The Nation 1909-05-06: Vol 88 Iss 2288
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nat e wm 2 Ae VOL. LXXXVII—NO. 2288. THURSDAY, MAY 6, 1999. PRICE TEN CENTS. Ie LO Brews, aa MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY “THESE ARE BOOKS THAT COUNT” MOFFAT, YARD & COMPANY THE LONG EXPECTED BOOK ON PSYCHOLOGY AND MEDICINE PSYCHOTHERAPY HUGO MUNSTERBERG, M.D., Ph.D., LL.D. Professor of Psychology at Harvard University. “EASILY THE MOST IMPORTANT BOOK OF THIS YEAR”’ “Especially will they (the public) be grateful to the man who can take up the phenomena so blindly used and blindly misused in the various systems of mental healing and faith cure, free them from mysticism, fanaticism and fraud, and present them as they are, with their possibilities and limitations definitely formulated and in some measure explained. This is the task, too long delayed, which Prof. Miinsterberg has here performed, and magnificently performed.”— N. Y. Times Saturday Review. 8vo, $2.00 net. By mail, $2.20. THOMAS F. MILLARD’S AMERICA AND THE FAR EASTERN QUESTION An EXAMINATION OF MopERN PHASES OF THE Far EASTERN QUESTION, INCLUDING THE New Activities AND Po.icy oF JAPAN, THE SITUATION IN CHINA, AND THE RELATION OF THE Uwnirep STATES OF AMERICA TO THE PropLEMS INVOLVED. Mr. Millard reaches the opinion that a thoroughly stable balance of power can never be reached without the active partici- pation of America. An important work. With 36 Illustrations and 2 maps. 8vo, $4.00 net. By mail, $4.32. IDA M. TARBELL’S FATHER ABRAHAM Of all who have written of the character of Lincoln none has realized the rounded, completed man as has Miss Tarbell; none has so clearly seen the great, throbbing, suf- fering human heart hidden deep from com- mon eyes under the rough, kindly, stalwart, forceful character he showed the world. It is this depth in his nature that Miss Tarbell sounds in this character study, the purpose of which is to make clear his attitude to- ward the army. But that, in Lincoln, which made the world, not understanding why, nevertheless call him “Father Abraham”— that is her real theme. Illustrated in colors by Blendon Campbell. 16mo, 50 cents net. By mail, 55 cents. MISCELLANEOUS WILLIAM S. WALSH’S PUNCH AND ABRAHAM LINCOLN Fifty cartoons reproduced with an able introduction by Mr. Walsh. $1.00 net. By mail, $1.10. ALFRED T. SCHOFIELD’S NERVOUSNESS An elementary review of modern conditions by the leading English authority. 50 cents net. By mail, 55 cents. CEORCE HODCES’S (Dean Hodges) THE APPRENTICESHIP OF WASHINGTON ; Lik Five historical papers of unusual interest dealing with the by-paths of colonial histary. 12mo, $1.25 net. By mail, $1.35. WILLIAM BRADLEY OTIS’S AMERICAN VERSE, 1625-1807, A scholarly work of much accomplishment and distinction. Treats early American verse in a philosophical and inter- pretative manner. 8vo, $1.75 net. By mail, $1.90. H. ADDINCTON BRUCE’S THE ROMANCE OF AMERICAN EXPANSION __ é A work of sound historical research and accomplishment, constructed on a popular plan and suitable for family read- ing. Illustrated, $1.75 net. By mail, $1.90. FICTION J. C. SNAITH’S ARAMINTA (Third Large Printing Nearly Ready) “Not a flaw to mark its delicate perfectness.”—Chicago Evening Post. 12mo, $1.50. JOHN TREVENA’S ARMINEL OF THE WEST “A novel that will bring him fame on both continents.”— London Observer. t2mo, $1.50. JOHN TREVENA’S HEATHER The second novel in the trilogy of which “Furze the Cruel” was the first. Greeted in England with distinguished applause. $1.50. CRACE LUCE IRWIN’S THE DIARY OF A SHOW CIRL “The sprightliest novel of theatrical life ever published.” “An altogether joyous and unusual book.” Illustrated by Wallace Morgan. 12mo, $1.50. JAMES LOCKE’S THE PLOTTING OF FRANCES WARE Look out for this brilliant mternational novel, due within ten days. Scene is Afghanistan, Paris and Warsaw. MOFFAT, YARD « COMPANY NEW YORK
Page 2
The Nation. Educational. UNIVERSITY OF GENEVA (SWITZERLAND) Holiday Course of Modern French, 15th July—28th August, 1909 Write for Detailed Syllabus to SECRETARY OF THE UNIVERSITY. A GRADUATE of the Massochusetts rf meine ~ wy Aagy ae engaged, and chem- nent schools. aod the entire time bas ta and - mm We the tne chemistry and [Vol. 88, No. 2288 | Educational. “The Wathen A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. at the New York City Post Office ase second-class mail matter.) [Bntered Bryn Mawr, Pennsylvania. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Preparatory to Bryn Mawr and other colleges for women. Smal! classes supplemented by careful in- dividual instruction. Teachers all thoroughly fa- miliar with Bryn Mawr requirements. Tennis and basket ball. Eleventh year opens Oct. 6, 1909. The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; William J, Pattison, Treasurer; Ham- ical chemistry, _ for part mond Lamont, Editor; Paul Elmer More, Asso- " ~~ a ciate Editor. Three dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mewico; to Can- ada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4.00. Address THE NATION, Bow 794, New York. Publication Ofice, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. EDITORIAL ARTICLES: Tightening the Tariff Grip The “Commodities Decision” The English Budget Research and Results SPECIAL ARTICLES: The New Stage of Pragmatism News for Bibliophiles In Memory of Swinburne CORRESPONDENCE: Tennyson's Revisions of His Poems... A Word About Cardelius Plagiarism Great Britain and Germany A Correction 460 NOTES Book REVIEWS: The Mongols.—The Mongols in Russia 465 Fraternity 5 The Actress The Girl and the Bill We GUND cccececse scooceseese soe Ge The M.P. for Russia .. 467 The Moral System of Dante’s Inferno 468 Madrid 58 . 467 SCIENCE: The Home Garden.—The den of Pleasure Summer Gar- DRAMA: The Playhouse and the Play Music: Beethoven's Letters .........c.seeeees ART: A Century of Archwological Discov- FINANCE: The Problem of the Railways Books OF THE WEEK ***Copies of The Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. analyt > organ o> lee on am years has acted as eub- stitute for the professor in the class work and be Kk - of the laboratory courses. Has had experience in nations chemistry, es pecially in positions of responsibility in chemical lological examination of water supplies, and i the past four years has given a course in sani- tary chemistry and Ss anoles &, as he of the course in hygiene. Add The Nation. Mr. Sargent’s Travel School 9%, ‘lusive, 1909-10. tion for college. Three instructors. ROUND THE WORLD. October to May in- Sixth year. Efficient prepara- Prospectus PORTER E. SARGENT, Box 24, Cambridge, Mass. Supplies schools of all teachers. Vacancies occurring. throughoe ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY with competent it the year. Just Published Osthaus and Biermann’s German Prose Composition 65 cents A carefully graded text-book of German writing for high school and college use. The range of material offered is wide, copious footnotes pro- vide needful suggestions, and the volume contains a digest of syntax and full vocabularies. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston Granville’ $ Plane and Spherical Trigonometry and Tables Also tesued in the following forma PLANE TRIGONOMETRY AND TABLES LOGARITHMIC TABLES Only the latest and most improved methods employed. Contains the best figures in any trigonometry. Examples under each case in the solution of triangles expressed both in degrees and minutes and in d and deci parts of a degree. Granville’s New Combined Ruler and Pro- tractor furnished with each copy of the Trigonometry. GINN & COMPANY, Publishers, 29 Beacon m.. Beste Send for HARLAN P. bulletin. FRENOH, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N.Y. ( ( ( 2 1748—1846 RETROSPECT OF A CENTURY'S PROGRESS { } Early Western Travels 7 FULL DESCRIPTIVE CIRCULAR ON APPLICATION. = oe See e. Cleveland, Ohio. § “TONO- BUNGAY” or CORRIE WHO? Maximilian Foster’s brilliant new story, the NATION says: “As charming | a@ piece of light fiction as one is likely to | come across in many a day. It is a story of mystery handled very = It possesses exceptional charm of ety SMALL, MAYNARD 4 cancer - BOSTON Thé By GORK WY SCHOOL DECORATION AND SANITATION By SEVERANCE BURRAGE and HENRY TURNER BAILEY A guide to the sanitation and decoration of school buildings and their surroundings. Cloth. Illus. 196 pp. $1.50. D. C. HEATH & CO., Publishers BOSTON NEW YORK OHICAGO SHAKESPEAREANA It is believed a Caricature of the Droeshout Por- trait of Shakespeare has been discovered in the Works of an Elizabethan writer. A facsimile of this rare print, with a description of same, will be privately printed in June. Those desiring copies please send names in early, as fifty copies only will be published. Price 75 cents net, postpaid. B. B., care The Nation. Prof. George E. Woodberry’s new Life of Poe NOW READY Send for List of NEW CASSELL PUBLICATIONS. Cassell & Co., 45 East 19th St.. N. Y¥. Send for Catalogue. fie ScHOENHOF BooK co. “ANeHZ 138 ens AUTRORS NTERNATIONAL SOCIALIST REVI Recent No. and BOOK CATALOGUE for 10c. CHARLES H. KERR & CO. CHICAGO SAMPLE COPIES O The Nation will be sent to any address for three weeks WITHOUT CHARGE ADDRESS THE NATION 20 Vesey Street NEW YORK CITY
Page 3
The Nation.
Figures in Landscape GIORGIONE IMPERIAL GALLERY, VIENNA
Published in the Med- ici Prints, a series of reproductions in color after the Old Masters, issued by the Medici
CATALOGUE ON REQUEST. FOSTER BROTHERS 4 Park Square, Boston SOLE AGENTS IN JU. S. FOR THE MEDICI SOCIETY
BEST facilities for supplying
American German English BOOK S Italian French Spanish
Catalogues free. Correspondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 50 years. 30-32 West 27th St., New York STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Balzac, Bronté, Bulwer, Carlyle, Cooper, Dick- ens, Dumas, De Foe, ~~ yy BE Gibbon, _ zot, Hawthorne, Hugo, Irving, a Prescott, Reade, a, Scott, Gusaliett” ‘snake: speare, Thackeray, Tolstol, Send for Descriptive Booklet. THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO,, New York LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and in any up im the Boston and oe libraries ars, writers, racts, lations, and bibii and revision of manuscript. and library refere H. BUCKINGHAM, Boston, Mass.
nces. MISS M. 96 Chestnut Street, Research Work in Washington In libraries and archives for literary work- ers; translating, copying, preparation of bibliographies and revision of manuscripts. References. E. L. STONE, Stoneleigh Court, Washington, D. C. The Musicians Library == SEND FOR FREE BOOKLETS = OLIVER DITSON CO., Ditson Bidg., Boston, Mass.
MAGAZINES (including THE NATION) bought by A. 8S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y.
SELF CULTIVATION IN ENCLISH By CEORCE HERBERT PALMER, LL.D. Professor of Philosophy, Harvard University.
good effect.”—Boston Herald.
“May be unreservedly commended to any one who desires to write or to speak our common language with
32 PP.
Thomas Y. Crowell 12mo, paper cover, Ten Cents, net. By mail, Twelve Cents. NEW YORK
& Company
a “bargain,” or he may be “stuck.” the best and safest purchases. do their work. competition and a fixed price. reliable in the country. the ordinary papers. Hampshire Paper Company South Hadley Falls, Massachusetts “The Standard Paper for Business Stationery” We are the only paper makers in the world making bond paper exclusively Now and then, in individual instances, a man may secure But staple, branded articles, selling at a fixed price, represent, in the long run, Time and competition
“Look for this Water Mark” has been sold for years, in strong but open The concerns that use it are among the strongest and most This is pretty good evidence that the paper is worth what it costs, tho it is a little higher in price than
f OUR LIBRARY SERVICE| | We have recently supplemented our ser- vice to Libraries, by procuring Out-of-Print and Searce Books, and by importing English books rl Educational Catalogue con- tains a full list of Supplementary Reading, indicating the grade to which each title is auapted. Our Clearance Catalogue contains overstock at special prices, a an alpha betical arrangement by authors of all chea Recent Popular Fiction editions of
Standard Library a in one list. $2.50. Our Librar Cotategee o +, 3,500 | approved titles, following A lines, is THE of great convenience to small libraries. Our Monthly Bulletin notices promptly every new book of importance. These Catalogues are sent on request. Three notable features of our service are: Promptness, thoroughness, and low prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. + Wholesale Dealers in the Books of All Publishers
The STATESMANSHIP of ANDREW JACKSON As Told in His Writings and Speeches Edited by Francis N. Tuoupe PA.D., LL.D. T= ONLY COLLECTION ever pub- lished of the writings of Jackson. Introduction, Notes, liography, Index. 538 pp., 8vo, Cloth, By MARIAN A. HILTON GOOD STORY for girls. Fully il- lustrated. 360 PP... 12mo, Cloth $1.50. The Tandy-Thomas bo Comaany 31-33 East 27th Street, New York City Chronology, Bib- CARDEN OF CIRLS
32 East 17th St.. New York.
AT
THE CLEVEREST BOOK OF THE YEAR OLD AND RARE BOOKS SPECIAL PRICES WRITE FOR LIST F. APPLEYARD, EAST ORANGE, N. J.
ANNE OF GREEN GABLES Lic”
By L. M. MONTGOMERY
A new book by an Charles Seymour, outs (Hew to produce I Fluency) is now lish Teacher of Orat m&, -, IN YUB- ideas and How to acquire obtainable in America <hroogh Messrs. E.P. DUTTON & CO., New York. $1.25 net.
Page 4
The Nation. Ready This Day The New Novel by Mr. F. Marion Crawford The White Sister Its scenes are laid in the field of Mr. Crawford’s most brilliant successes, modern Roman Society. Its skilfully shifting contrasts bring together army officers of the new politics, members of the old nobility “more papist than the Pope,” hot primitive southern passions, and the cool serenity of cloister gardens, wherein we meet again Sant’ Ilario’s second son, the Ippolito whom we knew as a young priest in Corleone. By the author of “Saracinesca,” “Sant’ llario,” “Paul Patoff,” etc.. Decorated Cloth, $1.50. OTHER NEW MACMILLAN FICTION Each, Decorated Cloth, $1.50 Ellen Glasgow’s sew novel The Romance of a Plain Man Ready next week Miss Glasgow’s special field has hitherto been Richmond | just after the war, exhausted but not beaten; in her new novel we see as no one else has pictured them cer- tain possibilities of the new South. By the author of “The Deliverance,” Eden Phillpotts’s ew novel The Three Brothers “has in it the flavor of life, a charm hard to overcome. Few will resist its delightful humor and never-failing human interest."—Evening Post, Chicago. By the author of “The Secret Woman,” etc. Frank Danby’s new novel Sebastian The London Graphic describes the book as “an almost perfect character study, so human, so weak, and yet so strong is the boy.” By the author of “The Heart of a Child.” Rina Ramsay’s The Straw lhe novel of the year for those who love the saddle, the thrill of following at a gallop the running fox, and the olly chaff of a gay handiinds set.” etc. Mr. Percy MacKaye’s new book The Playhouse and the Play A volume of forcible addresses pointing out that, whether we realize it or not, the theatre is a tremen- dous national educational influence. In the course of his demonstration that this important factor in civic life is managed on principles obviously absurd when applied to any equally educational institution, Mr. Mac- Kaye makes a strong argument for an endowed theatre. Cloth, t2mo, Decorated, $1.25; by mail, $1.35 Francis B. Gummere’s The Oldest English Epic Necessary to the student of the early English literature ; interesting to any reader for the simple direct vividness of the old tales sung to the hall-thanes in a swinging metre that is half chant, half lilt, wholly attractive. Cloth, t2mo, $1.10 net READY THIS DAY Dr. Edward T. Devine’s ew book Misery and Its Causes An analysis of social life which considers preventive | measures as well as relief, community needs and stand- | ards as well as the individual’s welfare. Cloth, t2mo, $1.25 net; by mail, $1.37. By Theodore D. Jervey Vice-President of the South Carolina Historical Society. Robert Y. Hayne and His Times An entirely new view of So. Carolina history at its most interesting epoch before the Civil War; it is largely based on local material and contains informa- tion heretofore inaccessible to historical students. Illustrated, Cloth, 8vo, $3.00 net; by mail, $3.17. By Edmond S. Meany Professor of History in the University of Washington. History of the State of Washington The story in large part of the great Northwest, a fas- cinating section of American history, in a form so com- prehensive and admirably arranged that it will be for long the standard on this subject. Illustrated, Cloth, 8vo. Ready next week. The Faith and Works of Christian Science Those who read in this author’s Confessio Medici the witty thrusts at Christian Science may recall his remark about the book he would like to write—a small part of what physicians and surgeons know of the so-called science and its effects. This is that book. Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net; by mail, $1.35 By Irving E. Miller Professor of Psychology and Pedagogy in the State Nor- | mal School, Milwaukee, Wis. The Psychology of Thinking Strongly pedagogical in bias, original and thorough in its development of the dynamic aspect of mental pro- cesses. Cloth, 12mo, $1.25 net. John Spargo’s Socialism A new edition with an added chapter embodying the author’s personal opinions as to “Means of Realiza- tion.” Cloth, t2mo, $1.50 net; by mail, $1.62. A new Volume in the Series of hand- books for the United Study of Missions. The Gospel in Latin Lands Cloth, 50 cts.; by mail, 57 cts. Paper, 30 cts.; by mail, 35 cts. By Francis E. and Harriet A. Clark | Outline Studies of Protestant Missions in the Latin Countries of Europe and America. Published by THE MACMILLAN COMPANY 64-66 Fifth Ave. New York [Vol. 88, No. 2288
Page 5
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 6, 1909. The Week. Every time a Democratic Senator is caught with protectionist principles on his person, there is great hilarity in Republican ranks. But the country at large fails to catch the full force of the joke. Senator Aldrich and his lieuten- ants take delight in “smoking out” the Democrats, as if the sole duty of a leg- islator were to show that his opponent is no less a fool or a rascal than him- self. It is not Democratic opposition that has forced tariff reform upon the Republican party, but a popular upheav- al that was strong enough to make the Republicans write revision into their last national platform, and their Presi- dential candidate pledge himself sol- emnly. From the Democratic party the country has long ceased to expect either efficiency or common sense. If Senator Aldrich shows the Democrats to be pro- tectionists at heart, he merely proves that the Republican party has infected its rival with a lust for tariff plunder equal to its own. It needed only the speech of Senator Scott of West Virginia last week to il- lustrate to the full the intellectual darkness which envelops the mind of the “standpatter.’” Why alter the Ding- ley act at all? We had great industrial prosperity after 1907, did we not? The Dingley bill was enacted in 1897, was it not? Then the Dingley bill caused the prosperity after 1897. We had hard times between 1893 and 1897, did we not? There was no Dingley law in that period, was there? Then the hard times between 1893 and 1897 were caused by the absence of a Dingley law. This be- ing so, why change the law at all? Why not go on to the end of time, with that heaven-inspired measure showering pros- perity on the American people? We are aware that we do not do full justice to the ad captandum argument, the mis- statement of fact, and the mental in- eptitude displayed by the Senator from West Virginia; but our brief summary will fairly reproduce his logical pro- cesses, and we refer to it here as an illustration of a state of mind which, we have some hope, is passing away with other ancient superstitions. The time, we may suppose, will come when American schoolboys who read of such arguments being employed in Senatorial debate will smile in- credulously, as they do to-day when told of the similar arguments over the divine right of kings. Sena- tor Scott is interesting chiefly as a relic, and as such he may be worth pre- serving. That his instructive speech should have reached its climax in the exposition of the way in which the Wil- son bill of 1894 caused the panic of 1893, was to be expected. A rude and annoy- ing Senator of the opposing party, who volunteered to accept Mr. Scott’s dem- onstration that the Wilson law of 1894 was the cause of the panic of 1893, pro- vided the West Virginia Senator would extend his argument and admit that the Payne tariff bill of 1909 caused the pan- ic of 1907, elicited no response. Yet that invitation may hereafter be accepted, if the Scott type of mind continues to be represented in the Senate. One can at least conceive some oracle, say in 1923, explaining how everything went well until, in October, 1907, on the sudden suspicion that, a year and a half later, protective duties might be revised, the Knickerbocker Trust Company closed its doors, the Westinghouse Electric failed, the New York banks issued Clearing House loan certificates, and the mills began to cut down production and dis- charge their hands. The beleaguered missionaries in Asia Minor could receive no more cheering message than the news of Oscar S. Straus’s reappointment as Ambassador to Turkey. Missionaries in that land of terror and bloodshed always speak of the halcyon days of Straus. The lately- deposed Sultan has found it easy enough to pull the wool over the eyes of the average Minister to his court, and Mr. Leishman—the retiring Ambassador —did not satisfy Americans with inter- ests in Turkey, any more than did that curious Minister from Texas whose chief boasts were that he was a rebel who had never surrendered or taken the oath of allegiance, and that he could snuff out a candle at thirty paces four out of five times. Mr. Straus, however, always stuck to his contentions and to the Sul- tan like a leech, and missionaries and teachers everywhere in Turkey looked to him with confidence. The country is to be congratulated that, in this time of upheaval and revolution, it will be represented at Constantinople by a man so admirably fitted for the post. W. W. Rockhill’s transfer from Peking to St. Petersburg is another piece of good news, in refreshing contrast to one or two other recent diplomatic ap- pointments. For some time past there has been a feeling that Mr. Rockhill was less interested in our trade relations with China than a man of different training would be. That some one else would go to Peking has been known from the beginning of Mr. Taft’s ad- ministration. It would, however, have been a genuine misfortune if a man of Mr. Rockhill’s long diplomatic exper- ience and rare knowledge of Oriental languages had been dropped out of the service. At St. Petersburg his linguis- tic attainments and his knowledge of the Far East will still be of great value to him and to the country. J. W. Rid- dle, the present Ambassador to Russia, is another man with a rare talent for languages, who worked his way up after thirteen years of service at Constanti- nople, Cairo, Belgrade, and St. Peters- burg, to an ambassadorship, and his re- tirement would be a cause for earnest protest were it not that the delicate state of his health has made the tender of his resignation something more than the usual courtesy to the incoming Pres- ident. That all the cities along the Mississippi, from New Orleans to St. Paul, are Hable to attack and demolition in case of war with a foreign Power is the startling informa- tion that is now being disseminated. Not only this but many of the cities on the tributaries of the Mississippi, such as Coun- cil Bluffs and Sioux City on the Missouri, Cincinnati and Louisville on the Ohio, and many others, are in like danger. This is the alarming news being spread from New Orleans to Washington. The Red River thrills with it, the Yazoo Valley is filled with alarm. The Mis- sissippi delta is shuddering daily at the thought of a battleship bombarding its levees. It is fear of the deep wa-
Page 6
