The Nation 1906-11-01: Vol 83 Iss 2157

Page 1

GENERAL UNIV. OF MIC. NOV B 1906 _ The Natrqn day, al Wy fap, Ay, VOL. /LXXXIII—NO. 2157. THURSDAY, NOVEMBER tf, 1906 “ay, » CENTs EE . 9. x HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & COMPANY’S NEW BOOKS WALT WHITMAN Important shee hies By BLISS PERRY P “This biographer has got at the significance of Whitman's life and of his place in th period that was his. Nothing in the fact or fiction of the day is more vivid than the pictur of the poet’s early life. Wr. Perry is to be congratulat d upon the letter of his achievement, but more particularly upon tt! spirit of what he has done.’’—Sv?. Louis Globe-Democrat, ‘\lustrated. $1.50 met. Postage 12 cents By ELIZABETH ROBINS PENNELL | ‘** This season’s most important piece of American biography."’—3oston Advertiser. “A work of exceptional interest, grac ll | and sympathetically written . . . a full-length portrait of one of the most picturesg f American personalities Phila delphia Press. \\lustrated. Two volumes. $5.00 met. Postage 28 cents. LIFE AND LETTERS OF LAFCADIO HEARN By ELIZABETH BISLAND This is one of the most notable publications of the season, for Hearn’s life was interesting and romantic in th He was also one of the best letter-writers of his time, rivalling Stevenson, and much of his correspondence is her With many portraits and illustrations. Two volumes, in box, $6.00 4-7. Postage extra. (Ready about Dee. 1st.) MY PILGRIMAGE TO THE WISE MEN OF THE EAST By MONCURE D. CONWAY Recollections of travels among the leaders of religious thought in Ceylon and India, by a writ who i lwa Illustrated. S8vo, $3.00 met. Postage 20 cents. published THE PRACTICE OF DIPLOMACY By JOHN W. FOSTER A handbook of diplomacy as illustrated in the foreign relations of the United States, by th greatest American authority. $3.00 wef. Postage 20 cent GOLDEN DAYS OF THE RENAISSANCE IN ROME By RODOLFO LANCIANI | Rome at the time of Paul Ill., of Michael Angelo and of Raphael, by the greatest authority on the subject. Th | number about 100, many reproduced for the first time, and show the interesting monuments of the Postage 31 cents. ORGANIZED DEMOCRACY By ALBERT STICKNEY A political argument clearly expressed and based on the belief that Americans are practically slaves to “The Machine.’’) Mr Stickney offers some very suggestive and definite ideas for reform. $1.00 met. Postage 10 cents. STUDIES IN PHILOSOPHY AND THE ENGLISH PATENTS OF MONOPOLY PSYCHOLOGY By WILLIAM H. PRICE By FORMER STUDENTS OF CHARLES E. GARMAN The first volume of the “Harvard Economic Studies"’ presents . ER considerable ortginal material on an important phase of “Thirteen papers full of individuality and independence of | economic history. $1.50 met. Postage 17 cents. thought. . . . A nobletribute to a great teacher.’’— 7 Ae Outlook. With portrait. $2.S50nc¢. Postage 24 cents. THE STRUGGLE FOR A FREE STAGE FROM OLD FIELDS | IN LONDON By NATHANIEL S, SHALER By WATSON NICHOLSON A stirring collection of blank verse poems dealing with | A scholarly account of the history of London theatres between | Professor Shaler’s experiences in the Civil War. $3.00 met. | 1660 and 1840, showing the long struggle against theatrical Books of Special Interest illustrations period, $5.00 met Postage extra. monopoly. $2.50 ef. Postage 15 cents. _ “Boston” HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & CO. “xew'Vouu™ Neen rn SRNR ee ern a rm _

Page 2

we eo : a@ Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2157 Nation. The 4 WREKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1866, [Entered at the New York City Post Office as second class mail matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER Tae Were 361 EprroRtaL ARTICLES The Japanese Proteat - 364 Museum Extension in Schools 364 How to Grow Old , ... 36 New Light on Oardinal Newman .. eee 365 A eal Linguistic Reform 366 BrRoraL ARTICLE The Dangers of the Small College . 367 CORRESPONDENCE Spenser's Dating of ‘“Oolin Clout’ 368 The resent Position of Latin and Greek... 369 A Better Postal Oard . 369 Sores sey Hoon KRavinws rhe Political History of England, 1801-1837. 372 Memoira of the Count de Oartrie , se oe fhe Mirror of the Sea 7 +» 374 The Plow-Woman coves GEO The Belovéd Vagabond 375 Letters to Women in Love secs Ge fhe Bible as English Literature ~+. 375 Persia Past and Present ae 376 Emma, Lady Hamilton 376 DRAMA Garrick and His Circle 377 Muer The Coming Musical Season 378 Ant American Silver vr 379 BclreNcR Kemarkable Human Bones in a Nebraska Mound om The Principles of Botany . 380 hooks or Tue WeeK : SSI TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to Jor- clga coun(rtes comprised tn the Postal Union, $35. The date when the subs-ription exptres is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to @ subsequent date becomes 4 receipt for a remit tance, No other receipt ts acnt unless requested. Remittances at the riak of the subscriber, unless mide by registered letier, or by eheck, express svder, or Postal Order payable to “ Publisher of The Nation When ac of address ta desired, both the old and the new adcdtreaaes should be given Address (THB NATION, Rox 794, New York Publication Office, 008 Rroadway hange TERMS OF Fifteen linea lo the inch Twenty per cen’ ADVERTISING. cents per agate line, each tnertion; 14 advance for chotce af page ov top of column 4 column, $10 each insertion; with choice of page, $2 A page, $0 cach insertion; front cover page, $80, A lwertia meets matt be acoestable ia every: rempect Copy received until Tuesday, 6 P.M THE NATION ta sent (ree to th ae who adver tise in Uf aa long as advertisement continuca Discounts upon applica’ion, rocured in 17 Avenue de lO ; to rafalgar *,* Coples of Tax Nation may be Paris at Brentano's, London of B Stevens & J Brown, Square, Charing Cross, E Aucational Massace seTrTs, Boston Boston UNIVERSITY Law School. New features, Address the Dean. M. M. BrerLow. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. Shop for Mechanic Arta. Strong teachers. Earnest boys. Gymnasium with new swimming pool. Fits for college, eclentifice school and business. oung boys in separate building. Address Dr. BC. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hille, Mass. School Agencies. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Records, Send for Circular on Free Registratic HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel St... “albany, N. ¥. The President’s English By WILLIAM ARCHER See THE LIVING AGE (LITTELL’S) for Nowember 3 The same pumbes contains ** Between the Catarac > Harvld Spender; * Russia from Within,’ a: Special Commissioner of the National eview; “The Labor Party in the United States,” from the London Outlook; “Some Shadowy Characters in Shakespeare,” from The Gentleman's Magazine ; a clever short story, and other interesting feat ures. At the newsrooms, or direct, postpaid, from the publishers for 15 Cents. Trial subscriptions, three months, thirteen numbers, beginning with this number, $1.00. Annual subscrip'ion, 3360 pages, $6.00. New subscribers for 1907 will receive the remaining numbers for 1906 free. THE LIVING AGE CO. 6 BEACON STREET, BOSTON BOOKS for the HOME Long's Brier-Patch Philoso Greenwood’s Famous Balla al ent’s 8s Physical Edueation r’s Greek Painter's Art von Mach’s Outlines of the History of Painting von Mach’s Greek Scul Heller's Studies in M Literature Davidson's Philosophy of Goethe’s Faust Walch’s Moral Damage of War CINN & COMPANY, - BOSTON LIBRARY RESEARCH Topics of all kinds and tn any language looked ture ern German up in the Boston and Harvard libraries, for schol- ars, writers, and others. Abstracts, copies, trans- lations, and bibliographies made. Proof-reading and revision of manuscript. Highest university and library references. MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass, JUST OUT. PROF. HYSLOP’S NEW BOOK, Treats of Normal and Abnormal Psychology. Price $1.50 net. 12c postage. HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., Boston, Mass The Library of Literary Criticism Of English and American Authors From 680 to 1905. Eight Volames. Oompiled Studies of 1,160 Authors, tn chronological arrange- ment. Most accurate and authentic Reference Work on all phases of English Literature. et an eat praise from Scholars throughout the English- smaking world. Sample pages, etc.. free by mall. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York READ THE HEART THAT KNOWS THE BEST BOOK. The American Journal of Sociology A Bimonthly edited by the Sociological Fac ulty of the University of Chicago,with the advice of leading sociologists in America and Eurupe. ALBION W. SMALL, Ed tor-in-Chie/, THE ONLY JOURNAL IN THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE DEVOTED PRIMARILY TO PURE SOCIOLOGY $2.00 a year; single copies, 50 cents impotent sympathy with the most helpless social classes, plus some premature schemes of relief. In the mid- dle of the nineteenth century, Sociology as proposed by Comte appeared to be merely an algebraic formulation of the facts of human life. Schiaffle and Spencer represent a stage in the development of the science in which the attempt was made to picture the es- sential facts in the social process by means of biological analogies. fe imo Sociology was hardly more than During the past quarter-century the name Sociology has been used by theorists of the most heterogeneous varieties, but creditable progress has been made toward a consen- sus about essentials which marks a distinct stage in the development of the science. The sociologists are agreed that to reach a literal statement of the facts of life they must work in close partnership with the psychologists. ‘They have abandoned mechanical, and materialistic or pseudo- materialistic, hypotheses of social progress. They assume that the activities of society, while dependent upon antecedent organic and inorganic physical processes, are dis- tinctively the play of interests within per- sons and between persons. Sociology has consequently become a con- scious program of investigating social ac- tivities considered strictly as a complex of processes, all of which have their origin in the impulses of persons, and the termi- nus of which is in the character and re- lations of persons. This JOURNAL is devoted to research in- to the origin, development, present condi- tions, and indicated purposes of social in- terests, as interpreted from this point of view. Subsoriptions filed immediately to begin January, 1907 will include the November, 1906, number free. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS (Dept. 21) CHICAGO and NEW YORK THE BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY are the leading booksellers in the United States along certain limes. They issue a Catalog of Rare Volumes monthly, and this, together with their List of Publications de- voted to American History, will be SENT FREE to any one making the request. OF CLEVELAND, OHIO Financial. We buy and eeil bills of exchanges and LETTE make cable transfers of money on E OF RS rope, Australia, and South é ca; alse make collect tone and issue ‘ommerctal CREDIT «nd beep) y= Credits available tn all 0 orld. International ues. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO: NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK.

Page 3

Nov. 1, 1906] The Nation. ae — the union of the crowns. commended unreservedly. STORIES FROM DICKENS The famous children of Dickens are here sep2rated from the crowded scenes are told about simply, yet in Dickens’s own language largely. Dombey, Pip, Smike, and David Copperfield are among the story-people every child should know 16mo, Cloth, Ulustrated, 6 Cents STORIES FROM SCOTTISH HISTORY Scott’s ‘Tales of a Grandfather”’ is the basis of this book, which tells directly of the heroic struggles of Wallace, Bruce, Douglas, and other chiefs, for the freedom of Scotland. Itis a book to fire the blood. 16mo, Cloth, Illustrated, #) Cents TALES FROM HERODOTUS Herodotus was the first of story-tellers, and is worthy the triendship of against the Persian tyrants, are among the most famous in history. before the coveted blue best-known writers for children. MEG AND THE OTHERS By HARRIET T. COMSTOCK. Illustrated by M. Seldom will the reader tind a more charming story for girls thin this ** Meg of the Long Ago,”’ and unflagging interest. By HERBERT BASHFORD. An outdoor story of boy-life met with anywhere. told with dash and enthusiasm JOEY AT THE FAIR Joey is a New England farm lad, who has a prize calf which he ribbon is secured several interesting things happen. T} By MADALEN The The Illustrated, #) Cents present I6uno, Cloth, THE TENTING OF THE TILLICUMS Illustrated od CHAS. C J)PELAND on the Puget Sound, J Tillicums”’ stir up a new 12mo, Cloth, By JAMES OTIS. The four “ 75 Cents i2mo, Cloth, 7 Cents I2mo, Cloth, 75 Cents and or experience with ¢ POPULAR NEW BOOKS for the CHILDREN By J. WALKER McSPADDEN in which the Oliver Twist, Little Nell, EDGAR history is given By H. L. HAVELL every child. retelling is especially Illustrated by FRANK T. MERRILL her friends, her joys, griefs and escapades, y appear, ana Paul and connectedly to His stories of Greece. and her str meritorpous, and « f the liveliest camping narrativ very chapter, and the w at the County Fair; but fhuor eu i ¢} wints to enter P. O'MALLEY new one by Miss Com k form 3 picture colored witht ality Send for Free Illustrated Book List THOMAS Y. CROWELL & COMPANY, 426% West, Broadway THE NATION FOUNDED IN 1865 A Weekly Journal Devoted Drama, Music, Art. Science, Finance and Politics st The Nation aims to present from week to week a report of the intellectual progress of the world, notices of the most important books, plays, musical events, and the princi- pal exhibitions of art, here and abroad, the development of science, and the significant movements in foreign and domestic politics. Its book reviews, its art criticism, and all its other articles are written by the most competent specialists in America and Eu- rope. The Nation stands alone in its field. It has a larger circulation than any other po- litico-literary journal published in this coun- try, going to all the principal libraries and reading rooms and into thousands of fam- ilies. The circulation is chiefly among thinking and substantial people—lawyers, physicians, teachers, clergymen, and other professional men; in short, it goes to the homes of culti- vated people. Sample copies for three weeks sent free upon request. The cost of a subscription for one year is $3.00; for any less period a proportionate rate 1s charged. The Nation 206-210 Broadway, New York. to Literature, | WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. 1. A tremendous miscellaneous stock 2. Greatly increased facilities for the im- portation of English publications. 3. Competent bookmen to price lists and collect books All of this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. The Man in the Case A NOVEL OF MYSTERY AND ROMANCE BY ELIZABETH STUART PHELPS | English Monumental Brasses The valuable collection of Brass Rubbings of the late J. R. LUNN, B.D., for disposal. It consists of upwards of 1,800 rmbb! ng. rite. E. A. LUNN, Blockley, Worcester, England. RESEARCHES made in the BOSTON LIBRARY, HARVARD LIBRARY, BOSTON ATHENABU"1. TRANSLATIONS made from French end Italian Summaries of a or one Expert copy and roofreading Mass. Institute of echnology, © a, 4 BOOK FOR EVERYBODY EATING TO LIVE. Ry JOHN J. BLACK, M.D. With special advice to the Gouty, the Rheumatic, and the Diabetic. Cloth, $1.50 net J. 8. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. ANACTORIA and oher b Lyrteal Pee « chosen from the works Hand- yo “int edi om tht fet. MITCHELL KRENNERELEY, 116 E. #8th Bt., New York “Here is a volume with sage and a pur pose; a book appeals, lt treats of the great est Of question the eter nal, uu mate problem —Death and After Death The obsere are those of aclever, experienced, and sympathetic man The Chronic! The Gate of Death ANONYMOUS ) Nearly 25 net ami whitch the ation ready **’ This beautiful and remarkable book Hardly any boo ince ‘In Memoriam’ has pre ted such notable claims to the consideration of popular theology I he really uncommon beauty, and is not likely to be forgotten in asingle season or a single ndon Telegraph Crown dvo. 1 Se] book possess year Le Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. G.P.Putnam’s Sons, 27 & 29 te 234 St., Literary JIN PERIL of CHANGE & Social By ©. F. G. MASTEUMA? Studies |THE NEW HUMANISM By EDWAKD HOWARD GKhIGGS Each 81 Sone P B.W. MUR BSOCH, Publisher, N.Y OLD ENGLISH COUNTRY COTTAGES Extra number to Internat Stadio. Ready Shortly 223 lilustrations. 14 (olor Miates. Cloth $3.00 net Wrappers, $2.50 net Postage i'« The Bodley Head, N.Y. ) JOHN LANE ©O.,

Page 4

- The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2157

N N ~ 2 I SW NOVELS S<RSONAL REMINISCENCES Ay \

New Macmillan Books By Henry George, Jr. The Romance of John Bainbridge = Ready this day novel of present-day life, politics, and love, in which many will trace with especial interest critical incidents An effective n based on facts in the career of the author’s father. Cloth, $1.50 Jack London’s White Fang rhe story of a wolf-cub tamed by man. In reproducing the magic of the still, cold North there has been nothing to com- pare with it since his great success, ‘The Call of the Wild.”’ Cloth, $1.50 F. M. Crawtford’s A Lady of Rome F. Marion Crawford since the days of ‘Saracinesca.” . . . Tragic, human, con- ‘The most notable novel written by Cloth $1.50 incing."'--Aecord-Herald, Chicago. Charles Egbert Craddock’s The Amulet a new story of this author’ s peculiar territory—the mountains of golden Tennessee. if Great Smoky Mountain. By the author of ‘ The Prophet Cloth $1.50 Bram Stoker’s Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving ‘*No matter what life or lives may appear with Irving as their subject, none will have stronger appeal, none will be more fective than this thrice commendable work before us.’’—Aaltimore Sun. With portraits and hitherto unpublished illustrations. Two demy 8vo volumes, $7.50 net E. E. Hale’s Tarry-at-Home Travels “Dr. Hale always treats his reader as his personal friend, and chats with him about men and things out of a fll store of high ideals and knowledge and with abundant personal anecdote, apt literary illustration and historical parallel generous patriotism.’’— 7A’c Outlook. With 200 illustrations of Dr. Hale's own collection. $2.50 net , Frederic Harrison’s Memories and Thoughts Men.—Books—Cities—Art. “For more than fifty years Harrison has been the friend of nearly every distinguished leader of English thought, and has been associated with practically every important movement of the period. Few have a richer fur 7 of reminiscence. . . Stimulating and suggestive.’’—Zwvening Post, Chicago. Cloth, r2mo, $2.00 net ABLE BOOKS ON HISTORY, ETC. Herbert Paul’s History of Modern England ‘Alertness of mind and the ability to visualize and present pointedly are Mr. Paul’s to an extraordinary degree this book is unique.’’—N. Y. Times. Complete in five volumes, Tolume V. just ready, $2.50 net; the set, $12.50 met Correspondence of William Pitt, Lord Chatham Secretary of State with Colonial Governors and Military and Naval Commissioners in America. When lhe standing committee on historic research of the Colonial Dames of America suggested in a recent annual report the publication of these important documents written at a critical time in American History. Edited by GERTRUDE SELWYN In two volumes. Cloth, 8vo, $6.00 net KIMBALI Professor Franklin H. Giddings’s Readings in Descriptive and Historical Sociology <tracts range from Genesis to a newspaper of the current year and supply at once a comprehensive body of sources rh ¢ for the student and a model of scientific treatment of the material constantly appearing in reviews, newspapers, etc. Cloth, ramo, $1.60 net Beatrice C. Baskerville’s The Polish Jew. His Social and Economic Value is the result of eight years’ residence in Poland, wide opportunities of observing both towns and settlements, and of contact vith leaders of thought upon all sides of the question from anti-Semitic to the Jewish nationalist. Cloth, Sve, $2.50 net VEL AND DESCRIPTION: Professor A. V. Williams Jackson’s Persia Past and Present “Few books of travel published this year approach this in interest.""—PAiladelphia Public A Book of Travel and Research. With 200 illustrations and a map. Cloth, $4.00 net. By mail, $4.20 ledger E. V. Lucas’s A Wanderer in London eminently useful to the stranger in the great English city.’—7Zhe Mew Yors ‘“Eminently interesting and, above all, 16 of its many illustrations are in color. Cloth, ramo., $1.75 net Trihun William Lithgow’s Rare Adventures The Totall Discourse of the Rare Adventures & Painefull Peregrinstions of long Nineteene Yeares Travayles from Scotland to the most famous Kingdomes in Europe, Asia and Affrica. Inthe series of reprints of famous 16th and 17th Century travels to which already belong “ Purchas His Pilgrimes,’’ ‘‘ Corylat’s Crudities,”’ etc. With 12 facsimiles of the original engravings. $3.25 net ruvishes THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “8 50 ave. by

