The Nation 1906-05-24: Vol 82 Iss 2134
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
ovens
VOL. LXXXII—NO, 2134. THURSDAY, MAY 24, 1906. PRICE TiN CENTS.
Recent Economic Publications
A Living Wage ITS ETHICAL AND ECONOMIC ASPECTS By JOHN A. RYAN, S.T.L. Professor of Ethics and Economics in the St. Paul Seminary, with an Introduction by RicHarp T. Ey, Ph.D., LL.D. Cloth, 12mo, $7.00 net To defend the general conviction that wages should be sufficiently high to enable the laborer to live in a manner consistent with the dignity of a human being, by setting forth the basis of industrial fact upon which it rests, as well as its other aspects, is the aim of this volume. OTHER RECENT VOLUMES IN WHICH LABOR CONDITIONS ARE DISCUSSED Mr. John Spargo’s The Bitter Cry of the Children This is said to be the most searching examination of the effects of poverty upon children ever published. It pre- sents vividly many phases of the social problem :—the measure in which poverty is responsible for the excessive infantile disease and mortality, the tragedy and folly of at- tempting to educate the hungry, ill-fed school child; the terrible burdens borne by the working child in our modern industrial system. 17+-.357 pages, with 32 full page il- lustrations, Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net (postage 13c.) Mr. Robert Hunter’s Poverty By ROBERT HUNTER, President of the Social Reform Club; Chairman of New York Child Labor Committee; Formerly Head Worker of the University Settlement of New York. Cloth, 12mo, $1.50 net (postage 13c.) “It is the work of a man who has observed the evils of poverty at first hand, who feels strongly the injustice of what he has seen, apd yet «ho thinks straight—a man with a heart and a brain.’ Tae SociaL Serruer in Boston Transcript. Professor Thomas S. Adams’s Labor Problems By THOMAS S. ADAMS, Assistant Professor of Political Econo- my in the University of Wisconsin, and HeLen L. SUMNER, A.B., Honorary Fellow in Political Economy in the University of Wisconsin. Cloth, Svo, gilt top, 154-579 pp. $1.60 net “ Invaluable as presenting in convenient and accessible form necessary material that would else have to be searched for in widely seat tered sources."’— Providence Journal, Mr. W. J. Ghent’s Mass and Class A Survey of Social Divisions, By WILLIAM J. GHENT. Cloth, $1.25 net “It would not be easy to find anywhere to-day a student of economic subjects who has a better mastery of clean, sinewy English and who knows so well how to cleave to essentials and brush away the superfiuous.”"— New York Bvening Post Mr. John Graham Brooks’s The Social Unrest Studies in Labor and Social Movements = Cloth, $1.50 net “A more thoughtful discussion of the relations of capital and labor and the future of industry we have not seen. Both sides of the controversy can derive instruction and i ration from it.” —The ing Sun, New York
by rubished THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, °“4{654v:-
SS <2F ap ee aes eee pf “Perey as cSt. As pee ees CA =" Se . ee
Page 2
The Nation. 4 WEEKLY JOURNAL DEVOTED Tu Politics, Literature, Science and Art. FOUNDED IN 1865. uw the New York City Post-Ofice as second-class mail matter. | Katered CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Tus Wee« ‘ ee 417 EDITORIAL ARTICLES I’a 7. rf e Rate Bill 420 Republica I ebodings 420 Cheapening Canal 421 ~ ” for luses 422 A 8 ctive Art Museum 422 SPRCctAL CORRESPONDENCE r Commercial Oonquest of Sinaloa 423 | I t Rost-Bellum Budget 425 N ” 427 Hook REVIEWS; ] vsaky'a Goeth sw bene ‘ Whig Party (1807-1821) 2 ‘I No ‘ 4a j Cathedral Builders in England i4 1 \uegrabungen auf dem Forum Roma lier. 1 45 Sense Gardens How to Plan and Viant Them ° By) ‘ te us 46 hooks or Tum Wee 436 TERMS OF SUBSCRIPTION. Three dollars per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Canada; to for- eign countries comprised in the Postal Union, $4. The date when the aubacription expires is on the address label of each paper, the change of which to a subsequent date becomes a receipt for a remit. tance. No other receipt is sent unless requested. Remittances at the risk of the subscriber, unless mide by registered letter, or by check, express wider, or Postal Order payable to * Publisher of The Nation.” When a change of address ts desired, both the old and new addresses should be given. tddress THE NATION, Box 794, New York, Publication Office, 208 Broadway. TERMS OF ADVERTISING. en cents per agate line, each insertion; 14 the ineh, ent. advance fur choice of page or Pulte lineato Tu ty per top af column { colums, $20 each insertion; with choice of page #2. 4 paje, M0 each insertion; idvertisements must be front cover page $80 acceptable in everg reapect Copy recelved until Tuesday, 6 P. M DISCOUNTS, Time 4 Insertions 5 per cent. 6 - : 1 o is oo iz sn an ‘ 15 . ‘wv ee ecocococce 62 sad sees bis) “ Amount $100 within a year 10 per cent. —: ~~ — Ue senspeccensesesensennaes ik “ 500 : sas oesceeln 750 - = ‘ eveee DO 1,000 ” on ecee coves 5 eS 1,500 o S ee 80 o 2,000 oe say Ct THE NATION ta sent free to those who adver- tise in Ut as long as advertisement continues. *,* Copies of the Natron may be procured ia Paris at Brentano's, 17 Avenue de l'Opéra; in London of B F. Stevens & Brown, Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross
The Nation.
[Vol. 82, No. 2134
Educational STON UN] 8, Boston. BS TON UNIVE R SIT Y Law School, New features. . M. BresLtow. HARVARD UNIVERSITY EXAMINATION FOR ADMISSION Will be held in New York, in the rooms of the Harvard Club, June % to 30 inclusive. The terms of admission, fees, expenses and me gt any or all departments of the ny A learned from DESCRIPTIVE PAMPHLETS Suich may be had on application to the Secretary. Harvard University, Cambridge, Mass. RADCLIFFE COLLEGE CANDIDATES FOR ADMISSION and other women who wish to take the Harvard Examinations will be examined in New York, at the same time as the candidates for admission to Harvard University All information with regard to these examinations may be had on application to the Sec’y of Radcliffe College, Cambridge, Mass. DIVINITY SCHOOL oo HARVARD UNIVERSITY CAMBRIDGE, MASS. AN UNDENOMINATIONAL SCHOOL OF THEOLOGY. Announcement for 1906-07, Now Ready. A school in the country for FARM SCHOOL : boys affording the outdoor advantages of a wr F -school while providing the healthy environment of a well-regulated indoor life. Numbers limited to insure a constant, personal oversight. Summer term, June 15th to Sept. 15th, 500, including a trip to the Maine coast. H. ©. PORTER, Ph.D. Media, Pa., F. R. D. 3. ROCK RIDCE SCHOOL For Boys. Location high and dry. Laboratories, Sho °p for Mechanic Arts. Strong teachers. High id deals.
new gymnasium with ewimming pool. Fits for college, scientific school and business. Illustrated pamph et sent free. Address Dr. B.C. WHITE, Rock Ridge Hall, Wellesley Hills, Mass.
Summer Camps. CAMP CHESTERFIELD .: Athletics, manual training, tutoring. am... season. Highly recommended; college men in charge; equip- ment the be —. sboritonb
School Agencies. WE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES Everett 0. Fisx & Co., Proprietors. 4 Ashburton Pl., Boston 1505 Pa. Ave., Washington 156 Fifth Ave., New York 414 Cent. Bid., Minneapolis 208 Mich. Ave.,Chicago 1200 Williams Av., Portland 401 Cooper Bid., Denver 525 Stime’n Bik., Los Angeles 818 Rook'ry Bik., Spokane 717 Market St., San Fr’ncisco Send to any address above for Agency Manaal,
ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY. Bee See Positions for Good Teachers with Good Reco Send f for Circular on Free Registration. HAKLAN P. FRENCH, 81 Chapel 8t., Albany, N. Y. CHERMERHORN’ S Teachers’ Agency. ~J Teachers—Schools—Tutors—Governess— Property. Tel. 6129 18th. Joun C, Rock weit, Magr., 8 E. 14th St., Situations Wanted. DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY, present connected with " leading American 7 who has had two years’ expertence in col- lege raity. and has spent one year in study and travel abroad, wishes to secure @ college position tn economics and sociology. Address x 4¢, King Ferry, New York. Handy Volume Classics 155
N. ¥. C.
Used by schools and colleges everywhere. vola,, —— size, List prices, cloth, %e, per vol., limp ther Tic. per vol. (Special prices to schools rand colleges.) SEND FOR CATALOGUE. Thomas Y,. Crowell & Co., NewYork
THE LIFE OF Sir Richard Burton By THOMAS WRIGHT Author of “ Life of Edward Fitzgerald,” etc 2 vols., 8vo. 64 Illustrations. Net $6.50 “Crammed with curious anec- dotes and interesting information about the most romantic English- man of modern times. The work leaves one with an impression of profound astonishment, and with an almost exciting sense of admi- ration for Burton's prodigious per- sonality.”"—The Tribune. Send for New Illustrated Catalogue. G.P. Putnam's Sons, THREE FRANKLIN LEAFLETS are among the last issues of the Old South series: No. 161, Franklin’s Boy- hood; No. 162, Franklin on War and Peace; No. 163, Franklin’s Plan for Western Colonies. 27 & 29 West a3d st.,.N. Y.
5 cents a copy. $4 a hundred. Send for complete lists. DIRECTORS OLD SOUTH WORK Old South Meeting House WASHINGTON STREET, BOSTON
BOOKS FOR CHILDREN The Jane Andrews Series Long’s Wood Folk Series The Youth’s Companion Series Classics for Children Series Collodi’s Pinocchio Chance’s Little Folks of Many Lands Dickerson’s Moths and Butterflies. CINN & COMPANY, BOSTON
ENICMAS OF PSYCHICAL RESEARCH. A book dealing scientifically with Mediumis- tic Phenomena, Apparitions, Clairvoyance, Telepathy, Dreams, ete. By Prof. James H Hystop, author of “Science and a Future Life.” Price $1.50 net. Postage 12c. extra. HERBERT B. TURNER & CO., .eeenare, 87 Ensex Building, Bc Boston, M ass.
Travel. HARVARD fin cialgg teson Europe. Will tutor or act as travelled extensively in France, also in fgand and Italy. Address 1904, care of The! Nat
Financial. LETTERS mech rei Tee tees CREDIT Fyavellore’ Credita avaliable inal inall in 0 world International Cheques. Certificates of Deposit. BROWN BROTHERS & CO., NO. 69 WALL STREET, NEW YORE.
Page 3
May 24, 1906] The Nation. iii Telephone Duplication ITS RESULTS ELSEWHERE Of the total Independent Telephone Subscribers in Ry 5.550 64Anenass 2 78 per cent. Philadelphia.......... 73 sos. wees ween’ . 65 . Baltimore.............. are also Bell subscribers, and therefore have TWO BOOKS TO CONSULT TWO BELLS TO ANSWER TWO BILLS TO PAY There can be no such thing as telephone competition. The correct phrase is— Telephone Duplication NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY
Page 4
The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134 NOTEWORTHY BOOKS—FUST PUBLISHED A Book That EVERY ONE Should Read CONSUMPTION AND CIVILIZATION A COMPREHENSIVE EXPOSITION OF THE EFFECT WHICH CONSUMPTION HAS HAD UPON CIVILIZA- TION AND A CONSIDERATION OF ITS RELATION TO HUMAN AFFAIRS: ITS PREVENTION AND CURE - :: BY JOHN BESSNER HUBER, A.M., M.D. For the LAYMAN as well as the PHYSICIAN 't has now become thoroughly realized that consumption forces upon the world a prodigious and much pervading human problem, one with which it is quite beyond the ability of the medical profession to grapple, alone and unaided, and it is from this broad viewpoint that the work has been undertaken. Technical and professional matter, not calculated to interest the lay reader, is so indicated, and the greater part of this is put in appendices. THE SUBJECT IS DIVIDED INTO THE FOLLOWING PARTs —————"—— Prevention Administrative Measures General Consideration The Specific Cause of Tuberculosis ‘The Cure Non-Governmental Activities Predispositions to Tuberculosis The Means of Cure Scientific Resume Sociological American Sanatoria Sociological Resume . Che Home European Sanatoria Appendices The Sanatorium and its Adjuncts Profusely Illustrated. 536 Pages. Large Octavo, Cloth, $3.00 net. HEROES OF DISCOVERY IN AMERICA BY CHARLES MORRIS hese tales of the life and work of explorers, from Leif the Lucky down to Peary, who revealed the greatness of the Western Continent, will stir the blood of all Americans. The book occupies a field which has never before been at once so fully ind popularly worked Postage, 10 cents extra. Illustrated. t12mo. Cloth, $7.25 net. TWO REMARKABLE NOVELS ONE OF THE BEST SELLING BOOKS VANITY SQUARE | THE ANGEL OF PAIN By EDGAR SALTUS \ love-story in which a disappearance is involved and which By E. PF. BENSON iffords complications that make the mystery peculiarly baffling. ont en SE eee - —Newark Evening News. * For sheer clevernes no American novelist surpasses Edgar Saltus ” “It is the strongest and at the same time the most delicate story the author of * Dodo* has yet written."’—Cleveland Plain Dealer, New York Herald, Decorated Cloth, $1.25 12mo. Cloth, $1.50 J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY - PHILADELPHIA
Page 5
ht MR temic. ey The Nation. NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 24, 1906 The Week. One of the most troublesome questions that the Reclamation Service has had to deal with has been settled by the treaty just signed between the United States and Mexico, which apportions the waters of the Rio Grande available for irriga- tion. The fight for the right to divert water from the Rio Grande has been go- ing on for years, but it has become seri- ous only since the irrigation idea grew popular. Increased use of the flow in New Mexico has resulted in a shortage for the Mexican users, and the quarrel naturally went to Washington and the City of Mexico for settlement. The terms of the compromise appear to be advantageous to the United States. From the costly Engel dam in New Mexico, which practically controls the Rio Grande’s flow, Mexico is to get about one-eighth of the store in return for the relinquishment of her ancient rights of diversion. Those Western Senators who, it is reported, are opposed to giving Mexico any of the impounded water, should not carry their opposition to the point of defeating the treaty; if they do, we shall have another long-drawn-out, harassing Kansas-Colorado suit that will not only disturb our excellent relations with Mexico, but retard development along the Rio Grande as well. “Irriga- tion rows” are notoriously difficult to patch up, and the success of Secretary Root and Ambassador Casasus in set- tling this one is matter for congratula- tion. ; Whoever reads the report of Satur- day’s debate in the House of Represen- tatives on the bill to provide against the “leaking” of information from any department of the Government, will per- haps understand why the Senate still has the “effrontery” to “block” that branch of our national Legislature which “does things.” As agreed upon at a joint conference, the bill provided that every officer and employee of the Unit- ed States, while holding office or posi- tion, be forbidden to give out informa- tion as to the products grown in the United States that would affect the mar- ket value of United States bonds or the bonds and stocks of any incorporated company. The prohibition embraced the President as well as the charwomen in the offices of the Department of Agri- culture. The only point on which the conference was in doubt was whether members of Congress should be includ- ed. Interrupting the discussion, Repre- sentative McCall of Massachusetts se- cured an hour's time, and showed that, in trying to remedy one specific evil, the “leaking” of cotton statistics, the bill would really go far beyond all proper bounds. What the proposition to include members of Congress in the list of those who should remain clam-like amounted to, Mr. McCall declared, was “to com- plete and make perfect the exquisite ab surdity of an absurd bill.” “The ideal perfection of the universe” —this, as the Massachusetts Represen- tative pointed out, was the real intent of the bill. “After hearing of this trou ble about cotton, the gentleman tries to perfect the whole universe in order to take care of cotton.” Pursuing his argument, he warned ‘the House that it would, by enacting any such legislation, encourage State trials, “the spectacular and bizarre prosecution” of officehold- ers who might be judged by the domi- nant party fit victims to “enhance the popularity of somebody.’ Such a mea- sure, too, would “augment executive in- fluence over Congress.”” With such a weapon, the President might set up his Paul Mortons and pull down his Judge Humphreys with no thought except for the “good of the country.” Going on in his heartless way, Mr. McCall ex- posed the bill as one of the haziest bits of legislation ever attempted Not a dozen members, he affirmed, knew what the bill meant. Its minimum penalty of a year’s imprisonment he character- ized as “absolutely heathenish.”” A Cab- inet officer would go to his post in fear and trembling. If some morning in talking to a newspaper correspondent he remarked that the weather was very bad, and the price of corn dropped, and the stock of a corn-products company fell in price, clearly the Cabinet officer could be imprisoned for a year. Be- fore Mr. McCall’s hour was gone, the whole matter was exposed in its cru- dity, with the result that the bill was tabled and killed by a vote of 107 to 63. This showed what unfettered discussion can do in an unchained House. In finally deciding in favor of a sea- level canal at Panama, the Senate com- mittee has gone back to the recommen- dations of the majority of the consult- ing engineers whose advice President Roosevelt rejected. As a matter of fact, we suppose the committee’s action was intended mainly as a disapproval of the 85-foot project, with three locks in flight at Gatun. The weight of technical opin- ion seems against that plan. But mere- weary and angry mood, can be held in Washington long enough to come to a clear decision between rival plans. This wiil throw the whole matter back upon the President He has said that, in that event, he would begin building a lock canal, as provided for in the Spoon e; act, though he admitted the prob For them, he would certainly have to call in the en ability of “modifications.’ | gineers again Perhaps a compromis« between the 85-foot plan and the sea level may in that way be reached. Best of all would it be to throw the whol matter open to bidding by responsibl« contractors, and take the Government's blundering hand off the business. While challenging the House Commit tee on the Judiciary to show that Cor gress spends the people's money more wisely than the officers of the big in surance companies who contribute to party campaign funds, Senator Bulke!l resorted to the only defence a_ plat: speaking man could offer Suppose I did give $5,000 of the money paid by the Aetna Fire Insurance Company policyholders to help elect McKinl in 1896? he asks. Am I not a faithful guardian of my stockholders’ interest And were not other faithful guardian vigilant in protecting the country from such perils as W. J. Bryan? Senate Bulkeley was exceedingly moderate in his estimate of the proportion of per threatening the Aetna company admits. Even $20,000 would have beer but a “flea-bite” to what he personally paid to help defeat the Democratic part) This statement will be appreciated tn Connecticut, where the continued dis play of Bulkeley’s skill as a manipula tor of campaign funds led finally to the passage of a corrupt-practices act by th: Legislature. The Milwaukee investiga tion bears out the impression that Bulke ley, MeCall, McCurdy, and the rest of the insurance patriots who rushed to help the Republican party save the coun try with the country’s own money, were following an accepted precedent The only difference appears to have been that, in the Wisconsin case, $2,000 was judged sufficient. But then, the West is notor iously indifferent to “political peril.” The sworn testimony at the hearing of the Interstate Commerce Commission in Philadelphia last week that trusted of ficials of the Pennsylvania Railroad are vulgar “grafters,” would have shocked | and surprised men a vear and a half | ago; but the insurance revelations have ly to vote sea-level does not get us | there. One lock at least is necessary, even at so-called sea level. And it is doubtful if Congress, in its present hardened us to news of this kind. George W. Creighton, general superintendent of the Altoona division, received some 1,300 shares of stock from mining companies
Page 6
418 with which the railway has constant dealings. Asked whether the gifts had been presented for “pure love and affec- tion,” Creighton replied, “I just accepted them asking any questions.” George W. Clarke, a car distributor, was made happy by such tokens of regard as occasional checks for $50, baskets of wine, boxes of cigars, and dividends on coal He didn’t know what the checks were for, but, he added, “I cashed them.” He came into possession of stock worth $5,000, but he didn’t “recall the circumstances.” John M. Jamison, pres- ident of the’ Jamison Coal and Coke Company, frankly declared that, in order he had sent a check for $5,000 to Robert E. Pitcairn, assis- tant to President A. J. Cassatt... He had also given stock to other specified Penn- sylvania officials. Michael Trump, gen- eral superintendent of transportation, ard R. L. O'Donnel, general superinten- dent of the Buffalo and Allegheny Valley division, both confessed that they ha accepted as presents the stock of com- panies which shipped coal over the rail- way. Charles E. Pugh, second vice-pres- ident, had bought considerable amounts of coal stock and bonds. Naturally, he was not inclined to encourage the de- velopment of new mines along the rail- way, because the old mines, as he ex- with a laugh, “furnish more is needed.” To mistake the significance of these admissions is im- possible. A coal company which wishes t» avoid trouble presents neat blocks of stock to Pennsylvania officials, or else persuades these gentlemen that the stock is a good Investment. The managers of without stock. to secure favors, plained ecal than the railways are certainly in a position” to Increase or diminish the earnings of the coal companies. Not to put too fine a point on it, the officers of the Penn- sylvania have subjected their shippers to elaborate and systematic blackmall These transactions throw light on a phase of high finance that has provok- ed frequent the inexplicable transfer or even disappearance of shares of stock. In some of Whitaker Wright's operations “press were noted by the censorious, The comment certain mysterious calla” mystery was cleared up, however, when four high-minded newspaper writers were forced to disgorge £13,454. A yet more striking instance occurred in the organization of the American Steel and Wire Company. John W. Gates was chairman of the finance committee. When he was asked in 1902 what had become of a little block of stock—$26,- 000,000 In all--which had not been ac- that he did In the light of present knowl- edge, we can Imagine that the stock was judiciously allotted to trainmasters, di- vision superintendents, car distributors, and other gentlemen who were able to show favors at the right time to the counted for, he confessed not know The Nation. Mr. Jamison’s company got off without paying such heavy toll— right people. only $35,000. Such dealings show the most cynical disregard of moral obliga- tions—to say nothing of mere law. A bank president or cashier who should accept a private “rake-off" on every im- portant loan, would be generally recog- nized as a scoundrel. The buyer of a department store who should take gifts from manufacturers, would be discharged as untrustworthy. The case of the brib- ed railway official is in certain respects even worse. He serves a corporation which enjoys peculiar rights and which in return is bound as a common carrier to serve all patrons alike. If he forms a conspiracy to help one shipper at the expense of another, he is guilty of a crime not merely against his employer, but against the public. Senator Patterson’s the people of Denver that, if the municipal ownership ticket was defeated this year, he would run for Mayor of the city next year on that issue, should not be remembered against him. Undoubtedly, the Senate would spare him resigzed- ly, but it is most unlikely that Denver would put him at the head of her city government. At the election on Tues- day week, when six important franchise propositions and five charteramencdments were voted upon in addition to alder- manic candidates, county supervisors, and election commissioners, a two-to-one vote was recorded against the municipal- ownership programme. Among the propositions favored were those to grant franchises to the Denver Gas and Blec- tric Company, to the Northwestern Ter- minal Company, to the Union Pacific, to the Municipal Traction Company and the Denver Terminal Company. The charter amendments were concerned with the regulation of charges by public- service corporations, the purchase of a lighting plant by the city, the voting of $5,000,000 to beautify the city, the mak- ing of a ten-year contract for street lights, and a police pension scheme. The opportunity for a straight fight between the “M. O.’s” and the “corporation slaves’’ was an exceptional one; the fact that Senator Patterson deserted Wash- ington and had been for two weeks working continuously for the ownership ticket, showed how earnestly the issue was pressed. Denver's negative and decisive verdict should give the public- ownership enthusiast something to think about. promise to By passing the Shurtleff direct-pri- mary bill, the Illinois Legislature ended ingloriously a dismal special session that had lasted since April 10. On that date Gov. Deneen called the lawmakers to- gether at Springfield to remedy the mis- take of a year before, when an uncon- stitutional measure was passed, It is probable that the Shurtleff bill will stand the test of constitutionality, but it will hardly satisfy those who really want the direct primary. As explained by the Chicago News, candidates for elective State and county offices, for municipal offices to be filled in November, for clerk- ships of Appellate Courts, and for the House of Representatives and the Senate are to be voted upon. ‘The delegates to the nominating conventions are to be bound to the candidates selected in the primary “for at least one ballot” only; and to the County Central committees, which are not named by the party voters, is left the definition of the delegate dis- tricts. With such an imperfect bill be- fore him, it is not surprising that Lieut.- Gov. Sherman, who declared that “there is not a line in the bill that gives the people a right to say whom they shall nominate,” should have denounced the session as a humiliating failure. It is to be hoped the report that Gov. Deneen will sign the bill is not true. A “lawyers’ ticket,” proposed by the bar of the city for the action of the vot- ers in November, when ten new Supreme Court justices are to be chosen in the First Department, should have an excel- lent chance to win. Not only are the ten thousand and more lawyers of the New York bar competent to select a ticket free from entanglements with Tammany or Quigg, but they know how to run a campaign in which they are deeply in- terested. Almost to a man, the Je- reme workers last fall were lawyers. They supplemented the District Attor- ney’s enthusiasm with hard work and an unexpected ability to organize and con- vert. This year there is no possible rea- son why these practitioners should not disregard every offered political alliance and say: “Here is our ticket; take it or leave it.” We believe thet prompt action of this kind by a really representative body of lawyers would force sufficient endorsement from the party organiza- tions to insure the success of the ticket. Put, even if it did not, the city is in a mood to appreciate a vigorous indepen- dent campaign, based on the demand that the judiciary shall be absolutely free from the dictation of politicians, while the machine is horrified that the lawyers and the Citizens’ Union do not propose to “wait.” George W. Jimenez, a New York pa- trolman of Cuban birth, has just re- turned from Panama after an unsuc- cessful attempt to reform the police of the republic. His experiences, though doubtless serious enough to him, are diverting reading for others. He took charge of a corps of 360 policemen, many of whom were crippled derelicts of an- cient revolutions; a good half the force were detailed as butlers, coachmen, and walters to the Government officials;