A452 terway which Congress is constructing that is causing this panic in the Missis- sippi Valley, and is leading Milwau- kee’s brewers to tremble, lest the war- ships, after passing the New Orleans forts in the best manner of Farragut, should sail on up past Chicago into the Great Lakes, picking up coal and food on the way from unsuspecting river transports. Now, the foregoing is not the plot of a new play entitled “An American’s Home on the Mississippi’; it is a genuine statement of a propa- ganda to-day carried on in New Or- leans in order to induce Congress to ap- propriate money “on a great scale” “for a powerful fortified naval base at New Orleans.” We have always felt that this big-navy mania, this fear of con- quest to which the Anglo-Saxon nations suddenly fall prey, was a_ species of madness. After hearing of New Or- leans’s fears for St. Paul’s safety from naval attack, we are certain that it is nothing else than insanity—but calcu- lated insanity. The story of the Sugar Trust’s steal- ings from the government and the res- titution it has been compelled to make, brings out more than the old truth that corporations have no soul. It is also evident that some of our largest cor- porations have no face to blush with. For ten years and more the stealing went on, with the indubitable conniv- ance of officers of the company who were powerful enough to stop the prac- tice if they had so chosen. But here again men who would be horrified at the idea of theft in their private char- acter, found it clever and legitimate to resort to the meanest form of theft, in behalf of the corporation they served. The Constitutionalists in Turkey are determined not to repeat their error of last July. Mistaken clemency or mis- taken caution made them accept a com- promise with the old order. The cost measured in human lives has been re- vealed during the past three weeks in Asia Minor and elsewhere. The initial error is now being repaired. Abdul Hamid is removed from the scene, and upon those who aided him to stir up mutiny and massacre, stern punishment is being visited. Kipling and his school have popularized an argument against liberty for the greater portion of the human race. It consists in one word: The N ation. [Vol. 88, No. 2288 “Oriental.” When the East was created, the inhabitants thereof were doomed to servitude in perpetuity. Reaction nat- urally seizes upon the hackneyed argu- ment: “In spite of Constitutions and Parliaments, the East will always be the East.” This is own cousin to the argu- ment that the iniquities of the Czar’s rule are justified by the fact that when you scratch a Russian you find a Tartar. The Young Turk leaders seem to have accepted the charge of being Orientals with a certain grim humor, When Abdul Hamid’s chief eunuch was hanged high on Galata Bridge for the people to gaze at, even as Haman was hanged, the de- sire to impress the Oriental mind was evident. When the murderers of a mem- ber of the Turkish Parliament are put to death on the precise spot where their victim fell, we catch a distinct echo of the Cadi of the Arabian Nights, who had transgressors hanged from their own door-posts. But that the Liberal leaders at Constantinople know the na- ture of the people they deal with is not to their disadvantage. British capital, frightened by Mr. Lloyd-George’s white apron, cups, and blood basin, is said to be contemplating a flight abroad. The rumor need not be taken seriously. In the first place, capital may be fugitive under hostile circumstances, but it has also the habit of fixity. When the Stock Exchange transfer tax was enacted in this State, we all remember how Wall Street was going to move across to Jersey City. In the second place, British capital, even if it would run away, scarcely has a place to run to. On its way across the Channel it may run full tilt into French capital migrating from the Paris Bourse, the inevitable outcome, according to the prophets, of the proposed French in- come tax. Should they both seek refuge in Germany, the Minister of Finance will welcome them with a broad smile and a knife behind his back. Capital need not deceive itself. The merry game of battleship-building has become world-wide, and wherever it shall go— Spain, Austria, Brazil, Argentina—cap- ital will.find finance ministers, chancel- lors, grand-viziers, and maghzens wait- ing impatient. Capital cannot away. It must make up its mind to stay at home and fight. Capital, like labor, must fight against Dreadnought run manias, against official incompetence and extravagance, against corporation stealing from the government. All these things must be paid for; and capital pays for them in high taxes as labor pays in high-priced loaves of bread. The birth of a daughter to the Queen of the Netherlands is, of course, an event of political importance. Yet it isa question whether the natural and long- deferred desire of the Dutch has not tended to exaggerate the possible con- sequences of failure of issue to Queen Wilhelmina. Vast German ambitions were supposed to be contingent upon the death of Wilhelmina without a suc- cessor of her body. Holland has been regarded as essential to the Pan-Ger- manic ideal which contemplates a Teu- tonic Empire straight across Europe from the North Sea to the Adriatic. For commerce and war the Dutch harbors would be of tremendous value to Ger- many. Such an ideal, Germans may cherish or not, but the birth of an heir to the Dutch crown need not interfere with the plan, any more than the ab- sence of a direct heir would have great- ly facilitated it. The succession in the Netherlands is definitely regulated. If Wilhelmina had died childless, there were in Germany a number of heirs, second-cousins of Wilhelmina, and their children, to whom the crown would have legally descended. That the accession of a German prince would have brought nearer the danger of absorption by Ger- many by no means follows. It is al- most a natural law for foreign princes to forget their nativity for the interests of the people over whom they are called Great Britain is not particu- larly Germanophil because the father of Edward VII was » German prince. If the Kaiser or his successors want Hol- land, they will have to take it by per- suasion or by force in very much the same fashion, whether Queen Wilhel- mina’s children or her cousins occupy the throne. to rule. In the new Italian Chamber there is one Deputy who will gain prominence as a compact and independent Parlia- mentary party of one. He is Don Ro- molo Murri, a priest, whose Radical ac- tivities, chiefly in connection with the National Democratic League, of which he is the founder, have brought upon him the penalty of major excommunica- tion. Don Romolo advocates a sharper
Page 7
May 6, 1909] The Nation separation of Church and state than is now the rule in Italy. The state is to abstain from further interference in the administration of religious funds, and the ecclesiastical properties under its care are to be distributed among as- sociations similar to those contemplated by the French Separation Law. On the other hand, the state is to guarantee freedom of instruction, with the right to pronounce on the scholastic pro- gramme. Feeling has been aroused in Rome by Murri’s refusal to lay aside his priestly vestments. No ecclesiastical penalty can deprive an ordained priest of his sacerdotal character, and _ the Church admits the new Deputy’s rignt to retain his priestly garments, while deploring that he shoula choose to exer- cise that right. With the strengthened Socialists and Radicals bent on a vig- orous anti-clerical policy, the strength- ened Catholics bound to resist bitterly, and Don Romolo Murri as an ecclesiasti- cal free lance, Church questions are sure to form an important feature of Parliamentary discussion in the near future. How rapidly nations forget is illus- trated in the case of Portugal, which has experienced during the last half year a succession of ministerial crises. It would be imagined that such a blood- letting as Lisbon witnessed in February, 1908, would sober the country’s judg- ment and turn its serious attention to the crying need of reform. The murder of King Carlos and the crown prince was brought about by the King’s at- tempt to rule as a dictator. But this in turn had been made almost inevitable by the hopelessly corrupt state of par- liamentary government. Two political parties, almost equally matched, worked steadily together for the looting of the state. The “rotative” system prescribed that as soon as one party had had its chance at the offices and the bribes, it should make way for the other. The dictator Franco tried to break up this system, the King was assassinated, Por- tugal for a time hovered on the verge of republicanism, and then it went back to the hallowed system of codperative plunder. Once more the party of the Regenerators is engaged in regenerat- ing the private fortunes of its leaders, and the party of the Progressists is making its regular recurrent progress through the pockets of the Portuguese people. No attempt is made to conceal the fact that the good old times are back again. People in Portugal must be very much like people in New York, where Senator Depew is again making after- dinner speeches. TIGHTENING THE TARIFF GRIP. Developments in the Senate have now gone far enough to show what the lead- ers of that body are prepared to do with tariff revision. In a word, they would make the tariff rates higher than be- fore, with the only chance of change in an upward direction; and would so com- plicate and strengthen the administra- tive machinery designed to harry the importer and oppress. the that the last estate of those unhappy citizens shall be worse than the first. This conclusion is the only one that can be drawn from the duties in the Aldrich bill, averaging siightly above those of the Dingley bill, and from the other proposals of Mr. Aldrich re- specting a maximum and minimum tar- iff, and his sweeping amendments to the administrative sections of the tariff act. The whole performance must final- ly shatter the confidence, or the hope, which President Taft has cherished that he could “do business” with Senator Aldrich. It is now seen to be true, what an ex-Senator said when told of the consumer, inclination of the Administration to trust Aldrich to revise the tariff down- wards: “Aldrich could give Taft all the trumps, and as many other good cards as you please, and still beat him!” That the Rhode Island Senator has all along intended to give the lie to Re- publican campaign pledges of tariff re- vision, has now become abundantly evi- dent. He has made himself the very prophet of the “stand-patters.” And as if to destroy any last lingering doubt concerning his attitude the amendments which he introduced last Friday. In his provisions for maximum and minimum tariff rates, he has com- pletely reversed the position taken by both the McKinley bill and the Ding- ley bill. In them, we had high duties, to be sure, but the promise was held out of getting them reduced in prac- tice, by means of reciprocity agree- ments. To-day, however, the only pos- sibility of alteration 1s upwards. We may think Aldrich’s level of duties high enough in all conscience, but he pro- come 453 poses to have them increased by 25 per cent. all around, in tne case of any or all countries which discriminate against our foreign trade. True, this increase is left to the discretion of the Presi- dent, and we may be sure that Mr. Taft would not abuse it: but the maximum tariff is made more of as a threat, than the minimum tariff is as an induce- ment; and in any event, we cannot hope to get a trade arrangement or reciproc- ity treaty which will lighten the bur- den of tariff taxes. Aldrich’s figures will be the irreducible minimum, if he can make them so. In the same way, his new Section 8, relating to the methods of collecting tariff taxes, reveals a purpose to make the administrative machinery a still more ready means of injustice. It con- tains, for example, the proviso that the appraisers may, in certain cases, com- pletely disregard invoices and affidavits, and fix as the legal wholesale price abroad “not less than the wholesale price in the United States, in the open market, due allowance by de- duction being made for estimated du- ties thereon, cost of transportation, in- surance, and other necessary expenses.” Still more threatening than this, 1s the quiet proposal of Senator Aldrich to create a Court of Customs, consisting of a presiding judge and tour associate judges, at a salary of $10,000 each. ‘I'o this court shall be taken all appeals from any Board of General Appraisers, and its judgments or decrees “shail be final.”” That is, recourse to other Fed- eral courts is cut off. Many famous customs suits have been taken to the Supreme Court, and great victories won in the interest of the consumer; but if Senator Aldrich’s plan is adopted, a man may have his property taken away from him by this Court of Customs, while his right to appeal to the highest judicial tribunal will be cut off. The intent is obvious. Like all the other tariff schemes, which men such as Senator Aldrich favor, the aim is to tighten the grip of the tariff upon the consuming public remorselessly. This week’s debate and voting in the benate may easily be critical. The game of the high-tariff intriguers is to secure enough votes to pass their bill very much as it is, on the plea that the meas- ure will be altered for the better in conference between the two Houses. It
Page 8
454 is even said that the President has been urged to say nothing at present about the bad features of the Senate bill, in the hope that the conference will insist upon a really honest revision. But we hope that neither he nor any tariff-re- form Senator is credulous enough to be taken in by this. If Aldrich can get his measure through, on whatever pre- tences, without serious opposition, he will lead the Senate conferrees to an unyielding battle with those from the House. The time to attack and check him is before the bill gets out of the Senate. Hence we welcome the state- ment that a dozen or so of revisionist Republican Senators from the West are to take the floor to expose and denounce the kind of tricky revision which Ald- rich has devised. Only by meeting him openly and resolutely, and by refusing to vote for those exorbitant duties which he would levy, in defiance of party pledges and of all decency, can the hands of the Ways and Means Com- mittee of the House be held up, and the way made ready for the emerging from conference of a tariff bill such as the country was promised, and strongly desires. THE “COMMODITIES DECISION.” When Senator Elkins, in June, 1906, proposed an amendment to the Hepburn Railway Rate bill, forbidding a railway to transport from State to State any commodity (with certain specified ex- ceptions) manufactured, mined, produc- ed, or owned by such railway, he thus described its purpose. It was: To divorce transportation from produc- tion on the part of the railroads engaged in transporting coal they mined and sold in competition with other shippers, which was a great abuse. This abuse grew into a grievous wrong to independent shippers. I sought to correct this abuse by an amend- ment confining railroads to their legitimate business of transporting freight and pas- sengers, and prohibiting them from en- gaging in the transportation of any com- modity which they might own except for their own use. The West Virginia Senator was un- doubtedly prompted to his action by the independent coal producers of his State. They complained that conditions were most unfair and destructive to their business when the railways, on whose services the independent miner must de- pend to get his product to market, were themselves engaged in competitive coal production, and were favoring them- The Wation. [Vol. 88, No. 2288 selves in the matter of transportation. Quite apart from discriminatory rates, the railways would, it was alleged, find it inconvenient to provide the cars which the independent miner needed. Coal produced by the railroads had the right of way. The “commodities clause” was wholly directed towards the mining industry. It would have applied to such iron mines as were then controlled by the Great Northern Railway; but that company has since divested itself of its ore lands through transfer to a separate corporation and a contract with the United States Steel Corporation. Rail- ways are not engaged in or connected with manufacture on any such scale as to make the “commodities clause” a mat- ter of importance in that direction; and they produce on a large scale nothing but the articles referred to, barring tim- ber, which is expressly excepted from the operation of the law. The scope and purpose of the “commod- ities clause,” then, are clear, and natural- ly the law was tested in the case of the coal-mining railways. When the govern- ment brought suit in the Federal Cir- cuit Court, almost exactly a year ago, the Attorney-General contended that the prohibition affected coal in which a railway company had any interest, in- cluding coal produced by a company any of whose stock the railway held. Counsel for the railways argued that the “commodities clause” not only forbids transportation under such circum- stances, but “absolutely outlaws . coal in which the railroad company orig- inally had any such interest, no matter how many times the title to it changes within the State of Pennsylvania.” On this assumption the argument proceeded that, since the railways could not divest themselves of their heavily-mortgaged coal property without great pecuniary loss, the effect of the clause was “the taking of the defendaut’s property, cor- porate rights, and franchises, without due process of law.” With this view of the case the Circuit Court concurred, Judge Gray’s opinion of last September being that the clause “invades the right of the State by strik- ing down the liberty to engage in interstate commerce to the fullest ex- tent as to all harmless articles, whether owned or not owned by the carrier, and deprives of their property these defend- ants, contrary to the letter and the spirit of the fifth amendment to the Constitu- tion.” On Monday the Supreme Court reversed the lower court’s decision as to the constitutionality of the “commodi- ties clause.” It did so, however, by giv- ing a very different interpretation to its scope. In this respect, the Supreme Court does not follow the argument of the Circuit Court, or that of the gov- ernment, or that of the defence. It de- clares that ownership of stock in a man- ufacturing or mining company does not constitute ownership of the commodities produced, and cites prior decisions of its own to that effect. Therefore, the argument that property owned through stock investment would be taken from the railways without due process of law was irrelevant. As to the question of direct ownership of coal or other com- modities by a railway company, the act merely provides that they shall not be thus owned while in process of transpor- tation. In other words, the railway must in good faith sell products thus owned by it before transporting them—which involves neither hardship nor confisca- tion. Attorney-General Wickersham points out that “the decision does not sustain the full contention of either the gov- ernment or the carriers”; also that “it sustains the principle contended for by the government, that Congress has pow- er to prohibit a carrier from carrying, in competition with other shippers, com- modities which the carrier owns or in which it is interested.” Indeed, Mr. Wickersham believes that, under the de- cision, Congress itself has the power, if it sees fit to exercise it, to extend the prohibition to products of companies in which the railway has merely a stock interest. The probability or improbability of such action depends largely, we should say, on how the railways hereafter use the opportunities opened by indirect ownership. It may be made, by un- scrupulous use, a real abuse and a griev- ance to both competing producers and the consuming public; or it may be so exercised as to conform to the principles of equity and fair play. For ourselves, in view of the extent to which power over traffic and prices has been extend- ed in this country, through purchase of stock in one corporation by use of the credit of another, we cannot regard it as unfortunate that this particular weapon is left in the hands of the na- tional legislature. The “industrial amal-
Page 9
May 6, 1909] gamation craze” of 1899 and 1901, the Northern Securities incident, and the more recent exploits in the field of rail- way corporations by Mr. Harriman, are landmarks which at least impress on the public mind the value of a power re- served in the hands of the people. THE ENGLISH BUDGET. The finance of English Liberalism was confessedly put to its trumps in the bud- get laid before the House of Commons by the Chancellor of the Exchequer last week. The financial record of the party had been better than of the Conserva- tive Ministries immediately preceding. Until the demand for enormous sums for the navy, and the swelling expense of old-age pensions, disturbed the equi- librium of the budget, the Liberals had both remitted taxes and reduced the public debt. During the three years that Mr. Asquith was Chancellor of the Ex- chequer, the national debt was reduced at the rate of $75,000,000 a year. In 1903, the total was $3,800,000,000; it is now $3,480,000,000. This involves a diminution in the yearly interest charges to the amount of nearly $10,- 000,000. That was good financiering. But what the Conservative leaders had all along been hoping was, of course, that the Liberals would be driven into aban- doning the policy of free trade. If only Mr. Balfour could see the Liberals make a beginning of tariff taxation, with in- cidental protection, his cup would run over. But that kind of net is spread in vain before any Liberal Chancellor of the Exchequer. More sagacious as well as more honorable than our own Democrats, he recognizes party suicide when he sees it, and knows that it is better to fail, tempo- rarily, with a sound policy, than to at- tempt to get on for a time by com- promise, trickery, and self-stultification. The figures for the current year were not so black as they were expected to be. During the last few weeks of the fiscal year, the revenue picked up sur- prisingly. At the same time, expendi- tures were somewhat held down. The net result was a deficit of about $7,500,- 000, much smaller than had until re- cently been thought certain. But it is the budget for 1909-10 that causes the difficulty. How to cover the increased expenditures of nearly $80,000,000 was the problem of the Chancellor of the Ex- The Nation. chequer. He could not dodge it, after the happy-go-lucky fashion of American public finance—letting the deficit go, and be hanged to it, or issuing bonds to pay current expenses, or putting up Sen- ator Aldrich to guess that there will be money enough. Mr. Lloyd-George had to set it down in black and white, and show just what his new taxes will yield. In an unguarded moment, he once jest- ed about robbing a hen-roost to get the financial eggs he might need. He might well have been reminded of what Mon- taigne says in his essay on “Glory”: A man is not always at the top of a breach or at the head of an army. ‘ He is often surprised between the hedge and the ditch; he must run the hazard of his life against a henroost. Various small eggs, the Chancellor of the Exchequer can always put his hand upon through minor taxes. That he has done, here and there, in his budget. But it was all along evident that the main dependence must be placed upon the enlarged scope of old taxes. There are really, in England to-day, few “untap- ped” sources of funds for the Treasury. It is the land; it is inherited wealth; it is the tax on incomes, which alone fur- nish an elastic revenue. Accordingly, the expectation was strong that the Chancellor would be compelled to seek his eggs mainly in those nests; and he has done so. Added taxation of the land, in the shape of heavy levies upon free- hold ground-rents in London and other great cities and a super-tax on large in- comes are the resorts which the Chan- cellor has adopted. This plan has raised, in anticipation, the cry of “confiscation.” It might, indeed, be the case that such taxes would bear very heavily, perhaps inequitably, upon the great landlords and the very rich. But theré would be a kind of retributive jus- tice in making them shoulder the new burdens, because they have been chiefly responsible for the increase of those burdens. By their insensate talk of war and artificial clamor for Dreadnoughts without end, they have pushed up the naval estimates abnormally, and it is only just that they should be made to foot a good share of the bills. If Lloyd- George could only find a way to make bellicose editors, too, put their hands in their pockets to pay for the folly which they have helped to blew so large, his justice would be fairly poetic. Viewed purely as a measure of finance, the new English budget is capa- 455 ble and business-like. It goes straight to the point of raising the needed mo- ney by the necessary taxes. There is no artful attempt to conceal from the people the burdens which their repre sentatives have voted that they shall bear. The Chancellor of the Exche- quer simply comes forward remorseless as fate, to say to the House of Com- mons, and to the nation: “Since you have decided to spend such and such sums of money, I will show you how the uttermost farthing is to be got out It is business applied to states- manship. While the German govern- ment has struggled for months in vain to get through the Reichstag a tax-law to make income equal expenditures; while at Washington our system of tax- ation is left to guess-work and intrigue, with hugger-mugger the probable result, the English cling to their old successful way of making a responsible Ministry draw up a budget in which a tax is laid for every penny spent. Whatever else may be said of this, it is efficient finance. Politically, the budget marks for the Liberals a decided lurch in the direction of the Radicals and the Labor party. The very taxes which make the City of London cry out in rage, fill the work- ing classes and the Socialists with glee. To get at accumulated wealth by dis- criminating and depleting taxes, has long been their dream; and Mr. Lloyd- George has now made its realization seem much nearer. When we add that he has provided for labor ex- changes, after the French model, and has outlined a scheme of state insurance of workingmen against lack of employ- ment, we can see how strong a bid is made for the labor vote. With the La- bor party split, as it now is, the Lib- erals may win some votes and retain some seats, as a consequence of their Radical budget. Yet their defeat is written in the stars, next year, or as soon as they step out or are turned out of office. They will have alarmed and alienated so many of their wealthy and middle-class followers that, as the drift of the bye-elections shows almost be- yond a peradventure, the Conservatives will easily come back to power in the next general election. Thereupon, ac- cording to all precedent, all the Socialis- tic legislation of the Liberals will be, not repealed, but retained and extended by the Tories! It was so with the Irish land law, with the Harcourt graduated of you.”
