The Nation 1909-07-08: Vol 89 Iss 2297

Page 1

The Natio® ¥ e .2 VOL. LXXXIX—NO. 2297. THURSDAY, JULY ——— -~ — 8, 1909. PRICE TE THREE VALUABLE LIBRARY BOOKS ee == TTERS FROM CHINA By SARAH PIKE CONGER (MRS. E. H. CONGER) “In range of observation and in fluency of descriptive narration she is not unlike Madame Waddington.”—The Dial. “Fully as valuable as Mrs. Fraser's ‘Letters from Japan,’ are Mrs. Conger’s ‘Letters from China.” Her richly Il- lustrated and well-indexed book ig vivid and fascinating, and as a whole is likely to hold its own as a permanent contri- bution to our knowledge of China.”"—The Natéon. “This is reaily one of the most important books on Chima that has appeared in recent years. . . . It is quite wonderful how many elements of unique interest appear in this wholly admirable book, furnishing glimpses of the interior life and spirit, character and sentiment of the better Chinese homes.”—The Tribune. “An extended view of Chinese life, delightful in its variety and important for its content. The book is indeed a de- lightful addition to our knowledge of a country of which no one nowadays cam afford to be ignorant.”—The Argonaut. With 86 illustrations and map. $2.75 net; postpaid, $2.95. THE ANDEAN LAND Member of the Board of Regents of the University of Michigan “In the course of an extended journey the author visited the chief cities along both coasts of South America, and he has as c there a vast amount of information about the states and cities which he visited. He touches at length upon such topics onsuls, the errors of American exporters, railroads, grain inspection, international trade, mines, crops, markets, and so- jal customs. His work is readable and instructive.”—Chicago Tribune. “The work not only combines the informalities of a genial and venturesome traveler with the thoroughness and erudl- i tion of a student, but it fills a niche in the scanty literature on a country that has suffered a peculiar neglect. The work will therefore remain unique in value and Interest for some time to come.”—Detroit Journal. “The work is one which will speedily find a place in all public libraries and which no private library of any pre- tensions can afford to be without."—Deily Mining Journal. Two volumes, with 60 illustrations and four maps. Large 8vo. $5.00 net. By mail, 85.35. set down his observations of men and affairs as he found them. His book will not only be entertaining reading, but is c THE EMPIRE of THE EAST Japan as It Was, Is, and Will Be By H. B. MONTGOMERY “We have here the clear impressions of a keen observer and straightforward narrator, and the text shows warmth of heart and an honest sympathy with an aspiring people. The illustrations, both in taste and execution, are unusually fine.”’-- The Nation. “The work is worthy the attention of all interested in Japan and its people. Its terse and simple style is no small ’ element of its attractiveness.”"—The Chicayo Record-Herald. “All that he writes bears the mark of independent inquiry and opinions formed without reference to conventional ity. But it would be hard to impugn the good faith in which it is written or the carnest care of its preparation.”— The Argonaut. With frontispiece in color and siateen other iliustrations. Inder. Large 800. $8.50 net. By mail $2.64 eee A. C. McCLURG & CO., PUBLISHERS, CHICAGO i 4

Page 2

The N The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. the New York second-class mail matter.| [fntered at The Nation ts published and owned by the New Oswald Garrison Villard, Paul York Evening Post Co President; William J Elmer More, Editor Pattison, Treasurer; Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Can- ada £3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Unton, £4.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Team WERK .ccccccccccccccccccccccseces 23 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Nearing the Tariff? End............+- 2 The Science of Race-Hatred.......... 26 As Baedeke: Sees Us......... eseessees 27 SpPecIAL ARTICLES: Why We Commemorate Calvin........ 28 News for Bibliophiles.............+-. 31 CORRESPONDENCE: Was John Cotton the Preceptor of Henry Vane? - a oe The Bacon Acrostic : ae Fifteenth Century Verses in Praise of Printing TTeTrrrrTt tT Ty tit 33 od ecu ncsceceduceusesecsiesbesbatel 34 Book REVIEWS: The Great Lakes.—The Story of the Great Lakes.—Old Times on_ the Upper Mississippi .........-eeeeeee 36 The Romance of a Plain Man........ 37 Co See eer ree 37 Wem POSSE ccccccccsvcccccceccsse 37 0 rr peesenerveesckesarens 37 Poetical Werks of Giles and Phineas PEO ccccasccsrvaczetotendesbadsss 38 The Love Affairs of Napoleon.—A Fa- VOTO CC FORGO Gs oc icceccsceeecess 38 SciIENCR Birds Of the Wola... .ccccccccecsccess 39 ART: Art Experts on the Defensive........ 40 FINANCI ee 41 Boor or Tue WreeK 12 ** *C ple of The Nation may be procured ta Parle at Hrentane’s, 17 Avenue de Opéra; in lomion of B. FF. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar ‘quere, Oharing Cross Six Months Subscription Free, THE NATION will extend SIX MONTHS the term of any subscriber who sends a name not already on our list with remit- tance for the new subscription for one City Post Office aa ation. [Vol. 89, No. 2297 Educational. Educational. ECOLE LIBRE DES 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, 4 PAR Fonpatevur: E .—COMIT HENRY, am eur Comptes; Georges L . U député, ancien président du Conseil des Minis ESMEIN, de I'[nstitut, puté; BOULANGER, conseiller maitre a la député, etc, Histoire parlementaire et législative de la France, de 1789 A 1875. a constitutiennelle de I'Kurope et des Etats- nis. Histoire diplomatique de l'Europe, de 1713 & nos jours. Histoire politique de l'Europe pendant les vingt derniéres années. Politique coloniale des Etats européens depuis 1783. L’ Amerique contemporaine: Etats-Unis d’ Amérique, Canada, Amérique latine. Questions politiques et économiques dans Il’Asie orientale. Organisation et administration coloniales com- parées. Géograpble et organisation militaires.—Géographie des possessions francalses. libérale, dans les grandes entreprises privées, n'ont A justifier d‘aucun grade universitaire. A juin 1910, Une Brochure speciale ¢ les carriéres auxque/les eile prépare. meres de France; Ch. LAURENT, ancien premier président de la Cour des 1S, ambassadeur, ancien directeur des Affaires politiques et commerciales au ministére des Affaires 6trangéres; MAGNIN, vice-président du deur; PALLAIN, gouverneur de la Banque de France; A. RIBOT, de l' Académie frangaise, La durée ordinatre des études est de trois ans, toutefois, on peut la réduire A deux années, dipléme est délivré, en fin d’études, aux é6léves qui ont subi avec succés les examens. NNEE SCOLAIRE 1909-1910.—L' année scolaire commencera le 8 novembre 1909 et finira le 4 On s inscrira au Secrétariat A pertir du 2 novembre 1909: Inscription d’ensemble don- nant entrée a tous les cours et conférences réguliers et complémentaires et Ala bibliothéque (environ 25,000 volumes et 160 revues et puvenee frangais et 6trangers) SCIENCES POLITIQUES IS (Trente-neuviéme année, 1909-1910) mile BOUTMY. I.—Directeur: M. Anatole LEROY-BEAULIEU, membre de I'Institut, il DE PERFECTIONNE MM. Leon BOURGEOIS, sénaieur, ancien président du Conseil des Ministres; CAMBON, ambas- sadeur; FLOURENS, ancien ministre: HANOTAUX, de |' Académie fra DU BOYS, ancien directeur des Affaires commerciales au ministére des Affaires 6tran; MENT ngaise, ancien ministre; nat; NISARD, ambassa- t res. Itl.—CORPS ENSEIGNANT MM, LEVASSEUR, de l'Institut; LYON-CAEN, de l'Institut, doyen de la Faculté de Droit; A. prof, Ala Faculté de Droit: RENAULT, de l'Institut, de Droit; Anatole LEROY-BEAULIEU, de l'Institut; Albert VANDAL, de |'Académie fran- cgaise; E. BOURGEOIS, prof. A la Faculté des Lettres: Charles BENOIST, de l'Institut, dé- J. FLACH, prof. au Collége de France; ROMIEU. conseiller d'Etat; TARDIEU, TEI 8S! ER, maitre des requétes au Conseil d'Etat; CHEYSSON, de l'Institut, Inspecteur général honor. des Ponts et Chaussées; DE FOVILLE, de l'Institut, conseiller maitre a la Cour des Comptes ; Rene STOURM, de l'Institut, ancien inspecteur des Finances; Aug. ARNAUNE, conseilier maitre a la Cour des Comptes, ancien directeur de l'Administration des Monnaies; ‘our des Comptes; COURTIN, PLAFFAIN, inspecteurs des Finances; SILVESTRE, ancien directeur des Affaires civiles au Tonkin; J. CHAILLEY, TABLEAU SOMMAIRE DES COURS rof, A la Faculté Ethnographie de l'Europe.—Géographle commer- clale et statistique. Droit des gens.—Droit international conventionnel. Organisation et =mati®res administratives en France et A l’étranger. Questions algérienne et tunislennes.—Droit musul- maa. Législation des chemins de fer. Economie politique; Economie sociale; Législation ouvriére. Hygiéne publique et grands travaux publics. Finances francaises et étrangéres. La monnaie, le crédit et le change.—Affaires de banque. Politique commerciale des grandes puissanc 5. RENSEIGNEMENTS GENERAUX L’Enseignement de !' Rcole des Sciences politiques est le couronnement naturel de toute éducation Chacune de ses grandes divisions constitue en outre une préparation compléte aux carriéres d’Etat et aux examens ou concours qui en ouvrent l’entrée: (Diplomatie, Conseil d'Etat, Cour des Comptes, Inspection des Finances, Inspection des Colonies), et A des postes d’initiative ou de contréle Les é6léves sont admis sans examens, avec l'agrément du Directeur et du Conseil de I’Ecole; ils Un Par ANNEKE: 350 fr. onne des renseignements détailiés sur l organisation del’ Ecole et sur Sedresser d VECOLE, 27, Rue Saint-Guillaume, PARIS. 7 ‘HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Everett 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2 A Park Street. Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 208 Mich. Ave.. Chicago 292 Swetland Bid., Portland 405 Poston Bid., Denver 238 Doug!’sBid., Los Angeles on Bid., Spokane 2142 Shattuck Ave.,Berkeley ind to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY Supplies schools of all grades with competent teachers. Vacancies occurring throughout the year. Send for bulletin. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany,N.Y. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY WORCESTER, MASS. Established in 1856. An ideally healthful location. Efficient taculty. Prepara- tion for the best institutions. The Rt. Rev. A. H. Vinton, D.D., LL.D., Visitor. For Catalogue please address 408 EPH ALDEN SHAW, A.H., Headmaster. ] ETHLEHEM PREPARATORY Bethiehem, Pa. [frepares for lead! Catalogue. H. A. FOERING, SCHOOL, colleges. B.8., Headmaster. STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Balzac, Bronté, Browning, Bulwer, Car- lyle, Cooper, Dickens, Dumas, De Foe, Eliot, Gibbon, Guizot, Hawthorne, Hugo, Irving, Macaulay, Plutarch, Poe, Prescott, Ruskin, Scott, Shakespeare, Thackeray, Tolstoi. | Send for Descriptive Booklet. THOWAS Y, CROWELL & C0, Now York Do you know theBeacon Biographies? The only authoritative lives of twen-| ty-nine eminent Americang that are at the same time brief. Each volume 60 cents net; by mall, 54 cents. Send for a descriptive pamphlet. & Co., 2 year, MANLY’S ENGLISH PROSE 1137—1890. 544 pages, List Price $1.50 A library of the best English Literature from the Anglo-Saxon chronicle to Stevenson, tn one small, light, well-bound UNSURPASSED IN Range, Choice, and Variety. GINN AND COMPANY, Publishers 29 Beacon Street Boston, Mass. Quarto, clearly printed volume. Important Historical Publications Relating to America CATALOGUB MAILED ON APPLICATION. THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO. CLEVELAND, OHIO. PRIMER OF AMERICAN LITERATURE By ABBY WILLIS HOWES Autbor of “A Primer of Boglish Literature.’’ Cloth, 14 portraits, 160 pages. 60 cents. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers BOSTON, NEW YORK. CHICAGO. MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) bought by A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y.

Page 3

July 8, 1909 THE JULY ISSUE Harvard Theological Review Includes the Following Articles : THE BEARING OF HISTORICAL STUDIES ON THE RELIGIOUS USE OF THE BIBL Professn Frank C. Porter, Yale University. A fresh and striking treatment of the help and hindrance for religion from modern historical study, and of the service religion can render to history. THE MARROW OF CALVIN’'S THEOLOGY. Professor William W Fenn, Harvard University. A candid and sympathetic exposition of what Calvinism actually was. A BASIC PRINCIPLE FOR THE- OLOG). Professor Edward 8. Drown, Episcopal Theological School, Cambridge. A consideration of the Kingdom of God as the foundation for an adequate system of theology. FRIEDRICH NIETZSCHE, ANTI- CHRIST, SUPERMAN. PRAG- MATIST. Dr. John M. Warbeke, Wil- liams College. An analysis of Nietzsche's philosophy and a discussion of his influence. WHAT HAVE FACTS TO DO WITH FAITH? Projessor Charles H. Hayes, General Theological Seminary, New York City. “Is the affirmation in the creeds of his- torical happenings valuable, or does it prove a stumbling block?’’ This is the question which Professor Hayes faces. JESUS, THE SON OF GOD. Professor Benjamin W. Bacon, Yale University A new and striking view of the meaning of Jesus's Sonship in his own thoughts, and its relation to his mission. THE ALEVIS, DEIFIERS OF ALI. Rev. Stephen Van Rensselaer Trowbridge of Aintab, Turkey. The first account from adequate original knowledge of a remarkable modern sect of Mohammedan syncretists. The Harvard Theological Review is issued quarterly by The Faculty of Di- vinity in Harvard University, and is pub- lished by THE MACMILLAN COMPANY Subscription price $2.00 a year 50 cents a copy The Nation. MT. CLEMENS. MICH. Open Allithe Year Round Oven Alithe Year Round HVED ATS = NB suit all tastes and purses. Mt. Clemens Mineral Water Baths SS ? Ke i N G S Nature’s Cure for RHEUMATISM and All Nervous and Blood Diseases The ularity of Mt. Clemensas a HEALTH AND PLEASUR ESO) reases each succeeding year. Mt- Clemens offers every requisite for — a ee The merits of Mt. Clemens Mineral Water Bat where. Mt. Clemens is delightfully situated 20 miles from Detroit. Throug hs are attested by prominent yaipate every- rains from all directions. Detroit suburban electric cars eve ry half hour. Illustrated book t. Cle mailed free. Address F. R. EASTMAN, Chamber of Commerce. Bs Siecanen, Mich. — a Prof. George E. Woodberry’s new Life of Poe NOW READY Ths => By GORK WY JUST ISSUED. Cloth, $1.50 net. SAINTE-BEUVE By Prof. George M. Harper, Princeton University B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. “TONO- ~BUNGAY” THE CLEVEREST BOOK ) OF THE YEAR ANNE OF GREEN GABLES By L. M. MONTGOMERY HE MUSICIANS LIBRARY SEND FOR PREE BOOKLETS | OLIVER DITSON CO., Ditson Bidg., Boston, Mass. OUR LIBRARY SERVICE We have recently supplem..ted our ser- | vice to Libraries, by procuriag Out-of-Print and Scarce Books, and »y importing Bnglish books. Our Educational Catalogue con- tains a full list of Supplementary Reading, indicating the grade to which each title Is adapted. Our Clearance Catalogue § contains overstock at special prices, and an alpha- betical arrangement by authors of all cheap editions of Recent Popular Fiction and Standard library 12mos in one list. Our Library Catalogue of 3,500 approved titles, following A. L. A. lines, Is of great convenience to smal! libraries. Our Monthly Bulletin notices | promptly every new book of importance. | These Catalogues are sent on request. Three notable features of our service are: | Promptness, thoroughness, and low prices. | THE BAKER AND TAYLOR Co. Wholesale Dealers in the Books of All Publishers 33 East 17th St., New York. BOOKS—aAll out of print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me, stating books wanted; I can get you any book ever published; when in England, call a inspect my stock of 000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP, 50, John Bright St., Birmingham, England ) Bend for Catalogue. TAICHNITZ ES SCHOENHOF BOOKCO. pRiT|SH Moston. Mass.” AUTHORS SOCIALIST REVIEW TIONAL Recent No. and BOOK CATALOGUE for 10c. CHARLES H. KERR & CO. CHICAGO Newspapers Sources For the period which covered Reconstruction, from 1865 to 1877, | used The Nation to a large extent. Its bound volumes are convenient to handle in one’s own library, and its summary of events is useful in itself, and as giving leads to the investigation of other material. editorials have spoken for the sober sense of the people with amazing success, er of The Nation since 1866, Ll have felt the fascin- ation of Godkin, and have been consciously on I tried not to be led away by his guard against it. incisive statements and judgments. bias, he had an honest mind, and was incapable of knowingly making a false statement; and this, with his other qualities, lent historical material. great care some friendly criticism, I can truly say that I have no apology to make for the extent to which I used The Nation. The Atlantic Monthly, May, 1909. ut whatever may be thought of his as Historical Frequently its As a constant read- sometimes uncharitable makes his journal excel- After considering with James Ford Rhodes, in

Page 4

LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S NEW BOO KS | The Political History of England Written by Various Authors under the Direction and Editorship of the Rev. WILLIAM HUNT, D.Litt, President of the Royal Historical Society and REGI- NALD LANE POOLE, M.A., LL.D., Editor of the English Historical Review. In 12 Volumes, 8vo, each Volume having its own Index and Two or more Maps. Vol. IX., From the Accession of Anne to the Death of George II. (1702 to 1760). By I. S. LEADAM, M.A., formerly Fellow of Brasenose College, Oxford With 8 Maps. pp. xx—557. $2.60 net. «* Vols. I, IT, II, TV, V. VII. X, XI and XII are The price of the com- also ready Each, $2.60, net. plete work—12 Vols.—$28.00 net PRESS COMMENTS ON THE WORK. “Full, clear, scholarly, moderate, and useful.”—Annals of the American Academy. “The Historv already shows that it is to be well com- pacted, homogeneous, and of uniform quality.”"—The Nation “With the issue of each successive volume, the im- portance of this history is made more clearly evident.”— Boston Transcript. “Is now recognized as the standard history of Eng- land.”—Standard, London. Studies in History, Economics and Public Law Edited by the Facalty of Political Science of Columbia University NEW VOLUMES Vol. XXXIIL, No. 3. An Introduction to the Sources R to the ic Invasions. By CARL- TON HUNTLEY HAYES, Ph.D., Lecturer in His- tory in Columbia University. -8vo. Paper Covers, $1.50. Cloth, $2.00. Vol. XXXIV., No. 1. Transportation and Industrial De- velopment in the Middle West. By WILLIAM F. GEPHART, Ph.D., Instructor in Economics, Ohio State University, sometime University Fellow in Eco- nomics, Columbia University. 8vo. Paper covers, Vol. XXXIV., No. 2 Social Reform and the Reforma- tion. By JACOB SALWYN SCHAPIRO, Ph.D., Tutor in History, College of the City of New York. 8vo. Paper cavers, $1.25. Vol. XXXIV., No. 3. Responsibility for Crime. By PHILIP A. PARSONS, PhD. 8vo. Paper covers, $1.50. Vol. XXXV,, No. 1. The Conflict over Judicial Powers in the United States to 1870. By CHARLES GROVE HAINES, Ph.D. Professor of History and Political Science, Ursinus College. 8vo. Paper covers, $1.50. Vol. XXXV., No. 2. A Study of the Population of Man- hattanville. By HOWARD BROWN WOOLSTON, Ph.D.. Formerly Lecturer in Sociology, Western Re- serve University. 8vo. Paper covers, $1.25. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91-93 Fifth Avenue, New York LETTERS AND MEMORIALS OF Wendell Phillips Garrison Late Editor of the Nation (1865-1906) In one volume, crown 8vo, 300 pages, with photogravure portrait. Price $1.50 net, postpaid. During the forty-one years in which he edited the Nation, with a thoroughness, ability, and conscientious devotion unsurpassed in the records of American journalism, Mr. Garrison was an indefatigable correspondent, never employing an amanuensis, but writing tens of thousands of letters with his own hand to his contributors, who embraced practically all the leading American scholars and critics of the period. From a dozen groups of these, which have been kindly loaned by the recipients, a sufficient number of selections has been made to illustrate the relations between Mr. Garrison and his great corps of contributors, the frankness and tact which he exercised towards them, and the wide range of his interests, tastes and sympathies. The volume also contains a brief sketch of his life, a dozen of his best poems, and several of his characteristic editorials, reviews and essays, besides a fine photogravure portrait. It likewise preserves the notable letter of appreciation addressed to Mr. Garrison by more than two hundred contributors to the Nation on the completion of his fortieth year of service, and his acknowl- edgment thereof. The book has been privately printed at the Riverside Press, but as it is believed that it will be prized by many who long had literary or friendly relations with Mr. Garrison, or who have been readers of the Nation for many years, the opportunity is given to such to secure it. It would also find fitting place in public and private libraries which possess and treasure the bound files of the Nation. ee 20 Vesey Street eS The Nation New York City [Vol. 89, No. 2297 —_————_—~+