Page 7
baht + Cimaeclapaie tite ed May 24, 1906] about 150 were on daily duty. Chief Jimenez variously attempted to make the police of Panama conform to the New York standard, but very soon found that the chief and only imperative duty of an officer was to vote early and often for the Administration on election day, and so far as possible prevent the Op- position from voting. Between elections the force was chiefly a refuge for pen- sioners of the wives of the authorities. Mr. Jimenez also objected to the ill- treatment of persons imprisoned on sus- picion, and it revolted his manly soul to see handcuffs immediately clapped upon any person under arrest. It ap- pears that the average Panaman officer is not of a physique to make a com- patriot, much less an American, “walk Spanish” without such artificial aid. It is ill dealing as a reformer with a peo- ple that abhors reform, and Mr. Jime- nez’s unhappy experience lends an il- lustration to Mr. Taft's offhand state- ment that the United States will inter- vene in Panama to keep order as it sees fit. Evidently, the Republic of Panama is a poor thing, but our own. After four years of President Palma, the Cubans are glad to have four years more of his rulé. If his Administration has been open at times to criticism, it has, at any rate, brought a new pros- perity to the island, has been success- ful in suppressing irresponsible revolu- tionists, and in making the people con- tented. President Palma, of course, had the moral backing of Washington in 1902 when he took office—indeed, he was more American than Cuban after twenty-five years of residence in New York State; but that has not altogether explained his success. It might have accounted for his first election, but not his second. The sensation of self-gov- ernment has been felt all over Cuba, and it is because Palma has thrown himself enthusiastically into the work of transforming “free Cuba” into pros- perous Cuba, that he has strengthened his hold to such a degree that all op- position was withdrawn before the last election. The reciprocity treaty, better sugar and tobacco crops, and the de- velopment of transportation and manu- facturing have been powerful campaign- ers for Palma; and the Isle of Pines incident only served to show the good understanding between the Administra- tion at Havana and that at Washing- ton. The President of Cuba has in- creased his claim to the title of “Cuban patriot.” The French Ministry increased its majority on the second balloting on Sun- day, which saw the defeat of the group of Nationalists and other reactionaries left in suspense at the first trial. The victory has been won on 4 basis of anti- clericalism and of social) reform, M. The Nation. Sarrien is backed by a group of Radi- cals falling only a little short of a ma- jority, and is less dependent than he has been on the votes of the Socialist Left. The Temps accepts the voting as pri- marily a triumph for the Republic. It points out that for the first time since the Third Republic was founded, no prominent candidate has dared to pre- sent himself as its opponent. The var- ious types of Royalists and Imperialists have taken to cover under the vague ap- pellation of Nationalism. When the Temps also professes to see in the elec- tions a check to collectivism, its case is not so convincing. If the Socialists languish temporarily, it is only because successive Governments have outdone each other in the attempt to kill their exacting allies by kindness. Most par- ties will stand an enormous amount of this treatment without giving up the ghost. Paternalism is likely to have full sway for a number of Parliamentary ses- sions. Fortunately, men of proved sense and executive capacity are in charge. A curious result of the vindication of the Separation Act is to make Rome a far more interesting point for observers of French politics than Paris itself. Will Pius X. follow the advice of the most distinguished Catholics of France and accept a hard dispensation resignedly, or will he oppose the application of the Sep- aration Act and take the chances of a re- ligious war? His decision will be mo- mentous, and will pretty well settle the question, raised by certain skeptics and old-line Catholics, whether the Car- dinal-Patriarch of Venice was “pope- able” or not. ¢ The rejection of a Labor bill in the Lords is a straw that shows the drift. The particular act aimed to suspend the incoming of all laborers from abroad during a trade dispute. It looked to- wards a foolish and impracticable em- bargo, and was well voted down. The in- cident, however, gives a hint of very embarrassing possibilities for the upper house. Will it dare throw out the trade- dispute bill granting immunity for trade- union funds? What will be its attitude towards the act promising a free meal to all school children? It is years since the calm of the Peers has been so con- stantly threatened. Obviously, a prac- tice of rejecting bills from the Commons will hardly do. The Lords are not pop- ular enough to risk a course that would point the outcry for their abolition. It is likely, then, that the more radical labor legislation will go through rela- tively unopposed, and that the negative and amendatory votes will be kept for the Education bill, or on the off-chance that the local self-government bill for Ireland should bear the look of an ad- vance towards home rule. Delimitation of spheres of influence in 419 Persia, perhaps the most important fea- ture of the Anglo-Russian understanding now nearing final negotiation, would relieve international politics of a partic- ularly dangerous question. It is said that Russia abandons her claim to a port on the Persian Gulf, and Great Britain acknowledges Russia's paramount posi- tion in the northern half of the Shah's dominions. British influence was once supreme throughout Persia, and imports into that country came almost entirely from Manchester; but the markets of Teheran, Tabriz, and Meshed have been flooded with Russian goods, and the en- ergy of Russia's agents has destroyed British influence in the north. But if Britain gives way in North Persia, she holds her own with the greatest deter- mination in the south. Every Foreign Secretary, Liberal or Conservative, has recognized the necessity of keeping Rus- sia at a distance. No one within re- cent years has been more instrumental in maintaining this policy than Lord Curzon. In his book on Persia he says that he would impeach as a traitor to his country any minister who permitted Russia to penetrate to the Gulf. Hence the fact that Russia and England are in agreement is a particularly encouraging sign of the times. The Duma’s reply to the Czar’s ad- dress held language respectful but firm. It appears to be a body that knows its own mind, perceives the need of extend- ing its powers, while exercising them in an orderly manner, and has clear ideas about the only way in which represen- tative and responsible government can be established in Russia. Its demand that the Imperial Council be either abol- ished or shorn of its obstructive func- tions, so that the Duma may express the people’s will directly to the Czar, is the most radical that it makes. One must doubt if it will be acceded to without a struggle. Probably the autocracy will consider this an attack upon one of its inalienable prerogatives. The Duma is on surer ground when it calls for the instant repeal of exceptional repressive laws, for the doing away with imprison- ment without trial, and for the right of the people’s representatives to have a direct voice in all legislation. The re- actionary policy could not well be chal- lenged more sharply. The Czar's re- fusal to receive the memorial of the Duma direct from its president and a deputation is, however natural, calcu- lated to stir discontent to the depths. To the Duma it will be the sign that Nicholas II. is still swayed by bureau- cratic counsellors. For the present, the new Legislature proceeds quietly to the land question, assuming its jurisdiction in the premises quite as cavalierly as the Czar has stood on an improvised punc tillo, and awaits the first probable con- cession, at least partial amnesty, i +, i } ; : ' ew eid, & oe . @Ebe. ee a ee ob ign - P .moyT ey retry egies
Page 8
—_— The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134 PASSAGE OF THE RATE BILL. The sudden passing of the amended Railway-Rate bill by the Senate on Fri been due to weariness superinduced either heat talk. Of the latter, the Senate should surely have gone through a surfeit cure during the past three months. Be this as it may, the bill now goes to confer- very day afternoon may have by or able to guess form and we are nearly what its final also to estimate its practical and politi- cal effects All agree that, but for Roosevelt's initiative, no such bill could been got through Congress. Senator Tillman frankly that his opinion in the closing hours of the debate: though he added, in duty bound, that the whole idea was stolen by the President from the Democrats. But that of hardly in politics No file a patent applied for in the case of a and a radical, acciden- ence, will be, as President yet have gave as as charge counts can sort one notice of po litical invention: tally in power in a conservative party, may take his own wherever he finds it Accordingly, the reluctant acceptance of Rate bill by the Republican Sena tors must be reckoned as the personal achievement of Mr. Roosevelt. Unluck- for him, the very hour of his tri- umph has been clouded revelations which have damaged his reputation more seriously than any- thing that befell him in public life: so that he loses the fruits of vic tery at the moment of plucking them. A dozen Rate bills could not make up for the Chandler letters and diary and the unrefutel about the Presi dent's tergiversations made in the Sen ate. Even if this withering of the laurel at the instant of putting it on had not occurred, it would still have been neces sary to ask just what it was the Presi- dent fought for, and precisely what it is that he has got. the first, it some excellent the ily by unquestionably ever assertions the But Cer- that features From was clear bill had these were chiefly non-contentious up in the practice, which had grown de- velopment of everybody but their greedy beneficiaries which willing These were such tain abuses railway: to be abuses, and every but even eager matters as rebates, jugglery about term inals and terminal charges, the outrages private-car companies, the guise of There was no ob agreed body themselves was and to correct by under committed extortion payment for refrigeration, etc jection the Congress having the slightest to the passage of laws rigidly forbidding and punishing these public evils. They were of a sort to clamor for regulation under the Interstate-commerce clause of member of influence on part of any the Constitution, and every measure aimed at them met with instant ap- proval in Congress. Indeed, the Sen- ate itself went far beyond the House in the stringency of the provisions aimed at such railway wrongs. In general, it tore the Hepburn bill to pieces, so that its printing in the amended form looks very much like a map of the earthquake section of San Francisco; but in no re- spect did the railroad-ridden Senate out- strip the House more clearly than in sweeping clauses levelled at these inci- dental railroad abuses. It restored the criminal clause in the law against giving rebates. It reduced the pass mischief to a minimum. It brought sleeping cars and express cars under the scope of the act. It forbade railroads to own coal mines. It made pipe lines common carriers. There was, in a word, a per- fect enthusiasm and unanimity of re- form in all these respects. The Presi- dent’s recommendations were, in that sphere, far exceeded. There was practi- cally no opposition to these wholesome reforms; and they could have been en- acted into law in a month as really non- contentious, had they not been mixed up with the bitterly and long-contested conferring upon the Interstate Commerce Commission the power to fix clause railroad rates. This was the one thing for which President Roosevelt went to battle, and we need take only the testimony of his friends to conclude that he comes back defeated. It is not necessary to go over again the acrimonious charges and countercharges of the past fortnight. It is sufficient to go to President Roose- velt’s messages and speeches, and even his letter of May 14 to Senator Al- lison, to put it beyond mistake that he desired to give all power to the Com- mission, and to keep railway rates out of the courts so far be done constitutionally. But the bill, as amend- throws everything into the courts which may “enjoin, suspend, or annul” any rate whatever made by the Com- mission. As a last rallying-point, the President and his friends stood for the words “in its judgment,” as defining the powers of the Commission. Commis- sioner Prouty thought it vital that these words should remain in. But they were stricken out, 50 to 24. The point is, of that they seemed to warrant the exercise of both legislative and ju- dicial powers by the Commission. It is highly doubtful if Congress can delegate any such powers; but, to solve all doubt, the Senate struck out the last thing in the rate-making clause which made it look as if it had what Senator Bailey calls “teeth.” The bill, have said, contains many meritorious and needed features depending, however, Bunsby-like, upon their application. If rigorously enforc- ed, they will go far to cure long-stand- ing evils. But, may the people will at once pass to other things. If the bill had failed, there would have been a great outcry and agitation; pass- as could ed, course, as we we be sure, ed, it enters at once the limbo of things fully discounted, and of which the coun- try is “tired,” and politicians will turn restlessly to other issues. REPUBLICAN FOREBODINGS. ‘Worried before over the outlook for the Congressional elections this year, the anxiety of the Republican managers is visibly heightened by the occurrences of the past week in Washington. It may well be. Such strained relations between the President and the leading members of his party have not been seen for years, if ever. The most damaging charges against the President were made in open Senate, and not one Republican Senator rose to defend Mr. Roosevelt. Fven Lodge left off running to the tele- phone. When the breach between Cleve- land and the Senate was at its worst, there was always some Senator to speak up for him; but the Republican oracles have all been dumb: The President was attacked with the greatest directness and particularity; Messrs. Tillman and Bailey challenged the Republican Sena- ters to reply, but they all sat silent. Their silence was most eloquent, po- litically. It testified strikingly to the distrust and dislike which Mr. Roose- velt has excited in the minds of the chief Republican Senators. So extraordinary a party situation cannot fail to be re- flected in the Congressional campaign. The troubled Republican managers at Washington are, reports the Herald, pointing to the fact that “no Republican President ever before sought deliberate- ly to defeat his own party with Demo- cratic aid.” The effect of the disclosure that Roosevelt was concerned in such a scheme will, they fear, have “a stun- ning effect upon the straight-party men and paralyze the organization.” Ac- cordingly, their efforts are to be directed to restoring the shocked patient, and causing the symptoms of paralysis to pass away. This they propose to accom- plish by calling in the physicians of the American Protective Tariff League. The plan is to rally the demoralized party by a galvanic stand-pat campaign. It is to be opened in Philadelphia this week, with Speaker Cannon as chief lauder of the all-wise-and unchangeable tariff. By making a loud noise in that way, diver- gent voices within the party are to be drowned out. These tactics are the natural resort of a certain order of mind, but they are not even shrewd, in the circumstances. If the party is dividea about Roosevelt, it is still more badly split by the tariff. The revelations about cheap sales abroad by protected manufacturers who exact the uttermost farthing from the Ameriean consumer, have stirred many Republican consciences to revolt. We have not forgotten what Gov. Guild of Massachusetts wrote to the President last fall. Of what advantage would it
Page 9
Wehr ye meet mo May 24, 1906] The Nation. = be to the stand-patters to keep Pennsy!- vania but lose Massachusetts? Tariff revision sentiment is strong among Re- publicans in many parts of the land, and cannot be stilled by the loudest beating of stand-pat drums. “President Roosevelt and the Republican party which he leads are for tariff reform,” declared the Portland Oregonian of May 11. With Republicans all over the coun- try believing and asserting this, how can you turn the Congressional campaign into a hurrah of the stand-patters? A more skilful, if equally insincere, strategy is advocated by the Oregonian. This consists in drawing party lines taut. “The true test of Republicanism is to vote the Republican ticket.” That is, in effect, the platform which the Ore- gonian lays down for the June election of Representatives from its State. A Democratic county convention had af- firmed that “a party exists to maintain principles’; but the Portland editor shows the folly of that. He denies that it is the true function of a party to “sit perched forever like a fat Buddha on a pedestal and eternally utter abstract propositions."”’ “‘No party that is wor- thy of public confidence exists merely to maintain principles.” Precisely: the main thing is to win elections and get the offices. So let tariff reformers and stand-patters sink their differences and vote alike for the grand old party that doesn’t know its own mind except on the point of liking uncommonly to be in power. Even, however, if there could be agree- ment upon such a policy of waiving principles and going in for the offices, Republican reasons for apprehension would scarcely be lessened. The party has suffered blow after blow. Perhaps the heaviest one came from the revela- tions of the way in which previous Re- publican campaigns have been corruptly financed. The managers have had their ignominy disclosed. That they could en- dure, but they have also lost their insur- ance money for this year at least. The two things together make a burden greater than they can bear. It is not strange that they look forward with trepidation to their task of saving the country without the aid of funds stolen from widows and orphans. Behind all these uncertainties of pol- icy and ways and means, lies the uncer- tainty how the President will interpret the election. If the Democrats win, he will be tempted to say to his party: “There, you see what comes of not lis- tening to me. Besides, I always did get on well with Democrats.” If the Repub- Iicans succeed, he would probably, in like manner, take it as a personal en- dorsement, and demand that all of his miscellaneous programme be written into law at once. But there are thou- sands of influential Republicans who would prefer, rather than that, to see their party beaten. This adds dubiety to the prospect. Prophecy is always the most gratuitous of blunders, but this may be said with perfect safety: if the Democrats do win the next House, even by the narrowest margin, it will be ac- counted a great Republican disaster, In view of the large Republican majority in the present House. And President Roosevelt will be held, justly or unjust- ly, accountable for it, exactly as Presi- dent Cleveland was for the Democratic dcbacle of 1894. In that event, the President's philosophy, personal re- source, and political skill will be put to a ruder test than they have yet had to undergo. CHEAPENING THE CANAL. Lovers of logic and consistency, among whom we venture to reckon ourselves, must be profoundly disturbed by the course of the Administration in pur- chagjng supplies for the Panama Canal. If we are to stand pat, let us stand pat, without shuffling and compromise. If the glory of the country, the development of its manufactures, and the wages of its workmen demand that we pay from 25 to 500 per cent. more for home than for fereign products, let us all, including our rich Government itself, put our hands into our pockets and settle our heavy bills like gentlemen. What is sauce for the goose is sauce for the gander, even if that sauce happens to be the blessed protective tariff. This question of alien machinery and materials for the Panama Canal is not raised for the first time to-day. Some time agothe Administration bought some foreign-built vessels on the wretched pretext that they were much cheaper than anything to be had in this country. Then Secretary Taft, in a letter pub- lished last January, appealed to Con- gress for specific direction whether or not he should continue to purchase in the cheapest market; but the oracles of Congress have remained dumb. And now a new case vexes the soul of Mr. Taft. A Scottish firm is the lowest bid- der for some dredges; the Maryland Steel Company comes next. Shall the Government pay a domestic corporation from $60,000 to $70,000 more and there- by protect American capital @nd labor; or shall it turn to the Scot and there- by strangle an infant industry in its cradle? If the Government, which is far from bankrupt, is justified in patroniz- ing the canny Scot, why should not the individual enjoy the same privilege? Government money is certainly not so tainted that beneficiaries of the tariff will haughtily spurn jit. Indeed, your protected interest is notoriously as in- satiate as the daughter of the horse- leech. The sophistry by which Mr. Taft per- suades himself that he should buy in Scotland could be torn to shreds in a moment by Speaker Cannon or Secre- tary Shaw. As a precedent, the Secre- tary of War cites the purchase of large amounts of meat in Australia for the army in the Philippines—merely be- cause the Australian meat cost about half as much as that brought from the Pacific Coast. But this example proves nothing except Mr. Taft's callous indif- ference to the prosperity of American packers. The foreigner pays the tax; and embalmed American beef is better for the stomach of any patriot than the juiciest sirloin produced by the pauper labor of Australia. Still another plea advanced by Mr. Taft is that Panama is “outside the tariff wall.” That, on the face of it, is a mere quibble. He shouid view the tariff wall not as a physical entity, but as a spiritual conception. The appropriation act of 1875 expressly de clares that the Government must give preference to American material; and to that act he should conform in spirit as well as in letter. The mere fact that the material is to be used in Panama does not alter essential relations. When Mr. Taft refuses to buy of the Maryland Steel] Company, the Maryland Steel Com- pany is in so far forth denied the boon of protection, and a deadly dagger is driven into the heart of one of Dingley's darlings. In the course of this discussion some men who are secretly tariff-reformers whatever creed they profess-—have maintained that, unless the Government can buy abroad, our home manufactur- ers will form a combination to charge extortionate prices. No argument could be more irrelevant. The great practical benefit of protection, as we have learn- ed by abundant experience, is that it makes possible just such effective com- binations. That is exactly what the tar- iff is for. It is intended to give the American a weapon by which he can ex- tort from the consumer the highest pos- sible price. If the tariff failed to accom- plish this, it would fail in everything. Adherents of protection who complain that the life is squeezed out of them by the Trusts, are about as consistent as a clergyman who should object to re- ligion on the ground that it converts men from sin. So long as we are bound to have a tariff, let us look it squarely in the eye and khow it for what it is. Toward the end of his latest utterance on this topic, Mr. Taft lets the cat whol- ly out of the bag. “Some purchases,” he says, “have already been made abroad and a saving effected in the purchase of comparatively small quantities of ce- ment. In the construction of the cana! an enormous quantity of cement wil! have to be purchased”; and presumably there might be enormous savings. In fine, Secretary Taft has a sneaking de- sire to build the canal cheaply. We have known some men and more women who are inspired by this sordid wisn to get their clothes, their furniture, ana even their houses at a cost as low as Te i) om ee ee Oe? RRR a ene SET
Page 10
