The Nation 1906-11-08: Vol 83 Iss 2158

Page 1

— - eek _ The Nation CR, ~ _ VOL. LXXXIII—NO. 2158 THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 8, iy "2 dine es, EN CENTS. oe ; “ayy, 4 m0 GENFRA| LIBRARY, UNIV. OF Michi. NEW SCRIBNER BOOKS The First Forty Years of Washington Society From the Letters and Journals of Mrs. Samuel Harrison Smith (Margaret Bayard), Edited by Gaillard Hunt With numerous illustrations and portraits. 8vo, $2.50 net. Postpaid $2.70 Reminiscences and descriptions of Jefferson's Election, with the exciting contest with Aaron Burr determined by the casting of a single vote; Jefferson at home, both in Washington and at Monticello an intricate personal study; nae © Inauguration and the Inauguration Ball; Washington in the hands of the British (1814); Henry Clay personal and political reminis- cences and anecdotes; Jackson’s administration and its political and social excitements (Mrs. Eaton, etc.); Webster’s Reply to Hayne; Harriet Martineau’s visit to Washington; Prominent women of Washington Society, etc. BRILLIANT volume of reminiscences covering an almost untouched period in the history of the social life at the Capital. A The author was Margaret Bayard, who married Samuel Harrison Smith, the distinguished journalist who was the founder of The National Intelligencer, the oldest paper in Washington, and who by his position came in contact with the leading statesmen. Mrs. Smith had the social tact and political acumen of her family, the famous Bayards of Delaware, and her letters and journals give a vivid picture of her friends and of the great questions of the day. She wasa writer of books popular in her time, and consequently even the intimate letters to her family show decided literary grace and skill. Her life in Washington be- gan with the nineteenth century, and closed in 1840. Jefferson, Madison and Clay were among the intimates of her household. The literary foreigners who came to this country all went to Washington, and all met Mrs. Smith and are described by her. THE TEXT OF SHAKESPEARE SHAKESPEARE AND THE By T. R. LOUNSBURY MODERN STAGE Professor of English in Yale Ualversity B SIDNEY LEE ‘It is delightful, for it is by no means common to come upon a y : ripe scholar who believes it his duty to digest his materials thoroughly Eleven brilliant essays on the relation of Shakespeare to oe ‘nts the results he derives from them to the public.” the modern stage and modern life. m — $2.00 net. Postage 15 cents $2.00 net. Postage 14 cents THE CAMBRIDGE APOSTLES THE BIBLE AS ENGLISH LITERATURE By CHARLES BROOKF ELD By J. H. GARDINER Delightful reminiscences of the brilliant group of young Asst. Prof. of English at Harvard University men at Cambridge University which included Tennyson, Hal- : ; . Rossi: a . A valuable and highly interesting discussion of the Bible lam, Trench, Spedding and Lord Houghton. in relation to English literature. Illustrated. $5.00 net $1.00 net. Postage 10 cents AF SHANISTAN By ANGUS HAMILTON ITALY AND THE ITALIANS A thorough, compact and complete account of the country By HELEN ZIMMERN oe it ts to-day, with the fullest geographical, political and Aclear and popular account of the Italy and Italians of commercial data. to-day, their life, interests, industries and amusements. Profusely Illustrated. $5.00 net Illustrated. $1.50 net ROMANTIC CITIES OF PROVENCE | A GERMAN POMPADOUR By MONA CAIRD By MARIE HAY Illustrated by J. Pennell and E. Syng . y Px . 4 This a notable plece of work The Athenaeum A delightful book, beautifully illustrated, about the won- Illustrated. $3.50 net derful cities of Provence. Illustrated. $3.75 net HILLS AND THE SEA CORREGGIO | By HILAIRE BELLOC By T. STURGE MOORE | Over thirty of the most enchanting essays he has ever An able and comprehensive life of this master with many | written. Entertaining, enlivet.ing and suggestive. illustrations. IMustrated. $2.00 net | $1.50 net THE COMPLETE WORKS OF HENRIK IBSEN The volumes have been revised and edited with new introductions by William Archer and are most attractive in form and makeup. There are eleven volumes, each sold separately. $1.00 per volume. NOW READY A DOLLS’ HOUSE and GHOSTS (1 vol.) BRAND THE VIKINGS and THE PRETENDERS (1 vol.) CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS - New York

Page 2

-— eel The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2158 The Nation. 4 WHREKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1864, at the New York City Post Office as second class mail matter. | [ Entered NUMBER 883 CONTENTS OF THIS Tun WeeK ARTICLES Peary’s Arctic Work 386 The Case of Municipal Ownership 386 Iniversity Teaching of English ° 387 Codes of Professional Ethics 8S Eprrortal SpeoraL ARTICLE Thoreau and German Romanticism 388 CORRESPONDENCE , ; 390 Saved? 391 391 Real Simplified Spelling Shall the Alhambra Be \ Pure Mental Food Law Norges aces Oe Book KRevirwe Recent Verse ) Ibragon Patnter teyond the Rocks he Call of the Blood 396 he Cruise of the Violetta l'rincess Maritza rhe German Workman lectures on Modern History larry at Home Travels DRAMA Irving 398 Sir Henry VMuen Saint-Safns Concert ‘ 399 M “lern Music and Musiciane 3ey Ant lrreasures from the Artemisiom at Ephesus 400 SCImENCR Theory of the Algebraic Functions of a Complex Variable : . 401 FInNanor: Spatching Control of Rallways 402 Books or Tua Ween 402 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any partof the Untted States or Canada; to for- cig countries comprised in the Postal Union, $6. he date when the subs ription exptres is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to @ subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remtt tance. No other reccipt ty sent unless requested, Remitlances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letver, or by check, express der, or Poaatal Order payable to ** Publisher of The Nation When a change of addrew ta destred, both the old and the new addresses should be given Addvess THE NATION, Rox794, New York Publication Office, 08 Rroadway TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen centa per agate line, each insertion; 14 linea lo the inch Twenty per cent advance for chotce of page or top of column A column, 20 page, of A page, 0 cach insertion; front cover page, $80. Al fia-meats acoeptahle in every: respect Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P. M THR NATION ta sent free lo thiae who adver fiee in U as long as advertiaement continues. Discounts upon applica‘ion, each insertion; with choice of nas be *,* Copies of Tae Nattow may be Parise at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de London of B. F, Stevens & @quare, Charing Cross yrocured in ‘Opéra; in Brown, Trafatear Educational Massacn' seTTs, Boston. OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BrerLow. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. Shop for Mechanic Arta. Strong teachers. Earnest boya. Gymprastum with new swimming pool. Fits for college, actentifie achool and business. oung boys In separate building. Address Dr. & C, WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellesley Mills, Mass. School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES. Everett 0. Freak & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Pi., Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 154 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid.. Minneapolis 208 Mich. Ave, Chicago 1200 Williems Av., Portiand 401 Cooper Bid., Denver 525 %time’n Bid.,Los Ange les 313 Rook'ry Bik., Spokane 717 Market St. Aan F’ncisco Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Recorda. Send for Circular on Free Registration. HARLAN P. FRENCH, &1 Chapel St.. Albany, N. Y. Just Published Davison’s Practical Zoology By Alvin Davison, A.M., Ph.D., Pro- fessor of Biology in Latayette College. $1.00 A scientific, yet simple and interesting. treatment of the structure, life history and relations of animals, The necessary direc- tions as to methods and equipment for laboratory work are included. The illustra tions consist of numerous drawings and re- productions of photographs. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Boston THE BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY will issue on November 10a catalog of books de voted strictly to American subjects. It will be an annotated bibliographical list fully priced and arranged according to the sy seam adopted by the OF CLEVELAND, OHIO A. L. A. Guide, The price is 25 cents to all except reguiar customers. It will be invaluable as a guide. An old friend with a new face is Peter Rabbit of the Brier-Patch., William J. Long interprets his philos- ophy. Charles Copeland illus- tratesit. $1.50 net, GINN & COMPANY, Boston. RESEARCHES made in the BOSTON LIBRARY, HARVARD L'BRARY, BOSTUN ATHENAEBUN, TRANSLATIONS made from Prench and Italian Summaries of books or sine i Expert copy and groctvonting Fr. H. DIK Mass. Institute of ‘echnology, =m A BOOK FOR EVERY ROD Y. EATING TO LIVE. Ry JOHN J. RLACK, M.0). With epectal advice to the Gouty, the Rheumatic,and the Diabetic. Cloth, $1.50 net J. 8. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. LEDCERS and LITERATURE By GEORGE KNOLLYS. “The Romance of Book- keeping,” ete. '2mo, 81.85 net. Postage 12c JOHN LANE CO., The Bodley Head, N. Y. EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY Cloth, 50 cents; leather, $10. BD. P. DOTTON & OO-7 - s List on ge The American Journal of Sociology A Bimonthly edited by the Sociological Fac. ulty of the University of Chicago ,with the advice of leading sociologists in America and Europe. ALBION W. SMALL, Ed tor-in-Chie/. THE ONLY JOURNAL IN THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE DEVOTED PRIMARILY TO PURE SOCIOLOGY $2.00 a year; single copies, 50 cents ties were adopted under the advice of a Council of Elder Statesmen, the mem- bers of such an advisory body should have had not only wide practical experi- ence, but also the broadest possible sur- vey of the details and the meanings of all phases of social activity. The fundamental work of the sociologists is to plot the field of study which it would be desirable for men to pursue, if it were known in advance that they were to be- come members of a Council of Elder States- men. As the sociologists plot the field, it is not a different territory from that already cov- ered by the various types of history, by economics, by the legal sciences, and by ethics. It is the same territory, with the lines of relationship drawn from different points. The survey of human society which the sociologists propose is not a substitute for the older forms of study. It is rather an attempt to supplement those researches by viewing the same facts in a wider perspec- tive. The central reality in the sociological ren- dering of life is not the working of par- ticular institutions—economic, political, religious. This is merely a detail in the sociological picture. The main features are the evolution of types of wants in persons, their creation of institutions as ministers to those wants, and their re-creation of the institutions as the wants pass into new stages of development. Since public opinion is virtually the Council of Elder Statesmen that guides this process in democratic countries, every person who helps to form public opinion should take account of the work of the so- ciologists. This JOURNAL aims to represent the progress of scholars in filling out this view of society. Subscriptions filed immediately to begin January, 1907 will include the number for November, 1906, free THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS (Dept. 21) CHICAGO and NEW YORK |" the working policies of civilized socie- WA yy 1: E D —Original outegregh lettera of famous persons. Highest prices id. WALIER R. BENJAMIN, 1 West 34th St., New fork City. Letters sold. Send for price liste Financial. We buy qne sell wee of eachonges ie T TE make cable transfers of money on u- LE RS rope, Australia, aad South Africa; also OF make collections and {ssue Commercial CREDIT and Travellers’ . ° ee available in all rte of the wo International Enea heques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO; FO, 50 WALL 8TREET, YEW YORK,

Page 3

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 8, 1906. The Week. The election of Charles E. Hughes as Governor of New York by a majority of merely 55,000 cannot afford Republi- cans much ground for elation. Hearst was personally detested by tens of thou- sands of respectable Democrats who, like Mayor McClellan, scratched the ticket so that Hearst ran far behind his colleagues. He had secured his nomination by pandering to the lowest element in the Democratic party, and by a shameless bargain with Charles F. Murphy, whom he had denounced as a criminal. But he had not captured all the machine politicians; for he was op- posed by McCarren in Brooklyn and by Croker’s old guard in Manhattan. On the other hand, Charles E. Hughes had an impeccable record in character and attainments. His private and profes- sional life had been irreproachable; he had performed distinguished public ser- vice in the legislative investigation of the gas monopoly and the insurance companies. He was brought forward as the candidate, not of the Republican bosses, but of the very best men, like Herbert Parsons, who wished to rehabil- itate the party. Business conditions seemed favorable to Republican success Wages were high, the demand for la- bor keen. The country was floating on a high tide of prosperity, for which the Republicans have loudly claimed credit. Under such circumstances and on the face of this contrast between a reckless demagogue and a man of ability and conscience, detached observers might suppose that Hearst would suffer an overwhelming defeat; that he would, as some sanguine opponents predicted, be buried under a landslide of 200,000 votes. What, then, is the meaning of this comparatively narrow escape from Hearst? It means but one thing: the people of New York are tired of oppres- sion and dishonesty in the management of our huge corporations, and tired of the corrupt alliance between corpora- tions and machine politicians. This was the issue which Hearst has been urging for years. This is the issue on which he has secured such a formidable following. Indeed, the result proves that had not Hughes himself won such repute as a scourge of thieving insurance officials, his candidacy would have been hope- less. Had the nerveless Higgins been renominated, he would have hardly been the race at all; but thousands of con- srvative men, who are eager for the jurification of our public life, turned to Hughes as the man who is more like- ly than Hearst tothelp us in this time of need. For his agitation against corpora- tion abuses Hearst could have had abun- dant material without resorting to ex- aggeration anc misstatement. The cases of the insurance companies, of the Stan- dard Oil Company and its rebates, as exposed by Government investigators, of the rebates to the Sugar Trust, for which the New York Central has been convicted, the stock-jobbing and stock- watering by public utility corporations in New York, Brooklyn, and other cit ies of this State, the extortions of the anthracite monopoly and the Ice Trust, and the control of political machines by these combinations of capital—all these modern instances have strengthened the popular conviction that plain people are not being dealt with fairly. Hearst promised redress; and to Hearst people turned, not because he was an ideal can- didate, but because he seemed to be the weapon at hand. The warning is unmistakable. If Mr Hughes fails to do his utmost to check abuses and redress grievances, if in this cffort he is thwarted by the hirelings of the machine, Hearst or one of his kind will surely have his innings. The cor- porations have rights which must be re- spected as scrupulously as those of the individual: but our common carriers cannot be allowed to use their immense- ly valuable franchises from the public as instruments of discrimination; our traction and lighting companies are not licensed to loot our cities: our anti ronopoly laws must not be _ violated with impunity. Such men as John D. Rockefeller and Henry H. Rogers of the Standard Oil: Thomas F. Ryan and An- thony N. Brady, the manipulators of traction President Charies A. Peabody of the Mutual Life and other life insurance officials who trying to prevent a free vote by policyholders; such buccaneers in high finance as E. H. Harriman, have heretofore shown little appreciation of popular sentiment. They have acted as if no power on earth had right or might to check the greed of their corporations. To them the of Tuesday should carry les- son. The faith of thousands in as a saviour has its pathetic side. In casting their ballots for him they have blindly cried for justice. They will not be denied. stocks; are also its Hearst vote No commentator of Professor Bur- gess’s Berlin remarks on the Monroe Doctrine has struck the real infelicity involved—namely, that these observa- tions meant one thing to Dr. Burgess and quite another to his German hear- ers and readers. To him the issue was academic—a mere weighing of a case in international morals and diplomatic pro priety; to Germany generally, it is to be feared, it seemed to indicate a revo lutionary change in American sentiment and policy. For the view that morally) the Monroe Doctrine is obsolete, much may be said. The conditions that gave ic dignity have ceased to exist We no longer fear that any monarchy will snuff out republican government in the West ern Hemisphere. Moreover, our former aloofness from European and Asiati politics, which gave force to the demand that Europe should equally abstain from the Americas, been utterly abandoned. When this nation | from to absurd to interfering in has in world Algeciras Peking, it the commercial and quasi-colonial inter Germany in South America. But unhappily rather little to do with the matter. As a sentiment, the Monroe Doctrine has become stronger as its mor For years to come resentment of Eu ropean interference in this hemisphere will our Presidents, and, at a pinch, our arnfies and navies. In short the “Doctrine” tional to the instinctive stage, and is, if politics is logically deny and logic ests of Italy has devotion to al basis has become more flimsy many move has passed from the ra anything, more formidable than be fore. That such opinions as Professor Fturgess’s will ultimately prevail, we make no doubt; meanwhile, it is pre mature to give the impression to Furopean Power, most of all to Ger many, that, because certain of our diplo matic syllogisms have been proved fal lacious by events, our traditional con clusions are held less passionately than before. of the Eleventh Cen Debt, and Taxation,” Since the “Wealth, no comprehensive statistics of report sus upon in 1892, Federal, published in finance have United States local the We had begun to despair of ever see: the finance statistics of the Twelfth Cen State, and been Recently, however, the first advance sus sheets have come to hand. The follow ing table of the net indebtedness (i total indebtedness less sinking funds) presents the essential data, stated in millions of dollars: 1870 15m) 18) 1ge2 Federal debt 2.331 1,919 mim) w2h State debt A684 276 212 24 County debt 187 124 1485 196 Municipal and other local debt 228 724 781 1,434 Total 3,100 3.042 2.028 2.7K Per cap\ta debt $82.00 80).65 $892.90 $35 40 Since 1870 the aggregate net indebted ness has decreased; since 1890 it has increased. Meanwhile, the per capita debt has fallen very materially, but since

Page 4

1890 has manifested a slight upward tendency. If we separate Federal and State from county and municipal indebt- edness, the table will stand as follows: 1870. 1880. 1800. 1902 Federal and State debt 2.0m 2,194 1,102 1,159 (County and municl- pal debt 615 SAS ¥26 1,630 Total 3,190 3,042 2,028 2,789 It is clear that two opposing forces have been at work. Both Federal and State debts were swollen to abnormal propor- 1870 on account of the civil war; and the subsequent decrease, amounting by 1902 to $1,525,000,000, was but natural—at least, according to American theory and practice. Upon the other hand, local indebtedness has risen since 1870 by not less than $1,- 115,000,000, and, what is more, the rate of increase was never so rapid as at the present time. We find also that, of the aggregate local debts of $1,630,000,000, not less than 48 per cent. belong to New York, Massachusetts, Pennsylvania, and New Jersey, which contain but 24 per cent. of the population. In the coun- try at large, the heaviest local debts are in the industrial States having large centres of population. Earlier census reports upon “Wealth, Debt, and Taxa- tion” contained instructive tables show- ing the purposes for which all debts were contracted. The data thus far pub- lished do not give such information for but we may hope that, since a beginning has at last been made, the rest of the results may be speedily forth- tions in 9. 1902; coming. Magoon, by dismissing Cuban of ficials wholesale, has laid his hand se- riously to the reform most needed, but he Is also in danger of exciting unhappy animosities The Latin are a unit in regarding officeholding as the most desirable career, and the lack of a post as something like an ignominy. At many points, Secretary Taft's mili- emissaries found the chief diffi culty of the situation to be that the in urgents expected to take up office as laid down their antiquated fact, the trouble that has with in Cuba Is the innate of the outs to shoot their It may be said that such sentl- ments little credit our wards; their sensibilities have to be considered all the We doubt that Gov. Magoon's clean sweep is justified on all practical grounds. We hope, how that his zeal will be tempered by that life in the bush Is Gov races tary fost as they firearms In dealt propensity to be way in do to same do not ever, the recollection The a delightful recreation in Cuba, while the Cuban insurgent is a much more formidable antagonist than his col league, with whom Mr. Magoon js more | familiar, the revolutionist of the Isth- mus. N at 10M. [Vol. 83, No. 2158 A steady increase in the number of college men entering politics in New York city is evident from the “Voters’ Directory” published by the Evening Fost a few days before election. This Directory contains the names and a brief characterization of all the candi- dates to be balloted for in Greater New York. This autumn 123, or more than a third of the whole number, were trained either in college or law school. The significance of these figures appears from a comparison with figures for four The following table shows both years the totals and the distribution of can- didates among the several colleges: 1903. 1904 1905. 1906. Yale .... sees 4 5 5 6 Harvard ‘ 3 3 7 Princeton ‘ 6 5 5 5 Cornell 1 5 3 4 New York University 4 7 9 5 City College 11 15 14 7 Columbia 10 Ss 11 6 Amherst : 2 3 4 Hamilton 1 2 2 Williams ; 1 3 Other colleges 10 15 20 31 Law School only 29 21 30 33 80 87 102 123 The preponderance of men from the free College of the City of New York is, of course, to be expected. The interest of college men in politics is a gratifying it means among our office-holders greater intelligence. ‘We believe it also means higher character. So far as our own observation goes, however, the de- fect of our office-holding class to-day is moral, not mental; the members of the New York Legislature, for example, suf- sign: fer less from ignorance than from in- Stability. They are clever enough, but they are afraid to resist the machine politician; they compromise too easily with conscience Andover Theological Seminary’s low estate is again brought to public no- tice by the figures of this year’s enrol- There are, it seems, but eleven all told—actually fewer than the professors. This is a sorrowful pass for the ancient seminary, once regard- ed as head of all the theological schools of the country. The alumni and trus- tees have made great efforts to keep the institution going, but discussion will now be renewed, we presume, of the project to settle, like the Episcopal Theo- logical School, under the wing of Har- vard at Cambridge. It is commonly supposed that the decayed prest'ge of Andover is due to doctrinal reasons. The “Andover controversy” is ordinarily re- the marked ment students, to as the cause of falling off in the number of students. That acrimonious theological struggle, no doubt, had something to do with the seminary’s decline, but it probably did little more than accelerate the working of a larger cause. The “drift of the cit- les” has strongly affected theological education. To be directly in touch with ferred organized Christianity and charity, ona large scale, has become the great desire of theological students. They “pine for their slums,” as Professor Park of An- dover once sarcastically put it. At any rate, New Haven and Chicago and Hart- ford have grown at the expense of An- dover. Union Seminary in this city had its own theological hatreds, and was at one time almost taboo by the Presby- terian Church; but the pull of the city brought it students as before. The old conception of a theological seminary as a quiet place where a man could do ath- letic reading and needle’s-point thinking, is giving way. These are the days when the theologian, too, has to “hustle” and “do things.” Christian Science and mental healing were the topics to which Dr. Pierre Janet of Paris, chiefly devoted himself in a recent lecture at the Lowell In- stitute on “Psychotherapeutics.” In some cases he admitted that healers had accomplished good results; but he com- plained of the absence of precise data in the reports of “cures.” A recovery of 80, 90, and even of 98 per cent. had been claimed, but no diagnosis of the cases was made, and the statistics were scientifically inconclusive. This neg- lect of diagnosis and contempt for the medical profession has been characteris- tic of all healers since P. Quimby’s la- bors in 1840. Cure by faith resembles the old medieval “theriac,” a mixture of drugs, some one of which might prove to be a good shot, and hit the bull’s-eye. Dr. Janet thinks that the miracles of Christian Science are on a higher plane than those of Lourdes, but he puts hypnotism above the method of either. Every educated Frenchman is surprised that faith-healing should be with us a religious process. But in demanding of the Christian Science advocates a diag- nosis of the cases cured, and authorita- tive statistics, Dr. Janet is surely ad- cressing deaf ears. The virtual abolition of the Mathe- natical Tripos at Cambridge University was briefly announced in the dispatches a few days ago. The reasons for this step now appear more fully in the Eng- lish papers. In a letter published on October 22, eleven of the Cambridge professors and lecturers in mathemat- ics, including Robert S. Ball, G. H. Dar- win, A. R. Forsyth, and J. J. Thom- son, set forth their arguments in sup- pert of the change, then pending. They felt that the old system involved “too great a sacrifice of the educational in- terests of many students, the charac- ter of whose work during their course at Cambridge is dominated by the re- quirements of the final examination.” Men spend “far too much time in elab- orating the details of the general mathe- matical course.” One of the chief ob-