Page 5

*) NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 8, 1909. The Week. The first glimmering ray of hope that has for many days broken upon a tar- iff-ridden public shone out in President Taft's brief but meaning reference to the tariff in his speech to the Yale alumni. If Aldrich is insensible to the ground-swell of general irritation, Mr Taft is not. The Chief Executive real- izes that the only political responsibil- ity we have evolved in this country is that of the dominant party to the elec- torate, as construed in the platform pledges. Relegation to the rdéle of the minority in opposition is the menace which confronts the cynical violation of Mr. Taft, it is evident, realizes that the country will hold the political vows. Republican party to a strict accounta- bility in this matter. not less, but greater, in that the Demo- The resentment is crats have shamelessly failed in their obligations to fight the “Dingleyizing” of the House bill. This will eventually make powerfully for a split in the Re- publican ranks, and not impossibly for new party alignments altogether, unless the President can bring to bear on his party his own sober counsels of decency and honor. It appears now that the tax on cor- poration incomes was not devised sim- ply to help the chairman of the Finance Committee out of a hole, but was draft- ed by the Attorney-General shortly af- ‘When the House leaders chose to substitute an inherit- ter his appointment. ance tax, the President apparently de- cided to lie chance. This came in the determination low and wait for his of a Senate majority to graft an income tax upon the tariff bill. Aldrich pro- tested, and when he fled for help to the President, Mr. Taft smilingly produced the corporation tax. Vowing he “would ne’er consent’’—or never for more than two years’ duration of such a measure —Mr. Aldrich finally “consented.” He had even the humiliation of having to swallow his proposed time-limitation, though he files tis personal caveat at Mean this feature of the measure. time, Mr. Taft's pointed reference to The Nation. tariff reduction at New produced Washington. Members of Congress re- They have anxiously rushed to inquire if he real- Haven seems to have consternation § at gard it as an “ultimatum.” ly said it, and if it has any political significance. The Washington dispatches report that the query “amused Mr. Taft greatly.” There has been a rush of blood to the heads of Congressmen since they were answered genially by the President “to use their own intelligence on that subject.” The list of Independence Day casual- ties will probably need rev'sion for some Fuller raise the number of the injured. The time to come. information may usual proportion of injuries will go to swell the number of the dead. It re- mains certain, nevertheless, that the last holiday marked a notable advance to- wards a sane, if not a quiet, Fourth. This year the country was vouchsafed two days’ opportunity for self-destruc- tion instead of one; the sharp decrease ‘n fatalities indicates growing recogni- tion of the truth that people need not sacrifice life in celebrating liberty and the pursuit of happiness. Washington and Cleveland report a noiseless holi- day; in Chicago the ban was laid on the giant firecracker and the toy cannon Many towns restricted the sale of holi- day explosives to a few days before In Day. manufacturers and the doctors get to- dependence Unless the powder gether and have Aldrich rig up some sort of protection for their threatened interests, it really seems as if future holidays will demonstrate the complete compatibility of freedom and common sense. In line with the recent declaration of the Merchant Marine League, in favor of free ships, is an article in the July Atlantic, “Wanted: An American Mer- chant Marine.” written by a British naval officer. He identifies himself no further than by saying that he is “second officer on a Liverpool liner.”” In common with the seafaring folk of all countries, he is amazed at the supineness of Americans in letting other nations do practically all their ocean-carrying for them A Strangely enough, it is | | chief reason for our marine backward- ness he finds in the “insane law” which “makes it impossible for a ship whose keel was not laid down in America to fly the stars and stripes.”” Ah. but we ought to fear the foreigner even when he is bearing us the gift of good advice! How do we know that this British offi cer is not a secret agent of English shipbuilders, who want to get orders from the United States? In any case, he shows a deplorable ignorance of our noble policy of protection, when he sug gests that we could build ships as cheap- ly as anybody else, if only our iron and steel manufacturers would sell for as low prices at home as they do abroad. That proves clearly that this benighted Englishman has not the faintest concep tion of the blessings of a high tarirt which favors the foreigner at the ex pense of the native That an indictment should have been found, after all, against the Sugar Trust and its chief officers, suggests a con trast between the present Administra- tion at Washington and a certain pre- ced'ng Administration. In former days we grew accustomed to the loud threat against corporate iniquity, followed by the discovery that something or other had happened to make the wicked cor have the poration immune. To-day, we refreshing spectacle of a government prosecution seemingly foundered on the old rock of the statute of limitations, but escaping the danger very cleverly and going right ahead. Counse! for the Sugar Trust have not been as successful as they thought they were in persuad ‘ing the government's representatives that the Trust could not be prosecuted The Department of Justice has found acts of criminality in ‘connection with the Segal case that run back less than the magic three years which wipe out all things. It is a novelty to see Justice displaying something of the resource- fulness which we have hitherto associat- ed entirely with its opponents The white firemen on the Georgia Railroad are quite ready to agree that, properly manipulated, arbitration is a | very beautiful thing. If arbitration de- ‘cides in your favor, why, there you are. But if judgment goes against you, then,

Page 6

ee as members of a dominant race, you can draft a bill proh!biting negroes from wcrking as railway firemen, and lay that bill before a Legislature which will think twice before it refuses to dance to The sense of what is just the tune of the Dominant Race. most elementary and permissible under the Constitution must be outraged by the latest shame- lees attempt to apply the educational! test clause to the keeping down of the dirt where, accord'ng to negro in the Dominant Morality, he belongs. Are we soon to see the day when a man shail be allowed not to stoke an engine or turn a brake-wheel unless his grand- father was a freeman before 1867? In his alumni, President the Yale Hadley discriminated recent address to between different fields of scientific re- He tain kind of research as about the poor- search. aptly characterized a cer- est business a man could engage in, and still retain the acknowledged status of a gentleman and scholar. Even the dis- covery of some things unknown before is not. of itself, sufficient to create any obligations on the part of the learned world to the discoverer. There are said, for example, to be known something like a million distinct varieties of living animals. A distinguished zoédlogist has given it as his guess that there are prob- ably still uncatalogued an additional million, mostly microscopic, however and not confined to the continent of Africa. Merely to discover a single ad- ditional spec'es would serve, of course, as the basis for the “ord'nary Ph D. of commerce.” But beyond that it would be of little The estiguitor must possess at the outset, or worth. serviceable in- acquire, an instinct for such knowledge as is wort! while. A Detroit Stuart, torate of twenty-three years, because, as the Reed resigned, after a pas- clergyman, Rev. has just he explains, he does not feel “equal to the work of the institutional church.” Without any bitterness, but in the most matter-of-fact way, he defines that sort of church as the one which “believes in free soup, in boys’ clubs, and basketball, and in cadets carrying guns in the name of Christ.”” Those things, he admits, may be necessary in the modern church, but he intends from now on to leave the management of them to others. His early The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2297 | ideal had been that of a preacher, a spiritual leader; but he had found more and more of his time and strength tak- en up with the infinite variety of organ- izations within the church. We fancy that many a weary minister would find all this waking a response in his own heart. The institutional church does, no doubt, a world of good; but some of its activities are confessedly only a sort of pious bribe to induce people to occupy pews, and it certainly tends to belittle the prophetic function of the clergy- man. What is really needed is a divi- sion of labor, by which ‘hose who have in the Scriptural phrase, may wreak themselves a talent for “serving tables,” on the machinery of the boys’ brigades, while those who feel a message burn- ing in their souls may be left free to shape and deliver it. The assassination in London of L’eut.- Col. Wyllie by a Hindu student is bound to produce a more painful impression in England than it could make in any England has so long been the home of public secur- other part of the world. ity that acts of violence take on a mean- ng often out of proportion to their im- portance. Englishmen have not known is for over two hundred They must go back to the Peter- massacre—an event which even what revolt years. loo among us would be described as a riot— for an example of serious public dis- order. When a couple of Russian anar- chists went mad and ran amuck in Tot- tenham a few months ago, the country was driven to discuss the expediency of excluding foreign political refugees of a “dangerous” type. Hence such a cold- blooded act as this political murder can- not telp creating a condition of public excitement which may in the end bring harm both to Great Britain and to the Lord Morley may have to face a loud outery for summary action in It will be his duty to judge just how much significance must be ascribed to the wanton act of the Hindu student and terrorist. Hindus. Ind‘a. India, as a whole, has ac- cepted the political concessions recently granted ter. It would be unfortunate if the work of conciliation should be hampered by the action of a fanatic or a lunatic. If Professor Dicey and the editor of the London Spectator were among the onlookers in Parliament Square at the latest suffragette riot, we may be sure they kept well in the background. It was not only feminine brickbats, but their own words also, that they were afraid of having thrown into their faces. Professor Dicey, in a book he has just published against woman's rights, joins in the belief, that women “entertained by nearly every man, are often lacking in the virtues, such as active courage, firmness of judgment, self-control, steadiness of conduct, and, above all, a certain sense of justice maintained even in the heat of party conflict.” In approving this, the Specta- tor goes a step further: The basis of all government is force. Women also have less ten- acity. This is a simple demonstrable fact. We wish to lay particular stress upon it, because in our own mind, it has a pres- ent application of conclusive urgency. Eu- rope is entering upon a struggle for naval supremacy which may mean a physical contest in which the less resolute combatant will surely be the loser. Amid the cavalry, din of charging suffragette crashing window glass, anl n'ghtsticks thumping on feminine bac: constitutionalist and journalist Leard a strange answer to the'r arguments. Sydney Smith once defined benevo- lence as the feeling which A experi- enced when he thought that B ought to do something to relieve C’s necessities. This vicarious excellence seems to-day to prevail in international public finance. The corporation tax works excellently in France, but, it is argued, is ill-suite1 to the United States. Mr. Lloyd-George finds that land taxes are admirable fis- cal devices in the United States and Australia, but the Opposition pressed with the totally different situa- tion in Great Britain. The German Ckancellor admires the patriotism with which the death duties and the legacy taxes are borne in England. but the Prussian Junker resents the importa- tion of such a noxious fiscal project into the Fatherland. No expectant contribu- tor sees the tax-halter draw “with good opinion of the law.” If this mode of ar- gument continues, the “shifting of tax- ation” will soon bear a different mean- ing. Like the criminal who asked as a dying favor that he might choose the tree on which to be hanged, the pros- pective tax-payer returns at night with the weary sheriff and confesses with is im- tears that he cannot find a suitable tree.

Page 7

July 8, 1909] The contrast between the latest utter- ances of the Kaiser and Lord Charles Beresford is significant. It is also very much in the Kaisers favor. To use a nautical phrase, it quite takes the wind out of the sea-dog’s sails. Lord Charles is not a panic-monger, and yet he in- sists on the necessity of expending be- tween $275,000,000 and $300,000,000 on the navy, “in order to put the Empire in a state of safety by March, 1914.” In the interim, what is to prevent Albion's foes from driving her from the seas’ Lord Charles, it should seem, has as yet failed to substantiate the charges he launched against the Admiralty admin- istration of Sir John Fisher. But with a Herculean reserve, he refrained from reference to the charges that are still sub judice. There might almost be a sus- pcion that the gallant tar is a veritable Hobson come to judgment, were it not for his reference to German industr‘al progress. The Kaiser in pacific fashion agrees with the doughty son of Neptune. In his recent interview with the head of the French Parliamentary Arbitra- tion group, the Kaiser spoke deprecat- ingly of the current hysteria in Eng- land, and remarked that the Br-tish nervousness would d‘sappear when Great Britain reaiized that by progress in industry she might regain her lost economic ground. German method inheres even in Ger- man madness. So venturesome an un- dertaking as Zeppcelin’s proposed fight to the North Pole is to be gone at with an elaborate precaution which may be enough to turn madness into success. Before the final dash for the Pole, the region between the starting point and the goal is to be carefully explored for its geography and its meteorology. When Zeppelin sails at last it will be on no uncharted atmospheric seas. Were accident eliminated and the problem re- duced to a mere question of distance to be traversed, Peary might yet see him- self anticipated by the Germans. But, unfortunately, accident still thickly strews the paths of the aeronaut. True, that most dreaded peril to balloon and aeroplane, the tree, is beneficently ab- sent from the Polar regions, and except for a possible impalement on the Pole itself, collision can occur only with an obstinate ice-hummock here or there. But that other dread foe, the wind, blus- ters sadly in these northern regions, and . The Nation. in case of storm everybody outside of England knows that there are no Ger- man reg’ments at the Pole to hold the airship down in safety M. Cruppi, Minister of Commerce, out- lined on Monday, in his speech to the Deputies, the government's attitude to ward the pending tariff revision in France. His speech was 2 singular blend of studied moderation in practice and of intellectual detachment as _ regards theory. A customs policy, he declared, ‘'s “not an essential factor in the eco- nomic development of nations.” Free trade in Great Britain and protection in Germany are proof. But M. Cruppi would not disturb the status quo, and believes in the efficacy of an elastic tariff as a weapon in bargaining for markets. The “reasonable protection” which France has establ’shed he deems compatible with an extension of foreign trade by reciprocity treaties. But he deprecates the loud talk of tariff reprisals. With an export trade of a billion dollars he be- lieves in soft words for the foreign cus- tomer. He undoubtedly impressed his auditors by cit'ng the alarm evidenced by French chambers cf commerce at the drastic way the Parliamentary com- mission on tariff revision is setting about its task. Especially delicate were M. Cruppi’s allusions to Great Britain and the United States. It was the kind of counting-house prudence which ap- peals to the thrifty sourgeovisie. It shows a shrewd realization of the fact that French exports are largely of a luxuri- ous or quasi-luxurious character. Silks, porcelain, wines, objects of art and of voluntary consumption, not necessities, are the wares that France excels in. It is the part of w'sdom noi to talk of dras tic reprisals when the world at a pinch can do without many of these creations. The most regrettable aspect, perhaps, of France's latest “affair,” the navy scandal, is that the reactionary element will fashion a weapon for itself out of the exposure of frightful maladminis- tration under the present régime. The Republican bloc which came into power under Waldeck-Rousseau was naturally concerned, first of all, with saving the country itself from threatened wreck over the Dreyfus affair. It was inevita- ble that reasons of political strategy should have outweighed every other con- sideration. Yet once the crisis had been 25 weathered, the bloc, like every other government, should have concerned it- self with governing. Now, the anti-Re- publican parties are in a position to show that what most Frenchmen con- sider the chief duty of their rulers, the maintenance of an adequate system of national defence, has been wofully neg- lected. When Gen. André, some ten years ago, set about ridding the army of anti-Republican intrigue, the result was, according to the opponents of the bloc, that the army was brought down to a state of disorganization which was first revealed in 1905, when France had to accept Germany's dictation concern ing Morocco. Now come revelations which, if true, would argue that the French fleet is about as well prepared to meet an enemy as was the late Ad miral Rozhestvensky. The Young Turk leaders have evident- ly decided that the most press'ng need of the moment is to ward off a second reactionary upheaval. They must show themselves as zealous for the maint: nance of Ottoman suprentacy in the Em pire as they have hitherto been for con stitutional progress The attitude of the government in the matter of Crete is an instance in point Had ‘t con- sented to the occupat:on of that island by Greece, the government might have had another counter-revolution on its hands. In forcing the Powers to con- sent to a virtual continuance of the Cre- tan occupation, the Hilmi Ministry has closed, for a time at least, the mouths of the reactionaries. Parliament, mean- while, has been working along the same lines. In giving statutory form to the var ous provisions of the Constitution of 1876, it has repeatedly laid stress on the connection between the Islamic re ligion and the Empire. Recently, the Chamber adopted an educational claus which provides that public instruction is free, but that “all schools are placea ander the control of the government the necessary measures shall be taken to assure to every Ottoman subject 4 uniform system of education.” In spite of the accompanying guarantee that “there shall be no interference with the rel'gious education of the different com munities,” the Greeks and Bulgarians profess to discern in the proposai of a uniform educational system under gov- ernment control a possible curtailment of their existing rights

