The Nation 1906-08-30: Vol 83 Iss 2148
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The N: at: Shree, ‘te fare, Any iy ba i] a; VOL. LXXXIII—NO. 2148 THURSDAY, AUGUST 30, 1906. ee mo CENTS. CENERAL LIPRAR Books of Travel and Description READY NEXT WEEK. ILLUSTRATED IN COLOR A Wanderer in London By 5 Vv. Lucas By the author of the companion volume, *‘A Wanderer i: n which Mr. Maurice HEWLETT found a charm that he pronounced ‘*‘ altogether delightful.” With 16 plat wn" , ni many othe riiustration $2.00 net, by matl $2.75 There are a number of volumes recently published, which, though not guide-books in any formal sense, should be noted as very desirable gifts to the traveller either departing or just returned, They include A Wanderer in holland By E. V. aa With 20 illustrations in color by Herbert Marshall and 34 other illustrations. loth $2 “The book begets an immediate desire to set out fo thy ith and see it all for oneself.’’ a Evening Post, New th The Land of Pardons By Anatole Le Braz Translated by FRANCES M. GOSTLING. With 12 illustrations in colors by T. C. Gotch, and 40 others in monotone fron photographs. Cloth, $2.00 net “Charming, quaint pictures not of the Brittany of the tourist, but the true country seen through Breton eye: The Norfolk Broads By William A. Dutt With 48 colored and 49 uncolored illustrations by FRANK SOUTHGATE Cloth, $ A description of the restful land where rivers go wandering in the meadows in an old world holiday Oxford Described by Revert shan and H. c. ‘Minchin With roo tliustrations in colors showing how her beauties hai i everal artists. ith, $2.00 The Cities of Spain By Edward Hutton With 24 colored illustrations by WALLACE RIMINGTON, and 20 uncolored. Cloth, $2.00 net “It is a remarkable book, for Mr. Hutton is an artist and master of a vocabulary apparently as inexhaustible and colorful as Ruskin’s . his book is one to make one feel the true spirit of Spain. Record-Herald, Chicago READY SEPTEMBER 19 Professor A. V. Williams Jackson’s Persia Past and Present A Book of travel and research. With more than two hundred illustrations and a map. Cloth, 8vo, xxxi+-472 p. $4.oonct; by mail $4.20 The route traversed by caravan carried the author from the Caucasus mountains on the north nearly to the Persiin Gulf on the south, thence to Yeszd, in the central desert, and back northward to Teheran and the Caspian Sea Published ~=THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “6 Ave. by ? UNIV. oi MICK. AUG 81 1906
Page 2
The Nation. ‘4 WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865, at the New York City Post Office second clasa mail matter Entered CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER Tue Weer 173 EDITORIAL ARTICLES lbrawing New Class Li 176 | Vacillating Cra 176 Architectural Competitio 177 The Reading of Farmers 178 BPpROIAL CORRESPONDENCE I Tea K f la A Crit n nd a I nedy 178 First Bediti f ‘The 8 f Seanda 179 CORRESPONDENCE Tiint ‘ \ t and Medert Ist) I Ms f Evelyn's Dia 1s] 1? Mille Halifax 181 NorTes 181 Rook Revirws ! t Books ISD I is Hodgsk the I r of Ana sm 187 Rees he t ISS A il ry f Englis Prosealy ISU Zarathueht th \ remenids, and lserael 1&0 I Social Ideals of Alfred Tennyson 1m) hooks or Tank WReeK 190 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4 The date when the subs ription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remit (ance No other receipt ts sent unless requested, Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless made by registered letter, or by check, express order, or Poatal Order payable to **Publisher of The Nation.’ When a change of addresa ta desired, both the old and the new addresses should be given Address THE NATION, Bozx791, New Publication Office, 208 Broadway York TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen centa per agate line, each insertion; 14 lines to the inch Twenty per cent. top of column A column, $20 advance for choice of page or each insertion; with choice of. page, , 4 A page, $60 each insertion; front cover page, $80 Advertisements must be aceeptable in every re spect Copy recetved until Tuesday, 6 P.M DISCOUNTS. Time 4 Ineertions 5 per cent o 10 ” 18 ee 12h 26 1S 8e . soon Ag 26 AMOUNT=— gio within a year 10 per cent » os Iu noo oe 15 750 20 1.000 25 ee 1,500 - i) os #2 000 ‘ e - ihe THER NATION ta sent free to those who adver. tlae in U as long as advertisement continues *,.* Copies of Tuk Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross The Nation. — | Educational Massacuvusetrs, Boston STON UNIVERSITY Law New features. Address the Dean. M School. M. BIlagLow. B ) FE ETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Bethlehem. Pa.—Prepares for leading colleges. Catalogue H. A. Forrtna, B.S., Prin Micuiaan, Orchard Lake THE MICHIGAN MILITARY ACADEMY Prepares for all American Colleqg’s and scientific schools Ideal location, 26 miles from Detroit teadily accessible, but removed from city dangers, Beau- tiful lake region; ample grounds; fine buildings The school insures excellent physical development with superior academic and military training Unusual religious, musical, and social advantages. Six-year academic course; eighth grammar grade, high school, graduate Thirtieth year bezins September 1th, 1006 For information address Lawrence Cameron Hutt, Head Master ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry l aboratories. Shop for Mechanic Arte. Strong teachers. High ideals A new gymnasium with swimming pool. Fits for col lege, sclentifiC school and business. Illustrated pam phiet sent free. Addre Dr. B C. WHITE, Rock : Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hills, New York $724, ¥szr,cpen (es University sessions 0:30 to 12. After. Law School } noon Classes, 3:50 to 6. L.J Mass. Evening © leases. 8 to 10 Degrees LL.B, LL.M., J.D Address Washington Square, TOMPKINS, Secretary, N.Y NEW YORK | Day Schvol § 35 Nassau St., LAW SCHOOL | Evening School |} New York City ‘Dwight Method” of tns‘ruction. LL.B. in two years. LL.M. inthree years. High oepes ards Send for catalogue, GEORGE CHASE, Dean. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY WORCESTER, MASS. Kotabliched A 1856. The Rt. Rev. ALewx. H. Vinton, PD. . Spring field, Visitor. Fits its students ter edinn places tn professional, or business life Josera ALDEN SHaw, A.M., collegtate, Headmaster School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENC/ES. Evererr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Pl... Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 20% Mich. Ave., Chicago 1200 Williams Av., Portland 401 Cooper Bid., Denver 6525 S8time'’n Bid.,LosAngeles 313 Rook'ry BIk., Spokane 717 Market St..San F’nelsco Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Records Send for Circular on Free Registration. HARLAN P. FRENCH, &1 Chapel St., Albany, Teachers with Good N.Y “CHERMERHORN’S Teachers’ Agency reachera--Schools—Tutors—Governess— Property Tel 6120 18th. uw E. 14th St., N. Y. C. Teachers, etc. WOMAN OF HIGH SCHOLAR- ship, with graduate work, considerable travel, years’ experience, desires to teach English or history Pu M., care Nation pocTorR OF PHILOSOPHY, experi- enced teacher, woman of unusual equipment, de sires English instructorship Address “* Vassar,” Ithaca, New York A and four BOOKS FOR CHILDREN Long’s Wood Folk Series The Vouth’s Companion Series Collodt’a Pinocchio Spyri's Moni,the Goat Hoy,and Other tories Chance's Little Folks of Many Lands Hardy's Sea Stories for Wonder Eyes Chandler's In the mengn of Coyote BOSTON CINN & COMPANY, TB seas 83, No. 2148 WILLIAM R. JENKINS 851-853 SIXTH AVENUE. NEW YORK Corner 48th Street No Branch Stores FRENCH Publish the BERCY, DU CRO QUET, SAUVEUR, and other well-known methods. OUR PUBLICATIONS ire up-to-date and used in many of the best schools and colleges. The general stock of imported books Is large, not only our own publications, but those of all oublishers at home and abroad. Our ROMANS CHOISIS, CON- TES CHOISIS, and other series, low-priced, contain master pleces of French, Spanish, and Ttal slian authors. Many have notes In English. A complete ataloque of all thee of imported bo requested publications, ks sent when SOME NEW PUBLICATIONS A new book in the Bercy sertes SIMPLE GRAMMAIRE FRANCAISE Accompagnée d'un Questionnaire et Basée sur la Réforme de la Syntaxe) par PauLt Bercy. B. L., L. D., et G KORG Es CASTEGNIER, B.48-L., B-¢8-S 12mo, cloth, 220 pag $1.00 First. it is In French; difficult words and sen- tences are translated into English and placed in parentheses. Second, rules and exceptions are based upon the “Reform of the Syntax.” Third, English exercises to be translated into French are invaluable, Fourth, the “Questionnaire” of great assistance to teachers and pupiis, can be used for conversation, as questions and answers are in simple form; pedagogy avoided. Fifth, the chapter on distinction between masculine and feminine nouns will be much appreciated. CHOSES DE FRANCE rsation. La France, sea Indus- ses Institutions, par C, Fon 12mo, cloth, 104 pages, $0.75 AND OTHER FOREIGN Lecons de conve tries; son Histoire et rank, B, L., L. D HISTORIETTES ET POESIES by Marnie M Rontqgue. Large type, simple, at- tractive for Children. Conversation exercises follow each 12mo, boards, 107 pages, 80.60 ROBINSON'S GERMAN VERB FORM Blanks for systematic verb drill. Size 9% x 12, 54 pages, press board cover - $0.50 A BRIEF ITALIAN GRAMMAR WITH EXERCISES EpaRren, Ph. D 12mo0, cloth, 128 $0.90 lesson. by HJsaLMAR pane 8 JAPANESE FOR DAILY USE P. Prenrys, assisted by KAaMETARA 63 pages, full leather binding by E worTo. THE COMPLETE POCKET GUIDE TO EUROPE Edited by Epucnp CLARENCE STEDMAN and Tuomas L. STEDMAN. Revised every year. Gives best Routes, select Hotels, many maps and general valuable informatio’ of all Europe. 1 volume, over 500 pages, full leather binding $1.25 SA8A- $0.75 Any book sent prepaid for the price WILLIAM R. JENKINS 851 & 853 Sixth Ave., New York OUTLIVES OF ENGLISH AND DMEF ICAN LITE? ATURE By J. H. GILMORE, Ph.D., of the Uni- versity of Rochester. \ Book that meets the present requiremets in teaching Literature. For advanced High School or first year College work. Price, 75 cts. Specimen pages mailed on request, SCRANTOM, WETMORE & CO. ROCHESTER, N. Y. Hannah Logan’s Courtshi Told in the diary of the lover of this stately daughter of Penn's famous secretary, Beau tifully tilustrated. $2.50 postpaid, or at book stores Send for catalogue of interesting books of Pennsylvania history and Wography FERRIS & LEACH, Publishers, Phila. Financial. We buy and sell bills of exchanges and make cable transfers of money on Eu rope, Austraila, and South Africa; also OF make collections and issue Commercial and Travellers’ Credits avatiable fn all CREDIT parte of the world. International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit BROWN BROTHERS & CO, LETTERS NO. 00 WALL STREET, NEW YORK
Page 3
ae ae a August 30, 1906] The Nation. PUBLISHED DURING THE PAST YEAR Brooks and Hubbard’s Composition- Harkness and Forbes’s Caesar’s Commen- Rhetoric . ‘ ‘ : . $1.00 taries on the Gallic War. Books I-IV By Stratton D. Brooks, Superintendent of Schools, Boston $1.00 ind Marietta Hubbard, formerly English Department, High School, La Salle, Hl. By Albert ess, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor Emeritus, ivers sisted bv Charles H. Forbes, Prot Latin, Phitaps Academy, Andover, Mass Long’s American Poems . ; $0.90 ‘rinceton Morey’s Outlines of Ancient History,$1.50 By Augustus White Long, Preceptor 1 glish, | University By William C Morey, Professor of History and Political Science, University of Rochester Smiley’s Manual of American Literature $0.60 Mather’s Caesar. Episodes from the Gallic By James B. Smiley, A.M., Assistant Principal of Lincol and Civil Wars e ° ° $1.25 High School, Cleveland ” dited by Maurice W. Mather, Ph.D... formerly Instructor i Latin, Harvard University. Rolfe’s New Shakespeare. 40 vols. Each. . , . - $0.56 Jordan’s Elementary Latin Writing, $1.00 Edited by William J. Rolfe, Litt D. By Clara B. Jordan, Head of Department of Latin, Hughes High School, Cincinnati Shakespeare’s Julius Caesar (Gateway Series) . : ‘ . $0.35 Harkness, Kirtland and Williams’s Edited by Dr. Hamilton W. Mabie, Editor of Ze Outlook New Cicero, Nine Orations . $1.25 Six Orations , , ; $1.00 . ’ . . Edited by Albert Harkness, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor Emer Goldsmith s Vicar of Wakefield (( sale - itus, Brown University. Assisted by J.C. Kirtland, Jr wav Series) a - ‘ . $0.45 Professor in Phillips Exeter Academy, and G. H. Willian Ph, D., Protessor in Kalamazoo Colleg Edited by James A. Tufts, Professor of English, Phillips Ex eter Academy. Burton’s Selections from Livy . $1.50 College Entrance Requirements in Edited by Harry E. Burton, Ph.D., Professor of Latin, Dirt English tor Study and Practice, mouth Golleg 1909-1911 . ‘ , ‘ $0.90 Containing Shakespeare’s Macbeth, Milton’s Minor Poems, Benner and Smyth’s Beginner’s Greek 3urke’s Conciliation, Washington’s Farewell Address and | B k Webster s First Bunker Hill Oration, Macaulay's Johnson, | oo ° ° . ° . $1.25 and Carlyle’s Burns. By Allen Rogers Benner, Professor of Greek, Phillips Acad my, Andover, and Herbert Weir Smyth, Ph.D., Eliot Professor of Greek Literature, Harvard University Washington’s Farewell Address and Webster’s First Bunker Hill Ora- tion (Eclectic Eng. Classics) ‘ Gleason’s Greek Composition for $0.20 Schools ; 7 : : $0.80 By Clarence W. Gleason, A.M., Roxbury Latin Schoo! Perry’s Introductory Course in Argu- | mentation. ; , , $1.00 By Frances M. Perry, Instructor in English, Wellesley College. Adams’s Lysias. Selected Speeches $1.50 Edited by Charles Darwin Adams, Ph.D., Lawrence Prof sor of Greek, Dartmouth College Harding’s Essentials in Mediaeval and Modern History . . ~. $1.50 Lamberton’s Thucydides. Books Il From Charlemagne to the Present Day. By Samuel Bannis ter Harding, Ph.D., Professor of European History, Indiana and ll . « 3 . $1.75 University. Prepared in consultation with Albert Bushnell Edited by W. A. Lamberton, A.M., Litt.D., Professor of Hart, LL.D., Professor of History, Harvard University Greek, University of Pennsylvania. A COPY OF OUR DESCRIPTIVE CATALOCUE OF HICH SCHOOL AND COLLECE TEXT-BOOKS WILL BE SENT TO ANY ADDRESS ON REQUEST AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY CINCINNATI CHICAGO BOSTON ATLANTA DALLAS SAN FRANCISCO NEW YORK
Page 4
lv The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2148 GINN & COMPANY’S PUBLICATIONS Series 1909-1911. A complete list with suggestions for the teaching of English literature in secondary schools will be sent postpaid on application. Myers’ Histories Outlines of Nineteenth Century History. General History. Revised edition. Ancient History. Revised Edition. Medizwval and Modern History. Revised Edition. The Middle Ages. The Modern Age. Rome, Its Rise and Fall. Eastern Nations and Greece. Revised Edition. History of Rome. Revised Edition. The Standard English Classics Selections and Documents in Several new volumes are in preparation to meet , the College Entrance Requirements in English for | Economics Edited by WILLIAM Z. RIPLEY, of Harvard University. Now Ready Ripley’s Trusts, Pools and Corporations. Commons’ Trade Unionism and Labor Problems. Carver's Sociology and Social Progress. Bullock’s Selected Readings in Public Finance. The International Modern Language Series A comprehensive series of French, German and Spanish classics, annotated and edited for secondary schools and colleges. Over 100 volumes are now ready. NEW YORK ATLANTA BOSTON OAKLAND GINN & COMPANY, Publishers LONDON COLUMBUS CHICAGO DALLAS LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO”’S NEW BOOKS A HISTORY OF MEDIAVAL AND MODERN EUROPE By Henry E. Bourne, Professor in the College for Women, West ern Reserve University. With numerous Illustrations and Maps. Crown S8vo $1.50 This ts, of course, a textbook for the use of schools, but It Is, at the «ame time, prepared in so thoroughly interesting &@ manner as to make it a valuable book for the general reader, or for occasional reference. . A ries of Interesting and valuable mape are added, and the illustrations which are freely scattered throughout the text are not only exc ellent In execution, but have the merit of being unusual and illuminating.’’—Transcrtrr Boston, December 14, 1005 . a work embodying the beat scholarship and the most progressive deals an Immense imprevement over anything to be had ten years avo.” Tue Dia, Jan. 1, 1808, THE HISTORY OF ENGLISH RATIONALISM IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY By ALFRED W. BENN, Author of * The Philosophy of Greece,’ t 2 vols SVO $7.00 net conetderation to the tafluence of Coleridge and the neo-Platontists, to utill tarlaniem and Benthamlem, to the Oxford movement, and to ali literary work f diatinetion whieb has Influenced the epread of rationallem or tended to curb ite apread New Youn Times, June #3, 1v06 Harvard Hiatorical Studies New Volume THE DEVELOPMENT OF FREEDOM OF THE PRESS IN MASSACHUSETTS By Crype AuGustus Duntway, Associate Professor of His tory in Leland Stanford Junior University. » | Itmay safely be commended to all whose enthusiasm for liberty needs a stimu | Hie book Includes Intelligent summaries of the various systems of philosophy which have influenced English thought, and gives much detailed | Svo. Pp. xvi—202. §1.50 net. | CUBA AND THE INTERVENTION By ALBERTG. ROBINSON. (‘‘A. G. R.’’) Large crown, 8vo. 370 pages. $1.80 net. By mail, $1.92. " . a book which ts destined long to figure among the most valuable materials fora comprehension of Cuba's history ata criticalconjuncture. . . . The author was an eyewitness of the events that he describes, and he brought to his task a mind qualified by education and experience for the work of ob- servation.”"—Nrw York Sun, March 10, 1005. A HISTORY of MODERN LIBERTY | By JAMES MACKINNON, Ph.D., Author of ‘‘ The History of Edward lll.,’"" etc. Vols. Land Il. Vol.l. Introduction—Origins— } The Middle Ages; Vol. Il. The Age of the Reformation. Svo. $10.00, net. In the fleld of political history Mr. MacKinnon’s reading, if by no means exnaustive, has been widely chosen, and his instinct for facts is singu . Takenall in all, his book is both readable and instructive. lariy sound | lant.’ Am. Historica. Review, July, 1906. PRINCIFLES OF ECONOMICS | WITH SPECIAL RiLFERENCE TO AMERICAN CONDITIONS. By Epwin R. A. SELIGMAN, LL.D., McVickar Professor of Political Economy in Columbia University; Author of ‘ Es- says in Taxation,” ete. With 28 Maps and Charts, some of which are in color; a general bibliography, chapter refer- ences, and full Index. 659 pages. Crown 8vo, $2.25. ’ affords a thorough, well-balanced treatment of the subject which he handles . This book will serve the double purpose of a text-book for university students, and a volume which appeals to more mature readers, who may desire to supplement a practical acquaintance with the business world bya study of economle theory . .. the book fs a valuable addition to the litera- ture of ecogomica ve ery: | to that part which serves the professed student and the ordinary eltizen at the same time.”—YaLe Revirw, ay, 1006 LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., 91 and 93 Fifth Avenue, New York ~ TSeapegaee,
Page 5
