The Nation 1906-08-09: Vol 83 Iss 2145

Page 1

SEWER?’ LIBRA

UNIV. of MICH. NG - wr,.%O 7%. figs eV ay Cc j / "ey, 4 j Pa a : Aln f O79, VOL. LXXXIII—NO, 2145. THURSDAY, AUGUST 9, 1906. PRICE TEN CENTS

The Macmillan Company’s Latest Publications SCIENTIFIC BOOKS Hallock and Wade’s Outlines of the Evolution of Weights and Measures and the Metric System By WILLIAM HALLOCK, Ph.D., Professor of Physics in Columbia University, and Hersert T. Wape, Editor for Physi Applied Sciences of ‘* The New International Encyclopedia.’ t+ 304 p., Svo, cl., $2.25 nets by mail. $ Stevens and Hobart’s Steam Turbine Engineering By T. STEVENS and H. M. HoparT, author of ** Electric Motors,”’ et 1o+Srg p., with 516 illustration Professor E. W. Hilgard’s Soils Their Formation, Properties, Composition, ani Relations to Climate and Plant Growthin the Humid and Arid Regior By E. W. HILGaRD, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor of Agriculture in the University of California, and Director of the Galiforni Agricultural Experiment Station. Cloth, 8vo, 590? page %, S g.< Professor E. H. S. Bailey’s A Text-book of Sanitary and Applied Chemistry The Chemistry of Water, Air, and Food. By E. H. S. BaiLey, Ph.D. Professor of Chemistry, University of Kansa r+ S45 py l., f2mo, $1.90 net, by mail, $7 ON ECONOMIC QUESTIONS Raper’s The Principles of Wealth and Welfare By CHARLES LEE RAPER, Ph.D., Professor of Economics, University of North Carolina. 10+-376 p.. samo, cl., $1.0 net y mail, $7.2 John Spargo’s new book on Socialism A Summary and Interpretation of Soctalist Principles By JOHN SPARGO, author of *‘ The Bitter Cry of the Children.”’ 164-267 p., 1amo, cl. $1.25 An especially notable chapter discusses liberty in the Socialist stat Thompson’s From the Cotton Field to the Cotton Mill A Study of the Industrial Transition in North Carolina By HOLLAND THOMPSON, Ph.D., Sometime Fellow in Columbia University. 10+-284 p., 12mo, chy $1.50 net; by mail, $1.67 A very valuable contribution to the study of factory conditions in the cotton states, particularly in North and South Carolina

eed MISCELLANEOUS NEW BOOKS Major’s First Steps in Mental Growth A Series of Studies in the Psychology of Infancy By Davip R. MAJOR, Ph.D., Professor of Educaton, Ohio State University, 14+ 360 p., illus., r2mo, cl., $1.25 net; by mail, $1.3 “As a record of patient and competent minute observation, the book is of immense value in many ways.’’—Couricr- Yourna

Professor Horne’s The Psychological Principles of Education A Study in the Science of Education By HERMAN HarRRELt Horne, Ph.D, Professor of Philosophy in Dartmouth College, Author of “The Philosophy of y Education.”’ KU 475 pus cloth, 12mo, $7.75 net; by mail, $7.88 2 a AAO ERECT Co: OTE Published THE MACMILLAN COMPANY “£é 50 Ave. New York

Fe Ae - 7 — 7 ro

Page 2

The Nation. 4 WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED TO Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865, Fintered at the New York City Post Office as second-class mat satter CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER.

Tue Were 109 } 1 ' ! AY IF i low Idea And Others 112 } nd M ts 112 I x f ss in Poll . 113 I \ Francis 114 ¥ ' 4 ats 114 | ‘ \ged 115 1aAL ¢ ne »N a , ¢ l 116 ‘ r ic . ] . pathy for Animals 117 | i ng of Emperor W um’s Gifts to ' Museu 117 ' , Nod 118 | ’ Lis I KeVIR Dodd ' 122 I ‘ | no 122 I Inf ‘ f Western Purope n Scand ivi 1 n 123 | ‘ Wild 124 | I I es y f Paul Revere 124 | I I f Willlam Bentley, D.D 12h ‘ \ ire in England 126 (ireek 7 f Elen iry Cognitl 126 I I ion of Numa 127 I il de I'Kstoll 127 Papers of tl Military Hi rical 3S ty f \Massachu . 128 rr Reformation in England 128 Its Yesterdava 128 La Fondation de l'Rmptre Allemand 129 | i Constit nal History of New York 120 | I want Life in the Holy Land 129 I D F ne WeeK «+» 130 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Thre lollara per year in advance, postpaid, in | sny part of the United States or Canada; to for- | eign untries comprised in the Postal Union, #4 The date when the subscripti n expires is on the address label of erch paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remit tance No other receipt is sent unless requested Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless sade by registered letter, or by check, express order. or Postal Order payable io ** Publisher of The Nation When achange of address is desired, both the i and the new addresses should be given tidress THE NATION, Box 794, New York Publication OMee, 208 Rroadway TERMS OF ADVERTISING. Fifteen conta per agate line, each inaertion; 14 lines to the inch Twenty per cent. advance for choice of page or top of column 4 column, $20 each insertion with choice of page, s 1 page, $60 cach insertion; front cover page, $80 4ilvertisaements muat be acceplable in every reaper

Copy received until Tuesday, 5 P. M DISCOUNTS. Time ‘ ort - > per nt PM 0 19 12s “ if ; v0 A™ 1 sino w na year 10) per nt iv ie) } “A ) 7 0 0 ” tills THE NATION is sent free to those who adver fise in U as long a4 advertisement continues *e*Coples of the Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opera; in Lonion of B. F. Stevens '& Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charipg Cross |New York Nation. The [Vol. 83, No. 2145

Educational. Massacuuserrs, Boston. STON UNIVERSITY Law School. New features. Address the Dean. M. M. BIGELOW.

JETHLEHEM PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Bethlehem, Pa.—Prepares for leading colleges. Catalogue H. A. Fourtna, B.S., Prin.

MASSACHUSETTS, BOSTON. School of the Museum of Fine Arts Scholarships. Paige Foreign Scholar- ship for Men and Women Cummings Traveling Scholarship for Men Helen Hamblen Scholar- Anstractors. ELC. Turbeil, F. w Benson, Philip Hale, W.M. Paxton, F -yatlt deg ship. Philip Hale Anatomy Gardner Scholarship. A, K. Cross, Perspective Ten Free Scholarships. Prizes in money awarded in each Department. Drawing and Painting Modeling Department of Design C. Howard \atker. Director For Circulars and Terms _ address the Manager, Sist Year begins Oct. 1 Auice F. Brooks.

JUST PUBLISHED! The Problem of Spelling Reform By the Rev. Professor W. W. SKEAT Being a lecture delivered before the British Acad- emy ‘May 2, 1906. 8vo, paper covers. 25 cents

** Every one interested in spelling reform should read this lecture.” The King’s English Crown 8vo, cloth, $1.75 net From the Preface The plan of the book was dictated by the JSollowing considerations. it is notorious that tnglish writers seldom look into a grammar or compe sition book; the reading of grammars is repellent because, being bound to be exhaustive onagreater or less scale, they must give much space to the obvious or the unnecessary; an composition books are often useless because they enforce their w arnings only by fabricated blun- ders against which every tyro feels himself quite safe For sale by all booksellers. Send for catalogue. OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, American Branch, 91-93 Fifth Avenue, New York

ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories. Shop for Mechanic Arts. Strong teachers. High tdeais, A new gymrastum with swimmirg pool. Fits for col lege, scientific school and business. Lllustrated pam phiet sent free addre Dr. B. C. WHITE, Roc k Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hills, Mass.

§ 72d Year opens Oct. Ist, 1¥06. Morning Classes, sessions 0:30 to 12. After- University noon Classes, 3:30 to 6. vening Classes, 8 to 10 Law School f Deere LL.B, LLM., J.D. Address L. J. TOMPKIN 4, Secretary, Washington Square, N. Y.

NEW YORK /| Day Schvol § 35 Nassau St., LAW SCHOOL | Eve ning « School) New York City. ‘Dwight Method” of tnstruction. LL.B. in two years. ULM. in three years. High standards. Send for catalogue, GEORGE CHASE, Dean. The HIGHLAND MILITARY ACADEMY SS. Established in 1856. The m ~ git a3 Vernier D.D., LL.D., Springfield, Visitor. Fits its students for le alae places in colle- giate, professional, or business life Joseru ALDEN Suaw, A.M., Headmaster.

School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Evererr O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Pl, ®oston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cen. Bid., Minneapolis 203 Mich. Ave.,Chicago 1200 Williams Av., Portland 401 Cooper Bid., Denver 525 8tims’n Bid,.Los Angeles 413 Rook'ry BIk., Spokane 717 Market St.,S5an F'ncisco Send to any address above for Agency Manual. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Has Good Positions for Good Teachers with Good Records Send for Circular on Free Registration. HARLAN P. FRENCH, 8! Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ss‘ "HERMERHORN'S Teachers’ Agency. ® Teachers—Schoola—Tutors Seve rne ated rel. 6120 Isth 3 FE. 14th St.. Y. ©,

Situations Wanted. /e NPERIENCED Teacher secks fal! en- gagement. Languages. English. A. B., Ithaca, N. ¥

f tnanciald. » buy and sell bills of exchanges and LETTERS ae cable transfers of money on Ku- OF rope, Australia, and South Africa; also make collections and {ssue Commercial CREDIT and Travellers’ Credits avatiable in all parts of the world International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO. NO. 50 WALL STREET, NEW YORK.

‘Ae Interesting as The Devil” says the New York Sun of THE IDLERS Mr. MORLEY ROBERTS'S Masterful Novel of Society

WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficieat depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. 1. A tremendous miscellaneous stock. 2 Greatly increas«d facilities for the im- portation of English publications. 3. Competent bookmen to price lists and collect books. All of this means prompt and complete shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR Co., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York.

BOOKS FOR CHILDREN The Jane Andrews Series Long’s Wood Folk Series The Youth’s Companion Series Collode’s Pinocchio Chance’s Little Folks of Many Lands Hardy’s Sea Stories for Wonder Eyes Chandler’sin the Reign of Coyote CINN & COMPANY, BOSTON

Handy Volume Classics Used by schools and colleges everywhere. 155 vols., pocket size. List prices, cloth, 35c. per vol., limp [oa ther Tic. per vol. (Special prices to schools and colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE, Thomas Y.Crowell & Co., NewYork

EN CMAS PSYCHICAL RESEARCH k dealing scientifically with Mediumis- the Phenomena, Apparitions, Clairvoyance, Telepathy, Dreams, etc, By Prof. James H. Hysviop, author of’ Science and a Future Life.” Price $1.50 net. Postage 12c. extra. HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., Publishers. 87 Essex Building, Boston, ‘Mass, LITERARY GRITICISM Of English and American Authors. 680 to 1905. Ineight royal 8vo volumes. 6,000

Prescriptive matter and specimen pages on re- quest. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO, Buffalo, New York “It persistently and a yey ~ eqgertains” SIROCCO.

ies eee

ane Sit as DONE A Rh

Page 3

The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, AUGUST ®, 1906 The Week. “Campaigning in forma pauperis” cer- tainly describes this year’s activity of the two Congressional Committees. Chairman Sherman announces with some pride that his one dollar subscriptions have reached “four figures.”” That is, they must total something like half as much as the single check which the Equitable gave Mr. Babcock two years ago. “We are poor,” now rises the voice of Chairman Griggs, “and we can- not afford to chase rainbows.” There- fore, if any district is hopeless, it is the duty of good Democrats to tell him so frankly. More modest in its require- ments than even the Republicans, his Committee asks the faithful for the pres- ent to expend only the price of a two- cent stamp. We offer our sincere sym- pathy to the manufacturers of banners and torches and regalia. Their occupa- tion’s gone, indeed. But the fear that really haunts us in this crisis is that the Populists or the Prohibitionists who are not manifesting any scruples against taking all they can get, and presumably have as big funds as ever, may come forward suddenly, out-bid the poverty- stricken Democrats and Republicans, and run off with the election. Gov. Higgins’s statement of his rea- sons for refusing to remove Fiscal Su- pervisor Bender for violating the civil- service laws is queer reading. The tail of it eats up the head. It would almost seem that the Governor asked his legal advisers for two opinions about Bender: one completely exculpating him; the other condemning him roundly; and that then Mr. Higgins used parts of both. His decision begins by declaring that there was really no evidence against Bender, and that it is doubtful, anyhow, if the Legislature had power to pass so stringent an act against gifts to the party campaign fund by State officials; and winds up by showing how “‘detri- mental to the service” is such “a dis- regard of the spirit of the civil-service law” as “this investigation has disclosed in this office’—that is, in Bender’s, But the Governor declines to remove him, though the investigation was by a Re- publican Board of Civil Service Com- missioners, who strongly urged Mr. Hig- gins to serve notice upon the politicians that this kind of defiance of law must cease. The notice which he has served upon them, however, is that if they make themselves a useful part of the Governor’s machine, they have nothing to fear. It seems probable now that Bender has all along had a promise of immunity from Mr. Higgins. The lat ter’s action completes the display of a character which is the less admired the more it is understood A possible explanation of the almost complete failure of the New Hampshire press even to mention Winston Church ill’s candidacy for the Governorship is his declaration, in a speech at Conway the other night, that seventy out of seventy-five newspapers in the State are subsidized by the Boston and Maine Railroad. almost equal parts of “‘rusticators” and To an audience made up in natives, he discoursed on the iniquities of the railroad lobby He that when he first entered the Legisla contessed ture, he had confused the lobby and the Republican party of New Hampshir¢ and that even after enlightenment he had an idea that reform might be ef fected from the inside without unneces sary publicity. Then, in words that might have fallen from the lips of his own prototype in “Coniston,” he declar ed: “You cannot which is reaping a large annual profit and gaining many inestimable tages by governing a State to cease gov erning that State merely because a band of misguided foolish enough to sign the Declaration of Inde expect a_ railroad advan idealists were pendence away back in 1776." The pre siding officer at the Conway gathering thought it necessary to put an end to one misconception which he _ feared might be prevalent A man he had talked with, he said, refused to support Churchill, on the ground that he was “a foreigner, and only a short time ago had been prominent in the British Par liament.”’ Resumption of dividends on the com mon stock of the Steel Corporation is a matter of wide interest. That company’s dividend policy has from the start been subject to keen discussion The pro moters fixed for the common stock a quarterly dividend of 1 per cent., and announced it from the first as “regu lar.”” This they did in spite of the pro test of practically all unbiassed critics and accountants that the company need ed a larger working falance and very much larger allowance for depreciation, before attempting to pay out anything on this inflated stock. Some of the com pany’s own officers endeavored to word the dividend announcement 80 as not to commit the company to continuous pay ment; but they were overruled; the con trolling powers announced a “regular quarterly dividend.” Hardly two years passed before a moderate trade reaction so far cut into earnings that these com- mon stock dividends had to be h dropped. The accumulated surplus, wl had reached $99,809,000 in 3S pt 1903, fell to $61,794,000 in the ensuins March. But the ! nh Was not managers have paid no commor dividends since that month The made much more liberal appropria for depreciation. But continuans large profits has now moved th: agement to resume the commor! dividends, though at only one-hal! rate fixed in June, 1901 Under t} imstances, there is an excuse action which did not exist fi ago We think that the manag lent might better have merely announced dividend’ than have declared one half of 1 per cent. for the March q ter and the same for the June qua first because retroactive mea ‘ of this sort are needless and confusing and, second, because it looks like eva sion of the fact that, in realit the June quarter's entire surplus earning are used to pay this dividend Inas much as the total surplus, reported the company itself for December 1905, was less by $15,000,000 than in September, 1903, there will b ome people to argue that the common stoc} dividend ought to have been at least dé ferred until the surplus was brought its former maximum Mr. Root'’s address at the Pan-Ame ican conference is a timely and most velcome footnote to the Monroe D0o« | trine. The history of American diplo macy to be sure, abounds in altruistlk expressions for the republics tothe soutl of us, but, in view of what followed the war with Spain, and, more especial! of the seizure of the “canal strip, an explicit statement of our attitude to wards these sister nations is by no meat superfluous Mr. Root’s assurances on this point are admirable, both in i stance and in manner. “We wish fo no victories except those of peace he aid. “We wish for no territory except our own, and no sovereignty except over ourselves.”” These words must have been eminently satisfactory to all delegations ave the Colombian, and, indeed, walv ng by-gones, it is difficult to see how Mr. Root could have acquitted himselt of a somewhat difficult task with great er tact and frankness. The note of con descension, which is most trying to races representing an older civilization than our own, was entirely absent It is the hope that Mr. Root will la bor actively to bring about closer and better relations with the other Ameri can republics which gives his words sig nificance He is a man who pay with h person and it ma

Page 4

110 assumed that his service to cause of conciliation is not comprised in a single speech. In a large measure, he holds the situation in his own hands, and already has done ‘much to allay dis- trust of the United States. Unhappily, the most durable sort of alliances—fa- | vorable trade treaties—are prevented by the policy of the party In power. Here, too, Mr. Root must have the courage of his idealism, and accept the ungrate- ful task of educating Congress to ration- al ideas of trade. His elevated words will find a favorable echo from Patagonia to the Rio Grande; but they will fail of practical effect here foreign unless some intelligent attempt is made to put the United States, not on such a commercial basis as England enjoys in America—that is too much to hope—but at least on so tolerable a foot- ing as a protective nation like Germany has made for herself South On Monday at Charlotte, North Caro- lina, three negroes, whose trial for mur- der was already under way, were taken from the jail and lynched, in spite of the appeals of the Mayor, the Judge who was trying the cases, the city solicitor, and United States Senator Overman. rhe local promptly, but thoughtfully supplied with only blank cartridges, were spectators outrage The State of North militiamen, ordered out it th Carolina seems to be rapidly earning for itself the unenviable distinction of being 1 centre for the most violent anti-negro feeling of the South. The recent action of its Republican State Convention ad- vocating the further extension of the suffrage discrim- grandfather clause” ination goes beyond any previous dec- laration of the kind in the South. As we have pointed out before this, the per- manent retention of this method of let- ting the illiterate white man vote while illiterate plausible excuse ever offered excluding the negro destroys the ony for the Southern Constitutions, namely, that after the expiration of the “tem- impose the both some letters recently porary plans they would ame tests for the suffrage on race As to th written by North Carolina ire, to say the least, illuminating. Such Democrats i letter In the Atlanta Constitution sixnature of J. R. Keen: The negroe ire wide awake to the situa over the ol ind are doing all in their power to educat themaelve and their children, while the whites continue that indifferenc« » education that has always characterized them | last month listed the taxes of this township and nearly one-third of the men hat listed could not make their ‘X."’ Anthony Comstock and his Society have done such a world of good In sup- jressing the viler sort of pictures and printed matter that it is a pity he should, from time to time, discredit his The Nation. | the | work by unintelligent activity beyond his province. This time he has seized an issue of the American Student of Art, a monthly magazine issued in the inter- est of the Art Students’ League of this city. The offence was merely the re- number of “acad- emies,”” or drawings from the nude figure. This is commonly done by other art schools that maintain a jour- nal. The circulation of such periodicals is practically limited to art students and those concerned with their instruc- tion. In an individual case, a wrong use might conceivably be made of these nudities, but to pounce upon such publi- cations is, as a teacher at our League justly remarked, as absurd as to hale the publishers of Gray’s “Anatomy” to court for intentional pornography. All this is Greek to Mr. Comstock, but it is not Greek to some of the directors of the Society for the Suppression of Vice, who owe it to themselves and _ their work to restrain his more questionable production of a vagaries There is a good custom in Boston by which no wealthy citizen may die in peace unless Harvard College and the Art Museum are mentioned in his will. The number of small bequests is con- siderable, and, being usually unrestrict- ed, these minor gifts are a peculiarly available resource. If it is too much to hope that Columbia University and the Metropolitan Museum will ever make quite the claim upon New York that the corresponding Boston institutions do upon their more homogeneous public, one must at least desire that our great- est museum and university should be nore generally remembered. We are ciad to note that by two wills probated list week the Metropolitan Museum re- ceives of $20,000 and $1,000. The example is worthy of imitation. If, fcr example, every subscriber to the Mu- seum should, according to his ability, “remember it in his will,” the actual in- crease in income would be considerable, while small or even nominal bequests co as much as the more conspicuous do- rations to set a praiseworthy fashion. It should be quite as bad form to leave a will without mention of some beneficent institution as it once was to transfer an estate unprovided with some modest “back-log” of Government bonds. bequests One more rich young man has been exposed at his questionable diversion of pretending to be poor and needy. This time it is the son of a Chicago banker who wants to be a missionary. In prep- aration for that calling, he desires to become “on intimate terms with hard- ship and adversity,” and has taken the position of scullion at the country club of a summer resort In southern Wiscon- sin. He has been scrubbing and scour- ing and polishing the handles of the big [ Vol. 83, No. 2145 front door there for the last month, and has enjoyed some singular experiences, as, for instance, being barred from the dining room when his family were eat- ing at the club, and he had donned his own good clothes to partake of their hospitality. But the newspapers have discovered him. The self-abnegation of the rich man’s son is under the same everlasting glare as his vices. In either case it must be an exceptional charac- ter that can develop normally under it. Given the most sincere ambition for simple and humble service, what can become of all these good intentions when the right hand can read in the papers every morning just what the left hand doeth? The poor, hunted scullion will have to drop out of sight and seek new employment, only to be exposed again and again and driven into more remote places. The hunted criminal is not more in terror of detection than the wealthy day laborer. And this, after all, is only the most insignificant side of a condition for which the sensational press is chiefly responsible. When the twelve-year-old grandson of a wealthy Chicagoan was gravely interviewed here the other day, on the questions of the hour, the pursuit of the families of the rich was seen in its silliest aspect. The Liberal Administration lived up to the best English traditions in the pro- posals for the new government of the Transvaal which it laid before Parlia- ment last week. Self-government on a fair and equitable basis it offers Eng- lishmen and Boers alike. There are no special provisions to insure Anglo-Saxon domination, as had been expected by many. For the moment, the upper house is to consist of fifteen members ap- pointed by the Crown; but arrange- ments will at once be made for an elec- tive body instead. The guiding princi- ple of manhood suffrage will also be embodied in the constitution for the Orange River Colony, which is in course of preparation. In short, within four years of the war, if Parliament agrees, the former Boer republics are to be as much in control of their own affairs as either Natal or Cape Colony. This plan attests both the courage and generosity of the Ministry. Mr. Balfour only echoed the words of the Jingo press in denounc- ing the scheme as premature and reck- less. Kipling assumed, merely upon ru- mors of the Ministry’s intention, that the Boers would be put in complete pos- session of their old country. The exact number of voters of British or Dutch ancestry is still in doubt, and the Min- istry has had to face the possibility of Dutch control of the new lower house. This risk, if it exist, Sir Henry Camp- bell-Bannerman has had to take; he has entrenched himself firmly on the demo- cratic principle that each citizen twen- ty-one years of age shall have a vote in the government of the country. The Rha cli on eat Lh ae hd) Nhe Ie ng png Ra gE 8

