (“Maori Life ir Aotea”; Christchurch, N. Z.) is an at- tempt atan imaginative and sympathet- ic realization of the life the old Maori led. He is vividly portrayed in war an |i in peace, as cultivator, wood-carver, hunter, and sea-farer. He is seen, no less, in his recreations—in the ceremon- ious haka, and in the fireside recital of legends concerning fairies, demons, and gods. He is depicted as a warrior, creeping like a sleuth-hound on the track of his foe, crafty, remorseless, im- placable, and, at the orgies of the can- nibal feast, a very brute. Using White's collections, which he calls his “base- work”, and calling to his aid all appro priate contemporary research, Mr. An- dersen has produced a very interesting volume, solid in its erudition, glowing in its idealization, and strangely at- tractive by its exotic manner of dra- matic presentment. It is the worx of an ancient skald in the South Seas. Mr. Ngata, a pure-blooded chief who writes the best English, a legislator who is on his way to cabinet rank, vouches equally for the broad truth of the pic- tured scenes and the accuracy of their details. Mr. Andersen believes that the painter and the sculptor will find in Maori lore subjects for many a canvas, figure, or group; and poets will dis- cover matter enough for twenty epics. His own book is perhaps the first of those epics. Two other recent New Zealand works, both published by Whitcombe and Tombs, Christchurch, deserve to be men- SOT tioned. One of them, Earle’s “Nine Months Residence in New Zealand in 1827,” is a reprint of a book first issued in 1832, when New Zealand was a land almost unknown save to the missionary and the beach-comber. In it were first made those charges against the Angli- can missionaries, of appropriating Maori lands, which were sheeted home to them nineteen years later by Gov. Grey. In the Quarterly Review Southey (for it was evidently he) warned his readers that Earle’s “statements must be received, for the present, with any- thing but rash confidence.” The other book, “Bishop Harper and the Canter bury Settlement,” by the Rev. H. T. Purchas, instructively shows once more how large a part is still played by the priests in the infancy of a community. The venerable prelate lived to see the young “settlement” become an impor- tant province in a new federation. We may add that he was the brother of that. Jesuit father who has given a com- manding synthetic view of the Scholas- tic philosophy, which also belonged to the less advanced stages of society. J.C NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES Louis I. Haber is another of the older book-collectors who are sending their treas ures to the auction room Mr. Haber has been collecting about twenty-five years, and many of his books and manuscripts were bought at prices which will be exceeded many times over at the sale to be held by the Anderson Auction Co, in twelve session afternoons and evenings of December and 2, 7, 8, 9 and 10. Part I, to be sold next week, contains the books from A to K of the alphabet, with a selection of the important literary manuscripts Among the early English books are Gower's Confessio Amantis” (1532), Barclay’s “Ship of Fooles” (1570) Chaucer's “Workes” (th undated edition printed about 1550), John Heywood's ‘Woorkes (1577), and (1571) and Roger Ascham's “Toxophilus” “Schole Master” (1579). Among books of the Seventeenth Cen tury are Ben Jonson's “Works” (1616), Chap man’s “Whole Works of Homer” (1616) Beaumont and Fletcher's “Comedies and Tragedies (1647), Burton's “Anatomy of Melancholy” (1621), Greene's “Never Too Late to Mend” (1607). Cowley'’s “Poetical Blossoms” (1632), Phineas Fletcher's “Pur- ple Island” (1633), and Herrick’s “Hes- perides” (1648) Of modern authors there are first editions of Keats's “Poems” (1817), “Endymion” (1818), and “Lamia” (1820); and books by Mrs. Browning, Matthew Ar- nold, Dobson, Gosse, Eugene Field, and other authors, English and American Among club publications are nearly com- plete sets of the publications of the Grolier Club, the Bibliographical Society, and the Bibliophile Society, with a long series of William Loring Andrews’s books and speci- mens of the Kelmacott, Daniel, and other presses. The manuscripts in this portion include a twenty-eight-page letter of Keats; a translation in Irving’s autograph of a part of Sahagun’s “Conquest of Mexico,” 86 pages; O. W. Holmes’s “The Stereoscope and
Page 14
5OS the pages; Stereograph,” thirty-one and a Bret Harte’s “Lothaw,” thirty-nine pages; J. Fenimore Cooper's “Life of Rich- ard Dale,” sixteen pages; Conan Doyle's “The Sign of the Four,” 160 pages; and two sketches by Mark Twain, a set of autograph letters of the Presidents, and other interest- ing documents On November 30, the same auc- tioneers Frank Maler’s collection of There manuscript by Longfellow of his poem “The Children’s Hour” on four pages, quarto; a Holmes of “The Voiceless,” letters of Carlyle Hawthorne, Grant, and Tuesday, will sell miscellaneous autographs is a manuscript by quarto; and Dickens, Cooper, Wilde, one-page Gladstone, Leigh Hunt, Oscar yen others the December 3 they will sell a collection of Japanese prints, upwards of Japanese stamps and coins The Clark On evening of two hundred lots, and some Clarence H is to be dispersed Henkels, in several the first being on November’ 30, af- and evening. This library is per- notable for the extra illustrated Works of John Lothrop Motley, to twenty-seven volumes Mrs. Clark was a daughter of the historian, and on this Mr. Clark took especial in building up this set, having spent, it is said The first sale includes also the illuminated manuscripts, among being a fine Book of Hours of the teenth Century, on 186 leaves, with thirteen collection of the late of Philadelphia this season by Stan V sales ternoon haps most of the extended from nine copy and inlaid from octavo to folio. account pride $35,000 upon it them Four- full-page miniatures and twenty-four small- er ones, and an interesting Persian manu- script, being the “Shah Nameh” of Firdau- si, of sixteenth century execution There are several of the most famous books from the Elzevir Among early Americana are Bullock's “Virginia Impartially Examined” (1649) Champlain's Voyages (1632), with the large map in facsimile; Capt. John Smith's True Travels” (1630); the very rare “Breeden-Raedt aende Vereenichde Ne- derlandsche Provintien” (1649), and De- Vries's “Korte Historiael” (1655), the last two being among the earliest printed books relating to New York Many of the books are in elaborate tooled or inlaid bindings On December 1 and 2, C. F. Libble & Co in Boston, will sell the libraries of W. K Stafford of Newton, Mass., and William Par sone Lunt of Boston. The collection is chief ly notable for the books and pamphlets re lating to the Indians and for American lo cal histor: especially books on Michigan the region of the Great Lakes, and Califor nia Hawthorne firat book ‘Fanshawe, a Tal (Boston, 1828) fine copy, sold in t! firet Mater eale last week for $350, and other first editions of Hawthorne sold at r lerate prices “The Sister Years” (1839) bringing $150 ‘The Celestial Rallroad” (184 $140 and Time's Portraiture” ( ), $50 Correspondence. THE BURIAL OF SIR JOHN MOORE EpItor Tur NATION To THE oF SIR often John In been of copies, more Sir poems have “The Burial the Few than but reprinted Moore,” even no two of half The Nation. the best anthologies, agree exactly in their reading. Concerning one of these varia- tions, “sullenly,” or “suddenly,” in the sev- enth stanza, there has often been lively dis- cussion among editors and critics; some asserting that “suddenly” is the only au- | thoritative reading, others saying that Wolfe wrote “sullenly” at first, but afterward “al- tered it at the suggestion of a literary friend.” This latter statement, based upon a note from “an early friend of the author” (print- ed in the London Morning Chronicle, Octo- ber 1824), The “early friend,”” commenting on the line, “That the foe was suddenly firing,” says that it “was originally written” thus: “Of the enemy sullenly firing.” But the Rev. John A. Rus- sell, in the “Remains of the Rev. Charles Wolfe,” 1825, remarks that the line was at first written, “That the foe was sullenly firing’’—the reading in the text as he prints it. He adds: It was subsequently altered as he [the writer in the Morning Chronicle] gives it, at the suggestion of a literary friend; but) it seems proper to print it as it actually stands in the author’s own manuscript, from which I take it. There is no differ- ence in sense; but perhaps some may think the rhythm better as it was originally writ- ten, 29, is incorrect This obviously refers, not to “sullenly” (which is the same in both readings, and which tould make a serious difference in the sense), but to the words that precede “sullenly.” I cannot, however, agree with Archdeacon Russell, that the “rhythm” of “That the foe was” is possibly better than that of “Of the enemy,” which Wolfe adopt- ed when it was suggested. That “sullenly” was the original and the only reading of the poet is definitely settled by a communication I received more than ten years ago enclosing a careful copy of 1 letter from Wolfe, immediately after he completed “.e poem. I regret that I have lost or mislaid the letter accompa- pying this interesting manuscript, and can- not recall the name of the sender. The orig- inal letter of Wolfe was somewhat worn and torn, and its imperfections are minute- ly in the copy; but luckily they do the text, the only lost being “rest” and “him,” in the last two lines of the third stanza, with the last letter of “him” in the preceding line and the first letter of “Few” at the beginning of the next stanza The letter is addressed (on the same sheet containing the poem) to written indicated not obscure words ' John Taylor Esq at the Revd Mr. Clononlly Cashel Armstrong's It the portion copied does) thus: I have completed the Burial of Sir John Moore, & will here inflict it upon you; you have no one but yourself to blame, for praising the two stanzas that I told you so much fhere there Is something lost] begins (or The text of the poem follows in the spell- ing and pointing of the original. The stan- zas are numbered 1, 2, 3, ete. Not a drom was beard, not a funeral note, A4« bie corse to the rampart we hurried; Not a Soldier diecharged his farewell shot ‘her the grave where our Hero we barted. We beriked bim darkly, at dead of night, The sede with our bayonets turning; ty the’ straggling moonbeam's misty light, tnd the lanthorn dimly bua ning [Vol. 89, No. 2317 No useless coffin enclosed his breast Not In sheet or in shroud we wound [him], But h* lay like a Warrior taking his [rest], With bis martial cloak around [him]. {F jew and short were the prayers we sald And we spoke not a word of sorrow But we steadfastly gaz'’d on the face that was dead, And we bitterly thought of the morrow; We thought, as we hollow’d his narrow bed, Anl.smooth’d down his lonely pillow; That the Foe & the Stranger would tread o'er bead And we far away on the billow! Lightly they'll talk of the Spirit that’s gone, And o’er his cold ashes upbraid him But littie he'll reck, if they let him sleep om In the grave where a Briton has laid him. But half of our heavy task was done, Wher the clock struck the note for retiring, And we beard the distant & random gun That the Foe was sullenly firing Slowly & sadly we laid him down From the field of his fame fresh and gory We caiv’d not a Mine, and we rais'd not a stone But we left him alone with bis glory. The poet adds: Pray write soon—You may direct as usuab to College [Trinity College, Dublin] & it will follow me to the Country Give my love to Armstrong, & Believe me My Dear John Ever Yours Charles Wolfe. The letter is not dated, but is postmarked Sept. 6, 1816. According to the “Remains,” the poem was first printed “without the concurrence or knowledge of the author.” The editor adds: It was recited by a friend in presence of a gentleman travelling towards the north of Ireland, who was so much struck with it that he requested and obtained a copy; and immediately after [in 1817], it appeared in the Newry Telegraph, with the initials of the author’s name. From thence it was copied into most of the London prints, and thence into the Dublin papers; and sub- sequently it appeared, with some consider- able errors, in the Ediuburgh Annual Reg- ister, which contained the narrative that first kindled the poet’s feelings on the sub- ject. The biographer seems not to have known (and I do not remember to have seen any reference to the fact, which I accidentally discovered in preparing for this present writing) that the poem was printed in the first volume of Blackwood’s Magazine (June, 1817, p. 277), with “some considerable er- rors,” like “Nor in sheet nor”; “the face of the dead”; “tolled the hour”; “suddenly firing’; and the omission of “and” in the last line but one. The initials of the author are omitted (as probably in the newspaper reprints from the Newry Telegraph), and the editor appends the following footnote: This little poem first appeared in some of the newspapers a few days ago. It is too beautiful not to deserve preservation in a safer repository; and we have, accord- ingly, inserted it among our original poems, [Ep. In the “Remains” (1825), the only varia- tion from the text of the letter to John Taylor is “hour” for “note”; and the only other change made by the poet appears to have been “Of the enemy” for “That the foe was," where the archdeacon, as we have seen, preferred to retain the original reading. These two authorities—the letter wend the book—are the only trustwortay ones for the text as the poet left it at the time of his death, in February, 1823. The cor- ruptions began, as those in Rlarkwood prove, as soon as the poem was printed (probably in the Newry Telegraph, where
Page 15
eS Rie kl Oe HOT Nov. 25, 1909] the author saw no “proof” of it), and have continued and multiplied ever since. I have examined many texts, English and American, but have found none that are absolutely correct. Ward's “English Poets” (Vol. IV, p. 323) is one of the most accurate, but it retains “That the foe was,” and in the third stanza has “nor” for “or” in the second line. In Linton and Stoddard’s ‘‘Lyrics of the Nine- teenth Century” (New York, 1883). where } the reading (p. 102) is “suddenly,” a note says “Sullenly is generally misprinted for suddenly. Wolfe’s manuscript has suddenly.” The corruptions in Blackwood have all been copied in many reprints. Others are “con- fined”’ for “enclosed”; the insertion of com- mas before and after “like a _ warrior,” marring both rhythm and sent it, “ram for “rampart”; “And we knew by ird by’) the distant and 1 gun foe é ld th 10 R is ned othe1 pu vy Wolfe h > sch effor in bilan ve! ), yne oO \ printed g h lif The v ilso contains a h er! is I of r re ma r for publication all f g i ex ception , I l i re rl ple inst ‘ ta single p tion, or any other rhetorical e1 A long and ulogist review ol i ‘ appeared in Blackwood, for Mar 1826 (Vol. XIX, p. 323), both vers ceiving far more praise than they I ] For instancé the song, “Go, for which besam: pul when set declared to me Cx edingly beautiful only in thought and feeling, but in xpres s:on—and iffi nt to prove hat he [Wolfe] had the deep and fin n lity the poet. The pathos is pure and tender as the moonlight The first stanza hich is decidedly the best of the three, reads thus: Go. forget me why should sorr O’er that brow a shadow fling’ Go, forget me and to-morrow Brightly smile and sweetly sing Smile though I shall not be near thee; I shall never hear thee: Sing-—t hough May thy soul with pleasure Lasting as the gloom of mine! Go, forget me, et« I remember hearing it sung by young friends some sixty or more years ago. Strangely enough, the reviewer is doubt- ful whether Wolfe wrote the poem that made him famous He asks: How could Mr. Russell publish the cele- brated lines on the death of Sir John Moore as the production of Mr. Wolfe without giving any proof whatever that they are so? . . . Medwin knew no more of the matter than any coal-porter on Dublin Quay. Medwin, in his ‘“‘Conversations of Byron,” as quoted by Russell, had referred to By ron’s reading the poem to Shelley and other friends, and calling it “little inferior to the best which the present prolific age has brought forth.’’ After reading it, he “rs peated the third stanza, and said it was perfect, particularly the lines, ‘But he lay like a warrior taking his rest, etc.” Shel- ley said that he should have taken the poem “for a rough sketch of Campbell's but Byron replied: ‘‘No; Campbell would have claimed it if it had been his.” The review Blackwood, it will be seen in The Nation. SUMMER SCHOOLS London Morning Chronic after Blackwood had 8S amazing that found out—or had forgotten N 2 # ly e de SY I { ' ' I ‘ pre ‘ ld , il i } } ‘ ' a In I 4 ir publ With the teacher as ex rie r sit earmne jiation hetr ed. If tl n our yl laboratory pleasanter . +} that + ; na I 8
Page 16
510 of us find summer teaching, foregoing the inconveniences of the season, less arduous than the work of the regular session, large- ly because the preponderance of teachers in our classes divides between the instruc- tor and the student the question of en- thusiasm, whereas during the regular ses- sion the professor generally has to supply it all It is possible that many men who give in- struction in our summer schools, lose sight of what seems to me the important privilege of the colleges and universities that main- tain summer sessions. The fact that every ear several thousand teachers from both ondar and high schools place them- selve under the instruction of the college or university professor gives the latter some opportunity to be of great service to these teacher and, therefor to do a little, at least, towards making the schools below the olleg onform to his ideals la glad to read a protest against “ex ol work and the listener.” A sum e! chool of the Chautauqua type is a we it affords slight recreation, and practically no education. Progress comes nly through serious work; merely listen- nz to lectures, and watching demonstra- tions, unless supplemented by thorough reading and study, is almost wasting one’s time FRANK CARNEY. I> son University, Granville, O., November 10. RULES OF THE BODLEIAN. To THe Epiror or THe NATION: Sir: Of the many American readers who have worked in the Bodleian Library, prob- ably few have ever become familiar with the Staff-Kalendar, published by the LI- brarian annually for some years past, the 1909 edition of which has just come to my hand This extraordinary little book, measuring only two and a half inches by four and a half, is a veritable revelation in what it shows—still more in what it im- plies—of the system that has grown up for enturies in connection with the adminis- tration of the venerable library whose name t bears. Who that has labored dreamingly among the ancient tomes in Duke Humph- rey'’s room, occasionajly pondering on the simplicity and quiet that reign there, in ontrast with the noise and fussiness of the Biblioth®que Nationale, has realized that every man and boy employed in the library arries a printed book in which it is re orded that on February 1 the east end of “the H” | to be swept, that on Feb- ruary 8 the Bodley clocks are to be wound and wet and that on Febru ut 7 the Camera chimney and flues are ! cleaned? Or who that has received hook from the charming little boys it glide about the place has imagined hedged about with an aggre- ca of rule eemingly utterly irrelevant h gentle creatures’?