The Nation 1907-01-24: Vol 84 Iss 2169

Page 1

GENERAL LIBRARY UNIV. OF MICH. JAN 28 1907 The Nation Ww 7 “ee, la = 4d a) VOL. LXXXIV—NO, 2169. THURSDAY, JANUARY 24, 1907. . “ge LEN CENTS The following books are announced for early publication by DUFFIELD & COMPANY : The Windfall By CHARLES EGBERT CRADDOCK A fascinating modern romance from the world of mountaineers whom Miss Murfree famous. has lo iy mauaut $] Sa) postpaid The Dower Woods By EMMA BROOKE * A new novel by the author of “The Engrafted Rose, relating the efforts of the young Baronet Elvot Ingall to save from commercial destruction the Dower Woods (the bride's dower of an old Engl family) and at the same time make vood with his own life $1.50 postpaid A Winged Victory By R. M. LOVETT A new novel by the author of “Richard Gresham,”’ teeming with the intensely real life of the West S] 1) postpaid Success in Life By EMIL REICH A new book by the author of “Success Among Nations,” crammed full of vitally interesting suggestior How to be successful in whatever walk of life is both the key note and the inspiring ideal of the whol $1.50 net postage ext The Spirit of Labor sy nutcnins napaoop A work in a field parallel to the same author's “Autobiography of a Uhief."” ~ The Spirit of Labor” ts, in fact, the life-story of a Chicago labor leader and trades unionist. A flood of new light is thrown on the absorb ing and important subject of the conflict between labor and capital $1.50 net; postage extra Among continued successes from Duffield & Co's fall list are: Geronimo’s Story of His Life Taken down by S. M. BARRETT Illustrated by photographs, $1.50 net; postage 14 cents ** A book worthy of all praise..’"—New York Evening Mati Molieére: A Biography By H. C. CHATFIELD-TAYLOR Introduction by Professor T. F. CRANE of Cornel! University; pictures by “JOB'’; pp. xxiv.-446. $3.00 net; postage 24-cents **The standara in the English language both for the general reader and the student The Philadelphia Public Ledger Reminiscences of My Childhood and Youth By GEORGE BRANDES $2.50 net; postage 16 cent ‘* There is not a dull paragraph, not a single dry-as-dust element in this highly instructive autobiography.’ Paul Harboe in the North American Revte- Marcel Levignet $1.50 postpaid ** Marcel Levignet is a jolly bachelor of Paris, a bon viveur, a raconteur, a French Sherlock Holmes and a romantic and rous defender of virtue. Intrigue well handled, plot carefully constructed, and crime ably conceived and skilfully carried out 8 i enter into the story."’— New York Sun. "NEW YORK 36EAST 21° ST

Page 2

el me The Nation. 4 WARKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED Tt Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. Rntered at the New Yori cu Post Office as second clase matl matte CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tar Weer 71 } 4 Ar » I pa s aidy Scandals 74 I Hit Sense i4 I W f lawn! ¢ i " " P e « a 76 ‘ Cha Mu it ” LA ” nA I iture in 1006 77 ( re eNCFE I Va f the PD a Degree 7s | Spelling Reform 70 i \ box n Rats Dx ’ led 7 eT ST y s sv 4 ‘ Bens n (leasing “o> I Abeurditle f the Tariff 80 Tee sO) I Kk Keview \ Ex s4 I I ds f the Virginia Gompany of Land S4 Mm Privateers SS rm Ne 4 Generation RA News f Ribliophiles ta 3) (pus Epistolarum Des. Erasm! Roterodam! Ne Fiat | Bases f Religion Primitive Babylonian, and Jewlsh RT rhe Practice of Diplomacy 87 ls Wallace An Autoblography S7 jamea RR ' WA ! s Johannes SN M l ird &S ues s Salome bs | Ar I Per yivania Academy 8D tenor \ Quart Century of Catastrophism 1 The & ntif Papers of J. Willard Gibbs v2 } ANc® I Iireak in t Stock Market 92 ! a] ne Ween vs 4/ WS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in wny part of the Untted States or Canada; to for ign countries compriaed in the Poatal Union, 84. The dute when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which fo a aula quent date becomes a rece ipt for aremu-. No other receipt ta sent unless requested fan emitiances at the riak of the subscriber, unteas made hy registered letter, or by cheek, express ler, or Postal Order payable to “Publisher of The Nation When «@ change f address ia desired, both the old and the m wldresses should be gtuen iilcdrease THT NATION, Rov? Neu Publica ton Ofte fon Hr York ; 4h, eadway TERMS OF ADVERTISING Fifteen cents per agate line, each ineertion 14 lines to the inch Twenty per cent advance for choice of page or top of column 4 column, $00 cach insert on with choice of page. $t4 A page, 460 cach insertion; front cover page gan Advertionmentsa muat be acceptable in every re spect Copy received until Turaday.6 P M The NATION ts sent free to those who adver tise in it ax long as advertiaement continues Discounts upon apy lication *,* Copies of Tan Nation may be procured in Parie at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Oross, (Vol. 84, No. 2169 A Universal Exchange of all Varieties of Earnest Religious Thought JANUARY NUMBER JUST READY THE HIBBERT JOURNAL Yearly subscription $2.50 post free. post free, Each issue 240 pages, 7 Enlarged to 240 pp., 2s. 6d. net; 2s. 9d. post free. scriptions, 10s. per annum, post free. Sub- PRINCIPAL CONTENTS. OUR FINAL VENTURE. By Prof. Camppec. FRASER THE ENTANGLING ALLIANCE OF RELIGION AND HISTORY. By Prof. A LA CRISE RELIGIEUSE EN FRANCE ET EN ITALIE. By Pavt Sanatier THE FAILURE OF THE FRIARS. By G G. Covtton, M.A THE MESSIANIC IDEA IN VIRGIL. By Prof. R. 8. Conway. THE CHRISTIAN DOCTRINE OF ATONEMENT AS INFLUENCED BY SEMITIC RELIGIOUS IDEAS. By the Rev, R. J. Campreti. M.A PERIL TO LIBERTY IN THE CHURCH. By the Rev THE NEW THEISM, By the Rev. Cart S. Pattoy. THE ** ETERNAL NOW” IN ANGLICAN THEOLOGY. CHANCE OR PURPOSE? By Hves MacCoii THE PARALLELISM OF RELIGION AND ART. A PEACE POLICY FOR IDEALISTS. By W. R With a number of Discussions, Signed Reviews, Bibliography of Recent Literature, etc Subscriptions are hooked and sinele copies sold by G. EB. STECHERT & CO.. 129-133 W. 20th Street, New York; THE 4MERICAN UNITARIAN ASSOCIATION, 25 Beacon Street, Boston. From any good bookseller or direct from WILL'AMS & NORG ITE, 14 Henrietta St., Covent Garden, London, Eng. O. LOVEJOY HastTinas RAsHDALi GRENSTED By the Rev, F. F By Basil pe SELINCOURT Boyce Gipson F:ducational. | Fk:ducattonal. ATHENE ZUG (Switzerland) High-class School for Young Ladies. Modern Languages, Sciences, Music, Arts, Swedish Gymnastics, Sports. Large grounds by the Lake. Charming country. First-class establishment. Apply for detailed prospectus to the Principal at the above address. nvserrs, Boston 2a mina Teachers Agencies 7 mere, Semantem “MB : ae 1GELOW. \ hie FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everetr ©. Fisk & Co., Proprietors, 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 4 Ashburton P1., Boston 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL 156 Fifth Ave., New York Laboratories | | | poait | | For Boys, Lecation high and dry shop for Mechanic Arts, Strong teachers. Earnest bows, | 203 Mich. Ave.. Chicago 1-00 Williams Av., Portiand Gymnasium with new swimming pool. Fits for college, 405 Cooper Bid., Denver 228 Doug!l's Bid.,LosAngeles aclentifie school and business, )oung boys in separate 313 Rook'ry BIk.. Spokane 415 Studio Bid., Berkeley building. Adress Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Dr. B. C. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall. Wellesley Hillis, Mass. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Records. Send for Circular on Free Registration. fHiARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. 3 Books, Prints, Autographs AT AUCTION Almost Daily Sales THE Anderson Auction Co., SUCCESSOR TO BANGS & CO., (ESTABLISHED 1833) 5 West 29th Street, New York. NOW READY IBSEN | THE MAN, HIS ART \B4nd His Significance By HAI DANE MAC F ALI A VIVID CHARACTER PORTRAYAI BRILLIANT ANALYSIS $7.50 met, postage 15c. SHEPARD COMPANY v5 Fourth Avenue, New York SEND FOR THE SHEPARD CATALOGUF 750 pave .. Issues catalogues in which the above material is adequately and faithfully described. Call at our Salesrooms or send for a catalogue THE LIBRARY of LITERARY CRITICISM Of English and American Authors Fight volumes Collected criticiam making best authenticated bietory and perapective of ilterature, O80 te 1006 Already to use in over 1000 academic Inatitutions Particulars by mail Fair dealings absolutely guaranteed. Carefu' attention given tocons g men s Executed Without Charge. CHAS. A. WENBORNE, Boffalo, N. Y. BOOK S—Ali out of print books supplied, no matter on what subject; write me stating books | Thelast work of thelate FERDINAND BRUNETIERE vented; I can get you any book ever published; when in England e¢all and tnepect my stock of Honoré de Balzac 50.000 rare books. BAKER'S GREAT BOOKSHOP At all booketores. Cloth, @1.50 net. Poetpald $1.00 ’ Bright St Pirmingham, Fnelat J.B. LIPPINCOTT COMPAS) Philadelphia

Page 3

Jan. 24, 1907] The Nation. ill Forty-seventh Annual Statement of the HOME LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY GEO, E. IDE, President ist, 1907 January ADMITTED ASSETS LIABILITES *Bonds and Mortgages $5,809,650.00 Policy Reserve $16,006,708.00 Bonds and Stocks - a Miscellaneous Liabilities $297,780.84 (market value) $8,907 ,787.91 dia Val fall Divi Real Estate $1,650,609.81 prea h wrote " . adel Cash in Banks and Trust nevcng ee Companies $293,545.75 mulations ( pividends ) $1,621,413.00 Loans to Policy Holders $1,950,996.14 Reserve to provide for all Other Assets $406,220.52 other Contingencies $1,092,908.29 Total $19,018,810.13 Total $19,018,810.13 *Of the Mortgage Loans of the Company 90% is on property located in New York City, 82% is guaranteed as to principal and interest, and al) are on a basis not exceeding 60% of a conservative valuation RECORD OF 1906 (fiic""") Premium Receipts, (‘f""\"*) $356,662.91 greater than in 1905 Insurance in Force, December 31, 1905, $79,775,340.00 Insurance in‘Force, December 31, 1906, $86, 113,559.00 Gain for Year, $6,338,219.00 Gain in Admitted Assets for year 1906, $1,132,215.00 Largest Issue of New Insurance in the history of the Company. Greatest Growth in Insurance in Force in any year in Company’s History. WILLIAM A. MARSHALL, Vice-President and Actuary ELLIS W. GLADWIN, Vice-President and Secretary WILLIAM G. LOW, Vice-President and General Counsel HENRY E. IDE, Assistant Secretary FRANK W. CHAPIN, Medical Director LEMUEL H. ARNOLD, Coansel JULIUS CC. BIE RWIRTH, Associate Medical Director GEORGE W. MURRAY, Supt. of Agents FREDERICK C. HILLIARD, Cashier DIRECTORS JOHN BE. BORNE wm. G. LOW THOMAS T. BARR COURTLANDT P. DIXON THOMAS H. MESSENGER GEORGE E. IDE Www. M. ST. JOHN ANTON A. RAVEN J. WARREN GREENE WM. A. NASH JOUN §. FROTHINGHAM JAMES MceGOVERN H. EK, PIERREPONT JOHN F. PRAERGER MARTIN JOOST FPRANCIS L. HINE LEMUEL H. ARNOLD ELLIS W. GLADWIN kk. LE GRAND BEERS ROBT. BL WOODWARD WILLIAM A. MARSHALL Mr. Hughes failed to bring out a single quest

Page 4

lv The Nation. [Vol. 84, No. 2169 ~Among the New Macmillan Books Miss Jane Addams’s New Book Newer Ideals of Peace Its great value lies in its showing how the powers of healing, of militant good will, of friendliness, which she has found in the poorer quarters of a great city, may, 1f they become operative in society, become the basis of anew internation- ilism which shall do away with war. Citizen's Library. Cloth, leather back, 12mo, $1.25 net (postage 10¢.) The Tariff and the Trusts By FRANKLIN PIERCE, of the New York Bar. \ clear, simple statement of the requirements of the Dingley Tariff and especially of its effect upon the consumer. Phe necessary historical information and the analysis of present conditions are adequate without being technical 387 pages. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 met. Just ready Introduction to Business Organization By SAMUEL E. SPARLING, Ph.D., University of Wisconsin. After an Introduction on legal and economic aspects, the book treats of extractive industries —chiefly farming —of manu- facturing, methods of marketing, advertising, credits, collections, etc. ‘‘An important addition to the literature of commerce.''—Philadelphia Press Citizen's Library. Cloth, leather back, $1.25 net (postage 71c.) Federal Power over Carriers and Corporations By E. PARMALEE PRENTICE A review of the practice, Federal and State, defining the powers of government ; an account of the growth of stage- coach lines and rallroads, with a full discussion of the history, meaning and possibilities of the Sherman (or Anti-Trust) Act Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net. Just ready The Psychology of Religious Belief By JAMES B. PRATT, Ph.D., Instructor in Philosophy in Williams College. \ discussion, strictly psychological, but sympathetic with religious faith and feeling, of three types of religious belief— nalve acceptance, and those based in intellect, or in emotion. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net. Justready The Religious Conception of the World By ARTHUR KENYON ROGERS, Ph.D., Professor of Philosophy and Education at Butler College. \ restatement of the argument for Theism in the light of recent philosophical development, which the author keeps in touch with actual human experience and concrete human interests. Cloth, 12mo0. Ready January 30 Life in Ancient Athens By Professor T. G. TUCKER lhe book follows, with a clearness almost dramatic, the social and public life day by day, of a citizen of Athens in the period of her greatest glory and most vigorous vitality. Cloth, 12mo, 723 pages with 85 illustrations. $1.25 net Emerson By GEORGE EDWARD WOODBERRY Professor Woodberry ranks easily among the first critics of our time, and his gifts are especially those which aid in the He is just with respect to Emerson's work, appreciative of his interpretation of the work of a man of kmerson’s mold. . Cloth, 12mo, 75 cents net. Ready this day immense moral force and inspiiing power. A History of the Inquisition of Spain VOLUME IIL. hy HENRY CHARLES LEA, Author of ‘‘The Inquisition of the Middle Ages," etc. the third volume of the only work approaching authority on this interesting subject. The new volume completes the ction on ‘* Punishments "’ begun in Volume I1., and discusses also ‘‘ Spheres of Action,."’ Cloth, 8vo, $2.50 net (postage 22¢.). Tobe completed in four volumes, of which I1.—III. are now ready, each $2.50 net The International Law and Diplomacy of the Russo-Japanese War By A. S. HERSHEY, Ph.D., Junior Professor of Political Science in the University of Indiana. \ complete narrative of the war from the point of view of international law and diplomacy. It discusses War Corre- lelegraphy, Submarine Mines, Russian Seizures, Contraband of War, the Voyage of the Baltic spondents, Wireless Cloth, 8vo, $7.00 net Fleet, the North Sea Incident, and the Treaty of Portsmouth. rubisbed THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “54 4v by

Page 5

The Nation. 1WO7 NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY The Week. That the Governor of Jamaica has, in a great crisis, acted like a_ glorified beadle, seems to be the almost unani- mous opinion in England as well as in this country. The letter which he wrote to Admiral Davis should alone be enough to terminate his career. Such a mixture of clumsy insult and vul- gar smartness would have been out of place at any time, but to be addressed br the Governor of a smitten Colony to those who came as friends and rescuers, was simply amazing folly. Even if the Americans there were ignoring the nice technicalities, they were kind-hearted and were doing useful work, and ought not to have been kicked off the prem- ises as trespassers. The most charitable supposition is that Gov. Swettenham had simply lost his head through anx- iety or overwork. England need not be troubled about good relations with this country being disturbed by the incident. 24, Clown. | have an answer will serve all men Countess. Marry, that’s a bountiful answer that fits all questions {All’s Well that Ends Well The bountiful answer of President Roosevelt, to every objector to any pol- icy of his, seems rapidly getting to be that all opposition to him is inspired by the Trusts. All the Washington dis- patches agree that this is now the White House attitude towards the crit- ics of the President’s action in discharg- ing the colored troops. sentment at his successful attacks upon “corporate interests.” is the protagonist in the debate on the Brownsville affair; he was also the chief opponent of Mr. Roosevelt's railway- rate law; so what could be plainer? The infuriated corporations are using For- aker and Knox and Aldrich to strike back at the President who has drawn their fangs. Mr. Roosevelt has descried this hidden and wicked motive many times before. Any challenge of his Pan- ama plans, for example, could have sprung, we were given to understand, only from enmity prompted by the smarting railroads. The long refusal of the Senate to approve his policy in San- to Domingo had a similar abhorrent origin. On the public side, the effect of the attitude of the President is very un- happy. Here is a large question, about which opinion is much divided, and about the legal and Constitutional aspects of which able and honest men seriously dif- fer; but Mr. Roosevelt would have it set- | , j tled purely on the basis of personal loy- | alty to him. Now, there is no doubt that | | ed It is merely re- Senator Foraker | President Roosevelt has evoked a mark- devotion; but for him to throw that into the scale when there is pending a great of right or wrong under the law, of justice or in- | justice, is to confuse the and obstruct the working of our machinery of government. To keep each question clear and distinct, and to on its merits, is the great desideratum of public discussion. Mixing dis parate subjects and dragging in person al motives can but muddle debate, cloud the popular mind, and lead conclusions. If the corporations do hate the President and would embarrass and mortify him in every way possible, that | personal question issue to settle each | up to lame | is a question by itself, to be dealt with on fit occasion. But just have other work in hand at present we Senator Spooner’s speech last week on the President’s discharge of the colored troops was largely discussion. a One of the Wisconsin Sen- |} son had exceeded his lawful | pressed | | vietions, may to leave impeachable to the offences House Exercise the power mpeachn f President the p give the wer at his destroy all evidence upon wh i that power could be exer sed! It is idle t cannot be maintained for a ment! The fact that has always felt free to debate the legal of the of the we hope it always will had it journal of the Senate That mo is, of course, the Senate President, and Webster entered ity acts and Clay solemnly upon the Andrew Jack powers. In 1894 of in a report formally President a committee Republican Sena tors brought recit that of “an appointing Mr. Hawaii We the vacant-mindedness Cleveland had been unconstitutional act” in Blount commissioner to cannot reduce ing guilty the Senate of which has neither read, formed, nor ex to a jury an opinion. Senators who may hold, and may have uttered, strong con yet be judicial, and decide | the case according to law and evidence lawyer's abstract | ator’s general principles was: Even if a which he or it bad motive, I should greatly deplore an at- tempt the it pass judgment upon it the exercises President abuses power possesses, with by Senate to investigate or Mr is Spooner’s reason is that the Senate the body which has the sole right, under the Constitution, to try impeach- ments; and “it would be a horrid thing if, when articles of impeachment reach this laid fore a court which in-another capacity, having investigated and considered the same ‘matter, had prejudged it.” This being so, we might imagine that Sena- tor Spooner must have “greatly deplor- ed” the attempt of the Senate in 1886 to “investigate and pass judgment upon” an alleged violation of the law by Pres- igent Cleveland a determined attack for weeks upon that chamber, they should be be. Executive, led by Senator Edmunds, on | of his refusal to send to the Senate certain papers bearing upon re movals from office. The act was declar- ed to be lawless and in defiance of the Constitution. But turn to the Congres. sional Record of March 18 and 19, 1886, and you will find a two days’ speech by Senator Spooner, arralgning the Presi- dent in the strongest for having failed to comply with the law, and set at nought a provision of the Constitu- tion. He asked if Mr. Cleveland was “too great to be subject the What he now deplores, he then did with the utmost gusto. And as if with pro- phetic joy at the thought of eviscerating his own argument of twenty years later, he exclaimed, when told that he ought account way to | port when the time comes. The passage by the Senate of the bill the men, increasing 6,000 officers and in the House, is another example artillery by over and its favorable re | of the way our military forces are grad vally being increased. Prior to the war with Spain, our artillery consisted of five regiments, comprising about 3,500 men; now we have 663 officers and 18,166 soldiers With the additional strength about to be authorized, the artillery alone will be as large as our entire army on January 1, 1898. The | War Department has found that any large increase would not be voted; it , | Millions upon battleships and law.” | | Ordnance There was at that time | has therefore hit upon this way, as Con gressman Theodore FE. of Ohio has pointed of getting its whole loaf Burton out, it ast the slices L that the Artillery, the Medical branch of the service far as the artillery is concerned, we told it by vear was increased and Corps Corps was this it is next year some year it will other be or So are because we have many defences: a few years was asked for guns we had none for our artillery, and the game goes on. The public has quite we need 20 coast ago Congress because BO forgotten that when the Endicott Board's vast system of .coast defence was created it was with the assurance that with these forts we should need a large navy never Now we squander land de fences alike. The House of Representatives has made a new record by passing 628 pr! vate pension bille in one hour and thir

