The Nation 1906-11-15: Vol 83 Iss 2159
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
“Th Ne a 1 () i “di ? Ary) er, VOL. ‘LXXXIII—NO. 2159. THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 15s, 1906. PRICE TEN CENTS VOLUMES VI. AND VIil., PUBLISHED THIS DAY, COMPLETE Dr. James Ford Rhodes’s “rivaled History of the United States FROM THE COMPROMISE OF 1850 TO THE FINAL RESTORATION OF HOME RULE AT THE SOUTH IN 1877 From among hundreds of comments of the highest authority, made as each volume appeared, we quote a few tndicative of tts characteristic qualities Accurate, Complete, Sincere ““It is not probable that we shall see a more complete or better balanced history of our great Civil War.” — The .Nation. “Mr. Rhodes is writing a political and social history with rare judgment, accuracy and patience, with good literary skill, and with sincerity and honesty of purpose.” —ANDREW MCLAUGHLIN in The American Historical Revieu “ The author’s grasp of detail is sure, his sense of proportion seldom, if ever, at fault; his judgment of the reader's interest in a subject admirable; and his impartiality can never be doubted. His style is adequate, never lacking in vigor, precision, and color. No one need hesitate to hail Mr Rhodes as one of the great American historians.””"—M. W. H. in the New Yor4# Sun. Thoroughly Readable ‘* His impartiality is really judicial, and never results from missing or underrating the greatness of the issues wherewith he is dealing. . . . It is one of the most readable works on the subject which it has been our fortune to meet." —The Saturday Review, London. * The work is thoroughly admirable in point of style—clear, concise, and really fascinating in its narrative. A more thoroughly readable book has seldom been written in any department of literature.""— Boston Herald. Inflexibly Impartial “The first volume set a hitherto unattained standard of judgment, of criticism, of fairness to all parties concerned. Not a single chapter nor a single paragraph of the succeeding ones has fallen short of the high promise of the first.""— New ‘Yor# Times. “Mr. Rhodes has charm and lucidity of style and a rare gift for quotation, not the trick of essayists who make a pastiche of other people’s clever sayings, but the faculty of seizing the word or phrase from letter, speech, or debate which reflects the actual movement of events and makes his reader the participant in a living scene. Above all, he is inflexibly judicial, without causes to plead, friends to eulogize, or enemies to condemn, but with one sole aim, the truth.”"——New York Tribune. The set. complete in seven octavo volumes, in substantial dark blue cloth binding, price $17.50 net; bound in half morocco, $372; in three-quarter levant, $4o. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY Publishers, Sixty-four and Sixty-six Fifth Avenue, New York rMRAR ; t ‘ :
Page 2
= * N: ation. : 4 WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865, (Entered at the New York City Post Office as second class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER tus Weer 405 EDITORIAL ARTICLES The National Aspect of the Election 408 Absorbing the Conquered 408 Excavating Herculaneum 409 The Literature of Business 400 Real Prevention of Diseas: 410 SpeoraL ARTICLE Thoreau and OCerman Romanticism 411 CORRESPONDENCE Washington's Proposals for Education 412 The Honor System of Examinations 412 Newman on Jane Austen 418 NoTREs 418 Hook Reviewe The Text of Shakespear 414 A Lady of Rome 417 The Poet and the Par'sh 417 The Breath of the Runners 417 Henry Northcote ‘ 418 Portraita and Jewels of Mary Stuart 418 A QOuveen of Queens 41% A History of Higher Education in America 419 A Priced Lincoln Bibliography 120) T Principles of English Verse 420 The Passing Korea 121 DRAMA Kate 421 Murer Madam Butterfly ms an Opera 22 Dr. Muck and the Boston Orchestra 22 Art The New York Wat Color Clut 422 BOCLENOCE The Mathematical Tripos tn Cambridgs 424 The Behavior of the Lower Organiamea 424 FINaANOR The Deficit In New York Bank Reserves 426 Books or rux WaeeK azn TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any partof the United States or Canada; to JSor- eig + countries comprised tn the Postal Union, $4 The date when the subs ription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to @ subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remtt tance. No other receipt ts acnt unless requested, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless read letier, or by check, express Postal Order payable to ** Publisher of The Nation When a of addres ta desired, both the old and the new addresses should be given Addvess THE NATION, Boz79, New York Publication Office, 208 Broadway mide by order, or regial change TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen cents per agate line, each insertion; lines to the inch Twenty per cent top af 4 column age, $4 { page, M0 each insertion; front cover page, fso A:tloertia mart acoeptatle in every re spect Copy recetwed until Tuesday, 6 P. M THE NATION te seat free to thine lise intl wlre Dincs 14 advance for choice of page or flumn each insertion; with choice po of mat re who adver long ae rlisement continuca wna ul ’ feu *.* Coples of Tae Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra: in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross The Nation.— Fducationat. Massacu''seTrTs, Boston B' ISTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean M. M. BIeRLOWw. PatLapecraia, Chestout Hill BOARDING AND DAY Mrs. Chapman and .4%oo1 ror Miss Jones GIRLS. Thorough College Preparatory and Finishing Courses, with special opportunities for culture. Number of pupilslimited. Classes small, insur- ing individual attention. Large, comfortable house with pleasant grounds. Gymnasium, tennis, basketball, and skating. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry Laboratortes. Shop for Mechanic Arta. Strong teachers. Earnest boya. Gvymrastum with new swimming pe ol. Fite for college, aclentifie achool and business. Foung boys in separate building. Address Dr. BR C. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellestey Mills, Mass. School Agencies. ’ AGENCIES. , Proprietors . Washington WE FISK TEACHERS Evererr 0. Frex & Co 4 Ashburton Pi., Boston 1505 Pa. Ave 154 Firth Ave., New Vork 414 Cen. Bid... Minnespolis 2083 Mich. Ave . Chicago 1200 Williams Av., Portland 401 Cooper Bid., Denver 525 Stime'’n Rid. Los Angeles 318 Rook'ry Bik., Spokane 717 Market St..“an F’nelsco Send to any address above for Agency Manual ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Posttions for Good Teachers with Good Records Send for Circular on Free Registration. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St. Albany, N. Y. WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. A tremendous miscellaneous stock Greatly increased facilities for the im- portation of English publications. Competent bookmen to price lists and collect books Allof this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. THE BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY will issue on November 10a catalog of books de voted strictly to American subjects. It will be an annotated bibliographical list fully priced and arranged according to the system adopted by the A. L. A. Guide, The price is 3 cents to all except regular customers It will be invaluable as a LEVELAND, OHIO guide, PROOFS of LIFE AFTER DEATH Avo. Cloth, 365 pages, $150 net, 12c. postage A COLLATION OF OPINIONS AS TO A FU- TURE LIFE BY THER WORLIYS MOST EMI NENT SCIENTIFIC MEN IN CONFUTATION or THR MATERIALISTIC SCHOOL OF THOUGHT HERBERT B. TURNER & CO. Boston, Mass. LIBRARY RESEARCH Copies of all kinds and in any language looked up in the Boston and Harvard libraries, for schol- ‘ writers, and others Abstracts, coples, trane- lutions, and bibliographies made. Proof-reading and revision of manuscript Highest uulversity and library references. MiSS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 06 Chestout Street, Bowten, Maus. [Vol. 83. No. 2159 The fiistiaes ni “ Sociology A Bimonthly edited by the Sociological Fac- ulty of the University of Chicago. wtth the advice of beading -ncioloaists in America and Rurope. ALBION W. SMALT, Ea tor-in-Chief. THE ONLY JOURNAL IN THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE DEVOTED PRIMARILY TO PURE SOCIOLOGY $2.00 a year; single copies, 50 cents already differentiated several distinct of social science, in addi- tion to those which are older than Sociology, The preliminary report of the material to be studied—or “Descriptive Sociology,” it is sometimes named—is now cast in a form which marks an advanced degree of social insight. In Spencer's Principles of So ology human institutions were de- scribed as so many architectural types, ob- served from the outside Ratzenhofer’s work has now set a standard for descrip- tion of human institutions from the inside; Ts sociological method of approach has livisions as i. e., in terms of the interests which were their motives. Descriptive Sociology is now an account of the genesis of institu- tions through the conflict and accommo- dation of the interests that were efficient with persons who made the institutions. Again, the study of primitive races is yielding results certain to influence the science of pedagogy. The movements of the primitive mind may be compared proft- ably with the phenomena of the child mind. 4 distinct division of social psychology is concerned with the mental processes of masses, from the mob to the nation. The phenomena of public opinion, of the trans- fer of individual impulses to the mass, and of the ascendancy of the mass over the in- dividual by purely psychic means, consti- tute the materials of a sub-science which is not a mere curiosity, but deals with the most significant forces in practical life. “Social Technology” is becoming as firm- ly founded in General Sociology as medical practice is in general chemistry and biol- ogy. Applied Sociology is no longer chi- merical, but it is constructive in its aims It studies with equal frankness ways and means by which the strongest may help the weakest, and the wisest methods of co- operation between the responsible mem- bers of society for the promotion of gen- eral progress This JOURNAL attempts to give pro- portional attention to each of the special phases of Sociology. Subscriptions filed immediate'y to begin January, 1907 will include tha nundar for November, 1905, free THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS (Dept. 21) CHICAGO and NEW YORK PUBLISHED THIS WEER. The Philosophy of Goethe’s Faust author of EDUCATION , etc 150 pages. By peau Da videon, THE WAGE EARNERS, ete edited by Charles M. Rakewell, @ cents net. delivered in 1896. at Cambridge. Mass., are partly in response to the eoqoent who heard them delivered and have the desire to have them In permanent formn. and partly in the bellef that they will be welcome to a much larger circle of renters. CINN & COMPANY - BOSTON winter of published of those expressed These lectures the Financial. We buy and sell bills of exchanges and make cable transfers of money on Ea- rope, Australia, and South Africa; also make collections and Issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credit availiable tn all CREDIT arte of the world. International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO: NO, 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK, LETTERS OF
Page 3
Nov. 15, 1906] The Nation. IMPORTAN T THE TEXT OF SHAKESPEARE ‘ By THOMAS R. LOUNSBURY, or of English at Yale University a ae we NEW BOOKS SHAKESPEARE AND THE MODERN STAGE By SIDNEY LEE, author of “Great Englishmen of the 16th Century 4 work of the greatest importance and value to all students a! lovers of Shakespeare At. Paul Pioneer Press THE CHAPTERS The Dramatic Situation in Shakes- Popes Treatment of the Tex peare’s Time The Eariy Career of The ‘ Differences of the Early Texts Theota’d s Attitude towards Pope The Earliest Editions ot Shake. The * Original Duncia speare Shakespeare Controversy of 17s Pope's Edition of Shakespeare Theobald s Edition and its Reception $2.00 net. Postage 15 cents INDUSTRIAL AMERICA By J. LAURENCE LAUGHLIN, Professor of Political Economy at University of Chicago tHE BERLIN LECTURES OF 1004 “An able and vent sper account of the industrial problems at present occupying public attention in the United States, presented ina way that a non-specialist ‘ena ence would find instructive and impor tant.’ THE CHAPTERS American Competition with Europe The Trust Problem Protectionism an: Reciprocity The Railway Questior The Labor Prob!em The Banking Probler The Present Status of Economic Thinking in the United States $1.25 net. Postpaid $1.37 THE ART OF THE SINGER Practical Hints About Vocal Teaching and Style By W. J. HENDERSON “A book of the greatest interest and importance to all singers and lovers of singing.’"’— Washington Siar. SOME OF THE CHAPTERS What is Singing * Practice in Beginning Tones The Artist and the Public Style and Recitative Fuodamental Breathing The Lyric in Style Breathing and Attack Waenrr Singing The Singer's Musicianship $1.25 net. Postpaid $1.37 Eleven essays treating of different aspects of the Shakespearean irama in its relation to the stage and to the life of today Suggestive ible and delightfully written THE ESSAYS Shakespeare and the Modern Stage The Mur pal Thea Shakespeare and the Elizabethan Aspectsof Shakesreare's I'l sophy Playgoet Shakespeare and Patriotien Shakespeare in Oral Tradition \ Peri of Shakespearean Research Pepys at Shakespeare Shakest eare ia France Mr ise Ds amd Shakespearean The ¢ a emoration of Shakespeare Drama in La n $2.00 net. Postage ts cents LIBERTY, UNION AND DEMOCRACY THE NATIONAL IDEALS OF AMERICA By BARRETT WENDELL, Professor of English at Harvard Universit }leasant, graceful essays with just enough admixture of exhorta ion, prophecy and appeal to make them genuinely earnest Ont Ree d Herald Prof, Wendell’s account of the great national idealsis the kind of final work that builds itself into the mind of the student and remains as the foundation for future building.” -— Providence Journal $1.25 net. Postage 10 cents THE PRISONER AT THE BAR SIDE-LIGHTS ON THE ADMINISTRATION OF CRIMINAL JUSTICE By ARTHUR C. TRAIN, Asst. Dist. Attorney in the City of New York This bc ok describes, primarily for the layman, but also for the law- yer, the actual administration of criminal justice, usicrg New York City as an example. It is filled with anecdotes, and the subject, while thoughtfully discussed, is treated in a lively and entertaining manper SOME OF THE CHAPTERS The Law's Dealings rhe Judge The Defendant Women in the Court The Jury What Fosters Crime $2.00 net. Postage extra THE FIRST FORTY YEARS FROM THE LETTERS AND JOURNALS (MARGARET BAYARD). EDITED BY illustrations and portraits. Svo, f OF WASHINGTON SOCIETY OF MRS. SAMUEL HARRISON SMITH GAILLARD HUNT With numerous rice $2.50 net. (Postage 20 cents.) . ‘ teenth century, and closed in 1840. Jefferson, Madison and Clay were an Margaret Bayard, who married Samuel Harrison Smith, the distinguished journalist. who was the founder of The National latelligencer, the oldest paper in Washington. and who by his position came in contac time, and cousequently even the intin ate letters te her famiiy show decided literary grace and \ Margaret volume of reminiscences covering an almost untouche: this country all went to Washington and visited Mrs. Smiih and are described by her 1 period in the history of the social life at the Capital The author was twith the leading statesmen, She was a writer of popular books in he Iskill) Her life in Washington began with the nine ng the intimates of her household. The literary foreigners who came to SOCIAL MESSAGE OF THE MODERN PULPIT By CHARLES R. BROWN, D.D., Pastor First Congregational Church, Oakiand, Cal. Lyman Beecher Lectures at Yale University ni ‘We wish every clergyman in the Church would read, mark, learn and inwardly digest them, and that they could aioe come to the hands ot laymen who might be interested in the problems discusse The thu THE CHAPTERS The Need of Moral Leadership in The Oppression of a Peopl Social Effort The Cail of an Industrial Deliverer The Scriptura! Basts for a Social Mes- The Training in tndustrial Pre don sage The New Social Order The Best Lines of Approach $1.89 net. Postage extra STUDIES IN THE BOOK OF JOB By FRANCIS N. PELOUBET, D.D, Author of Select Notes on the International Lessons OUTLINES OF BIBLICAL HISTORY AND LITERATURE from the Earliest Times to 200 A. D. By FRANK KNIGHT SANDERS, D.D., sometime Professor of Biblical Histery end Archwology in Yale University These outiines enable the student to get at the Bible iteelf in a mv: «t helpful way, to realize vividly the history which it relates, supplements or develops, and to appreciate the varicus staves in the gradual dewelk > ment of the Israel which became the world’s re igious teacher Thia in me of the volumes of “The Historical Series for Bible Studenta f which seven have Leen published 12mo, $1.25 net. Postage extra A el THE APOSTLES’ CREED IN MODERN WORSHIP By WI.LIAM R. RICHARDS, D. D, Pastor Brick Presbyteri 4b Tais remarkable book sheds new light on the Book of Job. and is ex Church, New York ceedingly helpful for advance | Sunday-schvol classes, biblical literature courses in high schools aad colleges, eveniog services, and individual us« It gives r-adiags in character, bi .ckboard diagrams, references for Hibl cives one a rare insight into the most aocient and « omprehenslve study. points of contact with daily life, literature and history, and notes ymbot in Christendom the Weatmtinater An admiratle series of on difficult passages. seven lectures The Congregationatia $1.09 net. Postage 10 cents $1.00 net. Postage 10 cents CHARLES SCRIBNER’ S SONS, NEW YORK ; ’ ’ 4 ’
Page 4
lV The Nation. [vot 83, No. 2159 Among Notable New Macmillan Books BOOKS GF UNCONVENTIONAL TRAVEL Mr. Clifton Johnson’s Highways and Byways of the Mississippi Valley Keady this day. Cloth, cr. 8vo, $2.00 net; by mail $2.20 By the author of * Highways and Byways of the South,’ and other books which delight the sympathetic observer, to whom they suggest possibilities of travel and sight-seeing untouched by ordinary guide books. Dr. Edward Everett Hale’s Tarry-at-Home Travels ** An unequaled treasury of memories "’ embracing nearly all the original thirteen States. Fully illustrated from portraits prints, etc., of Dr. Hale’s own collection. Cloth, 8vo, $2.50 net; by mail, $2.70 IMPORTANT HISTORIES ’ Mr. Herbert Paul’s just compleed History of Modern England ‘** Pre-eminently readable and entertaining . . . clear, vigorous and direct.”— 7he American Historical Review. These volumes are so readable that one is in danger of overlooking their genuine historical worth.""—Contemp rary Review. The set, complete in five octavo volumes, cloth, $12.50 net Cambridge Modern History Volume IV. The Thirty Years’ War A new volume in the great work planned by Lord Acton to which the leading historical writers in England and America are contributing To be complete in twelve royal 8vo volumes, cach $4.00 net “The most full, comprehensive and scientific history of modern times in the English language, or perhaps in any language.’’— Zhe Nation. NEW NOVELS Jack London’s New Novel White Fang Illustrated in colors. Cloth, $1.50 ‘A thrilling story of adventure . stirring indeed. Every scene is etched with a vividness that bears new witness to the author's graphic powers touches a chord of tendernéss that is all too rare in Mr. London’s work.”’ ~Record-Herald, Chicago. F. Marion Crawtlord’s A Lady of Rome ‘With a tine problem of conflicting human passions to solve, the story goes zrandly on with the old time swing of fascin- iting incidents and still more fascinating characters.’’—Mew York Times. Cloth, $1.50 Will Payne’s When Love Speaks modern material, with a climax as novel as the is sure to arouse discussion; it is vigorous, interesting, of good live unusual situation is dramatic. Cloth, $1.50 NEW VOLUMES OF VERSE ; Mr. Alfred Noyes’s Poems Olive green cloth. with design in gold, $1.25 net In England Mr. Noyes is held to have reached the highest mark in recent poetry for vigor and originality. The London Bookman has said of his verse : “ Nothing is overstrained; there is no gush of mere sentimentalism, but a true feeling for chitdhood and mystery and the deep things of life.’”’ Mr. Coningsby wm. Dawson’s The Worker and Other Poems ‘erity marks the genuine post-who realizes the essential love and hate, hope and fear of A production whose elemental sir Cloth, 16mo, $1.25 met. Ready this day nen of all time Mr. Wallace Irwin’s Random Rhymes and Odd Numbers Amusing verses 48 varied in subjects as they are irresistibly funny. Cloth, r6mo, $1.75 net. Ready this day NEW JUVENILES ’ Miss Christina Gowans Whyte’s The Story Book Girls is the simple, unpretentious story to which was awarded some months ago a prize offered by Dr. Robertson Nicoll’s famous paper 74e Bovkman for the best story for young girls. Ready this day. Cloth, $1.50 Miss Beulah Marie Dix’s Merrylips _ Mtustrated, Cloth, $1.50 1 story for little girls that ‘‘contains nothing but brightness and pure joy . . . enduringly wholesome, wise, and sweet i yn Transcript. Charles J. . Remmnete The Wonder Children Mlustrated, Cloth, $1.50 One of the choicest holiday books of several seasons . . . very modern extremely good, too.”’— 7runmscript E. Nesbit’s The Railway Children Ilustrated by C. B. Brock. Cloth, $1.50 ‘Everything is natural and the children are just everyday, bright, lovable children . . plucky and honorable clear through. Mothers will do well to give their lads and lasses the book to read.”"—Avening Post, Chicago. Mr. ErnestIngersoll’s The Life of Animals: Mammals ind very valuable descriptions of all phases of life and relationships of the mammals . . . contains so dotes that it is very good reading even if one is net seeking scientific information.” Daily Evening Transcript, Boston. efore published, including 15 plates in colors, $2.02 net; by mail $2.20 Very fascinating many interesting little ar Vith ra tilu tirons, many of themau , rubisbed THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “4,5 4r by
Page 5
r NEW YORE, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 16, 1006 The Week. Our escape from Hearst does not free us from the duty of weighing rightly the forces which alone made him for- midable. Recognition of this is general. Major Henry Higginson of Boston ob- serves that in Massachusetts, too, cor- porations and the rich at ease in Zion had their fright. On this, Major Hig- zinson remarks with point: “It is the old story about a larger and wid- er philosophy and religion which have got to come to the front and choke such nonsense as Hearst and his followers put out.” Governor-elect Hughes gives gratifying proof that he is alert to the demands of the hour. Frankly stating that many who voted for his opponent did so in an intense desire to “end abuses,” Mr. Hughes asks their support in the task of “squaring the adminis- tration of the Government with the in- terest of the people.” But what can he or any man do? Well, Mr. Hughes can ap- ply with great advantage his rare busi- ness talent to the business of the State. He can introduce method, economy, ef- ficiency, where they are sorely lacking. Useless commissions, the surplusage of | employees, dawdlers fattening on the treasury, he can cut away. The Railroad Commission he can make a really ef- fective instrument to bring railway cor- porations to their senses and the peo- ple to their rights. Above and beyond all this, however, something must be done to satisfy the deep craving for a more perfect establishment of justice in our public affairs. It is the rankling sense of injustice somewhere that lends to the Hearst movement its real significance. | Wild impossibilities will, no doubt, be demanded. Hearst promised them free- ly; Hughes will be asked to execute them. But the State can guard no man against the consequences of idleness and vice. There are economic laws, and especially moral laws, beyond reversal or even tinkering by the Legislature. Yet there is a root of dissatisfaction and suspicion which can be torn out by an upright Governor and an honest Legis- lature. It is the special privilege, the bought favor, the sinister influence, the corrupt alliance which have so often made Albany execrated. And it is to the removal of this prevalent feeling that wealth and political power can freely work their will at the seat of gov- ernment that Mr. Hughes should bend his best efforts. President James J. Hill’s address be- fore the Merchants Club of Chicago on e Nation. Saturday evening, a restatement of | the case for reciprocity or, if pos- sible, free trade with Canada, is marked by a powerful grasp of fact and a prophetic sense of inevitable busi- | ness developments No one can ques tion his mastery of the commercial prob- lems of this continent. The demonstra tion of his knowledge lies in his past achievements in the Northwest: and his present large projects across the border attest his faith in the speedy coming there of a vast production and immens« markets. With a fine sweep of business imagination, Mr. Hill showed how na . Wrongdoers, is admitted by the South- ern-born officer who advocated this drastic punishment The seriousness of the original offence we cannot and would not mitigate It was a gross | breach of discipline—-not unheard of, however; for the Ninth Cavalry had a similar fracas in Texas in 1899: and the | White soldiers of the Fourth Cavalry, ture had indicated a unified growth of | agriculture and industry and transporta- tion on this continent. Stupid nation- al policies for a time hinder progress. But a mighty development in west- ern Canada is impending, whether laws | favor it or hamper it. The question for Americans is simply whether they mean to get into natural relations with it, and profit by it, or to keep up the fool ish tradition of isolation and antagon ism. The same idea is urged by |and ammunition that veteran champion of close politi- | cal and commercial relations between the United States and Canada, Prof Goldwin Smith: “Reciprocity is the voice of nature, and her dictate to all whom she has made partners in her bounty on this continent.” Thus the wide-awake business man agrees with the philosoph- ical writer and publicist; even if a pro- tective tariff attempts to expel nature with a fork, she is bound to come back. Politically, Mr. Hill’s speech serves to point afresh the lost opportunity of the Democrats in the recent campaign. They threw away a winning issue of states- men to chase after the false and losing issues raised by demagogues. But it ifs not yet too late to move upon Congress and the President. Mr. Roosevelt would doubtless sympathize with appeals from | New England and the Northwest. Sec- | retary Root would be more than favor- | able to reasonable proposals of reciproc- ily. President Roosevelt has decided upon a punishment of the colored soldiers of the Twenty-fifth Infantry which is with out precedent in the annals of the army Because some of their number, under when stationed at Fort Walla Walla Washington, formed a mob, stormed the town jail, and lynched, on April 22, 1891 a civilian who had killed one of their comrades Yet no companies of the Fourth Cavalry were mustered out Their colonel Charles FE. Compton, was tried for neglect of duty, found guilty, and sentenced to suspension This is the correct military procedure In every foreign service the officers are held accountable for the conduct of their men Mr. Roosevelt should first have asked the white officers, How did your men get out of hand? How was it that they obtained their arms Where wero the officer of the day and the officer of the guard? Knowing the provocation, where were your precautions? If these officers had failed to give satisfactory reasons, then they would have confessed their lack of fitness for command. But even if it was necessary to punish the troops for failing to “peach” on one another, the regiment might have been Btationed for a probationary period in Alaska, just as a rowdy battalion of the British Guards was sent to Gibraltar. Many of the men, and particularly the non-com missioned officers, have served for up wards of twenty years with honor, on the frontier, in the Spanish war, and the Philippine insurrection, with the promise that they would be retired ona pension after thirty years’ service. Now | they are turned out to shift for them- great provocation, “shot up” the town of | Brownsville, Texas, killing one man and | companies of this brave regiment are to be dishonorably discharged by execu- tive order, the innocent with the guilty. The special reason for this action is that, when threatened with this fate, the soldiers still refused to tell who were the guilty ones. That many thus sum- marily treated are innocent of any wrongdoing, or even of knowledge of the | which has been almost selves. Thus the President's action con- stitutes a grave breach of contract, unanimously condemned by the press The part that luck plays in men’s lives was never more clearly exempli- fied than in the career of the late Major tien. William R. Shafter. An excellent regimental officer in the Civil War, he was content at its close to apply for a lieutenant’s commission in the regular seriously wounding a policeman, three | army. By the error of a clerk, he was appointed a lieutenant-colonel, thanks to which he became in 1879 colonel of the First Infantry. In this position he displayed every necessary quality. For years Shafter’s First Infantry was un equalled in the service for discipline and efficiency. On the outbreak of the war with Spain, fate again gave Gen Shafter an unexpected promotion. The i} } ' ; {