Page 8

‘> ~ 6 NEARING THE TARIFF END. Two reasons explain the speed—al- most beyond the legal limit—with which the Senate is winding up its part of tariff-making. With the corporation tax adopted after less than a week's discus- sion, the Constitutional amendment au- thorizing an income tax passed without debate or even opposition, the special customs court voted in one day and the of the tariff agreed to at the same time, people might administrative features be excused for wondering what forces had suddenly overcome the Senatorial inertia. But there is always this kind of accelerated motion, when the Senate is deal'ng with large and controverted measures of legislation. The first para- graphs are debated with minute and ap- parently endless obstinacy. Time is wasted, and the endurance of mortal lungs and throats taxed to the utter- most. Despairing observers begin to think ‘twill never be done. And then unexpectedly the whole discussion falls in a heap, and many of the sections which seemed to promise oratory world without end, are accepted without de- mur or delay. This is partly the result of sheer physical exhaustion. After three months of incessant use, the tongue even of a La Follette cleaves to the roof of his mouth. Moreover, the power of a disciplined majority has, by then, fully asserted itself. Opponents ask them- selves wearily: “With mate in four moves inevitable, why insist upon mak- ing them all painstakingly?” Another reason for the rapid crum- bling of the Senate debate lies in the general conviction that the tariff is not really to be shaped by it. As Senators near the end, they are more and more impressed with the fact that their end is not the true end, that a great deal of insincerity and lack of finality has and that the to be put in effect marked their procedure, tariff law will be framed, as the Engl'sh Parlia- actually mentary phrase is, “in another place.” That place is the committee of confer- ence between the two houses. The ten or twelve men who meet in secret are the real tariff-makers. What they report back will the be put through en bloc, by House of Representatives under special rule admitting of no amendment, and by the Senate under the irresistible pressure of party organization. So why need Senators haggle any longer over The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2297 after having undergone a sea-change, altered into a shape which may or may not be rich, but which will certain- ly appear strange to those who begat them? Hence the growing desire in the Senate to get it over. One would have said that the entirely new provision of the Senate bill, estab- lishing a court with special and final jurisdiction in customs cases, would have furnished controversial enough to last the Senate a month. Yet it was dispatched in a single session. True, several vital amendments were adopted. Senator Rayner did good ser- vice in exposing some of the doubtfully constitutional, as well as manifestly un- just features of the plan, and secured their abandonment. The salaries of the new judges of the Customs Court were also cut down to the level of those of other Federal judges. With these changes made, and with the understanding that taken from the Customs Court by to the Supreme Court, when it can be alleged that flag- rant injustice has been done, or prop- erty taken without due process of law, the chief objections of lawyers to the proposed court are removed. President Taft may be counted upon to appoint able and disinterested judges—even if this qualification rules out the men who have been toadying to Aldrich in the hope of judicial preferment. matter cases can be certiorari The fact that every Senator present voted for the proposed amendment of the Constitution, authorizing the levy of an income tax, is not alone to be ex- plained as a part of the bargain made by Aldrich and the President. Such unanimity is significant of a strong pop- ular feeling in favor of a clear Con- warrant for that form of taxation. The House will undoubtedly agree with the Senate in this matter. It is said in Washington that those op- posed to the tax are confident that the amendment will not be ratified by three- fourths of the States. They talk of eleven States—names not given—of which they say they are certain the Leg- islatures will reject the amendment. But such predictions are more easily made than fulfilled. The arguments for the amendment are not necessarily argu- ments for the tax. It may fairly be maintained that the power to lay an in- come tax ought to exist, even if it be unwise to use it at present. The opin- stitutional well as the utterances of Presidents and other public men, shows how serious a thing it might be for the nation, if in a great emergency, it found itself shorn of the right to place a direct tax on incomes. Add to this consideration the obvious spread of the conviction that the Federal government will be com- pelled in the future to resort to direct taxes more freely than at any time since the civil war, and the chances that the Constitutional amendment will be ratified by the necessary number of States, seem to us to be very good. We shall know within two years whether there is, after all, any truth in the as- sertion so often made that it has become impossible to amend the Constitution of the United States. With the whole tariff question now nearing its final stages, the responsibil- ity of President Taft for the ultimate form of this legislation grows acute. The country looks to him to exert all his in- fluence and authority to induce the con- ference committees to agree upon a bill which he can honorably sign, and which the people will not regard as a betrayal and a mockery. THE SCIENCE OF RACE-HATRED. Two recent magazine articles on the negro invite consideration because of their individual significance and the contrast they offer. In the July Mc- Clure’s, William Archer enters on a thorough search for a solution to the negro problem, after he has convinced himself that such a problem exists. Hav- ing enumerated the four possible ways in which the South can deal with the question—all of them calling for “al- most superhuman wisdom, energy, and courage”’-——Mr. Archer finds it impossi- ble to conceive that the negro can be exterminated, assimilated, or tolerated, and therefore pronounces in favor of segregation. A negro State within the Union might be built up, at first by the voluntary emigration, and after some twenty-five years by the forcible trans- portation, of all negroes under the age of forty-five. Into the details of a scheme which the writer admits is one of enor- mous difficulty, we need not enter here. ‘rhe idea is not a new one. Whether eith- er white men or black men in the South want such a State, whether such a State could be erected, and, if erected, whe- ther it could long exist, are really ques- details which may !ssue from conference ion of the Supreme Court judges, as tions of more than magazine scope.

Page 9

July 8, 1909] Booker T. Washington s opinion of the plan is well known. Given a separate negro State, it would take a very high wall to keep the negro inside, and three or four very high walls to keep the white man out. But it is with the writer’s moral jus- tification of his scheme that we are con. cerned. Mr. Archer widens the ques- tion from the negro and the South to the world and its various races. He argues: “But,” it may be said, “the rights and liberties of civilized humanity include the right to move freely hither and thither over the face of the earth. This right, at any rate, would be denied to the Afro- American, inclosed within the ring-fence of his own State.”” There is, I think, a sufficient answer to this objection. The right to travel would not be denied to the negro. Never would he be debarred from emigrating and settling abroad among any community that was willing to receive him. It is, I think, becoming more and more clear that the right of every man, white, black, or yellow, to effect a per- manent settlement outside his own coun- try, is subject to this qualification. The idea that all the world ought to belong equally to all men, and that rational de- velopment tends toward an unrestricted intermingling of races, seems to be sig- nally contradicted by the trend of events. Is it mot the great essential for the ul- timate world-peace that races should learn to keep themselves to themselves? This is plain speaking. It immediately suggests the other article to which we have alluded, William English Walling’s “Science and Human Brotherhood,” in a late number of the Independent. Mr. Walling is without doubt an enthusiast. He is quite as strongly in favor of race admixture as Mr. Archer says the white South is against it. But, again, it is not with Mr. Walling’s specific views that we have to do, but with the gen- eral issue he raises. Are we in the midst of a reaction away from those ideals of democracy and of human bro- therhood to which the eighteenth cen- tury gave birth and from which the nineteenth century drew its nourish- ment? Our writer protests against what he describes as the growing Nietzschean- ism of the times. Under modern names and backed by scientific instead of the- ological authority, the ideals of caste, of national exclusiveness, of the rule of force, are coming back to thrive among us. As for the Declaration of Inde- pendence, all scholars know nowadays that it embodies a vicious compound of Rousseauism and demagogy. Such a view of the present march of The Nation. civilization seems to us greatly exag- gerated. But that such a view should be entertained seems natural enough when a man so conspicuously identified as is Mr. Archer with progressive ideals in other fields of life, finds it easy to ask, ‘is it not the great literature and essential for the ultimate world-peace that races should learn to keep them- selves to themselves?” Put aside the ut- ter insufficiency of real evidence in fa- vor of such a contention. Pass over the fact that a half-dozen years of Imperial- ist madness cut no perinanent groove for the progress of the world. Merely consider that the ideal of race-exclusive- ness here hinted at means nothing less than a throw-back to conditions that antedate civilization. High Chinese walls around every country to keep out not but the stranger himself—that is what the mod- only the stranger’s goods, ern theories of race-superiority and race- Mr. Walling asks: Will the defenders of individual freedom, social justice, and human oprotherhood awake in time to the danger of the most monstrous reversion in histcry since the foundation of the religions of human broth- purity bring us to. erhood and love two thousand, yes, three thousand years before the period when the world was made physically one by steam and electricity, and half the population of the earth became sufficiently enlightened to claim a share in the world’s progress? We do not think the danger so immi- nent as all that. We find it deplora- ble, nevertheless, that Western thought should be dandling about ideals which we associate with a somnolent China and a caste-ridden India, and at a time when China and India are forcing their painful but steady way towards West- ern ideals. The position held by Mr. Archer con- siders itself, and is apt to be considered, as scientific. His opponent’s views are as sentimental. will that sense the old humanitarian view against the race and caste advocates. The chief scien- tific characteristic of the latter is their apt to be stigmatized show is with Yet deeper reflection science in a truer cold-bloodedness. A segregated State, a locked-up frontier, is impressive because it is cruel. It is not scientific to fix one’s gaze upon the present spasm of militarism in Europe, and overlook the growing desire of the world’s masses negro for peace, as twice shown at The Hague. It is not scientific to dwell on the de- fects of democracy in the West, and to pass over the stirring of nearly all . 7 ~ Asia to democracy. It is not even scien- tific to interpret racial conflict as tend- ing to racial exclusiveness. California's and Australia’s hostility to the Japanese seems to Mr. Archer proof that the races must be kept apart. But it is nearer the truth to say that the existence of anti- Japanese feeling only means that the old rule of exclusiveness will no longer work. When the Japanese didn't count, no one disliked them. Now they do count, and, for all the temporary hat- laws, they must reds and exclusion to equality as their Civilization which has make their way strength grows. grown by contact among the nations of the earth will not tolerate the split- ting up of the nations. AS BAEDEKER SEES US. There is members of the “See America First” so- one pleasure which loyal ciety can never enjoy. This is the pleas- ure of perusing Baedeker’s United States from the comparative point of view. The American the limp red binding with old-world asso- tourist who associates ciations gets a pos'tive thrill from the inspection of the volume devoted to his own native land. John Graham Brooks in his recent volume, “As Others See Us,” has skimmed the cream from many a volume of forgotten lore about our country, but did not include the imper- sonal Baedeker. It must not be imag- ined that anything one could say of this world-renowned of hand-books can add to or detract froin their merits. They have become an inter- But one may ven- series travellers’ national institution. ture to indulge in reflections upon the Procrustean formality with which they Their cosmopolitan- envelop the business of travel. Olympian aloofness and ism do not alter with a change in lati- tude. The serious-minded British globe- trotter and the indefatigable German tourist insist on taking their pleasures sadly, and find support the ever- faithful Baedeker. Despite the fact that Dr. J. F. Muir- head has for over a quarter of a cen- tury had charge of the English editions of Baedeker, the style has been thor- oughly subdued to the material in which he works. The introductory article proves this up to the hilt. Beginning, as is proper, with the question of the expense of an American tour, he remarks truly in enough that it may be reckoned inevit-

Page 10

28 ably from one-fourth to one-third more in this country than abroad. “Persons of moderate requirements,” however, by frequenting boarding houses, instead of hotels, and by avoiding carriage hire, may travel comfortably in this country. On “Threughout almost the whole country, one point he is very reassuring: traveliing is now as safe as in the most civil'zed parts of the world, and the carrying of arms, which, indeed, is for- bidden in many States, is as unneces- sary here as there.” Thrice armed is he who has his sensibilities under control. “He should, from the outset, reconcile himself to the absence of deference or servility on the part of those he consid- ers his social inferiors; but, if ready himself to be courteous on a footing of will seldom meet any real As the Amer'can hostelries will be found “fully equality, he impoliteness.”’ to hotels, best as comfortable as the first-class hotels of Europe by all who can accommodate themselves to the manners of the coun- try, ete.” Real penetration is evidenced, however, in the warning to avoid res- taurants “which solicit the patronage of ‘gents’"; and discrimination in the re- mark that “soap, curiously enough, though provided in hotels, is not pro- vided in boarding houses or lodgings.” for monopoly of the traveller in effete Eu- Ringing soap is evidently not a re pe As to travelling, he weighs carefully the respective merits of the American and European railway carriage, or “car,” as he notes it is called here. A “single crying infant or spoiled child may here annoy from sixty to seventy people,” whereas abroad the worriment will be confined to “the few in the compart- ment.” Rugs, as a rule, are not neces- sary upon our trains. Indeed, our trains are generally overheated, even in win- we are informed. But there are cor- the amusement derivable from watching the ter, responding advantages, such as other occupants of the long car, though, of He does not commit himself to a in case accident, there are but two exits final decision, yet he is not quite with- out hopes of us. Even at Niagara Falls, “the former extortionate charges and impertinent demeanour of the Niagara hackmen have been somewhat abated.” “General Hints,” the compara- method yields the following gem: Under tive of sociological induction “The art of the Barber and Hair-Dresser has been The Nation. developed to a high point in the United States, where the ‘tonsorial saloons’ are often very luxurious. The prices, how- ever, are high, 10-25 cents for a shave, including hair-brushing and the applica- tion of essences.” Most important, however, are the tour- ists’ Glossary and the allied hints about “An American takes a lady out to dinner, social usages upon the frontier. while an Englishman takes her in.” To “wait on” the table does not imply that the garcon here leans against or sits on the festal board, but is merely the of dinner. A “block” is a “rectangular mass of building, bounded by four streets.” A “deck” is a “pack of cards,” though with Teutonic thoroughness it is noted that this use of the term is found in Shake- A “bug” is anglice “a beetle, in- And time it- celf would fail us to tell of the patience with which “gums” and “rubbers,” “bis- cuit” and “crackers,” “grips” and “bag- gage,” “high Balls” and “chowders,” “pie” and “parlor,” are defined for the wandering subjects of the Kaiser or the King. We were sometimes disposed to complain of a certain condescension in foreigners. We were sometimes inclin- ed to ask shudderingly how we were vulgar, and were rebuffed by the an- swer, “Because thou art not like unto American equivalent “waiting at” speare. sect of almost any kind.” us,” from Lucifer, Son of the Morning. But we have changed all that. Our sen- sib'lities ought no more to be wounded by the stranger within our gates. For as the excellent Baedeker says: “The first requisites for the enjoyment of a tour in the United States are an ab- sence of prejudice and a willingness to accommodate one’s self to the customs of the country.” WHY WE COMMEMORATE CALVIN. I. It would probably be difficult to find anywhere to-day more than a handful of persons who would really enjoy be- ing called by the name of “Calvinist.” Yet the Protestant world is joining with singular wnanimity in celebrating, on the tenth day of this month, the four hundredth anniversary of Calvin's birth. Geneva, the scene of his chief outward activities, will, in these days, be the central point of interest for all those, who, divided in every detail of relig- fous organization, are one in their op- position to a church of authority. If we can explain this apparent paradox, we shall come near to an understanding of [ Vol. 89, No. 2297 what Calvin means to the thinking men of our day. The approach of the present anni- versary has revived to a notable extent interest in Calvin’s dominating, but per- plexing, personality. The materials for the history of his life and work have been presented to the worlé in absolute completeness, and biographical studies of greater or less extent have helped in a general understanding of the man and his meaning for the world. Still, after all, the popular impression of him remains singularly inadequate. Probably most Protestants and all Catholics con- tinue to hold the idea once expressed in the writer’s hearing by an educated wo- man, that Calvin was a malignant, at times a furious, fanatic finding his chief satisfaction in violent controversy, a man whose memory was to be execrated and whose example was valuable only as a horrible warning. Nothiag could be further from the truth, “Fanatic” is the last word that could properly be applied to Calvin. If it means anything, it means a man so absorbed by one idea that all others lose their proper proportion in his mind. From the first moment of his approach to the problems of his life, Calvin shows us the type of the deliber- ate, systematic, constructive mind to which all fanaticism is specially abhor- rent, which cannot even co-exist with it. No fanatic has ever become a great leader of men along lines of constructive utility. Fanatics have, indeed, often giv- en the inspiration that has roused en- thusiasm and led indirectly to great results, but they have never built up the world’s systems, either of thought or of social organization. If we inquire into the causes of Cal- vin’s influence, we shall be impressed first of all by its universality. The oth- er great leaders of reform, Wycliffe, Hus, Luther, Zwingli, were, each in his time, identified with the special needs and the historical conditions of a single country. Each of these men represent- ed, in a singularly true and singularly complete sense, the spirit of his own nation. Each was in his own way and has remained ever since the popular type of the people he primarily served. It might fairly be said of each, that he was the natural product of the national genius. His work was done ior the na- tion and was made possible through it. The man and the nation belonged to- gether, reacted upon each other, deter- mined cach other’s character and defined the limits of expression within which each might move. No such limitation exists in the case f Calvin. True, he was, as has often been pointed out, in many ways a typi- cal product of the French genius; but France would not receive this, one uf the greatest of her sons. She drove him out into an exile, bitter at first and nev- er to become quite sweet to his emi-

Page 11

July 8, 1909 nently domestic and affectionate na- ture. Through this exile, he lost that background of national support his ear- lier colleagues had possessed, but the gain was greater than the loss. Without fault or merit of his own, he was freed from a multitude of complications that had fettered in countless ways the thought and the action of the other re- formatory leaders. They had been com- pelled at every turn to take account of the social and political conditions of their several lands. They had, almost from the first, been driven into com- promises and adjustments that had se- riously modified their own original views. They had had to consider ways and means, sometimes to play fast and loose with the standards of right they had themselves laid down, and all this had cost them dearly in the estimation of the world, even the world of sym- pathizers outside. ‘ If, for example, we compare the Luther of 1520 with the Luther of 1530, we are at once impressed with the change that has come over his ideals Step by step during that decade he had been driven from one position after an- other by the insistent demands of one and another policy too important for him to overlook. He had been warned by the extravagances of the _ radical wing on the one hand, and by the con- servatism of ex'sting powers on the oth- er. His attitude, defiant at first, had by 1530 become largely apologet’c. The great Confession of Augsburg, the Con- stitution of later Lutheranism, is pene- trated throughout by the spirit of com- promise made necessary by the compli- cations of German political and social life. We are not questioning e‘ther the wisdom of this attitude or the nob lity of the ideals still preserved in the Luth- eran position. We are only illustrating the practical limitations of national'ty and world-politics that kept the Luth- eran movement mainly with'n’ the sphere of German life. It would be easy also to draw similar illustrations from Switzerland, from Bohemia, and from England. In each of these cases the Reformation had to make its way into the structure of an already fixed social and political order, and the meas- ure of its success depended largely upon the degree to which it could conciliate the various elements of that society. II. If now we turn to Calvin we find an entirely different situation. The exile of 1535 remained an exile throughout his long life. Geneva, the home of his active years, was never the “place where he belonged.” Instead of claim'ng him as its own, as Bohemia claimed Hus, it was rather taken in hand by him as ma- terial for the working out of ideas al- ready elaborated elsewhere. Geneva was Calvin's laboratory, not his father- land. Calvin belongs, therefore, not to The Nation. but to the world. His greatest work for humanity was not so much what he did for and with Geneva, as in the sys- tem of ideas worked out into tang ble form before the thought of carrying them out into practice could ever have occurred to him The author of the “Christian Institution” was a young. sol- itary, and homeless scholar, living, like so many others of his class, under the sheltering hospitality of that Swiss town of Basel, where Erasmus had spent his most peaceful fru tful years. The theology rmation in its main established and mest of the Ref propositions already and was Under its Lutheran ts Zwinglian forms it was making its way: but so far no one had gone at the problem free of all entanglements, as a theologian pure and simple. It is true, Calvin addressed his appeal d rectly to the French king, but one feels at once thet the audience he had in mind was as wide as the interest in religious things If we compare this appeal to the French government with Luther's “Ad- dress to the Christian Nob'litv of Ger- many.” the difference is obv’ous. Luther proposes a series of practical measures whereby the religious ideas he would enforce might be realized under the leadership of the only “safe” class in the community to which he belonged Calvin rises above all immediate ques- tions of policy into the higher regions of speculative thought, entrusting to time and circumstance the of his ideals. It is this quality of uni- versal appeal that more than anything else has made Calvin a name of dignity in the world of thought. Agree with him or not as we may, we recognize in him the man of universal grasp on the greatest problems of the rel'gious life Keeping still within the field of spec. ulation we may find a second explana- tion of Calvin’s permanent influence in his emphasis on the great fundamental tact of human sinfulness. In our more joyous and, I venture to believe, sound- er v'ew of human l'fe we shall doubt- less feel at first thought as if this were but a sorry title to the lasting memory of our kind. Calvinism suggests probably to most of us, first of all a sour-faced disapproval of most pleasant and natur- al things, a gloomy insistence upon a Hebrew standard of morality little in harmony with our modern respect for what is natural and our modern sym- pathy with what is beautiful. That Cal- vin’s emphasis on the sinful side of hu- exaggerated, we realization man experience was need not question It was exaggerated. as every reaction against rooted evil must be, ‘f it is to be effective It be- comes intelligible only when it is seen in relief against the background of evil it was designed to remedy. Calvin's ser- vice in this matter was in making once again clear to the conscience of Chr's- Geneva, as Luther belongs tc Germany, | 29 of individual experience, not a de- vice to explain the mystery of human nature, but a tremendous, insistent fact, not to be explained away by theological ingenuity, nor palliated by ecclesiastical but met squarely and dealt such fashion as the corporate of Christianity might ap prove. Of course, in seeking support for his position went back to the source of all later th’nking on the fun damental problems of man’s mora! na Augustine, and reminded the to that singular the tans that sin was a fact mere theologica) devices, with in conscience he ture, to world anew of its debt medley of reason Augustin‘an theology ran perilously and Of course near the unreason, again, in so doing he line along which Augustine was always the borderland of dualistic ever tempting with its easy so the of Chr'stian who approached its frontier of Vanichrus shows that contemporaries did fail to see his peril He Augustine had saved himself, by coasting, thought lution loyalty every thinker His nickname Novus his not saved him self as insisting, after all was said, upon the unity of the divine admitting the d'vine authorship of what “evil.” even to the point of man in his blindness calls Ill service of Calvin in the light of our or To est mate this we must look at it, not modern by whatever name of getting public and ght of the whole to replace e adjustments, compromises, we may call our ways along with our private, but the Calvin, in with Protestant world, was trying His work was dictated by a of the of right-minded man of his day could overlook. Least of al! could right- thinking ¢ afford, for the sake of their own institutions, to neglect the demand for a pretty thorough of the ecclesiastical consciences, rather in what common profound need reform, which sense no ‘atl olics insistent overhauling whole system With the pitiless logic of the French mind, Calvin went straight to the heart of the matter, and found his solution in that emphasis upon person al sin as a part of the very nature of we new being which are here considering. He had no of the existing order to offer. All that had From Wryeliffe cn there had been no lack of reminders as to the outward ills of the ecclesiasti- cal body What principle whereby men could coérdinate all -the forms of protest had inefficient for lack of such a rational un'ty. Neith- er was novelty in the proposition itself The Church had built up its machinery of sacramental rem- edy and recovery What was new was the emphatic position given by Calvin to sin as the fact in man’s dealing with his religious needs. every human er ticlem before been done was needed was some and harmonize varied that so far been there any absolute regarding sin in accepted it and upon it central