Page 5

~ % rats MET August 9, 1906] The Nation. 111 magnanimity of this action recalling that of the North towards the South in our Own country, should be a potent fac- tor in hastening the return of peace and prosperity in a sadly harried and unhappy country. Upon the question of servile and Chi- nese labor, the Government has also spoken out emphatically. At the mo- ment of conferring power upon a ma- jority, probably in favor of a continu- ance of Chinese slavery in the mines, it serves notice on all concerned that re- cruiting of Chinese labor must cease on November 15. More than that, the Con- stitution will contain a positive provi- sion against servile labor of any kind. For this the blacks may well give thanks. It was high time for the Min- istry to take this stand; in the ranks of its followers dissatisfaction with its handling of the Chinese question had long been rife. Of 50,000 coolies on the Rand, 1,311 are in prison, while law- lessness and disorder are steadily on the increase. Only the slaveholders—the mine-owners—are really satisfied with conditions as they are. Parliament rose on Saturday, leaving the reputation of the Liberal Ministry heightened, on the whole, as a result ef the labors of the session. There have been some signs of vacillation and even cf disagreement in the Government, but the Prime Minister has kept a firm hand on the puodlic business. It has moved on with great dispatch. The Cabinet has shown much more driving power than Mr. Balfour’s had for the last year or two of its existence. While the routine bills have been handled skilfully, the various pronouncements upon _ public policy have been marked by grasp and consistency, and have been well receiv- ed. The official Opposition, of course, has got up a great deal of manufactur- ed fury, but the country has remained calm, even when Mr. Balfour was, as the Chancellor of the Exchequer said, tear- ing an artificial passion to tatters over the Education Bill. The change in Mr. Balfour is, indeed, an interesting study in psychology. Years ago, as Irish Sec- retary, he made his reputation as a mir- acle of coolness under the taunts and revilings of the Parnellites. As Prime Minister and Leader of the House, his favorite réle was that of condescending daintiness, immovably amiable, indulg- ing by preference in the superlative of under-statement. But now, in Opposi- tion, he mounts to noble rage nearly every day, and is shrill and extravagant where he once would have been quiet- ly sarcastic. Is this a sign of waning powers, or simply of a losing cause? Perhaps Mr. Balfour has felt it neces- sary to invent an impetuous anger to hurl at the robust impassiveness and downrightness of Campbell-Bannerman. The Anglo-Indian Pioneer has under taken to print the complaints of Hin- dus with reference to the “injustice and insolence” of the English in India. A correspondent of the Berlin Tageblatt supplies further details. Young officers sve accused of being specially flagrant offenders. “In driving through the cit- ies they ply their whips right and left to clear the streets, without reflecting that thereby they arouse feelings which, eaining force from year to year, must end in an explosion.” The educated Hin cus are aggrieved because the English treat them with the same contempt as ‘ue coolies, refusing to eat or associate vith them. They are becoming impa- tient, in proportion as they share the henefits of a European system of educa tion, at the postponement of the day when they are to have a voice in the shaping of the country’s policy. The German referred to is at a loss to un- cerstand the British attitude toward the educated Hindus. “I have become ac- quainted with a number of these,” he Writes, “whom I liked decidedly better than many an English snob or German cfficial I have met.” M. Hertzenstein, the member of the Duma who was assassinated on August 1, had gained prominence as an author- ity on the land question. He had draft- ed a project of law for the expropria- tion of unimproved holdings. ‘That lit- tle Jew in spectacles,’ was the temptuous phrase of the landlords in re- ferring to him. He at least showed the financial and constructive talent of his race. His was the bill which the Duma would have been most disposed to enact, had not the stroke of dissolution fallen. Hertzenstein proposed that all lands not actually worked by their owners should be taken by the State “‘at a just price.” In those words lay the rub. What was the “just price,” and who was to fix it? The St. Petersburg correspondent of the Paris Figaro relates a conversation on this subject which he overheard between a landlord and Aladin, the peasant lead- er. The latter resented the charge that his party would take land without pay- ing for it; were they robbers? Well, then, asked the landlord, “how about that property of mine in Cherson, which Catherine II. gave to my great-grand- father®’ “Ah,” replied Aladin, smiling, “for lands which your ancestors acquir- ed without expense, the nation will pay nothing in resuming control of them. You will lose your property without in- demnity. Justice wills it.” One sees how thorny is the agrarian question in Russia. ¥ con- Emperor William, in denying to a re- porter of the Paris Matin that he is p'eased at every report of scandal or disaffection in the French army, prob- ably was thinking as much of Russia as of France. The meaning of his say- ing, “anti-militarism is an international pest,” depends upon definition of terms; but it is certain that Russian autocrats doubtful of the loyal- ty of their own troops is one that causes uLeasiness in military nations As Ana- tole France has just said, “The Russian revolution is a universal Its rumblings are felt afar ized and leaderless as the present move: ment appears to be with all adic outbreaks, its haphazard bloodshed, and its strange lack of solidarity among the men of even a single regiment, it is o? an earth-shaking sort. Doubtless Herr Bebel would say to-day with even more emphasis than he did a year ago: “The revolutionary which has broken out in Russia finds an echo in the heart of the German workingman.” There is the spectacle of revolution.” Unorgan- its spor storm ro present question, of course, of any thing like rious disaffection in the German army. But if the report had been true that the Emperors of Austria and Germany had promised to lend the Czar troops to put down the revolution- ists, there might a different story to tell. Happily, the report was promptly and officially denied at Berlin. have been The which the Prussian bureaucracy will go in order to discred length to it the Social-Democrats, appears from a recent circular of the Prussian Minis ter of Education. In the event, he ruled of any persons offering to give school children training in gymnastics free of cost, permission is to be granted if the applicant can prove his moral fitness to undertake that work. To this the Min added “The any such moral fitness is to be denied in the ister possession of case of all members of the Social-Dem Naturally, the tion of this extraordinary document haa Writ Theodor ocratic party.” publica called forth sarcastic comments ing in the Berlin Nation, Dr Barth asks whether the next step should not be the “commandeering” of al! chil dren of Social-Democrats. If no one of the three belonging to that party is morally fit to teach gymnastics, millions surely not one is a person to instill correct growing children. the nation take and educate all dren of a Social-Democratic father or mother. The Social Democracy larger number of voters than any other party, and, if we may judge by its suc- cess in the last three elections to the Re chstag, there is no reason to believe that its influence with the masses is waning. But, instead of codéperating with other parties in order to achieve definite reforms, or of turning for new recruits to other than the laboring classes, the Social-Democacy is wasting its time and strength in interna! sensions and theoretical discussions. proper into the Hence he sugests that chil- ideas minds of has a dis-

Page 6

112 THE “IOWA IDEA”"—AND OTHERS. of the Iowa State Con- characteristic of the ways of politicians. A contest had been bitterly waged for and against a prin- ciple. After a severe and dubious strug- gle, the friends of the principle won, controlled the Convention, took all the offices, and, apparently, threw the prin- ciple out of the window. In other words, Gov. Cummins had been savagely fought ty the stand-patters, whom he in turn bad denounced and attacked, but when he had them beaten and himself safely renominated, lo! the Convention adopt- The outcome vention was highly ed a stand-pat platform, the lion and the lamb lay down together, grace, mercy, and peace were hymned by all factions, and the only wonder of the by- stander is what the long and envenomed quarrel had been all about. It has certainly been about something. The long thunder of the captains in Iowa and the shouting could not have been caused by a desire to write such stand- pat platitudes into the platform as the Convention actually adopted. The fight was personal to Gov. Cummins, and on account of his pronounced views about the need of tariff revision. It was for this reason that Secretary Shaw jour- neyed so frequently to Iowa to make speeches and pack caucuses against Cum- mins. Shaw is the pattest stander of them all. Others, like Roosevelt, may be but half-pat, standing on only one foot, like a sleepy heron, and wonder- ing where to put down the other, but the Secretary of the Treasury is always firmly planted with both feet on a tariff which it is sacrilege to revise. He had openly and declared Gov. Cummins to be a heretic on the tariff wicked Democrat—and for that reason had called upon faithful Republicans to excommunicate him. On his part, Cummins had not minced lan- guage. He had publicly and repeatedly arserted that certain tariff schedules were retained only in the interest of op- pressive monopolies, and that the “rob- bery” committed by the Beef Trust and the Standard Oj! was as nothing to the of the by a tariff. Yet he amilably accepted week a platform of which the tariff plank was made of the familiar old punk-wood—duties to “secure remunera- tive prices,” yet to foster “domes- tie monopoly”: rates to be “adjusted from time to time,” but only in a way to “keep the tariff in harmony with our Industrial and commercial progress.” We defy any Republican, not minus one or more of his senses, that client nonsense without laughing. Are suppose, then, that Cummins is, after all, not a_ lion, but a sheep? Has he bartered his tar iff-revision birthright for a mess of of fice? There will be some, doubtless, to iasinuate that the Governor of Iowa was repeatedly no better than a protective last robbery people not to repeat an we to Gov. The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2145 insincere throughout, or that he was perfectly willing to say, cynically, that a renomination vaut bien une messe in the shape of a platform written by the stand-patters. But that would be a su- perficial interpretation of the result. In large effect, it was a great triumph for progressive ideas about the tariff within the Republican party. A good test of this is the position in which it leaves Secretary Shaw. He was hissed to his face in the Des Moines Convention last week. Observers on the spot report him to be “broken and discouraged” by the outcome. He had certainly staked his political future on beating Cummins. Beaten by Cummins, he will not be so ardent or confident in urging his own Presidential candidacy as the blindest ef all the stand-patters. This of itself is a momentous consequence of the Iowa Convention; nor can it be supposed that Gov. Cummins will be inclined to mod- ify, much less abandon, tariff views on which he has won a great victory. Not for nothing was his wing of the party called “progressives,” as against the stand-patters. He represents an element of Republicanism ready to come out of the old tariff cave, with its owls and bats, and move on to a new policy de- manded by the new times. Thus in its general effect the result in Iowa can- not fail to encourage those Republicans in New England and Indiana and Min- nesota—there may be at least one in Oyster Bay—who are for having their party move next against tariff monop- olists and restrainers of trade. Certaialy in Massachusetts, zeal for tariff reform seems to be seizing upon the Republican party. “We are all tar- iff revisers now,” they say. They have not forgotten Gov. Guild’s letter to the President last year, stating that the Republicans would have lost the State had it not been for their promises to re- form the Dingley tariff. They are re- doubling those promises this year, with what credence by the people remains to be seen. But the protectionists are vis- ibly as much shaken in Massachusetts as they are in Iowa. Their wisdom has been simply that of the stronger— and power is al- The power ts always theirs, ways wise— and when once they find that the other side can carry conventions and win elec- tions, they will discover that the time has come to improvise life-long convic- tions of quite another tenor. HARVESTS AND MARKETS. It was an English financial critic, we believe, who some years ago described the United States as “Nature's spoiled child.” By this he meant that the reck- lessness of our financial and industrial experiments had been such as to invite the most serious penalty; yet an unex- pected stroke of good fortune in Amer- ican industry, or some development that could not have been confidently pre- dicted, had counterbalanced the excess- es of our promoters and speculators, averted the threatened crisis, and even- tually led the way to what seemed to be a still stronger economic position. The industrial reaction of 1903, for in- stance, coming when our capitalists were tied hand and foot in rash indebtedness, seemed at the time to forebode a cul- minating stroke at overcapitalized con- solidations and amalgamations. What happened was that a cotton crop in 1904 of wholly unprecedented magni- tude, with the world’s cotton prices at a level fixed by three years of scarcity, followed by an equally unparalleled crop of wheat in 1905, harvested and sold under very similar conditions, so enriched our interior communities that the home market for manufactured prod- ucts became larger than at any pre- vious time; while purchases by foreign nations, forced by their own inade- quate supplies to buy in unusual quan- tity, served to cancel an excessive float- ing indebtedness of our own to them. This good fortune could not have been safely predicted by the most sagacious observer; the events on which it de- pended were in fact pronounced im- probable, in advance, by the great body of trade experts. No one has forgotten the debate of the cotton trade in 1903, whether it was possible ever again to raise such crops even as those of half a dozen years before. The weight of opinion leaned to the conclusion that it could not be done; exhaustion of the soil and insect pests put the achieve- ment out of the line of probability. Pre- diction, at that time, that a cotton crop, 20 per cent. larger than the largest ever previously harvested, would be grown within a year, would have been re- ceived with ridicule. Yet that is pre- cisely what happened. So, in 1904, when a wheat crop of small size and poor quality forced us to import 3,000,000 bushels from other countries, many of the highest authori- ties in the grain trade pointed out evi- dences that our capacity as a grain- growing and grain-exporting state was destined to be progressively impaired. Good wheat land could, so one of the foremost English experts argued, no longer be obtained at reasonable prices; the older cultivated area was either be- ing invaded by towns and cities or di- verted to other forms of produce; the permanent fall of the United States to a minor position among the world’s wheat producers was an early probabil- ity. Nature’s answer to this fairly plaus- ible theory was an American wheat crop, the very next year, never but once exceeded in the country’s history. These facts simply go to show that those venturesome experiments in the American money markets—which de- pended on exactly this agricultural out- come—were not saved from wreck by 1 a PReine th AR

Page 7

Sew Ne oA ce ila OR te 0 August 9, 1906] events sagaciously foreseen. The same is true of the country’s financial and industrial history of the current year. Last year ended and the present year . began in the markets with a note of distinct and formidable warning. A reckless speculative undertaking, in which banks and great banking houses seemed alike to be engaged, had tied up large sums of capital at a time when it had become manifest that all available funds were needed for legitimate trade purposes. At the end of 1905, money touched 125 per cent. in Wall Street; in January, the New York bank surplus was at the lowest point, and money at the highest, reached in that month during twenty-six years. In April, when the Eastern banks ordinarily begin to strengthen their position, with a view to the later call for harvest money, bank reserves fell below the minimum fixed by the Banking Act—something which had not happened, at that time of year, since 1884. High financial ex- perts disagreed as to the immediate cause. Mr. Schiff ascribed it to an in- elastic currency; Mr. Hepburn, with whose conclusions the practical banking community seemed to be more closely in accord, placed the blame on “over- trading,” absorption in land and stock speculation of capital urgently needed elsewhere. But whatever their general inferences, all financial authorities ad- mitted that the known phenomena de- noted a future full of danger. Once more, however, Nature seems to have come to our relief. The season is nearly at hand when the country’s im- portant crops will be assured. Taking as a basis the Government’s latest es- timates of acreage and condition, there is promise of a wheat crop second in size only to the great yield of 1901, a corn crop fairly equalling last year’s and far exceeding all others, and a cot- ton crop surpassed alone by the great yield of 1904. Accidents of the season are yet possible, and not all of this promise may be realized. But at the moment the situation is propitious; its importance, in offsetting the evil influ- ences foreshadowed in the springtime, is very great. Such harvests would mean, first, continuance of high prosperity in our inland communities, and, with it, continuance of home demand on our manufacturing output; next, it would mean a full available surplus of agricul- tural exports, through which our mar- ket’s heavy borrowings from Europe, at the time of the money disturbances of four months ago, may be paid off without serious strain. Whether the situation is such as to admit of another plunge of our specu- lating bankers and capitalists is a dif- ferent question. Their performances of last year were based on the theory that, with large crops of wheat and corn, and with profitable industry in progress, the The Nation. use of bank reserves in wholesale spec- ulation was entirely safe. But it was not safe then, and would not be so now. The very richness of the present har- vest promise points to unprecedentedly large demands from interior markets upon the country’s reserve money and on its capital. The sums tied up in real estate speculation, over the entire coun- try, are probably much larger than a year ago. Recourse of large corpora- tions to issue of notes because they can not easily market their bonds, and fail- ; ure of such a security as New York | city 4 per cents to bring more than a | trifle over par, are signs that available | capital is not sufficient for both legiti mate industry and inflated stock specu lation. One hears the Wall Street ora- cle answer that we can borrow from Europe. But serious financiers are well aware that our present concern is not to increase, but to reduce as rapidly as possible, a foreign floating debt which lately reached proportions possibly nev- | er before attained. THE RELIGION OF SUCCESS IN POLITICS. Guglieimo Ferrero, to whose occasion- al writings one seldom turns without getting suggestion based on learning and reflection, has a recent article on “The Religion of Success.” This is not mere- ly a variant of “The Gospel of Success.” Tc preach the saving grace of “doing things” and “getting there’ does not tuke one so far as it does to accept the doctrine and make of it an absorbing and sacred conviction—a religion. Yet this, Ferrero contends, is what the mod- ern world is doing with greater unanim- ity every day. In department after de- partment—education, theology, art, jour- nalism—-the ¢clat of success is not only the sufficient answer to every objection, but the thing which we are bidden to seek and worship before all other gods. What Ferrero points out with much acuteness is that, particularly in poli- tics, this religion of success is the syurce of great difficulties. It vitiates our political judgments. It disturbs the orderly development of political ideas and movements. For the causes of suc- cess in politics are exceedingly complex. They are often wrapped up in accidents and even blunders which baffle the most trained sagacity. Yet let there be great success, or the plausible appearance of it, and we instantly take up with some single cause, some sole explanation sug- gested, and thereafter reckon that cause and that explanation among the politi- cal certainties. Some extraordinary happening, some brute event, turns for the time the course of political history. We see a brilliant success snatched by chance, and we say, “That is the way it ought always to be done.” Military success is less subject than political success to causes which no 1138 astuteness can foresee or impede Ye even in it, with our tendency to reduce everything to the simplest explanation we reason about a mere accident as if it were the essential thing. Rome beat Carthage, we say, because her govern ment and her army were better organ ized. But should we have been so sure of that had we not the success before our eyes to persuade us of it? Su pose, writes Ferrero, that Hannibal had conquered, as he certainly came very near doing; would not the historians and the philosophers have shown how absurd it was to imagine that an army ef which the generals were chosen by | popular vote, and who were changed every few months, could cope with a | force wielded under such an iron dik tutorship as Hannibal's? In politics, as we forgive everything but failure, so we pardon anything that succeeds. And we reason back from the success, of which the real causes are intricate and obscure, to some mere accompaniment, and then erect that into a canon of political activity. For con crete illustration, take the Hearst can didacy for Governor of New York It would be as ludicrous as it is disgust ing were it not that a specious argu ment from success can be made out in its favor. Hearst as a possible Gover ror would not be thought of by the wildest dreamer, or the most gullible ro nance-fed errand-boy, in this city, had le not run for Mayor last year and polled 200,000 votes It is those votes which paralyze the reasoning power and dazzle the imagination, and lead even good men, not ignorant of Hearst's char acter and motives, to say, “Well, there must be a great moral force in him somewhere, otherwise he would not have come so near being elected.” It is the religion of success at work. The actual! causes of the great Hearst vote in this city were diverse and subtle. The cam paign fell on a time of political up heaval. Unrest was in the air; revolt in men’s hearts. Scores of thousands struck out blindly with the Hearst weapon, as they would with any club that came handy, not greatly caring that it was soiled. But we are to be lieve all the 200,000 devoted to munici- pal ownership, imposed upon by what has been aptly called the Hearst “yel- ling peril,” taken in by his pose against the corporations; and we are gravely told that his canvass marks the begin ning of an entirely new era in our poll tics! Yet if his vote had been but 20 000 instead of 200,000, none of these things could be true. Those who would hold themselves steady against these insidious fallacies of political success should take a long look before and after. It is a tonic thing to remember how many great successes in their day have become the gigantic failures of history—the bursting rocke! of the evening only the refuse in the re

