The Nation 1909-07-29: Vol 89 Iss 2300
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Na avon ° = —— E TEN CENTS. WILLIAM ALLEN WHITE’S new novel A Certain Rich Man “It pulsates with humor, interest, passionate love, adventure, pathos
=<
“a Bic —every page is woven with threads of human nature, life as we know AND it, life as it is, and above it all a spirit of righteousness, true piety, SATISFYING and heroic patriotism. These inspire the author’s genius and fine BOOK”’ literary quality, thrilling the reader with tenderest emotion, and holding to the end his unflagging, absorbing interest.” — The Public Ledger, Philadelphia. “Mr. WHITE has studied American life from the inside and has made a novel out of it possessing uncommon vitality and interest .. . a cross section of human experience, a kind of representative record “HUMAN . . « It gives us glimpses into the heart of a people, moulding its destiny EXPERIENCE in no academic fashion, but through the ups and downs of the everyday POSSESSING struggle for existence. The soil of the Middle West is in this book. UNCOMMON . . . Itis a vivid picture Mr. White paints—real, exciting, sympathetic, VITALITY AND often amusing and as often touching. ... It is not John Barclay alone INTEREST” who interests us. On the contrary his environment is equally absorbing . for the breadth and the depth of that stream of life we have great admiration.”— The New York Tribune. “Mr. WHITE has written a big and satisfying book made up of the ele- ments of American life as we know them—the familiar humor, sorrows, “DEFTLY WOVEN ambitions, crimes, and sacrifices, revealed to us with peculiar freshness and vigor in the multitude of human actions and by the crowd of delight- INTO A ful people who fill his four hundred odd pages. . . . It deserves a high pono con tng place among the novels that deal with American life. No recent Ameri- OMANCE. can novel save one has sought to cover so broad a canvas, or has created so strong an impression of ambition and of sincerity.” —Evening Post, Chicago. A Certain Rich Man By WILLIAM ALLEN WHITE cow, si50 FIRST EDITION SOLD ON PUBLICATION. SECOND EDITION READY BY THE END OF THIS WEEK. ORDER AT ANY BOOKSTORE NOW
rune = THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “%.7%2,0°
Page 2
ae —s The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 18665. the New York City Post Office as second-class mail matter.) {[Rutered at The Nation ts published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Eimer More, Pallitor Three dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewtco; to Can- ada £3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Poatal Unton, 84.00. Addrese THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tue WrEK EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Representation in Theory and in Fact 90 The New Prosperity...........«seee+ 90 France and Europe ........sceeseeeees 91 The Fight Against Opium....... soso Lawyers and the Public...........++- 93 SpPectaAL ARTICLES: ete Tee. cciiccenseedeeenbadds 94 CORRESPONDENCE From Lombrose to Shakespeare on Cromwell and America ; . ee Religious Authority in Turkey and Persia nee 262 : . owe 97 Teachers of Advanced Mathematics OS Hanging Animals .. sbteses . 8 No TES TTT TTT CT seees 98 Book REVIEWS: rhe Life of Edgar Allan Poe, Personal and Literary; with his Chief Corre- spondence with Men of Letters... 100 PUTCRSTS THNGS cscvcccicssoscese soon EE The Lodger Overhead ........ secon Be Nadir Shah 102 Philip the Forester 102 Dictionary of the Bible \ Standard Bible Dictionary \ Commentary on the Holy Bible a Siena, the Story of a Mediwval Com mune seco Ea rhe Story of the State of Washington 103 Wanderings in South America, the Northweat of the United States, and the Antilles, in the Years 1812, 1816, 1820, and 1824 The Andean Land (South America) ses Ee Science The Behavior of Noddy and Sooty Terne stecee Be ART: Royal Palaces of Spain 105 FINANCE Forty Years of American Finance.... 106 DOCG GH GED Welllilsscccectoctsscotes 107 ***Coptes of The Nation may be procured in Parle at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross, Stevens [Vol. 89, No. 2300 The Nati on. Educational. | Educational. ECOLE LIBRE DES SCIENCES POLITIQUES 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, & PARIS (7'rente-neuviéme année, 1909-1910) Fonpatevr: Emile BOUTMY. I.—Directeur: M. Anatole LEROY-BEAULIEU, membre de |'Institut, Il.—COMITE DE PERFECTIONNEMENT MM. Leon BOURGEOIS, sé6nateur, aocien ident du Conseil des Ministres; CAMBON, ambas- sadeur: FLOURENS, @ocien ministre; HANOTAUX, de |' Académie frangaise, ancien ministre; DU BOYS, ancien directeur des Affaires commercisles au ministére des Affaires é6trangéres; HENRY, ambassadeur de France; Ch. LAURENT, ancien premier président de la Cour des Comptes; Georges L . UIS, ambassadeur, ancien directeur des Affaires politiques et commerciales au ministére des Affaires é6trangéres; MAGNIN, vice-président du Sénat; NISA RD, ambassa- deur; PALLAIN, uverneur de la Banque de France; A. RIBOT, de |’ Académie frangaise, député, ancien président du Conseil des Minietres. IIl.—CORPS ENSEIGNANT MM. LEVASSEUR, de l'Institut; LYON-CAEN, de l'Institut, doyen de la Faculté de Droit; A. ESMEIN. de I'fastitut, prof, Ala Faculté de Droit; RENAULT, de l'Institut, prof. a la Faculté de Droit; Anatole LEROY-BEAULIEU, de l'Institut; Albert VANDAL, de |'Académie fran- caise; E, BOURGEOIS, prof. 4 la Faculté des Lettres; Charles BENOIST, de I'Institut, dé- puté; J. FLACH, prof. au Collége de France; ROMIEU, conseiller d'Etat; TARDIEU, TEI-S!ER, maitre des requétes au Conseil d’Etat; CHEYSSON, de I'Institut, inspecteur général honor. des Ponts et Chaussées; DE FOVILLE, de I'Institut, conseiller maitre & la Cour des Comptes; Rene STOURM, de l'Institut, ancien inspecteur des Finances; Aug. ARNAUNE, conseiller maitre A la Cour des Comptes, ancien directeur de l'Administration des Monnaies; BOULANGER, conseiller maitre A la r des Comptes; COURTIN, PLAFFAIN, inspecteurs des Finances; SILVESTRE, ancien directeur des Affaires civiles au Tonkin; J. CHAILLEY, député, ete, TABLEAU SOMMAIRE DES COURS Histoire parlementaire et législative de la France, , Ethnographie de 1l'Europe.—Gé6ographie commer- de 1789 A 1875. ‘ clale et statistique. Histoire constitetionselie de I'Burope et des Btats- | nroit des gens.—Droit international conventionnel. Histotre diplomatique de I’Europe, de 1713 & nos | Oreanisation et matiéres administratives en France et A l’étranger. jours. Questions algérienne et tunisiennes.—Droit musul- man. Histoire politique de l'Europe pendant les vingt derniéres années. Politique coloniale des Erats européens depuis 1783. L’ Amérique centemporaine: Etats-Unis d’ Amérique, Canada, Amérique latine. Questions politiques et économiques dans l’Asie ortentale. Législation des chemins de fer. Economie politique; Economie sociale; Législation ouvriére. Hygiéne publique et grands travaux publics. Organisation et Finances francaises et étrangéres. paréea. La monnaie, le crédit et le change.—Affaires de Géographie et organisation militaires.—Géograpbie banque. des possessions francaises. Politique commerciale des grandes puissances. RENSEIGNEMENTS GENERAUX L’ Enseignement de I Reole des Sciences politiques est le couronnement naturel de toute éducation libérale, Chacune de ses grandes divisions constitue en outre une préparation compléte aux carriéres d’Etat et aux examens ou concours qui en ouvrent l’entrée: (Diplomatie, Conseil d'Etat, Cour des Comptes, Inspection des Finances, Inspection des Colonies), et A des postes d'initiative ou de contréle dans les grandes entreprises privées, Les é6léves sont admis sans examens, avec l'agrément du Directeur et du Conseil de I’Reole; ils n'ont A justifier d’aucun grade universitaire. La durée ordinaire des études est de trois ans, toutefois, on peut la réduire A deux années, Un diplome eat délivré, en fin d'études, aux éléves qui ont subi avec succés les examens. ANNEE SCOLAIRE 1909-1910.—L'année scolaire commencera le 8 novembre 1909 et finira le 4 juin 1910, Ons‘inscrira au Secrétariat A partir du 2 novembre 1909: Inscription d’ensemble don- nant entrée A tous les cours et conférences réguliers et complémentaires et Ala biblioth¢que (environ 25,000 volumes et 160 revues et journaux frangais et é6trangers)...................... Par ANNEE: 350 fr. Une Brochure speciale (donne des renseignements détaillés sur l organisation del’ Ecole et sur les carrtéres auzquelles eile prépare. S'adresser 0 VECOLE, 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, PARIS. administration coloniales com- 7 WE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Everert 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. The Journal of Political Economy The following important articles have ap- peared in recent issues: 2 A Park Street, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 408 Mich. Ave., Chicago 292 Swetiand Bid., Portland 405 Cooper Bid., Denver 238 Dougi’sBid., Los Angeles 618 Peyton Bid., Spokane 2142 Shattuck Ave.,Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all ades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. MAY. GOLD AND PRICES....... J. Laurence Laughlin Send for bulletin. . | AN ECONOMIC HISTORY OF THE ILLINOIS SL | AND MCNNGAN GANA. ©....5. W. Poem Barn Mawr, Pennsylvania. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School JUNE. Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other colleges for | pre ILLINOIS AND MICHIGAN CANAL. II. women. Small classes supplemented by careful in- dividual instruction. Teachers all thoroughly fa- | J. W. Putnam miliar with Bryn Mawr requirements. Tennis and | EXHAUSTED FARMS AND EXHAUSTING basket ball. Eleventh year opens Oct. 6, 1909. TAXATION ceseceseseeeH. J. Davenport | ABSTRACT ECONOMICS ACCORDING TO The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY WORCESTER, MASS. Established in 1856. Aa ideally healthful location. Efficient taculty. Prepara- tion for the best institutions. The Rt. Rev. A. H. Vinton, D.D., LL.D., Visitor. Por Catalogue please address 408EPH ALDEN SHAW, A.M., Headmaster. ] ETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Bethlehem, Pa. Prepares for leading colleges. Catalogue. H. A. FOERING, B.S., Headmaster. SCHUMPETER ..........+++: Alvin 8. Johnson JULY. THE ILLINOIS AND MICHIGAN CANAL. III. J. W. Putoam THE LANGUAGE OF ECONOMICS William Warrand Carlile THE COMMODITIES CLAUSE....L. C. Marshall Every issue contains General Notes, Washington Notes, Book Reviews, and a complete bibliography (about 80 pages) of publications in English, French, German, and Itallan. The New Hudson Shakespeare Edited and revised by BE. CHARLTON BLACK, Protessor of English Literature in Boston Univer. sity, with the co-operation of the late ANDREW J. GEORGE and M. GRANT DANIBLL THE TEMPEST —just Published List price, © cota, Published monthly, except August and September 3.00 A YEAR, IN ADVANCE, 35 CENTS A COPY. Appress Derr 21, THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO, NEW YORK. OTTO HARRASSOWITZ, LEIPZIG. Mailing price, ™ cta, Puntmnep: As You Like It, Mac- and The Mer. ALREADY beth, Henry V, Julius Cmaar, chant of Venice. Six of the remaining volumes will be published in the fall, A more complete announcement of the edition will be seat upon request GINWN AND COMPANY, ty Beacon Street Publishers Boston
Page 3
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 29, 1909. The Week. Insurgency as a temporary condition has plagued the Republican leaders sore- ly. Presumably, they would be still less pleased if Republican insurgency were to become a habit. From that to open rebellion and revolution the descent is easy. There are indications that the minds of men are turning towards the possibility of permanent cleavage with- in Republican ranks. Secretary Mac- Veagh has openly threatened the Repub- licans with a realignment of parties, if the party now in power fails to rec- ognize the changing spirit of the times. Senator Gore’s speech of Saturday was more jesting in He was merely stating facts in saying in tone than import. there are persons in the Democratic party who ought to be in the Republi- can party, and persons in the Repub- lican party who ought to be in the Dem- ocratic party. But we are getting down to something of a programme when Sen- ator Gore advises that the Democrats refrain from putting up candidates against the anti-Cannon Republican Con gressmen. In return—politics always demands something in return—Demo crats running against stand-pat Republi cans ought to have “a reasonable hope of assistance from “progressive” Republi- cans.” What large hopes of a third par- ty, anti-tariff and anti-Trust, Senator La Follette is carrying about with him, one cannot definitely say. Senator Culberson makes a belated and pretty futile attempt to show that the Democratic record on the tariff in Congress was not so bad, after all. The Texas Senator seems to think that a lit- tle ingenious figuring and explaining will correct the impression. First, he asks us to leave out the votes on iron ore, coal, lumber, and hides. On them, he admits, many Democrats went wrong; but those were the very items on which the Democratic party had most explicitly committed itself, and recre- ancy hove is fatal to any pretence of loy- general It is of no avail for i aly to pledges. Senator Culberson to point out that the | Democrats were “in effect unanimous” The Nation. for reducing the duties upon many ar- ticles of common use. The critical votes were those in which Aldrich needed Democratic help, and got it; and he doubtless could have got it, if it had been necessary, on the schedules which Nothing that can be said or alleged now will Senator Culberson specifies. break the effect produced by the display of ratting on the tariff, which Demo- eratic Senators and Representatives have given in the extra session of Con- gress. The country may be disappoint- ed with the measure of tariff revision which the Republicans wil) give it, but nobody can now convince it that it could have got any revision at all if Bryan had been elected. The appointment of William Franklin Willoughby, of State for Porto Rico, to the position of the present Secretary Assistant Director of the Census, is an- other gratifying evidence of the Presi- that highly competent instrument for scien- dent’s desire to make bureau a tific investigation and research. Secre- tary Willoughby has been in the govern- ment service since 1901, serving first in the capacity of Treasurer of Porto Rico, and more recently as Secretary of State for the island the Governor he has aiso acted in his stead. that the of the Census has not been regarded uni- In the absence of To say Bureau formly as a scientific arm of the Fed- eral service, is to put the matter mild- ly. It has been at times a sort of pri- vate hospital run at public expense for the personal parasites of the politicians In the character and competence of the new Director and Assistant Director, we have a guarantee of better things United States New York of the has been conferring bankers about the possible effect of new The Treasurer with bond issues upon the quotations of Gov- ernment securities. The situation makes one thing clear beyond cavil, that the market prices of United States bonds are a very imperfect index of the Fed- eral government’s Tle error dates back at least as far as the publ'- cation of “Triumphant Democracy,” and credit | assumes that the relative credit of this and other countries can be gauged by comparing the prices of public stocks bearing the same nominal rate of inter est. The truth is that our 2 per cents, which are but barely above par, convey a double income to their holders—the banks—besides the advantage of exemp To cent. paid as interest are to be added tion from tax-liability. the 2 per either the profits on the note circula tion based on the bonds in question, or the gains made by holding public depos its for which the bonds stand as secur ity. If it is desired to keep above pat the market quotations of our 28 and 3s there would seem to be an additiona! ground for denying to the purchasers of the new Panama bonds the right to take out circulation based upon the bonds in The dilemma Ad ministration faces is iust If the new Panama bonds are made available question. which the this for circulation, the public credit will! evidently fall, and the 2 per cents may go below par. If the new bonds are not made available for note circulation, an entering wedge will have been driven into the present system of a currency based on deposited securities The of partment of Labor and Commerce before the Law League at Narragansett Pier, dwelt Assistant Secretary the De in his recent speech Commercial upon one great defect in our industrial is the congested labor where labor is greatly There anomaly in Western farmers crying for system. It failure to distribute in demand. is an unmistakable hands and Eastern cities endeavoring at the same time to cope with the prob lem of unemployment. So far as trades unions act as clearing houses for re quests for jobs and demands for work ers, they perform a wublic service no less beneficia] to themeelves than to the country at large Unfortunately, the workers most likely to be stranded, espe cially newly arrived imm/'‘grants, cannot avail themselves of the employment bu We dally of Adam Smith’s dictum, that “after all that has been said of the levity and inconstancy reaus of the trades unjons have to witness the truth of human nature, it appears evident from experience that a man Is of all sorts of luggage the most difficult to be Mr. McHarg urged that forwarded Wash transported.” advices should be to ington regularly as to the condition of
Page 4
88 local labor markets. This is what we do already in the case of the wheat, cotton, and iron markets. It might help in securing a better distribution of labor power throughout the country—a task which the immigration officials may very properly study. Of course, there will be unemployables under any system, for “unemployment” is unfortunately a spe- clalty of some who find that they can live without labor Tne Employers’ Liability Act, passed by Congress on April 22, 1908, cannot be enforced by a suit brought for damages in a State court. This is the unanimous finding of the Connecticut Supreme Court of Errors in a decision handed down last week. The case was one where William H. Hoxie, a train hand, injured in coupling cars by the negligence of a tellow employee, sued the New York, New Haven and Hartford Railroad for damages. It will be remembered that the original employer's liability act was de- clared unconstitutional. The present law was designed to avoid the errors into which the draughtsmen of the original statute had fallen, and was passed at the hot insistence of Mr. Taft’s prede- cessor. The soul of the act is that in industrial accidents arising in inter- state commerce, the employer may not plead in defence the common-law doctrine of fellow-servant. The Connec- ticut decision would seem to imply pri- marily that a Federal court is the only proper forum for damage suits brought under the law in question. It further af- firms that Congress has no power to compel State courts to assume jurisdic- tion in such causes. The unconstitu- tionality of the act is also seemingly implied in that it requires State courts to disregard, in special cases, the law of fellow-servant, irrespective of the particular commonwealth’s law. The Dominion Finance Department has determined to deport the American silver coins now current in Canada. It is estimated that 30 or 40 per cent. of the silver circulating in that country bears the stamp of the American mints. In some of the western provinces fully one-half of the silver coinage emanated from this country. The Canadian banks are to begin impounding the coins in question. When the silver is exchanged, or is redeemed im standard money by our Treasury in units of twenty dollars The Nation. or multiples meses? Canada will have realized about twice as much as is re- quired to purchase silver bullion to re- place the expelled American coins. The other half will be seigniorage, or gain to the government of the Dominion. The acceptance of American silver in Canada has been customary for years, although on this side of the border Canadian sil- ver has generally been received with re- luctance, or accepted only at a discount. “Riches,” according to the proverb, “take wings,” but evidently silver coins that have suffered a seigniorage exemplify the adage only for a time. After all, we have nothing to complain of. The very purpose of exacting a seigniorage on subsidiary coin is to prevent them from seeking a foreign market or the melting-pot. The gain from seigniorage results at issue, and accrues permanent- ly only when the coin remains in circu- lation. When the coins are redeemed, the seigniorage is lost again. To say that Bleriot’s flight across the Channel last Sunday was dramatic is not necessarily to say that it can have no practical results. It may be months before another man will duplicate Bleriot’s exploit, though the chances are that it will be done much sooner. Bleriot himself might not be able to repeat his flight the next half-dozen times he tries, though the chances are that he would. But the practical result of his achievement is in the fact that something which man has done once becomes a spur to a thousand other men to attempt the thing again. It was no utterly wild guess that in this country alone ten thousand men are now experi- menting with airship and aeroplane. A victory like Bleriot’s swells this army of inventors and would-be inventors. Dr. Huntington was long rector of a prominent church in New York; but it is neither that fact, nor the host of friends and admirers he conquered, which invites to newspaper comment upon his career. He was a clergyman who held his own in a day when the clerical profession has been slipping back. Others of his calling have felt this insensible decline of influence and of im- portance, and have by various devices sought to recover lost ground. Some of them have cheapened themselves into vulgar advertisers and sensationalists. Not a few have wreaked themselves upon [ves 89, No. 2300 the j cenmenttiien of the auch: bene made themselves business managers; have organized instead of preaching; made more of clubs and classes than of prayer. All these tendencies of modern organized Christianity beat full upon Dr. Huntington, as they do upon every minister to-day, but he was not swept away by them. Being of his age, he could not help taking of its color. Grace Church has fallen in with the current set towards “the institutional church,” and Dr. Huntington’s firm and directing hand was upon all this multifarious ac- tivity not directly of a religious kind. But he did not waste himself in that sort of effort. He held himself to the older clerical ideal. Of a type which seems to be vanishing, he was a fine illustra- tion of its power, even in a generation grown dull to excellencies such as his. This clergyman remained all his life a student and a thoughtful preacher. If there were groundlings in his audiences —as there are in all churches—he would not stoop to tickle their ears. It was his way to add reflection to knowledge, and to lead his hearers to consider high themes in a spirit of grave inquiry. Dr. Huntington occasionally preached on “current topics,” even on political mat- ters, rarely. Being a citizen of this breathing world, he could not be indif- ferent to what his fellows were think- ing and doing. But in all his attempts to bring lasting truth to bear upon pass- ing events, there was no clamor or pos- turing. It was not essential to his com- fort that the press should print his ser- mons, or that reporters should Jurk in the pews before him, on the watch for some phrase that would look well in a Monday-morning headline. Dr. Hunting- ton was absorbed with the work he had in hand; addressed his immediate au- dience, and cared little for a wider pub- lic, except as it might be reached through those who passed on the im- pulse got from direct contact with him. Last Saturday's great demonstration in London, by workingmen, in behalf of Lloyd-George’s budget, is an indication of what would happen should the Lords throw out the bill. The issue would at once be changed, and a close alliance, if not an actual union, brought about be- tween the Labor party and the Liberals. What such a step might easily mean in electoral returns, was shown a few days Rita, ph et tan ies i a ee