Page 6

GR ty-five minutes Three or four thou sand similar bills become law every vena and no President since Cleveland ha been willing to take the trouble cf looking into their merits one by one Hut the service-pension advocates, hav ing put Senator McCumber’'s bill through the Senate, are making much of an ar- gument derived from this special legis letion Most of the beneficiaries of the private bills would receive pensions un- ver the general act, as the proposed change would make it Instead of the $24 or $30 a month which the average private bill now carries, they would get $12 to $20 said the father cf the bill enty-five vears of age should receive ‘Probably hog “if these men who are sev $20, they would not apply for the other $10 per month by special bill.” Trust in pensionable human nature still persists i eynical Washington Mr. McCumber ure that veterans who might have had $230 a month, will be perfectly sat fied with $20. Yet ont of the first 100 | bill passed on this record day to hich we refer, no less than nine two increased pensions already grant ed, while only eight authorized new pensions What earthly warrant is there for the supposition that there be any fewer applications for “in crease under the new law than under the old? Special pension legislation is excused on the ground that it tempers the omissions and inequalities of the rigid general law That Congress can itisfy everybody merely by granting a pensionable status to new classes of epplicants | is beautiful a dream as that it can satisfy all the shipping in terest with one modest little subsidy The choice of two United States Sen ors Tuesday in Oregon was the result or the nearest approximation to popular election that Ingenuity has been able to devise without amending the Constitu tion. In fact, the process by which they The Nation. | Vol. 84, No. 2169 in the regular election. They had, first, to commend themselves to a plurality of the members of their own party, and then to a plurality of the voters of the State. They will have a serious responsi- bility at Washington as the first products | of a system which the Western States are hurrying to copy. South Carolina having shown the way in which a State may legally bring im- migrants from abroad to settle within its borders, Virginia has promptly prof- ited by the example. The Commissioner ef Immigration and Agriculture from that State, G. W. Koiner, expects a par- iy of domestic and farm workers from Europe to arrive at Baltimore before the end of the present month By the United States Immigration Commission- er at Baltimore he has been informed that “they will, in all probability, if not physically disqualified, be permitted to land, but until the foreigners arrive at the port and apply for ad- mission it will be impossible for this office to decide upon their eligibility to land.” Commissioner Koiner says he can find work in Virginia for not less than 50,000 white farm-hands and do- mestic servants In other Southern States the newspapers have spoken of | Secretary Straus’s recent ruling in the South Carolina case as if it solved the problem of diverting a proportional part of the stream of immigration to the South. The problem, however, is differ- ent in several respects from that of the States of the Northwest when they first sought European settlers. Apart from the negro question, the fact that these States have no public lands to offer “homesteaders” brings the South’s ap- peal, from the immigrant’s point of view, down to a simple question of wages. How far the organized efforts of the Southern States may be able to offset higher bids elsewhere is still an |} open question. were selected was considerably more | democratic than what was usually meant iD po ilm election a few years “ako I I. Burkett of Nebraska was elected ! popular vote In that sense. He was nominated for Senator by the same con vention which named another Repub lican for Governor, and his name was paced on the offielal ballot on election the Legislature merely confirming In Indiana on Sunday a passenger train was blown to pieces by the ex- | plosion of a car of powder which was the choles oO mace A. J. Hopkins of | IHiinola was nominated in State con vention, but not voted upon by the peo pole A dozen ‘or more of Southern Sen ators were chosen as the candidates of an invincible party in popular primar ies Rut these Oregonians, F. W. Mul key and Jonathan Bourne, were put through a double process They were chosen as the Republican Senatorial can cidates in a direct primary, and then veted upon like other party candidates | part of a freight train going in the op posite direction; eighteen passengers were killed. In New Jersey a locomo tive exploded; three enginemen were killed In Ohio a passenger train ran into a telegraph pole which had been blown across the track; twenty persons were injured Just over the line from West Virginia one of the two engines pulling a passenger train jumped the track: one passenger and one trainman were injured. In New York a locomo- t've ran off the track, in the Grand Cen- tral vards, tipped over on its side, and blocked traffic for several hours In Minnesota ten express cars, running off the track, were smashed to kindling. On Saturday, besides two other wrecks in Indiana and one in Minnesota, there were accidents of a serious nature in Massachusetts, Kansas, Illinois, Missis- sippi, and South Carolina. Eleven States thus contributed to two days’ news of railroad accidents. As made up from the dispatches, there was a death-roll for these two days of twenty-seven and an injured list of fifty-eight. Exception- al conditions of various kinds must have taxed the resources of operating offi- cials. There were two wrecks in the list caused by obstructions which had blown or fallen on the tracks since the previous trains had passed safely. The explosion at Terre Haute of a car of powder which, for anything that ap- pears to the contrary, was being trans- ported in the customary way might be set down in the category of unavoidable accidents. But what of the two loco- motives that exploded? What of the three head-on collisions, one rear-end collision, one collision of character not stated, and two unclassified “wrecks’’? What of the four derailments and the “narrow” escape of a fast train in New Jersey which passed over a broken rail? Protests against the kind of manage- ment and equipment under which such catastrophes are possible have been raised so often that they are almost in danger of losing their force. Yet the ac- cidents go on, not on one road, nor in one section, nor under one set of diffi- cult conditions, but on all roads, in all parts of the country, and under all sorts of conditions. If legislative bodies are turning to remedies which railroad men Say are wrong and ineffectual, the rea- son is not far to seek, The mass meeting held at Carnegie Lyceum Monday night to demand a Congressional investigation of the status of women workers; Saturday’s appeal of two associations for equal pay for women and men teachers, in this city: the formation of women’s trade unions, and the growing demand for the ballot among working women, both here and abroad, are indications of widespread unrest among the rapidly increasing number of women who are bread-win- ners. Yet it is easy to understand how the discrimination in women's wages has arisen. The first women who be- came industrial producers lived and worked at home; so do many to day. Moreover, the average man-worker must generally earn enough to support not only himself, but a wife and family as well. These are the historic arguments with which economists have eyrplain- ed and still explain the disparity in wages. In Germany this problem of the pay of the woman worker is recognized by careful students as one of the most serious of our modern industrial condi tions, with most direct bearing upon race deterioration and prostitution Hence an elaborate study of the inequal ity of wages between the sexes by Dr. |

Page 7

je ol Jan. 24, 1907] ) Alice Salomen has been warmly welcom ed To the classic explanations of the discrimination against women which we have cited, she adds that they are physically unfit for certain occupations such as the making of iron and stee which fact tends to confine them to the poorer paid because more crowd- ed industries. She also lays stress upon the absence of a keen desire to rise to the more highly paid grades of la- bor, and the fact that 1] are loath to enter skille« young girls occupations requiring a long apprenticeship; hence they are‘restricted to employments easy to learn and readily recruited afresh whenever there is a_ strike In or der to lessen differences in wages, Dr Salomon relies more upon the proper training of women workers than upon unions. She cites, of course, the case of the Lancashire weavers as proof that unions accomplish something. But the success of these women in raising wages to the same level as those of the men is ilso due to the fact that they have been over a century in this employment with much resulting solidarity and pride in their work They are serious in it, expect to give their lives to it, and afte generations of experience—and this is most important of all—have learned to insist upon a most rigid training of the young girls who enter the trade. The death on Thursday of the Rev. James Woodrow reminds us how far the hand has moved across the dial in two decades. He was a teacher in both the University of South Carolina and tne Columbia Theological Seminary, a Pres institution In 1884 he ven- tured to declare his belief in evolution; he thought it body of man descended from some ani byterian “probably true” that the mal, and that “at a certain point his Maker met it and breathed into it spir it.” In 1886 he was tried for heresy by the Augusta (Ga.) Presbytery, and acquitted; then the Synod of Georgia reversed the action of the Presbytery Finally, in 1888, the General Assembly of the sustained the whelming vote, and forced Dr. Woodrow Theologica! denounced Southern Presbyterian Church Synod by an _ over- from his position in the Seminary His opponents the doctrine of evolution, even in the mild form in which he held it, as con trary to Scripture and subversive of the interests of Christianity and of the Church astical organization that would stand on Where to-day is the ecclesi- that platform? The incident has its les son for heresy-hunters, though as a class they are our Bourbons, who learn nothing and forget nothing. It is use- less to remind them of Gamaliel's ad- vice as to dealing with heretics—advice which is confirmed by all ecclesiastical history Refrain from these men and let them The Nation. al ne For f +> , " t f God , $ haply y t f ! R ¥ God lhe inhappy , . Bien forms the subjec of aj vertu ‘ er lressed to the Lor s | \ ur John Evans, an eminent ithority on the archwology and |} té or the Nearer East His acq ntance with Turkey and the Balkans gos i f more than thirty year rhe or for his appeal is the rumored intention cf Russia and Austria, the two Power charged with the execution of reforn r Macedonia, to follow up their schem: of financial renovation, according to the Miirzsteg programme of 1903 with a series of judicial reforms. The burden of the letter is the absolute vanity of expecting any real reform under their auspices. What is the present condition of Macedonia, after more than vears of the Miirzsteg régime? The in spector-general in charge of the reform programme is Hilmi Pasha the Sul tan’s dme damncee and nominee.’ The Austrian and Russian assessors have merely advisory powers without an real control The International gen darmerie has shown little efficiency, be cause the European officers have been provided with an inadequate staff, and must take their orders from Hamid’s agent.” The Turkish Govern ment is acting in concert with the Gree} bands against their common enemies the Bulgars of Macedonia. Incendiarism and massacre run riot, and the tradi tional futility of the European Concert receives one more demonstration. Great concludes Mr Evan could force a termination of the régime Pritain alone, of terror But can England enter upon such a course? At this moment in In dia, Great Britain is trying to rall lohammedan opinion to its ipport against the Hindu national movement and must naturally be anxious to avoid all conflict with a Mussulman Power Georges Clemenceay is not at this moment in labor-union circle in France For the second time nce his accession to power, about nine months ago, he has made use of the military and the police to maintain 01 der against the adherents of organized labor. Yet its representatives in Par liament stand in more or less intimate relations with the Cabinet especially on the religious question. From one point of view. of course, the Premier's action in suppressing the projected labor dem onstration in Paris Sunday required less courage than was called for by the situation in the northern departments last May. Then it was a case of check- ing the strikers driven into violence by TB fe he he oO of the Cou eres mine ex . Sunday no s langer f I ouse I opi! vt thre ened the Mir R ‘ he othe hand is al | ‘ f M. ¢ ea il ! ! i { or I ! C} mber whose i ort rhe can ca lispense with in his present contest vith the Papa At the same time, the events Of Sunday may yx t move e ¢ the oppo > a ore ¢ 0 pole We ead tha ne ("} h pape id ha these S ist A wanted t t ‘ pe ‘ on of he ‘ he ve eople vho Ww ! ! Government te op Catholie pr ! lo wl h M Clemenceau I ©] l¢ i 1 i l bet ween poli i the mn \ hat threaten I eC Hot t! you must Prema ve ! of medica ‘ \! ! } ‘ ne one bevond f e® Of OXI ment has many dan yer The X-ra vas hailed on all side he ‘ ‘ ! nacea Within a ‘ ve it had been tried ol ] ) of adie ind the paype were reporting resul nothing short of mirack Conserv: e medical en Ked In Valin fe Lime observe rr I | v} now 1 the i ude of t} | fe m toward X-ra therapeu ] I eplaced 1 e of the older method et iin! no ul cal ope Ol I vith canes | 1 ised oT vw he eve 1 cal! isure } failed nd then onl oO de ease the ray i of the tumic vt The illeged psin cure for cancer has been similar trumpeted more loud than the cientifie test ‘ warrant Phe re ts of the experiments on mice |} Dr ve! encour ng bu I! case ol human cancer it j et eat too oon to make any positive claim whatsoever Of cancer there ire many type some grow quickl) nd without removal are repidly fatal ome, again, are so slow r their growth that years may pass before their presence is even recognized to decide, even when the result ppear most conclusive, whe her a cure of cancer has been effected urgeons believed that if a cancer did not recur in its first site within one year, the patient was free of nee That time (“observation time,” urgeons call it) has been increased first to three, then to five years, and at present one of the most experienced surgeons in this country believes that cancer may recur even after ten yeare Thus it is evident that the factors which enter into any adequate determination of the value of trypsin as a remedy for cancer are not simple, nor do they quickly become manifest even to the . ' hh ‘. coum le ntiousr and & entific po iclan

Page 8

TA PREPARING SUBSIDY The subsidy hunters have apparently Roosevelt. They at- weak love SCANDALS. captured President tacked of national grandeur the him on his side—his In his speech last of the For- eign Commerce Convention, he said that Wednesday at dinner The Nation. Indeed, the evidence is strong that what we have in the subsidy bill is, not a measure which any large number of people are asking for, but a scheme got the of a few ship-build- and ship-owners, who are not too scrupulous in the instruments and meth- ods they employ. The legislation now sought they regard as something which they have bought and pa.d for »y means of contributions to the Republican cam- peign funds, and to secure which finally are ready to put up money. There is no real and general demand for ship subsidies. Even under great pres- sure, three Republican members of the Merchant Marine voted against reporting the bill. That was one-third of the Republican member- ship; and probably represents about the proportion of Republicans in the House vho are against the subsidy raid. But the is counted upon to per- suade Theodore Roosevelt, the up in interest ers they more Committee on President them. | clean, the hater of corruption, is to be used to overcome the objections of hon- est Republicans to a scheme which they | believe to be both bad in itself and push- he had never given any particular at tention to the question of steamship communication, but that he had been startled when told by Secretary Root that our flag is seldom seen in South American waters except upon a war ship. This sudden discovery filled him with patriotic mortification and a de sire to do something immediately He wants to “see the flag fly,” just as Thiers wanted to “see the tall chim neys smoke”: and is seemingly as ready to resort to bad legislative and eco nomic means to bring about the good result Mr. Roosevelt probably does not re member the Pacific Mail scandals of the early 70s It might do him good to} read the exposure of the corruption, in connection with that subsidizing legis lation, which so badly smirched the Republican party of that day And, next, it would be well for this enemy of corruptionists to take a sharp look at men and suspicious meth- of Treasury the uspicious to engineer this latest for a grant of $3, Congressman Grosvenor of task? made use the ods raid on 0.000 a year what sort repu- He is head, and he erving h last is at thelr tation does bring to the term. To such a depth he he of in Ohio was his dubil- the inter clamoring for York Evening Post pub facsimile of for $1,000 Grosvenor, nominally for a “Book of the Presi used him with deadly ef in discredit) had sunk even in his that own district was denied renom ination, and one the chief arguments ised against him financial relations with have been sub New ! that The everal dy lished J Pierpont years agko a Morgan's check payable to of Grosvenor s The fact his constituents Grosvenor’s ub copy dent was against mone fect right-hand man thi idy business is Littauer—a Representative also in the last weeks of hi Secretar’ ervice, also under a cloud hoot’ enarcely publi report, which the Pres forgotten, in of from ident can have timated that the statute alone saved Littauer prosecution for dabbling With thi Alexander R in Government contracts prectou is employed pair Smith, whose business it is to “work up public sentiment” for the subaldy bill He was openly charged by Samuel Gompers with having tried to bribe labor leaders into withdrawing their opposition to subsidies, and the riatter has been under investigation by District Attorney Smith him self admits that he was in a position to funds” for the subsidy propa Jerome “secure ganda ed by corrupt methods' Special legislation of this sort has al- ly ays been the besetting sin of the Re- | class limitations rublican party. No sooner does it get firmly in power than it begins to dole out favors to particular classes. Put in office in 1896 to establish the gold stan- dard, it moved most reluctantly in that direction, but ran in eagerness to allow manufacturers to write their own duties the tariff. If now it rounds off its record by voting public money into pri- vate pockets by means of ship subsidies it will go far to confirm the charge that joined idols of legislation. In the proposed Dill there is an amusing attempt to disguise the gift of money to J. J. Hill and E.H The bill gravely says: In it is hopelessly to its Harriman. Pacific north China, and the the Coast to Japan From a on Mendocino $350,000 for a monthly port of Cape Philippines service, $700,000 for a fortnightly From a the Pacific of Cape Mendocino to Hawaii, Japan south China, port on Coast ind the Philippines, $350,000 for a monthly service, $700,000 for a fortnightly Put what has Cape Mendocino to do with it all? Nothing, except that the ex- isting Hill line of steamships from Seat- tle is north of it, and the existing Har riman line from San Francisco (the Pa- cifle Mall) to the south. The committee simply did not like to say outright that it was intended hand a present of $700,000 to Hill, and the same amount to to Harriman. We hope to see the bill fought and defeated. Subsidy is a hateful word, and it ought to be erased from our leg- islative dictionary. It has reeked with scandal in the past. So it infallibly will again, if allowed to creep into our laws. There are ways of restoring our mer- chant marine, as every American hopes [Vol. 84, No. 2169 it will be restored, without the touch of corruption upon them; but they consist in abolishing old bounties and statutes for a favored few, not in enacting new ones, with their endless possibilities of favoritism, fraud, and political demoral- ization. THE HISTORIC SENSE. Readers of the English reviews may bave seen very favorable notices of a book, “The Great Days of Versailles,” by G. F. Bradby. It is, indeed, an en- tertaining work. Here you may follow the daily life of Louis XIV. and his court to the minutest details—what they ate and wore, how they talked and quarrelled and loved—a strangely vivid picture. Only one aspect of that exist- erce is omitted: there is scarcely a word to indicate why those days should be called “great.’”’” The monotony of court life is set forth in full, but nothing is added to explain how this monotony was only the last rigid stage of the ideal of uniformity, or rather conformity, which had produced the literature of the grand siecle. Something is said about the production of Racine’s “Esther” at Saint-Cyr, but chiefly to show the vexa- tions the play brought upon Madame de Maintenon. Nor does religion fare bet- ter. Here you shall read of the trick by which the sham devotion of the great ladies was exposed to Louis; Madame Guyon also is mentioned, and Fénelon’s connection with the Quietists, but for petty reasons only. Louis’s own submission to the Church is related, but there is nothing to indicate the deep religious current that ran through the age side by side with its worldliness, sparing inits course not even Versailles. However, we have no quarrel with Mr. Bradby’s book, which is excellent in its hind. It concerns us here only as rather an extreme example of what is grow- ing more and more evident in recent literature—the absence of the historic sense. It used to be the boast of the nineteenth century that it was the cre- ator of science and of the historic sense; and in a way the boast was justified. Certainly, no previous century had un- certaken to worm itself into the secrets of the past as did the century of Renan and Taine and Sainte-Beuve. From the great doctrine of relativity and of de- velopment inculcated by Germany from Kant to Hegel, came the notion that an era of the past is something distinct in spirit, something to be comprehend- ed by getting outside of present asso- ciations, To this end the study of de- tails was to be carried to indefinite lengths, for gradually, through the ac- cumulation of minute point after point, the picture of a past environment was to be produced, and from this knowledge of surroundings we were to infer the nature of the soul of the period. The historic sense, as then understood, was

Page 9

Jan. 24, 1907] thus an offshoot of skepticism and science, of skepsis in the double mean- ing of that ancient word. As scholars lost faith in the immutable and uni- versal principles of human nature, they became more interested in tracing the path of what is changeable and locally determined. As the past lost in author ity it seemed to grow more valuable to us as a field upon which we could ex ercise our unconcerned love of abstract truth. Those who have read Buckle will the of this pursuit. remember how methods were adapted to Or. bet ter yet, there Taine’s attempt avalyze the of English liter- ature as if they were so many chemical is to products compounds. It is a question whether there not a certain admixture of self-decep- tion in all this brilliant resuscitation of the past, whether the historic spirit of was the nineteenth century ever escaped quite so entirely from the clinging fal- lacy of the present as it supposed. It is at least significant that those who were loudest in proclaiming the new scientific and skeptical method are just those who are most rapidly losing credit to-day. Buckle his erudition and eloquence, is no longer taken quite seriously; Taine is notoriously an un sure guide, and the “History of English despite Literature,” written confessedly as an exemplification of his theory, is a con tinued distortion of the reality. One riay doubt whether their vividness in reconstructing what they called the past was not really due to the completeness of their implication in the spirit of the present: the picture at least was in tensely alive. It would be odd if in the long run the earlier writers who were concerned with what they regarded as the unchanging elements of human na ture should prove to have been truer in their grasp of the past than these disci ples of scientific relativity. On the whole, it is safer to admit a noment in the nineteenth century, when the older notion of continuity and au thority combined with the newer theory of development and relativity to create a genuine historic sense. A perfect ex ample of this may be seen in the “Port Royal” of Sainte-Beuve, where a writer essentially skeptical reproduces a ciety dominated by religion; in English we have the greater historical novels culminating in “Henry Esmond.” What cannot be ignored the fact that for many years the historic sense, that is the power of calling forth any true il lusion of the past, has been sureiy wan sO is ing. The abuse of the documentary method of study may have something to do with this, by habituating the mind to dulness, but the real cause lies deeper. The means has destroyed the er d, and those who try to be most en tertaining are likely to be least histori- cal. The effort to accumulate pictur- esque details has blinded us to the pur science

