The Nation 1909-10-28: Vol 89 Iss 2313
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GENFRAL LIBRARY, UNIV. Ur mcr, Sey. _ o OCT 29 1909 Y C qooon U -%, VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2313 THURSDAY, OCTOBER 28, 1909. PRICE TEN CENTS, l Bost oS) Just Published The Autobiography of HENRY M. STANLEY Edited by LADY STANLEY The revelation of the personality of the great African explorer. On account of its intimate touch, the author’s keen individual views of men and affairs, and his remarkable experiences, it will take rank as one of the books of permanent importance in its field. ‘The complete story of his life—his youth in America, his experience and service in the Civil War, and his explorations—forms a remarkable narrative. ; The Chicago Post says: ‘‘ No more interesting book than Stanley’s will appear this season.’’ The volume is fully illustrated with portraits, maps, and other illustrations reproduced by a new and artistic process. Svo, $5.00 net. Postage, 25 cents. A Troop of the Guard, and Other Poems By Hermann Hagedorn Thia little volume will be a source of enjoyment to all lovers of verse. Mr. Hagedorn's work is marked by its fineness of poetic feeling. Square 16mo, $1.10 net. Postage 10 cents Carlyle’s Laugh By Thuxzas Wentworth Higginson Lightly but vigorously drawn pen portraits of his friends and contemporaries by .ne dean of American literature 12mo, $2.00 net. Postage, 15 centa Labor and the Railroads By J. O. Fagan A fearless analysis of labor conditions to-day, written with a first-hand knowledge, a vigor of analysis, and a pic- turesqueness of style seldom equaled. J2mo, $1.00 net. Postage, 10 centa A Brief Pilgrimage in the Holy Land By Caroline Hazard An interesting account of a recent trip by the President of Wellesley College, with side lights on familiar Scripture passages. Illustrated with colored sketches and photographs by the author. Crown 8vo, $1.25 net. postage, 10 conts Harmonies By M. A. DeWolfe Howe Polished and thoughtful verse by an accomplished man of letters which will please readers who care for the art of poetry. Large crown &8vo, $1.10 net, Postage 10 conta The Nibelungenlied By Daniel Bussier Shumway An authoritative and faithful translation of this fine old epic poem of the German race With introduction and ex planatory notes. Large crown &ro, $2.00 net Postage 15 centa Fifty Years in Constantinople By George Washburn A vivid. first-hand narrative of Turkish affairs of the last half century, with many fresh side-lights on eminent Euro peans. llluatrated, 8ro, $3.00 net Postage 20 cents MODERN RELIGIOUS PROBLEMS A series of compact little volumes, giving the results of modern theolog! cal scholarship, written by men of wide reputation and sound learning Edited by Dr. AMBROSE W. VERNON The Founding of the Church The Gospel of Jesus By Professor B. W. BACON, Yale University. By ProfessorG. W. KNOX, Union Theological Seminary The Historical and Religious New York. With General Introduction to the Series Value of the Fourth Gospel Sin and Its Forgiveness By Professor E. F. SCOTT, Queen's University, Kingston By President WILLIAM DeW. HYDE, Bowdoin College . These volumes now ready. Thin 12mo, 50 cents cach. Poatage 5 cents Iastrated Holiday Balletin and new Portrait Catalogue FREE on + equest on HOUCHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY __ new York
Page 2
The Nation.
[Vol. 89. | No. 2313 The Nation. | Educational.
|caises, promenades, voyages et conver. FOUNDED IN 1865. | gation. (Fntered at the New York Clty Post Ofee os|C, SCHUWER, O.L, M.H., M.M.,, second-class matl matter.) Professeur Université de France, A WEEKLY JOURNAL. }ancien Directeur d’Ecole normale regoit | |6léves pour langue et littérature fran- Medici Series OF COLORED REPRODUCTIONS AFTER THE Old . Masters
11 RUE LIANCOURT, PARIS, XIV.
The Natton ts published and owned by the New 2 A Park 8 Srpeere bat fy Se.0 Washington York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, | 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Con, Bid.) is President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul | 228 Mich. Ave., Chicago 292 \wetiand Bid. Elmer More, Editor 3 Bia Bend to any address above for Agency Manual.
HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES
A series of reproductions by pho- tography printed in color, Endorsed pore Bad Shnttack ive Berkeley | OY the art critics everywhere—and enjoying the patronage of the Muse-
ALBANY TEACHERS’ gy a Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, tn Supplies schools of all grades with any part of the United States or Mexico; to Canada| teachers. Vgeneetes occurring throughout y- a £3.50, and te foreton countries comprised in the} Send for bulleti Postal Union, £4.00. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York.
Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. ROLFE’S NEW SHAKESPEARE CONTENTS OF THiS NUMBER. . 40 vo‘umes. Each, 56 cents EE GREE 0.005 0st ocn ten see nedeoccecaveans 395 | E A A helpful and scholarly edition, a published in convenient pocket form. The Diplomatic Service .............. 398 . - » Troubled English Politics ........... 39¢}§ 2¢ incorporates the results of the The Function of the College .......... 599 new conditions in Shakespearian criticism, and the notes are unusual- SPECIAL ARTICLES: ly full. Fifty Years of Victor Hugo ........ 400 News ‘or Bibliophiles .................. 402 AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY CORRESPONDENCE: New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston
Henry Charles Lea WO GS HSNO o6ss ceccccecncedéenses Frult-Growing in New England Hetch-Hetchy bevadaatesneeese i Tee ED. cunniancnnssemenanedeet Professor Lombroso’s ‘Confession of
Long’s English Literature BY WILLIAM J. LONG, Faith , ahnuéeetredes Hecenel A Scientist to Dr. Cook ............... Frontispiece in Eleven Colors. List price $1.35 “I have looked it through with great LITERATURE: interest and find it terse, keen, and vital to an exceptional degree.”— Katharine Lee Bates, Department of English Literature, Wellesley, Mass. John Brown , weeeewoapues The Battle of Gettysburg sneseessedcnd Martin Eden The Way Things Happen panmeucoatins S " . . The City of Beautiful Nonsense GINN AND COMPANY, Pablishers « one ‘ n, | e rhe Redemption of Kenneth Galt 29 Beacon Street Beeston, Mase Chapters on Municipal Administration ind = Accounting.—Accounts Their Construction and Interpretation .. 4107 BELLES- LETTPES SERIES.
Essays of Poets and Poetry, Ancient Exodus and Daniel. Edited by F. A. Blackburn. 60c. ind Modern 108 | Judith Edited by Albert 8. Cook Oc The Humin Way 409 Juliana. Edited by William Strunk, jr 40¢. ‘ - ‘ ’ ve > The Battle of Maldon. Ed. by W.J. Sedg field. 40c. rhe City of Jerusalem 409 | The Gospels of Matthew, Mark, Luke, and Jobn Lives of the Hanoverian Queens of in West Saxon. Ed. by Jas. W. Bright. Each 60c. England 419 | The West Saxon Psalms Edited by James W. ‘ ; Bright and Robert L. Ramsay 60c The Owl and the Nightingale Edited by John j 410 Edwin Wells. 60 The Pearl Edited by Charles G. Osgood CO06c Early Sixteenth Century Lyrics Kdlited by Fred erick M. Padelford G0e DD. ©. HEATH & CO., Publishers, The Founda of the Origin of Sp nosTON NEW YORK CHICAGO “TONO- remert woven 8! BUNGAY ” \ Now Hxhibition of OM Masters. 4 Bureau of Library Research FINANCE Search work in Washington Libraries, translating, typewriting of MSS., indexing,
Music
The Bank of England and Wall Stre« 417 revision References. E. L. STONE, Director, Books or Tue Were 4118 101 Stoneleigh .Court, Washington, D, C. Tt) , ” <secopien of The Nation may be procured to! THE “CHILD'S GUIDE” SERIES Paris at Bewotane’ eT Avenue te Nopten | THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Publishers 33-37 East Seventeenth Street, New York Square, Charing Cross,
um of Fine Arts, Boston, the Boston Public Library, and many of the Universities, Colleges, and Libraries ‘throughout the United States and | Burope. | [ustrated Prospectus on request FOSTER BROTHERS 4 Park Square, Boston Sole Agents for CHATTO & WINDUS’'S MEDIC! PRINTS Etched Portraits of Famous Americans By Jacques Reich |GEO. WASHINGTON, ALEX. HAMILTON, THUS. JEFERSON, BENJ. FRANKLIN, ANDREW JAUK- SON, PAUL JONES, JAS. MADISON, DANL. WEBSTER, GEO. WM. CURTIS, WM. McKIN- LEY, ANDREW CARNEGIE, THEO. KOOSEVELT, GROVER CLEVELAND, AUTOGRAPHED BY MR. CLEVELAND; ABRAHAM LINCOLN, PRU- | NOUNCED TO BE THE BEST PORTRAIT OF | THE GREAT PRESIDENT; GEN'L U. 8. GRANT, | JOHN MARSHALL, Size of plates 14x18 inches.
| SERIES OF ETCHINGS OF AUTHORS: | SEN ESOS, BRYANT, WHITTIER, LOWELL, HOLMES, PLATES 11x14. "THACKERAY, GEO. MEREDITH, PLATES 4x1. ‘Robert Louis Stevenson, 13'4 x 18M For List and prices apply te JACQUES REICH, STUDIO, 1 MADISON AVE., NEW YORK, METROP. LIFE BLDG.
NOVEMBER AND DECEMBER FREE The issues of The Nation for November and December will be sent without charge to mew subscribers for the year 1910. The Nation 20 Vesey St., New York
Page 3
Oct. 28, 1909] The Nation. “The Lion was Lord and His Reign was Cruel.” ¢ Theodore Roosevelt’s Second Article of his Series IN Scribner's Magazine For NOVEMBER describes LION HUNTING on the Kapiti Plains In this article Mr. Roosevelt is fairly on his hunting ground. The ranch was in the beautiful Kitanga Hills, and many things about it reminded the author of his experiences on the great plains of the west. The story of the Lion Hunt, with its most interesting preliminary comments upon the relative dangers of hunting big game in Africa. is a vivid and exciting narrative of adventure. by Kermit Roosevelt and others of the party. Of all the game encountered, the Lion is credited with the greatest number of hu- man victims. “The Licn was Lord and his reign was cruel.” The abundant illustrations are Other Notable Features o: November Scribner President Woodrow Wilson, of Princeton, asks and answers the question What Is a College For? Richard Harding Davis's “A Charmed Life.” 4 love Story of the Spanish war. The hero is a young war correspondent. The New York Plan for Zoological Parks By W. T, Hornaday, Director, tells of the development of the greatest Zoological Park in the world. W. C. Brownell's article on Emerson is a masterly study of the charac- ter and work of the great New England philos- opher and essayist. The Drum -Beat of the Town By Nelson Lloyd, gives an impression of the life and movement and fascination of New York. The illustrations, from George Wright’s Sketch Books, are reproduced in colors. Henry Van Dyke contributes a poem, The Ancestral Dwellings To be sure of having the entire series of Mr. Roosevelt's African articies, begin your subscription with the October Number $3.00 a Year 25 Cents a Number CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, Publishers, NEW YORK
Page 4
‘The Nation. TIMELY VOLUMES FOR THE TRAVEL LOVER Be sve: 89, No. 2313 Inns and Taverns of Old London By HENRY Cc. SHELLEY Author of *‘Untrodden English Ways,"’ etc A most in zx volum setting forth the historical and liter- iry associa s of those ancient hostelries, together with an account f the mos Mable coffee-houses, clubs, and pleasure gardens of the British Metropolis Iilustrated from rare old prints and photographs, $3.00 OTHER RECENT ITALIAN HIGHWAYS AND BYWAYS FROM A MOTOR CAR By FRANCIS MILTOUN Author of ‘The Automobilist Abroad,"’ et« S colored plates and 50 other illustrat‘ons and minor deco BLANCHE MeceMANUS Maps and index Octavo. Cloth decorative. Boxed. $3.00 SICILY: The Garden of the Mediterranean By WILL S. MONROE Author of ‘‘In Viking Land,”’ With rations hy etc “*Mr Monroe's new volume is a good, sound, conscientious, com prehensive and interesting book of description, just the kind of book that one ought to read (and usually doesn't) before visiting a for- elgn country.’’——Chicago Record-Herald. lilustrated. Cloth. Boxed. $3.00 THE SPELL OF ITALY By CAROLINE ATWATER MASON ‘Mrs. Mason writes with the fresh enthusiasm of a first acquaintance and, best of all, she makes her readers see Italy and feel its spell The author's breezy, anec- dotal style, with touches of enlivening fiction here and there, makes ber book as companionable as a novel.’’— Chicago Record-Herald Profusely illustrated. Cloth. Boxed. $2.50 L. C. PAGE & COMPANY JUST PUBLISHED In Wildest Africa By PETER MacQuEEN, F.R.C.S. The well-known lecturer and adventurous explorer. This volume is illustrated with most wonderful photographs taken on the spot by Mr. Peter Dutkewitch, by special arrangement with Underwood & Underwood Cloth decorative. Boxed. $3.00 TRAVEL BOOKS MOTOR TOURS IN WALES AND THE BORDER COUNTIES By MRS. RODOLPH STAWELL of 70 full-page illustrations and illustrations in Map and index. Decorative cover. Boxed. $2.50 ople of To-Day TER. GUATEMALA and Her Peo Author By NE\ and Her People of To-day,’’ ete. NEVIN O. WI “Mr. Winter studied his subject at close range, travelling through the country leisurely and verifying his facts. These he has clothed in enterta'ning narrative and illuminated with fascinating photograpbs."’"—Philadelphia Public Ledger. Illustrated. Cloth. Boxed. $3.00 FROM CAIRO TO THE CATARACT By BLANCHE M. CARSON “To him who bas the prospect of an Oriental trip, the book will be a foretaste of the pleasures to come. To him who has to stay at home, this book will prove a consolation prize.’’—Chicago News. Profusely illustrated. Cloth. Boxed. $2.50 With upwards duogravure LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S NEW BOOKS A Memoir of the Rt. Hon. William Edward Hartpole Lecky M.P., O.M., LL.D., D.C.L., Litt.D. Member of the French Institute and of the British Academy. Large Crown 8vo. With Photogravure and 4 other portraita, Pp. avii-482. Cloth, gilt top, $2.50 net; by mail, $2.65. A singularly attractive picture of a fascinating character.” The Timea Mr Lecky has written this graceful memoir of her dis- tinguished husband with conspicuous good taste and personal restraint The boo a revelation of a singularly noble char- acter Ntandard Mr Lecky has icceeded to admiration She has pro- duced a mple, sincere, affectionate and adequate account of ‘ ' vhose integrity, humility, and gentleness made him uni- versally beloved, even as his ability and learning commanded wide respect Lecky was an even, peaceful, prosperous, af- fectionate. and enviable career if ever there was one, and his wife has rendered it with admirable skill and sympathy.”—The Kritiah Weekly A memoir valuable as a record of the successes of the greatest English hist: rian that has been born in Ireland and admirable as a portrait of a character at once studious and endowed with a rare insight into the a nature lofty, amlabl motives which impel hu- man action and sincere.”-—The Scota- WORKS BY W. E. H. LECKY Leaders of Public Opinion tin Ireland: Flood Grattan O’Connell ? vols, 8v0, $4.00 net Democracy and Liberty Cabinet Edition 2 vols. Crown &vo, $5.00 Historical and Political Essays . 800, $3.50 net The Map of Life: Conduct and Character(r. svo, $2.00 The Family and the Nation A STUDY IN NATURAL INHERITANCE AND SOCIAL RE- SPONSIBILITY. By WILLIAM C. D. WHETHAM, M.A., F.R.S. Fellow and Tutor of Trinity College, Cambridge, and CATHERINE D. WHETHAM 8vo. Pp. viii-233. Cloth, $2.50 net. Immediately. The Sayings of Confucius Translated by LEONARD A. LYALL, of the Chinese Customs Service 8vo, $1.25 net. In this new translation of the Lun-yié Mr. Lyall tries to reproduce the rhythm and brevity, as well as the literal mean- There a short introduction and brief otherwise the book is left to speak for itself. The Gilds of China ing of the original. are historical notes; WITH AN ACCOUNT OF THE GILD MERCHANT OR CO- HONG OP CANTON. By HOSEA BALLOU MORSE, of the Chinese Customs Service “The Trade Administration of the Chinese Empire. 8vro, $1.20 net. The Theory of Structures By R. J. WOODS, M.E., M. Inst., C.E., etc. With 157 IUuatrations. 8vo, pp. vii-276. $3.00 net. Author of and LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO. NEW YORK
Page 5
7 Teherene ys Teh glee r « NEW YORK, THURSDAY, OCTOBER 28, 1909. The Week. President Taft uses no more empha- sis than the case calls for when he de- clares his absolute opposition to any ap- plication of the “pork-barrel” idea to the great sums of money in contempla- tion for waterways improvement. The log-rolling methods that have hereto- fore governed in the annual appropria- tions for rivers and harbors were bad enough when the money had to come out of revenue from current taxation; if anything of the same kind were permit- ted when the money is raised upon long- time bonds the result would be utterly intolerable. And it is not only the piece- meal log-rolling as between Chicago and St. Louis, or Duluth and New Orleans, that the President objects to. He takes hold of the thing at its beginning, in the proposal to divide the prospective fund between the great sections of the country. “There is a proposition,” he says, “that we issue $500,000,000 or $1,- 000,000,000 of bonds for waterways and then that we just apportion part to the Mississippi and part to the Atlantic, a part to the Missouri and a part to the Ohio. I am opposed to it. I am opposed to it because it not only smells of the pork barrel, but it will be the pork bar- rel itself. Let every project stand on its own bottom.” That is sound doctrine; but nobody knows better than Mr. Taft himself how difficult it will be to devise a method for effectively putting it into practice. The small proportion of the negro vote in Maryland—one-fifth of the total —1is not the only thing that distinguishes the movement for a_ disfranchising amendment in that State from the like movements in the States further South. In these latter States, negro suffrage was indissolubly connected in the pub- lic mind with the corruption and mis- government of the carpet-bag régime of the years following the civil war; in Maryland, on the contrary, the fight for a fair count of the negro vote was the very centre of the struggle to throw off the long domination of the Gorman- Rasin ring, which, for more than twen- The Nation. ty years, held the State and the city of Baltimore in an iron grasp. The fore- most leader of the fight for fair elec- tions was Severn Teackle Wallis, the most distinguished member of the Bal- timore bar, a man who had suffered im- prisonment during the war on account of his Southern sympathies. When the victory was at last won, in 1895, an ad- mirable election law was enacted and faithfully enforced; and Maryland en- joyed, for the first time in a generation, the privilage of fair and orderly elec- When the regular Democrats again got control of the Legislature and tions. the Governorship, they made modifica- tions of the election law, especially in certain counties, which have permitted gross trickery and fraud; but the elec- tions in Baltimore, and in a large num- ber of the counties, are still fair and clean, and the independent vote still holds the balance of power between the parties. In fighting the amendment, therefore, the Baltimore Reform League and great numbers of independent Vem- ocrats throughout the State are not only opposing a flagrant disfranchising trick, but are also seeking to prevent the restoration of that ring rule which was so long the shame and the despair of good citizens. Gov. Harmon's best friends, in and out of Ohio, will rejoice to hear that the Democratic State bosses have de- clared war upon him. It is a good augury for the future of the man about whom centre the hopes of many old- fashioned Democrats the country over. No aspirant for the leadership of a re- united and revivified Democracy can start better than Cleveland did—-with the hatred and the fear of the political machines to his credit. The outbreak against Mr. Harmon is due, of course, to blasted hopes and sadly empty pockets. The Governor has refused to be “manip- Republican officeholders have not been turned out of doors to make ulated.” room for the hungry among the faith- ful. The cry for jobs has made the Ohio welkin ring, but the Governor's heart has been of stone. Whereupon the Democratic machine leaders have dls- covered that giving them the jobs was what Mr. Harmon was elected for, and that he has consequently violatea his “Gov. Harna:on,” pledges to the people. says Ohio’s indignant national commit- teeman, “was supported with the idea that a complete change would be inade in the State House and all State insti- tutions. have vain.” Hopes, however, been Hence 40,000 Republicans who voted for him will not vote for him again, and 40,000 Democrats will cut him. But those who wish Gov. ‘Har- mon well must advise him to snap his fingers at these men in buckram. The State of Washington is the latest to respond to the movement in favor of the commission plan of city govern ment. Tacoma has already voted to adopt that method, and a campaign has been started in Spokane looking to the same end. The Tacoma election was disappointing in that it was decided by less than a quarter of the voting strength of the city; the vote in faver of the change was in the proportiun of 4% to 1. of the possible voting is due to the fact Perhaps the small percentage that Tacoma has been overburdened with special elections lately. The char- ter election was the seventh held in that city this year, and there are two more to come. In Portland, Ore., last summer, a proposal to take up the com- mission system was submitted along with more than thirty other questions. The electorate had no mind for so large a mouthful, and rejected practically the entire programme. It is worth noting that the saloon element in Tacoma was strongly against the new plan. The charter adopted is of the general type, providing for an administrative and legislative board of five men, elected on ballots bearing no party names or em- blems. The initiative, referendum, and recall are provided for. In a year prolific in reminders of America’s debt to Champlain, to Hudson, to Verrazzano, it is now the turn of Portola. fated not Don Gaspar de Californians have, however, merely the first white man to gaze upon the Gol- den Gate, but likewise their own ac- complishments: Hail to thy daring, to thy cheery mood, And stormy progress, brother multitude! The cosmopolitanism of San Francisco's heritage appears in the merrymaking.