Page 8

114 Nation. The [Vol. 83, No. 2145 gutter the next morning. The pro-slav- ery politicians were for years the most si ccessful men going. They had every sign of popular approval—the votes, the offices, the honors, the money. But they are sunk stars. Gone, too, and despised are explosive and passionate movements that had, in their little hour, the prom- ise of sweeping everything before them the Grangers, the Knights of Labor, the Populists. How long will it be be- fore Hearst and Gompers are as forgot- ten as Denis Kearney and Powderly? The real religion of success must be based upon real success. And to the latter, reasoned principle and _ stanch conviction are as essential as they ever were. All the hysterics and the shame- less self-advertising cannot change that. And the worshipped causa victriz of to- duy may prove to be really victa, when history and the sober judgment of man- kind finally get at it. PELIEF WORK AT SAN FRANCISCO In the confusion which followed the catastrophe at San Francisco, it was not to be expected that a system of re lief could be instantaneously devised and applied which would meet the de- mand for both speed and precision. At first, the latter consideration had to be suerificed to the urgency of the primal wants of 100,000 men, women, and chil- dren: and in the act there was no doubt u percentage of waste. The tremendous pressure caused many small leaks. But now, three months later, it may fairly be stated that the thousands who gave to the various relief funds may rest as- sured that their main object was attain- ed and that, broadly speaking, people in the stricken city have not suffered for luck of food, shelter, or clothing; that there has been no serious waste; and that, as a result of generous assistance and the faithfulness of those in charge ot a bewildering and thankless task, there Is now available a large sum—more than 5,000,000—for substantial and carefully constructive relief work. Three weeks ago, the Rehabilitation Committee began giving money away with a discreet hand at the rate of about $10,000 a day. Some 2,000 families had applied for assistance up to July 27, and of these nearly 1,500 were helped to re- establish their homes or businesses with grants varying from $25 to $900. Of the first $104,249 thus disbursed, $35,000 vas In unsecured loans, $600 in secured loans, and the remainder was given out- right. Of the total amount accounted for In the first report on these particular operations, $45,000 was credited to “household reéstablishment” and $28,500 to “business enterprises.” Possibly, had this distribution been begun earlier, much of the somewhat bitter criticism in San Francisco of re- hef methods would have been forestall- ed, and a debate about “scientific char- ity” avoided. It was natural that West- ern and Eastern ideas should clash; but, as between the lavishness of the former and the caution of the latter, a fair middle course has been adopted. The petty depredations, always more picturesque than serious, such as the disappearance of a van-load of whiskey, or a consignment of some other relief supply, may be left to the local grand jury without further reflection than that the sneaks are always with us. Com- plaints of “red-tape” were {» vitable, and events have shown that “red tape” is not always an unmixed evil, especially when counterbalanced by a vigorous ex- pression of the idea that the victims of such a disaster were not to be treat- ed as ordinary applicants for charity. In the conditions prevailing it would have been a miracle if there had been no dis- satisfied voices. But the broad assertion that the re- lief funds have relieved can be made without fear of contradiction; and the tentative plans remaining are on a large scale. They include the expenditure of $100,000 for a winter pavilion for the aged destitute; $150,000 for park shel- ters for the homeless, also for the win- ter; $500,000 for outright gifts to lot- owners to help them to rebuild; $500,000 in loans for the same purpose; $2,500,000 for cottages, houses, and flats to be sold at cost for cash or on the instalment plan. As the amount to be given away in cash or loans outright is $1,500,000, the sum of $5,250,000 is thus accounted for under six specific heads alone. Alike to the Red Cross, the army, the Relief Committee, the Rehabilitation Committee, and the Mayor’s Food Com- mittee is due praise for hard and effec- tive work, often under most disorgan- izing and discouraging conditions. In the practical task of the revival of the city, the professional politician, on the other hand, is increasingly present, with his schemes of “honest graft,” which may frequently be more honestly called blackmail. Something to this effect has already come over the wires: as when saloonkeepers who desire a license are prompted to buy all their glassware from one politician and all their whiskey from another. The field is wide and the genus San Francisco “grafter” is a resourceful kind of highwayman. These things, however, should not be confused with the relief work, and the thousands who have given help have apparently nu cause to fear that the native plun- derers have been able, or will be able, to gather up more than a few scrapsfrom the relief-fund table. But it will be well if the San Francisco editors cease to chastise any and all who, in the cause of progress, report the capers of the goats as well as the gambollings of the sheep. The leeches should not be protected from the widest obloquy by any false conception of civic pride. Nor should the greed of the labor unions, taking advantage of San Francisco’s necessity, be sparingly dealt with, any more than the kindred exactions of tar- ift beneficiaries. On the part of the refugees them- selves, whose nymbers are daily lessen- ing as they again become builders of a city, a prominent official observer re- marks: “There has been an extraordi- nery amount of patience, moderation, and acceptance of incidental hardships aud inconveniences.” With such testi- mony as this regarding the spirit even of the most unfortunate of the people, there need be little fear that the still serious problems of the winter and the longer future will not be sturdily, if only gradually, surmounted. WAVERING RUSSIAN AUTOCRATS. The news from Russia continues grave —grave in the events occurring, more gcave in the implications which lie be- hind. It is obvious that the rejoicing of the Government over the first compara- tive quiet of the country was prema- ture. The dissolution of the Duma was accepted with a calm which Stolypin declared reassuring, but which was in reality ominous. It was inconceivable that the people who, a year ago, com- pelled the Czar to grant the Duma, would tamely see him withdraw what they had wrested from him. If agita- tion and disorder and the general strike were efficient weapons in 1905, when dis- affection among the troops had not gone nearly the lengths which it has since reached, it could hardly be doubted that means of coercing theGovernment would be sought in 1906. Hence there should have been no surprise at the succession of protests, outbreaks, and mutinies. That they seem to have failed of their purpose, for the moment, argues no real breaking down of the national deter- mination. It seems evident that Stolypin’s pol- icy was impossible from the beginning. He called it “strong-handed reform.” It was to be a mixture of iron repression and liberalism. Now, an amalgam of that kind might avail in certain hands, but not in those of an autocracy. A Liberal Duma, working out into self- consciousness, and struggling for the rights of the people, might make tem- porary compromises of that sort, and still press on towards its goal, while the people would be reasonably content. But a tyrannical Government has to do one thing or the other—give up its power, or use‘it ruthlessly. Both in the philosophy and in the actual grasp of the situation, Gen. Trepoff showed himself a year ago s‘tperior to Stolypin. In his secret cir- cular to the police, he elected unhesi- tatingly the plan of Thorough. He said with much force, from the standpoint of #n agent of autocracy and repression: There is always a psychological moment, which, if not duly appreciated by the au- tee be haaienl SR AAC ARO Hon Se ene Cl AOC Ap alt ati

Page 9

August 9, 1906] thorities, paralyzes their action. If the military are not called out tn time or not to the right place, and if they are used hesitatingly, if a meeting is imprudently permitted, if the leaders in disorder are seized too late—all this is a proof of the weakness of the authorities, and even at times of their complete incapacity. We do not say that such a policy could have succeeded this year any more than last; but it was the only policy for a Czar, talking of his “Imperial will” as the sole basis of law or popular rights, to adopt. Whatever “psychological mo- ment” existed for Stolypin, he lost in his wavering announcement that he would at once bayonet and- bless the Russian people. Even the reactionaries, it now appears, will none of his two- faced policy; and another Premier must be found. Stark and unsparing repression might have for a time suc- ceeded. Even in that case, however, the result of a Government triumph could only have been to revive Swinburne’s description of Russian absolutists: Those that crouch and shrink and shudder, girt with power— Those that reign and dare not trust one trembling hour— Those omnipotent whom terror curbs and drives— Those whose life reflects in fear their victims’ lives. That sort of terrified reigning by terror might have been for a time possible for the Czar after he had been nerved up to send away the Duma; but without the resolution to resort openly and every- where to blood and iron, he cannot ex- pect that he will have even a respite for any length of time. In fact, it may not be long before the Czar’s own nobles and intimates will be telling him that he confronts again the impossible conditions of last summer. They then went to him, a month before he issued his proclamation summoning the Duma, and informed him in the plainest language that he was guiding Russia towards ruin. They told him that distrust of the Government was universal, and that all its moral force had disappeared. The peasants, they de- clared, were taking the law into their own hands, “knowing that the authori- ties have neither prisons nor soldiers enough to cope with the whole popula- tion.” Under such circumstances, to postpone concessions to the people was only postponing a revolution which, by the very delay, would be only intensified in its “bloody remorselessness and mad ferocity.” Whether the great landlords and the nobility will have the courage again to utter these unwelcome truths to Nicholas, we do not know; but the course of events during the past few days has been thundering them in his ears. How long shall it be before American Sympathy finds an effective manner of expressing itself? There is, we believe, a committee in process of formation, and if it does nothing but voice popular Nation. sympathy, it will be of value. On the initiative of some London editors, Lord Frederic Harrison. George Meredith, the Rev. Stephen Gladstone, and many others have signed a memorial to the Duma, which reads in part as fol- lows: Brassey, We have learned to admire the genius of the Russian people; the heroism of its sacrifices for freedom and ts sufferings in a long and painful struggle have touched the heart of every generous man The complete triumph of liberty in Russia, to which we look forward at ao distant date, lish and Russian peoples to give formal expression to the friendship already un- iting them, a friendship based on commun- ity of ideals, which must help to realize the aspiration of all good Europeans for a civilization devoted to peace But the Russians need more than mes- sages of sympathy. Think of the Jews. A writer in the Westminster Gazette says that “during the past week a stream of frantic telegrams has poured unceas- ingly into the Jewish communities of London, Paris, Berlin, and Washington —one long-drawn, terror-stricken cry for help from five millions of men, wo- men, and children threatened with fire, sword, and dishonor.” Day by day they face the danger of massacres, instigated for no other purpose than in the vain hope of “drowning revolution in Jewish blood,” as Plehve is reported to have said. If the sight of the Russian peo- ple in travail is not enough to stir Amer- icans, then the additional horror of the Jewish situation should} move _ every heart and also loosen purse-strings as soon as it is possible to say where funds should go.to aid in the work of relief and liberation. ATHLETICS FOR THE AGED. With the “silly season” in England has arrived the inevitable questionnaire, this time on the proper ages for the various outdoor sports. Professor Allbutt of Cambridge started the discussion by declaring that no one should be per- mitted to play golf until thirty-five, be ing capable before that time of the more vigorous games. According to this view, the active age stops, in Dante’s words, “midway in the path of our life.” A number of prominent British athletes, whose opinions have been tabulated and averaged, took a more hopeful view. Football, to be sure, should be dropped at the mere nonage of thirty, but hockey may be played till thirty-five, cricket five years longer, while one may row and play lawn tennis till sixty. These limits, naturally, apply to amateurs, and not to professionals, who frequently con- tinue into grandfatherhood with athletic value unimpaired. Waiving for a moment the grievous dictum that makes the ancient game of golf merely a solace for declining physi- 115 cal force, it is clear that these aver age ages of retirement are In a manner misleading. Did not the great cricketer, W. G. Grace, celebrate his sixty-eighth birthday recently by making seventy- four runs? A few years ago, when the friends and admirers of the eminent scholar, Dr. Frederick J ed to signalize his seventieth birthday, they could think of no more suitable gift than a fully rigged double scul! and it is safe to say that few even of the younger subscribers Furnivall, wish could = safely | have engaged to pull bow to his stroke will at length make it possible for the Eng- | from Richmond to Teddington. Nor should we forget that other septuagenar- ian who not long ago beat his youth ful record in walking from Philadelphia to New York. Evidently, there are some who pass these not only with impunity, but with posi tive benefit. But for the generality, the figures may afford a rough and ready guide. Yet the question of retirement is, after all, a two-fold one. fancy, is theoretical dead-lines A sport, we very rarely given up for hygienic reasons. We drop out not be- cause the recreation has ceased to please or the exercise to benefit, but because our game begins to go off. Finding our- selves at a disadvantage with the young: sters, overhearing that we play well “for our age,” we decide no longer to cum- ber the field. Thus, on a punctilio, many ® sportsman takes really a farewell premature of his favorite pastime. We judge that the table given above is based rather on a sense of what is good for the sport than for the individual play- er. Fortunately, the scale admits of a gradual descent to senility by way of golf, which knows no age limit, but merely regards the grave itself as a sort of nineteenth hole. Some have said that when all else failed one might at least hold a tiller, but the case of the gen- tieman who was stricken last week at the wheel of a friend's yacht, hints that the cockpit is no safer than the putting green. For golf as an old man's game. there is unquestionably much to be said. It requires that abundant leisure which in the active years demands some apology: it deals gently but firmly with those or guns immediately below the diaphragm, whose torpidity is the very sign-manual of approaching eld. It may be taken up without risk by anybody who can walk two miles in one hour; and it may be relinquished without that omi- nous going off physically which dropping the more active games often entails. But in the case of golf, too, one must face the inexorable dilemma of what is good for the player and for the game. There is no doubt that golf is good for the old gentlemen, but how good are they for golf? In the way of suppression or manipulation of scores, they are prone t» set an awful example. They are giv- en to threesomes and to sociabilities en

Page 10

116 Nation. The [Vol. 83, No. 2145 route that delay the progress of all fol- lowing they are not above small evasions, being averse to the “sand iron,” often “dropping for one,” when a true golfer goes down into the pit. Old men have been detected teeing up by mutual consent in the bunchy sea- son of early frost. In short, their at- titude is generally opportunistic, and few of them are above the suspicion of playing merely because it is good for their health. A doctor’s prescription lurks in the pocket where the score- card should be. Were golf restricted to men over thir- tv-five years, according to Professor All- butt’s decree, we should still retain many of our best players, but what a.loss of idealism there would be in the game! We have hinted already that the severi- ties of the code are maintained chiefly by the effort of high-minded youth. Even more, the too much discredited ideal of “form” depends upon mastering “stance” and “swing” in tender years. The stern fact of repeated victory by players who have no form to speak of has given the game a go-as-you-please quality. Yet we presume there are a few faithful who still regard the often-beaten Findlay Douglas as the most finished American golfer—the model and exemplar of graceful and effective play. No one whose muscles have stiffened—assured- ly, no one whose stomach has “gone down"—1is likely to master this admira- ble slashing style, the possession of which is almost more than that of infi- nite mugs and medals. Golf emphatically needs the old men, quite as much as they need it; but it also needs the steady infusion of young blood, if only that the beautiful style of the “old school” may not utterly yield to the stodgier me- chanics of middle and later years. matches: A COLONIAL AUTOCRAT Sypney, July 5 It can seldom happen that the passing away of a colonial public man is an event of sufficient moment to deserve the atten- tion of readers at so great a distance; but the death of the Premier of New Zealand, a fortnight ago, occurred under circum- tances so awe-inspiring, almost so tragic, and he was himself so striking a person- ality, with a career so remarkable, that a noticeable blank would be left in these let- ter recording the political evolution of the Australasian colonies, if it were quite ignored. Mr. Seddon had been officially in- vited to visit Australia, as a sovereign might have been invited, and from the day that he landed in Sydney till he took his departure, he was féted like a king on a royal progress He was banqueted; he made innumerable speeches; he was inter- viewed by the representatives of every pro- gressive movement; he honored Australian institutions by merely visiting them; and he wound up by negotiating a treaty of commerce between the commonwealth and New Zealand. Then, when the steamer that bore him away from these shores was hard- ly out of sight of land, the indomitable will that had never once in a lifetime re- laxed its grasp, gave way, and, like Scott’s Queen Margaret of Anjou and many an obscurer individual, he fell suddenly dead. It was the most glorious of endings—a “death at Trafalgar.” The ship that was carrying him back in triumph was con- verted into a funeral barge—‘‘Home they brought their warrior dead.”” He was laid to rest on a commanding eminence, look- ing down on the scene of his legislative vic- tories, after an international funeral, in which England and the United States, as well as Australia and all New Zealand, may be said to have participated, and where the dramatic laments of the Maoris for their Great White Father were blend- ed with the heartfelt grief of a whole peo- ple It was the colonial parallel to the exequies of Gladstone—as Sir James Stephen insisted that the old Latin word should be written. Mr. Seddon was wont to say that the colonies did not sufficient- ly honor their distinguished men. They have signally falsified the saying in his own in- stance. They idolized him in his lifetime and are worshipping him in his death. Three memorable lessons, out of many, may ‘be drawn from his extraordinary career. Mr. Godkin has impressively remarked on the revolution that took place in Ameri- can politics when education and social standing ceased to be required of candi- dates for a legislature. Mr. Seddon was a member of the Ministry that marked the accomplishment of a similar revolution at the Antipodes. Till 1891, New Zealand ministers had usually been distinguished for academic rearing, social rank, or emi- nent public services. The theory involv- ed was then apparently supplanted by an- other theory—that every citizen is fit to be a legislator, that every legislator is fit to be a minister, and that every min- ister is fit to be premier. At all events, ministers were now first chosen from the rank and file. The results were startling. An itinerant dealer became premier, and projected a daring policy of State social- ism A Highland shepherd became Min- ister of Lands, and took the first steps or strides towards the nationalization of the land. A journalist became Minister of Labor, and established a system of indus- trial arbitration. These were great achieve- ments, but they were all destined to be eclipsed by the exploits of the Minister of Works, who carried still further the Socialist policy of his predecessor, closely linked his colony with the fortunes of the Anglo-Saxon race, and raised New Zealand to be the second country in the empire after the mother land. Richard John Sed- don seemed an unpromising person to be the executor of such a programme. Suc- cessively an engine-driver, a storekeeper and a publican, he was but half-educated and wholly devoid of culture. In earlier days he had probably never read, and could not read a book. In later years he rose to the level of colonial periodicals, but never to that of literature. Talent he seemed to have none. It was long before he could properly express himself. His style of both speaking and writing grad- ually improved, but to the last his Eng- lish was often bald, clumsy, and uncouth, and he never possessed the faculty by which Gladstone and Disraeli, Webster and Clay, exalted every topic they touched up- on. What made him the man that he be- came? The same things that made Abra- ham Lincoln one of the greatest of Amer- ican Presidents—the acquisition of power and the assumption of responsibility. He issued victorious out of every battle that he fought, and the strength of every ri- val he defeated entered into him. Acci- dent had made him premier, and accident continued to befriend him. Like Crispi, he gained consideration at home by ac- quiring prestige abroad. He was the first of the colonial premiers to set foot in England on the occasion of Queen Vic- toria’s “diamond jubilee,”’ and he captur- ed the British public by his aplomb, the vigor of his utterances, and the robustness of his character. Coming back to New Zealand aggrandized, he was acclaimed “King Dick,’’ another Richard the Lion- heart. Serious illness threatened him, but, heroically battling down two strokes of pa- ralysis, he showed an unbroken front to his enemies. Indeed, opposition gradually died away, and he was kept in office by overwhelming majorities. Albert Sorel and other historians have shown from a mass of contemporary evi- dence that Napoleon tyrannized over France with its own consent. Mr. Seddon despotized over New Zealand with its cor- He wielded unlimited authority. The whole political machine was moved by his will. As the English secretary of state was originally the pri- vete secretary of the sovereign, the colon- ial secretary in British colonies was orig- inally the private secretary of the gover- nor. Introducing a species of political atavism and substituting himself for the governor, Mr. Seddon converted his col- leagues into his private secretaries. Their measures, their bills, their appointments even, were his. He held two successive gov- ernors—English noblemen!—under his sway, neither of them venturing to oppose any of his demands; and he wrote of “my government,” as the governor used to speak, and as the King of Spain still speaks. The recent history of New Zea- land furnishes the most striking proof of the proposition that, under the forms of parliamentary government, a free country may be ruled as Bismarck ruled Prussia, or even as Metternich ruled Austria. It was in perfect consistency with his domestic policy that Mr. Seddon should be the chief fugleman of colonial jingo- ism. In his first speech in England he sounded the keynote of all the speeches afterwards made by the colonial premiers. He intimated that, if danger threatened or war broke out, England would “find the colonies behind her.”’ He offered their sup- port to the Motherland and virtually en- couraged it to plunge into war. The declar- ation was duly noted, and the South Afri- can war was engaged in on the under- standing that the colonies would take part in it. But for their unflinching advocacy and interested participation, it might never have been undertaken, and it would cer- tuinly have languished. The injury Mr. Seddon thus inflicted on his native land was grave and doubtless irreparable. He lived long enough to regret it. When the importation of Chinese to the gold mines of the Rand was sanctioned by the British Gevernment, he plainly informed it that, if the retrograde policy was persisted in, dial codédperation. Sr a ee oe Ean un Hi