Page 6
406 original intention of the McKinley Ad- ministration was to make a mere recon- noissance about Santiago, with perhaps | For the com- | expedition, Gen. Miles Shafter as an excellent brig. five thousand men in all ot named Gen mand this adier Subsequently, as the Santiago expedition became of dominent impor- tance, Gen. Shafter was forced into a part for which nature had never intend- ed him. How he bore the responsibility is well known. That the expedition did not turn out a complete failure was not his fault. But Alger’s backing, it was easy for him to say that he had in one hundred and thirteen days | McKinley had ask- the war sense of hu with Secretary President Santiago done what ed and end the people prevented of Shafter take Fortunately, however, mor of the any such American hero-worship as later marked the career Admiral Dewey Neither President McKinley nor Secretary Alger could make a great man or great soldier out of Gen. Shafter With admirable sanity, the public esti- mated him at his precise worth, and felt that the major-generalcy which Con- bestowed upon him for what were at services of gress subsequently sufficient painstaking and honest was reward best From fighting bosses, Secretary Bona parte has gone through the stages of being something of a Maryland boss himself, and finally of coming to believe that a party boss would be a pretty good thing if only he got his office by elec Mr. Bonaparte just for others to work tion, not bribery “throws out the idea” Most “thrown The political as well rubbish that su in it are just the to be of wisdom up such ideas left heap out’’—upon notion seems a is capable one and that unable party of boss, virtue but itself so much as a candidate for this Is much like call his reason preme act thereafter to choosing a must confess pick out intelligently sheriff. In effect ing upon man long enough to choose an infallible guide, a to exercise ind then never to trust reason again itut the theoretical objections to Mr onaparte plan are no stronger than the practical. Bosses cannot, in fact, be made in the way he suggests, nor will men cease trying to prove thelr powers in the rough and tumble of party con tents Instead of producing harmony, it would only multiply strife to have an elective boss parcelling out all the of fice The Secretary's acheme, which is, o far as outlined, pretty vague and dreamy, falla singulariv fll with the creatly heightened power and tmpor tance of party primaries, under the di when voters are hav than rect syatem Tust more to do with nominations Mr. Bonaparte tells them that the: that fob at all Hercules tn the ing ever to are really not equal and should call upon a form of a boss to relieve them of It | the lack of delicate, or at ' that recalls the imperial days of Rome. The Nation. A cynic might find a certain amuse- ment in the suddenness with which this city annually becomes artistic. After a Six months’ torpor there is an explosion. The dealers wake up on Fifth Avenue, the artists’ exhibitions begin, the clubs start their periodical shows, and this year, as if the fixtures were not enough, the Metropolitan Museum founds a de- partment of Egyptian antiquities, and the National Arts Club formally opens commodious new quarters, especially dedicated to the cause of industrial art. if it is not for least expen- It is very evident that the commercial always an im- portant one—art depends on the hand- ful of people who can and do spend lav- ishly upon the furnishing of their houses or upon collecting in the stricter sense. Doing something for art means, at bot- tom, attracting the dollars of this class. Surely, art languishes, sive, attentions. on side- Its taste regulates the demand which the artist must meet, or lack clients. if art is at a low ebb among us, it is because such patrons usually have no personal taste of any sort. Their bar- baric love of simple acquisition is di- rected by the flattery of dealers and fur- nishers. The result fs that the man- sions of this country present an aspect indiscriminate mixture of the worst. Beside the Renaissance bronze stands the modern forgery. In the same room with the priceless carpets of old Persia are base of ancient tapestries. Throughout such houses or collections the story is the same; and frequently the intrinsically poor or fraudulent ob- for at the highest There is the an best and imitations has been paid and is correspondingly valued by ject price the infatuate owner. Anything like per- sonal quality is of the rarest. There prevails a frightful monotony of ex- pensiveness—the same rugs, the same porcelains, the same portraits by the same fashionable painters. Everywhere one witnesses merely the focussing of a little group of commercial interests upon a pile of new money. There every reason to believe that the collec- tors of Roman times and of the Renais a humbler attitude to the acqua‘nt- is sance were in wards art. They sought ance of artists, and trained their taste by discourse with the competent. Their pride was in the beauty of the work they possessed, not in the price they had paid for it. The bitter cry of the Iill-paid college professor filling the land. In report after report our university presidents Schurman of Cornell and Butler of Co have pictured is lumbia have just spoken the unhappy lot of the occupants of pro fessorial chairs. These teachers and in- vestigators are compelled to see the bills of prosperity go on mounting while sal- From the point aries remain stationary [ Vol. 83, No. 2159 the trouble is as clear as the remedy is simple. College professors have no unions. They neither keep down the number of apprentices, nor shut out “scab” competitors. We sometimes hear of college students going on strike—for this is what a “student rebellion” really is—but the hard-worked professors on small wages never nail up the recita- tion rooms or smash the windows of the college treasurer. ‘While the Erie Rail- way employees are vigorously demand- ing more pay, and threatening to tie up the road, the non-unionized profes- sors are being driven to such desperate expedients as marrying rich wives. With a book agent the nearest thing they know to a walking delegate, they suffer on in helpless patience. They cannot dig, but their presidents are not asham- ed to beg for them. The founding of the Atlantic Monthly, with James Russell Lowell as editor, was a notable event in American let- ters. In celebration of its fiftieth year ii, 1907 the magazine promises a ser- ies of papers by living ex-editors, Wil- liam Dean Howells, Thomas Bailey Aldrich, and Walter H. Page. To one long familiar with the _ At- lantic perhaps the most striking thing is its consistency of character; the mot- to of its jubilee number might well be qualis ab incepto. At times it has lean- ed a little to that ultra refinement known tu mockers as Cambridge weak tea. Again, it has stiffened up and sought for strength in too hasty a reflection of the problems of the day. But in general it has been remarkably successful in com- bining refinement and strength—a diffl- cult ideal. It is the ablest of our month- lies, standing on a level above even the most attractive of the New York il- lustrated magazines, whose aim is to flatter the taste of l'homme moyen sen- suel. Taking all things into considera- tion, we are inclined to regard it as the best of the general magazines published in the English language to-day. And we regret that its home is not in New York. The influence of such a magazine in the centre of our publishing business would do much to counteract the tone of flashy commercialism that is the mark of New York in literature. Various heroic clergymen, in this city and elsewhere, are resorting to extreme measures to induce people to come and listen to them preach. Meanwhile, the sermon-problem is being attacked by others in a different way. Arthur C. Ben- son, himself the son of an Archbishop of Canterbury, has an article in the No- vember National Review, in which he argues, not for increasing the supply of hearers, but for diminishing the supply of sermons. One a Sunday is all, he thinks, that weak human nature ought
Page 7
Nov. 15, 1906] to be expected to endure. Moreover, he would have those of the clergy who can. pot, even in the considerate judgment of mothers in Israel, preach in an edifying or even tolerable manner, frankly give over the attempt, and read a discourse by a great preacher. Mr. Benson writes in full and charitable perception of the enormous difficulty of preaching accept- ably to the same congregation twice é@ Sunday, year in and year out. What is really demanded of a preacher, if he is to minister successfully to the same flock for a decade or two, is that he should be an orator, a literary man, a saint, and a man of the world, all rolled into one. That such a combination is rarely found, is not surprising. By way of comfort to the minor prophets, Mr Benson declares: if [| had to take my choice’ between hearing, say, Chrysostom. or Bossuet, o1 Newman, twice a week for the rest of my life. and never hearing them at all, I! should not hesitate to choose the latter alternative. Weariness with sermons is common, and apparently deepening, but people hear a born preacher as gladly as ever. Truth made living and instant through a per- sonality is still the greatest source of inspiration in the world—in church or out. When the rare genius is found who can stand up before the great congre- gation and catch up their vague aspira- tions after a better life into the soaring utterance of a Robertson or a Liddon, a Beecher or a Brooks—to name only the dead—it is a cruel pity that the church has not some division of labor by which such men could be set aside exclusively for the work of preaching. To make them grow haggard over church finan- ces, or to dissipate their energies at bazaars or in the multiplied business of the modern “institutional church,’ is little short of a crime. Minister Briand’s statement that the French Separation Act will not be en- forced against the Church until a year from December 11 next indicates that the Government sincerely wishes a set- tlement with the Vatican. During that interval, associations may be formed vgreeably to the law, failing which, con- fiscation by gradual legal process will begin. This respite leaves in a rather ridiculous position the ultra-clericals, who have represented the Government as desiring persecution and courting civil warfare. The truce should give a good opportunity for revising the Papal interdict on the associations. The pro- tests against them have been based upon the assumption that the Government would not observe good faith in the mat- ter. It was even said that fraudulent or anti-religious associations would be allowed to obtain control of the churches. M. Briand’s decision is a quiet but effec- tive rebuke to insinuations so intemper- ate and ill-founded. Unless the Vatican ; The Nation. is wholly implacable, the year should bring forth a modus vivendi acceptable olics of France ‘ The old Slavophile party in Russia is apparently moribund The movement has almost come to an end in the face of Western ideas and the revolutionary propaganda. Unlike Pan-Slavism, Slavo philism was originally not a_ political but a romantic and mystical theory It was late that Slavophilism assumed a determinate political form. Its earliest exponent was Kircevsky, who, during the earlier part of the nineteenth cen tury, sought to combine Russian mystic ism and romanticism with the thought of Western Europe. But Kircevsky set his face in opposition to the institutions of the West. Like the anti-Napoleonic romanticists of Germany, he clung with almost bigoted devotion to the Russian throne and religion. The French Revo lution had wrought a reaction against the idea of universal empire; the dread of Napoleon increased this reaction. The Slavophiles, besides their romanticism in literature, dreamed of a future golden age, under a theocracy. They also look ed for the subjugation of other nations and for their conformity to this holy ideal No Russian, Kircevsky main tained, could feel pride in exotic insti tutions. He saw a religious halo above the crown, and maintained that the way to the establishment of a theocracy lay through the awakened feeling of the nation. Visionaries and poets gathered about him. Thus Slavophilism was like a survival of mediewvalism, in the midst of the rapid progress towards democ racy. Its strength has been in the croy- ants and the reactionaries; but it will die, or, rather, reappear transformed in reconstructed Russia. — The fall of the Prussian Minister of the Interior, Von Podbielski, is announced Since the discovery that he wasconnected with the firm of Von Tippelskirch, the army contractors who have been grow- ing rich out of the war in Southwest Africa, he has been subjected to volleys of ridicule and denunciation almost without parallel in the history of the Empire, coming, indeed, from all sec- tions of the press. The Emperor's per sistent refusal to remove him led to the rumors of a Chancellor crisis, and to astonishingly frank complaints that the court “camarilla” kept the Emper- or in ignorance of the feelings of the people. Even such strong Government supporters as the Berlin Areuzzeitung and personal direction of the Govern ment is particularly deplored Of this policy the recent appointment of Bern hard Dernburg, as director of the Co alike to the Government and the Cath and Post recently published = severe | criticisms The Emperor's impulsive | 407 is a selection which deeply offends the merchant class, as well as the aristo« racy, and the Chancellor is supposed to be by no means pleased by it As vet, however. there is nothing definite to show a breach between the Emperor and Von Bulow M. Santos-Dumont, by a flight of more than 200 metres in his airship, becomes the first skipper of a flying machine who has risen from the level, flown for un appreciable” distance and landed without serious mishap. The latter part of the performance is the most remark able, for, as the falling Irishman re narked, “It’s the landing that hurts und Santos-Dumont’'s landing was made under circumstances of unusual confu sion Still, Monday’s experiment re mains rather of scientific than of pra tical value At least, its practical appli cations seem at present remote The hold voung Brazilian has done success fully what the late Professor Langley tried in vain: building upon the experi ments of Hiram Maxim, he has produced a motor-driven aeroplane that can be controlled in a limited course, and near the ground. Evidently. it a far cry from a performance of this sort to de serving the proud title of the “Bird of Prey.” One of the darkest spots on the chart of modern civilization is the high rate cf infant mortality. How largely this is preventable is shown by an experiment of the Mavor of Huddersfield, England He offered a prize of $5 for every child, born during his term of office, which lived at least twelve months. Though several epidemics occurred, the mortal ity’ was reduced from 122 per thousand to 44, largely by the aid of women who instructed mothers in sanitary matters While maternal ignorance and careless ness are thus shown to be important factors, another of prime importance is the source and quality of milk It has leng been established that intestinal troubles caused by improper food (chief ly cow's milk) account for the largest number of deaths of infants under one ‘ear. It has also been frequently sug gested that a great improvement could be effected by substituting the milk of goats for that of cows. A plea for goat milk is contributed by Dr. William Wright to the London Lancet. He points out its great superiority in the three essential points of cleanliness, digestibil itv, and freedom from disease germs Among the 130,000 goats and kids brought to Paris for slaughter ever) vear, the meat inspectors have failed to discover a single case of tuberculosi Weight for weight, the goat vields twice as much milk as the cow, and if the ani mals are properly fed, their milk has no flavor to distinguish it from cow's lonial Office, is cited as an example. It | mill : , ; ’ f
Page 8
408 NATIONAL ASPECT ELECTION. THE OF THE To those who had hoped for a strong policies, and Republican Republican the last week's Congressional vote against particularly against *standpatters,’ disappoint elections come as a distinct ment The two most devout worship pers of the Dingley tariff, Messrs. Can- non and Dalzell, have been triumphant reélected: and there is nothing in the result to make them abate adoration for their idol, or to induce the Presi dent to resurrect his long-buried tariff reform message So far as the voters have indicated their choice, the Repub l'can party is still licensed to grant spe cial privileges to those manufacturers who are ready to pay for them If the overthrow of this intolerable injustice jis still postponed, the Demo crats have themselves alone to blame. Hardly convalescent from the Bryan ill ness, the party fell a victim to an even more virulent disease, the staying of which in New York, Massachusetts, Cal ifornia, and Illinois became the duty of the With what patriotic readiness independent ped Hut aod his the hou Democrats have again step breach, the had avitation to draw the attest no Hearst attention from of could into the returns even if there been Represen hardly contest for House the Democrats control A atives nerveless that have obtained stupidly inefficient campaign was ol Congressional the Democratik was dull, its strat the incer. ty niittee its literature infantile From beginning it Lae me | and it practical efforts eked vigor weeks ago credit abandoned ender for cannot take much even uch successes as have occurred for thie ire largely due to factional strife local causes the defeat of of the Sec because of his the that, direction, or to importance. But Congressman J. T. MeCleary District, his Ppmioneg Republicans or small ond Minnesota tandpattism” and record on tariff and Philippine shows clearly with serious intelligent tariff reform might have been made a winning issue of Democratic chief lesson of The election of both Rhode together with It is want thi utter which is the the contest a i whole Governors in North Democratl Ieland the recapture Dakota Missourl Democrath ind of and the re election Governor Minnesota proves’ what hard fighting can accomplish where there is con fidence in the Integrity and sanity of | the Democracy If any headway is to he made during the next two years, it can be only by rendering the Democracy a genuine Opposition In and out of Con Willlams has but the character gress. John Sharp done his best In the House, of many of his Southern associates, such as Tillman, in the party councils, has andicapped him, to say nothing of the Nious nature of support. from such a The | | possible Com- | | itism | | | | [Vol. 83, No. 2159 Northerner as Bourke Cockran. A par- t; can grow stronger only by pounding away at the weak points in the enemy's armor. Failure to adopt aggressive tac- tics will leave the Democracy in an equally helpless position two years hence. It is not as if there were no stirring issues upon which to appeal to the coun- Republicans steadily furnish grounds for attack. But of these possi- ble issues none is so important as the between the party and _ the Trusts. President Roosevelt and his At- torney-General may tilt all they please at Standard Oil and dissolve a combin- ation here and a Trust there. So far as any real far-reaching reform is concern- ed, their spectacular efforts are of no value save as object-lessons in the en- forcement of the law. They constitute no remedy for the disease; and no rem- edy will be proposed while the corrupt partnership between the Republican par- ty and the tariff-made monopolies con- tinues. To the Democratic party is more than ever granted the opportunity to come to the rescue. It alone can undertake clean- handed the reform ef conditions which Hearst as a political captain and has suddenly made of So- cialism a live issue. Americans will be content with their political conditions only when they are convinced that they are getting a “square deal.” As long as Congress legislates for a few, thousands will go on demanding a new form of government which will make such favor- and no one can deny that justice is on their side. Should the results of the elections deceive the Re publicans into thinking that all is well with them, that, as Mr. Cannon main- tains, their house does not need to be set in order, then are they far along the road to disaster. For the Democrats who have maintained their party’s hon- in this crisis, the path of duty is plain. If, with the fine energy and en- thusiasm which has just spurned Hearst and Moran, they do not work day and to regain control of their party machinery, they will find themselves without an organization to register their will try. alliance rendered impossible; or night ABSORBING THE CONQUERED. More than a century after the parti- tion of Poland the Prussian Government is buster than ever assimilating the Poles within its territory. Within the lust few weeks there has been a fresh outbreak of racial disturst and hatred which has affected even the school-chil- A cartoon in Ulk represents their plight. The teacher whips the school- boy for praying In Polish; his father beats him for praying In German; and the priest uses the birch !f he does not As a result, the boy’s hand dren. pray at all. tres. Recently, an unpopular teacher who had threatened his scholars with arrest for failure to answer questions in German, awoke to find his house in fiames and his family at the point of suf- focation. In the town of Baronowo there has almost been bloodshed because Ger- rian children were not only prevented from taking a short-cut to the village school, but were repeatedly driven away with whips by the highly aroused Polish youths. This really serious state of affairs arouses in Germany mingled anger and astonishment. There was a time sever- al centuries ago when Prussia absorbed Polish subjects without difficulty. Thir- ty or forty years ago Germanization seemed to be progressing satisfactorily, if slowly. Suddenly there came _ the change. The Prussians attribute it to the Polish nationalist movement. They can see no difference in their own atti- tude or policy. To them this resistance is ingratitude, pure and simple. Yet what are the facts? About 1870 many Polish workmen in upper Silesia, to cite one example, were wholly free from any antagonism to the Germans. Indeed, they eagerly learned the language, yeal- izing that its use widened their field of labor. To become a German at that time meant to be free; to be a German prop- erty-holder was to be beyond autocratic official interference. In short, to be- come a Prussian citizen meant the right to rise socially. Unfortunately, a change was at hand. The Pan-Polish movement could never have become what it is had there not been a Pan-German movement to offset it, to stimulate it, and to fan the dying embers of race strife. First came increased protective du- ties and the limiting of imports, which at once made the Poles feel that they were worse off than their cousins in Russia or in Galicia. The cost of liv- ing rose by leaps and bounds, furnish- ing precisely the acute grievance the na- tionalist agitation needed. Then came blundering on the part of the Prussian bureaucracy in religious matters; the law unfortunately prescribed the teach- ing of religion in Prussian schools, and laid down the lines along which it must be taught. It made no allowance for differences in schools or in the charac- ter of their attendance; hence the teach- er in Polish sections was. inevitably brought into conflict with the village priest. It would, as a writer in the Ber- lin Nation points out, have been a wise and far-sighted policy to have abolished all religious instruction in Polish schools. Instead, the bureaucracy made the incredible mistake of requiring that it must be given in German. If a prize had been offered, says the Nation writ- er, for the action which would give the Polish agitators the very best weapon for their propaganda, nothing: better than this could have been devised is against all the constituted authori- | Through it the school, which should be
Page 9
Nov. 15, 1906] The Nation.