Page 5

= hin ‘ Nov. 8, 1906] jects of the new scheme is “to provide tor the needs of the important class of men who ought to spend part, but not the whole, of their time at Cambridge in studying mathematics.” The problem al Cambridge is in one point the reverse of that which American universities, with the elective system, are forced to Here the difficulty is to keep too many students—especially those who have no definite view—from dissipating their efforts over too wide a field. The attempt to counteract this tendency toward diffusion is met in some institutions by the offering of “honors” and other prizes for excellence in one line. In no American univer- sity, however, have we an honor which distinction Mathematical wrangler, consider career in carries the accorded to the Tripos at and leader of the Cambridge, the consequently there is not such a gener- senior al temptation to concentration along one line. Yet our prizes, such as they are, together with a desire to hasten prepar- ation for professional work, indubitably encourage the ambitious in the tendency deplored at Cambridge—immature and excessive specialization. Premier Clemenceau has received the extraordinary vote of confidence of 395 to 96. The programme that elicited so unprecedented an expression may be briefly characterized The Fremier engages to enforce the Separa- tion Act, though the method is not speci fied: to old-age pro- as radical. vote pensions, a gressive income tax, and increased priv- | i'eges to labor unions “Democratic” word chosen projects In a vas the Government way, the Clemenceau prospectus is mere- general ly a continuation of the policy of several Ministries past. Evidently, the keeping of these depends mainly on money in hand, and the large deficit in the current budget pretty well reduces the more costly plans to pious wishes. As regards European policy, also, M. Clemenceau will apparently continue in the footsteps of Rouvier and Bourgeois, confirming the new friendships with Italy and England, while abiding by the Dual Alliance. We have already pointed out that the actual sincerity of that com- pact was in doubt from the very begin- ning. Its value to-day is largely facti- tious. But it seems as if, beside the more genuine understandings which are gradually forming, there must be main- tained a solemn equilibrium of paper alliances—if only to please an inter- rational Mrs. Grundy who still domin- ates the chancelleries. M. Clemenceau’s tenure, finally, is by no means as com- fortable as his great majority indicates. He has ahead the thorny problem of applying the Separation Act and of financing his humanitarian projects. His course is perilous and will require a skilful pilot. promises to describe the | | formity The Nation. deadlock between the French Government and the 4 possible solution of the Church over the Separation Law is sug gested in the Revue Politique by M. Esmein, an eminent authority on pub- he law M. Esmein finds the crux of the difficulty in the failure of the law tc make specific mention of the Cath olic Church Sut if it the bishops to accept the associations of law, public prescribed in the why may not the laity wor! ship proceed with the taking such associations, in their by-laws the full formation of + care to insert est guarantees that the bishops may de If the bishops will not accept under mand? religious associations organized an obnoxious law, it is within their pow- er to bring about the formation of as sociations before the law comes into effect Up to that date (December 11) they would retain power over the Church be the only whe formed is in organization and judges association with the of the Church make itself, in the bishop's will property ther any con- general Such an association can fact, the If the faithful are wise instrument of enforcement of the “The posses and anticipate the law, they have nothing to fear orthodox association will be in sion and beati possidentes.” worse—to be blind or to be that and Which is dumb? Kant discussed question in his “Anthropologie,” concluded that the blind were less to be pitied that the found, as a rule, more morose Ludwig deaf and whom he The emi- nent Cohn, considers the same problem in the Ber- one-hun- deaf-mutes, oculist, Dr. serlin lin Tagebilatt, apropos of the dredth anniversary of the opening of the first asylum for the blind in Ger many. All the blind persons whom he has questioned hold their affliction to be more endurable than that of the deaf mutes. Yet at social gatherings, and in the theatre, not to speak of the opera the eye makes amends for the lack of hearing to a much greater degree than the ear does for the absence of sight But “if we ask a deaf-mute if he would change places with a blind person, he always answers, No.” The latest pub lished figures, for 1900, show that there were at that time in the German Em- pire 48,750 deaf-mutes, as against 34,334 blind. Much more done for the deaf-mutes than for the blind in enabling them to earn their own living; and Dr. Cohn regards it as one of the main problems of the future to devise means of making the blind self-support- ing. To that problem humane people in this country have applied themselves with much success has been If certain practices now common among small domestic tradesmen and | servants continue much is impossible for | 3885 longer, there will be little need of agitating f i graduated income tax, or for a mita tion of great fortunes The wealth of the unhappy employers will be distrit uted in commissior In h famous advice to servants Dean Swift ol serves Take all trad 7: naster, and w) ! er offer to hea I b pay the full d hig? ve master's |} I hillings in y | } { , mnsider if you ! | much, he can bette iff ! ‘ han t po tradesman The custom of giving and tak ! missions on all articles bought f household use has grown until many cooks receive more from the purvey than they do from their employe Some marketmen will pay as much a 10 per cent. to a cook to keep the pa tronage of a large family No one main tains that competent domestic servant are greatly overpaid Often they ren der services which no wages could cure But if a large percentage on the cost of provisions 1 to zo into the 301 vant’s poc ket. then employer will no doubt seek some way of self-protection The commission system, which | bad enough in the kitchen, is even worse in the stable No doubt the blacksmiths and harness dealers would themselve welcome a remedy for the present state of things, when the employer's purcha ing power is too often regulated by the greed coachman’s A struggle of twenty-five years In the Bermudas £70, channel of Colonial Parliament of the has ended in the appropriation of 000 for the deepening of the St. George’s Harbor. This is a body of water within a mile of By this project the dians hope to create such harbor facil ities as will make their islands a great plying lies land lox ked the open sea jermu coaling station for steamships the North Atlantic As in the trade routes from to the Gulf of Mexico and the Caribbean Sea, her position as a port of call is sin advantageous. At present, she cannot of one safe or convenient anchorage for coaling. The advocates of the St. George’s channel scheme met with Bermuda the Continent gularly boast strong local opposition. Even the Im- perial authorities frowned on the pro ject. But after the Spanish-American war the Home Government withdrew all objection. To-day, public opinion tn Bermuda is unanimously in favor of the improvement. The change of fee ing is largely due to financial depres sion As the winter tourist trade wil not make up to the colony for its other losses, the Bermudians have concluded to make a bid for the Atlantic coaling trade.

Page 6

386 PEARY'’S ARCTIC WORK. In the short dispatch of Saturday announcing the return of Commander Peary, we have the bare record of what must for many years be regarded as one of the most remarkable pieces of exploration ever accomplished. Whether ible to justify itself in the light of a eontribution to science or not, whether it is to act as a stimulus or a deterrent to further exploration in the same field, the journey itself proves a courage and an ability on the part of individual man to battle with the forces of nature, which are but rarely found illumining even the brightest pages in the annals of discovery Indeed, Mr. Peary, in his numerous Arctic ventures, entirely apart from the importance or significance of his discoveries, has set a standard for exploration which few will have the dar and still fewer the phys Starting ing to emulate ical capacity to carry through. on his great work in 1891, al! of systematically his the the clearing up of the the F North virtually all of 1906 that that devoted to the accomplishment he has since time energies: one end in view Ten the was not tak- mysteries of ar years and more period between IS91 and several the en up in preparations for his have been passed in of expeditions Arete ert ice and Che chief of Mr plorations are to be found in the deter des snow results Peary’s ex- mination of the insularity of Greenland the Arctic boun- seemingly the (1892); the fixation of daries of what is most northerly land-mass of our planet (Cape Morris Jesup, latitude 83° 39’ north (1900); and the tracing (1906) east and westward of the Arctic shore line through 80° of longitude; that is, from the northeastern extremity of Greenland to nearly 20° of longitude beyond the furthest point that, in Grant Land, was reached in 1876 by Aldrich Aldrich, it will be remembered, was one of the lieutenants of the British national ex pedition under command of Capt. (Sir) (jeorge Nares. To this major work of Mr. Peary must be added the close chart ing of the inner waters of a large sec tion of Northwestern Greenland, and the most complete study that has ever heen made of that small band of true (ireenlander hardly 250 to 300 in number, who inhabit the region lying northward of Melville Bay, and who ippear in the early explorations of Sir john Ro under the name of Aretic Highlander Many of the more strict ly seclentifie details of the explorations have not been elaborated, or at least have not yet been published Our knowledge of the great ice-cap of Green- leal conditions prevailing to the northward the late and fur- the it phy its land relation uncover that which initiated by Nordenskjéld 1883, and ice-free ove? ed or land lies of it Baron was in thered by the “first crossing” of Nansen, or | | | The | The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2158 we owe in the main to Mr. Peary. We likewise owe to him the presentation of of interesting problems in | the domain of zoégeography. Among the latter is the occurrence in the land beyond the ice-cap of Greenland of the The presence of this animal, which the explorers have used as food, }a number musk-ox. has alone on two occasions made it pos- sible for Mr. Peary to starva- tion. escape “farthest north” 6’) surpasses by thirty-eight miles the earlier achievement, northward of Land, of Capt. Cagni, the expedi- singularly Duke It also eclipses hy 196 of the is now made (87 record that statute brilliant Franz Josef long arm of the “Stella tion of the of the Abruzzi. statute miles Mr. Peary’s own best pre- record of 84° 17’, of Cape Hecla, on Grant Land, in In the final days of the heroic struggle of Captain (now Admiral) Markham, one of the lieutenants of the British expedi- tion of 1876, the advance over the hum- mocky pack-ice in the same field which at one-quarter Polare” successful northward 1902. vious traversed this was made rate of half of a mile a day. was the year, than This distance not more | is considerably less than the retrograde movement of the ice that carried the ex- plorers southward. This experience af- fords an insight into the labor which has permitted Mr. Peary to pass Mark ham’s furthest point by 250 statute |ayniles. Two hundred miles still inter- | vene between the furthest of this year and the Pole, while the area of the re- gions in the extreme north that remain still | not unknown, or at best vaguely known, is reckoned in millions of square miles. One of the most important lessons to the Peary ex- peditions unfortunately, that has yet been able to break through the barrier of accepted notions—is the value of a critical study of clothing and food. In a knowledge of these all-important adjuncts to travel, Mr. Peary is facile princeps. The almost complete absence of every form of illness from the Peary camps through so many years of severe and the elim- ination of that plague of Polar explora- tion, scurvy, is a triumph which points of this regret achieve- Antarctic be drawn from various one, trial exposure, absolute to success in future ventures kind And that the brilliant ments of the British National Expedition of 1902-1904 of their the breaking out of scurvy and the death of yet one reads with otherwise were shorn probably best results through the dogs, as a consequence of improper food And, seemingly, it matter of clothing which prevented Nan- was chiefly a }een from making a higher northing at | the time that he abandoned the Fram | to its famous drift Troubles of this class never beset the Peary expeditions. | Nature's elements are still the force that baffles the best conquer them. efforts put forth to OF MUNICIPAL OWNER- SHIP. It is not surprising that the League of American Municipalities declined to adopt a general resolution favoring mu- nicipal ownership. Its adoption would at best be premature. There is no pres- ent agreement among economists either for or against the further extension of the functions of American municipali- ties. There was a period when munici- pal enterprises were advocated and, in some cases, taken up in this country on more or less vague reports of similar experiments in Great Britain and else- where. This time has passed, and has been followed by one of inquiry, the re- sults of which have not yet been fully ascertained. The evidence is not yet all in; obviously, the time has not arrived finally to decide the case. The facts, to date, are that municipal functions both in Europe and America have greatly expanded within the last few years. Great Britain leads the way, with Germany close upon her heels, and America following more slowly. Great Britain numbers among the enterprises undertaken by her cities, not only the familiar water works, gas and electric l:ghting plants, and tramways, but also municipal markets, baths, dwelling houses, telephones, theatres, warehouses, hotels, lodging-houses, abattoirs, golf li:nks, savings banks, crematories and cemeteries, oyster fisheries, rabbit war- rens, sheep farms, hop farms, coke and tar factories, and brick yards. Ger- many has gone extensively into munici- pal lighting and_ street-car_ service. American cities have thus far generally confined themselves to municipal water works, gas works, and electric lighting plants. No American city has yet un- dertaken to operate street cars, though there are several instances, as in New York and Boston, where the city owns the right of way and leases to an oper- ating company which supplies the equip- ment. Have the results thus far been favor- able or unfavorable? Here the conflict begins. Dr. E. W. Bemis and Profes- sor Howe have one opinion; Prof. L. S. Rowe and Prof. Hugo R. Mever hold another. The report of the Bureau of Labor, based on three separate investi- gations of the results of municipal trad- ing in Great Britain, admits a princi- pal charge against the system-——that it increases municipal debt and raises the tax rate—but, on the whole, is mildly favorable. The most complete presenta- tion by a single economist, “Municipal Ownership in Great Britain,” by Profes- sor Meyer, is strongly against the sub- stitution of municipal management for private enterprise. The Civic Federa- THE CASE

Page 7

Nov. 8, 1906] — tion, which promises an elaborate re- port, is yet to be heard from. Of the results in this country, no com- plete summary is available. It seems to be generally agreed that American mu- nicipalities can satisfactorily maintain end operate their water works, but oppo- nents of municipalization urge, with some force, that the case of water is ex- ceptional, not only because the supply is in most wholly natural and the means of distribution simple, but also because water is required by all, while gas, electricity, and street are used by only a portion of the com- Apart from water, the reports cities are as confusing cases munity. from American as the conflicting testimony from Great Britain. Toledo, Ohio, pays interest an- nually on a million-dollar debt for which the city has absolutely nothing to show, having sold for a tenth of its cost the embarked upon Virginia, natural enterprise a dozen years ago. Richmond, has waked up to the fact that her sup- posed profit from a municipal gas enter prise was a matter of bookkeeping, and that instead of a profit there is a seri- ous loss, which made in cash—renovating a worn-out plant— or the business abandoned. Alexandria, Virginia, has within a few months sold for $3,000 an electric plant costing $17,- 000. Current dispatches tell of four Indiana cities which are preparing to wind up their lighting ventures soon as they can find purchasers for the plants. Many American cities, on.the other hand, point with great pride to their municipal electric plants. This may mean that their experience is to be counted on the affirmative side—or it may mean that they have not yet called in an expert accountant. One might gather from the tenderness with which the subject is treated by the politicians that all the voters are in favor of municipal ownership and opera- tion, but there happens to he proof that this is not true. Chicago, it will be re- membered, voted for municipal owner- ship but not for municipal operation; and if the street cars of Chicago are to be run by the city, specific authorization for it must still be secured at the polls. San Francisco was forced to take over a street car line, where the franchise had expired, but refused, on submission toe the voters, to authorize municipal operation of the cars. Cleveland, Ohio, being urged by Mayor Johnson in 1903 to undertake the construction and oper- etion of a municipal lighting plant, and the question being submitted to the elec- tors, declined by a substantial majority. The city of Seattle, which in March of this year elected the mayoralty candi- date of the municipal ownership party, thought better of it, and on September 12. by a majority of more than gas must now be news as ent of a total of 14,000 votes cast at a spectal election, refused to authorize a bond issue for municipal street car lines. up | 1,500 | tion cars | The Nation. Certainly, there is nothing now in the record which calls for a generaliza in favor of the wide extension of n.unicipal functions, commonly implied within the term “municipal ownership.” For the present, at least, each proposal should be compelled to prove its own | cuse, and the closer the scrutiny the bet ter. UNIVERSITY TEACHING OF ENG LISH. One who marks current discussion of | college English will be reminded of an ungrammatical but expressive catchword of twenty-five years azo “Hit him again; he's Irish, and he han’t no friends.’ The latest castigator of these studies, Prof. George Rice Carpenter deals the faithful wounds of a friend, being himself the incumbent of a chair of English in Columbia University. His criticism, as contained in the Columbia | Quarterly, affects English as taught in the universities. He notes that many Ph.D’s in English have received a train ing wholly scrappy, and quite apart from the subjects they are to teach in the colleges. Thus we fill our chairs with erudite scholars, to be sure, but myopic teachers, disqualified from tak ing comprehensive views even of their Naturally, such men are poor vague specialty leaders of youth, having merely conceptions both of literary values and of pedagogical possibilities A little acquaintance with college fac ulties will show that professors of this limited sort are by no means rare. We venture further, and assert that most of the good teachers of English have be come so through a combination of na- tive ability and vitality sufficient to overcome the defects of their university Many a faithful teacher, re viewing his own university career, would say, that it in itself or wasted, but that it had been grossly un unprofitable of many education not was bad and relatively the similar systematic actual service teach- fashion, gloriously regards In as ing. a Grecian who has settled hoti’s and ingloriously, to acquire some famil iarity with literature. In fine, the university often not merely neglects business,” is compelled, Greek the more valuable studies, but so ur gently puts forward the less valuable, that the student has no leisure for re pairing individually the gaps in a hap hazard Nothing more common than to find a doctor of philos ophy whose mental acquisition, after all consists of snippets of literary history and philology—a dash of and the Chester Plays: asmat- of the Minnesinger: a and one of Dr. Donne; of Anglo- Saxon metre, and Aristotelian critiques the ragout that Is curriculum is uncodrdinated Chaucer, tering of Gothic, and a sample semester of Gower a soupcon cf poetry—such Is tardily | 387 versity education. Evidently a student who escapes such a course with his as sociative faculties unimpaired is a mon ument to his own mental equipoise, not tu the intelligence of the university that made him a doctor The cause of this confusion is largely false ideals of research inherited from Germany, but even more the absence of clear thinking in university administra tors and teachers Fro Germany we have imported the notion that the pro cess of investigation is everything thre materials quite indifferent In thi view there jis a plausible disintere | ness, and just enough truth to obscure the fundamental error. We would not minimize the value of any sort of truth por the desirability of researc h, however minute and remote from contemporary importance; but there is a world-wide difference bet wee such self-effacing in vestigat o ed by a trained scholar as part of a large and well-reasoned plan, and similar studies pursued by a novice in the name of education. The distinction is fundamental what in the first case may seem necessary and herote becomes in the second merely foolish If Germany has thus imposed upon u casual and g an eminently unphilosophical notion of the relation of research to university education and college teaching, she has unconsciously done us a deeper harm by confounding in the one word “philol | og a great variety of linguistic and literary studies, of differing importance and availability The ignorant sort of dilettanteism we have already had: we have lded a more insidious because a learned and plausible sort The gush ing person who imagines that he can teach English literature by plenary in | spiration, without any knowledge of the | history of the language, or even with out first-hand study of the history of the literature, is, after all, becoming rap! ily discredited: the philologer who on the basis of inarticulate enthusiasms that frequently served up in the name of uni- | fixes himself in a chair of literature is far more det and incommunicable tastes, rimental to sound studies. He is learn ed, and he the impression of being also wise, which The quarrel here is with philology, as such, but with who, without comprehensive views or noteworthy attainment even in subject, dabble languidly in both philology and literature: whose vaunt- ed investigations frequently merely of marginalia: whose teaching iy regulated not by any plan either phi! ological or literary, but by the passing curiosity of the year or by the casual pressure of publisher or editor. Men of this type, however vast their merely cumulative attainments, are dilettantes —true successors of the Alexandrian scholiasts and the Della-Cruscans Without exaggeration, this is the tem- gives to college presidents too often he fs not not those consist