Page 6
396 “The smelting pot of the races,” Steven- waterfront. One found there black men, yellow men, beggar men, There were Laskars in turbans and dis-braided Chinese and Italian fishermen in tam o’shanters and wide, gaudy sashes—Greeks, Alaska In- dians,and men of the South Seas, That was the old San Francisco—or a part of it. The new city is more American, and has fewer suggestions of the San Francisco of Bret Harte’s Argonauts. It is their future to which Californians are looking even in celebrating Portola. In a paragraph printed in the San Fran- cisco Call of April 15, 1906—or just be- fore the earthquake—it was said: “Our destiny is upon us. We cannot escape it.” Fire and earthquake have done their worst, but San Francisco's destiny is son called the thieves. upon her still. A long and honorable judicial career is ended by the death of Mr. Justice Peckham of the Supreme Court. Spe- cial attention was drawn to him at the time of his appointment by President Cleveland, owing to the sensational re- jection by the Senate, under the prompt- ing of David B. Hill, of the two preced- ing nominations of Mr. Hornblower and Wheeler H. Judge Peckham, however, gave himself with unrem‘tting labor and unusual ability to the work the and soon ceased to be thought of except as an upright and use- ful member of our highest tribunal. His service fell in a time when many impor- tant and agitated questions were passed upon by a court too often divided; but Judge Peckham’'s opinions were always Peckham. of court, extra-judicial heat, and were marked by great lucidity and cogent reasoning. His death, with the fact that two or three of his colleagues are without humanly certain to retire soon, sug- gests the probability of a reconstitution of the Supreme Court during President Taft's term of office. The promise cf fit appointments is bright at the hands of an Executive who has himself been a judge, and who will not allow politt- clans to dictate to him the naming of the Federal judges. The death of Henry Charles Lea, at the age of eighty-four, removes one of the very small group of American schol- ars and writers of true distinction and admitted importance. His life was as different from the common run as his The Nation. work was superior to the ordinary lit. | erary output. The son of a prosperous Philadelphia publisher, and engaged in the publishing business himself from his youth up, be was the possessor of an ample fortune and the head of an impor- tant business concern; but he found no difficulty in leading a laborious life de- voted to intellectual pursuits. In making himself master, and one of the world’s greatest authorities, in a large field of historical research, he was continuing one of the most pleasing of English and American traditions, that of the man of wealth and business who is also a schol-| ar or literary man of real merit and | It is a lesson of Mr. Lea's | career that there are still great results | which can be achieved by individuals | unconnected with any organization for | the systematic production of learning. | And it is proper to mention that, while) his interest was so largely absorbed by | a subject very remote from the doings | of to-day, Mr. Lea did not fail to bear | his part as a citizen. significance. The advertising campaign planned by the Home Missions Council is more com- prehensive than novel. Churches have long practised advertising, and clergy- men of a certain type have been known to have the habit. The religious motto painted large on the landscape, or stuck in the form of a minute paster on the car window, goes far back in time. What is new is that the churches now intend and eco- nomic” truths as well as religious, and to advertise “social, racial, to do so through the regular medium of newspapers and periodicals. In such a will there be left for the newspapers and magazines to put into their reading columns? We know how hard the passionate press-agent will work to smuggle a bit of advertising into the reading matter. We know what case, what importance is attached to the three as- that separate the paid truths We know what the means when he terisks from the unpaid. man the scornfully invites the bore to go hire a hall. Why, therefore,should the churches expend large amounts of money to get. “social, racial, and economic” mutter out of the columns where everybody reads it into the columns where, the presumption is, nobody looks for it un-| less he is strongly impelled? The maga- | zines we can understand. Their ~“t-| read and most attractive pages have in street ‘ported, or have been recently reported, [Vol. 89, No. 2313 long been in the advertising section. An article on the race problem that would be lost between a spring poem and a Wild West stcry will make a mark if inserted between the picture of an automobile and the advertisement of a safety razor. The fatal injury to one of the Annap- olis football players will not, we pre- sume, greatly disturb the equanimity of those who, like Justice Oliver Wen- | dell Holmes, believe that athletics are cheaply bought by the annual sacri- fice of a few lives. This case is, how- ever, bound to attract attention for sey- eral reasons. In the first place, the un- fortunate midshipman was a trained player, and not, like many other vic tims, a member of a scrub team with in- sufficient teaching and control. Also this casualty indicates that, much as the game has been “opened up” by the new rules, the dangers still persist. The daily reports from the various football fields read as of old in their descriptions 'of the injured and their hurts. So long as violent physical contact is permitted, just so long will more or less serious in- juries continue. But a further change of the game in the direction of the Eng- lish contest ought to be of some help. Hence we regret to note in the games thus far a marked disposition to return to the “old-fashioned” style of play and a neglect of the onside kick and forward pass which did so much to lighten the strain on the players and increase the interest of the spectators. When Prince Von Biilow decided to give up the Chancellorship rather than appeal to the country on his finance bill, he showed his customary sagacity. What would have happened to the Gov- ernment’s thin majority in a general election is indicated by the remarkable victories of the Social-Democrats all over the Empire. It did not take them long to recover from their heavy defeat of three years ago. Three years of Dread- nought-mania, a growing deficit, and the logical recourse to increased taxes on food, drink, light, and air, have swelled the ranks of German discontent. Where in 1906, after the famous Imperial vic- tory, it was all talk of scotching the Socialist serpent by restricting the fran- chise in Hamburg, in Saxony, and Ber- lin, heavy Socialist gains are now re
Page 7
s AE Pali, Oct. 28, 1909] from Prussia, from the Rhineland, from Saxony. In the Saxon Diet the Social- ists bid fair to leap from a member- ship of one to a membership of twenty- five, possibly, or nearly a third of the entire Diet. The German Governments have all the more reason to fear these results, on ac- count of the possibility that the Social- ists may consent to join hands with Rad- icals and Liberals in the Reichstag and the Diets. Opportunism, or revisionism, to give it its economic name, is making headway among Bebel’s followers. The orthodox doctrine of complete absten- tion from the process of bourgeois law- making received a severe setback last year when the Socialists in the Bavarian | Diet joined with the Centre to force | through a number of progressive meas- ures. In the Socialist Congress at Leip- zig, last month, the new moderation was evident. There were none of the old anti-patriotic outbursts which more than anything else have driven the Liberals into the Government camp. There were no fiery onslaughts on religion. A pro- posal to establish Socialist schools for children of non-believers received less than 30 votes out of 300. The cause of all this is the natural weariness of a policy of mere negation carried on through decades. The fall of the Spanish Ministry may have been inevitable for other reasons, but it was undoubtedly hastened by the agitation over the execution of Profes- sor Ferrer. To the flood of foreign pro- tests were added cries of shame and out- rage in Spain itself. A political and moral atmosphere was rapidly created in which the Prime Minister, who was responsible for the extinguishing of one held a light of his country, could not breathe. Premier Maura’s resignation involved the summoning of the leader of the opposite party to form a Govern- ment. -How long Sefior Moret’s Minis- try may go on without the need of elect- ing a new Cortes is still doubtful. In any event, the new head of the Cabinet is not to be envied his task. Popular dissatisfaction with the slow progress) and disappointing results of the Riff campaign is again mounting, and with internal discontent fed by other causes, the outlook is troublous not only for the Ministry, but for the monarchy it- self. The Nation. 397 It is natural enough that the meeting murderers really had. If the Ko-ean between the Czar and the King of Ita'y | people came to associate the crueltics of should bring up again our old friend, | Japanese rule with the personality of the break-up of the Triple Alliance. Roy-| the man who up to a few months ago al encounters are always supposed to be | was Japan's viceroy in the peninsula, fraught with tremendous matters of| the inference was a natural one. Cer- state, and surely, in the present in- | tainly, they could hardly have register- stance, Nicholas II would never have | ed their protest in more emphatic torm undertaken that painful trip of a couple | Not even an attack on the life oi the of thousand miles between two walls of | Mikado would have roused the world at bayonets, if he were not really eager to! large as will the unhappy death of the join hands with Victor Emmanuel| best known and most gifted of Japan's against their common aversion, Austria- statesmen, the one whose life has been Hungary. But experience has shown that | most closely bound up with his nation's the Czar’s momentous interviews with | rebirth and imperial growth. the, heads of foreign governments have | ~—~ -~- When an article on “The Public Debt but a good deal of trouble for Russia.} of New Zealand” begins with pointing The Czar comes to take advice and get | out that the net public debt per head of help, never to offer it, and Italy, for all! the population in that country is $314, her irritation against the Hapsburgs, is | as against $145 for France, $80 for Great pretty sure to remember what a weak | Britain, etc., one rather looks for an reed to lean upon the Czar turned out| exhibition of the Australasian expert- for France in her hour of need. It is| ment station as an awful warning. Such typical of a blundering mis-government} jg not the case, however, with the paper like Russia’s that it will go far enough/in the Journal of Political Economy, to exhibit its spite but seldom far! signed by James Edward Le Rossignol ' usually meant little for Europe at large, enough to make its enemies take it \of Colorado and William Downie Stew- seriously. Whatever may happen io the | art of New Zealand as joint authors. Triple Alliance in the course of years— | ‘The article is a quite colorless examina- it is beginning to show unmistakable | tion of the New Zealand public debt signs of dissolution—at least no mortal | ang its history. It explains at once that blow will come from the side of Rus- ‘a very large part of the debt represents sia. | productive investments, and it mentions |many other elements which must be The assassination of Prince Ito at taken into account before the true egigni- Harbin seems to bear out the old rule| ficance of the figures can be judged. One that the fanatic’s knife or bomb most | incidental remark is of special interest often strikes either when it should not for this country. “The most common or whom it should not. Such broken in- | form of political corruption in the Unit- formation as has come to us out of | ed States,” it says, “the corrupting influ- Korea, since the Japanese investment, | has represented Prince Ito as the one Japanese statesman most concerned in mitigating the rigors of foreign domina- tion at Seul. If that was the case, the | death of the veteran statesman at the hands of a Korean patriot falls akin to the assassination of President Lincoln by a Southern sympathizer, or the as-| sassination of Alexander II of Russia on the eve of his granting a Constitu- tion. But we cannot press the point too ence of railways and other business cor- | porations, does ‘not exist to any great “extent in New Zealand, because of the | prevalence of governmental and mu- nicipal ownership, but the concentration of economic power in the hands of the / government has created a form of cor- “ruption which, while it may not be 60 bad morally, is far more wasteful from | the economic point of view.” The writ- | i | ers refer especially to the building of roads, bridges, etc., as a matter of iocal far. The other tendency has grown up | or personal favor, which is elsewhere re of asserting that every incompetent monarch who fell a victim to popular resentment was just on the eve of blos- | soming into an archangel and establish- ing elysium within his dominions. Nor does a murdered statesman become thereby retroactively the best friend his ferred to as “the current coin of pcliti- cal corruption.” What dimensions this } sort of thing would be capable of in our country, under government ownership of railways, it staggers the imagination to picture. It is prudent to watch these movements from afar.
Page 8
398 THE DIPLOMATIC SERVICE. When Mr. Taft returns to Washing- ton he will find nothing more pressing than the reorganization of the diplemat- ic service. Ordinarily, the various posts abroad have been bargained off within *. few days after a new Administration has assumed office. Mr. Taft wisely an- nounced that he would take his time in selecting his ministers and ambassa- dors. Now, however, elght months bave elapsed and some important appoint- ments have not been determined upon. Several of them have gone begging in a way to cause considerable mortifica- tion, and the unfortunate affair with Mr. Crane cannot but add to the diffi- culty of obtaining a Minister to China, if not in choosing men for other posts. Moreover, there are many clouds upon the diplomatic horizon. Are we to have tariff wars with Germany, France, and Canada? Is there to he serious friction over Japan’s policy in Manchuria? No one can at this moment answer these | The Nation. To Russia Mr. Rockhill has been sent With the close of the holiday season from China, because, as was openly ad-| it is to be hoped, too, that the State De- mitted, the Administration wanted a/'| partment itself will be so fully manned “live” business man at Peking. When it got one who was just of that sort, it [Vol. 89, No. 2313 as to make it impossible for any one else to charge, as did Mr. Crane, that he treated him so roughly as to exasperate| was started for his difficult and distant Mr. Crane’s intimate friends. He was post without adequate consultation and fairly dragged off his steamer, compelled instructions. Of this, Mr. Huntington to cross the country under public curi- Wilson's serious illness is, to be sure, a csity and suspicion, and then dismissed partial explanation. But there are dis- as one would discharge a commercial quieting rumors that, besides departing traveller. Before Mr. Crane was asked American diplomats and those awaiting to take the mission, Stuyvesant Fish, orders, foreign diplomats also have had F. A. Delano, ex-Senator Fulton, and difficulty this summer in finding out others declined the position. He will just who is in charge of this policy or that negotiation. Mr. Adee is, of course, always on hand with all his val- uable experience to aid him; but some- be a brave man who will finally.con- sent to fill the demand for a Minister in Peking. Meanwhile, the months drag on, and the United States, whose inter- ests in the East Mr. Taft, above all oth- ers, deems of vast importance, is repre- sented by a chargé d'affaires in China. times even an able second secretary does not quite take the place of his su- periors. It will be a good thing for the whole Administration, not yet shaken In Italy, Mr. Leishman has taken’ gown like a tested piece of machinery, over the embassy in succession to Mr. when the holidays are over. Indeed, Griscom; and Mr. Straus’s appointment we are sometimes tempted to beiieve questions. That they can be asked is,|to Constantinople has been hailed with that a statutory prohibition of vaca- however, in itself a strong reason why no time should be lost in filling the lead- ing diplomatic offices. Justice to the ambassadors alone de- mands this. No man can do his best work if he is in ignorance about his im- mediate future. Take the case of Dr. Hill, for instance. Is he to remain at Berlin, or to be transferred to another post or retired from the service? So far as we are aware, no official statement has yet been made as to his future. In Paris, Mr. Henry White, after remaining for months in a state of uncertainty as to when he would be relieved by Mr. Robert Bacon, has notified the State De- | partment that he can hold his place no longer than November. Yet, despite Senator Aldrich’s recent assurances, the question of a tariff war is apparently nowhere else so acute as in France. The situation in London is similar. satisfaction by all interested in Turkey. tions during the first six months of a The Japanese mission remains in Mr. | new Administration would not be amiss. O'Brien's hands; his pleasing personal- ity makes him as welcome in Tokio as heretofore. But the office of Minister to TROUBLED ENGLISH POLITICS. Cuba, important now on account of our No one can read the English press of relations with that island, is yet to be both parties, or talk with Englishmen disposed of, since the promotion of Mr. 4nd others familiar with political condi- BE. V. Morgan, the present incumbent, tions in Great Britain, without getting is understood to be impending. The 4 pretty serious idea of the great con- Austrian and Mexican missions must troversy over the budget. It is a real also be re-manned, particularly the lat- crisis, though we cannot help feeling ter, in which Mr. Thompson has been that it has been artificially created. The occupying his leisure moments with the question of new taxation was difficult purchase of a railway to which he will enough of itself; but the attempts on hereafter devote his attention. Until both sides to make political capital out all the places to be filled have been dis- of it, with the violence of extremists of posed of, the feeling of unrest will con- either party, have blown the affair out tinue. Indeed, the whole situation must of all natural proportions. It may yet strengthen the hands of those who ad- serve as a classic illustration of what vocate a permanent diplomatic body, pro- | political passion can do to inflame and tected as a whole from the now inevita-| distort a problem of finance into some- Mr. Reid is obliging the State De- | partment by holding on, though ful'y | aware that his supersession may take | place at any moment. But the President | is unable to find anybody so eminently | fitted for this post as would have been | Dr. Eliot. That he has been asking | many for suggestions has long beev an) open secret. No one can deny, however, that the failure to find the right man | ble upset on the inauguration of a thing very near revolution. President, and affording guarantees for Those are doubtless correct who main- a life career. As it is now, we have tain that no Chancellor of the Exche- such a case as that of Mr. Riddle, tate- quer ever held such language as is the ly Ambassador to Russia. Though a common stock in trade with Mr. Lloyd- fluent linguist, master of Russian,and a George. Instead of dropping his old graduate of the Paris School of Politi- fighting and slashing manner, now that cal Science, he has been dropped from he is charged with weighty responsibill- the service after sixteen years in Rus- ties, he has, if anything, intensified it. sia, Turkey, Egypt, and Servia-——not an Of course, he does not lack provocation. is injurious to the service and detri-| encouraging example to the young Foolish dukes and reckless Tories are mental to the dignity of what is one of | our greatest positions. ‘ thoroughly for diplomacy. American who aspires to fit himself as much to blame for the political ten- sion as are headstrong radicals and Oe a ce ae
Page 9
Oct. 28, 1909] swashbuckling Liberals. But when all is said, we look for more gravity and steadiness in the head of the British Treasury than the Chancellor of the Exchequer displays in his utterances whether in or out of Parliament. His speech at Newcastle, the other day, was a fine instance of how a great Minister of State should not harangue the pub- lic about taxation. Where Lloyd-George was defending the actual taxing propos- als of the budget, he was sensible and defensible. not very burdensome in themselves. They might be extended so as to be con- fiscatory, but it is not the English way to be logical in extending taxes or any- thing else; and the Chancellor might well have rested with the economic and The new taxes are really fiscal defence of his measures. Instead, he launched into a violent attack upon the House of Lords—made up, he said, of men “chosen by accident from the ranks of the unemployed”—and indulg- ed in language which gives point to the charge of his opponents that he is a So- cialist at heart. from his peroration to show the kind of We cite a few words social dynamite that Mr. Lloyd-George tosses about light-heartedly: Who ordained that a few should have the land of Britain as a perquisite, who made 10,000 people owners of the soil, and the rest of us trespassers in the land of our birth; who is it—who is responsi- ble for the scheme of things whereby one man is engaged through life in grinding la- bor, to win a bare and precarious subsis- tence for himself, and when at the end of his days he claims at the hands of the com- munity he served a poor pension of Sd. a day he can only get it through a revolu- tion; and another man who does not toil receives every hour of the day, every hour of the night, whilst he than his poor neighbor receives in a whole year of toil? Where did the table of the law come from? Whose finger inscribed it? These are the questions that will be ask- ed. The answers are charged with peril for the order of things the Peers repre- sent, but they are fraught with rare and refreshing fruit for the parched lips of the multitude who have been treading the dusty road along which the people have marched through the dark ages, which are now emerging into the light. slumbers, more It is not strange that sober-minded Eng- lishmen find it hard to reconcile them- selves to a budget which has such doc- trines tagged to it. However, the practical question how the Lords are to deal with the budget when it reaches them remains very much what it was. As the time ap- proaches when action must be taken, counsels are divided and the outlook is The Nation. confused. It should seem a good case for English compromise; but recent dec- larations of responsible Ministers have been wholly unyielding. The measured and dignified Prime Minister, Mr. As- quith, is as explicit as the impetuous Lloyd-George and the harum-scarum Winston Churchill in asserting that no interference of the Lords with a money bill can be tolerated. If they amend or! reject it, the Commons will at once re- solve that there has been a breach of their privileges; and then there could not fail to be an appeal to the country in which the whole veto power of the House of Lords would be the chief is- sue. It is fear of this and what might follow which leads the ‘Spectator to think that it is better to accept the bud- get, disagreeable as it is, than to throw the British Constitution into the melt- ing-pot of a general election. Notabie, too, is the opinion of the Birmingham Post, which is, or at any rate was, the organ of Joseph Chamberlain. It ad- vises the Lords that they have too much to lose and nothing to gain by rejecting the finance bill. The evidence that the country wants the land taxes, this Con- servative newspaper thinks to be con- clusive; and it adds that “a dissolution on the finance bill would almost cer- tainly be followed by a return of the Government to power with a definite mandate which the Lords could not ig- nore.” The Glasgow Herald is equally convinced of the bad policy of rejecting the budget. Of course, many Conserva- tive organs, the London Jimes at their head, strongly urge the Lords to throw the bill out. Mr. Balfour, however, has not spoken. Till he does, the Lords will searcely know which way to turn. In their perplexity, they are expected to get new light from the bye-election that is held to-day. This is a London constituency describ- ed by Charles Booth as the poorest in the city. The population is about 80,000, of which a large proportion depend in Bermondsey upon casual labor, and many families are always upon the verge of want. It is thus a working-class constituency, and it was thought that it would afford a fine test of the “popularity” of the budget. But a three-cornered fight is rag- ing, the Labor party having put uo Dr. Salter, who appears to be that unusual combination, a Quaker of extreme So- clalistic views, and it is quite possible that he, with his programme of the 399 right to work, a minimum wage, and the nationalization of land, railways, and mines, with the municipalization of everything else, may win over both the Liberal and Conservative candidates. In that case, the Lords would be in great- er doubt and darkness than ever. Even should the Tories win, it might be dis- astrous for them to pluck up courage from a single election. In 1880, when Beaconsfield was in doubt whether to go to the country, as Gladstone was chal- lenging him to do, he carried a bye-elec- tion and that decided him to dissolve But that bye-election was, curiously, also in Bermondsey, and after winning it, the Conservatives were badly beaten in the general election. THE FUNCTION OF THE COLLEGE. When it is stated that President Woodrow Wilson has written a maga- zine article of considerable length upon a fundamental question of college edu cation, it is almost superfluous to add that a contribution at once substantial and attractive has been made to the dis- cussion. In his article in Scribner's Magazine entitled “What Is a College For?” he surveys the present condition of life and study at the typical large American college, judged both by the end which the college proposes or should propose and by the efficacy of the ar- rangements actually in operation for the attainment of that end. On the first President Wilson's thesis is laid cown branch of the question with great emphasis and insistence It turns altogether on the complexity of the modern world—on the demand for intense effort, and for the capacity to turn with vigor and effectiveness to any task, however unexpected, to any prob- lem, however novel, which the changes of the time may present. A picture— decidedly overdrawn, we submit, what- ever be the number of instances on which it may be based—is presented of the way in which the man whose only capital is some special skill is con- demned to be a servant perpetually, and may at any time become a useless ser- vant, his “skill gone out of use and fashion.” To lead a life worthy of a young man’s aspirations, he must pre- pare himself to meet and conquer all the chances and changes of the c'me; and the function of the college is to equip him for such a role. “To me,” says
Page 10
400 President Wilson, “the question seems to be, Shall the lad who goes to college go there for the purpose of getting ready to be a servant merely, a servant who will be nobody and who may be come useless, or shall he go there for the purpose of getting ready to be a master adventurer in the field of mod- ern opportunity?” Into the other branch of Mr. Wilson’s discussion it is impossible here to en- ter in a manner at all adequate; nor would it be proper for any but an ex- pert in questions of tion college orgauiza- The breakdown of the old college discipline, based on the boarding-school idea; the to pass judgment upon it. development of the multiform activities —athletic, social, literary, business— which now absorb so large a portion of the student's time and interest; the dominant part played by college frater- nities and other social groups—these are brought out vividly and are cor- related with the main theme. In all this development President Wilson finds an inevitable process of evolution, due to the need of something that the col- lege as such has not supplied; and he draws the picture not merely as a pre- sentation of historical fact, but for a definite practical purpose. The absorp- tion of time and interest involved in these extra-collegiate activities makes it impossible for the college to utilize the four years of precious opportunity for its own great purposes; and Presi- dent Wilson proposes such a remuvdel- ling of the relations between faculty and students as shall turn all the vitality now scattered in these accidental ways into the right “The oigan- izations whose objects lie outside study,” he says, “should be but parts of the whole, not set against it, but included within it.” channel. With nothing that President Wilson gays in regard to the ways and means of effecting a needed improvement in college life have we any quarrel; and there is In the whole article a high se- riousness, both of substance and of form, that makes us regret the more that we find in it a radical defect. We submit that there is an issue deeper and more vital than any of those dis cussed by Mr. Wilson, however import ant these may be; and on this issue his note does not ring true. The preaching of the gospel of strenuosity has gone far indeed when one can read page afte The N ation. ”* [ Vol. 89, No. 2313 =x page of an essay so serious as this, and coming from such a source, yet find barely a hint that there may be a va'ue in college culture other than what is ties; and we do not think it would be going too far to say that the college will lose sight of what is the most benefi- cent part of its entire activity when it measured by outward achievement. Of-eeases to regard with pride and satis- the effect upon a man’s inner life, of the satisfaction he may get simply from a broader outlook or a deeper insight, of the heightened joy and added solace which the treasures of literature or the interests of science may afford him be- cause of those four golden years, there is no word. Nor can it be justly an- swered that all this has been omitted because it is matter of course. In the first place, in our day, with the din of the preachers of efficiency as the one and only good ever in our ears, it is not matter of course. And secondly, Mr. Wil- son sins not only by omission, but also by commission. Again and again, he strikes the strident note that is the fashion of the day: “To be a master adventurer in the field of opportunity” should be the purpose of the college stu- dent; and again: “We must distinguisi is for, without dis- paraging any other school, of any other kind. It is for the training of the men who are to rise above the ranks.” Strug- gle, conquest, “doing things”—that, it should seem, is the be-all and end-all of modern education. what the college Against this view of the function of the college, we hold it to be the duty of all men of culture to protest. Unques- tionably, the college should be a nursery of leaders, of men who go to the front both in the competitive pursuits of or- dinary life and in the advancement of the welfare and progress of their coun- try and of the world. But what of the score of youths who are not endow- ed—perhaps in ability, perhaps in tem- perament—for such a career, as agains’, the one who is? Is there nothing for| them in the college? Nay, is it nothing for the country and the world that the type which they represent shall be pre: served? Are we to admit that “things are in the saddle” so absolutely that to be a gentleman of taste, or refinement, | of a generous and unambitious interest in high and beautiful things is to “be nobody"? With all its restless progress and resistless changes, there is still, we trust, room in the world for the quiet and cultivated gentleman who is cen-. tent to earn a modest living, or even to live a life of rational ease in unvb- trusive performance of unpretending du- , faction the furnishing of this leaven to our overstrung and society. strenuosity-ridden FIFTY YEARS OF VICTOR HUGO. Paris, October 12. It is fifty years since Victor Hugo be- gan pouring out to the world “La Lé gende des siécles.” Its successive utter- ances, with minor poems of the same strain in between (1859-1877-1883) ex- press that modernizing vision of the past which now most pleases official French thought. Popularly, there are fifty copies of Alfred de Musset’s poems sold for one of Victor Hugo’s. There are even signs of the newest Young France turning altogether back from the nine- teenth to the seventeenth century—the grand siécle once more. The Société Victor Hugo, which charges itself with the master’s fame, seized the occasion of the half-cente- nary for a week of celebration. Sunday, September 26, the Comédie Frangaise played “Ruy Blas” at the matinée. Then, on successive days, there was a visit to the poet’s house, which has been turned into a Victor Hugo Museum; the in- auguration, in the historic gardens of the Palais Royal, of Rodin’s statue, which has been waiting fifteen years for the day; a pageant of the Cour des Mi- racles, which was to have illuminated the facade of Notre, Dame with Esmer- alda and Frollo, but was spoiled by des- perate weather; and the final obligato banquet—all with occasional verse and discourse and speeches from Govern- ment. Perhaps the importance of the anni- versary has been overrated. In 1885 po- litical and religious exaltation of the Republican and Freethinker made an international demonstration out of the poet’s interment at the Panthéon, the church being expelled to make room for his corpse. In 1902, for the centenary of his birth, the desire to recognize na- tionally the one overmastering genius of French poetry in the century which was past gave a genuinely literary col- or to the celebration. The presen: in- terest in “La Légende des siécles,” tak- en apart from the poet’s complete work, should be rather to know the appeal which Victor Hugo's ideas and art have continued making to the changing lit- erary judgment and feelings of France during fifty years. In 1859 the old official criticism was still intr iched in the university citadel, in spite of thirty years of attack and defeat at the hands of the Romantics. Désiré Nisard was its spokesman in NEXT> ne
Page 11
1909 Oct. 28, his “Etudes d’histoire et de littérature” of that year: The history of the works of M. Victor Hugo is the history of ephemeral books which graft on to the day’s commonplaces or imitate like works, and in which the merit of invention does not belong to M. Victor Hugo. I do not know one of his books of which the thought is his own. ; You would almost say that M. Vic- tor Hugo is condemned to be in truth but “a child of genius,” as M. de Chateau- briand called him. Nowadays, M. Doumergue, who as minister of public instruction is grand master of the university, begins his in- augural discourse for Rodin’s statue: The government of the republic could not allow the fiftieth year of “La Légende des siécles” to be celebrated without taking part in it. The glory which Italy owes to Dante, which Shakespeare has given to England, France, without excessive pride, can give thanks for to Victor Hugo. Some, I know, not understinding his ge- nius or irritated by it, have denied him the thinker’s glory. But his word at which the world wonders, could it so thrill us if he had lacked that inner flame which strong thought alone can kindle? With a tone of combat, the minister wound up his eulogy: Glories of mediocrity do not resist the, effect of distance and the intense life of our day. But the figure of Victor Hugo, as it withdraws in time, far from entering into shadow and obscurity, stands out in piercing relief, like the decided features with which the sculptor here makes him to live again for us. In the name of the government of the republic I make my sa- lute, bowing with the homage of an admi- ration which has not weakened. And yet, in the testy foolishness of old-fogy Nisard, may there have not been a glimmer of reason? Like Carlyle, the English writer whom he resem- bles essentially in more ways. than one, Victor Hugo “always felt himself qualified @ priori to crack and pick any philosophic nut extant; to discuss and determine the toughest providential problem conceivable, without a taking of testimony or investigation of any sort, but by sheer force of genius or esthetic instinct.” Better fitted still to Victor Hugo’s case is this further judg- ment of Carlyle by the elder Henry James: “He did, indeed, dally with the divine ideas long enough to suck them dry of their rhetorical] juices.” It would be difficult to find, in the expressions of French thought to-day, a single idea brought into it by Victor Hugo. The theism of his prime and the doubtful pantheism of his age are alike formless, with only the splendor of col- or; and, even his declamations on 2 practical subject so worked by him as capital punishment ave left merely resonant emotion. Nisard, who saw only printed pages through his spec- tacles, might easily find chapter and verse for the original propositions of The Nation. the poet’s thoughts: his disastrous fail- , ure was in his inability to estimate at, its proper value the transforming, of- ten deforming, poetic imagination, of which Victor Hugo was all compact. The poet seems to have had a glimpse of the truth in the name he chose for the great work which he assured Vac- querie, in a letter of March, 1859, “shall contain mankind, shall be man- kind.” Among unpublished notes for a preface, he wrote: “When you consider the human series parallel with the ae- ries of the centuries, man has two as- pects—the historic and the legendary. The historic aspect borders on the dra- ma; the legendary on epic poetry.” The name for his work was to be “Petites Epopées.” And he wrote his own idea of the work in characteristic lines, now published for the first time: Ceci sera la page énorme; et les vivants L’auront vue, au milieu du vaste effort des vents, De l’erreur, de la haine ardente, de la foule, De tout ce qui s’éléve et de tout ce qui croule Et de tout ce qui va dans la nuit, em- portant Le chiffre vain, le réve obscur, l‘homme hésitant, Demeurer, et garder son accent inflexible. Fléche, reste le roi, peuple, reste la cible, Jusqu’au jour ot viendront d'autres hommes disant: Toi, sols la fiéche, et toi, gois la cible A présent. Alors commenceront les sombres des- tinées Until then Victor Hugo had been the transformer of French poetry in g-ner- al. For Sainte-Beuve, he was of “iyric renown”; for Théophile Gautier, whose “Histoire du romantisme” appeared only a few months before “La Légende des siécles,” the turning point was the drama of “Hernani”: A movement was wrought like that of the Renaissance. We seemed to have found again the great lost secret; and it was true, we had found again poetry Two years later Baudelaire wrote: When we remember what French poetry was before Victor Hugo appeared and how it has grown young again since he came; when we imagine the little it would have been if he had not come, how many deep, mysterious feelings which have found ex- pression would have remained mute; how many intelligences he has brought to their birth, how many men have shone by him who would have stayed in the shadow, it is impossible not to regard him as one of those rare, providential spirits who work in the literary order the salvation of all, as others do in the political order Voices were still raised in opposition. Common-sense, bourgeois Francisque Sarcey remarked in 1868 that he had “always professed mediocre sympathy for the dramas of Victor Hugo.” In 1881 Zola, in the full success of his natural- | 401 ism, while naming Victor Hugo “the man of the century,” did not fear to pronounce his new work, “L’Ane,” an incroyable galimatias. The theatre-go- ing public has ratified Sarcey’s judg- ment, while Racine still holds the stage. You seldom meet young Frenchmen who have read the lyrical poems of Victor Hugo; and the new education turns minds definitely away from his purely poetic imaginings. The verses of Riche- pin and many a lesser playwright do, indeed, echo the master’s sonurous line; but his lack of social perception, without subtlety or suppleness or dell- cate shades of feeling and wit, has stood finally in the way of any Hugonian school among generations bred in psy- Phology. In the tribute which French men of letters presented to Victor Hugo for his eighty-third birthday, Zola, seemingly unconscious of its fundamental crit- icism, uttered what is still the truth: In Victor Hugo, I salute the poet victo- rious from ancient combats. To honor him with our worship to-day is to protest against those who hooted after him in those days The battle was already won. Four years later when the poet died, the unliterary Clerical newspaper, La Croiz, amidst all the intentionally offensive apotheo- sis of the Panthéon, had nothing worse to say than this: Victor Hugo died at 1:35 o'clock. He was the greatest poet of our age. He had been mad for more than thirty years. May his madness be his excuse before God. Now, after twenty-five more years, it is evident that the poetry of the j;ears of madness—“La Légende des siécles” —towers high above all the other poetic work of Victor Hugo, as Paul de Saint- Victor, who had been Lamartine’s sec- retary, prophesied it would. True, as the governmental speeches show, the odor of combat is still in the air. Yet even if the sympathy of France, official and popular together, should move away from him, French poetry and all litera- ture can never again be quite as they were without him. When he died Henry Houssaye could say: All who wield a pen to-day, prose writers as well as poets, journalists as well as playwrights, in greater or less degree pro- ceed from him. His imprint is on modern style. Strip this celebration of the fiftieth year of “La Légende des siécles” of its factitious surroundings, and it is the genuine tribute of the new century to what Emile Faguet calls “the gong in Victor Hugo's brain. Incident, anecdote, events struck upon it, and there was grave, sweet music or re sounding thunder.” 8. D.