the best medium of friendly Ger- manization, is now the place above all others in which race hatred is created and intensified. Curiously enough, the very Prussians who insist upon Germanizing the Poles by force are the same ones who bitter- ly resent efforts in Russia, Hungary, and elsewhere to make loyal Russians, Mag- yars, and Czechs of those who speak German and retain their German cus- toms. Side by side with associations for the creation of German communities in Polish Prussia, flourish societies to oppose the anti-German movement in Bohemia and Hungary—and no one seems to perceive the absurd contradic- tion. Only few have as yet been keen enough to notice that whenever the Ger. mans undertake a new line of action, it provokes a similar move by the Poles. Thus when the Government began to buy up large estates and settle German emigrants upon them, the Poles found- ed banks whose special business it was to do likewise for their own people as ¢ purely business affair, with the result that the number of Poles owning small land-holdings has increased faster than the number of small German land-own- ers. In the general inference to be drawn from this German experience the United States has a special interest, because of our new oversea burdens. It is a fatal policy to deprive a people of its lan- guage or iis customs. To try to make Americans of Malays, Russians of Finns, and Germans of Poles or Magyars, is merely to intensify the earnestness with which they cling to ancient customs and mother tongue. To attempt to strike down a people’s nationality by force is not a sign of enlightened patriotism, but of political and social decadence. Let him who doubts this face the facts —the amazing Gaelic revival in Ireland, the success of the Hungarians against the Austrians, the failure of Russia in Finland, and elsewhere. Let him then turn to Switzerland as the country in which people using three languages have for centuries lived side by side in peace and harmony. The lesson should be carefully conned, for the call for the Philippine Assembly is out, and our pro- consuls in Manila need more than ever to be warned against any attempt to force Filipino development along other than their own racial and national lines. EXCAVATING HERCULANEUM. \tter long negotiations, Prof. Charles is not s» Plan for excavating Her- And Thoreau”, international auspices symbol of two Ih.in principle by the and converging togéie delay has had cannot find the equivahhe excavations, ermacher. I find ratherally Italian. of the romantics, when he at the for- basis of man’s nature, he <n make
sible, will have a favored position as as sociates in the work. For a layman, it is difficult to realize the importance of this project, so far have the sensational discoveries at Pompeii dazzled the popu lar imagination From the point of view of art, how ever, all that has been found at Pompeii is of slight importance compared with the results of casual excavation at Her culaneum The remarkable Greek and Greco-Roman bronzes that are the pride ot the Naples Museum came from a sin gle villa at Herculaneum The few scraps of wall painting that give a hint of the dignity of Grecian painting have the same origin, but are relatively ob scured by the showier examples of plas terers’ work from Pompeii. The ruins of the latter city have not furnished a single manuscript; Herculaneum, prac tically unsearched, has already given up a large library—medical and scien tific, to be sure: further investigation may well bring us substantial additions to classical literature. In short, when we look at Greco-Roman antiquity through Pompeli, it is as if some thir- tieth-century archeologist should judge American civilization from the remains of Saratoga or Long Branch; whereas Herculaneum will represent the polite tastes of early Imperial Rome as truly as, say, Newport or Manchester-by-the Sea might represent those of our own Rooseveltian dispensation. Furthermore, Pompeii had been greatly damaged by earthquake, and flimsily rebuilt in the taste of the decadence, before it was overwhelmed by the falling cinders; but Herculaneum, when the mud rolled over it, still kept intact the treasures of the most cultivated Romans—Hellenizers of the generations of Lucretius and Cicero The value of these hidden treasures, the wildest imagination is not likely to exaggerate. Suffice it to say that here is an important classical site locked up in a perfect preservative—hardened vol canic mud—a site that has never been sacked by armies, rifled by pilferers, or drained by the insistent demand of wealthy amateurs. The history of archeology hardly affords a parallel. The excavator of to-day breaks into an un- known Pharaoh tomb only to find that a sneak-thief had preceded him by a thousand years. The Greek marbles of ancient Rome are mostly in the mor- tar of the medieval city, but here are the summer homes of cultured Rome of the Augustan period and earlier, only awaiting the careful use of the pick and spade. As if to provide against such a prize being enjoyed too cheaply, nature has sealed Herculaneum under about eighty feet of volcanic concrete, and fate has willed that some twenty thousand Neapolitans should swarm above the villas where Roman patricians dwelt in spacious ease. To uncover Herculaneum will be an expensive business, involv- 409 Yr ing the condemnation of much land, and
then the most cautious methods of ex cavation The nature of the work di tates patience all around. No one should expect quick results at the cost of irrep arable damage to the beautiful objects imbedded in the stiffened mud. On th: other hand, we can imagine no invest ment of capital by an art-lover that more certain to bring handsome returns rhe uncovering of a single villa like that which contained the large bronzes ot the Naples Museum would amply jus tify any expenditure likely to be made We discern a peculiar appropriate ness, too, in the fact that this great proj ect is to be international in its scope Many times in the history of Western civilization a quickening of national cul ture has been due to a sort of vision of Grecian art through Roman eves. Italy has from the first been the mediator of the Hellenic tradition, and when the amateurs and archwologists of Western Europe and America unite to reclaim Herculaneum for Italy and the world, they merely acknowledge in money and rood will a greater if a more intangible debt that has been accumulating inter est through the ages THE LITERATURE OF BUSINESS Not long ago it was the fashion of purists to complain of the bulk of ad vertising in the magazines. But discus sion of the matter in the press brought out numerous champions of the adver tising pages. It was warmly asserted that they constitute a most interesting addition to the reading matter, and could about as ill be spared as the so called literary features Certain read ers, who appeared sincere but may have been malicious, actually expressed a preference for the literature of soups, underwear, real estate, correspondence schools, firearms, and motor cars—a pas sion which has recently obtained notable confirmation through the confession of an editor. Edward W. Bok has declar ed that he will do his modest best to rake the literary section of the Ladies Home Journal as good as the advertising section, though clearly he despairs of attaining so high an ideal We hasten to add that the editorial policy of pretty nearly all the maga zines we know is happily approximating the advertising policy. In a superb mis cellaneousness, in timeliness, in direct and vociferous appeal to the reader, the editors are, after all, not lagging s0 much behind. They have recently taken up the evidently useful practice of com mending their own wares—discreetly setting forth the merits of their best contributors, or more specifically declar ing the current features, as they issue from the press, to be substantial add! tions to permanent English literature When the editors are so alert In follow ing a promising lead, no one should too a AE Tce EE er ‘
Page 10
410 rashly despair of the future of perlodi- eal journalism In all seriousness, a very little study of the literature of advertising will show that the writers command a rhetoric re well adapted to their purpose, and if persuasiveness is a chief merit in vile, the tront and back pages must fairly out lank the wsthetes and muckrakers who fill the Indeed, by main taining vertising writer would scorn, the liter- iry fellows frequently fail to establish confidential relations with the reader rhe reason for the success of advertis Collins (in an article, “The American Grub treet unconscionably buried in the middle portion of the Atlantic Monthly) finds in the following fact nm irkably nameless contributors to the middle pages an aloofness that a seasoned ad ing rhetoric James H Musing Advertising requires versatility of a high le the writer of advertising must combine human interest with strict scecuracy, his subject is constantly chang ne To-day he studies the methods iking cigars and the many kinds of bacco that enter therein; to-morrow he “ ‘ 1 monograph on enamelled tin cans tigating the processes of making them he factory; and the day after that his | may be breakfast foods, taking him investigations of starch, gluten, di gestive functions, diet, and health, and set him upon a weary hunt for synonyms deseribe the “rich nutty flavor.” \ fair inference from this description that the superiority of the advertis ing writer lies in his greater serious ne which is not perhaps the “high riousness” that Matthew Arnold advo cated, but still a quality removed from end above the dilettanteism that in the mere author In any case, ch experience makes for worldly ex und we can imagine a success ful advertising writer, finding himself placed at dinner between, say, William i Howells and Dr. Henry van Dyke, re rience eating Goethe's phrase l'rophet to right, prophet to left i World Child between coffers of the ultra-literary sort have cted to seorn the advertiser as a new and bumptious apparition. Bump tious he may or may not be, but new he emphatically is not In the most technical sense the profession is very oid, while on a narrower rhetorical basis the parallel between the modern vdvertising writer and the Meistersing ‘ the member of a Northern Puy, or Floral Association, is Like mediwval modern advertiser of a Southern worth recalling these predecessors, the writes to order, in competition frequent lv, and on set themes; he is judged, more- cver, rather by the effectiveness of his style than by the pith of his argument To be sure, the Metstersinger and the banded poets of the Rhone celebrated «pringtide, love, or, more abstractly, the tive merits of the rose and lily, or “ter and wine, whereas their mod- The Nation. ein successors exalt bootblacking, scour- ing soap, baking powder, ready-to-wear clothes, grape juice, and influenza cures Fut the change of subject matter should biind no one to a stylistic unity which is all-important. It boots not that one vrite a Remedium Amoris or extol a corn cure; the spirit in which the work is done is what really counts How effective the work of the adver- tising writer is, very little perusal of the magazines will show In all that makes for persuasion his art is supreme We know that an appealing and well waistcoated youth can sell our. real estate, however barren or remote; we long for fences and sheds that another gentleman may paint them pigments. Our engaging with the ideally best heart flutters whenever we read of the ravages of coffee and the value of cereal beverages. Can one deny to writing of this force the name of art? A _ poster, not in print, but prominently displayed, shows the stylistic refinements that may enter into this sort of composition; we learn of a certain whiskey that it is “mellowed by eight vears’ repose in the wood.” Only note the yalue of that word “repose.” How bald and unconvincing any other asseveration of age would be! But so long as we preserve the image of that brown and fragrant fluid peace- fully reposing in its charred prison- house, pure food committees may ex- pose the brand in vain. Who could doubt a stimulant that has not merely grown old, but grown old so gracefully? REAL PREVENTION OF DISEASE. The gay young spark in Moliére who sought a cure for the ills of intemper- ance received from his _hysician a lec- ture on hygiene. In the midst of it, the impatient youth broke in: “Yes, ves, all that I know, but can't you give me a pill?” This attitude is very human. Our chosen path is pleasant, and if it happen to lead into trouble, why, we'll ask the doctor for a pill. In our Western world, the habit is to seek medical ad- vice only when we are sure we need it, but we might with profit copy the Chi- nese. They retain their physicians to keep them well, and demand the return of their fees if they fall sick. The great benefit that medical science has brought to humanity in the last half-century has been chiefly through preventive medicine. The plagues that swept the Old World in the Middle Ages are no longer possible. An epi- demic of typhoid fever is now a reproach to the infected community for having neglected the means which science has placed in its hands. But preventive medicine has concerned itself mainly with contagious diseases which threaten wholesale, and deals but slightly, in the popular conception, with indfviduals. The result is that there has grown up in the public mind a feeling of careless- [Vol. 83, No. 2159 ness regarding disease except where the state is supposed to protect us. We are much concerned about the purity of our crinking water, but few stop to ponder the fact that a majority of us will die of some chronic disease which in its in- cipiency might be arrested. For pro- tection from acute infection we may depend upon boards of health, but for safeguarding against chronic disease we must trust to the physician. He, how- ever, can do nothing to prolong our days unless we give him an opportunity to detect a malady in its early stage. Health is without price, yet how many periodically submit themselves to their doctors for thorough examination? That such a periodic examination is the wis- est of precautions, is shown by the re- jected applications in every life insur- ance company. Thousands were boast- fully proud of their robust health until some life insurance physician rated them “bad risks.” The conditions under which Ameri- cans live in large cities are particularly adapted prematurely to age the heart and arteries. In all probability, these conditions will not soon change, and the only way one may guard oneself is by measuring the wear and tear on one’s erganism. Medicine has grown rich in methods and instruments of precision for the detection of subtle changes in- dicating the onset of disease. A manu- facturer with a fortune in machinery would not neglect to employ an expert engineer to scrutinize it from time to time. Very likely, however, the same man has omitted to ascertain through a physician whether his manner of life has worked ravages with his heart or arteries. Almost every one goes to a dentist at least once a year; why should one not go to a physician? ‘We con- stantly hear that nephritis is a menace, and cancer is becoming more common. Cancer is curable if a surgeon is called in time, and one may live his allotted days, despite nephritis, if he be told how to live. Oliver Wendell Holmes once said that the way to live to old age is te become the victim of a chronic dis- ease and then take care of yourself. The real danger in the chronic type of dis- ease is the insidious progress that gives its victim no warning, until the period when medical aid avails is past. Pre- ventive medicine cannot be of use until men have learned to hunt out dangers before they appear. The White Plague is no longer captain of the men of death; pneumonia has taken its place; and physicians tell us that the reallv awful mortality in pneumonia t~-* “ade great part to latent hear**@iring that disease. The physici-“™™®". If a prize pital in this city *°4¥8 the Nation writ- have saved ha!?" Which would give the tients had th’™ the very best weapon earlier and “OP@sanda, nothing: better respect * “ could have been devised Do: zh it the school, which should be ~~
Page 11
Nov. 15, 1906] would rather “drop in their tracks” than live to an invalid old age. But the possession of a pet chronic disorder is not an unmitigated evil. It often means that a man who has worked like an express locomotive will content himself with slower service. He may be advised to play more golf and less market. He can find good excuses for longer vaca- tions. more time to read, and to culti- vate old friendships that have been al lowed to lapse. Well-known men in this city, having early found their danger, have so regulated their lives that they appear as active as ever and enjoy life more than before. It is not inconceiv- able that the prompt recognition of a bad heart, say, would be a real blessing to many a driven man of affairs THOREAU AND GERMAN ROMANTICISM (Continued from last week.) One might follow the transcendental movements of New England and of Germany step by step—through irony, aloofness, and sacred idleness, through their flowering in musical and communion with nature and show how they develop on lines, always alike on the surface, yet al ways with some underlying difference more easily felt than named. And this difference is felt more strongly, is indeed then only to understood, when we go back to that tree individualism which is the root of all “Contemplation,”’ says “Is revery parallel be this varied growth, Schleiermacher in his second Discourse and always remains something single, sep- arate, the immediate perception, nothing more; to connect and bring together into a whole is not the business of the senses, but of abstract thought. So with religion: it is hers to abide by the immediate experi ence of the being and activity of the uni- verse, by the individual perceptions and feelings; each of these is a work existing in itself without connection with others or de- pendence upon them. Of derivation and as- sociation religion knows nothing; of all things that may touch her, these are the most contrary to her nature It is due just to this absolute individuality that the sphere of contemplation is so infinite.’ Here certainly—and we are at the very heart of German romanticism—is a doc- trine which the wise men of Concord would have been the first to repudiate Infinity to Schleiermacher was only another word for endless variety of particulars, amid which the soul of man, itself a momentary atom in the stream, moves in a state of perpetual wonder. The ideal of Emerson was that self-reliance by which the individual, shak- ing itself free from the mere conformity of manners and tradition, might rise to the community of the higher nature figured by him as the over-soul: ‘In all conversation between two persons, reference is made as to a third party, to a common na- ture. That third party or common nature is not social, it is impersonal; it is God.”’ And Thoreau represented friendship by the symbol of two lines divergent on the earth and converging together in the stars I cannot find the equivalent of this in Schlei- ermacher. I find rather that, like the rest of the romantics, when he sought for the basis of man’s nature, he turned to pure tacit The emotionalism, the power and faculty are bound within the limits of We that to the religion Nation. very by which we seen of our individuality have Schleiermacher essence neither thought nor action, but contempla- tion and feeling Let us see in what col- ors he picture# this passive surrender of the soul to the impression of the world Thus he continues in the “Reden"’ Only do not suppose—this is indeed one of the most dangerous errors—that relig- ious contemplation and feeling at their be- ginning in the first activity of the soul (des Gemuths) are severed in any such way as they necessarily are in our discourse Contemplation without feeling is nothing and possesses neither the right source nor the right power; feeling without contem- plation is likewise nothing: both are some thing only when and because they are originally one and unseparated That first mysterious moment, which comes to us with every perception before contem plation and feeling have drawn apart sensuous fleeting is it and transparent, like the first exhalation wherewith the dew breathes upon the awakened flowers, demure and tender like the kiss of a virgin, holy and fruitful like the embrace of marriage. Nay, not like this, rather it is all this. Quickly and magically an appearance, an event, un- folds itself to a likeness of the universe And so, as the beloved and ever-desired form takes shape, my soul flees to her, and I embrace her not as a shadow, but as the holy essence itself I lie in the bosom of the infinite world; | am in that moment its soul, for | feel all its powers and its in- finite life as my own At the least Jar the holy union is blown away, and then first contemplation stands before me as a separate form; | gaze upon her, and she mirrors herself in the open soul as the image of the departing loved one in the open eye of the youth And now first feel- ing rises up from within him, and spreads like the blush of shame and desire over his cheek. This moment is the highest flower ing of religion Could anything than this be more essen tially at variance with the product of Con cord? The nearest approach to it in sub- stance is the hedonism of Pater as ex pressed in the “Conclusion” to his Renais sance studies. For what in the end is this religion of Schleiermacher's but that cul ture of the fleeting artistic impression which Pater taught perfec { “Every moment some face; tone on the hills or the sea is choicer than the form grows in hand or some rest; sume mood of passion or insight intellectual or excitement is irresistibly real and attractive for us—for that moment only’”’ It is but the modern decking out of the ancient philosophical heresy of Her- acleitus that all things move and flit away which the English writer places as the motto of his essay I would not be un appreciative of the great German divine but | cannot sever his unctuous preaching of emotionalism from the actual emotions which ruled among the coterie to whom his discourses were addressed. When he turns from his image of the bridal of the soul and the universe to the fable of Paradise. and declares that only through the coming of Eve was Adam enabled to lift his thoughts heavenward, when he makes of love the only source of religion, he is. of course, speaking within the acknowledged rights of the preacher Yet I cannot for get the morbid life of Rousseau, from whom all this Gefuhlephilosophie is ultimately de rived I Heinse's remember particularly for wilderness apart from the world where he might like a Platonic sage his life in saintly studies—with Lais at his side. I am afraid more yearning some pass of a religion which accords so easily with is | 411 this blending of Plato and Lals, and which serves so well a literature whose prin ple as announced by Tieck was briefly this The decency of our mmon prosa life is unallowed in ar in these happy, pure regions it i8 unseemiy s am gu even the document of our commonns ss and im morality l am Puritan enough » dis like anu to distrust these nfus s; and t is because | do not find them Th reau that | can turn to him aft« reading much in the romantiache Schule with a sense of relief, as one passes from a sick chamber to the breath of the flelds cord is remote and provincial pa son with ghe Berlin and Jena of those days it lacks the universality and ilt f those centres; above all, it lacks the itm posing presence of a Goethe and a Schiller who, however loosely, were atill connected with the romantic brotherhood; but it pos sessed one great offset—chara ‘Life shall be the living breath of na ture,”’ might have been the motto f Thoreau as was of a great German. He too, went out to find the God fh ry in nature, inasmuch as man is but a part of the whole, a brother to the worm but the ways of their search led them far asunder We have seen how on the surface the mystical revery of Novalis Lehrling zu Sais” is akin to the ideals of Thoreau yet follow the two to the end W shall see one of the scholars of Sais journeying through a tropical clime to the shrine of Isis: we shall see him in an ecstasy t fore that veiled goddess of nature, then lifted he the light, gleaming vell, and—Ro enblithchen sank into his arms It ynly } ) Heinse’s Plato and Lalis, or Schle‘ermach er’s Adam and Eve if you will, under other names There is a taint of sickliness in all this It corresponds too well to the heavenly weariness’’ of Novalis himself, as he might be found at the grave of his So- phie, vowing himself to death for a lofty ensample of love's ernal faithfulness and in a short while after discovering his religion incarnate in another woman Now there was no Sophie in Thoreau's life, no sentimental identification of a dead living Julie, and above all of both of Sophie with a embrace the granted in of It be of human emotion is so pronounced no the may rapturous together goddess that person nature even the absence primitive in his diaries as thin and of this to render them bloodless To lay bare the sources difference Novalis it would be necessary to analyze a score of influences silently at work beneath the sur face of his culture—the inheritance of Pur denied indeed, but still between Thoreau and itan religion mak ing any real return to mediwvalism im possible; the British notion of practical individualism expressed in the philosophy of Adam Smith; the lesson of Wordsworth’'s in the to of fine expectancy derived poets of the seventeenth century chief incalculable ty It austerity devotion nature; the the who were spirit from Thoreau's mental nourishment: the of Emerson's comes at the the freedom of the the end that the might develop; practice force personali last chiefly to th romantic school whole emotional in Thoreau it was higher self-restraint wa to nature for the of a The romantics sought for the common bond of human nature in the Geméth, Thoreau be lieved it lay in cljPacter In the Gemdth
Page 12
The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2159 (the word is untranslatable; heart, with the connotation of sentiment, mood, revery, is the nearest equivalent) Schleiermacher found the organ of religion, to the absolute exclusion of the reason and the will; there Novalis looked for the inspiration of all art; communion with nature was desirable only because in her, too, might be discov- ered “all the variations of an endless Gemiith’’; and to this organ of the individ- ual person was reduced in reality the high- sounding I of Fichte. Gemiith—character, Gefuhi—conduct; in that contrast lay the divergence between German and New Eng- land transcendentalism. “What are three- score years and ten hurriedly and coarsely lived to moments of divine leisure in which your life is coincident with the life of the universe?’ asks Thoreau in his Journal; but he continues: “One moment of life costs many hours—hours not of business, but of preparation and invitation. Yet the man who does not betake himself at once and desperately to sawing is called a loafer, though he may be knocking at the doors of heaven all the while, which shall surely be opened to him. That aim in life is highest which requires the highest and finest dis- cipline.” Man's life, he says elsewhere, “consists not in his obedience, but his op- position, to his instincts,”” and genius was to him another name for health. This was his resolution and his prayer: I pray that the life of this spring and summer may ever lie fair in my memory. May I dare as I have never done! May I persevere as I have never done! May I purify myself anew as with fire and water, soul and body! May I gird myself to be a hunter of the beautiful, that naught escape me! May I attain to a youth never at- tained! I am eager to report the glory of the universe; may I be worthy to do it; to have got through with regarding human values so as not to be distracted from re- garding divine values. It is reasonable that a man should be something worthier at the ewtd of the year than he was at the beginning And so, despite its provincialism and its tedium, the Journal of Thoreau is a docu- ment that New England may cherish proud- ly. It ts the mirror of a life, the record of romanticism striving to work itself out in actual character, and shows thus, as clearly as the far greater writings of Hmerson, wherein the originality of the Concord school really lies. The dangers of transcendentalism are open enough—its facile optimism and unballasted enthusi- asme—dangers to the intellect chiefly. Any one may point at the incompatibility of Thoreau's gospel with the requirements of society. To follow him, as to follow Walt Whitman, a man must needs shun the re- sponsibilities of the family and state, and walk in solitary ways. Yet, withal, there is brave inepiration in the scornful inde- pendence of this botanizing vagabond. For the motto of his Journal one might choose the familiar lines of Matthew Arnold: For most men in « brazen prison live, Where, in the sun's hot eye, Wit® beads bent o'er their toll, they languidly Their lives to some unmeaning taskwork give, Dreaming of nought beyond their prison-wall And the rest, a few, Kecape their prison and depart On the wide ocean of life anew There the freed prisoner, where'er hia heart LAsteth, will sall; Nor doth he know how there prevail, Despotic on that sea, Tradewinds that cross se eternity Awhile he holds some false way, undebarr'd By thwarting signs, and braves The freshening wind and blackening waves, And then the tempest strikes him. . And he too disappears, and comes no more. Put out of mind the wild hurtling words Thoreau was so fond of uttering, forget the ill taste into which his narrower circum- stances often led him, and there remains this tonic example of a man who did ac- tually and violently break through the prison walls of routine, and who yet kept a firm control of his career. If his aim was to refine his senses so that, like an olian harp, he might quiver in response to every impression of mountain and field and river, at least he sought for this re- finement by eliminating all the coarser and more relaxing emotions of his breast; by disciplining his will into harmony with the pure and relentléss laws of universal be- ing. And if the terms of his practical phil- osophy may be traced back through the German romanticists to Rousseau’s ideal of a return to nature, yet his sympathetic knowledge of hard savage life among the Indians and the tradition of New England’s struggle with the wilderness kept him, always in act and generally in words, from sentimental softening of the reality. P. E. M. . Correspondence. WASHINGTON’S PROPOSALS FOR EDU- CATION. To THE EpItoR OF THE NATION: Sir: Speaking of agricultural colleges in your issue of November 1, you make the following statement: Thomas Jefferson was the first American to urge the importance of such schools. Writing in 1803 he deplored the overcrowd- ing of the trades and‘ of the learned vro- fessions. He recommended that a pro- fessorship of agricuiture should be estab- lished in every college. No one will, I believe, endeavor to in any way belittle the effort made by Presi- dent Jefferson. History should, be kept straight, however. In his first message to Congress, January 8, 1790, Washington ex- pressed the hope that “The advancement of agriculture, commerce, and manufactures, by all proper means, will not, I trust, need recommendation,” and continuing: Nor am I less persuaded that you will agree with me in the opinion that there is nothing which can better deserve your patronage than the promotion of science and literature. . Whether this de- sirable object will be best promoted by affording aids to seminaries already es- tablished, or by the institution of a na- tlonal university, or by other expedients, will be well worthy of a place in the de- Iiberations of the Legislature. It is to be noticed that agriculture and a national university for the promotion of science and arts were closely associated by Washington. In his last annual message he writes: “it will not be doubted that with refer- ence either to individual or national wel- fare agriculture is of primary importance. Institutions for promoting it grow up, supported by, the public purse; and to what object can ft be dedicated with great- er propriety? Apparently, then, remembering that he had in his first message called attention to the great subject of agriculture, he adds: I have heretofore proposed to the con- sideration of Congress the expediency of establishing a national university, eto. R. C. BARRETT. Towa State College of Agriculture and Mechanie Arts, Ames, November 6. [We can hardly regard the vague pro- posal of Washington, suggestive though it be, as really forestalling Jefferson’s definite plan for education in agricul- ture —Ep. Nation.] THE HONOR SYSTEM OF EXAMINA- TIONS. To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Sir: The “honor system” is of long standing in several Southern colleges. It has been introduced recently into two New England colleges; and a third is experi- menting with it. The institutions which have it profess to like it, and say that it works well. Working well, however, is not a final test. As every manufacturer knows.,. effi- ciency may be secured by materials or processes that cost too much. _The chief objection to the honor system is that it is ethically extravagant. You can get sap and syrup in springtime by tapping the maples on your lawn. You can haul clay by har- nessing a thoroughbred trotter to a dump eart. But these devices are not economical. Neither is it a prudent expenditure of the deepest ethical resources to tap them for the prevention of a little cribbing, and hitch them onto the tail of an examination paper a dozen times a year, wn The honor system involves a double) standard. The students in a Southern col- i lege will run out of town and ruin forever | a man convicted of cheating in an exam- , ination; yet they look lightly on sexuai offences, which cut infinitely deeper ifito the sentiments which honor should syp- port,(and leave on character far more fast-/ ing scars.) A student who entered a North- ern college which has no honor system from a Southern college where it had prevailed was found guilty of cheating at the first op- portunity, and offered as a sufficient ex- cuse that he had not been put on his honor. In one of the New England colleges that has adopted it, an instructor was recently asked at the beginning of a brief quiz whe- ther it was to be conducted on the honor system or not. The president of the senior class in that same institution recently said knew that cheating was still going on un- der the honor system, Yet he, like all the in a speech at an alumni dinner that he \ } rest, had given a solemn promise on honor 4 to report any chegting that he knew. This promise, by the way, to report way} violation of the honorsystem seems to be an | essential part of the honor system wher- f ever it is applied. The honor of every stu- dent appears to need watching at Geese ing by the honor of every other. Yet it is \, a significant fact, one more creditable to the students than to the devisers of the system, that in one of the New England > colleges now trying the experimdot every case of conviction for dishonesty Since the system was introduced has been. based on j internal evidence drawn from the blue ?