The Nation. pose for which these details were first desired. Of this Mr. Bradby’s book af ferds a striking example At first the attention of the reader is deeply en goged: he expects to < ] o the very spirit of the ize Present he is chagrined to discover that the pictur esque anecdotes and dé ription ead nowhere Because th it iration of that age was different from ours, it i simply non-existent to the auth he has no standard by which to measure the relation between the uniforn ind 1straint of manners ind on the other the discipline of mind that showed itself in se many we of f£enius And missing this interest the higher things of humanity whic) rake of that age a lesson and autho! ity, he falls into the most vicious fallac of the present Because we with our habits and conveniences should be bored and shocked by the physical conditior of that life, he represents the great days of Versailles as a time of almost un tigated boredom THE WORSHIP OF LOCAL COLOR Mrs. Gertrude Atherton has fluttered London journalists by a letter to the Times in which, in her “second-be Californiaese,” she bade the august edi tor “go to the devil Far more signifi cant, however, is an earlier letter to the same newspaper setting forth het theory of “local color,” for here she spokesman of a whole school of modern rovelists. She would have a writer a cept nothing at second-hand For the sake of a single chapter in her la novel, “Rezanév,” she spent thirteen days on a trip from San Francisco to Sitka She found the effort “quite worth while,” for her mental picture of the place was very different from the ality. She adds: I iy irg 1 tha a fe igral of description do not matter one way o anothe ind that the average reader w never know the differenc« likely i no will skip them; bu matters to the au thor, who is not worth his salt unl he writes first of all to please himself; and places his work before every other con sideration Moreover, there are subtl ms in suggesti his work, that he would never get th wise This, we submit, is to follow the spirit of the age to the bitter end, by subject ing works of creative imagination to the limitations of the exact sciences. Th inference from Mrs. Atherton’s state ment is that the novel must, like a mod ern doctoral thesis in history or be thoroughly documented and fortified by abundant experiment. This, indeed, is the contention of Zola and his discl DIOLOKY, ples among the uncompromising real ists We all know to our sorrow what lo- cal color is. The novel of to-day reeks a new atmosphere related to | -) with it—dialect so « t tv ininte ble f Ces on of pers ticulous attention t ind < oms I Now, we raise n t fT kcal color t end ba story bt we wisl would bear in mind tl isn made fe the ‘ the background _ x Mrs. Atherton’s to Sitka ars thins that distract the ve his main theme of cl} " ! When ve write of a \ have known long and ! an preserve your sense of | for ( are not carried iw novelt of the view Rut after you ! ve completed a long journey expressly t ee what a country is like the tempta tion to ove maid the ile with a d 1 on of it i ult ri tible You cannot th ¥ aw in a word ‘ two the en ] | ‘ whicl have taken so much t ble t et Then, too, it j ‘ scription now that hown us all th trick Wi match him in chara ! auct of ever bu come out strong on de any fairly trained sketch of the Ka ! Popocatepet! that n ! ( cribed to the master hit f not turn for examples to the vhose fault we |} So competent a nove Joseph ¢ id has fal i ! er a 1 writer of d H ‘Nostromo in ible espects oppre ‘ u wit! te } about the mere ph ‘ ‘ Inco Obvious i thore h fam i place is iO Lut} t em of success in handlit the minuti@w of local color It worth Sco era and Dicken t f hat yu can write most \ lly of the ene in which you have ved But whe such long familiarity i mpossible, we think a little—a very littl second-hand information better than a flying trip t Sitka or exhaustive study of book We all know what happened when Georg: Eliot went to Florence and skimmed a thousand books for the local color of Romola.’ If any book is killed by ! eal color it is “Romola’’—alway ex cepting, of course, Becker's “Gallus” and “Charicles."” Shakespeare made no such painstaking study of Verona f his “Romeo and Juliet but crith sure us that it is Verona in very truth that he draws for us. Two weeks as we printed Kipling’s striking statemen: that in the “Tempest” Shakespeare cer tainly showed us the Bermuda I who go to-day to a certain beac! two miles from Hamilton will fi: t} for Act II., Scene stage set

Page 10

wa & lin theory is that Shakespeare talked with me sailor At ar rate, we know that for Captain ( ira 1 Kiy ng did not go to the Grand Banks with any Capt Disko rroop. bu chatted comfortably on shor with tl isher men Defoe had never been on a des ert land or through the heart of Africa, yet neither Robinson Crusoe ne Captain Singleton wh ocal co or oO far a t ! ded for capital tory So fa ocal ec needed. And the fact that of the kind of local a wil t durit 1 few days in Sitka, n f is needed thar comn ' Ippose The reat novels A make bold to 1 contain y it t n he wav of diales or d riy lor Ihe wuthor of Tom Jones Pride ind Prejudt and Vanity halt had more vital topic t deal with than scenery They wel ! vy with human characte! and all else was in cidental Henry Esmond” i often called the best historical novel ever written It give in incomparable pi ture of England in the age of Anne. ¥Y how ttle it contains that is purely pl torialt One scene, very brief, will stand out as typical in the memory of most reader a few lines that afford a glance Castlewood as the ill-omened Mohun took his leave mr) kv b gl ' ) ] | f | bullding ind ! i sdow ov } memento mor bed ind h 4 ! " ! ! ! ind a span irly wh he ) vith his f p to in, and th fing l gra ind ind m ! f w.i , libly Chat all, and that is enough rhe vel of thi yeu of grace ha fallen nto the ame delusion a th tage manager, that elaborate and historical lv a irate etting in ¢ entiai hut if the characterization be vital, and the tale compelling in its interest, the re eather ind’ prune i Shal yy suditor needed nothits more t i nhoard to tart th in ! ‘ n vn da l i) Greet has cut h ‘ lown ft nl y more ha that irredue minimun ind ye | pel formance do not suffer The play t! thing Our novelist may, without go wn to extrem take a lesson from Mr (jreet and from the old master of the for eller eratt and les te distinguish between the « ence and th cident THE INTERPRETER OF GRAFT When ix or seven Vear wo, a vol ume called The World of Graft de scribing the life of the “underworld,” firat attracted notice, the ordinary re spectable readers had to find out what the last word of the title meant They learned that it was a sort of thieves’ Nation. ‘The Latin for the ill-gotten gains of the pow- ers that prey. It applied to the petty thief’s takings, the swindler’s gains, the gambler’s winnings, the corrupt police ian’s hush-money But there was some ascination about the word. It began to ippear in respectable company. Grad ually it lost its quotation marks. It lost its original meaning at the same time The term “grafter’ came to be reserved for the unfaithful employee or public servant, the purchasing agent who ac- epted secret commissions, the legisla- tor who sold his vote, the official who held an interest in public contracts With that meaning, the word passed the tage of slang within an almost incred bly short period, ana as yet shows no igns of disappearing from our speech. That word is the real monument of Josiah Flynt Willard, “Josiah Flynt,” as he signed himself, who died Monday at Chicago The term with which he en riched the language seems destined to live much longer than the studies of criminal and semi-criminal life which first contained it It was no new thing for a man of good family and education to become a vaga- bond by choice. Not to mention Sir Richard Burton in the Orient, the gypsy tudies of Borrow and Charles Godfrey Leland have a permanent place in liter ature To every one who _ possesses either intellectual curiosity or love of adventure there is an appeal in this kind of exploration that does not re cord its achievement on the map—in the discovery of new worlds almost at one’s doorstep talboa had no finer moment than Leland when he found in the tink er’s jargon a language, which was un Lnown and yet which was spoken along the roads he had trodden all his life. Josiah Flynt had nothing in common with the dilettante sociologists who every now and then hold their noses plunge into the human cesspool, and, climbing out, presently spray themselves nd hurry off to write their experiences. Richard Harding Davis once lived, as ve know, disguised “among the thieves of Philadelphia.” Certainly, he has never gone back to them from choice Richard Whiteing and Arthur Morrison have interpreted their London of mean reel with only such concession to the wil of the people who became their characters as Dickens and a hundred other writers have made. Flynt, how ever, could be called quite as truly a tramp with a gift for expression as a iterary man who became an amateur tramp He thus belongs at the opposite pole from the sociological investigators who play the part of the honest workingman Prof. Walter A. Wyckoff spent eighteen months doing odd jobs throughout the ountry His accounts of that period were highly interesting, but they hardly pretended to interpret the workingman’s psycholog, The idea that his trials | criticised. [Vol. 84, No. 2169 | and privations are of his own making, and that they could be terminated in twenty minutes by a telegram, is ever with his readers. They find him in dif- ficulties which would not be such for the ordinary “worker” he pretended t be. A man who does chores about a summer hotel and refuses to accept the tips which are a regular and expected feature of that kind of employment, an unemployed laborer who refuses the refreshment offered by the free-lunch counter, are not typical of anything or anybody Similarly, Mrs. Van _ Vorst could mark an emotional crisis by put ting in parallel columns the cost of the clothes she took off and of those she put on when she went to look for work in tactories It was a crisis for her, no doubt, but it would not have been lt “the woman who toils” for a living or te any of Josiah Flynt’s people, out cists, criminals, and semi-criminals, ab normalities generally In dealing with this class he lacked the genius really to ennoble his narra tives, however vivid and searching they might be emotions they aroused; Pity and terror were not the rather, plain curiosity. Such influence as they may have had was in their disclosure of cor- rupt alliances between the criminal and the officers of the law. Like any ordi nary “exposer,” he encountered for a time the wrath of those whom he had For example, after his ac ecunt of crime in New York was pub- lished, our whole police force was hunt ing him unsuccessfully. But even in | this public service Flynt was doing only what Dr. Parkhurst did a few years pre vious by a brief personal investigation of the evil of the city. Voluntary vagabondage will exist so long as “the call of the open road” is heard There will be scholar gyps‘es end “wander-lovers.” Flynt by nature must have belonged to the restless tribe yet the journeys on which he took his readers were, after all, little more than protracted slumming tours. OUR CHAMBER MUSIC. The attention of the whole world of music has been drawn to this city be cause of the opening of a second grand opera house. Yet Oscar Hammerstein's venture is no better index of New York's extraordinary musical growth than is the development of our chamber music It is fourteen years since the Kneisel Quartet gave its first series of concerts here, in an almost virgin field. True, there had been quartets before theirs, and irregular chamber music concerts for forty years. Yet the permanent de velopment of this form of music must cate from the arrival of these great art ists. The generosity of Major Henry L Higginson of Boston made. possible their venture, for which musical America owes him a debt that can never be liqui —

Page 11

Jan. 24, 1907 | dated And when these _ performers found it desirable to sever their connec Orches again proved his tion with the Boston Symphony tra, Major breadth of view by Higginson freely granting their wish, even though it meant a great loss to the orchestra for which he has made such sacrifices Now, the Olive Kaltenborn, the besides the Kneisels, we have Mead, the Flonzaley, and the Ma Dannreuther, the rum quartets, all giving concerts in this and other cities, and all worthy of re spect, as is the new Boston Symphony Prof. Willy them ranks, of course of which Hess is None of C,uartet, leader with the Kneisels, and none is nearer te their standard than the Olive Mead Quartet This is not only an organiza t women, but has the distinction thoroughly American Miss Mead herself rned on of f being the most them all. quartet of never even studied abroad, but le: her art himself The fact may shall not be Europe for our best chamber-music play entirely from Kneisel indicate that hereafter we compelled to draw upon ers. The concerts of this club are not cnly well attended here, but are in de result of the They mand in many places—a work of the Kneisels into cities where cham and the pioneer early ventured unheard of, concerts” ber music was term “orchestral generally meant at its best a Sousa or a Duss The other the good sense of the word At schools quartets are also popular in and colleges and private entertainments their services are sought by really musi cal people. If the begun to be in a Kneisel concerts in this city have sense “fashion- able,” of our music lovers, and in none the less the pick such num if Mendels they draw bers that it even looks as sohn Hall would soon be too small Since chamber music does not appeal tc the musical masses, this apprecia tion of our quartets is in itself evidence of the improvement of American taste Great dynamic or dramatic effects are not to be obtained or desired in a small hall. It is the finish of the players their high artistic skill, which counts Only rehearsing stant practice can the high-water mark or ensemble-playing be reached, and then by endless and con only in case the artists have especial gifts to start with. Tonal and color ef- fects are to be obtained only by the most of the instruments; careful correlation by unceasing study of intonations. Cor rectness of phrasing and of notes is first cessful chamber-music player. merely the requisite in the su Nor must it be thought that cham ber music appeals only to those whose money has given them unusual oppor tunities for perfecting a _ taste The Auxiliary Club of the People’s Sym phony Society has recognized the ex tent of the interest in music, and is en gaged in an excellent undertaking—sup ' The Nation. ( | vO pers f +} f t ‘ f i o! with ked Sv et eive Wt é he au } r ‘ t of 1 \! ‘ son Ss rv f We I ey 4 +} ( he Py ; . } } . t 1 | roo 1¢ ne ‘ we wind } Symphor Ore} a this city vith fa wi K howe l cle f high rar in o 1? n cl t< ‘ iT? mber must All in New Y« I ene! ma nnort given o of ean much to the ven i rit n mue omposer CA ADIAN LITEI 0 ~ { Zz ) n ! with n I wr r ul f +} l ‘ ind } a} ] ry } nr h pr Ip +} ' r +} . | } »} I, ’ ! I rf ‘ r } e o . ’ i ! ' ¢ ’ he " } : ’ r ‘ f m h t ) t hed b W i ( nat Du . : . ' Rot M I) ge ) () f th: D. Rot \ it ] ! I too the gi ch-Canad hat Dy ! rm ( Re ) ( ner all er ver at published |} rh new po } otl " rl eveal a b 7 n f ul I al I j l Carman has |! ative land for many his th ( ‘ pre nces F ~? } " } hood ) gl » ? “ the € ru 4 that fr ! f the Ba ) ! ‘ x & { a [ f al rec t i | ig ‘ ! [ vt h he ha a {f Na I \s s ¢ +) n of ‘ ‘ } ! J ) " In h \ i M ing) and j il Ll) in Cam ow 4 field tha i iched 1 vers j j i ‘ I s fe I 1 R l 1 of the © and ‘? A y i | ‘ l i lsu \ I x ‘ r a h Bathe i " ‘ a . , ! G Hi " i) A 1 K ‘ \ is { | \ we , (a a A the I bl Ro M l i panied by a | ( K and | I ( } I 1) I M M ald Wi 1 ad ' ‘ by t Ni iM f books of ve nt lia ty pI n wo ag [ , h above lit u niv | } ‘ 0 f the evidences of Canada’s rise nat ihood the increasing Interest r ! early history of the country 1} le of early Canadian h ha ippealed to more than o ft I more erious le aking asing hold upon the n ] f tt i¢ In her Pathfinders of the W nd Vikings of the Pacifi M Ag Laut has revealed the richness of th fle Not every one po her pictu qu touch, but mn more prosaic fash oth Canadians are helping lig tl sat has remained fo many y hidde and forg n TI i yf the " w

Page 12

ng done in the Dominion Archives has lready been explained in the Nation. Of almo equal importance s that of the Prov if Ontario, the " of which was published late 1) iber The 1906 transactions of the on ty of Canada, of the Ontario H | Society, the Literary and His t ety of Quebec, and other sim idded npo il ma i } 1a ; " é i ot I 1 i) I Canadia and Dr S } Br iin Society is doing excellent " n the editing of h 1 the publication of annotated r« torical manu irly Canadian books Several 'y Cana 1 iT prepared for the new edition ! B i i otably . ( i i ry, by | \\ Colb ) VceG Univ V nu i \\V I ) » | y 1 | J. Burpee hav I 1} Canadian li V \ I Gran who } i ! i w k on } ; ) | 1zZ { im planned y iH i \ An i A I il ha i I I " 1 for th xplora m of An 1 Canadian biography three important rn ippeared during the year in Mo Makers of Canada Serie Dr. W. D Fro ic,’ John Lew G Brow *and Le Blond de Brumath’s 1) Hannay Wilmot and Til ) ind Bradley's “Lord Dorchester” are y for publication. The Rev. Charles W (better known a Ralph Connor) prepared a life of Dr. Robertson, th nent Canadian divine; and the Hon. J Longley is editing the Letters of Joseph i e, one of the fathers of Confederation he htev.C. W. Gordon has brought ‘ vel r} Doctor tlreadyect Nation Dr. Wilfred Camp winning a ime for himself as a ha now followed h fellow-Cana ( rl Roberts, into fiction His 0 | it romance of old ne the ime period as the I 1 f Perth Mr. Roberts him f two booka of fiction during t very readable novel The / | ~ the other a good boys’ The ¢ of the Dido Another k for boys is Norman Dun I ropsall Mr Everard Cotes t) field that she has made so " her vn in “et in Authority”; llarve J. O'Higgis f Don-a-Dreams,” Marion Ke i The Iver Maple,” R. L Richardson I Camerons of Bruce,"’ Dr. Price Brow n “In the Van,’ and Mr Knowle n ( ht t's have taken ract« f Canadian ene is the set f heir v rhe quiet humoy mracterist f Sydney Preston's k sa marked feature of his “On Com mon Ground W. A. Fraser brings to- re ra furthe lection of } very read le hort stories in Thirteen Men.”” A Canadian edition of Jean Mci!wraith’'s Rod k Campbell ha been ssued. Th The Nation. brief survey leaves out of account a num- ber of Canadian books of a lentifie or technical character The most French-Canadian contribution to 1906 was Abbé G. Dugas'’s “Histoire de l'Ouest Ca- nadien de 1822 A 1869" (Beauchemin). This is a continuation of his valuable work important literature in published ten years ago, “L’Ouest Canadien, a découverte par le sieur de la Vérendrye, on exploitation par les compagnies de traiteurs jusqu’A l'année 1822." The sig- nificance of La Vérendrye'’s Western explo- rations is being recognized more and more by students of Canadian history, as witness Judge Prud’homme’s scholarly memoir in Royal Pierre Gaultier de Varennes, Sieur de La Nord-Ouest, 1685-1749." In the same transactions Dr A DD DeCelles he Transactions of the Society, Vérendry¢ Découvreur du librarian of Parliament pays a tribute of appreciation to the mem- ry of that scholarly Canadian churchman, l'Abbé Bourassa; Camille Roy contributes in elaborate critical pap Etude sur l'histoire de la Littérature canadienne, 1800- 1820 and in an appendix is found an ex- haustive bibliography, covering 161 pages, ompiled by Dr. N. E he legislative library, Quebec, Dionne, librarian of “Inventaire chronologique des ouvrages publiés a Il’ét- ranger dans diverses langues sur la Nou- elle-France et sur la province de Québec, lepuis la découverte du Canada jusqu’A nos jours 1534-1906."" z Pierre Georges Roy of Quebec ad his genealogical studies of French-Cana- During 1906, led another to lian families, this volume being devoted to the Panet family, which has given many em nt men to Canadian public life. Dur- ng the year Beauchemin of Montreal uught out a book of verse by the late Alfred Garneau In December last the Rerue ond year, a remarkable record for a col- Canadwnne completed its forty- onial periodical with only a very limited field to appeal to. In the character of its historical, critical, and descriptive articles t is far ahead of any other review pub- lished at any time in Canada L. J. B Corresp« mndence. THE VALUE OF THE DOCTOR'S DEGREE, ro THE EprTroR or THE NATION Sir: Prof. H. A. Todd of Columbia chose a timely topic for his recent address before the Modern Language Association at New Haven In nearly all that he said on the Function of the pressed what may be termed the orthodox Doctor’s Degree” he ex- German view The ordinary candidate for the degree should not, according to Pro- fessor Todd, spend more than a year on the actual writing of his dissertation, and all successful dissertations should be printed. To be sure, the American thesis should aim to combine the solidity of German scholar- hip with the French finish of form. It Is Lo be fearé d, however, that satisfactory doctors’ theses are not to be compounded by any such easy recipe Most German theses, on literary subjects at least, are as flimoy in substance as they are crude in form,and finish of form in the French thesis has value only in so far as it is the outer zn of maturity of substance One can [| Vol. 84, No. 2169 | scarcely contemplate the German theses as they pour by hundreds into a large library without a sort of intellectual nausea. To adopt Professor Todd's suggestion as to printing would, under present conditions, simply mean adding an American tributary to the stream It is not so much, however, what Pro- fessor Todd actually said that is open to objection as what he took for granted. Hope for literary study in this country would seem to lie in questioning the very things that to our philologists of German training seem self-evident. Thus Professor Todd as- sumed not only that the chief aim of our graduate schools should be to train investi- gators, but that our graduate students have as a rule a preparation sufficiently broad to justify them in embarking at once on their investigations. He assumed—and this is perhaps the underlying assumption of the whole German school—that there are two kinds of scholars: the receptive scholar, who takes things on authority and is still in his intellectual nonage; and the origi- native scholar, who proves that he is in- tellectually of age by independent research. But this is to overlook the all-important, intermediary stage when the mind is neither passively receptive nor again orig- inative, but is assimilative in the active and masculine sense. It is this oversight which leads to the exaggerated estimate of the man who brings forward new material as compared with the man who has really as- similated the old. In a recent paper on “Aspects of Greek Conservatism,” Prof. H. W. Smyth of Harvard points out how per- fect a balance was maintained in Greek literature between the forces of tradition and the claims of originality, so that Greek literature at its best is a kind of creative imitation. It is precisely the lack of this creative imitation that is the special weak- ness of our contemporary literature, just as the lack of creative assimilation is the spe- cial weakness of our contemporary scholar- ship. A pseudo-originality is equally the bane of both. The trouble with most of our imitation of German scholarship is that it has not been creative, but servile. Our practice in regard to the doctor's degree might at least have been tempered by hints from England and France, both of them countries with older literary traditions than Germany. For instance, a First Class at Oxford has lit- tle in common with our undergraduate hon- ors, but offers a tra’ning comparable in dif- ficulty to that of the doctorate. This train- ing, however, is of an entirely different kind; it is at once a test of humane as- similation, and a discipline in thorough- ness and accuracy. The Frenchman, again, who has gained in the lycée the education- al equivalent of the gymnasium, can- not, like the German, to specialize; he must in all cases receive in nearly all cases the agréga- of assimilative proceed at once the licence and actually does tion—involving before he receive years work arrives at his spe- cial investigation Even with these restrictions, Sainte-Beuve, himself one of the greatest and most accurate of investi- gators, complained of the harm done to hu- mane letters in France by an undue empha- “originality” and research. In our sis on own time, the same complaint has been re- peated with less amenity by Brunetiére. As Sainte-Beuve says, “L’ére des scholiastes sat nk RB