Page 5

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 1, 106 The Week. Advocates of of “the means of production and trans- Government ownership are getting excellent object lessons these days. The failure of the at its Brooklyn navy yard battleship Connecticut the portation” Covernment build the rapidly as her sister ship, ana, was constructed in private yards to as Louisi despite most unusual exertions—has been widely commented on. Now, after fourteen years of experimenting, the Government has awarded to a private concern the contract’ for printing postage stamps. This has been done at the Bureau of Engraving and Print ing, whose bids were regularly be low cost. This fact led many people to believe that the work was being done far more cheaply by the Government than it could be by a private concern But these people failed to note that every vear Congress made up the differ ence by a special deficiency appropria- tion. As soon as Congress compelled the Burean of Engraving to compete with private firms on a fair basis, the American Banknote Company walked off with the business. Some day this country may decide to own all its rail roads If so, it will only be because the evils of private ownership it seeks to alleviate are less endurable than an inferior and a costlier service, to say nothing of the political danger of plac ing a million or more employees on the Government payroll. institutions A bill educational is pending before the Massachsetts Leg taxing islature. President Eliot, G. Stanley fall, and other prominent university men, have appeared before the Commit tee on Taxation to oppose it. Dr. Eliot showed that in Cambridge the tax rate was lower than in places where there was no university. The town has $25,- 000,000 of exempted property, with a tax-rate last vear of $19, whereas Low- eli, with only $3,000,000 of exempted property, has a tax rate of $20.20. Presi dent Hall said that Clark University rad no income from the students, and ‘f the bill were passed would have to curtail its work. Those Western States which support their own universities seem ignorant of the great discovery of that the way is to tax it Massachusetts statesmen, to foster education An example of the efficiency of agri cultural colleges is afforded at Fort Col- lins, Colorado, where $4,000 was paid out last year to the students for working at Crivelli, ‘ he Nation. the rhe class of ‘ 1907 has already been engaged by the school itself entire president of a Chicago iron company to Me x1ico, cows a work on his plantation in upon Which there are 1,000 dairy t looked after o be be cultivated 1.000 hors farm, and 40,000 acres of land to irrigated, and 130.000 acres to be Thomas Jefferson was the first American to urge the importance of such schools. Writing in 1803, he deplored the overcrowding of the trades and of the learned profes sions He recommended that a profes sorship of agriculture should be estab lished in every college. “The same arti ficial means,” he wrote which have been used to produce a competition in learning may be equally successful in restoring agriculture to its primary dig nity in the eves of men. It is a science of the very first order In hoping that the subject would one day have an hon ored place in the curriculum, he thought that more men might be induced to un- dertake the “labors of the field He would have been confirmed in this opin ion if he could have foreseen the vast expansion of the West If the project for consolidating the art collections of John G. Johnson, Wil liam M. Elkins, and P. A. B. Widener is carried out, Philadelphia will possess a museum superior to anything in \merica, and inferior only to those of the European capitals. Since the con tents of the proposed museum are al ready amply provided, and there is lack ing merely a proper site and building we cannot doubt that these will be promptiy furnished. The quality of these great collections should make an irre sistible appeal to public spirit. One can hardly imagine such a gift being declin ed If it were. as many American cit ies would strive for this great gallery of as Grecian towns for the hon paintings or of claiming Homer as son Since there is no published catalogue of the Johnson collection, the largest of the three. and the catalogues of Mr. Widen er’s and Mr. Elkins’s pictures are some vears out of date, anv numerical esti mate of the gift must be of the rough est sort Reckoning the pictures at twenty-five hundred, about half of which were painted before the year 1800, we shall be on the conservative side. But numbers give very little impression of the value of the gift. In the Early Flem ish schoo! there will be such a notable series as the two Van Evcks, Van dei Wevden, Memling, Gerard David, Old Breughel, Teniers Rubens, and Van Italian painting will Mantegna, Mo examples In northern the Dyck Vivarini, Bellini, Moroni, all by fine be represented Giovanni of retto Brescia English painti: s exen ified y im portant canvase of Revfiold Romney Gainsborough Purnes ind Constable Dutch painting wi ifford the most re markable display One may mention several portraits of Frat Hals best the landseapists Ru lnel and Hobbema a long series of the ® master in ciuding the rarest, Vermes of Delft ind, finally, somethin ke a dozen Re brandts, all fine, and represent hin in nearly every phase of a We must pass over the excellent Rena sance sculpture owned by Mr \V ene nd the ve ‘ n poi rm of the moder! sero in three co lections Suffice it to sav that the t ed museun vi have everal of Puy Ss sma es for } ty mu ] inting i! “ I t nore l i | t In short, from an art-l oriea ind on there w I no se ox ce] in he Ea rene! chool and in American painting This mere outline of the new gallery uffies te how how fortunate Philade phia i if i benevo lent triple illiance of « } ned art collectors The newest Concert of FE ) o the dispatches affirm, is to be an alliance to prevent the exportation of its best art to America. The Kaiser ven the unofficial patron; Dr. Bode of the Be lin Museum, who in times past has not a little aided in the exportation of fine prctures from Europe, is iid to be at ively enlisted in the movement What will be the practical method of embargo is not stated. One can hardly imagine the Pacca edict extended to all Europe Even the plan mooted in England of listing all important works of art, and in case of sale giving the Government a right of purchase at an official appraisal seems hardly likely to prevail As a riatter of fact. we judge that the move ment will simmer down to an organ Amer personage ed expression of defiance to the ican millionaire collector—a rough treat of for every vho hardly deserves such He has bought thousands old Lenuine the ment puta tive masters at top he aid of his moneybags he de whole toplie nonsense If we of H G John prices, snapped For arly example has up his On talk the ty vith {ow triumphs has paid much had Havemeyver of Philadelphia Gardner of Boston has had the of money ha is of this « collectors of have 0 Johnson L collector rrade ohn and \irs no ‘mertican same combination taste that fortunate to make Ludwig Mond In Rodolphe Kann if n fine here 0 ond opportunity yone the galleries of Dr of the late Moreover London or in Paris ins pie tures have come over have

Page 6

362 many returned to Europe. The Ww C. Whitney's Raphael is in the hands of a London dealer; Joseph Jefferson's fine carly Rembrandt went back to Holland; one recalls late other good canvases a Van Dyck of the Genoese been abroad. In estab- many particularly have resold kind of equilibrium is lishing itself, and American collectors have sufficient cause for self-congratula period snort, a tion without accepting themselves quite at the valuation of European alarmists. should be rejected That a tax on art in France is less surprising than that it should be proposed. When M. Poin- caré suggested a rate of 20 per cent. on importations of art objects produced before the nineteenth century, he was undoubtedly driven to such an expedient ty the difficulty of balancing the bud rer It is noteworthy that there was no thought of protection in the plan. The French collector was to be allowed to prefer Zorn, Mancini, or Zuloaga to the painters of Paris, without being mulcted for his taste But even as a revenue | measure the scheme has evidently seem ed abhorrent, for the budget committee has rejected it If the French Minis- try is unwilling to profit by a tax on education, whichis justifiable on fiscal grounds, what shall be said of ourselves who retain the mediwval schedule, al though it is relatively unproductive and the surplus grows apace? The in the House of Lords, Monday, on a section of the Edu unfavorable vote cation Bill is the beginning of the strug gle between the Liberal Ministry and that body It is upon the Peers that the Conservatives rely to block the meas- of the Campbell-Bannerman Gov- ernment, and it will all the skill and patience of the Prime Minister to overcome the obstacles in his path with out resorting to vigorous coercive meas ures as the of a large number of Liberal Peers for the express purpose of putting through the legisla ures take such creation tion for which the House of Commons has voted. Besides the Education Bill, four others are awaiting the action of the Lord They are of comparatively mall importance, since they relate to the sale of intoxieating liquors in Ire land) marriage with foreigners, marine insurance, and notices of accidents In mines, factories, and workshops. A very important measure that has passed the second reading in the House Is the Trades Disputes bill, which makes trades-unions a favored class in the It ia causing so much Liberals that are as eager for the opposition of to its progress as they are the passage of the Educa But that the Ministry will in the end seems certain: outsiders will eyes of the law resentment among certain they the Peers zealous for Bill have its way tion meanwhile, he | interested | The Nation. to see just how far the agitation against the House of Lords, led by such radical Liberals as Lloyd George, will go. That gentleman persists in irreverently call- | ing the Lords “old iron that ought to be ] scrapped.” The woman suffragists, whose rowdy- ism was the scandal of the opening of the English Parliament, are doing their cause a vast amount of harm. To ap- peal for the power to participate in the rovernment of the country is eminently within their right, but the appeal should at least be accompanied by some proof that the petitioners set store by that law order which is the basis of every sovernment. Every such outbreak—and have been far too many—covers chagrin leaders who depre- cate the to Yet even this disturbance illustrates clearly how creat is the desire for the extension of the suffrage. Every London newspaper contains news of the campaign now be- ing carried on with extraordinary fer- t'lity of and determination. Not a week goes by without its impor- tent meetings. Indeed, were there one- half the enthusiasm and vigor displayed by the advocates of woman's suffrage this country, the would be so that politicians could not af- ford to dodge it. The latest triumph of obtain an with the Exchequer, Mr. As- Mr. Bryce, is the opponent of woman’s and there with those resort violence. resource in issue pressing agitators is to deputation English for a of the who, next Cabinet the andience Chancellor quith, to strongest suffrage. The question whether men or women have the higher sense of honor has been under discussion in the National Union cf Woman Workers in England. One of men were not allowed in the debate—accused her sex of a ten- dency to cheat at cards, to make false boasts concerning their home affairs, to eavesdrop, and to read other people’s letters. A representative of Newnham College held that the public expected a lower sense of honor in women than in men But psychologists say that it is not the sense of honor which is lacking in women, in comparison with men. It is, rather, emotional equilibrium and self-restraint. This is illustrated by the fact that hysteria is far more common among women than among men. It has been recently shown that this nervous affection is analogous in its expression the imaginative games of children, being a morbid form of playfulness with no deliberate intention to deceive. Doubt- less, in the past, so little responsibility has been put upon women—if we except that early incident in Eden—that it is dificult for them to keep their feelings of matters where feeling is out of the speakers to out place [Vol. 83, No. 2157 The problem of dealing with the un- employed has been solved at a stroke by two borough councillors of Lam- beth. Let the borough laborers work, instead of eight hours, four; pay them the same wages as before; thus twice as many hands will be employed with- out reducing any one’s comfort. Evi- dently, the process can be carried out indefinitely, until the Borough of Lgm- beth hires all the labor and pays pret- ty much all the wages in the United Kingdom. No one has yet raised the sordid consideration of merely supply- ing the money. Indeed, the thought is sacrilege. The city fathers of Lambeth are absolutely single-minded. They will take care of the unemployed, and some- body else must provide the means. The principle of the right of employment at a living wage has seldom been advo- cated with such simplicity. Edmund Gosse’s inaugural address before the London Library Assistants’ Association contained much good sense. After a word of caution respecting the danger lest the librarian become a mere- ly mechanical classifier and arranger, he spoke of the dignity of books, and the care of them which was demanded. During the Middle Ages strict library rules were enforced to prevent injury and defilement of paper and binding. It was forbidden tv cut pages with knives which had been used at the table, and also to “eat fruit and cheese” over the Look itself. It is inexpedient, he con- tinued, to be too magisterial in the choice of library literature. Bad books will not prove to be attractive; as a rule they are “false, dull, sentimental, aud claptrap.” But the managers of libraries should not flatter readers too much, especially by giving out statis- tics as to authors most in demand, and Looks most often asked for. Thus bad taste is disseminated. It still seems hard to determine what shall be done with apparently useless books. Mr. Gosse thinks with the late Sir Leslie Stephen, tiiat they should be destroyed or that libraries should be instituted for them. It is, however, difficult to make a just discrimination. What is called “the general reader” is a capri- ious animal, and “the special reader” is one whose habits and eccentricities no librarian can fathom or be sure of meet- ing. special The slight excitement caused by the retirement of a veteran Foreign Minis- ter like Count Goluchowski is a fine testimonial to the stability of Austrian foreign policy. Baron Aehrenthal will presumably continue along the tradition- al lines. In many respects it is strange that there should be comparatively so little interest in the politics of the pivotal state of Europe. For this In-

Page 7

Nov. 1, difference one may account partly by the fact that the internal dissensions of the Dual Monarchy have been ab- sorbing, at the expense of international concerns. In any case, the only substan- tial contribution of Austria-Hungary to internationalism, since the striking paci- fication of Herzegovina, has been the al- liance with Russia for preservation of stability in the Balkans. As judged by its practical effects in Macedonia, this cxtente cannot be called a brilliant suc- cess. It is, however, at least a more re- sponsible guarantor of future peace than that concatenation of inactivities mis- called the European Concert. One may assume that Count Aehrenthal will, like his predecessor, maintain a pacific and rather negative attitude towards West- ern Europe, while reasserting, as occa- sion offers, the ulterior claims of Austria in the Balkan Peninsula. The Spanish Ministry has introduced a bill providing for “cult associations” after the French type. This is the beginning of an attempt to revise the present treaty with the Vat ican, and the movement, subject to the uncertainties of politics, is include religious education, the marriage and burial questions, and the control of the religious orders—in fine, a general sub- crdination of the Church to the State The attempt is of especial interest, be- cause its reception by the Vatican will reveal the true attitude of the Pope to- wards the similar movement in France The Spanish Government and the Vat- ican are in continuous diplomatic rela- tions, and presumably each stage in the revision of the concerning the Church will be thoroughly discussec If the Pope, then, should countenance the Spanish cult associations, it would show that his opposition to similar bodies in France was due not canonical principle, but to a sense that his ecclesi- astical dignity had been slighted. The Encyclical of August was vague, and if the deadlock between France and the Yatican is of a personal sort, there may yet be hope of an adjustment. M. Clem- erceau should be able to find ways of soothing the offended sensibilities. Mean- time, the success of anti-clerical legisla- tion in ultra-Catholic Spain must remain in doubt. much-discussed to laws to any The anti-militarist agitation in France finds an echo in Germany, at a time when the accession of Clemenceau is regarded as rendering relations between the two countries more difficult. A writ- er in the Berlin Vorwdrts has calculat- ed that of the three million men com- prising the German army on a war footing the Socialists may claim one million. The truth of this assertion has been challenged by a good part of the German press. These newspapers draw a distinction between mere weak sympa- The Nation. thizers with Socialism, whose numbers Evidently this girl ere admittedly large, and actual adher ents of collectivist principles, fanatic to the extent of braving military law and trial for high treason. No doubt so runs the argument, at the call to arms, such new-fangled ideas as “internationalism” will be swept away by the old spirit of soldierly obedi- ence, that Treuheit which is the pride of the Teutonic race Isolated cases of disloyalty may occur, but the authorities will undoubtedly be prepar ed to deal with them rather, true to the traditions of the Ger man General Staff, a little before they arise. It is not impossible that the prop is they arise, or, er cells and jailers have already been lesignated for Messrs. Bebel, Singer, and Kautsky. But though the press may be right in holding that the claims of Socialists as to influence in the army are exaggerated, their power for harm cannot be denied, once the possibility of even partial disloyalty is admitted. The strength of the German army is in Its mechanically perfect organization and ciscipline. If doubt of the absolute co lerence of its parts do but enter, that splendid engine must lose, if not in ac tual effectiveness, certainly something in prestige. The of reform in Russia, as observers have noted, is thwarted by a too vivid consciousness of the French Revolution. Recalling Mirabeau, Dan- ton, and Robespierre, the leaders of the Cuma feared to achieve less than their illustrious exemplars; while the Czar, we are told, refuses to make the obvi- ously necessary concessions because he bas before his eyes the fate of Louis course XVI. But modern politics hark back even to the classical examples. Tyran- nicide is recrudescent in Russia, and Harmodius and Brutus are its avowed patrons. The feeling is illustrated by an incident which fell under the eye of 4 special correspondent of the London Times. Having occasion to examine the albums of many students, he found them usually made up of portraits of assas- sins. Here is the “Pantheon” of a young girl of seventeen: On the first page was a photograph of a painting which was entitled “Prove thy- self worthy,”’ and which represented a girl thrusting into the hands of her lover a revolver with which he was to go forth and—assassinate The second page was adorned with a sketch of a Roman in whom recognize—Brutus! Then followed photographs of Kalayeff, who assassinated the Grand Duke Serge; of Sozonoff, who assassinated Plehve, and of many others—assassins all—‘‘of whom the time would fail me to tell”; and the piece de résistance was the photograph of Marie Spiridonova. On writen in I was supposed to a modest maiden the fly-leaf of the English: album was Lives of great ones all remind me [ can make my life sublime. ready for tyranni cide of the classical type as an exalted public duty. Writing on “Exchanges in Social Life M Paulhan in the Revue Philosophigq considers sentiment ! ts @X] ion as commodities. He usses the que tion whether a material value can bk put definitely upon emotions, so that they may be compared in terms of mo ney. It is plain that sensations have a real value, as may be seen by the prices charged in restaurants Esthetic emo tions also have a money equivale we pay to hear music or to see picture To a than those caused by a satisfied appetite for and certain extent, higher emotions are thought to be worth paying Good health, which makes life easy prosperous, may depend not only on the advice of a doctor, but and sentimental earnestness in the case of certain friend Even the observed In trade on his interest The pecuniary worth ships is also easily estimated ordinary courtesies and other kinds of business have an appreciable value, although a_ shifting scale of charges for such things would have to be made, if they were included in the bill. An excellent example of emotional exchange is furnished by the arrangements of married life. Compro mises, arrangements, plans of agres ment, even quarrels, lead up to an ad justment not unlike a trade-bargain Many of these “affective” to exchanges ars subordinated social interest in gen for where services for the benefit belonging to a certain eral, as, example, in patriotism are rendered in return which is derived from There is however, danger in this kind of nice cal culation, lest good-will, good words, and nation good acts come to be regarded as mar ketable commodities Americans linguists is Venice The abroad old complaint that are indifferent echoed by our consul at the college graduate who knows the lit eratures of European nations is seldom able to speak their languages. The con- calls attention to the Royal School Venice, where, after a Even sul of Commerce in year’s study, the pupils are able to un- derstand English and to speak it fairly well. Among American graduates there are, we believe,.more who could give a list of Goethe’s plays, or explain the origin of the French language, than there are who could read with ease the German and French newspapers, or carry on a simple conversation In a for- eign tongue. Yet for one man who needs a knowledge of philology and the his tory of literature, there are hundreds who would be the better for acquaint ance with colloquial French and Ger. man. It was Charles V. of Spain who said that to know an additional lan guage was to be a new man

Page 8

364 THE JAPANESE PROTEST. The irritation of the Japanese over the exclusion of children of that race from the schools of San Francisco has become a serious matter—so serious that President Roosevelt has thought it worth while to dispatch a member of his Cabinet, Victor H. Metealf, to the Pacific Coast to investigate the trouble Yet to those irresponsible agitators who have endeavored to induce the United States to treat the Japanese as it has the Chinese, Japan's official protest against discrimination in the schools will smack only of impudence For a nation of vellow people to arrogate unto itself the methods of civilized Powers in pro- tecting its citizens against wrongs suf.- fered abroad is the purest insolence. Why talk of treaties and treaty rights? Is not the Japanese an Asiatic; is he not accustomed to living on six cents a day Are and is tioned? As for our national pledges— we had a treaty with China, but the Su- at home? not his morals open to criticism, not his honesty ques preme Court held that Congress could violate it at pleasure. The Chinese, however, have not un- til recently been in a_ position to show effective resentment. Last win- ter, they started a boycott on Amer- ican goods, and a different tone was as- sumed by the representative of the Chi- a more vigorous inevitable re and the nese Government: policy in future is ult of the Chinese awakening The Japanese, flushed by success in one of the world’s notable wars, conscious of extraordinary development as a nation, cannot berexpected to sit by calmly and see their subjects treated with contume- ly With a civilization in ways superior to they some ean hardly against what our own, be blamed if they ery out the Japanese minister called the subjec- indignities of innocent, little Japanese children “poor, tion to The Japanese Minister was quick to that discrimination is purely fact he added, ' his the San Francisco local, but that can hardly be un- countrymen Particu- of the forma- California to all Jap- anene, He readily explain that, the Chinese issue no longer being avail tepping-stone to office, an un- editor began an couple of say he is aware stood by larly, we faney, In view tion of an association tn bring about the exclusion of cannot able as a serupulous California antiJapanese campaign a the purpose of winning in the United States Senate. Were vears ago. for a sent the mass of the Japanese people familiar with affairs, they realize that this aspiring statesman was merely imitating Southern politiclans who, tn default of any other issue, negro domination. Down with the Japanese! is not quite so effective a cry as Denis Kearney'’s shrieks against the Chinese our internal would numerous about raise a hullabaloo | tion. | Orlewns [Vol. 83, No. 2157 The Nation. used to be, because there are not yet one hundred thousand Japanese in all the United States; still, it may serve the purpose with professional labor agi- tutors and ignorant voters. The arguments—if so they may be dignified—were summed up by Representative E. A. Hayes of Cali- fornia, who in Congress last March made long attack upon the Japanese. Mr. Hayes explained that, while there are some good and pure Japanese men and a “small minority”’—the nation is really far gone in _ licentiousness; that concubinage is rife in Japan; that al! Japanese are native-born liars and quite untrustworthy in business: and that their new civilization is merely a veneer. Of Mr. Hayes made much of the complaint about cheap la- bor. In his view, the landing of 76,000 Japanese since 1900 constitutes a “most real and impending danger to the ma- terial and moral welfare” of the people of California. He told of 2,000 phe picking fruit in Santa Cruz County, where white girls used to pluck the ber- Convinced that 2,750,000 Japanese now plotting to descend upon us and “sweep the entire country of the Rocky Mountains clean of white laborers,” Mr. Hayes was natur- ally urgent that the bill before the last the provisions of exclusion act to all Jap- Koreans should be passed. this kind of claptrap in spite of the fact that the whole Pacific Coast is suffering for lack of labor. The development of all its in- dustries is retarded for want of hands. An immediate influx of from fifty to one hundred thousand Chinese and Japanese would be a great blessing. common women course, ries before. are west Congress to extend the Chinese and He indulged in anese That the protest of the Japanese is in accordance with their treaty rights is indisputable. Were the boot on the oth- er foot, we know how quickly an indig- pant State Department would rise up on behalf of injured Americans. Un- fortunately, Mr. Roosevelt cannot promise Viscount Aoki the discontinu- ance of the San Francisco discrimina- In like manner the United States Government was helpless after the New massacre of Italians in 1891. Unless Congress passes a statute in exe- cution of the treaty with Japan, all that Mr. Roosevelt can do is to beseech Cali- forn'a to mend her ways That warning, will do well to heed the and allow no temporary ex- such as the plea that fire has schoolhouses, to allenate Ja- non Trade with that country is one of ‘ts and the nation’s great assets, an asset that ought to Increase in value. Viewed from a broader aspect, the friendship of Japan is something the I'nited States cannot afford to throw away. Count Okuma has just sald that State igvencies destroved ithe United States and Japan “are the two great powers in the new world of the future.” There should be no mis- understandings between them. MUSEUM EXTENSION IN SCHOOLS. H. G. Wells, the Socialist critic of things American, tells how, attending the meeting of a Boston literary club, he was obsessed by the conviction that the mind of the world was dead, and he sought relief by tramping the streets for an hour or so. We do not know whe- ther his evening walk took him past the Museum of Fine Arts, or as far as Sim- mons College or Harvard University. In any case, the sight of any of these in- stitutions ought to have reassured him as to the mind of Boston, if not of the world. These three bodies are associat- ed in a novel and interesting alliance, descriptively but rather cumbrously en- titled a Committee for the Utilization of Museums of Art by Schools and Col- leges. President Eliot of Harvard is chairman of the committee, President Lefavour of Simmons College, vice- chairman. M. S. Prichard has resigned the acting directorship of the Museum of Fine Arts to accept the secretaryship. The work surely could be under no bet- ter personal or official auspices. Before noting what is peculiar in this new step, we should recall briefly other forms of art propaganda in the schools. For many years public-spirited commit- tees and individuals have sought to place in the public schools fine reproduc- tions of the best works of art. This practice is very common in the cities. Free lectures, such as are conducted by Columbia University and by university extension committees generally, have given much attention to the criticism and history of art. Something of the sort is done incidentally by the schools of painting. Loan exhibitions are a cus- tomary and successful feature of settle- ment work among the poor. In all these activities the museums have played a passive part. They have, however, very generally made it easy for bodies of school children to see the collections. Such visitations are frequent, the cice- rone being a volunteer enthusiast, a public-school teacher, or, more frequent- ly, perhaps, a preceptress in a fashion- able girls’ school. It is this relation al- ready established that the Boston com- mittee desires to improve and extend. A little observation of parties of school children, in the Metropolitan Mu- seum, for example, will show that these visits are often discouragingly unprof- itable. Museum gazing is fatiguing at best, and when youngsters are solemnly marched about by one who has little more knowledge than they, and no means of expressing the collective feel- ing, the performance, however well- meaning, is not very useful. What chil- dren, and for that matter most grown-