Page 5
~~ July 29, 1909] The Nation. ago in the bye-election in Mid-Derby- shire. There the Liberals and the La- bor party put up unitedly as candidate a member of the latter. He was elected by a majority of 2,343. This, to be sure, was less than the abnormal majority of 3,509 which the Liberals obtained in 1906, but is more than double the Liber- al majority in the three previous elec- tions. Mr. Balfour is certain to think twice before provoking everywhere a combination that would be so formidable for the Conservatives to face. At the moment unexpected, M. Clemen- ceau’s fall does not come ultogether as a surprise. And the reason why this veteran politician has been latterly ex- posed to defeat rests, oddly enough, in the fact that logically he is the best man for his place, and that the majority of Frenchmen seem to have felt this to be so. Between revolutionary radical- ism and the old forces of reaction, M. Clemenceau has held the balance, not too rigidly, perhaps, but as well as might be, under the circumstances. The Right and Moderates, up to the recent postal strike, reproached him with making con. cessions to the lawless elements. But to have expected the Premier to take drastic measures against labor agita- tion would be to overlook the strength of the 1adica] idea in France, manifest- ing itself in gradations from Clemen- ceau and Briand, through Combes and Jaurés, to Gustave Hervé. On the oth- er hand, when the labor agitators begz.n to threaten the Government itself, M. Clemenceau put his foot down with a degree of emphasis that won the appro- bation of even the Right. But if Clem- enceau could adapt himself to the vary- ing moods of the French people, he could not hope to cope permanently with the shifting moods of Parliament. Holding the balance redounds to the benefit of the people, but it creates numerous ha- treds in the hearts of Deputies. And sometimes the sum total of such hatreds is enough to swamp a logical majority The immediate cause of the overturn would really seem to have been his sharp tongue. An assured majority was turned into a minority by the Cham- ber’s anger at the introduction of per- sonal acrimony into a debate on what is probably the most serious question of the moment in France—the pitiful state of disorganization and corruption in the Navy Department. Here was 4 vital problem discussed by Delcassé, one of the most serious statesmen France As the head of the committee that laid bare con- has produced in many a day. ditions in the navy, Delcassé was speak- ing with knowledge and authority. At such a time, to evoke wantonly the un- happy memories of the Moroccan cris‘s of 1905, turned out for M. Clemenceau a fatal mistake. Nobody in Germany appears to be pleased with the financial compromise which the Government finally accepted. in place of the ambitious scheme sub- mitted to the Reichstag which was to wipe out deficits, consolidate the im- perial finances, and make ample provi- sion for the future, the outcome is a thing of shreds and patches. A series of rough-and-ready taxes was adopted, the yield and incidence of which can- not be predicted. The chief new or in- creased imposts are upon beer and spir- its, tobacco and matches, and coffee. Then there is the tax on dividends and interest —the Cotierungssteuer—which was so strongly opposed by financial cir- cles, but which finally they acquiesced The of ficial estimate is that the added taxa- in as a disagreeable necessity. tion will bring in a revenue of $125,000,- 000. But this is confessed to be large- ly guess-work. The Norddeutscher Zeitung recalls the fact that the tax re- forms of 1906 were figured by the Gov- ernment to produce between $50,000,000 and $55,000,000, though in the event the return was only $25,000,000. Should the present estimate prove equally over-san- guine, the Government would be far from out of the financial woods. In any case, the circumstances under which the Government was forced to compro- mise made a bad political impression. One feature of the German financial compromise was not reported in the cable dispatches. It was announced in the Reichstag that the Government pro- posed to bring in a bill for taxing the unearned increment in land. In order to give due notice to all concerned, the new measure is to be introduced not lat- er than April, 1911, and to go into effect one year from that date. And the yield of the tax is estimated at $5,000,000. Meanwhile, a check is to be put to mu- nicipal experiments in taxing the land 89 increment. As is well known, several German cities have resorted to this form of taxation, with varying success. Their experience has been cited on both sides of the debate now going on in the House of Commons over the proposed taxation of the unearned increment in England. But when the new Imperial tax of that kind is levied in Germany, municipalities are to go no further with it. It is, indeed, may retain the revenue already accru- but the further experimenting with a tax about provided that they ing from this source up to 1917; whose operation little, confessedly, is known, will be done by the Imperial government. This last decision seems rather a pity, for the tax is, in the na- ture of the case, almost confined to ur- ban and suburban land, and one would think that the cities could best feel their way in this sort of nove] taxing South America’s present state of mind may be described as one of belligerency modified by a strong aversion to fight- ing, and ignorance as to who ought to fight whom. But since the beginning of the trouble we have had discussions on the possibility of war between Bo- livia and Peru, Bolivia and Brazil, and Chili and Peru. That war between Bo- livia and Argentina should even be sug- gested, throws a new light on the diffi- cult problems of international arbitra- tion. The parties to the original dis- pute were Bolivia and Peru; the judge was Argentina. Here, then, is a claim- ant who is net only dissatisfied with the award, but wants to fight the arbi- trator. Evidently, the nation that sits in judgment between her fellows must be either so much more powerful or 80 much weaker than either of the liti- gants as to make it impossible for the judge to be drawn into the dispute. Pro- fessor Scott, in his new work on the Hague Peace Conferences, points out the defects in arbitration by a sovereign. The case is submitted to him without argument, and he decides solely on docu- mentary evidence; his decision “does not, as a rule, state the reasoning by which the conclusion is reached”: and, consequently, the judgment is of little value as a precedent. And, finally, there are the sovereign’s own interests, which, in a dispute between Peru and Bolivia, would have made the President of Switzerland a_ better than the President of Argentina qualified judge
Page 6
The Nation. REPRESENTATION IN THEORY AND | the wider area of allegiance—but with YO IN FACT. The student of politics is not infre quently confronted with a difficulty pe cullar to that science. It is, to realize the identity of an institution described in the text-book with the real thing when studied at close range. Blackstone and John Adams each in his way befogged the students of political institutions for generations. Blackstone made cur- rent the idea that the British Consti- tution was a complicated maze of in- terrelated powers and forces into whose ultimate nature it were almost irrever- ent to peer. John Adams hopelessly mis- guided many a student of American Con- stitutional law by his juggling of “checks and balances.” Not until Bage hot simply blew away the idea of “pa- per Constitutions,” did we begin to see some reservations as to particular du- ties to specific constituencies. One more matter settled in advance, and our Mal- tian is ready to buy a railway ticket to What is the ideal basis of Shall it the numbers of the population solely, with Washington. representation? be on the attendant danger of the gerryman- der? Or ought particular interests, like the laboring class, the farming class, the professional and the trading class, to send from their own ranks avowed ad- vocates of these special interests? Thrice-armed with the knowledge of the schools, our celestial visitant, let us the night express for suppose, takes | Washington with letters of introduction something of the reality of present-day | politics. But the old method is less eas- ily banished for good than temporarily exiled. Only contrast the “paper” theory of representation in some of the mod- ern books on politics, with the actual situation as it appears to an intelligent person at Washington, provided he has never caught the infection of so-called political science. The theory and the fact of represen- tation will furnish a crucial illustration. If the traditional Mars were to make us a visit to study our system of government, we may imag- ine him providing himself, let us say, of visitor from with Professor Jenks’s “Principles Politics.” Under the title, “Representa tion,” our Martian would first find the query propounded whether the M.C. o1 the M.P. should act as a representative, using his independent judgment on dis puted issues, or as a delegate simply re- cording the preponderant view of the district for which he stands. The alternative is commonly resolved in favor of the representative as against the delegate, though the ideal superior- ity of the first has never been put more forcibly than by Macaulay, whose ver- dict that the should choose wisely and then confide freely in their After the ideal character of the legislator has been set- was electorate representative tled, the next issue raised concerns his allegiance—shall it be primarily to his constituents, or to the wider public, the country at large? Here the polifi- cal doctors, Professor among them, resolve the queastio tavor of Jenks for example, to those in actual touch with affairs. What chance is there that he could dis- cover M.C. who would even avow that his allegiance in tariff-making was primarily to the nation as a whole? There would doubtless be many eager to protest that they are fighting tooth and nail, each for his own district. But if the man from Mars should follow them up, and ask how they had discov- ered the interest of their own constit- infallibly ascertain an uencies, he would that a few influential persons whose profits are primarily at stake were the sole exponents, or alleged exponents, of the wishes or interests of the various districts. The truth is that in tariff- making the M.C. can hardly be called a delegate, let alone a representative. e ‘s practically the special agent of the veciferous industrial parasite that has fastened on the country, but lives in his bailiwick. The present situation. is quite plain. The ony pretends to represent the is outside of Congress perscn wW.0 interest altogether. Congress is making an or- ganized effort to betray the general in- terest, and is stopped only by the power and influence of the President of the United States. So far as the idea cf representation general based on classes is concerned, it is near- er the truth to say that, instead of not having introduced it into this country, we do not know any other system. Of course, the facts are carefully concealed. The agents of the cotton interests, for example, are disguised as members of Congress from certain enumerated dis- tricts. They commonly wear masks of partisan principles, or goggles and false beards that are stamped with geograph- [Vol. 89, No. 2300 They are themselves even into a real belief in their own personal rectitude and indepen- dence. But unless there were an ob- stacle to their power, they would mark cash deposits for their ultimate political creators with the regularity of a cash ical labels. hypnotized register. If a realist were to etch the outlines of our system of representation, it might run somewhat as follows: Per- sonal ambition, a certain grade of ability, and amenability to the party machine will secure a nomination for Congress. This selection of the machine will be ratified at a so-called popular election. When a tariff measure is un- der discussion, the large contributors to the machine pull the wires that jerk the elected member. The clash of interests arranges through Congressional commit- tees, and finally through a conference committee, a treaty that is as satisfac- tory a division of plunder as circum- The cost is paid by the “myth.” stances permit. ultimate consumer, who is a Barring any opposition from the rep- resentative of the “myths,” to wit, the President of the United States, the rep- resentative system works to enrich its manipulators by a wholesale betrayal of the country at large. THE NEW PROSPERITY. It needs not the assurances of finan- ciers returning from vacation, to con- vince the American people that better times are ahead. The signs of rapid and large recovery from our two years’ de- pression are unmistakable. The country vas even left off waiting for the pas sage of the tariff bill to “give the sig- nal.” Customs duties do not make pros- perity; they can neither keep it when we have got it, nor retard it when it is coming back. Natural law, combined with the moral qualities of personal saving, economies in manufacture, prud- ence, enterprise, is doing the business. Even European observers, as recent financial dispatches have been showing, are now convinced, after long skepticism, that the American outlook is extremely bright. Prosperity is coming, but it will not be the old prosperity. We refer not to its outward form or bulk or duration, but to its spirit. The enlarged business which is before us, the new displays of energy, the further growth and achieve-
Page 7
bv /S July 29, 1909] ments of capital fruitfully employed in corporations and otherwise, will be marked by other methods. We shall not easily drop back into the old style of conducting the great business of the country. It is necessary and timely to dwell upon this, because many have been persuading themselves that the excite- ments, the reforms, the painful inches of progress gained in the past few years, were all to go for nothing and that we should settle back with swinish com- placency into the mire where we for- merly wallowed. And the evidence that this is not to be is plainly angering “To be blunt, of the Union League Club to the Sun the other day, “William Howard Taft is a great disappointment to a host of peo- many. wrote a member ple who had been looking to March 4 for a material change from things past to things to come.” The implication of such complaints is obvious. Reckless financiers had felt themselves disagreeably checked in their operations. They had intensely disliked the publicity, the inspection, the regula- tion to which their proceedings had been subjected. And it was a flattering unction to lay to their souls that all of that would pass away with a change of Administration. But they ought to have been keen enough to perceive that no force is lest in the pol‘tical and business world, any more tran in the physical The efforts recently made to render business cleaner, and to hold corpora- tions to a stricter accountability, were often violent, frequently ill-judged, and sometimes were but a tool in the hand of political ambition; but their intent in the minds of the people was honest and their effects were wholesome. Those effects will abide with us. Business will soon be larger than before, but it will be managed more cautiously and with more integrity than before. The coun- sels which we have taken to heart in a period of adversity, will not be wholly ignored when prosperity returns. There will not be so many impudent flotations, so many secret manipulations of prop- erty, near the verge of the criminal law. Promoters may hate the new provisions for inquiry and publicity, but they will also dread them, and work under a salutary fear that they may be applied to their combinations at any mo ment. A saner spirit and sounder meth- ods will be visible in cur great entre- The Nation. preneurs and administrators of vast ca} ital. It was, in many respects, a very try ing time which we were called upon to go through—a period of clamor, of wild and whirling words. Put it was not en tirely destructive. Out of the confusion have emerged certain large and clear principles, and they will remain in force Public service corporations, for exam ple, can never, not even by all the king’s horses and all the king's men, be put back where they were before if any of them hereafter are tempted t& ask what the public has to do with their affairs, they wiil find that it has everything to do. And the same thing is true, to an extent, cf every other kind of large business that touches our citl- zenship at a thousand points. A new attitude as come and it will persist The ease with which the corporation tax is slipping through Congress, de spite the intense opposition of powerful interests, is a clear proof that thé pop- ular temper is inclined to step forward rather than backward. No appeal by creatures of government, such as cor porations are, against government “pry ing into our affairs,” will longer avail The answer is very like what Gov Hughes is reported to have said last ear when a delegation from the Stock Exchange urged him to minit him self against an investigation: “If your books are clean, you have no reason t fear an investigation; and if they are not clean, you ought to be investigated.” After investigation, the Stock Ex- change found itself rather helped than hurt. the minor Hughes’s Commission will be carried out in good faith. “Unlisted stocks,’ for example, are to be known no more in the Exchange, after April 1, 1910 Such a move for improvement in busi- And the assurance is given that reforms urged by Gov ness methods is an admirable example of the way in which wise and far-sighted men will seek to adjust themselves t? the new conditions. By holding fast to the good results worked out in our late troublous days, by accepting construc- tively the teachings of the dear school of experience, they will at once reassure the public, attract new confidence with new business, and cause the coming prosperity to be, in Oliver Cromwell's phrase, “without a worm in ag 1 FRANCE AND EUROPE M. Briand’s Cabinet, the practical com pletion of which is announced, makes greater changes than were expected. Six Clemenceau men are left, six new men ire coming in. As if to offset the pres ence of a former militant Socialist at the head of the Ministry, the other new members show a decided lurch to mod eratism. M. Cochery, the new Minister f Finance, is more conservative than Lis predecessor, M. Caillaux. Millerand who becomes Minister of Public Works, was once a terror to the bourgeo'sie, but has long since grown tame For the war and navy portfolios M Briand seems to have gone to professicnal men who are not so well known as Gen Picquart and M. Picard, but who need not therefore be the less efficient Under Clemenceau, the French Repub lic was more than usually forward in the eye of the world. Its internal his tory for the period covers the epoch- making rupture of the connection be tween State and Church, the rise of a tormidable revolutionary movement among the working classes, the appear- ance of the anti-militarist doctrine of the picturesque M. Hervé, and, in a nar- rower political sphere, the partial dis- integration of the Republican bloc which since 1899 had ruled the country. Abroad, the Clemenceau Government had ta wea ther a steady succession of crises in its relations with Germany, inher.ted from preceding Ministries; to carry on a diffi- cult and dramatic campaign in Morocco; and to draw tighter the connection with England under stress of danger from be- yond the Rhine. Where France was not directly a party to a quarrel, as in the Balkan crisis of 1908, she was neverthe- less compelled to play an important part as the nucleus in a scheme of alliances and understandings which upheld the European balance of power against Ger- many and the Triple Alliance. Viewed in its broadest aspects, the Clemenceau régime was more than ordinarily suc- cessful. The Separation problem was solved, and the other internal questions we have mentioned were dealt with ag ably as might be. The fore'gn prestige of France, Clemenceau left much higher than he found it. Now that Briand has stepped into the Premiership, it is hardly conceivable that any sharp departure in policy wil! ensue. And this is not merely because Clemenceau’s defeat is known to have
Page 8