Page 10
ee eee —— ee / a 456 inheritance tax, and there is no reason to doubt that it will be so as well with Lloyd-George’s taxes on wealth and fa- vors to labor. Mr. Balfour will be able to reconcile his opposition to them when out of office with his adoption of them when in power. “There were grave ob- jections to these measures, but now that they are enacted, and the people are used to them, and even seem to like them, it is not expedient to expunge them.” RESEARCH AND RESULTS. The trustees of the Carnegie Trust, at their annual meeting held in London recently, discussed at some length the results of the effort to encourage orig- inal research in the universities of Scot- land. Mr. Balfour, for example, was amazed to find that the number of fail- ures was so small. It was not an easy task, he declared, to catch the right man, and the number of men worth catching was not very large. He dl- vided these eligible persons into two classes: those who had the gift and ambition, but not “the rare and over- mastering” desire — forces one into this career. Such m must be taken early before they are a\sorbed in the necessary occupa’ ‘ns of\life. There was also a higher ss, “those who seem born for researe!:\’ to whom the penetration of the secreis of nature and history seems an overwhelming pas- sion, from which they are scarcely to be diverted To these men, said Mr. Balfour, it was all important, “not for the sake of the men but for the sake of the community, that they should have a chance of devoting their talents to that great work for which God undoubtedly intended them.” Mr. Balfour thus emphasized an idea to which Americans have hitherto paid but little attention. Before the Carnegie Institution of Washington was estab- lished, there was scarcely any organized effort to promote research. A few of our better equipped universities main- tained chairs of research, and a few others tried to afford some leisure to those teachers who displayed special aptitude in this line; but with a grow- ing population pressing hard on our educational resources, most colleges have been forced to lay on their facul- ties too heavy a burden of instruction. An occasional professor has deliberately slighted his classes in order to do work The Nation. [ Vol. 88, No. 2288 which has seemed more important, but such cases are exceptional. The aver- age professor has stuck doggedly to his assigned tasks and relinquished one am- bition after another, till failing strength has forced upon him the bitter truth that his magnum opus, his monument more enduring than bronze, has been a dream. Such failures contain a large element of the tragic; for, in propor- tion as the aim has been high, so must the consciousness of failure be galling. And this is one reason why every col- lege faculty contains men who carry the scars of the balked and the disappoint- ed. In many instances, doubtless, these men might have coree far short of suc cess even had they been offered an op- portunity to become authors, to edit im- portant historical documents, or to pen- etrate the secrets of nature; but most of them can justly complain that they have never had a fair chance. The effect on our institutions of high- er learning has also been depressing. The tendency has been to stiffen the tra- ditions of intellectual mediocrity which are already too strong, to maintain a faculty which is content merely to go through the motions of teaching with- out actually inspiring our youth. We would not be thought to urge a faculty made up of investigators, for successful investigators may be poor teachers, espe- cially of young undergraduates; but a faculty which contains few or no men of eager and inquiring mind inevitably stagnates. In far too many of our small colleges, East and West, teachers and students are doing nothing but whirl round in their squirrel-cages, with im- mense outward activity, but no actual progress. We complain that our under- graduates are absorbed in athletics, in social affairs, and in everything but study. Such diversions offer a peculiar- ly strong temptation to youth, and the only way to draw the undergraduate in the other direction is to make study it- self attractive. This is not the same thing as making courses slipshod and easy; quite the contrary. The real meth- od is to rouse ambition, to quicken, to energize; and for this task men of force and ambition are needed, men who, while they discharge their daily duties faithfully, still look forward and aspire to something beyond the routine of the classroom, and thus give their pupils an outlook into the world that lies outside the shaded streets of the college town. We have been using the words “re- search” and “investigation,” but they are too narrow in scope. In all fields, much interesting and stimulating work is always to be done that cannot, strictly speaking, extend the boundaries of our knowledge. In the natural sci- ences, there must be constant reorgan- ization of data, and restatement of principles in the light of new experi- mentation—constant popularizing, not vulgarizing, of the results obtained in our laboratories. This, which was what Huxley undertook, is no dry mechani- cal process, but a challenge to the most ingenious of minds, a sure means of intellectual development. And in his- tory and economics, in philosophy, and literature in all its branches, the same labor awaits the skilled hand. The clas- sics of all tongues must be edited and criticised from the point of view of men and women of to-day, reinterpret- ed in the terms of modern speech. His- tory must be rewritten for every gener- ation. To these important undertakings, America could and would lend far more help, to the great advantage of the cause of education and our higher life generally, if we could entertain a larger conception of the function of a college. THE NEW STAGE OF PRAGMATISM. I. It is one of the difficulties of coping with a philosophy of the flux, that no sooner have you come to grips with it than it flows into another form and eludes your grasp. To read the bold frontal attacks of Messrs. Schinz and Pratt* and then tu find that the ad- versary in a simultaneous publication; has already slipped to one side, is to recall the Homeric wrestling match with the wily old man of the sea. No doubt he is Proteus still, and the contest is with the same foe, but the weapons must be changed and the grip altered. The chief concern of Professor Schinz is to lay bare the social milieu out of which Pragmatism has grown, and his conclu- sions touch the problem of democracy and aristocracy. His criticism of Amer- ican life and literature from this point of view is extraordinarily keen. Pro- fessor Pratt is concerned more with the religious outcome of the movement *Anti-Pragmatisme. Par Albert Schinz, Pro- fesseur A l'Université de Bryn Mawr. Paris: Félix Alcan. What is Pragmatism? By James Bissett Pratt, Assistant Professor of Philosophy in Williams Col- lege. New York: The Macmillan Co. tA Pluralistic Universe: Hibbert Lectures at Manchester College on the Present Situation in Philosophy. By William James. New York: Long- mans, Green, & Co.
Page 11
The Nation. 457 than with its social meaning. The new philosophy is to him a part of the scien- tific tendency of thought which, in the words of a distinguished biologist, de- scribes the Moral Imperative as a “psychic correlate of a reflective, cere- bro-spinal, ideo-motor process, the ef- ferent end of which is organized into motor tracts coérdinated for a specific action.” Whereto Mr. Pratt remarks gravely that this method “has pressed its splendidly useful and illuminating formule too far, it has attempted to sim- plify too much, and in doing so it has become somewhat narrow, somewhat blind, and somewhat unempirical.” And he adds: “To my thinking, the pendu- lum has now swung too far in the anti- intellectualistic direction.” Both writ- ers make easy work with the equivoca- tions of Mr. James’s last book on “Prag- matism.” And indeed it needs no pro- found study to see the weak joints in a logic which undertakes to determine the inmost nature of things by what we regard as pragmatically useful in our own lives, and to prove that truth is actually created by what we think it expedient to believe. There is something like the hilarity of sport in dragging out the inconsis- tencies, if not insincerities, of a phil- osopher who has tried to defend ration- ally a system which is professedly an attack on rationalism. For just that, and nothing more, is Pragmatism. It is easy to show that such a philosopher ought, so far as the correspondence of logic and reality goes, to be a complete skeptic. Well and good. But what will you do if, before the ink is fairly dry on your book, this Proteus of the lec- ture hall is before the world with a re- cantation of his errors and a frank re- treat to just such logical skepticism as you denounced him for not confessing. In one sense, Professor James’s Hibbert Lectures are consistent with his past; they are in the right line of develop- ment from that temperamental impetus which by his own theory is the source of every philosophy, however he may have sloughed off various inconsisten- cies to attain this position. As a mat- ter of fact, the word Pragmatism scarce- ly occurs in these lectures, and the at- tempt at their end to tack on a theory of creating, or even discovering, truth by the “practical reason” is purely perfunc- tory. Their central point, their crisis, so to speak, is the magnificent repudia- tion of the whole process of meta- physics: I saw (he says) that philosophy had been on a false scent ever since the days of Soc- rates and Plato, that an intellectual an- swer to the intellectualist’s difficulties will never come, and that the real way out of them, far from consisting in the discovery of such an answer, consists in simply clos- ing one’s ears to the question. When con- ceptualism summons life to justify itself in conceptual terms, it is like a challenge addressed in a foreign language to some one who is absorbed in his own business; it is irrelevant to him altogether—he may let it lie unnoticed. I went thus through the “inner catastrophe”; I had lit- erally come to the end of my conceptual stock-in-trade, I was bankrupt intellectual- istically, and had to change my base. Il. To such an inner catastrophe, not un- like one of the conversions he has de- scribed so luminously in his “Varieties of Religious Experience,” he was brought after long struggling with the prob- lem of reason and covering hundreds of sheets of paper with memoranda of his self-questioning. As the worldling under the stroke of heaven forswears the world, so now he is “compelled to give up logic, fairly, squarely, and irrevoca- bly.” The apostle to him in this agony was the young sage of Paris, Henri Bergson, to whom many others, indeed, in these times of perplexity are turn- ing inquisitive eyes, and to whom Mr. James devotes one of the most brilliant of his lectures. To that lecture itself, or to G.-H. Luquet’s “Idées générales de psychologie,” the questioner must be referred who hesitates to plunge into M. Bergson’s own uncoérdinated works. Mr. James centres his exposition about the hoary and awful paradox which sets Achilles forever approaching and never overtaking a tortoise, since by the time he reaches the tortoise’s first starting- point, the tortoise has already got be- yond that starting-point to another, and so on ad infinitum, the interval between the two being endlessly subdivided but never obliterated—just as % plus 4 plus 1% may be prolonged into an infinite series without equalling unity. The solution is a statement of the absolute divorce between reason and sensuous ex- perience; the one is discrete, the other is concrete and continuous. To analyze actual experience into the terms of the intellect is simply to use words without meaning: You cannot explain [by abstract concepts] what makes any single phenomenon be or go—you merely dot out the path of appear- ances which it traverses. For you cannot make continuous being out of discontinui- ties, and your concepts are discontinuous. The stages into which you analyze a change are states, the change itself goes on between them. It lies along their intervals, inhabits what your definition fails to gather up, and thus eludes conceptual explanation alto- gether. With this sling of metaphysical ne- gation he attacks Mr. Bradley, the cham- pion of monism, or abstract idealism, or pantheism, or whatever you choose to call it; and, believe me, he makes good sport with the doughty Goliath of Ox- ford. I confess that to me monism has always been merely another word for monomania, and I have followed Mr. James’s sallies into the madhouse with a kind of gay amusement. The attempt to catch and hold the universe in a syllogism, denying thereby all our con- crete experience, all our sense of multi- plicity and change, all our knowledge of evil, denying life itself for an ab- stract unity of the reason, has been one of the tyrannous obsessions of meta- physics. Common sense might protest against monism as a madness, but com- mon sense is apt to shrivel away un- der the frown of a supercilious Rea- son, and Reason declares there shall be no contradiction in the sum of our ex- periences. The only escape is to deny the validity of reason itself as the sole criterion of reality. To this liberation Mr. James has been guided, or has at least been confirmed therein, by the new luminary of Paris, and now proclaims his gratitude. His protest against the whole school of German intellectualism will find an exultant echo in many la- boring breasts. It is in a very literal sense the “psychological moment” for such an authoritative utterance as this: The English mind, thank heaven, and the French mind, are still kept, by their aver- sion to crude technique and barbarism, closer to truth’s natural probabilities. Their literatures show fewer obvious falsities and monstrosities than that of Germany. Think of the German literature of esthetics, with the preposterousness of such an unesthetic personage as Immanuel Kant enthroned in its centre! Think of German books on Re- ligionsphilosophie, with the heart’s battles translated into conceptual jargon and made dialectic. III. Macte virtute! we cry, and toss hats into the air. There is no hope in Kant or any of his followers, for, as Mr. James rightly asserts, both wings of modern philosophy rest on intellectualist logic, “the absolutists smashing the world of sense by its means, the em- piricists smashing the absolute—for the absolute, they say, is the quintessence of all logical contradictions. Neither impugns in principle its gen- eral theoretic authority.” I, for one, am ready to follow any leader out of the Egypt of Kantian metaphysics, and I would not belittle the honor due to M. Bergson and to Mr. James as the Moses and the Aaron of this exodus. Yet a word of demur must be entered against so extreme a statement as that “ration- alism has never [before] been seriously questioned and Bergson alone has been radical.” Such an avowal rouses the suspicion that Mr. James him- self has not really looked beyond the circle drawn by the wizard of Kénigs- berg, that he too stands entranced in the illusion of the present. Sometimes as I consider with myself how this illu- sion daily more and more enthralls and impoverishes our mental life by cutting off from it all the rich experience of the past, it is as though we were at sea in a vessel, while a fog was settling upon the water, gradually, as it thick- ened, closing in upon our vision with ever narrower circle, blotting out the far-flashing lights of the horizon and
Page 12
wal | | 458 the depths of the sky, throwing a pall upon the very waves about us, until we move forward through a sullen obscur- ity, unaware of any other traveller upon that sea, save when through the fog the sound of a threatening alarm beats upon the ear. Mr. James, who has pondered s0 well Bergson’s analysis of the indi- vidual consciousness as a summing up of all the past, should have seen the application of the same definition to the general consciousness of mankind. He should have seen that Bergson’s rejec- tion of reason as the arbiter of reality Was no new thing, but the old insight re-defined in the terms of modern psy- chology. Had he been more completely freed from the vicious circle of the present, he would have known that in denouncing Platonism as the type and source of rationalistic metaphysics, he had in mind not the Greek Plato, but a Plato viewed through Teutonic spec- tacles. The doctrine of reminiscence, and indeed of ideas themselves if prop- erly understood, should have taught him that Plato’s instrument of truth was an intuition far closer to the facts of con- sciousness than is any canon of discrete logic, and at one with the faculty of religious insight wherever and when- ever this is found. The Neo-Platonists developed this method—while denuding it of vitality, making it “thin,” as Mr. James would say—in their d'stinction between intelligence (vois) and the non-intelligible One or the First Good. Henry More, in his tantalizing obscure rhymes, sought to unite this higher skepticism with Christian theology, as, for instance, in his “L'fe of the Soul” (ii, 98): How then, said Graco, is the spirit kaown If not by reason? To this I replied, Only the spirit can the spirit own But this, said he, is back again to slide And in an idle Circle round to ride Why so, said I, is not light seen by light? Straight Graculo did skilfully divide All knowledge into sense and reason right. Be ‘t so, said I, Don Graco, what's this reason’s might? If then, said he, the spirit may not be Right reason, surely we must deem it sense. Yes, sense it is, this was my short reply. And Pascal meant the same thing when he declared that “there is nothing so conformable to reason as th's disavowal of reason,” and that “the heart has its reasons, which the reason does not know.” To this extent the insight of faith is in agreement with the common- sense of the street, in so far as to both the meaning of the world is given by immediate experience rather than by any metaphysical system; and they are both in agreement with the compleie skeptic in so far as they all hold their judgment in a state of suspension (é¢moxj. toward the pretensions of rea son to act as the final arbiter of reality: “The truth is Pyrrhonism,” said Pascal. In this contrast to rationalism, saint The Nation. and man of the world and skeptic are at one: they diverge on other lines. It has seemed worth while to point, in passing, to this kinship of Bergson’s psychological superrationalism with the constant attitude of faith, because the aspect of Mr. James’s work which most deserves censure is the encouragement afforded therein to the particular van- ity of our age—a smart contempora- neity. He should have pondered the scope of his own pregnant sentence: “If we do not feel both past and present in one field of feeling, we feel them not at all.” IV. With this reserve, we may regard the call from metaphysics to a philosophy of immediate experience as altogether wholesome. Abstract reason is not in its own field a false thing, nor is it without indispensable usefulness in the application of experience to life; never- theless, not through it shall we come into intimate touch with reality, but through life itself; the truth for us is not what we have defined logically, but what we actually fee] and will. It does not follow, however, that in accepting heartily this method we must equally accept Mr. James's statement of the rela- tive values of what he reports as ob- tained by the method; we may even suspect that in his evaluation he slips into the very error from which he is so eager to save us. Consciousness, he says, is not discrete, or divided into dis- continuous moments, as it is presented to us by the reason, but is continuous; nor has it any conformity with the static void of monism. Time and change are of its essence, and if we wish to know reality we must “dive back into the flux itself.” His cry is like the com- mand of Faust to leave the musty cell and throw one’s self into the stream of the world—Hinaus ins Freie! There is a splendid exhilaration in the call. There is grave irony as well as stirring exhortation in Mr. James’s personal ap- peal to his audience: If Oxford men could be ignorant of any- thing, it might almost seem that they had remained ignorant of the great empirical movement towards a pluralistic panpsychic view of the universe, into which our own generation has been drawn, and which threatens to short-circuit their methods {of monistic dogmatism] entirely and be- come their religious rival un'ess they are willing to make themselves its allies. Yet, wedded as they seem to be to the logical machinery and technical apparatus of ab- solutism, I cannot but believe that their fidelity to the religious ideal in general is deeper still. Let empiricism once become associated with religion, as hither- to, through some strange misunderstand- ing, it has been associated with irreligion, and I believe that a new era of religion as well as of philosophy will be ready to begin. That great awakening of a new popular interest in philosophy, which is so striking a phenomenon at the present day [Vol. 88, No. 2288 in all countries, is undoubtedly due in part to religious demands. A pluralistic panpsychic view of the universe. That is to say: as our only knowledge is experience and our ex- perience is an inner consciousness flow- ing with ceaseless change about end- lessly differing sensations presented to it from without, so the truth of the world for us is not monism, but plural- ism. We are du réel dans le réel, but this reality is an infinite group of in- teracting, interpenetrating forces, over which no absolute law can be found to govern. And as these forces, like our states of consciousness, are in a con- stant mutation, so, like ourselves, they may very well be, in part at least, other streams of consciousness, meeting and embracing and repelling one another. How else, indeed, can they have any meaning or reality to us? The universe may thus be panpsychic, and one of the most interesting of Mr. James’s lectures is a revival of Fechner’s animism, with his vision of the world-soul enveloping and nourishing the souls of men. For the proof of such a theory Mr. James goes to what he deems the facts of ex- perience: In a word, the believer is continuous, to bis own consciousness, at any rate, with a wider self from which saving experiences flow in. Those who have such experiences distinctly enough and often enough to live in the light of them remain quite unmoved by criticism, from whatever quarter it may come, be it academic or scientific, or be it merely the voice of logical common sense. They have had their vision and they know— that is enough—that we inhabit an in- visible spiritual environment from which help comes, our soul being mysteriously one with a larger soul whose instruments we are. By such steps the pragmatist, now rath- er choosing to be called the radical em- piricist, arrives at the belief in a deity, who is by no means the static timeless absolute of the monist, with its foreign- ness from all things human, but a mighty God above other gods, “having an environment, being in time, and working out a history just like our- selves.” V. It is a seductive theory and has at least that quality of “thickness” which Mr. James, with his genius for phrase- making, contrasts with the “thinness” of idealism. It is charming, but then the dog that trails always at the heels of the pragmatist will have his bark: Is it true? Somehow one cannot be quite at ease in this new Zion, and, reading M. Luquet’s analysis of Berg- sonism, I seem to divine where the trou- ble lies. ‘When we enter upon the study of psychology, says that expositor, we must begin by discarding the logic which we used in the sciences. In this field contradictories no longer exclude each other. Every state of conscious-
Page 13