Page 9

Nov. 1, 1906] ups, need in art museums is intelligent and eager guidance. This it is that the Boston committee hopes to provide; accordingly, it will for the present con- centrate its efforts upon educating and The Nation ° stimulating school teachers in matters | of art. It is felt, and rightly, that the culture of the teacher is the measure of the pupil’s appreciation: hence the | true objective of art propaganda through | the schools. For the coming season the committee has provided two sets of | lectures primarily for teachers, one dealing with general and esthetic con- | siderations in the main branches of the arts, the second with limited fields in art history. The six lectures in the general course will be of a distinguished sort. America could afford no better trio than W. P. P. Longfellow, to treat architecture; Prof. George Santayana, sculpture; John La Farge, painting and | the minor arts; while the more specific purposes of the course are represented by two educators, Prof. H. Langford Warren of Harvard, who will speak on “What May the Schools Do to Advance | the Understanding of Art?” and Walter Sargent of the State | Board of Educa- tion, who will discuss “Museums of Art | and the Public Schools.” We have given this entire list because it is a gauge of the seriousness of the movement. The bane of similar at- tempts in the past has been the half- baked lecturer and the pushing amateur. Evidently, the Boston people are on their guard against both, and hold by the true democratic principle that only the best instruction is good enough for the people. This ideal is worthy of imi- tation, for there is such a prodigious deal of mere vaporing in matters artis- tic as to produce a veritable disgust with the word and the thing. We trust that the affiliation between Columbia University, the National Academy, and | | physical the Metropolitan Museum—a compact primarily for academic purposes—will | also result in increasing the amount of | popular instruction in art, and in ma- terially raising its quality. For those who are more immediately | | centrated on higher things and infantile concerned with the museums than with the schools, the implications of the Bos- ton movement are v interesting. It is no secret that either through its cura- tors or through its accredited representa- tives the Boston Museum of Fine Arts is planning to undertake direct instruction in the history and appreciation of art. Such viva-voce teaching, in the presence of the very objects of study, is surely the ideal, whether for the professional student or for the casual enthusiast. To have been a Peripatetiker in the Berlin Museum with Ernst Curtius, or to have heard August Mau descant on Greco-Ro- man painting at Naples, is one of the rare privileges that stick in the mem- ory. Difficult as it is for such lecturers to find the middle course between ped- antry and dilettanteism, the method its | | | surely the humane and fruitful one Some such undertaking, on the more modest scale suitable to youth, seems to be the logical next step at Boston the goal, indeed. wherever lovers of art are trying to thake our art museums more directly serviceable to the people through the schools HOW TO GROW OLD > Almost as much advice is given indi rectly to the aged as is given directly to the young The question is asked openly, “What shall we do with our boys?” But a question, as pressing in many cases, though never put above a v hisper, is, “What can we do with old men and old women?” Possibly, the ob jects of the latter inquiry, conscious of vessels their sclerotic and rheumatic may themselves have misgivings their To them it were danger that the of the Roman poet might be adopt the of those getting joints, social econ if “tristis senec- about function in the may m as there omy sé term tus” mere matter pro old avoid In longing life, have a fair idea of their duty ing draughts, unwholesome diet, and un Growing old, however, a if usefully, comfort cc now. who are in due excitement would ene could only do it ably, and gracefully. In the Revue Scientifique makes some suggestions about the body not be so serious business Dr. Bridou the mode of to avoid evils degeneracy, the fail, and the sun is in the west. There in which men may when begins is a correspondence between each step in the advancing years and certain hab its and of mind body. For example, the child is naturally rest processes and less, turbulent, and playful; these are signs of good health. But the gestures and acts of children, if observed in old are symptoms of sickly excitement, disintegration When the practices of youth are adopted men disorder, and or retained by age, we recognize that there is retrogression, which means re laxation of one’s hold on life But if, with advancing years, emotions are con diffusions are avoided, there will be self health. Men in the affairs Kelvin new moral who are control and like Bismarck of state, or their coveries in science, feel chiefly the phy- active who like Lord have attention engaged upon dis- sical disadvantages of advancin® years, but their minds have the vigor of youth This fact few old recognize, and so they expect fin It not by the affectation of youth that old age is to preserve itself from degeneracy and senile imbecility. The sprightly old lady who dyes her hair, paints her face, smiles away the downward droop of her mouth, and dresses like a débutante; the is a which people must une maussade ef rancuni¢re is really | old viveur who believes that by keeping his youthful vices he conceals his ad- | here i service of 8365 vancing years, who, being no longer by the return of passion, seeks the horror of gratified disenchantment To escape by reverting to the indulgences but not the unconscious! The ot healthy, 1 t 1ovs of these people are vy out of step with the musk imitation « and impulse ment sane and youth seems t the me mut it indicates a growing mot } ; al incapacity at a pecu to In America, the aged are liar disadvantage leave the stretch is lom offered imawvers, after have passed the grand climacteric. Their of day Ss the course long before in sight. Churches are se sur retainers to to clergymen, gical operations doctors, they sought because their ex but their In the Old The mounted advice is active are al World they septuagenarian Rotten be There perience, most done have a better chance be he is fortunate may seen in Row to pushed by the elbow into a cab are many Parliament the con White-haired men sitting in as in the Reichstag, still active in striking who an empire—in here re their too old or too feeble-minded Their experi ence, which is their one precious posses to Senators but trast certain fain seats, seem to resign sion, is useless because of the atrophy of their faculties Plato, in a fine passage in “The Re public,” anticipates the theory of Dr Pridou In reply to Socrates. who asks whether life grows harder as the end approaches, the aged Cephalus say: “Old men assemble, and at our meetings, my friends tell me, ‘I cannot eat, | cannot drink, the pleasures of vouth and love are gone.”’”’ Yet he con ciudes that In old age there is a feeling of calm and freedom when the passions relax their hold. For it is then, as Sophocles says, that there has been escape from the control, not of one mad master, but of many. Regrets and fu tiie desires lie In the characters and tempers of men, “for he who is of a calm and happy nature will hardly feel With the develop idea in all our readers the pressure of age.” ment of this same “Rabbi Ben Ezra” familiar— Browning's are Youn nll lay shall know, being old. in dispute; I We must admit, however, that such ad vice to the old is very apt to meet the fate of that offered young. In deed, any moralist exhorting the aged ought to do so in the spirit of the phil. osopher who said that he never gave ad vice except when he knew it would not taken to the be LIGHT ON CARDINAL NEW MAN A great gathering of ecclesiastics wa: present on October 9 at the tion of the church which has been erect ed at The Oratory, Birmingham, in NEW CONBECTA

Page 10

366 honor of Cardinal Newman. The Arch- bishop of Westminster said in his ser- mon that it had been but right for Catholics to “appeal to the whole Eng lish-speaking world” to help in erecting this memorial to Newman. It. might well be that Protestants would be glad to unite in a tribute to a man who was a religious genius and a master of style Indeed, Newman the writer seems des- tined to live longer than Newman the ecclesiastic Many who cannot fol- low his reasoning, yet feel the spell of his English in printed sermons which still have power to make the hearts of readers burn within them, as did his spoken words the hearts of the Oxford undergraduates in St. Mary's in the early days of the Tractarians. Men whole diameters away from Newman's theological position turn often to his Apologia” to taste again of its simple eloquence Estimates of Newman the man have varied with the personal or ecclesiasti cal point of view. Carlyle’s rough con- tempt for his intellect was one of the things that startled or shocked the world on Froude’s publication of the | “Reminiscences.”” Kingsley'’s attack on Newman's personal sincerity was terri bly punished, yet there were those who had their doubts Newman's “Gram mar of Assent” did not tend to lay them; since that book could be popu- larly described as an attempt to show that you could believe anything if only you tried hard enough Yet the Cardi nal himself disclaimed being a contro versialist Once when a_ Protestant champion challenged him to a _ public debate, he quietly replied “IT have really no taste or aptitude for contro versy, but my friends are good enough to say that | have some little skill on the violin It was left, however, for a co-religion ist to reveal Newman in new aspects of his character Lord Acton, the great acholar and stout Catholic, was thrown much into Newman's society, and in some of the letters just published in Lord Acton and His Circle,” there are many liftings of the curtain on New man'a private life Acton was backing the Rambler and often consulted New- man about that and other Catholic pe riodicals Here is a report of a con versation in 1858, when the Rambler was in trouble | had a three hours’ talk with the ven- erable Newman, who came out at last with hie real ventiments to an extent which startied me with reapect beth to things and persons, as Ward, Dalgairna, ete., ete natural inclination of men in power to tyrannize; ignorance and presumption of would-be theologians I did not think he would ever cast aside his diplomacy and buttonment so entirely, and was quite sur prised at the intense interest he displayed in the Rambler He was quite miserabl when I told him the news and moaned for a long time, rocking himself backwards and The Nation. forwards over the fire, like an old woman with a toothache. He thinks the move provoked both by the hope of breaking down the R. and by jealousy of Déllinger. He asked whether we suspected any one He has no present advice, being ignorant of the course of such affairs in Rome, ex- cept that we should declare that we do not treat theology in our pages. He wants us to have rather more levity and pro- funeness, less theology and learning A good story, he thinks, would turn away wrath, and he enjoys particularly your friendly encounters with Bentham, Combe, Buckle, and the like. Lord Acton, to be sure, held a racy pen, yet his picture of Newman as act- ing like “an old woman with a tooth- ache” suggests that all was not perfect serenity in The Oratory, after Newman's submission to Rome. On another oc- casion, in 1860, Acton found him a victim of the blue devils: I never saw Newman so much out of spirits, so distributively angry. ... I have never heard him speak openly on af- fairs as in the bitterness of his spirit he spoke during the half-hour I was with him We are not told the objects of “New- man’s wrath’; “he wished me not to repeat”; but the hint that his ‘‘vehe- ment language’’ was reported to be “in substance the same that I have been hearing these nine years from Dollin- gzer,”’ leaves little doubt that i: was the Ultramontanes with whom Newman was “distributively angry.” This infer- ence is borne out by another letter of Lord Acton’s, this one written to R. H. Hlutton in 1891, and only now made pub- lic by the latter’s son. In it, Lord Acton said that his own impressions of Newman were based “chiefly on the years 1858 to 1864." He added: It happened that those were precisely the years in which a semblance came over him of what he would certainly not have called Liberalism, but which showed itself in his dubious attitude towards the tem- poral power, and even in the Oxford scheme and the treatment of Liguori, and which was backed by much personal aver- sion for Wiseman, Manning, Faber, and even Ward These revelations are mainly of in- terest as showing that a spirit like Newman's had much to brook even af- ter he had gone over to the Roman Communion. But the dread of Liberal- ism which, as there is good evidence to show, first pushed him and Pusey into the Oxford Movement, was always pow- erful with him, and sufficed to make him acquiesce in measures to combat it, even though he disliked them. Where Acton and Ddllinger openly protested against the excesses of Ultramontan ism, Newman's rule was to submit. Yet Lord Acton’s intimate disclosures give us fresh knowledge of how often New- man's proud soul had to lay to ttself the command of “Faust’’—solist ent- hehren [Vol. 83, No. 2157 A REAL LINGUISTIC REFORM. Critics of the simplified spelling move- ment have justly noted that its cham- pions demand either too much or too little. If it is a serious question of re- forming the language, a little clipping of vowels and consonants here and there produces no real effect—is, in fact, like undertaking to clean up the Augean stables with an oyster fork. Better to let things comfortably alone than to stir them up to so little effect. We share this way of thinking, and feel that there are many reforms more worth the at- tention of orthographic ironmasters than that of spelling. To speak candid- ly, we have a little reform of our own, only awaiting its subsidy, namely, the consolidation of the many disguised compounds in the English language. In the natural course of things linguistic, everybody knows, set combinations of words come to express a single idea. The process is represented on the printed page by the hyphen, the finished prod- uct by the true compound word. All this is in the interest of simplicity. We gain when a hat-rack becomes singly and indivisibly a hatrack. But this useful tendency has halted half-way; the printed page to-day is clogged by superfluous hyphens and by phrases that are no phrases, but true compound words. Since the vocabulary of literature and the press knows no un- successful persons in commerce, why not write at once and plainly success- fulbusinessman, conservativebanker, and the like? Similarly, since the chron- icles of the bucket-shops are infra-liter- ary and ignored, when speaking of a Wallstreetmagnate one should mention him as a greatoperator, financialpower, or moneyking. The same principle ap- plies geographically also. A lethargic Westerner has never yet been mentioned in the newspapers; accordingly, one may dub the class generically breezywest- erners. By the same token pulchritude being universal south of Mason and Dix- on’s line, all females between the ages of ten and seventy resident in that lo- cality should be described as South- e:nbeauties, or, specifically, as Ken- tuckybelles. Girls generally may be suf- ficiently denoted as perfectgibsontypes, or, more elaborately, as_ thefinestprod- uctofourwesterncivilization. It is a striking fact that many of the phrases which need fusing into a single word apply to women. To a cynic this might suggest that the sex receives more than its share of lip-service. There is room for reflection in the fact that | the well-to-do world is peopled with delightfulhostesses, who marry, however, below them, for their husbands are merely genialhosts. Except upon the funereal samplers wrought by our grandmothers, widows are, as a rule, eminently consolable, hence we need the word, dashingwidow, or the still more

Page 11

Nov. 1, 1906] alluring compound, dashingequestrienne. Popularsportsmen usually choose their mates from this class, but sometimes are unlucky enough to marry notorious- adventuresses. In the literary world these disguised compounds are even more persistent, and need more urgent- ly to be set forth in their true unity. Passionatepoetess and talentedauthoress, soulfulnovelist, daringrealist, fearless- analyst, will immediately occur to every frequenter of literary teas) Why should the types keep asunder what the lips in- variably put together? In politics, too, we need a unifying process. Let us call our practicalpoli- ticians, logicalcandidates, and _ favor- itesons by their real names. These terms are actually as compact and single in intention as, for example, spellbinder or stumpspeaker. Professional life will af- ford many instances of these compounds which lie perdus, waiting only for the consolidating hand. Let one recall only the millions of prominentclergymen in the land, not to mention the brilliant- lawyers, graveprofessors, famousartists, renownedphysicians, and, in all modesty, ablejournalists. We have shown that this settling to- gether of invariable combinations of words is in the good traditions of the language. One might recall Homeric precedent also. Would the coiner of “rosyfingered” as an epithet for dawn, have been content to speak of a fair maid? Since all are so by courtesy, fairmaid is as inevitable as goodman or goodwife. Again, the economic argu- ment is not to be disregarded. An emi- nentstatistician who prefers to remain unknown has estimated that if all these disguised compounds were printed as the true compounds they are, the saving in white paper in the average American daily would amount to 5 per cent., in typesetting to as much, and the grand- total of these combined economies would be annually, in the civilized world, a sufficient sum to pay all the debts of the South American republics. Nor should the dearchildren of our schools be forgotten. If these words were prop- erly printed, the pupils of tender age would learn that these are not real ad- jectives and substantives, with the usual content of meaning, but simple decora- tions with which we festoon our shop- worn nouns. To learn this early in life would save many a disillusionment later on. The notedscientist quoted above has calculated that the saving of the aver- age child would amount to no less than a fortnight during its school course, in which time the easier complexities of simplified spelling might readily be mastered. In short, so many and co- gent are the arguments for this reform that we anticipate serious opposition only from the Iincorrigibly conservative class of Newenglandoldmaids. ‘The Nation. THE DANGERS OF THE SMALL COL LEGE “Whether the college, placed between the efficient high school and the powerful university can qgontinue to hold its own, and still offer an education worth reward- ing with a degree, is a question whose serious consideration cannot long be evad- ed.”" Thus the Nation, in an editorial of December 7, 1899, expressed a common doubt, and implied that the gravest danger of the small college was ‘“‘the inevitable tendency of the largest institutions to grow the fastest.”” Two years later, Pres- ident Harris of Amherst College, writing in the Outlook, seemed to regard that dan- ger as the heart of the matter, when he said: The question of the future of the small college is whether the universities are to grow at the expense of the colleges, At present the number of men in the detached colleges of New England, upwards of 3,- 000, is about the same as the number of men in the two universities. Will the pro portion continue the same or will It change? Whether the small college has yntinued to hold its own; whether the tendency of the largest institutions to grow the fastest is inevitable; whether the proportion of the university and the college enrolment has changed—these are questions which can now be inswered with something more than opinions. And here are the facts Lack of uniformity in college catalogues makes the task of extensive comparisons difficult. The figures here given represent the enrolment in the academic depart ments of the largest universities as fur- nished by their respective registrars to Columbia University The figures for the small colleges are taken from the cata- logues Although, for the reason men- tioned, it is difficult to be exact, these tables are substantially correct for De- cember of each year Table I. gives the enrolment for the past four years in seven small colleges of New England, with four added for gives the enrolment outside New England comparison. Table Il of men students in the College of Arts of colleges thirteen of the largest universities, except that Wisconsin is omitted, because in 1903 the A.B. degree there was suddenly made much more accessible. TABLE L.—COLLEGES 02-03. "03-04. "04-05 5°06, Put Amherst 385 48 40 ing 18 Bowdoin 275 277 2s) 289 5 *Dartmouth OSS 7™ yh Os 40 Trinity li4 118 145 1h 44 Tufts suv WO say 7¥ 22 Wesleyan 312 316 2u2 s21 = Williams tS1 417 44 44s 7 Colgate 72 178 227 246 4 Haverford 117 127 140 138 is Swarthmore 206 226 2435 Zs) A) Wash. and La 270 310 ae TD) S75 sy Total 224 3,450 3,822 4.059 + 20.59 TABLE I UNIVERSITIES Boston 451 456 45 4n2 4 Chicago 613 nee we 7 22 Columbia 44 4603 527 557 15 tCornell 783 726 672 Hie 12 Harvard 2107 2.077 2,006 1,505 10 Indiana wn wr nwo 43 19 tiohns Hopkins. 162 158 186 15S 16 Michigan m2 742 720 Sth “A Minnesota sul 470 470 470 4 Missouri s18 254 On 319 0.4 Nebraska 407 i) 315 263 ao Prit TSS 7322 (vl aco ‘ Yale 1m 251 1. 2s0 to ‘ T l rime s si se & @r oo *M ’ : . t* M and a“ Now, we can answer the questions asked by President Harris four years ago rhe answer is that In the past four years Har vard and Yale in t) rcadem lepart ments show a net 1 whil ! seven small col'eges f } ‘ per 1 show a net gain of 1 ) f we egard Dartmouth as neither larg: small, the growth of the remaining x " rilege of the highest rank app. than that of the two univers.ti« To add Ba Colby, Clark, and Maine to Table I would make the showing even m favorable t the sma!! college The gravest dang f the small college,” therefore, appea oO be no danger at all It has been said that the loss in the academic department of the large lege of all is due rather to the growth of universities In the We than to any in ure ng preference of New Englanders fox the small college But two facts show the falsity of this assertion first the college of arts in the West have not grown so rapidly as the New England small colleges second, Harvard College has suffered a de crease in the enrolment of students fromm New England and from Massachusetts her elf The report of the president says that at Harvard, in the undergraduate work there has been no durable gain in the number of students from New England or from Massachusetts, by itself, for five yeara past.” In fact, there were 1,235 New Eng land students at Harvard in 1900-1901, whereas in 1904-1905 the number had fallen to 1,162 In 1900-1901 there were 1,113 Massachusetts men at Harvard; in 1904-1905 there were but 1,050 It is evident that no durable gain” is a conservative ex pression for actual loss And, since, dur ing these same years the prestige and en rolment of the graduate schools of New England universities, especially of Harvard have measurably increased, and since the total college population and that of every small college in New England has in creased, there is strong ground for con cluding that, in the choice between the New England small! college and the college of arts of the large university, the country is showing a stronger preference than ever before for the sma!l college Two reasons which have hitherto induced men to choose the larger and older inatitu tions have been prestige and educational advantage But there can be no contin ued monopoly of either The difference in prestige—due to age and to the fame of alumni—has been growing less with the years Time will take care of that it is not surprising that the great men of one hundred years ago, if they went to col lege at all, went to the thirty colleges then founded William and Mary College had | her Jefferson and Monroe, Harvard had her Emerson and Holmes Bowdoin had her Hawthorne and Longfellow But now that there are some 450 colleges in the United States, the influence of prestige in deter- mining the choice of a college is not so conspicuously in favor of a few institu- tions. On the contrary, of the six universi-