Me ae 3 Sm, NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST 30, 1006, . , The Week. On the question of intervention in Cuba, it is gratifying to note that the attitude of President Roosevelt has thus far been absolutely correct. He has giv- en no encouragement whatever to th eager meddlers. And in this the better part of the press is of his mind. Here and there one meets a bit of the old swagger—“Oh, yes, we'll have to take hold of that Cuban mess, and if we go to the island again we'll never come away”’—but sensible newspapers hold a different tone. They feel, not the President does, that the honor of this country is pledged to give the Cubans a fair trial in self-covernment After boasting of our unexampled mag- as we doubt nanimity in taking our hands off, we should put them on again only under high necessity. What may be called the business temptation, we are sure that Mr. Roosevelt will put aside. He is not likely to surrender the pride which he has taken in the action of our country in giving Cuba her independence, mere- ly to render it easier for certain inter- ests to make money. The seductive ap- peal to him would be on the score of His order to the Government Printing Office is resented and strong opposition as an attempt to impose his private And the President fancy upon the public practice result may be most unhappy Roosevelt's successor will be likely to evoke the order Then there would ve two years’ output of messages and Government docume! standing apart n the public archives in their queer lit cary dress. As we said when the lists of new spellings were first published some of the forms recommended are al ready in good usage; a few others may fight their way to recognition after a neration or two; while the stranger and more offensive spellings can ad- vance only over the dead bodies of those who will resist while they have breath forms that surprise and irritate, with no real compensating good, and who are accustomed to think of lan- e as a fine art. The American voter certainly needs to be a skilled metaphysician, if he is to keep up with the intricacies and fine distinctions of contemporary tariff doc- trine Here is the Nebraska Republi- | can platform declaring, for example “preventing chaos.” Let the American | investors in Cuban tobacco and sugar get up a fair semblance of chaos on the | island, and the ruler who feels himself ordained to be the policeman of this | hemisphere would be sorely tempted to draw his night-club. But we hope he will not forget that the Cuban notion of chaos is very different from that of his well-regulated mind. Armed tion may seem to the Cubans only what a party split does to Americans. If, after all the disturbance, a strong and orderly Government emerges, it is all we have a right to ask. President Roosevelt no doubt was un- prepared for the universal ridicule now beating upon him like an Atlantic surf for his spelling-reform ukase. Aside from the personal aspect of the matter, it is not exactly a cheering American citizens that the Chief Mag- istrate of the United States should be regarded in civilized nations as a med- dier in what does not concern him. There is a feeling that he should not have drag- ged his office into what was for him only a personal vagary. If he had sim- ply chosen, as Theodore Roosevelt, to join the band of heroic spelling reform- ers, there could have been no objection. Even if he had instructed his secretaries to spell his official correspondence so as | to please Brander Matthews, he might have excited smiles, but not ridicule thought for | — a lutely plain, absolutely simple, absolute- insurrec- | | speech of the Hon. James T. “While yielding nothing from our ad- herence to this principle [protection], we believe ;,that changes in schedules follow should changes in conditions.” But is the “Nebraska idea” more or less | liberal than the “Iowa idea,” or the “North Dakota idea’? Only the wise men of the party know. But this is certain The Nebraskans would never have said anything about changes in schedules being made to “follow chang- if they had read the McCleary 9° es in conditions” | of Minnesota, delivered on June 25, and just now published in a much-belated issue of the Congressional Record. Mr. McCleary has taken the greatest pains to explain that conditions are made by tariff schedules, and practically nothing else. Thus, “revision downward” in 1857 | brought “hard times”; “partial revision | times,” | of our economic history. downward” in 1883 brought “partial hard while “revision upward” in 1897 brought “prosperity.” It is abso- ly satisfying—to any one who has not made himself mad by too much study But the apos- tle of still higher duties would almost be justified in giving up in disgust when he sees his logic wasted on a community that continues talking about “condi- tions,” as if they were something that went on of themselves and changed spontaneously, instead of being mere tar- iff by-products After the campaign which has beep The Nation. waged in Georgia upon almost every imaginable issue and personality, it would be folly to ascribe Hoke Smith's vietory in last week's primary to any Smith was regarded as the representative of the extreme form of one cause. anti-negro suffrage doctrine, yet it was hard for an outsider to see where his policy was fundamentally different from those of the other candidates. A more definite issue was that of the opposition to corporation privilege. The same feel ing of discontent which has made it self felt in Wisconsin, New Jersey, New Hampshire, and other States contribut- | ed to the opposition against Clark How- | ell, who was regarded as the “railroad candidate.” It was in Georgia that the State Supreme Court, two or three years ago, made th: markable decision that the railroads, in effect, had the right to charge freight rates high enough to pay dividends on their whole system out of their profits in Georgia alone. Of course, State regulation became farcical under such a principle. Whether this particu- lar incident figured in the late campaign, | we do not know, but {it is the sort of thing which would naturally disgust the people of any community with a gov erning ring over-favorable to the al- ready over-protected corporatfons. We have already remarked on the exceptionally favorable promise of this year’s harvests, and their good effect on our financial situation. But it has also been pointed out by all conserva- tive critics that this benefit might be n the mo- jeopardized by recklessness ney market. This summer's great har- vests will of themselves call into life, on an unusual scale, legitimate trade activity: demands of this trade on the country’s capital will be proportionate- ly large money son with its available reserves of capl- tal already under a heavy strain. At the opening of the year. Wall Street’s mo ney rate was the highest and its bank surplus the lowest In twenty-six years; | and the April deficit in reserves was the first that had happened in the spring- time since 1884. More to the point Is the movement of bank reserves and mo- ney rates this month. Two weeks ago the New York bank surplus fell to very much the lowest figure reached at this time of year since 1893—a figure, in- deed, never touched in the summer months of any previous year without severe money stringency following. This week the rate for Wall Street demand loans has risen to 6 per cent. a price attained at this time of year only twice in fifteen years—in 1902 and 1893, both of them years of great derangement of | capital Yet, as every one knows, the market enters the autumn sea-
Page 6
money iS a su ign unquestionably it done ny it cannot be ery inciel Last week Union Pa- only one il mm nion Pacific's ‘ ‘ e of evel nce | in a mood tor on iiut it has also been made peculate , ney It is highly for outburst of crazy stock Mr held in money Harri check For in not e that it 1 so Situal who fam phemistically call th ol that class virtue thelr nd opportunity, know il when 0 D ind unto! Rio approved it ie TI tes have the the con and The very ibunal prem of a debtor harshly sacrific t of a credi about the ac [)y © doctrine when by representa Amer other South On the hat | of may not lye individual to collect vith reeent tenden ‘ nd with com beta have gradu om immemortal con belleve tie md we when to go to war peculators have in wimittedilv bad absurd If v applie ir in th molly af¢ f any of such to the paper Inve sors in | that The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2148 wholly correct to say | securities act with their eyes open, and the price they pay fairly represents the hazard they take. One can hardly doubt the jurists constituting the Hague Tribunal will in some fashion adopt the It is preposterous that an be able to invoke against a State a more sum- method of collection than the law debtor in Drago plan individual should sovereign mary permits in the case of a bad the next street. An officer of the Smithsonian Institu- tion, being interviewed on the question art gave that “a patent- would there of its plans for gallery, the office He an welcome assurance of art” that exhibit be avoided. also observed would be | some difficulty in getting the proper pic- the is Since all Institution growing etc. of the to useful is clear enough that an art be maintained from the endowments. Gifts, though un- offered, will af- uncertain tures, sculptures, available income already pledged and activities, it gallery cannot present doubtedly will be at best tematk many ford an and unsys- method of acquisition. In sixty years, for example, the Institution has received one important print collection, the small one of the late Harriet Lane | Johnston, and a few straggling bequests The seum building for the National Mu- may not contain room for a growing art museum: in any new or may proper case, the Smithsonian must depend upon private beneficence, or Congress, for the support and increase of its department of art We regard the latter resource as the proper one, and the friends of a national gallery at Washington chould, we believe, devote themselves to fram- ing a scheme that will be acceptable to Congress. found, we of a Such a plan may be the foundation are confident, in gal- lery of American art, retrospective and contemporary. The fitness of such an exhibition at Washington needs no la- bored pleading. The mere immunity from influences of the schools and art- ist cliques that a Washington director may enjoy, would be a signal advan- tage. Moreover, the expense of the en- terprise would be inconsiderable when compared with that of a general mu- eum. There would be no need of a large, costly staff, and, considering the ulvantages of representation at the cap- ital, contemporary works of art could be bought at favorable prices. A really choice collection of the best of Ameri- can art at Washington would, we be lieve, have a wide-reaching effect “pon the taste of the country at large. Once started, gifts would flow in to such an American Luxembourg,” though the tactful rejection of the mediocre would call for much adroitness in the director \n indispensable feature of the founda tion would be a considerable appropria- tion to start the gallery of older Amer- ican art. The better pieces of the early schools are going up, and every now will the work or three at a later time. the Smithsonian Institution tained its powers as an art dollar of Presumably, granted do two has ascer- gallery by a recent judicial in full sciousness of the responsibilities involv- ed. We look to see the regents under- take a positive programme; and we submit that the plan sketched above is better fitted to win the good will of Congress and the people than any more decision, con- elaborate and costly scheme for a gen- eral museum of art. The Americanization of Europe has reached the stage of train robbery. De- tails of the hold-up of the train from Warsaw to Vienna show that the model may be even improved upon. One of the passengers stopped the train with the automatic Three men arm- ed with revolvers promptly jumped upon the commanded the gineer uncouple the mail car take it a short distance from the train There it was surrounded by thirty other ormed men, and the cash was demand- 16,000 rubles from Alexandrewo, 75,000 from Lowicz, and so on. The ban- brake. en- and locomotive and to ei- dits knew exactly what there was, and secured 200,000 rubles. In the mean- time armed men were parading up and down the other cars exhorting the pas- sengers to keep their seats and telling them harmed To prevent an accident, the courteous high- had in the to Warsaw no cne would be meantime sent a that Waymen telegram saving train No. 12 was stalled and must be guard- ed from collision. A second robbery was a more serious affair. A custom- house official was travelling, in a third- class car, escorted by two attendants and four border policemen. He had with him nearly 50,000 rubles. Sudden- ly und shot one of the policemen dead. Six that followed a passenger got up. drew a revolver, moment entered the ear. A in about 150 shots were fired. Among those kill- ed were two generals, who happened to he in the adjoining car and who prompt- other men at melee which ly took part in the fight. The thieves also lost a few men, but got away with the money. Dr. Carl the former German explorer and colonial official, is the lat- African that movement Peters, observer to become Africa-for-the-Africans There Kaffir rising continent, cst con vinced an he has started is, danger colony on rebellion of a that is believes, every and a of the general only a matter this danger Dr. Peters In order to meet and drawing time. English clares, Roers are, de closer closer to war i Afri off the gether, and a general wl that * is needed to “set
Page 7
Tt TREES August 30, 1906] can powder-magazine.” This may all be true; but it ought to be added that if the natives wanted an excuse for such an uprising against the white man’s domination, it would be found in the cruelties Dr. Peters practised and the wrongs he inflicted while in the German colonial service, for which offences he was forced to retire to private life. But in England this is forgotten. For the moment, Dr. Peters’s testimony is cited as proof that Sir Edward Grey was cor rect in his first position that the House of Commons must not criticise the Eng lish administration in wished to see rebellion in that country. Egypt, unless it From that stand, it should be noted, the Foreign Secretary has now rather in gloriously receded, there being abso lutely nothing to connect the murder at Denshawi with any political movement the the Afri cans to oppose European influence is to Surely, way to stimulate show just such nervousness as betrayed Sir Edward Grey in this case. of the other Gert the Social rise to never-ending discus- of suc- The proper attitude man parties towards Demo- crats gives sions, which have been intensified late cesses. by renewed Social-Democrati« The Emperor and the reaction- the all the voters in a league to defeat the party Bebel. This, patriotic duty. aries urge banding together of in their opinion, is a It age, therefore, for a radical Dr. Barth to with the Social-Democrats. of requires some cour Liberal like alliance rather an Himself an urge individualist, and in no sense a believe in Socialism, he finds himself compelled to this step by the steadily growing pow er in the Empire of the clerical and agricultural influences. The schools in Prussia have just been handed over to the church, there are millions upon mil- lions of dollars to be spent upon canals at the of the there is a total absence of any desire to uplift the of the the selfish protection interests are more menacing. When the Liberals have aided the National-Libe1 the Centre of the Reichstag, these parties have sim behest great landlords, masses people, and and more radical als or in electing members ply accepted the favor and gone on with the slightest regard the of those, like Dr. Barth, who turned the in their favor. To the Social Democrats Dr. Barth now makes tures, despite their policy of isolation, for with all defects it the party which, correct mistaken methods, seeks earnestly to right intol- social conditions. Should the radical Liberals follow Dr. Barth’s ad- vice, the Social-Democratic wing of the to make gains in certain portions of Prussia out for wishes scales ove! is its one by or erable Reichstag ought considerable we “While pray for the end,” we weep over the mean must wrote Jeffe: | The Nation. Sol speaking of tl that the efforts of 1 ! the freedom of w aeprive | ‘ | | ! 1 \“ vic ne nd even ! The vO! to the , f he te political n st. P 2 In Ru i, t I t ! ta esponse \ } cen ip, the disse oO he Duma the suppression of Dp With every other vent fe t) peo] wi closed, outrage and issina ! come press and orator in one. W muzziing of newspa] \ bat no explanation, 1 I ! ty f remonstrance, how « ‘ as Wendell Phillips vid it SS1, re is had to the last \\ t l choked and manacled beyond all othe resistance God m I iat ul power shall be inse ine i eftiect ol the attempt to kill Premier St pit attended by such horrors as th i patches have told us, may lead t} Ru Slan autocrats to new and fiercer as of repression. But the lesson they should learn is the need of hastening the law ful and free and recognized expr on of the hopes and demands of the Ru sian people by means of an unfettered press and local and national assemblies Through them, no doubt, the Czar would be exposed to many explosions of elo quence, but that is better than bu ng bombs And it may lb t down as certain that, hereafter, in tl low of Russian tyranny will stalk t Ru sian Terror Condemnation of the Gree} rand whose recent outrages introduce a new complication into the Macedonian situ tion, is well enough, but it hardly ‘ in the mouths of the Bulgarians, who invented this form of ag tion At a mass meeting held at Philipopolis on Sunday, it was resolved to break off diplomatic relations with G and to affirm the inadequacy of tl Muersteg programme for pacifying Mac: no race is in sufficient plurality to have a prescriptive right to Macedonia; and the recent atrocities of the Greek bands While horrible enough, are merely de layed reprisals for years of persecution from many quarters, especially from. the Bulgarian side It is natural that the Bulgars should résent a movement whicl thwarts their plan for a greater Bul garia but it was also to e expected that the Greel would organize to pro tect their civil and ecclesiastical rights The whole imbroglio does, however,show that the Muersteg reforms are entirely inadequate to the situation When it appeared that the Bulgarian revolution might sueceed, a solution of the Mace lo n¢ tion was fairly in view ro da that hope i more than clouded No i ement o be expected until some mandatory of the European Con ‘ ip} ‘ ‘ if \ emplified so 1} Herz i 3 tition of ing it tl Pow re ) i I ( I rar \ name to 1 i Minister in Pat i to a puzzled pressman that ment towards a (:¢ } sentative I tit | iliv be re irded Foreign idea hay t I absorbed at Tel Ku opean ‘ nee i een nvit tro } ! bers withis i \ fitt q ol have been nt fro alone One mem ) } ( Hossein-Khat " 1 Polytechnique of Par Of tl nationa issem|! nar Cong of Nat nal ¢ Persian Mir r has the } | I} Shah he in ne t w 1 Tt n thre x! of the people. It al ime d ‘ t dk democrat The most hoy ire earcely ready t tl stitution in Pe i ind in ¢ he will heart hoy that ft zin movement in Persia 1 ibruptly ende ifter the fa ro d hs ' hy fa W hil \\ American ra t Pan-At way bel t Of t » metre from ( | Cu is now completed it r.erre from ( ‘ ‘ } and 1.500 from C to K I if gz the nt | ier equire tl perm ! if « many ¢ the Cons t to ection of tl ti t be rea y ranted | ise 60 int ( of ! ng i nortl line to unit t! existing o iteral railroad 4 tremends vill accrue to England from thi of tl Negus to use Aby ! to now practically a ‘ Khartum to Fashoda it woul po ble to build the railway Nile, because of a vast swamy ten degree of latitude The ment with the ruler of A take the road through a most gion along the Blue Nile nd of the mountain i far dolph, where English s« reached, France, also, dé efit from the arrangement i as her railway will now ‘ the fertile hiehtatr there connect ‘ t African lings
Page 8
176 DRAWING NEW CLASS LINES. “Bryan,” writes a Hearst supporter, “really does not represent the interests of the but those of the small shopkeeper and farmer.” On this point, Mr. Bryan might easily make an- workingman, swer along the line of a famous pas- sage in his Chicago convention speech It ran thus “The farmer who goes | forth in the morning and toils all day who begins in the spring and toils all summer—and who by the application of | brain and muscle to the natural re- | sources of the country creates wealth— is as much a business man as the man who goes upon the Board of Trade and bets upon the price of grain.” He might ay now that the farmer is as much a workingman” as any one employed in a shop or factory But suppose it be accepted that for some mysterious rea- son the interests of the farmer and the all shopkeeper are permanently dif- ferent: suppose that future political cleavages in this country should be on lines of complete “class consciousness”— how would that affect the prospects of the “workingman’s candidate”? We sup- pose he would concede the right of the despised farmers and shopkeepers to cast a vote apiece, and have it counted. It only remains to ask how many there are of the two groups under considera- tion. That discourager of so many attrac- tive theories, the United States Census, supplies the answer. It shows that with- in the continental United States there were 29,073,233 persons engaged in “gain- ful occupations” in 1900. They were dis- tributed among the five groups of indus- tries as follows: 10,381,705 Agricultural pureuits Profeas al service 1,258,538 Thom ind personal service 5.580 G57 Trade and transportation 4.766.004 Manufacturing and mechanical pursuits 7,085,309 Thus, at the outset, the group to which the “workingman” belongs is outnum- bered considerably more than two _ to one by the groups in which the farmer and the shopkeeper are found. Even after deducting women and children, the totals remain as 12,403,713 to 6,533,872, reapectively. Or one may limit the scope of the classification, cutting out all min- or subdivisions, and consider merely the and overseers” and “merchants and dealers (except " Of these two classes, again women and children, there “farmers, planters the wholesale) leaving out ore 6,121,671, as against only 5,601,988 in the whole range of “Manufacturing and mechanical pursuits” from “Car- penters and joiners” to “Upholsterers.” Plainly, if the artisans should unite against the farmers and the shopkeepers, every tightening of class lines would mean an additional certainty of defeat. For the notion that the artisan, the mill-hand, and the like constitute a spe- cial class which should be the object of bis solicitude and favor, several peculiar The Nation. causes are responsible. The unions have done all they could to foster the idea. There was no other hypothesis on which two million or so of citizens could claim the right to dictate to the other eighty millions. Yet the protectionist has prob- ably done still more to create the false impression. The cartoonist of Judge, for instance, draws the workingman in his square paper cap and the capitalist with mutton-chop whiskers, if they represented the entire interest of the country, so that the full dinner-pail for and the fat bank account for the stood for universal prosperity. as one other Yet Edward Atkinson showed from the official figures that at most 14 per cent. of the people of this country are sup- ported in industries directly benefited by the tariff. Protectionists believe that among “produc- throughout the engendered will diffuse itself nation; yet they do not dwell on the fact that the group from which this beneficent influence spreads includes so small an element, while 86 per cent. of the population receive their tariff bless- prosperity ers” ings at second hand. Attempts to array the rich against the the employed against the employ- are nothing But such a poor er, new against capital, in this country. between different of the oppressed is somewhat Is not the Trust giant smiting with impartial bludgeon the farmer, the shopkeeper, and the workman? Extortionate selling prices, inadequate buying prices, illegal discriminations are certainly taking mo- ney out of the pockets of all three alike. Yet that is not a cohesive issue for the “toiling masses” only. The profession- al classes, the domestic servants, in fact all but a minute fraction of the voting population, agree with Mr. Hearst or Mr. Bryan or President Roosevelt or any one else who preaches against spe- cial privilege. For this, the most genu- ine grievance, is the one which there is least excuse for attempting to make a class issue. It has always been the pride and the distinction of American political par- ties that they have drawn members from all social and industrial classes alike. There is nothing in the present situation to justify a change in this historic policy. It is possible sometimes for a smaller group to hold the balance of power, locally and for a time, as or- ganized labor is attempting to do in the Congressional elections. But avowed exclusive devotion to one element would be the very surest way of reducing either of the great parties into a petty faction, or a public menace labor even break groups novel. THE VACILLATING CZAR. The unexpected dispatches, stating that the Russian Government will pro- ceed at once to the distribution of 20,- 000,000 acres of public land among the [Vol. 83, No. 2148 peasants, raise more questions than the} The plan is announced as in part political. By doing a popular act, and granting what is admitted to be an instalment of long-delayed justice, it is the Czar’s hope that he may get a ‘docile’ Duma next time. But the re- sult might easily be the opposite. The peasantry may take this concession merely as one extorted through fear— really a confession that the policy of autocratic repression is breaking down in the Government’s hands. Something bas to be done; so this sop is thrown to the peasants; but strange thoughts are evidently astir in Ivan’s head, and he may conclude that all he has to do is to keep on threatening and mutiny- ing and massacring in order to get much more. The second Duma may prove more indocile than the first. 