Page 12
402 —— —_ —————— EE ———————————— NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES More than two years ago there were printed in this column some notes on the variations in several early editions of Sheridan's “School for Scandal,”’ in- cluding particulars of two American edi- tions, one printed in Philadelphia by Rob- ert Bell, in 1782, and the other by Hugh Gaine in New York in 1786 There has just been brought to our at- tention another Philadelphia imprint, with a similar title, “The School for Scandal. A Comedy The Third Edition London: Printed Philadelphia; Re-printed and Sold by Thomas Bradford, at the Coffee- House M. DCC. LXXIX.” An examina- tion of the text, however, shows that while the characters, so far as they ap- pear, are the same, the text is not that of Sheridan's play at all, but is political in purpose, relating to English affairs dur- ing the American war. Washington is once “General Washingball.”’ Baker in his “Biographia Dramatica”’ en ters “The School for Scandal, 8vo. 1778,” and describes it as “a paltry catch-penny, intended to be imposed on the public as the genuine production of Mr. Sheridan. This despicable piece is political.” Brad- ford's recorded by Hildeburn and copied from him by Sabin, Baker notes another political piece with the title “The School for Scandal As it is per- formed by His Majesty's Servants,”’ 1784 has no more relation to plece, than lead has to referred to as American edition is but it is undoubtedly very rare “This,” he says, Mr. Sheridan's gold. It is a political satire on the India Bill and the Coalition.” Sheridan's play was produced at Drury Lane Theatre on May 8, 1777. The first edition, printed in Dublin for J. Ewling, is without date and in booksellers’ catalogues is usually as- eribed to 1781; but, as Mr. Pollard has said, it is more likely that 1778 was the correct date. The title was an attractive one, and was appropriated for this politi- cal piece, which, by the way, is dedicated by its anonymous author to Richard Tick- ell, who was afterwards Sheridan's broth- er-in-law There was reason for Robert Bell, in bringing out the first American edl- tion of the play in 1780, to call it “The Real and Genuine School for Scandal.” On November 3, the Anderson Auction Company will sell a collection largely made up from the library of Mr. Sainsbury Lang- ford Sainsbury A presentation copy of Mra. Browning's “Poems” (1844); first edi- tions of Sir Thomas Browne's “Hydriota- phia” (1658), and the first authorized edi- tion of the “Religto Medici” (1643); first edition of Keats's “Endymion” (1818); a collection of books with Alken and Crulk- shank plates, including “Real Life in Lon- don” (1821-22) and Ireland's “Life of Na- poleon Bonaparte,” 4 vols. (1828), are nota- ble lots On November 4 and 6 the same house sells the second part of the J. C. Chamberlain collection. The first portion, sold last Feb- ruary, was made up of the books of the ten great American authors. The first editions of Aldrich, Curtis, James T. Fields, Cooper, Halleck, Harte, Mitchell, Parkman, Sted- man, Bayard Taylor, Walt Whitman, and other lesser lights are now offered, as well as some duplicate coples of books included in Part I. Among special rarities by minor authors we may note Aldrich’'s “Pére An- The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2313 teine’s Date Palm” (1866), “Pansy’s Wish” (1870), and “The Story of a Bad Boy’”’ (1870) ou large paper (six printed, of which three | were destroyed in the Boston fire of 1872); Drake and Halleck’s “Poems by Croaker, Croaker & Co.” (1819); Howell’s first book, “Poems by Two Friends” (1860); Motley’s two novels, “Morton’s Hope” (1839) and “Merry Mount” (1849); Stoddard’s ‘“Foot- prints” (1849); Taylor’s “Ximena” (1844), his first book with title reading, “By James Bayard Taylor’; and Whit- man’s “Two Rivulets” (1876), the author’s own copy, with many autograph corrections. Among the duplicate books by some of the ten great authors are Haw- tborne’s “Fanshawe” (1828); two copies of Lowell's “Poems” (1844) on large paper; and Longfellow’s “Outre Mer’ (1833-34). The “Rime di Michelagnolo Buonarroti” (Florence, Giunti, 1623), the very rare first edition of Michael Angelo’s poems, is one of the few foreign books in the collection. On November 1 and 3 the Merwin-Clayton Sales Company offer a collection of Ameri- cana including about thirty-five lots on California, books on the Indians, first edi- tions, a collection of Lincolniana, and a series of autograph letters, mostly of American authors. On November 4 and 5 they sell the library of the late Rev. Joseph Ee. Chapman of Perth Amboy. Books and pamphlets on New Jersey, the American Revolution, and several editions of the Book of Common Prayer are included. On November 3 and 4 Messrs C. F. Lib- bie & Co. of Boston will seil the libraries of James Brown and*David J. Lord. Mr. Brown's Burns collection was extensive, in- cluding a copy of the very rare first edi- tion “Poems chiefly in the Scottish Dia- lect” (Kilmarnock, 1786), the second edi- tion (Edinburgh, 1787), and later editions, among them a fine extra-illustrated set. Another copy of Bryant’s “White Footed Deer” (1844), a book which brought $285 in the Poor sale last year, turns up in this sale. Audubon’s Birds (1840-44) and Quadrupeds (1849-54); Michaux’s “North American Sylva” (1819), with the supple- ment by Nuttall (1849), and Wilson and Bonaparte’s “American Ornithology” (1808- 33), 13 vols. in 7, are important natural history books with colored plates. A long series of first editions of Bret Harte, collections of books on fencing and mem- ory culture, Kelmscott Press and Doves Press publications, and a lot of book-plates and books on book-plates, including a col- lection of 1,200 cards describing additions to Allen's “American Book-Plates,” are also offered. Correspondence. HENRY CHARLES LEA. To THe EpiTorR or Tue NATION: Sin: The death of Mr. Lea is a great loss | to historical science, of which he was the) foremost exponent in this country and one. of the world’s recognized leaders. His sub- | ject, medimval history, was in his deft hands, | and with his exhaustive study, revived in the | long series of volumes on church history | and kindred topics. His reputation as a) scholar and an author was greater abroad | even than at home. His chief work was ‘translated into French and Italian and Ger- |man, and the scholars in those countries paid tribute to him. At home he was elect- ed president of the American Historical As- sociation, and was honored by degrees from our principal universities. Years of toil were spent by him in gathering great quan- tities of original material from Spain and Italy, from France and Germany, from Mexico and South America, and not only did he use it with advantage in his own vol- umes, but he gave access to it freely to younger students. His life was one of ear- nest research for the truth, and he put his conclusions in clear language, every state- ment supported by exact references to the sources of contemporary writings of author- ity. But Mr. Lea was much more than a schol- |ar; he was an active reformer and a mas- terful worker in every field for improving the nation, the State, and the city in which he lived. He was the leader in every real movement for improving the body politic, and whatever of reform spirit exists in Philadelphia and Pennsylvania owes its ori- gin to him. During the civil war he was ardent in his zeal and his work for the Un- ion, and his facile and graceful pen produc- ed much of the useful literature issued by | the Union League of Philadelphia, an im- portant factor in guiding the war for the Union to a successful end. The son of a distinguished scientific man, Igaac Lea, who was a leading authority on many branches of natural history, Henry C. Lea in his boyish days contributed to the American Academy of Natural Sciences papers that attested his ability, industry, and original- ity. A small volume contained some verses and poems that attested his literary clever- ness. It was in his maturer life, during an active business career as a publisher, that he began the collection of matcrial for the succession of works on mediwval church history which surprised the scholarly world by their exhaustive and masterly character. His public benefacticns to the University of Pennsylvania and to the Philadelphia Libra- ry and to many other institutions, showed that, although not himself a university graduate, he was fully alive to the impor- tance and advantage of thus strengthening education. The fact that the first and largest recog- nition of his work as historian and scholar came from abroad, ought to be a lesson to our own universities and the public organs of learning in this country. Great as is the praise given to Mr. Lea’s works to- day, both at home and abroad, it was wel- come to him only as an incitement to re- newed study and authorship, and he leaves an unfinished volume on the subject he had made peculiarly his own, that ought to be | published to show his method of work and | his almost judicial impartiality in dealing | with the material gathered in years of re- search from forgotten and neglected sources. He set an example of sound scholarship that has already been fruitful of good re- sults in historical writing. The Nation owes him this tribute, for he was among those who first took a substan- tial part in its establishment, and of more value than his money help were the literary contributions that he gave to its columns, when hig time and his pen seemed fully en- grossed by his studies and by his wr ‘tings. J, G. ROSENGARTEN, Philadelphia, October 24. od then ie OL Be a tar als Pa eh meow Neh e Ce ee ee eee
Page 13
a ° art? Katee ect. PO pare Ls eT ete NA ieee SNAP te aint ese A witinl eA T oe Steg eenaisney Fink Oct. 28, 1909] VERSE AND MELODY. To THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Str: I am a little surprised this week to find condemned, in the music column of the Nation, a tendency which I had been accustomed to regard with not a little approval. If “Danny Deever’’ must serve as a point of departure for esthetic discussion, at least the problem involved is by no means so slight as the occasion First, I must confess that Damrosch’s “cheap” setting of this poem, and its ren- dering by Mr. Bispham, have seemed to me pretty nearly what the piece required. I believe, on the whole, there is a great deal of indefinite talk, and much more in- definite thinking, on the subject of what a “song” ought to be. The pre-Wagnerian librettists were not so far astray in one particular, at least; they recognized their limitations. They recognized—as many of us to-day have entirely forgotten—that one cannot attend to two different artistic appeals at once. The point has been dis- cussed; sometimes, it is true, with little enough understanding; sometimes very ably. The latest and best treatment of it I know is in Mr. Yeats, the Irish poet's, book of essays, “Ideas of Good and Evil.” Grateful indeed for the Nation's clear statement of the case, I find myself quite unable to accept your critic’s final judg- ment. If art, as a French writer has said, is a species of hypnotism (allowing the epigram to contain at least this germ of truth, that artistic appreciation re- quires almost hypnotic attention), we must admit our inability to be hypnotized by two things at once. It is precisely as your critic says: there are “songs in which the music plays second—sometimes twenty- second—fiddle to the poem.” Surely this is as it should be, in certain cases—most notably in “Danny Deever.” Either the poetic appeal predominates, or the musical. There can be no such thing as “two arts going hand in hand.” In cases where they seem to do so, it is we who are deceived. Either the music forms a mere accompaniment, a chant as it were, for the poem; or the poem is a mere cord on which is strung the harmony. Of course, one thinks first of all of the Wag- nerian opera, which I do not wish to discuss here in detail; I believe in this case we know the text, and rely on the music for the emotional appeal. Confin- ing ourselves to songs, who is there who has not often felt, after listening to some elaborate musical setting of an intense lyric, that somehow it was all wrong, in spite of the excellence of the music— that the words did not require all this? I remember the first time I heard Debussy’s music to Verlaine’s magical revery, ‘La Lune blanche.” Of course I knew the poem by heart, but I confess I did not listen to the words; I could not. The music held me entirely. And yet, as an artistic whole, I felt the performance to be unsatisfactory. The music did not—it could not—express exactly the same train and blendings of emotion evoked by the words. Instead of artistic unity there was a duality of appeal, a conflict. It seems that we must either write music pure and simple, to a set of words that merely suggest the subject without ex- acting deep emotiona] effort; or, on the other hand, be content merely to accom- The Nation. pany verse. Music written in the first of these two manners includes all legitimate opera and oratorio, together with such songs as, say, the sixteenth-century set- ting of “It was a lover and his lass,” where a charming melody and movement (entirely different from the natural rhythm of the words) make the true appeal; on Lieder, such as many of Shubert's and Nevin's; or more popular songs, such, for instance, as “In Old Madrid.” In the second class I am tempted to include the traditional music to Ophelia’s “And will he not come again?’’; and most certainly many modern songs, among which would be our “Danny Deever,”” ‘Mandalay,’ Mrs Woodforde-Finden'’s “‘Less Than the Dust and “The Temple Bells,"’ and Tosti's ‘Good bye.”’ It is asked: “‘What then is to become of music, of melody, if this continues?” One feels like retorting ‘What is to become of verse, of poetry, if this opera business goes on?” I think the musical art, like itself to content with ‘playing second fiddle.”’ Still, I can under stand why such a view must be the poetic, must either confin its proper sphere, or be heresy to a musician I suppose it is just because music is the most elusive of the arts that there is so little real musical criticism That which itself ‘‘musical usually either confines itself to the discussion of technique, or wanders into the bypaths of “appreciation” and “in- terpretation.”’ One yearns for more really intellectual dedling with musical lems; such as, for example, that least crit- ical of critics, Mr. Arthur Symons, has given us in his essay on Strauss, in his “Studies in the Seven Arts.” C. H. DICKERMAN. Philadelphia, October 21. calls criti- cism” prob- {Mr. Dickerman’s remarks are worth pondering, but they do not answer our cbjections to the new tendency in song vecitals. There are many poems, like “Danny Deever,” to which it is a super- fluity to add music. The fact that musi- cians formerly insulted poetry by using it as a mere scaffolding, is no reason why, now, meaningless music shou'd be used as an excuse for bringing certain poems into the concert-halls. A song should be what it is in the Goethe-Schu- bert “Erlking’—an amalgamation of great verse with great music.—Ep. Na- TION. ] FRUIT-GROWING IN NEW ENGLAND To THE EpitTor OF THE NATION Sir: During the past week in Buston the attention of the public has been called to the beginning of an organized attempt ol the New England fruit growers to capture their own market. Of late years t!.is mar ket has been controlled by Western rrowers notably those of Oregon. Their fru:t is al ways perfect in form, highly colored, and well packed, It has been so attrac*ive that New England orchardists have ¢°nerally dropped their hands, feeling that tion was impossible. There have always “ompeti- been, however, men who knew better; and these men have at last, by preaching and by practice, succeeded in making peopie that New England has a chance after all. aware 403 This chance depends on five factors (1) that New England orchard land ‘s now cheaper than Western; (2) that tne soil as repeatedly proved, is not worn »ut, but with proper handling is excellent for fruit: (3) that the Fastern farmer can pick his fruit when it is more mature lan the Western, and thus finer flavored 1) that the cost of transportation is notably less; and (5) the answer to the question: Is the astern fruit as attractive as the Western? To answer this question there has been held in Horticultural Hall, Boston. an ex- hibition devoted solely to New ngland fruit No doubts of the possibilitics of New England orchard could survive an ex amination of the exhibits. Not only in flavor, but also in shape, in size, and ip olor, the fruits displayed were che equal of truit grown anywhere else in America This is, of yurse the result of modern iethods of spraying and general culture What New England now has to learn is the ommon sense of marketing its fruit rhe first requirement here is proper limi tation of varieties Professor Craiz points out that it is the part of wisdom to grow few varieties, but to become known for growing those varieties well rhe senee of the fruit exhibition agrees with this, for while there were almost hundreds of va rieties shown in small quantities, the large packages were all of a few varieties. in apples scarcely more than half a dozen. The second requirement is proper grading of the crop, so that inferior grades are either sold as such, or not brought te market at all (It was a part of the purpose of the exhibition to illustrate meang of the eco- nomical disposal of culled fruit.) The third requirement is attractive packing Here the bushel box promises to supersede the basket of two or three dozen choice fruits will hold the retail trade. The sixth require- ment is uniform branding, so that packages bearing the name of an individual or of an organization can be depended on year after year barrel, while perhaps some day the The most striking feature of th's whole movement is that it has been endorsed by the Boston Chamber of Commerc« For the first time departing from its custom, the Chamber !ast week devoted one of its meet ings to the encouragement and discussion of an agricultural enterprise At its din ner there was presented a printed report on the possibilities of New England fruit Some 600 men growing farmers and men of business, sat down together The spokesman for the Chamber of Commerce: promised help in securing legislation and fair railway rates; the spokesman fo he Nothing in the whole meeting equalled the roar of mingled Hale, the most prominent fruit-grower in the East, farmers asked for capital delight and applause when J. H and, perhaps, in the country, referring to he preface to the printed report, cried Think of that, fellers showing us the chance that lies before us!" Then, turning to the bankers, he asked for onfidence and support. “How much is Lee Higginson willing to put up?” It is searcely to be supposed that the movement will stop here. New England has these city dudes in itself or within twenty-four hours of its borders a third of the population of the country, the third which is not only the wealthiest, but also—since it is the manu- facturing portion of the country—the least
Page 14
404 agricuitural, wanting the best and ready to pay for it. The market is at hand, then, and not only the home market, but also the for New England is at the gateway great European trade in fruit. New England, let us believe, is coming again into its own. 4. F foreign of a Concord Mase.. October 23 HETCH-HETCHY To THe EpiTror or THe NATIUN Sir As the meeting of Congress ap- proaches, the public is concerned about its action on the pending bills, confirming the Hetch-Hetchy Valley as a reser- voir to supply water to San Francisco. Al- though this measure failed at the last regu- ube of lar session, it will be pushed again before the new Congress Those who seek to turn Hetch-Hetchy into a reservoir are endeavoring to estab- lish the new principle that a national park is merely a temporary sequestration of the natural objects contained within its boun- They hold that nationa! parks must cease to exist in time, by the appropriation of the utilities which they and that a municipality has a perfect right to invade a national park, if it elects to do so, in spite of the fact that the same utility may be obtained easily elsewhere. Ex-Secretary of Interior Garfield, issued a revocable permit to use Hetch- Hetchy Valley, in his permit that: “The present water supply of the city of San Francisco is both inadequate and un- satisfactory."’ But the evidence taken be- fore the Senate committee, and before the the present nor daries contain; who stated House committee, proved that water supply is neither “inadequate” “unsatisfactory.” It appears in this evidence that the Spring Valley water system, which now supplies with water, is ample for present needs, and is capable of being developed sufficiently to supply a San Francisco population three times as great as the present population of San Francisco. The supply now is 36,000,000 gallons a day; and according to the carefully prepared state ment of a former city engineer, it can be leveloped to 109,000,000 gallons a day. It d, further, in evidence, that the San at hand, may be pump appeoare Joaquin River, close ed from for an additional supply of 150 000,000 gallons a day. So that San Francisco has close at hand a water supply sufficient for a population of 3,000,000; which is more than the ty has ever stated can be ob talned from Heteh-Hetchy. Moreover, from the evidence, it appears that, by using a markable natural filter belonging to the ne Valley system, this water can be lelivered in a filtered condition, equal in quality, if not uperior what may be obtained from the Hetch-Hetchy ix - Se Garfield, in his revocable etary rmit, aleo made this statement 1 do t need to pass upon the claim that this ts the only practicable and rea sonable source of supply for the city. It that after a careful and com ia sufficient jale insist that such petent study, the of is the case startiing statement, to come from a leading official of the United States He held that it was not his investigate, in behalf of the na- ntegrity of & interesting to This is a government duty to destroying the It would be before park. tion, national much public business he did on learn how his successor has found a serious work at hand, in restoring the administration of the Department of the Interior toa law- | abiding basis. As a matter of fact, evidence taken before Congress showed that no source of water supply, other than the Hetch-Hetchy, had been seriously in- vestigated or even considered by the city officials. All these officials of San Francis- co tacitly admit that plenty of water can be had elsewhere. If the people of the that the national United States lieve park system is a the | [Vol. 89, No. 231 OF FAITH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Professor Lombroso’s latest volume on psychic matters (“After Death—What?’’) has a pathetic interest from the fact that |it was issued in America only three days be- | wise and permanent feature of our national | policy, they must make that belief effective in Congress next winter. If they wish to preserve the Yosemite National Park, which contains the Hetch-Hetchy Valley, inviolate in its natural grandeur, they must insist that their representatives in Washington shall abrogate the revocable permit which has been so injudiciously issued by ex-Secretary Garfield. GEORGE EDWARDS. Berkeley, Cal., October 8. A BRITISH ICARUS. TO THE EpItToR OF THE NATION: Sir: We have often heard lately of Icarus and Darius Green as giving warn- ing of the perils of aerial navigation. According to the legendary history of Britain, no less a person than the father of | King Lear and son of King Hudibras was the first aeroplanist at whose flight the British neck craned and heart sank; and | he suffered from adverse winds and treach- erous machinery even more than the Wrights and Latham have done. Less wise than his near-namesake Blériot, King Bladud took his flight not above the Chan- nel, but above London: He boasted that he wonld fly In the manner of a bird, That all his folk might see, And his flights behold He made his feather-gear, And therefor be had mickle shame. To London he fared With his mickle folk His feather-gear he put on him, And his flight there began; With his cunning flight He drew toward the upper air; He fared very high, To the welkin he was nigh The wind came against him, His flights wavered, The strings broke That he stretched his wings with, And he fell to the The king was fated earth, Upon a place That tn London stood, Apollin's temple, Which was the mighty fend. The king fell on the roof, That he was dashed in pleces Thus was the kingdom Of ite king bereft Most of this is due to the imagination of our first distinguished poet since early Anglo-Saxon times, the twelfth-century country-priest Layamon (the original is in Madden's edition of his so-called “Brut,”’ ll. 2870-97) torla,” his ultimate, and Wace's “Brut,” his immediate source, have only a few words on Bladud’s flight. Joun 8. P. TATLOCK. Ann Arbor, Mich., October 7. Geoffrey of Monmouth’s “His- | before his own decease. If there is any answer to his question he knows it now. In his volume he expresses through- out a most profound belief in the survival of the mind after the dissolution of the vis- ible body, and his preface shows that he wished the work to be taken as his confessio fidei, or last testament, to the world. Hasty and superficial critics, spying a jtable of a few errata in the book, have |leaped to the unwarranted conclusion that all due to a careless trans- proof-reader. The fact is that Lombroso’s manuscript was hon- eycombed with mistakes in English and American proper names, due, I judged, largely to his copyists, but partly to be ascribed to his astonishing handwriting, in which both his copyists and I had a good deal to struggle with in the way of emendations, interlineations, and additions. If you will catch a small housefly, dip his feet in ink, and then let him walk over a sheet of paper, the minute trails made will give some idea of the microscopically they are lator and Professor ‘fine lines of this eminent pathologist. But nothing except a facsimile would adequate- ly portray it. An aggravating feature of the professor's cacography was furnished by his habit of writing only a part of a word (‘“dimens” for ‘dimension’ and “psicolog” for “psicologia,”’ e. g., my eye catches in a letter of his now before me, in reference to my translation). I found him, however, very patient in writing over and explaining illegible words, to the slight extent he was able to do so in re- vised drafts of his copy. I must say, how- ever, that the task of licking his manu- script into shape, and tracing out and veri- fying his references and correcting his errors in English and American names, was rather formidable. And it is this background of unrewarded work in a book of this kind that superficial critics rarely recognize or understand, even when they have been through similar experiences themselves—a thing to make one wonder. WILLIAM SLOANE KENNEDY. Belmont, Mass., October 21. A SCIENTIST TO DR. COOK. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Dr. Cook tells us that he needs something like two months in order to prepare his records for submission to ex- perts. What the experts want is the rec- ords exactly as they were made in the Arctic regions. If Cook insists that they must be revised or explained, let him at once place them in the hands of some com- petent body, such as a trust company, who shall hold them for such use as Cook wish- es to make, provided that he works on their prémises and in the presence of a trusty witness, who shall at the end of the work testify under oath to the precise nature of the additions that Cook has made; and let this sworn statement go with the rec- ords when they are submitted to experts * és heres ah a al RAS 6 at ined ia be —e