Page 8

8388 per that our university education tends uphold the honor of the profession is the why and of ofr sionism is to and this reason both ductive ineffective for intellectual produce our college teaching our pro scholarship are a scrappy the principle and order course, ly for we reme impre and disorder, logic What Instance When the education for considered, all investigators need in the present is of rationalized perception ends. condition of a and the teaching col al are practic qualifications fairly lege absurd t equip college English as will seem culpable will eem 0 of German sense; teacher in the to Impose it merely random and still student of literat udies, worse fo! eem indispensable to observe a certain the to prescr be them the v history. It will and to omit equence preposterous periods like The university and afford rtations rewarding authors bec for doctoral most imply iuse these do not ] topl diss real reform will come when gain some conception of the lit authoritic distinctions between linguistic and philological | | of the army erary study: realize that the scholar’s conscience may be produced without gnoring the finer enthusiasms; and in- ist that no subject shall be taught with out some recognition of its educational values and its relations to the whole field of the humanities And this im plies a generation of univers'ty profes ors more forceful as personalities and better oriented as intellects, than the average of to-day CODES OF PROFESSIONAL ETHICS Writing on “The Ideal Lawyer” in the current Atlantic, Justice David J. Brew er of the Supreme Court cites with ap roval the action of the committee of the American Bar Association in advis it the adoption of a code of profession eththe This committee was appoint ed in 1905 to report upon the advisabil if ind practicability of such a code ind its recent report is worthy of wider | tention than it has thus far received n Justice Brewer's opinion, it is plain of that the profession as a whole recognizes that there is an ideal lawyer, nd intends that “no one shall be tol- erated who does not possess one at least of the elements of such a lawyer, to wit s high moral character.’ The committee, denouncing the con duet of certain lawyers, declared Mem? of tl bar, like judge ire of fi f the t ind ti} judg hould hold off luring good be ha t ( 1 beha hould not ? ‘ ' t t r hadowy term ! 1 of 4 i} application save in f! i It hould be lefined and mea I by such ethical standards, how high, as are necessary to keep the ad in ration of Justice pure and unsullled Such tandarda may be eryastallized into 1 written “le of professional organiza tions, local or national, formed to promote the administration of justice and Nation. The Such a code in time will doubtless become of very great practical value by leading to action through the judiciary; for the conditions warrant, for the reasonable canon of ethics as courts may, ill uitable require as candidates bar to subscribe a and ondition Indeed of admission. people, for to fur- to the na precedent eventually the welfare the community and the of by constitutional provisions or legis- tments, demand that all, before being granted by the the valuable franchise to practise, shall take an oath but estab- ther 1dministration justice, may, ther ] ve ena State Constitution be to support not only the canons of ethics by la uch lished With as may Ww this plan lawyers of the type of Edward M. Shepard Joseph H. Choate will be in They realize that the rush for wealth, as Mr. has in old-fashioned They number and hearty accord. recently out, Shepard pointed many cases undermined of an professional ethics. ever-increasing of men enter the profession solely as a means of obtaining political office or of getting into some lucrative business by of their legal knowledge. These birds of passage naturally care little or nothing for the calling which they make standards have seen means merely a means to an end. If in the number of law schools of high standing has done much for the profession, there still are, as every one knows, far too many men who prostitute their abil- the increase to instil a respect ities by using them only to show peo- ple how to avoid the penalties of the law while committing acts contrary to its spirit. We gravely doubt whether there has been an actual multiplication of shysters out of proportion to the general growth of the profession. There were blacklegs in the law centuries ago, as well as in the time of Marshall and Webster. But the increase in the num- ber of lawyers has made the corps too to quickly, and thus the punishing by disbarment dificult, except in many a rascal escapes be- cause his wronged client either does not know how to press for punishment or would rather avoid further notoriety and unpleasantness. Plainly, the best way to unwieldy act of and and process is long clear-cut cases; tone up the profession, besides contriv- machinery make disbar- and more frequent, tis standard the beginning, that eandidates for ad mission clear understanding that, In accordance with a written code, as honorable conduct is expected of them demanded of officers navy. ing some to ment speedier fix make to a at and sure have a as is traditionally and If it oldest of the learned professions seeking to keep itself pure, it is even more en- couraging to find a new one striving to ethical which its members shall be bound. At the twenty third of the Amertl is gratifying to see one of the establish an code by annual convention | | [Vol. 83, No. 2158 can Institute of Electrical Engineers, held in Milwaukee this year, the presi- dent, Schuyler Skaats Wheeler, devoted his address to the question of engi- neering honor, and cited as his text these words from Francis Bacon’s “Max- ims of Law”: I hold fession; seek so ought every man a debtor to his pro- from the which as men of course to receive contenance and profit, endeavor them- do they of duty to selves by way of amends to be a help and ernament thereto. Besides expounding the ordinary rea- sons for a code of ethics which apply to all professions, Mr. Wheeler dwelt at some length upon the duty the electrical engineer owes to the public, if only to it from the charlatan and the As a result of the president’s the Institute decided that, in imitation of such examples as the rules governing the relation of physician to patient and architect to client, a com- mittee should be appointed to draft a of electrical engineering ethics. This committee is now at work, on the understanding that the result of its la- bors will be submitted at the next an- nual meeting. protect impostor. address code It is with such voluntary acts as these that the defender of American business and professional life can best reply to the critic, whether native or foreign, who would have it that our ideals are perishing in an age of materialism. Just as ethical standards are higher and ethical teachings more insistent and sys- tematic than at any time in our history, so there is in every profession a growing desire to oust the quacks and the im- moral. Even in the dental profession, debased as it is by countless frauds and fakirs, there is a stirring which bodes well for the future. Indeed, if this striv- ing after ideals continues, we may yet a professional code among news- paper men. Miracles have happened, and we may yet see such a portent. The time may come when journalists who pander to the basest passions, who delib- erately incite to crime and immorality— or who sell their opinions for gain, will be professional outcasts. see THOREAU AND GERMAN ROMANTICISM After forty-four years of waiting, the Journal of Thoreau has been published in practically complete form, filling fourteen out of the twenty volumes that make the attractive new Walden Edition (Houghton Mifflin, & Co.). Of the value of the Jour nal itself in this extended form, there may be at first some doubt. Most of the memorable reflections and descriptive pas- sages had already been transferred by the author to “Walden” and his other regular works. What remains is made up largely of trivial daily memoranda, often written down in the fleld and then copied out at home for more convenient reference. There recompenses for the wary well are, of course, reader who has learned the gentle art of

Page 9

‘The Nov, 8, 1906] | skipping—new fragments of magic descrip- although ich a master of the )

ia tion, shrewd bookish criticisms, glimpses of | Friedrich Schlegel pref him serene vision, the old familiar thoughts | col¢g a Gri } struck out in fresh language And apart | was mainiy a x ' . f from any question of immediate interest, | .,m, imagined hom ‘ he this simple record of a life in nature rast, and h k hit : offers a real profit to the student of the | oiripgq, . larger intellectual currents. From Thoreau’'s medieval Churcl r P , comparative poverty in original ideas and | ogup 4) —_ : from the practical independence of his habit of t} Middle Ac . + character we can see, better than in the | .jyiy ' » Stee -—~ : case of Emerson or any other of the group rivers ending uj p } . wherein the transcendentalism of Concord | there. even in the d lined e the was an echo of the German school, and | eighteenth century hed whos ehe wherein it differed | devths had been brol , , ’ No one has yet traced the exact channels l se of the § n i < by which the formule of Romanticism mi- peared at the irf ’ P grated from Germany to New England, al- | gotten and it \rrent cha , with though it is known in a gencral way that lepo from 3s hid \\ the direct influence through translations re accustomed to find tl in the American magazines and elsewhetr 4 R 1 . a 6? Middl As was considerable. Moreover, most of the hiefly . m f Concord scholars dabbled at one me or } r Unendlichke wtrehes +} another in the German language The ‘ ru B W ! the strongest impulse, no doubt, came indirect eaning of tl word } , ly through Coleridge, Carlyle ind = the , ‘ Ml \ had other British Teutonizers, but once here it f tl f ne t found a far more suitable soil than in Eng her | ed ‘ land Something in the mental constitu The mo of tl tion of our people fitted them to absorb " nocte tacentia a } the nebulous ideas that were in the air, and \ mn of petrified ete something in their spiritual antecedents of the nfinite in Shal } | drew them particularly close to Germany he mediwval po | togetl They had just thrown off the strait-jacket Pl 1S han il ! of Puritan religion and were revelling in vening hoolmen What the Mid Ax the always perilous consciousness of spir eally strove for was to combine the leas itual liberty The situation in Germany | of personality and limitlessne the hu at the time of the Romantic School was man pe mality wa » I | ' l not altogether dissimilar. Lessing and the | changed through unending } l f time Titans of the Sturm und Drang had wres- | the deity was to be at once } lan in na tled against the deadening tyranny of the j tu inbounded in pows " yn Lutheran Church; they had discarded the | of world which could hay n only formalism of French literary law, and with wl feeling for the inf ea m it pretty much all sense of form whatever; | thing po ve in itself and diff from they had, with the help of Kant, broken | @ Mere quantitative limitless had been down the official philosophy of Leibniz and lost Nec irily such an ef n Wolff. On all sides resounded the watch. | tain the infir within the ve 1 of the word of Freiheit, liberty—except in poli- | finite brougt ts pel ) n nd tics, where neither then nor now have the | #2 unwholeson CZAaIta I laxing Germans, as a people, reached any notion every, to he is to St. A 1 e, the of individual liberty submitting to the dis- nguish of mortal If-ce ud on. Tl cipline of self-imposed restraint, without was the burden of the Confessions How need of the strong hand of Government or [I call upon my God, God and my the bonds of socialistic regulation. So far | ! For I call him into myself when I as the aim of the Storm and Stress can be I upon him (quoniam utique in meipsum described, it might be called a rejection } ay ocabo, cum imvocabo eum) And of the eighteenth-century principle of se- wi oom is there in me, whe my God lection for that of universality. The whole | ™@Y enter in where God may enter in, God of human nature should be embraced and | ¥!0 made heaven and earth?” And this developed, and this development was tc | “O™bat between the thought of a limited come through a setting loose of every im ind an unlimited personality passed pulse and passion of the breast to run its hrough the Middle Ag lisappeared for full unhampered course. What that career | * ‘'™ ind then returned to be absorbed meant, the Genicsucht, the Unendlichkeits- nd modified ir h wi gs of th Ro atreben, the ringende Titanenthum, the | ™ intic school Emancipation des Fleiaches, the Seelenpri- | Only so can we understand the Jch which apismus—may all be seen, by whoever cares | Fichte erected into that tortured system of to read it, in such a work as Wilhelm | philosophy, whose chief value is that it Heinse’s “Ardinghello.” Out of this blind gave a backbone of rigid articulate logic ferment of freedom came at last the spirit | to a body of otherwise flabby sentiment of a new and more compact school, the | The spirit of revolt is the beginning of the cultus of the Jch, the romantic I, as formu- | Movement Not only in art does the will lated by Fichte, the Schlegels, Schleier- | or whim (willkur) of the poet iffer no macher, and Schelling, and as practised by law over itself, as Friedrich Schlegel avers Tieck, Novalis, and a small band of con- | but, more m ca ! liberty is nee temporaries essary for the expar n of the I into the German romanticism is often defined as desired state of limitl elf-satisfaction a return to media@wval ideals, and for the Here is no true nse of finity, nor yet decline of the movement such a definition much talk of God and the yul—these had is fairly exact. And even in the beginning, | withered away under the Au/fkldrung—but Nation. at at pt th we 1 by gz gw I and the l ] pia i fa \ I i ] t of hing t | ? tit ‘ fo a bes B i ! y \ \ and \ ’ he \ x we tl ha i m God | | mnality i | i il ve tl oO \ ’ ery i I \A | ) t ng a a fleld f y ment He n f f bou ed exa f tor! t ri | com witl } ‘ ! f ilty o lef rn ! kins) it V n 4 re ra t ! ! I f ‘ wh I rT 4 i * ‘ pudia t fl ! f t! f il which leavy ! l | iwa ro Se) ' } } ’ ¢ +) It ] rt “ ! ality neitl tt j tio! i ! e by which the soul ! i f l ng hing 1 | 1 not-I swoo yet! I b yu feel ng hie thou } ] co par y all the loing f ‘ i holy music; he should do l t} r 1, noth ing through relis ! And the iim of poetry was the It, to hould avoid all that is harply defined, and should blend ill the genres into a | of ineffable musi« ippealing neitl ! ! ght nor the 4 I I v) ! 1? ] y and ire full of bea ful w ! but without any ense or ce rece ling to Noval the im f ar From the me yu t! pe | i ny men f tt movement—the ) led roma th l {ne fro society the i ! Ile (rive tl outre i ! x xz her Ww I h contemy of | j i ind inevitably there aris¢ il e wi h is the modern ce | f \ugustine’s restling with the pe mality of God Fichte might argus il t the we l as not-I, but to the inflamed imaginatior f t Schlegel this division of nature was a lisruption of self from self; it became the everlasting, uncompromising discord be tween the ideal and the real The only escape from this anguish of dissatisfaction was to ascend into those towers of indif ference from which the transcendenta I might survey the life of mankind, ever own activities, with unconcerned iro In art this is the quality by which the artist ‘appears to smile down upon his own ma terpiece from the heights of his sy t in life it is the feeling wt h lead 41 man to move about in ociety as in an alien world whose concerns are to him nothing a mere piece of “transcendental buffoon ery.”” Hence the contempt of business and of the Philistines follows as a kind of seal set upon the romantic soul which is con scious of itself. It cultivates a divine idle ness; the summons to loaf and invite one's

Page 10

390 l | pul ime from over the sea long before the indalous outbreak of Walt Whitman And the theatre of this vagrant aloofness wa natur To the wanderer in the fleld and on the mountain side, with his spirit bathed in tl hifting glamour of color and f n, with no troublesoms all upon his i or h will, this v ble mu of na t might eem now to be pun like a im f m the leptl of } own being ! “ » be absorbed in silence back in himself Schelling had modified this every into a vast metaphysical parallelism The ystem of nature,” he rid ut the ime time the system of ‘ p ind a I Na the vist I t the I t nv ble nature And | » whom thought wa only a ad im of tl fer “ held that by a kind f nd i mag to use his fa mou " 1 aman might juggle or shuf i { ind iture together. In his “‘Lehr ling 1 Sa omanticism received per haps i pure expression At the well of freedom y one in that book we sit ! py the great magic-mirror wl ein ind clear the whole crea t ) reveal elf; herein bathe the tender | ind images of all natures, and here “ behold all chamber laid open ind when we wander from this view into e herself, all to us well known and V hou ‘ we recognize every form It illa great scroll, to which we have the key Whereto another prophet | n the book replie in the language of I te elling how a man is lord of the “ ld nd how his 1! brooding mightily ‘ the al of mutable form reduces t! lowly to the eternal order of its ow law of being. der Veaste acines Ichs vow, of the ystemat romanticism of | Fichte and Schelling there is little or noth n th wr ngs of our New England ur endentalist Many of their ideas may be found in Emerson, but divested of their logical yherence; and as for Thor eau metaphys was his aversion,” says William Ellery Channing peculation on he pecial faculties of the mind, or wt h the Not Me come out of the ‘I’ or the All out of the infinite Nothing, he could ( iin Nevertheles n its more | iperficial aspects, almost the whole body | f romanticism may be found reflected, | tly or implicitly, in his Journal and | f il works He foo, had sat roving | well of freedom, and the whole art and y f} life were a pwan of lib- | I i man toa himself he must perf f And this was his mis ict himeelf, and to point to others he | h of f fom Calvinism had been i irded f rd as Lutheranism had ! ! ) romantt ta at Berlin There tall n Thoreau of God and the i) but in pia i sense of individ jaliam, of i me eg m, reaching out » embrace the world in ecstatic commun ion. His religion wae on the urface not dis | milar to hlelermacher mystical con templation of the universe; vast filma thought floated through my brain.” he ya on one o ision; and the true harvest of hi daily life he pronounced a little star-dust caught, a segment of the rainbow which I have clutched.” This revery, or contemplation that spurned at limitations passed easily into the romantic ideal of music—and that in a very literal, some- How far this irony carried him in his hatred of Philistinism and his aloofness from society, no reader of his books need be told. The life of the business man he compared to the tortures of an ascetic, and the California gold-fever threw him into a rage of disgust “going to Cali- fornia It is only three thousand miles nearer to hell The gold of Cali- fornia is a touchstone which has betrayed the rottenness, the baseness, of mankind.’ Nor did the daily commerce of man with man come off much better. He was not one who would “feebly fabulate and paddle In the social slush.” “I live,”” he says, “in the angle of a leaden wall, into whose al- loy was poured a little bell-metal. Some- time in the repose of my mid-day there reache my ears a confused tintinnabulum from without It is the noise of my con- temporaries.”’—Could an image be more ublimely impertinent? Often a passage in the Journal bears the tamp of German romanticism so plainly upon it, that we stop to trace it back in memory to Tieck or Novalis or one of the followers of the earlier Storm and Stress Such are his seattered observations on childhood sacrament thought of a new mythology which is to be The Nation. A to console him for the loss of his times ludicrous, sense. music box was sufficient brother; of the old eemed to him to convey to his soul some instrument the humming wires on a a hand-organ was an gods; and day—his telegraph harp he called it— et harmony of the universe. “The wire my it always brings a special message to me from the Highest.”” This is the thought that occurs over and over again in the Journal More particularly in one passage dated September 3, 1851, and given in fuller form than by the present he harmony of the spheres: redeemer; by Channing editor, expatiates on this mod- ern As I went under the new telegraph wire, I heard jt vibrating like a harp high over- head t was as the sound of a far-off glo- ous life; a supernal life which came down » us and vibrated the lattice work of this life of ours—an Aeolian harp. It reminded me, I say, with a certain pathetic modera- tion, of what finer and deeper stirrings I was susceptible, which grandly set all argu- ment and dispute aside, a _ triumphant though transient exhibition of the truth. There is something bordering on the gro- homage to a it might be enthusiasm of Thoreau te this in rhapsodical wire, but paralleled by like the German brotherhood. Nor unaware of this intrusion of humor into his Like Friedrich Schlegel, he in- the romantic of smiling himself walking jue humming telegraph many a was cat asy dulge in irony lown and through I the affect and doubleness by which I can stand remote from myself as from another. However in- te my experience, I am conscious of the presence and criticism of a part of me, which it were, is not a part of me, but spectator, sharing no experience, but tak- of it; and that no more I than When the play, it may be the tragedy, of life is over, the spectator goes his way. It is a kind of fiction, a work of the imagination only, so far as he was con- upon a doppelganger: human entity; thoughts and of a certain myself as a speak, of am sensible know s0 only scene to nse note 1s you ing it is cerned on sleep, and the all-enveloping of ailence; such is his constant the end of our study and our art—‘all the phenomena of nature need to be seen from . 83, No. 2158 [Vol Men are probably nearer to the essential truth in their sunverstitions than in their science.”” These, I take it, are not cases translation or plagiarism, but rather of that larger and vaguer migration of thought from land to another. They show how thoroughly the transcendental philosophy of of one New England had absorbed the language and ideas of German romanticism, if not its inmost spirit. P. E. M. Correspondence. ‘ ' REAL SIMPLIFIED SPELLIN( TO THE EpItoR OF THE NATION: As exceptionally SIR one who has come into per- with the graduates you per- the current dis- touch the will haps close orthography exhibited ot mit by our schools, me secondary to add word to cussion of the “‘simplified’’ spelling? Dur- ing the last the the English Northwestern instruc- at the three from more than two hundred reputable prepara- fourteen years, of have more tors in department University tested spelling of somewhat than thousand freshmen, coming to us schools, tory and representing nearly ev- ery State in the Union. In order to be sure that we were using, in these annual tests, only such words as belong to the ordinary vocabulary of freshmen, we have taken our lists, regularly, from themes written by freshmen of the previous year in the course of their college work. Now, in comparing the words misspelled in these and in thousands of college with the hundred words in the so-called “‘simplified” list, we find that only two or three words in that list have annual tests, themes, three been generally misspelled by freshmen. Such words as the possessive form “their” and the common verb “lose” are mis- spelled with vastly greater frequency than any word in the three hundred arbitrarily selected by the simplifying committee. If, it be admitted that data from over three thousand graduates of over two then, our hundred schools are sufficiently wide to form a fair basis for generalization, one conclusion is obvious, namely: if all our secondary school graduates were fully to the “‘simplified’’ spelling, it would not reduce their errors in orthography to adopt any perceptible degree One or two other deductions from our long direct observation may be mentioned bearing the We have uniformly given, in the tests, one hundred and fifty words, and have marked “passed” all who misspelled not more than twenty of the hundred and fifty. Yet, al- though great pains were taken, uniformly, to pronounce every word distinctly, and to define it both and by giving a sentence containing it, nearly 60 per cent. of the freshmen, on an average, have failed the test from year year. For many years we have required all who thus as on discussion. out directly to to pass failed to enter a sub-freshman class, one hour a week, and to continue there until they either materially improved their spelling or demonstrated to us that they positively could not learn to spell. The work of this sub-freshman class, sig- nificantly dubbed by our students ‘the pity the point of view of wonder and awe sakes class,”” has. of course, not count-