Page 13

Jan. 24, 1907] et commentateurs se mence.”” One cannot help being reminded | of Sainte-Beuve’s prophecies of a new Al exandrianism by the poverty of real inte! lectual achievement on the part of ou modern language teachers, as compared with their eager interest in such subj« as the making of concordances, dialect study, and spelling reform It is a pity that more time cannot b spared from these topics to consider not only the best training for the modern lan guage student, but the field that this tr: ing should cover; above all, the quest to the relative importance of the medi@vai iin ion as and the classical backgrounds. In theory several of our institutions—especially Har- vard—recognize the value of the classical background But practically when a stu- dent is once started on his bit of mediz- | val research, he not only has to forego his classics, but in preparing for his doctor's | examination often has to cram from man- | uals a hasty knowledge of the very parts that he is afterward to | Ordinarily, a student will be forced the Middle rarest of the modern field teach. make a choice between Ages the can he really master both to and classics; in only the cases Now a man may | be properly qualified to teach seventeenth century French though he has nothing more than a general notion of the Middle Ages; but he cannot be so qualified if he does | not know at first hand his Latin classics at least. The break with the medizwval past than was far less abrupt in England in France, yet even for the student of Eng- lish literature a knowledge of the Middle | Ages before Chaucer is vastly less impor tant than a thorough grounding in the | classics. This being so, one can only deplore the complacency with which modern language teachers as a body seem to regard the | rapid decline of Greek studies during the | past ten years, as well as the prospect of the near future for A.B degree without Latin. To talk in this con- nection, as some of them are doing, of in- evitable tendencies and ‘‘manifest destiny,” is simply to surrender to what is cheapest in the spirit of the present age. The utilitarianism which to the study of the the expense of the ancient if yielded to, deprive this very study of a large part of its seriousness and dignity. Hadley may, as he said in his New Haven address, prefer ‘““‘Wilhelm Meister,” to Pla- but it should be remembered, would be more offended by the doctrine im- plied in than self The modern languages, then, if they are deserve to rank as humanities, be taught so as to insure broad assimila- tive reading; they taught with reference to the classical background In a previous paper in the Nation (Septem- ber 20, 1906) I expressed the opinion that these ends could be best attained by a com- prehensive plan for graduate and graduate honors, undergraduate honors be a demand in an cur- rent appears exalt modern at languages will, President to; no one, this utterance Goethe him | to should and should be under ing so used as to give seriousness to the A.B. degree, and graduate honors to the A.M. The problem, however, is not so ' much to devise some new form of academic | machinery as to change the spirit that is responsible for the of the doctor’s degree present This superstition will be a rouvre et recom- ] The N ° . ecessary f liminary ! lit ilizing of our study of he ‘ 10d ern languages l i BaABBIT Harvard University Ja 5 4 BACON ON SPELLING REFORM TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION S1 In Miss Gra N n's | rin your ie of January she quoted a very ii ‘ ig passage from How I ers in fay f reform sp _ i I ispect that some of your read iy ested n the opinion of another and gz even eenth-ce iry Ww W 2 I n in going to a of things Fra Baco ikes a } ] t} l a] yn him If and ha} f xth l , +) rT OOK ) l Ly Augm » i i ‘ vs And with regard to t mm raphy itself, a controve y and question ha been raised among us imely, wheth words ought to be written as they are pro nounced, or in the usual way B his ap parently reformed style of writing (viz } which the sp lling should igree W“ h the pronunciation) belongs to the la f un profitable subtleties For the pronun ition itself is continually changing loes not remain fixed; and the lerivatior of words, especially from forei ong ure thereby completely obscured And as the spelling of words according » tl fashion s no check at all upon the fashion of pro nunciation, but leave free »> wl pu pose is this innovation? This seems to me to be the l word but if spelling can be separated from pro nunciation I would suggest that if the re formers wish to persuade the publ to uss their list of w is, they will do well to lire their attack upon the makers of d tionaries, and content fhemselves with ob taining the admission rf ! f n ed spellings, each n 3 pror place but subordinated to th already i it form Litigious persons referring to a di tionary will thus find that the reformed spelling is a legitimate variant. The whol question reminds me of a passage in Crabb Robinson's “Diary,” in which the Rev. Dr Rees describes his visit a committee of other Non to Lord Thurl object was to ask his lordship if the his the for the Test Act n tion with ynjun two ymformist Their could their divines, Chancellor Ww y ount obt Parliament on support in the event o iining introduction repeal Th ion and ir] by God I lamn me! for the other I'm against you Established church have any more regard Established Church than for any church, but because it Established if you can get your damned rs lished, I'll be for that, too! Gentlemen, am for the Not that I is the of both apparer t Bas if pronunciation by Messr Matthe of the they wish Boot that would » the Butler, and I suspect sanity and Thurlow become could listen te Skeat, Thomas, their us to adopt? Murray, Brander ws Calvin Roosevelt list spelling of which WILLIAM 8 of words H Boston, January 17 PROFESSOR ON RATS WATSON'S EXPERIMENTS DEFENDED TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION Str: The recent criticisms of the Nation upon the experiments by Dr. John B. Wat- son on rats are evidently based upon in accurate newspaper ré The purpose of Dr Watson's work ha been misrepresented The discovery of mysterious “sixth sense was not his ain although in his ge al lies he h found that rats appare possess a ct tain sé bility to tl I of the com pass But this d . has no ime t whatever with !? : ex] n ‘ \ hat happened I ment ed the sa por | ’ with ma the parative fj ? sts and bio gist Lt Watso irrying on exte »bservat 3 upon tha t pregna lodern | blem t v t i f ae F His own 8] field has be f the mammalia a field whiel \ isly li lose he doma ! : In h f 1 it + iry oT ) y I { l \ evide ‘ ‘ p } ly q ‘ M i lown x W ex I ! f ’ I get eX f tl t if th | ! f tl iecha m i ece i I h ex] is Dr. Wa 1 f 1 | ‘ 7 | } , s tuet f 1 Ww 1} ‘ ‘ tril ) » tl f psychol g , which | ' hygiene, a psychia larg pe ally the forms of psychia ling with a mer ld lopn rt ady rf ) i iia ’ pra ti Value As to the expe } ‘ ‘ were jucted with tl im ire regard ina t 1 and | haracte ‘ the I i mn of al I irs | have \ pe il pa quir nto th rh i ged f rn of the inimal x) l ™m grewsome picture hav bee lraw laily paper in point of fa co l the slight use of an ethy hloride spra a dey long mployed by surgeons fi prod nz a ery transient dermal ana thesia lea ng ’ afte eflect if lamag or pain Other measure have been sim larly misreprese ed I mals re from the peratior ilmost immediately how prodigio ippetit« and promptly retu o play and t with their com pa mn Vf h ! of the Natior no il 1e el wuld by their behav listinguist the 1 mal rats from those upon whom the operations have been made Th latte re fa rong, and vigoro ind appare y do everything which tt normal brothe do, and with equal fa It was because previous experimentatio | emingly showed that the so-called higher senses were of little or ) quence for these animals under conditio rf aptivity that the vivisection expe ments were felt to be essential Could be that animals of so much apparent in elligence really get along almost wholly by means of their ‘movement’ and organ! sations? If so, primitive mammalian m 8 quite a different sort of thing from ¢ common psychological conception of and the outcome of the experiments is appar- ently to show that such is the fa If we assume as a matter of that we are at liberty to remove r by linger

Page 14

THE own reading slow yrriure of rat ! iny othe neans he s not i whe in ani ley 1 of wr hap; No wholly I 1 1 ! ex np ntl he an rf 1ousa ff pe ) ff fo ‘ h wl Dr l i gard them fa | itl han I i l how i ; i l iv ' vy! I ! ra l¢ t the ) ha I | m t ( el han the ga I J. MARK BALDWIN lia Ja SHELVES NATION ! of January i ' lit n the if ] i wwhat | V t nt parativ y ta i n but ! n We nia t it m i 1 give i owing [ th building pay ’ mportant 1 il A member Library Com b meeting, within he hought the open t iu t my | l l ip ) | ym thu he ! I ‘ pa ind th howe ido] itterly " exp ha Pi i of oF ' Kiven the i her li i uuld no b i} e have tt tatement that inds ten time lection when hich ther ure h and hat i leal mad ! ir libra i x peopl ) pa ‘ fit We open childre book i be Th idu ‘ the helves n to be fru 1 ) And what are we pointed out that wi he proper Wearing The Nation. to say to that large and ever-growing class of technically and professionally educated pl who are already knocking at ovr om fo iccess to the shelves? No ii- brarian living can meet the needs of the people by a sele ion of be books ! a very 8 ous question, deserving idy and experimentation on a rg il before we conf failure \t he Clark University library we have had open-shelf system since its opening, In 889, and it has been an unqualified success We heck p our books or 1 yeal ud ) lo have not averaged $ a year Lous N. WILSON ( I vers Ww es Mass January 15 "Ww hardly need to point out that hildren’s libraries are, in fact, select libraries; and that as regards open shelves the problem of the college li- brary is not exactly that of the public brary Ep. NATion.] a 5 BENSON ON GISSING ro THE Epitor OF THE NATION: Su Apropos of the article on George G ng in your issue of Jannary 17, perhaps those who have not seen Benson's para- graph upon him in “The Upton Letters” will be glad to have their attention called oO Then there is another writer lately dead, alas! whose books I used to read with ibsorbing interest, George Gissing They had, when he treated of his own peculiar tratum, the same quality of hard reality which | value most of all in a work of fic- tion The actors were not so much vulgar is underbred; their ambitions and tastes were often deplorable. But one felt that they were real peopl The wall of the subur- ban villa was gently removed, and the life wa before your eyes The moment he trayed from that milieu, the books became fantastic and unreal But in the last two books By the Ionian Sea” and the “Papers Rycroft,” and etical of Henry new provinces beautiful and pr Gissing stepped into a produced exquisitely idealistic literature ALBERT 8S. CooK January 19 rik ABSURDITIES OF THE TARIFF ro THe EpitrorR oF THE NATION: ptitudes of tariff are afflic- them I our chau ble source of gaiety, or ally patient under mn pay without a murumur, duty on ymplim iry copies of books which i New York t look at have to publish in my own won London exper ! ences ind I have ju lence transcends must alt Iny griev- had sent me my Master's used) of Cambridge Univer- m England I was assessed article of rationally on this as an which speak- I then tariff that But, no; evidently, illector of cu b ine o'ested; In Hoode and x is not I pr vain figure on the cent., that in any case chargé n of the ¢ stoms, and the rely a subterfuge ho vl commercial vas'on on my part; my hood that was not has currency ind I must therefore be pitchforked I bluah into ipparel! when I think of | the epithets which the research st [ Vol. 84, No. 2169 udent of the year will bestow on our viliza tion J 2000 Cambridge Mass., January 16 Notes. Macmillan’s list of spring publicatiot long and interesting. It includes the “Prima Donna,” by F. Mari Lake,”’ by Ar Heming; ‘‘Befor and Life,”” by “The “The “Family Washburne; ing yn Crawford ‘Spirit Adam,” London; thur “Love of Gulf,” Kinsman,” by Secrets.”’ by by John ther Long; Sidgwick; Marion “Poppea of the Post Foster Office,"” by Mabel Osgood Wright; “Ghetto Comedies,” by Israel Zangwill; ‘The Earth’s Bounty,”’ by Mrs. Kate Saint Maur; “The Birth of the Nation,’” by Mrs. Roger A. Pryor; “A len Book of Vegetables,”’ by “Problems of the nal,”’ by Henry L. Abbot; “Three Liberty,”” by Bolton Hall; Al- Panama Ca- Acres and ift,”” by French; Mabel Osgood Wright; “Life and Letters of Edwin Lawrence Godkin,”’ edited by Rollo Ogden; “‘Mrs. Gaskell,”” by Clement Short- er; “Charles Kingsley,’’ by G. K. Chester- “Shakespeare,” by Prof Walter Edward of Ben ton; “‘Emerson,” by George and Writings Raleigh; NVoodberry; “‘The Life jamin Franklin,” H Smyth; “A ” vol. x., edited History of the Edward Middle Crawford Prof. Giu- “A History of the Henry States,” vol. ii., by Channing; \ History of Rome in the i., by F Tomasetti; Marion and Inqui Seppe sition of Spain,’’ vol. iii., by Charles Lea, LL.D.; “The Cambridge Modern His tory,”’ vol. x “The American Colonies in the Seventeenth Century,’’ vol. iii by Herbert L of Puget Osgood; “Vancouver's Discovery Sound,” by Edmond 8S. Meany ‘The Development of Shakespeare as a Dramatist,’’ by George P. Baker; ‘The Modern Reader's Bible,”” one volume, edit ed by Richard G. Moulton; “A Flower ot Old Japan, and Other Poems,” by Alfred Noyes; “Lyrical and Dramatic Poems,” vol. ii, by W. B. Yeats; “Sappho and Phaon,” by Percy Mackaye; “Her Own Way,” and “The Girl and the Judge,” by Clyde Fitch; “‘The Truce in the East and the Aftermath,” by L. Putnam Weale;: “Essentials of Economic Theory,” by John Bates Clark; “The Government of European Cities,” by William Bennett Munro; “Races and Immigration in Ameri ca,”” by John R. Commons; “Federal Power Over Carriers and Corporations,” by F Parmalee Prentice; “Practical Problems iu Banking and Currency,” edited by Walter Henry Hull; “The International Law and Diplomacy of the Russo-Japanese War,” by A. S. Hershey; “Newer Ideals of Peace,” by Jane Addams; ‘‘Labor and Capital,” by Goldwin Smith; ‘The Tariff and the Trusts,’ by Franklin Pierce; Freedom In the Church,” by the Rev. Dr. Alexander V G. Allen; “The Steps of Life,” by Carl Hilty; “The Crisis of the Church,” by Shailer Mathews; “The Psychology of Re ligious Belief,” by James B. Pratt; “Chris tianity and the Social Crisis,” by Walter Rauschenbusch; “The Persistent Problems of Philosophy,” by Mary Whiton Calkins; “The Way to Happiness,” by Thomas R. “The Conception of the Slicer; Religious

Page 15

Jan. 24, 1907] The Nation. 81 World,” by Arthur Kenyon Rogers; “The | tion by \ Seeming Unreality of the Spiritual Life, n rivers, and a } by Henry Churchill King; “Religion, Nat cial geograph id f : R ural and Revealed,” revised, by N. S. Jo British As seph; “Early Traditions of the Israelites of the O} St N by the Rev. T. K. Cheyne; ““Monuments of ae = ' the Early Church,” new edition, by Walter Libra ; as r - Lowrie; “Grove’s Dictionary of Music and : ; . : Musicians,’ vol lii., revised and (1E8 “ ; greatly enlarged “Life in the Homeric er Raleigh I , é' Age,"" by Thomas Day Seymour; “Life in works « r ‘ Ancient Athens,” by T G Tucker; ‘ : = The Principles of Secondary Educa- Pos p 5 ; yn,” by Charles DeGarmo “Class mas 1568 \ : : og om Management; Its Principles and Pamphlets \W ’ gee - . . Technique,” by William Chandler Bagley Sentalenan “ae ig ' Theories of Style,” arranged by Lane and am led , : Cooper; A Brief Course in the History of Dev . to 1 , Education,” by Paul Monroe; “A History of Friends plea . Greece for Secondary Schools,” by J. B - wien . Bury; “The Larger Types of American exist. alt) - H Geography” (Second Series), by Charles A D Grosa 9 re : McMurry; “Economics,” new edition, by — giuee . , Frank W. Blackmar; “German Science : , Reader,” by William H. Wait; ‘‘American emen who ¥ History for High Schools,” by Roscoe Lewis | tne interval betw Ashley “Elementary English Composi- rhe —_— , yn,”’ by Tuley Francis Huntington, A. M every scholar « Methods in Teaching,’’ by Mrs. Rosa V wilt welec Winterburn and James A. Barr; ‘Paris,’ The edito ' . by Mortimer Menpes and Dorothy Menpes; :, s of Chauce H rhe Art of Theatrical Make-Up,” by Cav- he fact that th idish Morton; “The Savage South Seas,” | gi, pyjj p Sid \ by Norman H. Hardy and E. Way Elking- | jjnes «w > to a , 1; “Canada,”” by T. Mower Martin and | ¢)) of rare inven Wilfred Campbell; “English Costume,” by ; Dion Clayton Calthrop; “Ireland,” by Fran- | rhe Comp ' ' The B vs I S. Walker, and Frank Mathew. H ong edited, wit ys I | rold idded to x 0 J. A. Farrer has written a study of “Lit- | , m of the po .s I ! iry Forgeries,” including the “Eikon | Doshoute Ingoldsby 1 é: ! , } Basilike,”’ Chatterton’s poems, and the a saa al ‘ wis : i ( 0.1 I ‘ } ; . . , Mf } , re Di syn -_ and . sates ; . ™ . | r forged Letters of Byronand Shelley. Messrs atta teens thet aan Mi ; i gly | Longman have the book in press provided a m nee | [wo important works are soon to be pub- | food than has h , , . . lished by M. Champion of Paris: ““Mélanges, | searching out from ‘ & with tl , Linguistiques,”” by the late Gaston Paris, | eould be certainly a ited ! : , of the ¢ ind the second volume of “Les Francais | adding half a doze1 v | 1 tl , Italianisants au XVIe Siécle,” by Emile | useript. We conf ha pas Picot ho le to th ma f \ The German National Free Mason Asso nificant matter and adding abi : ‘eo ® : ciation proposes to celebrate its fiftieth | of writers who already I ! es e sate ' : anniversary in September, 1911, by the pub- | servation of too mu I I ——. : a ee ;' lication of a complete bibliography of Free | result of such accun 3 : Mason literature, and has for this purpose | the number of an au the ! ; : | set aside as a preliminary the sum of 15,000 | him ever deeper , \ \\ | at least tw ‘ marks. Down to 1750 the work is to be | needed most of all now : fig! ; an international bibliography, but from 1750 | ciously selected (1 xpurs : _" psittmeete eae aa to the present it will be limited to pub- which would ligh f » ii ! n and eration, noth lications in the German language the past with us. Such a ld hay been expected : The Geographical Journal for January | ©@5¢ Of Hood, would ; : or opens with an address by Sir G. T Goldie his few poems of strang i ! ipul hat | book | in Edinburgh at the award of the Liv- | P@thos and aerial fancy a ' ae = ngstone medal on geographical ideals. He | f'°™ the mass of mY characterizes Livingstone as the ideal ex funny corner’’the poems who f I r John H. Reaga Mem plorer, and Reclus as the ideal cartograph ennially fresh. We should like, |! way Publishing Co.) a pa el Dr. Stein sends from Central Asia an | 4 Study of Hood’s w and | ' | ' g. Pert account of his exploration work, the most | WOUld show how they ofte ! more accurate 1 iy that M interesting feature of which was the dis- same faculty of playing w j ‘ recollection of e early day f covery of a large number of manuscripts | W°°ds. For the rv we 5 lependen 3 not particularly | on paper, in Sanskrit, Chinese, and the | Praise for the pres M And yet these days must ha unknown” language of old Khotan, be noles are capital i rtair ense, lively enough to sides many wooden tablets inscribed in | VO!ume attractive many incidents typical of a the same language, and in Tibetan. ‘‘Som« Correspondence of ‘1 » J by hapr past We miss the per ‘ excellently preserved large rolls of a Lady Guendolen Ramads ied by t where th element must ha Buddhistic text in Chinese, having on the Longmans, Green & ( I rother l nat \ po f reverse what is evidently its translation whose letters make [ ' al of tl f howeve Mi Rea , into the ‘unknown’ language, may prove to portly volume, but by n neans all of it n firmer ground, and ha " i furnish the long-desired clue for the de }; are Lady Guendolen Ramsden's grandfather hat are not without f hist al value cipherment of the latter.” Among the | the eleventh Duke of erset, and her We hear the personal note and get som other contents are an illustrated descrip | great-uncle, Lord Webb Seymour. The pe- ' insight into the workings of the Confeder