——as that no or assumption of authority will be rated ind that boyea must not run olently on air Their regulations are sleo in part of a kindly paternal tone rhus Oxford climate ha leveloped a para graph admonishing that as boots often let water unexpectedly, every boy is advised to keep at the library a dry pair of boots and a dry pair of socks.” Boys are also warned against reading in a bad light as though any other kind could be found The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2317 during a good part of the Oxford winter! “It is no answer to say that they can see perfectly, because the more short-sighted they were becoming the better they would see in a bad light.” This bit of refutation brings out the fact that, whatever objection or exception or occasion you may postulate, you will find that the Staff-Kalendar has foreseen the contingency. Here is a note suggestive of many troublesome letters, following an elaborate account of the fire-alarm sys- tem: “Other libraries desiring informa- tion as to the details of this system are begged not to write to the Librarian, but to the Expansion Sprinkler Syndicate,” etc. Yet a moment later, in a mollified mood, the Librarian adds that he “might, how- ever, be willing to answer inquiries as to whether the systein had or had not given satisfaction.” The fire-alarm question runs through all the Kalender, and one derives the impression that a kind of hysteria, or pyrophobia, pervades the place. Under- graduate demonstrations are clearly one of the chief causes of alarm—perhaps on other grounds also; at any rate, the staff is warn- ed on every day from May 21 to June 2 that “eights celebrations [are] to be watched for.”” Street bonfires are a matter of spe- cial concern, and if they are not extinguish- ed, on request, by the policeman on duty (“which has happened’’), appeal is at once to be taken to higher powers. Most im- pressive, however, in this connection, are the warnings against carrying any kind of light, or striking any match, in the Bod- leian building; these go back to a Latin statute of 1610, and have been san ‘tified further by various interpretations and en- forcements. “In 1901 a newly admitted foreign reader lighted a cigarette in go- ing down the Bodleian stairs, and his ad- mission was cancelled.” But later some- thing still more tragic occurred. “In 1903 a graduate of forty-five years’ standing struck a light on the same staircase, to. examine a picture by, and was informed that he must never again enter the build- ing: the picture itself was removed.” This last clause, whose italics are ours, certainly gives a fitting final touch to the solemmity of the subject. Talk of hanging animals for crime! That was child’s play compared with punishing a picture, by forbidding it to hang, for inciting a venerable man to mis- conduct Enough of details. One thing is certain: “who touches this book touches a man.” Not only the reverend past of Bodley’s Library, but the arresting personality of Bodley's present librarian, make the Kalen- dar far more than the merely utiliarian production it professes to be. LECIOR. Palo Alto, Cal., November 15 THE READING OF VERSE To THe Epiror or THe NATION: Sin: Professor Gummere's plea in the Vation of November 11 for the reading of Not only the professional readers and actors in vocue, as well as the delicate-handed dilet- tant! of our most esoteric circles, but too many of our most advanced young gentle- men profess and practise the pernicious verse as verse is just and timely heresy of reading verse as prose, sternly denying time-values to poetic lines, anl resolutely submerging the emotional and the esthetic elements of measured speech: in the logical and analytical elements. Whence comes this tendency? Is it an outgrowth of the attempt of Whitman and those who came after him to loosen the shackles of regular rhythm? Does it re- sult from the disintegration of modern. blank verse and its resolution into a bas- tard prose? Or is it simply due to the subjection of our generation to the per- vasive influence of the scientific habit of mind and all its implications? Our contemporary poets—those of the widest influence, at any rate—are not chargeable with it, nor do they counte- nance it. Rather, are not the new and pronounced rhythms of the schools of Kip- ling and of Swinburne protests against this tendency and landmarks in a new reaction against over-refinement and emasculation of rhythm and the levelling of verse into prose? Even the tyro or the iconoclast caa hardly render such movements of speech as Thus saith the Lord in the vault above the cheru- bim, Calling to the angels and the souls in their degree— otherwise than with the rolling rhythm of chant or pan. The sensuous effect of flowing measures, the glamour of verse and its spell, are still the things sought for. Herrick’s “holy in- eantation of this verse’’ is still felt to- day as the test and touchstone of poetry. Are our neoterics in their turn trying to start a reaction against even the new- est school of poetry? I fear that much of the blame rests with those who profess to teach literature from: the chairs of learning. How many of our college teachers can sincerely testify that they themselves have never subscribed to- this heresy, in practice if not in theory? FREDERIC Ives CARPENTER. University of Chicago, November 12. Literature. H. M. STANLEY. The Autobiography of Sir Henry Mor- ton Stanley, G.C.B. Edited by his. wife, Dorothy Stanley. With sixteen photogravures and a map. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $5 net. Stanley’s story of his early life is not only profoundly interesting, but is full of stimulating thoughts and experiences, especially for young men. For it is the story of one who, “without a parent, re- lation, or friend on earth to turn to,” began his life in a workhouse and end- ed it in Westminster Abbey. The name, Bula Matari, “Breaker of Rocks,” given him by the natives who saw him with drill and hammer helping to hew a road around the rapids of the Congo, and engraven on his tomb, fitly char- acterize a man who from his youth vic- torlously battled with the hardest that earth could afford. To those who know him only as the African explorer the story of his early career will be full of surprises. John Rowlands by name, his father having died in his infancy and eat Se i = a Shs 1
Page 17
i] ‘| \ — a Siabd ve. a “ov ‘ 5 PG 1 Bs Nov. 25, 1909] his mother having cast him off, he was brought up in a Welsh workhouse. Here he stayed till he was fifteen, when, on account of inhuman treatment, he escap- ed from the “house of torture” and shipped as cabin-boy on a vessel bound from Liverpool to New Orleans. [t was in those days the custom of many ship- masters to be so cruel to their boys that they would desert on reaching port, and so forfeit their wages. This was the case with our hero, and his next years were spent in the South in shops, on plantations, and on a flatboat. On the breaking out of the civil war he en- listed in the Sixth Arkansas Regiment. At the Battle of Shiloh he was teken prisoner and carried to Chicago. Here his sufferings in the prison at Camp Doug- las were so great that, to secure his re- lease, he enlisted in the Union crmy, his sympathies also now being entirely with the North. Being discharged on account of having “prison-disease,” he joined the navy as “ship’s writer.” In this capacity he took part in the capture of Fort Fisher, a graphic account of which he sent to the newspapers, and so began his career as a correspondent. The real autobiography ends with his discharge from the army on June 22, 1862, when, without a penny in his pocket, he worked his way from Har- per’s Ferry to Baltimore. As the record was written nearly at the close of Stanley’s active life, it is not impossible that the boyish thoughts and aspirations here portrayed may be to some extent the product of his maturer years. But of their gen- eralaccuracy and _ truthfulness one may be assured by the success of his later life. This success was won, it is evident, by his determination to do his duty, to make the best of everything, and not to give way to dis- couragement. “I exclude all words like ‘fail, ‘can’t,’ from my vocabulary,” he writes at a depressing period. “I have nothing to fall back upon but energy, and much hopefulness,” is another in- spiring thought; as is also, “I mean by attention to my business, by self-denial, by indefatigable energy, to become, by this very business, my own master, and that of others.” Another striking char- acteristic, which is but little emphasiz- ed in his published works, is the relig- ious strain running through the whole of his life. While in the workhouse a conviction came which never left him, that, though without an earthly father, “he had a Father in Heaven.” When he landed in New Orleans the book in his pocket was a Bible given him in the workhouse for “general good conduct,” and the first man whom he asked for employment, seeing it, became interest- ed in him and finally adopted him, giv- ing him his name. This Bible, it may be added, was the one book which he took with him when he went in search of Livingstone. ‘The Nation. The personality of the Stanley. who, as special correspondent, accompanied the British Abyssinian and Ashantee ex- peditions and our Gen. Hancock's cam- paign against the Comanches, who sought for Livingstone in the wilds of Africa and founded the Congo State, the “traveller in five continents” and the member of Parliament, is revealed by extracts from his journals, note-books, and private letters. Lady Stanley links together the different parts with many interesting and her predominant aim “something of the working of his own reminiscent passages, being to show mind and heart.” So he thinks aloud, as it were, on almost every page. Very lit tle material is taken from his published writings, ten in number, and much new light is thrown upon the varied expe riences in this, the most important part of his life. Among other things, he says that Livingstone’s “return to home and kindred—though he found his energies waning, age creeping on him, and fet- tering him fn its strong bonds vented by an overscrupulous fidelity to a promise that he had made to his friend, Sir R. Murchison, that he would set the matter of that watershed north of the Tanganyika at rest.” An ardent affection for the self-sacrificing mission- ary was kindled in his breast during the four months they were together, and when the parting hour came, “I was as a sensitive child of eight or so, and yielded to such bursts of tears that only such a scene as this could have forced.” The inspiration of Livingstone’s example had much to do with the founding of the Congo State. For, in this, Stanley’s main purpose and passion was the “betterment of mankind; ... to pour the civili- zation of Europe into the barbarism of Africa.” Apparently, he did all in his power to induce his countrymen to un- dertake this noble task, “but the gov- ernment and the people of England turn- ed a deaf ear” to his pleas. An inter- view with Mr. Gladstone in 1890, shows how little was the interest of the ex- Premier in* Africa’s crying needs. This was not the case with Queen Victoria, who sent for him on his return from his Livingstone expedition: was pre- The conversation, which was pr pally about Livingstone and Africa, though it d not last more than ten minutes, gav me abundant matter to think about, from hav ing had such good opportunities to look into her eyes, and absorb as it were my impressions, such as they were What I admired most was the sense of power the eyes revealed, and a quiet, but unmistake able, kindly yndescension; and an inimit able calmness and self-possession I was her, not only for the giad to have seen honor, and all that, but also, I think, be- cause I have carried something away to muse over at leisure I am richer in the understanding of power and dominion, sit- ting enthroned on human features. The closing years of this adventurous life were spent in travelling, giving lec- O11 tures, and in Parliament. H's travels extended to Australia and South Africa, where, in 1897, he went in Pretoria to the house of President Kriiger, of whom he gives one of the most graphic de- scriptions we remember to have read: You have seen lots of stout-bodled old Parisian concierges; and I da say you have seen them in their ly black clothes, when going out on a \ t put a little top-hat on one of them, give him stooping shoulders, with a heavy, lumber ing. biggish body and you w know Kruger at once! Well! let him v " vis to you; put much obstinacy toa f that is unusually large, with a ooh of forehead and two small eye ‘ he fig ure sink in h chair, with an at i mination in every iine and giv him a big briarwood pipe which held in h left hand, and there you hav him Taking the autobiography as a whole, is a work of remarkable interest and Value, not so much on account of the information which it gives, as for the spirit with which Stanley approached the hard life-problems he had to solve. Should it would recommend that two episodes of reach a second edition, we his boyhood in this country be omitted, on account of their suggestiveness to the youthful reader. Ten of the sixteen illus trations are portraits showing him at different ages from 15 to 54, and on a map of tropical Africa are traced the routes of his three great expeditions CURRENT FICTION. A Novel. Being the Autobiography of Nicholas Worth. New York: Doubleday, Page & ‘'o. The Southerner: The novel is hard to define, and this book may be one. We incline, howe ver, to think it rather less than a nove!, cor- rectly defined, and we are quite sure that it is also a good deal more. To con- stitute it a novel, there are some more fictitious thread of a plot to hold it together, and an intermittent or less characters, a_ thin love-story. But it Is also biography, since decidedly more than suggestions of many of the char acters were got from real persons ome of them still living. It is likewise auto- biography, and at times unusually trank autobiography at that, although, on the other hand, even in this department, the admixture of fiction is large It is his tory—-with a like qualification It is a And it is belated, study in politics and sociology a pretty lively, though a trifle tract for the times. So far as it is fiction, its quality may be indicated by placing it about midway between Mr. Thomas Nelson Page's “Red Rock” and the lurid stories of the Rev Thomas Dixon, jr. But it differs from both quite otherwise and more funda- mentally than by coming in between. Mr. Page is a very pleasing and well- bred, Mr. Dixon a very coarse and vio- lent, defender of the South's past and
Page 18
_ 1° ~ present, of its traditions, and ways and point of view. The writer of this book is a critic and a would-be reformer and The feeling for the South a transtormer. hich his work reveals is strong—pos- sibly as strong as theirs—but the point of vi and the animus are utterly dif- ferent. ry animus, as well as the method in far as so nondescript a work can be aid to have a method is, we think, decidedly open to criticis: There is too much of the spirit of the combatant, ani mething, we fear, of the bitter I of unpictur pulses. That is makes the putting of real people i tory o plainly questionable, | ular in¢ fictional form per i di gard fo uch requirements of a ira is an out-and-out biographer istorian would hav to meet. This, taken ith the anonymity of the work, \ ougl ntment, and f ning for violent re to ft purpe oft con- criti 1 it has. It is not for ume Dante's priv- i ith 1 en j vhether living or dead verthel t he animus, the ind strong and at times pas ite rebellion against what may be ed the forces of delay in the South I whatever and whoever may be ling it back and keeping it apart, t ives to the book its force. We 1 sa hat much of the true spirit ‘ form and progress, although mixed ith other and less worthy heats, and although too little alleviated by rev- erence and appreciation, is here to be found. The principal character, a young Southerner. with a Northern education, sees much that false and insincere in Southern civilization and manners, much that is anachronistic in South- ern life, and is gradually drawn into of sense, can- dor, and progress and to hate and to fight cant and ultra- Bourbonism in in common He comes to deplore a protagonism conservatism in religion and methods sentimentalism ‘n politics, archaic aims education, and false everything; and winds up his career by getting elected State superintendent of education on a fusion ticket—and then being counted out. His stanchest ally is “Professor Billy,” of the State Uni- versity. who, by persistency, shrewdness, yood nature, and a gift for story-tell ing of the cross-roads variety, does suc ceed in reforming education at the bot tom, and dies president of an industrial achool for girla. A young woman with the old Southern sentimentality, busy about Confederate memorials, falls away from the hero to an Episcopal clergy man: a woman with his own vision and ideals takes her place. A Confederate colonel, with atilted but a shrewd eye to the political value of hero- worship and negrophobla, is his arch-an- tagon!st. The Republican machine, eloquence, The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 made up mainly of postmasters, plays its part—a good deal to the life. A Yankee college-mate makes some invest- ments. A quiet younger brother takes the industrial problem without leav- ing the old home, and solves it. Negroes come into the action. Hardly a type is neglected. The best pages are those given over vigorous talk about “the problem,” and, perhaps, the best of these is that which declares it to be no problem at all, but a condition, capable of indefinite im- but not, in the nature of things, capable of any “solution” at all. Here are words in which few Southern- ers Northerners as a would concur: ul to provement, and not so many few years ago negro merely be- care for him be- child. I prefer to hink of the people in the Southern States hite and black alike—living inder certain conditions, which can be made i care nothing for the iuse | is a negro | he is a man—or a L1us¢ 1S a people—w ery fortunate an conditions rather than race of them prosperous about any particular class or In are proper schem¢ men, any education, there white no lack no men—only men On the contrary, the feeling that, how- both the races may be changed by training and education, there are funda- mental differences between them which evel can probably never be eradicated, and that they can never live together as if all of the same race, is prob- as strong in the South to-day was, and in the North strong- er than it has been since the civil war. This is, we think, but one of several in- stances in the book of a failure to sense correctly some of the problems with which it essays to deal. Its appeal is, of course, to public opinion, and the au- thor evidently shares the inability of most radical reformers to see clearly the nature and workings of that mys- terious force. In dealing with it, not one in a million seems to have Lincoln's gift. The book would doubtless do more good than harm in the South if it should be widely and candidly read there. It is much more likely, however, to get a wide reading, and a rather too serious acceptance, in the North. While no real person is put bodily into the story, and no career quite as it happened, the real persons who suggest- ed—and more than suggested—certain of the principa' characters may be nam- ed with a good deal of confidence. The State is North Carolina. For “Profes- sor Billy” one may read Prof. Charles 1. Melver; for Col. Graham, of Gra- ham'’s School, Col. Robert Bingham, of Bingham's School; for Senator Barker, they wer ably quite as it ever Senator Matt. W. Ransom; for Col. Stringweather, Gen. W. R. Cox, with admixtures, perhaps, from Col. Spier chairmen of the State for Capt. Bob for Mr. Whitaker—two Democratic Committee; Logan, Col. J. C. L. Harris; brarian; for the Globe, the Raleigh Chronicle; for the White Man, the Raleigh News and Observer; for the Cotton Boll, the Progressive Farmer; for “Brother Charles,” Mr. Henry A. Page; for Nicholas Worth, hero and au- thor, Mr. Walter H. Page. The list of recognitions and partial recognitions could be lengthened. Old Rose and Silver. By Myrtle Reed. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. The harmless necessary novel blooms again, and the voice of Myrtle Reed is heard in the land. Old heads nod hap- over the old rose-leaf chapters; young muscles stretch and gladden at :crobatic episodes; the world that loves a lover turns pages contentedly, knowing that all really true love runs at last smooth in the land of Myrtle Reed. The disciples of the Woman's Column feast visions of old gold satin, deep green velvet, clinging chif- fon, spangled net, and gems to match: all the costuming being done with nice regard to the soul, as well as to the eyes and complexion. For music lovers, a yearning melody is braided, motive- wise, into the and as often set down in rea] musical notation, arranged for two hands on the piano, name and address furnished in a note. For .epi- gram-searchers, there is good hunting: pily the on story, Men keep best in a cool, dry atmosphere Wisdom consists largely in a graceful ac- ceptance of things that do not immediately oncern us, i priceless saying! So are many fed. But those who ask for the untidy or the unwholesome, find the cupboard bare. A Castle of Dreams. By Netta Syrett. Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co. Stories of a pretty romantic flavor, having to do with young, innocent, and modest girls who chance also to be titled heiresses, are never a drug in the market. It is always interesting to see by what specific path they are to be brought to the desired haven of matri- mony. Adventurers are to be avoided, calf-love is to be shunted aside with sisterly affection, the plottings of adored but mercenary parents are to be set agley, the rivalry of naughty ladies is to be triumphed over: no end of unto- wardnesses may threaten—in vain. The conventions of this type of fiction may as well be accepted as the conven- tions of polite comedy. They afford a perfectly trustworthy and irreproach- able form of entertainment for people who do not care to let their literature worry them. The Lady Bridgit O'Shaughnessy of this tale (it is to be noted that a cook or a saint spells her name “Bridget,” but a heroine “Brigit” or “Bridgit’) conducts herself efficient- ly in the part assigned. She almost does Birdeastle, Mr. Birdsong, once State li-| more than that—almost proves herself
