The Nation 1907-10-24: Vol 85 Iss 2208
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
~The 4 == — ———————> —=="_ = ESE VOL. LXXXV—NO. 2208. THURSDAY, ¢ 24, 1907 ; PRICE TEN CENTS. eer A NEW EDITION IN ONE VOLUME The Modern Reader’s Bible THE BOOKS OF THE BIBLE Presented in modern literary form by RICHARD G. MOULTON, M.A. (Camb.), Ph.D. (Penn.) Professor of Literary Theory and Interpretation in the University of Chicago. We are all agreed to speak of the Bible as a supremely great literature; yet when we open the ordinary versions, looking for the lyrics, epics, dramas, essays, sonnets, treatises, which make the world’s literatures great, we find a sequence of numbered sentences, which, as a whole, is almost as barren of form as a stenographer’s note-book. Dr. Moulton’s great work has been to so set forth the Revised Version of the Bible as to exhibit for the first time the full value of the Hebraic classics as an instrument of culture quite as efficient as the Hellenic. The inimitable freshness of primitive life which holds our interest in the Homeric poems is quite as well preserved in the epic stories of the Old Testament; the simple idyl of | Ruth is far more attractive than any by Theocritus; the lyrics of Pindar seem almost provincial beside the Psalms. The imaginative poetry of the Greeks is perfect in its own sphere, but the Hebrew prophets show an imagination quite as bold and far more spiritual. It is interesting to analyze with classic historians the dead past of the nations, but the historic books of the Bible keep us in touch with the origins of living thoughts and institutions. It is impossible that an intelligent man with any claim to a liberal education should neglect the literary masterpieces, unsurpassed and unsurpassable, of these Scriptures. The Modern Reader’s Bible Is HERE FOR THE FIRST TIME ADEQUATELY PRESENTED TO THE GENERAL READER) - Cloth, in a binding uniform with the new Globe Poets, $2.00 net; by mail, $2.18. In limp morocco, with full gilt edges, $5.00 net by | Published ~ THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “£6 Fh ave
Page 2
The Nation. A WEERLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. (Batered at the New York City Post Office ase second-clase mail matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; Philip Loring Allen, Treasurer; Ham- mond Lamont, Editor; Paul Elmer More, Associ- ate Editor. The Nation. Educational. SCHOOL FOR DELICATE BOYS Physical development and individual intellectual needs of each y- ¥- 4 attended to. amp. tutering. Part o year spent in New shire, part in Bichy Physician in attendance. of references. ddress Box 136, Dublin, Rew Hampshire. THE MICHIGAN MILITARY ACADEMY Orchard Lak h. ce, M Ideal site. Fine uipment. Prepares for colleges. Strong teaching. Genuine = tral ing. Symmetrical culture. a reform school. LAWRENCE ‘CAMERO. HULL. President and Superintendent. R TRAINING BACK WARD AND Mentally Deficient Children, NEW JERSEY TRAINING SCHOOL. Vineland, New Jersey. E. R. JOHNSTONE, Supt. Three dollars per year in ad tpaid, in any part of the United States or Meszico ; ‘to Can- ada $3.60, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4.00. Address THE NATION. Bow 794. New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Pee Whee ccccccccccccocccccccessccece 363 EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The End at The Hague ............-- 366 The Philippine Assembly ............-. 366 Protection Falling Into inane . 367 6 The Hapsburg —_—: enctnn coos 368 The “Facts” of History . 368 Cancer and Trypsin .........cccesceeess 369 SPECIAL ARTICLES: The German Book World ............- 370 News for Bibliophiles ...............++. 371 CORRESPONDENCE: Defects of College Entrance Require- TROEED c ccc cccccecccccecencoccce cco cceccss 372 Ineffective Teaching in English...... 372 The “S.P.” of Phi Beta Kappa ........ 374 374 Poe e UU E ECO CC SCE CC CCS eee ee eee ee Book REVIEWS: The Cults of the Greek States The Stooping Lady ............. Ancestors Te Wee GH @. BOOM. cccceuncssscocessese The Tents of Wickedness Leading American Soldiers ........... 378 Berlin comme je Il’ai vu . 378 A Vedic Comcordance ............csceses 379 SCIENCE: Cyclopedia of American Agriculture.. 380 DRAMA: Unpublished ee | of David Garrick .... . 380 Music: Erinnerungen an Richard Wagner .... 381 ART: Public Baths and Wash-Houses ...... 383 FINANCE: , House-Cleaning of the Banks ........ 384 BOOKS OF THE WEEK..........eseeeeee0s 385 *** Coples of The Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l’Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. Six Months Subscription FREE Any present subscriber sending a new subscription for one year to THE NATION will have his subscription extended for six months. MASSACHUSETTS, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School, New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BiGELow. Teachers’ Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Prepricters. 4 Ashburton Pl., Boston 1505 Pa. Ave —— tse Fifth Ave., “New York 414 Cen. Bid., Min nneapolis 203 Mich. Ave., Chicago 1200 Wiiliams Av., Portiand 405 ed Bid. mver 238 Doug!'s Bid. ,LosAngeles 813 Rook'ry Blk. Spokane 415 Studio ~ PL ea Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY 4A Soot Positions for Good Teachers with Good Circular and Application Form. Send ‘ter HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Tutoring. under the pefvenn e of His @unse FRANCE the Archbis hop of Westminster. English tutor taking only a limited number of pupils. Special attention to French—Three firsts in French into —_ and India Police—Foot- ball, Hockey, Tennis, bath ing. References Earl of Gainsborough, sir Hy. ichborne, Mr. George B. Emmons. Apply M. DE BAY, Les y Metteries, St. Servan, Ille-et-Vilaine, France. A University Graduate of long and experience as a teacher of boys, offers biS services as Private Tutor in New York city or vicinity. Prepares for entrance examinations in school or Would be glad to pass winter in the References of the highest character given. Address A. M., the Nation. vasrane FOR COLLEGE OR SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL. The undersigned offers private instruction to one, two, or three boys preparing for college or for a scientific school. Harvard references. Address 1105 Massachusetts Avenue, Cambridge, Mass. EDWIN P. SEAVER. EXPERT TUTORING b cialists furnished wherever cessful record in ie 2 preparation. age teachers. A. W. LESLIE, A.M., fifth Ave., N. ¥ highly trained spe- esired. 10 Financial. #12,000 WANTED for five cent. for business investment o Conservative management. Funds controlled by lender. Address BUSINESS, Box 12, Nation. ears at 15 per high character. NEW BOOKS CARPENTER’S THE CHILD IN ART LANSING’S RHYMES AND STORIES JOHNSON’S eausATm BY AYS AND GAMES KNIGHT’S MEMORIALS OF THOMAS DAVIDSON MORAL TRAINING IN THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS BURKETT’S DOMESTIC ANIMALS CINN & COMPANY - BOSTON “The best SINGLE yousus edition that has yet been published.’"—Branpme Mat- THsws, in New York Times. SHAKESPEARE mbridge Edition Edited by WILLIAM ALLAN NEILSON. Send for deacriptive circular. , MIFPLIN & CO., 4 Park Street, Boston _S 85, No. 2208 MAKE A MEMO. That will remind you to examine a copy of Steiner's Life and Correspondence of James McHenry the next time you are in a bookstore. A work of great interest in both the historical and personal aspects. A hitherto unpublished portrait of Washington by Birch is the frontis- piece. The price is $6.00 net, and the book is worth it. [_ * BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY — CLEVELAND An Exquisite Book for Christmas. THE FOOTPRINTS OF THE SAVIOUR By Rev. JULIAN K. SMYTH. Cloth, 16mo. Price 50c. net; postage 7c. ‘‘Written in cordial sym- pathy with the religious needs and experiences of the individual soul.’"—The Churchman. Send for free catalogue. The Nune Licet Press, 53 W. Coulter St., Philada. OOKS—All out of print beoks supplied, no mM . on what subject; write me, stati a wanted; I can get you a book ever = when in England, call and in cx of 50,000 rare books. John Bright §t., Birmingham, Engl School Advertising THE NATION The ation, in its special field of political and literary criticism, is un- like any other periodical, Amerfcan or foreign. It is taken by read- ing clubs and literary associations in a large number of places, and may be found on file in every library of importance in the country. There are probably few weekly periodicals whose columns offer so favorable an opportunity for reaching an audience interested in educational matters. Advertising rates, 15 cents a line each insertion, with the following dis- counts: 5 per cent, on 4 insertions, 10 per cent. on 8 insertions, 12% per cent. on 13 insertions, 15 per cent. on 26 insertions, 20 per cent on 39 1n- sertions, 25 per cent. on 52 insertion’s Orders may be forwarded through any responsible advertising agency, or directly to Tue NaTIon, 20 Vesey Street, N. Y.
Page 3
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. iii IMPORTANT BOOKS ON EDUCATION LITERATURE IN THE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL By PORTER LANDER MacCLINTOCK The book gives @ series of detailed studies on the choice and teaching of the various kinds of stories; on poetry; on the drama; on myth as literature; on the correlation of literature with the other disciplines; on the actual teaching of the class in literature; on the return to be asked from the children ; a chapter on out-of-school reading for children ; and finally a list of titles in literature for each of the elementary grades, offered as a sug- gestion to the inventive teacher, but also defended as a working program tested by expe- rience. 240 pages, 12mo, cloth, net, $1.00; postpaid, $1.12. . THE PLACE OF INDUSTRIES IN ELEMENTARY EDUCATION By KATHARINE E. DOPP. New edition, illustrated. 218 pp.; 12mu, cloth; net, $1.00; postpaid, $1.11. “*One of the most important contributions to educational thought of recent years.''—Kindergarten Review. ‘*Altogether, the book is one of unusual value, and is deserving of the wide attention it is receiving."’—Journal of Education. **Miss Dopp seems to have absorbed the best that Darwin, Froebel, and Professor Dewey have given to the educational world.’’—The Commons. : “*An admirable little book. We can only wish that it may have the wide reaching influence upon the makers of school programs which it deserves.’"—The Nation. THE SCHOOL AND SOCIETY By JOHN DEWEY. Fourthedition. 130 pp., 12mo, cloth; postpaid, $1.00. **An epoch-making book.’*—Cheesman ~ Herrick, Central High School, Philadelphia. ** A small, but luminous, and perhaps epoch-marking book.’’—Sunday-School Times. “* May the weighty little book have a large circulation and the experiment it accumpanies attain the brilliant success its ideals and its generous supporters deserve.’ '—Sylvester F. Scovel in Post-Graduate and Wooster Quarterly. THE PSYCHOLOGY OF CHILD DEVELOPMENT By IRVING KING. xxii+266 pp., 12mo, cloth; net, $1.00; postpaid, $1.11. ‘The book fills a need long felt, and it will be of great value to normal schools as well as to the teachers in elementary and secondary schools.’’—Journal of Pedagogy. CONSTRUCTIVE BIBLE STUDIES A series of text-books, by prominent religious educators, designed for use in the modern Sunday school, college Bible classes, and private study. The series comprises fourteen volumes, and more are in course of preparation. Send for detailed de- scription, sample pages, and information about auxiliary books. 104 pp. 12mo, ]| Some Types of Modern Educational Theory. By Euua F. Youne. 70 pp.,12mo, paper; net, 25 cents; postpaid, 28 cente. Scientific Method in Education. By Et.aF. Youne. 14-pp., 4to, The Educational Situation. By Joun Dewey. cloth; net, 75 cents; postpaid, 80 cents. The Child and the Curriculum. By Joux Dewey. 40 pp., 12mo, 4, 27 paper; net, 5 cents; postpaid, 97 pom 4 PP. aa net, 25 cents: oan , 27 cents, ’ Publications of the National Herbard Sostety, 1696-1698. : Isolation in the School. By Exta F. Youne, 112 pp.. 12mo ‘ The various parts may be purchased se y or in one volume o net, 50 cents ; postpaid, 54 cents. caida 1040 pages; price $5.00, net; postpaid, $6.33. ae Publications of the National Society for the Scientific Study Ethics in the School. By Ex1a F. Younc. 44 pp., 12mo, paper; net, of Education, 1902-1907. The various parts are sold sepa- 25 cents; postpaid, 27 cents. rately. Detailed information on application. ADDRESS DEPT. 21 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS CHICAGO and 156 Fifth Avenue, NEW YORK | —y ==
Page 4
The Nation. THE AMERICAN REVOLUTION Part III. SARATOGA AND BRANDYWINE—VALLEY FORGE —ENGLAND AND FRANCE AT WAR By the Right Hon. Sir GEORGE OTTO TREVELYAN, Bart. Maps, Large Crown 8vo. Pp. xii+492. Green cloth, gilt top. $2.50 met. By mail $2.68. *.* ParT I. ORIGINAL EDITION. Out of print. PART II. (two volumes) ORIGINAL EDITION. $5.00 net. By mail $5.32. A few copies of Part II. may still be had. *.* A CHEAPER EDITION of PArRTs I and II, re- vised and rearranged in THREE VOLUMES, has now been issued as follows :— Green cloth. Volume 1. Red cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net. By mail $2.18. ' . Volume 2. Red cloth, gilt top, $2.00 mez?. By mail $2.18. Volume 3. Red cloth, gilt top, $2.00 net. By mail, $2.18. With Three! INNOCENT THE GREAT By C. H. C. PIRIE-GORDON, B.A. With 4 Maps and 8 Genealogical Tables. 8vo. Pp. xxiv-273. $3.00 net. This is a biographical study, yet is not a biography in the strict sense of the word, orincipally for the reason that Innocent the Third is unknown apart from his pontificate. The anecdotes which have survived about him are few, and diaries or private letters are non-existent or unknown. He has to be criticised and interpreted in the light of, his pontifical coronation charge by which he was entirely influenced. TALES OF TROY AND GREECE By ANDREW LANG. With 15 full-page Illustrations spe- cially drawn for the volume by H. J. FORD, ani a map. Square Crown 8vo, Ornamental Cover. Pp. xii + 303, $1.50, met. Postage additional. *** The tales comprise: Ulysses the Sacker of Cities; The Wanderings of Ulysses; Meleager; Theseus ; «Perseus. JOCK of the BUSHVELD: The Story of a Dog By Sir PERCY FITZPATRICK, Author of “‘ The Transvaal from Within,’’ etc. With a colored frontispiece, 22 full-page illustrations, and very numerous border sketches of South African life, fauna, etc., by E. CALDWELL. Square 8vo, pp. xvi-475. $1.60 met. [Immediately This narrative, which is a ‘‘dog story’’ for grown-ups, had its be- ginnings in fireside stories for the Little People. It is a true chronicle of the life of a dog in South Africa, and the hunting and mining ad- ventures of its master, in most of which Jock played an important part. WILD AND CULTIVATED COTTON PLANTS OF THE WORLD A Revision of the Genus Gossypium, framed primarily with the object of aiding planters and investigators who may contemplate the systematic improvement of the cotton staple. By Sir GEORGE WATT, C.I.E., M.B., C.M., LL.D., F.L.S., Corresponding Member Roya! Horticultural Society of Eng- land; formerly Professor of Botany, Calcutta University. etc., etc. With 53 full-pige plates, of which 10 are colored. Large 8vo. Pp. xiv-406. $9.00, met. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS HENRY VAN DYKE’S van Dyke. These “Days Off’ are days in fully, with a number of the best short stories he of the year. has ever told. Leaving Off—Leviathan—Books That I Loved As a Boy. EDWARD PENFIELD The a, and beauty of Mr. been published before. The text charm of Holland. They country. HOWARD PYLE us than ever before. de Kriidener. the readers of the first volume will give to the second. THE LATER 19TH CENTURY The brilliant discussion of our most recent literature, THE CREED OF JESUS and Other Sermons HOLLAND SKETCHES Penfield’s work is well known and it is safe to say that gives a pleasant account of many parts of the are reproduced in full colors from the author's sketches, With 32 illustrations reproduced in full colors from sketches by the Aut THE STORY OF SIR LAUNCELOT This is the third in the series of the “Stories of King Arthur and His Knights,” and beauty of his drawings and the high and inspiring quality of the tex* bring these immortal stories more clearly and ~ au — 2. net. MEMOIRS OF THE COMTESSE DE BOIGNE 1815-1819 A second volume of these inimitable memories, telling of Napoleon's return from Elba, the Hundred Days, and describing intimately such people as Wellington, the Prince Regent, Princess Charlotte, Pozzo di Borgo, The “Atlantic Monthly"’ said: “She is a a open-minded DAYS OFF Those who have read ‘Little Rivers’’ and ‘Fisherman's Luck’’ will know what pleasure is in store for them in this new book by Henry the open air spent in fishing, in rowing, in thinking pleasant thoughts and telling them delight- In charm, and atmosphere “Days Off’’ stands alone among books interest, Illustrated in colors, $1.50. THE CONTENTS Days Off—A Holiday in a Vacation—His Other Engagement—Little Red Tom—A Day Among the Quantocks—Notions About Novels—Between the Lupin and the Laurel—The Perils of a Looker-On—Silverhorns—Remarks on Gulls—The Art of no such attractive book on Holland has ever and the drawings are a permanent expression of the hase of the life and landscape of the or. $2.50 net (Postage extra.) countr and show every which Mr. Pyle is writing and illustrating. The vigor Beautifunly illustrated by the Author. the Second Restoration, etc., Emperor Alexander, and Madame agreeable talker. There is no doubt as to the welcome which Frontispiece. $2.50 net (Postage extra). By GEORGE SAINTSBURY and final volume in the important serie# of Epochs of European Literature, edited by Professor Saintsbury, who is the — py —— - net. By HENRY SLOANE COFFIN, D.D. Pastor of Madison Avenue Presbyterian Church, New York City, and Lecturer in Union Theological Seminary. be found authoritatively in, the religious experiences of its founder. EPOCHS IN THE LIFE OF JESUS An untechnical and popular statement of the Christian Gospel based on the idea that the message of Christianity arose from, and is to $1.00 net (Postage extra). By A. T. ROBERTSON, D.D. Professor of New Testament Interpretation in the Southern Baptist Theological Seminary. c ica e, q a» | the reader's knowle commentary life and unity, and th e spirit of the style endues the work wit merely eloquent but remarkabiy pungent and pithy, without, of course, any sacrifice of real reverence. A unique presentation of the life of Christ interpreted in terms of the Master's teaching and spiritual experience, which are disew logit of the familiar biographical outline. ssed in The division into Bpochs gives the chain of h an altogether unusual vividness and vivacity. Its exposition is not $1.00 net (Postage extra). CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS NEW YORK . . . . [Vol. 85, No. 2208
Page 5
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, OCTOBER 24, 1907. The Week. The suspension on Tuesday of the Knickerbocker Trust Company, an in- stitution with $63,000,000 deposits, fol- lowing the difficulties of the Mercantile National Bank, with its $12,000,000, earlier in the week, cannot be charac- terized except as the outcome of pro- longed indulgence in unsound banking. The case of the Mercantile, which was saved from insolvency through the prompt and judicious assistance of the larger New York banks, is a sequel to the career of certain promoting finan- ciers, who undertook to support their outside schemes by buying control of a group of small banks and obtaining ac- cess to the surplus funds. That episode we discuss at length in the article on current finance in another column. The troubles of the Knickerbocker Trust arose, as far as can now be seen, from a not wholly dissimilar use of the insti- tution’s resources; but they must also be ascribed to the defective provisions of the law for trust company reserves, and to the wholly inadequate supervi- sion of the State Banking Department. We believe that a remedy for these evils will now be forced, through urgent and enlighten? public demand, and that the house-cleaning of New York’s fiduciary institutions will make for a much safer financial future. “Well, it looks as if legitimate busi- ness would now have a chance to get banking accommodation.” Words to that effect have been heard from hundreds of business men within the past few days. They think they see in the rescue of cer- tain banks from domination by promot- ers and stock gamblers, the promise of a return of all the banks to the tradition- al and safer methods of an older day. ‘lhat is, in a word, to utilize savings and employ capital so as to secure the steady ongoing of mercantile and man- ufacturing enterprise. The honorable tradition has been that each bank has its customers whom jt must “take care of.” That simply means that the mer chant and the manufacturer, the planter and the farmer and the dealer, shall be able to get their necessary loans, on proper security, and always be sure that good bills will be discounted for them. To minister to such business needs, banks were first created; and their chief duty should be to fulfil that end of their being. But what have we seen in New York during the past half-dozen years? Great banking institutions prostituted into tools of unscrupulous. speculators. Under such a twisted and malign con- ception of banking, business can, for a time, make shift to get on. But let a period of restricted credit befall, as in the past six months, and what is the re- sult? It is legitimate business that is first made to suffer. It is the merchant, the manufacturer, whom the president of the bank sends for and says that he is sorry, but that he is compelled to ask him to cut down the “line” that the bank is carrying for him by one-third or one-half. And interest on loans is marked up, even for old customers. But all the time, there is too much reason to believe, the resources of certain banks were being put at the disposal of pro- moters and speculators. In other words, the hold of stock gamblers upon banks has really been a grip upon the throat of business. The immense discredit into which this vicious system has now fallen must give great satisfaction to those conservative bankers who have consis- tently denounced and resisted specula- tive banking. It was to them that the very speculators had to turn, when the crisis came; and for their courageous, firm, and thorough dealing with the per- verted banks, the financial community is lastingly in their debt. What is perhaps the largest cash prize ever offered for literary effort, aside from limericks and short fiction with “heart-interest,” is put up by Sena- tor Bourne of Oregon for the “strongest and best written argument” in support of a “second elective term” for Theo- dore Roosevelt. Three propositions laid down by Mr. Bourne form the skeleton which the successful contestant is to clothe in verbal flesh. At first glance, the thing seems so easy that any citi- zen not of the undesirable sort could do it out of sheer patriotic inspiration. It is true that the first “proposition,” that the President “must and will” be re- elected by reason of “honesty, courage, initiative, imagination,” et cetera, de- mands only the sort of fervor which Dolliver, Beveridge, or any of the po- litical novelists, like Brand Whitlock or David Graham Phillips, could supply. But Mr. Bourne’s introductory demon- stration is more difficult. It must be shown that Roosevelt is competent to arbitrate the destinies of this nation, to regulate most of the affairs of a free people, to spin, on occasion, the very ‘globe in his hands; in short, to decide anything and everything—except the next Republican nomination. To show that a man of incredible justice and wis- dom must still be overridden on the question which concerns him most near- ly, demands the logical adroitness of Root or Spooner. William Allen White could make another hit like his “What’s the matter with Kansas?” if his straight- driving Western pen could only be made to explain how infallibility can be wrong in its most emphatic expression of be- lief. We suggest that a collaboration would stand an excellent chance of win- ning the prize, for the field of indepen- dent competitors is narrowed by the circumstance that some of the chief Re- publican intellects, Fairbanks, for ex- ample, Foraker, Knox, La Follette, and Cannon, will not be in the running at all. Gov. Hughes's speech at the New York Republican Club Friday night has been eagerly scanned to see if he gave Mr. Parsons, in the arms of Hearst, any comfort. The comfort is exceedingly cold. In general, Mr. Hughes restated his position of last year. He is for a resolute but patient and orderly plan of putting an end to public abuses, “with- out tumult or disorder, without injus- tice or demagoguery.” That looks as hard and straight at Hearst as did any of the Governor’s speeches last year. Still more explicit was his reference to “those political grafters who endeavor to make selfish profit out of public wrongs.” And, coming down to details, Mr. Hughes plainly declared that, as Governor, he had steadfastly refused to express either approval or disapproval of “party action or of particular can- didates’”—especialiy to “pronounce upon such action or candidacies in advance.” Now, if words have any meaning, this is intended to inform the people of this city that Gov. Hughes did not advise the fusion with Hearst. In his attitude towards national politics, Gov. Hughes seems determined to drive the poli- ticians to despair. He roundly declares that he is not seeking “any public of- fice,” and that he is not trying, and will not try, to influence the choice of “any delegate to any convention.” The men whom he has called about him in the public service, he has “counselled” to stick to their jobs, and let politics alont. No; if the people of this country have any notion of bidding Gov. Hughes go up higher, they will have to attend to the business themselves, without the in- tervention of any machine. Here is a man who makes it evident that he does not want, and will not seek, the Presi- dency; and who thinks of the burdens of that great office as tolerable only when assumed “under honorable condi- tions and at the command of the peo- ple.” What a fool! the politicians will think, to imagine that he can get on without spokesmen and workers and press agents and a personal organization. Yet such is the perversity of political human nature, such the liking of Amer-
Page 6
| | | ' 364 The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 icans for a man not too consumed with anxiety for office, that the Hughes boom for the Presidency is certain to be strengthened by his denial that he wants any boom. To call this a two-billion-dollar coun- try is to-day far inside the truth, in the view of the various officials who are now making out their estimates to lay before Congress. Every department wants more money, and as all the pur- poses for which they want it, from four new battleships to ship subsidies, public buildings, and food-inspection, are equal- ly worthy, the obvious policy is to give each what it asks. That, again, can be done only on the assurance that the country will stand the bills. Indeed, the efforts to rouse some enthusiasm which can be cashed later on have been among the most prominent features of recent news. The President’s cruise down the Mississippi, furnishing the opportunity for a thousand special articles on river improvements, the dispatch of the fleet to the Pacific, the voyages of the Lusi- tania, with demonstrations that Ameri- cans could have done still better with an adequate subsidy, down to the attacks of indigestion which could have been averted by a little more liberal provi- sion for Federal inspection, already in- .creased 500 per cent. in ten years—all these help to get Congress into a money- spending frame of mind. The last Con- gress was the doer. It had the satisfac- tion of carrying out the Presidential pro- gramme of legislation. One need not be in Speaker Cannon’s special confidence, however, to be sure that his programme for the new House resembles that of the Lords in “Iolanthe,” to do nothing in particular and do it very well. The seizure this week of 8,750,000 cig- arettes manufactured by the Tobacco Trust is very drastic governmental ac- tion. Yet this policy, like so many of the other recent polictes “with teeth,” is not based on a new law at all. It is, in fact, in the poor old Sherman law that authority for the seizure is found. Nobody ever thought before of using the section which declares forfeit “any property owned under any contract or by any combination, or pursuant to any conspiracy,” but the authority existed all along. Most so-called “lost arts” are believed by archeologists never to have existed at all. Yet the race which in- habited this country in the days before the infiltration of iron in our blood and the summary expulsion of the coward and the weakling, seems to have known a few things about making laws that will really hit the malevolent corpora- tions. Possibly in time another stanza may be added to those popular verses which tell the merits of “old wine, old books, and old friends.” “Old laws to enforce” would not be a bad working motto for the Attorney-General’s office. The refusal of the Navy Department to allow some of its officers who are studying engineering problems to wit- ness the experiments with gas engines now going on at the Jamestown Exposi- tion, is characteristic. The experiments in question are of the greatest interest to the martime world; but the the Navy Department intends to ignore them, be- cause it is not satisfied that the gaso- lene launches now in its possession are a success! One thing the present ré- gime in the Department cannot be ac- cused of—a desire to lead in the naval world. In the matters of turbine en- gines, the speed of its torpedo boat de- stroyers, the size of its battleships, its floating mines, etc., it is ever content to follow. What has become of our American enterprise and _ initiative? Since the English naval architects are at this moment discussing a thirty-knot gasolene liner and an explosion-engine battleship, one would think that the Navy Department would have detailed at least one engineer officer to go to Jamestown, and then to England, for the purpose of finding out everything pos- sible as to this new method of propul- sion. Some bright mind might even suggest that the Department ought to be experimenting itself, instead of being content to build twenty-four-knot de- stroyers, when other nations insist on thirty-three knots, and to turn out sev- enteen-knot battleships two years after the appearance of the twenty-two-knot Dreadnought. The recent newspaper statement that our army is 20,000 below the authorized strength is borne out by many facts which have appeared of late. At the un- veiling of the McKinley monument a company of the Twelfth Infantry parad- ed with but 18 men in line. The Sixty- third Company of Coast Artillery at Fort Casey, Wash., has 27 men in it, or 25 per cent. of its authorized strength. In the East there are artillery companies reduc- ed to eight and ten men. The dearth is not peculiar to any locality or branch of the service. “The same situation,” says the Army and Navy Register, “exists at all army posts, and in the infantry and cav- alry, as well as the artillery.” When regiments go to the Philippines they aré supposed to have ranks full of men with at least two years to serve. The adju- tant of the Twenty-third Infantry, which ing to the Army and Navy Journal, that there were in the regiment on Septem- ber 21 only 136 enlisted men who have service enough to go to the archipelago. Of these, only nineteen are privates, two are cooks, and the rest sergeants and corporals. Now, if every one agreed that is to leave in February, reports, accord-* ene or two causes were responsible for this state of affairs, the army might re- gard it with cheerfulness. But there is no general agreement, save perhaps on the desirability of raising the pay of the non-commissioned officers and on the relation of the prosperity of the country to the falling off in enlistments. Among the other causes assigned are the con- stant shifting of officers, and the pres- ence of many incompetent ones; rough, brutal, and inefficient or untrained ser- geants and corporals; too many practice marches and manecuvres; dislike of for- eign service; the refusal of the public to consider desertion a crime; the ab- sence of an army service corps, as a re- sult of which lack the man who enlisted to carry a rifle is compelled to become a scavenger, a teamster, a servant, or a day-laborer as soon as he enters the ser- vice; and the absence of a beer can- teen. Finally, the disease of a depleted army is a progressive one. The smaller a company becomes, the less contented it is bound to be. It takes the life and interest out of a soldier if he is made to go through a company drill when there is but a platoon, and officers similarly lose interest. So far as the pay is con- cerned, a higher rate for non-commis- sioned officers as well as for officers seems just and desirable, and would help to keep in the service a permanent staff of sergeants. But a mere increase of $2 a month in the pay of the private will help, in our judgment, not at all— nor would $5 or $10, as long as there is such unrest among the officeis and so much hard, non-military labor required of the soldier. According to the Pension Commission- er’s report for the fiscal year ending June 30, 1907, there were no less than 24,000 pensioners of our little war with Spain and the Filipinos, on the rolls on that date—only nine years after the battle of Santiago. The size of this small army of young pensioners becomes the more astounding if one remembers © that the Fifth Corps, which assaulted Santiago, had only 17,000 men in it when it sailed from Tampa, and that all told there were in service in the army in the years 1898 to 1901 not over 350,000 men. Perhaps during these years 40,000 more served for one period or another in the navy. Moreover, all of these men were supposed to have undergone before en- listment the most rigid physical exam- ination ever applied in this country, and it was confidently asserted that the pen- sion evil was therefore not to be dread- ed as a result of this war. At the bat- tle of Santiago 21 officers and 222 men were killed, and 101 officers and 1,688 men were wounded. The casualties in the Philippines were much larger, but if every man wounded since 1898 had been given a pension, and one were awarded for every soldier killed, we should still