Page 16

The Nation. | very noble-minded American millionaire, ite Cabinet. Written in sensible, straight f ward tyl these Memoirs’ cover no mplaint, reveal no humor they are the rious expression of a serious man’s remin ences, with the political pect of thing wi squarely to the front In the \W } ! Confederacy (Neale Publis) zx Co.) the Rev J. I Un lerwood ha M4 | gether from ‘ariou i aon ! I pisodes I (a 1 ‘ ) bea nz mn t l mn and i th women of South lu u h “ \ n h Sta We hav ilway believed that to women fa he hard ) mn war, and irely 1 th vou v had a harder lot thar } wor rf } Confederacy; none ever | e it incomplainingly Whether he cause wa ght or wrong t | t ind ga heir all And hey " le day a littl i M Underwood well-meant l } 1 when tl x h just will 1 itl > the ord f in in words of i I ym John W Munson's “Reminiscence iM y Guerrilla” (Moffat, Yard & Co.) i hat Mosby's partisan inger ‘ Idier Col. Mosby himself un | ibl held 1 Confederat: ymmis fw may 1 the a mint of h men we! me and again ! mnt y ha yn G i i i wa o kill or s enemy in open ba legitimate, but to kill him and ib h wa h and money to pra ude fa highwayman. There was h of this sort of thing in Mosby " int as to be undeniably a blot on the r f the most daring and skilful " tha ver rode boot to boot It is pa of the ord, however ind, if the ith giv expre ion to it much as if he were d bing a bear hunt, we must recol that his purpose is purely reminiscent i not the rious one of weighing Mosby's is part of the sum of Confederate " | in My Life on Land and Sea,”’ by \\ Giaml Commander Royal Navy (kh. P. Dutton & Co.) sa book which some | ’ ! joy reading. The author is a phew of Admiral Gambier of Baltic y Af retiring, he went to Turkey he Ru » Turkish war is naval | 1k of th L, lor Times Hi a fre off-hand manner, and is f j inrefined, even to coarseness | \ b ibout = the world he appears to have \ ted many out-of-the-way pla i lescription of Norfolk Island f natanes ntere ing. since we sel dom hear of it There is a curious absence f date rhe reader has to guess in what it ! rambling allot is undergoing ! remarkable expertences If the book has literary merit, we have failed to dis or any mark of distinction The author mmenta are a a rule com monplace yet a kind of devil-may-care tone ma render h chapters entertain ing to read who like a slashing way of iking f men and v As indicating the merits and defect of thia rather un ueual plece of autobiography, we may quote a single passage, taken at random I rushed over to Paris to say goodbye My American friends were in a emali pen sion in the Rue du Colysée, No. 8, and were practically living on the charity of a Mr. Corcoran, who, I believe, kept half the American colony of Southerners going all through the war I found a well-known French historian hanging about the eldest girl, and instinctively mistrusted him. He was a plausible, sneaking, conceited hum- bug, and brought great sorrow into that family I also heard of an extremely wealthy German banker, of Jewish extrac- tion, as paying great attention to the younger, my flancée. But I thought no- thing of it, and left again with as light a heart as the prospect of this temporary separation would permit Could I have foreseen the future, I should have stopped in Paris, called out both men, and have tried to kill them. Page 287 The third edition of Thomas Kirkup’s History of Socialism’ (The Macmillan Co.) has been revised at a few points and pages. The first twelve chapters are substantially un- changed, but the thirteenth, treating of the of been completely rewritten in order to bring it up to date. The concluding chapters deal with the al- leged forces now making for the coming of socialism, and review in a dispassionate, if sympathetic, way the philosophy of the enlarged by some forty growth socialism, has movement Since 1887, when the author published his first work upon the subject, great changes have occurred, both in in- dustrial conditions and in economic opin- ion, which seem to justify many of his forecasts; and it is not strange that he now speaks with calmassurance ofthe com- ing socialistic state. He is singularly free from the exaggerated statement and decla- matory style which characterize the writ- ing of so many socialists, and the conclud- ing pages of the present show him Others have written with full- of the or from intimate acquaintance with the prac- volume it his best er knowledge literature, more tical propaganda, but none have surpassed Mr. Kirkup in philosophical grasp of the essentials of socialism, or have presented the doctrine in more intelligible form. Francis W. Hirst's ‘Monopolies, Trusts, ind Kartells,”” which was brought out by Methuen & Company in 1906, is now pre- sented to American readers by E. P. Dutton So far as we can observe no changes Persons who be- & Co made the plates that the “‘trust movement” flourishes in a free like England will learn much to their advantage by perusing the English its are in lieve trade country volume in either its or American dress The stuff that exemplified by Prof Re So sociology made of is Franklin H. Giddings’s Historical which beginner in s0- examples of and of con- is and Co.), in Descriptive (The Macmillan offer to the studies significant facts evolution interpretation.”” The three four hundred extracts vary- ing in length from five lines to five pages, and classified the headings: Society, Elements and Structure of Society, The So- cial Mind and Social Welfare. The puzzle seems to be: Fit these extracts, if you can, into the author's gen- 1dings is jlology”™ ! “to signed ‘ ologk al of social the great thelr volume tains or under Social Organization, eral scheme of sociological classification and terminology. Turning, for instance, to page 72, under the general heading Ele- ments and Structure of Society, and the sub-heading Aggregation, the student will find the following An Army of Blackbirds.—Last Wednes- day army after army of blackbirds flew [Vol. 84, No. 2169 over Aline, headed north. The advance guard was about a half-mile long and fiy- ing in lines or files reaching from the Rock Island to the Orient track. The sec- ond flew in column formation and was fully three-quarters of a mile long. At intervals of from fifteen minutes to an hour all through the forenoon patches and squares of birds followed. A conservative estimate of the number that passed during the fore- noon would be five hundred thousand. The birds flew very low, and their wings and chattering could be heard at a great dis- tance.—Kansas City Journal, April, 1905. From birds the student may, if he choose, pass to Bostonians, and wrestle with the fellowing extract on page 76: The Early Bostonians.—The Bostonians, almost without exception, are derived from one country and a single stock. They are all descendants of Englishmen; and of course are united by all the great bonds of society: language, religion, government, manners, and interests.—Timothy Dwight, “Travels in New England and New York,” vol. i., 506. By stages he will advance from the sim- pler problems of social elements to the more complicated questions of social or- ganization and welfare, until he finishes “a fairly complete scheme of elementary in descriptive and _ historical sociology."" The value of it all we shall leave to those who have the courage to try it; the belief of the editor is that such exercises keep the student’s mind “alert to discover essential similarities be- tween facts drawn from widely different sources.”” readings Professor, now also Sir, William M Ramsay has collected under the title ““Pau- line and Other Studies” (A. C. Armstrong & Son) some fifteen essays ranging from “Shall We Hear Evidence or Not?’ to “Life in the Days of St. Basil the Great’’— papers which, with one exception, have al- ready seen the light in various British re- views. The title is inexact and the unity of character in the studies slight. The il- lustrations which accompany the text are new. The Rev. Dr. Morgan Dix, rector of Trinity Church of this city, has earned the gratitude of all who are interested in the history of New York, as well as those who concern themselves with ecclesiastical mat- ters, by his careful completion of his “‘His- tory of the Parish of Trinity Church in the City of New York,” of which volumes iii. and iv. are now published (G. P. Putnam's Sons). The period covered in these two vol- umes is from 1816, the year in which John Henry Hobart began his able leadership of the parish, to 1862, when the author of this history was inducted to the rectorship. The history of Trinity Parish is in large part the history of the Episcopal Church in the city and State of New York, since up to 1830 the offices of Bishop of the Diocese and Rector of Trinity Parish were filled by the same person. Moreover, Bishop Hobart was a man of national influence, whose ser- the Church in general Dr. not overestimated. The ex- tended bounty of Trinity is tradi- tional, and the recital of applications granted and accepted has obliged the au- thor to touch upon religious situations of great variety and extent. Dr. Dix has been thorough in his search for documents and careful in their use, and his work will be invaluable to students of the matters with which it deals. As to outward form vices’ to Dix has

Page 17

Jan. 24, 1907] these volumes leave nothing » be ] sired, either in dignity, taste yr serv ableness Ten lectures on the origin, mutual rela tion, and historical value of the four Gos pels and the history of their adoption into the canon, delivered in the spring of 1906 by F. Crawford Burkitt at the Passmor Edwards Settlement in London, and, or the author’s election to the Morrisian Pro fessorship of Divinity at Cambridge, rs peated as his inaugural course, are put lished under the title “‘The Gospel H and its transmission’’ (Charles Scribner's Sons) The volume evinces ripe scl ship and good critical judgment The priority of Mark is maintained and the construction of the framework of Christ's life, according to the Marcan account, is attempted, with some original and valu- able suggestions The theory tha M cion is the real source of the doctrine that Christ’s death was a ransom to the devil which was for many centuries the received teaching, is made quite plausible “The Psychology and Training of th Horse,” by Count Eugenio Martinengo Cesaresco, has been imported by Charles Scribner’s Sons The author devotes a considerable portion of his book to a dis cussion of the mind of the horse, and al though he uses the pretentious term ‘‘psy he starts with the generally ac- ‘the horse is endow- chology,”’ cepted statement that ed with fair intelligence within the range of ideas allowed by his mental constitution While describing the mo- of the animal the author mingles a considerable of instruc- advice; and many pages comes to the conclusion that “every horse according to his mental nature, sen- sibility, intelligence, and his physical qual- is more or less adapted to a particu- lar In truth, al- though the author has prepared a readable book, under a title indicating an entirely original treatment of the subject, he is forced back to certain facts proved by the long experience of many horsemen. The horse must be trained by teaching him the use of the various implements and aids When he has learned that by obedience he meets with kindness and that through failure to comply he incurs resistance or punishment, his training proceeds smooth- ly To this extent he may be said to rea- son, but in the main the horse is absolutely a creature of habit An entire chapter is devoted to fear, its causes and amelioration, but after all is said and sights and unaccustomed sounds arouse sus- picion and fear in all animals; punishment generally fails to remove it, and, not in- and faculties tives and habits amount after tion and wise ities, use or employment.”’ a done, strange frequently, increases and fixes it as a habit while patience and kindness will nearly al- ways enable an animal of limited reasoning powers to overcome acute fear of things which do not actually injure it. The final chapter on the use of the bridle and curb bit is not up to the standard of accurate knowledge, and detailed instruction of the cavalry schools of America, France, Ger many, Austria, or the very efficient estab lishment in the author’s own country “Behind the Scenes With Wild Animals,’ by Ellen Velvin (Moffat, Yard & Co.) will appeal to the lover of the sensational, as it consists of a heterogeneous collection of The Nation. m lotes deta gz ha breadth escapes f anima sundry bitings end i h 2 ij 1 a 1a The autl ha ir } tain inter g i I y which was ‘ y . 8a ynal \ r hem ! . f 4 ' . rp! ‘ | ] : I i Ww i ! ‘ a lote 1 b A i} ip ‘ : reader's ; J 4 , ‘ ; ’ fa « I x \ il ac? isting \ t of v p es of am “ h hav t 1 aptivity T photograp fa 8 y | KR. San- ] ' Ss ar \ Cathedrals and ¢ if } = h f France: Gascony, Proven Langue Elise Whitlock Ros with j i ons from original p) graph by Vida Hunt Francis, i led vo vo by G. P. Putnam's Sor This work a s to illur th 1 tray It s no cl cal ind } tor 1 side not very systema Ye the author preserves 1 just sense of pr The churches f the ancient maritime provi: f south France are, of cours t to be com- pared for ze or magnificence with the athedrals of the North Purity of design is to be found in only a few of them, and in spite of the audacity with which some of their builders ventured to combi: fea tur f iif t igi the structures show comparatively little origi nality Many of them, especially those among the foothills of the Pyrenees, were long ago reduced from cathedrals to parish churches But the makers of th two beautiful volumes have discovered other merits and a manifold charm in the wilful perversions of style, and have read a mov- ing story of ecclesiastical ambition and popular heresies, and finally national indif- ference, in the battered and mouldering walls But few cathedrals of the South are of commanding size, as Bayonne, Rodez, and Auch Perhaps not one, unless it be Bayonne, is regular in style. Many, espec ially if we include those which have lost their former diocesan @ignity, are very small, as the forsaken relics at Digne, Senez, and Saint Papoul. Quaintness and confusion, rather than any claim to artis- tic excellence, characterize the edifices at Toulouse and Rieux The interest of the ithedral at Carcassonne is almost pure- ly romantic, depending on its picturesque wonderful town and on The Was aS much a sfa- elevation above that itsassociations with the wars of religion building at Maguelonne mark and watch-tower as a church, and the forbidding walls of the cathedral of Albi were intended largely for defence The high-perched fanes of Entrevaux and Sis- teron, approached over drawbridges and up chiefly precipitous streets, are remarkable for situation Yet all these peculiarities are elements of a charm which is amply transmitted in these volumes. The author struggles rather helpl« ly with general historical and archmological questions in the opening pages, and is often uncertain and inexpert in th of language, but manages nevertheless, with the help of many fine illustration to convey the charm Not by the law of 19096, but by the withdrawal of faith, have these churches ' of the Pyrenees and the Mediterraneaa been left desolate In he Comparative Stud Nursery Rhymes” (Duckworth & Co), I a Eoke stein aspires neithe to exhaustiveness of eat t nor fina v i { at } \V Ti | afie ] f s! ‘ ‘ y ) shy much that neaninef and worthy ¢ attent f 1d ! 1 the spa f twoh Ired pag ery rhyn | | and } por i ngs handed low 4 em ymes and ballad y da s and ga ym rhymes and riddle rhym iulative pleces, chant f numbers ant ! hants on } 1 sa fi Of actua mp he mak« ‘ ast f } ’ ad i 1 ; ' * any f t? i irativ rd when wr £.¢ g f ga j illy Wa Drop t Handk I f fa | n v i riage-tf I i H I 4 I iH Tha Jack Bu ha ley lf r ency on rey i i i Of i appea ) " to naking and un h of sy like h han f i ‘ ind of tt} ia by } in nded ’ y i rh para lels to tl f n La ! Spa Ca ada, et i es ully fj ting The book is a who ; Wwe arranged and readable } sid al A nN ) Ik al knowle ige We are gratef fo the of foreign authorities and if he tlo f nu ry rhyme i h los ‘ order I \ 4 f he i t fw h Basq inguage studen " i th nging to light t DD J le | ] n the Fran an mvent of Zarauz rf Obras Va yngada Basqu works) of Joanne D'Etcheberr Th writer f whom but litth s know wa born at Sare, in the itry of t I t Basques n he at half of th even teenth century His exa lat i i tain, as the registers ar ipert H lived for a time in h at R practising as a phy an Ir ‘ ) reason or other we find } " g France and settling in Spain He supposed to have died there in 1749 Ww) at Sar he began a dictionary of four languages Basque, Spanish, F h, and Latin This is mentioned by the cholar Larramendi but is now lost, if indeed it ever was fin shed. The manuscript discovered by Don Urquijo belongs to the same period (circa 12) It is written in the Labourdin dia “ } admitted to be the best, and neis of two distinct parts, (a) the Rudi m f Basque (b) the Rudiments of Latir The second he intended as sup; me » the dictionary, believing thatLa tained the roots of all the languages rhese works, with Spanish notes and duction by Don Urquijo, make up a Vo ime of some three hundred pages qua: rhe publisher is Paul Geuthner, P In our review last week of tI Ha j Studies in Classical Philology we mig have noted that the volume (No. xvi.) was intended, in the w yrds of I i ‘ a token of affection and ¢ m f ment Lawrence Smith, of the t f is for thirty-four years a valued member f the department, but for 1 by hea

Page 18

SS 4 The Nation. [ Vol. 84, No. 2169 y Po Prof | t f | and inevitabl truggl Everywhere to the Rio Grande. On the whole, both Ty- have been pointed out the dark and | ler and Polk pass this new scrutiny with VI ¢ Ox le machinations of the slave power, and | enhanced redit Clay’s standing is not ’ , : Lp »where more strikingly than in the case of | raised, however, nor Buchanan’s, while ' rH ! annexation of Texas and the Mexican | neither Scott nor Taylor add to their mili- VI ( we) r—topi which naturally occupy a/| tary laurels. We have no space to dwell pro | minent place in Professor Garrison's | on these or other interesting points, how- ¢ | volur It one of the sp il merits of ever, and can only commend the book as : , Prof ” Garrison's book that, without | a thoughtful and scholarly study of a pe- ng the true importance of slavery | riod which has long needed impartial ex- \ period with which he deals, he has | amination p ed himself from bondage to a conven _ a , | theory which, however stimulating | The Records of the Virginia Company of R ' ynally 3 a i whole both insuffi London. The Court Book, from the Man- , ied B ent and misleading, and has taken a po- | uscript in the Library of Congress. With Maw ’ . i n more in harmony with the facts an introdugtion and bibliography by Su- 4 . Prof 1 Garrison's view. the under- | san Myra Kingsbury Vol. I Washing- isan ! fq mpul n the United States, from | ton. Pp. 636, facsimiles 0 to 1800, Ww rial pansion; and | After the lapse of nearly two centuries, rt Uxtord plan territorial expansion inevitably in- the Court Book of the Virginia Company f to | produced lved a ettlement of the conflicting | of London, 1619-1622, is printed in full for forgo : SP n f slavery and freedom in the new the first time. The romantic history of regions of the West, Southwest, and North- | the manuscript is known to scholars Oxford. 1 lavery was a secondary, and not 4] Hastily prepared by some members of the l ' nit primary, influence in determining the new company who knew that their actions as 1 as the regius and r rial policy. The working out of this | members of the company would be subject f rf has resulted in a volume some parts | to hostile examination, it passed from Eng- I Oman, ¢ prot r of En : { which are positive additions to hitherto | Jand to America, and through the pur- K I l owl vailable knowledge; while the use of man- chase of the library of Thomas Jefferson be know t tu ript material—a rare thing in this se- | came into the Library of Congress It is uy ' j t I in the archives of Texa ind Mexico | the transcript of a lost original, and is H la Bry newly appo 1 well as at Washington, gives additional | jtself only a fragment; but as material : ’ 7 I | ght to his conclusions The author is | of history its value cannot be too highly " , i , it his best, we think, in exhibiting the | estimated It is one of the earliest rec- 1 to graj " itu ) | he to great events rather than in| ords of English colonization in America, ! rf fleld ga lescribing those events themselves Thus | and it is one of the earliest and fullest but from f th ve have illuminating chapters on the be- | official records of the transactions of a in and ich H Stud Atla ginn of the Texas question, the Texas | trading and colonizing corporation, active | Geography lou boundary controversy, and the diplomatic | at a time when such corporations were us ’ a negotiation for annexation, as well as on | clothed with governmental functions, ex- work, 1 ty h nnexation itself. Two later chapters tell | ercising in an imperfect manner what it ) ! » comn l the ry of the rupture with Mexico and |! properly belonged to the Royal Govern- ‘ f 1 t ! Slidell mission—both of them rather | ment Hence these experiments were doom- Ls r pe ' where lected tople while the military opera- |} ed to failure No monopoly could sustain i W geographic have ons of the war are rather summarily dis- | them, and> the very features which seem- | f | The Atla : vid po l of The history of the Wilmot pro ed to confer strength, the features of self- rr and p ila i Berg o, with its divisive effect on both Dem- | government and protected interests, proved M ’ , 1 Aly with at ind Whig parties, gains signifil- | their weakness Whether the trade was - h has g e by considering the territorial as well with Muscovy, Africa, the Levant, or p lency of the British Al h lavery aspects of it. The adjust- | America, there came a time when a lit- , \ ‘ t meeting f th ! t of tl Oregon difficulty was a less | tle competition proved the futility of ( b va non ited iplicated matter, with even more re | granting exclusive privileges, when a dim- that body mot onnection with slavery while the | inution§ of profit awakened dissensions 7 , Maine boundary dispute stands by itself, within the company, and when the King, llustrat n its limited field, | deprived of his expected royalties, saw fit } prevailing demand for territory to interfere and revoke the charter. Equally uggestive, if not always at The Virginia Company was no more suc- first ght equally convincing, is Profes- | cessful than other like ventures; and were Garrison exposition of the party situ- the Court Book for its entire existence as { i ORY " n and the motives and conduct of party | a company available, the peculiar as well id Both the character and the /|as the general causes of its decline could " . : men of Tyler are exhibited in a | be described Fragmentary as this printed we ; h mo favorable light than has cus volume is, the contents are conclusive up- ’ i i f rily been the case For example, in on the crisis which led to the dissolution of s G idable volume | i of condemning Tyler for his breach | the company. Any person who paid or ad- f hanging h the Whig Professor Garrison credits | ventured £12 10s. became a member, as did I fr ' cholar toward the him with honesty and courage, declines to | also those to whom a share had been given ! f f I ! n the period vd juds him guilty of untruthfulness in | for services. As the membership increased, Vith few excey , bank matter, and points out that his | the actual management fell into the hands ! ! was only what was to be ex of a small number of the more active or ! i " “| from a tanch believer in State | influential members Some of their acts h f ref t ' ght For Polk, too, whose invaluable | were undoubtedly oppressive. It was diffi- ' ' | | manuscript diary he has used, he has de- | cult to control the colonists, whose lot ' wit) mp } . f f e and idiciou ommenda mn. The ex was by no means a happy one, at so long ! " mand fr ! } yf ict status of the Texas boundary was dim 1 range, when the length and expense of a hadow backward r the cul if not possible, to determine, but voyage prevented frequency and regular- itely p ling years as to make j t the evidence adduced by Professor Garri ity of sailings Differences in Virginia i h every vent in regard to which ¢ mm goes far to acquit Polk of the charge | were carried to London, and the proper at- North and the South wert of differe of deliberately instigating an invasion of | tention to settlements could not be given minds seem but another step towards the | Texas when he ordered Taylor to advance | in a body which was too large for executive