Page 15
ee ee ce an nee Sede eB® ee ee Oct. 28, 1909] at Copenhagen or elsewhere. Cook's friends in particular are just the persons who should insist on this method of working the records up for examination. Without some competent and impartial testimony as to the nature of two months’ work on the records, the public will be in grave doubt as to what is original and what is “improved.” x. Cambridge, Mass., October 22. Literature. HARPER'S FERRY BURG. John Brown. By W. E. Burghardt Du- Bois. Philadelphia: George W. Ja- cobs & Co. $1.25 net. That so gifted a writer as the author of “Souls of Black Folk” should te tempted to write a new life of John Brown from the point of view of the negro is easily understood. It also goes without saying that Dr. DuBois has made a readable volume of his apprecia- tion of the martyr of 1859, the fiftieth anniversary of whose execution is now at hand. So little have the negroes themselves as yet done to honor the memory of John Brown that this book might have taken on a special signifi- cance. But Dr. DuBois’s work is dis- appointing in that it betrays no original research and abounds in inaccuracies. This is partly because he has relied upon his predecessors in the field. His is the eighth serious biography of John Brown to appear and unfortunately only one or two of these were written in the spirit or manner of the historian who desires to be impartial and to go to orig- inal sources for his information. Thus Col. R. J. Hinton’s book is frankly a brief for Brown, and Mr. Sanborn's biography, a treasure-house of material, suffers from the author’s association with the preparations for Harper's Fer- ry. It is, moreover, twenty-four years old and since its publication much las come to light, both in Kansas and else- where, which is of importance to the 'n terpreter of Brown and his times. For this and other reasons, Dr. Du- Bois leaned upon untrustworthy stave: when he relied upon his predecessors A few examples will suffice. He accepts Col. Hinton’s attribution to Edmund Babb of Cincinnati of the anonymous letter of August 20, 1859, betray- ing Brown’s exact plans to Secre- tary Floyd. But it has been known for years that David J. Gue, now liv- ing in New York city, was the author o: that letter and that it was written not to injure Brown, but to save his life by heading off the raid. The fu!’ story Dr. DuBois will find in Benjamin F. Gue’s valuable “History of Iowa,” published in 1903. Again, he follows Redpath in accusing the Border Ruffians of wholesale assaulting of women in th« AND GETTYS- The Nation. early Kansas days. In the entire range of Kansas literature and manuscripts now |available, there are but two recorded instances of this crime, and these are by no means wholly established, for at least one rests only upon Redpath’s word, when acting as correspondent of an Eastern newspaper. Dr. DuBois also assumes, with another biographer, that John Brown's victims en the Pottowat- omie had the benefit of some sort of trial. But not a scintilla of evidence has yet been produced to confirm this belief. Indeed, the facts all make against it. Again, Dr. DuBois accepts without investigation the repeated statements that John Brown was descended from Peter Brown of the Mayflower, although this is denied by the foremost authorities on the Mayflower genealogies. Finally, it must be noted that Dr. DuBois fol- lows Sanborn, Hinton, and others in justifying the abominable Pottowatom:e massacre, which, had it been perpetrat- ed by Border Ruffians, would have been denounced as a crime against humanity. But Dr. DuBois’s own errors are nu- merous enough. He makes of George B. Gill, Brown's Kansas follower, a Canad- ian (p. 223), whereas he was an Amer- ican; to Jeremiah G. Anderson of In- diana, born of sturdy, white farmer parentage, he attributes negro blood (p. 282), and Lewis Sheridan Leary, a free- born negro, becomes slave-born on the same page and is dubbed Lewis Sher- rard Leary as well. Of the twenty-two raiders, Dr. DuBois says that “six or seven” were negroes; he adds John An- derson, a mythical raider, and Jere- miah G. Anderson to the five actuai ne- groes, Leary, Copeland, O. P. Anderson, Green, and Newby. Incredible as it may seem, Dr. DuBois records that seven- teen negroes were “probably killed” in the raid, when, besides four of Brown's negroes, Leary, Copeland, Green, and Newby, but two slaves lost their lives, and neither of these while fighting. He accepts also, in all its absurdities, the narrative of O. P. Anderson, the negro who escaped, and endorses it as a trust- worthy document. Yet Anderson insist- ed, for one thing, that there were thirty men killed on the Southern side, ia the face of Col. Robert E. Lee's official re- port to President Buchanan that there were but five deaths, all told, in uddi- tion to John Brown’s own losses; and Lee is yet to be accused of falsifying facts or failing to obtain them. Dr. DuBois is not, however, to be bound even by John Brown's words, for he evolves the astounding theory that the raid failed through the delay of the rear-guard in Maryland in moving the arms into Harper’s Ferry before the trap into which Brown had walked was sprung. But, unfortunately for this, Brown repeatedly stated while in jail that he deserved to be hanged for his military blundering (for instance see New York Herald, November 24, 1859), 405 and he assured Gov. Wise and others that his care for his prisoners led him to delay too long, despite the warnings of his men that he must leave the town at once. Part of Dr. DuBois's difficulty here is due to his belief that William Thompson, Brown's messenger to the rear-guard, failed to reach it. If he should read Terence Byrne's testimoay before the Senate Committee of Inquiry and John E. Cook's confession, he would not only ascertain that Thompson did carry out his instructions but find many details with which he is now unac quainted. Coming to John Brown's trial, Dr DuBois says that the jury “was em- panelled without challenge,” although, in fact, Brown's counsel used every peremptory challenge to which he was entitled. This is duly recorded in the minutes of the trial and attested by the presiding judge. Again, the author places Brown in Iowa in August, 1856, although he never entered the State at that time. But why continue? A page of the Nation would not suffice to record the other slips which make it impos- sible to accept this volume, readable as it is, as a reliable contribution to Amer- ica’s history. This is most regret- table because of Dr. DuBois’s valuable sociological studies, upon the accuracy of which no doubts have been cast His last chapter in the book before us is a notable discussion of the race question as it stands to-day in the light of John Brown's sacrifice. The Battie of Gettysburg. By Frank A. Haskell. Wisconsin History Commis- sion. This account of the great battle of the civil war, written within a month of the engagement, has had a somewhat singular fortune. Though printed at once, it received little attention untill after forty-five years. Then, in quick editions, somewhat Eng- These have been widely circulat succession, two garbled, were published in New land, ed, the narrative so long neglected be- ing declared by high authority to be “far and away the best description of Gettysburg ever written.” In view of this recognition, the Wiscozsin History Commission does well to reprint the document once more, taking care that the text shall stand as originally writ ten. Since this long-forgotten story is sud denly receiving such attention, it will be worth while to consider what it is ani what it is not. Haskell, a Dartmouth graduate of 1854, settled as a lawyer in Wisconsin, whence he went to the war, falling at last at Cold Harbor, in 1864, colonel of his regiment (the Thirty- sixth Wisconsin Volunteers), and in command of a brigade. His service had been constant and brilliant. In 1863 he was adjutant-general on the staff of
Page 16
406 Gibbon, commander of the Second Corps at Gettysburg, and in that capacity went through the memorable three July days. Before the month ended, he set down what he had witnessed and en- dured in a letter to a brother, without thought of publication, and this letter constitutes the book. As the personal record of a brave and capable soldier who was in the heart of the battle, the story deserves all that has been claimed; as a history of however, it has inevitable What fell kell’s own eyes—-and he saw much be- sides the work of the Second Corps—he describes with surprising accuracy and the event hortcomings under Has- vividness; in what he reports from hearsay, he sometimes errs and some- times omits, though he hits the truth ore nearly than would seem possible, writing as he did almost at the moment. lle represents Meade as having selected Gettysburg for the encounter, and as de- liberately concentrating there for that purpose: it is now well established that the meeting of Buford’s cavalry with A. . Hill's corps, which brought on the en- gagement, on the morning of July 1, was quite by chance, and that Meade fought on ground of which he was ignorant, his plan for making a stand at Pipe Creek coming to naught. As regards the work of the wings, Haskell’s report is neither full nor correct. The strug- gle on the left for Little Round Top, on July 2, one of the crises of this battle, receives slight mention, and the name of so distinguished a participant as G. K. Warren is not once given. The immi- nence of the danger which the Twelfth Corps warded off on the right, when the Stonewall division pushed to within an eighth of a mile of the Federal rear, on the Baltimore pike, has small ap- preciation. Haskell’s necessarily has- ty judgments as to men and events must sometimes be rejected. He de nies to Sickles, commander of the Third Corps, both character and capacity, and holds his conduct, on July 2, in taking ground in advance of the line laid down for him by Meade, to be quite incom- prehensible; whereas, though Sickles’s disobedience may have been inexcus able. he nevertheless had, in the dom- inance in his front of the crest along which runs the Emmitsburg road, an excellent military reason for feeling un easy Our author never mentions the Eleventh Corps except in terms of dis- paragement; and yet no one circum- stance probably contributed more to- ward the Federal success than Stein- wehr’s occupation, on July 1, of the crest of Cemetery Hill. The possibility of a counterstroke, immediately after Pickett’s repulse on July 3, does not seem to enter our author's mind, al- though he states that the Sixth Corps, the largest in the army, well comman(4- ed. not hitherto engaged, and burning The Nation. for conflict, stood right on the field within a mile or two of the disordered Confederate retreat. He sets July 13 as the earliest moment when Lee could be attacked with any hope of success. Then at Williamsport the triumphant Federals held their discomfited foes in a narrow space, with the swollen Po tomac behind them. Even here he de- clares Meade was not over-cautious in delaying attack till he had fully recon- noitred. The result of the delay, how- ever, was Lee’s complete escape. The world has come to feel that Meade’s cau- tion was untimely, and that the war thereby was sadly prolonged. Gettysburg’s great interest lies in the question it suggests: Why did Lee fail? As a soldier, Lee is indubitably a far greater figure than Meade. How could such a leader fail, in the prime of his power, with an army almost match- less, practically equal in numbers to the adversaries, whom he had repeatedly beaten? Did Lee’s own management come short, or were his lieutenants at fault? What brought that proud spirit so low that he fell into depres- sion, begged he might be allowed to re- sign, and that some younger man might take his place? It is hardly fair to look to Haskell for an answer to these inter- esting questions. Haskell’s record, therefore, is not at all a satisfactory history of Gettysburg. But as an account of what one man saw and went throrgh in that battle it is| perhaps unrivalled. His position was at the centre, in closest touch with the defence of the lines against Pickett’s charge, the event in which the battle culminated. While on some minor points he is in conflict with other good | witnesses of the event, his substantial | accuracy cannot be doubted, while for vividness the description has not been excelled. We mention as passages espe- cially graphic the council of war at Meade’s headquarters on the night of July 2, with its pictures of the corps- commanders as they gathered; the re- past on the crest, immediately before the Confederate assault, of which Meade, Hancock, Gibbon, and Pleasanton par- took, chatting meanwhile of what lay behind and before; and, finally, the breasting of the storm of attack. Here, by a miracle, Haskell, the only mount ed officer, escaped with merely a severe contusion. His stout horse, though gash- ed by a shell and with three bullets in his body, did not fail him until the “high tide” rolled back from the “clum) of trees.” The Wisconsin History Commission deserves thanks for printing entire and in authentic shape this invaluable doc- ument. [Vol. 89, No. 2313 CURRENT FICTION, Martin Eden. By Jack London. New York: The Macmillan Co. The literary free lance is, as should be well-known, the butt of an unfeeling world. He eats behind the screen in the bookseller’s shop, or below salt at the editorial table. Though he work at his unorganized trade twenty hours a day, he is looked upon as rather a shiftless person. People wonder why he does not get a job, and editors return his manuscripts quite as if he did not need the money. It very seldom falls to him to be avenged as handsomely as he now is in re “Martin Eden.” Martin came of poor and otherwise unspecified parentage, had a few years of public-schooling, and went to sea with his teens, already an accomplish. ed hoodlum. He had thereafter a varied experience as hand before the mast, stevedore, pearl-diver, smuggler, and general rowdy of adventure. At twenty, happening to spend between voyages an interval at San Francisco, he met a young woman of higher social standing, and fell in love with her. One of two things might have been expected to fol- low: either the girl would scorn him for his uncouthness, and he, after a period of outer darkness, would find himself a mate of his own class; or he would raise himself to something ap- proaching his beloved’s level, develop business ability, and be taken into part- nership with her father. Neither of these things did actually happen. In- stead, Martin made up his mind to be an author. This naturally seemed a pre- posterous programme to the girl, who called his attention to the probability that an apprenticeship was necessary to the trade of letters as to any other. Martin did not see this; he began 4 stiff if random course of reading all by himself, progressing in a few days trom Swinburne to Madame Blavatsky and Spencer. The girl advised him to study grammar, and, for a wonder, he took the advice, studying by himself throughout an eight months’ voyage, and returning to San Francisco a master of English. Apparently the whole subsequent action takes place within a year or so. Mar- tin wrote an extraordinary amount of copy and sent it the rounds of the prin- cipal editorial markets. He knew it was a good deal better than most copy, but for a long time none of it was ac- cepted. This offended his sense of jus- tice, but he kept on. After an immense interval (several months, apparently), one or two manuscripts were taken, and either not paid for, or paid for at starv- ation rates. A group of lyrics which he sold to a Chicago publication (at a dollar apiece) were horribly garbled by the tyrant at the editorial desk. Meanwhile he had become betrothed to the girl, against her parent’s wishes, against her own better judgment. She baad CS hee Oe re ek te tetas lt
Page 17
. : R/V Pa Pye men See Oct. 28, 1909] considered herself his superior in every | detail but physical strength. She had taken a university degree (in English), and knew the conventional thing to say on “culture” topics. But he refused to accept a place in her father’s office, and went on writing copy which she con- demned because it was unsalable. Final- ly she sent him about his business, and it was then that the tide chanced to turn. A book (a philosophical treatise) was accepted by an Eastern publisher, and made a big hit, on the strength of which Martin was able to unload every word of copy he had previously offered in vain. He wrote no more, but con- tented himself with the ironical occupa- tion of piling up a fortune of a hundred thousand on the strength of work which had been done and despised before his coup. Martin was now a disillusioned man, and his startling end was near. In achieving it, he employed the only means by which he could adequately express his contempt for university peo- ple, editors, publishers, and the reading mob. Such of the reading mob as may be attracted to his history are likely to discern a good deal of autobiography therein, and to be stirred piquantly by its daring adumbrations of various well- known proper names. But nothing ac- tionable! The Way Things Happen. By Hugi de Selincourt. New York: John Lane Co. And do they really happen in the world as they do in this gentlewomanly chronicle? Incontrovertibly they do; indeed, one might accuse Mr. de Selin- court of plagiarizing Real Life, that novelist who sticks at no improbability and to whom no canon of art is sacred. In its mild, low-voiced moralizing, its gracious and circumspect composure, its seemly emotions, this sudden idyl of London recalls the immortal “long, thin love-story of two o'd maids and an old bachelor,” which some of us hold more truly the crown of Thrums than Tom- my himself. Miss Paul, a gentle lady who has become a specialist in joy de- spite loneliness and poverty, meets with a man whose capacity for joy has sur- vived the yet more crucial test of lone- liness and wealth. The first time he steps from his six-cylinder Napier at the | door of her lodgings, he proposes, after the manner of a prince in a fairy-tale, to carry her off straightway to a fu- ture of love and luxury. She is as frank and simple in the confession of her own need of him, but they are barely set- tled in their new home when he is brought dying from a street accident, and the gentle looker-on at life sees the close of her golden interlude. Her brave struggle to be true to his name for her—“my apostle of joy”—fills the rest of her life and of the book, which her chronicler closes with this fitting epitaph: “A little corner of the world was unquestionably cleaner and The Nation. brighter and happier because she had lived. That is why her history is worth recording.” It is a pity that so charming a whole should be marred by a somewhai af- fected style; Mr. de Selincourt’s pen picks its way at times with a mincing primness the example for which could never have been set by Miss Paul's feet. The City of Beautiful Nonsense. By E. Temple Thurston. New York: WJodd, Mead & Co. The web of this romance is spun quite in the French manner. And, indeed, the reader, from the first chapter, becomes a busy translator, re-turning to France the plot, the geography, the manners, epigrams, and language of this clever and entertaining little idyil. When by chance John and Jill meet at St. Jo- seph’s altar on the eve of the saint's day, on candle-burning bent, it is hard for the reader to regard them as really at home in Sardinia Street Chapel, in London; his fancy carries the actors to Paris The blended pathos and sen- timentality of white-haired parents and young lovers—the wedded wit and hu- mor—these qualities are equally deftly managed, equally Gallic. Even the lan- guage has at times the manner of a translation, as in such sentences as these: An ideal as high above the conception of life as it is good for the eyes of man to lift. Since he had come back from Venice the world might have been dead of her. There is, however, an untranslated sound about “awfully cute,” and it is a blow when John thus describes his little white-haired mother. Grammar too of- ten suffers, and proofreading has fail- ed to alleviate; but delightful sayin.zs bubble freely and certain scenes have the lustre of fine enamel. |The Redemption of Kenneth Galt. By Will N. Harben. New York: Harper & Bros. There is a sort of playfulness occa- sionally indulged in by well-known pub- lishers, that consists in launching a trashy book with a reputable imprint, to the great discomfiture of the too- trusting public. Harper & Bros., in such a mood, cast forth “Kenneth Galt.” So might a staid and ponderous judge cast a paper-filled purse in the street on All Fools’ Day, looking to his victims’ wry faces for his jest’s reward. This book has astonishingly little excuse for being, even in this age of incontinent pens. The plot and characters are as hackneyed as the title, and the quality of the English, which is richly jour- nalese, differs sadly from that of mercy. Even the moral is of questionable value, though the writer’s intention is evident- ly honorable. Kenneth Galt has ruined and deserted a simple village maiden; she has shielded him—at the expense of AOT another man’s reputation—through a series of persecutions that are at the present day the specialty of melodrama. He returns, to find her noble, talented, self-supporting, and more beautiful than ever. He yearns for her and for his child, and finally overcomes her natural aversion to his belated proposals of mar- riage by working on her desire to give their boy an unblemished name. She marries him, therefore, loving and re- specting another man, who, we may re- mark in passing, seems to have done but little to deserve these sentiments. Such are the papers in the April Fool purse. Regarded humorously, the book may be enjoyed; and, after all, one could hardly be prepared to take the contents of such a cover seriously. CITY GOVERNMENT. Chapters on Municipal Administration Frederick A Longmans, and Accounting. By Cleveland. New York: Green, & Co. 2 net. Accounts; Their Construction and It terpretation. By William Morse Cole. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $2 net. We are only gradually awakening to understand that the management of a modern municipality is a matter of bus- iness. We have devoted much attention to the relative merits of the mayoralty and the commission scheme of govern- ment, to the composition of the commou council, to the appointment of certain municipal officials by the State, and the like; but in only one or two of our larg- est cities, and there only recently, have we come to appreciate that a municipal- ity is a corporation with manifold and complicated activities, and that, to be directed in such manner as to promote the highest public welfare, it must em- ploy the most approved and modern business methods. It is the purpose of this book by Mr. Cleveland, the director of the Bureau of Municipal Research ta New York city, to advance this idea, The volume is a collection of magazine articles, and of addresses and reports delivered to various bodies during the last six years. It has the weaknesses which are necessarily found in a work of this sort: it is loosely constructed full of repetition, and in some respects out of date. However, its constant re iteration of fundamental principles wiil prove not to be a fault if it results in driving home the indisputable propost- tions so clearly and convincingly set forth. These propositions can be briefly stated. First, good government is based on ac curate knowledge. Legislation which prescribes the powers and duties of of ficials may be ever so carefully drawn, but it is impotent to accomplish its pur pose if the public is without the infor- mation necessary to appraise the ser- vices of its officials. Secondly, this pub-
Page 18