Page 7
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 365 be unable to account for two-thirds of the noble army of 24,000. Evidently, the typhoid-fever patients of our camps are getting their fingers into the Treasury. lt must not be forgotten, too, that the 24,000 pensioners referred to do not in- clude officers and men on the army re- tired lists in consequence of Cuban or Philippine service. The Princeton Board of Trustees has voted to defer serious consideration of President Wilson’s quadrangle plan for two years. If this be a setback to the president, he may find some consola- tion in the permission given him to continue his efforts to convert faculty, students, and trustees. Two years hence he may have the heavier battalions on his side. Universities are slow-moving bodies, and many a college president would be satisfied with having to his credit so radical an innovation as the preceptorial system Mr. Wilson inaugu- rated at Princeton. It must be confess- ed that the college world has not been in the habit of thinking of Princeton as an experimen: station; but its situatign and organization make it an ideal place for trying the quadrangle system. Some- where the experiment must be made before long—thé discussion of the Eng-. lish college plun at Harvard proves that. Our universities cannot continue to grow as they have without some new subdivisions, if only for purely adminis- trative reasons. And the ever-widening gulf between student and professor is still another reason why our education- al experts should support President Wil- son in his warfare on the baneful un- dergraduate clubs, and his quest of a truer collegiate democracy. When Irishmen are not fighting the English, they are fighting each other. A bitter quarrel has been raging for some months between the Sinn Fein (or revo- lutionary) movement in Ireland and the Nationalist party. By the latest bulle- tins from the field of battle, however, it would appear that Mr. Redmond and his fellow-Parliamentarians are getting the better of the controversy. To have en- listed John Dillon on their side would alone more than make up for the defec- tion of Sir Thomas Esmonde; while the news that William O’Brien is willing to return to public life in aid of Redmond, together with the adherence of influen- tial Catholic prelates, shows which way the tide is running. The Sinn Fein agi- tation made an undoubted appeal to na- tional pride, and threatened at one time to carry cff most of Young Ireland with it. Time and argument, however, have apparently convinced the mass of Irish- men that they have most to hope from orderly political methods, and in keep- ing their representatives at work, with as solid a backing as possible, within the House of Commons, It is significant, “coast.” in this connection, that there are ru- mors of a new Irish Bill next year. Affairs in Morocco are moving rapid- ly. Even though the general trend of recent events has been towards the ulti- mate establishment of a French protec- torate, no one expected that a protecto- rate would so soon be openly discussed. Yet that is the question that is reported to have been taken up in the interview at Rabat between Sultan Abd-el-Aziz and the French Minister Regnault. As a preliminary step towards a protecto- rate, the Sultan is said to have wanted the French Government “to take imme- diate possession of the entire Moroccan This, of course, France will not do at present. So open a vfolation of the Act of Algeciras would certainly lead to trouble with Germany. But French interests are well enough sub- served by formal adherence to the Alge- ciras agreement in the matter of or- ganizing the joint European police for the ports, composed of natives under French and Spanish officers and a Swiss inspector-general. That such an organ- ization is doomed to failure, there can be little doubt. Not only will it be diffi- cult to count on the services of the na- tive police against their countrymen, but the safety of the officers themselves would be in some danger. Moreover, it is in the power of France to bring about the failure of the international police in ways financial. The Sultan must bear the cost of the police, and the Sultan, a bankrupt, is now turning to France for money. Soon he may be turning to her also for protection against his brother, Mulai Hafid. It has been clear for a long time that responsibility for the continuance of the chaos in Macedonia must be shared alike by Bulgaria, Greece, and Servia, together with the Ottoman Government. Evidence coming from partisan sources is to be had on all sides, and that por- tion of it relating to the réle of each nationality as the sufferer at the hands of the others is unquestionably true. Last week, it is reported, the Greek Crown Prince and the Cabinet partici- pated in the ceremonial laying of the foundation stones for three cities to be erected in Thessaly as homes for the Greek inhabitants recently expelled from Anchialos, Philippopolis, and other Bul- garian cities. There are to be a new Anchialos and Philippopolis, the cost of which hundreds of poor Bulgarian peas- ants will undoubtedly pay with their lives and property to the active Greek guerrilla bands. The corner-stone cele- brations must have been truly impres- sive. They carry the mind across 2,500 years to the time when Greek emigrants, carrying fire from the native altar, went across the seas to found new Corinths and Sicyons, The unbappy present-day meaning of the event is that racial war is rife in the Ralkans, and that the gov- ernments are determined not to have peace except at their own price. Macmillan’s Magazine, one of the best of the London monthlies, will soon cease publication. Macmillan’s was founded about the same time as Temple Bar and The Cornhill; all three maintained a high standard and enjoyed the credit of introducing to the public several au- thors who have since become famous. But Temple Bar has already gone, and of the trio The Cornhill will be the only survivor. A year or two ago Longmans’ also succumbed. Presumably, these magazines, which have tried to preserve some kind of literary standard, are drowned out by the flood of cheap and popular periodicals. -We are not pas- sionate admirers of magazine literature; we would not transfer, even to a good magazine, Milton’s dictum about a goo? book, and say that he who kills it, “kills reason itself, kills the image of God, as it were, in the eye.” Yet we cannot see Macmiillan’s pass out of existence with- out expressing our regret. A popular magazine, as most people know, is like an army, in that it travels on its belly; it will go as far as its advertising will carry it, and not a step farther. The importance of the advertising is indi- cated by a remark made a few years ago by a magazine publisher: “If I can get a circulation of 400,000, I can afford to give my magazine to any one who will pay the postage, and I can grow rich from the advertising.” ‘Whether this statement was ever literally true we do not pretend to say; probably the present prices of white paper would force a revision of the estimate; but, under any circumstances, the fact re- mains that the proverbial advice to the publisher of a magazine is: Advertise- ments are the principal thing; therefore get advertisements. To the achievement of this end the direct and obvious means is a huge circulation. The aim, then, is to make your stories, your articles, and your pictures appeal to the largest possible reading public. To choose ma- terial of literary excellence is fatal; for not one reader in a thousand can boast anything more than the most rudimen- tary taste. They are incapable of sus- tained attention, and they therefore de- mand all sorts of scraps and snippets; they must have even the short story shortened still further into the “stori- ette.” It is for a clientéle of this grade that many of our most widely circulat- ed magazines are obviously intended. These cheap and vulgar productions not only crowd out decent magazines where they might otherwise be read, but by gobbling up the advertising they leave the magazine of respectable but limited circulation with littie or no financigl support,
Page 8
oo re 366 The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 THE END AT THE HAGUE. A half-apologetic air appears in the very act drawn up and adopted last Thursday to summarize the work and mark the close of the Hague Conference. It speaks of the constant “desire” of the delegates to meet the hopes centred in their deliberations, yet has but a meagre array of actual achievements to submit. The world hoped for measures that would be effective in preventing war, and it gets a convention providing that fishing boats shall be inviolable in time of war!) We do not say that none of the agreements reached are of no great- er value./ The establishment of an in- ternational prize court; the extension of the Geneva convention to warfare by sea; the limitations imposed upon the collection of contractual debts, with some of the regulations about submar- ine mines and bombardments, and the pious vow in favor of arbitration, all have their merit and promise. Taking the work at The Hague as a whole, how- ever, it cannot be denied that it is a keen disappointment. But though dis- appointing, the net result is not neces- sarily discouraging. In the very fact that representatives of all the civilized nations have for four months been debating the means of pre- serving the peace of the world, we have a fresh guarantee of that peace. War is one of those evils which cannot bear publie discussion. Brutal natures may secretly exult in it; ambitious men may, in their hearts, hope to gratify their lust for power by means of it; but no one can get up in a gathering of enlight- ened men and speak of war in anything except a deprecating tone. Even when alleged to be necessary, war has to be grouped with the unavoidable calamities of the human race. On the other hand, the blessings of peace are such and so obvious as to extort tributes of praise even from those who pay them insin- cerely. And the progress of civilization and the hopes of philanthropists are so bound up with the maintenance of peace, that it is easy to enlist eloquence and poetry and logic and large aspira- tion in its cause. Hence the fact that the debating hon- ors of the Conference have been carried off by those who have been most ardent in demanding that the bulwarks of the world’s peace be built high and strong. Members of our own delegation have won personal distinction and reflected lustre upon their country by their stout championship of the advanced positions of peace-advocates. Mr. Choate and Gen. Porter have most ably expounded and defended the humane views with which President Roosevelt and Secretary Root, by their instructions, identified this gov- ernment. That the chief project, the one for an international court to pass ju- dicially upon disputes between nations, failed of final adoption, was not for lack of convincing advocacy by Mr. Choate. He found in the French and Italian dele- gations warm seconders. A large ma- jority, indeed, of the whole Conference was won over to the plan, but the re quirement of practical unanimity, in or- der to make any convention binding, proved a fatal obstacle. The real sentiments of the Conference were, in fact, often obscured by this dis- regard of majority rule. Again and again were projects recorded as “defeated,” though they had perhaps 39 votes in their favor to only 6 or 7 against. To find the seven votes in opposition be- came, in truth, the apparent task of those who would obstruct the passage of the more important measures. Fur- thermore, the national pride and per- sonal dignity of the South American delegates were often skilfully played upon to bring about the delay or defeat ef projects which it was awkward direct- ly to oppose. From all this it is clear that if the assembly at The Hague had been subject to the ordinary rules of pro- cedure, it would have decided by a very large vote in favor of measures now set down among those rejected. But this majority sentiment, though not techni- cally effective at The Hague, really does represent and actuate the majority of the nations. In that thought there is cheer for the despondent. In a way, the plan of legislating for the world’s peace—which is the main intent of the Hague Conference—is not unlike the slow establishment of par- liamentary government. H. Stanley Je- vons has written of it in the Contem- porary as if it were the faint begin- nings of the establishment of an Inter- national Parliament. Viewed in that light, we see more reason to be patient with the delays and repeated disappoint- ments. It was a long road from Magna Charta to the final vindication of the Commons’ power of the purse, and to the current proposals to strip the House of Lords of its remaining right to ob- struct the people’s will. One has but to think of all the jealousies to be com- posed, the prejudices disarmed, and the selfish interests compelled to surrender. Something of the same process is visi- ble in the successive Hague Congresses; and by the time the next one comes round, we may hope for a more assured tone and more fruitful action. Such a result we may confidently look for if the matters left for diplomatic adjust- ment among the Powers are vigorously urged, as they should be, and if the rulers and the press of the various countries meanwhile seek peace and ensue it. In some respects, and especial- ly as compared with the high hopes of lovers of their kind, tne Hague Confer- ence adjourns as a failure; but nothing is a failure which leaves earnest men only baffled in order to fight better. THE PHILIPPINE ASSEMBLY. With the opening of the Philippine Assembly by Secretary Taft, the islands enter upon a pew phase of their devel- opment under American rule. Nearly nine years ago, through inexcusable blundering on the part of our civil and military authorities, we began that need- less war upon the Filipinos which cost both them and us so dear. It is depress- ing to recall with what enthusiasm our country entered upon that campaign of conquest, and with what absurd expecta- tions of wealth and profit. The sun was never to set on our dominions; the Phil- ippines were not only to make us all rich, but were to help us obtain the greater part of the Asiatic trade; we were to make the Filipinos love us as soon as we had shot them to pieces; and, finally, interest in their affairs was, as Attorney-General Griggs put it, to cleanse American politics and inspire the nation by making it forget its “pure- ly parochial domestic problems.” From that intoxication we have long since sobered up. Not even Griggs could now make such a speech as he delivered in 1899. Our parochial problems, such as race questions and the control of cor- porations and railways, have so fully absorbed our attention that practically no one knows or cares what is happening in the archipelago. No newspaper keeps a special correspondent there, and it re- quires the visit of Mr. Taft, or rumors of war, to set the Philippine cable in- struments to ticking. We have denied to the Filipinos the tariff benefits our Re publican President declared we were in honor bound to give, and have to all in- tents and purposes told them we did not care if their trade remained hopelessly prostrate. In this affair the moral sense of the nation has proved less effective than the lobby of the Sugar Trust. In short, as recent newspaper interviews with our Congressmen have again prov- ed, we are heartily sick of our Eastern possessions. Even those pudlic men who would continue to hold the islands ex- press no enthusiasm. We ‘must, they say, have a coaling station—and, then, “We cannot let go if we would.” But the desire to sell the islands to Japan or to turn them over to the Filipinos themselves under some kind of joint protectorate grows steadily. While this extraordinary change of sentiment has been going on at home, the native hostility towards the Ameri- can conquerors has become more and more intensified. The desire for inde pendence which provoked their rebellion against the Spaniards has in no wise abated. Two-thirds of the Assembly, which listened last week to Secretary Taft’s declaration that the islands will not be ready for self-government for a generation, desire immediate indepen- dence, while the remainder ask the fix- ing now of a date in the not remote fu-
Page 9
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 867 ture. That during our nine years of possession we have accomplished some- thing besides sJaughter and destruction, no one would deny. The greatest of our achievements is the establishment of the school system, and of local self- government in the cities and provinces. And yet both of these acts have increas- ed the longing of the Filipinos for the full management of their own affairs. The establishment of the Assembly is, of course, the most striking reminder of our nation’s good-will toward the na- tives, and our promise to turn over the government of the Philippines to the Filipinos. And Mr. Taft’s sturdy stand against the exploitation of the islands by the Trusts, rich capitalists, and the horde of unprincipled adventurers that followed on the heels of the troops, is one of the things we can most be proud of. So far as the new Assembly itself is concerned, its powers are, of course, lim- ited. It consists of 81 members appor- tioned on the basis of one delegate for each 90,000 persons, and it may be in- creased to 109 members automatically. This Assembly is intended to correspond to our own House of Representatives, and the Philippine Commission is to bear to it somewhat the relation of the Senate to tha lower house. The Com- mission, which is wholly an appointed body, will have the right to veto any measure of the Assembly. In this way “too radical” legislation may be check- ed. But the Assembly cannot be de prived of its right to express its opin- ion. What its course will be, no one can foresee. That it will be vigorous in its assertion of the right of the Filipinos to their own country, we may take for granted. As well-wishers, we must hope that it will display the same ability that won for Aguinaldo’s ill-fated Parliament the praise of American observers. We wish for it, too, conservatism in utter- ance and deed, and that patience which is characteristic of those whose cause is just. That the situation in the islands, al- ready a delicate one, may be made more critical by the opening of the Assem- bly, no one can dispute. Two months ago, on August 23, on account of the re- appearance everywhere, after the Assem- bly elections, of the Filipino flags, the Philippine Commission deemed it neces- sary to pass a rigid law, forbidding the Filipinos to display the “flags, banners, emblems, or devices used in the Philip- pine Islands for the purpose of rebellion or insurrection.” But this was not all; the Commission also amended the al- ready extremely obnoxious and unwise sedition act, as follows: Every person who shall utter seditious words or speeches, write, publish, or cir- culate scurrilous libels against the Gov- ernment of the United States or the insular government of the Philippine Islands, or who shall print, write, publish, utter, or make any statement or speech or do any act which may tend to disturb or obstruct any lawful officer in executing his office, or which may tend to instigate others to cabal or meet together for unlawful pur- poses, or which suggests or incites rebel- lious conspiracies or riots, or which tends to stir up the people against the lawful au- thorities or to disturb the peace of the community, the safety and order of the gov- ernment, or who shall knowingly conceal such evil practices, shall be punished by a fine not exceeding $2,000 or by imprison- ment not exceeding two years, or both, at the discretion of the courts. All this is aimed, we learn, against “post-election celebrations in which demonstrations against American sov- ereignty are made.”” What the Assembly will say to such imitations of the Czar’s ukases, to such heavyhanded measures for limiting free speech and encourag- ing informers, the next few months may show. FALLING INTO DIS- REPUTE. When Mr. Chamberlain set out, four or five years ago, to make England pro- tectionist, the high-tariff Bourbons in this country were in ecstasies. The last bulwark of free trade was about to be destroyed. The whole world would shortly come round .to the magic doc- trine of getting rich by taxing your- self, and where could the ridiculous revenue reformers of the United States turn for comfort? Tariff revision would appear so plain an absurdity that no- body outside of a lunatic asylum could any longer talk about interfering with the beneficent operations of the Steel Corporation, for exampfe, by removing the needless duty on steel rails. All the other tariff beneficiaries were to be left encased in their fat, undisturbed. Well, a change has come over the spir- it of that dream. Our protectionists can certainly no more lift up their eyes to Chamberlain, whence they thought their strength came. He has led his party to disastrous defeat, although he had or- ganized manufacturers, after the Amer- ican fashion, to finance his campaign lavishly, which they did in the hope of writing their own duties in the law afterwards, in the manner of the Mc- Kinley Bill. Furthermore, Chamberlain is hopelessly broken in health, and per- manently retired from public life. The net result of his protectionist foray is to leave England more firmly commit- ted to free trade than ever. If anything had been lacking to complete the dis- gust of Englishmen of all parties with the scheme of a British Zollverein, hav- ing preferential trade inside it and high duties against nations outside, it would have been supplied by the new Austra- lian tariff. Against it, English newspa- pers of all opinions and public men of every faction have been declaiming ever since its schedules were first published. PROTECTION The reason is that this new fiscal law of the Australian Commonwealth is real- ly a measure of extreme protection. It builds high the tariff walls about the island continent. There is, indeed, a pre- tence of “preference” for British goods, but examination proves it to be a sham. The framers of the tariff really mean to protect Australian manufacturers against all effective competition. If 40 per cent. on blankets,for instance, would do it, the duty is made 50, and then a kind reduction of 10 per cent. is made in behalf of goods from the Mother Country. The practical result is well depicted in one of Mr. Gould’s cartoons. The British lion stands before a high tariff wall, over the top of which the head of the Australian kangaroo ap- pears, and in which two doors are built, one entirely shut, the other open a crack. The latter is a special concession to the lion. “But I can’t get through,” he protests. “You were not meant to,” cheerfully answers the kangaroo. The new tariff is regarded almost universal- ly as a death-blow to the fantastic pro ject of Chamberlain to wean away the colonies from protection by making England herself protectionist. It is safe to say that, in Great Britain to-day, pro- tective tariffs are more abhorred than ever, and free trade more firmly based than before. The National Review, which had staked everything on prefer- ential trade, now says gloomily: If we cannot get more effective support from the colonies in trade and arms colonization would mean sheer loss of na- tional blood, leading to national death. At the very time when alien aid and comfort are thus failing our American protectionists, they have to face por- tents at home. They see the high tariff denounced in the house of its friends. Never, it is probable, have so many trade associations of one kind and an- other, from newspaper-proprietors to carriage-builders, gone on record with a demand that the tariff be revised. Even the Protective Tariff League has lifted up its heel against Dingleyism, through the admission of its Secretary that the sentiment for tariff revision is every- where rising and will soon be irresisti- ble. Protection is losing the supernat- ural aspect which it long had in many minds. That it does not miraculously keep everybody employed and hold stocks at top figures, all can now see. And once this exaggerated respect has been lost, the high tariff comes in for outright denunciation. Not in our mem- ory have so many abusive things been said of it by those who formerly were its stoutest champions. In this respect, there is a striking analogy between the talk to-day about protection, and the talk, in 1848-56, about slavery. Many frank people in the South admitted that slavery was a curse. Olmsted on his travels found hundreds of men who saw the evil of the
Page 10