3esides, it is necessary to ask how far the scheme of land relief will go, be- fore deciding that it will be popular much less accepted as a permanent so- lution of the agrarian question. On this point the figures are eloquent. We fol- low a Russian writer in the Journal des Débats of June 20. He shows, first, the enormous preponderance of the agricul- tural population in Russia. According to the Imperial census of 1897, it amounted to 112,000,000 out of 129,000,- 000 people in all the Empire. Probably to-day it numbers 125,000,000 out of 145,000,000—six-sevenths. Thus Russia is by far the most “rural” country in Europe. Yet more than half of all the lund is owned by the state and the com- munes. The Russian Government is the greatest landed proprietor in the world. In the various forms of crown lands, appanages, etc. it owns some 400,000,000 of acres. Only a small per- centage of this, however, is suited for agricultural purposes. The larger part is forest and swamp. Hence it would be impossible for the Government to sat- isfy the vast land hunger out of its own reserves merely. It is now proposed to distribute some 15,000.000 acres of pub- lic lands. The authority we are fol- lewing estimates that very little more than that is actually available for til- lage. But what is this among so many? Will not this bare beginning inevitably drive the 100,000,000 landless peasants forward to the plan of expropriating the holdings of the great landlords? And how can such a project be financed? Certainly not without the Duma; and it may be the Government that will be “docile” when it has to go to the repre- sentatives of the people to ask for loans and financial gugrantees. This first step in land distribution is piainly taken only because the Czar's counsellors perceive that the peasantry is seething with discontent and revolt. The first taste of popular institutions among the peasants has altered them radically. Many landlords who went to answer. ‘
Page 9
; August 30, 1906] gan its sittings, returned to the capital saying: “We do not recognize our peas- ants. They have changed completely since the elections to the Duma,” The is a thing of the past. reason, as the servile mujik And that is the very great authority on Russia, Anatole Le- roy-Beaulieu, explained in advance, why this stop-gap plan of land apportionment will not do. The peasants have their eves opened at last. They have lost their old simple faith in the Little Fath- er who would do justice, did his cour- tiers permit him to know the facts. They see that the Grand Dukes are the greatest and richest landlords, and will rot hear of a law of even partial ex- propriation. No more will the Church. And the attitude of the peasant Depu- tres in the Duma made it pretty certain that, as M. Beaulieu writes, when once it is clear that the Imperial family is the great obstacle to the distribution of land, the peasant will have been “cap- tured for the revolution.” There may even be, thinks this cautious and _ in- formed French observer, “an overthrow of the ‘hrone.” This is very like what the best Eng lish authority on Russia, Mackenzie Wallace, writing from St. Petersburg on August 11, predicted in the London Times. He foresaw the coming of a time of “internal ferment, compared with which all the disorder, pillaging, and assassination of the past months will have the appearance of public order.” In- deed, another correspondent of the same reports a statement made a prominent newspaper full three years ago by Russian, since known as a Constitution- al Democrat. Even at that date he was appalled at the success of the propa ganda of the extremists. He said: Neither you nor any other foreigner knows, very few Russians know, the prog- ress these men have made among the peas- antry and workmen, in the face of what seemed insurmountable difficulties But I have made it my business to keep in touch with their agitation, and I assure you that I am almost appalled at the way in which it has grown and is still growing They have won from the people that I frankly doubt whether it is any long er possible to save Russia from a bloody such support revolution. In view of the bittter discon tent which is steadily growing among all classes of the population, the Government will, sooner or later, be forced to try to conciliate public opinion by some real or pretended concessions But it will be too late. It the bureaucracy shows a sign of weakness, is already too late. So soon as the revolutionary movement will become irresistible. Satisfy us will be of no avail against th« new forces which are being roused through out the country The will make demands which it will be im porsible for any Government to grant There will be an appeal to force, and the result will be a chaos. Reforms which would amply uneducated masses alarming as this Depressing and The Nation. visit their estates after the Duma be-| prophecy is, it reads amazingly like a description of the course of events as Nothing, in fact, has occurred since the abrupt dissolution of we see it unfolded. the Duma to alter the conclusion that it blunder. The Czar should have terms with the Moderate party. In the next Duma, there may be no moderate party was a monumental come to ARCHITECTURAL COMPETITIONS. There is professional circles with discontent in the prevailing halit of architectural competitions. The that managed and that they are uneconomic and vicious in Representing the first nent architect asserted in the last gen- Institute that Mr. conside rable dissidents take the view either competitions are clumsily unfairly judged, or else class, a promi- : meeting of the McKim’'s plans for the University Club in New York would never have received a competition. The state- and certainly in n award in ment was undisputed cicates that there usually is something ain‘ss with the programmes, the judges or the competing architects. The small- er class which regard competition not only as subject to perversion, but as un- just ab initio, offer a plausible but not wholly convincing moral argument for their case. It is illustrated in a clever skit by Mr. Henry Rutgers Marshall, in last month’s l American imagines the which he Architectural | | ' | these are defects principle. | | architects almost | only after they have Architect, in | | System that | say, fifty designs 1G7 bers of the jury, we will not go, because inherent in any such If the profession of architec than rivalry ture is worse off in the others, it this respect behooves the authorita a severer attitude There said against a tive bodies to assum«e towards unprofessional conduct is, however, much to be uneconomically brings out where a single build ing is required, and tends at least to eliminate the best firms and leave mon umental buildings to be scrambled f by mediocrities. But all this is large! a matter of methods. Because invitatior competitions are insufficiently paid is not a reason for abolishing them, nor is the frequent petitions holding of open com would What ulviser where limited contest be advisable, a cause for despair we want is clearly a class of and judges, such as actually exists in France, capable of drawing up simpls and rational programmes, beyond per sonal influences, and fully aware of the mere tricks of the draughtsman which would pass for substantial design In short, the most serious criticism of com petitions among us lies not so much vegainst the system itself as against the average committee and jury When it is remembered that young always commend the exstem, changing to the other opinion arrived, it will be felt that the practice has at least the | merit of encouraging rising talent. For League proposing a competition among | lawyers in order to choose its solicitor. | The fairly of the reward, ete. wiih the slightest alterations from the programme for the new buildings of quacy Union Theological Seminary. The in- rence is that such a competition is an offront equally to the legal and archi- tectural professions. The moral] objection may be more concretely stated as follows: Ten estab lished firms are invited to enter a competition for a million dollars, being rromised a thousand dollars apiece as for the expense of. prelim- But the regular fee for would be in ndennity inary designs. such reparing designs | every case one per cent., or ten thousand dollars. In other words, the building | committee receives, in nine cases, at a | This argument, worth ten math- dollars a service however is too thousand ematically good to be true, and falls to the ground when it igs recalled that no be compelled to enter a competition The could any day le defeated by an agreement of the best firms to stay out. On the other hand, it should be noted that estab- lished firms do compete under protest, the method is very to grave miscar- archiicet can system wit a sense that defective, and subject riages of justice. Into the matter of log-rolling, play- ing up to the taste of influential mem- grotesque terms, the inade- | are borrowed | this reason alone, we should be sorry to see the admittedly uneconomic open competitions wholly done away with Ve feel that it is the hazard of very important building; but there is a unwise to trust to such a free-for-all any whole class of smaller structures of a public or semi-public character where competitions eminently in With respect to the missions, we can only say that it Is ab open seem mace greater com turd to expect a firm that is prospering to encounter unpaid the chances of a furthermore, that it is un with- large field; fair to as} every such a firm to compete fully Experience has taught, too, that in most cases the best obtained without tion by selecting the architect directly But right the human and unprofessional side of the problem An individual may fairly picking his man, but the great buildings are rarely in the hands of individuals A corporation, lay or ecclesiastical, will practically have the greatest difficulty in making an impartial choice. As many competent architects may be in as there are stockholders or pew-owners When the rebuilding of St. Thomas's Church was broached, it was found that some forty architects had substantial backers in the parish. Under such cir cumstances, what is there for it but the Apostolic method of casting a lot, out at stage repaying the costs of competition. results are compet! here appears succeed in sight
Page 10
form of competition? It edly thi motive that led Commune of Florence in the old » | out so many of its monu I l competition and the same ym is likely to be sought whenever rect choice of an architect seems im ) ible iB natural misapprehension of the ope of competitions th have been ( ed i bad way ofl eller ne i Llcdis \ 1 matter of fact they eV ire a wavy of selecting a building The artfully tinted drawing that win the uff of juris have the very ntest re Lt lor to the building that » | At best, they are merely an tion that the winner of the com- n WwW we 0 an acceptable | \ 1 method of choosing an chiteet—the real difficulty for build- committee there is much to be r competition They afford, if fi iently a lame conclusion, at least a eonelh on where otherwise there might i interminable deadlock | 1 it the situation broadly, the ) vin advice micht be tentatively offered to client (1) Choose an arch ‘ direct if you can; (2) for a mon- el 1 buildin hold a limited and nerly paid competition if vou must; (3) for an ordinary building, hold an open competition, if you will. Finally rchitects will probably have to put up th a tem generally unsatisfactory from a professional point of view, so on is it affords an obvious convenience to that soulle but indispensable en t the average corporate client THER READING OF FARMERS tatistie of cireulation in the trav ellir librarie of Wisconsin throw an nite light upon the reading of fa ! of that State When the em tarted seven vears ago the ! iy boxes were plentifully stock i with worl on agriculture and na hool 1 careful selection of the ir nd mo popular being made. But ‘ found that the Wisconsin farmer ill not read such books under any in ducemet He desire no advice about hi el ne incurious a to the ! ! beast and plants of his neigh rhood. The liow to Know” and sim ol had, however, a splendid read the town The farms showed an feeble demand for works on rile finance, and civie improve rent ieven discussions of the labor probletr e per tently neglected, His for too. found ‘ few devotees In f t. nothtr ie more striking about the bucolle taste In tters than its complete contemporanett Thi ear in the first class of hook which the farmer of Wisconsin do read Biography has fallen below the expectations of the literary bureau but for lives of persons of current no | Nation. The toriety there is a considerable demand. The only solid reading that is really popular on the farms is travels. Fic- tion, both standard and current, is eag- | erly devoured there as elsewhere. We believe we may consider Wisconsin in this matter as fairly representative of ithe country at large. Sojourners on New England farms will confirm the triple categories of recent biography, travel, and fiction. The books that are likely to be in every prosperous farm- er’s library are such biographies as the Grant Memoirs, Blaine’s “Twenty Years in Congress,” and the lives of such not- able divines as Beecher, Moody, Spur- geon, etc. Many New England farm- houses of the better class possess the entire series of Livingstone and Stan- ley, to which are frequently added the chief Polar expeditions, and more rare- ly the travels of Sven Hedin and other Asiatic explorers. The Alpine books of Whymper Fiction, by are rarer, but not unknown. of and the indiscriminate grace the summer board- taste for it is ap- Where New England might perhaps claim a superi- er, abounds, | rently ority over Wisconsin is in the matter of devotional and theological works. There bas been and is a considerable public for such harmonizing treatises as those 0° the late Henry Drummond, on science and religion. The Wisconsin statistics are silent as to those rural character- sketches comprised in the _ so-called ‘b’gosh school,” but it is safe to say that these are very little read in the reighborhoods whence the various Uncle Ephraims and Aunt Sabrinas are drawn. Caricature is, in fact, rarely greeted with enthusiasm by the travestied persons. One need not be a profound psychol- ogist to realize why farmers do not | read for self-improvement. Even in these of the and car the agricultural life is a comparatively days telephone trolley monotonous one, and if the toiler reads all, it is for recreation solely. A nat- curiosity leads him to explore the of political heroes: at ural lives his and ecclesiastical a vague longing for wider bound- for of romance, ex- plains the taste for fiction and books of aries, something travel. For many a community the itin- erant missionary represents’ strange lands and peoples, the steamy breath of palms. He the tropics, and the feathery is the natural forerunner of the book egent with African and Asiatic, not to say Polar, adventures to sell. The ‘Wis- | consin and all other statistics fail us on an interesting point, namely: What hooks are read by Philemon, what by Paucis? We think it no unfair sup- position that “Twenty Years in Con- gress” and the Stanley travels are read by father, and the “Dolly Dialogues” and Zenda books by mother, after the upper dishes have been put in the cup- board It would be interesting to carry the analysis closer and inquire what novel- [ Vol, 83, No. 2148 ists are read in the country. From ob- servation, limited be but ex- tending over several years and includ- ing many districts of New England, we confidently say that Howells and James are not read on the farms. Apparently, the objection of Mr. Owen Wister’s “Vir- that nothing happens in such damns them among our sturdy wasterners also. Curiously enough, Mr. Cable was read, apparently, for his ex- oticism. Mark Twain's earlier books, especially “Roughing It” and “Innocents Abroad,” have usually been present in book-cases under our observation. Of recent years the more knowing society nevels have put in an appearance; but these glimpses into Mayfair and Cosmop- olis are, as we have hinted, due rather ic the summer boarder than to the bu- to sure, ginian” books, colic demand. Of course, all inferences from statis- tics of travelling libraries and inspec- tion of farm-house living rooms are vit- ieted by the all-pervasive magazines. Through clubs, the monthlies are very extensively circulated. and there is no means of knowing which portion of the fare provided by the editor is best rel- ished by the farmers of the land. One may fairly assume, however, that the preponderance of fiction is what at- the up-country districts, as in- deed it does the towns. The slack de- mand for the works of publicists shown by the Wisconsin statistics suggests that the muck rake may not have stirred the country soil very deeply. Its havoc has been, perhaps, largely confined to city thoroughfares. There is nothing in the taste for romance that forbids us to be- lieve that they are canny folks “in the deestricts” and rather “sot in their ways” as regards both their reading and believing. If our theory that farmers read chiefly for recreation be true, it is no wonder that they decline to be caught in the present quasi-sociological freshet. tracts THE TEACHING OF LATIN—A CRITI- CISM AND A REMEDY. thirty years the teach- in the high school has been completely revolutionized The a conviction that adapted to mod- and that loss of Latin as of classical cul- to the method of teaching rather than to the itself If the changed conditions could be adequately met it seemed that no further decay was to be During the last ing of Latin almost change has been due to the old ern conditions, the chief fure was method was not representative due study apprehended These considerations were The position of Latin and the method of teach- were the heritage of the Middle Latin formed the greater part of the training of youth for every pursuit in life. It was, therefore, a practical study intended to be immediately useful, and the it detailed and extensive times, however, the pressure other subjects upon the sound ing it Ages when training in was modern many in of at- sO
Page 11
