The Nation 1909-08-26: Vol 89 Iss 2304
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2304. 5 rat Lie ; UNIY. ur MICH, AUG 2'7 1909 THURSDAY, AUGUST 26, 1909 Ready Everywhere September First The new book by L. M. MONTGOMERY ANNE OF AVONLEA Sequel to the delightful «Anne of Green Gables ”’ “Everything ANNE says—and she talks without ceasing Illustrated, $1.50 is absolutely in character. She is heavenly with- out being a Sunday school child in the least; and impish without a touch of the callous disregard for others’ feelings that makes the ‘pickle’ of real life so great a palliation of Herod’s memory and conduct.” The London Observer. SICILY TheCarden of theMediterranean By WILL 8S. MONROE, Author of “IN VIKING LAND,” ete. Illustrated, Boxed, Cloth, 83.00. % Morocco, $7.00. “Mr. Monroe’s new volume is a good, sound, conscientious, comprehensive and interesting book of description, just the kind of book that one ought to read (and usually doesn’t) before visiting a foreign country.”—Chicago Record-Herald. GUATEMALA And Her People of To-day By REVIN 0. WINTER, Author of “MEXICO OF TO-DAY." Illustrated, Boxed, Cloth, 83.00, % Morocco, 87.00, “Mr. Winter studied his subject at range, travelling through the country leisurely and verifying his facts. These he has clothed tertaining narrative illuminated with fascinating photographs.”—Phil- adelphia Public Ledger close in en and AND HER PROPLE New Revised Edition TURKEY and THE TURKS By WILL 8S. MONROE, Author of “SICILY, THE GARDEN OF THE MEDITERRANEAN," etc Illustrated, Boxed, Cloth, 83.00, % Morecco, 87.00, “To the many readers who know Turkey only by the hearsay of sen suality, the newspaper reports of Ar- menian massacres, or the magazine contributor’s anathemas, this scholar- ly yet interesting Monroe book will come as a herald.”—Philadelphia Item. THE KINDERGARTEN IN THE HOME By CARRIE S. NEWMAN Illustrated, $1.50 A book full of practical suggestions for the young mother, and of great value to the teacher “From the frank announcement of the author that her object is to present in a simple and attrac- tive form some of the truths underlying Froebel’s system of education, that in the homestead wherein are placed her characters all was sunshine, happiness and reverence for one another, this book is particularly timely and interesting.”—Chicago Record Herald. to the final lines which show From Page's L.C. PACE & COMPANY, Publishers, Boston (AT ALL BOOKSTORES) List
Page 2
The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. [Batered at the New York City Fost Office as second-class mail matter.) The Netion ts published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, ‘President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Wimer More, Editor. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, ia any part of the United States or Mesico; te Can- ada £3.50, and to foreign countrice comprised in the Postal Unton, 84.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tue WEEK EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Arithmetical Naval Strategists The Gemerel Gerte ccccccccccceccocccs 176 UE eae ee 177 A Weed fer AWtUEAR 2. cccccccccccccece 178 SPECIAL ARTICLES: TD. DE cca dcaseeseetsenseesasonnt 179 News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE: Practical Education ....ccccsccccceces 18] SIUGRUEEEED Soccececese docvoecaccoesceuss 182 The Hypnerotomachia ...........+..+. 182 BMereGith’s Latter on cccccccccccccccces 183 NoTes . Book REVIEWS: A Literary History of Rome from the Origins to the Close of the Golden BED chiveccccoce oscvoseccnceeeseqace 186 The Hungry ert EPPS ST TT Tat 186 A False Position aendcousevdcweesaius 186 Leas Than Kin ... seece BOO The King Who Never Reigned.- The | , _. SRRTTULTR Ce eee 187 A Vindication of Warren Hastings.... 187 ORGS BS kcccesccee seecevoscens 188 The Awakening of Turkey ............ 188 ScIENCE Paychotherapy DRAMA AND Music . 191 ART: The Dearth of Antiques 191 FINANCS: Wall Street and Mr. Harriman........ 192 BOOKS OF THE WOK .... ccc ccccccsess 193 ***Gaples of The Nation may be procered in Porites at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2304 from Library Orders We have conducted a special department for many years that has been exceptionally successful in handling book orders PUBLIC LIBRARIES SCHOOLS, COLLEGES and UNIVERSITIES Our Monthly Bulletin of New Books, with annotations and brief descriptions of each title recorded, is one of the most helpful aids in book selection. Library Department A. C. McCLURG & CO. CHICAGO Educational. THE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES 1a orn neeh Ea DS So. Seaton Fifth Ave., New York 414 Con. Bld.) for Bb pas Sos Dears y n Bid., Spokane 3149 dbattack Ave Berkeley Sa akies above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY o- lies schools of all —. with competent rs. Vacance throughont the year. send for bulletin HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel 8t., Barw Mawes, Pennsylvania. The Misses Kirk’s School or to Bryn Mawr and KR. y- ty caretel for Smal! classes Sividual instruction. Teachers an horgughly Re millar with Bryn Mawr requiremen = and basket ball. Seventh pose ane Oa 6 6, 18098 The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY WORCESTER, MASS. Established in 1856. An ideally healthful location. Efficient faculty. Prepara- tion for the best institutions. The Rt. Rev. A. H. Vintoa, D.D., LL.D., Visitor. For Catalogue please address 408EPH ALDER SHAW, A.B, Headmaster. NEW YORK Day School 174 Fulton St. LAW SCHOOL Evening School New York City “Dwight Method"’ of Ye LL.B. in two years. LL.M. in three ‘High standards. Send for catalogue. GEORGE CHASE, Dean. BETHLEHEM B PREPARATORY Rethiehem, Pa. Prepares for leadin Catalogue H. A. FORRING, B.8., Albany,N.Y. SUHUUL, colleges. Hea ter. Visitors in New York are invited to examine the resources of our retail store. Here will be found a large stock of current and standard werks from American and foreign presses. Teachers or students prepar- ing for courses of reading will find an excellent choice of moderate-priced editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- logues. E. P. DUTTON & CO., 81 West 234 Street, New York. 5 Astor Edition of Poets is the best for echeols 99 vols. Lést price, 60c. per vol. ; Ly - hs SEND FOR LisT. Thomas Y.Crowell&Co., New York “TONO- BUNGAY ” Modern Languages Aldrich and Foster’s Elementary French. Aldrich and Foster’s French Reader. Lazare’s French Readers. Hem and Leonard’s Brief German GINN AND COMPANY, Publishers 20 Beacon Street Boston Johnson’s Introduction to Economics Balances theory with actice; full of contemporary interest « value; for stu- dent and citizen. 41 $1.80. D. ©. HBATH & O0., BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO Squere, Ohertag Oroes. | HAREMLIK By DEMETRA VAKA “A remarkable description of the life and manner of thinking of Turk- ish women.”—New York Sun. JUST ISSUED. Oleth, $1.50 net. SAINTE-BEUVE By Prof. George M. Harper, Princeton University. 4. B. LIPPINOOTT ©CO.. Philadelphia. The By GORKY BOOK S——All Scan tome matter on what ‘any . books sae yo i ARETE Bbotito 50,000 books. BAKER'S : rare a 0 T
Page 3
WBW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 86, 1909. ——————— ———— ———————— The Week. The Attorney-General, the Secretary of Commerce and Labor, the Secretary of the Interior, the chairman of the In- terstate Commerce Commission, and the Solicitor of the Department of Justice are, it is said, to furnish President Taft with material upon which to base rec- ommendations to Congress. The legis- lation relates to the powers and func- tions of the Interstate Commerce Com- mission, the amendment of the Sherman Anti-Trust act, and additional safe guards against corporate abuses. Some profess to see an innovation in this rec- ommendation of speoific statutes to Con- gress. President Taft, however, is not only an able lawyer himself, but evi- dently constituted his Cabinet so as to entrench himself ag behind a bulwark of distinguished legal advice. Hia experi- ence with the tariff bill, where the cor- poration tax was ef Cabinet manufac- ture, may have convinced him of the utility of having qa measure in definite white and black to urge upon the at- tention of the lawmakers. This plan, even if in some degree novel—and we are not at all certain that precedents eannot be found for it—is at least rather more dignified than the back-dcor deal in patronage to buy legislative approval of particular measures. However, if the experiment is actually tried, it will but register the growing inclination to trust the Chief Executive, rather than Con- gress, with the initiative in measures taken in the interest of the nation as a whole. President Taft is reported to be not at all disturbed by the news that the corporation tax is to be taken into the courtg, to test its Constitutionality. He expected this. He knows the ways of lawyers, and only laughs when told of their eager preparation for the great battle. But he should not forget that a similar hilarious incredulity was dis- played in 1894, over the proposal to challenge the income tax in the Su- preme Court. Why, it was res adjudi- cata; the Court itself had upheld the validity of the tax, and how ridiculous The N ——— — Sms it was to imagine that it could be up set. But it was upset; and Mr. Taft can- not have forgotten the innocent smile with which Mr. Choate remarked, when all was over: “Well, some things can be done as easily as some other things.” It is, of course, true that very able and experienced lawyers agree with the President that the corporation tax is not obnoxious to any Constitutional prin- ciple; but just as many take the other view, and what the courts will hold can- not be predicted. Acting Secretary Reynolds of the Treasury Department has come forward as an authority upon official wsthetics. There are two provisions in our tariff law, the one providing for the free ad- mission of works of art over one hun- dred years old, the other for similar products more than twenty years old. The unsophisticated person might imag ine that the effect would be the free ad- mission of any work of art more than twenty years old. But such an opinion differentiates the untutored Philistine from the Treasury connoisseur. The regulations just issued discriminate *twixt tweedle-dum and tweedle-dee very nicely. The twenty-year provision is to be strictly construed. Under its terms, nothing is held to be a work of art, which can, by any possibility, minister to aught but the wsthetic sensibilities. “Nothing suitable for purposes of util- ity,” so reads the edict, “suck as tapes- tries, paper hangings, glass windows, ornamental clocks, chandeliers’ or other furniture may gain free admission un- der this proviso. The one hundred-year provision, however, is to be construed with the liberality which is of right paid to age. With the single exception of rugs and carpets which are denied free admission though they might come from the palaces of the Pharaohs, any work of art over a century old is welcomed, despite its possible utility. Thus, if one buys a dozen Apostle spoons, he may bring them in, duty free, for kitchen use, if he chooses; but a lace handker- chief that was made subsequent to Ful- ton’s navigation the Hudson is promptly charged with its appropriate duty. Secretary Reynolds seems to have answered with wonderful acumen the Conundrum of the Workshops of ation. 3 And the first rude sketch that the world has seen was joy to his mighty heart Till the Devil whispered behind the leaves: “It's pretty, but is it art?” It is a pity that Congressman Fowler's attack upon Speaker Cannon is 80 per- sonal and in language as partly to obscure the real gravity of his charges. People cannot be got to work themselves into excitement over the fact that one Representative, rather than another, is made Chairman of the Committee on Banking and Currency Recriminations on that score will fal! rather flat. Only languid interest can’ be taken in the assertion, on the one hand, that Mr. Fowler's deposition from his chairmanship will yet rank “the crime of 1909,” or in the retort, from so violent as the other side, that his lamentarions are nothing but the wails of a “squealer ” Much more to the point is the exhibi- tion of the Speaker’s very bad record in matters of public finance. We our selves have shown that he was on the wrong side in every financial measure of capital importance, having voted reg the inflation bills and ularly for all silver bills, and against all the sound measures—even the repeal of silver pur chases, in 1893—that have come up in his time. If currency reform is to be left to the tender mercies of a public man so ignorant and narrow and perverse as Speaker Cannon has shown himself to be, we can only say, Heaven help the re formers. The bloodshed McKee'e Rocks should surprise no one who has watch at ed the progress of the conflict hetween the Pressed Steel Car Company and Its employees. A disgraceful civil war has virtually been raging at the works. No less than 3,000 men under arms on the side of the strikers alone: have been daily fusillades have been reported, and yet the State of Pennsylvania has not acted except by ordering. out a nandful of constabulary. Whatever the its of the strike, if the is able to man its works owes it to itself company’s property of the men it employs. ers have a just cause, they are only In juring it by resorting to violence. Bui mer com pany the State the lives protect the If the ertrik to and
Page 4
174. lets will restore no man’s job and will merely harden the hearts of the em- ployers. Killing strike-breakers feeds no hungry mouths and alienates public opinion without which no such strike can be successful. Punishment of un- just and cruel employers can come gen- public erally only through that same opinion On the as strongly hand, we feel quite the time has gone other that when employers can take such a stand as President Hoffstot takes toward by his men. If the statement is correct that a_ skilled days and two nights, and then received riveter worked ten only $6.50 pay, and that another em- ployee of seven years’ standing worked ten and one-half days and received only $14.95, when he had formerly earned $30 in the same time, there is every reason why the company should have met its employees and discussed labor condi- tions in an amicable spirit. To institute order is, we insist, all-essential for every one concerned, but as the Pittsburgh Sun put it: “More important to Pitts- burgh than her tonnage output is the making of good citizens out of all who labor here. He is an optimist, indeed, who can see any good at all in such eco- nomic conditions as ure bared in this strike and attendant rioting.” For an of- ficial to refuse to arbitrate where no principle is at stake, but merely a ques- tion of wage rates and hours cf labor, is to prove one’s self not only entirely out of touch with modern economic con- ditions, but entirely too autocratic and unreasonable to have charge of the destinies of thousands of employees. At last, Mr. Taft is caught in delib- erately, unblushingly, and wickedly re- versing one of his predecessor's poli- We hasten to call it to the atten- tion of the muck-raking magazines. West Point reveals the parting of the ways. It is only eight months cgo that Mr. Roosevelt was confronted with a hazing case involving five cadets. He knew that the law required the dismissal of these men; that the Academic Board of West Point was unanimously in favor of letting the law take its course; that the superintendent, Col. H. L. Scott, had publicly declared his apprehensions for the discipline of the Academy if the cadets were permitted to go cles. The Nation. superiors. But Mr. Roosevelt knew bet- ter, and true to his habitual custom, he let no such little thing as a Congress- made law stand in his way. Now, Mr. Taft deliberately reverses Mr. Roose- velt’s humanitarian policy, without a word of explanation or justification, and seven poor “boys” must undergo the “en- tirely needless hardship of being turned out.” Nothing is said about their being sent back for one year—there is merely, at Beverly, a craven desire tc abide by the law which prescribes diemissal for each hazer, without alternative. Secretary Wilson of the Department of Agriculture might well be content to allow the department year book just issued to stand as his nunc dimittis. In the twelve years that have marked his administration of the department, he has seen the staff grow from 2,444 to 10,420—due to the increasing duties loaded by Congress upon this branch. The period has witnessed an increased average production per acre of such staples as cotton and corn, the former rising in the ten years prior to 1906 from 172 pounds to 191 pounds per acre. Of course, this advance may con- note even more than a corresponding outlay per acre, but it may be due in part to more scientific and more econom- ical cultivation. The Secretary is very sanguine as to the American farmer's ability to provide food for any possible growth of our population. His declara- tion that as regards wages the “farm laborer has fared better than the work- ingman employed in manufacturing and mechanical industries” raises the query whether this wage increase in an es- sentially non-protected industry is com- patible with the protective shibboleth which the Secretary's party has always uttered. Not the least of the services which the farmer renders is the inter- national credit his exports create in our favor—a factor of great importance just at this present juncture, when gold ex- ports are large enough to be sobering. With the mimic war in Massachu- setts over, the country may now rest in peace—until there shall have heen drawn from the mancuvres the inevit- able dread lessons. Meanwhile, we are very happy for the regular army that it has achieved so glorious a victory. We can well imagine the heart-burnings [Vol. 89, No. 2304 with an inferior force, had outwitted three of our shrewdest regular army generals. That we felt sure was an im- possibility, unless General Pew should prove a Napoleon in disguise. As for the lessons to be drawn from these field exercises, without in the least pretend- ing to military wisdom, we are really to wager a field gup against a cocked hat that they demonstrate, clearly, the utter defencelessness of our coasts and the absolute necessity of, at least, 20,- 000 more coast artillerymen—or, should we say 30,000? At the same time, it is pleasant to record that in this war game the various State troops seem to have conducted themselves extremely well and demonstrated anew their military progress since 1898. The oft-repeated tale of our annual fire-waste was never more cogently put than by Mr. Edward T. Campbell last week at the Trans-Mississippi Congress at Denver. Losses by fire in the United States, he declared, cost three-quarters of a million dollars a day. In 1907, the entire fire-bill reached a total of $456,- 000,000, or about one-half of the total value of new constructions in the same year. The neglect of collective hazard in the matter of high or non-fireproof buildings is the chief reason why our per capita fire losses are about ten times as great as those in Europe. There is in this country no adequate recogni- tion of the fact that fire losges are nev- er ultimately indemnified, and that fire insurance premiums are essentially tax- es imposed upon the community to spread the losses over a period, rather than to compel individuals to incur the same losses in lump sums at a single time. It is refreshing to see how frankly the West can be told of its errors in the matter of insurance. Mr. Campbell pointed out fearlessly that the three States of New York, Pennsylvania, and Connecticut practically insured _ the country, because of their reasonable laws governing insurance. There have been gross misrepresentations sent out regarding actions of the Depart- ment in certain matters. Criticisms have been pretty severe from some quarters; but knowing that I am absolutely right in the position 1 have taken I have paid no at- tention to them. In time it will be shown beyond a doubt that my course has been all right. In these words, according to a_ dis- the heads, of their military over in the service if a mere militia general, patch to the New York Sun from Butte,
Page 5
Aug. 26, 2909] The Nation. ata Secretary Ballinger has commented on the various attacks upon him. “At the same time,” he went on, “I realize that there are some things in the law gov- erning the disposition of public lands, which ought to be modified, and as soon as I shall have opportunity, I shall sug- gest such changes as appear to me to be necessary, and report to Congress.” the meantime, Mr. Ballinger says, the established policy of the Interior Depart- ment will continue. It is hard to see why even Mr. Pinchot should not be satisfied with this. In A dispatch from San Francisco as- serts that President Wheeler of the Uni- versity of California has established a strict censorship over all news emanat- ing from that institution. It can hardly be the case that the so-called censor- ship applies to matter other than of- ficial announcements of university pol- icy or action which should emanate from the university authorities. The dispatch in question, however, re- lates that “a curt letter has been sent out forecasting trouble for any profes- sor or instructor who discloses anything concerning the working of the institu- tion to reporters.” In view of some of the sensational reports that from university centres, it is easy to sympathize with President Wheeler. May not, however, the desired end be approximately reached, if discretion is exercised in the choice of a staff of in- struction? Liability to epigrammatic seizure may well disqualify for a faculty position a candidate otherwise qualified. The judicious organization of a uni- versity bureau of publicity codperating with a press bureau composed of stu- dent reporters has eliminated many of the cruder evils which unregulated and sensational newspaper exploitation of universities formerly occasioned. rightly emanate The action taken by the School Board of Chicago against Greek-letter secret societies in the public schools is no doubt wise. And, indeed, clubs and so- cial organizations even in the university, where the students are older, are, at the best, not an unmixed good. The recent action of Chicago University in dropping one hundred students brought a statement from the president that one cause of low scholarship was too great “social” interest. That, perhaps, is partly true, but a greater objection to strictly organized societie: is the ex- ciusion from the larger university life that membership often implies. They, too, often lead to a certain snobbish- ness and chauvinism, to a general nar- rowing of the sympathies. There should, of course, be social life at the uni- versity, which, broadly considered, has as its primary end the introduction of the student to the widest life, lectual and cultural, and that includes the social. intel- But the narrower and more intense social life invoived in the strict- ly organized “society” often works against the wider and more humane out- look. We can hardly believe that the verdict of $20,000, given by a St. Louis jury against a physic’an of that city, because he sewed up in a patienta roll of gauze, will stand in the higher courts. More intelligent persons will, we are sure, feel that to proceed against this cherished practice of some of our most dis- tinguished surgeons will be an undue interference with their liberty and their pursuit of happiness, and, therefore, quite unconstitutional. And whut would become of the newspapers, if they could not record from time to time tha: the great surgeon B., or the wonderful op- erator C., had carefully sewed up an unsterilized instrument or thirty-six inches of gauze in the place of a re- cently removed appendix? We are the more concerned because this is the sec- ond verdict of the same kind which we have noticed during the last few weeks Now we submit that physicians are but as human as the rest of us, and that to require general infallibility while op- erating ‘s a little bit more than the med- ical profession can be expected to endure in silence. Financial legislation in the British Parliament contrasts favorably with the analogous process in our Congress. The budget proposals emanate from the Ministers, and are presented to the House of Commons on the collective re- spons'!bility of the entire Cabinet. Then in the Commons, the scheme is canvass- ed both in its totality and in minutest detail. During the debate, which, as in the present case, often extends over weeks and months, the closest outside scrutiny of the measure is kept up un- der the sharpshooter fire of the press on both sides. The bye-elections, during this time, give to Parliamentary lead- ers and to the country at large a good inkling of the pulse of popular opinion. As a result of these combined processes, the dross is pretty thoroughly refined out of a budget measure, and the event- ual statute is at least a consistent whole. It is not pleasant to compare such a method with the of our legislators, from the first secret dark-lantern process concoction of a measure in the seciuded rooms of the majority of the Ways and Means Committee, to its final hasty s'gn.- ing by the President. The features from the pending Finance bill very well elimination of specific illustrates the peculiar excellence of the British process. Virtually, the aim of the measure is to secure large amounts of additional revenue, ooth for the navy and various schemes of social reform, without resorting to a protective tariff. Two main sources of new revenue chos- en are a tax on the increment value of land, and a super-tax levied on incomes of over £2,000. parture in finance had involved various But so radical a de dubious expedients. The excision of those excrescences one by one hag re- sulted from the complex process of cr'‘t- icism, while the basic principles of the budget are left intact. Thus the of the land’s valuation, it was proposed originally to impose ou the owner. The hardship this would have worked in in cost dividual cases was made so clear that the state now undertakes the valuation and will pay the cost thereof. The fail- ure to provide appeal for the taxpayer was pointed out by the Lord Chief Jus- tice in a public address. As a resu!t of this criticism, an appeal has been al- lowed. The somewhat whimsical tax on ungotten minerals could not stand up against the ridicule it occasioned, and has been replaced by a tax on mining royalties. As a result of this open, pub- lic, and above-board discuss'on, the finance measure has stead'ly grown in popular favor. The bye-elections and public political meetings have shown an apparent stemming of the adverse po- litical tide. The Lords’ bluster about throwing out the budget beautifully less, and even Mr. is said to have advised them against The result is growing Balfour such unprecedented action. shows the unquestioned value of public- ity in the legislative handling of finan- cla] measures.