Page 12

368 h have shown the greatest net gain of the four nsin, Syracuse, Michigan, Chi and Minnesota) Michigan) neither } eventy ye ties wh ollewe arts during last co only ‘ eth ) iwe tern or and over old, and Bix loss n it shown the Penn ka), all Thre fifty ye old greatest have Harvard Nebra old which (Ind Cornell ina yivania neeton, but f the two are over eighty years heaviest losers (Harvard 7; Penn 0 imong United 166 Princeton 129) are founded in motives syivania first tates the six colleges the ¢ stronger than Evidently and are to-day governing the of other age prestige choice college rhe in a trong col ad in has bee the luc potent thi elaboration of the univer motive which te mi est leading men prefer ynal fact point mall, nat itl vantage, is a le of a « to note o the rr it 18 the small the choice On 4 without behalf the enough common uments in thin sity under tem the multiplication erective y oon reaches a point beyond which the value of any considerable exten to ninety undergraduates out of a hundred that be is a more apparent than real the instruction may that mall highs college there of are st quality; and iifest gain fr rhese all app the fa are ym—stthe maliness which the Nation, fathers arguments of many o readers ly aling to and even the above ons, how justify the college is best for there Not compari that the conclusion the small all be might ‘ er On contrary exceptional men who lead and will always college 30 easily in athletics nm a small tcholarship music, debating, other student activities that they would need the ith stimulue of the keener competition There maturity “ larger numbers will always whose and strength are afeguards against the dan I if numbers There will always eaft great who really of not to want and can profit by ecrtain courses study which the small to otter enables college ought attempt il there will always whose bu others al more iness ability them io monks money during their college ‘ at a large institution than they amall institution has preparatory of mall coll make at a boy who found his let not every hip easy in school one those exception represe nt hool but me fittest in many has failure college not, attract of im the to bie ot rn othe vv ate growth unl in dangers at tudents and abortive universities ' atu sake stand foo many for entrance ink lange! itt That whi the low th falla b ri lege hat « of oumber urd of danger the « w which it competes, suffers | lower in in ollege which entrance requirement to become in fa than they are on paper, is in danger That which movements for Certificate such the college refuses to join uniform standards as danger to means perma college Boards, is in Such temporarily in but it course means the a crease enrolment, nently to lower the college standard ta | ing sort | r [Vol. 83, No. 2157 The Nation. A second danger—abortive attempts to become a university The college should be fundamentally a maker of men. Its | greatest source of strength lies in doing well precise ly that kind of work which uni- versity conditions render more difficult. In its desire to keep up with the times and to | thicken its catalogue it should not encroach on the work which is the distinctive of the for purpose prov- ines To provide technical university undergraduates is to miscon- of the college. To subjects to the few who wish to is beyond the the college owes the of its faculty to training the of- ceive fer remain such for graduate work of most colleges and beyond of all. The service means proper scope time and highest the A In undergraduates. intercollegiate athletics stand- a fac- Not stand con- scholarship than the whole. In fact, I have the tabulating of 18,- attained by all students’ in for five that the athletes non-athletes, third the danger degradation of scholarship the whole all but the athletes college. this is blind whole for which ards tor can see it the a as icuously lower in other students just asa discovered from ranks Bowdoin College rank of 80.37, shows \ titutions of years and than 3 per cent found for in iverage ae less result I + The excessive the 7.07 and difference similar six other in danger lies the interest in- wv hole the minimum of the know of which admitted, with- influence in tercollegiate student body entrance games the on and in influence on college at and requirements to cost I a desire New out win any England college retained man of the that that captain, examination, and a un- fit f any college, in written of rr Spite he he whom his fitting school was unprepared. The reason the br of the football the faculty dared not offend the bold but prote sf was was other A new graven of the been altar college have set on 8 image ofr late protest ventur- the still, scholarship has had but the yelling of thirty college game In- the all-absorb- student body, afford almost the tim- authorities the until recently of against smal a voice chances thousand voices at a athletics, the tense rivalry in of of and ing interest whole least the public those who can the enthusiasm of this particularly interest, of and the time fanati the idity school college as they makes intercollegiate athletics are now conducted dangerous to in com- their number of men, mall college They persist with universities which draw teams from ten times the ind from taken under their retain they constantly the not are pressure, ir friends” and own mis- ion to admit and men vw hose ily qualification is proficiency on the diamond or gridiron The er its refuses to low- the im- devotes small college, which standard from any notion of of energies of portance mere numbers; which its its own mission as the men and leaves to the university ts of spe- clalists; which guards against the evil and the which the con upon in- temporary extravagance of spending large buildings and smal! sums for strong teachers; which maker diatinet work making own athletics; shift employs good in resists temptation to any of underpaid, siderable part its teaching and the sums for fine experienced, assistants; which sees avoids the large college tendency to sub- stitute mechanism for personality in ad- ministration; svch a college, open to the accredited graduates of every approved “high school, offering a few elective courses in the most important branches of strict- ly college study, taught to small groups by first men, has a place important that all the in large colleges and in schools are serving only to the small college against its real and supposed dangers. WILLIAM TRUFANT Foster. towdoin College, | scholars who are | and so | so | secure temdencies to-day professional strengthen a Brunswick, Maine. Correspondence. SPENSER’S DATING OF “COLIN CLOUT.” To THE EpDITOR OF THE NATION: The date Again” biography as the SIR: Home of “Colin Clout’s Come important in Spenser's proof that he re- turned to his estate at Kilcolman in Ire- land in 1591. At the head of the poem appears a signed letter from the author to Sir Walter Raleigh, in which he: speaks of “my late being in England.” The let- ter is dated: ‘‘From my house at Kilcol- the 27. of December, 1591.” This apparently indisputable evidence is, how- ever, confronted by the date of the “‘Daph- naida.’’ It will be remembered that, ac- to the old style, then in use, January was the eleventh and not the first month of the year. Spenser dates his ded- icatory letter prefixed to the ‘“‘Daphnaida,”’ “London, this first of January, 1591’"—five days later than the date of “Colin Clout.” No imagines that Spenser returned to London immediately after sending ‘“Col- in Clout,” and composed the “‘Daphnaida” en route. The time limits forbid even Pegasus such a feat. Therefore, since there no reason to suspect either text, edi- tors such as Grosart and Lord Hales have taken refuge in an assumption that Spen- ser in the latter instance is using the style. Surely a desperate assump- tion, that Spenser in a single instance, without apparent cause, has violated the of his contemporaries! The only circumstance adduced to support this solu- ytion is the date of Lady Howard's death in 1590, as if it were proof that the elegy in her honor must have been finished in the same year. This leaves still unex- plained the reason for Spenser’s anoma- lous alteration of the calendar. As a literary device, it is true, Spenser did just this thing in the “Shepherd’s Cal- endar’’; but he devotes his “General Argu- ment” chiefly to a defence of the innova- is sole man, cording one is new usage tion, acknowledging that: “To some he {the author] may seeme fowly to have faulted, in that he erroniously beginneth with that moneth, which beginneth not the yeare.”” Spenser begins with January, as he explains, to conform to pastoral dec- orum; “Wening it perhaps no decorum that Shepheards shoulde be seene in a mat- ter of so deepe insight.”” In the case of his own dedicatory letter addressed to a marquess, no such excuse can be pleaded. A simpler explanation of the incongru- Vity has been passed by. The make-up of “Colin Clout” reveals a reason. Here

Page 13

Nov. 1, 1906] The Nation. Spenser takes occasion to describe, under Queen Elizabeth, her and court ladies, bestow- in turn a proportionate Very prettily he frames an of his visit pastoral names, courtiers, poets, ing upon each meed of praise these encomia in to England, which feignedly he renders to a group of his “‘shepherd’”’ friends in Ire- land. No doubt these friends were in- terested in the Elizabethan but so the court folk themselves. It is for London readers primarily that the poem was written. But how delicately Spenser couches this flattery in a recital feignedly made far away at his homecoming! So ap- propriately and with such a consistent sense of decorum that he feignedly dates the poem from home at Kilcol- man, being in reality—where? Where his poem would be fully appreciated, in Lon- don, where he was five days later, when he dedicated the ‘“‘Daphnaida.”’ account court; were his Irish PercY W. Lona, Ph.D. (Harvard). Bryn Mawr College, Pa., October 26. THE PRESENT POSITION OF LATIN AND GREEK. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Iam sure that others, as well as myself, noted with surprise the remarks of Prof. A. O. Norton of Harvard in your issue of October 4 (p. 280) in regard to the decline in the number of students of Greek in and college. “The abandonment of prescribed Greek for college entrance,” says Mr. Norton, “has probably not greatly influenced the decline’; and, again, “‘Greek is still and well protected, at most colleges by being given credit for a given amount of work than any other subject.” The latter statement will un- doubtedly hold true in the case of the col- leges which he names; but the context shows that his argument is of general, not local, application, and I am unable to see by what considerations he would justify his conclusion in respect to the colleges of the United States as a whole. In this connection the statistics of enrolment of Greek students in the secondary schools of the different groups of States are in- structive when confronted with the entrance requirements of the colleges and of the school protected, more arts departments of universities in the same States. Thus, for example, the de- cline in the enrolment of Greek students in the schools of the North Central States from 5,030 in 1897-98 to 2,767 in 1903-04 is synchronous with the adoption of an “om- nibus”’ bachelor’s degree by several promi- nent colleges in the same region; how broad are the entrance requirements of these institutions at the present time may be seen in the tables published by Princi- pal F. L. Bliss in the Proceedings of the North Central Association of Colleges and Secondary Schools for 19065. If he had not been hampered by limi- tations of space Professor Norton would probably have pointed out the fact that the statistics for the study of Greek in col- lege, which he cites (16,218 students of Greek in 1900-01, and 14,729 in 1904), are of interest only as indicating a general trend; they are too inaccurate to be of value in estimating the proportion of college stu- dents enrolled in Greek, which is sug- gested by the citation of the figures show- ing “the total college population” in the same years. Not to speak of other omis- sions, the totals given contain no report of the enrolment of Greek tud Harvard, Yale, the University M iga and the University of Chicago It is to be regretted that by a slip of the pen Mr Norton ha i ented in respect to the study of Latin some figures which are misleading He says (p. 2s1) Latin flourishes in the secondary schoo almost beyond belief. In 1894 th: were roughly 480,000 secondary students in the United States, of whom 43.59 per ent were studying Latin; in 1904 the numbers were $22,000 and 49.96 per cen I é tively In the report of the commi yer of education for 1903-04 the num $22,235 represents the whole attendar of sec- ondard students who were en ed in “public high schools, public normal schools public universities and collegs pri vate” institutions of like grade private colleges for women,”’ and “manual train- ing schools.”” “While the number of sec- ondary students in the preparatory de- partments of colleges and other institutions is given,” says the report, has been found impracticable to collect complete Statistics of such departments.” Con- sequently the statistics for the enrolmen in Latin are limited to public and pri- vate high schools and academies In 1903 04 the enrolment in Latin in the publi high schools was reported as $23,028, in private high schools and academies as 46,301, making a total of 369,329; this is approximately 49.96 per cent. of the total enrolment of students in these classes of institutions, which is given as 739,215. Had account been taken of the enrolment of students of Latin in the preparatory de partments of the colleges, particularly the denominational colleges, and in all othe! institutions having students of secondary consid- the the number must have been erably augmented; but dents enrolled in Latin formed a greater or rank, whether stu- smaller proportion of the whole 822,235 secondary students in attendance at all classes of institutions it is impossible to tell One may hazard a guess that the percentage, if known, would fall below 49.96 FRANCIS W. KELSEY Aun Arbor, Mich., October 20 A BETTER POSTAL CARD To THE EpITOR OF THE NATION: of Sir: In the Nation April 5, 1900, 1 wrote as follows to me why this gives itself every Can any explain splendid big nation, which one conceivable form of luxury annot manage to provide for its inhabitants a white pos tal card? In England a lady or a gentle man can write a short note on a po card and not feel that one has done anything de rogatory to one’s dignity; but here ons must make use of an unpleasant yellow thing, of inartistic proportion rel £0 through the fatiguing and ex] ve work of writing a note, putting | nto an en velope, and affixing to it a two-cent stamp Last year, being a publi pirited person I wrote myself to the postmaster-general and begged him to provide a white and tidy card, even if it had to cost two cent he replied that it was impossible at that time but that it should be done another year Another year has come, and there its etill nothing of the sort to be seen Now what I wish to know is this: Why should a lux urious nation think it worth while to prac- tise this particular form of penury Six years have come and gone, acd a white postal card, of good writing surfa and of good proportions, must still be num bered n this Among non-ex t s Could I ! RK eve r ou i : be per suaded to tal ! ! eded f Cc. L. I Ba wore October 27 Notes. I P. Dutton & ¢ ! ving books on. the i rir ind Clock fa lr i 1 metho f i H. H. Cunyngha H ! and ¢ Po by John Day “ ‘ i poetry The Heart of Eng Ls hdwa rho with ] by H. L. Richard William Blak \ Cr val | Ly t Sw ‘ ‘ “ j ‘ \ | y nd Exy ve b S And vw N ‘ \ igran and iliust nD and Socia S by Geors W. E. R ell, autl ( | and Re llecthe \ nual m 1) ber, 19 he \r in H ‘ il A m aj proved the plan of f | i » conta th | al 3 i whicl he « ly } f Ur | State founded ) The ger il litor } fi t me was J Franklin Jan nm The fi volum 1 ied by Charl Ss t Sor ealled The N hmen, ¢ ni and Cabot 85-1] The voyage f tl NO nen are edited by | f J i] 0 hose of Columbu ind Jol Cabot ! I f. Kk. G. Bourn Phe it Cambridg H f | list L ire n f iT which } " i be int the lum will ut hed tt I G. I Pu i Ss ! gula x f th Camt lg I I On book 01 igh t eri of English Cla 4 rl Plays of B imor 1 F! he } Bu I Gra \! ne und I’\1 ! I ) ‘ 1 by l) John Brown rhe } , 1 Er h Pla f Abraham Cowl lited } A. R. Wal rhe Worl f Gile ind Phineas Fl has edited } } S Boa The Poe! of George Gascoigne edited by I iJ. W. Cunliffe rhe Poems of Georg: Crat vol. ii rhe Life of §$ Leslie Stephen, K.C_B by Fred k William Maitland is alr nounced among the November publications of G. P. Putnam's Sons Lr Maitland, a e friend of Sir Leslie and h family Downing professor of law at Cambridge University The Macmillan Company will ) ha idy an English edition of the now fam is Memoirs of Prince Von Hohenloh+ Thomas Whittaker is bringing ou rhe King and His Kingdom by the Rev. ¢ J Ridgeway, dean of Carlisle, and Religion and Experience,” by the Rev. J. Brierley of England (J. B.""), editor of the Chris tian World. In mentioning, last week The Complete Works of Abraham Lincoln ssued by the Francis D. Tandy Company, we spoke

Page 14

[Vol. 83, No. 2157 370 tenth We are the vol- completing two more volume as that containing informed an appen- hand place; a by an to appear material that came to too lusion in its Ribliography of Daniel Fi of chronological late for in proper Lincolniana, prepared sh of Lincoln's Judge Minneapolis; nthology sayings and epi- grams i index and an ex- haustive analytical index has of has the many years of for Anatole France, who for i pecial student the story loan of Are bee n ibject is at ten book publish and who years engaged in writing a on last about to his vork through Calmann-Lévy McKie David Rambles" covers a good and includes Ireland, Wales, The first and is rhomas “Summet (kid deal of ground otlaad nburgh Douglas) and Germany Dublin capital England, Si happens to describe though like a surprised iriously unlike that tain hints of resemblance not picture was taken All Mr. McKie'’s chapters gayeties thronging Cork, or that half a distressful tal- lack that writer raph, that we are the some fiftv vent iZzo the and population of Limerick, or reader that remind the depopulated Mr. McKie topography, and He falls the ry ha has not the his ske into the puntry But ent fot bits ind « tches sin olor » often besets descriptive } pr the ivate dearer to him philosophy is his read- described than ambition to transport the plac t ers imagination to Fr. Berke “In London Town” York ley Smith's Funk & Wagnalls Co.) is writ- whose iNew Paris gaudier home is the by When he of looked on her many-sided face back unimpressed ten spirit’s in superficial has gathered charms London with a hand with a the by to so many ind eye he hurries to Weber has made Mr would life of efiorts at uperficial Re taurant quite that London dear Smith offers his read- call of the artiste, the Em a cosmopolitan gayer side hall Bohemianism, the confronted er what he the London, the music the back heavy tairs life of the Gatfety and Imagine Charles Lamb pire with these Frenchy illustrations of rouged gilded torical and youths, this complete the hi women lack of feeling, this amazing London stands for description of a Sunday society of a little route is most what in the he ignorance of of men gay the imhteor in Dat enne picked up en chapter we have read for a ‘my simple highly-titled harks back thy he is only too be more book is lone tlie \ for podigres to h eentur we fear could that no one effect of ha attrac tively bound editions of Palgrave's “Treas- Kinglake’s in the dD. Ga Orien- ry of rred tong and Kothen It Introduce Hogarth tal read work, by wok of long tliat was refused by sev ecuriou to tion to the latter that this superb b travel belongs to the of re feote j 1 manuseript It her before it was tasued, in of Pall Mall, partly at expense risk Philosophical Classics publi 1844, by Oliver the author own and Number 60 of the published by tain Fichte’s Vox the Open Court Company, con ition of Man,” translat The Nation. ed by Dr. Willlam Smith. The series now embraces an excellent selection of the great philosophical treatises, sold at commend- ably low prices. “The Economy of Happiness,”” by James Mackaye (Boston: Little, Brown & Co.), is a treatise on logic, ethics, and economics In his Introduction the au- thor advises those who are not interested in the first or the second book to read the third. It would have been better if he had condensed some and omitted other parts of the earlier chapters, which are unnecessar- ily long and discursive. The way to happi- ness, he tells us, lies in the application of common sense to social and economical con- ditions, with “utility” as the standard. Mr. Mackaye calls his theory “Pantocracy,” which is founded on “the socialism of Marx and his co-workers.”” Among the “eight different features” of this scheme are: pub- lic ownership, retention of the wage sys- tem, and abolition of profit, with organiza- in three books. tions to adjust supply to demand, and to deal with all the principal problems of economics. The author has a fancy, ap- for coining words which obscure meaning. The theoretical part of his work ts partly elucidated by mathematic- al formulas by diagrams which some people may find interesting, if not instruc- tive. . parently his and Specialists have known that the best book by an Occidental scholar on Hindu religion is the (or section, or part; the division of these German books is inex- of Professor Deussen’s “Allge- meine Geschichte der Philosophie.” This has been translated by A. S. Geden as “‘The of the Upanishads’’ (imported by Scribners). It is a work to be heartily recommended, although the reader must be advised that a certain note of intellectual- ism, bound to appear in the treatise of any second volume tricable) Philosophy German metaphysician, somewhat distorts the primitive character of those ancient books. Some time about the year 800 A. pb. a great Hindu metaphysician, Shankara (or (ankara, as the name is more commonly transliterated) developed the VedAnta, as it lay in germ in the Upanishads, intoa system of stupendous intricacy. He was the Doctor Angelicus of India. In 1883 Professor Deus- sen published a compendium of this phil- osophy, under the title of “Das System des Vedanta,’’ to which he added at the end a brief summary of the doctrine. This sum- mary, “The Outline of the Vedanta System of Philosophy, according to Shankara, by Paul Deussen,”’ has been translated by J. H. Woods and C. B. Runkle, and published in a slender volume by the Grafton Press It is the best exposition of the chief school of in brief compass Hindu metaphysics obtainable A pathetic interest attaches to the Rev. Dr. George Matheson’s “Rests by the Riv- er’ (New York: A. C. Armstrong & Son) since the blind minister of St. Bernard's, Edinburgh, closed his useful and devoted life only a few months ago. The present volume resembles several of the author's previous books, In that it consists of a large number of devotional meditations, of three or four pages each. The brief hom!t- lies are based on original, sometimes fan- ciful, interpretations of a Scripture text, and have a flavor of true piety. Dr: Mathe- son was more at home than most men of these times in the region of religious mys- teries. His death removes the seer from the company of Scotch theologians, but the present volume will conspire well with his former writings to preserve his beautiful spirit and to exhibit to the many who need the lesson that it is possible to be pious without being foolish. Two considerable volumes of “Spiritual Studies in St. Luke’s Gospel,” by the Rev. Arthur Ritchie, Rector of St. Ignatius Church of this city (Milwaukee: The Young Churchman Co.), manifest both the merits and defects of High Anglican churchmanship. Sincerity and enthusiasm and a religious spirit are evident. The au- thor has devoted much study to the Church fathers, and under every important text he marshals passages from Augustine and Chrysostom, Cyril, Ambrose, and Jerome. Unfortunately preference is shown for fanciful patristic exegesis. Stier and Isaac Williams, whose cabalistic style of interpretation is well Known, are the modern commentators he cites most frequently. To recent critical works, even of the thorough scholars of the author's own communion, he pays no attention. Dr. Ritchie has arranged hts commentary in short sections, and divided each “study” into an exposition and a series of three “thoughts,”’ thus adapting his work to quick reference and ready comprehension. Lewis A. Hart, author of “‘A Jewish Reply to Christian Evangelists” (New York: Bloch Publishing Co.), is a Jewish notary in Montreal and a former lecturer in the faculty of law at McGill University. He is greatly outraged by Protestant endeavors at the conversion of Jews, especia'ly by the efforts of the Jewish Mission in his home city. It seems that a member of the Pro- testant Ministerial Association of Montreal wrote to the Jewish Times of that city in extenuation and explanation of the prosely- tizing endeavors, and Mr. Hart made the series of vigorous replies now published in book form. The essays are naturally polem- ic, and from their point of view, able. The special object of attack is the doc- trine of the Trinity, which is understood as tritheism, ‘‘a triumvirate of gods.’’ He has, of course, no difficulty in overthrowing the arguments by which it is sought to estab- lish this doctrine from Old Testament texts, from the “Elohim” as plural, from the trisagion of Isiah vi., etc. His philippic against this sort of exegesis and the doc- trine founded on it, takes one back to the days of Channing. But, unfortunately, when he seeks to define and vindicate his posi- tion as a Jew, he sinks to the same literal interpretation that he condemns in his op- ponents. This method may have lent force and effectiveness to his papers as tracts for a particular situation, but essays of this quality are of no value in exhibiting the peculiar strength and weaknesses of the religions with which they deal. word In “The Poetry of Chaucer, a Guide to its Study and Appreciation” (Houghton, Mifflin & Co.), Dr. R. K. Root of Princeton has given us an agreeably written book of «a popular character, which in accuracy of statement and fulness of information sat- isfies all scientific requirements. To be sure, for professional students the work contains too much that is elementary—at least, for consecutive reading—and on the other hand, being purely expository and eritieal and not biographical, it may prove