a, ee — ee ee ee; 368 2 | institution, and wished to Heaven it ha never been established in the South; but, of course, they all said that it would never do to free the slaves. That would ruin everything. Similarly, many protectionists are saying to-day that the high tariff contains undoubted abomina- tions, and has demoralized our politics, but that we cannot get rid of it, because to attempt to do so would bring univer- sal disaster. But slavery disappeared, and nobody wishes it back. The South is more prosperous than it ever could have been under a slave system. In like manner, overdone protection will one day be swept away, and we shall won- der that Americans so long endured it. They must see to it that they do not imi- tate the pro-slavery men, by making of the high tariff, as Von Holst showed that the South did of slavery, the more of a fetich the more untenable it was proved to be. THE HAPSBURG MONARCHY. In the discussions to which the illness of the Austrian Emperor has given rise, the remarkable feature is the absence of the pessimistic tone with which it has been customary to debate the future of the Dual Monarchy. That the ter- mination of the present reign must bring about the dissolution of the Haps- burg territories had become a common- place of European politics. Today it would appear to be admitted that not only has the impor: of Francis Jo- seph as a unifier b ~xaggerated, but that the disintegrai..., forces at work in Austria-Hungary have been unduly dwelt upon to the exclusion of impor- tant factors that make for the mainte- nance of the status quo. In saying this we do not for a moment deny the im- mense loyalty which animates the great bulk of Francis Joseph's subjects, a fact attested even by the fond way in which his former Slav or German subjects in this country speak of Unser Ka'ser. In two ways the Hapsburg monarchy was to be broken up. On the one hand, Hungary, chafing under the connection with Austria, would refuse to acknowl- edge the successor of Francis Joseph; on the other, Germany would proceed towards the realization of the Pan-Ger- manic hope by incorporating the more than ten million Austro-Hungarian sub- jects of Teutonic race. Add to these two possibilities Bohemia, with aspira- tions for Czech autonomy, Galicia cher- ishing dreams of a _ restored Poland, Italy longing for the Tyrol, with minor dreams of a Greater Croatia, Greater Dalmatia, ete., and there could be little doubt that the signal given by the Ger- mans and the Magyars would be follow- ed by chaos. On the other side, it was unlikely that in the absence of a Hun- garian secession or an aggressive move by Germany, the small Slav nations would of themselves attempt the break- The Nation. up of the monarchy. The problem re- solves itself, therefore, largely into the question whether the ambitions of Hun- gary or of the Hohenzollern rulers call for the near dismemberment of the Aus- tro-Hungarian monarchy. In both cases the answer must be a negative. However pugnacious the Magyar lead- ers may have been in their attitude to- wards Austria, they have, on the whole, recognized that the maintenance of the partnership is necessary to their own safety. The aid of the Austrian army is not to be despised by a nation eager to preserve its independence; and it is” clear that formal independence is not much to be preferred to the virtual in- dependence which Hungary at present enjoys. The argument that the Hun- garians, who have been so recusant to- wards their venerable ruler, would be still more refractory under his succes- sor, is not wholly sound. It may well be that the Magyar statesmen have hop- ed to extort from the septuagenarian Francis Joseph, who is naturally anx- ious to leave harmony behind him, great- er concessions than they could expect from a young monarch with plenty of time ahead to settle controversies. Eco- nomic reasons, no less than political, also counsel Hungary towards modera- tion; for, anxious though she may be to establish her own industrial indepen- dence, she cannot hope to do that as yet without the coéperation of the Cisleithan half of the monarchy. One of the surest guarantees against Hungarian secession is to be found in the existence of a powerful Austria; for such an Austria is not only a desirable partner, but may become a formidable enemy. In so far as concerns the Aus- trian Empire, as distinguished from Hungary, it is fully as strong now as it ever was during the present reign. In spite of continuing echoes of racial strife, the recent introduction of uni- versal suffrage has reduced to a mini- mum the danger from that source. The Emperor has recognized the advantages that would accrue from the substitution of a truly Imperial for a sectional Par- liament, and to that end he has been willing to work in conjunction even with the Socialists. The results of the first Reichsrath election last May, on the basis of universal suffrage, were disas- trous to nationalist parties, like the Czechs of Bohemia or the Austrian Pan- Germans. The leading parties in the Parliament are the Christian Socialists and the Social-Democrats, both of which as class parties are opposed to national- istic separatism. As to a Pan-Germanic movement, the elections of last May, shattering the strength of that party, removed for the moment any danger of Hohenzollern ag- gression. The German Kaiser, even if he were so inclined, would not attempt the incorporation of the Austrian Ger- {Vol. 85, No. 2208 mans without their consent. It is, in- deed, doubtful whether the Kaiser would care to make the effort in any case. It is easy enough to speak of incorporat- ing the Germans of Austria into the German Empire, but inasmuch as large numbers of the Hapsburg Germans are scattered all over the monarchy, to a large extent in Hungary, it is evident that the task cannot be accomplished without bringing Germany into confi‘ct with the Slavs and the Magyars. That such an enterprise might also mean a general war, with the Continent arrayed against Germany, must alsa be taken into consideration. Italy eager for a share of the Austrian spoils, Russia alarmed by the tremendous advance to- wards Constantinople and Asia Minor which German success would mean, France and Great Britain, as a matter of course, would all take sides against the Kaiser. For the welfare of Europe at large, it is desirable that the Austro-Hungarian monarchy should persist. The very fact that it is an association of nations, rather than a nation, makes it the fit- test place for the working out of a prob- lem that is sure to become of greater importance with time. That problem concerns the fate of the small European peoples. Are they bound to be ultimately absorbed by the great Powers, or is there a chance for the development of a strong federated state composed of small na- tionalities enjoying ‘extensive political and complete cultural autonomy? That ideal is row stirring strongly in Rus- sia among Poles, Letts, Jews, and Ar- meniars It has, of course, been agitat- ing the nationalities within the Haps- burg realm. Many shrewd observers be- lieve that the preservation of that realm guarantees the smaller nations the real- ization cf the:r ideals; and that under the protection of the Hapsburg sceptre they msy pursue their own racial devel- opment. With vie monarchy broken up tuey might be swallowed by their pow- erful neightors. THE “FACTS” OF HISTORY. A pleasant illustration of the science of history—it happens that two books are published this autumn almost simul- taneously, dealing with the same period, but with results so diametrically oppo- site as to startle even the most harden- ed reader. One of these, from the Cath- olic Summer School Press, is by Dr. J. J. Walsh, and explains its purpose frankly in the title: “The Thirteenth Greatest of Centuries.” Dr. Walsh admits that his thesis. will appear paradoxical, pre- posterous, to most people, yet it is easy to understand his point of view. Name the thirteenth century, and immediately we think of Dante and his supreme vi- sion; of the Latin hymns, Stabat mater dolorosa and Dies ire dies illa, which in the magnificence of their rhythm sound
Page 11
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 3869 like the very trumpets of heaven; of St. Francis, who for a while made Chris- tianity a reality of common life; of Thomas Aquinas, whose “Summa Theo- logie” is almost a sum of human knowl- edge; of the Gothic cathedrals, the uni- versities, the organized charities, the great beginnings everywhere — there needs no special learning to be stirred by the wonders of that age. On the contrary, here is another schol- ar, G. G. Coulton, with very special learning, who comes to us with a second edition of his “From St. Francis to Dante,” avowing that the thirteenth cen- tury was a sink of every kind of skepti- cism, vice, misery, cruelty, filth, and degradation. About the only good thing to be said for it is that the preceding ages were even worse. And his point of view is also plain. His book is based on the well-known Chronicle of Salim- bene, the gossiping, very human memoirs of a Franciscan friar, who saw the wick: edness of the world about him and set it down at length for the edification of his niece. His intention was honest enough, and so indeed is Mr. Coulton’s. Says he: I have found it hopeless, however, to give in a book of this compass more than a very small fraction of the evidence, which I have collected during the past nine years to show that what Salimbene describes is no- thing exceptional, but simply the normal state of thirteenth century society. And what Salimbene and his contem- porary chroniclers describe is so bad that a good deai of it is left in the orig- -inal Latin and tucked away in notes. Which of the two is right, Dr. ‘Walsh or Mr. Coulton? There is always an easy solution of the difficulty when doc- tors disagree. Of course, both are equal- ly right and wrong, and the truth lies in the middle—a shiftless way of decid- ing, no doubt. Yet in the present case there may be good reason for rejecting both extremes, for both writers carried an avowed prejudice into the past. Dr. Walsh is a devout Catholic, and his aim is to show the supremacy of the so- called age of faith, when the Roman Church had reached the fulness of its power. Without impugning his entire sincerity, one can see how he would in- evitably select for his picture of the age the Flowers of St. Francis rather than Salimbene’s prying Chronicle, and the activity of the universities rather than the horrors of civil war. But the preju- dice of Mr. Coulton is no less marked; he is a stalwart believer in Progress, and goes to the thirteenth century with the settled conviction that it must be seven centuries worse, as it is seven cen- turies earlier, than the twentieth. He has an absolute measuring rod for the rise of civilization, and to belong to the past is to be damned. Naturally, in his endeavor to flatter the living at the ex- pense of the dead, he does not dwell on the ancient triumphs of art and relig- ion, but gathers his evidence from the reformers and scandal-mongers of the period. And as the thirteenth century is commonly called the age of faith, he is bound, first of all, to make it out an age of doubt: The world is far purer and better for the decay of sacerdotalism. One-tenth of the abuses that reigned in the thirteenth century would have sufficed to wreck any cburch in a less barbarous age. Art was not the produce of medizval religion, but of wWorldliness under some restraint of religion, etc. Now, we all believe in Progress, but is it not possible that the doctrine of advance, held absolutely and mechanical- ly as Mr. Coulton holds it, may become a source of error the more insidious as it falls in more perfectly with the cur- gent of the day? There is such a thing as the fallacy of the present, just as there is a fallacy of the past. And these two fallacies point to two historical methods whose difference is deeper-seat- ed than the prejudices of Catholicism and Progress. What, in a word, is the true criterion of an age, the products of its higher and rarer imagination, or the daily, unrelieved life of the multi- tude? Who reports the thirteenth cen- tury truly, Dante or Salimbene? Certainly, Dante saw and experienced evil enough in his lifetime. He was pointed at in the streets of Florence as the man who had been through hell; but he had also seen the vision of peace. How real to him was the consolation of that vision, and to what degree does he stand for his age? It is a question of the reality of the imagination. His- torians of the type of Mr. Coulton would give to that reality the least value. For the distress of Dante’s exile they see little compensation in his inner life, and even this little is peculiar to himself and without meaning to the people for whom he wrote down what he felt. Again, the danger before the historian is the more insidious because it accords with his training. The great works of the imagination are open to all who can read; the task of the scholar is to run down the obscure records of an age and build up his picture from what the world ignores—otherwise, in what is he iearned? And the temptation lies there. These obscure records are just those that contain the minute and ephemeral transactions of life, and it is extremely difficult to dwell among them continual- ly without coming to regard them as the only reality, and thus emphasizing them far beyond their desert. Dante’s glimpse of Beatrice grows more and more a shadowy thing, and Salimbene’s com- plaint over the vermin of the convents more and more a characteristic of the century. Not many historians can pre-. serve their balance; can at the same time see the great things and the little things of the past, and compute the gains and losses of time. Hence the so- called science of history offers one oi the subtlest temptations to distort the facts. CANCER AND TRYPSIN. A little more than a year ago we print- ed an article on the treatment of can- cer by trypsin, summarizing expositions of the process contributed by Dr. C. W. Saleeby to Harper’s Weekly and Mc- Clure’s Magazine. In conclusion we re- marked that Dr. Saleeby’s zeal would be discounted by cool observers, espe- cially in view of the fact that compe- tent authorities in London, where the method had been tried, were skeptical as to cures. In the twelvemonth that has passed trypsin has been employed in this country, in England, and on the European Continent. On the basis of these experiments Dr. Saleeby again writes in eager support of the treat- ment, this time in the September issue of the Contemporary Review. In spite of his warmth, well-trained scientists will, we believe, still maintain an atti- tude of skepticism. In the first place, the theory upon which trypsin is urged—first propound- ed by Dr. John Beard, lecturer on com- parative embryology in the University of Edinburgh—is not yet proved, and is, indeed, imperfectly understood. These matters are, of course, beyond the lay- man; but so distinguished a patholog- ist as Prof. James Ewing of the Cor- nell Medical School is quoted in the Journal of the American Medical Asso- ciation, December 15, 1906, as wholly un- able to follow Dr. Beard’s reasoning, “either embryologic or physiologic.” Pro- fessor Ewing has also talked with vari- ous other “embryologists and physiol- ogists, and has found that they, too, have been unable to grasp” Dr. Beard’s meaning. But, as Dr. Saleeby says, “the theory is naught.” It may still be prov- ed true; and even if it is both incom- prehensible and false, trypsin may con- ceivably cure cancer. Let us, then, examine some of the cases in which he pins his faith. Three difficulties attend such examination. For one thing, cancer is a generic term, used by the laity and by many physicians to cover a group of tumors, varying in malignancy and obstinacy. For exam- ple, epithelioma, a skin-cancer, is fre- quently excised completely and perma- nently by the knife, and it sometimes breaks down and disappears under ap- plication of X-rays or radium. There- fore, cures of epithelioma signify little as regards the more malignant and deep- seated types of carcinoma. Furthermore, unless the cancer is exposed on the sur- face of the body, exact diagnosis is often impossible. Even microscopic examina- tion of a small scrap may be inconclu- sive; for the cells may be mixed and different fn different parts of the tumor
Page 12
— aE 370 As the New York Medical Record for December 22, 1906, puts it, there may not be absolute certainty “until this diagnosis has been made a number of times by a number of competent micro- scopists.” And, finally, a cancer is not really cured if it returns to the same or to some other part of the body within three years. With these points in mind, we may consider some of the cases in this country to which Dr. Saleeby points with pride. The first was published by Dr, Clar- ence Rice in the New York Medical Rec- ord of November 24, 1906. “This,” says Dr. Saleeby, “is a case of what cannot be doubted to have been cancer of the larynx, and it was cured.” Dr. Rice re- ports four cases, of which only one was benefited by trypsin. He and other physicians think the cured case was a malignant cancer, but there was no mi- croscopic examination; and the exact nature of the tumor is therefore uncer- tain. Dr. Saleeby next cites a report on twenty-nine cases, including “two abso- lute cures,” by Dr. William J. Morton in the New York Medical Record, December 8, 1906. “Many of the other cases,” adds Dr. Saleeby, “are now going on toward cures.” But Dr. Saleeby fails to note that the two “absolute cures”—to date—re- ported by Dr. Morton, were epithelioma; and that most of the cases were also treated by X-rays. Of the other twenty- seven cases, five were dead at the time of the report; three had to be operated on; three were benefited but little or not at all; and sixteen—six of them epith- elioma—were improved, at least tem- porarily. The report, however, does not say they “are going on toward cures.” In one of the operated cases, Dr. Mor- ton tells us, “a remarkable process of retrogression by degeneration and atrophy of a carcinomatous breast gland to final and curative obliteration has been microscopically demonstrated.” This case Dr. Saleeby described in an ar- ticle in Harper’s Weekly, January 19, 1907, as “the most valuable, because of the completeness of the demonstration.” Yet, according to an article in the New York Medical Journal of March 2, 1907, by Dr. William Seaman Bainbridge, who performed the operation mentioned above, Dr. Morton’s report was “pub- lished in advance of a thorough study of the entire tumor mass, and against my most emphatic advice.” What is more, the patient died in four months, with metastatic cancerous growths in many other parts of the body. Another case noted by Dr. Saleeby was a multiple fibrosarcoma of the tongue reported by Dr. Frederick Holme Wiggin of this city for the Journal of the American Medical Association, De- cember 15, 1906. According to Dr. Salee- by, the patient was “treated and cured by trypsin and amylopsin”: but accord- The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 ing to Dr. Wiggin, “the growths at the back of the tongue had not quite dis- appeared.” Dr. Wiggin also speaks of the case as “inconclusive.” Indeed, two pathologists pronounced it fibroma, and not sarcoma; in other words, not ma- lignant. Again, Dr. Saleeby tells us of a case of cancer of the stomach treated in the clinic of Professor Von Leyden of the University of Berlin, and reported last January in a German medical pub- lication. The remedy applied was “tryp- sin, amongst other things,” and the re sult was “either great improvement or recovery.” Yet, according to the Journal of the American Medical Association, May 4, 1907, the verdict from Von Ley: den’s clinic is, “that trypsin to date, while displaying a curative influence, cannot yet be heralded as a definite method of treatment.” We have considered Dr. Saleeby’s strongest cases; we will not weary the reader with an analysis of the others. It is evident that Dr. Saleeby has writ- ten with the enthusiasm of a poet on a subject that demands absolutely dispas- sionate discussion. Trypsin—like sever- al other methods of treatment—appar- ently checks, at least temporarily, the growth of one or more varieties of can- cer and breaks down the cancerous tis- sue. Possibly a complete cure for cer- tain forms of cancer, even the malig- nant, may yet be worked out through the employment of trypsin. But that is a matter of speculation. We must wait several years before we can pass on the question of permanent recovery. We should therefore be guilty of exciting groundless hopes if we did not say frankly that to-day there is not a single unequivocal record of malignant sarcoma or carcinoma cured by trypsin and amy- lopsin alone. THE GERMAN BOOK WORLD. The most ardent adherents of the ultra- modern school of German literature are beginning to admit that a reaction has set in. A general revision of the critical stand- ards introducec by youthful heretics has resulted in a return to the’old ideals and in a restoration to their former exalted places of almost all the masters regarded as classics. The personality of Goethe was not esteemed at its full worth until it began to be compared with that of the most pow- erful moulder of modern German thought, Nietzsche. Even by so radical a writer and reformer as Ellen Key, who has be- come more popular in Germany than in her rative Sweden, Goethe is now pronounced the consummation of what Nietzsche only aspired to. The steady progress of the Goethe renascence far surpasses the Schil- ler revival which seemed to have begun at the occasion of his centenary. Even the tradition that Schiller alone is the Ger- man people’s own poet is being disposed of by the fact that a demand for good new ecitions of Goethe at moderate prices and of popviar works on Goethe has increased until the publishers’ output in this field has assumed remarkable proportions. Selections being much favored by Ger- man readers, the number of Goethe books of that kind is almost appalling. Dr. Wil- helm Bode, the editor of the quarterly magazine Stunden mit Goethe, now in its third year, has edited a selection of the letters of Goethe in two volumes under the auspices of the Deutsche Dichter Gedachtnisstiftung in Hamburg, and has also compiled two volumes of aphorisms from Goethe’s conversation, called ‘“‘Goethe’s Gedanken nach seinen miindlichen Aus- serungen (Berlin: Mittler & Sohn.) More of Goethe’s conversation is being offered in “Goethe im Gespriich,” edited by Franz Diebel and Fried. Gundelfinger for the Insel-Verlag of Leipzig. One of the most practical collections of aphorisms is prob- ably that compiled and arranged under different headings by Theo. Achelis, and en- titled “Was sagt Goethe?’ (Stuttgart: Greiner & Pfeifer.) A new edition of the Conversations with Eckermann has been prepared by Adolf Bartels for Eugen Diederichs, Jena. This firm is also publish- ing the correspondencewith Bettina vonAr- nim, edited by Jonas Frankel, and a note- worthy edition in two volumes of the corre- spondence with Schiller, prefaced by Hous- ton Stewart Chamberlain, whose character- ization of the two German masters is one of the best in our modern criticism. There are numerous new editions. Dr. Georg Eillinger is supervising the critical edition which bears the imprint of the Bibliograph- ical Institute of Leipzig; and the Goethe Gesellschaft of Weimar plans an edition in six volumes, revised by Erich Schmidt, which is to be the people’s Goethe. The same society has published a comprehensive cc section of “Maximen und Reflexionen.” The “Goethe Jahrbuch,” now in its twenty- sixth year, edited by Ludwig Geiger, is still dcycted to the more serious work of Goethe s:bolars. There are new editions of the Italian Journey (Berlin: Julius Bard), and of the poems (Berlin: S. Fischer). Among books on Goethe and his work may be mentioned Carlyle’s, in a fine new edition by Oesterheld of Berlin; and “Goethe’s Tod,’ a faithful record of his ‘death by Karl Schiiddekopf, is published by the Insel-Verlag of Leipzig. Among the Breslauer Bietrage zur Literaturgeschichte is a treatise on Goethe’s nature-sense by Arthur Kutscher. Eugen Diederichs, Jena, publishes Jacob Minor’s address on Goethe's “‘Mahomet,”” given at the Goethe Day in Weimar. A remarkable work has been un- dertaken by Hans Gerhard Graf for the Literarische Anstalt, Riitten & Loening of Frankfort. it is a chronological record of Goethe’s opinion of his own works, call- ed “Goethe iiber seine Dichtungen,” of which five volumes cover the epic and dra- matic poems alone; the sixth is to be de- voted to the dramas, and the seventh to his tyrical poetry. Nor should the pic- torial Goethe be forgotten: ‘“‘Goethe Bilder- buch” (Leipzig: Schulze), with its well- selected and finely reproduced portraits and pictures and the carefully edited text. The “Goethe Kalender,” edited by Otto Julius Bierbaum, who with the late Hartleben was one of the faithful adherents of Goethe dur- ing the storm and stress, is eagerly wel- comed year after year. German Romanticism comes in for a large share of attention. An edition de luze of Brentano’s “Gockel, Hinkel, und Gackeleia,”’
Page 13
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 371 with the designs which the author himself had made for the book, is limited to 300 copies and published by the Insel-Verlag of Leipzig. Bettina von Arnim’s novel, “Giinderode,” is being brought out by the same house. Brentano’s “Godwi” is repub- lished by Hermann Seeman, Berlin, and two volumes of selections from his writings bear the imprint of Herder, Freiburg. The centenary of Anastasius Griin has been productive of a new complete edition of his works in ten volumes (Leipzig: Max Hesse). That delightful piece of broad old German humor, “Die Jobsiade,” by Kortum, has been edited and prefaced by Bierbaum and reprinted in a garb faithfully reproducing the typography and binding of the period when it was first given to the laughter- loving world (Leipzig: Insel-Verlag). Among the rare and curious works reprint- ed under the collective title Die Frucht- schale, by R. Piper of Munich, are Jorg Wiekram’s story, “Der Goldfaden’”’ (1557); a volume of aphorisms by Friedrich Schleg- el, called “‘Fragmente und Ideen’’; auto- biographical fragments by Adalbert Stift- er; a new edition of Platen’s journal; and the Irish fairy tales collected by the Grimm brothers. A complete edition of their “Kinder und Hausmirchen” is _ being brought out by J. G. Cotta of Stuttgart. Kleist is being republished under the su- pervision of Wilhelm Herzog by the Insel- Verlag. The same house announces for publication in the spring the last work from the pen of Nietzsche, “Ecce Homo,” while the publisher of Nietzsche’s complete works (Leipzig. C. G. Naumann) plans a pock- et edition in ten volumes at a moderate price. A library of selections from the writings of the classics bears the pompous title Statuen deutscher Kultur (Munich; Beck). However carefully they are com- piled, it seems doubtful whether the ex- cerpts from Jean Paul’s “Titan” and “Flegeljahre,” published respectively under the titles ‘‘Triume” and “Idyllen,” will convey a correct impression of the au- thor’s individuality to one not already fa- miliar with his writings. The same doubt arises with reference to the tales culled from “Heinrich von Ofterdingen’”’ and pre- sented under the title “Novalis’ Marchen.” Ecually ponderous is the collective name bestowed upon a similar enterprise, Er- zieher zu deutscher Kultur (Jena: Eugen Diederichs). The introductory volume, “Schiller als dsthetischer Erzieher,” con- tains about two hundred extracts from his vritings carefully selected and arranged by Alexander von Gleichen-Russwurm, whose name appears also on the title-page of the little volume in the Kultur series (Berlin: Marquardt & Co.) called “Schillers Weltanschauung und unsere Zeit.”” A com- pinion volume to the former work is en- tilted “Klassische Schénheit,” and con- tains selections from Winkelmann and Lessing. ‘Hans Sachs als Humorist,” with commentary by Otto Brandt, and the “Schopenhauer-Brevier,”’ by Rudolf Pres- ber, are books of the same order. Tolstoy and Ibsen have not escaped this new form of literary exploitation. Their reading of life is presented in the “Tolstoi-Buch,” by Dr. Heinrich Meyer-Benfey, and “Schicksal und Wille,” by Dr. Wilh. Hand. A curiously interesting work is called “Zehn lyrische Selbstportraits” -(Leipzig: Theo. Weicher). It contains facsimile re- productions of autobiographical sketches of ten contemporary German poets: Ferdi- nand von Saar, Felix Dahn, Johannes Tro- jan, Martin Greif, Ernst von Wildenbruch, Detlev von Liliencron, Gustay Falke, Arno Holz, Richard Dehmel, and Otto Julius Bierbaum, with portraits from life by M. A. Stremel. Some additions to the Kultur series are of special interest. Dr. Kithe Schirmacher presents an exhaustive state- ment of the relations between Germany and France since the war of 1870-1, “Deutschland und Frankreich, seit finfund- dreissig Jahren.’’ Her scholarship and many years’ residence in France have peculiarly fitted her for this task. Johannes Schlaf contributes a_ singularly dispassionate treatise on war, “Der Krieg,’”’ in which he ives America credit for changing the drift of modern thought on that subject, speak- ing appreciatively of William Lloyd Gar- rison, the non-resistant. Eduard von Mayer iu “‘Fiirsten und Kiinstler” shows in his- torical and philosophical perspective the relations between the artists and the pat- rons of all times. Jarno Jessen draws a sympathetic portrait in “Kaiserin Fried- rich,” a woman whose social service ani many British innovations endeared her to those Germans broad enough to overlook the hated British alliance and to see in her a remarkable personality. The editor of the series, Dr. Cornelius Gurlitt, is the au- thor of a book, “Dresden,’’ which presents a vivid account of its development as a centre of German culture. Marie von Ebner-Eschenbach calls a se- lection from her works intended for young readers “Aus meinen Schriften” (Berlin: Gebr. Paetel). It contains some of her gems, like the inimitable dog sto- ries, “Die Spitzin” and “Krambambuli”; and also some of her romantic tales, po- ems, and aphorisms, which will be enjoyed by readers of every age. Otto Ernst, who as a dramatist has risen to a prominent place through ‘‘Flachsmann als Erzieher,” and as a novelist became famous through “Asmus Sempers Jugendland,” is also a charming causeur. His volume of humor- ous talks, “Vom geruhigen Leben” (Leip- zig: L. Staackmann), is a mine of homely wisdom, with not a few critical thrusts at education, society, etc. Wilhelm Schar- relmann, who will be remembered for his controversy with the school authorities of Bremen, and who, in collaboration with Johann Wiegand, wrote that powerful play “Krieg,” which was by some critics at- tributed to Gorki, has published a volume of short stories, “Die Fahrt ins Leben” (Berlin: Egon Fleischel & Co.). With a remarkably firm grip upon the realities of life he combines exquisite sentiment. Some of these scenes of everyday life are prose poems. Herman Hesse, who since the publication of his novel “Peter Camenzind” and the deep impression made by his story of school life, “Unterm Rad,” has become one of those figures in contemporary Ger- man fiction that stand for strength, orig- inality, and seriousness of purpose, has written a book of stories. They need no heading like “Aus Kinderzeiten” and “Der Lateinschiiler” to suggest a background of personal reminiscences, and justify their collective title, ‘“Diesseits” (Berlin: S. Fischer). With charming simplicity, the author reveals the source of his inspira- tion—the homely incidents of average life. But there is a dignity and sweetness about his realism. which proves the progress German fiction has made since it has out- grown the naturalistic creed. A. VON ENDE. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. A little book, well known to collectors of first editions of Charles Lamb, under the title “Original Letters, &c., of Sir John Falstaff and His Friends,” has been included with more or less justice in the various Lamb bibliographies. It was published in 1796, “Printed for the Author.” The strongest evidence that Lamb actually had any hand in the little book is in a letter by Southey te Moxon, dated February 2, 1836, more than a year after Lamb’s death. Speaking of Lamb’s friend, James (or “Jem’’) White, Scuthey says: “He and Lamb were joint authors of the ‘Original Letters of Fal- staff.’"’ John Matthew Gutch, who was also a Christ’s Hospital boy, wrote in his copy of the book: These Letters were the production of my old schoolfellow, James White, with inci- dental hints and corrections by another schoolfellow, Charles Lamb. That indefatigable searcher after everything relating to Lamb, Ernest Dressel North of this city, has discovered an interesting copy of the book. The sheets are actually of the first edition, but there is a reprint- ed title-page reading, ‘“‘The Second Edition,” and dated 1797, instead of 1796. On one of the fly-leaves is this inscription, apparently in Lamb’s own autograph: “To be half bound & Letter’d ‘Falstaff’s Letters.’ ’’ This is evidently one of the copies of which Bryan Waller Procter tells in his “Memoir” of Lamb: “Lamb thought highly of White’s book, which he used often to purchase and give away to his friends, in justification ot his own taste, and to extend the fame of the author.” And Procter adds: “The copy which he gave me I have still.” On Tuesday afternoon and evening, Oc- teber 29, the Anderson Auction Company of this city sells a selection of books from the library of an old New York collector, There are a few items of Americana: Egede’s “Description of Greenland,” 1745; Gordon’s ‘‘New Jersey,”’ 1834; a presentation copy of Kennedy’s ‘“‘Texas,” 1841; Ramsey’s “Annals of Tennessee,”’ 1853, etc. On October 30 and 31 this firm offers the library of H. C. G. Bals of Indianapolis, which con- tains, among other desirable lots, Chaucer’s Works, Bonham’s edition, without date, but issued about 1550; first editions of Dickens, Thackeray, and Lever; a few good Western books, such as Dillon’s Indiana, 1843, and a long series of presentation copies of James Whitcomb Riley’s books. The copy of Gabriel Thomas’s “Historical and Geographical Account of the Province and Country of Pensilvania and of West~- New-Jersey,”” London, 1698, which was offer- ed at the sale of the library of Rev. Horace E. Hayden in Philadelphia on October 17, brought $825. Two copies were sold at auc- tion in London last season, one bringing £160 at Sotheby’s on May 6, and the other £99 at Hodgson’s, on May 31. The previous American record was $805, in the McKee sale in 1902.