408 licity can be secured in the modern mu- nicipality, with its manifold financial, industrial, and social activities, only through a complete scientific system of accounts. Thirdly, such a system of accounts will fail of its purpose if it con- templates merely a scheme of checks and balances which shall protect the public against official malfeasance. Rather must the system be patterned after that em- ployed by the large business corpora tion, and so present the facts that they will form a basis for wise administra- The administrative valuc of accounts—-this is the doctrine urged throughout the volume. The skeptical have only to read the detailed descrip- tion of the condition of New York's ac- counts at the time investigation was undertaken by the Bureau of Munici- pal Research to be convinced of the ne cessity of some new system that will let in the light. It is certainly a pitiful spectacle when the greatest city in the country is utterly unable to determine from its records whether or not it has exceeded its debt limit. Chapters are devoted to the considera- tion of separate departments of munici- pal administration, such, for example, as the New York Board of Education, hospitals, and eleemosynary institu- tions. It is to be regretted that the work of the Bureau of Municipal Re- search is not described in greater de- tail. Yet its influence is apparent in all the reforms now under way, and its work should soon so commend itself to the body of New York citizens that it will be made an integral part of the city government. Chicago's experience is touched upon and its reform movement tive control. described The title of Mr. Cole’s book accurate- ly describes its contents. It is in no sense a discussion of accounting prin- ciples. It is rather a description of the various forms of accounts with detailed instructions as to their use. To be sure, much can be gathered from it concern- ing the fundamental bases of accounting, but it must be picked up by the way The volume is written by an accountant rather than by an economist or a stu- dent of finance. The distinction between the two kinds of writing becomes clear if one consults, for example, chapter seven on the distinction between capital and revenue. Instead of entering into a discussion of fundamental economic author informs his accounts the various differences the readers to what items there discussed should be carried Again, chapter elght, entitled the Gen eral Principles of Depreciation, is con- cerned almost wholly with methods of handling depreciation. For the student of accounting practice, this book, clear- ly and concisely written, should prove a valuable guide. Part one covers In an elementary way the principles of bookkeeping, In which the fundamental books and statements The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2313 are described. Part two, called the Prin-| ciples of Accounting, treats of Capital and Revenue, Depreciation, and the Bal- ance Sheet. Then follow chapters which | apply the principles to various forms of business activity, such as railways, banks, trust companies, insurance com- panies, factories, and municipalities. The book closes with a brief chapter on Auditing, and with appendices contain- ing information concerning forms and statements. It is difficult to understand why some of the chapters have been included in a book of this kind. For example, chap- ter fifteen, called Accounting in Reor- | ganizations, is corporation finance, pure and simple; chapter twelve on Principal and Interest in Valuations is a discus- sion of the theory of annuities; chapter. eighteen on Accounting for Insurance and for Life «‘enures is a discussion of the fundamental principles upon which life insurance is based. No doubt, this !s all valuable information to the young accountant, but if all these lines of in- vestigation are legitimately within the field of accounting, one must revise one’s conception of this growing “science.” The best chapter is that on Factory Ac- counting, which makes a thorough study | of the subject of costs. the rest of this volume is a puzzle wor- | thy the attention of Baconian cipher ex- perts. It seems to us the best thing yet written on that most serious of Vic- torian poets and most dandified of re- cent critics. Dr. Warren has stated Ar- nold’s paradox fully and frankly and has unravelled it with a clarity, light- ness, and sympathy more suggestive of the Rue des Ecoles than of “The High.” One realizes as never before the highly unstable equilibrium of Arnold—some- thing quite different from the frivolity of which he was commonly accused. Too much the man of the world to be wholly the poet, he was also too much the mor- alist to become completely the critic, and perhaps too much the publicist in petto to enter far upon either pathway of the muses. Everybody knows that overmuch school inspecting and the res angustule hemmed him in at every point. But Dr. Warren rightly con- cludes that Arnold’s limitations were rather of temperament than of condi- tions. He gives the impression of a protean talent that never quite found itself. But it is much to say of any man—and particularly of a vacillator— that in the triple capacity of poet, critic, and pedagogue-theorist, he will not wholly die. Towards Arnold's none too /auspicious excursions into theology, Dr. Essays of Poets and Poetry, Ancient and Modern. By T. Herbert Warren. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $3 net. The nine essays composing this book are highly typical of modern academic | criticism in England, in their leisurely movement, sound learning, and modera- | tion, as well as in their inequality and | occasional slackness of grasp. Vice- Chancellor of Oxford, President of Mag- dalen, author in prose and verse, Dr. Warren presents in collected form the occasional criticism—review articles, public addresses, and the like—of nearly fifteen years. All the better qual- ities of the genre he represents appear in the initial essay on Sophocles. The supremacy of the author is illuminated by parallels from many times and tongues. Particularly satisfying is the analogy with Goethe. In conclusioa Dr. Warren stakes the case of Greek on Sophocles—a daring but a warrantable challenge to modernizing humarists. The historians, the philosophers, the other dramatists, even Homer, we may have in a fashion at second hand, or in measurable equivalents, but if “the world were ever to give up Greek as a part of the general culture of its most cultivated minds, the greatest treasure it would lose is Sophocles.” To this, most Grecians will say amen. All that | Dr. Warren writes about the Aristo- | tellan distinction between “frenzied” | and disciplined genius is excellent and | for our times most salutary. How the author of the brilliant essay on Matthew Arnold could have written | Warren seems to us something short of fair and generous. As mere infivence, '“God and the Bible” and “Religion and Dogma” probably rank with any similar English books of the half-century. The | gist of the latter book is also that of the Modernist movement. In fine, most of the present-day pragmatical religious po- sitions were cheerfully occupied by Arnold a score of years before the term had been invented. All this will doubt- less pass, but meanwhile the pioneer de- serves his credit. Six of the seven remaining essays— The Art of Translation, Dante and the |Art of Poetry, Virgil and Tennyson, Gray and Dante, Tennyson and Dante, An- cient and Modern Classics—leave a little the impression that the author has said learnedly and gracefully just what might have been expected. In that on Dante and Tennyson, he emphatically over- drives the free horse of personal paral- lelism. The concluding study, In Me- moriam After Fifty Years, is an elab- orate defence and exposition along the orthodox lines of Tennysonian commen- tary. It reaffirms Genung, Van Dyke, and the rest. No critic, we feel, has per- ceived the real critical dilemma involv- ‘ed. We are told that no one can appre ciate the poem, unless he has lived it, while obviously no one who has lived it is quite in a position to pass upon it as sheer poetry. No other very great poem refuses the approach from without. In the case of “In Memoriam,” now nearly |sixty years away from us, the opportu- nity for circumspection seems suspic- lously postponed. Possibly, it would bear 4° ay Lo eee mC gy SBS e eat aoe acl ar Meas eae
Page 19
+ + {4 7 t Bete didtae-. 0s Oct. 28, 1909] The Nation. objective treatment rather ill. In the long run, it may appear that the much berated reviewer who suspected “the widow of a military man” to be the au- thor was less a fool than a knave. At any rate, the “In Memoriam” question is far from closed. We have considered too briefly these learned and well matured essays. A seas- oned reader will find pleasurable mat- ter and suggestive judgments in all; a grudging Epicurean would perhaps hard- ly venture beyond the second essay. Academic critics and reviewers in Ame2r ica may well yearn fcr an air in which such casual flowers of scholarship may bloom in so dignified a seemliness. The Human Way. By Louise Collier Will- cox. New York: Harper & Bros. $1.25 net. “If all the peace and power and joy you can ever win, must be won now, and all fruit of victory gathered here or never’—then, what? To those for whom the ancient religious way of reconcilia- tion with life is no longer available this book commends the quest, in the Ruskin- ian sense, of the crown of wild olive. It is written apparently by one who has effected some measure of harmony between the desires with which we are born and the knowledge which is thrust upon us; by one who is conscious of the results of modern thought and is not dismayed by them. Mrs. Willcox has what was formerly common enough among women—the religious tempera- ment. She is sensitive to the influence of storied windows richly dight, to the splendor of Latin chants, to the inti- mate appeal of St. Francis and of Plotinus. But, what is distinctly less common, she also reveals genuine sym- pathy with the stoical utterances of Marcus Aurelius and Epictetus and with the hard sayings of Eastern moralists. Something of mystical fervor meeting with intellectual candor in a mind dis- posed to reflection lends to her style at its best a certain masculine energy and distinction. From her chapter on life out-of-doors, inspired, perhaps, equally by nature and Thoreau, this for an ex- ample of the poetically vigorous: ‘The wind is a fine companion for the strid- ing heart.” For an example of the plain austere, this from a passage on sym- bols: “An inspiration toward righteous- ness must be very vague indeed that does not result in a duty performed, an obligation accepted, or some kind of com- memoration.” The “human way” of reconciliation involves a fusion of pragmatism with a refined type of modern epicureanism and cosmic enthusiasm. It disposes of pain and evil by conceiving of creation as the “struggles of spiritual beings to come to higher and fuller conscious- ness.” It insists that “progress is one movement of all humanity, not the sep- arate jaunt of a sect or a party,” and it finds, therefore, an uplifting solemnity “in the least task of so great a work as the unification of human endeavor.” !t rehabilitates the will, affirming the cre- ative power of steadfast desire: The world-will is indeed without us, but it is also within. The universe pushes against us, and in the end, will surely over- throw our bodies and we shall lay them down to make some spot of earth greener and more fertile, but so long as the life- breath is in us, the world-will is within as well as without. So long as we breathe we can react against the push of the universe So far as Mrs. Willcox deals with funda- mental philosophical ideas, she shows clearly the influence of Professor James's thought and even of his style. But her book is primarily an essay on the fine art of living, and in her plea for the decoration of the spirit, she looks to Pater as her master: If we will have life repay us, even to the last, when age and decay encroach, then il faut cultiver son jardin—we must be unre- mitting gardeners of life, we must hoard beauties, we must keep records of them as they flit, we must be ever alert to catch the essence of the rare and worthy moment and to prolong its life in memory and in written annals or imitative images. These lines are little more than a re- statement of a well known passage in Pater, and Mrs. Willcox is rather fre- quent in such reminiscences. This, in- deed, gives interest to her work, that it reflects so many different aspects of con- temporary thought and feeling. Yet in its total impression, her book seems not secondary and parasitical, but fresh and independent. She has assimilated, com- posed, and harmonized the elements of culture. She has written with an air of meditation and a note of conviction which awaken the perceptions of the reader to the finer qualities of his ex- perience. The City of Jerusalem. By Col. C. R Conder, LL.D., MR.A.S., R.E. New York. E. P. Dutton & Co. $4 net Col. Conder has written this work with the object, as he tells us in the preface, of presenting in a convenient form the results of research and explora tion, “which have accumulated during the last half century, but which are scattered in many expensive works, not easily accessible for the general reader.” He has cast his material into the form of a history of “forty centuries,” based chiefly on “monumental information,” and “carried down to the present year.” His opportunities for acquaintance with Jerusalem and its antiquities have been unusual. Connected with the Palestine oxploration Fund’s surveys from 1872 to 1882, he spent in all three winters in Jerusalem itself, where he had the op- portunity of seeing Warren's and Maudeslay’s explorations, and, owing to 409 the deconsecration at that period of the Dome of the Rock, for the purpose of repairs, of examining for himself por- tions of the temple area which the or- dinary explorer must take on the word of others. The changes which have taken place in Jerusalem since that time are extra- ordinary. Valleys have been filled up, new areas have been built upon and ancient remains obliterated, so that the best trained scholar of to-day must take at hearsay much of what the man of forty years ago could see with his own eyes. Of course, even then the topogra- phy of the ancient city had been se riously obscured, as the excavations of Warren and others have shown, the sur- face of the Herodian period lying at places forty or even ninety feet below the present surface, while the rock east of the Haram area was 125 feet below the present level of the ground: but the changes in the last thirty years have been greater than those in the 300 years preceding. Conder points out that, with the ex- ception of the Herodian fortress by the Joppa gate, the temple site, the iower of Antonia, the Tyropoeon valley, and the Pool of Siloam, there is no absolute agreement on ancient sites in Jerusalem. He himself holds, with tne older school, against the present dominant view, that the southwestern city, modern Zion, was the original city of David, and that the orthodox Calvary, the site of the Church of the Holy Sepulchre, was Akra. He believes that the sakhra, the holy stone enclosed within the present Dome of the Rock, was not the site of the altar before the Holy Place, but the “founda- tion stone” of the temple, on which the western wall of the Holy of Hollies rest- ed. In front of this, eastward, the rock originally descended in steps, so that, viewed from that side, the original ef- fect must have been much like that of a Babylonian stage-tower or ziggurat, the Holy of Holies occupying the place of the small shrine on the sum- mit of the latter The tom» of David was probably the ancient tomb discovered in the orthodox Golectha, while the rea] Golgotha was the knoll near the Damascus gate, to the north of Jerusalem. The tomb of Joseph of Art- mathea, in which the body of Jesus was laid, was not, however, the so-calle.j Gor- don’s tomb, which is preserved and shown as such to-day by certain plous but uninformed iconoclasts, this tomb being in reality of a much later date. The book is interestingly written. The author’s views are not put forth in a dogmatic manner, and, while much that he has to say, especially with regard to ancient sites and ancient history, will not be accepted by the modern scholar, the work is full of valuable suggestions, from the author’s own observations, and of much interesting and useful informa- tion, albeit the reader should at times
Page 20
410 check the facts recorded by reference to other authorities. The least valuable part is that which deals with the pre- Herodian history and antiquities. The most interesting and vivid chapter is that which deals w'th the Jerusalem of the Herodian period; but probably the most valuable portion is the full ac- count of mediawval sites, both Moslem and Christian, because it is precisely this material which it is difficult to find except by exploration of many and of- ten inaccessible volumes and _ treat- ises. The perusal of his remarks on forged coins, contained on page _ 197, which are also true of Palestinian an- tiquities in general, might be useful to the tourist, if he could be induced to read them before visiting Jerusalem, and so be persuaded to desist from the purchase of “antiques.” On the whole, the book is a welcome addition to Jeru- salem literature by one of a generation which saw things before they were de- stroyed. Lives of the Hanoverian Queens of Eng- land. By Alice Drayton Greenwood. Vol. I: Sophia Dorothea of Celle and Caroline of Ansbach. New York: The Macmillan Co. $3.50 net. The second volume of these lives is reserved, presumably, for the dull and precise Charlotte of George III and for the foolish and badgered Caroline of the First Gentleman of Europe. And we may say now that, if the sequel is as well studied and written as the part be- fore us, the whole will make a valua- ble work. Miss Greenwood's purpose is evidently to take a middle ground be- tween the formal political histories, which tend yearly to become more doc- umentally dull, and the popular me- moirs, which tend equally to flimsiness and bad English. In both sections of the volume—whether her figures move in the courts of Hanover and Celle or in that of England—the political situa- tion is kept well in view, although, nat- urally, persons rather than institutions are mainly considered. In this respect Miss Greenwood tis particularly success- ful in unravelling the tangled relations of the electorate. She is more interest- ing here by far than when she vomes down to the tragic story of Sophia Doro- thea and the brutal Count Kénigsmarck, which is her real theme. It is a curious commentary on the essential dulness of all that surrounds the Hanoverians that not even the mystery and pathos of Sophia's love can make that tale any- thing but vulgar. If Miss Greenwood drawe out the sentiment of the adven- ture to wearisome length, she at least uses notable discretion in separating the facts from the volumes of fiction that soon overlaid it. The riddle of Kénigsmarck’s disappearance she does not pretend to solve, although she ac- cepts the strong evidence of foul play. The Nation. She evidently tries to believe that Sophia was innocent of real guilt, be- ing led to this partly by natural sym- pathy and partly by her utter detesta- tion of George I and her desire to pre- sent him always in the worst light pos- sible. This animus against George I, which the present reviewer shares quite heart- ily, forms in a way the dramatic mo- tive of the book. His meanness, vindic- tiveness, and lack of kingly qualities (“he knows nothing of what is prince- ly,” wrote his caustic aunt, the Duchess of Orleans) throw an atmos- phere of pity about Sophia Dorothea; they bequeathed “to his descendants, for four generations, the gloomy tradi- tion of family hatred"; they are, if truth be said, the most human quality in the royal annals. To show them as dark and detestable as possible, the onus of the quarrel between George I and his heir is laid entirely on the father’s shoulders. George II is made almost an attractive figure, and as a furvher consequence the nasty feud between George II and Frederick must be charg- ed entirely to the frivolous imperti- nences of the latter. This is not pre- cisely the historic temper, but it lends interest to Miss Greenwood’s pages, while not leading her to make any real distortions of fact. ridicule of George the Second’s private life as something closer to truth than mere fictitious satire; but if we would make George II more coarse and foolish | than he appears to Miss Greenwocd, it does not follow that his father was any better than she makes him. It is rather the fashion for the histor- ian of institutions to write of the first Georges as, on the whole, wise admin- | istrators. Such a view can be support- ed, but it does not affect their character | as the heads of society or their inflnence on the intellectual life of the day. Caro- line was a woman of liberal interests and gathered into her court a number of men, like Bishop Clarke, who dis- cussed the religious and philosophical problems of the day. Miss Greenwood does bravely in her attempt to throw some literary value into the Queen’s in-| fluence; but the result is small. As a matter of fact, one by one the really great minds of the age—in things of the imagination, that is, not of statecraft— drew away from the Georgian circle. A perusal of the correspondence of Lady Suffolk, Lady Sundon, and others of that set shows only too plainly that. something more than political Toryism or rancor for favors unreceived, that, | in a word, the inherent dulness and vul- garity of the court were responsible for this aversion. It would not be difcult to maintain the thesis that England's gradual lapse through the eighteenth century from her International leader- ship in ideas to a state of unideaed [Vol. 89, No. 2313 We ourselves are, inclined to accept Hervey’s scathing somnolence was in considerable meas- ure due to the Hanoverian court. Miss Greenwood, dealing with the Queens rather than the Kings of St. James’s, is naturally thrown upon this social aspect of the court. On the whole, she does admirably with a not very en- tertaining material, although she might have made more of its literary associa- tions, such as they are. We shall await with interest the story of Charlotte and the second Caroline. Notes. John Muir's “Our National Parks’ is to be issued by the Houghton Mifflin Co. in a “New Holiday Edition,” fully illustrated from photographs by Herbert W. Gleason. Pierre de Coulevain’s “Sur la Branche,” translated by Alys Hallard as “On the Branch,”’ is promised for immediate publi- cation by E. P, Dutton & Co. In “The New North,” which the D. Apple- ton Co. promises for autumn publication, Agnes Deans Cameron writes of her explo- rations, in the summer of 1908, down the Mackenzie River in Canada to the Arctic Ocean. Miss Cameron gives here an ac- count of the Eskimo and other Northern tribes, which should, at this time, have a peculiar interest. There are to be over a hundred illustrations, chiefly after her own photographs. Dr. Robert M. Wernaer declares himself —in his “Romanticism and the Romantic School in Germany,” now in press—en- thusiastically in favor of that coming |art which he denominates “humanistic,” and in which he sees a reconciliation of | the love of liberty in romanticism with the |restraining influence in classicism. The | German romantic movement as a tendency jhas not been very thoroughly examined by | English or American writers: the study of it, which, forming the basis of this new lite- rary essay, will be looked to, on its publi- cation, with a good deal of curiosity. The writer treads here the mazes of Romanti- cism and Symbolism, Impressionism and Appreciation, Romantic Irony, The Golden Age and the Blue Flower, and Neo-Roman- ticism (D. Appleton & Co.). We have referred to the inclusion in the Constable edition of Meredith in twenty-six |volumes of the unfinished novel “Celt and Saxon.” In his conversation no less than in his fiction and verse, George Meredith expressed pride in his Celtic heritage; “I have not a single drop of English blood in my veins,” he once said to Mr. Shorter. The last named writer, who stands sponsor for this bit of anecdote, states also that “Translations from Homer: Experi- ments in English Hexameters,” will be one of the unfamiliar elements of the new il- lustrated edition promised by Constable. The Americara publishers of this Memo- rial edition, Charles Scribner's Sons, an- | nounce further that inclusion will also be |made of an unpublished comedy. “The | Sentimentalist,” other fragments, and sev- | eral critical reviews. There will, too, be | collected all the poetry published by the | author over his own name, or with regard | to the publication of which he gave in- | structions. One volume, furthermore, will re ee ani sei
Page 21
x ” ) Cate eee ees a Si Neriihe ; 3 ; 4 / : : 3 Oct. 28, 1909] x The Nation. contain notes of various changes and re-_ writings, together with the bibliography to which we have made an earlier refer- ence. The new edition will be printed from new type on fine paper, and will be sold by subscription. The illustrations will comprise reproductions of many ef the original illustrations which accompanied the novels and poems when published ia magazine form, the artists being Millais, Du Maurier, Sandys, Charles Keene, and H. K. Browne. A number of portraits will be added, and pictures of scenes asso- ciated by the author with many of his novelg and poems. There will also be nu- merous reproductions of MSS. The first volume of this notable edition will proba- bly be issued in November. The Letters cf the novelist, which are to be edited by Lord Morley, will not be ready for publication for a year or more. Dr. Fabian Franklin, who is writing the authoritative life of the late President Gilman, would be obliged for the privilege of reading any letters from him which are likely to be of service. Such documents may be sent to Dr. Franklin, in care of the Nation, and will be promptly returned. Among the recent noteworthy additions to the Boston Public Library are some 900 volumes belonging to the late Louise Chand- ler Moulton. A _ special catalogue of the gift is to be found in the quarterly bulletin just issued, in which it is said that the library is now helpfully and significantly strengthened in the field of English and American poetry and belles letters. Many of the volumes are gift copies containing autographs, and frequently more extended writing of a personal nature. Some of them are copies of limited or numbered editions especially issued for the author’s use. The Macmillan Company has a new edi- tion of Edward Caird’s “‘Essays on Litera- ture,” which were first collected in a vol- ume in 1892. The thoughtful and ripe style of the late master of Balliol needs no characterization at this day. While still good reading, it is true that most of the essays, as one comes to them in their new issue, seem somehow not quite vital enough to endure. If there are exceptions to this judgment, it would be the discussion of The Problem of Philosophy at the Present Time, which contains an excellent compar:son of the reconciliation effected between religion and sophistry by Plato and Aristotle, with the reconciliation between religion and science needed in 1881, when Caird’s lecture Was given, and still needed. Even better is the essay on Wordsworth, with its ad- mirable comparison of Rousseau and his disciple. In his “Inns and Taverns of Old London” (L. C. Page & Co.), Henry C. Shelley, as we need go no further than the sub-title to discover, takes in also the chief coffee- houses, clubs, and pleasure gardens of the metropolis, Indeed, he includes rather too much, for his pages would be more enter- taining if he allowed himself space for writing more fully about the houses that are richest in traditions. In a good part of the book he traverses the same ground as Timbs, in his well-known “Club Life of London,” and the later work, by its too great jauntiness and rapidity, suffers from the comparison. But Mr. Shelley has a good subject, and his writing certainly can- not be condemned for heaviness. From | Starts, to Finch's Chaucer's old Tabard Inn, with which he Grotto Gardens. with which he closes, he keeps the reader a!- most in a state of bewilderment with the names of the great and the witty of Eng- land, and with anecdotes of their social life. Though his style is light, there is evidence that he has turned over many books to get his materia) together From Sturgis & Walton comes a new edition of Boswell's “Life of Samuel John- son,” edited by Roger Ingpen in commemo- ration of the great Cham's bi-centenary The two volumes are in quarto size, with the lines extending across the full page This, with the weight of the paper, which is heavily sized for the illustrations, makes the books rather fatiguing to hand and eye. On the other hand the type is fair and large, and the printing careful, with fewer errors in the foreign quotations than is common in English books. In fact, there are only one or two misprints in the Latin and Greek which will arrest the reader's eye—supposing that any to-day would be arrested even if a spelling board got control of such quotations. The notes variorum and the editor's own, are judi- cious and sufficient; the index full and ser- viceable. The real feature of the edition is confessedly the illustrations. These Mr. Ingpen has culled from all sources, and made them a veritable visualization of the men and manners of Johnson's day His notes take the form chiefly of brief bio- graphical or topographical comment. be- neath these pictures, and are commonly much to the point. One error, or omission we have observed, where the editor says (I, 325) that Bishop Lowth “defended Ox- ford agains the attacks of Gibbon and Priestley,” forgetting the famous quarre!