The Nation 1906-10-25: Vol 83 Iss 2156
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
GEi UNIV. Ui statwas | . Pry OCT 26 1906 eC ALE i a “ay <j “HI,
VOL. LXXXIII—NO, 21 56. THURSDAY, OCTOBER 25, 1906. PRICE TEN CENTS
The Notable New Publications PERSONAL REMINISCENCES Bram Stoker’s Personal Reminiscences of Henry Irving **Many books of this sort have an immediate currency but only a short fame. No merely short fame will, we think, thes: volumes have. . . . They are admirably printed. They are finely illustrated . . . and they should receive from readers what they deserve, large purchase, close perusal, independent judgment and affectionate preservation in the library of the home and the heart. . . . Only one man ever lived that could have made volumes of this kind more inter esting than Bram Stoker has made these. . . . Had Henry Irving himself written his own Reminiscences the result might have been more? interesting than these volumes now are. But even that is doubtful.’’ Mr. ST. Clair MCKELWAY, in the Brooklyn Eagle In two handsome volumes, with portraits and other hitherto unpublished illustration Cloth $7.50 met Dr. Edward Everett Hale’s Tarry-at-Home Travels Because of a painful lack of native descriptive literature, intelligent Americans know more of populer sections of Europe than they know of their own country. Dr. Hale ‘‘touches briefly spots he knows well, weaving in happy anecdotes of persons and places, sometimes wandering far afield in personal reminiscences’’ (Boston Advertiser). ‘There is a good deal that is personal. That, we imagine, gives Dr. Hale’s books their charm" (Mew York Sun). The two hundred varied illustrations are of Dr. Hale's own collection and are rarely good. Cloth, $2.50 net Mr. Frederic Harrison’s Memories and Thoughts Men—Books—Cities—Art. * Part'y autobiographical, with a delightful width of scope, as indicated by the title: ; fine tone, the genial atmosphere, the rich suggestiveness, of Mr. Harrison’s writings that attract the reader and win him ; —The Dial, Chicago. Cloth, r2mo, ix+-gog pages, $2.00 net, by mail $2. 15 It is the Se ak Ne RT i aaa 6 IMPORTANT VOLUMES OF HISTORY Dr. Henry C. Lea’s History of the Inquisition in Spain Second Volume The second volume brings out as never before the prevalence of ‘ graft’’ in the Spanish Inquisition. ZA’ Churchman says ‘It has not been realized generally, perhaps never before could it have been realized fully, how great was the share of a third party in the unholy alliance of priestcraft and bigotry, the share of insatiable greed. It is with that phase of the subject, the finances of the Inquisition, that Dr. Lea’s second volume is especially concerned . Dr. Lea thinks justly : attributable to the Inquisition the stagnation of Spanish commerce.” To be complete in four 8vo volumes, of which the second is just issued. Cloth, $2.50 net per volume Correspondence of William Pitt When Secretary of State with Colonial Governors and Military and Naval Commissioners in America Auspices of the National Society of the Colonial Dames of America by GERTRUDE SELWYN KIMBALL. Cloth, medium 8vo, $6.00 net. Published this day Edited under the Including documents of great historical value, in whose publication Dr. J. Franklin Jameson, of Washington, D. C., and Mr. Hubert Hall, of the London Record Office, have been practically interested. STANDARD SETS RECENTLY COMPLETED Dr. James Ford Rhodes’s History of the United States From the Compromise of 1850 to the Final Restoration of Home Rule at the South in 1877. Now complete in seven volumes. Cloth, 8vo; price of the set, $17.50 net ‘Mr Rhodes has charm and lucidity of style and a rare gift for quotation, not the trick of essayists who make a pastiche of other people's clever sayings, but the faculty of seizing the word or phrase from letter, speech, or debate which reflects the actual movement of events and makes his reader the participant in aliving scene. Above all he is inflexibly judicious, without causes to plead, friends to eulogize, or enemies to condemn, but with one sole aim, the truth.” The New York Tribune. Mr. Herbert Paul’s History of Modern England Complete in five volumes Cloth, 8vo,; price per volume $2.50 met; the set, $12.50 net ‘Mr, Paul has a vivid, picturesque style that never fails to be suggestive, stimulating the reader’s imagination, and arous ing the interest the more one gets into the subject. He has, moreover, the facalty of getting at the heart of things; he penetrates the apparent meaning, and sets out the real gist of the matter in trenchant, forceful English.” ~Philadelphia Public Ledger, Published THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “5 4° by
Page 2
The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 The Nation. A WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1864 [Hniered at the New York City Post Office as second-class matl matter. | CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER Tum WORE... 2.0... ccccees . 889 EprroRIaL ARTICLES: New Light on Buropean Diplomacy .......- 342 The Newfoundland Fisheries 342 Wanted—A National GalbesF.. ccccsccccccces 343 Mute, Inglorious TAterature «. «6c cc cccceweee A44 2s 2 GL Ee: ccscntaddesevawenennsuesiee 344 Srectal ARTIOLES A Latinist at a Scientific School ........-. 845 Book Notes from Paria ......6.ssccceseceee 346 CORRESPONDENCE Ristori and Galwiml ..... «6 .sccccccusevuune 346 “The Present Position ‘of Latin and Greek’. 347 ASricam LAMBCAMED occccccccccccccccccccces 347 Herbert Spencer's Supporters ...........++. S47 NorTes 847 Boon Revirws Travel and T SEE 349 Religion and Biblical Oriticlam ............ 350 A History of the Reformation . 351 A Political History of the State of New York ba The Dream and the Business Sophy of Kravonla@ ......ccccccccccceceneee 302 BAstemer’s LATO oc cccccccccccscecevcscccccs 358 Ridolfo: The Coming ‘of the Dawn ........ 353 Some Reminiscences of William Michael Ros- setti 900606 00eses ecgecceeeesesoosseseses 353 An Introduction to Logic .............e0se- 353 The Arbiter in Gouncel 354 The Spirit of Democracy secccees 355 DmaMma ERO BOERS GE BEG” cocccccccccececsece 356 Musto 856 ART The Holman Hunt Exhibition .............. 357 BCLrENCE The Birds of the Cambridge aan ¢ of heed chusetts 358 FINANCE The American Market and London ......... 350 Koons or Tum WeRK.......... .. . 859 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to for- cign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4. The date when the subscription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remit- tance. No other receipt ts sent unless requested, Remittances at the riak of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Postal Order payable to “ Publisher of The Nation.” When a change of address te desired, both the old and the new addresses should be given. Address TUE NATION, Box 704, New York. Publication Office, 208 Broadway. The Man in the Case A NOVEL OF MYSTERY AND ROMANCE BY ELIZABETH STUART PHELPS CHAUCE A yy Rich in new material. Price $2.00. Circu- lar on application. Address, H. B. Hinck- ley, 564 Prospect St., Northampton, Mass THE BELOVED VACABOND WIL LIAM J, LOC KE’s NEW NOVEL ‘A Hterary event.” 12mo, $1.50. JOHN LANE ©O., The Bodley Head, N. Y. the Tales. FE:ducational. Massacn’ seTTs, Bow OSTON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BiesLow. cos RIDCE SCHOOL For Bo Location high and dry. Laboratories. Shop for Mechanic Arta. Strong teachers. Barnest boys. Gymnasium with new ee Fits for college, eclentific school and business. owng boys In separate building. Address Dr. BC. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hills, Mass. School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Evexert O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Pl, Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 203 Mich. Ave., Chicago 1200 Williams Av., Portiand 401 Cooper Bid., Denver 6525 8time’n Bid. .LosA D 813 Rook'ry Bik. Spokane 717 Market St.. San F’ncleco Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Records. Bend for Circular on Free Registration HARLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel 8t.. ‘Albany, N. Y. WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. 1. A tremendous miscellaneous stock. 2. Greatly increased facilities for the im- portation of English publications. 3. Competent bookmen to price lists and t books. All of this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. CHILDREN’S BOOKS Greenwood’s Famous Ballads Collodi’s Pinnochio; The Adventures of a Marionette Chance’s Little Folks of Many Lands | hd ane Andrews ks ’s Wood Folk Series he Youth's Companion Series Strong's All the Year Round Comstock’s Ways of the Six-Footed Chandler’s Ia the Reign of Coyote CINN & COMPANY, - BOSTON RESEARCHES made in the BOSTON LIBRARY, HARVARD LIBRARY, BOSTON ATHENABEUTS. TRANSLATIONS made from French and Italian Summaries of books or cha pert copy and speemenes. Fr. H. DIKE, Institute of ‘echnology, Boston. A BOOK FOR EVERYBODY. EATING TO LIVE. Ry JOHN J. BLACK, M.D. With special advice to the Gouty, the Rheumatic, and the Diabetic. Cloth, $1.50 net J. 8. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. ANACTORIA and ethos Lyrical Poems gheson, Som ot the works Alge rnon ined edt rae = ted edie MITC WEL L made paper, itm . New York. EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY Cloth, 50 centa; TL 7s Liat on uest, . P. DUTTON - NEW YORK AUTOGRAPH | °., Aengps.end Pet ” LETTERS | 1,7, 94th perger, How ; Bex Mass. The American Journal of Sociology A Bimonthly edited by the Sociological Fac- ully of the University of Chicago,wtth the advice of leading sociologists in America and Kurvpe. ALBION W. SMALL, Editor-in-Chief. THE ONLY JOURNAL IN THE ENGLISH LANGUAGE DEVOTED PRIMARILY TO PURE SOCIOLOGY $2.00 a year; single copies, so cents HE sociologists are working on the clue T that human association — or ‘the stream of life,’’ as it was called a gen- eration ago—is a process, made up of lesser processes, down to the vanishing of social relations in movements within the individual consciousness which make the problems of psychology. The goal of the sociologists is a statement of life in terms of the ultimate processes which are working out through the different incidents of human experience. Some of the sociologists prefer to describe their work as a return to the ideal of social study proposed by Adam Smith, but devel- oped by him only in the economic division of human activities. In the philosophy of the author of Zhe Wealth of Nations the activities prompted by the wealth interests were merely one of several departments of human pursuits. In his scheme, accordingly, economic science was only one of an indefi- nite number of social sciences which must be worked out and correlated in order to furnish an adequate chart of actual social proc- esses. For nearly a century the economic fraction of social science was cultivated as though it were the whole. Sociology is not a rival of economics. It is essentially a method of investigation, with the aim of making the other social processes as intel- ligible as the economists have made the processes which terminate in the production of wealth. This Journal is a medium of publication for both general and special studies of social relations, as they appear from this point of view. Subsoriptions filed immediately to begin January, 1907 will include the November, 1906, number free. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS (Dept. 21) CHICAGO and NEW YORK English Monumental Brasses The valuable collection of Brass Rubbings of the ‘ disposal. It consists rubbings. Write. jorcester, England. of upwards of 1,800 E. A. LUNN, Blockiey, Financial. We buy and sell bills of 4 LETTERS wake cable transfers of mone 2 Bu: Oe abyaiunangine Canoe CREDIT — of the world. reaees Tegel International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 59 WALL STREET, NEW YORK. These trade-mark cri es on every package Creseo (F RITS) BARL TAL Perfect Breakfas Health Cereals PANSY PLOU ke and Biscuit Unlike all grocers For ite FARWELL & REINES, WA NY. USA
Page 3
Oct. 25, 1906] The Nation. ae ae — NEW SCRIBNER BOOKS A new volume of ESSAYS by SIDNEY LEE, author of “Great Englishmen of the 16th Century.” SHAKESPEARE AND THE MODERN STAGE °2.3.25.. Eleven brilliant essays by this distinguished critic and essayist. Treating of various aspects of Shakespearean drama, its influence and traditions, and practical value on the modern stag THE ESSAYS Shakespeare and the Modern Stage The Municipal Theatre Shakespeare and the Elizabethan Play goer Aspects of Shakespeare’s Philosophy Shakespeare in Oral Tradition Shakespeare and Patriotism Pepys and Shakespeare A Peril of Shakespearean Research Mr. Benson and Shakespearean Drama Shakespeare in France The Commemoration of Shakespeare in London RADIOACTIVE TRANSFORMATIONS | THE INTEGRATIVE ACTION OF THE Silliman Memorial Lectures delivered at Yale University in NERVOUS SYSTEM 1905. By ERNEST RUTHERFORD, Professor of Physics at Mc- Silliman Memorial Lectures delivered at Yale University i Gill University, Montreal, Canada. 1904. By CHARLES S. SHERRINGTON, M.D., LL.D., F.R.S., Holt Professor of Physiology atthe University of Liverpool 8vo, with diagrams, $3.50 net. Postage extra . apoyo Rutherford’s investigations and discoveries have placed 8vo, with diagrams, $3.50 net. Postage extra m in the front ranks of the world’s physicists. This book embodies Professor Sherrington’s authority as a physiologist gives tripor the results of his labors in the fleld of radioactive bodies, where he tance and distinction ~] this new volume = stim an «= Memorial t o has long been recognized as a leader among modern scientists. His | tures, the first of which was Professor J.J. Thomson's “Electricity and book opens with a historical review of the more important proper- Matter,”’ published a year ago, In the multicellular animal, the author ties exhibited by the radioactive bodies and then passes to an ex- | holds, especially for those higher reactions which constitute its be planation of the “disintegration theory, which has been found to havior as a social unit in the natural economy, it is nervous reactions account for the , Processes occurring in radioactive bodies. The which par ercellence integrates it, welds it together from its compo application of this theory in unravelling the complicated series of , nents, and constitutes it from a mere collection of organsan animal in transformations in radium, thorium, and actinium forms the main dividual. This integrative action, in virtue of whichthe nervous sys subject of Professor Rutherford’s work. tem unifies from separate organs an animal possessing solidarity an individual—is the problem which Professor Sherrington discusses in this book in a manner at once luminous and authoritative, THE SOCIAL MESSAGE OF THE MOD- ERN PULPIT _ OUTLINES OF BIBLICAL HISTORY AND Lyman Beecher Lectures at Yale Uriversity, 1906. - LITERATURE FROM THE EARLIEST By THE REV. CHARLES REYNOLDS Brown, D.D., Pastor of TIMES TO 200 A, D. the First Congregational Church, Oakland, California. By FRANK KNIGHT SANDERS, Ph.D., D.D., Sometime Pro $1.25 net. Postage 10 cents fessor of Biblical History and Archxology in Yale Uni “No more significant sign of the set and the strength of this social versity. movement has appeared among us than the turn recently given at | 12mo, $1.25 net. Postage extra Yale to the Lyman Beecher Lectures on Preaching. The lecturer, Dr. Charles R. Brown, of California, possessed unusual qualifications for such a service. He isa man in whom both capitalists and labor ers confide for just appreciation and competency to lead. These outlines enable the student to get at the Bible iteelf in a most helpful way, to realize vividly the history which it relates, sup plements, or develops, and to appreciate the varinus stages in the | gradual development of the Israel which became the world’s relig “These lectures in book form are a to elicit a wider in- ious teacher his is ove of the volumes of “The Historical Series terest than any of their predecessors." Outlook. | for Bible Students,” of which seven have been published NEW POETRY THE COAST OF BOHEMIA | LORDS and LOVERS and other Dramas by | by THOMAS NELSON PAGE OLIVE TILFORD DARGAN A collection of Mr. Page’s poems, including those in ‘* Befo’ Poetic dramas of remarkable quality, the work of a poet of de War,”’ and many written in the last few years. rare gift, in many respects unique in modern history. $1.00 net. Postage extra $1.50 net. Postage 12 cents To Be Published on Oct. 27 Amazes §I PON, dee “SSeS A KNIGHT OF THE CUMBERLAND Illustrated in colors. $1.00 A unique and charming love story. The humor and sentiment, the picturesque mountaineers and the original incident of th tournament, make this a delightful tale. CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS - New York
Page 4
Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 NEW BOOKS NEW BOOKS With 17 Photogravure Plates. 2 vols. 8vo. Price $10.00 net Life and Letters of the First Earl of Durham 1792-1840 By STUART J. REID f Sydney Smith,” &c., Editor of * The Queen's Prime Ministers" Series, l is believed that the Life and Letters of the first Earl of Dur- | m will b ! Author of ‘The Life « i book of exceptional interest and authority it is based on the family and political papers preserved it Lambton Castle. It is an interesting and an important story which Mr. Stuart Reid has to tell and one which covers the secret history of the Reform Bill, the steps which led to the creation of the kingdom of Belgium, the policy in Europe of the Tsar Nicholas I, the origin of the famous Reform Club, and the in- trigues in the Cabinets of Lords Grey and Melbourne, But perhaps to readers in Canada and the United States, the chief interest of these two volumes will be found in the full and dramatic statement of the steps which Lord Durham took in 1838 to bring peace and prosperity to Canada. Mr. Reid gives for the first time the true account of the secret history of the celebrated Durham Report. lhe book is illustrated with portraits of the Lambtons by Romney, Gainsborough, Hoppner and Lawrence; and it tells for the first time the pathetic story of ‘Master Lambton,’’ the beautiful child, immortalized by the greatest picture which Sir lhomas Lawrence ever painted, which is reproduced in its pages. Lord Acton and His Circle Edited by Abbot Gasgvet, 0.S.B. Large 8vo. With Photogravure Por- trait, 460 pages, $4.50 net. *,.* The volume contains nearly two hundred letters of AcTon’s, mostly on literature and religion Abbot Gasquet as editor supplies a sympathetic monograph on the periodicals Acron and his friends conducted between the years 1856 and 1875. The correspondence, which treats of most of the im- percent literature current during that quarter of a century, extends “ over the vest years of AcTon’s life, presenting him.” says the Abbot, “in hie most char- acteristic mouds, and testifying to his most enduring friendships.” Western Tibet and the British Borderland By Caargies A. Seerrino, M.A., F.R.G.8., Indian Civil Service ; Deputy Commissioner of Almora. Royal 8vo, With 275 Illustrations and 5 Maps and Sketches. $6.00, net. *,* During the last few years Tibet, wrapped through the centuries in mys- tery, has been effectively “opened up” to the gaze of the Western world, and already the reader has at his disposal an enormous masse of Information on the country and its inhabitants. But there is in Western Tibeta ion which is still comparatively little known, which fs especially sacred to the Hindu and Buddhist, and fn which curious myths and etill more curious manners abound; and it is of this portion of the British Borderland, its government, and the re- ligion and customs of its peoples, that Mr. SHERRING writes. The book contains an account by Dr. T. G. Lonestarr, M F.R.G.S., of an attempt to climb Guarla Manhata, the highest mountain fn . - Tibet, with two Swiss guides,which is especialiy noteworthy as being the first oc casion on which a Tibetan mountain has been attacked according to aperey ed modern methods. A special feature of the numerous {llustrations in the book are the magnificent panoramic views. Abyssinia of To-day An Account of the First Mission sent by the Tents Govern- ment to the King of Kings By Rosert P. Skinver, Commissioner to Abyssioia, 1908-4; American Consul-General; Fellow of the American Geographical Society ; Soci dou Felibrige. 8vo. With numerous Illustrations and Map. $3.00, net. *.* The object of this American Mission to the Emperor Menelik was to ne gotiate a commercial treaty. The Mission was extremely well received. and the expedition appears to have been a complete success. e picture drawn by Mr. Skinwer of the Abysainians and their ruler is an exceedingly agreeable one; and his notes on this land of grave faces, elaborate courtesy, classic tone, and Biblical civilization, “ite history, politics, language, literature, relisxion, and trade, are full of interest: there are also some valuable hints on the organiza- tion and equipment of a caravan. LONGMANS, GREEN, AND CO. 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York Send for New illustrated Catalogue PVTNAM’S NEW BOOKS Send for New Illustrated Catalogue THE LAST RIDE TOGETHER By ROBERT BROWNING Wit six Full Page Photogravure Illustrations and Headpieces Engraved n Wood by F. 8. Coburn ' inmleomel inted in colors Crown *ro. #7,? Large Paper Edition, tes wnuine pf mm vellum, timited ti coptes. Net #5.00 REMINISCENCES OF BISHOPS AND ARCHBISHOPS By HENRY CODMAN POTTER Bishop of New York. ‘wo. With *° Portraits in Photogravure. #2 .00 THE onio RIVER, A Course of Empire By ARCHER B. HULBERT of Itistoriec Highways of America,”’ ete 4 itive narrative of the most impertant t lents connected with the river, com f some of ita most pictur i wit descriptions o tful exeursions into its le acenery and detigt ty ON THE GREAT AMERICAN PLATEAU | *’ * hy T. MITCHELL PRUDDEN oe among Canyons and Buttes ta the lof the CUM Dweller and the Indian of to-day Wuh ¢* original Ulustrations and a map THE HEART OF HAMLET’S MYSTERY By HENRY W OONTENTS: The Vicar of Morwenstow, Fanny Hurney, A Note on “‘Daddy’’ Crisp, George Her bert John Keats Kenjamin Franklin, Charles Lamb Again, Walt Whitman, William Biake, The Letters of Horace Walpole, The Theme of Paradise Laat The Best | New Novels A SPINNER IN THE SUN By MYRTLE REED. lary lore eatin. Mihbnaee THE SAINT (il Santo) FOGAZZARO THE SWORD OF WEALTH THOMAS. OF. #vo. THE MAN OF PROPERTY By JOHN GALSWORTHY A SON OF THE PEOPLE Or. avo. £1.40 $y KA RI Wi Translated by Kr anern wie. _ ym by By BARONESS ORCZY. Or. *vo ‘ith ‘must now. be Regarded. as une of the lend THE SHOCK OF BATTLE t—e—tiiLa ee -'—™“*@ By PATRICK VAUX (rown vo, Net e Fronthaptece. SHELBURNE ESSAYS NO. 101 Fourth Series By PAUL ELMER MOORI By WYMOND CARRY. Illus THE SCARLET PIMPERNEL By BARONESS ORCZY us, Or, #00. $1.40. ROMANCE of the ITALIAN VILLAS By ELIZABETH W. CHAMPNEY Author of ‘Romance of the Bourbon Chateaux.’'etc. A delightful blending of history, art, and ro- mance. Fully carries out Guizot's suggestion: ‘‘If you are fond of romance, read history." » net. svo. With» Photogravure, ‘ Colored and 44 other lus- trations. Net #3.00. CATHEDRALS and CLOISTERS of the SOUTH of FRANCE By ELISE WHITLOCK ROSE Deals with the cathedrals of the Provinces of Provence, Languedoc and Gascony, presenting many fresh and interesting side-lights on the history of these most fascinating structures. With 4 Photogravure and 2) other illustrations from Original Photogra, by Vida Hunt Francis, and a map. 2 volumes. svo. et $5.00, DAVID GARRICK AND HIS CIRCLE By MRS. CLEMENT PARSONS A life of the greatest of English actors, a record of his triumphs, a study of his methods, and also a broad picture of the social life of the day. #vo. 32 tlustrations. Net $2.75 PRINCESSES AND COURT LADIES By ARVEDE BARINE Author of “La Grand ademoiselle,"’ etc. The stories of hy ‘ladies who played impor tant roles in the at world, full of romantic interest, vividly picturesque and written with easy grace and vivacity. *vo. Iustrated. Net, $2.00 Or. 810. B14 ¥. #10. , 50, #7 .40 Cr. #v0. #71.50 #740 OF. #00, 87,40 (rown Net 27 @ 29 W. 25d St., NEW YORK G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS LONDON, 24 Bedford St., Strand
Page 5