August 30, 1906 mn f fhe hoel led >a progressive iilm of tl mie hat could be given » | I V nou iny pa ticular change n the method of teaching it, and the re lt wi i progressive diminution of the net result of knowledge and an apparent minution in its effective value as culture Two suggestions for improvement were made one with regard to the introductory ining, the other with regard to the 1uthors read The introductory book was restricted in compass, and greatly modi- fie in method The old idea of learning t heart large masses of paradigms, lists of exception ind multitudes of unimpor tant details was abandoned, and the essen tial facts were presented in small sections » that the student could make immediate ise of his knowledge The vocabulary wa tricted to the words used most frequent iy by Cesar and Cicero, and various dé vice were employed to produce interest the commentaric on Cesar, Cicero, and Virgil became marvels of exegetical and ilu itive material ethnology, geog raphy statistics comparative religior compara philology military science law, arch log irt, all contributed thei re In the note were otten twice a el vi i he ext And yet. in spi f this he criticism was made that stu den came up to college with a smaller hnowledg of Latin than they exhibited fort years ago, and, still worse left coi lege unable to read a passage of ordinary Latin except with an effort, which after 1 few years became almost prohibitive To meet this difficulty, some institutions under the lead of Harvard University, mod ified their entrance requirements so that entering students were required to trans late not passages from works previously read, but passages hitherto unseen. Un doubtedly, good results were gained from this requirement, but it appears that even here no definite plan of instruction was pursued, and, furthermore, that the ad vantas obtained by the student at en trance was lost in the subsequent college aining. Accordingly, it now appears that while Latin is increasing proportionally in the secondary school it is still losing ground proportionally in the colleges, and that the knowledge shown by students on le aving college indicates no signs of better Inent Several remedies may be suggested In the first place, it cannot be too strongly emphasized that the habit of making the classics the occasion for instruction in an is fundamentally be nt y, life, and art While cir history, unsound Latin will retained, and should be retained, largely on account of its exceptional value for mental train- ing, it is. nevertheless, just as unques tioned that the influence of this language for centuries has been due largely to the value of the literary masterpieces which it embodies. Now, any seheme of instru tion which minimizes the study of the Latin authors as literature fails to do jus tice to the study Livy and Tacitus are not the places to study Roman history Roman mythology should not be the es ential feature in reading Virgil Public law is not the main reason for reading Cicero It may be laid down as a funda mental principle that little more should be expected from a student be in Latin than could reasonably the exper ted from ancient The Nation. I ead of tt ' } { sa toon 1 mm ther information a he ¢ ogy of Britain or Germany nd ) nothing by h gnorance Why ! i more be de n led of our luck ! boy Now, to read a LA hor with ud ness and appreciat ju know lee and it is here that y chief sm of he present method of ir 1 on appl in acquaintance wit! x and with he « ential laws f V x nece ary ind is everywhere mands But ever with the knowledge f paradigms and syn tax, the student will | ible to read if he does not possess } wledge of word In the old method “ ippe tha this knowledge would t gained by a lu us humbing of he lex but any ne who has gone th igh school and »! lege annot fail to emember how little ial progre was mad the prepar m of any one le mn I t essential er of word-kn le rhe prime ne y in teaching | ! ! p y ecordingly he v mat ly ft wo rh tu I ‘ ! r rhe most listinguished cho both I I ype and here have emphasiz 1 it ind me again But, as far as | know, no fi 1ite system has been devised app ble to our present condition For the study of words oO language po ‘ ‘ such unique adva Lge a lor the Latin Its vocabulary marvellously compact as well as efficient, and there fore more can be done with a small im ber of Latin words than can be done with the same number in any othe language rhe authors read in chool prove thi rhe first five books of Ca r’s Gallic Wat show a total of 2,120 word rhe x speeches of Cicero read in the chools how a total of 2,158 word rhe total vo ibulary for the first x bool of Virgil's Eneid” is 3,229 words. The ital word-list of these three authors comprises only 4 6S words Now, it go« without ying that in the study of vocabulary hose vords should be particularly emphasized which occur’ most frequer y ind fo the purpose of my study I have illed out those which occur in the selectior mentioned five times or more The otal number 1929. That these words a presentative | have test through the ed by taking a cla Civil War of C@sar, the Pro Roscio Amerino’’ of Cicero, and four or five books of Ovid's Metamorphos: | found that of the words to which I have alluded, 1,900 appear in the authors | have mentioned,and that, with the knowledge of the meaning if those 1,900, my students w e able o read without difficulty and without consult n of the lexicon If, therefore, during the four years of his training in the high hool, the pupil were re{uired to acquai himself tho roughly with approximately 2,000 Latin words, he would have at hand fully nin tceen-twentieths of the total vocabulary of any Latin author of literary value which he would meet Several other considera ons reinforce thi argumet Phe (yf words to which I have alluded contain mors than 800 verbs, of which the majority are simple verbs If the tudent has, in addi m to this knowledge even rudimentary acquaintance with the principles of Latin ord formation, he has really at h contro! ' ’ ‘ " , | ) | , i i be ‘ , u iw Aine to read ord I y “ } lift ? ty pur s hey id | } ' \ . f | he ' ! ee) » 4 ' } " 1 i ' j | : . , " ' | “able ' _ } } \W hat ‘ ! mea ‘ 1 7 tud ’ 1 ide } vl } , } that i f ‘ ‘ “A I | Vill beg be i t pu r ip ! f h } ! j ‘>I } } —_— , , | P , ill | I ge ‘ ! 1 1 Ind " | = § ] with ea with a defi vl h ha i} G I ‘ FIRST EDITION OF rhik cy SCANDA Sheridan's play Drury Lane The e, M played succe f it { period No ed on was] a number of y t out in Dublin witt f production on tl P | ly considered the ff } Dublin, for J. Ew ‘ Mr Anderson, it he bit ¥ to Sandera’s Lif f ‘ for it he date of 7 w? Vl j in a recent bibliograp! i it was printed pre 1
Page 12
180 course of the next year after it was first acted, that is, 1778."" The date generally affixed in booksellers’ and auction cata- logues is 1781 In Part VI. of the McKee sale in 1902 a copy with imprint “Dublin: Printed in the Year, 1781," was offered, with the following note In all probability this is the genuine first edition of Sheridan's famous comedy It Is a matter of record that a manuscript copy of the play was sent over to Mr. Thomas Ryder of the Dublin Theatre, and as he himself, assumed the character of Sir Pe ter in the representation given at his own theatre (see cast), the presumption Is strong that his publication of the play pre ceded that of Mr. Ewling’s, which bears no date But an edition with earlier date than this, apparently undescribed, certainly ex ists, with the title The | School for Scandal, A Come- dy; As it was performed at the | Theatres Royal in | London | and | Dublin Dub lin Printed in the Year M,DCC,LXXX. | It is a very poorly printed pamphlet of forty-two leaves, in appearance looking like a pirated edition, or one got out in a great hurry for the use of actors. The dramatis persona, on reverse of title, does not con tain the printed names of the actors, though, in the copy examined, these have been written in A word-for-word com- parison of this and the undated edition printed for Ewling has been made in an effort to discover which is actually the earlier. The differences, comparatively few in number, show almost conclusively that either one was printed from the other or both from a common manuscript which was followed pretty closely. “End of the First Act,” ete., are found in the 1780 edition, but not in that of Ewling Exits read, “Exit Snake,” ets in the 1780 edition, while that of Ewling generally has ‘“Exit’’ only. Line 3, page 2, in Ewling edition, has “in their lives,’ while the corresponding phrase in the 1780 edition is, “in the whole course of their lives.”"’ This is the great- est textual difference, and, if it be taken as a basis, we are obliged to call Ewling’s edition the earlier, as later editions, after the play had been revised throughout by the author, read in the course of their lives.’ Drote’’ for “droit” and “‘done” for don simply show that the Irish printer of the 1780 edition understood no French Preserve youth,”’ in line 24, page 34, of Ewling’s edition, becomes “ruin youth" (exactly opposite and wrong), in the 1780 edition “Lies in question,’ in line 31, page 90, of the Ewling edition, reads, in the 1780 edition, “lying questions,’ the latter being wrong Most of the differences, in fact, are mistakes of careless printers, Ew- ling’s edition ia fairly well printed, and has a considerable list of errata, while the 1780 edition is a very roughly printed piece On the whole, it seema as if the edition printed for Ewling may retain its position as the first edition, although this hereto- fore undiscovered edition of 1780 may have the honor of being the firat dated edition It is worth noting that the first American edition of the play, printed In Philadelphia, in 1782, by Robert Bell, and called on the title-page, “The Real and Genuine School for Scandal! certainly printed from this 1780 edition, or a very accurate re- print of it. Most of the misprints, such as those of the two French words noted above, was | | | [Vol. 83, No. 2148 The Natio are copied. The Philadelphia printer, how- ever, saw the obvious nonsense of the phrase, ‘“‘ruin youth,” and was able to cor- rect the sense, though he did not light upon quite the correct word. He printed it “save youth.” I have examined, also, another Ameri- can edition, printed by Hugh Gaine in New York in 1786. The title-page states that it was printed “From a Manuscript copy in the possession of John Henry, Esquire, joint manager of the American Company, given him by the author.” Below the dramatis persone is the following advertisement: So many spurious Copies of The School for Scandal having been obtruded on the Publick, has induced the Editor to lay before them, in its proper Garb, this most excellent Comedy, presented to him by Richard Brinsley Sheridan, Esq.; the justly admired Congreeve of the present Times. In the same connection as the paragraph already quoted, Moore in his life of Sheri- dan, says: The edition printed in Dublin is, with the exception of a few unimportant omissions verbal differences, perfectly correct. I have collated this edition with the copy given by Mr. Sheridan to Lady Crewe (the last, I believe, ever revised by him), and find it correct throughout. and Then, in a footnote he gives one of the al- terations made by Sheridan in Lady Crewe’s copy: Lady Teazle, in her scene with Sir Peter in the second act, says: “That's very true, indeed, Sir Peter; and after having married you, I should never pretend to taste again, I allow.” It was thus that the passage stood at first in Lady Crewe’s copy, as it does still, too, in the Dublin edition, and in that given in the collection of his | works, the original reading of the sentence, such as I find it in all his earlier manu- scripts of the play, is restored: ‘That's very true, indeed, Sir Peter; and, after having married you, I am sure I should never pretend to taste again.” There is some discrepancy of statement here which I cannot explain Lady Tea zle’s speech as given in full by Moore in his edition of Sheridan’s Works (the above is quoted from the Life) is as follows: Sir Peter; and That's very true, indeed, should never after having married you, I pretend to taste again, I allow. But now, Sir Peter, if we have finished our daily jangle, I presume I may go to my engage- ment at Lady Sneerwell’s The same speech by Lady Teazle in three Dublin editioas (the dated 1780, the one printed for Ewling, and another later undated edition) reads: one Why then you force me to say shock- ing things to you But now we have fin- ished our morning conversation, I presume I may go to my engagements at Lady Sneerwell's While in the Gaine edition, printed from a by the author, the passage manuscript reads Aye! that’s very true, indeed, after hav- ing married you, I never should pretend to taste again But now, Sir Peter, as we have finished our daily jangle, I pre- sume I may go to my engagement at Lady Sneerwell's It is evident, therefore, that if Moore had by him a copy of some Dublin edition read- ing as indicated his note, it must have been of a more recent date. L. 8. L. nN. } as we This branch | who Correspondence. HISTORY, ANCIENT AND MODERN. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Columbia and Yale may be warmly congratulated on an innovation that is to mark the opening academic year. They have decided to join forces so as to constitute a specially adapted for students wish to fit for Govern- employment, consular or Incidentally, the same training to those whd Administrative Sir: department themselves ment colonial, diplomatic. will be of service merely wish to understand problems, or world politics, to journalists, to missionaries. Commercial and in- law, European and Oriental commercial geography, consular to others, even ternational languages, and diplomatic practice, economics, modern other allied subjects will be taught This all it should be, and corresponds with a need which our historic history, and is as growth as a nation has now brought on us. On text much might be written, but the present purpose to one branch only of these studtes, the one that this is to advert must answer the purpose of foundation for all the others, that is history. What is being done by Columbia and Yale is a hope- ful symptom for the future of historical studies in this country. For it brings into sharp prominence the utility of studying recent history and the further fact that the history of the nineteenth century—to fix a convenient period—is one requiring a special approach Whereas the study of the ancient world and of the Middle Ages tends dangerously to become an academic routine, in which research is merely the road to the doctorate and the professorial chair, the history of the years just behind us should be an introduction to practical life, a guide to the evolution in political thought and political methods from which the ever-changing fabric of human society in it to-day has been woven. of history, different from the old academic history, is a practical study, giving to the administrator, the dip- lomat, the man of the the politi- cian, the journalist, a comparative point of move so world, | view whereby he can judge more effectively how this, that, or the other event he has to deal with stands in the world's evolution and the struggle of nations. Nothing here written is meant to imply criticism of the very excellent work done in the history departments of our universi- ties. On the contrary, it is certainly the case that the standard set has been tend- ing steadily upwards of recent years. The trouble has been merely the non-recogni- tion of the fact that if the remote past was worthy of study, the immediate past is equally worthy, and, additionally, that its lessons may have practical, or let us technical, value. aay, It was the logical minded French who first perceived the need which the modern world has of drawing by scientific methods lessons from yesterday to guide its way to- morrow. A small group of eminent French- men, Boutmy, Taine, Albert Sorel, Paul Le- roy-Beaulieu, and others, Judging that the national catastrophe 1870-71 had pro- ceeded largely from ignorance of political science in all parts of the community, de- cided that this ignorance should be reme- of w
Page 13
died by instruction point of the now-famous Ecole des Sciences Politiques, an institution concerning which | two remarks must here be made. The first is that, taking the history of the since 1789 as the foundation of its teaching, it copied the methods of that older and excellent institution the Ecole des Chartes; been con- never academic. The oth- of modern has never also its aim has stantly practical is that shown er remark no institution and France such sudden such splendid Whereas the ol the Second Empire and of many of the early France has results years of the Third Republic was crassly, suicidally, ignorant of the elements of po- litical science, now, within the Tast few years, a most remarkable change has taken place, largely the work of the Ecole des Sciences Politiques. Frenchmen now write on colonial, international, economic ques- tions, statistics in hand and firmly ground- ed in political and and the old lies and fairy tales of the Bou- the laughing stock of fast becoming rieur jeu R. M historical knowledge, levard prints, long Europe, are JOHNSTON. Cambridge, Mase., August 27 THE MS. OF EVELYN’S DIARY. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: The new edition of Evelyn’s “Diary and Correspondence,” Mr. H. B. Wheat- ley, the accomplished editor of Pepys, has by been awaited by scholars with interest. The original editor of Evelyn, like those of Pepys, has omitted large portions of the diary, and additional material of con- siderable importance was expected in this Mr has been able only to reproduce Bray’s text, for the present owner of the manuscript has refused to permit a inspection of it. A similar difficulty of my own had prepared for this and as my experiences the annoyances such an edition as this en- new edition Wheatley, however, new result; to on me may illustrate which work serve tails, they may not be without interest to your readers. The Diary, letters, and other manuscripts of John Evelyn are now in the possession of a the who has also inherited the ancestral estate of Wotton Court. of these letters I was anxious to include in a work which I am editing for the Clarendon Mr. Sidney Lee kindly consented to inter- cede for me with Mr. Evelyn so that I might procure a transcript of the letter. Mr. Evelyn, who is now of a very advanced age, replied that he had presented all the MSS. at Wotton to his son, and that no one Mr. Lee thereupon wrote to the younger Eve- lyn, who, in reply, regretted that he was unable to permit an inspection of the let- ter, as his father objected to having the MSS. disturbed in any way! All the papers were carefully stored away, and there was no reason to doubt the accuracy of Bray’s original transcription. I was not wholly satisfied by this assur- ance, and on the recent visit of Dr. J. E Sandys of the University of Cambridge to this country I casually mentioned this dif- ficulty to him. He offered to obtain the descendant bearing same name, One Press, and but this son could give access to them assistance of Mr. Frederic Harrison, whose family were neighbors of the Evelyns at Wotten, and who might gain as a friendly This was the starting world | The Na tion. favor what the interests of scholarship had failed to secure The efforts of Mr. Harri- 60n were, however, no less futile than those of Mr. Lee; and so, like M Wheatley, I shall be obliged to rest content with Bray's antic ed transcript It will appear per- force in an appendix, for every other of the many texts in my tl volumes has been transcribed from the original The Diary of Pepys is in the possession of an academic ins it is always open to the inspection of mpetent schol ars; and successive ed rs have added such new material as a growing terest in Pe- pys and a fresher conception of scholar ship have demanded. The Diary of Evelyn is in the hands of a private owns who is wholly unaware of its histor and import wholly out of sympathy with the humane studies of his distinguished ancestor. Sure ly a public document of th sort belongs rightfully to a public institution, and no student of English letters will rest con tent until it has found its way into the British Museum. But there is still another observation which this incident suggests The charge of sordidness and unenlightenment which is so often brought against American collec- tors and bibliophiles may receive a wider application. Vandals and Goths may flour- ish among the country estates of England no less than in the stockyards of Chicago J. E. SPINGARN August 27 University, [Every scholar will feel with Mr. Spin- gurn in his indignation at such nig |} gardly treatment. At the same time a pessible mitigation of this judgment be found in the notice of the book may printed on another page.—-Ep. Narion.] DE MILLE IN HALIFAX ° To THE EpITorR OF THE NATION: SIR I submit that Mr. Burpee’s inter- esting letter to the Nation about De Mille was not entirely just to the people of Hali fax. The estimation in which Halifax peo ple held De Mille was substantially that in which he seems to be held by Mr. Burpee himself. I am sure that Mr. Bur mis pee i taken in supposing that Mr Seott Siddons discovered him for the people of Halifax I well remember the occasion of the id ing referred to; Mrs. Siddons prefaced it with the statement that it was by request Unless Mr. Burpee has evidence to the con trary, I should have assumed, as most of us did at the time, that Mrs. Siddons knew little or nothing about De Mille before her attention was drawn to his works by some of his Halifax admirers After De Mille’s death the manuscript of a poem was found among his papers, which was edited by Prof Archibald MacMechan of Dalhousie Uni- versity, Halifax, and published by T. C Allen & Co., Halifax I suspect that the greater part of the subscriptions, without which the volume could not have appeared, | came from Halifax, or, at least, from Nova Scotian admirers of the author. Mr. Bur- pee has made no reference to this work. There are many Halifax people, among | whom I number myself, who would be glad to have his critical opinion of the poem B. RUSSELL Halifax, August 18. Bard, Marq A ‘ lish shortly a w Re by I ft. G I Tt ‘amt ige 1 to issue the Inte authorized and rev i v incongruous form A new volume t ‘ Wright on Sei ( Testament H l by the Bibliot? lir U \ ra at by M | | rhe Life and Worth \ t publishe m by ihe Life ! G if Ludwig and f | f ] nenti ! ] ; \ Kiplir “Puch f | iH 1 by l it I & no } m } ' ’ r Rackham rhe e firm ha , } ot hook } Uy . ! } ‘ ] ‘ G vy K t | e Mu f ' ' l t | It M i On tt i \ h Wild Ar t t rhe Von I \ I f. Gee William Knox 5 f many years lived in th I has written a book o The Sf Orient now ir yu i Y Crowell & Co It d with r ations of Jay 1 tl I ern world we th war Edwin Mark! f electic f ! ‘ ! I Hi f garded by a | | t ch n. TI Mr. : } ed f ‘ ! is I i y » be w i by M Mark! I P. Dutton & ¢ ! ready f mediate public B tt feal Li mn Me wl h g i ite picture of 1 x ‘ i xt commonly seen by foreigne Later hey will put h A Child Recollect of Tenr on by Edith Nicholl Ell 1 " nehter of the lat Dr. Bradley, who i eded Stanley as dean of Westminster rhe book promises familiar and even amu ng glimpses of the Laur it home A series of critical biograph “ haracter l sufficiently nd uted by he le “Modern Poets and Christian Te ng.”’ is coming from Eaton & Ma rl volumes ready this autumn will b-« Rot ert Browning,” by Frank C. Lockw ! Richard Watson Gilder,” Edwin Mark ham,”’ and “FEdward Rowland Sill,"’ by D vid G. Downey; “Matthew Arnold,” by J M. Dixon; “Mra. Browning by Martha Foote Crowe, and “Lowell,” by W A | Quayle To commemorate the 250th anniversary of the settlement of that famous Massa chusetts town, Alice Morehouse Walker has written a book on “Historic Hadley to be published by the Grafton Press. The same
