The Nation 1909-09-16: Vol 89 Iss 2307

Page 1

GENFP 4s! | IRRARY, The Nafkan *™ Bed % pire ; * VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2307. THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 16, 1909. PRICE TEN CENTS. New Macmillan Books of Timely Interest The New New York | ™*s- Schuyler Van Rensselaer’s By JOHN C. VAN DYKE rye : “* fap | Illustrated by JOSEPH PENNEL| 2 New York in the with 124 illustrations, including 26 | Seventeenth Century plates in color. | /n two 8vo volumes, gtlt tops, $5.00 net. | | Cloth, $4.00 net, by matl $4.22 x ' : # . f Che author shows how from the first the special function of the city was the trans- forming Europeans of diverse origin (not merely “transplanted Englishmen’’) into Americans. ‘‘ The author does not The most attractive book that has been | written about the ever-changing city. Even those who have known it from a | lifetime’s association are hardly able to keep up with the constant shifting which, attempt a political history or even a his- while piling up granite hills on lower! tory of the municipality; she writes a Broadway, is at the same time throwing | history of the city and its inhabitants, out a network of bridges, tunnels and trol- | showing how the way of the Revolution leys to and beyond its boundaries. Both | was prepared. She succeeds in her aim author and artist have felt the fascination and paints the life of the people on ail of the still young and growing city, and sides . . . in such perfect order as to see its promise of development on a scale | attract even an indifferent reader and which the world has never yet seen. | absorb his attention from first to last,”’ Its pages are like the informal talk of a} says Zhe Outlook. cultivated, thoroughly-informed man, giv- | ‘It seems impossible that it will be ing substantial information, and at the | superseded. From the day of its ap- same time entertaining and witty—a_ book pearance it takes rank as standard.” that will live as the best presentment of the —The Bookman. city in the opening decade of the twentieth ‘‘A work which no student of the pe- century. riod can afford to neglect.’’—7he Nation. The Wayfarer in New York The Picturesque Hudson An Anthology. With an introduction by By CLIFTON JOHNSON. EDWARD S. MARTIN. Fully illustrated from original photographs A collection of interesting impressions of by the author. An informal account of a New York in many different phases of its ramble along the historic river from its life, and at different times. mouth to its source. Cloth, 16mo, $1.25 net Cloth, 16mo, $1.25 net rutet THE MACMILLAN COMPANY = “%2%2."

Page 2

— os The Nation. JOURNAL. A WEEKLY FOUNDED IN 1865. {Entered at the New York City Post Ufice as second-class mail matier.] The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Kilmer More, Editor Three dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Can- ada £38.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Poatal Unton, $4.00. iddrese THB NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Ofice, 20 Vesey Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. rue WEEK 243 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The New Political Burope............ 2 \ Notable Quinquennium The Tariff Commission Harriman and His Time Art and Rallway Stations SPECIAL ARTICLES: the Bi-Cen- seseenseeeds 249 . 261 Thoughts Occasioned by tenary of Dr, Johnson News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE Measur e sve Meanings America.. Square Changed Dante in John But LITERATURE Contemporary France rhe White Prophet \ Charming Humbug ' The Patience of John Morland \ Slight Indiscretion Fleet Street and other Life of Friedrich List, from His Writings Introduction to Early Medieval Law : The Christian Doctrine of God eeee rhe Hand-book of Alaska Its Re- Products, and Attractions... 259 Poems........ 4 and Selections Welsh.— Welsh ources IENCT Mendel's Principles of Heredity 261 DMAMA ANU 262 oming Art Exhibition 263 of Great Corporations Books oF THE WrEEK did | The Paris at Brentano's 7 Lomion fu ! Stevens & Charing Cross Nation procured ina Opéra; in Trafalgar pies of may be Avenue de Brown, Square Nation. The [Vol. 89, No. 2307 Ed ucational. Educational. pce eda yo ‘enmasrs University Grade Graduate School of or and man Address the DEAN, 18 University Hall, Cambridge, Mace E FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Y heen Everert 0. Fiex & Co., Proprietors 2 A Par Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Pith Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 208 — Ave, Chicago 2925 wetland Bid., Portiand 405 C » Denver 2388 Dougi’sBid. _Asgeiee 618 Pert : Bid., ’ spokane 2142 Shattuck Ave., eley Send any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY WORCESTER, MASS. Established in 1856. An ideally bealtbfal location. Efficient taculty. Prepara- tion for the best institutions. The Rt. Rev. A. H. Viaton, D.D., LL.D., Visitor. For Catalogue please address 408EPH ALDEN SHAW, A.B, Headmaster. NEW YORK Day School 174 Fulton St. LAW SCHOOL Evening School New York City ‘Dwight Method’’ of instruction, LL.B. in two years, LL.M. in three years. High standards. Send for catalogue. GEORGE CHASE, Dean. I 3 BETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SOHUUL, Bethlehem, Pa. Prepares for leading colleges. Catalogue. H. A. FOERING, B.S., Headmaster. Just Published KAYSER & MONTESER’S FOUNDATIONS OF GERMAN SO cents Presents only the topics which are absolutely essential, and presents them briefly and clearly. It makes large use of “living grammar,” and thus enlivens the instruction, stimu- lates self-activity, and develops the feeling for correctness in speech. It lends itself excellently to conversa- tional practice. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and in any langu looked up in the Boston and Harvard libraries for echol- ars, writers, and others. Abstracts, copies, trans- lations, and bibliographies made. Proof-reading and revision of manuscript. Highest university and library references. MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. THE EMPIRE OF THE EAST BY H. B. MONTGOMERY. A simple but thorough account of Japan notable for its unbiassed standpoint. eee > Ns 16 illustrations. $2.50 By mail $2.64. A. €, Mec ‘LURG & Co., Chicago. The By GORK VY HOOKS. All out of print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me, stati books wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call and inspect my stock of 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, John Bright St., Birmingham, England. of Celebrities Bought and Sold. AUTOGRAPH Send for price lists, LETTERS SAE B. SGRauin. Pub."THE OCOLLECTOR.’’$1 a yr Professeur Université de France, ancien Directeur d’Ecole normale recoit éléves pour langue et littérature fran- caises, promenades, voyages et conver- sation. C. SCHUWER, O.L, M.H., M.M.., 11 RUE LIANCOURT, PARIS, XIV. MRS. LOUIS KINGSLY will take entire charge of six boys desiring to board in Washington and attend Mr. Preston's University School during the coming session. For terms and catalogue of school address ROBERT L. PRESTON, 1327 18th St., N. W., Washington, . CONVERSATIONAL FRENCH Self-instruction-—schools—families—or Americans desirous of becoming FRENCH TEACHERS. Muiled for 75 cents; to be returned if the work ts not satisfactory. E. ROTH, 1135 Pine St., Phila. Long’s English Literature By WILLIAM J. LONG. 8vo. 582 . Tilustrated. List price, $1.35. Frontispiece in 11 colors. The latest word in the study of English literature. The book is delightfully read- able, showing admirable judgment in the treatment of the different periods and ell the graces of a finished prose style. Every need of the student has been an- ticipated in the historical introductions, bib- liographical helps, questions, and illustra- tions. GINN AND COMPANY, Publishers 29 Beacon Street Boston, Mass. A NEW WELLS’ ALGEBRA The SECOND COURSE IN ALGEBRA, by Professor WEBSTER WELLS of the Massa- chusetts Institute of Technology, completes the high school work, continuing his popu- lar “First Course.” Half leather. 240 pages. $1.00. D. C. HEATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago JUST ISSUED. Cloth, $1.50 net. SAINTE-BEUVE By Prof. George M. Harper, Princeton University. J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO... Philadelphia. MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. SAMPLE COPIES The Nation will be sent to any address for three weeks WITHOUT CHARGE ADDRESS THE NATION 20 Vesey Street New York City

Page 3

"Slow SER" Seo wae, Sept. 16, 1909] The Nation. lil RECENT AND FORTHCOMING PUBLICATIONS OF sds. § D, APPLETON AND COMPANY = “%,™ PSYCHOLOGY AND THE TEACHER By HUGO MUNSTERBERG, Ph D., M_D., LL.D. Professor of Psychology at Harvard University. This book aims to take up the study of the school child, and to present the modern psychology of imitation, sug gestion, memory, attention, emotion, intellect, fatigue, and so on. Still further, it aims to be of use in the choosing of subjects, and for the teaching of all studies elementary and higher, for both xsthetic and manual education 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net. An Admiral’s Lo The New North By Rear-Admiral ROBLEY D. EVANS, U. S. N., By AGNES DEANS CAMERON. The travels of two retired. This volume begins where his “A Sailor’s Log” women down the Mackenzie River, from Athabasca stopped, and tells the story of his eventful career down Landing in Alberta, Canada, to the Arctic Ocean and to the present time. back by the Peace River. Illustrated from photographs. Cloth, 8vo, $2.00 net. 100 illustrations from photographs, &vo, cloth, $3.00 net Army Letters from an The Junior Republic: Its Officer’s Wife History and Ideals By FRANCES M. A. ROE. An excellent record of the By WILLIAM R. GEORGE. The founder of the Jun daily and eventful life of the wife of an army officer ior Republic tells of the inception of the idea, the devel in the far west thirty years ago. opment of the Republic, and its successful fulfilment Many illustrations, 12mo, cloth, $2.00 net. Illustrated, 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net The History of French Literature A History of German Literature By ANNIE LEMP KONTA. Mrs. Konta takes up the By CALVIN THOMAS, LL.D., Columbia University discussion of French literature chronologically from the Although the space is necessarily limited, the work is oath of Strasburg to the publication of Rostand’s a real history, dealing with all the phases of German “Chanticler.” 8vo, cloth, gilt top, uncut edges, $2.50 net. literature. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net A HISTORY OF THE PEOPLE OF THE UNITED STATES By JOHN BACH McMASTER, Ph.D. Professor of American History, University of Pennsylvania. This volume brings the work down to 1852, telling of one of the most vital periods in the history of the coun try. It includes the extraordinary growth of civilization throughout the land, as well as the Ante-Bellum controver sies, the beginnings of the West, and the great commercial and shipping development led by New England Adequately illustrated, 8vo, cloth, gilt top, per volume $2.50 net. Americans: An Impression Medical Sociology By ALEXANDER FRANCIS. A sound, impartial, in- By JAMES PETER WARBASSE, M.D. It is hoped forming book. A record by a thoughtful man who has that this book may help, in no small degree, to break seen America, not in a glass dimly, but clearly, with down the barrier between the physician and the public vision. Demy &vo, cloth $2.00 net. Large 1t2mo, cloth, gilt top, uncut edges, $2.00 net Elements of Transportation Francis Joseph and His Times By EMORY R. JOHNSON, PhD., Professor of By The Right Hon. SIR HORACE RUMBOLD, Transportation and Commerce, University of Pennsyl- for many years British Ambassador to the Emperor of vania. A brief course in Steam R. R., Electric Railway, Austria. A very important contribution to the political and Inland Water Transportation. history of Western Europe. Fully illustrated, t2mo, cloth, $1.50 net Sumptuously bound and illustrated, demy &vo, $4.00 net American Business Law Romanticism and the Romantic with Legal Forms School in Germany By JOHN J. SULLIVAN, A.M., LL.B., Instructor im By ROBERT M. WERNAER, Ph.D., formerly lectur er at Harvard University. An historical exposition and Business Law, University of Pennsylvania. A book that will prove of great practical value to business men a comprehensive study of the writings of the Romanti throughout the country. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net School in Germany. &vo, cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net Girl and Woman A Text-book of Nursing By CAROLINE LATIMER, M.D., M.A., formerly in By MARGARET FRANCES DONAHOE, Superinten structor in Biology, Women’s College, Baltimore, Md dent of Nurses and Principal of Training School, Phila A sane, wholesome, optimistic text-book for the guid delphia General Hospital. A thorough, working text ance of mothers and daughters. book, treating of all the varied duties of a trained 12mo, cloth, $2.00 net. nurse. Illustrated, 12mo, cloth; $1.75 net WOMEN IN INDUSTRY By EDITH ABBOTT The author traces the growth and development of the employment of women from the earliest periods through the establishment of the factory system, and down to the oresent day. She deals at length with women in all the various trades, and discusses the problem of their wages and of the present status of the working woman. Her data are based upon study of all sorts of writings and upon her own experience as a member of Hull House, Chicago Large 12mo, cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net.

Page 4

The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2307 THE DIARY OF GIDEON WELLES Now running in The Atlantic Monthly A Great Soul in Trying Days “Gideon Welles’s war-time diary, now running in the Atlantic Monthly, is one of the most important and interesting publications of recent years. Indeed, there has never been anything just like it. It gives a first-hand, close-by view of President Lincoln, the mem- bers of his cabinet, and his generals. “Welles, Lincoln’s Secretary of the Navy, was a keen, clear- sighted, shrewd old Yankee, who had been a Democrat, and was not in any of the political cabals from the outside; he was the man up a tree all the time. For the most part, the opinions of public affairs which Welles formed as he went along, and which he jotted down from day to day, have been justified by the searching light of time and of historical inquiry. His personal record of the crucial years of the republic is destined to stand as one of the foundation stones of the per- manent history of the period..—The New York Evening Mail, Saturday, August 28, 1909. THE OCTOBER ATLANTIC will cover the period from September 22, 1864, to April 12, 1865. The end of the war and the capture of Lee. THE NOVEMBER ATLANTIC will print the detailed ac- count given in the Diary of The Death of Lincoln. 35C. a COpy $4.00 a year The Atlantic Monthly Co., 4 Park St, Boston, Mass.

Page 5

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 16, 1909. | eral in Mr. Wickersham’s absence. Ac- The Week. “Controversy” is altogether too digni- fied a term to describe the miserable war of words that now rages about the Pole. The situation is deplorable. The most dramatic achievement in the scien- tific annals of the age is being written down in Billingsgate. The nation’s dis- accustomed ears ring again with the once familiar epithet, “liar.” which was striven for during three hun- dred years of self-sacrifice and heroic let loose the baser passions of men, and the interests of truth are made secon- dary to the consideration of newspaper scoops, Chautauqua profits, and book royalties. For this unhappy result we cannot hold Commander Peary entirely blameless. The provocation, from his point of view, must have been great. If the painfully-won crown of his life’s The goal cording to this remarkable brand of law, the canal zone, though owned, con- trolled, United States, is merely a “place subject to the and operated by the use, occupation, and control of the Unit- ed States,” and, therefore, the Payne- Aldrich tariff does not apply. Those cynical persons who believe that law- yers will give any opinion desired, will find this decision the occasion for much ribald laughter. The government wants to get its canal supplies cheap, so it the tariff denying that the avoids by , zone is a possession. There is no escap- devotion, once attained, seems to have work were really in danger of being | snatched from him by an impostor, the temper of his challenge to Dr. Cook might be excused. But faith in his own cause and in the ultimate triumph of truth should have lent him patience. If Dr. Cook’s story is a_ fabrication, Commander Peary must know that it could not stand the light of serious in- | Its im- the vestigation for three months. probabilities had struck against world’s suspicion even before the mes- sage from Peary came. That mossage has only given the signal for a 1ud- slinging contest. Both explorers may be reminded of the moral verse: Were I so tall to reach the Pole, Or grasp the ocean with my span, I must be measured by my soul, The mind’s the standard of the man. Happy Panama Canal Zone! Its status changes in a way to make the leopard’s spots envious. One day it is the posses- sion of the United States, and if any one else should undertake to plant a flag there, let him beware. The next day there is doubt about the permanence of our suzerainty, and to-day, behold! it is not a possession of the United States at all; that is, so far as the tariff law is concerned. This is the startling opinion of the eminent Trust-buster, | months or two years; | violation of the law remains. | steamship lines on export and ing the tariff swindle for the private citizen. He cannot declare himself a resident one day and a non-resident the next, and, therefore, he is bound to look on the government as a dodger A highly interesting turn will be giv- en to the investigation of the railway rebate abuse, by the government's in- quiry into the charges that certain rail- ways secretly and illegally cut the rates offered by them to certain transatlantic import freight. The evidence of such rebating, published by the World, appears to be conclusive; it is, in fact, admitted by the assistant general agent of one steamship company, Holland-America This agent alleges that the offence has the Line. not been committed by or in behalf of his own line during the past eighteen the fact The cor- respondence of the steamship company but of | in the matter, which has in some way | been obtained and published, is ex- plicit on this point. It mentions in one letter an inland freight rate agreed “ur upon, which is “5 cents below the tariff inland rate”; in another, that “tho re- bate to outports will be refunded month- ly on your side”; in still another, “a private rebate of 2 cents on the barrel” of imported fish, and so on in a great number of cases. In this same remarka- ble correspondence there is constantly displayed full knowledge of the ille- gality of the act and the penalties in- curred. If evidence of what was going on should fall into the Interstate Com- merce Commission’s hands, one ‘etter carefully points out, “we should be lia- Wade H. Ellis, now acting-Attorney-Gen- | ble to a fine of $20,000 in each case.” Clearly the result of such railway rebat- ing must be to give some shipper or im- porter, at the western end of the rail- way line, a secret advantage over all competitors. The fact that the rebate was granted, not to an in dividual, but to an ocean steam- skip company, hardly disguises the transaction in the popular view, and does not alter it at all in the eye of law Both the anti-Trust Law of 1890 and the Elkins Law of 1903 were particularly careful in providing against the very operations now under review The whole matter calls for investigation in the courts, from top to bottom The address by the new chairman of the House Banking and Currency Com- mittee, to the Pennsylvania bankers, was interesting because of its positive bank solution of our currency situation. Peo- declaration for a central as the ple in touch with the Monetary Commis- sion have for some time been aware that the judgment of the Commission's lead- ing members was veering in that direc- tion, and that the visit of a sub-commit- tee to the European banking centres, a year ago, had emphasized that drift of opinion. No formal conclusion has been reached on the matter by the Commis- sion as a whole, and Mr. Vreeland’s epin- ion must for the present be regarded as His official position it and there is reason to suppose that Sen purely individual. necessarily gives weight, however, ator Aldrich, occupying a similar place at the head of the Senate Finance Com- mittee, concurs in it. Mr. Vreeland does His idea is for a central bank with monopoly of not go very far into details. note circulation, with dividends limited to 4 per cent.—so as not to encourage excursions for the sake of profit into the field of competitive banking—and with what he describes as “some meas- ure of government control.” It is no final condemnation of the new primary law in Ohio that it failed to draw out a heavy vote at the first trial. With nothing but local offices at stake, the number of voters participating was, to say the least, far larger than ever known in the old caucus method. At Columbus, the Republican machine candidate for the Mayoralty was defeat-

Page 6

244 ed by a young man with nothing be- hind him except an admirable record, as City Solicitor, for hunting down gratft- ers. In Cincinnati, an adherent of the Cox machine took the Republican nom- the Democrats shattered the Bernard slate ination without opposition, but from top to bottom, giving a large ma- John W. Peck, a young attor- With Gov. Harmon giving an unusually popu- jority to ney of apparently good promise. lar administration, and the Democrats of Cincinnati seemingly awake to their opportunity, the disgraceful submission to Cox may yet go far to put the Demo- cratic party within reach of a general victory. In Cleveland, the primary showed that Tom Johnson is still the chosen leader of his party. The re- fusal of some citizens to take part in the primaries because of the necessity affiliation, The Ohio of stating their party was only to have been expected. law has its defects, for no State has yet brought forth a Legislature at heart de- voted to the discrediting of the party The ever, will hardly be verified. The voters boss. predictions of repeal, how- of Ohio will not permit a backward step without a fair trial of the new sys- tem. There can be no question that the Census Bureau is in earnest about keep- ing partisan politics out of its work. rhe dent's instructions in that matter with He letter to each supervisor commanding Director is executing the Presi- vigor and intelligence. has sent a him to resign from any political com- mittee of which he may be a member. Another point carefully considered by Director Durand is the question whe- ther any supervisor may possibly hold a State office which might debar him from accepting a Federal position. A similar difficulty, it will be remembered, arose Mr. special employee of the Attorney-Gen- when Heney was at once a eral's office, and assistant prosecuting attorney in San Francisco. It is, of course, undoubted that most of the ap- pointments as supervisors and enumer- Their “submitted” by Congressmen and local ators are political. names are chairmen, either as a reward for past party services, or in the hope of bene- fits to come. But the authorities are making it clear that one benefit which will not come is the taking of the cen- sus as an adjunct to party machines. The Nation. A question of no little interest in the South is discussed in a pamphlet en- titled “Public Taxation and Negro Schools,” by Charles U. Coon, white superintendent of schools at Wilson, North read Carolina. It embodies a paper the Twelfth Annual Con- in the South, some of the conclusions of which, when before ference for Education reported at that time, were received with incredulity by several of the Southern newspapers. In view of repeated threats to divide school races, and the insistence in many quar- funds according to ters that the negro gets more for his schools than he pays in taxes, it is high- ly important that the actual facts shall These Mr. lays before us as a result of a careful become known. Coon now study of the statistics of eleven States, with a population, in 1900, of 11,776,391 and 7,199,374 negroes. These same States now spend $32,068,851 an- whites, for elementary and secondary Of this sum, if it were distributed among the races according nually public education. to their respective numbers, the negroes would receive as their share $12,800,000, or 40 per cent. As a matter of fact, they received only $4,736,375 in all, or 14 per cent. The question follows whether this is largely a burden upon the white tax- payer. It is impossible, Mr. Coon says, to ob- tain complete data bearing on this mat- ter, but he has secured figures for Vir- ginia, North Carolina, and Georgia which enable him to settle it for those States with some degree of accuracy. Taking Virginia first, he finds, from the State Superintendent's report, there was raised in 1907 for schools by tax- ation $3,305,871, of which $489,228 went to negro schools. Analysis of the tax- es shows that the negroes paid $120,000 for poll $22,500 for State tax levies on property, and $68,895 in local assessments. Setting aside from the library fund, the State and local taxes on corporations and direct State appro- priations, the percentage to which the colored people are numerically clearly entitled, Mr. Coon is certain that they should be credited with $507,305 of taxes, or $18,077 more than they actual- ly receive from the State for their schools. In North Carolina the colored people should receive $429,197, whereas they now obtain only $402,658. In Geor- gia the figures are even more amazing, taxes, | Vol. 89, No. 2307 for there the excess in favor of the ne- gro is no less than $141,682. That is, the white schools profit by that sum from negro taxation. of the strikers at the Pressed Steel Car Company’s works at The victory McKee’s Rocks is really a triumph of common sense. The company has sur- the final wage question is left for arbitra- rendered on nearly every point; tion, but an advance is already given. Thus ends in deserved disaster the stupid policy of President Hoffstot and the other officials Now, after fifty-seven days, the strikers of the company. have all gone back to work, the com- pany is said to have lost $1,000,000 and, what is worse, has achieved the reputa- tion of being inefficiently managed and behind the times in dealing with its la- bor. As for the strikers, unorganized but with righteous demands, they brought a great company to its knees and have, we confidently believe, taught a salu- tary lesson to corporation managers every where. George Bernard Shaw continues to devote himself to his task of manu- facturing paradoxes. What the world, especially the world of culture and sci- holds to, is necessarily wrong. Just turn upside down what good peo- ple believe, and you have the truth, is Shaw’s simple formula. Among other things of which Shakespeare was artistically guilty was using blank verse—and bad blank verse—because he was not able to write good prose. To show us how Shakespeare should have done it, and how easy it is, Shaw wrote a play in the Shakespearean style. It is so good that no one will ever mis- take it Shakespeare’s; and, per- versely, they will continue to prefer the Bard of Avon, for they know no better. And now Mr. Shaw comes out with a denunciation of vivisection; not in the spirit of controlling it, so as to com- bine humaneness and the progress of science, but as a fling in the face of the scientists whose cock-sureness is a splendid target for a Shavian paradox. To succeed along his present line, Mr. Shaw would need a long and painful campaign of propaganda, the object of which would be to explain to the people the eloquence and beauty of the paradox as such—and then he might be able to ence, for