Page 14
se A ee meu
eS ene Bee oe <r ee ~
a
B72 The Nation.
[Vol. 85, No. 2208
Correspondence. DEFECTS OF COLLEGE ENTRANCE RE- QUIREMENTS. To THe Epiror oF THE NATION: Sir: The New England Association of Colleges and Preparatory Schools gave much of the time of its meeting last week to the discussion of college-entrance re- quirements and examinations, a subject which, in some of its aspects or particu- lars, is almost inevitably assigned a place every year in the programme of all our lerger educational associations. Indeed, the subject is of paramount importance to the majority of secondary schools, for the de- mands of the colleges determine in great measure both the extent and the kind of teaching done by the schools. In the consideration of this subject the opinions of certain classes of persons are to be received with caution. These are: First, teachers in schools which from their situation or by choice prepare for a single college; secondly, those college authorities whose views are based upon the feeling in such schools; and, thirdly, those teachers whose one cry is always for easier require- ments and easier examinations, to the end that their own work may be the easier. The first two classes are not able to understand how great a boon uniform requirements for the different colleges would be to the ma- jority of schools, and how greatly the schools desire this uniformity. As to the last class, I venture to assert that it is much smaller than college authorities seem disposed to consider it. As a matter of fact, teachers know that it is not a difficult thing to prepare a boy of any ability for any college in a reasonable time, if he and his teachers can devote themselves to direct preparation for the entrance exam- inations of the college of his choice. If any one doubts this, let him investigate the re- sults obtained by private tutors. The secondary schools would do well, it seems to me, to agree to urge upon the colleges the two vital objections to the present system, and to abandon the irritat- ing discussion of details until there have been established the general principles up- on which the objections rest. The first of these objections is that there is still so great a diversity in the requirements of different colleges that the schools cannot arrange any course of study in any sub- ject which shall prepare for all colleges, or even, it is almost safe to say, for any two colleges. This fact may unconsciously influence the attitude of some private schools which owe their patronage largely to their fitting boys to meet the peculiar requirements of a particular college. It is perhaps not to be expected, or even de- sired, that all our colleges will agree to require only the same subjects of candi- dates for admission, but it certainly Is pos- sible to make the requirements in a given subject identical and to express them in identical terms. It serves no high purpose, for instance, that Princeton alone should require Sallust, and Yale alone require the Bucolies of Virgil; that Yale should base her examipation in Latin grammar upon the Catilinarian orations of Cicero, while Harvard sets these orations for the final examination and asks the questions in
grammar in the preliminary examination. It is uridignified and demoralizing for a school to have to teach candidates for Harvard in ene section, candidates for Yale in another, and candidates for Princeton in a third. But there is something infinitely worse than lack of uniformity. Uniform require- ments might be vicious, and uniformly vi- cious requirements seem to me likely to be the result of the little tendency toward uni- formity that one may detect in the require- ments in Latin. Many teachers would un- doubtedly be. willing to see the colleges agree upon the same four books of Cesar, six orations of Cicero, and six books of Vir- gil. For my part, I should prefer to continue to prepare some of my stu- dents for a college here or there which asks only that I send to it boys wno can show that they have had the training which thorough study of the language gives and that they can read Latin. I believe, as I have said elsewhere, at greater length and with a fuller setting forth of the reasons, that a much smaller portion of the Iitera- ture should be prescribed, and that ability and power should be tested by examinations at sight. If the college must know what authors and how much of them the candi- date has read, a certificate from the school would put it in possession of the facts. I do not intend to enter here into an at- tempt to prove anew the value of the trans- lation at sight as a test. I shall merely make the assertion that it may be made to test the quality of the work done, and that this is more important to the college than the quantity. Furthermore, I do not urge this plan of examination as an easier one than that now in vogue. I know by experi- cnce that it is harder to prepare a boy so that he stall be able to prove that he has some mastery of Latin than it is to prepare bim to show that he has been carried through certain parts of certain authors. Many teachers meet the present require- ment by simply coaching their students ip the authors prescribed, and any system that encourages this does an injury to the teacher and the boy, and to the cause o true education. ’ I may state the second objection to the present system, then, by saying that it holds the schools to a narrow drudg- ery, and prevents them from set- ting before themselves the highest ideals and from contributing their share towards rational education. The Latin requirements doubtless give the best illustration of the evils to which I call attention, but the evils exist to a greater or less degree in o\her requirements of the colleges. The college entrance requirements will not satisfy the schools until they are made uniform, and so long as the colleges keep the requirement in any subject one pri- marily of quantity they will continue to have reason to complain of the quality of the preparation in that subject. They them- selves have put the empbasis in the wrong piace. That they cannot so arrange their requirements and examinations as to de- mand and receive satisfactory evidence of thorough preparation without prescribing the full and exact amount to be studied, is a@ priori unreasonable, and has been proved untrue by the long experience of at least one great university of our own ceuntry. JOHN C. KIRTLAND. JR. Exeter, N. H., October 14.
INEFFECTIVE TEACHING IN ENGLISH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Two articles entitled “Overdone Teaching in English” have recently ap- peared in the Nation. Last week, at a meeting of the New England Association of Colleges and Preparatory Schools in Bos- ton, there was a further attack upon Eng- lish as it is taught in the schools and colleges. This cumulative arraignment. can not but sting into instant questioning: any one who is attempting, with the re- proach ever before him of the “monstrous: disproportion between energy expended and results’ obtained,” to teach English im either school or college. Is the teaching of Exglish in our preparatory schools rea}- ly overdone, or is it wrongly, ineffectively done? Is the difficulty a matter of quan-- tity and nature of material, or is it a mat-- ter of method of attack, of end in view? These are the questions crystallized by the: attacks of Prof. F. B. Gummere, Prof. A.. G. Newcomer, and the New England Asso- ciat'on of Colleges and Schools. Bo h Professor Gummere and Professor Newcomer maintain that the radical error in o'r present system of English instruc- tion is the amount and nature of the read- ing prescribed. They would reduce by half the present list, discarding fiction, such as, “Ivanhoe,” as never meant for study, set- ting aside the intenser classics, such as “Macbeth,” for matureryears. There might, one may grant, be a wise simplification of the l'st of books assigned for careful study: “Macbeth” might, perhaps, give way to a simpler historical play—though I question it; Burke’s “Speech on Conciliation” may more certainly yield with profit to short- er speeches. But to reduce the list by half, and substitute for a first-hand deal- ing with books a history of literature with certain selected texts as samples, would surely be a fatal retrogression. There must inevitably result a cramming of the mind with dead material of dates and char- acteristics; we should have conscientious teachers giving the book in toto; and then, speedily, examinations covering the ground from Caedmon to Stevenson—the very cam- el of the fable stalking through our schools in place of the gnat. The whole present system is, after all, a System of samples, and Professor Gum- mere’s contention that our study of the “classics” leaves no rich field still fallow, and results in “an invasion and forced possession of lighter literature which time can seldom cure,” is hardly justified by facts. The whole land of the ballads and of Scott Hes behind “Ivanhoe’’; the whole Forest of Arden, the coast of France, and the London of Prince Hal, the Rome of the ancient Ca@sars, lie away beyond the bor- ders of the Scottish heath. And many boys and girls learn the way to them in the school. My own experience in preparatory teaching, the general consensus of opinion among freshmen newly come from their preparatory training, convince me that here lies the fundamental weakness of Professor Gummere’s plea for a saving of the classic for maturer years, and a substitution of “the average, the sprightly, the attrac- tive, the typical’’ in the preparatory grades. Doubtless there are some so bored by a study of some “masterpiece” in school that they fly full speed to the lightest litera-
Page 15
ture. No wonder, if in a highly reputable New York school “Lady of the Lake’’ is read in two grades and studied in a third, if in a Massachusetts high school lines of “Julius Cwsar’ are doled out to the whis- perer to be memorized in amounts propor- tioned to his crime! Let judgment fall, howeyer, not upon the unfortunate master- piece, but upon the stupidity of teachers. Match these less frequent cases with the countless instances in which Homer, Shakespeare, Milton, read under the guid- ance of a genuine lover of them, have ren- dered quick the spirit of the boy and girl, and sent them, face forward forever, into the Promised Land of books. To many a one the written pages of the classics speak no word till a man possessed by the great human spirit that breathes through them has interpreted the writing. A few are for- tunate enough to be led from their own homes into the vital, human world of the best literature—of such, doubtless, Profes- sor Gummere is thinking; but the majority of American boys and girls, from the poor- est to the richest, must find their way thither through the instigation and guid- ance of the schools, or-not at all. But few in proportion go from our schools to our colleges; to save the best for maturer years and college courses, and to abide in the mediocre during preparatory training, is inevitably to make the mediocre a per- manent abiding place for many a restless, but untutored mird. The course of action suggested by Professor Gummere is the shortest and most direct way, I believe, to that “forced possession of lighter litera- ture” which he would avoid. The giants of the old days did not leave their Virgil and Horace, their Homer and Zschylus, for “‘maturer years”; they stud- fed them in the schools. And the result was a living culture which we moderns do not attain, and the way to which does not lie in a substitution of “the sprightly” for the lofty. Nor will a mastery of our Eng- lish tongue and power of expression ever come to us through the study of grammar and composition advised by Professor New- comer in the time saved by this reduc: tion of the reading list. Right and very essential such a study is in its place, as a strong foundation, but equally powerless is it to give, without the aid of much, and that the best, literature, that fine sense fot the values of language which is the essence of culture and the source of all fineness of expression. That can come only through genuine familiarity with sounding English prose, as in the old days it came from deep grounded acquaintance with pure Latin and sonorous Greek. I cannot think that Professor Gummere and Professor Newcomer have truly point- ed out the fault in our English teaching. Their criticisms have an unconscious per- sonal bias: the ballad stage does not last through all the preparatory years; English grammar and rhetoric cannot forever sup- ply the place of literature, even in the pre- paratory school. The line of thought in the papers read before the New England Association of Colleges and Schools is more suggestive of practical relief. In all the vigorous attack upon the excessive amount of the college requirements in general and ir particular, there was a notable rest from battle with the amount of the English re- quirement. Not quantity norquality of read- | The Nation. 373 ing assigned was the fault pointed out as lying at the bottom of our present ineffec- tive English teaching; the fault stressed in no uncertain terms by Dr. Farrand of Newark Academy, and more particularly by President Faunce of Brown University, was the method of attack, the substitution of knowledge as an end to our study of litera- ture in the schools in the place of appreci- ation and power of expression. The exami- nations set in English by most colleges— with the exception, named, of Harvard, and with the exception also of Bryn Mawr, where power to write, not knowledge, per se, is tested—are cramping the English in our preparatory schools. While over-edited text-books and English examinations of the present kind press upon the indifferent boy or girl, and the unwilling but submissive teacher, the necessity of knowing, for mere knowing’s sake, at a definite examination time, the mass of allusions and facts, the sum and substance, of every masterpiece named in the “Study and Practice” list, the teaching of English will be devitalized. While every book studied must be bared to the skeleton, and every bone numbered against that same examination day, there can be none of the joyous illumination that comes from order, and clarity, and fineness of discrimination, to light the way to per- sonal achievement. Only the teacher who will let his fearful conscience lie low, and his spirit rise, can wholly surmount these difficulties and stimulate the schoolboy and girl to vital appreciation and thought and expression. The American people have a_ right to question why the energy and time and money expended upon the teaching of Eng- lish in our schools and colleges to-day have nc more effect. The English colleges, we are told, have no elaborate courses in Eng- lish, yet turn out men cultured in speech and written word; the French schools have no courses in composition, yet send out students who can write French. And we bring forth, after hard labor, men “‘il- literate and unashamed’’—to use President Faunce’s graphic phase—before the beauty of their own language! These compari- sons are illuminating, and both confirm and add to the ideas already suggested. The training of the French school and uni- versity makes every written work a “‘com- position,” every master of science or econo- mics, of history or mathematics, a master also of French. That fact is to me the most illuminating that can be brought to bear upon the present situation. We waste time hopelessly through specialization and lack of codédperation. While we train stu- dents to write themes on subjects connect- ed with English courses, and other depart- nents allow the same students to write the detail of their regular work as fancy dic- tates, regarding only substance, and accept- ing slipshod English, we shall never send from our schools to our colleges, from our colleges to the outer world, writers of clear and efficient English. Yet, in no school or cecllege, so far as I know, is real codpera- tion established. We are making a begin- ning at Wellesley, but beginnings are ever difficult, and the public opinion necessary te assure success is not yet established. In it, to my mind, lies the great hope of our future effectiveness. But, one may say, if English courses trained students as they should train them, they would spontaneously, instinctively, write clear English always. Instinct!—in- stinct springs from inheritance and child- hood training; lacking it, a man must learn by slow, difficult degrees to conform to custom. Our schoolboys and schoolgirls, our college men and women, are no Latins by inheritance, and they come very often from homes wherein is no instinct for cul- ture, no instinct that leads to comeliness of speech or manner. Remembrance of the cultured homes from which the men of the English colleges pass by way of the far- famed classical training of the public schools to the university, points the moral, and makes only more visible the darkness of the cultureless homes in our money-get- ting land. We deal with another race—a motley, composite, untrained race—and there is vital need that concerted training in our schools and colleges act as a sub- stitute for that inheritance and breeding which best of all beget spontaneous and in- stinctive purity of speech. Truly, not less but more of the best that literature can give, a more vital compre- hension of the magnificent power of the English classics to mould mind and spirit and speech—these are essentials, if we are ever to create in America that fine spirit of culture, that fine sense of rectitude in things intellectual as well as in things moral, for which the whole land thirsts. AGNES FRANCES PERKINS. Wellesley College, October 16. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr. The letter of Prof. F. B. Gummere iu your issue of September 19, and that of Prof. A. G. Newcomer, in your issue of October 3, are both much to the point. Nevertheless they suggest the question; Why don’t you do something about it? The present course of English instruction :n our secondary schools is not a diabolical invention of those in charge of the schools, On the contrary, it is the direct and logical outgrowth of the entrance requirements outlined with tiresome similarity in nearly all college catalogues issued throughout the United States. There is no avail in pri- vately advising teachers to do one thing, while officially countenancing another. If college instructors in English are really desirous of a change in the condition of affairs, they must realize that the remedy lies in their hands, and in theirs only; they must completely revolutionize the college entrance requirements. Unfortunately this is more easily said than done. In too many of our universities and colleges there is a sharp line of de- marcation drawn between “rhetoric” and “literature.” Rhetoric, and all that it pre- supposes by way of previous preparation, is looked upon with suspicion and bare toleration. The voice of command is that which ponderously reiterates the opinion that, if youth be sufficiently stuffed with literature, enough rhetorical juice wil! un- consciously be expressed for the due diges- tion of the lump. Such being the case, there can be slight hope for a universal reform. Radical ao- tion must be taken where radical action is possible; that is, in institutions whose de- partments of English are at oncé united and enlightened. There should be enough such institutions to codperate successfully in the establishment of an entrance re- quirement in English, suited not only to the immediate needs of the secondary-
Page 16
3874 Th'e Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 school student, but to his preparation for maturer thought in college. A group of New England colleges have already made a feeble attempt in the suggested direction. I have no right to say that they would wel- come an infusion of enthusiasm from South and West; but there is no reason why they should not. HOMER EATON KEYES. Dartmouth College, Hanover, N. H., October 9. THE “S.P” OF PHI BETA KAPPA. To THE EpIToR oF THE NATION: Sir: A recent issue of the Providence Journal contained a discussion of the mean- ing of the letters S.P., which stand on the key of Phi Beta Kappa. It is there stated that the meaning of these letters may be quite unknown, or that they may be the initials of Societatis Particeps. Since the original minutes of Phi Beta Kappa give an answer to the question which differs de- cidedly from these, I address this letter to you. I remained at Williamsburg last month after the meeting of the Triennial Council of Phi Beta Kappa in order to examine carefully the minutes of the society with reference to this point. They yielded evi- dence which was unexpectedly clear and unequivocal. The main evidence lies in the presence of the dot of the letter é in each word, which was not erased, and in depres- sions in the paper corresponding to the erasure of parts of letters extending above and below the line. These are so placed as to leave little doubt that the letters stand for the words Societas Philosophica. These words may be regarded as practical- ly certain, with the exception of the termi- nation of the second. In that part of the word which follows the second Ah we have no indications of the letters, and cannot decide with certainty on the number. The space is such that there must have been more than two letters; and four, such as would be contained in Philosophorum, would be rather too long, although not impossible. There is nothing in the manuscript to de- cide a choice between Philosophica and Philosophie. E. A. BIRGE. University of Wisconsin, Madison, October 16. Notes. Putnams announce the following volumes of the Cambridge University Press: “The Life of Sir Richard C. Jebb,” by Caroline Jebb; ‘“‘Pages of Greek Verse,”’ by Walter Headlam; “Scientific Papers,” by G. H. Darwin; “Algebraic Equations,” by G. B. Mathews: “The JAtaka. or Stories of the Buddha’s Former Births,’”” vol. VI.; and “The Introduction to the Theory of Mul- tiple-Periodic Functions,” by H. F. Baker. E. P. Dutton & Co. are publishing several additions to their various series: in the London Library, “Popular Tales from the Norse” by Sir George Webbe Dasent, “Spec- imens of English Dramatic Poets” by Charles Lamb, and “Notes on the Parables of Our Lord” by Archbishop Trench; in the Muses’ Library, the Poetical Works of Thom- as Campion edited by Percival Vivian; in the New Universal Library, “‘A Summer fn Sky” by Alexander Smith, and “The Life of Cardinal Wolsey” by George Cavendish. W. M. Rossetti has prepared two more volumes about the Rossetti circle to be published by Brown, Langham & Co. (Lon- don). One is the “Diary of Dr. Polidori,” his uncle; the other is the “Letters of Christina Rossetti’ with notes and por- traits. The Baker & Taylor Co. is preparing what is to be called the Child’s Guide Series. The first volume, “The Child’s Guide to Pictures,” will be by Charies H. Caffin. A guide to mythology will be written by Mary E. Burt, and biography will be treated by Edwin and Catherine Markham. William Knight's “Victorian Anthology,” in the Newnes-Scribner thin paper series, has at least the virtue of inclusiveness. Tennyson, and Browning, to be sure, are barred out because their works are so well known and because it would be so difficult to draw the line when once selection be- gan. But as a compensation, Dr. Knight begins as far back as Charles Lamb, who ied in 1834, and is in no proper sense a Victorian, and takes in many poets not commonly read. His choice and sense o1 proportion are sometimes puzzling. Thus, four poems are taken from Adelaide Anne Procter, whereas from Matthew Arnold there are only three, two sets of stanzas from “Empedocles,” and “A Wish.” Again Clough has eight poems, as if he were more important than the elegiast who sang his death. We observe that the American poets are well represented, even including Walt Whitman. In the same series Dr. Knight has the first volume, containing the longer poems, of Scott. The shorter poems are reserved for a second volume. “The Poems of Edgar Allan Poe,” col- lected and edited by E. C. Stedman and G. E. Woodberry, and published by Stone & Kimball in 1895, is now brought out by Duffield & Co. E. P. Dutton & Co. issue a second and cheaper edition of Florence A. Maccunn’s “Mary Stuart.” In reviewing this book, April 26, 1906, the Nation characterized it as “a simple, lively narrative of the re- markable adventures through which Mary Stuart passed.” Members of the Congregational Church will be glad to know that “The ‘Retracta- tion’ of Robert Browne, Father of Congre- gationalism,”’ has been edited by Champlin Burrage and published by Henry Frowde. It is printed from the MS. in Lambeth Palace Library. “The Modern Reader’s Bible,” arranged by Richard G. Moulton, hitherto issued ina number of small volumes, is now published by the Macmillan Co. in a single volume. John Lane Company will soon have ready for publication a luxurious reprint of Jere- my Taylor’s “Marriage Ring,’’ with notes by Francis Coutts. From the State University of Iowa has recently been issued the first number of a serial publication, to be known as the Iowa Studies in Language and Literature. The special title of this number is “The Syntax of the Genitive Case in the Lindis- farne Gospels,’’ by Christian Emil Bale. It therefore forms a contribution to the study of the Northern form of Old Eng- lish, a field which, formerly little known, has in recent years received increased at- tention, especially on the side of pronun- ciation and inflections. This is no doubt due to a fuller recognition of the import- ance of Northern English for an under- standing of standard English of to-day. From the point of view of the use of the genitive case Mr. Bale discusses nouns, verbs, and adjectives, and the (modern) phrasal possessive with “of,” of which there are numerous instances in Northern Old English two hundred years before it was established in (the Southern) Eng- lish of London. While this form may have developed wholly indépendent of foreign influence, the author seems inclined to re- gard it as in part due to the wide distri- bution of Norse in Northern England, in which language similar constructions were common. The Boston Athenzum centenary is ap- propriately eelebrated by the publication of a@ memorial volume, which opens with a genial characterization of the influence of the Atheneum on American literature, by Prof. Barrett Wendell. As he calls up the distinguished men who frequented the li- brary one cannot doubt that to it was largely due the fact that “the Boston of the mid-nineteenth century ... was. the most memorable centre of intellectual ac- tivity yet developed in English-speaking America.”” Among them are the historians Prescott, Bancroft, Sparks, Ticknor,: Hil- dreth, and Parkman; the statesmen Webs- ter and Sumner; the divines Channing and Emerson. As his “‘Note-Books” indicate, Hawthorne was an occasional visitor, while the records show that Oliver Wendell Holmes, “who began as a grave reader of works on medicine, ended as a riotously general reader of everything which could possibly interest his humanely assimila- tive mind; his record, indeed, makes one half believe that without the Athen#um we might never have had, in its full luxuriance, that wonderful Autocrat of the Breakfast Table.” The librarian, Charles K. Bolton, contributes an historical sketch in which are some interesting facts in regard to the earliest Boston libraries. The first wa3 that for which Capt. R. Keayne, in his will dated in 1653, made provision, “a Library & Gallere for Devines & Schollers to meete in.” His books, which he bequeathed to it, he adds, are “not simply for show, but properly for use, they being all English, none Lattine or Greeke; . .. and though my bookes be not many, nor very fitt for such a worke being English & smale bookes, yet after this beginning the Lord may stirr up some others that will add more to them & helpe to carry the worke on by bookes of more valew, antiquity, use anc esteeme.” It is evident that in old times more than the intellectual needs of readers was cared for, as the first librarian of the Athenwum notes in a blank-book, “A box of Snuff is wanted.” Women were not admitted until March, 1829, when “the Trustees voted to give free use of the Li- brary to Miss Hannah Adams, the his- torian.”” Referring to this unprecedented event, Josiah Quincy, in his history of the library, says: “One solitary female ventur- ed to claim the freedom of its alcoves, and to endure the raising of the masculine eye- brows, provoked by the unaccustomed sight.” Among the other contents are lists vf the officers, members of the staff, pro- prietors, chief gifts and bequests, and the special collections. These include 384 books
Page 17
