The Nation 1909-08-12: Vol 89 Iss 2302
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
DNV. OF muCth ~The Nation — go &, | RAGE Y VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2302 THURSDAY, AUGUST 12, 1909 PRICE TEN CENTS. AUG 19 “=~ “iastive Pocket Editions | POCKET EDITION OF THE WORKS OF GEORGE MEREDITH 16 volumes, sold separately or in sets. 16mo. Limp Leather, $1.25 net; Cloth, $1.00 THE VOLUMES THE ORDEAL OF RICHARD FEVEREL THE ADVENTURES OF HARRY THE TRAGIC COMEDIANS DIANA OF THE CROSSWAYS RICHMOND LORD ORMONT AND HIS AMINTA SANDRA BELLONI BEAUCHAMP’S CAREER tHE AMAZING MARKIAGE VITTORIA EVAN HARRINGTON SHORT STORIES RHODA FLEMING ONE OF OUR CONQUERORS POEMS THE EGOIST THE SHAVING OF SHAGPAT “The convenient size of the volumes and their tasteful binding make them particularly attractive for summer reading.”—THE CHURCHMAN. » “This edition of Meredith is one to win the heart of the book-lover—a companionable set in green cloth, gilt tops, good paper and legible print.”"—Cuicaco Recorp-HERALD BIOGRAPHICAL EDITION OF THE WORKS OF ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON sold singly Cloth, $1.00; volume. Limp Leather, $1.25 met per THE VOLUMES 27 volumes, or m Sets TREASURE ISLAND ST. IVES FAMILIAR STUDIES PRINCE OTTO NEW ARABIAN NIGHTS THE AMATEUR BMIGRANT KIDNAPPED THE MERRY MEN (containing MEMORIES AND PORTRAITS THE BLACK ARROW DR. JEKYLL AND MR. HYDE) IN THE SOUTH SEAS THE MASTER OF BALLANTRAE THE DYNAMITER A\CROSS THE PLAINS THE WRONG BOX ISLAND NIGHT'S ENTERTAINMENTS ESSAYS OF TRAVEL AND IN THE ART THE WRECKER AN INLAND VOYAGE OF WRITING DAVID BALFOUR TRAVELS WITH A DONKEY COMPLETE POEMS THE EBB-TIDE VIRGINIBUS PUERISQUE TWO VOLUMES OF LETTERS WEIR OF HERMISTON “The most important thing in such an edition is the type and paper and form of the volumes, and in the present case these deserve hearty praise."—New York Eveninc Post “There was obviously a need for just such an edition, and the publishers are to be commended for giving it just this form.”—OUTLOOK. : POCKET EDITION OF THE WORKS OF ’ HENRIK IBSEN Sold separately or in sets. Limp Leather, $1.25 net; Cloth, $1.00. THE VOLUMES THE FEAST AT SOLHOUG, LADY EMPEROR AND GALILEAN (2 Parts) ROSMERSHOLM, LADY FROM THE SEA INGER, LOVE'S COMEDY LEAGUE OF YOUTH, PILLARS OF HEDDA GABLER, MASTER BUILDER VIKINGS, PRETENDERS SOCIETY LITTLE EYOLF, JOHN GABRIEL BORK.- BRAND DOLL’S HOUSE, GHOSTS MAN, WHEN WE DEAD AWAKEN PEER GYNT ENEMY OF THE PEOPLE, WILD DUCK “The most satisfactory edition obtainable in English.”.—Cuicaco Recorp-HERacp. “This edition is indispensable to the student or reader of Ibsen for two reasons: It is the only complete and authori- tative translation in English, and the series of introductions which William Archer has contributed forms the best exposition and analysis of the dramas that we have in the language."—Tue INDEPENDENT CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 153 Fifth Avenue, NEW YORK
Page 2
Nation. The ! A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. ([Hatered at the New York Otty Post Office as scooné- class mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Paul Elmer More, Editor. Treasurer ; Three dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Can- ada £3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, £4.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 80 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THE WPrEK - 129 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Unsettled Tariff .........+seee0- 132 The Aldrich Incubus....... pecesecee Sue The Japanese Sugar Scandal.......... 133 Churches and Wage-Earners......... 134 SPECIAL ARTICLES: The Second Poet Laureate........... 135 CORRESPONDENCE: A Lover of Geofroy Tory..........-- 136 A Cure for “Boosting’’.............. 137 Reet BASGED cccccccccccccccccccceeses 137 A Prophecy 137 138 >. 138 George Borrow’'s ‘Work in Spain.. NOTES Book REVIEWS: Samuel Pepys: Administrator, Ob- server, GOSSIP .....cceccceceenennes 140 J Ss. eer tT 141 Dragon’ BlCOd 2... ccccccccccscccsescces 141 A Gentleman of Quality.............. 142 Michael Thwaites’s Wife............. 142 The Story of the Pharaohs—The Queens of Egypt—The Explora- tion of Egypt and the Old Testa- BRO « ccocccesocceccceecencdsdeeseescsse Ee The Hague Peace Conferences of 1899 and 1907—Official Report of the Seventeenth Universal Con- SOR GE TERED occcncsccccsnvcoserss 143 English Literature in the Nineteenth GHG cv cccccccccccncsccosccesseocecs 143 Louls Napoleon and the Genesis of the Second Empire ........ccccsecs 144 ee Gee Ge BeBe ccccnceveacceus 145 SCIENCE: Fifty Years of Darwinism............ 145 DRAMA: Examining the Examiner ............ 147 GED eb eewnsesesce nes cceee0badeeneneseesse 148 FINANCE: eee Ga EE cadence teccdemsdecancie 148 BOOKS OF THE WEEE... .....ccccccccces The Nation WILL PUBLISH An Educational Number SEPTEMBER SECOND It will contain several pertinent articles and reviews of recent text- books. 4,000 extra copies will be mailed to teachers In schools and colleges. - Usual rates for advertising. The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2302 Educational. E FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES "bes EveRert o, 4a & Co., Proprietors. Boston 505 Pa. Ave. Washington SA Park 156 Fifth Ave., New York rn Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 208 Mich. Ave. - Chics g9a8 Swetiand Bid., Portland 405 Coo; Bid., 238 Doug!’sBid., Los 618 n Bid., pF 2142 ShattackA tfve.. address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all with competent teachers. Vacancies A, M. the year. Albany,N.Y. 8 Pey! eley nd to any Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other co —y; women. Small classes supplemen dividual | . Teachers all millar with Bryn Mawr ro pty Tessie an basket ball. Eleventh year opens Oct. 1909. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY WORCESTER, MASS. Established in 1856. An ideally healthful location. Efficient faculty. Prepara- tion for the best institutions. The Rt. Rev. A. H. Vinton, D.D., LL.D., Visitor. For Catalogue please address 408EPH ALDEN SHAW, A.B., Headmaster. NEW YORK Day School 174 Fulton St. LAW SCHOOL Evening School New York City *““Dwight Method’’ of instruction. LL.B. in two ye ars. LL.M. in three years. High standards. Send for catalogue GEORGE CHASE, Dean. ] ETHLEHEM got Bethlehem, Pa. Prepa Catalogue. H. A. FOERING, BS. For English Courses English Composition. Hanson. Manual of Composition a:d Rhetoric. "Gardiner, Kittredge, and Arnold. Working Principles of Rhetoric. Genung. Specimens of Prose Composition Note- book. Greenough, Nutter, and Hersey. of Argumentation. Baker and Huntington. GINN AND COMPANY, 20 Beacon Street Publishers Boston _ SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY | Publishers | _ School and College Text Books Musical Instruction Books Standard Literature Circulars, Catalogues and Price Lists on request. Correspondence Invited 231-241 West 39th St.. NEW YORK. Branches and Agencies in Boston Chicago, Philadelphia, Atlanta Dallas, San Francisco and London ONE-HALF COMPLETED |! THE NEW FIRST FOLIO SHAKESPEARE Ed. by PORTER-CLARKE. Text of 1623 Full notes and variants. READY: rE a iy Dreame,"’ ‘‘Love's - _ s- lant, ** “Comedie of Errors,’’ “Merchant ie," “Wing Lear,” = Night,” “As You Like etry the Fir” “Much About Noth : Juliet.” * - Uthel 7 +, eis Well **Measure tor Measure” Cloth tS cents ; limp leather, $1.00 per volume, postpaid. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., New York Romeo and er 2 Tale. i ‘Shrew.’ a *"*Two Gen- facilities for supplying esc” BOOKS | tien Catalogues free. Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Baskerville’s General Inorganic Chemistry Eliminates useless matter; includes the latest sclence 365 pages. $1.50. With LABORATORY MANUAL: 48 pages, 40 cts. D. CC. HEATH & CO., BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO | PIONEER DAYS IN THE ; ; NORTHWEST Dr. JOHN McLOUGHLIN The search for documentary sources has been thorongh and the material handled with care and accuracy."’——Amer. Hist. Rev. THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., Cleveland, Ohio } P 2 Ln Established over 50 years. 30-32 West 27th St., New York Do you know the Beacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americang tbat are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 cents net; by mail, 54 cents. for @ descriptive pamphiet. & Co., 21 Beacon St, Boston THE CLEVEREST BOOK OF THE YEAR ANNE OF GREEN GABLES By L. M. MONTGOMERY “TONO- BUNGAY” HAREMLIK By DEMETRA VAKA “A remarkable description of the life and manner of thinking of Turk- ish women.”—New York Sun. BOOKS—All out of print —. on what subject; write me, es , Ths By GORK WY TIONAL SOCIALIST Recent No. and BOOK CATALOGUE for 10c. CHARLES H. KERR & CO. CHICAGO MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) boughi by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. Reading Case for the Nation To receive the current sumbers in a convenient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, with The Nation stamped on the side in goid. Holds about one volume. Papers easily and neatly 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GR ; Sohn Bright St., Birmingham, adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 76 cents.
Page 3
each olbile The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 18, 1909. The Week. President Taft’s attitude in respect of the newly created Customs Court of Appeals, is understood to be that the judges must be lawyers equal to their responsible duties. The failure of Con- gress to provide in the Emergency De- ficiency bill an appropriation for the judges’ salaries may result in the estab- lishment of salaries of $10,000 a year instead of the $7,000 rate which was the figure tentatively fixed upon in the de- neiency appropriation. The President has decided to make no appointments until Congress acts. He will doubtless take the most solicitous care in filling the new court. The suggestion that it contain lay members he is said to op- pose. The experience of importers with the General Board of Appraisers would seem to support this determination on the President’s part. We shall confi- dently expect the new tribunal to con- tain no “jokers.” The confidence of the country would not be gained by seeing Judge Littauer, Judge S. N. D. North, and others of that ilk on the customs bench. The President’s policy in making cen- sus appointments in the South is now announced. In States solidly Democrat- ic, the jobs are to be equally divided be- tween the Democrats and the Republi- cans. In “debatable” States, however, all the census places are to be given to Re- publicans. The President’s statement adds, with gravity, that in all cases he will insist that the appointees “shall not be active partisans, but capable men.” If this means anything, it means that some sort of test or examination is to be made, beyond the mere recom- mendation of politicians. They, of course, always recommend ‘capable men”—men capable of great usefulness to themselves. Census enumerators, being special and temporary appointees, have long been made a part of the spoils system, and the bill for taking the next census, while providing that the clerks in the bureau at Washington shal! be chosen under the civil-service rules, left the naming of the men who are to col- lect the actual information, as before, to politicians. The President has shown, by his appointment of a new Director and Assistant Director of the Census, that he is anxious to have a_ thoroughly scientific and trustworthy piece of work done next year. Yet he must know that a great deal will depend upon the choice of enumerators. Speaker Cannon's long-promised pun- ishment of the insurgents among his own party reflects not nearly so much upon them as upon him. To his nar- row partisan mind it is, of course, just the thing to do. Whip the insubordi- nate and reward the abjectly obedient this is always the creed of the party boss, and from his point of view it is of- ten good politics. Not in this case, how- ever; the split in the Republican party has gone too far to be cured in any such way. Indeed, the pettiness of Mr. Can non’s action is likely to makg matters worse and intensify the growing opposi- tion to him. And he has not even gone far enough with the axe really to play the executioner impressively. Mr. Fow- ler has been a very useful man, and so has Congressman Cooper. As for Con- gressman Gardner, it will hardly im- prove Senator Lodge's relations with the Speaker that his son-in-law should thus be degraded. The truth js that the Speaker’s action will only remind peo- ple anew that he belongs to another po- litical age, and that the sooner he dis- appears from Congress the better will be its atmosphere, the quicker it will re- spond to the popular will, and the less it will be controlled by selfish interests. At least one of Mr. Cannon's new appointments will be acclaimed—as it was applauded in the House—that of Congressman James Breck Perkins of Rochester as chairman of the Commit- tee on Foreign Affairs. To this posi- tion, he is fully entitled by reason of ability and attainments, and it may well be tnat his able handling, in be- half of the House, of Mr. Roosevelt's charges against Congressmen in con- nection with the Secret Service appro- priation, won him this preferment, Mr. Vreeland’s selection to head the Com- mittee on Banking and Currency had been discounted. He was, with Mr. Ald- rich, sponsor for the currency bill pass- ed last year, which remains so melan- choly a piece of largely unused and un necessary legislation, and will now play a great part in the promised efforts to reform the currency at a future special session. He is one of Mr. Cannon's in timates, and, Judging by his past record, may be relied upon to take orders. In view of the improvement in our consular service, it should seem as if the $100,000 granted by Congress to M: Knox for extending our commerce might best be used to teach American tmer chants that they cannot trade with na- tives of Japan or India on the same basis as with their neighbors of Kankakee The Philadephia Commercial Museums have long been doing yaluable service of this sort, and similar object lessons are widely needed; for we must lay aside the old notion that the Yankee is the shrewdest trader in the world. He is, however, eminently teachable. Our ag- ricultural experiment stations and their wonderful results in diversifying and intensifying crops, prove this beyond dispute. Travelling exhibits of the goods needed abroad and statistics as to the opportunities offered would seem to be one of the needs of the hour, if the American merchant will not study for himself or send the proper commer- cial traveller—the usually selects a drum. mer to travel in China, because he bas “made good” in some Michigan lumber camp. There is, however, one way in which Mr. Knox's $100,000 could be made of especial value—by collecting and disseminating information showing how our absurd tariff laws, which close our own markets to foreigners, tend to close theirs to us and invariably sow the seeds of dislike abroad. It is not a convincing argument for Government railway operation—this re- port which Mr. Bernard M. Baker has made to President Taft upon the freight charges in force across Panama. The Panama Railroad and the Panama Steamship Company are now owned by the Government, and are operated as commercial lines. The rates in force upon American commerce are sharply discriminatory against our shippers in favor of those of Europe. Thus the rate on dry goods from New York to Cen-
Page 4
130 tral America is $21.40 a ton, while from Europe it is $20.40 a ton. The Panama Railroad charges from Colon to Pan- ama, in case the consignment comes from New York, $3.46 per ton; ‘f from Eu- rope, $2.77 per ton. Coffee, rubber, co- all difference in rates, Mr. Baker declares. He is of opinion that these discrimina- coa, show the same comparative tory rates were continued by the pres- ent company not of set purpose, but merely as an inheritance from the for- mer owners of the Panama properties. Be this as it may, it is certainly a sin- control ister omen that government necessitates investigation by an out- side party to obtain equitable treatment for the shippers of the nation that is building the Panama Canal. The dif- ferences in rates which result from charging what the traffic wil! bear, in- stead of rates set upon a mileage ba- sis, are notoriously great. The greatest sometimes seemingly disparities are justified by considerations of return loads, competing carriers, or alterna- But the seems to be one where the rates sim- tive routings. case in point ply bleed the American shipper to the advantage of his foreign rivals. The old tease of convict labor is again The State Labor Depart- ment of New York has caused the arrest to the fore. of a dealer for selling convict-made goods from Illinois without displaying a conspicuous sign that he dealt in prod- ucts of that character. The law of this State prevents clothing made by our own prisoners from being put on the gener- al market. But this apparently makes our market only a favorite dumping- ground for the convict-made products of the Joliet Penitentiary. The arrested dealer's attorney argues that the re- quirement to display the sign in ques- tion is an interference by a State law with the exclusive power of Congress to commerce. It cer- regulate interstate tainly should seem to discriminate against one class of goods, the subject of interstate commerce, in favor of anoth- er class. The difficulties affecting the products of convict labor are numerous. To keep convicts idle would be cruelty to them. It forego the reformatory influence that the practice To let out convict would be to of a trade confers. labor (inside the prison) to contractors is to invite harsh treatment of the State’s wards if the contractor is cal- The Nation. lous or brutal. It too frequently gives an unfair differential advantage over those who make the same product by free labor. To confine the employment of prisoners to tasks which the prison wardens can direct is often uneconomi- cal and ineffective. Probably the best disposition of the matter is to limit the work of the prisoners to providing goods required in the various public in- stitutions. As for the dumping of wares made by foreign convicts upon the markets of another State, the prop- er remedy seem to He in the hands of Congress, and in the widened would area of enlightenment in all our States in this matter of prison reform. It was inevitable that the proposals of the committee of New York Supreme Court judges, aiming to lessen the law’s delays, should be sharply criticised by lawyers. Special attack is made upon that the demurrer be practically done away with. This is an the suggestion old and often a most useful pleading, and it is not surprising that the bar should Great abuses have undeniably arisen in connection with it, but these might be got rid of, it should seem, without en- tirely disallowing the demurrer. Very likely, this was what the justices really had in mind, in their somewhat vague recommendation. As to the salutary nature of their action, as a whole, there can be no difference of opinion. It shows that those most nearly concerned are at last awaking to the need of remov- ing the reproach which attaches to the administration of justice in this State. The judges do well to point out that their plan is only tentative and merely a beginning. To be satisfactory, the re- form of judicial procedure will have to be much more far-reaching. The pub- lic will be neither contented nor secure until steps are taken to amend the jury impossible the stand up for its continuance. laws, so as to make present outrageous methods, in impor- tant trials, and to abolish wanton and frivolous appeals to higher courts. The defeat of Mayor Johnson of Cleve- land, in the special election, or referen- dum, on another issue in his perennial traction struggle, was apparently rct a decision on the merits of the ques.ion. It was, rather, an expression of the city’s weariness at the way in which the whole matter had been kept in poll- [Vol. 89, No. 2302 tics, year after year. The forces arvayed against the Mayor conducted their cam- paign on that basis. The Chamber of Commerce, as also a non-partisan asso- ciation of business men, and the lead- ing newspapers of both parties, rang the changes on the great harm to the city which was being done by the continued agitation. The cry was for a final ¢ettle- ment and a good rest. Granting that Mayor Johnson was right in his con- tentions and sincere in his motives, he made the fatal mistake, politically, of tiring the people out. The ability of a democracy to remain at a white heat of indignation, and to keep its attention fixed steadily upon the same subject for a long time, is notoriously limited This is a lesson which many a leader hefore Johnson has had to learn in bitter ex- perience, and it is his turn now. Be- sides this fatigue of the electors, there was the difficulty that the rival plans submitted to them were not so radically different as easily to arouse it*tense feeling. The so-called Schmidt franchise was for only a portion of the street-car lines, but was for a flat three-cent fare. On the other hand, the proposal of the old companies, as suggested by Judge Tayler, in whose court the receivership had its authority, was for a reorganiza- tion and a franchise, under which the maximum fare was not to exceed sven tickets for twenty-five cents, with one cent additional for transfers, while the earnings of the corporation were to be kept to 6 per cent. on the actual value of its property. This is undoubtedly the set- tlement which will now be made. The people or Connecticut evidently think that New York State has got a good thing in its Public Utilities Com- mission law. Last Thursday in the low- er house of the Connecticut Legislature, there was a battle royal between the Chandler bill, modelled after the New York statute, wud the Barnum measure, contrived in the interests of the rail- ways and the trolley lines. Connecticut has long had a railway commission of the “weak tyre,” with power only to scold. Places upon it have been politi- cal plums, whose net effect has been to draw salaries from the State Treas- ury and to furnish passes for the Com- missioners and their families. The Bar- num measure proposes to except from the jurisdiction of the new commission steam and electric roads. It is charged
Page 5