Page 19
es aay lapis alent isn 2 Nov. 25, not a mere romantic heroine, but a de- lightful creature of flesh and blood. But something too much is required of her: she is a bit too clever, too efficient to be credible. A girl whose aristocratic blood empowers her (at the age of twenty-two) to shift in a half-hour from a colleen in short skirt and bare legs to a lady of fashion and form, a self- possessed and dominant hostess, is hard- ly of this world. She must be as the child Bridgit has fancied herself: a fairy-lady. She must in that charac- ter have been to London and seen the great Queen to some purpose, to have acquired this conquering way. How- ever, she has it, and it suffices to bring her safe through a difficult situation without a tremor. What that situation is, with what special perils it is hedged zbout, by precisely what girl's force and cleverness serve her in the cvent, far be it from the commen- tator tospecify. There you have the sin- gle fair excuse for the whole perform- ence—unless it be in the quiet figure of “Standish,” the one real and stable fig- ure in this world of polite and present- able ghosts. means the Lost Borders. By Mary Austin. New York: Harper & Bros. It is difficult to believe that this col- lection of short stories is the work of a woman, so manly is its general tone. It is a tribute to our own Western cesert that will rejoice those who have fe't the magic of that place of sand and thorns, which to its lovers has no whit less of awful majesty than much-worded Sa- hara. The stories tell of primitive hu- man experiences with an impressive simplicity—episodes of life lived in the face of the great waste, where so many of the apparent essentials, as civiliza- tion sees them. die out like the vegeta- tion of the tilled fields, leaving only those hardy growths that are one with the soil. It is a wholesome book for city-dwellers in its largeness of under- standing, the essence of which is finely embodied in the dedication with its Kip- lingesque swing. Reading, we cannot but feel for the moment “the wind that wakes the morning on a thousand miles of sage.” TWO STUDIES IN LITERARY TYPES. The Short Story in English. By tienry Seidel Canby. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $1.60 net. The Autobiography. By Anna Robeson Burr. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $2 net. During the last ten years, all sorts of geniuses, critics, and professors have been discussing with marked animation the type, technique, and development of the short story. It was, therefore, in- evitable in the heyday of literary his- tory that some one should write the | The Nation. history of this ubiquitous parvenu. Let it be said at the outset that Professor Canby has performed with much tact and adroitness a pretty difficult task. If the book was written to remove the curse of popularity from the study of the short story, it should be successful. It clothes the subject with a severity which will surprise the uninitiated. In his vivacious preface, Professor Canby ad- mits that he runs the risk of “aggra- vating” the critic by overmuch of the ory, interpretation, and technical dis cussion. The difficulty does not really lie there. It lies partly in the lack of illustrative material in the periods where it is most needed. It lies partl) in the extreme condensation in other periods—the entire eighteenth century is disposed of in thirty pages. But it lies chiefly in a unified treatment of things fundamentally diverse The short story 3; a singularly unsatisfacto1 the evolutionist. The Anglo-Saxon “Jud th not mentioned in this treatis« 1 virtue of its brevit poignan and singleness of effect, nearer to th Cask of Amontillado” than almost an) of the century. short stories of the sixteent Again, short story telling re from Chaucer to th Though Profess Canby does not attempt to establish steadily dresses nineteenti centur continuous and orderly evolution, it is fairly obvious that he does approach al! his material and measure its permanent importance with the purel! literary standards established in the nineteenth ind twentieth centuries. The constant forward reference, explicit or implicit, in his criticism of the early English, medieval, and Elizabethan periods uni fies the intention of his history, but subtracts from its interest. To write, with one eye fixed on Poe, of such a Protean and wholly indefinable type as “the short narrative in English,” to write of all sorts of religious, moral, and sociological tracts—the ezempla of the Anglo-Saxon homilists, the coney-catch- ing pamphlets of Greene, the euphuistic conversations of Lyly, the “Oroonoko” of Mrs. Behn, the character sketches of Addison and Johnson—to write of all these things which never had the faint- est intention of being short stories, with one eye fixed on the master of short stories, is to be rather dry and unedify- ing. The catholic h'storian of all types of short story in every period of Eng- lish needs to forget Poe, and exercise the historical imagination. Professor Canby’s historical sympathy and imagi- nation are at times distinctly defec tive. Speaking of Alfred's apology for the heathen myths in Boethius, he says: “A hateful spirit this is, and the abomi- nation of priggishness in the eyes of Chaucer.” The remark does not indicate the most favorable temper in which to approach and interpret the narratives 0’ a religious age Of its own well-defined kind or yenre 513 Professor Canby’s book is a very good specimen—well-informed, critical, com- pact, severe, instructive. And yet when we read such an entirely unamusing ac- count of the most purely amusing of lit- erary forms, we cannot help recalling observations made Goldsmith's some time ago “Of Learning in Great Bri- tall juire a chara r for lea ga x ! English at present, it is ‘ \ h more than is eitl i 1 It s¢ is the spirit of here to exhaust their " ’ xploring th t 0o $ ight i ] ear gf i ‘ too minute i Hy wh ’ ry . ‘ He ] } ‘ . I ; i at | re 1 to COMDA su Autobk ipl h Pro r ( t tudy in the short story d yet the juxtaposition of the two woks j igs tiv the defects of the Oo are opposite, their virtues are com piementary. If “The Short Story in Eng- 0 borrow Jonson's comment on smelled too defect of the verses of Drummond much of the The Autobiography Schooles,” the arise largely from the boldness of the undisciplined stu dent The speaking, a contribution to the history latter work is not, strictly of literary types. It originated in 4 pas ion for knowing personalities through their own records, and in a desire to kindle a similar passion in other read- ers. As the circle of acquaintances wid- ened, however, the author found certain laws of autobiographical writing reveal- ing themselves under her eyes, and she began to suspect that her data had a genuine value for psychologists as well as for the layman. She accordingly made a number of investigations of which the results suggested the division of the book into chapters on such sub- jects as The Autobiographical Intention, History, The Three Great Archetypes, The Autobiographical Group, The Ner- vous Systems of the Past, Memory, Hu- mour, etc.—and the list might have been extended almost indefinitely! The field of the exploration is delight- fully wide, ranging from Marcus Aurel- jus through most civilized countries— vith special emphasis upon the material of France—to writers as recent as Ed- mund Gosse. Indeed, Mrs. Burr is so bold as to declare, “the reader may be sure that the omission of a work simply means that it contains no definite mat- following ter worth noting in the
Page 20
S514 pages.” When we turn to the list of two or three hundred “capital autobi- ographies” and find Charlotte Charke and Sir Egerton Brydges present, and Montaigne, Thomas Browne and Amiel absent, we question whether the state- ment was carefully weighed. The abso- lute ignoring of Montaigne is quite in- In her chapter on “The Three Archetypes” the author says, “Augustin, Cardan, and later Rousseau and Mill—these are the auto- biographers who have influenced others, the great self-students.” A that Cardan’s was “as much comprehensible. Great and these are little later asserts ‘Book of His Own Life” read and as much imitated as the “Con- she fessions” of Rousseau Until we have seen some shadow of evidence to the contrary, we shall continue to believe that Montaigne was incomparably the greatest and most influential “self-stu- dent" before Rousseau, and also that the influence of Mill's “Autobiography” is not to be mentioned in the same day with the influence of Rousseau’s “Con- fessions.” \ reckless audacity of statement is the prime defect of the book. Christian- brought the subjective influence into literature: The “Meditations” of An- toninus were written after the birth of therefore, the subjectivity was due to Chris- ity Christianity; ‘Meditations” tianity. Here !s a specimen law of au- tobiographical production: “The subjec- tive groups itself about the movements and changes and lessens of the autobiography great intellectual of the disappears in times of material change.” Mrs. Burr does not give the dates of pub- lication, but the birth and death dates of her authors; and whatever element truth there may be in this law is supported by her extremely vague history. The declares, world, or of not references to and jaunty “intellectual uprising,” she “produces Rousseau and his group; when action followed, the self-study disap- peared.” We should be inclined to state the matter thus: “Rousseau and his group produce the Intellectual upris- ing: when they were dead, they ceased A touch of the modern in her (There from self-study.” condescension Richard” confusion of the she al as “Richard.”) Hav views of the scientific appears comment on Burton meme to te some here with a modern bearer name; wave refers to him of religious phenomena, she re ing spoken two recent nature of marks Richard Burton, tn the ‘has unconacioualy lo the second Anatomy of Melancholy) added the of his elancholy ta for the packed examples to weight erudition section on religious ' though all unwittingly with maintain the neuropathical opinion Burr has rather the acquaintance of Burton tin Alfieri. We sus- “Richard” could psycholo- We suspect that Mra avo'ded behalf of her favorite that if old from his grave, pect poor rise modern [Vol. 89, No. 2317 The Nation. gists would not find him quite so “un- conscious” or so “unwitting” as she would have it appear. In spite of its defects, however, the book is remarkably entertaining. Theré is not a particle of doubt that Goldsmith would have preferred it to Professor Canby’s “Short Story in English.” It really accomplishes its most valuable purpose; it makes one desire to possess the entire list of “capital autobiogra- phies’—and two or three besides. It almost makes one wish that Professor Canby and Mrs. Burr could collaborate in writing literary history. Studies in Mystical Religion. By Rufus M. Jones. New York: The Macmillan Co. $3.50 net. There are special difficulties in writ- ing the history of Christian mysticism, or even in treating certain selected phases of it, as Professor Jones is care- ful to state was the intention of this work. The very question of selection, for instance, is a vital one, for it is de- cisive of the purpose of the work as a whole. It happens sometimes that the teaching of certain mystics is more in- fluential than their personality; on the other hand, as in the case of St. Ber- nard, the man himself is much greater and more important than any part of the theological system he held. In the present volume there is no evidence of systematic choice. While much of it is well written, and while some chapters, notably the one on Dionysius, show originality, the result of a vigorous and independent study of a hard and weari- some author, there is not enough ana- lytical power applied either to the theory or the different phenomena of mysticism. The plan of the work, too, is somewhat spoiled by the fact that it was prepared as the introduction to a history of English Quakerism. Some of the concluding chapters, though ex- tremely interesting in themselves for the light they throw upon the obscurer developments of English religion dur- ing the periods of the civil wars and Commonwealth, are appropriately intro- duced to illustrate the environment in which Quakerism emerged, but are dis- proportionately long in a general appre- clation of mysticism. If Professor Jones had pursued his work with some definite object in view, he might well have confined his atten- tion to the mysticism of unorthodoxy, to the influence of mystical tenets on the parties which opposed the Church during the mediwval period from the Paulicians to the Waldensians and Lol- lards. But his studies present a con- glomeration of orthodox and unortho- dox mysticism without any speciai at- tempt to discriminate or explain why certain mystics felt thoroughly at home in the communion of the Catholic Church, while others stubbornly revist- ed its authority. Viewed solely from the theoretical point of view, the mystical principles of the heretic and orthodox churchman might be closely allied, yet the orthodox mystic, as in the case of Thomas a Kempis, could speculate un- disturbed while the heretic would be confined to the dungeon of the inquisi- tion and subsequently burned. ‘What possible place for a church organization of any kind would there be if Chris- tians followed the standard of the “Imi- tatio”? Any ecclesiastical regimen must to mystics seem secondary; if treated seriously, their views are nothing more than religious anarchy. Why, therefore, was the Waldensian damned and the “Imitatio” given to the faithful as a standard devotional manual? On these doubtful and _ far-reaching problems which have both a place in the progress of human thought and can be seen to be of predominant importance in the study of society, little help can be got from this volume. Yet in a collection of essays these structural defects are not so serious as they would be in a systematic treatise, and there can be no question that Mr. Jones’s sympathetic appreciation of mystical types of thought and his ability to present ther succinctly and in popular form are cer- tain to secure for his book the atten- tion and recognition of many readers. They will find in him a stimulating guide, even when he fails to satisfv their deeper questionings. Wisconsin Historical Commission: Orig- inal Papers. No. 1, A View of the Vicksburg Campaign, by William F. Vilas, Lieut.-Col. of Twenty-third Wis- consin Volunteers. No. 2, Capture and Escape, A Narrative of Army and Prison Life, by John Azor Kellogg, Colonel of the Sixth Wisconsin Vol- unteer Infantry and Brevet-Brigadier- General. These handsome books introduce what will probably be a long series relating to the part played by Wisconsin in the civil war. They are well printed, but now and then the editing is careless. An officer of the distinction of Joseph E. Johnston ought not to appear as “John- son”; and still worse is describing Gouv- erneur K. Warren as “George G.” It is a good plan, no doubt, to fortify the se- ries with a well-known name, but we think Mr. Vilas’s paper is no very val- uable contribution to history. It is a rather heavy account of the Vicksburg campaign, containing no new facts or judgments. There are serious omissions. Grierson’s raid, an important incident of the campaign, tending as it did to con- fuse the Confederate leaders, is not men- tioned, and a line or two ony are given to the embarrassments caused by Mc- Clernand, the commander of the Thir- teenth Corps. The campaign in general has often been more vividly and accu-
Page 21
a ¢ ? k Cnn. WER IMP Soh ates Nov. 25, 1909] The Nation. rately described, and there is an utter absence of the personal touch which a participant in so marvellous a drama might easily have imparted. Of much greater value is the com- panion narrative of Col. Kellogg, who, as a captain, was captured on the skir- mish-line in the Wilderness, May 5, 1864, undergoing imprisonment from whica he finally escaped six months later. He traversed Virginia, the Carolinas, and Georgia at a time when exasperation was at its height: he endured the jail and the prison pen at their worst, bare- ly got off alive while tunnelling to es- cape, leaped for liberty from a train at full speed only to be hunted down by ploodhounds, was incarcerated under Federal fire in Charleston, but at last through the aid of friendly negroes and mountain Unionists made his way to Sherman’s lines just before the open- ing of the March to the Sea. It is indeed a harrowing recital, and the heart of the reader bounds when at last after famine and nakedness the stout captain grasps once more the hands of comrades. But, turning to Rhodes, what shall we say of a declara- tion like the following, in the light of such a story? Summing up his account of the treatment of prisoners of war, he remarks: “All things considered, statis- tics show no reason why the Nortb should reproach the South.” (Vol. V, p. 508.) Rhodes is an historian always thor- ough, and his investigation here has been especially painstaking. The strait in which the South was placed could scarcely have been more severe. The constant and vigilant patrol of gunboats on the Mississippi cut off all help from the West, the blockade made impos- sible relief from the East. Grant and Sherman, each with a hundred thousand men and more, were at Richmond and Atlanta, the Eastern and Western cita- dels. Every effective man was needed at the front; food and clothes in vast supply must be provided. Though the slaves still caused the land to produce, the Federals had so far devastated even the interior that transportation was scarcely possible. While thus at disad- vantage many thousands of their en- emies fell into their hands to be cared for. The Richmond government, says Rhodes, did not intend inhumanity. The rations of prisoners were the same as those issued to soldiers; there was no thought of deliberate starvation or tor- ture. But the captures came overwhelm- ingly. To guard the multitude « force was detailed, the minimum as regards number, the poorest as regards effi- ciency. It becomes explicable, such being the circumstances, why there should have been “a dead-line,” why the pris- oners should not have been furnished with tools to provide shelter for them- selves; axes and saws in the hands of men desperately bent on escape would become formidable weapons. As to food it is contidently asserted to this day that at Andersonville, the ration of prisoner and guard remained always the same; but if not, naturally the armies would be first served, and, impaired as the transportation was, the prisoners might easily fall short. Meantime, there prevailed a like con- gestion at the North, a corresponding crowd of Southern captives languishing at Fort Delaware, Elmira, and Johnson's Island. It may well be asked why could there not be ap exchange? The answer is because Grant refused; he believed that whereas the Northern forces, after such an exchange, would be only recruited, “the release of all the rebel prisoners in the Norta would insure Sherman's defeat ani would compromise our safety here.” So he wrote August 18, 1864, at City Point (War Records, serial num- ber 120, page 607), persisting in a re- fusal to exchange which dated from the preceding April. “It is hard on our men held in Southern prisons not to ex- change them,” said Grant, “but it is hu manity to those left in the ranks to fight our battles.” By this stern insistence, setting at naught his own gentler na- ture, the piteous and universal clamor of Northern hearts, and the tears of a multitude of captives, he very possibly saved his cause. Here, at any rate, we find the highest proof he ever gave of his strength of character and the sin- gleness of his devotion to his country. Painful though Col. Kellogg’s nar- rative may be, yet weighing duly the situation and the facts of hurran nature, it does not conflict with the conclusion of Rhodes, that the North has no rea- son to reproach the South for the treat- ment of its prisoners of war. Such hor- rors are an inevitable part of the thing we call war, as mucn so as the carnage