The Nation 1909-08-19: Vol 89 Iss 2303

Page 1

GENERAL LIBRARY, UNIY. OF much. The N&sion VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2303. THURSDAY, AUGUST 19, 1909 PRICE TEN CENTS. Duffield ¢s Sewers Hew and + ioauuen Books “The Barbarians of Morocco” By Count Srernperc. Translated from the German by Ethel Peck; pictures in color by Douglas Fox-Pitt. A rather daring book of travel, taking the Moroccans from a sympathetic point of view Cloth &vo $2.00 net: postage 2 cents “The Play of King Leir and His Three Daughters ” Fe The old play on the subject of King Lear. Edited by Sinney Leg, D.Litt. Frontispiece. A new volume in the Shake speare Library. ° “Etiquette for Americans” A new edition containing illustrations showing the proper way of costuming housemaids, setting of tables, ete, et Bound in limp leather. with gold stamping and gilt top $1.50 net; postage 10 cents “Sir Guy and Lady Rannard” By H. N. Dickinson. A novel of English life, full of love. politics aml shrewd character-drawing. Cloth, 12mo. $1.50 FIFTH EDITION. FIFTH EDITION “Tono-Bungay” in London is being received with an almost of it in the Daily Telegraph in the following ecstatic terms: ‘We think that “TONO-BUNGAY ” will prove to be Mr. H. G. Wetts’s “David Copperfield.” One of the most significant novels of modern times, on¢ of the sincerest and most unflinching analyses of the dangers and perils of our contemporary life that any writer has had the courage to submit to his own generation. Mr. Wexts has certainly done nothing to approach this book, both for courage and conviction.’—Boston Evening Transcript. $1.50 postpaid unanimous chorus of praise. Mr. W. L. Courtney writes “The Book of the Divine Consolation of St. Angela Da Foligno” Translated from the Italian by Mary G. STEEGMANN, with an introduction; illustrated with reproductions of the woodcuts of the original edition, Genoa. 1536. ae 4 4 2. Early English Romances of Friendship Edited, in modern English, with Introduction and Notes, by Eprrn Rickerr. Illustrated by photogravures after ilu minations in contemporary MSS. Brown pigskin, antique clasps. $2.00 net; by post, $2.08 William Eleroy Curtis “ONE IRISH SUMMER” Sketches and descriptions of Ireland and the Irish; “One of the brightest, freshest and fairest books about Green Erin that I have ever read.”—Hon. James Bryce, British Ambassador to the United States. Ulustrated from 64 photographs $3.50 net; postage 10 cents Hutchins Hapgood “AN ANARCHIST WOMAN” “One of the most interesting human documents that has ever come under my eye.”—Edwin Markham, in San Francisco Examiner. $1.25 net; postage 10 ce: AT ALL BOOKSELLERS OR FROM THE PUBLISHERS DUFFIELD "8 COMPANY 36WEST 377 ST NEW YORK

Page 2

Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. The FOUNDED IN 1865. [Patered at the New York City Post Office asa second-class mail matter.) The Nation ts published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, President: William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Kimer More, Faltor Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewvtco; to Can- ada £3.50, and to foreign countrica comprised in the Poatal Union, 84.00 iddrese THE NATION, Bow 794, New York Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tue WeeK. néecvebececeedss. ae EDITORIAL ARTICLES Popular” Taxes 154 ScientifiC Speculations jendesse Ie Fair and Foul-Weather Yachts ....... 156 Letters in Biography . ; . 156 SPECIAL ARTICLES News for Bibliophiles wheat -- 167 CORRESPONDENCE: Personality in Politics 157 A Relic of Charles Lamb ‘ 158 Too Much Education . 158 Beasts and the Law sa 159 By Means of the Acrostic . .. 169 NoTES : 159 Book REVIEWS ° Dante in English Literature from Chaucer to Cary sue 161 A Certain Rich Man ......... ‘ 163 Norah Conough 163 Brothers All kee svee ED Gambolling with Galatea 164 The Religious Attitude and Life in Islam . 164 Sir George Mackenzie, King's Advo ate, of Rosehaugh His Life and Times 165 Social Organization A Study of the Larger Mind 165 We Two in Weat Africa 166 Haremlik .. 166 Screener 166 DRAMA Plays 167 AnT Gentile da Fabriano 168 FINANCE The Union Pacific's Assets 171 Rooks or THe WreKk . 172 ***Coples of The Nation may be procured tn Parle at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in lewton of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. . WIE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES bo tase eee Bypeere O. Fisx & Co., ‘Weobineton 1505 Pa. Ave., Wi 190 Fifth Ave., ‘or York sie Cen. Bid. Minneapolis, 208 Mich. Ave.. Chicago wetland Bid., 405 Cooper Bid., Denver 338 Doug! i’sBid., Los 618 Peyton Bid., Spokane 2142 Shattuck Ave. be eley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y. For English Courses pee Composition. Hanson. Composition ard Rhetoric. ew a iredee, and Arnold. Rhetoric. Genung. of Prose ‘Gane Nut- ter, Hersey, and Greenough. En an Sous ion Notebook. Green- ough, Nutter, and Hersey. ples of Argumenta' ion. Baker and Huntington. GINN AND COMPANY, Publishers 2) Beacon Street Boston HEALTH STUDIES By BE. B. HOAG, A.M., M.D., Throop Polytechnic Institute. 233 pages. 75 cents. Teaches the care of personal and public health, with a basic study of physiology; scientific and practical D. C. HEATH & CO., BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO se WANTED | A Writer of Advertising Who can translate an idea into written English with force and pre- cision. | Who has sufficient judgment, in- sight, and imagination to grasp the vital advertising poinis in a selling problem Experience in advertising work is | not a requisite. To the right man a | rare opportunity is offered. Appli- eations will be held confidential Address by letter only Mr. Burrill, 328 John Hancock Bildg., Boston, Mass Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere, 155 vols pocket size List prices, cloth, 35e¢. per vol.; limp leather, T5e. per vol (Special prices to schools and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y.Crowell &Co.,New York HAREMLIK By DEMETRA VAKA “A remarkable description of the life and manner of thinking of Turk- ish women.”—New York Sun. JUST ISSUED. Cloth, $1.50 ner, SAINTE-BEUVE By Prof. George M. Harper, Princeton University. J. 8. LIPPINCOTT ©O., Philadelphia. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACAREEY MASS. uaabtiched fe An ideally bealthfa!l location. ea i tion for the best institutions. a > ALDEN ~— rena H., Headmaster. D.D., LL.D., Visitor. For Catal 408EPH NEW YORK Day School 174 Fulton St. LAW SCHOOL Evening School New York City “Dwight Method’’ of instruction, LL.B. in two ears. LL.M. in three years. High standards. d for catalogue. GEORGE CHASE, Dean. I . ee ay PREPARATORY SOHOUL, Bethlehem, Pa. P res for leading colleges. Catalogue. H. A. FOERING, B.S., Headmaster. Visitors in New York are invited to examine the resources of our retail store. Here will be found a large stock of current and standard works from American and foreign presses. Teachers or students prepar- ing for courses of reading will find an excellent choice of moderate-priced editions. MAIL ORDERS WILL BE SHIPPED PROMPTLY. Send for cata- logues. E. P. DUTTON & CO., 31 West 234 Street, New York. Bargain for Public or Private Library Brehm’s Tierleben THE WHOLE ANIMAL KINGDOM. The famous and unequalled work on Natura! History; last and best edition; 10 volumes, Leipsic and Vienna. 12 maps; 1,910. illustrations in text, 179 in full pages, nearly all finely colored. Pub- lisher’s price, 35 dollars. Securely cked and sent to any address for 12 dollars. . R., care of Nation. Do you know the Beacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americans that are at) the same time brief. Each volume 50) cents net: by mail, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. | & Co., 21 Beacon St, Boston THE CLEVEREST BOOK OF THE YEAR ANNE OF GREEN GABLES By L. M. MONTGOMERY Ths By GORK WY BOOKS All out of print books at. 3 Bo matter on what subject; write me, ye by wanted; I can get you any book ee lished . matock 0 of 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S G r AT BOOKSH Jobn Bright St., Birmingham, Te MUSICIANS LIBRARY END FOR FREE BOOKLETS OLIVER DITSON CO., Ditson Bidg., Boston, Mass. F seneinter pee o8 aera BUOKS. 195 Srement Suset Anon § when in England, call and ing Pee eee Se ie a eee ~

Page 3

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 19, 1909. The Week. The Western Republican “insurgents,” both Senators and Representatives, have had triumphal receptions at home. It is clear that they understood perfectly the sentiments of their constituents, and represented them accurately. The strong Republican papers of the West continue to be amazingly outspoken about the shams and cheats that were left in the tariff, and to urge a continuance of the fight to get the frauds taken out. And the demand is that the work be done under Western leadership. Says the Kan- sas City Star: All of those Republicans in Congress who stood on the side of the people, who took the party platform and the President's campaign pledges in good faith, are West- ern men. And with these men and the spirit, the public sentiment, the public feeling, the national intelligence they rep- resent, lies the hope of tariff revision, the hope of the elimination of corruption and graft and oppression from the tariff system. Similar views could be cited from the St. Paul Pioneer-Press, the Minneapolis Journal, and the Topeka State Journal. We have plainly before us the begin- nings of a new “Winning of the West” away from mole-eyed protection. Attorney-General Wickersham, in an- nouncing that he is planning to con- tinue his official work while on vacation near this city, is quoted as remarking: The Administration policy to continue the prosecutiong of corporations that are violating the Sherman act or have violated it is well enough known now, but I can- not, of course, say what plans for further action we may have. This pronouncement is in line with Mr. Wickersham’s previous declarations. We do not suppose it to mean that the Department of Justice is mapping out an aggressive general campaign against any class of corporations; but it is fairly to be inferred that the Administration is convinced that the need for close watch of attempted combinations in vio- lation of the law is imperative. Such a policy has no inconsiderable relation to the new tariff law. It was an open secret that the Taft Administration, in answer- ing the argument that the maintenance or advance of certain duties would in- The Nation. crease the cost of living, took the gen- eral attitude that free home competition would prevent such an outcome. But, obviously, if the erection of a new tar- iff barrier against foreign competition were to be followed by domestic com- binations to force up prices, this argu- ment wouid collapse at once. It is the business of the Department of Justice to watch the developments in that di- rection. Many complaints against the methods and results of different United States made by statisti- cians and investigators. Serious discrep- Censuses have been ancies have been pointed out between the figures of one census and those of There have delays in editing intolerable publishing the We have hardly got all the data of one census before the ten-year another. been and material. period has rolled by, and the time has All this has led to an uneasy suspicion among students come to take another. that our census-work has been only ap- proximately accurate. This feeling has been shared by foreign scholars. Hap- pily, the promise for the Census of 1910 is bright. Mr. Taft's letter to Secretary Nagel comes as near as is now possible to taking the census away from the spoils- men. The appointment of supervisors and enumerators is to be made cn a political basis—-though even here the Democrats are to get half in several Southern States—but the actual ap- pointees are to be under stringent or- ders to take no part in politics what- ever, on pain of instant dismissal. This action by the President is a fitting se- quel to that provision in the Census Dill which, for the first time, put the per- manent employees of the office under the civil-service rules. For that step in the direction of political decency, we were indebted to President Roosevelt, who met the schemes of the spoilsmen with a sharp and effective veto. The bill then failed for the session, but it soon became apparent that Mr. Taft would in- sist upon the same reform principles. Congressmen were forced reluctantiy to retreat, and the small army of census clerks in Washington were finally brought under the rules. Original ap- pointments are to be made only after competitive examination, and, once in Office, a clerk is to be protected from arbitrary dismissal. The replies made by national bank directors to Comptroller Murray's let- ter of inquiry, indicate how timely the circular letter was and how lax is the sense of responsibility frequently felt by those charged with the management of these institutions. the directors admitted frankly that they knew nothing about their banks, while to de clare that they had personal knowiedge Four per cent, of only 25 per cent. were ready of the real conditions of their banking business. In something less than one third of these associations are loans and discounts actively approved by the di- rectors, while, in the remainder, these functions are discharged by the officers of the bank. It is perhaps of less rea! importance that 80 per cent. of the di rectors admit that they cannot certify as to the genuineness of signatures upon business paper which the banks have But the highly Making every allowance for the plea discounted. disclosures are, nevertheless, unsatisfactory that bank directors rely, and in large measure are forced to rely, upon the confidence they repose in each other and in their elected officers, the office is de its due dis charge requires a first-hand acquaint the more intimate signedly a responsible one. ance with bank’s business much and extensive than at The General Lee is one that directors should present prevails. story toll of take to heart. After the war, when the general was besought to lend his name to a concern with the assurance that he would have nothing to do and would re ceive $50,000 a year, clined upon the ground that if his name the veteran de alone was worth that much a year, he must be very careful how it was em ployed. With, Mr. Gifford Pinchot’s strong de sire to conserve the remaining water powers of the country and prevent a wa ter-power Trust, every one must sym pathize. Public opinion has undergone a great change in this matter. Whereas it was formerly thought perfectly proper for any one to acquire water powers who had the means, it is now felt that they should not pass into the hands of

Page 4

L52 anybody save through a limited fran- chise or lease. Beyond doubt, both Mr. Roosevelt and Mr. Pinchot have repre- sented in this matter enlightened senti- ment, They seem to have gone about it at times in a thoroughly Rooseveltian manner by suspending or overriding the laws where they interfered with their public-spirited policy. Secretary Balling- er, himself a Western man, thoroughly fam‘liar with the wishes of the Western people and formerly connected with the Land Office, believes in sticking to the letter of the law, perhaps because he is a lawyer of high standing. Mr. Pinchot, speaking last week before the Irrigation Congress at Spokane, uttered a protest against “legal technicalities’; in fact, uis whole fervid defence of Mr. Roose- velt’s conservation policy must be tak- en as a protest against the procedure of the present Administration. }t follows several ‘“muck-raking” articles in va- rious magazines which have hinted that Mr. the “old régime” and is really working for the Ballinger. stands for interests” that prey upon the people. This we do not for a moment believe, any more than we can think that Mr. Taft is secretly and malevolently plot- ting to undo what was the best of his predecessor's policies. And, in fact, the statement given out last Friday in Mr. Ballinger’s behalf by the Gene- ral Land Offce, would seem to leave but little of the contention that he has been giving away water powers to any one who knocked at his door. It must have been a great shock to the New York legislative committee to learn, from the Republican Governor of Kansas and the Republican National Committeeman and leading Republican newspaper editors, that the Kansas pri- mary law has eliminated bosses and all corrupt political influences. Yet this was the testimony they were compelled to Kansas would not dream of returning to a convention system; in- deed, Kansans, who take such a great mistaken, of course—interest in Gov. Hughes, find only one criticism of his direct primary suggestion—that it does not go far enough. “Eliminate every delegate” is the Kansas slogan, and the most critical and hostile New York com- mitteemen will have to admit that the system has worked well there. They can only fall back upon the agricultural character of the Kansas population, if listen to, The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 they wish to explain away this success. Whatever the verdict in the inquiry into Lieut. Sutton’s death, it cannot be denied that the Marine Corps has su.- fered grievously by the testimony as to the life the young Officers affected were leading while stationed at the An- napolis school of instruction. They were supposedly there to learn to conduct themselves as young gentlemen and of- ficers, instead of which they appear to have been a rowdy, hard-drinking, and fist-fighting lot, who thought that it comported with good manners to throw a comrade down on the floor and beat him until he threatened, and actually tried, to commit murder. More than that, there seems to have been a sur- prising lack of discipline, for officers were apparently on the most familiar terms with privates and sergeants. The Marine Corps has hitherto borne an ex- cellent reputation; in efficiency and sol- dierly conduct it has ranked very high; higher in Cuba and elsewhere, than the regular army organizations beside which it has served. There are excellent and high-minded officers in the Corps, who must be deeply chagrined that in one batch so many undesirables were foisted upon it, and that the officer in command of the school was not able to subordi- nate and train them properly. Nietzsche’s “blond,” whom he loved so much, and whose decline through the cunning of his darker rival he so much deplored, is, according to Dr. Charles E. Woodruff, surgeon and major in the United States Army, on the point of ex- tinction. Our jails are full of blonds, he alleges, who have fallen into poverty, disease, and crime. Light hair and in- genuous blue eyes often accompany the pickpocket’s dexterity and moral lan- guor. Dr. Woodruff thinks the cause of this deplorable state of affairs is an ex- cessive sunlight, which the sensitive blond cannot endure. Whether or not the blonds are a declining type, it seems to be a fact that they are, relatively to the brunettes, decreasing numerically. Even in German cities and towns, where one might expect to find the light-hair- ed and blue-eyed Saxon and the sun- touched Teuton, increasing numbers of brunettes are to be seen. Blond women, indeed, are growing so rare, that, like some species of orchids and other deli- cate plants, they have a special charm for whole races of men, the French, for instance. Perhaps, too, the bionds may have some spiritual grace, often asso- ciated with the languor of early decline. But Nietzsche seems to have been a bad prophet. Madame Maurice Maeterlinck, who is an operatic actress, has a plan to trans- late art back into the life from which it springs. She intends to produce “Macbeth” at her husband's chateau of Saint-Wandville, without a stage. The building is an old, castlelike affair, with architectural elements from the twelfth century. It is full of great cor- ridors, huge rooms, an impressive ban- quet hall, and its environment is wild and secluded. The idea is, not to play “Macbeth,” but to reproduce it. The banquet, for example, will take place in the actual banquet hall, the sleep-walk- ing scene in the bedrooms, and there is a desert heath where the witches will weave their malevolent webs. If there are any spectators, they will be as the spectators of a drama in real life, who glide in and out of the scenes, to whom not all is revealed of the tragic circum- stances, but who feel, vaguely, the in- definite horror of the events. This is realism with a vengeance, and suggests the ultra-esthetic idea that nature is a copy of art. No more difficult problem confronted the men who have been organizing a great and united state in South Africa than that of dealing with the native. There is, of course, some racial preju- dice against the dark skin, and some horrible crimes have been committed there by white men, in the name of Christianity and civilization. But, on the whole, there is warrant for saying that the relationship between the races is cordial and friendly. The Boers are, perhaps, harsher with the untutored na- tive than are the English. But even the Boers respect a native who has acguir- ed property and shown himself a stable citizen, and admit him to their church- es. Now the Act of Union con- tains a clause (No. 35) that “no person who is registered as a voter in any Province shal] be removed from the register by reason of any disqualification based on race or color.” This does not, however, mean that there is to be manhood suffrage all over South Africa, for where the na-

