The Nation 1906-11-29: Vol 83 Iss 2161
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
VOL. The LXXXIII—NO. 2161. TO BE PUBLISHED NEXT WEEK THE BOOK WHICH ISTHE SENSATION OF THE EUROPEAN CAPITALS The Memoirs of Prince Hohenlohe In two volumes, lustrated with portraits, fac- simile letter, etc. Cloth, $0.00 net Volume I. covers YoutHr 1819-47 Revolution—Imperial Mission to Athens, Rome and Florence, 1848"50—-The Years 1850"66—The Bava rian Ministry, 1867-'70,. Volume Il, covers The Reichstag, 1870 ’'74—Ambassador at Paris, 1874-"85—Statt halter at Strassburg, 1885-04 — Im pe rial Chancellor—The End, 1894-.’01—Index. For the last month every capital in the civilized world has been ringing with the sensation caused by the publi- cation in Germany of the Hohenlohe Memoirs. From the outset of his career Prince Hohenlohe was in touch with almost every court in Europe. Subtle, shrewd, closely observant, it was his business as a diplo- mat to be on intimate terms with men of great impor- tance. His discretion, silence and tact, together with his family and official position, marked him as the one man who was certain to hear both sides of every story. But he told it only to his diary. Few incidents in contemporary history have been more dramatic than the story of Bismarck’s fall. Here for the first time we have the true story; a little later the man who tells it was in Bismarck’s place, and for six years the Kaiser's right hand man. The style is racy and utterly unaffected, with a dash of caustic but not unkindly humor. The interest and importance of the work cannot be exaggerated. The Memoirs of Prince Hohenlohe Two 8vo volumes, with illustrations, $6.00 net Published THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “54+ by
Page 2
— a The Nation. 4 WRAKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED Tt Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED LUN 1866, [Rntered at the New York City Post Office as second class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER Tas Wee Eprrortal ARTICLES Secretary Root on South American T 4 \ Progre Parad se 4 The I thall Season 4 ! te va. Rule mn Fnglish 4 rhe Books of a Poet-Bibliographer ‘ esive"’ Sreorat AgTicue Conte nee m Se ndary PFaluc South CORRREPONDENCE The Case of the Twentr-fifth Infantry 4°08 rm HW Swate l ind Out 4 g a Treat m in Colleg r Literature ophiles of Old Whitehall ea Hyvwave Dorset ‘ I Delightful English Towns Artist 404 44 ds Lee 166 Virg ' ; 148 48 407 167 468 4068 Art deputs les ['remilers TT wqu'A Nos J mps ure 400 470 470 471 Boom Times TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to for- eigae comprised in the Postal Union, $4. The date when the subs ription expires ia on the address label af each paper, the change of which to @ subsequent date becomes a recetpt Sor aremit tance, No other reecipt ts aent unless requested, Remitfances at the riak of the subscriber. unless uniries mide by registered letter, or by check, express der, or Postal Order payable to “ Publisher of The Nation When a change of addres ta desired, both the old and the new addresses should be given Address THE NATION, Box 794, New York Publication Office, 208 Broadway TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen centa per agate line, each insertion; 14 lines lo the inch Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page or top of column A column page, ots A page, #60 Alvertia reapect Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M THE NATION ta sent free to those who adver. tee in U as long as advertisement continues Discounts upon applica/ion, on . *.* Copies of Tae Nation may be Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de ff0 each tnaertion; with choice of cach insertion; front cover page, $80. nus’ be acoeptable tn every- nenate rocured in ‘Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross The Nation.
[Vol. 83, No. 2161
‘“< Indispensable to every reader who wishes to keep informed upon public af- current discus- fairs and sion “SZ [he subscription price is SIX DOLLARS a year, the United States, Canada, and Mex- introduce the TRIAL SUB- postpaid in ico. To magazine, SCRIPTIONS will. be received, Three Months (thirteen numbers) for ONE DOLLAR. New subscribers for 1907 will receive free the re- maining numbers of 1906 4 THE BEST THINGS In English Periodical Literature Reprinted Unabridged In a Single Weekly Magazine at Moderate Cost HATEVER other magazines you may subscribe for, you cannot afford not to see regularly The Living Age (Littell’s). It supplements the American magazines, containing what they do not. It makes superfluous the taking of a con- siderable list of English magazines, as it reproduces without abridgment the freshest, most important. and most timely articles from their pages. More than thirty of the leading English periodicals are regularly drawn upon to make the contents of The Living Age. The magazine publishes the best essays, fiction, poetry, travel sketches, literary, art, and musical criticism, historical and bio- graphical papers, scientific articles, discus- sions of social, religious, and educational questions. and papers upon PUBLIC AFFAIRS and INTERNATIONAL POL- ITICS, together with an editorial depart- ment devoted to ‘‘ Books and Authors.” No other mafazine, Amer'can or English, presents the writings of so many brilliant and distinguished authors. Light and easy to hold, the magazine con- tains each year about twice as much material as any of the four-dollar magazines, and its weekly issue enables it to present the articles which it reproduces with great promptness.
6 BEACON STREET
THE LIVING AGE CO. BOSTON, MASS.
lease mention The Nation F:ducational. School Agencies. MASSACH SETTS. Boston. ‘WHE FISK TEACHERS' AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. I ye tho UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BiesLow.
ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location bigh and dry. Laboratories. Shop for Mechante Arta. Strong teachers. Barnest boys. Gymnastum with new ewimming pool. Fite for college, actentifie school and business. Foung boys tn separate bullding. Address Dr. & C. WHITE, Rock R dge Hall, Wellesley Mills, Mass 4 Ashburton Pi., Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid.. Minneapolis 208 Mich. Ave, Chicago 1200 Williams Av., Portland 401 poener Bid., Denver 525 Stime’n Bid.,LosAngeles 313 Rook’ry Bik., Spokane 717 Market St..San F’ncisco Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Records. Send for Ctreular off Pree Registration. * HARLAN P. FRENCH. #1 Chanel St.. Albany. N. ¥.
PROOFS of LIFE AFTER DEATH fvo. Cloth, 345 pa . $150 net, 12c. post A COLLATION 1Y OPINIONS AB TO A . TURE LIFE BY THB WORLD'S MOST EMF | NENT SCIENTIFIC MEN IN CONFUTATION | OF THE MATERIALISTIO SCHOOL OF | THOUGHT. HERBERT B. TURNER & ©O. Boston, Mass.
Financial. We buy and sel! bills of exchanges and make cable transfers of money on Eu- rope, Australia, and South Africa; also make collections and teeue Comme LETTERS OF Travellers’ Credite available tn ef) CREDIT -_ of the world. International nes, Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO: NO. 50_WALL STREET, NEW YORK.
Page 3
The Nation. ae —a ae BOOKS FOR CHRISTMAS CHILDREN’S BOOKS The Jane Andrews Series Long's Wood Folk Series The Youth’s Companion Series Strong’s All the Year Round Series Collodi’s Pinocchio. The Adventures of a Ma- rionette * Chance’s Little Folks of Many Lands Hardy’s Sea Stories for Wonder Eyes Chandler's In the Reign of Coyote Comstock’s Ways of the Six-Footed Morley’s Nature Study Series Atkinson’s First Studies of Plant Life Gould’s Mother Nature’s Children Eddy’s Friends and Helpers Beal’s Seed Dispersal Frye’s Brooks and Brook Basins Dickerson’s Moths and Butterflies Weed’s Seed Travelers Hale’s Little Flower People Emerton’s Common Spiders Stickney and Hoffmann’s Bird World Willlams’s Some Successful Americans Hill’s Lessons for Junior Citizens Blaisdell’s Hero Stories from American History Blaisdell’s Short Stories from American History Catherwood’s Heroes of the Middle West Spyri’s Heidi Spyri’s Moni, the Goat Boy Ramee’s Bimb Aesop’s Fables Shaw’s Stories of the Ancient Greeks Greene’s Legends of King Arthur Swift’s Gulliver’s Travels Wyss’s Swiss Family Robinson Defoe’s Robinson Crusoe Kingsley’s Water Babies Kingsley’s Greek Heroes Ruskin’s King of the Golden River Lamb’s Tales from Shakespeare Scott’s Lady of the Lake Scott’s Marmion Scott’s Tales of a Grandfather Franklin’s Autobiography NEW BOOKS Brier-Patch Philosophy ** Peter Rabbit “ of the Brier-Patch expoun !s his philosophy of men and mannersto WM. J. LONG, who interprets it. and to CHARLES CUPELAND, who illustrates it Frontispiece in colors, full page and m a! illustrations.... sec $ Stories from Famous Ballads GRACE GREENWOOD'S popular w children Edited by CAR LINE Bt RNITE. Director of Children's Department Cleveland Pubiiec Library. Llustrated bv EH, Garrett SO cents net, The Sunshine Primer By MARION IL. NOYES and KATE L. The latest and most beautifuily book for children Physical Education By DUDLEY A. SARGENT, 11.D., Directo: gin QUILY ustrated of the Hemenway Gymoasium, Harvard Uol versity. The Philosophy of Goethe's Faust Six lectures delivered in Cambridge, Mass by the late THOMAS DAVIDSON, author of “The Education of the Wage Earners Mountain Wild Flowers of America By JULIA HENSHAW. Send for ITilustrated Cireulars BOOKS ON ART Weir's Greek Painter's Art von Mach's Greek Sculpture von Mach’s Outlines of the History of Painting Hoyt’s World's Painters and Their Pictures Partridge’s Technique of Sculpture Cross*s Free Hand Drawing LITERATURE van Dyke's Poems of Tennyson Bellainy’s Twelve English Poets Heller’s Studies in Modern German Literature Gayley’s Classic Myths in English Literature Gayley and Flaherty’s Poetry of the People Parratt and Long's English Poems from Chaucer to Kipling ECONOMICS Ripley's Trusts, Pools, and Corporations Commons’s Trade Unionism and Labor Prob lems Carver's Sociology and Social Progress Bullock's Selected Readings in Public I White's Money and Banking Johnson's Money and Currency Ward's Applied Sociology Ward's Psychic Factors of Civilization Davidson's Education of the Wage Earners HISTORY Fiske’s Discovery and Colonization of North America Fiske’s How Nation Hitchcock's Louisiana Purchase Robinson's Readings in European History Robinson's History of Western Europe Cheyney’s Short History of England Montgomery's Student’s American Revised, inance the United States Became a History, GINN @ COMPANY, Publishers :: TRADE DEPAR TMENT 29 Beacon St., BOSTON THE LEADING REVIEWS The Nineteenth Century and After $4.50; any Quarteriv $10.40; WAAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. j l. A tremendous miscellaneous stock 2. Greatly increased favilities for the im- | Fortnightly Review, Contemporary Review, Westminsier Review ; any one, two, $8.50; any three, $12.00; all tour, $16.00. Biackwvood's Magazine, $3.00; Review, Edinburgh Review; Blackw od’s and one quarterly, $6.50; with two, either quarterly, $4.00; the two, $7.50. Booklet and specimen copies iree. LEONARD SCOTT PUBLICATION CO., 7 Warren St., New York portation of English publications. READ 9 3. Competent bookmen to price lists and EVERYMAN S LIBRARY pr may Bh mg m 0 price 8 » SHOR T Y McCA BE Cloth, 50 cents; leather Si. All of this means prompt and complete By SEWELL FORD Kk. P. DUTTON @4 CO. - - aw ar shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. | THE ANNUAL PERPLEXITY THE of the holiday season will be only a minor embarrassment if you consider the v epihdd OF CLEVELAND, OHIO of a year’s subscription to THE NATION 4s 4 Christmas gift COMPANY THE NATION, founded in 1865, aims to report each week the intellectual ' | progress of the world, and its tiles are an incomparable library of contemporary issue monthly, a catalog of rare, scarce and un- | , : . : usual books. They also offer lbrarians and col- | history and politics, scientific development, pertinent financial commentary, and lectors their fully annotated list of Americana and : American his- | impartial and scholarly criticism of art, literature and the drama aspecially prepared brochure on tory which tells of the publications issued by them and of those in contemplation. A post-card sug- gesting that guch material would be appreciated will have immediate attention. SIX MONTHS’ SUBSCRIPTION FREE.—7%e Pudblishe The Library of Literary Criticism of Tue Navion wll extend six months the term of any sul Of Engish and American Authors , J 7, From 660 to 1905. Eight volumes. Compiled scriber who sends the name of anew subscriber with the remit Studies of 1,150 Authors, in chronological arrange 5 ment Moat accurate and authentic Reference tance for one year $ Stu Ase riplion Work on all phases of English Literature. Highest . raise from Scholars throughout the English-speak- ng world. Sample pages, etec., free by mail. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York MUSIC OF TO-MORROW And Other Studies By Lawrexce GtLman. 12mo., $1.25 net. Postage I2c. JOHN LANE CO., The Bodley Head, N. Y. Subscription, $3.00 a year, postpaid PUBLICATION OFFICE, 205 Broadway, New York
Page 4
The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 216 BEFORE CHOOSING HOLIDAY BOOKS ASK TO SEE BOOKS OF TRAVEL OR REMINISCENCE ~ BO 13) Nk W Dr. Edward Everett Hale’s Tarry at Home Travels “Every page is full of that charm which always belongs to everything that Dr. Hale writes.’’— The World To-day. With over 200 illustrations selected by Dr. Hale. Cloth, 8vo, $2.50 ; by mail, $2.70 Prof. A. V. Williams Jackson’s Persia Past and Present “Few books of travel published this year approach this in interest."’--PAiladeiphia Public Ledger. With 200 original illustrations anda map. Cloth, 8vo, gilt top, $4.00 net; by mat’, $4.20 Mr. Clifton Johnson’s Highways and Byways of the Mississippi Valley ‘One more delightful study of the picturesque inthe scenery, . . and the mental views of the inhabitant along the route: negro roustabouts, Missouri fishermen, and lowa farmers . . . adelightful whole.’’—/nterior. ‘ With 12 full page plates and many smaller illustrations by the author Cloth, crown Sv0, $2.00 net; by mail, $2.20 Mrs. St. Julien Ravenel’s Charleston: The Place and the People Phe book is charming and will especially interest those who enioyed Mr. Owen Wister’s descriptions of the city in “Lady Baltimore..’ Illustrated with pen drawings by Vernon Howe Bailey. Cloth, $2.50 net; by mail, $2.67 Mr. E. V. Lucas’s A Wanderer in London ‘* Heartily welcomé, eminently entertaining, and above all eminently useful.”’"— Mew York Tribune. With many illustrations, among them 16 plates in colors. Cloth, r2mo, $1.75 net +] . . . Mr. Bram Stoker’s Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving ‘A very valuable contribution to the records of the dramatic art . . . volumes that will have wide popularity, not only amongst those who knew Irving, but amongst those who are, in however small a degree, interested in the history of the theatre.” —W. L. CourTNEY in the Daily Telegraph, London. /n two handsome 8vo volumes, illustrated, cloth, $7.50 net ANDARD HISTORIES JUST COMPLETED Mr. James Ford Rhodes’s History of the United States From the Compromise of 1850 to the Final Restoration of Home Rule in the South in 1877 “Countless histories of this period have been written by authors of more or less repute, but none of them compare in fulness, fairness and authoritativeness with Mr. Rhodes’s narrative.’’ — Boston Transcript. Complete in seven volumes. Cloth, $17.50 net; half calf or half morocco, $32; three-quarter levant, $40 Mr. Herbert Paul’s A History of Modern England “‘Itisclear, vigorous and direct . . . pre-eminently readable.”"— Zhe American Historical Review. A handsome, substantial edition in five volumes, cloth, Svo, $12.50 net QOKS OF VERSE Mr. Wallace Irwin’s Random Rhymes and Odd Numbers = “ustrated. Cloth, $1.50 net Are the best humorous verses since Eugene Field’s; full o° pure fun and audacity, irresistible in jolly lilting measures. Mr. William Butler Yeats’ Poems Gollected edition. Includes all of the published lyrical verses of the man most closely identified with the recent Celtic revival; these have unti) now been widely scattered in small volumes and magazines. Cloth, r2mo, gilt top, $1.75 OKS OF INSPIRATION Mrs. A. R. B. Lindsay’s The Warrior Spirit is a ringing, martial call to advance in a sane, aspiring life among present conditions. Cloth, $1.50 net; by mail, $1.60 President Henry C. King’s Rational Living is the best aid 4 young man could have in the fight for character, for full equipment. Cloth, $1.25 net; by mail, $1.37 JUVENILES Christina Gowans Whyte’s The Story Book Girls The best new book to give toa girl of fourteen or over. It makes much the same impressions of reality and charm as Miss Alcott's “Little Women,"’ It was awarded the prize recently offered by Dr. Nicoll’s Bookman, Cloth, $1.50 Miss Beulah Marie Dix’s Merrylips The best book for a little girl from ten to fourteen. ‘A brave, strong, inspiring story of a dainty little maid with a boy’s heart, as wholesome and sweet as sunshine and open air.”’——//rra/d. Illustrated, Cloth, $1.50 . , . . E. Nesbit’s The Railway Children “One of the most thoroughly satisfying books for and about children . . & most desirable book for the young people's holiday list.”"— Aerald With charming illustrations by C. E. Brock. Cloth, $1.50 Charles J. Bellamy’s The Wonder Children ‘Stories of marvels that have all the fascination of fairy tales, yet are ina modern setting in which science and invention play no small part.’’—Aaltimore American. Attractively illustrated. Cloth, $1.50 ravisbes THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “65 Ave. by be aatate ROSS i ole ¥ ado
Page 5
The Nation. NEW YORE, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 2%, 1906 The Week. The German Ambassador's appeal, at the New York Chamber of Commerce dinner, last week, for a square tariff deal must not be allowed to fall on deaf ears. His exposition of the great growth of the trade between the two countries should rouse to action even those who can be moved only by self-interest. A vast amount of exploration and _ ex- ploitation would have to be done in South America before our trade there could hope to reach the sum of $350,- 000,000, which represents the business to be done between Germany and the United States this year. Shall this be deliberately decreased? Moreover, the amount of money each country is per- manently investing in the other is stead- ily increasing. As a market for the sale of American bonds Germany has long attracted the attention of our capi- talists. To meet the growing demand, «a new bank in Berlin has just been started which will make a specialty of American securities and furnish accur- ate and up-to-date information to any German investor who thinks of purchas- ing our stocks and bonds. Every such enterprise will be hindered if there is a failure to agree on a_ reciprocity treaty. Continue on the present basis of unequal treatment we cannot. We must either improve matters by a new treaty or find ourselves at swords’ points; for Germany, if the existing modus vivendi is not renewed cr better- €a, will be forced by her other treaty ar- rangements to discriminate against us. Every manufacturers’ association and chamber of commerce in the country ought to be fighting for the very thing that Ambassador Sternburg asks. That there is to be a determined effort io pass the Ship Subsidy bill at the coming session of Congress is now ap- parent. The President will be urged to follow up the speeches of Messrs. Root | and Shaw with a recommendation in his annual message. In other words, the Republican leaders have failed to read the signs of the times. They are as fatuously disregarding the warning of the candidacies of Hearst and Moran as are our railway presidents. Neither of the two Secretaries seems to realize that the unrest among the voters is due to a desire to strike at special priv- ileges. The ship-subsidy measure is no- thing else than a bill to give special privileges to a few citizens, to induce them to embark in a business which would not pay for itself without Gov- ernment aid This sort of thing creates Socialists as quickly as any policy that | one of 1882 can be devised. If it is defensible, there are plenty of exporters engaged in risky enterprises that are equally entitled to Government aid. Though they do not send the they do the In one aspect, the ship-subsidy campaign is ill- ships abroad cargoes which must be carried. timed The Commissioner tion has just reported that if the pres- of Naviga- | ent rate of construction is not checked | by strikes or delays in steel, the out- | put of our shipyards will be the larg- This is hardly a reason why the shipyards should be al- est in half a century lowed to help themselves out of the pub lie Treasury. President Roosevelt Porto Ricans as “fellow-citizens.” is technically incorrect. They are not citizens of the United States Failure to give them a -they are only subjects. national status has been one of the L addressed the | This | most shocking cases of neglect of duty | by Congress. elling abroad is forced to undergo the Every Porto Rican trav- humiliation of declaring himself a man | without a country. can?” “No.” a Spaniard?” “No.” you?” “T am a Rico.” Mr. Roosevelt vas aware of this against one class of people under the American flag, and promised to do what he could to have it removed. He has What, then, are citizen of Porto showed that he discrimination “Are you an Ameri- | “Then you must still be | | needs before urged Congress to do the Porto | Ricans this elementary justice, but thus | far in vain. short Let us hope that even the | session of Congress will not be | too short to remedy this mean treat- | ment of our island wards. But it has been notoriously hard from the begin- ning to do what President McKinley called “our plain duty” to Porto Rico As a witty woman said at the time, the duty was so plain that it was actually repulsive We have been anxious to see sign of encouragement the Home Mar- ket Club would detect in the result of the late election, with its defeats and reduced patters.” At last banquet, James W. Van Cleave, president of the National suggested a truly thought. “T am not,” mediate revisionist, or a standpatter. I stand between the two. And I feel, especially since the election, that a large majority of the people are with me.” The programme he for the reconciliation of divergent views is as follows: Congress is soon to pass an week's comforting line of he said, “an im- proposes what | | session of che | the long e act creating a tariff commission like the Then all through the short rifty-ninth Congress and session of the Sixtieth, that commission is to pore over the Dingley schedules and take testimony as to what business interests desire Then, and not till then, namely, in the summer of 1908, the Republican party is to prom ise to revise the tariff. The people will vote in November for the Republican candidates, of course: and some time after March 4, will call Congress together and the sa 1909, the new President cred schedules will be touched at last The suggestion differs from that of, the “standpatter” only in deferring hope definitely for talking the “near future.” It differs from that of the sincere revisionist in that the latter would have the preliminary in made in the regular manner by) three years instead of vaguely about “next year” or quiry the Ways and Means and Finance Com mittees of House and Senate, and have the new tariff law signed by President Roosevelt, and not his unknown succes Cleave's sor President Van proposal! deserves the old lady's characterization as “a middle extreme The insistence by the junior Senator elect from Arkansas that what the Unit ed States Senate needs is a “good, old fashioned row,” is not for the public to pass over lightly We have heard about many things that the upper house better men, a higher sense of patriotism, less corporation money, les talk, election by the people, publicity for executive sessions, a larger member ship, a smaller membership, a_ redi tributed closure rule, the loss of control membership, an age limit, a over appointments, with a gain of prestige by the House. But “Jeff Davis now as serts that the real way to regeneration is through strife. He is going to tell the corporation-ridden graybeards just what he thinks of them, and right to What is more, he not going to spend a half-hour in bow every time he their faces, too ing and apologizing | touches a colleague on the raw A lit majorities for leading “stand- | Association of Manufacturers, tle more than ten years ago something along the same line was said by another new Southern Senator, every bit as ag gressive as Vardaman or Davis, ané with considerably more of a record than either one of them for stirring up af fairs at home. The question is, Wi!! our latter-day fire-eaters go the way of Tillman and the radicals who have pre ecded him? For six years to come they will sit daily in a company of sweet faced old faced old their tempers, and things in each gentlemen and impassive gentlemen never applaud the who never loss good other's speeche
Page 6