Page 7

Sept. 16, 1909] cram his particular absurdities down their throats. The return of the amateur golf cham- pionship to the West was generally ex- pected, though the Eastern representa- tives in the tournament fell by the way somewhat earlier and easier than was looked for. If Jerome Travers had been in form and had contested, the result might have been different. It is only fair to admit, however, that the young Western players have developed a very high quality of golf. Their medal scores are astonishingly low. When Gardner, who never before competed, can play two successive days in 146 and 147 for 36 holes, the pace is confessedly terrific. In previous championship struggles, Travis has been put out now and then in matches at 18 holes; but this usually thought a “fluke,” and it was said that no amateur could defeat him at 36 holes. But this year the matches have beeen at 36 holes, and the youthful beat the Travis rather easily. These dashing youngsters of the Western links seem was test Gardner veteran able to combine brilliancy with great steadiness. When they can do that, there can be no doubt that golf is pre- eminently a game in which youth will be served. Americans back from Piccadilly report the Briton to be in unwontedly hum- ble state. He feels his insular security vanishing before the aeroplane—in his case, a real “scareoplane.” The result of all this is a state of things that only a Carlyle could describe, in his familiar French Revolution style, with apos- trophes to budgets and balloons, con- scription and _ suffragettes, tortured wealth and gleeful Radicals. In his ar- ticle on Jean Paul in the Edinburgh Re- view of 1827, he said: Except by name, Jean Paul Friedrich Richter is little known out of Germany. The only thing connected with him, we think, which has reached this country is his say- ing, imported by Madam De Staél, and thankfully pocketed by most newspaper critics, that ‘“‘Providence has given to the French the empire of the land; to the English, that of the sea; to the Germans, that of the air.”’ But the threatened German empire of the air is, of course, of a kind not dreamed of in Jean Paul's philosophy. Lord Rosebery’s attack upon the Lib- The Nation. eral budget, in his recent speech at Glasgow, had been pretty thoroughly discounted, yet its political effect must be considered. The orator disclaimed any title to speak for the Liberal party; he was again in his favorite “lonely fur- row”; but his antagonism will count Liberal Merely as from a rich man, and a member of the Lords, mainly as that of a former Prime Minister. House of his assault upon a “popular” scheme of taxation might tend to make it even more poular, and so aid Ministerial supporters. its The Chancellor of the Exchequer is booked to follow Lord Rosebery in Glasgow at an early Mr. Lloyd-George will doubtless be tempted to turn to some of Rosebery’s day. published writings and discourses in the spirit of the latter's own statement, that the chief use of old speeches is to be In “explored for untimely quotation.” that the adopt for himself the words which Rose- way, Chancellor might bery applied to Sir Robert Peel, that he “preferred the fruitful task of admin- to the candor of criti- istration spent cism.” But on the crucial point of the right of the Lords to modify a finance bill, Lloyd-George could draw a deadly citation from a speech of Lord Rose- bery’s in the Gilded i*self. When the budget of 1894—denounceéd as socialistic a'most as fiercely as that of Chamber this year—came before the Lords, Rose- bery deprecated even discussion of the measure. His words were: I do not think it is necessary for the purpose of passing the bill that they [the peers] should make themselves master of it, because I deprecate altogether the idea that the House of Lords has anything do with money bills. Any discussion of it must obviously be academic, and therefore I should have thought the least said soon- est mended with regard to this measure. to This, of course, is no denial of the right of the Lords to reject a money-bill in toto, if they see fit, and so bring on a conflict with the House of Commons. That is not a question of power, but of political tactics, or of courage. Paul in L'Economiste danger of a tariff war between France and the United States. This arises primarily from the fact, that, in our commercial agreement with France, there was no clause calling for notice of its abro- gation. Consequently, under our new tariff law, the French agreement can be Leroy-Beaulieu points out Francais the 245 and is terminated on October 31. At that date, unless some other comm: rcial treaty is first negotiated, the expo:is of France will be subject in our tom houses to the maximum tariff sates. cus- Meanwhile, England and Germany, un- der the terms of their agreements with this country, are entitled to six months’ notice, so that for more than three months they would enjoy a tarilf ad- vantage in our markets over France. This is what critical for the makes the situation so French authorities, as also for the Government at Washington. If we clap on the maximum tariff upon French goods, France may make repris- als by applying her own maximum rates to American exports. The result could not fail to be disastrous to both sides, precisely as was the case in the tariff and Switzerland. war between France M. Leroy-Beaulieu strongly argues against any such policy. Prime Minister Stolypin continues to demonstrate his title to real statesman- ship. Not only by comparison with the average run of Russian bureaucrat, but with the best statecraft that Europe can show, he looms up large. It is no mean achievement to have steered a disorgan- ized Empire through anarchy to peace. The mon movement, by com- checked The transformation of to revolutionary admission, has been for years to come. the Russian system of land-tenure which he has set himself, is undoubtedly the most that any government is at present con- impressive economic scheme cerned with. Finally, there is the devel- opment and colonization of Siberia, a movement which is attracting much at- tention even outside of Russia. From 1906 to the year, 150,000 peasant families were colo- nized in western Siberia. In view of the large size of the Russian peasant fam- ily, this means the transplantation of close to a million souls from overcrowd- ed European Russia to a region of very high fertility. Statistics indicate that within three years the Steppes region alone may be in a position to export 50,000,000 bushels of wheat annually. Railway construction is being actively The development of the resources proceeds beginning of the present carried on. country’s mineral! more slowly, but geological surveys are going on all the time, and the future has almost limitless possiblities.

Page 8

246 THE NEW Announcement POLITICAL EUROPE. of the issuing of a Turkish loan of $30,000,000, draws atten- tion afresh to the extraordinary changes which the past year has wrought In the idea of the historic European equilib- rium. The intention of this putting of the Turkish Treasury in funds is to enable the new régime to consolidate its power. Old debts are to be paid off, in- demnities taken care of, the current budget made to balance, and the various departments of government reorganized. This of itself is sufficiently novel, but the really striking aspect of the matter of financial Turkey is the emergence from her old tutelage. We are told no more of a Concert of Powers dictaling the terms of the loan and presiding over the details of its administration. There is not even the rush of different nations to force money upon Turkey, as upon China, in order to obtain an equitable lien upon the national property. It is but one sign more of the break-up of the century-long theory of the balance of power in Europe—what Kinglake called the “Usage.” Bismarck once said that the problem of the Near East had an awkward /:abit of becoming acute at intervals of about twenty-one years. The Crimean war in the 50s was followed by the great Bal- kan explosion which ended in the Ber- lin Congress of 1878. But since then the unsettled question has disturbed the re- pose of nations at shorter periods. There has been no violent outbreak of hostili- except the Greece and Turkey, but the unrest in ties abortive war between the Balkan states has been chronic, mas- sacres in Armenia and Macedonia have diplomacy to not permitted European sleep, one “programme” after another has been adopted, like that of Miirzsteg In 1903, only to fail of enforcement, and then came the events of 1908 to make a complete finish of the old status quo. The doctrine to which the statesmen of Europe have outwardly subscribed for two generations is now an empty form. A moral revolution has swept its sub- stance away. No radical change in ter- ritorial alignment has been brought about, except the annexation of Bosnia- Herzegovina by the Austrian Empire— and that was little more than the recog- nition of an accomplished fact—but the entire atmosphere is different. The Chancellors and Foreign Secretaries of an earlier day would not know how to The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2307 breathe in the new air which envelops European diplomacy, to-day, in the pres- ence of the questions of the Near East. The man to whom the historians will doubtless give the credit, or discredit, of precipitating the new order of things is the Austrian Minister, Aehrenthal. His cool announcement last October, that Austria would thereafter regard Bosnia and Herzegovina as her Baron von own territory, really sounded the dvath- knell of the Concert of Europe, as for- Pre- ceded, as this was, only two days be- merly understood and observed. fore, by Bulgaria’s declaration of inde- pendence, it gave a shock to the old ar- rangements from which recovery has since been impossible. All the king’s horses and all the king’s men cannot put Humpty Dumpty back again. Baron von Aehrenthal’s audacity has been crowned by the event. The outbursts of protest which it at once provoked have died away. England took firm ground, and held a high tone. There had been a breach of the Treaty of Berlin, and the guardians of the public law of Eu- rope could not allow it to be sanctiuned. Sir Edward Grey put this before Parlia- ment and before the Cabinets of the Powers in the most emphatic way. At the very least, there must be another in- ternational conference to pass upon the bold initiative of Austria, and, if her act was not repudiated and disallowed, to make the usual “compensation” to the other Powers. There were the most con- fident predictions of a Congress of Eu- rope to be held this past summer. Plans had gone so far that place and time and agenda had been discussed. But nothing has come of it all. The talk of a congress has faded out. Germany's firm backing of Austria, together with what was practically her ultimatum to Russia, made it certain that Austria’s position at any meeting of the Powers would be unassailable. So the whole scheme appears to have been dropped indefinitely. But the work had been done. Old things had passed away in Europe, even if all things had not be- come new. As a well-informed writer in the London Times puts it: The restoration of the Turkish Constitu- tion, the proclamation of Bulgarian inde- pendence, the annexation of Bosnia-Herze- govina, the dethronement of Abdul Hamid, and the withdrawal of the international contingents from Crete, mark the close of the period that began with the Berlin treaty, and state in altered terms the prob- lem of the Near East. The necessary readjustments will take time and patience. Baron von Aehren- thal has been acclaimed as the new Bismarck. He is at least like that states- man in displaying moderation after a great triumph. Holding fast to what he has won, the Austrian Minister has been prudent and conciliatory in imeet- ing the new situation. From anything like a war policy, he has shrunk, being confirmed in that course, doubtless, by the aged Emperor Francis Joseph, who has had bitter experience of the truth that any war may easily prove a blunder and calamity, both politically and finan- cially. But there is no denying that Germany and Austria have become the centre of diplomatic interest in all that relates to the Eastern question. That again is proof of the remarkable change which has come over the face of E.1ro- pean politics. It may not be necessary to speak of rolling up the map of Europe, but though territorial possessions and names may long remain unchanged, the moral dislocation of the great Usage is undoubted. A NOTABLE QUINQUENNIUM. Five years, almost to a day, before Peary came out of the Arctic wilderness and began the now famous Battle of the Explorers, another battle was fought and finished on the other side of the world. It was actual conflict. Ja- pan had just beaten the Russian army at Liao-Yang in the first pitched battle of a war whose vast historical cuonse- quences we have not yet fully realized. Between two such surprisingly dramatic events as the triumph of Asia over Europe and the discovery of the North Pole, lies a short stretch of years packed close with notable achievements. The balancing of age against age and cen- tury against century, is rather a profit- less occupation, recalling the favorite topic of debate on backwoods platiorms, “Resolved, that Greece did more for civ- ilization than Rome.” There are some who, like Professor Walsh, believe that the age of faith, which many of us call the Dark Ages, marked the apex of hu- man attainment. The thirteenth cen- tury is to that authority the “greatest of centuries,” and he has written a book to prove it. Others have plumped for the eighteenth century because it contained in itself the seed of which the naine- teenth witnessed the fruition. But this

Page 9

Sept. 16, 1909] The Nation. doctrine of the seed may lead one too far away. It has led Dr. Walsh back into the Middle Ages; it might take us to the time of all beginnings. But reduce the comparison to five- year periods, and the game grows more absorbing. A half-decade largely ex- cludes movements, tendencies, and seeds, and deals with a certain number of concrete facts, which are easy enough to compare. Or, if origins and causes are eligible for the contest, these cannot be so many in number or so badly in- tertangled as not to be amenable to comparative treatment. There are not many five-year periods that begin sharp- ly and yet yield transcendent historical events. The first that suggests itself isthe five years of French history from 1789 to 1794. This calls up immediately the five years of American history from 1776 to 1781. pushing back our quinquennial incica- And so we may go on tor like the slide on a vernier, till it covers a significant period or single sig- nificant event—1688 in England, 1588 in England, 1492, Charlemagne’s crowning in 800, the five years after the battle of Actium, the five years from the cross- ing of the Rubicon to the tragedy at the base of Pompey’s statue, or the five years after Salamis. The present is at heart usually a humble age. For «Jl its loud complacencies, the passing day is always deferential to the past, and awed before the future. Even the most hardened of spread-eagle orators will hesitate to assert that the years 1904- 1909 will mean more in the history of civilization than the age of the discov- ery of America, or the age of American liberation, or the age that witnessed the death of feudal Europe. And yet what a magnificent record of progress is included between the Febru- ary day of five years ago, when the Jap- anese torpedo-boats threw themselv«s at the Port Arthur fleet, and the February day when Peary set out on his final dash for the Pole. The political and social results of the great war in the East have not yet been fuliy reaped. But already we can enumerate the admis- sion of Japan into the family of great Powers, the establishment of constitu- tional government in Russia, a Consti- tution in Persia, a Constitution in Tur- key, the promise of a Constitution in China, and the beginnings of self-gov- ernment for India. In other words, within five years nine hundred million souls have taken a highly critical step forward in their political evolution. The complacency of Christendom received a setback when, after pagan Japan, Mo- hammedan Turkey and Persia demon- strated the compatibility between a non- Christian faith and political progress. On a somewhat lower plane of impor- tance, we have the introduction of uni- versal suffrage in Austria and in Sweden; che dissolution of a partner- ship nearly a century old be.ween Sweden and Norway, and of a still old- er partnership, between the Church and the State, in France; the appearance of the British Labor party in Parlia- ment, with important consequent changes in the British government sys- the introduction of woman's suf- in Finland. In tem; frage the birth of a great British commonwealth in South Africa we touch once more on a mat- ter of capital importance. And then, of course, there is Science's North Pole may be of no prime scientific value, record. The discovery of the but simply as the successful conclusion of a three hundred years’ effort, the event is enough to signalize its age. It is only two years since land first «poke to land across the Atlantic without visi- ble medium, but already we are habit- uated to the miracle of the wireless. The is still longer it fresh to will predict. If it “conquest of the air’ us, but how much re- main so we dare not comes to balancing results, who vhall say that the beginning of human flight will bring less important consequences to civilization than the establishment of the American republic, or the birth of At always European democracy? bottom, we the towards the past and the future. humble But who shall begrudge a little outburst of that repeat, present is vanity now and then to an age can count, within the space of an in- fant’s life, conquests so great and chang- es so immeasurable? THE TARIFF COMMISSION. The appointments to the new tariff commission, made public on Saturday, are of a sort to argue that President Taft and Secretary MacVeagh mean bus- iness. They would not have sought the services of such men, unless they had intended the work to be worth while; nor could they have secured them for a merely ornamental or dead-and-alive 247 Emery of Yale, Prof. H. C. named as chairman, is an economist of He has kept his scientific knowledge close- With Reynolds function. recognized training and acuteness. ly in touch with actual affairs. him will be associated Mr. not the great Reynolds, but an Assistant the Mr. Sanders of Chicago, who represents the Secretary of Treasury--and practical agricultural interests of the West. mission, or whatever it is to be called, Thus we have a board, or com- which has at once a good balance and promise of efficiency. There has been a vast amount of words regarding the scope of this com- mission's activities. It is well known that the full plan for a scientific tariff commission did not find favor with Con- gress. Speaker Cannon would have of it. abhorrent to think of a body of experts none To his lofty mind, it was inquiring into the exact facts regarding cost of production in this country, and discovering the needlessness of giver tar- iff rates, except to make profits inordl- Even the truncated form of nate. i pro- vision for a tariff commission, repurted in the Aldrich bill, was further cut down in conference between the two houses. As the President's authority stands in the law enacted, it reads thus: To secure information to assi the Pres- ident in the discharge of the duties imposed upon him by this section, and the officers of the government in the administration of the customs laws, the President is hereby au- thorized to employ such persons as may be required Now, “this section,” of course, was section 2 of the Payne-Aldrich bill, deal- ing with the maximum and minimum tariff, and with reprisals against foreign countries. Senator Hale openly con- tended in the Senate that it tied the President’s hands, and prevented him from investigating, in an independent and thorough way, the domestic work- ings of any tariff schedule. On the other hand, Senator Aldrich maintained that the clause, as accepted at last, gave Mr. Taft tha: he the President ample power. himself declared, at the time, was satisfied with the outcome, since the language of the law, when “proper- would admit of all the inquiries that were contemplated uader the original scheme of a tariff commis- sion. That the President is still of that mind, was shown on Saturday at Bever- ly, when he said that he did not care what the new body was called, so long ly construed,”

Page 10

248 as it was fitted to do the desired work. Moreover, the official statement proves that the Administration does not feel it- self bound by Senator Hale's narrow in- terpretation. It runs: The Treasury these President and the Secretary of the the plan that constitute the authority to may be foreign have agreed upon three gentlemen are to board, and are to be given employ such special needed und domestic tariff experts as in the investigation of the In the nature of the case, it could not The tion 2 is to the effect that the President be otherwise. whole tenor of sec- must be “satisfied” that foreign coun- tries are discriminating against us in the matter of customs duties, or that the operation of their tariff laws is not “reciprocal and equivalent,” as com- pared with our own. This opens the whole question. No construction of the law can be so strict as to debar tne President full facts from trying to ascertain the The information he gets may not all of it be relevant exclusively to the subject of the maximum and mini- mum tariff, but is there any way of keeping him from making such use of it as he sees fit? It is his Constitutional duty to make recommendations to Con- gress from time to time. The more knowledge he has upon which to base such recommendations, the better; and also, we may add, the more imperative his obligation to press upon Congress the measures he believes to be for the good of the country. We shall doubtless very soon get an Taft's intentions, earnest of President or hopes. At least when he comes to ad- dress the people of the West, so dissat- isfied with the outcome of his efforts to tariff revised, he will take us get the into his confidence. Two things are cer- tain: one is that in his tariff commis- sion the President has a potent instru- ment for influencing public opinion and Congress; the other is that if Mr. Taft, his hand look back, would seriously damage his own reputa- having put to the plough, should now he not only tion, but would blight the hopes of his friends and of the great majority of the people HARRIMAN AND HIS TIME. Upon the personal side of the late E. H. Harriman, the tragic nature of his end would alone forbid us to dwell. Pale death knocking with equal foot at the door of his unfinished palace, and turn- his old age into a scene of eternal rest, sufficiently presses home the morai of the vanity of human wishes. Even en- be silent before such a mity would stroke of fate. Nor shall we stop to undoubted Harriman the discuss the nature of that ability which made Mr. great power he was in the railway and Such sults as he wrought do not come with- Suffice it to say financial world. impressive re- out adequate cause. that all the evidence points to h's hav- ing had a remarkable genius for com- bining forces and for associating vast He is admit- ted to have been as able a railway man accumulations of capital. as he was stock manipulator, giving as keen and far-sighted attention to physi- cal properties as he did to the securl- ties representing them. All this stands What remains to be asked, however, is the question how he fitted into the time in which he lived, cance, both social and political, of such written on his career. and what is the larger signifi- a course as that he ran. He came rather late in life to his ex- but he had been for some years under that fierce light which, beats upon men of great wealth. How traordinary promirence, in modern democracies, did Mr. Harriman meet the peculiar de- mands which the organized life of the world to-day makes upon men in posi- tions like his? change in the attitude of democracies That there has been a towards citizens possessing large for- tunes, and the power growing out of them, cannot be doubted. It is visible to all of us everywhere. The art of being a very rich man successfully, is nowa- days highly difficult. modern king think to get on by means of the autocratic and calloused methods of a mediwval ancestor, as that the own- er of millions to-day should fancy that he could safely imitate the ways of the Fuggers or the Medici. democracy has changed all that. As well might a Latter-day It puts the very rich in a class by themselves, and exacts from them a bearing and a discharge of certain public duties curi- ously Iike what the people of decadent Rome expected, as Mr. Dill has shown us in a fascinating chapter of his “Ro- man Society from Nero to Marcus Au- relius,” from the great proprietors of their day. It will not do to say that a deep popu- ‘Jar interest In rich men, and a kind of | Vol. 89, No. 2307 awed hanging upon their movements and their style of life, are absolutely new things in this country. When Tal- leyrand was in our young republic in 1794—the “good old days” of our pris- tine simplicity and purity—he found a worthy citizen of Machias, Maine, very anxious to go to Philadelphiatosee not Gen. Washington, who was well enough in his way, but a Mr. Bingham, “who they say is so rich.” Talleyrand added: “J'ai trouvé dans toute l’'Amérique cette méme admiration pour l’argent, et sou- exprimée.” There was, therefore, no great novelty in the concentrated public interest with vent aussi grossiérement which Mr. Harriman was followed in re- cent years. His downsitting and upris- ing were compassed about with report- News about him and inventions about him were read with absorbed at- tention by millions of his fellow-coun- ers. trymen. He stood as one of the chief symbols or his class—a name freely bandied about, abused more than he was admired, yet always a synonym of pow- er, possibly of danger, but unquestion- ably of social and political importance. The new thing in which Mr. Harriman had to face was not the observation, fawning or envious the conditions or merely curious, which has so long been fixed upon those having great possessions, but the kind of angry with which the public has watch men of his_ sort. scrutiny to A changed in regard to the ownership of enor- one of the things come community-consciousness mous wealth, is which not even boundless riches can afford The people quietly assume a certain sort of right to dictate to the very rich. From them are de- manded, or at least expected, large gifts for public charities. Their wealth is their own if they use part of it in ac- cordance with public opinion; otherwise there is a tacit sense of injustice and oppression in the mere control of such to ignore. vast resources. Moreover, and this is worth more notice, there is a pervasive demand that the magnate be magnani- mous; that he cherish neither enmities nor revenges; that b‘s business meth- ods be of a live-and-let-live sort; that he seek no undue power, for the further piling up of gold, through the secret purchase of politicians to do his bidding. Judged by these exscting tests, Mr. Harriman’s career cannot be accounted either happy or successful. He was born