Page 12

30 Under the Roman system this conscious- ness of sin, though theologically ‘accept- ed, tad in practice become obscured and confused in a mechanism that kept the mass of believers satisfied, but could never escape the criticism of whoever could read the signs of the times. The reformers preceding Calvin had palter- ed with the sacramental system, trying to hold as much of it as possible out of regard for the weaknesses of those on whom they depended for support, both from above and from below. Calvin, to all intents and purposes, threw away these fictitious props to the relig'ous life, calling sinful men back sharply to their sin and giving them what he be- lieved to be the true means of remedy. It is impossible to pass over this chapter of Calvin's activity without ref- erence to what would now probably be though! his most repellant doctrine. The idea of predestination had never been able to take deep root in Christian soil Ever since Augustine it had risen now and again to the surface of discussion, only to be either repudiated or so great- ly modified as to lose its most distinc- tive character. Augustine himself had distinctly balked at the extreme form of putting the inevitable logic of the situation. He was willing to accept a selection of those destined to be saved, but he could not go the length of ad- mitting a divine determination of those who were to be lost. Calvin did not shrink from this dire alternative. From the point of view of God, i. e., of an ul- timate philosophy, such as Calvin believ- ed himself to possess, there was no great difficulty in accepting the idea that divine knowledge and divine will were so absolutely one that the final destiny of every man was determined in every sense in that infinite plan, which lay at the back of all Augustinian thought. The horror of the “double” pre- destination comes when we frail mor- ials trv to bring in the eleme t man will and human responsibility, Cal- vin saved the day for himself and for those who followed his conclusions, as Luther had done before him, by the doc- trine of justification by faith. The man of faith brought—or, what was the same thing, believed he brought—his own will Into harmony with the di- vine that there was no contradiction be- not indeed once for all, but so that a continual effort was neces- sary so entirely tween them, That is the explanation of the extra- ordinary grip of the Calvinistic morality upon minds of a certain type wherever they were found. French Huguenot, Eng- lish Independent, Scotch Covenanter, New England Puritan, all alike were seized by the irresistible logic of Calvin's argu- ment. The obvious comment, heard al- ready in Augustine’s day, that all pre- destination was fatal to morality, be- ‘rhe Nation. beforehand, all motive to morality was taken away, proved itself utterly ir- relevant. it was precisely this fact, this stripping away every element of bar- gaining with Providence, this categori- cal imperative without reference to re- wards and punishments, that stiffened the moral sense and braced it to meet the assaults of temptation. ‘The prin- ciple of effort, personal to every man, unaided by human mechanism, neces- sary at every point and wholly with- out guarantee as to its final result—this was something worth while for strong men and patient women. They were nerved to the effort, not by the hope of tne conviction that t. were thus entering vitally and personal- ly into the “inscrutable plan of God.” R'ght was right, no longer in virtue of a canonical system depending upon hu- man enactments or human compromises, but because of an imperative command, laid down by divine sanction and need- ing to be interpreted only by the hu- man conscience, guided by such light as a reverent study of the “Word of God” would give. IV. It is this directness of appeal that forms the third claim of Calvin to the respect of the modern world. It would, of course, be the insanity of laudation to describe Calvin as an apostle of re- ligious liberty as we of to-day under- stand the word. Such an idea was ut- terly foreign to the thought of the six- teenth century. Men were searching, not for any abstract liberty, but for trust- worthy guidance. They were repudiating the direction of an institution that seem- ed to have outlived its usefulness, but they were not proclaiming “Rights of Man” nor building temples to the “God- dess of Reason.” They were seeking, in bitter earnestness of soul, for a better guide, and believed they had found it in the infallible written word. It needs no skill to point out the crudities and absurdities of any literal Scripturalism, Hebrew, Mohammedan, or Christian. Such criticism is only too easy, and it has been tried in every possible form. Nothing useful can be gained by it. To ridicule the appeal to Scripture as nar- row and blind and fatal to human pro- gress, is only to miss the point of the real Calvinistic contribution to the world’s movement. The doctrine of the final authority of Scripture may well be compared to the theory of law which has led now and again to important cod- ifications of existing legal practice. So- clety was getting along rather clumsily with its precedents and their interpre- tation by the courts, but how much neat- er it would all be if this mass of con- fusion could but once be analyzed out into chapters and paragraphs 80 that he who runs might read. So codes of law have been made. But, alas! no cause, if a man’s fate were determined 2297 | Vol. 89, No. than the process of interpretation has had to be begun over again, lest the law, the hourly creation of the changing needs of men, should be hardened into a rigid system sure to defeat the very ends of justice for which it was framea. Ttis appeal to Scripture is really the summons to every individual man to go for himself to the original sources of Christian truth, and to interpret trem for himself in the light of every illumination he can bring to bear upon them. If from time to time experts throw new light upon the meaning of Scripture, their appeal is again to the reason and conscience of the individual, and so new regions of thought and ex- perience are opened up for the profit of generations to come. Such illumina- tion can come only out of the contin- uous effort of individuals stimulated to their best thought by the call to person- al actiog. To this directness of the appeal to faith corresponds, then, a similar di- rectness in man’s approach to his God in every stage of worship. As he is free to believe what he must, without the dictation of any organization, so he is free to come face to face with the di- vine mystery without the aid of any priestly intervention. “The priesthood of the Christian man,” the idea that every believing soul stands just as near to the sources of all truth as any “or- dination” can ever bring him, is in many ways the most precious legacy of the Reformation. No doctrine of the reformers struck more vitally than this at the vested interests of every estab- lishment or called forth more violent opposition. The reforming churches modified it in practice. Their ministries became sometimes as despotic and as arrogant as any apostolic succession could ever be, yet these ministries could never forget that they owed their au- thority, in the last resort, to their own personal superiority, intellectual and spiritual, to the people they guided, and would lose it if they failed in these par- ticulars. The sources were as open to one as to the other, and if the ministry should deny a reverent freedom to their flock, they would be undermining the very basis of their own influence. It would, of course, be idle‘to main- tain that all these glorious possibilities were realized in the Geneva of Calvin: but the history of his struggle there to make his abstract scheme of a civitas Dei acceptable to the warring factions of the Genevese citizens is a perfect ilI- lustration of the principles we are con- sidering. These hard-headed citizens had not thrown off one tyranny, only to accept another. The Reform must com- mend itself to them in all essential ways before they would commit themselves to it. The notion that Calvin, in some mysterious fashion, hypnotized Geneva into a blind obedience to his will, as sooner was the ink dry upon their pages the saintly heroes of the Middle Ages

Page 13

July 8, 1 909] — won their victories by appeals to the superstition of a credulous age, is whol- ly erroneous. His life there was one long conflict with men who were as de- termined as he not to accept what did not commend itself to their judgment. Vv. The universality of his appeal, the emphasis upon personal sin and the di- rectness of the approach to God as the way of salvation, these were what rous- ed the individual to a new religious ex- perience, and these constitute the chief part of the world’s debt to Calvin. One other side of his activity claims our at- tention. Calvin was, indeed, primarily a theologian, but his idea of theology was a very large one. Already, in the first draft of an “Institutio Christiana,” he had outlined his view of the mutual relation of religion and the state. De- veloped theoretically in the later edi- tions and put into pract'ce at Geneva, this contribution to political science forms the practical commentary upon the soundness of the more speculative achievements of Calvin’s genius. The example of England, where a determin- ed monarch had declared h‘mself under | God Head of the Church in his realm, filled him with ind‘gnation. The Luth- eran solution of expediency which al- lowed the head of the state to dictate | the religion of his subjects was hardly less repellent to him. In principle his ideal differed little from that of the Ro- man Church. L’‘ke that, it favored com- plete independence of church and state, provided only that the state should be absolutely dominated by religious pur- pose. The world owes to Calvin the les- son to be learned from his model ex- periment with the little community of Geneva. It was, humanly speaking, an accident that gave Calvin his opportu- nity. So far as we know, he was not seeking a chance to put his theoretical scheme into practice, but was simply resting at Geneva in the course of a journey back from Italy to his study in Basel, when he was importuned by his early friend, Farel, then chief minister of the reformed Geneva church, to stay and help him in his difficult task. We cannot even be sure that the opportu- nity was welcome to Calvin. He had never been what we now call an “or- ganizer.” He was anx!ous to be back at his congenial studies. His nolo episco- pari was more than the conventional Teluctance of the canonical tradition. Yet that momentous resolve to lend a hand where it was sorely needed gave an impulse to the whole process of de- limiting the civil and the spiritual pow- ers, the most recent wave of which has appeared in the final separation of church and state at Geneva itself. The advocates of that separation were the true spiritual children of Calvin, rather than their opponents, who claimed that title for themselves. The Nation. The Calvinistic state was, indeed, very far from being what we now think of under the name of a purely civil order. Its ideal was almost a theocratic one. It conceived of a community so thorough- ly penetrated by religious feeling that its government should be only the work- ing expression of religion. It was not that the government, being something different from the people, as in a Ger man principality, might dictate the forms of religious belief and Rather, the government was the instru- ment whereby the people was to carry out its highest ideals into beneficent practice. Yet Calvin's ideal form of gov- ernment was not a democracy any more than it was a monarchy. It was an aris- tocracy, that is, really a government by the best fitted to govern, and so far as the world has advanced in this matter the results have at least not yet dis- proved the value of this ideal It is through this principle of a civil community interpenetrated with | the ideals of a kingdom of God on earth, | that we come to Calvin's chief service as ; a teacher, although an unconscious one, of human liberty. If it were true that every man had a right to be heard on the most important problems of the spir- | itual life, and if the community as a w!tole were to be founded upon the best results of such deliberation, then it seemed to follow of necess'ty that every man might also jn the last analysis have a right to his opinion on the problems of social order as well. This conclusion did not need to be drawn in any theoret- ical fashion. It was suggested by the very working of the Calvinistic state it- self. It was idle for leaders of the Ref- ormation to protest that they were not advocating a liberty that in the end must prove dangerous to the tyrannies of every land in which it could gain a foothold. It was only a momentary check that came from such a monstrous inconsistency as the destruction of Ser- vetus, carried out by Calvin and approv- ed by the leaders of the reformed churches everywhere Tre ancient Church was perfectly right in maintain- ing that the impulse of the religious revolution could not be perm'tted to go on without danger to all the traditions it held most precious. It was impossi- ble for the reformed state not to go fur- ther. If the sources of religion were to be understood in such a way as to make them vital for the people’s good, then they must be studied, no longer in the foolish manner of the medig#val allegor- izing method, but with an honest desire to know what the writers of the sacred books really said and meant. If such study were to be successful, education must be directed to this end. If edu- cation were to be free to work out its own ends, it must be protected by the civil order. Scholarship must be raised from the service of a religious institu- tion to an Independent standing as the practice. | 31 ind’spensable foundation of all sound doctrine. If the enlightened human rea- son were, indeed, as Calvin maintained, a necessary adjunct to a complete un- derstanding of the word of God, then it was obvious that a sound philosophy must come in to make the mere linguis- tic accuracy of Christian scholarship ef- fective. In short, if we examine the progress of all modern liberal thought, we see that the way was prepared for it by the struggles after clearness of the | systematic reformers and, above all, of | Calvin and his successors. There is no fact better worth impressing on the | modern liberal churches than this: that | they have come to be what they are | | through a development out of the Cal- vinism they are only too ready to un- dervalue or to despise. Whatever they have that is most v'tal to the religious experience of today, they owe, not to the rags of eccles‘asticism that still cling about a timid Protestantism, but to the sound, creative principle of rev- erent liberty that is the best heritage of John Calvin Eruraim Emerton. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES The volumes of Charles Fvans’s great “American Bibliography” are coming along with surprising regularity. Vol. V, cover- ing the period 1774 to 1778, has just been by the author from his home in Rogers Park, Chicago This was a pro- lific period for the American Press, and 3,085 books, pamphlets, and broadsides ap- ire described in sent out pearing in those six years the volume The items from the printing in 1639 to the end of 176. With each volume the quality Evans's work His first was mainly a compilation, few of the books were described de visu. Now he is getting and fresher field, much of and his descriptions are the books themselves. his preface the 1774 the literature been distinctly religious. beginning with 1774 the best minds of the with political dis- present total number of introduction of 1778 ia 16,- of Mr. volume re orded improves, into a broader his work largely As he present is new, from in up to made points out to volume, of had But for a period intellectual effort of the colonies were occupied cussion, and the presses teemed with po- litical pamphlets. The first at Philadelphia, September 5, 1774, and ex- tracts from their proceedings were re- printed in most of the colonies. These va- publications have been well worked Ford, in his edition brought by In January, 177€, America Congress met rious up by Worthington C of the “Journa‘s’’ being the Library of Congress. Thomas Paine’s “Common Sense” anonymously from the press of Robert Bell in Philadelphia, and of the twelve editions, according to Mr. leas than a hundred thousand copies were printed. The Legislature of Pennsylvania voted its au- thor five hundred pounds in appreciation of its value of American lib- erty. The difficulty out appeared Evans, not to the cause paper must at that time having seriously hampered the printers Some of “Additions to Plain Truth; addressed to the Inhabitants of America,”’ printed by Bell in 1776, have of securing coples

Page 14

+ +352 the latter portion printed on blue paper with a slip To every purchaser The impossibility of obtaining white. constituted the law of necessity for part of these Additions to ap- pear in blue. The philosopher reacheth be- yond outward appearances The patriot surmounted every difficulty, And the book seller industriously attempteth business, agreeable to the prescriptions and decrees of the British and American laws of free- lom concerning the liberty of the press. Third Street, April 24th, 1776 Another printer, Isaac Collins of Burling- to in his Almanac for 1773, says: Paper so scarce is grown of late My customers I stin:, For tho" I've matter In my Pate It can’t get into print In our notices of the preceding volumes we have called attention to the wasteful- f the space in the column headed Auction Values.’ It is even more nota- ble here. Out of the 3,085 titles recorded uction values’ are given for seventy-six nly No effort whatever seems to have ven made to secure this information, and th values where given are largely from the Brinley sales and other now antiquated records. Misleading values are worse than useless As examples: for Romans’s “His- tory of East and West Florida,’’ 1775, the Barlow sale record of $85 ig given, though 1 copy brought $410 in the Conely sale at Libbie’s in 1902. For that Tory tract, “A Dialogue between a Southern Delegate and his Spouse,” 1774, the ‘‘value” is given as $'6, though $100 was paid for the Penny- packer copy in 1907 Other similar cases might be noted Correspondence. WAS JOHN COTTON THE PRECEPTOR OF HENRY VANE? To THe Epitor or TuRm NATION: Sir The letter of Dr. Henry M. King in your issue of June 10, ‘Wag John Cotton the Preceptor of Sir Henry Vane?’ since it calls in question statements made in the present writer's “Life of Young Sir Henry Vane,”’ of twenty years ago, ig a challenge to maintain, if it can be done, those positions. That Vane was affected by his association with John Cot- ton, Dr. King denies; and in general that an went back from New England to Old England which was potent in shap- influence ing the English Commonwealth, he gravely doubts. In these opinions Dr. King rejects the conclusions of J Wingate Thornton, in bis “Historical Relations of New England and the English Commonwealth" (passim) and of David Masson, in his “John Milton” (vol, Il, pp. 597-.) He attaches no weight also to the con- temporary testimony of Baillie, the Cove- nanter, the enemy of the English Com- monwealth, nor to that of the Independent ministers and leaders who promoted ik powerfully. The popular cry of the days of the English Civil War, that Independency the New England Way,” Dr. King makes little account of. If his opinions are just regard as discretited one of most picturesque and interesting traditions of New England history, which no good scholar has seemed in- was we must +10 until now clined to question. The Nat [ Vol. 89, No. 2297 ceeding from Cotton, Dr. King objects to the phrase “trained in Cotton’s study,”” em- ployed by Thornton and approved by the present writer in his biography. Vane in New England was little more than a boy in years, but twenty-three in fact, finei; endowed and precocious indeed, ripened, too, by remarkable experiences, for he had travelled over Europe as far as Vienna in the depth of the Thirty Years’ War, seen life in courts, camps, and universities, and enjoyed the privileges of a high-born Eng- lish youth. He was nevertheless immature, showing plainly in his New England career the youthful faults of conceit, petulance, and unsteadiness, He was, of course, sus- ceptible to influences from his environ- He had been trained at Westmin- ster and Oxford, trained also, there is too much reason to suppose, at Vienna in the crafty atmosphere of the Jesuits, who, un- der Ferdinand II, were laboring to undo the Reformation; trained also among Calvinis- tie Protestant lands. Now came a in John Cotton's study What manner of man was John Cotton? If we had only his writings to judge from, he is at a disadvantage as com- pared with several of his New England con- temporaries. To modern readers he is less interesting than the candid and sensible Winthrop, the bold and earnest Roger Wil- liams, the pungent Nathaniel Ward, “The Simple Cobbler of Agawam.” In the enor- mous perplexities, moreover, among which his lot was cast, his course was sometimes vacillating and inconsistent. In spite of all this he must be reckoned one of the best purposed and forceful Englishmen of his day. For a generation his character leav- ened the life of the Eastern counties of England in a marvellous way. After his emigration he dominated New England no less; he maintained his prestige, though unsteady in his politics and theology and apparently treacherous in his friendships; and when he died at last the people who had felt his power saw portents in the heavens as at the passing of almost a God- inspired prophet With this strong figure, then, in full mu- turity, Vane, an age when all men are impressionable, came into close association for many months. Dr. King thinks Vane must have regarded Cotton with repulsion. Why, then, did Vane seek Cotton out and cling to him? Dr. King does not question the accepted story that during Vane’s so- journ in America they lived together by Vane's election in the same house. So far from being repelled, Vane was plainly at- tracted by Cotton. They had many points in sympathy, notably an admiration for the prophetess Anne Hutchison. Cotton was no democrat, avers Dr. King. Nor was Vane a democrat, for not until a time long after this did he accept the doctrine of the sovereignty of the people. Of course they differed. When is it otherwise in contacts of vigorous natures? There is the best evi- dence that for Vane Cotton was a presence winning and congenial. As the two leaders of the colony, Winthrop being for the mo- ment in the background, we may infer without much stretch of the imagination what they talked about. Certainly the con- stitution of the churches would be a topic, and the author of “The Way of the Churches” and “The Keys,” epoch-making ments. disputants ia time of training at ion. come the accepted text-books of Indepen- dency, would instil into Vane’s mind In- dependency—a thought, of course, not new to the youth, for, as Dr. King rightly de- clares, it had been working its way in England for half a century. But the vetr- eran’s convictions would certainly not fail to clear and deepen the idea in the mind of the incipient champion. In 1637 Vane and Cotton parted, the latter to pursue a eareer in which a disposition naturally broad and kind was warped into severity and narrowness which would not have de- veloped among other surroundings, the for- mer to move among conditions which car- ried him at last into an atmosphere of the freest. The facts of human nature being what they are, Vane must have carried an impress from Cotton. Besides his wide training in other schools, it is certain he was trained in Cotton’s study. As to the claim that New England had an important influence in the setting up of the English Commonwealth, a claim which Dr. King seems to think not well founded, since New England Congregationalism was something quite different from Independen- cy, this may be said. For full half a cen-‘ tury, no doubt, before the Plymouth and Massachusetts immigrations, Robert Browne’s leaven was working in England. Independency was, however, a movement under the surface, not effectively voiced, and without vogue among the classes which held place and power. It was nevertheless struggling up, and notably the founders of Massachusetts Bay were scholars and gentlemen well disposed toward free ideas. At the setting up of the First Church, Au- gust 27, 1630, the church of Plymouth was invited to appear and take part. Plymouth sent its delegates, who, however, were prevented by storms from arriving in time. The ceremony was of the simplest, the ordination of Wilson and Nowell being by a simple laying on of hands by mem- bers of the congregation, and when the Plymouth men, out and out Separatists, ar- rived, all that had been done was fully ap- proved. Winthrop was naturally of a lib- eral spirit, undergoing rebuke for undue “leniency.”” Cotton, too, arriving somewhat later, was by nature as we have said, broad-minded. But the experiences of Massachusetts Bay soon discouraged a tolerant policy. However much we may admire Roger Williams, his words and deeds were often of a kind to startle peo- ple of steady habits, anxious for a quiet, well-ordered society while they clung pre- cariously to the edge of the new continent. When a little later the Hutchinsonian ex- citement began, however much the proph- etess may call out our pity and sympathy, no careful student of the time will judge otherwise than that the crisis was appall- ing. When men like John Underhill, the successful soldier of the colony, claim- ing to be a “subject of grace,” gave him- self up to libertinage, such excesses as those of Munster seemed not far off. When in the Pequot war, with a blotting-out of the colonies imminent, the Boston contin- gent, an important part of the forces, re- fused to march because the chaplain, John Wilson, was “under a covenant of works,” it was only reasonable to ask how under such conditions the English hold could en- dure. Inevitably the disposition toward tol- \s regards an influence upon Vane pro- tracts of Cotton about to appear and be- eration grew feeble, giving way to the con-