The Nation. 45 May 6, 1909] ness is at once an existence and a knowl- edge, the thing known and the knower, a part and the whole. Here identity and change, past and present, are simulta- neous attributes of the same subject. And he continues: Hence we explain at once the existence and the falseness, at least relative, of the two opposed psychological doctrines called phenomenalism and spiritism. The latter sees in the ego an immutable substance which looks on with indifference at the unrolling states of consciousness; the for- mer sees in the ego only a succession, a collection of isolated states of conscious- ness, of which the first has ceased when the second is produced. This truth explains, I surmise, some- thing more than the two present modes of psychology. Is not this irreconcilable dualism of consciousness the source of the two opposing schools of philosophy, which, ever since Parmenides and Heraclitus set forth the paradox of ab- solute rest and absolute motion, unity and multiplicity, identity and change, have been at each other’s throats? Log- ic demands the rejection of a contra- dictory; and as the temperament of a man leads him to dwell on one or the other phase of his inner experience, so, if he is a metaphysician, he forthwith sets out to build a rational theory of the universe on that phase fo the ex- clusion of the other. What, at bottom, is this Pluralism of Mr. James, but the same ancient presumption of the reason which he has himself so shrewdly de- nounced. His feeling for flux and change and multiplicity is a reality, a great and desirable reality, set over against the monist’s exclusive sense of unity; but is it the whole of reality? How can one recall the innumerable witnesses of religion, or hearken to the self-revela- tion of the poets, how can one look into the mirror of one’s own life, and not perceive that the sense of some- thing immutable and undivided exists in some way side by side with the sense of everlasting flux, that there is within us some ... central peace subsisting at the heart Of endless agitation? Mr. James does, indeed, throw out hints that he has caught the meaning of this dualistic reality of experience, but, like other philosophers, he soon cowers at the imperious command of reason, and tries to hide the nature of his own sub- mission to one horn of the dilemma by merriment over the writhing of Mr. Bradley on the other; meanwhile com- mon sense stands like das Weltkind in der Mitte. And if the Pluralism of Mr. James is mo true substitute for dualism, but a rejection of the one for the many, so his Panpsychism commits the other er- ror of metaphysics in translating a fact of inner experience into a theory of the universe at large. The comfortable be- lief in these world-souls and commin- gled spirits and finite Jehovahs is even a projection of our consciousness of per- sonal change into the void, just as the monist’s absolute abstraction is born of his consciousness of personal unity. No doubt we are not alone in the universe. Forces beat upon us from every side and are as really existent to us as ourselves: their influence upon ourselves we know, but their own secret name and nature we have not yet heard —not from Mr. James, or Mr. Bradley, or another. Until that prophet has ap- peared, I do not see what better thing we can do than to hold our judgment in a state of complete skepticism, or suspension, in regard to the correspond- ence of our inner experience with the world at large, neither affirming nor denying; while we accept honestly the dualism of consciousness as the illogical fact. Reason, I should suppose, may be our guide in determining the relative values to us of our opposed phases of consciousness. The will may be no Will to Believe—for we know—but a power to make of this choice of values the motive of contemplative and prac- tical life. And, if I have read correctly the lesson of the past and of the pres- ent, faith, I dare avow, is something that strikes deeper than the mythol- ogies of religion, or the imaginings of a fevered Pragmatism; it is the voice from our own centre of calm, asserting through all the noise of contradiction: “I am the better self and the higher value, the stronger life and the finer joy.” To many who have looked stead- fastly into the meaning of their inner life, that “wider self from which saving experiences flow in” will seem to be in- deed a wider self rather than any en- vironment of ghosts; and they will feel that in this belief they have a firmer as- surance of reality than is offered to them by the new mythology of Prag- matism or Panpsychic Pluralism. They will think that John Woolman uttered the truth of dualism and of religion when he said: “The necessity of an in- ward stillness hath appeared clear to my mind; in true silence strength is re- newed.” P. E. M. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. In 1906 the directors of the Virginia State Library made provision for the preparation of a Bibliography of Virginia. The period first taken up was Colonial Virginia and the report of the bibliographer, William Clayton-Torrence, covering the period 1607 to 1754, has just been printed. This is sent out as a pamphlet with the modest title “A Trial Bibliography,” but an examination of the 154 pages, describing 219 books, pam- phiets, and broadsides shows it to be a careful, accurate, and scholarly piece of work, hard to improve upon. The collations are moderately full; copies are located, so far as possible, in several public libraries, and references are given to earlier biblio- graphical works. Reprints are also referred to, and references are made to certain en- tries in the Stationers’ Registers which, if ever printed, are not now known to exist. When we consider how many of the known pamphlets exist in one or two or three ex- amples only it would be folly to say that those which have not been found were never printed. The historical, biographical, and bibliographical notes appended to many titles are especially interesting. The “Bib- liography” as now printed ends with 1754. A note at the end says that descriptions of 230 additional titles, bringing the record down to 1776, had been prepared and that by a fire in the printing office the manuscript was destroyed. There is one early broad- side, important because it is so early, which Mr. Clayton-Torrence seems to have overlooked and of which there is a copy in the British Museum, described as fol- lows in the Fourth Series of William Carew Hazlitt’s “Collections and Notes” (1903): Fort the Plantation in Virginia. Or Nova Britannia. London: Printed by John Windet. 1609. A broadside. B.M. An advertisement of an intended and ap- proaching Voyage thither, and an invitation and encouragement to practical emigrants. The late Dr. Alexander Brown discovered a transcript of this document in the Span- ish archives, but was unable to locatu a printed copy. ° On May 12, 13, and 14 the Anderson Auc- tion Co. of this city will sell the library of Mrs. Constance C. Poor of Tuxedo Park. The collection is chiefly notable for books on gardening and botany. Among the older works are Dodoen’s ‘“‘Newe Herball’”’ (1578), Cook’s “Manner of Raising, Ordering, and Improving Forest Trees” (1676), Cotton’s “Planter’s Manual” (1675), Gervase Mark- ham’s “Cheape and good Husbandry” (1631), Barnaby Googe’s “Art and Trade of Hus- bandry” (1614). Important modern vol- umes are Sowerby’s “English Botany,” 13 vols.; Michaux’s ‘‘North American Sylva,” 3 vols.; Sargent’s “Silva of North America,” 3 vols.; Curtis’s Botanical Magazine, 1787 to 1867, 93 vols.; and Paxton’s Magazine of Botany, 1843 to 1849, 16 vols. A collection of fifteen autograph letters of Carlyle; Chaucer’s Works, Kele’s undated edition, also Islip’s edition of 1602; and the Kelms- cott Press Shakespeare, are other notable lots. On May 11, 12, and 13 the Merwin-Clay- ton Sales Co. of this city will offer the li- braries of Dr. E. C. Williams of Chicago and R. N, Oakman, jr., of Brooklyn. Among the items are the first edition of Pope’s translation of the Iliad (1715-20), with au- tograph receipt for the first payment, sign- ed by Pope, inserted; Burns's “Correspon- dence with Clarinda” (1843), first edition; the first portion of the Catalogue of Robert Hoe’s library, Early English Books, 5 vols.; and books from the Kelmscott Press. On May 12 and 13 C. F. Libbie & Co. of Boston sell the library and autograph col- lection of Franklin Webster Smith of Wash- ington. Extra illustrated copies of Better- ton’s “History of the English Stage,” and Charles James Fox’s “History of the Early Part of the Reign of James the Second”; and a set of the Dunlap Society Publications are worthy of mention. On May 10 and 11 Stan. V. Henkels will sell at Freeman’s Auction Rooms in Phila- delphia the library of the late John McAl- lister, jr., including a long series of Phil- adelphia directories, American almanacs and magazines, and a large collection of
Page 14
460 pamphlets extending from colonial times to the civil war. As addenda, to be sold at twelve o’clock Tuesday, are eight New Eng- land pamphlets: Underhill’s “Newes from America” (1638), lacking plan; Wood's “New England’s Prospect” (1639), lacking map; and six of the very rare tracts by John El- fot telling of the conversion of the New England Indians, with the following titles: “New England's First Fruits” (1643), as usual without the errata leaf; “The Day- Breaking, if not the Sun-Rising of the Gos- pel with the Indians in New England” (1647); “The Clear Sunshine of the Gospel breaking forth up on the Indians in New England” (1648); “The Glorious Progress of the Gospel amongst the Indians in New England” (1649); “Strength out of Weakness or a Glorious Manifestation of the Further Progress of the Gospel among the Indians in New England” (1652); and “Tears of Repentance; or a Further Narrative of the Progress of the Gospel” (1653). A most remarkable Caxton volume will be included in Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge’s sale of May 20 and 21. It is made up of five productions of Caxton’s press: (1) “The Mirrour of the Worlde’’ (1481), (2) “Dictes or Sayings of the Philosophers” (1478), (3-4) “Cicero’s ‘De Senectute’ and ‘De Amicitia’ (probably published together, 1481), and (5) “The Boke named Cordyale” (1479). The volume is in old oak boards, probably Caxton’s original binding, and the pieces are all perfect and in fine condition. The book was recently discovered in an old Manor House in the North of England. Among other books included in the same sale are “Robinson Crusoe” (1719), 2 vols., first editions; Hakluyt’s “Principal Naviga- tions, Voyages, and Discoveries” (1589); Quarles’s “Emblemes” (1635), first edition; Smith’s “Generall Historie of Virginia” (1682), with the “True Travels” (1630); and several first editions of Tennyson, presen- tation copies to Sarah Hayword. IN MEMORY OF SWINBURNE. (Vale, vale, in @eternum, vale!) L April whispers—“Canst thou, too, die, Lover of life and lover of mine?” April, queen over earth and sky, Yearns, and her trembling shine: Master in song, good-bye, good-bye, Down to the dim sea-line. lashes II, “This is my singing season,” he cried, “April, what sweet new song do you bring?” April came and knelt at his side Breathing a song too great to sing— Death!—and the dark cage-door swung wide: Seaward the soul took wing. III. Sleep, on the breast of thine old-world lover, Sleep, by thy “fair green-girdled” sea! — —E = The Nation. [Vol. 88, No. 2288 There shall thy soul with the sea-birds hover, Free of the deep as their wings are free, Free; for the grave-flowers only cover This, the dark cage of thee. IV. Thee, the storm-bird, nightingale-souled, Brother of Sappho, the seas reclaim! Age upon age have the great waves rolled Mad with her music,fierce and a-flame; Thee, thee too, shall their glory enfold Lit with thy snow-winged fame. ¥. Back thro’ the years fleets the sea-bird’s wing: Sappho, of old time, once,—ah, hark! So did he love her of old and sing! Listen, he flies to her, back thro’ the dark! Sappho, of old time, once /—Yea, Spring Calls him home to her, hark! VI. Sappho, long since, in the years far sped, Sappho, I loved thee! Did I not seem Fosterling only of earth? I have fied, Fled to thee, sister. Time is a dream! Shelley is here with us! Death lies dead! Ah, how the bright waves gleam. VII. Wide was the cage-door, idly swinging, April touched me and whispered “Come”: Out and away to the great deep winging, Sister, I flashed to thee over the foam; Out to the sea of Eternity, singing “Mother, thy child comes home.” VIII, Ah, but how shall we welcome May Here where the wing of song droops low, Here by the last green swinging spray Brushed by the sea-bird’s wings of snow, We that gazed on his glorious way Out where the great winds blow? IX. April whispers—“Canst thou, too, die, Lover of life and lover of mine?” April, conquering earth and sky, Yearns, and her trembling lashes shine: Master in song, good-bye, good-bye, Down to the dim sea-line. Atrrep Noyes. Ewburst, Rottingdean, Sussex, England. Correspondence. TENNYSON’S REVISIONS OF HIS POEMS, TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The publication of the new Evers- ley Edition of Tennyson has called atten- tion to many variant readings of the poems and reminds me of one that I discovered in the first American (1859) edition of the first four “Idylls of the King” (“Bnid,” “Vivien,” “Elaine,” and “Guinevere,” as they were then entitled), which was print- ed from advance sheets, sent from England. Of two of these (“Enid” and “Vivien’’) six “trial copies,” as the reader may know, had been printed in 1857, with the title, “Enid and Nimué; the True and _ the False,” only one of which is said to have survived—now in the British Museum, There is also a volume of proof-sheets at South Kensington, with the title, “The True and the False; Four Idylls of the King,” dated 1859. It contains the poems, which, after further revision, were published in July of that year. In the authorized American edition (1859) a passage in “Vivien” (lines 148-151) reads thus: She loathed the knights, and ever seem’d to hear Their laughing comment when her name was pamed. For once, when Arthur, walking all alone, Vexed at a rumor rife about the Queen, Had met her, etc. This reading is found nowhere else, and the poet must have changed it before the London edition of 1859 was printed. There it reads: She hated all the knights, and heard in thought Their lavish comment when her name was named. For once, when Arthur walking all alone, Vext at a rumour rife about the Queen, Had met her, etc. Later the last lines were changed to the present text: Vext at a rumour issued from herself Of some corruption crept among his knights, Had met her, etc. The 1857 reading was: She hated all the knights because she deem’d They wink’d and jested when her name was named. For once when Arthur, walking all alone And troubled in his heart about the Queen, Had met her, etc. There are a few other slight discrepan- cies between the English and American edi- tions, not recorded by any of the com- mentators, but hardly worth mentioning here. For the most complete and accurate collation of the Hnglish editions (includ- ing the 1857 proofs), the reader may con- sult Prof. Richard Jones’s “The Growth of the Idylls of the King” (Philadelphia, 1895), in which I have detected very few omissions or inaccuracies. Apropos of the “Idylls,” there is a strange omission in the text of all the English editions, not excepting the one just edited by the present Lord Tennyson. In the “Memoir” of his father (Vol. IL, Pp. 129) we are told that in 1891 the poet, “thinking that. perhaps he had not made the real humanity of the King sufficiently clear in his epilogue” (“To the Queen’), had inserted ‘as his last correction” the line, “Ideal manhood closed in real man,” after line 37: ‘“New-old, and shadowing sense at war with soul.” The “Memoir” ap- peared in 1897, and I inserted the line in
Page 15
The Nation. May 6, 1909] = —=—==——_ the next issue of my edition of the “Idylls,” and also in the Cambridge Edition of 1898. It is probably through mere oversight that it has not appeared in the English editions printed since 1891. I wonder if any reader has noticed that in one edition of the poems (I think only one, in 1897), Lord Tennyson included the poem entitled “Kate,” first printed in 1833, but suppressed until after the poet’s death. Apparently, on second thought, he decided to add nothing to the collected works as last arranged by his father. Morton Luce (“Handbook of Tennyson's Works,” 1895), and R. H. Shepherd (“Bibliography of Tennyson,” 1896; printed for subscribers only), neither of whom is invariably accurate, mention six short poems omitted in the collected editions. I have found three of these, and have added them to the successive issues of the Cambridge Edition; but the others (not referred to in the “Memoir”) I have not been able to trace. They are “a stanza in the volume of his poems presented to the Princess Louise of Schleswig-Holstein by the nurses of England; lines on the chris- tening of the daughter of the Duchess of Fife; and lines to the memory of J. R. Lowell.” Can any reader of the Nation help me in finding them? The lines on Lowell were probably reprinted here, but I have hunted for them in vain during the last ten years. It is not generally known that Edward Lear made some two hundred drawings il- lustrating many of MTennyson’s. earlier poems. No English publisher was willing to incur the expense of reproducing them; but in 1889 a few of them were used in an edition of three poems—‘Lines to E. L. on his Travels in Greece,” “To a Daisy,” and “The Palace of Art”’—of which only one hundred numbered copies were published (London: Boussod, Valador & Co.), all sign- ed by the poet, with a special introduction from his pen. Later the entire set was bought by Dana Estes of Boston, and as many of them as could well be used for the purpose were copied by photogravure for the de luge edition of Tennyson (12 vols., limited to 1,000 copies), which I edited (1895- 98). This edition had been planned several years earlier with the approval of the poet and his son, who assisted in the selection of the illustrations (of which a dozen or more were connected with single poems in some instances), and gave me other valu- able help in the work. These drawings by Lear are not mentioned in the “Memoir” or any other book or article about the Tennysons that I have seen, and I was sur- prised to find no allusion to them in the recent “Letters of Edward Lear.” Neither have I met with any mention of the large painting by Lear which hangs in the hall of Tennyson’s summer residence at Ald- worth. It illustrates one of the stanzas in “The Palace of Art” which describe tapestry pictures so graphically: One seem’d all dark and red—a tract of sand, And some one pacing there alone, Who paced forever in a glimmering land, Lit with a low large moon. The picture is “‘all dark and red,” with the full moon shining red through the twilight haze of the horizon; a solitary man striding across the foreground, and nothing else ex- cept a towering rock near the left side. The stanza is inscribed on the frame below. The painting was evidently hung in the broad, well-lighted hall, extending from the front to the rear of the mansion, because it was too large for the walls of any room. I am no connoisseur of painting, but the picture interested me greatly, and the more each time I saw it. The fifteen stanzas in the poem describing as many tapestries had always impressed me as remarkable exam- ples of word-painting. Some of them have more of detail than this one—particularly that delineating a volcanic landscape: And one, a foreground black with stones and slags, Beyond, a line of heights, and higher All barr’d with long white cloud the scornful crags, And highest, snow and fire—— a four-fold view of plain, hill, and moun- tain, ending with the trisyllabic “snow and fire’’—active volcanoes towering above the snow-line, painted no less vividly than con- cisely. This poem, as the reader knows, was first printed in the volume of 1832 (published in the winter of that year, but dated 1833), but some of these pictures were much altered in 1842, and some were omit- ted. The two quoted here were then as follows: Some were all dark and red, a glimmering land Lit with a low round moon, Among brown rocks a man upon the sand Went weeping all alone. One seemed a foreground black with stones and slags, Below sunsmitten icy spires Rose striped with long white cloud the scornful crags, Deep-trenched with thunderfires. Throughout the book compound words gen- erally omit the hyphen, as here. Two of the omitted stanzas may be added, as the book is in no American public or college library (Boston and Cambridge not except- ed) that I know of: Or Venus in a snowy shell alone, Deepshadowed in the glassy brine, Moonlike glowed double on the blue, and shone A naked shape divine. Or blue-eyed Kriembilt from a craggy hold, Athwart the lightgreen rows of vine, Pour’d blazing hoards of Nibelungen gold, Down to the guify Rhine. W. J. ROLFS. Cambridge, Mass., April 28. A WORD ABOUT CARDELIUS. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Your correspondent’s query in your issue of April 1 about the writings of Car- delius interests me, and I am glad to be able to inform him of the probable source of the quotation he has seen—though who could have taken the pains to translate even a slight portion of this little-known writer interests me—and I would in turn beg to know how the extract referred to may be obtained. John or Joachim Cardelius was one of the most learned writers of the sixteenth century. He was a native of a small town in Franconia and son of a physician who is reputed never to have taken physic or to have been bled. At the age of ten our writer was graduated by his teacher as knowing more than he did; and thereafter the pupil succeeded to the master’s per- quisites. He had a peculiar affection for the classics, was a humanist in everything but his humanity, and wrote a vast quan- tity of Latin verses, dealing chiefly with the delights of learning, of which he was entitled to speak, and of marriage, of which he could have known nothing, since he is reputed never to have entered wed- lock. One of his works best known in his day is on the virtues of garlic, another on the spread of polite literature among the peasant classes, and a third on the dis- eases that affect bookworms. Singly his works are very rare—rarissima—as is the collected edition also, printed by Mauretius and only mentioned, so far as I know, by Euges in his “Icon illustrium Virorum,” j where our writer is spoken of as follows: Eo provectus est Eruditionis, ut communi Doctorum omnium consensu, peritiorem Lingue Greece neminem, in Latina vero Lingua disertiores perpaucos, exactiorem autem nullum scriptorem habuerit Germa- nia, sicut plurima ipsius monumenta tes- tantur. ROBERT RESTIEAUX. New York, April 15. PLAGIARISM. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Prof. T. M. Parrott opens his in- teresting communication in the Nation of April 15 by the somewhat wide generaliza- tion that “the idea that the first, if not the sole, duty of an author is to be original at all costs is distinctly modern. The very word ‘plagiarism’ was unknown to the Elizabethans.” One of Professor Parrott’s examples is Jénson. In Jonson’s works (ed. of 1640) is an “Epigram to Proule the Plagiary”’: Forbeare to tempt me Proule, I will not show A line unto thee, till the world it know; Or that I have by two good sufficient men, To be the wealthy witnesse of my pen, etc. This seems to show that Jonson knew the thing—when he saw it in another. Quite a little anthology might be adduced, in fact, from Jonson, and other Elizabethans, to show that—under such conditions—plagiar- ism was one of those airy nothings in- cluded in poetical nomenclature. Antedating the Elizabethans, middle age literature is full of the literary scandals of authors Whom the lore of centuries, plus a hundred fights, Taught no great respect for one another’s rights. The lore of centuries indeed. Horace dis- cusses the practice; Plutarch repro- bates an instance of it in Epicurus (7), and Professor Parrott well shows that the Eliz- abethans knew their classics. The Blizabethans, under the mellowing action of time, seem very fine people in their way, but “Victoria has thieves as good.” Why Professor Parrott’s unde- served slur on the “over-scrupulousness” of modern writers? ‘Were it not invidious to select from such abundance of material, one might well adduce modern authors who could give spades and trumps to Alcyonius himself, who was accused of having burn- ed the only known copy of Cicero on Glory that his own might not suffer by the dis- covery of his borrowings therefrom. BUNFORD SAMUEL... Philadelphia, April 27. GREAT BRITAIN AND GERMANY. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: To your explanation (April 15) of the deplorable condition of the Anglo-Ger- man relations, I should like to add a word. It is undoubtedly true that between the
Page 16
4A62 ~ ae a common people of Germany and Great Bri- tain there is little if any widespread hos- tility, but undoubtedly there is consider- able acerbity between the commercial en} official classes of those nations. And the reason is not far to seek. Judging from the tone of British news- paper and magazine articles as well as speeches in Parliament, the British have viewed with complacency, or at least with- out alarm, the growth of the German army and the military supremacy of Germany in Europe. No very serious objections have been urged against German colonial ex- pansion outside of Europe. Birmingham and Manchester have felt the pinch of German competition pretty keenly, but if the peo- ple of Central and South America prefer cheaper German goods, que voulez vous? World commerce is free, and that is part of the game. “But how about the German navy?” the British public is asking. “What will it be used for?” What is the need of such a tremendous navy? Why such a startling disproportion between the size of the Ger- Man navy and the amount of German ocean- borne commerce? So long as the British mavy bas been supreme, no restrictions have been laid on foreign commerce ex- cept tariffs by the foreign countries them- selves; but, supposing the German navy ‘were supreme, would these free-trade con- ditions continue to be open to all competi- tors? Great Britain lives by foreign com- merce—it is the breath in her nostrils, the blood in her veins, the food in her mouth. She lives by manufacturing for and trad- ing with foreign countries; and it is an absolute prerequisite of her existence that there should be complete security on the ocean for her traffic and commerce. Pres- ent conditions of world-commerce demon- strate that with the British navy supreme all nations, great and small, may traverse the ocean in absolute security and un- hampered in search of markets and trade; but, judging from Germany’s commercial methods and her past economic history, is it certain that such conditions would last 4f the Germans were supreme at sea? And with changed conditions, what will become of Great Britain’s foreign commerce, and, with her foreign commerce restricted or imperilled, what becomes of Great Britain? We in the United States could manage to worry along pretty comfortably even if all of our ocean-borne commerce were shut off; but under similar conditions Great Bri- tain would die of inanition in six weeks. These are some of the problems agitating the British public at present. Of course, it may be that the Kaiser is laying down new Dreadnoughts merely in a spirit of facetiousness, and the feverish ac- tivity of German naval ship yards is all a huge joke. If so, the most excruciating part of the joke lies in the fact that it geems as if Germany in 1912 would have more Dreadnoughts in her navy than Great Britain. Add to this that Austria, Ger- many's ally, has taken to building Dread- noughts, that the Russian navy is a minus quantity, that the French navy according to recent revelations is unfit—and the joke becomes positively killing. Meanwhile, Germany placidly assures Great Britain of her earnest desire for peace. According to our humorists Englishmen are slow to see & joke of any sort, and clearly Anglo-Ger- SS The Nation. man diplomacy has a large task ahead of itself to convince the British public that there is nothing serious in the present German naval programme. E. L. C. MORSE. Chicago, April 19. A CORRECTION. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: In the interests of accuracy kindly allow me to correct an error into which Prof. Arthur W. Goodspeed fell, in his ac- count, in your issue of April 29, of the recent meeting of the American Philosophi- cal Society at Philadelphia. Prof. Christian Hiilsen, secretary of the German Archgolo- gical Institute in Rome, is credited by many of us as being the greatest among Roman topographers of the present day; but he is a German, and I’Italia faré da se. The gentleman who “has been in charge of the excavations of the Forum in Rome,” as well as of other things, is Commendatore Giacomo Boni, who should not be deprived of any of his well-deserved credit, even in the popular mind. E. T. M. University of Chicago, May 1. Longmans, Green, & Co. have ready for early publication, “Five Months in the Himalaya,” by A. L. Mumm, formerly sec- retary of the Alpine Club; and “The Basis of Ascendancy,”’ by Edgar Gardner Murphy. The Yale Publishing Association has in press “The Journal of an Expedition Across Venezuela and Colombia, 1906-1907,” by Dr. Hiram Bingham. The author gives the results of explorations made by him over the route traversed by Bolivar in the celebrated march of 1819 and on the battle- fields of Boyaca and Carabobo. Next autumn A. C. McClurg & Co. will give us two books of political memoirs, one “The Diary of James K. Polk,” the other Adlai E. Stevenson’s “Something of Men I Have Known.” Polk’s Diary was used by Professor Garrison in writing the seventeenth volume of “The American Na- tion,” and James Schouler also made use of it, but it has never been so well known as its historical value is said to warrant. The April issue of The American Journal of International Law opens with an elab- orate eighty-five page study ‘by Alejan- dro Alvarez, Councillor of the Chilian For- eign Office, “Latin America and Interna- tional Law.” He finds during the entire period since allegiance to the European home governments was severed a deter- mination to foster and perpetuate the idea of Latin-American solidarity, how- ever the realization of that determina- tion may have been interrupted by con- tests between certain of the so-called re- publics. The editorial comment sets forth the exact status of our controversy with Venezuela. Due emphasis is laid on the first decision of the Central American Court of Justice, the interposition of that court in the dispute between Honduras on one side and Guatemala and San Salvador on the other, without either of the liti- gants having made a request for such ac- tion, resulting, as the editorial declares, [ Vol. 88, No. 2288 in preventing the outbreak of war. The judgment of the court is given, in a lit- eral translation. The editor also comments on a real diplomatic triumph—that of M. Isvolsky, Minister of Foreign Affairs for Russia, in proposing a mode of solving the Balkan question, which has met the approbation of Bulgaria, and of the signa- tories of the Treaty of Berlin. The de- tails of our remission of a part of China’s indemnity for damages growing out of the Boxer troubles of 1900, are also given, and the preliminaries to what is likely to be a final settlement of the Newfoundland fish- eries controversy. The Supplement presents the treaties that affect the Panama Canal. The number is noteworthy as exhibiting triumphs of diplomacy in averting the peril of war. Sturgis & Walton of this city have been brave enough to bring out a new edition, neatly printed and bound, of “The Lost Tales of Miletus,” by Sir Edward Bulwer Lytton. We should be interested to know how many readers can be found to-dey for these rhythmical experiments in rhymeless stanzas. The poems sound pretty thin when compared with the richer work of William Morris in “The Earthly Paradise.” A timely reissue for this season, when the flood of travel to Europe is beginning, is “The Playground of Europe,” by the late Sir Leslie Stephen (G. P. Putnam’s Sons). The handsome typography and binding are uniform with those of other volumes by Stephen published by the same firm. This book, as many of our readers will remem- ber, is made up of papers on Switzerland and the Alps, most of them written when this enthusiastic Alpinist was a young man. The illustrations are excellent half-tones. A fourth edition of Baedeker’s “United States, with Excursions to Mexico, Cuba, Porto Rico, and Alaska” has just been is- sued (imported by Charles Scribner’s Sons). The excursions to Cuba and Porto Rico appear for the first time in this vol- ume. There are thirty-three maps, as com- pared with twenty-five in the third edition, and forty-eight plans, as compared with thirty-five. The handbook on the United States is perhaps not so well known as those volumes of the series which treat European countries, but, like all the rest, it is crammed with useful and interesting information. Largely through the instrumentality of the graduate schools in our greater uni- versities, the history of the United States, especially during the eighteenth century, is being rewritten in monographs on par- ticular periods, districts, or movements. Of such works one of the most important which has recently appeared is Dr. E. P. Tanner’s “Province of New Jersey, 1664- 1738,” which forms Volume XXX of the Columbia University Studies in History, Economics, and Public Law. It is a monu- ment of painstaking research. Its 700 pages give us the most minute and scholarly ac- count yet produced of any colony during a similar period. Dr. Tanner seems to have exhausted ail printed and accessible manu- script material on the subject, which is pri- marily “an account of the politicai insti- tutions of New Jersey during the period of her executive union with New York.” One wonders, however, whether some light might not have been thrown on certain
Page 17
May 6, 1909] — features of the work by consulting the Journals of the Lords of Trade and Planta- tions, preserved in Philadelphia. The field covered is one of much interest, and no little difficulty, and his careful discussion of the proprietorships and the land systems of East and West Jersey will be welcomed by all who have had to do with those trou- blesome questions. By far the larger part of the study is, of course, devoted to the administrative aspects of the province. He has chapters on the Governors and their powers; the Council, its personnel, its legal position, in administration and in legisla- tion; the General Assembly and the conflict between Executive and Legislature; the judicial, financial, and militia systems; the Church of England; and concluding chap- ters on the proprietorship under royai rule. The critical apparatus, and the elaborate index, are good. Such work has much to commend it. And not the least of its uses is that some day, on the basis of these studies, we may come to a better under- standing of those political and administra- tive situations which underlay and led up to the American Revolution. Then we may hope to have adequate histories of that most important event. A formula book of English official his- torical documents is in process of publi- cation by the Cambridge University Press under the editorship of Hubert Hall of the Public Record Office. Mr. Hall originally planned this collection as an appendix to his “Studies in English Official Historical Documents,” but as the work increased in bulk, he finally decided to issue it as a separate publication. The first volume, which has now appeared, contains diplo- matic documents, 225 in number, dating from the eighth to the nineteenth centuries. They are classified in groups and in some instances, for example the nine instru- ments illustrating the passage of the Con- necticut charter through the seals, form a continuous series. The documents were transcribed by the seven members of Mr. Hall’s seminar in the London School of Economics, Mr. Hall selecting the speci- mens and assuming all the responsibilities of editorship. The work is admirably done and its usefulness is beyond dispute. Th only previous “Formulare Anglicanum” is that of Thomas Madox issued in 1702, a col- lection almost entirely legal in character and much more limited in scope. Mr. Hall proposes to issue a second volume to con- tain formulas of surveys, inquisitions, ac- counts, and a few selected judicial records. When completed, the work will be a help- ful introduction to the still youthful science of diplomatics. “When Railroads Were New,” by Charles Frederick Carter (Henry Holt & Co.), is the outcome of the conviction that no satis- factory account of railway beginnings is available to the general reader. To admit this contention is to overlook the classic writings of Charles Francis Adams and the standard histories of individual systems such as Smalley’s “History of the Northern Pacific.” Upon all of these the author has evidently drawn in his attempt “to gather the floating fragments of railroad history having a human interest into a coherent narrative.” Yet there is not a word of acknowledgment or a_ bibliographical reference. That he has cultivated his field The Nation. assiduously is clear from the abundant harvest of new and fugitive material which he has garnered. Amid such an array of matter one expects to find occasional errors in dates and points of fact, but these could be more readily forgiven if the finality of statement, so prevalent through- out the book, were supported by the evi- dence. Such evidence seems called for, when we are told, for example, that Peter Cooper antedated Stephenson in the in- vention of the multitubular boiler and the artificial draught. Yet the author with his keen sense of the humorous and the dramatic, traces in a most entertaining way the struggles of the idealists to overcome the conservatism of capital, the opposi- tion of vested interests, and the prejudices of the blind and the ignorant, and, barring his all too frequent descent into flippancy and slang, presents his material effectively. We follow the pioneer days of the most important seaboard railways, of the “incu- bator” roads of the Middle West, and the romantic construction of the Pacific lines whose completion was celebrated by pro- cessions, feasting, and the driving of golden spikes. Finally we reach the prosaic birth of the Canadian Pacific, brought to life in an undemonstrative business-like fashion—at the completion of which its general manager only remarked, “The Iast spike will be just as good an iron one as there is between Montreal and Vancouver. Any one who wants to see it driven will have to pay full fare.” F. Frankfort Moore comes to the study of the eighteenth century—“‘A Georgian Pageant” he calls his book (E. P. Dutton & Co.)—as a child of Erin and as novelist. The combination is rather piquant when you consider that his subjects are Fanny Burney, the Thrales, Dr. Johnson, The Gunnings, Goldsmith, Sheridan, the Rev. James Hackman, and others who flutter about that lively company of British and Irish folk. You feel the touch of the novel- ist and dramatist in the very opening scene, which discloses Fanny Burney in Kew Gar- dens pursued by mad King George. The account of that famous adventure is vivid enough in Miss Burney’s Diary, but Mr. Moore can tell you just what gestures she made, and precisely what lines of verse “flashed through her active brain,” with the divination which has always been the prerogative of his school. As for the child of Erin, his huge indignation against any one who has smiled at the two Gunning girls or their masterful mother, or hinted that they had a brogue, his outcry over poor Boswell’s contempt of Goldsmith, his rage with Johnson and Mr. Thrale—a hun- dred little touches throughout the book tell where his heart lies. “Where is there an element of romance in the story of the Gunnings?” he exclaims; “they were by birth entitled to the best, and by beauty to the best of the best. As it was, the one only became the wife of a contemptible duke {two dukes in succession], the other of a ridiculous earl. It may really be said that they threw themselves away.” It is not their romance Mr. Frankfort really means to deny, for, as a trained novelist, he is careful to wring the full measure of that element of interest out of their story; his quarrel is with those who, like Walpole, saw anything odd in this capture of Eng- land from Castle Coote, County Roscommon. 463 For Goldsmith the converser, Mr. Frank- fort makes out a strong case; undoubtedly the sneers of Boswell & Co. were due in part to their priggish inability to under- stand a right Irish humor, but it is hard to believe also that Goldsmith did not at times talk like poor Poll. The evidence is too strong. The curious thing is that Mr. Frankfort stumbles into the very same pitfall when he denounces Jobnson’s con- versation, failing to catch the note of Brit- ish humor in the doctor’s exaggerations. Of all Mr. Frankfort’s chapters the truest seems to us to be that on the tragic story of Mr. Hackman and Miss Reay. Here his training enables him to analyze as in- teresting a psychological problem as ever confronted a novelist. He should, however, have given his reasons for accepting the whole of that correspondence as authentic. Altogether his book is more entertaining than the average writing of the kind on the comedy of the eighteenth century. The motley multitude of wonders as- cribed to the Virgin during the age of faith and fancy is represented in the New Medieval Library by a serection mainly from the thirteenth century collection of Gautier de Coinci, translated into English by Alice Kemp-Welch, under the title, “Of the Tumbler of Our Lady and Other Mira- cles” (Duffield & Co.). Though these stor- ies are told quite simply and briefly for religious edification only, several of them contain matter which should be attractive to mediwvalizing poets. The first, by the way, was elaborated by Edwin Markham no longer ago than 1907, into an unusually meritorious Christmas poem, called the “Juggler of Touraine.” There is a consid- erable diversity in the marvels here re- corded—a knight whose place in a tourna- ment is taken by Our Lady, a violin player to whom the image of the Virgin bows, a monk who dies in an actual odor of sanc- tity, with five celestial roses in his mouth —but these are all, so to speak, conven- tional and orthodox miracles, such as might have happened to any well-regulated de- votee. There is nothing here to illustrate the curious vulgar extension of the Vir- gin’s benefactions to an interposition, some times grotesque and profane, in the affairs of bakers and tapsters, the desperate crises of pious thieves, and the predicaments of religious but very worldly sinners. That play of a primitive and untutored credu- lousness which, as in the apocryphal New Testament, credits a divine being with a purposeless and even immoral display of power, is to the general student not the least instructive aspect of popular media- val literature. For it was but one step from the credulity of the ignorantly de- vout to the skepticism of the free-thinker who, in derision, fabricated burlesque mir- acles easily mistakable for originals. A future volume in thig series might well be devoted to the highly interesting group of ambiguous legends clustering about the Virgin. The Proceedings of the Bostonian Society, just published, contain the annual address of the president, J. F. Hunnewell, on the historical museums of Europe, the most noted of which is that in Zurich, where in some sixty rooms “over sixteen hundred years of national history are illustrated.” The one in Munich is the largest, its near- ly one hundred halls showing the great
Page 18
464 length and variety of Bavarian history from the rudest to the most civilized ages. S. A. Bent proves satisfactorily and with many interesting facts the mythical char- acter of the commonly accepted story that Mary Chilton was the first passenger of the Mayflower to step upon Plymouth Rock. The portraits of two colonial patriots, James Otis and Samuel Adams, with sketches of their careers, add value and attractiveness to the publication. Alfred P. Schultz's “Race or Mongrel” (L. C. Page & Co.) is one of those curious but well-meant productions which cannot be commended without serious qualifica- tion, yet whose reading is not devoid of stimulys and profit. Upon the foundation of a brief and fragmentary outline of the history of ancient nations is reared the theory that the fall of nations is attributa- ble to promiscuous intermarriage with alien stocks, and that the one sure source of national strength and perdurance is ra- cial purity. What tells in the struggle for survival is not government, or institutions, or education, or religion, but blood. The in- evitable result of indiscriminate racial mix- ture, as Mr. Schultz constantly asseverates and tries everywhere to show, is the pro- duction of a mongrel type containing in it- self no power of development or perpetua- tion, and doomed to extinction. In proof, we are pointed to the history of the Hin- dus, the Greeks, and the Romans, and of the present South American whites, ‘‘bas- tards of incompatible races, the descend- ants of two, three, and more cultures that have nothing in common, of races that be- long to different periods of development”’ (p. 163). On the other hand, the Jews, whom Mr. Schultz apparently thinks of as likely to possess the earth, and the Anglo- Saxons in Europe and America, owe their ascendency and permanence to abstention from intermarriage, save under rigid con- ditions of selection, with alien races. The particular lesson of all this for us is that the United States should rigorously restrict immigration, shun with horror the absorp- tion of alien neighbors like the Mexicans, and see to it that the foreigners who come to us be allowed for a generation the free use of their native language as a safeguard against too rapid assimilation. To show the incompleteness of Mr. Schultz’s sur- vey of human progress would be to elabo- rate a treatise on anthropology and soci- ology; and we cannot but fear that his book, notwithstanding the crude vigor of its language and the undoubted suggestive- ness of its observations, will be classed by students as an extreme and one-sided pre- sentation of an interesting and vital sub- ject. Three volumes of Richard Dehmel’s works are issued by S. Fischer of Berlin: “Le- bensblatter,” “Betrachtungen fiber Kunst, Gott, und die Welt,” and “Der Kindergar- ten.” Hitherto Herr Dehmel has content- ed himself with printing his thoughts at random; and it is only in his collected works that one sees how prolific and vigor- ous a writer he is. In his “‘Lebensblatter,” for example—a rather unfortunate title, since Dehmel himself once issued a vol- ume of poems under the same name—there are a dozen good short stories, modern German in spirit, and yet having much of the old-time mystery and magic about them. The best are “Die drei Schwestern,”’ “Der Werwolf,” and “Der laichelnde Erbe,” [ Vol. 88, No. 2288 The Nation. all infused with poetic fancy. Dehmel’s “Betrachtungen” disclose the thinker, but not the man of such sober, dry thought that no one but an abstract philosopher will read him. He wishes to reorganize men’s ideas about beauty, nature, the purity and preservation of language, the moral train- ing of children, public discourse, the relation of personality to art, and the value of art to the masses. He sees the humo- in even the most serious of situations, and knows that if he can make others see it also, he will the more easily convince and convert. In remarkable contrast, as com- ing from the same author; is the volume of stories, poems, and plays designed for the kindergarten world. Here are quaint jin- gles and rhymes, suggesting sometimes Mother Goose, but more often Stevenson or Eugene Field, A particularly charming poem is that which pictures the revolving, Starry heavens as “The Great Merry-go- Round.” Here also are simple plays, such as little children may easily produce, de- signed to awaken in the expanding mind, perhaps, some of that same curiosity for the stage which Goethe early experienced. How the author of the more serious essays could put and keep himself so effectually in touch with the young would be, perhaps, a mystery if one did not perceive that he finds in child life and children, the begin- ning of human development, a theme of ab- sorbing interest not always vouchsafed to those who have become sobered and bur- dened with prosy affairs. The recent action of the Prussian govern- ment in admitting women to the universi- ties on an equality with the men and the thorough reorganization of the secondary schools for girls in the kingdom are produc- ing fruit in the shape of books treating the historical and the theoretical phases of the problem. One of the best of its kind is that of Dr. B. May, “Die Madchenerziehung in der Geschichte der Paidagogik von Plato bis zum 18 Jahrhundert” (Strassburg and Leipzig: Josef Singer). The author confines himself to a discussion of the theories that have been urged in reference to the education of women, but does not take up the practical attempts to realize these ideals. In the Grecian age he deals chiefly with Plato and Aristotle; in the middle ages largely with Jerome and Vincentius of Beauvais; in the period of the renais- sance, with the Hispano-Dutch humanist John Louis Vives; in modern times with such men as Erasmus, Luther, and Fénelon. Unfortunately the book closes with the end of the seventeenth century, and hence ig- nores the even more interesting period that begins with the eighteenth. The book has the merit of being a systematic summary of what has so far been found scattered through many works. Under the title, “Religionsgeschichtliche Erklirung des Neuen Testaments,” Prof. Carl Clemen of Bonn has published an ex- haustive and thorough study of the de- pendence of early Christianity upon the non-Jewish religions and _ philosophical systems (Giessen: Alfred Tépelmann). He has collected with utmost pains the asser- tions of such dependence from Philo and Celsus to the latest phase of the “Babel und Bibel” controversy, which was brought so prominently to general notice by the lectures of Professor Delitzsch and the theological fulminations of the German Kaiser. With the greatest care he has examined the large number of suggested parallels between early Christian views and expressions and other Oriental reli- gions, cults, and philosophies, determining by careful criticism whether dependence existed, and in which direction and to what extent. Every phase of Christian doctrine and each item in Christian history is com- pared with similar topics in non-Christian literature. His conclusion is that in the preaching of Jesus and the Synoptic Gos- pels direct or indirect influence is to be found only in particular expressions, met- aphors, and parables. In some of the speeches of the Acts, on the contrary, he asserts direct dependence upon the current Greek philosophy, especially Stoicism. Yet all in all the Christian system is declared to be independent and original, foreign sources having affected only the periphery of Christian literature, not the essence of the faith itself. The result of the most careful comparative study of Christian ori- gins Professor Clemen believes will be ap apologetic gain, revealing the non-Chris- tian source of some of the conceptions which have been an incubus on the Chris- tian faith and leaving its essential message in clearer light. The method of the inves- tigation is fair, cautious, and impartial. The student will find an abundance of sal- ient material gathered from widely scat- tered sources. In this field, where vague and general assertions have been abundant and hasty conclusions rife, such thorough criticism was much needed, and the in- terests of sober and unprejudiced truth will be served by wide use of Professor Clemen’s study. Of the French works which have been called out by the approaching Calvin cen- tenary in July one of the most important and most able is Prof. C. Doumergue’s “Jean Calvin: Les hommes et les choses de son temps (Lausanne; Bridel). The author draws from many sources, from the letters of Calvin especially, but also from other documents. As the subtitle indicates, the work is really a history of the thought and the civilization of the age of Calvin. No- where else is the historical setting of the Geneva reformer more fully described. In- deed, it may be an open question whether Doumergue has not, by the very abundance of materials, crowded the person and the work of Calvin into the background. Of the five volumes that are to constitute this set, the fourth, entitled “Le Programme,” and the fifth, “La Lutte et le triomphe,” are yet to appear. Those that have been issued are called ‘“‘La Jeunesse de Calvin,” “Les Premiers Essais,” “‘La Ville, la mai- son et la rue de Calvin.” Each is hand- somely illustrated. Thus far there has been a little too much special pleading for the hero. It is proposed to establish at Columbia College a library of English literature in memory of Prof. George Rice Carpenter. A nucleus for the memorial already exists in the form of several volumes gathered together by Professor Carpenter for the use of students in English and compara- tive literature. It is expected that a sepa- rate room will be set aside for the col- lection when it has attained sufficient size. A committee has been formed to take charge of the matter, composed of Profs. William T. Brewster, Wilson Farrand, Jef-
Page 19