Page 11

Sept. 16, 1909] The Nation. a generation too late. The imperious and ruthless methods which he too of- ten adopted, used to be endured in a Commodore Vanderbilt, in a Fisk or Gould, but they were obsolete even while Mr. Harriman was employing them. We say nothing of his chari- ties, for they may have been much larg- er than the public knows; but in his remorseless march to power over the wreck of other men; in his cold disre- gard of the human element in finance; in his impatience of criticism; in his elutching after and use of political in- fluence to further his business ambi- tions, he was really out of joint with his day. ART AND RAILWAY STATIONS. A few years ago it was the fashion to indulge in artistic sneers at the sky- scraper. Our Pharisaical painters pass- ed it by on the other side of the street. They turned, instead, to reaches and rocks of Brittany the barren or to the ruined castles of the Rhineland, as fitter subjects for their art. To-day it is a different tale. The office buildings of Manhattan, clothed in their wreaths of smoke and steam, our avenues, glisten- ing in rain-wetness, reflective of lights from arc lamps and shop windows, have become an almost banal feature of current magazines and contemporary exhibitions. They are, at last, recog- nized themes for the painter and the etcher, as for the artist in words. Now- adays, Ruskin to the contrary notwith- standing, there is also a moving beauty in our railways. The railway carriage has found its way into verse. Baudelaire, taken with a great horror of towns, cried out: Emporte-moi, wagon! enléve-moi, frégate! Even so, the poet thought it well to import a ship into his verse, to make it more conventional. There is Verlaine, to be sure; poor Verlaine, who, in his poem of the “Belle Chanson,” us to admire invites Le paysage dans le cadre des portiéres, but that is rather a different matter. Even Henry James has felt something of tae unexploited poetry of the rail- way. His confession of the kindness that he feels for stations is just what one had a right to expect: half whimsi- cal, half serious. He likes them #s- thetically, he tells us; with complacency, even when he would he views them neither come nor go. “They remind me,” he says, in one of his essays, “of all our reciprocities and activities, our energies and curiosities.” And the spec- cacle of Paddington or Euston offers an exhibition of variety in type which com- pensates him for having to live a part of his year in London. station was called a “deepo” and was an arcnhi- Time was when the railway tectural horror. In those days there was indeed much need to philosophize and transcendentalize if one was in the least to enjoy its “spectacle.” As we have watched the construction of the newest of the New York stations, we have, how- ever, felt that tne building of the past and that of the different matters. present are two very Just as the mystical imagination and aspiration of the Mid- dle Ages found their ultimate expres- sion in cathedrals which remain to-day, centuries after, the noblest monuments of Christian faith and of European civ- ilization, so is the modern railway sta- tion a kind of memorial and evidence of the vast energy and insistent utilitar- We what ianism of this twentieth century. live in the age of the machine; more proper than that we should ex- press ourselves in brick and stone dedi- cated, not to a Saint, but to the heroes of our Dusk of the Gods, demons Steam and Electricity. And the greatest temple to these demigods thus far erected is the building that fills four blocks in this city, and that will soon be sending its trains out to east and the twin to west, to north and to south, through tunnels that burrow under great rivers. We are proud, in our way, of our demi- gods, and of their celebrants. Sometimes, in viewing the pictures of our office-buildings, with their noses pricking the clouds, we have thought the artist’s work too cleverly managed for anything except effectiveness. The veils of smoke and of steam have been adjusted almost too coquettishly. There is at least no need to idealize these new for which we hope railway stations, some Monet will in time emerge. Monet has found Charing Cross and Montpar- nasse subjects worthy of the brush that renders the flower-gardens and the mists of his exquisite Giverny. Who will prove to be the Monet of Eighth Avenue? “I ’ would give anything,” Lafcadio Hearn once wrote, with London roaring in his ears, and his heart full of the bitterness of things, “to be a literary Columbus, to 249 discover a romantic America.” As to the matter of an America romantic for the man of letters, we dare not answer very positively. Sterne could discover the If, however, Laurence poetry désobligeante, why should not his liter- ofa ary heirs find it in a Pullman coach? And certain it is that for the painter a romantic America stands very close at hand. THOUGHTS OCCASIONED BY THE BI-CENTENARY OF DR. JOHNSON. I I suppose that I ought to begin this brief paper with Lichfield and the 18th day of September, in the year of our Lord one thousand seven hundred and nine, where and when the _ subject of what some persons regard as the greatest of all biographies was born into a world not soon likely to forget him. For reasons of my own, I wish to begin it at Oxford, and at a much later period. It is almost superfluous to say that there is scarcely another town of its size that calls up before the mind of a sojourner such a host of distinguished names as Oxford can summon from out the past. Keble, Pusey, Newman. with Sheliey for a counterpoise; Burne-Jones and Morris and Swinburne and Arnold and Pater, Freeman and Froude and Stubbs—these are names that to me almost at random, and they are all comparatively modern. Probably a true latter-day Oxfordian could not have written the preceding sentence without inserting the name of Jowett. | am not myself enough even of an adopted Oxfordian, despite many profitable hours I have been permitted to spend in the Bodleian, to venture to make a list, however short, of typical Oxford men whom every true son of the university should honor. All I am competent to do is to say that, whenever I go to Ox- ford, one great personality emerges from the unending file of its notable sons, and stands apart for my imagina- tion with a peculiar and extraordinary impressiveness. come II. Why is it that my thoughts and my feet always turn first to Pembroke Col- lege? Johnson said that in his day it was a nest of singing birds, but / afraid that the good Doctor knew little about singing. With Spenser, ton, Dryden, Gray, Wordsworth, Byron, and Tennyson enrolled among the sons of Cambridge, it seems to be as plain as anything can be in the realms of taste that the university on the Cam decided advantage over Oxford as nursery of songsters. If I were in a pessimistic mood with regard to the present and future of British poetry and wanted to walk among bare ruined am very Mii- has a

Page 12

250 - choirs where late the sweet birds cang, I should certainly desert the banks of the Isis for those of the rival river, and I should not need to reéxamine the con- tentious poems of Thomas Warton and William Mason before making my choice. But Oxford has enough great poets of its own to render so invidious a comparison unnecessary, and, as the of poetic charm, the nursery of poetic idealism, has this home of lost causes any real rival among institutions seat of learning? Dr. Johnson, however, was not a poet- ic or a charming personality, and he was far from being a representative idealist. The spell of the Middle Ages hangs about Oxford; Johnson is usually considered to have been a typical prod- uct of the eighteenth century. Oxford has been the alma mater of some of the greatest writers and scholars England has produced; it is open to doubt whe- ther Johnson was a great writer at all, and the quality of his scholarship was with its wide hardly commensurate range. Even in those features of his char- acter in which the stamp of his univer- sity is most clearly seen—his devotion to lost causes and his reverence for the Established Church—-Johnson seems less memorable than many another Oxford man. We naturally associate the great lexicographer either with Cranford or with the metropolis he so dearly loved, and probably many a modern reader who has a fairly clear idea of his per- sonality would be puzzled to tell offhand which university he attended, or whe- ther he received any sort of formal aca- demic education. Why in the name of all that is reasonable should Dr. John- son dominate the mind of any sojourner in Oxford? III. That he does dominate other minds than mine was proved for me a few years ago by a chance encounter with a fellow American in the smoking room of a smal! Oxford hotel. The source of my agreeable compatriot’s income, if I recollect aright, was that useful metal, copper; the source of his chief delights was Boswell's “Life of Johnson.” He carried about with him a handy edition, but he also carried enough of his fa- vorite book in his head to astonish such reticent Britons as he could manage to engage in conversations having his hero for theme. I am Inclined, however, to think that the average American visiting Oxford does not pack Boswell alongside of Baedeker. Doubtless Johnson's un- couth, portly form recedes from the imaginations of most visitors, native or foreign, a few moments after they have lost sight of the memorials of him pre- served at Pembroke College. For one person who in his mind’s eye sees him haranguing his fellow-students in a thread-bare gown or tossing away the mew shoes put in. charity at his door, The Nation there are probably dozens, who, as they move along the narrow streets or make excursions into the adjoining country, repeat to themselves phrases from Ar- nold’s preface or lines from “Thyrsis” and “The Scholar-Gypsy.” Any person likely to wonder whether Johnson ever returned to the library of Pembroke the copy of Lobo he trudged so many miles to borrow is still likelier to know the obvious facts in the case from Birkbeck Hill and to refrain from making in- quiries. Scores or hundreds of people go to Oxford yearly in order to manifest their veneration for Newman or Pusey; how many really venerate Johnson's memory there or anywhere else? Cer- tainly in no place connected with that memory will one see three spinsters standing in such dense awe as enveloped, one September afternoon, three mute worshippers at the Shelley shrine at- tached to University College. Those ladies—my countrywomen, I think— bent their eyes, now on the recumbent marble form, now on the star-spangled vault, now on their note-books, and I could not help wondering what use there would be in erecting memorials of questionable taste if there were not a fairly constant number of sentimental persons ever eager for a chance to wreak their emotions. It would be as easy, however, to sit comfortably on a barbed-wire fence as to wreak one’s sen- timentality over Dr. Johnson or any- thing connected with him. IV. But sentimentalists are not my game, and it is scarcely necessary to ddd that my reference to those three spinsters [ once encountered casts no reflection upon intelligent admirers of a poet whose genius in the sphere of essen- tial lyric poetry is almost unrivalled. What I am bent upon is to determine the reasons why, whenever nowadays I stand upon or approach a spot connect- ed with him, the burly doctor’s form fills up, if I may so phrase it, the land- scape of my imagination. I have never been to Uttoxeter, but, save St. Giles, Cripplegate, where Milton lies buried, there is scarcely a spot in England that could make more impression upon me than the market-place in the little Staf- fordshire town where Johnson, by stand- ing in the rain on the site of his father’s book-stall, expiated a youthful act of disobedience. That was surely not an heroic feat; from some points of view it was rather a foolish one. If the late Earl of Beaconsfield, or one or two American politicians who shall be name- less, had performed it, I should have been among the first to call it theatrical. In Dr. Johnson, it seems to be a pathet- ically impressive act of true filial piety, with the elements of sentimentalism and self-display eliminated. Why do I dissociate from Johnson whatever is merely spectacular, and why [Vol. 89, No. 2307 does the epithet “impressive” present itself spontaneously whenever I think or write about him? Loyal Johnsonian though I hope I am, I cannot but admit that he was little of a poet; that as a biographer he was surpassed by his fol- lower, Boswell; that he was not the greatest of British scholars; that, al- though the soundest and sturdiest critic of his day and still unrivalled in his common sense and probity save possi- bly by Dryden, he was not a very phil- osophical and acute judge of literature; that as an essayist in the strict sense of the word he fell far short of his pre- decessor, Addison; that as a writer of fiction, despite the solid merits of ‘ Ras- selas,” he is not to be compared with Defoe, or Fielding, or Richardson, or even with Goldsmith; that as a moral- ist he could well have afforded to ex- change some of his wholesome senten- tiousness for a little genial persuasive- ness; that as an editor of Shakespeare he was lazy and somewhat slovenly; that, finally, even as a lexicographer he was not entirely above reproach. Un- doubtedly, the Dictionary was a great achievement, and so was the “Lives of the Poets,” but, when he endeavored to tread the higher walks of literature, his gait was, to say the least, unsteady. The author of the “Life of Richard Sav- age” was also the author of “Irene,” a tragedy which I have not ventured to re-read within the past twenty years. I doubt if‘I ever shall re-read it, unless— to borrow an amusing remark of Long- fellow’s with regard to some forgotten or never-known poem—a special act of Congress is passed making such re- perusal compulsory upon me. We may smile approvingly at Garrick’s epigram to the effect that Johnson had beat forty Frenchmen and would beat forty more— we may add that he browbeat a much larger number of Englishmen; but we must admit that, when every allowance is made for his writings, they bulk small indeed in comparison, for exam- ple, with those of his great French con- temporary Voltaire. I value personally “Rasselas” and the “Lives,” “The Vanity of Human Wishes,” “London,” the stanzas on Levett, and some of the impromptu verses, many of the essays in “The Rambler” and “The Idler,” the preface to the Shakespeare, numerous letters besides the famous one to Chesterfield, and, last but not ‘east, the prayers and meditations. I value these, and I have reason to believe that in over twenty years of teaching I have helped to make others value them. But with all my admiration for Johnson, I must admit that he left behind him after a long life a very small amount, perhaps too small an amount, of excel- lent literature to serve as the basis of an imposing and enduring fame. His concrete achievements are neither nu- merous nor of an exceptionally high or-

Page 13

Sept. 16, 1909] der of merit. Even in his own club he was surpassed as a writer by Goldsmith, Gibbon, and Burke—perhaps by Bos- well, too—and he obtained in no single line save as a talker the preéminence of Garrick and Sir Joshua. Can it be that, after all, those persons are right who maintain that Johnson was not truly great save in his capacity as the Ursa Major of Gray—Gray the true poet, sen- sitive, lover of nature, charming letter- writer, and splendid scholar, to whom Johnson devoted the very worst of all the “Lives”? Can it be that they are right in asserting that the Cham of Lit- erature would not live in our memories to-day, had he not, most inconsistently, allowed a little Scotch sot to toady bim? V. That these hostile critics of Johnson are partly justified in their contentions cannot well be denied. If Hawkins’s biog- raphy had remained the standard, if the literary dictator had overawed into si- lence or nervous prostration Mrs. Thrale and Miss Burney, if he had used on Boswell’s obsequious head the club he bought for Macpherson’s, it is scarcely open to doubt that not one educated per- son out of a hundred would be greatly interested in Johnson in this, his bi-cen- tennial year, or would be familiar with his peculiarities and not ignorant of his works. On the other hand, it may be ar- gued that, while it is Boswell who has really made Johnson known in de- tail, it is Boswell and the infirmities of human nature that have obscured for many readers the essential greatness of Samuel Johnson’s character. Is our abil- ity to quote a man readily and to see in imagination the veins swelling on his forehead as he gulps his tea any proof that we really comprehend his personal- ity? Is not our interest in biographical gossip often satisfied at the expense of our appreciation of a life and character in their totality? In the case of the fa- mous doctor, do we sufficiently realize the fact that in the years before Bos- well’s narrative becomes copious, John- son through sheer mental and moral force and through solid acquirements rose from obscurity to comparative emi- nence, overcame poverty and physical defects that would have daunted most other men, maintained a stanch inde- pendence even in Grub Street itself, cherished his old mother and his scare- crow wife, made himself, as his means permitted, the almoner of the distressed, and finally became the commanding cen- tral figure of a group of exceptionally able men® Did Johnson dominate such men as Burke and Goldsmith and Rey- nolds and Garrick and Gibbon merely because he was a very gifted talker of -exceedingly bad manners? Were his pen- sion and the interview with George III, that so flattered his loyal soul, due in ‘the main to his political recalcitrance The Nation. and his ecclesiastical obfuscation? Could Boswell’s biography, as I have more than once had occasion to ask, possibly have been such a great book, had not its subject been a very great man? Has the English race in its entire history pro- duced many personalities as robustly and wholesomely impressive as that which emerges when Boswell’s biogra- phy and Johnson's own works are thor- oughly read and not merely skimmed? No one who will take the trouble to answer these questions—not hastily, but after some reflection and perhaps some refreshing of his memory—will be like- ly to be seriously indignant with me when I confess that, with John Milton set aside, I can think of no Englishman for whom I have a greater real venera- tion than I have for Samuel Johnson. Whatever he was or was not, one'thing at least he was—a man! W. P. Trent. New York. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES The bibliography of “Essay on Man” has never been properly worked out by any of his Indeed, the writings is Pope's editors and commentators whole bibliography of a half-explored field was the greatest English poet tury and his books rare show variations enough to lectors. Marshall C of years Pope's Yet he of his cen- enough and interest are col- Lefferts opportunity to number add collection of has for a lost variations to Pope’s works, and had planned a Pope bibli- ography, the however, now no edi- tions or his publication of which he has, definitely The following notes as to the editions and varia- abandoned tions of the “Essay on Man” have been, with his permission, made from his books. The poem was published in four parts or “Epistles,” from February, 1733, to January 1734. Each, it is said, was taneously in folio, quarto, and octavo, but it is the folio which is usually considered issued simul- the first edition, though the quartos and octavos seem to be even rarer. Mr. Lef- ferts has three of the octavos, but has never seen one of the quartos The first edition of the first Epistle appears in two forms, both having the title “An Essay on Man. Address’d to a Friend. Part I. Lon- don: Printed for J. Wilford, at the Three Flower-de-Luces, behind the Chapter-house St. The that the earlier has heretofore scribed It consists of signatures A, two leaves; B, B (repeated), C, and D, The title (verso blank) and “To the Reader” up the first The is paged [5], 6 and 9-20, 7 being omitted from the pagination Each page of text (except p. 5) headline “Epistles,” and the page number is in the outer corner. Only the first two pages have the couplets spaced apart. Only’ three copies are known to Mr. Lefferts besides his own, two being in collections in England (one lacking the title-page) and one in Chicago. The second form (heretofore con- sidered the first edition) ten leaves, signatures A to E, each two leaves Pauls.” form appears to be been unde- leaves, being leaf; two nine one and each leaves (two pages) make signature text and § has a consists of 251 title and “To the Reader” are identical The with the first and were doubtless printed from the same forms. The text is correctly numbered [5]-19. There are no headlines, and the page numbers are in the centre, as is the case with later editions of this Epistle, and with all the editions of the other Episties. The couplets are all spaced apart, giviag the book one more page than the first edition. It was printed on sheets than the other, with The the same wording, but the imprint the date, 1733 It printed from the second form described above, the 245-249 being repeated edition, larger wider margins first octavo edition has a title with contains was evidently as it contains same error in line numbers Though in a smaller type, it is page for page with No. 2, except that pages 17 and 18 each contain two lines and is mistaken in saying that the “Address to less page 19 four more lines Elwin the Reader” is not in the octavo edition. It is certainly found in Part | Another small octavo edition was printed but with different pub in Dublin, with title as the preceding styled “Second Edition,” lishers, and dated 1734 It was evidently printed from one or the other of the two preceding, though the error in the number ing of the lines has been corrected These four editions all designate the book as “Part I.” In the third folio edition the title is al tered to “An Essay on Man. In Epistles to a Friend. Epistle I. Corrected by the Au thor,’ with imprint same ag No. |! Th two-page address “To the Reader" of the earlier editions has been suppressed and new one of seven lines only substituted “Contents” of Epistles i, ii. and tii fill pp [4-6], giving the book eleven leaves \ number of changes were made in tt text This was probably issued late in 1733, b fore Epistle iv was published, but after the publication of Epistles ii and iil Another folio edition (actually the fourth) has the words “The Second Edition’’ added below the line “Corrected by the Author,” and has the date 1735 in the imprint It is page for page with the preceding, but is reset and has different printer’s ornaments. The first edition of the second Epistle has he title “‘An Essay on Man. In Episties to 1 Friend, Epistle II Printed for J Wilford, at the Three Flower-de-Luces, be hind the Chapter-House, St. Paul’s.”’ It consists of ten signatures A, B, C and D, and E, leaf up of title, and “To the [5]-18 colla London leaves, two leaves, one half-title, Reader,’’ each one leaf and text, pp The has the tion, throughout with different notable variation is the each made second edition but ornaments that in this uot numbered same is reset The second most edition lines are Wilford’s octavo edition of this part has title dated 1733, but is paged continuously from Part i, pp. 23-26. There is also a corresponding Dublin reprint called ‘Second Edition” with title dated 1734 The first edition of thé third Epistle has the same title as the second except for the substitution of “Epistle III.”" It also cona- sists of ten leaves made up of half-titl title, and text, pp. [5)-20. At the end is this notice in two lines: “N. B. The Rest of this Work will be published the neat Winter.” The second edition of the third Episti« though entirely reset, differs very slightly The vignette on the title of the first edition