Page 15

viction that, if the colony was to stand, there must be greater rigidity in both church and state. Hence it came about that what Dr. Dexter calls a ‘“‘presbyterian- ized congregationalism” set in in place of the freedom to which the wiser ieaders at first inclined. Plymouth, not populous and in a way remote, felt the strain less; the tradition of spiritual freedom, moreover, was deeper and stronger there; it re- mained liberal. Liberal, too, remained Rhode Island, which was only, in fact, the asylum of the Massachusetts recalcitrants; and also Providence, though it ought not to be lost sight of that there were bounds even to the tolerance of Roger Williams Turning now to Old England, the develop- ment was widely different. Browneism, long submerged, working its way among humble people with little recognition from the scholarly and high placed, found at last authoritative statement, a_ setting forth which gave it prestige and respectability; and the champion was no other than John Cotton (Masson's “Milton,” II, 598), his earlier time the ecclesiastical light of the Eastern Counties, and now the dominat- ing personality of the New England Church No one will contend that he was consistent. He vacillated; in the strait into which he came he did violence to his natural dispo- sition and went back upon his earlier pro- fessions; for democracy in church or sta‘e he never had a kind word. Nevertheless in the “Way of the Churches” and “The Keys” (the ideas in tracts we may suppose were in his mind during his inti- macy with Vane) he distinctly an order in which certainly neither prelate nor synod had part, each congregation, after the Browneist fashion, being left to de- termine for itself what it should believe ani practise. The books appeared at the crit- ical moment. The writer was in a wilderness, but they went far and throughout agitated England, and we the testimony of the great independent di vines how powerfully they were themselves affected by them, and how far the tracts con- tributed to crystallize and make potent the ideas at the basis of the then nascent Com- monwealth. in these enunciated distant wide have The return tide from New England to the old home was strong. While immigrants poured westward, there was always a reficx stream eastward, and in the stream went many men of force and education whom it was a misfortune for the colony to lose. Most of the first Harvard class, of 1642, found their careers in the Old World, illustration of the strength of the attraction exercised by Europe upon the more intel- ligent young men. While in one way the drain was calamitous, in another it was for the best, for it is quite certain that far the larger part of this New England reflux engaged in the effort to establish that con struction in which the Anglo-Saxon race has especial reason to take pride, the English Commonwealth. A few New England men, no doubt, found Presbyterianism more con- genial, of whom Thomas Weld was a type; but far the larger number, however balked in its development the Independency might be from which they had come, upheld the Root and Branch, fought with the Ironsides, and helped to break the power of crown, bishop, and synod. To glance at a few figures of especial significance among these returning New an The Nation. Englanders, first comes Henry Vane, whose inclination toward we persist in believing, with all due deference to Dr. King, was defined and confirmed by his training during his Boston sojourn in John Cotton's study. He was the head and front of the leadersh'p which achieved among such trials the great result. A man of great influence, too, was Hugh Peter, who, however he may at time have dis- claimed Independency, King shows, became in a new environment perhaps the the early Independency in one as Dr most extreme type of idea he had once rejected, the especial béte noire of Cavalier and Covenanter, whether he preached or headed a squadron of Ironsides or sat at the ear of Cromwell! as the most radical! of counsellors, until at last he was tortured to death by his foes in a martyrdom whose details must not be given for modern read- ers. A soul of ev purer zeal nd de- votedness was Roger Williams, who sped back and forth across the Atlantii ind was scarcely less a power Old England than in New In particular his “‘Bloudy Tenent” established toleration as a car- dinal principle of the Independent creed In the same company must be reckoned George Downing, nephew of John Winthrop, of 1642 Beginning his ) Okey's a Harvard alumnus English career as chaplain of regi- ment in the New Model, he soon became an active soldier, rising, until at last as ‘scoutmaster-general” he became the eye of the army; later he was not iess capable in the field of Cromwellian diplomacy He fell at last under a cloud, adhering to the Stuart after the Restoration, and while he | feathered wel] his own nest, betraying his | old comrades to suffer as traitors ani regi cides. For long George Downing ran well, though sadly hindered at the end from winning the race Such were the eaders men of lesser note following numerously, the reflex stream | from New | ing ruiting and invigorat- ‘es of Independency Engiand r ing essentially the for There are good histor'cal grounds for say that the idea first formulated in John Cotton's study, in which Henry Vane, the boy a useful training the popular in England did wide of the truth when it spoke of Independency as the “New England way.” JAMES was authoritatively Governor, underwent and that voice not go K. HosMER St. Paul, Minn., June 25 THE BACON ACROSTIC To THE EDITOR or THE NATION Sir: I have been following with an in- perhaps disproportionate to its real value in affairs in this latest Ba- acrostic. It “curlousest’’—as Alice would say that I have met with. Here is a variation of the old numerical “‘string’’ cipher apparent- ly, as an identification mark for keeping Bacon’s name Shakespeare's works There are and columns have already given expression—who con- sider the acrostics to be accidents. So did I at first. A friend of mine, however, a mathematical professor, examined Mr. Booth’s book for me, and showed me, on a scientific basis, how such a thing was, in the present case, impossible. One acrostic found in an indifferent place in a book— terest general, the puzzle con is ever used in some your them such as Gray's “Elegy,”’ with which Bacon i far from being proved 33 could have had nothing to do, is not sig- nificant. The problem in Mr. Booth’s book is this: Can a series of similar acros- tics recurring on first and last pages throughout a single set of writings be due to chance? It is the duplication, the re- duplication, in corresponding and signifi- cant places that counts Let me relate a personal experience: Having the mathematician’s words echoing in my mind, I set to work looking for acrostics Instead of confining myself to one man’s books, however, | took down volumes at random from my shelves, and, applying all of Mr. Booth's varieties of the (one) method, sought for ‘‘signatures’’ on first pages. Out of over a hundred books thus inspected I got one acrostic, better than those which Mr. Rice published in your paper for the 24th. It read Francisco Bacono from the corner of the top line to 2 central O, and then ran out backwards to a corner F on the last line. It read the same up It read Francis Bacon in the same two directions, keying on a cen tral N It read Fran as well as Fra Bacon up, but not down. Moreover, it should be peated, this was only one in a hundred first page and there was no recurrence in the book firet and last pages of the chapters Calling then chances of finding an acrost by at lent on first or last pages one in one hundred (and this was by using all the “approaches” that Mr. Booth uses) the chances of finding another, in the same book, in a rresponding place are two in a hundred squared Three would mean three in a hundred to the third power, and 80 on. If there were a bun- dred, as is the case with the First Folio, the figures are so overwhelming that the veriest Shakespearean—as I once was—must throw up his hands Of the accuracy of this calculation there can be no question, and I am anxiously waiting for the schol- ars who understand this problem to tell us what it all means. The literature of the pher is so little known in this country, however, that we may have to cali on Ger- many to help us out W. L. STODDARD. Boston, Mass., June 25 {In the interest of fair play we gladly print letter, though com pelled add that the illustration and the argument seem to us not at al! fina) That the works, in whole or in part, at- tributed to Bacon, Shakespeare, ser, Marlowe, Puttenham, Bodenham, and Barnfield, were written by a single man, is 80 repugnant to historical evl- dence and the most elementary literary sense as demand proof of gether extraordinary sort. cipher, if it exists-and its ex'stence is this we feel to Spen to an alto- Such a could only have been inserted by some wanton mystifica tor. The discussion is not profitable Ep. Nation.) FIFTEENTH CENTURY VERSES PRAISE OF PRINTING IN To THE Epitror or Tuk NATION Sin: The correspondence on what we may perhaps call the evolution of Cardelius (see the Nation of April 1, May 6, 13, and 27)

Page 16

34 has been very amusing Before the ap- pearance of the illuminating letter of Mr J. C. Dana I had been much puzzled by the the pseudo-Cardelius, for I was at the time occupied with a gen- fifteenth century poem in honor of the first printer. It is remarkable that so little was in its early days said of the in- vention of typography. In ancient times it was the function of poets to celebrate the heroic deeds and skilful achievements of those who contributed to the advance- ment and prosperity of the tribe or nation which he belonged. But this was dis- continued at an early date, for where is the poem to celebrate the invention of print- ing? And yet what battle or conquest has had wonderful an effect on civiliza- tion as the art of multiplying books by means of metal type? The greatness of the invention was, how- ever, not entirely without recognition. In reading Mr. Alfred William Pollard’s re- markable monograph on “Colophons” I came across phrases which show that some men had at least a dim sense of the power of the new revolutionary force But the most elaborate attempt I have is in the verses subjoined by Hieronymus Bono- nius to his edition of the “Orthographia” of Tortellius of Arezzo, sometimes called Jean which was issued in 1477. Of the quotation from ulne to 50 seen Aretin, author there is a characteristic notice by Pierre Bayle in his “Dictionnaire.”” Bono- nius is known to me only as a name in the British Museum catalogue. The text of his poem begins thus: dispositis chartas quicumque metallis et insignes edidit @re notas satus: genitrice Minerva semine mentis erat Tingere Cerpit Mercurio genitore Preditus wtheres The whole poem, which extends to thir- teen couplets in the original, may be turn- ed thus into modern speech: POEM OF HIERONYMUS BUNONIUS LN HONOUR OF THE FIRST PRINTER. The man who first devised the happy art With brazen type on paper fair to write, THE Was surely son of Hermes, god of skill; Pallas Athene was his mother wise, And in bim dwelt the spirit of the gods, Ner Ceres nor yet Bacchus did he love, And was disdainful of all worldly wealth The Latins, eager though they were for books, Had but a slender store for their delight. Now goodly books on every side are seen, Thanks to the man in whose applause we speak; Now for a trifle books of worth are sold, Though countless colin they cost in former days, Bo greedy were the sellers then of books. Now Livy's History In the mart is seen; Virgil and Piiny, Marcus Cicero Alike in every grammar school are found Buch are the happy arte of this our day No books lie mouldering on forgotten shelves Kings only in the past, yea scarce a prince, The priceless volume could obtain, but now No man so poor but he may own a book Here in thie goodly volume, by this art, The words of wise Tortelliug are set forth, Then buy this beok all ye who wish to know The Latin tongue in all ite varied forme Buy thie and from the skilful master learn Whenas the double letters must be used And when the syllables are short or long Master this book, and you will skilful be In all the use of right and pleasing words. who and volume sball receive make known to men gratitude And you from this Pleasure profit, quick By hearty praises all your May Providence forever prosper him, The pious artist-crafteman, who has made By his skilful art thie ever useful book. The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2297 the cost of literature is very emphatic and useful. But how gladly we would ex- change his complimentary phrases about Mercury and Ceres for some homely de- tails about that first printer who had ex- cited the poet's gratitude. WILLIAM E. A. AXON. Southport, England, June 28. Notes. G. P. Putnam’s Song announce that the fourth volume of the “Cambridge History of English Literature” will appear early in the autumn. It will cover the period from Sir Thomas North to Michael Drayton. Other publications announced by Put- nams for the early autumn are: “A Book of Precious Stones,” by Julius Wodiska; “A Quiz Book of Nursing for Teachers and Students,” by Amy E. and Thirza A, Pope; “Biographical Story of the Constitution,” by Edward G. Elliott, and “American In- land Waterways,’ by Herbert Quick. Another Stuart book is to be issued by the Oxford University Press, dealing in this case with “The Last Days of Charles II,” from the point of view of the physician. The author is Dr. Raymond Crawfurd. From T. Fisher Unwin we learn that a volume containing the Complete Plays of Robert Greene is to be added to the Mer- maid Series. The editor is Thomas H. Dickinson of the University of Wisconsin. The serieg is published in this country by Charles Scribner's Sons. Longmans, Green & Co. announce the fol- lowing books for early publication: “Ta- bles and Diagrams of the Thermal Proper- ties of Saturated and Superheated Steam,” by Lionel T. Marks and Harvey N. Davis; “Hydraulic Tables and Diagrams for Prac- tical Engineers,’’ by Capt. A. ff. Garrett; “Artificial Manures,” by Georges Ville, translated and edited by Sir William Crookes; “The Basis of Ascendancy,”’ by Edgar Gardner Murphy; “Explorers in the New World,” by Marion McMurrough Mul- hall; “Some Papers of John Francis,” from essays and speeches delivered by him, and “Elementary Chemistry,” by W. H. God- frey. Mme. Gabrielle Sand, granddaughter of George Sand, is dead. She has bequeathed the chateau at Nohant for an academy, with $20,000 for its maintenance. “The Love Letters of Famous Poets and Novelists,” selected by Lionel Strachey and prefaced with descriptive sketches by Wal- ter Littlefield (The John McBride Co.), is a prettily bound volume containing seventeen groups of amorous correspondence by Eng- lish, German, French, and American ge- niuses, with their variously beautified Ophelias. There are philandering epistles by Laurence Sterne expressing the pious hope that, when his inamorata is a widow and he is a widower, they may meet under more auspicious circumstances. There are tragic little sallies of wit and love from Heine lying half blind in Paris and waiting for death. There are frenetic outgushings of sentiment by Victor Hugo. There are romantically idolatrous letters from Poe, Bulwer-Lytton is exhibited in his dod- dering erotic idiocy. Goethe reveals his Our poet's testimony as to the change in stasy of passionate expression. Byron be- trays the unscrupulous rake. This collec- tion, though it looks like a bible for Daphnis and Chloe, is really a museum of curiosities made up of just those things which the curious public rushes to see, and which the judicious critic declares should be burned. The showmen do not bore us with any tedious historical preamble or moralizing conclusion. They merely inform us, not without a certain zest in the sala- cious, of such facts as are essential to a lively relish of the object. They make it perfectly plain that when it comes to an affair of the heart a great genius may be as consummate a fool as a gro- cery clerk. They assemble considera- ble evidence of the fact that several dis- tinguished men of letters have been very free moral agents. The excerpts from the various writers are so short that one can gain from them no adequate conception of character; but the gossip-loving ear re- tires satisfied as from an exciting session at seventeen different keyholes. Like that other traveller, the Lady of the Aroostook, the visitor to Florence “wants to know.” He wants more of the human side of the city’s story than the standard guides tell him, especially if he outstays the four days assigned by Bae- deker. When, for example, all Florence goes hunting crickets in the meadows of the Cascine, he wonders at the associa- tion of this festa del grillo with Ascension Day, and asks how it represents the “‘as- piration of youth for love.’”’ To meet such needs a class of books which supplement rather than supplant the standard guides has sprung up. To this class belongs, in spite of its pages of “useful information,” Signora Elvira Grifi’s ‘“Saunterings in Florence,”” of which R. Bemporad & Son have just issued an enlarged edition. The author shows familiarity with both Italian and English sources, and writes adequately of Florence, and con amore, yet briefly, of Florentine heroes and families. The book has so many excellences that one would gladly recommend it as a desirable acces- sion to American librarians, did it not sorely need passing through the hands of a competent English editor, for the sake of added clearness and conciseness and to remove the frequent lapses in grammar and spelling which reappear uncorrected in successive editions. In “Italian Highways and Byways from a Motor,” by Francis Miltoun (L. C. Page & Co.), we are carried through delightful scenes, but the method of conveyance is not calculated to give the traveller more than a superficial impression of the coun- try he is going through. How can it be otherwise? In the space of 370 not over closely printed pages, diversified by Blanche McManus’s suggestive illustrations, we are hurried from the Genoa Riviera to Naples by way of Tuscany, around through Ro- magna to Venice, Lombardy, and back to Piedmont. A motor car can merely speed through—may one say?—the broader by- ways and allow only a fleeting glimpse at the obvious. At Sermione, for example, we can see all we wish of the Scaligers’ fort- ress, while passing it at the rate of twelve miles an bour, but that most alluring of spots, the villa of Catullus, would require @ pause, and with the pause would come the sempiternal softness. Keats swoons in ec- temptation to linger. This temptation Mr.