} with Warburton. The present reviewer is not much enamored of picture books, but reader must confess that this gallery of faces and scenes, many of them new to him, tempted him to a re- reading of the familiar story, and made him prefer these heavy volumes to his old favorite edition. Johnson and his friends never before seemed to him quite so living, nor that old London quite so real And he may add, though it is scarcely per- tinent to this notice, that as he finished the long record he was more than ever con vinced of the greatness and, ben*ath the bear's rough coat, the tender-heartedness of the Ursa Major. It seemed to him that, if the moral of Johnson's long musing, and talking, on the meaning of man's life were to be summed up in a few words it would be in the couplet which opens the Prologue so strangely prepared by the moralist for the comedy of ‘The Good Na- tured Man”: Prest by the load of life, the weary mind Surveys the gen'ral toil of human kind Most readers of Dr. Washington Glad- den’s review of a long and variously ac- tive career (“Recollections”; Houghton, Mifflin Co.) will agree that the best wine is put before them early. The chapters de- scribing the nature of the struggle for live- lihood and for education, in a family of artisans and farmers seventy years ago, are more interesting than the later ones. This is not alone because the experience was rarer, but also because it is written out with more vividness. Dr. Gladden's memory of those rude years is not only re- 411 tentive, but intense and visualizing. The price which poverty had to pay for bread and books is set down with detail that sticks in the mind. For the rest, the ‘Rec- ollections” are discursive, part autobiog- raphy and part contemporary history, and stamped with that bread churchmanship and geniality, combined with the capacity to stand up stoutly for a firm conviction, which we have been accustomed to asso- ciate with the author. Swinburne’s life-long idolatry of his Stratford god culminates in a prose rhap- sody of some eighty pages, entitled “Shakespeare,” written in 1905, but now first published (Henry Frowde). At its best and at its worst Swinburne’s critical work was always almost as lyrical in mood as his poetry He always expressed a lofty scorn for students of the drama who went to their task with no other equipment than ability to count and patience and eru- dition. But thirty-five years ago, when he contributed articles to the Fortnightly Re- view—articles later incorporated in his “A Study of Shakespeare,”’ 1880—he was him- self an industrious student His earlier utterances upon Shakespeare, as upon the other Elizabethans, though often tumid and ecstatic, were yet sprinkled with passages revealing a fine appreciation, discrimina- tion, and insight. In his later essays, how- ever, he occupied himself more and mere exclusively with the expression of his own violent emotion in the presence of master- pieces. His last tribute to Shakespeare is, as nearly as possible, praise with the sub- stance of praise strained away. He be- gins on a high note of rapture, Only the “supreme and crowning fools among the foolishest of mankind,’’ he asserts, would deride the declaration that it were better to lose all other treasures of human genius and keep this one than to lose this one and keep all others. He does not attempt serious argument of the thesis; he simply passes in review all the plays, and af- firms, in twinned epithets charging pair after pair like sea-horses up the foamy crest of his billowing sentences, that each drama of Shakespeare's, with one or two exceptions, is the most divinely and in- comparably excellent thing of its kind in the world. He makes, to be gure, some dis- tinctions among the children of the mas- ter’s mind, but reverently, as a mortal distinguishes the differing glories of the seraphim. Now that Swinburne walks with Shakespeare among the fields of asphodel it is to be hoped that he regrets the in- tolerable turgidity of style in this effusion. The substance he will scarcely regret; for it is not a criticism—it is a Pindaric ode, a pean, a gloria in excelsis J. Keir Hardie, the author of “India: Impressions and Suggestions’ (New York: B. W. Huebsch), is an avowed socialist, and one of the leaders of the Labor party in the House of Commons. The subject mat- ter of his book originally appeared in 1907 in the form of letters in the London La- bor Leader, a Socialist weekly. Were one but to remove the writer's name from the title page, and an occasional reference to English scenes from the body of his book, it would be easy to imagine these “Impressions and Suggestions’ to have been written by a native Hindu agitator. As for what Mr. Hardie learned in two months’ time about the $150,000,000 India annually
Page 22
412 pays as its tribute to England, about “probably not less than 76 per cent. of the harvest [that] goes in taxes,”’ about the 70,000,000 Indians who eat “but one square meal a day,” about the government spend- ing 1%d. and one shilling per head, respec- tively, on education and militarism, about “the partition of Bengal [being] a huge blunder,” about 5,000,000 Hindus suc- cumbing in the last ten years to plague, which, “in the main, is due to hunger,’ and many other conditions of a similar nature—he could just as easily have gleaned all these statistics from the cas- ual speeches daily delivered by Indian nationalists, without taking the trouble to go to India. Even in Mr. Hardie’s sugges- tions for quieting the Indian “unrest,” there is nothing beyond a rehash of the stock remedies advanced by Indian writers. But we have a more serious fault to find with this book. Mr. Hardie “went to In- dia to see the people.” His book gives the impression to the reader that all Indians are dissatisfied—which is not exactly true. His object in sojourning in India being ‘“‘to learn of their [the East Indians’) griev- ances,” he did not see much of the great work that Indians are manfully doing all over the land to give woman a new status In society, to implant the germ of mod- ern habits in agriculture and industry, to vitalize the people by reformed edu- eation. to refashion the national structure on a less conservative and more approved model, and in a hundred ways to hasten the evolution of the country and the na- tives. The greatest lack of his book is that it is practically silent concerning these features of the India of to-day, which, in the last analysis, mean infinitely more to Hindustan than do verbal and pic- ric acid bombe The “Proceedings” of the third annual meeting of the American Society of Inter- national Law, held last April, should com- mand attention for the efficient loyalty of the Society to its declared objects, the fos- tering of the study of international law and the promoting of international rela- tions on the basis of law and justice. The opening address by President Elihu Root has been alluded to in a notice of the July number of the society's quarterly Journal. The reasoning of the other papers is no less forcible. John W. Foster reviews the principal arbitrations by which the United States and Great Britain have sought to settle their differences, concluding that as a rule thelr determinations have not been judictal, or wholly satisfactory. The fault has lain in the method of selecting the tribunal. Mr. Foster cites the late James C Carter in confirmation of the principle that a party should no more be a judge in his own case in an international matter thas In a private litigation; drawing a lessou from the conduct of Lord Chief Justice Cockburn of England tn the Geneva arb tration over the Alabama Claims, where this arbitrator assumed the role of ad vocate as well as judge, and as soon as the decision (from which he dissented) was read, seized his hat, and abrup* ly withdrew. Furthermore, the more rece. arbitration over the Venezuelan boun- dary has, in result, given but scant satis- faction Delegate Anderson of Costa Rica argues, further, that international differ- ences should be settled by tribunals com- posed not of publicists, but of jurists; and The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2313 Wayne MacVeagh pronounces in favor of the submission of international differences to a judicial tribunal in permanent session at The Hague. The two addresses on the constitution and powers which an inter- national Court of Arbitral Justice should possess, one by United States Senator Burton of Ohio, the other by A. J. Montague, former Governor of Virginia, incidentally touch on the same subject. Of the other matters discussed in the “Pro- ceedings,” we find space for passing notice of one only: that of extradition. Of the three papers on this general topic, the second, by F. R. Coudert of New Yurk, dis- cusses elaborately the question of what so-called political offences are; such of- fences, in fine, as justify our ministers abroad in affording asylum He charges that the government, one of whose officials, J. Reuben Clark, jr., had read a paper, had followed no consistent policy. No one who reads Mr. Clark’s paper can, however, fail to conclude that he sought to assume a judicial attitude, and succeeded. The paper read by Julian W. Mack of Chicago on this subject comes nearer to supporting the view of Mr. Clark than that of Mr. Coudert. Mr. Mack quotes with high approval from our treaty with Brazil: “Extradition shall not be granted if the offence for which the surrender is demanded be of a political character or if the fugitive prove that there is an intention to try or punish him for a political crime.” He contends that it is but fair, in considering the rights of revo- lutionists, to consider the measures taken by the demanding government, in punishing revolutionists; that if it be known that the demanding government inflicts punishments that are inhuman, that fact should debar the granting of extradition of its fugitives. He alludes to the fact that in the Rudovitz case our government had official documents, even admissions in the reports of the Duma itself, of the commission by officials of the most outrageous crimes; the inference be- ing that the possession of such evidence controlled in the refusal to grant extra- dition. From R. Bemporad, Florence, we receive “Almanacco Italiano: 1909." Besides the usual chronological, meteorological, and of- ficial features, this handbook contains, for the jubilee. an account of the Italian cam- paign of 1859. There is an abundance of compact encyclopedic information, under such heads as aeronautics, agriculture, do- mestic economy, women’s industries, nec- rology, ete. Naturally, these chapters are calculated for Italian readers, but the book, with its many illustrations and diversity of well-indexed data, will not come amiss to any one concerned with current affairs on; the Continent of Europe Dr. Paul Carus has selected a number of the rhymes of the German mystic Silesius, rendered them into English in the original metre, and printed both German and English on the same page. The vol- ume is an addition to the large library of mysticism, whose constant growth is one of the signs of the times (“Angelus Sile- sius.” By Paul Carus; Chicago: The Open Court Publishing Company). In its deaconesses the Methodist Church has long had one of the most valuable forms of Christian service for social bet- terment, and at a conference held at St. Louls last autumn thelr work and other forms of philanthropic effort conducted un- der Methodist auspices were discussed. The papers are published under the title “The Socialized Church’; they are edited by the Rev. Worth M. Tippy, D.D., (Eaton & Mains). In the third volume of “The Historical Bible,” on “The Kings and Prophets of Israel] and Judah” (Charles Scribner’s Sons), Prof. Charles Foster Kent has performed the task necessary to careful study of the Old Testament, but difficult and involved for all but specialists, of weaving together in chronological order the narratives of the historical books and the sections of the prophetical writings which deal with the same period. Only the important passages have been included; and by means of brief introductory notes, which portray the his- torical situation, the reader is enabled to follow readily the sequence of events and discern the significance of the narratives. German prose has very little that corres sponds with the French causerie, yet Georg Hermann has no need of apology in offering the volume entitled “Sehnsucht: Ernste Plaudereien” (Berlin: Egon Fleischel & Co.) to the readers whose sympathies he has won by his novels. The book seems to have been written with no other purpose but that of fixing in the author’s mind and convey- ing to his readers impressions received and conclusions arrived at in odd moments. There is here a genuine sentiment quite rare in the writings of modern Germany, s0 heavily laden with the supercilious cynicism of a generation drifting towards decadence. In one of his lighter papers, Hermann pleads for childhood; it is not half so es- sential for the child to become a man as for the man to remain at heart a child. Hermann has no sympathy with monarchy, army, clergy, bureaucracy. He is not even a patriot in the accepted sense of the word, and ventures the assertion: ‘Napoleon was a bearer of free thoughts, and the Rhine provinces looked upon him not as destroy- er, but as deliverer. Leipzig and Waterloo are victories of reaction over progress. Had Napoleon been victorious, they might have been the last battles of history.” He pro- tests even against the exaggerated wor- ship of fatherland and mother-tongue. Among other heresies is his doubt of the vitality of serious drama. He sees in the theatre a place of amusement which should never attempt to be anything but play, and in reality does not want to be taken se- riously. “Grosse Manner” is a collection of es- says and lectures by Wilhelm Ostwald, published by the Akademische Verlags- gesellschaft, Leipzig, and worthy of care- ful digestion. The giants of the centuries are, of course, themes for the philoso- pher’s attention, but there is a conscien- tious, if not always sympathetic, consider- ation of “the great” in very recent times, and some interesting references to con- temporaries and associates of the writer himself, including Zeppelin. Dr. Eliot and Benjamin Thompson are, perhaps, the only Americans mentioned, but Ostwald in- cludes them both among the men who have rolled the world along apace. Thomp- son (Count Rumford) he credits with hav- ing given an early impetus to scientific research everywhere, while in Dr. Eliot’s refusal, some years ago, to accept the football autocrats as the proper persons to iden: dessins: ealitdinl 5 Peek aie
Page 23
& § «sum thd gmt tl AREA Sy Oct. 28, 1909] bring about reform in American football, he finds a somewhat surprising argument in favor of looking to a new set of men to bring about German school reform. The volume concludes with effective summaries on the woman question, the German pro- fessor taking kindly to the idea of woman's advancement—“when properly kept with- sp the ropes.” He admits her power to do wuch that man alone has generally done, but doubts if she can attain to the highest in science. Few autobiographies contain such a va- riety of strange adventures and singular reminiscences as ‘“‘Helene von Racowitza: Von Anderen und Mir, Erinnerungen aller Art” (Berlin: Poetel). The maiden name of the autobiographer was Helene von Dén- niger, and she was born in 1845 in Munich, where her father held the post of tutor of the Crown Prince (the future Maximilian Il). Her first husband, von Racowitza, she married when she was under twenty years of age. He died soon afterwards in a state of mental depression at having killed in a duel Ferdinand Lassalle—a rival for the hand of Helene, (See “Ferdinand Lassalle and Helene von Dénniger: A Modern Trag- edy,’’ by Elizabeth E. Evans; London, 1897). After her first husband's death, she married | an actor, Siegwart Friedmann, from whom she was divorced. Some time afterward she became the wife of Baron Serge von Sche- witsch, with whom she is now living at Munich. In the course of her most recent matrimonial engagement, the writer of this autobiography has toured the United States with her husband and a theatrical troupe organized by him. She has also assisted him in his journalistic and literary ven- versatile adventuress bring the reader into contact with her most celebrated contempo- raries in literature, music (Liszt), the fine arts (Lenbach and Makart), as well as in politics a* 1 social life. Prof. Edward Heyck has published as volume 29 in the series of which he is the editor, and which is known as Monographien der Weltgeschichte, a popular account of Luther, based on the latest researches, bearing the simple title “Luther.” The au- thor is a master of precise and condensed style. The illustrations, 114 in number, are mostly excellent reproductions of contem- poraneous pictures. / The death of Henry Charles Lea removes one of the most widely known of American scholars. He was the third of a dis- tinguished family to gain a literary reputation. His maternal grandfather was Matthew Carey, the publisher, who in the last years of the eighteenth century and in the early part of the last had some repu- tation as a writer, and his father, Isaac Lea, also a publisher, was noted as a naturalist. Henry Charles Lea was born in Philadelphia on September 19, 1825. He never attended school or college, but received, long before the end, the honorary degrees of Harvard, Princeton, the University of Pennsylvania, Giessen, and Moscow. From 1843 until 1880 he was engaged in the publishing business, although in seasons of what he called “‘‘in- tellectual leisure’ he undertook histori- cal research. Before, however, he at- tained his reputation as an historian of mediwval Europe, he wrote several scientific articles and books. Among his earlier pro- ductions were essays on “Superstition and The Nation. Force” (1866) a “Sketch of Sacerdotal Celibacy,” which so recently as 1907 was re- , printed in London, and “Studies in Church History” (1869). In 1888 appeared the “History of the Inquisition in the Middle Ages,” in three volumes, of which a French translation has been made and German and Italian translations planned. Mr. Lea's oth- er works were “Chapters from the Religious History of Spain, Connected with the Span- ish Inquisition,” 1890; “A Formulary of the Papal Penitentiary in the Thirteenth Cen- tury,” 1892; “A History of Auricular Con- fession and Indulgences,"’ three volumes, 1896; “‘The Moriscosof Spain: Their Conver- sion and Expulsion,” 1901; “A History of the Inquisition of Spain,” four volumes, 1906-7; and “The ‘nquisition in the Spanish Dependencies,” 1908. He found time also to engage in labors of social reform, and he was elected president of the Philadel- phia branch of the American Social Science Association. In 1871, he helped to organize the Citizens’ Municipal Reform Association, the aim of which is and has been to bring the public business to the same degree of efficiency and economy as is obtained by a private corporation. He was also president of the Reform Club and was an early advo- cate of civil service reform. In 1889 he made a liberal contribution to the Philadel- phia library, and in 1892 he aided largely in founding a department of hygiene in the University of Pennsylvania by erecting for it a laboratory. Brevet-Col. Theodore Ayrault Dodge, 'U. S. A., retired, died at Versailles, Octobcr 26, in his sixty-eighth year. He was born at Pittsfield, Mass., and was a graduate o. the University of London and of the law lumbi University. His tures. These memoirs of a fascinating and | °P@ftment of Columbian ity military education he received in Berlin under Major-Gen. Von Frohreich of the Prussian army. He served as a voluntee: throughout the civil war, receiving several wounds, and afterwards served in the Bu- reau of Enrolment in the paymaster’s office, and in the regular army. He was a distin- guished military writer, being the author of a “History of the Art of War,” in twelve volumes; “The Campaign of Chan- cellorsville’; “Bird’s-Eye View of Our Civil War’; ‘“Patroclus and Penelope’; “Great Captains,” and “Riders of Many Lands.” Lieut.-Gen. Oliver Otis Howard, U. 5. A., retired, a distinguished veteran of our civil war, died at his home in Burlington, Vt., October 26, in his seventy-ninth year. He was a graduate of Bowdoin College and of the Military Academy at West Point. After the civil war he served in the Seminole campaign in Florida, and, at West Point, as a professor of mathematics He was largely instrumental in establishing How- ard University at Washington, and has served as its president and trustee. Gen Howard was long a popular lecturer, and was the writer of a books, among them “Life of Agenor de Gasparin,”’ Life of Zachary Taylor,”’ Castile,” “Fighting for Humanity,”’ Wild Indians,” and “Autobiography” (two number of “Isabella of “Our volumes) A former vice-president of the Société des Gens de Lettres, the novelist Charles Diguet has died at Mantes, etat years. He was born at Havre, and began his literary career with the publication of “Rimes de printemps."”” He was the author seventy-three of many books on a variety of subjects; one 413 of those on hunting, “Mémoiresd'un liévre,”’ was crowned (1885) by the French Academy. ——=-—— ~ =~ = ae science. The Foundations 0/ the Origin of Spe- cies. By Charles Darwin. Edited by his son, Francis Darwin. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $2.50. This interesting volume comprises two essays written respectively in 1842 and 1844. The first is the more sig- nificant, and especially suggestive of the wonderful mind of the man; in deed, the second, while much longer, is avowedly only an elaboration of the 1842 sketch. This first essay, covering about fifty pages, while only now giv en to the public, was printed in an dition de luve earlier in the year for presentation to the delegates of unive-- sities and societies who attended the celebration at Cambridge of the cen- tenary of the birth of Charles Darwin An account of the successful programme of this interesting occasion has already been given in the pages of the Nation (July 15). The significance of the oc- casion was enhanced not only by the presence of Darwin's three sons, but by the giving to the world of this unpub lished digest of the principles, embodied seventeen years later in the most fa- mous book of the last century. Th: finding of this was rather dramatic--« small package of manuscript being un- earthed in a cupboard under the stairs at the house at Down long after the death of Darwin. We have had voi- umes tracing the growth of the ideas embodied in evolution, from the days of Anaximander and Aristotle, but in this short essay we first realize the last steps which led to the fully formed pr2 sentation in the “Origin.” The editor has gone carefully over his father’s man- uscript, clearing up abbreviated sen- tences, tracing out almost illegible words, even reproducing phrases which have been crossed out and rewritter From a perusal of this we realize more fully than ever before the great patience and the powerful concentration of thought which this pioneer brought to bear on the thousands of loose facts at his command. One by one they fell into place in the mosaic of his mind, anl gradually formed the complete image which was given to the world. Almost nothing in his biography brings us into such intimate appreciation of Darwin's methods of work as this stray outline or “Foundation,” cast aside and never in- tended for publication. In regard to the elaborated secon] essay, while showing more finish than the hurried and condensed manner of ths 1842 sketch, it yet gives the impression of an uncorrected MS. rather than of A proof-read book. It lacks much of the force and conciseness of the “Origin,”
Page 24