Page 15

Nov. 1, 1906] The Nation. too long perhaps for the taste of the gen- Nevertheless, both classes of readers with profit. Th» author has utilized all Chaucer investiga- tions up the present year, including the important recent discussions of the Prologue to the ‘“‘Legend of Good Women.” One does not look, of course, for new dis eral public may consult it to coveries with regard to Chaucer or his works in a book of this character, but in setting forth the present state of knowl- edge of his subject the author exhibits in- dependence and good judgment in his at- titude towards the work of others Es- pecially to be commended is his con- servatism in rejecting the ingenious spe ulations which have recently aimed at rev- olutionizing the generally accepted chro nology of Chaucer’s poems. On the side of literary criticism Dr. Root shows the same qualities of conservatism and good judg- ment Like that issue from American universities, it is perhaps too didactic in aim, and the shadow of ortho- times hangs a little heavily over Yet the book is written so evi- dently amore that the sympathy of the writer can hardly help becoming in- fectious. The discussions of the characters in “Troilus and Criseyde” and of the ‘litel clergeon” in the “Prioress’s Tale’’ furnish, perhaps, the best examples of our authors work from this point of view. Among er- rata we may remark that Dr. W. E. Mead’s edition of “The Squyr of Lowe Degre”’ ap- peared in the Albion Series, not the Ath- enwum Press Series. Finally, it seems to us that in any enumeration of authors (p. 12) who illustrate the intellectual activity of England about the close of the four- teenth century, it is a mistake not to men- tion the author of the plays in the nine- line stanza in the Towneley collection. most books doxy at its pages. con The large number of students in our uni- versities who occupy themselves with An- glo-Saxon subjects will be pleased to have a handy and easily obtainable translation of Asser’s “Life of King Alfred,’’ such as Prof. Albert S. Cook has supplied (Ginn & Co.). The present is an opportune time for a translation of Asser’s work, inas- much as the authenticity of the book, so long in dispute, has been pretty well vin- dicated in recent years by Plummer and Stevenson. Indeed, the advantages which Professor Cook's translation enjoys over previous ones is due mainly to the fact that he has been able to use the results of the investigations of these two scholars, especially the latter, whose edition (1904) of Asser’s “Life” in its original form has superseded all others. Professor Cook has appropriately added two appendices—one consisting of Alfred’s well-known preface to his translation of Gregory’s ‘Pastoral Care,”” in which the state of learning in England in his day is described, the other of the letter of Fulco, primate of the Franks, in reply to Alfred's request for the services of the priest Grimbald. Three volumes in the dumpy but attrac- tive World’s Classics now issued by the Oxford University Press, contain “The Works of Edmund Burke,” vol. ii., with an Introduction by F. W. Raffety; “The Pro- fessor,” by Charlotte Bronté,”’ with the Bronté Poems, and Defoe’s “Adventures of Captain Singleton.” Mr. Watts-Dunton contributes the Introductions to the Bronté and Defoe volumes, and in the latter gives some rather interesting information about the relation of his friend Borrow’s style to that of Defor The influence of the older author on the younger was, he says, beyond all Kauging Often and often has he [Borrow] said to me that Defoe was the only ‘professional’ author who could ‘tell a plain story on paper.’ Mr. Watts- Dunton thinks it a curious subject of spec- ulation whether the recent revival of in- terest in Borrow will cause a revival in the master himself And what, he asks will be the effect of Defoe’s simple, lucid, direct style of narrative upon the style of the prose Mr as a participator in his favorite fiction of the twentieth century? Watts-Dunton Defoe and much- To bring Crusoe under “Aylwin” is seems to regard noised “‘renascence of wonder.” of category the “Robinson that of “wonder” the same as a bit of critical legerdemain Another published in a expensive two-volume memotlr now volume at a Brook- Scrib- sing e cheaper price. This time it is “Mrs field Her ners. The custom of issuing a cheap reprint the justification and Circle,” imported by its of view, but seems almost an imposition upon from same plates doubtless has from the publisher's point the early purchasers of the more expensive edition. Professor Howard of Leland Stanford publishes through Macmillan a_ careful study of the German Constitution, under the title of “the German Empire.” After a brief introductory chapter he takes the Constitution of the new pro- ceeds to analyze its component parts. Thus we have chapters the Kaiser, the Reichstag, citizenship, judicial organiza- tion, military service, finance, and kindred subjects. The text of the Constitution is given in an appendix, and the book, as a whole, will prove a convenient manual of the subject viewed in its strictly constitu- tional aspect. empire and on Paul Leland Haworth has chosen as sub- ject for a thes‘s “The Hayes-Tilden Dis- puted Presidential Election of 1876” (Burrows Bros.). The author sets forth with care and in a judicial spirit the facts as he finds them in the contemporary news- papers, and in the proceedings of gressional committees. He does not, how- ever, put forward new evidence of any im- portance, nor does his verdict vary from that which is commonly accepted It is possible that Tilden should, technically, have been elected; but it is quite certain that the of malpractice told against the Republican vote in the South. Those who like terpreted for them Soul,”” “Historic Process,” ‘‘World-Spir- it,” and “the Self of the will doubtless find much to please them in Mr. con- balance have in- terms of “Folk- to in history Universe,” Denton J. Snider's ‘‘American Ten Years’ War, 1855-1865"" (St. Louis: Sigma Pub- lishing Company) The array of incident is, indeed, respectable, and the comments of the author are sometimes keen and sug- but to the his- tory of the Kansas struggle and the Civil War, it is the kind of book that we fancy a historian would pre- fer and that a on gestive; as a contribution negligible It is to relinquish to a_ philosopher, philosopher would gladly pass to a historian That historians of mediwval Italy have | | | | hitherto 371 too turned the attention exclu sively to the study of the Communes is a statement which can hardly fail to obtain | the assent of every thoughtful reader. We have numerous learned treatises on the | private and publ life of the cities, thei: guilds, their magistracies, and the stat utes; and, although much yet remains to be done before we can fully appreciate the peculiar characteristi.a of each sep arate Commune, we are already able to form a tolerably clear idea of the insti tutions and customs of the Communes as a whole When, however, we pass outsicds the walls of the cities, we are in a coun try which is practically unexplored or the castelli and the ville, of the serf and the colonus, we know hardly anything dead before our way in Feudalism is treated as it wa even moribund, and we lose trackless forests where we expected to find cornfields and vineyards. Our idea of me diwval Italy is like a picture without a background The foreground is clear, but behind it is well-nigh impenetrable mist Here and there, it is true, a faint light shed by monographs on individual villages monographs such as that of Profeaso: Zdekauer on the Carta Libertatia of the Rocca di Tintinnano, or the recent pamph let of Dr. Paolo Piccolomini on the Statuto del Castello detla Triana, in Monte Ami ata (Siena: Tip. Lazzeri); but for many years no serious attempt has, we believe been made to treat the subject as a whole. It is for this reason that the learned work of Dr. Francesco Briganti “Citta Dominanti e Comuni Minori nel Medio Evo con speciale riguardo alla Re pubblica Perugina’’ (Perugia: Unione Tip Codperativa), is especially welcome; for it is the “minor communes,” the villages of the Perugian contado, which are here studied, and we are thus enabled to under- stand how the villagers, the tillers of the the the vignari, the bifulci, lived after they had exchanged the of the ignior for the lighter yoke of the “Dominant City.” As soil, the coloni, manenteca, yoke feudal sé one of the librarians in the Biblicteca Comunale of Perugia, Dr. Briganti has had exceptional advantages, and he has used them well. We may not always agree with his conclusions; but his conclusions are of secondary importance, since he has laid half of his pages are made up of notes in which the which textually reported. Such a a subject is all his evidence before us. Almost he relies are book documents upon on such invaluable the of mediwval Italy. It enables him to obtain a new point of view, to fill in a back- ground to his picture, and to perceive how groundless are many of those generaliza- tions which he has heretofore been taught regard as axiomatic An admirable work, which may be profitably studied tn connection with Dr. Briganti’s volume, is “I Codici delle Sommission! al Commune di Perugia,” edited by Count V. Ansidei and Dr. L. Giannantoni. It was commenced in 1895 and has been published in succes sive numbers of the Boilettino della Societa Umbra di Storia Patria. It will, derstand, be completed in the forthcoming issue of that periodical to student to we unh- A breath of the South American prairies permeates the pages of Rudolf Schmied's “Carlos und Nicolas: Kinderjahre in Ar- gentinien” (Munich: R Piper & Co.), and

Page 16

wD) 3°72 brings us something quite different from th conventional atmosphere in even the t of our own descriptive works on that f off country That the author has been there and knows the life whereof he speaks very apparent, and so is the fact that he is the typical German, possessing the iand in advance of his Yankee neighbor, notwithstanding the Monroe Doctrine and ita terrifying paragraphs. Carlos and Nic- olas are the lusty “young ones” of a wealthy German ranchman, far away from he city and civilization; and on their nlendid mounts they wildly course the prairies. Stretched out on their backs on the boundless pampas, these boys dream dreams. and draw on their imagination un- til Nicolas swaps his boleadoras or iron weighted lasso for a prospective ship Carlos pretends to possess Aside from the naive narrative of the boys, the vol ume conveys an impression of national life ch as one might expect to be given the traveller in Argentina, and is, all in all, refreshing reading Another copy of that rare pamphlet, rhe Prose Romances of Edgar Allan Poe,” Number 1, containing ““‘The Murders in the Ku Morgue and “The Man That Was Used Up has been discovered It was terally picked up” in the country and ld to Frank Maier of thi eity whose col lection of first editions of American au- tho i now one of the finest in exist- ence rhe book is so rare that there is toubt whether in the ordinary sense of the word it was ever published at all The ver (there is no title-page) reads, “Uni form Serial Edition Each Number Com- plete in Itself No. 1." but no second imber is known. The price as printed on he cover was twelve and one-half cents lhe only other copy which can be definite- placed was purchased by the late Fred- ‘ k W. French, about 1896, for about $90 it had then already been in the hands f th bookseller A New England book- iler (who may be called No 1) found i book and, thinking it to be, prob- bly niy an odd part of Poe's works, old it to bookseller No for sixty-five lie, knowing what a good item he had acquired old it for $60 to bookseller who in turn sold it to Mr. French fier his death, at the sale of his library mm in 1901, $1,000 was paid for the book It is now in the collection I Kh. Hlaleey, whose library is famous ' ning two of the three known { f lo firat book, ramerlane, and Vl Poem The Librarian of Congress has instituted irch f t volume of the original man ' I Jourpala of the Continental Con which ha been missing for many ul It not known when or how it dis ppeared Pousibly it ia now in the posses f " library or collector who ta mrant of tt nature In hope of recover x the volume Herbert Putnam has is 1 the ving deserip n of rh writing should be that of Charles lThomaeon It hould begin with the en for March 19, 1778, and end with the ntries of May 1, 1778 It may be bound in hin boards, of a bluish ablor, and if any label is on the front it should be merely No. 1." The volume immediately pre ceding it is written on folio paper with he | by a crown, on one sheet, and the letters ] | | Nation. J. W.” on the other. The volume im- mediately succeeding is written on paper bearing the same figure of Britannia on one heet, and the full name “J. Whatman” on the other They were evidently made up of quires of the paper, by Charles Thomson, and not by any binder The collection of Bibles which Prof. Wal- ter Arthur Copinger of the University of Manchester made for the purpose of writing his book, “The Bible and Its Transmis- on,” has passed into the hands of E. Hartland of Hardwick Court, Chepstow, England This collection is one of the finest of the kind It consists of nearly 1,- ) editions, in about 350 different lan- guages and dialects. Of the Greek Testa- ment there are over 300 editions The ommittee of the Cambridge His- torical Society, which has undertaken to lebrate on February 27 the hundredth niversary of the birth of Longfellow, has nt out a circular announcing its plans The occasion will be observed as “Long- fellow Day” in all the schools of Cam- bridge. In the evening in Saunders The- itre, there will be public exercises, at which William Dean Howells, as we noted in our issue of October 11, will be the principal speaker, and President Charles W. Eliot, Col. Thomas Wentworth Hig- ginson, and Prof. Charles Eliot Norton also will give addresses An exhibition will be held of early, rare, and beautiful editions of Longfellow’s works, together with memorabilia As a memorial of the event, a special bronze medal will be truck, to be designed by Bela L. Pratt, who designed the similar medal com- memorating the twenty-fifth anniversary of the accession of Charles W. Eliot to the presidency of Harvard Of the Long- fellow medal only 200 copies will be is- sued at $10 each, and the subscription list has been opened to libraries, museums, and Subscriptions may Allen, No. 15 individual collectors be to Street sent Oscar F Dunster Cambridge The celebration of the quatercentenary of George Buchanan began yesterday at Glas- | |} gow with an exhibition of books, portraits, | relics, and other memorials in the library | of the University. To-day Principal J. M. Lindsay gives a public address on Bu- chanan The name of Elizabeth Barrett Browning will, by permission of the Dean of West- minster, appear in the Poets’ Corner of the Abbey When Robert Browning died, the honor of burial was, according to the Lon- | to the remains of his but the offer ithenwum, offered at don wife, which rest Florence; was refused. Now, on the centenary of her birth, her name is to be inscribed at the foot of her husband's grave in the Abbey From Paris news comes that the Librairie Novelle has ceased to exist. It was found- ed in 1849 and passed into the hands of Michel Lévy Under this publisher the | place became in the fifties and sixties the haunt of literary men and politicians. Alex- were regular customer, Flaubert, Due indre Dumas pére was a Gam Rivoli Verne, the Augier, Jules Maupa frequenters and de and the betta, sant of shop Kaiser, at In out an expedi- the German his Some months ago of Rosen, the suggestion representative Abyssinia, Dr sent water mark of Britannia seated with tion to that country, the first report from shield and spear, in a circle surmounted | which has just been made to the Academy [ Vol. 83, No. 2157 of Sciences in Berlin. The members of the expedition have been at work in the old city of Aksum, have prepared a plan of the city, have examined the rich ruins there found, have reéxamined the old inscrip- tions, and have discovered a number of large new inscriptions, which have* been copied and are now in a shape to be stud- ied. These latter take the history of Abys- sinia back to the fourth and fifth centuries before Christ. THE HISTORY OF ENGLAND, 1801-1837. The Political History of England. 12 vols. XI.—The History of England from Ad- dington’s Administration to the close of William IV.’s Reign. 1801-1837. By the Hon. George C. Brodrick. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $2.60 net. Wherein does the political England of 1906 differ from the political England of 1837? This is an inquiry inevitably sug- gested and partly answered by the dry yet accurate summary of events contained in the book before us. To sum up the answer in one formula is scarcely possible. Who- ever wants to realize the character of an immense change which every one recognizes but no one can easily define, had best note, after studying the work ofthe late Mr. Brod- rick, a few definite contrasts between the England of to-day and the England of well- nigh seventy years ago. In 1837 the leading politicians had all been bred under a system which the Re- form Act had destroyed. They, however, governed by ideas of a bygone age, hardly perceived the true nature of the revolution which had taken place. Nor is this won- derful. The alteration in the constitution of Parliament was not large. Modern crit- ics are surprised at the limited increase in the electorate worked by the Reform Act. A fundamental innovation had moreover been carried through, much to the amaze- ment of Tories, and even of Whigs, in a strictly legal manner, and with slight and indirect appeal to force. A reform achiev- ed without revolutionary violence seemed, after a year or two, no revolution at all. Yet the Reform Act in fact worked a revo- lution in the whole scheme of government. The disfranchisement of absolutely rotten boroughs and the moral certainty that as time went on all close or nomination bor- oughs would be disfranchised, had extra- ordinary effects. It deprived the Crown and a limited number of wealthy and aris- tocratic landowners, of whom the King might be considered the head, of the means for exercising that “influence’’ which at one time was almost a technical term, and which (as ardent Whigs not fifty years be- fore the Reform Act had declared) “had in- creased, was increasing, and ought to be diminished.” A King or Queen of England has never been without genuine authority, but since 1832, or at any rate since 1837, this authority has never been a power which any man feared. George III. pro- longed the war with the American colonies after it had ceased to be popular. He for- bade the concession of. political rights to Roman Catholics when advocated by the most powerful of his ministers. His un- bending will strengthened the national re- sistance to the attacks of France. George IV. was a contemptible voluptuary; he was

Page 17

Nov. 1, 1906] reputed, whether truly or not, to be defi- | 1837 courage which had but George IV., ac- cient in the persona! distinguished his race; cording to the belief of the time, could of his own will, if he had have brought the Whigs into power against the determination of the country to support the policy of the Tories. To the well mean- ing, though feeble, patriotism of William IV. was due in great measure the peaceful passing of the Reform Act The will of the King could, even in 1832, have put the possibility of parliamentary the issue of civil war. Such exhibitions of pow- so wished, reform to er have been impossible to Queen Victoria Note, however, that this as- sertion the that in circumstances utterly different from those of authority of the Crown may again increase. It is for the future to or to her son does not preclude possibility 1837 the show whether King or House of Commons will become the moral representative of the empire The act, again, which struck at the roots of royal influence had another curious, though less noticed, effect, to which at- tention has been called by the acuteness of Walter Bagehot. Parliamentary life was, up till 1832, a profession, a pursuit in which a man might obtain not only honor, but wealth The game, it is true, was one in which prizes were few and blanks many. Still it had its prizes, and, though they too frequently fell to a low type of politician, they might be attain- ed by such men as Pitt or Burke. Hence the appearance on the political stage of that singular character, the patriotic ad- venturer. He has vanished, and his dis- appearance marks a fundamental change in English public life. Up till 1829-1832 the unreformed Parlia- ment was, if theory, yet in truth, an English Parliament. The Scottish mem- not in bers were few. They followed principles which sound purely selfish, but promoted the interests of Scotland; they acted as one body; they supported as a rule the Government of the day; they obtained per- sonal rewards for their services. This was the policy of Dundas, the most skilful of all Scottish managers, but it was also the policy of all his predecessors. It was not ideal; be termed by Whigs, who were except when in office, patterns of virtue, a system of corruption. But it rested on principles sound enough in themselves. Scotsmen were to stand apart from the party controversies which divided Englishmen. They were sedulous- ly to support the Executive, that thereby the Treaty of Union shoyld become a bar- gain favorable the Rea te interest of Scottish members and to the material wel- fare of Scotland. it impossible for the representatives of Ire- land to pursue this scheme of enlighten- But Irish members were exclusively Protestants, members of the United Church of England and Ireland. They were landlords, in full sympathy with the landlords of England. They, too, in the main, adopted on all Imperial ques- tions ideas which commended themselves to the English governing class. But the reform of Parliament, which seemed to introdue@ pothing but certain modifications of the electoral system, produced one ef- fect of immense importance which was hardly recognized by Englishmen even in it might always, to Various causes made ed selfishness. The Nation. The Parliament which met at West- minster had ceased to be an English Par- liament Tur lastly, from domest iffairs and note a singular transformation in tl for eign policy of England From 1689 to 1837 England had been profoundly interested in Continental politics. The glorious Revo lution’’ had been the work of a D h army led by a Dutch King. The accession to the ty linked Eng land, most unfortunately for both countries throneof the Hanoveriandyna with Hanover; the intrigue of German courts interested the first two Georges far more keenly than did the expa on of England’s colonial empire And the Cont nent, to Englishmen, down to 1837, had practically meant France The great war which terminated with the battle of Water loo seemed, though it really bore a different character, a mere prolongation of the secu lar conflict between Englishmen and Frenchmen. From 1837 onwards, the whole aspect of English foreign policy and of Eng lish ways of looking upon foreign affairs has changed. The accession of Queen Vii toria broke the ill-starred Hanoverian con nection This meant much; it freed Eng lish policy from all the complications with a German State belonging to a _ political system in which England had no real con cern. But the fact that Queen Victoria was not the ruler of Hanover facilitated a fat more essential change in relation to Con tinental Powers. Contests which keenly in terested the rest of Europe ceased to be of immediate importance to England. If Eng lishmen intervened in such contests at all the grounds of interference were henceforth to be either sympathy with the ideas of some foreign party, e. g., with the aspira tions of foreign Constitutionalists, or the determination of England to preserve her Eastern Empire. As a matter of fact, po litical sympathy has, during the last seventy years, hardly ever of itself involved England in Continental conflicts The feeling which rightly or wrongly has brought England near to war, has been the fear of attack upon India The circumstances which have diminish conflicts ed English interest in Continental have had a further effect They have pre served peace with France. It is now over ninety years since France and England have met in battle either on land or on sea. Are we to attribute this happy con dition mainly to the growth of pacific sen timent? An optimist may answer y¢ but an unbiased observer will reply that amicable sentiment is the sign rather than the cause of peace. The secular warfars between two progressive countries ha come to an end, because every man of common sense perceives that the conflict between their real or apparent interests has ceased to exist. France does not men ace either the colonial or the Eastern em pire of England Most Englishmen would rejoice could some pacific arrangement re store to France the possessions lost 1870. Englishmen no longer dread either the revolutionary propaganda of French Democrats or invasion by a French Em peror. French Jacobinism or French Im- perialism is to Englishmen as dead as the Jacobitism of the eighteenth century. We need not pursue this matter further. The sentiment which even in 1837 kept Eng- land in constant fear of a French inva- whose in | | | MEMOIRS OF THI Vi I:t Vemoirs the ¢ i ef of a French r Vendée where of of the extraordinary and of h he gardener Frédéric Masson appendice | by Pierre Amédé« New York: John 1 followed he hu ) { tion Enormous as Ver of a cropped up h The sacer va Vendei on is a prt deat the liv Byron would not have praise Napolk shooting Suc feeling mors is His account the manuscript | one of the ror It i apparently dictated b the auth friend words ested shing an Eng publi English who only cat the and sons and and often caught them naturally the prope. town throughout. Notw came to the conclu and i ibject with M. Pichot ocial he entered nto ninunicat I he him a latter much a h difficulty Frances posit iped on ion sOlVInNE every ked way in noble family the ‘Memoirs,’ the tra every in connected with De Cartris itioned in the resto ur names correet 5 the lw proper gave of the and o of redible, found « alogies author fied mantt ver mysteries advent as to appear ins trail and followed it with the patien ind sagacity of a sleuth-hound, explored pa and for ly guarded this | t | records and service lists way family what army the muniment Mr modestly styles I Publisher's Advertisement,” but ly forms a chapter almost as 1lou All his into most je rooms in Lane which real fa nating being the correspon- Pich rather as any in the volume dence between himself and M In one case, however, M. Pichot is on the wrong track. Madame ot or in two