Page 11

Nov. 8, 1906] The Nation.

ed among the required number of hours in | secured without the college curriculum Although most of the young people who have gravitated into this class have been vehement in de- claring that they never could learn to spell, we from year to year, less than one per cent. of incor- rigibly bad spellers among them. We have not pretended to perform miracles or to render carefully observant, during the of their lives, young people who came to us habitually careless and non-observant But we that a of drill have been sufficient tically all the members of each successive positively have found, rest have found very few hours to cause prac- class to pass readily tests quite as severe as those in which they failed on entering college Our methods have ple. In the first the delinquents on rules for doubling final letters, etc., which but were not, made very familiar to these students in their grammar school and high school days. we have called particular attention to the etymology the been extremely sim drilled well-established place, we have those consonants, dropping should have been In the second place, of English words derived from Latin, so far as such a relation bears upon Eng lish orthography. For example. the dent who has spelled is not likely to repeat such a blunder after stu- “amatory” ‘“‘amitory” he realizes that this word retains the con necting vowel of the first conjugation. But nearly all the improvement that we have been able to secure in the spelling of our students in this sub-freshman has been obtained simply by requiring them to class spell by syllables analytically In other words, we have insisted that they learn to observe carefully the successive con struction of polysyllables After this somewhat wide experience and observation, I am convinced that much of the talk about the difficulty of learning to spell English is not founded on fact I am also convinced that most of the bad or- thography exhibited by our secondary school graduates is due to the unwise, un- scientific, and unpsychological method of teaching orthography to young pupils in our grammar and high schools, generally known as “the word method.” as this method is in teaching the child to read, it certainly teaches him not to spell I am informed by in mental psychology that it is impossible for the ordinary person to perceive intelligent- ly at one volition more than four letters of a polysyllable. The that when even such a common and polysyllable as “multiplication” is placed before a child and then the child, when asked to reproduce, is quite as likely to begin “‘m-u-p” as in any other way. He has gained simply a confused jumble in stead of a clear analysis of the word. An- other deduction, then, is obvious, namely if the time, money, and energy that are now being expended to secure the “simplified” spelling were used toward securing, in our high schools and grammar schools, a wiser method of teaching orthography than that which generally prevails—if would cease teaching pupils noi to spell and would begin scientifically to teach them to spell, the results would be vastly more valuable and more easily attainable than any that can posSibly be obtained by Mr Carnegie’s committee; and they would be Invaluable young specialists experi- consequence 15 “easy , erased, our schools

| | doing violence to the his- tory and the genealogy of our mother tongue 3.8 Cane Northwestern University ber 31 ry SHALL THE ALHAMBRA BE To EDITOR OF THE NATION THI SIR I have been surprised to see in our papers no reference, except your incidental allusion of some w reported 1 When in while in Spain), the the ingerous condit hambra Granada, a year ago (or ! later quieting rumors as to the ! irity of ious building and the po bility of its Besides decay and obstruction of the a el prec falling the peril arising ducts which pervade the palace in all pa that which it was said the corrosive a n of the river Darro, encircles the hi.l w the Alh as to threaten The trophe imbra crowns, had so far proceed to undermine the ru ire emplation fall th dismay con mere as the even in an edifice fills w art or history or be said, the At thetic charm a regard for hambra both in its a nd in it 1 ) is a world-treasure and long That the Hall of th \ of the Two Sisters ciations it on ssadors or that would deeply impoverish the worid of forever The only ondit it? While judiciously that if the authentic, is h question illeged on are Ss ¢ current repairs are at pre

provided for, it m the Spanish Government, throug not be justified in mal poverty, would the large expenditures involved in the rad ical measures needed for security of th structure What can be done, before it is too late? Could there be organized an in ternational commission as in certain other cases even now before the public, which should inquire into the subject and obtain the means which may be required Your own modestly offered suggestion is the tinest, if it could find a respons« When one thinks of the Aladdin-power of the mighty private fortunes of to-day, one can but long that it should sometimes be direct ed to magnanimous aims like this of r« cuing an incomparable world-monument and pres¢ rving it to dazzle and delight men for eight more centuries Is there not among us some large-minded possessor of great wealth,.some man or woman, who shall be touched by the contemplation of such a possible loss to the world and be prompted individually to avert it? If a miscreant still survives in memory as the destroyer of the great fane of Ephesus how long and well shall he or she be re membered who shall invert the ambition of Herostratus and come forward to save the Alhambra? li Philadely Novembe A PURE MENTAL FOOD LAW To THE EpiTtor or THE NATION Sin: I take it that | am an older man than the correspondent in your issue of Oc- tober 25, Prof. Clarence G. Child of the University of Pennsylvania; hence it will not be presumptuous in me to say that for a generation I have held and cham- pioned the position he defends. It seems to me the positior logical and impreg nable For centuri« the degree of A.B has stood for mor: Greek and Latina that it may oft ! t less rather than more has r x lo with the ques- n Let ¢ ew k tha in educa with a " j good il I Ht wha \ hey choose We w I } fler ha no quarrel with their de t “ object to placing an | ‘ 1 I rhaps the rex l i | law can be made to apy ‘ to bodily pabulum Tha hrive ist as well ‘ nea ‘ flour does not ju fy a iler nea the former ler the la r na ( W i ' Att 0 October 20 ’ Notes. I M ] B ‘ t i pr } \ | ) i j | ‘ { I alled The Hu Lit | f) fou , ru ‘ ] ‘ da 5 I Pi \ ind I lited | 4 kin 1 tf i { ) l i i \ga WW ‘ a y J. W. Macka I ed volha I I ind ‘ \ W iney's rhe Def cr ‘ edited t G Re I W Ibe y A <« kk I ! f he lun a! I n | I hara f } bookmal r a 1 by ( I ifthe j rhe nd volume of Saint Min Po f e Caro s l yon ) t l by the Oxf i [ y Press Some : 4 poems hav eV ‘ been P 1 and mn i ww repr if e f n Altog } “ r 1 this I i ful l ! iin j ul work \ nt of ‘ Unw I i Ni Voyages wh 1 containg Admira Sir Thomas Usher ed) and J R. G Rea Ad n Cockbu erland) ID Ho 1 | ig a new ] ) f his an ntro lu 1 f

ealt in the yma f « made the hero of a novel, The R of John Bainbridge (The Macmillan Co: by Henry George, jr It the story of a Young law yer who ¢« rs politics from a sense of luty Cuba is the main topic of the National Gieograpkic Magazine for October A valua ble summary of facts concerning the isl ind, its people, resources, and industries accompanied by a large map and nu merous full-page reproductions of photo- graphs From an interesting account of ostrich farming we learn that there are now 2.500 birds on farms in the United States, more than half of which are the progeny of a single pair, owned in Arizo- na in 1891 Other subjects treated are Korea, Russia's wheat crop, and the burn- ing of clay roads, an economical meth od of good road-making originated in Mis- sissippi by the Office of Public Roads

Page 12

The Cent y Co has brought out a rade editic at a reduced price, of Gen. Horace Porter's “Campaigning with G t ivailable hitherto only in a limit- ! l The chapters originally ap- red ‘ illy in the Century magazine 896-97 The lapse of time has not nged the general impr ion produced by the work at its first appearance It is » sense a formal or comprehensiv: history of Grant campaign indeed, it not pretend to be such It is, rather a sketchy account of Grant's personal lif from day to day by one who stood close to him during the Virginia campaigns, and who has industriously noted the personal habits and tastes of the great commander his comments on men and events, and the happening grave ind gay, of camp and battlefield r book is undeniably enter- ta 1 in its pr ent attractive dres hould have a new lea of lift rhe new i ie, in one volume, of B. E and M. Martin's “The Stones of Paris in Hi ory and Letters’’ (Charles Scribner's ) present no important change save he rrection of a certain number of er ! f detail to which attention was orig- lly drawn in our column The authors hold tl t! philosophical or literary of Rousseau is an extinct quantity p i) likewi that all he j vy of 1 va ! intuition.”” In all il res] t th work hold its own » in resting guide to the antiquities f Lutetia Parisiorum I " yn of a photograph of a man rij yppy of Lincoln Gettysburg ad i which, upon examination, turned out i 1 photograph, not of the original of November 19, IS but of a copy made by | | ir April Is64 has led Di Her Bu ize into a minute study of t ! ry f tl famous address, with special references to the change in i logy which th iddress underwent nh manuscript nd print The results of l qguiry form about one-fifth of the ent fa volume entitled “Gettysburg i Lincoln (Putnam) The rest of the k eontains a readable description of Gettysburg battle, an account of the ition of the national cemetery and Its tory, and a detailed history il quent h nal park and its administration ! nati rhe text is embellished with numerous | of the localities described rhe last i ie of the “American Jewish y ! \ (Jewish Publication Society, ‘ in of « n more melancholy interest Thirty-five pages are given to bulated history of “po- ’ f Kishineff in April 1903, to j \ 1006, and 254 are reck ! rt ! plain, unsensation and = heartre ling Dealt with more y a ! je ! ition in Moro inl j with the Al ue ‘ " he new laws on migra i i on The ac- nt of the | r has t isual strong gy f n 1 unfamiliar gl ind ti t ! f natur which makes h Under the title Iiriefa for our Times,” the Rev. Morgan M. Sheedy, Rector of St John's Chureh of Altoona, Pa., issues a volume of some thirty-five sermons (New York Thomas Whittaker) Mr. Sheedy to be a fearless, straightforward sects | | | | | | | thought The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2158 with a turn for the practical, with ability to couch his in vigorous English. It cannot be said that he has anything surprisingly new preacher, and to convey, or that his thought rises much ibove ordinary reaches, but in spheres in which the majority of people are at home, he deals out common-sense, good morals, and a modicum of religion, in a trenchant and pleasing manner. His sub- jects embrace ethical topics such as ‘‘The Value of Self-Control,” “The Duty of Ser- vice,” social themes like ‘‘The Gospel of Wealth,” “Social Unrest,” with now ind then a more specifically religious sub- also ject The volume of the noteworthy Ger- man work the New Testament edited by Prof. Johannes Weiss of Marburg, ‘“‘Die Schriften des Neuen Testaments, neu itiber- fiir erklart.”’ second and enlarged edition (Géttingen: Vanderhoeck Ruprecht) Professor Weiss has had the coéperation of ome of the of the liberal school, among them Professors Gun- kel and The to torical first on etzt und die Gegenwart ap- pears in @ und most eminent scholars Baumgarten. has been afford an of the New Testa- and to provide for the non-specialist Jiilicher, Bousset, endeavor his- understanding ment i clear presentation of the results of criti- cal inqutry The success of the undertak- ing has been notable, and the volume in hand is a striking witness to the painstak- ing diligence and the powers of insight of The Apostles are Biblical students Synoptic Gospels and the Acts of the ated in Volume I, and a second volume covering the remainder of the New Testa- is promised before the new year German tre ment One of the most important psychological texts in the history of philosophy is cer- tainly Avicenna's concise little treatise on the existence and faculties of the soul. It took up the Aristotelian and Platonic sys- tems and classifications, recast them in a queer combination, and was very largely formative of Muslim thought on the sub- ject Thus it may be said to have stated the standard Arabic position on the func- tions of the brain; other systems might di- but they were philosophically hereti- verge cal, more or less In mediwval Europe it was also formative in Latin versions; through it Chaucer could speak of Arcite’s “celle fantastyk.” But the only accessi- ble form of it for non-Arabists has hitherto been Landauer’s German version hidden away in vol. xxix. of the Zeitschrift of the It seems worth English version E. A Soul,” German Oriental Society. therefore, that been published by Dr the 1906 notice, an van by 94) as has now Dyck ("A Ibn Dyck in but intelligible have added Shahrastani'’s extend Compendium on Pp literally, Sina Verona: by translates very he chools, van students in Egyptian his will be To the references on Avicenna has mind version generally he might ed treatment as translated by Haarbriicker 213-332); De Loer's book, also, which he mentions, Dutch (Religionspartheien,”’ il is in German, not In his “Enigmas of Psaychical Research,” Dr Jame H. Hyslop was occupied with tain abnormal or supernormal psychical vents, which, although as he supposed at tested by competent witnesses, were as yet incapable of explanation. In his new vol moral and | ume, “Borderland of Psychical Research” (Boston: Herbert B. Turner & Co.), he deals with certain abnormal phenomena which have been or which can be explain- ed. Among them are illusions, hallucina- tions, frauds of the medium, and self-de- ceptions of the credulous. He explains cer- hallucinations and apparitions by changes confined to the organs of sense, which have no extra-organic cause. He traces the history of spiritualism, and main- that the contempt of philosophers, not the inherent absurdity of its claims, has put it so completely in the hands of charlatans. He notices also the mistakes made by observers, owing to the dexterity and the tricks of false mediums. But the discussions contained these 400 pages and more, are long and diffuse; and the “Enigmas,” his earlier work, is more en- tertaining by reason of its naiveté and credulity. Those who are interested in the issue between parallelism and interaction- ism should read Dr. Hyslop’s chapter on ““Mind and Body.”” He opposes the former theory, and presents some strong reasons for believing that there is a causal relation between the psychical and the physical. Since the book is written for ‘the laity,” we refrain from wondering why much old psychological lumber has been put into Dr. Hyslop’s earlier chapters. Many years ago Budgett Meakin deter- mined to do for Morocco what Lane had done for Egypt in his ‘““Modern Egyptians.” Thence came a three-volume thesaurus of really great value and one fatal defect. Mr. Meakin had, evidently, not thought it worth while to learn Arabic thoroughly as Lane had done; he contented himself with learn- ing to talk the Moroccan dialect after a fashion. His information, therefore, wher- ever it touched upon book knowledge, was fantastic and unreliable, though his eye and instinct for life were evidently keen and his industry great. It is natural then that his last book, “Life in Morocco” (E. P. Dutton & Co.), as a series of sketches should be more uniformly successful. Bar- ring a few unlucky wanderings into Arabic, its pictures and impressions, dashed in, it is true, in a broad, exclamatory style, are very vivid, interesting, and substantially correct. The spirit of the life of the mass- es, too, has been caught, though of that of the educated and learned, after Moorish fashion, there is not a sign. Mr. Meakin might, perhaps, say that there is no learn- ed, educated side to Moroccan life, but that is hardly so. There are students of the- ology, canon law, poetry, and history still. Instructive, but not so brightly interesting, are the inevitable chapters on the political situation, the moral—probably sound—of which seems to be, Don’t believe anything in the newspapers about Morocco. The last chapters are short views of Algeria, Tunis, Tripoli, Spain, as contrasted with Moroc- The French colonizing method in Al- to make of it an “Africa Provincia” “Afrique Mineure’’—the modification of this in Tunis on more English lines, the Turkish rule in Tripoli, are well brought out The chapter on Moorish remains in Spain is the weakest; everything in it has been said and said again. The illustrations are all good, It marks an improvement in the require- ments for the doctor’s degree in our uni- versities when, instead of a dissertation tain tains in 80 co geria or