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 375 which belonged to George Washington, first editions of American authors, international law, and Confederate literature or books and newspapers published in the Southern States during the civil war. The value and attractiveness of the volume are enhanced by the thirty-four illustrations, portraits of the presidents and librarians, and pic- tures of the various homes of the library. G. M. Godden of Kincairney, Weybridge, Surrey, England, is preparing a life of the novelist Henry Fielding, to be published next spring. He desires copies for publi- cation of any autograph letters by or to Fielding. Sig. Ernesto Nathan has edited the edi- zione diplomatica of Garibaldi’s ‘‘Memorie” from the definitive autograph copy (Turin: Societ&a Tipografico-Editrice Nazionale). The volume is handsomely printed, and will be henceforth for every reader and stu- dent the authentic source of one of the world’s most remarkable autobiographies. Had Odysseus, returned to Ithaca after his many wanderings, written his memoirs, they would probably have more ‘nearly resem- bled these confessions of Garibaldi than any others the world now has or is likely to have. We may remark also that it is two men of action, and not men of letters— Garibaldi and Grant—who produced the foremost autobiographies of their genera- tion. The publication in Italy of works on the Risorgimento goes on apace. We have re- ceived lately two volumes concerning men who, though not of the first importance, were nevertheless concerned in critical events. First, Michele Rosi writes of An- tonio Mordini under the obscuring title “Il Risorgimento Italiano e l’Azione d’un Patriota, Cospiratore e Soldato” (Rome: Casa Editrice Nazionale). Next, Capt. N. M. Campolieti deals with Carlo de Cristo- foris in “La Mente e ]’Anime d’un Eroe” (Milan: L. Mondaini). As Mordini and Cristoforis were both republicans, these volumes are valuable because they throw light on republican activity in 1848-9 and on the succeeding decade of conspiracies. Mordini’s career, which extended down to 1902, is also interesting as showing how the young Mazzinian of 1848 grew naturally to be in his prime a loyal minister of the Crown. ’ The publishing house of Nicola Zanichelli, ir Bologna, which brought out Carducci’s later writings, as well as his collected works, has just issued, through the Italian press, an appeal addressed to all who pos- sess letters of Carducci, inviting their co- operation in the preparation of an edition of his correspondence. Zanichelli has pur- chased from Carducci’sheirs the publisher’s rights to all the letters in their possession. The work, which will cover a period of more than fifty years, should be not only of the greatest importance for the history of Italian literature, but also, if the pub- lishers succeed in bringing together con- siderable correspondence of Carducci’s earlier life, of not a little interest for the political history of the first troublous years of united Italy. In a book of 164 pages, entitled “Japans Zukunftsreligion’’ (Berlin: Karl Curtius), Dr. Hans Haas, for many years pastor of the progressively inclined Protestant con- gSregations in Tokio and Yokohama, pub- lishes three lectures, in which he discusses the development of religious forces in Ja- pan. He regards a modern type of Chris- tian religious thought as the most likely to prevail there. Quoting the statement of Count Ito, to the effect that the only true civilization is based on Christian princi- ples, and that the future leaders of Japan must be men educated in acoordance with the teachings of Christianity, Dr. Haas declares that modern Japan is rapidly dis- carding its old religious ideas, the main- stay of which is still Buddhism; and that Christianity properly presented will appeal strongly to the Japanese as the correct substitute. This opinion is not altogether in harmony with that of other observers, but the author insists that his views are not too rosy, since, within fifty years more has been achieved in Japan than in any other mission field. Under the title “Moderne Propheten,” Karl Résener, has begun the publication of a series of critical essays on the ideas and ideals of leaders of modern thought, par- ticularly in religion and philosophy. The first volume, just issued by Beck of Munich, a work of 231 pages, deals with Hartmann, Tolstoy, and Nietzsche. The discussions are not of a sensational character, but are marked by objective scholarship. A second volume is to discuss Carlyle, Ruskin, and Emerson; and a third, perhaps, Chamber- lain, Gobineau, and Naumann. The group- ing in the first volume is certainly not based on a harmony of thought on the part of the “‘prophets,” for Nietzsche’s contempt for the philosophy of Hartmann is well known. ba The well known German Oriental travel- ler and savant, Max Schlagintweit, has re- cently issued two small volumes. The first is entitled, “Verkehrswege und Verkehrs- projekte in Vorderasien,’” which, with a chart, comes from the house“of Paetel, in Berlin. The work gives a bird's-eye pic- ture of the railroads of Asia Minor, Syria, Transcaucasia, and Turkestan. By way of appendix Major Schlagintweit gives a sur- vey of the roads of the Iran. The other volume, entitled “Die Reform im Kongo- staat,” from the house of Oldenbourg, in Munich, is a cool discussion of the Congo problem. The author is of the conviction that a group of British merchants in Liver- pool in conjunction with others of Ham- burg, are decrying the present condition of affairs in the Congo for the purpose of having Great Britain take possession of this country. The writer insists that af- fairs in the Congo are in a satisfactory con- dition, and do not justify interference on the part of outsiders. The building of the Baghdad Railway is strougly urged by the noted traveller, Mark Sykes, in an account of a recent journey in northern Mesopotamia, published in the Geographical Journal for October. He says that it will not only put an end to the ceaseless intertribal warfare between the Kurds and Arabs, but it will change the nomads into cultivators of the soil. The leading Kurdish chieftains in the region through which it will pass are eager for it. One of them said to him: “When the rail- way comes, we shall be very rich. I shall bring all my people down here; the gov- ernment will be forced to protect them; and we may build, perhaps, five hundred villages.” The truth of this statement is proved by what is taking places ‘in- fi¢ country around Aleppo, since its iné¢reasing size and prosperity has made it ‘necessary to bring the Bedawin under control. Ten years ago the sixty-mile tract between that city and the Euphrates was practically an uninhabited desert. Last year Mr. Sykes passed over it and never left ‘cultivated land until he was “within two hours’ ride of the river.” In another @istrict fifty-six new villages have sprung up inthe last three years, showing that all that is needed for the regeneration of the country is the protection of the peasant farmer. Some interesting facts illustrating the influence the librarian may exert on the quality of books Circulated, by the mere display in attractive editions and on con- venient and conspicuous shelves of the most approved books; are reported ‘by the head of the circulating department of the Grand Rapids Public Library in the - Library Journal. For the display of such books as are deemed especially worthy of attention, a special room has been fitted up to hold about -2,500- volumes. - Here among the better grade of the new and popular books have been placed during the year excellent editions of the principal works of the great writers of the world, and from this room are now circulated more than one-third of all the books ts- sued from the library, though it contains only about 3 per cent. of the total stock. The novels of Jane Austen, Hawthorne, Victor Hugo, the essays and histories of Irving, Gilbert White’s “‘Natural History of Selborne,” which, in the former indis- criminate arrangement, were drawn only once or twice a year, have, since the new plan went into effect, been issued as many times a month, and some of them have rivalled in popularity the ‘much adver- tised books of the hour. All ‘the larger libraries now report regularly the propor- tion of fiction circulated, and from the high percentage the conclusion has been drawn that the great majority of the patrons ot’ the public library use it only for drawing fiction; but there may be a great dif- ference between the percentage of fiction drawn and the percentage of the library’s patrons that draw it. To get at the lat- ter fact a special investigation has recent- ly been made by the Grand Rapids Library, Of the total card holders, numbering 15,- 000, only 3,890 drew fiction during the past year, and of these, 1,050, or about 7 per cent. of the library’s patrons, drew more than 60 per cent. of all the novels taken out. A further study showed that 3,071 novels, or 16 per cent. of the whole is- sue, were drawn by 152 card holders. Thus, the large relative issue of fiction seems due, not as is so generally complained, to the demands of the public at large, but to the voracious appetite of a small pro- portion of readers. It is hoped that further investigation along this line may be made in other cities. , Good reading and the intelligent use of the public libraries of Great Britain are significantly aided by the National Home Reading Union. The membership is large and the “special courses’’ are now more than fifty in number, says the chairman, Dr. Alex. Hill, master of Downing College, Cambridge, in a communication to the London Times. In response to the interest excited by the controversy last winter in
Page 18
3876 The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 regard to the place of Greek in education, a course of reading, “Homer in Translations,” was prepared which proved so successful that a general request has been made for a similar course on the Greek dramatists. This and courses on Oriental literature, Carlyle, Goethe and Schiller, Tennyson, History of The Netherlands, Marco Polo, heredity, and the origin and history of cul- tivated plants are the most recent additions to the list. GREEK RELIGION. The Culte of the Greek States. By Lewis Richard Farnell. 5 vols. Vols. III. and IV. Oxford: University Press. III., pp. 398; IV., pp. 454. 40+652 plates. $9.75. An epigrammatic saying was current among scholars a few years ago, that the Greeks had a rich mythology, but no re- ligion, while the Romans had a well-estab- lished religion, but no mythology. This idea, if it still existed, would be over- thrown by the mere appearance of these large volumes on Greek cults. The first two volumes of the work were published in 1895; the fifth volume, on the cults of he- roes, is to be published in a year or two. The whole field of Hellenic antiquities has assumed a different aspect in the last half-century, because of the discovery of more than a hundred thousand inscriptions on stone, and of a profusion of old coins and painted vases, and the uncovering of the ruins of many ancient structures. But perhaps no part of this field has changed in appearance more completely than that oc- cupled by mythology and religion. Trea- tises on these kindred subjects used fo have a rather bad name among gcholars, as being based on imagination rather than on fact. At one time the myths of Greece, so far as was possible, were brought into relation with those of ancient India, and all facts inconsistent with this hypothesis were supposed to be late accretions to the story. Some thought the solar myth ex- plained most of Greek belief with regard to gods and heroes. Other scholars ac- cepted much as due to the Egyptians and Phenicians. Others still inclined to the view of Euhemerus—that the Greek gods and demi-gods were only mighty men of valor, whose achievements had been mag- nified after their deaths. Some were dis- posed to derive all Greek religion from the worship of ancestors, and almost all of the Hellenic deities were said to have been originally gods of the lower world. In these discussions the word chthonic ap- peared often, and was treated as a univer- sal solvent. Theosophists found indica- tions of serpent and phallic worship in Greece as well as elsewhere. Then schol- ars endeavored to explain what was ob- scure in the religion of ancient Greece from what has been observed in modern races at a primitive stage of culture, and general anthropological principles were applied, of- ten excessively. Thus the totem was in- troduced into Greece, even in cults which afforded no apparent indication of it, and the matriarchate was made to explain the prominence of the goddesses Hera, Athena, Aphrodite, and Artemis. More recently, and much more effectively than the last two principles, the “demon of vegetation” has been introduced. The most important step in advance, in the study of Greek religion, has been made by transferring the centre of interest and research from myth to ritual. For histori- cal purposes, the advantage of the cult over the myth is clear on a moment’s considera- tion. The cult is far more stable. While sometimes a myth may suggest or affect a cult, far more frequently ritual suggests an gwtiologic myth. In all departments of life, customs are continued long after the rea- son for them has been forgotten. Until very recently, at least, the boys of Ports- mouth, N. H., have celebrated Pope Night, without knowing or caring much about Guy Fawkes and the Gunpowder Plot. The children who dance about the Maypole have no thought of the origin of that fes- tival. Many of our Yule-tide festivities were customary among our ancestors before Christianity was received by them. In no- thing are men more conservative than in their religious customs. At least in its in- terpretation, a doctrine can be modified more easily than a rite. So, in Greece, a charming myth might be accepted and re- told readily in another land, but one of the first Hellenic principles, supported by an oracle from Delphi, was to worship the gods in the manner of the fathers. A band of colonists or emigrants generally would take their cults with them. Sometimes these would be assimilated to those of the land whither they went, but sometimes a cult, together with the immigrants who brought it, would be accepted by the earlier inhabitants. If the same special form of worship of the same divinity is found in places remote from each other, some his- torical explanation is to be sought. The cults of the Greeks have the greater his- torical importance because the Hellenes were a pious people, and were disposed to consecrate all things of secular life. The question is indefinitely complicated, how- ever, for cults have a tendency to cleave to the soil as well as to accompany emi- grants. Newcomers naturally believed it well to accept the local cults, and some- times, as it appears, gave the old local wor- ship to the new divinities which they brought with them. Thus Farnell holds that Apollo was not originally a god of di- vination, but his worshippers took posses- sion of an old oracle of the earth-goddess at Delphi, and he explains certain other chthonian traits in the Apolline ritual as inherited from the earlier system. Even the name bee (Melissa) given to the Pythian priestess may have been so derived, since some priestesses of the earth-goddess Demeter also were so-called. The great Isthmian festival of Poseidon at Corinth belonged originally, according to Farnell, to some buried demon of vegetation. Thus the cults sometimes seem more stable even than the divinities to whom they are sacred. ,To show the service which the study of cults renders to mythology, two illus- trations may suffice. Scholars have been strongly inclined to believe, with many of the ancients, that Apollo was originally a sun-god, the divinity of physical and men- tal light, the god of prophecy, of poetry, of music, and of art, of health of body and of mind. In « brilliant tract, Roscher equated Apollo with the Roman Mars. Both, in bis view, were at first sun-gods and wer- gods. But Apollo resigned the latter office to Ares, and Mars surrendered his func- tions as sun-god to Apollo, imported from Greece. The myths agree well with this theory. But Farnell holds that Apollo was originally a demon of vegetation, and he finds in early Greek cults little or no evi- dence to connect this god with the sun. The offerings of first fruits, which were borne to Apollo along the Sacred Way, are explained as due to him as an agrarian divinity. Another example of the working of the method is the treatment of Demeter Thesmophoros. From Virgil’s time, this epithet has been interpreted as declaring her to be the patron goddess of laws and institutions. But in cult, no evidence is found of such functions on the part of De- meter. The case is clearer than that of Apollo. It is not easy to resist the conclu- sion that the ordinary interpretation of the epithet has been wrong, and Farnell inter- prets this as Giver of Wealth. Volume IIL is given to Earth (Gaia) and her “emanations,” Demeter and Perse- phone; Hades or Pluto; and Rhea-Cybele, the mother of the gods. The catalogue of local worships of Earth is brief. But, from the original earth-goddess, not simply De- meter, but also Persephone, Themis, E- rinys, Aglauros,and Medusa are regarded as emanations or detachments. In most of these are found both chthonian and vegeta- tive or agrarian elements. Many festivals @re connected with agricultural processes. The divinities of the earth must be ap- peased before the breaking of the ground for sowing, and again before the harvest, which in primitive times was regarded as a dan- gerous act; and a thanksgiving service was due after the harvest was gathered. Some survivals of human sacrifice in the worship of Apollo are explained by Farnell as con- nected with Apollo’s original office as a de- mon of vegetation. The devil must be ex- pelled before the harvest. The most im- portant worship of Demeter was in Attica, at Eleusis, but of this comparatively little is known. In spite of the fact that hundreds of thousands of Greeks were initiated into the mysteries, we can only surmise as to the worship within the sanctuary. The cult of Hades never had great importance in Greece. Farnell thinks him to have been developed as the counterpart of Zeus, who, as a god of vegetation, had acquired some- thing of a chthonian character. Agamem- non, “king of men,” in his view, was not an “emanation” from Zeus, as some have thought, but a buried ancestor who became a chthcnian power with Zeus. The name Rhea, too, was not much used in cults; the appellation Great Mother was pre- ferred. Her worship is derived by Farnell from Crete, where the Greeks found a mother goddess, to whom, in order to form a system, they affiliated Zeus and Hera. We are not obliged, however, to derive from her Hera, Athena, and the rest, who may have come down with the Greeks from the north. Volume IV. is devoted to Poseidon and Apollo—chiefly to the latter. Even Poseidon is thought to have a vegetative function, but this point is not pressed by our author. Poseidon is believed to have been original- ly a fresh-water god, and his name is con- nected with the root of the verb to drink (cf. potion). The worship of Apollo is much more interesting to us. Our author believes him to have come into Hellas with the in-
Page 19
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 377 vaders from the north. The Apolline wor- ship at Delphi is recognized as brought from Crete, and as earlier than that at Delos. The Delian temple and worship were found- ed by the Ionians when making their way across the Avgean Sea. Having left their earlier homes in Greece, they diverted to the altar at Delos the offerings which had been brought by Apollo’s worshippers to the temple at Delphi. Lycia was colonized at a very early period by worshippers of Lycean Apollo (from whom the land re- ceived its name), setting out perhaps from Argos, and moving by way of Crete and Rhodes. The Cretan worship of Apollo thus becomes prehistoric, but Farnell is not in- clined to believe him to be derived from a Cretan sun-god, though he thinks Apollo may have stepped into the place, and be- come the successor of some Cretan divinity, just as some Christian saints in the popular mind took the places of some old pagan gods and heroes. The purification from blood-guiltiness, which became an impor- tant part of the service of Apollo’s shrine, according to Farnell, indicates Dionysiac influence, and the lustration with pig’s blood was borrowed from the older chtho- nian cults. That Apollo became the special god of music and song, Farnell explains not from any primitive characteristic or from any musical traits of his special wor- shippers, but as due to his brilliant fes- tivals at Delphi. On the whole, the work before us is ju- dicious and sane—and in this fleld these epithets are a special compliment. The author avoids hobbies, and bases his argu- ments on evidence clearly presented. The “sources” are gathered and printed in full, by themselves, with a geographical register which shows conveniently the grouping of each cult. He says nothing in these two volumes about the solar myth, and has only a few sentences with reference to those who lay much stress on ancestor-worship in Greece. He thinks it necessary to be more explicit in his arguments against totemistic views. To say that the work is very learned would give it only a small part of its meed of praise. It presents perhaps the best fairly concise, yet accu- rate and intelligible, statement of the latest views with regard to the Eleusinian Myste- ries and the Delphian oracle of Apollo, as well as the most complete statement of the eults of the divinities here discussed. The etymologies in general are according to the strictest philological sect, but, neglecting the quantity of the vowel, the author thinks the old name of Delphi, Pytho, to be the Place of Inquiry, and thus in itself to in- dicate the seat of an oracle. The study of cults carries us back into the prehistoric period with more precision and certainty than was expected. But many problems re- main for solution, and doubtless many of our author’s conclusions must be modified. CURRENT FICTION. The Stooping Lady. By Maurice Hewlett. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. The last thing to be looked for from Mr. Hewlett is a surprise. We have him ticketed. He has his own trail quite plain- ly blazed. He is “tapestry.” And now he appears in 1809, marching straight into the modern world, Richard Brinsley Sheridan is there and “Prinny’; Creevy noses about in the offing; Castlereagh’s name floats through the pages; there is mention of Tom Moore. Yet the most embittered enemy of the historical novel will find no- thing to carp at in “The Stooping Lady.” The reasons are simple. Instead of hark- ing back to the diction of Shaftesbury or of Isaac Walton, Mr. Hewlett uses a tongue no more archaic than that of Miss Edge- worth, certainly less prim. He succeeds in making his main characters live, and places his celebrities well in the background. Now we all know that plays in which people thrill in attics while heroes as re- cent as Napoleon or Wellington ride past, unseen by the audience, are far more im- pressive than those in which mediocre actors, with wide waistcoats or hook noses, declaim straight over the footlights. Con- ceding this to be also true in stories, Mr. Hewlett at once gains an air of reality by using the greater lights merely to give atmosphere, and in letting go his wonderful skill and imagination in sketching so minor a personage as Cobbett, brilliantly focuss- ing and embodying all the queer traits of that vulgar and forcible agitator. As for the rest, Mr. Hewlett’s stupid sporting young man who is a gentleman, the other who is a cur, the minx, the old Lady Kew type of grandmother, are entirely like such people in Thackeray’s time, or our own; and his girl, Hermia Mary (this is saying a great deal), seems to live with the real heroines of fiction. To-day at least, what- ever readers of the future may think, she comes before one’s eyes with the youth and spirit of Clara Middleton. Not only has Mr. Hewlett created a warm and breathing wo- man, in spite of fancy dress costume rather than by its aid, but in treating that age of robust drinking, gaming, and general in- discretion, he never once lapses into a hint of the perversity which has at times cast a suspicion of taint across his medigeval pictures. Rightiy or wrongly, he evidently believes this secret taint characteristic of the Middle Ages, a quality entirely dif- ferent from the frank animalism of the Regency. Consequently, his young men brawl and misbehave themselves without a trace of morbidness. His lady loves very nobly; and suddenly, out of a gay comedy scene he evolves a climax of unexpected, but quite logical, pathos. His attack upon the sensibilities is perfectly free from cheapness; and, as a solution of the purely persona! problem of Hermia’s future, the closing drama at Charing Cross is a miracle of delicacy and tact. The whole book might be taken as. con- clusive illustration of the disputed truth that a high degree of skill need in no way hamper an author’s individuality or warmth of expression, that a classic re- siraint of manner by no means reduces the emotional quality to the academic level of an eighteenth-century essayist. Ancestors. By Gertrude Atherton. New York: Harper & Brothers. Whether “Senator: North” be tolerable or the reverse, whatever the value of Mrs. Atherton’s serious historical studies, there can be no question that “Ancestors” is an able book. Whether the people be natural and closely studied or no, hardly seems to matter; the forward movement is so swift as te carry one on with a sense of growing excitement. Mra. Atherton, moreover, shows enlarged grasp, a capacity for carrying on codrdinating threads without loss of speed. Although the opening, at the usual English country house, is sufficiently well done, the real pace is struck only when Elton Gwynne decides to look up a California property, and cast his future fortunes in America. Like Plantagenet Palliser, this rising young statesman is pitchforked out of the House of Commons into a peerage. Unable to en- dure the ignominy of a tame seat among the Lords, and a big title with a small income, the young man vanishes from home, to emerge in America as plain Jack Gwynne. To be quite frank, this does not appear over likely. Better at once to con- fess it a rather strained method of intro- ducing a study of a keen, trained English- man’s sensations on making acquaintance with American political customs at their worst—in San Francisco before the earth- quake. Nevertheless, Mrs. Atherton gives those impressions with such vividness as to win instant acceptance of the somewhat dubious device by which her situation has been brought about. Once safe in California, the story pro- ceeds breathlessly. Notwithstanding all the descriptions, all the lenses which have been turned upon that exotic city, she still is able to give a picture of untarnished freshness. In truth, she is at her best in a frankly garish scheme of color. She revels in a jumble of high buildings, plot- ting politicians, patriots (for California only), alien races, millionaires with Span- ish surnames. She runs two risks often deadly in fiction, only to emerge quite suc- cessful. She ventures to use the characters we have met in her earlier novels, Helena Belmont, Magdalena Trennahan—all ‘“‘The Californians.” But the greater achieve- ment is to end with an account of the re- cent earthquake without producing an anti- climax. That Mrs. Atherton’s manner at times is somewhat rough cannot be denied. Thoughtful she is, and in a way penetrating, though quite without subtlety and grasping things more violently than is always to the taste of the over sensitive. With an unmis- takable intellectual.development, she does not fine down either in point of view or expression, but this defect is distinctly mitigated by her remaining vivid and for- cible, and by her showing no symptom of crystallizing into a hack imitator of her own, sometimes sensational, successes. / The Way of a Man. By Emerson Hough. New York: The Outing Publishing Com- pany. The villain of this novel is no conven- tional ranter of melodrama. An English marquis by birth, possessed of ingratiat- ing manners, diabolical cleverness, and in- credible coolness, he has added thereto all that mystic India could teach. “I am a Raja Yogi,” he confesses to John Cowles, his dearest foe and the teller of the story. “I have taken the eight mystic steps.” “All that means nothing to me,” I ad- mitted, simply. “No, it means nothing for me to tell you that I have learned Yama, Niyama, Asana, Pranayama, Pratyahara, Dharana, Dhya- na, and Samadhi! Yes, I was something of an adept once. ... But——” he smiled with all his old mockery—‘‘mostly I failed on