452 Can flesh and blood maintain righteous and flaming wrath in the face of it? Peer Gynt, fighting Bojgen in the dark, had an easy time by comparison. “Shak- ing up the Senate” is, in fact, fitly to be compared with that other achievement attempted about as often by new mem- bers, “reviving its oratorical traditions.” The boy orator is really half-brother to the shaker-up of dry bones; one expects to startle and amaze the Senate by what he says, the other by the way he says it. The Senate is used to both; it will not be ruffled by either. And if the new member is a sensible person, he will plunge into the routine of commit- tee work as Tillman and Beveridge have done, and presently find himself with a reputation among his critical fellows Edward H. Harriman’s statement that ‘the widest possible distribution of own- ership of railway properties is a most desirable thing,” will be applauded off- hand in many quarters, though there is another side of the question. In theory, no one would endorse’ the personal ownership of the great ma- jority of shares in the Union Pacific, with its numerous subsidiary proper- ties, by Mr. Harriman. Still less would people be pleased by the an- nouncement that Mr. Rockefeller, for instance, had in his own name all the shares of two or three competing trans- continental railways. The contrasting ideal, which the public would accept with the most complacency, would be such distribution of ownership, in safe hands, as is common in many smaller corporations, where no officer or “in- sider” holds, personally or through com- binations and affiliations, such a pre- ponderating portion in the stock that he cannot be unseated; and where, accord- ingly, officers and managers can be call- ed to account. We doubt, however, if this is exactly the sort of “distribution” which Mr. Harriman had in mind. No- body who is “running” a great corpora- tion to suit himself and his immediate associates, would approve such an ar- rangement Railway men are aware that the most convenient ownership is the holding of shares by a great number of individuals widely separated, none of them possessing enough to make his voice of importance in an annual meet Ing If votes for directors are cast at random, with the sole alternative of giv- ing proxies to the existing management, that management can readily dispense with such an empty formality as actual ly owning a controlling interest. If this lesson had not been learned before, our life insurance companies would have taught it. The defect of this “widest possible distribution” is that it leaves . very slight check on the errors or mis- deeds of a virtually self-perpetuating ex ecutive | deep religious feeling. Peary's own account of his winning | The Nation. the farthest north shows the achieve- ment to have been possible through an extraordinary combination of good luck and good management. The remark- able dash from the Roosevelt would have been in vain if at the last the con- dition of the ice had not permitted a matter of 130 miles to be made in a few days—an almost unexampled feat on the polar ice; and it is fair to add that the story of the new record would never have been told if Peary’s asso- ciates, equipment, and personal leader- ship had not been of the best. Indeed, the journey back over the crumbling ice to northern Greenland constitutes the most thrilling part of the narrative. Of the fifty-two days spent between the last land and the new farthest north, twelve were lost through storm or open water. In about 290 miles of actual sledging, the party, numbering at the last seven men and six teams, consum- ed forty days. Provisions were failing and the weaker dogs were being fed to the stronger, when the great oppor- tunity appeared. The six days’ storm, which had drifted the party seventy miles eastward to near longitude 65° west, had also beaten the snow into the crevices of the ice pack. Then an ex- traordinary march of more than thirty miles was made in a single day. A few days later the new record was made after a continuous march of twenty- four hours, ending on the noon of April 21 last. It is evident that, had not cir- cumstances favored this final spurt, it would have been quite impossible to pass Nansen’s mark of 86° 14’, not to mention the Duke of Abruzzi’s 86° 33’. On the other hand, it was a kind of luck upon which the gallant Peary had reck- oned, and by which he profited with foresight and daring. The history of Arctic exploration has no finer chapter. Yet the bearing of this expedition upon Polar exploration generally can only be surmised. It is clear that without the delay of twelve days on the march northwards which depleted the stock of provisions, and with equally favorable conditions at the end, Peary might read- ily have got, say, a hundred miles near- er the pole. When it is recalled how far North the Fram drifted, it would seem that a dash with sledges from such a fioating base might, under fortunate circumstances, bring some happy explor- er within considerably less than 200 miles of the pole. The getting back will always be the pinch, though some emu- lator of the unfortunate Andree may yet do the trick by balloon. Dr. Algernon 8. Crapsey's letter of withdrawal from the Episcopal Church is written in excellent taste and with Any Church would be the poorer for losing such a man. Such gifts as his are too rare in any communion. He makes it clear that [ Vol. 83, No. 2161 he was seeking neither notoriety nor martyrdom, but was, out of a sense of duty to others as well as himself, chal- lenging “an authoritative and deliberate decision” of the Church whether his views were permissible. Having now got it, he retires with dignity; but how can he say, as he does, that the judg- ment against him “affects no person” but himself, and urge the “hundreds of clergymen and thousands of laymen in the Episcopal Church who have reached the same conclusions that I have” to stay in the Church, where, Dr. Crapsey alleges, their “position is just as tena- ble as it ever was”? This seems to us to be in the interest neither of ecclesi- astical order nor of sound morals. Every clergyman must, of course, settle the question with his own conscience: but the idea that the progress of truth or the reform of the creed can best be ef- fected by remaining in a morally am- biguous position, is one to which we find it difficult to subscribe. The so-called honor system in col- leges has been much discussed of late. Championship of the system, it is to be noted, comes largely from the South. Many Southern professors declare that not only in examinations, but deport- ment generally, Southern students are bound by the honor of a gentleman. A similar sentiment, we are assured, frowns upon and keeps down horse-play in the classroom, “ragging” professors, ard other demonstrations that in too many colleges of the North are regard- ed as lawful recreations. The South, it is plain, is exceptionally blessed. Where a clear-cut student sentiment exists in support of a high code of ethics, facul- ties would be foolish, or worse, to run counter to it. The existence of such a sentiment, as a fixed tradition, is evi- dently far different from the deliberate attempt to create it. President Hyde's remarks in the Nation of November 15, for instance, apply not so much to the Southern institution, as to the honor system as consciously introduced in the North. He is right, we feel, in doubting if the results of the propaganda have - fulfilled its promise. The honor system in the North is weak precisely where the liberal régime in the South is strong —namely, in an aggressive student sen- timent to enforce it. President Hyde re- calls that in a college in which evidence of cheating is referred to a student tri- bunal, no evidence except that of the blue-books has ever been presented. This means either that for several years no student has ever seen a college mate cheating, or that the express agreement to report and discipline offenders has been persistently disregarded. So appar- ent is it that a certain amount of cheating has gone on that advocates of the system often rest merely on the as- sertion that there is less cheating, after all, than there was when the activity of ‘2 a ee
Page 7
pateetiees Nov. 29, 1906] proctors made it a kind of sport. If this be the case, it is clear that student sentiment remains pretty much what it was, and that the adoption of a system has not inculcated an effective sense of honor; it has nowhere evoked a public feeling so tonic and formidable as that which prevails south of Mason and Dix- on’s line. Prince Biilow’s second-day speech in the Reichstag passed from the general subject of German foreign policy to the means of carrying it out—the diplomat- ic service. He diverged into a witty discussion of the “new diplomacy,” made necessary by modern develop- ments. He said that he was in the hab- it of advising young diplomatists to take for their model Alcibiades. He was “intellectual with the Athenians, ate black broth with the Spartans, and wore flowing garments among the Per- sians.” Yet, what help, in the actual transaction of his business, does a dip- lomatic representative gain from being thought a jolly good fellow, or—in the United States—from having, what for- eign nations now seem to regard as in- dispensable, an American wife? Not much, we think. Of course, the person- al and social advantage is obvious. We all like approachable and interesting foreigners, whether of diplomatic rank or not; but because Sternburg lets Roosevelt beat him at tennis, are we to knuckle down to Germany in the tariff controversy? Because M. Jusserand is scholarly and affable, and Madame Jus- serand charming, are we the less stren- uously to protect Lodge’s bogus jewelry from competition with the real French article? Even if the suggestion that Mr. Bryce be made British Ambassador were carried out—and surely this country would receive him with open arms should we allow his great personal pop- ularity to weigh in settling the fisheries dispute? The expounders of the new diplomacy are mixing up two different things. An ambassador represents his own people. Therein, it is of the high- est importance that he should be agree- able, friendly, captivating—what you will. But he also represents his Gov- ernment. That is a business capacity. In the questions arising out of it, per- sonal charm has to give way to force of reason and the true interest of the two countries. Representatives of one people to another have a useful func- tion; the more gracious and sympa- thetic they are, the better. But for an insinuating Alcibiades-diplomat to pre- sume upon his personal acceptability as a ground for demanding governmental! favors, would be much like an amusing guest at a dinner suddenly asking his host for a loan. Berlin finds it difficult to predict what | The Nation. new phase the racial struggle in Prus- sian Poland may assume in conse quence of the sudden death of Dr. Flor ian von Stablewski, Archbishop of Po sen and Gnesen, which occurred on Sun- ' 453 Witte redivivus is bulking large now udays against the flat background of a | Characterless bureaucratic ministry—so much so that the reactionaries are de day. As an uncompromising champion | of the Poles in their resistance to the complete Germanization of the schools he made himself extremely to the Prussian Government. Neverthe less, to force the election of a German Archbishop in succession to Dr. Stablew ski, as the Kdlnische Zeitung strongly obnoxious urges, might only add to the bitterness‘ of the conflict. On the part of the Gov ernment, it would be carrying the wat into the enemy’s camp by threatening the very citadel of Polish influence and aspirations namely, the Catholi Church. What Catholicism means to the Poles is well expressed by the Paris Temps, which speaks particularly of the situation in Russian Poland, but makes no exception of Posen “People are converted, not to Catholicism, but to the ‘Polish faith.’”’ Entrance into the bosom of the Roman Church is so little an ac of religion, and so largely a_ political step, that it used to be common to hear “Were our country to achieve its freedom to Poles of the middle classes say morrow, we, too, could cry, Los von Rom; but the Roman Church is our great weapon in the struggle for the preservation of our national Iffe.” “The decision of the German naval au- thorities to use turbine engines here after is remarkable, because up to this time their prejudice against turbines has been strong. A complete reversal of judgment has taken place, and it will be interesting to see if the German merchant fleet will now indulge in ves sels thus propelled. Hitherto both the North German Lloyd and the Hamburg- American companies have stuck by th® reciprocating engine. England alone has sone in for the turbines whole-souled I) this her procedure has been charac teristic of the spirit of the Admiralty for some decades. Once convinced that ar invention is valuable, it invests in the device with British thoroughness This was true of the adoption of the torpedo boat and torpedo-boat destroy er. With the submarine the Admiralty delayed until France had a big start; but, once the conversion was effected, the building of submarines went on with astonishing rapidity With the turbines England again took the lead, and it will be years before any other country has a turbine battleship like the Dreadnought. At Washington the authorities are inexcusably indifferent to submarines and torpedo work of all kinds, being blinded by the craze for monster battleships. And the turbine engine has few, if any, friends in the Navy Department—not any more than had the origina! Monitor, and other in- ventions. | manding his expulsion from the coun try While Russia wes still suffering from the violent after-effects of the dis olution of the Duma, Witte was ill at a German watering place. With the estab lishment of comparative calm in the em pire, his tonsils are cured, and there some rumor of his being considered fo the post of Governor-General of Poland Why Witte should have become the ob ect of such universal 4d etestation 1 both easy and hard to understand. The reactionaries hate him as the author o Constitutionalism, and, in fact, as the originator of that ndustrial poli which has been the principal factor in the upbuilding of a revolutionary work ingmen’s party The Liberal elements were outraged by his attempt to mu afte popular representation on the eve And he encountered the common fate of the Neverthe of the meeting of the Duma trimmer in times of stress less, there is no denying that as an op portunist he has displayed remarkable skill, and he is still the only person in Russia that has accomplished anything definite and big It is not impossible that with time remembrance of his rather devious policy with regard to the Duma will fade, while the liberties he has been instrumental in gaining will plead for him when these liberties ar in danger of submersion Pope Pius has approved a Diocesan Association organized by the Cardinal Archbishop of Bordeaux, and it is an nounced that the French Gévernment will regard this body as a “cult associa If so, the way is open to reconciliation and to tion” under the Separation Act. putting an end to the present unseem ly squabbling over the inventory of church possessions. As in many cases involving personal dignity, the compro mise has a comic aspect Archbishop Lecot undoubtedly reports to Pius X that the Diocesan Association is organ ized under the old law, and in flat de fiance of the impious Separation Act Minister Briand, on the other hand, re ports to M. Clemenceau that a cult as sociation has been formed under the ' Separation Act. Moreover, the Diocesan Association which the Vatican accepts seems to be, but for the name, the asso ciation fabricienne which, though rec ommended by the French episcopate was summarily rejected by the Vati- can. In fine, the quarrel has very large ly had to do with names. It has been so serious, however, that one must heartily welcome an agreement if merely on the basis that the State is to 8a contentedly, while’ the intones tweedle- tweedledum Chureh persistently dee,
Page 8
SECRETARY ROOT ON SOUTH AMER- ICAN TRADE. Secretary Root’s second speech at Kan sas City dropped from diplomacy into trade, aS was natural in an address to a Commercial Congress Doubtless, many members looked upon his recent South American trip as that of a glori fled drummer, and expected a_ report from him accordingly They did not get that, but they did get a discussion of the whole question of our trade rela tions with the republics to the south of us, marked by the breadth of view which characterizes most of the Secre tary’s public utterances. We say this, though from some of his conclusions at Kansas City we strongly dissent His argument was for subsidizing steamship lines to South Amer'ca, but he first stated some of the antecedent obstacles to our developing a_ large South American trade and did it with a fairness seldom met with in the peeches of subsidy-advocates. Mr. Root frankly admitted that American manu facturers and exporters have gone about the business of catering to the South American market tn a blundering and back-handed They have not been willing to suit their goods to the fashion eustomer’s demand They have taken no pains to get agents who speak his language or know his ways. They have not been ready to adapt themselves to his usual system of credits; they have established no banking facilities of their own; have not thought of investments far-reaching and designed to secure low though increasing returns in en larged trade, but have wanted huge prof- i at onee, or have turned away in dis have had, finally, nothing but coutempt for the men whom they ex- gust: thes pect to buy their wares. All this Mr lioot admits. It is, indeed, an old story. lhe very consular reports have for years been filled with it. The Secretary thinks that, in time, we Americans will learn to “do our business abroad as we have done it at home, with force and energy,” but coneede that, as respects South \merica at least, we have not yet learn int bow The truth is, and it is a fair infer ence from Secretary Root's admissions, that what we have to deal with in this matter is a state of mind, more than a tate of trade. American policy has too long and too suecessfully discouraged attention to foreign commerce The habit of disregarding it has at last be come ingrained When the framer of the fiseal law under amiable Dingley which we live, could express the wish that the oceans surrounding us were of fire, so that no ships could cross, how can the average American be expected to give Intelligent attention to trade be yond the seas? In fact, he has not done so. The chief reason why we have not done better in South American trade The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2161 is that we have not thought it worth bothering about. All our energies and plans have been concentrated upon de- veloping our own vast territory—the greatest area in the world over which absolute free trade prevails. Upon that we have been taught to fix our eyes ex- clusively; while bidden by all that is patriotic to keep foreigners off it, and to have as little to do with them as possi- ble. Such an inveterate attitude cannot be changed in a day, though influences are, it is true, at work to change it. We are accumulating capital. We are multiply- ing our power of production, at the same time that we are reaching the limit of our own lands available for settle- ment. When the crest of our present wave of prosperity is passed, with its unprecedented demand at home, we shall undoubtedly be driven, by neces- sity, to turn our minds to the cultiva- tion of the foreign field. The main thing is to get American business men and investors seriously to bend their faculties to the subject. When they do, and the preliminary mental difficulty is overcome, we shall not hear so much of the invincible obstacle in the lack of mere ships. On the question of ship-subsidies it- self, Mr. Root did not appear to have informed himself with his customary care. He says, for example, that Ger- many has abandoned the policy of free ships. Since when? Within the year, one great German liner was turned out of an English shi, yard. Mr. Root also refers to the tariff provision allowing substantially free importation of ship- build'ng materials. If he had read the testimony in the Senate Committee re- port, he would have found that, in prac- tice, this law is entirely illusory. Yet the Secretary is wholly frank in grant- ihe that the protective policy has been disastrous to our shipping interests. He even defends a subsidy as but due “com- pensation for injuries inflicted upon American shipping by American laws.” It might occur to others first to remove those injuries. But that is not the way of the Socialist legislator, known as a protectionist. Having taken the taxpay- ers’ money to give one industry an un- fair advantage, his remedy is, not to undo that wrong, but to commit another by giving any one who complains (if he has political power enough) a share of the pickings. Mr. Root speaks only of a ship-sub- sidy for the South American trade. But does he imagine that the Ship Trust will allow money to be voted for that, with- out insisting that it be given ten times as much? On that point the Secretary might have consulted the pending bill to advantage. And as for his idea that a subsidized South American line would instantly create business, has he forgot- ten the old scandals of the Pacific Mail subsidy, and the complete failure of the subsidized steamers to Brazil to pro mote any business except that of the lobbyist and Congressional corruption- ist? A “PROGRESSIVE” PARADISE. In the recent borough elections in London, something like a political revo- lution occurred. The “Progressives,” who for some years had been carrying everything before them, were unexpect- edly routed. Control of borough after borough was won by the “Moderates”; and it is confidently predicted that this result foreshadows a similar defeat for the Progressives in the coming elec- tions to the London County Council. The Progressives are, of course, the ad- vanced municipal experimenters, of so- cialistic leanings, in close alliance with the Labor Party and affiliated generally with the Liberals; the Moderates act with the Conservatives. Thus this up- set in the boroughs may have important political consequences of a national sort. Mr. Balfour has, in fact, hailed it as a sign of a speedy Conservative revival; the wisest Liberals do not deny its sig- nificance. Now, what was the cause of this marked change of heart in London vot- ers? Tax-bills. The management of the affairs of the boroughs was becoming fearfully extravagant. Lavish borrow- ing was the order of the day, to keep up with the costly application of social- istic theories. The rates were going up, and were bound to go much higher, un- less a halt was called; and the rate- payers did, in the election, imperatively call a halt. In several of the boroughs there were also scandals, the exposure of which bad something to do with the revulsion against the Progressives. On the demand of aggrieved rate-payers, an official inquiry was made into the ad- ministration of the Poor Law in Pop- lar. This is a metropolitan union sig- nalized by Charles Booth ten years ago as the least pauperized of the ten which he grouped as “specially devoted to manufacture and trade.” To-day, as the investigation showed, it is the most pauperized; while it has incurred so great a debt that there is now no suf- ficient security for further loans. How this unhappy change was brought about, is shown in detail by the report of the chief inspector of the Local Government Board, J. S. Davy. It has just been issued as a Blue Book. The story is a depressing'one of bad management, careless waste, and use of the public funds in a way to extend the very evils to be checked. This condition of affairs is the more significant in that William Crooks, the well-known Labor member of Parliament, was one of the Poplar guardians. Thus it was under the most Progressive auspices that the paupers have increased fourfold, while the rates have jumped up almost as eet G Be 2 tigi te arian tte: apenas Nama a
Page 9
Nov. 29, 1906] The Nation. ominously. Early in 1904, the reliev- | Socialism?’ That its cost will be great, | ing officers had orders to grant outdoor relief to all applicants without insist- ing upon a labor test. The result was that the weekly cost rose from $450 to $1,500, though Inspector Davy reports that “there is good ground for thinking that the high figures of relief were arti- ficial, and in no way represented the real need.” Many cases of flagrant abuse were un- earthed. A typical instance is that of a certain Mrs. Carey, one of a deputa- tion of unemployed women whom Pre mier Balfour received a year ago. She asserted that her husband was a dock laborer, seldom employed more than two days a week. They had six small children; and Mrs. Carey declared: “If something is not done, we shall have to eat one another, or else there will be bloodshed.” Relief was given to this family by the guardians without inves- tigation; but the official inquiry brought out the fact that Carey had earned $14 during the week preceding his wife’s call upon Mr. Balfour, and that his average weekly earnings during 1904 and 1905 were nearly $10. Management of the Poplar workhouse was so lax as practically to put a pre- mium upon being a tramp. A generous dietary was provided—better, as Mr. Crooks admitted, than that of the self- supporting laborer. Tobacco and beer were freely supplied. This was against all rules, but the irregularity was got over by means of a medical certificate, that, in many cases, beer was necessary for reasons of health. How- ever, when the medical examiner was called before the inspector, he testified that so much pressure was put upon him by the guardians that he could not refuse to give the certificate. But after the official inquiry, such certified beer almost ceased to exist. This may have been hard on the inmates, but it at least removed temptation from the guardians, some of whom had been seen on the workhouse premises drunk. Poplar had also a farm-colony in Es- sex, where a hundred acres were pro- cured and accommodation provided for 50 men. A summary of the report adds: saying They had three meat meals a day, with allowances of tobacco; and, as a farm of that size cultivated by plough in the or- dinary way would not occupy more than four or five men, only spade labor was employed, the land being dug over and over again to give some pretence of work, how- ever useless. The discipline was very lax; the chief constable of Essex complained of the conduct of the inmaies, many of whom had convictions against their names Naturally, the experiment proved a total failure. Such a concrete experience as this teaches its own lessons, and asks its un- answerable questions. The hardest of these ts, “Who will pay the bills of is admitted by its more intelligent ad vocates. Ordinary taxes will not begin to cover it Hence, as John Graham Brooks has pointed out in the Novem- ber Atlantic, English Socialists are frankly fiscatory going over to the plan of con- They take anywhere from 10 to 15 per cent. of the fortunes of the rich thankful that them But an first be necessary, cannot how taxes. propose to who ought to be anything at all is of Parliament if the con duly left will fiscators act and even elect a borough council, are they going to get a majority in the House of Commons’ THE FOOTBALL SEASON The football season just ending has | | been distinguished by a great improve ment in the from the point of view of both players and spectators. The game new rules have been successful in “cpening up” — A55 according to So far as accidents go, the Chicago Tribune's figures, the death roll has been decreased to eleven while the serious injuries have fallen from 159 to 104. It is, of course, im possible to say whether the total num ber of players this vear was greater or less, but probably the proportion of seri ous injuries has been smaller It seems to be established, too, that the elimina tion of mass-play has decreased the ris) among whom That the disappear so of accidents to schoolboys still.occur most of the deaths danger of accident will long as mer must come into violent per sonal contact is not to be expected \ bad fall while running in a broken field disastrous as being or fifteen hazard may be quite as doubled up under ten excited players But the has been | slightly reduced the play, in giving larger | opportunity to the individual player, and in making it possible for those vatching to follow the ball as in early days of American football The for ward pass and the onside kick have added an interest and necessitated a skill lacking of late vears. Most im- | portant of all, brains are now at a pre- mium, instead of brawn The fat, un wieldy players of a year ago have given lighter and it is no longer a question of battering ram line-plunges, with both teams piled upon the man with the ball, or of wear attacks takes head way to more active men ing out opponents by incessant upon one or two players. It work and strategy now to win, as was clearly proved at New Haven on Satur- day There the Harvard team, perfect in its line defence and superior in the old-fashioned football and in kicking, was easily defeated by the daring and the excellent tactics of the Yale eleven —wonderfully trained in the new rules by the master-coach, Walter Camp. More than that, the spirit of the play ers has somewhat improved; they have behaved this year slightly more like gen- tlemen. This advance is not due to the extra official provided by the new rules, because in most games both cap- tains have declined to avail themselves of the added umpire, a bad example which Harvard and Yale did not follow on Saturday. There is such need of this extra umpire that his presence should be made compulsory, if only to enforce the new and complicated rulcs. On every one of the large college teams, this year, save Cornell’s, one or more men have been disqualified for foul play, which in past years would have been overlooked. Nevertheless, we must ad- mit that this season, at least, there have been reported no flagrant cases of biting, gouging, or maiming. But, as F. S. Bangs of Columbia has -pointed out, there is still room for improvement. | be influenced by objections to football President Eliot bettered The general remain unchanged that the game has been but he welcomed the forded by the recent dinner to the Har has noted opportunity af vard crew to declare again for athletics of which the changed from nis and rowing are, in his opinion, the for intercollegiate moreover that it break rules do not have to be year to year. Lawn ten only sports fit con He is, as saying reported § this would do Har off athletic re with tests week “no harm to Yale, or a sentimenf in vard lations with even every other university” which we most heartily concur. To our minds Columbia nothing much by her abolition of intercollegiate that her themselves to has lost and gained fcotball, and we trust govern ing bodies will not allow the clamor of the the un dergraduates for restoration of the combats Changes in rules, more bona-fide umpires sironger insistence upon stu dents as Yet they do not the intercollegiate the scrption of the undergraduates, the spec players, are all well enough touch real vice of matches utter ab tacular character of the struggles, the huge money stake, the newspaper no toriety—in short, the total disproportion ot athletics to studies in the college world. Faculties and athletic tees have meekly submitted to the dom ination of the athletes: the scandals about professionalism, about hired out siders, and financial mismanagement, are all too well known to bear repeti tion here. These evils must be grappled with and eradicated, for they are clear evidence that the great intercollegiate contests no longer serve the purpose for which they intended—the atim vlating of the mass of undergraduate to beneficial exercise commit were TASTE VS. RULE IN ENGLISH The formal rule of grammar has lost much of its authority as an arbiter of English expression. Little of positive