Page 13
Nov. 15, 1906] book; in no case has evidence come volun) tarily from the students who have beem pledged to give it a It is a serious thing to drag out of its natural soil in the subconscious the deli- eate, sensitive sentiment of honor, which ordinarily comes to the surface only under some such stirring experience as love or war, and at the end of every examination “make each student that he has neither given nor received aid. In a recent \ discussion of the question, President Eliot of Harvard declared that there never was a time when he could have been brought to sign that statement. It assumes that the desire to cheat is normal and univer- sal; and only under special stress of honor \ ean the temptation be overcome. . The evil of cheating in examinations can never reach very serious proportions in a institution. There is no student sentiment, left to itself, tolerates cheating win prize or an election Phi Beta Kappa. Such cheating as student sentiment condones is confined mainly to cases where a dull or lazy student aims to escape being dropped. Then student’ sentiment undoubtedly say, “Poor drowning devil, let him clutch the forbidden straw.’ Limited to this re- stricted sphere, cheating in examinations is not sufficiently important, either as an aid to rank or an injury to character, to warrant erecting the sentiment of honor into a system for its eradication. The evil can be cured by cheaper means In a certain college for a series of years the greater part of all complaints of cheat- ing came from a single department. This was taken as one of several evidences that the teaching in this department was less vital than in the other departments, and the department was reorganized. A good instructor sets papers of such a nature that illegitimate aids are of little avail Grasp of a subject, the relation of part to part, judgment on critical questions, ap- plication of principles to problems—these can be extemporized no more with than without adventitious aids. \ Vital teaching, frank and friendly personal relations, firm administration when required, can secure at moderate ethical cost results quite as satisfactory as those achieved under the honor system, It is therefore the part of a wise ethical economy to refrain from all attempts to superimpose the systematized sentiment of honor on the uncovenanted judgment of the right. WILLIAM DEWITT HYDE. November 6. declare well-conducted college where to a to does Bowdoin College, Brunswick, Me., ‘al NEWMAN ON JANE AUSTEN. “To THE Ep1ToR oF THE NATION: Srr: Here is a tribute from Cardinal Newinan to Jane Austen, which perhaps has not been brought to the notice of many of her admirers: / He used to say that he read through “Mansfield Park’’ every year, in order to perfect and preserve his style.—‘‘Reminis- cenges of Oxford,” by the Rev. W. Tuck- well, p. 184. Cassell & Co., 1900. 1. F. WILSON. Cincinnati, November 7. Notes, Houghton, Mifflin & series of yolumes after the model of Curtis Hidden *whief They announce for early publication following “The Chief Elizabethan matists’’ (except Shakspere) to the of thé theatres, edited by Prof. William A of Harvard University editor Shakspere; ‘The the Sixteenth and and The Chief British of the Eighteenth Century,” edited Prof Hidden The selections will cover the full practical needs book will bibliographi- Co. are preparing a Poets.”’ the Dra- close Page's American Neilson the of the new Chief British Seventeenth single-volume of Centuries,”’ Poets Poets by Curtis Page courses, and each be of college furnished with biographical cal, and explanatory notes Three more yolumes are promised for this ide Press Edli- _ a. translated e..2 autumn in the special River tions of Houghton, Mifflin & Idyls of Theocritus,”’ Calverley numbered “The Song of Roland,”’ translated by Butler graphy , viz by sale) Isabel Biblio- of by B There no more tastefully made books on the than the of this (300 copies for numbered copies); “A Wendell Ives (500 numbered copies) (200 Oliver Holmes,’ George are volumes market to-day series Doubleday, Page & Co. will publish early in January erner,”’ appearing in the Atlantic in serial form Dobell to various the We “Centuries publish and in- seven- Bertram is proposing by edited subscription unknown of centuries sixteenth and teenth have men- tioned of Meditation,”’ by Thomas Traherne, and the “Gleanings from Manuscripts.” To these shoulg now be “The Works of William Strode,” “The Letters, Speeches, and Poems of Sir Nicholas Bacon’’ (1509-1579), and “The Partiall Law, a Tragi-Comedie”’ (circa 1620-1630). It little while ago that Oxford University Press published a text of Keats’s poems with elaborate anno- works already his added Poetical the new was only a tations by E. de Sélincourt. The poetical works are now to be added to the “Oxford Library Editions,” with textual notes by H. Buxton Forman. The volume will in- clude some lines hitherto unprinted. Gilchrist’s “Life of Blake,’’ published in 1863, will now be reissued by John Lane in | a cheaper edition. W. Graham Robertson has edited the text, written an Introduction, and added a large number of reproductions from the most perfect of Blake’s drawing? and pictures Much the of Swinburne ever wrote is his volume, ‘‘Wil- liam Blake,"’ which has long been out of print. A new edition now issued by E. P. Dutton & Co. is therefore really worth while. Mr. Swinburne adds a Prefatory Note, only a few pages long, but abound- ing in his eloquence. E. P. Dutton & Co a new edition ot “The House of Quiet,” with an Intro- duction announcing the author as Arthur Christopher Benson. He says frankly that the chief reason now for giving his name is that it seems foolish go on to keep a secret that is no secret at all best piece critical work polyphloisboian issue to trying. 4 tions, “The Autobiography of a South- | by Nicholas Worth, which has been | of Brandes's 413 Benson, like the of of writers Mr longer We Andrew begin to believe that Lang, is no name lety be always to write individual, but of a sox he continues to and of an However always in teresting with the artist leisure of Lord His son has written to the appearance We Acton’s correspondence are to have more London Times, stating that after a suitable lapse of time he will publish the letters to Déllinger Charles Scribner's Sons announce a book on bridge whist by P. F. Mottelay It will contain the collected opinions of the beast- known authorities regarding the declara- tions, leads, and different emergencies of the game. Mr. Mosher’s Bibelots for October and November contain, respectively, “Giordano Bruno,” by Walter Pater, and “The Last Days of John Addington Symonds,” by Mar garet Symonds With the publication of the “Main Currents in (the sixth a year ago) that standard work in criticism The with illustra full in- views are so well fifth Nineteenth volume Century Literature” came out is made ish dress » complete in its En Macmillans now issue the 4. to the dex is added. Brandes’s known that any detailed review of the fifth “The School in or of the work as a whole, would He the full tide liberalism, and his are mani- political affiliations, but writes always with spirit; is always in- and sixth volume a volume, on Romantic France,” be of festly colored by he teresting, and at times (notably in the vol- “The School many’) shows the faculty of plucking out superfluous wrote in opinions ume on Romanti« in Ger- the heart of a complicated movement. The translation in the present edition is idio- matic, and, so far as we have examined. ac- curate , Following hard upon Winston Churchill's full and official biography of his father, Lord Rosebery’s .essay, “Lord Randolph Churchill” (Harper's), is, as he himself says, merely a sort of debt of friendship He was much thrown with Lord Randolph, and it is personal appreciation of which his volume is made up Political sympathy there could be little between the two men. But the audficity, the perversity, the bril- liance of Randolph Churchill appeal to Lord Rosebery, if only as matter for neat description or sententious comment. Of this is plenty given, if little real information. It is put beyond doubt, how- though it was never really in doubt that, in the great crisis of his career. his resignation as chancellor of the ex- chequer, Lord Randolph was merely biuf- fing, and did not expect Salisbury to take him at his word. Lord Rosebery declares that when the time comes for the private letters of those two 4 be published, there will be tidbits for intellectuaf gourmets His own style retains all of itg point. The long decay of Lord Randolph’s faculties, along with his Yoss of ptitical power, »is put into this epigrams*“He was the chief mourner at his oW® protracted funeral, a public pageant of gloomy years.” There are many 6 Roseberyisms gn the book. J Shelley's “Literary Bypaths in there ever Henry Old SMgland” (Boston: Little, Brown & Cp". is a thoroyghly readable book. It Pin #0 easy for literary pilgrims to be dull
Page 14
ind to foree on the reader a rehash of the old aneedotes and descriptions, that Vr Shelley is the more to be commended f fu hing in each of these eleven vd ome new ingredient if only a birth « fleate to prove that Hood's tomb- rT) wrong by a year, or more inti iT pa ila of the career of John Hamilton Reynold Hood's brother-in-law, he friend of Keats. Most people will think hat tl hapte on Hood is the most tin- n Mr. Shelley prints for the first rie me of Hood witty and tender” ‘ ind give is new glimpse of the fumil nto which he married and the in- et of his life These documents were | ireal hrough Hood nephew, the late lbownels Green The anecdotes gleaned itt the Carlyle country are all unpleasing, ind maintain the tradition that Carlyle eed to | saved from his biographers Those who have not themselves visited b lefechan and Seotsbrig, may be sur- prised to learn that their cebery is not desolate bleak The road that con- hie wo place lies between luxur hedgerows and flower-covered banks.” ‘) he haunts and homes of Spenser, Sid- bey, Penn, Gray, Gilbert White, Goldsmith, iiurus, and Keat Mr. Shelley bas in each omething to contribute His style pleasing and impersonal, and his illus ' on from photograph are numerous { well reproduced Constance Elizabeth Maud’ Felicity in Pranes (Charles Seribnets Seuss) is @ lively and well-written account of a sum biel peut in Normandy and Brittany by Pelicity aud an energetic aunt If this is fuithtul record of their experience the pair must have fairly shattered the French illusion is to the reserve and stiffness of the British tourist. They made friends with all classe and were equally at home in a bour hunt at Fontainebleau or sharing the market cart of a peasant Everywhere they found resentment and grief at the sec- ularization of the convents, and never any thing but reverence and pity for the buns, whe in many cases have been quartered inp ihe houses of the hospitable Ltowaspeople sud pend their time in bursing and teach- ug. Dueyed up by the hope of a turn in pulitical sentiment The most interesting hapter is an account of the home of the belibre in Prauvenes these enthusiasts vho. filly years ago, began the work of re ing aod perpetuating the old language fr sri el thie langue dk which was i iyiow inte wa palo Felicity visit iM | biteelf, the soul of the move mek vi | complained bitterly of the taaeatent ‘ Which make it easy for parties of rT ale ad on him at all bours of the da wel coigghat | have the misfor jue ft be now io thei stalowue of monu sient i wheel volume in entertalp oy and a i ively ma ) it would be i ‘ ellent guide for touriat ‘ peetally women wh winl ! “ ‘ 1 in the tore emote villas i bran ml te tuy it sunvent whil ther mvent left sther han in bie hotel \ new | k by owt fsiward White no lounge thew immny recommendation \ im open yed f t rambler ind moun sin climber he is easily in the firat rank of nature writers, though, of course, with out the peculiar literary flavor and the varied background in wider experience of ghe Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2159 life which one finds in the outdoor books of a Henry van Dyke. The present volume, “The Pass" (New York: Outing Publishing Co.), climbing In eastern-central California, in the region of the Great Western Divide of the Sierra Ne- with Cloudy Canyon, Dead- Canyon, and the of King’s Roaring River immediate is devoted to mountain vada range man’s River surroundings, and the peaks about Yosemite the Tuolumne Valley the far dis- Mr. White was accompanied by his but are likely make popular as a summer for Mr. White pays a high tribute to the good sense and fidell- of the official of thi gion, and puts in a plea for an extension of valleys and for and in tance their not the society wife, experiences to region resort women ty forest ranger re- this service and more adequate compensa- tion It is a poor year that does not bring to our table one or more text books upon elementary economics, and this season’s crop begins with Prof. Charles Lee Raper’s Principles of Wealth and Welfare” (New York: The Macmillan Company). The book offers little that is novel in method or ar- rangement, and—very wisely—does not at- tempt to reconstruct’ economic theory for the benefit of high-school pupils. The style is clear, if sometimes oracular; and he doctrine generally sound Dr. Paul Marcuse’s “Bet rac htungen iiber la Notenbankwesen in den Vereinigten Staaten von Amerika” (Berlin: C. Hey- mann) an attempt to describe for Ger- man readet the national banking system of the United States After a brief ac- count of American banking prior to the Civil War, Dr. Mareuse treats of the growth and present position of our na- onal banks. Particular attention is giv- en to note issues, but other aspects of the subject are not neglected For Amer- ican students the book has little value or interest, and German readers will be mis- led as often as aided by it. The introduc- tory chapter upon banks of issue prior to 1864 particularly open to criticism. On his first page the author states that col- onial banking experiments were unre- strained by the home Government; where- as in 1741 Parliament extended to the colonies the rigorous provisions of the “Bubble Act.” He thinks that the first bank of the United States was chartered primarily as a means of reforming Ameri- in banking. rather than as a fiscal agent if the American Government; and that it prevented a “rapid increase and exten- sion of other banks.” He imagines that the notes of State banks used to circulate only in the State in which they were is- sued The overflowing revenues of the national Government in 1835 and 1836 he attribute to the new protective tariff system”: wherea duties were steadily falling at that time under the provisions of the “Compromise Tariff," and the inordl- nate increase of the revenues was due to he phenomenal sales of public lands. He writes an account of the second bank of the United States without making use of Pro fessor Catterall'a indispensable volume; and throughout displays but a superficial acquaintance with the literature of his sub ject Dr Marcuse would have served his readers better had he been content to be- gin his narrative with the founding of the national banking system. Aas it stands, we cannot commend it to the constituency for which it was designed Alessandro Luzio, director of the archives at Mantua, has won a commanding position as an authority on the Risorgimento. His “Profili Biografici’” just published (Cogl- ati, Milan) is a collection of articles mostly from the della Sera and dealing with Italian personalities of the nineteenth century. The author's style is as agreeable as his erudition is extensive, and, unlike Italian scholars in this field, he of the German and English literature of his subject reprinted Corriere most is abreast valuable of recent con- history of religion is s “Das Religion des Ju- im neutestamentlichen Zelitalter.” The author, who is a professor at Gét- tingen, has bestowed much labor on the rabbinic and apocryphal and pseudepi- graphic literature; and the extent and ac- curacy of his information of Jewish writ- ings from the pre-Maccabeean time on- wards is widely recognized. His book is griindlich in the real German manner. Pro- fessor Bousset not only a master of facts, but also a competent historian and clear His monograph presents graphically the development and charac- teristic features of Jewish piety, with light on the religion of the masses as well as One of the most the . tributions to Professor Bousset dentums is writer. the more easily discoverable religious system of the scribes. The book has prov- ed to be more than commonly useful, as is evidenced by repeated references to it, both in scholarly and popular works. We the appearance of a second edition, thoroughly revised and enlarged. (Berlin Reuther und Reichard.) An English trans- lation of this valuable work would be most acceptable, and would serve to dissi- pate many popular illusions in regard to Jewish religion in the time of Christ note The Swedish Tourist Traffie Society in Stockholm has issued a small volume, the character of which is well described in its title: “Sweden: A Short Handbook on Sweden's History, Industries, Social Sys- tems, Sport, Arts, Scenery, ete.” The opening chapter, by Emil Svens6n, entitled “Sweden's Place in History,.”’ gives an in- teresting bird’s-eye view of the history of the country, with constant reference to that of Europe at large. The other chap- reasonably full accounts of the material and intellectual and social conditions, curiously enough omitting any mention of Swedish literature; the last describes “Sweden as a country for tour- ists." The volume illustrated by ex cellent photograyures. An Index woulda have enhanced its value as a work of ref- ters give resources is erence The German Asiatic Soclety of Japan is- sues in Band x, Teil 3, five papers of upus- ual interest. The first, presented with il- lustrations, is upon Japanese Falconry, by D. A. Schinzinger, and embodies the result of much study of native literature upon this subject Dr. Miura of the Imperial University treate of the Japanese litera- ture of dreams and the canons of interpre- tation. In discussing the question of the naturalization of Japanese trees in Europe, Mr. Hofman points out the climatic posal- bilities of the most important of the trees of Nippon and tells something of native forestry. The famous, but now obsolete,
Page 15
Nov. 15, 1906] Nation. sport of inuw no mono, or the hunting of dogs with blunt arrows by archers on horseback, which was only rarely cruel, is treated in text and by picture The Asiatic Society of Japan sends forth vol. xxxiv., part 1, of its Transactions, in a pamphlet of but fifty-nine pages Yet in weight and value few of its issues have exceeded this one. John Carey Hall, the British consul-general, who has a perspec- tive of thirty-six years of residence in Japan, furnishes a translation of what may be regarded as the literary basis of Japan ese feudalism, the magisterial code of the Hojo power-holders, promulgated a. b 1232. ‘The code existed the seventeenth century, when it was print knowledge, but for of has been done in manuscript until ed, not for public ficial use. The translation with great care and the explanatory notes illuminating. Besides being of the highest interest to the student of feudal- ism, it confirms the view held by literary scholars, that the position of the Japanese woman in the early and middle ages was much higher than the Tokugawas, when the Chinese philosophy ethics fettered not only the national intellect, but swayed the social customs of the Japanese A brief paper on Chomei, “the Wordsworth,” and an unusually paper on the study of Korean, point of view of a student of the language, complete this number. are under and Japanese practical from the Japanese The Imperial Cabinet of Japan has issued the tabulated statement which shows the movement of the population of the em- pire in 1903. The brief text and terms are in French, and the details of births, mar- riages, deaths, divorces, and diseases fut nish data for conclusions as to the ad- vance in public hygiene. On the whole Such a con- the figures are encouraging clusion is more than confirmed by the “Ré sumé Statistique de l’Empire du Ja- pon,” which, in its twentieth issue, for 1906, gives the statistics, in con- densed form, though none later than 1904. Within the memory of living men there were no public hospitals in Jap- oft an: the exact number in 192 was 909. the 37,180 physicians, probably 30,000 prac- tise according to modern science. Of epi- demics in 1904, dysentery and typhoid fever claimed the greatest number of victims Recent legislation has strikingly dimin ished the number of divorces. Instead of one divorce to every three marriages, the figures for 1902, exclusive of Formosa, show 394,165 marriages and 64,139 divorces The like our Indians, so far from dying hold their own Ainus, out, seem to con Le direc- The Nuova Antologia of November | upon the the important article The author tains an gends of Trajan.” tor of the excavations in the Roman Forum, whose discoveries in regard ins Giacomo Boni, to the Column of Trajan were discussed in a letter from Rome printed in the Nation of July 26. He not only gives the results of his recent researches in and about the Column of Trajan, but brings together a unique collection of photographs of tapes- tries, sculptures, frescoes, engravings, and pieces of majolica of the Middle Age and the Renaissance, illustrating the origin of the legends of Trajan, and showing their transformation as they were passed on from century to century. Hall the the Dr Title Rudolf publication Haupt under Luthe if announces of lon of Reformation, termining books and in editorsh Pp Johannes ile Borders for th of the purpose of aiding in de of undated During rept led any le this inting pt pamphlets of free the and unrest ed period hardly pamphlet at yet regat as | general by racy, a that arouse interest and reprinted booksellers though very « The was comment was pat hou the title mn various of Germany ifien wi piace o date orhamentation on pages eVen always on the same page il jliography opled, though aot whose title Bit the ser publication on had orig been found here dire culture nally is of the de undated pam of be used tly Vice history of of in as the termination of light inasmuch imprint place these on the spread The will throw phle Ss the issued teformation ideas work will eight h contain In for plate in SIX lo pat ear litate the of mmpanied by ng fifty ler » fac of plate 8 ol work each use he the purpose com parison is a a duplicate on transparent paper correspondence of sold at by the highest Ww E the Field were t Friday The Selections rom WwW ity aur Mer the late Cyrus tion in this ¢ las Clayton price $ivl, for a to Mi Months in a Rebel Mr. Field had Message win Company paid was from Gladstone reading Thir copy original Pri him Mr Septem sO, aa The Field ieewu of which sent cable read by the Crystal Palace in this city the of the laying of the $30 November at ber 1, 1858 carnival cele Athanti day brating the cable was sold for the Merwin offer literature On Monday, IW Sales Company will at au of Lincoln Clayton tion a collection in Con books also a few fifteen the latter Ferry ag cluding some scarce items; some of Harper's first John Brown,” Whittier's federate pieces and One ls of the of Thoreau's “Plea for Capt about John Brown Redpath’'s 1860 “Echoes which contains publication two speed hes by Emerson, and of Ossawatomie.”’ I. M as ol English poem ‘‘Brown The cage American of Chi Dillman One of first of ranks library Which great of will collections editions century authors this Company nineteenth Anderson Mr Diil rich in Shelley, Keats His copy Browning's page Browning seuson by the this espe ially be dispersed Auction ol eity man’s collection is books ol Rossetti of ' Pauline,”’ with Lamb, Coleridge Brownings Reuben title and the 1833, Was on the Robert inseription in his by his aulugraph distributed first publication privately This copy was given me by his father my eldest brother Reuben Browning This identical copy bas already appeared three times in the auction room At the George T Maxwell sale in April, 1895, it brought $260. being bought by a firm of booksellers who sold it to Alfred J. Mor gan When part of this library was sold in April, 1902, the book brought $720 In the sale of the library of Daniel F. Ap pleton, April, 1903, it brought $1,025 Al though Pauline’ is probably the most valuable single book, the Keats, Shelley Lamb, and Coleridge collections include rare items Many of the volumes are in the original boards, uncut | 415 * ee a ” Thursdays N Hote N ‘Oo t I ! ‘ ‘ *. sell a na rile mm of book na vy Eng h 5 u and iding a few volu { ai 4 iy rh ii ny ily hes ne mA of Si) ' Shey heard (a ‘ page w la wit! j i ij 1 a Londo y Thomas Ea John Ha mn, the young ‘ The f i ’ vf | } are an mos valual henge h h Th has come ite th lark ia yea Phe earl ] j i \ e (lub n f \ ‘ ‘ on and No Is Wi i 1OS6 ind we know f no r , } the first of econd ui ! in rhe sale alse luck v ‘ ea Shakspere quartos The Who Con tion betweene the House of Laneas ‘ York,” the undated ed mn pris 1 Thomas Pavier mn 1619 ing h hi edition of Pa ll and Ill of We Vi The Merchan f Ven t i edition, but with th mprin ul from th tle-page Hamls 127 he sixth i on, & large py and I lt he xth ed rt bu lacking h There is a fine and perfect py of th firs Ollected ed " f Shak 1 Poems 1640, with h i froutiay by Marshall ilso two j ) lacks hree leaves of tex he h pert t of the spurious play The H y of Life of Sir John Oldeastlh been Anott book of Shakspe an inte john Tay lor the Water poe Head tf all Fa nf 1642 ire ind en ely uncu e) hie le- page ‘ eventeen head of them being tha T Shakspe Or mu modern book hie he Valuable ar little college magazine The Gownsman which issued seventeen weekly number Isto, and which, i ipposed, Thackeray had a hand in editing; Tennyson's “Poems Chiefly Lyrical S30 incut and) Pope Essay on Man,” fir ed 7 of the fou par An even raret eve of view of > York streets, than those of Jone & New man, deseribed in the Nation of October is one published by Alfred Talli Called Tallis’s New York Pictorial Directory aut Street Views of all the Principal Cith sud Towns in the United Stats and Canada The views were engraved on steel, whe 4 Jones & Newman's were lithograph it covers state that the engravings will executed under the direction of Mr Joti Rogers and Mr John Kirk of this cit The “Directory was issued in part ea containing two plate and two leave text, one side of the leaf being matter 4 scriptive of the buildings, the other side ad vertisements Apparently eight part taining sixteen plates, were issued, though this full number is net owned by any collector Several of the plats ex different states, new names being added the fronts of the buildings from tim time, as the occupants were induced come advertisers in the serie The Athenaum wot hat W He Hau of Cleveland, Ohio, has found in Wo ter Cathedral Library a valuable MS fifteenth century the literature Middle English of the late which has not yet attracted of students of English attention ind his