422 may be consistent with good quality. These bargain-hunters have been sternly rebuked by the high priests of protec- tion. Every devout worshipper of the McKinley and the Dingley schedules thrills when he recalls President Harri- son's apothegm of the stump, “A cheap coat makes a cheap man.” If a cheap coat casts such a terrible blight on in- tellect and character, a cheap cana would utterly corrupt our national con- science. The higher the cost, the greater our happiness, the more exalted our virtue. SCHOOLS FOR GENIUSES. A demand for special schools for the specially gifted is making itself heard in Germany. Notable among those ad- vocating the plan are Wilhelm Bélsche, ia his ‘Weltblick,’ and Dr. J. Petzoldt, in bis ‘Separate Schools for the Conspic- uously Gifted.’ Dr. Petzoldt of the gym- nasium of Spandau feels his heart go- ing out to “the highly endowed, who, misunderstood by those nearest to them, see their divine spark being slowly ex- tinguished,” for lack of proper training. The neglected genius has always been more abundant in Germany than else- where, but Herr Bélsche and Dr. Petz- oldt show us how to foster both unrec- ognized genius and the less elusive va- riety. The Doctor makes it clear that he is not lacking in sympathy for those slighted by nature. There are in Ger- many numerous schools for backward and feeble-minded children. In nearly 170 cities and towns about 12,000 of them are being educated by the State. In thus providing for them, Dr. Petzoldt asks, “Do we not allow the impulses of our heart to get the better of cool rea- son? Are not the especially gifted far more entitled to pity than the mentally disinherited?” He makes a strong show- ing for the feasibility of establishing special schools without throwing addi- tional burdens on the State or sacrific- ing existing schools. He would select, say, from the fourth class of the gym- nasium, twenty of the brightest pupils, to form the first class of the Sonder- schule. The teachers, a picked corps, must be able to recognize clearly the pecullar mental gifts of their scholars. A special diary is to be kept for each. The natural sciences are to be given first place in the curriculum, the main object of all the courses being to train the stu- dent in “thinking to the very root of the subject, until hatred of superficiality becomes an Instinct.” The study of bi- ology is expected to lead to a higher con- ception of art than prevails among the moderns, whose bizarre creations, Dr. Petzoldt incidentally remarks, are sim- ply the result of ignorance of natural acience Psychology, blography, and English and Italian are to be compul- sory subjects in the lower classes: the higher are to provide elective courses, [Vol. 82, No. 2134 ——— scientific, technical, artistic. The hours of instruction are to be limited to four a day, and two hours daily are to be given to gymnastic exercises in the open air. Singing and drawing are not to be neglected. The entire plan of instruction, by con- densing two years’ teaching at the high- er classes of the gymnasium into one, is to enable the student to devote the time from the fifteenth to the eighteenth year to subjects usually taught only at the university. A specialist in nervous diseases, of thorough pedagogic train- ing, is to be constantly on the lookout for any sign of over-exertion or abnor- mal behavior. As to the cost of estab- lishing these Sonderschulen, Dr. Petzoldt argues that the 400 gymnasia and 100 Realschulen in Prussia would, through the elimination of their brightest pupils and teachers, savé enough money to en- dow twenty-five Sonderschulen, while the gain to the country from an esti- mated steady supply of 3,000 unusually bright and specially trained young men would be incalculable: There is, of course, no particular orig- inality in the plan itself. The need of providing suitable instruction for gift- ed pupils has often and in various ways received practical consideration, not least in Germany itself. In the town of Mannheim, for instance, the most tal- ented school children—about 10 per cent. of the total—have for some time been specially taught, though in the same class with those of average capacity. But there is a novelty in the almost ag- gressive attempt to lay down hard-and- fast rules for the treatment of gen- ius, in disregard of the great difficulty which educators and philosophers have from time immemorial experienced in even defining the very term. If Les- sing be right in maintaining that it takes genius to awaken genius, Dr. Petzoldt’s initial difficulty would seem to lie in dis- covering the genius of the teacher. Nor is this all, for, in the new education, en- vironment plays a very important part. Apparently, Dr. Petzoldt would as nearly as possible provide for the budding Moltkes, Bismarcks, and Kants the con- ditions that made their prototypes what they were. “Could a Moltke in time of peace andea Bismarck under a ruler like Frederick II. have attained their full development? Did not Kant employ all his ingenuity in the service of theologi- cal metaphysics until awakened by Hume from his dogmatic slumber?” It is true that the Faradays, Liebigs, and Schliemanns triumphed over a thousand obstacles, but Dr. Petzoldt would spare their successors an equally hard strug- gle—fatal, he thinks, in many recorded and unrecorded cases. It appears to him highly probable that, under adverse cir- cumstances, even Goethe would not have given to the world his masterpieces (Schopenhauer has confessed as much for himself). He maintains stoutly— pace Lessing—that Raphael could not have become a great painter had he been born without arms. Dr. Petzoldt is well aware that genius may be simultaneously creative in vari- ous directions. But varied stimulus, while imperatively called for in some cases, must never degenerate into co ercion. The obstinacy of genius in re- jecting instruction is often only wise recognition of its own limitations—vide Alexander von Humboldt, “who ought never to have been forced to take music lessons.” As the object of the Sonder- schulen is eminently practical, it may be asked what test as to the quality of genius fostered in any given pupil will be applied on graduation. Or is the out- put to be measured in quantity? Pro- ductivity of the right sort was defined by Goethe to be the surest touchstone of genius, though its results be only an occasional song like Béranger’s. But we fear there are many perplexing prob- lems for the teachers in charge of genius at the Sonderschulen. A SELECTIVE ART MUSEUM. At the organizing meeting of the As- sociation of American Museums, on May 15, Mr. Benjamin Ives Gilman, Secre- tary of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, made an important contribution to the new science of museology by ad- vocating a selective or anthological prin- ciple for public art museums. Mr. Gil- man believes that the duty of an art museum is not primarily to afford in- struction in archzology, but to minister to the pleasure that comes from the un- disturbed contemplation of beautiful ob- jects. With this end in view he would select from the possessions of a museum its finest objects, and exhibit them un- der the best conditions of light and space. The rest of the collections he would store or exhibit compactly for the use of students and investigators, hold- ing such study collections open, however, te all applicants. In both the public and the study collections the arrange- ment would be chronological, but in the public galleries the arrangement would be based on esthetic, in the study halls on scientific, considerations. A twofold plea is made for this some- what revolutionary theory of dualism. First, it is obvious that the public is un- equal to the task of picking out the ex- cellent exhibits from the mediocre or merely curious. As collections increase, the task becomes ever more vexatious. An entire public is forced to plod through miles of galleries, many of which appeal only to the professional s-udent of art, possibly the hundredth part of the museum’s public. Hence the duty of sifting the collections into an anthology. An ideal director would treat his possessions much as Matthew Arnold did the works of Wordsworth, making such a selection as should at-
Page 11
May 24, 1906] tract interest and minister to culture. The special student, it is plausibly main- tained, would also profit by the introduc- tion of the selective policy. The great- er part of the collections would be ac- cessible to him, with a more compact and convenient installation, under favor- able conditions for undisturbed study and in handy proximity to libraries, workrooms, and the offices of consulting curators. The chief objections to the anthologi- cal idea were raised by Professor Good- year of the Brooklyn Institute in a very trenchant but courteous rejoinder to Mr. Gilman’s address. Professor Good- year held that the selection of the best is practically impossible, being based simply on individual taste or caprice, and that our only certitudes are of an historic sort. Hence history and chron- ology are the only safe guides for a di- rector, and the best arrangement for the student will turn out to be the best also for the man in the street. Professor Goodyear’s agnostic attitude as to de- cisions of taste represents a way of thinking widespread among scholars. It is based partly upon a praiseworthy caution, partly upon a less commenda- ble distrust of the emotions. As a mat- ter of fact, the dictum, de gusitbus non est disputandum, is practically ignored by those who preach it most vehement- ly. There is an absolute consensus as to the finest periods of art and as to many individual works. No archzologist hesitates to affirm that the Greek sculp- ture of the fifth century ps. c. excels that of the fourth and third. There would be no dispute of the dictum that the Dutch painting of the seventeenth cen- tury surpasses that which precedes and follows it. Nor would any well-inform- ed person deny the supremacy of French painting in the nineteenth century. If it were really true that taste is merely personal and helpless, there would be no such consensus of judgment. Within these great periods, also, one does not hesitate to distinguish the vary- ing merits of different works. The com- parative mediocrity of Rubens in por- traiture is generally admitted; the great- er significance of Rembrandt's later works has become a truism; converse- ly, every one is familiar with Van Dyck’s degeneration into an elegant but meaningless mannerism. We perceive in Vermeer an exquisiteness beyond that of the Dutch school, and we balance the merits of his score of surviving can- vases as exactly as the tea-taster sorts tea by quality. There remains a fringe where judgment is varying—a certain number of debatable examples of art; but in all main matters these accepted verdicts of taste are quite as sure as the date on a birth certificate. Practically, a jury of connoisseurs and artists which should be asked to pick out from any museum the tithe best worth ex- hibiting, would agree in about three- The Nation. quarters of the cases. As to the rest, a broad-minded director would give them the benefit of the doubt, exhibiting all that obtained the suffrages of two or three competent judges. : As to historical considerations, it should be noted that Mr. Gilman and Professor Goodyear, representing the advanced and the orthodox schools of museology, would treat three-quarters of the exhibits in any given museum in precisely the same fashion. The differ- ence would be not in internal arrange- ment, but in conditions of public ad- mission, and in the disposition of, say, a quarter of the exhibits. Mr. Gilman believes the finest should be selected and advantageously shown; Professor Good- year believes that no sorting should be made by the museum, but that the duty of selection should be left to the average visitor. Mr. Gilman looks forward to a large public enjoying impressions of art, and a small public deeply studious of its history; Professor Goodyear is skeptical as to the wsthetic public, but hopes for a great increase In the number of the studious. We hold no brief for either view, and are willing to believe that both sorts of museums have their value. But, clear- ly, the unwieldiness of modern collec- tions plays into the hands of the an- thologist. Wherever the number of pieces is too great for complete exhibi- tion, the anthological idea holds. For example, print and coin departments rarely show more than a mere frac- tion of their treasures at one time Resourceful curators in such depart- ments ordinarily arrange a small perma- nent exhibition of the choicest pieces, and offer aiso periodical exhibitions from the reserve. This is precisely the pol- icy advocated by Mr. Gilman and like- ly to be adopted by the Boston Museum of Fine Arts, when it moves into its new building. One may readily foresee a state of things where the general col- lections of museums will be as congested as the print rooms are from the outset. The cumbered state of such museums, the fatigue and distraction of their cas- ual visitors, the increasing inconvenience of their overgrown and badly dispersed collections to investigators, will elo- quently plead the cause of the selective idea. THE COMMERCIAL CONQUEST OF SINALOA. FUERTE, Mexico, March, 1906 In three years a subtle change has stolen into the life of Sinaloa. Where there was formerly vague talk of progress, with an occasional electric-lighting plant or mu- nicipal water-works adduced as an exam- ple, while knowing ones insisted on their superior knowledge of the time when the railroad from Chihuahua would reach Topo- lobampo, and when steel rails would en- tice the slumbering lead mines of Topia to activity, now there is nervous restlessness 4238 in the face of the actual fact that a great wave of industrial development is sweep- ing upon the State; that a railroad, with all the power and determination of the Southern Pacific Railway Company behind it, is actually being built through the fer- tile coasta: plain; and that a well-financed land company is laying its hands upon the richest agricultural and grazing areas in the region. The effect of this, combined with the Spectacle of in-rushing hordes of adventurers and investors, has been to dis- quiet a goodly portion of the people, who see in it, with more or less reason, the prospect of changes subversive of the old standards of living and threatening the existing sociab order. The wealthier class- es, who hold the reins of power, number many who have travelled widely, have read much, and are not ignorant of the domi- nant habit of the Anglo-Saxon when he strikes deep root in a foreign soil. Al- ready the foreign colony refers to this or that Mexican notable as being “anti- American,” which is significant. The dis- trust of the impending commercial inva- sion has been communicated to the well- to-do masses, and the old-time cordial hospitality is less conspicuous than for- merly, coupled with a sharp discrimina- tion in prices, not to the advantage of the newcomer. The working people—we may as_ well cease calling them peones, since even local usage is attaching the implication of a slur to the term—are indifferent to the ul- timate results of the awakening which steam and labor-saving machinery, and their masters, may effect. They are con- scious only that there is a keener com- petition for their services than formerly, and that this has raised the compensation from one hundred to two hundred per cent At the same time the small planter has felt the scarcity of labor, and has raised his prices for corn and fodder and mules, The excessive rains which for two years past have damaged crops, are chiefly credit- ed with the advance in prices, but this is only part of the truth. There is no doubt that the area under cultivation has de- clined because sufficient labor has not been available at the usual wages. It is difficult for the man used throughout his life to paying thirty to forty cents silver a day for ranch hands, to acquiesce in the demand for fifty cents to a dollar. He has not yet become as profoundly impressed as the common laborer with the urgent cry, from the mines in Sonora and across the Gulf of California at Santa Rosalfa, for workmen, and ever more workmen, at two and a half to four dollars a day. He has not«seen the shiploads of laborers dis- embarked at Santa Rosalfa, nor the trains from Guaymas crowded with eager seek- ers after opulent rewards, hurrying to- wards Cananea, and he tries in vain to cling to the ancestral conditions while the formerly-contented workers around him are having their standards of values pro- foundly altered by the tales of riches so quickly won at the mines and in the ser- vice of the railroads. By not taking warn- ing from the changes already wrought, he is thus widening the opportunity for the aggressive colonists who are coming to fill the gap. The wiser heads perceive all this, and foresee its consequences. Hence the anti- American sentiment already noted as be- ene ar fee at De, Sf ie mnt se PEEL RD ee MR ors aa Be
Page 12
The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134 ginning to spring up, the general increase of ancient usage in almost every country any of the largest landholders to sell at any price. It will be hard to dispossess | sturdy Dons of their broad acres zh a multitude of the lesser ranchers t inevitably succumb One device for their undoing is destined to hasten their itastrophe far beyond the effects of nor- mal competition Several years ago the Mexican Government granted a so-called concession to Don Luis Martinez de ba) y y ( tro. one of the most astute lawyers and politicians in the State of Sinaloa The ivowed purpose of this contract was to minate all faulty land titles, and to ] rmine with exactness what lands were held by perfect title, all others then becom « baldio—that is, public and open to lo The concessionaire was accord nly required to survey, at his expense, } lands of the State, and was given yw to summon all landholders to pro their titles, in accordance with which nd the laws touching the questions of masiaa and excedencias* the boundaries to be adjusted and permanently fixed 1! marked. The gaps thus discovered be neighboring estates would, of course, as likewise would be all other which perfect title could not be n compensation for these services sionaire was to receive one- third of all lands declared baldio in the ta and to have the right to locate in m wrdance with the land laws as much of such lands as he might choose rhe only limitation of this right was that eded to the original occupants of lands whose title proved faulty, whereby they might, within a specified time, re- habilitate their claim to ownership by purchasing the land back from the Gov- ment and the concessionaire at the Gov- ment price per hectare, which at pres- en s $1.30 silver, or nearly 53 cents per I s method of farming out a_ public fun mm to an individual, whose self-inter- yould naturally cause him to subvert r than sustain the old claims to title, Is one with which the foreigner can ! no quarrel, if it pleases the people choose to adopt and submit to it fact, at the present time, it is operating ictly in the interest of the foreigner, this princely grant has been conveyed by the original concessionaire’ to the naloa Land Company, a corporation financed and managed in the United States Whether it pleases the people of Sinaloa is her question. It undoubtedly is accep- ble to many who have valid titles, and its x chaos of conflicting pretensions to ship can be only beneficial. It makes stability and producing mendously for financial progress but it is distress among a large, itndus- trious population, which finda itself threat- ned with reduction from a state of agri- il independence to one of complete epend © upon daily wage, or to possible incy under landlords To appreciate the opportunities for the acquisition of valuable lands through the operation of this survey concession, one needs to go back to the rise of an old in stitution in Mexico, which had the sanction | leva, p. 205 |} ence to ind values, and the unwillingness of in Europe, with Far Eastern prototypes | carrying the custom back into the unre- membered past. This was the village com- munity, from which so many of our com- mon-law ideas as to mewm and tuum are derived. In its essence it is a social soli- darity, confirming by official instrument, in an extended and more highly differentiat- ed form, the tribal relation of individual to individual and to the group. The rapid growth of the missions in Mexico among a people of sedentary habits, and the co-fra- ternity established in these groups, which were as essentially industrial as they were religious, tended naturally to just such a democracy as one of these village communi- ties finally became. The recognition of ab- solute equality among all the members of a group was necessary as a means for dis- cipline under that theocracy which the priests sought to establish, and in large part did maintain. Accordingly, royal let- ters-patent were issued to such groups of individuals for lands to be held and enjoyed en mancomunidad. A fundo legal of the “pueblo” was set aside, 1,200 raras square, with the village church in the centre, for- ever inalienable from the pueblo or com- munity as a whole; a very close analogue to the old English village-green. Outside of this lay the ejidos, for residences and private gardens, and surrounding these in turn lay the terrenos for general agricultur- al and pastoral uses. The boun- daries were determined by refer- well-knoéwn geographical fea- tures as landmarks, all duly set forth in the royal patents; but unfortunately these documents undertook to declare the areas of the lands included within the boundaries, which necessitated rude guesses at the dis- tances between landmarks. In level coun- try the errors need not have been very great, but in the mountains it was nearly all the result of surveying by the eye and the judgment of the observer, aided now and then by a compass. This laxity on the part of the peritos or estimators (we dare not call them surveyors) extended to all lands, so that in effect a recognition and certificate of landmarks was about the sum total of the benefits secured through their services. From this has arisen the con- flict of boundaries which the recent survey concession is destined to remove. Whether copies of these ancient titles were kept in Spain or not, certain it is they were not recorded in Mexico. It was assumed that a man would guard his own. If he lost the very necessary royal charter to his an- cestral acres, so much the worse for him, sary effect in bringing order out of the | regardless of warfare, fire, and the “moth and rust” that doth corrupt. It probably assumed also that the Church was the. greatest and most enduring fact in these communities, and that the priest, with his strong-box, was the natural protector of the people’s interests; therefore, that the pueblos’ titles would rest securely in the inviolable sanctity of the house of God. Such, in truth, Is the view expressed by many a padre in his memoirs and corre- spondence. To-day it is indeed a rare pueblo that has its priest; that does not see ite church in ruins; that does not hunt in vain for its precious titles, or treasure some torn, dis- | colored fragments, or perhaps a rude copy, lacking in some essential to establish its authenticity. Sometimes, in the last ex- tremity, after loudly proclaiming ‘‘Tenemos los titulos ilesos’” (We have the titles free from injury), they produce in court an unattested document, setting forth that such a one conveyed to such another his rights under a title, etc., giving dates and extracts perhaps from the original title, but insufficient to do more than establish what the universal testimony of all men for leagues around would have equally and better confirmed, viz., that the parties pre- tending to ownership had inherited from their immemorial ancestors lands recog- nized as theirs by virtue of an ancient royal grant. To the mind of the layman the existence of the pueblo, with its pop- ulation so long rooted to the soil; the tra- dition in favor of inheritance from early ancestors who as a group received recog- nition of an ancient sort of tribal right to the soil, thus generously and justly con- firmed by monarchs zealous, as all the world knows, for the welfare of their In- dian subjects; the general assumption that the land is more likely to belong in strict justice to those who, as well as their fathers and grandfathers before them, were born and reared upon it, than to some one else who perhaps never even looked (unless per- chance once or twice in envy) upon the soft beauty of its fertile vegas and swelling wooded uplands—to the mind of the layman these things are sufficiently conclusive, and he would know how to frame laws to pro- tect helpless men and women and children in such rights. But the law flourishes in a realm of logic apart; and in the end, after the wave has swept over, others will come maintaining a tenure which will bear analysis under: this inscrutable logic. After all, it is no more inscrutable than nature’s disregard of the individual in the general scheme of racial development. The immediate effect is that vast seeming injustice is to be done, people rendered homeless, desperate ones robbed by disrepu- table lawyers, who, instead of advising their clients to “agree with thine ad- versary quickly, whiles thou art in the way with him,” will encourage them to cast aside the scanty relief which the law af- fords, in reliance upon a hopeless contest on flimsy documentary evidence of rights, exhausting the last dollar that had better have been paid out for a new title. Some of the herederos (for the owners of right in these pueblos are, in both common speech and in legal phrase, called heirs), have taken refuge in the arms of the money- lender, sacrificing large areas to protect their houses and garden plots, which, how- ever, is the most rational procedure, under the circumstances, for those communities which are financially powerless. The tide of foreign colonists is just set- ting in upon Sinaloa. It will be at full flood in about twelve months, by which time, the Yaqui, Guadalajara and Pacific Railway, as the Southern Pacific calls its west coast line, will be well on the way to Cullacan. It is now completed from Guaymas to Torin, on the Yaqui River, and is being built northward from Mazatlan at the same time. Shiploads of steel rails have arrived at Guaymas and Mazatlan, and other shiploads are afloat. It is signi- ficant that the Southern Pacific Company has found the cheapest market for steel rails for Mexico to be, not in the United " ——_—-.