Page 17

July 8, 1909] Miltoun spares us. The book, however, is full of helpful hints, not only regarding by ways to seek out, but, when these have been sought and found, other directions of a more practical nature concerning dis- tances and inns, garages, and gasolene. It may well be a literal vade mecum. “Motor Tours in Wales and the Border Counties.” by Mrs. Rodolph Stawell (L. C. Page & Co.), is written for those who can read it in immediate connection with the same journey, and admirably fulfils its purpose. From Shrewsbury, through North Wales, the Heart of Wales and South Wales to the Valley of the Wye, Mrs. Stawell is a pleasant and observant guide. The motor is not obtrusive and the historical and antiquarian information is clearly and often attractively presented The general reader will miss a more in- terpretative estimate of landscape and as- sociations, and will wish that a lurking wit and sentiment had been allowed to develop into distinction of style. But mo- torists who desire to learn of new tours will be fortunate in the uniformly good taste of this convenient guide book. The photographs used in illustration greatly enhance the brief descriptions of a charm- ing country. “The Statesman’s Year Book” is well on the way toward middle age, the volume for 1909, which has just reached us, being the forty-sixth annual issue. With ad- vancing years it has gathered increase 0: authority, but also a decided corpulence which the publishers have attempted to counteract by dispensing with the larger type used for a good deal of the explana- tory text. By such heroic measures the book, 1,400 pages and more, has been kept down to the moderately chubby size which makes it so comfortable to handle. The ordinary reader will probably hasten to find what this standard British annual has to say on matters connected with the great question of the time, Great Britain versus Germany. A colored insert compares the growth of naval construction in the two countries. A table summarizing the finance and commerce of the principal nations is useful. One error, however, has crept in. When Germany is credited with a per cap- ita revenue of about twelve dollars, as, for instance, against France's twenty dollars, it would seem as if the Kaiser’s minis- ters were quite justified in declaring that the German people are among the most lightly taxed of the nations. The table should have stated that the revenue given is only the German Imperial revenue. Add to that the taxes imposed by the separ- ate States, and the German taxpayer is by no means a subject for congratulation. Un- der Turkey we catch the evidently unre vised statement that “the will of the Sul- tan is absolute,” etc. That is no longer 80, as the text goes on to show. Under New York, the State census of 1905 is not referred to. These are, perhaps, minor blemishes in a handboc of very large and recognized usefulness. “Qui Btes-vous?” the French Who's Who for 1909-1910, comes to us from Lemcke & Buechner. We note that an appendix of some thirty-nine pages has been added giving the regular biographical informa- tion about a number of Strangers. This will add to the usefulness of the book. We must say, however, that continual refer- ‘The Nation. ence to the preceding volume during the past year has shown that the list of home names does not do for France what “Wer Ist's” does for Germany and the two “Who's Whos” do for England and Amer- ica. “Qui Btes-vous’?" should be enlarged to double its size by the inclusion of the many minor celebrities now omitted The standard set by the earlier volumes of “The Catholic Encyclopadia" (Robert maintained in the The fear has been Appleton Co.) is fully present (fifth) volume expressed in many quarters that the con- troversy oves Modernism might affect the work unfavorably, interfering with its scientific character and compelling the editors to give it a more exclusively tra- ditional tone or to suspend pub!ication. The fear has thue far proved groundless. Vol- ume V, which, like its predecessurs, carries the show ecclesiastical imprimatur, continues to the th of treatment, aad the same desire to make its readers acquainted with the results of the The article on the Old-Catholic Professor Doellinger,where if anywhere in a Roman Catholic dictionary the epirit might expected manifest itself, is on the whole remarkably sympathetic and appreciative, though the author’s own personal attitude on the issue raised by the Vatican Council is revea'ed clearly enough toward the close, when he says that Doellinger ‘weakly yielded to the pressure of those who were bent on apos- -a rather unhappy characterization of the motives of the men who could not ac- cept the dogma Papal infallibility! Among the more elaborate and notable ar- ticles are those on Discipline, Dispensation, Divorce, Dublin, Eastern Churches, Eccle- siastical Art, Education, England, and Egypt. Evolution treated with intelli- gence, though the evolutionary hypothesis is rejected as not proven. The articles on early Christian writings are critical and fully up to date, as fur instance the one on the Pseudo-Dionysius. The interesting ar- ticle on Doctors gives a useful list of the titles applied to the medigwval Doctors in Theology—Acutus, Angelicus, Ecstaticus, Subtilis, ete., and that Doctrine, which deals chiefly with the subject of catechetics, contains much convenient and valuable in- formation concerning Roman Catholic cate- chisms. On the other hand the insertion of a portrait of the Philadelphia banker, F. A. Drexel, one of the few portraits in the volume, seems rather unnecessary, and is to be regretted as decidedly out of keep- ing with the dignity and general character of the work. same bread and fairness best modern scholarship polemic be to tasy’’- of is on The Gibb Trustees have also undertaken the publication of Ibn Miskawayh’s his- tory, “The Book of the Vicissitudes of Na- tions and the Results of Efforts.” The only known complete copy of this work was dis- covered in 1906 by Dr. Horovitz in the li- brary of the mosque of St. Sophia, while making researches in the libraries of Con- stantinople on behalf of Leone Caetani, Principe di Teano. The manuscript has been reproduced in facsimile, and the first volume has now appeared (Leyden: Brill; London: Luzac), with a preface and a sum- mary by the prince; this volume brings the history down to a. H. 37 (A. D. 658). Ibn Miskawayh (eleventh century of our era) is remarkable among Moslem writers for the almost modern character of his conception B85 of historical writing. He regards it not, as his contemporaries do, as an undiscriminat- ing citation of facts, legends, and gossip, but as an organic structure, whose details must verified, He suppresses the legendary and the miraculous, passes brief- ly over Mohammed's prophetic mission, but gives the Saessanian history at length—this last fact is explained in part by his posi- tion as treasurer to the Persian Buwayhid Sultan Adud-ad-dawlah. A is known of the historian’s life. be note gives what The whole work is to comprise six volumes. A. C. Hollis, to whom we owe an excel! lent book on the Masai, now gives us an equally excellent study of the Nandi (New York: Henry Frowde). These people, living in the British East African Protec torate, north of Lake Victoria, belong ina group of tribes that resemble one another in ideas and and differ mark edly from the Bantu. The Nandi, formerly nomadic but now agricultural institutions, appear to be clearly related to the Masal; a noteworthy f that the Nandi de- fact is are scended from a Masai clan. The principal magicians magician is the supreme political head; the young warriors are organized as a separate body. Worship is paid to the sun and to the dead, and spirits good and bad are recognized; it is, however, a mistake to say (as our author does) that they have a supreme dei.y and a “devil.” Circumcision is performed on both sexes. Sexual license prevails before marriage, but after mar- riage the relations between the sexes are carefully guarded. Mr. Hollis gives a num- ber of myths, folk-tales, and proverbs, and a full sketch of the grammar; the moat noticeable morphological feature is the elaborate structure of the verb, in which distinctions of time are clearly expressed Sir Charles Eliot, the well-known traveller and student of Oriental peoples, contributes an introduction, in which he discusses the institutions of the Nandi and the related tribes, with a comparative study of the languages of a considerable group—an in- teresting contribution to the linguistic his- tory of this little-known region. The ques tion of the possible Semitic origin ef the Nandi has been raised; Sir Charles properly holds that the available evidence does not favor the supposition of such an origin In fact, the character of the verb-forms is Mr. Hollis does not to be distinctly non-Semitic offer his work as exhaustive, and it is hoped that he will continue his investiga- tions It is worth while recalling the existence and indicating the progress the giant “Bibliographie des travaux historiques archéologiques publiés par les Sociétés Sa- la France,” prepared under gov- by Robert de of et vantes de ernment auspices Lasteyrie of the Institut, with the ald of Alexandre Vidier, sub-librarian of the Bibliothéque Nationale. The third fascicle (Nos. %5,413 to 100,817) of the fifth volume has appeared (double-column, pages 401 to 600, Leroux). The eighteenth series (Fiches, 1701 to 1800) of the “Répertoire bibliographique sciences mathématiques” is also published (Gauthiers- Villars). “L’ Année des internatiorale—politique—ouv- riére,” by F. Challaye, P. G. La Chesnais, and A. Thomas, begins its first year with 1908 (Pages Libres). The nineteenth year (1908) of “L’Année philosophique” is still directed by F. Pillon, its founder, along

Page 18

* “ - a . 36 with Renouvier. Besides the valuable French philosophical bibliography of the year, it contains four essays (Alcan). Dr. Georges Bohn publishes in a compact vol- ume “La Naissance de l'intelligence” (Flammarion), with forty figures to illus- trate the text from the natural science to which philosophy now stoops. H. Ollion, professor at Lyons, gives a small volume to “Notes sur la correspon- dance de John Locke,” with thirty-two un- published letters of the Enoglish philosoph- er to Thoynard, written during the years 1678 to 1681 (A. Picard et fils). Georges Deherme, who has shown original thought in his sociological experiments, has written a book with a strong personal flavor, “Au- guste Comte et son q@uvre” (Giard). Paul Mantoux, who has already publish- ed scientific studies of English social or- ganization, in “A travers l’Angleterre con- temporaine,” treats of English opinion and the South African war, the organization of the Labor party, and puvlitical evolution (Alcan) The Fratelli Treves of Milan publish a series of essays by Prof. Luigi Luzzatti of the House of Deputies entitled “Liberta di Coscienza e di Scienza,” which, while ex- amining the relations between church and state, historically and constitutionally, re- flect the attitude of the most liberal minds in Italy alike towards clericalism and anti- clericalism, “the product of the same moral deformity, intolerance,” and at the same time reveal the attitude of the leaders in church, government, and anti-clerical circles towards these minds. The death, in his fifty-seventh year, is announced of John Joseph Jennings, a well known newspaper man of St. Louis and New York He has to his credit two books Theatrical and Circus Life’ (1882) and “Widow Magoogin” (1900) Clement Lawrence Smith, professor of Latin at Harvard from 1883 to 1904, and dean of the college from 1882 to 1891, has died in Cambridge, Mass., at the age oi sixty-five. He graduated at Haverford Col- lege in 1860 and taught at that college before going to Géttingen On returning from Germany he held the position of pro- fessor of Greek and German in Swarth- more College for one year, and then, in 1870, went to Harvard as tutor of Latin. Besides contributions to philological jour- nals, his chief publication was an edition of the “Odes and Epodes of Horace.” Henry Hardwicke, formerly a_ leading criminal lawyer of New York, has died at the age of forty-seven He wrote five books The Art of Winning Cases,’ “The Art of Living Long and Happily,”’ “History of Oratory and Orators,"’ "The Art of Ris- ing in the World,” and “The Art of Get- ting Rich.” The death is announced of Learmont Drysdale in his forty-third year. Mr. Drys dale, who belonged to the younger school of Scottish composers, was head professor of composition in the Glasgow Athen@um School of Music He first came into promi- nence by wirning a prize of thirty guineas for hia overture “Tam o’ Shanter.” At the time of his death he had practically com- pleted the score of a grand opera for which the Duke of Argyll had written the libretto. The death is reported, in his fifty-third year, of Gluseppe “Martucci, director of the [Vol. 89, No. 2297 The Nation. Royal Conservatory in Naples since 1902. He wrote two symphonies, a number of pianoforte concertos, and much chamber music. OUR WATERWAYS. The Great Lakes: The Vessels that Plough Them; Their Owners, Their Sailors and Their Cargoes, together with a Brief History of Our Inland Seas. By James Oliver Curwood, 72 illustrations and a map. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $3.50 net. The Story of the Great Lakes. By Ed- ward Channing, Professor of H’story in Harvard University, and Marion Florence Lansing, Editor of the “Open Road Library.” With maps and illus- trations. New York: The Macmillan Co, $1.50 net. Old Times on the Upper Mississippi: The Recollections of a Steamboat Pilot from 1854 to 1863. By George Byron Merrick, Cleveiand: The Ar- thur H. Clark Co. $3.50 net. Mr, Curwood’s volume belongs to the American Waterways Series, the scope of which has been indicated by previous reviews in these columns. The facts of the lake freight traffic which he has here presented are doubtless in great part new to most Americans possessing no immediate financial interest in the subject, and are of unquestionable value to students who wish an accurate grasp of the main features of our present ma- terial development, and of its probable trend in the future. The more uncon- cerned reader, however, may be pardon- ed for tiring a little of the insistence with which the material magnitude of everything connected with the Great Lakes is thrust upon him by the author, who seems deliberately to prefer the tone of the professional promoter. One is continually meeting the city where in 1907 “was built more tonnage than in any other city of the United States,” the “richest country on the face of the earth,” the “greatest freight traffic road in existence,” the “greatest waterway of commerce in the world,” until even the adult head is in a whirl comparable only to that of the boy on his first visit to the wonderland of a Barnum and Bailey. i‘he boy who starts down at the bottom and rises to do things is much in evidence—the two who began in overalls and grease, pulling and heav- ing with common laborers until they stand today “monuments to courage and ambition, the earth’s two greatest builders of ships”; the poor ten-hour-a- day mechanic of a few years since, “whose word !s now law in the directing of more than a hundred vessels, the greatest fleet in the world”; the presi- dent of five steamship companies who began as a messenger-boy at Lansing, Michigan, “with just two assets: his clothes and h!s ambition”—and many an- other. One could wish that there had been less insistence upon such matters as these and somewhat more of detailed description of the methods by which some of the results of our lake traffic are secured. The pen and camera to- gether might have given, for instance, a fairly complete and clear idea of the development of loading and unloading devices, a triumph of mechanical in- genuity, the extent and importance of which is one of the first things to im- press itself upon the mind of the trav- eller on lake waters. The pages given by Mr. Curwood to the earlier history of the lake region are too hurried and subordinate to bear comparison with the second volume be- fore us, in which the historical motive is, of course, foremost. Professor Chan- ning divides his work into three parts: Discovery and Exploration, the Struggle for Possession, and Occupation and De- velopment; in the last of which we get in more subdued light the main features of that material growth to which Mr. Curwood’s volume is devoted. The main features of the story have been often told, but the grouping of the facts about the great bodies of water which so often gave them their character had never been systematically done, and was well worth the doing. Many read- ers who have already made the discov- ery that a number of statesmen of high ability and usefulness were thrown into undeserved obscurity by the brilliant light of the Websters and Clays of the first half of the last century, will appre- ciate the justice done in this volume to the services of Lew's Cass, as Governor of the Michigan territory during the critical years subsequent to the War of 1812. Though born in New Hampshire, Cass was a frontiersman by early train- ing, and held the first certificate of ad- mission to the bar granted by the new State of Ohio, dated in 1802. He knew the Indians, and in his dealings with them never lost that sense of justice which so many apparently regard as ap- plicable only to men of like skin. Many treaties were negotiated by him during this period of reorganization, always with insistence upon three points: The ch‘efs should understand fully the pur- port of the treaties to which their as- sent was asked; concessions received from them should in all cases have fair remuneration, and the agreements en- tered into should be faithfully kept by both sides. “The flag that he carried into the lake region remained during his administrat'on the symbol of justice and honor, and won the respect of all.” Mr. Merrick’s title, “Old Times on the Mississippi,” naturally suggests the somewhat random character of the chap- ters over which it stands, But even ran- dom observations are worth while if the observer knows what to look at, and a river pilot of the old days had per- force to train his eyes to catch what

Page 19

July 8, 1909] The Nation. was really significant. His experience at the wheel lasted less than ten years, but it came when the development of railway building had not as yet cut deeply into the rich profits which the business of steamboating drew from the rapid occupation of the lands of the river valleys of the Middle West, nor had the spice of variety and danger been removed by the clearing of snags and wrecks, the dredging of bars, the straightening of channels, the mainte- nance of lights, and other aids devised by a generation of experience in river mprovement at government expense. Mr. Merrick, therefore, has many a story of absorbing interest to tell, and he does not hesitate occasionally to put into four or five pages material which a more practised hand and a keener eye for the market would have been tempt- ed to expand into twenty. It is a good book for any one to pick up for a half- hour of recreation, but it is still more than that to any reader who would real- ize the life of our Western rivers a half- century ago, when mere human ingenu- ity, without scientific training, was meeting and mastering a class of prob- lems of enormous difficulty, now remov- ed and all but forgotten. CURRENT FICTION. The Romance of a Plain Man. By Ellen Glasgow. New York: The Macmillan Co. The story of this book needs a spe- cial charm to make one overlook its tr'teness—to forget would be impossi- ble. In brief, it is the rise of a man who works up from absolute destitution to spectacular wealth, and marries a gir! of refinement and high social position Her family in outraged pride disown her, and her husband, pursuing the Business to the neglect of the Dream, drives her in loneliness to lean almost to scandal on the tender consideration of a rejected but constant lover. The husband is ruined, and falls ill; Sally dees fine laundering to maintain the family, and there is a brief interlude de- voted to the Dream. But with Ben’s re turning to strength, the Business re- gains the ascendency, and he recovers his fortune only to find at last that he has tried Sally’s faithful heart too far and that her sweet and dutiful affection can never be rekindled even by the sac- rifice of his ultimate ambition, which, l nowing this, te makes silently, in ex- piation, not in hope. As with the greater number of Miss Clasgow’s books, the plot is only a thread whereon are held up for our delectation single characters as care- fully and intricately cut as Chinese beads. There is a fine distinction in the brief but suggestive picture of the hero’s mother; in the more exhaustive presentation of the General, the “gay old bird,” all whose faults cannot wholly belittle his inner greatness; and of those two gentle daughters of Pooh Bah, the conservative Miss Mitty and the radical Miss Matoaca, united only by sisterly love and “family pride.” Miss Matoaca indeed impinges sensibly upon the issues of to-day. As she marches with her suffragist banner, “her eyes on the sky and her feet in the dust,” one is reminded of modern instances of the pathetic incongruity of the real with the ideal; while in the General's naive outburst, “I tell you there’s not a woman alive that ain’t happier with a bad hus- band than with none at all. What busi- ness has a lady got with a view any- way ?’’—one catches the crude essence of the spirit that, homeopathically, to be sure, is still prescribed for the health of the body social. The plain man himself 1s so living and human that one invol- untarily compares him with other fig- ures of fiction. The story as a whole has a haunting flavor of “Lewis Rand,” and readers of the two books will find it an interesting diversion to note the startlingly frequent points of similarity. The resemblance, however, is kept well this side of the danger-line by the subtle individuality of the writer, which in- vests the most hackneyed themes with a touch of her own originality. Stickeen. By John Muir. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. We have had no American “nature writer” of quite the quality which has distinguished that indomitable patriarch of the wilderness, John Muir. Mr. Bur- roughs is of the farm, the domesticated countryside; he is the balladist, as Brad- ford Torrey may be called the sonnet teer, of wild life in the dooryard Thoreau at his most savage was within hail of the _ pencil-market and his mother's kitchen-garden Professor Van Dyke has studied the desert wastes as he has studied pic- tures or economic conditions—as a series of interesting, even exciting, phe- nomena, worth the consideration of sen- sitive and sophisticated town-dwellers But John Muir, with a full equipment of city lore, has written in terms of home-felt enthusiasm about the wilder- ress, that stupendous far-western wil- derness, which is (to so many whose daily walk hugs the Eastern seaboard, and whose daily gaze turns instinctively yet farther eastward) but the shadow of a name. This little story of a man, a dog, a storm, and a glacier, is full of the glam- our that belongs to the heroic-in-little. Hop o’ my Thumb was a great boy be- cause he was such a little one; and Stickeen, the least and most nonde- script of all dog-kind, triumphs for sim- ilar cause. And yet far more than that: Stickeen is a tiny but vital atom pitted against a vast conspiracy of inor- 37 ganic forces. He recognizes the odds, yet, at the summons of his fellow-atom, man, dares the impossible—and wins There is an ep'cal suggestion in this, as in other episodes recounted by Mr. Muir, which reduc » their r ght proportions, for the moment at least, those anec- dotes of street, shop, or parlor with which our magazines, and daily lives, are filled. Young Nemesis. By Frank T. Bullen. New York: E. P, Dution & Co Mr. Bullen is straying further and further from the excellence which Kip- ling discerned in “The Cruise of the Cactalot,” and which a large audience recognized in one or two later books His early catches were excellent, and to all appearances he is now able to dis- pose of pretty much anything that hap- pens to find its way into his net, sea- weed, rubbish, and all. The number of his books has already passed the score, and it must be confessed that most of the later ones are pretty bad—none quite so bad, perhaps, as the latest of all. “Young Nemesis” is a really ludic rous performance; a tract aimed at that pirate-worship which is implanted in all normal youthful breasts. Mr, Bul len has taken it into his head that the world is laboring under a damnable de- lusion with regard to the real nature of pirates, and here sets himself to demol- ish those false idols, Piracy is a monster of frightful mien, and he proposes to picture it to us down to the last horrid lineament The result is one of the most bloodthirsty books on_ record, which we cheerfully recommend to all good lovers of pirate lore. But, of ; course, there needs no able writer to tnvest such villany with glamour. We greatly prefer the pirates in this book to the young prig of an avenger whom Mr. Bullen has set up against them, and we do not see why it is not more fun to be bloodthirsty at the expense of vir tue than of vice, which is sadly remote from the lives of most of us. If deta Is like the Ten Commandments are going to be considered, Mr. Bullen might as wel] take our giants and our ogres away from us, and be done with it Salvator. By Percival Gibbon New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. Arms and the Man, Mr. Gibbon sings; a man’s life flung into the bottomless pit of devotion to a chimera. Salvator, the hero, is a gallant, vividly colored figure against the background of plain, honest, common-sense people who seem somehow hopelessly stodgy and self- centred by contrast with the fanatical idealist. He is bent upon the re generation of Mozambique, and _ to this visionary life-work he sacrifices his love for an English girl—a part of the Background aforesaid—and finally his