Page 16
416 Among of tal tale the MS collect ion the of are Pe Alfons's of called “Disciplina Clericalis,’ “Le This dis contents x ve on ter Orilet French poetry as pére Aa fils."’ is the only one yet own in old d'un son ver lin M ion ddle English literature years of ser- College of time the ifter forty at the his Rome Bo er chair to I i e in order to devote lenization of Raverty, an Oriental attainments and large per- d away in England of in formance, has just pa He the ‘company military service 1843, 1840-50 entered India ¢ ib the the the he 1864 East in served hun first frontier expedition of 1850 against In retired campaign of and in trib mm the Swat border 1863 in North pro attalne i majority, and the for Marathi, frontier he of Pashtu of had for out ) } transferred to we he d guished himself Per Nol his an and thwest the study began the study ] htu no grammar of that language he to mr he corrected bl hed in he levoted was compelled make one in enlarged aad After elf to and ISS5 his re- Oriental first rank One him | won a place in the rf} rriar of the Moslem Ea hi x achievement i hi Nasiri,”’ to lation he contem of earlier trans which lrawn from It is a storehouse mi tion regarding the Mohamune rule India and Northwe the \ of ly lan in fron Society stern t ‘ countries on if of siatic many his papers, practical independent He iT upon ih tory umd the was engaged in later of He innal of rat and its de Khorasan Martyn Baird College Hienry University died ghty-four of New Yonkers graduation he then studied Sunday at After 1850 trav- ver ty in Italy and Greece, and Prince he ofessor rheological Seminary and soo re of This chair of of Modern Robert of jlogical Seminary In ! » this « and became pt tire in New York he « ipled until 1902 ty University and during part the duties charged include the Rev the ngs of of Huguenots rhe Huguenots Revocation of the Edict of and Ihe lore Tk i oe Huguenots and Henry and the TROD of the Nante ‘ounsellor have le led that hurz shall hip at the be filled ome nemorial to Carl 8 rh | ’ each well prof rr from one of the German ippeals endant of the who, lik Carl between 1848 Schurz was a empha - movement par larly to the ds many of i rman settled in W onain The fact that Mr the State University, inds thou Schurz 1860 of and regent the | of | The Nation. sizes the appropriateness of the memorial For the present, the professorship will be one-sided,” but it is hoped some day to louble the endowment so as to provide for in American lecturer in Germany. The of German which in charge the preparation of the programme for the Second Internation- al Congress for School Hygiene, to be held has submitted to the minister Prussia a series of for reform in the secondary schools. The chief proposals are: (1) All compulsory class work to be restricted to | committee educators, has n London in 1907, cultus of proposals the forenoon hours, arf to this end per- ds of recitation not to be longer than forty to forty-five minutes; (2) the amount of work done at home to be materially de- fall away entirely in the middle and lower grades; (3) one afternoon each week to be given entirely to sport and and to reased exer and no written work assigned for ises, next day. A theological diploma for women, S.Th. (student in theology), is the latest advance n the higher education of women in Eng- land. It has been established by the Arch- bishop of Canterbury to supply a training schools where religious in- The is for teachers in truction of which the that of the honor schools of theology, in five Three 6f these tion and subject matter of the Old and New and the of Christian compulsory, and two may be s required examinations, standard approximately are subjects introduc- restaments, history doctrine—are chosen at the option of the candidates from A knowledge of New Tes- Hebrew Diplomas were successful candi- a varied group Greek optional subjects last five tament is necessary; is one of the given month to dates, one of whom was an American. The next examination will be held in July, 1907. dean An account of the travelling library sys- tem in Belgium by the Ligue de l'Enseignement is given in a recent issue carried on of the Revue des Bibliothéques et Archives de Relgique The league has forty-three libraries, containing from 110 to 135 vol- ich. These libraries are sent gratu- umes ¢€ ously to a teacher in any place not hav- ng a public library, on condition that the books be put at the disposal of the resi- lents of the locality at least one day a week The library is lent for two years, ind is then exchanged for another. If at the end of four years interest has not been sufficiently aroused to organize and support t local library, the league abandons the place as unworthy of further effort. Sev- enty-seven rural communities have been visited, and two-thirds of them have found- ed local libraries SHAKSPERE AND POPE The Yext of Shakespeare: Its History from the Publication of the Quartos and Fol- los down to and including the Publica- tion of the Editions of Pope and Theo- bald By Lounsbury. New York Charles Scribner’s Sons. $2 net. In his two previous volumes on “Shakes- Wars" Professor Lounsbury dealt length with the had raged over Shakspere as a dramatic artist. In the present volume he begins the history of the attempts to restore the text. His intention of completing this in Thomas R at controversies that original | Vol. 83, No. 2159 one volume has been interfered with by the necessity of a treatment of the Pope-Theo- bald controversy much more elaborate than had been foreseen, so that the book be- fore us is really an account of the “‘Dun- ciad,”’ its origin, growth, and results, with a few chapters prefixed on the earlier his- tory of Shaksperean editing. These introductory chapters give an ad- mirable summing up of the circumstances surrounding the writing and printing of plays in the late sixteenth and early sev- enteenth centuries, and bring out clearly the facts that there was nothing excep- tional in Shakspere’s apparent indifference to the publishing of his plays, and that the corrupt state of the early prints was the natural outcome of the casual aature of their in manuscript and committal to the press. In illustrating the risks which the text later ran from the backwardness of linguistic scholarship in English in the eighteenth century, Profes- sor Lounsbury states the case in a some- what unfortunate way. In such a line as transmission Whose own hard dealings teaches them suspect, the eighteenth century critic naturally jumped to the conclusion that “teaches” was merely a mistake in grammar, due to the compositor, and proceeded to emend the line, either as the editor of the Sec- ond Folio had done, by reading ‘‘dealing” for “dealings,” or, as Pope did, who read “dealings teach them to.” Modern textual critics retain the original reading, and it is on the ground for this retention that Professor Lounsbury’s discussion leaves something to be desired. He explains the “teaches” as a peculiarity of the Northern dialect, which, in the time of Shakspere, he believes to have been still contesting a foothold against the -e de- rived from the regular Midland -en ending of the present indicative plural. This ten- dency he regards as parallel to the sup- planting of the -th ending of the third person singular of the present indicative by the -s which is now the normal ter- mination. But it is more than a dozen years since it was pointed out to Professor Lounsbury, on the appearance of his “Stud- ies in Chaucer,’’ that this last ending was West Midland as well as Northern, and that Northern influence was unnecessary to explain it. Thus, as a support to his explanation of the -es in the plural, it has no force. Many, if not most, English scholars find it more likely that the -es in such passages as that quoted is merely an extension of the familar construction in which a singular verb follows a subject plural in form but singular in idea. He has, of course, a perfect right to prefer his theory of a Northern dialect origin, but hardly to state it as if it were the only alternative to the belief that the trou- blesome final -s was due solely to the depravity of seventeenth-century printers. The last twenty chapters form a contri- bution to the literary history of the eigh- teenth century of the highest importance. They clear upanobscureand tangled contro- versy, throw light on the character and conduct of the greatest poet and the great- est Shaksperean critic of the age, and make clear the origin of its greatest sa- tire. Much of this investigation of. neces- sity wanders far from Shakspere; but it is dificult.to see how it ¢ould have been -es of avoided, and the substantial results of the
Page 17
Nov. 15, 1906] author's researches ought to silence the critic who is inclined to quibble over the appropriateness of the title of the volume “The ‘Dunciad,’”’ Professor Lounsbury de- clares, “owed its existence the revela- tion which had been given of Pope's inca- The the pre- to pacity as an editor, and to that alone.” edition of the accessible of 1729, and of any completed ‘‘Dunciad”’ absence valence of the later version in which Cibber | replaces Theobald as hero, have combined to obscure this all-important fact, and to deprive the satire of much of its true signi- ficance. Not only does the present volume reveal the real origin of the work, but it also corrects many serious misconceptions that have clouded the whole matter for a century and a half. The pretence of Pope that his aim was to purge society from the nuisance of petty scribblers who assailed the great, is completely unmasked; and the satirist is shown to have sought in his ‘Discourse on the Profund”’ to draw out at- tacks which would seem to justify such castigation as he purposed in the “Dun- In this he was largely disappointed, to creat ciad.”’ but he the impression nevertheless proceeded that he was being perse- cuted, and he deliberately falsified his statements as to the treatment accorded him in the pamphlets and journals of the day, in order to provide a justification for what was in reality a vent for his private spite and mortified vanity. The success of his efforts has lasted to the present day; and readers of English literature have been induced to believe not only that Pope's victims were malicious, but that they were really dunces, and that the “Dunciad” an- nihilated them. All of this now appears to be untrue. Pope is further shown, in spite of his denials, to have used the Grub Street Journal as a personal organ, and later to have left its editor, now for the first time identified, in the lurch, when the paper no longer served his needs. The painful impression produced by such additional evidence of the degradation of a great writer is partly compensated for by the rehabilitation of Theobald. While this critic can by no means be freed from the charge of having stooped at times to un- dignified methods of controversy, he is shown to have been on the whole honest and disinterested as well as scholarly; and his position as the greatest of textual critics of Shakspere is made clear. Many inaccuracies of detail concerning his meth- ods and actions are corrected, and abund- ant evidence is produced of his learning and acumen. “Let it not be fancied,’’ says Professor Lounsbury in conclusion, “that I delude myself with the belief that the facts here presented, incontrovertible as they are, will reverse the verdict passed upon the man by ages too prejudiced to consider fairly, too indifferent to feel concern, too indolent to | investigate. The world cares very little for justice.” We may be permitted to hope that such pessimism reflects only a passing mood in the veteran scholar who has in his time labored so well for the cause of truth. Already the acknowledgments of Messrs. Clark and Wright, and the efforts of J Churton Collins and others, have done much to give Theobald his due. The present vol- ume will do more; and though the immedi- ate effect may be confined to a limited circle of specialists, sooner or later the truth is sure to reach the general reader, The Nation. of | and even for Pope and his victims will the whirligig of time bring in his revenges Meantime, we wait for the conclusion Professor Lounst y's survey With some res tir of his be ig §s of diffuseness | ind ‘ mn it should be possible to cove t rema ler of he hist f the ed n e volu and the s es will then Stand a ! mo mprehe v A punt ve pos s of the posthur fort s of English autho CURRENT FICTION 4 Lady of Rome By F. Marion Crawford New York: The Macmillan Co Mr. Crawford has no distinct message to deliver, or problem to sugg He is « sentially an entertainer To him a novel is not a vaudeville turn or a drawing-room discourse to the initiate The simplicity fluidity, and vigor of h tyle are charac teristic of his conceptions Subtlety of temperament or character often interests him, but never mere subtlety of mind This story reintroduces us into the Ro man circle to which “Saracinesca,’ Pietro Ghisleri,”’ and the rest gave us access long ago. The theme is that one inexhaustible theme, an unlawful love and its conse- quences Its treatment is refreshing; for these Sinners are not invented that a pun- ishment may be invented, nor are they dealt with according to the familiar con- ventions of prosaic retribution or poetic The suffering to which his lovers suffering ex- death, but, justice are brought piated by final renunciation or as chances, terminated by a stroke of fate which unites them by all bonds There is the which seem or immoral, per- believe that af- From the dramatic point is a human not a casualness in event may unduly sons who ironical, even to wish to human fairs go by rote of view the dénouement But a novel melodrama is certainly incon- follow the If the Craw- clusive does not rules of or tragedy bit of human experience which Mr ford hers is to be considered as its inconclusiveness need not be taken The the fa- its forerunners, it is sitting chronicles data insignificance story has swing; like book as miliar decidedly a to be read ata the Parish. By Mary Moss Henry Holt & Co One is grateful to Miss ing depicted, in these days of drivel about a poet who, is by no Poct and York The New Moss for hav- artistic temperament, socially the however irresponsible, means morally invertebrate. He loves and marries a stupid and conventional wo- man, and remains faithful to her, even continues to love her, by virtue of an in- nate purity and fidelity of nature which ‘the parish’’—that is, Mrs. Grundy—is in- capable of understanding He has not sinned in Adam's fall, but is a man of sound nature, whom gross temptations can- not assail. Consequently, he is blandly in- different to the little rules of propriety which are the fruit of social expedience or of social prurience Having suffered much from his fool of a wife, and come of any sympathy from her, he Circumstances “compro- per- The to despair her time society calls involving a leaves for a lead him into what missing fectly good girl, circumstances,” young actress a wife, belleving everything againat gO | back to he pa r girl is sul to scandalous 1 ) ' istr isly f ed by } inager Self-respect f t t leay ! ag and further cir i throw ! as upoa he y of th " Be ving self finally abandoned by } wif and feeling the appeal of ! git helple s and us ! abou t I me h pr or \\ the w | ’ nirking ~ ©) when ! iden \ lg ha nis wile s » bea h “A hild recalls him, not to submission to the pa h point of view, but to a renewal of the relation which he himself could never have will ingly dissolved rhe story, we think. would iv be mo powerful if not mor lia y effe ve f Ss tone had been | ligt nd t al We ire in danger of f ! ng ourselves th im i than a | by he 1V rf t s latio I ild perhaps, be « gh tha are yd r Meaningless person reven ind tha a deepe no em » sound benea th eb! and rs of t ‘ nedy | Th Breath f the Ru I Ma Mea New York bre \ \ k Co Fates of the artist emperame and the Bohemian life continue to multiply 7 parently the market for that kind of modity continues firm Ju now (perhay The Divine Fire’ set the fashion), no story of the order is complet without it pi duction of one or two ma terpiece by } gifted hero or heroine, or both It not enough that we should observe the artistl temperament in its rather lamentable minor incarnations struggling along the high road toward the goal of a _ decent mediocrity We must find productive gen lus presiding over whatever shabby tudio we may chance to peer into, and a great work upon every second easel. We a t quired to love the smell of paint and tl studio jargon, and to snatch a fearful j from the spectacle of one or othe pair of young idiots of different sexes being uncon ventional over a pint of wine in some snuffy café This, it appears, is Youth, and Art and Life These young innocents are all after Fam or Glory, and most of them “arrive or ‘succeed.”’ The standard of success is. to be sure, not very exacting; one has to dis tance a rival and make the critics “sit up and take notice.” “The Breath of the Run describes the race between two young and friends, for The writer has a serious ners” women, sculptors close this kind of goal “So long,’ reads the Preface, ‘‘as are centres of inflamed at normal activity into which types drawn and set acting and reacting upon one another in a relentless and incessant strug gie to attain preéminence, just long the parable in ‘The Breath of Runners’ must have weight.”” What | American girls purpose and our cities ) all are 80 the the contained parable? Two poor make their way to Paris and the inevitable Quar tier. One is honestly in pursuit of excel lence; the other desires to be praised, and particularly to be praised above her friend masterpiece I hen Fach the expected and is given place in the year’s salon which the author produces something happens
Page 18
418 gard is tragic, but which te us seems nearly farcical Enid, the self-seeking rtist and faithless friend, has made a luriog group of a death-angel giving a cup i dying soldier The angel mysterious ind buoyant, is gay even to laughter Her eyes meet the observer with a deep, inex plicable mirth, and like the eyes of some picture they follow him wherever he oes This work, at first hailed with ap plause, is presently pronounced = by the ritie as sensational and insincere The xroup represents not the Joy of death, but the Joy of life rhe other girl's work grows nu favor Enid determines to prove the sincerity of her work, and, according to the suthor, effects this perfectly by drowning herself in the Seine The critics take it all back, and the immortal merit of the manifesta work is assured by a supreme tion of insane venity! If it were not for this absurd person and the incidents which concern het the novel would be excep tionally good of its kind There is plenty of material in the story of Beulah Marcel really credible and desirable woman, and her experiences of art and of love, without esorting to the motive of morbid rivalry Henvy Northcote By J. C. Snaith Boston Hierbert BO Turner & Co rhirty four out of the thirty-olne chap of this story we read with seant pa tienee rhe narrative passages are written in the worst style imaginable, turgid, af- tected, diffuse, with a minimum of gram matical soundness and a maximum of rhe orical effort Why not demand it with all the fervor of his nature, like others who had sought their opportunity had done so often?” All the subtle imple- ments of his nature could not resolve such 1 potency as that.” And so on. For the substance of the story not much more can be said. Most of the characters are shad owy nuisances, and the hero ts a fantastic bore There is much fumbling at psycho- logical analysis of nothing in particular, and much detailed reporting of what is de- lured to be the matchless eloquence of the cheerful Northeote We might be reading he first literary effort of some grocer's lerk whose literary enthusiasm hung fire between Marie Corelli and Anna Katherine (ireen it is only the hope that the latter really the presiding genius of the pnarra- that carries us through those thirty- four chapters We seem to be following hough at @ enail’s pace, the scent of some Northcote, a brief for Henry receives @ mystery half starved barriater the defendant in a murder trial The ac used | s prostitute, who has killed he: lover of the moment under singularly brutal circumetance Northcote’s speech in her lefence is @ tinsue of lies and sophistries, but it wine the verdiet And here, some three-quarters of the way through the lawdliog volume, a real atory begins. Out of all this verbiage and sentimentality emerge omething distressingly like the naked truth At his moment of triumph Northcote wakes to a sense of his own per fidy, and perceives to his despair that the price ‘of his achievement is moral wreck Hie has prostituted his youthful ideals and hie manly powers to the service of un- worthy ambition He has destroyed his faith in himself Outface it the faw was might, as he The Natio in himself It had been there from the beginning . Better a_ thou- sand times not be distinguished from the mediocrity he was never weary of despis- ing, than to be at the mercy of a genius that would compass his destruction In this hour of possible regeneration comes to him the woman whom he has saved from merited punishment She, it seems, is a victim of heredity and circum- stance, and with all her vileness not utter- ly lost. She looks to him with hope as the possible saviour of her soul as he has been of her body He is pitiless with himself and with her He tells her that he has saved her not in the hope of a higher justice, or in a spirit of Christ-like com- passion, but to advance his own fortunes He is no longer worthy or capable of the task which she proposes for him. So he extinguishes the last ember of soul in her, and she, reverting to the wiles of her trade, usurps his body. Having dragged him to her level, she wishes to die at his hand, and end He deliberately plans and effects of the deed, and the final own soul. Nothing re- his genius and his am- at length by foree achieves her then quite the concealment of his but destruction mains of him bition, and they are allowed to go scot- free. The brutal directness and simplicity of the means employed to effect this partial escape are impressive in a manner strange- logically at variance with the vague the narrative up to the of climax. However reluctantly, one yleld a book the due to a thing of crude force ly yet inconsequence of point admiration must to such Vary Stuart. By The Macmillan Jewels of New York Portraits and Andrew Lang Co $2.75 net all Stuart is uncertainties by which the Among the most the Mary enveloped two the authorship of Letters and the Queen's Lang, whose courage is above reproach, grappled with the Casket of Mary Stuart.” study of the per- state and hold,”” he says, “that some portraits do more than is vindicate Mary's character for beauty, and, above all charm. I shall be taxed with credulity but that is a charge which does not afflict me” One follows naturally the process of ex- the Marian por- as far baffling relate to Casket personal appearance Mr Letters in his ‘“‘“Mystery He traits his now brings to the usual willingness to defend a distinet opinion a commonly supposed to for clusion, and in ease of traiture it can be pursued almost as with the pictures ascribed to Leonardo interpa- dis- and Giorgione At the Glasgow Exhibition of played eighteen portraits or miniatures, of which Mr be spurious and misleading effigies” tioual 1gvl there were Lang at once declares fifteen to Moat of false these hopeless types that eighteenth represent can be traced to the seventeenth and centuries or even to a period the regency of nun-like remote than George lV The the lady with a crown and crucifix, not more “round-faced person,” Book-of-Beauty heroine, are all together with though this material was not used by min- iature painters for a hundred years after the axe fell at Fotheringay However, since Henri Bouchot will admit the authen ticity of only four portraits among the hundreds named after Mary Stuart, the the there, several miniatures on ivory Th. [Vol. 83, No. 2159 management of the Glasgow Exhibition did well to secure as many as three for which something can be said. Mr. Lang, however, is less skeptical than M. Bouchot. Distin- portraits of whose au- thenticity there is complete proof and that stand in the authentic portraits, he enumerates thirteen likenesses which have a _ true historical The list embraces three drawings, and a me- guishing between those close relation to value five miniatures, dallion two portraits, the authentie straight feature of all the long, nose is also known to had a rather long face. Most people believe that Mary Stuart was very beautiful, and un- doubtedly a large part of the interest be- stowed upon her career is traceable to this In the however, it uncommon degree of enthusi- fixed portraits is The Queen One low, have impression portraits, requires an asm to discover any sign of exceptionally good looks. Some of the devotional por- traits reveal dignity, but they are not the most authentic, and, like t“.e others, they are a long way from sug gesting beauty Yet the fact remains, as Mr. Lang has phrased it “Mary was eith- er beautiful or she bewitched people into thinking that she was beautiful.” For pur- poses of contemporary effect it made little her beauty was appa- this distance of time it besides, most of difference whether rent or real, but at is a matter of considerable interest to de termine what she actually looked like For ourselves we much prefer the crayon done in France be- No one seems to dis- sketches which were tween 1559 and 1561 pute the pedigree of “Le Deuil Blanc,”’ by Francois Clouet, and there are good grounds for placing confidence in the sketch of Mary, as Dauphine, by Jehan de Court The hardness of these artists is well known and can be allowed for. Ex- pression is their weak point But in the delineation of features they were careful and can be depended upon to furnish a pretty decurate chart of the face as well as a most punctilious reproduction of cos- tume and jewels. They give no impression whatever of the Queen’s animation or nat- urel, but the elements of physiognomy are there Mr. Lang Melville portrait the property of the Ear! of Leven and Mel- ville It has undoubted merit and claims to be authentic on the score of the jewels introduces The picture belongs 1559-60; the costume is 4as- cribed by experts to a earlier than 1572; while, in the the late Sir George Scharf and Lionel Cust, the style of painting bespeaks a period still in the because it is tukes a great interest so-called which it ostensibly to date not opinion of later Against these considerations Mr. Lang's strong point is that the jewels shown in the portrait are distinctly set down in the inventory of Mary's personal possessions and could not have been known to an artist of the seventeenth century On the question of date he is willing to yield a little, but he stands firm on the main issue It will be conceded, | think, that if the Leven and Melville portrait is not an orig inal, probably painted in France about 1660, it is a very good copy of such an original, and not an arch@ological recon struction of the seventeenth century The reason why this particular portrait merits Mr. Lang’s championship is that it