Page 20
378 The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 Pratyahara, which says the senses must be quelled. . . . I'd liefer die than not enjoy.” - With such an agent of darkness abroad, it is needless to say that trouble will beset the ways of John Cowles and Ellen Meri- wether. The time of the story is just be- fore the outbreak of the American Civil War. Leaving an unloved but plighted sweetheart behind him in Virginia, John Cowles makes & journey to St. Louts and westward through the desert regions of the La Platte on a private mission to Col. Meriwether, a connection of his murder- ed father’s. On the way, fate brings his predestined love to him; and in the com- pany of Ellen, who is also going to meet the colonel, her father, he loses the car- avan and is hopelessly lost in the wilder- ness. Here the two live for some three months together, honestly, of course. eating buffalo flesh and what other provender the desert affords. Some weeks later. when want had considerably abated, their atten- tion went to more philosophical topics: “What is marriage. John Cowles?” she asked ‘of me, abruptly, without preface. “It ig the Plan,” I answered apatheti- cally. She pondered for a time. “Are we then only creatures, puppets, toys?” “Yes,” I said to her. “A man is a toy. Lové was born before man was created, be- fore animals or plants. Atom ran to atom, seeking. It was love.” * She pondered yet a while... . Had she known what testings of soul were to be hers upon her return to civ- jlization—upon the discovery that her lov- er’s promise had been given to another— she would doubtless have pondered even longer. But enough of the plot. “The Way of a Man” is chiefly of interest in the Il- lustration it affords of several tenden- cies in contemporary fiction, as deplorable as they are conspicuous: the glorification of the violent, the primitive, and the crude; a sophomorical searching after effects of style; and a habit of cheap philosophizing. The Tents of Wickedness. By Miriam Coles Harris. New York: D. Appleton & Co. This story belongs in so special a cate- gory as hardly to find place in a review of novels at large, if only because the same author who captivated public fancy in 1860 with “Rutledge,” is still sufficiently abreast of things to make a spirited (not to say acrimonious) attack upon New York society, divorce, and the Episcopal Church. “The Tents of Wickedness” indeed appear te cover most of the world’s surface, ex- cept that portion which is protected by the Church of Rome. Leonora Hungerford, fresh from a French convent, has tilts with the frivolity of her elders only equalled by those of Elsie Dinsmore, or to go farther back, of Anna Ross, when she left the Manse to visit her bad cousins. Numbers of pages are devoted to explaining the rite of confession to singularly ill-informed worldlings. A great many things happen in the story, and Leonora finds frequent oc- casion to enlighten and rebuke her father ahd all his friends. Clerics of the younger Church show a remarkable instability (one turns broker and another “goes over’’), while priests of the true faith are busy saving souls and frustrating lynchings. And when Leonora’s stepmother unjustly com- plains of the persecuted young girl's maid, Leonora quietly answers, “I don’t tiens particularly to Juliette,” which certainly shows the high advantages of her foreign education. Leading American Soldiers. By R. M. Johnston. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $1.75 net. To study America in her martial aspect one turns naturally to the period from 1861 to 1865. In our earlier wars the re- sources were meagre, the armies small, the opposing generals not usually men of note. Washington and Jackson are more interesting in other ways than on the bat- tlefield, while Greene, Taylor, and Scott are not relatively conspicuous men. The civil war, however, was a colossal struggle in every way, and Professor Johnston shows a proper eye for proportion in taking eight of his thirteen types from the men who were famous then. Undoubtedly the story of American soldiership culminates in in- terest at the battle of Gettysburg, to which Mr.-Johnston assigns adequate space. He has other merits than a good sense of pro- portion. Though not a man of military training, he has sound judgment and indus- try, and has written a book for Prof. W. P. Trent’s series on Leading Americans, which will help general readers, if not technical students. Confining our particular remarks to the Gettysburg campaign, we may say that the critics always have fought over it, and al- ways will. Our author, we think, is too much influenced by the writers who sus- tain Lee through thick and thin, casting the responsibility for the Confederate de- feat upon the shortcoming of subordinates. It can be plausibly asserted that errors abounded in the enterprise for which the chief was to blame. Great and brilliant though Lee was, he could make mistakes. It would probably have been better if Lee, utilizing his interior lines, after Chancel- lorsville, had left D. H. Hill to defend Richmond, while he himself, with a large force, crossed the mountains into Tennes- see; there, uniting with Bragg, by march- ing rapidly upon Cincinnati, in May and June of 1863, when the North was full of discontent and mutiny, he might have so threatened the connections between East and West that Grant would have been forced to loosen his hold on Vicksburg and hurry to the Ohio. In such a plan of cam- paign the possibilities of a good result to the Confederates were large. But leaving aside the matter of grand strategy, we be- lieve that Lee’s conduct in Pennsylvania was far from faultless. Mr. Johnston ad- mits the error of allowing Stuart to de- part withthe cavalry, thus leaving the army without eyes and ears in a hostile coun- try. The event proved that it would have been better to manceuvre to get between the Federals and Washington, than to risk an offensive battle. The battle once joined there were serious errors, both of omission and commission, notably the charge of Pickett, which cannot fairly be ascribed to the corps-commanders. We think Mr. Johnston might have paid more heed to the much abused Longstreet’s defence of him- self, and could have learned much from Gen. E. P. Alexander’s “Memoirs of a Confederate,” which probably appeared too late for our author’s use. As Mr. Johnston is too easy as regards the errors of Lee, his recognition of the merits of Meade we hold to be quite too cool. Put into command of his widely stat- tered host only a day or two before the battle, losing at its beginning his chief lieutenant, a man upon whom he especially relied, embarrassed by the insubordination of Sickles, who threw his schemes into confusion at a most critical moment, Meade undertook the conflict heavily handicapped. His course during the three days was bold and skilful in a high degree. He utilized to the utmost the advantages of position, the “fish-hook” of Cemetery Hill and Ridge, which fell into his hands. Alexan- der pronounces the Federal tactics a mas- terpiece in the management of large masses in a defensive engagement. We contend that in refusing to throw his exhausted army on the afternoon of July 3, upon an enemy whose demoralization at the mo- ment he had no means of knowing, Meade took the prudent course. A little of the imprudence which Lee was _ constantly showing, might have put the Confederates to rout and closed the war. We can see now that the risk should have been run, but Meade had reason in his caution. Lee was a brilliant military genius, but with all that he had the mortal liability to shortcoming. We know that Lee was much dissatisfied with himself after Get- tysburg. There are plenty of other cases where we might take issue with Mr. Johnston in his estimates of men and interpretation of events—in all of which, as in the case of Gettysburg, we have no doubt he might make a good defence, and in the judgment of many quite confute and confound his critic. The contentions among those who seek to interpret wars are only less mark- ed than they are among the combatants in the field. Though many things in the story of American soldiers strike us differently we do not fail to recognize in this narrator knowledge, fair-mindedness, and good sense. Berlin comme je Vai Huard. New York: Co. It takes a Frenchman to discover Berlin, and when he has found it, he may be ex- pected to express himself interestingly. Particularly if he is an artist as well as an author, he is likely to be entertaining, as in the case of M. Huard, who had pad and crayon always with him, and gives us some ninety-three sketches of the strange Allemands. There are inviting vistas in parks, burly German cab drivers and cooks, busy modern streets, quaint taverns, Herr Studiosus with beer-steins, and, of course, Prussian police and majestic military. That it is Berlin we see before us no one who knows the imperial city will doubt; and that the author aims to be fair and gen- erous, is also certain. But German as are the sketches, both in crayon and in word, there is still in the background a sugges- tion of the avenues and quays of Paris and the French lorgnette. The volume is a mate to “New York comme je l'ai vu,” the second in a series to be concluded by a work on London. Beginning with the famous avenue Unter den Linden, Huard thinks with many others that the Berliners have exaggerated its at- vu. Par Charles G. E. Stechert &
Page 21
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 379 traction, and yet he admits its importance in one of the great cities of the world. He meets there few Frenchmen, many Russians, and, above all and everywhere, Americans, whose nasal accent, revealing Pittsburghand Chicago, dominates the barsand grill-rooms, hotels, and shipping-offices. Entering the Tiergarten, Huard finds a population of marble and bronze, nor can he “make threc steps forward without having to swallow a couple of monuments’! The Sieges Allee in particular arrests him, but not because of its charms; he sees in the thirty-two figures of Prussian or Brandenburgian sov- ereigns only a horrible show of brutal force—heavy fists and ponderous boots displayed with little discretion. The French, it is true, have erected numerous monuments in honor of their victories, for the glory of their armies; but never have they so impudently sung of their triumphs. so insulted the conquered. Nevertheless, the Tiergarten is the paradise of children and nurses, of saunterers and dreamers. M. Huard is especially struck by the admir- able cleanliness of the lawns and of the érives—a characteristic not only of the Gar- den, but of Berlin as a whole. In com- parison, Paris is a stable, London a sewer, and New York a dirty hole (une bauge!). Taking up the streets and street life of Berlin, M. Huard remarks that while one must plough through the disagreeable in entering the capital by whatever route is chosen, once one is inside the trans- formation comes quickly and completely. Berlin is new and without pronounced character, very new, newer than any Amer- ican city, newer than Chicago, which is the only city of the world to be compared with Berlin for prodigious rapidity of develop- ment. Much that one sees in Berlin re- ealls an American city born yesterday in the fire of speculation, but an American city in which there is lacking the frenzied rush of the mobs, the atmosphere of strife, and the audacity of new architecture. One is also impressed with the admirable dis- cipline of the Berlin people, the suppress- ed cries of their venders, the modesty of street advertising. “When Buffalo Bill made his tour of Germany,” said Mark Twain, “his principal poster was not larger than a trunk label.” Strolling further in the city, Huard is impressed with the mar- vellous development of German industry. It was but a few years ago that England controlled the markets of the world; but now Germany’s stock of tools is greater than that of Great Britain or France, and comparable only to the industrial outfit of America. There was one kind of dress which never escaped the artist-author’s eye or pencil. That was the uniform of the German sol- dier. To the amateurs of military spec- tacles, Berlin offers a field of observation unexcelled, nor is it possible that in any other city of the world so many regiments file by, or so many sentinels cross one’s path. Indeed, from the deference shown the humblest wearer of a uniform, one sees, from the time one first sets foot in Germany, that the soldier is King, the offi- cer is God! Little enlivens this military show—except an occasional marriage with an American heiress. Besides the military, “the quantity of doctors and professors is innumerable, all ceremoniously running afoul of each other, each carrying his head high, and repeating the other’s respective titles to everbody’s satisfaction.” The women even absurdly use their husbands’ titles. One lady having saluted another in the tramway with “Comment allez-vous Madame le Chef d’Escadron?” received in reply: “Trés bien, je vous remercie, chére Madame Professeur de Théologie!” In dealing with the palaces and museums of Berlin, M. Huard shows the fullest appre- ciation, praising the Emperor for his art designs in a manner scarcely to be ex- pected from a foreign critic. He is delight- ful, both as artist and scribe, in his pic- tures of “Old Berlin,”’ lingering long and sketching with much feeling the little Fischerstrasse, and paying due homage, with the scared, scampering urchins, to the frowning, helmeted, heavily treading Schutz- mann. This majestic officer of the law re- calls in turn the pleasures of the German Verboten. In Germany one is forbidden to sit on certain benches, to speak in certain rooms, to smoke in certain gardens, to stand, to walk, to go up, to come down; in fact, to do just the very thing one wishes. And then, as if to make life still more miserable—at least for a Frenchman—the Germans do not know how to cook, but serve the most abominable concoctions ever devised by man. Epicures among the Ger- mans are unknown, and that is why the poor stranger within the Berlin gates would rather be stretched out, parched and pant- ing, on the deserts of Sahara than encoun- ter deutsche Suppe or a German Salat. A Vedic Concordance. By Maurice Blqgom- field. Royal 4to. Pp. 1102. Boston: Ginn & Co. $6. In the preface to his “‘Concordance to the Holy Scriptures,”’ the marvellous and erratic Cruden gives a brief historical account of concordances. Their value has been prac- tically recognized for well-nigh seven cen- turies, from the time of the Dominican friar, Hugo de St. Chers, who made a con- cordance to the Vulgate, employing, we are told, five hundred monks to help him. “The meaningofthe Scripturemaybehere known,” says Cruden, “by that which is accounted the best rule of interpreting Scripture, namely, by comparing one Scripture with another.” The rule holds no less for the sacred books of the Hindus than for those of the Christians. Bloomfield’s monumental work, accordingly, might justly make the proud claim to be a tool of absolutely first importance for the understanding of the books which are not only the most ancient scriptures of India, but are also the oldest recorded documents of the Indo-European family. It is well described by its title as “an alphabetic index to every line of every stanza of the published Vedic literature and to the liturgical formulas thereof, that is, an index to the Vedic Mantras, together with an account of their variations in the differ- ent Vedic books.” Strictly speaking, this concordance has no predecessor. Editors of many of the va- rious Vedic texts have, indeed, given for each an index of first lines of every stanza; but Bloomfield’s is an index to every line of every stanza. The earlier indexes, too, were ‘scattered through many different volumes; but Bloomfield’s, while being vastly more ecmprehensive in its scope, gives everything in one ‘single volume and in one single al- phabetic arrangement—advantages so great as to need only a bare rehearsal. From a rough calculation, the work would seem to contain a good deal over one hundred thou- sand entries, and of these some forty thou- sand come from the Rig-Veda alone, which is, of course, by far the most important of the books indexed; but, as appears from a bibliography of the works cited, not less than one hundred and eighteen other works, of which many areveryextensive, have been read and excerpted. It is more or less the fashion now to decry the kind of philological activity which consists in indexing and pigeon-hol- ing innumerable facts on slips, die Zettel- wirtschaft as the Germans call it. It is therefore in place to mention the fact that, although Bloomfield’s book does indeed pre- suppose an enormous amount of patient manipulation of slips, such drudgery would have been of no avail without a very broad and scholarly acquaintance with the Vedic literature as a whole. Most Vedic texts, even though largely or wholly metrical, are usually printed, like a German hymn- book, as solid prose. It requires the eye and mind of the highly practised expert to disengage the verse from the prose and to resolve the stanzas, into the metrical units of which they consist. The “Concordance” is, however, not mere- ly an instrument for the interpretation of the Vedas, it is a text-critical tool of the most far-reaching importance. The re- corded Vedic texts of the several different schools represent each the result of a long process of transmission, by oral tradition, of material, much of which was once com- mon to the predecessors of many different schools. Thus it happens that the readings of the different schools are to the -Vedic text-critic what the readings of the dif- ferent manuscripts are to the critical editor of a Greek text. The variants of verses which do not differ at the beginning and for which therefore the alphabetic order does not require more than one entry, are shown by Bloomfield in a very clear and compact form; so that the readings of as many as eight different texts, or perhaps more, can be instantly seen from a single brief entry; while for variants of verses which involve more than one alphabetic entry, a simple and effective system of cross-references has been devised. Hardly one single Vedic text has been edited so well in all respects, that a new edition is not already needed. The new editions should be made upon a broad and comprehensive and uniform plan. For the future editors of these texts, Professor Bloomfield has done a great service. His work is unpretentious; but—rapidly as books get out of date now-a-days—it is likely to maintain itself as an indispen- sable tool of Vedic scholarship through not a few decades. It is a worthy companion to Whitney’s great critical commentary on the Atharva-Veda; and it is safe to say that not in India or Europe or Amer- ica has any work appeared in this field within the last score of years, transcending these two in scientific value and signifi- cance. The typography, binding, in short, all the externals of the work merit the highest praise. In his preface, Bloomfield acknowledges the help received from no less than fourteen of his old pupils at the
Page 22
8380 The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 Johns Hopkins University. The list is one to awaken his pride no less than his grati- tude. The “Concordance” forms volume 10 of the Harvard Oriental Series. Science. Cyclopedia of American Agriculture: A Popular Survey of Agricultural Conditions, Practices, and Ideals in the United States and Canada. Edited by L. H. Bailey. With one hundred full-page plates, and more than two thousand illustrations in the text. 4 vols. Vol. I.-Farms. Vol. II.- Crops. New York: The Macmillan Com- pany. $5 each. P The name of Liberty Hyde Bailey on the title-page of this new cyclopedia is a suf- ficient guarantee of its comprehensiveness and authority. It is of similar scope and character to Professor Bailey's “Cyclopedia o* American Horticulture,” and the veteran author's long service in the Cornell Agricul- ture Experiment Station as an investigator and educator of the people has eminently fitted him for the management of the im- portant work of bringing together in com- pact form the voluminous and scattered re- sults of the study and practice of agricul- ture. No branch of scientific research has ever been subsidized so extensively as agri- culture in America by the Federal and State Governments through their agricultural de- partments, commissions, colleges, and ex- periment stations. In this there has been updeniably a great waste of money and loss of efficiency, not due to dishonesty, but chiefly to the fact that the gigantic task of investigation and popular education was pioneer work for which neither the methods nor the men were ready. Yet taken as a whole this research has undoubtedly paid richly in increased yield of crops, improved stock, protection against insect foes and disease, greater certainty of results, and unequalled rapidity of development of new territory. But the lack of system and even of cod}peration among the institutions in different States, or in the same, has re- sulted in a mass of literature of all de- grees of value, which greatly needs to be summarized and digested in such a work as this. About one hundred experts have con- tributed articles to each of these two vol- umes, and credit is given to twice as many more for assistance in various ways. These contributions have been codérdinated with considerable skill to avoid repetition as far as possible. The alphabetic arrangement has been wisely abandoned, except for sub- divisions of articles, each of the large vol- umes of about 700 pages being divided by subjects, and a full index being given to the whole volume. The geography of agriculture is the first topic. The achievements and possibilities of each State are discussed in turn, gener- ally by local authorities, and there are special articles on tropical agriculture in Hawaii, Porto Rico, and the Philippines. The planning of all sorts of farms is then considered, with estimates of the cost of different undertakings. Farm _ buildings, sanitation, and machinery are next treated, with some reference to rural art. The suc- ceeding chapter on the position and tex- ture of the soil includes the results of the notable series of investigations which have been carried on in the last fifteen years by the United States Department of Agri- culture. There is a contribution by the pioneer in soil analysis, Prof. E. W. Hilgard, now of the University of Calir fornia, as well as articles by the young men whom the Department has been train- ing up for this special work. The chapter on tillage includes a great deal of histori- cal matter, beginning with the Egyptians and Virgil, and recalling many of the for- gotten benefactors of mankind, Jethro Tull of horse-hoe husbandry and John Johnston of tile drainage. Special attention is giv- en to the agriculture of the arid and semi- arid regions; the Campbell system of dry farming is described by its inventor, ir- rigation by’ Elwood Mead, and alkali by Thomas H. Means. The chapter on wea- ther service is especially commendable, for its clear treatment of this difficult sub- ject and its practical interpretation of wea- ther signs. The second volume is chiefly devoted to North American field crops, from alfalfa to wheat, preceded by chapters on the growth and breeding of plants in gen- eral. The “Cyclopedia of American Agricul- ture” is indispensable to public and ref- erence libraries, and it should be exten- sively purchased for circulating and school libraries in the rural districts. Probably few farmers will conceive it possible to invest $20 in such a work, though they could well afford to, for it would easily save its cost in a year or two by attention to its instructions in regard, for example, to the purchase of fertilizers, insecticides, and seeds. It is a book which would be read in any family whose members read at all, for the language is in most cases as simple as can be employed on the subjects treated, and the book as a whole is readily com- prehensible to any person of average educa- tion. The technical data which form its foundations are duly subordinated. The pictures are mostly what they should be—small drawings inserted in the text just at the point where they are needed, though there are also many full-page half- tones. A few color plates might have been introduced to advantage, not to make a show and sell the book, but to bring out some points better than the black-and- white can do. In certain cases the ar- rangement or character of the illustrations could be improved, as, for example, in the case of mushrooms, where the cuts of the edible and poisonous species of amanita should have been placed side by side in- stead of 300 pages apart. and their differ- ences clearly indicated by marking direct- ly on the cuts. In the article on chemical weed-killers directions for the use of sul- phurie acid, carbolic acid, and arsenical compounds are given without the slightest warning as to the dangerous nature of these substances and the precautions necessary in handling them. The American Electrochemical Society held its twelfth general meeting in this city October 17, 18, and 19. The _ pro- gramme contained the following papers: “Diamond and Moissanite; Natural, Arti- ficial, and Meteoric,”’ Dr. George F. Kunz; “Deflocculated Graphic,” E. G. Acheson; “Electrothermic Reduction of Iron Ores,” Albert E. Greene and Frank S. MacGregor; “The Electric-Furnace Experiments for the Production of Pig Iron at Sault Ste. Marie,” Dr. Joseph W. Richards; ‘“Electric-Fur- nace Experiments,” Dr. H. N. Potter; “Moissan’s Experiments on the _ Boiling Points of the Metals,” Dr. O. P. Watts; “The Electrometallurgy of Zinc,” Gustave Gin; “A New Application of Chlorine in Metallurgy,” C. E. Baker; “The Heat Con- ductivity of Carbon,” F. A. J. Fitzgerald; “Granular Carbon Resistors,” Prof. S. A. Tucker; “Physico-chemical Notes on the Aluminates of Soda,” P. B. Sadtler; “Ac- tion of Ammonium Persulphates on Met- als,” J. W. Turrentine; “Use of the Ca- pillary Electrometer for Alternating Vol- tages,” M. G. Floyd; “Electroscopic De- termination of Radium in some Tufa at Hot Springs, Arkansas,” Dr. Herman Schlundt”; “Electrolytic Separation of Sil- ver and Copper,” H.»- W. Gillett; “Electro- lytic Determination of Minute Quantities of Copper,” E. E. Free; “Electrolytic Reduction of Nitric Acid,” Dr. H. E. Patten; “Electrochemical Methods for the Qualitative and Quantitative Determination of Free Silicon in the Presence of Silica, Silicates, Oxides, Free Carbon, and Carbo- rundum,” W. R. Mott; “Nature of Electro- lytic Conductors,” Dr. L. Kahlenberg; ‘‘The Electrolytic Theory of the Corrosion of Tron,” Dr. A. S. Cushman. Drama. Unpublished Correspondence of David Gar- rick. Edited by George Pierce Baker. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $7.50 net. Of all.the illustrious Englishmen of the eighteenth century, few are so well known to students of that period as the “mod- ern Roscius,” David Garrick. His per- sonal charm, no less than his brilliant his- trionic genius, won him the intimate friend- ship of many of the most famous literary and artistic personages of his day, who, by pen and pencil, have reconstituted him for us almost in his habit as he lived. Bos- well, Walpole, Hannah More, Madame d’Ar- blay, Kitty Clive,and Goldsmith, not to men- tion many others, and his own voluminous correspondence, have made his character, in all its varying aspects, as familiar to us as Gainsborough, Hogarth, Holland, and the rest have made his face and figure. It would be strange if, at this late date, any important new light could be thrown upon his disposition, his ability, or his career, and those who look for it in this hitherto unpublished correspondence, which Profes- sor Baker has extracted from the collection of J. H. Leigh, will be disappointed. With Mr. Baker the work of editing evi- dently has been a labor of love, as is proved by his ample explanatory notes, but it is unlikely that the ordinary reader will find in the letters the significance which the editor seems to attach to them. So far as they go they are thoroughly characteristic of their author, but the majority of them, although they possess a certain antiquarian interest, are exceedingly trivial, and are scarcely worthy of public reproduction. Everywhere they bear the marks of careless haste. The references to Miss Cadogan show that Gar- rick was capable of warm friendship, a fact which has never been disputed, but otherwise they are not remarkable.