Page 10
456 law is left in the linguistic Israel, and each may use without serious let or hindrance whatever form of speech is right in his own eyes. It is not the man who defies the grammarian that is put on the defensive to-day, but rather the one who is over-conspicuous in observ- his dictates. Theoretically, formal rammar should be merely the succinct tement of the facts of good usage. I ractically, the limits of good usage are lways too vague to admit of succinct latement with any approach to scien- tifle accuracy, The difficulties in the way of a scientifically unassailable code c{ “good English” are insurmountable, even for a single brief period, to say rothing of the fact that the best usage of one decade may differ in scores of particulars from that of the next. The downfall of the Harveys and Pinneos of cur childhood, therefore, is due not sim- ply to their many mistakes in points where accuracy was readily attainable. The most carefully elaborated code of rules based upon the usage of a former neration could not be rigidly fitted to he best English of the present. The growing appreciation of this plas city, even among the most highly cul- tivated and careful writers and speak- ol makes it unlikely that the credit of rules of grammar as such will ever be fully restored, even with scholarly and unceasing revision. Only a few of the most fundamental and persistent fucts of expression will be left to the cogmatie method. For all beyond that the dependence will be upon the cultiva- on of taste rather than the memoriz- nz of rules Unfortunately, however, rere emancipation from cramping rules does not implant the germs of good taste A newly realized freedom may mpt to lieense In language as readily 4 in anything else. The readiness with(4 which even educated people fall into ing proves that the current lack of re. wet for the rules of linguists has pass- ed with many to the point of disrespect or language itself. Quintilian’s pious iration of reverencg for speech as t «ift of the gods which most sharp- distinguishes man from the lower nimals would seem strained to-day; it as compared with the opposite ex- treme there can be no question which likely to make language of the greater service ifttitude | The fundamental position of critics like Professor Lounsbury, who have been brushing away the Iill-supported claims of the grammars and dictionaries to final authority, has been widely mis- understood, In showing that the split infinitive, for instance, has been used sporadically by good English writers for centurtes past, Professor Lounsbury has neither proved nor tntended to prove that good English usage demands the uniform insertion into the infinitive of all that it can be made to hold. His warfare is against the habit of dogmatic The Nation. assertion that no good writer would use such or such an expression, when the archives of literature show that vari- ous writers of incontestably good stand- ing have done so. But while he is not to blame for the blithe readiness of his fellow-citizens to overdraw their account at the bank of logic, the fact of this readiness perhaps puts the responsibil- ity upon men like him, teachers of Eng- lish possessed of national reputation and influence, to do positive work upon the ground which has so effectively been cleared of the jerry-built grammatical structures of the past. To many, Pro- fessor Lounsbury has seemed to prove that all things are lawful; may we not | look to him now for some positive aid | | to bewildered teachers and pupils in our schools in determining what is or is not expedient? Lowell once defined the ideal of Harvard as the development in her students of “that good taste which is the conscience of the mind, and that conscience which is the good taste of the soul.” Something akin to this is wanted in the special realm of language, if the passing of the grammatical deca- logue is not to be signal for linguistic anarchy. Only the exceptional child is born into a circle where, because of the absence of anything but good models to imitate, it learns no habits of speech but the best. The great majority must acquaint themselves with good English, if at all, against the influence of daily surround- ings, and chiefly by the study of writ- ten models. But the study of models, unfortunately, is a deceptive process. It is not alone the Browning or Whitman enthusiast who will wistake a charac- teristic blemish for a peculiar mark of yirtue; and blemishes, as the Roman ‘rhetorician noticed centuries ago, are much easier to imitate than virtues. Then, too, even in its most perfect achievement, a mere superficial imita- tion is so evidently undesirable that willingness to attempt it is a pretty plain evidence of mental weakness. The study of models for the cultivation of style can be a safe reliance only as the student learns’ to see through the surface to underlying principles, and then to apply those principles with a strict regard to difference of subject and circumstance. JAs a guide to that kind of study, there is room for a critical analysis of representative authors some- where between the broad sweep of such essays as Lowell's appreciation of Mil- ton or Spenser, and the inadequate and pedantic treatment found in the typical school or college text-book. If the chief agents in the final removal of the false guide-boards of the past will but blaze a possible path to good English in this direction, they will win the gratitude of many who find themselves for the pres- ent decidedly bewildered by the loss of the old and faulty authorities. [Vol. 83, No. 2161 THE BOOKS OF A POET AND BIBLI- OGRAPHER. The library of the late Richard Gar- nett, Keeper of the Printed Books of the British Museum, is soon to be put up at auction in London. The catalogue is of no slight interest to bibliophiles, rep- resenting as it does the personal pref- erences and accumulations of a trained bibliographer, who was also a poet and a critic. Garnett was a man who knew both the outsides and insides of books as few men of our time. His long ser- vice at the British Museum gave him an intimate knowledge of the book mar- ket, and the best facilities both for pur- chase and collation. It is curious, then, tc note that he was personally very lit- tle of a bibliophile, being apparently, with all his love of books, devoid of any insatiable desire of personal possession. Rarities bought as such were exception- al on his shelves. As he was a poet and the friend of poets, presentation copies came naturally his way. One finds, for example, gifts ranging all the way from Coventry Patmore to William Watson. In fact, such records of friend- ship give color to the whole collection. But it is strange to note that so famous a specialist on books possessed, for ex- ample, practically no incunabula, and only such early printed books—few at that—as served his historical studies. A sound psychological reason for this void may be found in his daily routine. Clearly, early printing and quaint title- pages could make little appeal to the mere curiosity of one behind the scenes in the British Museum. It seems as if abundance of knowledge had chastened any collector’s covetousness he may have been born with. For a Garnett, the quais of Paris and the back streets of Florence could have afforded few surprises. He could presumably hardly remember a time when he first thrilled at the sight of old stamped. pigskin, or an illegible scrap of manuscript bound into a sixteenth-century tome. All these things were from youth a part of his work, and he seems to have purged himself of the gnawing desire that mas- ters your true amateur. On the other hand, there came easily to him treasures for which many of us put our bank accounts and consciences in pawn. A grandson of Coleridge gave him the annotated Ariosto of “S. T. C.” Shelley’s son gave him three manu- script notebooks of the poet, containing, besides the “Ode to the West Wind,” unpublished memoranda for “Adonais,” “The Cenci;” and “Charles I." It was a rather poor return for this courtesy that Garnett made in later years by un- earthing and republishing one of Shel- ley’s well-forgotten juvenile romances. But it was ever difficult to keep the cult of Shelley in the grooves of com- mon sense. Garnett was no more a vic- tim of excessive piety than many an- 4 ae Sante OP Cas be.
Page 11
Nov. 29, 1906] other worshipper at this flickering shrine. It is to his credit, however, that he used a greater discretion with regard to the Shelley notebooks, which remain in great part undivulged—properly so, we presume. Curiously enough, for so convinced a Shelleyan, Garnett had nev- er been foresighted enough to secure the contemporary first editions of his idol. although his collection of biograph- ical material was extensive. Again, ready access tq the penetralia of the British Museum explains much. Beyond a small group of pamphlets and baoks relating to the British Mu- seum and to Dante, the library differs from that of the average scholarly gen- tleman chiefly in those presentation copies that we have already mentioned. Thomas Hardy, Richard Jefferies, and George Meredith are the brightest names in this list, though few of the younger British writers failed, at one time or another, to pay some tribute of respect to their learned colleague. Inscribed copies from foreign writers and schol- ars are surprisingly rare, for the keep- er’s duties brought him little in contact with readers at the Museum. Those who have had occasion to consult him by letter can testify to his unfailing courtesy and serviceableness. As befitted a high official at a vener- able ‘ibrary, his sympathy with what are called the newer movements appears to have been defective. To him, prob- ably, the nouveau jeu was represented by the writers for the Germ, of which bibliographical treasure he had an orig- inal copy. It is a little surprising, then, to find that his file of the Yellow Book is complete; but this is due possibly to the fact that he was a contributor, hav- ing been chosen, apparently, to ballast with his name and erudition that de- cidedly whimsical enterprise. In gen- eral, Garnett’s concession to modernity seems to have been the minimum prac- ticable for a titular critic. This appears in a singular omission in his scanty collection of Americana. It is probable that no other British critic of equal repute would fail to have a copy of Walt Whitman. But to the “Good Gray Poet” and the tedious literature sur- rounding him, Garnett appears to have been blessedly oblivious. Upon American literature, indeed, Garnett seems to have had the old-time notions. Like many Englishmen of lib- eral stamp, he was an Emersonian, pos- sessing two sets of the works; other- wise his American library consisted largely of Edmund Clarence Stedman's “American Anthology” and an edition of Poe, the gift of Prof. George E. Wood- berry, one of the editors. Hawthorne is unrepresented, and Lowell also. But Garnett was interested in that under- valued American writer, Herman Mel- ville, owning not only a copy of “The Whale” (“Moby Dick”), but also the two volumes of the remarkable, if un- The Nation. read, religious poem. “Clarel age to the Holy Land.” Such an excursion in these reward- ing but little known fields suggests that Garnett never fylly lost the adventur- ous spirit that makes a good reader. It is clear that he never really regarded There have un- a Pilgrim- himself as a collector. questionably been great librarians who were also great collectors, but in gen- eral it seems that the ideal bibliograph- er must cultivate a _ disinterestedness alien to the apparently kindred pursuit of bibliopolism. CONFERENCE ON SECONDARY EDUCA TION IN THE SOUTH CHARLOTTESVILLE, Va., November 24 On Friday and Saturday there met at the University of Virginia the State un versity presidents, the State superintend ents of public instruction, and the uni versity professors of secondary education from Virginia, North Carolina, South Caro Alabama, and lina, Georgia, Tennessee Among other guests were the United States Commissioner of Education, secretary of the General Education Board of New York president of the University of Texas, pres idents of the Virginia colleges, five State examiners of Virginia, Dr. S. A. Knapp of | i i or two papers ar ADT results, and to decide on definite plat the future The sessions were not public, and the discussions were free and informal! Each general topic was first presented in on 1 then considered by the conference as a whol The morning Friday was spent on the question, “In what definite ways may the State Department of Education further the establishment and development of a system of pul high schools?’ The State superintendents lined conditions the [ e Sta and suggested plar for im ving conditions It was evident that tl law and traditions of the iif | too diverse to allow uniform pla here are variations in the taxes for schools—by county court or ec ty commissioner by lire« v rf people ete.; ther ire varia minimum and maximum of achool tax {| mitted by law there are var t local school units d rict townshly county there are variations tl i t ity of local and State school boards. So of the six States already have high hool laws; others have non Some allow high schools to be supported out of the general school fund; others require spe il taxa tion. In spite of these difference the d issions resulted in establishir principles of importance: the necessity | State supervision of high school the va Louisiana, D. J. Crosby of the United States | Department of Agriculture, and Professor Lockhead of MacDonald College, Canada The object of this meeting was to con sider the present condition of public high schools in the six States above mentioned to plan a coéperative campaign for the establishment and moré® public high schools, to draw up bills on the subject for legislative enactment, and to work out the general principles of or development of ganization, supervision, and support. It was peculiarly fitting that a gathering of this kind should be held at the university founded by Thomas Jefferson as the cap stone of the public school system, includ- ing free high schools within the reach of every child. This complete system of pub- lic education has not yet‘been realized in Virginia or in the South, though the West ern States have carried out Jefferson's ideals with remarkable success ent high school movement in the South is intended to give to this section similar The pres- school advantages to those now enjoyed elsewhere The conference was the direct outcome of the General Education Board's interest ir Southern educational progress This board is contributing to six universities the salaries and expenses of the profes- sors of secondary education, who are the leaders in the high school campaign For the last year these men have been study- ing the situation in their respective States, have been organizing high schools at “strategic points,”’ and have. directed the educational enthusiasm of officials, teachers, and citizens, to this particular need. The monthly report of each pro- fessor has been manifolded at the board's office in New York, and sent to the other professors in order that the experience of each may aid the work of all. After a year of such beginnings, this confer- ence was called in order to systematize of State appropriations to promo self-help, the emphasis to be put upon both county (or township) and district ipport the need of opening high schools in towns and villages to children of the rural com munities, the advisability of starting wit three grades of high schools, et The afternoon was devoted to the rela tions of the State university and the pro fessors of secondary education to the pub- lic high schools. The professors reported on the work so far done by them, and plans were made for further advance In the evening a reception was given to members of the conference by the faculty and students of the University of Virginia Saturday morning was devoted to agricul ture in the high school, papers being read by Dr. Knapp and Mr. Crosby, and discuss ed by Professor Lockhead It was the opinion of the Conference that a creditable course in agriculture, suited to lo al condi tions, should be a part of the curriculum of every rural high school At there are in Alabama nine district agricul present ‘ tural high schools, supported by the State The last Georgia Legislature appropriated | to eleven district agriculture high schools, to be located at accessible points, certain fees that will give each district about $6,000 a vear The amount and teaching in the high school were taken up methods of in the afternoon, there being some 4 ence of opinion as to the place of na al Then followed the of science in such schools discussion of the agencies and methods training teachers for the public high schools in the South The present meagre opportunities for preparing these teachers were outlined and means suggested for meeting present needs The evening was spent in an informal talk about various matters brought up in former sessions The present conditions of public high schools in these six States are on the whole
Page 12
458 The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2161 encouraging; and the large number of pri- has greatly aided in deficiencies high schools supplying past and rhrough a $50,000 legislative appropriation vate present of last March, the Virginia State Board of Education has organized one hundred and forty-nine new public high schools The tniversity of Georgia has so used its ac- erediting system as to develop fairly good high schools in most of the towns of the State Tennessee is rapidly organizing county high schools at convenient centres, open to all the children in the county North Carolina, South Carolina, and Ala bama are not so well advanced in regard to high schools, attention having been con- centcated on the building up of an efficient of elementary schools. Of course, ystem the cities throughout the South have for years had public high schools of various grades of efficiency The present move- ment is not for them, except indirectly; it is for the small towns in the rural dis- tricts, thus equalizing the advantages in the different sections of the State The next fiVe years in the South will witness uch a growth of elementary and secondary education, as will affect every phase of Southern life and achievement ° | Correspondence. THE CASE OF THE TWENTY-FIFTH IN- FANTRY. To Tne Eprror or THe NATION: Sin Whatever the provocation, and confessedly it was the moral one of an- tipathy, not a physical imposition, shots were fired from the gallery of one of the barracks in Fort Brown into a neighbor- ing dwelling beyond the wall, and almost simultaneously other shots were fired into the town from the vicinity of two other occupied barracks Immediately, and as if by prearrangement, an armed party, variously from ten to fifteen, scaled the wall and began to fire into the estimated at house of near-by residents There cer- talnly was no present provocation of any sort. One man was killed and one wound- ed within a building; a police officer who had no arms in his hands was gravely wounded in the street, and his horse was killed; and very many shots were fired with intention tnte houses where women and children were sleeping and men and women were sitting quietly. It is clear murderous assaults with firearms were made by the concerted ac- tion of a number of soldiers acting ip di- reot deflance of military regulations and in that unprovoked violation of civil law As a military offence, it subversive of all approached mutiny in nically. Why were not apprehended? Besides was not only discipline, but closely spirit if not tech- these men at once the general over- sight of a company exercised by its first sergéant, a non-commissioned officer is al- ways in charge of each barrack, whose particular duty it is to preserve order and to eee that the public property is not mis- The arms are always kept in lock- ammunition is in the of the men only when specially The stain of firing may readily removed where there are treflities, but used ed hands gun-racks, and served be a dozen or more rifles cannot be cleaned in the of the night without at- tracting attention, any more than they could be surreptitiously removed withoulty observation. Officers might readily fail to anticipate such an outbreak from troops whose pre- vious record had been good, and who had been stationed there less than a fortnight. Whether after its occurrence the officers did or did not at once do what they should to discover the guilty, is beside present question. That question is: is possible to be done, when disci- is so far subverted that an entire known to contain such lawless substitutes for the its own middle the What pline battalion, dangerous men, manifest requirements of justice code for the concealment and protection of the guilty? It is morally certain that each company contained rioters whom non- participants could, if they would, pick out. suppose that those non-commissioned officers, or the most of the privates, would hesitate to denounce cowardice in action, or, if possible, to ap- prehend a deserter going over to the ene- my. To class the obduracy that refused in any way to assist the three successive inspectors with the code that restrains a boy from “peaching’” upon a schoolmate who transgresses a master’s regulation, is and It is preposterous to more than illogical; it t wicked. That the receiver is as bad as the thief is no more true than that an accomplice after the fact is fairly particeps criminis. Dis- charge without honor, clearly within the President's authority, is mild punishment for men so lost to military pride. They sacrifice nothing but the privilege of wear- ing the uniform they have disgraced. A false loyalty of comradeship has made them disloyal to the military service, and through it to the nation, and has gen- erated a conspiracy of criminal silence that in anticipation would have been thought incredible. ALFRED A. WOODHULL. Princeton, N. J., November 23. “peaching,” in so far as minor offence, was un- happily chosen. We have no desire to minimize the crimes of the _ riotous negro soldiers. No one can denounce their lawlessness in terms too severe for our amen. The point which we wish to emphasize is that in the present con- dition of sentiment, in the army and out, regarding informers of all kinds, the refusal of the soldiers to tell who did the shooting is scarcely surprising, though it is none the less deplorable. We feel that under the circumstances a wholesale punishment by dishonorable discharge serves the ends neither of jus- tice nor of discipline.—~-Ep. Nartion.] (The word it suggests a THE HONOR SYSTEM IN COLLEGE AND OUT. To THE EprTrorR or THe NATION: Stn: President Hyde's letter in the Na- tion of November 15 touches the core of a matter where cause and effect are per- sistently confused. Whether in college or out of ite the recognition, even implicitly, of the possibility of a double standard of honor is an ethical blunder. The so-called “honor system,"’ as sometimes understood, proceeds upon a supposition that the laws of organized society exist not to protect the honest man, but to terrorize him into good behavior. It harks back to the law of the jungle, where each beast takes what he can. There is no more a divergence of in- terests between faculty and students than there is between the judges on the Su- preme Bench and any law-abiding citizen” It is just as much to the interest of one as the other in each case that a male- factor—whether the forger of a cheque or the would-be thief of a ‘B.A. degree—be promptly detected and punished. As one who has had only a limited chance, and that some time ago, to observe the workings of the “honorsystem”’ in jexam- inations, I am willing to defer to those who have had more experience. If a system is ethically gound and also the most practi- cable, it is to be welcomed. But first of all, we must clear the atmosphere of the befogging fallacy that students may be ex- pected to cheat if watched. An honest man, we repeat, has no quarrel with either policeman or judge, with proctor or pro- fessor. Why should he have? We must also indignantly reject the plan, sometimes introduced, that the instructors, having turned such matters over to others, must ~~ be oblivious to fraud. No one can shift his responsibility altogether All are guardians of the law. It is a question af mahhood suffrage. Personally, I believe that maturer minds are best fitted to weigh evidence. A jury of students might, per- haps, impose the penalty. i But what concerns us primarily is not the particular system adopted, but the attitude assumed by all concerned, and Mr. Hyde has done a public service in mak- ing this general attitude clear, One might wish, however, that he had stated one point in different language. By way of showing that honor is not a thing to be confined to examinations he urges that the students in. Southern colleges should cease to “look lightly” on “sexual offences” which leave on character more lasting scars than “cheating in examinations."”” Whether or no Southern students are essentially worse in this respect than Northern students I will leave to the inipartial statistician, but this chiastic contrast of sins will, I fear, distract the attention of some readers from the main thesis. What one should empha- size is that, while immorality of the one sort undermines a man’s fitness for socie- ty, the habit of “cribbing” in examinations waquid logically be fit training for the de- faultere Many of the protests of “Protestantism” were based upon sound reason, and the pro- test against legal oaths made by the Quak- ers is germane to this discussion as assert- ing that a man’s word is too sacred to be nullified by a child’s reservation of “over the left” or to be reinforced by an oath on the Bible. For college haziness in regard to moral standards the students have not always been solely to blame. In a certain college catalogue, from the years 1891-2 to 1896-7, used to occur a formula administer- ed to entering undergraduates, beginning: “We, the undersigned, do individually ‘for oursélves promise, without any mental res- ervation, that”... and closing: “We also declare that we regard ourselves bound to keep this promise and on no account what- ¥ >