Page 20

38 life as well, for he is shot by a traitor in the moment when his revolution is declared. As a story of adventure the book would be commonplace and lacking in artistic finish; but its appeal goes below the surface. The writer has wisely kept his central idea so promi- nent that the eternal strife of the ideal and the practically expedient dwarfs the Reason admits the un- answerable the solid arguments of the Background, and yet where would this world be now without the flaming efforts of those divine fools who have filled up so many quagmires mere narrative. character of all by what seemed the useless throwing away of life? Poetical Works of Giles and Phineas Fletcher. Edited by Frederick S. Boas. Vol. If (Cambridge English Classics). New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $1.50 net This second volume contains an exact reprint of the poems, original or trans- lated, of Phineas Fletcher, which ap- peared in or after the year 1633, to- gether with “Brittain’s Ida,” first pub- lished in 1628. The earlier work of Phineas, together with all the poems of Giles, made up the first volume. It is unnecessary to repeat the commenda- tion of Mr. Boas’s care in carrying through this difficult task. How need- ful such care was any one may learn for himself by comparing a few pages of “The Purple Island” in the present vol- ume with the text of that poem as print- ed by Grosart. Our commendation of the editor’s labor is the warmer for a reason which Mr. Boas would probably repud ate—that it is expended on one of the most unrewarding poems of the lan- guage. Phineas evidently thought him- self, as indeed he was called by Francis Quarles, “the Spencer of this age”; and in so far as he possessed to an exag- gerated degree all the faults of his model, the characterization is just. It would be a fairly amusing diversion to compare “The Purple Island” with “The Faerie Queene,” Il, ix, of which it is a monstrous expansion, so to speak, and show how Spenser's passion for alle- gory, which only his great genius could save from tedium, becomes in Fletcher's hands not tedious but endlessly abeurd; and how, not content with ren- dering Spenser's allegory grotesque, he must lug in a would-be Spenserian pas toral theme with which the allegory has no natural connection It is well to speak the truth bluntly about “The Pur ple Island,” for since Lam's day an utterly false value bas been attached to the productions of the minor Elizabetb- ans, or Jacobeans—among them to this only dreariest work of the Fletchers. As a matter of fact, if Phineas is ever great, it is not when he is imitating Spenser, but, as it were; preluding Milton. His [Vol. 89, No. 2297 The Nation. true genius lay not in suavity or beau- ty, but in a kind of impulsive crude sub- limity. There are passages in “The Apollyonists” which must have been in the mind of the author of “Paradise Lost” when he portrayed the rebel Satan, and which possess an indisput- able, if formless, grandeur of their own. The total absence of warm beauty and genuine sensuous charm from Pthin- eas Fletcher's work makes it difficult to follow Mr. Boas in attributing to him “Brittain’s Ida,” which is included in this volume. That poem, it is well known, was published in 1628 as a post- humous work of Spenser’s. In 1762, Thomas Warton, in his “Observations on the Fairy Queen,” after rejecting Spenser's authorship on internal grounds, observed that “It’s (sic) man- ner is like that of Fletcher’s ‘Purple Isl- and.’” This conjecture was taken up by others, particularly by Grosart, but has of late years not found general tavor. Mr. Boas now attempts to con- firm it by the comparison of a number of lines in “Brittain’s Ida” with passages from the undoubted poems of Phineas. As for Warton’s suggestion, any one who can see a similarity of manner in “The Purple Island” and “Brittain‘s Ida” has a sharpness of vision to which the present reviewer lays no claim. “Brit- tain’s Ida” is a copy of Shakespeare’s “Venus and Adonis,” whose theme it takes, with a sensuous charm, rather pale, but very genuine, which to the rich glow of Shakespeare is as the moon to the sun. Of charm or appeal to the senses, there is nothing in “The Purple Island,” and but the faintest glimmer, or semblance, in the other poems of Phineas, whose theme would naturally lead to such qualities. ‘the verbal par- allels pointed out by Mr. Boas, if they mean anything, would indicate, not iden- tity of authorship, but that Phineas thought “Brittain’s Ida” to be Spenser’s, and borrowed language from it for his amorous poems as he had borrowed images, and even words, from “The Faerie Queene" for his allegorical “Pur- ple Island."’ The parallel passages noted by Mr. Boas could not, in the judg- ment of the present reviewer, have been written by the same man. To take an ex- ample, Mr. Boas quotes from the “Pis- catorie Eclogues” of Phineas: So is my love an heav'n; her hair a night: Her shining forehead Dian’s silver light: Her eyes the starres; their influence de- light: Her voice the sphears; her cheek Aurora bright: Her breast the globes, where heav’ns path milkie-white Runnes ‘twixt those hills: her hand (Ariona touch) As much delights the eye, the eare as much. Such is my Love, that, but my Love, was never such—— and asks us to believe that these halt- ing lines were composed by the poet who made this stanza of “Brittain’s Ida”: . Her spacious fore-head like the clearest Moone, Whose full-growne Orbe begins now to be spent, Largely display’d in native silver shone, Giving wide roome to beauties Regiment, Which on the plaine with love tryumphing went: Her golden haire a rope of pearle im- braced, Which with their dainty threds oft times enlaced, Made the eie think the pearle was there in gold inchased. It is extremely doubtful whether “Brittain’s Ida” was really the work of Spenser; from the comparison of two such stanzas as those here quoted it seems to be not at all doubtful that it was the work of a better poet than Phineas Fletcher. The Love Affairs of Napoleon. Trans- lated from the French of Joseph Tur- quan, by J. Lewis May, with numerous portraits. New York: John Lane Co. $5 net. A Faworite of Napoleon: Memoirs of Mademoiselle George. Edited from the original manuscript. By Paul Cher- amy. New York: The John McBride Co. $2.50 net. Like the other books of the author on the women of the Empire and the Restoration, “The Love Affairs of Na- poleon” has not the slightest claim to original research. It tells us nothing new is evidently composed of memoirs of the period, extracts from pamphlets, and stories of scandalous episodes, for sev- eral of which M. Turquan does not ad- vance any authority. But the work is decidedly interesting. Several of the anecdotes, and the book is fairly stuffed with them, will find an excuse for their presentation, in spite of their sadly un- edifying details, in the light they shed, not only on the social turpitude of the time, but on certain political events. In the pages of M. Turquan, the men and women who surrounded Napoleon are depicted as unspeakably coarse and brutal, with none of the grace and ele- gance which, in the opinion of the fa- mous Irish orator, palliated the immoral excesses of the ancient régime. Perhaps the most amusing chapters in the volume are those which treat of Napoleon's relations to Josephine be- fore and after their marriage. It bas been said, with some truth, that the Bonapartes belonged to the Renaissance in their morals, views of life, and in- difference to all the proprieties. The brothers and sisters of Napoleon, es- pecially the sisters, are shown by M. Turquan to have been as sublimely in- different to personal morality as were the deities of Olympus. Put Napoleon, in his earlier years, loved Josephine with

Page 21

July 8, 1909] an affection that was almost disinterest- ed and that lasted for years, in spite of her extravagance, frivolity, and numer- ous infidelities. There is something pa- thetic, as well as comical, in the nar- rative of his courtship of the Beau- harnais. The eagle-eyed warrior, the fu- ture despot, shows himself on this oc- casion as weak as a schoolboy. rhe whole affair is an illustration of the cynical maxim that in love, there is one who loves and one who consents to be loved. Josephine consented to be loved, and she made no secret of the fact among her intimates that her youthful suitor was perfectly indifferent to her, and that she married him in the hope of being relieved from her monetary embarrassments. Then when the divorce came, her anger and despair passed all bounds. There is no doubt that she be- gan to experience at this period as strong a passion for Napoleon as that with which she had once inspired him. Some moralist has said that women real- ly love only those who ill-treat them. One conclusion the reader will de- duce from the work of M. Turquan, namely, that not a single one of the women to whom this Corsican sultan deigned to throw the handkerchief had the slightest affection for him—though “we fancy that the author might have excepted Madame Walewska and Made- mo'selle George from the list. And they were all false to him—Marie Louise and Josephine and all. M. Cheramy, the grave and venerable president of the Society of the Solicitors of Paris, has deemed it necessary to ue- fend in a long preface his actions in publishing the memoirs of an actress like Mile. George. The gist of the whole explanation amounts simply to this: In the days when George IV was king, or when Plancus was consul, M. Cheramy was very fond of frequenting the so- ciety of actors and actresses; now that he is retiring from public life, he is re- turning to his premiers amours. But no apology was necessary. M. Cheramy is a Frenchman, and a Frenchman never grows old. Mlle. Weymer, who assumed the name of Mile. George, was born in 1787. Her father led a little wandering troupe of actors through the French villages, and was, in fact, what we would call a barn- stormer. His daughter must have been a precocious young person, for she play- ed comedy, vaudeville, and tragedy at the age of five. She grew up a marvel- jous beauty, to which circumstance, rather than to her talent, she owed her engagement at the Comédie-Francaise, wnenu barely sixteen. The next day, the consul saw her, and invited her to a supper at the Tuileries. The liaison last- ed from 1802 to 1808. Her memoirs cer- tainly reveal the Emperor in a sym pathetic aspect. if we are to believe them, Bonaparte was a tender and thoughtful lover. But like many of her The Na ————S——S= . tiom. class, she was very good-natured, not vindictive at all, and utterly free from malice. Subsequently, she had a multi- tude of ardent wooers, embracing kings, princes, authors, diplomats, and even a bishop, Talleyrand. The last of her lovers seems to have been Victor Hugo. M. Cheramy is inclined to consider her at heart a virtuous woman. He con- trasts her tranquil and kindly nature with the frenzied and passionate trans- ports of that other lover of Victor Hugo, Marie Dervual, whose correspondence he intends publishing. Science. Birds of the World. By Dr. Frank H. Knowlton. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $7 net. This is the third volume thus far pub- lished in Group I of the American Na- ture Series, the others being Jordan’s “Fishes” and Kellogg's “Insects.” The predecessors set a very high standard of excellence, which we are glad to see has been well sustained by the present pub- lication. Dr, Knowlton is a palwobotan- ist in the United States National Mu- seum, so that his success in this ambi- tious venture into ornithological werk is all the more remarkable. He has had the assistance of two well-known orni- thologists, Dr. F. A. Lueas, who has con- tributed a short but able chapter on the anatomy of birds, and Prof. Robert Ridgway, who has acted as general edi- tor of the whole manuscript. In a single volume of 873 pages the author has succeeded in setting forth in non-technical language the salient facts regarding the birds of the world. Such an undertaking by a naturalist to-day is, of course, largely a matter of compila- tion. Careful search through the pages shows that Dr. Knowlton has scanned a vast mass of literature and has shown good judgment in the selection of quo- tations. For example, in the two pages devoted to that strange reptile-like bird, the Hoactzin, we have, first, a well-word- ed general description of the plumage and structural peculiarities of the bird. Then comes a paragraph from Newton in the “Dictionary of Birds” concerning the remarkable crop, and then long quo- tations from the “Ibis” by Quelch and from a “National Museum Depot” by Lucas, treating of habits and general ecology. A final paragraph relates to the various opinions of Huxley, Sharpe, and Gadow as to the relationships of this strange creature. The frank way of using direct quotations is admirable The general method of arrangement is the conventional one. Five prelim- inary chapters treat respectively of Birds in General, Anatomy, Geographi- cal Distribution, Migrations, and Classi- fication. These are full, well-balanced accounts, embodying the most recent re- 39 SS EEE = sults obtained by ornithologists. The remaining twenty-one chapters are de- voted each to a single order of birds, this treatment making the chapters of very unequal length. The chapter on the elephant-birds (4 pyornithiformes) occupies only two pages, while that on the Passeriformes covers 244 pages. The lowest unit of classification to be cover- ed in detail is the Family; all known groups of this rank being included. Be- low this, especially in the larger assem blages, only the more typical genera and species are mentioned or described. The Families are marked by sub-headings, and the representative birds by black- faced paragraph titles. The classification adopted is essen- tially that of Professor Gadow, modified by the more recent investigations of other ornithologists. Their influence may be illustrated by the rejection of the sub-class Ratitm, and by the change of name of the genus of our American robin, from Merula to Planesticus. It is scarcely worth while to criticise any linear classification, the necessary se quence of groups written one after an- other rendering the relationships mis leading and erroneous. But it is the best we can devise for written use until some one invents a genealogical dia gram utilizing all three planes of space A review of the main body of facts shows that the author is conservative in all mooted problems. Both sides of a question are presented, and the more plausible solution is suggested Beyond this he does not go, as he is avowedly not writing for the advanced ornithologist, but for the average in- telligent student of birds who desires general information. The proof reading and editing have been carefully done, and errors chiefly those accepted in compilation For example, on page 337, as regards the South American Trumpeter; the bird does not call with its bill widely open; the females also share the trumpeting ability; the nest is not placed on the ground, and the eggs are not bright green. But errors of this sort show only how much we need real field ob- servations on birds. The author, by occasionally admitting our ignorance, stimulates observation on the part of bird students, as, for instance, in the chapter on Migration, where he con- fesses that the cause of this world- wide phenomenon “still remains with- out a wholly satisfactory answer.” And again, “it may be acknowledged that we do not yet know the winter home of our Chimney Swift, Bank Swallow, and Cliff Swallow.” The black and white number 236, and with few are old friends, taken from well-known isnglish, German, and Dutch works Their average of excellence is rather low, and we could have wished for a new set by some modern artist The are illustrations exceptions

Page 22

40 sixteen colored plates partly make up for this lack. They are from paintings by Miss Mary M. Mitchell of Washing- ton, and are unusually true to life. The surroundings are carefully chosen, and minute attention has been devoted even to the selection of appropriate plants. Thus in the frontispiece, representing the Resplendent Trogon, we have as a background a Mexican composite flower, and the ruin of an Aztec conventional carving of this bird, the deified Quezal of that ancient nation. A copius index of both common and scientific names adds much value to the work. The most serious drawback to the book is its unwieldy size and its weight of seven and a half pounds.