Page 23
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 881 Some of the letters dealing with his managerial difficulties are of more conse- guence, but the new matter in them is not weighty enough to call for detailed con- sideration. One of the most interesting passages contains a criticism of Home’s “Douglas,”” with which most persons who are acquainted with that dreary tragedy will heartily agree, but whether Garrick would have expressed the same opinion if he had discerned a good character in it for himself is another question: One of the Hoadley letters, however, seems to prove that the actor was quite sincere in his ex- pressed wish to leave the stage in 1765, but scarcely relieves him from all suspicion of seeking the good will of those high in authority. That he was anxious for august patronage ought not to be imputed to him as a grievous fault. In his day no actor, not even himself, could have existed with- out it. But if Professor Baker’s work is of some- what less moment than he deems it as a contribution to Garrick lore, it is neverthe- less a dainty volume, which will be sought eagerly by theatrical connoisseurs for the excellence of its typography and the beauty of its illustrations, which show the great actor at different periods of his life and in various characters, and afford materia] for an interesting study in physiognomy. Sev- eral of the portraits will be new to most readers As the First Folio edition of Shakes- peare (T. Y. Crowell & Co.) draws nearer completion, its value becomes always clearer. So far as we have tested the work of the editors, Charlotte Porter and Helen A. Clarke, it is done with minute accuracy, and this in an edition which attempts to reproduce the exact text of 1623, with various illustrations and read- ings from all sources,is a matter of the first importance. In the play of “Romeo and Juliet” now published the advantage of the Folio text is well marked by the in- clusion of five significant lines in Romeo's death speech, which modern editors, with the exception of Collier, omit, on the au- thority of the Fourth Quarto. The production of Percy Mackaye’s “Sappho and Phaon”’ in the Lyric Theatre did not achieve a success commensurate with the literary and dramatic value of the work, which is a genuine tragedy, classic in form, modern in inspiration, and rich and strong in poetic expression. It deals with human emotions and passions; is pictur- esque, varied, and vigorous in action, and is as full of really dramatic situations as it is of imaginative fancy. From a literary point of view, it is on a level with the best work of Stephen Phillips, while for purely theatrical purposes it is superior. If it had been acted thirty or forty years ago, before the race of actors trained in the poetic drama had become almost extinct, it would have received a far more competent interpretation than is now possible. The performance on Monday evening, although a great deal of money and pains had been ex- pended upon it, failed of its legitimate ef- fect for two reasons; first, because the actors, trained for the most part in the modern manner, were unable to identify themselves with the romantic mood; and, secondly, because, almost without excep- tion, they were wholly incapable of giv- ing to the verse its proper emphasis and rhythm. Thus many essential beauties of the poetry vanished. Madame Kalich, the Sappho, can declaim with much power and discrimination, but she has not yet master- ed the difficulties of English pronunciation, and in moments of excitement she was often unintelligible... Thus, the play was deprived of some of its greatest charm. None of the performers, except Madame Kalich, distinguished themselves in action. She was often exceedingly effective in the closing tragic scenes, especially in her profound despair and humiliation after Phaon’s reconversion to slavery. One of the most attractive features of the repre- sentation was the incidental music, written by Prof. A. A. Stanley of the University of Michigan, and admirably rendered. The stage setting and the costumes were un- commonly beautiful. Mrs. Patrick Campbell will play an ea- gagement of one week at the Lyric Thea- tre here beginning November 11. She will present ““The Second Mrs. Tanqueray,” “The “Notorious Mrs. Ebbsmith,” “Magda,” and “Hedda Gabler.” Immediately upon the completion of this engagement Mrs. Camp- bell will begin her tour of the country from coast to coast. In the spring she will again be seen in New York, and will offer her new productions, including a version of the “‘Electra” of Euripides. The Ben Greet Players recently began a new tour in Jersey City. Thence the company travelled to Canada, where a month’s season of Shakespeare’s plays “as Shakespeare wrote them,” has begun. Mr. Greet leaves the selection of his plays 10 the students of various colleges and che public, and those chosen by Canadians are “Julius Cesar,” “Macbeth,” “Romeo and Juliet,” “As You Like It,” “Twelfth Night,” and’ “Everyman.” About the New Year, Mr. Greet hopes to present a “cycle” of plays, written around “The Wonder Book” o! Nathaniel Hawthorne. They will prob- ably be given first at a series of matinées in Boston and New York. so that the Shakespearian plays can be given at night. The latest comedy of Madeleine Lucette Ryley, “‘The Sugar Bowl,” which has just been produced in London, is not to be reckoned, it appears, among her most suc- cessful efforts. Most of her critics agree in regarding this story as unlikely, to say the least, and the literary execution as decidedly inferior. The most notable fea- ture of the performance appears to have been the admirable acting of Ellis Jeffreys and Frederick Kerr, in the leading charac- ters. Music. Frinnerungen an Richard Wagner. Von Angelo Neumann. Leipzig: L. Staack- mann. Neumann's volume is the most important biographic contribution to musical litera- ture since the beginning of the century, with the exception of Wagner’s Letters to Frau Wesendonck. It contains a large number of the master’s letters which have never before been printed, and it gives so many interest- ing glimpses of life behind the scenes—both literally and figuratively—that in a short ime it has reached its fourth edition. Angelo Neumann is one of the many men who have become well known through connection with Richard Wagner. He began his career as a baritone, half a century ago. In those days it was regarded as an heroic feat to sit through a whole per- formance of “Lohengrin,” and Neumann re- members a performance of the “Flying Dutchman” with a good cast, which he left before the end of the second act. He be- came an enthusiast during the concerts which Wagner conducted in Vienna in 1862; he remembers how, after the “Freischiitz” overture, Wagner patted on the back the first horn player, whom he had coached with special care; and he remembers meeting the great man repeatedly in the street, coming from a “Tristan’’ rehearsal, usually talk- ing to himself and flicking his’ large red handkerchief. Two years later Neumann happened to occupy a room in the Hotel Marquardt in Stuttgart next to that of Wagner, who was then so hard up that he could not eat at the table d’héte, because that had to be paid for at once. This was just a day or two before he received the message from Ludwig II., which instantly changed him from a fugitive from creditors to the favorite of a king, with unlimited means placed at his disposal. In 1875, Neumann enjoyed the good fortune of being one of the artists who witnessed the rehearsals of ‘“Tannhiuser” and “Lohengrin” in Vienna under Wagner's per- sonal direction. What he saw on these oc- casions convinced him that this man was not only the foremost dramatic composer of all times, but the greatest stage-manager and actor. The six pages of details he gives of these rehearsals cannot be too highly commended to all interpreters of those operas. In the following year Neumann became joint manager, with August Fiérster of the Leipzig Stadttheater, and from that time on he played a réle in the life of Wagner, the importance of which has here- . tofore been known to few. The first Bayreuth Festival took place in that year. Neumann heard the second cycle, and was so enthusiastic that he conceived the am- bitious plan of securing for Leipzig the privilege of being the first city after Bayreuth to hear the Ring of the Nibelung. His first overtures were answered by Wag- ner evasively: * My work jis not yet finished; the per- formances called my attention to many im- perfections. Leave me time to repeat ny work next year here in Bayreuth in a carefully revised form. When Wagner found, however, that for pe- cuniary reasons there could be no festi- val in 1877, he remembered the offer from Leipzig and reopened negotiations. But Férster was less enthusiastic than his part- ner; his doubts as to the feasibility and profitableness of the Nibelung operas grew and were fortified by various enemies of Wagner. The upshot was that the project was dropped, to the great distress of Neu- mann. At a dinner when one of the afore- said enemies got up and proposed a toast of congratulation at having got rid of Wag- ner, Neumann dashed his glass on the floor and left the room. It so happened that the season at the Leipzig Theatre closed with a deficit of $30,000. This gave Neumann a chance to say “I told you so” to his rueful compan- ion. To cut a long story short, prepara-
Page 24
The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 tions for producing the Ring were soon under way. The chief obstacle to overcome was the famous Gewandhaus orchestra. The members of this ancient and honorable or- ganization, founded in 1781 and presided over at one time by Mendelssohn, were con- vinced that this latest Wagnerian music was unworthy of their serious attention and would lower their artistic level. They were finally persuaded, however, to acquiesce, and, when the task was accomplished, they frankly conceded that their artistic level had been actually raised. Once before, Neumann had had trouble with this orches- tra. It was when his regular conductor, Josef Sucher, was on a vacation, and he had ordered a performance of ‘“Tannhiauser”’ under Arthur Nikisch. The players object- ed to Nikisch as too young, but were final- ly persuaded to try him at a rehearsal. The result was a demonstrative success. It was Neumann’s good luck to introduce to the world four of the greatest living conduc- tors—Sucher and Nikisch, as well as Anton Seidl and Felix Mottl, these last two on the recommendation of Wagner. Concern- ing Seidl there are many things in this volume of special interest to Americans, as it was due largely to this favorite conduc- tor that Wagner’s later operas made their triumphant entry in this country. That Wagner had more confidence in him than in any other interpreter of his works is proved by remarks in several of his letters here printed. To cite only one of these, dated September 27, 1878 (two years after Hans Richter had conducted the Ring at Bayreuth): No other conductor knows my tempi and the correspondence of the music to the ac- tion as Seidl does. He is my pupil. He will conduct for you the Nibelung dramas better than any one else. If this word of mine is not sufficient, I shall never have any more recommendations to make to you. Neumann lost no time in adding Seidl to his forces, and under him battle after bat- tle was won. The Leipzig performances were a brilliant success; so were those Neumann gave ac: the Victoria Theatre in Berlin. The recital of the incidents leading up to and attending these Berlin perfor- mances makes one of the most extraordin- ary stories in the history of music. Hiilsen, the manager of the Royal Opera, had a very poor opinion of Wagner altogether, and as for the Nibelung operas, he wa® convinced that the only one worthy of being mounted on his stage was “Die Walkiire.” Wagner, on his part, refused to sell the rights for a single one of these connected works. Neumann's enthusiasm finally per- suaded Hiilsen to negotiate for the whole work. Diverse difficulties were overcome, the greatest being the engagement of Seidl, which Wagner made an absolute condition. There was a rule that new operas must not be conducted by any one but the regular Kapellmeister. This was finally overcome by appointing Seidl, with the Emperor's special consent, assistant conductor for three months. All the negotiations were concluded when finally Hiilsen sent a tele- gram to Wagner telling him he agreed to everything, providing he be allowed sub- sequently to produce “Die Walkiire.” To this insulting dispatch, with its implica- tion that the other three dramas were not worth producing, Wagner did not deign to reply. “‘The impudent fellow has not an- swered me,” said Hiilsen to Neumann, and the project was dropped, so far as the Royal Opera was concerned. The Victoria Theatre was then chosen, and the perfor- mances were an unprecedented success, be- ing supported by royalty and aristocracy as well as by the populace. When the cur- tain had dropped on the last scene of the first cycle, it was raised again and Neu- mann made a speech of thanks to his patrons. Just as he had spoken the words, “Thanks above all to the exalted members of our imperial family,”” Wagner, who stood among the artists, abruptly left the stage. This action was generally construed as an insult to the Emperor; Neumann himself took it as such, and he refused to accept Wagner's explanation that a sudden illness (heart trouble from the great excitement) had prompted it. Not till after the com- poser’s death did he realize that Wagner had spoken the truth. Fortunately this incident did not for a long time estrange the two men. The Kaiser showed by attending several sub- sequent performances and applauding vigor- ously, that he did not feel insulted, while Neumann, having won Wagner’s con- fidence, gained his consent for his project of a travelling Wagner Theatre for carrying the gospel to all the leading cities. The adventures which befell them in Paris, London, and the other European cities down to Italy take up the remaining pages of Neumann’s reminiscences, a volume of absorbing interest. “The Merry Widow,” the most sensation- ally successful operetta produced in Europe in two decades, has at last reached this country. After a month of preliminary per- formances in several other cities, it was given at the New Amsterdam Theatre on Monday evening by an excellent cast, in- cluding Ethel Jackson as the widow, Don- ald Brian as the prince, and an artistic ensemble such as Henry W. Savage has taught Americans to expect at his produc- tions. Its great success is significant be- cause it disproves the theory of managers that genuine operetta is too good for our public, which for a number of years has had little but vaudeville masquerading as musical comedy. “The Merry Widow” is genuine comedy, wedded to genuine music. The composer, Franz Lehar, is not as origi- nal as Johann Strauss, but he bids fair to equal Millécker or even Suppé. The waltz in the second act has already reached a sale of a million copies, and it is not by any means the best thing in the score. An interesting list of compositions is of- fered by the Philharmonic Society at ‘ts Carnegie Hall concerts this season. There will be revivals of Rubinstein’s ‘“‘Ocean’”’ symphony, Beethoven's “Pastoral,”” Dvo- rék’s “From the New World,” Schubert's Unfinished Symphony, Saint-Saéns’s C-Minor symphony with organ, Richard Strauss’s symphonic poem, “Don Juan,” Goldmark’s “Prometheus,” and Nicodé’s Symphonic Variations. “Herod's Dream,” which con- stitutes the first part of Berlioz’s oratorio, “The Childhood of Christ,” is planned for the third concert, at which the Philhar- monic Orchestra will have the assistance of the Bach Choral Society of Montclair. Wassily Safonoff, the conductor, has also been busy during his absence in Europe in selecting novelties; among these are the “Easter” overture by Rimsky Korsakof. “Das Meer,” by Glazounoff, and the sym- phonic poem, “The Sunken Bell,” by Viad- imir Metzl, founded on Gerhart Haupt- mann’s play, and performed last spring under the direction of Mr. Safonoff, by the London Symphony Orchestra. The list of soloists includes Kirkby-Lunn, Edward Dethier, Fritz Kreisler, Katherine Good- son, Jean Gerardy, and Josef Hofmann. The dates of the Philharmonic concerts are Friday afternoons and Saturday evenings, November 15, 16, 29, 30, December 13, 14. January 3, 4, February 7, 8, 28, 29, March 13, 14. Last season, the first under the conductorship of Wassily Safonoff, was the most successful financially, and one of the most successful artistically in the society's career of sixty-five years. The New York Symphony Society’s pro- gramme of December 1 will be devoted to “The Family,” as it has been illustrated by various composers. Walter Damrosch will give Richard Strauss’s “Sinfonia Domesti- ca,” descriptive of himself, wife, and child; and Wagner's charming tribute to Cosima cen the birth of their son Siegfried, en- titled “‘Siegfried Idyl.”’ The directors of the Musical Art Society announce that two concerts will be given in Carnegie Hall on Thursday evenings, De- cember 19 and March 12. In compliance with requests made by many of the sub- scribers of the Musical Art Society, the programmes of this season will contain a number of the works that proved most in- teresting during the past years. The most important works will be the ‘“‘Missa Papae Marcelli,” and the “Stabat Mater,” by Palestrina. The choir of the society has been increased by the addition of a num- ber of excellent artists, and is therefore better equipped to render the larger works for double chorus. Oscar Hammerstein contemplates giving opera every night during the season at the Manhattan Opera House; the large number of singers already engaged, with the three conductors, makes such a policy possible. The first of the first-class pianists to appear at Carnegie Hall this season is Jo- sef Hofmann. He will give a recital next Saturday afternoon, at which he will play the whole set of twenty-five Chopin Pre- luGes, a Beethoven sonata, a Mendelssohn scherzo, Schumann’s C major fantasie, and three Liszt pieces—‘‘Legende,” ‘“‘Dream of Love,”” and “Campanella.” Paderewski sailed from Europe Saturday for his seventh American tour. His first concert in New York was given on Novem- ber 17, 1891, in Carnegie Hall. That season he played 117 times. He returned the fol- lowing year and gave 67 concerts in 26 cities. His other tours were in the sea- sons of 1895-6, 1899-1900, 1901-2, and 1904-5. The present tour is one of the most ex- tensive that he has ever undertaken. It will last at least until the first of May. Already eighty appearances have been book- ed for him, and if he is willing to under- take more this number will be increased. This, however, is doubtful, as he does not care to play more than three times a week, except under extraordinary conditions, and his tour has been arranged with this limi- tation in view. In addition to his own new works he has added to his repertoire sev- eral pieces of importance, which he has never played in America. Among these are
Page 25
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. 383 Liszt’s B minor sonata; Beethoven’s sonata in B flat, Op. 27, No. 1; Chopin’s Scherzo in B flat minor; two études and a nocturne by the same composer; Stojowski’s “Chant d'Amour,” and Lizst’s transcription of Schubert’s “‘Auf dem Wasser zu singen.”’ Art. Public Baths and Wash-Houses: A treatise on their planning, design, arrangement, and fitting. By Alfred W. S. Cross, pp. xii, 276; 274 illustrations, New York: Im- ported by Chas. Scribner’s Sons. $7.50 net. The public bath is a much more impor- taut institution in Europe than among us. The abundance of bathing facilities in American houses and hotels, as well as in clubs, gymnasiums, Young Men’s Christian Association buildings, and public institu- tions generally in the United States, has made it superfluous to provide at public expense—or for that matter at private cost as an investment—anything like the public bath houses to be found in every British and Continental town of importance. And yet, while the well-to-do American en- joys the most complete arrangements for bathing, the poorer and humbler laboring men and women are, as a rule, unpro- vided for. Only within the last ten or fifteen years has America awakened to this deficiency, and begun to erect for the con- gested districts in our cities, bath houses, with or without laundries, and equipped with modern sanitary appliances. In England and on the Continent, on the other hand, the public bathing establishments, frequented by all classes of society, are larger and far more important architectu- rally than any of those erected by Ameri- ean municipalities. Entrances, lobbies, waiting-rooms, and rest-rooms are treated with all the elegance possible, and the swimming-pools are often of great size, and housed in halls of considerable architect- ural splendor. With the present increased attention to the subject in this country any authoritative account of the highly develop- ed foreign systems should find interested readers here. The most comprehensive treatise on bath houses hitherto published is Felix Genz- mer’s “Bade und Schwimm-Anstalten,” is- sued in 1899 by Bergstrasser in the Hand- buch der Architekur series. But German books are serviceable to only a few Ameri- cans, and Mr. Cross’s handsome volume has appeared at the right moment to attract the attention of American architects and municipal boards. Unfortunately, the title is misleading in omitting to prefix the qualifying adjective British. Not only does Mr. Cross write exclusively for the British public, and describe and illustrate only British bath houses and British practice— all of which is, of course, perfectly proper; but for him, apparently, there are no sug- gestions to be derived from Europe or America. Save for a single reference of less than two pages (pp. 100-102) to the Lassar spray bath and the New York Re- port on Baths of 1897, and a series of il- lustrations of an English design for “Baths at Maine, U. S. A.,” (sic) there is not so much as a passing allusion to for- eign practice. Except for this limitation, he has written a thorough and painstaking compendium of British practice; and if the proportion of Mr. Cross’s own designs described and il- lustrated seems a trifle too large, this at least assures one that the book is the out- come of a wide practical experience. The work is, indeed, solidly practical from be- ginning to end; the illustrations consist entirely of plans, elevations, sections, and details; and the chapters on equipment are cast in the form of technical specifications. The text takes up first of all the site and general arrangement of a public bath- house, with special discussion of the en- trances and ticket-offices, and follows these with chapters on swimming-baths, private baths, spray baths, and public wash houses and laundries. Several chapters are de- voted to details of construction and equip- ment, heating and lighting, administration and maintenance. Ample appendices set forth the most important acts of Parlia- ment and regulations of the London County Council pertaining to buildings of this class. In the treatment of all these sub- jects emphasis is laid on the fundamentals of convenience, abundant light, systematic heating and sound construction. The au- thor’s conclusions are generally reasonable and clearly set forth. Much of what he says should be suggest- ive for American architects. One feature which strikes the American reader is the duplication of the outfit for different class- es: nearly every establishment has its first and second-class baths and plunges; some even a third-class division. In this respect the Germans are somewhat more democratic than the British. An evidence of British conservatism is seen in the persistence of the “‘slipper’’ or tub bath, as the normal unit of the bathing system. The spray bath and the needle bath are referred to as if they were foreign innovations, commendable perhaps, but not for that reason to be thought of as necessarily supplanting the time-honored, if unsanitary, public slipper tub. The architecture shown is rational, but not of great distinction or charm. Per- haps the most generaily useful part of Mr. Cross’s work is that relating to public swim- ming pools, in regard to which the English practice is in many ways far ahead of our own. The book is a handsome imperial octavo, and, like most English technical works of its class, is excellently printed. It is fur- nished with tables of contents and an in- dex which might have been more detailed, but is fairly complete. In spite of its limi- tations, the volume should be on the shelves of every technical library and of every architect who is likely to design bath houses. Several books of the guide-book kind come to us which will prove more or less useful. The most pretentious, and the poor- est, of these is Edith Harwood’s “Notable Pictures in Rome” (E. P. Dutton & Co.). Miss Harwood announces in her Introduc- tion: Pictures have their own story to tell if we will allow them to talk to us. +8 Sometimes in happy hours they have told me far, far more than it is in my power to put into words, all that I can express is written in this book as an invitation to others to go and look for themselves. After that one is a little surprised to find that nearly everything in the book that ‘has interest is in quotation marks, though the source of the quotation is not always given. The volume contains, of course, a great deal of information, but it would be quite as readable and much handier if all the reflections and what little may pass for criticism were cut out. The thin little book in the Modern Cicer- one Series (Leipzig) on the Royal Picture Gallery at Dresden, by Prof. Hans W. Sing- ér, is of convenient pocket size, is profusely illustrated, and the choice of a hundred and odd paintings, for comment, out of the nearly three thousand in the gallery, is in- telligent, while the author’s remarks are sensible. We can object only to the some- what pedantic habit of speaking of all art- ists by their surnames, however unfamiliar, as Vicelli for Titian, Raibolini for Francia, and Gianuzzi for Giulio Romano, and to such Germanisms as Barock. “The Umbrian Cities of Italy,” by J. W. and A. M. Cruikshank (Boston: L. C. Page & Co.) is frankly a guide-book, though “it does not give information about the details of travel, nor notice all monuments irrespective of their merit or interest.”” The plans for the identification of particular pictures in lavishly decorated churches or other buildings should prove very useful. The illustrations are good, though one regrets that so many of them are on a very small scale. The authors evidently know their ground well, and have covered it carefully. Such a state- ment as that the reliefs on the Cathedral of Orvieto “are the finest works executed south of the Alps since the great Greek masters,” seems a trifle extreme when one thinks of Donatello and Michelangelo; but too much enthusiasm is preferable to none. J. Walker McSpadden’s ‘“‘Famous Paint- ers of America” (Thomas Y. Crowell & Co.) is, in the author’s own words, an at- tempt to find the man under the skin of the painter. In ours, it is a collection of personal gossip about eleven men who hap- pened to be artists, from Benjamin West to Chase and Abbey. The general reader may find some mild entertainment in it-—it makes no pretence to give any information about art. Among the ruins of the ancient Greek city of Pagase, in Thessaly, a rare find has been made in the form of a grave monu- ment, decorated, not as usual with reliefs, but with paintings. The fortunate excavat- or, H. Orwanitopoulos, distinguished four colors all of which are in excellent preser- vation. In view of the scanty materials at our command for a proper estimation of Greek painting and use of color, each new find of this kind is of great value. The stele is also decorated with ten interesting inscriptions. A provisional account has appeared of the recent excavations at Tiryns carried on by the German Archeological Institute under the direction of Dr. W. Dérpfeld. The aim of the undertaking had been to in- vestigate the layers of earth beneath the royal palace of Tiryns, and determine whether the site was inhabited in “pre- Mycenzan” times. The results of the cam- paign were so successful that the exca- vations are to be carried on during the coming season. The layers beneath the palace were found to have accumulated to a hefght of six metres, and four separate periods of habitation were distinguished, all antedating the royal palace. At the
Page 26