The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, OCTUBER 25, 1906. The Week. Among President Roosevelt’s new ap- pointments for the Cabinet, that of Mr. Cortelyou for the Treasury will prob- ably excite the most interest. In that important post Mr. Cortelyou will nec- essarily be an experiment. That he possesses high executive ability, has been demonstrated in the other Cabinet offices which he has held. Whether he is fitted to grapple with the large ques- tions of fiscal policy or expedient, which confront the head of the Treasury now and will probably be still more urgent and vexatious in the next three years, is another matter. Of financial train- ing, in the sense in which the term is used among business men, he has had none. This lack of experience is not a futal defect; Gallatin, for example, was one of our ablest ministers of finance. We cannot help feeling regret, however, that, at a time when the ques- tion of currency reform is coming to a crisis, and when the relations between the Treasury and the market have been complicated by Secretary Shaw’s over- stepping of the letter of the law, the new incumbent should not be a man whose experience and matured financial opinions would in themselves command unquestioned respect. As for the other ay pointments, that of Oscar S. Straus, as head of the Department of Commerce and Labor, is easily the best. Mr. Straus made an admirable Minister to Turkey; through his connection with the Civic Federation he has been brought into contact with labor leaders and labor questions. Of his broad view of com- mercial questions, there can be no doubt. Moreover, he can be relied upon to deal with immigration questions in a sympa- thetic spirit. But the best thing is that his appointment places in the Cabinet one of the foremost advocates of peace and arbitration in this or any country. George von L. Meyer will make a dili- gent Postmaster-General; but it is chief- ly to his wealth and social alliances that he owes political prominence. The navy may suffer from the transfer of Mr. Bonaparte, an excellent secretary, to the Attorney-Generalship. Mr. Metcalf served on the Naval Committee of the House, but has otherwise no_ special qualifications as successor to Mr. Bona- parte. The proposal to lend Government mo- ney on security of cotton—gravely set forth in a speech to the Bankers’ Conven- tion at St. Louls—we are inclined to re- gard as one of the first-fruits of Secre- tary Shaw’s recént policy. A few weeks ago the New York bankers wanted to The rate of low enough, if they paid interest on the mo- the import gold from London. exchange being then not quite ney involved, to make operation profitable, the bankers appealed to Mr Shaw to lend them Government money for nothing. He promptly did so. There was no pretence that the Treasury was in any way benefited by the importa- tion; there was no assertion even that the Government was restoring to circu- lation money withdrawn by its surplus revenue; for, by the terms of Mr. Shaw's arrangement, the loan of public money was to be repaid at once when the gold arrived. Now comes Charles J. Haden of Atlanta, with his plea to the bankers for loans of Government funds to move the cotton crop. “Why,” Mr. Haden asks, “should we not call upon the Gov- ernment for aid, as do the gambling- stricken banks when fren- zied speculation?” In our own old-fash- ioned opinions about the use of public moneys, we can discover a dozen reasons why such a call should meet with re- fusal, the chief reason being that the placing of Government funds at the ser- vice of private business enterprises is demoralizing to all parties concerned. Put Secretary Shaw is certainly estop- ped from using that argument. pressed by The conviction of the Standard Oil Company, in an Ohio court, for conspir- acy, is virtually a triumph for President Keosevelt, since the United States Attor- ney-General collected most of the evi- cence. The Anti-Trust law of Ohio makes every day of continuation in an illegal Trust a separate offence, with a possible fine of $5,000. ly imposed would go far to restore the pretty well shattered hope that the fine is an effectual deterrent to corporate of- fenders. But the effect of such a ver- dict cannot be measured in dollars and cents. It represents the triumph of the law over the most dangerous and cyni- cal of industrial corporations. We re- tain our belief that there is very limited help for present evils in mulcting those fictitious and fabulously wealthy person- alities we call Trusts. We note that Jack the Giant Killer struck not at the pockets, but at the necks, of his foes. When we see a few high managers of criminal corporations wearing prison garb we shall be within hailing distance cf real reform. We may at least re- joice heartily at the good beginning the law has made with the Standard Oil Company. If it is not difficult to fine its legal entity, there is probably some way also of getting at the real conspira- Such a penalty rigorous- tors behind the charter “It is not possible to defend a rebate case In the present state of popular opin ion.” Thus the counsel of the New York Central, at the conclusion of the trial in which the railway was convicted of giving rebates to the Sugar Trust Plainly, no defence was possible in that case. The offence was too flagrant: the proof too conclusive. The Central delib erately violated the law in the devil may-care spirit of the sandbagger. Yet railroad officials wonder that there is a strong prejudice against their compa- nies, and that Government ownership plans enlist the support not only of demagogues, but of sober men We re gard the conviction of the Central as one of the most important judicial events in years. It will call a halt on dishonest railroad managers the coun try over Naturally, Mr. Hearst was quick to make use of the verdict in his campaign He the platform at Plattsburgh and read the dispatch announcing “his”’ He was entitled to do so. for the Attorney General has testified that his informa- tion and proof came from Mr. Hearst's lawyers. This public service must be written down to Mr. Hearst's credit. The incident shows plainly enough why it is that the cries of the agitator and prom- ises of the demagogue no longer pass as unnoticed as the daily of the streets modestly appeared on victory noise At the meeting of the New England Association of Colleges and Preparatory Schools, West of Princeton spoke on “The Tutorial System,” which year ago in his col lege. He that at first the dents regarded the plan with amuse- ment and curiosity, and were rather shy of their new instructors, but that they have since learned to appreciate the ad- vantages of supervision and direction in their work. They are pleased with the arrangement, which “is now becom- ing a part of the college tradition.”” Dur- ing the year the library has been con- sulted as never before. There has also been improvement in discipline. Pro fessor West's allusion to the previous state of things might give an impres sion that there has been a change from comparative barbarism to civilization “No longer are there roving bands of students on the campus in the evening, but quiet reigns, and lights are seen in study windows.” Anything which could have this effect in so short a time is Professor was introduced a stated atu amazingly beneficial. The mere intro duction into Princeton of fifty young university graduates, most of whom have won distinction in some particu lar branch of learning, has been a stim ulus to both professors and students But as President Hadley of Yale, who
Page 6
340 Nation. The
[Vol. 83, No. 2156
likes the plan, pointed out not long ago, it is undeniably expensive. The endow- ment required is $2,500,000—a large sum to invest in any academic experiment. Five hundred English teachers, divid- ed into small squads, will begin an in- vasion of this country next month. They all grades, from the kinder- garten to the university. This enter- prise, like previous the same kind, is engineered by Sir Alfred Mose- is to familiarize English educators with systems which he re- guards as superior to their own. “The American boy,” he more than once, “is far better fitted for the battle with the world than is the English youth when he leaves school.” Sir Al- fred Mosely adds the further explana tion that “with Americans education is mostly along practical lines: with the English it is along the classical.” In- dubitably our educators have been less bound by tradition: they have more freely tried experiments, and naturally with studies that may be immediately useful in business or the trades. With- out denying that these commercial courses are of some value, we may doubt whether always supply a mental discipline equal to that of the classics which they replace. If stimulating the mind rather than directly imparting hnowledge be the aim of education, the represent ones of ly. His object has said they “practical” studies, with their appeal to | the stomach, may be overdone Our English visitors will, we trust, re member that in the eighteenth century and the first two-thirds of the nine- teenth, Americans, even under the handi cap of the studies which Sir Alfred Mosely distrusts, still managed to get on fairly well. The English observers roay also discover that with such oppor- success as Amer- easily tunities for material lea offers, bovs who are trained in the old classical curriculum, or according ic the latest plan of our new schools of commerce, or who have escaped pret- ivy much all formal teaching, still win their victories in the battle of life Dr. Pierre Janet of Paris, who is now lecturing to the Harvard medical stu- cents, has had a long experience in the vards of Salpetri@re, and is the author fa works on pevcholory and pathology. Hysteria” is the subject of the present a subject upon which he has al- number of important nervous course ready published a formal treatise, as well as clinical reports of much value it Is to be wished that he might resume tefore American audiences the discus sion of hypnotism and of dual personal its which awakened intense’ interest rearly twenty vears ago In his “L’Auto matisme Psvchologique.’ His explana tion of certain obscure cases of “the couble self,” by supposing a disintegra of consciousness, Is obviously open but in his hands it furnish tion to criticism:
ed a conception of the real process in- volved, and in particular gave men of science a working hypothesis with which to approach further investigations. That there are too many scientific congresses is the complaint of a writer in the Revue Scientifique. While iso- lation is a bad thing for the man of science, and while it is essential to his usefulness and reputation that he should at times compare notes with his col- leagues, much time, labor, and money are wasted by the multiplicity of these as- concrete example of the is furnished by the its report of the One of the semblies. <A incidental abuses same periodical, in Medical Congress at Lisbon. chief evils was the diversity of lan- guage. The reports were distributed so tardily that members of the congress had no time in which to prepare them- selves to speak. There were too many reports relating to the same subject, which gave rise to tiresome repetitions. Much time was lost in attending fétes and other entertainments. Moreover, a number of eminent men failed to ap- pear personally, and their papers were read for them by others. Yet the de- sire of attending congresses is keen, and it would be cruel to deprive even mod- est scientists of opportunities to be heard, or to prevent their hearers from manifesting the Christian graces of pa- tience and long-suffering. There is need of better education among the light-fingered gentry who cut pictures from their frames. That their taste is backward and their judgment doubtful has been recently shown in several instances. We have small pa- tience with the adventurer who has just risked State’s prison for the sake of a Meyer von Bremen in the Cincinnati Museum. To choose such a thing when better was to be had suggests an un- interference of sentiment with strict business. Even the successful ab- ductors of the Gainsborough Duchess got. after all, only a more than dubious even if their idea of commer- advertising values seems to have been excellent. In general, how- ever, picture-stealing can hardly rank as a fine art. Safe-cracking seems fair- iy an intellectual occupation in compar- iron. Evidently there are obstacles to conducting picture-stealing on a purely basis Commercial considera- tions must rightly rule. Morevver, the finest and most renowned pictures can hardly be stolen to advantage, being dif- Such considerations must happy picture, cial and artistic ficult to sell excuse much that may seem crude in an essentially liberal occupation. To astute riuseum directors, the debased state of the picture-stealing profession affords an Every mu- unexampled opportunity. | scum should create at least one gallery
of paintings that can be spared. A deaf mute, preferably blind also, should be chosen as custodian, and upon the door- post might hang conspicuously a pair of shears. Clemenceau’s reorganization of the French Ministry calls for little comment, except for the assignment of the war portfolio to Gen. Picquart. This is one of those rare instances in which prac- tical politics and poetic justice meet. In a sense, the appointment is a defiance rot merely to moribund Nationalism, but to the more respectable Moderate and Clerical sentiment that was on the wrong side of the affaire Dreyfus. It is a gauge of uncompromising Radicalism, and will be hailed with expectant rejoic- ing by the Socialists also. Otherwise, the Cabinet remains much what it was. M. Briand retains the portfolio of Edu- cation and ‘Worship, which promises that the Separation act will be carried into effect without faltering, and yet without bigotry or unnecessary proscrip- tion. No French Cabinet for many years has been complete without a So- cialist member, and now M. Viviani ac- cepts the newly created Ministry of La- bor. M. Pichon, the new Foreign Minis- ter, is Resident-General in Tunis, and has been associated with the colonial and diplomatic service in the Far East. A former colleague of Clemenceau’s on La Justice, he presumably represents the progressive colonialism so deeply desir- ed on the boulevards, tempered, how- ever, by humanitarian and socialistic scruples. It may fairly be assum- ed that the Foreign Office will continue the present policy of conciliation with ell and of positive friendship with Eng- land and Italy. It is premature to offer a forecast of the Clemenceau régime, but in general it may be said that it usually goes ill with a Warwick pro- moted to the throne. A man of states- manlike parts, Clemenceau is evidently relentless towards the Reactionaries and Moderates. Having already shown him- self, in the post-office strike, too much ef an authoritarian to please the So- cialists, his middle course will clearly be a difficult one to steer. The British Admiralty, by turning out the greatest battleship ever seen, with turbine engines and the phenomenal speed of 23 knots an hour, has com- pletely upset American arf’ Continental theories that the turbines were unsuit- ed to warships. Now the Admiralty an- nounces that the three so-called armor- ed cruisers building on the Clyde are rot cruisers at all, but battleships, with as heavy broadside fire as the Dread- nought, and of four knots greater speed. Indeed, these three vessels will actually be seven knots faster than any Amert- can, German, or French battleships, as
Page 7
Oct. 25, 1906] a speed of 27 knots is confidently ex- pected on their trials. Only one or two of our battleships can make 20 knots; the bulk of them average 17 under ser- vice conditions. In other words, the English designers have borne out the prophets who have been looking forward to the day when the distinction between the armored cruiser and the‘ battleship would cease to be. Our Navy Depart- ment, which has been for a year plan- ning to outdo the Dreadnought, finds itself compelled to readapt its plans in accordance with the designs of the new English battleships. As a sort of con- sclation, the American experts are try- ing to figure out that their twelve-inch guns are about the same as the British in size and ballistic qualities. From that there is but little satisfaction to be | cbtained, for the truth is that, by the revolutionary speed obtained for her new battleships, England has more than ever emphasized her naval superiority. No matter how much her naval rivals may strive to imitate her, England can always get ahead of them by her ability to build, equip, and send to sea a great battleship fully a year before a vessel started in any other country at the same time. The United States is not the only country in which protection is steadily making life harder for the laboring man. In Germany the price of meat has gone up so much that thousands of people are no longer able to purchase any. When prices jumped a year ago, there was a great outcry. The only re- sponse from theGovernment was a state- ment from the Minister of the Interior that the trouble was temporary, due to a bad crop year. Nevertheless, the price of meat has continued to rise, so that there is genuine suffering. A beef steer which cost $32.45 in Berlin in July, 1904, cost $34.40 in July, 1905, and $36.87 in July of this year. On the 29th of Sep- tember last, the price had risen to $41.75. The price of pork has gone up correspondingly. The Berlin Tageblatt proves conclusively that this is due not merely to the increase of population, as the Government has alleged, but that there has been a marked falling off in the possible supply. It points out that, instead of doing something to help the poor by making it easy to import cat- tle from abroad, the Government, at the bidding of the Agrarians, is doihg ev- erything it can to make importations more difficult. In 1895 the importation of Danish hogs was stopped. This was followed in 1900 by the prohibition of all imports of sausage and canned meats. In 1904, there was the edict against American hogs, and in the same year a ban upon hogs and ruminants from France, Belgium, Holland, and England. In the meanwhile, more stringent health regulations bave made | then. The Nation. it even more difficuit to import cattle on the hoof. This year have come in- creased tariffs on cattle and meat. It is obvious, therefore, that the situation is getting worse rather than better. While the Dutch are dis- cussing ways and ultimate absorption seriously means of averting by Germany, now | that hope of a direct successor to the throne seems to have been abandoned, the Belgians, too, are growing panicky in face of the Pan-Germanic movement. The French press in Belgium is greatly exercised over a plan recently on foot by the German part of the popula- tion to secure legal recognition of their native tongue. In 1900 the number of German-speaking inhabitants was only 2 per cent. of the total; but the ratio may have increased somewhat The claim is based on the con- stitutional right enjoyed by every Bel- gian to make use of his native lan- guage in his relations with the educa- tional, administrative, and judicial de- partments of the Government. Admit- ting, however, their numerical weak- ness, the Germans declare that they will be content with an official recogni- tion of their rights without seeking to have them enforced. The Flemish rep- resentatives in the Chamber, contrary to common expectation, have come out against the demands of the German-Bel- gians, possibly because they are con- vinced of the necessity of offering a check to German aspirations in general. set since The head that wears a crown may be au very good head for business. In the attacks upon Leopold II. of Belgium, in bis relation to the Congo Free State, tresh revelations continue to be made. Next to the notorious Abir Rubber Com- pany, the most prosperous corporation in the Congo is the Kasai Company, in which the State, that is to say, King Leopold, owns half of the stock. The State exacts its tax from the natives in the form of rods of copper, shaped like a St. Andrew's cross, which the Government receives at a valuation of one and a quarter francs apiece. But these crosses are only to be purchased from the Kasai Company, to which the Government sells them at three and one- nalf francs apiece, and which in turn makes a handsome profit on the sale to the natives. In other words, the State receives three and a half francs for a cross which it takes back at one and a cuarter francs, and in addition, as half- partner in the Kasai Company, shares in the profit on the subsequent sale of the copper. Compared with the King of Pelgium, Abdul Hamid II. appears posi- tively beneficent. The Sultan is the controlling spirit of a land company operating in the Mesopotamian valley, where it has been expropriating the richest sections. This is accomplished 341 ty manipulation of the water supply The peasant “must make the best terms le can with the man who can at will cut him off from all irrigation. He sells his land for a song.” In applying the latest Trust methods to high commerce advantage to If with the royal functions goes the spiritual head distinct be a monarch of some sort ‘i is evidently a ship over faithful millions, so much the better. Thus the Sultan under compulsion from anti-Trust laws to vest is no the ownership of his land in a holding company, say, at Samarcand or Zanz bar. In a book recently published, Dr Rinet-Sanglé tries to show that the He brew prophets from Samuel to Malachi were insane. Since certain critics doubt the historical it the prophets of the patriarchs, reassuring to be told that lived even if they of if the Oriental language and imagery of the Hebrew seers are taken literally, there are pas sages in their writings which are not conformed to the every-day experiences or even of Frenchmen Their visions may be interpreted as hallucinations, their denunciation of their enemies as violence, and their ap- prehensions of coming disaster as delu sions. But upon such a principle, many modern poets might be consigned to the peychopathic ward, while Dante, Milton end Bunyan would, like Jeremiah and Ezekiel, be put in the class of aliénés In both ancient and mediwval times, genius and insanity were thought to be allied. Dryden expressed that idea in his fameus epigram. Of late years such a belief has found support In the writ ings of I#lut, Moreau, Lombroso, Nes bit, and others, who contend that extra ordinary mental ability Is an evidence of a But there are strong general reasons for thinking it improbable that what goes by the name of genius is a morbid characteristic While it has never been asserted that insanity is a mark of genius, it would seem that, if genius is a mark of insan ity, there should be signs of high Inte! lectual and moral inspiration among the great numbers confined in asylums Kut with the exception of craft and cunning, qualities of an _ intellectual kind are singularly lacking in those un- fortunates. Even the insane who can still reason, but whose premises are the result of delusion, seldom show even a spark of the divine fire. It is natura! that all eyes should be directed towards conspicuous defects and aberrations in the character of men who have great In tellectual and emotional endowments But as one of the most eccentric vet most brilliant philosophers has sald. such men are like Mont Blanc, which lifts I's shining head above the clouds which darken its slopes. reality is almost etually were mad course of Americans, diseased brain
Page 8
342 VEW LIGHT ON EUROPEAN DIPLO- MACY. The real importance of the Hohen- lohe “Memoirs,” it now appears, lies in the exposure of German diplomacy about the time the Franco-Russian al- liance was ping! Almost equally im- portant is the explanation of German foreign policy for twenty years past as consistently anti-liberal, monarchical, and pro-Russian. Indubitable testimony bears out surmises in this tenor, and the general belief that France was be- fooled by Russia, and Austria and Italy ignored by the initiator of the Triple Alliance, receives striking confirmation Ex-Minister Lockroy, speaking at Rome last Sunday, urged the Italian lranco phile party to associate Italy with the Anglo-French entente, as a means of as- suring “the triumph of democratic prin- ciples in Europe.’ Undoubtedly, the sentiment to which he appealed will be greatly strengthened among French, English, and Italian readers of the Ho- henlohe revelations The league vf three Emperors— Drei kaiserbund—was a favorite dream of William I It was to be a sort of lim- ited Holy Alliance against democracy, Socialism, and liberalism of all sorts. On November 2, 1884, the old Kaiser, com- menting on Joseph Chamberlain's plan to create peers enough to pass the fran- chise bill, remarked that, if republi- can tendencies got the upper hand in England, “we shall have hard work keeping our places.” It was this feel- ing that dictated the so-called “reinsur- ance” with Russia, which is in moral effect to-day By this secret agreement, Russia was to have a free hand in the Balkans, agreeing to maintain neutral- ity in case of war between Germany and France. The agreement calmly ig- nored the claims of Italy and Austria in European Turkey; and, as Caprivi remarked when he refused to renew the treaty, in 1891, “if it had become known, it would have broken up the Triple Al- liance.”” The treaty lapsed, but the spir- it which gave it validity persisted till the eve of the Franco-Russian alliance Indeed, the most interesting, and glar- ingly indisereet, portion of the “Me- moira” is the account of Hohenlohe'’s conversations with the Czar and other high Russian officials, just before Nich olas Il spectacular visit to Paris in the fall of 1896 On an earlier occasion, Lobanoff. the Russian Chancellor, told Hohenlohe that Kiussia “did Europe a good service by taking up France. God knows what these people might have gone and done it they had not been reined in.” Natur ally, Nicholas Il. never committed him- self in quite the cynical terms of his confidential adviser, but he took pains, nevertheless, to explain away the Paris visit. Speaking with Hohenlohe in Sep. tember, 1896, the Czar “mentioned that Nation. ‘The Le had not spoken to the Emperor about Paris, and he asked me if I had any ob- jection to his visit to Paris. He was pleased when I replied that the visit to Paris seemed to me to be ‘inevitable.’ He laid stress upon the fact that he had declined to put up at the Quai d'Orsay, or anywhere else in Paris. He was go- ing to stay at his own embassy, like all Lis predecessors.” In view of the furore created by the Paris visit, this attempt to minimize it is of curious interest. But France wanted an ally, and Russia a lanker, and the part the Czar played in this exchange of French money for Rus- sian amiabilities did not require deep | conviction on the part of the leading centleman. All the remarks of the Czar at this time are of considerable political inter- est. Discussing tentative overtures from Fingland, he fully agreed with Hohen- lohe that “the English Constitution and the account which English ministers lave to take of public opinion made it impossible to conclude treaties with England.” In view of the Anglo-Jap- anese alliance and the Anglo-French en- tente, these words are worth recalling; | and since the opirion of the Czar can hardly have altered, they throw a cer- tain light, also, on the prospects for an understanding between England and Russia. On the other hand, the Czar discredited the favorite bugbear of the I-nglish Russophobes, the advance on India. On Hohenlohe’s remarking that the British activity in South Africa was really impelled by the dread of some day losing India, the Czar replied: “Yes, Lut who is going to take India from them? We are not so stupid as to pur- sue a design of that sort.” These words should be kept standing by every en- lightened newspaper in England, for use whenever the periodical Russian ague effiicts the young lions of the press. Certain remarks of the Czar look for- ward to the war in Manchuria, if only by implication. He liked the Japanese, i.e told Hohenlohe. Everything he had seen in Japan had greatly impressed him. . He had been struck by _ the great orderliness, activity, and intel- ligence of the population “But this sympathy,” he added, “has not kept me from acting against the Japanese when they have gone too far.” No doubt ef his ability to check them had en- tered his head. He further declared that Japan was arming at a great rate, but had no resources except the Chi- rese war indemnity. “When these were exhausted, he could not think how they were going to complete their military preparations. Besides, they would take years to do it, and by that time the Siberian railway would be ready, and then Russia would be in a position de faire face a toutes éventualités.” Evi- dently, the financial reckonings of Rus- sia were no better than her military forecasts. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 We need not enlarge upon the pathetic interest of these reports of the views ef the youthful Czar. They throw light upon the unwritten covenant between Cermany and Russia, and explain the cynastic sympathy that found such strik- ing expression during the war in the Far East. When Nicholas II. took leave of Hohenlohe in September, 1896, he used these furprising words: “Tell the Kaiser to continue to write to me personally vben he has anything to communicate.” Such a message, we venture to think, has rarely been transmitted to a potentate through his Prime Minister. Perhaps the chief value of the memoirs is the revelation of the importance of such cynastic sympathies—an influence which liberal governments are prone to under- estimate or even to regard as obsolete. Fut the spectacle which Prince Hohen- lohe affords of the arbiters of Ger- many and Russia either scorning or aeceiving pretty much all the rest of Europe, is certainly calculated to in- crease the diplomatic isolation of Ger- many. One can hardly wonder that the Kaiser wants the present Prince Hohen- lehe’s resignation, or that the Prince plans to spend his remaining years in the salubrious climate of the French Kiiviera. THE NEWFOUNDLAND FISHERIES AGREEMENT. According to our new modus vivendi with England respecting the Newfound- land fisheries, the English Government will “not bring into force” (that is, will temporarily disallow) the “Newfound- land Foreign Fishing Vessels Act, 1906,” imposing additional restrictions upon American shipmasters. It also consents to the use of purse seines by American fishermen during the coming season, though “due regard” is to be “paid, in the use of such implements, to other modes of fishery.” On its part, the American Government undertakes to di- rect American fishing vessels to conform to the Colonial customs law and harbor regulations, “when physically possible to do so.” This will cause the Captains Courageous of Gloucester to take fresh courage; also, we fancy, to indulge in fresh laughter. Further, our Govern- ment, while maintaining the right to ship Newfoundlanders, has “assured his Majesty’s Government that such ship- ments, if found necessary, will be made at a sufficient distance beyond the three- mile limit.” These provisions make the wrath of the Newfoundlanders, concerning which we have heard so much in the dispatches from St. John’s, wholly intelligible. They regard their entire herring fishery as imperilled. They made in 1905 what they believed to be a perfectly fair con- vention—the Hay-Bond treaty—to se- cure reciprocal rights in the fisheries. But this, our Senate refused to ratify, Sot aise ot np