Page 13

Nov. 8, 1906] laboring, as is often the case, some insig- nificant point in early English phonology, candidates for that degree are permitted to present as a proof of their capacity an edition of a work of some standard writer especially in the older periods The change unquestionably means a gain for the culture of the individual student, and so we believe, is in the interests of scholar ship in general An example of a recent thesis” (if we may extend the meaning of the term) of this character is Ezra Lehman's edition of “The Tragedie of Cha bot Admirall of France,’ by George Chap man and James Shirley, which has appea ed among the publications of the Unive: sity of Pennsylvania (1906) as vol. x. of the Series in Philology and Literatu! The edition consists of an exact reprint in every particular of the original quarto of 1639 (of which the university possesses a copy), without change of punctuation or even of passages obviously corrupt In a well-written introduction prefixed to the text of the play the editor discusses the relation of its plot to Pasquier’s ‘Re- cherches de la France” (1621), the only source hitherto identified—also the ques- tion who bore the chief part in the com- position of the play. His conclusion that Shirley merely revised Chapman's work is manifestly correct. On the other hand, the editor is not very happy in his explana- tion why this play failed on the stage. “The first four acts,” he says, “have all the elements of serious comedy; there is nothing in them to prepare for the tragic scene of the fifth " This is stretching the term ‘‘comedy” with a ven- geance matter of fact, if the first four acts had been comedy, provided they act use of the As a were good comedy, the men of Chapman’s time would not have bothered about the rest. The real cause for the failure, how- ever, lies on the surface, viz., that Chap- man was deficient in every quality of a good dramatist. In this play there is far too much talking in proportion to action; the characters, with the possible exception of Chabot, are mere shadows, and the lan- guage, though habitually elevated and often even beautiful, is too involved and labored In the scenes to suit a popular audience formal of the incompetence speeches trial dramatic is most apparent The editor has given only a few notes to the text and even of these some are very elementary. In this respect the edition appears to great disadvantage when com- pared with the editions of Ben Jonson's plays in the corresponding Yale series, even after allowance is made for the dif ferent character of the works of the two authors Just what is being accomplished in post- graduate research in Columbia, particular- ly in the Department may be in Dr. John thesis, “Edward Young issued by the Young, though times a wearisome personality, has of to the stu- literature, because of his the influence which he exerted on many writers in Ger- Dr. Kind, Carl Schurz in German appar- Chapter I. of Germanics, seen Louis Kind’s in Germany,” University Columbia Press at always been interest dent of German contemporary repute and many sometime fellow Columbia, has the field ently well surveyed deals with Young's relation to early Eng- lish writers of the eighteenth century, and | Chapman's | The Nation. gives an outline and a critical considera- tion of the “Conjectures on Original Com position Chapter I1., taking up the “Con jectures Germany gives a general su vey of G ul thought on original com- pos | 7 » 1760, no he transla ) f ‘ } ‘ the I itte ’ hricfe ind the | i Oo nality (1759-65), picks ou } t Hiar agische Drar if ] s Hamann and Herd 1 their a ide toward Young Chapter III. contains an historical survey f the N Thoughts” in Germany, and forth its influence on the Swiss Scho ! lidactic poets, Gottsched and h fol wel he philosophical poets, and the (; ingen Dichterbund Some thirty wo well-known authors are considered in de l, not to mention those of lesse fame \ part of the chapter of unusual interest s thi dev d to the re mm against the “Night Thoughts.’ Wieland, who early fed on Young, rejected him late La ng and Herder also tooled in their admiration for the English poet, and even Goeth who wrote to his sister in 1766 that he had learned much English from studying Young and who reflected Young in } We ! forsook him later The other work of Young and their audience in Germany are also presented, and there is a bibliography The book is printed in the simplified spell ing Books on bridge whist are as thick as the autumn leaves. The latest are ‘“‘Dal- ton’s Complete Bridge’ (New York; Stokes & Co.), and “Bridge Abridged’ (New York Duffield & Co.) In the former there is little variation from the many that have preceded, except that Mr. Dalton, in writ- ing on the discard, makes the astonishing statement that American opinion is about equally divided between discarding from strength or weakness He makes some good arguments in favor of strength, and then cavalierly dismisses. them with the statement that “they are not convincing.” They appear, however, to be better than his own in favor of the discard from weakne In “Bridge Abridged,” Annie Blanche Shelby follows in general the beat- en track, but differs from Mr. Dalton on the question of discard, declaring herself in favor of strength “The Arab Horse,” by Spencer Borden (New York: Doubleday, Page & Co.), is an interesting history of the animal, both on his native heath and in the countries to which he has been exported. Consid- erable space is given to the Arabs in America; and their pedigrees and history are interesting to the lovers of the breed. An important work in a new field of American bibliography is Charles T. Har- beck’s “Contribution to the Bibliography of the United States Navy,” just from the press. The bibliography now printed had its beginning (Mr. Harbeck says in his Preface) in the collecting of titles of books not in his possession, with the view of adding these books to his library The volume which now appears is based, pri marily, on Mr. Harbeck’s own collection, but with copious additions He has had the assistance of Miss Agnes C. Doyle of the Boston Public Library and of Axel Mothe of the New York Public Library, who have added titles from those two great collections Though of lesser interest to the reading | 1 to the book coll tor, the vario put s on the navy by the diff s of the G ‘ me i ‘ f the great : portance t the t ) n Th lis fl ted S v y fu The 1 f the 5 4 ny te 1 1 I a f work ! b ! i , . to be ? y ; ny A le } Although tt sf | f rw La s from W. Grav Esq t he Conduct of Rear-Ad Grav North Amer i during his A lental ¢ nand there for Four Mont 178 ecorded, the rriginal ed l l 781 or 1782, is not r Ba of Lak Erie has a para yn, and el es refer to tl lisp ! \ Con modore Perry and Capt . D. Bi t. t the Review of a Pamphlet | " t Docum n Rela » the Diff ‘ ‘ wl } ! 1 between h Commodore Olive Het 1 t. J e D. Elliott By a Citizen if M } etts, Boston 184 ha been « ] ked A number of tith of book by Comn lore Goldsborough have been entered, bu h Reply Attach l | the Navy of the United 8S ‘ t } Coues Portsmouth 1s4 N | 4 find the original pamphlet t Sar 1 Cou which brought forth tl \ ) to Sabin this wa i thin i if r pages published in Boston by the An Peace Society with the tle United 8 Navy What | Its ( By Samucl |} Coues.”” One of the rarest of books on the Navy in the Revolution, the Nar of Nathaniel Fanning, ha ilso been omit ! As first published it had the t \ Narrative of the Adventure of an Am ican Navy Officer, who served d g part of the American Revolution unde Paul Jones New York, 1806 The first i is without the author's names [wo years later the title was reprinted, and in tl later ue it reads Mem of the Lif of Captain Fanning, an American Naval Officer who served during Part of the American Revolution under Con modore John Paul Jone New York 1808."’ The book is a large o avo of 2h¢ pages, in large, clear type, with wide ma gins, in an edition of 350 copies. The com piler, for his personal use, will be glad to know of additional titles relating to the United States Navy which are not included in his Bibliography Charles New York Inquiries may be ad dressed to T. Harbeck, N Broadway The city of Berlin has inherited from the lately deceased book-dealer, Cohn, a valu able Shakspere bibliography, which, how ever, still had given the books and articles is fragmentary, although Cohn titles of more than 30 The authorities of th« city have determined to complete this list wo and the managers of the city libraries at a late meeting made arrangements with th: indefatigable German Shakspere Society to have the work done. Ten or twelve years work will probably be required for this task Sotheby, Wilkinson & Hodge of London will sell the library of the Duke of Suther 24 The few items first land at auction November 19 to 1,787 lots, which can be considered include of the however,

Page 14

The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2158 Among those likely to interest American ollectors are the following Coryat's Crudities,”” first edition, 1611, a larg opy, but with the Strasburg clock ‘ sual, slightly cut into Devenant's “Gondibert the 4to edition, 651 (the &Svo of the same date is generally idered the first), having an original gned poem by Sir John Denham on the fiy-leaf Esquemeling’s “‘Bucaniers of America 6x4, first edition, and with the fourth part published in 1685 rhe Spectator,” “The Examiner,” ‘“‘The Cuardian and “The Englishman all in the original folio numbers Florio's First Fruites,.”” 1578, and his ond Frutes,”’ 1591, both first editions Ffroissart's Cronycles translated by Lord Berners, the first edition in English, printed by Richard Pynson; the first vol ime in 1523, the econd in 1625 4 erie of Gould books on birds, «de scribed as an original subscriber's copy Gower's De Confessione Amantis ser md edition, printed by Thomas Berthelet 1ho4 Higden Polycronicon,” the edition t nted by Peter Treveris in lo2i Vol. I. of Ben Jonson's Workes,” 1616, first edition, large paper, but with one heet supplied from a smaller copy A Third Folio Shakspere, 1664, described a perfect and very sound and clean V but shortish and outside margins f two of the preliminary leaves cut close.” An English manuscript on vé llum of the fourteenth century containing i poem peculum Vite or Mirror of Life com posed by Richard Rolle of Hampole, who lied in 1349 rh family of the late Herman Melville tuthor of ry pee Moby Dick,” ete aré ing materia for a memoir and 1 be grateful if any persons having let by him would lend them to Miss Eliza- beth Melville rhe Florence Fourth Ave i and EKighteenth Street, New York. Such vill be carefully kept and promptly l 1 and returned Waldo G. Leland of the Carnegie Institu tion, Washington, D. C., and Prof. William j Dodd of Randolph-Macon College Auhland, Va., are endeavoring to collect for publication the letters of Chief Justice Marshall Since comparatively few Mar hall papers are known to have been pre erved—except those in the Library of Con- r t becomes necessary to “rake the try for the remnants of a correspon- lenee that must have covered a period of ! fifty yea Any one who has knowl- A {f the existence of Marshall letters a favor by reporting the fact Mi Leland or Professor Dodd I remains of Theodor Momm ported by the Nationalzeitung in " " ha ecently been put into the 1 n of the Royal Library in that cif hief nterest among these papers f lin cheata of letters which Monimnsen de red hould not be published } y i ifter his death To these ter received by Mommaen the library ‘ try t 1d¢d as many as possible of the t? und which h himeelf wrote This iiection of material will throw much lieh mn e political and literary history f he laaet fifty years I 1 il | of h Boston Public j ir just ! rife vine t ne ' to tha f the New York Library shich wa ummarized in the Nation of October 18 The New York Library gained S51 volume Boston, 7,883; in New York the increase of registered borrowers in New York was 101,161; in Boston, 3,450; the gain in circulation for home use was 1,061,128; in Boston there was a loss of 4 When, however, the difference in population is taken into account, it will be seen that the Boston Library is still ahead in relative resources and work done. To equal the per capita circulation for Boston the New York Public Library must idd more than a million to its present cir- culation; and to supply this city with books in the same ratio to population as n Boston, the New York Library must in- ease Its present tock of books threefold In current fiction the Boston Library con- fines its purchases to books of the highest merit according to a rather conservative Standard This policy has been justified; for, as the report says the experience of several years has shown that nearly all ot the works of fietion which for various ison we have found it impossib! to buy, have failed to demonstrate their abil ity to live for even a few months The femand for some of them was insistent for short time now their names are for the most part forgotten, and nobody cares to read them. If we had purchased 4 con siderable number of these volumes, the money, so far as present demand is con cerned, would have been wasted.” Out of the year's total output of fiction, only 161 titles were accepted From these titles, 1.230 volumes were bought, costing $1,260 The total expenditure for all books was $34,460 rhe recent annual report of the City Li- brary of Berlin shows that the average German takes more kindly to solid read- ing than the American. Of the 45,129 vol- imes carried home, no less than 22,327 were of a strictly scientific character, his tory and biography leading, with 4,088 works. The tendency in this direction is apparently growing The percentage of scientific works this year was 33, while a year ago it was only 31 These data are significant, as 52 per cent. of the readers belong to the working classes, and the educated and professional classes consti- tute a very small proportion of those lrawing books. Dean Andrew F. West of Princeton has decided to abide by his present duties as director of the Graduate School, but the moral value of his call to the presidency of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology remains. It confirms, as we have pointed out, the late Francis Walker's belief that scientifiCc education should also be liberal, ind it sets a precedent which trustees of technical schools must consider for the fu- ture It may be inferred that Dean West would hardly have refused so attractive an if he had had assurances that the Princeton Graduate School would be rapid- offer not ly developed in a university direction The idea of an international exchange of professors is being applied on a large scale by the city of Hamburg in the ar- rangement of its academic winter course, which has now been enlarged to cover many of the departments of a full university. Hamburg has secured the services of five foreign scholars: Prof. J. H. B. Master- man, Birmingham, who lectures on Robert Browning; Professor Rosset, Grenoble, the poetry of the Romance languages, and es- pecially Victor Hugo; Dr. W. H. Tolman, New York, industrial reform movements in America; Consul Dr. Solé y Radriguez, Uru- guay, the export trade and industry of his native land; and Miss Gelati, Italy, on the literary movements in Italy. It is proposed in the course of a few years to establish in this commercial metropolis of Germany a fully equipped university. The Leinster Training College for Irish will soon be opened in Dublin for the pur- pose of promoting the study of the modern spoken language and training teachers for primary and secondary schools. The School of Irish Learning, founded several years ago by Dr. Kuno Meyer and others, is chiefly devoted to the study of Old and Middle Irish texts RECENT VERSE. “The Two Arcadias,” by Rosalind Trav- ers (Brimley Johnson & Ince), is that rare thing, an altogether readable first volume Miss Travers has an exuberant poetic fancy; she has a great deal of litera- though she imitates methods rather than effects; and she has true poetic humor. The opening piece, which chiefly gives the atmosphere of the little book, is a dramatic of verse. ture phantasy entitled “‘Arcady in Peril.” To Silvio and Phoebe, engaged in woodland love-making in the Arcadian fashion of strict poetic tradition, enter two cockneys, Albert and Maria, attended by a chorus of " The sharp contrast between the old ideal and the present reality makes possible entertaining business be- tween the four, including the conventional Phoebe thereupon “trippers some interchange of lovers. invokes Diana's aid: O Forest Queen! liear from thy dreamy bowers Far in the and winding glen, Where quenched sunbeams fall in sparkling show ers secret, cool, (Dark boughs between) On strange and starry flowers, Azure and silver-streaked, unknown of men, Hear, and give aid, O Queen! the moorland, wild and wide, the sunny mountain-side; Ry the torrent, cool as snow, Murmuring to the fields below; By the pinewoods, breathing balm; Ry the moonbeam’s holy calm; By all nature's joys, that be Tameless, strong and pure as thee, Hear, and give aid, O Queen! Ry On Diana naturally gives heed to so melo- dious an incantation and promises her suc- A monster introduced, which Sil- vio takes to be a dragon, but Maria, his moment’s paramour, undeceives him: cor is Nil. Ye gods!!—there is a fearful dragon yonder! Mar. O-o-ooh! Where? Nil. On the near highway—his squat and bulky searlet form rests on four short, gray paws—his huge eyes glare—the earth shakes at his breath—oh, terror!—oh, hid- eous monster! Mar. Let me see, though—let me see! (Scrambling up the mound.) Why, you silly cuckoo, it’s nothing but a motor-car! Silvio refuses to “touch the accursed thing,”’ which is “too loathly-formed, too vile.” Maria thereupon returns to Albert, and they make off with the motor. It blows up, in accordance with the goddess’s plan of vengeance, hurling the trippers far city- ward; and Silvio is restored to the arms of Phoebe in a reéstablished Arcady. The piece then concludes with a_ significant chorus of nymphs: Where the hues of sunset fall, Where the sky is primrose-pale,

Page 15

Nov. 8, 1906] The Nation. And the silver moon hangs low; Faint and few the starry "Tis the land of fancy-d: Thither gieams eames go! mortals, let us Westward There's the burns the splendid sky Realm of Poesy Sought of many, found of few In that lambent air and fire Fragile-winged thoughts expire Withered, drop to earth anew 5 tut to Fancy’s paler sphere Ye may journey free of fear Even as our light verses fly Ye have wings, though cramped and smal Fancy-flights upbear you all; Mortals! spread your wings and try! Miss Travers was particularly discreet in choosing to draw her pastoral air from the Arcadias of Ramsay, Milton, and limiting herself ‘ancy. And artificial Sidney, thus resolutely within the sphere of F fantastic as the fable is, it is made poetically con- vincing by the delicate flair of the author The second of the two Arcadias is found in “The Suburbiad,” a celebration in the manner and metre of Pope of Mammon's gay mistress crowned The willing nymph Suburbia The hectic, gaudy life of climbing subur- bans is pictured with a metrical neatness and a firmness of satiric tone that, coming | after the long disuse of the genre, have an effect of pleasing novelty But a deeper poetic spirit moves under the satirical sur- face than one at first suspects: as we near the end, we come upon a passage which, read in connection with some of the short- er and less whimsical pieces in the vol- ume, gives high hopes of poetic pleasure from Miss Travers’s future work Yet many a City man may slowly fare Riverward, seeking peace and twilight there But all in vain pale dreams of far delight Steal o’er the dusky violet-beds of night; While great elms slumber in the meadows gray And the white moon begins her tranced way For still his anxious purpose never leaves The hope of gain; still cunning nets he weaves To catch the elusive gold; dark webs that lie Sad o'er the thought, and cloud the wistful eye “Ah, could I plunge deep in some quiet river! And rise, newborn in splendid strength, to shiver The old, unshapely life to pieces! tear Away the tawdry vain-delight; lay bar The waste of yeare, the wrong of mean desires and sordid care! Then build the home anew, on pillars firm Of comradeship and trust which years confirm; With simple joys and kindly neighborhood And general labor for the common good! Thus will the sad, suburban father dream Resting his gaze upon the cool, slow stream Then, breaking the couplet’s bonds Look up, O men! Shut in with little miseries, futile task And meanest self-inflicted care, arise! Fling wide the dusty windows of your soul On spring and sunshine, melody and mirth! A newer morning breaks o'er field and town; The sad air quickens; kindly gods are near! The “Poems” of Anne Whitney, privately reprinted with some rearrangement, forty- eight years after their original publication, are a gracious echo from that tempus ac- ceptabile, the transcendental One eould hardly be young in New England in the thirties and forties and not write poet- ry, certainly not a person of Miss Whit- ney’s temperament and Her poems are full of the engaging agitation, the alert catholicity, the earnest joyousness of those eager emancipated years. The de- fects of the transcendental quality are hers too, and not a few of the pieces have a cer- period receptivity tain mystical prolixity that reminds us that they we written in the day f es Yet Miss Whitney has, probably as the re sult of a vivid artistic tem, ame a dis tinct quality of her wn. In the concluding poem the only new piece we I eve n the volume, she is seen at her best Ey as a rose Fulfilled of beauty and des Lets fall its petals one by one The good day goes Subsides with mellower nots th wave's g ewell: Tt t ght gathers ir he «de And all hues melt in one 4 sma r } “ His cedar on the cliff And the listening q t of t pose lrills forth his evensong ris ev nes rhe rest, the peace The strife of day outgrowr We know the sign and heed the low md And hand in hand, Rearing our treasure safe above t blight And waste of years—the slow su aw Of Life's full fount—we irney f With trust in the great Mystery Toward the fast-coming night The easily-won, temperamental optimism the gentle if somewhat thin: piety, which marked the poetic work of Susan Coolidg: and won many readers, is the most notabl trait in her ‘“‘Last Verses" (Boston: Little Brown & Co.). How much may be attained without great heat of imagination, distin tion of thought, or richness of style, by sensitive perceptions and a fluent and lucid manner, may be seen from these lines on Helen Keller: Rehind her triple prison-bars shut in She the whitest soul on earth to-day No shadowing stain, no whispered hint of sin Into that sanctuary finds the way There enters only clear and proven truth sits Apportioned for her use by loving hands And winnowed from all knowledge of all lands To satisfy her ardent thirst of youth Like a strange alabaster mask her fa Rayless and sightless, set in patience dumb Until like quick electric currents The signals of life into her lonely place Then, like a lamp just lit, an inward gleam Flashes within the mask'’s opacity The features glow and dimple suddenly, And fun and tenderness and sparkle seem To irradiate the lines once dull and blind While the white slender fipgers reach and cling With quick imploring gestures, ques ning The mysteries and the meanings her mind The world is not the sord'd world we k It is a happy and benignant spot Where kindness reigns, and jealousy fs pot, And men move softly, dropping as they gx rhe golden fruit of knowledge for all to share And Love is King, and Heaven is very near And God to whom each separate soul is« d Makes fatherly answer to each whispered p aye Ah, little st ess soul, shut in 80 clos« May never hint of doubt creep in to be A shadow on the calm security Which wraps thee, as its fragrance wraps a rose The title of William Byron Forbush's “Ecclesiastes in the Metre of Omar” (Bos- ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co.) is perhaps a little misleading It is not so much a consecutive rendering of the words of Kohe leth as an imaginative construction of the Rubaiyat he might have written, made by a very eclectic assembling of words, phrases, and images from the Scripture woven to a single texture and skilfully col- ored and cadenced to resemble the manner of FitzGerald It is none the less, despite some roughness, a successful bit of work in its sympathetic insight as well as in its technical ability. The brooding, skeptical old poet, who has had the odd fortune to retain for so long a place among the canon- | forth by the author in cal writers i is t " the book 4 WwW I + * So ¢ 5 “ I ‘“ I Rut ‘ I P N } The v a A sug ‘ a f A k I ‘ VN if 5 l bear . ; " \ ® 4? t ‘ v Hi e | s’ 8 ry er I kh } ; \\ B {™M \ (‘o ! t ! H } ' of } ‘ Ve " } ) t? rn ve We 1} ntery] f rt I t l luring w k rt ‘ li by the gt p Phis qu M } l rwilight M n Mo M 1?) I poetry whicl with indersstreben, comm it weave neverthe the reader's mood l’ ima Patel Gilt r ( t? hig ! ! or i ‘ f TY il AY | ( h 1 i l with ease Kase ! " Jot 1’ Many I ! ‘ rf ” ! } of " } i i by a lay I i Ar } ! } \ ! \ fir hi i f I ‘ bef ' ' l and rite i il a " work highly | 4 ving ? a dusky £ P ‘ 1! in N i ~ ke if nd is Hinlf ¢t r kr the Ar i. nt 1 * The ripples in t And tin r t . I. ! r Within the K As graceful as Half hidden Night and Morning by (The John Lane Co), is t woman taken in adultery ret esquely colored blank ver aginative addition of the p lover, a ‘subtle Greek” The r Leonida Argument