Page 19

Jan. 24, 1907] The Nation. RSH efficiency, and was itself shif g it ym f : pos on th ig tl £ 4 ] i pia A of members Discor W iwalk } \i factions formed 1 t Xu oppose 1 « matters vt l { iffairs was tirely } per Wha ipl be il ! t of grea n t b I \ ence rf } f 77 4 { liscontents und he 1 . i to set a hearing la y I XK vances were very i i \ \ their ffe« the 1 fuine of the co | y \ the I il 4 ) f va tobacco, que o of ) ind e in Eng 1 w mat 1 ff ( It wa egarded I hibit the pl g of t ) I i | 1 Wa s t to l f } K exche required ne nN ! ' ; ma ot t . ‘ il I iT ] he \ nial yeed wa i f \ ‘ ! t company nor to the King’s custo I hopes of introducing vines, « of estal » ndustries by ind ng | led come from Cont ntal | ype \ i ‘ l to hye } say pointe 1 ~ h ; } " ' ‘ peted with the Virginia | rf I i proffered monopoly in tobacco cou : , = I m le good ind he ile ot } I M l rue y Ided uncerta i \pal from it iding act e \ . ginia settlem«é must b ) ' plied with fresh blood and even foo nding of ship st lone ind | I , ! ) of th vovage of the Gif the , 14 Landsmen and three i nas » tl two children was borne it ea & d ] , : ' ‘ nd at ! there ar il finding the Plan , ta I » be 1 great scare \ ul | ne lesired the company to beare w ’ - him, if for this yeare } mn 1ing 1 ect f ed the planting of Tobacco, and follow the ving of corne w he by ! i | veare he hop by tl ble ng of G t h r ( pp hereof } } } Plantacon shall have noe greate cause to H } comp aine ha of war The put re and the Oollege land i fo f 1 t I ist be cul ated a I f ‘ ot ! j the ympany Bad managemet ] S101 ind even dishonesty, re ilted i t t tle returns These various difficul acted upon the home company As a | ! é i ture of administrative problems this reco f can hardly be surpassed in interest pay tribute H 1 It remains to say a word on the execution Hert t a of this publication The editor introdu me tion and bibliography have already beer i praised in these columns To s ! th - I essential accuracy of text, the original w , first deciphered by Miss Kingsbury and ir ; lependently by the manuscript div ym of : the Library of Congres The re ilt w _ . / . anted this care. Every detail of the text Penny as A 1a titl if even to erased words and letters 3 repr come fi . duced so far i type can reproduce } ] ; . and = the very ¢ or f he co 1 t Ma ' noted. The labor involved een by glar which at " H i ing at the pages of the Court Record re erved It embo ! f : produced in facsimile The large type American life, t bou I a G K Q generous margin and fine paper ! ea hem Mr. PI ! t Ly j I 11 mo lignified volume but these mec} ‘ h ! f ! xf . wa matte e of secondary importan The . real matter of moment that so exter ‘ f} ire HH } t of I ! in undertaking can be carried to | ce ful ar sue by the Library of Congress He ‘ } id his bed | t f Ww ind printed as a Government publicatior ketching of pe. { t which An Hist , ” Som M It marks once more the appearance of a howeve Aoubtlese j e we morable Ac ns Particularly in Virgia

Page 20

~ ~~ 6 " Also | Against the Admiral of Algier, | ind in the East Indies Perform’d for he Service of his| Prince and Country, | By | Sr Thomas Grantham, Kt | (Quotation, es] London Printed for J. Roberts, i he Oxford-Arms in Warwick-Lane MDCCXVI rh wo ! ns n to be identical, x | for th title-page ind it is prob , hat the new title was made by some g printer or bookseller in order » a ate the al f the pamphiet i loubt that th nd title con- iin large typ he words “Particu i Virg i nuch th more at- ra ve I'he ewly d ve 1 1714 edition ind ft! f } 1716 edition are pag pa und th x s, with a few xceey . ! f } The headings of vario lo ! p 1 in italics, are ! fo I title leaf of the 1714 lit he fi leaf of the signature and , ious with its follower A‘ howing that this is the original rh lat late f any document i 1 in the book July 10, 1711 The ibility is that the book in either form had practically no sale, most of the copies ig very Iikely disposed of as old paper On Monday, January 28, the Merwin- ym Sales Company of this city offers ! mn i private t iry miaining f ed is of Ame in authors fu half bindir rr calf or ) Amon e wi a! Bret H yhn Hay, Hawthorn Longfellow 1’ ind Whitt Among o r books iH ! Linecol h Story of a Great Life three volumes, the original i e which wa uppressed, is perhaps the most n ible Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge of London will hold In the early spring an auction of t small but choice collection formed with in recent years by a member of the New York Stock Exchange’ Some of the books notably a first folio of Shakespeare, are from the Rowfant Library There are sev eral early Shakespeare quartos, including The Merchant of Venice 1637, which brought $1,300 at Anderson's auction rooma n this city last May, and Midsummer Night Dream,”’ 1600, which brought £480 it Sotheby's a year ago There is a copy of Sidney's “Arcadia,”’ 1590, which sold for £450 at Sotheby's in 1905 The library ilso contains a fine example of the first Kilmarnock” Burnes Lay / folarum lies. BRraami Roterodami wnitwm « ivetvm per P. 8 ! VM \ Coll. Corporis Christi j ! is4 i vew York Henry I ‘ More h yo centurte have elapsed, or ner tl half tl period following the leath of Kra i his correspondence is publ ! ) the completest collection then po t i volume til. of John Le cl folio Leyden edition of the “Opera Omota in 1703 Many cholara in many lands have felt impelled to the task achiev ed by Mr. Allen, and he has greatly profited by the communication of their interrupt ed enterprises,as well as by the ungrudging issistance of scholars and archivists By 0d fortune, a fellow-Oxonian, Francis Morgan Nichols of Wadham College sorking on parallel lines, has pub lished two noble volumes of “The Epistles The Nation. of Erasmus,” selectively translated, criti- cally set in order, and carried down to 1517, with a third volume well assured. Mr. Nichols, in his first volume, has made his acknowledgments to Percy Stafford Al- len of Corpus Christi College, Oxford, and now Professor in the Government College at Lahore, and foreshadows the appear- ince of the present ‘Opus Epistolar- um.”" Mr. Allen, on his part, tells of his enormous labor having “‘occupied my leisure for the last thirteen years,”’ and been carried on “under the gloom of Indian summers and in high valleys in Kashmir.” Mr. Nichols’s anticipatory publication is referred to (preface, p. v.), with counter acknowledgments of his having “given me | the full benefit of his ripe judgment and de- tailed study of the ground in which I have Seen allowed to glean after him.” This of Oxford moniously working spectack two men har- together to ends s0 creditable to their University, is heightened by the fact that their zeal might rather have been looked for in the sister Univer- | sity of Cambridge, seeing that Erasmus’s | stay in Oxford (at St. Mary’s College, in | 1499) was of the briefest On the other hand, Mr. Allen may have found an incen- tive in the fact that, after the founding of | Corpus Christi by Richard Foxe, one of Erasmus's correspondents, the latter mani- fested great interest in what was intend- } ed to be “the seat of the new learning.” We must add that the amicable coédperation described above has been consistent with | ent cholarly independence, as maniicst- d by the later comer Thus, Mr. Allen splits in two the letters numbered 119 and 128. to James Batt, though Mr. Nichols de- fends their conjunction; per contre, he re- place it the head of the letter (254) to Thomas Halsey sentences which Mr. Nich- ols had clapped on the end of another Again, they differ as to the date of lette; 193, to Christopher Urswick; while a cor- responding disagreement in the case of let- ter Sl, to William Herman, leads Mr. Al- len to question Mr. Nichols’s inferences as to persons therein alluded to For a final example, doubts about the attribution to Erasmus determine Mr. Allen to relegate to the appendix letters admitted by Mr. Nica ols to full inding in the regular sevci« rhe amount of Erasmian correspon dence available since Le Clere's gleanings has not been so considerable as might be thought, and leaves a vista for still further di very In Mr Allen's table of the letters to date of his volume i., there are but twenty-seven pieces not included in the Leyden edition; only four are here publish- ed for the first time, whereof only three proceed from Erasmus’s pen. Of these last, one is a mere fragment, bearing the prob- ible date of 1489, and written from Steyn to that indefatigable author, Corneliua Gerard of Gouda, exhorting him to perfec- tion of style in matter worthy of pos terity Another, derived from the Gouda find of MSS., and addressed to John Colet (Oxford, 1499), supplements by three times its length that opening of the ‘“Disputa- tiuncula’’ which Le Clere published in 1703 It is a labored reinforcement of the argu- ment which had failed to convince Colet in the dispute over the proper interpretation | Vol. 84, No. 2169 in response to Colet’s rejoinder, and is a capital example of Erasmus’s mode of rea- soning. One proposition of his, which no longer cuts a figure in the theological wrangling of the present day, is that Christ, as man, must have died some time, and not necessarily from violence. Not a few minds might now be almost as much shocked by this thought as by the theory suggested by a diplomat at The Hague in the Revolutionary epoch, viz., that, in view of the imperfections of this world, God must have died before completing hia work The interest of the debate over “Let this cup pass’’ is made more piquant by the fact that Colet advances the au- thority of Jerome, Erasmus’s great teacher, and is parried by the contention that this saint’s exegesis was a solitary utterance in his writings, while Augustine and other hold the meaning of Christ’s simple language Among the letters discovered and published other scholars, notably M. de Nolhac, since Le Clerc, it will suffice to mention Erasmus’s first to Aldus Manu- tius, the known example of his handwriting, two other examples of which; by the way, are among the plates inserted in the text. lights to of the equal common-sense view by earliest The period covered by Mr. Allen’s first is in the Leyden edition, by prefixing to the correspondence of his literary begin- nings and self-discipline, and detailed list of his writings, addressed to John Botzheim referred as the “Cata- of date January 30, volume overstepped, as Erasmus’s account and commonly to logue of Lucubrations,”’ 1523. This invaluable list, far as it is available for biographical the chief end of Mr. Nichols’s undertaking, he chronologically in 80 purposes, introduces piecemeal translation (e. g., I., 227 Next comes the Compendium Vite,” which Mr. Nichols translates in full (1., 5), and which cannot antedate 1516; and, finally, the letter from Beatus Rhenanus V. of 1, 1540. It is gratifying to find that the genu- ineness of the disputed “Compendium,” as well as of the letter to Servatius Rogerus of July 8, 1514, is maintained by both our Ox- ford editors; by Mr. Allenwith a shade more of positiveness. The latter’s apparatus is as Each letter by a more or less particular description of it as a document and with reference to its prop- in the sum affording a disconnected of Erasmus’s goings and comings and doings; and, in the case of to Charles June is introduced follows: er place in the series view first mention, a summary sketch of the cor- respondent, either writing or addressed. The pains bestowed on these elucidations, rich in bibliographical guide-posts, it would not be easy to over-praise; nor will the future biographer of Erasmus ever speak except gratefully of this blazing of his path. The footnotes exhibit the same scholarly temper and patience. They are the repository of variant readings; they identify persons imperfectly indicated in the text, and trace their biographies—the more carefully the the sub- ject; they endeavor to fix dates and events; more obscure they track to their source classical and other allusions and quotations; they take notice of such minor matters as, in Eras- mus’s letters to Batt, of his frequent use of the phrase fato tuo, with a “lucky-dog” connotation Together, the introductions of Christ's shrinking from death, instead of seeking it with alacrity The third letter, much the longest of the three, is notes afford an agreeable browsing- and

Page 21

Jan. 24, 1907] The Nation. ground, not only for Erasmians, but for any one of scholarly proclivities interested in the period. Equally readable and inform- ing are the appendices with the broader topics of authenticity, with several of Erasmus’s correspondents, the principal editions of the “Epistol#,”’ the letter-book, and the Gouda MSS. The above apparatus speaks to the eye, dealing Deventer and may be estimated for the editor's industry by him who runs. The labor be- stowed upon the text, resulting inevitably in one just like no other, lurks out of sight and can be weighed only on reflection. For letters published in Erasmus’s lifetime the text of the London edition of 1642 af- ter Froben’s of 1538 and 1541 has been scrupulously compared with the earliest authorized. For the orthography, Mr Allen conforms faithfully to the earliest original source, except where depravations are manifestly e corrected; the punctu ation, on the other hand, has been freely improved. For facility of reference in foot notes and otherwise, the text is numbered for every five lines. A temporary index of correspondents and some biographical no tices, supplied on a loose leaf, will bs superseded by a full one in the second vol ume To expatiate further were easy, but our readers can readily dispense with it The fortunate possessors of Mr. Nichols’s two volumes will not rest content without Mr Allen’s, which enables one to test the fidelity and closeness of his coadjutor’s homely idiomatic version, as well as to ascertain the ipsissima verba in any given All all experts will monumental libraries will both instance require, as laud, these publications. Historical Bases of Religion, Primitive, Baby lonian, and Jewish. By H. C. Brown. Bos ton: Herbert B. Turner & Co. $1.50 dangers This book the that beset the non-specialist in dealing with is an example of large questions. The author has consulted a number of excellent books, and much that he says is correct, particularly in his ac- count of the later phases of Judaism, from the prophets onward. But throughout the volume the wrong is so mingled with the right, and there is such a distortion (doubt less unintentional) of the history, that the general reader may often get an impression not in accordance with the facts Mr Brown’s tone is one of assurance and final- ity—he is certain of many things to which the best authorities are in doubt. He knows not only that the Babylonian civil- ization is earlier than the Egyptian, but that its records go back about 8,500 years, and that well-developed states, enjoying a civilized life that far outranks that of many so-called civilized countries of the present day, were in existence more than ten thou- sand years ago (p He is able scribe the furniture of a Babylonian temple (p. 102f.) with a minuteness not found the records, and to assert (p. 213) that Babylonia for a period of more than five thousand years existed as a homogeneous people, contented and happy under a system of government and religion practically un- changed. As to the origin of the Essenes, 4 question that still vexes scholars, he has no misgivings—he states as an historical fact that their practices were derived from Buddhism as 50) to de- in In addition to these exaggerations and discolorations the book has misstatements of important points. The language of pre Israelite Canaan was not Babylonian (p. 79) th> contrary is shown by the Amarna let ters That the mo theis leas of Ju- daism were lerived fr I x of Zoroaster’’ (p. 173) i sta hat 1 judicious critic w j “ a} The lea that the Semitic divine nat Be El, Baal and Al are all ght var fthe same word” (p. 166) will be a | » Sem scholars. Still more remarkat tl ‘ nouncement (p 1) that tl f the deity of the Israelitish nation wa and for it “the name Jehoval ! , ) was substituted’; and ‘ \ deity “to whom the name A ! hie one) was given Pa ng over the hithert unheard-of explanati if the mea iz of Jehovah . it s strange that t? never heard of the name Yahwetl i tha he is not aware that our word Jel ! the ignorant miswr gx of a friar f ! sixteenth century of our era as for \l lah,”’ it was the current name for the deity in Arabia in Mohammed's t S l | weaken one’s confidence in the author's general trustworthinse It must be lded that he is concerned to ww that the old Hebrew religion wa lerived, o t er ide wholly from tl Bat " It generally agreed tha ! Ba in i fluence on the Hebrews w gr t " proper estimate of Het ) and Judaism call for wider knowledge ind a ner and more judicial attitud ! ul found in this volume The Practice of Diplomacy A I l the Foreign Rel ) of the United States By John W Fr B loughton Mifflin & Co $ ( This is a pleasing ensibl book It not om haf ind ! prehensive treatis« a i t of runt comment on the history of Am in diplo macy, bringing out i guiding pr pie ind its technique, and giving an abundan of those best of al! definitior example Throughout, a high note of national obliga tions in international relations is maintain ed; and while Mr. Foster is careful to give both sides of several of our famou liplo matic controversies is in the Barrund case, for instance, and the f eal dispu he makes it clear that his own leaning is to justice rather than cleverne and to sound precedent more han no t vented ad ho In dealing with the arti ficial distinctions of diploma rank, Mr Foster displays great common sens at well as an American love of equality; and we could wish that his plea for absolut impartiality in the treatment of itional representatives however ds gnated i of nations themselves, might prevail In what he says of the unexpended and legitimately unexpendable balance of the indemni ex torted from China by the United States in common with other countr he points out an imperative duty of Congr It should vote to pay back the money, with as zealous a care for “the honor of the United States” as it showed in returning to Mexico the award fraudulently obtained under the Weil and La Abra claim If one were to pick flaw at all, it would be in regard to some of the refe ces tO Europe an practice ar ! sONnAa strate the point tl gula , s ofte prod y ri peaks f tt I Duff a f ! ( ‘ t i ; 8 t ‘ \ who WwW t t and fT i f tl KB h@G i qua f ! tt VW hink ha | 1 oOo | Rot M \ 1 at 1) I f al ‘ t w ha t i 1 ! liy i Mr I I ' eff | el f dij na He 1 i ‘ f i) [ t gat I rhe y ! ‘ ib l t hat vt t ‘ ! I ‘ i} 1 } ‘ I ‘ I Lew Watla in Aw phy p y k: H & B $ I i t grapopy { l Wa ‘ tI ' iry } i y) i 1 i i f ju iack f proper biography | per « ‘ nA ! r {r 1 tt j ! nu I I i | l ry a i V I 1 nco 1 I Wal ” ha i i | » i \\ t t 4 I )) lif NY I ‘ » | ) il t t hay i ! ryday hap] eat i i i i 1 } nl vt A t ‘ i \\ “ i itl i a i } ] ler I k il f x Hi ga ‘ ! litary pert ng f M I Wil idm t i wide acquainta g 1 fw personal ay 4 I cE I ve he xi i s | heard o of l) let and rh tab ; ‘ I uf novei The | if ir W hi great op, hie k charge of the enlistu i t of the Indiana lun mad onel of one of the new | hed h way » promin ea vw eandt it ful it at i¢ time joined Gr t i ! W brigadier-general He t + i apture of Fort He and | ind im the battle of Shilol I biography goes much into det these several operatior b movements as a whole and as to own share in them. We must leave itary critics the final judgment course at Shiloh, merely noting r oe) , \ a \ i “ } | ) ( ‘ ‘ ) ’ that i } } “ ' ol Mi ‘ i j 2 M i ) igt 1, how Re | ; | peara i er ! " ' iin 1 | i God ent and y ‘ ig i ) to ipou his that his