Page 9
Oct. 25, 1906] The Nation. Lodge taking the lead against that Ad- ministration measure. Thereupon, New- foundland set about defending her in- terests. As our intensely American ship- masters, in their patriotic efforts to make their fishing fleet a “nursery of American sailors,” are in the habit of shipping great numbers of Blue Noses, at low wages, the Newfoundland Legis- lature passed an act providing that “no British subject shall leave the colony for the purpose of joining a foreign vessel to fish in its waters’; also, more explicitly, that “no British subject shall fish in any foreign fishing vessel in the yvaters of this colony.” The act likewise forbade the selling or ieasing of “fishing gear,” of any kind, to foreign fishing vessels. Prohibition of purse seines has been the law in Newfoundland for twen- ty-five years. It is believed to be neces- sary if the herring are not to be made as scarce as mackerel have been, by the use of purse seines. Indeed, since the announcement of the agreement, the fishermen of both nationalities on the spot have consented to give up this method of fishing. Thus that clause of the modus is abandoned by its Leneficiaries. With regard to the obli- gation of American vessels to enter and clear at the colonial custom-houses, and to submit to inspection, it is main- tained by the Newfoundland authorities that only by such means can they be assured that the schooners are really American. No others have the treaty right to fish in colonial waters, and the colony asserts that it is in duty bound to board vessels and make sure that they are not smugglers or pirates. Very naturally, the disallowing of this legislation has caused great excite- ment and indignation in St. John’s. There was talk of the Ministry resign- ing in a body, as a protest, after the fashion of the Government of Cape Col- But the final decision was to re- ony. main in office and fight the matter through. Every colonial statute en- forceable against American vessels will Le employed. It was even proposed to re- peal the law forbidding colonial fisher- men to use purse seines, the idea be- ing that the local fishermen would thus be able to anticipate the Americans, and take practically all the annual catch in the Bay of Islands. But that would only drive Lodge and the other tariff- dodgers into new devices for buying the herring of Newfoundlanders, and then having them entered free of duty at Gloucester as “the product of American fisheries.” All this friction, however, but accen- the need of following up the modus vivendi with a comprekensive treaty, fair to both Newfoundland and New England, thus putting to rest a question that has troubled our diplo- macy for many years. Secretary Root has expressed the determination to clear up, if possible, every pending controversy tuates with England. This fisheries dispute is the most vexing of all. That the English has temporary of inflam- subjects, is an of on that We but hope, therefore, that the modus vivendi which Government made great concessions, even at the cost its earnest will ing own zood side can is but the precursor of a treaty will fair enough | to of Senator enough and the Lodge, and to remove forever a cause of | ill natural friends. be broad withstand assaults feeling between | ficing WANTED The customary A NATIONAL GALLERY. with its mat Burlington Magazine, enthusiasm in ters, urges editorially the creation of a museum Washington under the administration of the Smithsonian Although the scheme is advocated with national gallery at nonchalant hopefulness as means, it its favor. location aA somewhat has intrinsical- | Washington is the natural for a gallery of American art—a museum that should not merely display the art of the past, to ways and ly much in but should encourage that of the pres ent, becoming a sort of American Lux- embourg. Such a project has been fre quently mooted, but have been taken, partly because the fine arts have never had influential advo- cates at Washington, partly, perhaps, because the Corcoran Gallery, a private foundation, seemed to occupy the field. A judicial decision, however, has revived interest in the artistic function or the Smithsonian By its character it is empowered to collect and exhibit objects of art and of curiosity. 3efore the fire of 1865 it able collections; it now possesses the important print of the late | G. P. Marsh; has accepted the reversion of C. L. collection of | American and Japanese paintings; and. | no practical steps recent Institution had consider- collection Freer’s splendid by the court decision already noted, be comes the keeper of the art collection ot the late Harriet Lane Johnston. So | far as the organization of an art partment goes, the Smithsonian has no conspicuous connoisseur on its staff, but it already represents in an eminent de- gree the cautious scholarship. that should preside over such an enterprise On grounds of economy, too, the Smithsonian is the natural body to cre ate a national gallery. In the projected National Museum building, an art de partment could be accommodated for many years to come. Thus money which on any other basis must be spent upon a separate building, could be devoted to acquisitions. And in the present rapidly rising art market, money in hand has threefold purchasing power. Since the Smithsonian has no funds for such a new departure, the scheme for a na tional gallery depends entirely upon the generosity of Congress. But one can hardly doubt that a plan at once in- expensive, intrinsically desirable, and de | of the enormous endowment | be conservative, | make a handsome appropriation of | collect ion ly doubt | tution will magnify its own function and | ‘es of non-American 343 putriotic would make a strong appeal to no question here that believe our law-makers It is a gen the to requires. We Burlington when it eral museum estimate of the Vagazine the rent budget for both administration and fixes cur purchases at $25,000 annually. It should that if the American art be recalled museum concen trates upon the usual ex pensive staff will be unnecessary, a cur ator-director with proper assistance suf how It would be very important cver, that Congress should at the outset gay $100,000, in order to found the historical The prices of old American painting and sculpture are rising, and money now will save multiplied expenditure in the future. We can hard that, if the Smithsonian Inst! spent its own cause vigorously, Congress funds plead vote the necessary Why gallery will gladly It might aims of a to bition of American We frunkly, because an American the the exhi be asked, restrict national art? answer, museum because it is more urgently needed, night exert a useful influence upon our art and our standards of taste. and, finally, because the limited and patriotic appeal is far more likely to gain the support of Congress. To rival the Met ropolitan Museum without adequate funds would be very foolish. The Cor coran Gallery is an instructive exam ple of the drawbacks of conducting a museum in a capital on an income adapt ed only to provincial requirements If Congress would appropriate a matter of a half-million maintain a comprehensive museum, that annually to would be worth while, but the modest plan sug “ested above seems more likely to be carried out. Of course a national gal gift acquire many exam We called that the Smithsonian already has lery would by art. have re a representative collection of European engraving, and is to possess a rare col- of the finest painting of China end Japan Undoubtedly, the general collections would be similarly enriched as time went on. In fact, the prestige of such a national museum would from the first bring it gifts In abundance. No one, for example, could make a more dignified disposal of heirlooms of paint. ing, while artists and their friends would naturally seek the honor of rep- resentation on its walls. The funds would properly be spent in buying the pictures of the younger artists of tal ent; the veterans—at least the successful ones—could fairly be counted on to contribute by gift or bequest Evidently the director of such a mu- seum should be an enthusiast for Amer ican art, but it would be highly unfor tunate if he were nothing more than that. He should be familiar also with the best art of all periods. What the lection more
Page 10
The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 3844 production of our modern studios needs most is to be judged, apart from pa- rochial applause, by something like a universal standard. In fact, the most important function of a national gal- lery might well be the creation of a sound national taste. Not only would a director at Washington be fortunately remote from the promptings of the artis- tie cliques, but he would find a body of spectators singularly receptive to any lesson he might choose to address to their eyes. There is no city in Amer- ica where travellers go so frequently merely “for to see, and for to admire.” A collection of the finest works that American artists have produced, or are producing, could from Washington ex- tend an educating and refining influence to the remotest hamlet in the land. The realization of such a dream depends ap- rerently upon the zeal of the regents of the Smithsonian Institution and upon the good will of Congress. MUTE, INGLORIOUS LITERATURE. William Butler Yeats returns to a fa- vorite and suggestive theme in his es- say on “Literature and the Living Voice” in the Contemporary Review He maintains that the nerveless quality of much modern writing is due to the fact that literature, like the proverbial good child, is seen but not heard. Re- calling the days when the minstrel still held his own against the scribe, Mr. Yeats bids Ireland, which still repre- sents “the old world that sang and lis- tened,” resist to the last “the world that reads and writes.” More practically, he hopes first for a revival of the habit of recitation, especially by authors, and believes that the popular stage, like his own unique enterprise at Dublin, may again become a place where the people hear the best literature, learning the poets not from the inexpressive page, tut from the living voice of skilled in- terpreters Mr. Yeats’s peculiar theories of can- tilating verse have excited considerable comment The presence of the great diseuse, Mme. Yvette Guilbert, among us is evidence enough that there is be- tween singing and recitation an oppor- tunity for great art. That this art Is generally communicable, we doubt; and we hardly expect to see even in Ireland poets who habitually practise recitative to the rote or some modern equivalent or a guild of minstrels who declaim sonorously to the dulcimer. But if Mr. Yeats’s remedy for the widespread pov- erty of atyle seems fanciful, he has at least done much to explain a prevailing anemia in modern literature. It may fairly be maintained that only of late years has the eye been the sole medium of literary enjoyment. When books were comparatively few, and the habits of readers leisurely, even silent perusal was undoubtedly accompanied by a sub- consciousness of the sound of the voice. If there is one quality more marked than another in Elizabethan poetry, it ‘s that it was always a heard thing. It must have rung alluring in the ears of its authors; to-day, it rouses any but the most inert reader to break silence and give voice to its splendid cadences. With the great romantic writers, Byron, Shelley, and Keats in England, Lamar- tine, Chateaubriand, and Hugo in Trance, the case was the same. Their periods crave utterance, and can be ap- rreciated only dimly by those who have no consciousness of the sound. When the change came about and readers lost the use of the inner ear, is matter of simple conjecture. It evi- dently hangs upon the enormous mod- ern production of books, and the habit of silent reading. The hypothesis that most books of the last fifty years have been written by deaf people for deaf people would explain many things. It would throw some light on the admit- ted saplessness of current French prose. Possibly the average review article, with all its erudition and keenness, is pale and monotonous simply because it was never heard or mednt to be heard. Like a muted instrument, such a style has neither legato nor accent. And that is the prose of the day, whether you look to France, Germany, Italy, or, nearer home, to England and America. Every- where the same respectable, lifeless, in- sipid product. Certain scholars in Ger- many have recommended that school children be taught not to pronounce mentally when reading, because more ground may be covered the other way. The prevalence of such literary deafness would go far to account for the present condition of polite letters beyond the khine, though the defect is well-nigh universal. To recall the exceptional modern writ- ers who are in any sense eloquent, is, we believe, to name those who hear their writings and desire that others should hear them. D’Annunzio, Anatole France, Thomas Hardy, are of this type, where- as one might confidently assert that Togazzaro, Bourget, and Mrs. Humphry Ward compose without auditory satis- taction of any sort. The distinction is presumably psychological and funda- mental. Just as memories are classed as visual or verbal, so minds are audi- tory or the contrary, tending in the first ense to associate sound and sense, in he second to eliminate sound altogether. A reader of an introspective sort tells us that in reading poetry he habitual- ly recites it mentally, whereas he sel- dom hears prose at all, but occasionally {s checked by an instinct that a passage is finely cadenced, in which case he rolls it lovingly under his mental tongue. Eloquent verse will stimulate the in- audible recitation to an actual whisper, or even a croon. This appears to be a case of a good—that is to say, an audi- tory—reader, forced into the deaf, or merely ocular, class by a large bulk of duty-reading that must be done at high speed. The future of literature depends largely upon writers and readers who are in some fashion obedient to the liv- ing voice, and it is one of the most para- doxical instances of the prevailing in- tellectual confusion that, just as paint- ing is striving to attain to the vague- ness of musical expression, literature is disavowing its natural ally, indeed, its proper medium, the human voice. On natural principle of flux and re- flux, one may expect a return to the bet- ter way. We may not see again a Virgil and a Cesar weeping together -at a pri- vate reading, but may fairly hope for some reaction against the present surd- ity. Fortunately, the habit of mental audition can be cultivated, and writers will find their practical account in test- ing their product vocally. Similarly, readers who insist that the ear be satis- fied as well as the mind are already in a manner critics. In fact, criticism in the genuine sense can hardly exist on any other basis. The point may seem to some narrowly rhetorical, but it is a case where an improvement in the form must infallibly work an improvement in the substance also. Here Mr. Yeats brings indubitable testimony when he describes the results of rewriting his plays for popular audiences. He says: Every one who has to interest his audi- ence through the voice discovers that his success depends upon the clear, simple, and varied structure of his thought. 1 have written a good many plays in verse and prose, and almost all those plays I have rewritten after performance, some- times again and again, and every change that has succeeded has been an addition to the masculine element, an increase of strength in the bony structure. It is precisely this access of “bony struc- ture” that modern literature most needs, and while Mr. Yeats has verse chiefly in mind, the doctrine applies with equal validity to prose, where surely the need of reform is more urgent. AN &. P. C. P. Some benevolent but misguided per- son has proposed that a society be form- ed for the prevention of cruelty to par- euts. But no such reactionary step will, we hope, be taken. Emancipation of suc- cessive classes has been a mark of hu- man progress. The spiritual control of the laity by the clergy has given place tu the government of the pulpit by the pew. Kings and emperors hold their sceptres by the favor of their subjects. And fathers and mothers are beginning to be aware that they have no rights which their children are bound to re- spect. That they should enjoy special immunities or privileges would be ab- surd. In all progress there is a class which suffers and complains. And if a lin Remnee rain A a ahd eam
Page 11
Oct. 25, 1906 parents are suffering now because their children are getting the upper hand, they should not look to any voluntary society for relie?. Unfortunately, children have neces- surily to be burdened with what Steven- son called “subsidiary parents.” Thus shades of the prison-house begin to close upon the growing boy and girl; they seek greater freedom. Their consequent rise to a place of authority in the fam- lly is in many cases the effect of their superior education. Not only have they better advantages at school than their parents had before them; they also make acquaintances who move beyond the narrow parental circle. The fathers soon learn to abdicate to sons who have been educated with social superiors; and no daughter who has been properly “fin- ished” would think of submitting her cpinions to those of her mother. Estim- able wives of political magnates or of millionaires may be dressed by the best modistes of Paris and New York; they ray have the art of giving good dinners and “smart” balls; they may do well for fashionable charities, and may even show a halting respect for the rules of grammar. But without the approval of their daughters, it profiteth them no- thing. In former days wayward children could be corrected by rebuke or chasten- ei with a rod: but now the absorbing problem in families is how best to check erring parents and encourage them to persevere on the way to social eminence. Mothers may get endorsements from their children as good housekeepers, convenient chaperons, or faithful nurses; but of the finer social practices they are too often shockingly ignorant. Oveasionally, they are trained in the way that they should go by their daughters, but “queer ideas” have a trick ef haunting the brains of unruly mat- rons. Generally, they plod on quietly and peacefully, sometimes to their own social undoing, indeed, but frequently to a pleasant, shopping, dining-out, sit- ting-out, tiara-wearing, corpulent old age, heedless of a daughter’s tears and admonitions. In view of the fact that these shortcomings are often due to congenital defects, it has been contended that children should be more indulgent. But over-indulgence on their part has hurried many parents to their rnin. As for fathers, they do not so much matter. In developed societies the pa- ternal function has not been highly spe- cialized. The father is a bread-winner, and his kingdom is not of the world fn which his children move. It is true that, with obsolete ideas of the patria po- testas, he has sometimes made a feeble stand as the purveyor of munitions for the social warfare. But by intelligent sons and daughters it has been decided that, however highly he may be esteem- ed in Wall Street, he is out of place in the rarefied air in which they live and The Nation. move and have their being. Fathers take no due interest in the weightier matters of social life. For a brief pe riod during the early childhood of their offspring they manifest a proper spirit by believing in the inspiration of the children, and by quoting their sayings as if they had been uttered at Delphi. But as a social asset, a father is of lit- tle importance. Viewed merely as a blood-relative, no indulgence should be shown to him. Even if he should re- pent his mistakes and senile follies, and declare that he will arise and go unto bis son, let there be no minstrelsy or fatted calf provided for him. In the life of the rich, some parents still seek to resemble those cur- fews incarnate in humble life who keep the girls at home and the boys out of the bar-rooms. Middle life and old age, even when money is abundant, are too hidebound to get accustomed to the manners of the new generation of young men who are old and worn be- fore they graduate, and of young women who win or lose large sums at gambling. But whether parents are young or cld, children have a right to expect from them implicit obedience. At frst this may be difficult, but, as Aristotle says, “Virtue is a habit,” and it can be acquired. No one there- fore should complain of cruelty to par- ents. The chastisement which they en- dure may be grievous, but it will finally yield the peaceable fruits of righteous- ness. There are surely enough elements of anarchy in modern society without the encouragement of parental revolt. The man who “never shook his mother” was a rude denizen of the uncultured West: he should not be held up as an example for imitation. In these days of progress, theologians well say that all infants are elect, and that the Fifth Commandment is a part of the code of primitive tribes. very A LATINIST AT A SCIENTIFIC SCHOOL Prof. Andrew F. West, who is now pres- ident-elect of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, has a high reputation as a Latinist, but is even better known as an administrator. From the beginning of his Princeton professorate, in 1883, he has been a prominent figure both in the various learn- ed in the committees on entrance requirements, He was the organizing spirit of the Prince of 1896 ured societies, and intercollegiate ete ton sesquicentennial celebration It was he who, as secretary, se as delegates more famous European than festivity scholars had ever before graced an academic America money arranging pomps, he carried out the happy innovation of having the illustrious delegates of for- eign universities deliver lectures, many of which, being of permanent value, were pub- lished as a memorial of the event. In 1901 he became dean of the Princeton Graduate School, and has had a large hand in reor- in Besides raising and these academic the | 345 ganizing a rather rudimentary department upon a genuine university basis. He was also influential in securing the excellent adjustment of the old classical cur } riculum to the new elective system, which gives Princeton a uniquely conservative po sition among American universities He favored also the new preceptorial system of personal instruction, which introduces to America a method long approved at Ox fordand Cambridge. In fine been that of a convinced thoroughly claims of the natural sciences an his attitude has classicist, yet one perceptive of the educational ithe mod ern languages. Thus his call to the leade ship of a scientific school is less paradoxi cal than it would seem Andrew F. West was born in 1853 at Al legheny, Pa., the son of a Presbyterian clergyman During his college course at Princeton, from which he was graduated tn 1874, he ship with formed that close personal friend McCosh, which years later led to the appointment to a pro of Latin at In the meantime, Mr. West taught school President nine fessorship Princeton travelled and pursued his favorite classical studies Early in the eighties he became principal of the historic Morris Academy, Morria town, N. J., languishing to a highly prosperous condi The which he in many flelds was there shown in which he soon brought from a tion enthusiasm has since evinced his personal introduction of the then new Rugby football, the of the school team, and in the zest with which he organized the school exhibitions His old college gave the degree of Ph.D. and made him a professor of Latin in 1883 being captain him In the intervals of teaching he pre- of the comedies of Ter- ence, published in 1888; and that elaborate edition of the “‘Philobiblon’’ of Richard de Bury the Club published handsomely in 1889. In this work, which re- pared an edition which Grolier mains Professor West's most congenial and antici- in of His growing attention to achievement, he of La! inists perhaps important pated the recent revival interest medieval Latin the educational problems and to the origins of humanism found in the little “Alcuin and the Rise of the Chris- (1893) A (1902) is his latest contribution to the peda- A number of articles and addresses on college subjects, especi- able of the elective system as conceived by President Eliot of attest his interest in academic theory and have increased his influence. It is for these semi-public activities quite as as for his scholarship that he has received his honorary degrees, LL.D. (Laf- ayette) and D.Litt. (Oxford). It is significant that the trustees of the Institute of Technology seek as an admini- Strator not a scientist, but a classicist of the widest general culture. They tacitly in this decision a favorite doctrine of the late President Walker, who valiantly that the curriculum of his school should be, and was actually, more humane and liberal than that of the old- style colleges. Professor West's appoint- ment should probably be interpreted in this spirit. If he accepts, he will bring to his new responsibility not merely the scholas- tic qualifications we have enumerated, but those of a personality at once astute, en- gaging, and impressive. among even severer type. expression treatise tian Schools” Latin grammar gogics of his subject ally an critique Harvard, much accept maintained
Page 12