Page 13
Nov. 29, 1906] The Nation. ever to violate it.”” This surprising recog- nition of a succession of mental reserva- tions has been for some years, I believe, discarded by the in question Unfortunately, there still survives, even among some members of our college facul- ties, the notion that the ordinary criminal law ceases to be applicable to the student during the four years of his college life. This survival of an ancient privilege is mischievous anachronism. College students claim the privileges of indepen- dent living; they must accept its responst- institution now a bilities. FRANCIS G. ALLINSON. Brown University, Providence, November 21 To THe EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: President Hyde of Bowdoin under- states the case, I think, when he says, in your issue of November 15, that the “honor system” is of long standing in “several Southern colleges.”’ It is so, I think, im nearly all Southern colleges—at least in nearly (if not quite) all of the best repute And he might have added that no college (North or South) has ever tried this system in good faith without satisfaction with the results. I regret the phrase “honor system.”’ There It simply the Its application to exam- as I now do no such ‘“‘system.”’ is honor principle. inations is only one of its aspects, and by no means the most important As I un- derstand this “honor principle,’’ it is, above all, the obligation to truthfulness and hon- esty—not in examinations gly, but every- where. Its test is the scorn of a lie, every- where, as unmanly, cowardly, disgraceful If I am at all right this conception I cannot agree with President Hyde that this sentiment should “come to the surface” “only under suchstirring experience as love or war.” On the contrary, it should be everywhere present and potent, in the least as well as in the greatest things. I sympathize with that Southern student who inquired in advance whether the exam- ination was to be conducted honor or not. If | am trusted, I am under the obli- gation of honor to be worthy of confidence, If I am under espionage or suspicion, I rec- ognize no such obligation (beyond my own is in on self-respect). If the principle means: “You crib if you. can; I catch you if I can,” 1 shudder to think of its in- fluence upon character, not only during student life, but upon the standards -of ‘conduct and business in after years. colleges should at least set the highest ideals of conduct, even if imperfectly at- tainable. The honor system, I admit, is far from perfect in results, but it is at least an effort to recognize what is best. I write this with the most profound re- spect for President Hyde, to whose exam- ple and to whose writings I have been ac- customed to look for the highest ethical ideals. I am well aware that I have no authority to set against the weight of his name. But I have a long and wide ex- perience, and, at the end of it all, in spite of all shortcomings, an unshaken faith in the essential honor and honesty of Ameri- can youth, if they are treated honorably and trusted as gentlemen. I have seen this very confidence transform character. Let President Hyde try it at Bowdoin—for just one year—with faith, with patience, with forbearance. I venture to predict that he Oure would add his testimony to that of all oth ers who have so tried it EDWARD S. JoYNes University of South Carolina, ¢ November 18 ACQUIRING A TASTE FOR LITERATURE To THE EpiTroR or THE NATION Sir: Your litera ture in the schools confirm n in feel ing that to live with people who know the great of English and volumes of set articles on teaching WY writers is worth hours instruction Just here may I venture upon something were hard for they made personal? My father and mother working with little time thing but toil time to read people, any yet, loving books them; and of their experience | made an atmosphere of healthy interest for North of Samuel Spring was pastor, there children In the Church Dr had been founded a library where the mem their which bers of the parish had access to the works of Addison, Pope, and Locke, of Goldsmith These books For Sunday reading we and Johnson were in a case in the vestry own- ed a few volumes Bunyan, “Paradise Lost,”"’ with some narrow religious me moirs. We learned much of the Bible by heart Pierpont Ss Readers gave us lessons extracts in prose and verse from some of the best writings, English and American [Doubtless there was much in the earlier reading that was beyond us; but enough was made ours to become a priceless pos- session, and to prepare the way for fuller apprehension of, not less than the delight in, the literature of later years.] I cite these facts, not as exceptional, but as instances of how workers for daily bread improved the small time at their command, and how greatly the sum of hap piness was increased for themselves and their children. I have many similar cases in mind. There is a mistaken notion that the common people are debarred apprecia- tion of our literature, except as it comes through school and college L Newburyport, Mass., November 15 Notes. The Oxford University Press has now ready a “Life of Frederick York Powell, with a Selection from his Letters and Oc- casional Writings,” by Oliver Elton. With his frien¢-1ips and enthusiasms and in- satiable curiosity, Powell ought afford material for an unusual biography to The Sproul Company is issuing the “‘Uni- versity Press Shakespeare’ in forty vol- umes. Sidney Lee furnishes a General In- troduction and notes, the latter at the foot of the pages. Various well-known writers contribute Introductions to the separate plays. The Cambridge text is used by ar- rangement with the Macmillan Company. Longmans, Green & Co. are printing an adaptation, by P. A. Barnett, of Goffeaux's “De Robinsone Crusoéo,”’ which is nothing less than a Latin version of our well-known Robinson. The new edition is adapted for young readers. Two volumes of the ‘Thesaurus Linguae Latinae” have appeared, the inter- national committee in charge of the work and | of 459 t irranged to issu the third volume under charge of tt general editor, Dr Lommatzsch of Munich Dr Alfred Gieseck of the firm of G. B. Teubner, re ently established a f vielding five thousand marks a vea the interests of the Work Prescott still continues to be read. which is praise that can be given to very few the historians Thomas Y. Crowell @& Co. have brought out a library edition of his Complete Works, in twelve volumes fully illustrated It presents a readable page We have before us from the same pub lishers eighteen volumes of the thin paper classics in flexible leather bindings The poets—Burns, Keats, Longfellow, Ten nyson. ete are compressed within a single volume each; other works, such as Bos well's “Johnson Carlyle’'s “French Revo lution,” and Hugo's “Les Misérables,”” ex tend to sets of two volumes. The longest of these Les Misérables is still in fais sized type There. are photogravure frontispieces, and to many of the works specially prepared Introductions A striking poem by William Vaughn Moody, “The Death of Eve,” is one of the features of the Dec®#mber Century. In form . and substance, it is far removed from the smooth commonplaces of most magazine verse In “Lincoln the Lawyer” (The Century Co.) Frederick Trevor Hill gives us a.good rea son for welcoming his book is that “no one has heretofore attempted a sum President's legal ca- of Lincoln at the about him of Herndon but a which great accounts ming up of the Many many scattered through Arnold, Holland, Lamon, and Nicolay, book the first effort estimate of his position reer.’ anecdotes are the pages bar and this is to make and repu and the twenty-three yeara’ No lay- can fail carefully Indeed, the the careful lawyer, to present features of his the tation as a main Illinois courts the evidence practice in mention lawyer by story parts of the value of original writer has gathered much material at first man—not to 80 told almost to be interested sifted many and a so well bouk have documents, since hand from Judge Weldon, James Ewing, Col. Peter Dey, and other witnesses In some cases we wish for more detail. It seems a pity that the important speech delivered by Lincoln in the case of Hurd vs. Railroad Bridge Co., a full report of which was preserved by the late Repre- sentative Hitt, should not have been print- ed as one of the appendices. Again we may regret that only the last chapter of 17 pages %& devoted to Lincoln's work as President, in which, as the author shows, his legal training was often of the great- est value. When these chapters first ap- peared in the Century Magazine, the illus- numer - trations were far better and more ous than those of the present volume Sir Oliver Lodge’s “School Teaching and School Reform” (London: Williams & Nor- gate) contains four lectures delivered secondary teachers in training at the Uni versity of Birmingham. They discuss in a sketchy way the aims of the various sub- jects of the curriculum, and the methods of teaching those subjects. There are scattered pages on interest, attention, and other psychological topics. A portion of to
Page 14
! lecture devoted to boarding-school prol ! the fag system, the utilization f pupils’ leisure andthe increase of acher alaries Rambling, superficial i trite, are adjectives which fairly char terize the work Sir Oliver Lodge is led to much more than a respectful g in the fleld of physics, but these ‘ illustrate once more the fallacy nferring that because men are distin rn hed in a special branch of learning, thelr isual utterances on educational ns outsi that field are particularly A I hi if it nt on The Art of Class Management and Dis pline by Joseph S. Taylor (A. 8. Barn & ) ntended a i light contribu m to the a of cla liscipline. It is of f | that haple young woman who is beginning to teach."" There is need of h a book, certainly, but the character f th ribution searcely justifies its publication In the main it consists of ‘ na lizations which are undoubt- il tr I which can scarcely aid a her who faces for the first time a live é ind the econerete problems which it f for he mmediat solution Chap- 1\ 0 levies of cla government ! ' ifl o far as it goes. and the same ark applies to scattered pages of other chapter rhe remainder of the book is a ] i waste An i f Welsh extraction cannot but feel te t in the forthcoming publi tion of the life and letter of Edward L,! 1 (1660-1709) Few Welshmen have been held in higher esteem, have done bet ervice to their nation, or displayed greater intellectual brilliance and versatil ty Sir Hans Sloane spoke of him as ‘the best naturalist in Europe,’ and he was no less distinguished in the realms of language and archwology What gives his work its pecial value is the fact that in many cases, e. g., in Celtic philology, he made use of methods which are usually associated with modern research We know that he train- ed and supported a band of Oxford under- graduate ind travelled with them in the United Kingdom and Brittany to collect ma erlals for his bool Their hardly-won formation-—-they were chased by robbers Ireland, treated as conjurors in Wales, 1 as thieve in Cornwall—was em bodied n hi Lythophylacii Britannici hnographia (printed at the expense of Iman Newton and others) and his hwologia Britannica,” as well as in the ie f tay, Lister, Baxter, Nicholson, et rhe life and correspondence are to be brought out 1 Richard Ellis of Jesus Col of which foundation Lhuyd was also member The letters he wrote himself to be followed by those which reached him from Oxford during his travels. These ire particularly valuable ince to some ex tent they bridge over the gap which opens with the death of Antony Wood in 1695, and im not closed until 1705 when Hearne'’s liaries begin In the course of the next few months a mural tablet ia to be erected to hia memory in the Welsh alsale of St Michael'a Church, Oxford, by the Edward Lhuyd Soctety Lea Druides et les Dieux Celtiques A formes d’animaux” (Paris: Honoré Cham pion) adds yet another to the series of chatty little volumes by H Jubainville Among the most Interesting D’Arbois de | however, The Nation. chapters is that which deals with the “‘gu- the Gaulish priests, flamens; those who invoke the gods, (Com- ‘“‘god,"’ meaning “‘the in- voked,” “gudja,”’ the invoker, the priest.) We hear of one of them Hirtius’s addition to C@wsar’s Gallic Com- M De Jubainville, by tuatri,”’ or literally pare the English and Gothic % €., in mentaries the way, compares the gutuatri with Chryses, the Priest of Apollo, in the “Iliad,” not, as might have been ex- pected, with the Druids. A good deal of space is devoted to contrasting these lat- ter with Pythagoras and his disciples. Un- like the Pythagoreans, the Druids believed that death was the middle point in a long life, and that their souls went to a land of bliss beyond the limits of ocean to vivify [Vol 83, No. 2161 | —indeed, no such biography may be ex- | pected during his lifetime. The real val- ue of this work lies in its frequent repro- ductions of passages from what may be called Diaz’s own memoirs of his boyhood and military career up to the end of the French intervention. These are the recol- lections of Diaz, as related by him in re- cent years to the late Matiads Romero, who put them in order for private publication. Translations from them were furnished to an Englishwoman, who recently wrote a book on Diaz, and who used them as “hith- erto unpublished” selections from the “‘di- ary” of the pacificator of Mexico. It was this use of them which seems to have in- spired the idea of making them more gen- erally available in Spanish, and the anony- mous author has evidently full authoriza- then for such use. It would be much more interesting and valuable to have the “‘Me- in their entirety, as edited by Ro- mero, and approved by Diaz; but we note as perhaps significant the statement of our author that only a few of the “initiated’’ have seen these memoirs, and that. ‘“‘owing to certain defects beyond remedy, they may have to become entirely dead letter.” moirs” Number 8 in the series of “‘Unpublished | or Very Rare Documents for the History of new bodies This view comes nearer to that referred to by Hesiod, circa 700 B. c., and by the author of the “Odyssey.” We need searcely say that the book is cram- med with learning; it is somewhat ele- mentary in places, but generally speaking to the purpose. We recommend it to stu- dents of Celtic history and thought Paul V. Bacon furnishes a new edition of Heyse’s “L’Arrabbiata” (Boston: Allyn & Bacon) That which distinguishes the book from other editions is an interesting introduction narrating a personal visit to Heyse at his home in.Munich, when the | 1uthor told, among other things, of a Swiss who had heard of Heyse’s “Im Para- diese,” and sent in his card, happy in the thought of meeting the author of “Para- dise Lost’! The editor visited Sorrento and Capri to verify certain allusions in the story One could wish, however, that the book wet! embellished with illustra- tions of the author and the scenes he de- scribes—factors of greater value to the American student reaching out after for- eign culture than is often realized The publishing house of the Viuda de Ch. Bouret, Paris and Mexico City, has just brought out two books which, though re- motely separated in time, both deal with the development of a national spirit in Mexico It is some degree true that only in so far as this is in the title cf the first, ; de la independencia Mexi- is justified. The au- treats of the followers “Los precursore cana en el siglo xvi.,”’ Luis Gonzalez Obregon, of thor, dissensions Cortés and his with the Spanish crown and its agents, and of the movements later in the sixteenth century, wherein the conquerors and their sons displayed a tendency to resist author- ity. and even to throw off allegiance to Spain. Events of this sort up to 1568 alone are studied; and only the title itself con- nects these events with the Mexican wars of independence in the nineteenth century. have traced out the tendencies were in It would be interesting to for toward practically all the Spanish colonies almost first the other book the au- remains has us as to Mexico alone separation which notable from the In made psy- Diaz thor, who anonymous, historical “Porfirio 1865), his being thus life of the in its intimate phases as shown in “an in the title September, “the what he calls essay chology” (September, under 1830 aim to reveal people the life of a man who is all transparent.” apparently data Diaz's birth and origin are brought out. This Is, biography of Diaz Some new as to no adequate even for his early life and military career Mexico” is “‘Causa instruida contra el Gen- eral Leonardo Marquez por graves delitos del 6rden militar’ (Mexico City: Libreriade la Vda, de Ch. Bouret). These are the documents in the trial of Gen. Marquez for insubordination, embargo of money de- signed for the general treasury, etc., under the reactionary government of Miramon in 1859. The trial was suspended in 1860 because the reactionists were in straits and needed the services of Marquez in the field. The suspension became definite with the fall of the government which instigated the trial, and Marquez figured again in the an- ti-Juarez ranks as a general of the Inter- vention and Maximilian’s Empire; and es- caped to Havana after having, in Maximil- ian’s conception, betrayed him. These doc- uments, apart from the matter of personal interest, contain material bearing on the so-called “‘Wars of the Reform.” Lady Jebb is preparing a life of the late Sir Richard Jebb, to be published before the end of next year. She wil be grateful for the loan of letters written by Sir Rich- ard, and she will return them as soon as they are copied. Her address is Springfield, Cambridge, England. Léon Vanderkindere, well known as a pol- itician and historian, died in Brussels this month, at the age of sixty-four. At one time he was a professor at the Brussels Free University. Among his best-known writings are “The Age of Arteveldes,”’ 1879, “Belgian History in the Middle Ages,” 1890, and “The Territorial Formation of the Belgian Principality the Middle Ages.”’ in is to be erect- four hundredth A monument to Calvin ed in Geneva in 1909, the anniversary of his birth. The money is being raised by an international commit- headed by Prof. Lucien Gautier of Lausanne. tee, From an article by Dr. Ernest Schultze in the Sociale Pravis of Berlin, on “Peo- ple’s Libraries in German Villages,” it appears that there has been a five-fold in- crease in the number of these libraries
Page 15
, 1906] The Nation. 461
? Nov. 29 during the last ten years. In 1895 there | printers and their ways, old books, and old |! books relating to the biatory of Pennsy were less than one thousand: now there bindings They are in the nature of out mien and 0 , P . are between five and six thousand. Their | lines of that larger work on the history and i by Mr. Henkels on December ind distribution is very uneven throughout the | development of printing in } ind which | 6 T tior tall id | n in cial rie ‘ oOllection, co ’ ng ati tok empire. The kingdoms of Saxony and Wur- | js yet to be written » Bes a “ , ’ i oot if ‘ pec i r } a Tar ta rar temburg and the provinces of Brandenburg The Society of Yconophiles hag recently Pie : : ; , . : ! 5 10} i is f ct t : I rCTINA uu ana = pry Aaa in have the largest published a volume which will interest all Swedish books on Pennsylvania Among supply, while Bavaria, Alsace-Lorraine, and | collectors of prints relating to New York | these are boo} n New Sweden } et Mecklenburg have few More significant | «ity It is an Index to t} sattons tm icinaie: 4 H — . > at na ’ ne i ] ions 1 i ] af impart m and even than the great increase in numbers, | ;), famous series of New York City Com- | selius: among Dutch } —' ‘ . says Dr. Schultze, are the enlargement and | pon Council Manuals pr: pared by Davis T Donck’s “Beschryvinge van X w Sted wT . u hit , , _ . ee . improvement in quality Valentine, Clerk of the Council The Index | lant 1656& and Web?! Nader Informa The problem of a “learned proletariat,” itself has been prepared by R. H. Law tio en Bericht 1GX¢ ind nong 1} ‘ or a supply of university graduates far rence, secretary of the Society The Ir ) man books. Pastoriu Rn hreit g a beyond the demands of the professions in | duction (19 pages) is by W m Loring | zu allerletzt erfund: Provintz Pensylva Germany, a subject that perplexed Andrews, preéminently a lov: f pictures at 1700; and a translation of Thomas's Bismarck, is again under discus- | of old New York The first M sal. for Pennsylvania and Weat New Jet sion. Dr. J. Coured, an authority on po- | 1841 and 1842, is a little volume of 185 | tended as a supplement to Pa the litical economy in the University of Halle pages measuring 4% by 3! nehe It is | title being “Continuatio der Be i\reibuag has published an article on the subject in | the scarcest and most valuable of th es ler Landschafft Pensylvaniae.” 1702 It > Ss $s 4 ; = t ler P Ty , r ‘ . the latest issue of the Jahrbiicher fiir The size of the volume was enlarged for th rather irpt ng that Gov. Pennypacl Nationalékonomic und = Statistik In | issue of 1844 and 1845, again in 1849; and | had so few of the early books of William analyzing the causes he declares that a finally in 1868, 1869, and 1870 the annual | Penn. He seems not to have owned Pet sentimental pride in higher education a8 | pecame a large octavo. The Index as here | fi book on Pennsylvania, “Some Account such, originating in the class distinctions printed is divided into four sections: (1.) | of Proving of Pennsylvania 681. a ¢ he ; > res anc > _ a . , of the Middle Ag s, and the failure to ap Plates and Maps; (2.) Maps and Plar of copy of which was sold at the low _ e of preciate the intellectual .demands of the the City of New York and Vicinit >) $210, in the Proud ile in 190 " , ) : ork an Vicinity (3 . eo omit ‘ es Sc sat callings of modern life are Miscellaneous Maps; (4.) Facsimiles, Let however, hav the scarce “Further sug- nt ' ' e ae —_ a As remedies he rms ters, Signatures, Documents, Broadsides — So. Nor has he apparently Pens rests that matriculation fees be materially . lett g P - | 1 tt ; 1 b i ‘ and Certificates Following these lists asOLLOl 1685, except 4n a Dutch trans increased; and that stipendia at the dis- , p Pras t : , . F which give titles in full, is a general short , or the rat of the Government of posal of the universities be given only to ' ; “ the Province of Pennsylvat 1691. bot) . title Index in a single alphabet to all illu — ' ennsyivania , OU students showing special qualification In po of which occurred in the Proud sale. T! ume trations The volume is printed at the : een erpww Sms tee rou ate it addition he urges that the consequences VRIES n t valuable Pennsyly book n the , , sylvania.”” 16¢ and Bookbinders of Westminster and Lon- | in exceptionally fine condition, of quartos ract of Letters from Pennsylvania,” 169! don from 1476 to 1534,” just published here of “The Merchant of Venice,” 1600, and | | believed to be one of three copies : ’ . cnow! The coll tion ¢ reriodi« 4 by G. P. Putnam’s Sons, is made up of two | “King Lear,” 1608. For these the trustees | *"°W" 7! ection of periodicals in ; oe | cludes som: re eriesa oO ariy nerican series of lectures delivered at the Univer- paid a little more than one thousand : ra f ea Ar . . . | ne sity of Cambridge, in 1899 and 1904 The | pounds, and they now appeal for more author is the recognized living authority | generous public support in order to make rt itograph colle of the ate | on earliest English printers and their | the Shakespeare Birthplace Library ‘‘al- | ‘ Nold Teff gether with that of the . , | ; ‘ 7 YY ' ‘ 1? books, and is of that comparatively new | together worthy of its national character ite William J Bryant vill t u school of bibliographers of which the late Three works printed by William Caxton C. F. Libt & Co. of B ’ on M . Robert Proctor was the most prominent. | have been discovered by Hodgson, the | December There are veral | f The custom of the older writers was te de- London auctioneer, in a private collection Wa ngton, a short AI fl ied scribe a book, the title, the colophon, the | sent for sale from. Whitley Beaumont en from the Executive Ma ‘ June j j , 7 " Re1 t; : t lorer hout ow number of leaves, the illustrations, etc., | Yorkshire The three volumes, all more 10, 18¢ » Cal Dahigren, a ’ » new ¢ | gun; a Bryant manuscript, the poem “The then to pass on to the next William or less damaged by the cutting away of Blades with Caxton’s work, and Proctor blank margins or the abstraction of entire Strange Lad three pages folio, besides with that of the Continental printers, based leaves, are “The Royal Book, or Book for everal Bryant letter letters of Haw- studies on the comparison and classifica- a King.”’ 1484, “The Book of Good Man thorne, Irving, Ruskin, Emerson, Longfel tion of books by the types with which they | ners,”’ 1487, and “‘The Doctrinal of Sapl- low; a number of Revolutionary documents were printed. It was also the way of Henry | ence,” 1489 The first, according » the me of historical interest, from the papers Bradshaw, who, as late as 1882, wrote to | London Athenaum, contains only 100 out of | Of Major-Gene ral Edward Hand; etc. Some Francis Fry: 160 leaves, and only three of six woodcuts eresting broadsides everal relating to The only way to really find out about The second book, of which there are but vew Hampshire, are included in the sale these things is to take all a man’s books | two perfect copies in England, ontains The selection of books, broadsides, and which he is known to have printed—or, at | sixty out of sixty-six leaves The Do autographs from the collection of James any rate, such as can be got at- and to trinal of Sapience * has fifty out of ninety Terry of lHiartford, to be sold by C F study his habits of printing; not only his 2 : two leaves Libbie & Co., on December 6 and 7, in- type and cuts, but also his habits of using these materials. . . . But 1 really do Stan. V. Henkels will sell at the auction | cludes some choice items, the most not not know three people in Europe now liv- | roons of Davis & Harvey in Philadelphia, | able perhaps being a copy of the first ed . ing who study things in this way. on Friday and Saturday of this week, the tion of the Saybrook Platform, printed at In these lectures the first half-century of | collection of portraits of officers in the | New London in 1710 by Thomas Short. The book-making in England is covered. The | army and navy in the War of the Revolu- | autographs are largely from the corres Westminster printers, Caxton, Wynken de tion, of 1812, and the Mexican War, also pondence of Gov William Plumer of New ' Worde, and Notary; the London printers, | views of land and naval batties, belonging | Hampshire and Benjamin Trumbull, the hi Pynson, Lettou, and William de Machlinia; | to James T. Mitchell, Chief Justice of Penn- | torian They include a number of let Adams foreign printers and the books they made | sylvania. There are many contemporary | ters of John Adams, John Quincy for the English market; the early English | portraits in mezzotint, and there is a no-/| Silas Deane, Roger Sherman, William Wwil- bookbinders—these are some of the subjects | table collection of pictures of John Paul | |jams, etc Among the books and touched upon. The lectures are narrative | Jones | sides are several relating to Dartmouth in form, not technical, and are filled The third portion of the library of | College and its progenitor, the Indian Char- with interesting allusions and notes on old | Goy, Samuel W. Pennypacker, being his | ity School of Eleazor Wheelock. Stephen broad