Page 6
176 The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2304 ARITHMETICAL NAVAL STRATE- GISTS. How can a science be both exact and is inevitably suggested by the settlement of the great inexact? This question naval dispute in England over the ad- ministration of the fleet, between Ad- and Sir John Fisher. Both profess themselves wholly satisfied with the outcome; both feel that they have been overwhelmingly sustained by miral Beresford the sub-committee of the Imperial De- fence Committee, and Beresford is able to tabulate eight distinct reforms which his crusade has compelled the Admiral- ty to introduce. Let no one believe, how- ever, that the peace now established is of ficers must to be long duration. Naval of- be fighting always, if not in their dreams or in their play, then each other. Now this is a very queer thing, because our naval lords are ever dictating to the statesmen of the world what they shall tax the people. No professional man on the whole globe so readily has his way or is listened to and obeyed so zealously. The navy man knows each year just how many ships will prevent the despoiling of his native land, and each year he reports with sor- row new dangers and greater needs But when it comes to administering his own province, this superman is in hot water all the time; his infallibility ceases when the threshold of his own Whether it be yards should be conducted, special field is invaded. how navy whether marines should or should not be on ships, whether a naval general staff is or is not desirable, the service is certain to be split asunder, and naval science appears at once anything but a science Let a naval officer but enter the field of international relations, and all his professional doubts vanish. His fears remain, for he is the most timid of mortals, seeing death and destruction everywhere, if the battleships to those of some one else is as he thinks it ought to we proportion of his not exactly be. Thus, now have an ever-in- creasing number of amusing, pecause 80 naval strategists. In solemn earnestness they set in op- serious, arithmetical posing columns the lists of battleships and auxiliaries of the various Powers, find the'r own navy a poor second in the comparison, and immediately scent disaster to the integrity of their nation. Naturally, there follows a demand for still more ships and a fervent appeal to patriots to act promptly and vigor- ously, lest all be lost in a terrible dé bacle. That other countries are adding yearly to their fleets, making our per- manent superiority wholly out of the question, escapes the arithmetician’s notice. With a sigh of relief, he solves his little problem, points with pride to the result, and tells us that when we have a predetermined number of Dread- noughts, then, and not till then, we shall be safe. The latest apostle of the vicious doc- trine that only by predom!nant naval strength can the United States exist to carry out the plans of the founders and to an astonished world the orderly self-govern- ment based an universal suffrage, is W. H. Beehler of the navy. In an article in the current Pro- ceedings of the Naval Institute, entitled “The Navy and Coast Defence,” he gives the conclusion to which his imagination, prove practicability of Commodore and his exact science “To protect the country, our navy must command four different spheres, the Atlantic, Pacific, West Indies, and Philippines. Command of the sea in these four spheres is es- sential, and it can only be attained by an adequate naval force.” Granted the premises, and the outcome must be ac- cepted in a fleet strong enough in each of these theatres of war to overpower any antagonist. Delightfully simple and obvious. He would be unpatriotic, even perchance, a mollycoddle, who should ask whether this Union might not sur- vive with less, rather than more, armored vessels; who should brutally point out the impossibility of reconcil- ing this gigantic expansion with the President's flat order to reduce the naval appropriation by at least thirty millions of dollars; or who should suggest that by a single act of justice to the Philip- pines the assumed need of one of these fleets would disappear entirely. The arithmetical naval strategist is not like other men. He lives in a world of his own where he blows his little bub- bles and maps out the only possi- ble scheme of salvation, with serene in- difference to the actualities of life. It is a matter of course that he should coin new and sonorous phrases such as “strategic line of force” (whatever that his arithmetic, irresistibly lead him. may be); should advocate “a fleet of armored cruisers” (a discredited and ob- solete type); should dot the wide oceans with scouts cruising continually in search of the enemy (how happy to find him at last, like the old lady who night- ly looked for the burglar under her bed); should recommend fortifying such hopelessly exposed cities as San Diego; and should call for five vice-ad- mirals, forty-two rear-admirals, and oth- er officers and men in proportion. Very sapiently and in italics Commodore Peehler lays down this proposition. “Jf we command the seas no foreign naval force can attack our coasts.” Of course, dear arithmetician. who ever said it could? Some day there will arise a Lewis Carroll properly to satir:ze the Beeblers, the Deweys, the Beresfords of our day; to place the Mad Naval Officer alongside the Mad Hatter, the White Rabbit, and other immortal logicians. Meanwhile, we would simply submit to our statesmen who listen in such awe to every grad- uate of our Naval Academy, that naval officers’ decisions in matters interna- tional would be much worthier of cred- ence and acceptance, could they but reach a common understanding in a field admittedly their own. A science exact and yet hopelessly inexact is, we submit, an anomaly, particularly when, dealing with human beings, it begins its theories by confessing a total lack of faith in the human equation. The very exactness of their science prevents their taking into account national character- istics, conditions of discipline, and rela- tive efficiency. In his worship of the battleship, our arithmetician behind the gun sees no one in the conning tower, at the sights, or in the engine-room. A battleship is to him a battleship and nothing more. THE GENERAL STRIKE. The most recent advices from Stock- holm indicate pretty plainly the fail- ure and impending collapse of the Swed- ish strike. The struggle was unusually interesting for several reasons: it was perhaps the nearest approach to a uni- versal strike ever attempted; it vas con- ducted on the whole peaceably, so that the economic power of the unions was tested with little admixture cr alien forces; it was fought out among a homo- geneous people, where the introduction of immigrant strike-breakers was vir-
Page 7
Aug. 26, 1909] The Nation. tually absent. The complete history of the movement we may not obtain for some time, but the indications are that its ill-success has removed many of the predicted terrors of the genera] strike. In its theoretic aspect, nothing would seem more menacing than a universal stoppage of labor. Most urban communi- ties have had some experience of the extreme inconvenience that a tie-up of the local transit system will produce. Multiply this by whatever factor repre- sents the totality of hand-workers, and it should seem as if anarchy or social revolution must result. In France, in- deed, this is the connotation which the term—general strike—carries. It is only another name for the hoped-for super- session of the government of the bour- It that the extensive strike in Paris ear- geoisie by the labor unions. ig true lier in the year was spoken of as a gen- an- The policy of organized labor in France, it eral strike. But this was only by ticipation or by mistaken usage. must not be forgotten, is to ignore the existing government, to abstain from asking beneficial legislation frum the Parliament, and to prepare for a coup d'état, whose alias is the general strike. In Sweden, as in most Teutonic coun- tries where labor’s attitude is largely opportunist, the general strike is ex- pected to operate within the framework of existing institutions, and by sheer economic necessity to effect the granting of labor’s claims. The first cause of the weakness of the general strike is the failure to make it really general. It is not likely that all classes of operatives will feel aggrieved at one and the same moment. Those whose condition is for the time being fairly satisfactory have an aver- sion for a sympathy strike. Their at- titude is: The distant Trojan never injured me. While they may be coerced by the urg- ent claim of the solidarity of labor, they find it difficult to forget their individual grievance at having to quit work. Many classes again, even of hand-workers, are not unionized. The Swedish farmers seem to have repulsed all suggestions of codéperating with the striking urban op- eratives. On the other hand, some of the best organized unions refusc flatly to go out at the behest of an unrecog- nized labor leader. Those who are in public employ are particularly chary about quitting their posts. Thus the | | soldiers and the police in Sweden seem to have been mindful of ‘he services ex- pected of them by the state. Even the paupers supported at public cost, when ordered to perform certain tasks, such as burying the dead at Stockholm, fear- ed to decline, dreading the cessation of the support now received from the pub- lic chest. A second major reason which accounts for the general strike’s missing fire is the quick-spreading alienation of public favor. The strikers themselves are sur- prised to find how numerous is the rest Where the gle is restricted to an out-and-ont fight of the community. strug: between a single trade or corporation and its operatives, and where a good prima-facie case can be made out for the strikers, public opinion ‘s generally in clined to support the more numerous party. People put up good-naturedly with no little inconvenience in the hope that it may aid the workmen. Put when the public {n the réle of amicus curiae has its toes stepped on is compelled to walk in rainy weather as well ag in sunshine, because of suspended transit; has to put itself on siege rations depend upon the police for the «listribu- tion of the children’s milk, the beauties of the general strike begin to fade, and a prompt clamor arises for stringent enforcement of the law, and, if nec- essary, for an industrial dictatorship to protect society at large from the war- ring factions. When cases growing out of such in- dustrial conflicts finally come u» before the courts, and the conduct of the par- ties defendant is scrutinized in the dry, cold light of statutes precedents, and the law is generally found to be pe- culiarly unsympathetic to these at- tempts to coerce employers auc inci- dentally to starve and incouvenience the public in the process part of our law in this country is more bearing on the Perhaps no conservative than that legality of strikes. Originally, at com- mon law, both in England and Amer- ica, all strikes were unlawful. This ex- treme position has long been vacated, but courts still restrict with extreme caution the objects for which a strike is a lawful expedient. Anything that 8a- vors of the boycott or the sympathetic strike is likely to be treated with short shrift. The sharp doctrine is laid down terms of the that only to better the strikers’ own employment is a strike and | shy a § lawful. Employees in public service cor- porations, moreover, are assimed to have obligations co-extensive kind with that of the corporation. So in many other trades and professions, striking is not the privilege of any moment. A sur- ———__—= = : in geon who suspended an operation to haggle for a higher remuneration would probably land where operations are lim. ited to picking oakum. universal Strike The final weakness in the strike is that it cuts both ways funds lose their efficiency when every- body is on strike. The story ia told of an ambitious young strategist ct West Point who asked h's instructor why for- tifications were not built in the form of a circle so as to be “equally strong all The opined that such a fort would be around.” gray-haired instructor “equal- Something of this ly weak all around.” kind is discovered in the general strike its instigators are going to starve s80- ciety into submission, and then discover that their own larder goes bare just a trifle before that of their opponents We doubtless shall have many sore trials before our industrial organization is perfected, but it is comforting to be- lieve that the general strike is rather more terrible on paper than in fact WRATH AND GOLF. We are glad to see the spectator questioning the legend of the infuriated golfer. It is one of the ancient conven- tions of golf—or of those who talk and write and make jokes and draw comic pictures about the game—that it con- stantly provokes its votaries to wrath, all But were ever largely has malice, and uncharitableness. if that certainly ceased to be so. It is indeed true, it the case that you will occasionally see an unfortunate player in a hideous bunker or trap, burying himself deeper in sand and bad language, but that is exceptional. The dear old stories about the golfer who in a fit of rage breaks every club in his bag, and vents his fury upon man and nature impartially, re- late to prehistoric times, even supposing The choleric of they were ever true. ma- jors, the passionate pilgrims the links, the caddies fleeing from the wrath to come, the scarred bosom of the fair green, the air quivering with profanity all this has more to do with the humor- ous tradition of the game than with its actual practice.