Oren a Dt hl Aug. 12, 1909] that the attcurney of the New Haven Road is its author. The Chandle: bill would do away with the present Rail- road Commission, and give the new commission power over al] public ser- vice corporations. The presence and ac- tivity of lobby!sts and corporation man- agers on the floor of the House became so scandalous that the Speaker, amidst an uproar, finally ordered their ejec- tion. After ‘t seemed violently prob- able that the Chandler substitute for the majority’s recommendation of the Barnum measure would just pass, three votes changed with suspicious rapidity and the substitute for the majority re- port was negatived, 105 to 103. Dr. Jameson and Gen. Botha, sitting side by side on the steps of the throne in the House of Lords, while the Colon- ial Secretary asked for the second read- ing of the bill to create a South Afri- can commonwealth, in which Briton and Boer should have equal rights—this is the astonishing and gratifying spectacle which England is able to offer to the world. Who could have believed it pos- sible, when the desolating war in South Africa was raging, so short a time ago? It is a vivid proof that Great Britain has not lost her acquired skill in colon- ial administration. So healing and con- structive a piece of legislation as this Act of Union for the four South African Colonies has not been seen in many a year. It is an evidence of England's real greatness more convincing than all her battleships. The consummation of this great act of statesmanship under a Lib- eral Ministry will rank as perhaps the proudest achievement of the present Government. The Conservatives were at first cold to the project, which they pronounced premature, but in view of its triumphant conclusion, they do not stint their applause. Both Lord Curzon and the Marquis of Lansdowne offered their hearty congratulations te the Gov- ernment, and even Lord Milner uttered no jarring note. All this is far more of a national glory than talking till doomsday about debellare superbos. In replying in the House of Commone, the other day, tc the protests of the La- bor members at the official welcome to the Czar, the Foreign Secretary declar- ed, for the Government: “It is not our business to know what passes in the in- ternal affairs of other countries where The Nation. we have no treaty rights and no extra- territorial obligations.” This was in re- sponse to the array of statistics show- ing the appalling number of military executions in Russia. Now, this posi- tion of Sir Edward Grey's may be sound, but it certainly is not the traditional position of England She has long aspired to be, as Lord Rosebery once put it, the “moral censor of Europe,” and has made it very much her business to know what passes in the internal af- fairs of other nations. Is Palmerston so completely forgotten? Has Gladstone passed wholly out of remembrance? In the case of Bulgarian atrocities and Armenian massacres, it is true, England might be alleged to have a right of intervention under her treaties with Turkey; but what really led to in- tervention was simply moral indigna- tion overflowing the nice boundaries of diplomatic propriety. It is hardly fit- ting for a Liberal Minister to disown the past of the Liberal party. Reports of the “general stfike” in Stockholm seem to point to a result sim- ilar to the recent strike in Paris, and for much the same reasons. Everything now indicates a failure of the strike; partly due, perhaps, to lack of funds and dissatisfaction of the rank and file with their leaders, but due, in large measure, no doubt, to the public opin- ion, which is probably as strong in Sweden as in France, against a strike which tends to render inoperative the necessary activities of a great city, ty- ing up traffic, shutting down electric lights, and paralyzing postal service. To put up with such widespread practical inconveniences, the community must feel that a great moral and social prin ciple is involved; and whatever one’s political and social ideas may be, it is obvious that the general strike is not widely regarded as an inclusive moral measure. Even in the Socialist camp there is much condemnation of the gen eral strike Recent threatened revolutions, in Rus- sia, France, Spain, and Sweden, have all been more or less connected with in dustrial disputes. The “general strike” has played a part in all of them. It may be noted that in these countries, especially in Russia and Sweden, gener- al culture takes a strongly modern turn. Their literature, art, and music are 131 largely limited to those materials and ideas which are of relatively re- cent origin. To the imagination of the modern writer, even in a country of classic tastes,such as France, the new social tendencies strongly appeal. Wit- ness not only the great Russian group, but also men like Anatole France, Oc tave Mirbeau, and, indeed, a large pro- portion of the contemporary writers of distinction. In music, the name of ischaikovsky suggests an intense art comment on the modern social con sciousness. In Sweden, the “intelle tuels” are especially affected by the lat est note, often expressed with an ex treme hopelessness. It is about fifteen years ago that the Spaniards were fighting the Moors at Melilla, much as they are to-day, with- out, however, quite so heavy losses. But conditions in their camps in 1894 ex- plained clearly why they made no bet- ter showing against the tribesmen in Africa or the natives in Cuba. At that time the famous Martinez Campos com. manded, but the sanitary situation was unspeakably bad, the men being crowd- ed together, with little genuine disci- pline. The sentry work was poorly per formed, and there was a genera! air of laxity and shiftlessness which full; prepared the observer for the weak nesses exhibited by the Spanish army in Cuba. The Spaniards, moreover, had lost severely in their conflicts with the Kabyles, who then, as now, fought wit the fanaticism of the Sudanese in their battles in Egypt. It was currently be lieved that the Spanish general who fell in one of the engagements was shot in the back by his own men But the troops were on the whole marvellousls cheerful, considering everything Fo Melilla is at best an unattractive place a town crowded on to a high rock jut ting out into the Mediterranean—pictu: esque enough, but lacking in al) real comforts and wholly inadequate house the wounded properly. The fort fications are mainly antiquated, the ou lying blockhouses still dangerous to maintain, and the whole town probab) untenable, were the enemy in posses sion of modern artillery to mount upon near-by mountair slopes. That the Span ish army was as unable to profit by the lessons of the 1894 Melilla campaign as by its years of fighting in Cuba, ‘s a; parent from the present battling
Page 6
‘> ~ 1 Co THE UNSETTLED TARIFF. The tariff bill which was to settle everything, has settled nothing. It was to end agitation, but has only sharpened it. No other inference can fairly be drawn from the strong opposition shown to the last by Republicans in both House and Senate,from the President's state ment at the time of signing the biil, and from its reception by press and people. The tariff is plainly to remain ona of those unsettled questions which will have no pity for the repose of this na- tion. It will net be settled till it ia set- tled right. No previous tariff has been passed with such marked Republi- Republican can disapprova! stamped upon it so con- When the McKinley bill came up for final passage, only one reg- spicuously. ular Republican Senator, Mr. Plumb of Kansas, voted against it. Senators Pet- tigrew and Paddock were also recorded in opposition, but they were even then regarded as more Populist or Democrat- ic than Republican, and Mr. Pettigrew did, in fact, shortly abandon even his For the Ding- ley bill in 1897, the solid Republican Contrast nominal Repubiicanism. vote in the Senate was cast. this with what we saw on Thursday of last week. Despite the full pressure of party, notwithstanding appeals in which even the President is said to have join- ed, seven Republican Senators stood out to the end, recording their protest against the Payne bill, as giving the lie to party pledges and containing, as Sen- ator Dolliver boldly contended, swindles The two Senators from Minnesota, the two from upon the American people. Iowa, the only Republican Senator from Indiana, with one from Wisconsin and one from Kansas, refused to fall in line with their party. Nothing so signifi- cant and so om!nous has ever before at- tended the passage of a high-tariff bill. It argues irresistibly that a great change has come over the country. These Senators faithfully The Republl- cans of the West are up in arms against Republican repre- gent thelr constituents the continuance of protective duties which mean hich prices and monoroly. Unless something is done to satisfy them, disaster to the Republican party is certain to follow This sense of widespread dissatisfac tion and rebeilion is distinctly reftect- ed in Presiden: Taft's statement He ‘The Nation. [ Vol. 89, No. 2302 features, while admitting that it is not “a complete compliance with the prom- ises made.” And he gives a plain intima- tion that the end is not yet. Speaking of the power conferred upon him to em- ploy skilled agents to investigate the actual working of the new tariff, he remarks that they will be enabled to acquire information “under circum- stances favorable to its truth.” The im- plication that much of the alleged in- formation submitted to Congress was only a pack of lies, could hardly be clear- er. Furthermore, declares Mr. Taft, the exact facts, as secured by the Tariff Commission, will furnish a basis for “future Executive recommendations.” But Executive recommendations about the tariff can mean only recommenda- tions to Congress to change certain schedules. This is the obvious infer- ence from the President’s language; and it is borne out by the explicit assertion of a Washington correspondent that Mr. Taft is making plans for further tariff revision. This suggestive dispatch says: The President has let certain Senators and members of the House know within the last few days that he is not satisfied with some of the schedules in the new law, especially with the woollen and cot- ton schedules. He has made up his mind to pursue the investigation into those schedules which he began just before the bill came out of conference, and upon the results obtained from this line of inquiry to base a recommendation to Congress for further action which will involve a sub- stantial revision of them. We shall hear more of this when the President makes his Western tour next month. All accounts agree that the Re- publican managers in the West are deeply concerned over the political out- look. They are counting much upon Mr. Taft's efforts to “soothe” the dis- gruntled peop.e in their part of the country. But the only way to soothe a man who feels that he has been cheated, is to show that you propose to correct the injustice done him. This is as true of tariff cheating as of any other kind. Men in the West are now persuaded, as the speeches of the Iowa Senators show, that many parts of the Payne-Aldrich bill are designed to rob them; and when the President goes out to talk to them, they will want to know what he is go- ing to do about it. If he intends to go to the root of their discontent, he will have to expand his statement and let it be seen that he means still to use every weapon in his power to redress tariff signs the bill, for the sake of its good , This will be sneered at as “piece-meal” revision. But that is the only way now left to prevent piece-meal stealing. And an attack upon one iniquitous schedule at a time, would make the pretence that the whole business of the country was again to be thrown into confusion, ap- pear ridiculous. The tariff thieves would, of course, cry out for fear that their plunder might be taken from them, but nobody else would be disturbed. Only by thus pressing on with the work to which he nas set his hand, can the President justify himself for accepting a bill which confessedly comes so far short of his promises and his hopes. THE ALDRICH INCUBUS. It is announced that Senator Aldrich now thinks it doubtful if the bills for currency reform will be ready for in- troduction when Congress meets in De- cember. Yet his interest in this sub- ject remains intense. He is to make public addresses on the important top- ic, during the month of October, in Chicago, St. Louis, and other cities; and is to press the matter upon Congress, either in the regular session, or at a spe- cial session which, it is rumored, may be called in the autumn of next year. in any event, the great measure is to be under the peculiar charge of Senator Aldrich. His friends have known for some time that it was his ambition to round out his political career by af- fixing his name to a comprehensive financial bill that should cure our cur- rency and monetary ills for all time, and cause the Rhode Island Senator to be looked upon by coming genera:ions with something of the admiration and awe that Englishmen cherish for Sir Robert Peel. With such an ambition, we cannot avoid having a certain sympathy, but truth compels the statement that Sena- tor Aldrich can never realize it. After what has happened in the sight ot all men during the past four months, it would be madness for currency reform- ers to pin their hopes to this man. Any bill identified with his name wou!d be politically damned from the moment of its introduction. We do not like to say this, but we believe it to be the ‘act. Senator Aldrich’s ability and skill we freely admit. His desire to put our financial system upon a sound foo.ing wrongs. may be perfectly unselfish and stutes- x, SSRN ER ERS CI x, Ra IRE RIP NL HIT 2 NE SO IE BEE oo mS ry
Page 7
agit Aug. 12, 1909] Yet he ought to be told plain- ly, as ought those who are working with him and hoping for great currency reforms under his leadership, that his reputation, and the things he now st.nds for in the public mind, are such that any financial measure he advocates will be from the first violently suspe-ted, will be powerfully attacked, and will be defeated. Senator Aldr:ch has taade himself an incubus which will ec-ush manlike. into failure even honest and needed leg- islation. The first reform which cur- rency reformers should strive for is to take their cause wholly out of the hands of Nelson W. Aldrich. If this seems a hard saying, let any one who dissents from it calmly weigh the facts. Let him consider what sort of influences in politics those are with which Aldrich has now inextricably tied himself up. His name is, to-day, throughout the land, the synonym for grasping and corrupt legislation. His course on the tariff has made what was before strong suspicion turn into posi- tive conviction. The whole country has seen him standing athwart reasonable tariff revision, antagonizing and ev'scer- ating the best features of the House bill, rallying to his support the worst men in public life and repelling the »est, driving one-sixth of his party in the Senate into open revolt, and, through- out, making himself the attorney for selfish and unscrupulous interests. The men are known who have “seen Ald- rich,” and got him to arrange the law so as to put money in their pockets, and then gone away and boasted of it. We do not charge him with corruption, but he has been the willing servant of un- scrupulous and corrupt men and corpor- ations. This fact is known of all men; and there can be no mistaking the «ffect if Aldrich were to come forward next December as the sponsor and framer of bills for currency reform. The instant outcry would be: “What private interest is he serving now? What money-making scheme for whom lies behind this bill of his?” Under any auspices, a measure for the reform of our currency laws would have a hard time of it getting through Congress next winter; with Aldrich to father it, defeat would be certain in advance. The Nation is fully of the mind of those bankers and business men and economists who regard the need of set ting our financial house in order as The Nation. urgent. The shameful experience of 1907, when there was practically a sus- pension of payments throughout the United States, largely owing to our sys- tem of banking and currency, ought never to be repeated. Legislation should be had to bring this country into line with the practice of progressive nations Teo much emphasis cannot be placed upon this. The importance of the :aat- ter cannot be exaggerated But the more imperative we fee] the duty to be. the firmer should be our demand that the wrong man should not be set in the forefront of the work of its discharge We cannot afford to prejudice this great undertaking by entrusting it to the :ead ership of a Senator whose -mot'ves are suspected, and whose latest public uctiv ity has been in contemptuous disregard of the needs and desires of the whole country. All this may be said to be quite too morally fastidious. Very well: put it on the ground of the most “practical” polli- tics. It ‘put it through,” that he can wield the is alleged that Aldrich can whole power of “the organization’ to force a good finance bill to enactment. But can he? Look at the mess he has made of it. When was the Repub!.can party in Congress ever so divided and distraught as to-day? And it is largely his doing. Dislike of his personality and anger at his methods have riven the party following and filled many Repub- lican Senators and Representatives with the determination to oppose whatever he favors. This may be unreasonable, but it is the hard political fact with which “practical” men must reckon. Go to any intelligent and disinterested Con- gressman and ask him what chance there is of an Aldrich passing, and he will tell you: We have Aldrich we can stagger under for the currency bill “None whatever. already all the next Congressional elections.”’ Whether, therefore, we take the high moral view, or the low political one, the inference is the same: Aldrich has made himse'f im- possible. THE JAPANESE SUGAR SCANDAL. Japan, too, has had her Sugar Trust scandal, greater if anything, and cer- tainly more sensational, than that which has led to the indictment of our Sugar Trust officials and lawy: was a large aggregation of « ipital bent | Here, too, | | worse features 133 on aiding the “ultimate consumer” from that same philanthropy characteristic of our American Trusts. In Japan, as well as in this country, there was a close al- liance between the Sugar Trust and the tariff, and the former was quite as eager for special favors at the hands of the Government as our own. But there is one marked difference: Japanese courts have been prompt and merciless Within two months from the first ar rest of men prominent in pubiic life, the decisions of the court have been ren dered, and the sentences put into ef fect, despite the fact that no less than seventy lawyers, a larger array even than counsel for our own Trust, plead ea for the accused. We are very much afraid that by corporation managers in this country this ruthlessness of the Japanese courts will be set down as an- other shortcoming of a yellow race to which we are so infinitely superior The swift action of the Japanese court in these sugar scandals, recently reviewed at some length in the London Times, is particularly interesting be cause of the marked political features of the Trust's prosecution. lhe “Great Japan Sugar Company” was formed in 1906 by several refineries in the boom time immediately after the war with Russia, with a capital of six millions of doliars, on which it paid 84 per cent. in dividends in its first year, 32% per cent. in the second, and 15 per cent. in the first half of its third year. By that time, however, the company was badly shak en by rumors that it, like ‘our own Trust, had been paying dividends out of money “earned” by defrauding the customs Officials. Finally, late in 1908, a bank which had loaned large sums to the Trust went under, and a credi tors’ committee speedily discovered that the Trust was practically bankrupt. It then owed two millions of dollars to the customs (our Trust was also just two millions in debt to our Treasury for fraudulent underweighing at the same time), and its liabilities were nearly equivalent to the total of its capital. Moreover, the directors had been spec- ulating in the Trust's shares on the heads-we-win-tails-you-lose plan (also not unheard-of in the United States), by which, if they made profits, they pock eted them, but if they lost, the losses were charged against the company This,.was bad enough; but there were To help themselves out
Page 8
184 of their difficulties, the directors sought to obtain legislative aid for their poor But instead of buying struggling concern. with curious Oriental ineptitude, tariff favors by contributing to cam- paign funds of the all-wise and ruling political party of the hour, they chose the clumsy way of directly purchasing members of the lower house of the Diet. Up to that time, they had shown their usual ability to copy Western methods successfully. Even when they bribed, these poor heathen did not know enough to cover their tracks, so that soon no less than twenty-four members and ex-members of the lower house were in jail. The Trust first used mon- ey to obtain the passage of a bill en- couraging the export of sugar by grant- ing a rebate of the consumption-tax. This went through with a rush. In the next session of the Diet, the Trust tried to get what has not yet come about here—a state monopoly of sugar to which the Trust could then comfort- ably sell out. After spending $60,000 in “fixing” legislators, the Trust was com- pelled to abandon this plan. Of the jailed politicians, president of our American Board of Missions’ useful college at Kioto; the others were politicians of every party. But in the treatment of these states- men appears the real Japanese inferior- one was ity to us. There seems to be something wrong with their statute of limitations; their lack of demurrers, appeals, post- ponements, of abstruse technical ques- tions to insure the rights of the ac- cused, is painfully uncivilized. The ar- rests only began in April, but by July 5, of the twenty-four accused politi- clans, one was acquitted and twenty- three were found guilty and condemned t terms in jail of from three to ten months, execution of the sentence being The benight- ed Japanese judges failed wholly to ac- the that, were people of high position, they felt deferred in seven cases. cept plea as the offenders their disgrace and pain more keenly and should therefore have only nom- inal the foolish court ruled that the more exalted the sentences. Instead, offender the greater the severity with which he should be treated, and then rubbed it In by ordering the return of the bribes. What would become of us if such vicious Oriental beliefs were to become prevalent In our fair land? We fear that, despite their obvious er- . The Nation. rors of judgment and the shortcomings of their courts, these Japanese finan- ciers will be held by many Americans to be not far behind some of our own. But to those who would use this scandal to bring up the old stories about the lack of Japanese commercial integrity, we would suggest that a recaliing of our insurance scandals alone will show that we reside in the most fragile of glass houses. The fact that some Japanese politicians have been proved dishonest, and some financiers are now about to go to jail, is no more reason for doubt- ing the nation’s integrity than our own scandals were just cause for asserting the total depravity of all American busi- ness life. CHURCHES AND WAGE-EARNERS. In a recently published volume, the author devote; his attention to “a spe- cific, clear-cut problem—that of the gulf between the masges of the laboring peo ple and the churches to-day.” The book is based upon conditions long grievous- ly exaggerated on both sides. Such a declaration as “the attitude of the ma- jority of class-conscious workingmen is, on the whole, an attitude of active hos- tility to anything and everything con- nected with the churches,” will at pres- ent be resented by both churches and wage-earners. The question itself is not new. So far back as his day, Phillips Brooks once said publicly: “I like workingmen very much, and care for their good, but I have nothing distinct or separate to say to them about religion; nor do I see how it will do any good to treat them as a separate class in this matter in which their needs and duties are just like oth- er men’s.” Nevertheless, with the growth of the labor movement, the churches have felt the reed of special appeals to workingmen. Four leading denomina- tions, Presbyterians, Episcopalians, Methodists, and Congregationalists, not to mention the varied activities of the rw Ga Ae “labor depart- ments,” in the hope of maintaining cor- dial relations with wage-earners. Minis- ters become more often members of lo- cal labor unions. Discussion of labor subjects under church auspices, noonday services in factcries and mills, indicate the intent of the churches. Labor Sun- day, now appointed in May at the re quest of the American Federation of sustain Labor, is another noteworthy sign. Here [Vol. 89, No. 2302 is the way one Western city observed it this year: The fifty different labor unions of the city were invited to the sixteen churches which coéperated with the Labor Trades Assembly in the observances. Some unions attended in a body, making a fine showing. At some churches, men from the ranks of union labor made addresses; this feature will be more widely adopted next year. Both min- isters and labor leaders are glad at the re- sults, and are laying plans for a better ob- servance of the day next year. If these facts were all, the bridge would touch only one side of “the gulf.” But workingmen also show a change of attitude. At a recent meeting of union machinists in Boston, when an interna- tional official uttered disparaging cr't- icism of the churches, he was stopped by hisses. On the other side of the At- lantic, several hundred English church- men from the Brotherhoods visited Bel- gium last spring: in one city their ar- rival “was signalled by a welcome from 14,000 workingmen, many of whom had come in from the colliery and iron- working towns of the district.” Mr. D. A. Hayes, a vice-president of the Amer- ican Federation of Labor, has gone on record to this effect: We have heard it stated that trade union- ists are indifferent toward the churches. It is my candid opinion that both sides have unconsciously exaggerated this phase of the question; because I can truthfully say that the great majority of trade unionists are earnest church members, and after fif- teen years of active service in the move- ment, I know from experience and vbserva- tion that membership in labor organiz3- tions has made men better Christians and better citizens. Whatever credit is to be given to this declaration, certainly there is in it no spirit of hostility. Socialism has often been adduced among the causes of religious indiffer- ence. Critics solemnly assert that it has become among our wage-earners a sub- stitute for religion. But those actually in touch with our working classes know that this is a gross exaggeration. The lack of response by our labor movement to its Socialistic wooers has been con- tinuous. Keir Hardie, M.P., leader of the Socialist-Labor party in Great Brit- ain, returned this year from his Amer- ican visit disappointed and chagrined at the hopeiessness of a similar com- bination here. Secretary Hayes Robbins of the Civic Federation of New Eng- land declares: Perhaps nowhere to-day is the conflict with the Socialist propaganda being waged so continuously, so actively, and at such