Page 16

396 purpose of the piece is to elucidat« the di vorce problem by maintaining the “higher inner law of love itself which in itself is the highest freedom,” and which is “a Reatitude rather than a Law.” The poem not very explicit in its embodiment of the argument, and there is some contradik tion The meaning seems to be the rather hazy one that the higher love being a state of Beatitude demands the renunciation of human relations—though just how this bears upon the crux of marital infelicity d not clearly appear. The mood of the poem | admirable throughout ind the rkmanship respectable CURRENT FICTION The livragon Painter By Mary McNeil Fen losa I ) i tlhe Brown & Co Unfortur ly tatisti ire hardly at ible a ! ictual proportion of fond Japanese maidens who have been will y n o the triumphant allurements ‘ lure incor lerate foreign lovers In Japanese stories we read—usually writ by ourselve thi theme is so preva ha yur general conception of love Japa night be visualized by a collay l | figure weeping in the wake of a de- M Fenollosa, in het ly of he a t temperament in Ja ‘ ly avoids this hackneyed subject } rragon Palit is smoothly told, full f caret 1 sa factory descriptions. It ) ul ! of contemporary Japan " pan of enter ng daily papers, whose maak hang about old Kano’s gate leavoring to snatch a likens of his fa- on-in-law Kano himself i in h u mmfortable position of the enthusiastic ai who sud nivy find him If cast for the rdéle of hide-bound ignoramus by the d overy of u it once greats ind more untram melled than himself Since Kano adore Katsuo and mily w he to instruct nd el h him not a public dis ofitur bu merely a case of complete, i I nketing ro secure the ge (lackit i m of h own) Kano mar the wild mountain lad to his own care f brought-up daughter. Instead of bare | ng th alliance from filial piety, { ‘ » falla undutifully, not to say inde | n love with her husband, and the " ! » pleasant a honeymoon that no ly power will induce the genius to get back to hi ! imhe The n t ting part of Mrs. Fenol | to her deseription of the painter, } few! , ! irt, and towards the f b If the reat of the book ‘ alt neat particularly atriking, tt 0 t ble revelation of the j ! ! | failsa to cast upon yu t ranger Heyond the Rocks. Wy Elinor Glyn. New York: Harper & It her All the parents who we loubt about letting thelr lbuta laughter brow upon The \ of Elizabeth may turn them loose ipon Beyond the Kocks’ without a twinge of misgiving haying aside satire and cyniciam Elinor Glyn | tella a straightforward love story of the kind specially suited to young ladies in their teens. This statement must, however, The Nation. be qualified by a confession that the spot lees Theodora is kissed, and vulgarly peaking, hugged, on several occasions by her irresistible lover, Lord Bracondale Nevertheless, as her invincible goodness transforms him from a_ thorough-paced Lovelace into a patient and considerate Ritter Toggenburg, the impression left by her history is one of unflawed discretion Her sweetness furthermore transforms Jo siah Brown, her plebeian husband, into as a gentleman as King Mark of Cornwall; the amount of danger nobility the part lovers, Josiah opportunely succumbs and after exactly suitable despair and on of the to a trifling ailment fact about so this is that it should ring very old-fashioned, not in theme—since an innocent young girl sac- rificed by rapacious relatives belongs to all but in The and frivolous pen of “The Visits ot its Gyp-like au- the The curious story time manner and treatment witty Elizabeth” has quite lost audacity, evaporated. The light exaggerated modernity, have vanished the till ladies who once thrilled over the ‘“‘Duchess’ the that Elinor Glyn’s feel no apprehension when dacity Unfortunately, with the touch, sparkle also the with malice, * may (with assurance syntax more solid) see their young daughters similarly thrilling over the temptations and triumphs of the lovely Theodora. they The Call of the Blood. By Robert Hichens. New York Harper & Bros Not long ago we were hearing much from persons who for one reason or other id many novels, of a story by Robert Hichens called “The Garden of Allah.” Here at last, we gathered, was a work of real importance, something which could be counted on to arrest the attention of the most indifferent or the most skeptical We read it with care, and were dishcart- ened to find that it could not do for us what it had apparently done for others We found here and there descriptive pas- ges which were undoubtedly “vivid’’ and picturesque Elsewhere we found a pomp of phrase and portentousness of mien which at second glance appeared to be «mpty—like a brocade supported by its own tiffness, and really containing nothing hu- man The tale and the persons, like the tyle, seemed hollow inventions Yet we observed many earnest people applying a reverent ear to this artificial shell, and innouncing that they heard the ocean The “Call of the Blood” is in many weys 1 better book—a sincere book, if not a great one It contains less speech, and more matter The emotional tone is less forced, and the utterance less strained and oracular. We are not expected to gasp at every seene or thrill at every situation. A outhern setting is again employed An Englishwoman, past her first youth, mar- rhe a young Mercury, nominally English whose temperament is really determined by i strain of Sicillan blood At the bride's natance, they go to Sicily for their huney- moon Presently, being a person with an ivanced sense of duty, she leaves him to nurse an old friend, a man whom she might have married The bridegroom is ufficiently magnanimous to approve of this act; but, left to himself, he listens to “the call of the blood,” seduces a peas- ant girl, and Is killed by her father. This [ Vol. 83, No. 2158 consummation hardly amounts to tragedy, for the culprit is not so much a person as 1 temperamental victim of heredity. He not greatly engage the sympathies, ind the details of his error rather pall in the rehearsal. Nor are Mr. Hichens’s rotie touches grateful to a normal palate; they smack of that sentimental voluptuous- ness, which has marred and, one fears, few modern novels of loes popularized not a merit; for example, those of James Lane Allen In the end one is impressed with the fact that the true theme of this story is not suggested by its title. As a study of true friendship it is worthy of note. The faun-like hero, whose acquired sense of duty, whose true affection even, is not proof against the working of inherited temperament, is hardly more than a foil for the contained virtue of the friends who suffer by his existence. The Cruise of the Violetta. By Arthur Col- New York: Henry Holt & Co. Arthur Colton in the past proved himself too accomplished a story teller to turn out with impunity a bit of fooling so mediocre as “The Cruise of the Violetta.”’ He writes admirably, and describes with unusual charm, and possesses a mark- ed and delightful sense of fun. But in this case the humor He approaches the ticklish realm of burlesque with too great cocksureness. After a beginning as promising as the opening to ‘Mrs. Lecks and Mrs. Aleshine” (a conscientious, Pres- byterian lady from the Middle West scotching a Haytian revolution with knock- out drops is worthy of Stockton at his pleasantest) the pace is not kept up. Or to be exact, the story turns into a sort of musical comedy libretto, in which the comic intention is more apparent than the By the time that Mrs. Mink has settled the affairs of Hayti, outridden married the doctor, spanked (vicariously) a Kanaka king (incidentally settling a of Polynesian politics) picked up an orphan in the Malay Archi- and kidnapped a high- class Hindu fakir, and taken a hand in the electric light system (and revolution) in a small South seaport, you are fully convinced of Mr. Colton’s cosmopoli- ton has sees is forced. achievement. a tornado, bout pelago, buncoed American tanism, but rather tired of fantastic ad- venture. After reading “The Cruise of the Vio- letta,”” to regain faith in Mr. Colton’s ability and intention, one has, however, only to read, or re-read, his earlier vol- ume, “The Belted Seas.” Princess Maritza. By Percy Brebner. New York: T. J. McBride & Son. The hero of Mr. Brebner’s “Princess Maritza” is an English officer, who, con- victed, unjustly, of course, of cheating at cards, is cashiered and turns his back on his country his sword as a soldier of fortune to the service of the King of Wallaria This small but important State, which may be supposed to stand for Servia or Bulgaria, since its affairs rivet the attention of all the European cabinets, has all the equipment of a novel of the type of “The Prisoner of Zenda’: a stupid puppet of a king, an intriguing queen, a to dedicate lovely pretender to the throne, the copper- haired Princess Maritza, and, not least,

Page 17

Nov. 8, 1906] the reckless English captain of horse. The incidents are numerous though unconvinc- ing, the run with blood, best- dressed and frivolous women of the court turn out to be expert diplomats, more a match for a am- bassador, and mysterious signals are given streets the most than seasoned English from every house and street corner. But all this may be present and one thing be lacking. The personages do not live, we are indifferent to their fates, and when a lovely countess dies, in the main square, a case of heroic self-sacrifice, we feel that we could have watched the heroine fall instead, without a qualm. This is not so with the Seraphinas and Flavias of the masters of this type of fiction The German Workman: A Study in National Efficiency. By W. H. Dawson New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $1.50 net Agitation of the “fiscal question” in Great Britain has had at least one wholesome effect; it has marvellously stimulated in terest in the economic and social policies of those countries which are felt to be her chief rivals in the contest for the markets of the world. Of this fact William Harbutt Dawson's useful volume is the latest and not least significant bit of evidence Unlike Ashley’s “Progress of the Ge man Working Classes,’’ the book is not con cerned with the industrial effects of th German tariff; nor does it, like Shadwell’s “Industrial Efficiency,’’ deal broadly with all important factors in national economik progress. Confining himself to the socia! legislation by which for a generation pa the Germans have sought to guarantes workers a tolerable standard of living, M Dawson undertakes to investigate the meth ods employed and results achieved, to the end that his own countrymen may profil by the experience of their redoubtable competitor Previous study had qualifie! him thoroughly for his task, and he ha produced a volume which, if not attractive ly written, is probably the most convenient guide for ture into the mazes of German NSocialpolitik head the English readers who would ven- One's fairly swims as one contem- plates various and complicated insti- Government has of the for the for the sick, convalescent paternal benefit which a for the Decent tutions created working | housing marrie classes. laborer, temporary shelter home- less, for the homes to insure a permanent cure, crusades medi- hospitals against such plagues as tuberculosis cal treatment for children in the schools— these are some of the provisions designed to promote health and industrial efficiency Public employment bureaus, lodging-houses for the entertainment of travelling work- men, labor colonies for travellers who do not desire to find work, insurance against unemployment, relief works for the actual- ly unemployed, for those who need nothing but seasonable in keeping able-bodied When poo! and information bureaus advice, men from becoming public charges these agencies fail, the laws, which, although not perfect, ministered by men of intelligence and prac- often in England, cooperate there are are ad tical sense; and not, as by persons “without special qualifications who join boards of guardians for the mere pleasure of over-assessing their neighbors property and under-assessing their own ' | i | | The Nation. But further than this. as we all know, German legislation provide nsurance, on a national scale, against sickness, accident and old age; and it is upon these topics that Mr. Dawson's volums s disappoint ng. Since the beneficiar f the indus- trial insurance laws are now numbered by tl te 1 f and th y 1 I f t r has beer oO} t gq ¢ igh to able one to r fa y the r i there opportunity here for a 1 ‘ irch ng vestigation than y f gn observ er has yet made of the tual ] me f ! legislatior by vw t I narck ? to outbid tl S Democrats Ge wi I it 1 1s that he ilts of comy y e have bee g rally favoral ! no ’ j ht the 1 hon esty f tt reports B to t Ww h 1 th me one who ‘ with more l hment would lertah i hing ‘ } 1 idy sf the I yblem Ou wh Prof He W Fa m h made o ’ two To y into } field ind » | gretted that Mr. Dawson did not « V mething of ! ) Inst ! f th howeve he give meé ly a ! nal immary f } prov of he W nd de I h n hine t! } which t p ate Ou author not blind » th po ble langers of the experiment which Ger many has tried; neither fair to say ire ye of the Germa who have shown no littl horse sens¢ in administering ind kings which approach very closely the danger lings In Frankfurt, for in tance where it has become the estab lished policy to provide relief” work in i of unemploymer the town coun cil has deliberately avoided committing lf to the do ne that the municipal should find work for all it citizens It proceeds co tently on the theory that he relief work undertake imply ‘‘to | ve inv exter! v call for publ Ss rm lief nd deni that obligations ! ny furthe than h safeguard ng of finar al inters 3 Nor does Mr. Dawson allow h reader to suppose that every arrangement which works well n Germany would operate equally well in Great Britaiz on the contrary, he never fail to make lue allowance for differ- ences in national temperament institu tions, and inherited traditior Yet, upon the whol hi verdict ij distinctly fa vorable to the work which the Germans have been pushing with persistence and in telligence for a full generation He be lieves that in social legislation, as well as in science or technology, Great Brit in has much to learn from Germany and his book should bring not a few of his countrymen to a hopefully receptive frame of mind Lectures on Modern History By Lord Ac yn New York: The Macmillan Co. $3.25 net The late Regius Professor of History at Cambridge has been so lauded by those who came under his influence that it is perhaps worth while to inquire what should For us ‘ be of his asure the the ich exact me inquiry, praise st volume before an most Pollock, h Pp one of Acton's emotional lecture wa in trut? of the first work performances mnderful his strength; he truck tl of his he not, however a ecritte It w aer a ew There was imag ition Acton his vast irers wa store of accumulated details that had when to Mary Trent erected immorality at in the volume now under review, tatements a the following on Peter the William I be might and Frederick the first Europe without th other it Great out might ind ian.”’ And His letter one of the volumes of correspondence published of re but to o Mary lastly, as Acton’s literary output Gladstone constitute mo imulating 4st remarkable and st cent years correspondence cannot t the chief admirers have should be directly treated of a acholar His name as produc t that his something been anxious with associate: i more representative, and the two this these the delivered at the for with, poor books, volume have Lecture of Cambr very competent editors of set to work to elaborate on Modern History’ from notes one of the he The on and the reasons seek. To begin generally make ige disappointing far to courses result is, whole this are not notes for lectures and it is

Page 18

a n ti ‘ Again, the subject is too for the pace in which it is treated i from ercompression For in Acton covers modern t fall of Constantinop! f ( on in 1787 re on coupled with morbid d re for stating genet | ‘ occasionally whole para h history gets strangely di f ti perhaps Lhe most con mple is the la paragraph of t whicl within the pace of | } 1m him f ) proy itior that our Civil ‘ } lach fa lefinition ‘ ition; that Liberalism’ the i mor uu fraud” [ ple of Federalism has nunity more power! f 1 more lligent than world n all of which ache will easily discern fl generalizing from part | ‘ ‘ ie a a whole th he early period, the wars h elghteenth century y | " This is doubt nat in his follow he Fre h Revolution, Acton vement of opiniou Running through tom i phase } mn Rena la the n uspring of \ t! ‘ ft ) the j f over po ‘ o that ! \ to this line | though it be he u ! \\ 1 of warning, that ) 1 qu ions ‘ il w I hould be } | lo not vouchsafe ! i tl ! used ' ! , | ) ‘ ; j | hal i} Ht l } re if Mu | ! ! h bu | j it ‘ ler ! im ’ }? ‘\ 1 | | ) " i te , | ) i v1 by Ameri I ! Dr. Ha own ! mal bith ample ! I here at ! h of an ! l-informed ! aD ! ire ! the x ¥ Yor guild ! ! | l ‘ ! ! ited ! ! f iyi { ! l i ify } ! ' } ream of personal ! ! of Mr 1 " fr year } ' ’ tly ha t now I the The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2158 One defect of the work we may illustrate by a quotation: “ ‘A little college,’ Daniel Webster said; ‘but she has children who love her Now that is just what Mr Webster would have said if he had been Mr. Hale, but being Mr. Webster his words were It i sir, as I have said, a small rllege And yet there are those who love i We would not overrate the impor- ince of what is in itself a mere trifle, but typical of an inexactness against which one must always be on his guard in reading Dr. Hale, or any other writer who falls into the habit of drawing upon a rich- ly stored memory without checking results by the aid of external authorities. There ire nearly two hundred illustrations, on the whole well selected Drama. Nir Henry Irecing, a Biography By Percy Fitzgerald. Philadelphia: George W. Ja- cobs & Co It is too soon yet to look for anything like an authoritative and judicial estimate of the histrionic genius of Henry Irving— for genius he undoubtedly possessed, though it was limited by arbitrary bounds Al- ready he has been the subject of a consid- erable mass of printed matter, but most of has proceeded from enthusiastic eulo- either intimate friends or interest- | cribblers Mr Fitzgerald belongs o the former category, and reveals the re- lationship clearly enough in many of his glowing periods; but he is not so blinded that he cannot see the spots upon his lu- minary Moreover, he is a practised work- man in biography, and his book gives a really comprehensive view of the actor's caree! It would be better if it were a little more conservative and a little less discursive, but as a rule his selection of matter and his arrangement of it are both good, while his comment is generally per- tinent and well informed Without indulging in repetition of weari- some details, he shows how much Irving was indebted for his mastery of the tech- nical business of the stage to his long training in the old stock companies, and especially to his service, or rather servi tude, in Dublin and Manchester. Bills were often changed half a dozen times a week, und it was a common thing for him to play three parts in an evening He acted in pantomime farce, comedy, and tragedy Even then he attracted attention by the ire he devoted to his make-up. He would pend his last penny to get a correct cos- Lume From his earliest boyhood he fre- quented Sadler Wells to study the acting and elocution of Phelps in Shakspere In earlier days his speech was almost entirely free from the tricks which disfigured it iter. His first marked successes in London, is Cheventx, Rawdon Scudamore, and Digby Givant, were due to the minute finish of his york rather than inspiration lie was TT uspected of having any peculiar power of «emotional expression until he found him elf, so to speak, in Hood's Dream of Eu gene Aram” and in “The Bells’; and it is worthy of note that to the end of his career, in tragedy or melodrama, it was in the portrayal of the terrors of a guilty con- ence that h hiefly excelled. His Louis XI., Vanderdecken, Richard III., and Mac- beth are cases in point. It is curious that Mr. Fitzgerald, generally pretty critic, seems to prefer Coquelin’s dull Ma- a sound thias to Irving's imaginative conception Speaking of Irving’s Macbeth, Mr. Fitz- notes that it underwent many At first its moral and intellectual feebleness excited much derision. Later on gerald changes it became firmer and bolder, though never a satisfactory impersonation In reading the part on the platform he made it much more impressive His Hamlet, although the cause of much controversy, was always Mr Fitzgerald Phil- ip, in Tennyson's play, as one of his mas- popular regards terpieces in the portrayal of eccentric char- acter. When the famous production of “The Merchant of Venice” the at which An by was made, event was celebrated by a great supper, many illustrious persons were present awkward situation was brought about Lord Houghton, who, in a satirical speech, intimated that Shakspere had been entirely Irving parried the attack with smiling good temper, and thus eclipsed by the scenery averted what might have been a painful scene. Lord Houghton’s complaint, accord- ing to Mr. Fitzgerald, would have been much more justifiable in the case of ‘‘Ro- meo and Juliet,’’ when Shakspere was, he says, literally ‘“‘smothered in scenery.” Ir- ving’s Romeo he grotesque His lago, was, he says, one of the best things he ever did. of Edwin Booth, but his judgment in this case will be Perhaps there is a little prejudice in it, for he timates that Booth, had been treated with great generosity Irving, did attempt to return the compliment when the United know whether describes as absolutely on the other hand, He prefers it, apparently, to that not generally accepted In- who by not English player was in the States It be Irving had any grievance on this score But it impossible to note all the teresting points in Mr. Fitzgerald’s pages would interesting to is in- Only one or two more can be mentioned. It certainly is not generally known that “Twelfth Night” had a hostile reception when first presented at the Lyceum,andthat Irving was forced to make a protest before the curtain. It appears that his Malvolio, an admirable conception, was quite misunder- That his Joseph Surface, played at benefit, He tried to play it along have it traces begin- stood a memorable was an utter failure, is not surprising new lines, and to spoiled utterly Mr the ning of Irving's decline to his separation from Ellen Terry He pathetic picture of the last few months of the great life Misfortune after misfortune him He his theatre, his great stores of scenery were burned, he was and his health was failing. He was broken both spirit, but he struggled on the hope of making money enough to keep him In his prosperity he had been both of money and of need he had neither Death was merciful, seems Fitzgerald draws a actor's overtook lost crushed by debt, mind and courageously in in in old age recklessly prodigal and in the one nor the other etrength, his him from humiliation, and crowned him with honor in Westminster Abbey, be- fore the memory of all his triumphs, the- atrical and social, had begun to grow dim saved tragedy, “The Virgin work of a new dramat- new classic " the first The Goddess