Page 5

4 : e *» %. is Aug. 19, 1909] The Nation. tive is already excluded from the bal- lot he will, for the present, remain so excluded. As to the wisdom of this, there seems to be general agreement; but there has been a sharp difference as to whether the native ought to sit in the Union Parliament, which is to be the supreme legislature for South Af- rica. The Act of Union limits eligibil- ity to British subjects of “European de- scent.” Heretofore in Cape Colony the native has been eligible to the Cape Parliament, and, although he made use of the privilege, he held it in high regard. That right he retains. but the Cape Parliament becomes now mere- ly a local council. never Thus for the first time in history, the Cape native finds himself subject to a political disability because of his color. This is an entering wedge which has not only disconcerted the natives, but has led to vigorous and high-minded protests from men like Sir Gordon Sprigg, Mr. W. P. Schreiner, and others, who see here the jeopardizing of the “essential principles of free ment,” for it attacks “ministers of re- ligion, editors, teachers, doctors, pub- lic servants, clerks, land owners, trad- ers, and artisans.” They believe, also, that it will be now possible, in some reactionary moment, to disfranchise these same persons solely because of race and color. The Imperial Parlia- ment is not, however, going to interfere. The Ministry is satisfied that sub- stantially as many rights have been giv- en to the native as he possessed before, and that the question is a domestic con- cern which is best left to those mos: in- timately involved for final adjudication. govern- There has been a happy interchange of views between the Anglo-German Friendship Committees of Great Brit- ain and Germany, which affords evi- dence that not every one in England has lost his head in the invasion panic. The letter from the English Committee is signed by such men as its president, the Duke of Argyll, Lord Avebury, Lord Brassey, the Earl of Lonsdale, Herbert EB. Maxwell, and Francis William Fox. It asks among other questions: Why should there be estrangement be- tween our countries? Your heritage of cul- ture is ours also. Your chief heroes and teachers are ours. All your highest aims and aspirations are shared by us. There may be rivalry, full and unfettered, in gen- i} 158 never less cause for strife, and never more for unity of spirit. The Committee then assures its German friends of its readiness to do anything within its power to avert the terrible disaster of war, saying: We have put, and shal! continue to put, before our countrymen, as we doubt not you will before yours, the supreme duty at this hour of resisting that spirit of fatalism which assumes that two nations of the highest intelligence, and masters of their future, must sooner or later become foes, and oi combating the present propaganda of war with a no less earnest propaganda of peace. The German reply is in the same high tone, and full of gratitude for the ef- forts made by the British Committee. It quotes anew the Kaiser's words, spoken at the Guild Hall in London in 1907: “The main prop and base for the veace of the world is the maintenance of good relations between our two countries .” and asserts that the great and ever-increasing burdens of militarism on both countries “can hardly, be tol- erated any longer.” Among the German signers are Theodore von Holleben, Ed- uard de Neufville, and Wilhelm Faber. The reason why Von Biilow was not anxious to dissolve the Reichstag ap- pears clearly from the result of recent byeelections in Rhenish Bavaria. The Social-Democrats gained in the first elec- tion more than 2,000 votes, while the National Liberals and the Alliance of Landowners lost, together, 3,000 votes, and the Clericals 1,700. Another vote being necessary between the Socialists and Liberals, the former won the elec- tion by 1,000 votes; many Clericals ap- parently voting against the Liberal can- didate, whose party has now lost its last seat in Rhenish Bavaria. Tha re sult has, of course, created a great po- litical sensation. It being an off-vear contest, there was naturally a smaller vote than in 1907: but the significance of the outcome is not to be overlooked. The Liberals, who were a party to the bloc policy of Von Biilow, are beginning to feel the punishment they merit for compromising and abandoning the real Liberal principles. As for the in- crease in the Socialistic vote, the new and heavy taxation undoubtedly played its part, together with universal disgust at the delays and compromises in the Reichstag. While this district includes two considerable cities, they are located erous and pacific pursuits. Two nations had in an agricultural and highly conserva- tive province. The warning was, there- fore, the more unmistakable. The So- clalist newspapers speak of it as only the beginning of a great day of teck- oning. Aristide Briand, who is described as the “first Socialist Premier in France,” is the man most hated by the “radicals” to-day. Writers in La Guerre Sociale and L'Humanité regard him as the “loweat of mankind.” The cause may be that he has “the advantage of having a little common sense,” as Clemenceau once tri- umphantly maintained of himself in an encounter with Jaurés. Whatever the so- cial philosophy of Briand and Clemen- ceau might be, if they were proceeding a priori to construct it, they as practical and executive men recognize, when in power, that it Is a condition and not a theory which confronts them. As edi- tors, Clemenceau and Briand were not too much troubled by the facts; as min- isters, Clemenceau apparently has done his democratic best in guiding the State, and it seems that the “sadder and wis- er” Briand will follow in the footsteps of his predecessor. His name is and will be anathema to his former friends; but that is a situation which, in the course of human affairs, eternally recurs It is difficult to arrive at the merits of the dispute between China and Japan over the question of the Manchurian railway. The Japanese case was first put before the public, and cast all the blame on the sbilly-shallying of Chinese dl- plomacy. But Kipling has told us what anybody may expect who undertakes to make the Orient “hustle.” China's re- ply, issued later, charges Japan with seeking more than she was entitled to, under the treaty, and of depending on her “military and naval superiority.” This would seem to imply that the Man- darins are ignorant of the great Amer- ‘ean doctrine of the strong man armed who will neither suffer nor do injustice. One thing, at least, Japan has spared us, and that is a snuffling pretence that she is taking what she wants under an overpowering sense of Divine guidance. Western Christians, in their wars of conquest, have the great advantage over the heathen of being conscious servants of the Lord, when they kill and rob, They said their duty, both to men and God, Required such conduct—which seemed very odd.

Page 6

“POPULAR” TAXES. A revulsion of feeling over the new taxes proposed by the Liberals, is now The cable dis- They state that the Conservatives are much going on in England. patches but faintly reflect it. worried to discover that Lloyd-George’s budget is than they supposed. They have been attack- much more “popular” ing it tooth and nail, denouncing it as “fraud,” “robbery,” but is meeting “spoliation,” and they find that it with warm approval from large classes now in the electorate. The Liberals have been unexpectedly winning bye-elections on the issue of the budget, and a general chill has fallen upon the divided coun- sels of the Conservatives. One of their own newspaper organs, the Daily Vail, plainly tells them how the tide is run- ning. It says: What the Unionist party scarcely seem to the envy and cupidity mass of people whose Mr. Lloyd-George seeks are not versed in politics and They through the flimsy fallacies of socialist argument. To a large number of them the Chancellor of the Exchequer appears with the halo of his own creation as the friend of the poor man, the in high places, the realize is that to arouse stagecratt. cannot see sworn foe of injustice humbly-born castigator of the idle rich. Among those who watch most closely the fluctuations of public sentiment there is a pretty general agreement that during the last few months the position of the govern- ment has been strengthened. The immediate reference is to an ex- traordinary speech which Lloyd-George has just made in London. It was, af- firm the shocked Conservatives, a per- formance such as no previous Chan- cellor of the Exchequer could have been capable of: and they are right. It was a fighting and inflammatory speech. Lloyd-George carried the war into the enemy's country in dashing style. In explaining his new land taxes, he ridi- culed the Dukes, and held the land‘ords up to scorn, amid the uproarious ap- plause of his audience. He asserted that his opponents were making the great- political blunder in when est history, assumed that the land-owner was or that it would thing for any they beloved in England, or safe itself champion and defender of the landlords. be a shrewd party to set up as the special Describing himself as “a son of the peo- declared that he should see to it that the very rich should be compelled to pay their just this kind of of the ple,” Liloyd-George share of taxation. In campaigning, the Chancellor ‘The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 Exchequer is ably seconded by Winston Churchill, who has been speaking with great boldness and vigor, and declaring that the Government would not permit such a “crime against the British democ- racy” as would be “the slightest mutila- tion” of the budget by the House of Lords. Mr. Churchill has also anncunc- ed a scheme of workingmen’s insurance by the state, after the German model, to be introduced next year; and it is plain that the leading spirits of the Min- istry are preparing to throw themselves bodily upon the middle-class and iabor As the signs multiply that the new taxes are “popular,” the drift that vote. way will be more marked. Over the mere proposal to make a beginning of taxing the unearned iucre- ment in land, there seems no sufficient reason for all this excitement. It is a tax which has been advocated by emi- nent economists and leading statesmen in England. Joseph Chamberlain himself advocated it in 1885. Before that date, a Royal Commission on land taxation had made a report favoring a tax on the increment much more extreme than the Lloyd-George; that report was signed, among others, one now urged by and by Cardinal Manning and the present King of England, then the Prince of Wales. Proposals with such a weight of authority behind them, and with the en- of John Stuart Mill, seem hardly to deserve such a violence of epi- dorsement thet as the Conservatives have been bestowing upon them. But it all comes from flinging the measure into heated politics. In the circles where they move, and in the ranks of their own followers, Mr. Balfour and Lord Lansdowne found the new land taxes inte szely unpopular, and so they seized upon them as another stick to beat the Liberals with, speak- ing of them, as Sir Edward Carson has done, as “the beginning of the end of all rights in property,” “the satiation of greed,” and “a war of tne classes.” Such extravagance of language begets equal extremes in retort; and the result is that England is torn with passion over a question of taxation that should have been broached and settled with scientific coolness. The whole matter is expected to turn on the fact whether the taxes are “popular” or not. A good and just tax may be popular; but so may one that is ill-advised and oppressive. A sober statesman will look beyond any such external test. He will inquire whether the proposed tax is one sound in principle, equitable in cpera- tion, and such as will not do more to harm business and the good relations of the classes in the community, than it will do good in helping the revenue. But for the politician, it is enough to know that the people’s fancy is caught with the new taxation. That was the real argument by which the corporetion tax was passed in our Congress. It would be a “popular” tax, therefore necessar- ily a good one. But that remains to be seen. What we already know is that sound finance and wise taxation cannot be as fickle as the caprice of the crowd. SCIENTIFIC SPECULATIONS. If modesty is ever seemly, it is where the layman stands in the presence of the man of science. When the ultimate nature of physical phenomena is un- der discussion, we feel as did Thackeray when his story reached the battle scene. Like him we salute the military novel- ist and retire below decks. It is only when a man of science himself takes up the criticism of prevailing theories in physics that we dare to venture out un- der the shelter of his guns. It is true that long before Prof. L. T. More’s paper on “Atomic Theories” ap- peared in the Hibbert Journal for July, we had bemused ourselves over recent tendencies in science. Few who have been graduated from college in the last quarter of a century will forget what an impression of finality they received from their instruction in physics and chemis- try. The professors of these subjects used to refer in sportive satire to the lack of definiteness and the endless flux in the humanities. Science towered on high, with its quod semper, ubique, ab omnibus disdain. It, at least, dealt with knowledge untainted by human passion. And yet in the last two decades rumors of radical change have reached the ears of the old alumnus; stories of jangling schools of theorists who wage battle over the inmost mysteries of nature.. Professor More, in the paper referred to, contrasts the scientific procedure and the scientific precision reached in me- chanics, with this speculative chaos now obtaining in the realm of molecu- lar physics. The units of measurement in the physics of ponderable matter are based upon and verifiable by sense per- ception. Mass, length, and time are all

Page 7

‘ i" Neen i ee cg KA re Aug. 19, 1909] magnitudes related to experience. With the aid of the Cartesian geometry and the calculus, the motions of bodies and the interactions of bulky matte: are capable of solution. The paths they traverse and their velocities formulated quantitatively. In terms of energy, an explanation can be offered of the agencies which move them. To this Newtonian legislation all bodies on the earth beneath or in the starry heavens can be were and remain subject. Once the po- sitions, veloc‘ties, and masses of any system were given, its past or future could be calculated with precision. But when in the last century the phenomena of light, sound, heat, magnetism came under electricity, and investigation, the method of science, as Professor More demonstrates, showed a tendency to change. The bodily affections of col- or, pitch, temperature, and electrical charge were not susceptible of the ex- actitude of measurement possible in the case of molar physics. Most properly, therefore, these phenomena were reduc- ed to terms of energy as measured in mechanical units. Had the process been content to stop there would be But with the study of these less tangible phenomena, a new ecien- tific method nomena had supplied the raw material here, no ground of criticism. crept in. Hitherto phe- of study. But increasingly from now on a hypothetical method of conjecturing the nature and activity of the ultimate constituents of matter began. Newton had held aloof, with his hypotheses non fingam, from speculating on tne inner nature of the agency causing universal But in the matter of light he conjectured that minute corpuscles attraction. were flung off from luminous matter— to the retardation of the development of But by this scientific miscarriage, the mod- optics for a century. undeterred ern physicist revels wildly in the imag- inative creation of ultimate constituents of matter and its environment—mole- cules, atoms, corpuscles, ethers, and what not--and proceeds by experiment to confirm his guess or to change and elaborate his conjecture as the experimental test re- ions, electrons, protions, quires. He ends up, after piling typo- thesis upon hypothesis, with a molecule which is itself “an aggregation of par- ticles, each vastly more intricate than the stellar systems, and whirling around each other with a motion approximating The Nation. a hundred thousand miles per second.” The use of this method within limits is perfectly valid; but its prevalence is fraught with grave danger. In the first place, fictitious entities are assumed not perceivable by the senses. So lone as experiment does not invalidate the as- sumption, the hypothetical creations grow in reality to their inventor until, as Professor More puts it, “the essential differences between hypothesis and fact, between metaphysics and physics” dis- appear. One distinguished physicist de- clared to our author that “we know far more about the ether and the atom than we do about sensible matter.” To which the proper retort was given that “a Frankenstein might say of a me- chanical man which he had conceived and constructed—I know more about him than I do about a real man.” A second danger Inherent in the prevalent method is the assumption that the in- ternal, intrinsic, essential nature of mat- ter’s ultimate make-up is knowable at all. So far as physics has progressed, it has been by reducing observed phe nomena to regular cvexistences and se- quences. All analogy would seem, there- fore, to favor this process rather than to attempt to penetrate into the geomet- rical shapes of ions, or to discern whe ther they are spheres or disks, as cer tain savants in Germany are now trying to do. But the serious aspect of the matter science itself, is not the procedure of effect of such studies in the but the training of young minds. The question s whether a science based on such hypotheses does not tend to dull that conscious distinction between what one knows and what one does not know, which is almost the highest aim of edu cation. It would be a strange reversion if we should find in the end that sc:ence it is to be taught, at least as coming differs from poetry in not knowing the difference between fact and fancy FAIR AND FOUL-WPATHER YACHTS. It would be a misfortune to Aner! can yachting if the rough experience of the New York Yacht around Cape Cod, should act as a damp- Club, in its sail er on future open-water cruising. We have no desire to make light of the hard ships the boats encountered. There is no stretch of coast more trying in 4 blow than that of Cape Cod, from Hyan- 155 The shoals from the Vineyard to Chatham nis to Provincetown. dangerous make every navigator breathe more freely when he is well into Massachu setts Bay. Only the other week two big merchant schooners grounded in sight of Chatham, ther conditions under much better wea than the In that stretch of water a forty vaclLts ran into. mile breeze brings with it anxieties which would not be felt under other shores: and for this reason, as weil as the saving in time, navigators hope for an early completion of the Cape Cod ship canal, that the Cape may lose its reputation as a graveyard for vesse's Granting that the weather was bad and the coast dangerous, the \sacht fleet's experience is bound to raise the old question whether our racing craft are not too often machines built for com- petitions on Long Island Sound in mod erate breezes, and therefore oversparred with insufficient hull-strength for any thing like a deep-sea wind. Under the new scantling restrictions, the hulis of the present-day racers beyond doubt mark a great improvement over the time when imitations of Columba and Defender were al] the rage. But boats like the 57-footers and most of the rac ing schooners are still far better off in port than at sea on a wild night. Now, we are not of those who would insist that every racing boat should be fit to cross the ocean, but we do maintain that if vacht-racing is to do for the sport all that it ought, the average racer should be stanch and seaworthy enough to go out in a 35-knot breeze, or to take care of itself properly in a sudden blow. Too often races are postponed because of the English laugh at the suggestion that they should wind, when our rivals would stay at anchor. Curiously enough, the big boats are often the least eager to sail in a blow The difference in the types of boats is best illustrated by the performances of Elmina and the little Eleanora. The Elmina led the fleet in because she was sea-going, and at the a stanch, Lame time, a fast boat, combining all the desirable qualities. This was to ve ex pected, because her designer, Mr. A Cary Smith, has long been turning out just that kind of craft, even when his boats are built to race Eleanore, on the other hand, is a racing boat pure and simple, a fine light-weather per- former, but far too heavily sparred and

Page 8

156 with too frail a hull for such seas and wind as she met off Cape Cod—only to lose her mast. It is distinctly the El- mina type of boat that our yachtsmen should pattern after, and we believe they will more and more as the evil in- fluences of the last America’s cup racers fade further into the past. Those were skimming dishes, pure and simple, built for summer weather, on one particular course, and, as we pointed out then, bound to have a noxious influence. For what the sport ought to turn out is sailors able to take care of themselves at ali times, and not mere racing-mas- in light breezes in ters at ease only land-locked waters. Something of the same problem has recently developed in motor-boat racing The Bermuda race of motor boats this year is believed to have been the laat of its kind, and its founder, Mr. Thomas Fleming Day, has recently felt himself compelled to denounce the present gen- of eration yachtsmen as a “crowd of weaklings and degenerates.” But Mr. Day, we think, misses the point. There is bound to be a much greater differ- the boat and that built for every-day cruis- ence between ocean-going motor- ing, than between the sail-racer and the sail-cruiser. The ocean-going motor-boat needs, for instance, greater storage ca- pacity, stronger engines, than the ordi- nary pleasure craft, and sufficient sail- power to crawl into port in case of the disabling of the engine. So far the Ber- muda race has aroused interest largely because of the venturesome danger of going to sea in boats never built for that purpose, with one exception, Ailsa Craig. This is, again, an A. Cary Smith craft, which has since been turned into a tow boat for a racing sloop, for which hull and strong engine admirably fit her. admirably fitted for purpose her exceptionally heavy A motor vessel ocean racing is now in service on Cape Cod. She tis absolutely unsinkable, being divided ments, and having every mechanical and into nine watertight compart- engineering device ingenuity could de vise. Yet she is wholly lacking in the accommodations necessary for comfort- able long-distance cruising. There is no doubt that she could be driven around Cape Cod in a winter's gale with per- fect safety. But this exaggerated type of decked life-boat is not what the ordl- In racing, whe- nary yachtsman wants. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 able thing is a boat in which its crew can have confidence even when caught in a blow and driven miles out to sea. Experiences of this kind come to every yachtsman and are dreaded by the right sort of amateurs only when they are sailing a freak of more than doubtful sea-going qualities. We do not agree with Mr. Day that “the large boat-own- ers have degenerated into a lot of pond sailors whose only ocean lies between Larchmont and Glen Cove.” But we do believe that if we are going to develop real sea-going sailors, like the English amateurs, the first requisite is a safe and sane type of boat, that can take punishment proportionately as well as do the Gloucester fishermen. LETTERS IN BIOGRAPHY. Since Meredith's death, all kinds of reports concerning a possible biography His own wish was said to have been strong- of him have been in circulation. ly against the writing of any Life at all. There was the story that he had warned his friends that he should “haunt” any of them who might ven- ture to assume the rdéle of biographer. Also, we had the picturesque accounts of Meredith burning a lot of his pri- vate just as Browning and Tennyson were said to have done when letters, Froude’s Carlyle was published, and likewise rumors that he had expressed the desire that any who were in posses- sion of letters from him should similar- ly destroy them. Now, however, the whole matter is put in a new light. Mr. William Meredith has sent a note to the newspapers, requesting the loan of such letters of George Meredith's as may be in existence, for the purpose of publication under the editorship of John Morley. It should seem, therefore, that we are to have “Letters,” even if not a “Life.” It would be idle to speculate on the value of such a collection of Meredith's correspondence. The fragments of his letters which have already appeared in print interesting, but not distin- guished. They do not argue that he would take his place among the great letter-writers. Many a man has been in essay or poem powerful, but in let- ters contemptible. We would not say that this was true of Dr. Holmes or Matthew Arnold, but certainly their are ther motor-boats or sail-craft, the desir- published letters were disappointing: they did not seem level with their formal writings. On the other hand, no one could have foretold from Cowper's lit- erary performances that his letters would be such a monument to his fame. However it may prove with Meredith in this respect, the printing of speci- mens of his private correspondence should aid in solving the problem of his style. Critics will be anxious to see whether he wrote to his friends in as labored a form as he used when ad- dressing the public. Probably, it will be found that Meredith’s writing was much of a piece, whether hurried or studied, and that his style was de l'homme méme. This is known, for ex- ample, to be the case with Henry James. The idiosyncrasies of his writing in novels and essays, which some innocent folk imagine him as fabricating with endless and patient toil in his books, are so the habit of his thought that they drop from him spontaneously when writ- ing—or dictating, as he does by prefer- ence—the most unpremeditated private letter to a friend. We imagine it will prove so with Meredith. It is, however, not literary form, but personality, that we most desire to the letters of a well-known It is the living picture which study in author. they present that makes up the fascina- tion of letters in biography. And, as a rule, they are the best and most vital part of any biography. When Colcridge said that literary executors have a way of making havoc with the brains of the man whose Life they undertake to write, he doubtless had in mind the way in which too many biographers obtrude their own judgment or prejudices. They do not let the man himself speak. But this he does in any copious publication of his letters. In them, he is not mere- ly off his guard, and revealing himself as he is, but escapes the misinterpreta- tion, or inability to understand, of his biographer. Of course, even letters have to be edited with discretion. The mere fact that a famous man has written them is no necéssary warrant for their being given to the light in mass. George Russell is much to be blamed for some of the American letters of Matthew Ar- nold which he published. They gave great and needless offence and pain. If they had been written about English people, Russell would have edited them more carefully, or suppressed them; but he seems to have made up his mind in