Page 11

Bs bprnegen eit * eee ts = inate mania 2 ie EF gern cae bart ire NO dP ee ee ee August 9, 1906] there would be “a revulsion of feeling.” It was too late; the mischief had been done. Hegel stated, and, sorely against his will, Mommsen proved, that the conquest of the provinces had reacted injuriously on the constitution of Rome and the Roman character; while Zeller has shown how deeply it corrupted the old Roman religion. The reaction of free colonies on the motherland should make for freedom, and in general it has so made; but in one or in two directions it has been disastrous. It has nursed the passion of conquest, and it has not fostered the sentiment of pub- lic justice. In his last days Mr. Seddon declared that he was neither socialist nor anti-so- cialist. Misusing a word which, with its congeners, “humanity” and ‘“humanities,’’ has been often abused, he dubbed himself “a humanist.” His sole public end, he asserted, was to promote the well-being of his fellows. It was no idle boast, if good intentions only were reckoned; but his methods were those of Socialism. Leave out womanhood suffrage and a stringent licensing act, which he passed at the point of the bayonet, and one continuous scarlet thread is perceived to run through all his measures. They substituted the collective action of the State for private enterprise, individual or associate. He strengthened the system of State industrial arbitration. He repurchased vast tracts of private lands, which are partially retained by the State. He established old-age pensions— his masterpiece. He added a life-insurance branch to the Government fire-insurance department. He built hundreds of work- men’s cottages, with the result of inflat- ing the market price of the surrounding land and thus defeating his own object. And he announced a gigantic scheme of na- tional annuities, which was to place the coping-stone on his political career. It will be laid by other hands, but the adop- tion of his measures by one Australian State after another shows that, if an am- bitious minister desires to gain and hold fo. a lifetime the secure tenure of auto- cratic rule, he should initiate and pursue a policy of State Socialism. J.C. Correspondence. JEWISH SYMPATHY FOR ANIMALS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Authorities go and authorities come, but authority abideth forever, was my involuntary exclamation when I read the brief notice in the Nation (No. 2142), regarding the callous attitude of Judaism and Christianity toward the “little broth- ers” of men. The authority of Schopen- hauer is invoked for the unqualified state- ment, that these two religious systems were oblivious of duty toward dumb crea- tures. When a modern writer inclines to pick a flaw in the mentality of a mediaeval predecessor, he charges him, as a rule, with blind adherence to authority. The reproach is, that before the modern spirit of inquiry was abroad, all moot points were settled by merely quoting the dictum of some great man. Apparently we are no better off to-day, unless it be an advance to swear by Darwin rather than Moses, or = have Kant crammed down our throats in- stead of St call it other than blind adherence to au- thority, to rest satisfied with an ex cathedra statement by Schopenhauer, that Judaism Paul. For my part, I cannot has no regard for the feelings of the brute creation. If, instead, the elementary method of con- sulting the Bible itself were adopted, we should find reason to wonder at the abun- dance of legal provisions, rather than their paucity. The humane institution of a day of rest embraces the beast of burden in its beneficence; the fourth commandment bids cessation from work on the Sabbath for the sake of one’s cattle. A still more charac teristic expression of feeling is in the verse that forbids the muzzling of the ox while he Nation. 117 {We gladly give space to this inter- however, while alluding to Schopenhauer did not erect him into an authority, nor was any at tack made ethica.—Ep Nation. ] esting letter. Our note upon Jewish THE HOUSING OF EMPEROR WILLIAM'S GIFTS TO THE GERMANIC MUSEUM To THE EpiTorR OF THE NATION: Sin: The New Yorker Staats-Zeitung, in an editorial of July 7, stated that the manner in which the gifts of Emperor William to the Germanic Museum of Harvard Univer- sity had been received by the Harvard au- | thorities seems to show that the Emperor's he is treading out the corn The Jewish | law, however, goes farther; it prohibits castration, and thereby imposed great sac rifices upon an agricultural community But the highest degree of tenderness and sympathy with brute life is implied in the Biblical guard the relation of the mother animal injunctions that recognize and to the offspring; a nest may not be robbed of the dam and the fledgling birds at once; a cow or ewe and her young cannot be slaughtered for a sacrifice on the same day; and three times the Mosaic law warns against seething the kid in its mother’s milk. So much for the Biblical law As for post-Biblical Judaism, if it knew no such institutions as Societies for the Preven- tion of Cruelty to Animals, the reason may be that they were made superfluous by the stringency of the law. The strangér de- ‘ sirous of sojourning among the Jews had | to take upon himself a minimum of ob- servance, and this minimum included the prohibition against rending a live animal and eating its flesh, a demand so rigorous that the early Christians laid stress upon it (Acts xxi. 25). The rabbis would not failed of proper For, it said, in generosity had entirely recognition in this country effect, these splendid casts of monumental German sculptures were stowed away in a dusty old barn; and as for making use of them for the study of the history of Ger- man art, that was entirely out of the ques- tion, since nobody took any interest in them As long as these perversions of. truth were confined to the columns of a single ignore newspaper, I thought it best to them. Now, however, I learn that a recent dispatch of the Berlin correspondent of the London Standard reports that these state Berlin papers, and have led to a good deal of in ments have been copied in the dignant comment on American ingratitude for German favors, and to the expression of the hope that the Emperor would in the | future refrain from such acts of generosity towards America Under these circumstances, I consider it my duty to declare that the accusations of the Ntaats-Zeitung are absolutely false and sheer fabrications. The building in which | the collections of the Germanic Museum are permit animals to be tortured even for the | purpose of obtaining medical remedies. Except as a measure of self-defence, the | chase is unthinkable in the Jewish system About a hundred years ago, a very wealthy Jew’ plied a celebrated rabbi, Ezekiel Lan- dau of Prague, with questions as to whether the prohibition against hunting could not be modified in some way. The rabbi gave reins to his astonishment, that a Jew could desire to take the life of dumb creatures wantonly, and esteem it a pleasure at that temporarily installed is small and unpre- tentious, but it is admirably lighted and well adapted for exhibition purposes. Every one of the monuments exhibited (including the gifts of the German Emperor) is brought into clear view and can be studied in all its details. No one is more desirous than the Harvard authorities of having a | sufficient sum of money raised for the erec- tion of a large and monumental museum | | i That the law was not a theory, but the | practical and direct expression of the pop- | ular conscience, is demonstrated by legend and proverb. A pious husband and wife long remained childless They begged a | for this fund; repeated efforts have been made in this direction. The latest of these efforts consisted in collections for an “Emperor William Fund,” intended as a permanent endowment for such a building About $25,000 has thus far been subscribed building; and but we need more than ten | times this amount before we can think of saint who chanced their way to pray for | | stead of reviling what has been accomplish- the removal of the curse from them. He answered: “If you will so place the water- ing trough that even the young chicks can quench their thirst, you will have cause And so it was punishment for for complaint no longer.” sterility had been their heedlessness in the treatment of the ani- mals under their charge. And the whole case for Judaism, which has not been half stated in the above, was pithily compress- ed into one sentence by the wisest of kings: “A righteous man regardeth the life of his beast” (Prov. xii. 12). LOUIS GINZBERG Jewish Theological Seminary of America, New York, August 6. breaking ground. It is very much to be de- sired that the German-American press, in- ed thus far, should help us in carrying out these wide-reaching plans, As to the interest taken in the museum by the public, it is sufficient to say that since November, 1903, the time of its formal opening, the museum has been visited by some 70,000 persons, although it is regu- larly open only on two entire days and two afternoons of the week mediw@val German sculpture are regularly given in the museum to advanced students A handbook describing in detail the objects exhibited is at present in the press and wili appear shortly. KUNO FRANCKE. Harvard University, August 6. Lectures on

Page 12

118 The Nation. STUDY FROM THE NUDE To THE EpiTorR oF THE NATION: Sin: The recent seizure in New York on a warrant sworn out by the secretary of the Society for the Suppression of Vice, of a publication of the Art Students’ League entitled the American Student of Art, sug- gests some considerations that appear to be too often overlooked in connection with the study of the nude figure in academies of art Whatever may be the need of practice from the nude for the exceptional few who have capacity and elevation of mind enough to make proper use of it, such practice is in no way essential in the training of the average student of art. Considered as dis- cipline, for any ends that these students can compass, the study of any other natu- ral organic form is as useful as that of the human figure. The student who .does not find beauty in a spray of leafage will not perceive it in the Venus of Melos. But, however this may be, there can be no justification for parading in public the crude effigies of inelegant naked academy These belong in the students’ portfolios, if anywhere. They are not works of art, and have nothing to commend them to publie attention, while as mere display of nudity they justify the action that has been taken It is only when chastened by exalted feeling, and the highest artistic treatment, that the nude in art is ever justified. The nudes of academy students, and of the rank and file of professional painters, seldom rise above the coarseness and uncleanness models of those of Parisian Salons. CHARLES H. MOoRE. Harvard University, August 4. Notes. Harlow N. Higinbotham, who was for many years a partner of Marshall Field, has prepared a book on “The Making of a Mer- ehant,” which will be published in Sep- tember by Forbes & Co. of Chicago. Dr. Hugh Black, who is coming to New York to occupy the chair of Homiletics and Pastoral Theology in Union Theological Seminary, has ready a volume of sermons which will be issued by Fleming H. Revell Co Next week Henry Frowde will publish Mary Wollstonecraft's “Original Stories” for children in the Oxford Library of Prose and Poetry. The volume will contain the five illustrations by William Blake, and an Introduction by E. V. Lucas We have so often pointed out the ex- cellent features of the First Folio Edition of Shakapere, edited by Charlotte Porter and Helen A. Clarke, and published by Thomas Y. Crowell & Co., that nothing re- mains to be said about the latest volume containing “Twelfe Night, or What You Wwill.”’ Frederic C. Howe, whose book, “The City the Hope of Democracy,” was recently re- viewed in the Nation, has a new volume ready, called “The Confessions of a Mo- nopolist.”” Two of the chapters were pub- lished last year in the World's Work as “Confessions of a Commercial Senator.” The [Vol. 83, No. 2145 work as a whole will soon be issued by the Public Publishing Company of Chicago. John Addington Symonds’s “Walt Whit- man, a Study,” is published by E. P. Dut- ton & Co. in a single small volume. It is a curious contrast to turn from Symonds’s panegyric of Whitman to the somewhat embarrassed attitude of Whitman toward his admirer, as shown in his recently print- ed conversations with Horace Traubel. Burke's works are to occupy six volumes in the World's Classics, published by Henry Frowde, the first volume being now before us. To compress into a single book of pocket size the four treatises, viz., “A Vindication of Natural Society,” “The Sublime and Beautiful,”” “A Short Account of a Late Administration,” and ‘‘Observa- tions on ‘The Present State of the Nation,’ ” means pretty small type, although, as in all these volumes, the page remains quite readable. Judge Willis furnishes the Gen- eral Introduction. E. P. Dutton & Co. have ready for pub- lication a volume whose title runs: “Em- pires and Emperors of Russia, China, Ko- rea, and Japan; being notes and recollec- tions of Monsignor Count Vay de Vaya and Luskod.”” The English publisher, John Murray, has added a preface in which he relates the Count’s signal work for the Catholic Church in remote places of the earth. Another book announced by E. P. Dutton & Co. is a volume of fifteen sto- ries by George Gissing, called “‘The House of Cobwebs and Other Stories.”” This com- pletes the edition of Gissing’s works, and contains a long introduction on the author by Thomas Seccombe. From the autumn announcements of G. P. Putnam’s Sons the following titles may be noted: “The Ohio River,” by A. B. Hulbert; “The Connecticut River,” by E. M. Bacon; “Romance of the Italian Vil- las,”” by Elizabeth W. Champney; “Cathe- drals and Cloisters of the South of France,” by Elise W. Rose; “Winged Wheels in France,”’ by M. M. Shoemaker; “The Story of Old Fort Johnson,” by W. M. Reid; “Hunting Big Game,” by -W. S. Thomas; “On the Great American Plateau,” by T. M. Prudden; Mrs. Gaskell’s Works, Knuts- ford Edition; “Madame de Staél to Ben- jamin Constant,” unpublished letters and other mementos; “Essays of Sir Leslie Ste- phen,” in eleven volumes; “The Censor- ship of the Church and Its Influence Upon the Production and Distribution of Litera- ture,” by G. H. Putnam; “Shelburne Es- says, Fourth Series,” by P. E. More; “A Literary History of the English People,” vol. ii., part i, by J. J. Jusserand; “The Poetic Movement in England,” by Stopford A. Brooke; “The Gate of Death’; The Heart of Hamlet's Mystery,” by Karl Wer- der; “Tacitus and Other Roman Studies,” by Gaston Boissier; “Thomas A Kemp- is and the Imitation of Christ,” by J. E. G. de Montmorency; “Montaigne” and “Moliére,” in “French Classics for English Readers”; “‘The Life of Goethe,” vol. ii., by Albert Bielschowsky; “Princess and Court Ladies,’ by Arvéde Barine; ‘The Greatness and Decline of Rome,” by G. Ferrero; “Five Fair Sisters,” by H. Noel Williams; “George Herbert and His Times,” by A. G. Hyde; “David Garrick and His Circle,” by Mrs. Clement Parson; “Me- moirs of Comte de Rambuteau,” by George Lequin; “History of the People of the Netherlands,” Part iv., by P. J. Blok; “Ma- dame Recamier and Her Friends,” by E. Herriot; “The Roman Empire,” by H. Stu- art Jones; “Gettysburg and Lincoln,” by H. S. Burrage; “The Union Cause in Ken- tucky,”” by Thomas Speed; “A Spinner in the Sun,” by Myrtle Reed; “A Draught of the Blue,” by F. W. Bain; “Shibusawa,” by I. W. Adams; “The Sword of Wealth,” by H. W. Thomas; “The Saint,” by A. Fogazzaro; “‘The Man of Property,”” by John Galsworthy; “The Culture of the Soul Among Western Nations,” by P. Raman4- than; “‘The Evolution of Religions,’ by E. Bierer; “The Acts of the Apostles, etc.,” by H. P. Forbes; “‘The Hebrew Religion to the Establishment of Judaism Under Ezra,” by W. E. Addis; “The History of Painting,” by R. Muther; “‘The Develop- ment of Modern Art,”’ by J. Meier-Graefe; “English Coloured Books,” by M. Hardie; “Enamels,” by H. H. Cunynghame; ‘‘Gold- smiths’ and Silversmiths’ Works,” by N. Dawson; “The Essentials of Aésthetics,” by G. L. Raymond; “History of English Furniture,” vol. iii., by P. Macquoid; “The Power to Regulate Corporations and Com- merce,” by F. Hendrick. In pure literature the “Life and Letters of Lafcadio Hearn,” now definitely an- nounced by Houghton, Mifflin & Co. for the autumn, ought to be the most entertain- ing volumes we shall have for many a day. Mrs. Elizabeth Bisland, the author, knew Hearn intimately for nearly thirty years, and had the advantage of seeing him in many of his different environments. The bulk of the two volumes is given up to Hearn’s correspondence during a period of thirty-five years. Hearn was a volum- inous letter-writer, eloquent and witty, and his personality had that idiosyncrasy which makes such writing interesting. Bordeaux has bethought herself that she once had a mayor named Michel de Mon- taigne, and, as a municipal enterprise, has undertaken a definitive edition of the “Es- sais,”” of which the first volume has ap- peared. The complete text is, of course, to be given, and variations of type are to show the epoch to which each passage belongs; while notes will register the most trifling variants. Professor Strowski of Bordeaux University has editorial charge. The Quarterly Review comes out strong in history and government and rather weak in pure literature. In the former division it ranges through a review of “England in the Mediterranean,” ‘Northumberland,” “John Knox and the Reformation,” “The Oxford Movement,” “The General Election in France,” and other outlying subjects. Perhaps the article that will arouse most argument, at least among a certain group of readers, is Robert Dunlop's “Origins of the Irish Race.” According to the general view we are told to regard the ancient Irish as a homogeneous race, of Celtic ori- gin, who brought to Ireland their own arts and institutions, and developed them unin- terruptedly until the arrival of the Danes and Anglo-Normans arrested and finally put an end to a civilization which other- wise might have grown to something great and permanent. To each of these state- ments Mr. Dunlop opposes a direct nega- tive, with a fairly formidable array of ar- guments: “First, then,” he says, “there is every reason to believe that the ancient Irish (using the words in the sense of Dr. TAR Sart ap pores

Page 13

Poe at Be r pelts PO ane s : PWC areas, August 9, 1906] Joyce) were not a single, homogeneous, nor in the main a Celtic people; secondly, we have good grounds for concluding that when the Celtic or, more probably, Celti- berian conquerors arrived in Ireland they ‘ound the inhabitants of the country in a comparatively well advanced state of civili- zation; thirdly, there are good reasons for regarding the Celtic or Celtiberian con- quest of Ireland as the work of a relatively small body of invaders, resembling the Nor- man conquests of England and Sicily; fourthly, there is little doubt that Irish Christianity and what is called ‘late Celtic’ art are essentially Eastern in their origin and have little or nothing to do with Rome or Constantinople; fifthly, there is little question that the Danish invasions (apart from mere acts of piracy) served rather to develop Irish civilization and increase the chance of national unity than the reverse; and, finally, we hold that Irish civilization perished of its own effeteness and inability to stand against a superior and more high- ly developed civilization.” The Edinburgh Review for July contains three articles on French subjects, all, in one way or another, interesting. One deals with Alfred de Musset, devoting a good deal of space to the now sufficiently vulgarized episode of the poet and George Sand, but giving it some relief by a clever contrast of the two characters. George Sand the writer of the article calls a “Byronic woman with un point of Ibsen’’—a capital phrase. A second French paper is on Descartes as the “Representative Philosopher,” taking up a number of recent books on the subject by Miss Haldane and others. “He sought,” says the article, “to be alone rather in- teriorly than exteriorly; perhaps, on the whole, he preferred the solitude of the Hall to Eblis to the solitude of the desert under the silent stars.” The writer necessarily dwells on the famous Cogito, ergo sum, but he does not point out clearly how the over- intellectualism of modern philosophy starts with this false emphasis of cogito, and how much of the egotism of modern litera- ture is forshadowed in the sum. A third French paper, on “Illuminism and the French Revolution,”” we may pass over. The Library for June offers a symposium of contributions to the memory of Richard Garnett, the keynote being very happily struck by Austin Dobson: Of him we may say justly—Here was one Who knew of most things more than any other; Who loved all learning underneath the sun, And looked on every learner as a brother. Nor was this all. For those who knew him knew, However far his lore’s domain extended, It held its quiet ‘‘Poet’s Corner’’ too, Where mirth and song and irony were blended. The other writers recur to the same traits: his kindliness, the universal scope of his learning, his happy gifts as a writer in prose and poetry; and the feeling of per- sonal loss is notable everywhere. Mr. Pol- lard suggests the possibility of evolving by codéperation a sort of composite biogra- phy (which would be different from and on a higher plan than the ordinary biog- raphy)—lest “his reputation may attract to itself many of the Joe-Millerisms of libra- rianship.” Alexander Hill takes a some- what new angle of the fiction question in his article on ‘Responsibility for the Public Taste.” He takes the ground that the in- experienced reader needs protection against bad and stupid writers, who, he says, have y . German The Nation. opportunities denied to the public speaker. “Is the public the best good for its moral and intellectual health?” Mr. Hill thinks not, and he has a seventeen years’ experience as chairman of the Na- tional Home Reading Union to back up his | assertion. Librarians, he holds, should be not only receptive, they must, if they understand their responsibilities, be ag- gressive in attracting attention to what is good. Mr. Hill suggests three means of do- ing this: “‘(1) the display of books bearing | upon subjects which are at the time occu- pying the public mind; (2) talks on books by persons who know their subjects, and who have taken the trouble to look out the books in the library which will enable oth- ers to follow in their steps; (3) the forma- tion of public reading circles, meeting in the library, for the purpose of codperative study and discussion.” Reinhold Begas, probably the greatest sculptor, having just seventy-fifth birthday, the press is full of stories of his rich interesting career friend of make Chancellor's passed his and Bismarck’s, he had of him A personal several statues death, for sittings Im- occasion to before the which Bismarck gave like every one eyes of the him some with those wonderful blood iron, Begas exclaimed once as he worked “Your eyes, your Highness, are as if they could gaze upon several countries and over- look everything!” “Overlook retorted Bismarck; “that is not ment to pay to a diplomat!” before Bismarck’s death, Begas at Friedrichsruh to get a final impression of Germany’s most striking figure, before beginning work on the great Bismarck monument voted by the Reichstag. When Begas stated his mission, Bismarck replied: “Gott, why do you wish to set me a great Represent me as being on When they parted, Begas, feel- final for this pressed, else, man of Ten weeks appeared monument? crutches!” ing that the farewell world, the Chancellor waved him off, embraced him with deep feeling was and then In connection with the celebration by the University of Turin of Cesare Lombroso’s jubilee, his daughters, Paola and Gina (Mme. Carrara and Mme. Ferrero), pub lished a little volume giving a modest ac- count of their father’s life and work A chapter containing details of his rie intime has amusing stories. there a better impersonation of. the traditional savant—absent-minded, whimsical, frank, kindly, and always dwelling in the moon On one occasion in Rome, being without an overcoat and being instructed by his daughters to buy one, he was found in the streets with a huge and shapeless bottle- green affair, dragging after his heels, which he had blinkingly purchased from an un- scrupulous street peddler Tales of the enfant terrible order are told of him. Once his daughters were very reluctant to go with him to call upon a stupid lady of their acquaintance. Lombroso finally per- suaded them to go, and then burst out as follows to their astonished hostess: “I have had the deuce of a time in getting these foolish girls to come with me. They always do dread being bored! But I pro- mised them that we should hurry to eat some of your cakes, and then go away im- mediately!” Never was judge of what is | j and | | unique part in our 119 Charles Edward Garman, professor of philosophy at Amherst College, has f ‘ quarter of a century played a somewhat American academ ~ tem. To “publish,”’ to pursue “original vestigation,”” has during that time been the ideal that most of his compeers have aspired to; but he, with as good capa for that sort of thing as any of them. ha unswervingly devoted all his ene being an lishing’’ has the use of his successive classes Ths inspiring teacher; and ! only been of pamy sults have been extraordinary in t} fect, not only or the intellect, but character of those who have com: his influence. His pupils, many of w are now academic personag: of im; ance, have thought fit to ex; gratitude, admiration Festachrift on the and affectior by a German pattern, put lished by Houghton, Mifflin & er ed ‘Studies in Philosophy and Psycholos and dedicated to Professor Garma w he portrait forms its frontispiece The tl teen essays which the volume contals ire of first-rate importanes but too var and in some cases too technical o call for detailed notice here the philosopt t perfodicals will doubtless do them justice Meanwhile the editors have printed, as a | sort of introduction, without the knowl | edge of Professor Garman a long } ter, written by him many years ago which his views of the way to teaecl pl everything,” | a compli- | | tried to kiss Bismarck’s hand, but | osophy and of its réle in manly educat are vividly expounded The philosoph class-room is for him the place par ex celence in which a young man may acquire confidence in his own reflective judgments He thinks that the crisis of intellectual self-reliance in the individual may, with proper pedagogic skill, be brought on there, and may make him immune for life against weakminded imitativeness As in the breaking of a colt, there is one grand opportunity, which bad teaching may for feit, but which good teaching will secure and protectively vaccinate, as it were, the | student's future mental character Profes sor Garman’s own account of his methoda is delightfully original. The whole volume, full as it is of able and should suffice to show that a Iifs striking matter, modestly consecrated to what nowadays seems the half of a reap its meed of fame less fashionable “professor's” functions, may yet and burst, in spite of itself, into the wider publicity It should serve as encourage ment to the pure teacher the world over Berlin newspapers contain warnings against a literary thief, Erich R. Salbey, a young man from Erfurt an author, but seems so far to have who calls himself signed his name only to other people's work. One of his latest of whose lished over his own name. When accused Salbey at first denied the abused the accuser, admit his theft. ed by Erfurt newspapers, pected that his name will from Kiirschner’s “‘Literaturkelender,”” in which it should never have appeared The Mohammedan College at Aligarh ts one of the most interesting educational victims is a Viennese writer, two book reviews Salbey pub- charge and only subsequently to He has also been expos and it is ex now disappear institutions in India, not only on account of its marked success, but because it is aa unmistakable indication that the Indiag