Page 9
Aug. 12, 1909] close range, as within the ranks of the organized industrial crafts. What are, then, the actual relations between churches and wage-earners to- day? In the Catholic and Jewish faiths, the workingmen are a majority; and a great many Protestant churches would not be able to maintain themselves but for working-class support. Telling evi- dence comes from Rhode Island. Here, owing to the nature and distribution of the popuiation, industrial pr«blems are found in an acute stage. Hence the value of the testimony, when an able investigating relig- ious affairs, comes to the following con- commission, after clusions: About half of those in trades unions are Roman Catholics, the rest Protestants or without religious preference. About 45% churches in the State are largely composed of the common people, tradesmen, artisans, clerks. A large number of the 104,000 “un- churched” are not artisans. Hence a large number of the working class are in our churches or under their influence. It is also well known that emong the unchurched workmen, multitudes are re- cent immigrants. Their indifference or hostility often traces back to ecclesiasti- This class, with many native-born working cal oppression in the homeland. men upon whom the churches have lost their hold, admittedly constitutes a still unsolved religious problem. Rut such facts as we have cited show that there is no more foundation for hostility be- tween church and labor than there is for a formal etiiance. THE SECOND POET LAUREATE. 7 It is not always exact to say that The evil that men do lives after them; but this seems to have been distinctly the case with Sir William D’Avenant. To-day he is chiefly known as the initi- ator of the corrupt Restoration stage and the debaser of Shakespeare. Yet his contemporaries thought him a great poet, and careful reading of his works goes far to justify that opinion. D’Avenant, like Lope de Vega, was a man who wrote with one hand and lived with the other, or with both. He knew courts and camps and studied them with vast curiosity. He experienced strange vicissitudes of love and war. The Roundheads caught him and shut him up, and in daily expectation of death he wrote part of an epic. Then he escap- ed, and the epic was dropped for slight- er matters. Our most vivid informa- tion about him concerns his funeral. Aubrey was there: walnut tree. “He had a coffin of Sir John Denham said The Nation. ‘twas the finest coffin that ever he saw.” Pepys was there also: “Here were many coaches and six horses, and many hack- nies, that made it look, methought, as if it was the burial of a poor poet.” D’Avenant’s early plays are crude and violent, with the exception of “The Pla- tonic Lovers,” which is charming com- edy. But they are all full of a rich, strange, splendid poetry, too much neg- lected: And as the moon ne'er changes but ji’ the full, Even so the mighty nations of the earth Change in their greatest glory First, their strict And rugged discipline to vain delights, Their solemn marches next to wanton jigs heir battles flerce to duels splenitive And there are subtle, pregnant similes: For life is like the span Forced from a gouty hanj, which as it gains Extent and active length, the more it pains And there is sweet, sunshiny prose, though less of it: He seems a merry and innocent man, for he laughs at everything, as if he had nu more cares than a capuchin. But it is in “Gondibert,” the uffin ished epic, that D’Avenant’s real great- ness must be sought. ‘“Gondibert,” if anything, justifies the high praise of Dryden, one of the acutest critics that ever lived: Nothing was proposed to him on which he could not suddenly produce a thought extremely pleasant and surprising, And as his fancy was quick, so likewise were the products of it remote and new He borrowed not of any other and his imaginations were such as could not eas- ily enter into any other man. This at once suggests conceits and odd ities, like those of Donne. Doubtless, D’Avenant is not altogether free from such, and Donne’s mighty infiuence, is clearly found in the younger writer. But D’Avenant’s originality shows most in his having escaped the bad taste which was fashionable about him. “Gondi bert” is distinguished from such work as Chamberlayne’s ‘“Pharonnida,” so much and on many accounts so justly esteemed by Mr. Saintsbury, not only by the quality of the imagination, but by a certain restraint and self-command in the use of it, a bell-like clearness of utterance, which is, I hope, noticeable in almost all the passage cited below. II. No one reads “Gondibert” nowadays, and the reasons are simple. In the first place, the metrical form is wholly un- suited to narrative. The _ ten-syllable quatrain, admirable for reflection, as with Gray, will not blend its units in a continuous surface, as does the couplet; yet it has not amplitude enough for the individual development which is possi- ble with the Spenserian stanza. Thus D’Avenant’s story limps and sways and 185 stumbles, like a maimed soldier on crutches he is not used to. Yet even here the poet shows his great powers. For narrative purposes his medium is hopeless. But in individual stanzas he has rhythms of wonderful grace and melody. I am not aware that Gray read “Gondibert.” In any case, such stanzas as the following are most curious an- ticipations of the “Elegy” in their sweet- ness of cadence and their antithetic turn: Why should we now their shady curtains draw, Who by a wise retirement hence are freed, And gone to lands exempt from nature's law, Where love no more can mourn nor val or bleed? And the breadth of D'Avenant’s subject gave him opportunity for harmony far more varied than Gray's. Take, as mere music, this stanza from the last book of the poem His valor shall the Gothic conquest keep, And would to Heaven all your mighty minds As yon were pleased, as jnfants are with sleep, And you had music common as the winds. But it is not only metrical drawbacks that make “Gondibert" unreadable. One cannot be absorbed in the story itself The characters are human and sketched with vigor, but there are too many of them One group melts into another, before you can disentangle any. Also, the first book is the dullest, and this is disastrous. As the poet goes on, he seems to find himself. The narrative moves more quickly. The figures have animation And just when the work is interrupted, it begins to prom some interest. Very few, however, I imagine, have had courage to persist so far The reader who does persist will find himself repaid. The poem is loaded with acute and careful thought. D’Ave- nant had all phases of life, and profited. Like lis first patron, Lord Brooke, he was a most curious observer of political problems, and recurs to them often: more ise seen Yield not in storms of state to that dislike Which from the people does to rulers gTOW. Power (fortune’s sail) should not for threatenings strike: In boats bestormed all check at those that row Advice as good for the twentieth cen- tury as for the seventeenth. Some of D'Avenant’s political maxims seem rather Machiavellian; but this gives all the more significance to the moral ener- gy of others. So with religion. “On the most important subjects,” says the plous Southey, “D’Avenant’s feelings were unhappily in sympathy with those of his friend Hobbes.” That is to say, he was no shallow optimist nor conven- tional believer. Life was perplexing. If
Page 10
136 higher powers ordered it, they ordered it oddly: But sure the heavenly movers little care Whether our motion here be false or true; For we proceed, whilst they are regular As if we dice for all our actions threw Yet the author of “Gondibert” was nei- ther skeptic nor cynic, and if in the following noble lines he touches the weak point of prayer, he brings out by contrast the lofty and divine office of praise: Praise is devotion fit for mighty minds The differing world's agreeing sacrifice, Where heaven divided faiths united finds; But prayerin various discord upward flies For prayer the ocean is where diversely Men steer their course, each to a several coast Where all our interests so discordant lie That half beg winds by which the rest are lost Ill But admirable as is the intellectual element in “Gondibert,” the imaginative beauty is more admirable still. Those thoughts “pleasant and _= surprising, these imaginations “remote and new,” of which Dryden speaks, meet us at every turn, strange and subtle, but some- times grand and always rich and splen did In the passages quoted above I have looked rather to the thought than to the adornment, but in the blending of imagination and reflection D’Avenant at his best And to be rich, be diligent! Move on Li} heaven's great movers that enrich the earth Whose moment's sloth would show the world undone And make the spring straight bury all her birth Rich are the diligent, who can command rin Nature's stock, and could his hour giass fall Would. aa for acedsa of atars, stoop for the sand And by Incessant labor gather all In the dep'ction of passion also this singular imaginative touch gives most triking and fascinating effects. Direct intense dramatic action D'Avenant’s love scenes perhaps lave not, But there has rarely been a more delicate and sen sitive analveis of love's agony and tri umph, or a more radiant expression of them. Bertha grows conscious of her passion for Gondibert She thinks of Eden life and no rough wind In their Pacific sea shall wrinkles make, That atill her lowliness shall keep him kind, Her cares keep him asleep, her voice awake Orna cures her lover Hurgonil of his wounds She let no medicinal flower in quiet grow, No art lie hid, nor artist his thought, No fane be shut, no priest from altars go, in heaven’s choir no saint remain ease Nor The Nation. Nor more her eyes esteem Than sleep can the world’s eye, the sun, conceal ; Nor breathed she but in vows to heaven cr him, Till heaven and she his differ2at wourds did heal. could ease of sleep So with nature. D’Avenant is no landscape painter. Humanity is always first with him; but a poetical gift like his could not fail to enrich human pas- sion with the suggestions of natural beauty, or to transfigure the external world by the emotions of the soul. Now it is a sombre touch: Where desert rivers, cold and private, run. Now it is an outburst of joyous fresh- ness and sunlight: All showed as fresh and fair and innocent As virgins to their lovers’ first survey; Joyed as the spring, when March his sighs has spent, And by April's rash tears are dried May. sweet, And I hardly know where we shall find a subtler and tenderer blending of high- wrought pathos and nature’s loveliness than in the following stanza: When o'er him then, whilst parting life she rued, Her kisses faster (though unknown be- fore), Than blossoms fall on parting spring she strewed, sweeter and ‘in number Than blossoms more IV. As a general thing, these snatches of beauty in “Gondibert” are scattered, broken, and fragmentary. One passage, however, the beginning of the third canto of the third book, is a long-sus- tained climax of really remarkable dig- nity and grandeur. Unfortunately, it is too long to quote in full. But the poet calls upon all young lovers to cher- ish his memory: Thou who perhaps proudly thy bloomy bride Lead'st to some temple, where I withered lie; Proudly, as if she age’s frosts defied, \nd that thy springing self could never die . . Then when the priest has ended, if thine eyes Can but a little space her eyes forbear, To shew her where my marble coffin lies, Her virgin garlands she will offer there. And she will boast how spite of cynic age, Of business, which does power uncivil make, Of ruder cells where they love's fire assuage By studying death and fear for virtue take. And spite of courts (where loving now is made An art, as dying is in cells), my laws unsought Did teach her how by nature to persuade [ Vol. 89, No. 2302 And hold by virtue whom her beauty draws. Thus when, by knowing me, thou know'st to whom Love owes his eyes who has too long been blind, Then in the temple leave my body's tomb And seek this book, the monument of my mind. Alas, young lovers do not greatly care tor old poets. “A lady asked me the other day,” says Anatole France, “of what use were poets. I told her they helped us to love, but she assured me that one could love very well without them.” And D’Avenant himself recog- nizes that unfortunates who are Vexed by living beauties of their own Have shunned the wise records of lovers dead. Yet here and there one of those who fave been lovers long ago may be glad to be guided to a book in which love and life and death and almost all things human are clarified and glorified by the divine magic of beauty. GAMALIEL BRADFORD, JR. Wellesley Hills, Mass. Correspondence. A LOVER OF GEOFROY TORY. To THE EpDIToR OF THE NATION: The Nation dated July 15 contained a notice of the first Royal Printer and Bernard’s account of his life and works translated by Mr. George D. Ives. The de- light of calling up into still further exist- ence “Maistre Geofroy Tory de Bourges” urges me to address you a few words in honor of the master to whom I owe so much, who gave me the Art and Science of the True Proportions of Attic or Antique letters, besides of course certain rules for speaking more elegantly the French lan- guage. I know by his very opening pages that Tory meant the instruction for me. In his preface he reproaches those who will not give what they know, and takes for example the noble workman of the windows -vitres—of the Sainte Chapelle of Bourges which the Duc de Berri called Jehan had made. That workman was so ungrateful and such a glutton of his knowledge that never was he willing to teach any man— not even his son, so he said. The windows which he made are of such an art that the sun, however shining it may be, cannot with its rays at all penetrate them, which is a thing very beautiful, and without other example. If he had willingly taught that art, thousands of other men might have made since many beautiful and good oper- ations which have not been made and never will be made. Those windows I fell in love with and I tried in my way to make windows in ac- cordance with the definition that Master Tory had written out. I am sometimes al- most reproached with having carried out SIR: these ancient principles which Tory re- gretted to see drifting to nothing. He praises Albert Direr, the noble German painter; says he is worthy of being made an immortal memory, and we all agree. Then
Page 11
Aug. 12, 1909] The Nation. he goes on to explain the nature of letters and how useful they must be in picture and in window, in tapestry and on walls. Their size, their proportion, their space, are all considered, so that he has named his book “The Flowery Field’’—“Champ Fleuri”—for the grace and facility of the name. Of course, our dear master speaks lightly of his own handling of his book, or rather its beginning. He tells us how in the morn- ing of the Epiphany, having taken sleep and rest and a little light and joyous food, whose concoction had been easy, at the time that men count MDXXIII, being in bed, he took te fantasying, as he calls it. Thereupon some words of a quotation came to him to the effect that he ought to use his special knowledge for the public good; and he re- membered, too, other delightful themes Leo Baptista Alberti had written and demon- strated, and those of the late Leonardo da Vinci, who had died at Amboise, and was the most excellent philosopher and admira- ble painter, and, as it were. another Archi- medes. As to Luca Paccioli, in his “Divine Proportion” of letters, he borrowed what was good of the same Leonardo. Albert Diirer made mistakes, and I shall never forget the teaching of our master Tory with regard to the letter N, that the heel should be cut off according to the architect Bramante, as he has shown in the gallery of Pope Ju- lius II, between the palace of St. Peter of Rome and Belvedere. I have always follow- ed him, feeling that nothing could be better both for my art and for all the form of poetry with which our master has invested a question apparently so ordinary. But does not the very republication of the book which you review show how valuable still is the meaning of our teacher? I do not remember and I have not the courage to look up what the master says of a man who, like him, was a poet in the forms of letters, the scholar who gave us the “Hypnerotomachia” of Polyphilus, and who could hide, as we know, in the first capital letter of each chapter the secret of his love for Polia. I have so wished to be allowed tc write some ordinary essay on this bit of love and literature, which had its place in teaching to the world the lesson of form, and is still one of the world’s curios- ities. I regret to say that I had to sell my copy a few months ago, so that I cannot quote as I should like. But I have used my master Polyphilus on many occasions of good taste and with a secret defiance of the critics who do not know him. My first at- tempt at a window was taken squarely out of Polyphilus by the use of the photograph ; and yet learned critics looked at it and thought that the Renaissance features, dated as we know 1499, were not quite correct. So that I owe to this passionate lover, as well as to the said Geofroy, a continuous guid ance, sometimes almost hourly, a good deal over the third of a century. Hence my wish to draw still further attention through these few words to these old friends of mine, whoee quality in every way is as high as it can possibly be, but whose rarity, whose strangeness, whose very poetic envelope have prevented our more prosaic age from a sufficient practice of them. Joun LA FARGE. New York, July 29. A CURE FOR “BOOSTING.” To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Any person familiar with the meth- ods of teaching prevalent in the ordinary American public school will agree with the conclusions of your correspondent from Colorado writing to the Nation of July 15. Young people are too often taught that everything American is perfect, and that any criticism on things American must be unpatriotic and spiteful. The pure genuine patriot is he who hurrahs loudest and oft- enest; anything connected with the flag, however remotely, is sacrosanct and beyon? criticism, etc., etc. That sort of mental attitude towards pub lic affairs on the part of the youth of the land is indeed silly—but it is worse than that: it is dangerous because it precludes improvement which might result from can- did introspection and comparison with other nations. It opens up a rich, unlim- ited fleld for the demagogue The suggestion of your Colorado corre- epondent is that criticism of American af- fairs by intelligent foreigners should be introduced into the public schools But it is doubtful whether with such a com munity the desired result would be reached Persons in the state hardly accept with good grac: ty any criticism from when similar criticisms from icans, though in modified form of mind depicted would and sincert- dbservers Amer- foreign known notoriousl 7 xcite instant hostility, and carry the im putation of lack of true patriotism. A bet- ter method in my opinion would be to lay the proper facts before the child and let him draw his own inevitable conclusions For instance, instead of asserting cate- gorically that there were less accidents on English railways than on American, official figures might be laid before the pupils with the suggestion that they the sults and draw their own conclusions Tu most American schools “fin ished” in the seventh grade that is, when the average child reaches the age of thir- teen. The only history taught is American history, and that is principally panegyric. In all our wars we unanimous and absolutely just; our opponents were with- out a shred of justice on their side; the French government that assisted us during the Revolution was animated with a of democratic institutions; the war was a righteous performance; and any man that questions the wisdom of taking over the Philippines is at heart a traitor, etc. But the expansion of the British Em- pire, the unification of Italy, the recent com- mercial prominence of Germany—even the French Revolution—are matters of trivial importance. So, too, are the marvellous development of western Canada (with its influx of American immigrants), the tre- mendous leaps and bounds of Mexico (with its millions of invested American capital), the startling actualities and possibilities of the Argentine and Chill. ment denominated a kingdom must be a grinding tyranny, and every government labelled a republic must be a paradise of individual rights and freedom: witness, England and Venezuela. What the American youth of to-day (aud incidentally his teacher) needs is a larger mental horizon and a more judicial tem- perament. He should be taught to look out- side of the United States and behind the tabulate re- geography is were love Mexican Every govern-. 137 present era. He should then be taught :o look back to our country fairly and im- partially and compare what he has seen with what he sees now and here. His pa- triotism, while quite as strong, will be much more intelligent; the effect on public affairs will be wholesome when he comes to his majority E. LL. C. Morse Chicago, July 20 UNCUT LEAVES To THE EprTror oF THE NATION Sir: I wish to join the number of those who are thanking you for now sending out with 4s I have read every word and line of the paper from it the Nation smooth-edged cut leaves 8 initial issue in July, 1865, to the present date, and as it takes at least one minute to cut a copy of it neatly, to open pages, I find that I have consumed fifty-two minutes a year in opening for perusal Multiplying this by the forty-four years of its existence. my total loss of time in the process is equivalent to over a day anda half, if I have made no essential mistake n figuring it But, I will leave to you the further problem of multiplying this result as it affects me, by the average number of your subscribers for the period referred to which make 10,000 times a and a half It may have been may day thought once book, obtained that, for a choice, limited-edition uncut- ness is a charm to be and pre- served against the vandalism of an unap- preciative binder But it has been really always unnecessary, and it is always a nuisance. If it is desirable to be sure and save the perpendicular and horizontal mar- f gins of a page; or, rather, to know certain- ly that the page is intact, let the printer note, somewhere near the claim for copy- right, figures something like these: “1 by % inch.’’ The prospective buyer will then know how to avoid being bereaved and the binder will give up his unprofitable sinful- ness JOEL BENTON Poughheepsele, N. Y¥., August 6 A PROPHECY To THE EpiITorR or THE NATION Sin: The following amusing prophecy Is taken from the argument of Mr. Emmett in the of Gibbons v. Ogden Supreme Court of the States in 1824. In endeavoring to that Congress did the exclusive power of regulating commerce, he uses this language: celebrated case argued before the United maintain not have The thirteen original States were a band of brothers, who suffered, fought, bled, and triumphed together; they might, perhaps have safely confided each his separate in- terest to the general will; but {f ever the day should come, when representatives from beyond the Rocky Mountains shall sit in this capitol; if ever a numerous and inland delegation shall wield the exclusive power of making regulations for our for- eign commerce without ny em of in- terest or knowledge of our local circum- stances, the Union will not stand; it can- not stand; it cannot be the ordinance of God or nature that it should stand. The day which he dreaded came long ago, and the Union still stands. Geo. A. TORREY Boston, July 27.