92 T he Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2300 been largely of the nature of a person- al reprimand involving no condemna- tion of the Government's general con- duct. A new French Parliament is to be elected in the spring of 1910, and it stands to reason that no new Ministry will tamper with the principles that enabled Clemenceau to round out the longest Premiership in the history of the Third Republic. But aside from such practical reasons, there can be no doubt that a Radical government best suits the present temper of the French people. The general election of May, 1906, gave the Radical parties some 400 votes against 180 of the Opposition. If Clemenceau thinned down his majority by sending the Socialists disgruntled out of camp, he could afford to do so, because, splendid parliamentary tacti- clan that he was, he could count on the support of the Moderate Opposition, just when the Socialists were the most re- fractory. He did this on the question of Morocco, during the strike trouble among the miners of the North, and in the recent postal-strike. But even Clemenceau came to grief when he let himself put his trust in a paper majority of something less than one hundred. All the more reason for his successor to rally the entire Radi- cal strength, and by winning back the friendship of the Socialists to cement anew the old Republican bloc. Such a consummation, the greater number of Radicals have long been devoutly wish- ing; for the breaking of the old elec- toral pact with the Socialists has cost them more than one seat In the bye-elec- tions. Winning back the Socialists, how- ever, is not an easy task, unless the Gov- ernment is willing to go in for Radl- calism with a vengeance. What a Min- istry in alliance with the Socialists could have done in the postal-strike ex- cept surrender to the strikers, is hard to see. But, presumably, no such crisis will recur before election, and until that time a Briand may satisfy Jaurés and his followers with small concessions and sweet promises, while Jaurés may find it possible to forget that Briand Is a renegade and a reactionary. Thus Clem- enceau’s friends and some of his ene- mies may get together, but that Clem- enceau’s policies will be overturned does not follow. It is to be truce within the old bloc till next year. After that, qui vivra verra. Still less chance is there for a sudden alteration in the foreign policy of the Though Delcassé brought about Clemenceau’s downfall, the return to power of the Minister French government. whom William II forced out of office can come only when the country shall swerve sharply from Radicalism and the policy of peace with Germany, and a Moderate Ministry, prepared to fight Germany with England’s assistance, shall come into power. Such a contin- gency is still remote. It may be that fear of Jaurés and his phalanx may bring it about, but at present it is generally con- ceded that the policy of M. Pichon, Clemenceau’s Foreign Minister, is the policy the country wants. In general, the probabilities are that foreign affairs in the immediate future will not be so prominently to the front in France as they have been these four years. Mo- rocco remains a cause of some anxiety, but in view of the recent agreement be- tween France and Germany concerning Morocco, a repetition of the acute crises of 1905 and later years can hardly be looked for. The troubled boundary for some time to come will be not the Rhine, but the North Sea. Since the latest Dreadnought attack broke out, France has been conspicuously out of the diplomatic news. Her concern in the development of Anglo-German relations is, of course, of the first order. In fact, if not in name, England and France are now allies. But while the two rivals of the sea are disputing, a French Minis- try will pretty surely give its main at- tention to affairs at home. THE FIGHT AGAINST OPIUM. The Hague, which seems destined to become a permanent base of operations for international campaigning against all forms of human ill, may soon have a conference to discuss the international control of the production, manufacture, and sale of opium. Our State Depart- ment has extended invitations for such a conference to the governments that took part in the Shanghai Opium Com- mission of last February. These govern- ments were the United States, China, Great Britain, France, Germany, Japan. the Netherlands, Portugal, Russia, and Siam. With the results of the Shanghai meeting, opinion in this country and in Europe professed itself much disappoint ed at the time. The commission in its report seemed to have confined itself to the expression of those pious wishes which Hague conferences of another kind have made familiar. In addition, it was reported that Great Britain’s atti- tude at Shanghai was responsible for the failure of positive results. Our State Department, however, takes a different view of the Shanghai Com- mission. It observes that the commis- sion “was one of inquiry only,” that its function was “to study the opium prob- lem and report as to the best and most feasible means of solving it,” and that this programme was executed “to the entire satisfaction of the governments concerned.” Bishop Brent, who presided over the Shanghai Commission, declar- ed in his inaugural address: It devolves upon me to pronounce with emovhasis that this is a commission, and as those who are informed—as all of you must be in matters that pertain to international affairs of this kind—a commission is not a conference. The idea of a conference was suggested, but it seemed wise to choose this particular form of action rather than a conference, because, for the present, at any rate, we are not sufficiently well informed and sufficien:!y unanimous in our attitude to have a conference with any great hope of immediate success. The commission embodied its findings in a set of resolutions. In imitation of the example given by China and other governments, every government was urged to take steps for the suppression of opium-smoking within its territories. The unrestricted manufacture, sale, and distribution of morphine constituted a great and growing danger; drastic reg- ulation was immediately needed. Re- search for the purpose of finding scien- tific remedies against the opium habit was recommended. In some form or oth- er, nearly every government regulates the use of opium for other than medical purposes, but a uniform code of pro- cedure was desirable. In the specific case of China, the commission agreed that the government’s efforts to suppress the opium habit were sincere and productive of real, if somewhat “unequal,” results; but urged that foreign governments should take measures for the suppres sion of the opium dens within their Chi- nese concessions; and that all govera- ments should take steps to prevent the shipment of opium or its derivatives and preparations to any country which pro- hibits their entry. The campaign against opium is an in- ternational one, but primarily it is a Chinese and British question; for China is notoriously the worst sufferer by the meee 2 RE Rs er eter PORN 2in [re ee ae
Page 9
July 29, 1909] The Nation. drug habit, and British India is the great source o! opium supply. China followed up her anti-opium edict of 1906 by an agreement with the British-In- dian government under which the sup- pression of opium cultivation within China and the importation of the drug from India were to be done away with in ten years. Its total importation of 51,000 chests, the Indian government was to reduce by 5,100 chests every year, until 1917. The Chinese government, with characteristic enthusiasm, set to work at taking its own opium lands out of cultivation. The Indian government, however, was not convinced that China was carrying out her part of the bar- gain. The British delegates at the Shanghai Commission moved a resolution regretting China’s inability to produce trustworthy statistical evidence on the question. The resolution was withdrawn, but it showed the British temper. China, on the other hand, proposed that foreign governments should pledge themselves to reduce their exportation of opium to China in proportion to the reduced pro- duction of the drug within the Empire. This had it been agreed to and ratified, China resolution was also withdrawn; might conceivably have wiped out Brit ish importations at one blow by enforce. ing total and immediate prohibition of opium-growing within her boundaries. In choosing The Hague for the next opium conference, our government international At Shanghai, British and Chinese representatives are adroitly emphasizes the aspect of the question. in danger of consulting their own inter- With the eyes of the world fixed upon them at The Hague, Great Britain and China both will be the ests too closely. measurably forced into viewing question from the most enlightened standpoint possible. The ultimate root- ing up of the drug evil is a certainty. It is only a question of how sharply or how tenderly the problem should be ap- proached. LAWYERS AND THE PUBLIC. Several recent addresses before asso- ciations of the bar have betokened a stirring of the legal conscience on the question of the lawyer’s profession be- ing one peculiarly “affected with a pub- lic interest.” At the annual meeting of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, one speaker dwelt upon the urgent demand for reforms in the law, and called upon his brethren to see to it that this debt to their profession was discharged in the spirit of a Romilly. Still more point- ed was the language used by a member of the Illinois Bar Association. He put these searching questions to his fellows: What have the lawyers of Illinois done for the improvement of the administration of justice? What have they done to advance the interests of litigants. to secure justice to poor persons, to expedite the transaction of business, to simplify methods of proced- ure, or to aid in the proper and prompt enforcement of the criminal laws? Practi- eally nothine. The obligation is not denied. It presses with singular force upon law- yers, they the ought to be expert in the matter. They have much more to do than any other because are men who class with the enactment of laws. Every Legislature, as well as Congress, has a far larger proportion of lawyers in its membership than of any other group— often, larger than that of all other groups together. To this initial respon- sibility has to be added the fact that the the law, in the multiplying of technical- in practice and interpretation of ities, the overlaying of statutes with wire-drawn distinctions, the delays of trial, the trying of cases like the playing of a game of skill, rather than as a means of doing substantial justice, the legal profession is most directly con cerned. The evils are admitted. Judges dwell upon them. The leaders of the bar call for their correction Public opinion is urgent for reforms. Yet how little is attempted, much less accom- plished. We would not say that the great body of lawyers are unmindful of their duty Yet not to the public in this respect. we think it evident that we the law, have so many men eminent in as we once had, who are jealous for the stand- ing and usefulness of their profess on. swift to condemn abuses, and incessant in efforts to make the law a great in- strument of justice. The lawyer-publicist is not so frequent a figure with us as he This was remarked by Mr the used to be. Bryce, when he in 1904. pressions revisited country an article giving his im the In of since he made his first studies here, he changes in America mentioned the diminution, and well- nigh disappearance, of the class of great lawyers who gave of their time and strength not only to legal reform but to the leadership of all good public causes. James C. Carter was preéminently such 93 aman; and it is not invidious to ask what lawyer is to-day in this city filling the void made by his death. Certain insensible changes in the legal profession have partly accounted for the difference which Mr. Bryce noted. The immense growth of corporations, and the glittering prizes which they have held out to able lawyers, have tended both to specialize and narrow the activ- ity of the leading men at the bar. In their hands, the law has become in a sort commercialized. We use the word fn no offensive sense. Legal advice has been necessary to captains of industry. Vast undertakings have needed the skill- of lawyers at every step of the ed service and conduct, with of the first their formation result that many minds in the law have become rather business men than lawyers. Their range is not so great as that of the older practition- ers; it is harder for them to conceive of the law as a whole, ard of their profes- sion as One that calls for service of the it public, as well as of their clients is inevitable, then, that the lawyer as a publicist—we do not say office-holder— should seem to be sinking below our hor: zon It is a loss wiich is troubling other ountries than our own. English juris- | prudence is not what thoughtful men feel that it ought to be. In Germany, too, there is uneasiness about the drift in the Jegal profession. A university pro- | fessor had an article recently in the Frankfurter Zeitung, pointing out the dangers of a too technical attitude on | } the part of lawyers. According to him, reform should begin in the law-schools He ly grounded in the essential differences would have law-students thorough- between law and justice—Gesetz and Recht—and trained to think more care fully of their relations to the public. We know, too, that many who are con- cerned about legal education in our own land, are thinking along the same lines A high sense of civic duty cannot be di rectly taught. But the right ideal can be held un. and the inspiring example A doubtless always approach the law mere given. certain number of men will ly as a means of livelihood—simply an alternative to any other mode of secur- ing bread and butter. And some men can be prevented by no teach'ng in the law-schools from selling their talents to the highest bidder. But something might be done by professors of law, as
Page 10
94 we are aware that numbers of them are fully convinced, by insisting from the first that the lawyer not only has ser- vices to offer to individuals, but that he is also a “friend of the court,” in the sense of being a lover of justice, and that he should be ever ready to meet a reasonable public demand for improve- ments in the law, so that its processes may be made speedy, sure, and just. ANATOLE FRANCE.* I. The translation of the works of Ana- tole France, now proceeding under the editorship of Mr. Frederic Chapman, brings into the ken of English and American readers the most distinguish- ed Frenchman of letters living to-day. We shall await with interest the verdict of the Cisatlantic branch of the Anglo- Saxon court upon his claim to a high rank in international glory. It is not without significance that he comes to us In a somewhat expensive edition lim- ited to five hundred copies Obviously, his publishers do not expect to win for him at once the popular suffrage. Doubt- less, they estimate their public wisely For M. France comes from the nation most in love with pure ideas to the na- tion most hostile to them. From a peo- ple using speech to reveal thought, he comes to a people using speech to con- ceal thought For a mercurial folk of much external sociability he will find us singularly close-mouthed about all even when skep- like wild intimate concerns reticent about religion: oul tical creatures, ashamed of our loves: pre- ferring even to cast a veil of divine illusion over our business enterprises. Partly from habit and partly from a shrewd sense that publicity does not pay, such a book as M. France's recently published “L’lle des Pingouins” (the translation has not yet appeared) could pores! bly among us—not hecause it is bold, but because its bold- ness nothing serviceable Those who have a curious de- sire to know what the world is thinking about in theee days, no matter whether it pays or not, are pleased when Anatole France brings out a new book. Il, Many years ago Jules Lemattre, fining for himself the charm of Anatole said, “Je sens son @muvre ce qui l'a pré- not originate comes to however de- France's work, toute pleine de tout cédé; j'y découvre le plus ré- cent 6tat de conscience of I'humanité soit parvenue.” That is, indeed, part of its fascination: it represents in let- ters what Mona Lisa represents, accord- *The Works of Anatole France. New York: Joho Lane Company L'tle dea Pingowine Calmann-Lévy By Anatole France. Paris; The Nation. ing to Pater, in art—the “summing up in itself all modes of thought and life.” In his books one escapes from the shal- low modernity of contemporary litera- ture. He is a cosmopolitan not merely of the present year of grace; he was a citizen of the world before the Christian era. A leisurely aristocrat, polished, imperturbable, he has strolled with ironic smile among the neglected ruins of antiquity. He has discussed Greek philosophy in the Tusculan villa with Cicero, sauntered over the Aventine chatting with Horace, and listened with while Virgil read to the grief-stricken household his divine praise of the young Marcellus. He ob- served the strange star in the East, heard the stories of Lazarus and Mag- dalen, and dined with Pilatus, Procura- tor of Judea. In the Egyptian desert he occupied a cell with the Christian cenobites; in Alexandria he tasted the last luxuries of the pagan world. He caught from the catacombs the fervent murmur of prayer and the mysterious hymns of martyrs. He saw with a re- geretful smile nymphs and dryads and fauns at twilight scurrying through the country woodlands in terror of the cathedral bell. A lover of masquerade, he has crept into the cassock of medi- eval monks, and gravely announced the performance of miracles, or discoursed upon the lusts of the flesh and the pride of life, or whiled away long hours on a settle in the cloister splitting theologi- cal hairs with the church fathers. Espe- cially, he has haunted the steps of the Brides of Christ, irresistibly drawn by the allurement of their celestial roses, hoping, perhaps, to catch a drop of the spilled milk of Paradise. And all this he has told, not as one passing feverish- ly through successive stages of intellec- tual intoxication, but as one sitting at his ease and leaning indolently out from a casement in Elysium. More fascinating than all this select- ed world-experience is the point of view of the narrator. He keeps us wonder- ing where he is. The detachment of M. France is not that of Flaubert or Mau- passant. The realist withdraws a little from his object to gain the proper focus for his microscope. He is never- theless savagely absorbed in it. He means to bring it home to us, to make us enter into it and feel it tingling in our five senses. M. France, on the oth- er hand, seeks to tranquillize the senses. He contemplates the troubled face of the world through serene leagues of mo- tionless ether. He will report mundane affairs not to the prurient ears of mor- tals, but to the gods of Epicurus who inhabit the quiet above the clouds and winds, and feel from time to time a mild amusement in the human spec- tacle. Passing beyond the flaming ram- parts of the world, he would enter the celestial hall where the blithe Immor- tals revel, crying: O Shining Ones, bowed head [Vol. 89, No. 2300 let me, a mortal, share your feast. I have withdrawn my heart and hope from among the miserable race of men. For they come out of the darkness and struggle like beasts in the brief light and go into the darkness again. All their achievements are but as the excel- lencies of worms differing among one another. They are rent with a love more cruel than the grave. They are burnt in the fire of their own flesh. They are terrified by the shadows which they cast upon eternity. But I have learn- ed the secret of your immortal calm. I have found that there is peace for those content to perceive and not to possess the world. I have learned to look upon the labors of Hercules without desire to lift a finger, upon the temptations of St. Anthony without desire to sin, upon the crucifixion of martyrs without desire to weep. For to the ego wisely isolated from the contagious fevers of existence all these things are but as the fierce vexation of a dream. Make me, there- fore, a place beside you, and I will teil you tales of men, provoking supernal smiles. III. When M. France, after forty years of philosophical romancing in the garden of Epicurus, published his “Vie de Jeanne d’Arc,” the professional histor- ians were shocked and the Ep‘cureans were perplexed. It did not seem quite respectful to the Muse of History, for the author of “Le Lys Rouge” to pre- sent her with the life of the virgin of Domrémy. On the other hand, it appear- ed out of character for the author of “M. Jér6éme Coignard” to take the schol- arly ideal so seriously. To most of his followers his perilous charm had been that he always seemed to say—Mr. George Santayana has said it, too, in three lines of an admirable sonnet: The crown of olive let another wear; It is my crown to mock the runner’s heat With gentle wonder and with laughter sweet. Nor was it clear what garland a novice of over three-score could hope to win in the trite and well-gleaned field of his- tory where he made his début. To be sure, some critics tried to show that this work did not really represent a new departure in M. France’s development; for, they said, even in his romances he had been an historian, as even in his history he had been a romancer. Both views are partly right; the life of Jeanne d’Arc was, in a sense, only the latest in a long series of imaginative saints’ lives. But there was a differ- ence. How explain the lengthy preface discussing predecessors, theories of his- tory, original documents? M. France had sent his fine Ariel often enough among ancient Ibraries, but had never allowed him to appear in the sunlight with dust on his wings. What convic-
Page 11