465 May 6, 1909] The Nation. ferson B. Fletcher, G. C. D. Odell, and Ashley H. Thorndike, together with James G. Croswell, Frederick P. Keppel, secre- tary, and John B. Pine, clerk of the board of trustees. The following appointments have oeen made for next year at the American School of Classical Studies in Rome: Guy Blandin Colburn, A.B. (Brown University), Ph.D. (University of Wisconsin), acting profes- sor of Latin in Iowa College, to the fel- lowship of the Archwological Institute in Classical Archeology; and Henry H. Arm- strong, professor of Latin in Yankton Col- lege, to be a research associate of the Carnegie Institution in Classical Archeol- ogy. Dr. Sheldon Jackson, United States gen- eral agent of education in Alaska since 1885, died at Asheville, N. C., May 1. He was born in Minaville, N. Y., in 1834, and after graduation from Union College and Princeton Theological Seminary, he was ordained as a Presbyterian minister. For some time he engaged in teaching and in mission work among the Indians, and for more than thirty years he had given special attention to Alaska. He introduced the pub- lic school system into that Territory, and he was indefatigable in his efforts to im- prove social and intellectual conditions there. He was author of “Education in Alaska” (1872), “Hand-book on Alaska,” “Alaska and Missions on the North Pacific Coast,” and since 1886 of annual reports on education in Alaska. Caleb Benjamin Tillinghast, since 1883 State Librarian of Massachusetts, died at Boston April 28. He was born at West Greenwich, R. I., in 1823, and before tak- ing up library work he had tried both school-teaching and journalism. He had been chairman of the Massachusetts Free Public Library Commission and the Com- mittee on Publication of the New England Histeric Genealogical Society, and treas- urer of the Massachusetts Board of Educa- tion. The Very Rev. John Marshall Lang, prin- cipal of Aberdeen University since 1900, died at Aberdeen May 2, in his seventy-fifth year. He had been moderator of the Church of Scotland. His books are “Heaven and Home,” “Life: Is It Worth Living?” “The Last Supper of Our Lord,”’ “Homiletics on St. Luke’s Gospel,” “Central American Faiths,” “The Anglican Church,” “The Ex- pansion of the Christian Life,” and “The Church and Its Social Mission.” The death is reported from Edinburgh, in his eighty-seventh year, of David Lewis, a well-known temperance reformer. He wrote a “History of the Temperance Move- ment in Scotland,” “The Drink Problem,” “The Drink Traffic in the Nineteenth C :n- tury,” and “The Drink Trade.” Karl G. F. von Reinhardstoettner, pro- fessor in the Technical High School of Munich, has died at the age of sixty-two. He was an authority on Portuguese, writing a grammar of the language and a history of the literature. Stephen von Kotze, a Berlin writer of marked and humorous individuality, has died at the age of thirty-nine. His works include “Australische Skizzen,” “Ein af- rikanischer Kiistenbummel,” and “Im euro- paischen Hinterhaus.” The death is reported of Paschal Grous- set, a journalist of note and a member of the French Chamber. He was born sixty- four years ago in Corsica. In 1869 he was appointed by Henri Rochefort editor of La Marseillaise, and during the Commune acted as delegate for foreign affairs. After the establishment of the republic he escaped to England, where he lived until 1881. Under the name of Philippe Daryl he wrote for Le Temps on English topics and translated English novels into French. Under another name, André Laurie, he published a num- of romances and books of travel, Anthony Jannaris, who was for many years prominent in the political affairs of Crete, died suddenly April 26, on the steamship Majestic, bound to New York. Dr. Jannaris was born in Crete in 1852; from 1883 to 1885 he was headmaster of the Pub- lic Gymnasium of Canea; in 1889 was appointed lecturer in Greek literature at the University of Athens, but he gave up this position in the same year and re- turned home to take part in the insurrec- tion. For his share in this movement he was proscribed by the Sultan and fied to London. The next six years he spent in an investigation of the history of the Greek language, working in the British Museum. Returning to Crete, he was elected a mem- ber of the Cretan Assembly, and in the troubles of 1897 he acted as correspondent of the London Times. After various other vi- cissitudes he became in 1907 inspector-gen- eral of public education in Crete. He wrote numerous books and articles in various re- views. Among his more noteworthy works are grammars and dictionaries of the Greek language, studies of Cretan folklore, criti- cal notes on Longinus, and a translation into English of St. John’s Gospel as read by the early Christians. THE EMPIRE OF THE MONGOLS. The Mongols: A History. By Jeremiah Curtin; with a Foreword by Theo- dore Roosevelt. Pp. xxvi+426. Bos- ton: Little, Brown & Co. $3 net. The Mongols in Russia, By Jeremiah Curtin. Pp. xx+448. Boston: Lit- tle, Brown & Co. $3 net. When two years ago the pen dropped from the tired hand of Jeremiah Curtin, the distinguished linguist, ethnologist, and traveller, he left nearly ready for the printer a series of three volumes dealing with that great nomad race of Central Asia that seven centuries ago burst its desert bounds and made the yellow peril such terrible reality to Western civilization. These writings have since been prepared for the press by Mrs. Curtin, his companion and part- ner in all his journeyings and undertak- ings. The first volume came out about a year ago; the second has just appear- ed. The final volume, embodying a per- sonal study of a typical Mongol tribe, the Buriats, is promised for an early date. We learn from Mrs. Curtin that it was the author’s intention to include still another volume, on the history of Tamerlane and the Mogul emperors. With this in view, preparations had been made for an additional two years’ sojourn in Persia and India, when the iliness which proved fatal intervened to prevent the completion of the plan. Before taking up these books in detail, we may note that the term Mongol ap- pears to be of Chinese origin, and is properly applied to a group of closely cognate pastoral tribes centring in Mon- golia between Lake Baikal and the Gobi desert. They are a part of the great Turanian, or Tatar, stock, which in- cludes also the Manchus, Turks, and, with considerable Aryan mixture, the Finns and Magyars. “The Mongols” is really a history of Jinghis Khan, the founder of the short- lived Mongol Empire, and of his imme- diate successors; all that belongs to the earlier period is summarized in a few short paragraphs, while the long period of decadence after 1412 is dismissed in some twenty lines. The conquest of Russia is barely mentioned, and Timur- leng (Tamerlane) and the Mogul Em- pire of Delhi have been reserved for another volume. Temudjin, known in history as Jinghis Khan, the son of a petty tribal chief, was born in 1161 on one of the head-streams of the Amur River, in what is now Russian territory. Through cold-blood- ed murders and skilful alliances he managed to secure recognition as Khan, or, lord, of his native tribe, by the time he was forty years old, and four years later, after a series of rapid vic- tories in Mongolia and China, he as- sumed the title of Jinghis, “The Mighty.” From that time until his death his one object was the subjection of the known world to his own rule, and this object he systematically prosecuted for over twenty years with almost un- varying success, every conquest being a ruin and desolation, every pledge a treachery, and every victory a stupen- dous massacre of almost unimaginable atrocity. With these nomads every man was a warrior, and the army was sim- ply a group of marching tribes. A sin- gle illustration of Mongol warfare will suffice. At Nishapur (1221) they be- gan by laying waste the whole province of which the city was the capital. The siege was then pressed, with the help of three thousand balistas, three hun- dred catapults, four thousand ladders, and seven hundred machines for throw- ing burning naphtha. The city was finally taken by assault, the daughter of Jinghis leading one of the storming parties. In the ensuing four days of slaughter every living thing—excepting a few hundred skilled artisans reserved for future service—was destroyed, even to the cats and dogs. Every prostrate body was beheaded, and three pyra- mids were built, of men’s, women’s, and children’s heads. Fifteen days were oc- cupied in utterly razing the city, after which barley was sown upon the ruins. At his death in 1227, Jinghis left to his son and successor a greater extent
Page 20
466 of empire than had ever before been ruled by one man. Under Kubilai (Ku- bla Khan, 1259-1294) the Mongol Em- pire reached its highest magnificence. After him came swift decay. In 1368, the now degenerate Mongols were driv- en out of China by the founder of the Ming dynasty and later on were made tributary. All of their tribes are now subject either to China or to Russia. Nearly one-half of the second book is taken up with the history of Russia, previous to the first Mongol invasion. This portion is chiefly a wearisome record of the conflicts of rival cities, the history of the Russian state begin- ning in 862, when the citizens of Nov- gorod, weary of anarchy and invasion, invited Rurik, the Norseman, to come and rule over them. As a member of the Hanseatic League, “mighty Novgorod” it Se to greatness, but in the end (1478) all the Russian cities were brought under the central authority of Moscow. In 1224 the news came from the south that the terrible warriors of Jinghis had swept across the Ural and were ravaging the territories of the Po- lovtsi Tartars, a remotely kindred peo- ple, who had occupied the Black Sea country nearly two centuries before. In response to the cry of the Polovtsi, ““To- morrow they will strike you,” the neigh- boring Russian princes marshalled their forces against the enemy, but were to- tally defeated on the banks of the Kalka by the Mongol host under Su- botai and Chepé. The Prince of Kief and two others were crushed to death under a platform of heavy planks upon which their barbarous captors sat and feasted while their victims were in their death tortures. Then the Mongols retired, as suddenly as they had appeared, to the mystery of their own deserts, In 1237, the full Mongol flood came upon Rus- sia. The invasion was led by Batu, grandson of Jinghis Khan. To his de- mand for tribute, the Russian princes gave brave, but injudicious, refusal. One city after another was taken by storm —Riazan, Kolomna, Moscow, Vladimir, Tver—their treasures seized, their build- ings burned and levelled, their people slaughtered by tens of thousands, and their principal men crucified and flayed alive. Nothing could withstand the fury of the yellow barbarian. The next year Batu built his capital at Sarai, near the mouth of the Volga, and established the famous khanate of the Kiptchak, or Golden Horde—a name chosen from Mongol symbolism—which stretched from Turkestan to the Dnieper and for nearly two centuries dominated the whole of eastern Europe. Batu’s reign marks both the summit and the ebb of Mongol power in Eu- rope. With his death about 1255 be- gins the decay that follows inaction among races bred only to fighting. Within the next century the Mongols ‘The Nation. [ Vol. 88, No. 2288 exchanged their heathenism for the re- ligion of Mohammed. In the mean- time intestine feuds were wasting their strength, while Russian power was steadily consolidating under the lead- ership of Moscow. In 1380 Dmitri of Moscow, at Kulikovoon the Don, routed a great army led by the Khan Mamai himself. From that time on the Mon- gols, in spite of temporary successes, lost ground, and the last remaining Mongol khanate in Russia was extin- guished with the annexation of the Crimea in 1783. Besides the main story, the second volume affords interesting light upon the origin of the conflict between Rus- sia and Poland, the struggle between Rome and Constantinople for ecclesias- tical supremacy in Eastern Europe, and the Germanizing of the Baltic provinces in the name of Christianity by the Knights of the Cross. Paganism linger- ed in Lithuania down to the close of the fourteenth century. While the story of the Mongols is new to most readers, and is here vividly told, the style of the narrative, for want of the author’s final revision, is some- what too terse and abrupt for easy reading, suggestive rather of annals than of a rounded history. The lack of notes, bibliography, or reference to specific authorities, in both volumes, and the omission of an index to the sec- ond, are serious deficiencies, due also to the fact of the author’s untimely death, and not in accord with his usual care- ful custom. It is to be hoped that all these defects will be remedied in the proposed third volume. Each volume is accompanied by a map and portrait of the author. CURRENT FICTION. Fraternity. By John Galsworthy. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. This latest book of Mr. Galsworthy’s, like several of its predecessors, seems wilfully to leave the artistic sense of the reader unsatisfied. It has, strictly speaking, no hero or heroine, no climax, and no conclusion. Like “The Island Pharisees,” it is seething with the leaven of humanitarianism and is full of unanswered questions. The general interrogation of the work is summariz- ed in three lines from the “Electra” of Euripides printed on the title-page: Brother, brother, on some far shore Hast thou a city, is there a door That knows thy footfall, Wandering One? A sensitive skeptic, outraged by social injustices, haunted by the persistent dream of universal brotherhood, Mr. Galsworthy appears ready with Carlyle and Ruskin in his later period to let the “devil fly away with the fine arts” till that question is answered. Till a new light breaks for suffering human- ity, there is no joy for the artist in painting pictures or writing novels. In- deed, till some solution is found for our social problems, no deep and true book can possibly have a hero, a climax, or a conclusion. Meanwhile, the artist has a great preparatory work to per- form to shatter the complacent ego- tism of the contented, and to send to them in visions of the night a dream of the New Eden. To this extent, then, “Fraternity” is a purpose novel allied in spirit and general intention with many of the novels put forth in the Revolutionary Era of fair hope. But it is distinguished from them by a great difference which makes it faith- fully representative of the sober wis- dom gained by a century of disillusion- ment: though it yearns with the old ar- dor toward the divine idea of Social Justice, it betrays the new and almost tragical uncertainty as to her where- abouts. We have perhaps emphasized rather too much Mr. Galsworthy’s sacrifice of art to life. In spite of his desire to make fiction serve a higher master, he has produced a book which, even judged purely on its artistic merits, must rank as one of the most notable of the day. When one compares it with his earlier novels, such as “The Villa Rubein” and “The Island Pharisees,” one is astonished at his development in breadth, variety, subtlety, charm, and sympathy. In his recently published “Commentary,” a volume of brilliantly suggestive character sketches, we noted his unusual power of symbolizing an entire class or social stratum by one keenly observed, significantly delineat- ed individual. The same power is ex- erted on a larger scale in “Fraternity,” and with much more dramatic effect. Here is a whole social world—the fine grained, unpractical literary man, his brother the man of facts and action, the gross man of wealth and business, the strenuous young physician, the de- crepit butler, the model, the street- sweeper, wives, children, and infants— each member intimately, unmistakably himself or herself, and yet somehow clearly standing for every man and every woman of that stamp. What brotherhood exists in this world, what strivings toward it, what indifference to it, what repulsion from it—such is this study of the novelist. He has not simplified the problem; it is life in its complexity that he envisages—life with its immortal prejudices and its im- mortal egotism. Some of the charac- ters, too, are touched with the fever of fraternal love. But at the end of the book the literary man wears the wan smile of Hamlet. “It is a disease to smile like that!” comments the young physician. “Your prescription,” is the retort, “in this case has not been too successful, has it?’ And the Laertes of the story can only reply, “I can’t help it if people will be d——d fools.” There
Page 21
May 6, 1909] The Nation. 467 is one old man, however, feeble-minded, lost to his own time, a Maeterlinckian figure, whose prophetic eyes have seen the glory of the New Jerusalem on earth. Stepping into the night, he ut- ters one cry, “Brothers!” A policeman passing on his beat lifts his lantern and peers into the darkness: no one is there. That is one of many touches of grim yet tender irony which lend a pe- culiar fascination to this picture of a segment of modern life. The Actress. By Louise Closser Hale. New York: Harper & Bros. Mrs. Hale has given us in this book that refreshing and unusual thing, a wholesome glimpse of stage-life seen from the inside. The picture she pre- sents is neither framed by the pro- scenium arch nor caught by a surrepti- tious eye at the crack of the stage-door; standing among the hard-working, warm- hearted servants of the public whose labors we applaud so lightly, we realize the drudgery of what seems so spon- taneous. Glamor enough, however, mingles with the grind, to make Rhoda Miller, the heroine, scorn the hum- drum round of domesticity pressed upon her notice by her suitor, Aaron Adams, one of those characters whose strength, tenderness, and general desirability are so obvious in fiction and so easily over- looked in real life. Rhoda goes to Eng- land and scores a tremendous success, which falls far short of filling Aaron’s place in her heart; thinking that her deserted swain has found consola- tion, she endeavors in vain to do like wise—here Mrs, Hale indulges in a deliciously funny stab at the Artistic Temperament in the composer Meurice —and finally collapses in the severe ill- ness that is the last resort of heroines hard pressed by the burdens of their own folly. Of course, Aaron appears to gather her wasted form in his strong arms, and she gladly exchanges the world of make-believe for that of real- ity. The book abounds in clever char- acter-drawing, the descriptions of Eng- lish society being particularly well done. The Girl and the Bill. By Bannister Merwin. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. This story almost exceeds the speed limit. A girl and a five-dollar bill are the leading racers and are never lost to view, but their attendant train of persons and things grows to bewildering length. There are stolen papers, crypto grams, refrigerator prisons, and hollow Chicago tree trunks. There are sleuth- houndings in Japanese, Portuguese, and American styles. There are interna- tional sluggings, ranging from yellow jiu-jitsu to the good old-fashioned uni- versal monkey-wrench, and the futile but patriotically cow-boyish attempt to throw from a launch a lariat over a gentleman in a neighboring motor-boat. There are an intrepid girl and an en- gaging man, accomplished detectives both. And there are world-important diplomacies. All this and these, with much and many more, are whizzed be- fore the reader as the recorded contents of a day and a quarter—almost less time than it takes to tell it. Out of the whole emerges a very good, readable story, violating probabilities, as it should, but dealing mercifully with sen- sibilities. Uncle Gregory. By George Sandeman. New York: G. P, Putnam’s Sons. This story possesses the peculiar in- terest and fascination that always ac- crue to a book, as to a person, that can suggest depths of significance below what meets the casual glance. If these depths are a baffling puzzle even when their presence is recognized, the inter- est is so much the greater. It may be that Mr. Sandeman is guiltless of sym- bolic intent, and has sought merely to give us the round unvarnished tale of a wealthy Peer Gynt who wished to have only the memory of his shiploads of Bibles preserved for posterity. What- ever the intention of the book, its im- pression is of a strength disproportion- ate to the expressed subject matter, and we feel that there is real weight in the question so often asked by those labor- ing at the elusive biography: “What is the real Uncle Gregory?” They several- ly apprehend him as a grown-up child trying to embody his sister’s ideal for him—a saint—a demon—an epitome of the spirit of his time. One can but wish that the author had brought to his cli- max some such sledgehammer force as we feel in Chesterton’s “Man Who Was Thursday,” a book of somewhat similar effect; but he evades the questions he has raised, and closes the book, as it were, with an interrogation point. The M.P. for Russia: Reminiscences and Correspondence of Madame Olga Novi- koff. Edited by W. T. Stead. 2 vols. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $7.50 net. It is perhaps unjust to say that these volumes disappoint expectations. One knew of Madame Novikoff’s reputation, and of the conviction of many of her English and Continental contempo- raries that she was a woman of great ability and of extraordinary charm; yet to say that these are not conveyed by this record may amount to no more than to confess that personality eludes the printed page. But the editing is at least in fault in that it leaves many things obscure that should have been cleared up—for example, the precise na- ture of Madame Nevikoff’s relations with the Russian government—and in general tends to give the reader an in- tolerable deal of Stead to a pennyworth of Novikoff. The main facts in her ca- reer, however, are put in relief: her ardent and life-long Pan-Slavism; her whole-souled championing of Russia abroad, particularly in England, where she lived for a part of each year for many years; her remarkable mastery of English, and her conquest of many warm friends and admirers among the best of her day in Wngland—Carlyle, Froude, Kinglake, Tyndall, Gladstone. But when we come to the proof in cold type of her uncommon graces and bril- liant wit, it largely vanishes. After all, we have to take it on credit. What so many capable observers experienced in their own persons, cannot have been so mythical or so exaggerated as these pages would make it seem. Madame Novikoff’s greatest successes in England were won in those years when Beaconsfield called her by the title now given this book. During the pre liminaries of the Russo-Turkish war, while it was raging, and throughout its fateful sequels, she was “M.P. for Rus- sia” in the sense that she wrote books and articles and kept up a voluminous correspondence and maintained a salon in London, all for the purpose of cor- recting English prejudices and leading to that better political understanding which seemed to be established after Gladstone’s return ta power in 1880. Later, she was not so happy. The war with Japan and the following political developments in Russia were terrible blows to her. “Heaven save us from @ Constitution,” was her cry, and she dreaded a Parliament as devoutly as Froude. Thus the break-up of autocrat- ic Russia seems to leave this autocrat sad and puzzled, at the end of her days. And her proud cry, “The Future is ours,” rings pathetically now. From the old public issues treated with such prolixity and vanity by Mr. Stead, the reader turns to the human intercourse here outlined. Kinglake appears at his best in the letters of his that are printed. Froude in his was coldly kind and politically askew. Glad- stone writes as a tremendous man of business. With Disraeli, Madame Novi- koff, naturally, never got into close touch. She has some good stories of his habitual resort to fiattery, from the Queen down, in order to gain his ends. She was talking with Gortschakoff af- ter the Congress of Berlin. He said: “I cannot complain of Beaconsfield. He called on me no end of times and was most complimentary. He told me, among other things, that whenever he hears a bon mot, he always says, ‘Oh, it is not so good as what was said by Prince Gortschakoff’.” Madame Novi- koff frankly rejoined: “Prince, I must tell you that Lord Salisbury said not long ago that Beaconsfield’s power lay in his shameless habit of flattering ev- erybody.” Gortschakoff protested, but un peu tard, one fears, that he was not
Page 22
The Nation. [Vol. 88, No. 2288 easily taken in by flattery. Charles Vil- liers is quoted as authority for another story in the same vein. When the Queen published what Villiers is strangely made to call her “Reminiscences of Life in Scotland,” she sent a copy to mem- bers of Parliament: We were evidently expected to offer madrigals and burn incense... . We were all in a fix. Dizzy alone never lost cour- age. “This production,” he wrote, “can only be compared to Shakespeare, or to the Gospels.” I remained silent, while he went on, as if speaking to himself. “Yes, it wants a lot of courage for serving such a dish, and an exceptionally robust health to assimilate it!” The Moral System of Dante's Inferno. By W. H. V. Reade. New York: Henry Frowde. $4.15. This is the most exhaustive analysis that has ever been made of Dante’s mor- als. For five hundred years critics have discussed why the poet condemns sin- ners to an upper or a lower circle of hell, contrary to the popularly accepted enormity of their wickedness. To link Brutus and Cassius, who regarded them- selves as martyrs to patriotism, with Judas Iscariot, the supreme embodiment of treachery among Christians, has seemed a paradox to many a student of Dante. But nobody has been able to maintain that the verdicts in the Divine Comedy were haphazard or arbitrary: for there is no other masterpiece in the world in which every part has been so carefully adjusted to the whole, and where literally every word has been so charged with significance. Mr. Reade’s task is to discover the rules which guid- ed Dante’s verdicts. He begins, very properly, with an ex- amination of two modern theories which may be regarded as both representative and weighty—those of Witte and of Dr. Edward Moore. Having disposed of these, he goes back to the two great bodies of moral teaching—Aristotle’s and Thomas Aquinas’s—from which Dante drew directly. With patient elab- oration, he compares their systems plecemeal, virtue by virtue and vice by vice, and so is able to show not only which of his masters Dante followed in each particular case, but also the gener- al attitude towards life of the Greeks and of the supreme Catholic dogmatist. He traces, further, the origin of such of Dante’s verdicts as correspond with neither the Aristotelian nor the Thoman model. His fundamental division of sins into those of Force and those of Fraud, for instance, Dante borrowed from Cicero. The Christian theology natural- ly led to a whole tribe of sins which Paganism took no notice of. Mr. Reade’s treatise, therefore, may interest also students of comparative morals who are not primarily concerned with Dante. It could scarcely be more careful, thorough, or open-minded. We think it would be well, however, if he had translated his many extracts from St. Thomas, putting the original text in the footnotes. And he might assist the readers of his intricate arguments by summing up briefly and very clearly the points that he has demonstrated, chapter by chapter. Like many learned controversialists, he sometimes seems to forget that most of us read not for the sake of the controversy, but to learn its results. Howbeit, he has produced a work which every exhaustive student of Dante will turn to and which will not need to be undertaken again on so elab- crate a scale, Madrid: An Historical Description and Handbook of the Spanish Capital. By Albert F. Calvert. With 453 illustra- tions. New York: John Lane Co. $1.50 net. Madrid is not a typically Spanish city. The traveller visits it to see the Prado and the Royal Armory, but not to see Spain. In no other great Continental capital, to be sure, may one see ox-carts in fashionable thoroughfares, mule teams in the service of royalty, men wrapped in capas, and women whose street costume includes a fan in the hand and a rose in the hair. These touches, however, are by way of sug- gestion only. One must wait for some day when the city is en féte, when the promise of a great corrida has roused the national passion for the favorite sport and filled the Alcala with a stream of eager humanity, to realize that at heart Madrid is Spain. In this volume of the Spanish Series, Mr. Calvert proves that, while Madrid cannot com- pete with her older sisters, Segovia, Burgos, Seville, Cordova, Granada, To- ledo, and Avila, in antiquities or local color, the spirit of modern progress which has made her a prosperous capl- tal has not destroyed her charm for even the traveller of the romantic school. One could not ask for a better supplement to the more practical de- tails of the guide-book. The work is accurate, sympathetically just, complete without being tiresome, and profusely illustrated. It contains a chapter of general impressions, a brief history of the city, descriptions of the court, so- ciety, art, literature, and the drama, churches and public buildings, including the Escorial, La Granja, and Alcala; an excellent guide to that marvellous col- lection of arms and armor, so little of which, curiously enough, is of Spanish workmanship, and last but not least two chapters on the bull-fight. For those who wish more detail, spe- | cial volumes of the series are devoted to Goya, Velasquez, the Prado, Spanish arms and armor, the Escorial, and the tapestries of the Royal Palace. No oth- er country lends itself to a series of de- scriptive volumes as does Spain, for Spain is not one, but many, countries; and its people, from the Basque to the Andalusian, many peoples. Travellers will do well to economize space in other directions, if necessary, and include Mr. Calvert’s volumes in their outfit. Science. The Home Garden. By Eben E. Rex- ford. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $1.25 net. The Summer Garden of Pleasure. By Mrs. Stephen Batson. Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co. $3.50. Works on gardening written by opti- mists are pleasanter to read and much more profitable to use than those which are prepared by the unsuccessful and pes- simistic. Some of the smaller treatises on the art of managing plants appear to have been the outcome of disappoint- ment: the writers having failed to make their gardens pay either in money or pleasure, vent their vexation in the con- struction of delusive books. “The Home Garden” is the sober production of a successful gardener who has reaped fair crops of wholesome and kindly fruits of the earth. How far one can trust the author in estimating the attractiveness of gardening for boys is a doubtful mat- ter. Our experience does not wholly confirm the confidence which is here ex- pressed in the alluring nature of weed- ing with the aid of the latest improved tools. After giving a good account of certain labor-saving appliances, the au- thor proceeds: Nine boys, I venture to say, can be made to take an interest in the garden where the implements I have mentioned are used, where one could be induced to work in it with simply a hoe and spade. Boys, like men, have a horror of pulling weeds, and the writer of this cannot say that he blames them for it, for he can easily re- member the time when he would rather take a whipping than weed the garden for an hour. He very much doubts if he would have a garden now if all the work in it had to be done in the slow, hard, old-fashioned way. This book does not deal at all with the decorative floral features of gardens, but solely with the modest plots of vegetables and small-fruits which can be managed without too much trouble by a person with scanty leisure and good courage. ‘The directions for the management of the soil and most of the plants are plain and sensible, and can- not carry any beginner far out of the way. Moreover, the author wisely calls attention to the disheartening features of gardening which confront the begin- ner after the rosy dawn of the seed-bed has begun to grow gray with the com- ing of blights and insect pests. The ac- tual danger from these enemies is less- ened by the modern methods of spray- ing and by the judicious selection of va-