Page 14

‘> ~~ St ‘> ~ has in the centre an open book, in this edi- tion @ spread eagle. The page numbers are in a larger type, errors in line numbers are corrected, and the notice at the end is in a single line Wilford’s octavo edition is paged 37-55 The lines are correctly numbered. The Dublin edition, with title dated 1734, has separate pagination, and, as it contains the numbers as the first that it was line may presume same errors in folio edition, we printed therefrom There was apparently but one folio edi- tion of Epistle iv. This, which has a title corresponding to the other parts, has twelve leaves, signatures A to F, each two leaves, made up of title and “Contents,” each one leaf, text pp. [1]-18, and adver- tisement “Lately Published the three for- mer Parts,” etc., one leaf. Mr. Lefferts has not been able to secure Wilford’s octavo edition of this part. In the little DublMn reprint called on the title the “Second Edition,” the errors in line numbering are corrected. The four Epistles were collected in 1734, in one volume, quarto, with continuous pa- gination, with title-page: “An Essay on Man, Being the First Book of Ethie Epis- tles. To Henry St. John, L. Bolingbroke London: Printed by John Wright tor Law- ton Gilliver, MDCCXXXIV.” This book has the appearance of having been extracted from another volume, but no edition of the works agreeing precisely with it can be traced. It is the only copy seen by Mr. Lefferts. It seems to be from the same forms as the “Work of Mr. Alex- ander Pope, Containing his Epistles and Satires,"’ 1737, on thick paper, but, while having the same title, it differs from the “Essay on Man” as included in “Works,” vol. IJ, 1735. The first edition with Warburton’s com- mentary and notes appeared in 1743, and later editions in 1745, 1746, 1748, and 1763. Corre d vorrespondence. SQUARE MEASURE. To THe Epiror or Tus NATION: Sin Among all the tables of “compound numbers,” which vexed our infancy and still resist the rational simplicity of the metr'« system, by far the worst is that one absurd- square measure.’ lineal base, the Intrusion of a fraction, 16% or 5%, between foot or yard and rod, must suspicion, as well as re- the childish mind. In like an attempt to reconcile four discordant systems. Certain- the square mile, acre, rod, and each larger unit utterly refuses to con- next smaller one, in square form ly miscalled Even in its alwaye arouse even in our looks sentment truth table ly as to foot tain the an integral number of times. The acre is the frankest allen, for it cannot be laid out square at all, save with a length of side incommensurable with any unit of length known to us Certain other pecullarities of this table are so Interesting, and to the present in- quirer at least so novel and puzzling, that he hopes some specialist can throw more light on ite origin. The mile, in all ite variations, both of extent and of name, from the late Greek The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2307 pier down, must no doubt descend from the mille passuum of the Roman legionary, counted with the left foot only. The Ger- man meile, used for a league or hour’s walk, is most in need of explanation. But even there the word, at least, is a perfectly nor- mal “guna” formation (m-a-ile), exactly like the English, from mille. The square mile is most simply and naturally divided*by successive quarterings. The first produces our quarter-section, or normal homestead; the second seems to have no important history, while the third is recorded in the old word “fur-long,”’ i. ¢., furrow-length; a real furrow, presup- posing of course not length alone, but area. The phrase “ten-acre lot” has a certain familiar and traditional sound in all ears. To the average mind it calls up a goodly expanse of turf or ploughed land, with an associated feeling of its natural or duly unified extent. Its normal shape is pre- sumably square. Now, I have yet to chance upon the farm- er, or citizen, who will give offhand, when first questioned, the exact side-length of that same familiar square ten-acre lot. Yet it is precisely the furlong, or normal length for a straightaway furrow. The most fa- miliar type of fleld, then, is the square furlong. Certainly that is no accident. And yet, the method of division is here violently changed. The square ten-acre lot cannot be cut up into square acres. Our decimal system cannot express the side of the square acre at all, in feet or inches, fur- longs or miles! However, the square furlong or normal lot can be cut up into two rows of five equal oblong rectangular strips, measurable in integral feet, each 230x132 feet. That is the acre. Yet the acre, though not obtainable by any quartering process, is itself promptly quartered, into roods. The Century Dic- tionary, which as to etymology was in- spired by William D. Whitney. most compe- tent of linguistic scholars, does not clearly differentiate the word “rood,” in origin, from rod. Yet there is at least a strong temptation to connect it with the special use of the form “rood” for cross (cf. Holy rood), and to call attention to the cross formed in the attempt to quarter the (ob- long) acre. Yet again we descend to the rod, which is obtainable from the rood, efter three bisections, only by cutting sets of five ob- long slices, much the same shape as is the acre when derived from the furlong. Of course, the rod can also be laid out in many other shapes, including the familiar square, 16%4x16% feet. But a square rood or square acre cannot be completely cut up into patches of a square rod each. So here again “square measure” is a glaring mia- nomer. But the question asked is: How came it so? Whence, in particular, the “acre’’? A few remarks on kindred topics may be added. The furlone is far more familiar to youth- ful ears to-day as the “220 yards dash.” One is tempted to Imagine for our ancestors a communal system of agriculture, in which every able-bodied man was given the use of a square furlong or ten-acre field, and so could race, on his own side the hedge, with plough or seed-basket, harrow or hoe, against any one of four conterminous ri- vals, to his heart’s content. Is that a purely imaginative sketch? The coincidence of this distance, the fur- long or 220 yards, with the Greek stadion is not, after all. remarkably close, but yet is hardly a mere chance. The stadion is exact- ly 600 times a Greek foot, and that unit differed only by 1-100 from our English foot. It is probable that the Greeks had ascertained by experiment that 600 feet is about the distance for which a maximum speed can be secured without a flying start. A hundred yards is too short to make up the initial loss in gathering speed; on the other hand, the limitations of breath and muscular strain forbid the continuance of the full sprinting pace for. e. g., a quarter mile. The Greeks did, indeed, also run races of several laps, but only up to a mile or so. The atrocities of the miscalled Marathon race, or grilling long distance run, as a form of “‘sport,”” they left to Hesperian bar- barism. In closing, a mention of one more exact Hellenic parallel may be ventured. If acci- dental, it is indeed remarkable. The all but perfect coincidence between the Greek and the English “‘foot’” has been already men- tioned. Another unit in wide usage, with no less clear physiological basis, is the cubit (Lat. cubitus), or rixyvs. The Greek, like the Latin word, is the ordinary one for “elbow.”’ Our “ell’’ has the same origin, but in “ell,” as in “yard,” the measure usually appears doubled. The sixvs, as a measure of of wood or stone, at least, long remained just about 1% feet, 18 inches, i. e., the dis- tance from the elbow to the extended finger- tip of a normal man. Now, our “rod” is just eleven cubits, 16% feet. The name rod, or pole, pretty clearly intimates that it is the length at which a man can conveniently handle a wooden staff or measuring stick. Since Homer is our fountainhead for all Hellenic usage, in his works a parallel passage is naturally to be sought. As a matter of fact, he ascribes precisely the same length, eleven cubits, to the noblest ash-wood rod wielded by human hands. Hector’s spear is twice mentioned as just “eleven cubits long.”’ Evidently this was the “handy” length, in war or peace. The rod, then, is explicable. But— whence the acre? Wa. C. LAWTON. Scranton, Pa., September 7. CHANGED MEANINGS. To THe EpiItorR oF THE NATION: Sir: I observed in a bookdealer’s win- dow a few days ago a set of school read- ers bearing the general title of “Stepping Stones to Literature.” Though Tennyson once wrote about rising on stepping stones, the use has a queer look to one who, for more than half a century, has considered the only function of stepping stones to be that of assisting the foot traveller to cross a stream dry shod, I don’t know whether any writer has treated the subject of such alterations in the meanings of words as are brought about by ignorant usage in the first instance; but from my observation of certain changes of this sort which are still in process, it seems to me that there is good reason for noting that written speech is subject to this sort of modification. Take, for instance, the

Page 15

Sept. 16, 1909] Ih The Natio words “lurid” and “livid.” I am unable to recall any example before the civil war of the use of these words in the sense respec- tively red and pale, as the daily newspa- pers seem to have decided shall be their meanings hereafter. We now read of the “lurid” flames of a devouring fire, and of the “livid” face of a corpse. Some diction- aries have already gone so far as to s.nc- tion these usages. In the list of proper names in the “Stan- dard Dictionary” I note the word “Franken- stein,” with the following definition: “Hero of the story; a man monster.” In Mrs. Shelley’s story of that name, poor Frank- enstein is the victim of the monster, inatead of being himself the monster; but if our dictionaries approve of the transfer of qualities as above, it will probably have to be accepted. That was what happened to “incarnadine,” which was used as an ad- jective in the following description of the phenix in Sylvester’s version of the “Di- vine Weeks” (Week 1, Day 5), several years before Shakespeare used it in “Macbeth” as a verb: Two sparkling eyes; upon her crown a crest Of starry sprigs more splendent than the A golden down about ber dainty neck; Her breast deep purple; and a scarlet back; Her wings and train, of feathers mixed fine, Of Orient azure and incarnadine. rest; Sylvester was intimately acquainted with the French language, and undoubtedly ex- pected readers to understand that the wings and tail of his phoenix were blue and light red, such as may be seen in the eastern sky a little before sunrise. In turning the ad- jective to a verb, Shakespeare also con- sciously or unconsciously deepened the in- dicated color to the hue of blood. To satis- fy my curiosity as to the original, I turned in the 1578 edition of Du Bartas to the cor.. responding lines and found that they had been much expanded in the _ translation. They are there as follows: I) fit briller ses yeus: il lui planta pour créte Un astre flamboiant au somet de sa téte: Il couurit son col d’or, d’écarlate son dos, Et sa queuvé d’azur. Sylvester not only changed the sex of the bird, but also gave it new “points”: as the incarnadine tint. The word “flamboiant,”’ occurring in the original lines, however, leads one to reflect that great modifications have been made in the signification of this word also. In a magazine just opened I find a notice of a contemporary swagger- ing romancer, in which he is characterized as flamboyant, In the French text, the word is pretty nearly if not quite synonyinous with the English “twinkling.” “Stalwart,” we are informed by certain etymologists, is a modification of the An- glo-Saxon “staelwyrdhe,” meaning worth stealing. If this view is correct, a great change has come over the face of the ex- pression. In the North American Review for month Senator Clapp talks of a ‘‘recrudes cence of interest’ in a political question Twenty-five years ago this would have been an incorrect use, but on turning to the “Standard” I find “revival” given as one of the definitions of “recrudescence.” Although it is not yet so given in other dictionaries it may be hereafter, and the user is probably excusable at this time. I am not forgetting ignorant transforima- tions of foreign words, like “el lagarto” into alligator; “purgatoire” picket- this into wire; “chassez” (in calling figures of dances) into sashay, and the like—but that kind of error has been often written about. My object at this time is to call the atten- tion of some investigator to a source of change in language that is likely to be more and more productive as our already immense vocabulary grows still larger. THERON W. HAIGurT. Waukesha, Wis., Sept. 1. DANTE IN AMERICA. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: A recent number of the Nation (Au- gust 19) contains a review of Toynbee's “Dante in English Literature,"’ and the re- viewer notes that no allusion occurs to the influence of Dante upon American writers. Oelsner, in “The Influence of Dante Upon Modern Thought,”’ refers to American devo- tees of the Tuscan bard only in a footnote, mentioning Longfellow, Lowell, Parsons, Norton; and your reviewer gives us the same names. Permit me to say there are other names not to be overlooked in connec- tion with early Dantean study. George Ticknor is probably the pioneer in this field. Ticknor, while studying at Géttingen, 1815, bribed Balhorn, a lawyer and Italian scholar, with fine Havana cigars, to in- struct him in Dante. Prof. Karl Férster de- scribed Ticknor as an excellent Italian scholar, who had translated from Dante as early as 1807. Ticknor’s journal refers to weekly meetings for the study of the Divine Comedy, heid at the house of Dr. de Crollis, in Rome, in the early thirties, About 1831 the American historian expounded Dante to special classes at Cambridge, Mass. In pre- senting King John of Saxony, himself a profound Dantist, with Longfellow’s trans- lation, Ticknor recalls the enthusiastic meetings of the Accademia Dantesca (1835-36) held in the Royal Palace, Dres- The lampada vite Dantesce, so to the historian of den. say, was handed on by Spanish literature to the historian of the Conquest of Mexico and Peru, and in the letters of Prescott are found some fine ap- preciationg of the genius of the divine poet. Just now discussion is warm upon the subject of priority in Polar exploits. The discovery of Dante is an interesting item in the annals of American scholarship: let us do due honor to those who first blazed out the path. WILLIAM KINGSTON VANCE Fresno, Cal., September 8 JOHN BUT To THE EpItoR OF THE NATION As a foot-note to the correspond Nation (March 25, April 29, anc “Piers Plowman,” 1 the extraordinary SIR: ence ‘a the May 13), concerning may be added that “John But” (who, Manly, wrote Il sion), may have been something more than a mere or minstrel, as Professo Manly says (Cambridge Hist. of Eng. Lit- erature,’’ II, 36), since the very name oc curs in the “Paston Letters,” attached to a person well above that rank Ryth Wyrchypful hwsbond, I recomawn me to zw, desyryng hertyly to heryn of zour welfare, praying zw to wete that I was with my lady Morley on the satyrday next after that ze departyd from hens, an‘ told her qhat answer that ze had of Jon according to Professor 56-99 of Passus x A-ver- scribe 253 Butt, and sche teke it ryth strawngely. (Margaret Paston to John Paston, Apri) 1448.) Johu Butt was evidently, as the contex' shows, a tenant or agent of Paston or Lady Morley. In any case, he lived in Bast Anglia, where the Morleys and Pastons fought their feuds out. It is not impossi- ble that he was the son or godson of the man who helped “Will” with his vision HENRY NOBLE MACCRACKEN Conn., New Haven, September 9 Literature. HANOTAUX’S HISTORY OF CONTEM. PORARY FRANCE Contemporary France. By Gabriel Han- otaux. Translated from the French by E. Sparvel-Bayly. With portraits Vol. IV (1877-1882). New York: G. P Putnam's Sons. $3.75, net. With this fourth volume, M. Hano- taux brings to a conclusion his remark- able narrative of French history since the war of 1870-71. It has, with the ad- vantages which belong to the work of one who has lived through the events and can recollect the tmpression which they produced at the time when they occurred, some of the disadvantages in- evitably incident to the writing of his- tory before there has been time for the full result of events to be perceived, before the smoke of conflict has cleared away, before the personal feelings of predilection or antagonism which nat- urally attach to the leading personages in the mind of the spectator have had time to subside. Only a Frenchman, and perhaps only an exceptionally well in- formed and impartial Frenchman, could determine how far these feelings have warped the judgment of M. Hano- taux, who has himself been a party man and a “minister § and been brought into close touch with some of the men most prominent in the political conflicts of the time he describes. To us, such feelings are dis- cernible, but M. Hanotaux seems to have tried to keep them within bounds. There are few traces of personal or party hos- tility in his portraits, or in the anec- dotes by which they are set off; and the partiality he shows for Gambetta is pardonable when one considers how much there was in that statesman’s character to attract admiration, how much in his fate to awaken sympathy. The period covered in this volume is six years, whereas the preceding three volumes, taken together, covered only sev- en. This gives it the character of being hurried, as compared with the leisurely march and copious details which longed to its predecessors. A large part of it, moreover, is ocenpled by foreign affairs, although in most of these the part of France was a secondary one he-

Page 16

254 The historical student will not regret the comparatively full treatment given to these general European questions, for they are matters of extreme maznitude, and M. Hanotaux, from the knowledge he acquired while in the French Minis- try of Foreign Affairs, is able to throw some fresh light upon them. They all re- late to the Nearer East. They include the in southeastern Europe, which began with the Herzegovinian in- surrection in 1875, which developed into the Servian war of 1876 and the aboitive Bulgarian rising of the same year. They cover, but do not sufficiently emphasize, the terrible massacres perpetrated on the Bulgarians by the Turks that sum mer, massacres which, after futile ne- gotiations between the Great Powers, brought on the war of 1877-78 between Russia and Turkey, and wound up with the Treaty of Berlin in 1878. They also note the occupation of Tunis by France in 1871, and just touch, with a disap- pointing brevity, the earlier siages of the process by which England was led to take sole authority in Egypt in 1882, France retiring from the so-called Dual troubles Control The chapters which deal wiih the Eastern Question from 1875 to 1878 are full of interest. They present the view of a well-informed diplomatist belong- ing to that one among the great Powers which took the least active part in the negotiations and controversies, and was in so far best qualified to judge the con- duct of the others. They also quote from two unpublished sources: the “Recollec- tions” of Count Peter Schouvaloff, who represented Russia at the English Court in these difficult years, and was one of the Russian plenipotentiaries at the Con- gress of Berlin, and the also unpublish- ed “Memoirs” of Karatheodori Pasha, who was the senior representative of Turkey at the same Congress. These two sources supply less than one might have expected, but some of the details given by Count Schouvaloff, who was a man of note in his day, and possessed of plenty of talent, have a certain in- terest, throwing a personal light on the attitude of the leading personages to one another M. Hanotaux does not succeed in mak- ing his account of the course of events during these three momentous sears 80 clear as might be desired by a reader who does not carry the main facts in his own mind. The chapters are rather a running commentary than a narra- tive. His appreciation of the situations and the action is always intelligent, but correct, and he omits or slurs over some material factors. For instance, although the outburst of feel- ing In Russia in the middle of 1876 Is referred to, the pressure of Russian public opinion on the Czar to go for- ward against Turkey, and the command- ing role of Katkoff and his news- paper, not duly brought out. not always are The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2307 This is still more the case as re gards England. It has often been said the Americans are the only people out- side England who can understand the English. It is especially hard for the French to do so. M. Hanotaux has not got to the bottom of the movements of opinion which swayed England during 1876, and the two following years. He has not quite realized that Disraeli, then Prime Minister, was inclined to fight Russia and would have liked to bluff his own Cabinet into war, but that the Cabinet, partly through their own bet- ter judgment of the real sentiment of the nation, partly because Gladstone had roused the nation against the Turks after the Bulgarian atrocities 2nd was always ready to fall upon the Ministry with his overwhelming personal force, contrived to hold the Prime Minister back and succeeded in preventing that complete breach with Russia which seemed several times imminent. It was, perhaps, not necessary for our author, in mentioning the Cyprus Convention, made by the British with Turkey, and the se- cret arrangements made by them with Russia about Batum, to point out the results (eminently disappointing for Eng- land) of these two acts, for they did not directly affect France. But they illustrat- ed so well the policy which Disraeli fol- lowed that a mention of them would have set his character and capacity for a great foreign policy in a truer light than they bear in the pages of this his- tory. The account of the Congress of Berlin is well done, yet it is odd not to find, among the dicta which M. Hano- taux records, Bismarck’s appreciative remark on Disraeli, “The old Jew, that is the man,” and the well-known char- acterization, attributed to De Launay, of Lord Salisbury as “a lath painted to look like iron.” As a patriotic French- man, M. Hanotaux regrets that France kept herself so much in the background during these struggles. Others may think that she exercised a judicious prudence. Her interests were not really affected. She had nothing to lose by the advance of Russia, and little, if any- thing, to gain by claiming a share of such booty as was going. It remains to be seen whether the acquisition of Bos- nia will turn out to the real profit of Austria. Assuredly the acquisition of Cy- prus has brought ne profit to Great Brit- ain. Without much effort, France did, in fact, secure one important acquisi- tion, viz., Tunis, for it was at the time of the Congress of Berlin that the Brit- ish Government intimated that they would give her a free hand there; and as Bismarck subsequently did the like, wishing (as is supposed) to turn her ambitions outside Europe, and perhaps also to heap on her fresh Iiabilities which she might find embarrassing, she presently went ahead, and, in 1881, made herself virtual mistress of Tu- nis, much to the annoyance and disap- pointment of Italy. In the chapters which contain the French part of this story of six years, the most striking and dramatic scenes are those which preceded and accom- panied the last struggle of the monar- chical parties in the general elections of October, 1877. “Monarchical” one may call them, because, though the form of government was not openly and avowed- ly in question, the Ministry of the Duke de Broglie and M. de Fourtou, which conducted the campaign under Marshal MacMahon, were virtually fighting for a monarchical restoration, and their defeat proved to be the coup de grice to every monarchical section, Legitimist, Orlean- ist, Bonapartist. It is true that the chances of Bonapartism were noi deem- ed to have wholly van‘shed (till the death of the Prince Imperial, Louis Na- poleon’s only son, in a skirmish in Zulu- land during the war of the British with the Zulus in 1879; nor those of the House of Bourbon till after the death, long afterwards, of the Count of Paris, to whom the rights of the Count of Chambord descended. Representatives of Napoleon the First and of Hen- ry the Fourth do, indeed, remain: but the pretensions of both have melted hopelessly away. The danger from a dictatorship which subsequently threat- ened France, in a year which lies later than the period covered by this history, did not proceed from any member of either line, and did not spring from any sentimental or traditivnal attachment to the monarchical principle. In M. Hanotaux’s pages, the hero of the combat and the victory which has established the Republic in France is Gambetta. Our author dwells with enjoy- ment upon all his oratorical achieve- ments, and brings the tale to a close when the short lease of power which the great popular chief had at last obtained comes to its sudden end. He faintly in- dicates, rather than ventures to describe, the causes which began to rob him of real authority as soon as he had officially secured it. This is a pity. Ganbetta’s eareer was brilliant enough and will be long enough remembered to permit even his admirers to disclose and explain the causes which weakened his infinence. Incidentally, we have an account of the singular series of communications which passed between him and Bismarck. Not long ago there was a lively controversy in Europe over the matter. Some one alleged that Gambetta had actually gone to Berlin and seen his mighty antago- nist. Others showed the improbabilities of the case. M. Hanotaux tells us that the meeting had been arranged for in 1878, and that Gambetta suddenly, al- most at the last moment, changed his mind, thinking apparently that in the turn things were then taking the pos- sibilities of gain through an adjust-