; . 5 a “4 i] e - 3 5 Sintead “saa tae (ea Oe NAS oat res July 29, 1909] tion, slowly formulating, had brought this volant, elusive spirit, this mock- ing beguiler of an empty day, into step with his sober contemporaries? Let us not attempt to discover, said M. Achille Luchaire, reviewing the first volume of the work, ne cherchons pas a pénétrer le mystére de cette évolution. M. France has something of Prosper Mérimée’s repugnance to being divin- ed. On the heels of “Jeanne d’Arc,” as if anxious to complicate the chart of his evolution, he sends a satirical after- piece, “L’lle des Pingouins,” which dis- sipates in peals of derisive laughter any notion that its author has joined the modern historians. This, too, is a his- tory prefaced by a critical account of sources: but, though shorter, it is much more comprehensive than its forerun- ner. It is an abridgment of all history that has been or_ shall be, under the form of a_ veiled comic history of France. “In spite of the apparent di- versity of the amusements which seem to attract me,” begins the preface in the old ironical vein, “my life has only one object. It is wholly bent toward the accomplishment of one great de sign. I am writing the history of the Penguins.” In the search for the bur- ied monuments of this people, contin- ues the author, “I excavated by the seashore an unviolated tumulus; I found in it, according to custom, stone axes, swords of bronze, Roman coins, and a twenty-sous piece with the “head of Louis-Philippe I, King of the French.” Embarrassed by difficulties attendant on the interpretat‘on of conflicting evi- dence, the historian called in counsel several eminent archeologists and paleographers—“They looked at me with a smile of pity which seemed to say: “Do we write history? Do we at- tempt to extract from a text, from a document, the least scrap of life or truth? We publish texts pure and sim- ple. We stick to the letter. The letter alone is appreciable and definite. The spirit is not: ideas are crotchets. One must be very presumptuous -to.write history; one must have imagination.’”’ A surviving historian of the old school was more encouraging—“Why take the trouble to compose a history when you have only to copy the standard works, as every one does. One word more. If you wish your book to be wel- comed, neglect no opportunity to ex- tol the virtues upon which societies are based: devotion to riches, p'ous senti- ments, and especially the resignation of the poor, which is the foundation of or- der. Assert, sir, that the origins of property, nobility, and gendarmery will bé treated Ifi your history with all the respect which these institutions merit. Have -it-understood that you admit the superfiatural when it appears. On that condition you will succeed in geod com- pany.”-—“]_ have meditated these judi- clous-obseryations,” says M. France de- The Nation. “and have paid good heed to murely, them.” lV. The narrative, accordingly, begins with the apostolic calling of Saint Maél, his wonderful conversions, his wide wanderings, and finally his voyage in a miraculous stone trough over the tur- bulent Northern Sea to an undiscovered | island. After a detour of the place, the holy man, somewhat advanced in age and understanding, comes upon a circle of penguins. Mistaking them for a prim itive heathen people, Saint Maél explains to them successively Adoption, Rebirth Regeneration, and then in three days and three nights baptizes them all. “When the baptism of the penguins was known in Heaven,” proceeds the historian with the suave gravity which heightens the effect of his daring, “it caused there neither joy nor sorrow, but extreme surprise. The Lord himself was embarrassed. He called an assembly of scholars and theologians and asked them if they considered the baptism valid.” As the result of a long, hot debate, participated in by Saint Pat- Illumination and rick and Saint Catherine, Saint Augus- Saint Anthony Tertullian Orosius,and Saint Gregory of Nazianzen tine and with interposed questions and objec. tions by the Lord, it was decided that the penguins must be changed into men And it was done. Thus does M. France admit the supernatural, when it ap- pears! Since Lucian set the infernal gods quarrelling over ferry hire in Hades, dramatized the loves of the Olympians, and represented Zeus, when Timon began to rail, as inquiring cas- ually of Hermes what dirty fellow was bawling from Attica beside Hymettus, no one, perhaps, has dealt so unabash- edly with the reigning dynasty of the | Heavenly Ones. A late unpersecuted Vol- taire—tolerance has made a long march since the eighteenth century—he would gently laugh Jehovah out of Paradise Rien n'est plus Viche, says Pascal, que de faire le brave contre Dieu. True, one can fancy Anatole France replying, but see! The walls of chrysoprase, the sol- emn temples of the twelve-gated city are fast dissolving like an insubstan- tial pageant of the air. Is it not better to smile than to weep? With similar fidelity to the instruc- tions of his adviser against disparaging sacred institutions, M. France describes the origins of “property, nobility, and gendarmery.” Shortly after the baptism and transformation of the penguins, they begin to clothe themselves, en- close land, and fight. One brains his neighbor wifh a club; another furious fellow fixes his teeth in the nose of his prostrate adversary; a third brays the head of a woman under an enormous stone. Saint Maél is horrified, but he is assured by a religious brother of wider experience that the penguins are accom- O5 plishing_the most august of functions— “they are creating law, they are found- ing property; they are establishing the principles of civilization.”’" All this re- minds one of the “Social Contract” and the famous “Discourses” of Rousseau, but it is to be remembered that in the State of nature the penguins were feath- ered bipeds. No golden age glimmers for Anatole France behind the age of blood. Indeed, in “M. Jéréme Coignard,” he has subjected the revolutionary il- lusions to the most penetrating criti cism: “If one is going to take a hand in governing men, he declares one must not forget that they are bad mon keys.”” The history of the penguin a- tion is the history of half-intelligent beasts—the history of Yahoos and Houyhnhnms, At this point, I cannot forbear quoting the brief mordant sketch of “Draco the Great i hero of the Middle Ages He carried fire indifferently over the ter- ritory of the enemy and his own domain. And he was wont to say, to explain hie con duct: “War without burning is like tripe without mustard; it is insipid His justice was rigorous. When the peasants whom he had taken prisoner ould not pay their ransom, he had them hanged on a tree, and if any unfortunate woman i » beg his mercy on her penniless husband, he dragged her by the hair at the tail of his hors« He lived like a soldier, free fro effeminacy (/l vecut en soldat, sana mollesac) lt is a pleasure to acknowledge that h morals swere pure Something in that reminds one at the same time of Swift and of Tacitus. If the style is indeed the man himself, there is a tincture of iron in the blood of this Epicure There is much piquancy in the con- temptuous account of Les Temps Mod- ernes, but one feels the author's point | most sharply in the exultant pessimism of his vision of the future. The notion evolution of life on our planet has long France | that there is a grim limit set to the | | | been dear to the heart of M | Long ago he prophetically buried the | last desperate relic of our race in the frozen rind of the sunless world. But here he has worked out more fully the stages by which the human tragedy is to decline to the ultimate catastrophe. Before the somewhat remote Last Day there are to be a number of false or temporary endings precipitated by forces at work within the social organism. M. France seems now to have turned his back tipon the socialistic hope which he courted a few years ago. To the cen- tralizing tendency of wealth no effec- tive check can be opposed; in the long run, it is as irresistible as gravitation, the rising of sap in forests, the swing of-plasets If thelr ortits. But at cer- tain periods When the remorseless op- pression of capitalists brings the lower orders to the verge of extinction, they will gain for themselves a dreary
Page 12
96 breathing space with dynamite. They will level all populous cities to the dust and incinerate the painfully acquired materia] and intellectual riches of civ- flization. For a little while the exhaust- ed survivors will rest, and gasping in dismal anarchy recover their animai strength. Then the old blind urge of life will begin anew; step by step poor posterity will fight its way up the long ascent again; once more the many-stor- ied cities will hum, and lean anemic millionaires, Pharoahs half-mummified; lord it over the Egyptian millfons lay- ing the bricks for their mausoleums. And so the odd wheel of life will turn round and round in concentric circles, ever shortening its diameter, till at last it vanishes in a point, and the barren globe freed of its feverish animalcules journeys on through the void! V. It is the duty of every thinker who has formed an idea of the world,” says M. France in one of his essays on con. temporary literature, “to express that idea, whatever it may be.” If the last chapters of “L’Ile des Pingouins” were a faithful sense of the facts of life crowding in upon transcript of his the sensitive consciousness, we should have deeply to commiserate the author. But the pessimism of M. France is part- Emer- ly polemical. “The spiritualist,” son tells us, “finds himself driven to express his faith in a series of skepti- cisms."" M. France began life as a de vout humanist, forming his taste and his style on the noblest literature of Greece and Rome. In early manhood, however, he felt powerfully the new hope and enthusiasm of the early fol- lowers of Darwin. To the young men of his generation, it was a fresh, firmly- founded revolutionary gospel. But as the century wore on, the scientific mil- lennium receded into the infinitely re- To believe in it demanded as pure an exercise of faith as to be- lieve In the New Jerusalem. M. France's faith was unequal to the task. What faith remained in him reverted to his unre- fiecting mass of humanity had caught the fanatic fervor of the scientific dream, and had left humanism far in the rear When M ples of his gods he found them empty of And so, like most human- ists to-day, he is a disheartened human ist. He would, perhaps, have spoken se- faith if he could have is rather dreary to praise Pallas Athene in per- fect solitude. [t_js-more. diverting to steal into the camp of the victors, and mock their cause and insinuate horrible doubt Into every heart, Yet by a happy law of the universe only the petential philanthropist can be misanthropic. The Olympian detachment of M. France mote future early humanism. Meantime the France returned to the tem- worshippers riously of his found serious listeners It The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2300
a@ man can no more despise his fellows than Archimedes could lift the world. So long as M: France déspises us, we need not despair; the earth beneath his scornful feet is a part of the common heritage. T find a still more serious flaw in the would-be seamless garment of M. France's skepticism. He has often as- sured us that the skeptic is a good citi- zen, because, uncertain of all things, he ig the Teast radical of men. But the salt of the right skeptic is the love of truth. Whatever enters his head he re- ports freely, as one holding a commis- sion to act as the disinterested intelli- gence of mankind; surveyifig the past and present and spying out the future. That salt was in the virile fibre of Mon- taigne sitting in his tower in Perigord, cupboarding the choice viands of the ancients and portraying with unflinch- ing hand the manners and mind of the man he knew best. But Anatole France —<does he candidly attempt to represent the world as it appears? Does he love truth and the search for truth aboye.all else? As it seems to me, he loves above all else the luxury of philosophic déspair. Weis a kind of refined, phil- osophical sentimentalist. With the as- siduity of the Graveyard Poets, he cul- tivates and cherishes those truths, or seeming truths, which make for melan- holy. We hear every day: This is the truth: we must face it.. The fact is we may usually turn our back upon it, and it is often the part of w'sdom to do so. There may be a more wholesome truth at the opposite point of the compass. It is true that when a good man dies he rots like a rascal. It is also true that he lives a fragrant life in the memory of his friends. To embrace the latter truth, strengthens the heart; but a cer- tain kind of sentimentalist always em- braces the worm that inherits the shroud. It is the truth; we must face it. But no man can face all truth. We judge a man’s wisdom by his power of making intimates of those truths which give channel and speed to the languid. diffusive drift of his days. M. France has sought through all the world for truths inducing in the peréefver a pen- sive and helpless sadness. M. France is fo0 much concerned about the misery of the last man. If the good die young, as there is some warrant for believ- ing, the last man will deserve hanging. The skepticism of M. France is largely n literary pose. It is his justification for making capital of all unspeakable things. For a good skeptic he knows al- together too much about the future. When a man's philosophy has carried him to the point where several million years of civilization are as to-morrow, are as nothing, to him, it is a pity that it should not go a step further to the point where space vanishes and time ex- pires and the Iillusive ages evaporate For a good skeptic he is altogether too sure that the World has-exhausted its | possibilities. He holds, indeed, that we live in a bright-flowing mist of days and nights, of sleeping and waking dreams. But he does not hold this belief with strength enough to be dumb and aston- ished at thought of the germs of new orders of ideas now forming in society or slumbering as yet unstirred in the unused mind of the world. He does not recognize as frankly as a skeptic should how plastic is the eternal flux under the creative urgency of the desire of man, who had only to say, “Let the flux be peopled with demons and with seraph- im,” and it was. Only the new-born babe enjoys, however, that purity of uncer- tainty to which M. France pretends. And as soon as the babe first sniffs the vital air, it is a judge as well as an observer. It discovers at once that for the present at least some things are good and beau- tiful, and others terrible and necessary. Stuart P. SHERMAN. Correspondence.
FROM LOMBROSO TO SHAKESPEARE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: £rr: The speare-Bacon conviction that the Shake- controversy was after all confined to a narrow circle of scholars never forced itself so strongly upon me as when I took up other recent writings on Shakespeare, the authors of which suc- eced in finding new and living material for modern study in the familiar dramas Among such books is August Goll’s “Crim- inal Typesin Shakespeare” (‘‘Forbrydertyp- er hos Shakespeare,’’ Gyldendal, Copen- hagen, 1908) The author, a Danish po- lice inspector, presents Shakespeare in a new light, as a_ criminologist. Much has been written of Shakespeare as a psychologist, but his value to the stu- dent of crime has only recently been dis- eovered. It is not my intention to review Goll’s book. I want rather to make clear how it came to be written, and hope that the explanation will prove interesting to the Shakespeare scholar and the student of criminology alike. joll wrote his book because the present state of criminal psychology filled him with despair. At one time he marched in the ranks of those enthusiasts who flocked about Lombroso and his school, and like him he saw in the criminal a species of bumanity, a particular genus in the zo- ological group homo sapiens. He swore like him by the impossibility of deception in innumerable measurings and weighings, by the many deviations from the normal which characterize the criminal. But, again, he was one of the first to see that though Lombroso’s characteristic marks undoubt- edly do fit a small group of degenerate criminals who are closely related to the weak-minded and insane, there are many cases which they do not fit at all. He was obliged to acknowledge that criminals themselves do not differ materially in their thoughts, feelings, and will from others.
is INusory. Without a place to stand on, into the eternity of the everlasting Now. He could not fail to see that a particular
ee eT nh Se hee ne
Page 13
July 29, 1909] The N psychology did not even fit a particular group of criminals, that the same crime may be committed from absolutely differ- ent motives, while it is purely dependent on circumstances what will be the crime of a passionate or crafty character. We are all being forced to the conclu- sion, as was Herr Goll, that it would be better for criminal psychology if criminal- ists, instead of pointing out artificial sim- jlarities among all criminals, would show us real differences between individual crim- inals. It would be of greater value if they would collect single observations and ex- periences and present them in an objective form, so that the master-mind that will come some day may find sufficient material at hand to be able to construct out all these details a plastic whole. Actuated by this hope criminalists all over the world are beginning to collect ac- counts of peculiar criminal careers and of medical examinations of criminals. These studies have already shown how short- sighted we were till within the last few years. They prove that the former classifi- cation, according to the kind of crime, only leads to confusion, that the criminal is the point to consider in all classifications. It must not be forgotten that all these ex- aminations are of criminals in prison or on trial. But that the criminal in prison is not a trustworthy source of information about the criminal at large is clear even to the layman It s therefore only natural that we should try to supplement what we learn from a direct source of information by what we learn from an indirect source, that we should turn from reality to its reflection—from life to literature. Of course we must first choose carefully the kind of literature that has real bearing on the subject, for there is a literature about crime and a literature about criminals To the first belongs the real detective story. However exciting a tale of Conan Doyle, for instance, may be, it is always the crime and not the criminal that interests the author and the reader. Then, too, the real criminal literature, of which criminals themselves are the au- thors, is of very little value to the crim- inalist. Several criminals have appeared in literature, as, for instance, the Marquis de Sade, Casanova, Cellini, Villon, Harry Orchard, etc. We might also include some poems of the greatest French lyric poet of the last fifty years, Paul Verlaine. Lom- broso and his school collected hundreds of poems, proverbs, etc., by all kinds of criminals. But it is just this criminal lit- erature that shows how little we can be- lieve the criminal At best he is able to reveal only what he has retained of or- dinary human feelings. Another sort of literature is written by people who have associated with criminals in a friendly way, like Josiah Flynt, and Hans Leuss. But these books, valuable though they often are, enter only into the criminal’s opinions of justice and how he escapes it. Besides, their aim is general- ly to agitate and make a sensation. There remain only the great poets. These lay the criminal’s soul open like a book. They show us the birth of the motive, the nervous strain that develops with it, consideration of the kind of crime, the ation. —— ———}> = and the execution, the mental moods during and after the deed. They follow the crim- inal through love and hate, storm and calm, not merely as spectators and critics, but as if in the person of the criminal himself, as one who sees deeper than any determination growth of the the gradual criminal can. To them the criminal psy- chologists should turn with confidence. In our day, Dostoevsky has described crim- inal individuals in his “Raskolnikov” and in “Memoirs from a Death House,” as prison governors and criminal psychologists have tried in vain to describe them Above him, the greatest Slav, stands the greatest Teuton, Shakespeare. Goll thinks that in studying Shakespeare's criminals we come as near as possible to the ideal of “seeing the criminal in the man, the man in the criminal.” He sees in Caliban the g il crim inal, the creature with the purely anti- social nature whom Prospero tries to re form. Prospero gives h shelter he makes use of it to attempt rap« Prospero teaches him the power of language—h: uses it to curse. Prospero teaches him th faculty of thought—he uses it to ponder on evil schemes. He loves but one thing, spir- its; and fears but one, punishment He is capable only of the lowest kind of work, and has to be forced to do that From this primitive criminal, Goll leads uS on up to the political cr nal, to hate filled Brutus and the doctrinarian Cassius Naturally enough, he finds but little new to say about Richard the Third; his anal s of Iago, on the other hand, is asterly He lays bare the erot side of lago’s hatred of Othello—his instinct of erot cruelty,”’ as the criminalists now call it lago’s speeches are all em! ered by sexua insinuations. He sex n other only th expression of coars« sexual motives, tl best sign that they al underlie his own actions. He finds satisfa it oison ng Othello’s enjoyment of 1) lemona love, and takes pleasure in ng her mar tyred, first her soul, ther bod However, as I have d, t lin not intended to follow the ingenious au- thor through his analysis of all Shake- speare’s criminals. The book is strong enough to speak for itself. My purposs is only to show what undiscovered treas- ures still lie in Shakespeare, treasures which, to me at least, are infinitely mor interesting than all the acrostics that pa tient searching might reveal ADALBERT ALBRECHT. toston, July 23 CROMWELL AND AMERICA, To THE EpiItTor or THE NATION: Sir: The yet unsettled historical question whether John Hampden, Oliver Crom- well, and Arthur Haselrigge had taken their passages for New England in 1638, might well be revised, in view of certain entries that appear in the recently pub- lished “Acts of the Privy Council, 1613, 1680.” It will be remembered that Neale, in his “History of the Puritans’ (vol. I, p. 618), says: It deserves a particular notice that there were eight sail of ships at once, this spring, in the river Thames, bound for New England, and filled with Puritan families, among whom (if we may believe Dr. George Bates and Mr. Dugdale, two famous Royalists) were Oliver Cromwell, 97 afterward Protector of the Commonwealth of England, John Hampden, Esq., and Mr Arthur Haselrigge, who, seeing no end of the oppressions of their native country, determined to spend the remainder of their days in America; but the Council, being informed of their design, issued out an order, dated May Ist, 1638, to make stay of those ships and to put on shore all the provisions intended for the voyage Excepting that the dates do not exactly agree, the following order of the 30th of March, 1638, confirms the foregoing state- ment, as to the stay of the ships and the relanding of the passengers and provisions: Whitehall, 30th March It was this day ordered for reasons im- porting the State, best known unto theire Lordshipps: That the Lord Treasurer of England shall take speedy and effectual order, for the stay of eight shipps now on the River of Thames, prepared to go for New England: And shall lykewise give order for the putting on land, of all the Passengers and provisions therein intend d for that voyage of mé the passengers humble and the 6th of the of the restraint On tition April, upon pe rchants England, the owners ships bound for New removed, and to was pas- allowed proceed on their the resort sengers were owing to of per- govern- same New church that i prohibit New Eng voyage At time, to England affected t decided issued frequent ill it sons 0 and ment, was Proclama- 1a he mua D ike tion sh ing passen- gers being t n to ind unless | Old Engl: obtained pecial license o Lords of the Councll they had first that behalf from the for Plantation me ff t! made among the Privy without esult As th ossible the nong he brary at Lam beth That C ' ind romwell leaving re rded in Claren (vol I l in lon's “History of that stan is that after the lebate in the commons ] ar, whispered Falkland ‘ t! the House, that been rejected, had, the next seen England were many other resolution Cromwell n the « the if his Remonstrance he would have morning, and never have more; and he knew there honest men of the same leaving had sold all he two were as Clarendon further tells us (vol. I, p. 377), that, until the King revived their by his demand for the five members of the “some of them had re- courage, House of Commons, sumed their old resolutions of leaving the These Kingdom.” last words show that the idea of emigrating was not a new one N. DARNELL DAvVis Hathsheba arbados, June 24 RELIGIOUS AUTHORITY IN rURKEY AND PERSIA EpItoR OF THE NATION litorial- in the July 15, there is a sentence which may kk to gay, last more It TO THE Nation yf ad foot of Sin In an @ or misunderstanding You of p- 45 shown that the religious authority of Sul- column Once was tan or Shah was no very terrible weapon, after all.” The Shah of Persia has no religious au- thority and stands, in that absolutely different position from the S8ul- respect, in an