Page 13
A wits tie MS ak tae aerate ocean hi C ateed May 24, 1906] The Nation. — States, but in the English-managed iron and steel works of Spain. It was widely reported at one time that the Gould inter- ests were supplying the sinews for the Kansas City, Mexico and Orient Railway, which contemplates a trunk line from Kan- sas City to the splendid port of Topolo- bampo, of which a portion is now built in the United States, another section com- pleted and operating on the central pla- teau of ‘Mexico to the eastern base of the Sierra Madre, and a third section open for traffic from Topolobampo, sixty miles east- ward to Fuerte. It is difficult to understand how such experienced railroad managers could have permitted so important a con- cession as that for a north-and-south coast line through the broad, fertile plain front- ing the Gulf of California to escape them It was a vital point in the success of the transcontinental railroad; necessary as a feeder, without which practically no through freight to and from the west coast can be expected to choose that route. The Southern Pacific has made a great strategic move in securing the concession. It makes that company master of the situation, able to develop one of the few rich virgin areas of large size north of the Isthmus of Te- huantepec, and to offer an outlet via Ma- zatlan, Tepic, and Guadalajara to the cen- tral plateau, the City of Mexico and At- lantic tide-water at Vera Cruz, and in the other direction via Guaymas, Mex., and Benson, Ariz., to the great transconti- nental trunk line east and west. The agricultural and mineral wealth of the territory thus controlled is enormous. It is a fair presumption that systematic adver- tisement of the region as one with lands as rich as, and a climate softer than, Califor- nia will produce here a vast boom in real estate, and a crowding in of fugitives from Northern winters to revel in the balmy air, and to make merry amid the ideal beauties of rocky promontories and blue sea and dashing surf of Mazatlan, at once the most picturesque and salubrious port in the southern latitudes .of North America. COURTENAY DE KALB. JAPAN'S FIRST POST-BELLUM BUDGET Tokio, April 24. 1906 Let me begin this letter by saying that, misled by a usually trusty source, in my letter of March 31 I included in the list of foreign war loans a 4 per cent. 100-mil- lion loan which antedates the war. The part of war costs thereby balanced is cov- ered by loans authorized in the new budget. The Diet met on December 25, organized, was formally opened by the Emperor, and immediately adjourned till January 22 Meanwhile, the Ministry changed The Katsura Cabinet, first organized as a make- shift, was the longest-lived and most eventful since the Constitution took ef- fect. In war, it won the people's trust and praise. It became a victim of unpopu- lar terms of peace. Deaf to rising clam- ors for an extra session of the Det to let the nation share in plans for peace and fiscal readjustments, it meanwhile placed large foreign loans in July and November After the “Portsmouth surrender,” unwise police methods turned protests into riots A late promise to convene the Diet on the return of the peace commissioner from Portsmouth endangered treaty ratifica- tion, and so, unkept, became a faup pas After that, prolonged discussion and small concessions at Pekin brought more sur- prise and disappointment Strong re- straints on press and agitators kept firm the Ministry's grasp on Government, but acted as a ceaseless irritant In time, the nat'on saw that Russia’s vitals were safely wrapped in thousand-leagues, that ‘awakened China” is, like other States, a suspicious ingrate with new confidence of strength, and that some such terms at Portsmouth and Pekin were after all in evitable. Meanwhile cleavage between Ministry and nation became a chasm. Un- usually late assembly and the long New Year vacation of the Diet allowed the Min- istry unhindered to bring negotiations for ending war to a close. Then, even before Baron Komura was back from Pekin, it adroitly passed the reins of Government over to the Saionji Ministry, and so smoothed the way for post-bellum read- justments. The change of Ministry before the Diet could strike a blow deftly dissipated a pent-up storm. Many things favored the smooth and rapid working of the Diet, and gave an amazing sum of legislative grist The new premier, Marquis Saionji, en- joys the twofold prestige of liberal views and aristocratic associations. Successor of Marquis Ito as head of the Seiyukai (Friends of the Constitution), he was sure of devoted support by the strongest po- litical party—for in Japanese politics per- sonal attachments have greatest weight. By a catholic choice of colleagues, he avoided the resentment of those whooppose party government, and also conciliated a variety of influential interests. While oth- ers had sharply criticised the recent policy of the Katsura Cabinet, he kept an “open mind,” and rather upheld the unpopular measures as unavoidable. Aid and sym- pathy, won by his tactful leadership, made expeditious and fruitful what was expected to be a stormy and intractable Diet. In presenting and explaining the budget, both Premier and Finance Minister disarm- ed opposition by the frank avowal that the new Ministry had perforce adopted the budget of its predecessor, and so could be responsible only for its execution; that for want of time it had Deen unable to shape post-bellum plans for industrial and com- mercial expansion. In its main features. the budgetary scheme includes the budget proper, which is divided into ordinary and extraordinary parts; two supplementary budgets to cover deficits; a special supple- ment to complete the war budget, which is treated as a unit; a bill to continue the special war taxes; and a bill to create a sinking fund for extinguishing the war debts—the last two features being em- boilied in separate laws. With only slight changes, this scheme was made law. In the normal budget and in each supplemen- tary budget, some part of the expenditures had been paid and some part of the loans placed by authority of Imperial decree. Furthermore, the war policy of economy by postponing public works of less urgent na- ture was continued, and the sums so saved were used to balance budgetary accounts But, as much analysis and detail would be confusing, a summary statement of the main results will best show post-bellum fiscal measures and conditions The first supplementary budget covers out of Treasury surplus, a war contingent fund deficit of 7.2 million yen for the last fiscal year. The second supplementary budget pays another deficit of 46.7 million yen, viz., 43.35 millions debt redemption paid from the last foreign loan, and 3.36 millions military pensions and sundry ex penses paid from Treasury surplus The war supplementary budget borrows 450.46 million yen to pay costs of repatriating troops, military and naval rewards, enter- prises in Mantchuria and Korea, and defi cits caused by rising prices Of this sum 88 millions had been borrowed, leaving only 362.45 millions to be placed Furthermore in connection with the purposes of the first supplementary and the war supplementary budgets, payments of 28.8 and 60 millions respectively had already been made by au thority of Imperial decree, and so do not figure in the budgets All the supplemen tary budgets were voted as proposed In the normal budget, the main change made intheGovernment proposals was a re duction of five millions in expenditures for army and navy restorations, and a corre sponding reduction in the amount of loans required to balance the budget As adopt ed by the Diet, the normal budget for 1906-07 balances thus Revenue. Expenditure Yen Yen 191,186,958 .354,025,475 96,711,614 132,973,007 Ordinary Extraordinary Total .. 487,808,572 487,808,572 The ordinary revenues are drawn from taxes, stamp and custom duties—together 278.3 millions; from Government = en terprises and property 104.4 millions (to bacco monopoly 30.3 millions, salt monop- oly 26.3 millions, railways 10.1 millions, posts and telegraphs 30.2 millions, forests 5 millions, convict labor 1 million), from interest and income from special funds 6 millions, from miscellaneous 2.5 millions Extraordinary revenues include mainly 14.2 millions yielded by the sale of state prop- erties, 2.2 millions taken from the forestry fund, 2.9 millions miscellaneous, and a bal- ance of 75.8 millions raised by loans On the side of expenditure, the most striking fact is its increase. Put beside the average expenditures for the last three years before the war (1902-1904), the facts are (million yen): Yearly average. Budget, 1902-04. 1906-07. Increase Ordinary ‘ 167.1 354.9 187.8 Extraordinary oooe SZ 133. $1.5 TOO . cevesenes 268.6 487.9 219.3 To the increase of ordinary expenditure the war added directly 172.5 million yen, viz., sinking fund for war-debt interest and redemption 110 millions, pensions and an- nuities 32 millions, expansion of the army 10 millions, for the navy 4.9 millions, posts and telegraphs in Korea and Mantchuria and Saghalien 1.7 millions, costs of salt mo- nopoly and tax collection 14.5 millions These expenses must continue thirty years or more. Of the extraordinary expenditure, the war gave rise to 79.5 millions, which go through a contingent fund to army and navy restorations (45 millions), establish- ment and maintenance of garrisons in Mantchuria and Korea (20 millions), and ” OH
Page 14
The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134° About 40 millions of this sum instalments on expendi- tures which must continue for at least six Other extraordinary expenditures Hence sundry purposes. represent years are likewise of a recurring nature the normal budget of the next six years, if constructed on the basis of the present budget, would require at least 93 million yen yearly extraordinary expenditure, thus making a prospective yearly total expendi- ture of 447.9 million yen, é@. ¢., an excess over the average for the years 1902-1904 of 179.3 millions With no change of nues, that would mean after this year a yawning deficit of some 50 millions But in fact the present budget was con- structed mainly on the basis of retrench ment adopted during the war For new subsidies and enterprises and for resuming it appropri- Besides, reve- works suspended in the war, ates only about 10 million yen the schemes for post-bellum industrial and -long and much talk- ed about the Ministry for the next session of the Diet, and they must entail enlarged expenditures. Finally, the capital of the permanent funds which was used for the war should by law be re- stored. The Finance Minister informed the Diet that the Government could not now see its way to replenish those funds. Pre- sumably, it will soon try to do so. In the face of all these facts, increase seems more reduction of expenditures in the next few Meanwhile, the 16 millions this year obtained from the sale of war prizes will in the future fall away from the present amount of extraordinary income. Also, a 75.8 was needed to balance the present normal commercial expansion are promised by likely than any years loan of million yen budget In brief, the financial situation presented to the Diet in the budgetary scheme was this The war adds to the bonded debt * over 1,800 million yen, with yearly interest charges (after proposed conversions are made) of 82% millions. To pay this in- terest and cancel the principal, the Govern- aside a yearly sum of 110 sinking fund War pensions and annuities, military expansion and other new needs require an additional millions. As ment proposed to set millions as a yearly recurring sum of 62.5 a resource to meet this 172.5 millions of yearly recurring expenditure, it was pro- posed to perpetuate the new and increased with an expanded yield of about and to draw the remaining 12.5 war taxes 160 millions millions from the Treasury surplus. Again, in the extraordinary part of the normal budget, the war causes an expenditure of 79.5 million yen for army and navy restora- for creation and maintenance of gar- abroad sundry For that expense is covered by sums tions risons and purposes thie year obtained from the eale of war prizes and But about 40 millions of this sum yearly for six years, and no of revenue now exists to cover it The net result therefore is, that the normal budget this year could be borrowing 75.8 million least 40 millions of the so covered must recur yearly for six years But, the budget so balanced, the continued policy of retrench- ment has eliminated the less urgent expendi- tures by postponing the execution of works for which they were planned. Furthermore, it is commonly understood that schemes by loans must reeur after this year only by that at balanced yen, and sum from normal for post-bellum expansion, involving new and additional expenditures. must be adopt- ed by the next year’s Diet. The whole scheme thus outlined is now law, but it was a big and bitter pill. In three points especially it was assailed by Diet and press, viz., the creation of a sink- ing fund, the continuation of the war taxes, and the resort to loans for balancing the normal budget. The sinking fund of: 110 millions is solely to pay interest, and in about thirty years to cancel the principal of the war debt. Many thought it unwise thus to pledge a yearly sum equal to 65 per cent. of the whole ordinary revenue just before the war. It would hamper fiscal ad- ministration, put on the people unduly heavy burdens, surrender control of re- sources which might at times be more ad- vantageously used, restrict the power by limiting the means for post-bellum expan- Such an engagement now was hasty, because fiscal readjustments are not yet clear and settled. Worst of all was the means to maintain the sinking fund, viz., to continue the hastily devised and tem- porary war taxes en bloc, and still to bal- ance the normal budget with new loans—a course that would injure the nation’s credit more than the sinking fund would raise it. Finally, the Opposition was irritated by the report that the Government had, with- out authority of the Diet, through its finan- cial agent in England, stated its intention thus to deal with the war debt. Against perpetuation of the war taxes, it was urged that they were hastily devised and contain- ed some specially bad features; that the vation accepted them with slight consid- eration or discussion, from patriotic mo- tives and because of the clear provision that they should end within a stated time after the end of war; that to continue them without revision was to break faith with the people after their loyal support of the and deliberately to fix on a heavily people a radically bad scheme of taxes. Finally, the critics argued that the Ministry props up its bad financial scheme by balancing the normal budget with loans which seemingly must be recurrent. Hence, in their opinion, the sinking fund to main- tain the nation’s credit rests partly on a bad tax.system and partly on recurrent In short, the Government proposes to pay its debts and provide means for expansion by making more debts. This leads Count Okuma and others to deprecate “the present Government's loan policy.” In reply to anxious questions in commit- -for party councils the struggle was decided—the Government .said that the sinking fund was absolutely neces- sary to maintain national credit, especially with foreigners; that it would be efficacious sion. war taxed loans. tee there and in in doing so; that such maintenance of credit was needful both to bear the war burdens and to get means for future ex- pension; that continuation of the war taxes was an indispensable support for the sink- ing fund and other new expenditures; that the Government would seek new sources of revenue to substitute for loans in the fu- ture normal budget; that, while the Govern- ment regretted the necessity of both meas- ures, there was no other way out of the present situation; that therefore the cre- ation of a sinking fund and the continuation of the war taxes were the main basis of the present budget and of future financial pol- ley The Government pressed these meas- ures with all its power, and it was rumored that their failure would cause the Finance Minister to resign. Strong elements of op- position in all the political parties brought, as usual, a compromise. The Lower House agieed to pass the measures. The Ministry egreed to appoint a comprehensively rep- resentative tax commission which should make exhaustive investigation and report within two years a scheme for tax revi- sion, the Ministry to ask this Diet for an averopriation to pay the costs. The ap- propriation to pay the costs of a tax com- mission was, however, rejected by the Up- per House. Meanwhile the budgetary scheme became law. This is in itself a feat, for Japan's budget is usually born in travail—sometimes with the aid of tie Em- peror’s prestige; and sometimes it ‘s still- born, being, by constitutional provision for failure of the Diet to act, merely a con- tinuation of the last year’s budget. A few other facts will complete the sur- vey of Japan's financial condition as shaped by the new budget. After deducting from the loans authorized in normal and ail sup- plementary budgets those which had already been raised, there remained a total of about 425 million yen to be borrowed. The Finance Minister hinted that the in- demnity receivable from Russia for pri3zoa- ers’ maintenance might be used to reduce this sum. But, assuming that the whole 425 millions are floated at 5 per «ant. at home. then Japan's national debt will by pierent plans take this approximate form: DEBT GROWING OUT OF THE WAR WITH RUSSIA. Amount Yearly interest (million yen). (million yen). Foreign bonds @4%4% ....... 600. 27. Foreign bonds @4% ..... 500. 20. Home bonds @5% .. 706. 35.25 Total war debt .......... 1,808. 82.25 DEBT NOT CONNECTED WITH THE RECENT WAR. Foreign bonds @4% ......... 100. 4. Home bonds @65%..... about 475. 23.75 Total of other debt ...... 575. 27.75 Grand total national debt. .2,380. 100.00 Of the above debt not connected with the war, two blocks of “Home bonds” aggre- gating 93 millions were in the past sold in London. Of the war debt, “Home” 6 per cents, which are being converted into 5 per cents, were sold abroad to the amount of about 130 million yen. The new sinking fund to deal with the new war debt and o her existing provisions to pay the debt ne: connected with the recent war will. it th> plans are carried out, extinguish the whole national debt within the next thirty- five years. To sum up, Japan's first post-bellum in- ventory shows, as liabilities, her debt quadrupled by a net addition of 1,800 mil- lion yen, her yearly expenditures almost doubled, most revenue organs hard -worked, her financiers still seeking some needfal revenue resources. As assets, she finds still growing trade and industries, a larger ficld with much natural wealth, release from some overhanging dangers, an als:t CGov- ernment and people, a new national con- sciousness, credit and prestige. For her, the fruits of war weigh heavily in both scales. BE. H. Vickers.