Page 19

Nov. 8, 1906] The Nation. ist, Rudolf Besier, which has just been produced at the London Adelphi, appears to be a remarkable work, in spite of some faults, largely due to youth and inexpe- rience. It is, as we noted in our issue of October 25, written upon the lines of the old Greek plays; and it is said to be as in- teresting as it is bold and imaginative. Artis, a legendary city, is in peril of the enemy Cresphontes, the king, is willing to make a disgraceful truce, but his Queen Althea and his people are all for resist- Althea then for Hzephestion (sic), the exiled brother of her husband, who the fainting troops and the king still upon capitulation, kills him. As the king's dead body is borne to the temple of Ar- temis, it is met by his mother, who calls sends ance alone can reanimate He returns, as insists for vengeance She consents to pardon Hgephestion, however, if the deed was really done for love of country In the next act there is but one scene; Althea and Hzphestion are alone, and the latter confesses that and not for country, that he slew his brother. She re- and both rejoice bar their it was for her, ciprocates that there is But Artemis, the Virgin Goddess of city, will permit the to go punished; she proclaims, through her ora- cle, that Cresphontes must be avenged, that Althea must be put to death other hand than that of Hwphestion,or Artis Moreover, his passion, nothing to union the un- not crime by no and all its people shall perish adds the oracle, Hwphestion shall not stir from the altar until this vengeance be accomplished. In the fourth act Hwphes- tion is disclosed at the altar steps. The troops are clamoring for their leader; the enemy is advancing. But Hzphestion can- not move Again and again he strides forward, defying Heaven; again and again he is paralyzed by an unseen force. Pow- erless as he is, he cries out that Artis may fall and all its people perish, but he will not the Queen The contempt and rage of his mother and of the despairing women cannot change him. Not till Althea herself comes and tells him that slay cries this is the crown and glory of their love does he lead her within the temple, there to fulfil the decree of Fate. Soon he re- turns and announces, ‘‘The Queen is dead.” At the words victory comes, and the enrap- tured people shout their joy. But he stands rigid, a figure of stone, and so the play ends It seems to have been acted very finely Miss Brayton was a noble figure as Althea; Miss Genevieve Warde acted the old blind Queen mother with wonderful ef- fect; while Oscar Asche made Hephestion heroic in his fierce love and furious de- spair The representation, as a whole, seems to have been one of the most notable | of recent events on the English stage Whatever of and it likely to considerable Arthur Conan Doyle’s military romance, ‘Brigadier | degree success is | be awaits Gerard,”” which was produced in the Savoy Theatre of this city Monday evening, must be the of Kyrle Bellew, who played the hero with a dash and grace which few, if any, of his younger poraries could equal. The itself, al- though pretty well furnished with more or placed to credit contem- play less picturesque incident, is but poor stuff dramatically, the plot being a mixture of very old stage materials, and the rough | machinery at tims creaking ather dis dainty charm earnes and elegance | mally without being } . 4- the sa | Charles Serit S blist - subtle Acee and when he | atts ve little vol farses 1 plays own |} her the \ | Richard Haz g | , ) added cha f P , | The Galloper und M P with f x ’ | all f which er { . 8 bine " of | , y | , M > at i nS . pu x | ll } pt s ‘ ! j ene witl grouy ' y) 4 ! i’ | played } which w g ‘ , rem lie w " lecto of h t} , . , - veal : } Mad l \W Next week Houghto Mim & Co . 1 that | " } ' lish Th Strugel ‘ — Stag ‘ in f ! ! hf London.” by Wa Nick —— . . es structor in English a Ya r wer po ‘ Sy gives ay : f ti a a of his mos " 1 work : : library of the Madel l oly which gned I i 843, and } } ! r ! . 4 ] far ‘ . ‘ ! _ 7 nied act, and w t N ‘ _ ' magia > Societ an Saint-Saens leatt nour th t ha t all the plays that were included in its first six volumes without such tre ment and that | VWodern Viusi and Vu Ine Thy I A future issut will ir 1 ‘ he com Streatfeild New York r? M pared with the original texts or photo- | ©® $2.75 graphic cop’ rh will also Y Mr. Streatfeild he word is an extra volum ) f he 1 a very | , h recently recovered | \ Wealth ind 1 } book beg 2 upte Pa Health” and Impa ] er with w! Wa 14. and Bach ther matte of ind Hand wt . , , Hi - , ’, , , - 5 ey ! hoy 4% g at » tra ‘ . ly of the works of the grea ip 4 \ LISIC, h growth of the lea of a por ba } ind he hope i a will I I mn ‘ f > Ww i rinple h \ THE SAINT-SAENS CONCERT f programme : Ste halleves the It had been arranged that M. Saint-Saé t amere s such as the ad should make his Ame in début in Bos a of ab i r would have t ton a temporary indisposition, however t " 4a mea of exp iz human made necessary a re ingemé of dates em 1 as defi e and \ As a f and thus the honor of w ming France's s s After th prea « greate composer fell to New York He rather surprised to find » 1 abou was announced for two ppeara with programme nu n h \ ‘ That the New York Symphony Orchestra, last hows W lo not eas a faul As a Saturday and Sunday; but the demand for matte f fa h ibj of programme ticket wa so great that two extra con mus has re ved 1 recent yea her certs with Saint-Saens programmes ex- more than s share of atten n clusively, were heduled for November 15 There is a good deal that nsula } and 18 He was welcomed to Carnegie | Mr. Streatfeild To him Handel ' Hall with a_ cordiali that contrasted Shakspere of mu and he has the usual sharply with the coldly polite greeting ac- English aversion to deep mu al emotio corded last season to another French com- apart from the religiou phere One reads poser, Vincent d'Indy, who represents the with mingled amusement and weariness Parisian branch of the modern school of tha over all Chopin's mus lies the dead cacophony. Unlike D'Indy, Saint-Saéns be ly ail of disease and that Tchaikovaky lieves in using dissonance as a means, and nk » morbid pessimism, he rise to not as an end, and the musical public is hysteria In h remarks on two English certainly with him fols—Pureell and Mendelssohn—our author With his fresh and abundant melody, his | 82ow yn the other hand, a surprising de piquant harmonies his sparkling rhythms, gree if emancipation from insular preju his polish, and his never-failing musical dices He often feels sorry for earnest eaprit Saint-Saer represents the true te who, after reading the glowing French spirit in musie—the spl of Au ‘ wzies showered upon Pureell by h r- ber, Berlioz, Bizet, and Gounod. The pieces an irn to h works and find in them which he played, and which were new to » much that is puerile, ineffective, and New York concert-goers-—his ‘Africa’ fan- ibsurd that they give up the composer and taisie, an Allegro Appassienata and a his eulogists, bag and baggage, a5 a t Valse Caprice oddly entitled “Wedding | of humbugs Purcell’s strong and weak Cake (perhaps because of its delicate point are judiciously balanced by the rhythmi« frosting’’)—were all unmistak writer He has the courage not only ably French They sounded amazingly ju- gay of Mendelssohn's “St. Paul’ that venile for a composer who has passed his music is “often arid and expressioniess seventy-first birthday; indeed, Saint-Saen and not unfrequently suggests the labo is still what he was illed twelve years | scholar, rathe than the napired wm ago, ce jeune maitre The sparkle of youth an’’: but that dramat yrato n spite is in his playing, as well as in his eyes and f “Elijah remains “a hybrid and uneat- his musi His playing perhaps resembles | Iisfactory form of art . that of Mr. Joseffy more than that of any Other opinions of Mr. Streatfeid other pianist known here; it bas the same | will make some nod assen ythe i

Page 20

400 violently, are that “Gluck’s achievements a reformer have been overestimated”; hat “Wagner was great, not because of his theories, but in spite of them”; that at he present moment “Italy is the only yuntry in which opera is a living force.” rning this last sentiment may we V izgest to the author that there is real genius in the “Shamus O'Brien” I hman, Charles Villiers Stanford, in in all the combined operas of Mas- gn Leoncavallo, and Puccini, none of hom reaches even to the knees of Verdi, I la great mastel Pucelt opera, Madama Butterfly,” will have its first New York performance English, at the Garden Theatre on No vember 12 A monumental life of Chopin is being prepared by Ferdinand Hoesick The first volume, of 881 pages, is out in Polish, and being translated into German, French, ind English It i 1id to contain not only new and interesting details, but corrections of numerous errors in previous books on Chopin Wilhelm Tappert has brought out a new lition of his “Erlking’’ brochure. It con- tains a list of settings of Goethe's great ballad 1 eventy different composers, to j he with critical comments (Berlin Art. FROM THE AT EPHESUS rREASURES ARTEMISIUM October 31 LONDON who are ‘ mp rccount of the latest finds in the Artem mm of Ephesus during last winter vill have to wait until spring, when D. G Hogarth official work on the temple is published by the British Museum. The ob je themaselve are all destined for the nu hat ¢ tantinople where unfor inately, only a limited number of schol- | find them within reach M Hogarth has been fortunate enough liscover one of the most valuable pock f antiquarian treasure which have yet " » light, whether artistic, archmologi- il contributorytothehistory of religion \lthough much has been unearthed of va- in the great temple, the pres ire inelude approximately 4,000 be which must be attributed to dates wxhly mprised between 700 RB. c. and j hat is, they antedate the time of Cre The only considerable exception to of antiquity must be made in } ' f the col many of which run ren r period and, probably, ante- late any known existing coins Some ertainly be attributed to the eighth ntury before Christ Among them are mere lumps of metal without any impres- sion or mark of stamp Others, very ar- hal are mprinted with four characters Digamma, Alpha, Lambda, Digamma—which have been interpreted as the first four letters of the name of King Alyates, sup posing that his name had been spelled with two digammas as the first and fourth let- which subsequently dropped out. But 1s there is no other evidence that his name looking forward to | [Vol. 83, No. 2158 The Nation. was thus spelled, the matter must remain pure conjecture The Artemisium not the Temple of Diana of Ephesus, which was the scene of the exploits of Demetrius and the silversmiths. That was a much later the seat of a more decadent form of worship The most interesting, if intrinsically less valuable, of the find, to many will be the rude terracotta fig- ures of Artemis, of which there are several nowhere represented as excavated last year is temple, portion examples She is the luxuriant many-breasted figure of later is straight, stiff, but not ungainly and figures are the most archaic of all, she has an in- fant in arms in an attitude strongly recalling many representations of the Ma- and Child. In this connection it is worth while to recall that the worship of motherhood was a legacy trans- mitted from prehistoric times to Christian- It was at date Her form Sometimes, these her donna probably ity in this very city of Ephesus Ephesus that the Council of the Church was held which condemned Nestorius and raised the worship of the mother of Christ into It was said that the pas- populace to the contributed a Catholic rite. devotion of the sanctity of the Virgin to the decision of the council Artemis sionate largely her ac- of her Sometimes, as in Other figures of show two images, or one, the hawk. tablet, is shown winged, suspended by the tail The probably the most ancient and most frequent of her em- companied by sacred bird, an exquisite she with a lion in each hand hawk is blems, appearing in the most curious dis- guises. There is one extremely rude, squat figure, absolutely novel, painted black, with yellow spots, only recognizable as a bird or hawk by its eyes and hooked beak In others, minutely finished in silver or gold, the hawk comes to resem- ble so near!y an owl or an eagle that only its association with Artemis enables one to recognize it When on exhibition, the objects will prob- ably be classified by their materials: jewels ind crystals, amber and beads, bone and ivory, bronzes, articles made with gold, silver, and electrum. This latter compound interesting how used It intentional amalgam of gold and silver, but raises an question as to it came to be might well be an for various reasons it seems probable that state and so the lonians found it in a raw used it. Pliny speaks of a natural mixture of gold and silver being found in the Her- mus sands Another circumstance which confirms this view is that the objects made of electrum show all variations of the com- with the gold largely predomi- nating It this would have been the case if any artificial alloys of the which must necessarily stan- dards as a mere affair of habit But as a matter of description it is perhaps simpler to adopt another classifi- accordance with the purpose or their pound, but is improbable that metals had been used, conformed to some have cation in of the offerings with their material or interest attaches, as representations of Artemis surprisingly rather The mentioned character than value primary above, to the herself, of which there are and those of a character which in- dicate an elevated religious feeling. Her attributes and accompanying emblems are common. There are innumer- few, far more able hawks in gold, silver, bronze, stamped in relief, or carved in the round. A\l- most more frequent still is her bee—the melissa—which again symbolically everywhere. An elaborately worked bee is the most beautiful of the gold The bee's body and wings are the stereotyped patterns appears one of jewels. basis, too, of and ornaments. Besides these especial emblems, there are various animals which by their style and shape connect Ionian art with the civiliza- tions of which it was the common meeting- place. There scarabs and sphinxes; Persian sphinxes; a lion passant with a strong Assyrian character. Harpies, too, There is a_ peculiar sketch of a many are Egyptian are frequent couching boar; also a rough calf, which strongly recalls in shape some of the latest finds made by Mr. Bosanquet at Sparta Add and sheep, but curiously enough no cows or horses Next to come in some frogs emblems interest, though hardly in artistic merit, the various ex voto offerings. It takes one with a jump from Ephesus to Lourdes, over 2,500 years, to see a pathetic pair of hands and arms thin gold and joined above so that they resemble a delicate pair of sugar tongs. Yet this represents, perhaps, a cure of leprosy or curious wound on both arms. There are thin plates of gold the goddess and her the range of beaten in some just distinguishable as eyes or ears; legs, feet, and hands in plenty. Among objects once in use the largest is a three-wicked marble lamp. There are bronze bowls, knives, ivory knife han- dles, musical pipes, and some large cow- which may have been currency or mere necklace ornaments like beads. There is a large and important set of astragali, the earliest form of dice. They are mostly carved in bone ivory, and are of all from mere knucklebones to elab- orately carved studded with gold and amber, nothing so much as two draughts joined at one edge. The ries, and shapes, ivories, resembling astragali, with differing sides, were thrown by the petitioner to the goddess in or- der to ascertain by their fall wheth- er his prayer would be granted or not In connection with the astragali there are some mysterious circular rock crys- tal disks with fiuted edges, which may be of this character, except that they were always found singly, and no one could fit another exactly. Another explanation may be that they were worn as buttons on some ceremonial dress, but their purpose can- not as yet be exactly determined. The kernel of the treasure is, of course, the abundant stock of personal ornaments mostly made of the precious metals, but some also of bronze and lead. There are more than a thousand of these made of gold and electrum alone, with a small quan- tity of silver. They range from heavy bracelets, chains, fbul@, and earrings down to the most minute trinkets. There is a wonderful collection of repoussé gold plates, evidently intended to be sewn on dress materials. Some patterns which are of the purest design and highest artistic value are multiplied to serve the purpose of embroidery on a very rich dress. On the repoussé work and especially on the fbula is repeated the melissa pattern, and also, though not so frequently, that of the labrys, or double axe, which played so large

Page 21

Nov. 8, 1906] a part in the Cretan discoveries. The fib- ule and earrings predominate among the gold jewels, and next to them come a large number of hair ornaments, some obviously hairpins, but others of a more mysterious shape. Probably no woman could now com- pass their use, but their appearance sug- gests that a single lock was placed within them and given a double twist, to keep it apart from the rest of the hair. The hypothesis as to the vast number of precious ornaments is that they were de- voted by pious worshippers to the personal use of the goddess. They were found segre- gated from the other and more bulky part of the treasure in the very centre of the temple site, buried within a small rectan- gular space, which was situated at the crossing place of the two long halls form- ing the building. Evidently this must have been the base of the statue of the goddess herself, and this rather naive devotion of material wealth to her tends to confirm the early date of the find and the value of the objects. The presence of the large number of coins and the tendency of some of the inscrip- tions, which are, however, at present con- jectural, lead one also to suppose that the temple at this early date or perhaps later served some secular purpose as a treasury or even as a mint; but whether this be so or not, we must wait for Mr. Hogarth’s book to explain to us. G. B. D. Frits Thaulow, whose death at Volen- dam, Holland, was announced this week, was the first Norwegian painter of modern times to receive international recognition. 1847 at Christiania, stud- He was born in ied with Soorensen at Copenhagen, and with Gude at Carlsruhe, but his painting was chiefly influenced by the example of the French impressionists, whose mode of vision, if not technical method, he fully adopted. In the representation of snow scenes and of frozen rivers he was re- markable. For more than twenty years past he had been settled at Paris, making occasional to this country, where in particular he painted some pictures of the steel foundries at Pittsburgh. In his later years, owing to over-production, the pressure of dealers, and removal from his his painting lost much of its Honors and prizes of all sorts were showered upon him; and while by no means a great artist, he is likely to be remembered as a cunning prac- titioner in landscape. visits home scenes, vitality and charm. The Watts Memorial Gallery has recently been opened at the artist’s country home at Among the important works to be seen there are “Progress,’’ ‘“‘Paolo and Francesca,” “Godiva,” “‘The Slumber of the Ages,” “Green Summer,” “Diana and Endymion,” and portraits of Walter Crane, Joachim, Swinburne, Meredith, Mrs. Langtry, and others. There are also many drawings and studies; and when the sculp- ture gallery is completed, the models of the artist’s statue “Physical Energy,” his statue of Tennyson at Lincoln, and the tomb of the Bishop of Lichfleld will be placed on view. Limnerslease. A new portrait, presumably of Charlotte Bronté, acquired by the National Portrait Gallery of London, has provoked a sharp controversy. This portrait was attribut- The Nation. ed to Paul Heger, who was acquainted with Miss Bronté about 1844 This attribution has by a letter from Heger's son that neither he nor his father was either pain in Brussels now been upset who says ter or draughtsman Nor can the dates involved be made to fit by five or six years The exhibition of works of art of the eighteenth century at the Biblioth@éque Na- tionale comprises proofs of works by the finest English engravers of the latter half of the eighteenth century, hanging side by with examples of French stipple, and rare engravings printed in col- side aquatint, or. As lack of space made it impossible to exhibit to the of the inspiration of the engravers, a col- oil paintings show sources lection of miniatures and gouaches hibited for the To are added medals and “biscuits de Sévres,” thou- is €X- same purpose these a collection containing more than a sand examples. M. S advertence Prichard writes correcting an in- in the editorial, ‘‘“Museum Ex- tension in Schools,”’ in our issue of Novem- ber 1. He “acting-director” of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, but had been assistant director, and was bursar at the time of his resignation to take the secretaryship of the Committee on the Utilization of the Museum by the Schools and Colleges. was never Science, Theory of the Algebraic Functions of a Compler Variable. By J. C. Fields. Ber- lin: Mayer & Miiller. This is a serious and daring essay in one of the most difficult flelds of modern mathematics. While the subject is pri- marily analytic or algebraic, its investiga- tion has been mainly carried on since the great memoirs of Puiseux in 1854 and of Riemann in 1857 by the powerful assistance of geometric considerations. Indeed, geo- metric notions have dominated to such an extent in the leading developments that the student scarcely thinks of the subject in other terms; and the chief treatises, such as those of Neumann and of Appell and Goursat, are little than of the doctrine in terms of the theory of Riemann surfaces. All the advantages of that fertile and illuminating method will be missed by the readers Fields’s volume, for the method algebraic. This mode of doubtedly legitimate, and may have certain purely logical advantages of its own, but it will hardly win the approval of that larger mathematical constituency that Klein and Poincaré have called intuitionalists. At all events, the author should not, we think, have failed to indicate explicitly the con- nections of his own exposition with the masterful geometric treatises of his prede- cessors. Not only is Professor Fields’s method purely algebraic, but it aims at perfect generality; that is, it undertakes to give a theory for any algebraic equation what- ever, reducible or irreducible, no matter how complicated the singularities and no matter what its character at infinity. Here surely ‘ an impressive programme, and else expositions Professor is purely un- of treatment is 401 The in at many points it is well performed summit chapter xil., where we er of the steep ascent is reached the com the involved in ounter manding ‘complementary theorem" arbitrary constants number of the expression of the most general rational function constructed on ai given basis of coincidences, added to half the sum of the orders of the coincidences’ ex plicitly required by the basis, is equal to the like number constructed = with reference to the complementary basis. From the eminence here attained one is permit ted to behold readily a variety of class propositions that have hitherto been found only by difficult and circuitous paths In this service is found, we think, the chief claim of the work to distinction; for th: propositions thus disclosed to view are such as the Riemann-Roch theorem, the reci procity theorem of Brill and Nother, the so-called gap theorem of Weierstra and the related theorem of Hurwitz The volume contains an excellent table of contents, but no index The light to the eye. In the interest, h of accentuation and convenience page is a de weve! important theorems should have been set apart and italicised While opinions may differ as to the need of more such books, it must be admitted that the “‘“Manual of Anatomy” (vol. 1 Osteology; Upper Limb; Lower Limb) pre pared by Prof. A. M. Buchanan of Ander son's College, Glasgow (Chicago ae Keener & Co.), is an eminently practical book, convenient in form and beautifully printed The illustrations are numerous and for the most part clear and helpful the judicious use of color playing no in considerable part The text is clear and concise, with constant attention to the de mands of the dissecting room and the training of the surgeon, the rational treat of topographical ticularly commendable ment matters being par On the other hand it is to be regretted that varieties and ab normalities are not noted more fully, and that the more important questions of com parative anatomy are not brought to the notice of the student. The index is liberal but contains no mention of the ligament of Poupart For the use of schools, Little, Brown & Co. have published an “Atlas of Physiology and Anatomy of the Human Body,” made up of nine figures, each consisting of a number of leaves, or layers, to show the parts as they appear when the region or organ is dissected A very brief descrip tive text has been supplied by Dr. A. M Amadon. Such a book may be helpful to students when a manikin or good models are not accessible, but it must be used cau tiously, as some the figures dif ficult to understand, or are actually wrong, for example, the relation of the liver the duodenum, on the fifth leaf of first plate. The appearance of the skele ton on the third leaf is very unsatisfactory and the textual statement (p. 31) that vagus supplies “the heart with motion” is of are as, to the the bad for the beginner, even though his teacher be a ‘‘neurogenist.”’ With the title “Tuberculosis, its Origin and Extinction” (The Macmilian Co), Dr W. Pickett Turner has printed an enlarge ment of a lecture given by him on this sub-