of the battlefield. They always have oc- curred when the struggle becomes close and desperate; they will constantly re- cur until war shall be no more. feebly A Manual of Welsh Literature. By the Rev. J. C. Morrice, M.A. Bangor, Eng- land: Jarvis & Foster. Mr. Morrice gives, in a book rather longer than the familiar primers of Jebb and Stopford Brooke, an outline of the literary history of Wales down tv the end of the eighteenth century. While his work hardly bears comparison with those models of compact presentatiun of similar material, it is a useful introduc- tion to the subject and a convenient handbook for reference. All the more important Welsh authors are passed in review, the significant facts of their lives noted, and their chief works nam- ed and characterized. Considerable space is given to quotations, which ara frequently introduced to illustrate his- torical statements or expressions of crit- ical judgment. In spite of a certain 515. monotony in the plan, the book never becomes a mere dull catalogue of au- thors, for Mr. Morrice selects his ma- terial with skill and comments upon it with interest. But as a result of his choice of a method so largely biograph- ical, general historical considerations— the analysis of intellectual movements and influences, or the study of literary genres—are rather neglected or ob- scured. On the whole, the treatment of the early periods is less satisfactory than of the modern, perhaps because in Old Welsh literature some of the most im- mediate and fundamental questions of chronology and authorship are still un- settled. In the case of the bards tradl- tionally assigned to the sixth century, so much is matter of controversy that the problem of the author of a brief his- tory is especially difficult. Mr. Morrice has tried to treat the subject with due care; but cautious as his statements are, even to the point of vagueness, they go rather beyond what conservative »chol- ars will be disposed to concede as re- gards the authenticity of the poems in question. The discussion of the “Ma- binogion” (pages 29 ff.) is also decid- edly inadequate. The possibility of a Gaelic eiement in the oldest stories and the explanation of its presence, if so re- garded, are not dealt with at all. And in the case of the latest group of tales— “Owain,” “Geraint,” and “Peredur’—the question of French influence is dismiss- ed (page 31) with a few general re- marks about Geoffrey of Monmouth and the proximity of Normans and Britons, and without a single reference to the parallel romances by Chrestien de Troyes. Furthermore, the explanation of the title “Mabinogion,” as a term of con- tempt, meaning “tales for the young” (page 32), surely needs some defence in view of the abandonment of this inter- pretation by most scholars in recent years. While Mr. Morrice could not prop- erly enter upon extended argument about controverted matters, he ought to have taken pains to indicate his depar- tures from prevailing opinion, and to have stated some reasons for his views. With regard to the book as a whole, two general observations may be added, though they apply rather to the present state of knowledge on the subject than to any special delinquency on the part of Mr. Morrice. No one can read the manual without being impressed by the quantity of important Welsh writings which are not yet accessible in print; and it is clear that before anything like an adequate history of the literature can be written, a great deal of work must be done in the way of editing texts. It is equally plain that little more than a beginning has been made in the study of the relations of Welsh literature to that of the rest of Europe. Mr. Morrice, to be sure, does not take account of all that has been accomplished in this dl-
Page 22
516 rection, and his book is hardly a meas- ure of the results thus far obtained. But it is true, in general, that Welsh litera- ture has been treated too much as a thing apart; and there is an inviting field here for the application of the much-talked-of comparative method. Years Da- Put rican Trails: a Record of Three Mexico, 1904-1907. By Kirkham. New York: $1.75 net. We Stanton G.. ¥. iv Vis nam’s Sons Kirkham, already an author of ex- other Mr perience in fields, now gives a charming picture of Mexico. He does not ittempt to instruct; the book is an im pre ionistic painting, full of the atmos phere and color of the real Mexico—the Mexico of the Indian trails. Not special izing in any « subject, he has looke? everythir with seeing eyes: he is tere d in the mining camps, the making of pottery and sugar, the flow- nsects: and he shows an inti r acquaintance with the birds which fly acre his trail. Finally, in the scen yuntain and desert, he finds ial delight, observing everything ler the spell of Mexico's dramatic his .' Mr. Kirkham has traversed many miles of territo! still untouched by modern civilization, and his pictures of Indian life are full of feeling and pathos, Among lieved by touches of humor. his many intimate descriptions of the native life, there is one of especial in- tere It was only a chance encounter with a small Indian lad on the Atlaco- muleo Road, but Mr. Kirkham soon won the child's friendship, and it was not before little five-year-old Juan, bent a thirty-pound load of wood, was confiding his friend the all-im- portant fact that he was on his way to market, two miles distant over a rough that for his load long unde! to new road, adding proudly of wood he hoped to earn three cents. To Mr. Kirkham this childish burden- bearer is representative of the unceas- ing patience and unrewarded toil of the race Little Juan has helped to wear these ruts I high id They are eloquent of many Jua toddling bravely in their di- guarachaa; striding later after the burros laden with loaf sugar from the hacienda, or making the pilgrimage over the mountain, staff in hand; tottering fee- bly at last to the market to chat with old ! and to beg something to eat. Juan will inseribe the tory of his life on these atone He will wear them down a little, but they » turn, will wear out his life A short and truthful picture of the national flesta is given on page 115: The flesta in Mexico Is the legitimate: offepring of the Azte fair, and quite as much a matter of barter as religion. So now there be many who will sell a hen, later to bargain for a sombrero, present ly to go upon their knees within the church yonder, candle in hand; lastly to Ile by The Nation. the roadside, overfull of pulque and obliv- ious of this world or the next. The narrative is refreshingly free from statistics and chapters on the finan- cial resources of the country and the po- litical situation. As an artist is said to catch the expression of his model, so Mr. Kirkham has succeeded in portraying the individuality, the elusive spirit of Mexico. The is attractively illus- trated with twenty-four full-page repro- ductions of photographs. book French By R Holt & Co. A Short His- New York Revolution: M. Johnston. $1.25. The tory. Henry the work of the histov- in the field of the French Johnston effort Speaking of ians of to-day Revolution, that the straighten out the large question of give Professor modern details, but to avoid establish beyond precise shade of the col- breeches, but to having any the French Most stu this cavalier recent litera- Declaring that the “main outlines the Revolution, the proportion and relation of things, tend to become obscured under the accumula- tion of historical detail that is now pro ceeding,” he therefore attempts “to dis entangle’ from this of material “the shape, the movement, the signifi- cance of this great historical cataclysm,” and to judge freely the importance of its incidents. How has he succeeded in his task? He has written a brief and animated ac. count of the history of France from 1789 to 1799. But that he has disen tangled anything that cannot be found already disentangled in many other compendiums, is not apparent. He treat: almost exclusively the personal and the episodic in the Revolution. The careers and fate of important individuals, the struggles of parties and factions, ar traced with a fulness out of proportio. to their real significance. The treat- ment of the causes and the results ol the great movement is slight and appar- ently incidental to the more spectacular aspects of the story. Professor Johns ton devotes more space to Beaumarchais than to the remarkable changes in the civil and criminal laws of France, more the Revolutionary calendar than tu the Constitution of 1791. The extraor- dinary popular movement, which, all over France, followed the storming of the Bastille and which practically de- stroyed the feudal system, is merely characterized as “a regular Jacquerie.” As a consequence, the night of August Says “trend of is to the issues; to the Robespierre’s up unattainable as opinion whatever on Revolution whole.” will characterization as a dents consider a of the ture on the subject. of mass to 1, which was simply its culmination and ratification, has nothing like its proper setting and is greatly over-en- phasized. [Vol. 89, No. 2317 As the author approaches the end of his volume after long descriptions of the factional struggles and the Revolu- tionary days, he says: Meanwhile unconsciously the great social revolution had become an established fact. In the short space of five years—but such years—social equality, freedom of opportu- nity, a new national attitude, a new nation- al life had become ineradicable custom; the assemblies in their calmer moments had passed laws for educating and humanizing he French people. If this great social revolution, which was, however, certainly not accomplish- ed unconsciously, if this attainment of a new national life, the really important thing in the whole movement, had been described should be content with shorter accounts of the Diamond Nec*x- the flight to Varennes, and the juarrels of Hébert and Danton and Robespierre. Frequently the precise information we we lace, desire seems about to be vouchsafed only to elude us. Thus on page 32 it is stated that the feudal taxes will be ne ticed later in connection with the ses- sion of August 4, but when we reach that point we find no description of them, but only a vivid account of an ex- citing meeting which decreed their abo- lition. It is the same in regard to the Constitution. On page 75 it stated that it may be left for the present to be when it becomes operative. is considered When that moment arrives, on page 125, less than four hundred words are given to it, fewer than are devoted to the conspiracy of Babeuf. There are many evidences of careless- ness in the construction of the book. It is stated on one page that the Assem- bly of Notables met in January, 1788, and on the next that it was dissolved on May 1, 1787. Neither date is correct. Nor did that assembly consist of one hundred and fifty members. The deputies did not declare themselves the Nation- al Assembly on June 14, but on June 17. The march of the women to Versailles is given on page 82 as occurring on Oc- tober 5, on page 85 as occurring on Oc- tober 6. The Constituent Assembly did not vote the exclusion of members from the ministry “at the end of November,” 1789, but did vote it on November 7. The first session of the Convention was hel1 on the day of Valmy, as apparently as- serted on page 157, not on the day after as asserted on page 158. The 10th of Thermidor is wrongly given as the 29th of July, whereas four pages earlier the 8th of Thermidor is correctly given as the 26th. It is stated on page 229 that the Treaty of Basle was signed on April Sth, 1795, and on page 230 that it was followed by one with Holland, March 16th. Moreover, the Treaty of Basle certainly did not give the French Re- public a free hand south of the Rhine. It is asserted on page 90 that “the great- er part of French citizens” were exclud-
Page 23
. Ss % £ 4 Ay. = ‘4 o: ads SE Scar ASE ids DAN Aaa EUS al bh lcs as “shel tT Nov. 25, 1909] The Nation. ed from the franchise under the Consti- tution of 1791. Aulard, on the other hand, estimates the number of active citizens at nearly 4,300,000 and of pas- sive at about 3,000,000. The amount of assignats issued during the Revolution is exaggerated on page 252 more than three thousand-fold. There is a jumble of incorrect French on page 265. Unfor tunately, this does not exhaust the list of errors. In the opening chapter of his book Professor Johnston criticises Carlyle as failing “to resist the high lights of his subject,” Taine as “hasty” in much of his erudition, and Sorel as “incorrect in details.” Notes. “Dorian Days” is the title chosen for the new volume of poems by Justice Wen- dell P. Stafford of the Supreme Court of the District of Columbia, announced by the Macmillan Co. The Chaucer Society will soon publish an important short paper by Professor Skeat, entitled “The Eight-Text Edition of the Canterbury Tales, with especial reference to the Harleian MS. 7334.” A former professor at the University of Liverpool, W. H. Woodward, is preparing for publication a biography of Cw#sar Bor- gia, based upon all the published documents and the results of his own researches in the Archivio Segreto of the Vatican, and in other libraries. issue the Social Henry Frowde will soon first velume of Oxford Studies in and Legal History, edited by Professor Vinog- radoff. Included are “English Monasteries on the Eve of Dissolution,” by Prof. A. Savine, and “Patronage in the Later Em- pire,” by F. de Zulueta. The first volume of the collected edition of the works of Fiona Macleod (William Sharp) will soon be issued through Duf- fleld & Co. His writings under his long baffling pseudonym from 1894 to 1905 are here first presented in a complete edition with certain revisions and excisions which have been carefully made by Mrs. Sharp, as editor, according to the wishes and in- structions left with her, Barbey d’Aurevilly is to be honored this week in the erection of Rodin’s at his birthplace, Saint-Sauveur-le- Vicomte; that of Mile. Lucienne Delambre in the Montparnasse cemetery, Paris two monuments Provost Charles Custis Harrison of the University of Pennsylvania succeeds, Dr, C W. Eliot in the chairmanship of the board of trustees of the Carnegie Foundation for the Advancement of Teaching. The Open Court Company publishes an English translation of Spinoza’s “Short Treatise on God, Man, and Human Wel- fare,” rendered from the Dutch edition by Lydia Gillingham Robinson. The chapter on Spinoza from Dr. Albert Schwegler’s History of Philosophy is reprinted as an introduction. The interest in the life of Margaret Gor don, Lady Bannerman, jis altogether too slight to warrant the publication of a vol- ume which, though containing only (J9 pages of text, is made bulky by thick paper The Love” and expensive by the London tradition title of the book, ‘‘Carlyle’s First (John Lane Co.), will explain, if it does not quite justify the purpose of the author, Raymond Clare Archibald. As a matter otf fact, he has extremely little to say about Carlyle, and that little neither very new nor interesting. Those only who are con- cerned in certain Scotch genealogies will find the book valuable. One reflection i! raises. Now that virtually the whol of Carlyle material has been published, and all the facts of his career are easily avail- able, why does not some ambitious scholar undertake a thorough revision of Froud’ biography? By the correction of dates and quoted texts, by an modification of the text where Froude goes too far astray in his mass occasional note or interpretation of events, that much maligned life might be restored to its high plac It is scarcely within probability that any one will ever de novo write a life that will compare with Froude’s in general interest or even, in cer- tain aspects, come as close as Froude’s to The great need is to most the real man Carlyle. purge it of its errors, and that for the part could be easily done When Carlyle, in 1843, published “Past and Present,” the exaggerated cult of op- timism which we have to-day was not, as yet, a literary limitation. Carlyle was per- mitted to is dying of inanition,’ And now one of our latter- Gilbert Keith introduction for Carlyle’s write, in his Proem, that“ England * without being ruled out of court. Chesterton, writes an book, which is published in the World's Classics, by Henry Frowde. Mr day prophets, Chesterton is not at his best in this introductory essay. “All skepticism is like seasickness,” he writes; and we do not relish the figuré Nor do we admire its expansion: “If you cannot enjoy the universe it is better to throw it up.” Mr. Chesterton too often parodies himself in his occasional essays: and this kind of parody is the least admirable of against all. When, the everyday use of the however, he protests words “reactionary” and “progressive” as, inevitably, terms re- spectively of offence and of praise, we are more sympathetic “Progress,” he writes, “happens, in short, whenever men can en- And re- particular dure one tendency for a long tin action happens whenever some man can endure it no longer \ progressive is always a conservative he conserves the direction of progress. A reactionary is al- ways a rebel.” There speaks Chesterton in his better vein And his reactionary rebel is, of course, Carlyle It is good to have “Past and Present” in this new and excellent reprint. We are glad to see a good edition from the Clarendon Press, of Hobbes's ‘“‘Levia- than,” one of the great clarifying books, both for its style and its idea Nor does such praise necessarily imply an accept- ance of Hobbes’s theories, or of what would be their equivalent to-day. ‘It is idl says W. G. Pogson Smith, in his introductory es- say, “to qualify such a political philosophy: it is rotten at the core. It is valueless, save as it refutation content to leave it as a precious defini- morality. in so far stimulates to We may b« who need privilege to the lawyers, tions, and have no concern with > 17 has ever more And yet, no thinker on politics probed its fundamental conceptions thoroughly; and I say advisedly, if you would think clearly of rights and duties, sovereignty and law, you must begin with the criticism of Hobbes.” Mr Pogson Smith, whose recent death was much de- plored at Oxford, shows that he has him- self gone deeply into the analysis, not only of Hobbes, but of the political phil- osophy generally of that age and the next. of his remarks are penetrating, as when he speaks of Rousseau’s survey of human nature as often strangely and sus- piciously resembling that of Hobbes; but he fails, nevertheless, to give us the ap- preciation of Hobbism still so much need- ed. His comparison with Rousseau might have set him on the way, but he goes aside to consider subsidiary matters. What we desire is a thorough study of the element of social illusion, which, to Hobbes in the form of kingship, and to in the form of the rolonté générale (and, we might add, to Plato, and other philosophers in a variety of forms), seemed the necessary basis of government. In this, Hobbes and they differ in their respec- as essentially Some Rousseau Rousseau agree; tive views of human evil and egotistic or good and sympathetic. nature A proper study of Hobbes must, in the end, be psychological, rather than legal, and such a study Mr. Pogson Smith, with all his knowledge, does not give us interest in the poet has death will find in Arthur Readers revived by his whose been “Swinburne’s Dramas,” selected by Beatty (Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.), an at- volume edition of “Atalanta in Mary ious notes ex- tractive one Calydon.” “Erectheus,” and Stuart The editor has supplied judi plaining classical obscurities, and an intro- duction apparently not dictated by intem- perate enthusiasm In placing Swinburne beside Matthew Arnold as an interpreter of the results of “The Origin of Species,” he touches upon an important subject demand- ing rather fuller elucidation than he has rhyth- mical splendors of the choruses in the Greek al virtue felt on-dramatic been able to accord. In praising the plays he emphasizes a poeti in varying degrees in the ! well If dramas is to be of service in str offering of the ngthening Swinburne’s hold upon the publi it should s purely dra- work as this re invite reéxamination of what matic in the poet’s contributior It will never persuade any one that Swinburne had Webster Mary much virile mastered the art of Stuart,” though it contains verse, is merely the best in a trilogy of the formidably undramatic plays in the English language It lure some of the sad young people who go most should, however, al- about, intoxicated with mortality, chanting lines of “Hesperia” and “The Garden of Proserpine The star nor sun sha waken Nor any change of light it should allure those hot-blooded lovers of death into the sobering shadows of the Greek tragic spirit. There is in “Atalanta” Erectheus” not an intellectual, but depth, terror, which seems constantly to escape the easy and in an emotional a sense of pity and facile apprehension of critics It is to declare that the abandoned volubility of these plays, especially the earlier, is Swin- burnian and not Aeschylean or Sophoclean. On the other hand, it Is easy to point with