Page 15
May 24, 1906] The Nation. Notes. We learn, pleasurably for the author's sake, that Mr. James Ford Rhodes’s great task, a history of the United States from 1850, is now closed with two final volumes which will appear in November (Macmil- lan). As it stands and may stand, it covers a little more than a quarter of a century, for Mr. Rhodes has receded from his orig- inal intention to make 1885 his goal, and ends instead with 1877—that is to say, with the culmination of the reform movement which thwarted Grant’s third-term adven- ture, which signally revived in 1884 and again in 1892, and has since been nearly dormant except sporadically. A new translation of the Arabic fables known as the ‘Kalilah wa Dimnah’ is at present in course of preparation by Prof. Morris Jastrow, jr., of the University of Pennsylvania, together with two of his students, the Rev. William J. Hinke and Mr. Ellwood Austin Welden. Though the work is rapidly progressing, the book can scarcely be finished before a year or so. The authors expect to make a comparison of the text of the Beirut edition, on which their translation is based, with the other Arabic versions, and later to compare the Arabic with the Sanskrit, Syriac, and He- brew’s recensions. The book, when com- pleted, will make two volumes, the first being devoted exclusively to the trans- lation, and the second containing a gen- eral introduction, together with notes and illustrative material bearing on the text. The University of Chicago Press is on the point of publishing ‘The Legislative History of Naturalization in the United States,’ by Frank George Franklin. ‘The Mother of Clubs: Caroline M. Sey- mour Severance: An Estimate and an Ap- preciation,’ edited by Ellen Giles Ruddy, will issue from the Baumgardt Publishing Company, Los Angeles, Cal. The “World’s Classics’ of the Oxford University Press are to be augmented by a thin-paper pocket edition of Shakspere in seven volumes or thereabouts, the text edited by Mr. Watts-Dunton, who supplies also a preface and a bibliography to each play, while Mr. Swinburne will give an in- troductory discourse on Shakspere and his art. A part of the set will appear in the autumn. The seeker after out-of-the-way knowl- edge will find much satisfaction in the ‘Al- legations for Marriage Licenses Issued by the Commissary Court of Surrey between 1673 and 1770,’ transcribed from the origi- nal documents. Of the said allegations, those dating from the year 1674 to the year 1692 are bound up in a volume pre- served in the Faculty Office; for all the later ones it has been necessary to exam- ine the original records, many of them in a very dirty and dilapidated state. It is reck- oned that there must be at least 9,800 of them in the MS. and not less than 20,000 names. The contracting parties appear to have belonged to every rank in social life, almost every town and village in Surrey being represented. A large number of the names known in past times in the Surrey parishes will be found in the collection. The book will be put out by Messrs. Goose & Son, No. 19 Rampart Horse Street, Nor- wich, in an edition limited to 100 copies. Forewarned, forearmed. The first-fruits of the lesson taught by the destructive fire in the Library of the University of Turin is a facsimile reproduction of a surviving codex, ‘Il Messale Miniato del Card. Nicold Roselli (detto il Cardinale d'Aragona).’ The prospectus of this enterprise, which is under the direction of the Royal Academy of Sciences of Turin, proceeds from the firm of Fratelli Bocca in that city (New York; Lemcke & Buechner). The reproduc- tion promises to be in all respects gener- ous, as befits a codex of such importance in the history of miniature iilumination A second edition of Thomas Gold Frost's ‘Incorporation and Organization of Cor- porations’ (Boston: Little, Brown & Co.) brings the book—a very good one for its purpose—down to January 1, 1906 (it was in 1905 that the first edition appeared). What has made a new edition necessary has been “the material changes made in the Busi- ness Corporation Acts’’ by State legisla- tures in a single winter. The author has revised his forms and added five hundred cases His Digest of Incorporation Acts covers one-third of the book; it begins to look, therefore, as if an annual reissue would be called for One of the White Man's most serious burdens is his State legislatures It is, of course, monstrous that incorporation acts should be continu- ally overhauled and changed as they are frequently in the interest of jobbery. A rational and well-drawn act ought to last for a generation at least. ‘Fiscal Reform: Speeches delivered by the Right Hon. Arthur James Balfour, M.P., from June, 1880, to December, 1905’ (Long- mans), betrays further on in the title the politico-controversial quality which per- tains to this volume of nearly 300 pages. It embodies, to wit, also “‘a reprint of the pamphlet ‘Economic Notes on Insular Free Trade,’ and letters from and to the Right Hon. J. Chamberlain, M.P. (September, 1903)."" The author offers it as a time- saving work of reference, and while it would suggest and bear a great deal of comment, we think none is necessary. Its place is in the hands of party men in Eng- land and in libraries generally. Similar remarks are in order respect- ing ‘Lord Curzon in India: Being a Selec- tion from his Speeches as Viceroy and Governor-General of India, 1898-1905" (Mac- millan), which has, what is lacking in Mr. Balfour's collection, explanatory notes, an index, and a portrait. This volume is much larger, too—of double the size, in fact, and is more manifestly a displaced statesman’s apologia. Lord Curzon’s political future, granted health, is likely to outshine Mr Balfour's. His selected speeches are for those who have to reckon with him’ in domestic politics, and again for all libra- ries. Mrs. Elizabeth (Robinson) Montagu (1720- 1800) was a great lady in London, where she had a salon, knew everybody, and was ealled “Queen of the Bluestockings.” In 1742 she married Edward Montagu, who died in 1775; he and the husband of the more famous Lady Mary Wortley Montagu were cousins. Elizabeth has a small place in literary history as author of an Essay on Shakspere (1769), answering Voltaire, and of three “Dialogues of the Dead” in Lord Lyttelton’s book, but chiefly by four volumes of her Letters, published in 1810 and 1813 by her nephew, Lord Rokeby. Her great-great niece, Mrs. Emily J. Climenson, has now edited, with great diligence, her correspondence to 1761, and so much more than edited it that the two handsome and liberally illustrated volumes (E. P. Dut- ton & Co.) might be styled a memoir. Ac cording to this filial biographer, her sub ject was a wholly admirable person, “pur est of the pure,” beloved by her depen dents, and “adored by men of all opinions.” “She was one of the first people to inati tute Sunday schools. She was as interested in Betty's rheumatism as she was in the conversation of a duke or a duchess, a discussion with bishops and Gilbert West on religion, or with Emerson on mathe matics, or Elizabeth Carter on Epictetus all came alike to her gifted nature.’ Yet this publication will hardly add to her laurels, for, though it contains letters from Burke, Johnson, Sterne, Young, and other eminences, it offers little beyond everyday gossip. Thus, the numerous references to Conyers Middleton, his books and his wives, include nothing more vital than his deathbed comment on the uselessness of medicines, and Mrs. Montagu's complaint (1751) of “an insolence in the booksellers a set of wretches that live by other people's wits,”” in proposing to print by subscription his works, for which they had paid his widow £300. More elaborate is this sarcasm (1740) on her connection, Lady Mary: “She is a woman of great family merit; she has banished her children, aban doned her husband.” Mrs. Climenson has all her great-great aunt's letters (between 7,000 and 10,000), enough to fill “a large bookcase” if printed entire. As she intends to handle the rest of them (probably the great majority) from 1761 to 1800, we may hope it will be done with stern compres sion The latest issue of ‘‘Newnes’ Art LI brary” (Frederick Warne & Co.), devoted to Fra Angelico, is true to type. There are the usual large number of fairly good re productions of works by the artist and the usual unimportant text, and there is no perceptible improvement in arrangement It will be neither more vor less useful than its predecessors. ‘The Drawings of David Cox,’ as publish- ed in the Newnes-Scribner “Modern Mas ter Draughtsmen,” will hardly add to the reputation of an artist already much over- rated, at least in England. As a man, Cox was deserving of affection and admiration, but his art is only a bon ordinaire. Cox is one of “The English Water Color Painters” treated of by A. J. Finberg in his little book on that subject in the Duck worth-Dutton “Popular Library of Art,” and Mr. Finberg treats him sanely, but the author’s remarks about Turner are more novel. Briefly, he maintains that much of Turner's later work was dominated by the desire for immediate effectiveness; that it made him vastly popular and successful at the expense of some of the finer qualities of his art; and that it is as far as possible from being the natural expression of his personality indulged in in spite of public misunderstanding. “He wishes either to conciliate, or to astonish, or to flout his audience,” and produced little work of pure inspiration, most of it being tinged with wilfulness and theatricality. The i! lustrations tend to reinforce the judgment of the reviewer that, taken all in all, Joha Sell Cotman was the finest artist among English landscape painters. eo ees
Page 16
4.28 Those who may wish to know what the art of Goya was like, and why he is so much talked of, will find little to their purpose in Richard Muther’s monograph in the Langham series (Scribners). There a good deal about Goya's relations to politics and history, something about his personal character, a little about his rela- tion to earlier and later painters, but nothing that gives any idea of his methods of painting, his technical merits or defects, the essential qualities of his work. It is a book about a painter, but not about painting Jerome Bonaparte,’ by Philip W. Ser- geant, B.A. (Brentano's), is a work made up from the best-known sources for this subject Jerome had most of the Bona parte defects and few of the Bonaparte virtues Mr. Sergeant writes only for the general public, but his literary powers are not sufficient to impart freshness or inter- est to such a personage. The author ap- pears capable of better work. Dr. Hyslop’s ‘Enigmas of Psychical Re- search’ (Boston: H. B. Turner & Co.) is essentially a compilation from the rec- ords of the Society for Psychical Research, interspersed with censures on the apathy of the religious and on a generation which remains stubbornly indifferent and unwil- ling to consider these matters scientifical- ly For the rest, the book has the well- known qualities of Dr. Hyslop’s work, which are not precisely calculated to stir the masses It may be hoped, neverthe- leas, that he may be more successful in raising a permanent endowment for the clentifi© prosecution of these researches than the British Society, which has not get collected the $40,000 it demanded as a minimum The ‘Robert Louis Stevenson Reader’ compiled by Catherine T. Bryce, an East- ern primary-school teacher, will find ac- ceptance outside the schoolroom. It is a mixture of simplified Stevenson biography and of his children’s poems. The numerous illustrations in color are anonymous, but successfully catch the Willcox-Smith and Greenaway manner and are truly decora- tive A useful and suggestive list of books for boys and girls about gardening is ap- pended to the May Bulletin of the Boston Public Library It includes the making and care of gardens, a few stories and poems, as, Celia Thaxter’s ‘‘My Island Gar den,” famous works containing descrip- tions of them, as, Homer's account of a Greek garden in the Odyssey and Haw thorne’s of an American garden in ‘The Old Manse,’ and the leading Aterican works on school gardens Three years ago, Messrs. Dodd, Mead & Co. put forth a blank book for original memoranda and for critical quotations call- od ‘Playa I Have Seen’—a recoré over which (if the playgoing was indiscriminate) the maker might gloat or blush, like Pepys, in secret Now the same firm issues in cor- responding shape a ruled tabular blank- book for ‘Magazine Articles I Have Read.’ The sections are classified by topics, and for those who feel the need of this sort of ald to memory it will be just the sort of ald they will like. The duodecimo volume is neatly bound in green cloth The last number of the Arche@ologia, the tracts of the Antiquaries of London, con- tains a particularly interesting series of articles. Four relate to things Roman or [Vol. 82, No. 2134 The Nation. | Romano-British, viz., theaccount of the Ex- cavations at Silchester for 1903 and 1904, by Mr. St. John Hope and Mr. George Fox, Mr. Ashby'’s account of those at Caerwent (Venta Silurum) for 1904, “The Linares Bas-relief and Roman Mining Operations in Baetica,”” by Mr. Horace Sandars, and Mr. Fox's “Notes on Some Probable Traces of Roman Fulling in Britain.” There are two on English churches, viz., Mr. Cheales’s description of the Wall-paintings in All Saints’, Friskney, Lincolnshire, and Mr. Webb’s “Notes on the Augustinian Priory of St. Bartholomew, West Smithfield’; there is a paper on the price of Judas, “The Thirty Pieces of Silver’ and the part they played in mediwval legend, by M. G. F. Hill; a paper by Mr. Clement Reid on the Island of Ictis and the Ancient Trade- routes to Britain, etc., etc. Most striking of all is Doctor A. J. Evans's account of the Prehistoric Tombs of Knossos, making up a third of the whole volume. This num- ber (vol. 59, part 2), like all the Society's publications, is profusely illustrated. A study of the situation in the Far East resulting from the recent war, and one to be warmly commended, is that of M. Louis Aubert, ‘Paix Japonaise’ (Paris: Armand Colin). One might nearly guess that the author has been a student of the Ecole des Sciences Politiques from the care and tho- roughness of his method and from the im- partiality of his point of view. He al- lows no preconceptionof Japanese altruism to run away with his judgment, but, by copious quotations from Japanese states- men and publicists, draws reasonable con- clusions as to the near future of the East. If for a policy of a “Japanese peace” of the Orient the author had substituted a policy of “Hands off, Europe,” he might have been a shade closer the mark, but he would also have missed a good title for a good book. American commercial and political relations with the Far East are treated in chapters on ‘Japanese and Amer- icans”’ and “The Struggle for the Pacific.” We have received and, what is more, ex- amined with interest and profit the ‘Cata- logo Completo’ of the publications of the firm of Ulrico Hoepli in Milan, from 1871- 1905. The first date is that of the year fol- lowing the enterprising Switzer's arrival in Milan, and with a just pride he gives the chronology of his “‘vita editoriale libraria,” with all the appointments, decorations, and royal gifts which have attested his merit. Another shows his small beginning with two volumes in 1871, and his output of 144 in 1904 (in 1897, 157). Next follows a list, year by year, and month by month, of editions from July, 1896, to May, 1905, com- plementary to a similar one for the first twenty-five years in Hoepli’s jubilee cata- logue (1896). An aluthor-catalogue suc- ceeds, and finally a classed subject-cata- logue. The volume well betokens the com- piler’s sense of his honorable profession. Among his clients have been Rosmini, Scartazzini, Beltrami, Gubernatis, Lan- clani, Fogazzaro, Leo XIII. and Cardinal Mal, Luzzatti, G. Negri, Schiaparelli, and Villari. There is a notable line of man- vals, dictionaries, and ‘“‘libraries”; and juvenile books even of “indestructible” make are not infra dig. with this house. To the energetic bibliographical publish- er H. W. Wilson, in Minneapoiis, belongs the honor of having given American libra- rians for the first time an adequate and convenient record of their professional lit- erature. The first (April) number of his new periodical, Library Work, contains a “Bibliography and Digest of Current Li- brary Literature’ for the year 1905. Eventually the material will be cumulated, and it seems to be the publisher's inten- tion to cover some day the literature of past years also. A large number of the titles are accompanied by excerpts or sum- maries. In addition to this, the number before us contains various notes and news of interest to librarians, and a short ac- count of the H. W. Wilson Company, with pictures of its new building. Library Work is sent free to librarians on request. The library for April is a Shakspere number. It opens with some ‘Notes and Additions” to Mr. Sidney Lee’s Census of Copies of the First Folio, by: Mr. Lee him- self. Fourteen new copies have come to his knowledge since 1902, making a total of 172 copies now known to be extant. One of the new copies was in this country in 1902, five more have followed since. In all, 61 copies of the First Folio are in America at the present time, and Mr. Lee predicts that about 1915 there will be as many copies here as in Great Britain. As he already has announced in the Athenaum, the copy which is now the property of Mrs. Leiter in Washington (No. LIII. in the Census) is really a perfect copy; the pre- liminary leaf headed “‘A Catalogue of the Severall Comedies, Histories, and Trage- dies contained in this volume” being not missing, but bound in an unusual place. Among the other articles we might mention Mr. H. R. Plomer’s story of the vicissitudes of the “Printers of Shakspere’s Plays and Poems,”’ all, or nearly all, of whom seem to have been given to illicit printing, and Mr. Arundel Esdaile’s survey of the most important Shaksperian publications of the years 1091 to 1905, numbering nearly 170, with upwards of forty editions and trans- lations of his works. The San Francisco earthquake is the prominent subject treated in the National Geographic Magazine for May. Mr. F. L. Ransome, of the United States Geological Survey, gives his reasons for believing that it was of tectonic origin. He sketches the geological history of California, and main- tains, from the frequency of quakes—there were 768 shocks in California from 1850 to 1886,of which 254were recorded in San Fran- cisco—that the Coast Range is young and still growing. Hence the region, which is cut by long north-northwest faults into narrow blocks that are in turn traversed by many minor dislocations, is in unstable equili- brium. “Under the operation of the un- known forces of elevation and subsidence, stresses are set up which finally overcome the adhesion of the opposing walls of one or more of the fault fissures, an abrupt slip of a few inches or a few feet takes place, and an earthquake results.” The records of the earthquake written by the seismo- graphs at Washington and Cheltenham, Md., are also described, from which it appears that the time taken for the waves to cross the continent, 2,450 miles, was 6 minutes and 46 seconds. Mr. H. L. Bridgman gives an account of a voyage up the Nile to the head of navigation, Gondokoro, the most novel part of which was the passage through the sudd, He received a very fa- 2th lagna Sheth Ohya he Mahe tm 5 WO 1 Bs er te tose it #4.