Page 14

120 Mohammedans are awakening to a realiza- tion of their position and responsibilities. Founded in 1875 by a great reformer who, convinced of the evils attendant on a pure- ly secular education, determined to unite religious instruction based on Islamic ten- ets with the secular learning of the West, it has 700 students from all parts of India, Burma, and Persia. An extensive area is covered by the college buildings, consisting of quadrangles of students’ rooms, a mosque, central hall, museum and library, as well as a field for athletic sports. The rooms are divided into blocks, each under the care of a proctor. To develop the higher nature three student societies have been formed. The Anjuman ul Farz, or Duty, is to assist poor students, mainly by collecting funds to establish scholarships. rhe Brotherhood of Purity has for its aim the encouragement of manly morality. Last but not least is the debating and lit- erary society, in whose clubhouse the best English periodicals are eagerly read. The way in which the Mohammedans are re- guarding it may been seen from what a lead- ing Indian notable, the Aga Khan of Bom- bay, said of it in a recent address: “We want Aligarh to be such a home of learn- ing as to command the same respect of scholars as Berlin or Oxford, Leipzig or Paris And we want those branches of Moslem learning which are too fast pass- ing into decay to be added by Moslem cholars to the stock of the world’s knowl- edge And above all, we want to create for our people an intellectual and moral capital; a city which shall be the home of elevated ideas and pure ideals; a centre from which light and guidance shall be diffused among the Moslems of India, aye, and out of India too, and which shall hold up to the world a noble standard of the justice and virtue and purity of our beloved faith.” The practice and even the methods of latter day political criticism—muckraking, the unwise it call—are by no means new, is is attested in that journalistic miscel- lany “The Olivia Letters” (Neale Publish- ing Co $2) Writing in the winter of Ik67 from Washington, Mrs. Emily Edson Iiriges describes the descent of that grave historian, James Parton, upon the capitol- ine lobby “James Parton, the distinguish- ed magazine writer,” she learns, “has been here for everal days.” He had been seen on the floor of the House, and also in consultation with many leading mem- bers of Congress; but anticipating the late Senator Gorman’s tribute to the calling of Congressional page Mr Parton had also consorted with doorkeepers, messengers, page and all others who are supposed to be wise and serious when talked to in re gard to “a certain very delicate subject.’ The cause of the inquiry was “that Mr Parton ia preparing an article on the Washington lobby.” This monster of truly hideous mien “Olivia” proceeds to charac terize in terma which suggest that the Oc topus metaphor, too, ia of a most respecta- ble antiquity. She rejoices that Mr. Parton “ia going to hold up the monster in the broad light of day—this creeping, crawling thing. which, In more respects than one, bears a strong resemblance’ to Victor Hugo's devil fish.” The curious may still read Parton's exposure of the lobby in “Topics of the Times,’ where it stands as The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2145 a reminder to our more vociferous censors that the public interests may be subserved with a very moderate expenditure of ink and a merely gentlemanly supply of de- nunciatory rhetoric. The Celtic revival has been rather less active in Scotland than in the other Celtic- speaking lands, but it appears to have borne fruit there in the increased study of place-names and local traditions. A good deal of material on Scottish Gaelic nomen- clature has been brought together in recent years. Besides a number of articles in the Transactions of the Gaelic Society of Inverness and in other periodicals, we recall a book by W. J. N. Liddall, on the names in Fife and Kinross (1896), one by J. M. MacKinlay on the influence of the pre- Reformationchurch onScottish place-names (1904), and another in the same year by W. J. Watson, on the names in Ross and Cromarty. G. F. Black of New York has printed in the Caledonian short specimens from an extensive collection of material which we believe it is his intention to pub- lish. And now we have received from the firm of David Nutt in London a volume on the place-names of Argyll by Dr. H. Cam- eron Gillies, known already as the author of a Gaelic grammar and of articles on Gaelic medical lore. The chief service of these investigations has been in ascertain- ing and making accessible the facts with regard to actual local usage. For in this matter the official surveys, with their half- anglicized spellings, give very untrustwor- thy indications. The information is ob- viously fundamental for all study of the etymology of the names, and Dr. Gillies has taken great pains to make his collections for Argylishire accurate. In the examina- tion of documentary evidence concerning the earlier forms of names he appears to bave done less than Mr. Watson. Many doubtful names cannot be satisfactorily dealt with until such historical data have been generally collected, not only for Scotland, but also for Ireland, of which we under- stand that the Rev. Edmund Hogan of Dub- lin has in hand a great onomasticon. Dr. Gillies’s discussions of etymologies are not always lucid in exposition, or, in our opin- ion, sound in method: We are a little puzzled by his statement (p. 23) that one of two explanations of a name is “possible,” but that the other is “correct.” And we cannot agree with all of his derivations. We do not believe, for example, that machaire and oirthir are compounds of tir (as stated on pp. xxiii. and 3), or that aird is cognate with the English “earth” (p. 2). The first volume of A. H. Leahy’s “Heroic Romances of Ireland’’ was recently review- ed at some length in these columns. The second volume, now in our hands, contains five stories of the type known as “‘cattle- spoils,” which constituted a favorite class of sagas among the ancient Irish, and dealt with what was doubtless a common inci- dent of their tribal life. The great le- gendary struggle between Ulster and Con- naught turned upon a cattle raid, and the saga which narrates it, the principal tale of the oldest Irish cycle, is entitled “The Cattle-Spoil of Cooley” (Téin Bé Odalnge). With this great 7'din there came to be as- sociated a number of introductory tales (remecéla), some of them having little or no connection with the central story, and it is five of these lesser tales of cattle- spoil which Mr. Leahy has translated. They are all, in different ways, good ex- amples of the best period of Irish saga- writing. Mr. Leahy’s method in transla- tion differs from that employed in the first volume, where he rendered the Irish prose by prose and used verse for the metrical passages only. In the present case he has made a verse translation throughout, al- though the originals are almost wholly in prose, and he has supplied a literal prose rendering on the opposite page. We pre- fer his first method, for we are still doubt- ful about the value of his metrical ver- sions. His verse, while acceptable enough in an attempt to reproduce for English readers the cante-fable structure of the original, has no particular charm or power, and a somewhat diffuse metrical paraphrase does less justice, in our opinion, to the Irish than a close translation in idiomatic English prose. Unfortunately, the prose which accompanies the verse in the present volume is, doubtless intentionally,so literal that it sometimes ceases to be English at all. Take a sentence like the following, which we quote from page 6: “Fifty sons of kings, this was the number of his house- hold, co-aged, co-similar to him all be- tween form and instruction.” A few pages of this to show the peculiarities of Irish styleand syntax—as in the case of the inter- linear translation in Mr. Leahy’s Appen- dix—may well be of service, but a volume of it seems to us hardly worth while. In spite of the criticisms we have felt bound to make upon both Mr. Leahy’s volumes, we can commend them to English readers desirous of getting at the substance of some of the most interesting productions in Irish literature, and we believe they will help make the real nature of that literature bet- ter understood. Under the general title “The Church Universal,” a company of Anglican schol- ars propose to issue a series of eight small volumes dealing with the history of the Christian Church from the beginning to the present day. The volume now ap- pearing is “The Church and the Barbar- ians; Being an Outline of the History of the Church from A. D. 461 to a. D. 1003,” by the editor of the series, the Rev. Wil- liam Holden Hutton, B. D. (The Macmil- lan Co., $1.) To include the recital of the fortunes of Christianity, both Hast and West, political and doctrinal, during five and a half centuries, within two hundred pages, means altogether too great con- densation. Mr. Hutton is overwhelmed by the multiplicity of his facts, and one feels in reading his pages that one is examin- ing a skeleton, not following the develop- ment of an organism. The ecclesiastical bias of the writer is somewhat too evi- dent. No opportunity to prove that the Church is “a divine institution with a continuous life” is neglected. The author is fully persuaded that the great Councils simply defined the faith which was de- livered to the saints, and that if they had failed to define it just as they did— one person, two natures, two wills—*‘it would have been dissolved little by little by sentimental concessions and shallow inconsistencies of interpretation.” Church history of this sort certainly will not unsettle any one’s faith, nor will it con- LEVIN SOME ORE apis 1 fairs —_ - —_

Page 15

aay pp ese? tern August 9, 1906] vey a real appreciation of the struggles through which Christian doctrine came to be. The latest volume to be issued by the Royal Historical Society is “State Trials of the Reign of Edward the First’’ (Lon don: Royal Historical Society, Chancery Lane). The editors, Prof. T. F. Tout and Miss Hilda Johnstone, have made use of “two plea rolls preserved in the Public Record Office, containing the official pro ceedings of the trials of the judges and other royal officers, before a special com mission appointed by Edward I. in 128% This trial of the judges for breach of trust and general perversion of justice is a dramatic incident in the legal history of mediwval England. For more than three years prior to August, 1289, the King had been in Gascony. On his return he found the land filled with protests against those who had represented the Crown during his absence. Determined to find out whether the royal confidence had been abused, Ed ward appointed Burnell, his trusty chan- cellor, John de Pontoise, Bishop of Win- chester, Henry Lacy, Earl of Lincoln, and four other men of irreproachable loyalty, a commission to take evidence. Thomas de Weyland, chief justice of common pleas; Ralph de Hengham, chief justice of King’s bench; Adam de Stratton, a leading official of the Exchequer; William de Brompton, a judge of common pleas; Solomon de Rochester, a justice on eyre; William de Saham, a judge of King’s bench; Henry de Bray, justice of the Jews, and several les- ser personages were disgraced. There can be little doubt that the King was actuated to make the inquiry by just motives, but the size of the fines and the willingness of the Crown to accept satisfaction through payment of money, would indicate a desire to kill two birds with one stone. The episode is more striking than the docu- ments which contain the official records. Prof. Tout, with truth, calls them dull, and there are also large gaps. The chronicles of the period—Hemingburgh, the ‘Flores Historiarum,” and the “Annals of Dun- stable’—refer with their usual exaggera- tion to the iniquities of the judges; but, as Miss Johnstone points out: “The record is almost as disappointing as the chroni- clers. In no less than 60 out of the 165 cases recorded in the shorter roll, the accusation is never given, or only vaguely given as ‘trespass.’”’ There Is, however, evidence that some, at least, of the judges used personal intimidation, be- sides giving open aid to friends through counsel and advice. By far the liveliest document in the volume is the ‘“‘Narratio de Passione Justiciariorum,” a satire writ- ten by some unknown clerk. The work of editing has been performed by Professor Tout and Miss Johnstone with care and erudition. The second part of M. René Dussaud’s “Notes de Mythologie Syrienne’’ (Paris: Leroux, 1905) comprises two-thirds of the entire 183 pages, exclusive of the index. Of the nine chapters in this livraison, eight appeared originally as articles in the Revue Archéologique, Revue Numismatique, ete. The first livraison contained but one chapter, dealing with the symbols and im- ages of the Syrian sun-god. The principal chapter in the second part deals with the symbols and images of the goddess consort. | The Nation. M. Dussaud concludes that Hadad, with his msort, Atargat and the child or chil- Simios nd Simia ime from Baby- lon, gained a fo ng at Hierapolis, and I ad v sy Palestine, and Phe ‘ In Syria proper, as at Damas is, ft example, the local divinities were mpletely a nilated with these gods In tl Roman period we have a new dif- fusion of Hadad and his consort, superim posed on the f nde the secondary form of the Heliopolitan Jupiter (p. 115) in a chapter on the Phenician Pantheon M. Dussaud undertakes to show, with a onsiderable degree of success, that the fragments of a Phenician cosmogony pre- rved by Eusebius from a translation, by Philo of Byblos, of the work of the priest Sanchoniathon, possess little or no value as a record of genuine ancient Phoenician myths and legends The Pheenician Pan- theon was practically the same every where at the head a solar divinity, the master, or ba'al, of the town and its foun goddess As group Sadyk and ler, and along with him the tarte There was also a second apparently of agrarian origin his son Eshmun-Adonis. M. Dussaud pre Aramm@an and Pheenician mythol itself in the sents the gy, particularly as it shows Greek and the Grmco- later period, the Roman. All his illustrations are drawn from coins and monuments of that period, and represent rather that official mythology, which was a hybrid of West and East the native and original religion It is cu- rious that M keen to detect and disclose traditional er- _— than Dussaud, who is generally so rors, should himself have perpetuated such an error In the chapter on Dusares, he has much to say of betylia, a word which he uses to indicate any sacred stone or pillar. From neither Greek nor Semitic an- tiquity (cf. Prof F. Moore, in American Journal of Archeology, vol. vii., No. 1), can such a use be justified The baitulos or betylion is a small stone, sup- posed to have fallen from heaven, to be George endowed with motion and speech, and to give oracular responses It has nothing whatever to do with the stones or stone pillars, set up by the Western Semitic peo- ples, which they anointed, worshipped, and kissed, and at which they offered sacri- fices. The story of Jacob’s pillar, and the similarity of Bethel to baitulos, led to the confusion of the two words and their dif- ferent ideas. This misuse of baituloa or betylion can be traced back only as far as the seventeenth century Harrison Grey Fiske has returned to this preparations for the production of ‘The Kreutzer adapted by Langdon Mitchell from the Yid- dish of Jacob Gordin. The part of the hero- ine is to be played by Bertha Kalich city to superintend Sonata,” Gen. Patrick Maxwell, who died recently at Bath, England, in the eightieth year of his age, was an Indian officer, who served brilliantly in both civil and military ca- and was famous as a linguist. He author of admirable metrical of Schiller's “Maid of Or- leans’ and “William Tell” and Lessing's “Nathan the Wise,’ and made a prose translation of Lessing’s “Minna von Barn- remarkable has been pac ities was the translations helm.” His version of the drama of ‘Nathan the Wise” | highly commended both by English and | German criti imong the former by 8 Theodore Mart who ngratala " on having given to Enelish literaturs as adequate an interpretation of that not work as could be desired The proclamation on behalf of M Arnold Daly that notwitl anding ? | court decision in his favor, he wil] neit? produce “Mrs. Warren's Profs self, nor permit any one else to d tokens prudence and a tardy appr n of the best public sentiment Possibly a higher tribunal might entertain differ: effect of M upon I ib! Views as to the didactic morals. Mr general Shaw's vulgarities Daly is said to entertalr conviction that there is a fortune in ¢} piece for any one producing it. He w probably find out his mistake | the venture As a matter of fac t? not much to be said against th thing on the score of immorality. If a | might have been body but Mr. Shaw had been the auth poesible to argue t} was written with a genuine though desper ately mistaken moral purpose. But the d cussion would be exceedingly tiresom ar unprofitable The play is unfit for the stage because it is offensive, because, un der the pretence of startling and slutary exposure, it grossly exaggerates perfectly familiar evils in a fashion that may gra ify the coarsest taste, but is powerl f good; because it applies to mod: edy the methods of an ancient. outw and clumsy melodrama; because It | ! void of artistic restraint, truth, or sincer } ity; because, in spite of all its verbal clev erness, it is platitudinous, coarse, and ob noxious The dramatic critic of the London World H. Hamilton Fyfe, in briefly reviewing the “The public is not, by any means, without in past London theatrical season, says telligence It goes to musical comedies because it must go somewhere, and be cause the managers who go in for this form of variety entertainment take pains to give playgoers an article worth their money. But if an equal number of man agers took equal pains and spent an equal providing good plays, the amount upon public would, undoubtedly, transfer its custom. We should soon see the musical comedy hitting the workhouse, as the American journals put it Here then, is the reason why so few good plays are produced. It is because the manag ment of theatres is chiefly in the hands of people who neither care for good plays nor would be capable of running theatres which made a specialty of producing them It is nonsense to say they would provide more intelligent dramatic fare if there was a demand for it Very wisely they kept to the only kind of thing which they like, and in which they can profitably traffic It would be as grossly unjust to blame them as it is to cast the discredit of our decadent stage upon the public Good things never come in answer to 4 demand. They are forced upon the world from above. If we had a few managers resolved to make the theatre a living force in our national life, we should notice a change very soon.” This is the plals truth. The public has no means of making any demand upon the manager. It can take what is offered or go without. In- mongers

Page 16

122 variably it selects what is good of its kind, making the best of a bad bargain. “DADDY” CRISP. Burford Papera Being Letters of Samuel Crisp to his Sister at Burford; and Other Studies of a Century (1745-1845) By William Holden Hutton, D.D. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co Mr. Hutton’s latest book, “Burford Pa- pers,”’ is a hybrid work in which some fam- ily letters of the eighteenth century form a prelude to numerous short essays on the period, 1745-1845. The essays are by Mr. Hutton, who also furnishes in a few local sketches the background The letters themselves are a fragment of the corre- spondence between Samuel Crisp, the au- thor of Virginia,” and his sister, Mrs Gast The title, too, requires a word of explanation For most Americans the chief association of Burford is with a lit- tle village nestling under the western edge of Boxhill Here in the inn whose French windows open on slopes of green velvet, Keats wrote “Endymion,"’ while the whole neighborhood isredolent withthe memory of William Blake, Disraeli, George Meredith, and other literary celebrities. But not amid the highlands of Surrey is Mr. Hut- ton'’s Burford. In Oxfordshire, as every one will remember who knows his Claren don and his Matthew Arnold, there is an- other Burford—the Burford of Burford l’riory, where once lived Lucius Cary, Lord Falkland, the apostle of “sweetness and light"’ in a generation which otherwise was disturbed by the flerce strifes of Pym and Strafford, Nehemiah Wallington, and Sir Nicholas Crisp. William Lenthall, Speak er of the Long Parliament, bought Burford l’riory from Falkland, and since that time the place has had no remarkable renown. But near at hand is the town of Burford, whose beautiful parish church is the chief architectural glory of the Cotswolds. And since in England past and present are closely woven to form the same rich web, with Burford Church is connected the name of William Morris Just thirty years ago he happened to be at Burford for part of a day when the church was “undergoing Scandalized, he sat down at once to propose the formation of a society “which might deal with such cases, and, if the destruction done by the restorers could restoration.” not be stopped, might at all events make it clear that it was destruction and not pres- ervation.”’ So much for Burford in gen- eral The application of this place-name to the present volume has been explained by Mr. Hutton in the first sentence of the preface “Such unity as these ‘Studies of a Century’ possess is due to all of them, I belleve, having been written either to or at a house at Burford in Oxfordshire.” The residence referred to is the “Great House’ where Mrs. Gast was living when she received the letters of her brother, Samuel Crisp, and where Mr. Hutton him self seems to be living now when not en- gaged in tutorial duties at St. John's Col- lege, Oxford Samuel Crisp, who is the most prominent of Mr. Hutton's eighteenth century figures, is not quite forgotten by the present gen- eration Dr. Birkbeck Hill knew all about him, as he did about every acquaintance of The Nation. Dr. Johnson; and those who are curious about the family affairs of Fanny Burney have often come upon his name. For the rest, Mr. Hutton compresses what is es- sential into two sentences: Samuel Crisp was a man of letters and fashion, who, in 1754, produced at Drury Lane his tragedy of ‘‘Virginia,”’ when Gar- rick himself played Virginius and Mrs. Cib- ber Virginia. That, for the world, was his title to fame, for the play, if it was not a first-rate success, was much talked of, and was published in the same year by Tonson. Descended from Sir Nicholas Crisp, who is alleged to have spent £100,000 on be- half of Charles I., the author of “Vir- ginia’’ had good social connections, and either at Chessington or London lived a peaceful, interested existence upon the fringe of the literary and _ fashionable world. His letters to Mrs. Gast, however, do not convey much gossip regarding either movements of thought or the personal hab- its of wits and authors. Those which are here published were written when he was an elderly invalid, a little nervous about his investments. The one friendship of interest which stands out in Mr. Crisp's epistles is that with Dr. Burney and his daughter. The Thrales, Dr. Johnson, Sheridan, and other celebrated persons, come in at intervals, but, save for the Thrales, without leaving a very distinct impression of Mr. Crisp’s attitude towards them. We have noticed no more brilliant incident than a dinner at the Thrales’, which seems to have been on a plane with the host’s wealth. I met a vast deal of company at Streat- ham, wher¢ everything was most splendid and magnificent—two courses of twenty- one dishes each, besides Removes: and after that a dessert of a piece with the Dinner—Pines and Fruits of all Sorts, Ices, Creams, &., &., &., without end—everything in plate, of which such a profusion, and such a Side Board: I never saw such at any Nobleman’s. A most Gracious Reception, and such pressing invitations to stay as I could hardly escape; but I got away, and reach'd home by 9 o’clock, and glad I was to creep again into my own Nest.” A passage of somewhat greater intrinsic interest (p. 72) relates to the effect pro- duced by Cornwallis’s surrender at York- town, upon the mind of a small investor who is afraid of losing his principal. To compare small people with great, it re- calls Darwin's fear lest the discovery of gold in Australia should be the ruin of his children by lowering the value of his in- vestments. ‘“‘At present,” says Mr. Crisp, writing on December 29, 1781, “the pros- pect is dreadful. In times of such horrible Danger hardly anything but hard Gold seems secure, and the growing In- terest seems scarcely an Equivalent for the Risk of the Principal.” If Mr. Crisp may be called a star of small magnitude, his sister Mrs. Gast is hardly more than a speck in the Milky Way. She was good to the poor, disliked Non- conformity, was a friend of Molly Lenthall at Burford Priory, and was praised by the local newspaper in an epitaph which, from its length, could not have been put upon any ordinary tombstone. Miss Austen might have found material for a character in Mrs. Gast, but untouched by the spell of another's genius, she seems a common- place person. For biographical zealots, she enjoys the advantage of having flourished in the eighteenth century and corresponded with the author of “Evelina.” Samuel [Vol. 83, No. 2145 Crisp, by the way, thought that the emolu- ments drawn by Miss Burney from litera- ture came very easily. Apropos of the sum paid for “Cecilia,” he writes: “A pret- ty Spill (£300), for a young girl in a few months to get by sitting still in her Cham- ber by a good Fire!” Mr. Hutton’s essays are much better reading than Mr. Crisp’s letters, and de- serve well at the hands of all who love the eighteenth century. In one of them it is pointed out that the Oxford don of the present day knows much more about foreign literature than was known by his predecessor of a hundred years ago. Inci- dentally, Mr. Hutton’s own essays bear out this statement. They draw inspira- tion from many sources, and though writ- ten by a clergyman of the High Church party, are informed with a cosmopolitan spirit. Whether the subject be Raphael Mengs, the Stuarts in Exile, the life of Bath, or the minor poets of the eighteenth century, there is always an adequate fund of information. That the touch is not heavy may be seen from a single characteristic sentence, which occurs in one of the pa- pers on Bath: “Here Wesley preached, and Burke meditated, and Anstey satirized, and every person we have ever heard of—ex- cept Hannah More—gambled.” On the whole, the best section in this diversified volume is a group of eight studies “On the Religion of a Century.” We have styled Mr. Hutton a High Church- man, and he is not unwilling to amuse him- self at the expense of Whig ecclesiastics, like Bishop Watson of Llandaff and Syd- ney Smith. But his prepossessions do not make him disagreeable, while at times they add spice to his criticism of latitudinarians. His feeling for John Wesley is sympathy and admiration, heightened perhaps a lit- tle by the circumstance that the great evangelist looked upon himself to the last as a member of the Church of England. RECENT GERMAN FICTION. A distinct reaction against morbid tendencies may be observed in much of the recent German fiction. Kurt Martens, the author of the “‘Roman aus der Dekadenz,”’ and other stories which ranked him with the best novelists of the modern school, bas just published a new book which de- serves some notice. ‘‘Kreisiauf der Liebe” (Egon Fleischel & Co., Berlin) has for sub-title “the story of the better man,” and is a charming piece of still life, with just enough of narrative in it to keep up a steady interest. The local background is provincial, the intimate miliew of the hero being a quiet bachelor home, regu- lated as much by the set official duties of the “Herr Assessor” as by the pedantry native to him. Yet there is a flavor of idealism throughout, and there are pas- sages of a delightful humor. The opening scene is unique—with the sonorous bass of the Herr Assessor dramatically declaim- ing in his office a love poem which has just come from his pen, while the com- plainants, defendants, and witnesses are waiting for him in the corridor of the court building, and the officers on duty whisper to each other, “the Herr Asses- sor is writing poetry.”” The character of the dear old-fashioned Assessor Nothaas stands out against this background in OTR ee ce i ERR AAG REMI:

Page 17

bu Aerie, PARDON sfenae August 9, 1906] The Nation. strong, clear lines. It is plain from the outset that he is not a match for his friend Karstens, the artist, with the tra- ditional egotism and Bohemianism of genius. As a whole the story is a great relief after the pictures of morbid psy- chology in which Martens formerly in- dulged. The reaction is even more distinctly em- phasized in a story by Georg von Ompteda, ‘“‘Normalmenschen,” published by the same house. Obeying the voice of duty, the hero, a lieutenant in the army, s0 normal as to be almost commonplace, renounces an innocent love affair with a girl of humble birth and slender purse, and in the hope of advancement marries a girl of wealth and connections. But his abilities are in no way remarkable, and he is not promoted. The simple, straight- forward and unadorned way in which the author tells this story has an indefinable charm. Ompteda is a master in the por- trayal of German military types, of the impoverished nobility, and of the unmar- ried middle-class woman. His style is clear and easy. Quite another spirit reigns in “Ingeborg,” by Bernhard Kellermann (S. Fischer, Ber- lin), whose previous work,. “Yester und Li,” challenged attention and caused him to be looked upon as a writer henceforth to be reckoned with. This is a story of sentiment and passion in so fanciful a set- ting, as to call forth the question, whether it is not a romance of some remote period. There is no breath in it of the workaday world, but a holiday spirit, and an air al- most of sanctity. The hero is all purity, justice, and love. The woman is a more tangible creature, a child of nature, a woodman’s daughter with the voice and the artistic instincts of her dead mother. Of course there is a third, their friend, a poet, who leaves when he sees danger of disturbing the idyl. Yet the end comes, without bitterness, without jealousy, with- out a dramatic climax. The tragedy is not in what is done, but in what is felt. The book is a record of intense emotions, of genuine sentiments, but not of nerve- sensations. It is fanciful, perhaps ex- travagant, but it is sound throughout. There is for the most part a real charm in the author’s language, although he sometimes lapses into the staccato movement of the modern school. “Schwuele Tage,” by E. von Keyserling (S. Fischer, Berlin), is a volume of three remarkable short stories, amply justifying the title Sultry Days. “The first story “Harmonie,” is one of nerves. There are the healthy nerves of the hero, who would enjoy nothing better than a little work in the fields on his own estate; but such work is distasteful to his wife, who has the diseased nerves of her maternal an- cestors. The return of the husband to his home, only to find that his wife’s ailment has estranged them, is a fine bit of dra- matic impressionism. There is grim humor in the description of the family dinners which pass off like important social func- tions. There is even a suggestion of sa- tire, when the convalescent outlines the programme for the evening: crab soup, snipes, pain d’ananas, champagne, twilight in the blue room and the nightingale. Primitive instincts and primitive customs are the burden of the second story, “Die Soldatenkersta,” which depicts humorously one phase of recruit life. The book re- ceives its title from the third story, which like the first begins with a return. A college boy, who has failed in examina- tions, is forced te spend the summer alone with his father in the large manor house, while mother and sisters are away on their vacation. Father and son had always stood aloof from each other. Now the boy begins to study his progenitor, and in do- ing so picks up the threads of a romance which links his young cousin to the elder- ly man. The psychology is subtle, and re- minds one of the manner of our Henry James, who as yet has not been discov- ered in Germany Gerhard Ouckama Knoop is a writer of some originality, but there is an irrita- ting diffuseness about his work. “‘Nedeshda Bachini’ (Egon Fleischel & Co., Berlin) is the story of a woman's quest for love, Madame is a widow of rather incongruous inter- a grotesque Odyssey of errors national descent, her views are broad, and she encounters many adventures, some se- rious, others humorous, which she duly confesses to a faithful trio of brotherly friends. A number of books which seem to be the direct products of a Rosegger school have recently appeared. One of these is Max Geissler’s ‘“‘Huetten im Hochland” (L Staackmann, Leipzig), a splendid story of mountaineer life, near the Bavarian bor- der Simple life and simple mahners there is nothing complicated about’ the characters or the plot. The fate of these people runs its straight and plain course, logical as the operation of nature's forces With their strong untutored instincts they work out their own destiny, be it good or evil. A unique situation is presented in the chapter where Wenz am Kreuz meets the woman who had jilted him to marry another. The hour in which she refused him he had stopped his old clock and never wound it since Now that she is a widow her matter-of-fact nature sees no- thing wrong in openly courting him But he is of a more delicate fibre and her ad- vances kill the sentiment he has been cherishing for years. There are other in- teresting glimpses of simple soul life, as for instance the gradual blunting of the moral sense in a child not naturally a criminal. The nature scenes are almost equal to Rosegger’s. The stillness and the solitude of this snowbound world are ad- mirably suggested The same firm has published a new vol- ume of stories by Rosegger himself, ‘“Wild- linge,” which are full of the charm that has endeared the author to readers all over the world. It is the charm of sim- plicity and sincerity. Rosegger is to-day what he has been from the beginning: a woodland bird singing on in his untutored way and defying the subtle analysis of scholarly critics. So he describes himself in the preface to the new book: “If even to-day I am fond of calling myself the Waldbauerbub, it is only to call attention once more to the standard which is to be applied to my work; esthetically a low one, ethically a high one.” So the author, himself, a “‘wildling’’—why not use a direct transcription of the word he has coined? —tells in this volume some stories of his own crude youth, with many a reminis- cence of scenes and characters long trea- sured in his memory Nature finds in him an interpreter of almost solemn serious ness. It is sacred to him, for he se in it the work of the Creator “Ein Lied von ewigen Dingen is indeed a song of things eternal Others are remarkable for their humor, as the story of Naz, the country tailor, whose apprentice the author had been in his boyhood; and the story of the Vagabond known as the Waldteufe! THE INFLUENCE OF WESTERN EUROF! ON SCANDINAVIAN CIVILIZATION On the Fomorians and the Norsemen iy Duald Mac Firbis. The original Irish text edited, with translation and nots by Alexander Bugge. Christiania Caithreim Cellachain Caisil: The Vict us Career of Cellachan of Cashel. The orig! nal Irish text,- edited, with tra and notes, by Alexander Buge: Cl tiania. Vesterlandenes Indflydelae paa Nordbocrnes ydre Kultur, Levesat og Samhundsforhold i Vikingetinden. Af Alexander Bugge, Christiania Vikingerne: Billeder fra vore Forfadres Liv I. and Il Af Alexander Bugg Chr tiania The influence of Christian, and pa larly Irish, civilization on the Scandina n nations during the Viking age has long beet a recognized fact, and much valuable work in establishing the extent of th influ has been done by earlier Scandinavian h torian such as the Norwegian P. A Munch, who, with his wide learning and constructive genius, had a clearer ineight into this difficult question than many of his juniors; and the Dane, Steenstrup, who, in his epoch-making work on the “N mans,” has thrown a flood of light on early relations of the Scandinavians with Celts, Franks, and Anglo-Saxons Yet it was left to the youthful author of the works mentioned at the head of this article to go straight to the fcuntain-spring, and, by a thorough study of the old Irish language and early Irish texts, to gain the know!l- edge necessary for an intelligent grasp of the subject. The first two works named above are ed! tions of Irish historical texts, which, on account of their bearing on Norwegian his tory, the editor has chosen to render a cessible to a larger public by attaching an English translation, together with copious notes. The publication is at the expense of the Norwegian Government The last work in the list is a popular presentation, in two volumes, of the author's views and conclusions. Written as they are in an easy and interesting vein, these essays de scribe the social and political evolution of Scandinavia in a period which has not be fore been treated in a way at once saci entific and popular. Several of them, in deed, touching important phases of early English history, deserve translation into English. After the return of Fridtjof Nansen from his polar expedition there was subscribed in Norway “The Fridtjof Nansen Fund for the Promotion of Science,” which offered its first prize for a work upon the influence of western Europe on early Scandinavian, particularly Norwegian, civilization. This

Page 18

124 induced the composition of the third work under review. The author is the son of the philologist, Prof. Sophus Bugge, and is himself a professor of history in the Uni- versity of Christiania, having succeeded to the chair left vacant by the death of Prof. In about 400 octavo pages he examines the influence of western Eu- ropean civilization during the Viking Pe- riod on public administration (the royal Gustav Storm power) in Norway, as well as, less ex- haustively, in Sweden and Denmark, on dress, ornamentation and _ furniture, on commerce, ships and shipbuilding, as well as on the art of war, agriculture and cat- tle-raising, coinage, and pictorial art A final chapter treats the Norwegian colonies in Iceland and the Faroe Islands, and the influence of Irish and Anglo-Saxon civili- zation Professor Bugge shows that Harold the Fairhaired, in establishing a centralized royal power in united Norway, was guid- ed by the example of Charlemagne and his successors as well as by that of the Anglo- Saxon kings: and that this foreign influence exerted itself not only on the political but also on the social arrangement of his administration and his court Thus, his surrounding himself with a number of court skalds, or poets laureate, was in all prob ability due to Irishcourt customs, with which he and Norwegians generally must have been familiar through the connection between the people at home and the Norwegian kingdom in Dublin, then established for more than a generation, and ruled over by kings closely related to Harold himself In many re- aspects we are compelled to modify our former opinion of the Vikings as pirates and outlaws, a scourge to the countries visited by them They came to western Europe not solely on warfare bent, but more often as merchants, bringing the goods of south- ern and western Europe to the shores of the Baltic and the trading-places of Russia, and again bearing staples of the Orient to western Europe Norsemen taught other European nations the art of sail- ing the open sea without putting into port over night, as had been the cus- tom heretofore. Although the Vikings were good fighters, they had much to learn in cientifie warfare from the nations whose lands and cities they devastated; the em ployment of cavalry, in particular, they borrowed from their adversaries. In the same way they borrowed not only the art of fortifying cities—an art which the Norse- men in their turn introduced into Ireland but also that of besieging and assaulting fortified cities scientifically Colnage was unknown in Scandinavia be fore the Viking period, the imitations of Roman and other coins which were pre viously produced having served merely as ornaments, not as a circulating medium The firat money coined by a Scandinavian eema to have been that bearing the stamp of the Danish sea-king Haifdan, one of Lodbrok'’sa sons, colned during his sojourn with the great Viking army at London (871-872): but apparently the mint mas ters were Frankish rather than Anglo Saxon Coming to ornament, particularly on the runic stones, of which many have been pre served, chiefly in Sweden, it appears that these stones present striking similarities to Christian stone monuments in England, [Vol. 83, No. 2145 The Nation. and above all in the Isle of Man, which was conquered by the Norsemen, and where traces of Norwegian language and institutions are still found. This ar- tistic influence may have exerted itself through peaceful trade connections which existed from a very early period be- tween the Swedish town Birka (now Bjérk6 in the Mialar Lake) via Got- land, on one side, and English and Frisian cities (especially Dorestad, whose coins are found in great numbers in Gotland and on the mainland of Sweden) on the other. Taken as a whole, the works here briefly reviewed bear eloquent testimony to the learning, industry, and talent of the young author, filius preclaro patre dignus. OSCAR WILDE. The Life of Oscar Wilde. By R. H. Sherard. London: T. Werner Laurie; Néw York: Mitchell Kennerley. Whether there is any raison d’étre or not for a life of Oscar Wilde, the writing of such a biography is, at all events, at- tended with unusual difficulty. What can be told about the man, is already pretty well known, and there is little enough of it at best; whereas what is generally un- known, cannot be told at all. The result is that such a biography, as far as it is not impertinent, must be either a rather vague and unsubstantial apology, or else a bold and dashing denunciation. Of these alternatives, Mr. Sherard has chosen the former, and under the circumstances the choice is rather unfortunate. Not that Mr. Sherard is a partisan exactly; he is dis- posed to be fair and judicial. But as there is so much, in the nature of the case, to be suppressed, so much, too, which can be only alluded to, his book has a decided air of whitewashing. Nor is the effect entirely the fault of the subject and the circum- stances. Mr. Sherard’s tones are not quite clear; his moral philosophy is not quite robust and direct enough for the terrible problem of humar responsibility and error with which he has to deal; while he is still further confused by the distracting hubbub of creed and opinion which con- stantly dins the ears of the modern critic. As an apologist he is always in a frightful dilemma. He has to save his author’s wits at the expense of his character, or his character at the expense of his wits. So, for example, he represents Oscar Wilde the wsthete as no such fool as he seemed, but as merely posing for notoriety, playing “a double-faced réle” for the sake of the ad- vertising he might get out of it: He knew . . little about painting, and in the matter of furniture, tapestries, .wall papers, and architecture he was no more of a connoisseur than is any man who assimilates the current modes and the chatter of the arbiters. It is a fact that music bored him; it is a fact that he had no knowledge of any instrument; it is probable that he could with difficulty dis- tinguish one tune from another. Yet he was forced to pose as a connoisseur, and to speak and write about musicians and music with the alr of one who was profoundly versed in all the technicalities of the art. While on the other hand he seeks to excuse the errors of later life by a “psy- chopathia” analogous to that of the drunk- ard who is unconscious and irresponsible with regard to his worst acts: After each crisis Oscar Wilde seems to have been totally unconscious of having done anything bad, detestable, shameful, or even unusual. Under no other condition could be have maintained the serene and tranquil dignity which stamped him in his sane moments. Such consummate dis- simulation, where it is not hypocrisy—and Oscar Wilde was no hypocrite, could not be a hypocrite, was too arrogant to be a hypocrite—is invariably the concomitant of the worst forms of madness. And this of the man who has been repre- sented as a master of duplicity, playing his part for an easy celebrity! But the moral confusion and obliquity are increased by the writer’s scientific pretensions. “It is such a pity,”’ he com- plains in the midst of this very passage just quoted, “that people, because they are still under the stupid domination of the Church, will not approach these matters in a purely scientific spirit.”” It does not seem to occur to him that it is for the specialist alone that “these matters” are properly scientific; for most of us they are still moral matters, after all. And it is for this reason that his explanation of Oscar Wilde’s unpopularity with the re- spectable is so erroneous, scientific though it may be: There is much of the moping owl in a large section of our stolid Britishry, and people of that category dislike nothing more intensely than the man of radio-ac- tivity who bustles into the stagnate area of their gelid dulness, and interferes with their somnolent eupepsia. To be forced to think, to be forced to laugh, to be taught things, in one word to be inter- fered with. No! No! No! This may not be a favorable specimen of Mr. Sherard’s science or of his English, but it is fairly illustrative of the insecuri- ty of both; while as a consequence of all these causes of confusion he falls into a very unpleasant and misleading ambiguity of tone with respect to his subject in gen- eral, Oscar Wilde may have been a great talker; and, in default of any very large or solid literary residuum, it may be fair to argue that his reputation as a wit should rest mainly on that basis. But it is hardly decent, in such a connection, after remarking that “the greatest philo- sophers, the men who gave new relig- ions to the world, did not write; they talked,” to ask, “Did Christ write, did Mahound write, did Socrates write?” nor does it seem precisely in character to make the judgment of such a man a subject of unqualified pathos. At the same time, it should seem, there can be no doubt about Oscar Wilde’s charm when at his best, no question about his unusual gifts—and the writer has done well to set them in a strong light. But with all that there is moral confusion enough in the world al- ready without extending it to so plain a case. The True Story of Paul Revere. By Charles Ferris Gettemy. Boston: Lit- tle, Brown & Co. $1.50 net. It is one thing to break an image—a highly popular itmage—and another to plece it together again in a half-relent- ing way, and set it up on a pedestalof one’s own restoration. All this, and more, Mr. Gettemy has done, for the cracks and seams et NN al nace