Page 9

- ¥ bial Past * NER <n se enn ¢ oe NISL APSE NS FO NG Mc Ret 5 9 cas

Aug. 19, 1909]

The Nation.

a sort of Luther spirit that, reflecting only on Americans, they were “good enough for the Galatians.” Nothing of the kind need be feared in the instance of Meredith's letters, if they are to be edited by Lord Morley. Many nice problems of editorship arise in connection with printing the letters of great writers or statesmen. If their after-fame bulks large enough, we get the complete edition of their works, in which the “Letters” stand by tnem- selves, filling volumes, as with Swift or Walpole, Franklin and Washinzton Editing, in such cases, reduces itseli to arrangement and explanatory notes. But ordinarily the difficulty of the ediror is to winnow out, in the first place, the let- ters that ought to be printed, and sfter- wards to set them properly in the frame of the “Life and Letters.” The cider fashion was to put the biography in the first half of the book, and then to ‘ump the letters at the end. This too much severed the two parts. To avoid this the practice was adopted of stringing the letters along at the end of each chapter. Even then, the reader had to be turning back and forward all the If letters are freely used in the the effect is time. narrative more pleasing, but frequently tends to break the story proper, up the consecutiveness of There is also the question whether let- ters should be grouped chronologically, or by subjects, or correspondents. Each way has its awkwardness at times, and the most skilful editing is that which varies the method, as interest or en- tire impression requires, not following throughout any too rigid plan. But how- ever they may be presented, we all agree, despite the regularly recurvent complaints about letter-writing having become a lost art, that letters consti'ute the great charm of biography. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES Of the many rare pamphlets by Thackeray or with which Thackeray was associated probably the rarest is that first (and only) number of the Whitey-Brown Paper Maga- zine, being a series of lithographs from his drawings, with explanatory text by him This is undated, but was probably printed about 1838 or 1839. That first number must have been an experiment only, as no more, 80 far as known, were ever published. The copy, which belongs to Joseph Grego and is mentioned by him in his ‘“‘Thackerayana,” published anonymously by John Camden Hotten in 1875, now belongs to Major Wil- liam H. Lambert of Philadelphia. The drawings were also reproduced in the Auto- graphic Mirror, a curious periodical made

up entirely of lithographed facsimiles of manuscripts and drawings (Vol. I. 1864). They next appear reproduced from the Autographic Mirror in the “Miscellaneous Essays, Sketches and Reviews” (1886), which forms Vol. XXVI of Thackeray's collected works. . As Grego points out, the purpose and aim of the caricatures was to hold up to ridi- cule Dr. Dionysius voluminous writer on natural philosophy and editor of the “Cabinet Cyclopedia,” and Lardner’s friend Sir Bulwer Lytton. These two gen- tlemen were connected with the Literary Chronicle, a rival of Fraser's Magazine. to which Thackeray was an tributor Lardner important con- In this probably lies the explana tion of Thackeray's series of caricatures The same matter forms the subject of “Mr Yellowplush’s Ajew,” published in Fraser's Magazine, and included in “Comic Tales and Sketches’’ (1841) The features of Diddler throughout are, it is said, a faithfu! likeness of those of the eminent philosopher, Dr. Lardner. The illustration of “Mr. Shortman’”’ ture portrait of the head of the publishing house of Longmans & Co., and Pelham” is, of cours The original drawings were formerly own afterwards is a carica “Sir Hinry Bulwer Lytton ed by Joseph Grego, editor of the two Thackeray volumes The Student’s Quarter,” ed by him in four oak frames umler glass Victoria Era Earl's Court, London, in 1897. These have recent Thackerayana™ and and were exhibit- at the Exhibition at been acquired by a Chicago collector Correspondence. PERSONALITY IN POLITICS To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION Sir: Mr. G sonality in Politics’ in the August 5 is as interesting as it is scholar- Bradford's letter on ‘Per Nation of statements and implications might well command ussion by that portion of the forum for the ly, end its attention and dis press which serves as an independent general public. All history shows that it which initiates any change in crystallized alteration is personality convention; but as soon as the is effected it is convention that disowns perronality, and at if it does not, overtly or covertly, aim to crush it out. This is true not only in politics, but in all the other fields of human activ- ity or aspiration. All | propose to say on the subject at present, however, is in reference to an observation of your cor- respondent apropos of the decade immedi- ately preceding the outbreak of our civil war. Your correspondent never have said that “up to the firing upon Fort Sumter neither side had hardly more sus- picion of an impending war than they have now.” if he had ever read “The Impend- ing Crisis,” by the recently—and unhap- pily—deceaged Southern writer, Rowan Helper, an impressive output, considering its source, and published a year or two before the war began, or-—a still more striking example—"‘The Partisan Leader” (I think that was its title), a romance based, according to my recollection, on a least ignores it, surely, would

prophesied war, successfully waged by the

157 South against the North for its separation from the latter. This volume was pub- lished, I think, as far back as some year in the early thirties, and, I may mention incidentally, was lent to me, with a recom- mendation to peruse it, by Prof. Alexander Dallas Bache, a grandson of Benjamin Franklin, and the chief of the Coast Sur- vey. Prof. Bache was the vice-president of the United States Sanitary Commission during the war, and I was its assistant secretary. Both of us resided in Wash- ington, and my Sunday evenings were gen erally spent under the chief's hospitable roof, where, from the lips of other habi tués, chiefly officers of the navy of them Southern army, and civil service, and somé ers who had retained their allegiance to the United States heard many an anecdote illustrative of the fact that the ers of that up to consider a war with the North, in lefence of thelr based on the government, | majority of the young Southern- generation had been brought property and methods, peculiar institution, a something for which it behoved them to be prepared My duties, too, brought me into not in frequent contact with wounded and sick Confederate officers and men in our Union hospitals, or in our ambulances when, at the iron 1 was with sections of our armies on the march’’—they for the line of bai- tle or for the base and | for incidents to serve for my periodical letters as “supply correspondent with the commission's va rious branches throughout the loyal states. Among these Confederates | found many confirmations of the story of a long-time prevalent anticipation in the South of Seward's I had up arins for the irrepressible conflict indeed, just before both sides took bellum lethale that fol- lowed, quite realized that a fratricidal strife was upon us. For it happened that in the autumn and winter of 1860-1861 1 lived in house--kept by ao the same boarding Italian lady—with a lot of young South- erners studying medicine at the adjacent medical college in Fourteenth Street, New York (By the fellow- boarders among the few whose lines were cast in the North was the afterwards dis- musical Theodore Before table with these young scions of the “Sunny South” § way, one of our tinguished director, Thomas.) sitting at had, like most residents hereabout, count- ed the war talk of sophomorical bravado and bluff But at with thig party—mighty pleasant and companionable young fellows they nearly all were—I real- ized that I had been mistaken; and whea I exchanged friendly adieus with them ia the spring of 1861 it was in the full con- sciousness that they were in dead earnegt in averring they were going home to join Confederate regiments to fight us Your correspondent is entirely right, so far as the North was concerned. Except among a very few more observant and long-headed men, much more familiar with the South and better read in history thag the mass of those north of Mason and Dixon's line, the war talk by those south of it during the decade of 1860-1860 was regarded as buncomb; but his statement as regards the brave upholders of what, from their point of view, were their rights, their like as mere close and continuous quarters

is contrary to historical facts. The next

Page 10

158 with its “eruel war,’ its “lost and its needless and, for the hap- less Southerners, bitterly humiliating “re- period, clearly demonstrated mainly on their their mis:ake in tendencies of decads cause construction” however great and deplorable humanitarian that own account ignoring the heir generation, they had at least been in sympathy for the they had gone and deserved and earnes sufferings losses hrough And what candid and benevolent mind now refuses respect for the South's devoted stand in conscientiously defending, igainst the equally brave and conscientious North, what the former regarded as its law- ful dues? A. J. BLoor. Stonington, Conn August 11 \ RELIC OF CHARLES LAMB. To THe EpiTror or THE NATION: Sin: Amongst my books—phrase dear to the bookman’sheart—is a “Rhymed Plea for published by Ed- well-inten- Excel- its sentiments, and fully as I is doubt- which 1833. It is a tioned effort now entirely forgotten. rolerance was ward Moxon in lent as are approve of them in the main, it ful if this particular would remain for its association with For it was once in his pos- copy on my shelves but Charles Lamb session, and was presented by him to Thomas Westwood, the Arthurian poet and scholarly It formerly had Lamb's autograph fiyleaf, until foolish—to use adjective—autograph hunter away. But he has not succeeded in spoiling the identification of the book with Elia, for the inscription, perhaps writ- has left a impression on the title-page, and favorable angle of light there can be Westwood Jun from handwriting who called up for us angler on the some no harsher cut this ten with a pencil or stylus, shadowy at a read the words we Cc. L..” in the characteristic of the gentle “the old familiar faces.” The “Rhymed Plea” is anonymous, but it is known to been the verse-writer spirit production of John and philan- thropist, who enjoys the distinction of hav- the alders of Coleridge's terms of friendship Southey, Ticknor, Bayard have Kenyon, a ing been one of family He with Wordsworth was on Taylor, Barry Cornwall, and Walter Savage Landor To him Browning dedicated his “Dramatic Romances and Lyrics.” Crabb Robinson says that Kenyon had “the face of a Benedictine monk and the joyous talk of a good fellow.” When he died in 1856 he bequeathed £10,000 to Browning. His ver es are often graceful, but they lack foree, and do not greatly grip the mind. As an admirer of Pope, to whom he says belong The beights at once of satire and sweet song, he wrote his dialogues in Pope's metre. There are vivid reminiscences of the scenery of where Kenyon was born, and it is to hear of his induc- After They are almost monologues. Bote Jamaica not without interest tion into the pleasures of literature. the horn-book The Mees came with that expanding day, First Watts strange transition Cray! A chanee-found book! Ob! how I loved to read Of Kingly Odin and the coal-Diack steed The gory shuttle tossed from hand to hand, And all the mysteries of that Runte land The Nation. Rogers, Shakespeare, Dryden, and Milton. He describes himself as having “all but took the desperate plunge—in ink,” but perhaps was checked by the fear of “the Demon of review.” “The Plea” may be summed up in its concluding lines: howe'er each sect may brawl, Where pure the life, where free the heart from gall, the creed All! Whate'er Heaven looks with Love on How did this book of Charles Lamb? Westwood in the come into the hands The clue is given by delightful reminiscences of Lamb, which he contributed to Notes and Queries (3rd S., X, 221): There were few modern books in his col- lection, and subsequently such presentation copies as he received were wont to find their way into my own book-case, and often through eccentric channels. A Leigh Hunt, for instance, would come skimming to my feet through the branches of the apple tree (our gardens were contiguous); or a Ber- nard Barton would be rolled downstairs af- ter me from the library door. “Marcian Colonna” I remember finding on my window- sill, damp with the night's fog; and the “Plea of the Midsummer Fairies” I picked out of the strawberry bed. It was not that Lamb was indifferent to the literary do- ings of his friends; but their books were unharmonious on his shelves. They clash- ed, both in outer and inner entity, with the Marlowes and Miltons that were his household gods. Doubtless the “Rhymed Plea for Toler- was a presentation copy to Lamb, whe, finding it no fit companion for Fuller's “Worthies" or for Beaumont and Fletcher's plays, passed it on by direct or devious paths into Westwood’s young and willing hands. And now it has a cherished corner “amongst my books” for its autograph, or simulacrum of an autograph—a ghostly and shadowy relic of the gentle Elia. WILLIAM E. A, August 6 ance” AXON. Southport, Eng., TOO MUCH EDUCATION. . To THE EpiTor or THE NATION: Sin: We have insisted upon free educa- tion, education for all, compulsory educa- tion; all sorts of ologies and what not have been injected into our educational systems, and what is the result? In the first place, our anxiety for so- called education, a diversity of accomplish- ments, has been such that our children have no idea of thoroughness, they cannot spell correctly, they know little of any of the fundamentals, they have been taught to skim over the surface of things, a smatter- ing of a subject has been accepted as a satisfactory attainment, frivolity is en- couraged, a frivolity that sticks all through life, in matters of the greatest importance Then, too, 80 much is attempted in our schools that the youngsters believe themselves all candidates for college and higher things; ours Is a race of embryo Presidents, Sene- tors, captains of industry, directors, and managers. All believe themselves above working with the hands, headwork only is fashionable, and the least possible of that. Our farms are abandoned, the young peo- ple flock to the cities, they cannot, will not, do manual work, they must teach or be typewriters or petty clerks pro tem., awalt- ing the time they can be enrolled upon the From Gray he passes to the Bible, Homer, lists of the great. Our trade-unions fur- [ Vol. 89, No. 2303 ther complicate matters by limiting the number of apprentices in each trade and otherwise making those trades hard or un- desirable to get into. The farm, the shop, the mine, are as much part of the State communal body as is the office, the bank, or the shop. The State should not discriminate between these and help one at the expense of the other. It is doing that now by its free education; it is pulling people away from the farm and the workbench and fitting them exclusively for work requiring scholastic attainments. All of its grade schooling is planned as pre- paratory for high school, and the high school is managed as a stepping-stone to college. The State is really to blame for existing conditions, though it has erred in judgment and does not lack in good intent By its excess of education, so to speak, it has vulgarized the sciences. It has tried to bring everything down to the lowest level of comprehension; it has made millions of mediocrities, people partially or danger- ously little educated, but it has given us few, distressingly few, brilliant minds and thorough scholars. Indeed, it has been contended that many of our criminals have become such because of compulsory edu- cation; they had to read and naturally turned to debasing, demoralizing reading that in turn led them on into evil. Had they been compelled to work without know- ing how to read, they might have turned out better. Are we to face about and seek to re- create a peasant, a laboring, and unedu- cated class? No, but it should seem that something could be done to correct the wrong that is so apparent all around us. The State has got us into this pickle, now it is the State’s duty to get us out of it. Let there be less education and more instruction in the primary grades, more character-building, a training to get the child into the way of learning and applying what is taught. Let there be less kinder- garten and playful frills and a more thor- ough grounding in the rudiments, the three R's. If the child is fitted by nature for a professional career, he'll go on, never fear; if he is not, why should the State tempt him into it, and spend its money and waste his time trying to make a doctor or a preacher out of him, and perhaps spoiling a good farmer or butcher? The State provides the education, why should it not dispose of it to its own best advantage? Is not that its duty as repre- sentative of all the people and all the in- terests? After a certain grade point is reached, then, by most discriminating and intelligent examinations, physical as well as mental, the children should be divided off according to their especial fitness, this one on to high school, and later to college and a profession, that one to manual train- ing and a trade, and the other to the agri- cultural school and the farm. What is the use of leaving it to the fond parent, who may have dedicated to the ministry an in- fant who grows up better fitted by nature for a mule-driver? Oh, certainly! If papa wants to pay for it, let him educate his mule-driver into all the higher orgies of football, polo, poker, and so on, that he may get at the best universities, but I am writing now about the education supplied by the State, and for the maintenance of which we all subscribe. 1 Ami et oe SORE tfc:

Page 11

i 1 SAIN alan ane fiat Fe eS 2 RAD Ry peri he Aug. 19, 1909] What is the sense of one, or, at most, two, agricultural schools in a State and a high school in every cross-roads village? Our entire school system needs revamp- ing. The State has mistakenly gone on in one direction. It is worse than folly to keep on because it started that way. It is most important that a change of direction be made, and the time to do it is now. F. W. FImrzPaTRick August 5. Washington, D. C., BEASTS AND THE LAW. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srtr: In the various communications that you have printed concerning the legal tria! of animals I have not noticed any refer- ence to what is surely the locus classicus on the subject, “The Wasps’ of Aris- tophanes. Philocleon, gone litigation-mad after having been long restrained from the courts by his devoted son, is at last al- lowed to amuse himself by trying a dog accused of stealing a piece of cheese. The cause is pleaded, testimony is brought for- ward, the innocent babes of the accused are produced to work upon the judicial sym- pathies, and the culprit is finally acquittei by mistake in a whirlwind of Aristophanic gayety. Racine, in ‘“‘Les Plaideurs,’”’ has imitate’ the scene closely, with somewhat more of the “gravity of mirth,’ but also with orig- inal touches of graceful pleasantry, as in the advocate’s plea for the forlorn infants: Venez, famille désolée ; Venez, pauvres enfants qu'on veut rendre orphelins, Venez faire parler vos esprits enfantins. Oui, messieurs, vous voyez ici notre misére: Nous sommes orphelins, rendez-nous notre pére, &c. GAMALIEL BRADFORD, JR. Wellesley Hills, Mass., August 15 BY MEANS OF THE ACROSTIC, To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I find that by applying Mr. W. S&S. Booth’s acrostic theory to the Sonnets Isaac Newton can be credited with ix, xii, xv, and xviii, and Robert Browning with xxviii; while Theodore Roosevelt can claim xxxi, and George Gordon (Lord Byron) cx. This is a little confusing but is easily explained by the reincarnation of the omniscient Bacon who foresaw the per- sonalities he would assume. | have no books since the fire and little time to de- vote to discovering how much of all lit- erature is attributable to this Buddha. There is a letter extant written by Bacon to Sir Richard Twomley in which he says that he is revising his works for publica- tion, and has “the assistance of the best pens in London.’’ The date of the letter identifies these “best pens” as Shakespeare, Marlowe, and Johnson, who were at that time constant callers at Bacon’s house. Con- sidering the adulation that was offered to patrons in that day there seems nothing extraordinary in these writers rather en- joying the exercise of weaving just such subtle flattery into their compositions ALEX. F. OAKEY. San Francisco, Cal., August 5. The Nation. Notes. —_— Scribner's Magazine now announces that Mr. Roosevelt's account of his African trip will begin in the October and will run for a year. issue We are glad to hear that “Anne of Green Gables" is to have a sequel (published soon by L. C. Page & Co.), in “Anne of Avonlea.” May she prove as charming as her original se If. “Stradella,” another posthumous left by F. Marion Crawford lished by the Macmillan Co novet is to be pub- in the autumn It is described as a love story of Italy of the seventeenth century Henry Holt & Co. hope to issue in Se p- third volume of DeAlva wood Alexander's “Political tember the Stan- History of the State of New York which carries the narrative down to the time of Cleve- land's first term, Two more volum: of Scribners’ New York edition of Henry James give us ‘The Golden Bowl,” with a preface in the style of those contributed to the other stories In the present case, Mr prefatorial comment James begins his thus Among many matters thrown into relief by a refreshed acquaintance with “The Golden Bowl" what perhaps most stands out for me is the still marked invgteracy of a certain indirect and oblique view of my presented action: unless, indeed, I make up my mind to call this mode of treatment, on the contrary, any superficial appearance notwithstanding, th: straightest and closest possible. difficulty in what he means by an view" of the very There is no comprehending indirect and oblique those presented action; but who wish to know what he regards as a possible alternative to this must turn to the preface itself. They will find here a discussion of literary method which is at least frank, if it is not simple With these two volumes this handsomely made edition is complete. Tokio publishing house There comes out of clad in sea- green and gold, from the of Kyo-Bun-Kwan, a slender, gracile vol- ume by J. Ingram Bryan, called “The Feeling for Nature in English Pastoral Poetry.”” Upon the outside of the cover is something vaguely Inside, there ars This is not a treatise on Oriental in a Japanese vase stars, honey, fire, dew, end flowers. pastoral poetry, gentle a pastoral poem. Under author’s mellifluous, flows cal to an almost Hibernian forgets, as the tedious details of chronology, and orthography. may feel some shade of difference of opinion from Mr. Bryan—for when he says that Bion and Moschus “remind one more of the grammarian than the poet.” But again and again one finds one’s self in heartiest accord with him. “It would be a mistake,” he says, “to be hypercritically tempted into regarding the century as a period in which there were no great poets.” Perhaps one hesitates for a moment, but on thinking of Shakespeare and Jonson and Webster and Herrick and Milton and Dryden one must conclude that Mr. Bryan is right—is indubitably right. Again he speaks of Lyly’s “poetic prose, admirable for smoothness and charm,” and reader; it is itself the spell of the ring prose, tropli- richness, the forgot, all typography, Occasionally, indeed, one reader author example, seventeenth 159 one thinks how aptly that characterization would fit the of Mr Chesterton. “The calm and cultured atmo- sphere of Ben Jonson,” he continues with another inimitable bit of generalization “did not succeed in lending spontaneity to the lifeless classicism of Waller" Alas how can we deny !t—especially as we firm- ly believe that the full and fattened purse of William successful in lending daffodils to the guid pantheism of Rockefeller? among us who knew what a feeling for na- style of Carlyle or Wordsworth was equally un- lan- Those ture is——and it is not the fault of literary investigators if any one is now in ignorance will find in this volume much that is novel “The Literary Man's Bible,”’ a selection of passages from the Old Testament his- toric, poetic, and philosophi arranged with introductory essays and annotations by W. L. Courtney, has appeared in a The volume is before the reader the lat fourth and popular edition intended to set est results of the higher criticism, and to ittract attention to ‘the extraordinary lit Bible.” The essay accomplishes the first task very su cinetly. The erary value of the prefatory various Strata of underlying text are described no less than the priestly redaction made during and after the Baby lonian captivity. The editor is at pains to point out that some points in Jewish lit erary history grow rather more remarka ble as the result of recent studies, as. for instance, that the Jews were so largely dominated by Babylonian influences and yet emerged with a set of legends monotheistir rather than polytheistk Equally extraot dinary was the intimate connection in the early nomad faith of the Hebrews between ethics and religion, to the liturgical personal com parative neglect of sacrifice and worship. It isquestionable whether the se ond part of Courtney's task is equally suc cessful. Imagine a parallel case that Wolf's had been Suppose Iliad among the Greeks of Imagine the Ur-Iliad or the tale of a proto-Achilles torn from the con hypothesis of the broached the decadence ventional context and pieced by fragment allotted on alleged internal evidence (un verifiable by the average reader) to various subsequent periods and authors. The unity of the traditional design would be so brok much of the Iiterary en as to dissipate effectiveness of the tale. Something simi lar is experienced by reading the dissected portions of the Old Testament which are here arranged in an entirely novel order The text of the King James version is very properly followed, though here the editor's literary feeling breaks away from his scien tifle leash Historical Intro- Tracts” (E. P In the preface to his duction to the Marprelate Dutton & Co.) Mr. William Pierce states that he has in mind to publish an edi tion of the Tracts themselves, with the necessary elucidations. Such a work we should welcome heartily Meanwhile we ean only commend Mr. Pierce for the dili- gent study shown in the present and regret his spirit. That spirit, at hie best, can be shown in a brief quotation Early in his life Whitgift was swept by the tide of the Reformation into the Pro testant camp; and there, so far as creda} assent goes, he remained unchanged to th end. But Protestantism is more than ans intellectual assent to a reformed creed work

Page 12

160 it is the release of a new spirit; a buoy- ant and adventurous temper of the mind, a self-realizatiog of the freedom and the prerogatives of the soul. of Protestantism Whitgift stranger. was entirely a No be taken, perhaps, to such a statement; but Mr. Pierce's sum- marizing of the conflict under Elizabeth so to place all the freedom and preroga- tives of the soul under the banner of non- conformity and only tyranny and the crook- ed of hypocrisy the side of the church ends by revolting the taste and objection will as counsels on judgment of any but the most bigoted reader. This is not to write history, but a brief for a criminal prosecution. The story of the tracts themselves, their authorship and obscure printing, Mr. Pierce has stud- ied out with care, and his work is here valuable, although he has failed to put into his narrative the buoyant and ad- venturous interest of which it would be capable in a skilful hand Leopold von Ranke’s “History of the Latin and Teutonic Nations” was published in 1824 It was the first important work of the author, who has justly been regarded with peculiar reverence as the founder of the modern scientific instruction in history. It was revised by him fifty years after its first but with thorough- ness or with suitable employment of later appearance not material. Its value to the student consists in its bringing together under one point of view the exceedingly complicated political and military events of a period in which the northern and the southern nations of Europe were engaged in working out the problem of contro) in Italy It ie not a work of the highest authority. The events it deals with have all been examined many times by more critical scholarship, but for the purpose for which it was designed, it thanks are due still remains useful, and to the translator, G. R. Dennis, and to the publishers, The Macmillan Co., for its present reproduction. The most effective work now done in political science is that going on in the field of applied politics. Avoiding abstract principles and a-priori speculation, it ad- dresses itself to examination of the actual organization of public authority and of the way in which governmental function is car- In “The Government of European (Macmillan), Prof. William Bennett Munro of Harvard has made a valuable ad- to this literature. He gives a de- of the way in which mu- nicipal government is formed and carried on in France, Germany, and England. The atyle is clear, straightforward, and unpre- and the treatment is steadily con- ried out Cities” dition tailed account tentious fined to the subject in hand without any attempt to point a moral or ald a cause. At the same time references to American municipal methods frequently occur as in- cidents of the explanation of Kuropean pro- add to the value of the book for. American readers. The writing, while succinct, copious in detail, and only edminiétrative experts in the coun- tries respectively considered could check off all the statements made; but the work itself affords intrinsic evidence of its painstaking accuracy. One cannot read the book without being deeply impressed by the essential simplicity of the principles cedure, and these is And to the ethos The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 ment is constituted. The general aspect of municipal government is far more demo- cratic than in this country, and, in view of the contrast in results, the inference suggests itself that the road to improve- ment in American conditions lies in sub- stituting simple forms for the present com- plex entanglements. The commission plan of government now fast sweeping through- out the country is a movement of this character, but it is accompanied by a re- striction in extent of representation at wide variance with European practice, in which representative assemblies are so broadly constituted that every interest or locality is assured of a voice in the man- agement of public affairs, although with no power to frustrate action prompted by consideration of general interests. Pro- fessor Munro’s work has already been widely adopted as a text-book in univer- sity instruction, and extension of its use will be salutary Scientific history has put memoirs upon its Index—but that makes little difference to other people. Memoirs continue to ap- pear and to prosper, like most things on the Index, even if they may be unreliable as records of the past and of value to the historian only when his documentary Frénilly, whose life stretched between 1768 and 1848, while not a conspicuous figure in the history of the Revolution, was ac- quainted with those who were. He was a typical product of the privileged class of the oid régime, a young man-about-town with po other purpose in life than to shine in society. His Recollections, which were begun only in 1837, show a remark- ably keen memory, particularly for small but picturesque details, but they are so deeply dyed in aristocratic prejudice that he would be a bold historian who would be willing to rest content with such a source for any incident which it recounts. The best of memories are sadly strained at the distance of forty years; here we have both strain and warp. The reader should be reminded that the Reign of Ter- ror was but one incident in the French Revolution; there have been two other reigns of terror in Paris, worse from some points of view, of which we have relatively little literary record. Yet the human in- terest in those tragic days never flags. Frénilly just touched the fringe of the Ter- ror, or else he has something to conceal— which seems quite probable. Perhaps the most interesting feature of the memoirs is the light they throw on the way the old noble families managed to save the wreck of their fortunes through the disor- der of the time and in the face of con- fiscations. This is a page of French his- tory, and of the history of property, await- ing more thorough research. With the issue by Zanichelli of Bologna of the twentieth and final volume of the complete edition of Carducci’s works, a number of critics have published estimates of different phases of his art. Benedetto Croce in a recent number of La Critica discusses the influence which foreign poets, upon which Buropean municipal govern- ducci, and ingeniously leads to the con- clusion that their effect is wholly negligi- ble. Adolfo Gandiglio’s volume, “Studio su la Canzone di Legnano,” deals carefully with the historical sources of that poem, while, as the title of the book indicates, “Il pensiero di Carlo Cattaneo e di Giu- seppe Mazzini nelle poesie di G. Carducci,” by Pietro Tommasini-Mattiuci, weighs the political and historical influences on his thought of the times in which he lived. Zanichelli proposes to begin at once, in uniform edition, the publication of UCar- ducci’s letters, and to complete this col- lection with a volume of hitherto un- published writings. In addition to this more expensive edition, the publishers have begun to issue a reprint at seven cents a volume. When once you have become attached or, as the case may be, reconciled to the floridness of his style, there are few pleas- anter guides to Italy than Mr, Edward Hut- ton. His latest book, “In Unknown Tus- cany”’ (Dutton), describes a summer passed on Monte Amiata. Most Italian travellers have at one time or another yearned toward the great blue dome that towers in southern Tuscany, and have vaguely asked themselves what it was like up there. Mr. sources confirm the tale—or are lacking | pytton answers that question. It is full altogether. In this class belongs the | of ruined feudal castles and dismantled “Recollections of Baron de Frénilly,” | monasteries. At Radicifoni and Santa Fi- which, with the Introduction and notes by ora are raany fine enamelled reliefs of Arthur Chuquet of the Institut, has been Giovanni della Robbia and his school. translated by Frederick Lees (Putrams). Everywhere there are magnificent views over the Maremma, the lakes of Trasimene and Bolsena, or towards the more distant Appenines of Umbria and the Marca. The peasants are simple, independent, and cour- teous. Intensely religious—in a _ single sector of the mountain Mr. Hutton count- ed fifty-four beacon fires on the evening of the feast of the Assumption—the re- gion has within a generation produced a Messiah. The story of David Lazzaretti, who founded a theocratic republic only to fall before the bullets of the carbineer in 1877, is one of the most interesting parts of the book. People still speak of him on the mountain as nostro Gest. Politi- cally the history of the region is remark- able. All forms of lordship were repre- sented. The Abbey of San Salvatore ruled a large part of the heights. From Santa Fiora the Aldobrandeschi played a sharp though losing game with the Emperor, the Pope, and the Commune of Siena. Small tyrants, signorotti, kept alive here the traditions of feudalism long after it had vanished from northern Tuscany. Among these little lords was the famous robber Chino di Tacco, whom Dante and Boc- eaccio have immortalized. On the other hand the town of San Salvatore obtained a substantial bill of rights from its abbot lord in 1212, three years before the Eng- lish Barons met at Runnymede. Mr. Wil- liam Heywood contributes scholarly notes on all such matters. It is evident that the fuller study of this neglected region might cast muth light on the winning of communal independence in Italy. Natural- ly Mr. Hutton’s business is with his own impressions of the people and scenery— on which topics he is characteristically lyrical—and with the historical narrative, which enlists his more sober manner. The biend if not quite harmonious is and especially Heine, exerted upon Car- agreeable enough. As to practical ways

Page 13

Aug. 19, 1909] Th. 161 and means, the unexigent Anglo-Saxon may find good permanent accommodation at Ab- badia S. Salvatore, whence on donkey back the rest of the mountain may be explored. The book contains numerous photographic cuts and eight color prints after sketches by O. F. M. Ward. These are alluring to the intending traveller if rather faintly pretty as transcribed in colored inks. Volumes XIII, XIV, and XV of Worthing- ton C. Ford’s edition of the “Journals of the Continental Congress” (Government Printing Office), aggregating more _ than 1,400 pages of text, are needed for the reeord of 1779. The new matter is greater in amount than for any previous year, more than half of the record of proceedings being now for the first time printed; while, in addition, numerous reports of committees and boards, and the entries of the “Secret Journals,’ are inserted. The year was crowded with business and anxiety. Janu- ary opened with the summary dismissal of Thomas Paine from the secretaryship of the Committee for Foreign Affairs, following his blazing indiscretion, for which he seems to have felt no remorse, in revealing diplo- matic seerets. An investigation of the con- duct of the American representatives in Europe, though disastrous to the reputa- tion of more than one actor, both at home and abroad, was followed by the abandon- ment of the plan of one commission of sev- eral members, and the appointment of min- isters plenipotentiary to Great Britain, France, Spain, and Holland. Much time was also spent in discussing the terms of the anticipated peace, the most troublesome matters being those of boundary, fishing rights, and the navigation of the Missis- sippi. On the other hand, the supreme value of the French connection is never lost sight of, Congress adopting, as early as January 14, the fateful resolution not to make peace alone. The plan for a re- newed attack on Canada, which had haunt- ed Congress ever since the failure of Arnold and Montgomery, was finally given up. Commendable progress was made in the direction of a better administrative organi- zation. An inspector-general’s department, an ordnance department, and a board of admiralty were provided for, the former Treasury system was replaced by a Treas- ury board, and persons not members of Congress were brought into the administra- tive service. Of the admiralty powers of Congress, there was frequent consideration. On the other hand, State controversies and personal bickerings were rife, and the financial] situation was moving rapidly from bad to worse. Pennsylvania preferred charges against Arnold, which had not been disposed of by the end of the year; the people of the New Hampshire Grants com- plained of the encroachments of New York, New Hampshire, and Massachusetts; Rhode Island was suffering from the effects of an embargo on the export of provisions from Connecticut and Massachusetts; and there was outspoken opposition in Maryland and elsewhere to the course of Virginia in the matter of its Western lands. A step in the direction of sounder finance was taken in September, in limiting to $200,000,000 the total issues of bills of credit; and Novem- ber 29 saw the last output of this demoral- izing form of currency. Requisitions con- tinued to be made upon the States, as in the previous year, for money and specific The Natio supplies; while in September the situation was so bad that an address to the country was issued, in which Congress pathetically urged the folly of pledging the faith of the United States for the payment of a national debt, unless the States raised promptly and fully the sums apportioned to them. The only really bright spot of the year, outside of the reorganization of the diplomatic and administrative services, was the adoption of Steuben’s admirable infantry regulations, and the increased d'sposition to rely, in military matters, upon the judgment of Washington. Of the excellence of Mr. Ford's editing we can only repeat what has al- ready been more than said in our notices of the earlier volumes of this in valuable series. once Dr. Johannes Luther's “Die Titelein- fassungen der Reformationszeit,”’ soon to be published by Rudolf Haupt of Leipzig the publisher of the publications of the Geselischaft fiir Typenkunde des XV Jahr hunderts, will be an important source for the study, not only of the typography and engraving, but of the literature and civ.) ization of the early sixteenth century In these borders we find numerous illustra- tions of costumes, processions, plays, etc., of the time. The work will be published in six or eight parts, each containing fifty plates, and for each plate a transparent duplicate Everybody interested in the médiwva! ‘Dance of Death"’ must have felt the lack of a handy treatise on the subject. The publications treating the same are almost This want Prof Breisgau all too costly, or out of print is now filled by the work of Kiinstle of Freiburg im entitled “Die Legende von den Lebenden und den drei Toten nebsteinem Exkurs tiber die Joseph drei Jakobuslegende” (Freiburg i. Br.; and St Louis, Mo., Herder) This volume super- sedes all former publications, being based on the results afforde! by the most recent research Professor Kiinstle brings suf- ficient evidence to prove that the Dance of Death is the direct outcome of the thir- teenth-century legends of the ‘three liv- ing and three dead.”’ This is a new thesis and it enables the author to elucidate the development of the legend and of its rep- the twelfth to Like 80 many other resentations in art from the fifteenth century subjects of mediwval iconography, this was suppressed by the Tridentine Council. The author presents all the texts necessary to the understanding of the and among these a Lilbeck manuscript con- taining a low German dialogue between a dead man and a living one, with highly in- teresting drawings dating from the four- teenth century. The introductory chapter on the representations of the legends of St James the Greater in German art is an admirable essay on iconography This saint was specially popular in the Middle Ages in southern Germany, where many confraternities and chapels were dedicated to him. Recently several of the latter have been freed from the whitewash concealing the frescoes on the walls, and important representations of the legends connected with the saint of Compostella have been thus discovered. Benjamin Ellis Martin died August 15 in this city. where he was born seventy years ago. He spent his life writing and travel- subject, ling, and his best-known books are ‘About England with Dickens,” “Old Chelsea,” “In the Footprints of Charlies Lamb,” and “The Stones of Paris in History and Letters.” Prof. Wilhelm Bernhardt of Washington was killed on Thursday of last week at Burlington, Vt., by a train on the Rutland Railroad. He was deaf, and it is sup- posed that he failed to hear the approach- ing train. He was born in Halle, Thurin- gia, about sixty years ago, and this country after the Franco-Prussian war. He taught in various served as director of German tn schools of Washington from 1882 to and was the author of a German grammar, a history of German literature, besides ed- German authors came to places, and the high 1896, iting editions of many The Rev. Hiram Washington Thomas, founder of the People’s Church of Chicago has died at the age of seventy-seven. In i881 Dr. Thomas was expelled from the Methodist Episcopal Church for heresy. He is the author of “Origin and Destiny of Man,’ “Life and Sermons,” and “The Peo ple’s Pulpit.” DANTE IN ENGLAND. Dante in English Literature from Chau- cer to Cary. By Paget Toynbee. New York: The Macmillan Co. $5 To collect the available references to Dante in English literature from Chau cer to Cary is indeed a Herculean task; and Dr. Toynbee is to be warmly gratulated upon his extensive perform 2 vols con ance. His sane and thorough scholar- ship, which has long been known to English and foreign lovers of Dante, now demands recognition from students of English literature. This is, sure, a book of reference rather than a critical work. But the quotations from the five or six hundred authors are 80 clearly and so admirably arranged that it is not difficult to trace the history of to be Dante’s fame in England An introductory essay sums up the conclusions of the research. It is a dif ficult task to cover so wide a topic in so few pages: and, although the prin- cipal facts are clearly and soundly set forth, the essay lacks distinction in style and seems not to have accounted sufficiently for the various streams and tendencies in literature that have caus- ed fluctuations in Dante’s fame. Nor has Dr. Toynbee thrown any new light on some of the perplexing problems in this field of criticism. He gives no satisfac- tory explanation of the curious refer- ence to Chaucer in Lydgate: He wrote also full many aday agone Daunt in Englysch hym selfe so doth ex- presse. The treatment of the influence of Dante upon Lindsay’s “Dreme” is disappoint- ing; nor is there any mention of the same author’s “Exclamatioun to. the Reader twycheyng the wrytting of Vulgare and Maternall Language,” which may have relation with the “Con- vivio” and the “De Vulgari Eloquentia.”’ In the case of Dunbar, too, as in that