Page 19
Nov. 15, 1906] has a glow of life which one does not in the crayons of and Jehan Court. But even allowing essential au thenticity, the of Mary from temperament than her Especially of the Queen's jewels this study is a valuable addition to who have the ad Scottish antiquarians get Clouet de its must charm Stuart have come he rather from features in its account the knowledge of all not vantage of being Making of Spain New Scribner's 4 Queen of Queens: The Hare by By Christopher Illustrated York Sons Imported Charles $2.50 net first last picturesque The the bourgeois meets if he places he brings them himself the the somebody's son, his and difference: he old Catholic no drop of unchristian blood, or he cretly of Oriental inheritance from Hebrew or the ehurech with Rome Cid of chair above that of Spain did the knight gallant and follow chronicler The history of Spain and gives for writing of and admirable s« ope commonplace neve! its historian has common Distinction if of not blood with 1s note; even peasant has sense is an is sSe- proud his Arab ancestry. So, too equally the stands apart treats Rome _ yield endure the And not without cause there and makes legend cannot papal last errant run his if wander- of the melancholy of that noblest before Don career ideal last ages the of were and the the ing fires, of close spirit middle in and record the crown tale centuries irony period with its son Good two to pass the Quixote’s that brain-struck modern world appeared and laid again in rest; and over idealistic figure the And the awakening Spain there stirs the same spirit of distinction letters, and life It may give ours of comfortable lance space the most is Spaniard now in in art in in visions far removed from subjection to the opin jon of the many, but the commonplace can- not rule it If, in Oriental fashion, there is unrest and disturbance, there is, too Oriental color and spontancousness As a seeker of the picturesque, then, Mr Hare from his Italian studies to the story of Isabella the Catholic. Her and her fortunes he frankly regards as such he makes no claims, we take it, to independent historical Rathe guided by previous leanings, he has endeav- ored gain such familiarity with achievements and her may enable him to put all these vividly be- fore the more casual And the ma terial has answered to his hand. We here, if not a minutely and conscientiously scholarly, yet brilliant, an intelligible, and a fairly correct picture of her and her times. The first fifty pages are given to Moorish Spain from the conquest until the birth of Isabella in the little walled town of Madri- gal in Castile. From this point there is a wealth of illuminating detail. If we cannot be sure that the elaborate disentangling of the devoted has turned material; research to her entanglements as reader have a motives is sound, evidently sound are broad sketches of the and queenly Isabella herself; her enigma of a husband, a strayed figure from the Italian characte! Renaissance, uneasy in the simpler Spain; her daughter Catharine of England, a child in a foreign land, driven to set her wits against the unscrupulous keenness of Henry matte | sistent Columbus; The Nation. VIl.; Henry VII Ferdinand; Margaret of Austria, now marble the of Brou; the Cardinal Mendoza of Granada, and the Inquisition Queen only himself a fit opponent for lying in in church per the Polyglot and long surviving At the “the Mad permitting her Charles V seek Moorish figures the rest Juana, la loca dying in 1555, and son the his cell shadows fi at last Emperor If the tting to rest in mere across stage no other historian has succeeded in making them real. In all treat- this of the last like a fight with the puppet They the littl make ments war reconquest looms ghosts, or at best with of a romantic leg of far heroes of historians of Spain have knowledge could live end were an alien world, one which had no ao direct and in wise to and among them no great personality stood out with the convinge ing reality, as had done earlier Saladin Not even created Boabdil, fate his last battle for his own, strikes no such tragi great refusal of Culloden His sigh a is pathetic himself, interest missing his true in note as the Charles Edward at last might come But are from an opera the and the the Ferdinand'’s scheme all the on Spanish side events always stage The re New World, of European empire definits subject and is the great weighty plain that world is conquest, Inquisition, the are unravelled hers though they are The breaking dignity, Spanish character facts, even to the pic- of Spanish as made outburst turesque great energy, the into a life, the ference Mr successful new over-Seas dif make and all and essential force of the Hare's treatment That adjectives is only natural still scientific, whom Isabella the Catholi off his feet. That he read his proof-sheets is another be illustrations possible even he is somewhat given and that his en high natural would thusiasms The truth run 1s be more historian in sad would seems hard- not carry ly to have to balanced perhaps by the ex cellent tes York {1 History of Higher By Charles F I) The versity, a Kducation Thwing, LL.D Appleton & ¢ $3 net of Western graduate wa New ica Uni ve president Reserve of Harvard thirty ars ago, has rendered a good service to the of by stu dents education, in this country and abroad the preparation of an historical full it does not profess to be exhaustive the of (not exclusive volume which is and comprehensive though He informs twenty-five of that us that it is result years’ study interesting problem of and other The For the however) most the origin and development American universities, colleges higher in stitutions of learning scope is wide and yet it is restricted example, the great scientific societies museums, ana incidental men of descrid- observatories the independent and Rockefeller intimation of during forty receive only tion; and foundations Smithson are not ed There in a future that all years,”’ is an however, history education, in grades in this country the which are briefly considered in this volume One-third of the the pre-revolutionary Harvard, William Yale receive the writer will discuss certain subjects devoted of Mary, attention volume is to period course, and but and mnost to | 419 Princeton Pennsylvania and Columbia come in for briefer notices and Rrowr Rutgers, and Dartmouth are not overlook fed Then follows an account of later fou lations in all parts of the ul vy. and ape ial chapters on Finance the Edueat of Women, Undergraduate Affat Profe sional Schools. Course f Study earl and = later with a t ef final é im? the general result f all tt © off . ind undertakings The volume very ! pages are enlivened t many 1 ‘ sketches of men who we i ' educational movement It fe n ’ K that in so wide a urvey there are sional slips on the part of the narra and that there are omission which tl friends of each inagtitution that ts an ! will regret The work should have bee more thoroughly revised There ia no at tempt to give a philosophical review ( the various forces which have contributed t the intellectual progress of the « i On the other hand, there is no othe vol ume which contains such a full account of the manifold, intelligent. self-denving. and successful endeavors of the American pe ple to secure for their vouth the bhighe advantages of liberal culturs It is fortunate that the endeavo tio =e cure higher education both in New England and in Virginia was developed in the very earliest colonial days, and that the college were established on the principles and with the methods of the universiti of Grea Britain These original college we | established in a period when the un versity idea was suppressed in Oxford and Cambridge by the growth of funds, discip line, and usages more stricty collegiate and it was long before the word “univers ity’ was used with any freedom on this sid of the ocean As the country increased in population and in resources, the English ideas, modified and adapted to new condi tions, were transmitted to every one of the United States, so that “the college repre sents to this day, from Maine to Califo nia, substantially the same conception. It rhwing brings out this fact especially in his narrative of the origin and growth of Southern and Western institution The original colleges were largely, but not exclusively, governed bv ecclesiastk Ministers of the Gospel were the educated class, and before lawyers, physician and the laity in general made themselves felt the ministry cherished and guided the in fantile establishments. This affords no rea son for regrets It was the best thing that could be done in those simple and impecu nious days Even now there are many whu prefer this mode of control, as is shown by the large number of denominational founda i tions established in recent years On the other hand, the establishment of non-se: tarian State universities in the original Northwest Territory has had a wonderful influence for good They have been free from ecclesiastical control, but they have stood firmly and effectively for the promo tion of sound learning and for the advance ment of theology being purposely professional training, schools of omitted third of universities has come to the front nell, Johns Hopkins, Chicago, Leland Stan ford, and Tulane are conspicuous examples munificence has establish- lhuring the last half century a class tor where private
Page 20
420 ed self-perpetuating boards of control, in- lependent alike of States and churches. On the whole, every patriot may fol'ow with Dr. Thwing his appreciative review, ejoicing that se much has been done, and on the whole so well done, for the support f higher education, the preservation of the ons of the past, and the encouragement f literature and science; and the support- of superior education are certainly iteful to the author for bringing together wh a ma of details on this important 1 Priced Lincoln Bibliography. By William H. Smith, jr Privately printed The interest among collectors in every- thing relating to Abraham Lincoln has been increasing of recent years, and as a ibject for collecting, books about Lincoln may even rival the older favorite of Amer iean collectors, books about Washington The interest in a line of book-collecting may be gauged, with more or less ac- curacy, by the number of bibliographies on the subject. The first attempt at a Lincoln bibliography was compiled by Charles Henry Hiart and Andrew Boyd, and published by he latter in Albany in 1870: “‘A Memorial i,incoln Bibliography; being an Account of hooks, Eulogies gravinges Medals, ete Sermons, Portraits, En- published upon Abra- ham Lineoln,” ete Bartlett's “Literature of the Rebellion,” 1866, should perhaps hav precedence, for, though covering a larger fleld, it included some three hun lred eulogies, sermons, poems, etc., on the leath of Lincoln In 1900, Daniel Fish of Minneapolis compiled his “Lincoln Litera- A Bibliographical Account of Books | Pamphlets Relating to Abraham Lin- coln,”” published by the Minneapolis Pub Library The next issue of this char cter appeared from the Government Print- im” Offee in 1903 A List of Lincolniana he Library of Congress,” by George homas Ritchte The latest contribution is \ Priced Lincoln Bibliography,’ compiled Villiam H. Smith, jr. There is also an ced for immediate publication a new ind much enlarged edition of Mr Fish's ol to be ealled this time a “Lincoln Hibliography.”’ This latter was prepared publication in the Gettysburg edition Lincoln's work and only forty copies 1h te ued separately, each to be inter 1, for additions 1 comparison of Fish’s “Lincoln Litera ve) Ritchie's List,”’ 1903, and mitt l'riced Bibliography,’ 1906, does h in it should, that the last is ! ! If th author had called it a 'riced Liet of Books about Lincoln” tn lofa “Lincoln Bibliography,” he would hay lone omething to disarm criticism \ bibliography it 1 not The titles are ih condensed, and in some cases badly mndensed, and many of the collations are faulty The prices will doubtless be a ineful guide, but while they are sald, “with ry few exceptions,” to be those paid at uction, nothing ia sald as to the condition of he book or the circumstances of the ile, and In no case is more than a single price noted In some cases several coples of the same book have presumably been sold, but whether the price given is the highest or the lowest or an average, Library of Congress we know not The The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2159 “List” is the most accurate bibliographical- ly, and naturally, for no books were de- scribed except those directly before the cataloguer. The titles are sometimes con- densed, but condensed according to well- known bibliographical rules. In Fish’s book the titles are transcribed, generally at full length, and the collations) are full for the most part, from the books themselves. The collations of some books, not seen by the compiler, are faulty. In Mr. Smith's “Bibliography,”’ no printer’s or publisher’s name is given; explanatory matter, which by Fish was inclosed in square brackets to indicate that it was not on the title, is sometimes printed without the brackets; and the preliminary pages are, with pos- sibly a very few exceptions, omitted from the collations For example, where the Library of Congress “List’’ gives the col- lation as “‘xiil., 476 pp.”’ and ‘(2), xv., 471 pp..”” Smith says only “pp. 476” and “pp 171." These are not isolated cases, some fifteen cases having been counted among the entries under B alone. Smith’s “Bib- liography” in its 64 pages of books con- tains something like 1,100 entries, but a considerable number are more or less gen- eral works on the Civil War, and volumes of verse containing one or more poems on Lincoln. Taking the entries under the let- ter B as a basis, the Ldbrary of Congress “List” (excluding references to collected works) shows 89 entries of books actually in the library; Fish’s 1900 list contains 105; and Smith's compilation, excluding general works, bibliographies, volumes of verse, and a few such books as “ ‘Old Abe,’ the Live War Eagle of Wisconsin,” which are dimly and distantly Lincolniana if such at all, contains 119 entries. Several of these are books issued during the last five years The Principles of English Verse. By Charle- ton M. Lewis, Professor of English Lit- erature in Yale University. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $1.25 net So far as it goes, this little book is ex- cellent Apparently it is made up from the lectures, more or less recast, which have proved useful to the author’s stu- dents in verse-composition. The style is informal and readable and the treatment is marked by good sense and great clarity; clarity and good sense combined are alone enough to give some distinction to a work on English versification. Of originality the author does not claim much. The general line of procedure is indicated by the chapter headings: “Rhythm and Metre,” “The Pentameter Line,” “Blank Verse,” “Rimed Pentameters,” “Miscellaneous Me- tres,” “Embellishments of Verse.”” Some clever demonstrations are furnished by partly rewriting well-known passages in a way to illustrate the points in question. The serious defect which led us to begin with the cautionary phrase, “‘so far as it touches the very Lewis's doctrine of goes," unfortunately, Professor which is perfectly sound, but basis of rhythm, which requires an addition to make it adequate. “Rhythm may be roughly de- fined,” be says, “as a recurrence of similar phenomena at regular intervals of time.” He goes on to set fortn admirably two well established principles. First, the rhythm of speech, in verse and prose slike, is merely one manifestation of our instinctive tendency to give a rhythmi- cal form to all recurrent muscular efforts. Second, our wsthetic sense rejects, after early childhood, a rhythm that is too mechanically perfect; a certain de- gree of conflict between the ideal scheme in the mind and the actual series of sounds, which plays about and reveals, but seldom reproduces perfectly, the ideal scheme, is essential to continued pleasure. Mr. Lewis also restates very well another important fact, that the place of a stressed syllable in the ideal scheme is often filled satisfac- torily by a syllable that Is normally un- stressed; the time is kept sufficiently, and rhythm is a thing of times. But ac- eepting all this, and returning now to the ideal scheme, is the rhythm of our verse adequately described by saying that the stressed syllables recur at equal inter- vals, and that the number of intervening syllables is limited thus or thus? Mr. Lewis shies at the notion of the foot in English. He is willing to use the ancient terms, dactyl, iambus, and the rest, in the modern naming of syllabic groups; but since “feet are not organic elements of rhythm” (italics ours), he concludes that “analysis of verse by feet is like analysis of pictures by square inches.” But the illustration is imperfect and migs- leading. He should have taken, not a picture, but a design that is really analo- gous to a rhythmic scheme—as a meander, a Dorie frieze, a Bokhara rug. Designs like these can be analyzed only by a process very like the analysis of verse by feet. But a better comparison is with music. “The single melody is the molecule of music, the smallest element in it that cannot be subdivided without loss of character,”’ says William Gregory Mason. But the musi- cian would laugh at the idea that analysis of music by measures is like analysis of a picture by square inches. The foot and the measure alike are real units in the rhythm of verse and music, respectively. Without such a unit there is no rhythm. To describe the measure, to indicate the relation of its parts to each other, is the first step in describing a piece of musical rhythm. Shrinking from the analogous step in de- scribing verse, Mr. Lewis has no means of indicating some of the commonest pheno- mena—for instance, the obvious difference of rhythm between The world was all before them and To bicker down a valley By his traditional method both alike are Nor can he indicate the characteristic rhythmic type of such lines as these: Hame came my gude man, and hame came he. John Brown's body lies a moldering in the grave. Who found me in wine you drank once? Tt is not enough to say that frequently there is “no light syllable at all between stresses.”’ In short, having once recognized that rhythm concerns time-intervals, why need one fear to take the next step, logic- ally inevitable? The time-relations between the syllables in each group are what chiefly characterize each kind of rhythm. Without the notion of the foot there is no way of clearly marking or describing rhythm in verse, as there is no way of describing musical rhythm without the measure, or bar. Mr. Lewis's definition of rhythm is both clumsier and less complete than the _ | BVM a="
Page 21
Nov. 15, 1906] ancient one, “a regular arrangement of time-intervals."" The foot is a group of times which by repetition, with or without variation, characterizes and measures & longer series. The relation between up- beat and down-beat, arsis and thesis, with- in the foot part of the characterization the ancient marks of sense and mark the as is an essential If in we use their original rhythmic stress by acute accent, then the feet we divide music by the bar, the first quantity ictus or and divide two examples above are vv and v| S- v| s-]| The in This notes the differences accurately of the group all time, up-beat down be Why reject a method so simple and take this a book to examples second are even and beat ing equal adequate? If Mr. one logical he might give which would to all penetrate it, the whole heart of the of English verse-rhythms Lewis could step, us reveal, who care mystery The Passing of Korea. By Homer B. Hul bert New York Doubleday, Page & Co $3.80 net Books on Korea may be named by the aozen but this is the book Professor Hulbert has the genius of research. What ever is Korean interests him, and during two decades he has sought knowledge in every direction, from nursery rhymes and verbal folk-lore to private manuscript and printed encyclopedia Having founded the Korea Review, he has been not only edi tor, but chief contributor What our own S. Wells Williams did for China, he is do ing for Korea, and the present volume is the result of personal observation, literary research, intelligent industry,and of the co operation of native scholars His style is bright and rapid, his examples and i! lustrations from personal experience are abundant, and, happily for his readers, he has a sense of humor Sometimes, in deed, he seems to care more for fun than for severe dignity of style. On the Korean language, Professor Hul bert is an authority. In treating of litera ture, art, folk-lore, woman's position, man- ners and customs, he writes with easy command of resources. The book is hand somely printed, and there is a good index The pictures are all full-page, and ars from photographs, mostly new, several of extreme interest The historical narrative, which is con densed from the author's ‘History of Korea,”’ already printed in his Review though presented in very readable form, not satisfy all the rigid requirement criticism There The fact ancient does of or modern are no notes references however, that the field of the materials are is, in and media@val his tory not yet ready upon We me work of t sepa which a critical historian can cannot feel that Mr. Hulbert rated what of legend and tradition of sources these stretches in always carefully be called a actuality from There i examination of that ground in Japanese history seems to land the When modern history clear the has may reasonable view superabundant s slight proof of which any severe Chinese while most is solid be an he and ju unexplored to writer he is surprisingly comes to full, and, on whole | . > © t The Nation. 2 dicial We use our word idvisedly, for | spoken on the as 1, in any « 1 Mr. Hulbert does t eal the fa tha more radica t 1 he has all along, and s s with heat at a rR protested agair s K a by ’ by a s j } Japan; he even « ie I is es he a { N ‘ and acted in Wa R i K , Empero S priv é \ i x z hay yn tl de f Japa “ extremely o1 led \ uri that the one fo he t The attem teed is Ss from ha l f ‘ 4 cried I ly M } YT? ' t was Vaganza ef! led The New Far Eas llustrated } rey f Rrow Ww tix hict ‘ ‘ } 4 quota which s at g's drama il po Pippa ft irdity to thos who know Jay f ly e Maje I att 1M lay af n M Yet with all deductic his work | The proje« { the | ' entueiae le 1 ill books on Ke nhne f leserve credit fi t irag t ‘ y formation, and the n j ) t \A ! i f | g " author's broad-mindedt H s iz " with , Korea in gain nothing ? ! ling back zy and complicated era singu ind off ng to the | fy ia KY irly lacking } shere ind ju P ‘ ince rl i f vith a , ewes - - a all . » Vital o acted drama and 0 v ality f the force vt ht gt t cha . f ‘ ful perf na ‘ } conditio " vl I 1 brillian interpretat f tex His conclud v " h : } 1 vocal real i of . lagery ind a ° | i for education and Am clarifica n of its more re ndite pa igen ind a vivid portrayal, amounting irnation, of the leading characters N | ) ° if these requirements was fulfilled on this ‘ ‘ Padha. sion. Mrs. Le Moyne has long been know an effective and intellige ! Kut A Comedy in Fe \ By Brot of Browning, t he has 1 t 0 son Howard New York Hary & ' mbodims ol , 7 ‘ Brothers. $1.25 ' t of such a | as tl ; nehantress O n witl her f y | After a prolonged siler Brot How yn and ipple zg S! \ 4 ' ’ ard comes forward with I I itional . witl uff ent lo« ary kill. but comedy in four acts, called Ka } 1 pa on and pla gr Tr Ss | sented in narrative form hat to say I vi) ' . f V liam 3 1 wa ut r ale i dialogue is pieced togethe by tl aid of the ; . rt e was n b W f fe r l stage directions and yther explanatory or ‘ ' the | of Cc} G , ; lescriptive matter with which the | I h Pr} of Ele i Leigh had date dramatist eke out the lim 1 ir . quality to a } for tl p wl } igination of the modern actor it i play ‘ nt 1 ¢ ‘ ‘ Mabel 7 f V | j | with a moral which, reduced to it my ‘ ; | ; » whose a 4 full of pr r t expression that marriage “ ey 4 f I f I ! t racted solely for the sake of money o he long ‘ liloquy of rank littl better than pro tutior iit ’ ’ } for } I 1 « Written in the vein of the best of his pre of expre rhe | ury t vious plays Aristocracy it exhib n r sinn ' 1 fell far ‘ ila virtue ind defects It show rt et nd pn hil n ! vation, inventivens ind timely purpose , ; va wl ly " t } bea i ogether with a considerable amount of ippropriate and the m l ( co uctiv skill, but these good qual : ; paniment, w I William | t f t ire marred by an unfortunate extravaga rema ble for ‘ or both in types and incidents and an occa exhibited a f wi vn f g, and sional descent into rather crude sation was played t ! i f iT ilism . : lence f a th ‘ Few thoughtful persons will dispute the truth of the general proposition that mar The Ru in a Madame Alla iage without nrutual affection is nearly al zit 1, wi I ‘ F ha ways unwise and very often degrading, bur | ready lished f herself a J it does not follow that a flery mutual pas ‘ iderable p niner on the local sion the sole and sufficient justification played English for the f t of the tie matrimonial Between love and Py ‘ I i on Tuesda if pa on the distinction is very wid and f he lid bATY ' leed—although they may be vexistent—but all diff Iti fully ju fled t! hoy f this fact some of Mr. Howard charac he may do ) A not re fu ters seem to be ignorant. The heroine, the appeared as Ibsen Hedda Gabler, a p r ‘ té t lovely daughter of an American multi-mil which has t a ar 1a . _ ‘ : 7 ‘ lionaire, is engaged to the heir of an Eng- | achievemer and marked } ' ' t +) ’ | lish duke, but is in love with his brother xious characte ad —_ = a clergyman, whom she encounters at a rid empha Tt ange z , ‘ masked ball where they gazed into each | Plainly @ great ha , other's eyes without ape iking Later on leliberatior wi I 1 i when she about to be married and he is | Melodramatic artif y, Dut a rig sold 1 engaged, they meet again and the flame | tion was original, bold, and kindled by that fatal glance is renewed, | !!lustrated at times rising Clq ose 1 gestur Her betrothed, it appears, has ruined one of pose and ¢ -" of his father’s dependents, and the com Miss Ellen Terry will begin her An plications lead to discussions of the mar can tour in January. According to present ige relation which could scarcely be! plans she will make her first appearance