Page 12
> , 13388 GEORGE BORROW'S WORK IN SPAIN. To THE EpIToR or THE NATION: SIR Readers of George Borrow may be interested to know that the work Borrow was ostensibly doing in Spain, is still car- ried on along analogous lines I was re- ently sitting in a third-class compartment n the train from Pontevedra to Santiago, when a genial-faced man with grizzled beard and a pack on his back, got in at a way station. He at once began to offer a book for sale, for one peseta. Soon he was sub- jected to a fire of comment, which he an- swered with ready wit. The book was ex- amined with interest by several, who asked what it was. It was the New Testament in Spanish. Finally, one young man and my- self bought a copy of the Gospel of St. Matthew for one “perro gordo’—a “big dog,” ¢. e., two cents. To a lover of “Don Jorge” the scene was a striking one CHARLES ST. CLAIR WADE. Rarcelona, July 24 _ Notes. Lord Morley is publishing a collection of George Meredith's letters, and asks the privilege of copying any which may be sent to him Out of folly wisdom. The “Journal of John Woolman” certainly has no place in such a collection of books as was intended by Dr. Eliot for educating mankind. It is, however, a work of real charm, and we are giad to hear that Houghton Mifflin Com- pany, impelled by the newly aroused cu- riosity about the book, is reissuing it, with Whittier’s introduction. At an early date the Fordham University Press of this city will bring out a book entitled “Makers of bElectricity.”’ which will contain biographies of eminent elec- tricians, Some time this month B. W. Huebsch will publish “India, Impressions and Sug- gestions,” by J. Keir Hardie. Early in September John Lane Company will have ready “Seekers in Sicily,” by Elizabeth Bisland and Anne Hoyt, which recounts the experiences of two American ladies on the island The Century Company has made an inter- esting volume of tales for boy readers by selecting, and, to some extent, abridging, “Stories of the Great West,’’ from Presi- Roosevelt's volumes of Western ex- history dent and Frank A. Bates has prepared a practical little book on “Camping and Camp Cook- ing’ (The Ball Publishing Company), which in small space gives information in regard to camp outfits, the pitching of tents and with a chapter of general advice the layman perience lean-tos and a number of receipts for abroad in the world Alaska and its resources is the principal subject of the National Geographic Maga- sine for July, and the facts as presented by the different writers will come as a frev- elation to most readers. Major-Gen. Greely treats briefly but most lucidly of its eco- nomic evolution, the total value of its pro- ducts since the acquisition in 1867 being $327,651,196, and yet mot a tenth of the ter- ritory is prospected. There are eleven in- ‘The Nation. corporated cities, modern in their equip- ment and permanent in their construction, with $20,000,000 of property values. Ac- cording to Special Agent C. C. Georgeson, there are more than 100,000 square miles which can be utilized for pasture and cul- ture, as hardy vegetables, grains, and forage crops, and capable of supporting at the most conservative estimate a population of three millions. The principal mountain peaks are described by Mr. R. H. Sargent of the Geological Survey, the adventurous work of marking the boundary by Mr. T. Riggs, jr., chief of one of the survey par- ties, and the wonderful big game by Mr. W. H. Osgood of the Biological Survey. Other articles are upon the great indus- trial development of the States of Oregon and Washington by Mr. N. H. Darton of the yeological Survey, some giant fishes of the sea by Deputy Commissioner H. M. Smith, and the tallest tree that grows, the euca- lyptus, which is known to have reached the height of 480 feet. The numerous illustra- tions are as usual in this magazine most in- teresting and striking in their excellence and suggestiveness. The July number of the American Journal of International Law opens properly with the introductory official address of Senator Root as president of the American Society of International Law, at the annual meeting held last April in Washington. In a re- cent issue, former Associate Supreme Court Justice Brown had a paper on the same theme—in substance, the practicabil- ity of leaving to the adjudication of an in- ternational tribunal international ques- tions on which the highest courts of the states interested as parties have rendered judgments. Doubts had been expressed, whether it was consistent with national sovereignty for a Power to submit such questions to any extraneous. tribunal. Justice Brown thought it might be done without derogating from the sovereignty or dignity of the nations participating in the submission; and Mr. Root reaches the same conclusion. Assuming that each party to an international controversy seeks the doing of justice, and that national courts, however determined to do justice, may unconsciously favor their own na- tionalities, and that their decisions may not be accepted by the opposing parties who may seek an ulterior adjudication, he sees no greater inconsistency in a nation’s sub- mitting such a question to an international tribunal for adjustment than there was in sovereign States of the American Union assenting to a constitution under which questions between themselves or their citi- zens should be submitted to a national supreme court for final decision. An en- lightening paper follows, on how China administers her foreign affairs. Barry Gilbert presents a paper of practical] im- portance, especially for our ministers and consuls abroad, on the practice of granting asylum in our legations and consulates; a subject that has given our State Department anxious thought on more than one occasion. The Barrundia episode and the strenuosity of Minister Egan will occur to many. In a single final page, Mr. Gilbert summarizes the attitude of our government in a very comprehen- sive way. In fact, the whole article ought to be In the files of American representa- tives abroad, with the instructions which [Vol. 89, No. 2302 venient. One deduction is especially sig- nificant: the right of asylum can never be properly invoked to harbor criminals and offenders against the laws, when they are demanded by proper authorities in regular legal proceedings. C. H. Stockton’s paper on the London International Naval Confer- ence discusses, among other topics, the question of contraband, appending a list of articles positively contraband, and one of such as are conditionally contraband. A still more elaborate paper, the second nart of which now appears, discusses the most-favored-nation clause of treaties. The final part, yet to appear, is to con- sider the most-favored-nation relations of the United States and Germany—a thor- oughly practical question. Another volume, in the tasteful green and gilt series, issued by the Oxford University Press, contains ‘“‘De Quincey’s Literary Crit- icism,” edited with an introduction by H. Darbishire. The editor’s remarks on De Quincey as a critic are clear and discrim- inating, and call attention to the main threads running through the work of one, who, as Mr. Darbishire says, is preéminently “‘to be regarded as critic and creator of romantic art.’”’ The faults of De Quincey’s method are only too visible. They may, perhaps, be summed up in the spirit of recklessness and boastfulness. Too often he makes dogmatic statements, which on another page he just as dogmatically controverts. It gives one an odd sensation, for instance, to read, in his otherwise ad- mirable comments on the supposed ‘“‘correct- ness” of Pone, that the misuse of the word “attend” in the line “For him thou oft hast bid the world attend’’ would alone »~rove Pope’s incorrectness, and then, on am other page, to find De Quincey himself em- ploying the word in this very sense. His boastfulness shows itself in constant prom- ises of deep inquisition into the philosophy of some subject which has baffled all other critics, when, as a matter of fact, his own argument trails off into the merely common- place. Both his boastfulness and his reck- lessness lead him into a kind of magnificent paradox, as when (in one essay; elsewhere he takes the contrary stand) he bases his praise of Pope on that poet’s passion in “Bloisa to Abelard,” and denies him force in personal satire. Were it not for this note of paradox, the essay, by setting forth the genuinely poetical aspect of Pope’s work, would be a desirable corrective to much of the detraction aimed at him since the days of Wordsworth. But paradox does not always rule in De Quincey’s writing. His brief note ‘‘On the Knocking at the Gate in Macbeth” leads, as Mr. Darbishire points out, to the very heart of critical procedure. And, to descend to smaller things, almost anything could be forgiven a critic who has so keenly anticipated one of the excesses of modern scholarship as De Quincey has done in these few lines: It is a natural resource that whatsoever we find it difficult to investigate as a result, we endeavour to follow as a growth; failing analytically to probe its nature, historically we seek relief to our perplexities by tracing its origin. Not able to assign the elements of its theory, we endeavour to detect them in the stages of its development. “Col. John Quincy of Mount Wollaston, 1689-1767," contains the addresses made at a celebration in Quincy, in February, 1908, in honor of the man from whom the town was named. The career of the provincial every one is supposed to have always con- colonel can be given only in shadowy out-
Page 13
Aug. 12, 1909] line, for his papers were lost or destroyed. Yet he played an important part in his time, serving long in the Legislature as Speaker, and later in the Governor's Council, and suffered for his political opinions. For it so happened that Colman’s Land Bank was formed when Quincy was at the height of his popularity. His constituents were car- ried away by the liberal promises of pros- perity it held out to them, and turned from Quincy, whose common sense warned him against the plausible scheme of making the community rich by issuing paper money. He was set aside, and when the bank party threatened to use force to overbear the de- termined hostility and arbitrary measures of Governor Belcher, Quincy was placed in charge of the government forces. He lived long enough to be again restored to popu- lar favor, and served his country well for many years after the bank plan had re- sulted in confusion. The Rev. Daniel M. Wilson has made an interesting sketch of this incident, and in collaboration with Charles Francis Adams describes Quincy as it came into existence as a settlement. Of high interest, too, are Mr. Adams’s remarks on the historical vagueness of the provincial period in Massachusetts when compared to the colonial and Revolutionary periods, and the little reputation made by the leading actors. The volume is illustrated, and is published by the Quincy (Mass.) Historical Society. Canon and Mrs. S. A. Barnett have col- lected into a volume entitled ‘Towards Social Reform’ (Macmillan) papers orig- inally published in various magazines. The authors know from personal experience what they are talking about, for they have lived and worked among the London pwor for thirty-five years. Their point of view is steadily that of practical improvement, and they display remarkable freedom both from doctrinaire prepossessions and hu- manitarian illusions. Along with sympa- thetic appreciation of the need for chari- table endeavor they vigorously oppose the charity that degrades. It is pointed out that no social discipline can be effective so long as ‘casual jobs, night shelters, and free breakfasts make it possible for peo- ple to have the opportunity to enjoy the license and idleness of a loafing life.’’ Al- though for American readers, the work suffers from its localized outlook, yet its consideration of social problems is so sen- sible and judicious that it may be con- sulted to advantage by all interested in social service. “Essays and Addresses,’’ by Edwin Bur- ritt Smith (McClurg & Co.), is a dignified memorial of a life dedicated to public ser- vice. It contains various papers upon a variety of subjects, preceded by an intro- ductory appreciation of the dead publicist by his friend, Mr. George Laban Paddock. The contents are sub-divided into five gen- eral groups: Chicago and Illinois, devoted to State and civic issues; Municipal Gov- ernment, dealing with municipal ques- tions generally; The Nation, and Anti- Imperialism,”’ both concerned mainly with our new political departure in the field of colonial empire; and Miscellaneous Pa- pers, in which the economic problem of the Trusts is, perhaps, the most important. Mr. Smith’s all too brief career finds in this exposition of his thought both a pathetic and an inspiring monument He was a ‘The Nation. patriot of the intellectual type with following the civium prava jubentium He the old-fashioned democracy ation of Independence. He never reconciled himself to “necessity, the tyrants’ plea,” when it traversed the ideal equality of hu- man rights. He refused to confine demoe- racy to geographical limits, or to particular stages of civilization. He forswore party allegiance when he deemed that independ- ence of party pointed the way to the public good. Originally a Republican, he sup- ported Mr. Cleveland's candidacy in 1884 and again in 1892. In 1896 he was chair- man of the Illinois Sound Money League, and a member of the national convention which nominated Palmer and Buckner. His later public activities were largely devoted to the anti-Imperialist movement. He was perhaps dominated at the outset somewhat too completely by his a priori convictions upon matters of public law, and too opti- mistic in his attempted blending of the Austinian theory of sovereignty with an idealistic adherence to the doctrine of nat- ural rights. But where he came into most direct contact with the realities of political life, his views were wholly admirable. Thus in the essay on “Representative Govern- ment,” he says sagely: ‘‘The remedy for ex- isting ills is not further checks and bal- ances. We already spend too much energy in merely operating the machinery of gov- ernment, Its agencies must be simplified and made more directly responsive to pub- lic opinion.” Pathetic is the paper on “American Ideals,” revised in part in his last days, where he says, doubtless with a not content prevailing sentiment believed in of the Declar- also backward glance upon his own exacting labors: No one, we had supposed, cared any longer to deny that every daughter of the Confederacy was fair and every son brave, but it has been reserved for T. C. DeLeon to offer, in his “Belles, beaux, and Brains of the 60's” (G. W. Dillingham Compapy), incontestable proof of the fact. Here will be found set down, in no order what- ever, the name of apparently every belle who ever won the least recognition as such in the later ante-bellum South, together with an account of her pedigree, her suit- ors and dance partners, her husband or husbands, and her children and relatives living or dead. As a succession of flash- light views of the social life of Richmond during the war, the book not without value, and its reproductions of contem- porary pictures are interesting; but a work which is neither history, nor biography, nor genealogy, nor reminiscence, but an undiscriminating mixture of all four, Is hard to classify We cannot but wonder that the publishers should have allowed a volume of 464 pages, containing an ave- rage of 20 proper names to a page. to go out without an index The national committee, appointed three gathering and of the an exten years ago for the purpose of arranging material for the Risorgimento, has in preparation sive bibliography of related matter, includ- ing manuscripts, and other publications, based upon the alphabetical catalogue compiled by the Biblioteca Vit- history newspapers, torio Emanuele (which comprises, however, only works issued previous to 1885) and upon the partial lists of Fiorini and of Mazzatinti There will be supplementary 139 lists arranged for regions, events, and in- dividuals Some documents of interest are brought together by Prof. Hermann Gollancz in his “Translations from Hebrew and Aramaic” (London: Luzac & Co.). In the five or six centuries following the completion of the Talmud Jewish scholars did much serious work, grammatical, legal, and literary; but there was a popular demand for lighter matter, and it is matter of this sort that is offered in the present volume. The Tar- gum or Aramaic paraphrase of the Biblical “Song of Songs” is a frankly allegorical interpretation of the book, having no rele- tion to its real meaning, and throughout tame and tiresome—the changes are rung on the way in which Jehovah, the bride- groom, watches over and blesses Israel, the bride; its value lies in the picture it gives of passionate and confident patriotism. “The Book of the Apple” is a dialogue in which the eminent sage Aristotle on his deathbed (sustained by the scent of an apple) discourses to the assembled wise men on immortality and the excellence of philosophy—a feeble imitation of the Phado, the only point of interest in its argument being the reply to the assertion that suicide would be an easy and proper way of gaining the joys of immortality. The ‘Story of the Ten Jewish Martyrs,’ @ legendary imitation of the episode in Sec- ond Maccabees, contains one curious bit of mythology—the account of the birth of the high priest Ishmael, famous for his beeuty of person; the Almighty, taking pity on his pious mother, who was barren, sent Ga- briel to take the form of her husband and become the father of Ishmael Belief in supernatural not uncommon among the Semitic peasants of Syria, but it is surprising to meet it in a Jewish mid- rash otherwise of a serious nature; the ex- istence of such beliefs in certain parts of the Jewish world, however, is hardly to be questioned. In an appendix the author gives a medieval Hebrew elegy on the “Ten Martyrs," paraphrased by Prof. Israel! Gol- lancz. The last piece in the volume ig “A Dialogue on Games of Chance,”’ by Leo de Modena, an Ltalian Jewish scholar who liv- parentage is ed 1571-1648. Arguments for and against gambling are given, those of the former sort being the more elaborate and forcible, though the conclusion condemns the practice. Leo was an unstable character, and himself fell a victim to the passion whose charms he so well describes. In rendering the first Hebrew plece, the “Book of the Apple,"’ Professor Gollancz has collated various printed versions and manuscripts; the secend transia- tion, the “‘Martyrs,”’ is from @ manuscript in his possession. The Hebrew text of the third piece has been printed several times, and has been rendered into English by Chilmead (1650) and Ockley (1707). Five instructive lectures constitute the contents of the latest work of Wilhelm Win- delband, entitled “Die Philosophie im deutschen Geistesleben des XIX Jahrhun- derts” (Tibingen: J. C. B. Mohr). Among the subjects discussed are the msthetico- philosophical Pamdagogics of to-day; Ro- manticism and Hegelianism; Irrationalism, Materialism and Pessimism; Positividm, Historicism, and Psychologism; the modern Value-problem (Wertproblem), and the Re- turn to Idealism. several
Page 14