414 but is interesting as showing a “con- necting link” of reasoning between the generalized theories of the first sketch and the splendidly rounded-out material in the “Origin.” In a letter to Mrs. Darwin, the author requests that, in the event of his sud- den death, she will devote £400 to the publication of this second essay, thus showing a reluctance to publish it in its present state except as a final necessity The “Physical Laboratory Handbook,” by George A. Hoadley (American Book Co.), and the “Laboratory Manual,” by Charles F. Adams (American Book Co.), are design- ed respectively to accompany the authors’ well-known preparatory texts There is not much to choose between them, as the subject matter and its treatment are pretty much the same in each. They are fairly good, and will answer the needs of the ordi- nary school It is something of a pity, if physical laboratories are to be maintained in preparatory schools, that the same ex- cellence is not attained in this part of the subject as in chemistry The reason is probably that physics does not lend itself readily to elementary laboratory instruc- tion without considerable expense Ernst Haeckel, as the first work since his retirement from the Jena professorship of zodlogy, publishes a brochure entitled “Das Weltbild von Darwin und Lamarck” (Leipzig: Kréner). The purpose is to con- trast the investigations and aims of the great English and the great French defend- ers of the evolutionary theory. He shows that the exact scientific methods of the author of the “Origin of Species” and the more or less fantastic ideas of the author of the “Philosophie zodligique” have been the main facts in the popularity of the for- mer and the comparative unpopularity of the latter. Haeckel’s brochure is partly a plea for a better recognition of the merits of Lamarck The third edition of L. P. Gratacap’s “Geology of the City of New York” (Holt) ia enlarged, and is, besides, improved in ap- pearance over its predecessors. An intro- ductory chapter on North American geology in general has been inserted before th local descriptions, and much fuller trea:- ment is given the boroughs outside of Man- hattan Island. The reader for general in- formation, the engineer seeking local de tails, and the teacher needing instruction and guidance for excursions with classes, will all find much of Interest and value in the book Since, however, this work is primarily intended for readers not specially skilled in geology, the treatment should have been somewhat simpler and clearer than we find it. There are, too, occasions! lapses into a rather pedantic style, where such words as salic, femic, anamorphic, katamorphic, crenitic, and the Hike wil! only serve to mystify readers not learned in the science. Perhaps, if a fourth edition ig called for, the author may be expected to remove these difficulties and to add an index News comes of the death of Hugh Black- burn, professor of mathematics at Glasgow University, 1849-1879. He was, with Lord Kelvin, an editor of Newton's “Principia,” and was the author of a treatise on trigo- nometry. [Vol. 89, No. 2313 The Nation. Drama. The production of Stephen Phillips's tragedy, “Herod,” in the Lyric Theatre on Tuesday evening—whether it prove a finan- cial success or not—may safely be set down among the most important and interesting dramatic events of the current season. Al) intelligent playgoers owe a. debt of grati- tude to Mr. William Faversham, whose praiseworthy ambition has given them an opportunity of witnessing a work of such flue literary and dramatic quality. To say that the representation was in every re- spect ideal would be a grave exaggeration, but it was generally adequate, often excel- lent, and in places exceedingly impressive. No prolonged description of the piece itself is necessary at this time. All students of the modern stage have been familiar with it, in printed form, since it first excited the admiration of the English critics some years ago. It is genuine tragedy of a very high order, dealing with certain incidents in the reign of the great Herod—connected with the killing of his wife, Mariamne, and her brother, the high priest, Aristobulus— in a vein of rare and passionate poetic imagination, but with sufficient regard for the known facts of history. The central figure of Herod, tempestuous in love, crafty and bold in council, swift and remorseless in suspicion, and imperial in the madness | of despair, is depicted with vivid power. Mr. Faversham is incapable as yet of inter- preting the king in the full measure of his heroic proportions, but his impersonation was intelligent, consistent, and picturesque, and marks an upward step in his profes- sional career. It was deficient chiefly in elocutionary skill and in dignified gesture. The Mariamne of Miss Julia Opp was a dis- tinctly capable performance, as was the Sohemus of Burton Churchill and the Sa- lome of Olive Oliver. Mr. Cooper Cliffe did not grasp the possibilities of the part of Gadias. The blank verse, as was to be expected, proved a stumbling block to most of the performers, but if the rhythm and emphasis suffered, the meaning, as a rule, was preserved. The piece was lavishly and tastefully mounted, and several of the stage pictures were uncommonly beautiful. A more striking tableau than that of the stricken Herod standing rigid beside the bier of the dead Mariamne is not often seen upon the stage. The house was crowd- ed, and the applause frequent and hearty. The production of an English version of Henri Bernstein's play “Israel” in the Cri- terion Theatre, on Monday evening brought disappointment to those who expected to find in it a fresh and vital treatment of the Anti-Semitic agitation. The piece must have suffered badly at the hands of the adapter. At all events, in its present shape, it comes to a most feeble and conventional conclusion. Actually, the play is built around a particular situation, and probably originated from it, or rather from the idea that suggested it. The importance of it is far more theatrical than sociological. Thibault, a young French aristocrat, dis- tinguished for his abilities, his charm, his energy and his hatred of all Jews, is re- solved that the object of his especial detes- tation, one Gutlieb, a rich Hebrew banker and philanthropist, shall be socially ob- literated. Therefore he insults him publicly ‘in his club, fully intending to kill him in | the duel which must follow. He thinks that ‘he will thus do the Christian world a ser- | vice. But his mother, the proud, venerated | Duchess de Croucy, intervenes, and from | her he learns, after an excruciating inter- view, that he is illegitimate, that the loath- }ed Gutlieb is his father, and that he him- self is also, therefore, a Jew. It is upon the scene in which this confession is made, |or rather extorted, that the success of the | play here must depend. Undoubtedly, the situation is a harrowing one, and it is elab- |orated with great ingenuity. But it is this | very ingenuity, with all its transparent ar- tifice and its multiplication of melodramatic device, that detracts from its tragic signifi- /eance and its artistic value. The whole con- trivance smacks too much of the theatre to impress any but the most unsophisticated playgoer with a sense of reality or reason- ableness. In Paris, this scene was enacted by Madame Réjane, with great subtility and |eloquence of feeling, and the effect was re- 'markable. The part of the mother is play- ed here by Miss Constance Collier, a far less accomplished actress, whose effects a,e due more to physical prowess than intel- lectual or artistic suggestion. She roused a storm of applause by a fine burst of pas- sionate abandonment. But all this has very little to do with Anti-Semitism. This, in- | deed, is discussed at great length in the | first act, but with a careful observance o* opposing prejudices which is more like |managerial astuteness than philanthropi:> purpose. The latter certainly had nothing | to do with the happy ending, in which Thi- | bault, after saying that nothing was left for him but death or the cloister, finds happi- ness in the arms of a devoted girl, plainly | provided as an afterthought, to secure a blissful curtain. Rudolph Besier’s “Don,” which has been secured by the New Theatre management for New York production, has attained suc- cess in London, and seems to be a bright and original piece of work, with a significant moral behind its humorous fancies. Stephen Bonnington is full of generous impulse and apt to act upon it, without weighing conse- quences. Moreover, he is fearless. When, therefore, he hears that a young wo- man of his acquaintance is treated abomi- nably by her husband—a dour old Second | Adventist—he promptly carries her off to pow own home, amid a variety of suspicious | circumstances, and hands her over to his |mother. With the arrival of the outraged husband, the situation becomes semi-tragic; | but it does not end so. The rash hero ex- | plains to his betrothed that it is his love for |her that has made him so chivalrous an | admirer and defender of her sex; he finds a | way, too, to deal with the angry husband. | A generous idealism underlies the whole | merry piece, and differentiates it from our | imported farces, made over from French | models. | The latest play by Bjirnstjerne Bjiérnson | is entitled “When New Wine is in Bloom,” 'and the theme is the glorification of love |and youth. A chorus is employed, as in | clasaic drama, and serves as the background | to love episodes, one being the reunion of 'a husband and wife who have lived apart. |The play will be staged in due course at openhagen, the famous Danish actress, Mme, Hennings, playing the leading part. On the withdrawal of the spectacular "9 Pats, LON rR E SP Ns
Page 25
. GR eR ry ei Ae tReet te ow are Oct. 28, 1909 “Révolution francaise’ from the stage of the Thé&tre Sarah Bernhardt, the “Jeanne a@’Arc” of Emile Moreau will be substituted. Rehearsals of this latter play are now in progress, and are said to have inspired the participants with an unusual degree of en- thusiasm. A chatty and very personal little book, entitled “Eugéne Scribe, d’aprés sa corre- spondance avec Ernest Legouvé,” has been compiled by Charles Martel and enlightens the reader as to the methods of dramatic collaboration the correspondents used. The construction of “Adrienne Lecouvreur,” of “Les Doigts de fée,’’ of the “Bastille des dames,” etc., is treated in anecdotal style “Suzette,”’ the new piece, by M. Brieux, now seen in Paris at the Vaudeville, is to be followed, in due season, by a play in four acts by M. Noziére, The playwright has drawn upon the novel by Paul Reboux, “La Maison de danses,”” for dramatic ma- terial, and his third act is described as being “‘une représentation dans la Maison de danses,”’ with a hundred figurants in ad- dition to the regular cast. = Musice. Standard Concert Repertory. By George P. Upton. Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co. $1.75. Mr. Upton is not particularly happy in the choice of titles for his books. Last year he prepared the “Standard Corcert Guide,” a handbook of symphonies, ora- torios, cantatas, and symphonic poems, uniting under one cover, together with some new material, the contents of his earlier “Standard Symphonies,” “Stan- dard Oratorios,” and “Standard Can- tatas.” There was a gain in convenience, undoubtedly. Now he appears with an- other volume in hand containing brief analyses of overtures, suites, symphonic poems, rhapsodies, fantasias, etc., in the modern concert repertory. Such 2 vol- ume was much needed; but why call it the “Concert Repertory”? Would it not have been possible to find titles indicat- ing that the “Guide” related to longer works, the “Repertory” to the shorter pieces? There are no other reasons for finding fault with Mr. Upton’s new book. The works chosen for analysis are selected judiciously and with catholic taste; the analyses are brief, lucid, and free from technical jargon or pedantic “parsing”; and concert-goers will be able to find here information regarding most of the concert pieces they are likely to fear. If anything, Mr. Upton is too liberal; there are a dozen or more compositions in his list that might have been left out without being missed. There are pic- tures of fifty-seven composers, three on & page, and as the arrangement Is al- phabetical, it results in some odd groups, such as Beethoven-Balfe-Bala- kireff, and D’Albert-Auber-Bach. An in- troductory chapter treats briefly of the different kinds of overtures and suites. The Nation. It is interesting to note the names of the composers represented by the larg- est number of works: Beethoven, Ber- lioz, Dvorak, Grieg, D’Indy, Mendels- sohn, Tchaikovsky, Wagner, Weber America European gets not only the singers, but also the players, the best of whom give more concerts on this side of the Atlantic than on the other Prominent among these players is Fritz Kreisler, who is with us again, after an absence of a year. He gave his first recital last Saturday afternoon at Car- negie Hall, before an enthusiastic audi ence which filled the auditorium; and once more he showed that he has no superior, probably no equal, among living violinists He shares the of Paderewskli, with whom he also has in common the con- tempt for mere display, the technical mas the subjection of He is the most emotional of Paderewski is of and he knows how to fill the hall without making the slightest concession. The ordi nary violinist and pianist often wonder why high-class concerts do not pay as well as vaudeville or musical comedy. As a mat- ter of fact, they do pay as well if the music is as adequately rendered as the low- greatest best popularity tership, and technique to expression. violinists, as pianists; class music usually is. The success of Kreisler and Paderewski proves. this Kreisler’s programme included, as usual, some of those quaint eighteenth century tunes which he has exhumed A Handel a Viotti concerto were also or his programme. He gives a second re- cital this week, on Saturday afternoon. sonata and Oscar Hammerstein's preliminary season of what he called “educational opera” comes to an end at the Manhattan this week. It was confined entirely to French and Italian operas, which the public is supposed to favor particularly; but al- though the orchestra, chorus, and scenery were the same as those employed during the regular season, when seats cost more than double the prices asked during the preliminary weeks, the pecuniary results were so unsatisfactory that the manage) ‘has decided not to repeat the experiment Some of the leading singers were quite good; but the New York public has shown many a time that it wants nothing but the best, and is willing to pay any price for that. It was also, no doubt, a mistake to begin so early; September and October are never likely to be good opera months here. The regular season at the Manhattan will begin on November 8, with the first per- formance in America of Massenet’s “Hérodiade.”” After the American season, Mr. Hammerstein intends to take his com- pany to Paris. The Metropolitan company also has announced that it has secured a theatre in Paris for a series of Italian performances next spring With Caruso to head the list of singers there can be no risk involved in such an experiment If it succeeds, the German wing of the Metro- politan will in the following spring give the Parisians a chance to hear the real Wagner Edward MacDowell wrote mostiy (for piano, voice, and orchestra. His admirers however, have converted some of his com- positions into chamber music The latest of these arrangements consists of five of the “Woodland Sketches,” which Julius 415 violoncello and Schmidt of Leipzig and Boston, who publishes this novelty, has also Klengel has adapted for piano. Arthur P. recently printed a Beach and a trio and a suite by Foote piano quintet by Mrs. Arthur The first new opera of the present season of the Opéra Comique—which is the twelfth season of M. Carré as director—will be ‘Chiquito.” These “scenes from Basque life,” after Pierre Loti, have for their librettist Henri Cain, and the music is by This will be the first opera composer to be sung in Paris Jean Nougués. of the Art. EXHIBITION OF TERS. A NEW OLD MAS- Lonpon, October 8 Collection at the first important The National Loan Grafton Gallery is the of the season. It is called “Na- tional,” no doubt, because its profits are destined for the National Gallery Funds. The need is urgent. Love for art is not one of the av- erage Briton’s qualities. and for long he bore the loss of masterpieces with show decent composure. The government's grants to the national collections are less than small—they are iiser- ly; and private bequests do nol go very far in an era of tremendous prices. The only hope seemed to be in seme action on the part of the public, and already the National Art Colle> tions Fund has been established on the lines of the French Society of the Friends of Art. The excitement last sum- mer over the Duke of Norfolk’s sale of his Holbein—the Duchess of Milan, which he had loaned to the National yallery for so long that it was looked upon as national property—drove into a panic a good many people who had never before been interested in the problem. I believe that the present exhibition had then already been plan- ned, but as it was to be held frankly “in aid of National Gallery Funds,” the excitement probably attracted more at- tention to it and made it easier to ob- tain the loan of important works. It is appropriate that the show should be of the old masters which its ob- ject is to save from the clutches of the barbarian. There has been no attempt to represent any one school or period, but rather to arrange a series of mas- terpieces of many schools and periods, and to supplement these with an-equally fine series of drawings. The number in both cases is limited to about a hun- dred, for it is beginning to be under- stood that it is better to show a few pictures well than many badly. The se- lection, on the whole, is admirable, as It ought to be, the Royal Academy hav- ing long since prepared the way. The one great work the Royal Academy has ac complished in the last half century
Page 26
416 should not be forgotten, whatever its summer shows may be, for the winter exhibitions of old masters have often been of the utmost interest and splen- dor, and, if the more recent have prov- ed less remarkable than the earlier, it is not to be wondered at. The supply of old masters in the country, though large, is not inexhaustible. The majority ol those shown at the Grafton are already well known, and the great pleasure is in the opportunity given to see again mas- terpleces which, belonging to private collections, it is not always easy to see. I confess that I went to the Exnibi- tion with some misgivings. Pictures have seldom looked well in the Graf- ton, hitherto an over-decorated and poor- ly-lighted gallery. However, several members of the committee now in charge are also members of the International Society, and have inherited the Whistler traditions of arrangement and hanging. The gallery has been redecorated, and a much quieter scheme invented for it. The walls are now covered, in two rooms with gray, in the other two with a dull reddish gold that makes a neutral background. The pictures are never crowded, and each has around it the space which is as important to a framed painting as the margin to a print. No strict chronological order has been observed: you must go into the third room before you come to the earliest work. Even here there are not many primitives, undue prominence not been given to “the cock-eyed madonnas” in which the maker of at- tributions delights. Even as it is, the carefully compiled catalogue seems to challenge the Morellian to combat. Af- ter all, however, the masterpiece _re- mains a masterpiece, and new attribu- tions would not the beauty of the Holy Women at the Sepulchre, now attributed to Hubert Van Eyck, from Sir Frederick Cook's collection. The col- or would not lose in brilliancy nor the having lessen design in fine dramatic lines, the tow- ered and turreted mediwval town against the luminous sky would be as picturesque. More beautiful still and one of the most beautiful works in the whole collection, Is the Holy Family with Donors by Carpaccio, lent by Lord Berwick. You almost resent finding it in a gallery, so clearly was it meant to decorate a certain definite space. The great Venetians who came later seldom exceeded the splendor of this harmony in brown and gold, seldom surpassed the rhythm of the lines and masses. The road winds along the hilly background, little figures of the Magi, each in rich robes on a richly caparisoned horse, are seen as they come riding from out of the distance to where the child lies low on the ground between the kneeling mother and the kneeling donors, a man and woman, who are devoutly worshipping; that both are ‘portraits you are sure and down it the The Nation. without knowing their names or who or what they were. The subject was one only too often painted by Carpaccio’s contemporaries, but the master could create a masterpiece out of the most hackneyed theme. A Virgin and Child by Crivelli has not a little of the same decorative sumptuousness of color, and one can but feel how it must have glit- tered and glowed and shone in the place above the altar which originally it was intended to fill. These old masters never would have allowed their work to be seen, as we see it, separated from the surroundings for which they design- ed it, for they were, above all things, decorators. In this same room there are two portraits of the greatest distinc- tion, about which there has already been much discussion: attributed by the pres- ent catalogue to Giorgione and to Titian. respectively. The first, known as the Temple-Newsam Giorgione, is the por- | trait of a youngish man; his face, vc‘ean- shaven, has both charm and power, and his pose, as he stands behind a parapet, his hat in one hand, his gloves in the other, is of great dignity; while the col- or throughout is quiet, with beautiful passages of sombre red in the sleeves. The Titian, which came up for sale three years ago at Christie’s, represents an older man, whose face has less charm but whose pose is as dignified, and who wears a wonderfully painted fur-trim- med cloak. He has been described as Lorenzo de’ Medici, but it makes little difference who he is, or who actually were the painters of two portraits of such rare nobility and distinction. The many other pictures in this same group—by Luini, Ghirlandaio, the Maitre des Moulins, Fra Lippo Lippi, Bellini— all have their interest, if not always ar- tistic at least historical. There is an- other Giorgione, the subject of even hotter dispute, the large Adulteress Brought Before Christ, lent by the Glas- gow Corporation; although the most dis- puted Giorgione of all is the Giovanni Onigo, in the adjoining room, al- ready referred to by the critics as “the problem picture.” There are also two characteristic Raphaels, the Cowper Ma- donnas, as they are called—characteris- tic, that is, of the popular Raphael; they might hang as pendants to the Sis- tine Madonna. Near them, however, is the group of Cardinal Ferry Carondelet and his Secretary, with such strong in- dividuality expressed in each of the fig- ures, even in the third who peers out from the shadows of the background, that, like his portraits in the Uffizi, it makes one wish that Raphael had left his followers to paint the Madonnas then in demand and bad himself kept to portraiture. The most distinguished feature of the largest room is a wonderful wall of por- traits by Rembrandt and Frans Hals, only five in all, but each a masterpiece. The Man with a Hawk, from the Duke [ Vol. 89, No. 2313 of Westminster’s collection, so superb in its beautiful golden glow, and the Man with Close-Cropped Hair, loaned by Sir Edgar Vincent, that looks as if painted with a brush steeped in light, are the Rembrandts, and are so well known that it would be useless for me here to Jo more than mention them. The three Halses come from the Kann collection. Two are of men, both half-lengths and both severe in color, the black of the dress lightened only by collar and gloves. The third is of a woman, and is no less severe, the collar, cuffs, cag, and a handkerchief in her hands the sole relief to the severity. They are cat- alogued simply as Portrait of a Man, Portrait of a Burgomaster, Portrait «f a Woman. But the portraits would gain nothing in interest if the name of each subject had survived. These men and women live for us as surely as if they had been identified. They have char- acter in their faces, their pose, the way they carry off the fashions of the pe riod; beauty in the expression of this character, the vivacity of the handling, the sense of design with which each is placed on the canvas. Hals was no less a master of decorative design than Car- paccio, though he used it for so different a purpose. The vigor of Hals’s work sometimes blinds one to the deli- eacy of his detail. After this series of portraits, the Van Dycks on the opposite wall strike you as artificial and lifeless, and, indeed, finer examples might, with- out much trouble, have been chosen. Reynolds’s Sterne, too, loses by the comparison; El Greco's portrait of his daughter seems but a decorative ar- rangement, and Goya’s Duke of Well- ington but the Spaniard’s failure to paint an Englishman. Though portraits predominate, there is one beautiful though not entirely untouched Ver Meer, Soldiers and Laughing Girl, one of the gray interiors he loved, with two figures, and on the wall a marvellously painted map, In a large canvas like Rubens’s Queen Tomyris with the Head of Cyrus, one looks for other qualities than Ver Meer’s tenderness of tone and ex- quisiteness of surface; one finds them, too, in his tremendous vigor, dramatic action, swaggering pose, elaborate com- |position — the elaboration, perhaps, too evident—splendor of color. The flam- boyancy and vitality of it put to shame the machine of the modern weakling. The handling is so masterly that one is inclined to agree with the critic quot- ed in the Catalogue, that all the prin- cipal figures are by the master himself, /which cannot often be said of the pic ‘tures Rubens designed on so large a scale. Velasquez is not very well repre- sented. His Water Carrier and Old Wo- ‘man Frying Eggs are early works, their ‘interest mainly biographical, and the ‘small Portrait of a Man, never previous ly exhibited, is certainly not to be rank- ed with many of the other paintings by }
Page 27
oa Sai ih rai cS ene ne hehe nee tele ale vk ch an ke ee Oct. 28, 1909] him, owned in England. More than one of the early Italians could have been spared for the masterpieces of the great Spaniard, and it is hard to understand the committee’s apparent indifference to them. The English pictures, with a few ex- ceptions, have been hung together in the small octagon room, the first to be en- tered. Here, Reynolds towers, making up in a measure for the disappoint- ment in his Sterne, where it faces the great Dutchmen. The most important pictures by him are the two large groups of The Dilettanti Society, painted with a straightforwardness not invariably in- spired by the women who posed and languished for him. In both the color is perhaps a little forced, keyed up too high in an apparent and quite unsuc- cessful effort to vie with the golden glow of Rembrandt. But the figures are vivid and well arranged, and all the de- tails are painted with a joy in the work that is unmistakable. These pictures should have a place in any and every exhibition where the eighteenth-century British painters are hung with the old masters of whom they were students and followers. I have space only to add that Gainsborough and Lawrence are also included; that Chardin, Nattier, and Watteau are represented, that E) Greco’s extraordinary Supper in the House of Simon hangs with the por- trait of his daughter; that there are sev- eral of Rubens’s fine sketches, and that Tiepolo appears as his rival with an enormous Finding of Moses, in color and design less flamboyant and vigor- ous, but subtler and, used as mural dec- oration, probably more decorative. If there is no landscape at all, it is simply because some sort of limit was necessi- tated by the available wall space. No such limit was imposed in the se- lection of drawings, which almost all come from J. P. Heseltine’s collection and are of the French school. The Claudes are many, chiefly in pen and sepia on white or tinted paper: notes, or rather elaborate drawings, of broad landscapes with classic buildings and placid waters, with goatherds an‘ goats, with large graceful trees just where trees should be, and skies filled with light. Most of them are carried almost as far as his pictures, a few are simply studies and not one more mar- vellous for the etching than the careful- ly worked out two ships in a storm, The Shipwreck, a proof of his scrupu- lousness as student as well as skiJi as draughtsman. The Watteaus, dainty, and learned in their daintiness, are still more numerous. There are fewer Fragonards, but these few have no less grace and even greater freedom, and the slightest are proofs of the invaria- ble knowledge of his craft and sense of style. There are also Bouchers, Largil- liéres, and Lancrets, and originals by Gravelot and Moreau le Jeune, who are The Nation. better known in engravings; and, jinal- ly, this marvellous collection is brought down to David and Bailly, Ingres, and Géricault. The Exhibition will remain open four months. It seems one of the little .ron- ies of life that the Englishman who pat- ronizes it will be giving freely to the government in alms, even while the country is fighting over the means to force him to give to the government in tax. N. N. “The Art of the Belgian Galleries,” by Esther Singleton, is the ninth volume in the Art Galleries of Europe series, and is to be issued by L. C. Page & Co. on October 30. Five more volumes in the International Art series are promised for autumn publi- cation. Edgar Degas is treated by Georges Grappe, the Great English Masters by Fritz Stahl, Eugéne Delacroix, and Auguste Ro- din by Camille Mauclair and Gustave Kahn, respectively, while Fritz Boehle, a young German artist of remarkable distinction, whose work is not yet widely known, is the subject of a volume by Rudolf Klein (Un- win). The frontispiece of the September num- ber of the Burlington Magazine is a Ma- donna and Child, by Fra Angelico, recently purchased by J. Pierpont Morgan from the collection of the King of the Belgians It is said to be “the only single picture known of the painter’s last Roman period,” and should be a revelation, to many, of the serious artistic accomplishment of the Frate, while it has all the devotional feel- ing and sweetness of his earlier works The rest of the number, both text and il- lustrations, is devoted almost wholly to the minor arts, such as French Renaissance furniture, Sheffield plate, Kentish chests, crewel-work hangings, and Oriental pot- tery. The important exception is an article by E. B. Havell on “The Symbolism of In- dian Sculpture and Painting.”’ Volume XXVII of the International Studio (John Lane Co.), including the num- bers for July, August, September, and Oc- tober of 1909, is ‘‘true to type,"’ being some- thing halfway between a popular magazine and a serious technical publication, It is profusely illustrated, has a patchy air which comes from short articles and a poor lecorative sense in the printing of the page and the spacing of illustrations, and deals with current art production, good, bad, and indifferent, pretty fully It is not quite popular, because it prefers art that is new or startling or significant to that which is pleasing; not quite serious, because its criticism is seldom written by persons of real competence and never written for real students. What jt presents, at best, Is a popular account of unpopular art, and where the art is good as well as unpopu- lar (which is sometimes the case, though not so often as the unpopular artists would have us believe), such an account has its rees A Greek marble, “the most beautiful statue in the world,” has been snatched from “the envious greed of foreign mil- lionaires’’ and from “finding a place in some enormous collection of recent an- tiquities and bastard chefs-d’a@uvre,” and 417 placed in the Museo delle Terme, at Rome. This statue, popularly known as La Fanci- ulla di Anzio, represents a girlish figure Standing turned a little towards the left, her head slightly bent downward, her hair knotted over the forehead. She wears an himation and a chiton, which falls, leaving the right shoulder bare. She seems intent on some objects on a large disk which she supports with her left hand The atti- tude suggests the presence of another fig- ure It is not clear whether she repre- sents a priestess or some mythological character, but she is full of the warmth and truth of beautiful youth and of fine Attic grace. This statue was discovered in December, 1879, when a heavy storm caused a landslide in the Grotto of Nero on a farm belonging to Prince Ludovico Aldobrandini-Chigi, at Anzio. The waves exposed a wall of reticulated bricks, with 1 niche, covered with stucco, in which this statue was still standing. It had been seen by only a few foreign archmologists until an application for permission to ex- port called the government's attention to it. and resulted in its purchase (it is re- ported) for 450,000 lire. From Paris comes news of the death of Henri Bellery-Desfontaines, a landscapist, and of Edmé Antony Paul Noél (‘Tony Noél’’), a well-known sculptor. M. Desfon- taines was but forty-two years of age, and was an artist of varied talents. Tony Noél was a professor at the Beaux-Arts, and a former reciplent of the Prix de Rome, be- Guillaume, and He was in his sixty-fifth year ng a pupil of Lequesne Cavelier e inanece. THE BANK OF ENGLAND AND WALL STREET. Last Thursday's advance of the Bank of England's official discount rate to 5 per cent. was one of those events which cause a flutter of interest throughout the finantial world. In the first place, a 5 per cent. English bank rate before the close of October is unusual. Except for 1906, this is the first year in which the rate has gone to that figure at such a date since London's “Boer War panic” of 1899, and 1899 was the first year in which it had been reached in October since the “Baring panic” of 1890. Even this, however, is not the chief considera- tion. The Bank of England rate has been raised this month in three succes- sive weekly advances, from the 2% per cent. rate which prevailed up to October 7, to the 5 per cent. rate of last week. So rapid and violent an advance, though not unparalleled in the Bank's recent histery, is quite out of the ordinary. The particular interest which our own market takes in the Bank of England's action arises from a more or less prevalent idea that the Bank had entered the field expressly to curb the American stock speculation. Now the average man will be apt to ask what business it is of the Bank of England whether Wall Street