Page 14
——? house preparing a “History of the Ohio of New York,” by Jame H. Ken euly ind the autobiography of Colonel Richard Lathers, edited by Alvan F. San- born, under the title of “Reminiscences of ixty Years in South Carolina, Massachu and New York.” Chapman & Hall in London (the Amert- in importer has not yet been announced) ire preparing a “National Edition of the Works of Charl Dickens” to be complet- ed in forty volumes It will include more than a hundred pieces hitherto uncollected chiefly from his anonymous contributions to Household Words; the full series of Letter now first chronologically arranged; the Poems, Plays, and Speeches,” and the Life by Forster, illustrated by a com- plete I of portraits The first two volum will appeal! n October The edi- to be limited to 750 sets for Eng l 1 and Ame n Duffield & Co. issue to-day a book by M ,. S. Shaler called The Masters of hat which deals with the power of the wil » overcome the seeming disadvantages of life Say Mrs. Shaler For the sug- f the book and for most of the f material contained in it, | am in ! 1 to my husband. In his opinion, the vhole fleld of invalidism in its relation to llectual and moral development de- erve 1 consideration which it has not } hy » received H personal acquaint h many youth who start in the of life with a burden of grave dis bibitie resting upon them made it plain io him that the sense of their handicap was load that needed to be lightened It emed worth while, therefore, to prepare, with special reference to this class, a brief tatement of the achievements of noted perso who, under the stress of grave dif fleultic have hown skill in marshaling their physical and spiritual forces to play he part of men.’ Other books on the list of Duffleld & Co Moliére, the Poet and Man,” by Ho- (. Chatfleld-Taylor; Brandes’s “‘Rem ‘ of My Childhood and Youth,” lated by G M Fox-Davies; The World Painter Since Leonardo,” by J wi tison rhe Plays of Our Forefath ‘ by Charles Mills Gayley, and “China Ballads,’’ by Wallace Irwin Ihe Geographical Journal for August cns with an interesting account by Baron herland Nordeskidld of his archmological in_d ethnographical researches among the Indian in the primeval forests on the boundarth of Bolivia and Peru, some of hom are as yet utterly untouched by civ ition They are now few in number, bul the prevalence of ruins and especial ly of ancient burial places, in which were found many bronze and stone implements howed that formerly the region was dens« ly populated Though forest dwellers and having no ettled abo they are agri itturaliste and cultivate bananas, mandi ocn potator cotton ugar-cane and maize They are industrious, intelligent and chaste but, having a fatal propen ity for liquor, they are becoming pra tically enslaved to the white rubber trad et Their condition differs but little from that of the Congo negroes, and the Baron says that unless the governments inter fere and protect them.from both flre-wa The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2148 ter and the white man they are doomed to extinetion Prof. J. W. Gregory treats of the economic geography and development of Australia and says that because of the enormous deposits of coal and the high quality and wide distribution of its iron ores, he is confident that in the future with the possible exception of China— she will beat the world’s record in the production of iron. The geography of in- ternational boundaries is treated clearly and suggestively by Major E. H. Hills. He lays down the fundamental principles that the permanent frontier should be an ac- tual barrier, clearly indicated, stable; and following existing ethnological or tribal boundaries. Then are described with illus- trations from history the various types, as river, watershed, and artificial frontiers upon parallels of latitude, meridians, or a Straight line, with the grave difficulties arising from them. The importance of the subject to Great Britain is shown by the fact that in Africa alone there are 5,000 miles of frontier common with France and 3,500 with Germany, much of which is un- explored territory, and therefore contain- ing the germs of future misunderstandings Lieut.-Col. Maunsell contributes some notes to accompany his valuable map of Eastern Turkey in Asia Much pleasanter reading than the recent accounts of slaughter in Jolé is an episode related in the May number of the Far East- orn Review (Manila, P. 1.), devoted to the Moro province About two years ago the present district governor of Davao (Lieut E. C. Bolton) received word that a moun- tain tribe of Bilanes had made a descent upon the Tagacaols, and had murdered two or three of the latter. [The peoples men- tioned are non-Mohammedan hill-tribes.] The governor at once proceeded with one or two soldiers and fourteen Tagacaolos sdme fifty miles into the interior, and sud- denly appeared before the house of the Bilan chief, who had never before seen a white man. His first remark to the dis- trict governor was, ‘You look just as I do,” this Bilan chief baving brown hair and eyes, and rather light complexion To in- quiries about the murders, the chief re- plied: “Yes, and we have forty-seven more to kill to get even for a raid they made upon our tribe some years ago.”” The gov- ernor explained that such reprisals could not be allowed, and invited the chief to a conference to be held at Santa Cruz, on the Gulf of Davao, on a certain date some few weeks ahead, which was carefully re- corded by tying the proper number of knots on a string The governor then visited other tribes engaged in vendetta warfare, and on the appointed day the conference was held A judge was appointed from each tribe, with the governor as referee. Witnesses from five tribes went back over ten years of murders, thefts, ete A re- markable fact was that, so far as could be determined, the witnesses all told the truth A table was made showing the depredations of each tribe against the others, like a clearing house sheet, correspond- ing crimes were struck off, and a balance was left against two tribes which had committed more depredations than the others, which they agreed to settle by the payment of two hundred plates and three big gongs They then shook hands all around, and enjoyed the festivities arranged for them Arthur Symons publishes, in the tthe- nrum, some curious discoveries made in the birth registers at St. James's, West- minster, while in search of dates connect- ed with Blake. He found a William Mar- low, son of Christopher and Mary, born March 2, 1709; Jane Marlow, daughter of Xopher and Barbara, born September 21, 1709; besides a Hannah Marlow, born 1748. “It is safe to assume,” he says, “that in the year 1709 no name in English litera- ture was more completely forgotten than that of Christopher Marlowe, and that no Marlowe, therefore, not connected with his family was likely to choose so uncom- mon a name as Christopher (which I found only a few times in the registers of fifty years). Yet, here are two fathers of fam- ilies, at exactly the same time, both called Christopher Marlow.”” Not far off he dis- covered a Mary Ann Faust and a Hester Tamberline, besides a Mary Witchcraft and a Mary Ann Death “The Zambesi beyond the Victoria Falls” was the subject of one of the most at- tractive papers read before the British Association The author, Mr Trevor kattye, went up the river a hundred miles in native dug-outs into a region which, though traversed by Livingstone, had never before been visited by a naturalist. He found the natives highly intelligent, and said that it was not difficult to believe that their ancestors might have designed and built Zimbabwe, the finest of the Rhodesian ruins. This intelligence he il- lustrated by showing a perfectly symmet- rical bowl not made upon a potter's wheel, but by the unaided fingers of a woman; beautifully finished ivory rings cut by primitive chisels and files out of the solid tusk of an elephant; fish spears with barbs almost as fine and quite as sharp as those of a trout fly fashioned out of iron, smelted from the clay iron-stone and forged and then cut when cold. Such work could only be made in England by high mechanical skill. The king, Lewanika, and his son, Litia, were intelligent men anx- ious for the improvement of their people. When the king returned from the Corona- tion, he was so impressed with the won- cers of civilization that he began his open- ing speech to his people with the words, “You are simply baboons! Simply that!” Carlo Tivaroni, whose exhaustive his- tory of modern Italy has given him a per- manent reputation, died at Venice on Au- gust 6. He was born at Zara in 1843. Asa lad of seventeen he enlisted under Gari- baldi in the Sicilian expedition, and again in 1866 and 1867 he obeyed that magician’s call. He was a consistent democrat, who accepted, however, the monarchy as the indispensable symbol of Italian unity. He served one term as deputy from Belluno, but spent most of his life in the Depart- ment of Education, of which he became pre- fect. In 1882 he published his “Storia Critica de la Rivoluzione Francese."’ This forms, indirectly, an introduction to his monumental “Storia Critica del Risorgi- mento Italiano,”” which appeared in nine volumes between 1888 and 1897. The scale on which he worked was broad in generals and minute in particulars. He takes three volumes to bring the story down to 1815; three more for the years 1815-48, and a con-
Page 15
August 30, 1906] for the actual achievement of He had German cluding three unity and independence, 1849-70 the ideals of the most pedantic ‘scientific’ historians at their crudest, making his volumes a receptacle for an immense amount of miscellaneous matter thrown together without regard for form or for attracting the reader's interest. He uses no footnotes, but inserts titles and quotations parenthetically in the body of his text And yet his nine volumes are un questionably the most important record of Italy’s regeneration, and they will long remain a quarry for students, although they can never be popular. They are in the main impartial The fact that Tiva roni was a Mazzinian serves to give dis tinction to his opinions; indeed, the reader who cares to sample Tivaroni at his best cannot do better than to turn at once to his study of Mazzini It is not too much to say that if all the original sources on Risorgimento history were lost, Tivaroni's the notion magnum opus would enable cious historian to get a clear perspica- of that epic transaction The philologists of Germany, and particu larly of celebrating lately the of the birth of if least conspicuous, nine- Bavaria, have been hundredth of the German On annual anniversary one most creative, scholars of the the fourteenth of last meeting of the Ba- memorial teenth March, varian address was delivered by Prof. Ernest Kuhn, of the Adelbert Kuhn, Johann Caspar Zeuss; the founder of Celtic And on July international meeting in commemoration of century at the Academy of Sciences, a son celebrated on philology twenty-second, an Zeuss was held at Bamberg, where he was professor of history during the last years of his life. The chief address at Bamberg was delivered by Prof. Kuno Meyer of Liv- erpool, one of the most eminent of living Celtic scholars and the organizer of the School of Irish learning at Dublin. Professor Meyer also officially represented the Royal Irish Academy, and the Gaelic League, the great popular organization for the of the Irish language, sent a delegate who made an oration in Irish. M. Henri Gaidoz, wishing to offer a tribute on behalf of French scholarship, has reprinted and expanded an admirable account of the life and work of Zeuss which he published new revival originally in the Revue Celtique, in 1885 His brochure (privately printed, Paris, 1906), contains also a reproduction of a portrait of Zeuss now in the possession of the Bavarian Academy of Sciences Zeuss received scanty recognition dur- ing his lifetime. He passed most of his days as a secondary school-teacher and obtained a university chair, after repeated denials of his application, only to be quick- ly compelled to relinquish it because of ill health. Now that the branch of science in which he was an isolated pioneer numbers adherents in many universities of the old world and the new, it is a satisfaction some suitable paid to his memory. There were Celticists, perhaps, before Zeuss, but hardly Celtic philologists When the history of Celtic studies is writ- will be given to the work of such native antiquaries as Edward Lhuyd the eighteenth century O'Donovan and O’Curry in the early nine- teenth. But the debt of Celtic its to see tribute ten, due recognition in and supreme philology to the labor of Zeuss will always The Nation. be acknowledged It } ! playfully but appropriately Whitley Stokes in the quot Zevs apyn Zeds meoga, Ards éa TWarta rérvaer and seldom has a branct f learning owed more to one man H ly work Die Deutschen und Ihre Nachba mme'' (which he was compelled put h at his own exper ’ marked a ! ! v “ on of Germa ‘ eth ey ind -h chief produ: Gramma " Celtica (1853), laid } f latio and raised much of the | ma | i of scientifi { gramma lu ng the fifty-three y hat have elapsed since the publication of Z« gramma N small but ardent group of specialists have added vastly to the ma ils availabl for the study of the Cs language and literatures, and they have made many co rections in Zeuss’'s esul Bu hey all gladly acknowledge the ! lepende on his initial labor which him an t questioned place among t} vy few § " masters of modern philolog A curious intellectual phenomenotr is the growing influence of John H New man in France It exist in a well-d fined movement of ertain mind toward Catholicism; in what may prove an answet ing movement among younger Catholl with whom for the present it i in aid to their own belief; and, range to say, im the general settling of ideas among others, quiteapart from religion. The purely theological case of Abbé Loisy and hi sympathizers is less known in France than in England and America, except, perhaps among the clergy. But Brunetiére has long been insisting on Newman's place in evo lutionary philosophy; and Paul Bourget, when he first turned to his present sobri- ety of thought, published a striking study of the personality of the author of the ‘Apologia.’ Bourget now writes a sig nificant preface to a fairly complete book on Newman, as he interests Frenchmen, by Georges Grappe. He draws attention to the coincidence, within a few weeks, of Newman's entrance into and Renan’s exit from the Roman Catholic Church, and the consequences in the intellectual life of each The historical relations of New man’s life are gone into very thoroughly by that grave and highly respectable, if not sparkling writer, M. Thureau-Dangin, who is also a member of the French Academy, in his ‘“‘Renaissance du Catho- licisme en Angleterre.”” Raoul Gout has studied Newman in the form of a bulky university thesis for the doctorate at the faculty of Protestant theology in Montau- ban Lucie Félix-Faure (Madame Goyau) daughter of the late President, has made him the subject of one of her really super- ior popularizing volumes; and Ernest Dim net is le premier des newmaniens de France Abbé Henri Brémond, now the most prom- ising French clerical writer, who, as an exiled Jesuit, gained experience in English colleges, publishes Newman—Essai de Biographie Psychologique And a mem ber of the Pasteur Inatitut, professing at the Sorbonne acknowledges reading the essay on Development for its suggeative- ness One of the centenaries passed over this winter with little noise was the two hun- dredth anniversary of the death of John | Evelyn \ ! ! cca Hi } Wheatley ed Diary and ¢ responden ind t? ‘ i f volumes, has now ! ht regular impo ( s Evely Diary ‘ | ! 1818, Will Bra e th to houg! t? ‘ f ind tra ! re ‘ t VW l ‘ t The ed ‘ Bray ap x f be i many ‘ will ? f ! pages which in the opinion of 1 injudiciou critics may appe portant to meet the public eye That wa in the days when the pub! ! respect In 1879, H. B. Whea y | the work, but, with the excey fa life of Evelyn and a full bibliogray fl work could only prod I la incomplete text \ appeal to M WW Evelyn, the owner of the Evely: 7 for access to he original MS I 4 i ] Tha ‘ i { burt third edition of the D was ve co! tly p ed from tl MS ! iy t elie ! A i x . ‘ aie tex Che I ‘ edi " ’ I nt of ha f ik with, however, a number of freat lustra o! which add « ! ibly to val Mr. Wheatley, to whom we ows } m expanded Pepy how yime ligna the reserve of the present NI f Evelyn MS It is the natural feeling an editor and the public will probably agree with him But it quite po ble that Mr Evelyn is justified his ac I case of th ' 11 be le led a general rule, but on its particular merits Undoubtedly the character of Pey a fair ly solid man in hi lay, ha iffered a ¢ tain distortion from the publication of ree ords never meant to be seen any m than our own private thought ire meant to t heard Would th printing of Evelyt Diary’ in full take off somewhat from tl ober and dignified image of him we posse s? To his contemporart« is to ou selves, he was the typical English gentlh man of high character and broad culturs his representative to-day might well think twice before doing wrong to such a reputa tion by giving a false emphasis to his minor incongruitle We know what Pepys thought of his fellow diarist He read to me very much also of hi discourse, he hath been many years and now is about, about Guardenage; which wiit be a most noble and pleasant piece He read me a play or two of his making, very good, but not as he conceits them, I think to be In fine, a most excellent per son he is, and must be allowed a little for a little conceitedness; but he may well be o, being a man s0 much above others Johnson may wear his mole in Sir Joshua picture without detriment, but how might this “conceitedness’’ be thrown out of trus proportion by the betrayal of a man's un guarded words All this is, of course, mere conjecture on our part At least we may welcome an old favorite in its new dres although we might wish that the volumes were a trifle less bulky—and expensive (the price is $12) Beverley Warner's Famous Introduc tions to Shakespeare's Plays by Notabl Editors of the Eighteenth Century (Dodd lead & Co.) might well have been in
Page 16