Page 17

Sept. 16, 1909] ment of French and German policy were not sufficient to justify the risks of in- jury to himself, which the interview, if it became known, might bring. There are in this volume some other portrait-sketches of an interest only sec- ond to that which Gambetta’s excites. President Grévy is painted with a keen and distinctly unfriendly hand. His gifts could not be denied, but the less attractive features of his charac- ter, his coldness and dryness, and that want of dignity and loftiness, which the head of a great state ought to possess, are dwelt upon. M. Hanotaux thinks his election to the Presidency was a mistake and that Gam- betta ought to have been chosen. He does not convince us. The qualities which evoke enthusiasm are not always those which call forth the sort of confi- dence and sense of stability which were needed, at the moment when MacMahon resigned, in the person who should suc- ceed him and hold all Republicans to- gether. Grévy excited less affection, or admiration, than Gambetta, but also less jealousy and suspicion. The comparatively brief sketches of Bismarck, Gortchakoff, and Schouvaloff do not add much to what students of the time already know. Those of Lords Beaconsfield and Salisbury present a picture which is neither complete nor correct. But where M. Hanotaux is on his own soil and has ample ma- terials, his delineations can be delicate and instructive. Such is that of Frey- cinet, the capable and resourceful man who never did anything brilliant, never made a mark, either as speaker or think- er, or as leader, yet constantly came to the front, because he had so many gifts as an administrator and so much adap- tability for Cabinet and Parliamentary purposes. Two other men who figured largely in those days, Jules Simon and Jules Ferry, are also touched in with a careful brush. No recent historian has realized better than M. Hanotaux how much difference in the evolution of events the personality of men makes. Whatever be the case in America, personality seems in the Old World to count for just as much in a democracy as it used to do in the despotic monarchies, though the persons who make the difference are, no doubt, more nume;sous Strong as is now the sweep of what are called the “secular forces and tenden- cies,” there has not been a moment dur- ing the last forty years in the chief European countries when the removal of two or three men in each country would not have powerfully affected the form and direction those forces were taking. Specially important for the peacefui tri- umph of the republican principle in France was the character of Marshal MacMahon. He was himself in principle a monarchist, and in religion a Ruman ‘Catholic. His wife was more ferv- The Nation. ent than he in both these re spects. His personal friends were nearly all of the same color. A less upright and loyal man, a more personal- ly ambitious man, would have played the role, if not of Oliver Cromwell, at least of Gen. Monk, and would have carried through a coup d'état in favor of monar- chy, for which it would have been per- fectly easy to find pretexts. But Mac- Mahon’s honorable instincts repelled all such suggestions He accepted ministries most distasteful to his own feelings, and when the ac- tion they proposed for his guidance became too repellent, he quietly re- signed. In this last volume. M. Hanotaux’s style retains all its vivacity and its fin- ish. One propensity, visible in the ear- lier volumes, becomes more pronounced, and, indeed, too pronounced, in this one: the love of epigrammatic phrasing. In some of his epigrams, though the words sparkle, the sense is dark; in others, the glitter scarcely conceals a platitude. Al though the translation is well executed, it may be that, in some of these in- stances, the expression has _ suffered a little in passing into English from a language which, like French, seems to invite epigram. Nevertheless, the ten- dency to state obvious things in a high- ly wrought way has in this volume come near to becoming a mannerism. Some critics may complain that in the sketch- es of men and the dramatic treatment of situations, the graver underlying ele- ments of politics receive too little atten tion. In such a criticism there would be truth, but it may be suggested that the time has scarcely yet arrived for a phil- osophic investigation of underlying causes. It is with regret that we part from this animated narrative of events fateful for France and for Europe, which so intelli- gent and well-informed an observer has given us. It is all the more valuable be- cause the events are so near our own time that all but the best memories, outside France, have forgotten the de tails. M. Hanotaux has probably done well to close at a time so far distant that the vehemence of party feeling re- garding the chief actors has subsided. Of those actors hardly any are still upon the stage. But we cannot but hope that he is even now composing a se- quel, bringing the story down to the beginning of the present century, which may, in another ten or fifteen years, be given to the world. The historian who comes fifty years hence to this subject will be grateful for the light whict. this contemporary observer, who knew the men and remembers the impressions of the moment, gives here, and will (we hope) give again, with so much grace and vigor. _ a +> ~ “1 CURRENT FICTION. The White Prophet. By Hall New York: D. Appleton & Co. An “author's note” prefixed this volume states that, contrary opin- ions drawn forth by its serial publica- tion, the narrative “is intended to be read as a work of fiction only.” The al- legation has been that real persons and events in recent Egyptian history are here shadowed forth: a supposition not likely to be disposed of by Mr. Caine's rather elusive disclaimer. However the story may be intended “to be read, readers will doubt that it was intended to be in some sense a portrait of the thing as it is. The phrase recalls a couplet aimed at Mr. Caine some years ago by a witty rhymester: Caine. to to few He sits in a sea-green grotto with a buck- et of lurid paint, And paints the thing as it isn’t God of things as they ain't for the This enthusiastic novelist’s verisimili tude could hardly be conceived as of actionable quality. In fact, he is a mor- alist, not a story-teller. He is not of those who present and interpret human life and character in the concrete. He deals in problems and situations; and his fictions are a of elaborate parables. But a parable should not elaborate; to clothe itself in the pings of realistic fiction is to deny birthright. However sound the of the present fable, the persons and in- cidents of it are preposterous. Great events and heroic emotions under- series be trap- its moral are stood to be involved. Not only the fate of Egypt and of England in the East, but the fate of Christian civilization is sup- posed to hang in the balance. The chief figure is Lord British Consul-General at Cairo, and vir- tual despot of Egypt. After many years of power, he has become purely arbi- trary in the expression of his authority. He has only contempt and distrust for the native character. His son, a bril- liant young soldier who has grown up in Egypt, has a very different point of view. He loves the Egyptians and their land, and has faith in her possible fu- ture as an independent nation. He is a colonel, second in command of the Prit- ish army of occupation, and betrothed to the daughter of his superior o‘ficer News comes of a later Mahdi among the Mohammedans, who is said to be stir- ring up sedition. Nuneham has dismiss- ed the Khedive from Egypt as a sus- picious character, and now makes up his mind that this ranting Arab, Ish mael Ameer, is a new danger to be put down. The son, Col. Lord, is ordered to Alexandria to attend to the matter that is, to apprehend the new popu- lar leader, and bring him, practically a prisoner, to Cairo. But Lord does not find the Arab a mischief-maker or politi- cal aspirant. He is a prophet of spir Nuneham, itual truth, quite as bitter against the

Page 18

256 degeneracy of Islam as against the cor- rupt European civilization which the English have imposed upon Egypt. He is bent upon the regeneration of the modern world, not upon the triumph of any creed or faction. His doctrine, his spirit, are strikingly like those of the Christ whom Western nations profess and fail to follow. The young soldier returns to Cairo not only without the expected captive, but as his expressed admirer. The Consul-General and the commanding officer are furious. Lord is given a command which his conscience forbids him to obey. Degraded and threatened with a court-martial, he leaves Cairo. From this point on the incidents of the plot are fantastic and melodramatic. The account of them is drawn out to the point of tedium: Mr. Caine has a habit of dwelling inter- minably upon his facts without really illuminating them. A Charming Uumbug. By Imogen Clark. New York: E. P. Dutton @ Co. It is extraor‘inary that wealthy hero- ines who go as substitutes for gov- ernesses in fiction continue to assume the names of the parties of the first part, instead of taking fresh ones. It is, of course, a practice helpful to the intricacies of a plot, and one that con- tributes heavily to its improbabilities; but as a device it grows nearly as shop- worn as the gun that isn’t loaded. For better or worse, we are in for it in the story of “A Charming Humbug.” Then we go on to meet that ancient foster- child of fiction, the little-boy-in-love- with-his-governess who intends to mar- ry her “when he is a man”—who at the first interview decides that her name, her purloined name, is “stiffish,” and is made happy by her confiding to him for his use “a little heart-name the people who love me call me.” This is the sort of boy who, for the most part wallowing properly in slang, has moments when he likes “verses with a run-up-and-down- your-back feeling in ‘em”: and who in the morning drive expresses his love of nature thus early It kinder chokes a_ fellow, don't it? Chokes him up till he finds out how rip- ping it all ts Ain't you glad to be alive in this bully old world, Gay? In continuation there must be round room for the gentleman guest who de- viees ways of being with the governess and the boy, and so on to the predes- tined end. There is little to separate the story from its kind, excepting in the episode of the true governess’s cler!- cal flancé coming upon the scene and precipitating disclosure. For the sugary and the pert that go to make such ‘ales, this one fully equals the average; and The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2307 harmless and reasonably amusing little novel. The Patience of John Morland. By Mary Dillon. New York: Doubleday, Page & Co, The Muse of History will some day arise and demand an accounting from the novel writers. That day draws near, one must think, when with Andrew Jackson's administration for background and with the cabals of his Cabinet for accompanying fife and drum, the affair of Peg O'Neal and Major Eaton is spun out into a checkered love story, as full of blushes, rogueries, curled eyelashes, woman's wiles and man’s misgivings as any mushy “storiette” of the periodical. Mrs. Dillon avowedly stirs fiction-stuff into the making of her hero and hero- ine, easing her own attitude in the mat- ter by giving them new names. Peg O'Neal becomes Kitty McCabe. Her first husband is changed from Timberlake to Sutherland; and her second, Major Eaton, Senator from Tennessee and Sec- retary of War, figures as John Morland. He it is who has the patience; he who saves Kitty from an elopement, endures her whims, befriends her and her drunk- en husband, and is at last rewarded by her hand, only to be plunged into the social embarrassments which helped to make the history of Jackson’s first Cab- inet. The disguise of names does not ex- tend to the other characters and thus we walk in and out on terms of affable familiarity with Jackson, Calhoun, Adams, Van Buren, Webster, and Clay. The result is as to fiction a readable but rather commonplace showing of girlish caprice and _ long-suffering chivalry; as to history, a group of names, a list of policies, a mir- ror of costumes, and a few scenes. Al- most desirable, if the historic novel is to persist, is Miss Miithlbach’s candid habit of indicating each fact by an as- terisk. The chief merit of the type after all, and by no means a small one, lies in its sending an occasional reade: to the real thing. A Slight Indiscretion. By N. Y. Homer. New York: Cochrane Publishing Co. “N. Y. Homer” is a prophet of viva- clous and cynical humor who speaks with the tongues of drummers, and has an honest ambition to record things as they are. American novelists as a rule (says he) blink the facts. They are afraid to concern themselves with the divorce and murder, which, as every newspaper reader knows, are the staples of modern life. Not so our Jeremiah: he has kept his eyes open, and his ut- terance has no uncertain sound. His story is, he declares, to be “a story of to-day, as we all see it among the high and low, the rich and the poor, the vir- tuous and the vicious; a story of life for elaborated conversation addressed to an unseen rallery, it is perhaps be- yond the required standard Ia its case, as in theirs, it all results In a try the sun ever shone on.” Its hero (and martyr) is introduced as the pro- prietor of a rural variety store. “He was liked by all with whom he came in contact; and his lady, well, she was hardly to be mentioned the same day with other women.” But the lady in course of time proved frail; acquired a lover, who murdered her husband, mar- ried her, and played the villain in the stock market to his own eventual un- doing. Justice is visited upon the murderer ard his wrongly acquired “lady.” She takes poison and he, not long after, is shot. Observation less biased by the testimony of the vews- papers affords, it may be, a more trust- worthy basis for the interpretation of American life; but the present attempt is not without its instructive and even engaging aspects. POETRY AND LIFE. Fleet Street and other Poems. By John Davidson. New York: Mitchell Ken- nerley. $1 net. John Davidson’s unhappy end gives this last book of his a special interest, and, indeed, it is in this case his death which offers criticism the better text of the two. For while there are poets whose poetry is something substantive and substantial in itself, there are oth- ers whose work is rather the comple ment of their sufferings and misfor- tunes, acquiring significance largely from their immanence in it, as a lake takes its light and color from the sky. While one creates of his superfiuity and leaves his creation alone to take its chances; the other labors to eke out his own existence and to repair in imagi- nation the short comings of reality. It is to this latter class that John Davidson belongs. In spite of much good, though curious, verse, without which we should be the poorer by a thing unique, the ap- peal of his poetry draws very much upon the humanity of its author—one, as he says with evident reference to himself, Who could rehearse Unheard-of things; whose thoughts were gray With travail, and whose reason scarce Escaped the onslaught of the universe: Yet one who waged an equal strife, And, unsubdued, beyond the sad Horizon of terrestrial life In noisome cloud and thunder clad, And death-cries of the past that bade Repent, above the galaxy Enthroned himself; and, sane or mad, Magnanimously claimed to be The soul and substance of eternity. Such is the Dichtung, the poetic spell he tried to throw around his life. In respect to the origin of his inspiration, it recalls the words of Browning's Cal- iban: Thinketh it came of being ill at ease; He hateth that he cannot change his cold as it really is in this, the grandest coun- Nor cure its ache.

Page 19

Sept 16, 1909] But for all its perversity—and that there is a kind of artistic and moral per- versity about it, cannot be denied—it is by no means commonplace or ignoble. The difficulty is that such a vision is impossible nowadays even as a literary convention. The contrast with ‘Wahr- heit and reality as it appears in mo- ments of depression is too irksome to be endured. Hence it is, perhaps, that the sardonic spectres of actuality, dis- solvent of illusion, in its crudest and most typical aspects—the mob and the complacent vulgarian, together with their favorite places of repair, the rail- way station and Crystal Palace, and the like—come more and more to haunt his consciousness and at once revolt and fascinate him. In particular, the intent of his ironic exhortation to the bricks of Fleet Street is unmistakable— Such an enviable fate As that of any single solid brick In Fleet Street, London, well and truly laid, A moulded, tempered, necessary brick In that most famous faubourg of the worl1, Exceeds our merits! Could we but attain The crude integrity of commonplace Cohesion even in the most exhausted, most Decrepit, ruinous, forgotten orb In some back alley of the Milky Way, How happy we should be! It is the same story of the two worlds of dream and reality and the chill awak- ening as is told in the melancholy words of his advertisement, spoken in his own person: The time has come to make an end. I find my pension is not enough; I have therefore still to turn aside and at- tempt things for which people will pay. There is, no doubt, much human stuff of superior quality which refuses to lie in regular courses; but alas for its hap- piness in a world of four-square—-“the hell of the unfit’! And when sickness and misfortune are added to these mor- al irregularities, the problem is insolu- ble. But this is not all. There are com- pensations for him who is willing to pay the price—and compensations, we may judge, of no mean order. There may be an exaltation even in defeat which raises such a neiure to an outlook above that of ordinary vision: When, naked, I wrestled with Fate, The Destinies trampled me down; I fought in the van and was great, And I won though I wore no crown, In the lists of the world; for Fate And the Destinies trampled me down— The myrmidons trampled me down. This is the better Davidson—not the mutineer, the révolté of “Cain,” with its wanton reversal of accepted values and its vicious confusion of achieved distinctions, but the remote and disin- terested observer of men, the satirist ironic and yet not wholly ungenial, the seeker of the picturesque in unlikely places, the riddier of cosmic riddles. It is for this singular combination of au- _The Nation. thorship that we should rather thank the poet’s thwarted sensibility—the sort of thing that finds expression imperfectly in “Two Dogs” and with characteristic fulness in the fifty and five gutter-merchants of “Liverpool Street” — Their eyes were fire, their wrinkles changed To shadowed sculpture in the brute Effulgence of the windows, ranged Together closely, foot by foot Like giant marionettes, as mute, As quick and as mechanical Fronting the shops, they made their sult By signs alone; and each and all Unhuman seemed, austere, asexual Life of Friedrich List, and Selections from His Writings. By Margaret E. Hirst, with an Introduction by F. W. Hirst. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2 net. List Is an economist whose literary reputation has lagged far behind the immense practical influence he exerted. The prophet of the German Zollverein and the German railway system, his works are not infrequently rated with those of second-class economists, when indeed his works are not forgotten al- together. Such an anomaly is largely righted by this vivacious story of his life, and sane appraisal of his writings. Peculiarly incisive is the verdict upon the American influences which mirrored themselves in his crowning work, the National System of Political Economy. List was a striking type of the fiery political refugee whose race has seem- ingly become extinct. Advanced early in life by the favor of the Wiirtemberg minister Wangenheim to a _ professor- ship at Tiibingen, he was elected a mem- ber of the Representative Assembly, and flung himself boldly into the struggle for internal freedom of trade. Prus- sia alone at the time had sixty-seven dif- ferent internal customs barriers, impos- ed duties on over twenty-seven hundred articles, and supported a customs force of eight thousand officials. List’s activ- ity in this project brought him into dis- favor, and, being condemned in a judi- cial action, he suffered imprisonment, and eventually, with his family, went into exile. In 1825, he reached America led to our shores partly through his ac- quaintance with Lafayette. He settled in central Pennsylvania, experimented at farming, and, failing therein, began the promotion of coal mines, railways, and canals. It was while in this country that he first clearly elaborated his distinction between national and cosmopolitan eco- nomics. He afterwards developed the idea in his National System. For a prim- itive community, he taught, free ex- change is dictated by the necessity of awaking the torpor of the inhabitants. Next a dose of protection is to be ac- corded to develop infant manufactures. 257 ~ Finally when these industries are ma- ture, they are to be exposed to world- wide competition under free trade in order to maintain their virility and ex- cellence. What List wholly left of his reckoning was the emergence of in- dustrial menopoly on the one hand, and the dogged selfishness of industria! in- terests which have once tasted the blood of consumers exposed by a tariff. As Mr. Hirst says in his introduction out Had he lived another half-century to see the American tariff on worsteds and wool- ens raised higher and higher he might have begun to question the working value of his theory. Instead of tariffs falling as industries grow, colonial, Amer!- can, and European experience tells us that the reverse is usually the case. List’s lasting influence for good was in securing interna] free trade and the Ger- man network of railways. List was “an inveterate visionary,” a “born journalist and agitator."’ His style was vivid, pugnacious, direct, and some- times slanderous (p. 124). With all faults his work has a singular charm. He was impetuous to the last Wolfgang Menzel’s description “his short, squat body a disproportionately large and lion-like head. His eyes sparkled, thunder played round his fine and his mouth was as fiery as the crater of Vesuvius.” His was a romantic figure, and his vio- lent end was almost an inevitable cli- max to his career. The author's presen- tation is well We have dis- covered but a single error, where 1787 is given (p. 38) for 1789, as the date of the first Tariff act. its degree. cited . crowned by is brows, exec ated. Introduction to Early Welsh. By Johao Strachan. London: Sherratt & Hughes Welsh Medieval Law. By A. W. Wade- Evans New York: Henry Frowde $2.90 net The early Irish language and litera- ture have received in general more at- tention from scholars than the early Welsh, but several important works of the past few months may be said to re- store for the time being the balance be tween the two branches of Celtic phil- ology. In the current Heft of the Zeit- schrift fiir Celtische Philologie, Prof Ludwig Christian Stern has published what must be reckoned the best critical study yet made of the works of the great fourteenth century bard, Dafydd ap Gwilym; and almost simultaneously with his important article there have appeared in England two works devoted to the Welsh language and law. There is especial cause for satisfac- tion in the fact that Professor Strach- an's work had been carried far enough, before his lamented early death, to be saved to scholarship. The author, in keeping with what we have already sug- gested is a common practice of Celtic