346 BOOK NOTES FROM PARIS Paris, October 9 Now that French winds blow steadily toward a Culturkampf, books which are more than political pamphlets on the sit- vation are worth noticing The most im- portant is still the “Anticléricalisme” of Emile Faguet of the French Academy. His book is an attempt at a thorough diagnosis of the case in French society, but it is not written from the clerical point of view. A university professor, Victor Giraud, whose studies on Sainte-Beuve have made him favorably known in criticism, now publishes a short book, “Anticléricalisme et Catholi- cisme,”’ in which he tries to complete the work from the standpoint of a confirmed Catholle He reproaches M. Faguet’'s ‘‘na- tional irreligion’ with being only one side of the question, and remarks sensibly enough that there must be some religion left in France, if only to explain the vio- lence of the Anticlericals. His main con- clusion is in direct opposition with what is commonly taken for granted Politically vanquished, tracked and pro- seribed and persecuted, almost eliminated from public life and official organizations, never since Bossuet and St. Francis de Sales, perhaps not’ since the thirteenth century, has French Catholicism in reality been stronger, more fruitful, more alive Professor Giraud appeals to the present Catholic literary revival, which is as yet unheralded abroad, but which may be stud- ied in another new book, ‘‘La Littérature Keligieuse d’avant-hier et d'’aujourdhui,” by Henri Brémond, the young priest with English experience who has written the notable psychological study of Newman. From the standpoint of a Liberal Catholic layman, Imbart de La Tour, the historian, publishes “The Conditions of Religious and Social Revival in France,” present situation with that of fifty years comparing the ago, when Montalembert wrote his ‘“‘Catho- lic Interests of the Nineteenth Century.” All these writers, like M. Brunetiére, dep- recate anxiously any formation of a Cath- olic political party or any connection of Catholics as such with political parties Antoine Albalat, who is responsible for curlous studies of the ways in which French authors form their style and write their books, publishes a useful work, “Pages Choisies,"’ of selections from Louis Veuillot This intensely personal journalist's daily controversy for more than forty stirring years down to his death in 1883 made him feared and detested; and on account of his name being a symbol of the flercest Cler- icaliam, he never became known abroad ag the really great writer which he was Jules Lemaitre, long before he entered the French Academy, rendered justice to the qualities of Veuillot as a writer with a style transforming itself at will from sledge hammer into knife, subtly dissecting soul from spirit, and lancet-puncturing the most promising literary swellings. Little by lit- tle the higher journalists at least have come to recognize that Louls Veuillot was the master of them all. The very genuine democracy of Veuillot, working his way up from poverty in a rich bourgeoia society which chiefly profited by the Revolution, is perhaps another title to latter-day sym pathies. To the French language he con tributed the happy word boulerardier and the complex term odeurs dé Paris The Nation. In a communication made to the Acad- émie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, M. Maspéro narrates the results of the lat- est excavations in Egypt. Among them ic a find of such interest to Greek schol- ars that it is not safe to estimate its value for the present. At Kom Schgaon, a lo- cality to which M. Maspéro’s attention had been attracted several years ago, fifty fine manuscript rolls have been discovered, one of which is more than four yards long. Among them one contains some 1,200 un- published lines of a comedy by Menander. These will be published shortly, and may help to make known in his own work a classical author hitherto read chiefly through Latin imitations. Prince Albert of Monaco has undertaken the collective publication of the most an- cient manifestations of pictorial art—en- gravings and paintings on the rock walls of caves dating from the later palzolithic age (cut stone). The first systematic stu- dent of this art, Emile Riviére of the Col- lége de France, presented at a late meet- ing of the Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres his own series of repro- ductions in photogravure and plaster casts of the chief examples found by him in the cave of La Mouthe, Dordogne. With the exception of the figure of a hut, all repre- sent animals life-size or smaller. The bison, antelope, ibex, reindeer, a bearded horse, an ass resembling the wild Siberian asinus hemionus, a mammoth, and various felines are easily recognizable. The cave of La Mouthe is about 650 feet long. Be- sides the pictures on its walls, it has yielded thousands of bones of different species of animals, with flint and bone tools. At another session, Abbé Breuil, whose work is aided by the Academy’s subsidies, gave a summary of results ob- tained in six caves of the province of Santander, Spain. One, adorned with en- gravings only, shows a tailed anthropoid Another, having red-dot frescoes, portrays a horse and deer, and yet another in the Same style has two canines. The most archaic engraving is found at Molinar, Bis- cay, representing bisons and cave bears. The primitive drawings are mere outlines, but later on there is an attempt at model- ling forms. An elephant in red apparently differs from the mammoth commonly -rep- resented. The entire collection of these art representations gives a certain com- pleteness to our knowledge of the en- vironment of the men of the later Old Stone Age in Western Europe It is al- most entirely due to the labors of MM. Riviére, Cartailhac, Capitan, Duleau, and the Abbé Breuil, and, in Spain, to Sefior Del Rio and the Reverend Padre Sierra, the discoverers of the new caves. Correspondence. RISTORI AND SALVINI. To THe EprTror or THe NATION: Sin: In an article on the late Adelaide Ristori in the Nation of October 11, the writer, speaking as one of “‘the older gen- eration of playgoers'’ who remember Ris- tor! “as she was when she last appeared in this city,” says that, “applauded though she was here, she found us cool,” and cites a report of her having said to Salvini when [Vol. 83, No. 2156 he was leaving Italy for New York, “Give ‘em comedy, Tommy. They won't listen to your tragedy.” Your writer adds that Sal- vini accordingly “played the feeble David Garrick, making it seem a masterpiece, and failed dismally.” Now when Salvini first came to this coun- try in the autumn of 1874, Ristori had, of course, appeared here, but only on her first visit of 1866, not on that last Ameri- can tour which only old playgoers are now supposed to remember. The visit which your critic probably had in mind is one of which I find no mention, either in his article, or in your briefer notice of the death of the great actress, in the same number. My own first and last recollection of her (for I did not happen to see her in 1880) belongs to that visit; and the chill, which I not only noticed but felt, was due, in my case, to the spell, still unbroken, of Salvini’s Othello of the year before. My playbills of two performances, ‘Maria Stuart” and “‘Medea,”’ given at the Academy of Music in Philadelphia on April 22 and 23, make no mention of the year (why do play- bills so often omit this particular?)—but my more precise impression is confirmed by reference to back numbers of the Nation, where, under date of March 18, 1875, I find the record of Ristori’s presence in New York in an article on her acting. It is evidently from the hand of a brilliant, but now almost forgotten, writer, who was then on your staff as art critic, the late Earl Shinn. In noting the coldness of the pub- lic, which he attributed to the remote- ness, to our minds, of the classical idea, the critic pointed out her great distinction as an actress, confessed that as compared with the performance of her earlier days the ex- ecution dragged a little, but assured young spectators that “in witnessing the last act of ‘Mary Stuart’ or certain of the great points in ‘Medea’ they are looking at a sur- preme exhibition of the grand style of act- ing.”’ . This spectator was young then, but on that April 22 and 23, was but grudgingly aware of great statuesque beauty and dis- tinction, being heavy with disappointment under the overwhelming memory of those other evenings with Salvini at the Academy; of the large empty house (Ristori’s was not so), with a _ hand- ful of spectators in the front seats, a row or two in the gallery, and those marvel- lous performances of “Othello” and “La Morte Civile,’ for the emptiness was not wholly due to “David Garrick.”” There was that death of Corrado, in which every muscle gave token of the approach of l'Intruse, and the very blood seemed to ebb; that Othello, listening with folded arms, to the insinuations of Iago, silent, while every shade of thought passed over his countenance like the shadows over a field of wheat; then the foot and glance ready to crush the accuser and the change to anguish over the accusation that could not be crushed. They were more perfect performances, as a whole, than those which in after years took place in crowded thea- tres; the “business” was a little more com- plete, and, more than that, Piamonti was there, the lovely Piamonti, seeming not so much an efficient actress as one who chanc- ed to have been born Desdemona; or look- ing as if she had lived for years the sad part of Rosalia in Giacommelli’s play, giving by her very artlessness the one notwu i ee ee ee
Page 13
Oct. 25, 1906] which Salvini, in his immense tragic gamut, never quite reached No, it not comedy that we demanded of ‘““‘Tommé”; pathos was and I do not agree with the writer in the Nation that he made David Garrick “seem a masterpiece.”” His acting was wanting in the quality kindred to pathos—humor But though I felt this at once it took me more than a year and a half to discover any flaw ‘in a tragic expression so vast as to seem consummate; and it was not till long afterwards that memory conceded to Ristori a noble and great art, more harmo- nious, but also more frigid and artificial, than that of her compatriot. S. K Rosemont, Pa., October 16 “THE PRESENT POSITION OF LATIN AND GREEK.” TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: of will feel do, [ venture to enter an emphatic protest Sir: As one many who as I against the effect of Prof. Arthur O. Nor- ton’s article “The Present Position Latin and Greek” in your issue of Oc- tober 4. The writer premises that his pur- pose is not to present an argument either for or against classical studies; that he is not concerned with their intrinsic merits or defects as instruments of discipline and culture, and not at all with their value in How, then, the comparison with other studies. is it that his thesis is really this, that degree of A.B certain profitable discipline, whether or no is quite as significant of a it stand warrant for any Greek at all? This thesis receives explicit statement, and in- volving directly as it does the question of the value of Latin and Greek as compared it re- expense either the of concerned with their substitutes, the the logic, support of assertion with ceives stultifies, at or his that he merits. his fairness the their not The author is relative statement re- ferred to is as follows: Far-sighted administrators of college af- fairs have seen for years that the effec- tive preservation of the A.B., and all that goes with it, can be secured only by broad- ening the terms on which it may be ob- tained, and on which students may matricu- late for it. That is, a thing may be making it something different the tag and the good-will of the old firm and supplying an article seriously modi- by preserving preserved fied by substitution of an inferior ingre- dient within the can. My faculty is not that of classical languages, and I do not mean to presume upon your patience by en- gaging to set forth the merits of Greek and however, say that I know teachers both of the sciences in asserting Latin. I may, I speak for many historic and natural the belief that in the study of the classical languages an intellectual discipline is ob- tained, and more than that a culture, which cannot be obtained otherwise, and which invariably and unmistakably declares it- self in the subsequent work and life of the student. And if this be true, as it is an A.B. without the classics is not the same thing as an A.B. which stands for them So Cambridge thought last year when it threw out the proposition to make Greek optional at the Little Go by 507 votes in a total of 2,611, and recently decided that there should not be a choice between an A.B. in letters and in science (the lat- of The Nation. ter, indeed, involving a choice between Greek and Latin) by a vote of 747 to 241 Professor Norton remarks that many col leges still require a small amount of Latin —one or two-fifteenths of the total work for the degree—¢ebut even these the pre- scription of undergraduate Greek is rare and he refers to the entrance requirements of six universities, only one, he remarks demanding Greek for entrance to the A.B course Is it accident that he omits at least one university which both demands Greek for entrance and insists that one tenth of the total work for the A.B. degree shall be devoted to the classics? Near the close of his article Professor Norton quotes President Eliot by abstract to the effect that it is ‘‘not merely ridicu lous, but impossible, to uphold a scheme of education which no longer commands the respect of the public What has this to do with it? The point under argument is whether the A.B. degree should mean Greek and Latin if the public do not respect these studies and what they afford, the B.S is open to them Why should they want the A.B., if not for what it once stood for” And emphatically it is not any lack of respect that is in question, even in the case of that highly desirable element in a university, the idle and ignorant rich. What is in question is really only too much re- spect for Greek upon the part both of some schoolmasters and of the greater number of boys—for Greek and for the patient, care ful, laborious, but character-building work it demands The sum of the whole matter is briefly this: Omission of Greek from the require- ments for the A.B. degree means a substi tute, a cheaper substitute, in entrance re- quirements and the course that follows Certainly the substitution is quite legal there is no doubt of that—the institution that descends to making this substitution undoubtedly holds the copyright of the old label. There is no attempt to deceive; the change is made quite openly; and business the buying public, demands a less costly article. To be sure, there is the B.S. over there, just what they really want, just what they ‘respect.’ But they won't have it they want this tag—this tag still standing for something they do not ‘“‘respect CLARENCE G. CHILD University of Pennsylvania, October 17 AFRICAN LANGUAGES To THE EpItor OF THE NATION: Sir: The importance of language in rela tion to political and social aspects of the native question in Africa seems liable to be overlooked. The possibility of large groups of tribes, hitherto distinct and mutually antagonistic, becoming rapidly able and eager to understand each other in some common form of speech, has apparently to be taken into account Twenty-six years’ contact with Swahili and various dialects of Eastern and Central Africa so far points to the conclusion that there is a re markable degree of similarity, amounting in many important respects to substantial ideutity, in the grammatical structure of language over the whole vast area occupied by the Bantu races of Africa, from the Soudan to the Cape And the stock of words common to all Bantu tribes, when recognized under their various dialectile disguises, will 5 bably prove very / erable The officials, m i ack ‘ tlers and ave f " " al who are qualified t giv hely ») testing this conclusion by pe. land fi hand study of a Bantu ‘ " y dif ficul to eacl aca } 1 often isolated spher of worl It fore perhaps justifiat t isk publ for the request, that | jualified and willing to accept and ly toa communication on the would ‘ i me their addresses at |} N I Eastern Rhodesia \ M ‘ Student of Chr C} h, Oxford The British South Africa Nort astern KR lesia HERBERT SPENCER'S SUPPORTERS TO THE EpiTror oF THE NATION Si It he ill \ t of the ith the autl wl ha endorsed Hert Spe work t ‘ littl trange tha } ld ha ‘ I Da \ fa pl \W bow the kne t Sher r perhay ta is, } ' 1 wa ! her f wt ! emind me that tl ty « forts yea igo al very pretty ju | wi eed up in your column by your having perm ted a gentleman whose fleld w ' het to speak contemptuously of S ‘ r tation, because he was not an autl y i each ence that he had lald under tribution It has just occurred to me th a philosopher's work necessarily wt Original investigato ke to ll ‘ ! hand for even if life we long enough to make it first-hand whil t would be getting up one department, bh knowledge of the other departme: would evitably grow stale As this very obvi co sideration happened to « ipe the itten tion of the defence n tl onflicet in you columns, there is double on for m tioning it now unl Il am the only man ilive Who remembers the occasion Henry H Burlingt ve October 19 Tv Notes. Longmans, Green & Co. will soon pub lish the Life and Letters of the first Earl of Durham,” by Stuart J. Reid. This work is based on the papers at Lambton Castl and deals with the Grey and Melbour Cabinets, the Reform Bill, and other ma ters of that time E. P. Dutton & Co. have now ready From Libau to Tsushima,”’ which relates the voyage of Admiral Rojestvensky fleet to the East, including an a yunt of the Dogger Bank Incident The autho Eugene 8. Politovaky, chief engineer of the squadron, who was killed at the ba of Tsushima Walter L. Fleming, professor of h ing West Virginia University, has prepa ! a “Documentary History of Reconatru from unpublished MSS. of all sorts ry work is put out by the Arthi a. 6 Co Volumes seven to ten bring to a on
Page 14
The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 clusion the Gettysburg edition of the Com- plete Works of Abraham Lincoln issued by Francis D. Tandy Co We have already spoken of the quality of this edition, and take this oceasion only to compliment the publishers on the completion of this hand- sume undertaking We are asked to state that the Bureau of Statistics and Municipal Library of Chicago has ready a souvenir volume re- cently published for the League of Ameri- can Municipalities, which will be sent to ill applicants upon receipt of 25 cents, to cover postage The two-volume “Memorials of Edward Burne-Jones,” by his wife, has been re- issued by the Macmillans in a single vol- ume without other change One coull wish that the process which has been ap- plied to this excellent life might be applied to biographies generally in the first in- stance lwo volumes in the handy little series published by A. 8S. Barnes & Co. contain The Voyages and Explorations of Samuel de Champlain,’ translated by Annie Net- tleton Bourne, together with “The Voyage of 1603,"" reprinted from “Purchas his Pil- xrimes."" An Introduction and Notes are furnished by Prof. E. G. Bourne Doubleday, Page & Co. have issued a new edition of Upton Sinclair's “King Midas,” ind also of “The Journal of Arthur Stir- ling,.”” which, the author assures us in the newly added Preface, “will always be read.”’ Socialism,” by Robert Flint (Phila- delphia: J. B. Lippincott; London: Isaac Pitman), is a reprint, apparently without material alteration in the plates, of the work which the author brought out in 1894 In fits original form the book was read with profit by many persons, and the recent growth of the Socialist move- ment makes the present volume a timely one. As becomes its author, “Socialism” is 1 philosophical essay upon cardinal points of doctrine, and does not deal with the his- tory and present position of socialistic peculation or agitation Bb. F. Buck & Co. have published a new edition of “The Italian in America.” No sddition or change seems to have been made from the original edition except, pos- bly mechanical ones, in the arrange- ment of chapters. This is to be regretted, is in the last two years a great deal of study, research, and experiment, regard- ing various phases of Italian immigration to this country, has been carried on, which might have well fitted in the present work. Indeed, the entire omliasion of such items as the Investigation of conditions tn the South by the Itallan ambassador, the cre- ation of the Itallan Labor Bureau in New York, the extension of the legal protec- tion of Itallan immigrants by their Gov- ernment, and the resulta of an aggressive policy against Itallan peonage, constitutes a grave defect which renders many parts of the book out of date The field of the operations of the Carne- gie Inatitution of Washington is wisely varied, as is seen in the fact that its fifty- third publication deals with questions ‘of technical Oriental archmology and palw- ography from the land of the Nile. Dr. W. Max Miller has already made a name for himself as a student of the hierogly- phic writings, but not as an explorer. The present volume, ‘“Egyptological Research- es,"" embodying the results of a journey made in 1904, shows him in a new rela- tion. The fact that he was working alone, without a corps of assistants, dictated the manner and matter of his activity. His work as here set forth is intensive rather than extensive. He spent his time, in part, in traversing anew some of the ground of previous explorers and correcting their re- sults by rereading the old texts. This is particularly necessary, because reading Egyptian hieroglyphic writing is inherently dificult, and because some of the older publications were made by men whose ac- quaintance with the language was quite rudimentary as compared with the best knowledge of to-day. Dr. Miller divid- ed his attention between the monu- ments found in the Museum in Cairo and those still in situ at Thebes. As might be expected from the subjects of the au- thor’s special previous studies and pub- lications, those texts which have to do with the relations between Egypt and Asia or Europe claimed particular attention; and in this respect he has rendered valua- ble aid to students of early Biblical and Palestinian history by investigating the local names preserved in the hieroglyphic writing. The book consists of above two dozen monographs or essays on topics sug- gested by the texts which his tables con- tain, partly in photograph and partly in the graceful hieroglyphs in which the au- thor is an adept, both as a copyist and an expounder. The results of many years of patient and sympathetic study of the German peasant is embodied in A. l'Houet’s “Zur Psychologie des Bauerntums,”’ published in Tiibingen by J. C. B. Mohr. L’Houet is a Protestant pastor who has sunk himself for fifteen years, many miles distant from the rail- way, in German peasant life, where he could find it at its purest. He would seem to be a man not only of real German ca- pacity of devotion to one end, but also a student of wide learning and thorough men- tal grasp as well as a writer of unusual literary gifts. His essay is compared with Wilhelm Heinrich Riehl’s productions in the history of culture for its largeness of view and firmness of grasp. In l'Houet’s description of the German peasant one finds himself placed before a creature of distant ages, preserved as by miracle into the present time. The social and ethical unity of the village rather than of the individual takes one back to the times of David; and the tales of giants and demi-gods, the folk- lore yet in the making, show that the Middle Ages are not so distant as chronolo- gy would imply. L’Houet writes as a lover of the peasant, in whom he sees the Ger- man in his fresh, wild youth. Both the country pastor and the school teacher are charged with making a botch of their tasks, destroying the poetry and romance and deep native piety in the peasant soul under plea of removing relics of heathenism, but bringing in no compensating advantage. The book is likely to lead to more intelligent attention to the problems of the German peasantry. On Christmas day, the ancient city of Todi will celebrate the six-hundredth anni- versary of the death of one who was, per- haps, her most famous son, Fra Jacopone, “the jongleur of God.”” A new guide book to Todi is being prepared by Archdeacon Alvi, and, during the next few months, numerous monographs on Jacopone and his city may be expected to see the light. Al- ready Prof. Annibale Tenneroni has pub- lished a learned article in the Nuova An- tologia, of June 16, on “Le Laudi e Jaco- pone da Todi nel vi. centenario dalla sua morte,”’ which will hereafter reappear as the Introduction to the “Lessico di Laudi e d’altre poesie religiose italiane nel medio evo,”” now in the press; while an able and exhaustive treatise by Prof. Giuseppe Galli on “Disciplinanti dell’ Umbria del 1260 e le loro Laudi" has just been issued in the form of a _ special supplement to the Giornale Storico della Letteratura Italiana. This work is divided into five chapters: “The Religious Movement of 1260, and the Disciplinants of Umbria,” “The Codices of the Umbrian Lauds,” ‘“‘The Metre of the Lauds,” “The Argument of the Lauds and their Authorship,”’ “‘The Dramatic Lauds.” It is, as far as we are aware, the only book in which any attempt has been made to give a full and systematic account of the Umbrian flagellants and their hym- nology. James Duff Brown’s “Subject Classifica- tion” (London: Library Supply Company), a development of his “Adjustable Classifica- tion”’ published some years ago, is a solid and substantial piece of work which ought to be on every classifier’s desk. His plan is more logical than the Decimal Classifica- tion, and its notation is less formidable than that of the Expansive. Mr. Browu’s system has some very decided peculiarities, but contains no such absurdities of ar- rangement as, e. g., the classes 330 (Politi- cal Economy) and 650 (Communication and Commerce) of the Decimal Classification. The class Generalia, containing, among others, such subjects as Education, Logic, Mathematics, and Graphic and Plastic Arts, is certainly open to criticism, and to put Bibliography, Printing, and Library History and Economy in the middle of the system with Language and Literature, is awkward from a practical point of view, no matter what might be its logic. Less objectiona- ble, though more conspicuously contrary to all previous schemes, is the arrangement of the divisions in the class Physical Sciences, where Physics, Engineering, Architecture, Railways, Transport, Naval and Military Science, Electricity, Optics, Heat, Acous- tics, Music, Astronomy, etc., are put to- gether in this order. These and similar groupings, the author says in his most in- teresting and valuable Introduction, “are departures from the convention that there exists a clear difference between theory and practice, pure and applied science, and so on, which renders their amalgamation un- desirabie.”” A notable feature of this classi- fication is the notation, which was devised after the system of classification had been worked out, and consequently has been ad- justed to the system instead of the system being adjusted to the notation. The nota- tion consists of 24 letters of the alphabet, each subdivided by the numbers 000 to 999, with provision for further subdivision. On the whole, Mr. Brown's classification allows more free scope to the individual classifi- er than any other system we know of—and his notation is not copyrighted. poe ee sti ath ah