184. pired by Prof. Nichol Smith's re tion of the eighteenth century critics of the Morgann’s admirable ent col nearly identical are i} ore 50 mtents of the two on Falstaff, which is the chief attrac- pape mm of the latter, is absent from the for- mer, as it does not fall exactly within the bounds of the title; and its place is sup- plied by one or two of the prefaces proper omitted by Professor Smith. Like the ear- lier editor, too, Dr. Warner has opened his volume with an introductory survey or estimate of the material Under the cir- tances it seems a little odd that he should not have referred to his predecessor who has ina i preémpted the ground and whom he ought, at least, to have known of But the matter, as far as it is of any quence at all, is one of literary cour- tesy rather than of literary ethics. At all events, with these points the resemblance Prof. Smith's book, though by no foreign publica- means inacce ble is a ind it is no doubt very proper that the home market should be supplied with native products And besides there is one ght advantage which this new compila- posse though purchased at a con- ible sacrifice As it contains nothing I editor prefaces and contains virtual- y all of these, it gives the historical stu- f literature an excellent opportunity tl gradual evolution of Shaks- cholarship throughout the period, ime time that by omitting two of | general essays of the time—Mor- already mentioned, and Farmer's Learning of Shakspere’’—it fails give a fair idea of the criticism of the , ntury As for Shaksperian schol- Lip, however, it is easy to trace a grad- il narrowing of its interests from large eneral que The Nation. vival. For the critical interpretation of the | documents, however, and for mythological in Mr. Squire should be followed with caution. His specific errors are perhaps not numerous, though the de- rivation of “‘druid’” from the same root as the Greek dpis may be cited as an ex- ample of an opinion now generally aban- doned. His fault lies rather in the failure particularly misleading to the uninform- d reader with sufficient clearness between fact and theory. We are not how far he is himself aware of existing difference of opinion, but he ap- to have relied too fully on the ut- of or two scholars, and not to have read widely outside of them. He to be sure, upon a scholar f undoubted authority, Professor Rhys of Oxford, the doctrine he derives from has become a kind of current ortho- Nevertheless it should be more guardedly stated Professor Rhys would be the first to admit the large conjectural element in his theories, both ethno- logical and mythological. Yet from reading Mr chapters on the Welsh and Irish divinities one would hardly suspect that the whole theory of a Celtic pantheon had in recent years questioned by some of the best Continental scholars. While we agree in this matter rather with theory general, to distinguish sure pears terances one lraws chiefly, and him doxy own Squire's been Professor Rhys than with his critics, we think that their case should be stated, or | at least their exceptions filed, even in a popular handbook of Celtic mythology. tions of literature and life | James Hain Friswell, the essayist, critic, | and novelist, was a familiar figure in the literary society of London thirty years ago His most popular work, “The Gen- tle Life,”’ a series of essays, “scold like a | spelling-book for over thirty years” (to quote Besant). This minor classic was a favorite with the Queen, who wrote to Friswell that she wished his esgays could be engraved “in letters of gold.”” it | brought a fortune to his publishers, and to | searcity that exclusive preoccupation with ety- mological and textual concerns which was illy to mark the editorship of the nine- th century. The tendency is unnoticed ! e general editor; but he points out ly enough the chief merits of the eral prefaces, to which he has prefixed ise a brief life of the author ) ! hole, the make-up of the book leay omething to be desired. The mat- ter not very clearly distinguished for eference; the head-lines in particu no clue to the separate pieces ‘ quire’s “Mythology of the Brit bh J n (Blackie & Son) is frankly popular and unoriginal, written not for the Cel holar, but for the general reader, pply him, in the words of the preface, th “a kind of handbook to a subject of j ving importance—the so-called ‘Celtic | let ince.” "’ It alma, in short, to im- { “ ich knowledge of Celtic my- is most persons of cultivation are pI 1! to possess of the mythology of Cire ind Rome, and so far as the sub- ince of the ancient tales is concerned it accomplishes this purpose satisfactorily rm materials are well compiled, and the ri of goda and heroe are attractive ly told, often with close adherence to the Welsh and Irish narrative The boox vill give a reader who is unacquainted | literature a good impression of ye of its most characteristic fea- tures, and it ought to prove a sufficient guide to the mythological allusions in the writers of the recent re- Anglo-Celtiec the author less than one hundred pounds “The Gentle Life” turn long since, has been superseded by other tonic works of the same type. Miss Fris- her father knew everyone and everywhere, that the remi- she now publishes, “In the Six- (Herbert B. Turner fail be read- the fastidious may find autobiography, and nothing the famous men and reviewed. In the present personal about Mr. the description of a tea party (at the age of served its and and out well went so niscences and Seventies” & Co.) able ties could hardly to though too much strikingly new about who are of Swinburne, women gossip to which he was entrapped twenty-nine) and certain other rather meagre anecdotes related by Miss Friswell will be welcome to many. The Friswells were intimate friends of Sir Richard and Lady Burton The latter could talk of nothing but “dear Richard and the Gov- and the of her hus- band’s private life, in spite of his “polyga- When Stanley was about I Found Livingstone” his Friswell to re- ernment” strictness mous opinions.” to publish “How publishers sent the MS. to vise. It was ungrammatical and ill-spelt, and Friswell handed it over Jo his daugh- ter, who spent weeks in getting it into shape. All the proofs passed through her hands, and when the book came out “the critics were somewhat surprised at the [Vol. 83, No. 2148 clear, concise style in which it was writ- ten.” Miss Friswell, however, never met Stanley, and he did not know, or at any rate never recognized her share in his book, though his publishers paid her a hun- dred pounds. In her reminiscences one meets all the famous actors, writers, and artists who figure in the memoirs of that pe- riod, and some of the anecdotes which be- gin to show signs of wear. The contents are not quite worthy of the excellent pa- per and print of this handsome volume. They would have been more in place in a magazine. This is mainly because there is nothing whatever of political interest, and it is usually their politics that make Eng- lish memoirs worth reading. The Monnaie Theatre of Brussels has chosen two novelties for its next opera sea- son: “Salome,”’ by R. Strauss, and “Queen Vahsté,”" by Emile Matieu. The Italian librettist Illica and the com- poser Louis Lombard, formerly of this country, have finished an opera which is to be produced next season. The Société Musicale in Paris offers a series of prizes. The composer of the best opera will receive $6,000; for a comic opera $2,400 is offered; for a ballet $1,600; for a trio for piano, violin, and ‘cello, $600; and for a sonata for piano and violin $400. During his long life of 101 years Manuel Garcia many pupils who now reside in America. A memoir of the great teacher is being prepared by Mr. Sterling Mackinlay of London, who was for years a pupil of Garcia and who will be grateful for any information likely to be useful. instructed At the Leipzig Opera, during the past sea- eighty-two different operettas and operas were heard. The great German composers were represented by sixty-five performances, of which Wagner had forty- Weber ten, Mozart eight, Beethoven three. First performances were given of “Salome, “Feanto Solo,” ‘Werther,” “Enoch Arden,” “‘Die Neugierigen Frauen.” son, four, Strauss’s opera “Salome” had twenty per- formances in Dresden during the past sea- son. Mozart's operas were heard twenty- four times, and Wagner is, as usual, far in the lead, with fifty-seven representations. Here, as in other German cities, the doors of the opera house would have to be closed but for the operas of Wagner, of which Mapleson used to say that they “spell ruin.” There still exist antique individuals who hold that the greatest opera composers of Italy and Germany did not know how to write for the voice. Giovanni Sbriglia, the singing teacher, is one of these. He is quoted in the /tude as saying that “with the advent of the music of Verdi and Wag- ner it was no longer necessary to sing, and the artists simply had to declaim over the accompaniment of a large orchestra, so that the beautiful nuances of singing, which were its chief beauty, were impossible for the singer.”’ It has often been noted that Wagner ap- parently got the anvil motive in the “Ring” from the scherzo of Schubert’s D minor quartet. In volume vy. of his “Life of Wag- ner,’ Mr. Ashton Ellis points out that Wagner was studying this quartet in con- nection with a performance of it at Zurich, at the time when he was leading his Wotan
Page 17
August 30, 1906] down to Niebelheim. He also points out a resemblance between Mime’s_ so-called “cringing” motive and another passage in the same quartet, which is very likely to be similarly accounted for. A Viennese journalist, who visited the Johanneum museum in Graz the other day, came across an album which belonged to Anselm Hiittenbrenner. In this there was a lock of Beethoven's hair, and, in Schu- | bert’s handwriting, and signed by him, a | sentence from Cicero’s. oration, Rabirio”’: “Exiguum nobis vite curriculum natura circumscripsit, immensum gloria” (Small is the space which nature has measured off for our life, but great the field of fame). At the time when Schubert wrote this he was helping his father teach school. French critics are anything but pleased with the manner in which singing is taught at the Paris Conservatoire They accuse the professors of teaching so stilted and un- natural a method that after a year no one but their instructors cares to hear them. In “Pro | Germany, too, things have come to a sorry | pass, according to Lilli Lehmann. The singers, after two years of study, expect to reap a rich harvest, the result being that, after singing a few big réles, in which they have screamed themselves hoarse, they must resort to fresh-air sanatoriums throat specialists. and The lion of the past musical season in London was Edvard Grieg, and efforts are being made to have him repeat his visit in the autumn. On his return from London to Copenhagen he was interviewed by a repre- sentative of the Vort Land, to whom he ex- pressed his regret that in the last few years he had been unable to compose, especially in the larger forms. Ill-health alone had prevented him from completing a quartet and a trio. habit is to finish it at once, and to pro- tect him from the strain which this implies, his medical advisers insisted on his aban- doning composition entirely. A well-known painting by Raphael- “Madonna of the Tower’’—has been pre- sented to the National Gallery, London, by Miss Mackintosh. Since 1856 the picture has been in the possession of the Mackin- tosh family, having been bought by Mr. R. J. Mackintosh for 480 guineas from the collection of the poet Rogers, who looked upon it as one of his chief treasures. Although the paint- ing had previously formed part. of the Or- leans collection, it has always been best known as the Rogers Madonna. Crowe & Cavaleaselle write of it: “To the Rog- ers ‘Madonna’ we turn as to a lost ex- ample of the master. ... Our memory still clings to this masterpiece as embody- ing the feelings and tenderness of the Flor- entine period manifested in the del Gran Duca,’ and the ‘Virgin of Casa Tempi,’ combined with the dignity and elevation that characterize the later ‘Ma donna del Pesce.’” This “lost example” at Once started on a work, Grieg's the The Nation.
result that the outli: have lost their sharpness and the deta are blurred. As to whether the | wa riginally painted on wood or < invas, there is a difference of opinior I Orleans gallery catalogue describes it a t sur rile while Crowe and Cava elle believe that t was originally paint wood and af terwards transferred t invas But as marks of the canva , early v b! through the paint it would seem as if the Orleans opinion were the co t one Cri tics have also differed wit! egard to th superb cartoon of | | ire, purchased | a few years ago by tl 13 h Museum; the majority think it to | ‘ ! al work of Raphael, Mr. Bere anding almost alone in holding the PI opinion ri XT EOOKS Mr. R. L. A. Du Pon he editor of Cwsar’s “Commentari he series of Oxford Classics, has p 1 for use in chool “Selections f 1 Plut h Life of Cmsar (Oxford Clarendon Pre ) This attractively printed edition is intend- ed for beginners in Greek who are reading the same time Cwsar'’s “Gallic War” and Shakspere’s play. It impresses us as some what too dificult for fir year work in Greek, but might well be used in the sec ond year, as a substitute for part of the Anabasis.’"” We sometimes wonder at edu cators who regard the “Gallic War’ as a dull book; properly presented, with Plu tarch and Shakspere to follow, it ought to mark an epoch in the schoolboy’s career The Clarendon Press issues also an anony mous edition of Plutarch’s “Coriolanus,” with fairly elaborate notes and a brief and sensible introduction The book might find a place somewhere in the college cur- riculum, and has independent value, be- sides, since annotated editions of Plutarch, compared with translations of his “Lives,” are rare Of importance for both the classical stu- dent and the student of Shakspere is an edition of Plutarch’s “Liv of Coriolanus, Cesar, Brutus, and Antonius,” in the translation of Sir Thomas North, by R. H Carr This work, too, comes from the Clarendon Press, printed on poorer paper than we should expect. The volume is de-
‘Madonna | lost to the public since 1857—has now come | into the possession of the country through | the gererosity of Miss Mackintosh It is |} Company) an example, however, that will appeal more to artists and critics than to the general public, on account of its injured condition It had the misfortune to fall into the hands of an ignorant restorer, a long time ago, and was clumsily over-cleaned, with the | signed as an introduction to the complete ‘Lives’ of Plutarch in North's version, which will present for the first time the text of North accompanied by appropriate citation of Shakspere. The editor conve- niently divides Shakspere borrowings in- to two classes, giving m< references to passages which coincide with North in sub- ject matter, but quoting fully those in which his actual language is reproduced An introduction discusses the translations of North and Amyot and the plays of Shak the in the present most intimately related to of Plutarch included spere Lives” volume In the Gildersleeve-Lodge Latin Series, J. E cently Barss's “Beginning Latin” has re- appeared (University Mr. Barss the ini- tial problem in the teaching of elementary Latin together case would solve by building paradigm presenting forms of several declensions, tenses of all the conjugations, and 80 We with him in this programme, nor in the attempt to present on do not sympathize Publishing | bridge the gap betw he first-year book ind Cwsar by ery p tt atter 1 A iplified, that 1, form. The t 6 h s good fea ! v ir ding well-cl wid ing of ibte i t x | Beg ‘ B h h g : marily ind 4 | f Ca ho i he ' ‘ ips I I The lat t f G ek x I v ol of | It American I k « irly and a r t al t Sper he f I | Adams, the otl f 7 I and Ill., by Prof. W A. I ! first of these a wel " t t Profe or Morga ex r | 1 which | " rr? Ww T ‘ lud ne hy ‘ \ ’ ’ I for tl f ‘ f ef tiv l \ | t highest utteran ull 7T ! I t le Funeral Or A the e seri ) ' ‘ po j l ( (j Yed to accompany tl ! f X Anaba At ! ! t , hicl , ; put he I t I WW by Clara B ra VW i t? 1 ot) ! 1 cor ) 1 a to ! the method of |} ‘ { text al lto ‘ i +? ’ ) ’ » mor ndepetr \“ | ! Book Company ha aa 7 ! ) Morris and Morgan Latin two eda! tions which make a feature of ‘ i" by selections an idea of the wl t t of an author work or work which are too long for a ingle volume Wi not In sympathy with such a programme, we must acknowledge that kranting it ‘ it is skilfully carried out in tl two bool before us Selection from Liv t Prof. H. E. Burton, and—an admirab ed tion—"Cwsar, Episodes from the Gall and the Civil Ware by Dr. M. W. Mathe A pathetic interest attaches to the most in the Cornell Studies in Philology No Yui/ (Macmil entitled “Erichthonius by died a recent publication Classical and the lan)—a volume the Three late Benjamin few days which he of Ph.D dis iginal of Cec rops, Mr. Powell commencement the University, Daughters Powell the have before at would received degree this not brilliant- written in an from Cornell ana sertation Though is his ly o1 in treatment, and often characteristic of the ue The author considers the source of the both inter ungainly style too doctors’ dissertations, work has a val legends of Erichthonius in literatur and art, reviewing the pretation f various modern scholars, and retelling the history of the legends on the basis of the available evidence In an appendix, he prints in ertenso the passages cited from ancient authors, and adds a dozen plates illustrating the appearance of the legends in art. He acknowledges special indebted ness to the researches of Miss Harr and differs from her chiefly in a some Oriental influence on the legend of Erichthonius at an early stage of it tory, and in regarding the symbo f
Page 18
For evi- book ever written oa § The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2148 he nake as primarily sexual hiller’s most fa- the former point, undue attention |} mous poem i8 a series of justrations, the paid to 1s dangerous guide Robert largest collection heretofore given in one row Semitic Influence on Greek My volume logy Several errors in detail call for An acceptable edition of Ernst von Wil- ent One of the authors used as a| denbruch’s “Das edle Blut has just been | iry source (p. 6) is “Eudocia, the By- published. by Holt—the first American edi- , ew ‘ in h Violarium where- | tion of the little classic which has passed has been known for several decades | its sixty thousand copies in Germany. hat the work in question is a compila There are notes, vocabulary and prose ex- f the xteenth century Reference ,; ercises by Ashley K. Hardy of Dartmouth, re n (p ) to the Narrationes Fabu- | and a portrait of the flery dramatist. ! im of Lactantiu Placidus the | Another writer all too little known in our hol who accused of “mixing na | curricula is Gustav Frenssen, who finds ative ind “either writing from memory representation at last in Gravelotte” from a distorted version of the original (chapter xiv. of “Jérn Uhl’’), at the hands ry Bu iny hi ) of Roman litera- | of Prof. Otto Heller of Washington Univer- e contain the formation that Lac ity (Ginn & Co.) ius Placidu in anonymous prose \us dem Leben eines Taugenichts,”’ the pitome of Ovid Metamorphoses These | most popular of Freiherr von Eichendorff's wot serio ‘ ) it happens, but we writings, is such delightful autobiography ould ne 7 her ' loctot di in the lyrical-prose vein, without really re- tation flecting Eichendorff’s ideal of life, that Prompted by Prof. Calvin Thoma Dr ill another edition by Dr. George M. Howe Annina Periam has prepared “Hebbel's Ni- | of Cornell will be welcomed. (Henry Holt belungen: Its Sources Method, and Style’ | & Co.) (The Macmillan Co.) Only recently has A new contribution to class-room litera- Hebbel had admirers and apy itive eri ture, designed to promote conversation and } Nibelungen” being one of the few | &@ knowledge of German life, is Thiergen’s ma we ons of the wa which has Am deutschen Herde edited by Prof. S. nd favor on the stage Dr. Periam tells | W. Cutting of Chicago (Ginn & Co.). The ve Hebbel onception of his 1uthors are Dresdeners An imaginary am problem, the legendary sources journey is taken, beginning at New York; Hebbel’s relation to Raupach, Fouqué, Gei Berlin, Dresden, and other cities are vis- bel. Wagnet and Vischer. his inventions ited; the theatre and opera are seen and eatment of woman and religion. and the the tourists pass through all sorts of ex- ;, if the mythical and mystical in | perience even enjoying a Bierkneipe and A bibliography concludes the ng a duel! me Silver, Burdett & Co. will publish ina few | lo established reputation of D. C lays Through France and the French 7 h & o. for modern language text Syntax,’’ a composition book on original , vell sustained in their “Deutsches | lines by Prof. Robert L. Sanderson of Yale, buch the be collection of German ind \ Scientific French Reader,” by Prof with mu ever issued in America Harold Francis Dike of the Massachusetts editors are Prof. A. R. Hohlfeld and a | Institute of Technology of the Germanic Society of the \mong the new French texts of the sea- I of Wisconsit rhe songs are on, issued by D. C. Heath & Co., are a ged for irio vo ind there are | well-annotated edition of Labiche’s ‘‘La i ory 1 in German and a bio Grammaire’ from the pen of Prof. Moritz } il le I'he ime firm has lately Levi of Michigan: La Bruyére’s “‘Les Car- , Deutsche Reds including ictéres” from Prof. F. M. Warren of Yale, , by RBismarcl isillow Moltke ind Taine’s “L’Ancien Régime,’ from Prof nd Emperor William II, edited by W. F. Giese of Wisconsin. There is also a tolf Tombo ind | or | euriou Methods Rénin’ or first-year rT " f Columbia French in French, dedicated to Ambassa- j = one of the m enthusiasti dor Jule Jusserand | f Hein America to-day i rhe latest French text from Henry Holt i ies of the University of & Co. is an edition of Moliére’s ‘“Tartuffe Ml ' | is been known to be at ou l'Imposteur Dr. John E. Matzke of | he Poom rhe volume Iie Leland Stanford Jr. University, the editor, bef (Ginn & ¢ », beautiful in fresh upplies a good introduction on the origin, ; ' T mn autograph pirit, history, and sources of the play, r i long biographical besides discussing the characters in de- } He with especial reference tail \ bibliography adds to the work ! ’ n Da in analysis of his La Fontaine’s fables, scattered here and hara ind attitude toward religion, and | there in French readers, have always prov- ad ! lation to Romanticism en so readable that Prof. O. B. Super of iW { ' » musl also made | Dickinson College has been wise in editing ! he n extensive bibliog One Hundred Fables” by the same author iph (Portrait Ginn & Co.) \ " ! | illy for library re Those who have sought to acquire an ac- i ' i hill mg of the Bell quaintance at first hand with the ancient translated met all ind accompanied bY | lyrie of Southern France will admit that i histor il introdu on, a commentary they have encountered peculiar obstacles n other translations and a complete bibli in the complex phonological and ograph by Dr. J. Perry Worden, profe morphological conditions of the lan- modern tla " Kalamazoo | guage To remove these obstacles Colles " | » ¢ nan He by bringing order out of a bewildering ! I ga ‘ lel renee x of irray of linguistic facts was the task which he original, the special m of this first Professor Grandgent set himself, and it Is simple justice to say that he has achieved it his admirably and lucid grammar, “An Outline Phonology and Morphology of Old iD. Cc Heath & Co.). Being a competent phoneti- in the domain of Romance ogy, he has been able to explain satisfac- torily, in the of the course of sound change in the development from the Latin word to the form assumed in the of dialects which the poetry of the Troubadours is preserved to us. In this respect, no less than in his full and luminous statement of the mor- phology of the language, his book marks a decided advance upon the works of Suchler and others. “The Verse,” compact of the Provencal” in cian philol- vast majority cases, conglomerate in Italian Ford, the Chivalry in by Prof. J. D. M anu Miss M. A. Ford, of specimens of the English The with such excellent Romances of compiled of Harvard, best is volume liaiian Ss ‘leclions judg- (1) the epics for readers been made ment that development of the romantic epie as “% lit- genre; (2) the growin of Orlan- do story; (3) the characteristic qualities of Pulci, Boiardo, Berni, Ariosto, and Tasso. There are also fragments of the early “Or- and of the “Libro Volgar Our of 500 pages of text 225 pages are de the “Orlando not dis proportionate share, have by them one can trace erary the , ” lando’ about Furioso,”’ of preéminence as a poet and of the superior of his The stalian as a voted to a in view Ariosto’s interest importance of the product, has never epic itself, been sufficiently epic high literary recog- Per- well, nized by English-speaking students haps Professor Ford would have done call to its serviceableness as a but in his introduction, to more attention only Pul- i a vehicle not for instance, varied narrative, satire ci’s “‘“Morgante,”’ powerful satire on the Roman Church, al- though Pulci, like Rabelais generation later, compounded his sarcasm with a far- for for ‘Yves as 8s a rago of other material. Copious notes and a bibliography add to the usefulness of th's well-conceived compilation. (Holt & Co.) “Comedia Famosa del Esclavo del De- monia compvesta por el doctor Mira de Mesqua,” edited with an Introduction and Notes, by M. A. Buchanan, Baltimore. This is a welcome edition of a work by Mira de Amescua, a Spanish playwright of the midpoint of the siglo de oro, whose excel- lence has only in proper recognition from the historians of literature. In his text Mr. Buchanan fol- lows an edition of Barcelona, 1612 (probably the first of which unique copy is preserved in the National Library at Madrid; he has, however, adopted emen- His introduc- recent times received not edition), a dations from later editions tion discusses the affiliations of the various editions now discoverable, and examines the hagiology and the different sources of the subject matter of the drama. Because of connection with the Theo- philus, the St. Cyprian, the Faust, and oth- er legends of compacts with the Devil, the Spanish piece merits the attention of the student of the comparative history of lit- legendary its erature, On the of his own critical edition of Berceo’s “Santo Domingo,” already pub- lished in the series of the “Bibliothéque de I'Beole des Hautes Etudes” Dr J. D. Fitz-Gerald now makes a study of the basis at Paris, underlying principles of the verse struc-