Page 14

162 of Lindsay and the other Scottish poets, the problem of Italian influence needs further investigation. On all questions of the possible influence of Dante, Dr. Toynbee happily sins on the side of cau- In discussing Sackville’s Induc- tion, for example, he quotes Professor Courthope’s contention that Sackville’s were Virgil and Gavin Doug- las, and adds, “But this does not pre- clude the suggestion that Sackville was influenced by Dante as well.” It is, by the way, strange to see so excellent a scholar make the old mistake of assign- ing the plan of the poem on the model “Falls of Princes” to Sack- it is now well known, was a contributor to the work. Dr. Toynbee’s words on the relations be- tween Spenser and Dante are somewhat tion sources of Lydgate's ville, who, merely disappointing. Doubtless it is a “much debated question which it seems impos- sible definitely to decide’; but the per- sonal opinion of such a Dante scholar as the author would satisfy us more than his Scotch verdict of not proven. Such problems cannot, of course, be set- tled by parallel passages alone; it is de- cidedly refreshing to see an enthusiastic follower of a great poet refrain from as- signing to his influence similar ideas in later writers. But there are other liter- ary tests that might be applied. At the close of his preface the author asks for “information which may serve to fill the inevitable gaps in this first instalment of the history of Dante in English literature.” The first instal- ment is so elaborate and so large that additions of any moment cannot be ex- tensive, yet one or two references of minor importance it may not be amiss to give here. One interesting reference in Milton is omitted. In a letter to his friend, Deodati, written from London, April 21, 1647, the English poet be- speaks for his own religious views from the Italians the same indulgence which they showed to Alighieri and Petrarch. Under Thomas Fuller should be added a translation of Leland’s epigram on Sir Thomas Wyatt, which Dr. Toynbee prints under Anthony Wood, but which was also published in Fuller’s “Wor- thies of England,” 1662. It is also in- teresting to note that in the 1641 edl- tion of Foxe’s “Martyrs” there appears in the Index: “Dante an Italian writer against the Pope.” Dr. Toynbee is doubtless right In excluding what may be mere suggestions of the Influence of Dante, as, for example, the relations be- tween the “Vita Nuova” and the “Me- moire” of Sir Kenelm Digby. It may, however, be permissible to quote here what Professor Norton, tn an unpublish- ed letter, writes of Dante and Donne: I have the impression that there are one or two references to him in Donne's ser- mons, but possibly I am deceived by the memory of passages analogous in thought or statement of doctrine. I have not the volumes here té refer to and make sure. Rec Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 At aay rate, for richness of learning, abun- dance of thought, and depth of feeling Donne's are better worth reading than any other sermons of the time. To Americans it must seem strange that there is no allusion in these vol- umes to the influence of Dante upon American writers. To be sure, not much more than a beginning had been made before 1844, the terminus ad quem of Dr. Toynbee’s work. But the first ten cantos of the Inferno were translated by T. W. Parsons in 1843; and his dis- tinguished lines “On a bust of Dante” are no mean contribution to English poetry. Of course, the notes to Long- fellow’s translation, which are perhaps the most important contribution made by America to the literary study of Dante, do not come within the limits of this work. But Longfellow had begun his study of Dante much earlier than 1844. In his inaugural address as profes- sor of modern languages in Bowdoin College, delivered in 1830, he speaks of Dante as the immortal Father of Italian song, and adds: Throughout the Divina Commedia of Dante it is easy to trace the workings of the political and religious character of his age. Whether he leads you to the peace- ful shades of Paradise or enters that broad gate over which is inscribed, ‘Through me ye pass into the city of woe,” it is but a transcript of the stirring thoughts which agitated not only his own bosom, but the bosoms of the crowd around him, of his paternal city, of his native province, of all Italy, It is interesting to set such a passage over against Mrs. Trollope’s words writ- ten in 1832, labelled by the editor, “American ignorance of Italian litera- ture”: To speak of Chaucer, or even Spenser, as a modern appears to the Americans in- expressibly ridiculous; and all the rich and varied eloquence of Italy, from Dante to Monti, is about as much known to them as the Welsh effusions of Urien and Mor- dred to us. Doubtless the influence of Dante upon American letters was not marked until the work of Longfellow and Lowell and Norton had been published; but early allusions cannot be altogether lacking. Perhaps Dr. Toynbee has intended his work to be limited strictly to the Brit- ish Isles. In glancing over the chronological list of authors published at the end of the second volume, one is struck by the quality of the men in Bnglish litera- ture who have had the most to do with Dante. When we read the names of Chaucer, Milton, Gray, Shelley, and Keats, and of Sir Thomas Browne, Coleridge and Ruskin, we are reminded anew of the criticism that Dante com- pels attention from certain types of mind, and that the true appreciation of him is one of the touchstones of liter- ary taste. But it is not chiefly In gath- ering the tributes of such great souls as these that Dr. Toynbee has made his work of value: it is in the countless al- lusions to Dante from the lesser men that we may see more clearly the prog- ress of the Italian’s power in English literature. In some respects the editor has focussed the light on some interest- ing literary problems. The relations be- tween Gray and Cary, on the one hand, and Lamb and Cary on the other, are set forth most suggestively. Cary, by the way, is becoming more and more an important figure in our poetry. This fact is due in part to the time in which he wrote and in part to the fact that he has written what Professor Grandgent, in his interesting introduction to h’‘s lately published Inferno, calls, of the numerous English versions, “the easiest to read.” Dr. Toynbee writes: “Cary once and for all made Dante an English possession, and in so doing won for Dante, as well as for himself, a perma- nent place in English literature.” Dr. Toynbee also has valuable comments upon the work of expatriated Italians in England, such as Baretti and Fuseli, who, long before the time of the Roset- tis, helped to spread Italian influence upon English poetry and prose and to extend the knowledge of Dante. Nota- ble, too, are the comments of the editor upon Coleridge’s lecture upon Dante, and the impetus it gave not only to the sales of Cary’s version, but to the study of the poet in England. Although Dr. Toynbee’s work will nat- urally appeal more to the scholar and the student, many parts of it will not fail to arouse the interest of the gen- eral reader. It is no unlively literary adventure to wander through its pages and to see the quaint comments made upon Dante and Italian literature in the various centuries. Nor are all the early comments merely curious. Was Milton, for example, responsible for the interpretation of the Divine Comedy that led his nephew, Edward Phillips, to speak of it as the Paradise to which are added the Purgatory and the In- ferno? What must have been the con- flicts of emotion in Thomas Warton which led him to speak of Dante's “Goth- ic and extravagant innovations,” and yet to allow that his “grossest impro- prieties discover an originality of in- vention, and that his absurdities often border on sublimity”? It is odd to read of Miss Anna Seward’s attempts to rec- ommend Dante to Scott, and of his an- swer that the plan of the Divine Com- edy appeared to him unhappy, and that the personal malignity and the strange mode of revenge were presumptuous and uninteresting. Then there is the anecdote of Norton Nicholls, a fresh- man at Cambridge, drinking tea with Gray and winning that poet's encourag- ing affability by quoting a verse from Dante. And there are the curious judc- ments of Landor who at ono time called

Page 15

a +i OLE OOD IAN i ee 0 5 “ew

Aug. 19, 1909

The Nation.

the Inferno, “the most immoral and impious book that ever was written,” and who also pronounced thirty lines of the Ugolino episode to be “unequalled by any other continuous thirty lines in the whole dominions of poetry.” Not many would be likely to think of Fanny Kemble as a life-long admirer of Dante; nor to remember that Arthur Hallam rendered into verse most of the son- nets of the “Vita Nuova.” Gladstone wrote that Hallam often complained that “Dante was not properly appreciat- ed even by his admirers, who dwell only on his glowing power and sublimity, without adverting to the _ peculiar sweetness and tenderness which char- acterize, as he thought, so much of his poetry.” Many such criticisms may be found in Dr. Toynbee’s work; and we advise the general reader to go exploring for himself. He must have read little, in- deed, of English literature if he will not here find something to his purpose. And if te is also a lover of Dante, he will be glad to pay tribute again to the in- dustry, zeal, and breadth of scholarship of Dr. Toynbee. CURRENT FICTION. A Certain Rich Man. By William Allen White. New York: The Macmillan Co. Here is a full-bodied novel of the Middle West written in the generous, leisurely, ruminative style of the early Victorians. It is obvious that the au- thor has listened with interest to the yearning prophecies of The American Novel, and that he has attempted to end them by fulfilling them. Considering the magnitude of his undertaking, his success has been remarkable. He has set forth from boyhood to death the eareer of John Barclay, a representative American multi-millionaire and captain of industry. In portraying the life of Barclay he has written the history of the growth of a typical Kansas city dur- ing a period of fifty years. The actual field of the fiction may appear at first thought somewhat provincial; but Mr. White has shown a surpr'‘sing power of relating his Sycamore Ridge to the na- t’onal past, present, and future, and of making it mirror in some sort the devel- oping character of the entire country. The curtain rises on a struggling fron- tier town shortly before the beginning of the civil war. The conflict calls every competent pioneer into the ranks. The recruits from Sycamore Ridge are a faithfully composite lot—a_ tuneful Scotch harness-maker, a German, a sharp-tongued Irishman, a magnilo- quent Southerner, a passionate young abolitionist from New England, a quon- dam horsethief, and, as runaways caught by the tide of patriotism, bare- Toot, eleven-year-old Johnnie Barclay and h's chum. No one knows hetter than Mr. White what real boys say and do in every conceivable circumstance, and the first half-dozen chapters of his book dealing with the early years of his hero are, though splashed with b!ood. purely delightful. After the war the patriots, never utterly losing the ves- tiges of their soldierly consecration, fade away into matrimony, law, real-estate, wheat-raising, and railroading. Johnnie Barclay, at first a dreamy, imaginative youth fond of Emerson and music, de- velops shrewdness, acquires hardness, exhibits a bent for trading, gets the loose ends of locai business into his hands, and, finally, stride by stride upon the necks of his fellow townsmen,. emerges into the great financial world. Though the material which has been crammed into this novel is enormous, it is not without a certain large unity. The hero of the story is indeed rather Syca- more Ridge making itself a city out of the barbarous West, rather the gradual- ly awakening conscience of the nation, troubled by magnificent crimes unre- garded by the law, than John Barclay piling up his unscrupuious millions. And yet the character of the self-made Cresus, his manners, his morals, his might, are seen to be implicated “<oarse- ly or subtly in the destinies of all whom he touches, in the inmost fibres, in fact, of his town, of his State, of the whole commonwealth Nevertheless, the reader feels a loosening grip, a scat- tering of the interest in the latter part of the narrative. It was manifestly a difficult novel to terminate. Toward the end, the courts indict the rich man— the flavor here becomes strongly con- temporaneous—but he slips through their fingers. Mr. White, feeling. that this will never do, vet uninstructed by example, subjects Mr. Barclay to a kind of Christian conversion or change of heart, under the influence of which he buys up all the stock in his Trust, burns his certificates, and dies in the perform- ance of an insignificant act of self-sacri- fice. Aside from this over-moralized conclusion, there is small complaint to make on the score of realism. The aim of Mr. White, however, is far removed from the strident veracity of the alarm- ist and muckraker. He tells the truth unwinkingly, but with the reassuring poise and geniality of those who in the most dubious times believe in a slowly- bettering world. Norah Conough. By Walter George Hen- derson. New York: The Outing Pub- lishing Co. The map of British colonial fiction is being steadily filled in. Remote back districts are dotted with the red of ro- mance, and every port hath its minor Kipling. To an American the interest- ing thing about all this mass of story- telling is its solidarity, its wonderful, if familiar, coherence. We hear much of tte growing independence of the col-

163 onies, of their radical innovations u the insular way of doing their laudable similarity t The fact remains of their mu and the visible sign of it—an fidelity to the home code of malities—is as striking as ever.

Social- ly, it seems, every Colonial remains an exiled Englander. The rude conditions of military or pioneer service, the ex- otic scene, merely afford a quaint set ting for the familiar action Norah Conough is the dear girl of English story transferred, but not translated, to the comparatively fresh literary sol! of New South Wales. She and Donald Southerden, whose name sufficiently de fines him, have neighboring “selections” in a half-settled bullock-country. There is a new local technology for us to puz- zie over, and a back scene in which cat tle-fences, creeks, and gum-trees take the place of the English hedges, lanes, and parks, in which most of the action might as well have taken place. _ Theresa, the inn-keeper’s daughter, and her rough champion are the figures which give the pleasant story such distinctiveness as it can lay claim to Brothers All By Maarten Maartens New York: D. Appleton & Co This collection of short stories by “Maarten Maartens” differs little from its predecessors—unless, perhaps, as it makes smaller display of his versatil ity, and over-represents a type of hu- morous tale in which he does not excel A Dutchman who is influenced by di verse French and English models, and who writes in English chiefly upon Dutch themes, labors under evident dis- advantages. This writer has always shown a good deal of cleverness, espe cially in his stories after the French manner. It is as well for him, probably that he has not chosen French as his medium: there, we suspect, what has seemed Gallic finesse would prove to be mere Teutonic adroitness. Comparative ly few of his stories seem to have come into being through any other method than deliberate manufacture. Admira tion of his processes, of the skill with which he shapes his product to conform to the given model, and achieves the de sired finish, is, after all, a doubtful tribute. He is never so little success- ful as in his studies In the comic vein. Dutch peasant life offers pien- ty of material in this kind, but he is unable to make use of it; he cannot create an Ichabod Crane or a Mrs. Poy- ser. Half-a-dozen of the present stories are mere bits of facetiousness. The story-teller is at his best In those sim- pler and soberer sketches of Dutch character and manners which constitute his rea] gift to the literature of the day “The Death-Way” ani “The Promise,” with their grimly tender insight and sympathy, represent a sincere and fruit- ful native humor. Even in these tales—