Page 14
tan of the Ottoman Turks. He Is a mere locum tenens and maintainer of public or- ler until the Hidden Imam, the divinely ippointed and guided Head of the Shi'ite world, returns from his century-long ban- nent In the meantime the Mujtahids Shitite lergy, are the representatives that Imam in spirituar tnings, and they m practically an ultimate court of ap- pew heir excommunication” of the Shah can mean only a declaration on their | i ! ha iolated essential ele ft iT i | s no longer fit to be i i fa 1 The Ottoman Sult m the other hand, us au ty is he laims to be Khalif ) ssor of the Prophet, id of 1i¢@ Moslem world I é ipo grounds f that claim whi t is admitted ‘ n nh ol you! space But even the Sultan Khalit ur the Moslem people vio essential elements of I n ! ple ive a full constitutional fe » dep n the lemo it basis M i 2 ha itirely | Oo nak us of an auto , executiy In Turkey this popular will is supposed » be expressed through Shaikh al-Islam, the head of all the Llama, the canon lawyers, and theologians They and he represent the people, while in Persia the Mujtahid epresent the Hid len Imam rhus the deposition of Abd el-Hamid was cat 1 out strictly accord- ing to constitutional law, and that law iffected him both as Sultan and as Khalifa DUNCAN B. MACDONALD Hertford, ¢ j TEACHERS OF ADVANCED MATHE- MATICS Te ie Eporror or Tir NArion si It a generally unknown fact, but hat should be of interest both to the " ind especially to students of mathe- matical bent, that at present the demand f teaches of advanced mathematics dis- exceeds the supply. In support of itement that such an excess exists } may cite the fact that one Eastern univer rofe vr, though in no way connected with any teachers’ agency, has, within the la three months, received from widely listributed sections of the country no less tha i ve of requests for nominations for mathematical teacherships, ranging in grade from instructorships in technological achoo to university professorships; and that, though the professor referred to has in extensive acquaintance among teachers and advanced students of mathematics, he was far from able to meet all the requests It fair to assume that other professors of mathematics have had a similar experi enee Cassius J. Keyser HANGING ANIMALS To THe Eprror or THe NATION Sin: Does not the proverb, “Give a dog a bad name and hang him,” at least imply that the trial and execution of animals was once a matter of popular knowledge, if not of popular experience? Scott, also, seemed to think that’ the matter required no explanation when, in “The Talisman,” Lecky has wr! “History of the Great will be published in September by Charles Advertisements tion of the Origins of Advertising’ danving-schools, business enterprise. the advertisements in the Tatler, », would certainly modify the im- pression that the Spectator is of paramount importance as an illustration of the origins of advertising. as they are not. Past and Present, The Nation. has Henry of Cham- were well to hang up the dog, and put the slave to the torture.” R. P. UTTER. ten a life of her hus- Lecky, which will be pub- & Co, in the Gustavus Myers’s American Fortunes” and third vol- work, will be issued is possible note that a bust and letter- en unveiled at The bust is sculptor, Mr. J. W. Those who are mildly interested in the per- iod of Queen Anne will be entertained and Lewis's little book the Spectator: Being a study of the Literature, History and England as they are reflected therein, as well as an illustra- ’ (Hough- It serves as a very fair sub- advertisements are original sheets of the Spectator, and conveniently classifies its lotteries, cos- theatres, and much Even careful students of the period by the second chapter, the con- important and well But, pleasantly as Mr. Lewis ful- fils the promise of his sub-title, the value of his book would be considerably greater had he not seen fit to isolate the Spectator contemporaries. It is particularly to be regretted that he has which serves Spectator to an- that beset a student of the Queen Anne periodical consid- A thorough aroma hangs about “Utopian Papers’ (London: Masters of discourses and es- Dorothea Hollins. Patrick Geddes is the only well-known n.ume among the balf-score contributors to this gentle, smateurish volume of reflections on things So far as an outsider may gather from the rather esoteric style of the editor, the Ulopians are a group of London ideals, who meet frequently for the ‘nterchange of thought ind sometimes find the result good enough A paper on Chelsea, Past and is followed by one on Utopla’s and another on the But we get our sub- to a study | Vol. 89, No. 2.00 of St. Columba, or Goethe, or Indian Thought. It is characteristic of nearly all ideal world-builders that they deal with the concrete and the commonplace. What the authority of husband over wife will be, how many hours a day children will pass in school, the number of people to a table at the public mess, and the color and tex- ture of the garment reserved for magis- trates, predominate over detail of spirit and mind. No such precision marks the present volume whose right to the adjective Utopian is partly justified by the fact that it gets nowhere in particular. The nineteenth volume of “Harvard Stud- ies in Classical Philology” (Harvard Un!‘- versity, 1908) contains as its leading arti- cle a discussion by the late Louis Dyer »%* ‘The Olympian Council House and Council,” n which he defends against J. G. Frazer the current identification of certain remains as those of its foundations, uses them as evidence to prove the hitherto unsuspected existence at Olympia of a pre-Dorian Am- phictyonic League, and then elucidates cer- tain points in the history of the council. In the following articles, Joseph W. Hewitt examines the worship of Zeus under va- rious surnames, and shows that this bright- sky deity’s cult was extended by conquest among peoples who had worshipped chthonic deities, with whom Zeus became more or less identified; Sereno B. Clark decides from metrical considerations that the “‘dou- ble letters” in the ‘““Heroides” were written by Ovid, but at an undeterminable date; and William H. P. Hatch makes a lexico- graphical study of a group of Greek words of religious significance during the period as far down as 300 B. c. The studies as a whole are respectable rather than bril- liant, but that by Mr. Dyer will be likely to provoke more than passing comment among students of Peloponnesian history. In view of the leisurely fashion in which most of the calendars of English state papers drag forward, William Foster is to be commended for the dispatch with which he has brought out within a year another volume of “The English Factories in India” (Henry Frowde). In the period covered by this third volume, 1624-1629, the English trade improved considerably, in spite of the difficulty of raising capital at home. Indian calicoes began to be heavily import- ed, so that, whereas the English had for- merly paid the foreigner £500,000 per an- num for hollands, lawns and cambrics, they were now able to save more than half that sum, and began even to vend their calicoes from India in foreign parts. The rivalry of the English and the Dutch still caused bitterness in the Far East around Batavia; but in the West, from Surat to the Persian Gulf, where they met the hateful competi- tion of the Catholic Portuguese, the English reported that the Dutch agreed to “‘sticke as close unto us as the sherts one our backs, wee promisinge the like unto them.” To- gether they fought many a good fight against the Portuguese, and showed that the spirit of Drake and Hawkins and the Sea-Beggars of an earlier generation had not departed. In view of the later great- ness of Bombay, it is interesting to note that as early as 1626 the English cast their eye upon it as a place of “noe iil ayre, but a pleasant, fruitful soile and excellent har- bor’; a mate made a sketch of the ba which is here reproduced as the frontis- PAE STTA ISLES RaQ Lov ihe
Page 15
. ; | July 29, 1909] piece. No settlement, however, was made at this time, as the place was too exposed to Portuguese depredations. Of the 366 documents calendared with discrimination and indexed with care in this volume, a majority deal with the activities of the company on the west coast of India, some tell of the attempts to secure more trade on the east coast, near Madras, and of the failures of the English in the Far East; and others give much valuable information in regard to important events in the in- ternal history of the Mogul Empire “Our Foreign Service—the ‘A B C’ of American Diplomacy,” by Frederick Van Dyne (The Lawyers Codéperative Publish- ing Company, Rochester, N. Y.), is a sys- tematic account of the organization and duties of our diplomatic and consular ser- vice. It is purely expository, and it in- cludes a bibliography of the _ subject, statements of legal form, and a schedule of the consular service. Tne work appears to have been executed in a thorough and painstaking manner. complete “The Federal Civil Service as a Career,” by El Bie K. Foltz (G. P. Putnam's Sons), is evidently the outcome of the disposition to regard public service as a professional career, and to prepare for it as such. The book is offered as a manual for applicants for positions in the civil service and for those already in who desire to improve their qualifications. The is marred by journalistic fustian, as, for example: “So voracious is the American appetite for gold that the money devil seems to have gotten hig fangs into many of our university men.’”’ The book contains useful information, and seems to be based upon a careful study of routine detail. The latest addition to the excellent Man- uali Hoepli, issued by Ulrico Hoepli, in Mi- lan, is “Le rovine del Palatino,” by Do- minico Canogni, a leading authority in the archeology and history of Rome. It is rich- ly illustrated and contains a good plan of the Mons Palatinus. growing style The theory that Von Kleist was anything but a physical degenerate and one men- tally unbalanced, will be rather startling to many, but it is the basis of S. Rahmer's new work, “Heinrich von Kleist als Mensch und Denker,” a volume of 433 pages, with two portraits, published at Berlin by George Reimer. After wrestling some years with the “Kleist Problem,” Rahmer concluded that more than one accepted theory about the poet was false—that, for example, in- stead of being a recluse and morose by na- ture, he had in reality a good deal to do with men and affairs of his proved by his correspondence and his works. Examination of the Von Kleist ar- chives brought disappointment, but a search for other contemporary evidence led to the discovery of much material concerning Zschokke, Varnhagen, and others, hitherto quite unknown. With a scientific prefer- ence for the truth, however, Herr Rahmer admits that he has not yet been able to get as much support for his theory as he wished or expected. time, as is In three volumes Dr. Johann Friedrich von Schulte presents his Reminiscences as a jurist and teacher, and one long active in public life in Germany (Giessen: Emil Roth). The third volume is particularly interesting to foreigners on account of sev- eral essays setting forth Germany's re- ‘The lations to the Vatican and the author's rec- ollections of Bismarck Nation. Prof. P. Jensen of the University of Mar- burg has evidently with the reception accorded by philologians and theologians to his great work of more than a thousand pages issued two years ago un- der the title of “Das Gilgamesch die Weltliteratur,” in which h« to show that the bulk of old Ts ratives, especially the persona! been dissatisfied Epos und undertook stament nar- as also the doings of Jesus, are really adaptations from th lata found in the famous Babylonian Epic of Gilgamesh. He now brings out a smaller work, indeed only a good-sized brochure, entitled ‘“‘Moses, Jesus, Paulus: Drei Sagenvarianten | babylonischen Gottmenschen Gilgamesch vith the sig- nificant sub-title ‘*Eins lage wider The- ologen und Sophister nd ein Appell an lie Laien” (Frankfurt a. M.. Never Frank- furter Verlag) Th new feature of this argument is that the Apostle Paul is also made a reflection and re luction of « sodes and characters in the Gilgamesh Epic. It must be acknowledgedthat J: n, who Is in able Assyriologist, has found a number of striking parallels betw Paul and Gil- gamesh which ars ull =the more note- vorthy becaus the I t xpres- sion of religious beliefs or feeling om- mon to all men, but of historical facts and events in the lives of thes two erson- ages. The weakness of his method is that he does not and cannot show any inner con- nection between these phenomena that ex- look so much alike. It is the old fallacy of post hoc ergo propter ho ternally The first part of the fifth volume of edited by Eliza has appeared from Nietzsche's correspondenc beth Férster-Nietzsche the press of the Insel Verlag, Leipzig, un- der the title “Friedrich Nietzsche an Mutter und Schwester.”” The letters were written chiefly between the entire period is not covered Nietzsche home and long in such close pe ciation with his relatives that letter writ- ing was unusual. Much of this new corre spondence is very personal, and the reasons offered for putting it into type are the con- tinued attacks on Nietzsche's memory, the demand of his admirers for on the inner mind of the mysterious think er. The letters naturally include Nietzsche's spiteful criticism of Frau Lou Andreas Salomé and Dr. Paul Rée, whom the phil- osopher relied scientific coéperation, and with when failed him, he dealt so that are likely to enjoy a certain unwelcome im- mortality. To this editor seeks to show that Briefe 1856 and 1889, but probably because times at was severa sonal asso and more light upon for certain whom they severely they remove somewhat the bit- terness of unhappy experience, the Nietzsche criti cised Rée and Salomé as a matter of prin ciple, rather than through personal hatred Hans Brix Schubotheske A young Danish philologist has recently, through the publishing firm (represented in America by the Gyldendal Publishing House, Chi- cago), under the title “Fagre Ord”’ (Words of Beauty), given to the public an inter pretation of a number of the most fa mous Danish lyrics, beginning with thé national anthem. The application of philo- logical methods to the interpretation of modern lyrics is a matter of such rare occurrence that any serious attempt in that line is bound to be interesting. Mr 99 Brix succeeds, even in regard to the na- tional song itself, in dispelling misunder- standings and throwing light taken for granted, up to on passages, which, it can be this time not one out of a hundred Danes understand correctly H. Aschehoug & Co. of Christiania have just sent out the last (sixteenth) fascicle of the Danish-Norwegian lictionary (Dansk-Norsk Ordbok) prepared by 8. Schjétt and published, in part. at public ‘pense Danish-Norwegian in this ise means from Danish into Norwegian, ¢. ¢., a dictionary of the xiv- Danish language ng the Norwegian (landsmaal) equivalents. Under a Norwegian law passed three years ag t will be ympulsory two years from *all those who desire to be matricu- lated in the university (or, as they iy Norway, pass the eramen artium) to prove their ability to write, not only the sual city, or book language, but also the alled landamaal, a kind of common lenominat f the different vuntry dia- ts. Whil main stock of the regu- lar written language is of Danish origin, he Danish influen on t yvuntr " lects has been relatively slight, and the Ismaal, which, therefore, is essential- ly Norwegian in character, has, of late made ich progress as a medium of In- I on t! l school it me of the partisans of the essentially Dan itself imposed sh rigsmaal or kulturmaal-—-which of late, by a spelling reform, by the Michelsen ministry on the hools d all public institutions has been great y Norwegiani i—have taken fright and formed rigsmaal associations. The novel- , , Bjdrnson has been one of the leaders and it is likely that the f this movement bntense interest taken by him tl is question has helped to bring ibout the illness from which he is now suffering Schjétt’s dictionary will be of interest 10t only to Norwegian students and teachers but to everybody interested in Scandina in studies After an iilness of some days the Rev. Dr. William Reed Huntington, he well- known rector of Grace Episcopal Church, New York, died last Monday, at Nahant, in his seventy-first year Dr. Huntington was an active worker in the church, but found time also to write a number of books, in cluding fhe Church Idea,” “Conditional Immortality, Popular Misconceptions of the Episcopal Church,” “The Causes of the Peace of the Book of Soul, rhe Church,’ Short History of the Common Prayer,” The Spiritual House,” \ National Church,” “Psyche, a Study of the Soul,” Four Key Words of Religion,” ‘Sonnets and a Dream,” and “A Good Shepherd and Other Sermons.” Hans Hoffmann, the German novelist, has died at Weimar, in his sixty-firat year. Among his stories are “Brigitta von Wis- ‘Vom Le- Land- by,” “Im Land der Phaaken,’ benswege,”’ Ostseemarchen,”’ Haff und Hafen.”’ Baron Detlev Axel Adolph Liliencron, the died July 22, at the age of sturm,”’ and “Von German poet, sixty-five, Besides his books of verse, he wrote several novels depicting military life. From Breslau comes the death of Dr. Emil Bohn, History of Music in the university of that place. Among his books are ‘‘Bibliographie der Musik in der Bresiauer Bibliothek,” report of the professor of the and
Page 16