140 Gustav Wustmann’s “Aus Leipzig’s Ver- gangenheit"” (Leipzig: Fr. Wil. Grunow), the third volume in a series commenced in 1855, comes out aptly for the celebration of the university. It deals with the history of art, theatre, music, and literature in Leip- zig, and offers interesting reminiscences of the Schumanns, Gellert, Bach, Geissler, and others, together with reproductions of rare portraits ‘Das moderne Belgien” is the title of a large octavo volume by G. Sidsteen, pre- senting not only the works of architecture and art and the odd customs of the people found in the usual book on Belgium, but discussing, from the standpoint of a na- the industrial, economic, and political Nearly 150 text- tive, conditions in that country illustrations, and 19 full-page engravings from late phcetographs and realistic sketch- es from life assist in affording a glimpse of the land and people as they are (Berlin: Hermann Paetel) The aeath is announced of Eugéne Rol- land, founder of the Mélusine, a journal de- voted to folklore, and frequent contributor to La Revue critique @histoire and to Ro- mania. He was born at Metz in 1846. From Bad Nauheim comes the news of the deeth of Gustav Karpeles, the Heine author.ty, at the age of sixty Besides his erittical edition of Heine's works he wrot Heine und das Judentum,” “Frauen in der jiidischen Literatur,” “Geschichte der judischen Literatur,” “Heine und seine Zeitgenossen,” etc THE SERIOUS PEPYS. Samuel Pepys: Administrator, Observer, Gossip. By E. Hallam Moorhouse. New York. E. P. Dutton & Co. $3 net. It is now some ninety years since the Hon. Rey. Neville, head of Magdalene College, Cambridge, put into Lord Grenville’s hands six volumes of cipher manuscript from the library bequeathed the college a century before by one of her sons, Samuel Pepys, some- of the Admiralty to Charles Il and James II. There was lit- tle enough in the appearance of the ma- terial, or in the career of its author and donor, which gave promise of anything remarkable in the manuscript. Pepys was a man eminent, indeed, in his day and profession as a naval administrator and with some reputation as a virtuoso, Beside his position in the admiralty, he had held other posts of honor and prof- it. He had been member and treasurer of the Tangier Commission, surveyor-gen- eral of the Victualling Office, member of Parliament and president of the Royal Society. He had been a patron of art, literature, music, and the drama, and had collected the books and manuscripts which he left to his college. He had pro- jected history of the navy, which and George time Secretary a had never been completed, and had in- terested himself in various philanthrop- ic projects, In short, he had lived a full and useful life, notable for its public services and its honorable worldly suc- The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2302 — in biographical dictionaries, and even a line and a half in Hume, who noted that “The administration of the admir- alty under Pepys is still regarded as a model of order and economy.” For the son of a tailor, who had risen chiefly by his own efforts, this may be reckoned no small achievement; ye~ it gave little promise of literary distinc- tion. Whatever writing the secretary was known to have done was enshrined in the dusty and neglected files of ‘he navy office and in the correspondeuce he had presented to his college. ‘Lhe man whom Monck had called the rignt- hand of the navy was fairly on the way to being forgotten, when, six years after it was unearthed, the “Diary of Samuel Pepys” appeared, edited by the Rev. John Smith. With that was effects. a revolution in posthumous fame, un- parelleled in literary history; there emerged from the obscurity of more than a century, not, as might have been ex- pected, merely an able man of affairs, but a_ personality. At one bound, Pepys sprang to the world-wide publicity of ¢ prince of diarists. Since then, the industry and _ in- genuity of Bright and Braybrooke and Wheatley have given us all in any way fit for publication of the document which Smith issued only in part. To his diary, Pepys had confided his every thought and motive and action, high and low, good and bad, trivial and important. The result is not merely unique in literature, but almost, if not quite, in life itself. It might be sup- posed, therefore, that his frankness would not only endear him to his read- ers, but would give him a place in their esteem, comparable to that he occupied in the minds of his contemporaries. In some measure, this is true. It would be hard to bring together a longer list of appreciations of any man than the one we have of Pepys. Yet the spectacle of a man honest enough to set down his in- most thoughts, even in the decent garb of a cipher, is so contrary to those in- stincts which lead us to conceal our weaknesses, not only from our fellows, but from ourselves, that it has in no small measure, even to those who love him, endangered Pepys’s real strength and position. The same qualities which make his diary immortal have decreas- ed the rightful respect for its author. For we are apt to forget that to his own generation there was no such man as the Pepys of the diary. Amid its silks and laces, its domestic secrets, its days of good cheer and nights at the piay, we are apt to lose sight of the serious side of the man who wrote it. Even to- day the reader of the diary is not apt to delve into the calendars of state papers or of Pepys’s own papers. To previous generations this was quite impossible. The result is that most persons, even among those who have written of him, cess. These had’ won for him a place like. Coleridge, who had little or no knowledge of his serious work, spoke of him as a “pollard” man, without a top, but the sturdier in the lower branches for that. Lowell and Stevenson, to note but a few great ones among many, wrote in the same strain. Yet without the knowledge of Pepys’s official life and acts it is impossible to estimate the man fairly. The quality of which crit- ics and essayists have felt the lack, a higher motive, a less materialistic phil- osophy, may, indeed, to the careful ob- server, knowing his official record, ap- pear in his diary. Yet in the main it is not to be found there, but in the place one might least expect to find it: in those dry calendars, where is re vealed his devotion to his work, and, through that, to his country. When, nearly forty years ago, an en- lightened government began to issue cal- endars of the state papers for the Restoration period, it early became ap- parent that the famous diarist had play- ed a more important part in public af- fairs than had been imagined. ‘With the greater attention since paid to naval history, his fame has grown, and, of late, with the appearance of the three- volume catalogue of his papers in Mag- dalene College,the Navy Records Society has done much to increase the knowl- edge of the secretary. It is not too much to say that, had the diary never been written, we should now have very considerable information regarding him, and that he would have fairly recovered his true position in the history of his time. Hereafter our knowledge may be expected to increase, since we may hope for the appearance of his “Navalia,” nis memoirs, and memoranda, and may look forward to having, in something like complete form, the record of a man whose life is practically the history of the English navy for more than twenty years. As we go through the mass of his cor- respondence, as we read his letters and memoranda regarding the navy, as we see the operation and results of his methods, we can see that behind the apparently petty and even childlike sim- plicity of the diary there stands a man, shrewd; cautious, able, conscientious, honest, and brave, wholly devoted to his service and his government. To the appreciation of this world’s goods and pleasures, to the doctrines of Polonius and Franklin, he added a sense of pub lic duty and an unremitting industry in public service which lifts him above the lower levels of his diary and of his time. He represented a class not un- common during the Restoration, yet not wholly typical of it: the left-over Puri- tans, trained in the sterner and more ef- ficient school of Cromwell, on whom, amid the corruption and extravagance of a weak and dissolute court, the bur- dens of state rested. “If it comes to have had no idea of what Pepys was fighting,” observed one of Pepys’s
Page 15
friends to him, at a critical time, “the King must rely on the old party”; and this proved throughout scarcely less true of administration. Whatever its faults, the Cromwellian régime had one virtue which came out strikingly under its successor: it bred strong men. They were not always immaculate, and the most was made of their failings by their royalist rivals. Men have written of Pepys, for instance, as if he were a Rochester or a Sedley. But the compar- ison reveals the gulf fixed between the two classes. One need not, indeed, hold, biographer-like, a briéf for Pepys, at- tributing his vices to his age and his virtues to himself, to do him the jus- tice that, in a sense, he has denied him- self. In the great crisis of the Plague he stuck to his post in daily peril of his life, and, with a few kindred spir- its, did his share in carrying on the bus- iness of the state when all who could— Society, as usual, first—had fled. Be- fore a hostile House, hungry for ven- geance for a mismanaged war, he de- fended his service, his colleagues, and himself, with ability and success. He bearded Prince Rupert before the Board for the good of the service; he even chided his patron for improprieties un- worthy of his station. Throughout he was horribly afraid, but he was seldom too frightened to do his duty. Proud of his success in life, of his good clothes, his handsome house, his pretty wife, the respect of his associates, his vanity was neither uncommon nor unhealthy. Com- pared with the morbid psychology of certain so-called “Confessions,” compar- ed with what Disraeli, or a more recent American political personage, might have written, had either ventured on so intimate a chronicle, we may well stand | amazed at his moderation. That he was | a gossip is refuted by the confidences | reposed in him, his reputation as a safe man of affairs, his rise to responsible position, above all, by the diary itself. Only there was his confidence fully bestowed. That it reveals him a mass of inconsistencies is but another way of saying he was human. The present biography takes its place, therefore, as a part of the Pepysian renaissance and is at once timely and useful. In some measure, it represents the advance of our knowledge since Wheatley’s volume, or even the article by Stephen in the “Dictionary of Na- tional Biography,” filling in the lacunz of the one and elaborating the details of the other. The author has not con- fined herself to the diarist, but has told us much besides about the secretary. And though the book contains no great amount of material which can be called absolutely new, it has brought together much hitherto not easily accessible, in- cluded, all found, in the usual accounts, and added something beside. It is, in short, the best account of Pepys which has yet appeared. it is well and care- The Nation. fully done, almost invariably accurate, clear, painstaking, and interesting. And though it may not be final or definite, that is a result practically impossible at this time. It is written in the spirit of Pepys’s motto, which encircles his portrait by Kneller: Mens cujusque is est quisque. But one may fairly hope that in the light of broader knowledge we shall some day have a biography written less in the light of his life than in that of his works, which shall have as its motto: “Seest thou a man diligent in his business, he shall stand before kings.”” What we need is still more of the and of the gossip, more of the calendars and less of the diary, more of the navy office and less of the hours outside. In no gree, indeed, Miss Moorhouse has given us this. But to say of one of the most important periods of life that to write it in detail would be to write a history of the navy, in a sense begs the It from secretary less small de- his is hard to get question. away tne diary. If the period it covers bulks | larger here than the later and greater years of his life, one may, at least, be grateful that so much of those later years is included. We should Wave been glad to have a much-needed bibliogra- phy of Pepys included here, some foot- | notes, and an adequate index. For the | rest, we welcome this volume as a sub- | stantal sign of a reviving and better in- tormed interest in a man who has many holds upon our interest CURRENT FICTION The Score. By Lucas Malet. New York E. P. Dutton & Co “The Score’ is not the title of a nov el, or of either of the tales which give this volume respectable bulk. Standing, as the accompanying motto explains it, for the balance of good and ill in hu man character and experience, it might serve as title for any serious work of fiction. One must admit off-hand the claim to respectful consideration of any- thing Mrs. Harrison may It impossible to Richard Calmady” “The Far Hori- zon” as belonging to the common mer chantable order of current fiction. If proof were needed of the sobriety of this writer’s purpose, it might be found in her failure to follow up the success of “Sir Richard Calmady” by carry- ing the method a little farther. In that novel, she had made no deliberate ap- peal to the prurient mind, but her startling frankness no doubt had something to do with the size of her audience. She reaped the dubious re- ward of the English writer who per- mits himself to forget the young per- son. Regretful consciousness of this may have influenced her towards great- er reticence in her subsequent work. “The Far Horizon” must have disap- do is or 141 pointed the less desirable element among her readers. It retained the dis- abilities of the former book, the dif- fuseness, the self-consciousness of man- ner, the superfluities. The Nation ie corded its opinion that by omission and condensation “the novel might be gain- fully reduced to, say, one-fourth its present bulk.” The more cbaracteristic of the two stories, however, which are here bound together leaves nothing to desired in point of compactness. It presents our old friend Poppy St. John in a crucial moment of her later experience. She is now a successful star, thanks, in part, to the plays which have been written for her by that elegant author and man of the world, Antony Hammond. lor ten years their friendship and inter- dependence have been strong and real But Poppy the of her womanhood, and not so absolute in her dedication to friendship as she thinks This is the story of her test- If in style be is in ripeness herself. ing and final self-conquest it is still marred here and there by a touch of petty artifice, an excess of verbal adroitness, in substance it Is sound and simple. The second of the tales Miserere Nobis,” is of a very different sort. It is virtually what Browning used to call “dramatic ro mance,” the ceath-bed confession of a young parricide. From firsi to last, it has the air of a translation or para- phrase. Verse seems almost necessary | to 1 narrative pitched in so intense a key. One 1s tempted to hazard the guess that the author may have planned or begun this story as a poem; in its prose form, it is, to say the truth, strained | ed. regard a book like “Sir | and ineffective By Henry Milner Houghton Mifflin Dragon's Blood Rideout Co This we can but feel to be a sad come cown for Mr. Rideout. Only the other day a Nation contributor was speaking of him as one of the younger American writers from whom much might be hop- The remark seemed to be based upon his first book, “Beached Keels,” which contained at least two remarka- ble tales, or studies, of life on the New England coast. They were intense, real- stic, sombre, not easy to forget. Why has he done nothing more of the kind? Was it just a “pocket,” or did the vein turn out to be unprofitable? His sec- ond book, “Admiral’s Light,” was a rather tamely idyllic story—a short story attenuated into a novel—with still the New England coast setting, but with the prevailing flavor of conventional! ju- venile romance. For the rest, it was somewhat self-consciously stylistic: there was an experimental air about the whole thing. Well, some of us may have thought, he is trying his hand, feeling his way; we shall get something powerful next. Boston
Page 16
142 And now comes “Dragon's Blood’’— another experiment, and in what unex- pected direction! It is nothing more less than a blood-and-thunder ro- mance of impossible adventure. Such small flavor of novelty as it has is due to its setting. The action takes place in a forlorn and remote outpost of West- ern civilization, a Chinese coast-town where the only Europeans are a half- dozen agents of commercial houses, chiefly English and German, a French doctor, and a Protestant missionary, with his wife and daughter. There is also a female villain, wife of one of the agents. The missionary has made con- verts, and therefore enemies. Feeling against the foreign devils is stirred up by a wicked mandarin, who has his own ends to serve. Up to the eve of the actual outbreak the narrative has vigor and apparent verisimilitude. The lady-villain is rather preposterous in her obviousness, as is the gentleman- villain, who is not unnaturally arranged to be the Frenchman. But the others are sufficiently plausible. However, the sight of blood turns the writer quite mad, and he proceeds to involve all his persons, offensive and inoffensive, in a series of childishly absurd incidents in- vented for their own sake. The result is what is commonly called “a rattling good story,” and this, we suppose, is what Mr. Rideout intended. Let us hope that it will not be so indecently success- ful as to tempt him permanently from the paths of sensible fiction or By Frederic L. C A Gentleman of Quality. Van Rensselaer Dey. Boston: Page & Co. The story of the doubles and of the confusion arising from their apparent identity is one of the oldest in the world’s treasury of fiction. But it is always capable of fresh rendering, al ways ready to be brought to date, with the accessories proper to each succes- sive generation. The present version is surprisingly adroit and complete, so far as plot is concerned, and this (con- sidering the kind of story) palliates, if it does not excuse, some crudeness of manner. The dialogue is awkward and unnatural, and in consequence it is hard to believe in the flesh-and-blood reality of the speakers. But the springs af ac- tion are sound, and the incidents, how- ever strange, have as much plausibility as the nature of the affair demands. For a wife to insist, against his protesta- tions, that a stranger is her husband, may carry the strain upon credulity to the breaking-point, especially when the husband is English and the stranger American. On the other hand, when the Americanism of the stranger turns out to be a mere matter of chance up- bringing, and he Is revealed as the long- lost twin-brother of the real husband, a ‘The Nation. the apparent absurdity of much of the preceding incident. Michael Thwaites’s Wife. By Miriam Michelson. New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. Mr. Jerome K. Jerome, in his excel- lent book on the stage, has pointed out that by one of the oldest of dramatic conventions a discontented wife may leave the room, put on a new apron, and return to apply for the position of gov- erness to her own children. Now and then, when the new governess does up her hair in a particular fashion, the de- serted husband finds himself strongly reminded of his wife. Upon such prob- abilities the lively author of “In a Bish- op’s Carriage” and “The Madigans” as built up her latest story. When the bad twin-sister runs away from her husband, the saintly twin-sister, under the stress of circumstances, temporarily assumes the réle of wife to Michael Thwaites, whose failing eyesight, it must be con- fessed, makes deception in his case more probable than in the case of the reader. Developed in the proper spirit, the sub- ject of double or mistaken personality can make good melodrama. But, uprfor- tunately, Miss Michelson seems to have taken her plot too seriously. At differ- ent times she tries to write like George Eliot, Mrs. Humphry Ward, Robert Her- rick, and Frank Norris, when she should have consistently tried to write like Robert W. Chambers. The Story of the Pharaohs. By the Rev. James Baikie, F.R.A.S. With 32 full-page illustrations from photo- graphs, 48 iliustrations in the text, and two maps. New York: The Mac- millan Co. $2.50 net. The Queens of Egypt. By Janet R. But- tles. With a preface by Prof. G. Mas- pero. Illustrated. New York: D. Ap- pleton & Co. $3 net. The Exploration of Egypt and the Old Testament. By J. Garrow Duncan, B.D. With 100 illustrations from pho- tographs. New York: Fleming H. Revell. $1.50 net. These three volumes are the product of non-specialists, and possess the faults of their virtues, though they vary great- ly in quality. In Mr. Baikie’s history we have the conscientious effort of a cultivated writer who is obliged, how: ever, to take all his results at second hand. He has furnished an attractive volume which reads well. In his effort to present the two schools of chronol- ogy fairly, he even heads the pages in the earlier section of his book with the widely divergent dates of both systems. This is to ignore the fact that the older systeni is rapidly dying and doomed to disappear. In the important matter of the use of sources, he has sometimes mitigating lI'ght is ‘thrown back upon [ Vol. 89, No. 2302 the “Records of the Past,” which pre- sent the science of a generation ago, or taking the date of the marriage of Amenhotep III from Budge, whose inac- curacy is always such that he repre- sents no science whatever, either obso- lete or modern. Mr. Baikie omits Nubia on his map, which is unfortunate in view of the fact that Egypt’s only per- manent conquests were in the south. In “The Queens of Egypt,” by Miss Buttles, we have a more pretentious vol- ume than that of Mr. Baikie, with an introduction written by Professor Mas- pero. As the earliest women of histor- ical importance whose life and achieve- ments are in some measure preserved to us, the queens of Egypt offer an in- teresting and an important theme. But the plan of the book is faulty. As so many of the queens accomplished no- thing, and as, indeed, there is only one queen, Hatshepsut, of whose deeds we have full information, Miss Buttles’s book is necessarily a loose and discon- nected series of reports of archzologi- cal discoveries, interspersed with lists of monuments of the queens. Besides that of Hatshepsut, not a single person- ality capable of analysis emerges. Miss Buttles displays commendable industry in the use of sources, but lamentable failure to employ the latest form in which they are accessible. She quotes only Naville on her most important queen, Hatshepsut, and thus obtains translations and views representing the Egyptology of fifty years since. Or, she employs the “Records of the Past,” and thus reports that the city of “Zaru,” given to Queen Tiy by Amenhotep III, with its huge pleasure-lake, was situat- ed in the Delta, although we have long since known that its name is not “Zaru,” and that it was situated far up the river at Thebes. Graver errors result from un- familiarity with the later translations of the sources. It is even stated (p. 113) that under Amenhotep III the Egyptians conquered the entire valley of the Euphrates, an old misunderstand- ing which was exploded forty years ago. Perhaps Miss Buttles may be pardoned here, as she obtained the surprising fact from the “History of Egypt,” by New- berry and Garstang, who in turn took it from Petrie. If the Egyptian monu- ments have not shown clearly that the Pharaohs never conquered the entire Euphrates valley, the Amarna letters, with their display of friendly correspon- dence between the kings of Babylonia and those of Egypt at this very time, should settle the question forever. But Miss Buttles knows nothing of Winck- ler’s edition of the Amarna letters, long since to be had in English, much less of the more recent work of Knudtzon. Had her book been planned as the his- tory of women in the Nile Valley, their position, influence, and achievements, and the proper sources in modern form been unfortunate in his selection, using employed, she might have supplied a