“A Little Maryland Garden,” by Helen Ashe Hays (G. P. Putnam’s Sons)), Is a chatty and confidential book, well worth reading. When to its charm of style is added that of drawings in neutral tints, and a few remarkably fine illustrations in color, one can see that here is a garden- book above the average. Of course, the read- er does not expect to get from the amateur herticulturist much information which is not presented formally in the standard treatises, but he is sure to get some good hints as to what to avoid It has been asserted, apparently with truth, that the rapid advance in photography has been largely due to the work of amateurs. This class of enthusiasts can always be found ready to try costly experiments and to break over and through conventionalities: whereas the professionals do not care to take great risks. In gardening much the ime holds good methods are con- elther through design or and the results are made without reserve The writer of pleasing chapters had known the glories of sky and the profusion of bloom in California, and she brought to her little garden in the East a strong love for meny plants, together with numerous dis- likes, and even marked antipathies. Co- lumbines are black list, although iuthor had often seen their brilliant the The pea-shaped small in the same although she to some And wistaria, as yellow are tolerated “de- And ampelopsis is also under the ban it always a pleasure when find that our likes and dislikes are shared This and New stantly tried happy accident, known these on the the in caflions of of unloved the colora flowers size are blossoms, sweet-peas as well Coleus she clase sdmits larger favor broom teste in we who dares to speak out writer takes one into her confidence offers a wide range of choice as to likable unlikable things And if sometimes we cannot agree with her preferences, or may even think them unreasonable, at least by someone the statement of her case is generally well put It noted also that she is one who delights to work with her own hands, and thus has the sym pathy of a large and increasing group of garden effect is produced on the printed page by the bold for generic names hemerocallia, montbretia, tigridia, forsythia present almost an unclad appearance without their usual large in is to be a claim on true lovers A curious rejection of capitals thus and

| The Nation. [Vol. 89, No. 2297

tion of employing these words as common names, no gu<i objection can be urged. The “Absorption Spectra of Solutions,” by H. C. Jones and J. A. Anderson (The Carnegie Institution), is a continuation of Professor Jones's work on absorption spec- tra, which appeared as No. 60 of the Car- negie Publications. It gives results for about 1,200 new and different solutions. Be- sides publishing the maps of the spectra, an analysis of the bands has been under- taken for the purpose of comparison with Beer’s law. This law states that in a sim- ple solution the absorption of light of a given wave-length would be simply pro- portional to the number of absorbers in the path of the light. The authors find many confirmations of the law, but there are numerous exceptions to be accounted for. For example, in spite of the large amount of work on solutions of cobalt chloride, no adequate explanation of its absorption spectrum is known. In this work, the authors also find an unexpected effect in the appearance of new lines when a little water is added to certain non- aqueous solutions. This fact apparently opens up the question whether a salt forms a compound with the solvent. “L’Amérique précolombienne” (Rudeval), by Alphonse Gagnon, is a serious essay 2 origins of civilization in our side of the world (376 pages, 55 illustrations in text). Lieut. Lucien Mare of the Colonial Infantry, in “Le pays Mossi" (Larose), gives one of those geographical reports for which we are indebted to official expeditions of the French in their new colonial empire. It deals with the country and peoples of that central part of Africa which is in the neigh- borhood of the Niger curve. The book is illustrated from sketches and photographs taken on the spot. Dr. Daniel John Cunningham, professor of anatomy in the University of Edinburgh since 1903, anc dean of the Medical Faculty, has died at the age of forty-nine. His pub- lished works include: ‘Manual of Practical Anatomy,”’ “Monograph on the Marsupials (Challenger Reports),”’ “Two Cunningham Memoirs in the Royal Irish Academy,” “The Microcephalic Brain,’ and “The Anatomy of Hernia” (with Prof. E. H. Bennett). Art. ART EXPERTS ON THE DEFENSIVE. No lawyer and no judge, we fear, re- spects the expert witness. His follies and less pardonable vagaries are weil understood. But the art expert has on the whole managed to maintain the mystery and dignity of his high calling. We depend on him to tell us when pic- tures were painted, for example, and who painted them. Your more skeptical collector will buy no work of art without a written guarantee signed and attest- ed by some well-known authority. Even such reactionaries as the gallery direc- tors admit grudgingly to their cata- logues the more plausible pronounce- And yet the other day the profession got a knock that sets the plain man to thinking very hard. In the gallery of Cologne and elsewhere exist a certain number of old pictures, unduly pretty, inconsequential as art, but much ex- toiled by German cri..cism as the evi- dences of a strong and independent school of painting on the Lower Rhine. Because documents prove that a certain Meister Wilhelm lived at Cologne towards the end of the fourteenth cen- tury, these pictures have been arbitrar- ily ascribed to him. Well, it turns out that these panels were one and all fraudulently repainted early in the nine- teenth century. The restorer had ideas of his own. He not merely improved upon his archaic originals when pro- fessing to rejuvenate them, but when the restoration of an intricate bit of decorative background was called for, he took the easier way of painting in his own figures to conceal the damage. What a hundred treatises have with greater or less laudation set down to “Meister Wilhelm,” turns out to be the work of a journeyman restorer, whose name even escapes us. Fortunately these repaints are being removed, and under the skilful fingers of Herr Fridt is re- appearing the fine old work that was_ ruthlessly travestied some hundred years ago. All’s well that ends well, but what snall we think of the expertise that con- secrated this vandalism, gave it credit as art, found in it the sources of Ger- man painting? Can we trust anything any of the experts say until the re- storers have gone over all the pic- tures in all the galleries? As for the plain man, how shall he feel comfort- apvle in any enthusiasm, until he knows what he is looking at? Of what avail are the itinerant interpreter and the very best of stereopt:cians until we are freed of the horrid doubt that all this rhet- oric may apply to the work of some painter chap who flourished yesterday and probably belonged to a union? What’s the use, in short, of the expert, and of what possible value can be his judgments? If the average man argues thus, no one may blame him. And if expertism is for a while put on the defensive, no one need be surprised. Only good will come of a general testing of the accept- ed theories. But some one will say this was not a question of theory, but of fact. We understand that theories may lead into a realm of moonshine, but an expert is supposed to know whether a painting was done a hundred years ago or four hundred. Well, if all of art criticism and expertise were of a piece with this “Meister Wilhelm” business, we should be quite justified in dismiss- ing the self-styled expert to the limbo

ments of this pontificate. Yes, the times

jtiale; but if this is a step in the direc-

are disiinctly for the art expert.

of the astrologer and alchemist. But, as a matter of fact, “Meister Wilhelm” is a

Page 23

July 8, 1909] very special case, involving many possi- bilities of illusion that rarely enter into expert judgmets. In the first place, this mare’s nest was “made in Germany.” Next, it was made when Germany was at her silliest, name- ly, during the Romantic movement. Ac- cordingly, nearly all the writers on the subject have been consciously or uncon- sciously dealing, not in art history, but in patriotism. It became a national ar- ticle of faith to extol the ancient Wil- helm, the predecessor of the Van Eycks. A German critic was as little inclined to inspect injudiciously these panels of the early Cologne School as a devout believer is to challenge the articles of his creed. English, French, and Italian critics have given but casual atten- tion to this mythical master, and it is fair to say that they have seldom ac- corded him high praise as an artist. Foreign criticism, that is, while de- pending too indolently upon the Ger- mans for the facts, does not seem to have been far off in its esthetic judg- ments. To the credit of the Germans it should be said that they are now de- stroying “Meister Wilhelm” as unflinch- ingly as they invented him lightheart- edly. Where personal or patriotic fallacies enter, no expert, and for that matter, no scholar of any sort can be trusted. In our times an obvious forgery of Leon- ardo da Vinci has passed a number of the greatest specialists, for no better reason than because it once belonged to the critic Giovanni Morelli. Every judg- ment into which such motives enter is suspect. Perhaps an overhauling of re- cent art criticism would reveal oth- er cases as absurd as that of Co- logne. Yet such a revision would not be a demolition. Happily, the chief re- sults of art historical research are not infected by these sentimentalisms. We may measurably trust the expert when he puts himself seriously in contact with the facts. What we have to fear is some intervening emotion that makes him judge before he really sees. Schol- arship implies the elimination of these disquieting idols, and as a scholar the art expert is neither more nor less falli- ble than the biologist or the historian. The plain man must take the same pre- cautions in every case. But “Meister Wilhelm,” what trouble he has made! If he could have stayed home; but no. Again and again Italian scholars, misled by a sort of generaliz- ed prettiness in Meister Wilhelm, have speculated on possible relations between the Cologne School and that of northern Italy. Could Pisanello have been infiu- enced by Meister Wilhelm? Gentile da Fabriano? In the light of recent revela- tions, evidently not. But the painter who disfigured the old panels of the Canon Wallraf collection, may well have been at Paris, where Napoleon had gath- ered in Pisanello and eke Gentile. This : The Nation. hint mere journalism gives to art his- tory for what it is worth. It is not pleasant to have to condemn a book on art by an emeritus professor of the history and criticism of art at Yale University, but we can find little to praise in D. Cady Eaton's “Handbook of Modern French Painting."’ It gives, indeed, a good deal of information in a handy form, but the text is so carelessly printed as to de- prive this information of much of its value. What, for instance, is one to make of the statement that, ‘according to Diderot,”’ who died in 1784, “Constable's pictures, exhibit- ed in Paris in 1824, produced great excite- ment,” or the other that Raphael Collin was born in 1885 and received a medal of the second class in 1873? Of Professor Eaton's criticism it might be enough to say that he considers Gérard and Horace Vernet among “‘the greatest of French ar- tists,"”” that he has little sympathy with Ingres, that he prefers Breton to Millet, and is evidently inclined to think Corot the inventor of “an unnatural style that captured the careless eye of the public,” which “he worked out fully to the satis- faction of his pocket.” One specimen of what the publishers call “illuminating criti- cism” we will, however, give in full—a well marked, but by no means exceptional, type of his style of comment Of Lefebvre's “Truth,” holding aloft her immemorial sym- bol, the mirror, he discourses as follows: His Vérité has not the ideal grace or po- etic beauty of some of his other subjects She is a nude woman of ample proportions and life-size, standing upright in the bot tom of her well, Her right arm, stretched straight up, holds a gieaming incandescent globe With her left hand she holds the rope with which she ascends and descends. The rope is realistic; the electric globe is very modern; the well looks damp and un- comfortable. That is all; and anything further on our part is surely unnecessary. An exceptionally valuable work has been published by Karl W. Hiersemann, Leipzig, entitled “Altorientalisch Teppiche,”’ a con- tinuation on a large scale of the work un- der the same title which appeared from 1892 to 1896 under the auspices of the Vienna Museum of Art and Industry. The work appears in tweuty-five richly colored folio plates, with a descriptive text in Ger- man, English, and French. The editor is A. von Scala; the introduction is written by Wilhelm Bode; and the text is by Fried- rich Sarre. The edition is limited to 370 numbered copies. The Austrian Cultus Min- isterium has granted a liberal sum to de- fray the expense of publication. The Anthropos brings intelligence of a remarkable discovery, made in the gar den of the Trappist monastery in Dur ban, Natal, recently. This is a bronze coin, yellow in color and containing four Hebrew words, two on each side, these together reading: “Fourth year of the De livery of Zion,’ which considered as referring to the delivery of Jerusalem by Judas Maccabwus (143-136 B.c.). Similar coins have been found be- fore, but this is the first ever to turn up in Africa. Anthropos declares that two things are facts: (1.) that the coin must have found its way to Natal by sea; and (2.) that its discovery throws an entire- is by specialists ly new light on the vexed question as to 41 the origin of the great field of ruins in South Africa. It will be remembered that not a few archwologists now insist that the gold land of Ophir, to which Solomon sent his fleets, was in Southern Africa Finance. The Fourth was flanked by holidays on Saturday and Monday, and the calm surface of the market was hardly mark- ed by a ripple for the week past. The only real exception to the ruling apathy was cotton. The government report of the average condition of cotton was is- sued at noon on July 2. For the entire cotton belt the average is 74.6 per cent., the lowest record for this date for a period of fifteen years. Cotton jumped at once from 40 to 50 points—about two dollars a bale—and profits were taken on the bulge amidst excitement not par- alleled in years. But the activity in this market did not prove contagious in stocks, whose dealers looked on with a rather envious surprise, but quite un- moved. It should not be forgotten that there is still a full month of growing weather for the staple, and that its po- sition differs from that of wheat, in that the left-over stocks of the cereal are not large in comparison with the promised harvest The Lackawanna melon was cut on Tuesday last. It carried a 50 per cent cash dividend for registered holders The railway has now done _ forma! obeisance to the commodity clause of the Hepburn law by organizing a coal company. The cash dividend was de- signed apparently to facilitate the rall- way’s shareholders’ absorption of the coal company’s stock. The coal taken from the D., L. and W.’s properties is to be bought by the coal company at 65 per cent. of the tidewater price. The carrier will carry the freight as here- tofore. While the market mourns the dearth of the speculative customer and the paucity of genuine investment demand the world of productive industry seems to be quickening its pace. Bank clear- Financial. Buy and sell bills of exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; also make collections, and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits . Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques. of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York Letters Certificates

Page 24

Sind ings are 38 per cent. more than last year at this time. Imports are on the in- crease, but this may be in part a rush to evade higher duties. Postal receipts are swelling. The number of Idle freight cars is on the decrease. With it all, money is fairly easy. The Treasury's call on the banks for $25.000,000 of gov- ernment deposits and the export of two millions in gold to Holland and a half million to Argentina produced no appre- ciable stiffening in loan rates. Compar- ed with the attitude of business men in Great Britain, our industrial leaders seem fairly apathetic as regards the pending corporation tax in Congress. The small investor who is credited with acquiring a little block of stock here and there in the recent rich man’s panic is particularly immobile. He is sitting on his holdings very hard, even if he is not able or willing to take any more just at present. The summary of actual receipts and ex penditures in the fiscal year ending June 30 has been issued by the Treasury De- partment. Owing to the new system of Treasury statements, the deficit is vari- ously estimated. The nominal expendi- including the redemption of nation- al banknotes, exceed the receipts by $115,- 000,000. The actual difference between cash received and disbursed is $89,000,000, as compared with a similar deficit of $59,000,- 000 for the previous fiscal year. But the total cash receipts for the last fiscal year were only a trifle over three millions in excess of those of the year previous, and were sixty millions less than those for 1906-7 The cash expended in the past twelvemonth was $694,000,000, or $37,000,000 more than in 1907-8, and $116,000,000 more than in 1906-7. In other words, while the annual revenue has fallen approximately by sixty millions since the last year of nor- mal trade, annual outlay has increased by one hundred and twenty milliona Lures, nearly The expenditure alone ran $40,000,000 ahead of last year’s. But the idea of necessary retrenchment seems inexplicably Forecasts there are as to whether the Treasury's working cash balance can safe- in the War Department | to be wholly lacking. | ly tide it over the midsummer months when outlay is proverblally heavy; or | By Mee. KR. 8S. Garnett, daughter-in-law of the late Dr. Richard Garnett. (Just dsaued.) The Infamous John Friend A dramatic story of the proposed in- vasion of England by Napoleon. $1.50. Eva Lathbury’s The Long Gallery “Of anownal quality, with oncommon dis tinction of style. There in a soupoon of bigh comedy The dialogue i* keen and vivid.’’-— N. Y¥. Times Review. “Atmosphere constitutes the chief charm. The theme, immensely interesting, te the tn- fluence of the past over the present. . . Those weary of the banalitics of current fic- tien will greatly enjoy."'——Providence J Récently issued, $1 50, Henry Holt& Co. "y4i8. _ The Nation. Ren 89, No. 2297 whether Panama bonds or certificates of in- debtedness authorized by the Spanish war act of 1898 will have to be issued; but a serious proposal to bring about budget- ary equilibrium is conspicuous by Its ab- sence. BOOKS OF THE WEEK, A Lute of Jade: Being Selections from the Classical Poets of China. Introduc- tion by L. Cranmer-Byng. Dutton & Co. 60 cents net. Baedeker’s Norway, Sweden, and Denmark. Scribner. $2.40 net. Barnett, Dr. L. D. The Golden Town and Other Tales: From Soma-Deva's “Ocean of Romance-Rivers."’ Dutton & Co. $1 net. Bierwirth, H. C. Beginning German: a Ser- jes of Lessons with an Abstract of Gram- mar. Revised edition. Henry Holt & Co. 90 cents. Browne, Rev. P. W. Where the Fishers Go: The Story of Labrador. Cochrane Pub- lishing Company. Butler, Samuel. Erewhon, New and revised edition; Erewhon Revisited, Twenty Years Later; Essays on Life, Art, and Science, Edited by R. A. Streatfield; The Way of All Flesh. London: A. C. Fifield. Clark, Imogen. A Charming Humbug. Dut- ton & Co. $1.20 net. Conway, Morcure D. Addresses and Re- prints, 1850-1907. Houghton Mifflin Co. $3 net. Coolidge, Asenath for Barbarous N. Y. 26 cents. Crockett, Walter Hill. A History of Lake Champlain: The Record of Three Cen- turies, 1609-1909. Burlington, Vt.: Ho- bart J. Shanley & Co. Davidson, John. Fleet Street and other poems. Mitchell Kennerley. $1 net. Dearmer, Percy. Body and Soul: An En- quiry into the Effect of Religion upon Cherry Feasts Watertown, Carver. Fourths. Health. Dutton. $1.50 net. Duff, J. Wight. A Literary History of Rome. Scribner's. $4. Enright, Thomas. The King of Nobody’s Island. The Gibson Pub. Co. $1. Essex Institute Historical Collections. Vol. XLV—July, 1909. Salem, Mass. Grey, Zane. The Short-Stop. Chicago: Mc- Clurg & Co. $1.25. Grumbine, Harvey Carson Love, Faith, and Endeavor. Boston: Sherman, French & Co. $1 net. Harvard Studies in Classical Philology. Edited by a Committee of the Classical Instructors of Harvard University. Vol. XX. Cambridge, Mass. Helm, Mary. From Darkness to Light. The Story of Negro Progress. Second edition. Revell Co. 50 cents net. Hingston, W E. Forgeries and False En- tries. Boston: Roxburgh Vub. Co. $1. First, Margaret E. Life of Friedrich List and Selections from his Writings. Scrib- ner’s. $2 net. Huckel, Oliver. Mental Medicine. Thomas Y. Crowell Co. §$1 net. Humphrey, Richard L. The Fire-Resistive Properties of Various Building Materials. Washington. Government Printing Office. Hutton, Edward. In Unknown Tuscany. Dutton & Co. $2.50 net. Illinois Historical Collections: Governors’ Letter-Books, 1818-1834. Vol. IV. Spring- field, Ill.: Ill. State Historical Library. Islandica: An Annual Relating to Iceland. Vol. Il. The Northmen in America. Cor- nell University Library, Ithaca, N. Y. Lorraine, Rupert. The Woman and the Sword. Chicago: McClurg & Co. 1% cents, Lowe, Charles. The Prince’s Pranks. John Lane Co. $1.50. Low, May Austin. Confession and Other Verses. Boston: Sherman, French & Co. 80 cents net. Meakin, John Phillips. Utah and the Mormons. J. P. Meakin. Miller, Val. Standard Recipes for Ice-Cream Makers. Chicago: Laird & Lee. $1. Mitchell, Edward Bedinger. The Shadow of the Crescent. Frederick A. Stokes Co. Nead, Benjamin Matthias. Some Hidden Sources of Fiction: A Paper Read Before the Historical Society of Dauphin County, Pa. Phila.: Jacobs & Co. Racine, Jean. Andromaque, Athalie, Britan- nicus. Three volumes. Edited by F. M. Warren. Holt & Co. 35 cents each. Reiset, Vicomte de. Belles du Vieux Temps. Leaves of Truth: Salt Lake City: Paris: Emile-Paul. Sewall, Charles Henry. Lessons in Teleg- raphy. D. Van Nostrand Company. $1 net. Stewart, Mary. “ Tell Me a True Story”: Tales of Bible Heroes for the Children of To-day. Fleming H. Revell Co. $1.26 net. The English Vegetable Garden. Written by Experts. Scribner. $3 net. The Journal of the American Irish His- torical Society. By Thomas Zanslaur Lee. Vol. VIII. Published by the Society, Providence, R. I. The Legacy of a Man Who Wanted to Do His Duty. By Theocratus. Part I. Corona Publishing Company. 50 cents. The Progressive Road to Reading. By Georgine Burchill, W. L. Ettinger, and E. D. Shimer. Books One and Two. Sil- ver, Burdett & Co. The Splendour of God: Being Extracts from the Sacred Writings of the Bahais. In- troduction by Eric Hammond. Dutton & Co. 60 cents net. Underwood, Wilbur. Damien of Molokai: Poems London: Elkin Mathews. Victor Hugo’s Ruy Blas. Introduction by Kenneth McKenzie. Holt & Co. 65 cents, Wagener, Rev. Charles. The Home of the Soul. Funk & Wagnalls. $1.20 net. Willman, Reinhold. The Errors of Mind Healing. St. Joseph, Mo.: Advocate Pub. Co World’s Story Tellers: Stories by Chateau- briand; Stories by Balzac; Stories by the Essayists. Three volumes. Edited by Arthur Ransome. Dutton & Co. 40 cents each. “‘Thia stately and acholarly volume stands out preéminently beyond all other similar tributes.”’"——-N. Y. Sun. Darwin and Modern Science Basays Commemoration of the Centenary re ne outh of Charles Darwin and of the eth Anniversary of the Publication of he Origin of Species.”’ Tdited, for the Cambridge Philosophical Society and the Syndice of the University Press, by A. C. SEWARD, Professor of Rotany tn the University, Honc ~4 4 Fellow of FPmman- uel Colle yyal Svo. 600 Pages. Tite. 5 net, rriage 0 cents. = the contributions to this memorial vol- some of the authors have more espe- cially “Gencorned themselves with the re- sults achieved by Darwin's own work, while others pass in review the progress of re- search on lines which, though unknown or bot little followed in his day, are the direct ontcome of his work. G.P. PUTNAM 'S SONS, St A Special Rate SCHOOL ADVERTISING will hereafter be charged by ‘The Nation TEN CENTS ALINE NET FOR THIRTEEN TIMES Minimum space three lines

Page 25