Page 22
here ir Captain Brassbound’s Conversion,” ' he w have several other plays with he and likely to be seen in Portia and ovr . . The Pa heatrical eason has opened h tw ee ‘ one of which was bound ' have msiderable mer Both deal thoug? lifferently with the everlasting er ind it consequences The f'n igére by Capu who till the popula of high-cla amuse! in ! ive ! eve of adventure be falling husband o good-natured that his gh governm h wife mitlines mt his own cousin in need. to whom he wishe to do charit take him away from 1} wif whom he love larisian laugh even the penne personne, who, unde the new opine brought 0 uch plays The referee of Lucien Descaves ' epenite different full of the tragic emaotioar caused by the uncertainties of the i ne Feminine The hero has two danght of whom the younger is his “pre ferred ome busybody persuades him that he is me ! own, and the wife. already repentat through many long years, con fesse Hence much fine fury and the pack me off of mother ind hitherto preferred havaehte info oute pace—until the man f | hie ove the girl too much Dive | b Drama Soctety proposes 0 itions of the old ‘ ‘ } play ! he tv of Che i he ecured « consent of the mal wal authoritie The ‘i f ¢ mwey nd h bishop ! prot again iny uch | eoding on he ground that to many i" hie sill tee iflensive if not «ac las phemou MADAM HLTTEREFLY \ AN OPERA 1) f the me complete operatic flas vd wa hat of Puecini's latest ‘ } Madam Butterfly when i was f produced a Milan on February 7 of rhe ore was thereupon withdrawn os ind in the new version it ia itional succes n London ' with which it was presented led Miss Destinn and MM. Caruso ! ) no doubt was an important fa: The | formance of an English ver fiarden Theatre on Monday gh Iienry W. Savage Opera Com ff led the flret opportunity in th f wes r he merit ind demerit he t \f he first act It seem ‘ ‘ ! ind the Milan failure mn Ne | cceas but the econd h 1 act nade a more favorable im v tee ‘ iinty taged Mad mM Hhuttertl eautifu Phere i at eturesque 4 if Nagasaki lighted yp at nig med tt e are Full ind Bud dha 7 hoah ried Kitneone ind? a ona ! i ‘ ' ' ind herry ble " galore ly ne tee full of propeipa harm Iu int not only in whuce genuine Japanese ali bu oO hat monizes them as to emphasize their exotl quality Some of them recul The Nation. and by this repetition gain much In other respects Puc- cini has learned from Wagner—in the art impressiveness saturation of his score with vol- effectively for singers as well conductorship of Walter sand dollars that of any of the other sixty- (with the codperation Boston Symphony the more significant man of mere polish and energy and misplaced accent, like Paur; o1 two composers Beethoven's fifth symphony and three Wag fried Idyll,"" and “‘Meistersinger” interpretations pi oved a great In the “Siegfried Idyll" one as leading | climaxes, so to speak, with the aid of which [Vol. 83, No. 2159 Seidl used to make this sinfonietta do- mestica seem so beautiful. At the Satur- day afternoon concert Dr. Muck proved himself an excellent Brahms conductor, and there was more poetry in his interpreta- tion of Weber's “Oberon” and ‘Freischiitz”’ overtures than in any of his performances at the first concert. There was a time when pianists had to stoop to conquer; even the greatest of them, Liszt, was obliged, early in his career, to indulge in daring feats of vir- tuosity calculated to astonish rather than to exalt his hearers Rubinstein did not have to do this; nor has Paderewski ever done it. In this there ought to be a les- son for Moritz Rosenthal, who began his fourth American tour last Wednesday at Carnegie Hall For more than two dec- ades this Galician pianist has been famed for his skill in mastering difficulties, but a place among the greatest was denied him because technical skill was so much more in evidence than artistic feeling There had been reports from abroad that he had begun to curb his virtuosity and subordinate it to more musical impulses His choice of Brahms’s “Variations on a Theme by Paganini’’—an abnormally diffi- cult but absolutely empty show piece—and his playing of his “contrapuntal study in * on a Chopin valse, which degrades one of the loveliest pieces into a vulgar thirds’ show piece, seemed to indicate that the leopard had not changed his spots. Luck- ily, his interpretation of two concertos Chopin's E minor and Liszt's E flat major— revealed him in a far more favorable light. While he played these, no one thought of the technique, but only of the beautiful music and the exquisite art of the Iinter- preter It was authoritative playing— poetic, tender, graceful, and with an ad- mixture of interpretative genius. The grand opera season begins at the Metropolitan in Thanksgiving week. The programme for the first week includes “Romeo et Juliette’ (with Farrar, Plancon, and Rousseliére, who has taken the place of Jean de Reszke at the Paris Opéra), “Marta,” ‘“Tannhauser, and “Fedora.” Probably there will also be a popular per- formance of last season's success, “Hansel and Grete!.” The season at the Paris Opéra opened with an event of the first order—Massenet’s new piece, “Ariane,”’ with its libretto by Catulle Mendés. These two-—Massenet at sixty-four, Mendés at sixty-six—are vet- erans, each in his own art. Massenet has evidently striven valiantly to rise above the prettinesses of his prime. The poet, whose voluminous rhyming has often been too precious and easy, has now given the same care to a mere libretto which he devoted to the classical drama of “Medea,” all his own Art. THE NEW YORK WATER-COLOR CLUB The seventeenth annual exhibition of the New York Water-Co'or club is open at the American Fine Arts building, No. 215 West Fifty-seventh Street, till December 2. The J6L pictures are not as a whole above the
Page 23
Nov. 15, 1906] average of mediocrity The fashion re- mains in this exhibition, as elsewhere, to seek in water-co!lor effect but those characteristic of the medium. are plenty of effects of oil or pastel or but few amples of pure wash-drawing or handling almost any most properly There lithograph, very ex- that reveal transparent color and deft ness of touch An instance of the falsification that may come of overconfidence in the ‘“‘blottesque technique is the “Moonlight in Katwijk,” by Arthur Feudel, in which, as in certain atmospheric effects by Cazin, the surface of the house seems to be sloughing off a kind of luminous slime. Truer to nature are two moonlight scenes by Adelaide Dem- ing, which suggest with much charm through low tones indistinguishab'y rub bed together, the soft glow of dusk. One feels at once with relief, in turning to the two New England coast scenes by Childe Hassam, that one of the elements of their superior strength is their boldness of touch. The boldness, indeed, is almost bla- tant, but, with this reservation, the man- ner is a marvel of summary handling, and the pictures themselves, with a third, his “Newfields Village,”’ are unsurpassed in the exhibition of deftness, vivacity of color, and force in the presentation of a vivid and authentic impression Two scenes by George Wharton Edwards, ‘Early Morning —Monhegan” and “Irish Fishermen Enter- ing Port,”’ are fresh in feeling and suffi- ciently vigorous in handling. Three scenes by Fred. Wagner are remarkable for their pleasantly strong and crude color and for a certain blunt directness of drawing. Charles Warren Eaton is represented by several landscapes quiet in tone and Dutch in derivation. Several Moorish scenes by Ad- dison T. Millar show with an appropriately I simple handling a charming feeling for architectural quaintness “Pittsburg,”’ by John Edwin Jackson, is an interesting im pression The drawing in the background is too definite to give the proper suggestion of atmospheric vagueness, but the treat ment of the sordid homes in the foreground and of the children playing in the the put contrasting nearness of the homes and mills street 18 effective, and artist has into the something of its tragic meaning “The Fourth Watch,” by Charles Austin Need ham, representing Christ walking the waves, achieves an impression of mystery He would have achieved an impression of the miracle if he had made the waves look less like terra firma “The Mystic,”’ by Albert Prentice Button, is a delicate twi- light river view, sure in its gradations of tone. R. Wilkinson in the ‘Mission of San Juan Capistrano,’ and Alon Bement in *"1812"" strike quiet notes of gray and brown the gray and brown of old parchment. The feeling in interesting than its technica! accomplishment work is more this The figure pieces are fewer and of lower average interest than the landscapes. The Beal prize was awarded to M. Petersen for the ‘“‘Coppersmiths interior of a work- shop with the four or five coppersmiths at work. The lighting and values in this pic- ture are far from carrying authority, and there is on the whole life and inter- est in the same artist's ‘‘Fruit Sellers.” “Evening in the Park,’’ a little pastel by Alfred Feinberg, and two park scenes by Marianna Sloan show alert observation of an more The Nation. typical bits of city life Tw scenes by F. Luis Mora, ‘“‘New Americans” and the Spanish Fair in Goya's Tim« make with considerable cleverness a show of realism that keeps an eye out for theatrical effs tiveness A Study of John Burroughs,” by Mathilde de Cordoba, is, on the whole, the best of the few portraits in the exhibition In the November Bulletin the M »poli- tan Museum of Fine Arts announces im portant acquisitions A Holbein portrait of the Basle period, dated 1517, shows the master near his beginning In the strong shadow and a bas-relief in the background we see his keen attention to chiaroscuro The interest of a colossal Triton king ly like a Rubens, but probably by Van Dyck in his Genoese period chiefly tech- nical Artists will appreciate better than laymen what a splendid bit of flesh painting it is—solid, harmonious brilliant The Museur to increase its Egyptian col lection A. M. Lythgoe has been called from a curatorship in the Muse of I ‘ Arts, Boston, to take charge of this \ work Most of his me f the 1 1 ture will be spent in actual « ivations in Egypt In the department of classical ulpture the collections are the he by a marble statue of Eirene headles id armless, but of beautiful execu n being an early Empire copy of a Gree} original of the fifth or fourth ce iry, B Cc It is more attractive than dupl cate, the much restored Firene ind Ploutos of the Munich Glyptothek In the New York example, the style of the draperies is in every way more refined. as may be seen from the parallel illustra tions in the Bulletin Some eighty of the Whistler etchings and dry points from the royal collection at Windsor Castle, and some eighty others principally from the collection of the lat J. H. Hutchinson, are now on view for the month at Wunderlich’s gallery in this city The 161 numbers of the collection offer a comprehensive view of the scope and development of Whistler art on cop per Among the finest and rarest pieces are several examples of the Amsterdam series, representing Whistler's latest man ner. An exhibition of Rembrandt etchings, dry points, and drawings may be seen at Key pel’s gallery in this city There has been nothing for some years in New York to equal this collection of Rembrandt prints and though it makes no pretence to being exhaustive, the ninety examples are a larg: number to be found together in America They represent in proofs of beautiful quality the three great classes of Rem brandt prints the portrait the land capes, and the Scriptural piece It i interesting to note in this exhibition how much Legros, the greatest living tcher owes to Rembrandt The 102d annual exhibition of the Penn sylvania Academy of Fine Arts will open on January 21 and close on February 24 The exhibition of water colors, pastels, and works in black and white will follow in March J. Pierpont Morgan has given permis sion for a popular edition of the privately printed catalogue of his porce lains, loaned to the Museum This ad mirable handbook, prepared by William L.. Laffan inexpensive f In the ex Attica two light cavations at carried on by ephor have Doérpfeid'’ O.0388ai at 1a stalues As early as 1884 Dr. W has that this tions tarted under the supervision of Professor A. Salinas, the dire onal Mu , seum in Pals ie westera the three ans ghth gan to ¢ hoped light a sub rmo extremity of Sicily, wa ne trongholds to which the re tired seventh centuries the and tab that on when Gre remselv some if Vheenicla information . at the age his native city he reti before purpose of studying he ago Paris a little of painting For ten the war worked exclusively in the French tury and eighteer the Meantime n f Ps painted land native h uburbs o his puntry he negligence apes, whi whethtr from froma ramental inability he 0 temp left usual the incomplete condition of sketches horror, to But imipre ior group regarded |} light clearly relate him Hi ion of Corot he who landscape however is late reflect and in carrying or Corot tradition showed the way to revolted from A seTvative of the found iny young artists had impressionist formula exemplify - ing thus a somewhat con tendency which adopted some ts, he and qualities of the he ad and wise impressionis himself the of influence a school exercised a wide Samuel J. Kitson, the died in city last Friday at He was born sculptor the age of fifty- eight England, but he pursued most of his art studies in Rome where he became imbued with the relig ious spirit which marked much of his later He this im 1878 many prizes in Europe this in work came to country after having won
Page 24
4.24 The first ye elled bust f Samuel J works New York he mod- Longfellow, Bishop Potter Tilden, and are the Sheridan Va the fr Sailors’ Monument ir he was in others AQ yther M eze umer at Arlington, at the he Soldier ind medallion for Boston ind a ddral in SCLETIC®, rit MATHEMATICAI rrangement of ler of the chief gtory of the Tripos, as the Senior Wrangler, which of has been ut the century tt grea the against of men der pposition wa to this par re of the the the the forces most part honor who of ind kinds mathematicians work, while and scien aching mathematics had prepared tively t kind and who great ed subjects they were best Every one, how- necded of most Lust to know present conditions change was hat mit whole mathe the centred but for the azo here Twenty years beyond ele the the has t was around since then the those i rripos indidates rripos half n physics It Improve whil increased largely plan will restricting pure mathe- ring about a closer re and So ab Mathe the ipplied for p between pure he ition the prepar examin ‘ that can inclination to the ittle time or On other j not cla ed in the gineering Triposes, lectures cted who i or by tu never ele } ene certainly rripos of higher mathe mount i ' ' mathemattle y pure tudent physi« Fortunate fact sity the wher hey ¢ t he Univer by that irry thelr hhevtar through the caleulu 1882 of are imination ines candl ate for honors mathematt divi in 1 into vo part Men graded hon to the sul nightmare In generally who obtain irt |. are according with the Senior Wrangler at honor those who have obtained ent are eligible to that f examinations called Part II this there are four examiners, and who have been the bout as candidates many through ordeal So found willing to go The Nation. special and difficult are the questions that it is pure chance if a brilliant student an- swer one of them completely. of in first being able to get even a place class of Part II ” two years of residence, which shall be illed Mathematical Tripos Part I In this, dificultanalytical developments will be omitted, and stress will be laid on funda- mental physical and mathematical concep- Candidates will then pass on, either engineering, mathematics It is believed that in this way more pass the Mathematical rripos, and that the number of mathemati- the tions to physics, or proper men will through and old interests of research il teachers tained sired investigators may be re- at the to be de- the For the mathematical students who are to be teach- to be the The tripos level, a result in and igators there is Part Il will contain some elementary questions, so that invest Mathematical Tripos, as heretofore, the man whose mathe- matical ability is not of the highest and who will make a successful schoolmaster, can obtain his degree in honors. For the rest, it is a compromise between the “sec- ond four days’ of the present Part I. and the present Part II There will be no Senior Wrangler in Part I. with its element- ary subjects. ° The plan seems to be eminently reason- able. Cambridge since the time of Newton has about monopolized the teaching and writing in mathematics in England, and to- day students from all parts of the world come here to carry on this tradition. That the best mathematicians here, Profs. Sir Robert Ball, Sir George Darwin, Forsyth, Hopkinson, Larmor, and J. J. Thomson, are responsible for this reform, argues much its need and its success The Behavior of the Lower Organisms. By H. S. Jennings. New York The Mac- millan Co. $3 The tenth volume of the Columbia Bio- logical Series, entitled “‘The Behavior of the Lower Organisms,"’ by Prof. H. S. Jen- nings, brings together some of the most ent results in a subject known to the older naturalists as the study of instincts. Behavior, as understood by the author, neludes instincts as well as simple reflex movements, and also the so-called trop- ins or Orienting reactions shown by the lower forms of animal and plant life. Two opposed theoretical points of view are heid at present by workers in this field. On the one hand the animal is described as turning directly away frem or towards hence as orienting itself posi- negatively. This is the point of the tropism theory, advocated by follows the earlier this interpreta- by Jennings, who by many closely followed experi- that the orientation place the “selection of overproduced move- that by the method of “trial error.’ The behavior of of the lower animals may compared to that of a blind man who runs into a wall, backs iway from it, turning at the same time a a stimulus tively or of especially, view Loeb bot who inists Opposed to that ; m is maintained show | ments takes from ments,” Is, and one be little to the right or left, towards “a structurally defined side.” and then ad- vances again only to run into the wall at Nor does the Senior Wrangler of Part I. have any surety the The proposed change 1 relatively easy Tripos, taken after one | | | | } | | | . [ Vol. 83, No. 2159 a different point. He reacts again in the same way, and strikes the wall at a new point time he either finds the end of the wall and passes by it, or the turning may suffice to start him off in a new di- rection, when he continues to move for- ward in a straight line until he runs foul of another obstacle While the earlier writers looked upon external stimuli as cause of movements, Professor Jen- nings looks upon the movement as a neces- consequence of the “metabolic changes” that take place in the animal From this point of view external stimuli only prevent continuous movement for- the direction. Another general sized by the author is that the great vari- ety of behavior shown by the lower organ- In the sary ward in same point of view empha- isms depends on their ‘physiological states.’" Each motion or change of mo- tion, may in itself induce a change in the “physiological state’’ of the animal, so that a second time it behaves different- ly to the same external stimulus. This is only a general recognition of the famil- iar fact that a man after a square meal behaves differently from the same man hungry Applied to the lower organisms the idea appears to unlock many of the va- garies of their behavior. The older trop- ism theory looks upon the behavior of the lower animals and plants as stereotyped and regular, but Professor Jennings’s ob- servations emphasize the differences rather than similarities of behavior The life habits of ame@ba and parame- cium are treated in minute detail in the opening chapters; other infusoria fill the remainder of the first part. Part Il. deals with the behavior of the sea anemone and Part III. deals with the results described in the preceding chapters in somewhat more general terms Conflict- ing theories are weighed and analyzed The closing chapters consider the evolu- tion of behavior. Here the author points out that the experiences acquired by the individual may be transmitted directly to the descendants, wherever the descendants arise by direct division of the parent’s body a common method of reproduction of the protozoa. The wonder is, if such trans- mitted experience is possible, that these organisms have learned so little through- out the ages, and that still, after all their experiences, they go blundering ahead with their overproduced movements. As though appreciating this objection, the author ac- cepts the theory of natural selection as a more probable hypothesis of the origin of the behavior than inheritance of acquired characters; that kind of behavior the its alltes; the of the individuals that is most conforma- ble with survival being selected It is assumed that “random movements’ offer better solution of the complexities of a existence of the organisms than definite turning movements. However this may be, the fact remains that the animals con- tinue their overproduced movements de- spite the experience of each generation tending to short-cuts and to the selection of more definite modes of reaction. Professor Jennings’s admirable preseuta- tion of the results of his observations in this most attractive field of study will ap peal to professionals and laymen. The style of the book is clear, straightforward, and convincing. Some repetition of state-
Page 25