Page 22

Nation. rates The ‘ he ¢ } elaborately ‘ 1 in the community now suffer- Wal P € fa e } . P ' h a calamity Of more perma- withd fro é possibly ire the chapters \ " ! bing the relations between the races, , ft help I mixed hostility and mutual under- } , of the white and black regiments | the author quotes the views egro o1 iltimate inde H t e fo Jam , This man, who had ( i ed in England and on the Continent, | ig I } 1 what would be yme of the half- I I gov ment mntrolled chiefly th " replied ingeniously They } } Follow Drama. UC DERMANN'’S JOHANNES I ! I Hit il ibject for obvious reasons } ! n dear to the heart of the had w f ' I iger, and the chance of pro- lalou ensation under cov- it New Testament name is too , H It is to be regretted that ' who have done so much work a M Julia Marlowe and H. Ss ! 1ould have been tempt- of otoriety of the theme to pro 7 ‘ M y Harned’s adaptation of Suder- " ! Johannes,” a piece which on | f ptural or pseudo-historical side } tl 1ctual artistic value, while r f hief motives, the Salome legend, i he ibominabl« The play is } ! ! Baptist,’’ and purports to the prophet’s public life; ! in the wilderness, proclaim- ! mine Me iah, in the streets of " lebating with the Pharisees, lenouncing Herodias, in purning the odious solicitations of the hand of the execu- n the seenes with which ! ried to upplement the | | f Bil il reeord that the interest of H } | collapses John is represented ‘ | . sta loubt as to the sig- ; , f e of h own inspiration and as 1 by ih fragments of Christ's he Sermon on the Mount, for aq , he ean collect from the lips , ; Galilean peasants. The command | ir enemi works such an up | n him that instead of throwing it the guilty Herod, and thus giv- he nal for a general attack, he monarch’'s feet His vacillat- irives } disciples from him, : _ Dp illy deserted when he is ( ii p mm ; plausibility there may be in ractions of the prophet, : loubt hat their result is l virile and picturesque ' figu il purposes. At all events, ' y | fa 1 » endow him with the fire, grandeur of spirit, or maj ; , ming a prophet with such ty { ‘ | ’ m He had dignity and some right- l h n, but he did not glow with the ' = ha ! f ! ind consuming zeal. In his , ' _ Ben ‘ lome he bore himself rightly, } pa P fir with Iifference, then with angry ' 5 of the | re ‘ but no skill could interpret satis ' in thelr very essence un I I k. a espe i I iral and repulsive Wholly apart from res, Will satisfy the average read the gross improbablility of a delicate young s! ' popula i ilmost a child, such as Salome | there is the radical absurdity of the condi | | Vol. 84, No. 2169 is represented to be, conceiving a passion for a man of so rough and wild an aspe tions under which they meet—conditions which could never occur in the East. Sim ilar objections would lie against the whol play,which rarely makes any concessions to Oriental customs, except in the matter t attire Miss Marlowe, in her acting of Sa lome, a part for which she is not now suit- ed, seemed to be constantly trying to miti gate the unpleasantness of it by emphasiz ing its juvenility. She portrayed a petulant childish coquette This view, of cours was utterly incompatible with an adult pas sion which could drive a princess to such extremes All the details indeed of this love episode are as preposterous as t! original conception is vile But it is to be noted that the play follows the Biblical story with regard to Herodias and does not permit Salome to sport th the Bapt head. With Salom« sat play would b but a dull affair She is the chief excus for the representation, and a very bad one The cause of the American drama is no much advanced by the ymposition and production of such pieces as ‘‘Salomy Jane which was greeted with much boisterous approval in the Liberty Theatre, on Sat urday evening. Paul Armstrong, the adapt er, or rather joiner, has selected his rough material from “‘Salomy Jane’s Kiss” and other tales of Bret Harte and dovetailed them, after a fashion, into a melodrama well stuffed with sensational episodes, but rickety in structure, incoherent in sub stance, and no more a reflection of real lif in California, or anywhere else, than a the distorted figures in a comic mirror. Bret Harte, with the genius of a true roman clothed many gross realities with a glam our of beauty, nobility, or pathos, divert ing attention from patent anomalies by some subtle and often disingenuous appeal to that common human sentiment which is ready to applaud the attribution of th noblest virtues to the most unlikely pos sessor of them The publication of Mr: Harte’s earlier stories was followed by a perfect epidemic of frontier plays in which homicidal adventurers, hard and rough as the rocks amid which they labored and fought, melted suddenly with exquisite ten- derness, while audacious hoydens, heedless of virtue or morals, proved themselves angels of grace and goodness. Of late the far Western play has again been coming into fashion, and doubtless there is a wide field for the dramatist in the primitive life upon the borders of civilization. But lit tle is to be gained by working anew the exhausted vein of Mr. Harte’s fancy, and reviving the personages, vital, indeed, in his pages, but on the stage stale, flat, and unprofitable. Moreover, Mr. Armstrong has furnished in his Col. Starbottle, Yuba Bill Jack Marbury, Larrabee, Red Pete, and the rest of them, feeble copies of their proto- types The fact is that these imaginary creatures necessarily lose their verisimili tude when stripped of their literary adorn ment, and exposed in their naked person ality before the footlights The succe attained by the present performance will be due to the admirable acting of Reuben Fox the capable work of H. G. Warner, Raiph Delmore, Holbrook Blinn, Stephen Wright Ade Dwyer, and Eleanor Robson. The forest

Page 23

Jan. 24, 1907] scenery is superb In fact, the setting is worthy of a masterpiece The death is announced in London of a once popular English actress, Miss Hud speth, better known in this country a Mrs. Edmund Phelps She will be remem bered for her finished women in some of Charles Wyndham’'s pro performances of old ductions She was born sixty-seven yea! ago, and first appeared in London in 18 She supported John Drew the elder “Handy Andy.”’ Later she joined the Drury and for many years was on: of was Lane Company of the chief attractions tomime, in which the Vokes family, Brittain the annual pan witt Het also in associated Paul was she Kate Wright; she of “Eileen Edmund F Santley ring, and the “The Peep o' Day’ play cast Oge’’—next original alconer's successful Sarah Bernhardt to Mephistopheles in a by is play the ps of Bataille new version being prepared Henry Musie. RICHARD SALOME STRAUSS’S The sensational event of the mus cal Metropolitan Opera House on Richard bee any most season was he production, at the Tuesday eve of Strauss’'s Salome a ning writ the h work which has n more talked and other Parsifal’’ f Cavalleria of ten about thar since first the opera production of in 1882, wit Rusticana that with exception 0 the « the And as in ise Mascagni, so in libretto had more to do the story ot Strauss of than the old vogue the It enormous book Some success opera musi« that to work of or a needed than that should forbid it Salome” is in insu! an for .a art nothing mors is responsible censor on was Ber came to the rescue religious grounds both however moral or thus forbidden in Vienna and in lin Dresden Salome’ was produced at the Royal Opera on December 8, 1905, and made a great stir Since then, thirty other opera houses (in cluding the Scala of Milan) have produced it, and even the Kaiser found it advisable to relent, so that Berlin, too, heard the opera on December 5, 1906, on which o¢ casion the house could have been sold out twenty times, and $25 was paid to specula for single seats Music itself moral, though it voke There come tors neither moral nor im be bad suicidal is may 80 as to pro murderous or reflections are pages in Strauss's score that but the the that condition of That “Salome” perilously near the censors not offence the libretto, the Wilde, concerning of which there It bad glorify in music were in of they cause eyes lay in of premeditated nasti be for adventures notorious Oscar the ness can no two opin ions is enough composers to the feel ings of such depraved creatures as Manon and Lescaut, and Violetta (in ‘“‘La Traviata’) but when a diseased imagination conceives a character like Salome, which can be fully comprehended only after a study of the psychopathological works of Krafft-Ebing and a musician makes her the heroine of an opera, it is time to call a halt, and pro test that the stage is not a sanitarium Such subjects are proper for medical, not f mus re ' ed that tt ‘ 2 8 x " he t and ¢ } act pe ” ’ Ss ? ’ i lly I y igekravate Perhaps wi g in I be i l fer » Name i h g rccompanied by a dram ‘ ‘ the if Tha phra A ‘ | S4 he t very we | he S ge i mpo i i x “ul their cor bu a a ger ire’ q R w i I excey I f ‘ | x t Salome ind ai few { ; f the prophet } ) ld help feeling ) f M excellen artis Fren ud \ Bu rian, Dippel, Van Rov i M Dufrict B for ha x 2 | Way through a jungl f ’ phonic with hardly a f “ly o offe 1 a he g t he ¢ of the listener rh weakness of Strau 1 explains his method Ni having ‘ melodies to offer, he doe all sort f ntric things to hide h weal He lemands an orchestra of at lea 106 play ers; he uses new or like the heckelphone and vd voc to nprecedented x it lividing the string instrument i ving ch little group a pa f " pla In the love du of r " 1 | ! Wagner divides h K x " part Straus goes him four t and thus makes an 1dvance i W agne He shows extreme btlety ind V Dn 4 n combining the various leading i v making them iZZ vd nd cene quite in the Wagner way But there Ss an enormous differ Vagne leading motives are pregnant theme ly remembered because of the king meludies or appropriate harmo where is Strauss has nothing to off but i x nificant themes—nay, themelets—so ym wnonplace and unindividual that it ex .emely difficult to recognize them In a word, in the orchestral as in the vocal parts, the fatal defect of Straus | 1 s a ‘ack of melody Students will find much 1dmire ! ngenious mathematical ibtileti« f he printed score Their abors may tated by a perusal of t! Guid 3 lome by Lawrence Gilma red y fohn Lane a little book f eighty-fiv page thirty of which are levoted to an analysis of the mus with illu ‘ } m al type of the twenty leading h write has tound in th Fate sometimes has strok ‘ 2s well as its irony In May, 148% here bur upon the world a ! i Cavalleria Rusticana by I Ma ig ni, which was hailed ill over Europe and \merica as the beginning of a new hoo and composer ! i few t va h and famous Six year I the Scala it Milan had produced an of i I \ which strikingly anticipated he hief cullarities of the Mascagr hoo but a the opera was not a (iia » I ‘ pa ly witl rea x heated f t t t “wt Z ’ t t I ’ M I a’ 1 th \ H York " . , ¢ potita ! Ma o followed. w ) th ope . vel Ma n I " before it he ’ i Zg company, wh ro d al ! 1 on ‘ x lrévos ) pare whole with Ma 8 on vA 1 t VW h (Ca I Gr . , rowd “ t ) y } } I ) i wi rat ine "| 1 j r ‘ re | fa ‘ ndivid P wr mo eff » tha ‘ ‘ ) Ver r Bell rt Phill ‘ I hay ) ! vill } . n Brat q i ¢ Brahm pl } pe ng t i! il t Russia ind | ty most po} K ‘ Hi mat Germa ! hh h ul i tf Grieg Ur i m of fo } prece p hed und } No p v befo more of the r h nperame Fa . > . iV Hall ex la f she w Beethover No , Schul cherzo ‘ ai by Choy étu hort p Pold M t ff besque Danube waltz The i growing den f ! ne ind the pia the Au in, Edward Ma th mn part, Breitkopf & have just brought ou the famous Kigh Song well as English i \rt THE PENNSYLYS 1A ( en nearl f ‘ M i it . ’ ‘ Hug i pl i | 4 h ’ qe CK whi p v ' ‘> I

Page 24

9O | Vol. 84, No. 2169 nes of widely varying size to hang on the | alier by John Lambert, two of Miss Cas- walls, and about one-fourth as many pieces of sculpture to place advantageously, the hanging committee for the current exhibi- tion of the Pennsylvania Academy of the Fine Arts seems for the most part to have performed well its arduous and thankless task Examples there are of the individual sacrificed for the good of the whole as perforce must always be the case in the ramped quarters of this ancient and hon- ble institution, which this year holds its hundred and second annual exhibition rhe corridors and rotunda, for example, in- dignified, as be- ead of being simple ar fils an approach, present a somewhat jum bled appearance Here are assembled, with no great regard for relative proportions low reliefs, busts, full-length life-size figures of man and beast—indeed ilmost everything that would lend itself the plastic art, not to mention sundry Gaudens, Lopez McKenzie, things that do not St ronetti, Konti, Grafly Roth McNeil, Pratt, Bitter, Hartley, Brooks, and aul Nocquet, not to prolong the distin- xuished list, are represented by from one twenty examples apiece, which for the most part would lend dignity and beauty to he art of any country Thus emphasis once more, and from the _ sculptor’s point of view, given to the importance of more adequate and better lighted exhibi tion galleries in Philadelphia, whose needs this respect are only less pressing than hose of New York city Unlike the passing displays of the Na mal Academy of Design and the past lisplays of the Society of American Artists New York, the show in Philadelphia is not made up of what may be justly called the current art of the year, but, wisely or inwisely, includes much already familiar material, which makes for a higher artis- tle average, if less for freshness. Not thar the latter quality is wanting here—on the mitrary, the last word in smartness by the younger and more impetuous painters em phasizes the works of the elder workers ilong le them Among the contributors, uu wo hundred and fifty in all, there many new names ind on the other hand mu t few familia names are miss Passing into gallery F, the largest in the bullding, one is possessed by the spirit of serenity brooding over the place, to which Whistler's full-length figure of Count Rob- ert possibly gives the keynote, if that be not too loud a term to apply to this can vas which the dead painter has invested ijl h ubtle charm, a charm which finds echo in three other valued smaller canvases farther along, by the same hand At the same end of this gallery, too, one bas come to look each year for something mm the hand of John Sargent,who has this time a portrait of the Rev. Endicott Pea body, done, perhaps with a nice regard for the cloth, in an unusual spirit of sobriety and delicacy which Sargent's numerous fol- lowers may well take note of Frank W Benson with a fresh, wholesome portrait of a child, Philip L. Hale with a full-length life-size female figure in which ts no trace of the sensuous, Louls Loeb with the dainty head of a beautiful young girl, two charac- teristic canvases by John Alexander, a brilliant Matador by Robert Henri, a clever but unpleasant characterization of Chev- satt’s most able canvases, a graciously feminine portrait by William W. Churchill, a picture portrait by Sergeant Kendall, and a seated figure in blue by Cecelia Beaux, indicate, but do not exhaust, the list of worthy portraits in the room. In the same gallery are brilliant still life, by Cadwallader Washburn and William M. Chase (who has disposed about the building several portraits of varying excellence), two graphic figure groups, instinct with life, by William J. Glackens, and a joyous Tea Party by Marion Powers Here also is a powerful marine by Homer, one of jewel- like quality by Ryder, a choice interior by Walter Gay, and an interior with figure by Frederick Frieseke, which should not be overlooked Of landscapes in this gallery there are few, those by W. E. Schofield, Ernest Lawson, W. Granville Smith, Ed- ouard Steichten, Leonard Ochtman, and Charles Rosen being among the best. An adjoining smaller gallery is largely impressionistic large, vigorous, and virile canvases by Edward W. Redfield seem a trifle misplaced. Here are numerous brilliant contributions, new and old, by Childe Hassam, Willard Met- ealf, Robert Reid, John H. Twachtman, J. Alden Weir, and Charles Hopkinson, who, along with a few other faithful if less well-known painters of light, uphold the traditions and advance new theories given over to works of tendencies, amid which the two of the cult Gari Melchers has a gallery quite to him- self, where, insulated and isolated, the various phases of his art may be studied freely Portraits, “‘types,”’ a landscape or two, and even a large Last Supper, to- gether present a dignified appearance, and one of much harmony, albeit a trifle sombre contrasted with the brilliant work ot the luminists next door \ somewhat ineffective effort at insula- tion has been made, though just why, one can only half-surmise, with gallery J Here, besides the three fine smaller Whistlers already adverted to, hang Thomas W. Dewing’s delicious Lady with Lute, a vigorous young woman by Robert Henri, a portrait group by .William M. Chase, two landscapes sounding a new note, by Joseph B. Davol, and a group of three splendidly impressive landscapes by Elliott Daingerfield. Strolling through other galleries and cor- ridors, which seem less well lighted, one is attracted by such serious and well-paint- ed productions as H. O. Tanner's Two Disciples (one of the most thoughtful works here), John Sloan's Kent, Ken- yon Cox's Portrait of Maxfield Parrish, the two little canvases by Jerome Meyers, a portrait by J. J. Shannon, a Florida scene by Joseph Woodwell, and Mr. La Farge’'s Visit of Nicodemus to Christ—one of that artist's most dignified productions. Nor should the excellent portraits by J. McClure Hamilton, Irving Wiles, and Thomas An- shutz be overlooked, as in the remote gal- lery where they are placed they are likely to be In conclusion it may be said that, unlike most exhibitions in America, figures and not landscapes dominate the Pennsylvania Academy's show this year. The larger part of these are portraits, more individual than usual in their tendencies, and one's first and last optical impression.js of tall sin- gle figure portrait panels at frequent inter- vals, sometimes a seeming intrusion, and at others lending dignity to the galleries. BEN FOSTER Two books of drawings are disappointing for different reasons. The “Drawings of Gainsborough,” in the Newnes-Scribner Series of Drawings of the Great Masters disappoints from the _ slightness of the drawings themselves, few of them being more than hasty scrawls or possessing any quality sufficient to justify the praise lav- ished upon them by Lord Ronald Suther- land Gower in his introduction. The best of them had already been reproduced in Armstrong's great book on the artist, and two or three of these have great charm. “The Drawings of J. F. Millet’’ (Lippin- cott) is a much more sumptuous and elabo- rate publication, in a limited edition. Here the disappointment is in the selection There are some very fine drawings, as tLere could not well help being, among the fifty chosen; but somehow the collection fails to show the noble qualities of the artist at their highest—or so it seems to one who remembers this or that master- piece in chalk not here included. Now and then there is an obvious blunder in the title given, as in the so-called ‘“‘Sheaf-bind- ers,””’ who are gathering faggots, and in the “Peasant Woman Cleaning Out a Trough,” who is chopping straw. It is still considered obligatory that a book should have a text, and so this one has an “In- troductory Essay” by Léona Bénédite. It is well enough, but really little to the pur- pose. If a competent technical study of the merits of Millet’s drawing, as drawing, was unattainable, why not omit the text altogether and publ?/sh a portfolio? But enough of fault-finding. Fifty drawings by Millet are fifty drawings by Millet; and to have them thoroughly well reproduced, as these are, is to have something well worth more than the price asked, if one has the money to spend. Francesco Malguzzi Valeri’s little hand- book of drawings in the Brera, “I Disegni nella R. Pinacoteca di Brera” (Milano: Al- fieri & Lacroix), may be cordially recom- mended. Ninety-four drawings are repro- duced in the original colors by the half- tone process, and brief editorial notes give all necessary indications as to provenience and bibliography. Many of the sheets are from Morelli’s collection, being lent to the gallery by his executor, Dr. Frizzoni. In the matter of attributions the editor takes a sensibly modest course—the mark of in- terrogation abounds. The brochure is of pocket size, and may be conveniently used in galleries. We know of no similar pub- lication that so nearly meets the practical needs of the student. Similar handbooks of, say, the Louvre, the Ufizzi, and the British Museum, would be simply invalua- ble. We have no space to enumerate the artists represented, and must close with the hint that a drawing in the Metropolitan Museum ascribed to Raphael (temporarily withdrawn from exhibition) must stand or fall with the sheet of studies reproduced in plate 63. Morelli believed in the genuine- ness of the latter work, and it would be a dificult critic that would discredit its New York counterpart. The King of Italy has given to the Brera, bnew