Page 17
Aug. 12, 1909 coherent and highly useful but still un- written chapter in the story of woman. Mr. Duncan’s book is a pale reflection of the views of Petrie. It contains in- teresting and readable accounts of ex- per‘ences in the field at Petrie’s camp, but is entirely without value in solving any of those problems of the Old Testa- ment which are involved in Egyptian discovery. Indeed, Mr. Duncan has not even perceived the existence of these problems. He is entirely innocent of any critical knowledge of the Old Testa- ment. The following quotation is such delightful evidence of his state of mind that it is worth reading—for reasons hardly appreciable by the author him- self: Since the Bible states that Joseph was buried in Egypt, and his bones removed to Canaan at the Exodus, somewhere in this neighborhood there ought to be found an empty sarcophagus, or mummy coffin, in- scribed with the names, titles, and honors of Joseph. No such tomb has yet been dis- covered, but it is much more likely to be found in the cemetery of Heliopolis (On), where Joseph is understood to have resid- ed, than in the district of Goshen. After this, we do not wonder that the garrison of “240,000” men, stationed at Avaris, according to Manetho (not Jo- sephus, as Mr. Duncan states), is ac- cepted as a fact. We are, therefore, stil] without the much-needed volume by a competent scholar on the relations of Egypt and the Hebrews. The Hague Peace Conferences of 1899 and 1907. By James Brown Scott. Balti- more: The Johns Hopkins Pres; 2 vols. $5. Official Report of the Seventeenth Uni- versal Congress of Peace. London: The National Council of Peace Socie- ties. The cynically inclined will accept Mr. Scott’s two bulky volumes of nearly 900 pages each as admirably symbolic of their subject. They stand for two vreat world congresses which gathered after long preparation, debated profound »rob- lems at vast length, and dispersed, |«av- ing the world very much where it was before. But the cynical point of view on this subject of universal peace ‘s an easy one to take, as Mr. Scott pints out. Any measure of accomplishment compared with a large purpose mus! «p- pear ridiculous. “Congresses of | eace that have put in their time defining the laws of war,” sneer the cynics. “A con- gress of equals whose action cann«t be forced and whose decisions mus: be unanimous,” answers the jurist; “let us be thankful for what we can get.” That is the attitude of Mr. Scott, America’s technical delegate to the second Hague Conference, whose lectures before the Johns Hopkins University make u” our first volume. His second is given over entirely to the documents of the cofer- ences. These, with the exception of one The Nation. important paper, were published last year by Mr. Scott under the auspices of the International School of Peace, and commented on in the Nation of De- cember 10. Little of significanc: has escaped our author. First, here are your origina] treaties and convention. Secondly, you get nearly 150 pages of condensed commentary on the two cua- ferences. Lastly, you have an expanded account of 750 pages, authoritative aad circumstantial. The growth of international juristic comity, the addition of an article or a clause to the body of international law, are, to the specialist, things worth while. But Mr. Scott is aware that pub- lic opinion was concerned, not with in- ternational law, but with the limitation of the world’s armaments and with the establishment of arbitration. Well, even here there is some gain to reckon If the limitation of armaments was dis- missed at The Hague as unripe for crac- tical consideration, there is at least the formal pronouncement of the nations that the limitation of armaments is eminently desirable. If the principle of arbitration has made painful prozress with its Permanent Arbitration Court of 1899 that was not at all a court, but a long list of eminent persons to whom the nations, if they desired, might refer their troubles; and if the Court of Ar- bitral Justice of 1907 was a court with a general form of procedure and juages’ salaries, but no judges, the fact re- mains that from the first conference to the second the gain was so cons dera- ble that the ultimate establishment of a real court with real judges and real functions must be declared inevi:able. Herein our author, like his former chief, Mr. Elihu Root, whom he copicusly quotes, finds a basis for optimism: the habit of peace is growing. The first Con- ference came as a surprise and a p"zzle. But the first Conference already looked forward to a second Conference, j.1st as that second assembly spoke of con- ferences to follow. Mr. Scott is willing to wait. As long as the idea of tuter- national arbitration is making headway, other improvements can bide their time The nations’ refusal to disarm he fiuds quite natural: As long as a resort set- to force for the tlement of international difficulties is re- garded as proper, if not the only and reasonable expedient, no nation 1s likely to expose itself to strong, aggressive, and not overscrupulous neighbors by depriving it- self of the recognized means of protection and self-assertion. The means of warfare and the preparations for war will exist un- til a substitute for war be proposed which is not only reasonable in itself, but which is so reasonable that its non-acceptance would be unreasonable That is, we may keep our armies and navies, and yet sincerely and effectively work for peace. The nations, our writer speaks ot. To us it seems imperative to draw a dis- 143 tinction between nations and govern- ments. When Mr. Scott, in pall‘ation of what the two Conferences failed to accomplish, would rehearse the factors that are now working for peace he must refer to the interdependence of nations: the influence of internat!'onal commerce; “good understanding based upon knowledge and sympathy”; peace societies, international congresses con- ferences, associations, unions; the spread of representative governnt.ent; the growing sense of the uselessnees of war: and the growing sentiment tn fa- vor of arbitration. Now, these are all factors of importance; but they are, in a way, manifestations of national and not of governmental sentiment. It is only as the growing dread of war among the nations urges their governments on the road to peace that we can expect peace conferences, after long weels of high pleading and arguing, not to be brought up sharp against a governn:ent- al non possumus. The report of the Universal Peace Congress which met in London in the summer of 1908, deals in detail with just such a popular movement as Mr. Scott had in mind when he enumerate? his factors of universal peace. English Literature in the Nineteenth Century. By Laurie Magnus. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $2 net. Aside from the manuals which inform the schoolboy that Gower wrote in three languages and that Milton preceded Pope and was a greater writer, there are two rare types of literary history of distinct usefulness and interest—the purely bibliographical and the purely critical. The one would record, say, in the nineteenth century, all the authors of any importance and all their books with carefully ascertained dates and 4 brief statement of contents. The other would regard the nineteenth century as a great complex personality, would estl- mate the forces of ite heredity and en- vironment, trace the development of its ideas and its powers and modes of ex pression, and judgment upon the period in the light of other periods and other national literatures. The first type demands great industry and accuracy; the second demands immense industry, erudition, sympathy, discrimination, and Unfortunately, neither of these types flourishes among us in its purity. Our literary historians for the most part, feeling their weakness on both sides, take a shuffling middle course, leaving thoroughgoine bibliography to the Germans, and mingling with desul- tory criticism, fragmentary lists of books and trite biographical detail. The desire to say something about every- thing precludes the possibility of doing justice to anything. As a consequence, we find one of the most distinguished historians of nineteenth-century litera- pass style
Page 18
144 ture dismissing John Addington Sy- monds in a page and a half, in which we learn that he was a consumptive; that he wrote the “History of the Renais- sance in Italy”; and that he was prolix. Mr. Magnus aspires to the more diffi- cult type; he calls his book an “essay in criticism.” He possesses some of the qualities which are essential to success in that type. With Victorian literature in general, he is heartily sympathetic and at the same time discriminating. In dealing with individual writers he is direct, specific, and vivid. He comes to close quarters with the style, for exam- ple, of Ruskin; speaks appreciatively of the “sense of breadth and space, of the latis otia fundis” in his writing; does justice to the spirit which he breath- ed upon political economy; properly relates his sociological doctrines to his artistic faith; and at the same time lays his finger upon Ruskin’s temperamental limitation—his ego- mania and his quixotism. He has a fre- quent power over the compact illuminat- ing phrase. Of Newman he writes: “There are prayer and fasting in his style, as well as in his life. It has a virtue, at Its best, which can only be described as at once virile and virginal.” Of Mrs. Craik’s John Halifax he says: “He personified the virtues of Capital. He was the breath in the nostrils of in- dividualism. He illustrated by example the philosophy of John Stuart Mill.” His characterizations of the prose writers, on the whole, are less nearly adequate than those of the poets. His mild deri- sion of Mill through Mrs. Craik betrays his bias. Mr. Magnus is by tempera- ment and faith a Wordsworthian—tran- scendentalist and poet. Fiction, he holds, is a lesser vehicle of truth. The genius of the nineteenth century was not in its philosophers. It is the poets who have effected the reconciliation between knowledge and belief. By virtue of this achievement, Wordsworth becomes his hero of the first half-century, and George Meredith, to whom the book is dedicated, the hero of the second half- even so, it is rather strong to century suy that Meredith is “accounted among the greatest English poets.” His search for the formula of the age which he finds in its bent for “emanci- pation,” and his attempt to range all the writers with reference to it, gives to the work of Mr. Magnus something of that unity and coherence so much to be desired in a work of this kind, But the formula, like all others hitherto pro- posed, is far too simple. The great mo- ments of his period (1784 to the pres- ent day), the French Revolution and the “Origin of Species,” are indeed mo ments of emancipation, But it Is scarcely over-subtle to say, regarding the nine- teenth century as a personality, that though its predominant involuntary ten- dency was toward emancipation, its pre voluntary tendency was the dominant ation. Lhe N [Vol. 89, No. 2302 search for standards, the desire for val- id new bonds. The zest of the literature was in the conflict of these tendencies and in the rivalry of diverse-minded searchers. In indicating the line of con- flict Mr. Magnus’s book is decidedly weak. For instance, he gives no hint that every page of Carlyle’s is a broad- side against every page of Mill’s and vice versa. Indeed, his transcendental leaning and his undefined distinction be- tween literature and not-literature have led him to dismiss the Utilitarians with quite insufficient notice. To make the matter worse, he adds to his brief men- tion of Mill a single paragraph in which he lumps together a dozen other philo- sophical writers “who belong to, or are variants of, this school.” Among them it is interesting to notice Sir William Hamilton, who represented, in fact, the diametrically opposite school of thought, and “William James (of New York)”! Such a grouping of names as this is of no conceivable value in itself. It is mis- leading; and it seriously clogs the course of the exposition. Here and in many other places, Mr. Magnus has fallen into the trap of the writer of the literary manual from a desire for inclusiveness. Yet the failure of Mr. Magnus to bring into strong relief the main cur- rents of literature in his period is due, in the first place, to the lack of political and philosophical ballast, and in the second to an almost total neglect of for- eign influences, arising from a wish to prove the independence of English literature. His treatment of the Rev- olutionary era is superficial. He speaks of the rise of sentimentalism on British soil, of Cowper’s hare and Burns’s mouse; but he has only a pass- ing and insignificant word for Rousseau and does not even mention the giant struggle of Burke or the sledge-hammer blows of Thomas Paine delivered succes- sively in America, England, and France —does not even mention their names. To write of Shelley or Byron, or Words- worth without reference to them is as shallow—to compare great things with small—as to write of Swinburne or Os- car Wilde or George Moore without ref- erence to Victor Hugo or Gautier or Baudelaire. In dealing with the roman- tic movement as with the aesthetic de- cadence, the resolute chauvinism of Mr. Magnus shrouds the most significant things in a great darkness. To criticise the nineteenth century is still to crit- icise oneself; and he who is proudest of the achievement of the age is least like- ly vigorously to anatomize its character. Louis Napoleon and the Genesis of the Second Empire. By F. H. Cheetham. New York: John Lane Co. $5 net. Though written in the tone of apol- ogy, this book deserves attention be- cause it represents under an attractive literary form a detailed, if not a com- plete and thorough, account of the early career of a great French ruler. Person- ally, the third Napoleon cannot be said to have the individual claims to great- ness which his admirers, including Mr. Cheetham, would accord him. But he ruled over France in a momentous pe- riod of the life of the nation and in more ways than one his acts as Presi- dent and Emperor were of such a crit- ical character that the whole course of European political life was influenced by his policy. For many years the Second Empire stood as the incarnation of the democratic principle in European politics. It was looked upon as a bul- wark against the forces of reaction. Whatever may be thought about the character of Louis Napoleon as a man, or his achievements as a statesman, the fact that he was the leader of the French nation when it was at the fore- front of European progress made him a predominant figure in the history of the nineteenth century. It is because of this unique position that the nephew of the great Emperor has been able to secure such indefatigable advocates in his behalf. The literary tradition of our time seems to be strongly in his favor. People forget the virile crit- icism made by the republican opposi- tion, and almost without exception those who write on this period appear as apol- ogists of the Emperor. Mr. Cheetham’s work does not carry him further than the opening years of the political life of Louis Napoleon. Most attention is given to the obscurer portions of his career when he was the acknowledged exponent of the Napoleon- ic ideals of government. These years of his life are chiefly interesting for the light they throw on the nature and tem- perament of the man as these came to be revealed later on. There was then, as afterwards, the same _ indecision, moodiness, and insincerity, but small evidence of that later shrewdness and readiness to seize the opportunity as it passed. Neither by education nor by innate qualities was Louis Napoleon prepared for the task to which he was called in a moment of patriotic fer- vor. The moral fibre that from the first was lacking to his nature was never supplied. When he came into pub- lic notice he appears as an adventurer, bearing the name of the great Napoleon, but repeating mechanically the formulas and the ideas of the imperial régime. The uncle would probably have seen in the nephew only a specimen of the type of idealogue which the great man 80 thoroughly despised. Mr. Cheetham does not notice that Louis seems to have in- herited his literary tendencies from his uncle Lucian. As a pamphleteer he showed some of Lucian’s superficial br‘llianey. He certainly recalls Lucian’s lack of steadiness. The adventures in Italy, at Strasburg, and finally at Bou- logne, cannot, even with Mr. Cheetham’s
Page 19
Aug. 12, 1909] The Nation. pleading, appear as anything but exhi- | bitions of incapacity, the results of a badly thought-out and worseexecuted programme. The picturesque side of these events is well handled, but the enigmas of the situation are left unex- plained. Mr. Cheetham might have paid more attention to the recent Italian literature on the secret societies so active in Italy during the period of reaction. He should have noticed also the unfavorable refer- ences to Louis Napoleon in the memoirs of the time, more especially because Thirria, to whom Mr. Cheetham makes constant appeal,compiled his book large- ly from the contemporary newspapers; and Le Bey, a later writer, also fre- quently referred to, is notoriously under the influence of the Bonapartist legend. Mr. Cheetham speaks in a vague way of the activity of Louis Napoleon's per- sonal friends, in France, while he was living in England. Their relations with party politics before and during the re- public of 1848 deserve careful examina- tion. It is not sufficient to say that Louis Napoleon’s sudden rise represent- ed the aspirations of the majority of Frenchmen. Such a statement explains very little, especially when one remem- bers that the same electors who voted for a Bonaparte, as President, sent to Paris a body of legislators who were anti-democratic and showed no real sym- pathy with the Napoleonic tradition. The Silve of Statius. Translated with in- troduction and notes by D. A. Slater. New York: Henry Frowde. $1. Few moderns since the poet Pope have taken Statius seriously, and his epics which won him fame in the pe- riod that most honored him, the Middle Ages, are now accounted the least s:g- nificant part of his poetry. His “Si'v.e,’ related at once to the epigram and the epyllion, are more in keeping with the tendencies of his age, and to them one turns to-day, if one reads Statius at all; barring the panegyrics, which were virtually prescribed, these poems con- tain much that attracts. Poets who h.ve known the Bay of Naples intimately ought to show in their work a certain companionship. Statius is linked by this delightful bond to Virgil before h:m and to Pontano and Sannazaro after. lis admiration of Virgil and his echoes of certain Virgilian effects are noticeable enough: he suggests also a pleasant trait of the later poets, their habit of person- ifying bits of the landscape that they loved, of creating mythology from hill and stream as the Greeks had once cre- ated it: In those caves Anio himself finds rest; yes, he forsakes his source, and when in the secret night he has put off his sea- blue garments, stretches himself upon the springing moss, or into the deep ] poo: plunges his huge bulk, and with rhythm stroke claps against the glassy waters. In yonder shade Tiburnus rests; there Albula is fain to wash her sulphurous tresses. A bower like this might lure from Egeria, forest Phebe, rob cold Taygetus of his Dryad bands; and charm Pan from the Lycean woods (‘‘Silvm,” i, 3 ). Another matter that impresses ihe reader of the “Silve” is the poet’s in- terest in works of art. Cicero, and «ven Virgil and Horace, supreme in literary art, show little feeling for painting and sculpture save where these form a part of some literary tradition: they still have something of the primitive Roman contempt of the connoisseur and dilet- tante. But by Statius’s time, art must have been an important interest in the life of a cultured Roman: a villa stored with beautiful things demanded no ar ol- ogy. The philosopher Pollio, whom Statius celebrates, turns for doctriaal inspiration to Phidias Myron 20 less than to Ep‘curus. The English reader will detect these and other attractions of the “Silve” in the prose version of Mr. Slater, the quality of which may be seen in the above selection. Our author thinks that Pope, and Pope alone, could have translated Statius into verse., Cer- tainly the recent sonnet quoted by Mr. Slater, which attempts to render Sta- tius’s most beautiful poem, the inveca- tion to Sleep, is not a striking success. We have noted only a few minor infelic- ities in Mr. Slater’s translation. One who writes docta carmina is not a “scholar-poet” (i, 2, 172): the phrase “Lucretius the prophet and his im- and not fail to passioned lore’ for docti furor arduus Lucreti (ii, 7, 76) comes nearer tue meaning. “Duty, greatest of gods,” ad- dressed in iii, 3, is not the deity whom the reader of Wordsworth might x- pect, but filial devotion, Pietas. Mr Slater should have included a tran:la- tion of the prose prefaces: the brief statement about them in his introduc- tion is not a compensation In the introduction sufficient informa- tion is given about Statius and his “Silve.” The author does not attempt a penetrating study of the poems, 'ut he does well in showing that some of the severest criticisms of them have come from those who have not read them or have read with extraordinary inattentiveness. Thus Tyrrell’s treatment in his “Latin Poetry” is based not on Statius, but upon the brilliant thengh inaccurate essay of Nisard. A matte; of interest to which Mr. Slater devotes con- siderable discussion !s Dante’s account of the supposed conversion of Statius to Christianity in consequence of his read- ing the Fourth Eclogue of Virgil. He argues plausibly against Canon Moore that Dante did not invent the legend for a dramatic purpose, but followed mucn earlier tradition. He even reminds us that Statius might have met St. Paul at associating with this possible, Naples 145 or later-imagined, occurrence, the «ell- known story of St. Paul's visit to Vir- gil’s tomb at Pozzuoll. Science. SOME MODERN ASPECTS OF LUTION. EVO- Fifty Years of Darwinism. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $2. Of the many celebrations called forth in this country by the fiftieth anniver- sary of Darwin's “Origin of Species,” one only has so far been sufficiently am- bitious to pass into book form-—-the ad- dresses delivered before the American Association for the Advancement of Science in Baltimore on the first day of the year. Darwinism stands to-day for evolution as well as for the theory of natural selection, although evolution had long been advocated before Darwin Darwin convinced the thinking world of the truth of evolution, partly through the large body of facts that he brought forward in support of this view and partly through his special of natural selection which to give a reasonable explanation of the evolutionary process. While the doc- trine of evolution is now accepted by practically all students of animals and plants, the theory of natural selection, as proposed by Darwin, has not met with the same universal acceptance, al- though it has received, in one form or another, general recognition as an im- portant factor in evolution. These con- clusions are well borne out by the opin- ions expressed in the present volume. At the invitation of the Association, Prof. E. B. Poulton, a leading exponent of Darwinism, came to this country to give the first address of the series. The oft-told tale of the reception of Darwin's book, “The Origin of Species,” is rehearsed by him with boyish relish. The battle is fought over once more to the everlasting discomfiture of the op- ponents of evolution and natural selec- tion. And the confiict is at times turn- ed into an attack on those within the ranks who, following after Darwin, have not accepted his special theory of natural selection as an all-sufficient and self-satisfying explanation of how evo- lution has taken place. Fifty years of Darwinism seems in Poulton's eyes to mean just fifty years of Darwinism, and nothing besides. That our conception of organic evolution has grown vigorously since 1859 does not appear from Profes- sor Poulton’s address, although without a single exception the following nine addresses make this point of view suf- ficiently apparent. The greatness of Darwin's achievement is better shown, we venture to think, by those who have carried forward the work as it was left theory attempted
Page 20
146 by him than by those of his followers who turn deaf ears to what students of evolution have done since his day. In striking contrast to this somewhat lengthy “retrospect,” the second address by Prof. J. M. Coulter on the standpoint of botany offers a vigorous and indepen- dent treatment of the indebtedness of that subject to Darwin. After a grace- ful acknowledgment of the influence of Darwin's work, which extends even beyond his formulation of the origin of species by natural selection, Coulter adds, “whether natural selection stands or falls as an adequate explanation of the origin of species, there can never be any doubt as to the breath of life it infused” into the study of descent. Coul- ter points out that, while at first botan- ists were captivated by the explanation of adaptation in plants through natural selection and showed great ingenuity in accounting for such fitness, the old ex- planations began to lose hold when it was found, for example, that thorns, supposed to have arisen because of pro- tection afforded against grazing ani- mals, prevail chiefly among plants in regions peculiarly free from such ani- mals. The stinging hairs of nettles had been explained as built up by natural selection. It is now known that the net- tle gets along very well without sting- ing hairs. Natura! selection, Coulter concludes, eliminates species and indi- viduals: it has nothing to do with se lecting individual plants on the basis of some small, better adapted variation. The influence of the environment in calling forth new types as a result of directly stimulating the germ plasma is urged by Prof. D. T. Macdougal. In support of this view he cites some of the most important recent experiments showing the effects of temperature and moisture, of injections of salt solution, and of radium emanations. The subject of this address is a matter of the great- est interest to students of evolution, since it bears on the most fundamental of all evolutionary questions, the origin of new variations that are “definitely” inherited The study of the inheritance of varia- tions in Its most modern aspects is dealt with by Prof. W. E. Castle and by Prof. Charles B. Davenport in two brief and interesting chapters. Castle explains exactly In the light of modern research the appearance of ancestral characters (atavism) when races are crossed, or when artificial selection ceases. Races of domesticated animals and plants have been produced by losing some one of the original characters. When two such races from a common source are recom- bined by crossing, the original condl- tions are once more fulfilled and the atavistic form reappears. Thus, for ex- ample, two races of white peas when crossed give the original purple pea of Sicily. A black and a yellow rabbit produce a gray rabbit—the color of the The wild form from which the yellow and the black domestic races have sprung, each by the loss of a different character. Definite variations are generally call- ed mutations. Macdougal’s account deals with such mutations produced by en- vironment; Castle refers mutations to the loss or acquirement of single characters in De Vries’s terminol- ogy. Davenport urges that evolu- tion is due primarily to mutations, and not to the summation of fluctua- tions, and assures the reader that, were Darwin alive to-day, he would cordial- ly accept the same point of view. The mutation theory is not, however, in- compatible with the theory of natural selection, for there may be selection among discontinuous variations, as well aS among quantitative variations. As though in anticipation of such an in- terpretation of Darwinism, Poulton points out, in the opening essay, that in 1864 the Duke of Argyle said: Strictly speaking, therefore, Mr. Dar- win’s theory is not a theory of the origin of species at all, but only a theory on the causes which lead to the relative success or failure of such new forms as may be born into the world. To which Darwin replied: I demur to the Duke’s expres- sion of “new births."”” That may be a very good theory, but it is not mine. Truly, the made hard. Under the title of Adaptation, Prof. C. H. Bigenmann deals with the central problem of evolution. He brings to bear on this question his exceptional knowledge of cave faunas and the great adaptive changes that take place within certain families of fishes. Species be- come adapted by migration into con- genial locations. Migration obviously is the important agent in evolution, not isolation, as Jordan maintains, provid- ed the central problem of evolution is origin of adaptation rather than the “origin of species.” Isolation is urged by President Jor- dan as a primary factor in evolution. The importance of this factor has often been advanced before by those system- atists to whom evolution means thiefly the formation of geographical races and species. But it is not evident that nat- ural selection can have much concern with the formation of species, since spe- cific differences have nothing whatso- ever to do with useful characters. That the process of evolution (aside from the arbitrary definition of species) is concerned with fundamental adapta- tions rather than with superficial dif- ferences is self-evident. Granting that animals change with their environment and that isolation prevents intermin- gling and the production of intermedi- ates, it does not seem to follow that isolation need have anything whatso- ever to do with evolution of adaptive Nation: work of the reconciler is [Vol. 89, No. 2302 characters, for it is adaptive characters alone that natural selection pretends to account for. In Darwin's day the relation of the egg cell to the body was by no means so clear as it has become in _ recent years. The vagueness with which Dar- win conceived how the egg cell might be built up out of units (pangenes) re- ceived from different parts of the body of the parent, is pointed out by Prof. Edmund B. Wilson. A clear summing up of the evidence to-day is distinctly opposed to the theory of the inheritance of acquired characters advocated by Dar- win as a subsidiary hypothesis to nat- ural selection. No chapter in the whole range of evo- lution has been more important than that which deals with fossils, as the strongest evidence that evolution, in some way, has taken place. Prof. H. F. Osborn brings to this topic his wide fa- miliarity with fossil remains. He ar- gues that the evidence is demonstrative in showing that evolution has progress- ed in definite lines. This view has been held by a number of able naturalists, but Osborn implies that these definite lines are often adaptive lines. Selec- tion tries to account for the origin of such lines, but Osborn rejects selection as a sufficient explanation of the process and leaves the reader in doubt as to what the unknown cause of certain adaptive “origins” may be; for, while progression along lines that are not adaptive will be readily understood, pro- gression along adaptive lines without selection and without the Lamarckian factor is something at present outside the scope of scientific demonstration. In concise and strong statements Pres- ident G. Stanley Hall brings the volume to a close with “Evolution and Psychol- ogy.” The debt of genetic psychology to Darwin is generously recognized. Darwin is “hardly less the founder of a new departure in this field than in that of classification of form and struc- ture.” He posits a natural history rather than a philosophy of mind. ... Finally, as Darwin freed biology from the inveterate dominance of the ideas of fixed and divine- ly created species, conceptions directly in- herited from Plato’s ideas and Aristotle's categories, so everything in the present psychological situation cries out for a new Darwin of the mind, who shall break the present spell of theoretical problems in- capable of scientific solution, the ideal of a logical and methodical exactness greater than our subject in its present stage per- mits of, which Aristotle well dubbed ped- antry, and remand the haunting problem of the ultimate goal of the psyche to the same limbo. Only by so doing can we again get up against the essentia! facts of life as it is lived by the toiling. struggling men, women, and children, nor- mal and defective, of our day. Truly a wide range of subject and opinion; a fine tribute to the memory
Page 21
Aug. 12, 1909] of a great and independent thinker, even though much of what is written may be repudiated as not Darwinism by that narrow sect that claims to hold in fee the secrets of the master. In “The Garden Yard” (Philadelphia: David McKay) Bolton Hall continues his apostleship to those city folk who try to support themselves in the country. The book teaches intensive farming to the home gardener, and instructs the beginner in market gardening. It discusses general farming topics, the various classes of vege- tables, and poultry. For its size the book is very comprehensive, and its treatment of the ect is simple and practical. In his facts a advice Mr. Hall is up-to-date; his book s ld help to bring about the practice of intensive gardening which is to be the salvation of Eastern farmers and of suburban dwellers generally. Mr. Hall promises no millennium, however, to those who will not think as well as work. In an introduction N. O. Nelson urges the forming of coéperative farming settlements, and offers to finance them. To those visionary souls who still take pleasure in naming the constellations we recommend a little book by Willis I. Mil- ham, entitled “How to Identify the Stars’ (Macmillan). Raffaele Vittorio Matteucci, director of the observatory on Mt. Vesuvius, died there on July 16, from pneumonia contracted by exposure during scientific excursions at night on the crater. He was born at Seni- gallia, near Ancona, in 1866. Before suc- ceeding the late Professor Palmieri as head of the Vesuvian observatory, he was as- sistant professor of natural sciences in th. University of Naples. He had published a number of monographs on lava; on the fumarole and their products; on the phe- nomena exhibited by this volcano during the period between 1891 and 1895, and a work entitled “Come dovrebbe essere stu- diato il Vesuvio.” Drama. EXAMINING THE EXAMINER. The Examiner of Plays in England, George Alexander Redford, was for two days before the Joint Committee of Lords and Commons on the censorship, and his detailed testimony is highly en- lightening. Whether it is more amusing than depressing, it is hard to say. The disclosure of the complete lack of taste in the officer who regulates national dra- matic taste, and of the ignorance and want of fixed intellectual principles and moral sensibility on the part of the man who for fourteen years has decided what should and what should not be produced on the stage, must certainly compel a reform in the censorship, even if the result be not to reform it alto- gether away. None of the attacks upon it by playwrights and theatrical mana- gers has damaged it so seriously as the two days’ examination of the Examiner Mr. Redford, who, for the rest, ap The Nation. pears to be a well-meaning and con- tented citizen, was asked by the com- mittee to state his qualifications for his important task. Was he an educated man, a university graduate? Well, no, but “no doubt the Lord Chamberlain satisfied himself as to my competence.” Had he engaged in literary pursuits pre- vious to his appointment? Not exactly, though he had “dabbled in such things.” What had he written? “If you wish to know, I have written several plays.” Were any of them ever produced? Not one! What was his actual position be- fore becoming Examiner of Plays? “I was a bank manager.” How did he come to be appointed censor? Why, he was a friend of the previous censor, and had been in the habit of “acting for him when he was on holiday’! Mr. Har- court, for the committee, then asked the question, which even Mr. Redford must have perceived to be ironical: “So the public were permitted at such seasons to see only such plays as the censor's friend thought it desirable they should see ¥’ The whole inquiry brought out the incompetence and confusion and vacil- lating uncertainties of the censorship in the most glaring way. Mr. Redford was asked on what principles he proceeded in determining whether a given play should be or should not be licensed. His reply was that he simply applied “the official point of view.” Here is official art with a vengeance! But what was the official standard? Why, it was mere- ly “custom and precedent.” One sees how simple it is! A play of the kind that never has been licensed, never can be licensed, that is the whole of it. If there is in a play anything that the censor believes any of his predecessors would have thought indecent, or too per- sonal, or offensive to the head of a friendly nation, or—oh, yes!—irrelig- ious, that play cannot be produced in England. Another positive rule was that no drama or opera could be “Scriptural.” Mr. Redford was very strong on that point. But had he not recently licensed “Samson et Dalila’? Yes, but he had “stretched Yhe rule” in that case. But there was one rule which was never stretched—the rule against immoral plays. How did he decide what were im- moral plays? He was “bound by prece- dents—the unwritten law.” But that un- written law was precisely what the com- mittee wanted to get at, and they plied Mr. Redford with questions. All in vain, however. He made it evident that he had no fixed standards whatever. Even in the matter of indecency, he had to admit that the worst plays of Congreve or Wycherley would have nothing to fear from the censorship, because they would come under the head of old plays not under the jurisdiction of the cen- sor. Yet it was confessed that an in- decent Restoration drama could not now 14:7 be produced, simply because public opin- ion would not tolerate it. So there we have it—it is really the public taste, not the censor, that banishes the grosser plays from the stage. Quite apart from the question of an official license, there are standaids and also laws—such as those against libel and against indecent exhibitions—which no theatrical mana- ger could venture to disregard or vio- late. In the end this whole question of li- censing the production of a play seems cursiously like the question of licensing the printing of a book. Milton's ar- gument regarding the latter would apply almost literally to the former. In- decent or libellous books he would leave to the law; and as for the impossible duties of the licenser, the language of the “Areopagitica” seems prophetic of poor Mr. Redford, with his 7,000 plays to read In fourteen years: It cannot be denied, wrote Milton, but that he who is made judge to sit upon the had need common measure, birth or death of books to be the both studious, learned, and judicious. If he be of such worth as behooves him, there cannot be a more tedious and un- pleasing journeywork, a greater loss of time levied upon his head, than to be made the perpetual reader of unchosen books and Seeing, therefore, -hose who hy all evident signs wish themselves well rid of it, and that no man of worth, none that is not a plain unthrift of his own hours, is ever likely them, we may easily foresee what kind of lkensers we are hereafter, a man above pamphlets. now possess the employment, to succeed to expect either ignorant, im perious, and remiss, or basely pecuniary. It seems plain that the testimony of the censor will be the undoing of the censorship. The evidence of playwrights and dramatic critics was unnecessary, after Mr. Redford had left the stand. His office may not be abolished, but it is sure to be reformed. Probably, the first step will be to allow an appeal from his decisions, which are now as final as they are inscrutable. Mr. Red- ford’s innocent testifying to his own inconsistencies and ignorance was most diverting. He had refused a license to “La Citta Morta,” but had given one to the horrible plays of the Sicilian actors, because their manager had sent him a précis, and that seemed harmless. Ger man plays he felt a little weak about, since he did not know the language, but his wife did. The ewig Weibliche in the censorship’ “Willlam Shakespeare Player, Playmaker, and Poet” (John Lane Co.), Canon H. C. Beeching has tried to sum up as succinctly as possible the argu ments in G. G. Greenwood's bulky volume “The Shakespeare Problem Restated.’ In In Chapter i of Chapters fi and ili he reprints lectures on Shakespeare’s life and character. To this book Mr. Greenwood rejoing with “In Re Shakespeare” (John Lane Co.). Mr Greenwood, making much of the spell-
Page 22