Page 20

258 specialists, devoted his earlier studies chiefly to Irish, and was recognized as one of the foremost authorities on Irish historical grammar before he undertook the extensive treatment of Welsh lin- guistics. The present volume was put together with great rapidity during the last months of his life, and bears here and there marks of incompleteness. But it presents a systematic survey of early Welsh grammar, the first to be publish- since the “Grammatica Celtica” of Zeuss; and Celtic scholars are fortunate in receiving so important a work from the hands of an acknowledged master. The texts which accompany the gram- mar were selected chiefly to give prac- include some mate- edited. ed tice in reading, but they hitherto unprinted manuscript rial, and they are admirably The glossary is a welcome addition to the scanty lexicographical resources of students of medi#val Welsh. The whole work has been brought under the supervision of Prof. Kuno Meyer, who has discharged his part, it need hard- ly be said, with the competence of a scholar and the fidelity of a friend. Mr. Wade-Evans’s book is chiefly of value as supplying students of Welsh literature and institutions with a scrup- careful text and translation of one of the law-books of the code ascrib- ed to Howel Dda. In the older edition of the “Ancient Laws,” Aneurin Owen, the was amalgamation derived from several versions. But the present editor has adhered to a single out ulously by text an manuscript tradition, that of MS. Harl, 4533, which is, according to the ex- cellent authority of Mr. Gwenogfryn Evans, the oldest and most important representative of the so-called “Book of Cyfnerth,” It is to be hoped that the other books, or local codes, may be made similarly accessi- ble Mr. Wade-Evans's translation, as he himself says, is necessarily tentative His introduction con- tains a careful account of the various manuscripts of the different law-books brief sketch of ‘Welsh history from the departure of the Romans down to the reign of Howell the Good. The historical doctrines presented are, some of them, to say the least, heterodox, and should be with caution. For fuller arguments defence of views which depart from received opinion, and which are rather dogmatically set forth In the present volume, readers should consult Mr. Wade-Evans’s articles in the Celttc Review (Edinburgh) for 1905. or Gwentian Code. In many places and a received in The Christian Doctrine of God. By WiI- liam Newton Clarke, D.D. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2.50 net. Something over twenty years ago, af- ter a period of long barrenness in the field of systematic theology in both Great Britain and America, there was The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2307 of outlines of Christian doctrine, which surprised and delighted by its original- ity and force, its discerning insight and gentle persuasiveness. The author was found to be a Baptist clergyman, then past middle life, who had been impress- ed into the service of a_ theological school as temporary instructor in dog- matic theology during the illness of the regular incumbent. These outlines were seized upon by teachers who felt that Hodge, Shedd, and Strong were wofully out of touch with the times, and yet who had no comprehensive treatise, alive to modern difficulties, to put in their place. Here at last was a sys- tematic theologian capable of doing thorough justice to every phase of orth- odox doctrine, yet a man of the present age, aware of the necessity of recon- structing nearly every chapter of the church's working creed. Of covrse, such a book could not be hid. Expanded and revised for general use, it was published under the title “Outlines of Christian Theology,” and immediately fell into high favor among moderate men of all communions, both at home and in Great Britain. One who chanced to be travelling in Wales the summer after it was published found it even in the bookstores of remote vil- lages. It is safe to say that no work concerning Christian doctrine of the last twenty years has had a wider or more wholesome influence. There is nc book which can be put into the hands of one inquiring about any phase of Christian belief with better prospect that he will find his difficulties met, in the form in which he sees them, with a spirit of honest candor, and with no small por- tion of clear, resolute thinking. Dr. Clarke was not released from his pro tempore professorship. Until the last year or two he has taught contin- uously at Colgate, and lectured both in England and America. His best work, lLowever, is done by the pen, and his cecasional lesser volumes, such as “The Use of the Scriptures in Theology,” “Can We Believe in God the Father?” have performed useful service. It has long been known that he was engaged in the preparation of a work on “The Christian Doctrine of God” for the In- ternational Theological Library, and high expectations have been held as to the character and value of the work. These hopes are now justified. The book in hand is easily Dr. Clarke’s magnum opus. The theme gave him a great opportunity, suited to his temper- ament and to the particular quality of his personal faith. The time is ripe, as many have been saying, for construc- tive work in theology. The religious life, of which doctrine is the outgrowth, is notably richer, sweeter, and saner than that out of which the older theol- ogies had their rise. Criticism has ex- discovered a privately. printed volume posed a thousand errors, and made it easier to avoid unfounded presupposi- tions. Sensitive to the good in both the old and the new, and responsive to the needs of the present, avoiding haste in preparation, Dr. Clarke has contributed to Christian thought an eminently rev- erent, thorough, and wise presentation of the best Christianity has to offer as conviction concerning God and His rela- tions to the universe and to men. The book is not an essay In theism. It is not a philosophical discourse on the grounds of theistic belief and defence of its reasonableness. It is not a sum- mary of biblical teaching concerning God, nor a criticism of the classical Christian symbols in so far as they at- tempt to define the divine attributes. One is struck by the absence of refer- ence to other writers in a work of such large compass, which handles the favor- ite theme of numberless theologians and philosophers. After a careful reading Paley is the only author whose name one remembers to have seen in the en- tire aiscussion. It is evident that the work is not controversial—the spirit as well as the form is irenic, and one would as soon think of quarrelling with the first Epistle of St. John as with Dr. Clarke’s essay. “We shall encounter views of God that we cannot accept,” he declares; “we may leave them, but we need not stay to slay them. The views of him that we accept should be borne in upon our souls by the tide of a mighty peace, and received in a calm- ness that has small place for contro- versy. The doctrine of God will fight its own battles, and the best that we can do for it is to set it forth.” It is a fair review of Dr. Clarke’s vol- ume to say that he sets forth the Chris- tian doctrine of God in this devout and gracious spirit. By that doctrine he means the conception of God for which Christianity now stands, that view of Him which “Christian faith and thought propose for the present time, in view of the Bible, and of the history, and of all sound knowledge and experience, inter- preted in the light of Christ the re- vealer.” He sets forth the sources of this idea of the divine being, in the an- cient ethical conception of the Hebrew prophets, in the life and teaching of Jesus, and in the growth of Christian thought and experience. He is bold enough to maintain that much that is truly Christian has come to light and full force since the Galilean life and the days of the Apostles. He sets aside, without rancor but with firmness, much that has maintained itself as Christian with high authority. He does not ar- gue, he is at no great pains to defend: he declares with the beauty of simplic- ity the sublime faith in the beneficent ruler of the universe to which heroic souls have been led under the mastery of him who taught the world to pray “Our Father.”

Page 21

Sept. 16, 1909] The Hand-Book of Alaska: Its Re- sources, Products, and Attractions. By Major-Gen. A. W. Greely, U. S. A. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2. Alaska has been so remote, and in many parts so inaccessible, that to the present day trustworthy data as to what it really is and contains have been hard to obtain. At the time of its ac- quisition it was generally believed to be an ice-bound uninhabitable waste. Some enthusiastic writers now paint it as a veritable Garden of Eden in its beauty and productiveness. Between these ex- tremes have come representations of the most varied character as to its availabil- ity for human uses. To the too often un- trustworthy Alaskan literature Gen. Greely’s book is a welcome contribu- tion. One of the most accomplished and experienced officers of the army, he has had extraordinary opportunities for be- coming acquainted with far Northern conditions. He has been head of the sig- nal service, twice military commander im Alaska, a frequent visitor almost since the date of its cession by the Rus- sians, not only a most intelligent observ- er, but an efficient agent in the country’s development. The book presents usually only facts and statistics, devoid of glamour. What wealth has been amassed by miners, farmers, fur-hunters, fishermen, and traders, is stated in figures taken from official documents. “Moderately success- ful” is a frequent phrase applied to en- terprises in all the various fields. Though millions have been gained, much of the effort hitherto put forth in Alaska has ended in disappointment. But while Alaska, as compared with many other areas of the United States, has a heavy handicap, it possesses unmistakably vast resources. As to one thing only does Gen. Greely allow himself superlatives—the magnificence of the scenery: for this he holds that the world elsewhere has no parallel. Modestly disclaiming for himself the power to describe, he quotes many glowing passages from others, en- dorsing as simply correct portrayals what the world has been disposed to think extravagant. We have read with especial interest Gen. Greely’s account of the native pop- ulation, among whom the Eskimos and the Aleutian Islanders are rude races unusually endowed with capacity and attractive qualities. It is painful to know that up to the present, white men have sought them mainly “for exploita- tion and debauchery’—a contact under which their numbers have dwindled and their character deteriorated. The land and sea animals upon which they de- pended for subsistence have been pur- sued by the newcomers almost to exter- mination, while liquor and licentiousness have done among them the usual devil’s work. Gen. Greely speaks cordially, The Nation. however, of the work of the mission- aries, of the educational work of some of the commercial companies, and gives a consoling picture of how the govern- ment, by successfully introducing the reindeer, is to some extent making good the destruction of the whale, walrus, and the seal. Notes. “The English,” Henry Seidal Canby of Yale intended to be a critical guide The publishers announce for publica- of the professor Short Story in by Prof in press, and an Henry now is historical Holt & Co tion this Novel,” English account also autumn “Masters English Richard literature of of Burton at the by University Minnesota Four Years and of “Travels of United will John Davis's a Half in the States (1798-1802),"" which be Henry Holt & Co scribed as the only book of the America published next month by has been de period writ- ten by a traveller in the United States the object of which is not so much sta- tistics as pure narrative This is not so remarkable when we remember that Davis was a novelist and a friend of Brockden Brown. The travels described extend from New York to South Carolina This is the narrative of which Trevelyan wrote in his “American Revolution” “An exquisitely absurd book, which the world, to the diminution of its gayety, has forgotten.” Prof. W. J. Ashley as editor, the Messrs Longman, Green & Co. aspublishers, prom. ise a new edition of Mill’s ‘Principles of Political Economy” in which will be indi- cated, with their dates, all changes in the text reflective of variation or development in Mill’s opinions The Putnams announce a new study of “Fernando Cortes and His Conquest of Mex- ico,”” by Francis A. MacNutt The same publishers are preparing, under the editor- ship of Katharine N. Birdsall, ‘“‘The Young People’s Book Shelf,”’ which to contain some twenty volumes of adapted to the understanding of the young, is verse and prose and intended to stimulate as well as to en- tertain. B. W. Huebsch announces for publica- tion this autumn a number of works dealing with the of socialism Thus, we are promised John Spargo'’s “The Substance of Socialism” and “Karl Marx,” as well as Edward Bernstein's “Evolution- ary Socialism: A Criticism Affirma tion,” transiated by Edith C. Harvey. question and The issue of a second edition of Dr. George Burman Foster's “‘The Finality of the Chris- Religion” (University of Chicago gives the publishers the opportunity announce that the second part of this work will be ready before the end of the year, and it has enabled the writer to cor- typographical errors, and to restate, his belief in a tian Press) to rect in a brief preface, religion.” “free On September 18 Houghton Mifflin Com- pany will issue the following list of books: “Robinson Crusoe,” illustrated by E. Boyd Smith; “The Oath of Allegiance, and Other Stories,” by Elizabeth Stuart Phelps; “The 259 New Golfer's Almanac,” by W. L. Stod- dard; “Oliver Wendell Holmes,” by Samuel M. Crothers; De Cesare’s “Last Days of Papal Rome,” transiated by Helen Zim- mern, and with an introductory chapter by G. M. Trevelyan; ““‘The Elements of Military Hygiene,’ by Major Percy M. Ashburn. The publishers of Laa Novedades, a week- ly newspaper of some standing, an- nounce that on October 1 will begin publication of the first Spanish daily news- years they paper to be issued in New York city The name of the new newspaper will be the Diario de las Novedades Among the books to be published this month by Charles Scribner's Sons are The Narratives of New Netherland, 1609-1664," a new volume in the series of Original Nar- ratives of Early American History, edited by Dr. J. F. Jameson, general editor of the series; “The First George in Hanover and in England,”’ by Lewis Melville; “Famous Women of Florence,’ by Edgecumbe Staley; “Society and Politics in Ancient Rome,” by Frank F. Abbott; Universities of Ancient Greece,’ by J. W. H. Walden; “‘The Problem of Human Life by Rudolph Eucken; “Church Unity,’ by Dr. C. A. Briggs; “The Mystery of Education by Barrett Wen- dell; “The American of the Future,” by Brander Matthews. Some of the illustrated books to be published by Scribners are an edition of “The Arabian Nights: Their Best Tales,” illustrated by Maxfield Parrish; W H. Wright's “The Grizzly Bear’; C. W. Murlong’s “The Gateway to the Sahara": and, for younger readers rhe Story of Rustem, and Other Persian Hero Tales by Elizabeth Renninger; The Boys’ Catlin,” and Dan Beard’s “The Boy Pioneers Students of Swift wil! appreciate The tattle of the Books,” edited by A. Guth- kelch (London: Chatto & Windus; in the King’s Classics) In the introduction the editor ranges over the battlefield of the quarrel between the ancients and the mod- erns, from Perrault and Fontenelle to Swift's “Apology,” 1710 The appendix Sir William Temple's Reflections’”’ Boyle's ‘Phalaris,” Dissertation,”” Boyle's ‘Second Dis- ard the exhaustive In another Eng- with 80 gen- The reader has before likely throw light one of the most genial, yet at the same time puzzling, of literary satires. Only at one point have we found the editor lacking. He has overlooked the interesting discovery, made twenty years ago by Feyerbrand, Englische Studien, XI, 487-491, that the end of the “Battle,” the Bentley-Wotton epl- sode, though printed by Swift as prose, is really for the most part in blank verse, One has only to read aloud -to catch the rhythm. This metrical structure accounts for the ironical grandiloquence of the dic- tion. The “Battle” thus anticipates l’ope’s “Rape of the Lock.” gives selections from “Essay,”’ from Wotton's (both Bentley's editions), from “First and Bentley's copious, “Examination,” The bibliography seems to brief lish erous sertation.”’ notes are us we do not remember prose classic furnished an outfit everything to him upon most In condensing the narratives of Henry Hudson's biographers, Thomas A. Janvier (“Henry Hudson,” Harper & Bros.) draws the conclusion that every important move in the explorer’s life “of which we have rec- ord seems to have a forced move, sometimes with a look of chance about it.” been

Page 22

> 260 To his mind, the element of fatalism is always apparent, particularly in Hudson's third voyage, “that evidently had its origin in a series of curious mischances, and that doing precisely what those him on it resolved that he should This was the voyage that led to of the river that bears The fourth voyage, too, predestination Hudson, detained and forced to serve only under ended in his who sent do 7 exploration not the Hudson's nami Suggests England flag, was sent out to his death in Hud- Bay with this Mr. Janvier produces for the first time contemporary which had re- mained hidden three centuries in the Record Office These are a valua- ble addition to Hudson memorabilia. Here- tofore, the of information con- the mutiny resulted in his the Larger Discourse” of of the Discovery's crew: only the sworn testimony that of five of his mates, definitely established that brought to trial, al- as to whether they way in which the Mr. Janvier Discovery's in her son's In connection voy- age documents, for in London sole source cerning which death Prickett, me we has been mber have not Prickett the fact is mutines now of but and the though there is no From the together, that the had more than a colorable Hudson, although it mutineers were interested in mak- rs were clue were punished testimony hangs thinks it probable crew grievance against is apparent that the for themselves Reprints” of Mon- Mifflin Co.) appendix ing out a favorable case The “Addresses and Daniel ¢ form, as it were a mway (Houghton documentary sting autobiography, published The author, a lad of eighteen, to his intere years ago earliest was written the yas an unquestioning participant in slavery Methodism. His whole polemic against and against dogmatic religion gives of early acquaint- strove to abolish; for t enabled him to speak h autho of the detected, it cured for him a sympathetic understand- ing of his foes which bred not only amenity sounder position than was of question of dogma could not be settled 1850, when lavery favorable evidence his ance with what he while in each case wi ty evils he in debate but a attained by some his fellow-crusaders. rhe like that of slavery by resort to arms, nor would Mr. Conway have had it so settled. It remained one of the great interests of his life. for he was one of the joyful, aggres- ve agnost of the mid-Victorian type, and the resort to arms was Indeed the point at which his attacks on injustice and in- humanity converged. All his other Interests, and they were many, were congruous with this, and if some of his quarrels with folly composed, and others grew old-fash- ioned, this one sufficed to keep him abreast of the idea to publish of that were generations. It was a good these selections from a reflected so many phases of the great period of change through which he lived to give the public a quickened memory of a courageous and warm-hearted body work personality As a tribute to the memory of Gen. Herk- helmer of Oriskany, and in honor of the hundredth anniversary of the great outpouring in 1709, an Instructor at Heldel- berg has published a history of the emi- gration the Palatinate (“Auswander- ung und Koloniegriindung der Pfilzer tm 18. Jahrhundert,”’ von Daniel Haberle). The emigration begun In 1709,and, renewed with two from Nation. The [Vol. 89, No. 2307 in 1757 from Wiirtemberg alone 1,000 emi- grants came to America, and others went to Russia, Galicia, and Spain. All southwest Germany was being depopulated, and the authorities tried in vain to stop the emigra- tion. The Palatinate, once the Paradise of vermany, gave its name to all German emigrants, so largely did it supply them. While Joseph the Second, at the request of the Rhenish princes, in 1768 forbade further emigration, Prussia, Austria, and Russia were secretly seeking to establish colonies of Palatines, and the rising tide carried many well-to-do peasants to America. In 1785 over 3,500 went into Austrian prov- inces, many of them Leibeigenen, i. e., serfs, without leave or license, and in all over 29,000, not counting children, left the Ger- man empire. In 1749 the records show that 2,785 came to America, and year after year the number increased, carrying with them money, household effects, and such valuables as they could. Hard as was the journey down the Rhine or across France, to the seaports for the trying voyage to America, it was less severe than the long and weary land routes to Eastern Europe. The ad- vertisements in Frankfort a. M. of Dutch emigration agents pictured in glowing terms the attractions of America, where friends and neighbors and relatives had made successful homes. Help was at last provided by the German Society of Penn- sylvania in 1764, by that of New York, in 1784, and that of Maryland, in Baltimore, in 1817, but much misery and suffering must have been the lot of the German emigrant. Dr. Haberle gives all of the recent American literature on this subject, and much material hitherto un- used, from local archives. His account of the recent Palatine emigration to eastern Europe is of interest. A number of maps, full bibliographical references, and a good index add to the value of his book as a of information for the growing number of students of German-American history. The celebration of the fiftieth anniver- sary of the Italian war has been impres- sive in northern Italy, where monuments have been dedicated on several battlefields, and Italian and French veterans have re- assembled The Italian journals have printed many articles, historical or remin- some of which possess more than passing value. One book, at least, deserves to be mentioned, because it gives the best popular account of the diplomacy which led to the French alliance and a vivid narrative of the brief, brilliant cam- paign. This is “Il 1859, da Plombiéres a Villafranca”’ (Milan: Fratelli Treves), by Alfredo Panzini. Signor Panzini draws from the most authoritative sources, French and Italian, and has the art of tell- ing a story without vitiating its value as history. For an introduction, he presents two impressionist studies of Cavour and of Napoleon II], and a sketch of Italy’s con- dition before 1859. Several welcome an- nouncements also come as an aftermath of the celebration; the Italian War Depart- ment is to publish in full the official re- port of the war; the journal of an alde-de- camp, hitherto printed anonymously in fragments, by Chiala, is to appear uncen- sored; and Signor Alessandro Luzio has founded source iscent, ready a new volume of essays. The alde-de- camp's diary, usually attributed to Robi- increasing force in i717, steadily continued: lant, and has been is of great interest much used by historians for the intimate reports it gives of many significant epi- sodes. It is to be hoped that now it will be printed without the suppression of any names or statements. An ambitious and successful book for the purpose of instruction in the French lan- guage appears in two volumes belonging to the Oxford Modern French Series, under the general authorship of Léon Delbos (Henry Frowde). Michelet’s ‘Jeanne d’Are,” edited by H. Sacret, is provided with a scholarly introduction, certain to stim- eulate the reader’s interest in the text; and with notes, mostly historical, which serve to correct Michelet’s inaccuracies and An- glophobia. Two maps illustrate the politics and the campaigns of Jeanne’s time. In- tended for students who read French with some facility, the volume will appeal espe- cially to those who in preparation for col- lege or otherwise have studied De Quincey’s “Joan of Arc,” which attacks this very book of Michelet’s. In the same series, Sis- mondi’s “‘Pavie et le sac de Rome” (part forty of his “Histoire des Républiques Italiennes’’) is edited by Arthur Wilson- Green. Both introduction and notes, other- wise commendable, are marred by the em- ployment of French forms for proper names in an English context, and by the awkward use of French English. The literary remains of Detlev von Lilien- eron are to be edited by Richard Dehruel. The first volume to come out will be a col- lection of short stories, a number of which appeared on special festival occasions in the Vienna Neue Freie Presse during the past three years. The several volumes will appear under the title “Gute Nacht.” No. 5107 of the Reclam’sche Universal- Bibliothek consists of a beautiful transla- tion of six short Armenian stories by Arvetis Aharonean, done into excellent Ger- man by Agnes Finck-Gjandschezian. These stories all deal with the sufferings of the Armenian people under the oppression of the Kurds and the Turks. The Armenian author, born in 1866 in Igdir, is the literary editor of the Armenian monthly Mudtsh, published in Tiflis, and has in recent years become popular through his numerous Ar- menian stories. Henry B. Blackwell, who died in Boston September 7, at the age of eighty-four, had been for many years a prominent advo- cate of woman's suffrage, as he was like- wise one of the few surviving militant abolitionists. Born in England, but brought to this country by his parents when only six years of age, and soon left an orphan in a family of nine, Mr. Black- well was early thrown upon his own re- sources, as were, in some degree, his sis- ters, Dr. Elizabeth Blackwell and Dr. Em- ily Blackwell, who were among the first women to enter the professional life. When one adds that in 1855 Mr. Blackwell mar- ried Lucy Stone, one of the earliest as also one of the bravest of woman-suf- fragists, it is evident how close were the ties which bound him to the movement; and how natural it was that he should suc- ceed, after his wife's death, to the editor- ship of the Woman's Journal, founded in Boston in 1870. In his editorship of the Journal Mr. Blackwell has been assisted by his daughter, Alice Stone Blackwell. Mr. Blackwell will be remembered also for the