Page 8
178 The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2304 The present race of golfers are among the most equable-tempered and well- Watch them at thelr play, and you cannot but be struck with poised of mortals. the sedate way in which they go about it. Mental absorption, concentration of the whole physique, intent study of each shot, and a strained following of the flight and fall of the bali—these are the main things that impress the ob- server, and they are totally inconsistent with the intermittent explosions of un- which The devotees of the governable anger he may have been led to expect. links exhibit frequent gleams of jollity. They have their jokes with each other, their side remarks, their mock praise, all mates, and never violating the etiquette of the of their is melodramatic posing and violent out- their acid comment between inti- game—and a part fun cries, when calamity overtakes them, as if despair had seized them for its own. This may mislead the bystander, but the others know that it is only feigning. this fact, some the beloved tradi- Compelled to admit persons, steeped in tion of the wrathful golfer, put a wrong They say that becoming better tempered. interpretation upon it. golfers are If the Comminatory Service is not so often read on the links as it used to be, it is because men have grown ashamed of their senseless objurgations. They are convicted of sin by quiet and well- behaved companions, or, possibly, by the presence of ladies on the green or on the club-house piazza, and set about mending their manners. Their patience of the game itself, and they are less prone becomes schooled by the discipline than before to let the sun go down upon the links and their wrath at the same time Now, we are reluctant even to appear to take anything away from the moral glories of golf, and should be only too happy if we could make out the game to be the nursing-mother of all but the virtues; we fear the ugly fact is otherwise. It is not moral striving, the endless struggle for excellence that the avold but in the game, leads earnest golfer to tempestuous and un- seemly raging. of The acutest It is a question rather psycho- physics than of morals. analysis of golf shows it to differ from all other games in the degree of fixed at- tention it requires at the moment of the stroke. There is no reflex action to help the player. The game never becomes automatic. The impulse, the initiative, the summoning up of the whole man, have constantly to be under the golfer’s control, and he speedily discovers that he cannot get on without a nice nervous poise. He learns that the most trifling external accidents—a temporary indiges- tion, loss of sleep, business worry—will put him off his game mysteriously, and he is not fool enough to add anything in the way of internal excitement, if he can help it. An oath a hole is almost like giving his opponent a stroke a hole. avd heroic which he are only proofs that he is It is not If swearing more terribly than the army Hence, the self-restraint calmness under misfortune displays, trying to play the game well. a moral scruple that holds him in. in Flanders would cut his handicap, the air would be blue about him; but he is well aware that madness lies that way, The enoice of clubs is not more important as well as strokes over bugey. than the cultivation of an equal mind. Greater is he that ruleth his spirit, and maketh a fine recovery, than he who taketh a city, or captureth the gallery, by a brilliant drive. Ebullitions of rage mean not only bad taste, but a bad Herein lies the explanation of the fact that so many good golfers seem to to the mis- chances of their favorite sport, and to Sevis tran- quillus in undis, which may be translat- score. have steeled themselves have taken as their motto: “Don't get mad even if you crive ed, into a water hazard.” A WORD FOR AUTUMN. St. Nicholas for September prints a number of brief essays by boys and girls, written in a prize competition, upon the theme, “My Favorite Season— and Why.” Their excellence consists in the!r spontaneity and in their nat- ural, unsophisticated analysis of their delight in the out-of-doors life. The contributions are none the worse that they betray no inkling of a reminiscence of Thomson's But among those deemed worthy of the prizes there is none, if we except one, that sings the glories of Indian summer, which betrays a partiality for autumn. This predilec- tion for one of the other three seasons is characteristic not alone of children, but of their elders. Autumn is unquestionably the least “Seasons.” spectacular season. Spring appeals to the sense of novelty, to the expectation of release from confinement, to the pleasures of hope. With women, it is To them the earth’s “divine renewal” has almost universally the favor'te. a symbolical meaning which “mere man” cannot wholly perce've. If, in the spring, the young man’s fancy prover>- jally turns to thoughts of love, it turns thereto “lightly,” almost casually, and not improbably because the young man To the athletic temperament, summer is allur- has a touch of spring fever. ing. The sense of untrammelled free- dom in the out-of-doors, the escape from school tasks, from busi- ness, or the unalloyed delight in sport the vacat’on and exercise find in summer their fittest opportunity. On the other hand, winter has a double claim. The esthetic charm with their sports, tells in its favor. Winter, more- of snow and ice, zestful over, carries for the children the lure of Yuletide festivities, and for their eld- ers the pleasant sense of shut-in isola- tion and family solidarity peculiar to the open hearth. But it must not be forgotten that each season has the defects of its qualities. Spring, especially the early spring, :s varium et mutabile semper. Then you can never tell what a day may br'ng forth. The one thing certain is that it is dangerous to let the fire in the fur- nace go out. Neither the ground nor the temperature affords occasion for the hardy sports of winter, nor the vigorous out-of-doors existence that summer brings. The illness that mortal flesh is heir to is always lurking about the turn of the year, and every schoolmaster will bear witness that childhood’s epidemics usually cluster around the traditional spring vacation. The joys of summer are often purchased at a heavy cost. The conscious effort after bodily comfort is incessant. To speak of heat ani humidity and dust is superfluous, but every one has sympathized with Sidnev Smith, who “found there was nothing ‘left for it but to take off my flesh and sit in my bones.” But the discom- forts of wintertime are worse. Then, if ever, one agrees with Mr. Squeers in his verdict that “natur’ is a rum ‘un.” The white veil of snow which has 0 often been idealized means weeks of slush. The wizard architecture of Jack Frost means frozen water pipes and plumbers’ bills, not to mention the colds
Page 9
Aug. 26; 1909] The Nation. 179 = SSS and coughs and influenza that hold revel. To the eye of experience, therefore, the fall of the year may rightly have a claim as the most auspicious season No greater libel was ever uttered than the allegation that the closing days of November, the “saddest of the year,” are fairly typical of autumn. It is more than half due to the prejudice of the poets that the “season of mists and mel- low fruitfulness” bears so bad a name among its fellows. Whenever a rider of Pegasus feels lachrymose, he is almost sure to work !n some siander on the autumn. Thus Tennyson felt: Tears from the depth of some divine de- spair Rise in the heart and gather to the eyes In looking on the happy autumn fields. No wonder that he confessed he knew “not what they mean.” Here in sutumn, is found the even tenor of all the year as summer heat melts imperceptibly into the invigorating charm of cooler days. The harvests are all but gathered in. The grapes and apples and nuts presage a cheer that never attaches to the pre- carious peach crop. Even with its slow progress towards winter, the autumn is prodigal of gifts: When the frost is on the pumpkin, And the corn is in the shock. As one grows in years, performance and not promise takes an added value. It is broad-shouldered Ceres, with her lap full of good things, not the willowy and changeable “Aprille with his shoures soote,” that challenges our re gard. We come to dread the sudden change and climatic extremes. “Some- times too hot the eye of heaven doth shine” for us to remain quite unblinded by his rays. But in the clear light of the hunter’s moon we see things as they really are. THOMAS HOOD. ‘. It cannot be thought that a wew life of Hood was widely desired, nor does the writing* of Mr. Walter Jerrold show that charm of manner which makes us grateful for unimportant things. Yet, at least, the biography is the result of honest painstaking, and has the solid merit of correcting traditional errors and of offering a considerable amount of new material. It is well enough to be as- sured that the true date of Hood's birth in London was 1799; to have an exact *Thomas Hood: Hia Life and Times. By Walter Jerrold. New York: Jebn Lane Co. $5 net relation of his years in Scotland, 1815- 1817, when, according to Mr. Jerrold, his determination was formed to de- vote himself primarily to literature, rather than to engraving. and to know that h's marriage, in 1825, was not in opposition to the wishes of Miss Rey- nolds’s people and brought no bitterness to h's amiable heart. It may even be that there is still a sufficient number of admirers of Hood's humor and pathos —among whom, indeed, | count myself to justify the fuller printing of his mad letters and the telling of all his madder practical jokes. There may be some who will welcome the complete story of his stay on the Continent from 1835 to 1840, with its rollicking German friendships; who will read willingly the lengthened record of his struggle against fa‘ling health during his last five years | in England, and to hear his brave death- | bed profession of faith, almost his last remembered utterance: It's a beautiful world, and since I hav been lying here, I have thought of it more and more; it is not so bad, even humanly speaking, as people would make it out I have had some very happy days while I lived in it, and I could have wished to stay a little longer. But it is all for the best, and we shall all meet in a better world! Through the troubles and anxieties caused by illness and, it must be added, by imprudence in money matiers, Hood preserved this buoyant cheerfulness. One comfort comes trom this biogra phy—although Mr. Jerrold did not quite intend it—in dispelling the supposed tragedy of Hood's life, which would have him driven by grinding necessity to the production of vendible comicali- ties. At the very beginning of his ca- reer Barry Cornwall is exclaiming to a friend over the pity “that Hood should have given up serious poetry for the sake of cracking the shells of jokes which have not always a kernel”; and so the trad‘tion has been passed down to us of a fine creative artist who de- liberately diverted his talents to the pop- ular market, with all the misery of such a conscious degradation. There was, no doubt, a vein of delicate pathos in his genius, but no one can this l'fe without feeling that not the hateful res angusta but the inevitable bent of his mind made him from boyhood to the fading years of sickness the jester of England. His “National Tales” in prose (published early in 1827), de- liberate effort to prove his rights to an- read were a other name The ser'ous character of the generality of the stories [he says in his preface}, isa de viation from my former attempts, and I have received adv'ce enough, on that ac- count. to make me present them with some misgiving. But because | have jested else- where. it does not follow that I am incom- petent for gravity, of which any owl is capable; or proof against melan holy, which besets even the ass Those who can be touched by neither of these moods rank lower indeed than both of these creatures. It is from none of the player's amb tion, which has led the buffoon by a rash step into the tragic buskin, that I assume the sadder humor, but because I know from certain passages that such affections are for- eign to my nature life I have often been as “sad as night,” and not like the young gentlemen of France merely from wantonness, It is th« nor During my short time, con .rast of such leaden and golden fits that lends a double relish to our days. All which is perfectly true, but it did not save the “National Tales’ from be ing a flat failure. As for “Tylney Hal his attempt at sustained fiction, its char Dickens’: tas “the most extraordinar acter is indicated by praise wf jumble of extravagance and espec al Lamb's puns as “so neat, that foe to that sort of being expectant of might all thro’ and not find you out.’ II. in'mitable cqu'vocator impossible admiration the joke cleverness": or by of its most inveterate not ‘em, read it as the in words that Hood won a among his contemporaries, erd will be remembered. In Blackwood's Magazine for April, 1830, an unknown rhymster hit off a number of English writers in quatrains, ending with Hoo: It was reputation Impugn I dare not thee For I'm of puny brood Aad With pungent thou would’st punish hardinoop. me The foolish lines show the place of Hood in l'terature, though the puns em ployed are, as Mr. Jerrold rightly says, not at all of the genus that eave Hood his fame. His letters overrun with quib bling conceits; his pencil could scarcely draw a picture without a play in forms: hind of “the equ:vocation of his practical jests were a am phibology in the fiend!” the last, in wonder and dismay The fact is the pun has name in society, and Hood act we are likely to exclaim at got a bad dare we add Lamb also?—as its devotee would prob ably be shunned to-day as a Lore in any club of London or New York for this unpopularity of a once admired species of wit, for it ‘s subject to a woeful abuse. In his “Sh'r- Brooks of Punch” Mr. G. 8 gives too numerous illustrations of what the profession of to be; for horrid example There is some reason ley Layard punning soon came summer evening Thackeray arrived Punch He had given up a lady's dinner for a dinner with Lord John Russell, the litth left him in the lurch “So,” he come One late at the dinner and statesman had said, “I as a peas-aller to Mr. P. to eat my peas in peace.” “But mind your Q’s as well,” said Shirley, “and you must take your cues you must from me or I shall not excuse you.” Peculiar taste in entertainment! Let us pray for it an everlasting requiescat in pace. It should be added that the Victorian afterwits were not the first
Page 10
LO or only ones to bring the double-tongued Muse into contempt. Early in the forties of the eighteenth century, Mrs. El'za- beth Carter had planned a jeu d'esprit “The Whole Art and Mystery of Punning,” calculated “to ‘furnish the sweet nepenthe of nonsense in such co- pious streams as to water the face of the whole earth.” The prospectus should be perused by all intending sinners. “To on so great a height of perfection,” she declares, “have the authors of this work carried their design, as to lay down rules to divide, subdivide, compound, re- compound, decompound, rack, torture, strain, and quodlibetificate any word intd a pun by nineteen several ways of false spelling.” ITI. But the pun is not necessarily and was not always this criminal act of verbicide, as Oliver Wendell Holmes has called it; an evening with Theodore Hook, we may remember, could wring from Coleridge the exclamation that he was as great a gen‘us as Dante. There is a pleasant reward in going back now and then to the group of wits who treat- ed punning with the scrupulous delicacy of a fine art; and of this practice Hood, at least, so far as the litera scripta can decide, was the incomparable master. There is some exaggeration in saying, as a reviewer in the Spectator wrote not long ago, that “Hood’s pioneer work— Hood's own unique work—was the pun- ning ballad, which may be said not only to have begun, but in its best form to have died, with him.” That is to pass a little lightly over the work of many writers before Hood’s day; more particularly it is to forget the ballads of Goldsm'th, such, for instance, as the stanzas on “Mrs. Mary Blaize,” which would seem quite in place if found in “Hood's Own.” It is to forget also the excellent absurdities of the “Ingoldsby Legends” and other later works. Yet it is true that Hood remains the inap- proachable master of the pun in all its shades of excellence, and to understand his humor, and indeed his fancy, is to practise a useful discrimination among the different kinds of equivocation. Charles Lamb, as a connoisseur in the art, pointed the way to the right classi- fication, when, !n his remarks on the “Odes and Addresses,” he censured his friend not for excess of wit, but for the occasional use of the wrong sort of wit too What we allude to [he writes] Is a mix- of incompatible kinds; the perpetual of puna in these little effusions ture recurrence of humor; puns uncalled for, and perfectly gratuitous, a sort of make weight; puns, which, if missed, leave the sense and the drollery full and perfect without them. You may read any one of the addresses, and not catch a quibble In it, and it shall be just as good, nay better; for the addition of sald quibble only serves to puzzle with an un- necessary double meaning. A pun is good when it can rely on its single self; but, The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2304 called in as an accessary, it weakens—un- less it makes the humor, it enfeebleg it. What Lamb means, as becomes evi- dent from his comment on the humor of the “Ode to Joseph Grimaldi, Senior,” but what he does not quite say, is that the pun succeeds when it plays pri- marily on the double sense of a single word and not on the mere similarity in sound of two words. The Jate Canon Ainger, in his “Life of Hood,” comes closer to the real distinction, while hinting at a larger classification: Herbert, Crashaw, Donne [Lamb had made the same comparison with the “metaphysi- cal” poets], in like manner, have their abun- dant and perishable affectations. Yet all of these in turn show how true wit may sub- serve the highest aims of the Poet; and that in fact, so far from Wit and Poetry being irreconcilable, they shade and pass into one another by gradations quite imperceptible. Who shall decide, on the moment, whether Waller’s couplet— The soul's dark cottage, battered and decayed, Let in new light through chinks which time had made— is to be pronounced witty or poetical? The truth is that it is both; and that the two are fused, beyond possibility of separation, by the intensity and sincerity of the Truth enforced. Now Waller’s couplet, as Canon Ainger might have pointed out, is at once both poetical and witty just because it con- tains an uncertain play on words hover- ing midway between the true metaphor and the avowed quibble. Its position is clearer if we comyare it with two stanzas which turn on different equivo cations of the same word. In Cardinal Newman’s hymn— kindly Light gloom, Lead thou me on; the night is dark, and I am far from home; Lead thou me on, Lead, amid the encircling we have sheer poetry, with no suspicion of wit. The pun, if we may use the term in so generic a sense, lies in those physi- cal qualities of light which the mind has always and instinctively associated with the moral qualities of the spirit. There is an equivocation of ideas, if you insist; but without the clement of surprise, and springing from a deep similarity of emotional content. This is, properly speaking, metaphor. At the other extreme lies such a stanza as this epitaph on a lamp-lighter; Faithful at lighting lamps thou wast, Till soul and body grew so light, That one is wafted now with dust, While t’other shines a star of night. Here is the pun in its vulgarest form— a pure quibble, whose whole force is in the unity of sound of two distinct words “light” as opposed to dark and to heavy, and whose wit, if it have any, rests on the element of surprise alone. Between these two, the metaphorical and the quibbling use of the word, stands Waller's witty comparison, which is raised by its play on sense rather than sound above the quibble, yet which so dwells on the physical accessories of light, and so depends for its effect on the unexpected turn, as to be strictly, not a poetical metaphor, but a conceit. IV. These are the three terms of figura- tive speech—the quibble or base pun, the conceit, and the metaphsr. For the most part Hood ranges on a ground below the middle term and above the lowest—on a ground which way be des- ignated the legitimate pun. Not always, indeed; for at times, he, like other wits, forgets to resist the first temptation of his own cleverness. Thus a catch in an old Scotch ballad, “cauld, cauld, he lies beneath the deep,” may set him off on a long chase after words whose only association is their similarity of sound: But still that jolly mariner Took in no reef at all, For, in his pouch, confidingly, He wore a baby’s caul; A thing, as gossip-nurses know, That always brings a squall! The ensuing wave, with horrid foam, Rush'd o’er and cover'd all.— The jolly boatman’s drowning scream Was cmother’d by the squall,— Heaven never heard his cry, nor did The ocean heed his caul. But more often there is a kind of ac- companying twist in the situation it- self, playful or grotesque, which raises the humor above the exasperation of sheer verbicide, as in “Faithless Nelly Gray” or the less grewsome “Sally Brown”: O Sally Brown, O Sally Brown, How could you serve me so? I've met with many a breeze before, But never such a blow. And this twist may become the very substance of the humor, so that the play on words is lost in what may be called the equivocation of circumstances, or the pun in things themselves. So it is throughout the “Parental Ode”: Thou little tricksy Puck! With antic toys so funnily bestuck, Light as the singing bird that wings the air— (The door! the door! he'll tumble down the stair!) Vv. Hood’s manner of punning is an old story no doubt, and needs no iaterpre- ter. But it may not have been so often remarked that the trick pursues him even into his solemn moods; is, indeed, in more or less disguised form, one of his efficient instruments of pathos. There was a vein of melancholy in the man, nor was he, as he says, “incompe- tent for gravity.” He was in this respect like other humorists who have turned lightly from laughter to tears, but he differed from others in his ability to measure sadness with a conscious pun:
Page 11
Born of the secret soul's mistrust, To feel her fair ethereal wings Weigh’d down with vile degraded dust; Even the bright extremes of joy Bring on conclusions of disgust, Like the sweet blossoms of the May, Whose fragrance ends in must. O give her, then, her tribute just, Her sighs and tears, and musings holy! There is no music in the life That sounds with idiot laughter solely; There's not a string attuned to mirth, But has its chord in Melancholy. Perhaps it is the fatalistic pun lur- ing the mind from beneath the more man‘fest metaphor of may and must that gives a peculiar piquancy to these lines, as if under a masquerade of sorrow we should catch glimpses of « face not smiling, but itself sorrowing. Such an audacious quibbling with melancholy leads one to reflect on the intimate mix- ture of laughter and tears in some forms of art, on the slender partition in hu- man life between joy and sadness, or what may be called the ambiguity of the emotions. They stand so near together and pass so easily one into the other for the reason that their cause is so ambig- uous; for regret and disappointment, like the merry accidents of life, though to different ends, spring from a kind of disparity between expectation and event. The only peculiarity of Hood is that he uses the juggling with words more con- sciously than other poets to «xpress the juggling realities of fate. Thus, were it not for the harshness of the term, the ambiguity of sleep and morn and the soul’s secret mistrust in “The Death- Bed” might almost be called punning: We watch’d her breathing thro’ the night, Her breathing soft and low, As in her breast the wave of life Kept heaving to and fro! So silently we seem’d to speak— So slowly moved about! As we had lent her half our powers To eke her living out! Our very hopes belied our fears, Our fears our hopes belied— We thought her dying when she slept, And sleeping when she died! For when the morn came dim and sad— And chill with early showers, Her quiet eyelids closed—she had Another morn than ours! Is our perception here merely quick- ened by our familiarity with the equivo- cating habit of the writer, or has this habit really led him on more audaciously than others to that verge of sentiment where the _ in- strument of pathos is almost confused with that of humor? The latter is the case, I think; for I observe that he car- ries this same tendency not only into his other pathetic poems (making of this same likeness of sleep and death in one passage of his “Hero and Leander,” at least, a pure conceit), but into all the emotions. It would be tedious to hunt The Nation. out the various illustrations of this lurking wit in his poems of awe and regret and indignation and fancy; it would even tend to disconcert us !n our enjoyment of his delicate craftsmanship. Only one example I cannot pass over, for its comment on the ambiguous charm of beauty: O saw ye not fair Ines’ She’s gone into the Wes To dazzle when the sun is down, And rob the world of rest She took our daylight with her. The smiles that we love best, With morning blushes on her cheek, And pearls upon her breast. To Poe these lines had “an inexpressi- ble charm”—as indeed to whom have they not?—and I think it is not extrava- gant to say that some part here of that “petulant, impatient sorrow” (the word is too strong) which Poe connected with the incomplete realization of beauty in art, is due to the teasing duplicity in- troduced by the word “West.” The emo- tional impression of the whole poem is too fine and pure to class it as a con- ceit; it is metaphor of the truest sort Yet withal the realism of the action of the second line, the insistence on the similarity of physical motion, adds a certain whimsical element, as if a meta phor might at the same time be a conceit and—let us not say a pun, but— a play on words. Not the least or the in- terests attaching to Hood's werk is this persistent amphibology of his genius Better than in almost any other writer, we can, in him, follow poetic wit through all its gradations of quibbling and conceit and metaphor, where, in- deed, these are not blenied = to gether in a kind of sublimated punning We seem thus at times to come very close to the equivocation that lies in the human heart, too close, it may be, for the uses of great poetry. We are re- minded too coarsely that the powers of literature are only figures of speech, just as Brutus, after serving virtue for a lifetime, found it im the end, not a thing, but a word. P. E. M. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. In a recent letter giving some notes about that famous Italian book of wood-engrav- ings, the “Hypternomachia Poliphili,” Ven- ice, 1499, it is said that “an example has been acquired recently by Mr. J. Pierpont Morgan.” As a matter of fact, Mr. Morgan owns. and has owned for a long time, three copies of the first edition. One of these, in an old blue morocco eighteenth century binding, is perhaps the tallest copy known, the leaf measuring ful! 12% inches in height. It is from the Brayton Ives Libra- ry, and in the sale catalogue was described as “large paper” and as having been ‘bought from Morgand of Paris, and said by him to be unique.” All copies were no doubt originally alike paper, some having been trimmed than others Mr. Morgan acquired the book with the The- Irwin collection. His second copy as to closer odore ‘the sixteenth 181 only one-eighth inch shorter, is in citron morocco by Roger Payne, a fine and au- thentic specimen of the work of this fa- mous binder. It was formerly in the lection of Mark Masterman Sykes col and later ir that of James Toovey. The third copy from the Richard Bennett collection, is in a superb binding of brown morocco richly tooled, and bearing on each cover the fa mous device of Demetrio Carnevari, physi- cian to Pope Urban the VIII. Examples of books bound for him are as rare and as highly prized by collectors as those from the libraries of Grolier and Malol/ The book seems to have been of 80 much interest, even in early days, that special bindings were put upon many copies In the strictest use of the word it is not at all a rare book—probably a hundred copies might be traced—and while its value seems to hold in the auction room, it does not ma terlally increase. The Beckford copy, in an old Venetian binding, brought £130 in 1883, and the Turner copy £137 in 1888. These prices have, believe, been twice exceeded at public sale. Charles V's £151 in the Earl of Ashburnham’'s sale, June, 1897, and on November 3 of last year, £159 was paid for the Newton copy, blue Derome. This was a very tall copy, 12% inches, the same height as the Toovey-Morgan example Of the second edition of the book, which actually rarer than the first, and which was printed in Paris in 1545, Mr Morgan fine One is ‘n an Italian binding of brown morocco of the back sides very richly gilt and painted in colors. This volume was exhibited at the Burlington Fine Arts Club Exhibition 1891 The copy is in the original vellum covers The Third Quarterly Part of Karslake's “Book-Auction Record,” covering sales in we only ‘ opy brought in morocco by is no doubt has two very copies century, and in second London from April 1 to June 30, 1909, and recording 5,511 lots, is Just ready. But few items of exceptional rarity or interest are included in this part, the most notable be- ing the volume in old binding containing five pieces (or, more correctly, four, two having been published together) from the press of William Caxton. This volume, one of the most interesting of Caxton books to come into the years, was sold on May 21 to “Stanley” £2,600. It was, it is now reported, for the owner, and has since been dis posed of privately to Mr. J. W. Ellsworth of New York city Mr per- haps best known as the owner of the Brin- ley-Cole-Ives copy of the Gutenberg Bible and of the Daly set of the Four Folios of auction market in recent for “bought in” Elisworth is Shakespeare, although he is the owner cf many other rare books ( ‘ Ls a 7 J | , ; , orre spon ence. PRACTICAL EDUCATION To THE Epiror or THE NATION Str: Your editorial of August 5, upon “Studen: Activities,” continuing as it does a long series of adverse critic'sms upon uur present college administration, etates what is patently true, but fails, it seems to me, to give the fundamental! reason fo~ the ecl.pse of the curriculum by the “ac- tivities’ or to suggest any useful If the undergraduates at our colleges or in remedy
Page 12
182 the arts departments of our Eastern uni- versities concentrate their interest on ath- journalism, debating, fraternity management, and similar pursuits, it can- not be wholly due to their juvenility or barbirism If alumni habitually look back upon their college “activities” as the letics, most vaiuable part of their four years of undergraduate life, it cannot be all senti- mentalism There must be some radical failure on the part of the college itself to meet the wants of these young men It is a commonplace observation that the same youths who have idled through their college courses become enthusiastic work- e! in technical or professional schools; whereas only the grind—that is, the per- son who expects to turn his college course to advantage as a teacher, or as a means of paying his tuition through a scholar- ship-—takes the college work seriously. In the opinion of one whose fate it has been to teach in both Eastern and West- ern institutions, in large colleges and in small, the indifference of our undergrad- uate to his college studies arises from the absence of any more definite aim in his curriculum than “general culture.”" The courses offered and to some extent pre- scribed are those which every “gentleman” well know; but the undergraduate, confronting Latin Greek, the classical French or German authors, English literary mediwval and early modern his- economics, and the like, these subjects have for him intellectual interest and bear no vital to the life he will lead af- ter graduation, Toward the sciences taught as elementary subjects his attitude is more but there ithe of connection with the real world is felt In brief, the colleges offer studies of a purely intellectual character which certainly ought respect, but which certainly The student is not literary- minded, and it is idle to criticise him harshly for being what his family and busi- ness and social make him, and needless to wonder at his devoting himself to such interests as seem to him alive and might criticism, tory, realizes that abstract a purely relation favorable, even absence to command do not do so, interests real Under such circumstances, one may be allowed to doubt whether the sole rem- edy urged by the Nation year in and year out—namely, the exaction of more work and the imposition of severer examinations would prove Modern Amer- ican men are not likely to be made schol- efficacious arly by having general culture rammed down thelr throats The students would undoubtedly work enough harder to en- sure their remaining in the college, but they would continue to consider ‘college life’ as thelr real aim The problem is not to be solved rather by a searching study of the nature and oppor- so simply, but tunith of the college, as suggested by President Wilson in his recent Phi Beta Kappa address at Cambridge An experiment which the writer would be glad to see attempted would be the ef- fort by a college to meet the situation squarely as it existe. Taking the future business man, it might say to him: “We will fit you to live in the world of to-day, not by teaching you literary culture nor the rudiments of original research on one hand, nor typewriting and bookkeeping on the other, but by making you acquainted with the actual problems—economic, poll- | The Nation. | Vol. 89, No, 2304 —which every citizen is bound to confront. We will do this by prescribing courses in these subjects as thorough-going as those in any school of engineering or law. If you wish Latin or Greek or Anglo-Saxon or the history of mediwval Italy or the analy- sis of the Elizabethan literature, you may study these subjects here as electives or, better, at some university. This college prepares for the living world.”’ An insti- tution with such a programme, cutting loose from the English tradition of classi- cal culture or the German tradition of technical scholarship, might prove to be the means of elevating American citizenship. T. C, SMITH. Georgeville, Canada, August 9. {The exaction of more work kas not been proposed by the Nation as & pana- cea. The problem is to make culture real, not to throw it away because it is sometimes presented in an unreal fash- ion. And the first, but not the last, step toward reality is honest work.—Ep. THe NATION. ] EVOLUTION. To THE Eprror oF THE NATION: Str: That errors and defects may cxist in the theory of evolution, and in Darwin's own contribution to it, as “A Subscriber” asserts in your issue of August 6, is only natural to believe. It is hardly fair to expect that a radical innovation in human thought, which reversed or overthrew many previous conceptions, should spring into existence full-grown and nerfert, Rut oven if Darwin's theories were entirely discred- ited, the evolutionary hypothesis would doubtless still remain in some form or other. A common misconception of evolution seems to identify it with progress, with continuous betterment. It is constantly for- gotten that evolution is counterbalanced by dissolution; that growth is followed by de- cay. But it is impossible to demonstrate that the total of things is developing into a harmonious whole that passes, as Tenny- son would have the soul pass, “from state to state,” ever higher and more perfect. Rather is evolution to be considered as the development of separate existences, remote from each other in time and space, which, so far as we know, form no aggregate, slowly progressing under some super-evo- lution. Lower forms do change into higher (as well as higher into lower); but there is visible no gradual infinite progression of all lower forms simultaneously into higher. Nor is there evidence that any given set of forms has possibilities of unlimited de- velopment. When the solar system comes to an end, as it seems it must come. the race of men or even of supermen will not have left any contribution to the hierarchy of archangels whose existence Mr. Bernard Shaw poetically imagines as a future pos- sibility in direct line from the ameeba. This particular series of evolutions will have come to an end. Simultaneously perhaps myriads of other evolutions and dissolutions are going on, with no more permanent re- sults. Evolution attempts to deal only with the world of change, of the fleeting phenomena of mind and matter, and not with the First tical, scientific, philosophical, psychological more essential for evolutionary theory to explain this First Cause than it is for physical or biological theory to do so. They ali deal with the knowable and con- crete, and their validity can not be judged by their supposed relations to some thing or being whose very existence we can not conceive in terms of human reason. One philosopher’s idea of a tragedy was a de- duction killed by a fact; but there will probably be no fatal results in the attempt to reverse the process and kill a fairly well established scientific hypothesis by stating its supposed relation to something entirely beyond our ken. WARD SHEPARD. Cambridge, Mass., August 10. THE HYPNEROTOMACHIA. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Inasmuch as the recently published letters by Mr. John La Farge and by Mr. Gardner C. Teal ar: likely to awaken in- terest in the once-forgotten ‘“Hypnerotoma- chic Poliphili” of Fra Francesco Colonna, it may be worth the while to supply your readers with a few bibliographical data. (1.) The sixteenth-century English trans- lation of the “‘Hypnerotomachia,”’ 1592, was edited in 1890, by Andrew Lang, in the Tudor Library. This translation is appa- rently a much rarer book than the Italian original, 1499; at least, I infer from Mr. Lang’s introd.ction that the only complete copy is one in the Bodelian. (2.) Facsimiles of the woodcuts of the original Itali-n edition were published in 1889, by J. W. Appell, Ph.D., assistani keeper in the South Kensington, under the title: “The Dream of Poliphilus: Facsimiles of One Hundred and Sixty-Eight Woodcuts etc. Reproduced for the Department of Science and Art in Photo-Lithography,” by W. Griggs, 1889. (3.) The entire 1499 volume was reprinted in facsimile, in 1904, by Methuen & Co. This reprint is without a word of introduction or explanation. The price of the Appell volume was twelve shillings, sixpence. The Methuen re- print was issued at about two guineas. Mr. Teal says that he picked up his copy in London for less than a pound; he was lucky. Mr. Lang’s introduction is in his wonted style, readable but lacking in precision His chief reliance is upon Claude Popelin’s “Le Songe de Poliphile,”’ two volumes, 1880- 1883. Dr. Appell’s introduction, though brief, gives pretty much all the information one needs. Especially helpful are his ex- planations of the woodcuts. I should add that the reader ought to have the Atheneum review of the Methuen reprint, December 31, 1904, pp. 896-7, with Mr. W. C, F. Anderson's letter, Atheneum, January 25, 1905, p. 85. Here one’s atten- tion is called to the fact that in the origi- nal Italian edition of 1499 the date and place of issue are given in the colophon as Treviso, 1467 (!), but in the final errata page: “‘Venetiis Mense decembri. M.ID. in wdibus Aldi Manutii, accuratissime.”” The explanation is that the work was composed in 1467 at Treviso. In conclusion, Mr. La Farge’s enthusiasm is borne out by Dr. Appell's sober judg- Cause from which they proceed. It is no ment:
Page 13
Aug. 26, 1909] The Nation. 183 But if the Dream of Poliphilus displays little or no merit as a romance, it never- theless is a work full of curious details for the architect and suggestions for the orna- mentist; and it is also of great interest as an evidence of the current of thought and feeling in Italy during the fifteenth century. J. M. Harr. Corncli University, August 18. MEREDITH'S LETTERS, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Supplementing the announcement recently made in England and widely copied here that a collection of Mr. George Mere- dith’s letters is in preparation under the supervision of Lord Morley, Mr. William Meredith desires me to ask that any Amer- ican correspondents possessing letters, who may kindly be willing to place them in his hands, will forward them to me at this ad- dress, where careful copies will be made at once and forwarded to Mr. Meredith, the originals being returned immediately to their owners without the delay of transmis- sion to England. E, L. BURLINGAME. Scribner's Magazine, No. 153 Fifth Avenue, New York, August 19. Notes. Aleyn Lyell Reade is publishing a series of privately printed volumes, to be called “Johnsonian Gleanings.”’ His purpose is to deal with the less-known aspects of John- son’s life. Part I is now almost ready for publication. Henry Holt & Co. have ready for publica- tion “Hellas and Hesperia, or The Vitality of Greek Studies in America,”’ being three lectures by Professors Gildersleeve and Francis White. Thomas Whittaker publishes ‘““The Motor Boat,’ translated by Theodore E. Schulz from the text of W. Hantzschel Besides descriptive matter it contains a disinte- grable model of the boat for self-instruc- tion and for use in technical schools. M. Vicaire, a librarian of the Palais Maza- rin, has been appointed custodian of the Balzac collection bequeathed by M. Spoel- berch de Lovenjoul. The collection is to be kept at Chantilly, in the old convent of the Seurs de Saint-Joseph de Cluny. Some time this autumn Gilbert K. Ches- terton will publish, with John Lane Com- pany, a life of Bernard Shaw, under the title of an “Illustrated Biography.” It ‘ought to be, in view of the relations be- tween author and subject, hugely merry reading. The Macmillan Company announces the following volumes to be issued this autumn: “A Life for a Life,” by Robert Herrick; “Martin Eden,” by Jack London; “Stra- della,” by Marion Crawford; “A Gentle Knight of Old Brandenburg,” by Charles Major; “The Backwoodsmen,” by C. G. D. Roberts; “The Human Cobweb,” by Putnam Weale; “Discoveries and Adventures in Tib- et,” by Sven Hedin; “Labrador,” by Dr. W. T. Grenfell; “Mexico,” by W. E. Carson; “The New New York,” by J. C. Van Dyke, illustrated by Joseph Pennell; “The Way- farer in New York”; “The Picturesque Hudson,” by Clifton Johnson; “One Day and Another,” by E. V. Lucas; “Daniel Boone and the Wilderness Road,” by H. A. Bruce; “My Day: Reminiscences of a Long Life,” by Mrs. R. A. Pryor. Also, a new novel by Winston Churchi!! and another by Zona Gale; a volume on contemporary nov- elists, by Professor Phelps; a narrative, by Prof. Frederick Paxson, of the conquest of America’s last frontier; a volume of essays by J. R. Rhodes, and other works of sociolo- gy, economics, religion, science, and phil- osophy. The autumn publications of Charles Scribner’s Sons includ: the following titles “John Marvel, Assistant by T. N Page; “The Arabian Nights edited by K D. Wiggin and N. A. Smith Posson Jone’ and Pére Raphaél,” by G W. Cable; “Ste- venson’s Child's Garden of Verses”; “Home Letters of General Sherman,” edited by M A. DeW. Howe; “The Re'at'ons of the United States with Spain,’ by Rear-Admir- al F. E. Chadwick; ‘‘T! Birth of Modern Italy,” by J. W. Mario The Servian Peo- ple,” by Prince Lazarovich-Hrebelianovich; “Society and Politics in Ancient Rome: Es- says and Sketches,” by Prof. F. F. Abbott; “The Universities of Ancient Greece,” by J. W. H. Walden; “Narratives of New Neth erland,”’ edited by Dr. J. F. Jameson; ‘‘Rec- ollections of a Long Life,”” by Lord Broughton; “Pepys,” by Percy Lub- bock; “The Return f the Bourbons, 1814-1815," translated from the French of Gilbert Stenger by Mrs. R. Stawell; “The Letters of Percy Bysshe Shelley,”’ collected and edited by Roger Ingpen; “A Rose of Savoy: Marie Adelaide of Savoy, Duchesse de Bourgogne, Mother of Louis XV,."" by H N. Williams; “Memoirs of the Duchess of Dino,” edited by Princess Radziwill née Castellane; “‘The Gateway to the Sahara,” by C. W. Furlong; “American Prose Mas- ters,”’ by W. C. Brownell The Mystery of Education and Other Academic Perform- by Barrett Wendell; “The French Renaissance in England by Sidney Lee: “The White Bees and Other Poems,” by Henry van Dyke; “How to Be Happy Though Civil,” by Rev. E. J. Hardy; “The American of the Future and Other Essays,” by Brander Matthews Sixty Years with the Bible,” by W. N. Clarke; “Privilege and Democracy in America,” by F. C Howe; “Forty Minutes Late, and Other Stories,” by F. H. Smith; “Mr. Justice Ratfles,”” by E. W. Hornung; a new vol ume of stories by Richard Harding Davis: “True Tilda,” by A. T. Quiller-Couch; “Sea Breezes,"’ by W. W. Jacob A Romance o the Nursery,” by L. A. Harker; “Church Unity,” by C. A. Briggs; “The Problem of Human Life,”’ by Randolph Eucken; ‘The Boy’s Catlin,” by George Catlin, edited by M. G. Humphreys; “College Years,” by R D. Paine; “On the Old Kearsarge,”’ by C T. Brady; “The Boy Pioneers,”” by Dan Beard, and “The Story of Rustem and Other Persian Hero Tales from Firdusi,” by E. D. Renninger ances,’ ‘ We take pleasure in calling attention to Thomas Mosher’s dainty print of Brown- ing’s ‘Rabbi ben Ezra It is preceded by the “Prospice” and followed by the “Epi- logue.” With unflagging zest we have gone through, actual reading not sampling, the anthology in prose and verse gathered by Helen and Lewis Melville, under the title of “London's Lure” (The Macmillan Co.) The subject lends a kind of unity in variety to the thoughts of many men, and the whole answers to the somewhat confused impres- sion left by the city on the mind of a visitor. We commend the little book for its excellent entertainment. As « piece of magnificent book-making the two-volume quarto edition of Spenser's “Faeric Queene,” printed at the Cambridge University Press, and sold by G. P. Put nam’s Sons, takes precedence of anything we have handled for some time. The edi- tion is limited to 350 copies, and the type has beor distributed. The text is a literal reproduction (with modern « and vr, and a few obvious misprints corrected) of the edition of 1596 in two volumes quarto, The fragment of Book vii is from the follo of 1609; the letter to Sir Walter Raleigh end the verges addressed to and from Spenser are from the edition of 1590. The accuracy of the text it is safe to assume knowing the nature of the work turned out bv the Cambriuge University Press In general the writer of this note sees no profit in the reproduction of the Elizabethan spell- ing Why, he would ask, should any pe- dantic barrier be placed between the mean- ing of Snakespeare or Sidney and the mind of the ordinary reader? But in the case of Spenser there is a difference. Here the languerve is a more or less artificial crea tion of the poet's, depending in part for its savor on the quaint form of the words The editors of the present edition, as were their predecessors, are wise in anol attempting to straighten out or modernize Spenser's strange or- thoepy. As for the form of these two volumes, it must be acknowledged that their size and weight make them impossi- ble for holding in the hand. But on a book rest, these clean handsome pages would be a lure to follow the winding track of the faerie crew through forest and mea- low, by stream and lake, into aery palace and loathsome dungeon. Spenser is called the pcets’ poet, and the saying, we fear, is an excuse for all but poets to let him alone. The luxurious few who can read him n this new edition may have occasion to learn more perfectly the magic and insub- stantial beauties of his world. No poem of England begins with more winsome ro mance: A Gentle Knight was pricking on the pilaine none ends in a graver ecstasy: O! that great Sabbaoth God, grant me that Saba otha sight . And between these limits what a long Jour- ney of ever-changing entertainment. “The Oxford English Dictionary,’ with ita latest double section prepared by Henry Bradley, enters upon the letier 8S and pro- ceeds to Sauce, recording 3,886 words—3,557 han are found in the corresponding portion of Johnson. But what could the in- more sular lexicographer know of the East In- dian sabdariffa, good for cooling drinks; of the Cuban wood, sabicu, excellent for hardness; of the Russian antelope, saiga; of the evergreen shrub known in the Chi- nook jargon as salal; of the Canadian sas- katoon, combining the luscious virtues of currant and bilberry; or of the West Afri- can sassy, an efficient decoction for detect- ing witchcraft? Such stuff is English mate of. Even “sashy” or “‘sashay,”’ a humorous corruption of chassé introduced by O. W. Holmes in “Elsie Venner,” is admitted by
Page 14
184. our courteous host of words into the sacred precincts; and though the word now stands marked “U. 8. vulgar,” it has acquired a kind of function of its own, and may yet its way among its betters. Speaking Americanisms, we note by the way thai ’ is marked “U. 8S." and defined make of Ssauce-manbn as ‘one who deals in vegetables.”” “U. 8." is a large place, and may no doubt contain some obscure sauce-men vending vege- tables, but the present reviewer, who has bought divers kinds of garden products on both coasts and at several intermediate points from dealers of various nationalities, has never met a sauce-man, and knows of no else Lest some humorous Bri- ton, building on this dictionary, dilate fool- upon the curiosities of the American were well that such provincial- one who has ishly dialect, it isms should be labelled with the name of the particular locality to which they be- long As the editor points out, this section contains no long articles and compara- tively few words showing an interesting sense-development “Sake” is an excep- tion with a curious history. In the Anglo- Saxon times it meant for the most part something unpleasant—a lawsuit, strife The Hell-fiend Grendel in “Beo- contention wulf wreaked his hate on Hrothgar in constant “sake” (saece). In the fourteenth century “Harrowing of Hell” ‘“‘withouten sake" means “without cause.” In the Cursor Mundi,” 1300, the word approaches the modern use, but with an odd difference, the that Herod “For crist in assertion sake the childer slogh.’"’ Unless we bear in mind this neutral signification of the word in reading Genesis iil, 17—‘Unto Adam he sald, cursed is the ground for thy sake’’—we shall make God himself the author of a very bitter paradox. It is a strange pilgrimage this little symbol has made from the place where it stood for wrath to the breathless place at the end of a Christian prayer. On the other hand, there is a large group of words in this section which jllustrates the strong Roche- foucauldian tendency of the popular mind. The an and democratic soul hears of supreme virtues with a confidently skepti- In the pious Middle Ages plebe cal inward grin one could aspire no higher than to the praise of ‘“‘saintliness’’; nowadays the word has lost most of its desirable lustre—we rather avoid that sort of person More marked is jhe degeneration of ‘‘sanctimo nious’; in the sixteenth century it ordi- narily suggested perfect holiness; in the twentieth, it ordinarily suggests perfect Pecksniff Sacrifice’ is another fallen word; of old, it meant something on the altar; to-day it means something on the bargain counter. “Sapient,” too, has sunk; formerly it was applied to the Ruler of the Universe; in this age it would almost offend a Solon from Oklahoma, or a Senator from I}Iinols. Deepest of all has been the deg- radation of “sanctum sanctorum"’; In the elder time it was the word for the “Holy of Hollies” in the Jewish tabernacle; now it is the word for the inaccessible office of a journalist.—Deposuit potentea de sede, et eraltacit humiles Baron de Belabre, for some years French consul at Rhodes, spent part of his time on that Island in studying the fortifica- tions and palaces of the Knights of St. “John. tion (“Rhodes of the Knights’’; Henry Frowde), in which he gives, not a new history of the Order of St. John, but a most careful description of those monu- ments of the knights which still exist in The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2304 The result is a scholarly publica- New York: Rhodes, with glimpses of the social and military life of their builders. The treat- ment is in the main topographical, but, perforce, historical too. The author is master of all that has been written on the subject, and surpasses his predecessors in his diligent study of the remains at first- hand. He conducts his reader successive- ly about the various walls, the Grand Mas- ter’s Palace, the auberges of the different countries, the hospital, the town, and the remains outside the walls. He intersperses anecdotes agreeably, and much interesting information, such as the fact that the pres- ent Rhodian Jews are descendants of those who inhabited the city in the days of the knights, and that they still speak Span- ish. Most of the photographs with which the book is illustrated are unique, and were taken from places to which access is usual- ly denied. Students of political science will wel- come Walter F. Dodd's “Government of the District of Columbia” (Washington: John Byrne & Co.), while regretting that the work should not have been shorn of some of its crudities. Mr. Dodd has appar- ently thought it incumbent upon him to pack his book as full of information as possible, with the result, especially in the chapters devoted to the work of the vari- pus administrative bureaus, that many pages in the aggregate are filled with minor details having nothing to do with govern- ment and of interest only to an official. Detailed recital of the routine duties of a fireman or policeman, for example, pre- sents absolutely nothing that is not com- mon to every sizable community in the country, and is entirely out of place in a work which claims to be a work of scho!- arship. Equally useless and extraneous are the elementary disquisitions on duty, morals, and reform with which a number of the chapters are prefaced. Those who are likely to resort most to the book may be presumed to know that “it is the duty of every man to take care of himself and to provide for his family,” and that ‘‘de- fective plumbing is one of the most fre- quent causes of disease."”” With these ex- ceptions, the task of research has been carefully and thoroughly done, and the nar- rative, if dry and unadorned beyond that of most monographs, is at least clear and orderly. Benjamin Franklin, one hundred and six- teen years ago, published his conviction that in the centre of the earth all sub- stances would be converted into gas, or, as he called it, air, if temperature went on increasing towards the centre. This the- ory is probably correct, says Mr. R. D. Oldham in the Geographical Journal for August. He shows by a comparison of the rates of travel of the earthquake tremors and waves, as recorded by the various seis- mographs in different parts of the world, that “in the centre of the earth, extending certainly to not more than half, and, very likely, not to more than four-tenths of the radius, there is material which behaves very differently from that which lies out- side of it. In thie central core the rate of travel of the first preliminary tremor is checked and reduced by about one-tenth, while the waves of the second phase are elther stopped altogether or propagated but feebly, with their rate of travel re- duced by one-half.”” Evidently the suf- fragettes have been successful in Ghat in the meeting-place of the Saharan caravans, for the Governor, Jamy Bey, says that “‘tyr- annized over by their wives, the poor men have no liberty. This is by reason of the laws of inheritance by which all the real estate is the property of the women.”” The border region between the Uganda Protec- torate and the Congo State is described by Major R. G. T. Bright, the chief of the Boundary Commission. Of the pygmies he says that though both sexes are completely nude, the standard of morality is high, and, “strange to say, they are remarkably in- telligent.”” Some elaborate observat.ons on “dew-ponds” are contributed by Mr. E. A. Martin, F.G.S. The maps are of the Ru- weazori region and northwest Rhodesia. With “Meditazioni filosofiche inedite di Vincenzo Gioberti” (Barbéra, Florence) and “Vincenzo Gioberii, frammenti inediti” (Bocca, Turin), Edmondo Solmi has begun the publication of selections from the Gio- berti manuscripts, now in the Biblioteca civica of Turin. The ‘“‘Meditazioni” is made up of youthful essays, written before 1825, while the other volume includes ‘‘La teorica della mente umana,”’ “Rosmini e i Rosmi- niani,” and “‘La liberta cattolica,”’ some of the latest unpublished writings of this pre- cursor of the Modernist movement. In preparation for the coming centenary of the University of Berlin, Prof. Erich Schmidt, for over twenty years a member of the Berlin faculty, has been elected rec- tor of the university for the period 1909-16. Professor Schmidt came to Berlin in 1887 as the successor of Wilhelm Scherer, and has enjoyed exceptional popularity. not merely as the discoverer of the Goethe “Urfaust,” but as a man of science de- void of the cobwebs and must of tradition. His wide acquaintance with foreigners, es- pecially perhaps Americans, English, and French, should contribute to his arduous work of arranging for one of the most notable dates in the history of Berlin. Samuel A. Clarke, eighty-two years old, for many years librarian in the General Land Office and Department of the Interior, Washington, died at Salem, Ore., August 20. He was for a long time editor of the Portland Oregonian and published several historical works dealing with the State, George Cabot Lodge, son and private secretary of United States Senator Henry Cabot Lodge, died on Sunday at the age of thirty-five. He served in the navy throughout the Spanish-American war as an ensign. Shortly after the termination of hostilities he became his father’s sec- retary. Mr. Lodge was the author of a drama, “‘Cain,”’ and of several volumes of verse: “Song of the Wave" (1898), “Poems” (1902), and “The Great Adven- ture’ (1905). From London comes the report of the death of Sir Theodore Martin, the well- known translator of Heine, Goethe, Dante, Horace, and Virgil. He was born in Edin- burgh in 1816, and was the dean of English writers and pariiamentary agents. Be-
Page 15
Aug. 26, 1909] sides his translations he wrote several biographies, the chief of which was the “Life of the Prince Consort,” in five vol- umes, which was composed in collaboration with Queen Victoria. The death is announced, in his seventy- third year, of Adolf Hausrath, professor of ecclesiastical history in the University of Heidelberg. Among his publications are “Konrad von Marburg,” “‘Apostel Paulus,”’ “‘Neutestamentliche Zeitgeschichte,” “‘David Fr. Strauss und die Theologie seiner Zeit,” “Luthers Leben,"’ and severa] romances Another death, that of Adalbert Merx, the Orientalist, has occurred in the facul- ty of Heidelberg. Prof. Merx was seventy one years old and had been at the univer- sity since 1875. He had published a long list of Biblical and Oriental studies, includ- ing “Die canonischen Evangelien nach ihrem Altesten Texte.” ROMAN LETTERS. A Literary History of Rome, from the Origins to the Close of the Golden Age. By J. Wight Duff, M.A., Profes- sor of Classics, Armstrong College (in the University of Durham), Newcas- tle-upon-Tyne. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. 695 pages. $4.00. This history, or, rather, partial his- tory, of Roman literature forms the tenth volume in Mr. Fisher Unwin’'s “Library of Literary History.” This fact may suggest its general plan, and also explain its incompleteness—for the history of Roman literature is a long- er story than some of the similar his- tories already issued in the series, say, for Ireland, Scotland, or America. Per- haps it is the publisher’s intention to devote two volumes to Rome, as has been done for the literature of Persia In that case, we hope that the second part may be assigned to as capable hands as the first. Professor Duff’s book is a good, schol- arly piece of work. It is written pro- fessedly for the general reader, but even the professional student of Latin may read it with much pleasure and profit. Throughout the volume he insists upon the permanence of the Roman type, and wisely emphasizes the national aspects of the literature; for “the Roman bor- rowed in a Roman way.” His critical judgments are usually sound and well expressed, and one gets the pleasant im- pression that they are based on his own reading of all the authors concerned. The volume begins with a long intro- duction, of 57 pages, on the descent of the Romans, their language, character, and religion. This is an attempt to set forth the complex heredity of the peo- ple and their literature, and to discuss some of the “determining facts of ex- istence which constituted the Roman en- vironment.” Here the author grapples with some difficult questions, such as the relationship of the Italic tribes, the influence of the Italic dialects upon Latin, and the characteristics of pleb- The Nation. eian Latin. It is hard), some of his results are rather hagy or uncertain—“linguistic connection does not settle racial connec'ion.” And after all that has peen learned, or guessed, in much philological and ep'graphical re- search, some of his linzuistic questions must still wait for the accumulation of more evidence. The history proper is main periods: the earl'er literature of the Republic (from the origins to 70 B. c.) and the literature of the Golden Age, the second period being subdivided into the Ciceronian age (70 p. c. to 43 B. c.) and the Augustan age (43 pn. c. to 14 a. p.). The sketches of Ennius, Plautus, Varro, and Cicero are all good, and, as is apt tc happen in an English book, the chapter on Virgil is excellent. For the beauty of Virgil’s style still ap peals to the best English scholars: But it is to beauty that, like Dante, one returns as the final fact and feature of his style. Under Virgil's verbal sorcery, Latin becomes a golden language of ex- quisite richness, veined with a delicate mel- ancholy and wistful reverie upon the abua- dant travail of life. If his wealth of trem- ulous pities and mystic dreams do not make true poetry, then poetry was never written. his fault that livided into two The illustrative passages which are introduced to support the author's crit- icisms are given in English transla- tions, with the Latin relegated to notes. And the translations are always good Witness the teeth-chattering of the half- drowned Labrax (Plautus, “Rudens,” 533): If I only had luck to be a du-duck, So that all the wa-water would leave back dry! my Utinam fortuna nunc anetina ut-uterer, Ut, quom exissem ex aqu-aqu-aqua, ar- arerem tamen! Horace’s adventure with the bore is translated in prose as a dramatic sketch, and the two universal favorites, “Pene insularum, Sirmio” and “O Fons Bandusiz,” are cleverly turned into son- nets. Sometimes the reader is treated to a modern instance. On p. 244 we are told that Horace’s imitations of Lucilius, to compare great things with small, are “like Max O’Rell’s copying, in ‘L’Ami Macdonald,’ of Dean Ramsay's Scottish stories.” The atomic theory expounded by Lucretius “is still for scientific thought its basic hypothesis. Even in the light of the flashes of the spinthari- scope which merk the off-shooting of helium atoms from radium, it is not more than a modification of nomencla- ture that is necessary” (p. 289). And on p. 608 we are assured that Ovid real- ly deserves more handsome commenda- tion than Quintilian’s, “which is the ex- act counterpart of the fabled curate’s remark on an unsatisfactory egg—law- dandus tamen in partibus.” But the most striking parallel in the volume is 185 the comparison of Lucretius and his comprehensive icve of nature with Whit- man: Both rationalist, though Whitman Is less systematic; both at times prosaic and care- less of form, though Whitman Is excessively 80; both frankly approaching all processes of life in their naked simplicity; both per- haps seeking, though Whitman more evi- dently, for some ideal essence behind things, they are in nothing more alike than in their sense of the open and delight in the free growth that is in nature Lucre- tius, it is true, looks on the scheme of things with something of the enjoyment felt by the spec tator of a@ great tragedy He feels both horror and woluptas. But if he bas not Whitman's violent dithyrambic raptures over each throb of universal nature, his love is not less reali because more restrain ed, The parallel is resolutely drawn, but it requires too many “thoughs.” Professor Dufi escapes the charge of insularity which has sometimes been brought against his countrymen, by showing a wide acquaintance with the work of German, French, and American scholars. His decisions on d‘sputed questions will, of course, not satisfy everybody, but he is always scrupulous- ly fair and courteous. He js surely right in rejecting the contention of Bahrens that the “Albius” of Horace is not the poet Tibullus. And he is as surely wrong in accepting Skutsch’s reckless guess- ing as to Virgil’s indebtedness to Cor nelius Gallus in the sixth and tenth Eclogues. One or two other details may be men- tioned here. It is hardly worth say- ing (p. 90) that the Fescennine masque was the lineal ancestor of pastoral amebean verses like those in Virgil's Eclogues, without adding that Virgil had a very definite model for his ameebean lines in the Idyls of Theo. critus. And one who is very jealous for Virgil may fairly protest against the statement (p. 441) that “Ecl. viii, 58, omnia uel medium fiant mare, 18 4 blunder for SivadAa The general model of the passage is doubtless Theocritus, but the details are changed, and it can hardly be called a translation at all. On p. 281 we are told that Lucretius’s invocation to Venus “may have been suggested by the fact that Memmius was son-in-law to Sulla, who was devoted to the goddess.” This may be new, but it is not very convinc- ing. And it scarcely harmonizes with the statement (p. 295) that the Venus of the invocation is “a reminiscence of the Aphrodite of Empedocles.” The book is well printed, on good pa- per, and the proof-reading has been very carefully done. “Though” for “thou,” p. 541, 1. 25, is a rather lonely error And if “Mev‘us is the better spelling” for the enemy of Horace and Virgil, p 615, the “Mm@vius” of pp. 273, 480, 505 m'‘ght be changed. wavra yévaro.”