Page 23
The May 6, 1909] rieties of resistant character. The ad- vice to choose from the too enticing cata- logues only the old-established and ap- proved sorts, instead of the newer and untried, is sound and always safe. The author might also have called attention to the desirability of selecting only va- rieties which are suited to the particu- lar latitude and exposure of the garden. Plants which are adapted to Maine may not be so good for southern Pennsyl- yania. The little book is complete, as far as it goes, and does not refer the reader for necessary information to an- other book in the same series. In short, this treatise is a convenient, untechni- cal, but not encyclopedic, aid to begin- ners. Although it is very small, it ought to have an index. “The Summer Garden of Pleasure” is an English work which endeavors to justify its existence by an apologetic preface. The author tenders counsel to the “amateur who gardens on the level,” whatever that may mean, and “who longs after color schemes as ardently as do his brethren with larger powers.” To illustrate her views of color distri- bution, the author makes intelligent use of some exceedingly impressionistic paintings by Osmund Pittman. Much of the advice is presented in an uninter- esting manner, but it is all made easily accessible by the device—costly in print- ing, but very useful—of marginal head- ings for the paragraphs. The best part of the book is that which is devoted to the management of the flower garden in the midsummer season, in order to prevent complete banishment of attrac- tive flowers when the shadow of autumn is about to fall. The suggestions are, of course, better adapted to the exigen- cies of the English gardens than to ours, but with a few amendments many of the ideas may be carried out here. There will be considerable difference of opinion as to the artistic effect of some of the combinations depicted in this book, since a few of them appear to have been introduced as examples of what to avoid, but many are quiet and restful enough, even for a Japanese. Longmans, Green, & Co. announce as to be published ‘“‘The Fundamental Principles of Chemistry,’ by Wilhelm Ost- wald, authorized translation by Harry W. Morse. “Les Phénoménes psychiques et supernor- maux,” by Dr. Paul Joire, treats observa- tion and experimentation in such matter from the point of view of a professor at the Institut Psycho-physiologique of Paris {8vo, 22 figures, Vigot Fréres). “Le Cour humain et les lois de la psychologie positive,” by Antoine Baumann, is, like the other books of this author, an excursion where science and philosophy meet (Per- rin). “Le Rationalisme comme hypothése méthodologique,” by F. Maugé, is a phil- osophic treatment of theory which under- lies science, in two parts: first, the ration- alist hypothesis and experimental method; soon the conditions and principles of pages, second, systematizing in the sciences (617 Alcan). The recent publication of the official doc- uments in the case of Galileo has led to the preparation by a Catholic scholar, Dr. A, Miiller, S.J., director of the astronomical observatory on the Janiculum in Rome, or a work of some two hundred pages treat- ing the new phases of this old controversy, “Galileo Galilei und das kopernikanische Weltsystem”’ (Freiburg-im-B.; Herder). A further work on this matter, by the same author, is in course of publication, “Der Galilei Prozess (1631-1632) nach Ursprung, Verlauf und Folgen.”’ Naturally this mono- graph presents the matter from the point of view of the Catholic Church, “Unsere Kultur” is the title of a readable scientific volume by Prof. Albert Geyer (Giessen: E. Roth), designed to give a nep- ular view of the development of wmwodern life. The author cannot forget that he is more German than Weltmensch; he credits Bell with a part in the development of the telephone, but only after the Germans had previously made some progress; aud in ihe history of steam navigation he passes by unknown Fulton altogether, beginning with the steamboats on the Rhine, 1816, ihe Oder, 1825, and the Danube, 1833. Simeon Snell, president of the British Medical Association and one of the leading ophthalmic surgeons of England, died at Sheffield last month. He had been profes- sor of ophthalmology at the University of Sheffield, and had edited the Quarterly Medical Journal. Among his publications are: “The Electro-Magnet and Its Employ- ment in Ophthalmic Surgery,” ‘Miners’ Nystagmus,” “School Life and Eyesight,” “Prevention of Eye Accidents in Certain Trades,” and “Eyestrain as a Cause of Headaches.” Charles Bell Taylor, an eminent ophthal- mic surgeon, died at Nottingham, England, last month, at the age of eighty. He ob- tained his medical education at the Univer- sity of Edinburgh and Paris. He was the author of “On Diseases of the Eye,” which has run through several editions. Drama. The Playhouse and the Play. By Percy MacKaye. New York: The Macmillan Co. $1.25 net. In “The Playhouse and the Play” Percy MacKaye has collected the various essays on the theatre which he has writ- ten during the last two or three years. Most of them have been read before different universities, clubs, or associa- tions, and all have been published in full or in part. It is well that they should be offered in this convenient form, for—and this will be admitted even by those who do not agree with all his conclusions—they are full of in- teresting and pregnant matter. The fol- lowing passage in one of them may be quoted as the common text of all: In theatrical amusement we are con- cerned with public happiness. Real happi- ness means education; real education means Nation. 469 happiness. And in regard to our drama there can be no sounder, no more enlight- ening conviction than this truth: that by whatever name we choose to call it, the in- fluence of our theatres is a colossal, a na- tional influence in forming the taste, the moral will, the mental capacity of our people. In common with all other thoughtful students of the theatre and its possibil- ities he laments that so potent an en- gine of civilization should be delivered into the hands of commercial specula- tors, barred from the performance of its highest functions, and often degraded to the basest uses. Comparatively few persons ever stop to think of the actual influence of the theatre, for good or ill, upon public tastes and morals. Mr. MacKaye quotes some facts and figures which throw much illumination on this subject. Be- yond doubt, the influence is enormous, and, as matters now stand, more often mischievous than beneficial, or even in- nocuous. The question is how exist- ing evils are to be remedied and the po- tential benefits of the theatre to be brought into operation. Mr. MacKaye’s one solution is endowment. He even makes the rash statement that without endowment no effectual art can live, a dogma that would scarcely bear the test of examination. In his enthusiasm he imagines a civic theatre—apparently some ideal development of the ancient classical prototype—in every considera- ble city, capable of doing a large part of the work that churches, schools, and universities do now; an institution rep- resentative of all that is intellectually and morally best in the community, an unfailing source of incentive and exam- ple. It is a pretty dream, but, like most entiusiasts, Mr. Mackaye, with his soar- ing vision, overlooks the sordid finan- cial, political, and other practical diffi- culties in the way. There is the gravest reason for mis- trusting the possibilty of a sound and enlightened administration of a theatre by public officials. What might be ac- complished by private generosity and altruistic effort is another question, which need not be considered now. Mr. Mackaye is right in his assertion that the theatre will never reveal its high- est powers, until it is run in the public interest and not wholly as a commercial speculation. But it may be pointed out that public interests and private gain are not necessarily or invariably in- compatible. Plenty of money has been made before now in the higher walks of literature, art, and the drama. Mr. Mackaye’s dictum that ‘the rational aim of theatrical business is to ignore the rational aim of dramatic art” is by no means universally true. Even in this country, over and over again, the best plays have proved the most profitable. A great part of Edwin Booth’s fortune was made out of Shakespeare. Mr. Man-
Page 24
a The Nation. [ Vol. 88, No. 2288 TO tell, a far inferior actor, is doing well by following—longo sed intervallo—in his footsteps. In the dramatic business, as in others, it often pays to aup- ply the finest stock, and some dim per- ception of this fact is beginning to dawn, apparently, upon one or two of our managers. Being simply commercial men, they cannot, as Mr. Mackaye points out, be expected to risk their money in what they believe to be a losing venture, but for the same reason, they would readily abandon a policy threatening to be ruinous. The present talk among them of repertory theatres is not without significance. It is the lack of competition, not the want of en- dowment, that is stifling the theatre. Half a dozen really inderendent the- atres in the hands of duly qualified managers, with artistic impulses and some capital behind them, might do as much towards a theatrical revival as any endowment. The strong interest in everything per- taining to the drama which is noticeable in German letters to-dayis responsible for the attention which is now drawn to Ludwig Tieck’s writings on the subject. For it wus Tieck, as artistic manager of the theatre of Dresden, and as one of the translators of Shakespeare, to whom is due mucb of Shakespeare's popularity among the Ger- mans. It was Tieck, too, who, when he sat- tled in Berlin in the forties, succeeded in having Sophocles’s “Antigone” and other classical tragedies performed. ‘The little book which calls attention to his work in behalf of the theatre is Dr. Erich Drach’s “Ludwig Tieck’s Biihnenreformen” (Berlin: R. Trenkel). Dr. Alfred Schaer is the author of a book of 127 pages containing an interesting his- torical investigation: “Die dramatische Fearbeitung der Pyramus-Thisbe Sage in Deutschland im 16. und 17. Jahrhundert” (Leipzig: W. Schafer). “The Great John Ganton,” an adaptation of Arthur J. Eddy’s story of the Chicago stock yards (see the Nation of December 10, 1908, p. 580), by the young English dra- matist, J. Hartley Manners, was produced in the Lyric Theatre on Monday evening. The play may or may not please the gen- eral public—it undoubtedly possesses cer- tain elements of popularity—but is a crude, loquacious, melodramatic, insignificant be dismissed with brief a serious ob- piece, which may notice Pretending to have ject in the exposure and denunciation of corrupt, tyrannical, and unscrupulous busi- ness methods, and the evils of gambling in Wall Street and elsewhere, it deals mainiy in sonorous platitudes and extravagant in- without reaching any definite con- cident, clusion. From first to last it is intensely but not skilfully or effectively theatrical To the solution of current problems it contributes nothing, and it has no value as a picture of life or manners. In the cen- tral figure of John Ganton himself, incon- sistent as it is in more respects than one, there is a certain amount of vitality, and the character suits the personality of George Fawcett, an experienced actor, who plays it with humor and some emotional On him the future of the piece de- force. pends. The London Play Actors seem to have made a somewhat remarkable find in “Chains,” a realistic drama of the English lower middle class, by Elizabeth Baker, who is said to have had no experience of the theatre. Her topic is the awful mo- notony and drudgery of the treadmill ex- istence led by tens and hundreds of thou- sands of men dependent solely upon cleri- cal employment, without hope of progress, rest, or change. Olive Logan, lecturer, actress, and author, died at Banstead, England, April 27, at the age of seventy. She was born in Elmira, N. Y., and after some experience as a lec- turer, went on the stage. She was author of several books, including “Women and Theatres” (1869), and “The Mimic World” (1871); she wrote a comedy, “Surf,” a dramatization of Wilkie Collins’s “Arma- dale,” and a metrical translation of Francois Coppée’s “Le Passant,” produced in London in 1887. Musie. Beethoven's Letters. By Dr. A. A. Ka- lischer; translated with Preface by J. S. Shedlock. 2 vols. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $7.50. When the question of bringing out an edition of Haydn’s complete works was being discussed, some years ago, Brahms expressed the opinion that only those things that were really of interest should be printed. Of the others it would be sufficient, he thought, if a dozen copies were made by hand for distribu- tion in the largest libraries where stu- dents might have access to them. One cannot but think that such a plan should be adopted with regard to the printing of letters by famous men. Here we have a collection of Beethoven’s in two vol- umes, 925 pages altogether, yet all that was really worth reading could have been easily held in one volume of 400 pages. What earthly use is there in printing notes like this?—“Do tell me if I can speak to you this evening about five o'clock. The matter is pressing.” Or this—“His high-born von Smeskall is requested kindly to say where one can speak with him tomorrow.” There is a great deal of that sort of thing, and the result is that few even of those who purchase such books have the courage or time to read them through. Beethoven speaks of himself as being “fearfully lazy” as a correspondent. His output of letters certainly was a mere bagatelle as compared with the numer- ous and voluminous epistles of Schu- mann, Wagner, or Liszt. There are al- together 1,220 in these volumes, and most of them are very short, containing, like the two specimens quoted, things that we now usually confide to the tele- phone. That they make up so many pages is explained by the fact that most of them are followed by comments (often longer than the letters) by the German editor and the English trans- lator. Dr. Kalischer declares that he was engaged for a good twenty years on his task; during that time he ex- amined over six hundred autograph let- ters to correct the printed versions, and he found many new ones, some of ex- ceptional length, to add to those which had previously appeared. His notes are accurate, illuminating, helpful, and Mr. Shedlock, who has translated both the comments and the letters admirably, contributes more useful matter. It is with Beethoven’s letters as with his compositions: the longer they are, the more they interest us. Being, as he says, lazy as a correspondent, he never sat down to pen a long letter un- less he had something on his heart. It is when he talks to or about his pub- lishers, his spendthrift nephew, his in- corrigible servants, his critics, his grow- ing deafness, that he grows confiding and entertaining—unwittingly, for he never dreamed that any of these letters would be seen in print. Regarding the trouble with his ears, he wrote in 1800: “Please keep as a great secret what I have told you about my hearing; trust no one, whoever it may be, with it.” This remained his attitude for years; the malady was slow in developing, but by 1817 it had reached a stage which induced him to write to Nanette Streicher: Now a great request to Streicher; ask him in my name to be kind enough to pre- pare a pianoforte especially adapted to my weak hearing. I want the tone to be as strong as possible. A surprisingly large number of these letters, and not the shortest by any means, are jeremiads about servants. These are always amvrsing; they show the great composer from his most hu- man side. “I came here with an im- paired indigestion, and a terrible cold— the former through that archpig the housekeeper, the other from a beast of a kitchenmaid.” “Such people,” he de clares in another letter, “cannot be gov- erned by love, but only by fear; I see that now quite clearly”; and in har- mony with this suggestion is his state- ment regarding one servant: “I threw at her my heavy chair which stands by the bed; for that I was at peace the whole day.” He finally seeks consola- tion in this philosophical reflection: “We shall not fare better with other ser- vants.” His feelings were easily ruf- fled, and he often wrote as if he had been badly treated even by his best friends. With his publishers he had many a tiff. He complains of the en- gravers “who pick us poor composers to death”; of the many errors in the print- ed pages because his frequent requests for proofs had been neglected. He tells the head of the great firm of Breitkopf & Hartel that if he had his wish, said publisher “would have to wander about
Page 25
May 6, 1909] The Nation. 4°71 in penitential garments made of hair for all the wicked things that he has done to my works.” In another mood he writes to the same man: You as a more humane being and a more cultured head than all the other publishers of music ought not to pay poor terms to the artist, but rather help him on the road to accomplish undisturbed what is in him, and what one expects from him. “As you are neither Jews nor Italians,” he writes to another firm, “and I neither of the two, we shall no doubt come to an agreement.” The critics fare much worse than the publishers; in fact, they are castigated almost as severely as the servants. In the early period the critics were inclin- ed to make sport of Beethoven's art- work. “Advise your critics,” he wrote to a publisher in 1801, “to exercise more care and good sense with regard to the productions of young authors, for many a one may thereby become disspirited who otherwise might have risen to higher things.” But the culprits con- tinued to ply their nefarious trade. “In what a mean way are critics allowed to pounce upon us,” he writes in 1803; “I am treated infamously.” Eight years later he again complained of being “re- viewed in a shameful manner,” but look- ed at the matter more calmly: “It may give one a little prick like the sting of a gnat, and then it becomes quite a lit- tle joke. Not forever; that you cannot do.” What the critic had said was: In quartet writing the aim should surely not be to commemorate the dead, or to express the feelings of one in despair, but by soft, pleasing play of the imagination to refresh and gladden one’s heart. Dr. Kalischer tries hard to prove that the famous letters to the “Immortal Be- loved” were addressed to the Countess Guicciardi; he declares that Thayer’s attempt to “palm off the Countess Brunswick as the Immortal Beloved must now be regarded as having totally failed”; but since this was written, La Mara has proved in “Beethovens unsterb- liche Geliebte” (Nation, February 18, p. 177) that Thayer was right. On the other hand, one gains the distinct im- pression from reading Dr. Kalischer’s two volumes that the equally famous let- ters to Bettina Brentano are not genu- ine. He himself thinks there were “in- terpolations”; but when read in con- nection with the other Beethoven letters they seem so different in style and thought from all the others that one can- not but suspect that they were altogeth- er the products of that woman’s imag- ination. These beautifully printed volumes are adorned with many interesting facsim- iles and portraits. Henry W. Savage asserts that “The Mer- ry Widow” has been an unprecedented pop- ular success. First produced in Vienna, on December 30, 1905, it had had up to the first of April, 1909, 1,503 performances in America, 1,365 in England; total number of performances everywhere, about 18,000. It has been sung in 422 German cities, 135 English, and 154 American cities. It has been translated into thirteen languages and produced in thirty different countries, in- cluding Turkey, Persia, Japan, China, Hin- dustan, and Siberia. New York paid a million dollars to hear it last year; Chicago paid $364,000 in twenty-six weeks; Boston, $250,000 in eighteen weeks this season. More than 3,000,000 copies of the “Merry Widow” waltz have been sold in Europe; and in America the music publishers sold $400,- 000 worth of “Merry Widow” scores and selections in twenty-three months. Up to April 1, 1909, three American companies played to gross receipts of $2,694,000. A Century of Archeological Discoveries. By A. Michaelis; translated by Bet- tina Kahnweiler. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $4 net. In viewing the collections of Greek and Roman antiquities which almost every important city in Europe now possesses, or in visiting the ancient sites of classic lands, it is sometimes difficult to realize that the work which produced these museum collections and unearthed the remains of these cities has been almost entirely accomplished in the last century. A few exceptions, such as the discovery of Herculaneum and of Pompeii and occasional finds by private individuals, still belong to the preceding period, but most of the ma- terial now at our disposal and the grad- ual building up of a science of arche- ology are entirely due to the labors of the last ten decades. “A Century of Archeological Discoveries,” therefore, gives us practically the whole history of archeological excavations, from the tentative and fortuitous efforts of earli- er explorers to the carefully planned, systematic excavations of today. The picture is necessarily sketchy; yet, con- sidering the size of the volume, it is very comprehensive, because not only have the actual finds been recorded, but the more important discoveries in the examination of the material have been noted, so that the achievements of the scholar as well as those of the explorer have been embodied. Of the record as it stands archeol- ogists may well be proud. At first the remnants of past civilizations were treasured purely for their artistic value. But gradually their vast importance in shedding light on the history and life of the people by whose hands they were produced was recognized, and a sys- tematic study of the material began. The result is that we have now not only a fairly complete and codrdinate pic- ture of the artistic development of these people, but in some cases past history has been actually reconstructed. Thus, thanks to the spade and the critical acumen of the Cretan explorers, we are in possession of more knowledge of the civilization of prehistoric Greece than the Greeks of the classical period had themselves. Moreover, the impor- tance of illustrating and verifying writ- ten history by the material remains now at our disposal is being more and more recognized. A book describing in concise form this evolution of the science of arch- eology had been much in request, and Professor Michaelis’s work, which ap- peared in 1906, entitled “Die archidolog- ischen Entdeckungen des neunzehnten Jahrhunderts,” was welcomed don all sides. The translation into English is a matter for sincere congratulation, be- cause the book is addressed, as the au- thor expressly says, not.so much to the professional archeologist (who would be more likely to understand German), as to all those “who have preserved an interest in and love for ancient art.” The subject, indeed, is presented not in a dry and technical manner, such as a great specialist with expert knowledge often uses, but in a fresh, narrative style which combines accuracy and scholarship with the personal element of enthusiasm. We are indebted to Miss Kahnweiler not only for a good transla- tion—as any one who has tried render- ing a German scientific work into Eng- lish will admit—but for the addition of illustrations, such as plans of Olympia, Delphi, the Athenian Acropolis, as well as of the most important sites and mon- uments, which add much to the useful- ness of the volume. There are also sev- eral interpolations; for instance, a brief mention of the recent discoveries of the British School at Sparta, which bring the discussion up to date. The chief criticism is that the work is a little one-sided. Professor Michaelis himself admits that he has devoted most space to the German excavations, main- ly because his facilities have been great- er in that direction. In fact, German investigations—even the more recent ones—have been faithfully recorded here; Dr. Dérpfeld’s theories regarding the theatre, the old Athena temple, and the Enneakrounos are all clearly stated. The excavations of the Eng- lishmen Cockrell, Layard, and Newton have also been fully treated; but those of later date, carried on by the British and American Schools, are too cursor- ily mentioned. Crete, too, comes in for a very small share, considering the far- reaching importance of the discoveries there. A few additions would remedy this defect, and it is to be hoped that in a future edition this amendment will be made. From the Fine Art Trade Journal of Lon- don we have received the “Art Prices Cur- rent” for 1907-8. The record is limited to