Page 19
August 30, 1906] via, an early of the France (“Ver- found de Press) ture known the cuaderna Spanish arrangement in quatrains Alexandrine borrowed from of ‘Vida The ise Cuaderna via in de Columbia sification he as Berceo’s Santo Domingo Si- los.’ ”’ University His cal Baist ettled on several metri- efforts of not been he of high- treat throws light problems which, despite the Hanssen, have The possibilities ind hitherto f the Cornu account which gives o in the way synalepha, dialysis, and is Synizesis ly commendable, and his recapitulation of regarding the accent and of the agitated the discussion svilabie ter but Pietsch study The tales value diphthong ie—a mat Zauner in and the lately by valuable to all engaged 1s of Old Spanish of “Seven of (or the Ar- the thir- the framework form the Spanish known as Sages”’ s a translation from the of direction of Don Fad King Alfonso el Sabio of the oldest highly “Sindibad’’) i abic teenth ce made about middle ntury by rique, brother of monu de therefore one Spanish prose, and ing of a good critical edition folklorist, Comparetti little ry of the Sindibad the Appendix Libro di Sindibad.” ed by Folk in Unfor- MS imperfectly no attention to legend, pub- to his al ‘ pi sondon the Ricerche intorn His editis lore Society the Comparetti h this odu the 138382 tunately copy of Pufionrostro which used was many blem Bonilla which nt \ edition made, and Ss text prese s ishes. On account y San Martin new is on the MS XIV of Hispanica”’ now offers a t! and which Foulché- (‘Libro de has lirectly Volume “Bibliotheca los main ap Del- de las based ¢ pears as bosc’s los E Mugere Asayamientos Bonilla comparison and In the well ngaflos done the has with he has laps dl of and his task yet a which he Spanish e facsimile of folio 73 recto, prefaced to his text, shows that error of rks between to a common that the 2 of Old Spanish w ng to distinguish short cursive 8; desir, fisiestes, fiusa, a it no historical justification, and makes ete have facsimile all in at the MS mere glance such the single clear that the has in cases Not i title in- obvious why, S it allowed but a Old Happily asayamirntos 1s spelling ot the text tervocalic s, for the Spanish with errors was certainly the kind edition &S8 indicat are not numerous in In one or two places the a lack of sense, due to syn- the seems to show tactical irregularities; in absence of any remark by Bonilla it is to be presumed that the MS. is also at fault The intro duction contains the main facts relative to the sources and the diffusion of the story of the “Seven Sages.’’ The brief Glossary in spite of a few errors, will be found of material assistance The rarity of the chrestomathy of Old Portuguese published twenty-five years ago by Monaci and D’Ovidio has been a source of regret in institutions in which it has been possible to extend Romance studies as far as that language and literature Now the difficulty of obtaining a suitable man- ual has been removed by the publication of i selection of early te by Leite de Va favorably known to Romance phi folklorist concello ts and dialectologist, lologi as
The Nation. and as editor of th Revista Lusitana (“Textos archaicos para so da aula de philologia portuguesa’™’) The extracts here printed are intended ) llu ate the growth of the Portugu language from its origins down into th ute h n tury They begin with a few Latin deeds of gift and other legal a s in which stray words of the already emerging ver nacular show themselv: is early as the ninth century For the later periods the ditor has chosen lyri found the song books, such as the “Cancioneiro da Ajuda the Cancioneiro do Vat il and = the Cancioneiro Coloce Bra i sé atr f these poems have a idy been printed by Professor Lang of Ya l Lieder buch des Konig Denis ind in h Can ciol ro Gallego-Castelhano,”’ and of Lang*’s labors Leite de Vasconcellos makes suita ble use For the prose texts he has ha ecourse largely to important historical Ww h spec ially to those contained in th Portugalie Monument H ) " bu the Leal conselhe o of Dom Duarte ind the Demanda do Santo G | ilso epresented by brief passages The late extract in the book is from the Auto da Feira’ of Gil Vicente \ useful glossa of the more difficult archaic terms closes thi timely addition to the numbe of our Ro mance manuals THOMAS HODGSKIN THE PRECURSOR OF ANARCHISM Thomas Hodgskin (1787-1869) Par Elic Halévy Paris Société Nouvelle de Li brairie et d Edition Who wa Thomas Hodgsk Probably not one in a hundred of ou ade an answer this inquiry Even the omniscience of the “Dictionary of National Biography” fails to supp!y the information Thomas Hodgskin is, in truth, a writer who though he lived for some eighty wo yea ind during fifty labored fo he propaga tion of beliefs which since h time ha exercised marked influence Wil ten years before his death, forgo n by the men among whom he lived Neverthele he leserves the sort of literat revival which he has received at the hand of Halévy His claim to reputation consists in this: that his doctrines curiously link the teaching of Bentham with the beliefs of a school in many points opposed to Bentham ism, and that, though an author whos works were read by few, and a lecturer who arely obtained large audien he was in some sort the intellectual precursor of modern anarchism None but a too ardent adm will call Hodgskin in strictness original, but he po sessed that kind of second-hand originality if an expression bordering on a bull may be allowed—which a man may attain by fol lowing out his own thoughts, whatever their worth, without being overpowered by the authority of received teache Hodgskin was guided by two or three convictions which, to use an expression of his own might be described as ‘prejudices if that word be used without any bad connotation A letter to Francis Place, who encouraged the early teps of Hodgskin career and introduced him to the utilitarian sachool, ex plains the nature of the prejudices on which Hodgskin built up a system of social re
form The exis x < ‘ his eyes entia f ‘ ought to have t né | ? labor; b wl Hoods ill wealth wa working cla f ilmo wholly sts or the h wil or indire ly I I nature in tl 1 | lerstood and followed ‘ ! ‘ vinced, sufficient ce and the 4 rf were not only jua pa tially similar 0 he Hi f he Irew the ! ! » lin oppo 1 1 } ‘ ress and that ich progres 1} " moted only by the mo } { individual freed Now th ‘ 1 be i} to a ce i x ! Ww \ i bo m fundam illy Benthamism Hodgsh with ! ham held that th vd f rod ‘ ] ff il { j ] mon with the utilitaria f fully be ved that f i ! mo ! nay ia ‘ ld it be m ‘ ane expre » fr n ! h ry al subscrip ! ! ! faire One f) . that Hodgskin wa nothin t vidualist wl ‘ ! lua " i if Bentham \ i atte of fa I ou life he fell hea and \ most of the pract ul reform i i i utilitariar He wa favo raint placed o the powes fi G ment He wa h gd ‘ free ade He believed h compet on wa ! very } welfare He xp mes almo | t) ! vival of h | He with John Mill f rrably tempt to influer ) Governmental he bu rt Governmert ! i “ lea Zz Ww onal educat B } ference from I I wl ruled England from 1s Ise permanently be riled r ‘ period when no Be ha ‘ ! Hodgskin a t vrelig He } lw tjentham that the law of England ed reform But he did not, like Be Tr iim at ib iting good law f b law He idvocated measure tt ’ which laws themselves hould | ip For to Hodgskin it was not bad law l the existence of law, it wa bad £ romen but the existence of go hich caused all evils that torment mal nd Hence Hodgskin detested or pised the economical or ocial teache to whom Benthamit« paid the highe honor The doctrines of R ardo ar pecially his celebrated theory of nt we fallacies constructed in support of th ting state of society which reformer: to destroy Malthus taught not the . but the exact opposite of the truth. Fo increase of population was itself th a of ever increasing prosperity Malt moreover and thi to Hodgsh wa ufficient condemnation uleated the that natu herself had pla ia the development of human h App welfare. Hence Hodgskin, in common w
Page 20
188 [Vol. 83, No. 2148 The Nation. all the later assailants of Benthamism, | Hodgskin was an ineffective critic of the girl he has wronged, would certainly If we under- for example, W. R. Greg But beach to find his son and make him marry turned to the historical method and to the | Malthusianism because he assailed, not its | not have given up so tamely. ve study of society Nor can | possible weakness, but its certain strength. | stand the old salt (and it is entirely the iny one doubt that in his attempt to argue | He seems to have denied that increase | author’s fault if we do), bread and water from historical experience, and in the im- | of population could in itself be other than | or handcuffs wouldsurely have been the — portance he attached to the comparison of | a blessing, and absurdly enough thought he | ‘ain’s sallGest arguments. And again, Jane’s fferent social conditions, he did antici- | was confuting Malthus when he insisted up- | long self-sacrifice forher sister—a mischiev- to which the Benthamites were | on the way in which the pressure of pop- | US one as she finally sees—is indeterminate blind. He was in very truth | ulation might increase the inventiveness of | because it is — made qute clear how or of anarchism mankind. He in reality, though not in | fr she suffers in public opinion. The story it come to pass that such a | form, accused Malthus of overlooking the | £°¢S wider and deeper than any of its pre- forgotter ind that his life's | effect of that struggle for existence where- decessors; if with less perfection of con- 1 its mark? This inquiry ad- | of Malthus might in a certain sense be struction than the short stories, it is the distinct answer. Hodgskin was | called the discoverer. Hodgskin again — ripe of the novels. h more than ordinary talent, | anticipated some of the criticisms The King’s Revoke” combines — of rare tenacity of purpose, but he | which, whatever their worth, have been ee mest agreeable epee . — of lef for taking a grip upou his | Ricardo’s theory of rent. But he also ap- | © . a i : . . | shed, of historical episode and manners In th he was far inferior, | pears to have held that no inferences : . oe ace a theorist of original genius, | worthy of consideration could be drawn without affront to history; and, while not tham, but even to that singular | from the undoubted facts that the earth is cnieny 0 ec ee — os — lexterous wire-puller and ff limited size, and that the time would oe ot aged emp pe Se ae ‘ Frat Place The | come when, all the most fertile parts being m8 ort brates b Phe * _— bore ept w 1 real power, at | under cultivation, the unfertile remainder sdlidditaen tines Oa paheshudh tetnnt te Westminst Hodgskin had | would produce less and less in proportion pestis _ » age gars Aa , - aii of the rolling or guid to the labor expended upon it. When at sieges Racy ponds acc of ghbor Then, too last our prophet proclaimed that the way - conten caaiies ae bende wats fie ae =v ble for h teaching to deal with crime was to .establish per- the episode of Patrick Dillon’s expedition ind «61870 «neither English | fect individual freedom, and thus some- into France to rescue and restore Ferdi- English politicians felt any | how put an end to the production of crim- sand VIL, imprisoned in the country heme > the leas which underlie | inals, practical reformers felt that they ef Talleyrand by Napoleon while brother England. The world | must part company with a former ally Joseph Bonaparte rocked upon the Spanish i but a reformer, | who had himself bidden farewell to com- throne. The story opens heavily and the ; s retorm His | mon sense. reader expects a conventional and elabor- perfect! rand they wer ated work—like Bunthorne’s Jane, not h the middl lasses, and to | pretty, but massive. But as the plot thick- cae Wage-enrnes, poy | RECENT FICTION. ens the touch lightens. Patricio and his had, n ) thought out the atr tend uz. give themselves kin W n some spects a cap Smith. New York: Ch&rles Scribner's a fervor of loyalty like nothing so much as of utilitarianism. He percelv- oom. the Jacobite passion. The schemes and de- ince, in common with John Aus- | The King’s Revoke. By Margaret L. Woods. | vines ana allies of their invoking are im- the Benthamites attached too | New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. mensely entangling and for the most part rtance to mere changes in the | 4nthony Overman. By Miriam Michelson. | unhackneyed. If the narrative paragraphs nd he knew that social evils New York: Doubleday, Page & Co. move ponderously, honorable amends are Sues, OU Weu Get SO re Mr. Hopkinson Smith has a touch of his | made in the ingenious conversation. Bour- he transference of political au- | 1 telation to matters of the coast. | bon sensitiveness might be wounded by the mona © ae. SS There is a beauty of coloring in his beaches, | portrait of Ferdinand the Desired, and ob- ith In the benefit to be obtained | | aon and swirl in his waves, a rugged- | jectors to toying with history may raise the onas eae was Se See ness in his life-saving stations, a rough | eyebrow at the close-range picture of Tal- ind the prophet who attacked | | gorness in his sea folk that bear wit- | leyrand. But of such is the omelette 4 not likely to obt ey converts | ness to a sympathy made up equally of Vhistoire. leed, such as Carlyle, Who | | thetic perceptions and technical famil- | The community, the editorial office, la- le against individualism, | tertty In his new novel these well-known | bor, capital, the reformer, the journalist, carn t Hodgskin's con- | characteristies are fully evident, grouped | the “essentially feminine’ woman, the doc- lem changes would upon a background new in many ways. Old | tor, the striker, the scab—is there one ladies arising from @ Vicious | does he has given us in great variety of | word here to hold the tiniest promise of But teachers who desired pose and in many phases of trouble, yet | freshness? Yet this is the inventory of ) he were even MOre | here is another Capt. Holt—this time with | the chief contents of “Anthony Overman,” han were the utilita a wayward son—towering over the scene, | one of the most original of recent novels. | and in the end clearing the much-clouded | Other heroes have given themselves over had the times been more pro- | .;. phe vigorous group of life-savers, if | to altruism and to “idealistic schemes” ireer was from the | pamitiar down to their tarpaulins, find work | that promise “wholesale redemption from | to failure He thought | +, qo that is of a fresh interest. Though | earthly misery”; other heroines, God wot, but he thought wrong. He an there are a saintly girl and an executive | have sprained their ankles on mountain many of them false, which | qoctor as principals, and several neat land | roads; other journalists striven high and n England at the be portraits in miniature, yet the figures are | low for copy; other laborers struck. But lieth than they had | never quite so welcome as when salted. | there is a force in Miss Michelson’s book the nineteenth century This gives a thrill to the rescue by the | that sets it in a niche of its own. Its char- common with many rash ew; this its charm to the boys’ game of | acteristic is a determination to see things lu ed theorists, under @ fatal | pirates on the hull of the stranded sloop. | as they are. The point of view is saliently ; ! for actual facts, Or, | In such seenes Mr. Smith's touch is abso- | modern, not boastfully so; felt naturally, that element of common | |lytely firm and workmanlike. In the parts | not thrust out as a rock of offence. The it which even a revolutionary | that go to make a novel with a plot and a | hero is a renascent Daniel Deronda, with hardly, in England, at least, | problem there is less of conviction He | a modern as well as a racial difference: the tell upon the world. There scoms to have sent his story ashore with | heroine a “yellow woman journalist.” Such | objections to be brought | its sea legs on, to lurch about among the | elements must needs strike fire when they Malthusianism; they have been onventionalities of fiction. Capt. Holt, for | meet, and the story deals with their inter- rged by so orthodox an econo instance, who goes roaring down to the | action and final assimilation—say, rather reconciliation—since it is not easy to see
Page 21