Page 18

3874 Bulkeley, her husband, and Count Walsh de Serrant are about the three most in- teresting friends of De Cartrie in the book Madame Bulkeley was his sister. She is well-known to every one acquainted with the history of the Vendean troubles. She was one of the Amazons we meet with so frequently during this period According to her brother: My sister, brave as a heroine, never abandoned her husband, by whose side she fought in every action in which he was coneerned; and though her clothes were on several occasions plerced by balls, yet she fortunately escaped without a wound {After the death of Robesplerre and her release from prison] she put her- self at the head of the remnant of these [her husband's] troops, which, with some new levies, constituted a body of upwards of six thousand men With this little army she for eighteen months fought an incredib! number of battles, sometimes alone, and at others in support of Cha- rette But in the last she received two wounds, which threw her from her horse. He then eulogizes her virtues Other a different character. She is deseribed by the republican historians of La Vendée as a flerce and cruel leader, writers give her fond of torturing her Republican women prisoners, burning their houses, and plun- dering their property. In any case, she was a decidedly interesting character, and it was natural that M. Pichot should try tu get all the information possible about her and her almost equally interesting husband. De Cartrie says of him: “At this time Monsieur Bulkeley, born of a good was an elegant young feet 10 inches, of amiable character, and served in the regiment of Walsh-Ser- rant.” Yet M. Pichot writes to Mr. Lane asking him to search in England for por- traits of Bulkeley Walsh: “There must still be in England some members of the Walsh and Serrant families."’ This is the more surprising, as he says in the letter: “I greatly regret not finding a portrait of Madame Bulkeley; I have an Irish family, height figure and most man, in about 5 e fine and seine idea that if it is to be found at all, it should be searched for in England Her husband, William Bulkeley, was born at Clonmel, in Ireland, on December 7, 1766.” This sounds something like an Irish bull William Bulkeley was lived in Ireland until he lived and died in France; born and therefore, if you want to learn anything about him, search for it in England In fect, the Bulkeleys were established in nearly two centuries before Revolution Some of them may be there still, At least they are more likely there than in Yorkshire. Can M. Pichot have been misled by the report of Angers to the Mayor of after Bulkeley’s execu- Our holy mother Guillotine,” says vivacious official, “is actively engaged Within the last three days she has shaved eleven priests, nun, one general, and a handsome English- toan, six foot high, whose head was in the is now bagged!" As Walsh was colonel of his the could searcely have been belonged to a four or five ripperary for the French to be or the barin tion? that Mayor some time it her work one e@xX- way! It hereditary liish Brigade, he at Englishman. In fact, he family that for more than centuries was as much hanged, forfeited, banished as any in the green island therefore the more remarkable that regiment in and It is members of it still possess large estates [Vol. 83, No. 2157 in several Irish counties. Such families have always been especially eager for the preservation of records of their distin- guished relatives on the Continent. So that, if M. Pichot, instead of sending Mr. Lane on a wild-goose chase through Eng- lund, had written, say, to “Hussey Walsh of Cranagh and Mulhussey, Roscommon,” or to “Walsh of Carrickmines, Kings County,” or to “Hussey of Rathkenny, Meath,” he would probably have learned a good deal about their distinguished kins- man, Count Walsh de Serrant. The interest of these memoirs is very great, great everywhere, and they have considerable historic value, although the author may not have played a preponderant réle in the military events he describes. His romantic adventures in his Odyssey across France in company with his son, their hairbreadth escapes, his subsequent travels through Germany and Holland, and his life in England, are even more fascin- ating than his military exploits in La Vendée. This is altogether an enjoyable volume, and superbly illustrated. A map of the wars in La Vendée would have enabled the reader to follow some of his adventures with more ease and pleasure. RECENT FICTION. The Mirror of the Sea. By Joseph Conrad. New York: Harper & Bros. On the surface, this book is very much like A. H. Bullen’s “Idyls of the Sea,” a series of impressions and memories which are the fruit of a real and long sea expe- rience. Whether in forecastle or captain’s cabin, these men earned a knowledge of the sea to which no lubberly amateur may hope to attain. Long exercise of their stern trade has not drained them of their en- thusiasm for it, or failed to qualify them for the expression of that enthusiasm. Mr. Bullen, to be sure, is concerned with the fascination of the sea itself and its in- habitants, while Mr. Conrad is absorbed in the ships that go upon the waters. Mr. Conrad does not hesitate to challenge the convention of sea-worship: . . . Its immensity has never been loved as the mountains, the plains, the desert itself, have been loved. Indeed, I suspect that, leaving aside the protesta- tions and tributes of writers who, one is safe in saying, care for little else in the world than the rhythm of their lines and the cadence of their phrase, the love of the sea, to which some men and nations confess so readily, is a complex sentiment wherein pride enters for much, necessity for not a little, and the love of ships—the untiring servants of our hopes and our self-esteem —for the best and most genuine part. For the hundreds who have reviled the sea, — down to the last obscure sea-dog of the “old model,” having but few words and still fewer thoughts, there could not be found, I believe, one sailor who has ever coupled a curse with the good or bad name of a ship. If ever his profanity, pro- voked by the hardships of the sea, went 80 far as to touch his ship, it would be lightly, as a hand may, without sin, be laid in the way of kindness on a woman. not, ships are per- to Mr. Conrad, and not a limb or of them lies beyond his way of kindness. He will not have them misun- derstood or miscalled; the last detail of seamanly terminology is of importance to him. Such misconceptions of sea-phrase as “casting the anchor” inspire in him a Pathetic fallacy or sons feature mournful commiseration bordering upon contempt. On the other hand, his speech is as remote as possible from the lingo of the sea captain of fable. He has no wish to force sea talk upon the landsman as something picturesque and to be desired for its own sake, but wishes us to under- stand its esoteric value as a perfect vehicle, possessing “‘all the force and precision and imagery of a technical language that, cre- ated by simple men with keen eyes for the real aspect of the things they see in their trade, achieves the just expression, seizing upon the essential, which is the am- bition of the artist in words.” The prevailing note in these sketches is elegiac: eheu! the fading glories of that old sea life upon the sailing ship, the “ship of yesterday.”’ There indeed the mir- acle of good seamanship might be devel- oped. Not for it the unerring precision of steel moved by white steam and living by red fire and fed by black coal. The other seems to draw its strength trom the very soul of the world, its formidable ally, held to obedience by the frailest bonds, like a fierce ghost captured in a snare of some- thing even finer than spun silk. For what is the array of the strongest ropes, the tallest spars, the stoutest canvas against the mighty breath of the infinite but thistle- stalks, cobwebs, and gossamer. Mr. Conrad, of Polish birth, is quite as much French as English in his literary in- stinct and manner. He often gains, that is, through the medium of a pure and vigorous English, effects which recall Maupassant, or, far oftener, Pierre Loti. For example: “The lulling cadence of the rise and fall, the invariable gentleness of this irresisti- ble force, the great charm of the deep wa- ters, warmed my breast deliciously, like the subtle poison of a love-potion.’’ However he may hate the enchantress, this man is subject to her glamour, and able to impart the sense of it as few men have been. The Plow-Woman. By Eleanor Gates. New York: McClure, Phillips & Co. This is the story of the Lancaster fam- ily, father and two daughters, who, com- ing up from Texas into Dakota after the war, moored their prairie-schooner on a bend of the Missouri, built a shack, and tilled the ground. All opens peacefully and agriculturally. Dallas picturesquely ploughs with her two mules, and with the tame family bull, Simon, always in at- tendance. Marylyn, the younger sister, stays within doors and cooks the meals. The crippled father, Evan Lancaster, ex- section-boss, narrow-minded, jealous, sus- picious, holds his girls in a tight leash, hating all men, more especially all sol- diers, most especially any one who has so much as lifted a finger for the North during the war. How necessary men and soldiers became to him and his daughters in the enmities of rival land-claimants and the uprisings of Indians, is developed in the story. It is a book where the reader is made to see what it must be to “get the West,” as one of the characters phrases it. Dangers and horrors serve only to stimulate enter- prise and courage. For him who has the West “in his blood,” the open air, the flowery prairie, the springing corn are hardly dearer than the blizzard, the out- witting of the landshark, the fight with the Indian. To young Lounsbury from

Page 19

Nov. 1, 1906] The Nation. “the States” the perils were part of the fascination. Ingenuity is one of the author’s con- spicuous endowments. Situation after sit- nation keeps interest expectant up to the last. No less is her skill in definition of character, although here and there a bit may be judged out of drawing A girl like Dallas, for example, ready as she might be to sacrifice herself, would hard- ly urge a man to make unwilling love to her sister. This act of Dallas’s apart, she is a fine figure of girlhood developed by responsibility and hardship into something like a composite man and woman, with woman dominating. The feeble Marylyn serves chiefly to give Dallas an object for her maternal instinct. The _ tyrannical father is excellently drawn in all his in- firmities. The hero is made attractive and not too omnipresent. Each actor is as real as the principals. In characteriza- tion this is a virtue, although it should constrain the author to use not too many actors—fewer we think than this novel includes. But the same fidelity is carried into scenery, descriptions, and narrative to the point of faultiness. It results in a lack of perspective which is lifelike, per- haps, but like life seen with the eye and not with the selecting and omitting facul- ty which makes for And of a high order of art Miss Gates’s pen seems art. very capable, mutato mutando. The Belovéd Vagabond. By William J Locke. New York: John Lane. With the publication, last year, of ‘“‘The Morals of Marcus Ordeyne,’”’ Mr. Locke be- came a novelist of international interest. He had deserved American long before with stories as “Derelicts” and “Where Is,” but had not been able to command it. What books of his had appeared until then in cis-Atlantic covers had been received with quiet ap- preciation by the but had been buried, so far as the general reading public under what Mr. Howells has called the ‘‘annual rubbish-fall”’ of our “‘best sellers.’”” In “The Morals. of Marcus Ordeyne”’ Mr. Locke grafted romance upon realism with ironic as well as humorous intent. In his new novel he reverses the process with no felicitous result. Here a twig of realism grafted upon present- day romance, the romance of the open road and the free life. The realism of the vagabond’s personal habits spoils the ro- mance of his nobility of character. If ever a well-born vagabond justified the nar- rowness of English Philistinism, it is this rover of generous impulses, who, when he emerges for a moment from the pothouse to claim the place that is still his, must, through force of habit, take the manners of the pothouse with him into the draw- ing-room.. The knight-errant, while he oc casionally interests us mildly, neither at- tracts nor convinces us; and the sunny roads of France, her farms, villages, and inns have found more eloquent pens than Mr. Locke's ere now to praise their charms Mr. Locke should not be judged by his “Be- lovéd Vagabond’’ alone. success such Love critics, is concerned, is Letters to Women in Love. Bv Mrs. John Van Vorst. New York: D Appleton & Co. The letters are numerous; the women to 375 whom they are written, four Three of | His general attitude toward what most them have names and addresses likely attract the curiosity and respectful inter- est of the feminine readers of so-calle! “society” fiction Miss Beatrice Thayer, Fifth Avenue, New York; Mrs. Elizabeth Aiken, Tuxedo, New York; and Mrs brooke, Washington for all that, the case of the fourth humble, average Mrs. Jack Burnside of a New York bank clerk witha Newark the not very book An elderly woman of wide experience an Caires- But ome Dupont Circle wife ‘bome” in interesting after the of is most interesting fashion the whole deep and ready sympathies is supposed be the writer of these epistles, which re veal amazing confidence in her own wis- dom, incredible readiness to give advice in delicate matters, and staggering absence of hesitation about asking leading ques tions The plan on which the book has been constructed makes these blemishes unavoidable, and is therefore fundamentally faulty, but this defect is unlikely to dis turb the readers for whom the volume is chiefly intended. The elderly woman gives treatment by correspondence, so to speak for the cure of all kinds of afflictions of the affections, ranging from a young girl's doubt about an “offer’’ she has received to all the jealousies, regrets, disillusions material worries, and disappointments of married life There was abundant material here for the Mrs. Van with it beyond dis- The human interesting book little possibilities making of an Vorst has done cevering its cases she presents are not lacking in inter- but the deeper note is lacking est, By J. Scrib- The Bible H. Gardiner Sons. English Literature New York $1.50 net have as Charles ner’s For years complaint that the that which its Bible with the ago probably not been accompanied by a suggested remedy Bibie litera- application of this been pre- the now we been hearing generation which is passing, reads and at all and women is, nay, knows scarcely in com men This complaint, parison a century which is exaggerated, has generally the study of the as As the remedy, books pared; think, of Professor Gardiner’s, come of the courses he has been giving at Harvard and at the Lowell Institute as the book must ina ness warn teachers least that the of excellent text-book will smooth away the difficulties front the advocates of Bible-study schools; ror have we great hopes that this any other book will large por- tion of our adult population and studying what was truly the Word of to wit, ture. aids in have better which humerous none, we than this is the out- Good is, however, we fair- at pos- session an not which con- in our or set a to reading Life to their fathers and grandfathers The Bible, which was for so long, and still is, a great force in our civilization, has latterly found itself buffeted by op- posing forces which seem unamenable to literary control Hence, while we wel- come Professor Gardiner’s book as a val- uable aid in a good cause, we can hardly feel that the hopes and convictions that enabled him to attain success are as solid as the learning he has utilized and the expository skill he has displayed. to | | discussion | chaptes of half | | force exper tation | attend persons would regard as the crucial dim- culty confronting him is well described in a paragraph in his preface: In all my discussion I have assumed the fact of inspiration, but without attempt- ing to define it or to distinguish between religious and literary inspiration. The two come together in a broad region, where every one who cares for a delimi- tation must run his line for himself. It is obvious, however, that no literary crit- icism of the Bible could hope for success which was not reverent in tone. A critic who should approach it superciliously or arrogantly would miss all that has given the book its power as literature and its lasting and universal appeal Waiving the point that no good criti would approach any book superciliously or arrogantly, we may ask the question wheth the fact that book feels at running between the of such a liberty to forbear er writer as this literary in of the spirit a line religious and spiration is not symptomattk which neglect is responsible of the Bible to counteract. Hear allow mental state for that striving and the which ual in main he is and readers who complacently their teacher to refrain from showing his skill Profe Gardiner’s metaphor is responsible for object books a word as to in spiritual engineering ssor the will presumably not to a of the contains practically phrase which the As we prophetical not fulfilment of any specific prediction read the chapter, we recalled instinctively an old long his fathers felt once a year to preach a de signed prove the Christianity the fulfi'ment cies rhat the earth could he divine since gathered to it his duty at least of of chain who series sermons to truth from ofa of prophe of thought dear old man was of the salt What would he have read Profes The Prophecy''? without feeling omitted have Gardiner’s Will that a sor on those who read it neces been ever be of that good shall not attempt to answer that sary element has the same sort salt as We quest ions quite preacher? our own preferring to find lacking on the one say Gardiner the other the piquant de In a certain sense. our but found of high feeling, so much we expected to Professor book asm of unction and on the that hand enthusi usually accompanies earnest tructive criticism was realized, we so much sincerity sound literary appreciation, and so much helpful elucidation of the perplexities that the of the Bible misgivings layman's reading that our initial questions and were laid to rest The volume of four hundred pages is di- vided into nine chapters, of which the first introductory and deals with the Bible as a single book. Chapters il.-vii. treat the several genrea to be found in the the narratives of various types, the poetry, the wisdom books, the epistles, the prophecy, and the Apocalypse. They Scriptures are specially successful in utilizing the re of the so-called Higher Criticism to furnish a historical background with the that the documents stand out clear- ly as embodiments of the life of Israel at the crucial periods of the nation’s evolu- On the other hand, Professor Gard! in sults result tion. less his endeavors make and comprehend the value of the prose and poetry which have so deeply appealed to our race. His il- conspicuously both present ner has succeeded to us realize literary

Page 20

The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2157 rative citations are excellent, but he contaminated by his native civilization, overworks his epithets (cf., the | will find in Persia one of the last strong- of vivid on page 37), frequently | holds of the unadulterated Orient. » miss the inevitable phrase, and The ordinary approach through the Cau- ly appears to have overlooked | casus by rail, either from Batum on the ench the wordiness and to | Black Sea, or Moscow and Vliadikavkas, to | ons that were permissible Baku, on the Caspian, and thence by steam- wl mn a course of lectures Yet it er to Enzeli and Resht, was left by our t vwned that his criticism is often | author at Tiflis for the overland route to ind that it ought to send not a Tabriz. In either case Tiflis is the jump- 4 } to the great book that used to ng-off place of Western’ civilization. ' 1 in one clo when “closets” Whether one proceeds overland or by way ible luxuries | of the Caspian, one encounters at once the r ‘ meluding chapters are enti- | Oriental disdain for sanitary plumbing The Translation” and The King Professor Jackson's reason for entering rit rhey form a compendious Persia by way of Azarbaijan was that that ! t eresting narrative of the la province, as he believes, was the birth- ! in it wcessors, aud place of Zoroaster, and the purpose of his i « as useful to teachers | journey was antiquarian study and schol- ! 1} vel and instructive to arly research, especially with regard to Perhaps a few statements in | this great prophet of Iran. It would seem } R which deal with “The | as if this fact ought to have been embod- h ‘ tandard for the lit- | ied in some form in the title “Persia: be a trifle extravagant and | Past and Present” is misleading, in that it mparisons between forms | conveys no intimation of the real motif hat searcely have a common | of the book Indeed, except for informa- I rT h main one feels ou tion scattered through the text, a single Line book that Professoc | chapter of eight pages covers the whole ‘ imming up the position of | range of Persian history, religion, archi- Aut! | Version in our literature, | tecture, and language, and as to Persia ! I lequa to his important ané Present, one searches in vain for any con- ‘ isk nected account, statistical or otherwise, of | its political, economic. religious, or social ; Pest end Present \ Book of | life The reader soon discovers, however, a 1 Research, with more than | that the Zoroastrian, not the Persian, is ae and a map By A. V | the author’s real game A sis a tema New York The | Professor Jackson's chapters fall natural- \ Co. $4 n | ly under the two heads indicated in the , ~~ eve travel preface: those of a descriptive and narra- ; bas ttaie net the Puce | tive character, likely to interest the gen- meat . ies tata in anaes | eral reader, and those in which “certain ' ; a eng toes of o sei on | technical matters are discussed.” As to ' neem one tn ae} the former, the author cannot be said to va he bitter winds which | Possess the happy gift of making the read- to wet the menntain cnames | 7 what he sees and share his expe- me great lranian platess | riences. The incidents and accidents of 1 e gigantic saws Only | his journey are related pleasantly enough, Sion io the Russian | but the narrative is too academic, not to , Ce = . Teheran bese | 7 pedantic, to convey the rude charm of , oO da. in the ordinary sense, | Persian life and manners. Some of his though one may journey | less ambitious predecessors, who were not i ae , Kum and Kasvin by car- | °¥e? concerned about a_ reputation for r weller’e steed follows the | learning, as Miss Sykes, Browne, Mrs. » af enbawenn & 138 the plains Bishop, or Lady Durand, nave caught mere vusly in the deep holes | of the Persian atmosphere in their pie- pack-animals from the tures. The step which separates a languid aii’ thee Uae Gn ie rocky | interest from the fascination that makes te mot exist. if we ex one eager to get into the saddle and follow pt affair which conveys the author’s track is a long one, and we . erry eparating | 'magine Professor Jackson's work will be . ‘vim from the capital, a | More successful in interesting those who — for the travel know Persia than in stirring the imagina- wionits A so-called Eng tion of those who do not found at Teheran. whose But, after all, it is Persia as the birth- ly relative charac place of Zoroaster and the home of his sravanseral which religion with which Professor Jackson is , ed it, provided | concerned, and we know of no volume con- h for ite guesta, | taining so complete an account of the —— , lie fs © whieh gives a | present condition and religious rites of the ! f apa tod dlenity to deeayed | fire-worshippers, combined with so much " j } ne muat arrive early | information on the history and traditions h tof tl faresakh to find room of this sect The study of this subject on anima m the rowded court of | the spot is greatly facilitated by the fond- } chaparkhanah o lecent helter for | ness of the Persian for metaphysical spec- yne wo camp-bed within its bare walls. | ulation, a source of Information of which i wl willing to pay a literal | the author avails himself at every oppor- 1 of flesh for exhilarating out-of-door | tunity. It is doubtful whether In any other ny the sddle. who not too sensitive | country philosophical discussion plays so ’ und wed and who loves the | important a role in ordinary social inter- f wide horizons and regions un course. Sects of every descriptiiop have flourished in Persia from the earliest times down to the Babis and Sheykhis of to-day. who signs Jackson, as- the appearance of Zoroaster to the half of the century B. C. regards him as beyond doubt an actual his- toric personage, and seeks to identify va- rious localities historically or traditionally associated with his name. Thus he con- siders it “reasonably probable” that the of reeds the southern border of Lake Urumiah is the district where he made his first convert as told in the Pah- lavi writings; and that Mount Savalan, near Professor early seventh tract on Ardabil, is the mountain on which the prophet communed with Ormuzd and re- ceived divine revelations. To the present reviewer these and similar identifications seem to rest too largely on the author's evident enthusiasm for his subject. Far more important and tangible are the results of Professor Jackson's in- vestigation of the probable site of ancient Ecbatana, which at Hamadan instead of Takht-i-Suleiman. His reasons for differing from the conclusions of Raw- linson are forcibly stated in a wholly sci- entific spirit, a remark which applies to all his discussions of questions resting on historic as distinguished from mythical data. But the most important chapter of Pro- fessor Jackson's book is that which treats of the great rock sculptures of Behistan and the readings of the cuneiform inscrip- tions of Darius. Since the days when Raw- linson first copied these almost inaccessi- ble records, no attempt to verify his tran- The im- mense space of nearly 500 by 100 feet cov- he places scription has proved successful. ered by the inscriptions is some 300 feet above the base of the ravine on the precipi- tous rock, and, as stated by Rawlinson, “the climbing of the rock is a feat which an antiquary alone could be expected to undertake.” Professor Jack- son succeeded in examining most of the doubtful passages, and in verifying in gen- eral the remarkable transcript of Rawlin- son made ago; and the account both of his perilous climb and its over sixty years results are given with noteworthy mod- esty. The book is not very fully indexed, but is profusely and well illustrated, and pro- vided with an excellent map. Some slight errors, perhaps inseparable from so short a sojourn, are observable, as for example the statement that the American legation at Teheran has occupied the same grounds since its establishment in 1883. Unfor- tunately, in Teheran, as in most other capi- tals, the legation is a literal nomad. American By Walter Sichel. $5 net. Emma, Lady Hamilton. New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. Deep violet-gray eyes and tresses of au- burn tipped with gold are designed by na- ture to play an active part in the affairs of From Horatio Nelson to Walter Sichel the victims of Hamilton's charms are innumerable, curiously enough, even her enemies are to be num- the category For few writers mankind. Lady and, bered in have approached this extraordinary woman and retained their balance; those who have seen her bright side have become apolo- gists, those who have seen the reverse only