Page 15
Oct. 25, 1906] The Nation. Among the more interesting items of li- brary legislation enacted by the different States during the past year are the follow- lowing: Ohio provides for the establish- ment and maintenance by taxation of coun- ty library systems. The act is an attempt to solve the library problem of the rural community. This State has also created the office of “library organizer,”” whose duty shall be ‘“‘to furnish advice and in- formation to persons interested in libraries, to visit the public libraries of the State, and to assist in promoting and starting new libraries.”” In Virginia a comprehen- sive system of travelling libraries has been inaugurated, whereby every school district of the State may be supplied. In South Carolina a way has been indicated for the solution of the negro problem as related to the library, in a special act applying to the township of Union. This provides that when the colored people of the township shall have furnished a suitable building and equipment for a library, “a just and suitable amount of money shall be appro- priated by the aldermen for its suppart.”’ Plans for the next American Library As- sociation meeting, to be held in Asheville, N. C., the latter part of May, are well un- der way, and the main features of the pro- gramme have already been decided upon. The general theme of the conference will be “The Use of Books,” and advocates of different of literature, such as science, history, art, fiction, will each be given an opportunity to discuss his favorite field. That the rubbish of one generation be- comes the treasures of the next is exem- plified in the case of a series of illustrat- ed street directories of New York which were printed, primarily as advertisements, in 1848, 1849, and 1850. The plan was to show in the form of a panorama both sides of the street, the occupants of the build- ings being advertised by the signs on the fronts. The most interesting of these was the directory of Broadway entitled ‘‘Jones & Newman’s Pictorial Directory of New York,”” which extends as far up as Worth Street. It was issued in four parts, ‘Price 25 cents each.”” Other street directories which were issued in a similar form, were Wall, Williams, Fulton, and Maiden Lane. These curious works are now of the greatest rarity and command $50 to $75 each. They contain views of New York buildings which are apparently not found in any other form. Cc. F. Libbie & Co. of Boston will offer at auction during the coming season an- other portion of the collection of New England imprints and manuscripts made by James Terry of Hartford. In March, 1889, Mr. Terry sold a few hundred items from his collection, many of which brought record prices. At the Social Education Congress to be held in Boston Thanksgiving week, the programme includes mass meetings, de- voted to the following topics: Friday af- ternoon, “Education for Citizenship’’; Friday evening, “The School as a Social Organism”; Saturday afternoon, “The School and the Family’; Saturday evening, “Industrial Education’; Sunday evening, “The Education of the Conscience.” Sec- tion meetings will be arranged in the “Uni- classes mornings on the following topics: versity and School Extension,” ‘Health Education,” “Special Classes for Trouble- some Children,” “Industrial Education,” “Commercial Education,” ‘Self-Organized Group Work in the Schools,” “Social Training in Infapgcy and Early Childhood.” Among the speakers thus far announced are Gov. jr. Mayor John F Fitzgerald of Boston, Miss Jane Addams of Hull House, Chicago: Chancellor E. B Andrews of the of Nebraska, Mayor Z. R. Brockway of Elmira, Dr. M G. Brumbaugh, superintendent of the Phil- adelphia schools; President K. L. Butter field of the State tural College, President of Harvard, F. P. Fish, American Telephone and Telegraph pany; the Rev. Dr. Washington Gladden President G. Stanley Hall of Clark Uni- versity, Dr. J. P supervisor of art and manual training, New York city; W. 8S. Jackman, principal of the School of Education, University of Chicago; Prof. J W. Jenks of Cornell, President Henry Lefavour of Simmons College, Prof. S. M Lindsay of the University of Pennsylvania, Sir Alfred Mosely of England, the Most Rev. W. H. O'Connell, archbishop coadjutor of Massachusetts; Miss H. M. Orcutt, pres- Curtis Guild, University Agricul W. Eliot president of the Com Massachusetts Charles Haney, ident of the New York Kindergarten As sociation; Herbert Putnam, librarian of Congress; Prof. C. R. Richards of Col- umbia, Dr. D. A. Sargent of Harvard, Mrs. Frederic Schoff, president of the National Congress of Mothers; President W. O Thompson of the University of Ohio, F. A Vanderlip, vice-president of the National City Bank of New York; Dr. W. P. Wil- son, director of the Philadelphia Com- mercial Museum, and Mrs. M. S. Woolman, director of the Manhattan Trade School for Girls. A notable event in Russian journal- ism was the recent celebration of its fortieth anniversary by the leading month- ly of the country, the Westnik Jewropy (the Messenger of Europe); at the same time its founder and editor during these decades, Michael Stassulewitz, celebrated his eightieth birthday. The journal pursued a moderately liberal policy, all times advocating the necessity of a constitutional government. The who also plays a prominent rdéle in public affairs, has been particularly active in school reforms, and has been frequently to suffer on account of his lib- eral views, although, on account of his high standing in the confidence of the peo- ple, the reactionary party has never ven- tured to treat him with extreme harshness. Dr. Maitland Thompson, though he will retire from the position of curator in His Majesty’s General Register House, Edin- burgh, will continue his work in Scottish records. He will be succeeded by the Rev John Anderson, the assistant curator. The foreign papers bring news of the death of two European scholars and authors. The first is Karl Emich, aged fifty-one, Graf zu Leiningen-Westerburg, the author of several historical and her- aldic works, among them “Die Leining- schen Wappen und Siegel,”” “Historische Blatter aus dem alten Leininger Land,” etc. He was the owner of a large collec- tion of ex-libris, which, according to the Deuteche Tageszeitung, he has left to the Germanische Museum of Nuremberg. The has at editor, compelled 349 second is Louis Auguste Himly, doyen hon oraire of the Fa: Lettres of Paris where he was for | He was born at Strasburg in cated at the FReol elected to the Académie des Sclenes Morales et Politiques Mignet He was Carlovingian period, concerning ulté des nany years professor 1823 Chartes and edu les Hie was in 1884 to an authority on the published a number of studies His gr: the Histoire le ia I territoriale des Fitats de im iS7¢ est work was mation Centrale,” issued TRAVEL AND TOPOGRAPHY of t England, the no fleld photo Idyl Putnam's Sons) is one At the present rate of appearance pographical books will soon be no corner, no brook about path undescribed and painted or graphed. John Henry Garrett's ‘The lic Avon" (G. P of the most thorough of its kind of three Avon, A party spent a whole summer in a boat on the navigating that stream from Gloucestershire to Strat of Something over 250 pages and 89 full-page to that Tewkesbury in ford-on-Avon, a distance fifty miles illustrations devoted stretch of banks with which the Stratford this are Avon's and riverside villages reader becomes extremely but who weary of spot find of vale of Evesham and the charming remote Worcester of excuse intimate is the goal those will the well-trodden the descriptions and pictures villages of Gloucestershire and to their The is usually merely the shire more taste text book for stringing amateur photographs, but Mr how to collect and his tale of an English village is nearly though the where King Charles hid or slept come with such a together a number of good Garrett knew antiquarian information, always interesting, houses sickening frequency. There are, we regret to say, thirty songs and ballads contributed by Mr. Garrett or one of his party at in tervals during the journey. We have a de- cided feeling that it is not fair to the reader to publish one’s verse in this way There wild flowers the To their charming series of topographical welcome information about The book is well got illustrations excellent is much up and books, illustrated in color, Messrs. A. & C. Black (New York: The Macmillan Co.) have added “Surrey,” by A. Hope Mon crieff, painted by Sutton Palmer. Surrey is the most attractive and varied of the “home” counties, the Cockney paradise. But for all its tea-gardens and bungalows and motor-buses, and those innumerable resi- dences of well-to-do citizens, which, even in the days of Pepys, were planted along ita sandy ridges, Surrey has still many an “ancient haunt of peace.” Its silent pools and winding rivers, the lesser streams of the Wey and the Mole, escape the tripper and breathe the atmosphere of Devon These enchanting by-ways Mr. Moncrieff explored, following also the course of the too well-known Thames. He takes us along all the main roads, to all the more important country seats, and to the sum mits of heights, such as Leith Hill, from all of which one may see London lying there like a busy ant-hill, never to be kept out of the scenery. The chief charm of Sur- rey is her Downs, a little neglected by the
Page 16
350 present writer Mr. Kipling is always at his best when his imagination is stirred by the romance of places that have seen ie restless tribes of men come and go Mr. Moncrieff might have drawn on the poem in which he describes the early Briton who haunted the folds of the Downg before the Roman invasion. All that is es- ential is unchanged since Tegumai hunted there (m Merrow Down the cuckoo's ery, The silence and the sun remain Even the suburban settler cannot spoil these great spaces Mr. Palmer's full-page colored illustrations are fully up to the standard of the series “Warwickshire,” painted by Fred White- head and described by Clive Holland (the Macmillan Co.) is another of A. & C Black’ eries with full-page color illustra- tion As usual the pictures are charming, though we fail to grasp the significance of the tags of Shaksperian quotation, with which each one is labelled; this strikes one as a superfluous effort to remind the reader that he is In the poet’s country The get- up of the volume is most attractive. Mr Holland account of the district is con- cerned less with Warwickshire’s highways ind byways than her towns and larger vil- lages such as Birmingham, Coventry, tratford, Henley, and the rest These are lescribed with great detail, and especial tention to their earlier history and the part they played in the successive civil wal rhis preoccupation with human in- terests leave an opening for a second volume which should be devoted to “leafy Warwickshire’s” splendid trees, her lovely lane and streams, and her preéminently agricultural interests One hundred good photographs and an excellent map go far to Justify the exist- ence of Henry Wellington Wack's “In rhamesiand” (G. P. Putnam's Sons) The iuthor traces the course of the Thames from it ouree (not undisputed) in Glou- cestershire to London His travelling was done mainly in a canoe, and he has much to iy, though little that is flattering, about the quality of the riverside inns It is curious to remark how in the early stages of his course Mr. Wack, who is an Ameri- can tourist, regards England as a place to be orrowed over, “a land of white lave ind blind masters” (p. 70), a land which the entire educational system is triving mightily in the wrong direction” (p. 71); while he cannot see a peaceful village without commiserating the popula tion of decaying old men who have had to ee thelr sons and daughters swallowed by lain in the Boer war When he nears London however his tone chang ind the English are a ‘virile race a people whose glory cannot be idequately acknowledged by word or me mortal” (p. 368) It is as though size and crowds were needed to Impress Mr. Wack with the greatne of a nation Hie has not the tyle or the point of view neces ary for the writer of an Interesting topo- graphical book He is too personal; too much concerned with the way in which he and his companion were treated at inns and elsewhere, too prone to relate rather foolish anecdotes of other American tour- The book is, ists whom he encountered in fact, one to make an Englishman shud- The Nation. der, and to depress even more the Ameri- can who has been over the same ground. Monsignor. the Count Vay de Vaya and Luskod, Hungarian by birth and a travel- ler thoroughly familiar with Europe, jour- neyed through Asiatic Russia and several countries of the Far East previously to the Russo-Japanese war. He has collected his notes and recollections, some of which had already appeared as magazine articles, un- der the title “Empires and Emperors of Russia, China, Korea, and Japan” (E. P. Dutton & Co.). As envoy of His Holiness the Pope, he had interviews with the four rulers most talked about a year or two ago. None need, however, seek in this book for penetrating insight or for fresh and exact information. His interviews with the emperors seem to have been of the most perfunctory character. Few of the au- thor’s statements go above the level of those of the average hasty traveller, who accepts uncritically any story which is in- teresting. For one example of many, mon- signor does not seem to know that the drum hung in front of the royal palace at Seul, and struck by petitioners, was com- mon to all countries under Chinese influ- ences or tradition. The fires nightly light- ed on the Korean mountains were tele- graphic signals from distant points on the coast, and not methods of attracting the king’s attention to a petitioner. It is a pity that some expert could not have read the proofs and presented more of the proper names in correct form, even though the book is extraordinarily impersonal. Il- lustrations are for the most part already familiar. It cannot be said that the post- script in a final chapter throws much light on the situation; the author even thinks that “the peace of Portsmouth does not alter the status quo from what it was after the treaty cg Shimonoseki.”” Yet, despite these criticisms, the style of the author is easy and his text entertaining. The aver- age reader will surely be delighted with these experiences of a gentleman of kindly heart who adds to a pleasing style the graces of a cosmopolitan traveller. RELIGION AND BIBLICAL CRITICISM. Prof. William Newton Clarke of Colgate University, author of several theological works of wide circulation and consider- able influence, is at work upon a volume to be entitled, “The Christian Doctrine of God,” which he has promised for the In- ternational Theological Library. Dr. Clarke is one of the most eminent of living American teachers of doctrinal theology His literary activity began rath- er late in life, starting with a modest vol- ume of outlines of his lectures to classes of theological students. The unassuming book was privately printed and designed chiefly for the use of his pupils, but It was discovered by outsiders, and, after thorough revision by the author, was issued by Charles Scribner's Sons. 4t met with im- mediate success, and has attained greater popularity than any work of its class In re- cent years. In Great Britain an enthu- siastic notice by the late Dr. Marcus Dods brought it into wide favor. The appear- ance of the “Outline” was very opportune, since treatises handling Christian doctrine in anything like a thorough manner had become altogether out of date, and the books which were appearing from the new- er point of view were fragmentary, partial, and altogether unsatisfactory. Though published in 1898, the ‘Outline’ retains its place as the best systematic exposition of Christian belief of the moderately ortho- dox school. Since that time Dr. Clarke has issued a volume of lectures which he delivered at Harvard, entitled “Can We Be- lieve in God the Father?’ a book on the modern motive for foreign missions, and also a series of Yale lectures on “The Use of the Scriptures in Theology.”’ The latter may be taken to mark the epoch of the defi- nite renunciation of the proof-text method in American systematic theology Dr. Clarke’s present task is the most serious ons he has attempted, and if he succeeds in producing a book on the subject of Christian theism of the clearness and force which have characterized his other under- takings, he will have made an important contribution to American theological science. Prof. George F. Genung’s commentary on Leviticus and Numbers’ (Philadelphia: American Baptist Publication Society) is a clear and practical exposition of those books for laymen. The subject gives little occasion for the display of that paradoxical ingenuity which marks his works on Job and Ecclesias- tes. There is a touch of the same spirit, however, in the suggestion that the conception of sin as a substance—the com- mon savage notion—is a more developed idea than the ethical conception, and that the idea of sin as defilement was one of Israel’s permanent contributions tc the world’s thought. Even in a popular com- mentary, greater familiarity with Jewish ritual tradition on the one side and with the religious notions and practices of oth- er peoples on similar planes of culture would often stand the interpreter in good stead. The Hebrew words scattered through the notes are frequently repro- duced in surprising transliteration, such as garbain higtir (qorban, higtin. In “The Book of Job in the Revised Ver- sion,” edited with introductions and brief annotations (Oxford: Clarendon Press), Prof. S. R. Driver has provided an ad- mirable aid to the reading of the Book of Job in the Revised Version. The intro- duction sets forth, briefly and lucidly, the problem of the book and its structure, and adds helpful suggestions on the use of the marginal notes of the revisers. The text is broken into paragraphs; the headings of these sections, in italics, furnish a run- ning synopsis of the contents and analysis of the argument. The notes show a wise parsimony; the author's aim is to enable the reader to understand as he reads, with- out diverting his attention from the poem to the commentary. It is needless to say that judicious scholarship and mature re- flection are manifest in every line. Bishop Potter of the Protestant Episco- pal diocese of New York, in addition to his obvious opportunities for meeting eminent prelates while serving a metropolitan see, also, as secretary of the House of Bishops for many years, had exceptional opportun- ity to study the Episcopal overseers. Im- pressed of late with the value of anecdotal material and the personalia of great men as they shed light on character, he has
Page 17
A Sith GOR ME Oe nll wens Oct. 25, 1906] brought up from the wells of his “memory “Reminiscences of Bishops and Archbish- ops”’ (G. P. Putnam's Sons), which has an excellent collection of stories. Some studies of character, while not exhaustive, are il- luminating; by far the best is one on Bishop Dudley of Kentucky, who was a humanist to the end, never allowing the office to cramp and cabin the man. Bishop Potter has not refrained from disclosures respecting the use of tobacco and liquor by bishops, including himself, which will sub- ject him to still further denunciation by the Women’s Christian Temperance Union The net result of the book is to prove that ecclesiastics are like other men, in having a saving sense of humor, in regard for sub- stance rather than for form in religion, and in emphasis upon character rather than on possessions. The treatment of the men described in some cases is sketchy and thin, and in no case is there any such tri- umph of character-portrayal as James Bryce has given us of Bishop James Fraser in his “Studies of Contemporary Biog- raphy Principal Fairbairn, when Canon Gore was made Bishop of Worcester, said that he did not think the more of him for being made a bishop, but he did think all the better of bishops now that he was one; and in some such mood even a con- temner of bishops may arise from this book, since it discloses persons, a majority of whom were men first and always. STUDIES IN HISTORY. A History of the Reformation. By Thomas M. Lindsay, M.A., D.D.—I. The Reforma- tion in Germany from the beginning to the Religious Peace of Augsburg. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. $2.50 net. The first thing to be said about this vol- ume is that it is no mere compilation. Dr. Lindsay is well within bounds when he writes: ‘“‘My excuse, if excuse be needed, for venturing on the field is that the period is one to which I have devoted special at- tention for many years, and that I have read and re-read most of the original con- temporary sources of information. While full use has been made of the labors of pre- decessors in the same field, no chapter in the volume, save that on the political con- dition of Europe, has been written without constant reference to contemporary evi- dence.”’ In treating the Lutheran Reforma- tion, any one who can read German has before him a vast body of erudite, but unco- ordinated monographs. These Dr. Lindsay uses with great effect, but, as indicated above, his chief reliance is upon original documents of essential importance The work has many merits, but in our opinion its most distinctive feature is the careful analysis of social and religious life in Germany on the eve of the Protestant revolt. Here Dr. Lindsay accentuates the existence of evangelical piety in side the Latin Church—not confined to saints and mystics, but widely diffused among those of the common people who re- garded religion seriously, and not as some- thing which meant pilgrimages, miracle plays, and other ecclesiastical junkets We shall not multiply details, but the point seems well taken that there were many people in whose eyes Lutheran doc- trines when first proclaimed were self-evi- The Nation. | dent truths This appears to us the cen tral idea of It Lindsay book “The great Reformation had its roots in the sim ple evange lical piety wh h had never et | tirely disappeared in the mediwval church Luther's teaching was recognized by thou sands to be no startling novelty, but some thing which they had always at heart be lieved, though they might not have been | able to formulate As for Luther himself D Lindsay's | Views have already found expres m in the article he contributed to the Cambridge Modern History.” Here, again, the nu cleus of the discussion is to be found in a | Single idea Luther succeeded because the world could see faith incarnate when it re garded him In the words of Diirer's “Tagebuch,”’ he was “‘the pious man," ‘‘the follower of the Lord and of the true Chris tian faith,’’ “the man enlightened by the Holy Spirit.” Lord Acton has told us how Ddllinger, opposed though he was to Luther's falsche Imputationsileh ‘ used to defend him against some of the common accusations When people said of Luther that he does not come well out of his matrimonial ad- vice to certain potentates, to Henry and to Philip, of his exhortations to exterminat« the revolted peasantry, of his passage from a confessor of toleration to a teacher of in tolerance, Déllinger would not have the most powerful conductor of religion that Christianity has produced in eighteen cen- turies condemned for two pages in a hun- dred volumes. If one of the most eminent Catholic his torians could thus absolve Luther from conscious antinomianism, one need not ex pect from Dr. Lindsay a lesser degree of willingness to judge the reformer’s char- acter by its strongest rather than its weak- est features. Philip of Hesse’s bigamy is of course, a test case No other act 80 damaged the reputation of Protestant theo- logians as their refusal to accuse of vice the prince whose aid seemed indispensable to their cause Dr. Lindsay at once ac- quits Luther of trimming his sails to suit a friend and ally, and finds the explana- tion of his conduct in that fondness for tradition, which coexisted with his rever ence for the Bible The Church had been accustomed to say that it possessed a dispensing power in matrimonial causes of extreme difficulty and, in spite of his denunciations of the dispensations granted by the Roman Curia Luther never denied the power. On the contrary he thought honestly that the Church did possess this power of dispensa- tion even to the length of tampering with a fundamental law of Christian society, pro vided it did not contradict a positive scrip tural command to the contrary We have touched upon one or two points which seem salient in Dr. Lindsay's view of the Reformation as a religious move- ment, and of Luther's part in it. The poli- tical aspects of the revolt from Rome re- iess attent ceive on than would be given them by most historians, but we must re- member that, being a contribution to the “International Theological Library,” this volume ig bound to insist upon the theo- logical motive After sketching the ante- cedents of Protestantism and its progress to the Peace of Augsburg, the work con- | cludes with an excellent section, entitled | “The Religious Principles inspiring the Reformation.”” The chief topies which Dr Lindsay considers under this heading are 351 the universal priesthood of bellevers, jus tification by faith, the Bible, the person of Christ, and the Church is Lutheranism that ecelves the lion's Throughout it share of attention, but the comparative me- thod is freely used, and, in a complicated tangle of doct ne no vi ut opi mm is suffered to drop out of sight altogether On the strength of first-hand knowledge excellent arrangement, and thoughtfu this book deserves the most respectful at tention It is well adapted for use in the senior grades of univer y teaching { Political History of the State of New York By De Alva Stanwood Alexand Two volumes New York Henry hk & Company $5 rhe author who sets out to solve th problem which James Parton aptly calle that most unfathomable of subjects he politics of the State of New York has be fore him a task requiring at once the pr severance of an antiquarian, the discern ment of a political philosopher the im partiality of a judge, and the sympathet devotion of an enthusiast If the author of the present volumes has not all the jualities in sufficient quantity » give h | work the tith definitive,” he has at any rate given us a very useful history In deed, even if it were not as well done a it i the fact that it covers a practically unoccupied field would give the book a ce tain value For Jabez D. Hammond's h tory bearing the same title was completed in 1848, and Hammond himself was too close to the events which he described and too intimately related to the principal actors to be exactly fair or impartial Yet despite its long-windedness Hammond history remains a rich storehouse Of thi wealth of undigested material Mr. Alexan der has availed himself The two volumes begin with the adoption of John Jay's constitution, and the estab lishment of the State Government in 1777 and close with the outbreak of the Civil War In his that he hopes, in a third volume, to ca preface the author tells us ry the narrative down to 1896. The sel tion of 1777 as a starting point, although justified by the title, makes the begin ning somewhat abrupt A detailed expo sition of existing political forces would have afforded a much better understanding of the course of events during the early years of Statehood. The author has, how ever, a clearly defined method to which he adheres faithfully. This method is best explained in his preface The history of a State or nation is largely the history of a few leading men and it is of such men only, with some of their more important contemporaries, that the author has attempted to write It would be hard to find in any common wealth of the Union a more interesting or picturesque leadership than is presented in the political history of the Empire State Rarely more than two controlling spirits appear at a time, and as these pass into apogee, younger men of approved capacity are ready to take their places A writer who starts with that thesis runs a risk of conjuring up “controlling spirits’ where there are none, and this danger Mr Alexander has not entirely es- caped. The mantle of power did not al- ways find shoulders waiting for it When Jay and Hamilton passed from the stage and the Anté-Federalist leadership de