August 30, 1906] more community of first, and specu- that there was any creed at the end than at lation wonders what came of it afterwards The way of the altruist is to talk pages about himself, and Anthony is no excep- tion; but he is a fine embodiment of the passion for doing good and of the suffering over others’ pain. A History of English Prosody. By George Saintsbury. Volume I., from the Origins to Spenser. New York: The Macmillan Co. $2.50. If the history of writings on English metrics, of English prosodism, so to ex- press it, could be set forth as a drama and the qualities of the writers presented as the persons of the play, this book would mark the appearance of a new character and the stage-direction would be: “Enter Commonsense.”” The development of the subject might be more continuous, the ar- rangement of the material might be im- proved, much parenthetic matter might be omitted, but altogether what strikes one is the sensibleness of the book as a whole. Not merely for enthusiasts on metrics, but for students of literature in general, it is a good augury toward the probable clear- ing up of this entire blurred and cloudy subject to find Omond’s mild fairness and Thomson's telling simplicity followed so soon by this all-pervading common sense. It not only reveals itself in such utter- ances as “Attention to prosody never bar- red or spoiled attention to poetry, except in those made unpoetical from the begin- ning’’; and “One has, while admitting the great stimulating effect of music, to hint or rehint a doubt whether, by itself, it can do much for prosody save suggest’’; and again, ‘““You may call a thing an octo- syllable or an iambic dimeter or a four- beat verse, but the thing is the same and unmistakable.’”’ Mr. Saintsbury leaves it for others to discuss the nature and the basis of English rhythms; he wastes no time in expounding how this and that come to be true, he assumes them true and proceeds. Yet, even in the act of ridding himself of those questions which he regards as “‘previous” to his investigation, he lets fall fruitful opinions, such as, “In English, accent is a cause of quantity, but not the only cause, and not a stable one.” Belief in “the humble virtue of sticking to the facts,” the conception that “the Rule comes from the Work, not the Work from the Rule,” make themselves felt throughout. By “English Prosody’” Mr. Saintsbury means that of English poetry since 1300. He makes plain his conception of its va- rious origins and of their several contri- butions to the total result. He says, “Some of the most serious errors which have ever crept into the discussion of English prosody have come from a too ob- stinate determination to serve that pro- sody heir, at all costs and at all points, to Anglo-Saxon”; and “The differences ov English verse of 1000 and English verse of 1300 are differences of nature and kind; the differences of English verse in 1300 and 1900 are mere differences of practice and accomplishment.” On these points he will leave extremists unconvinced, but will appeal to all open-minded readers. Entirely logical is his treatment of his The Nation. main task as historian. He is very likely wrong assuming less difference than phoneticians contend for between Chau eer’s pronunciation and Spenser's Spen- ser may not have the dominating import ance as a metrist which is attributed to him But without categorical proof Mr Saintsbury’s views on these and other points in the historic sequence of transi- tions are made to appear entirely reasona- ble A history of prosody should be viewed not only as a history but as a contribu- tion to the theory of metrics, and Mr Saintsbury’s contributions, with the reser- noted above, certainly very considerable. He sets down,in big and black print, definite statements of the main laws vations are of English versification as he conceives them It is not hedging when he gives the caution: “In order to appreciate the theory of Feet which governs this book it is necessary to recognize that the writer does not maintain that they were invari ably, or even for the most part, present as such to the mind of the poet They may have had a potential rather than an actual value: he may have scanned lines not as we scan them, yet in such a way as to justify our scansion."" This theory of feet he affirms most explicitly: thus (page 63) “The norm of the line is always a cer- tain number of feet,”’ and “Though the constitution or arrangement of these feet may be uniform, the greatest melody is reached by variation of them.’’ Nor is he absolutely consistent. He expressly states (pp. 48, 49) “English tetrasyllabic feet do not exist at all,”’ and again (page 400) re- affirms this. Some will consider too loose, others too strict, his views on monosyllabic feet in English, for while he admits their existence he limits their occurrence As to trisyllabic feet he has no doubts. He not only recognizes them as the base of a separate kind of rhythm, but affirms their general, ubiquitous and continual substitution for disyllabic fget in disyllabic rhythms. He anathematizes “the obstinate heresy, finally formulated as orthodoxy by Bysshe, that the syllabic composition of English lines is arithme tically positive and unalterable.” He makes this view the kernel of his whole work (pp. 63, 83); reinforces it in various ways, lauding “the blessed _ trisyllabix swing and swell, the variation and sway on the iambic tramp.” Specialists, editors of critical texts, and the covered original investigators in non-literary of the field by this vol- ume are likely to dismiss it as amateurish or detest Flouts and their open features them These nutty it as irritating kind invectives or sly sneers at broadcast make occur reading for any one whose ox is not gored, and where they hit they will smart most because none is without a modicum of truth and sense- as for instance: “Notions as to Middle English grammar, prosody and pronunciation, which have been excogi- tated by guesswork, or, if that seem too uncivil, by inferential hypothesis.” But, although this book is unlikely to carry with it the established cliques, it is certain to set them reflecting, while for students it will be invaluable. Anyone who has worked over the literature of critical comment on this period knows its lack. The dissertations, treatises, and monographs on Middle English, while painstaking and ac- | monand bis congeners as on pages 53 181; curate, weary the most fanatical devot of the subject and send forth no glint of a ray to allure outsider This vol may win even those totally ignorant of it to read the poetry of the time. Nowhere else can a student find such illuminating characteriza tion of the defects of the rhythming of Laya- 76, and llences of Chau 155, 167 199; nor of the versing of Lydgate, Occleve Hawes, and Barclay, pages 234-240, 382 and 419, of its differences (page 324) from that of Googe and hig kind on the one nor of the vital as exc cer's metrizing on pages and as on hand, or on the n tha of Wyatt and Surrey other (page 306) The most extraordinary thing about this volume is that, unintentionally as it would appear, the author has produced the one English book now existing which is likely to be of real use to those who wish to per fect themselves in the formal side of verse composition In the vague jargon or positive misinformation of most, if not all, of the manuals on metrics, strong contrast with a neophyte at versification will here find dropped by the wayside, definite precepts of genuine worth These occur too fre quently to quote, but we may point to this maxim: “It is a mistake to try to foot- correspond the word-di the divides the By no means extinct is the delusion that however valuable the early poetries may as sociological linguistic material, everything, Chaucer before Tot tel’s Miscellany is to-day negligible as lit- This by the will convince the most skeptical that, from its earliest examples, Old and Middle Eng- lish poetry is full of vital lessons for pres- ent and future verse-makers and poets But selves single make with best metre is often that which words most.” vision; be or exe epted, erature volume (quite way) them Saints or defects obtrude Yet Mr bury placards his determination (pp. 7-10) to miscomprehend Skeat's preface to Guest; on page 311, oddly calls Wyatt's Terza Rima “interlaced heroic couplets.”’ The proof-reading is not impeccable. The parenthesis on page 69 should end with “tydings”; false indentation of the lines mars the printing of the quoted stanza in the page 154 and of the first in the note on page 251. On page 262, “44” should be ‘4,4."". The index is not perfect For instance, seeks in vain for Ot- tava Rima, and for Riding Rhyme. few errors there are errors and, note on one Zarathushtra, the Achaemenids, and Israel By Lawrence Heyworth Mills, of Zend Philology in the University of Ox ford. Leipzig: F. A. Brockhaus The Professor between Zoroastrianism, the religion of ancient Persia, and that of interesting, not only to the stu Oriental literatures and religions, even greater Christian theologians. To an elucidation of this problem Prof. L. H. Mills of Oxford, an American by birth, offers an important con tribution in his present work, which is it self a continuation of his “Zoroaster, Philo, and Israel.” question the leading authority now living on the GAthas, the oldest hymns of the Iranian faith, Professor Mills devotes to the volume consideration a wealth of learning and thought. The first half of his book is given to study of connection Israel dent but 18 of in degree to ou volume Beyond under a careful
Page 22
tl Old P in inseription is compared nes of tl Bib me new t! proclamation of Cyru or the re ! ! Temp it Jerusalem Her th ial authent y of the ( I ! 1 tl harmony nserly of Da 1 who ! ligiou policy of his ! mn € i H then proceeds vw tl harmony between the Old Pet in (a ! ! implica I of Il Chron XXX Eezra | ind Isa. xl xiv.) and the ‘ He ; l Ww y | nt ou } lel d f the phraseology of the Old Pe ul t | to the Assyrian | yionian yyal who influence hie vile of tl A\chaemenian eems to ha been far z " han was that of the \ Neverthel Professor Mills’s he | ! mn the spiritual life \ ‘ " which ha o tar been ii po on 0 he moot probsem whe ! haemenian were Zoroastrians } he only one tenable with the ita | n know to scholars He 1 1 ultimate origin the three s which he call the Vedi the hu i ind ! Dari were de ve from a mmon Indo-Iranian source Chis | fectly true And then, with a , ‘ wl h leserves the highest " l | sincerely hope no | \ suppose that | am 1 Zz a tablishing anything like an i y yeen the two lores [the Old | in and the Avesta], even though I » ke en their divergence, and ly as | may leavor to explain them , hey approach ich other in their in elements and in their historical de ypmer { pon ahsolute identity we muat he a thought The second half of the volume is devoted tt \vesta and it influence on the Jews f tl boxile Here Profs or Mills wisely es the fa that the so-called Young- ‘ hough later n date of composi han the hymn of the Gathas, really e} " ule ence of the pre ( ! on of tran Hi provisional i howeve that the Younger! \ ia the main between 700 and ' eems open to question Even phasizing Iranian tradition ! ! t | in t extant documents, ind is] ously exact, and which | | r in the seventh century nece ivy to Ippose that i! vi niluenced by the Yashts It not improbable mu ha known the non-Zoroas hip f Iran before it had been | 11 he x it reformer Zoroaster I } more probable if the earliest ! ! Z0 ist il m wa at I ! m » have been the case; f ! ible lapse of time would Nation. The be ecessary fo the make itself felt in the western parts of Persia known to the father of history The final section, which is on the debt of Judaism to the Avesta, is developed almust too slightly Notwithstanding the writings of Stave Béklen, and Séderblom, and despite the antiquated treatise of Kohut ind the somewhat exaggerated conclusions of Cheyne, one cannot but wish that Pro- fessor Mills would complete his trilogy by devoting a separate volume to the debt of Judaism to the Avesta and to the debt of the Avesta to the Semitic world, espe- cially to Babylonia In a work so admirable it may seem un- gracious to call attention to faults of de- tail, yet it must be said that the English style of Professor Mills’s book is not easy reading Occasionally, also, there is a statement which is open to question. The name of the river Euphrates (Ufranu in Old Persian) is probably Sumerian and not Iranian in origin, and in spite of the auth- ol elaborate plea, it is hard to see that the phrase “God of heaven" in the decree ot Cyrus recorded in the Old Testament necessarily implies that the supreme dei- ty of the Achaemenians was Deva, “he of the shining (sky).”’ The Social Ideals of Lifred Tennyson By William Clark Gordon Chicago The University of Chicago Press. $1.50 \s a thesis for the doctorate this essay an instructive example of the bewilder- ing effect of a study of sociology. Of Dr. Gordon’s rather cloudy philosophy it is difficult to give a clear idea Perhaps it would be better to let the Doctor speak for himself The serviceableness of literature to so- ciology is almost wholly dependent upon the faithfulness of literature to the ar- tistic ideal in the portrayal of life. Mere description of physical conditions and statement of social facts have their value, but @t is the psychical elements for which the sociologist looks most eagerly and which he studies with greatest care He wishes to know of what people have been thinking; what ideas they have cherished for the home and for the Government; how they have regarded woman; what attitude they have taken toward those of different rank and social station; what desires have exercised a controlling influence in the live of men and women; how the emo- tional life has expressed itself—all these ind a hundred other things of kindred na- ture are of very great importance to the tudent of human associations This is the kind of thing that he expects f literature In other words, he looks upon literature as a storehouse of social fact— or, rather, as a reproduction of social con- ditions, a miliew or what not, which thw sociologist can study in default of the orig- inal But mark does not guarantee the accuracy of its facts indeed it is not a report at all, but rather the confusions Literature Fulton’s Rhetoric and Composition By EDWARD FULTON, Professor in the University of Illinois. 253 pp. 12mo. illustrations from good literature and practical exercises. sents the work done in rhetoric in the Freshman year at a large University. HENRY HOLT & COMPANY Ready Sept. 15. A compact statement of the essentials of rhetorical theory, with abundant The book repre- New York & Chicago [Vol. 83, No. 2148 reformed religion to | an interpretation; and that interpretation is individualistic, or in other words, is an attempt to choose and arrange facts in such to bring out their personal significance. Is it, then, the author's sub- his consciousness, which constitutes a manner as ject or the social data? But his consciousness is in a measure exceptional, as is also his writing; for you may say that after all it is only the permanent portion of his work, and that of particular social complexion, which is literature in any just sense. There Thackeray, for instance; does any one pretend to say that his conception of life of the social thought of his And it was only the.other day that a clever and undertook to that his novels were altogether one- sided and hence false as a sociological doc- ument, as no doubt they are, being satire no is is a pattern time? amusing critic show and not comptes rendus. Why, like the rectly should not the sociologist, himself, fall back di- indisputable facts, statis- will then, littéerateur the memoirs, soon be enough of them—and whatever oth- Here is the upon tics, correspondence—there sources are to be come at? el curious and original part of Dr. Gordon's notion. He seems to think that it re- quires the imagination and passion of lite- rary genius to animate such materials suf- ficiently to make their study a study of life of dead lumber. The point is well taken; there undoubtedly much made of literature as depository thought, Dr. Gordon has discovered What he fails to see is that such a study and not is to be a of as will be moral, not social; in short, it will not be sociology at all, but criticism. It is the vision of the author which is re- veuled primurily in his work. But if Dr. Gordon wishes to collect what shadows of social habits, manners, and the like are traceable through that medium, to disen- tangle the influences of his milieu upon the author and the author's reaction upon and to call the result sociology; there is no reason that he should not. Every man is bound thankful for information he get upon life literature. Only why so much pother is after all a very plain and obvious a mere cataloguing of Tennyson's utterances on such subjects as the family, the state, and the church, wo- society, serious to be all and the can about what exercise, man? BOOKS OF THR WEEK. Day, Holman F The Ss. Barnes & Co. Rainy Day Railroad War. 1. Lawrence Daniel The Asbestos Society of hogs Sinners Boston: Mayhew Publishing Co. $1. Mary Woilstonecraft’s Original Storfes. With five illustrations by William Blake. With an In troduction by BE. V. Lucas. Henry Frowde. Kimandthan, P. The Culture of the Soul Among Western Nations. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. Read, Opie “By the Eternal.’ Chicago: Laird & Le Taylor, Emerson Gifford. The Upper Hand. A. S. Barnes & Co. §1.50. Tuttle, The Right Rev. D. 8S. Reminiscences of a Missionary Bishop. Thomas Whittaker. $2 net. TH HOA EAEAS OF CLEVELAND, OHIO COMPANY are the leading booksellers in the United States along certain lines. They issue a Catalog of Rare Volumes monthly, and this, together with their List of Publications de- voted to American History, will be SENT FREE to any one making the request.
Page 23
The Naticn. August 30, 1906] THE CLARENDON PRESS The King’s English; the common errors into which writers are liable to oe A how such errors can be avoided. By H. W.F. & F. The Problem of Spelling Reform. /}y the Rev. lecture delivered before the British Academy May 2 “ Everyone interested in spelling reform should read this lecture.’ The Canadian War of 1812. by C. P. L The Great Revolt of 1381. M.A. By CHARLES Oman An Introduction to Logic. /}y II. WW. B. Josrru. 8vo, Lectures on the Method of Science. Edited by T. |. The Elements of Jurisprudence. iy |. 8vo, Cloth, $2.50. The First Year of Roman Law. P. SHERMAN, D.C.L. “ The object of this labor of love is to place in the hands of students. and of oth Roman Law, an English version of a French work, designed for use in the law schools of France that adapt it to become perhaps the best elementary treatise for comn the study of Re ‘rs who rencing lesire Prof. 1go6. Svo, cloth, with 2 STRONG. HOLLAND, By Frernanp Bernarp. - , fall, and Crown Svo, cloth, $+, W. SV oO, SKI paper covers 8vo, with 8 maps, ap , cloth, $3.15 Svo, cloth, KC, Fenth Edition. Translated by CHARLES in acquaintance, t which is remark man ‘ton From the Tre For Sale by all Booksellers Send for Catals Lue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, American Branch, 91-93 Fifth Avenue, New York. MUSHROOM MAGAZINES Abound in this country, Newsdealers’ counters groan under them, Some of them are insignificant, Others grow to prodigious size, and claim enormous circulations “ Thousands of American readers prefer to read magazines whose value has bees pr perience. © Nearly 3300 numbers of THE LIVING AGE is more nearly indispensable to intelligent of the leading English periodicals, from most interesting to American readers weighty articles in the quar ed by long ex have already been published, and to-day the magazine readers than ever. It finds its material in more than thirty which it reprints, without abridgment, such articles as are No human interest lies outside of its field. Its range extends from the terlies to the clever things in Punch. “ The magazine prints the best essays, the best fiction, the best verse; it presents fresh literary, social, and religious questions; and gives special attention to internationa rent events. Its weekly publication enables it to present the articles which it repr: prom ptness. The magazine prints annually twice as much material as the four-dollar monthly and the list of writers represented cannot be equalled by any other single magazine, English or American. The subscription price is SIX DOLLARS a year, postpaid in the United States, Canada, and Mexico. Trial subscriptions, Three Months (thirteen numbers) for ONE DOLLAR THE LIVING AGE CoO. 6 Beacon St., Boston. Send for Our Bargain List OF EDUCATIONAL WORKS For the Study of Foreign Languages. Offered at 40 to 60 per cent. below the regu lar selling price, which is marked in paren ' thesis. C, A. KOEHLER & CO. 149 A Tremont Street liscussions of iffairs and cur ices with great Naga zines 425 Titles. Any quantity supplied from one copy up, as long as the stock lasts. BOSTON MASS. ‘Music and MUSICIANS By EPWARD A. BAUGHN I2mo, $1.50 net Post 12 ' JOHN LANE ©O., The Bodley Head.¥5.Y. EVERY ONE SHOULD READ CONSUMPTION AND CIVILIZATION | By JOHN BESSNER HUBER, M.D. JUST PUBLISHED J, B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart ment for the handling of Library orders. l A tremendous ‘ (ireatly increased f portation of kinglis} Competent bookrne collect books All of this shipments and right THE BAKER & TAYLOR CO., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. means prompt price ENICMAS OF sda HICAL RESEARCH *k dealir ifically with Medium ete ‘Phenome “rhea, Apparitions Clairvoyance Telepathy, Dreams, ete, By Prof. Jawes Hysvor, author of “Science and a Futu Life.” Price $1.5) net Postage « extra HERBERT B. TURNER & (®)., Publ “7 Fasex Building, Boston, Mas The Life of Oscar Wilde ‘> ompiete tif r Ww " » COT Mitchell Kennerley tay Buckranu gilt toy si tw t ! y vears “Ae Interesting as The Devil” says the New York Sun of THE IDLERS Mr. MORLEY ROBERTS ® Maaterful Novel af Boclety EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY Cloth EB. P, i) cents, leather © DUTTON &A CO WE w YORK
Page 24
vi The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2148 | TWO NEW BOOKS | The University Press The Chief American Poets of Cambridge, England Edited by CURTIS HIDDEN PAGE, Ph.D., Ad- junct Professor in Columbia Univ. . $1.75 A single volume containing all the poems of Bryant, Poe, Emerson, Longfellow, Whit- a tier, Holmes, Lowell, Whitman, and Lanier “— . : : : that would be prescribed for study in a col- [he publications of The Press (The Pitt Prees)| S=Se=2 > =. try. With bibliographies, critical and ex- are now handled by G. P. Putnam’s Sons, and they planatory notes; lists of references classified ° ° ° . under such headings as Biography, Criticism, invite correspondence with instructors, students, the general Editions, Tributes in Verse; brief biograph- ical sketches; indexes. The Elements of Political Science By STEPHEN LEACOCK, Ph.D., Lecturer at publi and the trade. The American Edition of the New Cambridge Catalogue is ready for distribution, and this and the Quarterly Bulletin will gladly be sent to those interested. | “mcgin University, Montreal. . $1.75 Correspondence concerning this list and Putnam’s Dapeng po ee Educational Publications should be addressed to Pu.D., Profesor of History and Polltiea Science in Columbia University. G. P. Put > § HOUGHTON, MIFFLIN & COMPANY s © ° u ham Ss ons . Boston New York Chicago Educational Department NEW YORK oe Astor Edition LITERARY CRITICISM LIBRARY RESEARCH of Poets Of English and American Authors. Topics of all kinds and in any language looked Os to 1M ,0OO-)) ap in the Boston and Harvard Libraries, for schol- In eight royal S8vo volumes, 6 pages a ars, writers, and others. Abstracts, copies, trans- | is the best for schools and colleges. % vols. List ; lations, and bibliographies made. Proof-reading | price, 60c. per vol. (price to schools 40c.). Descriptive matter and specimen pages on re and revision of manuscript. Highest university ee . quest and library wetnoonen® = BoCKmemaM SEND FOR LIST. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. Thomas Y. Crowell&Co.,New York The Second Educational Number of THE NATION Will be issued on September 6 and will reach the professors in the leading colleges and academic institutions in the country. our thousand extra copies of this issue will be sent to persons interested in educational affairs in addition to those sent to regular subscribers. This issue will be sent to teachers of Philosophy, Physics and Chemistry, Mathematics, and Natural Sciences. Copy for this number should be received on or before September 4. THE NATION Publication Office, 206-210 Broadway, New York City.
Page 25
gga — ale ia