Page 16
186 CURRENT FICTION, The Hungry Heart. By David Graham Phillips. New York: D. .ppleton &@ Co. If Mr. Phillips, with his fondness for exposing the weaknesses of polite soci- ety, has always a good deal about him of the bull in the china shor, there is no doubting his sincerity or denying his vigor. He is a voice of the Middle West; he speaks, without conscious pose, as a plain man of the people, which is to say, the people of the class and district from which he came. There is a something impressive as well as comic in his insistent expression of a conviction that the East is really little better than the home of effeteness and affectation. We recall how, but re- cently, “Joshua Craig’’ made ravage up- on the Atlantic seaboard, tringing to confusion all persons who were so luck- less as to have been bred or educated to the fair, false Eastern The present hero's mid-West- ernism is less rampant than Joshua’s, but, despite his respect for his grand- father, his cultivation, and his “long, aristocratic face,” he is plainly differen- in his creator’s mind from the Gallatin, whose artificiality and proclaim him from the according method. tiated Basil spinelessness East The story belongs to the general order of “The Helpmate’” and “Together.” That is, it is a study of modern mar- ried life, and begins where the old-fash- ioned novel used to end. Courtney Vaughan is a woman whose mind has survived social and college training. She has married with a high ideal of love, but shortly after her brief honey- moon discovers that her husband cares only for her physical charm, and has not the notion of making an intel- lectual companion of her. He has the old conception of a wife as a house- keeper and plaything. She is not con- tent, and falls into the hands of Galla- tin, whose love for her, she thinks, is of a more exalted kind. In time this illusion is destroyed. She sees him for a weakling; but clings to the poor shadow of their love, as all that is left least for her. Then the crash comes; the husband discovers the situation. Here the unexpected begins to happen. Vaughan, who up to this time has seemed a man of singularly narrow and dull apprehension, develops sudden tn- telligence and magnanimity. He offers Courtney her freedom, and even her child Mr. Phillips has acquired a considera- ble popular reputation as a man who tella the truth as he sees it. In fact, his method unites realism and didacticism in such proportions as naturally to com- mand, in his treatment of problems of sex, a large, if feminine, audience. Heart” is a _ vigorous “The Hungry The Nation: [Vol. 89, No. 2304 the invertebrate philanderer. Richard Vaughan is, if you take him literally, rather absurd. His character is not de- veloped: suddenly, at the proper time, he ceases to be one person and becomes another, by a process of conversion as violent and conventional as that of brother Oliver in “As You Like It.” ‘n the other hand, we may record with pleasure the impression that in Court- ney Vaughan, with all her inconsisten- cies and failings, Mr. Phillips has come nearer the creation of a living human person than ever before. Kingsmead. By Bettina von Hutten. New York. Dodd, Mead & Co. This is another of the Baroness von Hutten’s sequels. Here again (though receding into the background) Pam fig- ures, here the Brigit Mead, who loved a great violinist and became Lady Pon- tefract, here the Tommy who appeared incidentally as Brigit’s brother in “The Halo.” Here, finally, one may see Pam’s daughter Pammy steadily edging toward the foreground, a large and greeay young girl, who, we are told, is going to be good-looking some day. Obviously, she is to be the next heroine in the series. Meantime, Tommy, Lord Kings- mead, holds the floor, and for heroine we are forced to put up with an adven- turess of whom, presumably, we shall hear nothing more. She is, to tell the truth, rather preposterous: a shy, large- eyed damsel, who always carries a sil- ver mirror (whereby hangs a tale) and wears mignonette. She passes for a wid- ow, but damsel she is, and with a past. Tommy's bosom friend loves her, and Tommy does his best to marry them. But when it is almost too late, he dis- covers at the same moment, that he him- self loves her and that she is a fraud. Her past turns out to be lamentable— she tells Tommy all about it and she loves Tommy; but she still proposes to marry the friend. Tommy prevents this, and will have none of her himself. The curtain falls upon the “Mignonette Lady,” leaving her silver mirror in ‘’ommy’s hand, for remembrance, and rather piteously taking herself out of his life. If it were not for her persistent designs upon the bosom friend, and her attempts to get Tommy to keep her story from him, we should find it pos- sible to pity her more, and we shouid incline to despise Tommy for his squeamishness. As matters stand, we assent that he and the bosom friend are well rid of her. We suspect that Pammy’s forthcoming love-story will be not unconnected with Tommy's sober second thought. The tale is told with that air of light- hearted inconsequence which gives this popular novelist her charm. She ac- knowledges in a brief and good-humor- ed preface the discrepancies which “the tract. Basi! Gallatin is a fair type of series of novels. Witnout especial nim- bleness, one may find incongruities and contradictions in abundance within the bounds of the present story. A False Position. By Mrs. Baillie Rey- nolds. New York: Brentano’s. It is a pity that the qualification of a book as suitable reading for a young girl and safe to be admitted into the family circle, should commonly be ac- cepted as a sneer by implication. There is no reason why simple and wholesome themes should be relegated to the hands oi incompetence; pathology need not enlist the services of all the expert: but of late, there has arisen some- what of a cult that holds only the ab- normal and diseased worthy of skilled treatment. Mrs. Reynolds’s latest book is a pleasant rebuke to this fallacy. Its characters are neither consistently vil- lanous nor consistently heroic, but fal- lible humans trying for betterment, and if one must admit that they are a bit bourgeois, they do not differ in that respect from the majority of readers. Mrs. Reynolds has taken the cold but in- exhaustible theme that truth is the only safe foundation for every degree of human intimacy, and elaborates it with grace and ingenuity. The tangled threads of the plot are unravelled at the end with a minimum of breakage, and though no single figure may have impressed itself upon the mind as a salient and individual creation, one is left with the comfortable sense of hav- ing been amused and interested without a waste of time or an aftermath of un- pleasant recollection. Less Than Kin. By Alice Duer Miller. New York: Henry Holt & Co. The black sheep of an excellent fam- ily in the United States dies obscurely of drink in a South American republic after an absence of several years. On the brink of political imprisonment an exil- ed countryman of his, handsome, reck- less, yet in the main, thoroughly admir- able, goes North and presents himself as the returned prodigal. It is an old plot but a new author and a new story. If you can tell what is going to be done or be said from one page to the next, you are more astute than the present reviewer. If you can absent yourself from this two hours’ diversion before it is ended, your bump of curiosity must be insignificant—the Ancient Mariner could never have held you like a three- years’ child. The story is witty, terse, and swift. For a narrative so light, bent purely at amusement, the character‘za- tion is surprisingly sharp and vivacious. In fact, Nellie, the inflexible dogmatic young woman in the case comes pretty near being a very memorable creature. Wherever she appears, the sparks fly. nimble critic” may find In her “Pam” It would be unjust to the reader further
Page 17
Aug. 26, 1909} The Na tion. 187 to uncork the novel champagne of her personality. So crisp is the dialogue, so unconventional the action that it will be astonishing if some ene of our needy playwrights does not turn “Less Than Kin” into a charming little farce- comedy. LOUIS XVII. The King Who Never Reigned: Me mo'rs upon Louis XVII. Edited, with introduction and notes, by Maurice Vitrac and Arnold Galopin. To which is added Joseph Turquan’s New L’git upon the Fate of Louis XVII. New York: The John McBride Co. $3.50 net. The Little Dauphin. By Catherine Welch. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $1.50 net. It is recorded of Lord Beaconsfield that he once said to a young man anx- ious to shine in society: “Never inquire who the man in the Iron Mask was, or you will be thought a bore.” But, not- withstanding the advice of Disraeli, the tragedies of royal houses will always make their appeal. The identity of the masked prisoner, of Gaspard Hauser, and the fate of the son of Louis XVI are questions that will not down perma- nently. Of late there has been a decided revival of interest, in France and Eng- land, in the history of the young Dauphin, wko did, or did not, die in the Temple, and several volumes on the subject have appeared recently. Two of these are now before us. One, edited by MM. Vitrac and Galopin, is made up of the Memoirs of Eckard and Naun- dorff, and “New Light on the Fate of the Dauphin” by Joseph Turquan. Al- though Eckard’s work is old, it is lit- tle known, and is extremely important, for his memoirs have really formed the basis for all the researches that follow- ed. He was a perfervid royalist, but admittedly honest, and as he had an op- portunity of questioning many of the contemporaries of the Revolution, an cpportunity of which he availed himself industriously, he learned from first-hand sources facts which but for him would never have been brought to light. As for Naundorff’s Memoirs, there does not appear to be any excuse for publishing them at all. The narrative is a farrago of tncongruities and contradictions, of peregrinations, imprisonments in mys- terious and unknown places, strange mal- adies—the whole thing as grotesque as it is incredible. Besides, the absurdities are not even amusing. M. Turquan’s attempt to solve the mystery is interesting, because it pre- sents a new explanation of the drama in the Temple, or, at least, a new dénovement. His thesis is that the un fortunate son of Louis XVI and Marie Antoinette was assassinated within the precincts of his prison, on January 19, 1794, between eight and nine o'clock at night; that he was buried, before life was extinct, in the moat of the Temple; that a child, suffering from an incurable disease, was substituted in his place, and that his sister, the Duchesse d’Angouléme,. was made aware of the fact after her return to France, the knowledge of which fully accounts for her strange acts and words in re lation to the subject. The theory is based on a passage in the Memoirs of Comte d'’Andigné. This royalist chief, when a prisoner in tle Temple in 1801, obtained from Fauconnier, the concierge of the Temple, permission for the pris- oners to make little gardens of the heaps of earth that had been thrown into their quarters from the moat. Their labors resulted in the discovery of the remains of a child, which had evident- ly been buried in quicklime at the bot- tom of the moat. D’Andigné at once rushed to the conclusion that the skele- ton was that of the Dauphin. He ques- tioned the concierge, who replied in the affirmative. M. Turquan considers this formal declaration of the jailer of the highest importance. He supports his contention by a chain of arguments, some of which are decidedly ingenious, if not convincing. The Comte d’Andigné was the soul of honor and loyalty, and his sincerity was above suspicion. All which is no doubt correct, but very poor evidence to support the statement of the concierge. This man had filled the post of jailer only since 1798, and could, therefore, have had no personal knowledge on the subject. However, it is on his conjecture that the author has built up a theory. On the 19th of Jan- uary, 1794, he tells us, Simon strangled his victim, shortly before he left the Temple forever, by order of the Com- mune and the Committee of Public Safety. M. Turquan is not absolutely certain that Simon acted under official authority in the matter, for the cob- bler might possibly have killed the lit- tle victim in a fit of drunkenness or bru- tal passion, at any time before his de- parture. None of these suppositions is essentially improbable, and any of them would have the advantage of explaining Several circumstances which are at present incomprehensible; for instance, Simon’s abrupt dismissal from his post, and the laborious care with which at the time everything concerning the Dauphin, including his death, was con- cealed from his sister. But a conjecture cannot be adopted as true because it is a convenient solution of an enigma and is free from any inherent improbability, nor can it erase from history conclu- sions that are deduced from official doc- uments, such as jail registers, reports of physicians, This work, like those that have gone before it, will simply have the effect of prov- ing that it is useless to expect any com- plete revelation of the truth concerning, etc perhaps, the most poignant episode of the Reign of Terror. Miss Welch's volume on the same sub- ject is very pleasant reading. It deals with the whole life of the little prince from his cradle, and is marked by fresh- ness and individual judgment. The au thor Is too sane to venture on any posi- tive assertion as to what happened in the Temple in 1794, but she lets it be understood that she is inclined to be- l'eve in the escape of the Dauphin. She is certain, however, that every one of the forty persons who at very different epochs posed as the son of Louis XVI was an impostor. Miss Welch has a keen sense of humor, and this adds to the attractiveness of bright little narrative this A Vindication of Warren Hastings. By G. W. Hastings. New York: Henry Frowde. $2. When Warren Hastings returned to England in 1785 he expected some rec- ognition for his great services in India; he found instead that his hateful rival, Sir Philip Francis, had poisoned men's minds against him and that he was to be impeached. Burke's false setting of the Indian situation and the enchant- ment of Sheridan's oratory worked such prejudice to him that the trial dragged on for seven weary years and cost him the larger part of his fortune. Even death in 1818 did not end the ill-usage of which Hastings had had so much in Hfe—Macaulay’s essay was yet to appear. This essay, like that on Fred- erick the Great, exhibits a curious in- consistency. The great Whig historian could not help admiring the greatness of his hero, and frequently gives him unmeasured praise. But at the same time, laboring under the spell of Burke and Sheridan, and intoxicated by the exuberance of his own irresponsible rhetoric, he condemns Hastings as guilty of “great crimes,” and makes in- sinuations as to motives which still fur- ther blacken his character. This picture of Macaulay's, familiar to hundreds of thousands for half a century, has been somewhat damaged by the careful stud- les of Sir James Stephens, Strachey, Lyall, Forrest, and Lawson, and is now thoroughly demolished, as accurate biog- raphy, by Mr. Hastings’s “Vindication.” This !s in no sense a biography. It does not attempt to give a connected narra- tive of Hastings’s whole life, but mere- ly takes up in detail Macaulay's ficti- tious insinuations and “great crimes,” and examines them critically in the light of the official records. The chief of these records are the three folio vol- umes, containing the daily minutes of the Council during Hastings’s adminis- tration, wh'ch were published at Cal- cutta by G. W. Forrest in 1891. To show the result of this examina- tion, the Nuncoomar affair may be tak-
Page 18
18S en as a fair sample. Sir Philip Francis had the majority in the Governor's Council at Calcutta, and was lending a ready ear to any slander on Hastings, Nuncoomar appeared be- fore the Council to accuse Hastings of accepting a great bribe from the Munny Begum. According to Macaulay, (1) the letter which Nuncoomar offered as evidence was genuine. (2) To rid him- self of the charge and to destroy his accuser, Hastings suborned a native to make a counter-accusation against Nun- coomar of obtaining more than a lac of rupees by forging a bond. “The osten- sible prosecutor was a native. But it was then, and still is, the opinion of everybody, idiots and biographers ex- cepted, that Hastings was the real mov- er in the business.” (3) Nuncoomar was condemned “before Sir Elijah Im- pey”: (4) and “no rational man can doubt that Impey condemned him in or- to gratify the governor-general. Hastings later described Impey as the der man ‘to whose support he was at one time indebted for the safety of his for- tune, honour, and reputation.’ These strong words can refer only to the case of Nuncoomar. It is our deliberate opin- ion that Impey, sitting as a judge, put a man unjustly to death In order to serve a political purpose.” (5) How- ever Macaulay does not think even the murder of Nuncoomar can be reckoned among Hastings’s “crimes,” because he was acting for “self- preservation.”——Now, what are the his- tor'cal facts? (1) The letter which Nuncoomar offered as evidence against Hastings was unquestionably a forg- ery: he was notorious for his dishon- esty in other affairs: in his house were found counterfeits of the seals of many princes; he had a grudge against the governor, who had refused to ap- point him to a coveted office, and he sought this means to get even with him; he knew that Francis would gladly re- celve any accusations against Hastings; and it is significant that Francis took care not to put Nuncoomar through any cross-examination as to his allegations. There is therefore not the slightest rea- son to doubt Hastings’s statement that the whole accusation was a malicious forgery. (2) Hastings declared on oath that he had “neither advised nor encour- aged the prosecution of Nuncoomar.” The court records show that the private action on account of the forged bond was begun sir weeks before Nuncoomar appeared before the Council, that is, before Hastings would have any mo- tive for suborning a counter-accusation. It is clear that the idiots and biograph- ers were right and the brilliant essay- ist, who did not stoop to verify his facts, was wrong in regard to this all- important point. (3) The trial was not before Impey alone, but before a bench of four judges. Macaulay over- At the time when Nation. e Th [Vol. 89, No. 2304 Impey must be extended to the other three judges—or rejected. (4) The words of Hastings expressing lasting obligations to Impey, which Macaulay rashly accepted as conclusive proof of a dishonorable agreement between the judge and the governor to destroy Nun- coomar, do not refer to this affair at all; they refer to the attempt made by Francis to seize the reins of government some years later on the pretext that Warren Hastings (owing to a res'gna- tion handed to the directors in London by his agent, but disavowed by him) was no longer governor. The question was referred to the Supreme Court, where Impey and the other judges de- cided in favor of Hastings. (5) Ma- caulay’s justification of Hastings has the faintness which damns rather than justifies. How far a judicial murder in self-defence is justifiable is a point in ecasuistry which it is not proposed to argue. On page after page Macaulay 1s shown to be equally untrustworthy. And yet the official records from which all these facts appear lay at Calcutta when Macaulay was there. The author of the “Vindication” speaks aS one having authority. His grandfather, a distant cousin of Warren Hastings, was present in Westmin- ster Hall at the impeachment, heard the great speeches, and described the scene in h's latest years to the author, then a boy. His father stood in the Sheldonian Theatre at Oxford when Warren Hastings received the degree of D.C.L. at the hands of the university, and lived to refer to that occasion forty years after, when he himself was honor- ed with a similar compliment. The au- thor himself has known personally many men who knew Hastings personally, and he is one of the very few now living who knew Daylesford House, outside and in, as it had been when Warren Hastings was there. Naturally, he writes con amore, ahd often with ve- hemence, but he keeps within the bounds of good taste, and proves his case. Many of the facts he presents have already been published by Forrest in his edition of the Council Minutes, but not one person in a thousand who reads Macaulay's essay !s ever likely to see so much as the backs of Forrest’s volumes. Though nothing is ever like- ly to be written which will have a tithe of Macaulay’s audience, this “Vindica- tion,” attractive in form with the por- traits of Hastings and the pictures of Daylesford, deserves a wide circulation as an antidote to the famous essay. State Insurance. By F. W. Lewis, Bos- ton: Houghton Mifflin Co. $1.25. Mr. Lewis, who is a member of the Boston bar, has brought out a useful book. Economic insecurity he regards as a menacing evil; “a slight misfor- looked this fact. His insinuation against cident, illness”—may reduce a family to poverty and abject want; and the only remedy is a comprehensive scheme of insurance. Existing institutions—sav- ings banks, “friendly societies,” trade- union benefit systems, relief depart- ments of corporations, industrial in- surance—in some degree relieve eco- nomic insecurity, but fall far short of meeting all demands of the situa- tion. Mr. Lewis, therefore, advocates compulsory State insurance, substan- tially on the German plan. The Ger- man legislation of the eighties and the results achieved under it he briefly de- scribes, without exaggeration or un- due praise; and the folowing chapter, as if by way of contrast, gives an ac- count of the history and working of the fellow-servant doctrine in England and the United States. The cost of in- surance, Mr. Lewis thinks, should fall upon the workingmen themselves, and, wherever necessary, wages should be readjusted to the standard of a full living wage, including provision for sickness, accident, and old age. Old age pensions he rightly regards as un- sound in theory, since they do not reach the cause of the evil, and are dif- ficult to alter or amend after being once adopted. All pension schemes should be “contributory,” and “cannot be made effectually contributory without com- pulsion.” Altogether, Mr. Lewis has made out a strong case. He does not strengthen it, however, by presenting mere esti- mates of outlay for poor relief (p. 20), when the census statistics are avail- able; or by using rickety estimates of the distribution of wealth in the Unit- ed States (p. 15); or by citing un- reliable enthusiasts and sensationalists as authorities or “competent observers” (pp. 10, 15, 159). The Awakening of Turkey. By E. F. Knight. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippin- cott Co. $3 net. Mr. Knight calls his book a “history of the Turkish revolution.” For such a history, of course, the time is not yet at hand. The most we can hope for at present is a systematic résumé of what the newspapers during the last year have told us, supplemented by such spe- cial information as previous acquaint- ance with Turkey and her people may have placed at a writer’s disposal. The leaders of the Turkish liberation move- ment have been exceptionally gracious in their relations with Western corre- spondents; but they tell only what may be conveniently told. The greater part of the present volume is, therefore, neither very new nor yet very profound. Written from a decidedly philo-Turk- ish point of view, it would have little to say that the friendly Anglo-Saxon tune—enforced idleness, a serious ac- press has not already said, had not the