148 ing Shakespeare as the nom de guerre of the author of the plays, and Shakapere for the player born at Stratford, argued with great detail in his first book to prove that the player could not have written the plays attributed to him. Yet he did not directly affirm the Baconian theory of authorship, nor did he attempt to identify the concealed under the name Shakeapeare Point by point, Canon Beeching, as an en- thusiastic Shakespearean, this evidence. Point by point in hissecond book, Mr. Greenwood attempts to answer this at- tack person traverses Whatever else discussion of Shakespeare- an authorship may lack, it fails to make one or all of the disputants irate Canon Beeching talks of the “bluff” of Mr. Greenwood and accuses him of argumenta- tive more worthy of an advocate than a judge Mr. Greenwood retorts by animadversion on the pulpit and the cloth. All of which hardly advances the cause uf truth. Canon Beeching is the more judicial, but he does not always distinguish clearly between facts and surmises or between im- agination and real evidence. It may be questioned whether a writer who will devote a page to considering if, in the light of the plays, we may hold that Shakespeare drank tobacco, is the proper person to give the final destructive treatment to such a mare’s nest as Mr. Greenwood has constructed. The mind for that must be relentlessly analytic and impartial. On the other hand, Mr. Greenwood is open to some extent to Canon Beeching’s charge that he cares more to make his point than to search ingly for truth. He quibbles with his op- ponents, drawing off attention on special or minor points, and concluding as if he had answered or effectively weakened the whole opposing case. (See his treatment of Irving's argument against the Baconian theory, p. 112.) He also meets assertion with assertion, concluding as if he had proved something true. (See p. 62, as to the “Return from Parnassus.”) He choos- es the one witness among many considering a question who particularly favors his view, disregarding the immediate objec- tien—for instance,in the case of Mr. Fleay— that this opinion of his witness changed so often and was sometimes, at first, so arbi- trarily taken that it must be supported by other evidence or (See p. 53.) He even uses the argumentum ad hominem against Canon Beeching, and then seems to conclude that he has proved something for the There can be no question, then, that Mr. Greenwood's fervor as a controversialist leads him into strange ways. Nor does his exceeding- ly lame explanation, in an appendix, of his discourteous references to Mr. increase a reader's willingness never methods unswerv- witnesses reader (pp. 72-81). supposed Sidney to accept him as a whole-souled searcher for truth Art. “OGhirlandaio,” by Gerald 8. Davies, which is among the recent Scribner im- portations, has the distinction of being the only separate work on the subject in Eng- lish, and uniess its successors are to be better, we hope it may long enjoy that soll- tary dignity. It belongs to that class of The Nation. compilations which, falling short of thor- ough scholarship, are even more deficient in good sense and literary attractiveness. It is not so much that the author has not labored faithfully with his theme. The lack is less of diligence than of judgment. Relatively unimportant matters, such as the religious sincerity of Ghirlandaio, are la- bored at tedious length, while that most diverting and instructive document of the Florentine Renaissance, the contract for the Sta. Maria Novella frescoes, is merely mentioned in the text, though printed in the original Latin in an appendix. The magnificent portrait in the Louvre is passed in half a dozen lines; even more briefly the exquisite Giovanna degli Alb‘zzi. On most matters of disputed attribution, Mr. Davies is inconclusive, though, con- trariwise, he apportions between master a.d pupils the frescoes at the Trinita and Sta. Maria Novella with a certainty that excites wonderment. We have no space to enter into the various disputable mat- ters. Symptomatic inaccuracies are not in- frequent. On page 9 Masaccio’s Crucifixion at Sta. Maria Novella is called an Annunci- ation. On page 14 Ghirlandaio’s Salutation in the Louvre suffers the same transforma- tion. We hope no enthusiast will be in- duced to go to the Spedaletto at Volterra to see the fresco of the Forge of Vulcan, which is described as “ruined.’”” Her- bert Horne, eight years ago, found only slight traces of the underpainting. This work at Volterra, though described at sec- ond hand, is not mentioned in the chrono- logical survey. It must fall, as Mr. Horne has shown in his “Botticelli,” about the year 1485. On the other hand, the Last Supper, in the Badia of Passignano, which Mr. Davies catalogues as “‘lost,”” we saw in very tolerable, if repainted, condition about a year ago. We can commend little in this slipshod monograph except the clear type and the good cuts. If there is a de- mand for a Ghirlandaio book in English why does not some publisher take the ob- vious course of translating Dr. Herr' Hauvette’s admirable treatise? The second volume of Dr. G. Carotti’s “History of Art” (Dutton) bears the sub- title, “Early Christian and neo-Oriental Art, European Art North of the Alps.” Ex- cluding Italy, after the thirteenth century, it includes what is usually called early Christian, Byzantine, Saracenic, Roman- esque, and Gothic art. A great amount of information, generally accurate and up to date, has been packed within small com- pass. The bibliography is full, though not exhaustive, the lists of typical monuments, in smaller type, very useful. The scope of the work may be inferred from the space given to Gothic art—something more than one hundred pages, as against about fifieen in Reinach’s standard manual, “Apollo.” The numerous small cuts are very clearly printed, and the little volume is handy for the pocket or satchel. It should serve well as a class book. A laborious verification of all matters of fact is naturally impossi- ble, but in this regard the text meets cas- ual yet crucial tests, It seems to us that the author gives himself a little too unre- servedly to current and popular theories of the influence of Sassenid upon European art. We regret, too, his use of the term Carolingian, to cover all sorts of belated Byzantinism in and out of Italy. Taken broadly, it seems to us the best manual [Vol. 89, No. 2302 of the kind in the field. In their choice of a translator, however, author and publisher have been unlucky. Defects of idiom. sometimes obscuring the sense, occur too frequently. Geographical names appear carelessly in the Italian form, for example, “Monaco” (Munich), “Anversa,” “Gand.” A Gothic cathedral resembies a “‘carcase"’ (meaning skeleton), and, a few lines further on, a “carcass.” Fresco and porcelain are used loosely for wall painting and pottery In short the text has not had proper edi torial supervision and needs a minute ov erhauling. It is fair to add that these de fects are usually rather of taste than of substance. Kar! Hiersemann of Leipzig has issued Teil I, “Metall,” of a work containing an abundance of rare but trustworthy informa entitled “Erzeugnisse Islamischer Kunst.” This work describes and discusses in detail a collection of Oriental works of art, more especially of Persian-Islamic art, the description being given by the owner, Prof. Friedrich Sarre, with epi- graphical contributions by Dr. Eugen Mitt- woch, The collection appears in quarto form of 82 pages, with 10 tables and 54 illustrations, costing 12 marks. It is as- serted that this is the only collection of the kind on the continent. Dr. Sarre has also in preparation Teil II, entitled ‘‘Seld- schukische Kleinkunst,” with 60 illustra- tions, of which 25 are photographs. It deals with one of the most interesting periods in the history of Islamic art. tion, An announcement has been received in Rome of the resignation of Prof. C. Hiilsen, who for twenty-five years has been con- nected with the German Arcna@ological In- stitute in that city. His retiremen: is due to his lack of sympathy with the policy of the Berlin authgrities, who have reduced the sum allowed for the Institute library and have appointed a young schol- ar, a former pupil of Professor Hiilsen, to the post of provisional first secretary. it will be remembered that Dr. Dérp- feld, the head of the German Institute in Athens, also sent in his resignation last year, for similar reasons, and was only persuaded to keep his post by the per- sonal intervention of the German Em- peror. It is alleged that the policy of the Berlin authorities is to neglect Roman and Greek archwology in favor of research in Persia and elsewhere in Asia. F. Gutekunst of Philadelphia publishes a large photograph of Edward Everett Hale, which presents a striking likeness of the preacher-writer in his later years. Finance. AFTER THE TARIFF. Three or four months ago, it was the commonplace of Wall Street discussion to find every prediction of prosperity conditioned on, or at all events limited in date by, the enactment and signing of the tariff bill. Sometimes the proph ets promised 1 trade boom and a rising market “if a satisfactory bill passes,” but more often “when the bill passes.” Senator Aldrich, in a speech in April,
Page 23
Auy. 12, 1909] observed that “the era of prosperity is likely to continue uninterruptedly with the enactment of wise tariff legislation.” Since numerous schedules of the Sen- ate bill, which Mr. Aldrich fathered, have been thrown out in conference, it might have been questioned whether, on the condition above assigned, the promise regarding prosperity would hold good. But most of the prophets framed their prediction in the fashion of Mr. Schiff: “As soon as tariff revision is settled defi- nitely, America will enter upon a period of unexampled prosperity.” There was some question, even in April, as to whether a country possess- ing, as seemed to be assumed, all the elements that go to make up prosperity, was usually in the habit of waiting for an arbitrarily selected event before its merchants and speculators adjusted themselves to the prosperous conditions. Had it been a question between a revo- lutionary cut in the protective duties and maintenance of the existing sched- ules, hesitation could be understood. No manufacturer, importer, or merchant could then make any plans for the fu- ture. But no such condition existed. Two or three weeks after the convening of the extra session on March 15, every one knew what the general character of the new tariff bill would be. There were some exceptions. Makers of gloves, of hosiery, and of certain lines of cotton goods, remained for some time in doubt; yet even their doubts affected the question whether their commodities would get higher duties, or not. The trade in which reduced protection was a foregone conclusion from the start— largely because of Mr. Andrew Carne- gie’s exploit at Washington—was steel and iron, and the iron and steel trade has been expanding in activity ever since the tariff bill was introduced. The same thing has been true of the dry goods trade. As for the Stock Exchange, where prices, inferentially, were to hang fire until the enactment of the tariff bill | permitted a boom, St. Paul stock rose 16 points between the convening of the extra session and the final vote, New York Central 18, Amalgamated Copper 20, Union Pacific 26, Steel common 30, and Reading 38. All this looked as if somebody was too impatient to wait un- til “tariff revision was settled definite- ly,” or even for “the enactment of wise tariff legislation.” Nevertheless, the news of the passing of the bill last week was received in financial circles with interest and curi- osity which were more than merely po- litical. Probably nobody, on Wall Street at any rate, failed to ask him- self whether this was not one of those strategic dates which should indicate the our entry into a new chapter in history of markets. In recent years, there have been two notable instances of Abel, A. H long-expcted | The events whose occurrence is traditionally believed to have affected profoundly a financial situation. The Peace of Ports. mouth in Aurust, 1905, was one; the election of Mr. Taft in November, 1908, was the other. In reality, however the bearing of these two events on trade and on financial markets was not pre- cisely what most people imagine. If Nation. a steady industrial improvement—due to recovery from a severe financial setback -which began long before either the peace treaty or the election, and contin- ued afterward much as it presumably would have done had no such political incident intervened. As for the stock market, the story dif- fered oddly on the two occasions. High Finance had each time calculated, as implicitly as it did last April in look- ing to the tariff bill, on a “boom in stocks” to folicw the and time the market anticipated what was to come. £00d had When the news ac- in the one as in the other, somebody sold stocks heavily to realize profits on the anticipated sud- den purchases by the public: but the sequels differec widely In 1905,/ the market was instantaneously and unex- pectedly conf-onted with tight money, end the rest of the vear passed in a rather desperate struggle by the high financiers to maintain their speculative positions. In 1908, the spec- ulating public snatched market away from the speculating capitalists, end ran away with it so rapidly that the first word heard from the financiers themselves was a warning of disaster if the public did not stop. Here are two interesting precedents They are in many ways fair instances in point. In both, the industrial and speculative revival which theoretically was to follow the event had in fact pre- ceded it, and that is equally true of the present case. In both, the event to which expectations had been pinned was one sure to happen, and that is even more true of the tariff bill land-mark. Last week’s news was followed imme- diately by a aharp break in prices, and that, in turn, »» a violent recovery, un- der the visible direction of the same in- terests as had been in self-constituted charge of the market all the summer. This leaves ‘t,on the whole, a matter of psychological rather than of economic interest, what is to happen next. Psy- chology does not yet rule the course of events in industry at large, but it is often supreme on the Stock Exchange news, each tually came, instance extremely the BOOKS OF THE WEEK History of Events Resulting in Indian Consolidation West of the Mis- sissippi. From the Annual Report of the Amer. Hist, Assn. for Washington: Gov. Printing Office Adams. C. F. Physical Laboratory Manual for Secondary Schools. Revised edition American Book Co. © cents 1904 149 Andrews, L. R. The White Peril, or How I Cured Myself of Consumption at Home Revised edition, edited and compiled by A. B. Reader Danbury, Conn White Peril Co Ashburn, P. M. Elements of Military Hy giene. Houghton Mifflin Co. $2 net Beadnell, H. J. L. An Egyptian Oasis: An Account of the Oasis of Kharga in the Libyan Degert Dutton. $3.50 net Bennett, A. The O'd Wives’ Tale: A Novel G. H. Doran Co. $1.50 net | Cullum, R. The Compact; Story of an Un- their effect on general trade is consid- | ered, there will be seen in each period | recorded Conspiracy in South Africa. G H. Doran Co. $1.20 net Financial. The Utmost in 6% Bonds Irrigation Bonds, when properly issued, form ideal investments. No other large class of bonds, based on equal security, pays six percent. Irrigation Bonds are secured by first liens on the most fertile farm lands in America. The loan will not average one-fourth the land’s valve. They are additionally secured by a first mortgage on all that the Ir- rigation Company owns. Some are municipal obligations—in each case a tax lien on all the property in the district. Where else can one find such ideal security behind bonds that net six per cent.? These are serial bonds, so one may make short-time or long-time investments. And every bond paid off increases the security back of the rest. The bonds are issued in denomi- nations as low as $100, so they ap- peal to both small investors and large. We are the largest dealers in Reclamation Bonds. During the past fifteen years, we have sold seventy such issues. Not a dollar of loss has resulted to any investor. We have written a book based on all this experience—the best book of the kind ever published. Every investor, small or large, owes to himself its perusal. Every- one in these days should know Irrigation Bonds. The book is free. Please send this coupon to- day for it. Sroulridge UNiwert (Eatablished 18@3) Municipal and Corporation Bonds First National Bank Bidg. SO Congress Street CHICAGO BOSTON Gentlemen :—Please send me your new Bond Book, “The World's Greatest In- dustry.” Name— Town- State ——
Page 24
The N ation. American Book Co Johnston, H. Revell. 75 cents net Koester, F Hydroelectric and Engineering. Van Nostrand $1. A. Victorious Douris and the Painters Translated by B. Kahn- Pottier, Edmond. of Greek Vases. weiler. Dutton. $2.50 net. Publications of the Princeton Univ. Ar- chm@ological Expedition to Syria in 1904- Drage, G. Austria-Hungary Dutton. $6! Miller, J. R. Bethlehem to Olivet: net | of Jesus Christ, Illustrated by Modern Homer, N. ¥Y. A Slight Indiscretion. Coch- | Painters. Crowell. $1.50. rane. $1.50 | Monroe, W. 8S. Sicily: The Garden of the Hope, L. Songs from the Garden of Kama: | Mediterranean. Boston: Page & Co. $3. Illustrated from photographs by Mrs. F Otis, J. Found by the Circus. Crowell, $1. Wilmot Lane. $3 net. | Parker, E, H. John Chinaman ang a Few Horace's Satires. Edited by E. P. wi rris. Others. Dutton. $1.25 net. | | MLavhood. Developments $5 net. | John Levitt, D. The Woman and the Car 1905. Div. II Ancient Architecture in Lane Co. $1 net Syria, by H. C. Butler; Div. III. Greek McClelland, T. C. The Mind of Christ. and Latin Inscriptions in Syria, by W. Crowell. $1.25 net. K. Prentice. Section B, Parts 2 and 3. McConnell, F. J. Edward Gayer Andrews Leyden: Late E J. Brill. A Bishop of the M. E. Church. Eaton & | Ragg, L. The Church of the Apostles. Lon- Mains. $1.50 net don: Rivingtons Important New College Text Books Chamberlin and Salisbury’s College Geology By Tuomas C,. CHAMBERLIN and ROLLIN D. SALISBURY, Professors in the Uni- versity of Chicago. (American Science Series.) 8vo, 943 pp. + index, $3.50. A one-volume text-book on the lines of the author’s widely known three-volume work. Intended to serve as a basis for a half-year’s work; but by the judicious se- or, supplemented by the numerous be made the basis for more ex- lection of material may be used tor briefer courses; articles and treatises referred to in the text. it may tended courses. Rietz and Crathorne’s College Algebra By H. L. Rrerz, Assistant Professor of Mathematics in the University of Illinois, and Dr. A. R. CRATHORNE, Asscciate in Mathematics in the University of Illinois. Svo, 255 pp index, $1.25. Designed primarily for the freshman year in colleges and technical schools. Spe- method of reviewing the Algebra of the secondary cial attention is directed to the achools: the selection and omission of material; the explicit statement of assumptions on which proofs are based; the application of algebraic methods to physical problems. The application of Algebra in advanced mathematics has been carefully considered in determining the subject matter. Henry Holt and Company, 34 W. 33d St., New York. S78 Wabash Ave., Chicago. Library Orders We have conducted a special department for many years that has been exceptionally successful in handling book orders PUBLIC LIBRARIES SCHOOLS, COLLEGES and UNIVERSITIES Our Monthly Bulletin of New Books, with annotations and brief descriptions of each title recorded, is one of the most helpful aids in book selection. Library Department A. C. McCLURG G&G CO. CHICAGO The Life of Nation. cer be od No. 2 ngoe Sainsbury, H. Drug and the ald Habit. Dutton. $2.50 net. Semenoff, V. Rasplata (The Reckoning). Dutton, $3.50 net. Sloane, T. O. Elementary Electrical Cal- culations. Van Nostrand. §$2 net. Street, J. The Need of Change. Lane. 60 cents. Svenson, E. A Modern Valkyrie. Cochrane. Thursfield, J. R. Nelson and Other Nava! Studies. Dutton. $4 net. Upham. A. H. Old Miami: The Yale >f the Early West. Hamilton, O.: Republi- can Pub. Co. Warren, T, H. Essays of Poets and Poetry, Ancient and Modern. Dutton. $3 net. Watson, C. M. Life of Major-General Sir Charles William Wilson. Dutton. $5 net. | Winter, N. O. Guatemala and Her Peo- ple of To-day. Boston: Page & Co. $3. New and Cheaper Edition. Alexander Hamilton An Essay on American Union. By FREDERICK SCOTT OLIVER Popular Edition. 16mo. 75c. net. Usrary Edition. 8v0. $2.50 net. “Adequately supplies a real want in political history. A living portrait of the man himself is vigor- ously drawn in the midst of the his- torical and _ political chapters.’’—- Frederic Harrison in London Times. G.P. PUTNAM’S SON NEW YORK , & LONDON ESSAYS IN POLITICS By ANDREW MacPHAIL. Crown §&8vo. pp. vi+301. $1.80 net. CONTENTS: 1, The Patience of England. 2, Loyalty—To What? 3, The Dominion and the Spirit. 4, What Can Canada Do? 5, New Lamps for Old. 6, A Patent Anomaly. 7, Protection and Politics. 8, Why the Con- servatives Failed. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York THE Anderson Auction Co. 12 East 46th St.. New York. The Fall Season for the sale of Private Libraries and Art Coliections epens October 5th. A large majority of our dates have already been filled, and the s°ason prom’ses to be one of the most important and in- teresting knowr. We shall be glad to re- ceive further consignments of rare Books to be included with those now being cata- logued. Send for circular. Especial Attention will be given to meri torlops ART COLLECTIONS for the exhibi tion and sale of which our new galleries afford ample facilities. Expert inf: rmation upon request. Telephone 120—Murray Hill. Bargain for Public or Private Library Brehm’s Tierleben THE WHOLE ANIMAL KINGDOM The famous and unequalled work on Natura! History; last and beet edition; 10 volumes, Leipsic a Vienna. 12 maps; 1, 910 illustrations in text, 179 in full pages, nearly all finely colored. Pub- lisher’s price, 35 dollars. Securely eked and sent to any address for 12 dollars. . R., care scr bea ORT 128 Tremont & poston, Mase. AUTHORS MUSICIANS LIBRAR Bend for Free Booklets oeseie bebe. DITSON COMPANY | BOSTON |i pny JUST ISSUED. Cloth, $1.50 net. SAINTE-BEUVE By Prof. George M. Harper, Princeton University B. LIPPINCOTT C©O., Philadelphia. J.
Page 25
moe, me . A " a z . ‘ w oe we it. - . t - ; ey ‘ a mel - -* ° P : f : Noe as f « “ " Be } be he ie la ; ie T } * } r i 1 ad | _ Me 3. 4 x re} Ff a ‘ if . f nN oes ~ é , ‘ ' eg