Page 16
ILLUSTRATED both of its eru of photogr avures As for the material is not easy to write a Sunday-school book The Nation. pretension to be a concealed moralist. So far as we can infer, he writes for an audience from which the young per- on has been eliminated, and he considers it his chief function to amuse. In three at least of think that sup- reri been carried some- makes no his studies we pressio could have farther without creating an incorrect but the general reader who takes up a book on the Restoration is bound what impression, to run his own risks It is not improbable that Mr. Trowbridge has hoped to give his volume a distinctive If this is the We quality by lightness of touch. case, he has in a measure succeeded. think, however, that he has not quite hit the strain when he, writes: La Belle Stuart! The glamour of the Restoration is in that romantic name. At the sound of it our thoughts at once rush back to childhood, when we learnt English history out of story books and picture books: and old, half-forgotten tales of the Merry Monarch, and the gay doings of cava- liers with periwigs and swords, of maids of honor all lace and perfume, crowd upon the memory La Belle Stuart! to the very children of the Board Schools—if Imagina- tion be a faculty looked upon with favor it those practical seats of municipal learn- ing—must come visions of a far-off roman- tic time This passage will do more than columns of comment to let the reader know how Mr. Trowbridge handles his subject Highways and Byways in Dorset By Sir Frederick Treves With Illustrations by Joseph Pennell New York: The Macmillan Co. $2 Few counties are richer in historical as- sociations than Dorset, few have more va- riety of scenery and architecture Her fine harbors of Poole and Weymouth in- vited the invader from the days of the marauding Saxons and Danes to the morn- ing in June, 1685, when the effeminate Duke of Monmouth, the Pretender, landed at Lyme Regis for that campaign which was to end in the defeat at Sedgemoor. Charles Il. after the battle of Worcester made his escape through Dorset, hid in its country houses, and finally embarked for France on a coal brig from Poole His adventures and the humors of his escape in the disguise of a groom are here told with great spirit Everywhere are traces of Celtic and later and horn picks Roman occupation, the pit-dwellings of toiled with and yet managed to erect great earthworks men who cities of refuge like Maiden Cas- miles south of Dorchester. These Thomas Hardy has used in the to give an impression of gloomand vast spaces. Maum- introduced with so much effect of Casterbridge, Hardy Roman amphitheatre. Sir Fred- erick follows the tradition adopt- ed Hardy, and the of modern archwologists, who conjecture that camps tle, | earthworks or two setting of his village tragedies bury Rings, in the “Mayor w labelled a common theories by ignores the amphitheatre was built long before the coming of the Romans, and was a great temple of the sun. Dorset is also full of beautiful old manor houses that have been converted into farmhouses, of de- caying roofs of thatch that are being re- placed by hideous corrugated iron, and of churches painfully restored. [ Vol. 83, No. 2161 in British and Roman Dorset, and in the description of her scenery, of- ten wild and desolate without grandeur, and then again wonderfully fertile, a coun- try of lush grass and butter-making. Ev- erywhere he succeeds in giving the reader interested a vivid picture of Dorset coloring; the “jade green” of the downs, whose long rolling lines are “like terrific sea-combers about to break upon a shoal,” the rich yellow of the stone buildings which suf- fuses the church roofs and aisles with a golden radiance instead of the cold misty gray of less fortunate counties. Sir Frederick Treves, himself a _ native of Dorset, writes thus of MHardy’s Edgdon Heath, commonly called the Great Heath: The tone of the moor is a russet-brown, splashed by the bracken with green and by the heather with purple. Under the summer sun marvellous colors appear; : a faraway plateau may be Gobelin blue, and a near hillock bronze-brown. There may be here a bare slope of mush- room-colored sand, and there a_reedy marsh of parrot green. There charm which with whose for are glorified guide-books, depends the mere But the this is the case, and for that reason the volumes are the most attractive of their type. None that we have has a style more pleasing than this description by the famous court physician. Mr. Pennell’s drawings in pastel are as usual excellent, successful with the on their illustrations, text is a thread. present series never encountered and are especially gloomier scenery. Certain Delightful English Towns. By W. D. Howells New York: Harper & Brothers. $3. There is no doubt that to see and en- joy England aright one must be an Amer- ican. The country is, in the first place, peculiarly rich in small comforts that her people take for granted, not knowing their bliss. The Frenchman or German, having his own notions of comfort, re- gards the English brand with a critical eye. He has his own cheap and satisfac- equivalent for neat-handed, soft- servants, railway porters’ ob- sequious for twopence, and the afternoon tea that at certain hours seems to gush spontaneously all over England. Mr. Howells believes too that it will always be the American mind that “‘wherever it goes catches in some rhyme, some phrase, some story of fact or fable that makes the place more home to him than the house where he was born.”” The English- man cannot be expected to recall Kings- ley’s Mary at the sight of Chester and the river Dee, because he is probably ab- own tory voiced sorbed in making the history that is to thrill the New Zealand tourist centuries hence To the literary reminiscences, quite as much as the creature comforts, Mr. Howells does full justice, and shows an intimacy with Saxon Kings and the early vicissitudes of the British which could never thrive in the English breast. Plymouth, Exeter, Bath, Bristol, South- ampton, Oxford, and Chester were among the towns that he found delightful, and has enriched for the wiser sort of tour- ist, who should cultivate his exquisite tolerance, and resolve, when visiting those scenes, to enjoy even the hotels. Mr. Howells has a good word for nearly all The guide to Wessex usually dwells too long and too often on the Wessex of Hardy. Sir Frederick is happily more of them; and they offer in general so lit-
Page 17
Nov. 29, 1906] tle and at such high prices that one can feel his travelling companions must have this gift of quietly ignoring the unpleasant or inferior The book is illustrated, not strikingly. but sufficiently What will endear its every reader is unfailing the by of setting or only how priceless to been well its pages to humor, its nice balancing of emo- tions and westhetic impressions one whom whether thrown on no charm human association was away Constable's has a pe- due to the about “In Co.) all who wish to East Anglia find all they lated with better effect in Mr ume in the Highways and Byways Series The publishers of the present volume have wisely expended their: energies the il- lustrations, which will charm every admir- Constable. Here reproduced in color of the most of Con- stable’s paintings, half of these, including of all to most lov- Herbert W Country” (E. P Tompkins's Dutton & not at culiar attraction text, since those read will want re- Dutt'’s vol- on are famous er of sixteen the ‘“‘Haywain,’’ dearest ers of Constable, from the pictures in the All are, in fact, drawn galleries, which have only fortunate in gifts from the of Constable, but ready for the last years to pay twice as many thou- sands for a Constable earned hun- dreds, though Constable was by no means without honor in his own day. Mr. Tomp- kins’s share in the volume led him to wan- marshy Suffolk, which was county as well as Con- stable’s, and to describe the charms of “lilied lowland waters,”’ as they were called by Stevenson. Like Rembrandt, Constable was a miller’s son, and Mr. Tompkins has collected here all the known facts of his life, first as a miller and then as a painter of a county that has much of the Teuton spirit in its scenery, so that though Constable directly influ- enced the French school, it is of the Dutch that one is constantly reminved in his coloring and composition. The text have said, by no means the main interest, but it is well enough as a setting to the pictures, which are excel- lent examples of color illustration. John Addington Symonds's translation of the Life of Benvenuto Cellini is reissued by Brentano in two volumes that are a model of good bookmaking. The work was done by the Merrymount Press, and, bar- ring a rather trivial title page and imper- National Gallery the not from London been heirs twenty as he der through Gainsborough’'s its is, as we fect opacity of the paper, it is hard to see how it could be better. There are forty- one photogravure plates, representing Cel- lini’s work or his patrons, associates, and enemies. All of Symonds’s excellent in- troductory material is retained, and there is an index. Royal Cortissoz has contri- buted a preface in which he points out with sympathetic yet critical discernment the discrepancy between Cellini’s personal forcefulness and artistic achievement. The essay is useful as a corrective to Symonds’s, who was naturally obsessed by the sheer personality of his hero. This re- print is likely to remain for years the pre- ferable library edition of these fascinating | memoirs The palaces of France, in both beauty and their historical associations, are of furnishing endless themes for The latest volume of their capable artist and author. The Nation. this kind is “The Chateaux of Touraine” (The Century Co.), with text by Maria Hornor Lansdale and illustrations by Jules Guérin The pal flat colors used by M Guérin bring out the romans f the coun try admirably—of h& work no ymmenda tion is necessary It seems almost a pity that photographic reproductions, with their hard lines and glaring lights, should have been interspersed, although some of these are excellent of their kind The atoryv of the chateaux is filled with the echoes of old romance, cruel and sweet by turns John Lane presents a very welcome r« print of Alexander Gilchrist’s “The Life of William Blake,” in a single volume, friend ly both to the hand and eye. This reduc tion in bulk has been effected by the omis- Blake's accessible worka, which There are more than fifty well executed reproduc tions, about half of which from the the editor, W Robertson, and previously unpublished Gilehrist’s book leaves something to be de- sion of long extracts from now readily are are drawings collection of Graham sired in the article of criticism, but forty three years after its issue, it remains the standard source.for the facts of Blake's life. Without it, we should be largely r« duced to surmise as to his personality, as we are, for example,in the case of that oth This reprint is the er great visionary, El Greco from the point and, by reason of its illus- the special admirable of view of general reader, trations, necessary also to student. Emma Hamilton The proper rec ord of must be pictorial It was her beauty that conquered England's greatest admiral and that one of England's greatest painters, and beauty calls for that of the inspired subtle Mr bringing Hamilton” more delineation than printer Baily has therefore done well in together in his “Emma, Lady (F. A. Stokes Co.), a handsome quarto vol- ume, some twenty or more reproductions of the most famous of her portraits These are accompanied by a text, but as this is more of a setting for the pictures than an history, it need the contribution to not On the trations may be highly praised, though they original detain us whole, illus vary a good deal in process and in quality The selection made is altogether excellent it includes all the best Romneys that are really of Lady Hamilton, and among the most beautiful will be found two or three that are far from familiar Although the book is not an authoritative life or a criti- cal essay on her portraiture, it is quite the best pictorial record From Houghton, Mifflin & Co. comes a holiday edition of Whittier’s “Snow-Bound,” for which Howard Pyle, John J. Enneking, and Edmund H. Garnett have made draw- ings, and Adrian J. Iorio has furnished dec- orations. The same house publishes ‘“‘The Story of Pocahontas and Captain John Smith,” told and pictured by E. Boyd Smith, who, it will be remembered, made the pictures last year for “The Story of Noah’s Ark,”’ with their rare combination of beauty and humor. His work this year is of the same character, though without the hilarious fun One of the pler holiday the sim- of Thack most charming of books is an edition eray’s “Ballads and Songs” (Putnams), with illustrations by H. M. Brock The drawings fit in capitally with the humor 463 and occasional touches of pathos of the poems Less attractive perhaps but more elaborate, is Browning's “Last Ride rogeth« from the same publishers, with lecoratior ind = «pictures by Frederick Simpson Coburn Perhaps the best of Dickens's Chr mas tales is that “ h ibedded } Pickwick.’ neluding the visit to tl manor farm, the tory of the goblin, and he sport on the ice which tempted Mr Winkle to skate and M Pickwick slide This section of the book has bee printed by the Baker & Taylor C in a separate volume " M Pickwick Ch tmas,”’ with illustra ! n line ar color by George Alfred \V liam ‘) wanderers take on a very gentes app ance in these pictures Among the holiday books offered ! year by Scribner is an edition of Cat Old Creole Davy lustrated by Alber Herter Scribners also have \ Little Boob Bores bv Oliver Herford who furt ! beth and picture The hum with the alphabet, beginning A us the graph t \ \ a8 ley l ts] t if Dears Ihey d d ! The peculiar sentiment of Max Miille Memories seems to retain a peren interest for English as well as for Germa readet Again we have it in decorat borders and designs, the old translatior 1 good or+ by George P. Upton, put hed by A. ©. McClurg & Co Most attractive of all the cheaper hol day books, perhaps is George Eliot Scenes of Clerical Life’ (Macmillans) fully illustrated in color and line by Hugh Thomson His color work new to us but it has all the charm of his more familiar line drawings “A Cheerful Year Book” (Holt & Co.) is a diary for recording engagements and other matters of the kind, and it is some thing more On alternate pages there are humorous drawings with bits of aphori wisdom by F. M. Knowles on the perplex ities of life. And, as the title page say the whole is introduced and concluded with profound and edifying remarks by Carolyn Wells.”” It is altogether a piece of foolery which combines the utile and th: dulce CURRENT FICTION The Amulet By Charles Egbert Craddock New York The Macmillan Co Once again we must wish that Miss Mu free might stick to her mountaineers. He present historical romance is a sad affa perfectly artificial and unreal from i to finish It may be histo ally yund but this, other things being unequal i altogether trivial consideration The eighteenth century English of s dialogue is certainly incorres n irious farrago When the fair Arabella is in form » sure, and thinking of her pa } say Lord,” and “La,” and mo rous gen teel”’; and the gallant m ary «ge emen who surround her are capable in an ems gency not only of zounds and gad zooks,”’ but of “Stap me and ‘Sp m phrases upon which they obviously p The girl ia silly themselves
Page 18
ler ind the events recorded are ipposed to take place on the frontier of the Cherokee country, in the year 1763 The Soul of an Artist By Neera Trans ted from the Italian of Neera by E. L Murisor New York: Paul Elder & Co It is easy to see why for the uses of an American publisher the present title is re available than “Anima Sola,” or its juivalent Few persons willingly expose nselves to books of religious philosophy of devotion, but plenty of us are ready to out at a moment's notice in search of e least bit of fresh information about the mysterious “temperament These pages re ipposed to contain the confessions or mnfldence of an Italian actress of note They are addr ed in a series of imaginary letters to an English nobleman with whom he has once been intimate, but from whom he ha now been long separated His ' i” ‘ ul’’ has permitted him hardly or not at all to overstep the bounds of riendship, while she has cherished for him in ideal passion, the expression of her rch for that absolutely satisfying com- hip which is never to become the wrtion of her lonely soul These are, in hort, the records of a nature abnormally t tiv ind self-conscious But while it i commonest in such cases, as in that of Marie Bashkirtseff, that a morbid per il vanity should be the principal motive, what is chiefly expressed here is a morbid spiritual fastidiousness. This person, to be | ire, is emotionally unbalanced, the slave of moods, continually subject to a physical melancholy which might be taken as the result of an unfulfilled eroticism To say this of an English or American book would be to condemn it as intolerable on grounds of taste if not of morals But in these matters the Latin races have a dignity to which we rarely attain Love, which has been in its highest form denied her, is Neora theme Of l'amour she is not ig ts unrest, its ecstasy, its satiety; but of love the interpreter of human life she can only dream When I encounter one who loves the gray mists of winter; who prefers the green lepth of a thicket to the bluest of seas or the most golden of suns; cold to heat; to external life, reflection; to music, si lence: to color, shadow; to action, thought; hen | say this is my relative. When I en sunter one who lives in his soul as a priest i? emple, serving and adoring the mys of} office, there is my brother r) j of course not a true autobiogra- I but a fiction There is something a | little humorous in the earnestness with which the writer of the “Foreword” ad ul that Neera tis really one Anna Zuceari of Milan wife of Signor Radius,” la well-known novelist; and that though he writes much of “the overpowering pas on, love he ia very domestic, the angel of her home-—-not at all the portrait of any m of the heroines of her books.” There ts further hint that the great Duse may ive served as model for the writer of these nf ion rh is a matter of alight onsequence n judging of a book which xpre not t personality but a tem peram il typ Trusia By Davis Brinton Philadelphia George W. Jacobs & Co Nation. The seems that with each new culture the crea- ture creeps closer to the every-day, so that whereas the origina! heroes were on more | or less lofty British altitudes they later be- | came jaunty Americans, while the heroines grew less and less unapproachably exalt- | ed We do not say that in “Trusia’’ the limit has been reached. The future it is given to none to know. But it may safely be said that thus far this type of romance has heard no clearer call of the tame. Not that the adventures fall below the orthodox standard in variety or vehemence. It is rather that the domain of lost causes, | lost kings, and idolized, imperilled heiress- es-apparent seems newly invaded when the saviors are a New York club man and his cockney valet The proceedings are by turns stirring, comic, and bathetic. If there | were less real gore and real killing it would read like unstaged extravaganza Even as it is it seems widowed without light music. Yet the plots and mysteries are rot uno- riginal. As the story bounds from one melo- | dramatic situation to another, so the man- ner of its telling springs from height to height of flowery language, then plunges into sudden depths of contemporary slang. We have questing eyes and initiate percep- tions, portraits gazing from their coigns, the soft indulgence of Diana (meaning | moonlight), hair as light as the sheen of a pider’s craft, a mouth as sweet and kind is the animate soul of a rose Then in mitigation of all this dazzle the hero may | be heard saying, “Forgive me, sweetheart, but love will not be denied. Let the king have Krovitch, but you come with me.” Yet when all is said the traditional proof of the pudding is not wholly lacking—to this sillibub. The eating of it is painless and entertaining Under Pontius Pilate By William Schuy- ler. New York: Funk & Wagnalls Co. | Mr. Schuyler’s version 6f the New Testa- ment story is a series of imaginary letters supposed to be addressed to a Stoic friend at Athens by a Roman military officer quar- tered in Judwa, one Caius Claudius Procu- lus, the nephew of Pilate’s wife. All the well-known figures of the drama are in- troduced. The writer is intimate with Herod, Herodias, and Salome, and is pres- ent at the dance which earned the head of John the Baptist At every turn of the narrative, which is naturally crowded with | direct quotations from the New Testament, the reader asks himself what is the gain | over the immortal outlines of the original. Apparently to supply details for the un- imaginative is the motive of the whole. | Mr. Schuyler makes Mary Magdalene the hergine and Caius Proculus her lover, who, after her conversion, is drawn by her ex- ample into the Christian faith. In order to bring together the chief personages he as- sumes that she is identical with that other | Mary who chose the better part in the house of Lazarus In the Bible there is certainly no such identification. It is all done reverently enough, and can be read; but there is an effort at modernization In the attitude of the characters, and in the style there is more than one lapse of taste. It was, we think, a mistake to imply in the preface that the letters exist in a Latin authentic original, though, of course, only The Zenda microbe multiplies, and it | the most unwary could be taken in. [Vol. 83, No. 2161 Rosemary in Search of a Father. By C N. and A. M. Williamson. New York: S. S. McClure & Co. When this has been described as a “pretty” tale of the whipped cream and bonbon box type, there is not much more to A rich, disconsolate young man mourning his lost lady love is seized upon by an adventuress at Monte Carlo. She plays upon his respectful sympathy with a pathetic romance of hunger and a wicked, gambling mother He (in all honor) en- gages her services as secretary at forty dollars a week, and hands her out ten thou- sand francs to begin with. As he is unim- peachably faithful to the lost lady—in addi- say about it. tion to being the most high-toned young man alive—Hugh is also the most innocent youth who has ever made money in a gold mine and come to Europe to heal a broken heart. After his rescue by a petticoated little Lord Fauntleroy, the story proceeds smoothly to its happy end, by all the sign- posted highroads known to sentimental fic- tion. The Doctor. By Ralph Connor. New York: Fleming H. Revell & Co. “The Doctor” is a _ conventional novel about young people (apparently for young people), reeled off with the fluency of a practised story teller. Its best point is a description of a diphtheria epidemic in a Canadian construction camp; its least effec- tive, the Southern beauty who had “a re- serve of proud command due to the strain of a regnant, haughty, slave-ruling race.” Amateurs of every kind of dialect will find their account between the covers of this book—habitant talk, Irish brogue (of the Irish comedy variety), and whole pages of which the following is a fair example: “But *é hain’t got no toes to give ‘im the feelin’ of ‘is toes in "js mind or hennywheres else.” “*Dummed old fool,’ sez the doctor.” Pre- sumably there exist somewhere readers who find this amusing, since the first edition has run high into the tens of thousands even before the date of publication, but it is hard to see why the average adult should not find the story at once commonplace and pass- ably long-winded. LAFCADIO HEARN. The Life and Letters of Lafcadio Hearn. By Elizabeth Bisland. 2 vols. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $6 net. About one-third of the first of these two generous volumes is taken up with the Life by Mrs. Bisland,whowas an intimate friend of Hearn’s from his early manhood until his death; the Letters follow, printed so far as possible chronologically (he eschew- ed dates), and without comment. Such a division is somewhat unusual, but, in the present case, judicious. Of the biographi- cal chapters, it is possible to speak with praise, while admitting considerable reser- vations. Despite an occasional infelicity of taste and even of grammar, they give an eloquent account of the struggles through which Hearn passed, and depict in warm colors the romantic side of his character. What we miss is any adequate critical examination of his literary method or any study of the strange exotic elements that entered into his philosophy. Hearn’s place in our literature by reason both of
Page 19