Page 24
518 delight to metrical or pictorial triumphs— the slaying of the boar, the choruses, the of Chthonia. To grasp their var- and respond vitally to their unity is another matter. For full participation in the terrific ideas of life, death, and destiny involved in the tragedy of Meleager, or in the magnificent of civic duty symbolized by Chthonia, demands a rebirth in the antique world, demands a reader di- collected, hearkening like the strick- (Edipus for the of the God Tt is a task for a still, long, sunlit morning or for the privacy of a stormy midnight; and sacrifice lety conception vested en voice it is worth while The authorities of the Jamaica Institute are about to follow up their publication of ‘Bibliographia Jamaicensis” by the is- sue of a Bibliography of the West Indies, omitting Jamaica. The work includes all islands in, and lands adjoining, the Carib- Sea. It is arranged chronologically each country, and geographically the beginning at Bar- bados and ending St. Vincent. It in- foreign countries and colonies, as British and has a The volume has been prepared of the institute, Frank who is the author of the “Biblio- bean under round Caribbean, with cludes well possessions, full by Cundall, as index the secretary nsis’’ (1902), and its supple- graphia Jamaice ment (1908) Mr. Cundall has done much to draw attention to Jamaica and other British West India colonies by his writings, which include “Studies in Jamaica His- tory “Biographical Annals of Jamaica”: “Jamaica in 1905" (a handbook of informa- tion for intending settlers and visitors): “Brief Guide to an Exhibition of Maps of the Sixteenth Century, illustrative of the Discovery of America,” and “Jamaica Place Names.” He is collaborating with Dr. Izett Anderson in the preparation of a collection of Jamaica proverbs rhe first volume of “The Correspondence of Jonathan Worth,” edited for the North Carolina Historical Commission by Prof J. G. de Roulhaec Hamilton of the University of North Carolina, has just appeared. The chief interest of the papers is in the light which they throw on political conditions in that State during the period of civil war and reconstruction Worth, who entered pub life early as a Whig, was one of the most determined opponents of secession, and the calling of a con- Federal n 1861 opposed vention to consider relations, on the ground that such action by the Legisla- ture Was unconstitutional. Like so many of his associates, however, he “went with his Btat« and while condemning both the war and the onduct of it, was active in urging enlistment and labored faithfully for the succes of the cause. His well-known Union sympatht earned him bitter opposition, but In 1862 he was appointed salt commis sioner for his country, and presently be came State treasurer, in which dificult of fice he achieved notable success In Au gust, 1863, he wae sure that peace was at hand, and that the masses were for it “on any termes but his loyalty to his State forbade him to take any part In the peace movements of 1863 and 1864. When W. W Holden became provisional Governor, Worth treasurer, and later which required him was made provisional State agent, an office to collect the scattered property of the State which had been seized by Federal of ficials or stolen outright by individuals. On [Vol. 89, No. 2317 The Nation. the downfall of the Holden administration, at the end of 1865, he became Governor, and the good fortune to commend himself Sickles, the military commander of the district; but with Sickles’s successor, Canby, whose administration took little account of either the prejudices or rights of the people, he was at sword’s points, though he succeeded in preventing the appointment of Albion W. Tourgee as a judge of one of the State courts. In 1868 he was removed from office “to facilitate the process of restoration,” and lived in retirement until his death the following year. Aside from their political interest, the letters afford some information regarding prices and the conditions of business during the war. The few references to the negro are always kindly, but at the end of the struggle Worth was apparently hopeless of finding a satis- factory race adjustment; for he writes to his brother in September,. 1865, that “‘it would be better for you and for everybody man to leave North Carolina,” since “we who were born here will never get along with the free negroes, especially while the foo!s and demagogues had to Gen else who is a white of the North insist they must be our equals.” As an intimate picture of conditions in the Far West during the last period of its epic history, the period from 1871 to 188%, when even the officers and soldiers of th: United army had to reckon with Indians desperadoes, we find Mrs. frances M. A. Roe’s “Army Letters from an Officer’s Wife’’ (D. Appleton & Com- pany) more than ordinarily interesting. It is not a pretentious book; the author as- us that “all flowery descriptions have been omitted,” but in spite of the lack of such floral ornamentation the wild land be- tween the Mississippi and the Pacific, with its perils and fascinations, is very vividly described. Mrs. Roe was with her husband during sixteen years of service in what was then Indian Colorado Territory, Montana Territory, Idaho Territory; and her account of the country and of life in camp bears the stamp of absolute ve- interesting experiment States and sures Territory, and racity It is an to recall one’s early impressions of Dead- wood Dick compeers and see how far they square with the realities as de- scribed by one who was in the magic land and his just about when we were reading of it in the dime novels. Mrs. Roe participated is the running down of Indians and was, on several occasions, nearly captured by them. One gathers that, in spite of such recrea- tion as buffalo and antelope hunting af- forded, supplemented by dancing and the- atricals, the life was an exceedingly hard The charm of a more than usually at- tractive personality is felt throughout the book, whether it is a question of the do- atic social life in officers’ circles, hunting or occasional encounters desperate and gentlemanly outlaws Mrs. Roe's sojourn beyond the Mississippi was broken by a short stay in the South At Vicksburg In 1877 she spent three weeks in the house of Jefferson Davis, whom she sketches with a good deal of sincere sym- one and parties, mie with pathy Calderon, indifferent to the future for- of his dramas, gave forth no per- sonally supervised editions of them, apart from a few autos or religious plays. After death, his Gongoristic disciple, Vera tunes his Tassis, published the most complete collec- tion of them, and this, in the opinion of so important a critic as Menéndez y Pe- layo, shows probable traces of alterations at the hands of the editor, who is not un- duly suspected of having introduced purple patches into some of the best works for the purpose of catching the depraved taste of the end of the seventeenth century. Vera Tassis’s edition is, unfortunately, the chief basis of the modern editions of Cal- deron’s plays. In the case, however, of the “Vida Es Suefio’’ we have also the edition, published (with several other Pieces) by the poet’s brother José in 1636, and then, surreptitiously, in the same year, at Saragossa. Making use of the two 1636 prints and of that by Vera Tassis (1685), Dr. Buchanan has prepared the present welcome edition. (“La Vida es Suefio”: Comedia famosa de D. Pedro Calderon de la Barca, 1636,. edited by M. A. Buchanan. Vol. I. University of Toronto Library). He has undoubtedly improved upon Keil, Hartzenbusch, MacColl, Krenkel, Menéndez y Pelayo and others, who, in the course of the nineteenth century, have sought to present the drama in critical form. In the choice of variants among the readings of his three texts Dr, Buchanan has shown good judgment, and we shall look forward with interest to the appearance of the sec- ond volume, in which he is to discuss the previous history of the theme of the play and its general literary importance. The quarto “Odyssey” printed at the Ox- ford University Press in the type designed by Robert Proctor will be treasured by all who love what is rare and beautiful. The type itself, as Mr. Proctor has explained, “is based on the celebrated Alcala font of 1514. This was cut by order of Cardinal Ximenes for use in the New Testament of the great Complutensian polyglot Bible, and is usually supposed, though there is no di- rect evidence, to owe its form to an an- cient manuscript which was sent to Spain by Leo X from the Vatican library to serve as the basis for the text of the New Tes- tament in that work.” Whatever the origin, it is singularly rich in curves, and, after the first look of strangeness has passed away, easy to read. The Alcala type had only one capital letter, a 0, and for the rest Mr. Proctor was obliged to call on his own inventive ingenufty. He has been highly successful here, with the exception, possibly, of the epsilon and omega, which would have better matched the other capi- if they had been more angular. But this is a small matter, and we give our opinion here with diffidence. The paper is identical in manufacture with that used by William Morris for his Kelmscott Press. The text is that of Dr. D. B. Monro, is- sued at Oxford, in 1901. The edition is lim- ited to 225 copies, and the price is four guineas. Such a book is distinctly and frankly a luxury, but why should not schol- arship have its own magnificent rewards? tals, In 1907 the British Academy accepted a gift of £10,000, bestowed in memory of Leopold Schweich of Paris, as the founda- tion of the “Schweich Trust,”’ to be devoted “to the furtherance of research in the ar- chmology, art, history, language, and lit- erature of ancient civilization with refer- ence to biblical study.” A portion of the has been appropriated for annual interest on the themes income lectures of general
Page 25
& ¥ ny % - of i] g ow a ee Se ee Sed ~~ = ol Nov. 25, 1909] indicated in the foundation. The first ad- dresses were made by Canon S. R. Driver on “Modern Research as Illustrating the Bible” (Henry Frowde). They sketch briefly the progress made in biblical arch- @ology in the nineteenth century, and, more particularly, describe the information which has been secured recently on the early history of Palestine from the in- scriptions and monuments brought to light from excavations. Excellent illustrations accompany the text. The principles of the “New Thought” movement in American religious circles are set forth in a series of tractates by the Rev. J. Herman Randall, pastor of the Mount Morris Baptist Church of New York. Some of the titles are: “The Real God,” “The Subconscious Mind.” “The Power of Suggestion,”’ “‘The Rebirth of Re- ligion.”” (H. M. Caldwell Co.) Henry Frank’s “Modern Light on Immor- tality” (Sherman, French & Co.) surveys all history, all biology, and all philosophy in its quest for evidence concerning the problem of life after death. Since the author has no first-hand and little accurate knowledge in any of these provinces. ani manifests no sense for the distinction be- tween guessing and reasoning, his book, which is written in pretentious and un- grammatical English, has only the meri of earnestness and of independence of tra ditional opinions. The Rev. M. W. Paterson of Trinity Col- lege, Oxford, makes no claim of original research for his “‘History of the Church of England’ (Longmans), yet it is an un- commonly good summary. The author's point of view is that of a moderate Angli- can, and the treatment is characterized throughout by fairness and self-restraint, even while party spirit still runs so high in the English Church that the books deal- ing with its history—and they are legion— are all too frequently partisan in method The account of the ecclesiastical revolution under Henry VIII and of the critical gen- erations that followed is, on the whole, ad- mirable. The eighteenth century, on the other hand, fares very badly. Nothing could be more unsatisfactory than the brief ref- erence to the deistic movement, and noth- ing further from the truth than the notion, traditional among English churchmen, that Bishop Butler’s “Analogy” gave deism its death blow. Deism succumbed to quite other forces, and hardly an important book of the eighteenth century had less influence in its own day than the “Analogy.” The nineteenth century, like the eighteenth, re- ceives relatively too little space. The ac- count of the Oxford Movement is fair and sane, but other matters get scant atten- tion. Taken as a whole, however, the book is one of the best, as it is one of the most readable, of the many brief histories of the English Church A bibliography of the hymns of Paul Ger hardt and of the editions of his poems and sermons, the biographies, monographs, popular essays, and addresses, and the mu- sical and dramatic observances occasioned by the celebration of the three hundredth anniversary of his birth in 1907, has been prepared by a warm admirer of Gerhardt, Rudolf Eckart (Pritzwalk: A. Tienken). The work of Prof. Karl Beth of the Pro- testant theological faculty of the Univer- sity of Vienna, entitled “Der Entwicklungs- The Nation. gedanke und das Christentum” (Berlin: Edwin Runge), is a sign of the times, as it is an earnestly meant and skilfully un- dertaken attempt to reach an understand- ing between the positive principles of Bib- lical Christianity and the development idea In the second part of the book Beth shows in detail the influence of this idea on such prominent problems of theology as Theodicy, Sin, the Original State of Man, Revelation, Jesus Christ, and Immortality Beth concedes that, in view of what the modern development philosophy has ac- complished, it is necessary even for ortho- dox theological thought to make conces sions that would have shocked older gen- erations The death is announced of William Rich- rd Morfill, professor of Slavoni lan- tuages at Oxford University and curator of the Taylor Institution From Paris is announced the death of the classical scholar, Henri Weil, who was born at Frankfort (1818) and educated at Heidelberg but became a. naturalized Frenchman (1848), and held several aca lemic appointments in the Université dé France In 1882 he wags elected to the Académie des Inscriptions, where he suc- ceeded Delaurier He was the editor of numerous texts and of several works of scholarship, among them “Théorie général de laccentuation latine’’ (in Ollabora tion with Benlew), 1855: “Etudes sur | drame antique’ and “Etudes sur l'an tiquité grecque,”’ 1900; Etudes de Lit rature et de rhythmique grecques,”” 1902 John Bannister Tabb, a professor at St Charles's College, Ellicott City, Md., and since 1884, a priest of the toman Catholic ehurch lied on November 1%, in hi sixty fifth year He was born in Amelia Coun tv. Virginia, and served during the civil wal n the Southern navy becoming 1864 a prisoner of war. Though his v have appeared even very cently in th magazines, Father Tabb wa ome months ago stricken with total blindness His published work includes ‘Poems Ly rics,”” “An Octave to Mary,” Rules of English Grammar,” “Poems Grav and Gay,” “Two Lyrics,”” and “Quips and Quid dits.” William M, Laffan, publisher of the New York Sun for the last twenty-five years died November 19 at his home in Law rence, L. I He was born in Dublin, Ire land, January 22, 1848. His education was received at Dublin University Later he studied at St. Cecilia’s School of Medicine On coming to this country, he entered jour nalism, and in 1870 became managing edi- tor of the San Francisco Bulletin Later he became editor and part owner of the Baltimore Bulletin In 1877 he joined the Sun as a general writer, being elected pub lisher in 1884. Three years later he found ed the Evening Sun. In 1900 he purchased the interests of the Charles A. Dana es- tat An abiding interest, other than that of journalism, was that which he always had in the fine arts. During an early visit to the far East, he began those studies of Chinese ceramics which he pursued through his life, the chief monument of which is his catalogue of the Morgan-Gar- lend collection in the Metropolitan Mu seum Upon the reorganization of the Metropolitan Museum, after the death of Gen, Cesnola, he was elected a trustee, and was ever an influential member of the com- mittee on acquisitions. He produced not only a considerable number of essays for newspaper publication, but also a volume entitled “American Wood Engravers,’ 1553 and he edited several monographs and cata logues Richard Watson Gilder, editor of he Century Magazine since its organization in 1881, died November 18 in New York clty He was born in Bordentown, N. J., Febru iry 8, 1844 His father was a Method! lergyman, from whom the author inherited perhaps, a part of his creative impuls Owing to his frailness, he was educated at home; but when the Northern cause seemed hreatened in the campaign of 1863, his state of health did not deter him from en listing in Landis’s Philadetphia Battery ind he was under fire in the defence of Carlisle In 1865 he entered newspaper journalism. Five years later he joined the staff of Hours at Home, a monthly maga- ne issued by the Scribners It was in the same year that Scribner's Monthly WVagazine was started under the leadership {f Dr. J. G. Holland Dr. Holland made Mr. Gilder managing editor of the new monthly. On the death of Dr. Holland, the managing editor became editor-in-chief, nd when, in 1881, the magazine was pv-- hased by Roswell Smith, and the nam hanged to the Century, he continued the litorship of the magazine under its new mie It is aS poet, however, rather than " edito tha Mr Gilder attained atest reputation His first collection of verses, “The New Day,’ was published in “Fiv Books of Song’ came ou a $o4, and included earlier publication In Palestine wa issued four years lates Poems and Ins ptions (1901), and A Christmas Wreath” (1903) and A Book of Music’’ (1906), both anthologies, followed Other books wer« For the Country Fire né ind In Helena’s Garden But Mr. Gilder was more than editor and man ot letters His enthusiasms included an er active sense of ivi respo b id he was an unflagging work: fo i y bea i] and th i rig ) \s resident of the Tenement House Commis- yn Of 1894, he achieved invaluable i his was one of the vy i vain, against th abandontr f John’s Chapel in Varick Street He w ne of the founder of the Society of Ar in Artists and of the Author Clu nd vill be remembered as one of the m of a circle of literary men of wt liam Dean Howells and Mark Twa urvive — science, (Lcology of Plants; an Introduction to the Study of Plant-Communities. By Eug. Warming, Ph.D., professor ot botany in the University of Copen- hagen. New York: Henry Frowde. $2.90. To some readers, the name of the branch of botany here treated will, per- haps, be new. It is that division of the science which attempts to answer all possible questions in regard to the manl-
Page 26