Page 18
352 The Nation. [ Vol. 83, No. 2156 scended from George Clinton to his nephew, De Witt, the latter did not for many years find either among the Federalists or the factional leaders of his own party any single man who was anything like his match At a later period, after Van Buren's forced retirement, when the Dem- ocratic party was split over the slavery question, Horatio Seymour was a long time in bringing the warring factions under his control. It is difficult too, to find such an example of a single powerful leader in the Whig and Republican parties during the years of the Weed-Seward-Greeley triumvirate. Nevertheless, it is remark- able how near to the truth Mr. Alexander's picture of the constant warring of two predominant personalities remains A history written on such a plan is per- force interesting, if for no other reason than because men are more attractive than institutions Mr. Alexander has not ne- giected his opportunity, and his pages are enlivened and enriched by numerous pen-pictures of New York politicians and statesmen, which constitute what are per- haps the most valuable, as well as the most entertaining, portions. The style is terse and clear and good use is made of anecdotes and reminiscences, which are not, however, allowed to clog the narrative. The au- thor breaks from the annalistie form in which so much of our history that is not monographic is still His attention is directed to per- lods rather than years. The apportion- away absolutely written ment of space depends so much on the point of view that it Is dificult to criti- The fact that approximately 350 out of 400 pages in Volume I. are devoted to the struggle between the Clintons and their political opponents may be excused clae it on the score that their personalities really dominated polities for a half-century. But that the last eleven chapters of the second volume should be taken up almost entirely with the years 1859-60, when national and not State politics controlled, ‘is less com prehensible In his endeavor to get away from all local history in contradistinction to the larger fleld of State politics, the author has fallen into the error of neglecting to take full account of political events in New York city and their Influence on the State. He does scant justice to the growth and development of Tammany, the power of which was already recognized “up-State” in the first quarter of the last century It may be that the author's theory of the dominant power of personality allows him to minimize the importance of such sig- nificant movements as those of the Equal Rights party, the Anti-Renters, and the Anti-Masons, the origin of which could not be traced to some “controlling spirit.” There are some misstatements that show In Volume IL, pag- on 45 and 47, the statement is made that Burr had already (1789) served two terms in the Legislature, whereas he had only been a member of the Assembly of 1784-86 Gideon Granger was not a member of the Cabinet, as stated on page 202 of Volume I The postmaster-general was only made a Cabinet officer in 1829, when President Jackson's needs demanded it. E. D. Mor- carelessness of detall gan was chairman of the Republican na- tional committee from 1856 to 1864, but was never chairman of a Republican na- The story is well told, tional convention, as the author states, in Volume II., page 248. What Mr. Alexander has done ts to give an interesting, although, perhaps, a too uncritical, account of political leaders and events in a field of American history that was practically unoccupied. To the reader, who has hitherto found it impossible to get anything like a general idea of early New York politics in a single work, the volumes should prove a boon. RECENT FICTION. The Dream and the Business, By John Oliver Hobbes. New York: D. Appleton & Co This novel was already in press when its brilliant author suddenly died. It may well enough stand as her monument, for it suggests everything characteristic in her substance and manner. It says, per- haps, quite all that the next generation will care to hear of Mrs. Craigie. On this point one cannot affect to speak with cer- tainty, since cleverness is so often mere- ly a veil or a distraction which time may sweep away. The publishers have given the volume conspicuousness by setting it between ex- ceedingly garish, even lurid, covers, and by securing an introtluction from the hand of the Hon. Joseph H. Choate. This is more properly an obituary note than, as the publisher tags it, “an appreciation of Mrs. Craigie as woman and author.” Mr Choate was a personal friend of Mrs. Crai- gie He speaks of the freshness and pi- quancy of her conversation, and proceeds: The same qualities imparted to what she wrote and what she said a marked light- ness and delicacy of touch, which was per- haps the most striking feature of her lit- erary character, and her chaste and fastid- ious taste so controlled and permeated her thoughts and feelings that one can read all her many books from beginning to end without finding a word or sentiment io offend the most delicate standard. All, we observe, in the best obituary manner, which is for critical purposes the worst manner possible. Some score of years ago Mrs. Craigie captivated the world of English novel- readers by her first appearance in fiction. American born, French bred, she found her proper home in England. London seized and held her as it had seized and held Mr. James. And in turn she captured London with her sallies. She flashed, she sparkled, she was knowing and taking, and in all senses smart. She did extremely well what was hardly worth doing. She was, in short, a soubrette whose daring parlor perform- ances won the approbation of the “‘smart- est” people. Mrs. Craigie’s standard is the standard of convenance, and much of her charm is due to the grace and skill with which she manwuvres upon the ragged edge of inconvenance. Sex is her ab- sorbing theme, and more especially the perils of matrimony as experienced by the socially elect. In this last novel of hers “the dream” is love, inconsiderate of bar- riers religious, financial, or social; “the business” is life shorn of illusion, accept- ing love no longer as a delirium or an inspiration, but as a rather mournful prob- lem. None of the persons in this story, wed or unwed, find lasting happiness in love. But the wed, we are given to under- stand, have clearly the worse of a bad choice. Both looked resigned and at the stage in unsatisfactory human _ relationships when the pair, having exhausted their mu- tual dislike, were almost attached to each other by a common bond of suffering. They were seldom in complete sympathy. and they were drifting by degrees into the calm friendship of those who, having no illusion about each other, also never blend. Tessa dared not tell herself that they were friends who, in marriage, were mis- mated; domestic both, they failed to ap- peal to each other’s particular kind of domesticity. So our various wedded pairs are de- scribed; or, by way of generalization, thus: “A set composed of rich, agreeable cou- ples who lived to amuse themselves and each other, without scandal if possible, but at any rate with audacity.” One of these discontented couples is ac- tually restored to some sort of union. This happy consummation is led up to by a long interview, in which varied causes of discontent are thoroughly threshed over. Each of them, incidentally, confesses an inclination for an outsider. It is hard to take these persons seriously; they are not persons, but variously costumed interloc- utors. They are all clever, sophisticated, desirous of compunctions and half-shades of feeling; capable of paradox and epi- gram. There are “good things’’ of the lat- ter sort to catch the eye on every hand: One of the most sincere men I know has run away with his neighbor’s wife, robbed bis best friend, and drinks too much habitually. He would despise a mor- al person, and think him mad or a hypo- crite. Women like display of feeling, not its depths. The arts are but drugs for the disap- pointed imagination. People who wished to regard divine Providence as an English gentleman of large fortune, perfect morals, an anxiety to frustrate the foreigner, and a wish to feed, rather than to meet, the poor, were disturbed by Firmalden’s fear of God, which to some seemed superstition, and to others ill-advised. Only a few years ago Mrs. Craigie be- came a convert to the Roman faith; and it is not surprising that this last novel, in its most serious aspect, should be a sort of quiet brief for the Church as the only sure refuge for the heart-weary and world- ly-wise. Carnival or Lent—these are the poles of her experience; one perceives something rather middle class about sim- ple human happiness. The smart world deserves to be chronicled, like other worlds; but too much may be made of its artificial complexities. Sophistication, standing in wonder at its own reflected image, is not a theme for song. Sophy of Kravonia. By Anthony Hope. New York: Harper & Brothers. Mr. Hawkins cannot be called mute, yet as to the note that he sounded in “The Pris- oner of Zenda” his harp mouldering long has hung. His Rupert was hardly more than a spurious claimant to the affectionate in- terest aroused by the former book. In “Sophy of Kravonia,"’ however, there comes a lawful heir to enthusiasm. In no way con- nected with its honored forerunner, it pulls at the same heartstrings. By a reversal it is now an English woman whose fortunes knot themselves up with those of a mythi- ew oe en cg Oe ee ee ne aw
Page 19
"aoe hee Siat Oct. 25, 1906] The Nation. 353 —— > cal kingdom, yet there is nothing mythical about Sophy, though everything that is original. She is a genuine and most charm- ing.person, with “her masculine mind and her feminine soul’’—described by an admir- er as being “like a singularly able and energetic sunbeam.” The whole eventful story is so well knit that each marvel seems not only possible but almost in- evitable, from the childhood of Sophy Grouch, daughter of an Essex farmer, till the time when she sits in the dwellings of kings, and wears the sheepskin tunic of the shepherd subjects of her prince. The conspiracy which thickens the plot is capl- tally developed, and long before the matter is solved the reader has quite forgotten that at the outset there was a certain sense of oppressiveness in the very serious marshal- ling of documentary evidence, as if for the history of a nation or the biography of a nation’s hero. Listener's Lure. By E. V. Lucas. New York: The Macmillan Co. It is pleasant to relax from the strain of romantic or psychological narrative in the presence of a bit of good comedy cast in the despised and almost obsolescent epis- tolary form. The truth is, our pampered jades of fiction have learned to demand a free rein; without the power to invent their own forms, to describe and to com- ment and narrate as the spirit moves, they would reckon themselves hardly better off than mere dramatists. The people who write these letters are all delightful and all dif- ferent; and the story in which they col- laborate, while of no essential novelty, is agreeable, and seems true. There is a guar- dian unconsciously in love with his ward, and a ward unconsciously in love with her guardian. He magnanimously sends her away that she may have a chance to fall undesirably in love with somebody else. She goes so far as to make a false start in that direction, but recovers her footing in time, and everything should be. This might easily be tame, but the central af- fair is so enlivened by the commentary of several subsidiary persons, both wise and foolish, as to achieve a really fresh savor. Especially invaluable is a garrulous and in- consequent lady of the order of Jane Aus- ten’s Mrs. Bates. With her we are loath to part when the customary wedding bells ring down the curtain. is as it Ridolfo: The Coming of the Dawn. By Egerton R, Williams, jr. Chicago. A. C. McClurg & Co. This is sub-entitled “A Tale of the Renaissance.” The characters are ficti- tious, but their names and their deeds and their surroundings are borrowed from the histories of “The Magnificent Baglioni,” long the ferocious despots of Perugia. Ridolfo himself is suggested by the great- est of the Baglioni, Gianpaolo, who to his strength and violence added an element of magnanimity. The book tells of the culmination of Ridolfo’s cruelties, the dawning of a conscience, and the triumph of his better self through the love of a saintly wife and the martyrdom of a Fran- ciscan monk. The proper moment to read the tale is when the brain is fagged with books of trivial twentieth-century griev- ances and perplexities. Crimes and virtues are on a sweeping scale Oaths broken at will; a dagger for the annoying meddler, a cup of poison for the interceding wife. have a definiteness that well with the niggling problem of to-day's fic- alternates tion. The torture chamber may try the nerves, but it was perhaps necessary that the reader should see what Ridolfo saw in order to understand his conversion The author has searched well the his- tcry of Italy and the fifteenth century, and has his splendors and brutalities drawn up in effective contrast. His Fra Bernardo, based upon that saint Bernardino who came to Perugia in 1425, is a noble type of the followers of the Saint of Assisi, giv- ing his labor and his life for the revival of the spirit of kindness. Gismonda, the compassionate, long-suffering wife of the tyrant, conquering by love and righteous- ness, is not more than the others a por- trait of any one person, but a reflection of the womanly inspiration that was not lacking to even that dark period The book is a vivid picture where the high color is offset, perhaps mercifully, by the treatment time careful, leisurely, sermonizing While the flags, for much description of persons, things and story neve! there is Situations, of costumes and armor, in an equal absence of haste and rest. It leaves “a strong and even valuable impression of an age which it look back at, not only when modern puzzles seem petty, but is well to when modern civilization seems defec- tive Some Reminiscences of William Michael Rossetti. Two volumes Imported by Charles Scribner's Sons. New York. $10 | net It may as well be said explicitly that these memoirs are a disappointment. They contain an unconscionable deal of matter for which even the present fashion of in- discriminate autobiography can furnish no the illness justification—details about servants in the Rossetti the wife and children, domestic Nor the annoying than the excesses Holman Hunt published, what presumptuous title of ‘‘Pre-Raphael- the Pre-Raphaelite Brother- autobiography the burden of prove that the only faithful It was easy to read between Mr. Hunt jealous of Dante Gabriel Rossetti and not averse to belittling his fame. Naturally one looked in the present work to see some rejoinder, implied or expressed, to those rather ego- household, of his concerns of all sorts are omissions any less Only last year the under some- itism and hood,” an which was to the founder and the P. R. B. the that writer was member of lines was tistic assumptions Apparently Mr. Ros- setti has not even read that work; we gather, indeed, that his own record was completed in 1903, although the Preface is dated 1906, and includes the mention of the Complete Poetical Works of Christina Rossetti, which he edited in 1904. But the omission of any allusion to Hunt's auto- biography or to the “Memorials of Edward Burne-Jones" (1904) the most se- rious fault. The fact Mr. Russetti has in various memoirs and introductions all his wheat and that only the chaff is left for this garnering. He is kind enough to give in the Preface a list of his earlier writings, and this is well; but it is annoying, just when we are approach- is not is that given eut | raisonné of Mr ing an interesting topic, to be warned off with a reference to number 16 or 17 of his other writings For after page we have a catalogue Rossettt's among artists and men of letters page acquaintance to each of whom he devotes a paragraph of character! and may have kind of per dull of more en zation. His opinions are just form but there value in this sonal “Who's Who reading Here tertaining gossip slips in some asa they make and a bit Thus there is a of Chris which ta whole chapter given to the story tina Rossetti and Charles Cayley for a Christina's sonnet Innominata,” and for the Rosseggiar dell’ Oriente.” In the memoir Mr. Rossetti left this affair in the vague, saying distinctly “or the important to a close understanding of it—I understanding of Monna poema “Il necessary proper sequence named 4 Itallan earlier some what several details in second case—though never was cognizant." He now states more emphatically that the only bar between the lovers was Christina's refusal to bind her self to an unbeliever It is a pity that Mr. Rossetti’s fire has | been thus scattered, for his relation to his | brother and sister and to the whole cir cle of pre-Raphaelites might have furnish- |}ed him with material for one really valu | able and interesting book As it is, if one | wishes to get some notion of the da#monic quality of Dante Gabriel and of his strange influence on that group of ardent the best source is not the “‘Rem- of his brother, Mrs lished the “Memorials” The zations reformers iniscences” but the two vol Burne-Jones has pub- of her husband interesting of the of Burne-Jones, umes in which most characteri- are those who is portrayed as rather effeminate; of Swin- burne, and of Trelawny. Perhaps the best anecdote is that which shows the state of canting prudery in England when Swin- burne’s “Poems and Ballads” came out. The story may be given in Mr. Rossetti’s own words: In 1868, Mr. Legros exhibited in the Royal Academy an excellent picture of some monks or friars at their repast called The Refectory. There was a tabby cat painted in the picture In that year a pamphlet of Notes on Mr. Swinburne wrote was published the art of the season one section of it, and I the other. Swin burne—who is a great lover of cats (a fancy which J share with him), and also (a fancy which I only very faintly share) of serpents—wrote of this painted quadru ped as “a splendid cat.” The picture was bought—presumably before Swinburne’s eulogium had appeared—by a person of some distinction. Many years afterwards, in 1895, I had occasion to look at this paint- ing in the house of the heir of the original purchaser To my surprise, the cat had disappeared. “Why,” said I, “there used to be a cat in that corner of the picture.” “Yes."’ replied the owner, “there was; but my predecessor, on seeing that Swinburne had found a good word to say for the cat, got her obliterated forthwith.” An Introduction to Logic. By Horace Wi1- liam Brindley Joseph. Oxford: The Clar endon Press. It is surprising in what a variety of ways the different schools of logic of our day endeavor to lay the foundations of their science. One appeals chiefly to math ematics, another to metaphysics, a third to the general notion of a sign,a fourth and fifth to thie and that branch of psychology,
Page 20
354 a sixth to linguistics, a seventh to the history of science; and still the list is incomplete; and there is an equal disagree- ment as to the business of logic The school to which Mr. Joseph seems to give his adherence, which is that of the ma- jority of English logicians, is none of those just mentioned; for it troubles itself very little with any questions of method, but just goes its way, scattering opinions upon points of logic, and attaching to this one ind to that any reason that may suggest itself. Such promiscuity of method might be expected to issue in great variations 1smong the doctrines of the different mem- bers of the school; and it is true that some of its adherents—Miss Constant Jones, for example, and Alfred Sidgwick—have writ- ten books of marked originality, which readers who dip into the subject without diving too deep find very suggestive The greater number, however, among them the author of this volume, are led, by what- ever unseen and inscrutable power it may be, to reproduce in the main the divisions and forms of the traditional logic, slightly modified by metaphysical doctrines, partly in most cases those of Mill, mixed not in- frequently with those of Mill's philosophi- cal antipodes When, however, we say they reproduce the traditional divisions, we only mean that verbally they do so, for the significations ome of them attach to the old terms of logic, have only preserved the shell and have cast away the kernel For instance, Mr. Joseph excludes from the class of uni- versal propositions all those which do not imply the existence of some individuals de- noted by their subject, as well as all those which do not predicate by “conceptual necessity,’ both of which exclusions flatly conflict with the Dictum de omni of Aris totle and with all tradition, and which taken together, make one simple proposition to express at once both existence and ne sity, which constitutes a third breach of raditional usage in connection with the use of the single term “universal.” In such way is this he effects a verbal agreement with the traditional doctrine by demoli tions of parts of the existing system of nomenclature and using the débris to begin, but only to begin the erection of a new system in the place of it, like that architectural performance of Charles V. in Granada We shall not find fault with any man for any sincere study; and if it gives him any particular pleasure to call his study logic, that word is by this time pretty near past spoiling. Only we would suggest that to define one's object of study in such a way that searce anything would be exclud od--as when Mr. Joseph and others of his achool tell u that logic ascertains “how we think it seems fair to demand that their conclusions should be based upon in ductionsa correspondingly broad The re viewer, for example, can have nothing but praise for a logie he dimly remembers reading in the sixties, which carefully anal lyzed all those phrases of the German lan guage that are equivalent to conjunctions without any pretence that it covered all the possibilities of thought tn this narrow clase of conjunctional elements. We might think, however, that before coming to those variations of thought, it would be better to begin by considering all the ways in which The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 we must think in order to draw all kinds of necessary conclusions; for even if logic be concerned with all modes of thinking, we are inclined to the opinion that it is specially concerned with those forms of thought that have some bearing upon the validity or non-validity of different ways of reasoning It was fifty-nine years ago that Professor De Morgan called attention to certain forms of inference of great prac- tical importance, which nothing in the logic-books explained or gave any clue to, although it is necessary to sound reasoning to distinguish the cases in which such arguments are valid from the cases in which they are invalid. Yet we do not remember ever having seen any mention of these forms of inference in any treatise of Mr. Joseph's school. Here is an example of one of them: Every dollar that ever was or will be in the safe was or will have been received as a loan For every dollar ever received as a loan a payment of a dollar will be made. Hence, every dollar that ever was or will be in the safe was or will be paid out. When De Morgan opened this road te logical inquiry, he opened a road to semp- iternal glory for British logic; but un- fortunately investigators of any vigor uf thought were lacking. De Morgan did much more than that; for he also opened up the logic of relations, which had from the be- ginning been a well-recognized branch of logic, and which, when American and Ger- man logicians developed it, turned out to throw a wonderful new light upon every part of logic, while the logicians of the Oxford school merely advanced little rea- suns for thinking a logic of relations to be impossible. The distinguished mathematical genius, George Boole, produced a method of logical inquiry by means of algebra, which was a most brilliant achievement. A few logicians of the most numerous Brit- ish school have paid attention to the Boolian logic We mention here, not be cause they are the best, but because they are the most soundly critical, Venn, Je- vons, and Keynes. The great body seem never to have looked into it. Posterity will say that human intelli- gence is under vast obligations to the log- ical work of Alfred Bray Kempe, sometime President of the London Mathematical So- ciety. But one may search in vain for any evidence that logicians of the school we are speaking of, have so much as divined what relevancy his laborious researches have for any real problem of reasoning. It is a matter of regret to us that the brevity of this notice forces us to confine ourselves to Mr. Joseph's faults, since they are the faults of his school, and it is not quite fair to the individual to judge him exclusively according to the genus to which he belongs. But the truth is that when we have said that this treatise pos- sesses such original merits as the majority of the thousand treatises can claim that have appeared since Michael Scott and the western publication of Aristotle, and per- haps possesses a little more, we have ac- corded to it all the notice it merits; while its school is of more importance simply on sxccoount of its numerical greatness, and be- cause of the evil that it is working to British thought. This school is composed mostly of indolent and often feeble minds whose interest in logic lies in the profes- sorships, the fellowships, the popularity as tutors, or other sources of bread and but- ter which they enjoy, and who are there- fore sworn obscurantists, bound to oppose any movement of real thought in Eng- lish logic. When a study fails to de- velop definite and well-considered meth- ods; when it is not animated by a sufficient passion to find out the truth, whatever the truth may be, to insure the careful study of all the work that earnest students do within its province; and when in place of manifold new discoveries, it does no more than verbally reproduce fore- gone conclusions, it is idle to boast that is a science. Mr. Joseph sometimes lays down general propositions without any pretence at mak- ing their reasonableness evident; and he justifies this practice by saying that his book is not a complete treatise on logic, but, as its title indicates, is only “an in- troduction to logic.’’ Now, says he, in the first introduction to any science there must be more or less dogmatism. Is this Oxford pedagogics? Elsewhere, if a man is to write an introduction to any science—say chemis- try—he will draw a clear line between in- formation as to what has happened, and dogmatic insistence upon principles and the like, and will take the utmost pains in de- scribing, say, the experiments of Lavoisier upon the oxidation and reduction of mer- cury, to show the convincingness of the rea- soning; so as to remove the idea that there is to be any appeal to authority or other arbitrary determination of principles. If he has to teach botany, he will probably set the beginner at work to dissect a flower with his own eyes and fingers, and to de- scribe what he sees; and will be careful to make him understand that botany is only an orderly description of what can always be seen under favorable conditions. It ap- pears to some of us that the first steps in any science ought to deal with those de- partments of the science that come most in contact with the life and interests of the students; and we should not approve of an introduction to botany, whose first two hundred pages were occupied with the arti- ficial, though indispensable, technicalities that botanists are compelled to use in order to describe species and other forms. Yet it is the like of that, that Mr. Joseph does in logic; and useful as his book may prove to an advanced logician, it is almost the worst possible for a beginner’s introduction to the subject. The Arbiter in Council. New York: The Macmillan Co., $2.50 net. This anonymous octavo volume of more than 550 pages discusses peace and war. It is in the form of an elaborate sym- posium, supplemented by various reports in writing by the dramatia persone, among whom are Reginald Case, K. C., a barrister “with aconscience,”” Martin Truelove, in holy orders, the Rev. Augus- tine Clarke, an Independent minister, Leo- pold Meyer, a stock broker, William Browne, a learned Cambridge historian and pupil of Lord Acton, Captain Seymour of the Intelligence Department of the War Office, and Tracy de Vere, a retired ad- miral. The Arbiter himself is Mr, Ash- worthy, a veteran Liberal of seventy- 4 el es cl nim 22