Page 16

164 though less noticeably than elseewhere— effect is confused somewhat by the er’s attempt to translate the speech e Dutch peasant or burgher into vernacular terms. When a dy- ays, “Something's gone in my innards: I've a-felt it going. The farm’s very small and poor, but I done my best,” we find it hard to realize that a farmer of Holland is supposed to be the speaker. He seems merely to be using bad English of no particular habitat. with Galatea. By Curtis With illustrations by Oli- Boston: Houghton Mif- Gam bolling Dunham. ver Herford. flin Co. It would be interesting to know what Mr. Herford, to whom has fallen the task of bepicturing this extravaganza, really thinks of its quality. Mr. Her- ford's own sense of humor, though not extreme of fastidiousness, always the is lively and discriminating. Did this “bucolic romance” really seem to him entertaining, or did he simply make the best of it, choose a passage here and there which seemed to invite a fantastic pencil, and forget the whole affair as quickly as possible? The tale belongs roughly to the Bangs school. e heroine is named Galatea, and one of the other persons is a pig, who ex- quisitely becomes Pig-malion for a whole chapter, and has his portrait taken in Galatea’s lingerie hat. This taken as a fair sample of the which make up the may be sprightly episodes narrative. The tediousness of the per- formance is aggravated by the “liter- ary” affectation of its style. THE FAITH OF ISLAM. The Religious Attitude and Life in Is- lam {Haskell Lectures]. By Duncan Black Macdonald, Chicago: University of Chicago Press. $1.75 net. In a former volume, on “Muslim The- ology, Jurisprudence, and Constitution- al Theory,” Professor Macdonald has discussed Moslem’ theological dogma, including such points as the being and attributes of deity, human freedom, and the question whether the Koran was created or uncreated; in the present vol- ume, he describes the ideas of the Mos- lems respecting intercourse with the un- seen world—as his thesis, he takes Pro- fessor William James's definition of re- ligion, that it is the belief in an unseen order. In the life of the Moslem [Mac- donald says the “Oriental,” but the term is too broad], with his lack of the sense of law, the unseen plays a great part; our author’s object is to describe the methods by which relations with the supernatural are maintained through prophets, diviners, magic, jinn, dreams, and saints. In all these cases there is divine revelation. Prophets, Hebrew and Arabian, spoke by compulsion from The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 without, and commonly their utterances were in poetical form. In connection with this fact there is a question of some interest. Macdonald, here following Goldziher, observes that there is no dis- tinctive word in Hebrew for “poet,” and the common Arabic word for “poet’’ means “he who knows”; there is also a Hebrew term for “diviner’” with the same meaning. Goldziher concludes that for the Arabs poetry was magical ut- terance, and the poet in part a magician and soothsayer. It is doubtful, however, whether this is the proper statement of the Old-Semitic conception of the re- lation between poetry and magic. The authors of the great pre-Mohammedan Arabian poems speak out of their own minds, with no hint of supernatural in- fluence, and there is no trace of the relation in question in the Babylonian and Hebrew literatures. The better state- ment would seem to be that, according to Semitic ideas, all remarkable deeds and utterances came through supernat- ural influence; seers, soothsayers, and prophets spoke under a divine seizure, and as their words, by a natural hu- man instinct, fell into rhythmical form, this form came to be associated with soothsayers who, in old times, were the principal speakers of the community, and in Arabic the “knower’” came to be the term for poet. Poetry was the nat- ural form of speech of the inspired man; it was not that the poet was a sooth- sayer, but that the soothsayer was a poet. This, however, is an incidental point so far as regards the main object of Professor Macdonald’s volume. He has collected a large mass of ma- terial illustrating Moslem opinions con- cerning the messages brought to men from the other world in sleep and by jinn. For a full history of the jinn our data are regrettably meager: ertson Smith’s definition of them as “gods without worshippers” hardly does justice to the known facts; they are the spirits of early times, good and bad. Even in Mohammed's day there were believing jinn, and later these came to play a great role; they formed mar- riage alliances with human beings, and became the teachers and the pupils of saints. As for the Moslem belief in dreams, it was and is substantially the same as that which has been and is now not uncommon in the Christian world. An excellent feature of this volume is the exposition it gives of the Mos- lem philosophical explanations of the phenomena of prophecy and dreams; particularly Ibn Khaldun is cited at great length. This philosopher, it is true, is unique in the Moslem world—almost modern, as Macdonald says, in the sci- entific character of his thought; he was late (ca. 1400 a. p.), and he was much influenced by Greek philosophy. Still we may suppose that he represents advanc- ed Moslem opinion to a certain extent, and, in any case, his views have in- terest for modern psychologists. His point is that the soul is potentially a spiritual essence, ordinarily restrained by the body, through which it works; but it is possible that it may become free from the trammels of the bodily senses, in which case it will attain to the apprehension of reality and to the vision of the future. Such an emancipa- tion may take place in sleep, when the eyes of the rational soul are open. In idiots and insane persons also the ordi- nary capacities of the mind are obscur- ed or effaced, and the soul is in fit con- dition to enter into relation with the spiritual powers of the world. Men differ in their aptitude for spir- itual illumination; the most gifted persons in this regard are prophets, to whom the essence of truth and the se- crets of the future are revealed by God. Various other classes of persons are dis- cussed by Ibn Khaldun, such as as- trologers, wizards, diviners, and his sys- tem embraces practically all occult phe- nomena, Comparisons with the meth- ods of Christian science and the phe- nomena of hypnotism naturally suggest themselves, and are made by Macdon- ald; can Mohammed’s experience have been a case of auto-hypnotism? The ascetic life, with its mystical ex- periences, has been developed to an ex- traordinary extent by the Moslems, and .rofessor Macdonald devotes much space to the famous mystic Al-Ghazzali, quoting largely from his works, espe- cially from his remarkable autobiogra- phy (ca. 1100 a. p.), Al-Ghazzali, in his search for certainty, had fallen into complete skepticism. He found that his senses deceived him, and concluded that his reason was no more trustworthy than they. From this disease God healed him by a light cast into his breast, and he proceeded to examine the systems of the scholastic theologians, the allegorists, the philosophers and the sufis. It was only in the last of these that he found satisfaction, and, after passing througha variety of experiences, he withdrew wholly from the world and gave him- self up to meditation. At last he found peace by excluding all earthly things and immersing himself in the thought ot God. Reasoning and speculation he cast away, and sought to be conscious of nothing but God. The man’s serious- ness and modesty make him an attrac- tive figure, and he became a force in and beyond Islam. We are indebted to Professor Macdon- ald for a valuable exposition of one phase of Moslem thought, and we would suggest that the value of his work would be increased by distinguishing between the three sections of Islam, the Semitic, the Aryan, and the Berber. It is only the Aryan that has developed mystf- cism.

Page 17

Aug. 19, 1909] The Nation. Sir George Mackenzie, King’s Advocate, of Rosehaugh: His Life and Times. By Andrew Lang. New York: Long- mans, Green, & Co. $4.20 net. The names usually associated with the royalist side of the dramatic strug- gle of Restoration times in Scotland are those of Monmouth, Lauderdale, Claver- house, and Sharp, soldiers, statesmen, or churchmen. The name of Sir George Mackenzie of Rosehaugh, who as King’s Advocate from 1677 to 1686, and again in 1688-9, had principal charge of the government prosecutions, scarcely ap- pears at all in the ordinary books, and, when it does, is almost invariably cou- pled with the invidious epithet “The Bloody.” Sir Walter Scott, who did more to mould the popular conception of Scottish history than any other writ- er, mentions him several times in the Waverley Novels, almost invariably in terms of disparagement; the Dictionary of National Biography, “the modern Book of Doom,” as Mr. Lang calls it, declares that the “one redeeming fea- ture” of Mackenzie was his love of literature; so strong, indeed, is the pre- vailing tendency to attribute to him every single legal iniquity of the age in which he lived, that so eminent an his- torian as P. Hume Brown has been led into the grave error of assigning to him the réle of government prosecutor of the rebels of the Pentland Rising, in 1666, and of intimating that he was re- sponsible for the detestable torturing of Hugh Mackail, whereas in reality he was counsel for the defence, and did all in his power, at that stage of his ca- reer, to mitigate the severity of the pun- ishment of the Covenanters. A truer picture of the great King’s Advocate was given by John Willcock, whose life of the Earl of Argyll appeared in 1907, and who there lamented the fact that, though several zealous attempts had been made to represent the ruthless Claverhouse as a hero, Sir George Mack- enzie still lacked a defender. Pos- sibly it may have been at Mr. Will- cock’s suggestion that Mr. Lang took up the task. Whatever the cause of its in- ception, his book is, like all his other works, deeply interesting; it adds much to our knowledge of the life of its sub- ject, and it presents him in a far more favorable light than ever before. The importance of Mackenzie’s career as King’s Advocate has caused many writers to forget that during the great- er part of his life he was a friend and defender of the Covenanters. His pros- ecution of the Earl of Argyll in 1685 has overshadowed the fact that he won his first great legal reputation by his bril- Mant, though unsuccessful, defence of that Earl’s father in 1661. The key to his whole career is to be found in the reasons that impelled him to change sides, and accept the post of King’s Advo- cate in 1677. Briefly stated, if we omit his personal hatred of Lockhart, those reasons may be described as a firm con- viction that the maintenance of order by persecution was preferable to anar- chy and civil war. “Resistance in the name of civil and religious liberty was now going ‘beyond his first inclination,’ and he sided with the government, as a Radical, in face of Socialism, may be- come a Tory.” From that time onward his main tenet was that personal belief should be suppressed or dissembled at the bidding of authority, and that the state was at liberty to compel outward conformity to certain things, not be- cause they were true, but because they had been commanded. Thus the man whose bon naturel shrank from harsh measures allowed himself to be convert- ed into a persecutor. Such is Mr. Lange’s argument: and there is certainly much to be said for his side of the case. Whatever the final verdict of history about Mackenzie may be, it is clear that he deserves to be far better known than he has hitherto been. He is an infinitely more interest- ing person than Lauderdale; in some respects he is abreast of his more showy contemporary, Claverhouse. As a law- yer he was in the very first rank: a¢ a writer of prose and poetry, prolific and able. A rather melancholy interest at- taches to his final withdrawal, on the ar- rival of “Dutch William” and a régime in which he preferred to find no place, for study and seclusion to Oxford, “that dear city of youth and dream”: and the picture stands out the sharper by contrast with the dramatic ending of Dundee’s career at the pass of Killie- crankie. Social Organization: A Study of the Larger Mind. By Charles Horton Cooley. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $1.50 net. This is a notable book, full of dis- criminating insight and freighted with well-canvassed and hopeful! forecasis for democracy. The title sounds a bit mys- tifying, and might with advantage be re- placed by the less ambiguous phrase— a study of public opinion. For by “social organization” Mr. Cooley means essential- ly this: an analysis of public opinion, its genesis, nature, and functions, not only in the fleeting present, but in its more durable manifestations, such as its dom- inant ideals, its stratification in social classes, its methods of intercommunica- tion, its institutions, and its corporate activities. The book goes far to recon- cile one to the claim that there is a special sociological point of view, if one so chooses to call the attempt to scan society in its tout ensemble rather than from the narrower specia] standpoint of narrative history, economics, or poll- tics. Except that he limits his an:lysis to material psychological in essence, to the conscious though purely provisional exclusion of the physical environment, 165 his book is what an Aristotelian would call politics. It is much as though Mr. Bryce had written a work on the Amer- ican Common-Mind, ratter than on the American Commonwealth. It exempli- fies also a refreshing absence of the hyster'a with which the _ professtonal worshippers of the sociological Baa! leap upon the altar and cry aloud and cut themselves after their manner, though they succeed in evoking “no voice, nor any to answer, nor any that regardeth.” The single pertinent criticism to be passed on this work is what we deem its ill-founded assimilation of the eocial consciousness to what we know as self- consciousness The truth or falsity of this identification in nowise impairs the ripe wisdom that everywhere illumi- nates the discussion of concrete phases of public opinion. But the notion Itself is so little substantiated that its diacred- iting is worth while. “Mind,” says Mr. Cooley at the outset (p 3), “is aa or- ganic whole made up of coéperating in dividualities in somewhat the same way that the music of an orchestra is made up of divergent but related sounds.” “Self and society are twin-born and the notion of a separate and inde pendent ego is an illusion” (p. 5). “I am aware of the social group in w'iich I live as and authentically as I am aware of myself’ (p 9) The “codéperative activity” of individuals “gives us public consciousness, or, to use a more familiar term, public opinion, in the broad sense of a group state of mind which is more less distinctly aware of itself" (p. 10) immediately or At the peril of aligning ourselves with the benighted followers of com- mon-sense, we feel disposed to deny these assertions in toto. Making every allowance for the way one mind ts col- ored by its with anothe’, as well as for the comparatively late emer- gence in child psychology of the “I-con- cept,” the idea that even the most ex- treme mutual sympathy creates a cor- porate consciousness like in kind to in- dividual self-consciousness can onl~ be set down as an illusion. The gclden thread of persisting self-identity which threads the beads of individual paychi- cal experiences must be absent on the larger social scale. Dissent to Mr. Cooley’s view from a slightly differ- contact ent angle is admirably put by Henry Rutgers Marshall in his “Instinct and Reason,” where he first shows how the alleged social organism, if it ex- ists at all, is akin to the lowest cell-com- plexes which are aggregated together instead of integrated. He then per- tinently concludes that it is improper to speak of “the opinions of aggregates of men” . as a “social conscious- ness” . “for the conception of a social consciousness implies that the thoughts of men as they are related to the whole pulse of the social consvious- ness, must correspond in the main with

Page 18

166 particular psychic elements in us as these are related to the whole puire of our own conscious life” (“Instinct and Reason,” p. 189). As remarked above, the cardinal] error does not infect the substance of the analysis which follows. This analysis is wholly admirable. It is as though Lincoln, with his range of insight and experience, had superadded the culture of the schools, and were calmly ,oint- ing out in his exposé of public opinion the moral legitimacy of democracy. II- lustrative of the originality of the au- thor is his calm reargument and :¢but- tal of the hasty conclusion that group opinion is commonly below the average of intelligence in the group (p. 123 sq). Typical of his ripeness and sanity in matters of practical concern is his ad- verse verdict upon the general efficacy of “the referendum and similar d -vices for increased participation of the people at large in the details of legislatior (p. 129). Rare discrimination is show: for example, in the subtle inquiry whether democracy is hostile to distinction in production, in art or literature (p 157 sq.). The conclusion reached distin- guishes between the forces of a transi- tional era and the influence of democ- racy proper. The former are adjvdged hostile to distinction, but not the ‘atter. But chiefly of value is the sustained tone of calm, reasoned, but exacting morality which breathes in every page. Not for nothing Professor Cooley perused his Emerson. The Emersonian reach and wit and aphorism are very much in evidence. Like Emerson, too, he has garnered his fruit, leaving no pickings for the would-be follower They will find no forgotten apples to appro- priate as their own under Profcssor Cooley’s well-beaten tree of knowledge. has We Two in West Africa. By Decima Moore and Major F. G. Guggisberg. C.M.G.. R.E. With numerous illustra- tions and maps. New York; Import ed by Charles Scribner's Sons. $3.50 net This is the clever story, told by his wife, of the “going on tour” of the Di rector of Surveys of the Gold Coast, as the journeys are called which the head of every department makes periodically his staff, scattered through the colony, are carrying on their work, and to keep himself in touch with local conditions and requirements in the vart- ous districts The book is thus not simply an account of experiences in the West African “bush,” but describes the methods by which the native is ruled, and the natural wealth of his land Is de- veloped through railways, mines, botani- gardens, and agricultural stations to see how cal established to teach especially the in- telligent cultivation of cocoa and rub ber. The first part of the journey was by The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 rail to the gold district, and much space is devoted to the mining industry, whose ultimate success, it appears, depends mainly on the cheapening of transport by the creation of motor roads and rail- ways. Then followed a trip by ham- mock into Ashanti, in order to deter- mine the boundary between that coun- try and the Gold Coast. Here they were carried into regions never before vis- ited by a white woman. Some of the refinements of civilization, however, had preceded them. In a remote wild corner of the forest they came sudden- ly upon the chief of a town with his state umbrellas surrounded by a swarm of natives in gay-colored cloths and a half-naked band, consisting of a large drum, two kettledrums, and _ several fifes. This “struck up ‘God Save the King’ as we appeared,” and at its close the chief and his retinue “started for the town, followed by the band, playing “Way Down upon de Swanee Ribber,’ the drummer beating the big drum for all he was worth, and the conductor wildly waving his wee bit of stick.” The news of the coming of a white man and a white “mammie,” we may add, had been drummed by bush telegraph the day they set out from Kumasi to every village along the road a bundred miles before them. Occasionally they stopped at the stations of the district officers, and the life of these often “soli- tary pale-faced, fever-stricken” English- men, and the patient discharge of their duties as shown in the long-winded “pal- avers” on tribal boundaries, give one a high impression of these men whose single aim is to improve the condition of the native. The larger part of the book is natur- ally devoted to an account of various ex- periences while travelling, and many trivial details, especially of camp-life, are recorded, which make it at times somewhat wearisome reading. For the information which it gives, however, it is a valuable contribution to the litera- ture of the Gold Coast. The illustra- tions, 148 in number, are reproductions of photographs of nearly every notewor- thy scene and incident of the journey. Haremlik. By Demetra Vaka (Mrs. Ken- neth Brown). Boston: Houghton Mif- flin Co. $1.25 net. People who see in the positicn of Turkish women a subject for amazement or regret will find “Haremlik” disap- pointing or pleasing, as the case may be. The life of the women of the harem as portrayed by Demetra Vaka is ne!ther an unhappy nor a subservient one. Our writer is of Greek descent, born and educated at Constantinople, and married to an American. She should be aquali- fled to interpret the East to the West. To her, then, life in the harem passes in an atmosphere of sunshine and felic- ity. It is true that Turkish women suf- fer at times, but that would seem to be only when they are affected by our per- verse Western ideas on monogamy. Such instances are, however, rare. As a rule Turkish women scoff at the idea that one wife is quite enough for a man. Sometimes they even take it upon them- selves to find an additional wife or two for their husbands. On such occasions, as may be imagined, they display fore- sight as well as zeal. The new wite, as a rule, brings with her some missing element of happiness. Her presence also serves to intensify the spirit of ideal- ism and self-sacrifice in her predeces- sors. In spite, therefore, of her lone ac- quaintance with American civilization, Demetra Vaka maintains that the pre- mature adoption of Western ideas by the people of Turkey in general, and the women in particular, would bring about their destruction. From this standpoint our writer passes in review a number of incidents in Turkish do- mestic life which carry a certain East- ern tone, but are skilfully colored to suit the taste of romantic American readers. She cannot sufficiently praise the beauty, devotion, and integrity of the true Turkish woman, and she has little sympathy for the revolutionists among them, who find in Schopenhauer, Kant, and suffragette ideals merely un- happiness. A secret meeting of these radicals of the harem is described with something of the abandon of the Ameri- can reporter. In spite of assurances at the beginning of the book that every- thing in it is practically true, we fird it somewhat difficult to believe tha‘ the chairman's address at the meeting in question “ended up with the proposition that six members of the club should be chosen to kill themselves as a protest against the existing order of things.” When the president is made to suggest that she, by virtue of her office, should be excluded from participation in the lot-drawing, we are pretty near to bur- lesque. The women of the harem who, as we know now, played an important réle in the overthrow of the Hamidian régime, must surely have had more sense than that. Science. “The Balance of Nature and Modern Con- ditions of Cultivation,” by George Abbey (E. P. Dutton & Co.), despite the reticence of its title, Geals with Great Britain alone. The bulk of the book is thus of value chiefly to Englishmen; but the introduction is of more general interest, being a history of the rise of sporting, fishing, forestry, gardening, and farming in England from the earliest recorded period to the present. The sub-title, ‘A Practical Manual of Ani- mal Foes and Friends for the Country Gen- tleman, the Farmer, the Forester, the Gar- dener, and the Sportsman,” defines the specific purpose of the work, which is to