Page 22

402 His theories are novel, but the evi- presented is far too fragmentary and ject lence neonclusive to appeal very strongly to those who are familiar with the questions nvolved. Dr. Turner’s contention is briefly hat the extinction of tuberculosis is to be brought about by actinism, i. ¢., by the ac- tion of the ultra-violet rays which are sup- posed to penetrate the body and affect the bacteria either directly or indirectly Dr. Dudley A. Sargent of the Harvard ry! isium has given much valuable in- formation upon physical training in his wok of that title (Boston: Ginn & Co.) Reasons for exercise are many and varied, and the value of almost every kind is set forth clearly. There is much of interest n the volume : Farm Animals,’ by E. V. Wilcox (Dou- bleday, Page & Co.), is a practical book for general farm use, judiciously arranged for the largest helpfulness to the largest num- of readers. It furnish essays animal, nor does it give any- information on any sin- it will not make a good good nor will it needs of a stableman. It is llent compend of general in- the beef and ber does not on any one omple te that Is, thing like gle topic; dairy shepherd, man or a cover all the rather an exce formation about the horse mule, dairy cows, pigs, sheep, goats, poultry rhe chapter on dairy stock is the im the The illu being well but every chapter is good. have the advantage of subject Every is brought down to book, trations related to the discussion admitted which has not part of the late, and nothing is passed erutiny at our agricultural ex- periment stations \ new feature of the New York Botanical Garden will be an economic patch, devoted to specimens of growing plants which are f practical use to man A great many mn plants have already been brought yee the n the conservatories, but these from warm or tropical reg- ind the new collection is intended to iow such as are hardy in this latitude id ng will be begun very soon, and will be mtinued next spring Following the fication of the plant products in the omic museum, the groups of the species grown here will consist of food, drug, and fibre plant and those yielding miscel- ha sus products used in arts, sciences, ! lu lhe chemical industry in Germany is the i pal ibjeet treated in Petermann'’s Witteitu 1, number nine The facts are from the returns of the census of } mn purpose of the author, Dr mil, being to show the geographical butlo of the industry throughout he Empire Some detaila are given of a f the work ind from the accompany x map we learn that the largest num- ! 000 hands, are employed at Ludwigs hafer n Baden, where are the greatest aniline and seda factories In the world, and where a ial indigo was firat put upon the market N. A. Busch describes a journey hrough tl northern Caucasus region for the purpose of studying its botany, espe- clally that of the Alpenzones Sir David Gill, who has been His Majes- ty’s astronomer at the Cape of Good Hope since 1879, has offered his resignation, to take effect next February. The Nation. Finance. SNATCHING CONTROL OF RAILWAYS The ousting of Stuyvesant Fish from the presidency of the Illinois Central Railway, this week, by vote of his own directors acting in the interest of E. H. Harri- man, has again directed attention to the effort of powerful financiers to in- crease, by hook or crook, the number of railways under their personal control. This remarkable propor- the time of the excited financial “boom” at the opening of 1901. During two or three successive months, such an- nouncements were made as the purchase of the $101,000,000 Southern Pacific Railway, by the Pacific; of the $98,000,- 000 Chicago, Burlington, & Quincy by the Northern Pacific and the Great Northern; and of the $27,000,000 New Jersey Central, by the Reading. All of these purchases, some of them made in open mar- ket at extravagant prices, were paid for with proceeds of bonds, issued by the pur- chasing companies and sold to the eager investing public. The “game of grab,” as it was called even then, culminated in the famous fight between Union Pacific and Great Northern for conirol of the Northern Pacific's $80,000,000 stock. The movement to an end when the markets broke May, 1901, under the load of new movement reached tions at Union ame down in securities Efforts of the same sort were renewed when the Stock Exchange got its breath again. Shares of half a dozen great rail- ways were bid up to unheard-of figures by trying to get control in open market. In 1902 a band of stock-jobbing ad- venturers started in to buy up, with bor- rowed money, shares of some of the few in- dependent railways. These people thus secured possession of the $10,000,000 Chica- go, Indianapolis, and Louisville, and of the $52,000,000 Louisville and Nashville. They could not have kept their purchase; but their object was to force banking in- terests, connected with rival railways, to take over the stock at a still higher figure, rather than risk demoralizing competition in rates. The blackmailed bankers meekly paid the price, and issued bonds of their own railway companies to raise the money. To this kind of performance the financial of 1903—the “rich men’s panic’’— put an end; and it was two years before the talk of “buying up other railways’’ was heard again in Wall Street. But with the country’s recent great prosperity, and the revival of daring speculation, on the part both of the public and of the railway attempt to capture inde- resumed The was 1902, however, end for several Re- sources of capital had been so overstrained by heavy trade and extensive speculation that new bonds could not find a ready mar- ket; such operations as those of 1901 were therefore too dangerous. Again, the Wall Street millionaires who arranged the “rail- of 1901 had the surplus of life insurance companies placed at their dis- posal, to guarantee the undertakings. This was no longer possible after he Armstrong investigation. Finally, owners of the in- dependent roads had in the interim forti- fied their own position, and with maay of capitalists collapse millionaires, the railways was 80 easy as in pendent achievement not reasons. way deals” [Vol. 83, No. 2158 them, control could not be bought at any price. The Illinois Central episode shows what expedients were at the last aaupted in the “game of grab.”” E. H. Harriman of thea Union Pacific wanted the road—partly for a southern outlet from his own lines; part- ly, so Wall Street inferred, because Stuy- vesant Fish had, as chairman of the Mu- tual Life trustees’ investigating commit- tee, pushed his inquiries uncomfortably close to certain large capitalists on the board. His investigation was blocked by President Peabody of the Mutual, but the incident was not forgotten. Harriman was unable to buy up Illinois Central stock; it was too securely lodged with real investors. After attempting unsuccessfully to obtain without purchase—through organ- izing a “holding company” in which IIli- nois Central shareholders were invited to place their stock—Harriman secretly or- ganized a revolt against Mr. Fish in his own board of directors. control By what means he prevailed, it is not easy to say; but on Wednesday of this week, at a “snap” meeting of the board, called when one of Mr. Fish’s supporters was ill and another like- ly to be kept away by political engage- ments, the directors voted to unseat Mr. Fish in favor of a tool of Harriman. Among the directors working and voting against Mr. Fish was Charles A. Peabody, president of the Mutual Life, who had re- fused to put Mr. Fish’s inquiries to the trustees, who is a director in Harriman’s Union Pacific Railway, and who has lately won distinction for his letter threatening those agents of his insurance company who did not support the administration ticket. This particular “railway capture” has been marked, in a quite unusual degree, by intrigue and treachery. It also provides an instance where one of the few remain- ing independent railways has been seized without the annoying preliminary of buying it. The incident is in this respect sugges- tive. The orgie of railway speculation in the seventies came to a climax by very much such methods; but they marked its approaching end. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Bein, Jobn, jr. Cigarettes in Fact and Fancy. Beston: H. M. Caldwell Co. B.bliography of Folk-Lore, 1905. London: Da- vid Nutt. Book-Prices Current. London: Elliot Stock. Conferences on the Moral Philosophy of Medicine. Kebman Co. Dietzgen, Joseph. The Positive Outcome of Phil- osophy. Translated by Ernest Untermanna. Chi- cago: Charles H. Kerr & Co. Dix, William Frederick. The Face in the Girandole. Moffat, Yard & Co. §2 net, Dodge, Henry Irving. The Hat and the Man. G. W. Dillingham Co. Dole, Charles Fletcher. The eve of Immortality. Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. 75 cents net. Donnell, Annie Hamilton. The Very Small Per son. Harpers. $1.25. Feullletons Chols.s. Edited by Cloudesley Breretoa. Henry Frowde. Forbes-Lindsay, C. H. Oe Ph.ladelphia: John C. Winston Oo. Franklin, Benjamin. irae Ww ‘itie Edited ed Albert Henry Smyth. Vols, VIII, _ 1X. millan Co. $3 net per vol, Frenssen, Gustav. Peter a Fabrt nach Std- west. Lemecke & Buechne Greenleaf, Sue. Don Miguel Lebumada. B. W. Ihxige & 5 Gubernatis, Angelo de. Ecrivains du Monde Latin. S.xth livraison, Rom Harvard Studies & Cc “lassical Philology. Vol, XVII. Oambrid Ma Hudson, ‘nam ‘Gadwalader, J.P. Dunbar. B. W, Dodge & Hull, Eleanor. -_ Text Book of | Literature. Part |. London: David Nutt, net. Johnson, Burgess. Beastly | a Thomas Y. Crowell & Oo. §1 net, Kidd, Dudley. Savage Childhood. Macmillan Co. 0. asen, Alfred Henry. Confessions of a Detective, A. 8. Barnes & Co. §1.50.

Page 23

Nov. 8, 1906] The Nation.

Moore, T. Sturge. Correggio. Imported by Scrib- | H. M. Caldwell Co. 75 cents. ners. $2 net. Rivers, W. H. R. The Todas Macmillan CGo Munson, Jobn W. Reminiscences of a Mosby 2is. net Guerri.la, Moffat. Yard & Co. §2 net. Ross, Minnie S. C. Around the Mediterranean Nicholson, J. 8 The Relations of Rents, Wages Grafton Press and Profits in Agriculture Imported by Scrib Russell, George W. E. Social Silhouettes. Dutton ners #1 $3 net Pendegrast, Viliiam A. Credit and Its Uses Sanderson, Edgar Great Britain in Modera Appleton $1.50 net. Africa Imported by Scribners $1.75 net Perkins, Lucy, Fitch. The Goose Girl. Chicago: Selections from the Sabih of Al-Buhart Edited A. C. McClurg & Co. by Charles C. Torrey Le ld E. J. Brill Politovaky, Eugene 8. From Libau to Tsushima Sentence Analysis. Henry Fro wee ls. td Translated by F. R yk Dutton. $1.50 net Seymour, Frederick H. A Saunterings in Spain Riley, Alice C. D. The Wishbone Boat. Boston: Dutton. $3 xet

VY" A Beautiful and Novel Gift Book for Nature Lovers Stone and Beebe’s THE LOG OF THE SUN embraces 52 charming papers by C. William Beebe, author of ‘“ The Bird: Its Form and Function,” giving each week its proper seasonal accompaniment, 52 corresponding plates in color and decorations by Walter King Stone, and 200 illustrations in text. Large 8vo, full gilt, boxed, $5.00 net. Carriage 35 cents. HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY ‘ew You IMPORTANT AUTUMN PUBLICATIONS The History of the Papacy in the XIX. Century By DR. FREDRIK NIELSEN Translated under the direction of JAMES MASON, D.D., Master of Pembroke College, Cambridge. 2 vols. 8vo. $7.50 net. Social Silhouettes By GEORGE W. E. RUSSELL Author of ‘‘Collections and Recollections.” 8vo. $3.00 net. Researches in Sinai By W. M. FLINDERS PETRIE, D.C.L. 186 lIlustrations and 4 Maps. Royal 8vo. $6.00 net. A Child’s Recollections of Tennyson By EDITH NICOLL ELLISON Illustrated. $1.00 net. The author of this delightful book is a daughter resident in this country —of the late Dean Bradley, who succeeded Stanley in Westminster. There was the closest intimacy between the families of the Dean and the Poet, and from the age of three the author had many opportunities of seeing Tennyson in all the freedom of home life. E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY EPVE 31 WEST 23D ST., NEW YORK EPG

BEST Letters Personal and Literary of facilities for supplying ytt ween bine ean’ _ Obert, Earl of Lytton English BOOKS Italian (Owen Meredith) French Spanish | Edited by his Daughter, Lady BETTY BAL- Catalogues tree. Cuorrespoudence solicited FOUR. With 8 Portraits. 2 vols. 8vo. LEMCKE & BUECHNER #00 net. Ketablished over 5v years. 11 East 17th St., New York LONGMANS, GREEN, & cn, New York | PROOFS of | LIFE AFTER DEATH oe sro, Cloth, 905 pages. $1.50 vet, 12e neatere, |! The Man in the Case TURE LIFE BY THE WORLD'S MOST EMI.

NENT SCIENTIFIC MEN IN CONFUTATION A NOVEL OF MYSTERY AND ROMANCE OF THE MATERIALISTIO SCHOOL OF | THOUGHT. :

--- —-- - _~<~— ~~

HERBERT B. TURNER & CO. ‘Boston. Mass. ELIZABETH STUART PH*LPS 403 Swinburne, Algernon Charles William Blake | Dutton. $2 net | Talbot Filen Bliss rT Fundamental Prir i ciples of Fichte’s Pt ’ Macu mn (x Talbot, Ethelbert My | pu tf <2 Piains liar pers 75 net Va Nyevel Rar as 8 Va Pay ‘ | Life it Dutch Rey Dutton. 84 net |} Wells. H. G The Future of America Harpers | $2 net | Wheeler, Charlies Kirkland Hundredth Oentury pemooents Be mt Press of James A. West « Whe Et K Bet 1 th Vet Land Devid west.

“Here is a volume with a me sageand a purpose; a book which appeals, It treats of the great est of gquestions—the eternal, uit mate problem—Death and the After Death. The observation are those of aclever, experienced and sympathetic man The Chronicle The Gate of Death ANONYMOUS Crown 8vo. 1.25 net **T his beautiful and remarkable book Hardly any book since ‘In Memoriam’ has presented such notable claims to the consideration of popular theology. The book really possesse uncommon beauty, and is not likely to be forgotten in a single season or a single year.’'—London Telegraph. } Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. G.P.Putnam’s Sons, 20's” xv"

WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart ment for the handling of Library orders. 1 A tremendous miscellaneous sto« 2. Greatly increased facilities for the im portation of English publications. 3. Competent bookmen to price lists and collect books All of this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., Ni w York.

The Library of Literary Criticism Of Engish and American Authors From 680 to 1906 Eight Volumes OComptied Studies of 1,150 Authors. in chronological arrange ment. Most accurate and authentic Reference Work on all phases of English Literature High eat aise from Scholars throughout the English speaking world. Sample pages, etc.. free by mall MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York THE HEART THAT KNOWS THE BRST ROOK

These trade-mark cr

Kage

Page 24

404 The Nation. (Vol. 83, No. 2158 NOTABLE BOOKS AND GIFT BOOKLETS Putting the Most | The Spirit of the | Every Man a King or, Might in Mind Into Life Orient Ree By Booker T. Washington | By George William Knox | gy Qrison Swett Marden Author of ** Up From Slave Special type designs. 30 Author of “Pushing to the . yecause Stuy- ~* the Mu- ry.” imo. cloth. 75c., illustrations from photo- | mmit- “limp leather, $1.50. graphs. 12mo, cloth, $1.50 | Front.’’ 12mo, cloth, “a net. Postage 15 cents. $1.00, (Postage © cents.) No more {mportant problem xo | B is now engrossing the atten (Postage 10 cents.) | | tf he civilized world than | dresses before the students bs pe fe pee Orient. The latest of Dr. Mar- of Tuskegee Institute, well | The present ts one of the clear den’s popular books is a - est, sanest, and most enlight- worth printing in perma- | ening studies of the subject powerful plea for mental | | A series of practical ad- that has yet appeared. India, | eontrol. th master manent form for readers Taine aed Seten thelr ne. | « q e a o" y of generally. The author's | tional’ traits and attitude to | self, and the training of , ’ . | the world about them—are ex- ; ability to draw forceful plained from within and logic. | pe forces to the highest ends, truths needs no comment ally THE CHISWICK SERIES SIX NEW VOLUMES. The finest line of dainty gift books obtainable at their price. Each book contains distinctive features of workmanship in the way of special type or illustrations. 12mo, cloth each 50c net. (Postage 5 cents.) The Beauty of Kindness. By J.R. Miller. A, Longfellow Calendar. By Anna H. Smith. popular ethical booklet, fully illustrated by Harold | Appropriate quotations from this ‘household poet’’ | adapted to each day inthe year. Special type designs. : Copping Friendship. By Henry D. Thoreau. One of his Saint Francis of Assisi. By Oscar Kuhns. A = most delightful essays. Beautifully printed. | delightful study of the life of this famous church | saint. Illustrated from rare prints. | Germelshausen. Translated from the German of Friedrich Gerstacker, by Clara M. Lathrop. The | The Man Without a Country. By Edward quaint tale of a buried German village which came | Everett Hale. A classic of patriotism which every to life again one day in each hundred years. Frontis- | one who has not read should read. Frontispiece by piece by E. Boyd Smith. Clyde De Land. Send for Free Iilustrated Book List THOMAS Y. CROWELL & COMPANY, 426-8 WEST BROADWAY, NEW YORK } | By EDGAR SALTUS |The Settlement of “Mr. Saltus comes pretty near to being the only man in | Jamestown America now writing who has a style.” —.S¢. Louzs Mirror. | by CAPT. JOHN SMITH, and LORD | BALTIMORE’S PLANTATION IN MA- | RYLAND, from Father White’s Narrative, HISTORIA AMORIS $1.50 net | | are just added tothe OLD SOUTH L2AF- A HISTORY OF LOVE, ANCIENT AND MODERN a en ee “A brilliant book, with chapter on chapter of beguiling Price 5 cents each. $4 per hundred. attractiveness. —2/iss Carman in the Brooklyn Eagle. NP ae . DIRECTORS OF OLD SOUTH WORK THE POMPS OF SATAN $1.50 net Old no House ” A collection of brilliant essays. Saannnn, Ganenenarmenen Two By EDWAKD HOWARD GRIGGS. $1.60 net IMPERIAL PURPLE $1.90 net Great | CHRISTIAN ORIGINS ; , P as Books] By OTTO PFLELIDERER. $1.50 net. “The splendid tragedy of Rome, dazzlingly depicted. B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, N. Y. —The Times. | MARY MAGDALEN sida THE NATION ‘i . an independent weekly journal, was estab- A story of great strength and almost photographic Sehed fn 1865. ths Gentetbuanes tactede intensity. —oston Transcript. the most prominent names in literature, science, and art, both in this country and abroad. It is emphatically found in the homes of people of culture and refinement. No intelligent American, desirous of keep- ing abreast of the best political and literary thought of the day, can afford to be with- out it. Subscription price, $3.00 a year, postpaid. Address PUBLISHER OF THE NATION, 208 Broadway, New York Olty. At all booksellers or sent postpaid by the pablisher oa receipt of price. MITCHELL KENNERLEY, 118 East 28th Street, New York City CHAUCER 4, coroner raion English Monumental Brasses Rich in néw material. Price $2.00. Cireu- FA 4 er ae? collection of Brass gh MH af B. . LUNN, B.D., 4 1, lar on application. Address, H. B. Hinck- 1. 800 for on ley, 84 Prospect St., Northampton, Mass SS ost Taccbhay Worcester ttngland.

Page 25

® : F ees 7 = a ae a ‘ “ . eis mae t \ P : ‘ iy} wee