100 “Die musikalische Handschriften Stadtbibliothek Breslau.” News comes of the death of Samuel Mar- tin Deutsch, professor of theology in the University of Berlin, in his seventy-third in der year. His published works include “Die Lehre des Ambrosius von Siinde und Siindentilgung,”” “Drei Aktenstiicke zur Geschichte des Donatismus,”’ “Synode zu Sens 1141 und die Verurteilung Abdlards,” and “Peter Hagenbach.”’ THE AUTHORITATIVE LIFE OF POE. The Life of Edgar Allan Poe, Personal and Literary; with his Chief Corre- spondence with Men of Letters. By George E. Woodberry. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. 2 vols. 12mo Pp. xii, 383; villi, 481. With illustra- tions. $5 net. The appearance of these volumes is the most important event connected with the centenary of Poe. We might go farther and say that the present work is the chief biographical contri- bution yet made to Poe studies, but for the fact that the same author's mono graph on Poe in the American Men of Letters may fairly be held to have laid the foundation for critical as opposed to partisan and amateur study of Poe's life and writings, and, in consequence, to have shaped, or at least influenced, most of the subsequent Poe literature that has any value. It is not likely, of course, that biographies of Poe _ will cease to appear, or that Mr. Woodberry, judicial and sanely sympathetic though he be, will be chosen—to his own chagrin—moderator of those unseemly wranglers, the Poeites and the Anti- Poeites But it is likely that no large amount of new biographical detail cal- culated to affect our judgment of Poe awaits incorporation in a future book, and it is almost certain that better-in- formed, more impartially balanced, and more discreetly appreciative criticism of Poe's writings in their entirety is not to be looked for in our generation. illuminating fact come to light; we shall led to shift an empha- to modify an inference: it will be- and less difficult to form a composite conception of Poe the gentle- Poe the of Poe the Here and there an will doubtless occasionally be als come lers outcast, man and true artist in verse and prose, and Poe the hack writer who took up his abode now and then In the purlieus of charla- tanism:; but our approaches to a more understand- Poe was did will be niong the lines of painstaking opposed to hero-worship and adequate and sympathetic ing of what and made study, as demon-exorciam, first cons'stently and effectively followed by Mr. Woodberry. The genesis of the volumes is suc- cinctly described in their preface. Mr Woodberry was joint editor of R. W. Griswold'’s papers relating to Poe, and he also edited the Poe-Chivers papers. Much information came to him from The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2300 other sources—particularly, one may gather, from persons who contributed Poeana to the newspapers. It seemed desirable, therefore, for him to gather up his “earlier and later labors in a more full and precise biography” than his monograph of nearly a quarter of a century ago. He admits that during this period he did not engage “in per- sonal investigation”—the failure to date some of the newspaper clippings util- ized seems to be evidence of this fact— and he expresses the modest conviction that he has at least “made easier the way” for the ideal biographer. Our opinion upon this point has al- ready been given; another point made in the preface demands a word. Mr. Woodberry telis us that he has “aimed to make this, in the main, a literary biography,” that “as such it has two special interests, in that it is a life led outside of New England,” and that “it embodies much contemporaneous liter- ary his.ory not involved in any other life of our greater writers.” Against these statements no caveat need be en- tered, but it seems fair to say, in the interest of the general reader who hap- pens not to care greatly for Poe or for the American literature of Poe’s period produced outside of New England— much more in the interest of the un- patriotic soul whose reading is not pre- vailingly confined to the writings of his own countrymen—that Poe and most of his correspondents were not great let- ter-writers, that it is a petty and often ignoble world which is evoked for our contemplation, and that such persons as distrust their powers of literary as- similation may legitimately hesitate be- fore settling themselves to the task of reading through these more than eight hundred pages. There are doubtless readers who would find more pleasure and profit in Professor Woodberry’s earlier biography than in this fuller work, which suffers from the defects of its qualities. The undaunted reader of the present book, however, will get for his pains al- most everything to be found in the earlier, for the criticism has been trans- ferred bodily—at least to all intents— and a large part of the biographical nar- rative proper has been utilized unchang- ed. The expanding and the redistribut- ing of material have been accomplished with quite exceptional skill, and we found the book readable from preface to index, not excepting the notes on obscure points with which each volume concludes. The first chapter and the two open- ing notes show how carefully Mr. Wood- berry’s original investigations were made, and how completely unaffected they remain by recent attempts to de- prive Boston of the little-prized honor of being Poe's birthplace. The de- tails added with regard to Poe's school and college days need no comment, but a slight change made in the brief ac- count of the publication of “Tamerlane and Other Poems” should not be over- looked. In his earlier work (p. 36), Mr. Woodberry drew from insufficient prem- ises the conclusion that Poe lived in Boston in the spring of 1829, under an assumed name. In the new book, this inference is omitted, and the change is an indication not only of the care, but of the spirit of justice that has been manifested throughout the revision. The fourth chapter deals with Poe’s life in Baltimore, after he left West Point, and adds something to our knowl- edge of that mysterious period. Time will show whether more light can be thrown on these years, which are spe- cially important, not only in the evo- lution of Poe’s imagination, but in the development of his unfortunate habits and of his defects of body and mind. With regard to the relations sustained by Poe to the Allan family, and to the improbable charge of forgery brought against him—a charge ignored in the earlier biography—Mr. Woodberry gives an interesting note, which brings out the fact, not widely known, that there are Poe papers of presumable importance deposited in the Valentine Museum at Richmond, Virginia. They were placed tnere by the family of the first Mrs. Al- lan, and Mr. Woodberry is ignorant of their contents, having with uncommon discretion forborne to ask for a sight of documents not proffered to him. As twenty-five years have now gone by, it is much to be hoped that these papers, which may be the only means by which the scandalous tongue of tradition can be stopped, will be published speedily, and in their entirety. If they reveal nothing, the case for Poe will be helped by that fact. If they reveal unknown faults and misfortunes, we shall have all the more reason to emphasize Poe’s subsequent efforts at reform and his hard-won triumphs as a writer. It is in the fourth chapter that Poe first comes fairly before us as a corre- spondent—a fact which makes it neces- sary to recall the biography and the volume of correspondence prepared by Prof. James A. Harrison for the “Vir- ginia Poe.” The letter of May 30, 1885, from Poe to T. W. White of the South- ern Literary Messenger, inserted by Mr. Woodberry (II. 110-113) is also printed by Professor Harrison (XVII, 4-6). Both give credit to the Griswold Papers, hence one scarcely expects to find about twenty-five small variations in punc- tuation, capitalization, paragraphing, etc. On making further comparisons, we were led to believe that Mr. Wood- berry had the service of a better copy- ist than fell to Professor Harrison's lot, but that, in the main, it is a matter of indifference whether one quotes Poe and his correspondents through the medium of the present work or through that of
Page 17
4 E ee aon eet July 29, 1909] The Nation. the “Virginia Poe.” Still, we should have been glad of a note on the subject of the text of the letters, particularly on that of the despairing appeal made by Poe to J. P. Kennedy on Sept. 11, 1835. Mr. Woodberry credits his text to the “Ken- nedy Manuscripts” (II, 138-141); Pro fessor Harrison credits his to the “Gris- wold Collection” (XVII, 16-18). There are about thirty variations, some of which would be of the slightest import- ance, but for the fact that this letter nas been subjected to close analysis, in order that light might be thrown by it upon Poe’s mental condition. We have known it to be used as evidence that he was under the influence of opium when he wrote it. If such uses are to be made of letters, it is desirable to secure abso- lute accuracy. A profusion of correctly inserted commas might lead to a verdict of “not guilty”; an abundance of mis- placed dashes to a less favorable one. Our personal interest in this matter is of the slightest, but, if we stand upon the threshold of an Alexandrian period of our literature, it is surely time to safeguard the students of the future. We must settle our texts. Imagine the weary hours some yet unborn commenta- tor will spend, endeavoring to determine whether Emerson employed a comma af- ter some particularly orphic word, or whether Whitman separated two items in one of his catalogues with a dash or a semi-colon. If we will have cults, we and posterity must pay the penalty. Passing rapidly to the end of the first volume, we note that Mr. Woodberry prints several letters which either are not given by Professor Harrison or else are synopsized. This continues to be true throughout the first half of the sec- ond volume, and it is a fact that adds considerably to the value of the present biography. The correspondence as given in the “Virginia Poe,” however, is full- er and indispensable, and occasionally it might have been well for Mr. Wood- berry to consult it carefully. For exam- ple, the phrase “morbid sociability,” which he queries as used by F. W Thomas (II, 16), appears in the Vir- ginia text, “morbid sensibility” (XVII, 137). A few pages farther he would have found a letter which the Virginia editor presents as written by Poe to James T. Fields, an epistle which Mr. Woodberry is apparently correct in as- signing to the Poe-Lowell correspon- dence. Was it magnanimity or oversight that was responsible for the fact that no note is given calling attention to the error? However this question may be answered, there can be no doubt that Mr. Woodberry is both careful and mag- nanimous in the way he substantiates an account of the sole interview between Poe and Lowell given in the earlier biog- raphy, and called in question by Pro- fessor Harrison. The latter had writ- ten: That Mrs. Clemm, Poe's guardian-angel, the one woman in all the world most anx- ous to shield her nephew and son-in-law’s reputation from the cruel criticism of Strangers, should confess to the stranger Briggs that he was “‘tipsy’’ is altogether incredible, and rests only on the unauthen- ticated testimony of a man who was now Poe's professed enemy (the ‘Virginia Poe,” I, 204). Mr. Woodberry, in reply, leaves Briggs to take care of himself, but prints Mrs. Clemm’s letter to Lowell of nearly five years later, in which she not only show- ed that her memory was good, but ac- tually used the words, “The day you saw him in New York he was not himself.” This matter is not so trivial as it seems. It is a thousand pities that Poe's frailties have been exploited in such a fashion that they cannot be overlooked or forgotten; but this is quite as much due to the indiscreet zeal of his admir- ers as to the putative ghoul-like in- stincts of Griswold and his successors The facts had to be told, and, that being true, it is salutary and comfortable to find them prevailing over rhetorical sentiment. No admirer of Poe’s genius need have any quarrel with the revela- tions made in this book. What ' we should set our faces against, is incompe- tent censoriousness, fatuous eulogy, and impertinent intermeddling in literary matters by untrained persons. In his discussion of Poe's relations with women after his wife’s death, and of the wretched tragedy at Baltimore, Mr. Woodberry seems to us to have pre- sented as full and accurate a _ state- ment of the facts as is possible, and to have accomplished his difficult task with extraordinary tact In his appendix, among other items, he gives letters from Lowell to Briggs, some unpublished cor- respondence of Poe, an excellent discus- sion of “Poe and Chivers” and a just ac- count of “Griswold’s World.’ The notes are valuable, and the index seems to be ample and careful. It is almost need- less to add that but few misprints have been discovered. A Mr. Pleasants has lost the final s of his name, and John M. Daniel, the once famous editor of the Richmond Eraminer, has been allot- ted one to which he has no claim. These trifles, with an obvious slip in a date (11, 113, note 2), are all that we have noted. CURRENT FICTION Partners Three. By Victor Mapes. New York: Frederick A. Stokes Co. From the absurd cover, with its crude three-in-a-row pattern, which encloses this narrative, and from the situation with which it opens, the reader may be led to expect a not unfamiliar type of criminal-mystery tale, with a more or less perfunctory “love-interest” thrown in. Crime it does undeniably contain, but not of that frightful mien in which the moralist exults, or used to exult 101 “Yesterday,” begins the story-teller, “was the second anniversary of my ar- rival here in a cell at Sing Sing.” The reader at once, as if automatically, be- gins to speculate as to whether safe- cracking, diamond-theft, or murder is to be the motive of the yarn to follow. But the ensuing statement turns out to be no less true than remarkable: “How I came to be brought here, what crime I committed, how I was caught and tried, are matters which have very little to do with the story I am starting out to tell.” What follows is, in fact, a charming if perfectly unreasonable tale of sentiment. The whole affair has a freshness of savor for which the dutiful follower of current fiction must be grateful. For the story cannot be ranged in any of the familiar categories. It is neither tragical, comical, historical, criminal, sociological, nor even romantic-comical- sociological. It is a very simple story of the kind which very simple novelists are helpless to produce. The book is, it will be seen, a bit of imaginary autoblography—purely imag- inary, it must be admitted, so far as its form is concerned. No boy of “Patrick Isaac Ennis’s” age, even if he had a college behind him, instead of a reform school, could write as this au- tobiographer writes. On the other hand, it may fairly be held that the author, being a romancer, not a realist, is suc- cessful in expressing the feeling and the mental experience of such a boy bet- ter than he could express it himself. Patrick Isaac Ennis is taken from the “House of Refuge” by a benevolent Dr. Joyce, an inventor and dreamer. This gentleman has already in charge a girl of about Patrick's age, whom he has some time earlier rescued from a still more desperate plight. These are the partners three. It may be said at once that Patrick Isaac Ennis (he is “Pie” to h's partners) does not marry the girl, or even aspire to marry her. Be- vond this item we do not wish to dl- vulge any fact whatever in connection with a delightfully unconventional (yes, with its improvident genius, long- lost heiress, and all) romance. The Lodger Overhead. By Charles Bel mont Davis. New York: Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons. The middle-aged bachelor who is suf- ficiently confirmed in his estate to watch life clearly from his own cosy corner, intervening at times to play the cynical- ly benevolent deus ex machina, is a common enough type in fiction. The bachelor in the present collection of stories is a vague, Van Bibber-like per- son on whose elaborate furniture and fine linen and free use of cabs much stress is laid. He lives, of course, in apartments over a millinery shop, just west of Fifth Avenue, and not far from the theatrical district. He moves in good society; just how far below the
Page 18
102 society which Mrs. Wharton has made her own, a humble reviewer who writes for money finds it impossible to say. But Mr. Davis's folks do go down to the quieter Southern winter resorts, and drive out in their own motors to coun- try clubs After injecting quite a dose of ab- stract speculation into his first story, our author seems to have had enough. At any rate, he settles down to dispens- ing narrative of a mildly moralistic, mildly sentimental flavor without par- ticular character or distinction. Is it a trace of amateurishness, or is it actual fondness for a certain feminine pose that makes no less than five of his hero- ines, in moments of mental travail, lean forward in their chairs with their faces resting in their palms and their elbows on their knees? He gets commendably close to reality in the story of the bril- liant girl who married a good-natured vulgarian without the sense of humor. A half-page description of a_ hurried meal at a railway luncheon-counter, is perfect The story as a whole is excellent. ver, nearly Nadir Shah. By Sir Mortimer Durand New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. Sir Mortimer it for having at least hesitated before he cast this work into the form of fiction. Nadir Shah was a great Turkoman soldier of the eighteenth century, who advanced through blood to the throne of Persia and set about the conquest of the Orient. His government, as here rep- resented, was an able, iron despotism, tempered for a time by the influence of a humane Indian woman whom he made Against formed, Durand deserves cred- first his captive, then his queen his sway a cons iracy was which he repressed with barbarities re- minding one of “Titus Andronicus.” In volved in the ; lot was the shah’s own son, whom he visited with the most hor rible punishment. So much of the story, and it is the main part of it, seems to pretty firm historical ground. There is material, certainly, in the life of Nadir Shah, for an extremely intei- esting historical monograph. But some of the sources were difficult of access and some of the evidence, as usual, con- tradictory. The author, therefore, pre- ferred, while preserving as carefully as possible the known facts, to draw also his own rest on on unsifted tradition and on acquaintance with the East and to a considerable extent on Imagination to heighten the interest and color of his narrative, The narrative moves, It Is written in a clear, straightforward style not without force. It is enlivened by nearly a score of illustrations, of them old and curious. Except for the character of the heroine, which savors something too much of the Occident, some there is little te offend the sense of verisimilitude, Yet the book, like most Nation. The others of its kind, falls between two stools: as fiction, it leaves us rather cold; as history, it leaves us rather sus- picious. Philip the Forester: A Romance of the Valley of Gardens. By Daniel Ed- wards Kennedy. Brookline, Mass.: The Queen’s Shop. $4.50. By the accompanying note to the pub- lic and by the sumptuous price announc- ed therein, this book rightfully demands, first of all, comment on its exterior. The private press and bindery of the author are its birthplace. The large pages are printed from type on Italian hand-made paper of noble quality. The margins are lavish; the print handsome; the binding, an esthetic dull red paper backed by a cool brown muslin, suggests no ephemeral fiction, but a real book sitting in honored company on the shelves of a real library. The proof- reading, especially in the matter of spelling, is not unassailable, whether from the simplified point of view or from that of the opposing camp. For the luxuriant commas there may be champions. They are at least a novelty to-day. The contents, after disclosing beauti- fully printed title-page, dedication, and list of subscribers’ names, concern themselves not with the Hewlett-like fantasy one might predict from the name, but with an American, oh! very American! mill-town and farming coun- try, and with a young man who holds enlightened views on trees. Much of the action passes in the barroom of the “Golden Dog.” The rest in bucolic and sylvan settings. Sincerity, good faith, nature-love, may not be questioned in counting the merits of the work. For detailed criticism as to form and style, the fiction reviewer, having sung the praises of the outer book, respectfully refers inquirers to the eritic on book- | binding. Dictionary of the Bible. Edited by James Hastings, D.D., with the co- operation of John A. Selbie, D.D., and with the assistance of John C. Lam- bert, D. D., and of Shailer Matthews, D.D. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. Pp. xvi, 992. $5 net. Standard Bible Dictionary. Edited by Melancthon W. Jacobus, D.D., Edward E. Nourse, D.D., and Andrew C. Zenos, D.D. New York: Funk & Wagnalls Co. Pp. xxiii, 920. $6. Commentary on the Holy Bible. By Various Writers. Edited by the Rev. J. R. Dummelow, M.A. Complete in one volume; with general articles and maps. New York: The Macmillan Co. Pp. clill, 1091. $2.50 net. If it be true that the Bible is not known and read to-day as in the time of our fathers, at least the demand for _ = [ Vol. 89, No. 2300 helps to its further elucidation seems almost unlimited. Seven or eight years ago appeared, practically at the same time, the large four and five-volume dic- tionaries of the Bible, edited by Cheyne and Hastings, respectively. While these met the wants of scholars, they did not meet the demands of that much more numerous body who could not afford such large and expensive works, who could not consult them in libraries, and who wished to have on their shelves some handy work to which they could refer speedily. To meet this demand two one-volume dictionaries of the Bible have appeared simultaneously, the one edited by that veteran dictionary-maker, James Hastings, the other by Dean Ja- cobus of the Hartford Theological Sem- inary. Both of these works represent approximately the same theological and critical position. They are conservative- ly critical. Dr. Hastings’s Dictionary is not an abridgment of his larger five-volume work. While he has had in this the co- operation of Dr. Selbie, who coéperated with him before, his other assistants, Dr. Lambert and Prof. Shailer Matthews of the University of Chicago, are new. The list of scholars contributing is also quite different from that contributing to the larger work, and American schol- arship is very much better represented, presumably owing to Prof. Shailer Mat- thews’s coédperation. Occasionally, it is true, an article in the smaller Diction- ary is written by the same person who wrote the corresponding article in the larger werk, but this is the exception. The print of this work is small but clear Space is carefully economized; | and there is almost nothing in the way | of preface or ‘ntroduction. There are no illustrations and but one map of “the encient East.” which, we regret to say, is pocr, inaccurate, and not up to date. At the close of the volume there is an additional note to his article on As- syria and Babylonia, by the Rev. C. H. W. Johns, intended to correct the chron- ology of that article on the basis of King’s “Chronicles” and Hilprecht’s “Chronological Tablets from the Temple Library at Nippur.” The editor of the “Standard Bible Dic- tionary” is an American, and the bulk of the writers in this volume are Amer- ican scholars, the Hartford Theological Seminary furnishing the principal con- tingent. It is interesting to note, as in- dicating the connections of scholarship in England and America, respectively, that, whereas only two German schol- ars contribute to the English work, five Germans and one Dutchman are named in the much smaller list of contributors to the American volume. The latter is printed in larger type and contains over 400 illustrations, wood-cuts, half-tones, and maps, some of which are admirable, others mediocre, and a few bad. Most of the illustrations are from photo- 1 WR NT GEA IRA Oe OIE ee TN ty
Page 19