Page 17
May 24, 1906] vorable impression of the country under Anglo-Egyptian rule, and prophesies a prosperous future from the inexhaustible richness of the soil and adaptiveness for raising cotton, wheat, cane, rubber, and tropical fruits. The remaining articles are upon the recent eruption of Vesuvius and the spring “break-up” of the ice of the Yukon. An International Type-Facsimile Society (“Gesellschaft fiir Typenkunde des 15 Jahr- hunderts"’) has recently been formed witb Dr. K. Haebler of Dresden, Dr. E. Voul- liéme of Berlin, Dr. H. O. Lange of Copen- hagen, and Dr. I. Collijn of Upsala among the leading spirits. The purpose of. the Society is to issue facsimiles of the types of as many incunabula as is practicable, giving two facsimiles for each type—Firstly, one full page of each in the original size, containing the M- or Qu-form on which Dr. Haebler based his classification in the ‘Typenrepertorium,’ and also a set of fac- similes of as many of the letters of the alphabet used as possible. Each member of the Society will have the right to ask for the inclusion of one facsimile. The annual fee is not expected to exceed 25 marks. The life-membership fee is 500 marks. The treasurer is the bookseller, Rudolf Haupt, in Halle a. S., who will handle the publi- cations of the Society. The expedition fever has taken hold even of Switzerland, notwithstanding its inland position. The ogy in the University of Bern, Dr. Wal- ter Volz, will head an exploring expedition into the practically unknown Hinterland of Liberia, penetrating from Sierra Leone. The funds are furnish- ed by the Geographical Societies of Switzerland, and the purposes in view are as much commercial and industrial as eth- nographical and geographical. The scien- tific collections are to become the property of the museums of the Republic. The first of the North German universi- ties to agree to the matriculation of women is Jena, the territorial institution of the Thuringian States. Women are to be ad- mitted to all the facuities. As is well known, only the six universities of South Germany have hitherto consented to this innovation, while those which in scholar- ship and prestige stand highest in the Em- pire, namely, Prussia’s, are almost aggress- ively hostile to it. Not a few of the pro- fessors in these universities, in the list of courses offered, expressly advertise the fact that women will not be admitted to their lectures. Still, even here the ice is gradually breaking. The authorities in Berlin have announced that hereafter women students need no longer secure the special permission of each docent to attend his lectures, except in cases where the pro- fessor has especially announced that such permission is indispensable. In the office or “Quaestur” a list is displayed of those who do and those who do not admit women. Leipzig, again, has just de- cided that, beginning with the present sum- mer semester, women, with the proper testimonium maturitatis, may be matricu- lated, but they will not be admitted to ex- aminations in the law and the theological departments. privat-docent of zodl- The third volume of Smyth's Writings of Benjamin Franklin (Macmillan) con- tinues the chronological development of The Nation. Franklin's career as scientist and poli- tician. His activities in this period, 1753- 1759, wére many. The Academy was a favored scheme until it ran down under Dr. Smith, against whom Franklin had a grievance. Electricity, water-spouts, and house-heating gave rise to many an ex- periment and homely examples in illus- tration of his fondness for theorizing. The Almanac appeared regularly, and the im- mortal ‘Way to Wealth’ was thrown to- gether in 1758. As postmaster, Franklin gained influence and favored his news- paper; as a public man, he supported a militia law, opposed the claims of the proprietaries to be exempt from taxes, and drew up a plan of union for the eolonies He was sent to England to present the case of Pennsylvania, and the letters writ- ten to his wife during this visit are among the most characteristic in the book. The description of an outfit needed by a printer in 1753 is of high interest, and it is shown that Franklin was interested in printing- offices from Antigua to Boston, aiding his nephew Mecom in the West Indies and Parker in New England The editing is well done, and only one slip attracts no- tice—a variation in the spelling of the name Lutwidge. Mr. Smyth's resort to the original manuscripts shows that former editors have made one letter from extracts of two or more papers, and our editor has proved in more than one instance that matter has been omitted for no good rea- son, and that a draft is fuller than the letter as sent. Corrections in names and dates enhance the value of this edition —The Transactions of the Royal His- torical Society’ (vol. xix., new series) for 1905 contains, besides the presidential ad- dress, some eleven research papers com- municated by as many investigators The retiring president, Dr. G. W. Prothero, de- livered his farewell on February 16, 1905, his central theme being the relation of his- tory to both literature and science In general his attitude is a well-balanced re- action against the ultra-scientific concep- tion of history. The gist of his contention is that “a well-written book is a work of art; and the writing of history partakes at least as much of art as of science. If it is said that history is science, I reply that history is not science, and never can be science in the proper sense of that word— the sense that applies to astronomy, to physics, or to biology—the sense that dif- ferentiates science from knowledge I grant that the preliminary processes are scientific, or rather semi-scientific; for ab- solutely scientific they can never be. But in compacting these results into a fin- ished whole, in laying them before the reader, we pass into another field—the fleld of art” (p. 20). The somewhat labored conclusion is sound enough, if not exactly original. Incidentally Dr. Prothero lets drop the interesting remark that competent historical scholars would, for the most part. name Gibbon as “the greatest of modern historians.” —It so happens that of the eleven mono- graphs contained in this volume the two from women’s pens are of peculiar interest Miss Enid Routh recounts from documen tary sources the English occupation of Tangier (1661-1683), and the story sounds like an early Philippine experiment in 429 miniature Pepys's sententious remark is cited: “It is plain that we do overspend our revenue; it is of no more profit to the kingdom than it was the first day no more people of condition willing to live there, nor anything like a place likely to turn his majesty to account; it hath been hitherto, and for aught I can see likely only to be, used as a job to do a kindness to some lord, or he that can get to be gov ernor”’ (p. 70) This has a very modern ring Miss E. M. Leonard discusses the inclosure of common fields in the sever teenth century, and insists that this pro: ess, instead of being temporarily arrested in that period, was continuous A curious bit of biography is rescued for us in the Rev. J. Neville Figgis’s paper on the me- diwval jurist, Bartolus (b. 1313) The claim is made that it was Bartolus and not | Grotius who is the real source of Interna tional Law The scholastic bent of Bat | tolus is well illustrated in the story re counted of his legal discussion of the prop erty rights of Lazarus after he rose from the dead The part that Americans are taking in the investigation of English his tory is shown by the fact that one of these eleven monographs—that on the Beginning of the King's Council-—-is the work of Pref James F. Baldwin, associate professor of history at Vassar; while the Report of the Council makes mention of the recent presentation before the Society of a paper on The Midland Revolt and the Inquisitions of Depopulation of 1607, by Prof. Elwin F Gay of Harvard, and also of the impending issue of ‘The Minute-Book of a Presbyterian Classis in the Reign of Elizabeth,’ edited by Roland G. Usher, a Ph.D. of the same university, already reviewed in these col umns Dr. Grenfell and Dr. Hunt, the Ox ford scholars who from the first have been in charge of the fleld-work of the Graco Roman branch of the Egypt Exploration Fund, and have proved themselves as skil ful in editing as they are expert in find ing ancient papyrus documents, have r¢ cently made an informal preliminary re port of the results of their excavations dur ing last winter and the early spring, at Oxyrhynchus. They report the most re- markable discovery yet made of literary papyri, with dates ranging from the se« ond century B. c. to the sixth century of our era. In a Roman mound a heap of broken literary papyrus rolls was discov ered. Amid hundreds of smaller fragments there were a couple of cores of rolls, each containing ten or twelve columns, several pieces containing five or six, and many con- taining one or two. One of the longer pieces contains about 150 verses of Pin- dar’s pwans, with the authorship proved by a coincidence with an already known Pin daric fragment. The text is accompanied by elaborate explanatory scholla. Another long poetical fragment is from the lost play, “Hypsipyle,” by Euripides Of the prose MSS. several belong to extant works of Plato, Demosthenes, Lysias, and Iso crates. The most valuable of the prose pieces is part of an unknown history of Greece, possibly by Ephorus or Theopom pus. Another prose text is part of a com- mentary on the second book of Thucy- dides, different from the extant acholia In another Roman mound, fragments were ee Pee PIO Pe pane ee Lata Te ie ode ame Oe ee ae me as PX ~
Page 18
430 [Vol. 82, No. 2134 found of a library of which the owner had been interested in the lyric poets, and seems to have owned two or three MSS. of Sap- pho's poems, as well as one of Bacchy- lides. One of these fragments of papyrus contains more than seventy lines of Cerci- das, of whom only fourteen lines were known before A Byzantine mound yielded a vel- lum leaf (forty-five lines in all) from a MS. of a lost gospel, telling of the visit of Jesus with his disciples to the temple at Jerusalem, and their meeting with a Phar- isee, who reproaches them with their fail- ure to perform the necessary ceremonies of purification before entering the holy place, and describes in some detail the formali- ties which he himself had observed. The question of the nature and value of the gospel to which this fragment belongs, is likely to provoke much controversy We will add that American scholars and libraries have not given to the Greco- Roman branch of the Egypt Exploration Fund the support which it deserves and might expect. It has published already in ix volumes about a thousand documents of the Ptolemaic and Roman periods in Egypt, of high importance for philological criticism and for historical and archwo logical studies; each document being pro- vided with introduction, commentary, and translation Now we learn of the most important discovery of all. Another eason’s work of exploration remains to be done at Oxyrhynchus, and subscriptions to the fund are urgently needed. The con cession for excavation closes next year The volume containing the documents just discovered is expected to be published in the summer of 1907, and will be sent to all ubseribers to the fund. The double vol- ume of Hibeh papyri will be ready ina few weeks. Annual subscriptions (five dol- lars) may be sent to the secretary of the Fund, Miss Grace I. Gay, Pierce building, Copley Square, Boston A third collection of historical por- traits, this time of the worthies of the eighteenth century, is on view at Oxford in the earlier portion of the series are pecimens from the brush of Sir Godfrey Kneller (« g., his portraits of Addison, of 'relawney, of Atterbury, ete.), and others f the foreigners by whom English art wis largely dominated at this period, side by side with works by a younger school, cesentially English in spirit and style Chief of this prosaic but most praise worthy band was Jonathan Richardson, represented here by his portraits of Mat thew Prior (Nos. 14 and 15) and of Hans Sloane (65) Hie was followed by Thomas Hiudson—his Archbishop Potter (64) is a magnificent figure-—and by such excellent portrait painters as William Hoare (George Grenville, 81) and Joseph High- more (Edward Young, 77). The first, how- ever, to shake off the tyranny of Kneller ind the fashion of the “face-painter” Hogarth Numtber 83, representing an “Assembly of Artista,” is from his hand liad it not been for him and Hudson's was great pupil, Sir Joshua Reynolds, the Brit ish school would most probably have died a natural death The work of Reynolds and of Gainsborough, Romney, Hoppner, Lawrence, the other great figures of the golden age of British portrait-painting, not to mention that of a number of other artists only inferior to these, is splendidly exemplified in the latter half of the collec- tion. Among the masterpieces are Sir Joshua's portraits of the poet Warton, of Lord Rokeby, of Archbishop Markham, and the famous Gibbon lent by Lord Rose- bery; so, too, are Romney’s Warden Oglander and John Wesley, Gainsborough’s Doctor Buckler, and lLawrence’s Lord Auckland, an astonishing performance for a youth of twenty-two. A word of mention must be given to the portrait of the Duke of Portland, by the American Benjamin West, and to the George III. and Queen Charlotte Sophia of the Scotchman, Allan Ramsay, who won court favor despite the claims ‘of Sir Joshua. -Taking it as a whole, the exhibition of this year compares more than favorably with those of 1904 and 1905. The per- sons represented, ecclesiastics, judges, doctors, statesmen, soldiers, are no less distinguished, while the works of art are far more attractive and more varied. Not only so, but, with the exception of three portraits of Gibbon—we have already men- tioned the Reynolds—all these fine pic- tures have been brought together from the halls, common-rooms, and official buildings of this one university. The catalogue, as usual, is excellent; Mr. Cust’s introduc- tion is valuable, and the notes on the pic- tures, with their racy morsels from Hearne, Wraxall, Walpole, etc., are capi- tal reading An illustrated edition will appear shortly after the close of the ex- hibition on the 24th of May (H. Frowde). BIELSCHOWSKY’S GOETHE. The Life of Goethe. By Albert Bielschow- sky, Ph.D. Authorized translation from the German, by William A. Cooper, A.M., Assistant Professor of German, Stanford University. Vol. L., 1749-1788, from Birth to the Return from Italy. Illustrated. Pp. xvi., 439. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1906. Was man in der Jugend wiinscht, hat man im Alter die Fille. To those who be- gan their study of the great German in the good old days when texts were slovenly, and explanatory notes conspicuous by their absence, and one had to construct one’s own biographical notions out of the clever flippancy of Lewes and the dry dust of Diintzer and Goedeke, the need of a real life was heartfelt. Of late years, indeed, much help has come. Apart from carefully annotated editions, there have been many essays and monographs from some of the soundest and most brilliant scholars in Cermany All these writings, however, were onlye partial; they gave us either views of Goethe from individual points, or discussions of certain periods or sides of his activity. It was reserved for Bielachowsky to make the bold venture of giving us the whole Goethe as he lived and wrought and triumphed, of drawing not merely the poet and student, but the man And this was a venture after Goethe's own heart, for was it not Goethe's doctrine that in every writer the essential thing is the man? Further, in addition to his courage, Blelschowsky has brought to his task the two Indispensable requisites: on the one hand, familiarity with the de- taille of Goethe research, a world of scholarship by itself; on the other hand, the ability to think and feel and enjoy independently and to write with clearness and charm. The present reviewer, who has waited long and impatiently for such a life, may well be forgiven, then, for be- ginning his remarks with one of Goethe's favorite adages. Yet, alas, to quote another well-worn adage: Habent sua fata libelli. Just as Bielschowsky was about completing his monumental work, he sank into the grave. Never very robust, he was doubtless worn out with his absorbing devotion at the age of fifty-five. The first volume of the German original appeared during his life, the second (and concluding) volume appeared the year after his death. The translator says in the preface: ‘“‘The second and last volume was so nearly completed before his death that it was an easy matter for others who were familiar with his methods and aims to finish it.” What is meant by finishing? If nothing more is meant than bringing the book to a typographical and edjtorial conclusion, the judgment may pass. But if to finish means to preserve the same vital, informing spirit to the last page and sentence, then the translator is much too optimistic. One consideration will be quite enough to make us pause. In the second German volume 112 pages are given to “Faust.” Now the veriest tyro ought to know that “Faust” is the reflex and running commentary upon the poet’s inner- most life, almost from boyhood to the grave. When we read in the yerman preface, then, that only the first 22 pages are by Bielschowsky and the rest by Theo- bald Ziegler, we can only shake our heads and ask, Do twenty parts Bielschowsky and ninety parts Ziegler form the Hinheit in- dispensable to any treatment, however humble, of the “Faust’’? Verily, one need not be a witch at a riddle to suspect more than one discord between Bielschowsky and his “finisher.”” The very opening sentence of Ziegler (p. 591), “Faust ist eine wirk- liche Persénlichkeit gewesen, vielleicht ein Schwabe aus Knittlingen,” etc., comes upon us, after Bielschowsky’s glowing generali- zations, with the shock of a cold douche. There are other discrepancies in this sec- ond German volume; some of them may even be due to Bielschowsky’s own method of composition, to a slight weakening of his hold upon the complex subject. All such considerations, however, need not in- terfere with our enjoyment and apprecia- tion of the volume before us, the first of the translation. Covering the first 417 pages of volume i. of the original, it ends with Goethe’s return to Weimar from his travels in Italy. It is, to speak in Ger- man, avs einem Gusas: a clear, homogene- ous, sympathetic, and illuminating narra- tive and estimate of the first thirty-nine years of Goethe's life. We lay stress upon the term “narrative’’; for the biographer’s method is essentially that of the narrator, who tells first and explains afterwards, or, rather, who lets the explanation grow out of the narration. The method is, we re- peat, after Goethe’s own heart; the ab- stract and general are evolved from the concrete. At all events, we learn to know Goethe the man, we gain an intuition of the creative spirit shaping things to its conscious or sub-conscious impulses. And those thirty-nine years determined Goethe's individuality, Though he lived almost for- en ~ ree
Page 19
May 24, 1906] ty-four years longer, though he produced after 1788 some of his best-known works. “Iphigenie,” “Tasso,” ‘Hermann und Doro- thea,’ the ‘Meister,’ ‘Elective Affinities,’ not to mention his scientific and critical writ- ings, all these later products emanated from a mind and were embodied in a style definitively formed. From 1788 on, there is endless variety, but there is no change. Our first volume, then, presents to us Goethe in his formative period. The study is one of surpassing interest and value. To watch the growth of any productive spirit is a gain; how great the gain wheh that spirit is one which touches life at almost every point, enters fearlessly into joy and sorrow, struggles on and on toward an ever higher goal, until it reaches the clear consciousness of its powers and its limitations, an object-lesson for all think- ers! Through a good part of this volume, pearly one-half, the biographer is inevit- ably in competition with his hero as au- thor of ‘Dichtung und Wahrheit’—a hope- less competition, of course; yet Biel- schowsky has, it seems to us, kept very happily the middle path between a mere echo and résumé of Goethe’s autobiography and a sham independence. He supplements, occasionally (though rarely) corrects, often presents the situation from a different side, and always guides his readefs to a more comprehensive understanding. Even the professed Goetheaner will return from Biel- schowsky to Goethe with enhanced plea- sure. The core of the volume is that part (pp. 254-367) which treats of Goethe's establish- ment in Weimar. Not that we think lightly of the concluding chapter, Italy; Bielschow- sky’s handling of Goethe’s peregrination in the land of art leaves little to be desired. Still, the ordinary reader knows at least something, right or wrong, of Goethe in Italy; and, after all, the connection be- tween literature and art is self-evident, whereas Goethe's early residence in Weimar is, even to the well-informed Anglo-Ameri- can, quite terra incognita. In truth, it is not too well known even to the Germans themselves, all but the chosen few. Court dissipation, frivolity, favoritism, desertion of the poetic vocation—all these sins and many more have been discovered in the first Weimar period. How fundamentally wrong such a conception is, our readers can learn from Bielschowsky. True, he is not the pioneer in this field; notably he was preceded by Adolf Schéll in the series of studies entitled ‘Goethe als Staats- und Geschaftsmann,’ published originally in the Preussische Jahrbiicher and republished in Stoll’s volume, ‘Goethe in MHauptziigen.’ For the ordinary reader, however, Biel- schowsky’s account is the more useful be- cause simpler, briefer, more genuinely bio- graphical. At any rate, we behold now for the first time in English garb the man who literally made Weimar, made it the centre not merely of literary and artistic impulse, but the starting-point in social and political regeneration. One of the pettiest of Ger- man states, Weimar became under his guid- ance the model for its more powerful neigh- bors. That harmony of interest which we call modern Germany and which was sealed in blood forty years ago on the field of Sadowa, started in Goethe’s Weimar; we refer our readers to the conclusion of Her- man Grimm’s romance, ‘Untiberwindliche * The Nation. Miachte.’ When, in 1782, Goethe accepted his patent of nobility and the presidency of the Weimar Council, he had already given more than he was receiving. No man saw more clearly, carried out more strenu- ously, the motto Noblesse oblige. During the eleven years from 1775 to 1786 he had but one abiding purpose—the regeneration of the duchy through the upbuilding of the young Duke. Accordingly, we see him throwing himself with wisdom and energy into everything, into finance and army re- form, into drainage, agriculture, forestry, mining, even into the fire department Common sense, improvement, enlighten- ment, humanity—above all, economy—were his ceaseless preachment Never has a young ruler been moulded for the right with such utter frankness, yet with such marvellous tact, as Karl August was mould- ed by his prime minister, only eight years his elder. When at last in 1786 the prime minister literally ran away to Italy to seek rest for the body and rejuvenation for the overworked spirit, he could whisper to him- self, as a nunc dimittis: My Duke is now able to rule without my daily presence. Naturally, the unsophisticated will ex- claim with honest regret: But all these years were lost for literature, for poetry; the genius of the German folk was fretting himself away over dollars and cents, min- isterial squabbles, court intrigues, bureau- cratic red tape. In truth, Goethe thought as much .n moments of despondency. More than once Pegasus was on the point of kicking over the traces and bolting. Yet Goethe's calmer mood always led him back to reason. He learned thoroughly the les- son which many of his readers are only now beginning to apprehend dimly, namely, that a great writer’s final training-school is life. In wrestling with the hard, arid actualities of life, Goethe acquired that poise of thought, that delicately adjusted moderation of utterance, which were to be thenceforth his chief distinction. A single quotation will make our meaning clear. A sufficient™number of our readers are acquainted with ‘Werther,’ the master- piece of Goethe's youth. It is a work of which any writer might be proud, and—in a sense —Goethe himself never produced anything better. It is powerful, elemental. Never- theless, in the light of Goethe’s maturer genius, it is crude; it is lacking in poise and moderation. We ask our readers to compare with it the following, from the paper on Granite, based on the notes taken by Goethe during his Harz trip in Decem- ber, 1777, though not worked out until 1784 (pp. 340-341): “I do not fear the reproach that it must be a spirit of contradiction that has led me from the observation and descfrip- tion of the human heart, the most recent, most complex, most mobile, most change- able, most perturbable part of creation, to the consideration of the oldest, hardest deepest, firmest son of nature. For it will readily be granted that all natural things have an exact relation to one another. that the searching mind does not willingly allow itself to be excluded from anything attainable. Let me, who have suffered and still suffer many things from the varia- tions of human emotions, through their quick changes in myself and in others, enjoy the sublime peace which that lonely, silent presence of great whispering nature be- stows, and let him who divines something of it follow me. “With these sentiments I approach you, ye oldest, worthiest monuments of time. Sitting upon «@ lofty, barren summit, and 431 overlooking a wide landscape, I can say to myself: ‘Here dost thou rest directly upon a ground that extends down to the deepest places of the earth; no newer stratum, no heaped-up, washed-together fragments have been deposited between thee and the solid bottom of the primeval world’ In this moment, when the earth's inner pow ers of attraction and motion are exerted upon me directly, as it were, when the in fluences of Heaven hover about me more closely, Iam attuned to the higher thoughts of nature, and, as the human mind is wont to see a soul and life in everything, there dawns upon my mind a comparison, the sublimity of which I cannot resist ‘So lonely,’ I say to myself, as I look down from this utterly barren summit, and even at the foot in the distance can scarcely see a bit of puny moss—‘so lonely,’ I say ‘will that man be who opens his soul to none but the oldest, first, and deepest fee! ings of truth.’ Indeed, he can say to him self: ‘Here, upon the oldest eternal altar, reared directly upon the depths of crea- tion, I offer to the Being of all beings my humble sacrifice.’ ”’ ‘Werther’ was completed in the midsum mer of 1774 We can now estimate the progress in these Weimar years The transition illustrates Goethe's brief essay on Imitation, Manner, Style, which, al- though aimed directly at art, is also appli cable to literature. ‘Werther’ is in the au- thor’s best “manner’’; the Granite essay is in his noblest “style.” High as we rate Bielschowsky's treatment of Goethe's first Weimar period, we feel constrained to admit that it might have been fuller in one respect, namely, in the elucidation of the purely personal element in the relation between Goethe and the Duke. Herein our biographer is less satis factory than Herman Grimm in his ‘Goethe Vorlesungen,’ ii. 1-22 (ed. of 1877), the lecture entitled “Carl August und Goethe in den zehn Jahren.” Grimm's tone could scarcely have been more delicately sympa- thetic had he been an eye-witness of this extraordinary friendship. His charm is due for the most part to his appreciation of Goethe's poem “‘Ilmenau,”” given entire in Von Loeper’s edition of the ‘Gedichte’ (ii. 36-41). Composed for the Duke's birthday, September 3, 1783, it remained in manuscript until published by Goethe in the 1815 edition of his works. In 191 verses the poet sketches with all his cunning a daring situation. The language is veiled, yet—to the initiated—the thought is obvi ous. The poet pictures a hunting party camped by a fire in the woods; some of the portraits are still recognizable Their youthful leader, however, is apart in a hut, aslesp. Approaching the hut, the poet is challenged by his double, watching over the sleeper. The watchman refuses to reveal clearly who and what the sleeper te With an indescribable mixture of delicacy and firmness he intimates his own shortcomings and their half-justification, but is scarce- ly able to tell whence he has come or how: Wer kennt sich selbst? As for the sleeper— “A noble heart turned aside from Na- ture’s path by narrow destiny — suredly the years will give to his powers their true direction; meanwhile, with all his fondness for the truth, error is his pas- sion. . . . Gloomily wild in mirth, bois- terous without gayety, bruised and wound ed in body and in spirit, he falls asleep on his hard couch, while I, silent and scarcely breathing, my eyes directed towards the free stars, half awake, half dreaming, can hardly shake off the dream-spell.” Truly, a unique blending of devotion and admonition. A word or two upon the translation. Evi- 7 et WR REDR eS, as ous Rh ee a> ARS yet OEE end oe a