Page 19
Aug. 26, 1909] author been fortunate enough to obtain access to the letters and diary of Niazi Bey, who first raised the standard of revolt in Macedonia, a scant three weeks before the collapse of the Hamidian régime. Niazi’s diary, or what we get of it here, contains little of first rate im- port; but it is undoubtedly absorbing to follow in detail the makings of a revolution—the first daring step, the handful of refugees swelling with every day toward the dimensions of an army, and a free-breathing countryside break- ing through the pall of despotism like the surface of a slate under the sponge. Mr. Knight is almost Thucydidean in his minute account of what Niazi did and said during the two weeks of in- surrection. He strengthens the existing impression of the extraordinary care and laboriousness with which the ground for revolution was broken and prepared. We may cite a single instance. In one Mac- edonian village a man in the secrets of the revolution had babbled to his wife, who, in turn, grew over-communica- tive: This event led to the creation of a female police or vigilance committee in this and some other villages, whose chief duty ap- parently was to check indiscreet gossip con- cerning the committee. This is almost Japanese foresight. Science. THE PSYCHOLOGY OF HEALING. By Hugo Miinscerberg. $2 Psychotherapy. New York; Moffat, Yard & Co. net. This book, as we are told in the preface, is one of a series in which the author proposes “to discuss for a wider public the practical applications of mod- ern psychology.” A thoroughly scien- tific discussion of such a subject by a trained psychologist of the author’s po- sition and reputation would evidently have an important place in pedagogical literature; but an appeal to the wider public by one who claims to have only the interests of science at heart, as our author constantly does (e. g., p. 240), is scarcely justified, unless the specialists in his field are slower to employ the in- strumentalities at their command to the obvious advantage of the people at large. There is, however, no evidence of such an attitude of mind among the serious psychologists of our day, and it would, therefore, at first sight appear improper to treat this book, and “On the Witness Stand,” the preceding one of the series (reviewed in the Nation, May 21, 1908), as more than attempts to acquaint the ignorant public with the work of the psychologist and its possible applica- tions to practical life; attempts which The Nation. are, of course, entirely laudable, but which are not, strictly speaking, scien- tific. But, as a matter of fact, Prof. Miinsterberg here deals with an array of subjects none of which can be prop- erly understood except by the highly educated among the “wider public,” and most of which appea! either to the spe- cially educated doctor or to experts in psychiatry, psychology, and philosophy. His book must, therefore, be considered in relation to its effect upon these sev- eral classes of readers. The educated layman, upon perusal of “On the Witness Stand,” must have been impressed by the unbounded, and often unwarranted, optimism of the author in relation to the immediate value of the practical application of psychophys- ical method to the realm of law. In the book before us, this optimism will be less obvious to the average reader, but the specialist fail note again the author's weakness in this re- cannot to gard. Although scientific advance in any field must eventually affect all other related sciences, this very correllation of the sciences indicates the necessity of caution in treating advances in any spe- cial lines as of pre-« In fact, little of valu: tained when such attempts minent importance. is likely to be at are made in | appeals to a public which reads to be entertained, not to be instructed. The consequences of such reading may, in | fact, be actually evil in relation to mental discipline; for, to use our au thor’s own words (p. 201), “an untrained attention is attracted by everything which is loud and shining, big and amusing. The trouble is not with the rush and hurry of the impressions which demand our attention: the trouble is with our attention, which seeks a quick change of new and ever new impres- sions, because it discipimned to hold firmly to one important interest.” Nevertheless, a number of the au- thor’s teachings are of great value to the educated layman among this “wider public,” and offer a timely opposition to certain current misconceptions. It is unfortunate, therefore, that the bene- ficial effect of these teachings is likely to be much reduced, if not altogether lost, because the leaders maintain- ing the doctrines opposed by our author will doubtless retort ‘hat his opinions need not be taken quite seriously; basing their assertion on adverse criticisms which are bound to be made by specialists to whom alone certain parts of the book will be thoroughly comprehensible. is his discussion of not is Most important the relation of religion to medicine; in which he argues convincingly that the cures performed under such influences are diie to causes only fortuitously re- ligious, emphasizing the fact that a large proportion of the effects produced by psychotherapist the modern religious 189 may be produced equally well by the most barbarous of superstitions (p. 225) and calling attention (pp. 164, 335 f) to certain dangers, which are com- monly overlooked, in therapeu'ic prac tice connected with religious ap;.eals. He quite properly protests against current references to the “moral factors” in illness; justly holding (p. 56) “that the right entrance to psychotherapy is missed if the difference between moral- ity and mentality is not recognized from the very beginning.’ He does well, also, to call attention to the artificiality of the separation of functional from struc- tural nervous diseases, of which the modern religious psychotherapists make so much, With equal propriety he emphasizes the distinction between the §atti- tudes of the physician and the clergy- man, and points to certain dangers which are involved in the current neglect of this distinction (e¢. g., pp. 187, 2%). His contention (chap. xii) in favor of a higher view of religion than that which with the elimination of pain, gain the ear of the thoughtful the and laity alike; as should, also, his appeal (p. 381 ¢) in the of a of the and of God than that which thority over the mind from such an ex- es it should ir among clergy interest nobler view world “gains au- ternal motive as a belief in its curative effects.” “What is gained,” he justly asks, “if some nervous disorders are helped by belief. if the belief itself devastates our intellectual culture and brings the masses down to a view of the world which has all the earmarks of barbarism?” So far, his ideas are sound, When we turn to his treatment of suggestion, of hypnotism, and of the subconscious, we find an unfortunate at- tempt to speak to two audiences at the same time. The average well-educated layman would have been enlightened by jearning that suggestion, as employed by the psychotherapist, is not a myste- rious power of one “will” upon another “will,” but is merely a special form of an influence which every man exerts upon his fellows in normal life; and that the dangers connected with the use of this special form of suggestion, while real (pp. 106, 226, 383), are no other than those which in milder form may appear in the practice of the unskilled teacher who encourages in his pupil bad volitional habits. He would have been benefited by the knowledge thac hypno- tism is very closely allied with mental conditions which are agreed to be nor- mal, and that, while its employment by the uneducated should be discouraged, on the other hand its use by the skilled practitioner, with due caution, {fs no more to be feared or deprecated than is the employment of other radical therapeutic agencies where morbid con- ditions seem to warrant such use. He
Page 20
190 The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2304 would have found his thought clarified by the teaching that what is spoken of so glibly nowadays as the “subconscious” is not, as it is commonly thought to be, a mysterious inner moral force, espe- cially powerful in producing changes in the nervous system; and that, as thus conceived, no such thing exists. But, unfortunately, Professor Miins- terberg here presents views which are not at all appropriate for the considera- tion of the layman; which really appeal to the average well educated physician, and which are couched in terms certain to lead the physician to question the validity of the author's statements. And such doubts will be strengthened if the inquirer appeals for verification to skilled psychologists and psychiatrists. The psychologist, for instance, will tell his inquirer that the word con- sciousness is commonly employed in two senses, viz., (1) as the equivalent of mere psychic existence, and (2) as the equivalent of “awareness”: and only if we mean to use the word in the latter sense (cf. p. 133) is it true that “there is no subconsciousness”’ (p. 125- 157), é. e., no awareness of which we are not aware. But the psychologist will also tell his enquirer that we have very good reason to believe that there is a form of mental life transcending the narrow limits of awareness (what H. R. Mar- shall would have us call sub-attentive consciousness), and that it is this “sub- attentive consciousness” which is usual- ly referred to by serious students who use the unfortunate term “subcon- scious.” We are thus brought to the considera- tion of the effect of the book upon ex- perts in the several fields in which the writer claims to speak as h'meelf an ex- pert. The opening up of the field of scientific psychotherapeutic treatment is 80 the exploration of the fleld so manifestly inadequate, that it behooves the really scientific worker to record his observations In a form wh'ch his co-workers may examine ond verify; or if this is impossible, to state his own views with more modesty than our author displays and tu hold them more tentatively It is reasonabiv sure that practical psychotherap'sts will find recent, and thelr experience d!/fering in some re- spects from that of Professor Miinster- berg in regard to alcoholic and mor- phine patients; and certainly the psy- chiatrists will fail to follow him in his quite artificial restriction of rsychother- apeutic treatment to cases outside the alleniat’s field of work, which implies a sharp distinction between the sane and insane, such as few leaders In psychia- try would today defend. But, after all, our author, notwith- standing his desire to be numbered with the physicians, will be judged primar- ily as a psychologist. We may make due allowance for carelessness in writing under pressure to meet a present popu- that | lar demand; but it is under just such unguarded conditions that a man is likely to lay bare the real nature of the doctrines which guide his thought; and it is clear that in the case of our author these doctrines were derived in the receptive age of youth, and have re- mained virtually unmodified to meet modern criticism. His reference to “the will” is constantly made (e. g.. p. 31) in terms that hark back to the con- ception of the “faculty psychologists,” which should have succumbed to Locke’s forceful attack, but which actually held almost complete sway among the psy- chologists of our author’s youth. The opening chapters might wel] have been written by a psychologist of the early associationist school: although few even of them would have been bold enough to hold with our author (p. 24) that “the whole stream of menta! life” 1s “made up of sensations,” “we ourselves” being “for ourselves a complex com- bination of sensations” (p. 25). In fact, he actually proclaims (p. 23) that “if there were mental states which are com- posed of other elements than sensations, they would necessarily remain inde- scribable.” His reason for this question- able statement, viz., that “we could not grasp them because they would not have any definite relation to the common physical world,” is in line with a view of his own to which he attaches great importance, that “as soon as we look on inner life as merely psychological objects, then the material is connected only through the underlying physiologi- cal processes, and we can never explain causally the appearance of am idea through the preced'ng existence of an- other idea” (p. 139). In other words, he justifies the important place he gives to physiological psychology by the as- sertion that without reference to physi- cal process causal relations between psy- chic states would be inexplicable; an as- sertion which involves a very doubtful thesis as to the nature of the concept of causality and which carr‘es with it the dénial that anything like a valid psychology existed in ancient times when the masters of thought were ig- norant of the nature of the psycho-physi- cal process. He properly emphasizes the view, above referred to, that the suggestion employed by the psychother- apist is of the same nature as process- es observable ‘n normal life; but he takes a step backward when he sep- arates this psychotherapeutic sugges- tion from the ordinary emphasis of ideas through every day environmental influences. Few, if any. psychologists will follow him in holding (p. 100) that “it is meaningless to speak of suggesting an idea”: that (p. 101) “suggestions which are not suggestions of action are without exception suggestions of belief.” But, perhaps, we make too much of his psychological poritions; for his present Interests are philosophical rath- er than psychological, and, im this par- tieular book, we find not a little of in- terest in relation to what, broadly speak- ing, we may call the philosophy of life. His demand that the medical student should be trained in psychology (p. 364) is thoroughly warranted, anil timely. His explanation of the basis of the crude metaphysics of Christian Science (p. 344) is admirable. Interesting also is his comparison of the idealistic and realistic movements (p. 5); and equally enticing, although less convincing, is his distinction between the “causal” and “purpobive” views of life (p. 14 f), and his application of this distinction to the work of the psychotherapist (p. 56 f). The book will, without doubt, be wide- ly read, and will increase in marked de- gree the interest of the public in psy- chotherapy; and, in this connection, it may be worth while to consider the tendency of physicians who practise cur- rent psychotherapeutic methods to adopt a disingenuous attitude toward these patients. Even our author, notwithstand- ing his disclaimer on p. 361, shows him- self to be not averse to the occasional use of trickery and deceit (e. ¢., pp. 188, 223, 300). It is difficult to ra‘se logical objection to quackery and charlatanry, except on general grounds; the question concerns the value of what we may call the detective attitude in the physician, an attitude which this book will with- out doubt strengthen in many a young doctor. In the long run, we believe better results will follow from discour- aging this detective attitude, and en- couraging mutual trust between patient and medical adviser, the physician be- ing thus led in general to rely upon the correction of morbid ideas by the whole- some influences flowing from contact with life under normal conditicns and in normal surroundings. “Life Histories of Northern Animals,” by Ernest T. Seton; “‘The Grizzly Bear,” by W. H. Wright; “Latter-Day Problems,” by J. L. Laughlin, are among the scientific publications to be issued by Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons in the autumn. About a year ago Sir James Crichton- Browne delivered an address at Buxton be- fore a section of a meeting for the discus- sion of questions relating to public health. He took up the problem of extensive re- duction of the human food requirement, which has become a matter of genera] in- terest. An expanded version of this ad- dress has now appeared as a little book with the title “Parcimony in Nutrition” (Funk & Wagnalls Co.), and is well worthy of careful reading, particularly by such lay- men as have been attracted by the doctrines associated with the names of Fletcher and Chittenden. The author is a well known English physician of extended experience, and his views are fully entitled to consider- ation. In a sense, there is nothing abso- lutely new in the book, but there is a clever marshalling of facts which make against a hurried adoption of low standards of diet
Page 21
Aug. 26, 1909] and should give pause to those who, with more zeal than discretion, have advocated such procedures. Sir James points out that the experience of mankind is with remark- able uniformity in favor of a liberal diet and abundant nitrogen, and that the human habit is justified and fully confirmed by observations made among the poor and in prisons and workhouses, as well as by the best knowledge of the food requirement of animals. The experiments of Professor Chittenden seem to him exceedingly inter- esting but inconclusive, and as yet quite un- acceptable as a basis for a general reform of standards, particularly as to a lower in- take of nitrogen. That there is much over- indulgence is not denied, nor that a consid- erable restriction in the eating of meat would be beneficial. While economy in cer- tain directions is much to be commended, no extended reduction in the individual supply of food may be safely advocated on the basis of our present knowledge; in fact, our author believes that there is far more underfeeding than overfeeding in the world, and that poverty in nutrition Is a much more serious problem than economy Maria Parloa, one of the pioneers in this country of scientific cookery, died at Bethel, Conn., August 21, at the age of sixty-six. Her books are “First Principles of House- hold Management and Cookery,” ‘‘Kitchen Compeaniom’ “The Young Housekeeper,” “New Cook Book and Marketing Guide,” and “Home Economies.” Dr. Max H. Runge, professor in the Uni- versity of Géttingen and director of the Frauenklinik, has died at the age of fifty- nine. He wrote several books in his spe- cial field, including a ‘“‘Lehrbuch der Gyna- kologie.”’ Drama and Musie. Charles Scribner’s Sons will shortly pub- lish a comedy entitled “Open Country,” by Maurice Hewlett; also a volume entitled “Roses,” comprising a series of four plays by Hermann Sudermann, translated from the German by Mrs. Tenney Frank. Popular acting is coming to be more and more a real art in Germany. In the Ba- varian Highlands, Oberammergau is by no means the only place where the Biblical or legendary drama is cultivated by non- professional actors, and in the secular Volksstiick the peasant companies of Schliersee and Tegernsee rival successfully the regular stage of Munich or Vienna. A still more ambitious, and in many respects extraordinary, dramatic undertaking is at present going on in some rural communi- ties of Schleswig-Holstein. In Wesselburen, the native town of Friedrich Hebbel, mem- bers of the order of the Good Templars have for some time past been devoting their leisure hours to the study of Hebbel's dramas: From reading them aloud they passed on to private performances of se- lected scenes, until this summer they have come out with full-fledged, public repre- sentations of such plays as “Maria Mag dalena;” “Agnes Bernauer,” and “Gyges und sein Ring.” The earnestness, simplici- ty, and power of these performances at tracted such attention that neighboring towns, such as Meldorf, Lunden, Marne, The Nation. asked for repetitions; and it seems as though popular Hebbel festivals were to be a regular feature of the higher life of the sturdy Ditmarse farming population Preparations are already on foot for the celebration of Hebbel'’s hundredth birthday, in 1913, by a performance of his Nibelungen trilogy. That a play of philosophic depth and psychological complexity as “Gyges und sein Ring” should have been impressively acted by a company the stars of which were a carpenter, a rural dentist and a peasant girl, seems remarkable in deed. A curious concomitant of this dramatic activity of the Good Templars is such result reported to be the extension of their anti alcoholic principles Max Grube’s “Adalbert Matkowsky,” the last volume in the Dramaturgische Plaude reien Library (Berlin: Paetel), is little short of a biography of the distinguished German actor, whose death was recorded in the Nation of April 8 There are personal reminiscences of Matkowsky in his younger years of prep aration, at rehearsals, the Herman comple te romantic and behind scenes, and an examination of him as a man. His most successful roles are char acterized, and several portraits of him in private life, and as Sigismund and Mac- beth, are siven. News reaches us of the death of Wil helm Millowitsch, founder of the famous Volks Theater of Cologne His popula: drama, enacted by living players, was a successor of the marionette theatre of Christaf Winter, founded in 1802, in which popular local types were represented by puppets “Success in Music and How It Is Won,’ by Henry T. Finck, lications to be issued by Charles Seribner's appears among the pub Sons in October. Oliver Ditson have to their excellent total list added four Musicians Company new volumes Library, bringing th« fifty now up to The della the Association of Italian completed a catalogue of works on the the- ory of music found in the Reale Biblioteca Palatina, the churches of San Giovanni and the Stucata, the cathedral and the baptistry of Parma, where this society has its head- quarters. This brought to light many works interest by forgotten authors, such as three volumes of “Aron,” printed at Venice by Master Ber and Master Matteo de Vitali in 1523 and 1529; an Aristoxemus, Venice, 1562; that has Corriere Sera announces Musicians investigation has wf great nardino a “Regula musice plane,” by Fra Bonaven tura of Brescia, round charac ters, in 1497, and with wood cuts; a “Nico- lay Burti Parbensis opusculum,” printed in 1487 in characters coarse figures. other works of the late fifteenth and early is a manuscript divided with curious musical fine musical dialogues by Vincenzo Galilei (1581) have been found, and works of Glu- reamus (1547), Kircherius (1650), Lanfranco (1533), Pontis, Rameau, Francesco Salina and other sixteenth-century authors, and a large number of sixteenth and seventeenth century publications. It is the intention of this association to extend this catalogue so as to include all Italian works which ap- printed in musices Gothic and Among sixteenth centuries three into parts, compositions Some 191 peared before the nineteenth century, found in any public or private library in Italy. It is expected that their labors will serve as a basis for a great critical edition of the best Italian writers. Prof. Guido Gas- perini, of the Royal Conservatory of Music at Parma, is at the head of this movement. Richard Hoffman, musician and compos- er, died August 17. He was born in Man- chester, England, in 1831, and came to this country at the age He was an honorary member of the Philharmonic So ciety of New York, and in his younger days played at their He was gaged by Barnum to play in the first Jenny Lind concert as piano soloist. Some of his compositions were “La Gazelle,” ‘“‘Crépus- cule,” “Spinning Song,’ “Finland Song,’ “Crossing the Bar,’ and ory.”’ of sixteen. concerts. en- Love “Mem- Art. THE DEARTH OF ANTIQUES. Within ten years antique objects of art have quadrupled in price. This may be With such objects as happen to be in vogue, the rise has been much greater. In part, this rather want of tactics, of the new-rich collector, But that much should not be made to bear all the blame. Inflated prices rute also in the shops which he never enters. The desirable ‘rifles that used to pick up in Europe for a few francs, now cost as many dollars. The demand increases as the supply nears exhaustion. The smaller antiquar- ies judge that their part of the busi- ness may last another ten years, but hardly more. Many of them are em- barking perforce upon the dubious trade in false antiques; the more far-sighted talk of dealing in modern art. Mean- While the search is always more in tense and less fruitful. There are few hamlets in Europe too humble to have some agent whose connections reach eventually to London and Paris. But they no longer find much. Everywhere the story is the same. A noted rug-deal- er and expert deems himself lucky if a single carpet of high class rewards a long trip in the East. The causes of this dearth are many; chiefly, we think, the steady demand of the museums and the tendency of collectors to bequeath their to the public are responsible Every year thousands of fine objects are thus withdrawn from the market. In Europe, there exist at present only a handful of notable collections that can concelv ably come under the hammer. Here in America, at a wide guess, there may be in private hands a thousand meritor ious paintings by old masters. Of these it is safe to say not more than a third will ever come into the market again As regards the supply of antiques, we are at the end of an The taken as a rough average. is due to the tactics, or abused person one treasures era. main