Page 19

August 9, 1906] The Nation. 125 exposed in the character of Paul Revere do but render this worthy man more ap- preciable, humanly and historically, while his legendary virtues sink advantageously away. North End reared and taught, Revere was a seasoned Bostonian before the years of his true importance came to him on the threshold of middle life. He had by then followed his father’s trade of gold and silver-smithing, served as a soldier, been bound over to keep the peace for as- sault and battery, dealt in artificial teeth, and displayed some proficiency in copper- engraving, which he used in caricature, supplementing his art with the least no- table of his various achievements, patriotic verse. Dating from the Stamp Act period, Revere’s training in Boston affairs for some years had been shaping him into a revolutionist of a dis- tinct type. A Freemason, a Son of Lib- erty, with a relish for the mystery and excitement of secret meetings and town caucuses, he was so imbued with the spirit of American politics and its invariable de- mand for the quid pro quo, that we may allow ourselves to wonder to what heights he might have risen, or to what depths sunk, had it been Paul Revere’s fate to live a hundred years later. As early as 1773 he was known in the doggerel of the hour as “bold Revere,”’ and was ready, no doubt, in spite of the burden of a large family, for any venture which promised a risk He began to carry messages from the Committees of Correspondence between Boston and New York, and even Philadel- phia. “Steady, vigorous, sensible, and per- severing,” as Dr. Thomas Young called him, he did this work effectively and gained repute thereby. Mr. Gettemy’s interpretation of the Mid- night Ride is not Mr. Longfellow’s; but there is no destruction in his conclusion that Revere’s ride of April 16, to inform Hancock and Adams that the British were planning an expedition, probably to seize the stores at Concord, vied in importance with that more famous enterprise of two nights later. Left a widower with a well-filled quiver and soon remarried, Revere now began to make his service as a courier of patriot- ism profitable toward the support of his family; but, alas for the brightness of his laurels! his bills were not always audited for the amounts charged. The Massachu- setts Council cut his account for riding from five to four shillings a day, and even shaved his bill for printing money for the army. Mr. Gettemy cites other instances where the Government held that this pa- triot of many occupations was charging too high prices. Used to trading, it is prob- able that Revere regarded these financial criticisms as quite in the ordinary way of business, for there is no record of any protest against the economical moods of those who employed him; in fact, his true patriotism may have begun where his com- mercial spirit knew when it was best to stop. Of the several adverse happenings in his career, the severest was the charge against him of disobedience and neglect during the Penobscot Expedition under General Lovell and Commodore Saltonstall—an expedition as inglorious as the march of the noble Duke of York. Inactivity and desertion marked its short campaign. Persistently demanding a court-martial, Revere finally received this doubtful privilege, and was definitely if not triumphantly acquitted of the stigma of dishonorable conduct. Cow- ardice was little with his general character, that friendly court will probably satisfy the de- mands of historic As a soldier Revere made no mark; he was probably too pronounced a personality for customary discipline, though well fitted for adventure; his fame must rest on brilliant episodes so in accord this verdict scrutiny The war over, Revere, failing to get the coveted reward of heroes—a public office returned to the making of an honest live lihood. Mr. Gettemy says that Revere man ufactured gunpowder during the Revolu tion. This is a mistake. He did, however supervise the making of powder by one Evedon, and purchased it for the Govern ment. From powder to the founding of cannon was not a long. step, but it led to the establishment of a business substantial and creditable to the Revere family. Identified with all common interests of his day, with a fond natural of to various as ness for civic prominence, it was for Paul Revere freemasonry and to ‘“belong”’ to shine in the ranks sociations peculiar to the taste of the aver He the War of age citizen. survived 1812 during which he volunteered the service of | for with his fourscore years to help throw tifications. He died a few years later blemishes forgotten, receiving according to his Mr reserved but commendable study does probe deep, but it is truthful and scrupu in its intent. He over-stated his indebtedness to E.H. Goss's up honors deserts Gettemy's not has however, lous not, previous work. A suitable index, attractive half-tones, and Stuart's portrait of his sub ject, add to the value of the ume present vol- The Diary of William Bentley, D. D., Pastor of the East Church, Salem, Mass. Volume 1. April 1784—December, 1792 Salem The Essex Institute William Bentley was a man well known and widely honored in his day. He died in 1819, in his sixty-first year, after a pastorate of thirty-six years, leav ing a vast volume of manuscript re including sermons, letters, notes on natural history, meteorological observa tions, parish records, and his diary. A few sermons and addresses were published dur ing his life, torical notes have appeared in print from time to But his most important work, his diary, has remained the chives of the American Antiquarian Society of Worcester. By the coéperation of this society and the of Salem the first volume, covering a period of eight has been published in a sub- stantial of five pages It is prefaced with a brief biographical sketch, prepared by the late Judge Joseph G Waters, which recalls Dr. Bentley’s extra- ordinary linguistic attainments, his love of scientific historical pursuits, and the high which he was held by his own people, as well as by Presidents Adams Jefferson, each high office ter than any biography as a revealer of his true life. mains, and selections from his his time in ar Essex Institute years, now octavo hundred and esteem in of whom pressed him But the diary is bet- and to acc ept of a | | A diary, to be sure a dangerous thing for the reputation of its writer, especially if he resolve, as Bentley did, to write sor thing every day in the yea questioned if it is fair to proclaim upon the housetops what a man said to himself in the secret place of } liary The ex cellent Nathaniel Rogers, minister of Ips wich, required of } executor that } should burn his diary. evidently fearing the posthumous revelation of his inmost life to a critical world A deal of Dr. Bentley had been more wisely burned than put lished. It is a vast conglomeration of very miscellaneous material Much of it is of trifling significance, stories of excursions to his fishing and bathing ofa neighboring towns in the harbor, and commonplace annals quiet town. Much is gossipy and frivolo tales of his tea-drinkings and his petty landlady and new for recording variance with his He ‘ ndle as mong ers had a passion minutiw, and industry name fix highly of his and critic at parades his Boswell great Dr in He thought scholar, ures, and facts own talents as poet delive orded He of h strange and his the of the had a pedantic way of narra large, diary ances aa the obsejulious rec sayings Johnson ting some commonplaces in Latin or French snatches briefs of letters As ly jumbled with of poetry, ss moral reflections, and a literary composition, all this will prove a weariness of the flesh to the reader Nevertheless, this robust, Johnsonesqus parish minister is a very entertaining fle ure, a strong, kindly, though often sharp tongued, man among men He has pre served a vivid and valuable picture of the church life With loving attention to the smallest detail, he wrote down the name of all the people of his parish and much of their history Hot religious bickerings were the order of the da Young Bentley was a warm advocate of the new Unitarian creed. Universalism and Methodism were rising up in sharp rivalry with the old Puritan faith Anabapt New Lights, and “Hopkintonians” were as Apostles of itinerating tour the mselv« the new abroad ontroversial The putation, serting the order were on There were « disputes in papers fond of rancor spirit of the Methodist, preached tentley's reveals its but new diary writer sharpne of the famou di his were pl abs obably typical the and day Jesse Lee one in Salem evening that he large audience that 80 gener he In a news verdict was, ally disgusted a has finished his work in this town.” paper article he Cleveland of Ipswich" (the Chebacco parish, Essex), had calumniating Universalists “A “scarcely ever appeared.” the in disciples replied to “the infamous now who been the wretch,’ he says Anabaptists Beverly “immersing water and ignorance.”’ He rejoices in every more hardened were upon river their in thing that is opposed to Calvinism and tends to shake “the abominable doctrine of the Trinity.” Bentley's chronicles of the town are of great interest He went about the atreets remarking on the houses and other build ings and investigating the sites of ancient homes. He frequented the shipyards and the wharves Political affairs, too interested him. He deplored the prev alence of lotteries, which were ré sorted to by the State and by towns in be half of measures of public improvement

Page 20

126 The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2145 When the small-pox epidemic appeared in 1792, he began at once careful observa- tions of the value of the newly discovered inoculation. Taking large personal risks he visited hospitals, preached there on Sundays, and recorded full details of the of the disease. We admire this fine abandon of the man of gown and bands. We honor the scholastic spirit that led him to resolve “to insert a criticism of every work printed in America, within my much of its American progress knowledge, and as history as is convenient.” The genealogist will find much of value in the endless lists of names and vital statistics. The local antiquarian will wel- the topographical notes. A larger will find beneath the pedantries, the the jealousies, the strong life laborious, large-souled and come public trivialities, of an earnest, ympathetic man. Gothic Architecture in England: An Analy- sis of the Origin and Development of English Architecture from the Norman Conquest to the Dissolution of the Mon- asteries By Francis Bond, M.A., Lin- coln College, Oxford With 1,254 illus- trations, comprising 785 photographs, Sketches, and Measured Drawings, and 469 Plans, Sections, Diagrams, and Mouldings Pp. xxil., 782 London: B T. Batsford; New York: Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons. 1906. $12 net book. It is a very besides the preface, introduction, a “Chronology twenty pages long, illustrations, an index of “Index of Subject-matter Glossary.’ Besides the illustrations of the work there is of spires, a of plans of arches and through ground “springs,” sections through the jambs of doorways and jambs and mullions of and in these are immense number of those mould- are account chronology of English Gothic Archi- we repeat, a scholar’s book. from a thousand illustrations from the old Pugin, Parker, the as well This is a scholar’s octavo, full of English an index to larg having a rather Churches,” places, and an and a series in the body of plates series plers and sections through ribs similar sections courses and windows; Kiven an ings which made of so great im the tecture It is rhe material is drawn puree the book Brandon, Sharpe, Wickes, ent Colling, Johnson and rest, ind = fror writers j many ree the text from authorities, who are aguinat many fully There is original like had to reckon with in Hioomfleld’s book these columna; no ognized and balanced one another no pretence of that the rec ently which we of Mr reviewed in that knowledge, case claim of exemp- literary pro- for with tion from ordinary rules of duction which is sometimes asserted the practised artist, less familiar criticism than with production One approach only to practical knowledge is claimed by Mr. Bond: his work with photography. Indeed, he says that “it has been the writer's pleasant task to visit nearly every important church in Eng- land, camera in hand.” This work with the means a great deal of obser- vation, a great deal of prying into details, the constant of choice with re- to points of view and the truest ef- And so the camera exercise gard fectiveness of a composition. author has been able to study his subject, no doubt, while photography has also made it possible to include the wealth of illus- tration advertised in the title. A chapter is devoted to definitions, and the reader plunges at once into that con- troversy with Mr. Bond’s predecessors in the field, which is hardly to be avoided in a book pretending to encyclopaedic fulness. Mr. Bond is sure that “architecture is the art of building in general,” and will not hear of any limited definitions more re- strained because intended to be more ac- curate. However, the precise defini- tion of such great and comprehen- sive terms is as nearly impos- sible as any intellectual task can be. The word Romanesque is taken up, and Quicherat’s perfect and logical definition is dismissed at once (p. 6) as not explain- ing the whole body of the art—seven cen- turies at one effort and in twenty words. Then there is given the definition of Anthyme St. Paul, which is ingenious and critical, and embodies a brief history of early Christian architecture. Then come Viollet-le-Duc’s words about Romanesque, which are also historically accurate if not quite comprehensive enough, and this last formula is accepted by Mr. Bond, if we understand his meaning aright. But even here there is doubt, because a_ foot- note admits the extreme uncertainty which we know to exist as to whether the term Romanesque should cover many schools, Fast and West, or one school only. These doubts, once stated, leave us ready to re- ceive the impression of quite infinite un- certainty as to the meaning of Gothic; yet we welcome so much of certainty as that which binds the Gothic style inseparably to Romanesque as being the greater and more refined thing to which the cruder style led up. Chapter II. deals with the characteristics of Romanesque; four chapters deal with the characteristics of English Gothic; fifty pages in Chapter VII. present a “chro- nological history of the greater English churches” (a matter quite separate from the list of dated buildings mentioned above); and so with p. 145 begins Part II., and that which would seem to be the real subject of the book This part, divided into 34 chapters and containing 500 pages, of mediaeval in England; and the that the secondary title, as given limits the subject to the English churches for four centuries This analysis is pushed so far that the pillar or pier is treated as a principal subject in two chapters, and connection with the vault; itself, with its buttresses, seven chapters, and that other chapters are specially told off for the minor constructional elements on the one hand, and on the other hand for the great features of the plan—the choir, the neve, the galilee, the transept, eastern and western, the porch and the Chantry Chapel. We have, then, an all-embracing work like a cyclopmdia of a special subject, but arranged logically instead of by alpha- betical sequence. The danger here, as in other cyclopedias, is of omitting very im- considerations. How can the au- is a very complete analysis architecture reminded church reader is above, and a half. elsewhere in that the vault takes up portant thor and compiler be sure that every im- portant form of window-tracery and every important element in its growth and de- cline has been thought of and presented in its proper place? How can he guaran- tee it, and how can the reader feel assured that the mediwval capital, for instance, has been fully analyzed? These questions, however, are of little importance to those who consider that here is an enormous amount of matter, rather novel in its sources and certainly novel in its arrange- ment; that all this matter is made fairly easy of access by indices; and that, under any circumstances he, the student, would have to turn to other books—that no one work contains all the information which might reasonably be asked for. Greek Theories of Elementary Cognition. By John I. Beare. Henry Frowde. Greek psychology, in the sense of the doctrine of the “‘Soul,”’ is treated at large in the voluminous but uncritical work of Chaignet. Without committing himself to any dogma of “‘psychology without a soul,” Professor Beare, of the University of Dub- lin, has seen that “Greek Theories of Ele- mentary Cognition from Alcmzon to Aris- totle” is a much more definite and profit- able topic of study. As respects the ulti- mate problems of epistemology and the re- lation of mind to body the progress of science has added little to the speculations of the Greeks; and Plato’s “Theztetus,” rightly interpreted, says the last word far more effectively than either the physiologi- cal psychologists or the neo-Kantians of to-day can say it. It is still true that we do not, strictly speaking, see with the eye or hear with the ear, but through them. It is still “‘a monstrous supposition that a mob of sense-perceptions sits within us (like the Greeks in the Trojan Horse) not unified by the apperception of some central form, call it soul or what you will.” What Professor Beare has done is to set forth the theory of the five senses as it ap- pears in Alemzwon, Empedocles, Democri- tus, Anaxagoras, Diogenes of Apollonia, Plato, and Aristotle, supplemented by a dis- cussion of the common features of sensa- tion in general, and the Aristotelian doc- trine of the sensus communis. The texts of the Pre-Socratics were already collect- ed for him in Diels’ ‘‘Doxographi” and “Vor- sokratiker.” He has translated, para- phrased, and explained the relevant pas- sages, and so provided an interpretation which scholars must consider, and a trust- worthy book of reference for those who cannot use the originals. More interesting in continuous perusal are the concluding chapters on sensation in general and tke sensus communis, which present the sub- stance of the Platonic and Aristotelian psy- chology with the omission of Plato’s “proofs” of immortality, and the hopeless controversy concerning Aristotle’s doctrine of the noetic soul. Judicious as these limitations and the at- tempted exclusion of epistemology may be, the result is a somewhat distorted impres- sionof the true relationof Plato to Aristotle and of the real character of the Aristotel- jan philosophy. Professor Beare may not share, but his book will confirm, the pre- vailing idea that as Aristotle undoubtedly had more of the scientist's patient enthu- siasm for detail than his master, so his thought is more truly scientific than Plato's.

Page 21

Oe nt oweniwene sayy 7 August 9, 1906 | Yet in fact Aristotle's acceptance of the heart as the sensory centre is a distinct re- trogression from Plato’s teaching, and his doctrine of a common sensory is not so near the truth as we apprehend it, as is Plato’s reference of the intellectual and uni- versal element in sense-perception to the synthesis of the mind. The rigid separation of synthesis in sense perception from the synthesis of thought categories is the chief error of Kant, or of one interpretation of Kant. As Professor Beare himself admits (p. 260), “no psychologist has ever been able to answer satisfactorily the question where sense perception ends and thinking commences.”” Why, then, should he treat Aristotle’s confused and inconsistent theory of a common sensory as a distinct advance upon Plato? The historical importance of the doctrine justifies the interesting chap- ter which Mr. Beare devotes to it. But only the @ priori superstition of progress can treat it as a real step in advance. Mr. Beare’s scholarship is sound: He challenges Diels not unsuccessfully in the interpretation of Empedocles, and proposes (p. 321) an ingenious if unprovable solu- tion of thewell knowncruzrin‘‘De Memoria,” 452b, 17-24. He rarely errs unless it be where doubt is permissible. On page 51 the ref- erence Of éxeivwy ra@jyuara in Tim. 67c.-seg. should be not to rois ris bpews wépeow, but to ra depdmeva +. . dpa duminrovras Compare Tim. 43c, Ta Tav mpoommrévtwy waOjpara, and 61C. ra 42 wabhj- pata a’ray. The useful bibliography shows that Mr. Beare has studied the literature of his subject. He strangely overlooks Rodier’s monumental edition of the “De Anima,” a reference to which would have helped his interpretation of the technical term jeodrns which Zeller misapprehends. The Religion of Numa, and Other Essays on the Religion of Ancient Rome. By Jesse Benedict Carter. New York: The Mac- millan Co. $1. The five essays of this little volume aim to give merely an outline sketch of the de- velopment of Roman religion, from the ear- liest period accessible to modern research down to the death of Augustus. As a pupil and admirer of Georg Wissowa, Professor Carter bases his work on the results of careful research, and has supplied a much-needed introduction to the more extended and difficult literature of the subject. While accepting in general his correction of current misconceptions con- cerning the various accretions upon the primitive Roman faith, from Greek, Egyp- tian, and Asiatic sources, one may question ether the effect of these accretions was so wholly bad as the author seems to re- gard them. Dr. Samuel Dill has well em- phasized the fact that certain of these Eastern cults had in them elements of a higher spiritual life than could be devel- oped out of the older Roman faith unaided, and that the Roman tendency to resort to them was often the result of a genuine soul- hunger for just this higher side, and not for the demoralizing features associated with it. To the introduction of Apollo, probably from Southern Italy, towards the close of the kingdom, is attributed the later arrival of the Sibylline superstition, with all its harmful accompaniments, Was the welcome of the Sibyl, however, really the cause of the religious degradation so The Nation. naturally associated with it in thought. or was the Sibyl seized upon as an appro- priate tool for deteriorating forces already effectively at work? It is somewhat like the question whether Americans take to drink because so many foreigners keep sa- loons, or whether so many foreigners keep saloons because Americans take to drink. The chapter on the religious renaissance promoted by Augustus is deficient in its dealing with the literary phase of the Em- peror’s efforts. The extended building and repair of temples, with rigid Imperial atten- tion to the demands of official worship, could do much on the formal side, but, so far as there was any genuine religious life in this renaissance, its awakening was more largely due to a few of the great literary men to whose genius the Imperial court gave encouragement and direction. Pro- fessor Carter assigns an important place to Virgil in this fleld, but the work of Horace is strangely neglected. It is easy to think of Horace as an easy-going man of the world, fairly moral for his age, though car- ing little for the deeper phases of moral truth; but such is not a correct conception of him. When one reads his entire work with proper attention to the chronology of its composition, assigns much of the lighter part of it to its true Greek origin, and takes at its face value the large proportion which deals sensibly and seriously with ac- tual conditions and springs from the depths of the poet’s heart, he will recognize in Horace an instrument as peculiarly fitted to promote the religious policy of Augustus in the lyric field as was Virgil in the epic. No account of the religious movement of the time can be well balanced if it takes no note of him, especially when such evidently inferior religious forces as Tibullus and Propertius are mentioned. We accept as some redress for the grievance of this omis- sion, however, the author’s full recognition of that strong and steady undercurrent of genuine though uneventful religious life which flowed right on beneath the surface during the entire period—the solid, though comparatively unthinking, religious and moral basis upon which alone any religious reform, in any land or age, must build. Journal de l’Estoile: Extraits publiés avec une Notice Bibliographique par Armand Brette, et précédés d'une Introduction par Edme Champion. Paris: Armand Colin. 1906. M. Champion evidently believes that pop- ular illusions about the “good old times” are not to be classed with harmless errors, but rank among those baneful superstitions which retard the advance of mankind. In his selections from the correspondence of Gui Patin he showed the seamy side of French life during the best days of Louis XIV., and he now draws further illustra- tions of savagery and ignorance from the period of the later Valois. There are, in- deed, other reasons for presenting the me- moirs of Pierre de Il’Estoile in reduced form, since the original work occupies twelve volumes and is marked by a certain monotony of style which will always pre- vent it from becoming a rival of Brantéme or Saint-Simon. We feel sure, however, that the present editor is not simply con- cerned to present, for the sake of vulgar- ization, a selection of passages from a { gotten author A apecial motive becomes mat ‘ soon as one has read the last part ! introduction, a chapter wherein M. ©! pion discusses the French Revolut the light of the League La Harpe co tended that the Revolution, by v monstrosities, formed a history, and for the last century this at ment has been reiterated by popular w ers of every rank from Jephson to Ta What particularly disturbs M. Charm; the allegation that Terror are ascribable to the philosoph writers of the eighteenth century Whe for example, the Abbé- Maury maintal that, truly considered, the Louls XVI. is the work of the Philosoph« he is unable to quote passages from K seau or Diderot in favor of regicide [ because they do not exist. On the oth: hand, the most superficial sixteenth-century literature shows how th theologians of the League cited the Lib unique the excesses of execution know ledg: to justify the murder of Henry lil We select a single passage to indicate how M Champion stands in this matter as against the clericals who hold up the French Revo lution to the execration of mankind When L’'Estoile writes: “It is the ordi Dary practice of a Leaguer and the infa! lible sign of a zealous Catholic always to have the mass and religion on his lips brigandage at his heart, blood and murde on his hands’’; when he addsthat ‘‘the most execrable parricides and assassination: are deemed miracles and works of God that the preachers excite popular insolenc: and fury by their attacks upon the King whom they style a dog, a tyrant, a heretic (thus making him hated by the crowd), he has under his eyes ‘“‘placards published at Paris, printed with the license of the Holy Union, seen and approved by doctors of theology.”’ Moreover, these are not the statements and comments of a Huguenot L'Estoile was a Catholic. The “Journal” itself is a most valuable document, and the way in which M. Cham pion uses it furnishes a striking illustra tion of the animosity existing between th: clericals and liberals of L’Estoile, like L’Hospital, belonged to the third party, the party of the Politiques, who viewed the recriminations of Leaguers and Huguenots in the spirit made known to us by Montaigne. The brought together are a gruesome revelation of what can be done when the cause of re ligion is made a cloak for party hatred Many people think of Vagsy and Saint-Bar tholomew as isolated episodes, though not only was the spirit which prompted massa- cres present in France for a whole genera ‘fon, but there is hardly any break in the chain of atrocities from the beginning of the first civil war under Charles IX. to the accession of Henry IV. Voltaire thought L’Estoile an over-credulous chronicler of the gossip he got in the street. This criti cism has some force, but only as it affects details of the “Journal."’ The record, as a whole, was made in good faith by a man of moderate spirit who hated the excesses of the Huguenots no less than those of the Leaguers. For the historian it is a vast magazine of social facts; to the aspiring but discontented citizen it furnishes «a cheering standard of contrast modern France passages here