Page 26
AT2 The Nation. [Vol. 88, No. 2288 => es the sales at Christie’s, but, as the editor of the volume observes, any other system of inclusion and exclusion would introduce a confusing persona] element, while the vol- ume of business at Christie’s is so pre- dominantly large as to indicate fully the tendency of prices. In the series of monographs Die Kunst, edited by Dr. Richard Muther (Berlin: Mar- quardt & Co.), the fiftieth volume, just pub- lished, “Das Fest der Elemente,” attempts to show not only the use of the so-called elements, fire, water, earth, and air, in landscape gardening and pyrotechnics, but the relations which they bear to man’s read- ing of nature. The comparisons between the specimens of this art from the renaissance period and from modern times are interest- ing and suggestive. The author is Dr. Oscar Bie, the editor of the Neue Rundschau. The book is profusely illustrated. “L’Esthétique des _ villes,” by Smile Magne, treats successively of street decor- ation and movement, of processions, mar- kets, bazaars, fairs, cemeteries, of outer manifestations of water and fire (lights), and of all that goes to the artistic con- stitution of the Cité Future (352 pages, Mercure de France). “Die deutsche Landschaft: Deutsche Charakterlandschaften in farbigen Bildern,” by Prof. Ernst Liebermann(Hamburg: Gut- enberg-Verlag), is a work to be completed in eight series of five sheets each, at five marks a series. The first two series have already appeared. This enterprise, which endeavors to offer artistic quality at a low price, deserves to be commended to all lovers of German landscape, and particular- ly to those school and college teachers of German who believe in pictorial aid for quickening the imagination of their stu- dents. If they prefer an artist’s individual impressions to the unemotional accuracy of the camera, they will derive pleasure from these successful reproductions, in the rich but subdued original colors, of the paintings of the well-known Munich mas- ter. Of the different pictures, each of which can be bought singly, the following are per- haps the most typical and attractive: Thiiringer Landschaft, Buchenwald, Rudels- burg, In den Vorbergen der bayrischen Alpen, and Felder. Least successful is Bifellandschaft. The pictures are uniform in size (six by eight inches), and loosely mounted on black cardboard two inches wider on all sides. They may thus, «ven without further framing, be effectively 4is- played on the walls of the study or class- room. It will be no new observation to those who have followed the recent tendency of this of painting to say that in the forty-second annual exhibition of the American Water Color Society, now hold- ing at the Fine Arts Galleries, the old- fashioned thin washes are scarcely to be seen. Ben Foster’s Glimpse of the Sea, and H. Bolton Jones’s Early Snow, hang- ing together in the Vanderbilt room, stand out conspicuously in this respect, and make one regret that the clean transpar- ency and the light decorative value of the old style have been so generally discard- ed for methods that imitate without equal- ling, the heavier and richer effects of oils. There are a few other pictures in this manner, but they are for the most part insignificant. Perhaps, the most strik- genre ing of these—although it is by no means a pure example—is George Wharton Ed- wards’s Springtime in the Village, a large field in clear colors, crossed by two diag- onal paths. In the contest with oils, the new, carefully-worked method is most suc- cussful in the winter scenes. In a number of these—e. g., Charles Mente’s Mill Stream, and H. Bolton Jones’s Winter, the latter a pastel—the fuzzy texture of snow is represented better than can be done with the hard surface of oils, and the reflected shadows have a softer, less repulsive gleam. Another group, chiefly pastels, imitates well the glowing greens and deep blues of stained glass. Notable among these are Charles Warren Eaton's Cypresses, Reynolds Beal’s Middlehope Valley, Gustave Cimiotti’s Trooping Clouds, and Frederick Crane’s Afterglow. From these, it is an easy transition to such pictures as the Warwick Castle of Gifford Beal, with its large masses of solid, almost unshaded green, and the Lake Como of Charles Warren Eaton, with its heavy mass of ultramarine. For the rest, we can mention only The Village Green of Florence Francis Snell, showing a small group of children in a green com- mon, closed in by two converging lines of red houses; a group of pleasant out-of- door sketches, by Frederick Freer; a charming little view In a Swiss Town by Emma Lampert Cooper; The Buzzards’ Roost of J. C. Nicoll, showing a mound of ruins in a yellowish green field; an ex- excellent lifelike portrait of Enid Yan- dell, the sculptress, by Albert Sterner; and the little Puerto del Sol of Edward Pen- field. Not the least interesting part of the exhibition is the collection of etchings, prints, and drawings in the Central Gal- lery. In technique, the work in this de- partment is even more satisfactory than the brush work; the only drawback to full enjoyment is the monotony of the sub- jects chosen. Here the romantic etchings of Joseph Pennell and Ernest D. Roth stand out with some distinction. The same may be said, for other qualities, of the refined prints of Charles F. W. Mielatz, showing glimpses of New York streets and parks. For pure decorative charm the colored plates of George Senseney have a unique character; they would hang well in boudoir or hall. Altogether the exhibi- tion compares well with its recent pre- decessors, and, if not so impressive as the more pretentious displays of the Academy, is at least free from the loud monstrosi- ties that hurt the eye in the usual col- lection of oils. The chief interest of the summer exhi- bition, just opened at the New Gallery, is in the new departure made by the manage- ment. The objection to the methods of the artists who have taken possession of the New Gallery is the seme that was made a year ago (Nation of April 9, 1908, p. 340), when the Allied Artists’ Associa- tion was founded: anybody who subscribes has a right to exhibit—a plan which is bound to be fatal to the quality of an ex- hibition as a whole. The important differ- ence between the two groups is that the subscription to the Allied Artists is very small, and gives a chance .o the young and struggling, while the subscription to the New Gallery is very large, and gives a chance only to those who have arrived either popularly or financially. This year’s exhibition is an excellent proof of the point. Ata glance, it may look better than in previous years, simply because fewer pictures are shown and the walls are less crowded. But in the merit of the pictures there is no improvement whatever, and, after the first glance, the absence of any reason for the collection to have been brought together beyond the need of the artist to sell, is but too apparent. Work comes from the Academy, from the Inter- national, from the various other groups and societies, which have their own exhibi- tions at other seasons or in other places. There are a few survivors of the old Burne- Jones period, but they seem only sad wit- nesses of the day and a movement that have passed. There are several members of the Glasgow School that first dawned upon London at the last exhibition of the Grosvenor, and that now, as a school, has ceased to exist almost ag completely as the ‘“‘neo-primitives’” of the previous gen- eration. There is no possibility of co- herence in the meeting of all these differ- ent elements, nor is there cnough distinc- tion in individual work to make up for the lack. J. J. Shannon and George Henry are probably reserving their best portraits for the Academy; C, H. Shannon had more important work in the last International; the principal landscapes are by Frank Walton, Mark Fisher, and Mr. Peppercorn, who show in half a dozen other galleries. Water color is almost entirely absent, black-and-white holds but a small place. The sculpture is not remarkable. Alto- gether, the exhibition does not promise great things in the future from the new method and management. At the Carnegie Institute, Pittsburgh, the international jury in the annual art competition has announced the following awards: Medal of the first class (gold), with $1,500, to Edmund C. Tarbell, Bos- ton, for his painting Girl Crocheting; med- al of the second class (silver), with $1,- 000, to George Sauter, London, for his painting The Bridal Morning; medal of the third class (bronze), with $500, to Bruce Crane, New York city, for his paint- ing November Hills; honorable mention to Elizabeth Sparhawk-Jones, Philadel- phia, for her painting, In Rittenhouse Square; to Arnesby Brown, Cornwall, Eng- land, for his painting, The Gate; to E. A. Hornel, Scotland, for his painting Amuse- ment; and to Stanhope A. Forbes, Pen- zance, England, for his painting, The Vil- lage Industry. Among the exhibitions at the dealers’ gal- leries in this city are paintings and draw- ings by Max Weber at Haas’s, till May 8; and paintings by Chase, Melichers, Hassam, etc., at Montross’s, May 8. Theodcre Minot Clark, who from 1881 to 1888 was in charge of the department of architecture at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, died in Boston April 29 at the age of sixty-four. He was born in Boston, and was a graduate of Harvard in the class of 1886. Among his writings are “Rural School Architecture” (1880), “Build- ing Superintendence” (1884), “Architect, Owner, and Builder before the Law” (1894), and “The Care of a House” (1903). We have to report the death of two French artists, Lionel Le Couteux, an etcher of high repute, at the age of sixty- one, and Alfred Robaut, a lithographer and
Page 27
The Nation. 473 writer on art subjects at the age of sev- enty-nine. From Venice comes the news of the death of Prof. Franz Wickhoff, the art- writer, at the age of fifty-five. He wrote largely on the literary influences in art, publishing the ‘Wiener Genesis,” “Sachis Restauration der sterbenden Mutter des Aristides,” and “Diirer Studien.” Finance. THE PROBLEM OF THE RAILWAYS. It has been pointed out, as one cause for the stubborn maintenance of the higher price of railway stocks, that the dividends paid by the companies, even during the worst months of last year, were large enough to provide a hand- some margin to the buyer on borrowed money, over and above what he had to pay for interest. Such a stock as Chi- cago, Milwaukee and St. Paul, for in- stance, pays 7 per cent. per annum. Its price has lately been about 150, at which the holder would net about 4% per cent. Baltimore and Ohio, paying 6 per cent., and selling around 114, would yield 5% per cent. ‘With call loans obtainable and renewable at 1 or 2 per cent., the margin on such holdings will be 2 to 4 per cent. Even with Reading, whose price of 145 makes its 4 per cent. divi- dend yield barely 2% per cent., there is a surplus over the recent cost of call money in Wall Street. This sort of calculation is not final. The price of money might go up to 6 per cent., which would more than wipe out the margin over dividends. The market value of the stock might go down when the holder wished to sell; it would certainly do so if the money rate should rise. Or the dividend rate it- self might be reduced. All such consid- erations suggest the larger question, What is to happen to these railways and their stocks in the more distant fu- ture? Waiving the possibility of fluc- tuations in the money market, the main issue, after all, relates to railway finance, the maintenance or increase of the dividends. And this in the last analysis must depend on the future movement of traffic. In reply to an inquiry regarding pres- ent conditions, the chief of an important Western railway system has lately had this to say: Our business is not what it should be. The backwardness of the season is large- ly to blame. No disposition is being shown to anticipate good crops. The usual main- stay of the railroads at this time of year, freight made up of manufactured products, reflects only hand-to-mouth buying. This statement will probably sound odd in view of the recent statements as to monthly earnings. A number of im- portant companies published last week their gross receipts for March and the nine months of the current fiscal year. These are the principal changes from a year ago: March 9 months Gross. Gross. Erie ...........-+-+++. +$619,885 — $249,280 Union Pacific ...... + 812,231 +1,031,027 Southern Pacific .... + 629,846 —6,217,919 Atlantic Coast Line.. + 322,647 — 235,000 Northwestern ....... + 472,443 + 645,379 Rock Island ........ + 210,126 + 482,308 Southern Ry. ........ + 607,428 — 678,948 Atchison seseee + 871,202 — 103,442 Balt, & Ohio ........ + 543,801 —4,916,803 Kansas City So. .... + 36,219 — 443,707 Here is decided improvement, the gain for March alone, in a number of the companies, equalling or exceeding the whole of the nine months’ decrease. But the gain of March was made in comparison with one of the leanest months of the immediate after-panic de- pression. If the March comparisons are made, not with 1908, but with 1907, the result will be somewhat different. These are the changes from the corresponding month of the pre-panic period, two years ago: March 9 months ° Gross. Gross. Erie .....ceseeeeeeeeee $172,915 —$1,532,707 Union Pacific ...... — 42,556 + 2,853,046 Southern Pacific .... — 178,751 — 3,081,417 Atl. Coast Line .... + 147,917 — 309,479 Northwestern ...... —- 298,042 — 2,880,083 Rock Island ........ — 156,273 -+ 1,738,344 Southern Ry. ...... — 345,373 — 2,582,240 Atchison ........ — 160,983 + 713,969 Balt. & Ohio ...... — 683,827 — 7,430,870 Kansas City So. ... — 651,297 — 135,541 We are not, then, so far on the up- grade yet as the comparison with 1908, taken by itself, suggested. How soon the rest of the lost ground is to be re- covered will naturally depend, in the first instance, on the increase in traffic moving over the railways, a matter which, in its turn, hangs on the ques- tion of general trade revival. This sec- ond consideration, again, rests first on the recuperation from the effects of the break-down of credit; but, second, on the outturn of the crops. Wall Street often amuses itself with arguing that a deficient grain crop, sold at unusually high prices, is as much of an industrial blessing as a moderate crop sold at aver- age prices, or a “bumper crop” with prices below the lately prevailing level. However this may be with other inter- ests, it is not so with the railways. A hundred million bushels less produced upon the farms is a hundred million bushels less of freight. For the crop re- sults, we shall have to wait. Another factor in the recent improving earnings, which may or may not be permanent, is the higher freight rates. Since July 1, last year, local and through rates, in the South and West especially, have been increased all the way from 3 to 60 per cent. on coal, iron, steel, lumber, grain and grain products, packing-house prod- ucts, and scores of other commodities. The fixing of these higher rates was just- ly objected to, last year, as uneconomic and unfair to the consumer; but they were made. There are only two obsta- cles in the way of their remaining— compulsory revision under the auspices of the Interstate Commission, and com- petitive rate-cutting by the companies themselves. The increase will also test the force of the prediction, made by shippers’ associations when the rates were raised, that the contemplated ad- vance “would retard the return of nor- mal conditions.” “Railroad Promotion and Capitalization in the United States,” by Frederick A. Cleveland, will be issued soon by Long- mans, Green, & Co. Harper & Bros. have brought out in book form Victor Morawetz’s plan for solving the currency problem, “The Banking and Currency Problem in the United States." The views of Mr. Morawetz received so much, and well-deserved, attention when they were first published, that it is un- necessary to review them at length now. His proposal is, in substance, that the. na- tional banks be authorized “to issue notes upon their joint credit, and to control the uncovered amount of these notes by the joint action of the Secretary of the Treas- ury and of a managing board, or commit- tee, elected by the banks.” That by this, or some similar plan, our currency system could be improved at points where it is most defective, we cannot doubt; our only doubt is as to the desire or ability of Con- gress to enact a rational currency law. Two features of Mr. Morawetz’s presenta- tion of his case are worthy of special com- mendation. He appreciates, and clearly ex- plains, the fact that banknotes are in cer- tain essential particulars unlike bank de- posits; principally because by means of notes banks can indirectly increase the proportion which their reserves bear to their demand liabilities. The second note- worthy point is that, unlike many denizens of Manhattan Island, he maintains that the establishment of a central bank is not desirable or practicable in the United States. No one, in fact, has ever stated the reasons more forcibly and succinctly than Mr. Morawetz. “Compilation of Laws Relating to Trust Companies of the United States,” published by the Trust Company Section of the Amer- Financial. Buy and sell bills of Lette is exchange and make ca- ble transfers of money on all foreign points; of also make collections, and issue Commercial s and Travellers’ Credits Credit available in all parts of the world. International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. No. 59 Wall Street, New York
Page 28
| Sill The Nation. [Vol. 88, No. 2288 ican Bankers’ Association, is one of the most useful works yet published under the auspices of the American Bankers’ Associe- tiou. It covers a variety of subjects on which there has been insufficient light, and cites the important statutes of each State bearing upon trust company operation. An index at the end of each State section is a good feature. The compilation was made by Benjamin J. Downer of the New York bar, assisted by Philip S. Babcock, secre- tary of the Trust Company Section of the American Bankers’ Association. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Anderson, Ada Woodruff. The Strain of White. Boston: Little, Brown. $1.50. Baedeker, Karl. The United States. Scribner. $4.50 net. Barwell, J. W. Science, the Mind, Revela- tion, the Heart of God. Chicago: Jacobs & Holmes. Bayley, Harold. naissance: Displayed in Emblems. Dutton. $4 net. Bithell, Jethro. The Minnesingers. Vol. I. Translations. Longmans, Green Borodine, Myrrha. La Femme et |’amour au XlIle Siécle, d’aprés les Poémes de Chrétien de Troyes. Paris: A. Picard. Brebner, Percy. A Royal Ward. Little, Brown. $1.50. Cabot, Oliver. The Man without a Shadow. Appleton. $1.50. Cleveland, Frederick A., and Powell, Fred Wilbur. Railroad Promotion and Capi- talization in the United States. Long- mans, Green. $2 net. Collins, J. Franklin, and Preston, Howard W. Key to New England Trees. Provi- dence: Preston & Rounds Co. 40 cts. Crandall, Charles H. Songs from Sky Mea- dows. Outing Publishing Co. $1 net. Crawford, F. Marion. The White Sister. Macmillan. Darby, Mrs. That Affair in Philadelphia. Broadway Publishing Co. A New Light on the Re- Contemporary Important New Railroad Books McPherson’s Railroad Freight Rates: In Relation to the Industry and Commerce of the United States By LOGAN G. McPHERSON, Lecturer on Transportation in Johns Hopkins Uni- and full index. versity. With Maps, Tables, (Just issued.) The result of a first hand survey covering the entire country. So comprehensive and thorough as to be exceedingly valuable to railroad traffic men and large shippers. The general public and younger railroad men will find it lucid, interesting, and of specific application, their only means of learning what the present freight rate sys- tem is and how it has been evolved. The information as to the interrelation of the freight rates was obtained di- rectly from the traffic vice-presidents and freight traffic managers of the railroads, the traffic experts of great industrial and commercial corporations, of the shippers’ organizations of the various cities, and in many communities from individual shippers. Carter’s When Railroads Were New By CHARLES F. CARTER. 16 full-page illustrations, $2.00 net, by mail $2.16. “This invaluable account is unique. more Sun, “Full of interest. Very readable.”—New York Sun. McPherson’s The Working of the Railroads is in its 4th print- ing. ($1.50 met, by mail $1.63.) portant contribution to its branch of the subject that has yet been made."’ HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, “sew Yoar | D’Arles, Henri. Le Collége sur la colline. Paris: F. R. de Rudeval. a Gerald 8. Ghirlandaio. Scribner. net. Duncan, Frances. When Mother Lets Us Garden. Moffat, Yard. 75 cts. net. Eckloff, Christian F. Memoirs of a Senate Page (1855-1859). Edited by Percival G. It gathers the fragments of railroad history, weaving a human interest into a coherent record. A human and personal document, not a dry historical treatise, batch of statistics, or collections of anecdotes.”—Balti- Besides the general chapters on the beginnings the author gives the early history of the Erie, the Pennsylvania and the Baltimore and Ohio Railroads. of the Vanderbilt lines, the first Pacific Railroad, and of the Canadian Pacific Melbourne. Broadway Publishing Co. $1.50. Field, Claud. Tales of the Caliphs. Dut- ton. $1 net. Fifty Years of Darwinism: Modern Aspects of Evolution. Henry Holt. Flint, G. Elliot. The Short Cut. Romance Press. Ford, Sewell. Cherub Devine: A Novel. Mitchell Kennerley. $1.50. Foster, George Burman. The Function of Religion in Man’s Struggle for Existence. University of Chicago Press. Freer, Eleanor Everest. A Book of Songs, and Other Compositions. Milwaukee: Wm. A. un Music Co. Gerhard, Wt. Paul. Sanitation and Sani- tary Engineering. Published by the Au- thor, 33 Union Square. $1.50. Gillette, Fredericka B. Title Index to the Works of Honoré de Balzac. Boston Book Co. 25 cents. Godfrey, Elizabeth. A Sister of Prince Rupert: Elizabeth Princess Palatine and Abbess of Herford. John Lane. $4 net. Golden, George Fuller. My Lady Vavde- ville and Her White Rats. Broadway Publishing Co. Gookin, Frederick William. Our Defective American Banking System. Chicago Lit- erary Club. Guggisberg, Decima Moore and F. G. We Two in West Africa. Scribner. $3.50 net. Gummere, Amelia Mott. Witchcraft and Quakerism: A Study in Social History. Philadelphia: Biddle Press. $1. Haskell, Frank Aretas. The Battle of Get- tysburg. Wisconsin History Commission. Hawkins, Jean, compiler. Ghost Stories and Taies of the Supernatural. Boston Book Co. 20 cents. Jenks, Jeremiah W. Principles of Politics, from the Viewpoint of the American Citi- zen. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Jewett, Frances Gulick. The Body at Work. Ginn & Co. 50 cents. $2.25 net, by mail, $2.42. Le Socialisme A l’étranger. Avec une pré- face de M. Anatole Leroy-Beaulieu et une Conclusion de M. Jean Bourdeau. Paris: Félix Alcan. Little, Mary Wilson. Retrospection. Broad- way Publishing Co. $1. Making the Best of Things Series: The Point of View; a Talk on Relaxation; Mental Hygiene in Everyday Living. By Alice Katherine Fallows. Chicago: Mc- Clurg. 35 cents net each. Mason, Caroline Atwater. The Mystery of Miss Motte. Boston: L. C. Page. Mayne, John. Journal, During a Tour on the Continent, 1814. Edited by John Mayne Colles. John Lane. $4 net. Moorhouse, E. Hallam. Samuel Pepys, Ad- —— Observer, Gossip. Dutton. 3 net. Miinsterberg, Hugo. Psychotherapy. Moffat, Yard. $2 net. Nietzsche, Friedrich. Works. The Birth of Tragedy; Beyond Good and Evil; Thoughts Out of Season. London: T. N. Foulis. Perkins, Clara Crawford. Builders of Spain. 2 vols. Henry Holt. . Reich, Emil. Woman Through the Ages. 2 vols. Dutton. $7 net. Rostand, Edmond. La Princesse Lointaine. Edited by J. L. Borgerhoff. Boston: D. C. Heath. 40 cts. Sharpless, Isaac. The Quaker Boy on the Farm and at School. Philadelphia: Bid- dle Press. $1. Speer, Robert E. The Deity of Christ. Fleming H. Revell. Temple Shakespeare. A Pocket Lexicon and Concordance. Macmillan. 45 cents. Thompson, Ellen. A Book of Hours. For- est Press. $1.50. Torrey, R. A. Practical and Perplexing Questions Answered. Fleming H. Revell. 50 cents net. Tucker, Samuel Marion. Verse Satire in England before the Renaissance. Mac- millan. $1 net. Wagner, Richard. Letters to Minna Wag- ner. Translated by William Ashton Ellis. 2 vols. Scribner. $7 net. Werner-Spanhoofd, Arnold. buch. Boston: D. C. Heath. Wilcox, Henry S. Joys of Earth. Chicago: Wilcox Books Concern. Erstes Lese- Forty Years of American Finance A Short Financial History of the Govern- ment and People of the United States since the Civil War, 1865-1907. By ALEXANDER DANA NOYES Financial Editor of the N. Y. Eve. ‘ost. on Second and Extended Edition | of - rty Years of American + inance. Cr. 8vo. $1.50 net. The new book carries the story of the American financial markets down to 1908, describing and examining such episoles as the industrial revival after 1898, the t boom of 1901, the history of the teel Trust, the , Promo moters’ mania, the ‘rich men’s — of 1903, the ‘“‘millionzire specula of 1905 the and 1906, and panic of 1 1907. This is the first complete and thorou history that has been pub- lished of this extraordinary, dramatic and interesting chapter in finance. G. P, PUTNAM’S SONS, Sew Youx UNEMPLOYMENT: A Problem of Industry By W. H. BEVERIDGE, formerly Sub- Warden of Toynbee Hall. 8vo, $2.40 net. “It is a book which every one ought to have read who presumes to write or speak on the question of unemployment.”—West- minster Gazette. The Dial says it ix ‘‘the most im- LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., NEW YORK JUST ISSUED. Cloth. $1.50 net. : SAINTE-BEUVE Prof. George M , Princeton University. J. B. LIPPINCOTT Ct co., Philadelphia.