Page 23

Sept. 16, 1909] active part which he took in the Free Soil movement. William Lioyd Garrison, son of the great anti-slavery leader, and elder brother of Wendell Phillips Garrison, a founder and so long editor of the Nation, and wide- ly known as a_ 0publicist, died at his home, in Lexington, Mass., on September 12, at the age of sev- enty-one years. Mr. Garrison engaged in business of one kind or another until 1901, but by nature and inheritance a re- former rather than a merchant. He was, furthermore, revealed in his multitudinous addresses in behalf of free trade, and the single tax, writer of clear English, vigorous in and cogent in statement. True to the fam- ily traditions, he man of unlimited moral courage with an abiding interest in was peace, as a style woman suffrage, was a every humanitarian movement the world over. Martin Ferdinand Morris, whose death at Washington occurred on September 12, was born in that city December 3, 1834 Four years ago he retired as Chief Justice of the Court of Appeals of the District of Columbia, having been appointed jus- tice of the court by President Cleveland twelve years earlier. Judge Morris was the author of “‘Lectures on the History of the Development of Constitutional and Civi: Liberty,”” and of numerous mono- graphs and addresses. Mayo Williamson Hazeltine, book reviewer and editorial writer for the New York Sun since 1878, and a frequent contributor to the periodical press, died at Atlantic City, N. J., on September 14. He was born in Boston in 1841, was graduated from Har- vard College in 1865, and subsequently studied at Oxford, and in the Harvard grad.- uate school, Later, he read law and was admitted to the bar. His books include “Chats About Books,” “British and Ameri- can Education,”’ and “‘The American Woman in Europe.” Prof. Heinrich Bassermann is the fourth professor of the University of Heidelberg whose loss has been recorded last month. The distinguished professor of pastoral theology, who was in his sixty-first year, was the author of a “Handbuch der badi- schen Gottesdienstordnung,” “Ueber Reform des Abendmahls,” and of other works. Science. Mendel’s Principles of Heredity. By W. Bateson. Cambridge University Press. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $3.50 net. This is the second of Professor Bate- son’s works with this title, the first hav- ing been published seven years ago as a defence against certain attacks which had been made by the late Professor Weldon on Mendel’s methods. In that earlier book the author presented some of his views in rather a tentative man- ner, and a few of these he now graceful- ly relinquishes. The whole subject has expanded so rapidly of late that it was quite time for a restatement of the es- sential factors by one who has done good The service as a pioneer. In 1907 Professor Bateson delivered a course of lectures at Yale University on the genera] sub- ject of genetics, the new term which cov- ers all matters relating to the origin of living beings. In the volume before us, the Yale lectures are not presented, since they will form, with enlargement arate But the gives in a concise manner the so-called Mendelian principles, with an admir- able biographical sketch of Mende! and a few hints as to the wide and numer- ous applications of Mendelism The of Mendel’s itself almost incredible. Nation. a 8e@p- treatise. present work work 1s in Mendel 1822. After a good training in the gymnzsium, history Johann was born in Austrian Silesia in he was admitted to the Briinn, under Gregor Mendel]. Later he University of Vienna, to mathematics and physics turn to the monastery, he Augustinian mo- the of the himself nastery at name Studied a devoting On began h's re- the re the impregnation of plants, with which his now His investiga- of more than eight years, and the results were faith- fully reported to a scientific society and published in their journal. The publi- cation bears the date of 1866. But the memoir attracted no notice whatsoever. It remained without any recognition (except one bibliographical note in a treatise on hybrids) for more than thir- ty years; nor did he ever in his life time realize that his researches would later be regarded as epoch-making. Now it happened in 1900 that at least three investigators came simultaneously upon Mendel’s buried treatise, and found that its results harmonized in a striking manner with their own. They had thought themselves to be pioneers, but they saw that Mendel had ed them. From that date Mendel’s o1me has taken its place in the ranks of orig inal investigators of the first «order, where it is likely to remain. Professor Bateson, like others who have examined the total neglect of Mendel’s treatise for more than thirty years, is at a loss to account for it. The reparation hag been tardy, but it is Pro{eesor Bateson presents a capital account of the course of events which led up to the discovery of Mendel’s work. It may be worth while briefly to trace these steps, especially as the sketch discloses 2 fact which general readers and many special students are apt to sight of. and which is too often overlooked by ama- teur naturalists. In the first place, it must be distinctly understood that the idea of evolution is very old, and that even some of the early philosoohers dreamed that existing plants and ani- mals had sprung in some way from sim- pler forms. Such notions are to be met with (as Professor Osborne has well shown in his “From the Greeks to Dar- in a more or less pronounced markable series of researches on name is associated covered a tions period preced- complete lose win”), 261 form, down to the time of Wallace and Darwin. But from the middle of the eighteenth to the middle of the nineteenth century, the scientifiC world was s0 com- pletely under the influence of the idea of fixity of species as definitively for mulated by Linnawus, that all naturalists who held a different view found it diffi cult to command a hearing. Some were even laughed out of court But 'u the years from 1825 to 1855, there were many engaged practically In the study of horticultural varieties of plants and their by hybridizing. It of experimenters extremely skeptical as to the But explanatica crossing or natural that should improvement was some these become limits and was of was permanence of species there as yet no satisfactory the origination of new species. It at this that the strong clue was given by Wallace and As soon as the naturalists realized fully the efficiency of this clue in leading out obscure places, it that had barely anticipated the same suggestion, and had fallen just short of it. Professor Bateson says that a num- ber of the practical breeders, who had lending Darwin period trom was seen many been working assiduously up to the time of the publication of ‘The Origin of Spe- cies” in 1859, continued their researches for a decade longer, and then abandoned the fleld. He remarks: In all that concerns the problem of spe- cies the next thirty years are marked by the apathy characteristic of an age of faith Evolution became the exercising ground of essayists. The number indeed of naturalists increased tenfold, but their ac- tivities were directed elsewhere Darwin's far exceeded anything that was thought before, that what should have been hailed as a long-expected taken the completed remember receiving from one the was waste of time achievement so possible beginning for work l of the friendly to study the fleld was well earnest of seniors most my warning that it variation, for Darwin had swept Yet a few began to reéxamine the de- grees of variation whether it might not be possible to express the grades with mathematical precision. By the beginning of the present century this work in was fully under way, and the twin of biometry and genetics were attracting to their service some of the most earnest biologists. It was at the outset of this activity that Mendel’s forgotten came, by a mere accident, to its and to see exact measurement sciences new work own A brief of of Mendel’s classical series of experiments will indl- cate the nature of his work and show why so much importance is attached to his methods and results. The word “methods” is better than “principles” in describing Mendel’s contribution to science. The genus Pisum comprises about six species, of Mediterranean and West account one

Page 24

<6 Asian origin But authors rec- ognize only two species instead of six, a fact which shows the ambiguous char- acter of the marks by which the species distinguished. One of the species, far the most common, is Pisum sa- some are by tivum, or common garden-pea, which is horticultur- ists have long since ceased to keep count of the commercial varieties, except those so extremely variable that which are in present use. Every seed- man's catalogue contains a memorandum of some of the well-established sorts, to- gether with the newest aspirants to favor. Mendel recognized the suitabil- ity of this common pea, and its nearest for a of inherited In the first place he says: relatives study characters The experimental plants must necessarily (1) possess constant differentiating charac- ters, and (2) the hybrids of such plants must, during the flowering period, be pro- tected from the influence of all foreign pollen, or be easily capable of such protec- tion Pisum plants answer these two condi- tions: they have a few characters which serve separate the different forms, and they are practically self-fertilized. Plainly, then, we have in Pisum a blos- som which can be studied from two points of view, namely, under conditions of self-pollination or self-fertilization, and of cross-fertilization, since we can let it alone or we can transfer the pollen artificially from one plant to another. And this is what Mendel did. For two years he “tried out his plants,’ so to speak, until he had procured some which “yielded perfectly constant and similar offspring: at any rate, no essential dif- ference was observed during two trial years.” Upon different specimens of this comparatively constant material, he experimented by all sorts of crossing and hybridizing How did Mendel’s work differ from that undertaken by many before and at his time, so that it has taken such a commanding position? Perhaps it is in this chiefly: (1) He selected the parent- plants with great definiteness; (2) he carried on his studies on a large scale and over a long period of time; (3) he kept most careful records of the pedi- gree from start to finish; and (4) he compared his results with the design of seeing whether such precise figures in regard to form, color, and 80 On, might not exhibit definite relations. He was so fortunate as to detect certain ratios. To illustrate these ratios, a sim- ple case described by a recent writer may be cited: to Rose Bantams are of two kinds, blacks and whites, and pure strains of either kind breed true. Now cross the black with the white. Instead of being of an Intermediate color, the offepring are all black like the ‘black parent. For this reason, black is said to be dominant to white, which is spoken -of as recessive. When the hybrid blacks are ‘bred together, they produce blacks and whites in the proportion of three of the

‘The former to one of the latter. The whites so formed, thenceforward breed true, and pro- duce no blacks, in spite of their black an- ecestry. The blacks, however, are of two kinds—(1.) pure dominants, which give only blacks when mated with a white bird, and impure dominants, which behave like the original hybrids when mated together, giv- ing blacks and whites in the ratio of three to one. Moreover, such birds when crossed with whites may be shown experimentally produce equal numbers of blacks and whites. Nation. to This simple case taken from the zvudlog- ical side, stands as a type of the in- numerable instances studied by Mendel, in the garden at Briinn. Repetition after repetition has only confirmed the dis- covery by Mendel and thrown light upon this the most obscure of biological pro- cesses. The Mendelian ratios occa- sionally fail in practice, but serve nevertheless as the basis of a pro- visional principle, upon which one may select new material for the ob- taining of definite results. Such sug- gestive work is a distinct contribution to science, and its general resuits are likely to be wide and very useful. Pro- fessor Bateson has indicated some of the lines on which the new suggestions can develop, and he has presented the sub- ject in a clear manner. We must wait for his Yale Lectures in a published form for a further amplication orf these useful suggestions. One thing will strike every reader of Bateson’s work, namely, the indifference of Mendel to the limitations of species. Mendel’s expression, as translated by Bateson, is: It has, so far, been found just as im- possible to draw a sharp line between the hybrids of species and varieties as between species and varieties themselves.

Since Prof. Carl Zehden of the Handels- Akademie of Vienna published the first ex- tensive treatise on commercial geography in 1871, nearly forty text-books have ap- peared in this comparatively new field. Of these, twelve were published in the United States, an equal number in Great Britain, seven in Germany, while the remainder may be assigned to France and Italy. In view of the recent of the study of commercial or economic geography in the colleges and universities here and abroad, the recent revision and enlargement of “‘A Handbook of Commercial Geography,” by George G. Chisholm (Longmans, Green & Co.), the only text-book in the English lan- guage adapted to the needs of the college student, is a matter of small importance, This is the seventh edition that has ap- peared since the work was first published in 1889. Many changes are merely matters of small detail; the really important one being the substitution of the latest avail- able statistics for those which had become out of date in the elaborate tables in the appendix, The present enlargement con- sists in the Insertion of an entirely new and exceedingly valuable chapter on Trade Routes, with maps showing the leading express and transcontinental railway routes extension

in Europe, Eurasia, and North America.

[Vol. 89, No. 2307 Besides, there is a large pocket map of the world, bearing the trunk line ocean routes, shaded so as to show their rela- tive importance. The latter was prepared by Prof. Max Eckert, who is the author of the leading work in German on Com- mercial Geography. Dr. Henry Cadwalader Chapman, fessor emeritus of physiology and biology at the Jefferson Medical College, Phila- delphia, died suddenly at Bar Harbor, Me., on September 7. Dr. Chapman was born in Philadelphia in 1845, and was a grad- uate of the University of Pennsylvania and of the Jefferson Medical College. Three years of study were also spent in Eu- rope. From 1875 he held a curatorship in the Philadelphia Academy of Natural Sciences, of which he was for forty-one years a member. He was a contributor to the medical journals, and author of “The Evolution of Life,”” “History of the Dis- covery of the Circulation of the Blood,” “Treatise upon Human Physiology,” and “Medical Jurisprudence and Toxicology.” Heidelberg has lost in the death of its professor of surgery, Hermann Lossen, a lecturer of distinction and the author of several valuable books—notably “Die Ver- letzungen der Unteren Extremititen,” “Grundriss der speziellen Chirurgie,” anu “Lehrbuch der allgemeinen Chirurgie.” pro- Drama and Musie.

Charles Scribner’s Sons announce for early publication four one-act plays by Suder- mann, which will appear under the general title of “‘Roses.”’ Announcement is made of the plans for the first season of the New Theatre, which will open on November 8 with “Antony and Cleopatra,”’ and will last about thirty weeks. Among the plays announced are “The Cot- tage in the Air,” adapted from “Elizabeth nd Her German Garden,” by Edward Knoblauch; “The Nigger,” by Edward Sheldon; “Strife,” by John Galsworthy, and Sheridan's ‘School for Scandal.’’ The company, when fully organized, will comprise about forty players. Among oth- ers this number will include Edward H. Sothern, Charles Cartwright, A. E. Anson, Albert Bruning, Ferdinand Gottschalk, Jacob Wendell, jr., Pedro de Cordoba, Julia Mar- lowe, Rose Coghlan, Olive Wyndham, Jessie Busley, Mrs. Sol. Smith, Beatrice Forbes- Robertson, and Thais Lawton. Louis Cal- vert, who was brought from London to pro- Guce the standard dramas, is an actor of great ability, as well as a stage director of long experience, and will appear in several important roles. Of equal eminence in their fields are George Foster Platt, producer or modern dramas; Wilfred North and Freder- ick Stanhope, assistant producers; Elliott Schenck, musical director, and Edward Hamilton Bell, art director. The production of “‘Macbeth” in France, not according to the artificial traditions of the stage, but amid the ruins of the abbey of Saint Wandrille, has been widely commented on by the French press. It was given before about fifty persons, the admis- sion price was $40, and the scenes of the great tragedy shifted from room to room In the castle, or in the “deserted heath” of

the grounds, following the natural order of

Page 25

16, 1909] Sept. the events. It was that feature—the rather “precious” attempt at an art novelty— which seems to have attracted the attention of the critics. Mme. Maeterlinck, as the originator of the idea, receives high praise for tickling the taste of the msthetic groundlings. Little, comparatively, is said about the French translation of the play, by Maurice Maeterlinck, which, to judge from some extracts given in the London Times, has unusual merit. He evidently has caught, at least in spots, the poetry of the original. That he realized the difficulty of his task is shown by his statement: The humble translators face to face with Shakespeare are like painters seated in front of the same forest, the same seas, on the same mountain. Each of them will make a different picture. And a transla- tion is almost as much an état d’dme as is a landscape. Frederick A. Stokes Company have an- nounced for early publication a new book for children, by John Prendergast—‘'Great Operas for Young People.” The put into simple language the stories of “Faust,” “Aida,” and ‘“‘Lohengrin.”” Writ- ten to be acted by children, as the ‘Great Operas” have been written to be read, ar writer has Constance D‘Arcy Mackay’s ten short plays in verse, “The House of the Heart.” The new operas announced for produc- tion during the coming season, either at the Metropolitan Opera the New Theatre, are: Blech’s one-act German opera, “Versiegelt,” Bruneau’s “L’Attaque du Moulin,” Converse’s “The Pipe of De- sire,” Franchetti’s “Germania,” Goetzel’s “Les Précieuses Ridicules,’’ Goldmark’s ‘The Cricket on the Hearth,” Humperdinck’s “Children of the King,” which will be sung in English and produced for the first time on any stage at the Metropolitan, Lapar- “La Habanera,” Lehar’s “Gypsy Love,” Leroux’s “Le Chemineau,” Paer’s “Tl Maestro di Cappella,”’ Tchaikowsky’s Dame,” and Wolf-Ferrari’s “Le Donne Curiose.’’ Further announcement is made that producing rights for America have bought in the several new operas, some of which are not yet completed. Among these are Debussy’s “La Chute de la maison Usher,” “Le Diable dans le Beffroi,” and “La Légende de Tris- tan”; Dukas’s “Ariane et Barbe-Bleu,” founded on the Maeterlinck play; Kienzl’s “Der Evangelimann,” Leroux’s “La Reine Fiamette,” Gustave Charpentier’s “La Vie du Poéte,” Nougues’s “Quo Vadis,” Ravel's “L’Heure Espagnole,”’ and Salvayre’s ‘‘So- lange.” House or at ra’s “Pique exclusive been case of The Boston Symphony Orchestra an- nounces its usual series of ten concerts in Carnegie Hall, New York. The dates are as follows: Thursday evenings, November 11, December 9, January 13, February 24, and March 24, and Saturday afternoons, No- vember 13, December 11, January 15, Feb- ruary 26, and March 26. As stated last spring, Max Fiedler will again be at the head of the orchestra. The soloists that can be announced at this time are: Gili- bert, baritone; Samaroff, pianist; Elman, violinist; Sembrich, soprano; Rachmaninoff, pianist; Schumann-Heink, contralto, and Hess, violinist. Two others will be named in due time. Sir Francis Brady, whose death is an- nounced from Dublin, devoted himself for The the greater part of his life of eighty-five years to the encouragement of Irish music The Royal Irish Academy of Music, found- ed in 1856, owed its existence to his efforts, and had his keenest interest to the last. He was the author of several songs and collaborated with Dr. Esposito and others in the arrangement of Irish melodies. Nation. Art. A COMING ART EXHIBITION. On the 20th of September, as a part of the Hudson-Fulton celebration, there will begin a month’s exhibition of paint- ings at the Metropoltan Museum of Art, which as a symptom of taste and a prec- edent for the future is of great import- ance. It is a collection of fine paintings of the Dutch school, for the most part loaned by the private owners; and com- prises about thirty of the best Rem- brandts, four or five beautiful Ver Meers, and several of Franz Hals’s, Ruysdaal’s, and Cuyp’s. In addition, there are good paintings by the lesser men of the Dutch school, giving to the collection a representative character and enabling the amateur of taste to see and feel adequately the eloquence of one of the great periods of art. Tke acquisition of beautiful European works of art by Americans has been too often taken as a mere manifestation of the power of money. Without money, indeed, they could not have been bought. But there are plenty of rich collectors in England, Germany, and France, who would not have grudged the money any more than have the Americans. Mucb greater credit is due to the American's energy and growing taste than to his pocketbook. His energy is proverbial, and perhaps some day his taste will be. The existence of a beautiful collection such as that about to be exhibited in- dicates that this energy and desire for the acquisition of art knowledge are ex- tending beyond the artists to the peo ple. And such an exhibition is not only a symptom of the rising taste and knowl- edge of the community, but is a condi- tion without which modern art cannot lift its head. Creative art is an intense- ly traditional thing. It connects itself at every stage with what has gone be- fore it. Raphael would have been im- possible without Perugino, and, in gen- eral, the Renaissance of Italy could not have existed without ancient mod- Art is an application of known forms and traditions to the new life of the time. We often hear complaints from our artists to the effect that mod- ern work is neglected and misunder- stood, that living American artists are not sufficiently encouraged—a wail nat- ural enough, but thoughtless, for the public cannot be expected to desire or appreciate painting, of the traditional els. 263 basis of which it has no knowledge. The beauty cannot be felt, in other words, without the atmosphere. So that the bringing to America of old and new European art, far from harming our art- ists, is rapidly forming a miliew in which they may connect their creative ideas with traditional rorms understood, and therefore appreciated, by the pub- lic. The new art cannot come except on the basis of the old; and first, of course, what is old and classic must be known and felt by the people The International Studio (John Lane Co.) brings out “The Master Painters of Brit- ain,” edited by Gleason White, late editor of the Studio. It is a picture-book, pure and simple, the text being entirely insig- nificant, and its interest is that of a review of two centuries of British painting. In spite of the inclusion of a few Americans like Whistler and Sargent, the faults and sirtues of the works shown are typically British. Some of these painters are artists and some of the artists are painters, but al- most al! of them are picture-makers, not producers of studies—that is the best and the worst of them. We may call attention to the large amount of useful information to be found in “The Photographic Annual,”which comes to us in a fifth edition, from Tennant & Ward It has been revised and extended by the editor, H. Snowden Ward Gertrude Burford Rawiings’s “Coins and How te Know Them” (Stokes), as a hand: book for the study of numismatics, will be found usefui. In dealing in one volume of 374 pages with the coinage of ancient Greece and Rome, of mediwval Europe, of the Brit- ish Islands and their dependencies, and of the United States, the author had of neces- sity to forego all detailed descriptions. But the history of coins in these various coun- tries affords interesting comparisons be- tween their various products and shows in how far they influenced one other. In treat ‘ing the Grerk coinage Miss Rawlings has revised the geographical arrangement adopted in the standard books, such as Head's “Historia Numorum,”’ and instead of beginning with Spain and working her way eastward, she begins with Asia Minor, then takes up European Greece and Italy, working back by way of Africa to Syria, and India This arrangement doubtedly corresponds more closely to the chronological but it is some- what disturbing not to have the same order as that adopted in the standard books and museum collections, because thig handbook is in no wise independent of them; it has very few illustrations, and the short de- scriptions of the various types are of course insufficient to give the student a clear idea of the appearance of the coins, unless he has a coin collection or well-illustrated work to refer to. In adapting the interior of the Pantheon to its recent uses ag a royal tomb, the late Giuseppe Sacconi, in 1904, removed from one of the chapels a fresco, which he attributed to that rather commonplace artist, Antonizzo Romano. Neglected for years, this fresco has recently been ‘‘piec- ed together” and cleaned, and now, Ven- turil, Corrado Ricci, and other Italian crit- Persia, un- sequence;