Page 19

Aug. 19, 1909] discuss the wild and semi-wild vertebrates —mammals, birds, reptiles, and amphibians —found in the British Islands, in regard to their beneficial, neutral, or harmful rela- tion to the cultivation of crops. Mr. Abbey treats fully of “aids’’ and “hindrances’’; or, respectively, methods of protecting ben- eficial species, and of trapping or other- wise exterminating harmful creatures. One is rather skeptical of the science of an author who boasts of obligation only to “Wood's Natural History” and to two con- temporaneous treatises of equal value. But Mr. Abbey shows himse'f a close observer, and in food habits at least makes a real contribution to our knowledge of the Brit- ish fauna. The illustrations are numerous, but are mostly amateurish pen-and-ink at- tempts, which are almost unrecognizable and might well have graced some volume of a century ago. In a well-bound and well- printed book of 1909 they are merely laugh- able. The same artist has depicted nu- merous traps and methods of trapping, and these, considered diagramatically, convey valuable hints, which may be adopted to advantage by farmers in this country. The author is moderate in his statements, but a book such as this should be used with discretion, as a bird or animal may be harmful in one country and beneficial in another; while again its destructive or beneficent qualities may vary with the seasons. As “Epoch-Making Contributions to Medi- cine, Surgery, and the Allied Sciences” (W. B. Saunders Co.), Dr. C. N. B. Camac has brought together fundamental articles, now become medical classics, by seven noted authors: Lister, Harvey, Auenbrugger, La- énnec, Jenner, Morton, and Holmes. The object of the book is to give to students “the article which communicated such ob- servations as first placed the subject upon a sound scientific basis.’”” For each author there is a portrait and a list of his writ- ings, and for each, with the exception of Lister, a short biography. To the ar- ticles on ether Simpson’s pamphlet on chlo- roform is added. The controversy between Morton, Wells, and Jackson, concerning the discovery of anwsthesia is treated rather briefly, and Dr. Camac_ unhesitatingly awards the honor to Morton. The exist- ence of other claims is not mentioned. The bogk is handsomely and, barring a few slight typographical errors in the bibliog- raphy, excellently printed, and should keen- ly interest those medical aves—who can be induced to read anything outside the required textbooks. students—rara Under the title “Bacterial Food Poisoning” (E. B. Treat & Co.), Dr. C. F. Bolduan gives the reader an annotated version of a little book which Dieudonné of Municn published something more than a year ago. In a hundred pages of text are given the essentials of our present knowledge of poisoning by meat, fish, milk in its various preparations, potatoes, and a few othr foodstuffs. It is interesting to see how completely the point of view regarding this question has changed. Not many years ago it seemed as though the ptomaines of Brieger and the tyrotoxicon of Vaughan fur- nished the solution of these poison problems, and that most, if not all, of the disturb- ances attributable to foods would be found to be caused by specific substances of this kind. Later researches, often of great dif- The Nation. ficulty, seem to show, however, that such substances are far less important than cer- tain bacteria, developed in foods that for some reason have gone “wrong.” or than the toxic substances they produce. quite’ differ- ent from the ptomaines. Although often too technical and brief for a full understanding of the question, the book is profitable read- ing for any intelligent layman. The trans- lation is smooth, but there is a slight con- fusion in the nomenclature of the organisms and the linguistic difficulty, now common to bacteriologists, balloonists, and aviators, concerning the derivatives of aér presents itself on many rages. “Die natiirlichen Pflanzenfamilien ihren Gattungen und insbesondere den Nutzpflanzen,”’ edited by Prof. Adolf Engler of Berlin (Leipzig: H Engelmann), deserves mention as the most complete botanical work published The first volume appeared in 1887, and the nineteenth and concluding volume has just issued. More than have contributed to it, and the their exact and exhaustive researches can- not fail to be gratifying an! stimylating to all specialists in this department of natural nebst wichtigern Arten, evel been sixty botanisis results of science, The to add to its list of valuable monographs in natu- The latest volume is by Prof. K. Saj6, “Unsere Honigbiene,” deals with the culture of and Switzerland. Dr. Chicago, Kosmos, Stuttgart, continues ral science. and bees in Germany died in three interested in was the Training School for Sarah Hackett Stevenson August 14, Dr. Stevenson many charitable institutions and founder of the Illinois Nurses, and one of the promoters of the Home for Incurables She the first woman appointed instructor in the North- westerp Medical College, after a years illness. was was and also was the first wcman admitted to membership in the American Medical She was born in Ogle County, Illinois, in 1843, and from the Woman's Medical Col- 1873. She the author of a biology and medical pa- Association. graduated lege in was work on various pers Drama. Plays. By John Galsworthy. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $1.35 Those who have felt the irritation of Mr. Galsworthy'’s subtly novels will know what to expect from the three plays included in this volume, “The Silver Box,” “Joy,” and “St ife.” The remorseless preying of vital egotism upon dress-parade principles, or, to state it more broadly, the seemingly hopeless conflict of ideal justice with natura) in- stincts—this is the underlying theme. In the “Silver Box” a member of Par- liament sacrifices a poor man to save the reputation of his son—justice against the paternal instinct; in “Joy” a mother sacrifices to some extent her uncle and even her own daughter to save her lover—justice against the ama- tory instinct; in “Strife’’ the two non- compromising and principled representa- interrogative 167 tives of capital and labor are sacrificed to save their women and children— jus- tice against the instinct of self-preserva- tion. In the end we are all left darkling, troubled, as by twinkling lights extin- guished in a great mist. Roberts the labor-leader fn the last-named play-—by far the most effective of the three— thinks he knows the way out. When his famine-stricken fellows cry, “Give in to Nature,” he retorts with rude eloquence, “I tell you, strike your blow in Na- ture’s face—an’ let it do its worst!” But Nature strikes back, and Roberts falls. To Mr. Galsworthy there is a bit- ter reality in the trite phrase, the “‘prob- lems of life.” As yet he has been able to do little but indicate them; indicate them he does with painful pungency and ‘teration. His plays, consequently, have, like his novels, the interest of difficulties seriously confronted, vividly experi- enced. It has been said that the drama of the future will concern itself with the clash, not of characters, but of classes, and Mr. Galsworthy is emphatically a writer of the future, cautiously feeling his way into that vaguely defined and still more vaguely understood socialistic movement which may conceivably char- acterize the twentieth century as the democratic movement characterized the nineteenth. If such be the case, the future of the drama as a living literary form is dark. But the antithesis of class conflict and character conflict has been too sharply put; there is no necessary incompatibility between them. In fact, Shakespeare's “Coriolanus’—a tragedy, by the way, much underread and under- estimated—already demonstrates’ the possibility of representing the most bit ter class conflict in the most tremendous character conflict. Now, the effect of Mr. Galsworthy’s plays, in spite of their undeniable vitality, is very far from tremendous. His deficiencies are partly corrigible. He ought not, for example, to waste his energies in imitating the vivacities of Mr. G. B. Shaw, as he has done in the rather futile comedy called “Joy,” of which, furthermore, the expo- sition is very awkward. He ought not to confuse a situation with a plot, which he seems almost to have done in “Strife.” He ought to avail himself very gingerly of Ibsenese symbolism But, above all, he ought to recognize that great drama requires great characters The modern dramatist, in spite of mod- ern experiments, may still be urged prayerfully to meditate Aristotle's ob- servations upon the character of the tragic hero, and to remember the prac- tice of the Elizabethans. Mr. Galswor- thy’s leading dramatis persone are not so much feeble in characterization as in character—which is to be deplored be cause he is possessed of the seriousness, the idealism, and the irony which go to the creation of tragedy.

Page 20

168 A new edition of Sidney Lee's “Life of William Shakespeare,” now issued by the Macmillan Co., shows thoroughgoing re- vision. It is not so much that entirely new pages have been added, as that by provid- ing throughout the book details of evi- dence, what was general has been made specific. The sum total of changes is not than sixteen pages, but again and again these alterations have compelled a change in pagination. To the list of illus- trations has been added a copy of the con- temporary inscription in Jaggard’s pre- sentation copy of the first folio. In gen- eral, this new edition seems an improve- ment unon the old in its care to bring out the evidence, however persuasive a theory This is clearly a revi- more in itself may be sion which replaces the earlier edition, not an unimportant reissue. It is, however, disappointing that Mr. Lee has not so edited the note on page 40 as to include references to the interesting discus- sions of the Elizabethan stage by Brod- meler, Reynolds Albright, and Archer. Why, too, in the note on page 43 is Creizenach's “Die Schauspiele der eng- lischen Komédianten” omitted? Wegener, Art. ——_ GENTILE DA FABRIANO.* Lafcadio Hearn tells us that a Jap- anese daimio had the right to hew down summarily “an other than expected fel- low”—that is, one who accosted him brusquely or in terms not sanctioned by an immemorial etiquette. Towards the artist the public has always assumed *tientile santi da Fabriano, by Arduino Cola- Instituto Italiano d’Arti Grafiche), is a compact and scholarly mono- graph abounding in carefully sifted infor- mation, much of which is new, and ade- Dr. Cola- Santi prints a document from the Lateran archives which definitely fixes the death of Gentile in the year 1428, confirming the general chronology of Vasari The posi- tion of the lost frescoes in the Lateran has (Bergamo quate also on the critical side also been accurately ascertained. The po- lemical part of the study is largely devoted o the always dublous matter of an inde- pendent school of painting in the Adriatic Marches. Our author takes the affirmative view, and makes the most of a rather un- Again in tracing the un- widespread influence of Gentile questions whether what is satisfactory case doubtedly sometimes one called Gentilesque is not merely derivative from Siena from which he himself drew so much But in general. Dr. Colasanti will command a cautious reader's confi- dence We take serious issue with him only for helping to fix upon the little Ma- donna with Sigismondo Malatesta, in the Louvre, the too ambitious attribution to Jacopo Bellini. Its obvious superficial af- finities with Jacopo’s work will hardly sur- vive an w@athetic analysie of the picture it- With all its charm, it has no charac- to justify the ascription to any Like all the Bergamo mono- self teristic great master. graphs, this book is fully Miusirated with half-tones of good quality The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2303 this lordly prerogative. The other than expected fellow, whether he calls himself Uccello or Millet, Caravaggio or Whist- ler, has invariably had his period of faring ill. All triumphant and wise art- ists have had the grace of concealing their unexpectedness. Raphael came down from Urbino and in a short life- time revolutionized the graphic design of the world. But he always had the gracious air of a conformist, and, in fact, each work made so little break with the past, and so ingratiatingly pre- pared the way for the next departure, that men were admiring the School of Athens before they had ceased to adore the fugleman of Perugino. A hundred years before Raphael, a young painter from the same March of Ancona carried his broadening art from his native hills through the proudest cities of Italy—Venice, Florence, and Siena, to Rome itself. Gentile da Fabri- ano, like.his greater antitype, made the most of a pretty scanty education, drank from many cups, everywhere won for himself friends, honors, and gold, and left a deep if not a permanent impress upon his generation. Every work of his shows a passion for perfection, guided by a prudent sense of means and possi- bilities. We mark in him a fine economy of workmanship, an elaborate yet not merely cumulative beauty, which betok- ens serenity both in conceiving the vi- sion and in transferring it to panel or plaster. In short, Gentile da Fabriano came about as near being a Raphael as anybody could who was born to share the bankruptcy of Gothic painting. Unhappily, time has shorn Gentile of the chief evidences of his power and ver- satility. We cherish him for a few altar- pieces of exquisite feeling and work- manship, giving him a place in our af- fections with Lorenzo Monaco or the Sienese Sassetta. His contemporaries held a higher opinion of him. In the Ducal Palace of Venice might be seen until the fire of 1577 Gentile’s frescoes in the Hall of the Great Council. The very subjects are amazing for a painter whose work, according to Michelangelo, was “as gentle as his name.” In one panel the young Fabrianoese (his latest biographer sets these works as early as 1410) depicted the naval battle in which the Venetians conquered Otto III, the son of Barbarossa. On this work we fortunately have the opinion of a critic of the high renaissance, Francesco San- sovino, who praises the entanglement of the galleys and the fury of the combat- ants—precisely those qualities of energy in which Gentile seems deficient. Of the companion-piece which represented a storm, the chronicler Facio writes that “the sight of the whirlwind uprooting trees, etc. [alas that etc.!] struck with fear those who beheld it.” Of the chapel which Gentile painted in the ancient Broletto of Brescia we know not even the subject. But Facio tells us of the frescoes representing the life of John the Baptist painted in the Lateran, 1427, that Gentile, as if presaging his immi- nent death, here outdid himself. And, happily, Facio gives better testimony than his own as to the excellence of these works. Rogier de la Pasture, the greatest northern painter of his age, came to Rome in 1450. “Greatly taken with the Lateran frescoes, he inquired who the painter was, and, heaping him with praise, placed him before all other Italian painters.” The incident suggests that affinity between Gentile’s work and that of the north which must occupy us later. It proves more poignantly still the loss we have suffered in the destruc- tion, save a not very important frag- ment at Orvieto, of all of Gentile’s mural painting. And yet there remains the possibility that, as the great fresco by Guariento was found injured but still fine behind the Paradise of Tintoretto, in the Palace of the Doges, so Gen- tile’s two frescoes painted for the same hall may some day be rediscovered behind the sixteenth-century canvases that have replaced them. Until that dav we must judge and enjoy Gentile by what 1s presumably the least important part of his work. In trying to recon- struct imaginatively these lost master- pieces we may assume that they abound- ed in figures and action. In some fash- ion they may have resembled the viva- cious narratives of the earlier Floren- tines, Agnolo Gaddi and Spinello Are- tino. But we get a finer intuition of them by recalling that they forecast the monumental compositions of Gentile Bellini, and more remotely prelude both the delightful story-telling of Carpaccio, and such a romantic picture as the enig- matic St. Mark and the Demons which criticism ascribes now to Giorgione, now to Palma Vecchio. ‘We must turn back and try to imagine Gentile’s beginnings. The date of his birth is unknown to us, but it cannot have been much earlier than 1480. Un- til his thirtieth year, roughly speaking, when he went to Venice, he painted in his native city. What could he have learned in the March of Ancona? A good deal, perhaps, but rather little that was consistent or helpful. If French realism was latent in the Carca, the ostensible influences were of quite an- other sort. The Gothic-Byzantine of Venice still prevailed widely, but Siena had conquered the towns. Everywhere one finds in the Marca panels which be- tray the teaching, or at least the au- thority, of the Lorenzetti and Simone Martini. From Assisi there had also been a transmission of Giottesque influ- ence, but at Assisi, too, Simone Memmi and Pietro Lorenzetti loomed large, and on the whole the March of Ancona pre- ferred to Giottesque austerity the dulcet Sienese mood. The best exemplar of these pervasive influences was Alegretto Nuzi, the true founder of the Fabriano

Page 21

Aug. 19, 1909] school and Gentile’s master. Those who are lucky enough to recall the Umbrian exhibition at Perugia will not need many words about Alegretto. There he shone in a peculiar blitheness. He is less mystic than his exemplar Simone, more frankly sentimental, and his coloring is hardly less exquisite. Uneven in inven- tion and workmanship, a true provincial in his qualities and defects, he yet dis- plays a peculiar inwardness in his best pictures. We should remember him gratefully, for without him we should hardly have that most delicious of late Gothic Madonnas, Gentile’s little mas- terpiece in the museum at Pisa. Gentile’s earliest picture, the Corona- tion of the Virgin at the Brera, shows little of the eclectic character that was later to be prominent, It seems to go behind Alegretto to those Gothic paint- ers who retained much of the Byzantine feeling. At the base of the central panel a segment of the crystalline sphere bends over the sun, the moon, and the stars, and here is proudly set “Gentilis de Fabriano Pinxit.” Upon this arch kneel eight tiny angels playing musical instruments—a motive frequently found on Gothic-Byzantine organ shutters. On the expanse of gold above is incised a blazing aureole to receive the figures of Christ and his mothe’. They are seated upon clouds, the gold embroidered bor- ders of their robes are whipped into cal- ligraphic loops after the fashion of Siena and the late Byzantine painters. The head of the Virgin is bowed and her slender hands crossed in humility. The Christ reaches up from below and sets the crown gently in place with the suave gesture of a priest touching an in- fant’s brow in baptism. His free hand rests lightly upon his knee and holds erect a tiny cross. The partly exposed lining of his mantle repeats the stellar pattern at the base of the composition. Above, the Father, vestured in a rich dalmatic, reaches his hands towards the divine heads in approval of the rite. In the irregular space between Christ and the Virgin hovers the white dove of the Holy Spirit, not displayed stifiy and heraldically, as is usually the case, but swinging across the space as if about to alight. While the picture is by no means deficient in emotional serious- ness, it is chiefly remarkable for the beauty of its gold and tempera enamel, and for minor evasions of the underly- ing symmetry—artifices which give to this hackneyed theme a peculiar fresh- ness and vivacity. More serious in some ways are the tiny figures of saints which are minor features of this altar- piece. Some stand radiantly “upon the softe swote gras”—a greensward half- hidden by growing flowers; others kneel in their wildernesses, like St. Francis at La Verna; others, like the Aquinate, sit contemplatively over a book in a monastic garden plot. These miniatures betray more clearly than the central The Nation. panel the tenderness of Gentile’s Sie nese forerunners. Yet it seems to me that when Venice called Gentile to paint in the Palace of the Doges she merely reclaimed her own. He inaugurated, as we have seen, her school of monumenta! decoration; he became the teacher of that pioneer of the renaissance, Jacopo Bellini. Gen- tile’s too-little known Madonna in the Jarves Collection, New Haven, has a breadth of style that looks forward even beyond Jacopo to the triumphs of his greatest son, Giambellino. Venice made Gentile famous. Popes and tyrants be gan to compete for his brush. For Pan- dolfo Malatesta, at Brescia, he painted for more than four years. But the fres- coes in the Broletto have long since dis- appeared, leaving no trace even of their subject. We know Cosimo Tura saw them in 1469, and presumably disap- proved, for the stern Paduan manner then had the cry. In the autumn of 1420 Pope Martin V, already planning his triumphal return to St. Peter's throne, sojourned in the Brescian terri- tory and invited Gentile to come with him to Rome. Nearly a year later a safe conduct for eight men and horses was issued to the painter, but both Pope gnd painter had to postpone the Roman visit for several years. For Gentile at least the delay golden. He proceeded to Florence, and there, among other works, completed an enthroned Madonna with Saints for the Quaratesi family; and for that prince of humanists, Palla Strozzi, the Ador- ation of the Magi, a picture beside which only Lorenzo Monaco’s Corona- tion of the Virgin in the Uffizi holds its Own as a perfect expression of late Gothic design. But before we pass to the Adoration, we perhaps do well to recall the Florence that Gentile saw with an artist's eye. We must suppose he had the self-es- teem without which one would hardly be an artist at all. He would soon have found that only Don Lorenzo Monaco, who was painting in tne Trinita, and Masolino, who had begun the stupendous decorations of the Brancacci Chapel, were regarded as his peers. People per- haps talked of an eccentric young paint- er named Paolo Uccello, and of a youth of genius who served as assistant to the great Masolino. But Masaccio’s day was yet to come. Fra Angelico was prob- ably absent in Umbria; in any case, he had not yet asserted himself as a mural painter. In short, Gentile found him- self almost without rivals of his own quality and bade fair to repeat at Flor- ence his Venetian triumphs. No great decorative commission seems to have been given him. In fact, since he had put himself at the disposal of the Pope, he could hardly have accepted any pro- longed task. But he found time to exe- cute for Palla Strozzi that radiant Ador- ation of the Kinge which, formerly in was 169 the Church of the Trinité, is now a chief ornament of the Florence Acad- emy. No one who has seen this pic- ture forgets it, and for those who have not seen it, of what avail are many words? More than an Adoration of the Kings, it is a Triumph of Chivalry, so completely does knightly pageantry out weigh its charming religious sentiment. Lorenzo Monaco had already perceived this possibility of the subject. He was the first Florentine fo draw ouc the escort of the Magi upon an oblong panel, Indeed, the Adoration, which he painted for the little Church of St. Lucy in the Ruins may have served as a model for Gentile. But the newcome: outdid his exemplar. Never had the courtly and spectacular features of the scene been so fully developed. Gentile has raised the horizon to the top of the picture, in order to have more space in which to deploy his cavaicades, be- side the reverent group of the Holy bramily and the worshipping potentates, is a dense and jostiing throng of ar- rested horses, grooms, knights, men-at- arms. A great hound crouches before the hurly-burly, above it and behind a falcon strikes a dove and two monkeys balance on the humps of a dromedary. Over a hedge and the grotto where the ox and ass munch peaceably, one looks to a high-lying distance divided into three scenes by as many arches of the rich frame. To the iteft, the Three Kings look over the sea towards the Star in the East. In the centre, their cavalcade, with prancing horses and hunting leopards on the cruppers, swings up a hill towards a city. ‘Io the right, the Magi enter the gate of Bethlehem. Above, in the crocketed pinnacles, are medallions with God the Father, the Virgin, and the Angel of the Annuncia- tion. Below, in the base, the Nativity, and the Flight to Egypt, a night scene, and a dawn, in which the lights are effectively touched with gold. The third predella panel, the Presentation in th Temple, is represented only by a copy; the original, since Napoleonic times, has been in the Louvre. The Gothic side columns are treated as if they were of skeleton construction. From a dark background within the mouldings painted flowers spring as if planted within. The gilding and varied tempera enamel afford a gorgeous and yet har- monious effect. Diapered gold, lapis Llue, crimson, these are the prevailing colors In technical brilliancy, no panel of the century surpasses this radiant work of Gentile’s. The group of the Holy Family is drap ed after the traditional half-ciassic fash ion, the remaining figures wear splen did costumes of the time, with minor Oriental features. This picture is the transition to the realistic genre manner of the Quattrocento in Florence. The step from it to those frescoes with state-