Nov. 29, 1906] the manner and the contents of his writ- ings that critical discussion in his official biography lays the work open to the charge of ama- the most valua- in the whole book, autobiographic papers little sketch- momentsin his career which is so the absence of such unique Altogether, ble sections here, if not the half-dozen for the es of particular teurishness are now first time printed make us regret that death or uncertainty of purpose kept him from writing the whole inner story of his life; it would have been a work of extraordinary interest, without parallel in the language If ever of any one, it could be said of Hearn that the child was father of the man. The very elements of his nativity his birth from the love-match of an Irish army officer and a Greek woman on the island of Lefcada (from which, by an un- explained alteration of the first vowel, he received his name); his early translation to Ireland and abandonment by his pa- gents—may help to account for the exotic strain in his character and for the un- appeased nostalgia that drove him, through life, a restless wanderer from land to land All this was pretty well known be- fore, but we owe to the present biog- raphy a knowledge of the morbid, torment- ed years between his first childhood and his emigration to America. He was, it ap- pears, adopted by a wealthy grand-aunt, a Mrs. Brenane, and taken to Wales, where he was the heated religious atinosphers surrounded by of a home newly converted to Catholicism The most striking of the autobiographic fragments goes back to his sixth year, when, as he says, he knew a go0d deal about ghosts, and very little about gods He had been taught to pro- nounce the invocation, “In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost but had no understanding of what the words meant He continues One of the appellations, however, seri- ously interested me; and the first reli- gious question that I remember asking was a question about the Holy Ghost It was the word “Ghost,’’ of course, that had excited my curiosity; and I put the ques- tion with fear and trembling because it appeared to relate to a forbidden subject The answer [ cannot recollect; but it gave me an idea that the Holy Ghost was a white ghost, and not in the habit of making faces at small people after dusk Nevertheless, the name filled me with vague suspicion, especially after I had learned to spell it correctly. in a prayer- book; and I discovered a mystery and an awfulness unspeakable in the capital G Even now the aspect of that formidable letter will sometimes revive those dim ind fearsome imaginings of childhood. But he was not long to remain in this groping ignorance. One of the few visit- ors to the house was a certain “Cousin Jane who passed the winters with them— a tall girl, as he describes her, a con- vert, who looked like some of the long angels in his French pictures, and who gave him “the idea of Sorrow as a dim something that she personally represent- ed."" One day she caught the child up into her lap, and, with her piercing black eyes to catechise him: fixed upon his, began “My child!—is it possible that you do not know who God is?” “No,” I answered in a choking whisper. “God!—God who made you'—God who made the sun and the moon and the sky,— and the trees and the beautiful flower,— You do not know?” everything! | | The Nation. ! | I was too much alarmed by her manner |} to reply | “You do not know she wi on, “that God made you and me?—that God made | your father an mother? and every- | body lo no know about } Heaven and Hel I do not reme r all the rest of her words; I can recall with d t ss only the following ‘and send you down to Hel » burn alive n fire for ever and ever! Think of it'—always burning, burning, burning! screaming and burning! s aming and burning!—never to be saved from that pain of fire! You remember when you | burned your finger at the lamp’?—Think of your whole body burning ilways. always always burning!—f ind ever?” ; I can still see her is in the instant of it utterance yrror up t, and he pa she 1idenly burst into tears, and m ind left th room | Just how much the ma maginatior | has played over this memory of childhood | itwould not beeasy 0 say; but on the whok one gets the impress of t stran | ly sensitive to the lim hadows of lift and involved from birth i network of dreams from which he ould neve free himself And from this imaginative terror | of religion he passed to the mor tangibl | distresses of poverty For two yea I deed, he had the protection of a J t yl lege in the ne h of Fran It was her |} that he acquired h ntimate knowledg of French Here he lost or of his ey | while playing the game of The Giant's Stride,” a disfigurement of which he wa always extremely sensitiv ind here he became possessed with the i idicabl notion that some mzysteriot Jesuitical plot was formed against him After this he disappears for a_ while nto obscurity ‘When I was a boy of xteen,”’ he wrote in Japan to one of his pupil ilthough my blood relatior we n of them very rich, no one would pay anything to help me finish my education I had to be com “what you neve have had to become i ery t I pa | lo ris ght I had tw yea of kness bed I had no on » help me And I had to edu my f 1 8 of all dificulti« Then came a brief season of starving in London, of hiding in a workhouse in an evil quart by the Thames, and some time in the year 1869, at the age of nine teen, without money or friegds, and with brol healt he found ssctt n the e¢ of New York How he now con rived » live does not appear He left the city by an emigrant train for Cincin nat irrying with him through life an implacable hatred and horror of New York as “something cyclopean without solem- nity, something pandemoniac without grotesqueness—preadamite bridges—super- impositions of iron roads higher than the aqueducts of the Romans—gloom, vapor roarings and lightnings.”’ In Cincinnati he got into new ipe work ling four teen hours a da i hat tensely vulgar and commonpla thing, called American journalism Here he became acquainted with H. E. Kreht 1 to whom the most interesting of his lett were addressed But the lure of the South wa n his blood and he soon went to New Oriean At this point his correspondence begins, and for the rest of his life we can track him through his owp letters in his wanderings in the West Indies, his brief return to New York, and bis various homes in Japan. Ik was well known that he married a Japanese | woman, and for the sake of his child t ame a subject of the Mikado. It is now pla ! n his later years he bega weary f Japa is } had wear 1 of ev hing « I! wa the ext t iy ma ‘ py Am ha ‘ av eV chang gg se at | ‘ i \ » In the end I gray ! \ f J i fe the 1} + f | ) oblit on of p ‘ bes “ on him; and at the ime tin ) - that had first attra it ! pushed to the w ! ! vis f the new vilizatio mr , painful in the fl letter They are fil 1 witl he ery for money tha ! iy for h family H i Gj ment teacher wa ‘ “u ! } ties on all h books we niv $88 a vea leath “ ' ; ime to him a a releas« Unque mably these lett f Hearn i in ig th most ints ting that hav ippeared for a number f year probably the most valuab n i publ i ) of I ArT ald l iry to ha He n had at h mmand a y of ex 10 iry vividne ind flexibility. Every t gz liv mnder h nag ict h re ) yme n New Orlea waif of s0- ty that ast path lrowsy ple ! rf p ind t! } j nad i f grea es he exqu le ey of Japan Mo of all we hav been It ere ed in he } nat i 1 of the 1 st preparing himself f h chosen work. He had the ! ences fthe F } hitterateur, of a } it t ‘ f the " of Anglo-Saxon gif Int) léhdcle of gious conv on I j I » art a ) i new and relentlk faith Ye hard of all sacrifice fo he i t } writes is th icrifice to rt trampling of self under foot!"’ And to the extent of crushing out worldly ambitior he made the sacrifice. His aim was perf y i He wi ed lifferent from th what chilly yle of American romancs lish realization of a upon foreign maste more forcible by the which is the chara tongues.””" To this end he to.led endl y ver the language of his essay ind tale writing and rewriting with ifinite pa lence He had “‘the rare yet terr ssary gift of waiting.” And with h style he deliberately fostered all the ro mantic elements of his own chara r There are unpleasant stories abroad abou levious ways into which his search for unusual emotions led him-—storl« which Mrs. Bisland does not allude, bu fo he most part his cultivation of the mant Ich was innocent, if odd. His read nz wa in out-of-the-way flelds; at o me in New Orleans he owned a library of some 500 books, valued at $2,000, and every volume “queer.”’ His unappeased longing for the tropics was due in part to delicate health, in part to his passion for luxurious sensations As sometimes goes with the impr-é onl tic temperament he had also a curious in terest in science and made of Herbert Spencer the Bible of his faith It wa his uplon of impressionism and devotio ) Spencerian evolution that renders 1 him ”
Page 20
466 deal interpreter of Japan India he would have been utterly blind, for the Buddhism of that land was the far hest po ble removed from impressionism inticism of any form; the austere if bnegation of the incient PAli books " ld hav emained forever foreign to But to the Buddhism of Japan, with xture of Shinto ancestor worship and lutterings of quaint mstheticism, he ime with the fullest preparation His inism easily fused with one as f Buddhist philosophy; his romanti m was ready to seize on all the ghostly ggestions of a past forever haunting the present, and coming to the urface in un | 1 way The re ilt a series of books perfectly unique in our language r ire 1 the grea free tradition of English literature, but they will probably n fame fo many years to come lisappearan of the ancient Japan on hich they re based will give them the " ru of omething that can t repeated ¢ mitated Into the ‘ itory of the brain that created these niece of jewelled impre ionism, the let oduce u Almost, but not quite the oul of the man / and Letters of Robert Edward Lee hy J. William Jone New York Th Publishing Co. $2 Ihe mosphere of Washington and Lee { ity dificult to resist The vener hat irrounded Lee when he under vk presidency after the war, kindli levotion, loyalty, all the higher emo ha mnoBble life with uch things ) ! \ i ited It cannot but stir feelings of every good man, and be tated that the author is ex y a ippolinting Hi title is impos ! fulfilment cant He dor not in mplish the purpo innounced | f i nz his subject fresh 1) lone “ ts Confederate chaplain ! ' he wa ind ha since been con 1 with Washington and Lee Univer There he had many opportunities of Lee, and after his death had access Further, Dr. Jones has had ! pal leral experience of editorial work i vas therefore well qualified to present ! public a biography of Lee founded inused documents and information, or if personal reminiscences, or, on of documents hitherto ! Unfortunately, he fails all ! te lie has a few unpublished to set out, bul these are all of light importance they are buried under ’ ma of other letters reprinted from ' " ! | on he subject, and there no aysatem to indicate to the reader which to unpublished and which Of personal reminiscences we get i very few pages, mostly at the end he bool uch value as they may have overshadowed by the fact that they are nbedded in a long narrative of the war distin is neither fresh nor specially xuished for accuracy. Among the unpublish d papers perhaps the moat interesting are ome scraps found in Lee's army satchel untouched nee Appomattox From the qu ttion may be made ’rivate and public life are subject to The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2161 To the spirit of the same rules; and truth and manliness are two qualities that will carry you through this world much better than pol- icy, or tact, or erpediency, or any other word that was ever devised to conceal or mystify a deviation from a straight Hine. In conclusion this volume suggests that the time is now getting near when Lee’s correspondence should be given to the world complete and edited with the same scientifi©c care as that of Washington | Jefferson, Cabell, and the University of Vir- ginia. By John S. Patton. New York and Washington The Neale Publishing Company $2 This volume of nearly four hundred pages contains, first, an account of the founding of the University of Virginia, based on the Thomas Jefferson and Joseph C. Cabell, Jefferson’s able coadjutor in securing the necessary legislation. The prior to the chartering of the Mercer's bill of 1817—is entirely overlooked This legislation, and a full account of the Jef- orrespondence of legislation university in 1819—such as Mr ferson and Cabell correspondence, has been treated in the History of the University of Virg nia and its Alumni, published by the (New York, Next is given an account of the and especial- Lew s Publishing Company 190%) irly days of the university, ly of the misbehavior of the students, un- til the final evolution of the ‘“‘honor sys- em."" Then follows a description of the Jeffersonian buildings, an account of the early faculty, notices of the literary so- cieties, and other student organizations, of their various publications, and of the great fire of 1895. We have also the story of the estoration of the buildings, the late de- athletics and of student so- brief of the separate and indepen- velopment of etlies and a account schools’’—as the dent chairs of this university are called— w'th the recent establishment of the pres- idency of the university Chronological order is not strictly followed, but the read- er may get a good idea of the organization ind development of the university Other chapters are devoted to the alumni who were in the Confederate army and the civil service, and to lists of students who attained honors and won prizes. In chap- ter xxv. the list of orators before the So- clety of the Alumni, from 1838 to 1861, is very defective One misses the names of the Hon. Muscoe R. H. Garnett, orator in 1849, and the Hon. John Randolph Tucker, orator in 1850 In addition to a number of errors of proof, which may easily be corrected, we find others more scrious, among them the following p. 12, Edmund Randolph for Edmund Pendleton; p. 33 Budwell for Burwell; p. 49, Dale for Dade Bledsoe is referred to as Alfred. on p. 214 and in note to p. 335, but correctly as Notwithstanding these Professor Albert on p. 335 oversights, the volume contains much in- formation that an alumnus may be glad to have in convenient compass liew Bvate Petruabrief: seine Entstehung und Stellung in der Geschichte des Ur- christentums Von Dr. Daniel Vdlter Strassburg: J. H. Ed. Heitz The firat epistle of Peter is not one of the greatest of the New Testament writ- ings, but it has a beauty and attractive- ness peculiar to itself in its kindly sym- pathy, its intimacy of appeal, and its per- vading atmosphere of buoyant hope. Many a downcast spirit has turned to it and found refreshment when the loftier writ- ings of St. Paul and the Evangelists seem- ed to be beyond reach. Critical objec- tions of no little seriousness have been raised against the Petrine authorship, and the date of the writing has been fixed in various years of the last two decades of the first century, and by Baur as late as 115 a. D. Harnack, to whom the objec- tions to the authenticity are insuperable, yet who cannot whole to be a falsification, has suggested that the opening and closing paragraphs are interpolations, thus saving the author from the charge of pseudonymity. In this he is followed by McGiffert. But now appears a monograph by Dr. Daniel Vé6l- ter, professor of theology at Amsterdam, which finds far more serious interpolg- tions, involving, in fact, all the distinc- tively Christian portions of the epistle. The theory of the Dutch scholar amounts really to a division of the letter into two distinct compositions, an original portion, which was written in Rome in the years following the Neronian persecution, and sections added by the redactor for the pur- pose of strengthening Christians of Asia Minor during a persecution which occurred about 115 a. pb. The Christianity of the original letter is declared .to be little more than a _ denationalized Judaism, founded almost exclusively upon the Old Testament, and not strictly a new reli- gion grounded upon original doctrines and sacraments. To the later author, all allu- sions to doctrines positively Christian are attributed. There is, of course, no textual authority for such a division, and the internal proof which Professor Vélter advances appears weak and inconclusive. As a specimen of believe the letter as a the evidence for interpolation may be cited the clause in 1:3, “begat us again unto a living hope by the resurrection of Jesus,’’ whereas, in 1:23, the text reads, “having been begotten again through the word of God.” The critic thinks it impossible that both the ‘word of God” and the “resurrection of Jesus” should be made the media of the new birth, and he therefore strikes out the first pas- sage with its allusion to Christ as not authentic. This amounts to saying that the Biblical writers were granted inspir- ed protection from a change of metaphor— which is a serious draft on faith. In- deed, it is the discovery of a mixed meta- phor in 2:5ff., the passage on the “living stones,”’ upon which Dr. Vélter lays great- est weight in proving the presence of large interpolations. But, we may ask, when was it demonstrated that the writer of a sim- ple letter like I. Peter could not become involved in his figures? The theory pro- posed is ingenious, but the reasons ad- vanced have no cogency whatever. In ad- ducing parallels, however, between I. Pe- ter and other writings, such as Romans, Ephesians, James, and I. Clement, Dr. Vél- ter has done some careful work, and his brochure is valuable for this material, whatever one may think of his principal thesis The brilliant success of the analysts of the Hexateuch and of certain of the pro-
Page 21
Nov. 29, 1906] writings has given occasion to violent endeavors to achieve like fruitful results in the documentary separation of literary productions of too brief extent and too great homogeneity to require the hypothesis of different sourees. It is one thing to discover distinct documents in a history extending over centuries, in which the most reader finds dis- crepancies, another matter to in a simple two. The real signifi- cance of abortive endeavors like the the- ory under review in the tribute they imply to the success of the creators of the Biblical of modern times phetical careless and quite egtabiish diverse elements tract of a page or is sober science Triumph of By Philip Revell Co imerica’s Awakening The Righteousness in High Places Loring Allen Fleming H $1.25 net. The recent exposure of political and cor- porate corruption in this country has been, the necessary portrayal of facts so harrowing on whole, so depressing, the plain and and upsetting, that it is refreshing to find a book which, like this of Mr. Allen’s, takes the hopeful view Yet it should be said at once that the volume has no kinship whatever with the pious optimism which has followed so promptly, especially in cer- tain religious weeklies, President Roose- velt’s pronouncement against the muck rake The common starting-point of all such baleful apologies is a denial of things as they are. Mr. Allen, on the other hand has nothing to conceal or condone He does not hold a brief for any reformer or any fad. What he has done is to point out, in a straightforward way, the forces which, in this period of extraordinary social tur- moil, have steadily made for righteousness both in the community and in the average man; to show some of the specific good that has followed the exposure of evil; and to indicate some of the directions in which genuine reform is unmistakably going After a short chapter on ‘“‘How the Awak- in which the situation 1900 ening Came,” in and the general sweep of reform since that time are briefly sketched, and another on “Graft among the Fathers,”” Mr. Allen passes in rapid review typical episodes in the public careers of six leaders of reform —LaFollette, Jerome, Folk, Weaver, Tom Johnson, and Everett Colby. The here, as elsewhere, is not so much rate the main facts, though the narrative is well attended to, as to point out the the which each of these leaders attained, the results which have already flowed from it. With Presi- dent the a few men working for the public good have, in purpose to nar- rea- sons for success and Roosevelt as inspiration, a brief time, aroused the public conscience; and it is from this public conscience, long thought to be dead, that the reformers have drawn strength. Whether it be Mis- souri farmers rallying to support Folk, or citizens of Philadelphia hounding their councilmen until the gas lease was with- drawn; or men, women, and children in New York contributing to a Jerome cam- paign fund, the explanation is the same The people who did these things had re- sponded to a moral appeal, and were ready to do anything in support of leaders whose honor and sincerity they could trust All of this, course, has in one way or The Nation. another been pointed out before, though hardly so interestingly o1 connectedly Mr Allen, however, is one of the first to dwell upon the deep and widespread moral purpose which has underla these various moveme@ts and which still perdures The striking thing after all is that bad as conditions have been t he people have not lost faith in the possibil ity of bettering them Most noteworthy of all, perhaps, is the spectacle of ma chine-made legislatures, a in Pennsyl vania and Missouri, supporting reform gov ernors, and passing laws of a progressive and reforming character Non-pa sar ship and independent voting hav he fleld politics and public work have bee epa rated as never before and the plea for party loyalty and the straight ticket has lost much of its charm To quote Mr Allen When the various Legislatures met n 1905, there were for the first time, prot ably, in the history of this country, five States with Democratic governors and Re publican Legislatures The number was reduced to four by the unseating of Alva Adams in Colorado Yet the other Demo- crath gzgovenors got along quite as well with their opposition Legislatures as the average executives in States where there had been a clean swee] There wa no a deadlock in any of the Stats with di vided governments In Mi un where the Senate was Democratic and the House Republican, it was the latter body which gave Gov Folk the more loval support In Massachusetts Gov Dougla actually vetoed fewer bills than any of his Republican predecessors who had dealt with legislatures of their own party faith The Republican governors of Michigan and Indiana vetoed eleven and seventeet re spectively, of the bill passed by the Re publican Legislatures of those States though a all but State’s Republic Minnesota to Johnson of able passed by slature Gov Dem f ocrat was approve one ot those his an Legi The Allen's of Mr in h assured of Sometimes and ie chiefly of events novelty book 1 interpretation he adds at least ledge—of detailed the intere course how ever materially to our knowledge or to generally available know transactions Such is of the campaign fund important his and of account source of Siz Jerome 1905 There separate the three had theory at least funds The Citizens Union Jerome nominators had one, and was a third which was spoken of rome’s personal fund The Citizen Union issued on October 17th an appeal for were, in one there as “J $50,000 The Jerome nominators two days later asked for $65,000 The money began to come at once, and it is the proud distinction of this campaign that it did not come in large corporat« checks, but in small amounts from indi viduals whose hearts were in what they sent The largest check received was for $5,000 The smallest item was a “lucky penny.” [The total amount collected was $120,433.53, given by 2,443 contributors. ] The last two chapters, on The Trend Towards a Pure Democracy” and Th Moral Wave and the Average Man,” are full of cheer for all who believe in popu lar government In the former, Mr. Allen points out particularly the extent to which virtual popular election of United State Senators has already gone in this country A constitutional amendment seems as re mote as ever, but nomination by pri- maries or conventions at the same time as other State officers, nomination by special Island, and in rapidly Rhode legislative convention, as lately pledging of advance, methods in the candidates are which are eRe bringing the choice of Senators under poy +? lar control Of the half thirty vac 1go7y, one have alr in stics of fidelity bonding my puts down Mr. Allen's t k, not w comfortable a ira e that e millet im at hand, but wit! i t hearter g and view r ro ’ , ’ > | , } ‘ . courage a he fresh a : lula X of the which earhesthess an ness the Ame an people are ex hibiting in racy Farm. By Th The Macmillan Co $ to Choose a mas F ork How New Y remarkable volume for that been com of of information has loss It overs Olls and art of without enthusiasm of tyle the every | Florida the United States, besides California be dryne an fleld neluding the cor of For inst farming in our continer ance the ony region of where fruits can trea i tropical grown, is much accuracy as the In this ce is based the style is with as corn a apple State tion we note that the work ritical of fact swamped by dry Dr. Hunt lays Those who exploit wealth inatior readable, ne Statistics bu rely to = tress on home land pretty Ine out of it ure to end of are the most Florida of er (one con uou ex pile amples was the orange-planting o the eightl ter thousand in all ines in millions rhe terprise and their together with orange ve the ms ere whole of Had out er he vict the State li of create arove I out a flock pe ople of to these ad be would sheep hom« inste gone get rich quick, they would there now, owning good farms, and have Il the prese nt oranges the market calls for rhe countryward not only into Florida where from city, | ort rhi by those Nature fail their of a whok home-maki should who ly ome ng be pur pos« di ill rather book carefully studied returning to that peopl They one spot w will cover men who in do than well to examine methods eek another location with unknown conditions The future de velopment of agriculture will be in the way of more scientific culture, more segre gation of crops, and more knowledge of environment Drama. The Struggle for a Free Stage in London Watson Nicholson Boston Houg! Mifflin & Co $2.50 net This book, although not likely to prov ver} attractive to the ordinary reade f theatrical biography or gossip, will be valu able to the genuine student of dramat history, for the demonstration which affords of the blighting effects of a mo nopoly upon the art which, professedly
Page 22