»2O _ The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 remains a vast group of autonomous plants, which are the common species all around us. This immense group has been divided and subdivided skilfully by Warming into minute classes, which have definite characteristics of structure fitting them for specific homes. It is this part of the subject which the general reader can easily strip of all embarrass- ing technicalities and interpret in terms of the familiar plants around his dwell- ing-place. Every bit of dry soil assumes a new interest as we look upon it, with its desert vegetation, and every swamp lying in the hot sun becomes a miniature jungle. It is by no means necessary to visit the tropics to find plants worthy of study as valiant fighters against great odds. In the tropics, plants have the climate which is best adapted to the most vigorous growth, but the struggle comes chiefly between the contesting kin- dred and the intruding strangers. Hence a tropical jungle has no fight against climate, whereas, in a tangled, wet thick- et in our so-called temperate climate, plants must contend with untoward cli- matic influences, with sudden frost, and most unwelcome thawing. protection against these perils, and the range of injury are among the objects of study in plant-ecology. In short, the cecologist is the historian of an unending battle, and, like the historians of hu- man warfare, he must take precautions against misipterpreting the signs of ad- vance and retreat. fold relations of plants to their sur- roundings. It touches, therefore, upon agriculture, horticulture, forestry, and economic botany, and makes use of the methods of morphology, physiology, and taxonomy. In fine, it leaves untouched very few interesting topics in the ap- plied biology of plants. Professor Warming this attractive field, and is recognized as its leading authority. His previous works on the subject have obtained wide circulation by their clearness and thor- oughness, and have exerted a profound influence. It is, therefore, with great pleasure that botanists receive this vol- ume, which is substantially new in all respects. The English publishers se cured the services of two eminent botan ists to prepare this edition, and they have had a great advantage over those who have hitherto made translations of scientific works. Professor Warming took the pains to prepare for these two botanists, who may be fairly called his English collaborators, fresh manuscript, and hence this volume differs widely from ordinary translations. He was as sisted in the preparation of the work by Dr. Vahl, his associate, and he has been aided throughout by the editorial skill of Professor Groom and Proitcssor Balfour. Like all new branches of science, ecology has a multiplicity of unfamiliar terms, but the occurrence of these in great numbers in Warming’s book must not discourage the general reader, who will find that there is hardly a prob lem presented which does not have its captivating aspects. Plant-ecol- ogy clearly recognizes the fact that every plant, in its struggle for ex istence, must be in harmony with its surroundings, or must disappear. When, therefore, we have before us a small patch of ground, with established vege- tation, we are forced to admit that these competing plants are the survivors in a is a ploneer in ume to all who are at all interested in the activities of living beings. The American Anthropological Association and the American Folk-Lore Society will meet in affiliation with Section H of the American Association for the Advancement of Science in Boston, December 27, 1909, to January 1, 1910. The Third International Congress to dis- cuss the education of children at home will be held in August, 1910, under the .patron- long fight, which has ended in a truce. 4.. of the Belgian government, in connec- If we compare the plants in one limited tion with the Universal Exposition at locality with -those which have been Brussels. The Congress will consist of five sections, for the study of children, of child- education, of abnormal children, of miscel- laneous subjects related to childhood, and of documentation, Americans wishing to participate in its discussions, or to further its work by becoming members should correspond with the secretary of the Prof. W. C. Bagley, peacefully growing together for a long while In another place, we at once the differences which separate plant- communities. And this brings us face to face with the difficult and absorbing ly Interesting questions, why the specieg congregate to form plant-communities, why these have a characteristic physiog- see respectively. American committee, Urbana, Illinois. nomy, and why they are distinctly lo- English writers are awakening to the Im- calized. The “growth-form” of a plant, portance of a scientific study of afforesta- as it is called, is the external and iIn- tion. An elaborate volume on this subject ternal structure, which has developed is announced by T. Fisher Unwin in Perci- in complete harmony with the environ- v4! Trentham Maw’s “Practice of Forest- ment Here we meet the first of the "% The writer was formerly professor at newer technical terms, namely ephar- ‘"® Cirencester Agricultural College mony of species. These epharmont: “Mendelism,” by R. C. Punnett (New York: Wilshire Book Co.), is a work which deserves a better setting than the poorly printed pages and the blurred diagrams of | this American edition. The whole treatise is of small size, and comprises only three dis- | tinct papers, together with a short but in- growth-forms are the units in «cology. Leaving out of view the plants which are dependent on other plants for nu- trition or for mechanical support, likewise those which are aquatic, and there Methods of | | sions. teresting preface by the American editor. The first essay gives in a limited space a cléar acédant 4f Men@el’s experiments and inferences; the second applies the so-called principles to practical improvement of or- ganisms, and the last essay is controversial. The second of these papers (“Applied He- redity”) is reprinted from Harper’s Monthly for December, 1908, and is doubtless re- membered by many readers, because of its attractive account of Professor Biffin’s successful attempts to improve cereal grains in England. JOHN GALSWORTHY’S “STRIFE.” The production of John Galsworthy’s “Strife” is the most satisfactory achieve- ment of the New Theatre up to the pres- ent time. It is good in itself and an earnest of better things to come. The play, in comparison with the great bulk of contemporaneous stage shows, is a notable piece of dramatic work. It deals with a subject of vital and present in- terest, it is full of vivid incident and of characterizations which are veritable transcripts from actual life. But it is not a great play, because it is founded upon insufficient premises, is specious and illustrative rather than logical in its development, and because it ends inconclusively, so far as the main prob- lem is concerned, or, at all events, in a /moral which is by no means vf univer- We can heartily recommend this vol- ‘sal application. \ The action covers the last six hours of a strike in some tin- platé mills, which has been in progress for many months, to the great loss of the employing company and the direst suf- fering on the part of the workers and their families.- The directors, on the one hand, save their president, John An- thony—an indomitable old fighter --and ‘the men, on the other—with the excep- tion of their fanatical leader, David Rob- erts—are ready to accept a certain com- promise, but neither chieftain will yield by a hair’s breadth. At last, when the credit of the company has been shaken and ruin is impending, and when Rob- erts’s wife has died of starvation, the more timid directors overrule their chairman, while the men desert their champion, and the original compromise, which would have obviated all the loss and suffering, is addépted. Both the protagonists are discredited and broken, and the savage struggle has been whol- ly fruitless. “That,” says the union dele- : e as the cuntain falls, “is where the n comes in.” The im is that all strikes, with their eaheuiiibe accompaniments, might be avoided by mutual conces- That is true. It is also a plati- tude. But it does not follow, by any means, that a comprom!se must neces- sarily be the wisest, or even the most humane, policy. A concession, for Iin- ‘stance, that would spell financial ruin
Page 27
A gi dest ope PAP rhe pov pebinak lence scabies scat Rcd. .:aik ons one Saad : Nov. 25, 1909] The Nation. in the near future, would not greatly benefit those who extorted or those who granted it. This is the argument used by old John Anthony and no attempt is made to refute it. This is the essent‘al weakness of Mr. Galsworthy’s play, that it generalizes unjustifiably from a par- ticular instance. As a demonstration of femiliar and conceded evils, it is pic- turesque, forcible, and truthful, but it suggests no practical solution of the problem which it proposes. It simply arrays antagonistic facts and figures without any effort to establish a balance \Dbetween them. | But his representation bf the conditions which he has selected is admirable. ; His directors are all live men, most cleverly and consistently dif- ferentiated. Anthony and Roberts, bold in contrast, are absolutely veracious types. His workmen and their women are sketched with equal felicity and with rare power of observation. His dia- logue, too, is singularly appropriate to each speaker, simple, significant, for- cible, and unaffected. He knows how to be realistic, without being vulgar or trivial. And the convincing way in which he was interpreted by the New Theatre company is a most hopeful indication of its future capacity. Louis Calvert, a little deficient, per- haps, in techiness and choler—in sheer brutal domination—furnished a finished and striking study of narrow but rea- soned obstinacy, as President Anthony, while Albert Bruning, an actor of great ability, contributed a really remarkable embodiment of the ascetic, fanatically radical Roberts. His impersonation thrilled with fiery zeal. Another notable characterization was the life-like Welsh- man of Ben Johnson, with its humorous admixture of piety and prudence. Almost equally good was the passionate acting of M‘ss Thais Lawton as his daughter, Madge, maddened by a sense of needless misery. Both Mr. Gottschalk and Mr. McVay, the one as a fussy, egoistic and timid. the other as a dull, lethargic, ut- terly selfish director, acted with hu- morous veracity, while Mr. Anson, as the younger and more sympathetic An- thony, played with distinction and feel- ing. The stage s2tting and management —especially of a mob scene—were ad- mirable. In fact, the whole achievement was of a high order of merit, though a clear mistake was made in shifting the locality of the piece from England to this country. Several of the chief per- sonages are too essentially British to harmonize with their American environ ment. A dramatization by Philip Littell of W J. Locke’s “Septimus,” which was tried ip the Hackett Theatre on Monday evening did not prove very successful. The story, not easily credible in its original form seemed still less plausible and much less pleasant when reduced, without much dex- terity, to its bare incidents. George Ar- liss, a dry and mannered but humorous and skilful comedian, succeeded in repro- ducing the surface characteristics of Sep- timus with much cleverness, but failed to suggest the finer intellectual and mora! qualities which distinguish him from the common brood of eccentric simpletons. He excited plentiful laughter, and the delicacy of his technical execution commanded ad- miration, but the true soul of the part eluded him altogether. With Septimus main ly an excuse for merriment, the production of course, had small dramatic or literary importance. Recruits for the New Theatre company in New York city include Miss Annie Russell last seen in “The Stronger Sex,” and, just previously, as Puck in a revival of “A Mid summer Night's Dream,”’ Matheson Lang and Guy Bates Post, who will, it is under- stood, have the principal réle in Edward Sheldon's play of the new South ‘The Nigger.”’ Euripides’s ““Medea” in Gilbert Murray's verse translation will be produced in Jor lan Hall, Boston, on the evening of LD ember 10 and on the afternoon of Ds cember 11, under the auspices of the Bryn Mawr Club of Boston. The proceeds are to swell the fund being raised for the further endowment of the college George Riddle who played C£dipus in the Harvard pro duction of that play, twenty-eight years since, has been appointed coach for the performances. Joseph Lindon Smith is plan- ning and supervising the scenery and cos- tumes, and Malcolm Lang has composed the music for the choruses and is training the singers and accompanists Mr. H. B. Irving is steadily growing; per haps it will not be long before he is gen erally acknowledged as the legitimate he'r to his father’s position as master of the English stage. True, he has not yet wholly scaped from his troublesome identification with some of his father’s most famous parts. Just now he has attained great su ess in a revival of The Lyons Mail,’ at the Queen's Theatre London The Times mments (the words are, of course, not Mr. Walkley’s) that the genius of the on i: the same as his father’s in this respect ‘that he turns what in the hands of many good actors would be meré nelodrama nto a vivid and real tragedy.’ Formed only in March of th present year, under the special patronage of J M. Barrie, Ellen Terry. Sir A. W. Pinero Sir Charles Wyndham, and others, the Playwrights’ Association in London is al ready so well advanced in practical work ing order as to be able to announce the presentation of two plays at the Aldwych Theatre. These are a comedy in three acts, “Love in a Tangl: by Harry B. Vo gel, and a one-act play The Debt,”’ from the pen of Mrs. Tom Godfrey—both au thors, who, in accordance with the require ments of the “regulations,” have not had a three or four-act play produced by an recognized London management in the eve ning sas We have referred to the completion of a new drama by Gerhart Hauptmann, of which the title is now announced: ‘The Night.” The piece is intended for the Lessing Theatre, Berlin The dramatist’s brother, Karl Hauptmann, has meantime made his first appearance as a playwright His offering takes the form of two Napo- leon dramas oi Louls N. Parker's English version of the three-act play by René Fauchois, Reet hoven,”’ first given at the Odéon last spring will be produced by Sir Beerbohm Tree at His Majesty's Theatre, this evening The composer is not for the first time pre sented on the stage; he appeared as a character in a play by Pietro Cossi, pro duced at Milan, as weil as in a German plece, “Beethoven und sein Neffe,”’ by Hein rich Heinemann, and in an earlier French play by Walther Schinz, produced at Paris in 1907 The Teatro Argentina of Rome, which bears to the Italian stage something of the relation of the Comédie Francaise to that of France, opens its present season on De cember 1. The piece chosen for the open ing is a comedy by Goldoni The modern repertory for the season 1909-1910 will in clude the French plays “Connais-toi,” by Paul Hervieu Griselda,” by Gerhart Hauptmann, and Galsworthy’'s “Strife.” Among the new Italian pieceswill be Butti I} Paese della Fortuna,” Moschini's ‘Tris tano « solta Giulio di Frenai’s Satur nale Cirinini’s Reginetta,”’ Vannicola’s Elsa labandonnata Lucio dAmbra’'s “Es li Soldani's “Andrea del Sarto Beneili's Il Amore dei tre re,”’ and unnamed coms dies by Nino Martorio and Vincenzo Morel- lo. There will be also an adaptation of A Midsummer Night's Dream,’ by the poet and novelist, Diego Angelo, for the performance of which Mascagni has been ngaged to conduct the orchestral rendi tion of the music of Mendelssohn \Lusie. The Ma illan Company will publish at in early dats \ Book of Operas by H E. Krehbiel, the veteran musical critic of the New York Trihune An account of the history and plots of the more celebrated op eras, with little or nothine of technical criticism, is promised A sixth printing of | L. Burlingame’s translation of the Art Life and Theories of Richard Wagner,” selected from his writings s announced by Henry Holt & Co. In this one volume the cream is skim— med from the eleven volume f the German edition of the master's works There « a steady nprovement mn the quality of the songs selected and printed for use in public schoo's. “Standard Songs and Choruses,” by M F MacConnell (American took Co.) orroborates this statement It s encouraging to find in such a collection n place of che trash formerly offered, such gems as Schumann's Lotus Flower Schubert's “Hark! Hark! The Lark Grieg's “To a Primrose,” Cho pin’s “Maiden’s Wish.” Such son¢s cannot fall to awaken a love of what is best in music, which ought always to be the chief object of mupical exercises in schoola though it seldom is The revival of dancing is among the striking phenomena of the day Ine of its most iInterestine branches is well fl lustrated in “The Folk Dance Book,” com piled by Dr. C. Ward Crampton, director of physical training in the New York pub lie echools (A. 8. Barnes & (o.) Here are “The Chimes of Dunkirk,” a “Danish Dance of Greeting,” a “Shoemaker’s Dance,”
Page 28
522 a “Children’s Polka,” a “Vineyard Dance,” an “English Harvester’s Dance,” a “Fin nish Reel,” a “Cossack Dance,” and others variety The music is given in in great each case, reduced to its simplest form, so that any one can play it at sight; and pre- ceding it are detailed directions to the dancers. This form of exercise the elements of song, drama, and vigorous muscular work. The present col lection is carefully supervised, everything that might prove objectionable being elimi- tribute to the ‘ombines play, nated The editor pays a teachers of physical training and the class teachers in the New York city schoois “whose devoted efforts have developed folk dancing in its sphere to the great benefit and joy of many thousands of children.” legitimate LD’ Albert Mottl, hagen, Stradal, Wolfrum, and Weingartner are the editors of the complete edition of issued in Breitkopf & Hartel. In their publishers say pertinently Busoni, Reuss, Staven Liszt's compositions, now being Leipzig by prospectus the that, if these works really were, as some still maintain, Insignificant, the would have long since passed them by world died at aged fifty-nine He had made several popular musi- Francis Thomé, the composer, Paris on November 16, years cal adaptations of poems by Hugo, Musset, Lamartine, etc., and was the author of nu- merous compositions for planotorte as well as of songs and of operas, inciuding Roméo et Juliette Art. rWO KINDS OF REALISM In the past days the National Museum at Rome and our own Metropolitan Mu seum have put on exhibition each a Greek statue displaying the unusual characteristic of realism Yet a great er contrast than these two marbles af ford can hardly be One has to remind himself that the Temple Min imagined istrant of Rome, a mere serving maid at her work, is not a hymph or even a goddess, while at first glance the Old Market Woman of the Metropolitan strikes one 28 a bad genre piece of no both presumably not a very ancient date Yet were cut by Grecian hands century, either way, Milo. On bler figure of the two appears the most from the Venus of close scrutiny aiso, the no- conscientiously realisth while the form is prettified for effect. We with ideals of Greek realism, and since realism is the meaner have to do contrasting leading artistic motive of our genera tion, a comparison of the two manners should be instructive First, as nearer at hana at the Old Market Woman forward crying her we will look She strains The whole is contorted as by a sort of recoil wares body from her vociferation Her tight arm, dainty before a possible buyer; her left clasps two fowls to her side while the hand holds a laden basket Her brow and now missing, brandished some The Nation. exposed breasts display the outrages of time, but her legs and sandalled feet have through the drapery the easy ele- gance of a Tanagra statuette. The art- ist has flinched from creating a com- plete effigy of shrivelled decrepitude. No Greek has given us the tragic fact em- bodied so pitifully in Rodin’s Armorer’s Wife. This Market Woman is caught at her most energetic moment, at one of those instants in which she defied her habitual lassitude. Surely, the theme is highly characteristic. Why, then, is the impression of the thing so unsatisfying? An examination of the Temple Minis- trant will go far to answer the question. The Temple Ministrant at Rome is plainly a daughter of the people. Her sturdy body is girt by a clumsy yet dec- orative mass of drapery rolled tight to raise the impeding garment from her ankles. Her hair shows nothing of that elaboration which we have come to re- gard as invariable in Greek sculpture. Two short tresses are drawn forward from the nape of the neck and roughly knotted over the brow—just the easiest method of getting the hair out of the The head is as boyish as the fig- The Girl of Anzio, as the Italians call her affectionately after the place of her discovery, is standing intent on some minor office in the cult. Her left arm bears the fragment of a salver upon which stood some utensil needed for the service. Her firmly poised body betrays her solicitude. The eyes re- gard the salver fixedly, less with rever- ence, it seems to us, than with a sim- ple determination that the trifling ser- vice shall be well performed. Yet the beauty of this menial action is akin to that of the processional marbles of the Parthenon, and the realistic traits in fig- ure, costume, and hair-dressing so read- ily adjust themselves to the grand style of the that with difficulty does one perceive that these elements The whole thing is of a lofty yet intimate beauty which finds Christian expression in the famil- lar lines: way. ure. whole only are quite exceptional Who sweeps a rocm as for Thy laws Makes that and th’ action fine, Between the Temple Ministrant and the Old Market Woman there is an im- difference in workmanship, the latter being quite mediocre in execution, but this difference is transcended