Page 28
418 chooses to gamble excitedly in securi- ties or not, and what right a London in- stitution has to force high money rates on its own market, with a view to im- peding speculative operations’ three thousand miles away. To answer this, a brief review of very recent financial history is necessary. Throughout the past five or six months,a stock specula- tion of extraordinary violence has been raging the New York and Berlin markets. Six weeks ago, the Imperial German Bank at Berlin took official cog- nizance of this specu'ative situation. During the last half of September and the first half of October, that bank rais- ed its official discount rate from 3% to 5 per cent., and its president plainly stat- ed at the time his belief that absorp- tion of capital in the Berlin stock rpec- ulation was seriously impairing bank resources, and declared his purpose of checking that speculation by making it more costly. This effort at Berlin appears to have been reasonably successful. But the German bank's position was in some re- spects peculiar. Its weekly statements showed plain evidence of an extracrdl- nary strain; at the time it made its sec- ond advance in rate, the actual status of the bank was the weakest in many years. Its so-called “emergency note circulation” had reached, that week, the largest total in its history. This was not the situation at the Bank of Eng- Even its statement of last Thurs- when the 6 per cent. on land. day, submitted rate was fixed, showed the ratio of re-| serves to liabilities in the London bank to be not far from the usual average at this time of year, and its stock of gold to be as large as it has been at this date | in several recent years. It was at the opening of autumn that the rise in prices on our Stock Exchange reached its pitch of especial violencc. Now, ordinarily, speculation halts on tne approach of autumn ixperience has shown that when the crop-moving sea- son comes and Western banks have abundant use for their funds at home, their New York balances will be heav- ily The prudent specu- drawn upon. lator always reckons, therefore, on 4 period of restraint until the harvest movement is completed. No such re- straint was in any sense exhibited this autumn. The speculation, converging as it did on shares of the Steel Corpora- tion, grew to wholly abnormal propo-~- tiots; prices continued to move up by leaps and bounds. Not only did the stock market as a whole show signs of fever- ish activity, but the Steel shares alone, or. days when total transactions in ail stocks on the Exchange exceeded a mil- lion shares, made up at times no less than 40 per cent. of that enormous tra.l- ing. In accordance with experience, the in- terior banks began some weeks ago to call home their New York funds; as a The Nation. consequence of this, and of the rapidly mounting liabilities, surplus reserves o* the New York associated banks ap- proached exhaustion. It was under such conditions, three weeks ago, that our bankers entered the London money mar- ket with exceptionally large demands for funds on the basis of Stock Ex- change collateral. In a single week, when the local situation ought to have been expanding New York bank loans, the bank statement at the end of the week, showed $49,000,000 loan reduction a contraction greater than had ever before been witnessed in this city. This meant unquestionably that an enormous sum of credits had been shifted from New York to London, as an alternative to actual liquidation of loans in specula- tive Wall Street. Here was the phase of the situation, which is alleged in Europe to have had its part in inspiring the Bank of Eng- land to mark up its discount rate, and thereby raise the general London money rate for restrictive purposes. Wall Street inquires exactly why the Bank should feel compelled to meddle in a borrowing operation in which the London lender and the American borrower equally pro- fess themselves to be content. The an- swer probably wil! be found in the expe- rience of both markets during 1906 and 1907. In the earlier of those two years, an equally extensive borrowing operation on the London market, to support a Wall Street speculation, had created a huge foreign credit for American ac- count. Things did not go well in the United States. The New York money market fell into disorder, deficits in | bank reserves occurred, and the holdevs of these London credits promptly drew 'on them in the form of gold, drainiag the London market in enormous sums and impairing seriously the Bank of) England’s gold reserve at the most awi- |ward moment of the year. In 1907, a somewhat similar result ensued, empha- sized by the panicky nature of the American demands. To all such reasoning on the question. it is frequently replied, on Wall Street and in certain quarters of financial crit- icism, that the American speculation cannot really have cut a figure in the Bank of England's action, and that the Bank itself must be frightened about iis power of maintaining a sufficient go)J reserve, and is doubtful as to the future situation of the London market. Bur nothing could very well beg the ques- tlon more completely ven granting that such a delicate situation had arisen or was anticipated on the London mar- ket, what would be said of a central in- stitution which did not then employ all its power to obstruct a sudden and large demand on home resources by for- eign borrowers, whose demands had no other basis than an extravagant Stock Exchange speculation? | Vol. 89, No. 2313 BOOKS OF THE WEEK. American Foreign Policy. By a Diplomatist. Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Archibald, R. C. Carlyle’s First Love, Mar- garet Gordon Lady Bannerman. Lane Co. $3.50 net. Arnold, G. W. A Mother's List of Books for Children. Chicago: McClurg. Bacon, J. D. In the Border Country. Dou- bleday, Page. $1. Bailey, L. H. The Nature-Study Idea. Third edition. revised. Macmillan. $1.25 net. Beard, A. F. A Crusade of Brotherhood: a History of the American Missionary Assn.; The Story of John Frederic Ober- lin. 2 vols. Pilgrim Press. $1.25 net each. Bell, L. The Concentrations of Bee. Bos- ton: Page & Co. Beruete, A. de, and others. on Joaquin Sorolla y Bastida. The Hispanic Society of America. Eight Essays 2 vols. $7.50 net. Blaisdell, M. F. Polly and Dolly. Little, Brown. 60 cents. Britton, W. The White Slavery: A Study of the Present Trades Union System. Akron, O.: The Werner Co. Brown, A. F. John of the Woods. Houghton Mifflin. $1.25. Buffington, B. E., and others. The Circus Book for Children. Sanborn & Co. Cabell, J. B. Chivalry. Harper. $2 net. Cable, G. W. “Posson Jone’”’ and Pére Raphaél. Scribner. Carroll, L. Through the Looking Glass, = What Alice Found There. Dodge. 1.50. ‘ Chamberlin, G. L., and Kern, M. R. Child Religion in Song and Story. Walks with Jesus. Chicago: Univ. of Chicago Press. $1.38. Chancellor, L. B. The Players of London: A Tale of an Elizabethan Smart Set. B. W. Dodge & Co. Chatterbox for 1909. Boston: Dana Estes. $1.25. Christmas in the Heart. Illustratei1. Hod- der & Stoughton. Clouston, J. S. The Prodigal Father. Cen- tury Co. $1.50. Conn, H. W., and Budington, R. A. Ad- vanced Physiology and Hygiene. Silver, Burdett. $1.10. Conway, A. E. and M. The Children’s Book of Art. Macmillan. $2 net. Daggett, M. P. In Lockerbie Street: A Little Appreciation of J. W. Riley. B. W. Dodge & Co. 50 cents net. Davenport, H. My Quest of the Arabian Horse. B. W. Dodge & Co. $2 net. Days with the Poets: Browning, Burns, Keats, Longfellow, Tennyson, Words- worth. Six volumes, illustrated in color. Hodder & Stoughton. Deland, L. F. Imagination in Business. Harper. 60 cents, net. De Voe, ‘ The Doors of Life. Funk & Wagnalls. $1. net. Dewing, E. B. Other People’s Houses, Mac- millan. $1.50. Drummond, H. A Golden Month; A Golden Week. 2 vols. Hodder & Stoughton. Eells, E. A Mission to Hell. Boston: Sher- man French. 80 cents net. Ellis, Mrs. Havelock. Steve’s Woman. McBride Co. $1.50. Financial. Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Traveilers’ Credits . Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York Letters Certificates
Page 29
¥ a & 3 z ra & ml. aaa NCAR ee eae tl nate ores Oct. 28, 1909} Everyman's Library. Edited by Ernest Rhys. The Conquest of Mexico, by W. H. Prescott 2 vols.; The Count of Monte Cristo, by A. Dumas, 2 vols.; The Bay- ard of India, by L. J. Trotter; The Life of William Carey, by G. Smith; Speeches on Politics and Literature, by Lord Ma- caulay. Dutton Ewell, A. W. A Text-Book of Physicai Chemistry: Theory and Practice: Phila.: P. Blakiston’s Son & Co. $2.25 net. France, A. Penguin Island. Trans. by A. W. Evans. Lane Co. $2. France, A. The Life of Joan of Arc. In two vols. Lane Co. $8 net. Gask, L. The Wonders of the Zoo. Dodge. $1.25. Gray, T. The Buried City of Kenfig. Ap- pleton. Griggs, E. H. Human Equipment, Huebsch. 50 cents net. Gwatkin, H, M. Early Church History to A. D. 313. 2 vols. Macmillan. $5.25 net Hagedorn, H. A Troop of the Guard Houghton Mifflin. $1.10 net. Hancock, A. E. Bronson of the Rabble Lippincott. $1.50. Heart Songs. Boston: The Chapple Pub. Co Henry, O. Options. Harper. $1.50. Hickman, A. Century Co. Hofmann, J. Piano Questions Answered. Doubleday, Page. 75 cents. Howells, W. D. Seven English Cities. Har- An Unofficial Love Story per. $2. Howe, H. A. Elements of Descriptive Astronomy. Revised edition. Silver Burdett & Co. $1.25. Hoyt, E. Play Days: Little Folks in the Country. 2 vols. Boston: W. ... Wilde Co. 50 cents each, Hughes, E. H. The Teaching of Citizen- ship. Boston: W. A. Wilde Co, $1.25. Hurd, M. K., and Wilson, J. B. When She Came Home from College Houghton Mifflin. $1.15 net. Hutton, E. Rome. With Illustrations. Mac- millan. $2 net. International Studio. Lane. $3 net. Irwin, L. G. The Secret of Old Thunder- Head. Holt. $1.50. Volume XXXVIII. James, W. The Meaning of Truth: a Sequel to “Pragmatism.” Longmans, Green. $1.25 net. Jastrow, M., jr. Die Religion Babyloniens und Assyriens. Giessen, Germany: A Tdé- pelmann. Jerrold, M. F. Francesco Petrarca, Poet and Humanist. Dutton Kautsky, K. The Road to Power. Trans- lated by A. M. Simons. Chicago: Samuel A. Bloch. Lea, H. The Valor of Ignorance. Harper. $1.80 net. Leeds, C. C. Mechanical Drawing for Trade Schools. Van Nostrand. $2 net. Lee, V. The Countess of Albany. $1.50 net. Lewis, L. B. Pupil’s Notebook and Study Outline in Oriental and Greek History American Book Co. 25 cents Livy. Book IX. Edited with introduction, etc., by W. B. Anderson. Putnam. 75 cents. Lane Co Cornell Studies in History and Political Science. The Nation. Love, A. E. H. Elements of the Differen- tial and Integral Calculus. Putnam. $1.50 Lucas, E. V. Some Friends of Mine. Mac- millan Co. $1.25 net. Maartens, Maarten The Doris. Appleton. $1.50 McCabe, J. The Iron Cardinal: The Ro- mance of Richelieu. McBride Co McCook, H, C. Ant Communities $2 net. Marriott, C. The Isle of Dead Ships. Li; pincott. $1 net. Marshall, W. V A Curb to Wealth. Fenno & Co, Masterman, E. W. G Studies in Calilee Univ. of Chicago Press. $1 net Matthews, F. Back to Hampton Roads Supplementary to With the Battle Fleet Huebsch. $1.50. Miller, J. R. A Golden Month: Week. 2 vols. Price of Lis Harper Predatory Golden Hodder & Stoughton Miller, R. J Around the World with the Battleships. Chicago: McClurg. $1.25 Minutes of the Commissioners for Detect ing and Defeating Conspiracies ‘n_ the State of New York. Albany County Ses sions, 1778-1781. 2 vols Albany, N. Y State of New York Mooney, H. J How to Train Your Own Dogs. Akron, O.: Saalfield Pub. Co. 50 cents, Mother Goose. Illustrations by J. Hassall Dodge $1.50. Munford, B. B. Virginia's Attitude Toward Slavery and Secession. Longmans, Green $2 net. Murray, J. L. The Apologetic of Modern Missions: Outline Studies i. est oe dent Volunteer Movement 15 cents. Nagel, Oskar Die Welt als Arbeit. Sec- ond edition. New York: Oskar Nagel. Old-lore Miscellany of Orkney, Shetland Caithness and Sutherland Records. Nos 17, 18, 19. London: Viking Club. Oxford Plain Texts. Milton's Paradise Lost, Book i and ii; Byron’s Prisoner of Chillon, Mazeppa, and Lament of Tasso; Shelley’s Adonais, Alastor, and Other Poems. Frowde. Parrish, R. My Lady of the South. Chi- cago: McClurg & Co. $1.50. Pennell, E. R. French Cathedrals. Illus- trations by J. Pennell, Century Co. $5 net. Philip, J. C. The Romance of Modern Chemistry. Phila.: Lippincott $1.50 net Phillpotts, E. The Haven. Lane Co. $1.50 Poets of Ohio Edited by Emerson Venable Cincinnati: Robert Clarke Co. $1.50 net. Potter, M. K. Richard in Camp. Boston W. A. Wilde Co. 75 cents Report of the Board of Water Supply of th City of New York. December 31, 1907 Report of the Department of Education of the City of New York for the year ending July 31, 1907 Report of the N. Y. Produce From Julv, 1908, to July, 1909 Reports of the Insurance Commissioner of the State of Maine, for the Year End ing Dec. 31, 1908. Augusta, Mé Rose, T. K The Precious Metal Van Nostrand $2 net Exchangs Vol. I. Money and Credit Instruments in Their Relation to General Prices Second edition, completely rewritten, with statistical material brought down to the close of the fiscal year 1908. By EDWIN WALTER KEMMERER, Ph.D. Cornell University, and sometime Finan al ment relative to the Establishment of th $1.25 net; by mail, $1.31. the laws determining the movement of general prices , Professor of Economics and Finance in Adviser to the Philippine Govern- Gold Standard in the Philippine Islands The book is of special interest now because of its careful treatment of the principles underlying the influence of the world’s gold production upon prices. From reviews of the first edition of the hook: “This little volume is in many ways the best thing that has appeared in monetary investigation for some years past. “Professor Kemmerer’s book we believe to be one of great value fessor Irving Fisher, Yale Review. “The study is of the kind which is a credit to American scholarship.” Nation. Pro- Professor J. Laurence Laughlin, Journal of Political Fconomym. HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, ¢ + : The subject of this book is the most fundamental problem in monetary science Mw W. 234 Bt NEW YORK 41% Russell, W. 8S. C., and Kelly, H. C. Labo- ratory Manual of First Year Science. Holt. 75 cents. Schauffler, R. H. Romantic Germany. Cen- tury Co 3.50 net. Shelley, H. C. Inns and Taverns of Old London, with illustrations Bostou: Page & Co. Sindall, R. W. The Manufacture of Paper Van Nostrand, 2 net Smith, D A Legend of Bethlehem Hod der & Stoughton Smith, F. B. The Lady of Big Shanty leday. Page. Smith, F. E. A Hand-Book of General In- Dou- struction for Mechanics. Van Nostrand, $1.50 net. tanley H M Autobiography Edited by his wife. Houghton Mifflin. $ Stories from the Iliad. By H. L. Havell $1 50. Taggart, M. A. Six Girls and the Seventh One Boston: W A. Wilde Co $1.50 rhe Arabian Nights, Edited by K, D. Wig- gin and N. A. Smith. Illustrations by Maxfield Parrish. Scribner. $2.50 The Arabian Nights. With Illustrations by W. H. Robinson, H. Stratton and others Dodge $1.50. The Catholic Encyclopwdia. Vol. VI Greg. Robert Appleton Co The Little Treasury Series: O Love Divine; My Hope is in Thee; Stand Fast in the Faith; Tidings of Great Joy; O Rest in the Lord; As Thy Days So Shall Thy Strength Be. Illustrated in colors, Hod- der & Stoughton. The Poetry of Nature Dyke Doubleday Trollope, A Is He Dodd, Mead. Tyson, S. L. The Teaching of Our Lord as to the Indissolubility of Marriage Se- wanee, Tenn.: The University Press. 75 cents net. Turner Ed The Standard Locomotive Engineers and Chicago: Laird & Lee. 75 cents Wade, M. H. Little Folks of North Amer- ica. Boston: W. A. Wilde Co. $1 Warren, G. A. The Musket Boys of Old Dodge. Fath- Selected by H. Van Page Pope njoy ? Vol Ze Guide’ for Firemen. Boston. Cupples & Leon Co. $1 Washburn, G Fifty Years in Constantl- nople Houghton Mifflin. $3 net Wells, € Dick and Dolly. Dodd Mead. $1.25 Wells, C The Clue Phila Lippincott $1.50 Wheeler, F. G. Billy Whiskers at ie Fair. Saalfield Pub. Co. $1. White, H. A Stonewall Jackson Jacobs & Co. $1.25 net Woodhull, A. A Military Hygiene for th Officers of the Line. Fourth edition. Wile & Sons. $1.50 net. Wright, P. A Three-Foot $1 50 net Yetter, J. M The Pennsylvania Phila. - Dutton. Stool Educational System of Cochrane Pub. Co Younghusband, F Kashmir. Macmillan $6 net. Zahn, T Introduction to the New Testa- ment. Translated from third German edl- er ols eribner The Conquest of the Air By ALPHONSE BERGET Profuscly illustrated from graphs and Diagrama by the Photo author Siro. 33.56 net \ history of aviation fram the earliest times to the present day, with full accounts cf the recent exploits of Zeppelin, Wilbur Wright, Farman Biériot, and Latham—to mention only a few, G, P, PUTNAM’S SONS, E*YoxDon | AMERICANS: An Impression By Alexander Francis
Page 30
The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2313 In 1910, A new novel by In 1910, “ Modjeska’s Memoirs.” “ An Unofficial Love-Story.” May Sinclair, “ The Creators.” The Life of a Great Actress. Other stories by Albert Hickman in 1910. Do You Enjoy An There is a quality of companionship in good reading which every one has felt and no more delightful reading is provided than in the pages of THE CENTURY MAGAZINE. In it you will find the best in many fields —fiction, history, travel, science, sport, art—a thousand and one sources of pleasure and interest brought before you. Underlying all you will find a quiet sincerity in maintaining the highest ideals and an avoidance of sensation whicl have given THE CENTURY MAGAZINE a character of its own. You Will Enjoy the T’CENTURY fry . . are tavited to examine the resources Ruskin Manusc 2nd Edition in Preparation. of our retall «tore. Mere will be found rl S a tlarae stock of current and standard LETTERS FROM CHINA works from American and foreign presses. Teachers or atadents prepar- ing for courses of reading will Gnd an . > atin excellent choltce of moderate-priced are forsale, Please enquir: by not only the latest, but the most inter ORDERS WILL BE letter to MR. JOHN HART, if cating of the many about my country.” “ . ae fa > ! ; € 8vo, $2.75. SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send fer cata Maltravers Hous:, Arundel St , | ae ee crows vo, $2.75 E. P. DUTTON & CO., West 234 Street, New York 2 In 1910, “ The Preservation of Health,” In 1910, “American Sports,” by Professor Metchnikoff. by Walter Camp. Illustrated with Many Photographs. SS 2 . ao I A nee em Visitors in New York By SARAH PIKE CONGER Several of these imporiant MSS. (Mrs, E. H. Conger) A native Chinese student writes: ‘‘Jt ig London, E »gland. A. C. MeCLURG & CO., Chicago. Print rad ee i ee a
Page 31
Oct. 28, , 1909] The Nation. In 1910, “Motoring in a In 1910, Beautiful Aauninen Gardens, at 1910 “The Holy Land,’ by Cactus Forest.” by Hildegarde Hawthorne Robert Hichens and Jules Guerin Agreeable Companion? If you ask for articles of rare interest by real authorities whose honest opinions not only inform you but are contributions of lasting value to their subjects, i If you enjoy stories, long and short, which possess all the charm ; and delightful interest and intellectual stimulus which are the (| characteristics of true literature, If you care for artistic loveliness in the faithful reproduction of beautiful pictures and the exquisite refinements which pains- taking care can give the printed page, _ Companionship of MAGAZINE In 1910, The Making of Good Roads, In 1910, “A Tramp in the Far East,” = In 1910 “City Planning in America, | by Ernest Fiagg and others A Young American's Adventures by Charles W. Eliot, LL.D BY SHRIDHAR U. KETKAR, A.M. IMPRESSIONS AND SUGGESTIONS TI ' . : 7 Othera bave written more thoroughly abour Indla 1¢ only reliable book in English on ,,,. Keir Hardie. But as a polemic tract on the caste in India. The author is a Sanskrit part of the opposition against the British policy in This volume contains critical investigation be pald the compliment not before accorded any | jbraries on request. book on the Indian situation of being read by the people.— Boston Herald OLIVER DITSON At bookstores, $1.00 net; by mall, $1.08. DITBON BUILDING, Messrs. TAYLOR AND CARPENTER, Ithaca, N.Y. 5. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, New York. of the conditions which gave rise to sys- tem of castes in the modern form. History of Caste in India | N DIA The - . Musicians - - . b4 $1.50 ‘net. $1.60 by mail. By J. KEIR HARDIE, M.P. Library For all Music Lovers, 50 Hand- 4 scholar and a sociologist of rare merit. India the little book is a masterpiece. It will Some Volumes. Special rates to all 4 COMPANY BOSTON, MASS
Page 32
vi The. N ation. _ [Vol. 89, No. 2313 ae FORM? PHAHHNNNUNAANNNNNTTTeneTD eevee AN ETT WNCEEAALOESUPNTUNEUCEOUAUUU RATT TUNE TGA ETT AS TRNNS LDA LD HEN US AMaAN gash ORNATE LEENA NMA PENNA INT AMT eT ATTA he tn " POLES. 10 TT NMC For the Boy or Girl You Love - - «(C4 am rofl there is a great happiness which you can easily bestow. For the Fairy Fields of Happiness @ lie open to every boy and girl in the pages of Str. NICHOLAS. oY @ You cannot bring into the life of a child you love a greater joy or a stronger influence for good than Sr. NicHo.as. a4 @ A hundred thousand joyous children who eagerly await its coming each month bear wit- &) ness to the hours and hours of happiness they “A ¥. find in its pages. (“q z di oa : Sw whi) q A hundred thousand older folk testify to its Wit Mh } splendid influence in developing all that is best Jel “\ in its boys and girls. {yd | @ Sr. Nicuo.as is the greatest of magazines Fx i for boys s and girls of all ages from three to six- . \} i teen. It has the best stories, the most interest- ing articles, the most helpful and entertaining departments, the jolliest rhymes, and the most beautiful pictures. ST. NICHOLAS The Great Treasure House of Happiness for Children Single copies, 25 cents. Yearly subscriptions, $3.00, At all the best bookstores and news-stands. SS re Be Sart . . * FOR Ss AL K BOOK S—Al! out of print books supplied, no Handy Volume lassics' Tem _olumes of the works of Benjamin, Wrath. | nated: 1 can get ou any book ever” Dublished! ‘ ;| Wan in - being set L.3 17 a Fy edition Inauer hen i England, call and inspect my stock of ' " ' » everywhere, 155 "7 ; | 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, ' wine ay t priee . Cloth B5c per She » are very bandsome books, printed in oc John Bright St., Birmingham, England. vol limp leather The. per ve i (Special prices ave volume of five bundred pages each; excellent | ' and colleges. ) quality of paper and press work; he” type, ‘pant tastefully teund in half leather, t top rice | SEND FOR CATALOGUE, 0. vy Be Rox 55. Wear Cheater, Pennsylvania. | JUST ISSUED. Cloth, $1.50 net. SAINTE-BEUVE Bend for Catalogur WNITZY . George M. Harper, Prince University. FOREIGN SCHOENHOF pooxce, AGH 6 hae LIPPINCOTT CO. Philadelphia. Thomas Y.Crowell&Co.,New York Do you know the Beacon Biographies? BOOKS 128 Tremont street. suiTuORS The only authoritative lives of twen- RORTON, MARA. MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 of Celebrities Bought and Sold. bought by A. 8S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. | Ws Send for a deacriptive pamphiet. A R. MARX’S CAPITAL, °°” y oun Boston 225 Fifth Ave., New York. 9 3 vols. Small, Ma & Co.. 31 Beacon St. LETTERS Pub. "THE COLLECTOR."$1ayr\ CHARLES H. KERR & COMPANY, i ee ad