Page 22
192 sources were the suppressed convents, whose dispersed treasures have now mostiy reached the museums or perma- nent collections; the churches, which are now forbidden by law to alienate their possessions; the private galleries of old or noble families, which, with trifling exceptions, have been sold out or registered as non-exportable; finally, private and illicit excavation, which is now severely controlled by statute. Of course, we are by no means at the end of the antiques, merely of the mar- ketable ones. Every year brings import- ant discoveries from Egypt. The sands of Turkestan yield up interesting ves- tiges of lost civilizations. Persia and Babylonia have been touched only su- perficially. Even the colonial cities of Greece have been rather reconnoitered than explored. Yes, there will still be notable returns from excavation, but in the main the local museums will be the gainers. The art market will re- ceive but little relief from this source. The chief sufferers from the shortage are new museums and modest collectors. No pity need be wasted upon the anti- quaries. They have developed abilities of such serpentine astuteness that they must succeed in any branch of trade. Nor need the many-millioned amateur claim our compassion. Other means of spectacular expenditure will be provid- ed for him. The humble collector suf- fers already in his pocket and in un- realized desires. But these mole-like folk have, after all, a faculty for taking eare of themselves. By barter, by at- tending sales too obscure for the deal- ers, by knowing a good bit more than the peripatetic agents, by familiarity with each other’s possessions, and pru- dently accepting the opportunities open- ed by adversity or mortality, the small collector will contrive for a time to keep supplied. Against him, too, the age is working. As he realizes the im- possibility of duplicating his modest treasures, let him murmur proudiy apres moi le déluge. The case of the new museum—-and we have many such—is harder. It must buy antiques on a rapidly rising and nearly exhausted market, or not at all. In fact, only a well endowed museum can hope to enter this competition successfully. For the smaller museums there will re- main the alternative of coneentrating on the art of the present, or buying small colleetions rather of archmological than artistic importance. Some such course will be forced upon most of our mu- seums of recent foundation. The duty seems all the more imperative, then, that the few American museums which ean afford to buy the finest examples of old art should do so while yet it is possible. Some years ago, the Boston Museum of Fine Arts took the almost unprecedented course of spending for ac- quisitions a large part of all uncondi- tional gifts and bequests. The authori- [Vol. 89, No. 2304 The Nation. ties Judged that it was more important to capitalize works of art than cash, and the outcome, both in its artistic and financial aspects, has fully justified a course that was, at the time, criticised rather severely. Only those museums which allow great freedom to their pur- chasing staff can hope to make the most of an art market ever rising as it nar- rows. Among the art books announced for early publication by Charles Scribner’s Sons are the following: “City People,” drawings by J. Montgomery Flagg; “Through the French Provinces,” by Ernest C. Peixotto, with eighty-five drawings by the author; “Art in Great Britain and Ireland,” by Sir Walter Armstrong; “The Art of Landscape Paint- ing,”’ by Birge Harrison; ‘“‘Pewter and the Amateur Collector,” by E. J. Gale, and “The American Girl,” by Harrison Fisher. The house at Toledo once occupied by El Greco has been presented by a wealthy am- ateur to the Spanish state. On the initia- tive of the King, and under the auspices of the Royal Academy, it will be convert- ed into a memorial museum, and filled with works of the eccentric Cretan master. In the City Museum of Padua has been discovered a portrait of Donatello. It is painted upon a thin beech panel, and evi- dently served as the cover of a man- uscript. Our only other authentic likeness of the great Florentine sculptor is the sadly repainted one by Paolo Uccello in the Louvre. To the National Gallery, in the Corsini Palace, at Rome, have been recently add- ed the following pictures: by Nicholas Poussin, The Triumph of David; by Sodo- ma, the Mystic Marriage of St. Catherine; by Novelli of Palermo, St. James. This gallery has also bought the wooden sketch model made by Bernini for one of the an- gels in the Church of St. Andrea delle Fratte, Rome. On July 4, at Milan, a gold medal was presented to Prof. Luigi Cavenaghi, in rec- ognition of his service im saving Leonardo da Vinci's Last Supper from rapidly ap- proaching destruction. The medal, which is reproduced in the July number of the Raasegna d@’Arte, is the work of the sculp- tor Danielli. While restoring the Church of 8S. Giuli- ano, Venice, a number of rolled canvases, and filthy, were discovered between the ceiling and roof. One of these, Christ Bearing His Cross to Calvary, an impor- tant canvas, measuring 2.63 by 3.12 metres, is said to be by Tintoretto. Other large compositions are attributed by ancient guides to Palma Glovane, and his minor contemporaries, The find includes two car- mosaics by Aliense, a designer century. toons for of the sixteenth The excavation of the Roman town of Calleva, at Silchester, begun by the So- clety of Antiquaries of London in 1899, has been so successful that the society has decided to engage in further work of the same kind. They have appointed a special research committee to superintend all undertakings of this nature, and pro- pose to begin operations this coming Sep- tember. The site chosen by them is that of old Sarum, the exploring of which is expeeted to yield valuable results. At the same time they have obtained permission from the Earl of Verulam to excavate the Roman city of Verulamium, the area of which is nearly twice that of Silchester. As this is close to St. Albans, and its archeological value might be destroyed by its being eut up into building lots, the seciety feel the need of beginning work on it as soon as possible, and it is hoped that sufficient will be contributed by the fellows ef the society and ethers te en- able it to be started im the course of next year. From Paris comes the report of the death of Louis Le Poittevin, the landscape painter, in his sixty-third year. He was a pupil of Bouguereau and Tony Robert- Fleury, and exhibited first at the Salon of 1877. The death is announced of Georges Vogt, director of the technical department at the Sévres manufactory. He was the in- ventor of the Nouvelle Pdte Tendre, and wrote, also, a number of books on his special subject. The death is also reported, at the age of ninety-two, of Joseph Schefsky, the Ba- varian sculptor. Finance. WALL STREET AND MR. HARRI MAN. It is not overstating matters to say that the paramount topic of the past week in Wall Street gossip, rumor, and conjecture, and the dominant influence on the movement of speculative values, were the questions whether Mr. EB. H. Harriman was or was not on the point of sailing from Europe for New York; whether he was or was not in better health than when he left America; whe- ther he was coming tome to a sick chamber, or to the directors’ room of the Union Pacific. When news that he was about to sail was received, prices of stocks advanced on the supposition that his return meant announcement of a “railroad deal,” or renewal of the Stock Exchange boom. When it was next announced that Harriman was still a sick man, and that the European spe- eialists had preseribed a programme. of complete rest and abstention from busi- ness activities, the stock market broke with great violence. People of the less imaginative sort suggested that there were other good reasons for the 10- point relapse than “Harriman’s health” —the fact of an overdone and artificial midsummer rise, for instance—but Wall Street insisted that the market was moving according to the news from Har- riman. Now all this demonstration, so far as 't actually had any such cause, will pos sibly take its place, in the minds of the average serious observer, as a piece of Wall Street foolishness. A market whose
Page 23
Aug. 26, 1909} ‘The Wation. intrinsic values depended on the pres- ence of a single financier would be a peculiar market. Furthermore, Wall Street's reasoning that Harriman’s re turn ought to put up prices appeared to overlook the fact that his absence, since his departure for Europe on the thirty- first of May, has been contemporaneous with an excessively violent rise in stocks. Evidently the rule was not sup- posed te work both ways. Neverthe- less, the fact of Wall Street’s supreme excitement over an absent financier re- mains, and it may be profitable to in- quire just what is the basis for it. One basis undoubtedly is the rooted belief on the Stock Exchange that pow- erfal capitalists fix the value of securi- ties. Wall Street does not go to the length of the La Follette theory; but it holds very firmly to the notion that “bull movements” are primarily the re- sult of individual initiative and manipu- lation. Most of the professional con- tingent and its satellites would hesi- tate to assert that the “multi-million- aires” can construct bull movements in a period of real adversity. Yet there are those who maintain this doctrine also, the presumption being that many scattered operators might be willing to bid up prices but unable to do it effec- tively, because of lack of concentrated effort and organized operation. There- fore, the reappearance of a “leader” tf in their eyes a “bull point” in it- self. Of recent years another argument for the theory of “one-man markets” has gained equal vogue, based on the rea- soning that capitalists daring enough and powerful enough to divert bank sur- pluses and corporation cash balances into the speculative stock market can do for “bull movements” what no one rely- ing on his own capital or credit coulda achieve. This, too, might serve in part to explain the attitude of Wall Street towards this week’s news and rumor. No attention seems, however, in apply- ing conclusions to the existing market, to have been paid to a certain forecast made by the subject of these various ru- mors. Just before sailing from New York in May, Harriman expressed his views to this effect: If we have favorable weather and corre- spondingly large crops, I look for happy times. There will be a big burst of specu- lation and a rise in the price of everything, but these will quickly grade down from the top to whatever level the crops make logical ,it a tide of speculation sets in rap- idly, ane we jump things up thirty or forty stories and then smash, the fall will nat- urally be greater. The obvious field of inquiry would be, at what stage of such an advance as prices have had this summer would the market be in the fortieth story? In some minds, there was another and a larger reason for the wide financial interest in Harriman’s return, and in his mented condition. It arises from reflection on the extraordinary charac- ter of the structure which Harriman has built up in the investment and cred- it markets. Never, perhaps, in the his- tory of the world’s financial markets has so extended and complicated a wet of machinery been put in operation. Its author knew every cog and wheel and pivot in it; that is quite generally ad- mitted. But a safe piece of machinery is one that can be relaxed or stopped without danger to any of its parts, and there were those who felt some appre hension as to whether Mr. Harriman’s invention could conform to those con- ditions. His own operation of it, at all events, seemed to involve the forcing of its speed to the utmost limit, and the extending of its connections in every direction, and sometimes machinery of that sort becomes difficult to control. Supposing the author of this mechan- ism to relinquish his part in the con- trolling of it, Wall Street itself will not fail to raise the question, to whom would he hand it over? This question may have had its share in the week’s misgivings over the cables from Cher- bourg and Vienna. It is a question which sooner or later will be upper- most in the serious discussions of finance. The most hopeful view of the case is that this danger-spot in the cred- it situation will be taken in hand by conservative and prudent men, and much of the past few years’ work of Mr. Harriman be cautiously undone. It will require men of large calibre to ac- complish even this: but it is quite as conceivable that competent men for that work could be found as that men capa- ble of driving the machine ahead with- out invoking disaster could arise. BOOKS OF THE WEEK Andreieff, L. The Seven That Were Hanged The Tucker Series. New York: EF. C Walker. 15 cents. Aristotelian Society Proceedings. New Se- ries.—Vol. IX. London: Williams & Nor- gate. Arrhenius, S. The Life of the Universe 2 vols. Harper. Ashburner, W. The Rhodian Sea-Law Frowde. $5.75 net. Becker, C. H. Christianity and Islam. Har per. Bertholet, D. A. The Transmigration of Souls. Harper. Birchall, 8S. H. Songs of Saint Bartholo mew. Boston: Alfred Bartlett Blanchaud, R. de. One Thousand Common French Texts. Crowell. 25 cents Brown, C. R. The Young Man‘s Affairs. Crowell. $1 net, Brown, J. D. Guide to Librarianship. Lon- don: Libraco Ltd. Bywater, I. Aristotle on the Art of Poetry: A Revised Text with Critical Introduction, Translation, etc. Frowde. $5.25 net. Canfield, W. W. Along the Way. Fenno & Co. $1.50. Crawfurd, R. The Last Days of Charles II. Frowde. $1.75. Crockett, 8. R. The Men of the Mountain. Harper. $1.50. Davis, J. W., and Julien, F. Finger Play Reader. Two parts. Heath. 35 cents each. Dewar, D.. and Finn, F. The Making of Species. Lane. $2.50 net Fisher, E. Dornréschen. Crowell Modern Language Series. 25 cents 193 Hein, G. Exercises in French Conversation and Composition. Crowell. 40 cents Herrick, C. Trust Companies, Their Or- ganization, Growth, and Management Bankers Pub, Co. Hilliers, A. As It $1.35 net. Hoag, E. B. Health Studies: Applied Physt. ology and Hygiene. Heath & Co, 75 cents Holliday, C. Once Upon a Time: a Col lection of Stories. Broadway Pub. Co Happened Putnam 75 cents. Hoover, B. R. Pa Flickinger’s Folks. Har per. $1. Hyatt, 8. P. The End of the Road: a Novel Appleton. $1.50 Financial. Our Most Popular Bonds We make a specialty of bonds secured by first liens on valuable farm lands. Some of them are tax liens—municipal obligations. They pay 6 per cent.—a higher rate than can now be obtained on any other large class equally well secured. They are issued in denomi- nations of $100, $500, and $1,000, so they appeal to both small and large investors. Short time or long time, as you prefer. We sell a general line of municipal, railroad and other public utility bonds, but we consider these particular bonds the most attractive in the mar- ket. They are preferred by a large majority of our custom- ers — people who know about them. We have written a book about these bonds—a book of unbiased facts and clear infor- mation. Every investor, small or large, owes to himself its perusal. The book is free. Simply write us a postal, or send us this coupon. Please do it now. Municipal and Corporation Bonds First National Bank Bidg. 5@ Congress Street CHICAGO BOSTON Gentlemen :—-Please send me your new Bond Book, “The World's Greatest In- dustry.” Name Sasrens ag einemaeseeRNNRERENRTESENNENEEE Town— ——— -—- — a 132 State ——-----—-_ —
Page 24
194 Irwin, W Confessions of a Con Man. Huebsch $1 net. Janvier, T. A. Henry Hudson. Harper. 75 cents, net Johnson, A. H. The Disappearance of the Small Landowner Ford Lectures, 1909. Frowde. $1.75. Lee, Vernon. Laurus Nobilis: Chapters on Art and Life, Lane. $1.50 net. Lugaro, E. Modern Problems in Psychiatry. Publications Univ. of Manchester. Med- ical Series No. XII London: Sherratt & Hughes. Meyer, A. Jesus or Paul. Harper. Myth, M. Y. T. H. Dorothy of Angelwood Broadway Pub. Co 75 cents Newell, L. C. Inorganic Chemistry for Col- leges. Heath. $2 net. Ready this week Melchisedec By RAMSEY BENSON, Lord of Lands.” $1.50. Remarkable characters and a faithful record of spiritual development dominate this story of the Northwest it i# the story of a quarter-blood Indian walf, quality of a mystic An author of ‘A whe Jas much the instinct prompts him to leave the northern wilds where be was bern, and leads him to singular adventures among the palefaces and through these to the discovery of his mission, which he conceives to be the recall of the Christian ministry to the way whereby it Is to saye the world, In the pursuit of this mis sion he encounters various adversaries, not least among them falling in love > . . Chinese Immigration By MARY R. COOLIDGE, formerly as- sistant Professor of Sociology in Stanford University. American Public Problems Series Presents fhe the Chinaman in the yet been attempted when the aliens were most comprehensive record of United States that has Beginning with the days welcomed as a helpful solution of the labor problem of the Pacific Coast, the author traces with painstaking im partiality the many phases of personal hos tility they have since encountered, and the legisiation, State and national, that has been framed respecting them What the Ohinese have really wrought as social and economic factors In the United States; what their in fluence bas been, and is likely in the future to their business methods, and their home their ideals and moral values, are con presented life; vincingly and picturesquely Karlier volumes in this series: P. F. Hall's ‘Immigration; and Ite Effecta wpon the U. 8.”"" and G H. Haynes's ‘“‘The Election of Senators,”’. Each $1.50 tet SEPPERESESSOSES ESS SSE SS £666666666666666666666666 ' Henry Holt and Company 346-35 | The Nation. Phelps, E. 8S. Jonathan and David. Harper 50 cents. Porter, G. S. A Girl Doubleday, Page Quiller-Couch, A. T. True Tilda, Scribner’s. Register of the Members of St. Mary Mag- dalen College, Oxford. New Series. Vol. of the Limberlost. VI. Frowde. Rowell, H. Allan, Son of a Gunmaker. Cochrane. $1.50. Sherrill, C. H. Stained Glass Tours in England. Lane. $2.50 net. Sinclair, W. J. Semmelweis: His Life and His Doctrine, Manchester University Se- ries. London: Sherratt & Hughes. Smith, V. A. Asoka: the Buddhist Emperor of India. Second edition, revised and en- larged. Frowde. $1.15. FURTHER ADVANCES IN PHYSIOLOGY Edited by LEONARD HILL, M.B., F.R.S. With Diagrams. §8vo, pp. vili+440. $4.20 net. This volume is a sequel to ‘‘Recent Advances in Physiology,’’ and deals with different branches of the science. While the former volume dealt mainly with metabolism, secretion, and excretion, this is devoted to certain problems concerning the Circu- lation and Respiration, the Neuro-muscular Sys- tem, and Vision. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York BEST facilities for supplying ssi" BOOKS Sz Catalogues free. Oorrespondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 60 years. New York MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. THE “CHILD’S GUIDE” SERIES Guide” Series. manual ald to the treatment HE cordial reception accorded to the titles already published has encouraged us in our effort to provide an educational series at once readable and instruc- tive, and adapted not only to the juvenile mind but also to the riper intellect of the adult who may wish to learn as he teaches. >. > . . > A Child’s Guide to American History By HENRY W. ELSON 350 Pages. The author of Elson’s “History of the United States” contributes a volume of much importance to the “Child's This carefully prepared work provides a which will come to be recognized as an invaluable youthful movement of importance is ignored, though necessarily the is along broad lines. one of interest and importance. PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED. A Child’s Guide to Pictures By CHARLES H. CAFFIN A Child’s Guide to Mythology By HELEN A. CLARKE The books are attractively bound in red cloth, with gold stamping and half- tone cover Inserts, and the Illustrations will be found notably interesting. Sold at a uniform price of $1.26 net; postage, 12 cents additional. 12mo. 16 Illustrations. students of American History. No The resulting volume is THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., Publishers 33-37 East Seventeenth Street, NEW YORK [Vol. 89, No. 2304 Stearns, W. N. A Primer of Hebrew His- tory. Eaton & Mains. 40 cents net. Stewart, J. D., and Clarke, O. E. Book Selection. London: Libraco Ltd. Stewart, J. D. The Sheaf Catalogue. Lon- don: Libraco Ltd. Sweny, H. R. The Big Stick and the Golf Stick. Albany: J. B. Lyon Co. University of Pennsylvania, Publications of the Egyptian Department of the Uni- versity Museum. Areika, by D. R. Mac- iver and C. L. Woolley. Wason, R. A. Happy Hawkins. Small, Maynard. $1.50. Webb, C. C. I. Ioannis Saresberiensis Poli- cratici. 2 vols. Frowde. $11 net. Wrede, W. The Origin of the New Testa- ment. Harper. Boston: New and Enlarged Edition DE PROFUNDIS By Oscar Wilde Second edition, with additional matter, edited by Robert Ross Crown 8vo0, with Portrait. $1.25 net In addition to the large amount of new material in De Profundis which was not included in the earlier edi- tions, Mr. Ross has added some of the letters written to him from Read- ing Gaol which illustrate Wilde’s varying moods in prison. He hab in- cluded also the two remarkable con- tributions to the Daily Chronicle on the subject of prison life. G.P. PUTNAM’S SON Do you know theBeacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at the same time brief. Each volume 50 cents net: by mail, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. The Musicians Library SEND FOR FREE BOOKLETS Oliver Ditson Co., Ditson Bidg., Boston, Mass. Send for Catalogue. FOREIGN TAUCHNITZ BOOKS SCHOENHOF BOOK CO. BRITISH AUTHORS 128 Tremont Street, BOSTON, MASS. TIONAL S@CIALIST Recent No. and BOOK CATALOGUE for 10c. CHARLES H. KERR & CO. CHICAGO NEXT WEEK The Nation WILL PUBLISH An Educational Number It will contain several pertinent articles, the leading being by Prof., Wm. MacDonald on Summer Schools in the Universities. Recent text-books will be re- viewed. 4,000 extra copies will be mailed to teachers in schools and colleges. Usual rates for advertising.
Page 25
2”