; : : é oe aia tie a Ea TARR. Or oR Saal decay meh OF nantes % t July 29, 1909] graphs taken by recent explorers, among which the pictures of implements and utensils furnished by Professors Grant and Paton are particularly valuable. The topegraphical chart of Jerusalem, ac- companying Professor Paton’s article, deserves special commendation for the clear-cut view which it gives of the physical conformation of the city and the ingenious way in which, by printing the letters and the numbers on the tis sue-paper cover, instead of on the map itself, one obtains an unconfused view of the whole. The “Standard Diction- ary” is furnished, further, with thumb- holes, lettered to correspond to the arti cles, so that the user may turn quickly to the word sought. The larger articles are divided into sections by box-heads numbered consecutively to facilitate cross reference. In scholarship, the two works stand on about the same plane, and, as al- ready stated, the critical and scholarly point of view in both is practically identical, as shown by a comparison of such articles as Abraham, Jerusalem, and John. The American work is some- what more inclined to be homiletical and to deal with theological topics, or questions of belief. In text content, it is about one-fifth smaller than the English work. At the same time, from its prac- tical arrangement, its larger print, and its abundant illustrations, it is presum- ably the better adapted for the class of users for whom it was intended busy ministers, Bible-class teachers, and Bible students. For the same class of readers, the Macmillan Company has published a one-volume commentary on the whole Bible, edited by the Rev. J. R. Dumme- low. This vork is more distinctly An- glican. Very few American and no Ger man names are included in the list of contributors, while the great majority of the writers are clergymen of the Church of England. The editor prefaces his work by the Collect for the Second Sunday in Advent, from the English Prayer Book. After this most readers would expect to find a very pious and antediluvian volume. That this is not the case is evidence of the great change which has taken place in the point of view of Bible scholarship in the last few years. The results of modern bibli- cal criticism are frankly accepted in this volume, and, while the writers of the various articles and of the com- mentaries on individual books are strict- ly orthodox, their orthodoxy is sane and reasonable, and there is no apparent consciousness of any conflict between orthodoxy and scholarship. The intro- duction to this volume comprises 143 pages, consisting of general articles, dealing with Hebrew history, Penta- teuchal analysis, the Laws of Hammu- rabi, Hebrew prophecy, the religious de- velopment of the Jews, and other literary and archeological topics, together with a ‘The destription of Palestine,a B.ble chrono! ogy, and discussions of the important doctrines of the Christian Nation. more faith. The commentary occupies almost 1,100 pages, of which somewhat’ more than 600 are devoted to the Old Testa ment and a little less than 500 to the New. the latter, therefore, receiving relatively much the fuller treatment. The commen tary on each book prefaced by an introduction, containing an analysis of the book, with a discussion of questions of authorship, date, religious value, ete ‘The commentaries are necessarily short, but quite as long probably as the aver age student desires. There are a few good, but rather crowded and over-con- densed maps, in black and white, at the back of the volume These three books are really valua ble additions to the Bible literature of the English reading world. The preach- er, the missionary, the Bible-class teach er, the intelligent layman, desirous of studying behind the letter of his Bible provided with one or the other of these dictionaries and this commentary, has really in those two volumes a com plete and very effective equipment for the study and interpretation of the Book, an equipment very far in advance of that which good technical scholars pos sessed not many years since Siena, the Story of a Mediwval Com mune. By Ferdinand Schevill. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $2.50 net. This book differs from similar popu lar histories in emphasizing the econom ic bases of Sienese civilization. But let no one suppose that such devotion to the dismal science implies a dull book On the contrary. the method lends con cretenecs and veracit to what otl wise might be a _ rather ncoherent chronicle. Mr. Schevill is refreshingly free from the common vice of personify ing his generalizations. He shows us the actuality—not Liberty or Democ- racy advancing, but the little traders upsetting the privileges and preroga- tives of the big ones, and then the work ing people getting even with both classes of their former betters not merely explain the successive and confusing changes of the c'ty ment, but also tell us why no stable rule was possible all Italy in this failure to the good of the group to that of the state. It is one of the paradoxes of his- tory that, after inventing and elaborat- ing the idea of the state for all time, Italy for nearly twenty centuries should afford a classic example of the evils of particularism. From this lack of real civic spirit Siena was peculiarly a suf ferer. She did develop, however, a substitute in a volatile local pride and a graceful self-sufficiency that make her These motives govern Siena is typical of ubordinate civilization highly characteristic and 103 p cturesqu in intelligence she was never rich. No poet, scientist, or inven- tor of the first rank was born within Rich she was, chiefly in en “Soft Siena,” as she early her gates thusiasm was called, readily produced revellers and saints, the plotters of massacres, and the artists who celebrated the mys ; tic Mother of God and patroness of the city. Mr. Senevill is keenly alive to these aspects of his subject, and has com piled his text so skilfully, interweay from the that his book should fully hold its own with its many excellent predecessors Its defect is merely in the minutiw of |; Style. A certain wordiness and an oc ng fine bits chronicles | casional bluntness of idiom detract from pleasure. These lapses might easily be remedied in a a gensitive readers | second edition |} of Siena is inconclusive and not very preéminence in the beautiful art of enamelling should have The chapter on the art suggestive Her been mentioned, while the charm of her painted sculpture in wood surely desery ed a word. In denying to Duccio high quality as an illustrator and setting him down as a decorator primarily, the point of Mr. Berenson's criticism seems to be missed in transcription. Duccio is one of the greatest of illustrators, only his genre was discursive the fifteenth rather cavalierly because they refused to be Matteo, Sano, and the rest at least cultivated their little gardens with utmost fidelity They show what charm- ing variations might still be played upon The epigones of century are dismissed progressive Sassetta, and delicacy. the apparently moribund Byzantine tra- No form of art is dead so long as any one practices it with love and in- teliigence. It seems the part of good dition taste, then, to take these belated mas ters for what they are, without crush ing them under the obvious and gra tuitous comparison with the giants of Florence This book contains a number of good photographic illustrations. It is so ju- diciously made, so sanely enthusiastic, | and so compact that, with a little mending of the rougher spots in the text, it should take its place with the best popular works on this much be written but never exhausted subject The Story of the State of Washington. By Edmond S. Meany, Professor of History in the University of Washing- ton. New York: The Macmillan Co 2.25 net. Coincident with the opening of the Seattle Fair appears Professor Meany’s excellent account of the new State In which it is held. He writes with the interest natural in one whose own de velopment has been involved in the de- velopment he describes. His pictures and judgments of men and events,
Page 20
104 though warmly patriotic, are never ex- travagant; the detail, though somewhat long drawn for the general reader, is none too elaborate for the public the au- thor has especially in view, the high schools and colleges of Washington it- self: the correctness of his statements is always well vouched for by reference to the good authorities from which they are derived. Physically, Washington offers many a smiling area in the midst of rugged- ness sometimes forbidding, but often most picturesque. It possesses in Puget Sound a vast haven into which more than into any other the commerce of the Pacific may in future be gathered. A fascinating list of characters figure in the story. We begin with Drake and the Spaniards of the sixteenth century with whom he fought; in due time come the later navigators, Cook, Behring, La Perouse, and Vancouver. The _ enter- prise of the New England captains, Rob- ert Gray at the head, is celebrated, an enterprise so marked that almost to this day a “Boston man” among the In- dians is the more intelligible equivalent for American. The explorers by land are a company no less worthy, Macken- zie, Simon Fraser, and John McLough- lin, on the British side, with Lewis and Clark, Marcus Whitman, Frémont, and Isaac I. Stevens, on the Amer‘can. For a decade and more it was doubtful whe- ther the land would go to England or the United States. The influx of an American population, however, decided the matter,and though the 54° 40’ north- ern line, which we coveted, escaped us, we obtained all we could rightfully claim, In Professor Meuny’s story no man seems to us to approach more nearly to the heroic stature than Isaac I. Stev- ens. He fell at the head of his divi- sion, with the national colors in his hand, In a successful effort to withstand the rush of Stonewall Jackson on the Federal capital after the Second Bull Run, September 1, 1862. It has been as- serted that at the moment Lincoln was considering his appointment to the com- mand of the army in Virginia. We know of no authoritative evidence of this, and it {s Improbable, for it was the misfortune of Stevens, and of his coun- try, that he fell In the first serious bat- tle In which he was engaged. He had had no opportunity to become known. Nevertheless, the record of Stevens in the Weat (of which possibly Lincoln was well informed) makes one feel that he might have done well even in that hich and difficult post. He led his class at West Point, then after service in Mexico was chief of the coast survey fn the Federal city. Made territorial gov- ernor of Washington in 1853, he also became head of Indian affairs and of the surveys undertaken for a northern Pacific railroad. Professor Meany calls him “a human dynamo”: and his ener- [Vol. 89, No. 2300 The Nation. gy in the midst of large and perplexing responsibilities, sometimes at peace, sometimes at war, was no more mark- ed than were his tact and courage. Some of the best soldiers of the civil war, North and South, got their training un- der him on the frontier. The account of his surveys is a work of the highest value in the history of Western devel- opment. He made a good record in Con- gress. His death occurred when he was but forty-four, at a moment when the future seemed burdened with honors for him. If any men might contest witn Stevens primacy among the founders of Washington, it would be such railway kings as Henry Villard and James J. Hill. But it must be remembered that in all their work they have but stood upon Stevens’s shoulders: he labored and they entered into his labors. Wanderings in South America, the Northwest of the United States, and the Antilles, in the Years 1812, 1816, 1820, and 1824. By Charles Water- ton. Including a memoir of the au- thor by Norman Moore, M.D. With illustrations and a brief introduction by Charles Livingston Bull. New York: Sturgis & Walton. $2.50 net. The Andean Land (South America). By Chase S. Osborn. Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co. 2 vols. $5. The interest in South America which was aroused by Mr. Root’s visit contin- ues to bring forth its harvest of books. Among them is an attractive reprint of Waterton’s. fascinating “Wanderings,” which it is a pleasure to welcome. Like White’s “Natural History of Selborne, Waterton’s “Wanderings” can never have too many editions. His vivid and faithful pictures of life in the jungle are ever new and always entertaining and instructive. Mr. Bull’s all too mod- est introduction makes one wish he had given more of his own impressions of the region which it was his good for- tune to visit a century after Waterton. Unfortunately, his experiments with photography were unsuccessful, and his drawings are rather too fanciful to be of much value. An appreciative memoir of Waterton, largely autobiographical, compiled by Dr. Moore, who was a friend of the great naturalist’s old age, adds in no small degree to the worth of this edition. Of Mr. Osborn’s two attractive vol- umes, encumbered as they are with sta- tistics and information of the guide-book kind, one cannot speak in such high praise. They are decidedly not up to the standard of recent books on South America, being neither so entertaining as Ruhl's “Other Americans,” so inform- ing as Martin's “Five Republics,” or so accurate as Keane's “South America.” The author is a Michigan “newspaper man,” and many of his stories smack of the Sunday supplement. A breezy journalistic style that tolerates “a swift poke in the solar-plexus” is hardly adapt- ed to a book of this kind, even when it is offset by a dreary compilation of sta- tistics for the cities and towns of the West Coast. There are, besides, chap- ters filled with “personal mention” of fellow-passengers, stars, albatrosses, and whales. But one cannot help wishing that this space had been used to give more adequate treatment to Brazil and Argentina. To the Falkland Islands is allotted an exhaustive chapter, and Chili is gossiped about at considerable length. A remarkable description of Valparaiso’s earthquake by an eye-witness and an en- tertaining account of the journey over the Uspallata Pass are worthy of spe- cial note. As an aid to travellers, how- ever, the work is of doubtful value, for the information in regard to railways leaves out of account the important progress of the past two years, and there are many serious inaccuracies. For in- stance, one may not “coach from Oruro through Sucre to La Paz easily in four days”’—or in fourteen; and there are excellent passenger ships that sail from New York to Buenos Ayres. Nevertheless, Mr. Osborn’s remarks on our trade with South America are im- portant and deserve to be widely read. Especially noteworthy is the letter from a Chilian importer who complains of the packing by American manufacturers as “one of the most disgraceful and discred- itable things imaginable. It is coming to that point where no concern wants to import from the United States, if they can possitly get the goods from Europe. It is a positive pleasure to see goods unpacked from German export- ers.” This subject arises continually in all the reports that come from South America. As Lincoln Hutchinson said three years ago, in his “Report on Trade Conditions in Brazil’: We have heard so much about the neces- sity for correct packing, the minute at- tention to details of orders, the indis- pensability of long credits, etc., that we turn from them with a shrug. Yet the reiteration is made necessary by our ex- porters’ persistent disregard of these fac- tors. Science. The Behavior of Noddy and Sooty Terns. By Dr. John B. Watson. Paper Num- ber VII from the Marine Biological Laboratory at Tortugas, Washington: Carnegie Institution. This paper of sixty-eight pages forms one of the most important of recent contributions to ornithology. The au- thor spent two and a half months on Bird Key, with the object of observing, as closely as possible, the details of the lives of the two species of terns found ADAP REAR GE PN TORIES Pe PALER OM, Mont,
Page 21
¢ a & Fe July 29, 1909] breeding there. Of the Noddy Terns there were about 1,400 adults, while the colony of Sooties numbered more than 18,800. The food and the feeding habits, the courtship, nest-building, care, and ex- ternal development of the young, and the entire daily activity of both species are minutely described, each phase of study being subdivided, and an excel- lent summary given of each. Contrary to what we should expect, these web- footed birds apparently never touch the water except to drink or bathe, and if they fall accidentally into the sea, they are unable to swim against the tide. The male and female, although indis- tinguishable externally, have each their separate work during the early breeding season, the latter building and guarding the nest, the former obtaining food for both. The proof of perfect, yet inex- plicable, recognition between the bird and its mate, its nest and young, is very striking. The most significant experi- ment was that of removing one bird of a pair, marking it distinctly with oil paint, liberating it at a distance from the island, and then noting the time of return to its nest. One bird, taken more than sixty-eight miles, returned in eleven hours, while the individuals which were carried by steamer a dis- tance of 1,080 miles, to a point just north of Cape Hatteras, were seen back at their nests several days later. In this case, however, their mates had al- ready found new partners, and they were not permitted to resume their share in the care of their own young. Dr. Watson has no explanation to offer, saying that the facts obtained from these experiments “are extremely diffi- cult for current theories of orientation to explain.” The author is primarily a psycholo- gist, and his language in a number of instances is made unnecessarily techni- cal by the use of such terms as intra- organic pressure. Although this ped- antry of expression is familiar to psy- chologists, the simplicity of the facts, together with their general interest, would seem to warrant recounting in terms of more common usage. The photographs of the birds, their nests, and eggs, are excellent. When we have biographies, such as this, of many more birds, together with a more thorough knowledge of their structure and development, we may at last hope for light upon the evolution and rela- tionships of these most difficult sub- jects of study. Dr. G. L. Walton’s “Practical Guide to the Wild Flowers and Fruits” (Lippincott) is another serious attempt to aid the be- ginner in identifving a good many common plants by means of their most obvious fea- tures. The primary divisions are based on color: subseauent ones on the more strik- ing characteristics of stems and leaves. Of The Nation. course, such a scheme for aiding everybody to find out the names of plants is open to many objections on the ground of super- ficiality and incompleteness. and there is hardly a page with which a professional botanist might not find much fault. But if the book can help anybody to know more about the plants of common life, it may Serve a useful purpose. The drawings as a rule are not satisfactory, and in one or two instances are distinctly misleading, but they are supplemented by a few good color- ed plates, and by an excellent reproduction of an old print of Dioscorides. Dr. Wal- ton’s plan has the merit of extreme sim- plicity, and in practice may be of service to a good many persons who would never take the trouble to study a botanical book of the most elementary character. The book shows how certain puzzles can be worked out, ending with the names of the plants. The Berlin Akademie der Wissenschaften has issued a number of grants for research, including: 2,300 marks to Professor Engler, for his work on the Vegetable Kingdom; 2,000 marks to Professor Schulze, for his work on the structure of the lungs of birds; and 3,000 marks to Professor Escherich, for his study of the Termites in Ceylon Samuel William Johnson, professor emer! tus of agricultural chemistry at Yale, died July 21, at the age of seventy-nine years. In 1855 he went to the Sheffield Scientific School, where he taught for forty years He was president of the American Chem! cal Society in 1878, and since 1866 a mem- ber of the National Academy of Sciences His best known book, “How Crops Grow," is used extensively in England and Amer- ica, and has been translated into German, Swedish, Italian, Japanese, and Russian. His other books are: ‘“‘Essays on Peat Muck and Commercial Manures,” ‘‘Peat and Its Uses as Fertilizer and Fuel,’ and “How Crops Feed.”’ The death is reported, at the age of fifty- one, of Alexander Anderson, since 1885 professor of natural philosophy in Queen's College, Galway, and since 1899 president of that institution. He published a num- ber of papers on mathematical and other scientific subjects, Art. Royal Palaces of Spain: An Historical and Descriptive Account of the Seven Principal Palaces of the Spanish Kings. By Albert F. Calvert. New York: John Lane Co. $1.50 net. The seven palaces described in this latest volume of the Spanish Series are the Alcazar, the Escorial, El Pardo, Aranjuez, La Granja, Madrid, and Mira- mar. The last hardly conforms to the popular idea of a palace, being a sim- ple country-house of unpretending Eng- lish architecture, destitute of historic interest or art treasures, the summer home of the royal family, where for a few months the formalities and eti- quette of Madrid are laid aside. Three of the remaining six palaces were erected by Philip V, who, after the War of Suc- cession, amused himself in lavishing 105 millions upon La Granja and Aranjuez, and, later, owing to the destruction by fire of the Alcazar at Madrid, was forc- ed to rebuild the royal residence in the capital. Mr. Calvert’s Handbook ought to turn the attention of travellers to La Granja, far surpassing Versailles in the inagnificence of its fountains and natural scenery, and easily reached by carriage from Segovia, itself one of the most interesting but least-visited of Spanish cities, although readily access! ble by rail from Madrid. On this royal retreat, set in the midst of pine-covered hills and dominated by the Pico de Pefialara, Philip spent 45,000,000 crowns Its gardens are its real glory, whereas the palace, in the degenerate taste of the Regency, cannot compare with the Escorial, its solemn neighbor on the op- posite side of the same Sierra, or with that finest of Bourbon palaces, whose white walls rise above the Manzanares in Madrid. The homes of royalty, in spite of their gorgeous monotony, are every- where objects of curiosity to the trav elling public. It may be doubted, how ever, whether those of any other coun try so justify this interest as do the palaces of Spain, either as the scenes of momentous events or as the reposi tories of art treasures. Certainly, no construction in Europe is so stamped with the character of its builder, so con forms to the spirit of its time and its natural surroundings, or leaves so dis tinct an impression of its Imperial mas ter and his age, as the Escorial. Few, if any, of the actual abodes of royalty can boast of rooms rivalling the throne room, Giardini room, or Hall of Ambas sadors of the Madrid palace, or match its collections of tapestry and art fur nishings. No existing royal retreat so reveals the personality of its creator as does that paradise of the melancholy pleasure-sated Philip in the Sierras, of which he said: “It has cost me three millions and amused me three minutes.” And outside of Spain there is no Al ecazar. Mr. Calvert says in his preface: These palaces of the haughtiest royal race In Europe are endowed with the rarest treasures of art and taste, such as only a semi-despotic Power could accumulate in bygone days. It is the object of this lit tle book to reveal these riches to the cu rious In such matters by means of illustra tions, the accompanying text being only to be considered in the light of explanatory notes and chronological data. The text and 165 small but excellent {1- lustrations fulfil the promise of the preface. A. C. McClurg & Co. publish “The Stan dard Galleries of Holland,” by Esther Sin gleton. When one reads that Miss Single ton is the author of “Great Pictures Dx scribed by Great Writers.”’ one knows what to expect—a compilation from all sorts of sources, put together without discoverabl« method. Miss Singleton announces that she