Page 20
432 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134 dently it has been made with scrupulous care and regard to our English idiom. It reads smoothly and reproduces the orig- inal closely. The passage quoted from the paper on Granite is a fair specimen of the translator's skill in overcoming difficulties In view of this labor of love kept up through hundreds of pages, the generous eritie will refrain from harping on minutia We note only a few passages in which the ranslator has made what may be called a slip. The description of Wilhelm Jerysalem (p. 157) is searcely intelligible without the original (p. 159) And the same holds good of the paragraph (p. 207): “It was woman's work that compromised the mis- understanding between Goethe and the Ja cobis, etec.”’ The italics are ours; the orig- inal (p. 211) reads “Es war Frauenwerk das den Zwiespalt zwischen Goethe und den Jacobis ausglich.”"” Af page 231 the translator renders: “In ‘Lilis Park’ he [Goethe] has given us an exaggerated pic ture of such situations, portrayed in pas- sionate Storm-and-Stress style.” This is a heer perversion of the original (p. 234); Bielschowsky wrote: “In ‘Lilis Park’ hat einen mit genialer Heftigkeit gestei- gerten Reflex solcher Situationen hinter lassen."" That Goethe would ever have ad- mitted his charming little poem to be in passionate storm-and-stress style, we take “Lilis Park” was in of it, that it the liberty of denying; the storm-and-stress, but not and Bielschowsky has not said was of it In the publi matter of illustrations, the Ameri- can her has been generous where his German colleague was decidedly parsimo niou In this first volume alone we got ten, against two in the whole German orig inal Still, we should gladly have ex changed Goethe's House in Weimar for the rischbein Goethe in the Campagna, which opens the first German volume; this Tisch bein Goethe is the fitting accompaniment to the Italian Journey Paper and préss- work are excellent ENGLAND'S WHIG PARTY (1807-1821) lurther Memoirs of the Whig Party (1807- 1821) With some Miscellaneous Remin- cences By Henry Richard Vassall, Third Lord Holland Edited by Lorl ttavordal With Portraits. E. P. Dut ton & Co 1906 rhi an Old-World book, containing Old-World gossip, and written by an Old World politician Of new information it contains little or nothing; the topics with which it,is filled can but slightly interest the readers of to-day Few care to hear about the indubitable virtues and the equally indubitable dullness of the irre proachable Francis Horner. The vagaries the follies, the doubtful virtue, and the talnly hard treatment of Queen Caroline ran now evoke neither a tear nor a amil> The meannesses of her contemptible hus band are almost too petty to arouse indig- nation and now too unimportant to kindle active contempt Who can really care much about the dulness of Mr. Perc! val or even the so-called Peterloo mas- sacre, which, after all, to any student of the State trials, will seem to have been no massacre at all? The plain truth is that the heroes, the patriots, the intri guers, and the villains of 1815-21 were a very poor lot. Their goodness and their wickedness are equally interesting. Yet to Old-World character of Lord Holland's book lends it a curious interest. The read- er who learns from it nothing which is, taken in itself, of any great importance, is yet perplexed by one question which weil deserves consideration: Wherein consists the “Old-Worldliness” of the society vf which Lord Holland was at once the mem- ber and the chronicler Why is it, ia other words, that the England of 1807- 1821, which is divided from us by not quite a century, seems almost as unlike th» England of to-day as are the times of Charles II.? The first answer to this inquiry is, that the English society whereof Lord Hollani has painted to the best of his ability the and the follies, formed, even in his day, but a small part of the life of Eng- interests land. It was, after all, little else than a circle of Whig noblemen, of Whig writers, and of Whig politicians. It was a littte world which derived its importance from the special conditions of public life at the beginning of the nineteenth century. These conditions have changed, and no society now exists which really resembles the class of superior persons who met togeth- er at the dinners of Holland House. The reform of Parliament and all that went with than a mere redistri- parliamentary £10-householders; it of a con- it meant much more of seats, the franchisement of the meant at bottom the stitutional system under which the Crown, bution en- overthrow the nobility, and a certain number of rich virtually the body who No doubt took a part, in politics who nor men of it was difficult for any man to Parliament merchants were England men active ZoOV erned part, and an neither landowners but entrance effective were wealth or to life obtain into take less public un- the Crown, of wealth who the House of is that the Parliament more the sentiment of the mass of the electors than is generally any part in he in some found a patron in or nobleman or of True it man could dispose seats in Commons nearly represented supposed by observers who note only the anomalies of a representative system which might seem framed for the very object of not representing the will of the peo- ple A curious remark of Lord Holland's, that even the borough of Calne, where the Lansdowne “influence’’ was almost su preme, could probably not have been in- duced to return a member who should ad- vocate the resumption of cash payments, is significant Boroughs which were close or corrupt might occasionally, under the pressure of strong publi¢ opinion, show an unexpected independence. It may, in- deed, be doubted whether on any great question, such as the resistance to th: American Colonies, or the war with France, the unreformed Parliament ever substantially misrepresented the dominant feeling of the nation The system, however, which gave im- mense weight to influence and connection, made the personal character of a small body of statesmen and politicians of ex-~ traordinary importance. We feel through every page of Lord Holland's book the im- attributed in the political mense weight world of his day to the characters, the pe- culiarities, and even the manners of leading politicians. Hence the best feature of the Memoirs: they contain valuable pictures of individuals. Lord Holland, indeed, was not, from a literary point of view, a great art- ist. He was, moreover a thoroughgoing party man. He never for a moment forgot the principles or the prejudices of a good Whig—every one who opposed Fox was, in Lord Holland’s eyes, in the wrong. But, for all this, he was a man of sound sense and of great good nature,and was born with a certain natural kind of fairness; hence his sketches of contemporaries are always worth consideration. * Few things are better in their way than this summary of the character of the Mar- quis of Wellesley: “He had,” writes Lord Holland, “more genius than prudence, more spirit than principle, and manifestly de- spised his colleagues as much as they dreaded him. Unlike most English politi- cians, he was rather a statesman than a man of business, and more capable of doing extraordinary things well than of conduct- ing ordinary transactions with safety or propriety.”” Even to George the Third he is fair; at any rate he sees, what few Whigs could bring themselves to acknowledge, that the King, by whom at every turn they were defeated, was a monarch of some vir- tues and even of some remarkable though limited talents. “He was,’ to quote Lord Holland’s lan- guage, “a man of principle, honest, and anxious in forming his rule of action, sa- gacious in the application and steady in the observance of it; but then his views were narrow and mischievous, his judgments warped, and his feelings illiberal. His dis- trust of mankind made him deem insincerity necessary and justifiable. He practised dis- simulation, and in some instances simula- tion likewise, without scruple. If he had the heart of a courageous and the talents of a dexterous or shrewd man, he wanted the enlarged understanding which constitutes wisdom, as well as all elevation and re- finement of sentiment which shed so much lustre on rank. He was, too, a stranger to every generous affection which renders a prince either amiable or benevolent. There was nothing great, nothing kind, nothing open, nothing graceful in his character or manners.” This summary of George’s character makes, at any rate, intelligible the power which he in fact exerted. But even the authority which a King of England endowed with high courage, a strong will, inex- haustible industry, and, above all, unfath- omable cunning could exercise for nearly half a century, is a far less sure proof of the existence of a state of things utterly unlike the social and political situation of to-day, than the power ascribed by men of ability to a worthless and cowardly vo- luptuary such as George IV. Lord Holland’s Memoirs make it clear that, in the opinion of the Whigs, the Prince of Wales could, on becoming Regent, have transferred po- litical power to the friends and the flatter- ers of his youth. He could, they certainly believed, have reversed the policy of the nation. Whether, indeed, the faith of the Whigs in the power of the Regent would have turned out better founded than their trust in his promises and expressions of good will, may admit of question. It is, however, certain that the Regent, with all his defects, might, if he had possessed the requisite ability and character, have exer- cised an authority perhaps as great as that which falls to-day to an ordinary prime minister. However this may be, the expectations formed by friends and foes of
Page 21
tated es May 24, 1906] The Nation. the change which might be worked by the Prince of Wales becoming Regent, is proof, if proof were needed, that the Government of England lay, during the times in which Lord Holland was the chronicler, in the hands of a small body of wealthy men. It was in fact, though not in name, an olig- archy, among whom the King could, if he had chosen, or had possessed the requisite ability, have played a leading part. If, however, the first answer to our in- quiry is to be found in the change which the social and political conditions of Eng- lish social life have undergone since 1821, the true answer must go rather deeper than any reply which depends wholly upon the visible changes either in the form or in the working of the British Constitution. The most satisfactory answer which can be given in a few words, is that the ex- ternal revolution in the political life of England is merely the outward sign of a changed spirit. A man must be a bold op- timist if he can confidently assert that the Englishmen of to-day are better or wiser men than were their grandfathers. The man must be a confirmed pessimist who can express a confident assurance that the changes wrought by a century of so-called progress have wholly or mainly worked evil. All that a sensible observer can ven- ture to suggest is, that the England of 1820, whether better or worse, was in spirit no less than in institutions essentially dif- ferent from the England of 1906. A whole host of ideas, good and bad, which make up the public opinion of to-day, were, to judge from Lord Holland’s Memoirs, almost un- known to himself and his associates. Of theological disputes, except in so far as they touch directly upon politics—e. g., in the conflict over Catholic Emancipation— he writes little or nothing; for political economy or economical problems he and his friends cared, we may suspect, very little. No doubt in 1821 if you stepped out- side the society which had its centre at Holland House, you might have heard many things which did not interest the Whigs whom Lord Holland entertained and Lady Holland bullied. For, in truth, the Whigs, whose hero had been Fox, were, with all their merits, behind rather than in advance of their time; their claim to our respect is, that, in a time of political reaction, they preserved their faith (though it was a rath- er narrow faith) in civil and religious lib- erty. But they certainly had little pres- cience of the then coming time. Lord Grey, though the accidental leader in the pacific revolution carried through by the Reform Act, was essentially an aristocrat; he also belonged to the body of Whigs who be- lieved in protection, and believed in it partly because it maintained the influence of landowners. The Whigs of that day did not turn their minds vigorously toward economic problems. During the years, in- deed, which elapsed between 1821 and 1832 the younger members of the Whig party who did not belong to the great Whig houses had become steeped in Bentham- ism, and aided in the production of that change of opinion which is typified by the transformation of Whigs into Liberals. But Lord Holland had, as a true adherent of Fox, very little sympathy with the middle- class Liberalism which became dominant after the Reform Act. Nor, again, did the Whigs as a body share that passion for national independence | adie to raise their thoughts above party which, under the form of the nationality movement, colored European politics say from 1835 to 1870. It was from the Tories, not from the Whigs, that the Spaniards received sympathy in their resistance to the power of Napcleon. The desire to pro- mote constitutional government abroad and to preserve popular government against the threats of the Holy Alliance, was ex- hibited by Canning; but Canning was the disciple not of Fox, but of Pitt. And Palm- erston, who in latter years carried on the policy of Canning, was always in sentiment rather a Liberalized Tory than a Whig. At home no less than abroad the Whig Party displayed a singular incapacity for entering into national feeling. The whole attitude of Lord Holland towards Napoleon betrays a defective appreciation of all that was at stake in the life and death contest between England and the Emperor. But this is not all. The bitter resentment of the Whig leaders at the treachery of the Regent is fully justified if you regard the question from a wholly personal point of view. Anything baser or more treacherous than George’s conduct is not easily imagined; nor can one honestly suppose that he was influenced by the belief that, if he betrayed his friends, he was loyal to the interests of the nation. On no single occasion, as far as history can be trusted, did he ever prefer any interest whatever to his own immediate comfurt and pleasure. But if the charges brought against the Regent are looked at from a national rather than a personal point of view, George's character is not raised, for no one could suppose that he gave even a passing thought to the welfare of the nation; but the character of the Whigs is placed in the most unfa- vorable light. It was as clear as day that the one vital matter was that the nation should be united in its resistance to Napoleon. The best of the Whigs knew this, and insisted upon the necessity of every Englishman standing firm on behalf of the independence of England. It was also clear that English opinion sup- ported the Tories, yet the Whigs were prepared to aceept office from the Regent, and this though they were apparently di- vided in their views as to the war with France. But the strangest matter of all is, that the Whigs who denounced and resented the influence of the Crown when that in- fluence was in the hands of George IIL, were prepared to use the influence of the Crown when it had been transferred to the Regent for securing the rule of the Whig Party. This, at least, must seem to a can- did reader to be the inference necessarily suggested by Lord Holland’s Memoirs. It assuredly is completely in keeping with the conduct of Fox as leader of the Coalition, and later, during the debates on the Regency, when the Whigs seemed on the point of driving Pitt from power—that is, of over- ruling the will of the nation by obtaining the patronage of the Prince of Wales on his becoming Regent. Nor is it fair to as- cribe conduct tc them which most his- torians now blame wholly to party spirit; it was due, in great part at any rate, to two features which characterized the Whigs between 1760 and 1830—they were, speaking broadly, a party which in some respects advocated good causes; but they were never feeling and to recognize the supreme im portance of bowing to the will of what Chatham calls the “Great Public.” And though, under the influence of Fox, they sometimes adopted and played with demo cratic sentiment, they were never demo crats; they believed, in reality, not in the sovereignty of the people, but in the sov ereignty of Parliament MORE NOVELS Between Two Masters. By Gamaliel Brad ford, jr. Boston: Houghton, Mifflin & Co. { Diplomatic Adventure. By S. Weir Mitch ell, M.D., LL.D. The Century Co The Lady of the Decoration. By Frances Little. The Century Co The world-old theme of the soul hesi tating between God and Mammon will prob ably never be exhausted, certainly not abandoned, by novel writers. The modern purely philanthropic novel is now old, too, and begins to specialize itself. To teach the orphan boy to read, the orphan gir! to sew, is superseded. There must be im proved ways of living, and an equal number of ways of teaching those ways. ‘Between Two Masters’ is a record of conflict be- tween the opposing forces of good and evil ‘n the very concrete forms of ‘tainted money” on one side and modern Boston Settlement work on the other. Amos K Phelps is rich and philanthropic, but his money has been made in the stock market and Trusts; and as ‘‘to be rich means sim- ply making some one else poor,’ he stands for Ahriman. On the other side are the Epis copalian Church, the Settlement, the Ten ement; in between stands, hesitant, Harvey Phelps. The millions are his if he will go into business with his uncle—with an easy- going athletic cousin to wife, if he is so inclined. A moderate competence and the approval of his conscience are all that Ormuzd promises, but in the end a saintly girl is thrown in, and virtue not only is, but has, its own reward. On the side of light are an ascetic rector and Diana the Settle- ment Saint, skilled in all latter-day sani tation and tenement accommodation; the powers of darkness behind the uncle are Phelps’s golf-playing daughter, a comic journalist, and a frivolous girl. The love affairs of the group are remarkable for in terchangeableness, and for the entire frank- ness with which the young folk plot and plan for one another's weddings, playing a kind of game of progressive hearts. The kernel of the matter, however, is not the story, but the arraignment of the top-heavy fortune and the exaltation of personal Christian consecration to good works A pleasant half hour for the reader lies tucked away between the covers of ‘A Dip- lomatic Adventure.’ A Dumas-like set of persons is made freshly interesting by be- ing assigned parts in a Franco-American tangle during the dark days of the civil war, when recognition of the Confederacy was the international menace. Dr. Weir Mitchell contrives, as only an accomplished writer could contrive, to bring into his lit- tle novel mystery, conspiracy, comicality, diplomacy and romance, with probability enough to keep unbelief at bay. French and Yankee swashbuckling are contrasted 433 nt SS WF Fa OS Farin 6 pits PINTS amie MEO
Page 22