Page 21
Oct. 25, 1906] The Nation. five, and disciple of John Bright. For every day during a week there is a discussion; the subjects discussed the causes and consequences of war, modern warfare, pri- vate war and the duel, cruelty, the fed- eration of the world, arbitration, the po- are litical economy of war, Christianity and war. As a summary of all that is to be said on the subject, thrown into a readable form, the book is well done; nevertheless, after reading it there is left in the mind of the reader the perhaps unavoidable feel- ing that it is an old story; that after all, we knew before that does not exist because there is anything to be said for it, but in spite of overwhelming evidence that it is the worst possible calamity. In other words, the book is a demonstration of what It is store- war nobody can successfully dispute. chiefly valuable, therefore, as a house of all the wisdom of the ages on the subject. Fifty years ago, so thoroughly was the world convinced of the disadvantages of war, that we doubt if the author could have found a publisher. In the last fifty years there has been a revival of the old fallacy, transmitted from the pre-indus- trial predatory period, that one of the ob- jects of national existence is war, and that there is a great deal to be said for war in the The progress of democracy, too, has thrown political power, which in- cludes that of making war, into the hands of vast masses of men who know little or nothing of history or political economy, and who are prone to the delusion that it is upon successful war that the greatness hinges. So that we are un- doubtedly living in a generation which much needs the wisdom contained in this volume Could it be instilled into the masses who now pleased with taxes imposed for battleships, and deluded with the notion that ‘‘Trade follows the flag,’”’ it would do more good than has been done by any one book the world, unless it be the Bible. Unfortunately, it is unlikely to be read except by those who are in sym- pathy with its argument. This, at least, is the impression made upon us. If we are wrong, so much the better. The only argument in favor of was brought forward in recent times that has any novelty in it, is that brought to our attention by the neo-Imperialists and re- actionaries here and in England, within the last twenty-five years—that war is a school of fortitude, and heroism. The im- plication is that you need war to foster those virtues. The answer to this sugges- tion is, of course, that there are countless ways in times of peace in which fortitude and heroism may be and are fostered. The fireman, the policeman, the sailor, the en- gineer, are heroically risking their lives every day, without the stimulus of drum or trumpet. But, besides this, it would be the work of a lunatic to introduce calamity and destruction in order to foster the virtues. We do not scuttle ships in order to develop the desire to save the lives of others at the expense of our own, nor set fire to a city for the sake of filling people with zeal to extinguish the flames. The idea that we can defend war by such an argument is abstract. of nations are in preposterous. It is not in arguments of thig sort that actual war finds it support. The fundamen- tal reason for war, the unanswerable rea- son, before arbitration between nations became recognized as an available substi- tute, that it the The last resort of sovereigns ment is exhausted, is violence particular case, the question always is, not whether the good thing in itself, qué war, but whether it was avoid- able We defend the of the Revolu- tion as having been forced on us civil is is ultima ratio requm after argu- Hence in any war was not a war In wars both sides usually imagine themselves to have into taking arms The great of age is that most wars are preventable by arbitration. If been driven discovery up our the world at large ever became persuaded that itself was a good inevitably the into that stage of they have emerged datory stage, in which war the natural which every man is trained first dier, and peace is regarded as the would back which pre- war thing, it throw leading nations civilization from the military or nized as is ree means of a State's growth, in to be sol- exce p- tion It is impossible to make extracts which will give any idea of the book as a whole. In the wide range of the no topic is left untouched, from the ques- tion of the Early Christian and practice as regards military subject, almost doctrine service, down to the question whether a general arbitra- tion treaty should or bar matters affecting The varied scholarship and reading drawn upon include everything, national honor give no clue, as far as we know, to the authorship. The Spirit of Democracy. By Charles F Dole. New York: Thomas Y. Crowell & Co. $1.20 net. In both its matter and its manner, Mr Dole’s book will undoubtedly please a good many It begins with the criticism of history—or, rather, of histori- cal writing—as largely concerned with the wrong sort of thing; it defines the “spirit of democracy” in terms which may much or little, according to the notions of those who use them; rapidly in review, with a considerable wealth of stim- ulating suggestion, a large number of con- temporary social conditions and problems; and it leaves the clear impression that, in the opinion of the author, the world is get ting on better than ever and is pretty sure to come out all right. That which is saving us from our sins, and fitting us not only for the life that now is, but also for that which is to come, is democracy. With the formal aspects of democracy, as a scheme or political organization, indeed, much thinks that the people. familiar mean it passes of government Mr. Dole himself, though he dent of the United States has quite much power, especially in the of appointments, and that American munici- pal government is pretty bad. What ests him most the worldwide develop ment of a temper by good-will, the rights of others hu- manity, justice, is giving way to cooperation jection is a painful anomaly, the exploita- tion of alien or inferior peoples a relic of barbarism, and war a crime. Of one blood are all the nations of the earth; let us live does not, concern Presi- too matter inter is distinguished for social neighborliness, and the good of all, regard Competition and peace Economic sub- as such! Mr. Dole is not, indeed, under the de- | susten that we have as yet perf: ;} ihn us | for ed all have done to this He inkly admits hat we those thine hat we ought to have done 1 have eft ind the things we ought to have d He d however, to believe that ¢} t healt On the contrary, } irvey f ent-day social interests and a \ has its object, apparently the that comings amid al yur re ib! the atmosphere tion Spirit of tru en ra of social ot ! regard, more and more yp. ? ‘ ! The tramples American party syst: f cample minorities and ‘ il but the | on political interest disintegrating the pa ind fa the of ma are ; y racy is voring formation Crime and pauperism we are attacking the causes of poverty and the perialism is a sordid reforming criminal. Our policy of affair by good mer Heaven and we reprobated are realizing its error and get rid of it. Our system vicious and undemocrat unrestricted migration a menace, and divorce a profound but the augurs the evil; growing Situation a remedy ofr Mr point nile fairly fertile: and at tl that we coms ipon the fundamental limitation of his book A an) exposition of the spirit of social altruism which ibr of small, of modern velal remedies Dole is humanity the land, and iknessa unity oad in the we as a entation lefects pres large or organization, the volume that is admirabl The tyle is nervou and epigrammatic, and the choles lustrations quite up to dats here is a directness, a downrightns oO manne that gives to its statement in air of com pleteness and finality be When from on of gratifying the dictment slight specificat and they are nn he fow and rutinize his 4 compelled to lhoes Mr power of the edie s, we are Dole real Presid ile inadequate the to strangely ly believe that likely tailment, or that better if it did; or that “popula we quote his jar is ever undergo whol things would be app clably taxation to be made acterization—by heavier be fined or dis attend taxes or that indirect on land; or men will franchised for failure to caucuses or vote; or that our great political partie ire to be replaced by a régime of political groups? If he does, then we cannot but commend to him, with all deference, the further study of that history for whose incidents he has, apparently, only limited respect We need to-day very much, as a great democratic State, two forms of service We need an accurate, clear, and thorough going description of actual social ond tions, and a sound, practical, restrained indication of ways in which we may bet ter ourselves To the satisfaction of the first of these needs Mr. Dole has made 4 worthy and suggestive contribution bu we cannot think that his treatment if the second has permanent significan
Page 22
The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 Drama. THE HOUSE OF MIRTH The production in the Savoy Theatre, on Monday, of a dramatized version of Mrs Wharton's “House of Mirth,” done by the author and Clyde Fitch, raised more than a ripple of excitement in theatrical circles, but did not prove to be a matter of much literary or dramatic importance. It did, however, afford one more practical demon- tration of the enormous difficulties attend- ing the conversion of a book into drama. The hopeless feat would not be attempted, of course, if it were not for the commer- cial value of a popular title. Mr. Fitch, who doubtless did most of the work of adaptation, has succeeded wonderfully well in preserving the chief incidents and per- sonages. but only at the cost of excluding nearly everything that made the original tory worth while. Stripped of all literary accompaniment, all discussion of charac- er. motive, and circumstance, Lily Bart and her associates become stage puppets of a very ordinary type, differing in no im- portant respect from those employed in many a modern melodrama There is no- thing novel or especially entertaining in their silly small talk, their cynicism, self hness, and immorality If the play had any fine comic or satiric quality, excited profound sympathy, or was rich in the ele- ment of suspense, the case would be alter- ed But it has nothing that resembles a plot, makes no appeal to the finer human impulses, and practically no attempt to lash or to ridicule the degeneracy which it represents In the last act, indeed, Lily, having drunk the cup of her own folly to the dregs, has a striking speech, in which he arraigns society for the callous indif- ference with which it discards disgraced or mpoverished wretches, but this is only a personal protest, without general applica- tion. Thus the play lacks a valid purpose us well as sympathetic quality. Even those persons who deny that the theatre has any mission to instruct or to preach, admit that it must entertain or perish. In “The liouse of Mirth” there is nothing that pro- motes either merriment or edification It offers more or less veracious exposures of bad habits, but cannot be described as in ‘ny sense a comedy of manners. To the ginal book it bears about the same rela- keleton does to the complete on a the mat rhe redeeming point in it as a play the opportunity which it offers to Miss Fay Davie for some very clever acting She |Hustrates the different phases in Miss Hart's downward career with much subtle perception, executive skill, and emotional power The long- promised revival of Shakspere’s Cymbeline made this week in the Astor Theatre, by Mises Viola Allen, is an am bitious and expensive but not very satis- factory achlevement The play, it is al- most needless to say, presents many prob- lems to the modern producer In the first place it is so long that cutting ts absolutely necessary to bring it within the limits of an evening's performance; and in the second, it has an exceedingly in volved plot, so that it is diMficult to cut it heavily without rendering it unintelll gible. This difficulty is increased when time has to be secured for the manipula- tion of elaborate scenery, such as Miss Allen has provided. She has, indeed, sacrificed so much to mere spectacle that the part by Shakspere in the production is often subordinate to the contributions of the scene-painter and costumer. She probably felt that the piece was not like- ly to win popularity on its merits alone, and it must be confessed that as an acting play, with its clumsy and highly incredible story, it leaves much to be desired. But these defects are emphasized rather than concealed by a gorgeous setting. The es- sentials to an effective interpretation are a spirited and capable delivery of the text, which contains many fine passages, together with much of inferior character, and a vivid embodiment of the principal personages. Neither of these conditions exists at the Astor Theatre. The Imogen of Miss Allen, an actress of very set methods, possesses womanly charm and intelligence, but is altogether uninspired. In utterance it is very faulty. Cymbeline and his intriguing queen, Pisanio and lachimo, exhibit scarcely a vestige of the individuality and force which belong to them. The eccentric Cloten of Sidney Her- bert, though strange in conception, has at least the merit of vitality and consistent design. The Posthimus, too, is right in conception. The havoc made of the text, including some of the most famous pas- sages, by minor performers was lament- able. Much of it was unintelligible at close range. On the whole the performance is rather dispiriting, as it shows that the art of speaking blank verse is almost ex- tinct upon the stage. But Miss Allen is entitled to credit for her personal en- deavor, and it is pleasant to know that she is playing to full houses. A new play, by a new author, Rudolf Bessier, is to be seen in the London Adel- phi Theatre this week. It is called “‘The Virgin Goddess."" The play, written in blank verse, is modelled on the lines of old Greek drama, the action taking place in Artis, an imaginary city of ancient Greece. Three acts sre required for the development of the story, while the unities of time and place are strictly observed. A chorus figures in the piece, but its func- tion is to contribute to, rather than mere- ly to comment upon, the action. The sixtieth birthday of Holger Drach- mann was celebrated by the first perform- ance of his latest romantic drama, “Sir Olaf he Rides,” at the Theatre Royal, Copenhagen, on October 9, and a banquet the following day. Music. It was no doubt a desire to exploit her comic vein that induced the greatest living contralto, Mme. Schumann-Heink, to aban- don the concert stage and grand opera two years ago and devote herself to operetta. Her admirers shook their heads over this procedure, and there was great joy among them when it was announced that she would return to the Metropolitan Opera House this season as well as to the concert hall, deserting a specialty which was suited velther to her matronly appearance sor to ,her big voice. On Saturday afternoon last Carnegie Hall was filled by an audience eager to welcome her back to her legiti- mate sphere. Although reports had come from Germany of her great triumphs last summer at Bayreuth and Munich, there was still some anxiety as to the possible harm that might have come to her voice from the wear and tear of the operetta stage; but this was soon dispelled. While there were traces of damage, and while the singer has acquired a habit of injudicious breath- ing, these things seemed hardly worth men- tioning in view of all the noble qualities of her art—her clear enunciation, her re- fined phrasing, her great command of tone colors, and above all her splendid dramatic temperament, which enables her to seize the real gist of a song and present it to the delighted audience in a stirring climax. An interesting novelty is to be produced at the first concert of the New York Ora- torio Society—‘“‘The Children’s Crusade.” It is a musical legend in four parts adapted from the poem by Marcel Schwob, with music by Gabriel Pierné, who won a prize with this work, which made a good impres- sion in Paris. The vocal score with Eng- lish text by Henry Grafton Chapman has just been issued by G. Schirmer. The Ora- torio Society will also sing “The Mes- siah,”’ as usual, and Elgar’s “Apostles,” as well as the newly added Part III, entitled “The Kingdom.” Boston is not yet certain of an opera season, Mr. Conried, manager of the Metro- politan Opera House, having promised a week or two only on condition that a suffi- cient guarantee fund is raised. But an in- teresting operatic novelty will be presented by the Cecilia Society, which annuunces a performance, in concert form, of the late Prof. J. K. Paine’s “‘Azara.” One of the treats in store for the music-lovers of London is a performance, under Hans Richter, of Liszt’s “‘Dante Sym- phony,” a composition which, because of its great difficulties, is seldom given. Wag- ner called it “an eternal work,” “a crea- tion equally inspired and masterly.” Even Michael Angelo, he wrote, did not succeed in infusing the soul of Dante into another art so thoroughly as Liszt did in this score, which could not have been writ- ten until after Bach and Beethoven had done their work. While Liszt was the most cosmopolitan of all musicians and spent but a fraction of his life in his native country, many Hun- garians think that his remains should, at any rate, be buried near where he was born, Raiding. In that district, a large Catholic church is being built, and it is proposed to erect in it a monument to Liszt on the hundredth anniversary of his birth, 1911. The local authorities are also making an effort to secure his remains, and the plan is to have them transferred next September, when a Liszt statue is to be unveiled in the new Academy of Music at Budapest. It seems doubtful, however, whether it will be possible to carry out this idea. Liszt died in Bayreuth and was buried in the cemetery there. An ef- fort was made at the time to make Weimar his last resting place; but even with the ald of the Grand Duke Carl Alexander, the project failed. Liszt belonged to the order of Franciscans, and ove of the rules of this aman latin thee
Page 23
Oct. 25, 1906] order is that members must be buried in the place where they die. The Allgemeine Musik-Zeitung also calls attention to the fact that Liszt’s last will of the date of 1867, contained these directions: “My body is to be buried not in a church, but in a public cemetery, and let no one undertake to remove it thence to another place.” Three years later, he said in a private let- ter: “I protest most emphatically against the dragging about of my corpse.” Finally, it is not likely that Frau Wagner would consent to the removal of her father’s re- mains. The unprecedented price of 44,000 marks is demanded by a Leipzig bookseller for the manuscript of Beethoven's “‘Waldstein” sonata, and the German bewspapers ex- press the fear that, because of this high price, the sonata will, like so many other precious documents, go to America. Art. THE HOLMAN HUNT EXHIBITION. LONDON, October 10. the merits of the Pre- their friends, business the least. There had been movements in art of far more importance long before their day, there have been movements as amusing since. But there has hardly ever been one 80 well advertised, so well talked about. Indeed, since Ruskin first constituted him- self their champion, the Pre-Raphaelites have figured much more effectively on the written page than on the painted canvas. Whatever were Raphaelites and capacity was not Their influence on art has been simply nil. For a while they had their followers, who threatened to monopolize the Gros- venor Gallery and then the New Gallery in its early days; and even until some ten years or so ago, critics had still much to say of the neo-Gothic School. But all this has completely passed. Anything less neo- Gothic than the New Gallery now in its spring exhibitions can scarcely be imag- ined. And, if you except Byam Shaw and Miss Brickdale, who still dabble in the old motives and methods, not a trace of Pre-Raphaelitism is left, and yet books about it continue to appear The opening of an exhibition of the life work of Mr. Holman Hunt comes 4s a use- ful reminder of what Pre-Raphaelitism really means. It is easier to judge it dis- passionately, now that more than fifty years have passed since the first rumors of it startled a mid-Victorian world. too decorous to be in sympathy with move- ments of any kind. If we are to believe him, Mr. Holman Hunt is, and always has been, its only true exponent. In his work, therefore, if anywhere, the movement may be studied profitably. Fortunately, a thor- oughly representative collection has been got together. The exhibition is held in the Leicester Galleries, whose managers have done everything possible to arrange pictures and drawings to the best advan- tage. Mr. Holman Hunt has never, even in 1886, been so well seen. Very few im- One looks portant pictures are missing in vain for the “Christians Escaping from Druid Persecution” and the “‘Rienzi’’—his firet declarations of faith, they might be The Nation. called—for the “Awakened and the two larger versions of the “Light of the World.” But otherwise. the series is fairly complete From the “Hireling Shepherd” and thf “Strayed Sheep" to the first Eastern pictures; from the “Finding of the Saviour in the Temple,” the “Scape- Conscience” goat,”’ and the “Shadow of the Cfoss" to the “Isabella and the Pot of Basil" and the record of the second journey to the East; from the “Triumph of the Innocents” and the “Distribution of the Holy Fire in the Church of the Sepulchre, Jerusalem,” to the ‘“‘May Morning on Magdalen Tower” and the “Lady of Shalott,’’ finished only yesterday—they are all here And there are the portraits from various periods: of himself, his wife, Sir Richard Owen the most conspicuous. And there are also many of the water-colors and drawings these last including several of the prelim- inary studies for the illustrations to Mox- on’s Tennyson and of the most fa- mous publications of the sixties To be honest, the first glance galleries gives one something of a The distressing of where, the hard, graceless forms that to jump you the canvas the exaggerations, the of feeling things are other round the shock discord color every seem from lack these Yet by as you would the painter at and of pass repose decorative an fence to thie Holman Hunt who plays his antics on canvas for the scandal There is taking the seriousness of his work to him the grim to for himself as they are, and then to show them eye you cannot who flaunts bis eccentricities, sake of a day's sensation or no mis determination see things as he sees them for the edification of the world You need not plod through those two ponderous volumes of his auto- biography—for an autobiography, despite its name, the book really is—to under stand the toil which has ever been his one definition of art. And that is just the tragedy of it—to have labored, to have evolved theories, to have made their prac- tical long only to see things like that! One of the funda- mental perhaps I might say the fundamental dogma—of Pre-Raphaelit- that the artist should work di- rectly from nature At the moment, it was a dogma that there was reason enough to cry aloud from English housetops. The mid-Victorian tendency was all for anec- dote neatly constructed in the studio. But very different you application a martyrdom, dogmas—or ism, was to go direct to nature is a thing from knowing how there what Realists in to The all for going was making his disturbing the were use see when France, Courbet you get Loo, were to na ture; manifesto in same time electrifying Paris about much as the London was not so years after had held the exhibition of his Salon-rejected pictures that of his Whistler, writing to another that work entirely from disturbing misleading; that it was more than to sketch from effects en plein air changed constantly that give possible only in the came the What he Raphaelitism his very Pre-Raphaelites But it many Courbet admirers was Fantin one Latour to nature was impossible to do her anyway, as and to was of know had What decision to use what nature studio young Whistler's we of the Pre-Raphaelite’s, when uncompromisingly Pre is revealed by Holman Hunt when he was came stuck to In earliest pictures not yet overpowered by a sense of duty and responsibility, before bis theory of art had become more important to him | than art itself, he did manage to see a | little beauty in the world about him. and to suggest it to a : landscape background Shepherd” is full liness of the English shines brilliantlyand tenderly on the green extent The the Hireling of the charm and ertain to ountry and the sua hillside of the “Strayed Shee; To me these two are by far the finest p ires he ever painted And yet, even at these you cannot look without the cons isness of how much he lost by pushing his theory to illogical extremes In the Hireling Shepherd” the two figures that fll the | foreground do not belong to the landscape they are not in it—they have the effect of figures cut out and pasted on For the curious part of the Pre-Raphaelites spect for detail was their indifference as to the relation of this detail to the pl! ture The most glaring instanc: f what I mean is the Huguenot Lovers’ by Mil- lais, who painted with infinite pains the walls against which the lovers stand ng before he had the slightest lea 4 the subject for which it was to be the background. In _ the Strayed Sheep” the elaborate detail is annoying, as one realizes how much better, with how much more absolute truth to nature, the effect might have been got without it rhe Pre-Raphaelites might paint a_ hillside with such minuteness that the blades of grass could be counted, but they did not render the one thing more important than all other in suggesting its character and beauty—that is, the atmosphere enveloping it Millais, who, of all the Brotherhood painted, in his “Ophelia” and ‘Marianna the most perfect Pre-Raphaelite pictures according to Pre-Raphaelite rules, who seemed to have something of the old Flem ings’ power of recording details in the most precise fashion without forgetting that the pic jure to be built up with them the Millais long realizing his enthustast! was main was not that he reformers were thing in and somehow on added, young fellow the track, Pre though, it must be Raphaelitism was deserted wrong in his case ouly for the more commonplace paths he had been so vigorous in denouncing. Ros- setti, with his head full of dreams of rich ensuous beauty, soon tired of a drudgery that did little to help him em- body them. Holman Hunt alone was faith ful As time went on, his eyes were con rcientiously developed into magnifying glasses; he peered more closely into Na ture for her detail, he insisted upon it more relentlessly And what was worse for his art, he began to fancy that thie pursuit of detail lent some sepectal spiritual force to his work. His story of himself as one of struggles that the quality of his painting he journeyed the hardship, the paintings when he The public of teeth the the morality, painter is do with fact that he nothing whatsoever to The that have faced of hi 4 London to East, was recommendation returned to heard of the dangers he braved Ko the to paint the of the Dead by Ruskin to anything the way he had to armed to ou And look for but Se apegoat Sea in order actual shores public, trained or religion, or