The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 San southeast corner of the palace there was found a large number of terracottas, most of which seem to have belonged to the sanctuary of Hera, where they probably served as votive offerings Moreover, the “necropolis of Tiryns” for which Dérpfeld had formerly searched in vain was dis- covered in the neighborhood of the modern station Another valuable discovery has been made on the Palatine in Rome. In the neighbor- hood of the temple erected by Augustus close to the royal palace, the remains of a colossal bronze horse have come to light. This is probably part of an equestrian statue, or from a monumental frieze of the temple of Victory. Prof. Dante Va- glieril, the d rector of the excavations on the Palatine, is busily occupied in trying to find further fragments of this monument. At the same time the Forum Romanum has yielded some interesting remains. The con- vent connected with the Church of Santa Francesca Romana, on the east side of the Forum, between the Basilica Constantine and the Arch of Titus, is being fitted out as a museum for the minor antiquities found on the Forum. In digging some foun- dations in connection with this new mu- seum numerous marble fragments, parts of friezes, etc., were found which have been identified as belonging to the Arch of Titus. The presence of such fragments on this site is explained- by the fact that in the Middle Ages, when most of the Forum was still unexcavated, the Convent Santa Maria Francesca was joined to the Arch of Titus by a series of buildings for which, accord- ing to the unscrupulous methods of that time, all available pieces from ancient mon- used as building materials. uments were G. Boni, the director of the Forum exca- vations, will investigate the fragments and decide whether the new finds are to be re- stored to the Arch of Titus or kept in the Forum Museum. The Metropolitan Museum of Art, acting in codperation with Mrs. Saint-Gaudens, will hold a commemorative exhibition of the works of the late sculptor, Augustus Saint-Gaudens, early next year. Where criginals cannot be secured, they will, so far as possible, be represented by casts, and if not by casts, by enlarged photo- graphs. The Charles Lawrence Hutchinson Gal- lery of Old Masters at the Art Institute ot Chicago opened this week. It is named in honor of Mr. Hutchinson, on the com- pletion of his twenty-fifth year as presi- dent of the Institute At the Wadsworth Athenwum in Hartford there are now on exhibition about 200 spec- imens of the early New England potters’ art. These pieces, a loan from Albert Hast- ings Pitkin of Hartford, are one of the most complete collections of early American ware in the United States. George Frederick Bodley, the English ec- clesiastical architect, who, with Henry Vaughn of Boston designed the Protestant Episcopal Cathedral of St. Peter and St. Paul, now being built in Washington, died on October 21. Mr. Bodley was regularly entered at an early age as an apprentice with the famous Gilbert Scott, and during the five years’ term of study he lived, ac- cording to the good old-fashioned tradition, in the house of his master. Scott drilled his pupil in a rigid convention of English Gothic, but Bodley later adopted a more gracious style He was closely as- sociated with the pre-Raphaelite move- ment. A church at Scarborough, England, designed by him earlier in his career, is decorated with cartoons by Madox Brown Burne-Jones, and Rossetti. It is said to have been through him that William Morr.» won his first opportunity to display his art in stained glass decoration. Apart from his professional interests, Mr. Bodley was a man of wide culture and attainments. He was an amateur musician of considerable ability, and a writer of verses as well. In 1899 he published a volume under the title “Poems.” He was a Royal Academician (1902), and a Fellow of the Society of An- tiquaries. Finance. HOUSE-CLEANING OF THE BANKS. The action taken regarding the Mercan- tile National Bank, the National Bank of North America, the New Amsterdam Na- tional, the Consolidated National, and the Hamilton Bank, by the executive commit- tee of the New York Associated Banks— commonly known as the “Clearing House Committee’’—is of much wider importance than appears upon the surface. To most persons the fact that a national bank had been in danger, and that it had been saved by the intervention of this committee, will doubtless be the chief point of interest; and in the eyes of bank depositors and of in- vestors generally the immediate signifi- cance of the fact is capital. In a general way, it has been inferred that the stipulation of the Clearing House Committee that the ex- isting directorate of the Mercantile Nation- al and certain directors and officers of the above mentioned affiliated institutions should resign, was due to last week's break- down of an attempt to corner United Cop- per stock. It was, in fact, disclosure of the extent to which the Mercantile Bank’s funds had been involved in that operation which brought the matter to a head. But the action of the Clearing House means a good deal more than correction of the mis- chief done in this single instance. It has to do with a series of events, dating back as far as 1901. It undertakes to deal with a State of affairs which has threatened the gravest danger to sound banking ever since that time. During the riot of Wall Street promoting schemes, half a dozen years ago, att ntion was called repeatedly to the extravagant prices bid for the stock of New York bank- ing institutions. At times these prices went so high as to give to purchas-rs of the stocks, at such figures and at preva'|- ing dividends, a net yield little greater than 2 per cent. Part of the buying was as- ecribed to large financial interests, which. in Wall Street’s view, were extending their influence over groups of financial institu- tions so as to fortify themselves in their ambitious “syndicate undertakings.”” Much of the movement, however, soon became traceable to financiers of distinctly second rate, and it was not long before the nature of their bank stock operations was discov- ered. What they were doing was to buy a con- trolling interest in the stock of a mod- erate-sized New York bank, put up this stock as collateral for loans in another tank, and use the proceeds of such loans to buy stock in still other institutions— repeating the operation with each succes- sive purchase. The practical result of this exploit was that a few capitalists of no great standing, actively engaged in specu- lative “industrial” schemes of the r own, were gaining control of a group of banks through mere stock ownership on a margin. With this control, they packed the boards cf directors in their own interest, and were naturally assumed to be using the funds of these deposit banks to support their own speculations. It is hardly necessary to point out the imminent perils of that situation. To people conversant with the facts and at all experienced in banking history, the undertaking plainly foreshadowed the pos- sible collapse of a “chain” of such institu- tions, at a moment when credit at large would thereby be most seriously deranged. Personal disaster to the affairs of one of these speculative bank owners, forcing 1 quidation of the loans for which the hold- ings of bank stock were pledged, might at any time have converged suspicion on the banks themselves—if, indeed, such suspicion did not come too late, after the men in control had gutted their banks’ resources in a struggle to save themselves. This possibility of disaster has been known for six years past. If it be asked why no one interfered with these practices during all that time, the answer is, first, that no one outside of the national banking department had the right to examine the accounts of these banks and challenge the manner of control; second, that the very hazards in- volved in existing conditions rendered open accusation extremely perilous. It was the fortunate side of last week's fall in United Copper that it gave the Clearing House Committee both the power to act and a proper opportunity for speak- ing out. The Mercantile Bank applied to the committee for assistance. As a neces- sary preliminary to such aid, the commitiee examined the institution’s loans and col- lateral. It found, as there had been every reason to expect, that the speculative own- ers of at least this one of the “‘chain of banks” had been loading its surplus ac- count with their own dubious securities. Refusing, very wisely, to stop with, stipu- lations regarding the future control and management of this single institution, the trained and conservative bank officials of the Clearing House Committee took in hand all of the banks which had been drawn into this dangerous circle. They demanded per- emptorily, not only’ resignations of certain directors in all of them, but the virtual retirement of Charles W. Morse, E. R. Thomas, and their immediate asso- ciates, from the New York banking field; and those gentlemen had no option but to submit. How great the relief produced by this drastic handling few people who have not for six years past been watching this pow- cer-mine, lying constantly open for the eparks of Wall Street speculation, can whol- ly appreciate. It is in many ways a logical and inevitable sequel to the divorcing of life insurance companies, by law, from re- lations with promoting syndicates, and the
Page 27
The Nation. 385 Oct. 24, 1907] prohibiting of ownership, by such companies. of banking institutions. That the overthrow of the mischievous “chain banking sys- tem” this month has been accomplished without appeal to the Legislature or the courts, and through the personal pressure ot the Associated Banks themselves, is a most encouraging sign. It means that leadership in our bank affairs by men of experience and conservatism is confirmed and reinforced, and that the “new order of things in American finance,” of which we heard so much in 1901, was simply the very old order of things known as unsound banking, which has now had its day and. run its course as it did in a dozen earlier eras of Bubble Finance. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Abbott, Frank Frost. A Short Roman History. Chicago: Scott, Foresman & Co. Ames, Joseph B. The Treasure of the Canyon. Holt. $1.50. a. Svante. Immunochemistry. Macmillan. 1.60 net. Baker. Louise R._ Bettie Pestee Boardwalk Com- mittee Philadelphia: Jacobs Banks, Talcott Miner. Poems. * Irving Press Barbour, —,, Henry. Tom, Dick, and Harriet. Century. $1 50. Bartlett, Dana W. The Better City. Los Ange- les: Neuner Company Press. Bates, David Homer. Lincoln in the Telegraph Office. Century. $2 net. Bennett, Abelard and Heloise. Paul El- $1.50 net Dutton. $1 net. der & Co. Binyon, Laurence. Attila. nomics for High Schools $1.20 net. Blackmar, Frank W. and Academies. Macmillan. Blanchard, Amy E. The Four Corners in Cali- fornia. Philadelphia : Jacobs. Brown, Helen Dawes. Mr. Tuckerman’s Nieces. Boston: Houghton, Miffiln & Co. Bruce, Philip Alexander. Robert E. Lee. Phila- delphia: Jacobs. Bryant, Sara Cone. Stories to Tell Children. Bos- ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. 1 net. Calthrop fon Clayton. The ance of Love. Holt. 1.50. Caffin, Charles H. Old Spanish Masters. Cen- tury. $6 net. Canfield, Dorothy. Gunhild. Holt. $1.50. Canning, Albert 8S. G. British a on Classic Lands. A. Wessels Co. \ Carling, Jonn R. By _ Neva's Waters. Boston: Little, Brown. & Co. Carpenter, John & Rue. Improving Songs for An- xions Children. Chicago: McClurg. Case, E. C. Revision of the Pelycosauria of North America. Washington: Carnegie Institution. Chenoweth. Mrs. C. Van B. Storlea of the Saints. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $1.2 Gus Iliad for Boys and Girls. Clements, Frederic Edward. Plant Physiology and a ag Holt. $2. Macmillan. Charles. and Alfred Harvey. English Chureh Furniture. Dutton. $2.50 net. | Crane, Walter. An _fnawe Reminiscences. Maz- | millan Co. ne Cronson, wr “Punt Self-Government. Mac- millan Co. Cutting, Mary yk 4 me The Suburban Whirl. Mc- Clure Daheim-Kalender, 1908. Lemcke & Buechner. Spee, 7. Little Me-Too. Boston: Little, brown 75 cents. Dargan, fawn Preston. The Afsthetic Doctrine of Montesquieu. Baltimore: J. H. Furst Co. Deland, Ties Pee. The Friendship of Aune. Bos Wilde Co. $1.50. ca R. National Problems. Harpers. Dickens's Seven Poor Travelers and The Holly Tree. Thumb-Nail Series. Century. $1. Daw Bente W. Atlas of Buropeas History. Holt. $ The Red Reign .- —-1" A. Old Indian Days. Emeraid and Ermine. Har af; 50 net. Erasmus Against War. ited y J. W. Boston: Merrymount Press Russia. Mc- Durland, i> 4 in Century Charles Mackall, | Favorite Fa.ry Tales. Harpers | Franklin Year Book. Compiled by Wallace Rice. Chicago : Fynn, J ‘Environment. McClurg . The i merican Indian as a Product of Boston. Little, Brown & Co, $1. 50 net. Ga:lon, Tom. The Cruise of the a Believes. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. 1.5 Garland, Hamlin. Money Magic ia rs. $1.50. Gilder, Richard Watson. The Fire Divine. Cen- tury. Golden Thoughts from Sir Thomas Browne. Edited by Herbert Ives. John Lane a =. aes net. Haggard, H, Rider. Margaret. Haines, Alice A eee oe he Lata oO tbe Dudley Grahams. Holt. 1.50. | a, e M. Dalmatia. Lane. $1.50 net. Hamp, Sidferd F. The Boys of Crawford's Basin. py W. A. Wilde Co. $1.50. Harriman, Karl Edwin. Sadie. Appletons. $1.50. Henry, ©. Heart of the West. McClure Co. Frederick wx Decisive Battles of the =. Harpers. $2.25 net. Hoffman's Meister Martin der Kiifner und Seine pesesen. Edited by Robert H. Fife, jr. Holt. cents. Holland. Clive. Things Seen in Egypt. 75 cents net. ee J. R. The Boys’ Book Conductivity and Jones, "Her rry C., and others. Viscosity in Mixed Solvents. Washington: Car- negie Institution. Knowles, M. A Cheerful Year-Book. Holt. Lefévre, Félicité. The Cock, the Mouse, and the Little Red Hen. Philadelphia : Jacobs. Lincoln Year nook. Compiled by Wallace Rice. Dutton. of Locomotives. Chicego: MecClu Longfellow’ 8 Tales wor : Wayside Inn. Thumb-Nail Series. Century. Lucas, E. V. The "Gentlest Art. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Maceunn, Florence A. Mary Stuart. Dutton. $2. ss Eva. Two Royal Foes. McClure Co. eens, ae. Nursing Technique. Macmillaa ret. MeMahan, Anna B. Shakespeare's a Gift to Queen Bess. Chicago: Pars Malvery, Clive Christian. The Sou Market. Me- Clure, Phillips & Co. Marx. W. J. For the Admiral. Jacobs. Matthews, F. H. Education. ' Putnam’ Philadelphia : see Principles of Intellectual Meade, L. T. The Colonel’s Conquest. Philadel- wnhia: Tecobs. Meyer, Hugo Richard. The | State Telegra- hers. Macmillan Co. $1.50 n Miller, Olive Thorne. Harry's itunaway and What is of it. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. Mincoff, Elizabeth and Margaret S. Marriage. Pillow Lace. Dutton. $5 net. The Parables of the King- Morgan, G. Campbell. dom. Revell. $1 net. Noyes, Arthur A. The Electrical Conductivity of Aqueous Solutions. Washington: Carnegie Insti- tution. Olney, Oliver: The Novelty Circus Company. Philadelphia: Jacobs. j Payne, William Mortoh. The Greater English Poets of the Nineteenth Century. Hoit. $2 net. Pes ee Elizabeth Stuart. Walled In Harpers. Pickard, Samuel T. Life and Letters of John Greenleaf Whittier. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin « Co. Porfirio Diaz and ea Work City of Mexico. Porter, Eleanor H. Cross Currents. isvsion: A. Wilde Co. Porter, ¥ Women’ > Thoughts for Women. A. Wessels Co. 50 ce Poulsson, Emilie. Father and Baby Plays. tury Co. -25. Ww Cen Pyle, Katharine, and Laura 8. Porter. Theodora. Reed, Helen Leah. Napoleon's Young Neighbor. Boston: Little. Brown "Edited by William F. Giese. Holt. 5 cents Rhodes, Harrison. Rollins, Frank West. What o= a Young Man Do? Boston: Little, Brown & Co. 31.50 net. Trans- — bf ~ es W. Hamilton. Macmil- a4 arten, 3, @. nch Colonists and Exiles Boston. Little. Brown & Oo. Renan’s Ma Scour . eno The Flight to Eden. Holt. $1.50. Roman counnass of Ferdinand “Gregorov us. Fre Fs t 4 United States. Philadelphia: Lippincott. ne Saint Mary’s Falls Canal: Semicentennial. 1905. Edited by Charles Moore. Detroit, Mich.: Semi- Centerrial Commission. : er, Bs E. The Queenly Mother. Re- vel, ° Schaff, {1.00 ve The § + of Old West Foint. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $3 n Sedgwick, Anne Ran A pecan Sealed. Century Co. Longmans. $1.50. The Adventures of a She ——7y P. A. Lisheen. Smith, Nora Archibald. Do Co. Childhood. Duffield. $1.50. ll. eClure Sowerby, Githa. Sparks, Edwin Erle. National Development. Har- pers. $2 net. Stevenson, Papert L. The Sea Fogs. Paul Elder & Co. $1.50 net. Stevenson's Travels with a Donkey. Thumb-Nail Series. Century. $1. Storm, Theodore. Immensee. Chica go. McClurg. Taggart, Marion Ames. on Girls and the Tea Room. Boston: W. A. Wilde Co. $1. Taggart, Marion Ames. i Daughters: of the Little Grey House. MeClur Thanksgiving. Edited by Robert H. Schauff- ler. offat. Yard & Co. $1 net. theodore M. Davis’ a The Tomb of Toulya and Toulyou. $12.50 net. Victorian Antho . Ed ited "te ba Knight. Imported by Secribners. $1.25 n Villani’s “ents Translated te , ae E. Selfe. Dutton $2_p Wade, Mary Hazelton, . ¥— — Nation. Bos- ton: W. A. Wilde Co. 76 cen Wade, Mary Ba Z, The Indian Hunters. Bos- , ton: W. A. Wilde Co. $1. Warren, Waldo Pondray. Thoughts on Business. Chicago: Forbes & Co. 1.25. Waters, Robert. Culture by Conversation. Dodd, Mead & Co. .20 net Watson, John (Ian Maclaren). Bet"s Message to the Human Soul. Revell. . Weyane, Stanley J. Laid up in Lave nder. Long- Outing White. “Stewart Edward. Camp and Trail. Publishing Co. $1.25 net. wae. ey d Edward. The Blazed Trail. Me. ure , Whyte, Christina ‘Gowans. Nina's Career. Mac- millan, $1.50. Woodberry, George Edward. Great Writers. Me- Clure Co. Westen, Mrs. Wilson. The New Missioner. Mc- Clure ° Weseler.. 3 A. Concepts of Monism. A. Wessels Co 30. Wright. Wilmer Gave. A Short History of Greek Literature. American Book Young, Egerton R. The Battle of the Bears. Bos- ton: W. A. Wilde Co. $1.50. READY THIS WEEK WORDS TO THE WISE—AND OTHERS By ELLA BURNS SHERMAN, author of “ Taper Lights.” by mail $1.62. 301 pp. $1.50 net, A bri liant collection of subtle and fascinating essays on literary and social topics, unusually well worth reading. The subjects are timely, The chapter heads are : Root a and the ideas stimulating and attractive. Foliage of Style—When Steel Strikes. Punk— Our Kin and Others—Where th: Veil Is Thin—At the End of the Rainbow—Ruskin— Serendipity—Modern Lett-r- Wr ting, with various actual ex Our Comédie Hum sine— J r The Slain That Are Not Numbered—A Plea for the Naturalization of Ghosts. ONE HUNDRED GREAT POEMS R_ J. Cross, Editor. 230 pp , full gilt, limp covers, cloth, $1.25 net; full morocco, $3.00 net From Shakespeare to O Shaughnessy. This dain'y p-ck-t volume is a worthy companion to Lucas's “The Open Road” and “The Friendly Town.”* HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, 29 W. 23d St.,NEW YORK FOREIGN B00 128 Tremont Street. BOSTON. Mas&® 8 Catalogue Quen iat Boot Ce. yf Z| AUTHORS JUST PUBLISHED. FRANCOIS RABELAIS By ARTHUR TILLEY, M.A. Men of a> Vol. Froth $1 80 net. Postpaid J. B. LipPincoTT Cea., Paiiadelphia. The Queen Letter Writers (Madame de Sévigné) By Janet Aldis, author of “ Jane Austen and Her Times,” etc. 8vo. Illustrated. $3.50 net. The story of Mme. de Sévigné’s life involves—what this book gives in a graphic, picturesque, and charming fashion—an account of the aristocratic life of Paris and Versailles, of events in the world of literature, art, and politics, and of the petty intrigues, spites, and follies of the day. G.P.Putnam’s Sons 27 & 29 West 23d St.. N.Y.
Page 28
386 The Nation. [Vol. 85, No, 2208 What you think about business stationery isn’t quite so important as what your correspon- dent thinks. Don’t buy OLD HAMPSHIRE BOND “Look for the Water Mark’’ because it pleases you, but because it influences the man you write in your favor. Otp Hampsurre Bonp is a clean, crisp paper, made for clean, crisp business folks, It is sold on the assumption that there’s economy in quality. A handsome specimen book mailed upon request. Hampshire Paper Company The only paper makers in the world making bond paper exclusively. SOUTH HADLEY FALLS, MASS. THE Hibbert Journal A Quarterly Review of Religion, Theo- The OCTOBER issue, now ready, begins the sixth volume PRINCIPAL CONTENTS: NATURALISM AND HUMANISM By Professor F. J. E. Woodbridge rHE STATE OF THE DEAD By Rev. David Purves, D.D. THE UNIVERSE AS PHILOSO PHER By . Jacks ARE WE PARTS OF N ATU RE By Professor i Mackintosh PROGRESS AND RE aie F.. Barbour WHAT AND WHERE ts THE SOUL? By Hugh Maccoll DISC USSIONS AND REVIEWS and numerous other valuable articles $2.50 per annum; .75 a single copy, postpaid Subscriptions can be filled immed tate- ly and single copies had by return mail by addressing SHERMAN, FRENCH & COMPANY 6 Beacon St., Boston, Massachusetts or apply to your local mews agent or bookseller. BEST facilities for supplying American B German English OOK Italian French Spanish Catalogues free. Oorrespondence solicited. LEMCKE & BUECHNER Established over 60 years. 11 Bast 17th St., New York Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere. 155 vols., ket size. List prices, cloth, 35c. per vol.. limp leather 75c. per vol. (Special prices to schools and A, SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y.Crowell & Co., NewYork Just Published Wright’s Short History of Greek Literature By Wilmer Cave Wright, Ph.D., As- sociate Professor of Greek, Bryn Mawr College. $1.50 This volume affords a general survey of the whole field of Greek literature, from Homer to Julian. It is written rather from the literary than the ph lological standpoint, and contains such helpful fea- tures as numerous parallels quoted from Pnglish literature, lists of standard trans- lations, and references to modern essays dealing with the Greek masterpieces. It is a book which will appeal both to the gen- eral reader, and to the college student who wishes to realize intelligently the signifi- eance and relations to the whole of the classic masterpieces he is reading. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY Chicago Boston New York Cincinnati Paris—20 Rue de Tournon 20—Paris Archives Diplomatiques Monthly record for Diplomaqy, History and International Law. the Lawyer Indispensable for «the Historian the Diplomatist This periodical ought to be inthe Reading-room of every library. SUBSCRIPTION PRICE, $11, POST FREE. Specimen. free of charge, on application. Write to-day to Bureau dex Archives Diplo- matiques, 20 Rue de Tournon, Paris. STUDY AND PRACTICE OF FRENCH L. C. BONAME, Author and Publisner 1930 oe pe St. PHILADELNPIA, A carefu ed series for schools and Thorough woh fa pronunciation and essentials ro gram. mar. Practice in conversation and composition. Part I. (60 cents), Part IT. (90 cents), for primary and in- termediate grades Part III, ($1.00), mpoguine verse, idioms, composition, syntax. for advanced Pa IV. (35 cents), Ha fation, con- cise and comprehensive for advanced Books, Etc., at Auction. Pe a $ THE ANDERSON AUCTION COMPANY SUCCESSOR TO BANGS & CO. ] 5 West 29th Street, New York October 28, 1907 Etchings, Engravings and Oil Paintings October 29, 1907 The Library of An Old New York Collector > October 30-31, 1907 § The Library of the late H. C. G. Bals, Indianapolis, Ind. Catalogues on Application. , Telephone 3150 Madison. ~~ WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. 1. A tremendous miscellaneous stock. 2. Greatly increased facilities for the im- portation of English publications. 8. Competent bookmen to price lists and collect books. All of this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO. WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. MORAL EDUCATION Two By EDWARD HOWARD GRIGGS. $1.60 net. Great CHRISTIAN ORIGINS Books ]| By OTTO PFLEIDERER. $1.50 net. ROBERT NEILSON STEPHENS'S CLEMENTINA’S HIGHWAYMAN B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, N. Y. Book Plates for Aooklovers. The nm disfigures, but artistic labels, created especially for YOU, ornament, identify, and pro- for VALENTINE tect. rite a. Co. KIRBY (Special Ex Libris Artist), 1455 Emersen St.. Denver Col. MSS prepared for peatieation: typewriting. ® proofreading. etc. Good, _ accurate work. Address BOX 3, Station D, N. Y. City. IN A GREAT Public Library The Office Clerk is instructed to cut out the advertising col- umns of THE NATION as a guide for the Purchasing Com- mittee. To many libraries and to many individuals, books advertised in THE NATION are at once rec- ommended as desirable.
Page 29
Oct. 24, 1907] The Nation. V THREE IMPORTANT BOOKS The Raid on Prosperity A ‘telling exposition of Chancellor James R. Day’s now’ Chancellor Day famous views. Chancellor Day is fearless in his outspoken attitude against the unconstitutionality of recent Federal inter- ference with large corporate interests, and his attack is marked by a biting humor that makes it very live read- ing. The book presents vividly one side of one of the most interesting questions of the times. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 net (postage 12 cents). Memories of My Life Without question the greatest actress of her generation, Sarah Bernhardt Sarah Bernhardt has lived a wonderful life outside the theater as well as within. She is a painter and sculptor of recognized ability ; she has written her memoirs with her own hand and with her own inexhaustible enthusiasm for life in all its phases. The memoirs of this astounding woman could not but be fascinating to read. The edition is sumptuous in binding, paper, and typugraphy, richly illustrated. Svo, cloth, $4 net (postage 30 cents). Evolution and Animal Life This work, by the President of Stanford University and the, David Starr Jordan Professor of Entomology and Bionomics, is a popular discus-: sion of the facts, processes, laws, and theories relating to the' Vernon Lyman Kellogg life and evolution of animals. The reader of it will have a very clear idea of the all-important theory of evolution as it is held to-day by scientists. The illustrations are very numerous, and the work is written in a style of the utmost charm and clarity. Svo, cloth, 300 illustrations. $2.50 net (postage 20 cents additional). D. APPLETON & COMPANY, N. Y. Publishers also of APPLETON’S MAGAZINE. THE GREAT ENGLISH MAGAZINES O YOU know them—know what they are publishing—read them—subscribe for them? There are the Edinburgh Review and the Quarterly, the Church Quarterly and the Hzbéert Journal; the Contemporary, Fortnightly, Albany, Nattonal, West- minster and Nineteenth Century Reviews; Blackwood’s, Cornhill, Gentleman’s and Pall Mall Magazines ; the Spectator, the Saturday Review, the Nation, the Outlook, the Academy, the Atheneum, Chambers’s Journal, Nature, Punch, and others. No matter how many American magazines you read, you need to know some- thing of our English contemporaries. The one convenient, sensible, inexpensive way is to subscribe for THE LIVING AGE, which gives every week the best contributions from current numbers of the foreign periodicals. 2 Its scope includes literature, science, history, politics,—especially timely discus- sions of public affairs; travel and exploration; essays, reviews, and criticisms; fiction, —both serial and short stories. Founded in 1844. SIX DOLLARS a year. Trial subscriptions, 3 months (13 numbers), ONE DOLLAR. Specimen copy free. New subscribers for 1908 will receive free the remaining numbers of 1907 from the date on which their subscriptions reach the publishers. The Living Age Co. Boston, Mass. o--esee™ D 6 Beacon Street
Page 30
vi The Nation. [Vol. 85, No. 2208 Ready Oct. 25 | NOVEMBER NOVEMBER THRE CENTURY. Beginning the New Volume OPENING CHAPTERS THE REMINISCENCES OF LADY RANDOLPH CHURCHILL (Now Mrs. Gzeorce Cornwa.uis- West) Memoirs of a brilliant American woman in the English court, ry wy with inter- esting anecdotes of the most important men and women of the last forty years FIRST PAPER *‘ THE GENESIS OF A WORLD” IN A SERIES ON «‘MARS AS THE ABODE OF LIFE” By Percival Lowell Director or THE LowELt Osservatory, Fiacstrarr, ARIZONA Illustrated The suoject that is attracting the most attention at the present time in the scientific world. ERNEST THOMPSON SETON, ON “The Natural History of the Ten Commandments ”’ A surprising chapter of nature study. Likely to. start a new discussion among nature students THe WHOLE Story OF LINCOLN’s OFFER OF A COMMAND TO GARIBALDI A revelation of secret history with hitherto unpublished documents STRIKING POEMS “THE QUEST OF EDITH,”’ by Stephen Phillips “ODE ON A LYCIAN TOMB,”’’ by S. Weir Mitchell “GRIEG THE MAN” ** AUTOMOBILE PROBLEMS” By his friend, WILLIAM PETERS Should arrests be made for speeding or for inefficiency? ILLUSTRATIONS IN COLOR, PHOTOGRAVURE AND TINT Madame Bressler-Gianoli as ‘‘Carmen.” Painted by de Ivanowski ‘*Tue SacReED Boat or Isis” PORTRAITS OF **LANCING A WHALE” By André Castaigne Lapy Ranpoire CHURCHILL By Clifford W. Ashley Davip BispHAM Epwin MarkHAmM TO BEGIN SOON 66 TH & RED CITY 9 | A New Enterprise 0 THe CENTURY A Novel of old Philadelphia by T H E MO N U M ENTS Dr. 8. WEIR MITCHELL | OF ECYPT ller Paintings by The Text by IMusteated by Kelle . mah JULES GUERIN ROBERT HICHENS Continuing Dr. Mitchell’s famous novel, “ Hugh Wynne” | Reproduced in the Original Colors Author of “ The Garden of Allah” | Visceccecietninaiadiaaie aes The Century Co. ees Metember | Vnion Square, New York |