The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134 434 picturesquely. The diplomatists are reason- able and human, and the fact that he who tells the story is neither the real hero nor his Boswell is refreshing. The valet in the pay of both the Empire and the American Secretary, with his sly, recurring ‘“‘circum- tances,” ts a crisply modelled little figure of fun. And the hiding-place devised for the valuable papers is far too good a one to be here disclosed The Lady of the Decoration’ gives very pretty pictures of Japanese life, landscape, babies and mothers, and very comical ones of the Kentucky woman ‘implanting in Asiatic minds the seed of American knowl- edge, under missionary auspices The bables were taught to laugh and romp; the lass In physical culture studied “skip- ping,’ and initiated the mothers in that tonic exercise. The young teachers were instructed in psychology—effectively, we may be sure, for one of them handed in this definition: “Reflex action is of a ac- tivity nervous. It is sometimes the don’t inderstand of what it is doing, and stops many messages to the brain, and sends the motion to the legs.”” The young Kentuckian reflects in her narrative the flowery charm always to be expected of Japan, and is able even to enhance it by her special ex- periences, for they include many little every-day contacts acquired in the routine life which she leads as a teacher in winter, with summer vacation journeys into holi- day places. With these peaceful affairs is contrasted a glimpse of the Japanese-Rus- sian war, the horrible sights of the hospi- tal, the gay departures of the soldiers, the harrowing bravery of the women. “a hope,’’ writes the American, “I shall never get to the point of believing that it’s right for strong, useful men to be killed or crip- pled for life in order to settle a contro- versy.”’ The book is in the form of letters, where- in pluck strives with homesickness for the a truly American hu- with a sentiment made rather over- prominent by the first person singular. It is to be hoped that the little Japanese did teacher's wills and shalls, mastery, and humor mor not copy their unless, indeed, they reversed them. The missionary accessories tempt her mirthful- ness into an occasional lapse from taste; ind it may be added that though the letter- writing form makes colloquialism more than allowable, the slang should be tempered with merey for proportion’s sake, since it reaches the reader in cold print. Mr. Hen- ry James has said that Mrs. Kemble “was a the richest colloquial humor is not dependent for its success upon least of all (as this is a matter in gilda) that of the gay,”’ he adds, “that her occasionally crossed grace- fully that of 1840." It may be hat in 1980 Mies Little's slang may appear xraceful and gilded as a Japanese fan constant proof that slang which hour distance upon | won't not lips were enough by The Mdward 8 Cathedral Ruildera in England. By Prior, M.A., F. 8 A. London: New York: EB. P. Dutton @& 112 This is one of the Portfolio Monographs, although very many of them are of Seeley & Co.; Co. 1906. Pp and great Importance, admirable books to read and to keep within reach of the hand, it thought to may be overtop them all Mr. Prior is the author of a ‘History of Gothic Art in England,’ which appeared in 1900 and was duly reviewed in these col- umns. Since that date Mr. Prior has thought much upon the theme, and what he has to say now is most impressive. The present is not to be regarded as in any sense an abridgment of his former work; yet, treat- ing an important subject from one point of view, it may be thought to give to many readers that which the more exhaustive work will not give. The general title in- cludes much, for, in Mr. Prior’s presenta- tion, the medigwval building from the be- ginning of the pointed style in England un- til the sixteenth century was very largely in the hands of the same artists who were in charge of the cathedrals. Of the nine chapters, each stands for a period of time. The first period, 1066 to 1150, deals with the Saint Albans crossing (that is to say, the important open space where the transept crosses the nave and choir), with the crypt and transept of Win- chester, the transept and nave of Ely, and so on through eleven churches, all of ca- thedral rank. There is also the note, given in the place where it is most needed, that in two of the churches in question where “choir, transept, and nave” are studied, the “crossing” itself is a nineteenth-century rebuilding. In this way the reader is told exactly what is under examination—the still unmarred ancient structure in this part and in that of any given church. Thus at the very outset is struck the keynote upon which the whole symphony is to be com- posed. To draw the sharpest possible line of division between rebuilt, reconstructed, “restored” nineteenth-century copies and the originals, no matter how close the imi- tation may seem to the ignorant and the careless, and to find out by study of the authentically ancient parts, larger and smaller, what the old artist was after—that is Mr. Prior’s worthy and much-loved task. He makes it clear at the beginning that he does not look on the architectural mass alone—the proportions, the majesty, the dignity, the general style—as the charac- teristic works of the eleventh-century and twelfth-century artist. The detail—the sculpture and the painting and the glass— requires all that the keenest observer and the most fearless critic can express by way of minute characterization. The fourth chapter has to do with the “Summit of Gothic Art,” 1250 to 1290, ané names ten parts of churches, such as the choir of Old St. Paul’s, the nave of Lichfield, and the chapter-houses of Wells, South- wells, and York. Herein lies the most se- rious part of the author's attempt to show that the European uniformity of Gothic ar- chitecture in those later days may have been largely the result of the French evo- lution of the style, while the battle begun in the earlier chapters against the 4 vneral assumption that Gothic architecture is a French art is still continued. We do not much admire that patriotism which makes a writer contend for the origin, in his own little political division of Europe, of some great movement in art or literature; but in the case of Mr. Prior and his patriotism there Is a vast knowledge of details—de- tails of building and of ornamentation, dis- coveries of date and of individual influ- ences, minute comparisons of sculpture with sculpture, arcade with arcade, all over England and Wales. So many foolish the- ories are here set upon and routed that the chief enemy is left unmentioned until another chapter has been begun. Much is made of the fact that the architecture of Angers and of Anjou generally is about the last which can be thought to have influ- enced English twelfth-century work; but if any assertion to the contrary was ever made, it must have been by historians of dynasties and foreign wars, not of architec- ture. One can see the “closet historian” and his suggestion of reasons why Gothic must have come to England from the Con- tinent: “Why, don’t you see? Three Ange- vin kings in a row, Henry II. and his two sons, and just at that period, too, 1154-1216. Of course, it was in this way that the Gothic was introduced.”’ That, however, is not the assertion of the more serious stu- dents of the art. The question as to where the ribbed vault and the vaulting-shaft first came in as a supersession of the Romanesque ways of building, has been answered by non-Eng- lish writers with the statement that the neighborhood of Paris, the old royal do- main of France, saw the beginnings of the new art. One exceptional building is in Normandy and puzzles everybody, but in general a circle drawn with a radius of forty-five miles, with the Cathedral of Paris as its centre, would contain the buildings in which the Gothic vaulting per- fected itself; and our quarrel with Mr. Prior is that he seems reluctant to ac- cept the peculiar vaulted structure with constructional ribs and flying buttresses as the one test of what is Gothic. The earnest appeals of the Introduction, the appeal to the sense of mystery, to the love of ir- regularity, to the love of originality, to the love of color, are to be accepted as a truthful rendering in words of what Gothic architecture says to us. The mis- take seems to lie in the assump- tion that the color design, the cary- ing, the moulding, the irregularities, the originality and dash, are essentially Gothic. They are not Gothic, at least not in a pe- culiar sense; they are the characteristics of any living art, of an art in its spring- time. And if the copies of thirteenth-cen- tury Gothic are wretched things, as we are told on pages 15, 18, and elsewhere, it is not an unexplained mystery that they should be so. Given a rebuilt nave, we hate it because it replaces a lost work of the thirteenth century; because we do not feel sure that this was what the medisval artist intended; because it is very hard and exact, and we believe that the old work would have been less precise; because it has no accidents or failures; because it shows no signs of old, half-effaced paint- ing; because, finally, it disagrees, in its accuracy, with the less methodical old work with which it is associated. It is true that some of ovr dissatisfaction with new Gothic buildings, when of the highest type, is unfounded. The reasons for our rejection of these are not the lack of the evidences of growth, of the visible “pro- cession of mighty forces’ (p. 18), but the mixture of real and imagined inferiority which we find in the new-built piece of work. And if it is found that a good mod- ern design such as Truro Cathedral is still disregarded, or is looked at with disfavor, that is because the modern world is wholly
Page 23
May 24, 1906] out of touch with Gothic architecture. Mr. Prior asks (p. 107) why Truro was not built of the material found near at hand, the granite of the hills, and finds a partial answer in the fact that “Pearson, a nine- teenth-century architect, . . « having learnt his Lincoln Cathedral, . . . could only use a stone in which the Lincoln de- tail could be worked.”” He was “‘obliged to repeat himself and give his clients what they had been trained to expect.”" Precise- ly! And it is because the modern architect cannot build freely, because he is an arche- ologist in the first place, because he can- not go to a granite country and make a granite Gothic, even as the Breton archi- tects did in the fourteenth century. It is not because Truro Cathedral is like Lin- coln that it is not great architecture; it is not even because it is built of foreign stone that it is not great architecture. It is very good and very freshly imagined work: and if it is not still better than that and really a great design, that is be- cause one cannot make a great design all by himself. He must have all the master builders of his time (whatever you call those master builders) working in harmony for a common result. It is only under these conditions that great designs are possible. Die Ausgrabungen auf dem Forum Roma- num, 1902-1904. Von Christian Hiilsen. (Rémische Mittheilungen xx. 1.). Rome: Léscher. 1905. One of the best features of the journal of the German Archeological Institute at Rome used to be the publication from time to time of Dr. Hiilsen’s reviews of recent work on the topography of ancient Rome. The cessation of this series was a cause of earnest regret to many. redders of the Mittheilungen on this side of the Atlantic, as in Europe. Three years ago the series was resumed in a somewhat more limited form, being confined in sub- ject to recent discoveries in the Forun; but Hiilsen’s article filled an entire num- ber of the journal, and was later issued in a separate form. The present article is of similar extent, and is illustrated by four plates and fifty-two cuts in the text, some of them reproducing early views and drawings, otherwise practically inacces- sible. Between the publication of these two accounts Hiilsen has also issued an invaluable little hand-book on the ancient remains in the Forum, which has been mentioned in these columns and has just appeared in a second edition. It is short- ly to be published in an English transla- tion by Prof. Jesse B. Carter of Prince- ton University and the American School in Rome. The wide interest that the recent ex- tensive excavations in the Forum—more far-reaching, more scientifically carrie] out, and more richly productive in results for history than any earlier work in the same region—have awakened among intel- ligent travellers, makes a brief summary of Hiilsen’s judgment on a few of the es- pecially controverted matters not without interest for other than special students of the subject. There has been a unanimous wail from students at a distance from Rome that the official journal of all excavations carried on by the Italian Government, the The Nation Notizie degli Scavi, is so preternaturally slow in publishing full and authentic ac- counts of the discoveries in the Forum. It may be that Commissioner Boni is too busy with digging to study and write. But prompt publication is as much the duty of the archm@ologist as active and care- ful digging, and such work as that in the Forum ought not to be treated as a pure- ly Italian family affair, in which outsiders need not interfere. Prompt and authentic news of the work we need and have a right to request with some degree ‘of insist- ence; rhetorical and other more scientific discussion can await the excavator’s great- er leisure. It is some comfort to notice that Hiilsen shares in the widespread criticism of the pen’s delay in this mat- ter, and some satisfaction that, since his remarks were printed, a fourth report on the prehistoric cemetery has actually ap- peared in the Notizie. The identification of the piece of hewn native tufa behind the Umbilicus Rome with the Ara Volcani is, according to Hiilsen, not proven, while Lanciani’s state- ment that the altar was discovered in 1548 is shown to be an error. The Greco- stadium, which Hiilsen himself, like others, formerly assumed to be identical with the Grecostasis, is now ascribed to a situation south of the Basilica Iulia, on the ground actually occupied by the hospital and church of S. Maria della Consolazione The author also takes serious issue with Richter upon questions connected with the rostra, as set forth by the latter in his programme of 1903, especially on the iden- tification of the Hemicycle with the rostra of Cwsar, and the belief that the rectan- gular structure is of later origin, clinging to his own earlier belief that the steps behind the Hemicycle served as the original approach to the contemporaneous (rectan- gular) rostra. Yet he concedes that further excavation is necessary to settle certain difficult points. The church of SS. Ser- gius and Bacchus is shown, by the help of two previously unpublished drawings, to have stood further to the west than has generally been supposed, its apse near the three standing columns of the Temple of Vespasian, its nave extending to the por- tico of the Temple of Concord. The mod- ern street now covers the site. Hiilsen repeats, with reasons, his belief that the archaic cippus under the “black stone” was mutilated and covered at the time of the Julian-Augustan changes in the Forum and Comitium, and argues at some length his points of disagreement with Petersen, in his ‘Comitium, Rostra, Grab des Romu- lus,’ previously noticed in these columns, and with Studniczka, in the Yearbook of the Austrian Institute. He doubts decided- ly the accuracy of the designation equus Tremuli, assigned to the recently unearthed foundation near the Heroén of Caesar, and suggests, though acknowledging difficul- ties, that to this structure may belong both the Augustus inscription (CIL. 6. 3747), and the Lucius inscription. He repeats, with additional argument, his criticism of Boni’s declaration that the cuntoulé of the Forum were constructed for use in games given in that place, and dis- agrees with Boni further in his declara- tion that the column hitherto called that of Phocas is really a columna Diorletiani, though he is inclined to agree with Boni 435 regarding the identification of the equus Domitiani. But he is in doubt concerning the proper interpretation of the archat or archaistic, vases found in the base of the last-named monument A full list is given of the paintings in th church of S. Maria Antiqua, and of th character and contents of the graves thus far opened in the ancient necropolis. Hil sen is utterly unconvinced by the areu ments of Boni and Vaglier! that the Arch of Titus originally stood further to the north, and was removed to its present site to make room for Hadrian's temple of Venus and Rome, pointing out that the one strong argument in favor of that view is totally upset by the fact that the con crete foundations of the Arch of Augustus which certainly was never moved, were in similar manner planted on an earlier street pavement The entire article, so richly filled with information, is characterized by the author’s wide knowledge and sanity of judgment, and by his well-known steady determination to declare nothing certain which can be proved only by such lively work of the imagination as distinguishes some of the otherwise excellent Italian archwologists, and makes distant scholars smile and doubt Common-Sense Gardens: How to Plan and Plant Them. By Cornelius V. V. Sewell New York: The Grafton Press. 1906 The title well describes this book. if seemingly a little arrogantly since the shelves are now full of books upon gar- dens and gardening; and now comes one which professes to deal with the whole subject from a common-sense point of view What is the matter with the rest of the shelf? The author presents to the owners of small estates and even much more hum ble holdings useful suggestions as to mak- ing the best outlay of time and money in beautifying the home grounds with or with- out the help of the landscape architect Nearly all the other works on this tople assume that the householder is to do all his own planning with little ald outside of the book in hand Now making a garden is very much like buying a horse. If you use your own knowledge acquired solely from reading about the desirable points of the ideal beast you want, you are in a fair way to acquire a large amount of ex- perience with great rapidity and mortifi- cation. A little assistance at the outset goes a long way towards success in either of these enterprises. But, nevertheless, one must be on his guard against following all advice too closely. The author says “Architects, garden and otherwise, have a way of talking their clients into doing or allowing them to do many things that the clients do not desire. It is part of their profession, and the more languages they can use, the more successful they are.” But, on the other hand, “consult a garden architect of good reputation, one whose work you have seen and know to ap- proach more or less to your ideal; but do not let him do more than offer a few sug- gestions at a time concerning the points about which you are most in doubt The architect will be useful in suggesting the shape ef the garden and the best ma- terials to use for the enclosure, and he may be better able than you to see the ieee eh Recta py mp i, Pea SA rE ~~ we Si al PIA - sae = + 2 PaaS ap Mans, ~— FR Re ot eT AS alls ITM GP eB
Page 24
436 The Nation. [Vol. 82, No. 2134 possibilities of the natural features of the his eye is trained to such ever on the alert." That is And now, “Do not follow his suggestions about planting, however, that, the first year at least, your- self.”’ And that, is common sense. There is very sound in the lirection to beginners to patronize (1) nur- for these will perhaps make and land, because work and is mmon sense but do too, counsel, also, home, and losses of plants one’s you occasional serymen near willingly advise good your (2) if you have to buy your plants from 1 distance, try to get them from some place farther north than your place, since these will probably prove more hardy rhere are some interesting words to be met with, here and there, throughout the book, for instarce, “cuppy,.”” as applied to clayey soll in which shell-like horizon- il cavities form, collecting too freely wa- ter that stays too long. And there are many pleasing turns of thought, rather out of the Thus, an account of Mov- presented, lilacs conventional line lilac-bushes with, 7 and if every ng large is well moved zone on to a closing have they have they flower, just drive when in blooming as were used age day.”’ rhe illustrated od reproductions of photographs, and the begin- too paper for a cat instructive volume is by a l taste at It fine a modern éditions excellent chapters ecorated of l} printed Handbook, of Country Life have accustomed us Therefore it per- its good ng the is almost upon too Garden but our de lure 1 hap to the very best is this work, with should be issued in a high- that may be more hands of those who who would do the thought- who guilty of erecting gas- and with this citation of good book to all: well that common sense form, it ly att likely ractive to fall into the need it most Among those to heed its precepts are ! ; ones are nces pipe fe ounsel, we commend the ungainly fence that has ever d is made by running lengths through upright wooden posts, them together. rhe st heen de of ga ind RACIAL DESCENT IN ANIMALS By THOMAS H. MONTGOMERY, rsity of Texas. net; mi Vine pipe coupling Jr., of the by liniv 2.50 $2 A critical examination of the methods of determining racial descent, and an examina- tion of the comparative values of the phenomena to be interpreted. HENRY HOLT & COMW# methetic point of view, such a fence has | from whatever not one redeeming feature; its ugliness stands out uncompromisingly and detracts beauty the house and grounds may possess. {ft is strong and easy to construct, and is quite cheap, con- sidering its substance, and it has a smug | appearance that many people cannot resist. They excuse the use of it by saying that they intend to cover it quickly with vines. They may cover it, but they cannot hide it; the most luxurious [sic] tropical growth would be unable to veil its protruding personality. You would know it was a gas- | pipe fence if it was boarded up and vines Corporations: From an mail | trained over the boards, and you would shudder when you passed it and instinc- tively anathematize the plumber who in- vented it. If men are known by their works, you would recognize a man who built such a fence around his yard or gar- den as one who, although he might be rich, yet was penurious—perhaps kind to his wife and children, but possessing no real affection; and you would pity his family. You would place him as a trades- man who had risen from the ranks, but who certainly deserved to be degraded again, and sum up by adding that, whatever he was, he possessed no soul; for souls and gas-pipe fencing are farther apart than earth and heaven.” A Study of the Origin and Development of Great Business Combina- tions and of their Relation to the Au- thority of the State. By John P. Davis. 2 vols. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. 1905. These volumes, as appears from the au- thor’s preface, were intended to serve as an introduction to a volume on the subject of modern corporations. Although super- ficially complete in themselves, they can hardly be regarded as more than a very foundation for a work which Mr. death cut short. They are and the reader can only surmise what conclusion the author would have reached. They are full of learning and research on the nature and history of corporations of all kinds—guilds, mu- ecclesiastical corporations, joint-stock companies, colonial companies, and eleemosynary corporations; but in the end we are left rather in the dark as to the elaborate Davis's unfortunate inconclusive, nicipalities, The Principles of Electric Wave Telegraphy J. A. FLEMING, M A., D.Sc., F.R.S., Pro- fessor of Electrical Engineering in Univer sity College of the University of London. With 402 Illustrations. S8vo. $6.60 met. By LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., New York Every page laabeorbing.’ CAtcago Record. Herald THE EVASION By EUGENIA BROOKS PROTHINGHAM Author of “The Turn of the Road.” | Graves, Henry THE BURROWS BROTHERS COMPANY OF CLEVELAND, OHIO are the leading booksellers in the United States along certain lines. They issue a Catalog of Rare Volumes monthly, and this, together with their List of Publica- tions devoted to American History, will be SENT REE to any one making the request. F, W. CHRISTERN (DYRSEN & PFEIFFER, Successors) 16 Weat 334 &t., opposite the “ Waldorf,” New York, Importers of Foreign Books, Agents for the leading Pattie Publishers, suchnita's British authors. Teub-. ner’s Greek and Latin Classics. Catalogue of stock matied on demand. New books recety from Parte aod Leipzig as soon as \ssued THE STUDIO YEAR BOOK oF pec ORATIVE ART. 194 At Clo 8:00 net Posta ipe _ JOHN L ANE. CO. The Hedley Head, N. Y. | & PF. DUTTON & CU., LITERARY CRITICISM Of English and American Authors. | 680 to 1905. In eight royal Svo volamea 6,000 P Bosc sriptive matter and specimen pages on request. MOULTON PUBLISHING CO., Buffalo, New York EVERYMAN’S LIBRARY Cloth 50 cents; leather, $1.00 List on request, NEW. YORK | author’s drift. The concluding sentence of the book consists in the epigrammatic statement that “citizenship” has been “largely metamorphosed into membership in corporations, and patriotism into fidelity to them,” while elsewhere (vol. i., p. 31) he lays it down that a “private corporation” is a contradiction in terms, and “has no place in a sound organization of society.” He makes war, as others have done, upon our old fiction—surely a convenient one still —that a corporation is an “artificial per- son. He calls attention to the “virtual exclusion” of the “small stockholder” from participation in the management, though he seems to fail to see that this is highly democratic—the analogue of the virtual exclusion of the average voter from “the ring’ which manages his party and his government. He insists that trade unions show a tendency to approach the status of “true corporations,”’ but does not perceive that they always endeavor to keep them- selves as far as possible from the responsi- bility in law which marks a true corpora- tion. Altogether, we must regard this book as materials collected with a view to the production of a definite theory, rather than any coherent statement of such a theory. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Morocco of To-day. Dutton. $2 Carlyle und Goethe. Lemcke & Edited by Adolphus W. Ward. Aubin, Bugéne. net . Baumgarten, Otto. Bueehner. Crabbe’s Poems. Vol. Il. Macmillan Co. Doughty. Charles M. The Dawn in Britain. 2 vols, Dutton. $3 net Everyman's Library Edited by Ernest Rhys. 60 vols. Dutton. 50 cents per volume. Farquhar,. Edwa The Youth of Messiah. Bos- Richard G. Badger. ©. Lectures on Homiletics. Phila- hia: Ame wen Ba past Publication Society. Headley, John W. wary rations in ada and New Yoru. Neale Pu blishing Oo. Joachin, Harold H. The Nature of Truth. ihe Frowde Lamprecht, Karl. Americana. & Buech- a John Lather. The Way of the Gods. Mac- milian Co. §&* Marston, E. Fishing for Siegguce and Catching It. Wilhelm Co. 3 ton: del = Lemcke Imported by Scribners. $1. Seidel’s Aus Goldenen Tene "Raited b Bernhardt. Boston: D. ©, Heath cents. WHAT WE ARE DOING FOR LIBRARIANS. We now have the most efficient depart- ment for the handling of Library orders. tock, Greatly increased facilities for the im- portation of English publications. . bookmen to price lists and co. t books, All of this -means prompt and complete shipments and right prices. THE BAKER & TAYLOR Co., WHOLESALE BOOKSELLERS, 33-37 East Seventeenth St., New York. 1, A tremendous miscellaneous s' 2, INA EE QUAKERIOM AND POLITICS py Ra ae an ARETE PR he ave? ford College. $1.25 Bomtpald. ora oF At bookstores p Send poe on is history apd biogra ong vi RRIS & L ane phere, Phila.
Page 25
Pat ~ ila ai "aT a er — ee Pee . . , « » - ae ’ oe ' oe Pi ’ - * ny > 4 2 . - i, . o é " ‘ rs . - . . a es Bis ’ ~ 4 . > wet —"