Page 21

Nov. 1, 1906] The Nation. have defamed her; one of our own histor- ians, Capt. Mahan, maintaining his alone in dealing is nearly composure when with her disconcerting memory Every beauty will meet with detractors; the Venus de Medici finds And, moreover, age must tell. Travellers, whom Mr. Sichel quote, that Emma Doubtless critics have asserted fat persons does not and vulgar to Hamilton was there were whom, and times at which, that aspect predominat- ed. be vestige until at ambassadress, she was gloriously beautiful for But, on the whole, such opinions may be the her there not that close disregarded, and can doubt the from youth of her of a least career as And more than beautiful, she was by nature an actress, every expression, every gesture, a skilled heightening of her fasci- nation She learned to play on the emo- that after the dismal experiences of youth, after passing through the hands of the ville and of the uninspiring Hamilton, she tions, and so it was when calculating Gre- met Nelson, a spark was touched that fired both their natures into a mutual blaze The compatibility of the t the two was so great as to make their link- that appears Nelson was emperaments of ed destinies something now inevitable, weakest and strongest at once in his high- almost excusable wrought emotional temperament, driving him at times into folly of speech and ac- tion, and at others to a pitch of heroism that gave his country the empire of the seas To meet such a man at the moment when the struggle for the Mediterranean between France and England was at its su- preme crisis, at the moment when she had just risen from the basest rank a woman may hold, to be ambassadress at the court of Naples, the centre of the storm was decisive of Emma Hamilton's future like England’s, was flung at lion-hearted admiral, who Her adoration the feet of the was struggling to the of Bonaparte What more natural? more deserving of sympathy? But, and it is here that we don Mr. Sichel, it possible this and yet go no have been the greatest Hamilton the most beautiful their amours the finest possible frenzy of high-wrought emotion, without ing all the facts of history to strengthen these perfectly arguable propositions. But this is, in effect, what Mr. Sichel does. He has undeniable talent, but it clearly is not of the historical variety tinuously shock the reader destruction What achieve must aban all may to Nelson Emma is see further. of admirals, of women, disarrang- His pages con- acquainted with the period, not by gross lapses, but by constant petty distortions that are too minute to criticise, and that may best be summed up as indicating a complete lack of the historical sense It is essentially this that robs the book of value; and the largest example of the fault is to be found in the treatment of the controversial point concerning the alleged secret order of Queen Mary Caroline for the provision- ing of Nelson's ships in 1798. The matter is far too lengthy to be set out adequately here. Suffice it to say that the chief cause of Mr. Sichel’s floundering in this question is that he does not grasp the essential fact that King Ferdinand and Acten ruled Na- ples, while the Queen had no authority whatever, only influence. Another bad in- stance of his Judgment is the contempt with | | which he treats the policy of the Kin n Acton, and Gallo, which, but for the pres sure of Nelson and the Qu “ ! doubtedly have saved Nay f th French invasion 1 th fi Mr. Sichel mak« eas ! { mu script, the ni t f wi ! ulto gether overrats but very imperfectly acquainted with tl! his book only landmark to tl ! hd rm illustration re, howe ro? , ne Drama. Garrick and His €i ‘ By M ( nt Parsons New Y h G : Putnam's Sons rhis i work of yuality o the s it m v f t } | ally th of recen | t} 7 and it isso ! It " 1 iy of a period howi! extra y indu ry in ircl ead the sele yn of material, a } of what is vital in chara I n, a m ym mendable desire f i 1 ind a judg ment it mice i¢ i ind hu Of course, it has nothing new the way of fact to offs being, in effec simply a compendious extract from the great body of printed stuff, good, bad, or indifferent about Garrick and h intimates, but Mrs Parsons has been so indefatigable that her Single volume may be said to contain the essence of a good-sized library It will be invaluable to all who may desire to a quaint themselves with theatrical and so cial conditions during the latter half of the eighteenth century in England, but ars inable to go to the original sources of in formation. Her style, moreover, is so viva- cious and her comment so keen and witty, so completely free from any appearance of labor or learning, tha ‘ isual reader absorbed in the sprightly gossip, might easily be unmindful of the store of infor mation behind it The long list of quoted authorities which she furnishe reveals only a part of her ubiquitous inquiries Perhaps the clearest idea of the scope of her work may be obtained from a glance at the different sections into which it is subdivided. Each of them, it may be noted is a finished little essay in itself As a whole, they tell a continuous story, and although of necessity they overlap to a certain extent, they never repeat. The in troduction is a sketch of life in the Lich field of the eighteenth century, with amus ing anecdotes of the social prejudices of the period. Then follows a paper on Gar rick’s early days in London and the Wof fington episode Next he is exhibited at the zenith of his fame and popularity as the dictator of Old Drury Later on, after chapters on old theatrical way Kitty Clive and others, and Mrs. Garrick, there is a picture of Garrick in h green-room Then come brief sketches of the ontem porary dramatists, an account of the fa mous “Club,"’ a review of Garrick’s lite rary output, a lively picture of the ways of the beaux and belles of the day, a de scription of the provincial theatres in Eng land and Ireland, et« Last of all is the story of Garrick’s social triumphs on the Continent, of the pleasant days of his re- at is legendary highly hed portrait, for which John and the on ick hin fini such Goldsmith, men as well Gart his correspondence— stand pect, at least he do x how little founda of habitual the fash recent bik howing for which it wa h memory by tion there is the chargé parsimony ones against him Some hed putable pr ble, but prudent » bring this oof that often raphe have tou upo! point but he offer indi he was not only charita largely gen expendi had and was though in minor be hooved a who he ivy ibilities ires as man financial respon nnumerable claims his pr upon she dor rhe wor Over his petty vanity great could hold a litt! ld in La or Macbeth de most buffoonerl« What Shak sapere attempt to throw any veil who ith hi the thrall w ar could lamentable he cra he to the ed hold fashion of remorselessly offences than a to which ved did to et the laugh violence after a gro whom he pr and doubtless did hold tion, is a and Mrs. P me of Doubtle in such venera notoriety, sets this ki grain of that he purpose full ambition of the h which he is amaz of less eyes he opportunity for personal display matter melancholy down nd arsons his worst in there was more Johnson's surly dictum in lofty the truth in deficient and serious of Among wa rhe cent iry were and the character of the play stage his stage and a treas re his highest some put upon the tra ing—was account in than ‘ hap which has an interesting Mr ter Parson the reforms of history on theatrical effected but all ntere too rick the expert } to of devoted this course ancient Some page . life wite, are of her most to the sting domestk virtues of life-long invaluable admirable Garrick the such his to whom a“ } 0 he gave devotion and who was such an helpmate to him both Theirs busine . careet ended in his social and romance which never body was a was borne from her side Abbey if mitted it would be pleasant to quote the lote the until his dead space spe freely which to Westminster incident and ane pages. It that most famous Kitty Sheridan from be said howe ve sketche f notor Woffington nl ‘Ww Torr crowd may in conclusion the rick’s raries or ous cf Clive Burke, ¢ Reyn Foote son, Fanny Burney Id ind coun

Page 22

378 leas others, are etched with a bold, and skilful hand In the November Atlantic, Prof. George P. Baker prints a number of hitherto un- published letters of Garrick, taken from the collection of J. H. Leigh. Others are In the present batch, there is light upon any Certain free, to follow that sheds additional tatement in Mrs references which she makes, to indicate that Leigh letters passed under her inspection none Parsons's Book. seem, indeed, some at least of these The “Caesar and Cleopatra” of Bernard Shaw time which was played for the first in this the New Amsterdam Theatre, on Tuesday night, cannot be taken but merits at country in very seriously as drama, new in the way of for intelligent a superior form of his tention as something light entertainment per sons It is really torical extravaganza, with a semi-serious passage introduced here and there to give of solidity As usual, Mr his characters the mouth- it appearance Shaw has made preces of his own opinions upon affairs of the universe, but his views are so wittily expressed, and are productive of so much amusement, that it would be churlish to object to them either person or period as inappropriate to Really humorous stage, now- when it and much llalogue is too rare upon the adays, not to be precious even is stuffed with strange heresies; of Mr. Shaw's dialogue is comparable with that of W. S. Gilbert In Forbes Robert son, for whom he wrote the part, Mr Shaw has found an almost ideal Julius Cwesar The actor not only looks the character, but plays it the right way, with- out a trace of exaggeration even in the most fantastic scenes, and in the occasion- with great intellectual ad the al serious interludes dignity and force His elocution was mirable It was a delight to hear language spoken with such clear ness and crispness and nicety of emphasis. English indeed, rhe speech of his whole company was uncommonly good, and the general performance of notable excellence Mr Kobertson’s artistic taste asserted itself in the remarkable beauty of the scenery ostumes, and groupings The representa tion was warmly received Miss Lena Ashwell, accounted one of the most powerful emotional actresses on the London stage, formerly a member of Henry first in this city on Monday evening, Irving's Lyceum Company, made her Appearance Theatre, and achieved an em Her face is high- in the Lyrt per ly intelligent: phatic onal success in the quieter passages she acts with close attention to the finer points detail, and in more of suggestive passion- ate scenes with large and varied control of vocal and facial expression Beyond ques she ia common ability, but tion a performer of much more than no conclusive estimate of her powers can be formed from her one “The Shulamite,” rather which is a gloomy, play It is an adaptation from the novel of that Askew and Edward Knob performance tin painful, and crude name by Claude lauch In it she appears as the lovely drudge of a bigoted and brutal South Af rican Boer Miss Ashwell, however, dig nified the performance by an impersonation which was marked with much skliu consistent, and the progressive development, through the inspiration of love, of an ab The Nation. ject, spiritless, and hopeless woman into a resolute and devoted creature, capable of any sacrifice or audacity. It was in the delicate suggestion of hidden suffering that she was most successful, but there was no lack of eloquence or vehemence in her more tempestuous moments. It should be noted that she created her effects without much aid from her associate actors, who were mostly incapable. Artistically, the weak- est point in her performance was her elocu- tion, which is often very bad. H. B. Irving closed his first New York engagement Saturday evening with a per- formance of “King Charles I.” He has achieved an artistic, if not an overwhelm- ing commercial, success. At present his father’s fame is rather a handicap than a help, for he has to endure the test of comparisons, which are sometimes found- ed prejudice, and are in themselves misleading and unjust. It would be ab- surd to pretend that he now possesses the extraordinary personal force, the al- most mesmeric charm, which made the im- personations of his father—even when most eccentric—so thrilling and authoritative; but his father did not have this power in any marked degree until he was approach- ing the meridian of his career. Judged solely on his own merits, the young Ir- ving must be assigned to a place in the first rank of living romantic actors. The full extent of his capacities, or his limi- tations, will not be known until he has been seen in such réles as Shylock, Ham- let, and Macbeth; but much may be ex- pected of a man capable of playing such diverse parts as Malatesta, Charles I., Dau- and Markheim. on tran, The Ben Greet Players are again in this country. They will devote the first few weeks of the season to the South; be- ginning with “Everyman” at the University of Virginia. All the plays included in last year’s repertory will be reproduced. About Easter a series of performances will be given at one of the Broadway theatres. “All's Well That Ends Well,” the whole of “Hamlet,” and possibly both parts of ‘Henry IV.” will be this year’s addition ' to the repertory. A Malone Society has been formed in England, for the purpose of making acces- sible material for the study of the early English drama. The society will publish reprints of old plays, chiefly in the Tudor period, and documents illustrative of the history of the stage. The plan is to print the following plays early in the new year: “Wealth and Health,” “St. John the Evan- gelist,”” Peele’s “Battle of Alcazar,’’ 1594; and Greene's “Orlando Furioso,”’ 1594. The first two plays were long thought to be lost, but they have recently been recovered. The extent of the society's activity will de- pend upon the number of members, at a guinea a subscription. The society hopes to issue each year one play or other such publication for every twenty-five members. The in charge of organization consists of F. 8. Boas, E. K. Chambers, Rk. B. MeKerrow, A. W. Pollard, and W. W. Greg The address of Mr. Greg, the secretary, is Park Lodge, Wimbledon, 8S. W. committee Gabriele d'Annunzio’s play, “More Than Love,”" which was presented at Rome for the first time Monday night, is reported to be a complete failure. [Vol. 83, No. 2157 THE COMING MUSICAL SEASON. The arrival from Europe of Camille Saint-Saéns, the leading composer of France, calls attention to one of the strik- ing feature of the musical season now opening. It was inaugurated, three weeks before the usual date, by Signor Leonca- vallo, one of the three most prominent com- posers Italy has produced since Verdi, the other two being Mascagni and Puccini. Mascagni we had with us a few years ago, and Puccini, as we have noted, is to be here later for the production of his latest opera, “Madama Butterfly,” at the Metropolitan Opera House. Paderewski also had planned to come here in order to accompany the Boston Orchestra when it plays his new symphony, but his coming is now regarded as extremely doubtful, for the symphony is not yet finished. From Russia we shall get Scriabine. Prominent composers have visited us heretofore—among them Rubin- stein, Dvordék, Tchaikovsky, Weingartner, Humperdinck, Elgar, Johann and Richard Strauss; but never have so many been here in one year. Among the few whom we have not had an opportunity to welcome are Grieg, Massenet, Goldmark, and Sibelius. The only new conductor we shall be called upon to judge is Dr. Muck, the leader, for a year, of the Boston Orchestra. Though one of the ‘“Parsifal’’ pilots at Bayreuth for a number of years, Dr. Muck is under- stood to be rather conservative and un- emotional. He will thus serve as a foil to the fiery Safonoff, who is to conduct the Philharmonic Society for three years. Mr. Safonoff, however, is by no means always ablaze, or suggestive of the impetuous Cos- sack; he knows when calmness is called for. While the Philharmonic Society has not yet issued its prospectus, one gets the im- pression, from a glance at the general situ- ation, that orchestral novelties will be few. This is not a reason for special regret, since few contemporary composers are dis- tinguishing themselves. But, apart from Paderewski, whose works are not heard as often as they deserve to be, there are at least two European composers who have heretofore been neglected here—the Finnish Sibelius and the Austrian Bruckner. Maud Powell is enthusiastic over the violin con- certo of Sibelius, which she is to introduce to us, and Walter Damrosch has on his list for the New York Symphony Orchestra a Bruckner scherzo; but these are only sam- ples. Nor is there any indication that the leading orchestral organizations will devote considerable attention to American com- posers. In this respect English composers are much more fortunate. Opera-goers, as a rule, are not clamor- ing for novelties. If they can hear ‘‘Faust,”’ “Carmen,” “Lohengrin,” and a dozen other favorite works given by the best singers, they are satisfied. Yet it is in the opera houses that the principal novelties of the year are to be looked for. Competition has already had its effect at the Metropolitan Opera House. Richard Strauss’s sensa- tional “Salome” is promised as the chief There will also be six more Cilea’s “Adriana Lecouvreur,” “Andrea Chenier” and “Fe- attraction. novelties: Giordano's

Page 23

Nov. 1, 1906] Nation. dora,” Puccini's “Manon Lescaut” and “Madama Butterfly,”’ and a stage version of Berlioz’s “La Damnation de Faust.” The Manhattan Opera House is also staging this work. For the rest, the Manhattan relies on the familiar repertory, with a few re- vivals, like “Norma,” “La Juive,”’ ‘‘Mig- non,”” and, above all, Auber’s masterwork, known here as ‘“‘Masaniello.”’ In the lists of both managers there is an unusually large proportion of Italian operas. This is due less to a revival of interest than to the fact that the managers place more reliance on their chief tenors—lItalians both—than on even their lists of famous prima donnas Whether New York can support two grand opera houses at the highest prices for four months, when other American cities find it difficult to support one for a week, is yet to be seen. In 1883-1884, the attempt to run two companies in this city, with a repertory chiefly Italian, resulted in disaster to both. But that was nearly a quarter of a century ago, and in this period New York has not much bigger, but has become more and more the winter resort of wealthy families. only grown Whatever the outcome, we shall 150 operatic performances, and perhaps twice that number of concerts. To we are still far behind the German cities, which have opera ten months a year, of having music from the first of January to the 3lst of But md) concerts a year, like Berlin, or fifty in one week, as sometimes in London, we have all have about be sure, or London, which now boasts December if we do not have we need The death of Germany's most eminent teacher of singing, Julius Stockhausen, has revived the question to his relations with Richard Wagner. It is certain that Wagner greatly admired Stockhausen, for he invited him, in 1864, to become the head of the vocal department of the pro- jected Academy of Music in Munich. Stock- hausen could not accept this offer, be- cause a contract tied him to Hamburg. Some of the German newspapers have tried to convey the impression that Stockhausen did not admire Wagner, and thought that Wagner's music ruined the voice. Stock- hausen himself defined his attitude, not long before his death, in these words: as Contrary to the prevalent opinion, | am firmly convinced that Wagner's music ab- solutely does not ruin the voice or short- en a singer’s career. If voices are ruined by Wagner singing, this is not the fault of Wagner, but of the singer who tries, before his voice is properly trained, to make it attempt the most difficult task that can be set—that of mastering the Wagnerian style of song (NSprachgesang). Madame Nordica will give her first concert in this city in seven years at Carnegie Hall, Tuesday evening, January 8. On this occasion she will be assisted by Walter Damrosch and his orchestra. Art. By R. T. Published by the H. Halsey. Bos- Museum of Fine American Silver ton: Arts. “American Silver,” dealing with the work of seventeenth and eighteenth cen- tury silversmiths, creditable catalogue of a loan exhibition held during is a most the past six months at the Boston Museum of Fine The text, introduction with includes an chief Bos 7 mh FF iginal re fleld The press-work is that of the Gillis Pre and which of the prepared Arts lives ton makers, has been H search Halsey, and represents or in a virtually untrodden ss is fastidiously elegant most perhaps in the catalogue pro; combination of rubricated numbers type, and copies of the inscriptions on pieces in a cursive charact« eight half-tone plates illustrate practical How ! h is studied n pior the entire collection ial be the mater here may realized from the fact smiths represented Mr names of r+ sides ninety silver by these 3232 pieces an appendix the tisans of the period whose work is s« known To appe ing of lonial ly many this al antiquar handsome most strongly as a bit anism considerable is artistic mer The Co craftsmen stood Their designs models part but admirable was striking te » present accept forms in workman appealed These urns to a sober but corres flagons bowls po nae beake teapots that tood on Ce sideboards the adorned Virgil proprietors’ were in preestablished harn Iwellings they of Horace inside well to re with excellent Georg the furnished the heads We do urselves of a when if uninventive This is better worth the while of an art museum an as with scraps and that of the mind time American taste was at least unvulgarized silver, with its obvious limitations than any subsequently produced among us By providing a loan exhibition catalogu that is really a hand-book of the subject the Boston Museum of Fine Arts has es tablished a valuable precedent. How many similar exhibitions in the past have gone by with nothing but a flimsy hand-list to commemorate them! This authoritative catalogue gives promise of a time when experts will as readily lend their learning to such a cause as collectors have always lent their more tangible treasures The constantly renewed demand for in expensive houses in the suburbs of the great cities and on the village street caus- es the publication of “‘Palliser’s Up-to-Date House Plans” (J. S. Ogilvie Publishing Co.). It presents on the front cover a half-tone print of a very effective house in old colonial style, the plan of which will be found inside. That house is gran diose enough, and is assumed to cost $18 000 when built of “Philadelphia pressed brick with white marble trimmings and if those trimmings include the tetrastyl portico and the pilasters which serve as responds to the four columns (for one must be technical in describing so stately a front), that would seem to be a low price for the work Few of the houses presented are as elegant as that, although there is one which in cost exceeds it large- ly, and several more require about the same outlay. The is generally termined, though stone is mentioned in one case andbrick veneer in another. The others are all shown as presumably built of frame with sheathing, and the material unde- clapboard cost and reaches $9,000 in some cases, } | | | 376 ) e 4 ‘ falls as low as =: $1, 000 Th l cuts of the exteriors ars ull) from drawings made 1 perspective n h regulation way, a rding to the office rules, and they are not attractive, but the person who is pleased by on f t plans given, such a view of tl hous shows at least what may t ‘ f It would be a good lea to 1 over or in anoth promine p ‘ any one of the Dla j an exterior n some , from the one offered In spite of th d ue ) Waldstein received from the |! ernment two years ago, he ha ‘ given up his scheme of excay H laneum Recent numbers of tl News | Prease and the Corrwre della Sera give a counts of interview with ? } whi expounds his great proje« with a enthusiasm as before H 1 t in making it an international und a} ltaly—or ideed, any co ry | t 0 sustain the enormous expe : , for the purpose ngle-handed ly Lh Waldst nj pose ha h ] be formed committees my 1 nent men for he purpose of i ng sut scriptior Mr} omm ) eonnected with an tee sitting in Rome f wh ! shall be the King of Italy l " mittee each n on shall sentatives, bu ltaly hall hav f minister of publ instructior I | of Naples, and two othe Phe KCa tions shall be i ed on by the mo at j} able and expert ed archmolog f th variou nation indet the ! ) f Italy All objects found shall na Italy Whatever our opinions on the fea sibility of this particula cheme he no doubt that the excavation of th pla if ever it comes to pa will be a ma of great public interest Herculaneum buried during the famous outbreak of \ suvius in 79 a. »., was a richer and mo artistic city than Pompeli + fellow victim While the latter was a mere provincial town, Herculaneum was a favorite imm residence of fashionable Romans Mo over, the catastrophe happened before th inhabitants could take refuge in great hum bers, as was the case in Pompeii, and they could not, therefore in this case return and carry away their most precious pos sessions The great objection hitherto raised against the excavations, that Hercu laneum is covered with hard lava, is, a cording to Dr. Waldstein, no longer valid The strata of lava are due to the eruptions of the last centuries; the city itself was covered with burning mud a substance comparatively easy to remove Excavations on the site of ancient Nu mantia are to be continued After las year’s successful campaign the Spanish minister of public instruction declares that he will do his utmost to further the work and if difficulties should arise from exag owners of gerated demands of the present the property, the land will be expropriated A museum for future finds is to be erected It will be remembered that, underneath the remains of the city was found the Iberian city which the Roman Roman of Numantia Still lower pre- General Scipio burned in 133 B&. c were discovered remains of an early