Page 22
106 has “‘endeavored to avoid all criticism by adopting the spelling [of artists’ names] used in the official catalogues of the galleries; and in a few instances these are not agreed."” This may be the proper course, but it would have been as well to give cross references. In the Index Ver- meer of Delft appears, but the reference is only to his View of Delft at The Hague One looks elsewhere and finds entries (in this order), Meer, Jan van der, the Young- er; Meer, Van der; Meer, Jan van der. On looking these up in the text, the dates giv en for the first and third are irreconcilable with those of Vermeer. There are no dates at all in the paragraph referred to in the second entry, and nothing whatever to in- dicate that this is the same painter as Vermeer of Delft, but the picture referred to is the celebrated Girl Reading of the Rijks Museum. In the text, but not in dexed, is a reference to Vermeer of Utrecht, who may or may not be one of the other Van der or van der Meers. Surely it is the duty of a writer to afford some guidanc« through this labyrinth. The death is announced of Jules-Clément Chaplain, the eminent engraver of medals He was born in 1839, and studied under Jouffroy and Oudinot. Among his better known bronze medallions are those of Re- nan, Robert Fleury, and MacMahon. Iinanece. Forty Years of American Finance. By Alexander Dana Noyes. Second edi- tion. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $1.50 net. Since 1898 students of the economic history of the United States have been under a heavy debt to Mr. Noyes for his “Thirty Years of American Finance.” The present volume renews and greatly increases that obligation. It adds to the author’s invaluable history of the pe- riod extending from 1867 to 1897 an ac- curate, dispassionate, and well-reasoned account of the decade that ended with the panic of 1907. The five new chapters, which narrate the events of the last decade, begin with the “industrial boom” that started in 1897. After pointing out that the great increase in the world’s gold output and the accompanying worldwide rise of prices contributed to the expansion of industry in all countries, the author shows that our own Industrial expan- sion began with the return of agricultur- al prosperity in 1897. As usual, deficient harvests abroad and “bumper” crops at home were the cause of this prosperity, which, on account of the continued rise in the prices of staple products, has con- tinued to the present day. At about the same time occurred the noteworthy growth of our export trade in manufac- tured products, which led to so much talk of our “industrial Invasion” of Eu- rope. The direct result of these devel- opments was the accumulation of large credits abroad which contributed to the stability of our rickety currency system, The Nation. and made our money market for a time independent of Europe. Such conditions favored, of course, the growth of speculation. Our newly ac- quired wealth entered the investment market and rapidly absorbed the avail- able supply of railway securities and public loans. Promoters of companies were not slow to take advantage of such an opportunity, and by 1899 and 1900 were busily engaged in the manufacture of “industrial” securities to meet the demand of investors. If speculation was active in those years, it became frenzied in 1901. Numbers of factories were consolidated into large corpora- tions, large corporation was joined to large corporation until the outcome was a Trust, and then came the gigantic holding company, owning a number of Trusts. Every stage !n the process was attended with the manufacture, then the duplication and reduplication of securi- ties, most of which were absorbed by gullible investors: until it seemed as if no scheme could be so reckless or vision- ary as to fail of support by the invest- ing public. A new era ‘n finance had come, in which men “thought in bil- lions,” and none of the old laws of trade were thereafter to apply to American industrial development. The Northern Pacific episode in May, 1901, in no way affected the sources of the country’s real prosperity, but, with other developments of that year, did give warning to ‘nvestors that things could be overdone, even in the new financial era; so that in 1902 spec- ulation was considerably less active. Most of the great men of finance, how- ever, took no warning; and, continuing to promote companies of more and more doubtful stabflity, found themselves caught in 1903 ‘n a “rich men’s panic.” This disturbance was but temporary; and after a short retardation, the wheels of industry revolved as before. By 1905 continued agricultural prosperity and rising prices for commodities led the great men to renew the boom in stocks; and this they did with cap‘tal procured abroad and by using the credit and oth- er resources of the great corporations they controlled. Simultaneously in vari- ous countries of Europe, in South Amer- ica, and in distant Japan, there occurred outbursts of speculation. On the sur- face, at least, things were going as they should in a new era which had formulat- ed its own laws of trade, and, incident- ally, abolished fear and possibility of panics. But underlying conditions were no longer what they had been in 1901. business in practically all lines was as good as ever, if not better than be- but for that very reason made greater demands upon the country’s supply of capital. And in Buropean markets, the lines were tightening. In- dustrial activity was intense, and to this was added unrestrained specula- fore: [ Vol. 89, No. 2300 tion in various countries; meanwhile two great wars had destroyed some three billions of capital that might oth- erwise have been available for indus- trial or commercial purposes. Discount rates in the money centres were a sure indication of approaching strain on the world’s supply of free capital, and ex- perienced observers gave warning of possible danger. If ever there was a time for prudence and moderation in stock speculation, the two years pre- ceding the panic of 1907 were such a time. What our great men did, however, wes to draw upon the resources of the financial institutions under their con- trol and utilize the credit of their rail- ways and other corporations for the purpose of inaugurating a boom in stocks. When falling bank reserves and rising discount rates brought this p-9- cess to an end, they then had recourse to foreign loans, and this even at the very season when, according to the old- fashioned finance, it had been thought necessary to husband resources in or- cer to move the crops. By the close of 1906 foreign borrowings had risen to a total of $500,000,000, and American mar- kets were clearly dependent upon Eu- ropean, in which capital was already searce in proportion to the demand, and was becoming scarcer. Meanwhile, in this country various revelations of wrongdoing in high places were destroy- ing confidence in the morality of our new financiers as well as confidence in the safety of their methods, so that the great men finally had the stock market pretty much to themselves. Py the fall of 1906, further borrow- ing in Europe had become impossible, and Wall Street had to appeal to the Federal Treasury for relief. Railways found it difficult or impossible to mar- ket their bonds, and were obliged to issue their notes in order to complete construction work and meet maturing obligations. By the middle of 1907, not less than $300,000,000 of such notes had been issued. The spring of that year had brought news of crises in Egypt and Japan; October was to report oth- ers at Hamburg and in Chili. In March and August heavy sales of securities on the New York exchange, evidently by some of the great men and for the purpose of obtaining ready money, gave evidence that new-fangled methods of abolishing panics might go wrong after all; while a number of business fail- ures indicated an increasing strain on capital. When the panic actually broke, a notorious “chain” of New York banks and a “speculative” trust company were the actual storm centre; but it might just as well have been precipitated in some other way. Since October, 1907 we have heard little of the new finance which was to supersede all the old laws of trade. Se RRO Aa ig a IONS NEEL ETE AIO IS rg + aw
Page 23
eT cee Md oo A ed ne ne short of doing justice to Mr. Noyes’s masterly array of facts in their proper sequence and his searching discussion of their meaning. Through the mad speculation of 1901 and the reckless op- erations of 1905 and 1906 our author studied, as they occurred, the events he now reviews as historian; he is equip- ped as is no other man for the task he has so well performed. In those days he was never dazzled by the most bril- liant operations of the new finance, or deluded by the sophistries of its ac- cepted exponents; and his history of the past decade is as good a vindica- tion as could be written of the old- fashioned finance based on the teach- ings of reason and experience. In any survey of such a wide field differences of opinion must inevitably arise at some points, and Mr. Noyes cannot, and doubtless did not, expect to escape all criticism. His opinions are certain, however, to have great weight, and his critics will have no easy task. Particularly valuable is his discussion of the significance of the Northern Se- curities case; also his analysis of the nature of the speculative movement of 1905 and 1906, and his pitiless dissec- tion of the assertion that Mr. Roose- velt caused the late panic. By way of criticism, it may be pointed out that it is misleading to say, as Mr. Noyes does that the currency act of 1900 provides that notes once redeemed “shall be held in the reserve fund until exchanged for gold,” without adding that elsewhere ‘‘A volume with many of the quali- ties of a work of reference and as read- able as a novel,” is what the Tribune calls When the Railroads Were New By C. F. CARTER. With 16 full-page illustrations. Net, $2.00. Though intended boys too like it. 34W.33d St. Henry Holt& Co. {v5 “TONO- BUNGAY” MUSICIANS LIBRARY | SEND FOR FREE BOOKLETS OLIVER DITSON CO., Ditson Bidg., Boston, Mass. BOOK S—Alil out of print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me, stati books wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call a Ins my stock of 50,000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOK SHOP, John Bright 8t., Birmingham, England. ; Send for Catalogue. TAUCHNITZ FREI hemor occ BRITISH for adults, 128 Tremont Street, AUTHORS BOSTON, MASS. The Nation. the statute provides a method by which | apparently the notes may be reissued without such exchange. On Tuesday, July 27, shortly after the close of business on the Exchange, an- nouncement was made of a quarterly divi- dend of % of 1 per cent. upon the common stock of the United States Steel Company This quarterly rate, if maintained, will put | this stock upon a 3 per cent. basis instead | of the 2 per cent. basis prevalent since May, 1906. The ruling prices of this se curity for some time have portended an | advance in dividends. Just before the ac- | tual announcement of the increase it closed | at 714. The earnings reported for the quarter ended June 30 would seem to justify the action of the directors, although the figures of earnings for 1906 and 1907 are not approached. Unfilled orders stand at over four million tons, and the outlook for future production is therefore encour- aging. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Avery, Mabel A. Mother Goose on Bridge. Syracuse, N. Y.: Lyman Bros Brady, B. F. Sectionalism and Some of Its Fruits. Goldsboro,, N. C B. F. Grady. 25 cents. Chile. Compiled by the International Bureau of American Republics. Washing- ton, D. C. $1. Christian Ministry and the Social Order Lectures delivered at Yale Divinity School 1908-1909. Edited by CC. S. Macfariand New Haven: Yale University Press Cramp, W. S. The Heart of Silence: ton: C. M. Clark Pub. Co Darwin, C. Foundations of the Or: Species, a Sketch Written in 1842 ed by Francis Darwin London bridge University Press Dodd, W. F. The Government of the Dis trict of Columbia Washington John Byrne & Co. $1.50. Bos gin of Edit Cam STUDIES IN HISTORY, ECONOMICS | AND PUBLIC LAW: Edited by the Faculty of Political Science of Columbia University. NEW VOLUMES. Vol. XXXIII., No. 3. An Introduction to | the Sources Relating to the Germanic Invasions. By CARLTON HUNTLEY HAYES, Pb.D., Lecturer in History in Colum bia University. 8vo. Paper Covers, $1.50 Cloth, $2.00. Vol. XXXV., No. 1. The Conflict over Judi- cial Powers in the United States to 1870. By CHARLES GROVE HAINES, Pb.D., Professor of History and Political Science, Ur sinus College. 8vo. Paper covers, $1.50 Vol. XXXV. No. 2. A Study of the Popula- tion of Manhattanville. By HOWARD BROWN WOOLSTON, Ph.D., Formerly Lectur er in Sociology, Western Reserve University 8vo. Paper Covers, $1.25. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York The —-* By GORK WY Prof. George E. Woodberry’s new Life of Poe NOW READY 107 Frost, T. G. The Man of Destiny. Gram- ercy Pub. Co. Hudgins, C. D. A Transferred Identity. Oglivie Pub. Co. 25 cents. Janitschek, M. irrende Liebe. Leipzig: B. Elischer Nachfolger. Knopf, 8. A. Tuberculosis. Moffat, Yard @ Co. $2. Knowlson, T. 8. The Education of the Will. Philadelphia: Lippincott Lake, F. P. Uncle Sim. Cc. M. Clark Pub. Co. Letters and Journals of Samuel Gridley Howe. Vol. Il. Boston: Dana Estes & Co. $3 net. Murdock, H Gentleman Paris, Describing the Great Fire. ton Mifflin. $5 net Newman, Carrie S. Kindergarten in Home. Boston: Page & Co One Day. Anonymous. Macaulay Company Oxford English Dictionary. Vol. VIII S— Sauce. Frowde. $1.25. Report on Codéperative Savings and Loan Associations for 1908. Transmitted to the N. Y. Legislature. Roberts, W. C., Jr It: a Chronicle of Foreign Eight-year-old Waterloo Boston: 1872: Letters Written by a in Boston to His Friend in Hough- the The Boy's Account of Travel by an Press $1 Spenser, E. The Faerie Queene. Printed for William Ponsonbie, 1596 Vols. I and II. Putnam’s. Transportation by Water in the United States. Report of the Commissioner of Corporations. Part 1. Washington: Gov- ernment Printing-Office Twenty-secor¢ Annual Report on Factory Inspection for twelve months ended Sept 30, 1907. Albany: State Dept. of Labor Vrooman, F B Theodore Roosevelt, Dynamic Geographer. Frowde Walsh, J. J. The Thirteenth Greatest of Centuries Second edition, with emen- dations and an appendix. Fordham Uni versity Press Wells, H. G Socialism and the Family Boston: Bal] Pub. Co 5h) cents net ; Wheeler, J. C. There She Blows: a Whal ing Yarn Dutton $1.20 net | White, Frances H Captain Jinks: the Autoblography of a Shetland Pony Boston Page & Co $1.50 Who’ Who Alone the North Shore of Mass 1909. Salem, Mass.; Salem Press Co. $2.50. NOW READY Fallacies of Protection By FREDERIC BASTIAT New Edition. $1.00 net This sro, Hastiat, century influence famous treatise of which, three-quarters of a back, exercised so large a” in the economic literature of Europe, has, in its English version, been out of print for a series of years The large measure of attention that is being given on both sides of the Atlantic to the issues discussed by Bastiat has warranted the production of a new edition. The introduction prepared for the book by the Prime Minister of Great Britain indicates the direct connection of Bastiat’s teachings with a most active question of the day. G.P. PUTNAM S SONS, f*toxocs SAINTE-BEUVE By Prof. George M. Harper, Princeton University J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. FOR SALE: An wz copy of each, lat, 2a, and 30 editions, of ‘Science and Health’’; in fine order Address No. 1427 Moom 4, Washington, D. C yr w., MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskil?, N. Y. ATIONAL SOCIALIST REVIEW Recent No. and BOOK CATALOGUE for 10c. CHARLES H. KERR & CO. CHICAGO.
Page 24
108 The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2300 IMPORTANT BOOKS THE WARS OF RELIGION IN FRANCE: The Huguenots, Catherine de Medici, and Philip the Second, 1559-76. By JAMES WESTFALL THOMPSON. The volume, representing nearly seven years of study, including two prolonged visits to France, is based upon a careful examination of original sources, and contains a valuable appendix of hitherto unpublished documents from the archives of Paris and London. It treats of the epoch of the Reformation, but does not attempt to deal with the religious conflict except in so far as it influenced the political, diplomatic, and economic activities of the period. Our whole in- terpretation of the sixteenth century, of course, has been profoundly changed by the recent progress in economics; and in the matter of industrial history and of the retroactive effect of wretched existing conditions, as also in the development of the Holy League of France out of certain political and social forces, the book makes decidedly new and valuable con- tributions. 618 pages, 8vo, cloth; illustrated; net $4.50, postpaid $4.84. MODERN CONSTITUTIONS. By WALTER FAIRLEIGH DODD. This collection contains the texts, in English translation, where English is not the original language, of the con- stitutions or fundamental laws of the Argentine nation, Australia, Austria-Hungary, Belgium, Brazil, Canada, Chile, Den mark, France, Germany, Italy, Japan, Mexico, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Russia, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, and the United States. These constitutions have not heretofore been available in any one English collection, and a number of them have not before appeared in English translation. Each constitution is preceded by a brief historical introduction. and is followed by a select list of the most important books dealing with the ~overnment of the country under considera- tion. 2 vols., 750 pages, Svo, cloth; net $5.00, postpaid $5.42. PRIMARY ELECTIONS. By C. EDWARD MERRIAM. For students of American political history, and especially of American party bistory, this volume will be particu- larly valuable. question. readers, as well as The absence of literature on this subject makes the appearance of the book the special students, will find it of interest. CHRIST AND THE EASTERN SOUL: it gives a clear account of the various laws and cases, and a critical discussion of the present primary especially timely. Many general 300 pages, 12mo. cloth; net $1.25, postpaid $1.35. The Witness of the Oriental Consciousness to Jesus ‘ Christ. Lectures delivered on the Barrows Foundation in India, Ceylon, and Japan. By CHARLES CUTHBERT HALL. The task undertaken is to show the best elements in Oriental religion, and to point out in just what way they may contribute to Christianity, which is in its essence, stripped of institution and dogma, Eastern in both origin and spirit. Analyzing the Oriental consciousness, Dr. Hall finds four great elements of strength, which he defines as the Contempla- tive Life, the Presence of the Unseen, Aspiration toward Ultimate Being, and Reverence for Sanctions of the Past. mysticism is really at the heart of both Eastern and Western religions, considers that He and shows wherein Christianity may become more vital through the introduction of certain mystic strains, and Oriental mysticism more virile by knowledge of the personal God of the Western World. ning personality of the author. Address Dept. 21. The book is written in an effective style, behind which one recognizes the win- 250 pages, 8vo, cloth; net $1.25, postpaid $1.37. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO NEW YORK Library Orders We have conducted a special department for many years that has been exceptionally successful in handling book orders from PUBLIC LIBRARIES SCHOOLS, COLLEGES ‘ and UNIVERSITIES Our Monthly Bulletin of New Books, with annotations and brief descriptions of each title recorded, is one of the most helpful aids in book selection. Library Department A. C. McCLURG & CO. CHICAGO PRIMER OF AMERICAN LITERATURE By ABBY WILLIS HOWES Author of “‘A Primer of Mnglish Literature."’ 14 portraits, 160 pages. 60 cents. Cloth, D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers BOSTON, NEW YORK. CHICAGO. , &4e Astor Edition of Poets ia the best for schools and colleges. 00 vols. List price, 60e, per vol.; price to schools, 40c. SEND FOR LIST. Thomas Y.Crowell &Co.,New York BEST facilities for supplying engi BOOKS ita French Spanish Catalogues free. Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 30-32 West 27th St., years. New York 7 ¢ EARLY WESTERN TRAVELS > 17481846 “The series should be in every public, collegiate, and institutional library, to say » nothing of private collections of respectable ‘ rank."’"—The Critic. » THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., Cleveland, Ohio Do you know the Beacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen- ty-nine eminent Americang that are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 cents net; by mail, 54 cents. THE CLEVEREST BOOK OF THE YEAR ANNE OF GREEN GABLES By L. M. MONTGOMERY