Page 22

128 Papers of the Military Historical Society of Vussachusetts. Vol. V.: Petersburg, Chan- cellorsville, Gettysburg. Boston: Hough- Mifflin & Co This collection of papers read before the Military Historical Society of Massachu- ts is, like most collections of the sort, of unequal value One series, however, making up about one-half of the volume and dealing with the events that passed between Grant's repulse at Cold Harbor ind the failure to take Petersburg two weeks later, is of exceptional interest and value Of the seven contributors to this page of history three deserve special men- tion: Gen. W. F. Smith, who failed to take Petersburg and here makes his defence; lohn CC. Repes, who states the case with usual clearness and method; Col. Ly- who, with his racy observation and n sense of humor, gives us the best ng in the volume veral points are brought out by these papers for which one would search our histori and even the War Records in vain; let us take them in order of date After Lee had thrown back the Federal irmy at Cold Harbor, Grant's first move of mportance was to detach Sheridan with the ivalry corps on a raid to the west of Riehmond As a raid this movement ac- mplished nothing, but it had an indirect result that nearly proved of decisive im- portance, though there is no evidence to how whether or not Grant foresaw this. On Lee finding that the Federal cavalry was raiding in his rear, he detached the bulk of his own cavalry under Wade Hiampton to check the movement; the ab- ence of his cavalry led to his failing to keep in touch with the remarkable advance that Grant began on the 12th of June, five ifter Sheridan had been detached—a fact that nearly cost Lee Petersburg and Richmond Having made up his mind that nothing more could be done to the north of Rich- mond, Grant decided to carry his army icross the James and to attack the Con- federat In this movement there were two notable features, capital from the south. lirat, the transportation problem; second- ly, the offensive climax of the operations. rhe transportation problem was solved plendidly in every detail, for in three over 100,000 men with long trains of wagons and great herds of cattle—and with Robert Lee« marched fifty Chickahominy, and one great tuary, the James. On this problem Grant had successfully concentrated all his wonu- lerful abilittes; but did he as carefully on their immediate flank—were miles, crossing one small river the ork oul the details of the military opera- tion that hould have crowned this great manure rhe answer appears to be that point Grant fell short of the high- indarde, and that his measures were ly half measures, lacking that thorough- of detail which carries success The passing of the army across the James vais but & means to an end, a means to at- ick the Confederates in a position more vulnerable than that oceupled by Lee at Cold Harbor. That position was Petersburg, miles south of Richmond, where everal lines of rail converged from the Now Petersburg was all but denuded of troops twenty South and West Lee was bound to The Nation. mass every available man against the main Federal army, and, what was more, he be- lieved until late in the afternoon of the 17th that Grant was still to the north of the James River. For two days, therefore, Grant was in a position to concentrate overwhelming numbers against Petersburg, but the efforts he made all failed. Space will not permit an examination of the various causes of the failure to take Petersburg; only three of them must re- ceive brief notice. First, it may be con- cluded that in June, 1864, Grant had not yet attained the clear perception of the best tactical employment of massed caval- ry that he displayed in April, 1865. Had Sheridan's corps been in the van instead of Hancock's, W. F. Smith would certainly have been reinforced in the afternoon of the 15th in time to complete the partial success he had won and to carry Peters- burg. Secondly, the dual arrangement whereby Meade commanded the army and Grant commanded Meade, was a false one and had a bad tendency. Thirdly, the staff and higher command was insufficiently or- ganized and improperly selected. It makes one hot with indignation, even now, half a century after the events, to think that, af- ter three years of terrific fighting, it was possible that political corruption and moral cowardice should still be sending to their death brave men under an incompetent grafter like Butler or a drunken coward like Ledlie, described by his own officers as “lying on the ground in a drunken stupor,” or “soliciting and obtaining whiskey to stimulate his courage while his division was fighting at the front.” Is it any won- der that Grant’s plans sometimes failed when their execution was entrusted to such men? And the question of staff organiza- tion is nearly akin. Devoted and able offi- cers made serious blunders owing to their lack of a proper staff education, as, for in- stance, in the matter of Hancock’s orders on the 15th of June and in that of the hand- ling of the information as to the state of supply of the Second Corps—a decisive fact, as a trained staff officer would have known. In conclusion, the Society may be con- gratulated on a carefully prepared and valuable volume. The Reformation in England. By 8S. R. Mait- land. Illustrated. New York: John Lane Company. 1906. $1.50 net. This book, although the publishers do not note the fact, is a reprint of a series of essays written more than sixty years ago for the old British Magazine and issued afterward (1849) with additions and modifi- cations by the Rev. S. R. Maitland, who died in 1866. The essays, owing to their technical character, have been less popular than Maitland’s “Dark Ages”; but until a recent revival of interest in Maitland’s writings resulted in a reprint of both vol- umes, even “The Dark Ages,” long out of print, was known to modern students of medieval history chiefly through refer- ences in bibliographies. Maitland was a man of books rather than of affairs, a writer of great learning, who for many years was librarian at Lambeth Palace, and missed a bishopric mainly be- cause of his eager championship of what he believed to be true both historically and theologically. He was especially gifted with [Vol. 83, No. 2145 critical acumen, loved an honest contro- versy, and proved a dangerous opponent to those whose zeal outran their knowledge As a critic, he was in advance of his time, for he lived in an age when men were either unwilling, or not sufficiently inter- ested, to test the truth of the ecclesiastical histories then current, and when evidences of credulity and partisanship were likely to be found in such works. “The Dark Ages,”’ he said, “were dark only to those who would not understand them"; and he might have added with truth that other accepted views continued to be erroneous because men would not take the trouble to test them by impartial criticism. Though a loy- al and orthodox Anglican, he was almost the first Protestant writer in England to do full justice to the work and influence of the Roman Church in the early Middle Ages. He had a delightful sense of humor. a pleasant style that in his essays becomes almost conversational. He was one of the kindliest of men, and, like the late Prof York Powell, opened freely his stores of knowledge to all who sought him with se- rious intent. His ‘“‘Essays on the Reformation in Eng- land” are really studies in historical evi- dence—the evidence of men like Fox, Strype, Burnett, Paget, and others, whose writings up to that time had been the main source of information for much of the history of the Early Reformation in England. Except for two volumes of State Papers published in 1830, there existed in Maitland’s day no official documents of the sixteenth century in print, and writers on the Reformation had to depend on the writings and chroni- cles of participators and partisans, such as Joye, Greene, Bale, Fox, Knox, and Brad- ford, either contemporary or nearly con- temporary with the events they narrated. Maitland analyzes this evidence with great skill, running to earth exaggerations, not- ing omissions and suppressions, inconsist- encies and contradictions, and laying stress upon instances of deliberate falsification, ribaldry, and political bias. He deals with Calvinist, Anglican, and Roman Catholic alike, and displays no small amount of courage in charging the enemies of the Church of Rome with distortion, trickery, and deceit, particularly in matters relating to the career of Bishop Gardiner and the Marian persecution. Such an outspoken and fearless defence of truth did not in- crease his popularity among his Protestant brethren, and in part cost him preferment, but it has given him high rank among Eng- lish historians. The influence of these es- says upon the writing of the history of the English Reformation has been great, but so mild and unoffending are they that it is not easy for us, in the presence of modern historical criticism, to understand their revolutionary character. They are deserv- ing of reprinting, not only for their own sake, but also as a tribute to the ability and learning of a great English scholar. Hawaiian Yesterdays; Chapters from a Boy’s Life in the Islands in the Karly Days. By Henry M. Lyman, M.D. Chi- cago: A. C. McClurg & Co. 1906. 8°, pp. xii., 281. Ills. This is the story of a son of a missionary to Hawaii. The father, a Connecticut boy, educated at Williams College and Andover a ar nee A hl

Page 23

1229 August 9, 1906] Seminary, married a Vermont girl, Sarah | of ancient history, could not keep the] panied by explanations of the po! Joiner in 1831. A few weeks later, with | Hohenzollerns out of his books, surely one | and social changes underlying its dev: eight other young couples in similar | may not show disrespect to that far less | ment. But, being arranged also by su case, they sailed from New Bedford | eminent historian, Von Sybel, in stating | and having a whole volume of tabl on the long voyage around the Horn. | that his widely read work on the founda- | indices, it is easy to find either the After six months they arrived at Honolu- | tion of the German Empire is more a polit- | ology and rationale of any ’ lu, and were allotted to the island of | ical pamphlet than accurate history. ¢. g. suffrage, civil serv ! Hawaii, where, among the resident mis- For many years after the Franco-Prussian | often of quite as muet my sionaries already on the spot, they could | war French writers shynned the subject | part played in the development of t! learn the language and prepare themselves | and left the events of 1870-1871 to be in- | stitution by any particular pe for their future duties. Ten months after | terpreted to the world by the Germans. It is | Gov. Tryon, John Jay, J. H. Choate ‘y their marriage they began housekeeping | only recently that they have awakened to] iii. is mainly devoted to the ¢ in a native house, built chiefly of bamboo | the fact that history was rapidly becoming | of 1894, but contains in an appendix and thatched with cane-leaves. perverted, and now we have at last a first- | commission and instructions of 1 The original idea of the Board was, that | rate book dealing with the events that] last expression of the wishes and | its missionaries were sent out for life, | brought Prussia from the revolutions of 1848] the old régime, before the ado; that they should live in houses like those | to the culmination at Versailles in January, | State government). Of cou the of the natives, and subsist upon the coarse 1871 Even with the French historical | tutions and amendments come in th: and unfamiliar native fare. After much | School so strong as at present, it is | torical order, beginning with tha f consequent suffering, the managers at Bos- | "0t too much to say that his present work | by no means the worst of t! ton finally perceived the poor economy of should earn for Professor Denis a conspicu- | have been in great measure the wo thus sending educated and capable men and | US reputation. His erudition is searching, | three statesmen, of whom the ! women to inevitable disability and prema- his presentation able, his style easy and in | thirty and the youngest twenty-f ‘ ture death. They began to send lumber | P@*sages marked by a stimulating strength | time of their appointment for the erection of sanitary and civilized of irony and independence of thought. As A characteristic portion of dwellings, and medical men to look after | 4 rule the most rigid impartiality prevails, | tion was the Council of Revis \ the health of their colonists. Mrs. Lyman | #2d the German achievements are not in the | power over legislation was x suffered seriously from the conditions un- | !east minimized; towards the end, however, | board consisting of the Gov der which she was obriged to live; her | this quality grows less conspicuous In | Chancellor, and the dg first child did not survive, and the health | his account of the Franco-Prussian war | preme Court Under thi of the second, the author of this attractive | Professor Denis cannot entirely forget his | liminary judicial revision, very few little volume, was for some time trembling | Own nationality, nor are his military criti- | stitutional questions seem to |! in the balance. The book recounts the | cisms altogether convincing Even in the | before the courts How it would w« k boy’s memories from the time when he | earlier years there are slight shortcomings, | day is another questio! rh could first appreciate his surroundings, to | a5 in the account of the Benedetti-Bis- | age in which suffrage witho i the period when he left the islands with a marck negotiations of 1866 qualification was a mer 144 view to entering an American university Yet as a whole the book is not only of | 8¥8tem-mongers; in which th len and acquiring a professional education. capital importance for the history of the | elective judiciary was still a dream Those familiar with the conditions of mis- | nineteenth century, but it also marks a| When almost everybody wi had a sionary life in such situations at that early | stcp in a healthy direction in the methods | 8tantial office held it by appott day do not need to be told that luxury | of historical study Nothing could show How rapidly the democrati I and selfishness formed no part of it. Others, | more clearly how fast the reaction is set- | Tecorded une rringly in these volur who have listened to the criticisms of | ting against the extremists who have pro- | 1821 the Council of Revision |} sailors and commercial adventurers, may | nounced history to be a science and noth- | @2tiquated, and = property qua find their conceptions of that life accept- | ing more than to find a professor of the | Were beginning to be lowered I ably cleared by reading this book. A so- | University of Paris, whose erudition is un- | ‘®€ Manorial system wa vept aws ciety which produced, for example, an] impeachable, disclaiming such a position | Sees and elections were democrat Armstrong of Hampton in the second gen- | and backing up his disclaimer by suppress- the modern period, which was to be ‘ eration, stands in need of no defence, | ing al! footnotes and all references to au- | '™ another half-century by a grow though an exposition of it may be wel- | thorities. This may be going too far, but | [ike of the administration of ju come. This is not a history, an ethnologi- | it is a healthy sign, and the author may be | “@™® '"- By 1875 it was found cal treatise, or a Sunday-school book, but | warmly congratulated on his courage and that the experiment of a a pleasantly-told account of the boyhood of | on his remarkable book. property qualification in cities prop a missionary’s son in a strange land. As by a highly competent commi mm wa such, we can cordially recommend it. If to be thought of. In 1546, people were some other son of worthy sires could take The Constitutional History of New York, Ey Snes 6 reba ~~ oe up the story where the author has left it. from the Beginning of the Colonial Period Mr. Simmons of Essex County is quot and carry it on to the more modern era to the Year 1905; Showing the Origin, saying that he could “tell a man f of steam and regular packet’ service, : “i feudal region by the very expr: Development, and Judicial Construction , it would be a praiseworthy undertaking. Our his countenance Volume iv i of the Constitution. By Charles T. Lin- chief criticism is that the narrative seems . « K ~ to an annotated Constitution, and at coln 5 vols. Rochester, N. Y.: The to terminate somewhat abruptly, leaving : the tables will be found a valuable « : : Lawyers’ Codéperative Publishing Com- the curiosity and interest it awakens not pany. $15 ification of statutes as they come unde ve v. wholly satisfied. heads Constitutional or Unconatit We are sorry not to be able to give much ; ; space to a work like this, which is not only La Fondation de UVEmpire Allemand. Par | 4 monument of industry and research, but | Peasant Life in the Holy Land K Ernest Denis aris: Colin. a useful historical and legal compilation as Rev. C. T. Wilson With illust This exceptional book marks a turning | well. The author is well qualified for his New York: E. P. Dutton & ( ‘ point in historical knowledge and opinion. | task, as he was a member of the conven- x. and 821. $3.50 net It is high time that the world should | tion of 1894, and for several years chairman The writer of this book was form: realize that von Sybet and the other | of the Statutory Revision Commission, be- | missionary of the Church Missiona German historians of his period were the victims interpreters of the political passions of their day. It was, in truth, a great period for Germany, and one would think less of the German whose heart had not beat faster during those anxious years during which Bismarck wrought out the modern German Empire. And if even the illustrious Mommsen, whose studies were and sides having been governors. We can best give an idea of what the book is by saying that it is arranged both historically and by topics. As a whole, it is the history of the constitution of this State, traced from its earliest sources in Magna Charta and the “Charter of Liber- legal adviser to three ties’ down to its present form, accom- ciety in Uganda and Palestine In h face he speaks of “a long Holy Land” and an intimat« with the people. That he sojou the length of his Evidently he was in Palestine a as 1901, and he refers to cond sojourn | no parently as of his personal « “ar qua nt has such quaintance the text itself makes plat:

Page 24

180 The Nation. [Vol. 83, No. 2145 in the middle of the last venture to think that, so far antedating 1880 or 1885 are has derived his information that the apparent per- nal with earlier conditions events of presentation. book is in general a simple description of the and customs of the peas- nts as saw them in various parts of but especially about ile describes minutely their ellings food, marriage and like. As he points building of railroads, the with foreign nflux of tourists, the the dis- marufactures, emi- the of education, es- illy endeavor, the hange in land tenure largely up communal! boldings by villages— like a the ial, economic, and re- yns of Palestine. His ‘‘apol- for writing this book, 3, customs, language, Palestfne, is the All that an- and Pales- suburb of Europe existed We conditions nceerned. others, which entuy he from and connection is an accident rs Wilson country, He implements, manne Mr the Jeru m burial customs, and the out, the acility of intercoul greater coun- ulting in an } of forei of gratior on a hools and tation gn goods and nati increase scale, of missionary large the spread through which has are producing something in sO) ondithe it as he puts ling the mannet f the peasants of l‘ty of is these changes and peculiar is vanishing, becoming a knowledge experience ervations of much value. He lived the people of tents on’'s and ob have among and come ind .with among whom naturally the many re- and to have ir ympathetic touch ntry In are preserved Audrey Craven By MAY SINCLAIR, Author of * "Tent ne Fire’ and ‘‘Superseded.’’ $1. **Superseded,” the earlier a by Miss Sinclair, has been so favorably received that her publishers are encouraged to issue another work, ‘“‘ Audrey Craven,” which some of the most discriminating | admirers of Miss Sinclair rank even higher | than “Superseded.” Audrey Craven is a pretty little woman with copper colored hair and the soul of a spoiled child. Though “a good woman,” she has a fatal fascination See most men. There are telling glimpses of the life of London writers and illustrators and not a little humor HENRY HOLT & CO REMBRANDT ertra 70 Plates in Color and Pastewer ure. f Tere oo W 2345 NEW YORK iu f the entenary with sumpta yet famous atrated ma of tin te hinge re ‘ JOHN LANE CO., THE BODLEY HEAD 67 PIPTN AVENUE, NEW YORK Hannah Logan's Courtship Told in the diary of the lover of this stately daughter of Pena’s famous secretary, Beau tifully Ulestrated, 62.50 postpaid, or at book Send for catalogue of interesting atoree books of Pennsylvania history and bogrephy FERRIS & LEACH, Publishers, Phila ‘ EVERY ON & SHOULD READ CONSUMPTION AND CIVILIZATION hy JOHN BPESSNER HUBER sD 1S: PUALISHED 1B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Ph sadeiphia, “4 ‘EB. P. DUTTON & 00. « «+ | COMPANY gards, as he rightly notes, the modern pea- sant reflects the conditions not only of Bible times, but even of the times preced- ing the occupation of Canaan by the He- brews. The town dwellers, on the other hand, have been much affected by foreign | thought and habits not only now, but at all periods; while the Jews, who have re- cently entered Palestine in such great numbers, are, so far as customs and relig- | ion go, modern interlopers, from whose life | nothing can be learned regarding ancient | times. For its presentation of the actual | facts of peasant life this unpretentious | volume is a valuable supplement to works already in existence on manners and cus- toms and to a less extent on the language | and folklore of Palestine. When it comes to | explanations, generalizations, matters of | history, exegesis, comparison of religions and the like, the limitations of the author’s equipment and the narrowness of his out- look render his remarks less useful. He for instance, to think that the Gypsies were in Palestine in the time of the Judges (p. 87), and that the Druses have inherited the calf-worship of old Is- rael (p. 34). Fortunately he occupies him- self chiefly with what he has seen and thus has relatively little chance for that sort of foolishness. The book is simply written, readable, illustrated with a goodly number of photographs. It gives a picture of the bet- ter side of peasant life, and incidentally is of considerable value to the student of Oriental and Biblical archeology, folklore, religion. seems, and and | BOOKS OF THE WEEK. ANpefians - bhedanands Swami. India and Her People. The Addis, W. B&B. in were Religion. $1.50. Ancient of Ear Mattes” James H. a. Vol, iv. 6 Press. 4 of p a... Bacon, Edwin Connectices River. Put- names. 50 Banner Guide to Vicinity. John D. Hall. cents. Beginning Latin. University Ba Jobn Edmund. Publishing Co. 1. Arranged H. G. Hale and N. Biblical Dramas. M. Hall. Boston: — Bibilotheca Romanica ols. 1 to 22. Strassburg: J. E. Ed. Heits. New York City and 10 Boissier, Gaston. Tacitus. 7 "oe by W. G. Hutchison. Putnams. $1.75 ne Buchanan, A. M. Manual of aiatomy. ve I. Chicago: W. T. Keener & Co. $2. Jana, John Cotten, nanning for , = Chicago: —- & nnis, James Christian Missions and Social . Vol. Ill. Fleming H. Revell Co. $2 50 net. The Duties and Qualifi Des Houssayes, J. B. Chicago: A. C. McClurg Cc. wy of a Librarian. Dumas’s La Tulipe Notre. Putnams. $1. Dury, John. The fpoteemes. teed “Keeper. Chi- cago: A. C. McClurg & Early Western Travels. Baitea by BR. G. Thwaites. Vol. LI: Travels in the Satester of North Amer- fea. Cleveland, O.; A. H. Clark Oo. Forbes- Lindsay, H. ‘Panama, the Isthmus and the Canal. Philadelphia: J. C. Winston Co. $1 net. Freeman, James E. The Man and the Master. Thomas Whittaker. 75 cents net. Comsets, Sete Henry. The Idyllic Avon. Putnams. ne Halle, Ernst von. Baumwollproduktion und Pflan- zungswirtschaft in den Nordamerikanischen Stid- staaten. Leipzig: Duncker und Humblot. Harrison, James George Washington. Put- nams. $1. = net. Heermance,. Church. “Ein Democracy in the Boston: toe on Press Hunt, Thomas F. How to Choose a Farm. Mac- milian. fe . 75. Jennings, H. 8S. Behavior of the Lower Organisms. Macmillan. $8. La Rochefoucauld’s Maximes. Putnam $1. Lacas, . The Canadian War of 1812. Henry Frowde. $4.15. Omes. Charles. The Great Revolt of 1381. Henry row Powell, Benjamin. Erichthonius and the three a poore of Cecrops. Cornell Studies in Olasst- ca . atone’ ae. Wacousta. Chicago: A. O. Stowell, Charlies H. Primer of Health. “at Healthy Body.—The mesontials of Health. ver, Burdett & Co. ¥UST PUBLISHED ' THE HISTORY OF ENGLISH RATIONALISM IN THE NINETEENTH CENTURY By ALFRED W. BENN, Author of ‘The "Philosophy of Greece,” etc. 2 vols., 8vo, $7.00, net. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York HE BURROWS BROTHERS OF CLEVELAND, OHIO are the leading booksellers in the United | States along certain lines. They issue 4 | Catalog of Rare Volumes monthly, and this, | together with their List of Publications de- voted to American History, will be SENT FREE to any one making the request. CARL SCHURZ Impertal Photograph Pronounced by “The Nation” ae « portrait charac. teristic and faithfal to such a degree as to make it the best of the existing pictures of this remarkable man. Plate 19x16 on 90x24 paper. Platinum finish $8.00. Albumen flaish $5.00 F. GUTEKUNST, 71% Arch Street, EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY Cloth, 3% cents; leather, $1.00. List on request. NEW YORK Philadelphia, Pa. The Making of an Orator With Examples from Great Masterpieces of Anc ent and Modern Eloquence. By JOHN O’CONNOR POWER Crown 8vo, net $1.35. This book is intended for speakers, young and old, who have had noprac- tice in public speaking and for speak - ers who are not unwilling to consider suggestions. “A refreshing book. . There are hints for all classes of speakers—the debater, the lawyer, the lecturer, the preacher—couched in easy informal language, pointed by anecdote, and re- inforced by well-chosen examples from the greatest orators.’’—The Outlook. G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS 3d St..N. Y. 27 &29 West 2 “Abounds with well-chosen anecdotes.” The Dial, Chicago. LINCOLN: Master of Men By ALONZO ROTHSCHILD Illustrated. $3.00 net; postpaid $3.17.

Page 25