Page 25

abe 6

Jan. 24, 1907] The Nation. 1

Milan, several mythological frescoes by with the name f th artis ts prove to it. Casam! ' Bernardino Luini, formerly in the villa ds nar ind forth. Many ng fa fe} mr ash f Pelluchi, near Monza The decorations of y . ar this villa are widely scattered A numbe y were already in the Brera, including th | e to alre hnown ¢ ‘ : ; , famous St. Catherine Carried by Angels; I i : 2 : others are at Hertford House, the Louvre n supplying . , , < and Chantilly Francesco Malguzzi Valeri . . . , “ : describes the royal gift in the Rassegna ; d’Arte for December, and, noting th ol . ul New } allies \ . showed laboration of Bramantino and Luin I . 5" . id eps die _ 7 villa, suggests that their relation was tha M . D of master and pupii. This furnishes at least ‘, AD CZK ie f art sil : a plausible solution of the obscure mat .w I i . f , of Luini’s apprenticeship N Yorl N Y k Comm " R I j ! The contents of the Oratorio of San Ar vhi? may } dd , to @ ha eartha sano, Fiesole, have been taken over from ; , : f , exis a — me R ‘ f Japa wl the bishopric by the Italian Government Fy n Dallas. Syracu ' . the 1 and will soon be placed in the littl mu — seum on the Piazza Mino. The sculptures | Wadsworth Ath Hartford we Earthqual include the head of a boy in unglazed | ©°®! to re ve a gilt of art | : 4s terra-cotta, by Luca Della Robbia—one of ng from J. Pierpont Morga . Memories Ra , his most beautiful works; a round of th: ! fatl S. Morga Virgin in Adoration, by Andrea della Rol ' chit yf pa ‘ . \ , f wed tl bia, with a notable frame of flower and Sa 3 now o ye Ml , , t of Ku fruit; besides interesting fragments of By ty , , I , | I zantine wood carving. The pictures number , ” ‘ine land ‘ led earthqua some fifty of the fourteenth and fift« ! ‘ fis Mino-Owar centuries—mostly of small size and im ; , wa an ex yed I portance. Four Triumphs of Petrarch | : tinguished Jacopo del Sellaio, formerly attributed to lore haracteriz t i Botticelli, are perhaps the most interesting ’ And \u 1 Roon hi | mbleme le items, but thé late Giottesque school is well y on the ev ng of January 16 the fol- | pout-etre on represented by minor examples. This a ving prices were paid for prin Robert me the tremend i quisition should make the Fiesolan mu- | Burns - - engraved by W 18¥4 seum, usually overlooked by tourists, a | “@!ker and S. Cou Aate me pe ng . meow om of place of resort by Na th, $10 Mi La Rix ex ; 1 by Bracquemond, $ M During the last two years, the National Partie Perdus etched by Bracquem , MOO . , Gallery at Berlin has made an unusual | ¢)79- yeijssonier’s 1806. etched by Jules Ja vent _ number of acquisitions. They number over | quot $100: Meissonic 1807. « To ' - » Vor mM , two hundred paintings and almost half as quet, $450; Me ' 1814 ™ , 06 ! many pieces of statuary The gallery now | que $210 M ¥ — — : sane Wi presents an altogether different appear- | @porjes Wa ¢ R ;, . ; A a ance from that of 1904, and is as fairly | woren etched by CW : $04 7% bh mOvem : representative of German art of the last] , sles B Ey nine : » Hamie ' . u hundred years as can be expected of a E pe ie tn a © Sie $100 | \lash I single collection. Besides this, many mod . . ern pictures by foreign painters have been Yakutat B bought or received as gifts ; eee ac The authorities of the Louvre will ar : | the mind ' range a special Rembrandt room, where Sclenlce. | by earthqual the twenty-two works of Rembrandt, now | ~—_o . scattered through the museum, will | ats ; brought together \ QUARTER-CENTURY OI CATASTRO | Quetzal r The Government of India has taken steps PHISM Ma to preserve the Sinbyame Pagoda, which is Th tudent of geolo: ieee teen | n May oft the only building of its type in the Mingun | » nind may be wit} ' 7 of . ' province of Burma. | the numerou insolved — probler n the | * leano, wit vl An interesting discovery has been mad physics of he eat not fail » be | : , ¥ ; in a Belgian convent of a painting of ply impressed by tl itastropl lap 7 “Christ Risen,” which has been attributed | ! ngs of the last venty-five yea Phe . reeihs to Rubens by various experts. In 1603 Ru ecord of no other like period » far a 7 . ; : bens painted a series of Christ and th: written in the book of science, car- | Shemaka and of Andija Twelve Apostles for the Duke of Lerma ries with it » clearly th oncept of th " ; : a ; The Twelve Apostles have long been in infinished glob or » eloquently teache aac atty anc kty thou oh the Prado at Madrid, but the Christ ha he inconsequence of man beside the ti “0 a dens oe the Som been lost sight of till this discovery in tanic forces of nature Wher n Augu : Ol inhabitar nt Belgium, which is now identified as the | /***, @ cataclysm rent asund th and _— n Japa . missing picture of Krakatoa, and cau I I K th igt : 8 ae Capen ut almost the t n f tl arth This event wa yn follow News has come from Geneva that in a| we saw how the pr ‘ of adjustment f those vast disturbance collection of Egyptian papyri Prof. Jules | which hape the interior of our globe were | which culminated in Nicole has lately come across an ancient | gtij] tending to produce equilibrium. For | March and April of 1906, w Latin guide through Rome, which he found | two years or more we gazed upon the won- | part of the island was deva in the midst of Greek texts. Th guide con | drous red and yellow ifterglowa which sands of lives sacrificed P tains an inventory of sculpture, enumerat irked the distribution of the high-blown | calamities by a few month ing the chief works to be seen in the city, | ash, and refi i the energy by which 40, with a paroxysmal awak and indicating exactly where they are plac 000 or more person were swept out of | was the earthquake of the M ed; it also gives a description of each one, ! existence At this same time, or close | gion of southern Italy. The ;

Page 26

was designed to super- The Nation. [Vol. 84, No. 2169 sede quaternions and Grassmann’s tusdchnungsichre. It is now taught in sun- dry European universities; but its vogue was prevented or hindered by a trait of ts author’s character that struck every- body that ever met him, and that we know not how otherwise to designate than is diffidence. Yet this is not a fit name for It certainly was not that diffidence which consists in timidity; nor can we issent to his brilliant scholar Prof. Bum- tead’s apparent view that he was uncon- is of h ywn superiority, which would ym 0 near to making him a gifted idiot, voting up his mathematical truffles like Périgord pig, and as oblivious of being | leprived of them We should rather con- | ceive of it as an exaggerated estimate of the possibility of any opinion of his being erroneous that might concern a difficult question no isceptible of a demonstra- tive solution He thought his method | yught to be left to make its own way in | the world; but he overlooked the fact that he was not giving the offspring of his brain | the fair start to which it was entitled. For | he limited himself to printing and private- ly circulating a fifty-page syllabus of that no illustrations of its appli- man of great more thau | method, with | The parts and attainments would not industry of a have sufficed to construct any decided opin- ion upon such a question from such a basis. | If Gibbs himself, after devoting his own | surpassing genius for some years to the was not prepared to put forth a matte | categorical decision as to the merits of the | method, pray who else could be expected to | undertake the office? We can only say that the ease and mastery with which his schol- i have handled some of the most thorny problems of physics, as contrasted with he infertility of the quaternionists, incline is to put our trust in “vector analysis.” | The book is clothed in all dignity and beauty of paper and type, carries a noble photograph of the master, and in every way (except by an index) recommends itself to | ie liking of friends of American science | I t good, but restrained, notice of t) most genuine of high intelligences by it worthy interpreter, Prof. H. A. Bumstead, who has taken Dr. Ralph Gibbs Van Name collaborating editor The following cientific books are in- cluded in Macmillan’s list of spring pub- | lication Cyclopedia of American Agri | culture,’ vol i edited by Prof L | H Bailey Experimental Zoodlogy,”’ iy rhoma Hunt Morgan; Economi | Geology of the United States,”’ by Hein h Rie Forage Corps,” by Ed- » | ward B. Voorhees; rhe Storage Battery,” ‘ by Augustus Treadwell; Practical Text- | wk of Plant Pathology by D. F. Mac- Dougal Introduction to Zodlogy,’”” new ' ed a by Charles Benedict Davenport and » | Gertrude Crotty Davenport Elements of | Electro-Chemistry,” by M. Leblanc; “Types f Farming by L. H. Bailey; ‘‘Meteorolo- | gy, Weather, and Methods of Forecasting,” new edition, by Thomas Russell; Princi- ple of Inorganic Chemistry,” new edition, Siudies in Physiology, new edition, by J. Bacterial Infec- ‘ by C. A. Her- Lectures on the General Properties of “System by H. C,. Jone | | Anatomy, and Hygiene,” | E. Peabody; “The Common tions of the Digestive Tract | Immunity,"’ by Svante Arrhenius; of Medicine and Gynzcology,” vol. ii., Part I., edited by Thomas Clifford Allbutt; “Clinical Psychiatry,” new edition, by A Ross Diefendorf. The ascent of Mt. Ruwenzori, the ancient Mountains of the Moon, last summer was described in a lecture delivered at Rome on January 7 by the Duke of the Abruzzi In a little over a month he climbed the sixteen highest peaks, made a survey of the range, determined heights, fixed the watersheds, and mapped and photographed the whole region The principal scientific results are the fact that the range consists 16,810 feet being The limit 14,600 feet, None of of six principal groups, the altitude of the highest peak. of perpetual about and of the lowest glacier 13,677 the glaciers were of the first they showed signs of receding SnOW was order, and Finance. THE BREAK IN THE STOCK MARKET About the middle of last December, after having held obstinately strong in the face of extremely tight money, repeated deficits in New York bank reserves, and prohibitory rates charged in London for American Stock Ex- change prices suddenly began to give way “carrying” securities, Since then, the decline has been almost continuous, up to the present week. Dur- ing the five-week period, such striking declines in the price of important rail- way stocks have been scored as 20 points in Chicago, Milwaukee and St. Paul, 23 in Union Pacific, 34 in New York Central, 39 in Reading, 63 in Northern Pacific, and Sv in Great Northern. People, learning of such a fall in prices, might easily infer either that a serious disaster had befallen the world of investors, or else that the Stock Exchange movement was foreshad- owing a highly unfavorable turn in our tide of prosperity And, in fact, the violent fall in prices last week and at the opening of this week, had so far the ground from under the feet who had been holding huge lines of stocks with money borrowed on collateral of these very stocks—as to force liquidation and some signals of real This, however, was pretty much restricted to that class of people known in Wall Street as “Stock Exchange profes- No one else seems to have been cut of speculators distress sionals.”’ badly hurt. The outside public, which lost millions in the Wall Street collapse of May, 1901, and which was probably hard hit in the two-day crash of December, 1904, has on the present occasion made little complaint. At the same time, no signs of trade reaction, or of alarm in business circles, is anywhere manifest. Instead, one hears the general comment, industry is in a far safer position, that Stock Exchange spec- ulation has collapsed and Stock Exchange that legitimate now prices have come down Nevertheless, there atill exists, even in Wall Street itself, a good deal of per- plexity as to why the stock market should have fallen at just this time. Two months every Wall Street had a word ago, one on . sais

Page 27

hoy, “pettig r " ee eae ape: Bi sag ®t": Ait ~ nha - 4 ’ respects things, it Jan. 24, 1907] to say of the “January reinvestment put up stocks and lower the money de- mand’ and the manner in which it would rate It was commonly alleged that, if prices uuld only be held up through December the market was safe.’ Since bankers ind brokers are apt to buy stocks in the last days of December, in order to sell it a profit to the January investor, this support to the market is likely to be felt before the year is ove: Yet it was pre cisely this time that witnessed the be ginning of the break, and it was in the week when money was cheap, bank re serves rising, and “January reinvestment normally in full swing, that forced li qui dation on the Stock Exchange went on most rapidly Why such a paradox—espec when the argument, that would only ially a rise in stocks reflect"’ or “‘discount”™’ increas ing prosperity, still appears to hold good” The first and most hat the rise in stocks may have been g ahead too fast in its ‘discounting.’ econd is, that it had been using speculation pure and simple, capital credit which were needed in the count expanding trade A third answer is the great rise in stocks had brought net yield, on the basis of existing di dends and prices, to 3% or 4 per cen obvious answel! is ing } The for and ry that the \ t this at a time when merchants were pay ng 6 per cent. for six-months’ loans when other borrowers, with the best S Exchange collateral to offer, were even higher Such a situation was’ ir anomalous in the nature could not continu The J lot ‘ST PUBLISHED art’s STANDARD ENGLISH SPEECH = 16mo, $1.00 net. ciation. Hobhouse’s MORALS IN EVOLUTION A study in comparative ethics, by author of ‘‘Mind in Evolution,”’ and * Theory of Knowledge.’’ 3754-294 2 vols., 8vo, $5.00 net; by mail, $5. 3¢ McPherson’s WORKING OF THE RAILROADS 273 pp.. $1.50 net; by mail, $1.65. ‘Now, of all times, it is very much t desired that all who can should get as about the railroads it seems to us that McPherson's lectures supply Not instructive, but interesting Told non-technical language with a sufficiency illustrative history, and we cannot see any essential facts are missing.’’ Sun PEEEEEOOEE4464646464646444464666666666688 telligent an idea as can be had of the railr: ing problem. Such fundamental information as every good citizen would do well to have and ocK paying all of plain By Prof. J. M. HART of Cornell. 93 pp.., An attempt to show how the Englishman or American of to-day has come by his pronu: the The PP: ’ ir vad ‘ Mr only in of that Evening NEW YORK HENRY HOLT &CO 2s mem FOR THE ARTISTS von Mach’s Greek Sculpture; its Spirit and Y~-» von Mach’s Ou:lines of the History of Painting Weir's Greek Painter's Art Hoyt’s The World's Painters and their Pictures Partr: ’s Technique of Sculpture Puach's Handbook of Linear Perspective, Shadows and Reflections Cross’s Free Hand Drawing CINN & COMPANY - BOSTON | BEING ‘The Nation. enough reason why the break occurred the moment when many people were |! ng for a further rise, was that som: the nore ’ la ng how | i s the po i ome lid not da 1! wt circum ar “ i ! delit itel sel l 4 ) Ww iso ) x pe r " and when, accordingly t Ne of the own burden to tl t i1dvantage Even so, the pressure of liquid out to be too heavy the lat t ams more ipid with eacl id “ price it ilmir ! ! x lemer fa week rhe ! ) in f l the ha 1 narke inno lec] v) ne ising. So fa th » tl ha he great financial pan hav 1 mn lose on tl heel f i \ ind appa ly pro movem No ) n ! pani of 140 which ? } montl when bank excha ! ind Lilway ‘ ! I ! high r | t ! ri } notabl i f ' r ! lo ! in il It ak-dow f low famou boom yea * and S vt own overwhelming collapse came ! after a year of unparalleled trad i ty. business profits, and peculative ure The reason wa lent il w i ‘cason, already set forth, for th mi yreak it tock at the heigl of the try’s material prosper WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. A tremendous miscellaneous stock Greatly increased facilities for the im portation of English publications Competent bookmen to price lists and collect books All of this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. I Wilfrid 8 Hiritis I bz \ j i ‘ ‘ 4 . . I L ! I & (* s . ‘ i . J 4 ! 4 \ 1\ and Vv iH su A ; ' \W " s ‘ Highlands ‘ ‘ z A \ | et } J \ I e ¢ $1.25 } ly Rot ] S 2u aN Kh I M I WW = i .s j M 4 \ s ! \\ i s tl I I M i H yi & ¢ $ t ‘ ! s P i ‘ ‘ HW ‘ \ M I } | t ! host Ml ‘ P s Ve I> 0 I ‘ t I W I Mel 4 ‘ \ I vi A M I if M s: J ! ‘ | ‘ ‘4 $2 | ' 1 . St I n A A S I e& s R I j M | l " © financial SYNTHETICA: MEDITATIONS AND ONTOLOGICAL. THE UNIVERSITY GIFFORD 1905 TO 1906. By S. S. LAURIE, LL.D. 2 vols., 8vo, $7 net LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York STANDARD AUTHORS IN SETS Balzac, Bronté#, Bulwer, Carlyle, Cooper, Dick ens. Dumas, De Foe, Eliot. Fielding, Gibbo Guizot, Hawthorne, Hugo, Irving. Macaulay. Poe, Prescott. Reade, Ruskin, Scott, Smollett, epeare, Thackeray, Tolstoi Send for Descriptive Booklet. THOMAS Y, CROWELL & CO.. New York EPISTEMOLOGICAL EDINBURGH LECTURES FOR 12-Page Circular Describing About 55 Well-Known Listed Railroad Bonds kr I pomtot se rit na income yield, ther ‘ ter form of investment than good bond recommended by expenenced§ Investment Bankers Holders ot attorded an market ood bond are hye ‘ rrtral tiveora Write for Circular No 0 Spencer Trask & Co. Investment Bankers. William and Pine Sts., New York Shake OF CREDIT. #00 Trav We buy ar billie of | LETTERS make canie transfers \uetra ‘ ake sof the International Cheques. ( ertificates BROWN BROTHERS . WALL ST PRT ‘SI & CO om Aa %

Page 28

The [ Vol. 84, No. 2169 THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS NEW BOOKS = . ° : . = Railway Organization and Working Edited by ERNEST R. DEWSNUP re of prominent railway officials have contributed to this volume the condensed esults of their experience. Eminently practical and thoroughly readable, the book vill occupy a unique position as a manual of railroad business, It is equally adapted to university classes aod to the needs of the professional railroader. 510 pages; small Svo, cloth; net $2.00, postpaid $2.16 Che New Appreciation of the Bible By WILLARD C. SELLECK This book seeks to do three things: first, to state briefly the principal conclusions of modern learning rewarding the Bible; second, to show the enhanced values which it and third, to point out some of the ways in which it may be most i24 pages; 12mo, cloth; net $1.50, postpaid $1.63 now exhibits helpfully used The Development of Western Civilization By J. DORSEY FORREST \n examination of modern European society which has in view the determining of ial forees by which it has been molded to its present form 418 pages; Svo, oth; net $2.00, postpaid $2.17 A Genetic History of the New England Theology By FRANK HUGH FOSTER \« the first genetic history of the greatest theological movement which America has yet seen, the book willeommand the attention of all students of our national thought 4) pages; small Svo, cloth; net $2.00, postpaid $2.17 , 9 . Hlomeric Vocabularies By EDGAR J]. GOODSPEED and WILLIAM B. OWEN This little book is pranned to aid the reader of Homer in the rapid acquiring of a vocabulary The words are arranged in the order of their frequency, a method which has proved remarkably successful in practice, 70 pages; small 8vo, paper; net $0.50 post paid $0.53. . ° o.6 ° >: ~ ° :vyptian Antiquities in the Pier Collection Part I By GARRETT PIER Mr. Vier collection contains a number of unique specimens and is known to experts throughout the world The catalogue is luxuriously printed and bound, ind profusely illustrated. 48 pages; quarto; net $4.00, postpaid $4.15 Index Volume to Breasted’s Ancient Records of Egypt An elaborate index to the collection will shortly be published as a separate volume. \ most important work will thus be completed. It will now be possible for any eader of English to have access to the entire body of Egyptian historical inscrip- net $2.00 tion yw pues SVvo; \nimal Micrology: Practical Exercises in Microscopical Methods By MICHAEL F. GUYER \n indispensable book for teacher, physician, student, or novice who wishes to earn how to prepare his own material for microscopical examination. Sufficient t of the theoretical side of microscopy is given to enable the student to get witisfactory results from his microscope 250 pages; Svo, cloth: net $1.75, postpaid, 31.58 Hebrew Life and Thought By LOUISE SEYMOUR HOUGHTON lhe reader of the Bible who wishes to be well informed, and who yet finds little to ittract him in accounts of scientific investigations, will do well to read this book. Enriched with the fruits of a lifetime of study and versed in the intricacies of mod- ern criticiam, the author approaches her subject with a depth of feeling that reminds me of the best religious writers of the past. 306 pages; 12mo, cloth; net $1.50, postpaid $1 f A Short History of Christianity in the Apostolic Age By GEORGE H. GILBERT This new textbook belongs to the series of “Constructive Bible Studies." It is in tendet for pupils of sixteen or seventeen years of age. Like the other volumes of the series it alms to embody the results of modern scholarship, while remaining true the spirit of ite great theme. 16 pages; Svo; postpaid $1.00 DEPT. 21 CHICAGO AND NEW YORK THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS THE BURROWS BROTHERS PRISONERS OF FORTUNE A New Book of Absorbing Interest OF GLEVELAND, OHIO ‘ italog COMPANY sl hook I'he aso offer librarians and col tore their fully annotated lat o” Americana and s specally prepared brochure on American his- “Abounde with well chosen anecdotes " The Dial, Chicago. ry which tells of the publications issued by them | wile tise in contemplation postcard «ue || LINCOLN: Master of Men vesting that such material would be appreciated wi have immediate attention By ALONZO ROTHSCHILD Iilastrated. 85.00 net; postpaid $3.17. READ By SEWELL FORD SHORTY McCABE | EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY 4th Series Shelburne Essays Fourth Series By PAUL ELMER MORE Crown, 8vo, $1.25 net Ready Now Contents: The Vicar of Morwenstow --Fanny Burney—A Note on ‘ Daddy” Crisp—George Herbert—John Keats— Benjamin Franklin—Charles Lamb Again -Walt Whitman—William Blake—The Letters of Horace Walpole—The Theme of Paradise Lost. “*It is a pleasure to hail in Mr. Morea genuine critic, high quality of his thought, serious purpose, and excel- lent Stvle.’—Harvard Graduates’ Magazine. Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. G.P.Putnam’s Sons, 234'ston ¥" PROOFS of | LIFE AF1ER DEATH 8vo. Cloth, 865 pages, $1.50 net, 12c. postage. A COLLATION OF OPLNIONS AS TO A FU- TURE LIFE BY THE WORLD'S MOST EMI- NENT SCIENTIFIC MEN IN CONFUTATION OF THE MATERIALISTC SCHUOL OF THOUGHT. HERBERT B. TURNER&CO., Boston, Mass. Literary |IN PERIL of CHANGE & Social By ©. F. G. MASTEKMAN. Studies |] THE NEW HUMANISM By EDWARD HOWARD GRIGGS Each — $1.50 net | B.W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, N.Y. Memotrs of Henry Villard Journalist and Financier 1835-1900 Two volumes, with Portraits and Maps. $5.00 net. Postage, 35 cents. An autobiographical record of the varied and romantic career of the war journalist who subse- quently became a power in the financial world, and carried the Northern Pacific Railroad to com- pletion. Full of incident and valuable for its reminiscences of Lincoln and other prominent men of the time, as well as for its descriptions of important battles of the Civil War. “A book of extraordinary interest. It is written with great ability, in a clear and flowing style; it detalls with perfect candor the incidents of @ great career; It is an admirable report of great events, all of which the writer saw, anda large part of which (after 1870) he was; it exhibits the rise and growth ofa rich and pow erful personality and a character at once remarkable for ite simplicity and {ts variety.’’—Joun Ware Caap- wick, in the New York Times Saturday Review. “This posthumous autebtograrty of the late Henry Villard (sa work of exceptional interest.”— . cial and Financial Chronicle, November 12, 1004. HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO., BOSTON AND NEW YORK Cloth, i) cents; leather, $1.00 List on request, EP. DUTTON @ CO. ~ - NEW YORK

Page 29