by a far deeper discrepancy in vision. Who- ever made the Old Market Woman saw her as she seen, and as every He accepted for his theme just the insight of every- bedy about. Whoever created the beau- tiful Temple Ministrant managed to see something that probably everybody else overlooked. The common gaze doubtless been on the statue of the divinity, or on the officiating priest. It was the artist who caught the simple majesty of that robust figure poised as it held faithfully a cup, a knife, or some mense chose to be passer-by saw her would have | Vol. 89, No. 2317 such nothing. The joy of that discovery we feel as we look upon the Girl of Anzio. Yes, the difference transcends technic. You might put the Roman statue through a series of casts and reductions until in handling it became infinitely the inferior of the Old Market Woman, yet it, whatever its debasement, would remain wholly superior as a work of art. It is, as with all creation, a question of vision. If you do your seeing with sim- ple curiosity, accepting unchallenged the average testimony of the eye and the casual observation of all the world, no technical mastery will save the result from cheapness and essential insignifi- cance. The true artist is the aristocrat of the eye. He makes his bold exclu- sions and stern selections. He looks deep into appearances, and is wary of their immediate appeal. Thus he re- veals things that the rest of us are too hurried or too untrained to see at all. Let no one say that the mere age and ugliness of the Old Market Woman are the trouble. She simply is seen too quickly and at the wrong moment. There is now at the Union League Club, a picture by Daumier in which market- women and decrepit clerks are huddled into a third-class compartment, and the group and each individual have the sombre distinction that we associate with Michelangelo and Millet. It seems all a matter of the aristocracy of the eye. Otherwise the difference between the artist and the average man would be merely quantitative—only that, for example, between the champion golfer and the awkward amateur. The Story of Dutch Painting. By C. H. Caffin. New York: The Century Co. $1.20 net. Mr. Caffin has taken advantage of the Loan Exhibition of Dutch painting to bring out one more of those books which he produces with such facile amenity. He gives in attractive form a consider- able amount of historical and biograph- ical information of timely interest. His enthusiasms are safe, his style eugag- ing and well-bred—in fact, he commands so many of the qualifications of an esthetic mentor that one feels a dis- tinct ungraciousness in going below the suave appearance to the critical reality. And, first of all, though much is said about the times, the lives of the artists, and the subjects of the pictures, sur- prisingly little is said about the pic- tures themselves—and that often in very general terms. Frequently words are used in the loosest sense. “Abstract,” for example, as applied to Rembrandt, seems to mean nothing more than spir- itual. But the word leads Mr. Caffin into linking Rembrandt up with the Far Eastern painters and the modern follow- ers of Matisse. Now, these moderns may or may not belong in this galley, but nothing is more certain than that & : : t Hy
Page 29
Mera de eee MEW Ei os, o Nov. 25, 1909} the most phantasmagoric invention of Rembrandt is based firmly on reality. He always consents to the appearance, nowever he may sublimate it for his own purposes. To confound him with the Buddhist painters, real followers of the abstract, only wastes words. Botti- celli, Greco, Goya, Blake, may seem vari- ously to belong in such a category, but hardly Rembrandt. Mr. Caffin is caught as he frequently is by putting on an equal basis the artist's concrete work and his own inferences as to its spirit. The neglect of facture as such will, indeed, seem to many the cardinal de- fect of this interesting book. One might read it without grasping that masterly touch by which main planes and linear accents are made identical, which is the especial contribution of Frans Hals to painting. Again, Hals is called “a fol- lower of surfaces” as if that were a de- fect in a painter. Note the subtle con- fusion between the literary and techni- cal connotation of the term. Mr. Caf- fin seems to imply superficiality as a defect where an artist would regard it as a high merit. One may well doubt whether those pathetic masterpieces, the latest of Hals’s regent pictures, do, in- deed, bespeak a senile decline. Fromen- tin said as much, but still felt the rare emotional qualities of the work. But is it possible that only palsy and failing sight put Hals in position to compete with Rembrandt? Many will feel that here we have to do with an ultimate and superb experiment. The later years of Titian afford an interesting parallel, and here, too, we are asked to believe that his most tremendous work is a product of disintegration. Such judg- ments will bear revision. Vermeer of Delft is treated with a somewhat perfunctory enthusiasm, for here our guide fears lest we be over-per? suaded by a consummate technique—a peril which is possibly small. There is no recognition of the variety and love liness of the textures; even Chardin is not Vermeer’s superior in this regard. But, again, such considerations may seem perverting to the simplicity of the popular view of art. This book, with its numerous well- chosen reproductions from European galleries, will hardly serve the turn of those who love painting as such. Those, however, who wish merely information about artists and their times, and dis- cursive meditation about pictures, will find it both edifying and entertaining. From Lemcke & Buechner we have re- ceived sample sheets, with a plate of Count 4. de Laborde’s “Les Manuscrits 4 pein- tures de la Cité de Dieu de Saint Augustin.” This fine work will be published in largest folio with more than one hundred and thir- ty heliogravures The edition (for sale) is limited to 100 copies, and the price is 250 francs. Of the bibliographical value of the work the name of the author is 4 guar- antee Fhe Nation. From the same source we have the pros- pectus of “Die Bildnisminiatur in Deutsch- ijand von 1550 bis 1850," by Ernst Lembur- gen. The form is small folio; there will be 65 colored and 300 monochrone reproductions; the edition is of 400 copies, and the sub- scription, subject to increase after Decem- ber 5, is from 200 marks, according to binding The sculptor Rodin and the art-critic and poet Charles Morrice are collaborating on a book treating of old French churches When the late Mr. Walters of Baltimors invested in Barye bronzes, Barye and his friends, the painters at Barbizon, were held in cheap consideration by their com patriots The Baltimore man bought the sculptor’s works Scotch amateurs th painters’ They were wise in their gen eration \ good opportunity to see Barye at his best is afforded by the exhibition of some of his bronzes at the Cottier Gal leries in New York city There are fine Baryes, many of them early proofs, at the Metropolitan ind there was an xcellent colle ion to be seen last season at the Grolier Club, but these specimens were and at show! under glass At Colt s one sees the bronzes quite exposed And to appreciat: ich work to the full, this is the great condition Pete Kroeyer, the Danish pair lied n Copenhagen November 21 Pierre Langlade, the designer whose death is announced from Scotland, was of French birth, but had long resided in that part of the world where he died at the age of ty-seve! Another artist, English by adop ol who ha ecemtly died at ig eighty-on Edward Rischgit i native of Hungars \ ipil of Corot he has bes better | \ i i acher ha i x hibit I H vas one of tl f ler of t | 1 So y of Pa I her nd i I 1 i ipest! gnin ind i i t ye Finance. THE WHOLE WORLD'S HARVEST The Liverpool estimate of Broomhall or. the whole world’s wheat crop of 1909, perhaps the most important of the an nual European calculations, is at hand this week. It shows the present year to have established an absolute high record in wheat output. The 3,346,968,000 bushels named as the world’s total mean an increase of 9% per cent. over the 3,- 063,280,000 of 1908. Compared with the 3,226,768,000 bushels of 1906, the pre- vious record, the increase is 3% per cent.; compared with the year of scar- c'ty, 1907, it is 15 per cent Two continents exceed all preceding records with their wheat production— North America and Europe. North Amer- ica runs 17,000,000 bushels above 1901, which was the previous record. Europe's total runs 158,616,000 bushels beyond 1908, and surpasses the previous high record, that of 1906, by 21,160,000. Bv- ery important wheat-growing country of the world shows increase over the pre- N23 vious year except Austria-Hungary, Ger- many, and Spain. Russia's harvest runs 68,800,000 bushels beyond its previous high record. Canada’s crop is 24,000,000 bushels above .ts best previous yield The English harvest is the largest since 1899, and with that exception the largest since 1892; though it is highly interest- ing to observe that its 64,000,000-bushel yield of 1909, while making these en- couraging comparisons, is still less than half the 140,000,000-bushel harvest of 1855, which has never since been equalled. No such change in the world’s grain trade from the two years of actual scart ity 1907 and 1908, could occur with out important results on commerce finance, and industry. The wheat crop shortage of 1907, pretty much through out the world, may have had some effect in aggravating the financial disturbences of that vear The failure of 1908 to replenish the empty storehouses—the whole world’s “visible supply” of wheat at the end of that year’s harvest, was 14,000,000 bushels below even that of a year before—caused the past season enormous shrinkage in the internatior al grain trade, and also made possib! the extortionate price to which heat and flour were raised in last May's “Pat ten corner” at Chicago It is a mat ter of interest, then, to inquire how far the financial situation generally will b benefited by the new turn in event The two immediate question ‘hich irise are first, what is the bearing of this harvest on the world’s industrial prosperity, and, second, what is its bear ing on our own export trade in grain’ That return to abundant harvests, afte scarcity, will be a help to better times a certainty. It is commonly said that the world-wide industrial activity of 1906 and 1905 had its origin largely in the world’s bumper wheat crops of (ose vears, and the inference is reasonable It is also true, however, that the wheat vield does not settle everything The world’s bad wheat crop of 1889 was a companied by an industrial “boom, ' and the two years of troubled markets, 1893 and 1884, broke all previous records in the harvests. This does not prove that good crops or bad crops had no effect at all, but it shows that the harvest’s in fluence may be superseded by other eco nomic forces. In the years referred to, it was the money market whose influence was paramount. Unbounded financial confidence and easy credit offset.the bad world’s harvest of i889; derangement of money markets, due to abuse of capt- tal and credit, offset the good harvest results of 1884 and 1893. Our export trade in wheat will be in- fluenced necessarily by the fact of bumper crops abroad. In so far as Europe raises enough to feed itself, it has less need to draw on the United States; and even in those European markets which must always buy foreign wheat, Russia
Page 30
Jt 24 and Canada are already competing ac- tively with our exporters. This would apparently mean that wheat prices can- not continue high. The question of storehouses depleted as a result of two short crops just before 1909, is, how- ever, also to be considered. The gran- aries of the world, on November 1, held SOOO O00 bushels less of wheat than in but slightly more than in 1908 or What is more immediately inter- that the stored-up supply in Europe's hands, though still some 12,- 000.000 bushels below November, 1906, is 1vOe ie esting is above all other years since 1904. In other words, a long forward step has already been taken towards restoring normal equilibrium between supply and de mand BOOKS OF THE WEEK r The Travelling Companions: a > y in Scenes Dutton $1 , Apologia and Florida. Trans. by H. Fk. Butler Frowde $1.15 \ ough, J. San Celestino. Putnam. $1.50 Barclay. F. L rhe Rosary Putnam, $1.35 Barn A. M A Little Lady at the Fall of Quebec Phila Penn Pub. Co Bart \. | The House on Cherry Street Dodd, Mead $1.50 Beach, BE. L An Annapolis Second Class man Phila Penn Pub. Co Chesterton, G K Tremendous’ Trifles Dodd, Mead $1.20 net Church, 8. H Religious Progress in Amer- a Address del. before the Centennial Convention of the Christian Church, Oct 16 Pittsburgh, Pa R. P. Morris. ‘orzins, P. H. Parliamentary Law Penn Pub. Co ‘ollins, W. W Cathedral Dodd, Mead. $3.50 net Devle, A. C rhe Crime bleday, Page Ldmison J P land Phila Phila Cities of Spain of the Congo. Dou- Stories from the Norse Penn Pub. Co ‘liot G. F. 8S Botany of To-day. Lippincott $1.50 net Smerson, R. W Journals, 1824 Vol Il 1832 Boston: ton Mifflin each nglish Love Old and New Edited by H. 8. Krans. Putnam. $1.25 net nelish Prose F A gelected list of about 800 titles and Minneapo!'s HWesW Ww Feininger K \n of Muale Aug Phila Vol. I, 1820- Hough- 1824 $1.75 net Poems iction authors lsaon Co 15 cente Experiential Psycholog: Gemiinder & Sons Fiction Catalog Selected List of 1.790 Titles: also an enlarged list Two book let Minneapolis: H. W. Wilson Co. 20 and cents respectively Fitch, CC A Wave of Life: A Novel Mitchell Kennerley $1.50 hroulkes, ¢ Armour & Weapons Frowde $2.15 net Ford, 8. Honk Honk!! Mitchell Kennericy 50 centa Foravth, M I The Beginnings of New York Boston: RG. Badger Foster John W Diplomatic Memoirs 2 voles Houghton MifMfiin $6 net Frewen, H. M Light Among the Leaves London David Nutt riendly Sona of St. Patrick in the City of New York 125th Annual Dinner 1909 Gale, FE. J Pewter and the Amateur Col lector Seribner. $2.50 net Gale, Z Friendship Village Love Stories Macmillan $1.50 Gordon, 8. D. Quiet Talks on Home Ideals Revell Co 75 cents Gould, FE. L Felicia’a Friends Phila Pub. Co Poems Published in 1768 One Thousand Salads Penn ray Green, © $1 net Grifith, H. § Penn Pub. Co Hale, P. L. The Madonna & Guild Co $1.50 Frowde Putnam Patty of the Cireus. Phila Boston: Bates The Nation. Hall, J. R. The Bourbon Restoration. Houghton Mifflin. A Junior in the Line. ton: Hare, T. T. Penn Pub. Hayes, E. ton: G. H, Higgins, A. C, pah Phila. Hosmer, 8. C. of Charades Hutchinson, Boston: Ho Insel zig: Insel-V James, A. L. nam. $1.25 James, H Its Pennell $7.50 net Jefferson, E. P Intimate Recollections of Joseph Jefferson. Dodd, Mead. $3.50 net John Rylands Library. Manchester. Lon-, don Sherratt & Hughes. Johnson, A. T. Chickens, and How to Rais« Them. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Johnston, C. H. L. Famous Indian Shiefs Boston Almanach Co. Ellis Co, A Little : Penn . Boston: $4 net. Letters to a College Girl 65 cents. Princess of Tono- Pub. Folded Meanings: R. G. Badger. $1. Diseases. Co. Ww Preventable ughton auf erlag. Housekeeping for net, ilian Boston Page & Co Mifflin. das Jahr 1910. Hours. Houghton Illus. by Joseph $1.50. $1.50 Two. Phila. : a Book net Leip- Mifflin Jones, C. P The Countersign: a Story © Tibet. Boston: R. G. Badger. $1.50. Jusserand, J. J. A Literary History of the English People. Vol. III, Part ii. Put- nam. 3.50 net Keats Poems Published in 1820. Frowde Lubonularve. KE. Fairy Tales lll. by A. A Dixon, Dutton. $2.50 Lathbury, E. The Sinking Ship Holt $1.50 Latimer, C. W. Girl and Woman: A Book for Mothers and Daughters net. Laut, A. C, North How to Acq redge. $1.25 Little Tots’ L Jack and th Hop-o-My-Thumb; ing Hood: G Lucian’s RS. me & notes in Gre Macaulay's H Ill. With ley Frowd« McFall, C. H. talized by ductions in ¢ McIntyre, J. T. it Lexington Mather, Cotton Collins. Rev. N., lished by Ba Miltoun, F ( Burgundy ton: Page & Boston: Lawrence, E. G Dialogues. the Canada, the Ginn & Co. Empire $1.75 ne The Power of Speech and Appleton. $2 of the 1ire It Hinds, Noble & Eld- ibrary, containing six books e Beanstalk; Puss in Boots; Cinderella; Red Rid- oldilocks ». Rouse; ek. istory introduction cents. ». 60 Beautiful Masters olor. The . Phila.: Los umgardt ‘astles and Illus. by B. Co. $3. Same, Two ‘books. of England. Dodd, Young Penn Elegy on the Death of the Angeles: Pub Chateaux Mc Manus by A Children With Mead. Co. Dutton. $1. Prepared for schools with short Frowde. Chapte: L. Bow- Immor- 50 repro- $5 net. Continentals Pub. Co. Repub- of Gld Pos- Modes and Manners of the Nineteenth Cen- tury. Trans Rhys ton: R. G. B Moon, R. O Philosophy Miiller, J 3 vols. Montenegro, C. by M Dutton. Alcestis adger. Edwardes; 1.25 $7 net a Drama intro. by G. Bos- The Relation of Medicine to Longmans, Green Hindrances of Life Trans. by F. F. Strecker. Mitchell Kennerley. £1.50 Mvers, F. A. Apologies for Love. Boston: R. G. Badger. $1.50, Newbolt, H. The New June. Dutton. $1.35 net. Oleson, A. Motor Control UCU. 8. Navy Elee- tric Series No. 1. Van Nostrand 50 cents net One Hundred Choice Selections for Read ing and Recitations No. 39. Phila.. Penn Pub Co. Ovid's Metamorphoses. Book III Edited with Introduction and notes by M. Cart- wright. Frowde. 50 cents Oxford Plain Texts De Quincey’s Spanish Military Nun, and Revolt of the Tartars; Macaulay's I listory of England, Chapter if 2 vols Frowde. 25 cents each. Paine, A. B. Elsie and the Arkansas Bear Phila.: Altemus Co. $1 Payne, W. The Automatic Capitalists. Bos ton R. G. Badger Perkins, J. G. The Life of the Hon. Mrs. Norton Holt 3.50 net Perry, F. F. Their Hearts’ Desire. Illus, by Harrison Fisher. and decorated by Theo. B. Hapgood. Dodd, Mead. $2 net Plato’s Ton Intro. and notes by St. George Stock Frowde. 60 cents Bos- Bos - Put- [ Vol. 89, No. 2317 Pond, E. L. The Tories of Chippeny Hill, Conn. Grafton Press. Powell, L. P. Heavenly Heretics: Jon. Edwards, John Wesley, H. Bushnell, Phillips Brooks, William E. Channing. Putnam. $1.25 net. Priestman, D. T. Home Decoration. Phila. : Penn Pub. Co. Putschi, Ferdiand. Charles Churchill, Sein Leben und Seine Werke. Vienna: Wilhelm Braumiiller. Quick, H. American Inland Waterways. Putnam. $3.50 net. Rackham, R. B. The Nave of Westminster From the Proceedings of the British Academy. Vol. IV Frowde Rantiett, S. A. The Shepherd Who 4id ‘Not Go to Bethlehem. Boston: R. G. Badg- er. $1 Raymond, E. Carlota of the Rancho. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Reader, E. The Story of the Little Merman. Macmillan. $1.50. Remick, G. M. Glenloch Girls. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Roe, E. R Run and Ruin: the Story of Dr. Caldwell. Chicago: Laird & Lee. $1. Royal Historical Society Transactions. Third Series. Vol. III London: Offices of the Society. Fuyl, B. B. Little Indian Maidens at Work and Play. Dutton. $1.25. Scott's Waverley, or "Tis Sixty Years Sine Introduction by A. D. Innes. Frowde. 6) cents Scott, T The Pleasures of Reading. Mi-- chell Kennerley. $1.50. net. Sheppard, W. C A Knight of the West Side, Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Shute, H A, Farming It. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.20 net. Sidgwick, Mrs. A., and Paynter, Mrs. The ‘hildren’s Rook of Gardening. Mecmil- lan. $2 net. Singleton, E, A Guide to Modern Opera Dodd, Mead. $1.50 net Smith, M. C. The Road of Life, and Other Poems. Seattle: Alice Harriman Co. $1. Songs from the Operas. For Alto. ¥dited by H. E. Krehbiel. Boston: Oliver Dit- son Co. $1.50. Spencer, H. P. The Haunted House. Bos- ton: R. G. Badger. $1. Spenser's Faerie Queene. Stories retold by L. H. Dawson. Crowell. $1.50 net. Staten Island and Staten Islanders. Com- piled by the Richmond Borough Associa - tion of Women Teachers. Grafton Press Story, A. T. The Northern Cross and Other Poems. London: L. N. Fowler & Co. Stawell. F. M. Homer and the Iliad: Aa Essay to Determine the Scope and Char- acter of the Original Poem. Dutton. 33 net. Stein, G Three Lives Grafton Press. $1.50 net. Stevenson's. A Child’s Garden of Verses Illustrated by J. W. Smith. Seribner. $2.50. Stirling, Y. A United States Midshipman in China. Phila.: Penn Pub. Co. Stovall, G. O. A Son of Carolina. Neale Pub. Co. $1.50. Susan Warner (“Elizabeth Life and Letters, edited by Wetherell’’) A. B. War- ner. Putnam. $2.50 net. Terry, H. L. Waters from an Ozark Spring. Boston: R. G. Badger. $1. Financial. Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits * Credit available in all parts of the world International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York Letters Certificates OO EY FOIE ITI RCN EL
Page 31
Pe 6 + * .c BR AAT Se 5 ace aaa ng aac lk <a aac BE EPL Le: 12 FPR Pell
Nov. 25, 1909] The Nation.