I en system of The Nation. iry, and using the same old argument, » familiar to modern ears, that the foolish- [Vol. 83, No. 2161 ing was left but “Carmen” and ‘Faust.”’ Six other works of the French school have | now been added, in the expectation that M. | Rousseliére will come to their rescue; and if we may judge by his Roméo, confidence in him has not been misplaced He is fortu- nate, like Jean de Reszke, in being of the manly class of tenors, in voice as well as in bearing. His diction is clear, and he fully entered into the dramatic spirit of his part. Miss Farrar has been for several yegrs |} at the Imperial Opera House in Berlin, a | loca! favorite. Last summer she partici- | pated in the Mozart Festival at Salzburg, where her Zerlina was marvelled at as an achievement unequalled since the days of Pauline Lucea. Then she sang at the Wag- ner Festival in Munich, with similar result; the critics, none too friendly to Americans is a rule, confessed themselves enchanted for once; an Elizabeth like hers, they de- clared, had not been heard there in years A wide range of vocal style and dramatic talent is required to do justice to réles so liverse as Zerlina in “Don Giovanni’ and Elizabeth in “Tannhiiuser.”” Widely dif- ferent, again, from both those rdéles, is the Juliette of Gounod Miss Farrar sang and acted it as if it were her one specialty The opinion was expressed by many that not only in the operatic, but on the local dramatic stage, too, no woman had ever presented so charming, so convincing, a Juliette as hers With her dark hair and eyes, and her graceful contours, she was the ideal of a Veronese girl in her teens Her acting was tragic realism of the high- est type. Her facial expression is as fasci- nating, as subtle, as varied, as Calvé’s; every note of the score is mirrored in her features. To all this she adds a voice dis- tinguished by the same beauty and ex- pressiveness; a voice of a most agreeable timbre, lending itself to every variety of coloring. She achieved a pronounced suc cess. | The Standard Operas. By George P. Upton Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co $1.50 “Nineteenth printing’ is the eloquent mark on the new edition of Mr. Upton’'s useful handbook, issued by its publishers just in time for the opening opera season It indicates the great and growing inter- est taken in grand opera in this country The 1891 edition was a book of 371 pages; the latest edition has 495 pages, besides %2 portraits,of singers in favorite rdéles. One of these portraits is of Geraldine Far- rar as Juliette. Equally up to date is the list of operas, except that, strange to say, the two reigning sensations, Puccini's ‘Madame Butterfly’ “Salome,” are not included Perhaps the and Richard Strauss’s author thought they had not yet earned their right to be classed among “standard” operas. There are some older operas in the list that might as well have been omit- ted, as they are never sung in this coun- try; among them, Auber’s “Crown Dia- monds,” Brill’'s “The Golden Cross,’ Flo- with " worthy rruption of the stage is the in- I f he long abl ymsequence of the depravity of ' I ion thea pul iste Edward Bulwer, the first ! Cover Garden 1 Ly Dy on the other hand, seldom vw) pa t onferrin peared » greater advantage than when ' 4] drama was leading the fight against theatrical ( i] 662 and con res, pleading the cause of free trade } , lefled ; ind insisting upon the true function holished finally t! ige, to inspire as well as to enter- I s4 a b Among the many interesting points noted ! ! Dr. Nicholson's book is the manner in Dr. Nicho has p ; h the introduction of transatlantic 1 the , imship yntributed to the overthrow of how patent houses by opening up a new } } sang i to the principal English actors and ’ spas by rendering them independent. Many , il » mad r curious facts in the history of theat- ' ha _ London are ti be found in these pages und finall avolved | ynscientious readers, Dr. Nichol- He has gone { furnishes a convenient summary of his . if k, as well a 1 complete bibliography . vspape ! lex | ph p rd ' pond rhe Rose of the Rancho,” by David Be- ' , e | o and Richard Walton Tully, which was edir po produced in the Belasco Theatre in this la m y on Tuesday evening, is a play on an well vorthy of American subject, having a semi-historical ’ ited lavor, and dealing with contrasted national pe ind on these *counts, entitled to ! f i b } 1 word or two of record It treats of the } +] ey pulous land-grabbing which occurred 1 jue Neither Southern California, after the United iad r minor tates had taken possession, in cases where i hil 1 play original Spanish residents had failed to i ind th : , ail themselves of the law of registration pre that As drama it is unimportant, being a ma- } i pon } ‘ made piece of an essentially theatri- a 1Q n Anne both 1 and spectacular ordet But the leading of it i pro te in American adventurer, a 7 of it. } Government agent, Spaniards, male | » favored mat ind female, an old priest, and so forth . ohats | a certain vitality and picturesque } , rhe lialogue is diffuse and poor , lt hief value of the representation lies ! t } ' the sett r and stage management, both f Cha ’ which a incommonly excellent Such f 1 . ine tho of the Mission Garden ' vas dur he nex he courtyard of the Rancho, and the roof } | i th of the house, with the surrounding land But it was also ipe, have eldom been surpassed on any { 1 ng th tag if Mr. Belasco’s plays were al h the royal preroga vay vorthy of the frame in which he ex bout t | nsing of h hem, the ar tic theatre would b ' mad the po om shed fact The acting in ‘The bl und led I of tl Rancho is fairly good il | lation Bill us arity ° ) . Musie. 4 hn i } i ‘ eet e METROPOLITAN GRAND OPERA n f The fit gun in the grand opera war was | ! ' ! h f 1 on Monday night by Heinrich Conried he Metropolitan Opera House. It will , ! ! inawered by Oscar Hammerstein next 1 dees Monday at his new Manhattan Opera House ! I Mr. Conried’s opera was Gounod’s “‘Roméo w Juliette which gave him an opportunity f ach luce two of the leading singers he | i ‘ her h eason added to his list Miss Ger- | ielancholy Farrar and Charles Rousseliére, the , y R ard Pa in tenor 4 good French tenor has yI zg a ! » desideratum at our opera house for tellect to mainta th veral seasons; for lack of one, the French which he was the bens epertory was gradually cut down till noth- tow's “Stradella,’’ Goldmark’s “Merlin,” Halévy’s “L’Eclair,”” Herold's “Zampa,"" Lortzing'’s (not Lértzing’s as the printer persists in making it) “Czar and Car- penter,”’ Marschner’s “Hans Helling,” and more than a dozen others; but it is bet- ter to have too many than too few The principal operettas of Genée, Lecocq, Johann Strauss, Sullivan, Offenbach, and others
Page 23
Nov. 29, 1906] are also included, quite properly. The ap- pendix contains a bibliography of American opera, and to the regular index the author has added an index of the principal vocal numbers in the various operas he describes and analyzes—a feature which will com- mend itself to many. Heretofore the ex- cellent Champlin and Apthorp “Cyclopedia of Music and Musicians’ (Scribners) has been the only reference book in which one could find out where a certain aria or title of which one happened to remember the name, but not the source, might be found In the next edition of his admirable hand- book Mr. Upton should refer to the arias in Gounod’s, Meyerbeer’s and Bizet’s op- eras by their French instead of their Ital- ian names; they are now always sung here in the original language or in English. Of all the none seems so un-Gallic a Bach cult great as Bach, in France. composers there is Berlioz professed to see nothing in Bach's music that was worth while; but Saint-Saéns him and found that this indifference was based ignorance; he had not’ studied the condemned, and greatly Saint-Saéns played for good many years ago, still doing missionary On Tuesday afternoon he in Carnegie Hall at which, yet quite tested on scores he pleased with what him. That was a but Saint-Saéns work for Bach. gave a recital was 1s for the first time here, he was heard as an interpreter of other music than his own. He began with the Italian concerto and a prelude and fugue by the great cantor, playing them in a_ delightfully lucid, archaic style. After adding two Rameau pieces, the pianist played Bee- thoven’s A flat major sonata; he made the variations of the first movement remark- ably interesting, and played the funeral march with deep feeling. Like his friend Liszt, not afraid put a symphonic movement on his programme —the andante from Haydn's “Surprise” symphony, charmingly translated into the pianistic idiom. But what gave most pleas- Saint-Saéns was to ure to the audience was his playing of Chopin’s “Barcarolle’” and of adroitly made arrangements of excerpts from his two operas “Samson et Dalila” and “Henry VIII."". M. Saint-Saéns has an- nounced that his present tour will close his career as a pianist The Vienna Male Chorus will visit the United States in April, 1907. The itinerary at present is projected to include New York, Boston, Chicago, Buffalo, Baltimore, Washington, Philadelphia, and Indianapolis The proceeds of the concerts will be given to local Austro-Hungarian and other chari- ties. Two hundred singers will make up the chorus, which pays its own expenses. Art. Histoire de UArt depuis les Premiers Temps Chrétiens jusqu’a Nos Jours. Edited by André Michel. New York: G. E. Stechert & Co. Tom. I. (Vols. I. and II.). Des Débuts de l’Art Chrétien a la fin de la période romane. About five hun- dred illustrations. 15 fr. a velume. The essentially social nature of French scholarship appears to advantage in this composite history of Christian art. Ten The Nation. collaborators have this first of eight volumes, yet there is no sense of dis- worked on parity of point of view or of disquieting difference of stylk Much of the credit for so remarkable a degree of coordina tion is due to the general editor; more to the sound traditién of higher education in France. The work is worthy of the race that produced the “Grande Encyclopédie” and the “Histoire Littéraire No other nation seems to have the art of collective | scholarship. Compared with the work be- | fore us,the variousGerman Grundriase, ete are lacking in sense of proportion, and such admirable British enterprises as the “Cambridge Modern History’’ in consist- ency and attractiveness of style It is a work of specialists for the let- tered public, by no means a manual for first studies Latin quotations are not translated, illustration is reduced in num- ber and scale to the minimum The book can be used profitably only by those who carry in their heads the memory of the im- portant monuments, or better, read beside a photograph cabinet It is, in short, a/| book for those who are in some sense scholars, and for such will be peculiarly valuable, as a comprehensive appreciation ’ of recent discussion and traditional the ories. The motto of the writers has been “prove all things.” Early Christian art has been treated by André Peraté in a delightful essay, in stinct with sympathy and good sens: Roman architecture before the Roman- esque period has been entrusted to Camill: Enlart, who length Ro manesque chapter of ex- traordinary interest is that on Byzantine Art, by Gabriel Millet His chief merit is to have defined that Oriental element in Byzantinism which usually has been vague- ly The of Merovingian and ex- of which illuminated Paul out also writes at on architecture A asserted very obscure Carolingian are topic —the confined fallen to through- to Emile Bertaux, He has also ed of Sculpture of that period in France has been selected by the general editor, André Michel Emile Male has forth beginnings of mural painting and of glass art amples practically to manuscripts—has Leprieur Italian painting | the period has been allotte: in two essays treat the Romanesque sculpture Italy set the painting in France Northern miniature painting is assigned to Arthur Haseleff The late Emile Molinier has contributed (enamel work), and also on the minor arts—ivories, articles on barbaric goldsmithy bronzes, jewelry, enamels—for the entire pre-Gothic period Brief intercalated chapters by J.-J. Marquet de Vasselot on Oriental influences in European art yield in interest to none of the more extensive contributions, but bear a little the look of special pleading. One is hardly ready to concede that a convergence of Sassenid, Tartaric, Gothi just a dash of Hellenic and Roman remin , and Coptic influences with iscence really explains the complex we call the Romanesque This dry enumeration of contents and contributors is really necessary to show the thorough and comprehensive nature of this work. It is, within our knowledge, the only general history of Christian art that treats architecture adequately and from the architect's point of view. The writers are consistently alert in noting the réal bonds | | | a ae a 46% between the arbitrary classifications of the and take, for example, be tween ivory carving, stone sculpture, mura! arts—the give painting, and illumination is illustrated in a hundred instances Thus the book be comes a warning against narrow specializa- tion and a lesson in humility. It shows that nothing is surer than that the art historian of a single specialty is a poor his torian To imagine that one knows, say monumental painting, without some study of such humble matters as_ ivori and manuscripts, is to be grossly self-deceived The superiority of much of this work ove similar writing in German and English lies in the fact that these French scholars have not been ashamed to practise a wis discursiveness We reviewing must waive the impossible task that « trates the scholarship of ten experts upo critically a volume oncen the art of twelve centuries. We may, how ‘ ever, add to our special commendation the chapters of MM. Peraté and Millet a reference to the editorial summing up by M. Michel He takes middle ground on the Rome-Byzantine controversy, holding that Byzantinism was a preceptorial influence ident the d itself as it never cordially adopted in Oc Roman Orientalizing tendency of M. Michel alao convinced, f of character which most fully realize ized Against the of his exception of the ware mo contributors takes being Asiatte With mere not example origin barbar thi s brie f hint at enamel richness work that zation, and a must k of Chri Suggestion we ive a serious student alike for delight every tian ar must read critical rientation and simple Thirty-three Chase School larger William ™M are the New York of Art December 3 It is a collection of Mr has been put on public view for some pictures by on exhibition at until Chase's work than time of years life, it of the and the development and including as it does his the examples work through last twenty in and still the portraiture, landscape represents excellently variety achievement, of Earliest of all the large Still Life,” back to student days in Munich of of the esting picture 18 which Mr that Whistler painted It this after having first approved, called an artist's his art works is the dates the most inter of Whistler in 1886 the the portrait of which Whistler “out po which From ‘Study in anecdote the painted point view portrait Chase at time him was portrait rageous lampoon.” Throughout the traits, mingling with the manner which is distinctively the artist's own, is apparer the influence of Whistler and Alfred Ste vens The influence of Whistler shows n the Japanese decorative motives, as in ihe Open Japanese Book’'’; in the har monious arrangements of low-keyed mono- tones, as in the “Mrs. C and Baby and in the attitudes of some of the figures The influence of Stevens, appearing a lit tle later, shows in such pictures as the “Portrait of Miss E and “The Musk Lesson.”’ The portrait of the late L. F Roos is exceptional for forcible expression of character Few of the portraits, in- deed, at any period, might be called psy- | chological, but the earlier work caught almost invariably with a distinguished manner the flowering charm of a person- ality. One gets the impression often that
Page 24
470 the artist has felt no vital interest in his subject—that, in his later portraits, es- pecially, he has nothing to say commen- surate with his means for saying it. This may account in part for the fact that much f his best later work is in still life, and interiors of which “The Study in Still Life No. 1, and “The Green Shade” are ellent examples In such work as this where the artist can deal with technical fieulties for their own sake, untrammel- led with the problems of portraiture, there tonishing freshness and finish bert L. Groll is exhibiting § at the haus galler n th city, a number of paintings of Arizona Mexico, and Cal " rh canvases repeat the scenes snd the manner with which he has already made us familiar Mr. Groll’s work shows ndividuality in jts color scheme, which s derived from the yellows and blues of the Arizona deserts and skies, and in the pa wus dignity of the composition A fine nd characterist example of these qual The Land of the Hopi Indian,” “ h shows a depth of yellow plain bound the d ince by blue mountains and inated by a vast blue expanse of sky show the need I many of the invases greater harmony of color and refinement An interesting exhibition of eighteenth entury French art is now open at Ehrich’s gn rie n th city Of the twenty hree invas« two of the most important fall outside the limits of the eighteenth ntury—the “Baptism of Jesus,”” by Nich olas Poussin, and the “Portrait of a Man,”’ ! Jean A. D. Ingres Both are fine exam- ple The Boston Miniature Painters have in | the Pennsylvania Society of Minia ture Painters, now exhibiting in the Acad- emy in Philadelphia, to exhibit the col- lection in Boston The exhibition will be given the first two weeks in December ievidence of the increasing importance ittached to modern painting in Great furnished by the ') cottish Modern Arts Association In formation of 1 preliminary prospectus, signed by Lord ihalearre Sir Walter Armstrong, Sir Ed- rennant, and other public men, in ad- to Sir James Guthrie, and the lead- painters of Scotland, it is set forth at there is not a gallery in. Scotland vl by the tudent of art ean be red containing a permanent collec- work adequately representative of h art The aim of this ¥ bod therefore will be first to se ie ear by year worthy works by Scot- h art ind second, as funds permit, juire contemporary works, other than h of outstanding interest peeling frescoes by Mor- Burne-Jor Rossetti, and others on The fading and } wall f the Library of the Oxford Inion have been photographed, and the photographs have been published by the j It j brar f the late Gen. Lou Palma j { i fo more than twenty years f « Metropolitan Museum of will be id on Monday, Tuesday, and Wednesday, December 3, 4, and 5, by the Merwin-Claytor Salea Co of this city Rook mart in : broadest ense predom inate, including architecture, ceramics, art sud their work, Japa ind Japan The Nation. ind books, etc. Among the special works are Ferratio’s “Costume Antico e Mod- erno,”’ 1829-1834, twenty volumes, folio; the “Florence Gallery,” 1789-1807, four volumes, one of the special copies on ‘“‘pa- irt, catalogues of collections of pictures | pier-velin superfine.” . 4 Scrence, NATIONAL ACADEMY OF SCIENCES Boston, November 23 The autumn meeting of the National Academy of Sciences, held in Boston, No- vember 20, 21, 22, in the new buildings of the Harvard Medical School, was notable in several respects. The presence of thiry-eight out of the one hundred members made an attendance decidedly larger than the ave- rage in out-of-Washington meetings, even larger than most of the meetings in Wash- ington, business session for the election of new members ordinarily at- tracts a good attendance. The number of papers was exceptionally large, owing to the addition of eighteen by invited speak- ers to the twenty-six by members. An ex- hibit of apparatus and specimens by nearly fifty members and invited associates was held the first afternoon, filling two big la- boratories and the adjoining hall; and this, as well as the scientific and public ses- sions, Was attended by an unusual number of interested visitors. The chief reason for all this increase in activity appears to have been the appointment at the last Washington meeting of a committee, with Prof. H. F. Osborn of Columbia as chair- man, to prepare a new plan for the au- the local committee had where the tumn meeting; | only to carry out the plan Among the exhibits by guests of the Academy were hybrids of wild and tame | | with which we are familiar is one of guinea pigs, by W. E. Castle, of Harvard, illustrating his experiments in the process of fixing characters in animal breeding; photographs of rill work by T. A. Jaggar, | jr., of the Institute of Technology, show- ing the results of experiments on erosion; zoetrope figures, showing the movement of the stomach and intestines, drawn by W. B. Cannon of the Medical School, from | X-ray studies; a new geological map of North America, by Bailey Willis of the United States Geological Survey; a new geological map of Massachusetts, by B. K Emerson of Amherst; the earliest stages of sexuality in plants, by A. F. Blakeslee of Harvard; examples of ultra-violet photo- micrography, by H.C. Ernst of the Medical School. Exhibits by members included re- | cent work of the Harvard College Observa- | tory, by its director, E. C Pickering; a platinum-lined bomb for experiments at high temperatures and pressures, by A. A. Noyes of the Institute of Technology; horses, by H F restora- tions of extinct Columbia; instruments for Osborn of research in acoustics by A a Webster of Clark University; plates of fossils from Patagonia, by W. B. Scott of Princeton; a machine for cutting wax-plates, used in constructing models, by BE. L. Mark of Harvard; charts of atmospheric nucleation, by C. Barus of pendulum apparatus for determin- quantitative Brown ne the force of gravity, by G. C. Com- [ Vol. 83. No. 2161 stock of Wisconsin; physical apparatus, by T. W. Richards of Harvard. This list should be more than doubled, to give full indica- tion of the richness and novelty of the ex- hibit The papers presented by guests and mem- bers in the scientific scsstons of the Acad- emy included the following: “Experiments in Aerodromics,’’ by A. G. Bell of Wash- ington; ‘‘Acoustic Measurements,” by A G. Webster of Clark University; ‘“Conti- nental Sedimentation,’’ by J. Barrell of Yale; “Evidence of Desiccation in Chinese Turkestan,” by Ellsworth Huntington of Harvard; ‘Planetary Inversion, by W. H Pickering of Harvard College Observatory; “Extent and Structure of the Stellar Uni- verse,” by G. C. Comstock of Wisconsin; “Section of American Tertiaries,” by H. F Osborn of Columbia; “‘Nature and Cause of Old Age,”’ by C. S. Minot of the Medical School; “Ores of the Cobalt-Silver Dis- trict of Ontario,” by C. S. Van Hise of Wisconsin; “Sun Spot Spectra,” by G. S Hale of the Carnegie Solar Observatory; “Reactions of Amphiurus to Light,” by G. H. Parker of Harvard; “Light of Extremely Short Wave Length,” by T. Lyman of Har- vard. The list of papers was so extended that many were read only by title, and even then there was insufficient time for discussion. The lunches, receptions, and dinners given during the meeting added much to the pleasure of a memorable oc- casion DENATURED ALCOHOL. The newspapers have printed a great deal about the uses of denatured alcohol for light, and also for fuel, especially in automobiles and other engines. Much has also been said about the possibilities of cheap manufacture from all sorts of fa~m products, and even from waste, under the law which removes the internal revenuy tax after January 1. The’ alcohol many. In fact, there is a class of com- pounds called alcohols, only two of which are commonly known — ethyl alcohol \C,H1,OH), that referred to in ordinary par- | lance; and methyl, or wood alcohol (CH,OH) which is a poison, with injurious fumes. This fact is illustrated in the dissolving of shellac. At present, on account of the high price of alcohol, wood alcohol is sub- | stituted, and its fumes are said to produce ill-effects in the workmen. Ethy!] alcohol is the product of yeast cells living at the expense of a special form of sugar—a form which may be produced from different sources. It may be made by a process called “inverting’’ cane-sugar; by “hydro lizing’’—chemically adding water to starch; by malting grain; or it may grow natur- ally in fruit juices and saps. Yeast action on sugar from any of these sources pro- duces alcohol and also about six per cent. of other ingredients. The alcohol, what- | ever the source of sugar, is of the same composition, but the six per cent. of other material gives individuality to the product, according to the origin of the sugar. Thus, rum is the product of yeast action on molasses, while whiskey is ob- tained from barley or corn, In addition to the above method of making alcohol, there is a possibility of obtaining it from such unpromising substances as coke and other forms of carbon. This process, however,
Page 25