Page 22

ee wae 17O ly citizens as witnesses of the ostensibly sacred theme is a short one. Now, this sense for pageantry and love of contem- porary faces and costumes appear very early in French miniature painting. It has been suggested, in fact, that both Gentile and Masolino got their hint from such pictures as those of the Lim- bourg illuminators and Hubert van Eyck. All this is possible, and even plausible, but I think it is easy to ex- aggerate the importance of this north- ern influence. Pageantry was in the air of Florence. The religious spectacles, the jousts, the ceremonials of the guilds constituted a festal year affording every variety of processional display. On St. John’s day this actual subject, the Ador- ation of the Magi, was occasionally giv- en with great splendor. Machiavelli de- scribes a performance of 1466 that was elaborate enough to occupy nearly the whole city for several months. In the Marches, the Adoration was given as early as 1380. In 1414, at Parma, we have a record which might be a de- scription in brief of Gentile’s picture painted eight years later. Now, this love of pageantry rarely found full vent in the religious painting of the time. Such a picture as this of Gentile’s, such a Cor- tage as that which Benozzo Gozzoli some thirty years later spread on the walls of Cosimo de’ Medici’s private chapel, remain in a manner exceptional. It was the humble, usually nameless, painters of storied bride-chests (cassoni) who were the true recorders of this vanished Florence. To them all was permitted. Through them we see the wedding feasts, the jousts, the horse races, the triumphs. With them we may wander in gardens of love, or enjoy in the fan- tastic travesty of the dawning renais- sance the old, sad stories of Virgil and Ovid. Truly inheritors of unfulfilled renown, for we rarely know even their names, these blithe craftsmen were the real illustrators of Florence in its hey- day and on parade. Gentile and Maso- lino were the great predecessors of these little men, though Paolo Uccello was to be their chief exemplar. They repre- sent the full flood of a tendency already vigorous in Gentile. If northern, or more specifically French, influence comes in at all, is it not merely by way of confirming an established taste? Alas, those days of significant pageantry! In england they are reviving the tradition- al spectacles with learned care; among ourselves mysterious orders of chivalry parade in knightly panoply. We strive arduously for the spectacular, and we get the resulta of those who strive too consciously. Perhaps the realists are right—Whitman in Brooklyn Ferry, Renoir in the Dancing Garden, our own young arranger of sombrely splendid pageants from the New York ghetto, Jerome Myers——perhaps they are right, I say, to eschew the arranged for the casual spectacle. And yet with the The Nation. sense of travesty departing, is not the casual spectacle also doomed—I mean as regards its appeal to the eye? This, too, would be of a piece with a civiliza- tion that willingly starves the eye in the alleged interest of the mind. Is it not significant that at a time when so- clety gives the artist so little to look at, the writer pushes description to its furthest extreme of technical excel- lence? What does that mean but that the naive joys of the eye have been superseded by a more complicated pleas- ure—one fairly within the range of a blind person? How can the painter and sculptor hope for a real place among us, until we concede to the claims of the eye—not that attention we gladly pay to those of the ear, but at least that re- spect which we give to the higher ex- actions of the palate? We have drifted far from Gentile. But really little remains to say. We find him at Siena and Orvieto, repeating his Venetian and Florentine triumphs, and finally, at derelict Rome, helping to dig- nify the return of the Pope. Gentile painted at Sta. Maria Nuova and in the Lateran, at that time the first temple of Christendom. There death overtook him suddenly, in 1427, still in joyous possession of his powers. He was buried at Sta. Maria Nuova, but time has cancelled his epitaph and even exact memory of his last resting place. Any judgment we may form of his painting, is defective in advance. His most important work we know on hear- say only. For us he is preéminently the master of blithe color, the inventor of certain soft appealing forms of wo- man’s loveliness—what Madonna pic- ture in the world is sweeter than the little panel in the Museum at Pisa? —the contriver of vivacious spectacles, the celebrator of dying chivalry in the full-blown splendor of its decline. For the rest, a simple spirit, carrying to the point of perfection the technique and forms he had inherited; a content- ed soul when divine discontent was in the air; an innovator only to the ex- tent of enriching established formulas. In every way, he seems one of those gracious spirits whose pious task it is to invest in an ultimate charm, an art no longer capable of real progress and foredoomed. The wistful flavor of de- cadence is in all his panels. They have, as compared with Gothic painting of the great time, the insubstantial flavor of Campanian marbles, as compared with those of early Attica. In both cases, the vague provincial suggestion is a weakness, but constitutes also an appeal. Our judgment approves Masaccio for his break with an exhausted past, our love goes out to Gentile for his unquestioning fealty to old and beautt- ful if tottering ideals. | could almost resent a discovery, say of those hid- den Venetian frescoes, which should [Vol. 89, No. 2303 demonstrate that Gentile, too, was an innovator. That he was that in a meas- ure, there is reason to believe—but a progressive spirit, not in the sense of the realists, but of Fra Angelice or Fra Filippo Lippi. Why Fra Filippo is not a realist, I cannot here take the pains to explain. As a wholesome sen- timentalist, and lover of the human spectacle, he was, in some degree, the spiritual heir of Gentile. Frank Jewett MATHER, JR. The July Burlington Magazine is not at the highest level of interest attained by that periodical, though it contains sev- eral articles of some importance. The note by Georges H. De Loo on “An Authen- tic Work of Jaques Daret” should fix a date and a name in the heretofore rath- er vague history of early Flemish painting; while A. M. Hind notices some “Newly Discovered Rembrandt Documents.” pub- lished by Dr. Bredius, which upset the re- ceived chronology of Rembrandt's etch- ings and show that that master continued to etch and to engrave up to the end of his life. Among the illustrations the most interesting are reproductions of several pictures lately in the collection of the King of the Belgians (two by Rubens and one by Hobbema) and a couple of rather timid works put forward by C. J. MA as possible early experiments by Vermeer of Delft. The special spring number of the I/nter- national Studio is devoted to the water colors of J. M. W. Turner. There is a growing feeling that this part of Turner's work is the best of what he has left us, and these thirty reproductions of draw- ings, ranging from the stiff formality of the earliest exhibited work of 1790 to the amazing sketches of the early forties, will be welcome to many. There are the in- evitable contradictions in the text, Sir Charles Holroyd dwelling on the “absolute truth,” even to the smallest details of lo- cality, of Turner’s sketches, while Mr. A J. Finberg maintains that they must not be regarded as “attempts to give an ac- curate representation” of anything, even of effects. Mr. W. C. Rawlinson’s detail- ed discussion of the plates and of Turn- er’s successive manners at different periods of his life is perhaps more profitable. The Académie des Beaux-Arts has an- nounced its awards in the architec- tural section in connection with the Grand Prix de Rome. The chief prize went to J. G. M. Boutterin, a pu- pil of Raulin and Héraud. The prize next in value was taken by M. J. E. L. Madeline, a pupil of Deglane, and the third by G. E. Lauzanne, a pupil of Laloux. Two other awards of the Académie are the Prix Troyon to Emile Marcel and a Mention Honorable to Mile. Marcelle Louis Noyon. From Kiel comes the report of the death, in her eighty-first year, of Prof. Johanna Mestorf, who until a year ago was director of the Schleswig-Holstein Museum in that town. Her title of “professor” was confer- red on her by the Emperor, in 1899, and she was the first German woman to be so honored. Besides her administrative work she wrote a number of volumes on arche- ological subjects.

Page 23

Aug. 19, 1909] Finance. THE UNION PACIFIC’S ASSETS. For a week past, the Stock Exchange has been indulging in great excitement over what it describes as the expccted “segregation plan” for the Union Pacific Railroad’s holdings of stocks of vther railways. In general, Wall Street's idea appears to be that these stocks— amounting by the company’s last re- port to $108,000,000 pledged against col- lateral trust bonds, and $131,000,000 held free in the Treasury—will somehow be transferred to other custody, so that the railway company, as such, will be disengaged from the business of operat- ing on the stock market. As to what method of segregation will be pursued, no official statement or intimation has been given out; it is, therefore, impos- sible as yet to discuss the matter from that point of view. Speculative Wall Street, after its fashion, jumped to the conclusion that the “deal” would be so arranged as to impart great additional value to the Union Pacific’s shares, which were accordingly bid up 16 pvints last week, with a relapse at the present week's opening. This throws no light on the project; the Stock Exchange, in its present mood, would do the same for the shares of any property in which a “deal” was rumored. But the “segrega- tion plan,” whatever form it take, hap- pens to be a sequel to a very sensational chapter of railway history, which it is well worth while to review. The Union Pacific’s purchases of stock in other railways, on the scale which has made its operations memorable, be- gan when the socalled “community-of- interest” idea had turned the heacs of our Wall Street millionaires. This plan of action was based on the pur- chase of one another's shares by the various railways, the purchase-money being raised on the credit of the pur- chasing company. It will be recalled that the process was largely at the bottom of the frenzied markets of April, 1901, when the buying power which converged on the Stock Exchange seemed to be absolutely unlimited. The Union Pacific had thus bought $75,000,000 stock of the Southern Pacific Company, bonding itself for the purpose. This operation attracted less attention, because its main purpose was to acquire the Central Pa- cific line, which, although owned by the Southern Pacific, was a natural connect- ing link to the Western Coast for the Union Pacific's main transcontinental line. But the ease with which this prop- erty was acquired stimulated the ap- petite and relaxed the caution of the rich “insiders.” The contest, first for pos- session of the Burlington and Quincy, and then for the Northern Pacific Rail- way, followed a few months later. The Nation. It was conducted on lines which, a very few years before, would have been described as unparalleled recklessness. Union Pacific's executive committee had virtual carte-bianche with the company’s credit; Harriman himself, as chairman of the board, had been voted practically unlimited borrowing powers, with the absolute right “to execute in the name and on behalf of this company a note or notes for the amount so borrowed.” Although no official admission of the fact has ever been made, there ‘s no doubt whatever that the $78,000,000 par value in Northern Pacific stock, bought by the Union Pacific in 1901, was pur- chased with money borrowed in the open market on the notes of the com- pany. This highly precarious operation was supplemented later by a bond is- sue to take up the floating debt thus created, and a fortunately favorable money market averted the grave perils which must always surround such ex- periments with corporation credit. The Northern Pacific corner, the exchange of the stock for that of the Northern Securities holding company, the disso- lution of that company, occurred with- out disaster to Mr. Harriman’s under- taking. F He sold on the open market the stock the liquidation of that merger, and got more than he had paid received on for it. The speculation had been lucky, and in the middle of 1906, Union Pa- cific was left with $55,000,000 free cash in its treasury. No idea of reducing the capital liabilities incurred in the pur- chase, or of devoting this money to the urgent physical needs of the railway property, seems to have occurred to Harriman. Instead, he rushed into the speculative Wall Street market, buying right and left the shares of other rail- ways, many of which had no connection with his own. The $55,000,000 cash was not enough: the Union Pacific incurred a floating debt of $75,000,000 more, and the proceeds were similarly used. Such an operation, secretly conducted and ac- companied by wild speculation ascribed to the people who knew what was £o- ing on, was bound.to take rank as a public scandal when the facts were made public That service the Interstate Commission rendered, and the people at large learned the truth of the matter at the moment when Union Pacific was struggling to place its bonds in an un- favorable money market, and when, by rough calculation, the market value of the stocks bought for the company in 1906 had depreciated $40,000,000. Since then, and up to the present time, there have been fairly well authenticated re- ports of buying and selling operations for the same account, and in the same shares, on the Stock Exchange. The panic of 1907 sobered up a good many millionaire speculators who had come to believe that there was no limit The Faets About 6% Irrigation Bonds We are the largest sellers of Irrigation Bonds. And these bonds are, by far, our most popular securities with inves- tors who know them. Our experience with Recla- mation Bonds covers 15 years. It covers the sale of many en- tire issues from 11 separate states. So we know the facts. These bonds are farm liens of the most conservative class. Some are Municipal obliga- tions. The interest rate — six per cent. —is larger than one can now obtain on any large class of equal security. The bonds are issued in serial ma- turities, and in denominations as low as $100. For the information of our customers—present and pros- pective—we have issued a book called “The World’s Greatest Industry.” It is interesting, unbiased, clear and illustrated. It tells the facts about this most attractive form of invest- ment. Please write us a postal or send us this coupon for it. (Fatablished 1892) Muantcipal and Corporation BRoud« First National Bank Bldg. 50 Congress Stre't CHICAGO BOSTON Gentlemen Please send me vour new Rond Book, “The World's Greatest In dustry.” Name Town 141 State Buy and sell bills of p ars exchange and make ca ble transfers of money . Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits Certificates

Page 24

172 of safety to their use of credit. Probably some of Harriman’s own associatee be- gan to feel misgivings over the policy s0 recklessly pursued, and to protest against its continuance. It had, more- over, become quite plain that unless our great railway corporations were to be- | come mere engines of speculation, and | their trust funds only handmaids of the Stock Exchange, a halt of some sort must be called. The most that they could , discover, in the way of remedy for the situation created in Union Pacific’s own finances, was some scheme for turning | over the company’s holdings of other railway shares to a separate company, or at all events, for placing imme diate control of them in different hands. It will oceur to all observant minds that a plan of this sort might leave the last of things as objectionable as the Rut comment on this aspect of the be deferred until the na- state first matter must Old Testament Narratives Selected and edited with an introduc- tion by Georecre H. NeETTLeTon, Ph.D., Assistant Professor in Yale University xxxvii 294 pp. 16mo. 60 cents. Thies collection covers completely the new college entrance voquee ment for reading ‘The Old Testament omprising at least the chief narrative eplecdes in Genesis, Pxodus, Joshua, judges, Samuel, Kings, and Daniel, together with the hooks of Ruth and Esther.’’ The text. that of the King James Version, Is with out annotation The introduction gives the main facta in the literary history of the Bible Armstrong’s Syntax of the French Verb By Epwin C. ARMSTRONG, Professor in Johns Hopkins University With Exercises by De LA WARR B. EASTER, Professor in Randolph-Macon College ix + 192 pp. 12mo. 90 cents A manual comprehensive enough to be used aa a reference book, with the material arranged for class use In connection with work in composition PLEEEEOESOSEEO 61 64666666664666666666 ‘Explorers in the New World | | Member of The The N ation. on of the contesbateenth “segregation plan” is known. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Baskerville, C. General Inorganic Chemis- try Heath & Co | Bisland, E., and Hoyt, A. Seekers in Sicily. Llane. $1.50 net. Bond, F. Visitors’ Guide to Westminster Abbey. Frowde. | Curtler, W. H. R. A Short History of Eng- | lish Agriculture. Frowde. $2.16 net. | Despatches From Paris, 1784-1790. Selected and edited from the Foreign Office Cor- respondence by O. Browning. Vol. I. (1784-1787.) London: Camden Society. Dumas. Le Comte de Monte-Cristo. Edit- ed by C. Fontaine. American Book Co. 40 cents. | Elford, P. Frowde. | Elson, H. W A Child's Guide to Ameri- ean History. Baker & Taylor. $1.25 net. Figgis, D. A Vision of Life: Poems. troduction by G. K. Chesterton. Lane. $1.25 net. Historical Stories and the Middle Nicholas Magazine. Practical School Gardening. Ancient World Retold from St. Century. of the Ages: 6 vols. BREFORE AND AFTER COLUMBUS, AND THE STORY OF THE JESUIT MISSIONS OF PARAGUAY. By MARION McMURROUGH MULHALL, Roman Arcadia, Author of | “Between the Amazon and the Andes,” “The ; Celtie Divina Commedia,” Maps. Crown Sources of the With pre-Columbian pp. xiv+313, $2.25 net. etc. vo, LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York “There can be no quarrel with WHAT IS A PICTURE? We are helped to an understanding of artistic ideals and to the qualities that we have a right to expect in a picture that ‘'s something more than a painting.’’——-The Ar- gonaut 60 cents net. A. C. MeCLURG & By mail 67 cents. co., Chicago. == _— _—_—_ z— = [Vol. 89, No. 2303 Ibafiez, V. B. The Shadow of the Cathe- dral: a Novel. Translated from the Span- ish by Mrs. W. A, Gillespie. Dutton. $1.35 net. Liverpool Committee for Excavation and Research in Wales and the Marches. First Annual Report, 1908. University Press of Liverpool. Lyons, A. N. Sixpenny Pieces. Lane. $1.50 Pattee, G. K. Practical Argumentation Century. $1.10 net. Phillips. D. G. The Hungry Heart; a No- vel. Appleton. $1.50. Photographic Annual. Fifth edition, revised to June, 1909. Tennant & Ward. 50 cents. Stephens, F. F. The Translation Period. 1788-1789, in the Gov. of the U. S. Social! Science Series, Vol. II, No. 4, University of Missouri Studies. Tennyson’s Shorter Poems and Lyrics 1833. 1842. (The Lady of Shalott, and Other Poems.) Edited with introduction and notes, by B. C. Mulliner. Frowae. Third Report of the Wellcome Research In- | Laboratories at the Gordon Memorial College, Khartoum. Toga Publishing Co. $5 net. Wollaston, G. H. The Englishman in Italy. Frowde. $1.75 net. Works of James Buchanan. edited by J. B. Moore. Vol. Philadelphia: Lippincott. Collected and TX, 1853-1855, Customers Out of Town are reminded that we give care- ful and prompt attention to or- ders received by mail, tele- graph, or telephone, for BOOKS AND STATIONERY Retail Dept 27 &29W. = Putnams “2323 “All Books of All Publishers” LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and in la looked up in the Boston and Harvard librarise for schol- md others. Abstracts, copies, trans- ‘ory Holtand Company XewYer® | MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) Henry Holt and Company cricago | bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. | Gente Geek eon a Wm. Prof 4,000 extra colleges. MacDonald Recent text-books will be reviewed. copies will be mailed to teachers in schools and Usual rates for advertising. SEPTEMBER SECOND The Nation WILL PUBLISH AN EDUCATIONAL It will contain several pertinent articles, the leading being by in the Universities. on Summer Schools NUMBER

Page 25

* © ‘ ‘ Font ’ ,: ¢ i « 2 i ¢ i th * t / ‘ ¥ fe nd -, q .