Page 26

264 ics, attribute it to the hand of Melozzo da Forli, and describe it as a rare and mag- nificent work of art. It is not yet acces- ible te the public, but an authorized re- production shows a lunette, representing descending in rays from God the Father, and, below, a large Annunciation of the Virgin, in which the Archangel ap- pears in the moment of checking his ad- and half falling in reverence be- the Virgin His figure, rather than the Virgin’s, seems to show the combina- tion of vivacity and religious feeling char- acteristic of Melozzo. The next number of the Bollettino d’Arte will discuss, in de- later attribution, and will con- pertinent illustrations. Are fail comment upon that such treatment of an important work of art is possible in a national monument under the very shadow of the Ministry of Education, at Rome. the Dove vance fore tall, this tain several lovers can hardly to this evidence Nicole and Gaston Darier, Profa. Georges of Geneva, have published an account of their discoveries in an illustrated mono- graph entitled “Le Sanctuaire des dieux Orlentaux au Janicule’ (Rome, Imprimerie Cuggianl) Their excavations of last win- ter brought to light the remains of two temples, one built about the beginning of the fourth century above that erected, as in inseription proved, at the end of the relgn of Marcus Aurelius § {fn spite of dili- ent research, the statuette of a goddess found in the triangular altar, or consecra- tion stone, of the inner, octagonal cell, Professor Nicole of Gnossus, till remains unidentified mpares it with a statuette serpents the Ephesian this statuette, The other stat- vhose tiara jis surrounded with which like bound in swathing clothes are identified as Dionysus, Hades, and black Egyptian king, epresented Attention is called o the frequent allusions in late Latin, and to the in- forms of arrange- ind recalls coins on Diana is represented, (that in basalt) an as a god writers strange Oriental to the and their entrances of the evidences of persecution the pecially in satirical of hip at Rome; cells iring upon the secrecy troduction wor unusual ment of the and ts be rites; which gilded to the ilted of in preserving intact Dionysus Follen McKim, founder of the firm of architects of McKim, Mead & White, ident of the of Ar- hitects Architectural Academy of Design, Museum of Art, the Ac- ia di San Lucea of Rome, and of oth- 14 at in Chester tatue Charles American Institute and member of the the tropolitan ! amuse " Mi iden National died on He Auguat r organizations t James, L, I September was born Va 24, 1847, the well-known abolitionist, MeKim County and was the on of Miller James After a year of study at the Lawrence Seclentifie School of Harvard Mr. McKim three years mn Paris as a pupil of Daumet, at the Beaux- Arta As the University spent and two more years in foreign travel. he played a great part in American revival of Italian models, and an architect received generous recognition at home and abroad. The name of Mr. McKim’'s firm is especially associated with the Boston Pub- lic Library, the Columbia University Li- brary, Robinson Hall at Harvard College, the Century and numerous other New York library, Morgan's clubhouses, J. Pierpont The Nation. new Pennsylvania Railroad station in New York city. Jean Paul Selinger, portrait and figure- painter, died in Boston on September 13 at the age of fifty-nine years. The son of a woodcarver of repute who was also one of the founders of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, he was educated in the Bos- ton schools, and at Stuttgart and Munich In this last city he was a pupil of Wilheln: Leibl, the master of Munkaczy. Léon Martineau, a mural painter and maker of decorative windows, died in New York city on September 7, at the age of forty-six. M. Martineau was a pupil of Luc-Olivier Merson, and was President of the Société de Peintres-Verriers, of Paris. Finance. CONTROL OF GREAT CORPORA- TIONS. Monday's action of the Union Pacific directors, in electing Robert S. Lovett, Harriman’s close associate, to succeed Mr. Harriman as chairman of the board, and in choosing as new members of the executive committee two other finan- ciers intimately affiliated with Harri- man, puts at rest for the time, at any rate, rumors of a struggle of rivai fac- tions for control. In these reports, in- deed, there was all along something of indecency; had they been correct, they would inevitably have suggested a fight over the sick-bed of a dying man for the property he was leaving. Even gossip would scarcely have busied itself with such assertions but for the curious state- ment, given out the day before Mr. Har- riman’s death by a man whom the As- sociated Press described as an intimate friend of Harriman, and who flatly de- clared that Wall Street interests, taking advantage of Harriman’s absence and illness in Europe, had “assumed his career was over,” “raided his property,” “struggled to unhorse him,” and “even announced the name of his successor.” Of the facts behind these somewhat sensational allegations, it is not easy to obtain certain knowledge. But it is at least reassuring to find that the episode, whatever its real character, has not been followed by any such open con- flict of opposing interests as would have confirmed the worst interpretations. The situation as a whole, however, suggests some reflections on the present posture of affairs in our great corporations. It will doubtless be remarked, in the first place, that the era in which great railway systems were passed along by will to the family of the controlling financier is definitely past. Jay Gould and the Vanderbilts of the earlier gener- ation literally owned the railways most closely associated with their names. Each selected his successor in office, re- serving, indeed, the right of establish- ing a kind of order of succession, where- [ Vol. 89, No. 2307 sonal control of the railway property, the rest of the family being commonly provided for in a trust fund. There are two reasons why this sort of family ownership and family succession is not likely ever to be repeated. One arises from the fact that, although railway properties were in these cases inherit- ed, capacity for administering them did not always descend along with the prop- erties. This, together with the increas- ing difficulty and complexity of such administration, and the necessity for dependence on large financial interests to procure the funds required for devel- opment and extension, made necessary the sharing of responsibility with out- siders. This could usually not be ob- tained without similar sharing of actual control and ownership. The second reason for the disappear- ance of family ownership arose from the same conditions as the first. If our great private fortunes have increased rapidly since the days of such owner- ship, the capitalization of the railways themselves has increased even faster. Such present-day stock capitalizations as the $248,000,000 of the Northern Pacific, the $299,000,000 of the Union Pacific, the $314,000,000 of the Pennsylvania, and the $178,000,000 and $112,000,000, re- spectively, even of such smaller enter- prises as the New York Central and the Erie, made virtually impossible c ontin- ued exclusive ownership, even of a ma- jority interest. This rapid and great increase of capital stock, which really began with the business revival after 1898, was fol- lowed, therefore, by the era of owner- ship by groups of financiers. The con- tests between great railways in the seventies and the eighties were mainly contests between individuals, who re- garded the several properties as their personal possessions. The contests of the decade past have been conducted between powerful factions. The Union Pacific-Northern Pacific struggle of 1901 was avowedly a battle between a group of wealthy capitalists known as the “Standard Oil party” and a second group known as the “Morgan party,” and the prodigious sums of money raisei on credit and flung into the Stock Exchange arena would have been inconceivable but for the accumulations of financial power banded together behind the two great properties. It is this fact which lends particular interest to the situation created by the death of Mr. Harriman. It is wholly improbable that Harriman’s personal ownership of Union Pacific shares was ever large enough to have carried an election. Actual ownership of the prop- erty could not be determined by his personal bequests; it depends to-day. as it did before his death, on the group- ing of separate capitalists, each of whom undoubtedly owns as much of the stock the War College at and the Washington, by the oldest son should succeed to per- as Harriman did, or more. And this,

Page 27

Sept. 16, 1909] in turn, explains why interest has con- verged so actively on the present atti- tude of this group of financiers toward the property and toward one another. That Harriman’s death has removed the will and personality which dominated all the others is conceded on all hands; the question of his successor, then, is less a question of what men will be formally elected to the offices which he held, than of what man will be able to manage as he did the group of capital- ists behind him. It is quite conceivable that no one will repeat the achievement, and that the railway property over which he ex- ercised so vital and personal a control will become an investment enterprise which no individual and no group of in- dividuals actually owns. The Pennosyl- vania Railroad is a property which al- ready occupies such a position. [tself the great prize of the American railway industry, its ownership is so widely dis- tributed that no man or group of men can be said to possess an actual con- trol. A very large individual invest- ment in the shares is apt to be recog- nized by the admission of the owner to the directing board; the property is managed by the largest owners of its stock and by such experienced col- leagues as they select. Mismanagement would undoubtedly displace an existing board, both by dissension among these larger owrers and by transfer of prox- ies by the great mass of outside and unrepresented shareholders, who would then be driven to united action to pro- tect their personal interests. It is prob- able that a status of this sort will be- come more common as the history of American railway finance goes on, and that we have possibly seen the last of such excesses, arising from group or faction domination, as marked the later years of Mr. Harriman’s career in Union Pacific. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Abbott, E. H. What They Did With Them- selves. Crowell. 30 cents net. A Century of Population Growth: From the First Census of the U. S. to the Twelfth, 1790-1900. Washington: Dept. of Com- merce and Labor. Benson, A. C. Until the Evening. Crowell. 30 cents net. Betham-Edwards, M. French Vignettes: a Series of Dramatic Episodes 1787-1871. Brentano. Boys on the Railroad. By M. E. Seawell J. Barnes, E. D. Deland, J. R. Coryell, E. Carruth, and others. Harper. 69 cents Bradley, A.G. Worcestershire. Painted by Thomas Tyndale. Macmillan. $3 net. Brandes, G. Anatole France. Doubleday Page. Burton-Fanning, F. W. The Open-Air Treatment of Pulmonary Tuberculosis. Second Edition. B. P. Hoeber. $1.50 net Calderon de la Barca, P. La Vida es Svefic. Vol. I. Edited by M. A. Buchan- an. University of Toronto Library. Carr, S. P. Billy To-morrow. Chicago: McClurg. $1.25. — E. V. Little Songs for Two. 1, Couch, 8 B. In the Shadow of the Peaks Dodge. The Nation. Darton, F. J. H. Pilgrims’ Tales: from “Tales of the Canterbury Pilgrims.” Dodge. 60 cents. Darwin, C. The Foundations of the Origin of Species: Two Essays Written in 1842 and 1844. Edited by his son, F. Darwin Putnam. 2.50. Dawson, E. R. The Secret of Sex. Coch rane Pub. Co. 50 cents. Del Mar, Wm. A. Electric Power Conduc- tors. Van Nostrand. $2 net. Depreciated Currency and Diminished Rail- way Rates. Philadelphia: Railway World Dudeney, Mrs. H. Trespass. Boston: Small, Maynard. $1.25. Ellis, K. R. The Wide Awake Girls in Win- sted. Boston: Little, Brown. $1.50. Faris, R. L. Terrestrial Magnetism. Ap- pendix No. 3—Report for 1908. Dept. of Commerce and Labor. Washington. Fewkes, J. W Antiquities of the Mesa Verde National Park. Bureau of Amer! can Ethnology, Bulletin 41, Smithsonian Institution, Washington. Fowle, F. F. The Protection of Railroads from Overhead Transmission Line Cross- ings. Van Nostrand. $1.50 net. Franklin Papers Appendix to the Cal- endar of the Papers of Benjamin Frank- lin Philadelphia: University of Penn- sylvania Garland, H. The Moccasin Ranch: a Story of Dakota. Harper. $1. Garnett, L. M. J Home Life in Turkey Macmillan. $1.75. Gildersleeve, PB. L. Hellas and Hesperia. Holt & Co. $1 net. Golden Treasury of Songs and Lyrics. Se- lected by F. T. Palgrave Revised and enlarged, two volumes in one. Macmillan $1.50. Greenwood, A. D. Lives of the Hanoverian Queens of England. Vol. I Macmillan. $3.50 net. Hichborn, L. Story of the Session of the California Legislature of 1909 Santa Clara, Cal.: F. Hichborn $1.25 Higley, E. E. Homespun Religion. Crowell 30 cents net. Howells, W. D. Boy Life. Arr. for sup plementary reading in the Elementary School by P. Chubb. Harper. 50 cents Humphreys, A. L. Salt and Sincerity. Dodge Pub. Co. $1. Hungary of To-day. By Members of the Hungarian Government. Edited by P. Alden. Brentano. Inrig, A. The Spirit of God in the Universe, Toronto: William Briggs. Irwin, W. Warrior the Untamed. Double day, Page. 50 cents. Jacomb, A. E. The Faith of His Fathers Dodd, Mead. $1.50. Jenks, T. When America Won Liberty. Crowell. $1.25. Jones, D. The Pronunciation of English Putnam. 90 cents. Kelly, M. The Golden Season. Doubleday, Page. $1. 20. Laird & Lee’s Webster’s New Standar‘ Dictionary. Adapted for Grammar and School Grades. Chicago: Laird & Lee. 75 cents. Lindsay, N. V. The Tramp’s Excuse, and Other Poems. Springfield, Ill.: N. V. Lindsay. McAulay, A. The Eagle’s Nest. Lane, $1.50. McCutcheon, G. B. Truxton King: a Story of Graustark. Dodd, Mead. $1.50. McDonald, E. B., and Dalrymple, J. Kath- leen in Ireland, Rafael in Italy, Manuel in Mexico, Umé San in Japan. 4 vols., Boston; Little, Brown. 60 cents each Mack, A. C. The Palisades of the Hudsop Edgewater, N. J.: Palisade Press. 75 cents net. Marden, O. S; Why Grow Old? Crowell. 30 cents net. Mikkelsen, E. Conquering the Arctic Ice. Philadelphia Jacobs & Co. Miller, J. R. The Gate Beautiful. Crowell 85 cents net. Miller, J. R. The Master’s Friendships Crowell. 30 cents net. Murray, C. Story Land. Boston: Little, Brown. 50 cents. Noguchi, H. Snake Venoms. Washington Cochrane. $1.50. 265 Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits Letters of Credit ieisscirsiows International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wali Street, New York Certiticates The Best Book On 6% Bonds We have written a book on Irrigation Bonds, based on long experience and Every investor, small or large, owes to himself its pe- rusal. intimate knowledge. We want to seni you a copy. In the past 15 years, we have sold 70 separate issues of Drainage and Irrigation Bonds, without a dollar of We are the largest dealers in these Reclamation loss to any investor. Bonds, and they have become, in late years, our most popular bonds. Irrigation Bonds aresecured by liens on the most fertile farm lands in America. The value of the land is often more than four times the loan. Some are municipal obligations, forming tax liens on the real property located in populous districts. They are serial bonds, running from two to twelve years. Each year, as the loan is reduced, the security back of the rest is increased. The denominations are $100, $500 and $1,000, so one may invest either little or much. The interest rate is six per cent. No other large class of bonds, equally well secured, now pays an equal rate. These bonds are bound to become more and more popular as they be- come better kn wn. They are the ut- most in six per cent. bonds. Please send us this coupon to-day for our {ree book, so you may know the facts. D. C.: Carnegie Institute O'Shea, M. V. Social Development and Educstion. Houghton Mifflin. $2. Oxford Plain Texts. Spenser: The Faerie Queene. Book I. Frowde. Parkinson, J. A Reformer by Proxy. Lane $1.50. Srowtridge LNiver'bo; (Established 18038) Municipal and Corporation Bonds First National Bank Bidg. 50 Congress Street CHICAGO BOSTON Gentlemen :—Please send me your new Bond Book, “The World’s Greatest In- dustry.” Name-——- Town State —

Page 28

‘ > 42 . 266 The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2307 Patmore, K. A. The Court of Louls XIIL. | Seipt, A. A Schwenkfelder Hymnology. | Thoughts of Comfort from the Writings of Brentano. Worcester, Pa.: George A. Seipt. $2. Marcus Aurelius Antoninus. Dodge. 50 Potamian, B., and Walsh, J. J. Makers of | Sélincourt, H. de. The Way Things Happen. cents. Electricity. New York: Fordham Univer- Lane. $1.50. Thurston, E. T. The City of Beautiful Non- sity Press Singleton, E. Dutch New York. Dodd, sense. Dodd, Mead. $1.50. Rage. L The Church of the Apostles. Mead. $3.50 net. Ward, Mrs. J. C. Under the Northern Macmillan. $1.40 net Smith, M, P. W. Boys and Girls of Seventy- Lights. New York: A. Wessels. Rawnsley, H. D. Round the Lake Country. seven. Little, Brown, $1.25. Warren, T. H. The Centenary of Tenny- Macmillan. $1.50 net. Spence, W. Tennyson's Idylis of the Kiag: | son, 1809-1909: a Lecture. Frowde. Ray, A. C. Janet at Odds. Boston: Little, A Spiritual Interpretation. Cochran. $1 ' Warren, W. F. The Earliest Cosmologies Brown. $1.50. Stevens, E. S. The Veil: a Romance of Eaton & Mains. $1.50 net. Recent Christian Progress. By Professors Tunis. Stokes. $1.50. Wells, C. Patty’s Pleasure Trip. Dodd, and Alumni of Hartford Theological | Stewart, J. D. The Sheaf Catalogue: A Mead. $1.25 Seminary. Edited by L. B. Paton. Mac- Handbook on the Compilation of Manu- | Whitham, G. I. Basil, the Page: a Story of millan. $3 net. script Catalogues. London: Libraco the Days of Queen Elizabeth. Dodge. Report of the American Relief Committee, Limited. $1.25. Rome, for the earthquake sufferers. | Stories Children Love. Edited by Charles | Wilde, O. De Profundis. Second edition Rome: Codperativa Tipografica Manuzio. Welsh. Dodge. $1.25. Putnam. Richards, M. E. Zandrie Century Co./ Sutcliffe, A. C. Robert Fulton and the | Wood, M. B. Just Boys. Revell. 75 cents $1.50. Clermont. Century Co. $1.20 net. net. Rickaby, J. Scholasticism. Dodge. 50 cents | Taylor, A. E. Plato. Dodge. 50 cents net. | Yates, K. M. “Chet.” Chicago: McClurg. net The Philippine Islands, 1493-1898. Analyt- $1.25. Rogers, J. E. The American Newspaper. ical Index. Vol. LIV, A-I, Vol. LV, J-Z. | Younger American Humorists. Compiled by University of Chicago Press. $1 net. Edited and annotated by E. H. Blair and W. Rice. Dodge. 50 cents. Santiey, ©. Reminiscences of My Life. Bren- J. A. Robertson. Cleveland, O.: A. H./}; Zangwill, I. The Melting-Pot: Drama in tano. | Clark Co. Four Acts. Macmillan. $1.25. A Political History of the State of New York VOLUME III (1862-1884) By D. S. Alexander. 8vo, $2.50 net; by mail, $2.70. This volume narrates, fully and entertainingly, the futile efforts of Weed and Dean Richmond to reorganize existing parties, the rise and fall of the Tweed Ring, Conkling’s punishment of Greeley and defeat of Fenton, Tilden’s defiance of Tammany and strug- gie with Kelly, and the overthrow of the stalwart régime by the crushing victory of Grover Cleveland. The publishers believe the author has been quite successful in making history as readable as a novel. [ts fairness will appeal to the strictest partisan. Original research materially modifies previously accepted theories. The author, now a member of Congress, has been prominent in state and national politics for many years. Volumes I and II (1774-1861) “the most entertaining story of state politics in were characterized by the Review of Reviews as American History.” Circular with sample pages on request. HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY | WRITING AND SPEAKING 4 W. 884 St. NEW YORK : : President Eliot’s A Text-Book of Rhetoric. By CHARLES recent address entitled SEARS BALDWIN, A.M., Ph.D.. Professor of Rhetoric in Yale University. Crown Svo. pp. xx+-445, $1.20. | | | The study of composition is presented here en- tirely afresh, as deriving its value and its method | from constant and consecutive relation to all other THE RELIGION OF THE FUTURE is printed for the first time in the October issue of the HARVARD THEOLOGICAL REVIEW studies Based on twenty years’ teaching and on systematic discussions with teachers, the book is at all points practical, made to be recited upon, but to be worked with. By the same author, “‘A Summary of Punctua- tion."’ Paper covers, $0.05. | LONGMANS, GREEN, & co., New York i Musicians Library Handsome booklets FREH, containing portraits of Editors, complete descrip- tions and tables of contents of 60 Vol- umes. if not Professor Royce contributes an article on WHAT IS VITAL IN CHRISTIANITY? =|) ouver ovr Dr. Samuel Angus, Rev. Howard N. Brown, Rev. Paul Revere Froth- BUNGAY” George F. FOREIGN councus Catalogwe, TAUCHNITZ BOOKS Address interested: OLIVER DITSON COMPANY BOSTON, MASS. ingham, and Professor Moore are also contributors. Single copies 50 cents THE MACMILLAN CO., Publishers FOR SALE AT THE 60, NEWSSTANDS SCHOENHOF BOOKCO. BRITISH 128 Tremont Street, AUTHORS BOSTON, MASS. The Conquest of the Is By Hugh C. Weir 8vo. Fully Illustrated. $2.00 net. It was to study the life of the men who are doing the work at Panama that Mr. Weir visited the Isthmus. It was not the machinery that held his attention, nor the pigeon-holed figures in the Government of- . fees, nor the red-inked reports of engineer- ing experts. It was the men, the men who are tearing from the red clay two million and three million cubic yards of earth every thirty days, who are levelling mountains, and building the greatest dams and locks in the history of the world. G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS, S*Yoxoon ONE-HALF COMPLETED ! THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE Ed. by PORTER-CLARKE. Text of 1623 Full notes and variants. READY:—*‘Midsommer Night's Dreame,’’ ‘‘Love's Labour's Lost,’’ ‘‘Comedie of Errors,’’ ‘‘Mercnant of Venice,’ ‘‘Macbeth,’’ ‘‘Julius Ceesar,’’ *‘Ham- let,”’ *‘King Lear,’’ ‘‘Twelfe Night,’’ ‘‘As You Like > ‘“‘Henry the Fift,’’ ‘‘Much Adoe Abont Nothing,’’ **Romeo and Juliet,’’ **Tempest,’’ *‘Othello,’’ ‘‘Winter’s Tale,”’ ‘‘Shrew,’’ ‘*Two Gen- tlemen of Verona,"’ ** Coriolanus,”’ a Wives,” “‘All’s Well,’ ‘‘M e for Cloth, 75 cents; limp leather, $1. 00 per volume, Postpaid. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., New York Visitors in New York are invited to examine the resources of our retail store. Here will be found a large stock of current and standard works from American and foreign presses. Teachers or students prepar- ing for courses of reading will find an excellent choice of moderate-priced editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- logues. E. P. DUTTON & CO., 31 West 23d Street, New York. THE CLEVEREST BOOK OF THE YEAR ANNE OF GREEN GABLES By L. M. MONTGOMERY THE “CHILD’S GUIDE” SERIES THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Publishers 33-37 East Seventeenth Street, New York MARX'S CAPITAL, 2°. °$0 0s vols., $6.00. CHARLES H. KERR & COMPANY. Chicago.

Page 29