The Calendar of Proverbs, 1910. Dutton. Thomas, E. M. The Guest at the Gate.! Boston: R. G. Badger. $1.50. Thomson, W. H. Some Wonders of Biology. Dodd, Mead. $1.20 net. Towne, C. H. Manhattan. Mitchell Ken nerley. $1. Vance, L. J. The Pool of Flame. Dodd, Mead. $1.50. The a of the Heart: And Other Plays for Children (Just issued), By CONSTANCE D’ARCY MACKAY. $7. sonet. by mail $1.75. “On Christmas Eve,” “The Christ- mas Guest,” and eight other well-writ- ten, short plays in verse. A satisfac- tory book to fill a real need. Each of these one-act plays contains a distinct lesson, whether of courage, gentle manners, or contentment. The settings are simple, and the within the compass of the school-room. Full directions for costumes, scene set- ting, and dramatic action are given with each play. All of them have stood the test of actual production.” —Preface. Henry Holt & Co.8.\ 8" rWO IMPORTANT BOOKS ON A VITAL ISSUER The Substance of Socialism By JOHN SPARGO Part I. The Socialist Hope. Part Ll oer -. Property and Personal Liberty in 1 Socialist State Part III. The oh ral Value of Class Consciousness Evolutionary Socialism A Criticism and Affirmation By EDWARD BERNSTEIN This work is of the utmost importance to those students of world politics who wish to understand the real meaning of the Ger- man Revisionist movement of which the author is the leader. costumes "cit emanate cet ei)
Each book $1.00 net; postage 10c. B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, 225 F.fth avenue, New York The Nation and The Review of Reviews FOUR DOLLARS New subscribers to The Nation may obtain these two magazines at this special rate. Regular Price Review of Reviews . $3.00 Regular Price The Nation. . . $3.00 SPECIAL OFFER SAVES YOU $2.00 The Review of Reviews Is impartial; it neither muck-rakes nor . ides facts. Dr. Shaw's editorial, ‘Progress of t% World,”” opens the magazine with thirty s, len didly illustrated pages that give the reader « clear, finely interpreted uccount of the men aaj events of the month Reviews of the best articies in the other magazines of the world are 80 com prehensively done that they bave given the Re view of Reviews fame all over the world Each month the Review produces the most grapb-c clever and striking cartoons that have appeared |: American and foreign papers The Nation 20 Vesey St., New York City
Van Deman, E. B. The Carnegie Institution of Pub. 108. Wagstaffe, B. S. Atys, and Other Poems Mitchell Kennerley. $1.25 Warde, M. Betty Wales & Co. Penn Pub. Co. Westermayr, A. J Fenno & Co. $1.50. Atrium Vesta. Washington. Phila Power of Innocenc: Books
525 Wheatley, i. B. Hegarth’s London The Manners of the Eighteenth Century. Dut- ton $1.89 net. Wodiska, J 4 Book of Precious Stones. Putnam $2.50 net. Worth, A. § Mary's Adventure on the Moon. Boston: R. G. Badger. 75 cents Youngman, A The Economic Causes of Great Fortunes. Bankers Pub. Co THE CHINESE LANGUAGE AND HOW TO LEARN IT on A Manual for Beginners, Pages 263. ¢ China riage cee Published by ae “nese a ths op = t The aaa = Open Court Publishing Company CHICAGO iy e-} ngiish, wit ze s system world “ A reprint (the ng son and er. hi 2h ma rhe Open Ce yurt Publis ing < mpany cart phy, Religion, Language Li Se ad. for Compte te Illuatrate a : I SIR WALTER HILLIER, Pasxes 240. Cloth, Swo. Price, Virtue (Lae-Tee’'s Tae-Teh-King) ,
K.C.M.G.,. GO. loth, Svo. Price, 83.75 net. the British authorities for the prepa ] n China This book f the Chinese lene “ earning LAO-TZE’S TAO-TEH-KING DR. PAULL CARTS, BAM) met. lucti transliteration md notes Con intr t met : s evolution, its relation to the Lao-Tze's f nd the 1 r histor f his The (anon of Rea- Paper Caowv- bat i ft uston Catalogue. I Oper AT ALL BOOKSTORES.
Art. Medici OF COLORED REPRODUCTIONS
Series
Company, 78 Wabash Avenu ‘ OUR BOOKS ON SALE fR AFTER THE cod Old Masters A series of reproductions by pho- tography printed in color, Endorsed by the art critics everywhere—and enjoying the patronage of the Muse- um of Fine Arts Boston, the Boston Public Library, and many of the Universities, Colleges, and Libraries throughout the United States and Europe. Illustrated Prospectus on request FOSTER BROTHERS 4 Park Square, Boston Sole Agents for CHATTO & WINDUS'S MEDIC! PRINTS Etched Portraits of Famous Americans By Jacques Reich GEO. WASHINGTON, ALEX. HAMILTON, THOS. JEFFERSON, BENT. FRANKLIN, ANDREW JACK SON, PAUL JONES, JAS MADISON DANL WEBSTER, GEO. WM. CURTIS, WM. McKIN LEY, ANDREW CARNEGIE, THRO. ROOSEVELT, GROVER CLEVELAND, AUTOGRAVHED BY MR. CLEVELAND; ABRAHAM LINCOLN, PRO NOUNCED TO BE THE BEST PORTRAIT OF THE GREAT PRESIDENT; GEN'L U. 8. GRANT, JOHN MARSHALL. Size of plates 14x18 inches.
AUTHORS: LOW ELL, SERIES OF ETCHINGS OF TENNYSON, BRYANT, WHITTIER HOLMES, PLATES 11x14 THACKERAY, GEO. MEREDITH, PLATES 8a1® Robert Louis Stevenson, 13'4 x 18 For List and prices apply to JACQUES REICH, STUDIO, 1 MADISON AVE., NEW YORK, METROP. LIFE BLDG
Published Wedneaday, November 25
Retrospections of an Active Life By JOHN BIGELOW Three vols. Imperial &vo j8 Jllus trations $12.00 net, carriage ertra A memoir of the classic type; co- pious in letters, documents, opinions anecdotes A record filled with great events, great scenes, famous men and women. Historic characters—Lincoln, Gladstone, Queen Victoria, Seward Thackeray, Lord Lytton Dumas, Guizot Maximilian, Stanton Lord Palmerston, appear in the ample pages. Second edition before publica tion. Indisputably the book of the year
THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. Su-t7T Mast 17th Street, New Vork
THE CIVIL WAR, 1861-1865. A COMPENDIUM OF THE WAR OF THE REBELLION By F. H. DYER (Late 7th Conn. Vols.) An invaluable contribution to the statistical and strictly historical side of the Rebel lion. The volume is divided into three sec- tions, viz ORGANIZATION ACTION HISTORY The latter being wholly devoted to regi- ments. A copy of the book can be seen at any of the large libraries, or it will be sent for inspection if desired, Quarto, half moroceo, 1796 pages, $10.00 THE TORCH PRESS, CEDAR RAPIDS, IOWA (Selling Agents for The Dyer Publishing Co.) The oreate reference work of tla kind ever pud- lished Descriptive ciroular on request. AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis
Page 32
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2317 “Fresh Fields and No phrase better describes the wide variety of delightful entertainment to be met with in the attractive pages of Tue Cenrv KY Macazine. Every month you will be charmed by the wealth of new and interesting stories and valuable articles brought you within its covers. You will find Tue Cexrvey different from other magazines. In reading its pages you will be conscious of the charm that you find in cultured men and women Every Month You Will "CEN e! U KR : A year’s present. 35 cents a copy, $4.00 a year. subscription makes an_ ideal | Tramping in the Far East | Adventu res of a Young American GoopD ROADS In AMERICA 2 EUROPE | Are You Plus or Minus 2 Anewer after reading the A SUMMER IN TOURAINE Ny FREDPRIC LES. ‘An ideal « ompanton for the tourtat as as for the armehatr traveler.’ Chteego Record Herald With twelve plates in full color and many other full-page Itllustrations, and a map. Large Svo, $2.75 net. By mali, $2.02 SELF-MEASUREMENT little beok whose fame ix spreading like wild-fire: A Seale of Human Values, with Directions for Versonal Application By WILLIAM DE WiTT ; President of Bowdoin College. nett by mall ’ aa : : hook ‘ A. C. MeCLURG & CO., Chtenges. ol wo nNUaiect. Pablicher New Woon: | Bend for Cetalogue. a wnt? OLD BOOKS FOREIGN scuoewnor A most interesting Catalogue has just BOOKS aw remot eet been issued and will be matied on request. BOSTON. ‘GEORGE P. HUMPHREY, Rochester, N. Y. | DECEMBER FREE The issues of The Nation for December will be sent without charge te new subscribers for the year 1910. THE NATION, 20 Vesey St. New York.
Page 33
hte oy Pee Nov. 25, agen} The Nation. i Author and illustrofor of a beautiful series” The Holy Land” Pastures New” Authorities in countless fields, admiring its broad-minded sin- cerity and avoidance of sensation, desire to have their articles of real importance appear in its pages. Famous artists, appreciating its care in the beautiful repro- duction of their work, make its pages lovely with their best achievements. Brilliant writers, knowing the high standard of merit demanded, are honored by the appearance of their brightest stories and most important novels in Tur Cenrvry. Find New Pleasures in MAGAZINE At all the best book-stores, or Tue Century Co., Union Square, New York. INSPIRING AND HELPFUL BOOKS WHY WORRY? and THOSE NERVES! Ss “TONO- Visitors in New York bid GEORGE L. WALTON,M.D. Cloth, $1 net, each B . LAPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. are invited to examine the resources 99 of our retail store. Here willl be found of Celebrities Bought and Sold. a large stock of current and standard AUTOGRAPH Send for price lists. works from American and foreign LETTERS ples. R. ye presses. Teachers or students prepar- a a Fad ant | ing for courses of reading will find an ub. ‘THE . aye) exceMent choice of moderate-priced B $—all P nest . editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) | 80OHKS—Al! out of print * supplied, B© SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send fer cata- matter on what subject; write me, stating ant:| logues. bought by A. 8S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. wanted; 1 cam get you any beck ever publiched: MARX’S CAPITAL, 77,5, so.e00 ease sects,’ BAKER'S OnDaT BOOKSEOP, | E. P. DUTTON & Co., OHRARLES 8. KERR & COMPANY ' John Bright St., Birmingham, Bagiand. 31 West 234 Street. New York
Page 34
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2317
Blest are ie St. Nicholas in their @ Blest because through one whole year they will find untold happiness in its pages. @ Blest because Sr. Nicnotas will come to them each monthcrowded with wonderful stories, beau- tiful pictures, splendid departments, and articles about a thousand and one interesting things.
Beton, @ Blest because hundreds of thousands of Make your present _ S'NICHOLAS Subscription $3.00 a year. Give your order to any book-store or newsdealer or send to The Century Co., Union Square, New York City.
—. to-day fer full - Whig Xe Musicians Library Should be in every home— public, school or col- Ss ay OLIVER DITSON CO., Ditson Bidg.. Boston, Mass
Good Dates to Advertise Books in THE NATION DECEMBER 2 DECEMBER 9 DECEMBER 16 musician
Page 35
Nov. 25, 1909] is The Nation. Children who find Christmas Stockings @ Blest because Sv. Nicnonas will help them to appreciate all that is finest and best in life. @ Blest because Sr. Nicno.as brings an uplifting influence into the lives of all its children that makes them better, healthier American boys and girls. called it one of the greatest sources of happiness and good that could enter the life of any child from three to sixteen. to the child you love For Boys-“Girls PET IAS en, If requested, a handsome gift card will be sent with the first number of the magazine and delivered to the child on any day desired. -_ . ” ‘ , neg . . ~- \ ~~ t \ ee “ & “ 4 r one & ‘p, Ne , Ci bt 4) eee Fy lt = y . = Gs : wis) s P , Wore ‘ ule . A ; ~% _ Cy Reading Case for The Nation {Do youknow theBeacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at To receive the current numbers in a convenient POEMS By HENRY BARRETT HINCKLEY Mr. Hinckley is a Yale graduate, class of 1892, and ecognized iuce cho } e (temperary) form, Su. the same time Grief, Bach volume 60) | ee ietion en aetie Cree cenelar. Ot he Lan stantially made, bound cents as by mali, 54 cents. Hinckley’s poetry is charming and well-wrought in cloth, with Taz Na- Small. & for a descriptive pamphlet. It will be read by all who are interested in the TION stamped on the side & Co., 21 Beacon St., Boston yy at iy peste Whe ethe oe oF met ere is he great American poet’ is not the ques- in gold. Holds about one tion Lovers of this form of literature cannot volume. Papers easily afford to be ignorant of ‘Oberon and Titania.’ * and neatly adjusted Sent, postpaid, on re. celpt of 75 centa. THE NATION 20 Vesey St. N. Y. City | | ANNE OF AVONLEA | SEQUEL TO “ANNE OF GREEN GABLES.” and we remit the price with An attractive octavo pamphlet of nearly forty pages, “Old Stratford’ paper with wide margins An elegant and inexpensive gift-book Price 50c Send your order by ecard directly to us, ~— a will send wit bill a coin-card te THE NONOTUCK PRESS, Box 267, Northampton, Mass, U. 8 A
Page 36
viii The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2317 IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS W. ¢. BROWNELL'S American Prose Masters $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.65 Poe, Emerson, Hawthorne, Cooper, Lowell, Henry James. “This is what.Mr. Brownell’s critical essays are: The carefully worked-out application and expression of a central conception formed deliberately, even anxiously, and as anxiously tested, retested, and adjusted at every stage of the process. The result for the reader is im- pressive, enlightening, often fascinating. . . . It is of no slight importance that these writers should be weighed in the balance held by a hand so strong and firm and delicate.”—Ed- torial in New York Times Revie. HENRY T. FINCK’S $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.20 Success in Music and How it is Won With a chapter by Paderewski. The greatest singers, pianists, violinists, and teachers in the world to-day tell the secrets of their success, and tell it in their own words in the case of Caruso, Sembrich, Eames, Farrar, Renaud, Kreisler, Jean de Reszke, and Wallner. Paderewski has written a chapter for the book on “tempo rubato” of the deepest interest. Mr. Finck discusses all the practical problems involved in a musical career, and gives the most practical and invaluable advice. It is a unique book of quite extraordinary interest. BARRETT WENDELL’S $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.35 The Mystery of Education and Other Academic Performances Essays on the Study of Expression, Edgar Allan Poe, The Study of Literature, The Mystery . ; ] £ 4 ’ a of Education, and other topics full of sound sense and brilliant expression. “As readable as it is thoughtful and as human as it is frankly academic.”—Boston Transcript. BRANDER MATTHEWS'S $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.35 The American of the Future and Other Essays “One of the most inspiring books of the season.”—Philadelphia Inquirer. FRANK FROST ABBOTT'S $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.55 Society and Politics in Ancient Rome “A large fund of significant detail is rendered peculiarly vivid by clever and usually sound comparisons with the facts of our own day.” Vew York Sun, WILLIAM H. P. WALDEN’S $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.65 Universities of Ancient Greece A brilliant account of the Greek educational world during the first five centuries of the Christian era, taking up every side of the life in a most illuminating manner. ERNEST THOMPSON SETON’S — 2 vols., 58 maps, 560 drawings by the author. $18.00 net; Life Histories of Northern Animals postage extra An important book of popular natural history on a strictly scientific basis. The most authoritative as well as interesting work on the animals with which it deals. Superbly illus- trated with maps, drawings, ete. RUDOLF KUCKEN’S The Problem of Human Life $3.00 net; postpaia, $3.30 “That the work has passed through eight editions in Germany is something to be thankful for; that it will have a large reading in this country is something to be hoped for, as it not only deserves it, but the people need it.”—Boston Transcript. Home Letters of General Sherman Edited by M. A. DeWoLre Howe. $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.20 “The war-time correspondence is truly thrilling, couched in the cool, measured language characteristic of the great general.”—The Outlook. J. LAURENCE LAUGHLIN’S Latter Day Problems = $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.65 Able and illuminating essays on such questions as Political Beonomy and Christianity, The Hope of Labor Unions, Large Fortunes, Social Settlementa, The Valuation of Railways, Guaranty of Bank Deposits. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153 Fifth Avenue, New York