Page 24
358 what should be looked for in art, did not fail to be appropriately awed Only a few people were flippant with Millais, who suggested that before the painter un- dertook to paint a scapegoat, he should be sure of being able to paint a goat at all { can still remember the first exhibition in London of the “Triumph of the Inno- cents,” the darkened room in which one sat. and the hushed voices offering praise, and the whisper that went around of the indomitable perseverance of the painter So it is now with all Holman Hunt's pic tures. We are bidden to admire them be- cause the making of them has been so la- berious and because of their moral beauty, although beauty itself, the great essential, evaded him in his pursuit of unnecessary fact and irrelevant detail How much his Judgment was warped by the entire misconception of the business of the painter to which his theory hastened him. he reveals in the pages of his book, with its ungenerous treatment of his old friends, his egotistical determination to take all the credit for Pre-Raphaelitism He would probably be horrified to find him- self accused of egotism and want of gen- erosity—no one could be less conscious, less desirous of being either the one or the other. It is simply that his theory has taken possession of him until he seems un- able to believe in anything else, to counte- nance anything not in accord with it As in his religious pictures he has overcrowd- ed the canvas with details and symbols, so in his portraits he searches so diligently for the exact anatomical modelling, the bony construction of the face, that he gives you something that is neither flesh nor paint, while there are pictures in which, as in the “Miss Flamborough,” he endeav- ors so arduously to express the innocence of childhood, that he tumbles headlong into worse banality than he ever could have found in the Academy to protest against. In the beginning he could not see nature for the detail; his latest work shows him to have reached a point whege he cannot see detail for his theory about It To admit this is not to complain of any want of interest in the exhibition at the Leicester Galleries. On the contrary, it is exceedingly interesting, in the first place historically, and in the second because the very seriougness of intention cannot fail to be recognized Ability Mr. Holman Hunt undoubtedly possesses. It may be too soon as yet to decide what his place really is in the art of the last half century But it is safe to say that he can never be forgotten altogether His personality, the pictur- enquenesa of the famous Brotherhood, will save him. Hut when you consider his early drawings for illustration, when you look at the beautiful painting of much of the detail, when you realize the knowledge, the tech Bical mastery devoted to his sermons in paint, you can only wish he had been spared the virtue upon which he moat prides him self-that he had not been faithful, but, with Millais and Rossetti, had escaped from Pre-Raphaelitism before it made him the slave of its fallacies N.N “Engraving and Etching,” by the late Dr Fr. Lippmann, translated by Martin Hardie (Scribners), is a well-printed version in English of the best concise treatise ever written about the history of intaglio prints The Nation. There are 131 illustrations on the scale of the original engravings, and while these impressions from relief blocks inevitably lack the quality of fine engravings, they suffice to study the technic of the artists. The record is carried only to the beginning of the nineteenth century, since it was Dr. Lippmann’s belief that the revival of paint- er-etching in the last century would re- quire a separate volume. It is a matter of deep regret that he was not spared to finish his work, for no writer on the subject has so perfectly combined minute historical ac- curacy with a sober and just taste. In the present volume we could wish a more de- tailed account of printing processes—wip- ing, retroussage, etc., and could wish away only the unhappy characterization of the always reserved Nanteuil as “straining after effect."" But these are hardly blem- ishes in a well-nigh perfect handbook. For a volume that the collector and student must handle constantly, the binding with its white back, will be a trial. The pub- lishers should not thus encourage the mak- ing of relief impressions upon a work de- voted to the other branch of engraving. Dictionaries of technical terms are al- ways in demand, and rightly; but hard It is to find one which is both inexpensive and thoroughgoing. Technical terms are diffi- cult to explain in precise language; if any one doubts, let him try to translate some of them from one language into another, even allowing himself excellent knowledge of both languages and long practice, or utilizing to the full the knowledge and the practice of others. As he will not find any one term which can be translated into a Single term in another tongue, accurate in every case, so he will not find an obvious form of words in which to express the full significance of even the simplest terms of building. That fact is what Thomas Din- ham Atkinson, who has compiled a “‘Glos- sary of English Architecture” (London: Methuen & Co.), must have found by this time. That is what persons who use the book will find too frequently. Opening the volume at a venture one finds “Respond” defined as “a half-column terminating an "; but a “respond” may be a half- column or a pilaster, or a corbel, or that wall-pier for which no precise technical term is in use—a projecting mass showing perhaps five faces of an octagonal pillar or the like. And then instead of “‘terminat- ing an arcade’’ the respond may be the pilaster behind a free column, or at the end of a row of such columns, even when no arches appear in the structure. The reader may amuse himself with the task of fitting a brief sentence to the varied re- quirements of that term. The greater num- ber of the definitions in Mr. Atkinson's vol- ume are, however, intelligible, and such terms as lronwork, Greek architecture, and plaster work give excuse for articles two or three pages long, which are really intelli- gent and are likely to be of use. arcade “The Gem-Cutter’s Craft,” by Leopold Claremont, is announced by Messrs. Bell (London) as the first book upon precious stones to be written by a practical gem- cutter In it every kind of gem is de- scribed, and the difficulties of discriminat- ing precious stones are discussed The archwologist Wilhelm Volgraff has recently brought to light at Argos the re- mains of a fortified city which appears to [ Vol. 83, No. 2156 antedate the Mycenwan period. He found a large number of pieces of ceramic ware, among which was a type of “‘bucchero nero,” whose manufacture recalls that of the period of the first city of Troy, with the difference that the Trojan bucchero is fash- ioned by hand, whereas this discovery shows traces of the wheel. He has also come upon fragments of vases, painted with a fine black, with a sober decorative design of a geometric character. At the foot of the excavated hill some tombs of Myce- n@wan chiefs were opened, in which were found fragments of vases painted with geometric designs, some gold jewelry, ivory tablets, and objects of bronze, stone, and glass. The Italian Government is trying to find a way of suitably rewarding the Norwegian sculptor, Christen Dan Magelsen, for a re- markable achievement—the discovery, ap- parently, of the material used by the an- cient Greeks in modelling. Italian experts agree with G. Korte, director of the German Archeological Institute in Rome, as well as with the director of the Greco-Roman an- tiquity section of the British Museum, that Magelsen has found a clay which presents great advantages over the material now in use. Director Kérte specifies two of its advantages: it facilitates the production of hollowed objects of any form and size, and it makes possible the use of iron sup- ports without running any risks when the iron is heated, or contracts again. Bjérn- stjerne Bjérnson writes enthusiastically about Magelsen in the Christiania Verdens Gang. This man, he says, who has discov- ered a secret lost for two thousand years, was originally a mariner, and it was not till after he had reached ripe manhood that he took up sculpture, although it had been his dream since childhood. He labored under great disadvantages. He was poor, he had a large family. Yet, though he was an adept in neither physics nor chemistry, he learned to experiment with his material till he had what he wanted. The National Society of French Archi- tects has opened in Paris the public ex- position of its fifteenth annual competition. The subject proposed for the competitors was essentially modern: A railway station, designed for a city of eight or ten thou- sand inhabitants. Science. The Birds of the Cambridge Region of Massa- chusetts. By William Brewster. With four plates and three maps. Cambridge, Mass.: Memoirs of the Nuttall Ornithol- ogical Club, No. IV. Contained in a thick quarto volume of 426 broad-margined pages and handsome- ly illustrated with plates and maps, Mr. Brewster's contribution must rank, in at- tractiveness of presentation and in wealth of information, as the most sumptuous lo- cal list that has ever been published In this country. The territory covered is not a large one—some fifty square miles of country adjacent to Boston—but, to quote the introduction, “‘The birds of the Cam- bridge region have been studied longer and more continuously, as well as perhaps more carefully, than those of any other ah Fw
Page 25
Oct. 25, 1906] The Nation. locality of similar extent in all America.” For upwards of seventy years attention has been focussed on this region. Indeed, Mr. Brewster quotes freely writers of the seventeenth century, Wood, Morton, Josse- lyn; but it was not until 1832, when Nuttall, then living in Cambridge, pub- lished his ‘“‘“Manual” that the birds there began to be systematically studied. Sam- vel and J. Elliot Cabot, Henry M. Bryant, Thomas M. Brewer, Wilson Flagg, and others of a generation passed away were the pioneers, and then followed William Brewster himself, and a host of contempo- raries, who have contributed their mite. Mr._ Brewster's own personal observations extend over forty years. With this back- ing and equipment he has produced a record unsurpassed in details of distribution and of migration. Moreover, we may search in vain for any other list wherein facts es- sentially dry are more agreeably pre- sented. Introductory sections, descriptive, his- torical, and analytical, occupy eighty-four pages, the rest of the volume being given to a carefully annotated list of the 248 species and subspecies found in the re- gion. As a frontispiece a fine portrait of Thomas Nuttall is aptly chosen; and be- sides several maps and views of country nooks, there is a colored plate of Brew- ster’s Linnet—a bird of which the type has remained unique. Whether it is a species, a hybrid, a mutant, or a color- phase, nobody as yet knows. Wherever we turn, we find much that is of general, as well as of local interest to ornithologists. For example, under the section “‘Faunal Changes’ there is a brief presentation of facts concerning bird popu- lation, with a new and plausible theory to explain its fluctuations—the theory being that ‘‘sexual jealousy’”’ renders the male, during the breeding season, intolerant of the near presence of rival males, and by driving them away thus checks overpopu- lation of a given area. Then, too, we find the descriptions of different localities very fascinating, especially to anybody who has floundered contentedly through the mud- holes of the Fresh Pond marshes or paused to listen to the bubbling melody of the house wrens that spend their summers in the Wren Orchard. Valuable as this contribution is to ornithological literature, we could wish its limits had been extended; for it is a lit- tle too small for a complete ornithology, and a little too large for a local list. In avian parlance, it is an ‘‘intergrade,’’ mark- ing, nevertheless, a distinct epoch in the evolution of the local list. There are no radical flaws, although a missing table of contents may be found in Bird-Lore for September-October. We think, too, that uncut pages are out of place in a scientific book of this kind. “The Loose Leaf System of Laboratory Notes,’’ by Theo. H. Scheffer (P. Blakiston & Co.) is a laboratory manual for ele- mentary students in zoélogy. Recent years have been prolific in laboratory directions of this kind, and experience has taught that each laboratory will probably have its own requirements that are met by a “loose-leaf system."’ Instead of binding the directions in conventional book form the author’s system is to tie the sheets to gether with a shoe-string between de tachable covers. The booklet will prove useful in high school and elementary col Whether it is best to in student lege courses troduce the into the mysteries of science by making dim learn the names of all the parts and organs of a number of selected types is perhaps a matter of opin ion. The method has been found generally acceptable to students and teachers alike for it involves the least amount of think- ing, and keeps the student interested and busy in the laboratory In such matters practical advantages outweigh theoretical considerations. A serious and thoroughly documentary history of the practice of medicine in Geneva before 1800, ‘‘La Médecine A Genéve jusqu’ A la fin du XVIIle Siécle,” by Dr Léon Gautier, has many pages both of scientific and general interest. Worth not ing are those parts of the book which deal with the advent, progress, and disappear- ance of leprosy (A. Db. 700-1600), with the leper colonies—maladrcries—and other mea- surestaken to guardagainst a disease which is now again an actuality. Of yet more absorbing interest are the accounts of the judicial trials (probably monstrous errors) 1545), where ““Monsieur Calvin ministre” is noted of the “plague-sowers’’ (1530 and as interceding for the poisoners condemned to death, that they should not be tortured too long, but be put speedily out of their misery The recent fire at the University of Groningen completely destroyed the excep tionally rich collection in the Institute of Natural History, which was the monu- ment of the indefatigable collecting zeal of Professor van Ankum, extending over many years. Finance. THE AMERICAN MARKET AND LONDON Since the article in this column on the Bank of England rate was published last week, the Bank has further advanced itz rate to 6 per cent. It did this, ostensibly because New York exchange on London, which had moved sharply in England’s fa- vor when the 5 per cent. bank rate was | established, October 11, had fallen back, in the .ensuing week, to a level where New York could again draw on London's gold. The incident is likely to stand as a landmark, because a 6 per cent rate has been fixed by the Bank only five times in the last thirty-two years, and because four of those occasions have becn The dates are 1899, when the when the disastrous. Boer war broke out; 1890, London house of Baring failed; 1882, when a “bank crash” and panic raged in Paris; and 1878, when the Glasgow Bank suspend- ed payments. The one exception was 1889, when there was no trouble, but, in a world wide “boom” of trade, London was losing gold too rapidly. The present case is seemingly analogous to the last mentioned. There is no sign ot calamity on the financial horizon, and the 6 per cent. rate, as in 1389, is intended to draw back to England the capital taken from it, and to stop the export of gold. In the few days since the Bank took action a 359 both these ends have been partly achieved! Exchange on London, at Paris and Berl has approached the point where both mus» send gold to England Our own gold im ports have abruptly ! ‘ ne change has risen ing capital from the Ar which such quantities had been invested is shifting those loans back to the New York banks Within a fortnight, loa these banks have increased $30,000,000-—a ipcrease ascribed almost ex y to tl taking over of such obligati from Lon don A highly interesti a question which concerns ig qu market, but all others whic! drawing on England How will wh nu kets be affected by thi udden 1 ! resources on which they had dey; led The answer must be sought in the u which that capital had been pu If Eng land's money had been borrowed, fo stance, to help move rops to mm and had been borrowed solely because was cheaper than money in New Yort recall would simply mean tha a lars demand would converge n New York and that rates would be somewhat higher. But if Berlin, for example, having strained own resources in providing f commercial needs, had built up an extray agant speculation in new pinpany ur and had sustained that speculation wholly through London money, something muat happen when London called the mon home This is exactly what did occur a Berlin in 1899 Germany's excited “indus trial per jlation of that vea was fina through London borrowing War t kk out in South Africa the Witwate rand which had sent $80,000,000 gold to Englant the, year before uddenly ceased prod tion the London bank rate 1 e to 6 | cent., and England recalled ipital fr Jerlin The result was, that the whol structure of Germany's industrial bo came to earth Germany at that juncture was far fr being as rich in real capital and wealtl a America is to-day our wh predica ment from the los of English capita proportionately less awkwa In a time that part of o own ipital wi has been engaged in moving the crop and financing the active autumn busine eason, WU! be released, and will take place of the capital withdrawn by Eng land The interesting present problem the manner in which the temporary voil will be filled. Sometimes advance in money rates is the only consequence om prices have to come down on the Stock Ex | change, to reduce the loans which have su |} tained them rhe first and, under the cumstances, the most natural tey Nia this week's relief by the Treasury BOOKS OF THE WEEK jarron, Elwyn Marcel Levigne lruft 1 & « $1.% jorden, Spencer The Arab Hors I VPage & Co $1.20 net Call, Anale Payson Every liay Living j ‘ Stokes Co. $1.25 net Cambridge Natural Histo \ I Ma ‘ Lo $4 25 Chatfleld-Taylor, H. ¢ Moliére A Biogra; Duficeld & Co $3 net | Crawford, F. Marion A Lady of Row Ma lan Co, Dalton’s Complete Bridge I \ Deussen, Paul. The Vedanta Syst by J. H Woods and *¢ Is kK n Press. §1 Fllie, Kdward & The Cruise of the Firefly Phi
Page 26
860 The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2156 Fi Winston Co 75 cents Heroes Every Child Should Know Edited by Ham Sangster, Margaret E Fairest Girlhood. Fleming iW Slavery and ft) Race Problem lliton W Mahle Doubleday Page & Co vo H. Revell Co. $1.50 net Fhe wat Dana Estes & Co. $1 cents net Shelby, Annie Blanche Bridge Abridged Duf k The P of \ w in History Kinglake’s Eothen Edited by D. G Hogarth field & Co. §$1. Mas Henry Frowde 2s. Gd net Slocum, 8. E.. and E. L. Hancock Text-Book Kdmunad G r King of Court Poets Knowles, F. M and others 4 Cheerful Year on the Strength of Matertele Boston: Ginn & I rut $4 1m Book Henry Holt & Co $1 net Co 2. Why rR « Breast is McMaster. John Bach A History of the United Smith, William H jr A Priced Lincoln Bibli e H. Revell ¢ 7h cents net States. Vol. VI Appleton $2.50 net per vol ography Privately Published His Lif Fd iby & M Mears. Mary. The Breath of the Runners yr. A Sweetser, Kate Dickinson Boys and Girls from & ¢ $1.50 George Eliot Duffield & Co $2 , i Ml mt Wom es } nch ‘rederick History of the Papacy 2 " Guy Made in His Image Philadelphia: | a: ES neott ol Dutton $7.50 net W. Jacobs & Co H Misrepresentative W ‘ Dut rbert A History of Modern England Thureau-Dangin. Paul. Saint Bernard!ne of Siena. ‘ : Co Dutton. $1.50 net J paet 4 Kentucky Chronicle ‘iigrim’s Staff. Poems selected by FitzRoy Car Traveller's Joy. Compiled by W. G. Waters. Dut I g $1.50 t on Duffield & Co. 75 cente ton $1.25 net. I Last Words Evolution Trans rf John H Memoirs Neale Publishing Co Underwood, J. L The Women of the Confeder- MeCa Pet Eckler $1 net &3 acy Neale Publishing Co 2 ! I Boys and . Rchmond, Grace 8 The Second Violin Double Westcott, Brooke Foss Saint P aul s Epistle to the } ‘ b ‘ lay. Page & Ca Ephesians. Macmillan Co. §2 t I ’ ind Judy Book Rossett W. MM. Some Reminiscences. 2 vols. Im Whisperings from the Great. C ome jiled by Con- Meld & « $1.25 ported by Seribners $10 net stance A. Meredyth Henry Frowde ] Timely Second Edition Now Ready. | | HE HEART ° . } interesting d France in the THAT KNOWS Alexander's New World | The Library of Literary Criticism Political History of QUEBEC IN THE (7TH CENTURY | Of Engilsh and American Authors From 680 to 1905 Eight Volumes. Oompiled Studies o " d 10Ts, »] 1 The State of New York By JAMES DOUCLAS, LL.D. Srodies ¢f 1,100 Authors, Ts chocnmiegiet) emeee Sve printed on spec‘al India paper throughout, Work on all phases of English Literature. High- very fully illustrated. $2.50 net (postage 13c.). eat praise from Scholars throughout the Englisb- 1774-1861 \ new edition, with very extensive changes and smaking world. Sample pages, ete.. free by mail. corrections, and an entirely new chapter, a résumé . ' t of the whole work, which is a valuable addition. | MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York $5.00 n Carriage extra ° , This second edition of Dr. Douglts's book | aie , o- oe wrw t/ imple pave n application has been printed with the view of appealing JUST OUT. PROF. HYSLOP’S NEW BOOK, ' particulorly to tourists, Itis made through | t ting ten columns to reviews of this out on India paper, the 617 pages being Oo k, t em Said: ** It would be impossibl under an inch in thiekness, and therefore of | ‘ ‘ tos ; ny sort of iustice a weight to correspond The illustrations : oe ; rer +1 ¥ SOT k aa ‘te many and beauti/ul, and to one journeying | iV ( " ry wre be . . , oO = ty tN ———— or Quebec, the vol- | Treats of Normal and Abnormal Paychology. plicity of its interesting d t | Price $1.50 net. 12c postage. ! - = From your bookseller o: | HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., Boston, Mase HENRY HOLT & CO NEW YORK THE BURROWS BROS. co., | IBRARIAN.—Old and Rare Books put CLEVELAND, OHIO. ~ inorder and catalogued. Americana a specialty i A. P. Sanrorp, 443 La Salle Ave., Chicago. BOOKS OF PERMANENT WORTH A HEART GARDEN | PRESCOTT’S By J. R. MILLER, author of “Upper | COMPLETE WORKS Carrems, ex IN TWELVE VOLUMES lime. plain, 65 centa net. Cloth, gilt top, . > a cael Sheets ast, Grestane 6 ecm) 60 Illustrations, 12mo. Per set, $12 to $36. More than a millionand a half of | The demand for a complete authentic Dr. Miller's popular devotional books | text of this great historian’s works, at a have been sold, and his fame is | popuias perce, bes a last been met » world-wids > ‘ynote the present edition. It is new through- : rl ~~ oy ~y keyn ite of ~_ | out, i large type, on good paper, and itest book from his pen is found tn with choice illustrations and binding. its opening lines: **A good woman | No American library is complete with- caid_ ° ; . out these great books: “Fer« inand and said, My heart isa little garden, and Isabella,” “Conquest of Mexico,” “Con- God is planting flowers there.’ Ev- quest of Peru,” ‘Philip the Second.’ ery heart should be a little garden, “Charles the Fifth.” A final volume of Miscellaneous Essays is also added, as i} 0 sweet an 3 oF s . , . full ; f sweet ind beautiful plants well as the standard Life of Prescott. ind tlowers by George Ticknor THE WORLD’S CHRISTMAS TREE By CHAS. E. JEFFERSON, author of ‘ Doctrine and Deed,”’ pecial type, 12mo, cloth, 75 cents net. Limp leather, $1.50 net. (Postage, 8 cents.) tof metropolitan ministers and writers here makes a powerful plea for the true spirit of Christmas. This attractive gift-book ‘ ne | for thought THIN PAPER, TWO-VOLUME SETS type on opaque Bibl FIVE SErS: pal , | Jn). a, X inn bou as % Count of Monte Cristo. Dumas half h thick on f the largest = hooks are tl got into remarkably small * Don Quixote. Cervantes ind t pa The binding is Les Miserables. Hugo full limp leather Life of Johnson. Boswell Price, $2.50 per set French Revolution. Carlyle THOMAS Y. CROWELL & CO., 426-8 West Broadway, New York