Nov. 15, 1906] The Nation. ment seems necessary, and may serve to emphasize the main points The American Association for the Ad- vancement of Science will hold its fifty- sixth meeting in this city December 27 to January 1, with Columbia University as the place for most of the sessions. In addition Association, about twenty hold Among to the American affiliated societies will at the American Society of Naturalists meetings here them the the same time are Astro Amer the Geologi« nomical and Astrophysical Society of ica, the American Society of America, the Botanical Society American Physical Society Chemical Society, the al of America, the Society for Horticultural Science, the Society for the Promotion of Agricultural Science, the American Society of Zoélogists, the Association of Economik Entomologists, the American Society of Vertebrate Paleontologists, the Society of American Bacteriologists the American Physiological Society, the Association of American Anatomists, the American An thropological Association, the American Psychological Association, and the Ameri- can Philosophical Association The first general session will be held at 10 o'clock Thursday morning, December 27, wheu the Prof. C. M. Woodward introduce the president retiring president, of Washington will of the meeting, Dr. William H. Welch of Johns Hopkins University At night the retiring president will deliver an address, and the trustees of Columbia will give a re- ception. Friday evening is reserved for din- ners and meetings of special societies and groups On Saturday afternoon, in the American Museum of Natural History, will be the unveiling of ten marble busts of pioneers of American science, the institution by its president, Morris K Jesup. In the evening there will be a re ception at the New York Academy of Medi- cine, with an exhibition of prog- ress by the Academy, including demonstra- tions and the of the se presented to scientific short addresses In course be held ssion meetings will also at the New York Botanical Garden, the Rockefeller Institute of Medical Research, and the College of the City of New York The American Association is divided into ten sections. The officers who will preside over them at the coming meeting are as follows: Section A, mathematics and astronomy Dr. Edward Kasner, New York; B, phys- ics, Prof. W. C. Sabine, Cambridge, Mass.; C, chemistry, Clifford Richardson, New York; D, mechanical science and engineer- ing, W. R. Warner, Cleveland, O.; E, geol- ogy and geography, Prof. A. C. Lane, Lan- sing, Mich.; F, zoélogy, Prof. E. G. Conk lin, Philadelphia; G, botany, Dr. D. T MacDougzel, Washington, D. C.; H, anthro- pology, Prof. Hugo Miinsterberg, Cam- bridge, Mass.; I, social and economic sci ence, Charles A. Conant, New York, K physiology and experimental medicine, Dr Simon Flexner, New York The official speakers will be Section A, W. S. Eichelberger, United States Naval Observatory, Washington, D. C.; B, Henry Crew, Northwestern Uni- versity, Evanston, Ill.; C, C. F. Mabery, Case School, Cleveland, 0.; D, F. W. Me- Nair, Michigan College of Mines, Houghton, Mich.; E, William North Rice, Wesleyan University, Middletown, Conn.; F, H. B Ward, University of Nebraska, Lincoln, Neb.; G, Erwin F. Smith, United States Department of Agriculture, Washington, D. C.; H, George Grant MacCurdy, Yale University; I, Irving Fisher, Yale Universt- | | tory | directs attention to the fact ty; K, William T Institute of Technology Sedgwick, Massachusetts Bost« n One of the expeditions sent most important out from Harvard U: ity in recent years is being organized by Peabody Museum fér the object nformation the litth n the eastern about s located Andes oO slopes Mountains in South Ameri f the of I a The absent which i be anthropology members s to be wc who Mi! A physi- about three yeat will Dr Farabee, instr ill head hau, ‘06 ill ters of the Peru uctor in the a and J also Ww expedition; Louis J e Ww be expedition w Hasting 05 rhe at W included headquar ill be cian Arequipa Ameri party s South The ne where Harvard has it astronomical observatory seek t headwaters This Ame rican scientists it only a an reach the tribes ar the the never will o of has Amazon and Parana region been iversed by and the reports upon by Europeans are and relate of meagre small part the territory A complete report of the German expedi leadership Dr. Ro Abyssinia, is to be published the the title “Eine he Ab with about The expedition tion made under the of sen to in future under deuts« near Gesandschaft in ssinien,”’ 160 illustrations consist- ing of nineteen Europeans, traversed some 2,000 kilometres other the Gala Blue Nils visiting, among he the ancient headwaters Aksum places districts of the The International Commission tific Aeronautics held fifth Milan during the first week The members visited Pavia and of Scien conference of On where M the observa tory, and liberated two ballons At of the Dr. Erk necessity of making ascents near or the Alps, nomena, its at tober Gam- ba conducted them through sondca one sessions urged tne among in order to study local the the phe In value such as Foéhn of of ballons-sondes and kites for atmospheric the bal- Professor a discussion relative study to a height of 5,000 metres by considered Rykatchew Ame an given by Prof director of Blue Hill Bort gave expedition to the Atlantic, and strongly urged kites Gen loons were Hergesell, while far preferable were as M of Law by and Berson ascents A Observa A paper on ri ballons-sondes rence Rotch M account was Teisseren de of the regions of by Mr Rotch exceedingly the an equatorial organized himself, good results were far over from which lowe I the obtained In upper air tem peratures were recorded Equator than at corresponding heights in temperate latitudes, a result contrary ill be to expectation Future conferences Ww held every three years The H. Turner of the the f University April the with proof-reading Prof Ob recently published Oxford year ending that report 0 H servatory for 30, 1906, work ing staff is chiefly busy of the Oxford section of the “Astrographic Catalogue,”’ and little new work has been attempted The catalogue will consist of eight volumes, of which the first is now practically ready, and its printing begun. It contains the measures of 66,000 star-images on 160 plates. Among other scientific papers contained in the seventy-third annual report of the Royal Cornwall Polytechnic Society, is a AR: verbatim account f ‘ ‘ 8 Norma Lockyer’s lecture An ka Chay r History of Cornwa li xpla ha the work he ha Augu 1 wit ‘ the i pine ! i evidence ‘ ~ ! ady that their erect j ! itarian necessity dar by observa ers In his 0} lo ‘ amply confirm from the study of Ez tographs f the | Hurlers and rh Mi shown in lante bles prove the w pose in the sight-! ‘ eve wi ‘ to local conditior he similar J. Philippe Lag i f e | Lyons, has been ap; ed by the Keuad Government a lirecto f the ot at Quito Or ‘ YT } p i iN i f ) in f At p ( t ‘ j f re i i il purpo fir i ley rate ha hose 1 Cr w! " ff for fu ‘ wa ‘ rod i n * ! i 1 ‘) | ry ib manu and va ) n qua tf wi I I b hrowt! ilo h i w f wha \N en ‘ i ] i ! I i Ww h ! pe l A mad iva b by ertain ba i i \ 1 pod iring p ia g len pea Fo yea cne ware rf bh i leple yn, have en, to draw on xhau ble ipply of almosy , gen It mu b n | lemica make ammonia (NH.), which bacteria co ver nio a form ble fo plant life n indergo } } nica lange produ r ‘ ame i I : Ba h , ‘ " ee rf 1 ) im i »> on i hen V . wi nh fs z h ) withou hang by i I yw be eved ia i i rd [ iz the ree f i 1 ed Two impo pay “ ‘ ‘ itly ead on I f Professor K. Birke l Farada Society 1 Londor } nd. by Profs ) lolpt Frank bef ! | ternational Congré of Applied Ct ! Rome rhe f pay was n the Birkeland-Eyd pro t Norway in which nitra f ‘ ide by « ire d harg he a Ihe nbination of the n } 1 oxygen of the air, togethe w iw nake he nits acid and ‘ i " asily ive l ) il im i i able for pliant food rhe ) 1 pa ‘ ‘ on the cyanamide | oe n Italy wh nitrogen distilled from liquid a passed ove@ calcium carbide in an ele fu nace, forming calcium cyanamide (Ca‘ ) This, with water, ylelds ammonia ga (NH.), in which the nitrogen | ndir y available for plant food. By an exten , of this process the oxygen of the 4 air, which distils at a higher temperature than the nitrogen an be used to oxidiz
Page 26
The Nation. below the 25 per cent. dead-line. A brought market's currency reserv may be drained by demands of interior centres. by gold ex- ports, or by the accumulation of cash in the national Treasury Unless loans are cut down in a still larger degree, the 25 per cent. reserve, which is required in New York city, may thereby be impaired Or without any actual loss of cash, deposit lia bilities may be so increased, through the making of loans at a reckless rate, that the erve will be Ik than the legal ratio The outright drain on the reserves is worst n such panics as that of 1893, when bank lep ! " withdrawing and hoarding money; the undue expansion of loans is commonly seen in “boom times,” when ev ery one is speculating and borrowing, and the banks are providing the credits. In a the below 25 cent. may be “boom,” it is likely to result from reckless- ness Hence the the G either to do fall of the reserve per the panic wholly unavoidable; in the discretion on part of vernment authorities nothing or to force the offending bank out of business banks influences be- instance the were deficit by Money has indeed York partly by needs In the brought to a present not yond their own control been d1 New of active internal trade, partly by the Treas- awn from ury accumulations Since the beginning of August, however, the Treasury has de- posited $18,000,000 in the banks; and $40,000,000 gold has been imported; never- theless the cash reserve of the New York Associated Banks has decreased $35,000,000 But this is a perfectly familiar phenome- t occurs because, when non of the season ide is dull at interior cities, bank liabil- ities light, and, therefore, need for reserve money reduced, interior banks send cash to New York. They do so, not only because they no longer need the currency, but be- cause New York banks, which can lend on Wall Street at all seasons, offer 2 per cent interest for use of this money of interior banks. With these fresh reserves, the New York banks expand their loans. In prudent inking his expansion will be cautious, pecially as autumn approaches; because harvest, the interior bank will ask for cash again Tens of millions in ac- ual « ency must be sent to the farming distriets to pay off hands; in addition, the rade of a prosperous larming season re- quires that inland banks themselves should increase loans to customers, and hence, hould need more reserve money If New York banks have used these bor- in particular, if, they rowed resources carefully “interior demand,” on the eve of the have brought their reserves to a figure 10 or 15 per cent. above the bank law's minimum, the return of money is easy This year he New York banks did nothing of the ort In the middle of last August, re erve tood at only 25% per cent. of de- posits. With the banks in so weak a po tion, and with the largest legitimate in terior demand in the history of the country just before them, powerful Wall Street capital controlling certain important bank tarted a stock speculation of such magnitude as to strain all the credit re ources of New York By September 8, a deficit was reported. With the help of the Treasury and the foreign markets, a sur plus was restored; but it was perfectly evi- dent that only by abandonment of Stock [Vol. 83, No. 2159 Exchange speculation, sale of the stocks jacked up with borrowed money, and con- sequent reduction of bank liabilities, could normal conditions be restored The gam- bling millionaires had no such intention; they continued their operations; as a re- sult, in spite of help from Europe—at pres- ent apparently cut off—the banks are again below the required reserve. One hears occasionally, even among intel- ligent people, that the 25 per cent. reserve is “for use when needed”; and that, since at this moment somebody needs it badly, commendable than Eminent finan- while the 25 enough for nothing could be more “dipping into the reserve.” ciers have suggested that, per cent. requirement dull midsummer markets, the ratio for the 15 per cent. or is well autumn ought to be put at less. This is absurd. The arbitrary 25 per cent. was fixed, not because that was ex- actly the sum required to meet a “run,” but because some line has to be drawn beyond which deposit institutions must not inflate liabilities. In 1857, when American banks largely arranged such matters for themselves, and when half of them had lost their heads in wild speculation, an al- most general bank followed. Government and people learned the lesson. The required for “‘reserve’’ cities might conceivably have been 15 per cent.; it might conceivably have been 35. What- ever it was, the business of the banks was to adhere to it Under the their successive deficits of the present sea- son have provided a chapter in American banking history of which no American can Suspension ratio circumstances be proud. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Edited Acton, Lord. Lectures on Modern History by John N. Figgis aud Reginald Vv. Laurence Macmillan Co. $3.25. Adams. Oscar ay. Sieut Patribus and Other Verse Published by tbe author, Baily, J. T. Herbert. The Lite of Lady Hamil ton Fk. A. Stokes Co. Barbour, Raiph Henry A Maid of Arcady. Phila delphia: Lippincott. Buskerville, Beatrice C. The Polish Jew, Macmil- lan Co, $2.50. Beard, Db. ¢ rhe Field and Forest Hand Book Scribners. $2 Beard, Lina- and Adelia B Things Worth Doing Ser. bners $2. Reet, Joseph Agar. A Manual of Theology. A. C. Son 4 Armstrong & : 5 net Benson, Arthur Christopher. Lbutton $2 Benson, EK. F. The House of Quiet let Paul Philadelphia: Lippincott. irch-Tree Fairy Book. Edited by Clifton Jobn sou Boston: Little, Brown & Co. §1.75. Black, John Janvier. Eating to Live. Philades phia: Lippincott. Bridgman, L. J. Seem-so’s. Boston: H. M. Cald well Co, Browning's Last Ride Together Putnams. $1.75. George R English Grammar. Macwil lan Co, 75 cents net, Cesaresco, Eugenio Martipengo and Training of the Horse hers $5.50 net. , 106 André Imogen. Santa Carpenter, The Imported by $1.25. Paris Dutton, Psychology Scrib- Dana Estes & Co. Un Crépuscule d'Islam. Claus's Sweetheart. $1.25 Chitlord, The Autoblography of Caldwell Co. $1.25. Fleming H, Kevell Mollie Lee. Polly: oston: H. M. Connor, Ralph. he Doctor. Lo $1.50 wk, | Wake Betterment: and Industrial, EF. A. Stokes Cooke, Willis A Kussell Lowell. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co Coupin, H., and Jobn Lea. The Romance of Ani mal Arts and Crafts. Philadelphia: Lippincott. $1.50 net. Crouse, Elizabeth. Day, George Kdward. A Wilderness Cry, c. M. Clark Publishing Co. Dickens's Sketches of Young Couples. Hl. M, well Oo Dickens Medis«e val Japanese 12s td, net Dickson, Individual, Social Co. $1.20 net Bibliography of James (eeorge Pott & Co Boston: Algiers James Cald and Frowde Primitive Henry Frederick Victor Feats. 2 vols Harris Gabrielle, Trangressor Phila delphia: Lippincott Duff, EK. Gordon The Kookbinders of Westminster and Put Stationers, Loudon Printers and name. §1.75 net Kdwards, Willlam Seymour Through Scandinavia to Moscow, COlneinnati: The Robert Clarke Co, $1.50 net, Oe ee re hms ‘ ‘ |
Page 27
Nov. 15, 1906] kee Co Philadelphia Everybody's Cyclopedia. F_ A. St Finnemore, John Foray and Fight Lippincott. Finnemore, John. Jack Haydon's Quest. Philadel phia: Lippincott Flagg, James Montgomery Why they Married Life Publish ing Co Fleming, Walter L. Documentary History of Re construction Vol. L. Cleveland: The Arthur H Clark Co Foster, John W. The Practice of Miplomacy. Bos ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. §$3 net Friendly Tow The Compiled by | \ l : Henry Holt & Co Gambier. J. W Links in my Life on Land and Sea Duttor $3.%) net Garrison, George Plere Westward Extens Harpers $2 net Genung, John Franklin of Wisdom Boston The Hebrew Literature Houghton ) Mifliin & ¢ $2 net George, Henry, jr The Romance of John Ba bridge Maemilian Co £1.50 George Hereford B New College 1856-14 Henry Frowde 2s. 6d net Glazier tichard 4 Manual of Histor Orna ment Imported by Ser'bners $3 net Grant, Ethel Watts-Muford. and others. Th \ together New Cynic’s Calendar of Revised W dom for 1907. San Francis Pa Eld & ¢ Green Allen Ayrault. The Good Fairy and the Bunnies Ch'cag A. C. MeClure & Ce Haldane, Josept Old Cronnak The Deck Pub lishing Cc $1.50 Hale, Helen Where Life is Rea Eator & Mains. $1 net Hall, Floren How Social Usaces at Washing ton. Harpers. $1 net Harlow. William Burt A Seor if Sonnets Springfield. Mass.: C. R. Kaplinget Hawtrey. Valentine A Romance of Ol) Wara Henry Holt & Co 1 Herbertson, A. J The Preliminary Geography Henry Frowde Hill, Constanc: The House in St. Ma s Street John Lane Co Hirst, Frances W Monopolies, Trusts, and Kar
tells Dutton. $1 net Hobbs toe R Zaos.—Gates of Flam Neale Publishing Co $1.50 He —- Thomas H Tit the Myst us I Stokes Co $3 ne Holland. Clive Thi Seen in Japar Dut 75 ceuts net Hopkins, Louise M. Signal Lights. Boston: C. M Clark Publishing C« Hopwood, Aubrey, and Seymour Hicks Bluebell and the Sleepy King Philadelphia: Lippincott Hoskins, L. M A Text-Book on Hydraulics. Hen ry Holt & Co. $2.50 net Howe, Samuel 4jridley The Letters and Journals of. Vol I The Greek Revolution Mdited by Laura E. Richards Boston: Dana Estes Co Huntington, Arria S. Memoir and Letters of Fred erick Dan Huntington Bostor Houghton, Mif fin & Co, $2 net Hyrst, H. W. G Adventures in the Great Des erts Philadelphia: Lippincott $1.50 net — is probably the most interesting, most comprehensive, and most authorita oan book on Panama will be issued Tuesday Four Centuries of The Panama Canal By WILLIS FLETCHER JOHNSON. With 16 illustrations and 6 colored inaps. 480 pp. 8vo, gilt top, $3.00 net. By mail 3.27. Johnson, author of “A Century of Expamion has been, since de Lesseps’ time, a close student of, and frequent writer on Isthmian Canal affairs, especially for the b New York Tribune and the London Times, and has studied them on the spot with Sec- retary Taft, to whom, by permission, the book is dedicated.
Just issued, a superb gift book for nature lovers The Log of the Sun About 250 illustrations (52 in color) by WALTER KING STONE, with text by C. WILLIAM BEEBE. net. Carriage 35 cents. HENRY HOLT & CO sei fis Pe : 3 : : :
The Man in the Case A NOVEL OF MYSTERY AND ROMANCE BY ELIZABETH STUART PHELPS READ SHORTY McCABE By SEWELL FORD
Johnson 8vo, $6.00 | | Studie The Nation.
Cliftor Highw s a Rywayes f the Mississippi Valley Mec ‘ 2 nv Krausaz, Sigmund A B. ¢ f Motoring Chi cag Laird & Lee Kra Sigmund Aut Re cr Ps I 1 & Lee Lamb, CC} amd Mary rales f s kespn t I by ) b I Kt ‘ Ml «ithe Fancif : s g. Hert ‘ ( . Robbe. M ‘ Swette : } I ‘ I s Edw ! I <i ; HW “ I $4 1 ve I I Moffa y 1& ¢ \ ! k's 1 h f | j ' \ ‘ ‘ X S ‘ I Krentano’s Williar \ M pt ‘) WW J W A ! | | | | ' l I \ ‘ He I I M ‘ $1 1 Y PF ilsor ‘ ‘ \ Id fu 1) i Lippir tt $6.m 7 t Hoek ! I f " 1 bw Seri ‘ Ready To-day. The Interpretation of Nature By C. LLOYD MORGAN, LL.D. PRS This thought treat that a belief in purpo ist reality of which nature 1 I iS not inconsistent witha ] hearted acceptan of th { iti of naturalism within their appropriat sphere. He contrasts two mod f j terpr tathor First, that whicl Nore outwards through human life as a<¢ and explains the world in terms of 4 pose inalogou to th purpo fon and, second, that which w k i from external mechanism to the huma brain with its a and ext a ‘} sociated n tal tal lains th univer i t natural law Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. G.P.Putnam’s Sons, 27 & 29 West 23d St., N.Y
Literary}IN PERIL of CHANGE & Social By ©. F G. MASTEMMA Studies | THE NEW HUMANISM By EDWARD } iL Fach
81 50ne FT R.W. HUBBER, Pobltisher, SY EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY Cloth, 5)
‘euts: leather. $1. 1 ie ” YEW YORK E. P. DUTTON & O00.
Page 28
[Vol. 83, No. 2159 The Nation. BOOKS OF UNUSUAL MERIG Special type design $1 50 ideals’’ ? by foreier scholar and writer Itme, cloth The “Ingersoll University of the arguments ges to a belief in Are we Americans ‘‘money mad’”’ and ‘‘devoid of These and other sweeping condemagations critics for the American Character | By BRANDER MATTHEWS | 8, 12mo0, cloth, 75 cents. Limp leather, net. (Postage #8 cents.) are here answered by an eminent The Hope of Immortality By CHARLES F. DOLE (Postage 8 cents.) Lecture,"’ delivered before Harvard year 1906. An able summing up which have induced mankind in all an after existence. 75 cents net Illustrated sides, 30 cents A pleasing little book packed with counsel and words of cheer, culled from great writers and arranged | for each day in the year. Success Nuggets In two colors from special type designs, cents net rhe well-known editor of ** Success’’ here collects some valuable little nuggets mined from many men’s experience, make the book one hard to lay aside. Daily Joy and Peace By ROSE PORTER 200 paces, 18mo. White back. violet ged Cloth, 530 cents. Limp leather, $1.00. By O. S. MARDEN 16mo, cloth, 75 Limp leather, $1.25 net. (Postage 8 cents. ) The original form and attractive pages I S propular sugurated a very few Four New Books, beautifully bound THE CHALLENGE OF THE SPIRIT \n intimate personal experience by a wel CHRISTMAS MAKING - \ holiday message from this optimistic a DOES GOD COMFORT ? of sorrows and trial PERSONALITY years is story OF \ ur POWER onymeo THE 12mo, 30 cents each. Postage 5 centa ) |-known writer who here uses an assumed name uthor is bound to be one of wholesome cheer s which yet led to the fight WHAT IS WORTH WHILE SERIES line of dainty little zift books has sold to the extent of hundreds of thousands of copies since it was in- The constant effort is to add new titles worthy of the series’ high reputation. ne practical hints by a practical writer on the value of personal appearance as a business asset. By Ellis A. Ford By J. R. Miller By O. S. Marden Send for Free Illustrated Book List THOMAS Y. CROWELL & COMPANY, 426-8 WEST BROADWAY, NEW YORK IMPORTANT A UTUMN BOOKS Ihe Secret of the Moor Cottage hy H RIPLEY CROMARSH 285 pages P e $1.25 at * new novel is A. ¢ 1 Doyle ta publ eu sity It is a story v iturally 1 ely vork u in i and | er writes Father Pink By ALFRED WILSON BARRETT 2u m6 pages Price $1.50 of the wily machinations of i seemingly harmless priest, in which large property rights are involved, including a hoard ed pile of diamonds, with eager rivals for the hand o 1 woman who owns the property in question The priest, as the cleverest actor ia the drama,is an unusually interesting characte’. \ lively narrative Latter-Day Love Sonnets Kidited by LAURENS MAYNARD Intimations of Immortality Cumpiled by HELEN B. PATtEN I2mo, 280 pages. Price $1.50 net. Postage 12 cts. wr ve. & Postage 10 « The brief but salient comments of the great achat 0 the Love Sonnet Series und learned of olden and modern times on Im e rilliant Love Sonnets of mortality—a compilation of remarkable diversity : ete of the |’ day and value, arranged under such topics as The : 4 ht tee a notable group of Testimony of the Ancients, The Speculations of a ued in the handsome | Philosophy. The Voice of the Church, The — | Vision of the Poet The Cheerful Cricket, and others hy JEANNETTE MARKS . 1) page Price be ! ce of din wi eatures of t n dull natural history ‘ ad ineident and netlon lellg fu languag wit? fas f lors The moet beau yw of tthe year English Iditerature Stella’s Adventures in Starland By ELBRIDGE H. SABIN Price $1.50 Svo, 175 pages For children it would be hard to find a more entertaining beok than this. Prompt action, frequent tocident bright conversation, do not allow curiosity to flag. Mercury the Messenger- lioy, Ul-Tempered Mr. Moon, Venus and her Sehool, Mr fares and Neptune are characters that, with the pictures, will delight any child. The Electric Theft hy NEIL WYNN WILLIAMS i £1.00 nod ft inalysl an « s| and nevel. but reas na * knit int tr a titante «etruggle ix ‘ » Make the very the al ef mastery — k well W while With Walt Whitman in Camden Ry HORACE TRAUBEL Ry M0 pages. Price $3.00 net Postage 20 cts This illuminating diary record has been truly likened » Bowwell’s Johnson in the fullness and’ veracity of the revelation of the poet's life and thought His conversations and wrespondence with a host of world-famous dally his “~ menof letters show afresh the breadth of his human ioterest and the acuteness and candor of his eritieal judgement SMALL, MAYNARD & COo., Publishers, Boston houty. th ROOK FOR BEVERY BODY EATING TO LIVE. FOUN J. RALACK, Mth) With apectal advice tothe mat and the Diabetic. Cloth, 61.50 net J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. NAPOLEON IN POLAND Accuunt of Campaign 1806-7 PETKE. With maps and plans ave 72 cente vo, 50 net. | JOHN LANE ©O., The Bodley Head, N. Y. By F. LORAINE Poat | | THE NATION FOUNDED IN 1865 A Weekly Journal Devoted to Literature, Drama, Music, Art. Science, Finance and Politics s The Nation aims to present from week to week a report of the intellectual progress of | the world, notices of the most important books, plays, musical events, and the princi- pal exhibitions of art, here and abroad, the development of science, and the significant movements in foreign and domestic politics. Its book reviews, its art criticism, and all its other articles are written by the most | competent specialists in America and Eu- rope. I he Nation stands alone in its field. It has a larger circulation than any other po- litico-literary journal published in this coun- try, going to all the principal libraries and reading rooms and into thousands of fam- ilies, The circulation is chiefly among thinking and substantial people—lawyers, physicians, teachers, clergymen, and other professional men; in short, it goes to the homes of culti- vated people. Sample copies for three weeks sent free upon request, The cost of a subscription for one year ts $3.00; for amy less period a proportionate rate ts charged. ws The Nation 206-210 Broadway, New York.
Page 29
sterile