Page 24

Screnece, Nation. _ h © bones it flesh had been skeletons that the the appeared stripped off before were marks of placed on the area, although no a tool have yet been found on the bones Once placed these bones were cov- ered over with clay to a depth of eighteen to twenty-four inches and a fire was built upon the top The layer of ashes was later covered by earth which had been scraped up with shells, and the fragments of the shells are still dem- onstrable in the earth mass The latter now measures some four feet in thickness It is, of course, apparent that the half- baked clay would serve as an admirable protection from the destructive elements, especially in view of the naturally perfect drainage of this location A small triangu lar flint knife and a number of fine pink quartzite spalls are the only other objects found in the area excavated None of the skeletons is complete, and many of the bones are imperfect, yet some peculiar features are apparent on first ex- mination Most striking of all is un- doubt: The supra dly the lateral aspect of the cranium orbital ridges are massive and prominent, while the frontal bone slopes al- most directly backward in a way which forcibly recalls the mo primitive human The developed its ecrania yet discovered lower jaw is ibnormally muscle attach- ments are prominent, and the teeth, even third The attachments the usually unused molar, are worn down to the gum bones are heavy muscle strongly de e both and thei veloped, wh femur and ulna display a marked culiar curvature forward In fact ae part and pe skeleton skele- gen- prim almost every part of the from the type of the human ton to-day in some particular, and in eral itive type differences indicate a The will be these more exact bearing of these pe after the the Barbour culiarities clearer com- detailed study of bones already begun by Profs. Erwin H ind Henry B. Ward of the Nebraska, to the entrusted pletion of the University of whom specimens have been for exact measurement and omparison with recorded data Of the importance of this discovery there even though its significance The re any can be no doubt no clear at this moment main are not readily referable to known aboriginal race of this continent com- the hab- their but before the completion of exact parative studies all speculation as to ize of the remains, the character and it of the people they represent, or tribes find less unpublished known This but elation to later appears omewhat premature together with others important widely known ind with some yet lincoverts regarding the remains of Nebraska the will pre iistoric man in lowa and west thorough add races on ward, indicate clearly that examination of this region much early this t knowledge of continent Ber- Ginn The Principles of Botany. By Kradley M & Co, $1.50 Joseph Y xen and Davis Boston There are now s0 many text-books of botany that nearly all of the available titles have been appropriated, and therefore some of the older tithes are being used over gain It is now about sixty years since Dr Lankester published his excellent trans- [ Vol. of Schleiden’s “Principles of Bot- any,”’ a work which with its polemic had much to do with the stimulation of research lation at the beginning of one of the most im- portant epochs in the science. It was the point of time when the subject of plant- fertilization was being assiduously studied and with more im- Protoplasm, the form- was just revealing it- with imperfect lenses perfect methods less creator of form self day, appeared to be marvellously simple in and, under the rude chemistry of that its structure It is extremely interesting to compare such a work as Schleiden’s in the forties, with this work by Bergen and Davis, standing as a sane exposition of the views held at the first decade of our new century We have space for only a few points of contrast At the outset, it is seen that a good deal of the older founda- tion-work still stands unmoved by recent investigation, but upon this secure founda- tion nearly all of the superstructure has Old flowerless and the broken through edifice throughout the been reconstructed partitions, such as that between the flowering plants, have been or taken down, and the whole has rebuilt symmetrically did prepared in been The vantage of have ad- the earlier work not being strong have cast the theories of evolution field of affinities; beginning light which over the whole dawn was then just Consequently we find, as we should expect to find, totally new views expressed in the newer book, as to relationships between plants, and we may further say, between plants and their Now these subjects are diffi- text-book. Even environment cult of presentation in a advanced students find some of the matters The lationship between the lower and some of hard to understand evidence of re- the higher plants is based for the most part upon examination with the microscope, and in some instaaces the work of investi- gation is extremely technical It is simply impossible to have the average stu- the of some of these relationships at obliged to take Here, then, is pedagogics. The meet it, and in Mr. Ber- gen is a teacher with large experience, who evidence first dent obtain hand; he is much of it on trust a perplexing question in fitted to our opinion they have met it well authors are well possesses a certain sympathy with the pupil which goes a long way towards bridging over serious difficulties Professor Davis is an investigator who has achieved dis- field of morphology, and he has presented his sug- tinction in many portions of the gestions and statements clearly The two have been in close touch throughout the preparation of the book, and team-work is always best The sixty-inch Harvard Observatory is mounting a reflector which will materially increase the efficiency of the astronomical The the three largest in equipment reflector, which is one of existence, will be used to make observations on faint stars and nebula The has Royal Scottish Museum at Edinburgh the of shells of about 5,600 specimens, be- been given collection British mollusca longing to the late Richard Rinmer The Oxford University Press is publish ing Dr Koenigsberger's “Life of Hermann von Helmholtz.” translated by Francis A Kelvin furnishes a Preface Welby Lord

Page 25

Nov. 1, 1906] The Nation.

in which he points out Helmholtz’s unique

position as a master and leader in mathe- matics, and in biology and physics BOOKS OF THE WEEK Abendschein, Albert. The Secret of the Old Masa ters Appiletons. $1 net Addison, Joseph, Selections from the Works of. Ed ted by Edward B. Reed Henry Holt & Co 75 cents Ade, George. In Pastures New. McClure, Phillips & Co. Alston, Leonard. Steic and Christian in the Sec ond Century. Longmans Archer-Shepl l. FE. H. Burning Questions 1 the Light of To-day London: Rivingtons 2s. td Det Austin, Mary The Flock. Boston: Houghton, M f- fin & Co. $2 net Baker, George Barr, and others. Mother's Geese Dodd, Mead & Co. $1 net Bates, Arlo Talks on Teaching Literature Bos ton: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $1.30 net Battersby, F. Prevost The Evening Hour Appl ton £1.50 Beckwith, Clarence Augustine. Realities of Chris tian Theology Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co $2 Reebe, C. William The Bird Hicnry Holt & Co $3.50 net Bell. Lilian Why M Remain Bach ald the Luxuries John ine Co Bellamy, Cherise, 2. The Wonder Children. Mac millan Co. $1.5 Belloc, Hilaire Hilts aml the Sea Imported by Scribners $1.50 net. Bennett, John ihe Treasure of Peyre Gaillard Century Co. $1.5 Biblography of vey ‘History of the United States Navy Compiled by Charles 1 Harherk Pri vately printed Bond, R. Warwick Montaigne ury Frowde Booth, Maud Ballington Tellight Fairy Tales Putnams. $1.25 net. Béttger, W Amerikanisches Hochschulwesen Leipzig Bourne, Fdward Gaylord. Columbus, Ramon Pane and the Beginning of American Anthropology. Worcester, Mass Brandes, Georg. Main Ourrents in the Nineteenth Century Literature. 6 vols. Macmillan Co Brinton, Davis Trusia Vhiiadelphia* teo. W Jacobs & Co. Bront®, Charlotte. The Professor. Henry FPrewde Burgess, Gelett Are You a Bromide? B. W. Huebsch. 50 cents Burke, Edmund. Vol. II Henry Frowde. Burnett, Frances Hodgson. Queen Silver-Bell. —— “ae Packetty House. Century Co. 60 cents each, Burnham, Clara Louise The Opened Shutters. Roston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. $1.50. Cabot, Ella Lymatr Everyday Ethics. Henry Holt & Co Carey, Rosa Nuuchette No Friend Like a Sister Philadelphia Lippincott Carpenter, Edward Childs Captain Courtesy Philade!phia: George W. Jacobs & Co Carpenter, George ih Rhetoric and English Com- position Macmillan Co $1.10 Castlemen, Virginia Carter Roger of Fairtieid Neale Publish ng Co Chapman, J. Wilbur 8s. H — x" of Water Street Fleming H. Revell Co. $1.26 net Charles, Frances Pardner of phecsom Range. Boston: Little Brown & Co. $1.% Colton, Arthur. The Cruise of the Violetta Henry Holt & Co. $1.50 Conspectus of American Biography. Compiled by George Derby. James T. White & Go. $10. Conway. Monecure Daniel. My Pilgrimage to the Wise Men of the East. Boston: Houghton, Mif flln & Co. $3. (wok Albert S. The Higher Study of English. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co net. Coolidge, Susan. Last Verses tjoston Little frown & Ca Correspondence of William Pitt Filited by Ger trude Selwyn Kimball. 2 vols Macmillan Co $6 net. Oraddock, Charles Pgbert. The Amulet Macmil lan Co $1.50. Crowley, Mary Catherine. In Treaty with Honor. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. §1. Daly, T \ Canzoni Philade ‘Iphia: Catholic Standard and, Times Publishing Co 1 Dargan. Olive Tlferd. Lords and Lovers and Other Dramas Ser bners Davis, Riehard Harding. Farces. Secribners. $1.50 net. Deakin, Dorothea. ‘“‘Georgie.’’ Century Co. $1.50. Defoe. Daniel. Captain Singletes. Henry Frowde

By D. S. ALEXANDER. THE NATION says: it is, the fact that it covers a practica “A 7 portions. reminiscences Scecesesosssesese useful history. , ly unoccupied feld would give the book a certain value. - « Enlivened and enriched by numerous pen-pictures of New York politicians and statesmen, which constitute what are perhaps the most valuable, as well asthe most entertainin The — is terse and clear. breaks away absolutely from the annalistic form.” HENRY HOLT AND COMPAN

Dunber, Paul Lawrence Joggin’ Briong Dodd Mead & Co. §1.™) net Dunne, Finley Peter. Dissertations by Mr. Dooley Harts. $1.50. Baton, Seymour The Roawevelt Bears. Philadel phia: Edward Stern & Oo. Eichendorf, Jose; F. v The Happy-tieLucky I anslated by Mra. Ag. Wiste Vhiladeiphia bso Ellis Clata Spald og Ww « Next Shall a la Liv Agaiu Be kk is Bauger Emerson's Friendship and Character. Oentury Oo 1 Fenollosa, Mary MeNe 1 I Paint Bos fon atthe Brown & ¢ Fitch M. H The Physical of Mind amd Morals. Chicago: Charlies H r & Go | Fitzgerald, Percy. Sir Henry Irving. Philadeiphia George Jacobs & Co Foster's Skat Manual. Met lure Phill ips & Oo Fox, John, jr. Knight of Cumberland : Introdu bn to l osophy. Mac $i. Rhetor | li $! wings Im t y he $2 Garneau, Alfred Poésies Montre Bea mit Gasquet, Abbot lard Acton and His Circle. Long mans 34.50 net Gilder rk. W A Book of Mus Century $1 net. Giyn, Elinor Beyond the Rocks liarpers , Golden Poems Fdlited by Francis 1 Browne Chicago A. C. MeClurg & CG Gordon, George A Through Man t ; B Houghton, Mifflin & ¢ $1.5 t Gosse, Edmund Moder Engl » Literatu I \. Stokes Co $2.50 net Greely, cents Holmes, Daniel ‘He -nry A Pedlar’s Pack I ID North. ae bach, Daniel A. Pathway to the Fields of Art. Published by the Author. 25 cents pet Jer ram, s Anglice Red Jemda Vol. il liens Frowde Kempster Aguila Salvage Appleton $1.50 Kerbey, J. Urtot The Land of To-m a Ww. t Lrainaril $1.50, Kildare, Owen My Old Bailiwick Fleming H Revell Co. $1.60 Knowles, Robert E. The Undertow Fleming H Revell Co. $1.50 Kobbé, Gustav. How to ppreciate Mus Mof fat, Yard & Co Sli. ms Ladd, Horatio Oliver. Chunda Eaton & Mains $1.25. Lafargue, Paul Social and Phil wophical Studies Translated by Charles H. Kerr. Chicag Charles I. Kerr & Co. & cents Lee, Sidney Shakespeare and the Modern Stage Secribners. $2 net. Lond, Jack. White Fang Macmillan Co $1.5 Mackaye, Jamea The Politics of Utility Boston: Little, Brown & Co. 50 cents net. Manual of Style. University of Chicago Press Martens, Etude de F. de Par ia Jus Vers la Paix G. E. Stechert McMullen, Lynn B&B. Forty Lesse Physics. He 4 Holt & Co $1.25 Millet, Jean Francois, Drawing- oluct « by Léonce Bénédite Philadeiphia Lippincott. Mitchell, J The Silent Wa e Publishing Co £1.50 Moss, Sanford A Elements of Gas Engine De sign I>. Van Nostrand Co. 50 cents net Miiller Max Memories Translated by Georg P. Upton Chicago: A. ©. MeClurg & Co Musset Alfred de. Posies ‘ risies Hienry Frowde Neera The Soul of an Artist Translated by EF I Murison San Francisco: Paul Elder & Co Nelson's Encyclopedia Ealited by F. M. Oolby and G. Sandeman Vol Il. Thomas Nelson & Sons. Nibelungenlied, The Translated by John Store Cobb Boston: Small, Maynard & Co Nicoll, W. Robertson The Key of the Bius Closet Dodd, Mead & Co $1.40 net A Political History “a the State of New Yor 2 vols., 800 pp., $5.00 net, carriage 40 cents If it were not as welldone a is made of anecdotes a Good use 29 W. 23 ?St. NEW YORK

EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY [| (BRARIAN. Soe. 50 cents; leather, $1.00. N & ©O. List on E. P. DUTTON NEW Y wet. | Old and Rare Rooks put In organ and catalogued. Americans a specialty P. Sanvoun, 444 La Salle Ave., Chicago. 381 $1.25 Noyes, Alfred. Poems Ober, Frederick A Ball Orange Fairy Book, Thi Lougma Green & Co Ostini, Frita von. Wilhelm & Buechner Phillpotts, Falen, and Arnold Rennett Met lure, Phillipe & Go $1.50 Porter, Thomas } y Songs Boston The tiorham I Pratt, Agnes Louls Aunt Sara G. Badger Prost, C. Alfred Deux (Kuvres de Greuss Les Services Postaux Francais Varia Proverbs of Selomen, The Century Gs. §1 Raine, Allen. Queen of the Rushes. Philadel; George W. Jaco®s & Co Ramaden, Lady Guendolea. Brothers Longmans Rideout, Henry Milner Houghton, Mifiin & Roach, Abby Meguire Harpers 1.3 Roosevelt, Ubersetat Rosebery, pers Riedl, ature Salmon held Sanders, Biblical Det Sargent, Dudley A Physical Ginn & Co. $1.50 net Scott's Old Mortality George. Henry Frowde Shackford, Martha Hale Boston: Benj. H. Sanborn Sigerson Dora The Story Roderick Harpers Simons, BEmogene Sanford Silver, Burdett & Co Sincére, O Un Royaliste Francais. Parts Singleton, Bather Historic Bulldings of America Innid, Mead & Co. $1.4) pet Skinner, Robert P Abyssinia of mana. $3 net Smith, G ” Macmitian Oo na Harpers Ed ted by Andrew Lang $1. vet von Kaulbach

lemcke Deubloons and mitry Ca le Theat R a) Oorrespondence of Two net Beacbed Oo $1.50 Some Su Keels Leostun esseful Marriages der Hints Berlin Qhuret Theodor: Im Retche rwhldler von Max Kulloick Lord Lord Randolph 2.25 net Frederick A Appleton $1.75 net Lacy Maynard. Pre Boston, Houghton, MI! and H = and Literature lias History of Hunga Lit the House $1.10 net (utitnes of $1.28 Boston Tress in in & (» F. Fowler History Seribners BPducation. Edited by Hereford B A First Book of Poetics & Oo and Song f Black First Year Pnglish Tl day Long Blan Haddon London Elliot Starling, Ernest H lology of Digestion io 2 Staunton, Schuyler cago: The Boitty St'ckney, Albert Organize r De mor Houghton. Mifflin & Co Studies in Sw te and —— ogy students of C > Garman Boston & Co. $2.5) net Ed ted by the Swedish Stockholm Mary Imlay Brown & Co $1.50 R. Wardlaw Griffith Jobn: The Sto Years In China A. © Armstrong Advances in the Ke Phys ener & ent Chicago Ww Ke

Daughters of Destiny ch! & Britton Co racy Bost By former Houghton MimMfiin Sweden clety Taylor Littl Thompson, of Fifty Son $2 net Tomlinson, Everett T quois, Toston: Houghton, , tradford I Mi iti Tourist Traffic B Boaton Marching againet the Iro Mifflin & Oo $1. jendsa on the Shelf Boston & to $1.25 Watern $1.) net The Friendly The Impersonator net ughtt ' Townsend, Edward Yard & Co Henry $1.25 of ¢ Year t Falited by Jull columbus and Cal» Blane Chi Walker, Margare Her Friet Wallace lew were Weyman age A ‘ Conlaon The taker & I ( An Autoblograptl 2 vols ita Lady ’ Stanley J i (lure, Phillips & Whitcomb, Ida Prentics Ye \rt Dodd, Mead & Co White | M T Sinwe Little, Brown & ¢ $1.% Whitney, Anne Poems i Merrymount Press. $1.50 Whitney, J. Parker tminiecences of a man Forest and Stream Publishing Oo Villlams, Pgerton R., jr. Ridelfo: The Coming of the Dawn Chicag 1. ¢ YI we & ¢ 5 Williams Saral Stone rh Ma fran Neale Publis g to $1.% N. and A. M Rosemary MeClure, Phillips & Go Till Canterbary Tales language The Faery Queen tn Simple Chicago 4. (. MeClareg & G@ ot Max Angel da ¥1 & Buechner ohn M What's So and What Ien't. «1 eag Oharles H. Kerr & Co 50 cente ppinge vately printed Ihe Sports Landon Town Willilamson, © of a Father Wilson, Calvin in Searct in Simpl Langunge mole Lem & Lord Acton and His Circle Edited by Abbot GASQUET, O.S.B. Large 8vo. With Photogravure Portrait 160) pages. $4.50 net. *,* The volume contains nearly two hundred letters of{AcTon'’s, mostly on literature and reli gion. Abbot Gasquet as editor supplies a sympa thetic monograph on the periodicals Acton and his friends conducted between the years 154 and 1875. Alike for learning, for industry. and for conscience, ACTON must rank among foremost editors—thi«. at least, ia the opinion expressed by the Abbot Some important Newman correspon dence also is published for the first time LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York

Page 26

3882 The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2157 BOOKS FOR THE BOOKISH JUST PUBLISHED Christopher Columbus AND THE NEW WORLD OF HIS DISCOVERY By FILSON YOUNG Two Volumes. Octavo. Cloth, gilt tops. $6.50 net, per set. In this important and exhaustive work, upon which Mr. Young has been engaged for some time, the object has been to disentangle the somewhat unfamiliar figure of Columbus from the net of controversy and histor- ical argument which has surrounded him and to present the man himself in a narrative of strong, human and picturesque interest. The volumes contain maps and illustrations; a photogravure portrait of Columbus; and a picture in colors of a caraval, such as Columbus must have sailed in, from a painting by Norman Wilkinson. Earl of Dunraven has also contributed a note on the navigation of Columbus’s first voyage. | READY SHORTLY A NEW VOLUME: | A SPLENDID VOLUME Fee eeecerenes, oS Drawings of Jean Francois Millet Ea lume contains a frontispiece portrait of its subject, and Fifty Facsimile Reproductions of The Master’s Work. With an an ad te index Introductory Essay. 12mo, cloth, paper label, $1.50 net, per volume, The edition is numbered and limited to One Hundred and postpaid, $1.60. Forty Copies. Imperial Quarto, for the United States. One Honore de Balzac. This latest addition to Balzac critical Hundred and Twenty Copies, numbered, and bound in buck- iterature is a very exhaustive study by M. Ferdinand ram, $20.00 net, each. Twenty copies, printed on hand-made B tiére, commonly recognized as the ablest living critic paper and bound in vellum, gilt, forming an edition de lure, f French literatur will be sold at $25,00 net, each. THE NEW VARIORUM EDITION OF SHAKESPEARE Edited by HORACE HOWARD FURNESS 7 lati prepared by one of the foremost living Shakespearian scholars, is the result of more than thirty-five years of | ireful preparation It represents the life-work of an American scholar of the highest type, whose learning, painstaking ind critical judgment are lauded throughout the literary world—not only by American and English Shakespearian but by those of the countries of continental Europe as well. Tl v Variorum Edition is without question the most complete in existence, as it is ar edition in which the various d editorial observations of the editions that have preceded it are recorded ‘* These monumental volumes are the admiration of every true student of Shakespeare,’’ says Dr. William Aldis Wright THE FOURTEEN VOLUMES WHICH HAVE THUS FAR APPEARED ARE Macbeth, Revised Edition by Romeo and Juliet The Winter's Tale HORACE HOWARD Furness, Jr The Tempest Twelfth Night King Lear A Midsummer Night’s Dream Much Ado About Nothing Othello As You Like It Love’s Labour's Lost The Merchant of Venice Hamlet (Two Volumes) IN PREPARATION Antony and Cleopatra, 1nd Richard the Third, Edited by Horace HOwaRD FURNESS, JR. Royal Octavo, gilt top, uncut edges, $4.00 net pev volume. Half morocco, gilt top, $5.00 net per volume. J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Philadelphia ee ————

Page 27