Nov. 29, 1906] yet to be worked out industrially by the chemist, would require—under conditions yet to be discovered—something like the production of calcium carbide (CaC _) from coke; then a conversion to acetylene (C,H, then to ethylene (C,H, and then by a double reaction to ethyl alcoho! Denatured alcohol, on the other hand, is pure ethyl alcohol, adulterated in accord- with the law. When so adulterated, it is branded tax free. For many or poisonous substance added to pure alco- hol no harm at the time renders the alcohol for medicine. For in celluloid; therefore with in the ernment has and has the alcohol der the supervision of ance “denatured” and is purposes, a disagreeable and same unfit does drinking or camphor denatured instance, there is alcohol objectionabl The Gov- adulterants bond un- De- would not be manufacture of selected denatured camphor celluloid certain in ls own agents natured alcohol, unless otherwise specified, must by law contain for every one hundred parts of alcohol ten parts of wood, or methyl, alcohol and one-half of one pari of benzine Since these ingredients are not suited to all industrial purposes, the Government -~when requested will use other substances such as shellac, resins, acetic acid, pyridin, acetons methyl acetate, aniline dyes, naphthalene, castor oil, car bon bisulphide, and carbolic acid The whole subject was considered at the regular meeting of the New York Section of the Society of Chemical ‘Industry last Friday night Professor C. E. Lucke of Columbia, presented figures obtained from a series of tests which illustrate the com- parative efficiency of gasolene and alcohol in internal combustion engines He con- cludes that alcohol, although more efficient will not compete for motive strong ly plentiful as it is now hold only gasolente powe r, long as gasolene is as The exception would little making al- SO with gasolen: there for in regions where is the c favorable nditions and cohol are most Rambles on the Riviera By Edouard Stras burger New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $5 net The Mediterranean coast of France and of western Italy owes much of its attra tiveness to the beauty and variety of its plants. The sunny skies and the fertile soil of that country known as the Riviera, produce vegetation in full splendor. A well-informed botanist would, therefore, be an admirable guide through the region; and just such a person is the author of this book. Professor Strasburger is,one of the leading plant-morphologisis of Germany, whose contributions to the science have opened new fields of thought He is a all Moreover, he is lover of nature, to whom living things are replete with interest uncommonly well read in all such matters as the uses of plants, the myths in regard to them, and the vanishing folk-lore He lets nothing escape his observation, and yet he does not tire his readers by wearisome display of knowledge pressionist, making sometimes a single line or a touch of color tell He has imparted to his volume something of the charm which of his laboratory manuals a charm largely due to an offhand, chatty style, his multifarious and exact As a writer, he is a true im- a long story has rendered one 80 popular, | The Nation. which is at the same time direct. This rec- | ord, then, is an attractive as well as sound guide-book The illustrations are well s lected, and finely executed Every reader will carry away a considerable amount of trustworthy information, es- pecially concerning the flora rhe follow- ing passage will indicate the style of the author and show, likewise, the excellence of the translation Night is drawing on, and Mentone lights are beginning to appear in the houses and the streets The strand is soon pick ed out with points of light, fringing the sea like a necklace of fiery px rhe lines of the Mignonlied passed through my mind, and the rhythm washing of the waves seemed to recall the music of Be« thoven’s beautiful accompaniment It is significant that those plants, which in this song of Goethe's conjure up in our minds such vivid pictures of Italy, are not indi genous in that land, which has been culti vated for over two thousand yea “hey came from the East, like all the great ideas on which our culture is founded, and were developed and improved on this classic orange irn had oli the grown by cullivation soil. Italy received the lemon a from the Semites, who in their received them from India rhe fig, the vine, and the palm were the Semites long before their penetrated to the West The laurel and myrtle indeed are indigenous in Italy, but their use for ceremonial purposes came across the Mediterranean from the East The home of the cypress is not in Italy, but in the Greek Archipelago, northern Persia, Cilicia, and Lebanon As though the great impulse given to horticulture by the discovery of America were also destined nad ve to leave its imprint upon Italian soil, the agave and opuntias have been established ‘here. Thus the spiny, glaucous agaves and the prickly, vivid-green opuntias, which ar so well adapted to the rocky coast of Italy that they seem to have been here from tim: immemorial, were really not introduced from America until the sixteenth century The range of subjects treated of is very wide From prehistoric times down through the golden ages of Greek and Roman culture, to the industries and the thinking of the present, is a long journey, but our author makes it with a cheery step, and with innumerable diversions by the way We hear the story of the Iron Mask, the legends of certain castles and convents, and the traditions clustering around the villas and villages, as we stroll along admiring or perhaps studying the plants which the author brings constant ly to our attention Before the rambles ire over, one -has learned much in regard to the great flower-market of the South the perfume industry, the fruits of the favored land, the factors of landscape, the part which ceremonial plants have played in early and in later times, and so on The whole book is written in a kindly spirit, and there are generous words for many people, some of which it would be very pleasant to cite But we must con tent ourselves with a single further ref erence, which brings the treatise very near home: Besides the Smyrna fig, the best varieties of date palm have lately been introduced into the United States. The United States Department of Agriculture in Washington devotes special attention to work of this kind, and men appointed as “assistants” in the Division of Vegetable Physiology and Pathology, or as agricultural ex- plorers”’ in the Bureau of Plant Industry, are entrusted with the carrying out of These are scientifically who have firat mastered these experiments trained botanists, the theoretical part of the subject and still keep up these studies side by side with 4°71 their practical work Two of these “as sistants now usefully employed by the t 1 States Department of Agriculture idied t iny at Bonn, and I have the highes n of the indomitable industry nd perseverance. th ntelligence and pa tier f tl young scholars One of the Wa Tr. Swingle, who ha since been iccessful ver ming the ob stacles which had hitherto prevented the satisfactory dev pme of the Smyrna fig in 1 who has made the United States, ar possible also t ‘ ire ermanent re with t? late-palm American Fossil Cy ‘ ‘ large quarto by G. |} \W ’ fy I versity, published igh the Ca Z I ution This worthy to Ame can paleobotany is ly l with fifty plates and 138 text figures it is an account of the American collectior f fossil cycad plants allied to the fer: fa is they hav been studied, and ths i f the author's investigations on the vegetative inatomy and reproductive or ga followed by a comparison of thes with similar ructure in living ecyead ind a d j nm of relationship it s I bably not generally known that som the best fossil preservation of these nteresting plants are in the United States Black Hills that the cycads the ind Maryland; and of fossil Universi particularly in Wyoming most the important ollection in world ts Yale ve of the « at iving representa the y yeads are remnants of which dominated certain al Zeoi.ok { time age was 1 Lora there was at one an when the of these The somewhat periods, and ids (Jurassic) earth forests plants as far ancient the of have the pole types of then same the for monograph creditable to the pre rf Is have the botan as yme contem reptilian groups the zo rhe botany is American and sswork the Carnegie Institution The the American Eclipse Expedition of 190 largest ever fitted out by any nation, is cribed in the National Geographic Maga for Admiral C ibute to thoriti« November by its commander, Rear M He al the of sh au well as to the ine Chester ord pays a ¢ tr courtesy the Span extraordinarily lors while on shore of Ceyion good conduct of his sai The the wonderful remains Anuradhapura of famous capital twenty-one beautiful John M old ports on the Spanish Maracait« similar manner by George rhe ount centuries ago, are shown in some ith des« and picture “ riptive ote by Abbot Main, © pictured three imana, La Guayra, and are in a M. L llustrated a other contents of Brown are an Peary's expe lition ind President Roosevelt's letter to the Congress of Irrigation Engineers on the nt two great undertakings of the Reclamation i and Forest Services On Monday and Tuesday the Anderson Auction Co. of this city will sell the 1 > brary of the late Elliott Coues, th: m nent ornithologist The scientific portion of the library, mainly ornithological, com prises 369 lots, and includes some rare and valuable books on birds, many being presentation copies The Catalogue of Birds in the Br sh Museum,” twenty seven volumes, is an unusual set, and has never before come yp for sale at auction in this country. Baird, Brewer, and Ridg way’s “North American Birds,’ three vol-
Page 26
which | | Birds of California,”’ and of the Nest and Eggs of Oh by Genevieve E. Jones j Schulze; all with col- ire among the more notable m ellaneous library con- rable items of Americana ! m of Patrick Gass’s yage ind Travels of a Corps Und Cay Lewis and zh, 1807; D. W. Harmon’s \ i ind Travels in the \m t 1820; and Al r'ra Is and Adventures 809. The bulk of Dr. Coues’s p ynal ) pondence O00 ttograph le rs i ) ‘ prominen will yn housand In 1 } life, Dr. Coues 1 in theosophy and kindred ved a numl of auto- n Madame Blavatsky ye hinance. REPORT IN “BOOM TIMES iilways a likely to ! people no meerned with ‘ n inv tment mar id dull On o isions, how loguent as ae reflection litions in a particular re- he yuntry a i whole The t yn Pacific Railway, pub iV i rik nz nstan of 0 ber, 189 when th shock va beginning to sub Pacif was unable to mee I was placed n re- ind did not emerge from July SY Even then ! ) Ivency only after the had paid a ish asse 1000, and old mortgages 1 down 1 interest or prin | mm fa bonus n new of it collapse, Union Pa come on a community that the verge of insolvency. The | Kansa ind Nebraska fail n wheat had im farmers, ata moment when f loans by Eastern markets 1 th ime farmer with dis ed Colorado, where the lu y Wa shutting down 0 of the ection in f hat both Kansas and a Populist as ret ed-tl gril il a In 1893, ig from it traf ! 1 80 ind t ‘ its fixed " there was a wide n nmunit nh ques il | ind that both ind mining were dea- | in; fital y of that region from ita de suragement is one of the in financial history mm day in 1896. India's wheat eason tailed, and American the Bryan campaigners had declared could under the gold stan- never, The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2161 dard, rise in price again, once more sold at a dollar a bushel. Less than a twelvemonth after the 1896 election, shortage in all of Kurope's crops, coinciding with an abun- lant American harvest, gave Kansas and Nebraska farmers the most profitable sea- son since 1879. “Debts were paid off; in- dustry revived; bank balances accumulated. rhe revival did not stop with foreign crop hortages. As prosperity returned to Amer- ican industry in general, one of its most triking results was a greatly increased de- mand for agricultural products. A series of almost unprecedentedly large harvests, old at highly remunerative prices, so far enriched the crop-growing States that, in place of the story of “Eastern capital loan- ed in the West,” we began to hear of Western bank funds outstanding on Wall Street.’” Such “interior loans,”’ these last few years, are believed to have run above the one-hundred-million figure. The reorganized Union Pacific began to pay dividends on its new preferred stock in Isvs, and resumed dividends on the com- mon stock in 1900. Its net receipts from transportation, which were $5,602,000 in the first year after its reorganization of 1897, had risen to $17,767,000 in 1900, and in the fiscal year ending June 30, 1906, are now shown to have been $30,317,000. In place of the bankrupt treasury of ten years ago, the current annual report makes the re- markable showing, along with other assets, of $21,258,000 cash on hand or in bank, and of $34,716,000 lent out on call in the money market ° The Union Pacific is not alone among railway companies in evidencing by such extraordinary figures the change in the country’s position. Its case is peculiarly its recovery from com- wealth interesting, because plete insolvency to possession of not dreamed of by any railway a dozen years ago, is typical of the spectacular change in the community which it serves. This chapter of history, both of the rail- and of the region from which it draws prosperity, adds point to the comment quently made by foreign observers, on remarkable extremes reached in the up- of American an episode to cu- way its fre the downward swings Naturally, such prompts the thoughtful as to the next chapter. ward and prosperity ometimes rious conjecture BOOKS OF THE WEEK Baldwin, May Peg'sa Adventures in Paris Dut- ton. $1.50 Bahkiwin, May That Little Lamb Philadelphia: Gieorge W. Jacobs & Co Barrett, Alfred Wilson Father Pink Boston: Small, Maynard & Cu. $1.50 Blanchard, Amy E The Four Corners. Philadel phia: George W. Jacobs & Co Bowen, Marjorie The Viper of Milan McClure, hillips & Oo $1.50 Buffum, George T Smith of Bear City and Other Frontier Sketches. Grafton Press. $1.50 net Runyan's Pilgrim's Progress Dutton. $2.50 Butterfield, Virginia M Parental Rights and Keo nomic Wrongs. Chicago: Stockham Publishing Co, Candee, Helen Churehill Decorative Styles and leriods In the Home. F. A. Stokes Co. $2 net. Cartwright, Julia The Karly Work of Raphael. Dutton, 75 centa net Celllal, Benvenute, The Life of Written by bim- self 2 vols Brentano's Chapin, Anna Alice. The Heart of Music. Dodd, Mead & Co $1.00 net Cipriani, List de The Cry of Defeat Roston: Richard G. Badger $1.25 Clark, Andrew A Hedlelan Guide for Visitors Heary Frowde Corolla Numismatica In Honour of Barelay V. Head re Frowde SOs. net Cromareh, hi ipley ‘-- _ Ronee of the Moor Cottage Resten mall, nard & Co. $1.26 uaa ing of a Housewtfe. Curtis, Isabel Gordon, The F. A. Stokes Co. §1.50 net Davidson, Thomas. The Philosophy of Goethe's Faust Boston: Gian & Co. W@W cents net Dixon, James Main. Matthew Arnold. Eaton & Mains. 1. Downey, David G. Richard Watson Gilder and Others. Eaton & Mains.— Ellis, Edward 8. River and ungle. Philadelphia: John C. Winston Co. $1. Essays on Shakespeare. By Leo Tolstoy, Ernest Crosby and G. Bernard Shaw. Funk & Wag- halls Co. Fairy-Gold Fairy Tales. Chosen by Ernest Rhys. Dutton, $2.50. Fairy Ring. Edited by Kate Douglas Wiggin and h , Nora A. Smit MeClure, Phillips & Co Fitzgerald, Hugh. Sam Steel's Adventures. Chi- cago: Reilly & Britton Co. Fletcher, Robert Huntington in Philology and Literature. Ginn & Co $1. Studies and Notes Vol. X. Boston: Friends’ General Conference, Proceedings of. Phil delphia. Games Book for Boys and Girls. Dutton. $2.50. Garrod, H. W. The Religion of All Good Men. McClure, Phillips & Co. Gate of Death: A Diary. Putnams. $1.25 net. Guerville, A. B. de. New Egypt. Dutton. §3 net. Gwynn, Stephen. The Fair Hills of Ireland. Mac millan Co. 2. Hawkes, Clarence. Shaggycoat. Philadelphia: George W. Jacobs & Co. Hildreth’s Japan as It Was and Is Edited by Ernest W. Clement. Chicago: A. C. McClurg & Co. Hilgard, E. W. Soils. Macmillan Co. $4 net. Hulbert, Archer Butler. Pilots of the Republic. Chicago: A. C. MeClurg & Co. Hutton, Edward. Sigismondo Malatesta. Dutton. et. Adrian J. My Lady's Point of View. Bos H. M. Caldwell Co. , Jeremiah W. Great “Phillips & Co. Johnson, Willis Fletcher, Four Ci we x of the Panama Canal. Henry Holt & Co Kore, Alice Maplesden. Cadwallader. “Golden acmillan Co. 25 net. La Chanson de Roland. A Modern Translation by J. Geddes, Z Macmillan Co. 9) cents net. Leighton, William. A Scrap-Book of Pictures and $4 b lorio, a. Fortunes. McClure, Fancies.—Whisperin of the Sphinx. Chicago: R. R. Donnelley & ns Co. Lindsay, Anna Robertson Brown. ‘Tie Warrior sf so in the Republic of God. Macmitian Co 50 net. Lockwood, Frank C. Robert Browning. Eaton & Mains. London, Jack. Scorn of: Women. Macmillan Co. Manners. The School for Donkeys Lushington, Mrs. Dutton. $1.25 and Other Stories. Maitland, F. W. Life of Sir Leslie Stephen. Put nams. $4.50 net. Malloch, Douglas. In Forest Land. Chicago: American Laumberman. Mann, Arthur Sitgreaves. Prince Ivo of Bohemia. Grafton Press. $1 net. Marabell, William. The Rise of Man. Published by the Author. $1.50. Mauclair, Camille. Antoine Watteau. cents net. Dutton. 75 Metealf, Syzanne. Annabel. Chicago: Reilly & Britton Co. 25. Mills, Wesley. Voice Production. Philadelphia: Lippincott. $2 net. Minor Poets of the Caroline Period. Edited by George Saintsbury. Vol. Il. Henry Frowde 10s. 6d. net. Montmorency, J. E. G. de he x 7 Peer oat His Age and Book. Putnams. $2.25 Morrow, Albert 8. The Immediate Case Of the In jured. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co. $2.50 net. Muckerstrum, Louis. Louis’ Mixed Drinks. Boston: H. M. Oaldwell Co. Orezy, Baroness. I Will Reply. Philadelphia: Lip- pincott Paris, Gaston. Littérature Francaise au Moyen Age. Paris: Armand Colin. Nibelungen. Macmil- A Bibliography of the Writings — +" Annina. Hebbel's la Philli = ‘Le Roy. of Henry James. Boston: oughton, Mifflin & Co. $3 net. Pilgrims’ Way. Chosen by A. T. Quiller-OCouch. Dutton. $1.25 net Prichard, K. & H. Don :.3" the Sierra. Phila- delphia: .~ wy lf Rattermann A a Lieder, und Gedichie. Cincinnati: Privately Ravenel, Mrs. St. Julien. Charleston: a Place and the People. Macmillan Co. §2. net. Records of the Virginia Company ms London. Edited by Susan Myra Kingsbury. *» vols. Washb- ington, D. C. Remington's Newspaper Directory, 1906. Edward P. Remington. Rickett, Arthur. The Vagabond in Literature. Dutton. $1.60 net. Rutherford, E. Radioactive Transformations. Scribners. $3.50 net. Sacred Seasons. Readings from the Writings of Handley C. G. Moule. Dutton. $2 net. Sharp, William. Fair Women. , Dutton. 75 cents net. Shoemaker, Michael oe Winged Wheels in France. Putnams. §& Smith, E. Boyd. The Story. of Pocahontas and Captain John Smith. Boston: Houghton, Mif- flln & Co. $2.50 net. Squires, Grace. Merle and May. Dutton. $1.50. Stockham, Alice B. Baby-Craft. Chicago: Stock. ham Publishing Co. Symons, Arthur. Cities. Dutton. $2.50 Trine, Ralph Waldo. In the Fire of the. ‘Heart. McClure, Phillips & Co. Van Dyne, Edith. Aunt Jane's Nieces. Chicago: Rellly & Britton Co. Wharton, Anne Hollingsworth. Italian Days and Ways. Philadelphia: —" incott. $1.60 net. Williams, J. BE. Hodde Life of Sir George Williams, A. ©, Arpetron & Son. $1.26 net. Williams, Neil Wynn. The Electric Theft. Boston: Small, Maynard &°Co. $1.50. Wilson, Floyd B. ont Silence in Realization. = & Co R. F. Y Droit Ottoman, Vols. tv. hl Vil. mace. oD IV.
Page 27
seed 29 1goe} The Labour Movement in Australasia By VICTOR 8S. CLARK. $1.50 net, by mail $1.65 A competent, temperate, and jud'cial treat- ment of an important subject, on which there has been a great deal of wild writing. In this untechnical volume the author says that he has described “In the first place union to political tactics on the part of organizat‘oas a development from trade labour “In the second place, compulsory arbitration of industrial disputes, which is enforced by etate and ‘ederal laws ip Australia and New Zealand “The progress of socialism in an Anglo-Saxon country—w th a race of pure British stock un- der popular government Socialism itself being a social phenomenon—not a theory—in Aus tralasia.’’ At the request of his publishers the author inserted a chapter contain'ng an account of the principal government industries and commercial enterprises HENRY HOLT & CO usd The Political | hought OF Plato and Aristotle By E. BARKER, M.A. Oxford Late Fellow of Merton College, &vo, net, $7.50 This work, is primarily of the political thought of Plato and the political sys- tem of Aristotle. Its central subject is through a study of Socratic philosophy, and finds a practical by a scholar of authority, a study approached pre- application in being brought to bear upon the problems of modern democracy. Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. 27 & 29 West 23d St., N.Y. G.P.Putnam’s Sons, THE HEART THAT KNOWS THE BEST BOOR. The Man in the Case A NOVEL OF MY mead AND ROMANCE ELIZABETH STUART PHELPS General Robert E. Lee OF VIRGINIA appreciation by GENERAL WOLSELEY of thet British Army. copies only printed of this beautiful tribute for GEORGE HUMPHREY, Rochester, N. Y. Price One Dollar. Literary IN PERIL of CHANGE & Social By C. F. G. MASTERMAN. Studies THE NEW HUMANISM By EDWARD HOWARD GRIGGS Each $1. 50 ner | B.W. HUEBSCH, | Publisher, N.Y. RESEARCHES made in the BOSTON LIBRARY, HARVARD LIBRARY, BOSTON ATHEN ABUT. TRANSLATIONS made from Prench and Sammaries of books or ee Expert ~_ = proofreading. F. H. DIKE, Mass me of Technology. Boston 4 BOOK FOR EVERY BOD ¥. EATING TO LIVE. Ry JONMN J. BLACK, M.D. With special advice to the Gouty, th: Rheumatic, and the Diabetic. Cloth, $1. 50 nec J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. The Nation. Vv LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO.’S PUBLICATIONS A History of Diplomacy in the | International Development of Europe By Davip Jayne Huw, LL.D, Minister Plenipo- tentiary of the United States at The Hague. In 6 vols. Svo Vol. Il. The Establishment of Territorial Sove reignty. 88 pages, with 4 colorea Maus, Chrono- logical Tables, etc., and Index. $5.00 nef. By mail $5.28. Just Ready Vol. 1. The Struggle for Universal Empire. 506 pees. with 5 colored Maps; Chronological Tables of imperors, Popes, and Rulers; List of Treaties etc.. and Index 504 pages $5.0) net Ry mail, $5.24 Lately Published Dr. Hill's second volume nces the formation of modern states, the’r schemes xpa 1, their rivalry for primacy, the deve t na tional law, the triumph of tert and the formation of a Europea | law. The first volume is chiefly devote position of the imperial idea, the se pacy and the Medimval Empire, their origin of national monarch'es, and the of diplomacy in Italy In vo intended to consider the Dt ne of Absolutiam, of the Revolutionary Era stitut'onal Movement, and of Commercial Imperial ism, thus bringing the history of international de velopment down to the present tir Each volum is. however, an independent work mplete rr the period it covers, and is sold separately The Historical Geography of Europe By FE. A. Freeman, D.C.L.,LL DD. Formerly Re gius Professor of Modern History in the Uni versity of Oxford, (New Elition) Edited by J. B. Bury, M.A., D.Litt., LL.D., Regius Pro fessor of History in the University of Cambridg« Rvo. $4.00 net Atlas to the Above. 65 Colored Maps SVO3« 2.10 net Lectures on Early English History By Witutam Strvsss, D.D., formerly Bishop of Oxford and Regius Professor of Modern History in the University of Oxford, Edited by Arthur Hassall, M.A., Student of Christ Church Oxford. 8vo. 400 pages, $4.00 net The American Revolution By the Rt. Hon. Sir Georce Orro TREVELYAN, Bart. New and cheaper Edition with Portrait Vols. L., 11., UL Crown &vo Each, $2.00 net By mail, $2.18 Letters Personal and Literary of Robert, Eari of Lytton (Qwen Meredith) Edited by his Daughter, Lady Betry BaLrovr With 8 Portraits, 2 vols, 8vo, $6.00 net The quotations we have given will show what a wealth of interesting material lies in these two volumes, material both literary and political, touct ing very closely contemporary affairs, aud unveiling to the public a most attractive and engag ng per eonality."’—London Dally Telegraph Early Essays and Lectures By the Very Rev. Canon Sueenan, D.D., Author of “My New Curate,” “Luke Delmege,”’ etc, Crown 8vo. $1.60 net CONTENTS. — Essays: Religious Instruction in Intermediate Schools—In a Dublin Art Gallery Emerson—Free-Thought in America—German Uni versities (Three Essays)—German and Gallic Muses Augustin'an Literature—The Poetry of Matthew Arnold—Recent Works on St. Augustine—Aubrey de Vere (a Study). Lectures: Irish Youth and High Ideals—The Two Civilisations—The Golden Ju bilee of O'Connell's Death—Our Personal and So cial Responsibilities—The Study of Mental Science —Certain Elements of Character—The Limitations and Possibilities of Catholic Literature New volume by the authors of “The Irish R.M.’ Some Irish Yesterdays Stories and Sketches. By E. (©. Somervit.ie and Martiw Ross, Authorsof ‘Some Experiences of ao Irish R.M.."" “Allon the Irish Shore.’ ete With 82 Illustrations by FF ‘PF. Someaviiie Crown &vo, $1. The Political History of England From the Conquest of Hritain to the End of the Reign of Queen Victoria Written by Various Authors fer the Direction and Editorship of the Rew W aw) Hew MA... D.Litt, of Tris ege xford, Pree dent of the Royal Historical 5 ety and Reatwatp L. x. M.A i Fe ‘ ft Magdalen College xford, and Editor of the ‘English Historical Review I pu hed in 12 volumes. Svo. Fach v m } ‘ Index and two or Maps NEW VOLUME nore Vol 1\ FROM THE CORONATION OF RICH ARD It TO THE DEATH OF 1 HAR (LST7-14S5) By ©. Ohman, MA, ¢ i sor f Modern H y t i f ford and mem. f the We #? Aca . With three Maps. $2.60 1 VOLUMES ALREADY ISSUED Vol I FROM THE PARLIPST TIMES Ter Tilt NOK a | CONQL ESI - \ i DC. ID I ‘ f Univeraty © ‘ London Fel w of the British Academy Ww two Ma “ Vor l! FROM THI NORMAN ONQUEST To THR DEATH OF Jol IN 68-1216 By G we Burton Adams, l’rofes f r y Yale t versity With two Maps Vol lil FROM THI ACCESSION OF HENRY Il. TO THE DERATH OF EDWARD III 1216 1377) By T. 1 Fout, M.A Profes ‘MM eval and Modern H ‘ t Victoria 1 versity f Ma heste W Maps Vol X FROM THI ACCESSION OF iFORGE Itt THE CLOSE © PITa’sS FIRST AI)MIN ISTRATION (176-1801 it t Kev Ww ‘ liun MA Ib LAtt rrinit Colleg oat j With thre Mapes Vol XI FROM ADDINGTON'S ADMINISTRA TION TO THI CLOSI Ol Wi IAM A s REIGN (1801-1837 Ity iH ie ge « rick, 1D.C.1 late warde f Merto { ue ix ford. Completed and Revised . «.% i ne im, MLA for Ser 1 f Mug College Oxf ] Ww M rhe price of each volume *s $2.00 fs separat ely but Complete Sete may be subscribed for at the price f $28.00 net wn x nade, if preferred, a f $2.34 ! delivery of each volume A Des ptiv I aye f tl Work w I at ny ad 1 Homer and his Age By AnprRew Lane. With full page il ations Rvo. $3.50, net. this I th H ul Z its | 1 * ta " ta I ‘ inact Key elsaad wr from the mparativ f tu of her early natior rnd of ative archmology and My ‘ and ¢ k a Life and Letters of the First Earl of Durham (1792-1840) By Stuart J. Rep, Editor of * The Queen's Prit Ministers "' Series With numerous Portraits 2 vols, Avo. $10.00 net The story wl at j vers ft . t history of the Reform Bi th measures w h led t the creation of the Kingdon f Belg un policy 1 of Tsa Nicholas I and the intrigues ‘n inets of Lords (ir and Melbourn Ru mat wnde the «) f interest f the Il be found In the full and dramatic state th steps taken by Lord Durham in 1838 peace and prosperity to Canada, t te whieh are here given for the first time Industrial Efficiency A Comparative Study of Industrial Life in En land, Germany and America, By AaTruun Sina weL_., M.A..M_D ¢ vols. Avo. §7.00 net Some of the chapters in thes volu are malel records of ecoromical investigation They sum up clearly and succinctly, and wit! rag geration, viv diy and often in | rremey ie me the outcome of much careful, diepas pate exa nation we know few recent books k to he more inetructive and } f and workmen."’ The Times Heresies of Sea Power By Frep T. Jaxx, author of Inventor of the Naval War Game and 14 Illustrations, Svo, $4. net ‘Fighting Ship.” &« With * Mapes "This book fe learned, suggestive. and r and compels thought The illustr me are i esting, cod the maps valnat's ‘avy and A y LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York
Page 28
[ Vol. 83, No. 2161 THE DECEMBER ATLANTIC This remarkable issue contains: vi The Nation. Christmas and the Literature of Disillusion, 4y SAMUEL McCHORD CROTHERS New National Forces and the Old Law, /y MELVILLE M. BIGELOW The Spirit of Present Day Spain, /y HAVELOCK ELLIS The Measure of Greatness, /y N. S. SHALER Literature and the Modern Drama, /} HENRY ARTHUR JONES The House of Lords, /y WILLIAM EVERETT The Spell of Whitman, / M. A. De W. HOWE A New Voice in French Fiction, /) HENRY D. SEDGWICK STORIES by ALICE BROWN, JULIET WILBOR TOMPKINS, H. M. RIDEOUT, ELIZABETH FOOTE. ESSAYS by H. W. BOYNTON, A. C. BENSON, GELETT BURGESS. POETRY by EDMUND CLARENCE STEDMAN, JOHN B. TABB, FRANK DEMPSTER SHERMAN, FLORENCE EARLE COATES. THE FIRST INSTALMENT OF “A MOTOR FLIGHT THROUGH FRANCE,” By Edith Wharton And the Second Instalment of the Unpublished Correspondence of David Garneck TWO IMPORTANT SERIAL FEATURES FOR 1907 The Helpmate The Spirit of Old West Point By MAY SINCLAIR By MORRIS SCHAFF General Morris Schaff has written a series of delightfal reminis- nees entitled ‘“‘The Spirit of Old West Point.’ They present a i! ‘ praise er ce M y of literary life in London, lively picture of the life at West Point before the days of new i He Mm Helpmate will 1 \ buildings and crack football teams, in the momentous years just pre- eputati It is a powerful story ceding the Civil War. They have, moreover, a wide significance as f people, tracing the development of perhaps the most vivid embodiment that has yet been seen In prose No less remarkable of the spirit of patriotism that fired young American manhood in ' and full-bodied the days of our great national struggle. The series will prove both tell I it ! ! t a valuable historical document and a notable piece of literature. It will begin in an early number INlustrated Prospectus for 1907 sent free on request, Chree issues (October, November, and December, 1906) will be mailed without charge to new sub- scribers for 1907, upon receipt of $4.00. A special trial subscription for three months will be sent to new 35 cents a copy, $4.00 a year. subscriber upon receipt of SO cents HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & COMPANY, 4 PARK STREET, BOSTON, MASS.